id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15033v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15033v2 | SmartTrim: Adaptive Tokens and Attention Pruning for Efficient Vision-Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:18:00 | 2024-02-26T15:26:20 | Zekun Wang, Jingchang Chen, Wangchunshu Zhou, Haichao Zhu, Jiafeng Liang, Liping Shan, Ming Liu, Dongliang Xu, Qing Yang, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite achieving remarkable performance on various vision-language tasks,
Transformer-based Vision-Language Models (VLMs) suffer from redundancy in
inputs and parameters, significantly hampering their efficiency in real-world
applications. Moreover, the degree of redundancy in token representations and
model parameters, such as attention heads, varies significantly for different
inputs. In light of the challenges, we propose SmartTrim, an adaptive
acceleration framework for VLMs, which adjusts the computational overhead per
instance. Specifically, we integrate lightweight modules into the original
backbone to identify and prune redundant token representations and attention
heads within each layer. Furthermore, we devise a self-distillation strategy to
enhance the consistency between the predictions of the pruned model and its
fully-capacity counterpart. Experimental results across various vision-language
tasks consistently demonstrate that SmartTrim accelerates the original model by
2-3 times with minimal performance degradation, highlighting the effectiveness
and efficiency compared to previous approaches. Code will be available at
https://github.com/kugwzk/SmartTrim. | [
0.013185096,
0.0413231254,
0.0010323713,
0.0498949327,
-0.0237486232,
-0.0008848803,
0.018696541,
-0.0270944424,
0.0038113371,
-0.0341457352,
-0.0365945622,
0.016485,
0.0260356162,
0.0447172709,
0.0309370402,
-0.044004228,
0.047439795,
-0.0514993481,
0.0071473843,
0.0069558998,
0.0040834644,
-0.0128473947,
0.0231678635,
0.0627892911,
-0.0091806296,
-0.0352519639,
0.0062356242,
0.0332286991,
0.0195549931,
0.0198224187,
-0.0108030215,
0.0444320962,
0.0061580213,
0.0285737962,
0.0000020684,
0.0004860592,
0.0216152593,
-0.0008039167,
-0.0010996429,
-0.0036274891,
0.0468693078,
-0.018003026,
0.0025186304,
0.0124441572,
-0.008279263,
-0.0431459062,
0.0712585598,
0.0139465546,
0.0571693033,
0.0394063741,
-0.0059200432,
0.0006701723,
0.0043359213,
-0.0313854367,
-0.0041095619,
-0.0121731916,
0.0198530816,
-0.0559190847,
-0.0413307697,
-0.0284344703,
-0.0456229411,
0.0600236207,
0.0421485454,
-0.0106959986,
0.0196348466,
0.0269446783,
-0.0807709321,
-0.0439452194,
-0.0320682153,
0.0344260186,
-0.0802870095,
-0.0270354468,
-0.007236856,
-0.0023609668,
-0.0072955405,
-0.0553566292,
-0.0560391396,
0.0164721906,
0.0101208286,
0.0193339735,
-0.0411425605,
0.0019233414,
0.0278032515,
-0.0124468887,
-0.0287209898,
0.0213987082,
0.0060983868,
0.0414769948,
-0.0359423161,
0.0067044096,
-0.0197501257,
-0.0454031974,
0.0151967229,
0.0208717603,
-0.0033250197,
-0.0094515914,
-0.0658539459,
-0.0327055492,
-0.0176936891,
-0.0338516645,
0.0655112714,
0.0505746379,
-0.0481262952,
0.067464821,
-0.0607589632,
0.0880132467,
-0.009259061,
0.0480512194,
-0.0340035819,
-0.0531488732,
0.0130973887,
-0.0035591302,
-0.0712936819,
0.0307128895,
-0.0348332636,
-0.0435979776,
-0.0185577311,
0.0230364464,
-0.0275616106,
-0.0284672808,
0.0309782252,
0.0098430449,
-0.0349354371,
-0.0145414881,
0.0115739973,
0.0461159311,
0.0061386465,
-0.0174419228,
0.0030813401,
-0.0770874992,
-0.0198410954,
0.0539912395,
-0.0035276257,
-0.0143574346,
-0.0165386926,
0.0879437774,
-0.0009427313,
-0.0448045395,
-0.0027945226,
0.0209984612,
-0.0114122732,
-0.0304454975,
0.0082117328,
-0.0621577613,
0.0504225083,
-0.0184536614,
0.000779741,
-0.0434681512,
0.0074035279,
0.0246461779,
-0.0291385315,
0.0393367298,
-0.0108716656,
0.0165235084,
-0.0075042541,
0.0008341783,
0.0018430508,
0.0673349947,
0.0229766816,
0.050349649,
0.0091006868,
-0.0237219483,
0.0066615888,
0.0440180227,
0.0011939656,
-0.011101542,
-0.0645678863,
-0.0020019761,
-0.0208337493,
0.0011490702,
0.0464361385,
0.0773716345,
-0.0396612957,
-0.0525413826,
0.0564416163,
0.0230196994,
0.0334203355,
0.0029760974,
0.0332011729,
-0.0219396725,
0.0047544506,
-0.0228797067,
-0.0891770944,
0.0699559748,
0.0274841543,
-0.0168242399,
-0.0174624398,
0.0681514591,
-0.0466740206,
-0.0319433659,
-0.0100863073,
-0.0167644341,
0.0087914858,
0.0217723902,
0.0377365351,
0.0161735248,
-0.0184951983,
0.057304468,
0.0021392601,
-0.031483911,
-0.0202651806,
-0.0758513883,
-0.0142770233,
0.0563300438,
0.0278472025,
0.0316743888,
-0.0447718166,
0.0163741335,
0.0285689346,
0.0299242418,
0.0021380002,
0.0164404102,
0.0522424765,
-0.0468853824,
-0.027721988,
0.0102779437,
-0.012814302,
-0.0076486217,
0.0206726585,
-0.0048738387,
0.0329074599,
-0.0345076025,
-0.000679131,
0.045927044,
0.0428676307,
0.0026097794,
0.0199970771,
-0.0029169552,
0.0081077283,
-0.0381404571,
0.0163640194,
0.002963091,
0.0586591475,
-0.0521338545,
0.0254923347,
0.0393761434,
-0.0570154972,
-0.0110053308,
0.0482359231,
-0.013568352,
0.004108448,
0.0584177859,
-0.0324435569,
-0.022271648,
0.0294806436,
-0.0455671437,
0.0261967797,
-0.0388025157,
0.0297742952,
-0.0047677779,
0.0435813181,
-0.0116110994,
0.0187698044,
-0.0279818829,
-0.0178101882,
0.0194580257,
-0.0068041487,
-0.0110691357,
-0.000531792,
-0.0128023867,
-0.0381179601,
-0.02819019,
0.0151636507,
0.0182076748,
-0.0229265243,
-0.0085292133,
-0.015910713,
-0.0649147257,
-0.0078416718,
-0.0405539684,
-0.0087429322,
-0.0040688482,
0.0438629761,
0.0284654051,
-0.03470001,
0.0168866105,
0.0579377636,
-0.0191421155,
0.0110633168,
-0.0174354631,
-0.0346758738,
-0.0223384388,
-0.0113763632,
-0.0338018686,
0.0301504321,
0.041034963,
-0.0286743157,
-0.0396611616,
-0.0308732409,
-0.0357543118,
0.000734465,
0.0533301905,
-0.0122287404,
-0.0346401371,
-0.0016454505,
-0.0161304604,
0.0578484237,
0.0823852345,
0.0100034447,
0.0161682311,
0.0293407459,
-0.0079998029,
-0.0361115038,
0.0247924235,
-0.0098327091,
0.0105247721,
-0.0159670115,
0.0083929691,
-0.0158624947,
0.0692034066,
-0.0376389027,
0.0149246044,
-0.0695449486,
0.017425226,
0.0076230201,
-0.049204357,
-0.0067164698,
0.0198521074,
-0.0205340534,
-0.0062545678,
-0.0297842212,
-0.0729406103,
0.0298925899,
-0.0417438485,
-0.0344029665,
0.0163481962,
0.0196816437,
-0.0139894271,
0.0519009046,
0.0596098192,
0.0176312104,
-0.0155492006,
-0.0079908418,
-0.0495555811,
-0.0016080039,
-0.0332313217,
-0.009138952,
0.0810773745,
-0.017790582,
0.0033968762,
-0.0321950652,
-0.0184880588,
-0.039988704,
0.0280744955,
-0.0246483199,
0.0333224908,
-0.0230691321,
-0.0379011631,
-0.0828708261,
0.0403552055,
0.023576295,
0.0773196444,
-0.0150085082,
-0.009210025,
-0.0172304306,
-0.0078944303,
0.0664618909,
0.0477250144,
0.0129799638,
-0.0130378008,
0.0089480765,
0.0879756808,
0.0503268279,
-0.0129836397,
-0.0806844011,
0.0067227245,
0.0553723238,
0.0274235085,
0.0100703314,
0.0207844488,
0.0332609303,
-0.1003152058,
-0.0176914483,
0.0787426606,
0.000744082,
-0.0378010534,
0.002887164,
-0.011406091,
0.0276907887,
0.033759404,
0.019680135,
-0.0528713651,
-0.0577139668,
-0.0044338033,
0.0241370611,
0.0431748815,
0.0031693438,
-0.0075866575,
-0.0506219156,
0.0577747375,
0.0101529798,
-0.0144022498,
-0.0283294506,
0.018465424,
-0.0001355078,
-0.018101139,
0.005189138,
0.0199417304,
-0.0201092307,
-0.0058115334,
-0.0008324052,
-0.0235604737,
0.0153850885,
0.0038823227,
-0.0439815223,
0.0047666356,
0.0598809533,
-0.0264096633,
0.0242131036,
-0.0639733523,
0.0316821039,
-0.0271591768,
0.0133500071,
-0.0177245401,
0.0099497447,
-0.0260516871,
-0.0450241864,
0.0108780032,
-0.0044331132,
-0.0423439629,
-0.0348230116,
-0.032052651,
0.0570543446,
0.004506513,
-0.0270505678,
-0.0550049394,
-0.0328033119,
-0.0595641211,
0.0724822879,
0.0302412845,
-0.029953165,
-0.0388069525,
-0.0056353556,
-0.0282840356,
-0.0556278862,
-0.0318942107,
0.0080503123,
0.0443220586,
-0.0541864671,
-0.0249597784,
-0.0062328838,
0.0448841266,
0.0453193411,
-0.0368398465,
-0.0209004004,
0.0010971782,
0.0016581125,
-0.0854676291,
0.043786291,
-0.0377944037,
-0.0026191827,
-0.070133172,
0.0086238375,
0.0193187725,
-0.0037473335,
-0.0087659676,
0.039720159,
-0.1090208516,
-0.0474736057,
0.0282170195,
0.0911614597,
0.0192573685,
0.0476494953,
-0.0246525537,
-0.0245432612,
0.0238060914,
0.0503910817,
-0.0123860566,
0.065668866,
0.008077682,
-0.0526778847,
-0.0017861319,
0.0548502393,
-0.0492055304,
0.0148457149,
0.0314290412,
0.0331193916,
0.0033670049,
-0.0189107861,
-0.0064169862,
-0.0139233125,
0.0779230222,
-0.0016860019,
0.0465418063,
0.009545085,
0.0250351597,
0.0195622928,
0.0052994266,
-0.0856786892,
0.0107632987,
-0.0099105993,
0.0218289346,
0.0175175965,
0.0199195743,
0.0129206218,
-0.0220872518,
-0.0391400605,
0.0154105695,
-0.02995071,
-0.0176501609,
0.0189302694,
0.0018596459,
-0.0025609785,
0.005076685,
-0.0055864472,
0.0049065575,
-0.0465372577,
-0.0043156859,
0.0168523435,
0.0230788365,
-0.044412896,
0.0499609113,
-0.0295421928,
-0.0773725286,
-0.0415699631,
0.0254163947,
-0.0107629513,
0.0009794118,
0.0498339497,
-0.0081039732,
-0.0073430561,
-0.064105086,
0.0265630521,
0.0203621499,
-0.0301109497,
0.0371315293,
0.0255655367,
-0.0216382723,
-0.0470935814,
0.0692116246,
-0.0059780711,
0.0124049466,
0.0043146717,
0.0173559543,
-0.0292019118,
-0.0450726971,
-0.0119118635,
-0.030460218,
-0.0049904184,
-0.0040509459,
-0.0229846481,
-0.0619949326,
0.0017850933,
-0.0035386342,
0.0252708104,
-0.0122696478,
0.0380007699,
0.0373050533,
0.0279023312,
-0.039978452,
-0.0000953199,
-0.0184902232,
0.0108477399,
-0.0251401681,
0.0485276878,
-6.224710581e-33,
-0.0283558499,
0.0026450497,
0.0278792493,
-0.0177331101,
-0.0212566089,
0.0437863544,
-0.0293390043,
-0.004999062,
-0.0206346419,
0.000713909,
0.023330804,
0.0150078963,
0.020893015,
0.0444124751,
0.0011490484,
0.0288670529,
0.0556521527,
-0.0140231308,
-0.0299909078,
0.0163426455,
0.01263435,
0.0187955685,
0.0413561501,
-0.0077868854,
-0.0776743814,
0.0210208911,
0.0003723591,
0.0021398675,
0.0253835618,
0.0655093417,
-0.0081882663,
0.0162384417,
0.0135195442,
-0.0211655274,
-0.0499820597,
0.0240964573,
-0.0826701596,
-0.0137736592,
0.0260413773,
0.0572571568,
-0.0965532884,
-0.0137546165,
0.0944212228,
0.0099844718,
0.0008903482,
-0.0453690514,
0.0063139354,
-0.0184131172,
-0.0564245731,
-0.0015283062,
-0.0647780001,
0.0152835902,
0.0218542665,
-0.0175316762,
0.0576128066,
0.0235823318,
-0.0105945664,
0.0375980064,
-0.0500387922,
-0.028917959,
-0.0329091698,
0.0543032512,
0.0842356384,
0.0617846362,
0.0164267793,
0.048777774,
0.0547069125,
-0.0515977554,
-0.0141275767,
-0.002659223,
0.0752601251,
0.0494864285,
0.0680498779,
0.0064890864,
0.0174583159,
0.005381152,
-0.0400605798,
-0.0175137091,
-0.0114748329,
0.0939589739,
0.0448585972,
0.0293833856,
0.0179789998,
-0.0031018066,
-0.0001960889,
0.0055259136,
-0.0550828427,
-0.0010841405,
0.0522868223,
0.0335879214,
-0.0456719063,
0.0293677449,
0.0745244101,
-0.0330940336,
0.0236981995,
0.0247923546,
0.0005092881,
0.0356552638,
0.0291051436,
0.0603182316,
-0.0331063941,
-0.0180403478,
0.028651176,
0.0296423491,
0.0171504803,
0.0145134041,
0.0203857124,
0.039105542,
-0.0649029389,
-0.0116069904,
-0.0509077683,
0.0121075371,
0.0006411446,
0.0533317253,
0.0427410714,
-0.002024855,
-0.0190814622,
0.023659423,
-0.0340468287,
-0.0657887682,
-0.0314873867,
0.0298644677,
0.0478609055,
0.0447503589,
-0.0338864513,
-0.0114499852,
-0.0628533438,
-0.0046944283,
0.0218696296,
-0.0434705317,
-0.031292744,
0.056902241,
2.644e-7,
0.0279412214,
0.0188983381,
0.0152485305,
-0.0189304054,
0.0250917096,
0.0351454169,
0.0027941754,
0.031417571,
0.0045283996,
0.0001343093,
-0.0116779646,
0.0540336482,
0.0412655622,
-0.0213709082,
-0.0553874448,
0.0486903489,
-0.0491048321,
0.015145394,
0.0031115552,
-0.0125389602,
-0.0243925303,
0.1026428416,
-0.013229588,
-0.0137613034,
0.0287677459,
-0.0302636288,
0.0310062692,
-0.0128296884,
0.0388397463,
-0.0083771702,
-0.0173857082,
0.0247624125,
-0.0247438569,
-0.0213961992,
-0.0077312812,
-0.0116478922,
0.0304694232,
0.0582779646,
-0.0553397834,
-0.0281210095,
0.0189460162,
-0.0042778947,
-0.0072270869,
-0.0745889321,
0.0583042465,
-0.067031458,
0.002723169,
-0.071671091,
-0.0011144042,
0.0469826646,
-0.0214752294,
0.0088084936,
-0.0152132241,
0.029551981,
0.0582866296,
-0.0367289521,
-0.0540028289,
-0.085015744,
-0.04631304,
-0.0629817918,
-0.0505117476,
-0.0176508129,
-0.0978903621,
0.003351212,
0.0348731428,
-0.0271209106,
-0.0593896881,
2.482362364e-34,
0.0252843853,
-0.017940456,
0.0000103219,
0.027550716,
-0.0055737747,
-0.0357623957,
-0.0336528905,
0.0351582728,
-0.0325760916,
-0.0543948784,
-0.04344045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15032v1 | How to Distill your BERT: An Empirical Study on the Impact of Weight Initialisation and Distillation Objectives | 2023-05-24T11:16:09 | 2023-05-24T11:16:09 | Xinpeng Wang, Leonie Weissweiler, Hinrich Schütze, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recently, various intermediate layer distillation (ILD) objectives have been
shown to improve compression of BERT models via Knowledge Distillation (KD).
However, a comprehensive evaluation of the objectives in both task-specific and
task-agnostic settings is lacking. To the best of our knowledge, this is the
first work comprehensively evaluating distillation objectives in both settings.
We show that attention transfer gives the best performance overall. We also
study the impact of layer choice when initializing the student from the teacher
layers, finding a significant impact on the performance in task-specific
distillation. For vanilla KD and hidden states transfer, initialisation with
lower layers of the teacher gives a considerable improvement over higher
layers, especially on the task of QNLI (up to an absolute percentage change of
17.8 in accuracy). Attention transfer behaves consistently under different
initialisation settings. We release our code as an efficient transformer-based
model distillation framework for further studies. | [
-0.0196596067,
0.0398279689,
-0.0056050541,
0.0262449309,
-0.0017439979,
0.0041014152,
0.0123222303,
0.0175568331,
-0.0433060229,
0.0188232139,
-0.0157934669,
-0.0106947282,
-0.0023170379,
-0.0117787523,
0.0305569097,
-0.0530289598,
0.0295519289,
-0.0286166519,
0.0129022254,
-0.0228327438,
-0.0346050747,
-0.0529361404,
-0.0111035816,
0.0339435227,
0.0279586557,
-0.0120578054,
-0.0532645211,
0.0423160605,
0.0208191872,
0.0082844803,
0.0067980876,
0.0719261169,
0.0436520427,
-0.0014553869,
0.0000021634,
-0.0010622394,
0.0092439437,
0.0118449628,
-0.0429010279,
0.0493817367,
-0.0391467214,
0.0225582924,
0.0069180378,
0.0137109188,
-0.0100507531,
0.0172865391,
0.0700816736,
0.0139987431,
0.0944059789,
0.0535529219,
-0.0017774766,
-0.0174423084,
0.0132595384,
-0.0034654201,
-0.0047730538,
-0.0212180726,
0.0443553105,
-0.0204131585,
-0.0360657759,
-0.0558829345,
-0.048063565,
0.0304356404,
0.0359646678,
0.014481185,
0.0123629188,
0.0276470557,
-0.0566024892,
-0.0419881009,
-0.0176768191,
0.068128109,
-0.027492445,
-0.0066194441,
0.0056433985,
0.0324686579,
-0.0123082353,
-0.0036158713,
-0.0445909128,
0.001640706,
0.0042167539,
0.0222446471,
-0.0333818421,
-0.0148444222,
0.0182558224,
-0.0332973525,
-0.043693725,
0.014628835,
0.0361875221,
-0.0571809411,
-0.0134823062,
-0.0090284348,
-0.0216759704,
-0.0514348373,
0.0530811809,
0.0454154573,
0.062822096,
-0.0120565034,
-0.0487744659,
-0.059957698,
-0.0304828733,
-0.0281123668,
0.0672287121,
0.0735927224,
-0.0040095909,
0.0028242271,
-0.0517755076,
0.1031338423,
-0.0228942521,
0.0405112766,
-0.0063735675,
-0.0020510692,
-0.0625393763,
0.01706562,
-0.0935227424,
0.0604821555,
-0.0178904906,
-0.02197887,
-0.0290429089,
0.0104308594,
-0.0178909134,
-0.0398224257,
0.0549704991,
0.0128469514,
-0.0148235019,
0.0310407691,
-0.0091495886,
0.0884445012,
-0.0175424758,
-0.005594031,
0.0159805361,
-0.0400739312,
-0.0539828837,
-0.0122694643,
0.0084537836,
-0.0049139597,
-0.010916126,
0.0075887186,
-0.0103309005,
-0.0430826023,
-0.0263801198,
0.0435879007,
0.0062151048,
-0.0288903639,
0.0650699288,
-0.0343866907,
0.0380281694,
-0.0215903707,
0.004625713,
-0.0392713062,
0.0097333845,
-0.0187896304,
-0.0130900219,
-0.0001598566,
0.0002853225,
0.0110968947,
0.0083950264,
0.0313798189,
-0.0252131503,
0.0590114035,
0.0426810384,
0.0269451365,
-0.0256738812,
-0.049805101,
-0.0058062049,
0.0264137704,
0.0734049976,
0.0202910695,
-0.0609262548,
-0.029997481,
-0.03145786,
-0.0121728107,
0.0389817506,
0.0588499829,
-0.066029191,
0.0149565106,
0.0613929704,
0.0345429219,
0.0651632324,
0.047757078,
-0.0274757035,
0.0121475989,
0.030354511,
0.0193515271,
-0.0240913182,
0.0479498506,
0.012442559,
-0.0079734819,
0.0402106494,
0.05765507,
-0.0370807014,
-0.0118875764,
-0.012105654,
-0.0078705503,
0.0294453856,
0.0036002067,
0.0284862965,
0.0173476506,
-0.0423573628,
0.1415252537,
0.0212491322,
-0.0819357038,
-0.0189136751,
-0.0677044317,
-0.0167949051,
0.0404902175,
0.0308334101,
0.0198849048,
-0.0412483849,
0.0109869232,
-0.0122999977,
-0.0067567984,
0.0131531833,
0.0104359416,
0.0617953576,
-0.0665777326,
-0.0559606515,
-0.0061468636,
0.0018982085,
0.0072955652,
0.0157819111,
0.001324218,
-0.001733062,
-0.0660670772,
0.0144490162,
0.0069725071,
0.0060275914,
-0.0263536032,
-0.0140612079,
0.0217459314,
0.0317529403,
-0.0060474402,
-0.026597878,
-0.0153619526,
0.0312352348,
-0.0232560467,
0.0018732413,
-0.0344411656,
-0.0404830948,
-0.065963544,
0.0151689108,
-0.0280419588,
0.0398799293,
0.0785991177,
-0.0179146845,
-0.0754485652,
0.0140498178,
-0.0419533588,
0.0605948046,
-0.0051769088,
0.0230808631,
-0.0127762761,
0.0035521479,
0.0045845686,
0.042963922,
-0.0433125794,
-0.0257125739,
0.0288060997,
0.0036880705,
-0.0010801731,
-0.0156760048,
-0.0252134502,
0.0146639748,
-0.038597431,
0.0042690197,
0.009653978,
-0.0222859234,
-0.0059580901,
-0.0390113331,
-0.0831158534,
0.0009705459,
-0.0328016505,
0.0397707708,
0.0216694362,
0.030485034,
0.0051949774,
0.0031511406,
-0.0259718932,
-0.0060051726,
-0.0621750951,
-0.0108780405,
-0.032666076,
-0.0103409188,
-0.0274901483,
-0.0120262569,
-0.0389440022,
0.0100576477,
0.0511395149,
-0.0608695038,
-0.0318287797,
-0.0110328812,
-0.0073515279,
-0.0197111703,
0.040347632,
0.011069078,
-0.0488438271,
0.0087218294,
-0.0106485076,
0.0392014943,
0.0485458039,
-0.0012782527,
0.0554564744,
0.0393447205,
-0.0155012365,
-0.0723133683,
0.0681848004,
-0.0351197124,
0.03492558,
-0.0167440064,
-0.0429552086,
0.0075189508,
0.1063861772,
-0.0305491574,
0.0004040296,
-0.0878406614,
-0.0514707118,
0.011639812,
-0.0285628289,
0.007003997,
-0.0131533714,
-0.0323337354,
-0.0085733933,
-0.0210134089,
-0.0228531491,
0.0741948038,
-0.0348092131,
-0.0082833646,
-0.0445255302,
0.017985357,
0.0214443021,
0.0012777821,
-0.0193180759,
0.0167687014,
-0.0214032829,
0.001841645,
-0.0178574789,
0.009526398,
0.0006288993,
-0.0015950688,
-0.000562961,
-0.0121752685,
-0.0106352866,
-0.0157144275,
-0.0420198329,
-0.0309297163,
0.0338051356,
0.0257493984,
0.0474600866,
0.0417286977,
-0.0620052628,
-0.0328837037,
0.006144884,
0.0241815485,
0.0371209867,
-0.0159339663,
0.0174624138,
-0.0237281676,
0.0350864343,
0.0062419353,
0.005655867,
0.0141025828,
-0.0408296473,
0.0282928571,
0.0283143464,
0.0694170445,
0.0156074958,
-0.0446714722,
0.0115915509,
0.0326531157,
-0.0117484936,
-0.0227806382,
0.0378173962,
0.0554227866,
-0.0570766218,
-0.0039248648,
0.0853897557,
0.0110563273,
-0.0146285044,
0.0016947273,
-0.0073950696,
0.0506211333,
-0.0093156537,
0.0211379211,
-0.0609848499,
-0.0325663723,
0.0144057721,
0.0519844182,
0.0440544561,
-0.023515163,
0.0132644502,
-0.0370433107,
0.0135195823,
0.0108107673,
0.0171377361,
-0.0487286374,
-0.0647221655,
-0.0004056363,
0.0147563703,
-0.0012581507,
0.0051360945,
-0.0029031353,
0.0100805135,
0.0550241731,
-0.0003420139,
-0.0522513166,
-0.0040862989,
-0.0030196819,
0.0228201207,
0.0811776072,
0.0226213969,
-0.0187495742,
-0.1060153618,
-0.021789806,
-0.0092277788,
-0.0051791049,
-0.0002757729,
0.0190328155,
0.0274774805,
-0.0048493021,
-0.0129718855,
0.0029878533,
0.0018711464,
-0.020439392,
-0.0290192142,
0.0575006902,
0.0022670296,
-0.0683305785,
-0.0132146338,
-0.0311296843,
-0.001793618,
0.0694527179,
0.0655754283,
-0.0108359409,
-0.04295839,
0.0144489789,
0.014972209,
-0.0657183304,
0.0465384424,
0.0147807281,
-0.0321858861,
-0.0656505376,
-0.0445682816,
-0.0022453601,
0.0080766948,
0.0433835052,
0.0094410321,
-0.0377846546,
0.0529395677,
0.0181340575,
-0.0573648438,
0.0211520698,
0.0125079146,
-0.0146137225,
-0.033573363,
-0.0547565781,
-0.0000157648,
0.0133506181,
-0.0125219626,
-0.012280032,
-0.0910174698,
-0.0521280281,
0.0428634621,
0.0621823408,
0.022591792,
0.0538804308,
0.0046145408,
-0.0206521172,
0.092741631,
-0.0044215722,
-0.0051251869,
0.0347547792,
0.0540050305,
-0.0438934043,
0.0160288177,
0.0237992853,
-0.0547292531,
0.0066280859,
0.0160441734,
0.0572898611,
-0.0351754911,
-0.0200395063,
-0.0009136145,
0.0129612051,
0.0555386618,
0.011934611,
0.0092879608,
0.0126351351,
0.0454603396,
0.0282357708,
0.0514471903,
-0.0930745006,
-0.0016293488,
0.0280783046,
0.0292065404,
0.0531876907,
0.0553425774,
0.0623298362,
-0.0353779607,
-0.0287276544,
0.027884217,
-0.0372774117,
0.0277947579,
0.0641359314,
0.0010952549,
-0.0153866811,
0.02212945,
0.0381603725,
0.0106570674,
-0.023989113,
0.0494748987,
0.0311734471,
0.0356386527,
-0.0184560716,
0.0285225958,
-0.0425771251,
-0.0710425451,
-0.0438195579,
0.0262636933,
0.0217684396,
0.0574594885,
0.0269661192,
-0.0306334998,
0.0118525783,
0.0058143903,
0.0064968569,
-0.0155955469,
-0.0061782072,
0.0357280001,
0.0121365776,
0.0274667796,
-0.0248853136,
0.0866667479,
0.0116830962,
0.0513899736,
-0.052722279,
0.0376783274,
-0.0225293748,
-0.0437219627,
0.0488480888,
0.0366334021,
0.0082397638,
-0.002359679,
-0.0109806899,
-0.0487716943,
-0.0053818589,
-0.0207757093,
0.0190718323,
-0.0325536765,
0.0831781626,
0.0142669724,
-0.0175179318,
-0.0618851669,
0.0184767172,
-0.0499897785,
0.0271033347,
-0.0250326451,
0.0166851748,
-6.604977126e-33,
-0.0342828222,
0.0554631799,
0.0268185344,
-0.031825196,
-0.0257583279,
0.0086000804,
-0.0600282028,
-0.0313572399,
-0.0096093984,
0.0213970337,
-0.0176830739,
0.0342586376,
0.0265561994,
0.0380502343,
-0.035341613,
-0.0195624456,
0.0839712173,
0.0030951286,
-0.0339562185,
0.0472847559,
-0.0012286529,
0.0472722575,
0.0424714312,
0.000246873,
-0.0361880101,
0.0099167563,
0.0174768735,
-0.015855398,
0.0067301304,
0.0015093226,
-0.0276464187,
-0.0008304557,
-0.0319764689,
-0.0490231402,
-0.0428990163,
0.0258114766,
-0.0627600551,
-0.0441627018,
0.0094385883,
0.0022529014,
-0.053925395,
-0.0459437333,
0.0634829104,
0.0375716276,
-0.0057337852,
-0.0258773677,
0.0142868171,
0.0118265459,
-0.0403273404,
-0.0792779475,
-0.0285381768,
-0.0056038662,
-0.0225193966,
-0.0619948246,
0.0365289301,
0.0205718875,
-0.0389390737,
-0.0242638309,
-0.0688400343,
-0.0104786446,
0.0608328432,
0.0205714907,
0.0584205277,
0.037307322,
0.0216423217,
0.0170173422,
0.0180589072,
0.0080284951,
-0.0322417952,
-0.0537946336,
0.0441648215,
0.0728697702,
0.0172311142,
-0.0776715577,
0.0497464575,
-0.0157278851,
-0.0476201251,
0.0073764138,
0.0040511093,
0.0298862513,
-0.0115996031,
0.0095091322,
-0.0132486671,
-0.0403236784,
-0.0276165251,
0.006394431,
-0.0080115339,
-0.0129580684,
0.0170945711,
-0.0025268546,
-0.0345032923,
-0.0411748104,
0.0536546633,
-0.0496303402,
0.052674219,
0.0040253922,
0.0015561845,
0.0335941091,
0.0165779777,
0.0070269974,
-0.0689589083,
-0.0271417107,
0.0402828008,
0.0024567484,
0.0217468739,
0.0246187523,
0.0051755812,
0.0558965243,
-0.0249565449,
-0.0358174779,
-0.0384405553,
-0.0057002292,
0.0451939851,
0.0357396305,
0.0245885458,
0.014478608,
0.0123574967,
-0.0066796979,
-0.0143939648,
0.0200631469,
-0.008799687,
0.0223056525,
0.0401104279,
0.0624960884,
-0.004518738,
-0.0138626629,
-0.0762659982,
0.0293749459,
-0.0183829963,
-0.054417599,
-0.0399536379,
0.0311722551,
2.848e-7,
0.0099398652,
0.0241274908,
0.0220331326,
-0.0435184501,
-0.0065207011,
-0.0034473019,
-0.0249904692,
0.0290800352,
0.0167309493,
-0.0057301754,
0.012754458,
0.0592739843,
0.0237284694,
0.0013260854,
-0.0704995841,
-0.0649659932,
-0.0464930385,
-0.0320289992,
-0.006654799,
-0.0300605483,
-0.0034603328,
0.044111222,
0.0272618532,
-0.0069779158,
0.0404322036,
0.0150597803,
0.0353860445,
0.0262768846,
0.0724407434,
0.0222118776,
0.0310360808,
-0.0329212546,
-0.0317487307,
0.0128987236,
-0.0131017715,
0.0247022603,
-0.0181123316,
0.0736781657,
-0.0238766298,
-0.0495136417,
0.0016022091,
-0.0000475525,
-0.0132979369,
-0.0393949002,
0.0305309501,
-0.0442034006,
-0.0016553395,
0.0337113366,
-0.0516611896,
-0.017304752,
-0.0042092055,
-0.0090543684,
0.0327726714,
-0.0078861807,
-0.0146070514,
-0.0133805908,
-0.0154977208,
-0.0575080663,
-0.0004223934,
-0.0066787028,
-0.0525661856,
-0.0670000389,
-0.0675747022,
-0.0627900437,
0.0392064042,
-0.0373667665,
-0.0044185324,
2.732002696e-34,
0.0131757818,
-0.0364939831,
0.0164952762,
0.050153967,
-0.0088154059,
-0.0473819152,
-0.0513501018,
-0.005104939,
-0.0022540202,
-0.0671296865,
-0.0392758958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15028v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15028v2 | ImageNetVC: Zero- and Few-Shot Visual Commonsense Evaluation on 1000 ImageNet Categories | 2023-05-24T11:14:31 | 2023-10-20T20:41:46 | Heming Xia, Qingxiu Dong, Lei Li, Jingjing Xu, Tianyu Liu, Ziwei Qin, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have been serving as general-purpose
interfaces, posing a significant demand for comprehensive visual knowledge.
However, it remains unclear how well current LLMs and their visually augmented
counterparts (VaLMs) can master visual commonsense knowledge. To investigate
this, we propose ImageNetVC, a human-annotated dataset specifically designed
for zero- and few-shot visual commonsense evaluation across 1,000 ImageNet
categories. Utilizing ImageNetVC, we benchmark the fundamental visual
commonsense knowledge of both unimodal LLMs and VaLMs. Furthermore, we analyze
the factors affecting the visual commonsense knowledge of large-scale models,
providing insights into the development of language models enriched with visual
commonsense knowledge. Our code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/hemingkx/ImageNetVC. | [
0.011181782,
0.0445906445,
-0.0232703872,
0.0709226355,
-0.010973162,
0.0161692239,
0.0005228333,
0.0148155969,
0.0301039536,
-0.0522318855,
-0.0469833724,
0.0294081215,
0.0097292066,
-0.0103021739,
0.047494106,
-0.0517994687,
0.0327197388,
-0.003315201,
-0.0159397367,
0.0068842242,
0.0256708805,
0.0278665777,
-0.023788603,
0.0372010618,
-0.0052208118,
-0.0239944775,
0.0120578669,
0.0222408995,
0.0227815919,
-0.0079286601,
-0.0393422581,
0.0545854755,
0.0612207949,
0.0258479603,
0.0000015309,
0.0180299617,
0.0933838114,
-0.0106809903,
0.0188473184,
0.021217389,
0.0587945282,
-0.0468588546,
0.0217526853,
-0.027113663,
-0.0364966169,
0.0027484966,
0.0521523468,
0.0135186007,
0.0733755976,
-0.0086675286,
-0.020174481,
-0.0050394866,
0.0256405976,
-0.0300413202,
0.0313120149,
-0.0364703052,
-0.002155696,
0.0492865294,
-0.0043546078,
0.0056660506,
-0.049591884,
0.0751786679,
0.0638896599,
-0.0365346298,
-0.0062662796,
0.0550596789,
-0.0614844523,
-0.0129527729,
-0.0236636419,
0.0908515304,
0.0194728523,
-0.0200283919,
-0.0145792225,
0.0031154745,
0.0093933623,
0.0156117501,
-0.0518664084,
0.0257007051,
0.0220019966,
0.0111760385,
-0.0198344477,
-0.0187781323,
0.000834006,
0.0454189591,
0.0183969028,
-0.0151487514,
0.0061194729,
0.0459965579,
0.0082611758,
0.0219698548,
-0.0740664601,
-0.0462737195,
-0.0176192056,
0.0149422083,
0.0119852759,
0.0121607091,
-0.0361065492,
-0.0333933868,
0.020890655,
-0.0618241616,
0.0492504276,
0.0103978375,
-0.0748070255,
0.0784860849,
-0.0464387424,
0.0590150692,
-0.0162962303,
0.0652896911,
0.0074792611,
-0.0152567066,
-0.0460782871,
-0.0197845288,
-0.0410875678,
-0.0272602309,
-0.0535071306,
-0.0410274155,
-0.0096584102,
-0.0279417802,
-0.0155782001,
0.0298253819,
0.0186176579,
0.0306289811,
-0.0354893506,
-0.0183329619,
-0.0289113671,
0.0437440574,
-0.0370266698,
0.0283993799,
0.0187617764,
-0.0281004664,
-0.0089675533,
0.0278109126,
-0.0008587197,
-0.0151534015,
-0.0164121017,
0.0394028351,
-0.0419291928,
-0.0101339165,
-0.0451372266,
-0.0253078807,
-0.0095128464,
-0.0232312009,
0.021011712,
-0.0838876516,
0.0046314369,
-0.0158954263,
0.0045622806,
-0.0170678739,
0.0045504211,
0.0087809814,
-0.0161210708,
0.0895787105,
-0.0376221687,
-0.0213068742,
0.0010000502,
0.026392024,
0.0163612198,
0.0831240416,
0.0065808627,
0.0193552207,
0.0255795475,
0.0110972244,
-0.0055730208,
0.0199911818,
0.0174986403,
0.0194435995,
-0.066210717,
-0.000084483,
-0.0428017825,
0.0442529283,
0.0556860827,
0.0274921563,
-0.0502852947,
-0.0245786551,
0.0686924607,
0.058753822,
0.0047487379,
0.0119519634,
0.0313209891,
0.0116915992,
0.0114800725,
-0.0042213094,
-0.0709289759,
0.0730767474,
-0.0050649936,
-0.0120937712,
-0.0464573056,
-0.0079781255,
-0.0357533507,
-0.0155787738,
-0.0116659719,
0.0170741938,
0.0169311818,
-0.0101114698,
0.0165566318,
0.0456073582,
0.004155701,
0.0292991642,
0.0377557948,
-0.0656739697,
0.0058660312,
-0.0148521857,
0.0322731212,
0.0577870384,
0.0431234241,
0.0200634524,
-0.0084187556,
0.0050818543,
0.0260846857,
0.0826706439,
0.0057773539,
-0.0142224152,
0.0096342992,
-0.0600089431,
-0.0199107472,
-0.0047786934,
0.0138268005,
-0.001259608,
-0.0063717565,
-0.002339999,
0.0075153131,
-0.0692064017,
-0.0190798659,
0.0269288477,
0.0210101474,
-0.006332295,
-0.0474567525,
0.0076798932,
0.003595585,
0.0037078117,
-0.0181448627,
-0.0162529591,
-0.0070809182,
-0.0397756286,
0.0016790821,
0.0273366198,
-0.0352022536,
-0.0848475918,
0.0437657014,
-0.0720666274,
-0.0484540202,
0.0492092893,
-0.0230569914,
0.0011430447,
0.0165589955,
-0.011344892,
0.0008011665,
-0.0572622009,
-0.0533096269,
-0.001742051,
0.0074962359,
0.0103734676,
0.0488703661,
-0.0330896825,
0.0002554001,
0.0239555724,
-0.0137289464,
0.0021660104,
-0.010761125,
-0.0157424174,
-0.0052106329,
0.0016194405,
0.0291144755,
-0.0102422778,
0.0470253527,
-0.0192116927,
0.0133086657,
-0.1145799309,
-0.0387008674,
-0.0308684222,
-0.0255675465,
0.0026897446,
-0.0539937653,
0.0228401758,
-0.0248376206,
-0.032921195,
0.052053187,
-0.0333763435,
0.0040354887,
0.0314552449,
-0.0137945134,
0.0065423916,
-0.0230108798,
-0.0153747536,
0.0089648543,
0.0388733558,
0.0229108278,
0.0386089012,
0.0160236899,
0.0232027248,
-0.0297094453,
0.0273532551,
-0.0184750017,
-0.0649357736,
0.0315096118,
-0.0096727982,
-0.0388644263,
0.0412690192,
-0.0104064876,
0.0485909581,
0.0145057207,
-0.0042146398,
-0.0376746245,
-0.0033917271,
0.0362501219,
-0.0102106221,
-0.0348448083,
0.0074972371,
-0.0429567099,
0.036401052,
-0.0071135401,
0.0219597742,
-0.0718802884,
0.0137746865,
-0.0389694795,
-0.0576740876,
-0.081110917,
0.031790629,
0.0059447819,
0.0381485336,
-0.0584520064,
-0.0435182601,
0.0496353023,
-0.0360783525,
-0.0218336377,
0.0205268525,
0.0151686976,
-0.0069019683,
0.0843948722,
0.0003308923,
0.0287139174,
-0.0279754251,
-0.0281409584,
-0.0757739916,
-0.0391876623,
0.0351881236,
-0.0100568105,
0.0660205111,
-0.0596118085,
0.0164726321,
-0.0522919819,
-0.0165309403,
-0.0043931832,
-0.0268289782,
-0.020089047,
0.0322312936,
-0.0073272046,
-0.0335230045,
0.0213553403,
-0.0085177533,
0.0277341716,
0.0315329581,
0.0140765915,
-0.0067749647,
-0.0244451091,
0.0529796071,
0.0634542629,
0.0484161936,
-0.018445272,
-0.005613449,
-0.003101113,
0.0595460795,
0.0179157425,
0.0001166088,
-0.0489965156,
0.0538168512,
0.0297838598,
0.019793082,
0.0056259315,
0.015100956,
0.0712435022,
-0.0567245446,
0.0058650649,
0.0580973625,
0.0177536309,
-0.0414752066,
-0.0143995155,
0.0014261516,
0.0182674732,
0.0422502719,
-0.0046808016,
-0.11178381,
-0.0607472174,
-0.0217327923,
-0.0245611984,
0.0215302594,
-0.0481582209,
-0.0032174313,
-0.0822899938,
0.0391336568,
-0.0018235606,
-0.0617040209,
-0.0359643586,
0.0298195686,
-0.0068721324,
-0.0188278798,
0.0051968228,
-0.0033413784,
-0.0016078355,
-0.020018775,
0.0019648061,
0.048173435,
-0.0502580442,
0.0205386281,
-0.0496831499,
0.0441675745,
0.0283456221,
0.0457275547,
-0.0216905214,
-0.0844037682,
-0.0035159714,
-0.0278052185,
0.0167140178,
-0.015061344,
0.0513210073,
-0.0169945005,
-0.0482754894,
0.0022765948,
0.044774618,
-0.0336111188,
-0.0450592898,
-0.0304785632,
0.0312128253,
-0.0094746565,
-0.0064780498,
-0.0289223958,
0.0065518063,
0.0187148415,
0.0544701144,
0.0719964132,
-0.0007887771,
-0.0114196893,
-0.0286039952,
-0.0321790054,
-0.052252043,
-0.060996294,
-0.0008363404,
0.0343279541,
-0.0282128286,
-0.0683954358,
0.0083550634,
0.0447910689,
0.02306436,
0.0026008666,
-0.0040294337,
0.0182355847,
0.0069288192,
-0.0346430913,
0.0522768497,
-0.0353490487,
0.0197416469,
-0.0152808381,
-0.0034097957,
0.0149594005,
-0.0099337418,
-0.0320360027,
0.0500556715,
-0.0435898602,
-0.030128425,
-0.0327104926,
0.0332157239,
0.017300874,
-0.0055217799,
-0.0158001874,
-0.0795210004,
0.0674231723,
0.0760833323,
0.0085890992,
0.0125213871,
0.0191421732,
-0.0153199155,
0.0191408023,
0.0660472736,
-0.0167990588,
0.0052938908,
0.0000822622,
0.0344487987,
-0.035215389,
0.0109046595,
-0.0258108377,
-0.004850023,
0.0257201679,
-0.0276215747,
0.0612012446,
-0.0483315736,
-0.0269463956,
-0.0016186639,
-0.0041896207,
-0.0630137026,
0.0064442148,
0.0289770514,
-0.032629516,
-0.009936152,
0.0432251282,
0.0068625794,
0.0489107743,
-0.0166084711,
-0.0004712733,
0.0320499651,
0.0159007628,
-0.0084888702,
0.0209183395,
-0.0113572609,
-0.0083278781,
-0.0638004839,
0.0248352997,
-0.0053327521,
0.084825471,
0.040739242,
-0.0362223983,
-0.0020490352,
0.0392014384,
-0.0031579742,
-0.0192344617,
0.0001653825,
0.0672897547,
0.0675338805,
-0.0052526002,
0.037102811,
-0.0349057615,
-0.0172263943,
0.0010605365,
0.0570387691,
-0.0085667213,
-0.0410553589,
0.0990925804,
0.0338473544,
0.0027859616,
-0.0293958876,
0.0697545707,
-0.0196526311,
0.0221521389,
-0.0109337028,
-0.0091736205,
-0.0236279536,
-0.0340041555,
0.0349165946,
-0.0016117906,
0.0087732701,
0.0444308147,
-0.0522126183,
-0.0851345137,
-0.0126720052,
0.0640319735,
0.0035582522,
0.0103236632,
0.0330880769,
0.0299332142,
0.0111777214,
-0.0272950362,
0.0006542449,
-0.0115429722,
-0.0788411051,
0.0077510029,
-0.0349548459,
-5.650833505e-33,
-0.0493874736,
-0.0225141477,
0.0265574437,
-0.02256421,
-0.0137108304,
0.0041771904,
-0.0492582396,
0.0263201073,
-0.0197322648,
0.0666572675,
0.0105830729,
0.0227210093,
-0.0010442734,
0.0259959809,
-0.0019292444,
-0.0175465457,
0.0216696784,
0.0026135363,
-0.0074081062,
0.019216897,
0.024322601,
-0.0317577273,
0.0517043993,
-0.0300423168,
-0.0083188517,
0.0312922373,
-0.0087460699,
0.0244495999,
0.0088674696,
0.069764331,
-0.012336391,
0.048659306,
0.0168725252,
0.0103182513,
-0.0246503539,
0.0303100217,
-0.0588563867,
-0.0241018347,
0.0360741057,
0.029995326,
-0.0852644667,
-0.0129887648,
0.0352343023,
-0.0049199862,
-0.0094524957,
-0.0121490713,
0.0550977625,
-0.0211484544,
-0.02312975,
-0.0171444938,
-0.0212425459,
0.0148541555,
-0.0145245939,
-0.0452359281,
-0.0093118623,
-0.0274000466,
0.0034003798,
0.0256157927,
-0.0511669554,
-0.0076060882,
-0.0153130954,
0.0358440317,
0.0930094793,
0.0050963932,
0.0215901472,
0.0566628464,
-0.0373025909,
-0.0352534838,
-0.0455797575,
0.017692633,
0.0605141222,
0.0868133828,
0.0723467022,
0.0915541798,
0.0173151027,
0.0008657923,
-0.0108297924,
0.0052287006,
-0.0588449985,
0.0863598585,
-0.0153395608,
0.0094975848,
0.0255700387,
-0.0042386982,
-0.0597825237,
-0.0863479823,
-0.0387112871,
0.0061448165,
0.0222183187,
-0.0147764739,
-0.0116941845,
0.0396190435,
0.0464619175,
-0.048269581,
-0.0251447763,
0.0443736278,
-0.0246948525,
0.0631182343,
0.0226754081,
0.0128170224,
-0.0675426945,
0.0029348182,
0.050101921,
0.0395803563,
0.0169870257,
0.0273804702,
0.0750789642,
0.0105576115,
-0.0131243011,
-0.0132979704,
-0.0397112072,
-0.0186100174,
-0.0264013559,
0.0119137866,
0.0368859172,
-0.0065833111,
-0.0547352172,
-0.008884809,
-0.038654048,
-0.0197139848,
0.0079760924,
-0.0076149311,
0.0008415464,
0.007977155,
-0.0311345533,
0.0024963215,
-0.0568368882,
-0.0231366381,
0.0658558384,
-0.0337099023,
0.0023627393,
0.0647305474,
2.113e-7,
0.0212080963,
0.0068564145,
0.0219032783,
0.0105655231,
0.0265265089,
0.0604197457,
-0.0177319124,
0.0375924818,
-0.0413628444,
-0.068027772,
-0.0194924697,
0.0781142935,
0.0616687685,
0.0226757899,
-0.0202079453,
0.0207501054,
-0.0458041169,
0.009983304,
-0.034474887,
-0.0087548709,
0.0688262358,
0.0453386568,
-0.0057927961,
-0.0327166803,
0.0711109191,
-0.0723037943,
0.0688003674,
-0.0328847542,
0.0135987392,
-0.039372474,
0.0080946935,
0.0564078391,
-0.0113083301,
0.008832979,
0.001146239,
-0.02706521,
0.011783435,
0.0294523202,
-0.013862527,
-0.0168605801,
-0.0471147634,
-0.0246136039,
-0.0086414404,
-0.0434444696,
0.0661061183,
-0.0700311959,
-0.0040358989,
-0.032466501,
-0.0128644081,
0.004052531,
0.0234916899,
-0.0180763565,
-0.0401927792,
0.0219518282,
0.0369262435,
-0.0310125202,
-0.0408745743,
-0.0655992255,
-0.0199057441,
-0.0233978517,
-0.0171301644,
-0.0321686119,
-0.0495060571,
-0.0279745273,
0.0171683971,
-0.0577957332,
-0.050049793,
1.300126254e-34,
0.0109489542,
-0.0118526667,
0.0240078699,
-0.0023275928,
0.0228771232,
-0.0015236941,
-0.0233643409,
0.0035413925,
-0.0177804511,
-0.0494765788,
0.0050511849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15025v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15025v2 | Dior-CVAE: Pre-trained Language Models and Diffusion Priors for Variational Dialog Generation | 2023-05-24T11:06:52 | 2023-10-23T18:51:10 | Tianyu Yang, Thy Thy Tran, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current variational dialog models have employed pre-trained language models
(PLMs) to parameterize the likelihood and posterior distributions. However, the
Gaussian assumption made on the prior distribution is incompatible with these
distributions, thus restricting the diversity of generated responses. These
models also suffer from posterior collapse, i.e., the decoder tends to ignore
latent variables and directly access information captured in the encoder
through the cross-attention mechanism. In this work, we propose Dior-CVAE, a
hierarchical conditional variational autoencoder (CVAE) with diffusion priors
to address these challenges. We employ a diffusion model to increase the
complexity of the prior distribution and its compatibility with the
distributions produced by a PLM. Also, we propose memory dropout to the
cross-attention mechanism, which actively encourages the use of latent
variables for response generation. Overall, experiments across two commonly
used open-domain dialog datasets show that our method can generate more diverse
responses without large-scale dialog pre-training. Code is available at
https://github.com/UKPLab/dior-cvae. | [
0.0202662833,
0.112042658,
-0.0069721919,
0.0140974363,
0.0285163037,
0.0035718402,
0.0250444021,
-0.039039772,
0.0111515606,
-0.0376363434,
-0.0209325664,
-0.0580113418,
-0.0114558218,
0.093803592,
0.0331604071,
-0.0802899227,
0.0010427043,
-0.033501137,
0.0089714862,
-0.0507605635,
0.0048136562,
0.0001028273,
-0.0342194214,
0.0351757444,
0.0003490478,
-0.0145265246,
-0.0571955703,
0.0050853156,
0.0229056254,
-0.0059277588,
0.0188257154,
0.0575308502,
0.0551200882,
-0.0138339475,
0.0000021093,
-0.0074593988,
0.0220309328,
-0.0244040862,
-0.0271164924,
0.0131268809,
0.038524814,
-0.0109506277,
0.0218629148,
0.0122826975,
-0.0061703487,
-0.0636153966,
0.0477887429,
0.0224561002,
0.0699053481,
0.0648801997,
-0.0073924931,
-0.043234095,
0.0459556244,
-0.0629649907,
0.0329921842,
-0.0598544478,
-0.0148242684,
0.0113395806,
-0.0049690246,
0.0081598107,
-0.0256373584,
0.0315277316,
0.0490841828,
-0.046883136,
0.0011847998,
0.0278230514,
0.0645438656,
-0.0384447761,
-0.0401976854,
0.1041341424,
0.0002329203,
0.0087156612,
-0.0178496055,
-0.0488971174,
-0.0165495276,
-0.0064809117,
-0.0526277386,
0.054720901,
0.0361665487,
-0.0095194411,
0.0066778227,
0.0482552014,
-0.025832193,
-0.0272745024,
-0.0129980212,
0.0117065534,
0.0506525412,
-0.0092542376,
-0.0093061142,
-0.0053633102,
-0.0067996401,
-0.0730034932,
0.0156916995,
0.0199709795,
-0.0452943146,
-0.0050677871,
-0.0605919622,
-0.022400165,
-0.0059609246,
-0.0047656908,
0.023620978,
0.0452383421,
0.0007366928,
-0.0203822944,
0.0169599541,
0.0268009342,
-0.0535074472,
-0.0141699323,
-0.0311736986,
-0.0156031046,
0.0117860818,
0.0030163825,
-0.0128442934,
-0.0045052445,
-0.0562596396,
-0.0462194197,
-0.0171988662,
0.034562964,
-0.0015869406,
-0.0155343898,
0.0006053089,
0.058996141,
-0.053400971,
-0.027396623,
-0.0198679268,
0.0316548608,
-0.0557804331,
0.0273491889,
0.0588990636,
-0.0243090428,
-0.0264778994,
0.0633567274,
0.0383400023,
-0.0182201751,
-0.0227155797,
0.0287967976,
-0.0294460747,
0.0481894799,
-0.0101368269,
-0.0255416967,
-0.0405749306,
-0.0446165875,
0.0162636712,
-0.0465255231,
0.0451313294,
-0.0140559319,
-0.015301072,
-0.0255365372,
0.0009659838,
-0.0181024689,
-0.0064009833,
0.0247858819,
0.0236491133,
-0.0118979607,
0.0642778203,
-0.0002350428,
0.0103215324,
0.0461014844,
0.0396641232,
0.0193420146,
-0.0234005935,
0.0007329544,
0.0069930032,
0.0165589023,
0.0379888564,
0.0083205225,
-0.0054262965,
0.0141588338,
-0.0375239551,
0.0221952386,
0.0706808567,
0.0374504104,
-0.0348934084,
-0.0251723453,
0.0365668871,
0.0172759071,
-0.0176421255,
-0.0037742062,
0.0503698885,
0.0602463298,
-0.034141615,
-0.0079004206,
0.0056504514,
0.0339650139,
0.0216861032,
0.0271988194,
0.0605304055,
-0.0040690252,
-0.0410904847,
-0.0361247212,
0.0523279123,
-0.0062200064,
0.0132801067,
0.0092036249,
0.0105193425,
0.0374506973,
-0.0501293428,
0.066102311,
0.0320504308,
-0.0560917854,
-0.0028715509,
-0.0201290734,
0.0507036746,
0.016574692,
0.0160898436,
0.0197158642,
-0.0200083684,
-0.0498767905,
0.0074190833,
0.0704036057,
0.0259281788,
-0.0075104446,
0.0188997909,
-0.0617649034,
-0.0307331327,
-0.0405757762,
0.0225187112,
0.0692744553,
-0.0481372215,
0.0106151132,
0.0346558653,
0.0150378356,
0.0164208971,
0.0097714588,
-0.006758627,
0.0035228899,
0.0335143134,
-0.002597926,
0.049896691,
0.0229819417,
-0.0013864271,
0.0353588462,
0.0066447146,
-0.0284886453,
0.0049521448,
-0.0049747629,
-0.0634190142,
-0.0822663456,
-0.0041427505,
-0.0493825674,
-0.0034050453,
0.0127443234,
-0.0179591384,
-0.0542592369,
0.0757659078,
-0.0320147797,
-0.0004963427,
-0.0217892062,
-0.0289043915,
0.0448581129,
0.0407696851,
-0.0066359234,
0.0508169346,
-0.0277369935,
-0.0201381575,
0.0611904413,
0.1063800678,
0.0210064258,
-0.0417057052,
0.0107189473,
-0.0288763996,
-0.0114704091,
0.0142327845,
0.0220815819,
0.0194679163,
-0.0251615439,
-0.0176214762,
-0.083306998,
0.0218097363,
-0.0416415147,
-0.006329787,
0.0261678081,
0.0355698951,
-0.0097455494,
0.0067762663,
-0.0521425679,
0.0373984762,
0.0352606364,
-0.0133200986,
-0.0001598948,
-0.0075026448,
0.0278469678,
-0.0400805324,
-0.0103734946,
0.0294323079,
0.0517165065,
-0.0088085411,
0.0240970179,
-0.001799351,
0.0209947918,
-0.0141010331,
0.0092870807,
-0.0183515642,
-0.0422317386,
0.0196516532,
0.0147019504,
0.089344047,
0.0317263976,
0.0476673953,
0.0265853163,
0.0156304017,
-0.0105494848,
-0.0519197397,
0.0381342731,
-0.0673252642,
-0.0134695759,
-0.0239012521,
-0.0323118865,
0.0074926619,
0.0438480042,
0.0474075451,
0.0336469002,
-0.0616586618,
0.0248855799,
0.0513804778,
-0.0670197681,
0.0194490328,
-0.023282636,
-0.0362734385,
0.0491840057,
-0.0149730165,
0.0049078576,
0.0555065572,
-0.0247763507,
-0.0202651843,
-0.0498168208,
0.0126706287,
-0.0003451062,
0.0125474781,
0.0160937607,
0.0168409515,
0.0255652945,
-0.0259889122,
-0.0147790024,
0.0374579169,
0.0019732029,
-0.0011877546,
0.0327553488,
-0.0115463315,
-0.0176609848,
-0.0016528334,
-0.0236965455,
-0.070719704,
-0.0451193787,
0.0210759696,
-0.0081309304,
0.034669362,
-0.0033066091,
-0.0301321056,
0.005832498,
-0.0027332315,
0.0443367139,
-0.0215288792,
0.0247315541,
-0.0296640992,
0.0766827986,
0.0779991746,
0.0329161882,
-0.0027837248,
-0.0511840768,
0.0235585552,
0.020904595,
0.0249870513,
-0.0016654331,
-0.0040194825,
0.0049034879,
-0.0025918244,
0.0482008606,
0.0367979892,
0.0340973102,
0.0786565468,
-0.0249672439,
-0.0335625224,
0.0879651085,
-0.0175007861,
-0.0544776581,
-0.001576644,
-0.0348378159,
0.0974573195,
-0.0157012716,
0.0071802544,
-0.0792078823,
-0.0224558804,
-0.0305335317,
0.0125697004,
-0.0059778225,
0.0016594054,
-0.0062822672,
-0.0811451897,
0.0551241823,
0.0160736181,
-0.0048930976,
-0.0164925978,
-0.0064196079,
-0.0250412468,
-0.0014395171,
0.0289807301,
-0.0128051611,
0.0255357623,
0.0044963476,
0.0237614792,
0.0224856567,
-0.0554431938,
-0.017551899,
-0.0255565476,
0.0460009873,
0.0658663735,
0.0281268507,
0.0112529537,
-0.0278151892,
0.0144108785,
-0.0577806793,
-0.0241597891,
0.0147331487,
0.042773854,
-0.0169608369,
-0.0010189081,
-0.0013438063,
0.0573465824,
-0.0432593152,
-0.0117001487,
0.0156785492,
0.0205789525,
-0.0445533134,
-0.0335035436,
-0.0258415323,
0.0395431928,
0.0515129566,
0.0444553308,
0.063515,
-0.0436420813,
-0.0453706458,
-0.0437355638,
0.0388977751,
-0.0513885319,
-0.0128432969,
-0.0060081463,
0.0615993664,
-0.063183099,
-0.0583373308,
-0.0583791435,
-0.0212891586,
0.0024688223,
-0.0182798281,
-0.0457552858,
0.0394113995,
-0.0325491317,
-0.0100281537,
0.0498068966,
0.0094326502,
-0.0262751486,
-0.0373252146,
-0.0377212167,
0.0032949669,
-0.0386591405,
-0.0334510766,
0.0255157612,
-0.1256636977,
-0.0610208027,
-0.0322793387,
0.0638301894,
0.0111737931,
0.068932943,
-0.0018180526,
-0.0345674828,
0.0497664027,
-0.0222387817,
-0.0259585213,
0.0074100606,
0.0500050522,
0.0169138219,
-0.0221195575,
0.0271423478,
-0.0212201048,
0.029622864,
0.0016173965,
0.0369001813,
-0.0263943076,
-0.0639721751,
-0.0147320796,
-0.0585837848,
-0.0046672518,
-0.0173483584,
-0.018404251,
-0.0643675625,
0.00945637,
-0.0135363461,
-0.0115552815,
-0.0795492977,
0.0063738115,
0.0219048187,
-0.0225880425,
0.0215032622,
-0.0275071822,
-0.0269924551,
0.0259296857,
-0.023864653,
0.0316388123,
0.0423119105,
0.0150687257,
0.0185161568,
-0.01858004,
-0.0417009927,
0.0135589633,
-0.0001980491,
0.0414754078,
0.0020080237,
0.0930542573,
-0.0066952738,
-0.0367518216,
0.0238707066,
0.0023676034,
-0.064861089,
-0.061986614,
-0.0450708345,
-0.0026234838,
-0.007920051,
0.0280016828,
0.066320695,
-0.0143321669,
0.0216769837,
-0.0305776186,
0.0554536656,
-0.0177199077,
-0.0425604768,
0.0439798608,
-0.0021786215,
-0.0171750989,
0.014322727,
0.071013473,
0.0168235619,
0.0134421485,
-0.0157175325,
0.0459262505,
-0.063065581,
-0.0648190677,
-0.0166421942,
0.0504185781,
-0.0121953543,
0.0383942164,
-0.0032566139,
-0.0282816961,
-0.0271621961,
-0.0061596665,
-0.0201024506,
0.0135137178,
0.0528113656,
0.0356526896,
-0.0277480744,
0.0052530463,
-0.0376858301,
0.0485723913,
0.0092236595,
-0.0282898974,
-0.0490150675,
-6.950917767e-33,
-0.044849474,
-0.0273625478,
-0.0091935983,
-0.0687472522,
-0.0292105842,
-0.0403067283,
-0.1063863039,
0.0037390348,
-0.0020532142,
0.0212829988,
0.0241520051,
0.0114786495,
0.0042597516,
0.0842792541,
0.0055035921,
-0.0288025942,
0.0539229102,
-0.0106654158,
-0.0122918012,
0.0640788302,
-0.0016932398,
0.0174239632,
-0.0071917716,
-0.0401496589,
0.0287146643,
-0.0389733166,
0.0056036296,
-0.0055380007,
0.0122542661,
0.0399253927,
-0.0594028272,
0.018624492,
-0.0170926265,
0.0009566678,
-0.0493627153,
0.0392778292,
-0.0446144193,
-0.0167302862,
-0.0049492354,
-0.0051092212,
-0.0264906213,
-0.0308899507,
0.0202527829,
0.0144293532,
0.0494699106,
-0.0246073678,
0.0195843447,
0.0008976909,
-0.0079266317,
-0.012635218,
-0.0590650849,
0.0235259365,
-0.017427288,
-0.0292760748,
-0.0122151123,
0.0582046025,
0.0101686055,
0.0197849777,
-0.0362502746,
0.0169445742,
0.0275949277,
-0.0096164132,
0.0531042293,
0.0153854126,
-0.0045607802,
0.0468496457,
0.0321942456,
-0.0051200027,
-0.0349105857,
-0.0091896346,
-0.0244949982,
0.0248464514,
-0.0166718327,
0.0481101088,
-0.0005429423,
0.0177247562,
-0.0475627892,
0.0131082861,
-0.0367971584,
0.0181019772,
0.016725149,
0.0053399992,
0.0078936564,
-0.0347079113,
-0.0266338196,
-0.0424356274,
-0.0199067742,
-0.0264539551,
0.0286732074,
0.0123579493,
-0.006212085,
-0.0539014712,
0.0642327815,
-0.005046743,
0.0132086361,
0.0263840724,
0.0034359519,
0.0082926676,
-0.0021103094,
0.0288370829,
-0.0413706377,
0.019307375,
0.0769471228,
-0.0180217177,
-0.0155731095,
0.0374931619,
-0.0469076335,
0.0112513639,
-0.0282446332,
-0.0008037387,
-0.0477803834,
0.0295280311,
-0.0119328545,
0.0790602788,
0.0047488068,
0.0044739032,
-0.0276933033,
0.091175124,
-0.0489613749,
0.0029820011,
-0.0233449508,
-0.0393583514,
0.0417755842,
0.0492557473,
-0.0803178549,
-0.0026515864,
-0.0105735678,
-0.0002451794,
0.0433410406,
-0.0461862199,
-0.0116607277,
0.0245556086,
2.702e-7,
0.0197737869,
-0.0046590306,
0.0338294879,
0.0034772521,
0.0282734875,
0.0499112569,
0.0120932758,
0.0282112639,
0.0197571348,
-0.0360675082,
0.0090232119,
0.013782395,
0.0536048934,
0.0033800246,
-0.0383891091,
-0.038162142,
-0.0621144511,
-0.0282602478,
-0.0189035255,
-0.0360560492,
0.0558968894,
0.1172971576,
-0.029253887,
0.0111276498,
0.0336979367,
0.0467731617,
0.0779843777,
0.0033866465,
-0.0588454902,
0.0383838378,
-0.0014305487,
-0.0326449573,
-0.0210233796,
0.0081038047,
-0.017615743,
0.0278236102,
-0.0121999728,
0.0522224493,
0.0268776752,
-0.0924474522,
-0.004839329,
-0.0032936493,
0.0113743953,
-0.0372045562,
0.0276992004,
-0.0546362624,
-0.0325678363,
-0.019143315,
-0.0329004079,
0.0139296828,
0.0341947004,
-0.0429911353,
-0.0060275756,
-0.0045345863,
0.0032494541,
0.0070906426,
0.0217592902,
-0.0622169264,
-0.0095833577,
-0.0045741266,
-0.0928473249,
-0.0218892973,
-0.0337112918,
-0.0248903036,
0.0437176116,
0.0256109312,
0.0149560058,
2.176954697e-34,
0.0466952473,
0.0046514506,
-0.0289404094,
0.0220361371,
0.016871566,
-0.0308499951,
0.0096415114,
-0.0314058103,
0.0472947806,
-0.0684713349,
-0.0577300563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15024v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15024v1 | ChatAgri: Exploring Potentials of ChatGPT on Cross-linguistic Agricultural Text Classification | 2023-05-24T11:06:23 | 2023-05-24T11:06:23 | Biao Zhao, Weiqiang Jin, Javier Del Ser, Guang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the era of sustainable smart agriculture, a massive amount of agricultural
news text is being posted on the Internet, in which massive agricultural
knowledge has been accumulated. In this context, it is urgent to explore
effective text classification techniques for users to access the required
agricultural knowledge with high efficiency. Mainstream deep learning
approaches employing fine-tuning strategies on pre-trained language models
(PLMs), have demonstrated remarkable performance gains over the past few years.
Nonetheless, these methods still face many drawbacks that are complex to solve,
including: 1. Limited agricultural training data due to the expensive-cost and
labour-intensive annotation; 2. Poor domain transferability, especially of
cross-linguistic ability; 3. Complex and expensive large models
deployment.Inspired by the extraordinary success brought by the recent ChatGPT
(e.g. GPT-3.5, GPT-4), in this work, we systematically investigate and explore
the capability and utilization of ChatGPT applying to the agricultural
informatization field. ....(shown in article).... Code has been released on
Github
https://github.com/albert-jin/agricultural_textual_classification_ChatGPT. | [
0.0288615189,
0.0436383672,
0.0209643319,
0.0390818194,
-0.0045410637,
0.0233852286,
-0.0038133569,
0.0116336113,
0.0483290255,
-0.0697218403,
-0.0110515198,
0.0040288172,
-0.0269483216,
0.0377211869,
-0.0342913233,
-0.0293657985,
0.0432411171,
0.0287043732,
0.0076046563,
0.0210335534,
0.0131596886,
0.0316629931,
0.0103843296,
0.0297083966,
-0.0416217893,
-0.008139885,
-0.0014961405,
0.006664292,
0.0356518216,
-0.0142533183,
0.0149050523,
0.0333373845,
-0.0009617313,
0.0633944571,
0.0000019487,
-0.0303793587,
-0.0604535453,
0.0108815869,
-0.0351936556,
0.0613648035,
0.0409386791,
0.0197189115,
-0.019132318,
0.0393455401,
-0.0282998718,
-0.0245776512,
0.072261259,
0.0453274772,
0.033178959,
0.0811810419,
0.006421675,
-0.0268378351,
0.0687609985,
-0.0034537066,
-0.0111792767,
-0.0356803909,
0.0306805968,
-0.0109366411,
-0.0181145351,
0.0560843982,
-0.0065673809,
0.031657964,
0.0367222875,
0.0068960688,
-0.0503955781,
0.0320961028,
-0.0442739725,
-0.0032130349,
0.0043246401,
0.0434525572,
-0.039897386,
-0.0324962214,
-0.0032414119,
-0.0151322503,
-0.0463088341,
-0.0195542108,
-0.0212300643,
0.0030717452,
0.0100185061,
0.0511529297,
0.0368917286,
0.0097431978,
0.0079593556,
0.0367180966,
-0.0212765764,
0.0347888395,
-0.0194991883,
-0.0050287149,
0.0274637043,
0.0149446828,
-0.0004781189,
-0.0430278331,
0.0422125086,
0.0193252433,
0.0436980203,
-0.0144698704,
-0.0198114291,
-0.0444262736,
0.0217299405,
-0.0683043078,
-0.0302981026,
0.0128363678,
-0.0552993268,
0.0258661788,
-0.0134254312,
-0.0074163233,
0.0010634441,
0.0339706913,
0.0181441717,
-0.0219564326,
-0.0936364159,
-0.0089463564,
-0.0497257821,
0.0172554869,
0.0034254778,
-0.0312128626,
-0.0329530276,
0.0108058127,
0.0265717898,
-0.0487557575,
0.0171449482,
0.0039686989,
-0.0263806004,
-0.0222249851,
-0.0100622,
0.0605318286,
-0.0091554206,
0.0490831919,
-0.0267138667,
-0.0836983845,
0.0056603439,
0.0001838427,
0.014099949,
0.0033901376,
0.0383248255,
0.0390374959,
-0.0224146545,
-0.0576219745,
-0.0474026725,
0.0044604279,
-0.0076439893,
-0.0302283466,
-0.042915564,
-0.0278950166,
0.0091033932,
-0.0169130247,
0.0332807414,
-0.042905733,
0.0122128548,
0.0349620804,
-0.029729329,
0.0804346427,
0.0058915308,
-0.0269874539,
0.0422041491,
0.0161196794,
0.0146849286,
0.0578524619,
0.0279870108,
0.0681935027,
0.0103689833,
0.0042294767,
0.0115142828,
0.023438558,
-0.0073473132,
-0.0030090238,
-0.0028156054,
-0.0066026715,
0.0032168771,
0.0081514698,
0.0242954995,
0.0430519916,
0.0171449892,
0.0303747337,
0.0722720623,
0.0598573945,
0.0400760546,
0.0443403311,
0.047394108,
0.0791446045,
-0.0082086036,
-0.0390452854,
-0.0035746475,
-0.0072997031,
-0.06438829,
-0.0264938194,
0.0135482308,
0.0401404686,
-0.0356552117,
-0.0435322076,
0.000778741,
-0.0268713832,
0.0139605049,
0.0186231807,
0.0706816986,
-0.016875688,
0.0069313059,
-0.004877096,
0.0476409681,
-0.0375617556,
0.0298526138,
-0.0572862588,
0.0064305393,
0.0119257104,
-0.0018727725,
-0.0512079522,
-0.0007669282,
0.0095926877,
0.059797138,
0.0271842554,
0.0620722584,
-0.0101093529,
-0.0138195725,
-0.0283680707,
-0.031361267,
0.0150273405,
0.0064761587,
-0.0133647053,
-0.0064085582,
0.0708094761,
0.0142429611,
-0.0071370942,
-0.0048397104,
0.0545566343,
0.0090173297,
-0.0233324431,
0.0047237375,
0.0148397842,
0.0148810828,
0.0380762406,
-0.0083838366,
-0.0231162813,
0.0224641468,
-0.0195581838,
-0.0281917434,
-0.0046979729,
0.0139442161,
0.0011030004,
0.0172541272,
-0.0341555402,
0.0116447089,
0.0341695026,
-0.044885464,
-0.0204838347,
-0.0165709369,
0.0072769495,
0.0430077724,
-0.0736948699,
0.0325852372,
-0.022860257,
0.058525525,
-0.0365098156,
0.0165471453,
0.0417839251,
-0.0171065275,
-0.0484852456,
-0.0628947988,
0.0652423277,
-0.0044775903,
0.0234504323,
-0.00970589,
-0.0482746921,
0.0354349799,
0.0202991497,
0.0781181082,
-0.0437892452,
-0.0353844948,
-0.0845850408,
0.0151652358,
-0.0467154495,
0.0365153365,
0.0027883679,
0.004531736,
-0.019545598,
0.016785495,
-0.0400667116,
0.0863137767,
-0.0402342156,
-0.0081426101,
0.0235996656,
-0.0223498251,
0.0331488736,
0.0180285051,
0.0230266191,
-0.0158284921,
0.0646881014,
0.0032372482,
-0.0628580377,
-0.0309068821,
-0.013557639,
-0.0121465325,
0.0242568161,
0.0000985354,
-0.0459462255,
-0.0508176908,
0.0121925371,
-0.0394412763,
-0.0003469919,
-0.0079705417,
0.024329463,
-0.004800437,
0.0300618671,
-0.0543908812,
0.0195656158,
-0.0280941315,
0.0107098455,
-0.0244425274,
0.0319832489,
-0.0050517209,
0.0435148887,
-0.0229450632,
-0.017341489,
-0.0211671498,
0.0079176165,
-0.0041277832,
0.0230317526,
-0.0152984932,
0.0529737845,
0.0328980424,
0.0130739119,
-0.0087920688,
-0.0384632312,
0.0313130766,
-0.0367533118,
0.0011301753,
-0.0992722884,
-0.047044754,
-0.0549402609,
0.0654760599,
-0.0008170519,
0.0302304085,
0.0472201854,
-0.0229158122,
-0.0277780555,
0.0297972914,
-0.0377531163,
-0.0106457369,
0.0093562631,
-0.0069257948,
0.0322976932,
-0.051399257,
-0.0268180221,
-0.013681368,
-0.0604172386,
-0.0306894854,
0.0534145012,
0.0582334809,
0.0133721102,
-0.0194889847,
0.048931811,
-0.0168901831,
0.0273338929,
-0.0117158657,
-0.0096713435,
-0.0012643837,
0.0358682312,
0.0018779869,
-0.0037477347,
-0.0359113626,
0.0270672571,
-0.0095856637,
0.0165530853,
-0.0185638443,
0.001621425,
-0.0007270291,
-0.0029795582,
0.0265991949,
-0.0782179758,
-0.027367875,
-0.0017535348,
0.0240091775,
-0.0600522384,
-0.0038528522,
0.108325012,
0.0236649718,
-0.0677254051,
0.0043538357,
0.0149640394,
0.0067410897,
0.0110522676,
0.0393115543,
-0.0704337806,
-0.0477037728,
-0.0052973316,
-0.0413948111,
-0.002311788,
0.0031057321,
-0.0559583455,
-0.0883463323,
0.004535947,
-0.0153603079,
-0.060737256,
-0.0234717354,
-0.0339641906,
-0.0401343778,
-0.0393086486,
-0.0024177721,
-0.0507536009,
-0.0197249558,
0.0045999135,
0.0461796969,
-0.0600403622,
-0.0467216372,
0.0278787427,
-0.0429446511,
0.0300310012,
0.0806080699,
0.0019640171,
-0.0350317359,
-0.0332830325,
0.0753845274,
-0.0064640981,
-0.026788475,
-0.0337452888,
0.0402474105,
-0.0394823812,
-0.0271015223,
0.0512860715,
-0.0073088552,
-0.0338981524,
-0.0002543367,
0.0055480343,
0.0996558666,
-0.0009657184,
-0.0267404821,
0.0079456251,
-0.0126177706,
0.0249307714,
0.0493693091,
0.0342704281,
-0.0758008808,
-0.061102923,
-0.0207972247,
-0.0410936922,
-0.0293865763,
-0.0488018505,
0.0239087529,
0.00499509,
-0.0673984066,
-0.0159258191,
-0.0391426757,
0.0784295946,
0.0050326651,
-0.0054153828,
0.0274250805,
0.0577959865,
-0.0041090231,
-0.0703799501,
0.0265376624,
-0.0484599359,
-0.0008125009,
-0.0473487303,
-0.0414445139,
0.0918961838,
-0.0427274331,
-0.0231456757,
-0.0145993289,
-0.0729801208,
-0.0409051217,
-0.0121589229,
-0.0121959355,
0.0151636638,
0.0059618382,
-0.0147842392,
-0.0526867248,
0.059582483,
0.0659205839,
-0.0144462995,
-0.044102978,
0.0495825075,
0.0089748055,
-0.0089622522,
0.0230512824,
-0.0162105151,
0.0490899533,
0.0120301358,
-0.0003504713,
-0.0213311911,
-0.0172664486,
0.0145399608,
-0.0035127085,
0.0892614126,
0.0040280363,
-0.0787242129,
-0.0587630235,
0.0048028086,
0.0249728542,
-0.0100996783,
-0.0316843465,
-0.0084142154,
0.0335753523,
0.020051904,
-0.0298314989,
0.0234492999,
-0.0007967721,
0.0031314152,
-0.0025092538,
-0.004774496,
0.0038904212,
0.0368659645,
-0.0014552121,
0.013397269,
-0.0166837107,
-0.0113635445,
0.0200454742,
-0.0107848896,
-0.0649392083,
0.0271958914,
-0.0209415443,
0.0274639651,
-0.0277920943,
0.0470698476,
-0.0092455493,
-0.0269700177,
-0.0590507947,
0.0458576046,
0.0727181733,
-0.0236601718,
0.0306370743,
-0.0224658381,
-0.0334734879,
-0.0258407537,
0.0356910862,
0.0000084463,
-0.0273912586,
0.0114982817,
-0.0315424874,
-0.0564942174,
0.0155527899,
0.0652172118,
0.009291512,
0.032633502,
0.0767257065,
-0.0340426899,
-0.026198389,
-0.018627096,
0.0300078597,
0.0013834048,
-0.0079470808,
0.0403315611,
-0.0060766642,
-0.0303436611,
0.0142408935,
-0.0457038097,
-0.0119893448,
0.0094373189,
0.0342826657,
0.0544672944,
-0.008482879,
0.0299498141,
-0.0364172012,
-0.0284572393,
-0.0302472953,
-0.0318551287,
0.0072927182,
-6.286851621e-33,
-0.0082253665,
0.0173742939,
0.0156618245,
0.0124224583,
-0.0024992779,
0.0326260515,
0.0059697581,
-0.0216827691,
-0.0180616472,
0.015224875,
0.0017140398,
-0.0164434854,
0.0267929509,
0.0735772923,
-0.0157553013,
-0.0022616435,
0.0143415108,
0.0114909019,
0.0099386508,
0.0338833928,
-0.0062341946,
0.0574415885,
0.0639614016,
-0.0698005781,
-0.0247109663,
0.0309978742,
-0.0268774442,
-0.0039064502,
-0.0065284269,
0.0443221852,
-0.0531194732,
0.0576700643,
0.05318553,
-0.0496477261,
-0.0026928512,
0.0419317782,
-0.0638163835,
-0.0474740118,
-0.0627994984,
0.0176535435,
-0.0281595401,
-0.0293649267,
0.0265928935,
0.0018072097,
-0.0037842107,
-0.0019372716,
0.0585017726,
-0.0269235298,
-0.0126553895,
-0.0476157479,
-0.0524029881,
0.0223929137,
-0.0039577503,
-0.0323025063,
0.014047238,
-0.0040053716,
0.0161425825,
0.0439858697,
-0.0619461387,
-0.013068663,
0.0102436235,
0.0314920433,
0.0524689816,
0.0002634007,
-0.0383830182,
0.0411593057,
-0.006081677,
-0.0275957305,
-0.006379792,
-0.0183423944,
0.0271476377,
-0.0055266581,
0.0406164788,
0.0359470285,
0.0665825978,
-0.0674956366,
-0.0983520895,
0.046421051,
0.0132964533,
-0.0109694526,
-0.0040631485,
-0.0120909847,
-0.0086139636,
-0.0233416092,
-0.025978025,
-0.0149129005,
-0.029212093,
0.0005562801,
0.0203658696,
-0.009871087,
0.0046503488,
0.0468709245,
0.0032794317,
-0.0254929978,
-0.0214439705,
0.0079591377,
-0.0242184587,
0.0064240703,
0.0002211353,
0.0357274376,
-0.0691694692,
-0.0908674076,
-0.0456333049,
0.0129893087,
0.0032030887,
-0.0136244362,
0.0703577548,
0.0417807437,
-0.0680994317,
0.00617579,
-0.0145887351,
0.0011058551,
0.0193222277,
0.0894914716,
-0.0017717968,
-0.0200456008,
0.0202198923,
0.0529608615,
0.0546427295,
-0.001379219,
0.0242058728,
-0.0077582812,
0.0077898419,
-0.0166941918,
-0.0013709429,
0.0301241465,
-0.0126746232,
-0.0147898979,
-0.0005394144,
-0.0533708185,
0.0020585991,
-0.0330299027,
2.636e-7,
0.073868975,
0.0710423812,
-0.0097045992,
-0.0456318259,
-0.0300337542,
0.0315922126,
0.0052278256,
0.0463576652,
-0.0786094368,
0.0501892641,
0.043178834,
0.0187136959,
0.0461628698,
0.0062042745,
-0.0780223384,
-0.0342254564,
-0.0684689581,
0.0306210853,
-0.0721498802,
-0.0100375172,
0.0509484299,
0.0949171409,
0.0060296329,
-0.0007251549,
0.0172656868,
-0.0365234576,
0.071136944,
-0.037356995,
0.0310720373,
0.053030733,
-0.0094719389,
0.0280436873,
-0.0126879187,
0.0034316781,
-0.0141256796,
0.0127890538,
0.012780292,
0.0700284541,
-0.011093921,
-0.014246935,
0.0158076696,
-0.0298868082,
0.0198498797,
-0.0287535768,
0.082712248,
-0.0798960403,
-0.0477117114,
-0.0109108491,
0.0298848785,
-0.0222672001,
0.0393568277,
-0.0335609578,
0.0252557099,
-0.0048218514,
0.0233828146,
-0.0344062038,
-0.0612194911,
-0.0975778773,
0.0070496327,
-0.011132868,
-0.0274501722,
-0.0160070565,
-0.0120682344,
0.0059886454,
0.0394241326,
-0.0188103784,
0.0418352671,
2.611546438e-34,
0.0266237166,
0.0011937284,
0.0132360011,
-0.0236529838,
-0.0098954039,
0.0457253084,
0.0838801637,
-0.0254074652,
-0.0257132817,
-0.0514131226,
0.0154871354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15020v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15020v3 | An Efficient Multilingual Language Model Compression through Vocabulary Trimming | 2023-05-24T11:00:33 | 2023-10-19T10:30:02 | Asahi Ushio, Yi Zhou, Jose Camacho-Collados | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual language model (LM) have become a powerful tool in NLP
especially for non-English languages. Nevertheless, model parameters of
multilingual LMs remain large due to the larger embedding matrix of the
vocabulary covering tokens in different languages. On the contrary, monolingual
LMs can be trained in a target language with the language-specific vocabulary
only, but this requires a large budget and availability of reliable corpora to
achieve a high-quality LM from scratch. In this paper, we propose
vocabulary-trimming (VT), a method to reduce a multilingual LM vocabulary to a
target language by deleting irrelevant tokens from its vocabulary. In theory,
VT can compress any existing multilingual LM to build monolingual LMs in any
language covered by the multilingual LM. In our experiments, we show that VT
can retain the original performance of the multilingual LM, while being smaller
in size (in general around 50% of the original vocabulary size is enough) than
the original multilingual LM. The evaluation is performed over four NLP tasks
(two generative and two classification tasks) among four widely used
multilingual LMs in seven languages. Finally, we show that this methodology can
keep the best of both monolingual and multilingual worlds by keeping a small
size as monolingual models without the need for specifically retraining them,
and even limiting potentially harmful social biases. | [
0.0163873415,
0.0818508267,
-0.0177037641,
0.0622411706,
-0.0568124242,
-0.0152608389,
0.0083811274,
0.0638777018,
-0.0398581214,
-0.0041125328,
-0.062717326,
-0.0285035111,
0.0015682344,
0.004046334,
0.0263592061,
-0.0316226669,
0.0353937522,
-0.0080521116,
-0.053563375,
-0.0330034308,
0.0196069423,
0.0128807472,
0.0781462342,
0.0177933946,
-0.0326763242,
-0.0142862173,
0.018424185,
0.0069430051,
-0.0315345228,
0.0243458115,
0.00355654,
0.0490134768,
-0.0136123309,
0.0194653478,
0.0000020757,
-0.0385560133,
-0.0325681865,
0.0000868375,
0.0111392727,
-0.0100805927,
0.0733506307,
-0.0413376652,
0.0107596843,
0.0098961359,
-0.0270045977,
0.0016001533,
0.0231574737,
0.0278431214,
0.0443446338,
0.0588352047,
-0.0072085545,
-0.023129493,
-0.0374843739,
-0.06110771,
-0.0576925725,
-0.0288753174,
0.0117530581,
-0.0449563153,
-0.0495574251,
0.0092878668,
-0.0308444314,
0.021667121,
-0.0077816593,
0.0320419893,
-0.031660594,
0.0008602759,
-0.0035395126,
-0.0447544232,
0.0456586331,
0.0290029123,
-0.0677756071,
-0.0571961515,
-0.0021855542,
0.0141168591,
0.0071861413,
-0.0151075106,
-0.038891729,
0.0409958847,
0.030839555,
0.0526904315,
0.0079658944,
-0.0209289361,
0.0294930357,
0.0018381595,
0.006860489,
0.0361853503,
0.0331314504,
-0.0312614106,
0.0204320978,
0.0129804881,
0.0134203527,
-0.0324291773,
-0.0027033489,
0.0013198482,
0.0026984345,
0.0122721195,
-0.0550101139,
-0.0180681869,
0.0490315855,
-0.0751508251,
-0.0046383636,
0.0220155548,
0.0245072991,
0.0338073187,
-0.0383015908,
0.018210452,
0.0413373373,
-0.0097079389,
-0.0755847394,
-0.0801442489,
0.004406997,
-0.0041211923,
-0.0314148515,
0.0399837717,
-0.0339496993,
0.0137251643,
-0.0518043488,
-0.0390876308,
-0.0499355458,
0.0125041315,
0.0156415347,
-0.0139176873,
-0.0140511878,
0.0025782897,
0.0195234939,
0.0182023868,
-0.057968799,
-0.0056633875,
-0.0491390079,
-0.0442625023,
-0.0064212265,
0.0486932658,
-0.0019480198,
-0.0251585599,
0.0515162311,
0.0833374187,
0.0038306755,
-0.0508022122,
-0.0451610088,
0.0100911018,
0.0078453422,
-0.0641569346,
-0.0047611161,
-0.0733500794,
0.0433652997,
-0.0298302583,
0.0116708595,
-0.0698190331,
0.0028927757,
0.0215482973,
-0.0464661978,
0.0538282283,
0.0059310826,
0.0119126802,
0.0342551246,
-0.0178155638,
0.0288410243,
0.1041230932,
0.0086869672,
-0.0096234586,
0.0856153667,
-0.0372960865,
-0.0117878076,
0.0784033015,
0.0536245592,
-0.0032447856,
-0.0449651144,
-0.0539634526,
-0.0038393876,
-0.026219761,
0.0636652559,
0.0569447838,
-0.004966951,
-0.0242797863,
0.030314507,
0.0534901954,
0.000188614,
0.0502059609,
0.0466534123,
-0.0165437423,
-0.0373290777,
0.0336874276,
-0.011679057,
-0.017398024,
-0.0238301642,
-0.0106767286,
0.0438743979,
0.063982524,
-0.0418413207,
-0.0098425718,
-0.0321541168,
-0.0593167432,
0.0763768405,
0.0051695332,
0.0434697345,
-0.003966732,
-0.0095297629,
0.093776837,
0.0591801405,
-0.0479486585,
0.0380524918,
-0.0416379496,
-0.0285370219,
0.0012067682,
0.0095441816,
0.0028270294,
-0.0114471074,
0.0008288219,
-0.0288937744,
0.0208751354,
0.0412270837,
-0.0309724696,
0.0330950804,
-0.0480458215,
0.0200984348,
-0.0070849345,
-0.001103924,
0.0174965989,
0.0458472706,
0.0368448608,
0.0148483943,
-0.0365900584,
-0.0336305536,
0.0304688048,
-0.0672976747,
-0.0214347076,
0.0227495916,
0.0075567202,
0.030245848,
0.0104977582,
0.0029800455,
-0.016060099,
0.0561575182,
-0.0535533167,
-0.0081119407,
-0.0094434721,
-0.0323342755,
-0.0470443107,
0.0666268617,
-0.0093291048,
0.0178571772,
0.059396103,
-0.0467431657,
-0.0257088747,
0.007646448,
0.006788956,
0.0002105248,
-0.0578579381,
0.0064559625,
-0.006710466,
0.0596719198,
-0.0192466471,
0.0261829477,
-0.0162900575,
0.0590768456,
-0.0041699293,
-0.0464391559,
0.0275993478,
-0.0389520191,
-0.0395524539,
0.056839712,
-0.0429272652,
0.0093864212,
0.0519126989,
0.0219935514,
-0.0039011803,
0.0030360052,
-0.0835986882,
0.0003951387,
-0.0085899886,
0.007217756,
0.0042059384,
0.0103013543,
0.0004005246,
-0.0210084803,
-0.0413575321,
-0.0020944278,
0.053871721,
0.0359454677,
0.0197841339,
-0.0260930043,
0.0343242437,
-0.0153664695,
-0.0197557509,
0.0461097769,
0.0787328184,
-0.0676911473,
-0.0576710701,
-0.0247374345,
0.0108231595,
-0.0645948797,
0.0356321484,
0.0066544847,
-0.0457618162,
-0.0444587767,
0.0224932544,
0.02732067,
0.040446844,
-0.0077976729,
0.0126288179,
0.0729854554,
0.0400073938,
-0.0372146294,
0.0262458846,
-0.0070672091,
0.0121730212,
-0.0315133817,
-0.0607215986,
-0.0044456744,
0.061085023,
-0.0077629471,
-0.0224554595,
-0.0600951053,
0.0026198605,
-0.027554078,
-0.0333004892,
-0.0319155306,
0.01423248,
-0.0359120443,
0.0279447418,
-0.0168848727,
-0.0296478793,
0.0286515187,
-0.0445264615,
0.0132760294,
-0.0243360884,
-0.0186482463,
-0.0329244435,
0.050175909,
0.0203306247,
0.0542806722,
-0.0118925786,
0.0099833086,
-0.0406704172,
-0.009453427,
0.027680913,
-0.0198106859,
0.0147342924,
-0.0242492612,
-0.0202794932,
-0.0276243594,
-0.0250024796,
-0.0142986663,
0.0123923644,
0.0049017826,
0.0204626769,
0.0341546834,
0.0098143499,
-0.0260326397,
0.001350441,
0.0223143101,
0.0526543893,
0.0168550443,
0.0537663475,
0.025876224,
0.0354613177,
0.0478805304,
0.0048717987,
-0.0063747512,
-0.0514379889,
0.0110608926,
0.0417607911,
-0.0039640511,
-0.0018239951,
0.0261973739,
-0.017681079,
0.0602916442,
-0.02989644,
-0.036530003,
-0.0126558449,
0.0220923275,
0.0052857641,
0.0007122104,
0.0901948437,
0.012358685,
-0.0267441384,
0.0133375647,
-0.0483704358,
0.0513566993,
0.030073097,
0.0329456888,
-0.0586242937,
-0.0197882764,
0.0381654948,
-0.0324874595,
0.0376182832,
-0.0128320055,
-0.0348514058,
-0.1198982522,
-0.0169482939,
-0.0101921977,
-0.0678229854,
-0.0117308646,
-0.0581390783,
-0.0164252259,
-0.0432023033,
-0.0090016769,
-0.0360840224,
0.0203325767,
-0.0113564488,
0.0088017015,
-0.0452912264,
-0.0428630412,
0.0233557075,
-0.0189050492,
0.0326890759,
0.0097777462,
0.0743144378,
-0.0322942846,
-0.0044717155,
0.0577784628,
0.0188411865,
-0.0090341335,
-0.0394293591,
0.0573833361,
-0.0129722748,
0.0131460261,
0.0465829,
0.0048654266,
-0.0155879119,
-0.0016052559,
-0.0100670997,
0.0788525343,
0.0635327026,
-0.0380558111,
-0.0217256639,
-0.0223342031,
-0.0358125307,
0.0933069438,
0.0084854532,
-0.0523664504,
-0.0124967573,
-0.001734676,
-0.0105027556,
-0.025923457,
-0.0206906218,
0.0029488539,
-0.0082796086,
-0.0587539598,
-0.0640143454,
-0.0743131489,
0.0060150139,
0.0083216401,
-0.0025499673,
0.0331543498,
-0.0500718281,
0.009050969,
0.0000649592,
-0.0112412656,
-0.052036088,
-0.0086598909,
-0.0307732485,
0.0370647162,
-0.0058908877,
-0.0078523699,
-0.0138893053,
-0.0170062464,
-0.0449310243,
-0.0507148579,
-0.0421424769,
0.0768615976,
0.0163790081,
0.0801633745,
0.0243384466,
-0.0364730097,
0.0073098578,
0.0124368286,
0.0032739462,
0.034770418,
0.0498019867,
-0.0168755408,
0.0018073696,
0.0876786038,
-0.0265799034,
0.0317822956,
0.0063560819,
0.0451354571,
-0.0136931967,
-0.0411575995,
-0.0021619159,
0.0322521701,
0.024291737,
-0.0581491888,
-0.0090026995,
-0.0463034995,
-0.0028161705,
-0.0207184367,
-0.0445967354,
-0.0266549401,
0.0222145133,
0.0284474976,
0.0097625358,
-0.0056007081,
-0.0141864577,
-0.0227656066,
0.0191458464,
0.0268502533,
-0.0094622048,
0.0150914574,
-0.0270028394,
0.0013230003,
0.043511752,
-0.0038672234,
-0.0324341357,
-0.0202233288,
-0.0035541984,
-0.0711190924,
-0.0110675013,
-0.007261964,
0.0288824849,
-0.021271633,
0.0156786516,
0.0266073607,
-0.009129989,
-0.0484817252,
0.0406084806,
0.0674337819,
-0.0286628455,
0.0405142084,
-0.0064170742,
-0.0248073861,
-0.0309867486,
0.0200896878,
0.0240829773,
-0.0463011712,
0.0194153208,
-0.0101246219,
-0.0409775488,
-0.0027417873,
0.1105920598,
0.0008105435,
0.0212246738,
0.002596844,
-0.0097398106,
-0.0293962695,
-0.0101163853,
0.0093946271,
0.0142296124,
-0.0325036943,
0.0167176034,
-0.0350056626,
-0.0862697586,
-0.0123497099,
0.0046715038,
-0.0058169649,
0.0125905471,
0.0354686156,
0.0914179459,
0.0176890641,
0.0373016112,
-0.0533411875,
-0.0128537351,
0.0315482356,
-0.0235134754,
0.021723615,
-6.096280477e-33,
-0.0023196165,
0.0112671647,
0.0103636226,
-0.0255055409,
0.0030311465,
-0.0001877938,
-0.0209860951,
-0.0018533968,
-0.045217488,
0.011230872,
-0.0431074798,
-0.0387227386,
0.0015575218,
0.0285303034,
0.0054841409,
0.0498829335,
0.0659872666,
-0.0011949296,
-0.0203103442,
0.0106885517,
0.0416599922,
0.0672907084,
0.1009442508,
0.0099773379,
0.0168787148,
-0.0151164373,
0.0022883946,
0.0145817464,
0.0368872583,
0.0252136271,
-0.031689629,
0.0213410761,
0.0358856879,
-0.0589473546,
0.0138364974,
-0.027059488,
-0.0531988703,
-0.0489218868,
0.0350610986,
0.0041351044,
-0.0129694566,
-0.0208401121,
0.0321118534,
-0.0214127954,
-0.0028686495,
0.0119357156,
0.0301104113,
-0.023028912,
-0.030539779,
-0.0088208029,
-0.0665751323,
0.0268518664,
0.0182993468,
-0.0034446623,
0.0507473424,
0.0642912909,
-0.0134547632,
0.0269147493,
-0.0324974507,
0.0001518641,
-0.0084478594,
0.0587717332,
0.0715561509,
-0.0197990779,
-0.0061933147,
0.0415752903,
0.0061277384,
0.0148722623,
0.0277024508,
0.0048770802,
0.0462108552,
0.0141360238,
0.0438727438,
0.0778913498,
0.0470936969,
-0.0424537323,
-0.0892480835,
0.0469697788,
0.0013237342,
0.0492036566,
-0.0100237615,
0.0039580772,
0.0087173339,
-0.0254087914,
-0.0205701739,
-0.0497806147,
-0.0213159509,
-0.0450474545,
0.0102896644,
0.0061541465,
-0.0461233445,
-0.0186140966,
0.0315607004,
-0.0401920602,
-0.046800904,
0.066042535,
-0.0163670387,
-0.0349936858,
0.0171922017,
0.0260054804,
-0.0473254733,
-0.0224951319,
-0.0376859009,
-0.0528673008,
0.0123401713,
-0.0076684887,
0.0692121983,
0.0028180145,
-0.0435856469,
0.028450029,
-0.0307401996,
0.0056354604,
-0.0113574741,
0.0707160905,
0.029280683,
0.0274004843,
0.0007116029,
0.0294400677,
0.073755607,
-0.0307877883,
-0.0389159918,
-0.0191853419,
0.0151189053,
0.0256832242,
-0.0233608503,
-0.0176624339,
-0.0280863047,
0.0125627872,
0.0413071774,
-0.035386797,
0.0030513757,
-0.0106744012,
2.697e-7,
0.0281095766,
0.0245046783,
-0.0276017692,
-0.0135256015,
0.0053207683,
0.0391192473,
-0.043992728,
0.0377288871,
-0.0331421681,
0.0280967858,
-0.0209718626,
0.0117311617,
0.0375337005,
0.0379108824,
-0.0853192359,
0.0242598578,
-0.0478952415,
-0.0188829862,
-0.007002586,
-0.0066717737,
-0.0238242652,
0.127216503,
0.0232012365,
-0.0334158503,
-0.0509685539,
-0.037793044,
0.054981336,
-0.0615941398,
-0.0373009518,
0.0121863931,
0.0147117674,
-0.0050195558,
-0.0077266619,
-0.0242045075,
-0.0593849719,
0.0403810702,
0.0362386517,
0.077577278,
-0.0044003329,
0.0055852388,
0.0379880145,
0.0010269271,
-0.0581328645,
-0.0555003583,
0.0636403188,
0.030880658,
-0.0160640571,
-0.0460925549,
0.004313786,
0.0324345194,
0.0570103526,
-0.0419578552,
-0.0384312943,
0.0337814353,
0.0311643202,
-0.0055666501,
-0.0479889885,
-0.0530989878,
-0.0310958717,
-0.0149090607,
-0.0253159422,
-0.0027360087,
-0.0133088566,
-0.0002810939,
0.0083650751,
-0.04319885,
0.0214575231,
2.279880018e-34,
0.0202338044,
-0.0059494036,
-0.0092177298,
0.0178763643,
0.0085316114,
-0.0535153337,
-0.0130686201,
0.0373855606,
-0.0330610014,
-0.008405257,
-0.0079302657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15017v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15017v2 | Calc-X and Calcformers: Empowering Arithmetical Chain-of-Thought through Interaction with Symbolic Systems | 2023-05-24T10:58:20 | 2023-10-23T15:23:22 | Marek Kadlčík, Michal Štefánik, Ondřej Sotolář, Vlastimil Martinek | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite outstanding performance in many tasks, language models are
notoriously inclined to make factual errors in tasks requiring arithmetic
computation. We address this deficiency by creating Calc-X, a collection of
datasets that demonstrates the appropriate use of a calculator in reasoning
chains. Calc-X is suitable for teaching language models to offload computations
to a symbolic system. We survey and unify several existing chain-of-thought
datasets into a proposed format, resulting in a standard collection of over
300,000 samples requiring arithmetic reasoning. Finally, we use the new Calc-X
collection to train open-source calculator-using models we call Calcformers and
show that these models approximately double the accuracy of generating correct
results compared to vanilla language model baselines. We make all Calc-X
datasets, source code and Calcformers models publicly available. | [
-0.0128556471,
0.1154408231,
-0.0234520864,
0.0453890711,
-0.0557570346,
0.0333535783,
0.0159691945,
-0.02346473,
-0.0265705939,
-0.0183592997,
-0.0127303777,
-0.0174447354,
0.0353923179,
0.0206628144,
0.0115250098,
-0.0373156853,
0.0312746502,
-0.0294158161,
0.0179335289,
0.0173359849,
-0.0259497855,
0.0291818213,
-0.0462192632,
0.0099466452,
-0.046045851,
-0.0660948753,
-0.0105644679,
-0.0465094969,
0.0417801999,
-0.0285879429,
-0.0147634177,
0.0109344665,
0.0278183203,
0.091357857,
0.0000022141,
-0.0438063778,
0.0130704939,
0.0338019505,
-0.0528269783,
0.0183814354,
0.0083655743,
-0.0089743389,
0.0041830828,
0.0243311767,
-0.0543006249,
0.0201625768,
0.0281612612,
-0.017051205,
0.0330858976,
0.0592950732,
0.0087107122,
-0.0171954762,
-0.0024813067,
-0.0017333602,
0.0312787369,
-0.0074874475,
-0.0015136761,
0.0350271761,
0.0190565195,
-0.0008366139,
-0.0247060992,
0.0103170248,
0.0791305527,
-0.0279366281,
-0.0279501788,
0.0169465952,
-0.0465090349,
0.0033840933,
-0.0076138233,
0.0615316704,
0.0077809324,
-0.05397534,
-0.0159772933,
-0.0145696001,
0.0144693367,
-0.0145782065,
-0.0528267287,
0.0422070175,
-0.0031831465,
0.0149009433,
0.0087604774,
-0.0015211505,
0.0183865372,
0.0198631585,
-0.0157978013,
0.0521231182,
-0.0062738387,
-0.0354462378,
0.0212350376,
0.0090591833,
-0.0300920401,
-0.0557615533,
0.0096533783,
0.051577162,
0.010192058,
0.0220083687,
-0.0146674225,
-0.0387494415,
-0.0153089752,
-0.0602662303,
0.0304153077,
0.079969123,
0.0015794018,
0.0316350944,
-0.0435876474,
0.036227636,
0.002822435,
0.0488739535,
-0.0136318384,
0.0503122844,
-0.0278180335,
-0.0194807611,
-0.0406227037,
0.0457116626,
-0.0243053362,
0.0301081166,
-0.0081222197,
-0.002352329,
-0.0395062305,
0.0326084457,
0.0177168641,
0.00096389,
0.0440992899,
-0.0307159182,
-0.0281439386,
0.0510872565,
-0.0522900745,
0.0272577573,
0.0422608666,
-0.0472010449,
-0.0217142105,
-0.0308476407,
-0.016729502,
-0.0080934083,
0.0429454409,
0.0620531291,
-0.0059928051,
0.0185813922,
-0.0183218922,
-0.0277612433,
0.0271242708,
-0.0866485089,
-0.0018915177,
-0.1034569964,
0.0150837172,
0.0331922621,
-0.0022844065,
-0.0075164307,
0.0378243588,
0.0270551424,
0.033836823,
0.0585698523,
-0.0094312867,
-0.0260251295,
0.001211054,
-0.0248582698,
-0.0301044751,
0.0650079623,
0.0878319517,
-0.0221593212,
0.0159954689,
0.0085601965,
-0.0015361374,
0.0297728088,
0.0010429154,
-0.0207797401,
-0.0581163689,
0.0154033192,
-0.0243064202,
0.0500156395,
-0.0174040403,
0.0461444855,
-0.0450833216,
-0.004860376,
0.0182790104,
0.031664703,
-0.0146231176,
0.0133675002,
0.088069655,
-0.0353121534,
0.0573205166,
-0.0445164144,
-0.082745038,
0.0436460301,
-0.0376352146,
0.011779719,
-0.0608399063,
0.0280935206,
-0.0085086711,
-0.0899051577,
-0.0098130787,
0.010063841,
-0.0112100467,
0.0057575861,
0.0467420444,
0.0293577146,
0.0138163138,
0.054218147,
0.0089190342,
-0.0839417204,
-0.0001659282,
-0.0218454078,
0.0367685668,
0.0175889973,
0.0670629591,
-0.0472340621,
0.0165048707,
-0.0460509397,
0.0032205542,
0.01257018,
0.0496049747,
-0.010403974,
-0.0313903354,
-0.0315384455,
0.0071393503,
-0.0178518016,
0.0270686783,
-0.0107427659,
0.0155723114,
-0.0060094548,
0.0140291927,
-0.078219302,
0.0028568108,
0.0256514437,
-0.0091650803,
-0.0432141982,
-0.0212148279,
0.0139516927,
-0.0170185454,
0.0178958084,
0.0019920175,
0.0482707135,
0.0035262054,
0.000375737,
-0.0227944721,
-0.0220338665,
-0.0609974973,
-0.0405028015,
0.0652380884,
-0.0419884957,
-0.0328212678,
0.0353076085,
-0.0475798585,
-0.0218038224,
0.0705614015,
-0.0530790687,
0.0340954512,
-0.0003795582,
0.0306086075,
0.0116225658,
-0.0339827053,
0.0216424502,
0.0867514983,
-0.0149109513,
0.0178487599,
0.0299796928,
0.018677583,
0.0177256688,
0.0395914726,
0.0344561711,
-0.0175456032,
-0.0176357329,
0.0063099638,
-0.0172499977,
0.0286511444,
-0.047146678,
-0.0075161573,
-0.0248100776,
-0.014803241,
-0.0142908292,
0.0499541722,
0.025290709,
-0.0152940014,
0.0094733015,
-0.0008798394,
-0.0314438343,
0.0216821916,
-0.0170986056,
-0.009110597,
0.0069856462,
-0.0171906315,
-0.0191530045,
-0.030815199,
-0.0374422483,
-0.0655268505,
0.0530224666,
0.0087633496,
0.0275601093,
-0.0085856905,
0.0120362779,
-0.0509707332,
0.0282668043,
-0.003259511,
0.0127967456,
0.0327086486,
-0.0364935584,
0.0036844206,
0.0425953344,
-0.0187991094,
0.0226124991,
0.0287818518,
-0.0098353969,
-0.0853714272,
0.0099251056,
0.0038171764,
0.0080072638,
-0.0224339031,
0.0114856865,
-0.0721386746,
0.0956641808,
-0.0197741296,
-0.0072313724,
-0.0270720106,
0.023407938,
-0.012655763,
-0.0206636786,
-0.03167817,
0.0029492227,
-0.0196416881,
0.023961449,
-0.0255277995,
-0.029936906,
0.0663418621,
-0.0050007654,
-0.0175870024,
-0.0206500404,
0.0185403228,
-0.0653410554,
0.0670952871,
0.0253768507,
-0.0184790976,
0.0151628293,
0.0043978612,
-0.0551497787,
0.004334176,
0.0218259618,
-0.0443999842,
0.072162196,
-0.0671826228,
0.0206584781,
0.0020607368,
-0.0390467346,
-0.022405576,
0.0666457042,
-0.052486483,
0.0352627598,
-0.0366208665,
-0.0367387347,
0.0104753561,
-0.0462519936,
0.0414107256,
0.0557731837,
-0.0101560764,
-0.040035475,
-0.0398915149,
0.0034924231,
0.0486439951,
-0.0076298909,
0.069805041,
-0.0194602609,
0.0241572056,
0.036026001,
0.0691734329,
-0.0064325188,
-0.0309760142,
0.0077425828,
0.0113125686,
-0.0227990579,
0.003378619,
0.0452889875,
0.0073681874,
-0.084087573,
-0.0502062775,
0.0730528384,
0.0447324179,
-0.0314806812,
0.0298803486,
-0.0851437151,
0.0170333236,
0.0486882739,
0.0090550538,
-0.1287014633,
-0.0262504313,
0.0180727523,
-0.0306044016,
-0.0028656705,
-0.0701804832,
0.0019433305,
-0.1174917147,
0.0060401536,
0.0247862674,
-0.0568465889,
-0.0117390668,
-0.0178167298,
0.0028831582,
-0.0154891182,
-0.0233757738,
0.042721156,
-0.0095249852,
0.0301404987,
0.0133975046,
-0.013059766,
0.0107792662,
0.0572181456,
0.0160563458,
-0.0022781971,
0.0188105814,
-0.008626692,
-0.0136527037,
-0.0883689746,
0.0635490939,
0.0131002339,
-0.0290279351,
-0.0028165167,
-0.0069088745,
0.0191686973,
-0.0120084872,
-0.0283586271,
0.0487109162,
-0.0410904065,
-0.0158132929,
0.0074094064,
0.1181357428,
-0.0095285168,
-0.0065702777,
-0.0020001787,
-0.0077396524,
-0.0097870212,
0.0189753622,
0.0365889445,
-0.0193941947,
-0.0433804169,
-0.0779800564,
-0.0484870039,
-0.030484518,
-0.0256908312,
-0.0038141164,
0.0712239221,
-0.0090919174,
-0.0325355902,
-0.035115689,
0.0467247255,
0.0216378886,
-0.0211568791,
-0.0293199886,
0.0439918041,
-0.0084697995,
-0.0299381837,
0.0239241906,
-0.0506766699,
0.0720912963,
-0.0057691392,
0.0240099356,
-0.0295469314,
-0.005412736,
-0.0287107229,
0.0437943228,
-0.0940959156,
-0.0405842215,
-0.0236942749,
0.0836507976,
0.0271308478,
-0.0040549492,
-0.0078291241,
0.000754501,
-0.0101801464,
0.0251438525,
-0.0499711446,
-0.0079941535,
0.0262498092,
0.0065593286,
0.0249489937,
0.0264765937,
-0.0227323938,
-0.0039789295,
0.0153923705,
0.0584629104,
-0.059049882,
0.0349685363,
0.0517490581,
0.0124468887,
-0.0054056598,
0.0037736117,
0.0174514819,
-0.0084990924,
0.0505807549,
-0.057801351,
-0.0145843625,
-0.0445335358,
-0.0029273243,
0.0058257389,
0.0090532107,
0.0089444872,
-0.0610524751,
0.0268633422,
0.0399449803,
0.0470135994,
0.0253986362,
0.0477779731,
0.0859749839,
0.0528283566,
-0.0465099476,
-0.0047242078,
-0.0207245126,
-0.0222156309,
0.0387241319,
-0.0183091015,
0.0785434842,
0.0107240099,
0.0089621013,
-0.0088894656,
-0.0182644986,
-0.0373412669,
-0.0547211915,
-0.0085651306,
-0.0342370421,
0.0141459266,
0.0263009388,
-0.0011509701,
-0.0490507558,
0.0024925692,
0.0114765242,
0.0359916687,
0.0046875966,
-0.0658734739,
-0.0015742981,
0.0397867411,
0.0298963599,
-0.0555504262,
0.0129977576,
-0.0672133639,
0.0406381004,
0.0085705202,
0.0168296099,
-0.0150795337,
-0.0465424359,
-0.0456175692,
-0.0162281133,
-0.001022322,
-0.0027371603,
-0.0910139382,
-0.0926217437,
-0.0227073114,
0.0592,
0.0091969492,
0.0040213005,
0.07037016,
0.0347160511,
-0.0320699364,
-0.0354495645,
-0.0189583618,
0.0350685455,
0.0072517926,
-0.0544090234,
-0.06211197,
-5.616267726e-33,
-0.0178300887,
-0.0115016643,
0.0510535352,
0.0265842006,
0.0094693294,
0.0030321439,
-0.0432442985,
0.0371028632,
-0.008948666,
0.0309728868,
-0.0103782462,
0.0320989341,
-0.0009569816,
0.0257032961,
0.0219187457,
-0.0282919761,
0.0003471,
-0.024126688,
-0.0400060378,
-0.0256891046,
0.0399681814,
0.0043603536,
0.0984761044,
-0.0562340841,
0.0395277217,
0.0236882512,
-0.0031466107,
0.0049186232,
-0.0566123836,
0.0272336826,
0.0323748328,
0.0365583263,
-0.0044548581,
-0.0095741255,
-0.0187382866,
0.0154301906,
-0.0547868088,
-0.0453786328,
0.0228680987,
0.0145347202,
-0.0585295223,
-0.0140786469,
0.0079597635,
0.0166053344,
-0.0138655128,
-0.0466725044,
0.0145160966,
-0.020111151,
0.0309077278,
0.007367786,
-0.0463962816,
0.0012416309,
-0.014309831,
0.0033884253,
-0.0251606442,
0.0374937952,
-0.0284755155,
-0.0343654752,
-0.0415677093,
0.0237524156,
0.0296969209,
0.0141729899,
0.0685948506,
-0.0212199818,
0.0008823384,
0.0214856155,
0.0127910459,
-0.0378034897,
-0.0465997681,
0.029138634,
-0.0040758518,
0.0397588164,
0.0970149711,
0.0221686121,
0.0488011725,
0.0491693579,
-0.0403053984,
-0.0242379215,
0.0327801034,
0.0557282455,
-0.0321404785,
-0.0294496864,
-0.026430808,
0.0294001233,
-0.0392406732,
-0.0047622039,
-0.0435096174,
-0.0135476878,
-0.0025690799,
0.0010504033,
0.0297973715,
-0.0167786069,
-0.00737275,
-0.0221524667,
-0.0432043634,
0.0499743782,
0.0400823131,
0.0456399135,
0.0085366769,
0.009053505,
-0.056239482,
0.0099964878,
0.0141036073,
0.0098405089,
0.0594949424,
0.0118530113,
0.0539424419,
0.0344289951,
-0.047699593,
-0.0112540144,
-0.0684021637,
0.0030610524,
0.0153698055,
0.0064841076,
0.0198850986,
0.0314633437,
-0.0117205987,
-0.0013162529,
-0.0450517014,
-0.0297264028,
-0.0260570627,
0.0343100242,
-0.0180092044,
0.0284863245,
-0.009448804,
-0.0526629239,
-0.0717359483,
0.0276356507,
0.0666137487,
-0.0479249544,
0.014364047,
0.0193173885,
2.801e-7,
0.0557892472,
0.0052909572,
0.0356696397,
0.0451184176,
0.0179315209,
0.0318538211,
0.0023040744,
-0.0030310904,
0.0001109512,
-0.0746522918,
-0.0107382592,
0.0250985343,
0.0409013107,
0.032367304,
-0.0322435945,
-0.0087232906,
-0.0368397161,
-0.0195147004,
-0.0314552262,
0.0018739909,
0.0177525468,
0.0549050346,
0.0603834838,
-0.0000218306,
-0.0122816749,
0.0077633262,
0.0108935516,
-0.0108911758,
0.0191488937,
-0.0182533581,
-0.0269463304,
-0.0432503335,
0.0174169932,
-0.0010585291,
-0.0176589619,
0.0050577121,
-0.0042682202,
0.037475694,
-0.0079200473,
0.0267418735,
-0.0336273871,
-0.0585341416,
-0.0328853019,
-0.0299874265,
0.0440516099,
-0.0269603822,
0.0303930659,
0.0021069765,
-0.0022652729,
0.0191687625,
0.0073333737,
0.002856812,
0.0378931165,
-0.0026376972,
0.016423976,
-0.0046540401,
-0.0040139831,
-0.0389275774,
-0.053415142,
0.0236079749,
-0.012755313,
-0.0370951891,
-0.0367012918,
0.0131533975,
-0.0081826458,
-0.0305421166,
-0.0279773083,
2.568184012e-34,
0.0419144891,
-0.0434741564,
0.0482496805,
0.0360381939,
0.0346638151,
-0.0174381528,
-0.0423146784,
0.0385890007,
0.03973433,
-0.0497209281,
-0.0187840164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15014v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15014v1 | Unlocking Temporal Question Answering for Large Language Models Using Code Execution | 2023-05-24T10:57:53 | 2023-05-24T10:57:53 | Xingxuan Li, Liying Cheng, Qingyu Tan, Hwee Tou Ng, Shafiq Joty, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have made significant progress in natural
language processing (NLP), and are utilized extensively in various
applications. Recent works, such as chain-of-thought (CoT), have shown that
intermediate reasoning steps can improve the performance of LLMs for complex
reasoning tasks, such as math problems and symbolic question-answering tasks.
However, we notice the challenge that LLMs face when it comes to temporal
reasoning. Our preliminary experiments show that generating intermediate
reasoning steps does not always boost the performance of complex temporal
question-answering tasks. Therefore, we propose a novel framework that combines
the extraction capability of LLMs and the logical reasoning capability of a
Python solver to tackle this issue. Extensive experiments and analysis
demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework in handling intricate time-bound
reasoning tasks. | [
0.0308940951,
0.0742741525,
-0.017956309,
0.0247907843,
-0.0689648464,
0.0286618173,
0.0114142057,
0.0049050776,
0.0303712767,
-0.0511276685,
0.050149288,
0.0016989254,
-0.0174651518,
0.0383410119,
-0.0276335273,
-0.0329781622,
0.0391764939,
-0.0701456591,
0.010214177,
0.0116347233,
-0.0257522687,
0.0220880378,
-0.0229210258,
0.011207616,
0.0146309724,
-0.0552464537,
-0.0268171038,
-0.0404377729,
0.0222701579,
-0.0323342197,
-0.0338301063,
0.0040894272,
0.0122082643,
0.0019417329,
0.0000018627,
-0.0418661423,
-0.0119445678,
0.0132351601,
-0.0611305088,
0.0230041984,
-0.0231967457,
0.0235742219,
0.0294445325,
0.0412720442,
-0.062605381,
0.0302693136,
-0.0011934118,
0.0005951446,
0.0612237342,
0.043707788,
0.0128800012,
-0.0107840374,
0.0089201052,
0.0357586034,
0.0167344604,
-0.0879010856,
0.018519938,
0.041550193,
0.0554421656,
-0.0477805994,
0.005785672,
0.0457348526,
0.0509745479,
0.0197820477,
-0.0169246718,
0.0378334448,
-0.028681647,
0.0145671098,
-0.0449253395,
0.028727673,
0.0032474285,
-0.0399087667,
-0.0013046684,
0.0156861525,
-0.0294864867,
-0.0216132179,
-0.0457265154,
0.03772787,
-0.0184765607,
0.0024378384,
0.0255903248,
0.0109222438,
0.0129867317,
0.0230471902,
-0.0831615105,
0.1218817681,
0.0028702884,
-0.0171778128,
-0.0232715905,
-0.0278951209,
0.0079501495,
-0.08017461,
0.032404419,
0.1219701022,
-0.026168447,
0.0188158993,
0.0179063268,
0.0125430729,
-0.0160165746,
-0.0231439136,
0.0026441487,
0.0524382405,
0.0264366977,
0.0688257888,
-0.0170393735,
0.0539224893,
-0.0626698732,
-0.0081488406,
-0.0319334641,
-0.0263042767,
-0.072438702,
-0.0431998596,
-0.01851728,
0.0510141067,
-0.01133247,
0.0120514259,
0.0047436222,
0.0334664136,
-0.0046532503,
0.0135900825,
-0.0284841321,
0.0217586737,
0.007819742,
-0.025581073,
-0.067306757,
0.0118672149,
-0.0378897823,
-0.0209690128,
-0.0005484109,
-0.0184069183,
-0.0260102805,
0.0043410058,
0.0155569669,
-0.0456710421,
0.025948666,
0.049830731,
-0.0164194815,
0.0264553372,
-0.0503423922,
-0.0549127236,
0.0070356326,
-0.0830628872,
-0.0037818865,
-0.0919657722,
0.0095806373,
0.0304693263,
-0.0350255445,
-0.0085115219,
0.0199465454,
0.0159837157,
-0.00660061,
0.0651460513,
0.0376834348,
0.0319829732,
-0.0012991753,
-0.0025784895,
0.0171071514,
0.0302483495,
0.0335823521,
-0.00052663,
0.0111043071,
-0.0060457955,
-0.0056412946,
0.0212228466,
0.0232458562,
-0.0254533757,
-0.0415927917,
0.0619405471,
0.0031141285,
0.0103796618,
-0.0380697399,
0.0400458612,
0.0053093475,
0.0045949793,
-0.0096854102,
0.0408359542,
-0.0250707325,
-0.0090287477,
0.0705582723,
-0.0245742034,
0.0224902108,
-0.0025417611,
-0.0314475894,
0.0314307809,
-0.0346719101,
0.0179329831,
-0.0318368673,
0.0567609817,
-0.0035110766,
-0.0637271404,
-0.0162719525,
0.0396073908,
0.0010677748,
0.0544163845,
0.0609642081,
-0.0005167635,
0.0007343636,
0.08225061,
0.0097040813,
0.0111834975,
-0.0064330264,
-0.0452643745,
0.0202748589,
0.0588389784,
0.0511197709,
-0.0358714648,
-0.040780779,
-0.0109885791,
0.0185605194,
0.006179668,
0.0102621512,
-0.0088464208,
-0.0105229504,
0.0076671266,
-0.0053845569,
-0.0117663052,
-0.0031253065,
-0.0080967424,
0.0655728355,
0.0181429274,
0.0081231864,
-0.0010917106,
0.0259713978,
0.0261921436,
-0.0370048918,
-0.0054476173,
-0.0130262515,
0.0216848608,
0.0309897102,
0.0100741796,
-0.0159026161,
0.0295411069,
0.0159847569,
-0.03793272,
-0.0369281843,
0.0150404675,
-0.0406545363,
-0.055199001,
0.0514368452,
0.0066932067,
-0.0583765134,
0.0154152494,
-0.0316190608,
-0.0159652345,
0.0461951196,
-0.0147501584,
0.0403086469,
-0.0044260803,
0.0086184945,
0.0071635093,
-0.0262970105,
-0.0517275631,
0.0843617469,
0.006147027,
0.0175888203,
0.0251669902,
0.0070943353,
-0.0002913929,
-0.0183157288,
0.0225650109,
0.0342576243,
-0.0068317549,
-0.0256610308,
-0.0101311868,
0.0196246989,
-0.0651625991,
-0.029821489,
-0.0531624742,
0.0273340698,
-0.0132940644,
0.0381913297,
0.0037511948,
0.001742792,
0.0079855397,
-0.0013728833,
-0.0316446684,
-0.0077594905,
0.0072328164,
0.0004403076,
0.0490710586,
0.0300243292,
-0.0613749474,
-0.0040821433,
0.0024453858,
-0.0565158576,
0.0680354983,
-0.0061162384,
-0.0299964342,
-0.0151617955,
0.0074773449,
-0.0503260754,
0.0239364114,
0.007752839,
0.0023419838,
0.0209695473,
-0.0340075977,
0.032873597,
0.0750654563,
-0.0081399884,
0.0067416774,
0.0539320633,
-0.0498641171,
-0.0443989709,
0.0436688922,
-0.0196062569,
-0.0090824589,
0.0040737777,
-0.0085104378,
-0.0165403467,
0.0603003576,
-0.0134637142,
0.002218355,
-0.041480951,
0.042605456,
-0.0105561418,
0.00083602,
-0.0245414674,
0.0125320014,
-0.01874898,
0.0696149841,
-0.0183627605,
-0.037632294,
0.0661992505,
0.0163854845,
0.0005872065,
-0.0284769014,
-0.0157054998,
-0.0760675669,
0.1073205769,
-0.0003648204,
0.0098698828,
0.0075735366,
-0.0506609567,
-0.0297308341,
-0.0126354033,
0.0199767388,
-0.0353366472,
0.0354481786,
-0.0754989162,
0.0211617537,
-0.004757226,
-0.0290558301,
-0.0481281579,
-0.0277545229,
-0.0636115968,
-0.0042306129,
-0.0493293293,
0.0125772944,
-0.0056207734,
0.0022985153,
0.0038202798,
-0.0188743118,
-0.004379225,
-0.0238273907,
-0.0159467701,
0.0363178514,
0.0413159356,
0.0113709299,
0.0117409453,
0.0326758102,
0.0527400486,
0.0430437587,
0.0801740959,
0.0102990903,
-0.0516183041,
0.0212559011,
-0.0124500943,
-0.0373042673,
-0.0013565376,
0.0396938547,
-0.0075369817,
-0.0959413722,
-0.0221787561,
0.0996345952,
0.0881114826,
0.0047212811,
-0.0035202573,
-0.0425052643,
0.0076720165,
0.0435658358,
0.0405397601,
-0.0691256747,
-0.0371707752,
0.0136233205,
-0.0309621785,
-0.0326821841,
-0.0360999033,
-0.026814349,
-0.1097054482,
0.011974453,
0.0024755632,
0.001757019,
-0.005970052,
-0.0078622876,
-0.0060161152,
0.0254684314,
-0.0382724851,
0.0393585451,
-0.0079800114,
0.0108001027,
0.0082300454,
-0.0273264032,
0.023135215,
0.0941368714,
0.0215403903,
0.0016144956,
0.0502116755,
0.0314185135,
0.0086780265,
-0.0227761716,
0.0339995772,
0.006146872,
0.0032793181,
-0.0424398631,
0.0053618532,
0.032615684,
-0.0153204305,
-0.0142563162,
0.0389176905,
-0.0259249751,
-0.0361682177,
0.035615325,
0.1125757545,
-0.0205389317,
-0.0061780708,
-0.0223351382,
0.0094768535,
-0.0311767515,
0.0616946258,
0.0019008596,
-0.0107494956,
-0.0871896967,
-0.0168332346,
-0.0719129965,
-0.0578722432,
-0.0500151291,
0.0028744857,
0.0360070616,
0.044405207,
-0.049111139,
-0.0219727494,
0.0342297778,
0.0274778381,
-0.0131801702,
-0.000016465,
0.0300724544,
0.0234265942,
-0.0536531992,
0.0121101858,
-0.0459998362,
0.044679068,
-0.0124248341,
0.0243547503,
0.0065502571,
-0.016409792,
-0.0231879223,
0.0321264006,
-0.1007435173,
-0.0395731814,
-0.0170302503,
-0.0088939508,
0.0229114071,
0.0462270863,
-0.0126676336,
0.0062244479,
0.0126045691,
0.0135748964,
-0.0176452938,
-0.0059140041,
-0.0027334057,
0.0465910733,
0.0120700225,
0.0249917191,
-0.0379384495,
-0.0274482779,
0.0011604385,
0.0607342124,
-0.0224500671,
-0.0091431001,
0.0467272513,
0.037848305,
-0.0291555971,
0.0405961089,
-0.0248119775,
0.0114801796,
0.0285592265,
-0.0312544331,
-0.0480596237,
-0.0262702536,
0.019398544,
-0.0167062823,
-0.0372377075,
0.0054202434,
-0.0155722173,
0.0227918196,
0.0129769715,
0.0186547581,
0.0112472996,
0.0202271398,
0.0132427737,
0.0513313785,
-0.0330104753,
-0.0181222297,
-0.012185527,
0.0047229505,
0.0496112779,
-0.0122120297,
0.0593538396,
0.0241289176,
-0.0096234912,
-0.0859962031,
-0.0340659656,
-0.1038774699,
-0.0603801906,
0.0380528569,
-0.0193767287,
0.0515996069,
0.0031176154,
0.0094085811,
-0.0266379509,
-0.0289511681,
0.0231413748,
0.0191068742,
0.0526213646,
-0.0294147711,
0.0293964688,
0.0264575072,
-0.0099084303,
-0.0153219746,
0.0444646068,
-0.0110833179,
0.0385525748,
0.0464855768,
-0.047206562,
-0.0332172289,
-0.0434405468,
-0.0590788648,
-0.0404334143,
0.0148022342,
0.0164089389,
-0.0803606287,
-0.0666794628,
0.0083969319,
0.0097418539,
0.0027549465,
-0.0130350925,
0.0132072316,
0.0614227913,
0.0643107966,
-0.0542631485,
-0.0341611505,
0.0636297092,
0.0258389339,
-0.0360559821,
-0.0474797823,
-6.019617306e-33,
-0.0241009891,
-0.051662147,
0.0579895489,
0.0177493524,
-0.0213454049,
0.0074903569,
-0.0513025634,
0.0078439442,
-0.0235100966,
-0.0065298579,
-0.0198526401,
0.0327663571,
0.0115349712,
-0.0056199059,
0.0143933455,
-0.0207976308,
-0.014597564,
-0.0004138137,
-0.0030819331,
-0.0023840696,
0.0588444062,
-0.0038339782,
-0.0078942562,
-0.0099107539,
-0.0368432552,
0.0204023309,
0.0193427522,
0.0635780916,
-0.0394501239,
0.0543855652,
-0.006861812,
0.0004521691,
0.028443411,
-0.0450258814,
0.0076576495,
0.0212608762,
-0.0806239471,
-0.0277418196,
0.0179432556,
-0.0104663828,
-0.0286687147,
-0.0366002098,
0.0018394594,
0.0079344753,
0.0347348973,
-0.0544123575,
0.0177191552,
-0.0373752043,
0.0052596661,
-0.0554152019,
-0.0606166795,
0.0457886159,
-0.0441492945,
-0.0222990308,
0.0283667203,
0.0244745389,
-0.0093149235,
0.0244442094,
0.0179703608,
-0.0110454084,
0.0253613777,
0.0039583193,
0.0500446483,
0.0078342389,
-0.0002699182,
-0.0017061693,
-0.0142510487,
-0.0165681541,
-0.0456876196,
0.0453245752,
-0.0169675872,
0.0396342203,
0.035344705,
-0.0165964942,
0.0256097559,
0.0384666435,
-0.0738078654,
-0.0140628582,
0.0116476472,
0.0649026409,
0.0341968089,
-0.0026479838,
-0.0147539191,
0.0096611138,
-0.04766104,
0.0653456748,
-0.0416104645,
0.0042131292,
0.0331420079,
-0.0102015752,
-0.0197086483,
-0.01389015,
0.0361936688,
-0.0453790277,
0.009787119,
0.0339107923,
-0.0155707067,
0.0136681087,
-0.0025650924,
0.0562486872,
-0.0145387892,
0.0311782546,
-0.0083219996,
-0.0204812046,
0.0293714646,
-0.019636333,
-0.0201885104,
0.0058836062,
-0.0437241197,
-0.0196612887,
-0.0780261159,
0.0232181922,
-0.0327383988,
0.0061715581,
0.0472815111,
0.0133658769,
-0.0126305586,
0.0315242298,
0.005268639,
-0.0243784916,
-0.0285113771,
0.047437042,
0.0124414843,
0.0115451422,
-0.0364108048,
-0.0215549991,
-0.0476805493,
0.0233649313,
-0.0071976208,
-0.0189673156,
-0.0108455783,
0.0407264382,
2.562e-7,
0.0190098248,
0.0344738327,
0.017799357,
0.1002847701,
0.0250819586,
0.0095074838,
-0.0020154638,
-0.0410633124,
0.0068228645,
-0.0340407006,
-0.0067907656,
0.0619282499,
0.0444137044,
0.0552900881,
-0.0077057625,
-0.0074809357,
-0.0205334872,
-0.0586985461,
-0.0801157057,
-0.0206078906,
0.0714944005,
0.0577147715,
0.0255884137,
0.000435569,
-0.0105632963,
-0.0591209419,
0.0300896652,
0.0269268677,
-0.0096154809,
0.0214333218,
-0.0148880202,
-0.024543399,
0.0142513458,
0.0275256205,
-0.0024093818,
0.0231290553,
-0.0461528674,
0.050142847,
0.0012508252,
-0.0043693543,
-0.0510339737,
-0.0600845814,
0.0142995305,
-0.0487559997,
0.1172218919,
-0.0675980821,
-0.0484356396,
-0.0209666044,
0.0153059093,
-0.0232760143,
-0.0384696461,
0.0300122071,
0.0160942413,
0.0326815248,
-0.0032553344,
-0.0207823813,
0.0059286291,
-0.1062372699,
-0.0282249972,
0.0266654771,
-0.0274517126,
0.0025853803,
-0.0047046603,
0.0155147891,
0.0168648958,
-0.0589809418,
-0.0098629612,
2.602326383e-34,
0.0240490101,
-0.0079023242,
-0.0009026484,
0.0543520898,
0.0818620175,
0.0079394113,
-0.0450935327,
0.0060438798,
0.0371297598,
-0.0911722556,
-0.010802744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15011v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15011v2 | Bactrian-X: Multilingual Replicable Instruction-Following Models with Low-Rank Adaptation | 2023-05-24T10:50:31 | 2023-10-10T07:46:44 | Haonan Li, Fajri Koto, Minghao Wu, Alham Fikri Aji, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning has shown great promise in improving the performance of
large language models. However, research on multilingual instruction tuning has
been limited due to the scarcity of high-quality instruction-response datasets
across different languages. To bridge this gap, we present Bactrian-X, a
comprehensive multilingual parallel dataset of 3.4 million instruction-response
pairs across 52 languages. Leveraging this dataset, we train a set of adapters
using low-rank adaptation (LoRA), which are lightweight components that
seamlessly integrate with large language models. These adapters have a
substantially lower parameter count than the base model, making them easily
replaceable and usable as plug-ins for different languages or language groups.
Extensive experiments in various multilingual evaluation settings demonstrate
that models derived from LoRA-based training over Bactrian-X outperform both
the vanilla models and existing instruction-tuned models. The code and models
are publicly available at https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/bactrian-x | [
0.0100375731,
0.0530800968,
-0.0204751212,
0.0566117615,
0.0068192985,
0.040889252,
0.0326915681,
-0.0209266096,
0.012324769,
-0.0317744389,
-0.065992333,
-0.0240628961,
-0.0143501228,
-0.0207478087,
0.0282247495,
-0.03603651,
0.0633424371,
-0.0508728586,
-0.0491971932,
-0.0075722747,
-0.0117355958,
0.0413896479,
-0.0189153031,
0.0323784314,
0.0643800646,
-0.0216307882,
-0.0139215766,
0.023411233,
0.0265287198,
-0.0124839982,
0.0432975851,
0.0475824364,
0.0209190641,
0.0223980229,
0.0000020328,
-0.0174847003,
-0.0336996764,
-0.0250817258,
0.0009528922,
0.0257694162,
0.0425204821,
-0.0236610044,
-0.0233590435,
0.0291084219,
-0.0005130732,
-0.0034936881,
0.0465514846,
-0.0098290434,
0.0471721478,
0.0677440837,
0.000404783,
-0.0176094137,
0.0149519118,
-0.0153342634,
-0.0307624675,
-0.0168836564,
-0.0185594745,
-0.012056875,
0.0111027528,
0.0418459028,
-0.0562827401,
0.0251533519,
0.0282734986,
0.0123841343,
-0.037637271,
-0.0114419237,
-0.008058059,
-0.0029488755,
-0.0438085347,
0.0749906525,
-0.0447818972,
-0.0073066414,
-0.0268364046,
-0.0136858216,
0.00067978,
-0.0272485334,
-0.0376737081,
0.0305498894,
0.0343782865,
-0.001898206,
0.0567991622,
-0.0471332483,
-0.0013008513,
-0.0286056157,
-0.0029499021,
0.0331862196,
0.0459901914,
-0.0418815203,
0.0141116986,
0.0095674675,
-0.0139728393,
-0.0277389325,
-0.0157103911,
0.012545363,
-0.0374349095,
0.0270103607,
-0.0531421602,
-0.0248984974,
0.0209027193,
-0.0193823557,
0.1136882529,
0.0708187744,
-0.0216894411,
0.0111433957,
-0.0322126672,
0.0815003887,
-0.0126971649,
0.0422084704,
-0.0311874766,
0.0199043658,
-0.0427147225,
0.0213496704,
-0.0250087846,
0.0134530105,
-0.0733775049,
0.0162563026,
-0.0125562083,
0.0486281775,
-0.0159526542,
-0.0069627203,
0.0183194503,
-0.028902106,
-0.0394493006,
0.0189343896,
-0.0032646528,
0.0689142197,
-0.0228251368,
0.0011607643,
-0.0097507341,
-0.053401012,
-0.0054766154,
0.0070638759,
0.0061535593,
-0.0502296425,
0.0454390272,
0.0436986312,
-0.0333649814,
-0.0324549712,
-0.0047188764,
0.0138015328,
0.0027945419,
-0.0751351342,
-0.003806412,
-0.061571762,
0.0462749638,
0.0028571526,
0.0358809792,
-0.0032212248,
0.0014407935,
0.028373586,
-0.0157660972,
0.034177199,
0.0408271588,
-0.0161351245,
-0.0310581345,
0.0034602655,
0.0275978651,
0.0544753969,
0.0260010213,
-0.0233605858,
0.0424766727,
-0.0468140543,
-0.0531551763,
0.0577921793,
0.012464501,
0.0226695389,
0.0160080418,
0.0153080299,
0.0142427832,
-0.0153681496,
0.0458794124,
-0.0027504265,
-0.0017328644,
-0.0057233721,
0.0467020348,
0.0025600391,
-0.0041142814,
0.0056232391,
0.0598173775,
0.0066350945,
-0.0119276317,
0.0058939108,
-0.0589882806,
0.0386774838,
0.0161073077,
0.010730613,
0.0033825599,
0.0562050827,
-0.0333440937,
-0.0440442972,
0.0008269339,
0.0044677253,
-0.0027991647,
0.0222458839,
0.0299785379,
0.001901894,
-0.0630403981,
0.0122731635,
0.0447489992,
-0.0694643185,
0.0184852537,
-0.0459166132,
0.0083333505,
0.0770778582,
0.0383154675,
-0.0095609082,
-0.0513848774,
0.0011627023,
0.0421493575,
0.0278031845,
0.0352838561,
-0.0054427255,
0.0295450557,
-0.0694068819,
-0.0305888969,
-0.0075713093,
-0.0019139714,
0.0608599819,
0.0036756054,
-0.0017746306,
-0.019791944,
0.0259408634,
-0.0687913597,
0.0375082716,
-0.0713291168,
-0.0556436405,
-0.0032770068,
0.0031510044,
0.0240803696,
0.0164092295,
-0.0025736676,
-0.0178799368,
0.0523285493,
-0.0194494855,
0.0478305332,
-0.0026682394,
-0.0478149988,
-0.0547558367,
0.0125314649,
0.0063715763,
-0.0038435028,
0.0650507584,
-0.0322554298,
-0.056315247,
0.0178595185,
-0.0273074359,
0.0350444652,
0.0029262537,
0.041030895,
-0.0141493231,
0.036318928,
-0.0166809354,
0.0024796664,
-0.0159118846,
0.0443519913,
0.0665687248,
0.0216012094,
-0.0092025474,
-0.031444855,
-0.0424563251,
0.0102749774,
-0.0168000832,
0.0282053482,
0.0061178431,
0.0573880821,
-0.0227668658,
-0.03024932,
-0.0636153817,
0.0470980369,
-0.0235421378,
0.0379651077,
0.0410665534,
0.021571476,
0.0026437829,
-0.0380913205,
-0.0180285573,
-0.0055920742,
-0.007136899,
0.0319621339,
-0.0008027201,
0.0060504978,
-0.0371092707,
-0.0435883068,
-0.021910632,
0.0030521567,
-0.0093003409,
-0.0338004269,
0.0346980728,
-0.0612912178,
-0.0063538519,
-0.0112469345,
0.0339238606,
-0.0153644243,
-0.0645249858,
0.0118417609,
0.0226279236,
0.0686076507,
0.0762216151,
-0.0356762744,
0.0013837658,
0.054465197,
-0.0087193474,
-0.0799931064,
0.0305861253,
-0.029069338,
-0.0427056812,
-0.0500999168,
-0.0580196083,
-0.0113318721,
0.0867300183,
0.0061829956,
-0.0121294428,
-0.0785785839,
-0.0476949327,
-0.0174311828,
-0.031107299,
-0.0162865091,
0.0350428186,
0.008427782,
-0.0346308537,
-0.0310203824,
-0.0284643583,
0.0708988458,
-0.0142041985,
-0.0388593152,
-0.0770156011,
-0.0058318335,
-0.0258375779,
0.0014675109,
0.0238645468,
0.0131102903,
-0.0730929971,
-0.0070423535,
-0.0609966256,
0.0376308076,
0.0166203864,
-0.0168908238,
0.0491497964,
-0.0659301877,
-0.021188071,
-0.0172393508,
-0.0385106504,
-0.002544051,
0.0024473148,
0.0311378427,
0.0035409462,
0.0165225659,
-0.0455993786,
-0.0494241714,
-0.0200988185,
0.0448526889,
0.0708132461,
-0.033810962,
0.0122122755,
-0.0483744517,
-0.0176724568,
0.0697599947,
-0.0040092436,
-0.0064898524,
-0.0540204942,
0.0370502137,
0.0299568996,
0.0670821965,
-0.0370850861,
0.0160512161,
0.0436982103,
0.0688535348,
-0.0077362964,
-0.0164259523,
0.0224706363,
0.0728285164,
-0.0491539389,
-0.026842529,
0.0862367302,
0.0079635857,
-0.0471750572,
-0.0083199283,
-0.0418765619,
0.0634232089,
0.017023202,
0.0408632085,
-0.0661588088,
-0.0115642091,
-0.0256839357,
0.0411197245,
0.0186164286,
0.0125939865,
-0.0127184512,
-0.1054879129,
0.0124594709,
0.0068841651,
-0.0715334639,
-0.0384233221,
-0.0420408361,
-0.0053139455,
-0.009735452,
0.0440383628,
0.0027383745,
-0.041143097,
-0.0066998778,
0.0332498886,
-0.0108092818,
-0.0407039076,
0.0378352255,
-0.0101905158,
0.0574267767,
0.0461480804,
0.0129367821,
0.0021472275,
-0.027952956,
0.0058917729,
-0.0555895455,
-0.0268024746,
-0.0179028846,
0.0210046992,
-0.0068427441,
-0.0205571149,
0.012334507,
0.017937446,
-0.0469673797,
0.0049935332,
0.0338099413,
0.0620990619,
0.0118464548,
0.0062434492,
-0.0076733422,
-0.0300201904,
0.0026930107,
0.0409269258,
0.0206217449,
-0.0796464607,
-0.006307852,
-0.0190368649,
-0.0269733146,
-0.0801480487,
0.0013267465,
0.0354262404,
-0.0804493651,
-0.0034287958,
-0.0420594923,
-0.0614628382,
0.0390046351,
-0.0028917803,
0.0263337363,
-0.0051496504,
-0.0152565483,
-0.0275189169,
-0.0155334314,
0.027612919,
-0.0192678161,
0.0088597871,
-0.1049445644,
-0.0534519106,
-0.0075524757,
0.0136110364,
-0.0221311077,
-0.0000940769,
-0.0498401597,
-0.0646925271,
-0.0024581205,
0.1044908315,
0.0056228591,
0.0511843041,
0.0224818103,
-0.0298304241,
-0.0174681414,
-0.0185737051,
0.0133701926,
0.0307804421,
0.0508367121,
-0.0351746045,
-0.0226290822,
0.0341938026,
-0.0367491394,
0.0415108763,
0.0410579257,
0.0551072434,
-0.0270446911,
-0.0092721153,
0.0021527624,
0.0125347394,
-0.0344531052,
-0.019831961,
-0.0374530628,
-0.0527887456,
0.0512107909,
-0.0299404189,
0.0233213361,
-0.0379450396,
-0.0128065171,
0.027015185,
-0.0413434654,
-0.0156519823,
-0.0193210598,
0.0079792431,
-0.0032020337,
-0.064309448,
0.0501153432,
0.017562924,
0.0372834168,
0.0175994374,
0.0318385288,
-0.0279819332,
-0.0126056308,
0.0267139934,
0.0541457124,
-0.0287515353,
0.0576000176,
-0.0127746789,
-0.0093114683,
0.025544513,
0.0429074802,
-0.0125222737,
-0.0132616032,
-0.0467727669,
-0.0169126298,
0.0354021937,
-0.0012818066,
0.1165968105,
0.0188742112,
0.0002111348,
-0.0147129977,
0.0164583027,
0.0023281595,
-0.0213555936,
0.0098455688,
0.0334438607,
0.0179552715,
-0.001951718,
0.045330938,
0.0234666746,
0.0563045405,
-0.0044467566,
0.0424033701,
-0.0523459613,
-0.0128023066,
0.0184279084,
0.0166974794,
-0.0152529161,
0.0208243392,
0.0088228835,
-0.0524810702,
-0.0378806889,
0.0324358083,
0.0037667232,
-0.0277152248,
0.0006286427,
0.0267021377,
-0.0356037691,
-0.0483450368,
-0.0509740636,
0.006751975,
-0.0156548265,
-0.0311403535,
-0.013331376,
-6.02892061e-33,
-0.0386371724,
0.0190736447,
0.0348931886,
-0.0210679024,
0.0244215596,
0.0027003465,
-0.0216159932,
-0.0209508482,
-0.0372811779,
-0.0056332294,
0.0214107875,
0.0039424975,
0.0187390652,
0.0299858768,
0.0437940136,
0.0242770612,
0.0366130359,
0.020558808,
-0.0214756671,
0.0392897315,
0.046710927,
-0.0048612677,
0.0882880837,
-0.0219372511,
0.0352725536,
-0.0429504588,
0.016082406,
-0.0078628417,
-0.0253467131,
0.0942663103,
0.0048425118,
0.0514185391,
0.0234353356,
-0.0126094306,
-0.0249625873,
0.0015116797,
-0.0787509307,
-0.0407651663,
0.0301781408,
0.0329223014,
-0.0262527782,
-0.0252454933,
-0.0065740701,
-0.0036770268,
-0.0297729615,
-0.0391294919,
0.0308818221,
-0.0209231619,
-0.004022277,
0.0627805442,
-0.0918916091,
-0.005367781,
-0.0049043768,
-0.0041930922,
0.0151920859,
0.1181891337,
0.0040491484,
-0.0125984177,
-0.0684400946,
0.0339120366,
0.0052027674,
0.0785730928,
0.0903116316,
0.0097925421,
-0.0169516653,
0.0041690515,
0.0250678193,
-0.0077178497,
0.0726544484,
0.0167437904,
0.0274169259,
0.0258000959,
0.0479357131,
0.0313072577,
0.0060776994,
-0.0039924774,
-0.0502641089,
0.0104742134,
0.0525994673,
0.0078021167,
0.0227827132,
-0.0163191091,
-0.0406485461,
0.0017718042,
-0.0236367695,
0.0023258752,
-0.0348885655,
-0.0338077508,
0.0705549717,
0.0064569847,
-0.0174220167,
0.0123880543,
0.051285401,
-0.016640909,
-0.0162376668,
-0.0095945727,
-0.006273346,
0.0198623072,
-0.003229897,
0.0476804525,
-0.053347636,
-0.0891322196,
0.004352631,
-0.0589300804,
0.0179421622,
0.0148777338,
0.0533177927,
0.0206637736,
-0.0754515231,
-0.0059644612,
-0.0377547592,
0.0498177558,
-0.010222218,
0.0505699888,
0.0088725062,
-0.0006863775,
-0.0019397084,
0.06798058,
0.022382658,
-0.0405160896,
-0.0263150651,
-0.0434895605,
-0.0071233609,
0.0345613509,
-0.031518206,
0.0123316767,
-0.0553570464,
0.0186000783,
-0.0207904037,
-0.0507344455,
-0.0018839302,
0.0070524164,
2.641e-7,
0.0063064373,
0.0341292806,
-0.0105572753,
-0.0087249437,
-0.0080541698,
-0.0112954965,
-0.0163984708,
0.0315278396,
0.0406889208,
0.030234091,
-0.0125132715,
0.0147450482,
0.0425155237,
0.0066638845,
-0.043150112,
-0.0201355629,
-0.0515349023,
0.0341426805,
-0.0605967604,
0.0017477431,
-0.0001003323,
0.0825935528,
-0.002751485,
0.0017346055,
-0.0378828757,
0.0287989192,
0.0201091301,
-0.0179024953,
-0.0227046125,
0.0121758664,
-0.0057810978,
0.0042753736,
-0.0214307327,
0.0152410334,
-0.0404418819,
0.04272791,
-0.0310335401,
0.0817431957,
-0.0249131322,
-0.0183988381,
0.061813131,
-0.0147176869,
-0.028429646,
-0.0586706065,
0.048352614,
0.0009343004,
0.0190044735,
0.000667338,
-0.023118645,
0.0001186541,
0.0115590645,
-0.0385674164,
-0.0188341495,
0.0207726825,
0.0450879261,
-0.0439852625,
-0.0034936797,
-0.0489394143,
0.0082451571,
0.0353410393,
-0.0058328868,
-0.0587553494,
-0.0502212755,
-0.0119496156,
-0.0148248021,
-0.0574558154,
-0.0080498867,
2.50875887e-34,
0.0155701153,
-0.0220005158,
0.0569028929,
0.0374101363,
0.0150586329,
-0.0213791337,
-0.0188588966,
0.0299443342,
0.0214818977,
-0.090971306,
-0.0458737984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15010v1 | Injecting Knowledge into Biomedical Pre-trained Models via Polymorphism and Synonymous Substitution | 2023-05-24T10:48:53 | 2023-05-24T10:48:53 | Hongbo Zhang, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) were considered to be able to store
relational knowledge present in the training data. However, some relational
knowledge seems to be discarded unsafely in PLMs due to \textbf{report bias}:
low-frequency relational knowledge might be underexpressed compared to
high-frequency one in PLMs. This gives us a hint that relational knowledge
might not be redundant to the stored knowledge of PLMs, but rather be
complementary. To additionally inject relational knowledge into PLMs, we
propose a simple-yet-effective approach to inject relational knowledge into
PLMs, which is inspired by three observations (namely, polymorphism, synonymous
substitution, and association). In particular, we switch entities in the
training corpus to related entities (either hypernyms/hyponyms/synonyms, or
arbitrarily-related concepts). Experimental results show that the proposed
approach could not only better capture relational knowledge, but also improve
the performance in various biomedical downstream tasks. Our model is available
in \url{https://github.com/StevenZHB/BioPLM_InjectingKnowledge}. | [
0.0442089364,
0.0494601727,
0.001483574,
-0.00526535,
-0.0129355183,
0.019240642,
-0.0178433843,
0.0277383011,
0.0073648463,
-0.050519336,
-0.0620895699,
-0.0020456668,
0.0193791017,
0.0302604977,
0.0192723777,
-0.0192541648,
0.0920710191,
0.0319999829,
-0.0188727118,
-0.0130092828,
-0.0239963345,
0.0054906108,
-0.0048064636,
-0.0083481306,
-0.001938481,
0.0241050106,
0.0315718278,
-0.0153608704,
0.0165875182,
-0.0098112598,
-0.0176232979,
0.062005043,
0.0144586945,
0.0059842994,
0.0000018,
-0.0576492697,
-0.0384366512,
0.040355742,
-0.0183936004,
-0.0166905317,
0.0133319469,
-0.0511034727,
0.0202696845,
-0.0175618734,
-0.0203479454,
-0.0515613109,
0.0604446493,
0.0136436969,
0.0072917081,
0.0493934043,
-0.0128468405,
0.0001211827,
0.0433186032,
-0.0193233006,
0.0475666299,
-0.0027398001,
0.0768088326,
-0.0018055881,
-0.0197340045,
-0.0038871833,
-0.0118067805,
0.0492250435,
-0.0217949431,
0.0502288453,
0.0634373873,
0.0442383587,
0.0130920662,
-0.0199021026,
0.0314968601,
0.0483498201,
-0.0593050867,
-0.0290798228,
0.0299296957,
0.0139244311,
-0.0320500992,
0.035014201,
-0.0123009207,
-0.0121226925,
-0.031994909,
0.0189361628,
0.0129518695,
-0.0384357311,
0.0410531051,
0.0129899075,
-0.0390831269,
0.0236869529,
0.0411979333,
-0.0110412017,
0.0170017257,
-0.0150278267,
-0.0116948718,
-0.0228289384,
0.0106468135,
0.023488801,
0.0104469154,
0.0492710583,
-0.0391822718,
-0.012695617,
0.0641443729,
-0.0957149267,
0.0028664565,
0.0119947447,
0.0018198995,
0.0370167755,
-0.0622413531,
-0.0037115761,
-0.0034901374,
0.0560778603,
-0.052328866,
-0.0027140006,
-0.0655499697,
-0.0118838754,
-0.0133578246,
0.0483555496,
0.0101211853,
-0.0014940407,
-0.0610554926,
0.0164785255,
0.0057056909,
-0.0110593662,
-0.0034500391,
0.0021147258,
-0.0376975387,
0.0224866029,
-0.0578275435,
0.0085449712,
0.0211258642,
0.0247226637,
-0.0597091652,
-0.0494700186,
-0.0041989787,
-0.0260423068,
-0.0001619571,
-0.0318078026,
0.0218482204,
0.0861865729,
0.0216751471,
-0.0584735274,
-0.0306759197,
-0.0159042142,
0.0053875041,
-0.0353216492,
0.0203678925,
-0.0437269285,
0.0613180697,
0.0020982083,
0.0067762914,
-0.0536394455,
0.0166827664,
-0.01107956,
-0.0873411894,
0.1238843799,
-0.0615166947,
0.0172151029,
-0.0042562946,
0.0301809702,
-0.0193046033,
0.0446565598,
0.0201789737,
-0.0628490448,
0.0135015743,
-0.0449529737,
-0.0088606477,
-0.0021959182,
0.0369467326,
-0.0561242737,
-0.0360730551,
0.0072488431,
0.0514302924,
0.0259638131,
0.0331916437,
0.0518289022,
-0.003921628,
-0.0117674284,
0.0327818654,
0.0296720397,
0.0427700318,
0.0184396971,
0.0562925264,
-0.0542007834,
0.0175143145,
-0.0047558998,
-0.0486867242,
-0.016580306,
-0.030298695,
0.0130619239,
-0.0061962898,
0.0248365756,
-0.0199167952,
0.0012485313,
-0.0087723276,
-0.0194028523,
-0.0167628787,
-0.0183251407,
0.0538932905,
0.0321616083,
0.0020907787,
0.1093416959,
0.0827090442,
-0.0190184526,
0.0499216206,
-0.0353024825,
0.0084111281,
0.0644158125,
0.0498453155,
-0.0407655872,
-0.0250869114,
0.0066945362,
-0.0598627739,
-0.0062310235,
0.0453549325,
-0.0318667963,
0.0281419586,
-0.0273398273,
-0.0048304666,
0.0508805215,
0.0081923176,
0.0086786617,
0.0429681353,
0.0321164057,
0.0100781871,
-0.0345598683,
-0.0217772853,
0.0383719318,
-0.0789927021,
-0.0156234531,
-0.0314554609,
-0.0127671007,
0.0242336337,
0.0161666293,
-0.0244268142,
0.0515001453,
0.0565993823,
-0.0224638246,
-0.029096622,
0.0029503412,
-0.0355553664,
-0.0351522379,
0.013591283,
-0.0124691566,
-0.0023846957,
-0.0356712304,
-0.0175931137,
-0.0171562415,
-0.0072714319,
0.0103797885,
0.0971036032,
-0.0240562446,
0.0368705541,
0.0003747988,
-0.0115718991,
-0.041035708,
0.0492021367,
0.0035697431,
0.0308492873,
-0.0222124849,
-0.0312912501,
0.0053578257,
0.0047580651,
-0.0407987162,
0.004307461,
0.0096588908,
-0.0058385511,
-0.0130609712,
-0.0413433947,
-0.0545772538,
-0.0033282749,
-0.069132477,
0.0024135804,
0.0484143384,
0.0185197666,
0.0197859053,
0.022926623,
0.0074064326,
-0.0124187535,
-0.0222722143,
0.0151358293,
-0.0251657609,
0.0528161004,
0.0088167898,
0.0223194994,
0.010501598,
-0.0366821364,
0.0045113275,
-0.052881103,
0.0330141596,
0.009047824,
-0.0132456236,
-0.0095980372,
0.0343320444,
-0.0602794327,
0.0198793765,
-0.0000674599,
-0.0220530126,
-0.0101927314,
0.0136066405,
0.0095937261,
0.0346654058,
-0.0115286196,
-0.0109147551,
0.0713190064,
0.0060057915,
-0.0174603909,
-0.0199174061,
-0.0627753809,
-0.0341569632,
-0.0091357995,
-0.021642765,
-0.011452917,
0.0534336641,
0.0140186744,
-0.0541076399,
-0.0254885033,
0.0017568142,
-0.0081467759,
-0.0030627616,
-0.0349368602,
-0.0061452664,
-0.01121163,
0.0190376006,
-0.0244902223,
-0.0499355756,
0.098763831,
-0.0041873888,
0.0353565887,
-0.0663217604,
-0.0021498683,
-0.015095857,
0.0317196548,
-0.000443968,
0.0309719667,
0.0269891303,
0.0048441496,
-0.0425000116,
0.0154356547,
-0.0181079209,
-0.0587065704,
0.0495056398,
-0.0333908238,
0.0198049527,
0.0290321242,
-0.0195357725,
-0.0671901852,
0.0024286881,
-0.0161843263,
0.0217643082,
0.0274837166,
-0.012856246,
-0.001653098,
0.0260895062,
0.0091875074,
0.0468185581,
0.0121172322,
-0.014417924,
-0.0118587352,
-0.0174603239,
0.020681968,
-0.0128216567,
0.0107434532,
0.0047586919,
-0.0133968359,
0.0397916026,
-0.0023910345,
-0.0121152764,
0.0091990717,
0.0268079713,
-0.0147171225,
-0.0354763418,
-0.009097117,
-0.0079325959,
-0.0357659757,
-0.0275317188,
-0.0087333228,
0.120247893,
0.0366445147,
-0.0570350438,
0.0374589562,
0.0050438344,
-0.0027732032,
0.0126593355,
0.0330719911,
-0.0922750905,
-0.0081481691,
-0.0130077107,
-0.0356640406,
-0.0136234984,
-0.0703395009,
-0.0217604097,
-0.0764025152,
-0.0358540714,
0.0166273583,
-0.0478542037,
-0.0354537554,
-0.0581207648,
0.0230484959,
-0.0321353637,
-0.0078543928,
-0.0009508483,
-0.0227651466,
-0.0004393605,
0.0135553917,
-0.001901697,
-0.0976952612,
-0.0062330733,
-0.0533139147,
0.0549820401,
0.0556111261,
0.0220363662,
-0.0139223374,
0.0031181595,
0.0037045164,
0.0069124773,
-0.0077761794,
-0.0129002752,
0.0847042054,
-0.0349851176,
-0.0167559963,
-0.0112242298,
-0.0066427374,
-0.0457085259,
-0.0305017643,
-0.0370117985,
0.0944513306,
-0.0068191248,
-0.0235729292,
-0.040201433,
-0.0018123211,
0.0118899783,
0.1119438857,
0.0204125941,
0.0007862909,
0.0236907769,
0.0150488615,
0.045308318,
0.043801561,
-0.0066527729,
0.0171498768,
-0.0686262026,
-0.0475801378,
-0.0791182891,
-0.013806222,
0.0643971115,
0.0087124463,
0.0559760332,
0.0261363797,
0.0319983214,
-0.0383539423,
-0.0784324259,
0.057009127,
0.0110904155,
-0.0061149346,
-0.0306096859,
-0.0751432404,
0.0730321184,
0.0201152451,
-0.0311159771,
-0.0047177402,
-0.0023409897,
-0.059783373,
0.0016741771,
0.0546155199,
0.0237901416,
0.034517318,
-0.005094267,
-0.0153276948,
0.0460873879,
0.0419195332,
-0.0374331847,
-0.0055994596,
0.000972558,
-0.0164138153,
-0.0109090349,
0.0153023899,
-0.0230152123,
0.0067801755,
0.0282375552,
0.0340326838,
0.0066431942,
-0.0393009707,
0.0302087162,
0.0184820071,
0.074863188,
-0.0113064889,
0.0228617713,
-0.0362422541,
0.0132642332,
-0.0236226339,
0.0081498092,
-0.0342732556,
-0.0087105753,
0.0457640663,
0.0472792126,
-0.0270918049,
-0.0150729734,
-0.0538404398,
0.0359656736,
0.0472035408,
-0.020515535,
0.019705385,
-0.0094420323,
0.0545184016,
0.01720603,
0.011691344,
0.0069506001,
-0.0151119037,
-0.00988732,
-0.0569195375,
-0.0029541526,
0.014360534,
0.0110424729,
-0.0345019586,
0.0219858214,
-0.0347242244,
-0.0298822764,
-0.0174103938,
0.0197210908,
0.0314547606,
-0.0377657637,
0.0093361549,
-0.0365346931,
-0.0020854364,
-0.0233633183,
0.0012309919,
-0.0455072969,
0.0297684409,
0.0755086094,
0.0308684055,
-0.0082019502,
-0.0205997005,
0.0850159079,
0.0126926173,
0.1076908782,
-0.0274070911,
-0.0462409817,
-0.006346433,
-0.0153261079,
0.0481181741,
-0.001936679,
-0.0846144706,
0.0062806336,
-0.0657961369,
-0.0990941525,
0.0446741879,
0.0016597158,
-0.0215858798,
0.0195539817,
0.0507644676,
0.0249087159,
0.0219533797,
-0.0360235199,
-0.0104268407,
0.0353372172,
0.0007980044,
-0.0439310074,
0.0353297405,
-5.990400027e-33,
-0.0297402609,
-0.0145022739,
0.0192728229,
-0.0528407134,
-0.0162901599,
0.0189950559,
-0.010078935,
-0.0171718486,
0.0030005595,
0.0322810076,
-0.0065187337,
-0.0066074044,
0.0024591812,
-0.0053080209,
-0.0115183126,
-0.0070781433,
0.0097111315,
0.017294446,
0.0211790614,
-0.0174895115,
0.0321328864,
0.078315191,
0.0653981939,
-0.0366723053,
-0.0200067144,
0.0383107625,
0.0292188283,
0.0157417059,
-0.0333056711,
0.0575914793,
-0.0399807319,
0.0447704755,
0.0211555548,
0.0342821404,
-0.0202769972,
0.0216066372,
-0.1065870672,
-0.0412512086,
0.0611622185,
-0.0192630552,
-0.0120177129,
-0.0219333526,
0.065934293,
-0.0232658722,
0.000032075,
-0.0126429852,
0.0015148461,
-0.0527740121,
-0.0316688679,
-0.0037460243,
-0.0636526719,
0.0076915328,
0.0464461222,
0.0144083947,
0.0478289239,
-0.0330542289,
-0.0069963252,
0.0151147293,
-0.0264364053,
0.0233769957,
0.0313452929,
0.0408488438,
0.0013145291,
0.0181680396,
0.0263676383,
0.0529644862,
0.0132633699,
-0.0150725758,
0.0172696654,
0.0220964756,
0.0341447666,
0.0221231151,
0.0141879302,
0.0144158164,
0.0212696735,
-0.0074450257,
-0.0687795728,
0.0153651219,
-0.0482331216,
0.0170425847,
0.0002518164,
-0.0124217952,
-0.021594407,
-0.0356607288,
-0.0640167668,
0.0159536339,
-0.0412405394,
-0.0604222231,
-0.0010863517,
-0.0312950164,
0.0000389155,
0.043911729,
0.0017590208,
-0.0371335112,
-0.0370814428,
-0.0101545919,
0.027080372,
-0.0026253005,
-0.0228730235,
0.0348338559,
-0.08339376,
-0.05029561,
0.0464946292,
-0.0193803683,
0.0321771689,
0.0326656662,
0.0269473474,
0.0168192778,
-0.0376129225,
-0.0280085411,
-0.0287928972,
-0.0621732436,
0.0314764827,
0.0006054515,
0.0154203521,
0.079124406,
0.0252829194,
0.0202605892,
0.0579807237,
0.0001476687,
-0.0458296612,
0.0404549725,
0.0087431828,
0.0602695867,
-0.0258658845,
-0.0232130401,
-0.0305604916,
0.0029970952,
0.0350394547,
-0.0518349037,
-0.008249959,
-0.0143327964,
2.724e-7,
0.0925888047,
0.0283653177,
-0.0079574427,
-0.0097406534,
0.0121170906,
-0.0076115401,
-0.017380178,
0.0580072142,
-0.0238290336,
-0.0235053711,
0.0335428007,
0.0192489531,
-0.0072563943,
0.0107289273,
-0.078395091,
-0.0456990898,
-0.0476073436,
-0.0342869088,
-0.0450460874,
-0.0114931269,
0.0146239595,
0.0821834654,
0.0217112079,
-0.0138419345,
-0.0250774864,
0.0043480196,
0.0407422893,
-0.0349403806,
-0.0044723167,
0.0523969159,
-0.0110373916,
0.0132913738,
0.0120772962,
0.086615555,
-0.0378013887,
-0.0241837204,
0.0248023216,
0.055971384,
-0.0468873121,
-0.0105761094,
0.0222486742,
-0.0168484319,
0.0077750268,
-0.0609741472,
0.0365221091,
-0.071901232,
-0.034627337,
-0.020122705,
-0.0037235126,
0.0178645216,
0.0113293855,
-0.0215785336,
-0.0318659581,
0.0311644282,
0.0305337645,
0.0553686842,
-0.0310421195,
-0.0830733404,
0.0090137739,
0.0401704162,
-0.0344516933,
-0.0729063079,
0.0149997389,
-0.0300271939,
0.0333778746,
-0.0575926565,
0.0314143039,
2.524202156e-34,
-0.0057392512,
0.0118826954,
-0.0030721435,
0.0368108004,
0.0330799781,
-0.0432079397,
-0.0075441934,
0.0264343265,
-0.0043898667,
-0.0946065411,
0.0107174916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15008v1 | Are Chatbots Ready for Privacy-Sensitive Applications? An Investigation into Input Regurgitation and Prompt-Induced Sanitization | 2023-05-24T10:48:05 | 2023-05-24T10:48:05 | Aman Priyanshu, Supriti Vijay, Ayush Kumar, Rakshit Naidu, Fatemehsadat Mireshghallah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | LLM-powered chatbots are becoming widely adopted in applications such as
healthcare, personal assistants, industry hiring decisions, etc. In many of
these cases, chatbots are fed sensitive, personal information in their prompts,
as samples for in-context learning, retrieved records from a database, or as
part of the conversation. The information provided in the prompt could directly
appear in the output, which might have privacy ramifications if there is
sensitive information there. As such, in this paper, we aim to understand the
input copying and regurgitation capabilities of these models during inference
and how they can be directly instructed to limit this copying by complying with
regulations such as HIPAA and GDPR, based on their internal knowledge of them.
More specifically, we find that when ChatGPT is prompted to summarize cover
letters of a 100 candidates, it would retain personally identifiable
information (PII) verbatim in 57.4% of cases, and we find this retention to be
non-uniform between different subgroups of people, based on attributes such as
gender identity. We then probe ChatGPT's perception of privacy-related policies
and privatization mechanisms by directly instructing it to provide compliant
outputs and observe a significant omission of PII from output. | [
0.0509480163,
0.054416772,
-0.0353041589,
0.0003292886,
-0.0563007258,
0.0041665565,
0.0300758705,
0.0107589113,
0.0695044622,
-0.0348975621,
-0.0016073075,
-0.0233097505,
0.0113744568,
0.0114739994,
-0.0022609604,
-0.0146991536,
0.0309633184,
0.0093112653,
0.0032599606,
-0.0111059537,
-0.0064621712,
0.0124645336,
0.0173318293,
0.0628127754,
0.0044939024,
-0.0242279842,
-0.0147412475,
0.0110831447,
0.0027769834,
0.0191566348,
0.0108216666,
0.0171601996,
0.0074330554,
0.0368359387,
0.0000017728,
-0.0661114603,
-0.0238785259,
0.0379148796,
-0.07788001,
-0.0249898415,
0.0579091087,
-0.0018292937,
-0.0028021049,
0.0193269309,
-0.0375025384,
0.040765956,
0.027213553,
0.0615765676,
0.0687191486,
0.0820670575,
-0.0122570237,
0.0400695354,
0.0255638994,
-0.0105641922,
0.0041033742,
-0.0412372202,
0.0071128001,
-0.0606203191,
-0.0018341773,
0.0259587541,
0.037591029,
0.0299096871,
0.0135449264,
0.0026091735,
-0.028450422,
0.0091449916,
-0.0143659897,
-0.0542778596,
-0.0182860568,
0.0459990948,
0.0368000157,
0.0114987483,
0.032291133,
0.0158541519,
0.0703239888,
0.0172576122,
-0.0363388099,
0.065022327,
-0.0561559275,
-0.0180656463,
-0.032841485,
-0.0270032343,
0.0345278569,
-0.0054655238,
0.0016059352,
0.019998841,
-0.0185959898,
-0.0367367081,
0.0146070719,
-0.0284832399,
0.0713508651,
-0.0674027801,
0.0278091133,
0.0512484461,
-0.0156963132,
-0.0005810519,
-0.0471964478,
0.0087273894,
0.0377016924,
-0.0281015672,
-0.026155211,
0.0221054219,
0.0146639477,
0.0346813649,
0.0029423404,
0.041031599,
-0.0131774805,
0.0696992502,
0.0066724187,
-0.0118721994,
-0.0305689014,
-0.0314542502,
-0.0004693496,
0.076126501,
-0.0006023567,
0.017285157,
-0.0525374971,
0.04436481,
-0.0474896096,
0.0453689769,
-0.0357014015,
-0.0085692024,
-0.0163539052,
-0.0017259076,
-0.0387297459,
-0.0612872131,
0.0056471,
0.0109609161,
0.0354479849,
-0.0615862645,
-0.0091767944,
-0.011800725,
-0.0023791487,
0.0131738074,
-0.0332765467,
0.1088147163,
0.0252161771,
-0.0314963721,
0.0007056206,
-0.0810643733,
0.0283479411,
-0.0564220659,
0.0213550795,
0.0015276606,
0.0277445596,
-0.0102496324,
-0.0263141431,
-0.0699657947,
0.0031186137,
0.0197046641,
-0.0434168391,
0.0710827634,
0.0366814882,
-0.0147984149,
0.0034018487,
0.06342794,
-0.0655911416,
0.0215393547,
0.0178653728,
0.0580964312,
0.0463267118,
-0.0251027606,
0.0698011294,
0.0080963792,
0.0079594208,
-0.0169946626,
0.0144681325,
0.0118492553,
0.0028508003,
-0.018752126,
0.0245907903,
0.0371018648,
-0.0224107951,
-0.0195931811,
0.0758967474,
0.1183885261,
-0.0038961894,
-0.0064069624,
-0.0062736124,
0.0307894591,
0.0192037169,
0.0429426171,
-0.0745803416,
-0.0110531244,
-0.0345778652,
-0.0502498485,
-0.0542663299,
0.0061091143,
-0.0245045498,
-0.0196386222,
0.0186515395,
-0.0545606203,
0.0287072621,
0.0174503177,
-0.0105593698,
0.0315899849,
-0.017751826,
0.0069999034,
0.0115614636,
-0.056881208,
-0.0460148752,
-0.0910680741,
0.0307508353,
0.0895678699,
0.0300558694,
-0.0013000355,
-0.013130663,
-0.0586554743,
-0.053208515,
0.003573095,
0.0401990674,
0.008489294,
0.0397307575,
-0.0304240957,
-0.0689942911,
0.0181693621,
0.0203207452,
0.0139982617,
0.0293442011,
-0.0059382771,
0.0236549452,
-0.0012425533,
-0.0056362576,
0.0279795602,
-0.0317818373,
-0.0262024533,
-0.0091854939,
0.0203326903,
0.0299967509,
0.0227602422,
0.026894128,
0.0084936488,
0.0281430278,
0.0196454506,
-0.0207821764,
-0.0067804288,
-0.0062865787,
0.0246521682,
-0.0196963623,
-0.0089855148,
-0.0389195606,
0.0377399698,
-0.0214585625,
0.0198745709,
-0.0252602492,
-0.0068950434,
0.0271332692,
-0.0372404829,
0.0091075674,
-0.0082379803,
0.0250821169,
-0.0150765972,
0.0150028914,
-0.0416957512,
-0.0389576368,
0.0021946758,
-0.0122370608,
-0.0192455444,
-0.067635484,
0.0168492105,
0.0179345664,
-0.0074960287,
0.0162193123,
0.0320347063,
-0.0108066425,
-0.0383545086,
-0.0151880188,
-0.0787992179,
0.0202082023,
0.0239051655,
0.018393036,
-0.006029096,
0.0198459532,
-0.0041442448,
-0.0445240997,
-0.0471335463,
-0.035709016,
-0.0083324127,
0.0627444237,
0.0518236421,
0.0012482071,
-0.0333489105,
0.0042302203,
0.0122519732,
-0.0095249377,
-0.0106492713,
0.0106837582,
-0.0021210632,
-0.0331514999,
0.0208762176,
-0.0250922963,
-0.0159542374,
-0.0287246313,
-0.0030487773,
0.0220564902,
0.0084738033,
-0.0125155449,
0.0908385813,
0.0343028307,
0.0627767816,
0.0217402112,
0.0438171625,
-0.0440923944,
-0.0096048797,
-0.0206723586,
-0.0029991183,
-0.0109416312,
-0.0397405177,
0.0233868472,
-0.005474207,
-0.0021361201,
0.0054059415,
-0.0400115661,
0.0621444136,
-0.0154697206,
-0.0537092648,
-0.0371540524,
-0.0159258526,
-0.0347389318,
0.044095099,
-0.0122293737,
-0.0643759891,
0.062419638,
0.0040055029,
0.0368787795,
0.0372349545,
-0.0548933707,
-0.0076227933,
0.0643760934,
-0.0213258248,
0.0101144863,
0.0546128824,
-0.0586773455,
-0.061678607,
-0.0090159792,
0.0354284905,
-0.0704355687,
0.0011433321,
-0.0129305087,
-0.0370455906,
-0.0009137413,
-0.0570559278,
-0.0632232204,
-0.0807337388,
0.0081153428,
0.0120734172,
-0.0118451389,
-0.0271708164,
-0.0137391435,
-0.0394678079,
0.014859247,
0.0219527725,
-0.0182032026,
-0.0084001413,
-0.0283329543,
-0.0171661563,
-0.0121648358,
-0.0075590839,
-0.0056934725,
-0.0097377757,
0.0197736751,
0.0742070526,
0.0187557787,
0.0249268524,
0.0180848818,
-0.0267847665,
-0.0208626986,
-0.016072629,
-0.0305117033,
-0.0130123133,
0.0572971478,
-0.0686708987,
0.0235063992,
0.0607151203,
-0.0070382217,
-0.0194472969,
0.0019122096,
0.0219340697,
0.0041333744,
-0.0136793302,
-0.0039593694,
-0.0675891563,
0.0126950238,
0.0345766656,
0.069893375,
-0.0675731003,
-0.0536061227,
-0.0155831762,
-0.0894761756,
0.0340022407,
-0.0120286932,
-0.0236038789,
-0.0528329834,
-0.0434785187,
0.0027762726,
-0.0095319813,
0.0339714065,
-0.0467094667,
-0.0219829176,
-0.0321713313,
0.0088749221,
-0.0532917082,
-0.0167912971,
0.0101394765,
-0.0396025591,
0.0382871926,
0.0688585714,
0.0335002132,
-0.0031609214,
-0.002004897,
0.0665607601,
0.0226012934,
-0.00967135,
0.029847797,
0.0624883175,
-0.0075496812,
0.0248308051,
-0.0208836272,
0.0449610762,
0.0134745659,
0.0005596154,
0.0338617824,
0.022194948,
-0.0535301641,
-0.0382517055,
-0.014511968,
-0.0031688006,
0.018808933,
0.0841399729,
0.0071267108,
-0.0218496583,
-0.0219888426,
-0.0489874259,
0.0179516021,
0.0437608846,
0.0008286071,
0.0057933982,
-0.053836111,
-0.0435832553,
-0.0559432581,
-0.0536479801,
-0.0045104474,
-0.0295226406,
0.0338365994,
-0.0285793561,
0.0340924263,
0.0223458838,
0.0202381518,
-0.0021195619,
-0.0607012212,
-0.0131627014,
-0.0034382234,
-0.0059633879,
-0.0283355992,
0.0013954275,
-0.0001553839,
0.0103953853,
-0.0501925088,
-0.0264881644,
0.0257045999,
0.0408389606,
0.034729749,
0.049527023,
-0.0063674273,
0.0008723747,
0.0627750456,
0.0751765817,
-0.0391343795,
-0.0040187361,
0.0729601309,
0.0247049201,
-0.0079743639,
0.0169415381,
-0.0257967766,
-0.0139579168,
0.0123816188,
-0.060473524,
-0.0474290475,
-0.0603162572,
0.0153266704,
0.0362582542,
-0.0089591369,
0.030512955,
0.0246810783,
-0.0242742691,
0.0059277727,
-0.0246680118,
0.008984657,
-0.0199617241,
-0.0230567139,
0.0187500529,
0.0090836156,
0.0472579859,
-0.012559942,
-0.0199790187,
0.0445359834,
-0.045265317,
-0.0246473923,
0.0048195296,
0.0307813231,
0.0103029571,
-0.0080977911,
-0.0207108669,
0.0824935585,
0.0067292233,
0.0365650207,
0.0005685365,
0.0494970083,
0.0184373837,
0.0266754869,
-0.0079412479,
0.04366244,
-0.1164650768,
-0.0866524577,
0.021075258,
0.0637402982,
-0.0407276899,
0.0192193743,
-0.018660102,
-0.0480116867,
0.0073175691,
-0.0117716091,
0.0212110262,
0.0113963466,
0.0127203409,
-0.0065706689,
-0.0061587803,
-0.0330864117,
0.0183542948,
0.0712248608,
-0.0076992158,
0.069886893,
-0.0442864299,
-0.0322336406,
-0.0688030124,
-0.0347195603,
0.0581654161,
0.0207735393,
0.0124582257,
-0.0343367308,
-0.062764287,
-0.057608854,
-0.0092302952,
-0.0216334537,
-0.0073780292,
-0.0287528131,
0.0138505185,
0.0392124616,
-0.0173272472,
-0.0394664146,
-0.0563432053,
0.0113349725,
0.0055603492,
-0.0011825677,
0.001315939,
-5.165726455e-33,
0.0061863023,
-0.0275024753,
-0.0036117851,
0.0618651547,
-0.012651721,
0.007745917,
-0.0068489118,
-0.0063746492,
-0.0137494421,
-0.0139001608,
-0.0585061386,
0.0357685909,
0.0032181775,
-0.0186193082,
-0.0165783931,
-0.0501788296,
0.0425559878,
-0.0292281192,
-0.0089172246,
0.0428845659,
0.0161229298,
0.0393694825,
0.0173982698,
-0.0879784301,
0.0850897506,
-0.0121581238,
-0.0502418876,
0.0073907161,
-0.0418379866,
0.032802511,
0.0031434861,
0.0085427566,
0.0162770282,
-0.0056079752,
0.0135233095,
0.1035249159,
-0.0484715179,
-0.0335248671,
-0.021630222,
-0.0086670248,
-0.0095548918,
-0.0789670348,
0.0464244112,
-0.046484042,
-0.0168462768,
-0.012256722,
0.0135869272,
-0.0191979017,
-0.0046427539,
-0.015121636,
-0.0038383761,
-0.0050617447,
-0.0238479916,
-0.0304186419,
0.017756829,
0.0661875233,
-0.0003134001,
0.0112812417,
-0.0312275775,
0.0293383244,
0.027318906,
-0.0360390432,
0.0306911506,
-0.0064408458,
0.0252203196,
0.0388471037,
0.0534542128,
0.0181405265,
-0.0223261956,
-0.0567624606,
0.0033890025,
0.0352565385,
-0.0209384803,
0.018808255,
0.0035875102,
-0.0384083539,
-0.0135689033,
0.0299142078,
0.0415116139,
0.0218645614,
0.0191040877,
-0.0239178408,
-0.0661433265,
-0.0124860369,
-0.0264334101,
-0.0340729877,
-0.0082933391,
-0.0070339846,
0.0118125081,
0.0130745647,
-0.012321692,
-0.0072063259,
-0.0166876055,
-0.077751644,
-0.0081199063,
-0.0134917097,
0.0041957977,
-0.0665877536,
0.0037575599,
0.0034513902,
-0.0422920324,
-0.031270504,
0.0252350643,
-0.0147475749,
0.0558353476,
0.043665085,
0.0442315266,
0.0249769054,
-0.0634895712,
-0.0280069262,
-0.0107692201,
0.0676976591,
0.0004550891,
0.0021460457,
0.0507533289,
0.0115203587,
0.0107889967,
0.0249112118,
0.0203214716,
0.0513359085,
-0.0609273352,
0.0227417089,
-0.0086505711,
-0.0055946768,
-0.0103131915,
-0.026038995,
-0.0260691363,
0.0363822691,
0.0649810284,
-0.035638839,
-0.0013280053,
-0.0272645671,
2.575e-7,
-0.0041722301,
-0.0175656676,
0.0088384692,
0.0157601088,
0.0181179829,
0.0836340412,
0.013361698,
0.0608555451,
0.0174903702,
-0.0295836478,
0.0141748507,
0.0167065151,
0.0485436842,
0.0255868249,
-0.0864269212,
-0.048005268,
-0.0296303034,
-0.0247973651,
-0.0259144679,
0.055175066,
0.059654884,
0.0638776571,
0.0490783527,
-0.0418127999,
-0.0059395563,
-0.0141595509,
0.0384895876,
-0.0515582785,
-0.0184903573,
-0.0048208311,
0.0735651702,
0.0387670472,
0.031960208,
0.0438292176,
0.0010646008,
-0.009124334,
-0.0193418879,
0.0931934342,
0.0020834799,
-0.0118555631,
-0.0015800257,
-0.0500813536,
-0.0039473725,
-0.0344742872,
0.0628234148,
-0.0153451096,
-0.0425203443,
-0.0706133023,
0.0128635475,
-0.0696829706,
0.0475257896,
0.012881428,
-0.0209961664,
0.0120913219,
-0.0259550512,
0.0352127925,
-0.0004518514,
-0.0484578051,
0.0248543546,
-0.0692550316,
-0.0157551877,
-0.1035688594,
0.024576854,
0.0142430672,
0.0264720786,
-0.0474399589,
0.0420724787,
2.16727845e-34,
-0.0031176587,
-0.0160100963,
-0.0099551845,
0.0565502234,
0.0151895862,
0.0254384279,
0.08259321,
0.0302218087,
0.0120082013,
0.0012949742,
0.0060660127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15005v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15005v1 | Sentiment Analysis in the Era of Large Language Models: A Reality Check | 2023-05-24T10:45:25 | 2023-05-24T10:45:25 | Wenxuan Zhang, Yue Deng, Bing Liu, Sinno Jialin Pan, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis (SA) has been a long-standing research area in natural
language processing. It can offer rich insights into human sentiments and
opinions and has thus seen considerable interest from both academia and
industry. With the advent of large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT,
there is a great potential for their employment on SA problems. However, the
extent to which existing LLMs can be leveraged for different sentiment analysis
tasks remains unclear. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive investigation
into the capabilities of LLMs in performing various sentiment analysis tasks,
from conventional sentiment classification to aspect-based sentiment analysis
and multifaceted analysis of subjective texts. We evaluate performance across
13 tasks on 26 datasets and compare the results against small language models
(SLMs) trained on domain-specific datasets. Our study reveals that while LLMs
demonstrate satisfactory performance in simpler tasks, they lag behind in more
complex tasks requiring deeper understanding or structured sentiment
information. However, LLMs significantly outperform SLMs in few-shot learning
settings, suggesting their potential when annotation resources are limited. We
also highlight the limitations of current evaluation practices in assessing
LLMs' SA abilities and propose a novel benchmark, \textsc{SentiEval}, for a
more comprehensive and realistic evaluation. Data and code during our
investigations are available at
\url{https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/LLM-Sentiment}. | [
0.0196196642,
0.0635995865,
0.0183015298,
0.0556862131,
-0.053074751,
0.0319822542,
-0.0023789993,
0.0027944108,
0.0242906548,
-0.09293513,
-0.066852048,
-0.0304301698,
-0.0272519309,
-0.0018253763,
-0.0216839518,
0.0007787646,
0.0235786084,
0.0472752899,
0.0382230468,
-0.0017878959,
0.0220976528,
0.0204670466,
0.0063021258,
0.0342434719,
0.000219481,
-0.025925545,
0.0350108892,
0.0060334946,
0.0168750081,
-0.0238166433,
0.0348820947,
0.0341905951,
-0.0163737237,
0.0253744628,
0.0000019085,
-0.0038495157,
0.0079364963,
-0.0029764918,
0.0376465097,
0.0181348026,
0.1047645658,
-0.0241445433,
-0.0078331539,
0.0187422484,
-0.0418207571,
-0.0394762419,
0.0213387311,
0.0515612066,
0.0506416634,
0.0890018195,
-0.0198233649,
-0.0246394966,
-0.0267536808,
-0.0190339349,
-0.0220520962,
-0.0332162492,
0.0108684776,
-0.0054884772,
-0.0163116362,
0.0455873609,
0.0023124758,
0.0093099829,
-0.0262180455,
0.0042942017,
-0.012319847,
0.0009321083,
-0.0427009091,
0.0003107947,
0.0035192,
0.0316678025,
0.0142892925,
-0.0070170476,
-0.0267235003,
-0.0285351742,
-0.0239255056,
-0.0453933589,
0.0069060102,
-0.0071731363,
-0.0061198068,
0.0616260692,
0.0088001657,
0.0390343554,
0.0196061544,
0.0360655151,
0.0210642274,
0.0286646802,
-0.0299493261,
-0.0199682824,
0.0277412999,
0.0748776346,
-0.0037942179,
-0.0058977851,
-0.0156575814,
-0.0112681482,
0.0114739137,
0.0305919815,
0.002518995,
0.0146475472,
0.0215103831,
-0.0979090631,
0.0063145207,
0.0172015205,
-0.0126623726,
0.0619044974,
-0.0110619171,
-0.0107535869,
-0.0002853867,
0.0031196037,
-0.010139199,
-0.0060577281,
-0.0782055259,
0.0225851033,
0.0209272131,
0.0307470374,
-0.0120623242,
-0.001139645,
-0.0690116063,
0.0055668526,
0.0040853224,
0.0083253896,
0.0381580889,
-0.0227717068,
0.0331750996,
-0.0001267977,
-0.0375082344,
0.0534103103,
-0.0175935403,
0.0337490849,
-0.0405828618,
-0.0387797914,
0.0223938469,
0.0279189125,
-0.0231848657,
-0.0149010662,
0.0192647837,
0.0492298864,
0.0472958125,
-0.0607975125,
-0.0289749913,
-0.0097376397,
-0.0344253406,
-0.0879176706,
-0.0160483625,
-0.0569695607,
0.0186868105,
0.0116947666,
-0.0053229593,
0.0066445861,
0.0238194931,
0.0251975935,
-0.0311873462,
0.058135666,
-0.014757094,
-0.0159684382,
-0.0267769527,
0.0138456458,
0.005777291,
0.074175097,
-0.0235503875,
0.0435318537,
0.0271764956,
0.0085091582,
0.0056791306,
0.0060837013,
-0.0047429348,
-0.0035542196,
-0.0073034363,
-0.0046565775,
-0.0540234558,
-0.0351170041,
-0.0125795798,
0.0388875306,
-0.0105317989,
-0.0272190291,
0.0247068089,
0.0153731424,
-0.0066956128,
0.0435486287,
-0.0051616738,
0.0222388692,
0.0204800256,
-0.0451281667,
-0.028244637,
0.0096615488,
-0.0178175811,
-0.0327684917,
0.0370517671,
-0.0182239935,
-0.0275378544,
-0.0739576966,
-0.0423452891,
-0.0200893842,
0.0147404755,
-0.012048508,
0.0599844307,
-0.0235164147,
-0.0398816355,
-0.0024298902,
0.0603744052,
-0.050066106,
-0.0325696543,
-0.0390261486,
0.0282035954,
0.077783592,
0.0096982457,
-0.0296606887,
-0.0285697747,
-0.0191948954,
-0.0123489629,
0.0477930419,
0.0550609902,
0.0130144376,
0.0073467013,
-0.025282627,
0.0202884171,
-0.0152373621,
0.0258904602,
0.0091527058,
0.0100957751,
0.0257959794,
-0.0247432329,
-0.0263246465,
-0.0029304146,
-0.0095527843,
0.0178845618,
-0.0053718053,
0.0191883445,
0.0002678837,
0.0441289991,
0.0417108163,
-0.0298239309,
-0.0049115643,
0.0119693521,
-0.0361955017,
-0.0707014129,
0.0120821539,
-0.0043137525,
-0.0755300447,
0.0088825896,
0.0102600344,
-0.0166310463,
0.0178672299,
-0.0479159988,
0.011875445,
-0.0000185914,
-0.0048205201,
0.0191258211,
-0.0227857828,
-0.0209577512,
-0.013504846,
0.0138336299,
-0.0266261287,
0.0561254881,
-0.015969567,
0.0078471862,
-0.0446792617,
-0.027743239,
0.0460766964,
0.028859796,
-0.0633143708,
-0.0079609072,
0.0277068559,
0.0172514208,
0.0439235568,
0.0149066774,
-0.0124817202,
-0.052270975,
-0.1251422614,
-0.0010967093,
-0.0012974521,
0.0419190153,
0.0056010634,
-0.0079715149,
-0.0002368467,
0.0249102414,
-0.0404136777,
0.0122121787,
-0.007307515,
0.0248910915,
0.0423476212,
0.0078675188,
0.0289767291,
-0.0626762509,
0.0122228432,
-0.0162573885,
0.0145452488,
-0.0015327092,
-0.0295221023,
-0.0189220756,
0.0439335331,
-0.0472434573,
0.0028620949,
-0.0140107134,
-0.0499613434,
-0.0002470629,
-0.0248161703,
-0.0021330472,
0.0175990947,
-0.0088084787,
0.0537478477,
0.0084676538,
0.0170760341,
-0.0426737778,
0.0251437631,
-0.0492735766,
-0.0004344503,
-0.0352106169,
-0.0046664914,
-0.0219414309,
0.0711611286,
-0.0062821023,
-0.0014925756,
-0.0599568896,
0.0260861348,
-0.0257709306,
0.0056965491,
-0.0059570717,
0.0401041731,
0.0103180753,
-0.006613011,
0.0067954911,
-0.0146775749,
0.0478064492,
0.0089154281,
0.0100811822,
-0.0569602847,
-0.0171200726,
-0.0602839217,
0.0688043833,
-0.0270792898,
0.0043816692,
-0.015971167,
0.0497384034,
0.0097788181,
-0.0365940854,
-0.0233931858,
-0.0295046382,
0.0114285527,
0.0120980386,
0.0193809904,
0.0071196263,
-0.0435219146,
0.020882383,
-0.0492858402,
-0.0853227675,
-0.0193687752,
0.0125284148,
-0.0058348496,
0.0108582377,
-0.0112175262,
-0.0253156237,
-0.0472622514,
-0.0012965344,
-0.0224806648,
0.0281943511,
0.0138020525,
0.0120353363,
-0.0545688719,
0.0117556592,
0.0142151071,
0.0253156889,
0.064245604,
-0.0268633422,
0.0238000266,
-0.0252973698,
-0.041650556,
0.0110533182,
0.0127925379,
-0.0316485353,
-0.0676112995,
0.0843335837,
-0.0401502326,
0.0028239547,
0.1276388913,
0.0295410007,
-0.0553043224,
-0.0007639942,
0.0198531132,
0.000136812,
0.0279008541,
-0.0094801513,
-0.05021137,
-0.0504407808,
-0.0531044826,
0.0182053167,
-0.0146751627,
-0.0095402775,
-0.0068348967,
-0.1189694703,
0.0172063373,
-0.0280030686,
-0.0259936452,
-0.0222718548,
-0.0306875557,
-0.0013141226,
-0.0432636999,
-0.0057963491,
-0.0690323412,
0.0098801833,
-0.0013577371,
0.0163834337,
-0.0440793857,
-0.0232901871,
0.0668057054,
0.0097450232,
0.0450969152,
0.020627182,
0.0676245093,
-0.0000583226,
-0.0264036618,
0.0640998334,
0.0000301777,
-0.0024192717,
-0.0354744568,
0.0876315907,
-0.0444110595,
-0.0450343899,
0.0029126296,
-0.0310657173,
-0.0553863123,
0.0247738454,
-0.0146865714,
0.0401581563,
-0.0018861117,
-0.0138987154,
-0.0319349468,
0.0356340744,
0.0079190983,
0.0843866765,
-0.0128363986,
-0.072997123,
-0.0176988859,
0.0028943948,
-0.02329267,
-0.0315114371,
-0.067114532,
-0.0238571372,
0.0179600343,
-0.0122360252,
-0.0572888367,
-0.052304592,
0.001816994,
-0.0005074044,
-0.0576757416,
0.0075499802,
0.0060287151,
0.0214999411,
-0.0328602418,
0.0225647371,
-0.0149132675,
0.0299691912,
-0.0142766079,
-0.0116409939,
0.0823023543,
0.0037392518,
-0.030607678,
-0.0359061323,
-0.0999780893,
-0.0344049558,
-0.0288589019,
0.050623104,
0.0102673844,
-0.0025279475,
-0.0221313275,
-0.0103883129,
0.0034939933,
0.0679266751,
-0.0358864404,
0.0002796622,
0.0584500544,
0.0843047276,
0.0198361482,
0.0417146422,
-0.0233780537,
0.0549398102,
0.0313483998,
-0.0143537568,
0.0017129788,
-0.0236320514,
-0.0007273655,
0.0022490004,
0.0740386546,
0.0262801033,
-0.0145042539,
0.0098695587,
-0.017571412,
-0.0193225201,
-0.0308205374,
-0.0498511717,
-0.0339418463,
0.0038776603,
-0.008373634,
-0.0951951444,
0.0095851207,
-0.0335685499,
0.0527919717,
-0.005412044,
0.0479194112,
0.0277761128,
-0.0165401343,
0.0024716523,
0.0088520041,
-0.0332820788,
-0.0103532653,
0.0019953058,
-0.0153413322,
-0.013299007,
0.0421753228,
0.000493624,
0.0153003586,
0.0068541719,
0.0197416004,
-0.021268202,
-0.0075187306,
-0.0047103171,
0.0496674851,
0.005411597,
-0.0263935104,
0.0458053797,
-0.0425929949,
0.0005898628,
-0.022696916,
0.018977087,
-0.023829421,
-0.0040040659,
0.0371711105,
0.001248692,
-0.0387381315,
0.0024241433,
0.067595683,
-0.0585264377,
0.0498661175,
0.0536945052,
-0.0096019376,
-0.0484396443,
-0.0093356259,
0.0299079269,
-0.009568139,
0.0278177764,
0.0600008555,
-0.0836787149,
-0.0467323065,
0.029655287,
-0.0478064492,
0.0175113417,
0.003805361,
0.0032004744,
0.051799126,
0.011295055,
0.0710451454,
-0.0726450831,
-0.027259782,
-0.0318973511,
-0.0189827606,
0.0051584053,
-6.277680561e-33,
-0.0031428956,
0.0206653532,
-0.0224998519,
0.0405981876,
-0.0166051332,
0.0047531859,
-0.0194622166,
0.0556502454,
-0.010140649,
0.0381821655,
0.0094555924,
0.0238052178,
-0.0140686613,
0.0322173201,
0.0169642065,
-0.0312999114,
0.0269422624,
-0.0207534861,
-0.0050563407,
0.0224246122,
0.0397081561,
-0.004437753,
0.0501344167,
-0.1084266379,
0.0351351947,
-0.0015253245,
-0.0507206917,
0.0213774685,
0.0195115693,
0.0500498377,
-0.0330802724,
0.0774365291,
0.035707131,
-0.0268777721,
0.0303794481,
0.0148633597,
0.0080241272,
-0.0139245866,
-0.0103509407,
0.007885376,
-0.0108125536,
-0.0098522874,
0.0057163048,
0.0063477443,
-0.0345909037,
-0.001069665,
0.0067558726,
-0.0266317483,
0.0285326038,
-0.0731635392,
-0.0515390635,
0.0453039706,
0.0102756694,
-0.0264955666,
0.0201273654,
0.0379056707,
0.0116136782,
0.0754777268,
-0.0295764301,
0.0043749991,
-0.0443065092,
0.0117789926,
-0.0268334467,
-0.0423411876,
-0.0091468869,
0.0958390534,
0.0221225489,
0.0375382192,
-0.0211627819,
0.0401468091,
0.0112011572,
0.0093078893,
0.0328189917,
0.066363804,
0.0101990039,
-0.0097974176,
-0.046168901,
-0.0002356721,
0.072266832,
-0.0182921868,
0.0726468489,
0.0053974311,
-0.0497714579,
-0.0064905388,
0.0154030994,
-0.0342745595,
-0.0335913487,
-0.0169538222,
0.0135459267,
0.0045260307,
-0.004916769,
-0.035402108,
-0.0038860834,
-0.0726565942,
-0.0308989268,
0.0529963896,
-0.0583981611,
0.0264332239,
0.007038082,
-0.000032502,
-0.0761494488,
-0.007984166,
-0.0186376683,
0.0347721577,
0.0047969166,
-0.015494274,
0.0791134238,
0.0242598224,
-0.0998767167,
-0.0242833849,
-0.0288918819,
0.0272249393,
-0.0300624426,
0.072156176,
-0.0055212295,
0.0074690166,
-0.0139527526,
0.0817575753,
0.005263187,
0.0496606231,
0.0184388589,
-0.0143231666,
0.0126181561,
-0.0133825131,
-0.0171238817,
-0.0365689881,
0.0151614305,
-0.0306677874,
-0.0241516158,
-0.0468132235,
-0.0007057833,
-0.0241487287,
2.613e-7,
0.0739250109,
0.0801816359,
-0.0378926098,
0.0090721752,
0.0293173939,
0.0704404265,
-0.0147576099,
0.0152377477,
0.001853511,
-0.0000295164,
0.0123832701,
0.0351850912,
0.0370516255,
0.0281542577,
-0.0845131502,
0.0306566302,
-0.0177789051,
-0.0151924631,
0.0055220313,
0.0257113073,
0.0961842462,
0.1293087453,
0.0530747138,
-0.003488149,
-0.0203840379,
0.0092016635,
0.0739085227,
-0.0420222469,
-0.045955006,
0.0133441752,
-0.0148126464,
0.0408705622,
-0.0045609945,
-0.0482136309,
0.0081641302,
0.0136282323,
0.0102844555,
0.0796055645,
0.0264331233,
-0.0404300503,
0.0179695152,
0.0202706754,
0.0208008382,
0.0161631834,
0.0557223074,
-0.0678354874,
-0.0450501777,
-0.093957752,
0.0114084883,
0.0138198622,
0.0779103339,
0.0146704754,
-0.0387661755,
0.0190474391,
-0.0058427784,
-0.0623253435,
-0.0476610959,
-0.066234231,
-0.0059775393,
0.0117090996,
-0.0143010207,
-0.0407233723,
0.0244494434,
0.0689501464,
0.0240748525,
-0.0420370139,
0.0000182622,
2.051380906e-34,
0.0681874007,
-0.0422081389,
-0.009463083,
0.0123846969,
0.01657084,
0.0263053291,
-0.0218049865,
-0.0364149138,
0.0235190671,
-0.020110067,
0.049778901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15004v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15004v3 | LLMDet: A Third Party Large Language Models Generated Text Detection Tool | 2023-05-24T10:45:16 | 2023-11-03T14:31:09 | Kangxi Wu, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generated texts from large language models (LLMs) are remarkably close to
high-quality human-authored text, raising concerns about their potential misuse
in spreading false information and academic misconduct. Consequently, there is
an urgent need for a highly practical detection tool capable of accurately
identifying the source of a given text. However, existing detection tools
typically rely on access to LLMs and can only differentiate between
machine-generated and human-authored text, failing to meet the requirements of
fine-grained tracing, intermediary judgment, and rapid detection. Therefore, we
propose LLMDet, a model-specific, secure, efficient, and extendable detection
tool, that can source text from specific LLMs, such as GPT-2, OPT, LLaMA, and
others. In LLMDet, we record the next-token probabilities of salient n-grams as
features to calculate proxy perplexity for each LLM. By jointly analyzing the
proxy perplexities of LLMs, we can determine the source of the generated text.
Experimental results show that LLMDet yields impressive detection performance
while ensuring speed and security, achieving 98.54% precision and x5.0 faster
for recognizing human-authored text. Additionally, LLMDet can effortlessly
extend its detection capabilities to a new open-source model. We will provide
an open-source tool at https://github.com/TrustedLLM/LLMDet. | [
0.0659869164,
0.0648969486,
0.0090328828,
0.0829152167,
-0.0730589554,
-0.0052998592,
0.0186444242,
0.0265875384,
0.0255433656,
-0.0288045332,
-0.0130062876,
-0.0207265913,
-0.0138570871,
0.0391934291,
0.0536269248,
0.0542796776,
0.0390500426,
-0.0037148797,
0.0176036227,
-0.0082974993,
0.0171657782,
0.0247238465,
0.0337099396,
0.0170551762,
-0.0142969461,
-0.0291707311,
-0.0114922002,
0.0035641503,
0.0172757562,
-0.0094160819,
-0.0164580811,
0.0721908212,
-0.0425524078,
0.1089390144,
0.0000021091,
-0.0526548289,
-0.0505472384,
0.0057178703,
-0.0340224914,
0.06844531,
0.0817573741,
0.0206338074,
-0.080128856,
0.031643834,
-0.0327356346,
0.0278376378,
0.0117496746,
0.0593030564,
0.0472906753,
0.0904778913,
-0.0185945313,
0.0040604132,
0.0552284345,
-0.0061366716,
0.0067760432,
-0.0174098015,
0.0358023942,
-0.0275641307,
-0.014206253,
0.0623133183,
0.0474884175,
0.0099729868,
-0.0017778833,
-0.051569324,
-0.0285353102,
-0.0017347314,
-0.0078552878,
-0.0206437148,
-0.0138909314,
0.0170670506,
-0.0411515124,
-0.0494182371,
0.0372660011,
-0.0118136397,
0.0243631247,
0.04328648,
0.014880361,
0.0697101429,
-0.0468235314,
0.0181406904,
0.034217611,
-0.0238751732,
0.0129083227,
0.0200918783,
-0.0018790156,
0.0383079834,
0.0182363,
-0.0248745475,
-0.0384407826,
-0.0335957594,
0.0148957837,
-0.0615025312,
0.0387390368,
-0.0115647661,
0.0468589999,
-0.0006867981,
-0.0594770946,
-0.0856262669,
0.0538468063,
-0.0582894124,
0.0186002422,
0.0108799282,
-0.0301666632,
0.0343302079,
-0.0665018857,
0.0354552418,
-0.0690505132,
0.0419390313,
0.0241163429,
0.0112489723,
0.0143673886,
-0.0069105392,
-0.011963591,
0.0095930565,
-0.0063237334,
-0.0013647729,
-0.0487178974,
0.0249795597,
0.0216152091,
0.022104973,
-0.0047752657,
-0.0294787586,
0.0034758602,
-0.0035930234,
0.0236242693,
0.0002283346,
-0.0025239727,
0.0027699419,
-0.0193285923,
-0.0561314933,
-0.0135280471,
0.0626910254,
0.0166163277,
-0.0033837517,
-0.0151391421,
0.0830709711,
0.0081297364,
-0.0265460424,
-0.0347887985,
-0.085798189,
-0.0126673933,
-0.036961142,
-0.0239668544,
-0.0589489862,
-0.056581486,
-0.0007617516,
-0.0172495842,
-0.0476131588,
0.0111870207,
0.0251473784,
-0.0183663946,
0.0096475333,
-0.0323377922,
-0.0081001315,
0.0075519127,
0.0063876878,
-0.013741225,
0.031500753,
0.0031320823,
0.0934507102,
0.0652604774,
-0.0148106152,
0.0243913401,
0.0740767121,
0.0349348038,
0.0086246291,
-0.0008296753,
-0.0293161422,
0.0554064773,
-0.0420684218,
0.0215295758,
0.0654537752,
-0.0041520041,
-0.0327831358,
0.067792058,
0.0720071644,
-0.0213369559,
0.0176719781,
-0.0037374403,
0.0500706583,
0.011330924,
0.0098089902,
-0.0213067122,
-0.0080023883,
-0.04147451,
-0.0540207438,
0.0415901802,
0.0429093428,
0.0371369645,
0.0200657155,
-0.0085104126,
-0.030072866,
0.0074823145,
-0.0369938686,
0.0328299887,
-0.00552066,
-0.038881205,
0.0152619192,
-0.0003847677,
-0.0686686859,
-0.0058820872,
-0.0913997367,
0.0601326413,
0.0488020927,
0.0599868633,
0.0081669083,
0.058491312,
-0.015340006,
-0.0136921871,
0.043114718,
-0.0337747671,
0.0127834044,
-0.0159669314,
-0.0297003668,
-0.0248134248,
0.00024332,
0.0226195231,
0.0157002173,
0.0562916286,
0.0278281048,
0.0262953434,
-0.0118696978,
-0.0145505657,
0.0086158747,
-0.0192317516,
0.0013762907,
-0.0022070133,
-0.0093380362,
0.0227792691,
0.0205585789,
-0.0224353205,
0.0455905683,
0.0331384093,
-0.0175289959,
-0.0094131464,
-0.0408270918,
0.0361055396,
0.0523784347,
0.0435211286,
-0.0195935015,
0.0092135286,
0.0157259312,
-0.0086245807,
-0.003208295,
0.0329234637,
-0.0203598123,
0.0206705444,
-0.0821946487,
0.0139916362,
-0.0336043015,
0.0448437408,
-0.0059661521,
0.0578797832,
-0.0151989767,
0.0101947077,
0.0019242369,
-0.0210853312,
0.0624292046,
0.0133829387,
0.0166792236,
-0.017502239,
-0.0369239934,
0.0033788108,
0.0176317636,
0.012760222,
-0.0135104693,
-0.0660788789,
-0.0335178897,
-0.0023243933,
-0.0173408482,
0.0392601565,
0.0466008447,
-0.0136651285,
-0.0281406008,
0.003437415,
-0.0276943035,
-0.0443509258,
0.0262969341,
-0.0081596281,
0.0286053345,
-0.0310546756,
0.0056527457,
-0.0139812138,
0.0209492426,
-0.0023741454,
0.0293071307,
0.0337621756,
-0.0454955623,
-0.071972549,
0.054959815,
0.0007539327,
-0.0219235551,
-0.0178171284,
-0.0369663872,
-0.0053659002,
-0.0364276543,
-0.0032452564,
0.0532965809,
0.043586757,
0.0217822846,
0.0194310453,
0.0200478584,
-0.0144335777,
-0.0548468977,
0.0053935344,
0.0158588272,
-0.0245889053,
-0.0349135287,
0.0179912038,
0.0044026501,
0.0366679989,
-0.0212605689,
-0.0069161681,
0.0339860246,
0.0070613665,
-0.0117353927,
0.0377052166,
-0.0347456746,
-0.0290629938,
0.0148550766,
-0.0110437516,
-0.068534784,
0.0091136843,
-0.0655351579,
0.035384655,
-0.0352994725,
-0.0337380469,
-0.0139570525,
0.0037941327,
-0.0332433134,
0.0435911901,
-0.0105414269,
-0.0266901329,
-0.0005182138,
0.0120375408,
0.0697973073,
-0.0348395556,
-0.0135683026,
-0.007595106,
0.0049172635,
-0.0210813601,
0.0163213927,
-0.0399627052,
-0.0721582249,
-0.0239213649,
-0.0313558169,
0.0450360328,
-0.0623167679,
-0.0123599218,
-0.0045857741,
0.0365512818,
0.0337946415,
-0.0468304865,
0.0245070029,
-0.0126889525,
0.0385409668,
0.0046939603,
-0.081343241,
0.0404343121,
-0.0374288484,
0.0172436573,
0.117332764,
-0.0123119596,
-0.0045982376,
0.0134452814,
-0.0249716844,
-0.0040419628,
0.0067909309,
-0.0055274698,
0.0123125259,
0.0257869549,
-0.041294165,
0.0280905385,
0.1013531908,
0.0099875499,
-0.0590542927,
-0.0303290505,
-0.0360458791,
-0.0106526697,
0.0015211651,
-0.0127199125,
-0.0949502066,
-0.0036154168,
0.0245163329,
0.0032834669,
-0.0519044623,
-0.0210623145,
-0.0144017432,
-0.0739028528,
0.0676626563,
0.0299112238,
-0.0191980992,
0.0006896583,
-0.0498352051,
-0.0245301127,
0.0585871525,
-0.038193617,
-0.0403386578,
0.0057248836,
0.0035094833,
-0.0205351561,
0.0012131266,
-0.0146085089,
-0.0066208779,
-0.0405676067,
-0.00227138,
0.0508118421,
0.0133512318,
-0.0074354168,
-0.0395710506,
0.050250601,
-0.0175155252,
-0.0367794596,
0.0022234323,
0.0457557552,
0.0048141307,
-0.0251955893,
-0.0427753553,
0.0674414262,
-0.0039935019,
-0.014008427,
0.0160460323,
0.0817499459,
0.0043104412,
-0.0138516417,
-0.014988184,
-0.0190578923,
0.0320238546,
0.0451796986,
0.0162491761,
-0.0360752605,
-0.0363597386,
-0.0462699383,
0.0319623053,
-0.0145675456,
-0.0276646763,
0.0013520727,
-0.0042693354,
-0.0529263057,
-0.0547377877,
0.0411495604,
-0.0303276815,
0.0112841288,
0.0237604287,
0.0383285433,
0.0204370748,
-0.0313333198,
-0.0520196855,
-0.0269680396,
-0.061110843,
0.0504269861,
-0.0910696462,
0.0229340959,
0.0051831161,
-0.0121877734,
-0.0070905732,
0.0208013169,
-0.0752500817,
-0.0471393876,
-0.0250114761,
-0.0146911182,
0.0227613188,
-0.0186092053,
-0.0447118282,
-0.0429799892,
0.0555265993,
0.0254633818,
-0.041873727,
0.0158808604,
0.0261767861,
-0.0445636809,
-0.0220310502,
0.0060081193,
-0.0338515267,
0.0073420699,
0.0379478596,
-0.0611444451,
-0.0219042189,
-0.0324008949,
0.0125703271,
0.0667766631,
0.0316102877,
-0.0117031252,
0.0578968935,
-0.0355918743,
-0.0079607265,
-0.0441789143,
-0.0012226894,
-0.0336870663,
0.0363982804,
0.0485839359,
-0.0414884835,
0.0226522889,
-0.00644481,
-0.016311042,
0.024163682,
-0.003369119,
0.0175159462,
-0.051912453,
0.0608787835,
0.039675843,
-0.0170928054,
0.0053848326,
0.0235624034,
-0.0015137594,
0.0418607518,
-0.0305211674,
0.0304146316,
-0.0026758588,
-0.0212721601,
0.0295907613,
0.0454220511,
-0.0634978414,
-0.0140155144,
-0.0427608341,
0.0316095054,
0.0489211455,
0.0326123573,
0.0419585109,
-0.040857099,
-0.0054944148,
-0.044595357,
0.0287477057,
-0.0030239872,
-0.0319494456,
-0.036111366,
-0.0133475224,
-0.0307978541,
0.0542062297,
0.0730501413,
0.0346290134,
0.0316822529,
0.0129858088,
-0.0647858977,
-0.0315264612,
-0.0315701179,
0.0044383965,
0.0064125615,
-0.027255008,
0.0083148582,
-0.0456012525,
-0.0460785031,
0.0186447278,
-0.0019173536,
-0.0187383592,
0.0094139418,
-0.0410689786,
0.0581356399,
-0.0318988785,
0.0058085737,
-0.0740940794,
0.0306232888,
0.0055453177,
-0.0472907238,
0.0220229775,
-5.827237003e-33,
0.0190567598,
-0.081608884,
-0.0574453585,
0.0009709999,
0.0225188266,
0.0272891074,
-0.0080019217,
-0.0206325836,
-0.0121982554,
0.0060555977,
-0.0130740246,
0.0366049409,
0.0065835416,
-0.0029518988,
-0.0225378238,
0.012285741,
0.0066239629,
-0.0031668996,
-0.015123005,
0.0455594882,
0.0679636374,
-0.0006518173,
0.0385361277,
-0.0916678011,
0.0168488882,
-0.0328273326,
-0.0447694659,
-0.0089651225,
-0.0448778421,
0.0549829081,
-0.0122091332,
-0.0011148781,
0.0041498519,
-0.0258608572,
-0.0062635392,
0.0236251187,
0.0109918835,
-0.0040366761,
0.0044406778,
-0.009528555,
0.0365295075,
-0.096922338,
0.0187670588,
-0.0212269947,
-0.0244540013,
0.0263863765,
0.0119794244,
-0.0168880429,
-0.020813087,
-0.0133841662,
-0.0243661776,
0.0393436849,
0.0067569311,
0.0463155918,
0.0337273106,
0.0090305386,
0.0283609908,
0.0142285172,
-0.0278615672,
0.0515171736,
0.0045322198,
0.0008578768,
0.0045192298,
-0.0034823921,
-0.0206049439,
0.0451514758,
0.0376076996,
-0.026922714,
-0.0031894823,
-0.014293083,
-0.009634587,
0.037920814,
0.0674919635,
0.0954503715,
0.0131566003,
-0.046053987,
-0.0657907054,
0.0369008444,
0.0024521421,
-0.000538334,
0.0432549007,
-0.0355383717,
-0.0418859199,
-0.0049034324,
-0.000004301,
-0.0605532452,
-0.0354220867,
-0.015158141,
0.0125141405,
0.0125647951,
-0.0439192317,
-0.0287145283,
0.0123191969,
-0.0665013418,
-0.0211488493,
0.0558290295,
-0.0384940878,
0.004745387,
-0.0109746996,
0.0370776094,
-0.0113771409,
0.0104747033,
0.0198594481,
-0.0529259034,
0.0095523251,
0.0011702101,
0.0156098902,
0.0026618147,
-0.0812928751,
0.0156112667,
-0.0149022546,
0.0399347916,
0.0243475102,
0.0060502663,
-0.0086926706,
-0.0400816053,
0.0218088422,
0.006806849,
0.0254952107,
0.024796946,
-0.0137944706,
-0.0000409245,
-0.0046504098,
0.0327833705,
-0.0099552935,
0.0165715218,
-0.0333290771,
0.0487060249,
0.0429371931,
-0.0351152308,
0.015204032,
-0.0060079759,
2.881e-7,
0.0348938704,
0.0294778459,
0.047886923,
-0.0139529137,
0.0421306416,
0.0538736284,
0.0057583875,
0.037840385,
-0.0488707051,
-0.0092447819,
-0.0408052877,
-0.0104619209,
0.0693861693,
0.0168075431,
-0.078782998,
0.0494872481,
-0.0631490052,
-0.0062989532,
-0.0803917572,
0.0186214335,
0.0343378335,
0.0683424324,
0.0202868599,
-0.0239914078,
-0.0077426401,
-0.0962257907,
0.0172209535,
-0.0007993612,
-0.0155839873,
-0.0021477758,
0.0445901826,
-0.0004595057,
0.0194446072,
0.0200270955,
-0.0143099315,
0.0030777124,
-0.0070111779,
0.0787343532,
0.0359589159,
0.020040771,
-0.0114465002,
-0.0664960071,
0.0178134739,
-0.0494680405,
0.0555733442,
0.0935646221,
-0.0078837918,
-0.0528166182,
-0.0164642911,
-0.0717534944,
0.018464461,
-0.0280026682,
-0.0057399082,
0.0270148646,
-0.0012971093,
0.0073184459,
0.0039341412,
-0.0555798002,
-0.0368982926,
-0.0545365624,
-0.0402897894,
-0.0343057103,
-0.0433576517,
0.0167003572,
0.0672433004,
-0.016641574,
0.0624170676,
2.988967138e-34,
0.028011078,
-0.0458912216,
-0.0095239114,
0.0511181615,
0.0526362322,
0.0093365368,
-0.0016631621,
0.0191634949,
-0.0074294293,
-0.0507389046,
0.0117900865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15002v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15002v2 | A RelEntLess Benchmark for Modelling Graded Relations between Named Entities | 2023-05-24T10:41:24 | 2024-01-31T03:56:22 | Asahi Ushio, Jose Camacho Collados, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Relations such as "is influenced by", "is known for" or "is a competitor of"
are inherently graded: we can rank entity pairs based on how well they satisfy
these relations, but it is hard to draw a line between those pairs that satisfy
them and those that do not. Such graded relations play a central role in many
applications, yet they are typically not covered by existing Knowledge Graphs.
In this paper, we consider the possibility of using Large Language Models
(LLMs) to fill this gap. To this end, we introduce a new benchmark, in which
entity pairs have to be ranked according to how much they satisfy a given
graded relation. The task is formulated as a few-shot ranking problem, where
models only have access to a description of the relation and five prototypical
instances. We use the proposed benchmark to evaluate state-of-the-art relation
embedding strategies as well as several recent LLMs, covering both publicly
available LLMs and closed models such as GPT-4. Overall, we find a strong
correlation between model size and performance, with smaller Language Models
struggling to outperform a naive baseline. The results of the largest Flan-T5
and OPT models are remarkably strong, although a clear gap with human
performance remains. | [
0.0634023696,
0.0639668703,
-0.0035579433,
0.0901535749,
0.0077961083,
0.0099263722,
-0.0073959492,
0.0071067405,
0.0324544534,
-0.0638562515,
-0.0094624339,
-0.0170843769,
0.0011350792,
-0.0111276787,
0.0314755738,
-0.0525058098,
0.0059782397,
0.0223205741,
0.0006457023,
-0.0136791933,
-0.01373656,
0.0211293548,
0.0261563007,
0.0181171484,
0.005027229,
0.0015224335,
0.035346169,
0.0005999407,
0.0560880862,
-0.0419121422,
-0.00452419,
0.0446229167,
0.0123306913,
0.0319276489,
0.0000020308,
-0.0329499245,
-0.010945756,
0.0107380962,
-0.002814448,
0.0180638377,
-0.0109483087,
-0.025124602,
0.0216720849,
0.0101011535,
-0.0245443285,
-0.0851036459,
0.0140285864,
0.0183667969,
0.0349411927,
0.0530701876,
-0.012656128,
-0.0714869872,
0.0260729194,
-0.0593872257,
-0.0194237996,
-0.0623162836,
0.0420534238,
0.0095417704,
-0.0065269251,
0.0454579107,
-0.0221292358,
0.0219426379,
0.0148432665,
0.0121282516,
0.0608581789,
0.0482890345,
-0.0262652002,
0.0332660191,
0.0289026443,
0.1187946647,
-0.0147939213,
0.0153407548,
-0.0007536825,
-0.0224542115,
-0.0105078006,
0.0236791968,
-0.000173019,
0.0004111399,
-0.013729292,
0.0382481813,
0.0272046886,
0.00255648,
0.06210519,
0.0204665232,
-0.0165316947,
0.0531366989,
0.0304818396,
-0.0440324061,
0.0112283397,
-0.0128754107,
-0.0409815013,
-0.0378176495,
0.0121705104,
0.0005387046,
-0.0154832117,
0.0376316644,
0.0055512628,
0.0299253259,
0.0014258123,
-0.0623912774,
-0.0109458612,
-0.0067381738,
0.0603365339,
0.0689440966,
-0.0383891538,
0.0514186248,
0.0022659253,
-0.0085535683,
-0.0213317834,
0.0006239436,
-0.0650628284,
-0.0010495934,
-0.0067104362,
0.0421341769,
0.0061679138,
0.0034954657,
-0.0413996913,
-0.0076665524,
-0.031587854,
0.0598627664,
0.0416860804,
0.0227747392,
0.0310889501,
0.0084030218,
-0.0726420581,
0.0088223889,
-0.046461504,
-0.0028707616,
-0.0479860902,
0.0196013972,
0.0286433641,
-0.0455073193,
-0.006420861,
-0.0551663153,
0.0115953097,
0.050578855,
0.0629498884,
-0.0605383255,
0.0377700329,
0.0123236077,
0.004222645,
-0.0689298511,
-0.0129908165,
-0.035791669,
0.0414685383,
0.0351777412,
-0.0001515724,
-0.0242006518,
0.0426975079,
-0.0068249186,
-0.0944723636,
0.0626717433,
0.0095732799,
0.000230593,
-0.0226567388,
0.0367958993,
0.0144208986,
0.0288516264,
0.0152837448,
-0.0121164974,
0.0356507227,
0.0040211948,
-0.0212723501,
0.0122481724,
0.0143068098,
-0.0085507967,
0.0139538329,
0.0218416527,
-0.0057416372,
0.066336751,
0.0303786453,
0.0584623367,
-0.0105219176,
-0.0798949003,
0.054858204,
0.0219541863,
0.0065417034,
0.0278859418,
0.0312259905,
0.0038323174,
0.019088421,
-0.0027949472,
-0.0545516126,
-0.0042203125,
-0.0165613983,
-0.0247967858,
0.007608789,
0.0244925674,
-0.0363959521,
-0.0018770505,
-0.0055152588,
-0.0038656383,
-0.0139902094,
0.0005275792,
0.0505170636,
-0.034494672,
-0.0347820893,
0.0327776149,
0.0384055227,
-0.0302614048,
-0.007184369,
-0.0177610349,
-0.0122337975,
0.1157569811,
0.0857944936,
-0.0423897617,
-0.022180289,
0.0082102465,
-0.0718610957,
0.0136467787,
0.0323921442,
-0.0263861772,
0.0212095343,
-0.0079599014,
-0.0276739784,
-0.0024384232,
0.0054263282,
0.0394846834,
0.0231874287,
0.0295986719,
0.0153337736,
-0.0428057499,
0.008473454,
0.0164559279,
-0.0157457199,
0.0009060541,
0.0298698936,
0.0068740305,
0.0081945537,
0.0500255525,
0.006603491,
-0.0024852885,
0.0260028765,
-0.0543750525,
-0.0326590799,
-0.0484749861,
-0.0181582496,
-0.0333689153,
0.0385820866,
-0.0253504496,
-0.0183039717,
0.0231051426,
-0.0360040367,
-0.0218142644,
-0.0071557406,
0.0256418046,
0.079864949,
-0.0016375829,
0.0042132805,
0.0102648335,
-0.0169223286,
-0.033651296,
0.1040176675,
-0.0225371327,
0.0444794595,
0.0063897334,
-0.0281106867,
-0.0054682926,
-0.0005544072,
-0.0738483146,
0.0163805615,
0.0240904987,
-0.0095770014,
0.0031482661,
-0.0257626213,
-0.0235504098,
-0.0371954553,
-0.0841531828,
0.0008502697,
0.0202240497,
-0.0006172601,
-0.0173282754,
-0.0033214106,
0.0153895784,
0.0303943995,
-0.0353254043,
-0.0003581806,
-0.0244392231,
0.0249096863,
0.017690381,
0.0175422281,
-0.0355659649,
-0.052850619,
-0.0406273082,
-0.0242181923,
0.0724939182,
-0.0009062253,
-0.0042287707,
-0.0101118181,
0.0744960606,
-0.0929563195,
-0.0068948935,
-0.0232143328,
0.0016408396,
-0.0162909329,
0.0143049425,
0.0544477329,
0.0211779214,
-0.0184780527,
0.0435784534,
0.0470423028,
-0.0204656757,
-0.0411624089,
-0.0035802848,
-0.0239808261,
0.0326377228,
-0.0071057887,
-0.0265877713,
-0.0605611354,
0.0432117693,
-0.0014804883,
-0.024952583,
-0.0568042248,
0.0600543544,
-0.013261321,
0.0172848329,
-0.0327231474,
0.0041825683,
0.0230765902,
-0.0098419702,
-0.0266190823,
-0.0142556187,
0.044901859,
0.00521664,
0.0359126441,
0.0380906947,
0.008039102,
-0.0556645207,
0.0777272508,
0.0377176143,
0.0072853649,
-0.0214403179,
-0.0075716092,
-0.0438340977,
0.0238992088,
0.0341196731,
-0.0445956402,
0.0178665631,
-0.0034110353,
0.0162567012,
-0.0055001341,
-0.0587786175,
-0.033842314,
-0.0310530793,
-0.0473182686,
0.0237830654,
0.0411506444,
-0.0253131334,
0.0270745773,
0.0349225476,
-0.0146042882,
-0.0260038245,
0.0036849382,
-0.0185435098,
-0.0117492359,
0.0487642139,
0.0513810888,
-0.0433999263,
0.0342649221,
0.0140261576,
0.0233404562,
0.0034133005,
0.0218770225,
-0.0166669022,
-0.0106705036,
-0.0151024628,
-0.0143792685,
-0.0322967917,
-0.0608813278,
-0.0058579925,
-0.0257036071,
-0.033182513,
0.0104738129,
0.133304432,
0.0401501879,
-0.0440819599,
0.0096549643,
0.0249169786,
0.0047004358,
0.047709316,
0.0118209282,
-0.1074381769,
0.0094310977,
-0.0088007031,
-0.0253869481,
0.0321685076,
-0.0885303766,
-0.0162648335,
-0.1185032353,
0.0022675889,
-0.0058636293,
0.0044504162,
-0.0141303809,
-0.063249588,
-0.0041884808,
-0.0254185721,
-0.0358044766,
-0.0319587216,
-0.0035189681,
0.0139419781,
-0.0225696415,
-0.0161418505,
-0.0610295422,
0.0692453906,
-0.0567763299,
0.0612142012,
0.0150010958,
0.0622273274,
-0.0166311599,
-0.0281995013,
-0.0234206673,
-0.0117153479,
-0.0502486639,
-0.0097736809,
0.0563407093,
-0.0408420861,
-0.0163887721,
-0.0537544079,
-0.0378385857,
-0.0250131134,
0.0274624079,
-0.0200864747,
0.0934965014,
0.0337023549,
-0.0425062105,
-0.0053679356,
-0.0296273902,
-0.0135296686,
0.104594402,
0.0100759557,
-0.0249171369,
-0.006099436,
-0.0308583472,
0.0421594754,
0.0118926438,
-0.0552927405,
-0.0121035436,
0.0249941498,
-0.0122456588,
-0.0597431399,
-0.0473613255,
0.0445576645,
-0.0010796543,
0.0107475817,
0.044345066,
0.0555247515,
-0.0117844911,
-0.0502611846,
-0.0154410768,
0.0002199088,
0.0195554718,
-0.0351255611,
-0.0143271787,
0.0527361184,
0.0075657484,
-0.0484636724,
-0.0430728644,
-0.0715598688,
-0.0389153361,
-0.0176788624,
0.0622536801,
0.0156479366,
-0.0011487352,
-0.0369219258,
-0.0315731242,
0.0325613916,
0.0445518829,
-0.0392179191,
-0.0088648479,
0.0200454593,
-0.0081498101,
0.0039164415,
0.0616279244,
-0.0622372143,
0.0190671459,
0.0191507395,
0.0543774776,
-0.0496388562,
-0.0662832633,
0.0156414229,
-0.0064159948,
0.0161386207,
-0.0103615224,
-0.0317886993,
-0.0528090708,
0.0099650268,
-0.0909536332,
-0.0211567804,
-0.0429678448,
0.0002263732,
0.0452053286,
0.0235619787,
-0.0393447205,
-0.0391707607,
0.0185089745,
0.0567688942,
-0.02765356,
-0.0172945317,
0.0126979984,
-0.0184609927,
0.0269953571,
-0.0135081951,
-0.0184829943,
-0.0033666831,
0.009184178,
0.0236133635,
-0.0418114625,
0.0259419959,
-0.0027494866,
-0.0014953776,
-0.0146884797,
0.0297167059,
-0.0234918427,
-0.0149447294,
-0.0051308377,
-0.0098668253,
0.0782798678,
0.0064933444,
0.051904127,
0.0002570537,
-0.0198678095,
-0.0000906702,
0.0155892558,
-0.0221808441,
-0.0333488956,
0.0469551906,
0.0439350456,
-0.0100757973,
0.0622786433,
0.0820054859,
0.0354579948,
0.047133524,
0.0283672176,
-0.0331044197,
-0.029753916,
-0.0354501568,
0.0075336243,
0.0279647168,
-0.0101079457,
0.0463198498,
-0.0876593068,
-0.0772167444,
-0.0210419074,
-0.0277628284,
-0.0408062227,
-0.0015445657,
0.0171813685,
-0.0097646406,
0.0234167278,
-0.0139428321,
-0.0366666541,
-0.0150262676,
-0.0536727943,
-0.0522923693,
0.0045119398,
-6.384044432e-33,
-0.0495416969,
-0.0281385407,
-0.0040587415,
0.0194941312,
-0.0275246967,
0.0448346324,
-0.0145598864,
-0.0025988256,
-0.0433159135,
0.0181762539,
-0.0200425144,
-0.002384214,
-0.0109904502,
-0.0045836726,
0.0031074567,
-0.0293226987,
0.0029300002,
-0.0015097638,
0.0137508838,
0.0456515178,
0.0246022753,
0.0281955246,
0.0406198651,
-0.0823263004,
0.0236793775,
-0.003572145,
-0.0141179692,
0.0144204395,
-0.0197739769,
0.0526157767,
-0.0439487137,
0.0275407117,
0.0401930846,
-0.021228034,
0.0139592933,
-0.0185977127,
-0.0927733034,
-0.0071057724,
-0.0037698303,
-0.0186265092,
-0.0083942274,
-0.0025448643,
0.0214987881,
0.0367354117,
0.0462475345,
-0.0362448283,
0.0533745885,
-0.0299191941,
-0.0200305022,
-0.0557939932,
-0.0143342884,
0.0278255735,
0.0033801156,
0.0281105042,
0.0362048186,
-0.0029677162,
0.0157553367,
0.0295531582,
-0.0462606028,
-0.0073699201,
-0.0070488262,
0.0347832255,
0.011978264,
-0.0188133772,
0.0015417982,
0.0831204429,
-0.0112792719,
0.0028498988,
-0.0133137703,
-0.0016299691,
0.0045214188,
0.0589151494,
0.0160170104,
0.0230507031,
0.0098428195,
0.0062319469,
-0.074529171,
-0.0035822173,
0.039121747,
-0.01113341,
0.0081542032,
0.0069245459,
-0.061957866,
-0.0475152545,
-0.0236251708,
-0.0253662188,
-0.0556265526,
-0.0365721509,
0.0267308913,
-0.0028964614,
-0.0085751945,
-0.0168815702,
0.004802044,
-0.0679212362,
-0.0801766366,
0.0643698424,
0.0028336125,
0.0193516258,
0.0241307039,
0.0391657092,
-0.0880428776,
-0.0108690728,
-0.0020283419,
-0.0175746214,
0.0233566426,
0.0273414943,
0.0314767174,
-0.013680662,
-0.0582215376,
-0.0169681888,
-0.0302925799,
-0.0474346615,
-0.0321904086,
0.0087446654,
-0.0022950878,
0.019144088,
0.0052132504,
0.0522770248,
0.0600067899,
0.0125128431,
-0.0101063261,
0.0135351978,
0.0321705975,
0.0156609975,
0.0162892863,
-0.001894039,
-0.0043073376,
0.0216808729,
0.0360945612,
-0.0329012759,
-0.0496739373,
-0.0252705589,
2.758e-7,
0.0390161164,
0.0572427176,
-0.008473021,
0.0442564525,
0.0239088945,
0.0321843438,
0.0187611021,
0.0592268035,
0.0022931299,
0.0024206117,
0.0270332377,
0.0029511871,
-0.0010203458,
0.0388852209,
-0.056093704,
0.0296510849,
-0.06491106,
-0.0404137485,
-0.0437805951,
-0.0554360524,
0.0579318367,
0.0996823087,
0.06907738,
0.0302329119,
-0.0388324596,
-0.0091773104,
0.0659460574,
-0.048944436,
-0.0138037028,
0.0039003685,
0.0001977153,
0.0456379503,
-0.0164215658,
0.051837489,
-0.0001401162,
0.0481703505,
0.0584145598,
0.0373493433,
-0.0020446051,
0.0020598911,
-0.0041560452,
-0.0467439741,
0.0054145623,
-0.0644055605,
0.0803146884,
-0.0268340334,
-0.0190787949,
0.042292539,
-0.0256250259,
-0.015602503,
0.0129863955,
-0.0002760605,
-0.0108959721,
-0.0054555782,
-0.0038422546,
-0.0323131308,
0.0102833873,
-0.0781998932,
0.0078568365,
0.0357637927,
-0.0131598534,
-0.0446465649,
-0.0049304669,
-0.003133184,
0.0054807495,
-0.0343897231,
0.0199528337,
2.801910401e-34,
0.0124413902,
0.0165945236,
0.0113783414,
-0.0172850583,
0.0590841472,
-0.0126846228,
-0.0678036734,
-0.0163674243,
0.030452108,
-0.0871989727,
0.0087798126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14999v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14999v2 | The Art of SOCRATIC QUESTIONING: Recursive Thinking with Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T10:36:14 | 2023-11-02T02:40:48 | Jingyuan Qi, Zhiyang Xu, Ying Shen, Minqian Liu, Di Jin, Qifan Wang, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting enables large language models to solve
complex reasoning problems by generating intermediate steps. However, confined
by its inherent single-pass and sequential generation process, CoT heavily
relies on the initial decisions, causing errors in early steps to accumulate
and impact the final answers. In contrast, humans adopt recursive thinking when
tackling complex reasoning problems, i.e., iteratively breaking the original
problem into approachable sub-problems and aggregating their answers to resolve
the original one. Inspired by the human cognitive process, we propose SOCRATIC
QUESTIONING, a divide-and-conquer style algorithm that mimics the recursive
thinking process. Specifically, SOCRATIC QUESTIONING leverages large language
models to raise and answer sub-questions until collecting enough information to
tackle the original question. Unlike CoT, SOCRATIC QUESTIONING explicitly
navigates the thinking space, stimulates effective recursive thinking, and is
more robust towards errors in the thinking process. Extensive experiments on
several complex reasoning tasks, including MMLU, MATH, LogiQA, and visual
question-answering demonstrate significant performance improvements over the
state-of-the-art prompting methods, such as CoT, and Tree-of-Thought. The
qualitative analysis clearly shows that the intermediate reasoning steps
elicited by SOCRATIC QUESTIONING are similar to humans' recursively thinking
process of complex reasoning problems. | [
0.0477234833,
0.0195781291,
-0.0120769804,
0.0248481669,
-0.0411216058,
0.030748181,
-0.0008755329,
0.0025200178,
0.0217310172,
-0.0154309794,
0.0277991798,
-0.0389437601,
0.0069607757,
-0.0155118695,
0.0123269875,
-0.0403035991,
0.0153626511,
-0.0631780848,
0.0352677479,
-0.0221195631,
-0.0336222276,
-0.0116348071,
-0.0264054425,
-0.0097336238,
-0.0197882261,
-0.049454499,
-0.0382684357,
0.0038360339,
-0.004285363,
-0.048710037,
-0.0327454209,
0.0440427549,
0.0131594371,
0.066887103,
0.0000023369,
-0.0655728951,
-0.0157441609,
-0.0189177804,
-0.0526141599,
-0.0378129445,
-0.0320510231,
0.0517294407,
0.03316148,
0.0476164035,
-0.0444570594,
0.0238983128,
0.0032010966,
0.0719654188,
0.0613058247,
0.041446764,
0.0131394155,
-0.0732445344,
0.010196628,
0.0132318987,
0.0129821142,
-0.0589117222,
0.0019189344,
0.0452229492,
0.0209666006,
0.0237726755,
-0.0308949016,
0.0199410617,
0.0534347408,
-0.0145887015,
-0.035390012,
0.0032864111,
0.0033155177,
-0.0211252514,
-0.0091031138,
0.0507822782,
0.0092919394,
-0.0108644525,
-0.0212528557,
0.0248365421,
0.0314003341,
0.0189042818,
-0.0633070767,
0.0505632572,
-0.0443003327,
-0.0331239067,
-0.0166741889,
-0.0084954333,
-0.0181873161,
-0.0183852781,
-0.0351266526,
0.0621588416,
-0.0233948231,
-0.0554873459,
0.041670721,
-0.0004820072,
0.0353601687,
-0.0642572865,
0.0211358164,
0.0733342096,
-0.0603421405,
0.0134005463,
0.017896276,
-0.0070934389,
0.0016052262,
0.0078090508,
0.0280422978,
0.037280634,
0.0355081595,
0.0293717533,
0.0053066029,
0.0177822132,
-0.0303116962,
0.0014132245,
-0.0650018379,
0.0130327772,
-0.058774367,
-0.0228355378,
-0.0534691699,
0.0567145757,
-0.0257923864,
-0.0025741926,
-0.00737873,
0.0261965189,
0.0071639367,
0.0172036495,
-0.0210826434,
0.0068422514,
0.0407091826,
-0.0051134052,
-0.0443808548,
0.0153844003,
-0.0733847842,
0.0130781978,
0.0292822402,
-0.0062964712,
-0.0109845074,
-0.0254539195,
-0.0002112245,
-0.0139632812,
0.0150009869,
0.0371727832,
-0.0362990275,
0.0087881656,
-0.0181395803,
-0.0564866178,
0.0234289113,
-0.0501956157,
0.030726755,
-0.0895818248,
0.0198753849,
0.0062954598,
-0.0365688391,
0.0058918148,
0.0273929071,
0.0458806157,
-0.0158165302,
0.0564189777,
-0.0073015951,
0.0309765376,
0.0404761769,
0.009274723,
-0.0005983643,
0.0383620858,
0.0585058443,
0.0149146877,
0.0230619349,
0.0165160317,
0.0480936915,
0.0008080396,
-0.0067626284,
-0.0243509915,
0.0280815754,
0.0207430348,
-0.0427555405,
0.0532539077,
-0.0464869104,
0.04100357,
-0.0059446548,
0.0079540582,
0.0307327826,
0.0668109506,
-0.00140613,
0.0234093945,
0.0271395817,
-0.0295377132,
0.0210014414,
0.0107404338,
-0.0367089882,
0.029796131,
-0.0482943952,
0.0055494127,
-0.0212181937,
0.0254890248,
-0.0272755157,
-0.0464819856,
-0.0087130247,
0.0596003309,
0.0404283479,
0.057988178,
0.0333568193,
0.0316324942,
-0.0089225825,
0.0181738939,
0.0004377948,
-0.0323314033,
-0.0491916426,
-0.0682708472,
0.0674698502,
0.0286370292,
0.0563798472,
-0.0211719126,
-0.0085764332,
-0.0165485926,
0.0418183766,
0.0114769107,
0.0069749681,
-0.0098572187,
-0.0520952158,
-0.0208974946,
-0.0282486193,
-0.0033091467,
-0.0216673538,
-0.0110623306,
-0.001039148,
-0.0007073662,
-0.0213159621,
-0.0100498246,
0.0304415692,
0.0240840912,
0.0111526018,
-0.0001043736,
-0.0312540457,
0.0227202252,
-0.0281222425,
0.0151306037,
0.0129493028,
0.047563158,
0.0226248521,
-0.0136590069,
-0.0742446035,
0.012722197,
-0.0607823282,
-0.0548141897,
0.0330764018,
-0.0460870042,
-0.0548448227,
-0.0031243211,
-0.0139161283,
-0.0238733534,
0.0553943403,
-0.0783431083,
0.0261801463,
-0.0004073681,
0.0238894336,
-0.009429168,
-0.0474741757,
-0.0309967045,
0.0926368535,
-0.00923777,
0.0004558655,
0.0281753913,
-0.0201284178,
0.0063882642,
-0.0276873838,
0.0239925552,
-0.0014341054,
-0.015454785,
-0.0197564624,
0.0000863723,
0.0397993289,
-0.0860553905,
-0.0146042891,
-0.071697101,
-0.002572557,
-0.0105930138,
0.0205212478,
-0.0052498369,
-0.0013274802,
0.0080497768,
-0.0263611265,
-0.057425864,
0.0286809076,
-0.0025560928,
0.021148419,
0.0303243063,
-0.0172676072,
-0.0016352728,
0.0138488095,
-0.0224544425,
-0.0430426039,
0.044694908,
0.0090345955,
-0.0031239355,
-0.032022763,
0.0307570528,
-0.0740685463,
0.0282626506,
-0.0020699105,
-0.0023857758,
0.0646594614,
-0.0079983529,
0.054220438,
0.0896370411,
0.0185655989,
-0.0063864505,
0.0178327132,
-0.0361990184,
-0.0085862307,
0.0387338176,
0.0012480989,
-0.029226359,
0.031222729,
-0.0471891165,
-0.0249007829,
0.0649888441,
-0.0080313645,
0.0093723927,
-0.0224536713,
0.0622704588,
0.0150945103,
-0.020953333,
-0.0800474733,
-0.0293031875,
-0.0004049158,
0.0783879086,
-0.0212925877,
0.0051599415,
0.076712355,
0.0174176376,
-0.0108079901,
-0.054002244,
0.046098426,
-0.0312251188,
0.0905866474,
-0.008921572,
0.0058332789,
-0.0131627414,
-0.0146822147,
-0.0504844189,
-0.0125744892,
0.012458737,
-0.047326915,
0.0503524132,
-0.0422078446,
-0.0053621186,
0.0006894964,
-0.0384917893,
-0.0484384969,
0.019283833,
-0.0183251593,
0.003187811,
-0.0226495173,
0.0050324919,
-0.019012142,
-0.0182645954,
0.0803897232,
0.0209229179,
-0.0067345789,
-0.0398362949,
0.0122805908,
0.0425352715,
0.0373461284,
0.0444611832,
0.0943828523,
-0.0342448577,
0.0699249208,
0.0788097754,
0.0818300396,
0.0002193395,
0.0055178837,
0.0173316486,
-0.004934499,
0.0001791114,
-0.0074952412,
0.0366046429,
0.0672410205,
-0.0798875839,
-0.0372045189,
0.1038055941,
0.0601404011,
-0.0292071998,
-0.0070789885,
-0.0822778717,
0.0358934402,
0.0630208924,
0.0256673582,
-0.0724481121,
-0.0387926251,
0.0423701778,
-0.0319591276,
-0.0308240708,
-0.0721002147,
0.0146771027,
-0.1295518279,
0.0368292294,
-0.0046669384,
-0.0481789596,
-0.0033558086,
-0.018382946,
-0.014725876,
0.0702316314,
-0.0641757399,
0.0594484471,
-0.0073838038,
0.0119746346,
0.0089474376,
-0.0196391921,
0.0693509132,
0.0486203097,
-0.0109599633,
-0.0288351718,
0.0300030839,
0.0286507439,
0.0226445068,
-0.0369022116,
0.0262532514,
-0.0435087532,
-0.0221191607,
-0.0151461652,
-0.0259731617,
0.0186568443,
0.002109857,
-0.0318300724,
0.0388132297,
-0.0221618004,
-0.0124046989,
0.075886488,
0.1065226272,
-0.0249109976,
-0.0292347688,
-0.0133610032,
0.0471965596,
-0.0216237046,
0.0448512174,
0.0310279224,
-0.033105161,
-0.0295161996,
-0.0284654722,
-0.0238210112,
-0.0033613166,
-0.0510007925,
0.0348040536,
0.0640999153,
0.0533997193,
-0.0687143877,
-0.0554472543,
0.0453062952,
0.0627093911,
-0.0171758849,
-0.0083976835,
0.0113780238,
0.0183892846,
-0.0437045842,
-0.0131199481,
-0.0226768572,
0.0149349906,
-0.0187411997,
0.030704001,
-0.0373485833,
-0.0380390212,
-0.0289062615,
0.0035551961,
-0.0772964433,
-0.0267156456,
-0.0517544486,
0.0374581739,
0.0260305572,
-0.0072847158,
0.0056625213,
-0.0230998881,
-0.0130941076,
-0.0213802643,
0.0019308341,
0.0195939187,
-0.0152554577,
0.0419833735,
0.0306022484,
0.032749366,
-0.0258013569,
0.0007288301,
0.0111288223,
0.0552416034,
-0.0447696336,
-0.0122427261,
0.0274289977,
0.0132177658,
-0.0281598922,
0.018884996,
-0.0038058399,
0.0011484909,
0.0332119092,
-0.0270439591,
-0.0405781828,
-0.0308334492,
0.0364232585,
-0.0189427864,
-0.0232548825,
0.0343784876,
-0.0357851908,
-0.0061989385,
0.0146112815,
-0.0174549315,
0.0161461886,
0.0311795454,
0.0104364138,
0.0245300177,
-0.0252061691,
0.0073231794,
-0.004556857,
0.0117207523,
0.0857696533,
0.033648517,
0.1178803593,
0.0289150849,
-0.022043325,
-0.0749481395,
-0.0021331599,
-0.0631987453,
-0.1232011169,
0.0448024198,
0.0329061188,
-0.0028743227,
0.0388267078,
-0.0280457698,
-0.0192248151,
0.0019250655,
0.0260834675,
-0.0142660895,
0.0123349186,
-0.0515158661,
0.0465284325,
0.0406509005,
0.0112255299,
-0.0083600562,
0.0118621672,
-0.0610868186,
-0.0090665789,
0.0091187656,
-0.0007678248,
-0.0256851297,
-0.0423536934,
-0.0266954396,
-0.0017068707,
0.0125612449,
0.0440078638,
-0.0800690129,
-0.0537730269,
-0.0407395326,
0.0101020671,
0.0161889102,
-0.0057974295,
0.0728234574,
0.0509997495,
0.012478712,
-0.0433335826,
-0.0189929977,
0.0490280278,
-0.0381035842,
-0.0457561947,
-0.0195477568,
-6.232974307e-33,
-0.0048839003,
-0.0557656288,
0.0688378438,
0.005876848,
-0.0265680868,
-0.0288319569,
-0.0474299751,
0.0420637764,
-0.0196258705,
0.0287126452,
-0.0308500156,
-0.0055987788,
-0.0069669881,
0.0095585631,
0.0192831103,
-0.006781464,
-0.0263613593,
-0.0107260793,
-0.0501832813,
0.0025225256,
0.0233169291,
0.0082789399,
-0.0109256282,
-0.0295544006,
-0.0294522475,
-0.0023675829,
0.0371364802,
0.059952043,
-0.0365960263,
0.014123545,
0.0056863748,
-0.0020073419,
0.0432770886,
-0.0193793401,
0.0141845355,
0.0731260628,
-0.0518277735,
-0.0225488059,
0.0238915831,
-0.0144257443,
-0.1016033366,
0.0118488204,
0.0191458128,
0.0048670107,
0.0161421932,
-0.0498704389,
0.0109770689,
-0.0097088404,
-0.0098182308,
0.0148917325,
-0.0459170341,
-0.0138539365,
-0.0359710567,
-0.0578731634,
-0.040016897,
0.0926753208,
-0.0095186699,
-0.0069886656,
-0.0291495584,
0.0274203531,
0.0079423878,
-0.0059124273,
0.0208025724,
0.003530984,
0.0026963365,
0.0086987289,
0.0271738935,
0.007554349,
-0.0361193046,
-0.0026706187,
-0.0371601693,
0.0295380838,
0.0805479363,
-0.006112047,
0.026390465,
0.0272929352,
-0.0463751741,
-0.0260072928,
0.0272008497,
0.038578786,
0.0134820063,
-0.0064846929,
-0.0104804179,
-0.0115683367,
-0.055065807,
0.0355210938,
-0.0435043089,
-0.0123785455,
0.0282039568,
-0.0132212546,
-0.0037183806,
-0.0382104218,
0.0037301313,
0.0039845952,
0.0136334253,
0.0183869526,
-0.0087396251,
0.0328886509,
-0.0068352176,
0.0329920389,
-0.0248251464,
0.0357467756,
0.0116081294,
0.0154022202,
0.003245529,
0.021619631,
0.0058027902,
-0.0240227506,
-0.0335390121,
-0.0292322766,
-0.0536427982,
0.0399646387,
-0.0034080651,
-0.0090440074,
0.0335626155,
0.0205376782,
-0.0159443021,
0.0166940633,
0.0102019301,
-0.0408286229,
-0.0479543172,
0.0106867654,
-0.0219287258,
0.0016408743,
-0.0213287156,
-0.0138967382,
-0.0450570695,
0.0550923757,
0.0079602227,
-0.0936962664,
-0.0183290392,
0.0194665585,
2.993e-7,
-0.0121482853,
0.0673794821,
0.0048426893,
0.0256861951,
0.0477612466,
0.0341927148,
0.0050984011,
-0.0212623589,
0.0606892183,
-0.0738667473,
-0.022550147,
0.0524563082,
0.0395381562,
0.0263790321,
-0.0743981004,
-0.060037028,
-0.0586983524,
-0.0196859967,
-0.0349244773,
-0.0078006736,
0.045503661,
0.0367358029,
0.0014372069,
-0.0303995851,
0.0071477438,
-0.0311581306,
0.04266572,
0.0184977725,
0.0045083649,
-0.0210497417,
-0.0182004087,
-0.0155197233,
0.0311276298,
0.0352237821,
0.0313895121,
0.0099597201,
0.0011692861,
-0.0276665352,
0.0055088704,
-0.0039148508,
-0.0174881574,
-0.0203857087,
-0.0012576483,
-0.0375144407,
0.0583905391,
-0.0451972224,
-0.0271432903,
-0.0022078159,
0.043725159,
-0.0295530483,
0.0130079901,
-0.0099846739,
0.001946828,
0.027341079,
0.0082586585,
-0.0118249208,
0.0423518419,
-0.0453808755,
-0.0095227882,
0.0176708158,
-0.0229138825,
-0.0141290128,
-0.0431797095,
-0.0001088809,
-0.0089384168,
-0.0158356298,
-0.0282960739,
2.453378622e-34,
0.0262617189,
-0.0343151465,
0.0488568582,
0.0427134149,
0.0534261651,
-0.016757004,
-0.0242532361,
0.0101014161,
0.0311471354,
-0.0621586777,
-0.018264262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14998v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14998v2 | An Examination of the Robustness of Reference-Free Image Captioning Evaluation Metrics | 2023-05-24T10:36:12 | 2024-02-06T04:20:15 | Saba Ahmadi, Aishwarya Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Recently, reference-free metrics such as CLIPScore (Hessel et al., 2021),
UMIC (Lee et al., 2021), and PAC-S (Sarto et al., 2023) have been proposed for
automatic reference-free evaluation of image captions. Our focus lies in
evaluating the robustness of these metrics in scenarios that require
distinguishing between two captions with high lexical overlap but very
different meanings. Our findings reveal that despite their high correlation
with human judgments, CLIPScore, UMIC, and PAC-S struggle to identify
fine-grained errors. While all metrics exhibit strong sensitivity to visual
grounding errors, their sensitivity to caption implausibility errors is
limited. Furthermore, we found that all metrics are sensitive to variations in
the size of image-relevant objects mentioned in the caption, while CLIPScore
and PAC-S are also sensitive to the number of mentions of image-relevant
objects in the caption. Regarding linguistic aspects of a caption, all metrics
show weak comprehension of negation, and CLIPScore and PAC-S are insensitive to
the structure of the caption to a great extent. We hope our findings will guide
further improvements in reference-free evaluation of image captioning. | [
0.0476465598,
0.043260403,
0.0011614816,
0.0341499522,
-0.0004761145,
0.0273297392,
-0.0034445066,
0.0355386361,
-0.014620807,
-0.0776797086,
-0.0507388748,
-0.0126286512,
0.04930586,
0.0152775533,
-0.0110205673,
-0.0690273866,
0.0335390121,
0.0061285058,
0.010958733,
0.0138525115,
0.0252310801,
-0.0141222263,
-0.0076796366,
0.0402391925,
-0.0361481681,
0.0060155508,
0.0332661085,
0.0341051519,
0.0078626433,
-0.0368755311,
-0.0251525491,
0.0778887272,
0.0012133577,
0.0462794639,
0.0000015597,
-0.0075748102,
0.0315468274,
0.001634625,
0.0326368921,
0.0108136162,
0.0672702417,
-0.0390542559,
0.0030551744,
-0.0402758457,
-0.0177854858,
-0.0258424859,
0.0947633386,
0.0698327497,
0.0673149154,
-0.0064725499,
-0.013181556,
-0.002049413,
-0.0435032956,
-0.0159120653,
0.0122354198,
-0.0200044177,
-0.0058341813,
0.0548255555,
-0.0263206456,
-0.0013146689,
-0.045869641,
0.0223358963,
-0.0223562233,
-0.0046172072,
-0.0143469954,
0.0637036338,
-0.0774519667,
-0.0684051961,
-0.005583894,
0.0861380845,
0.0252962839,
0.000779845,
-0.0470053889,
-0.0112704718,
0.0039213477,
0.0073278211,
-0.0267473273,
0.034225177,
0.0237814356,
0.0014873262,
-0.0478174761,
0.0368782878,
-0.0058904178,
0.005376277,
0.0525527075,
0.0019720644,
0.0092922524,
-0.009031334,
-0.0106325997,
0.0349244587,
-0.0489539951,
-0.0393442735,
0.0153949885,
-0.0358915292,
0.0228727795,
-0.0029075656,
-0.0422902741,
-0.0252086055,
0.0311228409,
-0.0710051581,
0.0221103877,
-0.0158399194,
-0.0689260736,
0.0899730548,
-0.0168936476,
0.0615019277,
0.0265901014,
0.0171942599,
-0.0268258788,
0.0403878093,
-0.0215483028,
0.0227263961,
-0.0072748298,
0.017945515,
-0.0710429251,
-0.049497366,
-0.0156246023,
-0.0523585826,
-0.0614493527,
0.0147301042,
-0.0310308021,
0.0541462712,
-0.0183035117,
0.0131493164,
-0.0621289387,
0.027850559,
-0.0217546094,
0.0115628876,
-0.0645378456,
-0.0358968414,
-0.0140948156,
0.0552912764,
0.0252210163,
-0.0059714094,
0.0023367642,
0.0536246337,
-0.0149509935,
-0.034229625,
0.0142054977,
-0.0353816189,
-0.0716337338,
-0.040325664,
-0.004909208,
-0.037161421,
0.0124076167,
-0.0128570879,
-0.0000499639,
-0.0527759492,
0.0325894579,
0.0335270017,
-0.0196218826,
0.1156625599,
0.0051064845,
-0.0203680787,
-0.0347791277,
0.0345187709,
-0.0296474565,
0.0646458864,
0.015468671,
0.0173252542,
0.0545213632,
0.0176014379,
0.0252495371,
-0.0112295914,
-0.0037404157,
0.0247006807,
-0.0265362933,
-0.0123156188,
-0.0074553448,
0.0092448415,
0.0398301519,
0.0632088855,
-0.0207249206,
-0.0013775603,
0.0726291463,
0.0400587469,
-0.061934486,
0.009192056,
0.0349085703,
0.0037482169,
-0.0032710298,
0.0441328473,
-0.061775025,
0.0455964021,
0.0069839158,
-0.0042695333,
0.0167994238,
-0.0202826615,
-0.0121302921,
-0.04071334,
-0.018996764,
-0.022357041,
0.0274012033,
-0.0716206655,
0.0187192149,
0.0300282892,
-0.0587132536,
0.0676748008,
-0.0228772089,
-0.0572926588,
-0.0047786725,
-0.0079798549,
-0.0033189591,
0.0244868789,
0.0394499004,
0.0132646738,
-0.0363675244,
0.0092476457,
0.0483675338,
0.0749223381,
0.0164736398,
0.0309262145,
0.0098350337,
-0.0262090247,
-0.0306969862,
-0.0083378851,
0.0381358601,
0.0060353954,
0.0045222705,
0.0153278476,
0.0406070538,
-0.0353096649,
-0.0706765205,
0.0178252719,
0.0998546332,
-0.028720757,
-0.0366811939,
0.0196604542,
0.0204694401,
0.0231046379,
-0.0466485135,
0.0092074517,
-0.0213171579,
0.0165223423,
-0.0351291336,
0.0467435047,
-0.042645514,
-0.0319186114,
0.015803922,
-0.1006126776,
-0.0203036442,
-0.0087439967,
-0.0172329769,
-0.0210241657,
0.0368763767,
-0.0524104238,
-0.0152658932,
-0.0797905698,
0.0112715233,
-0.0191023145,
0.0407867581,
0.0014911998,
0.0447411798,
0.0048423628,
0.0238857809,
0.0231388379,
-0.0021065583,
0.0404917188,
-0.0262237117,
-0.0756009817,
-0.0112475334,
0.0091459714,
0.0287396926,
0.0178144705,
0.0490592122,
-0.0575163998,
-0.0043787691,
-0.0660439059,
-0.0254423544,
-0.0135487393,
-0.0118800607,
0.0100720599,
-0.0304818172,
0.0144566949,
-0.0319418982,
0.0196482334,
-0.0107009262,
-0.0052506905,
0.0324350111,
0.0505096689,
0.0181834437,
-0.0072951862,
-0.0282367226,
0.012586751,
0.0085960608,
0.0692576692,
0.0431667864,
-0.0034414476,
-0.0180462226,
0.0212330669,
-0.0406864136,
-0.0064247297,
0.0324919149,
-0.0430161543,
0.0191281717,
0.0346604064,
-0.0138941519,
0.0279849656,
-0.0171823353,
0.0078576608,
0.0330020301,
-0.0324317515,
-0.0014037668,
-0.0136440191,
0.0191093404,
-0.079072684,
0.0638942793,
-0.0517376103,
-0.0126270605,
0.0084210113,
-0.0178302154,
0.0403264537,
-0.0834318474,
0.0419158898,
-0.0547451302,
-0.0687728152,
-0.0297097117,
0.0097067002,
0.0058356281,
0.0392816328,
-0.0447835289,
-0.040162228,
0.0473161265,
-0.060988795,
-0.0303193666,
0.007923387,
0.0267037358,
-0.0081078345,
0.0669409409,
-0.0013435797,
0.0214090385,
0.0240259357,
-0.0215875171,
0.0029582507,
-0.0296418127,
0.0239056591,
-0.0182840321,
0.0683157444,
-0.0471379496,
-0.021293154,
-0.0146031082,
-0.0196803082,
-0.0072551104,
-0.0123724183,
-0.0186095219,
-0.0265040081,
-0.0424708314,
0.0030384036,
-0.0293670297,
0.0668457597,
0.0046769027,
-0.0000353462,
-0.0110287415,
0.0039894246,
-0.0004494232,
0.038338203,
0.0176867601,
0.0214972515,
-0.0255248882,
-0.012893321,
-0.0134404413,
0.0260301325,
-0.0321343057,
0.0162796788,
-0.0331322588,
0.0158327445,
0.0119293462,
0.0299591795,
-0.0052688932,
-0.0019686432,
0.049548164,
-0.0261572767,
-0.0324566886,
0.0886080861,
0.0152449617,
-0.0432527773,
-0.0298833549,
0.0057569067,
0.0145339388,
0.0316127054,
-0.0386100225,
-0.0298453923,
-0.0561420619,
-0.0108960597,
0.0027663098,
0.0153977135,
0.0041182307,
-0.0373918004,
-0.0781997144,
0.0359660834,
0.0286556724,
-0.0608672984,
-0.0708771497,
0.0024628218,
0.0245409552,
-0.0121475095,
-0.0094738398,
-0.0241206456,
-0.0091866944,
0.0299384762,
-0.0035330576,
-0.0125002926,
-0.0383616835,
-0.0016488234,
-0.0471701361,
0.0187641047,
0.0401933342,
0.0338631906,
-0.0195722282,
-0.0334094204,
0.0010803852,
-0.0395862386,
0.0097505413,
-0.0092300475,
0.0758481473,
-0.024514202,
-0.0305492338,
-0.0032374088,
-0.0257553495,
-0.0137561215,
-0.018698778,
-0.0368764326,
0.0290845409,
0.002060672,
-0.0224181041,
-0.0498454571,
0.0638466403,
0.0065931142,
0.0745485425,
0.0634095222,
0.0158708356,
-0.0231570844,
0.0052445824,
0.0099729132,
-0.0569464192,
-0.0042726458,
0.008448394,
-0.0184469949,
-0.0217341781,
-0.0757925734,
-0.0353666767,
-0.0042948504,
0.0085083479,
0.0241535436,
-0.0029646864,
-0.0170755573,
0.0420718826,
-0.0254181214,
0.0438292362,
-0.0330499709,
0.0069102622,
-0.0069572944,
0.0265541263,
0.0443054549,
0.0305519924,
-0.0448022634,
0.0732738897,
-0.0201744754,
-0.001439453,
-0.0118214916,
0.032312993,
0.0170939006,
-0.0260544699,
0.0053294692,
-0.0070510162,
-0.009068761,
0.0706547797,
0.0451015197,
0.0375522524,
0.0320047028,
-0.0375329331,
-0.0133080613,
0.0340025462,
-0.0416453369,
0.0191181637,
-0.0121860923,
0.0649153739,
-0.0004985452,
-0.0219042953,
-0.013204149,
0.0198018365,
0.0239628833,
-0.0475220606,
0.0245051738,
-0.004728822,
-0.0180654451,
0.0170347542,
-0.015268865,
-0.0327468552,
0.0085886782,
0.0021190678,
0.0427036695,
-0.0289942641,
0.0150945978,
-0.056763716,
0.0412956886,
0.0194994491,
-0.0106697716,
0.0645601377,
-0.0298743937,
-0.0508622788,
-0.0143679315,
-0.02903351,
-0.040504694,
-0.0070084617,
0.0072714868,
-0.0120003065,
0.0398194194,
0.0219765715,
-0.0085286275,
-0.00429133,
0.0458567105,
0.0107763279,
0.0610521436,
-0.0471010469,
0.0389725678,
0.0627220422,
-0.0261918232,
0.0447044373,
-0.0255481787,
0.0028554972,
0.02131873,
-0.0045760074,
-0.0002825593,
-0.0441987813,
0.0355958864,
0.0230138246,
0.0235395357,
0.0398539864,
0.0311311577,
-0.0123072239,
0.0181595162,
-0.0114061823,
-0.0584512651,
-0.0205871873,
-0.0288528092,
-0.060638167,
-0.0023633493,
0.0009415595,
0.0331495516,
-0.0619101152,
-0.0623077676,
0.0269913971,
0.0302939117,
0.026450146,
0.0478688963,
0.0413201973,
0.0227476824,
0.0182670876,
0.0092096385,
0.0118576009,
-0.0290402472,
-0.0231506992,
0.0614304766,
-0.061054159,
-5.334160102e-33,
-0.0645064563,
-0.0631384254,
-0.0367338695,
-0.0146333948,
-0.0283812992,
0.0351027809,
-0.049117811,
0.0277096219,
0.0292963777,
0.0476813763,
0.0295998231,
-0.0067360881,
0.0255450513,
-0.0076972996,
0.0161205288,
-0.0206288733,
0.0499771312,
0.0269412212,
-0.0475103818,
-0.0147078009,
0.0102511207,
-0.0402224623,
0.0141093181,
-0.0784744248,
0.0551882051,
0.0009313394,
-0.0333090536,
0.0074627236,
0.066434592,
0.0702406839,
-0.0040477426,
0.0471733287,
0.0188614726,
0.0059876153,
-0.028729368,
-0.0029243561,
-0.06577795,
-0.0326858945,
0.0864124894,
0.0289057773,
-0.0064206123,
0.0036578653,
0.0306015518,
-0.0333032496,
-0.0491989851,
-0.0084836073,
0.0509092063,
-0.0350558609,
0.0335903987,
0.0077181528,
-0.0341001227,
-0.0005563272,
-0.0074656308,
-0.007795223,
0.0284758024,
0.0069991532,
0.0087516056,
0.0211166441,
-0.0405181758,
0.0435706973,
-0.018674124,
0.0105292751,
0.0620237067,
0.0186204556,
-0.016045047,
0.0552476346,
0.0115898177,
-0.0001691551,
-0.0163946059,
-0.0630766004,
0.0128895491,
0.0269388556,
0.0814347565,
0.0696114451,
0.0482425354,
0.0298844371,
0.011176534,
0.0119530438,
-0.0950238928,
0.0608157739,
0.0366345532,
0.0069318535,
-0.0492146946,
0.0090298075,
-0.0704168528,
-0.0305684488,
-0.0647481531,
-0.0265744105,
0.0380569994,
0.0032597168,
-0.0152491694,
0.0550648756,
0.0380141623,
-0.0081388261,
0.0412047915,
-0.0263403337,
0.0180266891,
0.0267388672,
-0.0069618858,
-0.0276447274,
0.0216953289,
-0.0316510499,
0.053407263,
0.0478779897,
0.0442092083,
-0.0301616974,
0.06236412,
0.0169885345,
-0.0387372412,
-0.0147146424,
-0.011681403,
-0.0185894109,
-0.0415537655,
-0.0403868593,
0.0307700504,
0.0295612514,
-0.0680253506,
-0.0206759162,
-0.0142022632,
0.0474445298,
-0.0093688751,
-0.0202434119,
-0.0258858539,
0.0038529397,
-0.0457709581,
0.0105271637,
0.0003293135,
-0.0419751145,
0.0019534419,
-0.0736227483,
-0.0329886787,
0.0382394008,
2.283e-7,
0.0065761814,
0.0529773384,
0.0313394442,
0.0131949922,
0.022103589,
0.0433393829,
-0.0365042947,
-0.0111353416,
-0.0202287864,
-0.0056138644,
0.0361766703,
0.01401038,
0.0055094738,
-0.0129831759,
-0.0195938069,
-0.0037005343,
-0.0506329611,
0.0005476243,
-0.0160654727,
-0.0313474499,
0.0639110133,
0.0345473066,
-0.0056975344,
-0.000976477,
-0.0078586899,
-0.1140542254,
0.0604630411,
-0.0319858082,
0.0184717271,
-0.0287402458,
0.0350285657,
0.0459771678,
-0.0205172766,
0.0604818203,
0.000699695,
-0.0409003571,
0.1063484102,
0.0186802763,
-0.0309851561,
-0.0120816827,
-0.0525908805,
0.0318193957,
-0.0024630658,
-0.0175494812,
0.0658199638,
-0.0459393524,
-0.0207263604,
-0.0206211712,
-0.0389044434,
0.0101651875,
0.0526553243,
-0.0203365311,
-0.0695022643,
0.0192576312,
0.0469801612,
0.0356815308,
-0.0607673898,
-0.0488283299,
-0.013837303,
0.0220063403,
0.0238976143,
-0.0495978296,
-0.0432916582,
-0.0165824052,
0.017817745,
-0.0434310436,
-0.0295642838,
1.712695958e-34,
0.0736957863,
-0.0272396225,
0.0266555063,
-0.0432090797,
0.0254588835,
0.0100453338,
-0.0262532029,
-0.0396376848,
0.0036917995,
-0.0351518653,
0.0135404821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16344v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16344v2 | Enabling and Analyzing How to Efficiently Extract Information from Hybrid Long Documents with LLMs | 2023-05-24T10:35:58 | 2024-03-07T13:44:27 | Chongjian Yue, Xinrun Xu, Xiaojun Ma, Lun Du, Hengyu Liu, Zhiming Ding, Yanbing Jiang, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional performance in textual
understanding and tabular reasoning tasks. However, their ability to comprehend
and analyze hybrid text, containing textual and tabular data, remains
underexplored. In this research, we specialize in harnessing the potential of
LLMs to comprehend critical information from financial reports, which are
hybrid long-documents. We propose an Automated Financial Information Extraction
(AFIE) framework that enhances LLMs' ability to comprehend and extract
information from financial reports. To evaluate AFIE, we develop a Financial
Reports Numerical Extraction (FINE) dataset and conduct an extensive
experimental analysis. Our framework is effectively validated on GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, yielding average accuracy increases of 53.94% and 33.77%, respectively,
compared to a naive method. These results suggest that the AFIE framework
offers accuracy for automated numerical extraction from complex, hybrid
documents. | [
-0.0113906087,
0.0453035682,
0.0189798698,
0.0586034432,
-0.0210660007,
0.0470365696,
-0.0192242824,
0.0435264036,
0.0036181675,
-0.0347384363,
-0.0533923469,
-0.0383823104,
-0.0061187167,
0.0298827719,
0.0157347228,
-0.0201147497,
0.035265822,
-0.0200133007,
0.047497116,
0.0303366892,
0.0353344865,
0.0011039639,
0.0350854062,
-0.0372401476,
0.0235762075,
-0.02781526,
0.0027151646,
-0.0354868732,
0.0182249751,
0.0041018105,
-0.0202054866,
-0.009029842,
0.0273586139,
0.060921777,
0.0000019781,
-0.0357373357,
-0.0808845088,
0.0280978046,
-0.0187807996,
0.0615871772,
0.044775892,
-0.0671482012,
-0.0053860275,
-0.0235358998,
-0.0438538305,
-0.0272460766,
-0.0083271097,
0.0701730251,
0.0577127896,
0.0778235793,
-0.0232253913,
-0.0648004413,
0.0290666092,
-0.0214917418,
0.0257226657,
-0.0946182534,
0.0212706774,
0.0642044544,
0.0217124466,
-0.0175479054,
0.0210786201,
0.034589991,
0.0277602058,
-0.0016434037,
-0.0119042452,
0.0204759706,
-0.05143499,
0.0083145602,
-0.0252482556,
0.0623151511,
-0.004548308,
0.0448661633,
0.0430279374,
-0.0180323515,
-0.0028724268,
-0.0183037389,
-0.0660618991,
0.0325883664,
-0.0534332953,
0.0082731163,
0.0376867317,
-0.0280420147,
0.0101890611,
0.0071088355,
-0.0763235539,
0.0404194891,
-0.0321881287,
-0.0492609702,
0.0423872322,
0.0055448906,
-0.0202197786,
0.0006364941,
0.0502576493,
0.0405621156,
0.0562232435,
0.0310372114,
-0.0244309902,
-0.049569089,
0.0036392552,
-0.0583259463,
0.0313340761,
0.0354207568,
-0.022861518,
0.0734960809,
-0.0686260015,
0.0284674373,
-0.0477051958,
0.0020928069,
0.0372724347,
0.0092477519,
-0.037001282,
-0.0101242242,
-0.018788049,
0.0586555675,
-0.0505836084,
-0.0246564299,
0.0147252288,
-0.0038196903,
0.010259348,
0.0372941382,
0.013052538,
-0.0464671589,
-0.0062322337,
-0.0546810403,
-0.0318665989,
0.0007279779,
-0.021586284,
-0.0121568469,
-0.0166995842,
-0.0301095098,
-0.0137285255,
0.0034805844,
0.026268173,
-0.0382233448,
0.019156523,
0.0492857434,
-0.0168847758,
-0.0293920804,
-0.0633466691,
-0.0267993417,
0.0224353019,
-0.0623570494,
-0.0149185704,
-0.0227143541,
0.0609944426,
0.0048986855,
-0.0370739363,
0.0066679623,
0.0056226761,
-0.0194217991,
-0.0183611605,
0.0702914372,
-0.0229873843,
-0.0283072162,
0.0140828695,
-0.0267696064,
0.0008531996,
0.0685079694,
0.037215054,
0.0204348732,
0.0182632152,
0.0171228554,
-0.0083768694,
0.0780667365,
0.0024050355,
-0.0610181652,
0.0109080421,
0.0680535734,
-0.0017029811,
-0.0255179014,
0.053695742,
0.0207852367,
-0.0236321632,
0.0012310694,
0.0429004356,
0.0111737875,
0.0493355691,
0.0561381094,
-0.0067670452,
0.031892553,
0.069994837,
0.0184968337,
0.0091776066,
0.0004050509,
-0.0230697989,
0.0688008368,
0.0130116753,
0.0270943046,
0.0144159468,
-0.0321560912,
-0.0095645599,
-0.0040488746,
-0.0372741371,
0.0023984967,
0.0631051287,
-0.0218629446,
-0.0582996495,
0.0563556068,
0.0167724267,
-0.036885906,
-0.0029017637,
-0.0121848509,
0.0595881604,
0.0499191135,
0.0500155725,
-0.0801152065,
0.0239289403,
-0.0173707604,
-0.0318604819,
0.0175519418,
0.0427132696,
0.0009103373,
-0.0002734544,
-0.0597863905,
0.0108759217,
0.027975833,
0.0192635991,
-0.0034307598,
0.0195463561,
-0.0122006638,
0.0223401487,
-0.0500033498,
-0.0309931543,
0.017157726,
-0.0087540383,
-0.0571180694,
-0.0187712759,
-0.0198689066,
-0.010101839,
0.0229618624,
-0.0262835864,
0.0068688411,
0.0126746027,
-0.0094123483,
0.0158960652,
-0.0277865138,
-0.0317862257,
0.007761322,
-0.0006441755,
0.0003256944,
-0.0478084311,
-0.0021331222,
-0.0273747332,
0.0105788736,
-0.050534375,
-0.0057119029,
0.0172216874,
-0.0713025704,
0.000196499,
0.026700886,
0.0192814432,
-0.0101162754,
0.0760859549,
0.0247373264,
-0.006295301,
-0.0202991664,
-0.0378756784,
-0.0250660311,
-0.040376991,
0.044165384,
0.0386371873,
-0.0107028624,
-0.0023239993,
0.0025934854,
-0.0070867683,
-0.0359122828,
-0.057994958,
-0.0722366795,
0.0105261412,
-0.026248401,
0.0627449527,
0.0280615296,
0.0084165186,
-0.0454536527,
0.0012313256,
-0.018728951,
-0.00911537,
-0.0009438506,
-0.0264784768,
0.0879635438,
0.0163274929,
0.0025387588,
-0.0459140316,
-0.0028594981,
-0.0237570461,
0.0241190828,
0.0383330286,
-0.0409136228,
-0.035410706,
0.027577363,
0.0183041263,
0.0043285778,
-0.01729667,
0.0279560443,
-0.013563564,
-0.0673184842,
0.0266678985,
0.0732590184,
0.0169163626,
0.0779419765,
-0.0323719382,
-0.027053928,
-0.0387720801,
0.0081651257,
-0.0145990001,
0.0589474551,
-0.0258818157,
-0.0210527312,
0.0400822498,
0.0225950126,
-0.0402279943,
0.0258382522,
-0.0182637684,
0.020637067,
0.0052753515,
0.0185847767,
-0.0059431945,
0.0412039347,
-0.0104420064,
0.0619671941,
-0.0036384827,
-0.0233236421,
0.032990966,
-0.0276508611,
-0.0326476768,
-0.0326740704,
0.0138206501,
-0.0821395889,
0.0676333234,
-0.0100640478,
-0.0250423253,
-0.0269307662,
-0.0491033457,
0.0091714999,
-0.0185170956,
0.0391542278,
-0.0349509455,
0.0910318047,
-0.0158149935,
0.0389744751,
-0.0364059024,
0.0058812448,
0.0022494718,
-0.0750280097,
0.0037413884,
0.0121809822,
0.0231302809,
-0.0201038588,
-0.0684796646,
0.0138076786,
0.0441185981,
0.0502833463,
-0.0511046313,
-0.0107630603,
-0.0176209342,
0.045453202,
0.0562223904,
-0.0235428493,
0.0329814553,
-0.0734925345,
0.046505373,
0.0266516861,
0.0115999412,
0.0089495378,
0.0180450995,
-0.0299153607,
-0.0247772597,
-0.0559007563,
0.0037076909,
-0.0031660162,
-0.0235424917,
-0.0999249369,
-0.0005787183,
0.1046928018,
0.0280219875,
-0.0105355904,
-0.0377076864,
-0.0268846583,
-0.0014310898,
-0.0370879695,
0.0688706487,
-0.0909145027,
-0.0096498029,
-0.0056323167,
0.0142967338,
0.0378821157,
-0.0490922853,
-0.0180838592,
-0.0886010379,
0.0540591069,
0.019872224,
-0.0265764985,
-0.0658921674,
-0.0286677517,
-0.021921508,
-0.0255028866,
0.0130601274,
0.0674555525,
-0.0445127785,
-0.0057993452,
-0.0014139451,
-0.0819330141,
-0.0028065494,
-0.0041153268,
0.0072800093,
-0.0518304631,
0.0371992923,
0.0301482528,
-0.027479874,
-0.0108274519,
0.0033093398,
0.0142535446,
-0.035784021,
-0.0250414647,
0.0481084734,
-0.0128672598,
-0.005072969,
0.0125330435,
0.0335806981,
-0.0124376267,
0.0527364202,
0.0336869881,
0.0510870218,
-0.0108456276,
-0.0377160013,
0.0232754909,
-0.0084587,
-0.0539970063,
0.0739167407,
0.0067131068,
0.0076012979,
-0.0581408329,
-0.0210647844,
-0.0511017926,
-0.0738674924,
0.0254126862,
0.0094496692,
-0.0243709926,
-0.0195731428,
-0.0445770361,
-0.068336077,
0.0466769375,
0.0224602968,
-0.0136888362,
-0.0079432903,
0.0229034331,
0.0100773321,
-0.0269071739,
0.0156527236,
-0.0409276262,
-0.0063524931,
-0.0488414094,
0.0192712191,
-0.0105747925,
-0.0283180214,
-0.0497414209,
0.0163592342,
-0.0571404099,
-0.030771153,
-0.0035205556,
-0.03075408,
0.024887383,
0.0189980846,
-0.0001107979,
0.0268080141,
0.0126578091,
0.0431723148,
-0.0966886729,
-0.0466193184,
0.0264538396,
-0.0095456354,
0.0123474067,
0.0084616756,
-0.0262395386,
0.0039435094,
-0.0272273961,
0.0297212247,
-0.0279232766,
0.019504264,
0.0134981107,
0.0524004884,
-0.0050852876,
0.064841494,
-0.0245544687,
-0.0406763107,
0.0068565202,
-0.0329483896,
0.005059998,
-0.0326461419,
0.0249748025,
0.0300106909,
0.0138535537,
-0.0341702513,
0.0287352391,
0.0035412884,
0.0193159357,
-0.0398345515,
0.0332507305,
-0.0096607786,
0.0009083635,
0.0148978662,
-0.0882824585,
0.0063059982,
-0.0177862756,
-0.0030625341,
0.0190102402,
-0.0052445955,
0.0460351147,
0.0187745858,
-0.006080729,
0.0007544216,
0.0002617541,
-0.0334379412,
-0.0123904152,
-0.0146626541,
0.0485753566,
-0.0015936497,
-0.0290894713,
0.0161654651,
-0.0569934137,
0.0061140945,
0.0052163294,
0.0092120692,
0.0597027652,
0.0130651435,
0.010164733,
0.0245416854,
-0.0350783914,
-0.036493443,
0.0570429303,
0.0123358984,
-0.0128215495,
-0.0303465277,
-0.0214493182,
-0.0574863441,
-0.0292303693,
0.0352944843,
-0.0162453987,
-0.0143449968,
-0.0174533129,
-0.0567243323,
-0.0213966835,
0.022372853,
0.0305861067,
-0.0303358957,
-0.020215435,
-0.015270723,
0.1046570316,
0.0117359385,
0.0065046712,
-0.0246875193,
0.0461332425,
-0.0023840626,
-0.022455167,
-0.0187270194,
-6.075246842e-33,
-0.0234837011,
0.0059662936,
0.01787013,
0.0232278127,
-0.0185922906,
0.0083353333,
-0.0311512463,
-0.0585329346,
0.0410989262,
-0.0011139471,
-0.0223868545,
0.0202341266,
0.0261332821,
-0.0078898827,
-0.0182822533,
-0.0199970063,
-0.0015172166,
-0.0366237983,
-0.0043870173,
-0.027196629,
0.020850623,
0.0747460499,
0.045176208,
-0.0409098901,
0.0602826215,
0.0102182981,
-0.005849917,
-0.0179835521,
0.0388401039,
0.042989891,
-0.0111044142,
-0.0198086035,
0.0332211293,
-0.0732975677,
-0.0205791835,
0.0303545874,
-0.0941234455,
0.0184703749,
0.0152176004,
0.0141915251,
-0.0033936265,
0.0036953934,
0.0387531556,
-0.0259433016,
0.0077571282,
-0.0491954349,
0.0196790677,
-0.028246345,
0.0117157176,
-0.0700174719,
-0.0819300041,
0.069803305,
0.0281256698,
0.0651243627,
0.0966240615,
0.0294842944,
-0.0352465771,
0.0465427712,
0.0121979807,
-0.0551373772,
0.0319971666,
0.0340595096,
0.0203255806,
-0.0100440281,
0.0213930737,
0.0210444555,
-0.0031493267,
-0.0135117825,
-0.05806683,
-0.0012350237,
0.0331026651,
0.0186272021,
0.0127181597,
-0.014367057,
0.0535535663,
0.0090374127,
-0.0580263697,
0.0406189114,
0.0397398248,
0.0151504762,
0.0218731351,
0.0021021392,
-0.0273421649,
0.0239558946,
0.0178110972,
0.0230721626,
-0.0221173242,
0.0121763963,
0.0173603296,
-0.0066999472,
0.0044007264,
0.0259716734,
0.0248144232,
-0.0056659314,
-0.0414715745,
-0.0091373613,
0.0064832815,
0.0247161072,
-0.0021798122,
-0.0172048248,
-0.031077465,
-0.0435099453,
-0.0362770222,
0.0236781929,
-0.0029458124,
-0.0156488735,
0.0347250476,
-0.0132521177,
-0.0501890853,
-0.0199512877,
-0.0329069644,
0.0413910039,
0.0171950143,
0.0389352888,
0.0105562825,
0.0188554693,
0.0005467374,
0.0037764979,
0.0144190397,
-0.0054165209,
-0.0165224727,
0.0004804454,
-0.0029748783,
0.0562479869,
0.0098130573,
-0.0153844012,
0.0071216994,
0.0242088847,
0.0060383603,
-0.0214085449,
0.0140624437,
0.063202478,
2.597e-7,
0.04532497,
0.0536620729,
0.0499458723,
0.0170886964,
0.0247333031,
-0.001012816,
-0.0252236575,
0.0062797223,
-0.0168643687,
-0.0292529333,
0.0624498054,
0.0155499103,
0.0937965438,
0.0288782232,
-0.0747163072,
-0.0418819413,
-0.0597399287,
-0.0509653054,
-0.0786189735,
0.0095295794,
0.0412604325,
0.0461530499,
-0.0205756146,
-0.0061322213,
0.0118193757,
-0.0672751293,
0.0565906763,
-0.0178800933,
-0.0058049602,
0.0153578911,
0.0641062036,
-0.0142786661,
-0.0278135184,
-0.0004069049,
0.0175973531,
0.0451951399,
0.0397247821,
0.0760573149,
0.0184002705,
0.0514551029,
0.0005375691,
-0.0482444875,
-0.0034734698,
-0.0599239394,
0.0848843679,
-0.0315143652,
-0.0238163341,
-0.0015825874,
-0.0384212919,
-0.0119431866,
-0.0248111878,
0.0084091006,
0.0137358885,
0.0608770847,
0.0136567494,
-0.0445975475,
0.014781801,
-0.0524496697,
-0.0035368395,
0.0474584661,
-0.0301193409,
0.0197275095,
-0.0289434921,
0.0227132924,
0.0151013788,
-0.0483568422,
-0.0136025092,
2.548693535e-34,
0.0467780307,
-0.0340494476,
-0.0282954052,
0.033473324,
0.0881284028,
0.0013916803,
-0.0116646457,
0.0577359274,
-0.0370250978,
-0.0965949595,
0.0106860846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14996v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14996v2 | The ACL OCL Corpus: Advancing Open Science in Computational Linguistics | 2023-05-24T10:35:56 | 2023-10-24T05:18:32 | Shaurya Rohatgi, Yanxia Qin, Benjamin Aw, Niranjana Unnithan, Min-Yen Kan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | We present ACL OCL, a scholarly corpus derived from the ACL Anthology to
assist Open scientific research in the Computational Linguistics domain.
Integrating and enhancing the previous versions of the ACL Anthology, the ACL
OCL contributes metadata, PDF files, citation graphs and additional structured
full texts with sections, figures, and links to a large knowledge resource
(Semantic Scholar). The ACL OCL spans seven decades, containing 73K papers,
alongside 210K figures.
We spotlight how ACL OCL applies to observe trends in computational
linguistics. By detecting paper topics with a supervised neural model, we note
that interest in "Syntax: Tagging, Chunking and Parsing" is waning and "Natural
Language Generation" is resurging. Our dataset is available from HuggingFace
(https://huggingface.co/datasets/WINGNUS/ACL-OCL). | [
0.0119264908,
0.0648807734,
-0.0013530138,
0.0185499694,
-0.0492868908,
0.0020669927,
0.0247185528,
-0.0140088806,
-0.0225723349,
-0.0529265404,
0.0175360311,
0.0190210566,
-0.0104373414,
0.0423134454,
0.0075199939,
-0.0121890921,
0.0191494934,
0.0020892723,
0.0628267601,
0.0013364425,
0.0031565835,
0.0204152819,
-0.0122778267,
0.0558369234,
0.0230757035,
-0.0444068238,
-0.0164919738,
-0.0408659354,
0.0006648207,
-0.0273526516,
0.0093429433,
0.0424696282,
0.00312957,
0.0693004653,
0.0000018137,
-0.0902165771,
-0.0098305354,
0.0107324244,
0.0246811751,
0.0062150932,
0.0574891008,
-0.0234572794,
-0.0100038713,
-0.0258098431,
-0.0556090698,
-0.0176412091,
0.0531888567,
0.0202204399,
0.0240893941,
0.0506248884,
0.006534263,
-0.0248542782,
0.0480637848,
0.0173659381,
-0.0018478993,
0.0563608557,
0.0089722481,
-0.055667866,
0.0379544944,
0.023687752,
0.0039144065,
0.0179509856,
0.0138791623,
-0.0611963943,
0.0526577942,
0.0193624757,
-0.0844193473,
-0.0142420745,
0.0418650247,
0.0514643043,
0.0514137596,
-0.0391057581,
0.0653603673,
0.0055628181,
-0.0065656295,
0.0197552945,
-0.064665556,
0.0606360771,
-0.0074061519,
0.0048798588,
0.0672002584,
-0.0106988586,
0.0265817102,
0.057870388,
0.0295702908,
0.08909522,
0.0088133551,
-0.0250798743,
0.0114878342,
0.01076419,
-0.0031235199,
-0.0355468243,
0.0077198027,
0.0028553822,
-0.0059733558,
0.0076399306,
-0.0061075888,
-0.0609800778,
0.0458226167,
-0.0034710222,
0.0112938862,
-0.0223114062,
-0.0282461196,
0.0209909063,
0.0115471696,
-0.0309210755,
-0.0340227708,
0.0053276038,
0.0102100624,
0.0189565383,
-0.0506418608,
-0.0236349441,
-0.0384488553,
0.0188382268,
-0.0226671062,
-0.0025322128,
-0.0135893961,
-0.0085478406,
-0.0126563879,
0.0042412868,
-0.0080948714,
0.0181065518,
-0.0444321558,
0.0260413084,
-0.0168533958,
-0.0048835897,
-0.0439944267,
0.0125009827,
0.0339062624,
-0.0590158813,
-0.0221864656,
0.0322816335,
0.017221868,
-0.0392243974,
-0.0264745504,
-0.0053953845,
0.0373675525,
-0.0261812694,
-0.0020584899,
-0.089071393,
-0.0142153939,
-0.0254878774,
0.0445965268,
-0.1055023074,
0.0131633785,
-0.0200562105,
0.011018509,
-0.0672536939,
-0.0038031817,
0.0427742712,
-0.007935903,
0.0355690047,
-0.0740972236,
-0.066031158,
0.0132585652,
-0.0190902147,
0.0351462811,
0.0299168918,
0.0301375464,
-0.0344598368,
0.0781817809,
0.0048190267,
-0.0204808712,
-0.0008008773,
0.0203791261,
-0.0440924279,
0.0081823329,
-0.0158415642,
0.0037827897,
0.065008752,
0.0073720082,
0.0583093092,
-0.024629958,
-0.0389606208,
0.0136348065,
0.067702733,
-0.0212235563,
0.0333284363,
0.0346743613,
0.0047714389,
0.0223730579,
-0.0095098717,
0.0149285505,
-0.0046030558,
0.0070426725,
-0.0040080338,
-0.0162004586,
0.0292487796,
0.0150789209,
-0.0270776749,
-0.0169116836,
-0.0016999127,
-0.0290160403,
-0.0565799996,
0.040326912,
0.0347099379,
0.02128499,
0.0071117319,
0.065109916,
-0.0365895554,
0.0402352773,
-0.0252267197,
0.0430665612,
-0.0383093022,
0.0518278703,
-0.0243556742,
0.0101101669,
-0.0494456664,
-0.0015708625,
0.0756826773,
0.0045939842,
-0.0153643088,
-0.0147851771,
-0.0081011252,
0.0331100076,
-0.0569712669,
0.0364956185,
-0.0320149511,
-0.0070538297,
0.0036154406,
-0.0103844982,
-0.0236321483,
-0.0504625961,
0.0445302837,
-0.018329503,
-0.0105333058,
0.0122298161,
-0.0402146354,
0.063832961,
0.0177626368,
-0.0161661915,
0.0392769724,
0.0325530171,
-0.0479425415,
-0.0062331054,
0.0389320776,
0.0188509282,
-0.0060264906,
0.0515137538,
-0.0939062983,
0.0199206565,
0.0217976384,
-0.0169792622,
-0.0375134945,
0.0593174323,
-0.0282478835,
0.0386475436,
-0.0289081931,
-0.0173900258,
0.0082201539,
0.0194745678,
-0.0366474688,
0.0511194617,
0.0072267666,
0.0539230146,
0.0393021293,
-0.0588131286,
0.0205895621,
-0.0225439742,
-0.0291419402,
0.0318135992,
-0.0006522866,
-0.0219347849,
0.0349023417,
0.0067094024,
-0.0680570826,
-0.0023463629,
-0.0531415828,
0.0011300445,
-0.0103770122,
0.0168885533,
0.027710285,
-0.0268085469,
0.0072850063,
0.0299586188,
0.0053984988,
-0.0104329977,
0.0118816216,
-0.0366895124,
0.0759682283,
0.0016292648,
0.003423573,
-0.0297773816,
-0.0218626764,
-0.0364599302,
0.0378303826,
0.0602910109,
-0.0223189667,
-0.0241458323,
0.0127345435,
-0.0317729227,
-0.0129032424,
-0.0027267972,
0.0053485013,
0.0013245617,
-0.0374039114,
-0.0200910736,
0.0698432922,
-0.0149885667,
0.0424024798,
0.0323646106,
-0.0171340443,
-0.0408750437,
-0.0165650826,
-0.014407672,
0.0122703752,
-0.0000020915,
0.0052382518,
0.0739151314,
0.0560040064,
-0.0314333439,
-0.03266,
0.0179043915,
0.0362047926,
-0.0515776761,
-0.0170872025,
-0.0114242136,
0.0047343681,
-0.009297559,
0.0768878013,
0.0207717195,
-0.0190700628,
0.0579767041,
-0.0135934213,
0.0043343632,
-0.0854591727,
-0.0275502298,
-0.061408408,
0.0403840616,
0.0223830026,
0.0002796613,
0.0936252847,
-0.0200415812,
-0.0298764613,
0.0332723036,
0.0135271279,
0.0140167736,
-0.007831662,
-0.0766142607,
0.0089599872,
-0.0167370886,
-0.0074362117,
0.0067273597,
-0.0542387441,
-0.0183498655,
0.056684643,
0.037553329,
-0.0481329896,
-0.0478869826,
-0.0424901992,
0.0097921295,
0.0203892086,
-0.031163469,
-0.0094594732,
-0.0483706519,
0.0552110374,
0.0731712952,
0.0064526852,
0.0158321857,
0.0144769894,
-0.0227377247,
0.0579150021,
-0.0129598882,
0.0556115806,
-0.0230058655,
0.0084201088,
0.0284863058,
-0.0780615211,
-0.0307267867,
-0.0015904321,
-0.0037161149,
-0.061887417,
-0.0360307731,
0.0981434956,
0.0356036127,
-0.0657828897,
-0.0235676579,
-0.0467140712,
0.0501461886,
-0.0155008063,
0.0133039365,
-0.1022417918,
0.0290555656,
-0.0103548393,
0.005854344,
-0.0385652445,
-0.0639938787,
-0.0038090735,
-0.1006565467,
0.0587028638,
0.0031117694,
-0.046759937,
0.018628126,
-0.0290843491,
-0.0288210269,
-0.0278081167,
-0.040328566,
0.0110588595,
-0.0388256237,
0.0335433148,
0.0326278731,
0.0097898357,
-0.0357121937,
-0.0096620442,
-0.0574401915,
0.0369064286,
-0.0125734042,
0.0749866888,
-0.0206429344,
-0.0436756238,
0.0036647294,
-0.0297770426,
-0.0449904054,
-0.0183010809,
0.0240695868,
0.0186456665,
-0.0129816392,
-0.038621068,
0.0604503676,
-0.0516791344,
-0.0124763018,
0.0426741131,
0.098110877,
-0.0149465427,
0.0142760864,
-0.035174869,
0.0324626938,
-0.0304965656,
0.0436232239,
0.0169033669,
-0.013309489,
-0.0346156321,
-0.0391063988,
0.0276113208,
-0.0357561484,
-0.0642545596,
0.006696301,
-0.0378861018,
-0.0717260689,
-0.0778837502,
-0.0388057977,
0.0048665102,
0.0010079567,
0.021699382,
-0.0136437407,
0.0284410976,
-0.010633707,
-0.064404957,
0.0386087932,
-0.0167640932,
-0.0065586763,
-0.0491325147,
-0.0158045739,
0.0722760335,
0.0242344905,
-0.0381936543,
0.0440317094,
-0.0239423905,
-0.0558509044,
0.0392482914,
0.0188020784,
0.021273721,
0.0158249047,
-0.0278470572,
-0.0781455487,
-0.0013802116,
0.067730017,
-0.0360950679,
0.0028779227,
0.0020711292,
-0.0287302602,
-0.0157411303,
0.0209678821,
-0.01052259,
-0.00794465,
-0.0597066097,
0.0033979453,
-0.03876248,
-0.0135165695,
0.0477305017,
0.0070464252,
0.0629041344,
-0.0406575091,
0.0014640181,
-0.040739052,
-0.0338498279,
-0.0035672546,
-0.0250266697,
-0.0170455873,
0.0151113253,
-0.0036281203,
-0.0019795964,
-0.021972863,
0.0649557114,
-0.0304903779,
0.0898573175,
0.0167196188,
0.0369122699,
0.0205505099,
0.0389718525,
-0.02208733,
-0.0014325144,
-0.017467428,
0.0031925382,
-0.0744851157,
0.0493524037,
-0.0061212275,
0.0065698153,
0.0228393115,
0.0133633809,
0.0389899947,
-0.0016190577,
-0.0751023144,
0.0102060372,
0.01973591,
-0.0026214505,
0.038315773,
0.0077004042,
0.078908734,
-0.0407303423,
-0.0393026955,
-0.027619468,
0.0619213171,
0.0024290245,
-0.0153236706,
0.0316428877,
0.0214815196,
-0.0432597473,
-0.0579026304,
0.0719195083,
-0.0055833636,
-0.0065331585,
0.0744839013,
-0.0003940738,
-0.0126628708,
-0.0427040979,
-0.0354584008,
0.0393870659,
0.03165631,
-0.0023266291,
-0.059571147,
-0.0039938134,
0.0010894171,
0.0289855413,
0.0072642509,
-0.0197250918,
0.0509510413,
0.0367596671,
0.0011672175,
-0.015848238,
-0.0694843009,
0.0557158366,
-0.0079551321,
-0.0559020713,
-0.0225226246,
-6.15734851e-33,
-0.0311066099,
-0.0283679347,
0.0068883086,
0.0476288199,
-0.024530068,
0.0017237656,
-0.0356224515,
0.0210663527,
-0.0041898126,
0.051731959,
-0.0153815467,
0.0240004025,
0.0016882042,
0.0421842039,
0.0676884726,
0.015234503,
0.0178637244,
-0.0139888786,
-0.0011811786,
0.0204602648,
0.0601756945,
-0.0061794831,
0.0520281494,
-0.0637076199,
0.0617743507,
0.0014959892,
0.0030792668,
-0.0001517052,
0.0112800533,
0.0474683791,
-0.0106381578,
0.0427081734,
0.0156280678,
-0.0123782838,
-0.0119995447,
-0.0032570267,
-0.0842704326,
-0.0421532579,
0.0207793955,
0.0068976944,
-0.0242830086,
-0.0753219351,
0.0260119922,
-0.0046829013,
-0.0070208642,
0.0018894457,
0.0912859738,
0.0072399355,
-0.0159464255,
-0.0542415194,
-0.0503487401,
0.0284001194,
-0.0361567363,
0.0283215065,
0.0315669514,
0.0291188452,
-0.0033680927,
0.0470763557,
-0.0406313725,
0.0411012806,
-0.0334691145,
0.0396589302,
0.0000969766,
-0.0488035493,
0.0099597005,
0.0451936461,
-0.0180290509,
-0.0098774079,
0.0243503526,
0.0514334738,
0.0344474539,
0.0674053952,
0.0088373162,
0.0692991614,
0.0579389893,
0.024064377,
-0.0425102562,
0.0047973162,
0.0537338257,
0.0385240465,
-0.0338007174,
-0.0270204283,
0.0286652651,
-0.0145031828,
0.0024124796,
-0.0462240875,
0.0078428732,
-0.0183246303,
-0.0159058403,
-0.041364383,
-0.0219380613,
0.0120815495,
-0.0021865072,
-0.0203393176,
-0.0108525455,
0.0416118018,
-0.0031413492,
0.0376374833,
0.013010513,
0.020567771,
-0.0978839919,
-0.0237145796,
-0.0225529708,
0.0236293487,
0.0352371112,
0.0069514234,
0.0531758778,
0.007605759,
-0.0198527146,
-0.0103034787,
-0.0443381406,
0.0169563983,
-0.0045338636,
0.0307443403,
0.009679608,
0.0411672741,
0.0048498684,
0.0064808917,
0.0470302179,
0.0416715927,
-0.0199338831,
-0.00293219,
-0.0061236229,
0.0139547009,
-0.0176198091,
-0.0202662647,
-0.0253928434,
0.0566533841,
0.0413265117,
-0.044312574,
0.0132544935,
-0.0363686904,
2.69e-7,
0.0388044193,
0.0233165007,
0.0253446233,
0.0270893537,
0.0416264683,
-0.0088282889,
0.0152103845,
0.0539543293,
-0.0287047494,
-0.003248533,
-0.0332070701,
-0.0339840017,
0.0073163463,
0.0512142964,
-0.1235211119,
-0.0289656855,
-0.0702708811,
-0.0375443436,
-0.0681864396,
-0.0107156215,
0.0153259849,
0.0469108187,
0.0382610373,
0.0026981535,
-0.011952715,
-0.0366231427,
0.0465655997,
-0.0293316245,
-0.0052004391,
0.0307720881,
0.0027701831,
0.0057397233,
0.0049144616,
-0.0324506164,
-0.007839378,
0.0305375755,
-0.0289779846,
0.0132784992,
0.0399700701,
0.0043748668,
0.0301101506,
-0.0293718055,
-0.00236335,
-0.0455779918,
0.0455442183,
-0.0085960412,
-0.0400365889,
-0.0363535285,
-0.0115384683,
-0.0150421383,
0.0424304344,
-0.0435571484,
-0.0094598271,
0.0206160862,
-0.0149322934,
-0.0464525297,
-0.0072687021,
-0.0519115254,
-0.0310176276,
0.0171728451,
-0.022429971,
-0.0439085141,
0.0186315347,
-0.0194339771,
0.0006306343,
-0.0377476551,
0.0191258285,
2.436911599e-34,
0.0466743074,
-0.0028195721,
0.0060875602,
0.0610630512,
0.016898457,
0.0016176035,
-0.0188590009,
0.0259921495,
0.0270361621,
-0.0448760688,
0.002529646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14994v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14994v3 | RefGPT: Dialogue Generation of GPT, by GPT, and for GPT | 2023-05-24T10:30:42 | 2023-10-19T00:45:51 | Dongjie Yang, Ruifeng Yuan, Yuantao Fan, Yifei Yang, Zili Wang, Shusen Wang, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have attained the impressive capability to
resolve a wide range of NLP tasks by fine-tuning high-quality instruction data.
However, collecting human-written data of high quality, especially multi-turn
dialogues, is expensive and unattainable for most people. Though previous
studies have used powerful LLMs to generate the dialogues automatically, they
all suffer from generating untruthful dialogues because of the model
hallucination. Therefore, we propose a method called RefGPT to generate
enormous truthful and customized dialogues without worrying about factual
errors caused by the model hallucination. RefGPT solves the model hallucination
in dialogue generation by restricting the LLMs to leverage the given reference
instead of reciting their own knowledge to generate dialogues. Additionally,
RefGPT adds detailed controls on every utterance to enable high customization
capability, which previous studies have ignored. On the basis of RefGPT, we
also propose two high-quality dialogue datasets generated by GPT-4, namely
RefGPT-Fact and RefGPT-Code. RefGPT-Fact is a dataset with 100k multi-turn
dialogues based on factual knowledge and RefGPT-Code has 76k multi-turn
dialogues covering a wide range of coding scenarios. Our code and datasets are
released in https://github.com/mutonix/RefGPT. | [
0.0351870432,
0.0650042444,
0.0002041027,
0.0397158451,
-0.0297850352,
0.0036673753,
-0.0281482935,
-0.0095641296,
0.0166474134,
-0.038694445,
-0.0188887231,
-0.0072585908,
0.0034264845,
0.028437309,
0.0429672934,
-0.0665290579,
0.0491234176,
-0.0285239331,
0.0225647744,
-0.0157036614,
0.0288033355,
0.0484354571,
-0.0357906893,
0.0478351526,
-0.0493669473,
-0.0342739597,
-0.0182378534,
0.0174712967,
0.0316997617,
-0.0000943845,
0.0184037238,
0.0494055115,
0.0071372436,
0.0409664735,
0.0000020893,
0.0034636157,
-0.0198428817,
-0.0267346315,
-0.0384680778,
0.0368423834,
0.0072073261,
0.0124064824,
-0.0177693292,
0.0351593867,
-0.0553178526,
-0.0264054742,
0.0418777354,
0.0839030221,
0.1296363771,
0.0938335285,
-0.0039693215,
-0.0262508988,
0.0246931072,
-0.0082497979,
0.0317853689,
-0.0272963382,
-0.0179352574,
0.0455086157,
-0.0052585653,
0.0179481767,
0.0158717185,
0.0232722778,
0.0364413746,
-0.0189164504,
-0.0251187924,
0.0265923906,
-0.0749744549,
0.0109764049,
-0.0235792976,
0.0840795711,
-0.0062866551,
-0.0210549515,
0.0033684215,
-0.0055313855,
0.010502168,
-0.0503792167,
-0.0306637436,
0.0322963558,
-0.0282766018,
0.0195805579,
-0.0030877839,
-0.0117578479,
-0.0013474603,
-0.0046770205,
0.007388392,
0.042043183,
0.0172437355,
-0.0146545218,
-0.0274498425,
0.0005280678,
-0.0140448939,
-0.0616909415,
-0.0003671059,
0.0068405694,
-0.0663551912,
0.0232902132,
-0.0675614253,
0.0420924947,
0.0237566568,
-0.0113997636,
0.0184335802,
0.0332719795,
-0.0080429409,
0.0223662164,
-0.0072836885,
0.0533473976,
-0.039909672,
0.0303399917,
-0.0152404653,
-0.0065798331,
-0.0347066261,
-0.0140317995,
-0.0729090497,
0.0137986746,
-0.0548997112,
-0.0142335966,
-0.0099542309,
0.0378322564,
-0.0045836046,
0.0342585407,
0.0138069456,
0.018259408,
-0.0314621627,
-0.0248622615,
-0.0039837686,
0.0104682688,
-0.0343842246,
-0.0320126638,
0.0487043634,
-0.0865077153,
-0.0310386959,
0.0341956168,
-0.0051644468,
-0.0153391911,
-0.0091199409,
0.0550581664,
-0.0176342633,
0.0110497493,
-0.0294210669,
-0.0523871109,
-0.0258568637,
-0.0830999538,
-0.0208016206,
-0.0508287624,
0.0363009386,
-0.0123821096,
-0.0089367088,
-0.028053578,
0.0269501582,
0.0340025686,
-0.011286295,
0.0452456363,
-0.0138999186,
0.0095078684,
0.0543218404,
0.0151279233,
-0.0242042262,
0.0464135595,
0.0532293133,
0.0051072026,
0.0149619905,
-0.0229165033,
0.047340516,
0.0274011493,
0.0250623766,
0.0196680836,
0.0340870656,
0.003118939,
0.0185752623,
0.0415904261,
0.043424245,
0.0793592185,
-0.0468249172,
-0.0112276832,
0.0730997995,
-0.0437867492,
-0.0184314046,
0.0446045473,
0.0533902943,
0.0597014353,
0.0158238988,
0.0311821662,
-0.0457928553,
0.0306350775,
0.0132085215,
0.0352610648,
0.0777135193,
0.0104197189,
-0.0267191399,
-0.0209304839,
0.019794615,
0.0080729816,
0.0016708289,
-0.0111785466,
-0.0269589666,
0.027532313,
-0.0977261513,
0.0823294818,
0.0084536262,
-0.0627055317,
-0.0338278785,
-0.0351012051,
0.0092089754,
0.0583629534,
0.0704930201,
-0.0112770125,
-0.0510039292,
-0.0354978368,
-0.0139576001,
0.0623058081,
0.0416470952,
-0.0101848608,
0.0154016279,
-0.0701742694,
0.019905366,
-0.0303067528,
0.0109252054,
0.033576604,
0.030351866,
-0.0115293134,
0.0339431986,
0.0134187732,
-0.0116642835,
0.011308345,
-0.0145524479,
-0.0227931906,
0.0020756633,
-0.0222180765,
0.017534785,
0.0159557275,
-0.0173059069,
0.0149976769,
0.0114887618,
0.0066812988,
-0.0075356341,
0.0163800716,
-0.0855517238,
-0.0624219775,
0.0294779353,
-0.0338252522,
-0.0208721478,
0.0129365223,
-0.0287195873,
-0.0466610827,
-0.0174316354,
-0.0673372522,
0.0351832472,
-0.0489805304,
0.0207392126,
0.0600680783,
0.0280752964,
-0.0064984527,
0.0428104922,
0.0023878943,
-0.0186524969,
0.0534950383,
0.0436185785,
0.012568702,
-0.0632585362,
0.0129392492,
0.0286634471,
0.0029161603,
0.0149398809,
0.0162133612,
0.0356639288,
-0.0584934168,
-0.036382515,
-0.1105299965,
0.0213140789,
-0.0055374964,
-0.0248916894,
0.0327585861,
-0.0082927952,
-0.0266413167,
0.0099665755,
-0.0592348874,
-0.0256261881,
0.041933585,
-0.0118243815,
0.0257114824,
0.0030676848,
-0.000741496,
-0.0242759101,
0.0261430889,
0.0016318582,
0.0022038596,
-0.0049347328,
0.0104751103,
-0.074287124,
0.0194713585,
-0.0341311321,
0.0271283071,
0.0015589877,
-0.053235434,
0.020892445,
0.0109244268,
0.0940487534,
0.028414296,
0.0364540219,
0.0141944159,
0.0026871709,
-0.0468965992,
-0.0321041234,
0.051598262,
-0.0086855413,
-0.0187537391,
-0.010923557,
-0.0313425735,
0.0271503143,
0.0285781994,
0.0614642352,
0.0310388859,
-0.0787439197,
0.0146288574,
0.0282023773,
-0.0240121372,
0.0381092988,
-0.0061336015,
-0.0550267957,
0.0053722681,
-0.0238735732,
-0.0420181528,
0.0621681325,
-0.0650232881,
-0.0381572545,
-0.0349753574,
0.0198204387,
-0.0196744613,
0.0346007422,
0.0029167959,
0.0106674209,
-0.0047217305,
-0.0190869458,
-0.0315014198,
-0.0003160635,
0.0187872723,
-0.0456695706,
0.0476019196,
-0.0617451444,
-0.0108228,
0.0033725824,
-0.0394580588,
-0.0639771149,
-0.0376953371,
-0.0026555653,
-0.0255337637,
0.0248100366,
-0.0361561961,
-0.0252481475,
-0.0077236439,
0.0162478834,
0.0382746086,
-0.0291454904,
-0.0044920268,
-0.0286143254,
0.0199782066,
0.0655233935,
-0.0055926833,
-0.0105364015,
-0.0074664867,
0.031688083,
0.0590604767,
0.0149879763,
0.0357650816,
-0.0096883131,
-0.0158571433,
-0.0006366103,
0.0002155159,
-0.0164844301,
0.0029605723,
0.0669977665,
-0.0433526449,
-0.0331425779,
0.1136674508,
0.0050299172,
-0.0330368765,
-0.009010667,
0.0011566007,
0.0826991573,
-0.0145238442,
0.0124627817,
-0.106139943,
-0.0214126669,
-0.0105174249,
0.0086227302,
-0.0308781713,
-0.0151125873,
-0.0403187983,
-0.1269725859,
0.0473710522,
0.0387654789,
0.0023274983,
-0.0476023667,
0.0199397486,
-0.0247364193,
0.0056557991,
0.0353422947,
0.0124269789,
0.015677562,
0.0162797887,
0.0071010967,
-0.0273489859,
-0.0021726203,
0.0320429802,
0.0059999358,
0.080030635,
0.0581985675,
0.0406213105,
0.0327142514,
-0.0197184552,
0.0190202557,
-0.0099695418,
-0.0257208236,
0.0095712487,
0.0636823922,
-0.019647941,
-0.0281863641,
0.0071060965,
0.0534166768,
-0.0141962934,
-0.0109445853,
0.0311011169,
0.0390405692,
-0.0405200794,
-0.0105976081,
0.0040988447,
0.0437207744,
0.0304387603,
0.0713168234,
0.0349899866,
-0.0233375281,
-0.0327739306,
-0.048582755,
0.0317290947,
-0.0704921037,
-0.0195035189,
0.0223140661,
0.0429517142,
0.0069011278,
-0.0853957236,
-0.0417922996,
0.0331935249,
0.0173342675,
-0.0253119431,
-0.0122057153,
-0.0090200091,
-0.0091322092,
0.0042888708,
-0.0117918253,
-0.059100233,
0.0009315612,
-0.0699223056,
-0.0673227757,
0.0409480557,
-0.0192516875,
0.0067463699,
0.0757267922,
-0.0819079056,
-0.0753527656,
-0.002059161,
0.0570899993,
0.0217825677,
0.0881878212,
-0.0063177398,
-0.0031496442,
-0.0265543219,
0.018105831,
-0.0399084128,
-0.0048011257,
0.033733774,
0.0449337587,
-0.0094010187,
0.0221625399,
-0.0065883291,
0.004533363,
-0.0277320538,
0.0381040536,
-0.032685928,
-0.0635067374,
0.0418804623,
0.0077905306,
0.0211119242,
-0.0219156407,
0.0366548859,
-0.0100104418,
-0.0004809695,
-0.0433587879,
-0.0249717049,
-0.0593685471,
0.0281024296,
0.0113933077,
-0.043161124,
0.0063412469,
-0.0638544485,
-0.050913278,
0.0223716684,
-0.0216427147,
-0.031511087,
0.0042703124,
-0.0202723555,
0.0273508262,
-0.0347660109,
-0.0422669686,
0.0119403228,
-0.0064582727,
0.0295420811,
0.009923473,
0.1077207848,
0.0185109228,
-0.0478191935,
0.0251424368,
0.0350605808,
-0.033466246,
-0.0358323976,
-0.0409564413,
0.0257224273,
0.0405721366,
0.0226530675,
0.0647263825,
-0.0503749177,
0.0111667886,
-0.0140066836,
0.059594512,
0.0163211245,
-0.0406344011,
0.0086147496,
0.0248501133,
-0.0369831286,
-0.0047938116,
0.0737881586,
0.0176125374,
0.0359064303,
0.0127822133,
0.0139725683,
-0.0769218504,
-0.055734776,
-0.0284213983,
-0.0322405398,
0.0014759452,
0.0015204413,
-0.0402405895,
-0.0439405702,
-0.0084425714,
0.0254006945,
0.0165796131,
-0.0255060624,
0.0520918034,
0.0384399928,
-0.0345362872,
-0.0019686476,
-0.0386112705,
0.0347407497,
0.0244542845,
-0.0288205463,
-0.0443920605,
-6.317133825e-33,
-0.0378397033,
-0.0451634005,
0.0307060555,
-0.0088883629,
-0.0421766229,
-0.0405374169,
-0.0308146533,
-0.0071175159,
-0.0060710404,
0.0065923971,
-0.0095221465,
0.017149251,
0.013056023,
0.051438652,
-0.0147047481,
-0.0316555984,
0.0543569028,
0.0148137473,
-0.0322454534,
0.1004183739,
0.0152277173,
0.0010224378,
0.0404256657,
-0.087558113,
0.0043558911,
-0.0445128381,
-0.0556276217,
0.0121738603,
-0.0228673276,
0.0513841212,
-0.0225819107,
0.0344358087,
-0.0006273114,
-0.0617585443,
-0.0423964225,
-0.0080507342,
-0.0133446176,
-0.0006019234,
0.0309609435,
0.0099260053,
-0.0170497764,
-0.0424945988,
-0.0162227266,
-0.0475942269,
0.0173022132,
-0.0180450976,
0.0001217273,
-0.0194220785,
-0.0175723452,
0.0126071563,
-0.0374313258,
0.0179058984,
-0.0220021047,
-0.0505724028,
-0.0238547791,
0.0480055325,
0.0137491561,
-0.037502721,
-0.0434660278,
0.0364663824,
0.017492367,
0.0071318611,
0.0234977063,
-0.0029175349,
0.0120335575,
0.0462269112,
0.0162930433,
0.0024700654,
-0.0191521961,
0.0022485733,
-0.0409780331,
0.059460178,
0.0142808212,
0.0561693124,
-0.0028268083,
-0.0185250808,
0.0128492713,
0.0022561641,
-0.018179426,
0.0170174446,
0.016403228,
0.004355744,
-0.0214385651,
-0.0136761535,
-0.0053092525,
0.0032972358,
0.0085103344,
-0.0234767646,
0.0306924023,
0.014054345,
-0.0174841546,
-0.0222708341,
0.039350301,
-0.0166452248,
0.0178538375,
0.036111366,
-0.0766298771,
0.0003949919,
-0.0413465984,
0.0243676808,
-0.0075567854,
-0.0205240659,
0.0598767884,
0.0177274588,
0.0249323752,
0.0323102437,
0.0061325836,
0.0182761345,
-0.0529228598,
0.0367259718,
-0.0375453085,
0.0734449774,
-0.0503980815,
-0.0116000772,
-0.0042950064,
-0.0152316093,
-0.0414237678,
0.038192071,
-0.0057009123,
-0.0006694486,
-0.0380104221,
0.0138131911,
0.0005070684,
0.0088156555,
-0.0326857977,
0.0332429446,
-0.0285323206,
-0.0284939483,
0.0130762104,
-0.0314495526,
-0.0118749924,
-0.0069220839,
2.675e-7,
-0.0328303836,
0.0249544699,
0.0605113022,
0.0407602675,
0.0190436561,
0.037563026,
0.0118825361,
0.0167983919,
0.022640137,
-0.0398040824,
0.0102499034,
0.0147846183,
0.0792809725,
0.0180800427,
-0.0988589153,
-0.0140257031,
-0.0736428723,
-0.0235435665,
-0.0672368035,
-0.02490573,
0.0599638224,
0.0866477117,
0.0028523835,
0.0104180202,
0.025902193,
-0.0035813625,
0.0475559607,
0.0001713986,
-0.0303663779,
0.0238086618,
0.0226808637,
0.0034727266,
-0.0189021938,
-0.0155202011,
0.0015546015,
-0.025376834,
0.0076642758,
0.0815819725,
0.0216782354,
-0.0513338745,
0.0009025455,
-0.0036735379,
0.005888198,
-0.0586104989,
0.0490484908,
-0.0161415599,
0.007770285,
0.0006263808,
-0.0146288751,
-0.0096933963,
0.0227323677,
-0.0505423211,
-0.0451486968,
0.0328959376,
0.0077395909,
-0.0035976837,
0.0229000319,
-0.0449130014,
-0.0289501343,
-0.0167412907,
-0.0729862228,
-0.020854108,
-0.0143471938,
-0.0161771197,
0.02601921,
-0.0280295704,
0.0157826412,
2.507970692e-34,
0.0291853491,
-0.0252227895,
0.049176991,
0.0232512131,
0.0543207303,
0.0064653507,
0.0298729856,
0.0174459517,
0.0158195812,
-0.0330024436,
-0.0425831154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14993v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14993v2 | Controlling Pre-trained Language Models for Grade-Specific Text Simplification | 2023-05-24T10:29:45 | 2023-11-30T14:14:31 | Sweta Agrawal, Marine Carpuat | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text simplification (TS) systems rewrite text to make it more readable while
preserving its content. However, what makes a text easy to read depends on the
intended readers. Recent work has shown that pre-trained language models can
simplify text using a wealth of techniques to control output simplicity,
ranging from specifying only the desired reading grade level, to directly
specifying low-level edit operations. Yet it remains unclear how to set these
control parameters in practice. Existing approaches set them at the corpus
level, disregarding the complexity of individual inputs and considering only
one level of output complexity. In this work, we conduct an empirical study to
understand how different control mechanisms impact the adequacy and simplicity
of text simplification systems. Based on these insights, we introduce a simple
method that predicts the edit operations required for simplifying a text for a
specific grade level on an instance-per-instance basis. This approach improves
the quality of the simplified outputs over corpus-level search-based
heuristics. | [
0.0166478772,
-0.0014393289,
-0.0239304584,
-0.0002255008,
-0.0312357135,
0.0023649905,
0.0276738983,
0.053138081,
-0.0031253884,
-0.024346713,
-0.0081791189,
0.0429773107,
0.0497546121,
0.0053787627,
0.0070952708,
-0.0862398744,
0.0365868695,
-0.0213059299,
0.0087775318,
0.009503779,
0.0371721089,
-0.0070855985,
0.0210378859,
0.0157680586,
0.01529676,
-0.0172390081,
0.009473891,
0.0279685538,
0.0018599359,
0.0522401705,
0.0460816771,
0.0712932721,
-0.0032001191,
0.0197836291,
0.0000019745,
0.0081725242,
-0.0494771153,
-0.0082985731,
0.0182086118,
0.0960163847,
0.1098168194,
-0.029337937,
-0.0346676894,
0.0379054062,
-0.003953564,
-0.0269627124,
0.0382500477,
0.0227391776,
0.065242812,
0.0618034191,
-0.0309270285,
-0.0411012322,
-0.0487251878,
-0.0214676429,
-0.0067307944,
-0.029150825,
0.0181575119,
0.0134592708,
-0.0384034403,
0.0079306811,
-0.0271883477,
0.0425039008,
0.0071335491,
-0.0527332872,
-0.0001890078,
0.0034795832,
-0.0018943024,
0.0106757451,
0.0273612197,
0.0501785353,
-0.0774735585,
-0.0705522224,
0.0015654713,
-0.0291086715,
0.0022152558,
-0.0080240406,
-0.030318547,
-0.0361860953,
0.005879546,
0.0298310611,
-0.0219367854,
-0.0018984864,
0.0199025273,
0.0102725895,
-0.0134241311,
0.010390495,
0.0258822273,
-0.0354779139,
-0.0068527618,
-0.0017740907,
0.0389002003,
-0.0667771921,
0.0917261243,
0.0262565501,
0.0136440098,
-0.0145154335,
-0.0800209641,
-0.0912687033,
-0.0077175987,
-0.0176925082,
0.0351731144,
0.0336150862,
0.0233413354,
0.0134898201,
-0.046258565,
0.0435926951,
0.0280921832,
0.0125505393,
-0.039466776,
0.0279129278,
0.0225851629,
0.0119094737,
-0.0727507323,
-0.0038530729,
-0.0355437919,
-0.0051507386,
-0.0272451118,
0.0039191297,
0.0517184772,
-0.032519266,
0.0003227947,
-0.0358220637,
-0.0291047394,
-0.0509344377,
0.0226214696,
0.0588887073,
-0.0260830782,
0.0187130962,
-0.0252318792,
0.0012483578,
0.0043043615,
0.0093981726,
0.0687264353,
0.0096049337,
-0.0053623691,
-0.0189113896,
-0.0525578335,
-0.0031806915,
-0.0511252247,
-0.0063348417,
0.0576481633,
-0.0049850489,
-0.0264258496,
-0.0511462502,
-0.0167071149,
-0.0113652153,
0.0014750795,
-0.0440275371,
-0.0206308775,
0.0156819467,
-0.0485823303,
0.0428749472,
-0.0467920825,
0.0257565547,
0.0265318044,
0.020476371,
0.0307936892,
0.0247860961,
0.0187614169,
0.0449810028,
0.0707938448,
-0.0550929867,
0.0557577312,
0.0668459088,
0.0064476826,
0.0051151449,
0.0200167876,
-0.0486316606,
-0.0742118433,
-0.0054643629,
0.0408789404,
0.0661405921,
-0.0379896834,
-0.0038004017,
0.0873057321,
0.0257028583,
0.050649289,
0.0241965912,
0.0523080565,
0.0277765896,
0.0487922728,
0.0600415505,
-0.0075444537,
-0.0229476485,
-0.0452885777,
0.031996578,
0.035195671,
-0.0055408343,
-0.0236599799,
-0.0768707171,
0.0388249829,
-0.016887309,
0.0354484133,
-0.0244945679,
0.0153942658,
0.035072051,
-0.0875235721,
-0.0243446101,
-0.0029233061,
-0.0906622484,
0.0260793958,
-0.0288123991,
0.0048838644,
0.0823101699,
0.0573835745,
-0.0113047883,
-0.0140046244,
0.0403641015,
0.0094892904,
0.0168357063,
0.0388517939,
-0.014499573,
0.029109044,
-0.0781411529,
-0.0089892074,
0.0279898942,
0.0273945611,
-0.0181025807,
0.0229191631,
-0.0335810743,
0.0318902656,
-0.055853039,
-0.0781956911,
0.0493100919,
-0.0006035105,
-0.0152021004,
0.0052853348,
0.0223545525,
-0.0349090584,
-0.0095695909,
-0.0010155829,
0.0039876318,
-0.0122532742,
-0.0035102232,
0.0104870601,
-0.0270762574,
-0.0127298515,
-0.0473810658,
-0.0031552855,
-0.0400491729,
0.0001403294,
0.0417255089,
-0.0469546095,
-0.0186254214,
-0.0302698407,
-0.0446964763,
0.0250202883,
-0.0266354438,
0.0617943555,
-0.0241301302,
-0.0351857282,
-0.0408424214,
0.0140144927,
0.0402400121,
0.0252340268,
0.0303935148,
-0.0020084928,
0.001851942,
0.003564243,
-0.003199806,
-0.0579492971,
-0.0177295078,
-0.012599675,
0.0544822216,
0.0462672561,
-0.0080560315,
-0.0091510508,
-0.0759461373,
-0.0441256091,
-0.0209186189,
0.0116823297,
0.0595497601,
0.0293236561,
-0.0147803128,
-0.0416128784,
-0.0215911604,
0.0247533936,
-0.0028594676,
0.0317933448,
0.0653724,
0.0020639473,
-0.0214461274,
-0.0675890073,
-0.0430726968,
0.0157155097,
0.0185787734,
0.0437064394,
-0.0177573562,
-0.0411574244,
0.0708148926,
0.0042901631,
0.0015854032,
0.0408679731,
-0.0502738953,
-0.0416323654,
-0.0124147683,
0.0789062008,
0.1037971005,
0.0274444688,
0.0117442617,
0.033621341,
0.0065040607,
-0.0345413834,
-0.0036603205,
-0.0239325818,
0.0039384901,
-0.0206657015,
-0.0686030686,
0.0348302312,
0.0860193968,
-0.0025492723,
0.0016146409,
-0.0565607138,
0.0019240377,
-0.0113096191,
-0.0163544081,
-0.0537999235,
-0.0134253949,
0.0099279489,
0.0380227752,
-0.024025742,
-0.0492844544,
0.0474303924,
-0.009175336,
0.0129487524,
-0.0535813607,
0.0258643515,
-0.0246435739,
0.0082245376,
0.0139467418,
0.0392684415,
-0.0017161387,
-0.0217629857,
-0.0499599874,
0.0268881433,
0.0226685014,
-0.0128428936,
0.0191756953,
-0.0712033138,
-0.0068025254,
-0.0371817909,
-0.0459126234,
0.0054655927,
-0.0252356604,
0.01912909,
-0.0144923609,
0.0566683076,
-0.0371603258,
-0.035359472,
0.0088873189,
0.003785261,
0.1175192744,
-0.015371304,
-0.014779333,
-0.0138489008,
0.0311115794,
0.0268404,
-0.0451553799,
0.0031021137,
-0.0271776412,
-0.0088050775,
0.0329691358,
-0.0000721642,
-0.0365170278,
0.0141095258,
-0.0201018881,
0.0340159014,
-0.06572216,
-0.010661629,
0.0237332508,
0.001557829,
-0.0827933699,
-0.0054443376,
0.1026247665,
0.0285357703,
-0.0221497994,
-0.0108025875,
0.0096977269,
0.0259759165,
-0.0279200282,
0.0192706231,
-0.0602549203,
-0.0111708371,
0.0232746843,
0.0197678898,
0.021371292,
0.0048912503,
-0.0154759055,
-0.0369380638,
0.0144720515,
0.0213496555,
-0.0252877716,
-0.0294620302,
-0.0151952896,
0.0078971907,
-0.0081304945,
-0.0186102744,
0.0318365172,
-0.0341992453,
0.0098664379,
-0.0368828326,
-0.0621848553,
-0.0257498883,
-0.0359997973,
0.0020945326,
0.0078570219,
0.0407027341,
0.0295260474,
0.0134246871,
-0.0000954133,
0.0594274551,
0.0098909838,
-0.0069413572,
-0.0454360582,
0.0315173417,
0.0292866882,
0.0058806883,
-0.0330653451,
0.0324560553,
0.021701077,
0.0255559795,
0.0025479903,
0.004906971,
0.0407144278,
-0.0734051466,
-0.0076691778,
-0.0154130338,
-0.0038747252,
0.07067734,
0.0550177917,
-0.0228726026,
-0.0569424294,
-0.06708505,
0.0041033775,
-0.0855154097,
-0.0667125508,
-0.0090669226,
-0.0360098146,
-0.0598386601,
-0.0690543652,
-0.0332132988,
0.0415103473,
-0.0236924905,
0.0203069486,
-0.009564518,
0.0360760987,
-0.008805153,
-0.0326951221,
-0.0264956392,
-0.0268779378,
0.0054835468,
-0.074354656,
-0.0123913288,
-0.0104974536,
-0.0106328316,
-0.0028894981,
-0.0039752056,
-0.0260432027,
-0.0326328278,
0.0159614459,
0.0579179302,
0.0140634673,
0.0187533852,
-0.0116983,
-0.0895063505,
0.0509759113,
-0.0022223818,
-0.0203340594,
0.0582906492,
0.0394743606,
-0.0266934112,
0.0154950731,
0.0387808457,
-0.0200829934,
0.0471151732,
0.0234048963,
0.0084122354,
-0.02359543,
-0.0366589502,
0.0109633878,
0.0317679755,
0.0081304135,
-0.0002654914,
0.0044738953,
-0.0294409785,
0.0152790938,
-0.0663353801,
0.0090786209,
-0.0380731225,
0.0406496674,
0.0336982235,
0.0468664542,
-0.0479795299,
0.0513344631,
0.0025937418,
0.0092665488,
-0.0113012735,
0.0149432244,
-0.0380973481,
0.0193579886,
0.0473932624,
-0.011813052,
-0.0278402716,
0.016065063,
-0.0245354101,
-0.0083186151,
-0.0086327177,
0.0026071591,
0.0151651585,
0.0260001961,
-0.0330901369,
0.064657934,
-0.0138629852,
0.0134355193,
-0.0402279347,
-0.0018253044,
0.0134818181,
0.0143579934,
0.0665211007,
-0.0372052491,
-0.023337882,
-0.0492666811,
0.0056882538,
0.0568148978,
-0.0107300188,
-0.0265729018,
-0.0074504362,
0.0038849148,
-0.0019673316,
0.1059427634,
-0.0213547125,
0.0426008701,
0.0055156378,
-0.0163635369,
-0.0253220443,
-0.02925702,
-0.0147525715,
0.0427879617,
-0.0192365684,
-0.0364724435,
-0.0343339071,
-0.0464531742,
-0.0013929791,
0.0282333568,
0.0025236565,
-0.0034378688,
0.0104107931,
0.0489517488,
-0.0344360955,
-0.0049443808,
-0.021364728,
-0.0164598171,
-0.0161091238,
-0.0491767861,
-0.0048873741,
-5.79767883e-33,
-0.0249339286,
0.004477541,
-0.0143635264,
0.0016613029,
-0.0040835198,
0.0359010436,
-0.0765814781,
-0.0062144627,
0.0071348562,
0.0288061742,
-0.035505347,
0.0160539635,
0.01483294,
0.0118058799,
-0.017721789,
0.0716833025,
0.0957300514,
-0.0225866772,
-0.043606557,
0.0180515759,
-0.0134138232,
0.0241726283,
0.026782183,
-0.0619178079,
-0.0306463912,
0.0018120989,
-0.0652288496,
0.0123763373,
0.029238781,
0.0142319864,
0.0020080728,
0.0164686386,
0.0258634426,
-0.0201795902,
-0.0449412838,
0.0653405562,
-0.0929062888,
-0.0168810096,
0.0446483754,
0.0131950397,
-0.0563026741,
-0.0755227879,
0.048889868,
-0.0343829319,
-0.0052935835,
-0.0290859267,
0.0327612273,
-0.0424397998,
0.0190095771,
-0.0782095566,
-0.0442649871,
0.0365622044,
-0.033575017,
-0.0167093612,
0.0380376428,
0.0231795553,
-0.0123046115,
0.0035197746,
-0.0206217859,
0.0461923033,
0.0746265128,
0.0738260001,
0.0373148806,
-0.0308089089,
-0.0000374594,
-0.0084242374,
0.0025820769,
0.024713045,
-0.0300400164,
0.0024471285,
0.0598990619,
-0.0030668809,
0.0652884245,
0.0258435365,
0.0407440849,
-0.0135179348,
-0.0313303061,
0.0556313954,
-0.0158990212,
0.0034710905,
-0.0233359355,
0.0252077132,
-0.0222147182,
-0.0313541889,
-0.0320462994,
0.0291050933,
-0.0224865824,
-0.0204507671,
0.0091266939,
0.0313550048,
-0.049539838,
-0.0034571481,
0.0151179545,
-0.0086448863,
-0.0064053303,
0.0294533148,
-0.0213774871,
0.0447106324,
-0.017655246,
-0.0110218115,
-0.0077133365,
0.0191066209,
0.0369350091,
-0.0180628933,
-0.0160139874,
0.018858362,
0.0246642362,
0.0268785171,
-0.0854706317,
0.0080702035,
0.0340104066,
-0.0161808655,
0.0412555225,
-0.0068053273,
0.0000791831,
-0.0017561547,
0.0123818219,
0.0106226048,
0.0274722278,
-0.0238066297,
-0.0513614565,
0.0118169095,
0.0433879606,
0.033759702,
-0.0051465505,
-0.0138374008,
-0.0310027357,
0.0064112036,
0.0445802547,
-0.0205712598,
-0.0270222537,
-0.0023147133,
2.371e-7,
0.0690069124,
0.0612589791,
0.0373186469,
0.0000012606,
0.0232465472,
0.0243171491,
0.0514569879,
-0.0249337163,
-0.0084103681,
0.0476573929,
0.0635406449,
-0.0186970048,
0.024842022,
-0.031754788,
-0.050667461,
-0.0006151804,
-0.020106243,
-0.0342181996,
-0.0193653628,
-0.0314044915,
0.0168529227,
0.0305959191,
-0.0135647161,
0.0086559281,
0.0085108913,
-0.0334740877,
0.0212187376,
-0.041768346,
0.0301065277,
0.0708297864,
0.0453826897,
-0.0360811353,
-0.0072098407,
0.0045024971,
-0.0400408991,
-0.0233529918,
0.0369956046,
0.115254201,
-0.0263298023,
0.0622731484,
0.0097167408,
-0.0608075857,
-0.011400301,
-0.0292481594,
0.0637473166,
-0.0280538891,
0.0479124747,
0.0270299278,
-0.0035455618,
0.0007241105,
0.0031863537,
-0.0080686333,
-0.0580396615,
0.0477759726,
0.0356044061,
0.0207099132,
-0.014451378,
-0.0803931504,
-0.0503999032,
-0.0226873886,
0.0130915903,
-0.0154335918,
-0.0564458035,
0.0243540108,
0.0214756038,
-0.0559376068,
0.0142736966,
2.44594913e-34,
0.0435875021,
-0.0278831162,
0.0100020869,
-0.0021902018,
0.0196213666,
-0.0259420127,
0.0072984817,
0.0160963759,
0.0056322422,
-0.0756931975,
-0.0221586302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14992v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14992v2 | Reasoning with Language Model is Planning with World Model | 2023-05-24T10:28:28 | 2023-10-23T07:24:28 | Shibo Hao, Yi Gu, Haodi Ma, Joshua Jiahua Hong, Zhen Wang, Daisy Zhe Wang, Zhiting Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable reasoning capabilities,
especially when prompted to generate intermediate reasoning steps (e.g.,
Chain-of-Thought, CoT). However, LLMs can still struggle with problems that are
easy for humans, such as generating action plans for executing tasks in a given
environment, or performing complex math, logical, and commonsense reasoning.
The deficiency stems from the key fact that LLMs lack an internal
$\textit{world model}$ to predict the world $\textit{state}$ (e.g., environment
status, intermediate variable values) and simulate long-term outcomes of
actions. This prevents LLMs from performing deliberate planning akin to human
brains, which involves exploring alternative reasoning paths, anticipating
future states and rewards, and iteratively refining existing reasoning steps.
To overcome the limitations, we propose a new LLM reasoning framework,
$\underline{R}$easoning vi$\underline{a}$ $\underline{P}$lanning
$\textbf{(RAP)}$. RAP repurposes the LLM as both a world model and a reasoning
agent, and incorporates a principled planning algorithm (based on Monto Carlo
Tree Search) for strategic exploration in the vast reasoning space. During
reasoning, the LLM (as agent) incrementally builds a reasoning tree under the
guidance of the LLM (as world model) and task-specific rewards, and obtains a
high-reward reasoning path efficiently with a proper balance between
exploration $\textit{vs.}$ exploitation. We apply RAP to a variety of
challenging reasoning problems including plan generation, math reasoning, and
logical inference. Empirical results on these tasks demonstrate the superiority
of RAP over various strong baselines, including CoT and least-to-most prompting
with self-consistency. RAP on LLAMA-33B surpasses CoT on GPT-4 with 33%
relative improvement in a plan generation setting. | [
0.0438626222,
0.0398900956,
-0.0091001131,
0.0080494462,
-0.0580541082,
0.0056610773,
-0.035505183,
-0.0174021795,
-0.0029081015,
-0.0042906408,
0.0124949813,
0.0162744969,
-0.0148775997,
0.0331457891,
0.0143040661,
-0.0434676819,
0.0280072074,
-0.0659084171,
0.0358195938,
-0.0204150379,
-0.050903175,
-0.0076734079,
-0.0189871099,
0.0368756577,
0.0036188504,
-0.0064153527,
-0.0621962473,
-0.0167384036,
0.035325598,
-0.0527390204,
-0.0402859859,
0.010995918,
0.0596914329,
-0.0049709319,
0.0000022477,
-0.0667659491,
-0.0092561571,
-0.0421739854,
-0.0335737169,
-0.0614593104,
-0.0418329202,
0.0264800265,
0.0030347593,
0.023716135,
-0.0585008189,
0.025525514,
0.005610453,
0.0436976813,
0.0272603612,
0.0636658669,
0.0132498629,
-0.0429867543,
-0.0130357854,
-0.0130164856,
0.0387438126,
-0.0749411806,
0.0078302957,
0.0365167893,
0.0579244792,
0.0252695903,
-0.0046422151,
-0.0055173538,
0.041166231,
-0.0265105274,
-0.051089406,
0.065552026,
0.0032048414,
-0.0126276752,
0.009413938,
0.0410332009,
-0.0045387982,
-0.0276113283,
0.0343351737,
0.0250170138,
-0.0025956752,
-0.0212956946,
-0.0370716862,
0.0947533697,
-0.0117167858,
0.026838107,
0.0522251613,
-0.0091559393,
0.031407591,
0.0148856146,
-0.0444955342,
0.1201226115,
-0.0228381734,
-0.0236323513,
0.0408195816,
-0.0034622166,
-0.0045897495,
-0.0835311413,
-0.0022120837,
0.0730282366,
-0.0775781944,
0.0404645354,
-0.0018622457,
0.0565935262,
-0.0371359996,
-0.0056782747,
0.0360252932,
0.0701886639,
0.0380863696,
0.0562010035,
-0.0167190693,
0.036004927,
-0.021796884,
0.0277244207,
-0.0465798751,
0.0024951128,
-0.0638376474,
-0.0036785733,
-0.026954744,
0.0403918065,
-0.0429835357,
-0.0215338655,
-0.0116769951,
0.0441603921,
-0.0110449418,
0.0361258462,
0.0402811468,
0.0127088511,
0.0234156847,
-0.0284743384,
-0.0937188417,
-0.0217316244,
-0.061028786,
0.0061460878,
0.0069991658,
0.0127496598,
-0.0106085557,
0.0058601392,
-0.0222352222,
-0.0220917147,
0.0267165937,
0.0944637284,
-0.0079895621,
-0.0045751771,
-0.0533499606,
-0.0336492024,
-0.0035260185,
-0.0862845778,
0.0760993063,
-0.054553654,
0.0308175348,
0.0065143364,
-0.0332374908,
0.004281282,
0.0298479684,
0.0142266685,
0.0034568757,
0.0588507131,
0.0586587191,
0.0167716257,
0.0007336157,
0.0085219452,
-0.0195782632,
0.0642746016,
0.0583810173,
0.0552170798,
-0.0257846378,
0.058586508,
-0.0104755713,
0.0382914953,
-0.0058916393,
-0.015805291,
-0.0032640602,
0.0179072581,
-0.0332582369,
0.0241127815,
-0.0237043146,
0.0043801176,
-0.0215611812,
0.011572279,
0.0225118175,
0.0230246875,
-0.0028680365,
-0.0076139965,
0.0457672067,
-0.0349165611,
-0.0244448986,
-0.0543183349,
-0.0571040697,
0.0723955631,
-0.0478593484,
0.0022752793,
-0.0294943396,
-0.0146988221,
-0.0152181191,
-0.0330516547,
-0.0122477487,
0.0317620151,
0.0203360561,
0.0213923696,
0.030973671,
-0.0226483382,
-0.0509510636,
0.0190247726,
-0.0210983716,
0.0215452127,
-0.009272513,
-0.0702980906,
0.0464589223,
0.0492257737,
0.0523403361,
-0.031289611,
-0.0267572161,
-0.0036292251,
-0.0132573489,
0.0503956899,
-0.0161452908,
-0.0298145302,
-0.0227610022,
-0.0281040668,
-0.0464039631,
-0.035547249,
-0.0147362892,
0.0384181142,
0.031554874,
0.015475221,
-0.0159254,
-0.0366308503,
0.0344407484,
0.0259958711,
-0.0442625955,
0.0025229191,
-0.0288882069,
0.0017282655,
0.0404144488,
-0.0038851413,
0.0054295515,
0.0358298607,
0.0073817922,
-0.0168453995,
-0.0425620042,
0.0304194298,
-0.0387552418,
-0.0465254895,
0.0486276969,
-0.0417010635,
-0.0095102256,
-0.0026280137,
-0.0201884024,
-0.0468820482,
0.0198202115,
0.0043028784,
0.0014624869,
-0.0297920741,
0.0287506394,
0.011325974,
-0.0560224466,
-0.0111202663,
0.0979016721,
-0.0122226402,
-0.0419810303,
0.0272390936,
0.008308474,
0.0030991577,
-0.0429719277,
0.0105253737,
0.0233546682,
-0.0001746362,
-0.0184293278,
0.0165105835,
0.044268392,
-0.0515186004,
-0.0397053175,
-0.0882086083,
0.0193107445,
-0.0039376337,
0.0106246769,
0.0102929091,
-0.0153579153,
0.0032650116,
-0.0009748275,
-0.0222531743,
0.031493526,
0.0233122241,
0.0166734848,
0.0188225862,
0.0208157878,
-0.0015297841,
-0.007624039,
0.0104865078,
-0.0373920947,
0.0020541595,
-0.0062781973,
-0.0097014941,
-0.0389021859,
0.0575304776,
-0.0441690572,
0.0311367586,
-0.0320121609,
-0.0105342064,
0.0413384624,
-0.0356103815,
0.01014766,
0.0697262362,
-0.0035221884,
0.0209561009,
0.0681084022,
-0.0303533245,
-0.0548416972,
0.0572473258,
-0.019198373,
0.0028009994,
-0.0364149325,
-0.0293753371,
-0.0125293927,
0.063289769,
-0.0177794285,
0.0332687907,
-0.0396691225,
0.023048766,
0.0171838831,
-0.0434309095,
-0.0328056701,
-0.0092628142,
-0.0062839268,
0.0651609302,
-0.0148652932,
0.0045733466,
0.0731335953,
0.0128246043,
-0.0036615087,
-0.0397214852,
0.0112516666,
-0.032278236,
0.0678403899,
-0.0017026517,
0.0075845253,
-0.0363417752,
-0.0053451038,
-0.0503885671,
-0.034877494,
0.0041599772,
-0.0100939944,
0.02176621,
-0.0718674734,
0.0084850797,
0.0062435381,
-0.0463780053,
-0.0615951382,
0.0316338427,
-0.0590682402,
0.0208870694,
-0.0202664491,
-0.0200222265,
-0.0245787557,
-0.0050094812,
0.0519141704,
0.0355386026,
-0.0132323634,
-0.0191447809,
-0.0113079622,
-0.0221689288,
0.0545013286,
0.0081850644,
0.0374386013,
-0.0250187851,
0.0479212515,
0.0231363699,
0.0185774919,
-0.0157646779,
-0.0162395649,
0.0334481448,
-0.0092856847,
0.001069888,
-0.013747137,
0.0481379814,
0.0221887734,
-0.0371960774,
-0.0354039073,
0.1041624472,
0.0295190196,
0.0110010356,
-0.01883897,
-0.0837870687,
0.0349917635,
0.0288504194,
0.0678660646,
-0.0272310823,
-0.0365205668,
0.0360359624,
-0.0271877274,
-0.0214799307,
-0.0775041953,
0.0107019078,
-0.0926026329,
0.056077484,
-0.0106543275,
-0.0450226925,
0.0175041538,
-0.0286811553,
-0.0258857552,
0.0127498861,
-0.0419417582,
0.0158096775,
0.0342357121,
0.0104573267,
-0.0124454331,
-0.0015339906,
0.0025439973,
0.0525917485,
0.0098071685,
-0.0000375445,
0.0768020302,
0.0332630984,
0.0105710719,
-0.0347006768,
0.0214284044,
0.0499147326,
0.0277233031,
-0.0266746189,
-0.0201049708,
0.0039909282,
-0.0056981291,
-0.0078744777,
0.0421866402,
-0.0427922234,
-0.0549618043,
0.0344759375,
0.1065920666,
-0.0445255004,
-0.0183651913,
-0.0229135398,
0.0249890778,
-0.0070876749,
0.0669606552,
-0.0303931609,
-0.0201865435,
-0.0733974949,
-0.0354994275,
-0.0614380725,
-0.066718854,
-0.0078399396,
0.0195366628,
0.0259644333,
0.0387772135,
-0.0297893398,
-0.0302215628,
0.0685140416,
0.0541027524,
0.0017492684,
-0.031183064,
0.0003111617,
0.0225004759,
-0.0354828574,
-0.0215660185,
-0.0615896247,
0.0173564143,
0.005699846,
0.0195707195,
0.0098371347,
-0.0523718596,
-0.0175513756,
0.013682398,
-0.0506060943,
-0.0394838117,
-0.0335949883,
0.0724119693,
0.0270488448,
0.0201434903,
0.0027470719,
0.0235217568,
0.0440571867,
-0.0139802843,
0.0032757835,
0.0407444797,
0.0113926744,
0.0392935835,
0.0271362234,
0.0299867429,
-0.0388741381,
0.0105643412,
0.0257570464,
0.0767055005,
-0.0061297766,
-0.0082084322,
0.0117982058,
-0.0045546023,
-0.0086880634,
-0.0139613673,
-0.0177564397,
-0.0180311073,
0.0064111659,
-0.0278052017,
-0.0335022807,
-0.0295331869,
0.0338776819,
0.0381083712,
0.0110950014,
0.0490424074,
-0.0046158643,
0.0021131046,
0.0002830244,
0.0457644835,
-0.0079064835,
0.0232142154,
0.0273453668,
0.0468539633,
-0.0053145164,
0.0067179427,
-0.0356913693,
0.0091493987,
0.0568304136,
-0.0004381014,
0.0949127078,
0.0343067683,
-0.0256847143,
-0.0495787002,
-0.0137980124,
-0.0693821535,
-0.0913301185,
0.0524271913,
0.0613909364,
0.0514627136,
0.0173744336,
-0.0169078223,
-0.1006687731,
0.0183122288,
0.0280446559,
-0.0201074146,
0.0193245318,
-0.0729552284,
0.0524395518,
0.0301969722,
-0.0017524561,
-0.0359358639,
0.022976432,
0.0036016095,
0.0633892715,
-0.0030710143,
-0.007456291,
-0.044047866,
-0.038052503,
-0.0253811441,
0.0301935021,
-0.003821952,
0.0185071751,
-0.0702419579,
-0.0430561006,
-0.0149444463,
0.041462779,
-0.0195733309,
0.0030081721,
0.0319889784,
0.0301755089,
-0.0105378227,
-0.0287681576,
-0.0199298467,
0.0071164779,
-0.0116054351,
-0.0198330898,
-0.0376623161,
-5.694154879e-33,
-0.01152083,
-0.028095467,
0.0886181518,
-0.0296184998,
-0.0158344079,
-0.0489138924,
-0.0672086403,
0.0168724172,
-0.0133649549,
0.0244324133,
-0.0355817005,
0.003445514,
0.0085269865,
0.0105799353,
0.0213562306,
-0.0065559037,
-0.0055304742,
-0.0093723768,
-0.0330920927,
-0.0071380958,
0.0554069243,
-0.0062543335,
0.0333929434,
-0.0235675946,
-0.0520904288,
0.0289636161,
-0.0192927159,
0.0753199309,
-0.0360626243,
0.0290919766,
0.0018690509,
-0.0403811559,
0.0327997617,
-0.0387612209,
0.0062513603,
0.0162748154,
-0.0495261662,
-0.048076611,
0.0537677146,
-0.0232304372,
-0.0509659946,
-0.01932423,
-0.0346495211,
0.0187633298,
-0.0190761983,
0.0009507359,
0.0045956024,
-0.0327633955,
-0.0067386627,
0.0343918465,
-0.0422259979,
-0.0112699755,
0.000606361,
-0.0226878989,
0.0128852678,
0.0290310476,
-0.0200915784,
0.0066113304,
-0.0175220892,
0.0409621745,
-0.0141824177,
-0.0208525341,
0.066982016,
0.0371612869,
0.0355644338,
0.0615764298,
0.0277399551,
0.0010030934,
-0.0575019084,
-0.0033186402,
-0.0064641265,
0.0748246238,
-0.0133035462,
0.0061267279,
-0.0078732492,
0.0527501144,
-0.0757966861,
0.0169286449,
0.0100665959,
0.0775666013,
0.0511600375,
0.0110714966,
-0.0105492789,
-0.0208378937,
-0.0506054498,
0.0098619433,
-0.0272328332,
-0.014703203,
0.034837015,
0.0097093889,
0.0009454832,
-0.0372430347,
0.0294981971,
-0.028692456,
0.00278163,
0.0708634183,
-0.0126371086,
0.0137368254,
-0.0177952666,
0.0338136256,
-0.0374930054,
-0.0420526713,
-0.0011110079,
-0.0124613075,
-0.0141964043,
0.0274481811,
-0.0292140841,
0.0230549369,
-0.007315686,
-0.0178578477,
-0.074442707,
0.0239657126,
0.0050052488,
-0.0019665046,
0.0436676778,
-0.0136229824,
-0.0020480838,
-0.0017335317,
0.0223346427,
-0.0610755123,
0.0032774992,
0.0077156737,
0.0035242396,
0.0114683546,
0.0050608078,
0.0101719098,
-0.0441597253,
0.0262154378,
-0.0140231829,
-0.0686413422,
0.019380834,
0.0625612289,
2.933e-7,
-0.018132899,
0.0393678993,
-0.0118289851,
0.0405216962,
0.031106241,
0.040673241,
-0.0206856336,
-0.027555028,
0.0100337407,
-0.0620970018,
0.0199418589,
0.0537055917,
0.0126724308,
0.0242412426,
-0.0888273641,
0.008423863,
-0.0054690521,
-0.0601316914,
-0.0427248329,
-0.007403702,
0.0485090092,
0.0539564379,
0.0188375134,
0.0003718955,
0.0213450808,
-0.0603521205,
0.0577903911,
-0.0238202289,
0.0094168773,
-0.0025068582,
-0.026389271,
-0.0250652339,
0.0026386986,
0.0131375818,
0.0184754562,
0.0310474858,
-0.0366295204,
0.0777369887,
0.0127955042,
-0.0374711715,
-0.0296045225,
-0.0404193215,
0.0100000817,
-0.0620625131,
0.0846302286,
-0.0464087017,
-0.0234618187,
0.0101675373,
0.0402680002,
0.0018853507,
-0.051920779,
-0.0066029341,
-0.000283224,
-0.0087348493,
-0.0073715546,
0.0017589972,
0.0202558953,
-0.0798406452,
-0.0105339093,
0.0099638859,
-0.0536100641,
-0.0293289162,
-0.0421778187,
0.0262112562,
0.0313279778,
-0.0373834185,
-0.0462650396,
2.834765238e-34,
-0.0029482229,
-0.0149897598,
-0.0020668067,
0.0094271805,
0.0353118256,
0.0104487594,
-0.009009908,
0.0339045115,
0.0435549989,
-0.0615480579,
-0.0536014773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14991v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14991v2 | MuLER: Detailed and Scalable Reference-based Evaluation | 2023-05-24T10:26:13 | 2023-11-29T10:47:58 | Taelin Karidi, Leshem Choshen, Gal Patel, Omri Abend | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a novel methodology (namely, MuLER) that transforms any
reference-based evaluation metric for text generation, such as machine
translation (MT) into a fine-grained analysis tool. Given a system and a
metric, MuLER quantifies how much the chosen metric penalizes specific error
types (e.g., errors in translating names of locations). MuLER thus enables a
detailed error analysis which can lead to targeted improvement efforts for
specific phenomena. We perform experiments in both synthetic and naturalistic
settings to support MuLER's validity and showcase its usability in MT
evaluation, and other tasks, such as summarization. Analyzing all submissions
to WMT in 2014-2020, we find consistent trends. For example, nouns and verbs
are among the most frequent POS tags. However, they are among the hardest to
translate. Performance on most POS tags improves with overall system
performance, but a few are not thus correlated (their identity changes from
language to language). Preliminary experiments with summarization reveal
similar trends. | [
0.0211675949,
0.0512988567,
0.0156553723,
-0.0059773573,
-0.0094433278,
0.0106179258,
0.0098575372,
0.014471028,
-0.0328540429,
-0.0483872332,
-0.0113464613,
-0.0138147622,
0.055377271,
-0.0131361941,
0.0350504927,
-0.0820489675,
0.0195716452,
-0.006529233,
-0.0199091658,
0.018882107,
0.0144690974,
0.0091026211,
-0.0050083301,
0.0494250096,
-0.0031991217,
0.0182104968,
0.0179236811,
0.0332108401,
0.0621558577,
-0.0267581083,
0.0011170218,
0.0349924378,
-0.0244709477,
0.0551466569,
0.0000019798,
-0.0479629226,
-0.030500669,
0.0128108747,
0.067720145,
0.0340020508,
0.0362283252,
-0.0350955538,
-0.0132803814,
0.0309237055,
0.0026801375,
-0.0244177412,
0.0534991212,
-0.0036108019,
0.0612265058,
0.0430503674,
-0.0021105416,
0.0212444123,
-0.0326307714,
-0.0212293807,
0.0258587394,
-0.0293763299,
-0.0491045676,
0.0072032651,
-0.021390127,
-0.0042659431,
0.0082171541,
0.0165846702,
0.0016219347,
-0.0081109004,
0.0216553602,
0.0286319982,
-0.0596029311,
-0.0225460213,
0.0496382229,
0.0717604235,
0.0102566369,
-0.0221830904,
0.0204126444,
-0.0023738816,
-0.0034779427,
-0.0285470169,
-0.0447194278,
0.0244112723,
-0.0033574684,
0.0114849778,
0.0077582649,
0.0294454861,
0.0142597118,
0.0410407893,
-0.0205086172,
0.0102265859,
0.0239059497,
-0.0181137547,
-0.0314930417,
0.0592768937,
-0.0103309928,
-0.0503926128,
0.0181968771,
-0.0040966189,
-0.0763544589,
-0.0048532514,
-0.0510135069,
-0.0523026176,
0.0434109047,
-0.0486519672,
0.0542399473,
0.0194390677,
0.0256690104,
0.0119908312,
-0.0278271958,
0.0847207382,
0.0254908949,
-0.0312214158,
-0.0436438993,
-0.0049742041,
-0.0498174429,
0.0239292681,
-0.0282285195,
-0.0127850911,
-0.0346741751,
0.0026059453,
-0.0442701466,
0.004378689,
-0.0116170365,
-0.0045825751,
-0.0247612502,
-0.0008646073,
-0.044316791,
-0.0058047124,
-0.0179689527,
0.0356055759,
-0.0521621034,
-0.0289743058,
0.026103545,
-0.018205896,
-0.0200886577,
0.0340439901,
-0.0067242561,
-0.0051041427,
-0.0151831973,
0.0630051866,
-0.0219304431,
-0.0155711118,
0.0235998891,
-0.0396780707,
-0.0200817473,
-0.0455704965,
-0.0130675528,
-0.0783224702,
0.0333479047,
0.0261635333,
-0.0016841032,
-0.0394997708,
0.0200034641,
0.0256484114,
-0.0288668834,
0.0128987329,
-0.0246308949,
0.004217756,
0.0154587319,
0.0111698313,
0.0121449605,
0.0515750796,
0.0662114546,
0.0528043993,
0.0320258327,
0.0152665274,
0.0040364196,
0.0119756246,
0.0053796605,
0.0245209225,
-0.0077475049,
-0.0373657569,
-0.0202100128,
0.0462049656,
0.03875947,
0.0842630416,
-0.0120154526,
0.0833776742,
0.0599373952,
0.0061756605,
-0.0062886318,
-0.0069039492,
0.0732932389,
-0.0040925876,
-0.0060213781,
0.0163367502,
0.0012783152,
0.0250772294,
-0.0126208942,
0.0500055104,
0.0856743753,
0.0286209118,
-0.0008686933,
-0.0623148121,
-0.0144012384,
0.0117261363,
-0.0005409698,
-0.0281301904,
0.0319799036,
0.0279725958,
-0.0473073609,
0.0701177046,
-0.0028988817,
-0.0871302933,
0.0538839363,
-0.0274459366,
-0.002468532,
0.0465183482,
0.0728950426,
0.0060261339,
0.010618574,
0.008881541,
0.0124723529,
0.0761708468,
0.079338491,
0.0041325465,
-0.0033522695,
-0.0466990061,
-0.026439961,
0.0124296062,
0.0240413677,
-0.0069133574,
0.0156067191,
0.0183779914,
0.0687404051,
-0.0625178367,
-0.0987036824,
0.0297117364,
0.0139917331,
-0.0268711653,
0.0161919706,
-0.0203515086,
-0.0030092436,
0.0297149699,
-0.0326685794,
0.0355051383,
-0.0077097844,
-0.0185399856,
-0.009711192,
0.0438322313,
0.0072911936,
0.0107880235,
0.0061246669,
-0.051503621,
0.0079858974,
0.0034951123,
-0.0473832712,
-0.0496622808,
0.0089533189,
-0.0698131621,
-0.0277140327,
-0.0201340616,
0.0346160233,
0.0098238364,
-0.006593246,
-0.0457909219,
0.0441995449,
0.024846578,
0.0497284979,
0.0397253446,
-0.0255618654,
0.0116699673,
0.0064955237,
-0.0408904888,
-0.013925367,
0.0012862845,
0.0313244723,
0.0694810823,
0.0390497521,
-0.0549839288,
-0.0480265878,
-0.0563252605,
0.0177335721,
-0.0170349348,
0.0516155846,
0.0516123176,
0.0291766673,
-0.0043622288,
0.0151669262,
-0.0096556721,
-0.0003678484,
0.0414341502,
0.023133859,
0.0699197426,
-0.0051922528,
0.0444749594,
-0.0540282652,
0.0114779919,
0.0104349451,
0.0274858512,
0.0621387027,
0.0261189844,
-0.0692023933,
0.0437378995,
-0.0631923303,
-0.0578631721,
0.0530631915,
-0.0521495119,
0.025480723,
0.0158275608,
0.057539396,
0.0112777408,
0.0226997752,
0.0138472933,
0.0463450514,
-0.0110091185,
-0.0417106599,
-0.0286031105,
-0.0162089337,
-0.0356816277,
0.0300143678,
-0.0709201247,
0.0335680395,
0.0410083085,
0.0094958916,
-0.0057573244,
-0.0406026281,
0.0310751814,
-0.0456006713,
-0.0229541548,
-0.03297133,
0.0238140635,
0.0109205367,
0.0470862761,
-0.0192069989,
-0.0473485067,
0.0636447668,
-0.0483669303,
0.0137833273,
-0.0414769165,
0.0224039964,
-0.0316882469,
0.0271300264,
0.0129845412,
0.0216092747,
0.0068732784,
-0.0139283463,
-0.0463195741,
0.0205681045,
0.0420326255,
-0.0298231132,
0.0239681173,
-0.0723448098,
-0.0237622112,
-0.0318401158,
-0.0116375573,
-0.0233092308,
-0.0070115216,
0.0024665722,
0.0000373851,
0.034580756,
-0.0193388201,
-0.0262629092,
0.015693998,
0.0480709486,
0.0266709868,
-0.0167197883,
-0.0417378508,
-0.0179601293,
0.0232288875,
0.0047854926,
0.0248882454,
0.0128186019,
-0.034312766,
-0.0297100581,
0.0409465134,
0.0140622249,
0.0086962888,
-0.0111750588,
-0.0276561547,
0.0152349779,
-0.0331329517,
-0.0233928151,
-0.0071386816,
0.0668350309,
-0.0679635033,
-0.0528338924,
0.1071542948,
0.0503502153,
-0.0182872266,
-0.005296119,
-0.0014578464,
0.0950677395,
0.0033698881,
0.0303057283,
-0.0540699847,
-0.0108418101,
0.0248578489,
0.0663110092,
-0.0113715222,
-0.0106885657,
0.0022428278,
-0.1150449291,
0.0179734584,
0.0359096453,
-0.0562928692,
-0.0275328364,
-0.0368147679,
-0.0280215573,
-0.0240757857,
-0.0075791986,
0.019033175,
-0.0049622892,
0.0452714711,
0.0138435783,
-0.0459964387,
-0.0359155312,
-0.0345109068,
-0.0611497164,
0.0194141194,
0.0633893013,
0.0382232368,
0.0004049992,
-0.0215345733,
0.0103559522,
-0.0481342748,
0.0065557114,
-0.005640706,
0.0530693121,
0.0205646437,
-0.0156251732,
-0.0263992306,
-0.0031231118,
-0.0107748006,
-0.0134478416,
0.0049349065,
0.0318971723,
0.0035679417,
0.0071726306,
0.0031899749,
0.0222329795,
0.00483634,
0.0585130528,
0.0559489802,
-0.030893676,
-0.035187427,
-0.0506897829,
-0.0079620695,
-0.0923459157,
-0.015288285,
-0.0117564425,
-0.0618367903,
-0.0606988929,
-0.12654984,
-0.0616576746,
0.0045112208,
0.0260067377,
-0.0099014528,
-0.0260590762,
-0.0296818651,
0.0017693713,
-0.0455882587,
0.0295406654,
0.0095229037,
0.0011915658,
-0.0237883087,
0.0091075441,
0.0200310443,
0.0137726031,
-0.0118857706,
0.0748988986,
-0.0464740023,
-0.0629738495,
-0.0272926018,
0.0689001009,
0.0241269544,
-0.0133185685,
-0.0093274387,
-0.0262524337,
0.0075296396,
0.0401883796,
-0.0061212517,
0.0196759701,
0.0126683842,
-0.0171945207,
-0.0263663586,
0.005817621,
-0.0502227768,
-0.013569897,
-0.0446236506,
0.0757537782,
0.0189569127,
-0.0045623849,
0.0112318899,
0.0329312161,
0.0228721108,
-0.0915653557,
-0.0238520987,
-0.0176191553,
-0.0526839532,
-0.0064764144,
-0.0407167487,
-0.0486212559,
0.0131971342,
0.0029052915,
0.0036894171,
-0.0043254779,
0.0385406576,
-0.0414393209,
-0.0038386891,
0.0132539999,
-0.0263671372,
-0.0156604834,
0.0347301774,
-0.0129433116,
-0.0060842996,
-0.0391140282,
-0.034717802,
-0.0200860333,
0.0113772191,
-0.0395715572,
0.0060592759,
0.0156843141,
0.0363103189,
0.0270407293,
0.0435204841,
-0.0251752771,
0.0247186143,
-0.0317842253,
0.027571911,
0.072787866,
0.0216857437,
0.1316654831,
-0.0205553509,
-0.0025806003,
-0.0186617076,
0.0543557592,
0.0071922485,
-0.0161627885,
-0.0457988791,
0.006483539,
-0.0033135354,
-0.0246834978,
0.0831825361,
-0.0071243001,
-0.0137084201,
-0.0157646369,
-0.0195003208,
-0.0109003158,
-0.0189673509,
-0.0648327246,
-0.0213144198,
0.005621444,
-0.0326900259,
-0.0674255118,
-0.0665582046,
0.0101597896,
0.0566005521,
0.0244196709,
-0.0106442478,
0.0215191189,
0.047050748,
-0.0181832165,
0.0367432311,
-0.0514799207,
-0.0088041089,
-0.038408678,
-0.0151313758,
-0.0328590237,
-6.101086044e-33,
-0.0535940565,
-0.0606107786,
-0.0111523997,
-0.027063651,
-0.052024737,
-0.0016209877,
-0.0690421164,
0.0213590339,
0.0627689287,
0.007803347,
0.0055310428,
-0.0278935749,
0.018102102,
0.0176901687,
0.0239190627,
0.0297848787,
0.0565407611,
0.025238581,
-0.0865910053,
0.0133117484,
0.0566513985,
-0.0095991474,
0.0506625883,
-0.0234941859,
0.0573509485,
-0.0046763234,
-0.0546770357,
-0.0016731427,
0.0452835113,
0.0279086307,
0.0122082476,
0.0447939262,
0.0211351402,
-0.014577874,
-0.0488534831,
-0.027479222,
-0.0642542467,
-0.0184747037,
0.0153433848,
-0.0137846544,
-0.0314666554,
-0.0329177417,
0.0391229577,
-0.0226186216,
-0.0097061526,
-0.0138102248,
0.0249594711,
-0.0501780063,
-0.0192842539,
-0.0347844586,
-0.0562574044,
0.0239737183,
-0.0176567398,
0.0035461334,
-0.0084616365,
0.0466096178,
-0.0126367444,
-0.0195104685,
-0.0459246859,
0.0268777534,
0.002094307,
0.0491488241,
0.0894475803,
-0.0049215923,
-0.0325573832,
0.0315880105,
0.017357653,
-0.0045805969,
0.0136443703,
0.0010128451,
0.0154193956,
-0.0018687389,
0.0746914595,
0.0811564103,
0.0286749676,
0.0085698022,
-0.0485871732,
0.1012186185,
-0.0469566211,
0.0281902011,
0.0079741897,
-0.0263243839,
-0.0176034141,
-0.0113227163,
-0.0462478213,
-0.0218395814,
-0.0368046053,
-0.0375583619,
0.0201513413,
0.0249271449,
-0.0374333747,
-0.0350858122,
0.0296803247,
0.0130476542,
0.0278731026,
0.0108330268,
-0.0514373258,
0.0223762468,
-0.0327944942,
-0.0176483411,
-0.0122947069,
-0.0393453427,
0.0135185877,
0.0619439706,
0.0382025689,
-0.0148756346,
0.0166005082,
0.0105178403,
-0.0570143163,
0.0387658924,
-0.0328414664,
0.0320194066,
-0.0294038542,
-0.0206209533,
-0.0171774682,
-0.044511538,
-0.0118437288,
0.0059339628,
0.0051570982,
0.0064756684,
-0.0075856643,
0.0211021621,
0.0215539671,
0.0370373577,
-0.0363759138,
0.0325939097,
-0.0093654264,
0.0382906087,
0.0445122533,
-0.0168077219,
-0.0489713885,
-0.023159856,
2.655e-7,
0.0601486713,
0.0616816245,
0.0186956711,
0.0502681993,
-0.0321509913,
0.0161963142,
0.0039568949,
0.0461722426,
-0.0108211916,
0.0535779074,
0.0243873857,
-0.0071293558,
0.062615037,
0.0546804406,
-0.0737166777,
-0.0452094674,
-0.0601234883,
0.007894964,
-0.028119348,
-0.0257907975,
0.0469717644,
0.0191264749,
-0.0124619203,
0.0088325841,
-0.0123681528,
-0.053150773,
0.0586915947,
-0.0147379274,
-0.0321219526,
0.020248713,
0.046297282,
-0.008731137,
-0.0246752277,
-0.0173683595,
-0.0388810895,
-0.0457152985,
0.0528391823,
0.030753985,
0.0368030816,
-0.018843241,
0.0220607612,
-0.0270350315,
0.0306961741,
-0.0416761637,
0.0218723658,
-0.0177992508,
-0.0021660973,
0.0068320655,
-0.0033363125,
0.0122403475,
0.0271944962,
-0.0380160622,
-0.0725768581,
0.0172420032,
0.0069820527,
0.0384682864,
-0.018859053,
-0.0175413769,
-0.0589673519,
0.0083745606,
0.0097910939,
-0.0851406604,
-0.0090092262,
-0.0077810227,
-0.0153819248,
-0.0414532237,
-0.0043053203,
2.469676897e-34,
0.0651340336,
-0.0207529943,
-0.0129320025,
-0.0262230672,
0.0523150638,
0.0011445498,
-0.0408637188,
-0.0170444306,
0.0076416433,
-0.0327742435,
-0.0138074737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04657v1 | Improving Empathetic Dialogue Generation by Dynamically Infusing Commonsense Knowledge | 2023-05-24T10:25:12 | 2023-05-24T10:25:12 | Hua Cai, Xuli Shen, Qing Xu, Weilin Shen, Xiaomei Wang, Weifeng Ge, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xiangyang Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In empathetic conversations, individuals express their empathy towards
others. Previous work has mainly focused on generating empathetic responses by
utilizing the speaker's emotion. Besides, external commonsense knowledge has
been applied to enhance the system's understandings of the speaker's situation.
However, given an event, commonsense knowledge base contains various relations,
potentially leading to confusion for the dialogue system. Consequently,
inconsistencies arise among the emotion, generated response and speaker's
contextual information. To this end, we propose a novel approach for empathetic
response generation, which incorporates an adaptive module for commonsense
knowledge selection to ensure consistency between the generated empathetic
responses and the speaker's situation. This selected knowledge is used to
refine the commonsense cognition and empathy expression for generated
responses. Experimental results show that our approach significantly
outperforms baseline models in both automatic and human evaluations, exhibiting
the generation of more coherent and empathetic responses. Moreover, case
studies highlight the interpretability of knowledge selection in the responses
and the effectiveness of adaptive module in our model. Code:
https://github.com/Hanscal/DCKS. | [
0.0647640601,
0.0006213801,
-0.0302330088,
0.0266832262,
-0.0002459684,
0.0270437635,
-0.0300271735,
-0.0028356765,
0.0410333574,
-0.0391484648,
0.0127266459,
0.0476296879,
-0.0136142215,
-0.0036792299,
0.0093893018,
-0.0897265449,
0.0246580597,
0.0383059196,
0.0433195494,
-0.0178681817,
0.0006867276,
0.0371420048,
-0.0322312936,
0.0403600596,
-0.0357083119,
-0.0068967459,
-0.0296859089,
0.0266535524,
0.0344223157,
-0.0093242582,
0.0204138067,
0.0098744454,
-0.0112071689,
-0.0214515254,
0.0000020083,
-0.0234361775,
0.0208375379,
-0.0254300423,
0.0120636886,
-0.0213302281,
0.0560215414,
-0.0233720429,
0.0132758971,
0.0005829672,
-0.0390536152,
0.010047609,
0.0250369254,
0.0165909305,
0.0667764768,
0.0304307733,
-0.014867574,
-0.0074486849,
-0.0277377367,
0.0070844037,
-0.0029052543,
0.000618799,
-0.0108401775,
0.0187398493,
0.0302498583,
-0.0470910706,
-0.012754973,
0.0163159873,
-0.0050842222,
-0.0286660064,
0.0298261177,
0.0409994386,
0.0046176189,
-0.0081893196,
-0.0320211463,
0.1129587218,
0.0395601876,
0.0382448919,
0.0354946703,
-0.0191003494,
0.0346013904,
0.002826435,
-0.0364410281,
-0.0158845261,
-0.0006475681,
-0.0046453946,
-0.0076493314,
0.0458912142,
-0.029574981,
0.0534360558,
0.0373500884,
0.0029880635,
-0.0090513453,
0.0132487165,
-0.0341691151,
-0.0055288225,
-0.0160773862,
-0.0374027267,
0.0119458176,
0.0437217578,
-0.0264426991,
0.0167694353,
-0.0392879732,
0.0289559867,
0.0119354492,
-0.0635221303,
0.006155123,
0.0449210852,
0.0026547331,
0.004416808,
0.013599514,
0.0240760259,
0.0227200929,
0.0078305658,
-0.0200568773,
0.0279703308,
-0.0581152514,
0.0002753486,
-0.0197674669,
0.0437707119,
-0.0798084438,
0.0015487015,
-0.0434553213,
0.0204742253,
-0.0006455677,
-0.0114611294,
-0.0233230647,
0.0200758912,
-0.0589629598,
0.0180072747,
-0.036861971,
0.0335907154,
-0.0844077244,
0.0114855021,
0.0328467935,
-0.0248921849,
-0.0056162332,
0.0239123218,
0.0283852313,
-0.0127250534,
-0.0158196241,
0.0181358978,
-0.0284101777,
0.0132978996,
-0.0426693633,
-0.0184668228,
-0.0304971896,
-0.0260861982,
-0.0299801361,
-0.0062580891,
0.043229036,
0.0145854298,
-0.0241377465,
0.0168864001,
0.0356766023,
-0.0203688741,
-0.066502884,
0.0315880403,
-0.0340967625,
0.0300598294,
0.0173519254,
0.0249336958,
0.0188571196,
0.0312565416,
0.0227556303,
-0.0226807538,
0.0515063629,
0.0013654211,
0.0207165778,
-0.0314198919,
-0.0057747588,
-0.0280327871,
-0.0036837852,
-0.002718885,
-0.0623927563,
0.0461318158,
0.0680750832,
0.0037120918,
-0.0436243005,
-0.0234323684,
0.0497043021,
0.0588766262,
-0.0263824239,
0.1034606174,
0.0226642452,
0.0275319666,
-0.0035170973,
0.0404145047,
-0.0174053777,
0.0567709319,
-0.0153451441,
0.000328415,
-0.030545909,
0.00732568,
-0.0294594485,
-0.0030701987,
0.0162994377,
-0.0097809033,
0.0314864889,
-0.0210328214,
-0.0175461005,
0.000318965,
-0.0332202241,
0.044538781,
0.0191588793,
-0.1067184284,
-0.0106097199,
-0.0261365231,
-0.0113301072,
0.0917821079,
0.0512357987,
-0.0143905189,
-0.0621780269,
0.0072997082,
-0.0606327653,
0.0431286693,
0.0286206175,
-0.0324038006,
0.07496503,
-0.0608082302,
0.0121683115,
0.0029806648,
-0.0089840181,
0.0105791995,
-0.0431559235,
0.0188565534,
0.0199639797,
0.012603892,
0.0537702441,
0.0170284491,
-0.0236903988,
0.004972891,
-0.0022180083,
-0.007777479,
0.0300597213,
0.0194549263,
0.0086595761,
-0.0144299772,
0.0109114144,
-0.0019801594,
-0.0061618467,
0.1238357574,
-0.0667576864,
-0.1149798781,
0.0098472293,
-0.0427964553,
-0.0147877121,
0.0044110259,
-0.0059380983,
-0.0278131738,
0.0544879213,
-0.0285619367,
0.0399931669,
-0.072798565,
-0.0084347893,
-0.0234652199,
-0.0138707533,
0.016605325,
0.0482313372,
-0.0084928209,
-0.0255096797,
0.0129739298,
-0.0052040005,
-0.0214920044,
-0.0319217108,
0.0089511406,
0.0056876009,
-0.0030070152,
0.0008086409,
-0.024840923,
0.0197616611,
-0.0609120354,
-0.0445558876,
-0.1027779952,
-0.0116809662,
0.0053385561,
-0.0089923088,
-0.000148028,
0.0151213193,
-0.0140860379,
0.0140370568,
-0.030034557,
0.0653647408,
0.0555319823,
-0.0283385776,
0.0089040315,
0.0199099649,
0.0123305004,
-0.0310991183,
0.0282399319,
-0.0163495783,
0.0238234177,
-0.0029903862,
0.034601137,
-0.0236155093,
0.0139426375,
-0.0692862943,
0.0162427071,
-0.0120438887,
-0.1147222146,
-0.0055048638,
0.0276559815,
-0.0070846444,
0.0212194324,
0.0343872532,
0.0593568496,
-0.0259504076,
-0.0552024134,
-0.0602107383,
0.0504278243,
-0.0264377687,
0.0568869188,
-0.0224065892,
-0.0200183578,
-0.0234518647,
0.0401796103,
0.0265157502,
0.0255610105,
-0.0725635812,
-0.0274900645,
0.0353677981,
-0.061890658,
-0.0246100351,
-0.0286507811,
-0.0065362481,
-0.0101946639,
-0.0036885852,
-0.0159116201,
0.076263614,
0.0291808043,
-0.0390469618,
-0.0438369177,
0.0303205214,
0.0046232645,
0.0655860901,
-0.0668178648,
0.0182146672,
0.0023777424,
0.0028691629,
-0.0329934806,
-0.0423174053,
0.0210147444,
-0.0364132635,
0.0109558208,
-0.0341891199,
-0.0233366489,
0.0205936562,
-0.0481052399,
-0.0319930799,
-0.0497857183,
0.0237139445,
0.001568991,
0.0221937243,
0.0030195843,
-0.0057664448,
0.0058542509,
0.0533658005,
0.0194443949,
-0.010865286,
-0.0109223528,
-0.021454908,
0.0467619561,
0.0200217683,
0.0523260161,
0.0402375385,
0.0094992127,
0.0663853437,
0.0390215702,
0.0537963435,
-0.008400497,
0.0379104204,
0.0296677854,
0.0064020664,
0.0164434109,
0.0111957574,
0.0096849911,
0.0518609211,
-0.0013644415,
-0.0222539119,
0.079307057,
0.0261589121,
-0.0185444094,
0.0307073556,
-0.044543732,
-0.0127674146,
-0.0032389236,
0.0103027998,
-0.038949132,
-0.0099749267,
-0.0036815275,
0.0517546609,
-0.0529321283,
-0.061978735,
0.0239894837,
-0.0790811703,
0.0432349965,
0.0088776583,
-0.0136025716,
-0.039710477,
0.013176119,
0.008173123,
0.0418150276,
-0.0047889422,
0.0026107323,
0.0254772007,
-0.0046202745,
-0.000029899,
0.0048452076,
-0.044429414,
0.0032001594,
-0.0101511162,
0.0875234455,
0.0409109145,
0.1065160334,
0.0403648056,
-0.0117175262,
-0.0579390079,
-0.0270078517,
0.0162311979,
-0.0316135287,
-0.0044826767,
0.0026493268,
0.0010545211,
-0.0520696752,
0.0710521489,
-0.0323411934,
-0.0215109307,
0.0162673891,
0.0458726436,
-0.0487663262,
-0.0014986999,
-0.0148204155,
0.0519237034,
0.0624261312,
0.0810932368,
0.0447553322,
-0.0066763489,
-0.0099382512,
0.0074483738,
0.0309250802,
-0.0350474007,
0.0028216543,
0.0269138031,
0.0142344991,
-0.0010768006,
-0.0925118402,
-0.0638753921,
-0.0006950131,
0.0344436169,
-0.0287375897,
-0.0377003588,
0.0212399811,
0.0146692246,
-0.0430826247,
0.0096707335,
0.01706139,
-0.0121425753,
0.0330776535,
-0.0039420831,
0.0295507163,
-0.0330962017,
-0.0098012649,
0.0410481356,
0.0276910979,
-0.0437247753,
-0.0041630864,
0.0713160783,
0.0162654724,
0.0227269959,
0.0138836512,
-0.0299163274,
0.0134162642,
0.0326655656,
-0.0568467006,
0.0218741,
0.0154338004,
0.0740354359,
-0.002675971,
0.0519349277,
-0.0080062961,
0.018775668,
0.011935058,
0.0493259318,
-0.0110177118,
-0.0664965734,
-0.0372660719,
0.0083908439,
-0.0173881017,
-0.0061043324,
-0.0225093365,
0.0026277155,
-0.0088648312,
-0.0391508341,
-0.0084895007,
-0.0585085675,
0.0152688082,
-0.0388802104,
0.0117937727,
-0.0136183156,
-0.0645826086,
-0.0559195988,
0.0081204716,
-0.0343538746,
0.0064986884,
0.000143217,
0.0153513197,
-0.0020844438,
0.0037513894,
-0.0294499751,
-0.0078514572,
-0.0250087287,
-0.007950766,
-0.0243322942,
0.1104712859,
0.0237015784,
-0.065735884,
-0.0070242491,
-0.003729604,
-0.0231663585,
0.04598739,
-0.0091240061,
0.0780239925,
0.0292735957,
0.026107803,
0.0480380133,
-0.0417262688,
0.0175580699,
0.0120490994,
0.0674748793,
0.0188764296,
-0.0531467795,
0.007608036,
0.0097934864,
-0.0267930664,
-0.0115705831,
0.0393696539,
-0.1103230044,
0.0268427823,
-0.0142037719,
-0.022575628,
-0.0551116392,
-0.0249788854,
0.0596712232,
0.0017416929,
0.0019326597,
0.0507228933,
-0.0998036787,
-0.0081942445,
0.0212807264,
0.0004106824,
0.0075579332,
-0.0462542288,
0.0317890123,
0.0468170531,
0.0048390711,
-0.0094623789,
-0.010217661,
0.0667149574,
-0.1301937699,
-0.0073780539,
-0.0304490775,
-5.858933474e-33,
-0.0350491181,
-0.0246540718,
-0.0472647175,
-0.0258239247,
-0.0576938279,
-0.0022847978,
-0.0591250136,
-0.0017171674,
0.0204523038,
0.0407413691,
-0.0231412351,
0.0201215558,
-0.0060460721,
0.0062259133,
-0.0205178037,
-0.0105227781,
0.0122681931,
0.0272249412,
-0.0321609974,
0.0729568899,
0.0348006077,
0.0371645875,
0.0246619862,
-0.0480199382,
0.0004398478,
0.0003752938,
-0.0050359904,
0.0092901783,
0.0443603732,
0.0444434918,
-0.012755448,
0.0518379398,
0.0136998631,
0.0039291284,
0.0161525831,
0.038666185,
-0.017143691,
-0.0248352922,
0.0290191956,
-0.0297354199,
-0.0538259335,
-0.0361746065,
0.0326089002,
0.0256648175,
-0.0205552801,
-0.012066287,
-0.001177516,
-0.0258788951,
0.0149939489,
-0.0399820656,
-0.0453856923,
-0.0020151862,
-0.0569948703,
-0.056567058,
-0.0481649786,
0.0203467999,
-0.0060803886,
-0.0128934039,
-0.0075856545,
-0.0068710814,
-0.0326746181,
-0.0462994203,
0.0031830191,
-0.0336068645,
0.0177087411,
0.0825928673,
-0.0417802185,
0.015145015,
-0.0251678918,
0.023495404,
-0.0024636295,
0.043470636,
0.026537301,
0.130234465,
-0.0527252704,
-0.04416072,
-0.0163680539,
0.050871212,
0.0445587933,
0.032724306,
0.0294976626,
0.001407902,
-0.0234262738,
0.0149791734,
-0.0279517211,
-0.0549274422,
-0.0051847319,
-0.0144256474,
0.004262744,
-0.015179731,
-0.0318243057,
-0.0306725148,
0.0020871605,
-0.0102043748,
0.0401996672,
0.0215351582,
-0.0504600666,
0.0175184458,
-0.0104300575,
0.0034359863,
0.0132003892,
-0.0354723558,
0.0427957997,
0.0034006971,
0.035220515,
0.0346549377,
-0.024877103,
0.0019410865,
0.006111362,
0.0015188465,
-0.0192346703,
0.058081191,
-0.0347389057,
-0.0399734937,
-0.017347239,
0.0072496831,
-0.0110554909,
-0.0305476002,
0.0047287997,
0.0091252169,
-0.0019049314,
-0.0291470718,
0.0353013985,
0.0626786649,
-0.0645906031,
0.0128638949,
0.014308664,
-0.0920636952,
0.0143334847,
-0.0041333451,
-0.0314826481,
0.0136514753,
2.732e-7,
-0.0577531122,
0.0174062252,
0.0136975832,
-0.0580607355,
0.0118248472,
0.0648033917,
0.0030544559,
0.0672724172,
0.0217353832,
-0.0394352227,
0.0322390646,
0.0072516617,
0.08609128,
-0.0043056426,
-0.0715217739,
0.0217540488,
-0.0381114036,
-0.0226076785,
-0.021074703,
0.0264189616,
0.0839424655,
-0.0150690861,
0.033726953,
0.0061807591,
0.0307537224,
0.0095703015,
0.0145749403,
-0.0502123833,
-0.0111778146,
0.0088277198,
0.0013089059,
-0.0457061604,
0.0111861881,
0.0191513617,
-0.0012596883,
0.0237783007,
-0.0040928242,
0.0774018839,
-0.0162580647,
-0.06330017,
0.0369529612,
-0.0125232693,
0.0105196116,
-0.0700227544,
0.0014159355,
-0.096342355,
-0.0176432934,
0.0019557192,
0.0059778853,
-0.0053957417,
-0.0310636666,
-0.0354734249,
-0.051370021,
0.0408918522,
0.0279987156,
-0.0086209029,
0.0068054041,
-0.0383628905,
0.0199694652,
0.005887236,
-0.054242786,
-0.0752948374,
-0.0228044819,
-0.0328184813,
0.0235395264,
-0.0573568493,
0.0132519789,
1.993893033e-34,
-0.0367324576,
0.0284721889,
-0.01768394,
0.0293566175,
0.0455629081,
-0.013601399,
-0.0015373302,
0.0119907586,
0.0449771658,
-0.0389505178,
-0.0052283173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14989v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14989v2 | Dolphin: A Challenging and Diverse Benchmark for Arabic NLG | 2023-05-24T10:24:10 | 2023-10-24T17:48:43 | El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, AbdelRahim Elmadany, Ahmed El-Shangiti, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Dolphin, a novel benchmark that addresses the need for a natural
language generation (NLG) evaluation framework dedicated to the wide collection
of Arabic languages and varieties. The proposed benchmark encompasses a broad
range of 13 different NLG tasks, including dialogue generation, question
answering, machine translation, summarization, among others. Dolphin comprises
a substantial corpus of 40 diverse and representative public datasets across 50
test splits, carefully curated to reflect real-world scenarios and the
linguistic richness of Arabic. It sets a new standard for evaluating the
performance and generalization capabilities of Arabic and multilingual models,
promising to enable researchers to push the boundaries of current
methodologies. We provide an extensive analysis of Dolphin, highlighting its
diversity and identifying gaps in current Arabic NLG research. We also offer a
public leaderboard that is both interactive and modular and evaluate several
models on our benchmark, allowing us to set strong baselines against which
researchers can compare. | [
0.0318193287,
0.0625402853,
0.0173747055,
-0.0205032974,
-0.0373677537,
0.0098886844,
0.0414626859,
-0.0445389077,
-0.0524395704,
-0.0363372639,
0.0001734898,
-0.0981677026,
0.0502813645,
0.0255935565,
0.0333568379,
-0.0543716475,
0.0047922931,
-0.0668753907,
-0.0207420047,
-0.0041625621,
0.057423424,
0.0299664102,
-0.0169129726,
0.0401988178,
0.013477345,
-0.0246351119,
-0.031601321,
-0.0198832043,
0.0142530613,
-0.0070532751,
0.0140634915,
0.0475222655,
-0.0109449718,
0.0083261868,
0.0000018992,
-0.0723704621,
-0.0251929052,
-0.0378998257,
-0.0053281677,
0.0108795725,
0.0190383401,
-0.0679354668,
0.0019539935,
0.0216195229,
-0.0091826245,
0.0271496698,
0.0171184968,
-0.0074926727,
0.0645453781,
0.0495807305,
0.0112675978,
-0.0296256226,
-0.0010622818,
-0.0284883901,
-0.0077087311,
-0.0232042242,
-0.0588469878,
0.0129518621,
0.0041152723,
-0.0317221247,
-0.0157562252,
0.014731979,
0.004576684,
-0.0387018397,
-0.0304558016,
-0.007391368,
-0.0707068518,
-0.0273798686,
0.0212646089,
0.0793779939,
0.007747849,
0.0019857492,
-0.0016323043,
0.0181182418,
0.0157673936,
-0.0384652466,
-0.017519217,
0.0943924636,
-0.0383386798,
-0.0099070258,
0.0410670787,
0.0312130637,
-0.0171611775,
0.0084669869,
-0.0457914695,
0.0170186032,
0.0229230765,
0.0083663343,
0.0059075137,
0.0113842022,
-0.0246307608,
-0.039055787,
0.0188103169,
-0.0013983584,
-0.0608096048,
-0.0286183842,
-0.0597537309,
-0.0295090266,
0.0249160416,
-0.0279476959,
0.0480431616,
0.0678966939,
0.0044588447,
0.0019905725,
-0.0159312543,
0.0503147431,
0.0401992723,
-0.0186042469,
-0.0832352713,
0.0036951227,
-0.029548876,
-0.0026433815,
-0.0370468795,
0.0492081679,
-0.0986222476,
-0.0054939259,
-0.0539127253,
-0.0014601737,
0.0099879876,
-0.0173419155,
0.0015675176,
0.0030224996,
-0.0427354313,
0.0032264367,
-0.0018528926,
-0.0299995691,
-0.0465665311,
-0.0076356675,
0.010362233,
-0.0818446428,
-0.0031258678,
0.011713502,
-0.0105500892,
0.0334615819,
-0.0313523188,
0.0656954944,
-0.029554436,
-0.0399373658,
-0.0166327562,
-0.0179144423,
-0.0379157476,
-0.0634004548,
-0.0248434637,
-0.0559679605,
0.0538922064,
-0.0016304452,
-0.0385669954,
0.0113255987,
0.0124146324,
0.0371402837,
0.0508586243,
0.0279410426,
0.0201675966,
-0.0089922827,
0.0545464754,
0.0200834516,
0.0299794488,
0.048384238,
0.0414197519,
0.0049036518,
0.0086347135,
0.0304128658,
-0.02107138,
0.0370478742,
0.0114273811,
-0.0019733543,
-0.0011310583,
-0.0300262477,
-0.017800156,
0.0822802708,
-0.0174458735,
0.0608516,
-0.0508252382,
-0.0113518583,
0.0355796181,
-0.0134814186,
-0.0505464487,
0.0190446433,
0.0490611643,
0.0438177437,
0.0378611982,
0.015240659,
0.0351768956,
0.0246656202,
0.0203917008,
0.0609181263,
0.0629386231,
0.092717357,
-0.0173726305,
-0.0721019134,
-0.0045916215,
-0.0014936357,
0.0262565743,
-0.0096334368,
0.0564360693,
0.0383879133,
-0.0665530935,
0.0174613427,
0.0069527626,
-0.0503532477,
0.0246714801,
-0.0276980363,
-0.0038688313,
0.0178208444,
0.0378039144,
0.0424061865,
-0.0549281724,
-0.0186819322,
0.020414697,
0.0556072779,
0.0664242133,
-0.0263127051,
0.0276825316,
-0.0290647931,
-0.0299128834,
-0.0112482402,
0.0004230437,
0.0053363922,
0.021312099,
0.0140781952,
0.0165087879,
-0.0366214179,
-0.014885596,
0.0348265916,
-0.0445171408,
0.010773601,
0.0093212221,
-0.0167414155,
0.0080960318,
0.0416119434,
-0.0300231483,
0.0296097044,
-0.0049053761,
-0.0571492463,
-0.0224664621,
0.0419629104,
-0.0532605313,
-0.0424668528,
0.0262078643,
-0.0600526184,
0.0219368618,
0.0265356172,
-0.0376295522,
-0.0472915806,
0.0593217313,
-0.0369770378,
0.021236483,
-0.0289111622,
0.0458890721,
0.0490003377,
0.0316276178,
-0.0249569006,
0.0627105162,
-0.0237910617,
-0.0269775372,
0.0123155331,
0.0114798741,
0.0431348644,
-0.0287097208,
0.0094651449,
0.0203603934,
-0.0099093867,
0.0114853829,
0.0798940361,
0.015940439,
-0.0433840193,
-0.0190728325,
-0.0788782686,
0.0119568175,
-0.0220341366,
0.0409356505,
0.0038090423,
0.0189852864,
-0.0094180871,
0.0155056408,
-0.0341536887,
-0.0551815741,
0.0592377111,
0.002839687,
0.0424518771,
-0.0082386965,
0.0261843801,
-0.0697879419,
-0.0014913094,
0.0644622371,
0.0566271357,
0.0408935547,
-0.0032333124,
0.0414812379,
-0.0329484381,
-0.0339347534,
-0.0187596865,
0.0079654455,
-0.0158017445,
0.0367605351,
0.0026734872,
0.0304195266,
0.0117074559,
0.0499425866,
-0.0011738631,
-0.0037288319,
-0.0083730351,
-0.0458136871,
0.0106092235,
-0.0066469917,
-0.021114761,
-0.0074692713,
-0.039867349,
0.0016103953,
0.0300026331,
0.0159060154,
0.003674404,
-0.0331195854,
0.0484390855,
-0.01955669,
-0.0206119567,
-0.017479144,
0.0147797093,
0.0016428372,
0.0864524841,
-0.0238798782,
-0.0668096542,
-0.0094697718,
-0.0169354826,
0.0233862419,
-0.0264049973,
0.0324154757,
-0.0358003043,
0.0116920192,
-0.020343706,
0.0471164659,
-0.0099220499,
-0.0053302413,
-0.0427478254,
0.0028002474,
0.0298949592,
-0.0243922789,
0.0416100994,
-0.1035910174,
0.0000568967,
-0.0118824206,
-0.0379527695,
-0.0417235307,
0.0037809149,
-0.0291844849,
-0.0235364158,
0.0861751959,
-0.0042855828,
-0.027895622,
0.0126352198,
0.0191437565,
0.0342810228,
-0.0187045336,
-0.0102271996,
0.0175666641,
0.0149173057,
0.0527948178,
0.0057851728,
0.03519319,
-0.0243443176,
0.0506084189,
0.0436131842,
-0.0232879668,
-0.0003348643,
-0.0559966862,
-0.0061402642,
0.0136470646,
-0.0419183858,
-0.0277251303,
-0.0254385862,
0.0270788576,
-0.0271106884,
-0.0223387312,
0.0838251263,
0.0391774252,
0.013949628,
0.0258661136,
0.0019163928,
0.0605923422,
-0.0122798905,
-0.0161632076,
-0.0925941095,
-0.018961912,
0.0187766459,
0.0390737504,
0.0250568353,
0.0083416961,
0.0129780807,
-0.1074436009,
0.0111851012,
-0.0067423857,
-0.0787712038,
-0.0199533477,
-0.0134066688,
-0.0423066765,
-0.0116817234,
-0.00285234,
-0.023793716,
-0.0181507301,
0.0739095584,
0.0496396758,
-0.0245262291,
-0.0465410911,
-0.0054469248,
-0.0231785458,
0.0023978525,
0.0457654074,
0.0108662695,
0.0162065271,
0.0215197783,
0.0009939856,
-0.0186365731,
-0.0210898872,
0.0073705316,
0.0261899568,
0.0203181989,
0.0015398728,
-0.0355962664,
-0.0038671475,
-0.0326132365,
0.0184269212,
0.0070628803,
-0.0383068174,
-0.0020476647,
0.0138577176,
-0.0190348458,
0.0495410785,
-0.0382486582,
0.0684603453,
-0.009372429,
-0.049441997,
-0.0601250492,
-0.0179419965,
-0.0268285014,
-0.1181374043,
-0.0194876622,
-0.0165354013,
0.0447070152,
0.0512106754,
-0.1471140832,
-0.0627826601,
-0.0074844011,
0.009678971,
-0.0100215552,
-0.0028611119,
-0.0278701819,
0.0050794678,
-0.0292038806,
-0.0140557401,
0.0312677696,
-0.0114557883,
-0.0550395362,
-0.0225474574,
0.0100364247,
-0.1071713269,
0.0059709428,
0.0385079421,
-0.0813551322,
-0.0521576889,
-0.0049926112,
0.027899418,
0.0142562194,
0.0227056146,
0.0350100137,
0.015105621,
0.0064890995,
0.0084279859,
0.0197572876,
0.038947396,
0.0161500312,
-0.000595701,
-0.0441438705,
0.0406685397,
-0.0050692842,
0.0020926928,
-0.0131129446,
0.0315518305,
-0.0040328749,
-0.0517557189,
0.0216590986,
-0.0063002408,
-0.0330112502,
-0.0714520961,
-0.0278701819,
-0.0264839604,
-0.0343101658,
-0.0205392018,
0.0015415242,
-0.0637283102,
0.0252840593,
0.0065567819,
0.0438759699,
0.0067500086,
0.0296201296,
-0.0104348464,
0.0087764189,
0.0082146889,
-0.0092899958,
-0.0132467225,
-0.0189072415,
-0.0288375672,
0.0106413532,
-0.0017888646,
-0.0518395454,
-0.065048039,
0.0498083942,
-0.022656735,
0.0151094226,
-0.0112732071,
0.0467971712,
0.0358509608,
0.0479649901,
0.0153294895,
-0.0173522383,
-0.0311956163,
0.0704194531,
0.0581183322,
-0.0324196815,
0.0689588562,
0.0240523946,
0.0074309581,
-0.0200954005,
0.0375600085,
0.0066584861,
-0.0535547175,
-0.0352806561,
-0.0125994645,
-0.0064854324,
0.0010436898,
0.1014186665,
0.0112849167,
0.0039897882,
0.023118658,
0.0285463743,
-0.0328186154,
-0.0278545339,
-0.0064735208,
0.0019923949,
-0.0118052652,
0.0268503986,
-0.0669865981,
-0.0579048097,
0.0211789031,
0.0161366314,
0.0548920669,
0.0132046631,
0.075729616,
0.0621116273,
-0.0097819446,
-0.0046076733,
-0.0622624569,
-0.0249497853,
-0.0384666473,
-0.0049032033,
-0.0306067355,
-5.697545813e-33,
-0.0023628431,
-0.0021065108,
0.0292039663,
-0.0240493342,
0.0045808717,
-0.0029285597,
-0.0396040119,
0.0104821948,
0.0257561561,
0.0059953504,
-0.0128635755,
-0.0098661678,
0.0138738574,
0.044416938,
0.0186026618,
-0.0057754181,
0.0260868594,
-0.0437328778,
-0.0550282188,
0.0472316407,
0.0136222849,
0.0207200088,
0.0518189333,
-0.0058217202,
0.0114229005,
-0.0396659933,
-0.0535654984,
0.0075847651,
-0.0119954916,
0.0865950882,
-0.0217353422,
0.0242941212,
0.0158889852,
-0.0284900591,
-0.0159351695,
-0.0206904095,
-0.0233173314,
-0.0115398988,
0.0082588475,
-0.0047440864,
-0.0475485176,
-0.0139148962,
-0.0444176756,
-0.0143475048,
-0.0412293747,
0.0241888948,
-0.004004573,
-0.0264376253,
0.0055254018,
-0.0274084006,
-0.0930133387,
0.0370301679,
-0.0391359515,
-0.0296447929,
0.0056299581,
0.0728814602,
-0.0228286609,
-0.0057093618,
-0.0212317463,
0.0367540456,
0.0285420027,
-0.0004352362,
0.086594522,
0.0233547986,
-0.0722752288,
0.0607723482,
0.0099203195,
-0.0261498373,
0.0214015841,
0.0582188778,
-0.007972965,
-0.0211022198,
0.0393573754,
0.086052902,
0.0438510329,
0.0314608067,
-0.0690843612,
0.0700780079,
-0.0198494457,
0.008342321,
-0.0074045062,
-0.0388791487,
-0.0331941843,
0.0033024058,
-0.0354808569,
-0.0124363927,
0.0181808397,
0.0183666684,
0.0456925966,
0.0289994758,
-0.0189284738,
-0.0148286391,
-0.0022149005,
0.0253421701,
0.0563430414,
0.011448551,
-0.017763136,
-0.0332172588,
-0.0056265024,
0.0271658078,
-0.0504769124,
-0.0088746762,
0.0283874981,
0.0487764105,
0.0084449751,
0.0013699399,
0.0211357232,
0.0132909482,
-0.0610243268,
0.0648390725,
-0.029375162,
0.0837074369,
-0.0014377052,
0.0545630381,
0.0077105551,
-0.0387464091,
-0.0266063064,
0.0596990101,
0.004243508,
-0.0180643946,
-0.0247798599,
-0.0180012919,
-0.0232557058,
-0.0100699142,
0.0030317614,
0.0726258457,
-0.0195172857,
0.0020029424,
0.0181669891,
-0.0305643361,
-0.0086645866,
0.01047346,
2.55e-7,
0.041689422,
-0.0021120899,
0.051650364,
0.0434769839,
-0.0251465142,
0.0033256761,
0.0287445057,
0.0207190495,
0.0079658693,
0.0403736681,
-0.0212510172,
0.0218215119,
0.0465057567,
-0.0066524218,
-0.0796228126,
-0.0045247157,
-0.0376398303,
0.025749173,
-0.0359228998,
-0.0398254618,
0.0485520847,
0.0902677178,
-0.0952841863,
-0.0081448797,
-0.0301723257,
-0.0479694493,
0.069006443,
-0.0103088347,
-0.0381868817,
0.0279057492,
0.0674475133,
-0.0337622501,
0.0050014802,
-0.0116135255,
-0.0443494208,
-0.0060715107,
0.0654053167,
0.0497945361,
0.0562330224,
-0.0288463105,
0.02102465,
0.0188010503,
-0.0121218236,
-0.0099583464,
0.0433027185,
-0.0137044946,
-0.0025732608,
0.0149910282,
-0.0251618419,
0.0210541263,
0.0253361296,
-0.0550795458,
0.0063107689,
0.0250445157,
0.0343021974,
-0.0022201973,
0.0135687785,
-0.0032417574,
-0.0155280344,
-0.0391646773,
0.0004156763,
-0.0003872281,
-0.0082902675,
-0.0022862628,
-0.0149478745,
-0.0052954624,
-0.0131235681,
1.81500093e-34,
0.0640558228,
-0.0107361656,
-0.0061949738,
-0.0183499418,
0.0479028672,
-0.0230349284,
-0.0112388181,
-0.0077347243,
0.0074429517,
-0.0167592783,
-0.0051939208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14987v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14987v2 | Investigating Table-to-Text Generation Capabilities of LLMs in Real-World Information Seeking Scenarios | 2023-05-24T10:22:30 | 2023-10-30T22:00:25 | Yilun Zhao, Haowei Zhang, Shengyun Si, Linyong Nan, Xiangru Tang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tabular data is prevalent across various industries, necessitating
significant time and effort for users to understand and manipulate for their
information-seeking purposes. The advancements in large language models (LLMs)
have shown enormous potential to improve user efficiency. However, the adoption
of LLMs in real-world applications for table information seeking remains
underexplored. In this paper, we investigate the table-to-text capabilities of
different LLMs using four datasets within two real-world information seeking
scenarios. These include the LogicNLG and our newly-constructed LoTNLG datasets
for data insight generation, along with the FeTaQA and our newly-constructed
F2WTQ datasets for query-based generation. We structure our investigation
around three research questions, evaluating the performance of LLMs in
table-to-text generation, automated evaluation, and feedback generation,
respectively. Experimental results indicate that the current high-performing
LLM, specifically GPT-4, can effectively serve as a table-to-text generator,
evaluator, and feedback generator, facilitating users' information seeking
purposes in real-world scenarios. However, a significant performance gap still
exists between other open-sourced LLMs (e.g., Tulu and LLaMA-2) and GPT-4
models. Our data and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/yale-nlp/LLM-T2T. | [
0.0413125195,
0.0320615098,
-0.0103655001,
0.0213800967,
-0.0372435078,
0.0010737182,
-0.027185902,
0.0417319387,
0.0118789533,
-0.0113229798,
-0.0456781723,
-0.0303152688,
-0.0070907958,
0.0156285577,
0.04774018,
0.0037600403,
0.0311086494,
0.0022125293,
-0.0370636918,
0.0446878262,
0.0152476318,
0.0257503614,
-0.0023392977,
0.0317193791,
0.0074387174,
0.0138225928,
-0.0341142491,
0.0216907095,
-0.0129895704,
-0.0290427245,
-0.033772327,
0.0591767244,
0.0160710271,
0.0120557547,
0.0000021198,
-0.0123170745,
-0.0497469567,
0.0100910487,
-0.0182585604,
0.0084905885,
0.0629899874,
-0.0094117988,
0.0093705487,
0.0131178014,
-0.0466466695,
-0.0009338146,
0.02453967,
0.0203013383,
0.0517172031,
0.045446068,
0.0080997134,
-0.0265941881,
0.0031624842,
-0.006034398,
0.0600364245,
-0.0315063894,
-0.011792358,
0.0058503537,
0.0437400118,
0.0078876549,
0.0548048504,
0.0441750996,
0.004517511,
-0.0181776397,
0.0076804413,
0.0402589254,
-0.0612480156,
0.0003437592,
0.0100702709,
0.094062157,
0.0340458564,
-0.0221067723,
0.0083581954,
0.002635035,
0.0216910709,
-0.014420405,
-0.0499334559,
0.010037181,
-0.026627861,
0.002939631,
0.0156080667,
0.0010714894,
0.0092980145,
-0.0089218942,
-0.0516660139,
0.0483962446,
-0.0080613969,
-0.0447214767,
-0.0011471376,
-0.0300318096,
-0.0059731901,
-0.0417748913,
0.0098226303,
0.0546947494,
-0.056724377,
0.0278373137,
-0.0190982968,
-0.0442666821,
0.0132440887,
-0.0513561517,
0.0684141964,
0.0413419195,
0.0203496255,
0.0075311507,
-0.0208229106,
0.0308808982,
-0.0021796285,
0.0163717642,
-0.0513816327,
-0.020632796,
-0.0418933444,
-0.0201774389,
-0.0393433794,
0.0429997481,
-0.081396319,
-0.0005488405,
-0.0040156473,
0.022299014,
0.0115123391,
0.0464188792,
0.0288864225,
-0.0174701903,
-0.0083892774,
0.0063398629,
-0.0583629385,
-0.0241534468,
-0.0074899672,
-0.0440848581,
0.0283943135,
-0.1012025028,
0.0186642446,
-0.0029862798,
0.0137414895,
-0.0146844666,
0.0342983305,
0.0708585605,
-0.0307394527,
-0.0180106647,
-0.0861428902,
-0.0482836701,
-0.0093644261,
-0.0505186692,
-0.0100504849,
-0.0498347729,
0.0502074435,
0.0306385662,
-0.0345468372,
-0.0593048483,
0.0129282698,
0.0642711148,
-0.011649318,
0.0493988134,
-0.0296176504,
0.0543707125,
0.0127848694,
-0.0241021495,
0.0018677092,
0.0804770365,
0.0324991085,
0.0551193953,
0.0181621108,
-0.021071896,
-0.0039294446,
0.0521162599,
0.0297026969,
0.0085132895,
-0.0119536528,
0.0589958131,
-0.0303252097,
0.0285891946,
-0.0162249338,
0.0341505073,
-0.0188890509,
0.0983108506,
0.0717121959,
0.0233890284,
0.0844937637,
0.062744379,
0.0335076563,
0.0347372778,
0.0169194341,
-0.0122797107,
0.005247395,
0.0345282443,
-0.0068693436,
0.0413892828,
0.0547740161,
0.0158330016,
-0.0066175056,
-0.0481437221,
0.0108918753,
0.0438541733,
-0.0078833979,
0.0101212421,
0.0207620747,
0.0174922273,
-0.0822025314,
0.0380802229,
-0.0032535251,
-0.0873746723,
0.0017750488,
-0.0244369507,
0.0357626453,
0.1119719073,
0.059288688,
-0.0293582026,
-0.0094598448,
0.0256102942,
-0.005054472,
0.0524022542,
0.0443488136,
-0.0060034869,
-0.0306798927,
-0.0346559323,
-0.0197834093,
0.0302790366,
-0.0031258075,
-0.0170546435,
0.0328321345,
0.0084664915,
0.0429792032,
-0.0504407994,
-0.0556932352,
0.0116817774,
0.0015078835,
0.0080530485,
-0.0022992287,
-0.0009242431,
-0.0096678408,
0.0584359914,
0.0007529304,
0.0541277528,
0.0399167463,
-0.0271650497,
0.0174339395,
-0.0144048687,
0.0054022116,
0.0178777892,
0.0156146185,
-0.0056011244,
-0.0076123606,
-0.0310357399,
-0.0249620434,
-0.0400982872,
-0.0307638701,
-0.0236681122,
0.0051611606,
-0.0280887261,
0.0103912819,
0.0125199836,
-0.0196609572,
-0.0210810397,
0.0931374356,
0.0000835088,
0.0262676012,
0.039769236,
-0.0376798511,
0.0089258915,
-0.0306318905,
0.0599373095,
0.0135434186,
-0.0112775248,
-0.0017073428,
0.0126586594,
0.0351652615,
-0.0587596223,
-0.0358366966,
-0.0814350322,
0.0294796098,
-0.0220872294,
0.0436217599,
0.0450125374,
0.0101404944,
-0.0277033634,
0.0192737468,
-0.0687192529,
-0.0221348442,
0.0184025299,
-0.0081114331,
0.0479878783,
0.0207437221,
-0.0225002486,
-0.0366732031,
-0.0072904998,
-0.0025514343,
0.0018393046,
-0.0080749085,
-0.0462099276,
-0.0488946661,
0.0202255212,
-0.0045569548,
-0.0133798178,
0.0109355776,
0.0006296432,
0.0081345374,
-0.0404712223,
0.0619129352,
0.0028900222,
0.0177140832,
0.0199391432,
0.0086807124,
-0.03652931,
-0.0480760261,
0.012691984,
-0.0124873472,
-0.0000663212,
-0.0015636833,
-0.1019956768,
0.0692666844,
0.0061553922,
-0.0062997993,
0.022091696,
-0.0508627258,
0.0119968643,
-0.0102420831,
-0.0097562848,
-0.0471942201,
0.0450354144,
0.0022170602,
0.0434442312,
-0.0116066327,
-0.0006625602,
0.0159219317,
-0.0604159944,
0.0146780014,
-0.0177950691,
0.0017334126,
-0.054107774,
0.0643990338,
-0.0096992059,
0.0159415044,
-0.0202589575,
-0.021689048,
-0.0470305122,
0.0174042936,
0.0040251166,
-0.053493157,
0.1188938469,
-0.0537257381,
0.0158809498,
-0.0284220539,
-0.0289133694,
-0.000670019,
-0.0217669979,
0.0001558439,
0.0076104207,
0.0703675449,
-0.0285103209,
-0.013954577,
0.0036100028,
0.0489014313,
0.0386798419,
-0.0095652398,
-0.0519764051,
-0.0260123331,
0.0200081728,
0.0493053049,
-0.0129124643,
-0.0244046915,
0.0058101127,
0.01357242,
0.0447417311,
0.0091685681,
-0.0377177261,
-0.000254359,
-0.0262135286,
0.0221730359,
-0.0336786509,
-0.0166409072,
0.0309207439,
-0.0147295995,
-0.0396382846,
-0.0011861857,
0.0952429846,
0.0325627029,
-0.0093415193,
-0.0156443138,
0.0001879383,
0.050994359,
0.0120451991,
0.0477306396,
-0.0809706971,
-0.0184347145,
0.0043999702,
0.0558764711,
-0.0152106332,
-0.0347726084,
-0.0392113589,
-0.1428718567,
0.0462093987,
-0.0198182613,
-0.028358629,
-0.0958829299,
-0.00643192,
-0.0241658445,
0.0118425889,
0.0033377807,
0.0734104738,
-0.0405102298,
0.0411446691,
0.0060768365,
-0.0528441668,
-0.0312799104,
-0.0199442003,
-0.0201987214,
0.0153936064,
0.0689105019,
0.029221084,
-0.0031408556,
0.004145476,
-0.0059534325,
0.0050737662,
0.0230627637,
-0.0361496769,
0.0427243635,
-0.0187315922,
0.0031571689,
-0.0278326869,
0.0072413511,
-0.0187658779,
0.0378749669,
0.0265353527,
0.0288314912,
-0.0184528548,
0.0298483223,
-0.0115876859,
-0.0050398433,
-0.0080677886,
0.0696766749,
0.035106048,
-0.0133321444,
-0.0324767977,
-0.0282545593,
-0.0169821903,
-0.0732251927,
-0.0077113905,
0.0238155052,
-0.0279479772,
0.0025121819,
-0.0535674654,
-0.0266323574,
0.0517173596,
0.0392768383,
0.0080479458,
0.0380324423,
-0.038095504,
-0.0097963894,
-0.0423600487,
-0.0219379719,
-0.0410079472,
0.0317190401,
-0.0514003448,
-0.024435807,
0.0133861573,
-0.057413511,
0.0041047106,
0.0541620962,
-0.0560639761,
-0.0272107255,
-0.0308829956,
0.001421698,
0.0274736006,
0.0076821758,
0.0199265927,
-0.0139714805,
-0.0085528335,
0.0440918244,
-0.0656552091,
-0.0243304037,
-0.0322338454,
0.0197827443,
0.0017380724,
0.0313754305,
-0.0479473174,
-0.0195540655,
-0.0302787758,
0.0601705387,
0.0189211983,
-0.0061641484,
0.0629930124,
0.0588609315,
-0.0264346674,
-0.0001190817,
-0.0214759428,
-0.0210035332,
0.0236451905,
-0.0624942482,
-0.0367277116,
-0.0547728278,
0.0078601995,
0.0134929596,
-0.0423487574,
0.0211677197,
0.0011319341,
-0.0013490614,
0.0443016924,
-0.039459046,
0.0061977166,
-0.0278946999,
0.0102012902,
0.0429578424,
-0.0510357209,
-0.0263042729,
-0.0111833783,
-0.0193320774,
0.0324076377,
-0.018911507,
0.0627050772,
0.0281420667,
-0.0538691916,
0.0008484696,
0.0679605082,
-0.0180151053,
-0.0583538301,
-0.042748291,
0.0092962347,
0.0295180529,
0.0459937677,
0.0535600819,
-0.0616801083,
-0.002620589,
0.001314383,
0.033986982,
0.0411064774,
-0.0168496743,
0.0058007613,
-0.0084733358,
-0.0115907611,
-0.0708355531,
0.1063733548,
0.0431886464,
-0.016739035,
-0.0225251373,
-0.0448547937,
-0.057587631,
-0.0112823369,
-0.0014642753,
-0.0256736316,
-0.0213522241,
-0.0518403575,
-0.0671705455,
-0.0372858159,
0.0078703128,
0.037476059,
-0.025551714,
-0.0243785102,
0.0276263803,
0.0818904415,
0.0318796635,
-0.0378536545,
-0.0506891049,
0.0410017185,
-0.0339342691,
-0.0244210083,
-0.0224098098,
-6.348465892e-33,
-0.0562262833,
-0.0368345268,
0.0285510961,
-0.0169142708,
-0.0210997034,
-0.0391461253,
-0.0252940599,
-0.0083428826,
-0.0005876588,
-0.0195489675,
-0.0386100821,
0.0187339969,
0.022846194,
-0.0012601047,
0.0046920469,
-0.0562998354,
0.0342297405,
-0.0103629846,
-0.0352608711,
0.0364103243,
0.0198214334,
0.0155847147,
0.0286119487,
-0.0220845807,
0.0396642052,
-0.0253430121,
-0.005852723,
-0.011302446,
-0.0228747725,
0.0261314828,
-0.0028141721,
0.0334302001,
0.0259571336,
-0.0435742401,
-0.0355643444,
0.0133139873,
-0.0919153169,
-0.0032168988,
0.0153818531,
-0.0123790503,
-0.0188576151,
-0.0400459021,
0.031923715,
-0.0245124996,
-0.036833711,
0.0081045907,
0.0022748013,
-0.0364509374,
-0.0191033594,
-0.0273953099,
-0.0131697087,
0.0336473957,
0.0256137438,
0.0112508032,
0.033247184,
0.0758390948,
0.0049767513,
-0.0143863102,
-0.0556188822,
0.0379172117,
0.0555236265,
0.0455546454,
0.0890614316,
0.0069433656,
0.0217611063,
0.0042762193,
0.0317492373,
0.0274266936,
-0.0337191001,
0.0028148459,
-0.0445691459,
0.0559493601,
0.0247055497,
0.0183692146,
0.0118442476,
-0.002292607,
-0.0246848539,
0.0599659905,
-0.0451684855,
0.0005582672,
0.0332166106,
-0.0264461953,
-0.0383034796,
-0.0144415749,
-0.0184456147,
0.0461662672,
-0.0338374414,
-0.040157076,
0.0500601605,
0.0132119153,
0.019982975,
-0.0401342809,
0.0019700625,
0.0205422733,
-0.0374751315,
0.0200518519,
-0.0300321262,
0.0210199412,
-0.0131671298,
-0.0158772096,
-0.0530997775,
-0.0124023706,
0.0017625014,
0.0170553774,
0.0001398195,
0.0375327133,
-0.0079326807,
0.0384229347,
-0.0527892523,
0.0075091128,
-0.0293843597,
0.0554219931,
-0.0321711563,
-0.0498119593,
0.0189743284,
-0.0314079337,
-0.0027343363,
0.0292084981,
0.0163148399,
-0.0005829249,
-0.011554379,
-0.0136705711,
0.0116655026,
-0.0020034101,
0.0378372706,
0.038194824,
-0.0569926463,
0.0199880432,
0.0524339601,
0.0042444649,
0.0027778712,
0.0207700375,
2.747e-7,
0.0633513257,
0.0217430741,
0.0329093114,
0.0873099342,
-0.0108673042,
-0.0004914242,
0.0217254534,
-0.0066097844,
-0.0062401555,
-0.0103027597,
0.0451299585,
-0.0224569067,
0.0569895208,
0.0244414043,
-0.039981816,
-0.026483573,
-0.0399801992,
-0.0138630047,
-0.094071798,
-0.0077874204,
0.0588076599,
0.0480867289,
-0.0693095103,
-0.0004840244,
-0.0045908242,
-0.0349558555,
0.029663099,
-0.0709465891,
0.0104163922,
0.0328978337,
0.0806278065,
-0.0205263458,
-0.0142119573,
0.0190104749,
-0.0258972645,
-0.0165550653,
-0.0061024888,
0.0366238207,
0.0363201834,
0.0000115877,
0.0106689613,
-0.0965729505,
0.0082363691,
-0.0799007863,
0.0692233816,
-0.0277302917,
0.0148177734,
0.0805737227,
-0.0159506183,
0.0048670056,
-0.055902265,
-0.0096814791,
-0.0137757147,
0.0070205075,
0.0204716604,
-0.0045970064,
-0.000565142,
-0.0113823451,
-0.0281666275,
0.0008010775,
-0.0198833756,
-0.0396709517,
-0.0707655996,
-0.0022033509,
-0.0472320244,
-0.0476871654,
-0.0252584498,
2.770427586e-34,
0.0321532302,
0.0012271695,
0.0273877326,
0.0122816749,
0.0829442516,
-0.0032302667,
0.0059273373,
0.0132781239,
-0.0098886639,
-0.0843774378,
-0.0259974934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14985v1 | IdealGPT: Iteratively Decomposing Vision and Language Reasoning via Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T10:19:57 | 2023-05-24T10:19:57 | Haoxuan You, Rui Sun, Zhecan Wang, Long Chen, Gengyu Wang, Hammad A. Ayyubi, Kai-Wei Chang, Shih-Fu Chang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | The field of vision-and-language (VL) understanding has made unprecedented
progress with end-to-end large pre-trained VL models (VLMs). However, they
still fall short in zero-shot reasoning tasks that require multi-step
inferencing. To achieve this goal, previous works resort to a
divide-and-conquer pipeline. In this paper, we argue that previous efforts have
several inherent shortcomings: 1) They rely on domain-specific sub-question
decomposing models. 2) They force models to predict the final answer even if
the sub-questions or sub-answers provide insufficient information. We address
these limitations via IdealGPT, a framework that iteratively decomposes VL
reasoning using large language models (LLMs). Specifically, IdealGPT utilizes
an LLM to generate sub-questions, a VLM to provide corresponding sub-answers,
and another LLM to reason to achieve the final answer. These three modules
perform the divide-and-conquer procedure iteratively until the model is
confident about the final answer to the main question. We evaluate IdealGPT on
multiple challenging VL reasoning tasks under a zero-shot setting. In
particular, our IdealGPT outperforms the best existing GPT-4-like models by an
absolute 10% on VCR and 15% on SNLI-VE. Code is available at
https://github.com/Hxyou/IdealGPT | [
0.0037316992,
0.0494731925,
-0.0034984702,
0.0541625693,
-0.0445408262,
0.0519008525,
0.0128596406,
-0.0066003976,
-0.0069231126,
-0.040127825,
0.0096989702,
-0.0130221369,
-0.012537824,
0.0154916579,
0.0143180462,
-0.0601675138,
0.0405852944,
-0.0726328641,
-0.0173321385,
0.0050034281,
0.0042899302,
0.0185718425,
0.0000924084,
-0.0002083133,
0.0129199149,
-0.0524221696,
-0.0328893736,
-0.0031810345,
0.0163125768,
0.0027436686,
-0.0415449552,
0.0097449729,
0.0676880777,
0.0347686671,
0.0000020752,
-0.0152879367,
0.0018431329,
0.0127148014,
-0.0562637299,
-0.0062368065,
-0.0342851579,
-0.0244237687,
0.0262485929,
0.0027304173,
-0.0298793446,
-0.066674456,
0.0201929715,
0.0420605205,
0.0710967779,
0.0712834075,
0.005262522,
-0.0555028841,
-0.026912272,
-0.0150548508,
0.0208616555,
-0.0603312105,
0.009301031,
0.0404628329,
0.0157334544,
0.0160621218,
-0.0280531403,
0.0448306315,
0.0699667186,
0.0289748143,
-0.0313641652,
0.0440654568,
-0.0130124828,
-0.0467157997,
0.0039829565,
0.0574656576,
-0.0294234771,
-0.0095128315,
-0.0221807677,
0.0122633772,
0.0085337264,
-0.030498419,
-0.0611573793,
0.0612799823,
-0.0116972728,
-0.0042679338,
-0.0163395889,
-0.0164748207,
0.0198557917,
-0.006172548,
-0.038308952,
0.0514481142,
0.0265790466,
0.0053297849,
0.0113231931,
-0.0044885413,
-0.0562849417,
-0.0600186437,
-0.0467075147,
0.0699970424,
-0.0565154366,
0.0290521607,
-0.0302321929,
0.0045497636,
-0.0277894437,
0.009241174,
0.0422339402,
0.0162947178,
-0.0062594148,
0.0768922865,
-0.0199389979,
0.0425563306,
-0.0347901881,
0.0141665908,
-0.0549187064,
-0.0476188287,
-0.0318091288,
-0.0189294461,
-0.0361042619,
0.0357632153,
-0.0500486344,
-0.0267158505,
-0.0071773166,
0.0227011964,
-0.000450544,
0.0129125789,
-0.0029552255,
0.0169280861,
0.0065138675,
-0.0561945289,
-0.0067732218,
0.0582674816,
-0.0442169756,
0.0131250145,
-0.000732682,
-0.0524555631,
-0.0394915976,
0.0251442883,
0.0177605562,
-0.0433664061,
0.0120070595,
0.0611896962,
-0.0184145942,
-0.0250817351,
-0.03434062,
-0.0366251022,
0.0115539245,
-0.098235257,
0.0454353504,
-0.06879282,
0.038392555,
0.0000450608,
-0.0170412119,
-0.0124862082,
-0.0119205015,
0.0168805141,
-0.0195867009,
0.1045948863,
-0.0017193217,
0.0001766471,
-0.0148719372,
0.0179263745,
0.0018362094,
0.0683919042,
-0.0309373755,
0.0331311077,
0.0016160172,
-0.0044097388,
0.0292864703,
0.0372778066,
0.0152246021,
-0.003877695,
-0.0237306897,
0.026415728,
0.012816241,
0.0004875532,
0.0262273252,
0.0380793959,
-0.0544193536,
-0.0269187689,
0.0508702621,
0.0235508867,
-0.0003382366,
-0.0093848445,
0.0599402748,
0.0080044912,
-0.0000774563,
-0.0011014467,
-0.075650081,
0.0435668789,
-0.0441273265,
-0.0028416975,
-0.0340751261,
0.0301828459,
-0.0522050224,
-0.0407492667,
-0.0049193674,
0.0113953892,
-0.0190075953,
0.0727106854,
0.0663718432,
0.0231197849,
-0.0306274816,
0.0232132599,
0.0285638589,
0.0098095117,
0.0029721269,
-0.0385793708,
0.0417194031,
0.009727926,
0.0430248454,
-0.0069721984,
-0.034586601,
-0.0054130466,
0.0285769869,
0.0103504052,
-0.0016999976,
-0.0113132093,
0.024534829,
-0.0356724337,
-0.0158193614,
-0.0220537577,
0.005607517,
0.0116653508,
0.0209162869,
-0.0323411003,
0.018323034,
-0.0484596677,
0.0488484763,
0.0136986785,
-0.0146626057,
-0.0330762789,
-0.0109977107,
0.0098252427,
0.0001569242,
-0.0183822308,
-0.0049189799,
-0.0079039847,
0.0052043027,
-0.0310748443,
-0.02124759,
0.0031989187,
-0.0277869385,
-0.0769688562,
0.0353102721,
-0.0440939479,
-0.0400158688,
0.0257500634,
-0.0789417326,
0.0002072227,
0.0158307627,
-0.0014309626,
-0.0026177226,
-0.0446900278,
-0.0019890601,
0.0201678388,
-0.018518284,
-0.0408738144,
0.0593937524,
0.0014077991,
-0.0352260508,
-0.0012913389,
-0.0072787818,
0.0170989949,
-0.010843249,
-0.0123154949,
0.03233888,
-0.0333330259,
-0.0080987308,
-0.0267122388,
0.0154488711,
-0.0575409159,
0.0037692771,
-0.0768097937,
-0.0022824102,
-0.0265848283,
-0.0149389319,
0.0100571876,
0.0118908603,
0.0128188916,
-0.0159502085,
-0.0148007795,
0.0278952438,
0.0266187917,
0.0022064492,
0.0166692454,
-0.0113286423,
0.0064091412,
0.0206257384,
-0.0106418179,
-0.003794723,
0.0543927401,
-0.0037300379,
0.002498776,
-0.0501656458,
0.0347895101,
-0.0402245894,
0.0321401134,
-0.0224948861,
-0.0035172792,
0.0238644239,
-0.0491534621,
0.0015568957,
0.0815387741,
-0.0458216667,
0.0075003663,
0.0310854726,
-0.0214507673,
-0.0165611599,
0.03273312,
-0.0170180239,
-0.0560498834,
-0.0218444038,
0.0229749512,
-0.0359062776,
0.0512809046,
-0.0334799998,
-0.0127494512,
-0.0660406798,
0.0536313169,
-0.0046453685,
-0.0218526423,
-0.0585631207,
0.0152323227,
0.0157720819,
0.0513610318,
-0.023915004,
-0.0267065149,
0.0453758277,
-0.0021313543,
-0.021228848,
-0.0327103101,
0.014234744,
-0.0360045545,
0.0849601328,
0.0235734507,
0.0080060707,
0.027741313,
-0.0070833005,
-0.0788096562,
-0.0284884498,
-0.0005698032,
0.00841555,
0.0646267608,
-0.0610584132,
0.0045811641,
-0.0182128903,
-0.0379590318,
-0.0456386991,
-0.0093564894,
-0.042209439,
0.0346847326,
-0.0875323415,
-0.0106348144,
-0.0231793374,
-0.0032795938,
0.0274390299,
0.0086346744,
-0.013400713,
0.0054257857,
-0.0339011475,
0.037093576,
0.0868660286,
0.0064788708,
0.0202684682,
-0.0344700366,
0.0313750058,
0.0772055462,
0.0370603912,
0.031814754,
-0.0331137255,
0.0297947917,
0.0120555963,
-0.000200849,
0.0168225821,
0.0307968408,
0.0576749705,
-0.0726109073,
-0.0243988913,
0.1112289503,
0.0139811896,
-0.0366957635,
-0.0096388478,
-0.0135133667,
0.0287685599,
0.0341783836,
0.0273932628,
-0.0987464935,
-0.0662310421,
0.0131076751,
-0.0176622886,
0.0514747575,
-0.0122978343,
-0.0208022799,
-0.1027216986,
0.0693426579,
0.0054913373,
-0.0089626135,
-0.016446447,
-0.0098519903,
-0.0107542602,
0.0011029459,
-0.0016579065,
0.0225047823,
-0.0020602413,
0.0199988298,
-0.0182849821,
0.0298187062,
-0.020362325,
0.0694087073,
-0.034585949,
0.0009472193,
0.0551914051,
0.0003514107,
0.0154129192,
-0.0272805113,
0.0295188539,
-0.0450718962,
-0.0075824773,
-0.0180980116,
0.0496922135,
-0.0128779421,
-0.0259493198,
-0.0086487019,
0.0513179377,
-0.0184191037,
-0.0307924096,
0.0127843469,
0.07576406,
-0.0207348727,
-0.0359603241,
-0.0149273351,
0.0016479238,
-0.0294357184,
0.0786426738,
0.0416707173,
-0.0138767436,
-0.0747539401,
-0.0042577628,
-0.0329025127,
-0.0311804339,
-0.0249531977,
0.0123202698,
0.0548571311,
-0.0047923243,
-0.0163275991,
-0.041038882,
0.0727935731,
0.0462815985,
-0.0435476378,
-0.0350528732,
0.000630885,
0.0090862243,
-0.0457802489,
0.031679634,
-0.0435908176,
0.0150496447,
-0.019445179,
0.0236203037,
0.0123216109,
-0.0472467691,
-0.0183943659,
0.0127275223,
-0.0880778134,
-0.0401071571,
-0.0091652311,
0.0717161,
0.0260358471,
0.0767310262,
-0.0183779448,
-0.0309087671,
0.0546792187,
-0.0032245023,
0.0329058133,
0.0383272953,
0.0014873529,
-0.0128070638,
-0.0006337139,
0.0565909706,
-0.0112593491,
0.0260820091,
0.0318418257,
0.0201952122,
-0.0256235376,
0.0375171937,
0.0357377827,
0.0178499576,
0.0346037038,
0.0188598279,
0.0268252585,
-0.0112371929,
0.0202456843,
-0.0258710496,
-0.0216029193,
-0.067691043,
-0.0033788814,
0.0482255928,
-0.0010393627,
0.0130702928,
-0.0121021681,
-0.0073060426,
0.0170673337,
0.0030773375,
-0.025652403,
0.0331810564,
-0.0037834812,
0.0347193368,
-0.0102974689,
0.0107159857,
0.014610013,
-0.0199997835,
0.0591811575,
-0.0138779152,
0.0825573877,
0.0535322502,
0.0002735382,
-0.053772714,
0.0100349514,
-0.0478506871,
-0.1090046391,
0.0247972645,
0.0323922411,
0.0318606719,
0.0104703838,
0.0087927813,
-0.0141219292,
-0.031394437,
-0.0107545163,
0.0310512185,
0.0150748398,
-0.0239135381,
0.0582414791,
0.050059896,
-0.0093588401,
-0.0416935459,
0.0513283685,
0.0063417549,
0.0448677018,
0.0185206719,
0.0159979574,
-0.0357096344,
-0.0589596741,
-0.0160107408,
-0.0058907703,
0.0011837445,
0.0512447916,
-0.0675184056,
-0.0852624029,
-0.0446752906,
0.0141543783,
-0.0264841579,
0.0196670201,
0.0185578745,
0.0636219978,
0.0226608645,
-0.0644397885,
0.0089478325,
0.000360317,
-0.027864622,
-0.0291035827,
0.0125035215,
-6.501986923e-33,
-0.0381445289,
-0.0145310815,
0.0738722831,
-0.0254497603,
-0.0269144904,
0.0069702151,
-0.0247452576,
-0.0014965512,
-0.0458984151,
0.026035171,
0.014979098,
0.0182883497,
-0.0077328756,
0.0488552041,
-0.0065538851,
-0.0342768878,
0.0090661068,
0.0059586097,
-0.0213867947,
0.0146494545,
0.0168399476,
0.0129954964,
0.0418770425,
-0.001693694,
-0.0375652201,
-0.0005354134,
-0.0155388108,
0.0733029321,
-0.0477704667,
0.0391074866,
-0.0108518992,
-0.0080799544,
0.027366912,
-0.0225805324,
-0.0042758104,
0.029977737,
-0.0950896516,
-0.0175367333,
0.0520797409,
0.0122438772,
-0.0800783783,
0.0035530096,
0.0064100805,
-0.0043356959,
0.0572508015,
-0.0918216184,
-0.000949037,
0.0008720047,
0.0326061808,
0.0192455892,
-0.0378411971,
-0.0000484407,
-0.0150780547,
-0.0429449864,
0.0526745543,
0.0516888164,
-0.0029402126,
0.0344090015,
-0.0315964594,
-0.0209962763,
0.0265364908,
-0.0090738861,
0.0642206147,
0.037235979,
0.0047289706,
0.0358859003,
0.0279236771,
-0.0346085317,
-0.0514582172,
-0.0161836129,
0.0044715414,
0.0691851601,
0.0166270901,
0.0342710316,
0.0463781171,
0.0658057928,
-0.07058613,
-0.0174179357,
-0.0439994112,
0.0866368264,
-0.003008046,
0.0034029235,
0.0193022806,
-0.0250985771,
-0.0498634428,
-0.0132540781,
-0.0471999235,
-0.0304124132,
0.0517535694,
0.0056471126,
-0.0204304419,
0.0211276282,
0.069091171,
-0.0436725914,
0.0109868776,
0.0414822213,
-0.0213045608,
0.0240899995,
0.0039979327,
0.0802969411,
-0.0352233946,
0.0057175891,
0.0142979138,
-0.0179255717,
-0.0219904315,
0.0106590325,
0.0484805144,
0.0171978604,
-0.005754089,
-0.014149541,
-0.0714349523,
0.0181003585,
-0.0156408474,
0.0566546768,
0.0442161821,
0.0548148826,
-0.0290511698,
0.0154896528,
0.0143414661,
-0.0311785322,
-0.0109494943,
0.0123129589,
-0.0000194908,
0.0053986046,
-0.0140904458,
-0.0055241049,
-0.0384382755,
-0.0307563748,
0.0035389492,
-0.0435609147,
-0.0079017337,
0.026271807,
2.722e-7,
0.0487963185,
0.0107763791,
0.0082925344,
0.0519702695,
0.0281693079,
0.0604342185,
-0.0034513962,
0.0048308196,
0.0343699344,
-0.0293345619,
0.0064632837,
0.097495012,
0.0183557477,
-0.0012520674,
-0.0315873474,
0.0336894616,
0.0102447951,
-0.0608058348,
-0.0554433875,
-0.0060764574,
0.0647913367,
0.0777449086,
0.015907649,
-0.0350612402,
0.0486781076,
0.0053233891,
0.0607490353,
-0.0075073908,
-0.0323448814,
-0.0007538809,
-0.0438554063,
0.0124155823,
0.0099380556,
0.0259087905,
0.0304007567,
-0.0277251508,
-0.0041735875,
0.060993921,
-0.0314752311,
-0.0198742654,
-0.0425838493,
-0.0027476128,
0.0022595287,
-0.0713706017,
0.116342023,
-0.0751893595,
-0.0549391322,
-0.0254979786,
-0.0603593178,
-0.0266920589,
-0.0044497475,
0.0112250373,
0.0017238816,
0.0291297771,
0.0066994764,
-0.0249910671,
-0.0227063801,
-0.0883582532,
-0.0152813271,
0.0067181936,
-0.0434845053,
-0.0123765599,
-0.0259393957,
-0.0012429688,
0.0589839444,
-0.0372835211,
-0.0231247358,
2.395762179e-34,
0.0229471512,
0.0156859253,
0.022725774,
0.0275520328,
0.0335195214,
-0.0212974306,
-0.0270816591,
0.0131464787,
0.0055784765,
-0.0768848509,
-0.0127912667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14982v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14982v2 | LAraBench: Benchmarking Arabic AI with Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T10:16:16 | 2024-02-05T07:27:18 | Ahmed Abdelali, Hamdy Mubarak, Shammur Absar Chowdhury, Maram Hasanain, Basel Mousi, Sabri Boughorbel, Yassine El Kheir, Daniel Izham, Fahim Dalvi, Majd Hawasly, Nizi Nazar, Yousseif Elshahawy, Ahmed Ali, Nadir Durrani, Natasa Milic-Frayling, Firoj Alam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
influenced the landscape of language and speech research. Despite this
progress, these models lack specific benchmarking against state-of-the-art
(SOTA) models tailored to particular languages and tasks. LAraBench addresses
this gap for Arabic Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Speech Processing
tasks, including sequence tagging and content classification across different
domains. We utilized models such as GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, BLOOMZ,
Jais-13b-chat, Whisper, and USM, employing zero and few-shot learning
techniques to tackle 33 distinct tasks across 61 publicly available datasets.
This involved 98 experimental setups, encompassing ~296K data points, ~46 hours
of speech, and 30 sentences for Text-to-Speech (TTS). This effort resulted in
330+ sets of experiments. Our analysis focused on measuring the performance gap
between SOTA models and LLMs. The overarching trend observed was that SOTA
models generally outperformed LLMs in zero-shot learning, with a few
exceptions. Notably, larger computational models with few-shot learning
techniques managed to reduce these performance gaps. Our findings provide
valuable insights into the applicability of LLMs for Arabic NLP and speech
processing tasks. | [
-0.0150620183,
0.0513328835,
0.0012296329,
0.0160948299,
-0.0551668108,
0.0297833066,
0.0549943373,
0.003467127,
-0.0358655266,
-0.0584692731,
-0.0374540985,
-0.0923692659,
0.047168009,
0.0011842974,
0.0200825166,
-0.0110551985,
0.0286880396,
-0.0543367974,
0.0138517255,
0.0043373979,
0.0142646506,
0.014448625,
-0.0185448416,
0.0457859002,
0.0157684181,
-0.0197875425,
-0.0214043707,
-0.0172615536,
0.0086632986,
-0.0059663891,
-0.0267646182,
0.0475860685,
-0.014726433,
0.073734127,
0.0000020846,
-0.0452129431,
-0.0101228682,
-0.0138369966,
-0.0568393916,
0.0186916701,
0.0220742952,
-0.027868256,
-0.062995851,
0.0135449301,
-0.0194654148,
-0.0108102569,
0.0329235084,
0.0215105973,
0.0157896709,
0.0798553824,
0.0044146492,
-0.0645970926,
0.0479813702,
-0.0361067243,
0.0326266587,
-0.0642068982,
-0.0069537265,
-0.0340117402,
0.0381959602,
0.0013457377,
-0.0401399769,
0.0308419894,
-0.001606948,
-0.0125095574,
0.0040230416,
0.0305855069,
-0.0772613436,
-0.0402546749,
0.0248644203,
0.0395602249,
-0.0474054702,
0.005875844,
-0.0004663408,
-0.0080931969,
-0.0165587869,
-0.0463069119,
-0.0364428647,
0.0527157784,
-0.0004662745,
0.0149169862,
0.0105533171,
0.0029374717,
0.0225052871,
-0.0050665797,
-0.0463120118,
0.0099551361,
0.0012283907,
-0.0386146232,
0.0113428049,
-0.0029346987,
-0.0036852367,
-0.0461884104,
-0.0199520513,
-0.0052881367,
-0.0284109004,
-0.0131956283,
-0.0188592356,
-0.0166576747,
0.0272985008,
-0.0439240411,
0.0687581822,
0.0956960171,
0.00023222,
0.0426502749,
-0.0676849708,
0.0482697822,
0.0579450764,
-0.0030432637,
-0.0110150492,
0.0115461098,
-0.0703849047,
0.008114676,
-0.0083182417,
0.0466423333,
-0.053088516,
-0.0284191743,
-0.0797230154,
-0.0032507933,
0.0029930461,
0.0392473713,
-0.005509465,
-0.0459792502,
-0.0122859785,
-0.0082325069,
0.0045552729,
0.0100211445,
0.0055492609,
0.0223761313,
-0.0255467426,
-0.1159133017,
-0.0104372166,
-0.0001906601,
0.0223764218,
0.0114092017,
0.0028237395,
0.0499762259,
-0.0026351323,
-0.0853879154,
-0.0413223729,
0.0272593517,
-0.0233667996,
-0.076531224,
-0.0259157196,
-0.0481467396,
0.0403864533,
-0.0068961303,
-0.0016179857,
-0.0032024814,
-0.0001322225,
0.0270591173,
0.0275126696,
0.0745347664,
0.0506792292,
0.0121013327,
0.0313648619,
0.0311324466,
0.0288542118,
0.099719651,
0.0206553638,
0.0068316204,
0.0043003177,
0.0047888858,
0.0169296283,
0.0423272438,
0.0193955265,
0.0216226317,
-0.0214809775,
-0.0405188724,
0.0242475457,
0.0707476661,
-0.0165750589,
0.0242398661,
-0.0558662489,
-0.017288046,
0.0770261213,
0.041914314,
-0.0188209247,
-0.0010988147,
0.0321995802,
0.0485782549,
0.0344291069,
-0.036344666,
0.007627442,
0.0050727106,
0.015642764,
0.0274493117,
0.0760704949,
0.0567015484,
-0.0425623208,
-0.0258675218,
-0.0376076475,
-0.0267136283,
-0.0098345997,
0.0069365148,
0.0808313712,
-0.0110476399,
-0.0671382174,
-0.0062186215,
0.0145994592,
-0.0000372094,
-0.0238532834,
-0.0661760047,
-0.0158689283,
0.0337472633,
0.0071475948,
-0.017536059,
-0.0602359362,
-0.0420080759,
0.0016461302,
0.0599918589,
0.0036213491,
0.0156474095,
0.0401192866,
-0.0338751115,
-0.0080935126,
0.009256891,
0.0151941776,
0.010016242,
0.0187502969,
0.0371000543,
-0.016715847,
-0.0070595588,
0.0198501199,
0.0138258673,
-0.057614889,
-0.0264869407,
0.0278147236,
0.0034169802,
0.0505281724,
0.0440732501,
-0.0408484749,
-0.0070649111,
0.009323719,
-0.0259828158,
-0.0236537978,
-0.0076204403,
-0.046623569,
-0.0234534629,
0.0486940518,
0.0443479791,
0.0153025324,
0.0058960435,
-0.0255356878,
-0.0461608432,
0.0777830631,
-0.0143239852,
0.049841281,
-0.0161262434,
0.0622479096,
0.0018185797,
0.0415925644,
-0.0095186559,
0.0152625712,
-0.0007209854,
-0.0086870901,
-0.0144166434,
-0.0050290981,
0.0490979031,
0.0067889323,
-0.0292434152,
0.0344957858,
-0.0114207352,
0.0011562919,
0.0292013083,
-0.0109820319,
-0.0265784785,
-0.0179783832,
-0.095747225,
0.0115946745,
-0.0099411029,
0.0594043024,
-0.0522147715,
0.0073533244,
-0.0307140592,
0.0032737085,
-0.0198370777,
-0.0023773499,
0.005425313,
0.0305317193,
0.0274528861,
0.0027855376,
-0.0337094776,
-0.0558245406,
-0.0067829061,
0.0164592769,
0.0509159826,
-0.0252265278,
-0.0393620245,
0.029913649,
-0.0284352899,
0.0004072393,
0.0085219853,
0.0053191194,
-0.0412536338,
0.0224772282,
-0.004071536,
0.0287062377,
0.041590374,
-0.0271229818,
0.0097877728,
-0.0044599785,
0.0019988727,
-0.0488199964,
0.0020599389,
0.0162774604,
-0.0311322734,
-0.0521192513,
-0.0079345023,
-0.0570432432,
0.0570693016,
-0.0235024262,
0.0176776387,
-0.0411319062,
0.0377434008,
-0.0101274922,
-0.0049088411,
0.0013092677,
0.0015332383,
-0.0072397054,
0.0510126501,
-0.0090607936,
-0.0419248864,
-0.0097897593,
-0.0413786806,
-0.009445589,
0.0077173263,
0.0015347342,
-0.0408068001,
0.0287799109,
-0.0020303174,
0.0193971228,
-0.0088295192,
-0.0375689901,
-0.0206762198,
-0.0233246423,
0.0096889418,
-0.0345072597,
-0.0012739581,
-0.0261856914,
0.0211456828,
-0.0397862121,
-0.033884123,
-0.0068570953,
0.0135093965,
-0.0672079697,
0.0219685063,
-0.0177963842,
-0.0251923241,
-0.0449183136,
0.0212310683,
0.0334510617,
0.0566026121,
0.0030611423,
-0.0105313221,
-0.00364138,
-0.01170725,
-0.0014003119,
-0.0495654456,
0.0019431964,
-0.0064067482,
0.0661875904,
0.0459758118,
0.0154956281,
0.0402212106,
-0.0760223195,
-0.040680971,
0.0507748201,
-0.0405831635,
-0.0452624448,
-0.0202391613,
0.0012105296,
-0.0677048042,
0.0199850053,
0.1004697978,
0.0067167403,
-0.0265307818,
0.0022768672,
0.0135693066,
0.0022051865,
-0.0053081862,
-0.002557491,
-0.1333981901,
-0.039650131,
0.0402612425,
0.005289339,
-0.0125534208,
-0.0078547308,
0.0193708483,
-0.1462272108,
-0.0083535118,
-0.015667012,
-0.0546949543,
-0.007581572,
-0.0525498725,
-0.0002973476,
-0.0301462822,
0.0146870902,
-0.0429751351,
-0.0150159979,
-0.0064703901,
0.0388802774,
0.0056082872,
-0.0762218013,
0.0329024084,
-0.0414136201,
0.0866114572,
0.0569393076,
0.0090960413,
0.005227088,
0.0156092206,
0.0428532921,
0.0260918494,
-0.0186939072,
-0.0093379384,
0.0132664144,
-0.0256996807,
0.0052781026,
0.0207540281,
-0.0334749073,
-0.0143806469,
-0.0098783495,
-0.0388191193,
0.0414731987,
-0.0085862596,
0.0140877496,
0.0050122412,
0.018623922,
-0.0356387459,
0.0618354864,
-0.0014268546,
-0.0384447724,
-0.0587585457,
0.0069079828,
-0.0242641922,
-0.0542339645,
-0.0394642092,
-0.0132228741,
0.0229238439,
-0.0205016788,
-0.048683174,
-0.0351663269,
0.0168614797,
0.0124033494,
-0.005283345,
0.0370948203,
0.0156627018,
0.0451249331,
-0.0118303597,
-0.0493164621,
-0.0019037896,
0.0196214672,
-0.0551582836,
0.0082074385,
0.0289684702,
-0.0593091771,
-0.0025208546,
-0.0407962464,
-0.1105647907,
-0.0456314422,
0.0008335817,
0.0045223352,
0.0172278006,
0.0200973712,
0.0021517465,
-0.0531651601,
0.061615821,
0.0586731732,
-0.033133287,
0.0308594536,
0.041945979,
-0.0005707708,
-0.0264848843,
0.0445004553,
0.0220345967,
0.0328178369,
0.0201753378,
-0.006700871,
-0.0100742374,
0.0096287886,
-0.0271710157,
-0.0274802074,
0.0268605296,
-0.041771464,
-0.0567164198,
-0.0029186974,
0.0072893393,
-0.0296475161,
0.0466687568,
-0.0119322082,
-0.0259367116,
0.0207868349,
0.026609404,
-0.0161017217,
-0.0122787356,
-0.0147419153,
0.0234771036,
0.0015037782,
0.0105147175,
-0.0018968889,
-0.0403219461,
-0.0171195269,
0.0271274112,
0.0099764792,
-0.0270164907,
-0.00838154,
0.0234421808,
-0.0412738621,
0.0251259189,
-0.0196744129,
0.0278578047,
0.0385610051,
0.0626427904,
-0.0216838941,
-0.0151242269,
0.0008144862,
0.075912796,
0.0698947981,
-0.0189612117,
0.0548859499,
0.0103972591,
-0.0008031139,
-0.0190789029,
0.0069401455,
-0.0448023677,
-0.0113640344,
-0.0274423528,
0.0219376981,
-0.0135356467,
0.0439816937,
0.07698033,
0.0385462344,
0.0169611555,
0.0306940582,
0.0084577827,
-0.0161785912,
-0.0113426391,
0.0159400105,
0.0122161005,
-0.0259431973,
0.0165650696,
-0.0716174766,
-0.0605295748,
0.0201392788,
-0.0190406516,
0.0011556918,
-0.0071475892,
0.0233271923,
0.0476122238,
0.0112251183,
-0.0071556517,
-0.0539036617,
-0.0407371409,
-0.0136359241,
-0.0395784527,
0.0401601754,
-6.442308545e-33,
0.0142383715,
0.0113218445,
0.0369684733,
-0.0008760809,
-0.0161843579,
0.0150499009,
-0.0247644205,
0.0113258138,
-0.017586587,
-0.0134508992,
-0.0551207922,
0.0147506269,
0.0334444344,
0.0420830958,
0.0534560047,
-0.017274227,
0.0508499406,
-0.0234620292,
-0.0127505064,
0.0380343273,
0.0181554854,
0.0489286333,
0.0759444684,
-0.0113157509,
-0.016100999,
0.0073479633,
-0.0222036839,
-0.0098950192,
0.0239841286,
0.0865717679,
-0.0391813703,
0.0405944325,
0.009422021,
-0.067825228,
0.0109796841,
0.0027150069,
-0.0409180634,
0.0197660625,
0.0065696174,
0.0416255109,
0.0349870883,
-0.0289619733,
-0.0483876504,
-0.0005402665,
-0.0554312579,
0.0098325172,
-0.0141288778,
-0.0316691771,
-0.0154738268,
-0.0238733236,
-0.1039429381,
0.0626812577,
-0.006510112,
-0.0015095229,
0.0833569169,
0.0490905568,
-0.0045359377,
0.0477939174,
-0.0668700486,
0.007468198,
-0.0072187511,
0.0411685184,
0.063505955,
0.0144745223,
-0.0258596539,
0.0632773787,
0.0608556941,
-0.0265171118,
0.0268383101,
0.0194490924,
0.0260257199,
-0.0170619916,
0.0295101535,
0.0663577914,
0.0491195098,
-0.0023383393,
-0.0824661329,
-0.0241369251,
0.0320334248,
0.0290481541,
0.0586989,
0.005577859,
-0.0653696954,
0.0069865324,
-0.0122512961,
-0.0402679443,
-0.0265883002,
0.0014012037,
0.0312139299,
0.0444458723,
0.0090934681,
0.0514725745,
0.0496454798,
-0.0172697064,
0.0468337573,
0.0087107318,
-0.026751766,
0.0065353625,
-0.0012289468,
0.0299449917,
-0.0839841962,
-0.057421498,
0.0118185831,
0.0494936369,
0.0318546034,
-0.0190362949,
0.0360986739,
0.0411535911,
-0.0991085842,
0.0153639242,
-0.0389931798,
0.0446370468,
-0.0059287851,
0.048031576,
0.0376689434,
-0.0082719866,
0.0024132433,
0.0564336441,
0.0169531852,
-0.0058717192,
0.0114572747,
-0.0290895868,
-0.0488327034,
-0.0313165076,
-0.001522942,
0.0465621985,
-0.0356481634,
0.0150191393,
0.0186889917,
-0.0627734289,
-0.0165357571,
0.0107392529,
2.952e-7,
-0.0136609748,
0.0429759398,
0.0094454084,
0.0020969564,
0.0059402995,
0.0459488519,
0.0004748694,
0.0117405187,
-0.008990298,
0.0549914911,
-0.0084360186,
0.0161389206,
0.0684683844,
0.0122090895,
-0.1059410796,
-0.0374943651,
-0.0512106083,
0.023328824,
-0.0734449998,
-0.0151883103,
0.0310890228,
0.1490280181,
-0.0288883727,
-0.0205262974,
0.006407395,
-0.0491110422,
0.0692108795,
-0.002112421,
-0.0355805568,
0.0088681998,
0.0151051544,
0.0094244918,
0.0088822534,
-0.0119661484,
-0.023545282,
0.0104865097,
0.0067024706,
0.0819487497,
0.0068613114,
-0.018821571,
0.0036852139,
0.0052023097,
-0.0204746984,
-0.0386000574,
0.0889329687,
-0.0223424975,
-0.0459328853,
0.0072653522,
-0.0335206017,
0.0018408555,
0.0630104765,
-0.0370511636,
0.016570596,
0.0277613718,
0.0250324756,
-0.0279106125,
-0.0005686552,
-0.025756374,
0.0201381091,
-0.0165341347,
0.0023857977,
-0.002543886,
-0.0245571062,
-0.0076380828,
0.0132728415,
-0.0187534951,
-0.0177137796,
2.471965667e-34,
0.0386641696,
-0.0294558313,
0.0218913052,
0.0054329131,
-0.0082592396,
0.0174400583,
-0.0245699063,
0.0094408263,
-0.0008423,
-0.0372736193,
-0.0062571443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14981v1 | Improving Factuality of Abstractive Summarization without Sacrificing Summary Quality | 2023-05-24T10:15:17 | 2023-05-24T10:15:17 | Tanay Dixit, Fei Wang, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Improving factual consistency of abstractive summarization has been a widely
studied topic. However, most of the prior works on training factuality-aware
models have ignored the negative effect it has on summary quality. We propose
EFACTSUM (i.e., Effective Factual Summarization), a candidate summary
generation and ranking technique to improve summary factuality without
sacrificing summary quality. We show that using a contrastive learning
framework with our refined candidate summaries leads to significant gains on
both factuality and similarity-based metrics. Specifically, we propose a
ranking strategy in which we effectively combine two metrics, thereby
preventing any conflict during training. Models trained using our approach show
up to 6 points of absolute improvement over the base model with respect to
FactCC on XSUM and 11 points on CNN/DM, without negatively affecting either
similarity-based metrics or absractiveness. | [
0.0413596146,
0.0280377883,
0.0293019935,
0.0248345267,
-0.0085266447,
0.0136019839,
-0.0361734405,
-0.0404222719,
-0.0428136028,
-0.0285645388,
0.022661129,
-0.0673602149,
0.0265635476,
0.0071418965,
0.0151198525,
-0.0842802599,
0.0196895842,
0.0348952524,
0.0009199147,
-0.0015273031,
0.0355308726,
0.0173412897,
-0.0025436555,
0.0186133664,
-0.0235060845,
0.0026141654,
0.0002222907,
-0.0108940117,
0.0723141953,
-0.0092642484,
0.0111587718,
0.0191918407,
-0.0059528649,
0.0038407182,
0.0000017779,
-0.0249670967,
-0.0204115491,
0.0053951479,
0.0037123817,
0.0335635319,
0.0475622751,
-0.0147611694,
0.0271401294,
0.0227785427,
-0.0067861006,
-0.0231383499,
0.0260664485,
0.0858903676,
0.0918741822,
0.0685190111,
-0.0043400596,
-0.0504884757,
0.0144200595,
-0.024797881,
-0.0696872398,
0.0340441652,
-0.0128477663,
0.0588174611,
-0.0527401827,
0.019513417,
0.0065761604,
0.0195367597,
0.0098582152,
0.0245151129,
0.0316725671,
0.0607940443,
-0.0330929272,
0.0064287661,
0.0461377017,
0.0594006442,
-0.0108439773,
-0.0112354318,
0.0185948554,
-0.0162942596,
0.0064865346,
-0.0205450431,
-0.0312766805,
0.0417487659,
-0.0173499715,
0.0288062207,
0.0383282676,
0.0418946557,
-0.008895196,
0.0425482728,
-0.020662671,
-0.0322897583,
-0.0116760898,
-0.0070638829,
-0.0452801101,
0.0101291006,
-0.0355679505,
-0.0541073307,
-0.0054791872,
0.0073607164,
-0.0159653444,
-0.0199162029,
-0.0678574592,
-0.0432152078,
0.0233077668,
-0.0602055155,
0.0248911139,
0.0210163034,
-0.0240586512,
0.0247060712,
-0.0041266903,
0.0362867117,
0.031354703,
0.0236611478,
-0.0554399714,
-0.0203581136,
0.0093335975,
0.0267775394,
-0.0167343859,
0.0620477274,
-0.0315001979,
0.0004845423,
-0.0497764796,
-0.0212001428,
-0.0111091509,
0.0082977209,
-0.0060394616,
0.0129187107,
-0.0233327448,
0.0051178918,
-0.0444585644,
-0.0085784607,
-0.0335337594,
-0.0115495929,
0.0244825408,
0.0087969163,
-0.0160703734,
0.0077032978,
-0.0044687903,
0.004366341,
-0.0044205086,
-0.0043473332,
-0.0342129953,
-0.0088651758,
-0.0267206281,
-0.0124473087,
-0.0134379892,
-0.0617987104,
-0.0247432496,
-0.0713995993,
-0.0054491945,
-0.0126362229,
-0.0128283715,
0.0081158932,
-0.0007764799,
0.0095546953,
-0.0053741289,
0.0414134674,
-0.0033907213,
-0.0367618985,
0.0096620051,
0.0013703615,
-0.0116015878,
0.0084108422,
0.03771054,
0.0314900093,
0.0359843075,
0.0666326359,
-0.0016250046,
-0.0376135074,
0.0092829363,
0.0031896469,
0.0530346595,
-0.0065278527,
-0.0371444896,
0.0009113807,
0.0491071492,
0.0728590041,
-0.0331459939,
-0.0243272781,
0.0692471936,
0.000160674,
0.0160372406,
0.0640304238,
0.046464704,
0.0496323258,
0.0065453057,
0.0932396799,
-0.0259941872,
0.0578504242,
0.015833376,
0.0718405023,
0.0900296345,
0.0416729748,
-0.0288451929,
-0.07908573,
0.0050499765,
-0.0177589171,
0.0003679598,
-0.015703693,
0.0020960346,
0.0174658801,
-0.0357031412,
0.0534031875,
0.0229917709,
-0.0598262623,
0.0006940069,
-0.0089506796,
0.0406494029,
0.0241381563,
0.0234776046,
-0.0186436605,
-0.0435262732,
0.0073001096,
-0.0213848799,
0.0562157929,
0.055487778,
-0.0130524831,
0.0117418617,
-0.046572987,
-0.0284632165,
-0.0546564162,
0.0131345959,
-0.019403087,
0.0048810444,
-0.0133433808,
0.0550244153,
-0.0234059058,
-0.0531914346,
0.0212645214,
0.0076905494,
-0.0054326234,
0.0048265159,
0.0046754559,
0.0078420658,
0.0240498986,
-0.0174996797,
0.0157352611,
-0.0061859111,
-0.0249907766,
-0.0176839698,
0.0133026857,
-0.0499011762,
-0.0694856495,
0.0530841537,
-0.0550849922,
0.0058025024,
0.0610561185,
-0.0719683319,
-0.0404948182,
0.0116791585,
-0.0784546435,
0.0262545012,
-0.0504437648,
-0.0027811162,
0.0608508512,
-0.018371677,
0.0144513603,
0.090067789,
-0.0262167212,
-0.0165726785,
0.0307101384,
-0.0298582781,
0.0060903039,
-0.0379864275,
0.0105793066,
-0.0254972298,
0.0188681446,
0.0394775867,
0.0410833806,
-0.0069928393,
-0.0316429175,
-0.0012374375,
-0.0676064268,
0.018214304,
-0.0267279018,
-0.0104214391,
0.0550688207,
-0.0256989524,
0.0277719852,
0.0195852257,
-0.063865453,
-0.059409637,
-0.0201498363,
-0.0130010592,
0.0497639813,
0.0306097101,
0.0264611207,
-0.0472908653,
-0.0116050588,
0.0117235333,
0.0457734838,
-0.0134254554,
-0.0136363991,
-0.0341157354,
0.0578368753,
-0.0595749244,
-0.0106440177,
-0.0050040502,
0.0115253301,
-0.0189251304,
0.0384433493,
0.0328635164,
0.0262308363,
0.057042744,
0.0059003928,
0.0432932377,
0.0329328477,
-0.0199844912,
-0.0082968958,
-0.0484098271,
0.0629795194,
0.0496034697,
-0.0492191389,
-0.0121865524,
0.0135212606,
0.0259120297,
-0.0046398924,
-0.0287188031,
0.0156110274,
-0.0191325638,
0.0018827361,
-0.0187133122,
0.0005053799,
-0.010840673,
-0.0061834017,
-0.0495041423,
-0.0013508978,
0.0904095396,
-0.0386598483,
0.0337631404,
-0.0601521283,
-0.0264821853,
-0.0266414303,
0.0048477491,
0.0035345894,
0.0345246941,
0.0030151501,
0.0128976554,
-0.0587196201,
-0.0434978381,
0.0470198654,
-0.0282142293,
0.1111547276,
-0.0169763137,
-0.0045112171,
-0.0221179537,
-0.0450056903,
-0.0290805567,
-0.0396691039,
0.0126077961,
0.0583548173,
-0.0080070663,
-0.0041577714,
-0.0590627454,
0.0053171981,
0.0535830222,
0.0687769577,
-0.025115855,
-0.0169499144,
-0.0184040479,
0.060096737,
0.0632427633,
0.0227863658,
0.0592081584,
-0.0481614955,
0.024268562,
0.0735057518,
-0.0024998516,
-0.0371853411,
-0.0230324436,
-0.0336589664,
-0.0351672322,
-0.0447041243,
-0.0001752022,
-0.0086297132,
0.0329883546,
-0.0278572198,
-0.0046316586,
0.0830787346,
0.0038041607,
0.0181854647,
-0.0034147464,
0.0215498097,
0.0292562135,
-0.0095464969,
-0.0268736389,
-0.0435693637,
-0.006759203,
-0.0207523685,
0.0256627053,
0.022820944,
-0.0014768196,
-0.0039785514,
-0.0759553462,
0.0204523802,
0.0122038657,
-0.0518567078,
-0.0568559244,
-0.0004299261,
0.0128229149,
-0.0576635376,
0.0139683923,
0.0283716712,
-0.0139488159,
0.0183202419,
0.0189430192,
-0.0342108533,
0.0099898055,
-0.0115201743,
-0.0614629127,
-0.0312365349,
0.0228585228,
0.0379696526,
0.0084226876,
0.0163635332,
-0.0030688369,
-0.0643313304,
-0.0145348907,
0.0106832115,
0.077523306,
-0.0331368484,
0.0119210249,
-0.0326592214,
0.0249464549,
0.0625211224,
-0.0375575535,
-0.0406606682,
-0.0088672033,
-0.0018727122,
-0.0043715304,
-0.0529711805,
0.0498233363,
-0.0267251115,
0.0860212967,
0.0469011255,
0.0081158914,
-0.0022092944,
-0.036481481,
0.0139819672,
-0.0591866635,
-0.0102659846,
-0.0238188412,
-0.0295252744,
0.015248226,
-0.089350976,
-0.0647816062,
-0.033842627,
-0.0166659467,
-0.0383496806,
-0.0340811275,
0.0178421307,
-0.024639193,
-0.0409652181,
0.0150130922,
-0.0130993556,
-0.0019336073,
0.0160132255,
-0.0437788591,
0.0730217919,
-0.0472264029,
-0.037045002,
0.0143932858,
-0.0330405347,
-0.0368396416,
-0.0382938124,
0.0575864986,
0.0110655865,
0.0902623683,
0.0189502798,
0.0235415809,
0.0733880997,
0.0170101542,
0.0200835839,
0.0405902117,
0.0377322212,
0.0196537133,
0.0033353551,
0.0151320063,
-0.0460816659,
0.0153346825,
0.0034632559,
0.0583260171,
-0.0420132987,
-0.037371818,
0.0416530333,
0.0170270856,
0.0312638655,
-0.020356657,
0.0062787677,
-0.0404260233,
-0.0018785218,
-0.0110613573,
-0.0283464678,
-0.040978644,
0.0548870079,
-0.0330872126,
0.047190804,
-0.0254694577,
0.0429267734,
-0.0326703005,
0.0333281904,
-0.0080888886,
-0.0476370864,
-0.0642273054,
-0.0372349843,
-0.056513831,
-0.0146388952,
-0.0937452838,
-0.0262413416,
-0.0284612011,
0.0289889779,
-0.0052494388,
-0.0124187088,
0.0463162884,
0.0249027833,
-0.0149213932,
0.0447061434,
-0.0671850815,
0.0310064834,
-0.1089244038,
-0.003237668,
0.0478656925,
-0.0511870906,
0.0519840792,
-0.0266846288,
-0.0028953082,
-0.0153171355,
0.0381498672,
0.0118972808,
-0.0063562728,
-0.0164029878,
0.0234553292,
0.0260829795,
0.0078714099,
0.0560748875,
-0.0889180452,
0.0113812946,
0.0129129253,
-0.0206180401,
-0.0435724109,
-0.0564473979,
-0.030996304,
0.0149997734,
0.0034746872,
-0.0166835357,
-0.060163416,
-0.0449082553,
0.0432859547,
0.0310478359,
0.02121998,
-0.0109859444,
0.0528567471,
0.0154491961,
0.0190665405,
-0.0344871283,
-0.0408217423,
-0.0292473007,
0.0161710605,
0.0269399583,
-0.0426640809,
-6.064454334e-33,
-0.0427215584,
0.0130653623,
-0.0156012392,
0.0017864811,
-0.0339004584,
0.0382383615,
-0.0500132516,
-0.002910041,
-0.0309386179,
0.0325850919,
0.0277317129,
0.0360656492,
0.00816801,
0.0244216658,
-0.045607347,
0.0102434959,
0.0545878634,
0.0260910671,
-0.0503794812,
0.0332753286,
0.0198435746,
-0.0234922431,
0.0492664725,
-0.0501458012,
-0.0039940248,
-0.0025345606,
-0.0149537651,
0.0239307228,
0.0033289727,
0.0546623021,
0.011019594,
0.0349082537,
0.0375966355,
-0.0364632607,
-0.0457301103,
-0.0394651294,
-0.048173923,
-0.026133813,
0.04959438,
-0.0625915527,
-0.0392569564,
-0.0386223197,
0.02946629,
-0.0146740694,
0.0046694917,
-0.0817695335,
0.0564016178,
-0.0463028662,
-0.0264824685,
-0.0487762578,
-0.0133222193,
0.0249788594,
-0.0031803367,
-0.0177574046,
-0.022593582,
0.024565639,
0.0287474189,
-0.0117221791,
-0.0540096164,
0.0327051543,
0.0292692464,
0.0575257652,
0.0082146339,
-0.001939361,
-0.0218511168,
0.0738459155,
-0.0136625487,
-0.0245713871,
-0.0386821963,
0.0057069096,
-0.0348903388,
0.0116705019,
0.0585874468,
0.0557037033,
0.0448684432,
0.0458075404,
-0.0509860665,
0.0760787353,
-0.0404977277,
0.0277007185,
0.0128177367,
-0.0088050347,
-0.0097809834,
0.0009426671,
-0.0237044599,
0.0389916487,
-0.0163140092,
0.0004786016,
-0.024408469,
0.025115449,
-0.0378454328,
0.0087749977,
-0.0049549248,
-0.0175892059,
0.0351195596,
0.0010412155,
-0.0468661413,
0.0082161603,
0.0035750701,
-0.021382397,
-0.0506974868,
0.0204479545,
0.013600179,
0.0151039474,
-0.0334123708,
0.0196288899,
0.0730549768,
0.0012276928,
-0.0154102091,
0.0340301804,
0.0048293085,
0.0005409509,
-0.0489034802,
0.0003912455,
-0.0135056367,
0.0287513863,
-0.0135454899,
0.0389825217,
-0.0157501549,
0.0253189187,
-0.0252413582,
0.0192864109,
0.0385991856,
0.0781117156,
-0.0055913581,
0.0306419618,
-0.0337335356,
0.0079837665,
0.0408529155,
-0.0568491966,
-0.0379662216,
0.0202357993,
2.294e-7,
0.0200045872,
-0.0354228429,
0.0258561913,
0.0431927256,
-0.04689968,
0.053805206,
0.0014086494,
0.0426855236,
0.0283420626,
-0.0173136275,
0.027915271,
0.0584139936,
0.0416360348,
0.0320957787,
-0.0558640063,
0.020973241,
-0.0924720541,
-0.0515107289,
-0.0091246367,
-0.0125944391,
0.0525599867,
0.0823880136,
-0.0008523112,
0.0113750147,
0.0319257006,
-0.0098167015,
0.0508463569,
0.0157099925,
-0.0391947292,
-0.0020870434,
0.0466815084,
0.0130927283,
-0.0256820284,
-0.0197980832,
-0.0159974154,
-0.0004124684,
0.0432997197,
0.0234683771,
0.0358638577,
-0.0366794802,
0.0233405009,
-0.0028162128,
0.0108903069,
-0.0015258632,
0.0287415739,
-0.0501235202,
0.0007493335,
-0.0294399597,
-0.0791867748,
0.0649217069,
-0.0135121662,
-0.000171154,
-0.0712959394,
0.0381501988,
-0.0107376268,
0.0061113355,
0.0102191353,
-0.0254562888,
-0.0567845628,
0.0361944325,
-0.0015070431,
-0.0536042973,
0.0385155454,
-0.0155547047,
0.0090639414,
-0.0658651367,
-0.007219736,
2.083577283e-34,
0.1054267511,
-0.0056376681,
-0.0156196095,
-0.0136059942,
0.0269711576,
-0.0049385647,
-0.0214408115,
-0.0510788709,
0.0178081915,
-0.0230145529,
-0.0233915355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14976v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14976v2 | GPTAraEval: A Comprehensive Evaluation of ChatGPT on Arabic NLP | 2023-05-24T10:12:39 | 2023-10-21T05:16:24 | Md Tawkat Islam Khondaker, Abdul Waheed, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | ChatGPT's emergence heralds a transformative phase in NLP, particularly
demonstrated through its excellent performance on many English benchmarks.
However, the model's efficacy across diverse linguistic contexts remains
largely uncharted territory. This work aims to bridge this knowledge gap, with
a primary focus on assessing ChatGPT's capabilities on Arabic languages and
dialectal varieties. Our comprehensive study conducts a large-scale automated
and human evaluation of ChatGPT, encompassing 44 distinct language
understanding and generation tasks on over 60 different datasets. To our
knowledge, this marks the first extensive performance analysis of ChatGPT's
deployment in Arabic NLP. Our findings indicate that, despite its remarkable
performance in English, ChatGPT is consistently surpassed by smaller models
that have undergone finetuning on Arabic. We further undertake a meticulous
comparison of ChatGPT and GPT-4's Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) and Dialectal
Arabic (DA), unveiling the relative shortcomings of both models in handling
Arabic dialects compared to MSA. Although we further explore and confirm the
utility of employing GPT-4 as a potential alternative for human evaluation, our
work adds to a growing body of research underscoring the limitations of
ChatGPT. | [
0.0283366181,
0.0543322191,
-0.0094220899,
0.0187286623,
-0.0592212044,
0.0172350332,
0.0467562601,
-0.0365322158,
-0.0369964167,
-0.0534244962,
-0.0063792267,
-0.1039338335,
0.0294475202,
0.0200899057,
0.043376144,
-0.0458009727,
0.0150491502,
-0.0485746227,
-0.0327489451,
0.0138322031,
0.0691483393,
0.0358867049,
-0.033127971,
0.0479382686,
-0.0119903218,
-0.0551853962,
-0.0395680442,
-0.0167218,
0.0192792751,
0.0158491451,
0.0070899776,
0.0669554844,
-0.0068419878,
0.0405267254,
0.0000019118,
-0.0628041849,
-0.0374989659,
-0.0304863248,
-0.0237317663,
0.0415083282,
0.048795674,
-0.0421427004,
-0.0316951722,
-0.0020793432,
-0.0305329543,
0.0159282368,
0.0359731652,
0.0268128011,
0.0597372688,
0.0281370021,
0.0042427895,
-0.004767824,
-0.0094173448,
-0.0106673315,
-0.0029543468,
-0.0289993528,
-0.034906093,
0.0032089904,
0.0057755467,
0.0114488527,
-0.0181608684,
0.0258407611,
0.0037219273,
-0.0201767702,
-0.0397245325,
0.003570704,
-0.0821292251,
-0.0290185791,
0.0043211877,
0.0383497514,
0.0178942662,
-0.0218341686,
-0.0056854733,
0.034882769,
0.0072191935,
0.0014358993,
-0.0310336445,
0.0361694917,
-0.0416415222,
0.0109751057,
0.0431895815,
0.0003129242,
-0.0191653967,
-0.0064053489,
-0.0047899899,
0.0484661199,
0.0289017335,
-0.013878813,
0.0301223695,
0.0264775511,
-0.029474793,
-0.0270575341,
0.018724015,
-0.0058577834,
-0.0236888845,
-0.0066533568,
-0.0232816357,
0.01844538,
0.0178545266,
-0.0523261279,
0.0075456286,
0.0642686784,
-0.010962164,
-0.0084345732,
-0.034752544,
0.0363375396,
0.0521358065,
0.0012862673,
-0.0638209209,
0.0056632878,
-0.075826183,
-0.0236885287,
-0.0543598048,
0.0275370162,
-0.0700164959,
0.0133730629,
-0.0709266365,
0.0093881506,
-0.0218478516,
-0.0104152039,
0.0114508066,
0.0023248757,
-0.0456547961,
-0.0161105189,
-0.0028575475,
-0.0189352892,
-0.0350411385,
-0.0155978119,
-0.0178025533,
-0.1083776504,
-0.0044390289,
0.0154792862,
-0.01680886,
0.0329508409,
-0.0538537949,
0.0642924085,
-0.0303415917,
-0.0445047691,
-0.065019697,
-0.0112468107,
-0.0370456055,
-0.0600688532,
-0.0362256877,
-0.052690845,
0.0429773815,
0.0125610484,
-0.0243410766,
0.0174927544,
-0.0038190633,
0.0273427609,
0.0544656366,
0.0372427963,
0.0163078494,
0.0020394728,
0.0327628292,
0.0224624053,
-0.002498833,
0.0911981314,
0.0038618292,
-0.0159925632,
0.0069186003,
0.0113728503,
-0.0001139815,
0.0252888091,
0.0040743528,
-0.0053394972,
-0.0068436489,
-0.0402480252,
0.0064707459,
0.0723791346,
-0.0191133115,
0.0511831455,
-0.0394522548,
-0.0179146212,
0.0325847119,
0.0000742075,
-0.0194450673,
0.0465194844,
0.0602340437,
0.0504498817,
0.0400266387,
0.0365997143,
0.0125173647,
-0.0063713887,
0.000285419,
0.0199412461,
-0.0061939657,
0.0974903107,
-0.0219805073,
-0.0556571707,
-0.0348377824,
0.0151347062,
0.0250678193,
-0.0299715996,
0.0595952459,
0.0160351228,
-0.0195243917,
0.0254151393,
0.0291046277,
-0.0106743015,
0.027111873,
-0.0522119068,
-0.0473653264,
0.036392387,
0.0428150818,
0.0297490265,
-0.0706745088,
-0.0070540402,
0.0055766189,
0.0441098921,
0.0442529283,
-0.0277101789,
0.0012233587,
-0.0475554802,
-0.0045028217,
0.0010495958,
0.0130899679,
0.0096881306,
0.0209126323,
0.0225024652,
0.0080215028,
-0.0556951612,
0.0045982138,
0.0343737565,
-0.0313308053,
0.0251043029,
-0.0161454882,
-0.007658117,
0.0058812657,
0.0450450554,
-0.0003801405,
0.0002268387,
-0.0124276215,
-0.0324715935,
-0.0167695452,
0.0609154366,
-0.0451477729,
-0.0543659441,
0.0338197835,
-0.0362314917,
0.0043841396,
0.008233902,
-0.0324136056,
-0.0401536264,
0.0729862005,
-0.0259452611,
0.0460178927,
-0.0553458445,
0.0210533179,
0.0356233343,
0.0227639843,
-0.0394235142,
0.0656996369,
-0.0051807254,
-0.0280224811,
0.0135652563,
0.0102194445,
0.064800106,
0.0096911099,
0.0037326552,
0.0250669587,
-0.016777657,
0.017490875,
0.0437413752,
0.024383666,
-0.061951004,
-0.0457548499,
-0.1045452207,
-0.0083055273,
-0.0221990962,
0.0607429221,
0.0323482417,
-0.0046324162,
-0.0179881919,
0.0215836931,
-0.0370063707,
-0.0019005903,
0.024680065,
0.0171652157,
0.0539218374,
-0.0214291494,
0.0020752291,
-0.0488028452,
0.0175331309,
0.0288585406,
0.0403207503,
0.042124629,
-0.0132763414,
0.0289918482,
-0.0421212353,
-0.0297447257,
0.0004496212,
0.0198399145,
-0.0438202098,
0.0281830039,
0.0025433025,
0.0456288569,
-0.0156451743,
0.0249820631,
0.0504681282,
-0.0230511501,
-0.0465440825,
-0.0373509899,
0.0098568257,
-0.0032978624,
-0.0372336842,
-0.0276646689,
-0.0499841422,
-0.0342944972,
0.0521766432,
0.0147952791,
-0.0177019481,
-0.0680537075,
0.0357135944,
-0.0605974756,
0.0192270949,
-0.0181803629,
0.0430488996,
-0.0078655938,
0.0834765881,
-0.024505455,
-0.0263529699,
0.0270031504,
-0.0426225886,
-0.0024122719,
-0.0419872887,
0.0268631335,
-0.0426710993,
0.0220775437,
-0.0458582006,
0.0432733297,
-0.0179252587,
-0.0350869223,
-0.0545597374,
-0.0027816049,
0.0209197216,
-0.0071767974,
0.0201141164,
-0.1000595242,
0.0071187089,
-0.0005790981,
-0.0322328508,
-0.0391408801,
-0.0031390695,
-0.0185833238,
-0.0038601188,
0.0673935637,
0.0082132174,
-0.0069138263,
0.0484981984,
-0.0071703941,
0.0096974475,
-0.0324492119,
-0.0137911076,
0.0121314479,
-0.0067689922,
0.0522228479,
0.0193488486,
0.0253753494,
0.0062138308,
0.0262355544,
0.0597581938,
-0.0231773928,
0.0031663431,
-0.057042744,
0.0112637058,
0.0299942642,
-0.0504402556,
-0.0431535617,
-0.045621708,
0.0204766802,
-0.0436781533,
-0.0145969586,
0.1008227021,
0.0370879695,
0.0015554354,
0.0223046243,
-0.0155622903,
0.0432950407,
-0.0230487082,
-0.026147671,
-0.1189963967,
-0.0046683652,
0.0257216524,
0.0222964883,
0.022641629,
0.0041415892,
0.011192414,
-0.0971047208,
0.0400631614,
-0.010814962,
-0.045181416,
0.0019156508,
-0.0017969576,
-0.0024165623,
-0.0169695932,
0.0102718771,
-0.0033181349,
-0.0323979743,
0.0663596466,
0.0783957839,
-0.018657919,
-0.0612622574,
0.0342822336,
-0.0081312973,
0.0297154728,
0.0260542911,
0.0123544224,
0.0038164402,
-0.0193922836,
0.0487354137,
-0.035775952,
-0.0226282589,
0.0013342892,
0.017588811,
0.0133767128,
0.0013981111,
-0.0318095498,
-0.0185028333,
-0.0686770752,
0.009633963,
-0.0119053926,
0.0167949274,
-0.0157838743,
0.0277758986,
0.0089938715,
0.0503676645,
-0.0338301361,
0.0614177398,
-0.0004103725,
-0.023189811,
-0.0673575848,
-0.0083488105,
0.0023324494,
-0.0752701983,
-0.0349452868,
0.0147668095,
0.0488516577,
0.0154723004,
-0.0940862522,
-0.0899895057,
0.0102813095,
0.030976437,
0.0087670246,
0.0119951256,
-0.0269328225,
0.0219999664,
-0.0162689369,
-0.0180052258,
0.0272363331,
-0.0355303176,
-0.0340219624,
-0.038267605,
0.0182515793,
-0.0867505297,
0.0001077375,
0.017884586,
-0.0851192251,
-0.0425844975,
0.0320293494,
0.0052511701,
0.0272813663,
0.0194184575,
-0.0080122324,
0.0086594783,
-0.0313898139,
-0.0052544484,
0.0308466647,
0.0176358018,
0.0095764818,
0.0230353083,
-0.0219803136,
0.0537618957,
0.0337557681,
0.0074271895,
-0.0366395563,
0.012715186,
0.0124490708,
-0.0248551164,
0.0628153533,
-0.0152419377,
-0.0059351525,
-0.0656367019,
-0.0251837727,
-0.0493926816,
-0.0279253162,
-0.0353986174,
0.0197077282,
-0.0553077236,
0.0187851973,
0.0030503636,
0.0151595809,
-0.0055383337,
-0.0281055402,
-0.0292872395,
0.0305145346,
0.0141177736,
-0.0095946658,
-0.0109088654,
-0.0038785546,
-0.0189860817,
0.0197698437,
0.0045622322,
-0.0524750762,
-0.0579767674,
0.0572914742,
-0.0331699476,
0.0542981438,
-0.0118757607,
0.0277761091,
0.0475922041,
0.0557386391,
0.0176800061,
-0.0315172449,
-0.0278564952,
0.0815219134,
0.0624745116,
-0.019992264,
0.0808386132,
-0.0055020256,
0.00980647,
-0.0134115675,
0.0505752861,
-0.0087162806,
-0.0276828762,
-0.0271917395,
-0.0121658845,
-0.0173752997,
-0.0092210416,
0.096315451,
-0.002140017,
0.0123517979,
0.0207590424,
-0.0069468846,
-0.0160080828,
-0.0352907442,
-0.0380069576,
-0.0238856357,
0.0056932317,
0.0415790975,
-0.0912069827,
-0.0717944354,
-0.025522491,
0.0222443826,
0.0366251245,
0.0202739853,
0.0701722503,
0.0951200798,
-0.015386262,
-0.0136176497,
-0.0748469681,
0.0047818162,
0.0026287299,
-0.0196597092,
-0.0078956829,
-6.463921478e-33,
-0.015545819,
-0.0145945176,
0.0315601975,
-0.0164183937,
-0.0175841171,
-0.0181630384,
-0.0314062089,
0.0186549667,
0.0184103064,
0.0218912661,
-0.0158825722,
-0.0034221008,
0.0231948793,
0.0191027615,
0.0485892929,
-0.0465308949,
0.0120522743,
-0.0261560362,
-0.0094830133,
0.0503277071,
0.0449857935,
0.0352450199,
0.1083279699,
-0.0238206033,
0.0324658826,
-0.0069797575,
-0.0406245515,
-0.0104189431,
-0.0008977723,
0.0763813555,
-0.0374985263,
0.0432090499,
0.0434550308,
-0.0212018751,
0.0144091975,
-0.0477572009,
-0.0289077908,
-0.0249086507,
0.0184485298,
0.0403407179,
-0.0354685225,
-0.008025446,
-0.0309972167,
-0.0227735527,
-0.057308279,
0.0364579037,
-0.0117951715,
-0.0022620284,
0.0238527209,
-0.0014588623,
-0.1052080914,
0.0479127578,
-0.0243925117,
-0.023879556,
0.0264822841,
0.0533705428,
-0.0247390661,
-0.032159403,
-0.011119171,
-0.0057889838,
0.0266132336,
0.0226130541,
0.0769527704,
0.0092637939,
-0.0625637844,
0.0500002503,
0.0000870205,
-0.032815896,
0.0379302464,
0.0271505192,
0.0051477365,
-0.0340883881,
-0.0017634918,
0.0779179558,
0.0095192324,
0.0128961699,
-0.0420918018,
0.0378327258,
0.0009491884,
0.0269438904,
-0.013302044,
-0.0373149626,
-0.0499499701,
-0.0198323391,
-0.0004669254,
-0.0310737882,
0.00916766,
-0.0287545994,
0.0446824618,
-0.0144376634,
-0.0127431685,
0.0170540363,
0.0008462104,
0.015317169,
0.0185371488,
-0.0081895087,
-0.044498682,
-0.0251466855,
-0.0053558522,
0.063877508,
-0.0221627392,
-0.0314585902,
0.007702494,
0.0703969374,
-0.0011097416,
-0.0094796065,
0.0109541304,
0.0290793329,
-0.0504904054,
0.0406371951,
-0.0670188144,
0.0789997652,
-0.0308644902,
0.0405567512,
0.0169023164,
-0.0248490926,
-0.0280955043,
0.0401304923,
0.0411278345,
0.0044431128,
-0.0308336075,
0.0122812847,
-0.0337445289,
-0.0275890958,
0.0216212012,
0.0478015468,
-0.0192306675,
-0.0406295396,
0.0102615161,
-0.0360692181,
0.018133752,
-0.0004729376,
2.725e-7,
0.0552497767,
0.0222676694,
0.0366274789,
0.0019292763,
0.0001095344,
-0.0058499081,
0.0123228515,
0.0110745914,
0.0129792085,
0.0213178657,
0.0005912446,
0.0235751066,
0.051488746,
0.0262219682,
-0.0651418567,
-0.0040097525,
-0.0309745893,
0.0062175263,
-0.0397956371,
-0.0097127389,
0.0930238739,
0.1051804647,
-0.0707847998,
-0.0047309478,
-0.0275784563,
-0.0269756038,
0.0726036802,
-0.0042901421,
-0.0411522612,
0.0673236921,
0.081232585,
-0.0321877226,
0.0308041442,
-0.0012856936,
-0.0214536507,
-0.0178066399,
0.0263021588,
0.0756396875,
0.0307020005,
-0.0208103284,
0.0357462242,
-0.0084941145,
-0.004025341,
-0.072294116,
0.0570721179,
-0.0177817065,
-0.0100970035,
0.0034581781,
-0.0264147371,
0.0107459985,
0.0165308286,
-0.0401108079,
-0.007120789,
0.0423938185,
0.0149909016,
-0.0242969021,
-0.0219386257,
-0.0076100957,
0.0036291014,
0.0049767694,
-0.0186489671,
-0.0022351102,
0.0102523994,
-0.0160213187,
0.0030015518,
-0.0213410668,
-0.0227207411,
2.045146653e-34,
0.0455226749,
0.0079605523,
0.0216972884,
0.0064537558,
0.047100883,
0.015692547,
0.0132207079,
0.0195357129,
-0.0116912592,
0.0123723298,
-0.0139489481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14975v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14975v2 | Just Ask for Calibration: Strategies for Eliciting Calibrated Confidence Scores from Language Models Fine-Tuned with Human Feedback | 2023-05-24T10:12:33 | 2023-10-24T04:27:42 | Katherine Tian, Eric Mitchell, Allan Zhou, Archit Sharma, Rafael Rafailov, Huaxiu Yao, Chelsea Finn, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL | A trustworthy real-world prediction system should produce well-calibrated
confidence scores; that is, its confidence in an answer should be indicative of
the likelihood that the answer is correct, enabling deferral to an expert in
cases of low-confidence predictions. Recent studies have shown that
unsupervised pre-training produces large language models (LMs) whose
conditional probabilities are remarkably well-calibrated. However, the most
widely-used LMs are fine-tuned with reinforcement learning from human feedback
(RLHF-LMs), and some studies have suggested that RLHF-LMs produce conditional
probabilities that are very poorly calibrated. In light of this perceived
weakness, we conduct a broad evaluation of methods for extracting confidence
scores from RLHF-LMs. For RLHF-LMs such as ChatGPT, GPT-4, and Claude, we find
that verbalized confidences emitted as output tokens are typically
better-calibrated than the model's conditional probabilities on the TriviaQA,
SciQ, and TruthfulQA benchmarks, often reducing the expected calibration error
by a relative 50%. | [
0.0544514954,
0.0975440219,
-0.0129301008,
0.0236366428,
-0.0358044244,
-0.0069281422,
-0.0277278405,
-0.0131613631,
-0.0091752615,
-0.0422487073,
-0.0735932663,
-0.043654222,
0.0078214183,
0.0206175894,
0.0258804094,
-0.0293221474,
0.0268974397,
-0.052673053,
0.041376844,
-0.0079119941,
0.0027621328,
0.0027775553,
-0.0264248829,
0.0413934886,
-0.0089343581,
0.0030673037,
0.0006367845,
-0.0006526039,
0.0149253113,
-0.0170973521,
0.0444019139,
0.0941594914,
0.0137412408,
0.049252335,
0.0000017992,
-0.0405353308,
0.0179309733,
-0.0286664516,
-0.0139640234,
0.0100802537,
0.0137790712,
0.0105648525,
0.0066859177,
0.0469335467,
-0.0551775657,
-0.0144773591,
0.0273257736,
-0.0095009226,
0.0352085419,
0.0709543005,
0.0213997159,
0.0183962658,
0.0173304025,
-0.0055758753,
0.0290553272,
-0.0529387221,
0.0029755556,
0.0209524427,
-0.0215819422,
0.0030096234,
-0.0062451498,
0.0307915881,
0.0311605781,
-0.0375195518,
-0.0181734469,
0.0404056124,
-0.0276308209,
-0.0282449406,
-0.0316881724,
0.0506304167,
0.0125774797,
-0.0494616218,
-0.0390144475,
-0.0286855828,
-0.0017279022,
-0.0050918809,
-0.0225586332,
0.0190819558,
0.0134604611,
0.0259623844,
-0.0204620492,
0.0250886921,
0.0341759548,
0.0075324527,
0.027730139,
0.0862649083,
0.0065126675,
-0.0239610542,
0.016688263,
0.039078515,
-0.0132730175,
-0.0406011418,
0.0015280148,
0.0211539902,
-0.0603658855,
0.0254613068,
-0.0468823873,
0.0211417638,
0.0272734445,
-0.0018029049,
0.0270795897,
0.0516421087,
-0.0095127188,
0.0316681601,
-0.0095471321,
0.0437050126,
0.012520493,
0.0250940453,
-0.0185515787,
0.0065211104,
-0.0301146396,
0.003079325,
-0.0261755046,
-0.0058579198,
-0.007004444,
0.0049391445,
-0.0881856158,
-0.0045005889,
-0.004837289,
0.0377908833,
0.0116324723,
0.0381748565,
-0.0368432328,
-0.0280574709,
-0.0540416092,
0.0319598205,
-0.0119760372,
0.0281903148,
0.0317610614,
-0.0836212337,
-0.0001643592,
0.0024127464,
-0.0143687725,
-0.0199559517,
0.0159064606,
0.0733131245,
0.0031124786,
-0.037510477,
0.0138457157,
-0.0310907364,
-0.0292710066,
-0.0871659443,
-0.0138683869,
-0.0500897653,
-0.0052048783,
0.0035380833,
0.0045319311,
-0.0051177787,
0.0185741,
0.0165100824,
-0.0032951557,
0.0872536451,
-0.0104937935,
0.0014165227,
-0.0062833121,
-0.0114072515,
-0.0302586332,
0.0810871273,
0.0580974594,
0.0269564819,
0.0461917408,
0.0024015852,
0.0525652766,
0.0175953526,
0.0252834018,
0.0123463674,
-0.0061833621,
0.0191609506,
0.0048878654,
0.032611642,
0.036172729,
0.0580918454,
-0.0253717396,
0.0094995098,
0.1066813767,
0.0346261673,
-0.0245435052,
-0.0333925486,
0.0373779498,
-0.0065188617,
0.0362906195,
0.0078586396,
-0.0792735815,
0.0078880116,
-0.0583895557,
0.0161342099,
0.0511183664,
-0.0140310004,
-0.0034108821,
-0.0601713955,
-0.0055852737,
-0.0169409402,
0.006550957,
0.0463180728,
0.0477977097,
-0.0065153493,
-0.0324966833,
-0.0094505996,
0.02690126,
-0.0378824323,
0.044315245,
-0.0576815307,
0.0448425673,
0.0342104398,
0.022957338,
-0.000790904,
-0.007605528,
-0.0044676983,
-0.0206828192,
0.0400797352,
0.0689229816,
-0.0072772852,
0.0081560817,
-0.0280072931,
-0.016939586,
0.0120007442,
0.0219525024,
0.0179820787,
0.0693120211,
0.0135028847,
0.0034313502,
-0.0309325904,
-0.0165581666,
0.0185804199,
0.0128275799,
-0.0337048471,
0.0139536448,
-0.0132941017,
0.0322595425,
-0.0103737731,
-0.0067003616,
0.0374102332,
0.019736506,
0.0254366212,
-0.0270312782,
-0.0185081381,
-0.0559986047,
-0.0284929015,
0.0480554663,
-0.0002090411,
-0.0224433951,
0.0256910808,
-0.0289802831,
-0.0230880212,
-0.0232308544,
-0.0140586859,
0.0249353778,
-0.0527417436,
0.0127868121,
-0.019611273,
-0.0188963022,
-0.0493115,
0.0171132833,
0.0010416132,
0.018057175,
-0.0138375303,
-0.0033685102,
0.0053244946,
-0.0360351615,
-0.0378735214,
-0.0150261316,
0.0030334971,
0.0329451971,
0.063655369,
0.0251377895,
-0.0600903109,
0.0015190056,
-0.0711078122,
-0.004847202,
-0.0235651974,
0.0186974742,
0.009838446,
-0.0169574283,
-0.0162063185,
-0.0420304611,
-0.0490739122,
-0.0138933873,
0.0253576487,
0.0229016785,
0.0334090777,
-0.0020220459,
0.0203300603,
-0.0860332474,
-0.0150617082,
-0.0202060901,
0.022995336,
0.0353029892,
0.0479933247,
-0.0580421649,
0.0290595964,
-0.018183386,
0.0271254629,
0.0027385245,
-0.053591501,
0.0247408804,
-0.0191177875,
-0.0174488947,
0.0570983216,
0.0088435011,
-0.0236344114,
0.0542147793,
0.0193572324,
-0.0630184337,
0.0104734944,
-0.0514299423,
-0.1022486612,
-0.0534124486,
-0.0166050084,
0.0084835887,
0.0559974946,
0.0225659404,
0.001245748,
-0.0837782994,
0.0154179325,
-0.0059008505,
-0.0406789742,
-0.0318912268,
0.0006620142,
-0.0305939764,
0.0752950832,
-0.0078069875,
-0.0841712728,
0.0995752737,
-0.0480269119,
0.0091699399,
-0.0291483458,
-0.0024955689,
-0.00966716,
0.0219127145,
0.0159561802,
-0.0153000737,
0.0163206309,
-0.0074932319,
-0.0612807721,
-0.0380933993,
0.0285889134,
-0.0597870462,
-0.0040134089,
-0.0414442569,
-0.0058840602,
0.0235386044,
-0.0411894768,
-0.0618644059,
-0.0358836539,
-0.0787263438,
-0.0107370261,
0.0281143934,
-0.046970576,
-0.003783162,
-0.001887117,
0.0148133738,
0.0269351527,
-0.0350879356,
-0.0211010482,
-0.0013667118,
0.0185986869,
0.0884176344,
-0.0120384358,
0.0374738872,
-0.0413042344,
-0.0146190999,
0.0550871789,
0.0456446074,
0.050336156,
-0.0191200245,
-0.0088878646,
0.0427764207,
-0.0021111504,
0.00608357,
0.0601613671,
0.0593882538,
-0.0244436469,
-0.044390846,
0.1381427646,
0.0244472884,
-0.0471705236,
-0.011608691,
0.0098942099,
0.0408258997,
0.0242336057,
0.0243386477,
-0.0874999836,
-0.0355463922,
0.0073481668,
0.042333927,
-0.0025184897,
-0.0231805295,
0.018525064,
-0.1397057623,
0.0119406721,
-0.0079952981,
-0.0349270552,
-0.0329292864,
-0.0455669351,
0.0246525034,
-0.0302532986,
0.0179736037,
0.0068216911,
0.0058235675,
0.0355550349,
0.0267694406,
-0.0489124879,
-0.047731474,
0.0415648855,
-0.0505845137,
0.064703308,
0.0814008936,
0.0096960887,
-0.0038471736,
-0.0274999831,
-0.0043958654,
-0.0046806103,
-0.0181509554,
0.0095560029,
0.0366589539,
-0.034778513,
-0.0062503275,
-0.0153959226,
0.0394379906,
-0.0227057226,
-0.0071469164,
0.0179255251,
0.0474883243,
-0.0007749667,
-0.0228339825,
-0.0115599046,
0.0334414095,
0.0306778252,
0.0725049004,
0.0335188657,
-0.0575653426,
-0.0206218176,
-0.0219882336,
0.0012587776,
-0.029524589,
-0.038651932,
0.0213820133,
0.0281832479,
0.0135661475,
-0.0410403162,
-0.0318072028,
0.041967731,
0.0079413941,
-0.0091443211,
-0.0194204897,
0.0225649476,
0.0280592851,
-0.0135603286,
0.0195240919,
-0.0536038578,
0.0284606386,
-0.0700137168,
0.0274821352,
0.0178976841,
-0.0229012631,
-0.0122206379,
0.0045077116,
-0.0962678939,
-0.0844573155,
-0.024493603,
0.0755831599,
0.0215876214,
0.0321238264,
-0.0219975878,
-0.0437965952,
0.0564790256,
0.0203680862,
-0.0452717394,
-0.0094407462,
0.0304408111,
0.0335445404,
-0.0047142524,
0.0362961404,
-0.0291472208,
-0.0209087897,
0.0337857828,
0.0608415566,
-0.0059463531,
-0.0876597092,
0.0346605219,
-0.010419121,
0.1087000594,
-0.0359032005,
-0.0051632794,
-0.0114480695,
0.0040933616,
-0.0299149957,
-0.0257116295,
-0.0183784533,
-0.0256987195,
0.0504765213,
-0.027700942,
-0.0237548929,
-0.0515841767,
-0.0351488218,
0.0519297458,
-0.0237711594,
-0.0147562707,
0.0581021979,
0.0221793186,
0.04513482,
-0.0259624887,
-0.0155176381,
-0.001283726,
-0.0017351238,
0.0567746982,
0.0337545983,
0.0477555767,
0.027591465,
-0.0387609974,
0.0102752345,
-0.0284920186,
-0.0836375728,
-0.0349453315,
-0.0370877981,
0.0609747916,
0.0517155752,
0.0069951727,
0.0127365598,
-0.0371644311,
-0.0088716177,
-0.0108590387,
0.0160248335,
-0.0032811554,
0.0069567058,
0.0482110679,
-0.0067122923,
-0.0302853938,
0.014743478,
0.0539060831,
0.0135769378,
0.0531668216,
0.0009415947,
-0.037163455,
-0.0073555633,
-0.0045282166,
-0.0049013868,
0.0251882505,
-0.0406839475,
0.0210472029,
-0.0374837816,
-0.0724054575,
0.0132780811,
0.0782245323,
-0.0247419141,
-0.0119460039,
0.0165210161,
0.0548082218,
-0.0205981825,
-0.0280980393,
-0.0609329231,
0.0086462116,
-0.0176344179,
0.0012030337,
-0.0341823027,
-6.414008518e-33,
-0.0228252243,
-0.0376127437,
-0.0029084629,
0.0148330638,
0.0015779672,
-0.0085297804,
-0.022745857,
0.0239401553,
-0.0011264061,
0.0272235367,
-0.0333057456,
-0.0021507996,
0.0249998737,
0.0322392732,
0.0360684544,
-0.0244868919,
0.0221593622,
-0.0265917238,
-0.0543957502,
-0.0059396792,
-0.0127306264,
0.0213799123,
0.075606823,
-0.0863381252,
0.0694554374,
-0.0137019297,
-0.0281369966,
0.0660930872,
-0.0355028324,
0.047294762,
-0.0152954645,
0.0313258059,
-0.0195922535,
-0.0018896514,
0.005756624,
0.0093335565,
-0.0559302531,
-0.0325847417,
0.0264824573,
0.0234689992,
-0.0590576939,
0.0253976099,
-0.005359279,
-0.0233497601,
-0.0276758596,
0.0048886896,
0.0152674373,
-0.0179819483,
-0.0141168879,
-0.0262744352,
-0.0200113151,
0.0022656391,
0.0062849415,
-0.0146163926,
-0.0154080549,
0.0614560656,
-0.0036656365,
-0.0117360326,
-0.0421282575,
0.0253322627,
0.0204585567,
0.0237924736,
0.0623342618,
0.0367287993,
0.0102191167,
0.0476705171,
0.04263331,
-0.0002420015,
0.0011038632,
-0.0219924115,
0.0314355381,
-0.013678777,
0.0479690954,
0.080813475,
0.0096005816,
0.0233705398,
-0.0484322123,
0.0206281226,
0.0107839592,
0.019914411,
0.04986104,
0.0101137962,
-0.0778209269,
-0.0338768065,
-0.0768451244,
-0.0268501081,
-0.0190975294,
-0.035547372,
0.0206064209,
0.023019325,
-0.0071583856,
-0.0154139791,
0.0059417728,
-0.0300351717,
-0.0372956246,
-0.0034475578,
0.0046503632,
-0.0020949719,
-0.0343780182,
0.0557705574,
-0.0352458656,
0.0064884857,
0.0155521566,
-0.0189516582,
-0.009059743,
0.0039786063,
0.0317090824,
0.0280020554,
-0.0643661916,
0.010371401,
-0.0216550492,
0.0223118979,
0.0248806849,
0.0064721797,
0.0292509105,
-0.0106913345,
-0.0247256067,
0.0232997034,
-0.0270015672,
0.0004408408,
-0.0205445103,
-0.027713364,
0.002747495,
0.0072177965,
-0.0375157818,
-0.0092825908,
-0.0363103934,
-0.0051679132,
0.0028876816,
-0.0269675571,
-0.0075208833,
0.0094111431,
2.572e-7,
0.0487095267,
0.0405249633,
0.0047151227,
0.0304187238,
-0.0147064198,
0.0614990853,
-0.0250178911,
0.0150946639,
0.0655660033,
-0.0257689729,
0.0098178871,
0.0241020527,
0.0549634732,
0.0427488163,
-0.0566599108,
-0.0394904353,
-0.0754248127,
0.0015688118,
0.0073006661,
-0.030490553,
0.0471220911,
0.0799622163,
0.0420565791,
-0.0144957956,
0.0104807466,
-0.0223720726,
0.0551396459,
-0.0448227786,
-0.0398007855,
0.0291503407,
0.051591672,
0.0161368251,
0.0092119174,
0.0209629294,
-0.0012760466,
-0.0071985619,
-0.0233666617,
0.0543526039,
0.0064371526,
-0.0267863628,
-0.0480870865,
0.0107369339,
0.0334909074,
-0.0518360585,
0.0534353107,
-0.0593417324,
0.0011832849,
-0.0548361279,
0.0154743195,
-0.0703740418,
0.050061848,
-0.0377770588,
-0.0364354849,
0.0161067992,
0.01606033,
0.0548177809,
-0.032613188,
-0.0665590689,
-0.0456906334,
0.0040360815,
-0.0199777056,
-0.047609482,
-0.0133102275,
-0.0082865357,
-0.012674788,
-0.0808735117,
0.0370559469,
2.164971312e-34,
0.0468301028,
0.0055845305,
0.0172513016,
-0.0099646226,
0.0586369894,
0.0329171754,
0.0313859954,
0.0047557792,
0.0733302906,
-0.0652368441,
-0.0322029218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14973v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14973v2 | OverPrompt: Enhancing ChatGPT through Efficient In-Context Learning | 2023-05-24T10:08:04 | 2023-12-14T16:17:20 | Jiazheng Li, Runcong Zhao, Yongxin Yang, Yulan He, Lin Gui | cs.CL | cs.CL | The remarkable performance of pre-trained large language models has
revolutionised various natural language processing applications. Due to huge
parametersizes and extensive running costs, companies or organisations tend to
transfer the models to the target task by zero-shot prompting techniques.
However, the prohibitive costs of tokens and time have hindered their adoption
in applications. We propose OverPrompt, leveraging the in-context learning
capability of LLMs to handle multiple task inputs, thereby reducing token and
time costs. This approach could potentially improve task performance during API
queries due to better conditional distribution mapping. Evaluated across
diverse classification datasets, our experiments show that OverPrompt can
achieve cost-efficient zero-shot classification without causing significant
detriment to task performance, and in some cases, even improving it. An
ablation study conducted on various LLMs, along with an investigation into the
robustness of our prompting strategy to different input ordering, offers
valuable insights into the broader applicability of our method across diverse
tasks. These findings also suggest a more seamless integration of our method
with LLMs through an API. | [
0.0157977063,
0.0269642752,
-0.002051177,
0.0229692813,
-0.0653910935,
0.0080854679,
0.0032303047,
0.0150048202,
0.02963534,
-0.1059958339,
-0.0271842591,
-0.0204505473,
-0.0165733304,
0.0253890827,
-0.0210980084,
-0.0041917046,
0.0395038724,
0.0055704797,
0.0189828072,
0.0219725743,
-0.0197534449,
0.0134210419,
-0.014190075,
0.0476650521,
-0.0043719946,
-0.0326614976,
-0.0043583205,
0.0191352479,
-0.0249991007,
-0.0303616188,
0.0093839755,
0.0658231378,
0.0157864839,
0.0379955396,
0.000001939,
-0.0633646697,
-0.0262872037,
0.0182891637,
-0.0672657266,
-0.0105976136,
0.0584013648,
0.0267883129,
0.0161862671,
0.057363987,
-0.0608613491,
-0.022833582,
0.0511770956,
0.0364042148,
0.0271975417,
0.0915287063,
-0.0229252428,
0.0089136241,
0.0037595429,
0.0021349308,
0.0165780894,
-0.0520064086,
0.0023836037,
-0.0619891509,
0.0221048892,
0.0215471424,
0.0077166134,
0.0144631071,
0.0108107422,
0.0212064385,
-0.0065139197,
0.031863559,
-0.0966320634,
-0.0352960117,
-0.0509380512,
0.0518349186,
-0.0461535938,
-0.024862973,
0.0069845254,
-0.0189093053,
-0.0183143411,
-0.0097848242,
-0.0347874574,
-0.0092141768,
0.0090956017,
0.0344938487,
-0.020263942,
0.0317060314,
0.0120839281,
0.0219193455,
-0.0156330336,
0.047238715,
-0.0032636025,
-0.0003022639,
0.011220864,
0.030882623,
-0.0436550528,
-0.063611418,
-0.0151154259,
0.0292984247,
-0.0481498614,
-0.0088628661,
-0.0503570624,
-0.0244993102,
0.03291253,
-0.0272149891,
0.0315867737,
0.0557604581,
-0.0432996675,
0.0460090004,
-0.0213150606,
0.0043722745,
0.0212117825,
0.0246183965,
-0.0144810556,
-0.0144914333,
-0.0813396126,
-0.0141957477,
-0.0384874307,
0.0558086224,
-0.0255922172,
-0.0514872186,
-0.0629701465,
0.0381601267,
0.0221673846,
-0.0324934274,
0.0118337339,
0.0109054539,
-0.0261282809,
-0.002244699,
-0.0018841327,
0.0228349976,
0.009054848,
0.0268810466,
-0.0095365476,
-0.0670160428,
-0.0238559023,
0.0253168009,
0.0153550105,
0.0008104889,
0.0161574576,
0.0553773828,
-0.0020070961,
-0.0871782899,
-0.062955685,
-0.0252201296,
0.0220763665,
-0.0464214161,
-0.0301076863,
-0.060272824,
0.0136048933,
0.011811357,
-0.0141859269,
0.0088647734,
-0.0059958682,
0.037358962,
-0.0366071537,
0.0969887748,
-0.0079279104,
0.0063871969,
0.0058275447,
0.0062180734,
-0.0377123132,
0.1093538776,
-0.0023449347,
0.0181183107,
0.0470185168,
0.0109777907,
0.0424784049,
0.0433124453,
0.0060601318,
-0.0054091667,
0.0096466662,
0.0091498112,
0.0072592748,
0.0126588689,
0.0303862561,
0.0094296131,
-0.0128114531,
0.0240572095,
0.042850256,
0.0726892725,
0.0240480788,
-0.031012794,
0.0196302775,
0.0404846482,
-0.0357061327,
-0.0302430652,
-0.0717071891,
-0.0055989758,
-0.0369730443,
-0.0091652339,
0.041025091,
0.0248837303,
-0.0333246663,
-0.0217468292,
-0.0022476742,
-0.0199916642,
-0.0290276576,
0.0319477692,
0.0414023586,
-0.0069819097,
-0.0436591133,
0.0349309109,
0.0361171551,
-0.0148160299,
-0.031284634,
-0.0792933106,
-0.0141757578,
0.0363889709,
0.0438995808,
-0.0515767783,
-0.0274311714,
-0.0014111984,
0.0327752456,
0.043014925,
0.0046650162,
0.0061575039,
0.0461503379,
-0.0291887093,
-0.0324844569,
0.0466243625,
0.0307457671,
-0.0111704078,
0.0514498726,
0.0401140116,
0.0197741613,
-0.0608329065,
0.0129006486,
0.0258189179,
0.0170979183,
-0.0558333732,
0.0625386015,
0.0106012663,
0.0035430687,
0.0188684538,
0.0057081296,
0.0087444,
0.0291242264,
-0.0293242205,
-0.0133566549,
-0.0091905547,
-0.0383413658,
-0.0372647457,
0.0356469899,
0.017323507,
-0.0082003297,
0.0133180562,
-0.0468906425,
-0.0345437303,
-0.020572532,
0.002014155,
0.0903168991,
-0.0250110496,
0.0122415544,
0.0050855954,
0.0173814297,
-0.0431501456,
0.0305840112,
0.02639254,
0.0037983372,
-0.0198120251,
-0.010768584,
0.007005827,
-0.0136582255,
-0.0126696574,
0.027559828,
-0.0134435417,
0.0195790567,
-0.002450852,
0.02814053,
-0.0451336987,
0.0055724452,
-0.1410316229,
0.0420423336,
-0.0279360674,
0.0360974185,
0.0097046373,
0.0407677479,
-0.0362810493,
-0.0260438714,
-0.0319783874,
-0.0021224341,
0.0115456609,
0.0491754971,
0.0217959173,
-0.0171194263,
-0.0287805554,
-0.0033205973,
0.0044802697,
-0.0112518091,
0.0320258252,
-0.0089797219,
-0.0342216752,
-0.0237511098,
0.0128620677,
0.0115944259,
0.0197004117,
0.0086772144,
-0.0071308701,
-0.0076444517,
-0.0279296953,
0.0144214677,
0.0216678251,
-0.0190501288,
-0.0022621641,
0.0038241525,
0.0111749228,
-0.0765629783,
0.0032409092,
-0.0237754397,
-0.0386935771,
-0.0078855986,
0.0079388814,
0.0081568556,
0.0407639891,
-0.0232702829,
-0.03275102,
-0.054106947,
0.0109754652,
0.0066679087,
-0.0066838376,
-0.0484634526,
0.0400818549,
-0.0091275666,
0.0333086364,
0.0107407458,
-0.0671287179,
0.0421536565,
-0.0217343066,
-0.0089885974,
-0.053768713,
-0.0253579952,
-0.0316456296,
0.07997749,
-0.0062237103,
-0.004129597,
0.0303796176,
-0.0570805967,
-0.0244804136,
0.0011245349,
-0.0053744828,
-0.0186621491,
0.0333220772,
-0.0300584696,
0.038111683,
-0.0281493962,
-0.033374086,
-0.0312941447,
-0.0797998831,
-0.0292991791,
0.0205773264,
-0.0352092832,
-0.0099156527,
-0.0335714743,
0.0170331076,
-0.0531269424,
0.0602641813,
-0.0130124707,
-0.0304383766,
-0.0135011207,
0.0094848191,
0.0279906131,
0.0094659058,
-0.0207878817,
0.033749409,
0.0038422875,
0.0491050519,
0.0657837391,
-0.0076961382,
-0.0125807896,
-0.0012985453,
0.0526079126,
-0.0617227592,
-0.0239163768,
0.0393157303,
0.0159115214,
-0.0462978296,
0.001449838,
0.1159999296,
0.0483386666,
-0.0827845335,
-0.0030804495,
0.0124411415,
0.0307994392,
0.0259668194,
0.030226443,
-0.1147597358,
-0.0732574388,
0.0213881806,
0.0375907011,
-0.0208785757,
-0.0399513207,
-0.0405528285,
-0.1354812235,
0.0486673564,
-0.023067357,
-0.0233943835,
0.0106873186,
-0.0600275807,
0.0108118951,
-0.0099631511,
0.0011886882,
-0.02388243,
0.0016025981,
-0.0092394045,
0.0109203542,
-0.0026155272,
-0.0739833713,
0.0225580633,
-0.0551127456,
0.0344025493,
0.0389621593,
0.0183025748,
0.0224395655,
0.0169835724,
0.0577841289,
0.0107792392,
-0.0203512534,
-0.0459752679,
0.0531004146,
-0.0324372649,
0.0136326198,
0.013483041,
0.0195154808,
-0.0546287559,
-0.0246292446,
-0.0050527169,
0.0925034359,
-0.0383387581,
0.0223420784,
-0.0376000032,
-0.0340162851,
0.0516323037,
0.093438983,
0.0002217498,
-0.0334201194,
-0.0501783937,
-0.0094769029,
-0.0383330584,
0.0012223455,
-0.0199534278,
0.0147672445,
-0.0160199031,
-0.0600334741,
-0.0450349972,
-0.0031992656,
0.044315543,
0.0467076041,
-0.0009015272,
0.0363478847,
-0.0126443021,
0.0392413698,
-0.0464637391,
0.0260623097,
-0.0351352841,
0.0149154402,
-0.0737247765,
-0.0094106225,
0.0582792126,
-0.0071040541,
-0.0119811734,
0.012770352,
-0.0775657147,
-0.0825055316,
-0.0187716018,
0.030672688,
0.0323912874,
0.0367144942,
-0.0220421925,
-0.0440969355,
0.0643595308,
0.1174037457,
-0.026653083,
-0.0026222768,
0.0408267677,
0.0301940106,
-0.0069507742,
0.0339754634,
-0.0439900979,
0.0115949959,
-0.0016429547,
0.0261698272,
-0.0052182348,
-0.0107534528,
0.0040529529,
0.0240812041,
0.0783142373,
-0.0338949263,
-0.0156575851,
-0.0268856306,
0.0290194266,
-0.0227126256,
-0.0133504206,
-0.0468414873,
0.008622475,
-0.0043684086,
-0.0180306621,
-0.0300936475,
0.0029590349,
-0.0384476036,
0.0327900574,
-0.0274125226,
0.0108649964,
0.0132615538,
-0.0546145849,
0.0419151001,
-0.0200964715,
-0.0082509927,
-0.0025626731,
0.0222879332,
0.0190466531,
-0.0644027591,
0.0331932716,
0.0194648579,
0.0369819738,
-0.0314158574,
0.0499881282,
-0.0574928001,
-0.0528999008,
-0.0008073332,
0.0403457657,
0.0476752557,
-0.0464294553,
0.0263531376,
-0.0375464372,
-0.0007532669,
-0.0228975751,
0.0435515679,
-0.0028697485,
0.0149385268,
0.0200423412,
0.0102683743,
-0.0300969146,
0.0241613388,
0.113625139,
-0.0165370144,
0.0432420596,
0.0172798559,
-0.0427618176,
-0.0414809957,
-0.0273911525,
0.0662280098,
0.023465734,
0.0075728735,
0.025989417,
-0.0361961909,
-0.0295761321,
0.0035609321,
-0.0511516146,
-0.0185795743,
-0.0136217177,
0.0559197851,
0.0974578261,
0.0187214427,
-0.0206570923,
-0.0431029946,
-0.0272822678,
-0.0093895169,
-0.0334702954,
-0.0204602759,
-6.42298856e-33,
0.0015145752,
-0.0234465301,
0.0206287373,
-0.0069837705,
0.0128482059,
0.0160664655,
0.021388514,
0.0040797819,
0.0125569999,
-0.0225533973,
-0.0443762466,
0.0144210877,
0.0454395339,
0.0385682471,
-0.0029882339,
-0.0301507786,
0.0290929209,
-0.0113802478,
-0.0213800259,
0.0122057879,
0.0148988357,
0.0391301885,
0.0369548425,
-0.049841743,
0.0007027524,
0.0129350526,
0.0122102695,
0.0204162411,
0.0318214558,
0.0362932384,
-0.016065577,
0.072921522,
0.0303776897,
-0.0351332054,
-0.0033780674,
0.050422281,
-0.0566237792,
-0.0453262255,
0.011965639,
0.0082601225,
0.0215745009,
-0.0015850532,
0.0276573002,
-0.0026295292,
-0.0061038109,
-0.0187025461,
0.0176663641,
0.0015863434,
-0.0342042148,
-0.0472400412,
-0.0430063717,
0.0338484496,
0.0158176888,
-0.0326948836,
0.0412940867,
0.045327764,
-0.0076786419,
0.0297975186,
-0.0504290015,
-0.0038086278,
-0.0112562058,
0.0390198119,
0.0388723239,
0.0406159647,
0.0050005773,
0.0451677181,
-0.0117259976,
-0.0013193568,
-0.006272723,
-0.0051001022,
0.0390746556,
0.0212587044,
-0.0049232468,
0.0148363644,
0.0812817365,
-0.0053366185,
-0.0536314249,
0.0175049454,
0.0403116904,
-0.0291417446,
0.0299573056,
0.0146495681,
-0.0449186936,
-0.0434232764,
-0.0033671395,
-0.0170922559,
-0.0364484191,
-0.0209006146,
0.0358734541,
0.0232619513,
0.0172915496,
-0.0021257086,
0.0477524661,
-0.0332839452,
-0.0267875865,
-0.0053155506,
0.006924558,
0.0081632826,
-0.0066567142,
0.0031000818,
-0.0351939723,
-0.0233574305,
-0.0069583957,
0.0000053261,
0.0206156075,
-0.0079782186,
0.0326514542,
0.0334526896,
-0.0853646398,
-0.0115934536,
-0.0109839765,
0.0494741909,
0.0054170541,
0.0462436192,
0.0391837545,
0.0155749749,
0.0041219215,
0.05591207,
0.0185811259,
0.0128554143,
-0.0240925793,
0.0052675004,
-0.0160703138,
-0.0020743078,
-0.0277885105,
0.0200688001,
-0.0136141023,
0.0044235899,
0.0226438064,
-0.0620964803,
-0.0231943429,
-0.0101315835,
2.766e-7,
0.0476598516,
0.0535927042,
-0.0135675343,
0.0280446615,
-0.0123481648,
0.0504911989,
0.0121258833,
0.0191819873,
-0.005771012,
-0.0157816168,
0.0114891427,
0.0029436485,
0.0480358265,
0.032990288,
-0.1217375323,
-0.0310435724,
-0.0399224833,
0.0140967444,
-0.0692271963,
0.0109829353,
0.0820103064,
0.1094280034,
0.0128476573,
-0.0329843275,
0.0086994339,
-0.045717705,
0.022922067,
-0.0246823244,
0.0073551424,
0.0179346185,
0.03613903,
0.0176081769,
0.0292988531,
0.0320507362,
-0.0400053598,
0.0234052073,
-0.0069836979,
0.0606222786,
-0.0144007439,
-0.0362724885,
-0.010907352,
-0.0258381087,
0.0143884234,
-0.018440634,
0.1085733697,
-0.0772737116,
-0.0397490077,
-0.0238206591,
0.0218108054,
-0.0345870145,
0.0270049609,
-0.0048049092,
-0.0213916562,
0.0448108576,
0.0441373847,
-0.0338442661,
-0.0163063221,
-0.1042768285,
-0.0225795023,
0.0066852444,
-0.0286536124,
-0.0349503495,
-0.0266223475,
0.0054108435,
0.0318531021,
-0.0509383306,
0.0009822354,
3.064095691e-34,
0.0338802375,
0.0095862821,
0.0388155989,
0.0609544367,
0.0014300483,
0.0257702377,
0.0127043454,
0.0172807667,
0.0173720755,
-0.0652540103,
0.0015529889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16343v1 | A Distributed Automatic Domain-Specific Multi-Word Term Recognition Architecture using Spark Ecosystem | 2023-05-24T10:05:59 | 2023-05-24T10:05:59 | Ciprian-Octavian Truică, Neculai-Ovidiu Istrate, Elena-Simona Apostol | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic Term Recognition is used to extract domain-specific terms that
belong to a given domain. In order to be accurate, these corpus and
language-dependent methods require large volumes of textual data that need to
be processed to extract candidate terms that are afterward scored according to
a given metric. To improve text preprocessing and candidate terms extraction
and scoring, we propose a distributed Spark-based architecture to automatically
extract domain-specific terms. The main contributions are as follows: (1)
propose a novel distributed automatic domain-specific multi-word term
recognition architecture built on top of the Spark ecosystem; (2) perform an
in-depth analysis of our architecture in terms of accuracy and scalability; (3)
design an easy-to-integrate Python implementation that enables the use of Big
Data processing in fields such as Computational Linguistics and Natural
Language Processing. We prove empirically the feasibility of our architecture
by performing experiments on two real-world datasets. | [
0.0350429565,
-0.000668014,
-0.008462932,
0.048651129,
-0.0539362617,
-0.0035126046,
0.0386333391,
0.0092901839,
0.0056642727,
-0.0876300335,
-0.0243930221,
0.0259761345,
-0.0204906128,
0.0710734725,
-0.0232267436,
-0.0519125871,
0.0453766733,
-0.0166964736,
-0.0090946238,
0.0258023441,
0.0011394803,
0.0284970589,
0.0065972111,
-0.011112418,
-0.0141899409,
-0.0157348234,
0.0147298509,
-0.0678055957,
0.0264726933,
-0.0039513628,
0.0042476626,
0.0115372231,
0.0051563033,
0.0542601012,
0.0000017815,
-0.0352529399,
-0.0593876541,
-0.0155794425,
0.026671242,
-0.0173640549,
0.0942781866,
0.0062240711,
0.0224187635,
-0.0009129557,
-0.0454235487,
-0.0235005934,
0.0194590855,
0.0433954373,
0.0457111858,
0.0406087264,
-0.0289865378,
-0.1165614501,
-0.0118975695,
0.0210797768,
-0.0626311228,
-0.0384688526,
0.0268151611,
0.0041814195,
0.0620621964,
0.0185680054,
-0.0085788202,
0.0065567885,
-0.0389865227,
0.0125796543,
0.0299342461,
0.0314877257,
-0.0605491474,
-0.0420637354,
-0.045906499,
0.0338101313,
0.0241177361,
0.0039548194,
0.0285357535,
0.0049667396,
-0.0233375859,
0.0486523956,
0.0127199618,
0.0061028278,
-0.0244911313,
-0.0224336796,
0.0166209452,
-0.0132785896,
0.0093977675,
0.0233021975,
-0.0235622171,
0.109930791,
0.0345885009,
-0.0306101721,
-0.0276587177,
0.001926243,
-0.0441484712,
-0.0680844337,
0.0789271221,
0.0005122295,
-0.0311173182,
0.0192731041,
-0.0356674604,
-0.030903304,
0.0108667957,
-0.0448952541,
-0.0577331483,
-0.0382560045,
0.0171798244,
0.057964053,
0.0249581765,
-0.0407761671,
0.0196061116,
-0.0313382894,
0.005051442,
-0.0059470306,
-0.0517639853,
0.0091279624,
-0.0111526512,
0.0203710012,
-0.0276824925,
-0.0191286467,
-0.03776557,
0.0219594315,
-0.0085686306,
-0.036556799,
-0.0176990274,
-0.0093039097,
0.0340263136,
-0.0097216964,
-0.0085093323,
-0.0131565323,
-0.0660958812,
0.0115977637,
0.0246089417,
-0.0204804949,
0.0272695478,
0.0199345872,
0.0723676756,
-0.0061072316,
0.036268454,
0.0623502098,
0.037431933,
-0.0412364639,
-0.0332661495,
-0.0409722626,
0.0061135655,
-0.0149273733,
-0.0358870961,
-0.0628029555,
0.0054501994,
0.0208593495,
-0.0000589569,
0.0170888156,
0.004195197,
0.0013888775,
-0.0142147448,
0.0524660945,
-0.0690660551,
-0.0061586164,
0.0542540029,
-0.0010370429,
-0.0222318769,
0.0187166464,
-0.0150799444,
0.0432784706,
0.0956047103,
-0.0219193064,
0.0008282866,
0.0213589929,
-0.0024800037,
0.0042514582,
-0.0101340059,
0.0221619699,
0.0003115137,
0.0257381909,
0.0144454744,
0.0150074363,
0.0210831445,
0.0125010237,
0.0152826943,
0.1235911623,
-0.0078897784,
0.025728181,
0.0099436361,
0.0529567488,
-0.0044145384,
-0.0196660236,
0.0465801023,
-0.0452530049,
0.0115634119,
0.0113465432,
0.0330559239,
0.0594877899,
0.0175678357,
0.0153293405,
-0.0489081778,
0.0208003316,
-0.0366506912,
-0.0348742269,
0.086396277,
-0.0288392529,
-0.0104910703,
0.009514655,
0.0227551591,
-0.0130838854,
0.0043514352,
-0.0116025312,
-0.0100004431,
0.0366180874,
0.0721798614,
-0.0479741655,
0.0008897715,
-0.0126074804,
0.0673970282,
0.0447985195,
0.0163914282,
-0.0425388403,
-0.0556778796,
-0.032109946,
-0.0087640947,
0.0569319017,
-0.0073963269,
-0.0041966089,
0.0251556542,
0.0302965529,
-0.0086617684,
0.0126188667,
-0.0014957738,
0.0619768314,
0.0143966656,
-0.0385490432,
0.0097740619,
-0.0121432738,
0.0325698592,
-0.0044749603,
-0.0370755754,
0.0001068824,
0.03075606,
0.0087454701,
-0.0316840783,
0.0042472961,
0.0316700153,
0.0492627807,
0.0327621736,
0.0312721282,
-0.0358971618,
0.0074243704,
-0.0131672146,
-0.0134536242,
0.0150216501,
-0.0063617756,
-0.0225277189,
-0.0158579703,
0.0314252675,
-0.0260156877,
0.0591278002,
-0.0495504811,
0.0613716766,
0.0491279699,
0.040902283,
-0.0486986674,
-0.0440445393,
-0.0088261263,
0.0008584501,
0.0149320466,
-0.0066287122,
-0.0257792622,
0.0470667146,
0.0289431605,
-0.0483502299,
-0.0526720099,
0.0640980527,
-0.0192163605,
0.053483095,
0.0005346812,
0.0518262051,
-0.0037438867,
0.051706519,
-0.0272941459,
0.0134775741,
0.0076640444,
0.0140586412,
-0.0050540054,
0.033406876,
0.0348462686,
-0.0008028838,
-0.0312742703,
0.0344755948,
0.0010073982,
-0.0199910086,
0.0666752681,
0.0426179096,
-0.0481049083,
-0.0234931726,
0.048094403,
-0.0207812823,
0.025226796,
0.0306527615,
0.0384372137,
-0.036038857,
-0.0164720379,
0.0501476377,
-0.0174379498,
0.029953571,
-0.0301338732,
0.0049332767,
-0.042515479,
0.0031018879,
-0.0059802136,
-0.0430919789,
0.0431980081,
0.0323874652,
0.0538099483,
0.0648251474,
0.0266944133,
-0.0135614229,
-0.0158933699,
0.0218555368,
0.0200178195,
-0.0149413422,
-0.0345720612,
-0.0521294065,
0.0102307601,
-0.0130661484,
0.0083637582,
0.00770699,
-0.0441877879,
0.0442906395,
0.0240821596,
0.013347365,
-0.077049233,
-0.0123142097,
-0.0074433126,
0.056442257,
-0.0326661356,
0.000379216,
-0.0446044765,
-0.0340701677,
0.030667441,
0.0169189088,
0.0157495849,
-0.0345019139,
0.038114015,
-0.0139376419,
0.030871477,
-0.0211893562,
-0.0062753335,
0.0009338894,
-0.031337861,
-0.0441955291,
-0.0014224697,
0.0109189358,
-0.0055005788,
-0.036230959,
0.01496528,
-0.0066408725,
0.0345066302,
0.0098765278,
0.0008840447,
0.0255868938,
0.0071790987,
0.0000792651,
-0.0280886721,
0.0121510113,
0.0072396672,
0.0337265655,
0.0486415476,
0.0365980044,
-0.063998431,
0.0124195805,
-0.0196388438,
0.0263142399,
-0.1249824539,
0.0151500674,
-0.0200978275,
-0.0087080076,
-0.0595559143,
-0.0198163111,
0.0869476721,
0.0213572681,
-0.0522170551,
0.0009703842,
-0.0344080515,
-0.0318989009,
0.0143735064,
0.0468789749,
-0.1192993671,
-0.0584184788,
0.0072820731,
-0.0133434823,
-0.0275868624,
-0.0350843705,
-0.001016287,
-0.0859657601,
0.0324813165,
-0.0234338101,
-0.0055032037,
-0.0173554756,
-0.055817984,
-0.0013294808,
0.0120886536,
-0.0808943734,
-0.0164514948,
-0.0109792482,
0.015703734,
-0.0017688087,
0.0323950835,
-0.0570993423,
0.0508856736,
-0.0626440048,
-0.0309827831,
0.0506177396,
0.0241171159,
-0.0313042887,
-0.0325863287,
0.0318186544,
0.0496621542,
-0.0452449396,
-0.0478200652,
0.0071118879,
-0.0394527093,
-0.0148210926,
-0.0184821952,
-0.0108365761,
-0.0300984308,
-0.0290248264,
0.0395667329,
0.1116272062,
-0.003027726,
-0.0043958663,
-0.0081824157,
-0.0211134367,
0.0009356434,
0.0342799388,
-0.0269867815,
-0.0299809892,
-0.0287977979,
0.0217620805,
-0.0437331907,
-0.0263409968,
-0.0626863539,
-0.040062841,
-0.0451715849,
-0.0362789482,
-0.026005974,
-0.0066127814,
0.0518904962,
-0.0035212901,
0.0270361546,
0.0271612331,
-0.0271219816,
0.0489806794,
-0.1089443192,
-0.0082189636,
-0.0147166736,
0.0222576447,
-0.0488107428,
0.0059072967,
0.0600594766,
-0.0099362945,
-0.05399305,
0.053575024,
-0.0100516547,
-0.0309954453,
0.0422457419,
-0.0388035141,
0.0108936951,
-0.0084894476,
-0.0277419947,
-0.0303945784,
0.0627983063,
0.0865870267,
-0.0480252281,
-0.0166554376,
-0.00062431,
-0.0291544814,
-0.0147898756,
0.0280612204,
-0.0327543393,
0.0476386957,
-0.0223581214,
-0.0117341345,
0.0242200848,
0.003305855,
-0.0211664736,
0.0337436944,
0.0517110005,
0.0033864838,
-0.0060239001,
-0.0614017844,
-0.017796563,
0.0118835922,
-0.0482168272,
-0.0236079171,
0.0044705933,
-0.0203005224,
-0.0436537899,
-0.026361011,
0.0347608738,
0.0323215462,
-0.0448866338,
-0.0331631936,
0.0443037711,
0.0406457111,
0.0181119312,
0.0055099716,
-0.0213476401,
0.0241137128,
-0.0415919237,
0.0114650158,
0.0283220727,
-0.0545464009,
0.0082441736,
0.015453361,
-0.0204056576,
0.0033298368,
0.0218618773,
-0.0394621491,
0.0421716236,
-0.0120016998,
0.0454958454,
0.0272745881,
0.0010839597,
0.0072508063,
0.005578652,
-0.0466865748,
-0.0313051715,
-0.0060329102,
0.0027054192,
-0.0153035708,
-0.0288719293,
0.0175546035,
-0.0740423352,
0.0115062678,
0.0189374574,
-0.0448619723,
0.0049765147,
0.0468206443,
-0.0956026986,
-0.0264308956,
-0.0100054974,
-0.0373039059,
-0.0082275439,
-0.022844512,
0.0157084092,
-0.0498290993,
-0.0030764227,
0.0010510237,
0.0048514679,
-0.0002174135,
0.0056705149,
0.0307240933,
0.0758420378,
0.0399362817,
-0.0023046483,
-0.0578860417,
0.0782046914,
-0.0792057961,
-0.0334985331,
0.0146353273,
-5.622061444e-33,
-0.0202091876,
-0.0381343961,
0.0116560608,
0.0433426313,
0.0060243495,
0.0261708964,
-0.0027264855,
-0.0206096806,
0.015512255,
0.0313600637,
-0.0176688675,
0.0174575634,
0.0276031308,
-0.0042653447,
0.0264448244,
-0.0160172787,
0.0140024452,
-0.0150127523,
-0.0035177199,
0.0106669376,
0.0844528228,
0.0533295125,
0.0608786121,
-0.0244399421,
0.0304598473,
-0.0312259868,
-0.0063903793,
-0.0233724508,
0.0391058736,
0.0287608691,
-0.0410474688,
0.0454307906,
0.0124360202,
-0.0785442516,
0.0061766431,
0.0376538225,
-0.0470754243,
0.0159650464,
-0.0008808626,
0.0022879853,
-0.0104378248,
-0.0195871759,
0.0233887732,
0.0081940154,
-0.0323701985,
0.0168870352,
0.0255591962,
-0.0085371463,
-0.0287448168,
-0.0331853814,
-0.0819814131,
0.0719252303,
0.0209734458,
0.0091777053,
0.0638182163,
-0.0304535907,
0.026538305,
0.0694548115,
0.0013705539,
0.0347857513,
-0.0189659689,
0.0563930534,
0.0366062596,
0.0509317219,
0.0225085691,
0.0788370296,
0.01330839,
-0.0101853106,
0.0515671894,
0.0295766313,
-0.0353837162,
0.0362345353,
0.0006535779,
0.0445823371,
0.0059733,
-0.0419872887,
-0.0347064808,
0.0157598499,
0.0388191193,
-0.0344332755,
0.0002027098,
-0.0059924768,
-0.0060027987,
0.0096223373,
-0.0013355599,
0.0057189488,
-0.0382725298,
0.0131686572,
0.0187646076,
-0.009328587,
-0.0239139851,
0.1205667183,
-0.0047247009,
-0.0306038428,
-0.0245645363,
-0.014044595,
0.0073364279,
-0.0105146216,
0.0026911416,
-0.0101502854,
-0.0441680141,
-0.0160438754,
-0.0765795708,
0.0100055737,
0.0158188678,
-0.0275082886,
-0.0157753304,
-0.0308844224,
-0.0524254031,
0.007469113,
-0.0055665453,
-0.0030719473,
-0.0274190567,
0.0608353913,
0.0158433132,
0.0246266574,
0.0175001621,
0.0606213622,
0.0651122853,
-0.0171077829,
0.0085862,
0.00468439,
-0.0138756586,
-0.0085685654,
-0.0184571184,
-0.0112066409,
-0.009119235,
-0.029643191,
0.0284231212,
-0.0365200192,
0.0001755342,
-0.0230072048,
2.708e-7,
0.0159952082,
0.0656114519,
-0.0030057577,
-0.0217686947,
0.0065271994,
0.0531770848,
0.0223163776,
0.0577451624,
-0.0000567463,
0.0293692946,
-0.0307024773,
-0.0268364269,
0.021767674,
0.0322608277,
-0.1155509874,
-0.0515729822,
-0.0403247029,
0.010406645,
-0.0526227765,
-0.0039648497,
0.0217217524,
0.0696151778,
0.028541211,
-0.0098454719,
-0.0201982893,
-0.0646851286,
-0.018343566,
-0.0075432076,
-0.0392607376,
0.0521992706,
-0.0510376804,
0.0190964807,
-0.0188024472,
0.0248126984,
-0.041934371,
0.0640043318,
0.0234456416,
0.0496591143,
-0.0087048346,
0.075956732,
0.0038425142,
-0.0542692766,
0.0282108337,
0.0328194611,
0.0601394624,
-0.002845804,
-0.0595688894,
-0.063722007,
0.0004554926,
-0.0551767386,
-0.0096482402,
-0.0093893493,
-0.025325682,
0.0155321937,
-0.0164290834,
-0.0027547821,
-0.0489460565,
-0.0848761052,
0.037954405,
-0.0003533354,
-0.0216586553,
-0.026675446,
-0.0127966981,
0.034138754,
0.0499777943,
-0.0620399453,
0.0014082678,
2.268042882e-34,
0.0241537075,
0.0404946394,
-0.0587502569,
0.0663491637,
0.0010660761,
-0.0211764351,
-0.0032011108,
-0.0106590874,
-0.0090087261,
-0.0351292416,
0.0239103455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14970v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14970v2 | Getting Sick After Seeing a Doctor? Diagnosing and Mitigating Knowledge Conflicts in Event Temporal Reasoning | 2023-05-24T10:04:06 | 2024-04-08T14:59:53 | Tianqing Fang, Zhaowei Wang, Wenxuan Zhou, Hongming Zhang, Yangqiu Song, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Event temporal reasoning aims at identifying the temporal relations between
two or more events from narratives. However, knowledge conflicts arise when
there is a mismatch between the actual temporal relations of events in the
context and the prior knowledge or biases learned by the model. In this paper,
we propose to detect knowledge-conflict examples in event temporal reasoning
using bias indicators, which include event relation prior bias, tense bias,
narrative bias, and dependency bias. We define conflict examples as those where
event relations are opposite to biased or prior relations. To mitigate
event-related knowledge conflicts, we introduce a Counterfactual Data
Augmentation (CDA) based method that can be applied to both Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs) and Large Language Models (LLMs) either as additional
training data or demonstrations for In-Context Learning. Experiments suggest
both PLMs and LLMs suffer from knowledge conflicts in event temporal reasoning,
and CDA has the potential for reducing hallucination and improving model
performance. | [
0.0201508589,
0.0568156764,
-0.031509392,
0.0402688794,
-0.0590479486,
0.016044667,
-0.0028147984,
0.0177606046,
0.0493362658,
-0.0512166843,
0.0136500793,
-0.0347857773,
-0.0057071508,
0.0290823299,
-0.0162541531,
-0.0648734644,
0.0868960619,
0.0134436507,
0.031682156,
0.0170769151,
-0.0204801653,
0.0187231954,
-0.0514375642,
0.0074792048,
-0.0281711109,
-0.0436463989,
-0.0044045243,
-0.0147479642,
0.0615783632,
-0.0674551725,
0.0031513013,
0.0224873014,
0.0200676154,
0.0255955812,
0.0000019586,
-0.0313656293,
-0.003647035,
-0.0376480892,
-0.040685676,
-0.009157693,
-0.0056418939,
-0.0131095313,
0.0251167342,
-0.0195084307,
-0.0574310161,
-0.0411604345,
-0.0067896387,
0.1130887344,
0.0120950155,
0.0964614078,
-0.0225678664,
-0.0130760046,
-0.0071339267,
-0.0063682967,
0.0025970044,
-0.0284188502,
0.0268783923,
0.0212480612,
0.0242340006,
-0.0464644544,
0.0076725418,
0.028059883,
0.0108351279,
0.0413162187,
-0.0106120184,
0.0607459508,
-0.0256782603,
0.0312967375,
-0.000702643,
0.0440522358,
0.0181800611,
-0.057499975,
-0.0000184178,
-0.0233819783,
-0.0006581983,
-0.0004453658,
-0.0140476301,
-0.0312124658,
-0.0122188209,
0.02865058,
0.0356588401,
0.0304534025,
0.0452189036,
0.0115189422,
-0.015998058,
0.0891914219,
0.0032665269,
-0.0351286791,
-0.0311388094,
-0.0123428935,
0.0136942221,
-0.0442619808,
0.0324668959,
0.049491141,
-0.0343593955,
0.0182938147,
-0.0349474289,
0.0207712632,
-0.0016886179,
-0.1091811955,
-0.0411912389,
0.0247275997,
-0.0228135772,
0.0463910215,
-0.0076128026,
0.0130623579,
-0.0206255447,
0.0265869256,
-0.0307273082,
0.0449820422,
-0.0223854482,
0.0096834134,
-0.0361934379,
0.0027447867,
-0.021988295,
0.0053250245,
-0.0083729904,
0.0035565582,
-0.0184857976,
-0.000387909,
-0.0304747596,
0.0230084173,
-0.017035624,
-0.0343614109,
-0.0517846905,
0.0336887129,
-0.0285374317,
0.0413744934,
-0.0444962718,
-0.0279697049,
-0.0195582286,
-0.0122298812,
0.0128971897,
-0.041792836,
-0.0323478058,
0.0257654022,
-0.0166413952,
0.0117071318,
-0.1162461936,
-0.0323533267,
-0.012830629,
-0.0520424545,
-0.0330657959,
-0.0242015552,
0.0277403146,
-0.0184305105,
-0.0024964178,
-0.0225368049,
0.0173391011,
-0.0278667472,
-0.0507425144,
0.0487435833,
-0.0064549726,
0.0125471903,
0.0148934284,
0.0237974897,
0.0131030809,
0.0359782912,
0.0395882055,
-0.0534781702,
0.0052850144,
0.0183973275,
0.0043494026,
-0.0051064054,
0.0262356233,
-0.0318550803,
-0.0493864305,
-0.0069556455,
0.0203823708,
0.0384264477,
0.0139752179,
0.0135650085,
-0.0356457718,
-0.0193099044,
0.0480559729,
-0.0491988584,
-0.0187175795,
-0.0559738837,
0.0244837981,
-0.0411713459,
-0.0013919774,
0.0559104495,
-0.0482632257,
0.0015496882,
-0.0119380467,
-0.0116433967,
-0.0397927985,
0.0040911101,
-0.0341971666,
-0.0167072397,
-0.0076567256,
-0.0123048201,
0.0047922242,
0.0032160264,
0.0200634412,
0.0124285072,
-0.0513234474,
0.0556759201,
0.0147079835,
-0.0110826865,
0.0211811755,
-0.0129611017,
-0.0085135028,
0.0986090824,
0.0389235057,
-0.0471488051,
-0.0899529308,
-0.0214507114,
0.0131343389,
-0.0021165072,
0.0551418886,
-0.0244262703,
0.0168863777,
-0.0349504203,
0.0079178065,
0.0137847848,
0.0210868344,
-0.0118388245,
0.0021666279,
0.0418201052,
-0.002359716,
0.015029382,
-0.0054865754,
0.0364387222,
-0.0459618792,
-0.0506804325,
-0.0529183485,
0.008410153,
0.0123179825,
-0.001989465,
0.0200166013,
0.0029697502,
0.0450162292,
-0.0124932276,
-0.0027718723,
0.1239027083,
-0.0908373892,
-0.1053808555,
0.0213012695,
0.0223931707,
-0.0331354588,
-0.0063268342,
-0.0369688272,
-0.0270521156,
0.0171391591,
0.035358496,
0.1000305116,
-0.0107328016,
0.045956403,
0.0204254743,
-0.0190140624,
-0.0127668139,
0.0705999732,
-0.0298381466,
-0.0045937444,
-0.0338975899,
0.0203502998,
-0.0007691244,
-0.0309704393,
-0.0165707506,
0.0260315556,
0.0346618816,
-0.0444778688,
-0.0227338448,
-0.0667238235,
-0.0690871701,
0.0282427073,
-0.1035180986,
-0.0076704319,
-0.0113697033,
0.000383469,
0.0092819175,
-0.0193444509,
-0.0112550417,
-0.0250140484,
-0.010445388,
-0.0314613506,
-0.0074927732,
0.0231221337,
0.0024627345,
0.0537154861,
0.0245834384,
-0.0220836755,
0.009593877,
-0.0821040347,
0.0558340028,
0.001662646,
-0.0396917425,
-0.0430776589,
0.0198002961,
-0.0048015486,
0.0488515161,
-0.0284996927,
0.0152046541,
0.003799232,
0.0048778933,
0.0543947294,
0.05396837,
-0.0006863826,
0.0182212554,
0.0806522742,
-0.040868327,
-0.0390721522,
0.0371116437,
-0.0306743663,
0.0215544663,
-0.0410167053,
-0.0265719872,
-0.0455186404,
0.0634209812,
0.0078673977,
-0.009199759,
-0.0578379296,
-0.0301327202,
-0.0384855047,
-0.0261842199,
0.0214278921,
-0.0560142063,
-0.0495247059,
0.0097256638,
-0.0351558812,
0.0097403321,
0.0682951882,
0.0022946747,
0.0254727416,
-0.0278687552,
0.019009795,
-0.013548417,
0.0693891793,
0.0017308324,
0.0117731392,
-0.0068628443,
-0.0127347279,
-0.0360531658,
-0.0089327991,
0.0079523996,
-0.0329134874,
0.0062940735,
-0.0479895547,
-0.0092519037,
0.0267538745,
-0.0136515517,
-0.0839611813,
-0.0640270337,
-0.0135260643,
-0.0332525596,
-0.0606204756,
0.0304789674,
-0.0389265567,
0.0146772889,
-0.04444943,
0.0472030528,
0.0050748843,
-0.0086354828,
-0.004149585,
0.023819454,
0.0208300948,
0.0156988949,
0.0150042707,
-0.0010677718,
0.0108179487,
0.0321961865,
0.0869812369,
-0.0247997139,
-0.0254239198,
0.0172534529,
-0.0125189703,
-0.0260078255,
-0.0231259894,
0.0038508542,
-0.0005929713,
-0.0725960806,
0.0045635668,
0.1094897464,
0.0534654967,
-0.0223639794,
0.0316554904,
-0.0141150737,
-0.0063175107,
0.0213340688,
-0.0210286416,
-0.0809742138,
-0.0044117058,
0.0022431025,
-0.0465489365,
-0.0442652367,
-0.046291098,
-0.016183557,
-0.0880945474,
-0.0033586887,
0.0268348847,
0.0103125637,
-0.0215716623,
0.0074398727,
0.0131340483,
-0.0014813251,
0.0235255025,
0.0109774489,
0.0049372902,
-0.0168311968,
-0.0027898292,
-0.0332773924,
-0.083617501,
0.0252803937,
0.0039221453,
0.0613339692,
0.0151959173,
0.0541052781,
0.0159353092,
-0.0357595794,
0.035065826,
0.0236789193,
0.0199210774,
-0.0163801145,
0.0463784859,
-0.0304631162,
0.0093318233,
0.0098033566,
0.0213322956,
0.0258767195,
-0.0840823799,
0.001838762,
0.1169391647,
-0.034734264,
-0.0176365823,
0.0058728405,
0.01984662,
0.0471036546,
0.0768412277,
-0.0251770988,
0.0158827025,
-0.0291650519,
0.057995908,
0.0291311424,
-0.0161325242,
0.0286100302,
0.0204608198,
0.0174420532,
-0.0071468186,
-0.0598848984,
-0.0685631037,
0.0208397843,
0.0263956878,
0.0006010964,
0.0304900985,
-0.0013437797,
-0.0338759683,
-0.0564272776,
0.0586073771,
-0.0229367167,
0.0191838089,
0.0175719485,
-0.0158714447,
-0.0163595937,
0.017734671,
-0.0103339925,
0.0348328538,
-0.0563900024,
-0.0562605597,
0.0389145315,
-0.009715585,
0.0215639807,
0.1106427461,
-0.0188861843,
0.0013979594,
0.0026457082,
0.0042878934,
-0.0356210992,
0.0076279477,
0.0384365283,
0.0073365564,
0.0027759313,
0.0234553814,
-0.0186425243,
-0.0080826059,
-0.0094101587,
0.0471413955,
-0.0526690297,
-0.0002394689,
0.025409095,
-0.0339555517,
0.0623181649,
-0.0124774091,
0.0000645752,
-0.0601052009,
0.0368095376,
-0.0608388931,
-0.0086172419,
0.0122671071,
0.0087049352,
0.0233801249,
0.0246541165,
-0.0316098779,
-0.0134271029,
-0.0544004068,
-0.037168473,
-0.0101590352,
-0.0088283941,
0.0777118132,
0.0020206338,
0.0421735607,
-0.0049973885,
-0.0239953212,
0.0303980578,
0.0088423016,
0.0110000893,
-0.0139167812,
0.0604837015,
0.0491738133,
-0.005010515,
-0.0341565497,
-0.0391028039,
-0.0804339424,
0.0268531572,
-0.0022321173,
-0.0235549193,
0.0509932041,
-0.0795214847,
0.0424749441,
-0.0371964164,
0.0197866969,
0.0197471175,
0.0064898594,
0.0446703769,
-0.0113899671,
0.0277858824,
0.003491706,
-0.0240002032,
0.0661384612,
0.0675179288,
-0.0384208672,
0.1192628369,
-0.0091719022,
-0.0156478249,
-0.0103413807,
-0.0701904669,
0.0161810797,
0.0201188307,
-0.0545290597,
0.0014059833,
-0.1095480099,
-0.030899331,
0.0207173117,
-0.0144128324,
-0.0205898769,
-0.0329507254,
0.004088501,
0.0247454531,
0.0287663583,
-0.0387110263,
0.0061832536,
0.0251427256,
0.0510569327,
-0.0047047916,
-0.0474799424,
-6.328257675e-33,
-0.0216005594,
-0.0205825865,
0.0216216203,
-0.0406799167,
-0.0290583223,
0.0092518153,
-0.0306789447,
-0.0130232787,
-0.0180562157,
0.0310186073,
0.0062797293,
0.0419105887,
0.0269612595,
-0.0108971409,
-0.0051778643,
-0.0170348547,
0.0562113374,
0.0205510817,
-0.0082100797,
0.0099440245,
0.0277441312,
0.0382197388,
0.0463281609,
-0.0773048103,
0.0330479853,
-0.0075198254,
0.0048718988,
0.0353463329,
-0.0051552923,
0.017568795,
-0.0197592322,
0.0096499762,
0.0388302356,
-0.0164364167,
0.0010851889,
-0.0128594022,
-0.063641198,
-0.0421599559,
0.0634425953,
0.0235928036,
-0.0133201648,
-0.0366718359,
0.0002384848,
-0.0060469704,
0.0009683506,
0.003982686,
0.0164735988,
-0.0315341465,
0.0253883153,
-0.006206593,
-0.0695516989,
0.0268688165,
-0.001295849,
0.0153459562,
0.017014103,
0.020965457,
0.0195933525,
-0.0214895736,
-0.051002644,
0.002633475,
-0.0008849226,
-0.0117873279,
0.0215949323,
0.0250660013,
-0.0240007695,
0.0662228912,
0.0121620251,
0.026077114,
-0.0638008192,
0.0587981082,
0.0226270929,
0.020343326,
0.0216116775,
0.0612936728,
0.0328926519,
-0.0212507211,
-0.0396658257,
0.0052448432,
-0.0135695506,
0.0144656673,
0.0302464925,
0.011733124,
-0.0332085192,
-0.0202012248,
-0.0206394736,
0.0089972932,
-0.0123862401,
0.0048667295,
0.0276879612,
0.009771999,
0.0481059141,
0.0496767126,
0.0135734109,
-0.0137101188,
-0.0177805535,
0.0422590263,
-0.0054400223,
-0.0104479576,
-0.0210180394,
0.0653403997,
-0.0344284065,
-0.0124838529,
0.050136935,
0.0029521482,
0.0525534786,
0.0054645636,
0.0479061194,
0.006334797,
-0.0263270866,
0.0026667423,
-0.0140876062,
-0.0109133413,
0.0097932573,
-0.0374651738,
0.0642374307,
0.0260802936,
-0.0159399007,
0.0187991392,
0.0201739073,
0.0049333326,
-0.0240352899,
-0.0064968979,
-0.0151014989,
0.0344031155,
-0.0056445571,
-0.0003175882,
-0.0008983791,
0.019941017,
0.0090773115,
-0.0474879332,
-0.0013302289,
0.0103067951,
2.69e-7,
0.0352558233,
0.0286472254,
0.0151795289,
0.0084293615,
0.0060479082,
0.0124795269,
-0.0341032818,
0.0140137803,
0.0149935037,
0.0141060073,
0.0387054645,
0.0440666787,
0.0455102958,
0.0368317626,
-0.0029854844,
-0.0402019434,
-0.0537346564,
-0.0283869281,
-0.0639025569,
-0.037447717,
0.1146857142,
0.0469473675,
0.0663736016,
0.0084055187,
0.0149556492,
-0.0432338379,
0.0420506746,
-0.0068635973,
-0.0065554846,
0.0296430849,
-0.0004014517,
-0.0023642408,
-0.0146063017,
0.0620485768,
-0.0160355866,
-0.0077016144,
-0.0417365134,
0.0411931351,
-0.045191206,
-0.0184309464,
-0.0348044224,
-0.0085116569,
-0.0301395543,
-0.055506859,
0.0995308533,
-0.033777412,
-0.0235312972,
0.0135435937,
-0.020355843,
0.0102479625,
0.0037819049,
0.0258696899,
-0.0266149826,
0.0368405618,
0.0148542766,
0.0399317034,
-0.031881921,
-0.1168150678,
-0.0557301305,
0.0845018923,
-0.0108665647,
-0.0132528441,
0.0268807597,
-0.0193261281,
0.0310801454,
-0.074674882,
0.0115590664,
2.335732759e-34,
0.0161158442,
0.039962966,
-0.0062771211,
0.0317088328,
0.0335653089,
-0.0134987496,
0.0257800426,
0.0165673904,
0.0371843129,
-0.0346396565,
0.0018614032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14965v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14965v4 | Tricking LLMs into Disobedience: Formalizing, Analyzing, and Detecting Jailbreaks | 2023-05-24T09:57:37 | 2024-03-27T04:38:44 | Abhinav Rao, Sachin Vashistha, Atharva Naik, Somak Aditya, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent explorations with commercial Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown
that non-expert users can jailbreak LLMs by simply manipulating their prompts;
resulting in degenerate output behavior, privacy and security breaches,
offensive outputs, and violations of content regulator policies. Limited
studies have been conducted to formalize and analyze these attacks and their
mitigations. We bridge this gap by proposing a formalism and a taxonomy of
known (and possible) jailbreaks. We survey existing jailbreak methods and their
effectiveness on open-source and commercial LLMs (such as GPT-based models,
OPT, BLOOM, and FLAN-T5-XXL). We further discuss the challenges of jailbreak
detection in terms of their effectiveness against known attacks. For further
analysis, we release a dataset of model outputs across 3700 jailbreak prompts
over 4 tasks. | [
0.0441685803,
0.0525670797,
-0.0212226864,
0.0430222079,
-0.0356113128,
-0.0289536547,
0.0307006575,
-0.0009822273,
0.0697900802,
-0.0102551775,
0.0008157062,
0.0066808825,
0.0105580483,
0.0371159613,
0.0238254126,
0.0082355654,
0.0437924974,
-0.0377914608,
-0.0086152442,
0.0092027187,
0.0117025971,
0.0295839086,
0.0431632325,
0.0348139703,
0.0200040732,
-0.0323484764,
-0.0292894207,
0.023753278,
0.0093032848,
-0.0210171752,
-0.0346661918,
0.0435632505,
-0.0360066704,
0.0611634515,
0.0000021805,
-0.0337214954,
-0.0410172269,
0.0296218731,
-0.0459024832,
0.0881778821,
0.003525821,
-0.0320763588,
-0.045979742,
0.0215357915,
-0.0279347692,
0.0281363446,
0.0255742278,
0.0244355518,
0.083012335,
0.0313084871,
-0.0053494005,
0.0211374722,
0.0289917439,
0.0058837417,
0.0213042162,
-0.0137520786,
-0.0048177871,
-0.0488353372,
0.009694322,
0.0258233231,
0.0176339261,
-0.0079580666,
0.0433671735,
-0.0246550273,
-0.0623728782,
0.002244029,
-0.033538878,
-0.0355435684,
-0.0125367669,
0.0326918364,
-0.0346374288,
-0.0156381708,
0.0287748631,
-0.0049257507,
0.02604446,
0.0363619588,
0.0114728529,
0.0571473539,
-0.0151154604,
-0.0111161936,
0.0154886907,
-0.0383904427,
0.0445142463,
-0.0121214818,
-0.0188371353,
0.0399289951,
0.0275038294,
-0.0282776039,
-0.016168071,
-0.0375092626,
0.0159821212,
-0.069647029,
0.0104125012,
-0.0170220416,
0.0172770862,
0.0098844524,
-0.0593094304,
-0.0153108602,
0.0408169664,
-0.0252402015,
-0.052295953,
0.042314887,
-0.0309716351,
0.0050160442,
-0.0171594005,
0.0039732899,
-0.0352195948,
0.0375333317,
0.0444059484,
0.0341273546,
0.0129173165,
-0.0195896477,
-0.023374116,
0.0240309052,
-0.0201625898,
0.0239804536,
-0.0206423551,
0.0560326017,
0.0023419131,
0.0488150828,
-0.0215511825,
0.0006361398,
0.0122415135,
0.0148914484,
0.0456698537,
-0.0328481346,
-0.025612697,
-0.0382687077,
0.0045573954,
-0.0648201406,
-0.0061074165,
-0.0238382667,
-0.0693034604,
-0.009646588,
-0.0207542535,
0.0950795114,
0.0406535193,
0.0104795052,
-0.0833492652,
-0.1164649799,
-0.0310302768,
-0.0188214704,
-0.0264702141,
-0.0836412907,
-0.0243867915,
-0.0057222038,
0.0090126991,
-0.0474656187,
-0.0119053079,
-0.0185216516,
-0.0283964612,
0.0096851876,
-0.0223872978,
-0.0112356236,
-0.0163589176,
0.0612872951,
0.0548701584,
0.0391498283,
-0.0158321206,
0.062414784,
0.067843169,
-0.0328987576,
0.0692876503,
0.0465615653,
-0.0325224921,
0.0295078289,
0.0017012381,
-0.0154716289,
0.0581603572,
-0.0228242092,
-0.0311026648,
0.043735262,
0.0053306292,
-0.0242716949,
0.0835841149,
0.0688124821,
-0.05848727,
0.0197387524,
-0.0264965463,
-0.0237317625,
0.0077354647,
-0.0012183087,
-0.0401798077,
-0.0012910751,
-0.0715479478,
-0.0074193119,
-0.0265133791,
0.0399875045,
0.0112793874,
0.0299822204,
0.002699462,
-0.0319603458,
-0.0286529139,
0.0085831666,
-0.000683146,
-0.0041375365,
0.0264452212,
0.0607195869,
0.0159709789,
-0.0315305479,
-0.0408119783,
-0.0900608897,
0.0280807912,
0.082477212,
0.0447266735,
0.0181213766,
0.0340334289,
-0.0142846089,
-0.0174004138,
0.0077259638,
-0.0081846928,
0.00731058,
0.0063619157,
0.00547774,
0.0157059971,
-0.0093348809,
0.0356595777,
0.049224034,
-0.0202507805,
0.0056452043,
0.0090326089,
-0.0365612879,
-0.0209937394,
-0.0011663736,
-0.0017218846,
-0.0304644927,
0.0053655384,
0.0263647139,
-0.0296240877,
0.0217488632,
-0.0162430741,
0.0044576484,
0.0608398654,
0.0260613225,
0.0478309505,
-0.0002176918,
-0.0293571465,
0.0227134228,
0.0433633178,
-0.02927012,
-0.0063643167,
0.0616192669,
-0.0342167616,
-0.0158157926,
0.0695161894,
-0.0158225205,
0.0693730563,
0.0015567326,
0.0260386486,
-0.0043855994,
-0.0190866962,
-0.0099153388,
-0.0258346256,
-0.0209959019,
0.0097387172,
0.0099251857,
0.0118187545,
0.0125733316,
-0.0004050944,
-0.0823191032,
0.04085299,
-0.0404794812,
0.0182221737,
0.0022140848,
0.0219524577,
-0.0014147074,
-0.0302870162,
-0.0359816514,
-0.0141299237,
-0.0311923791,
0.0487905219,
0.065134868,
0.0524754785,
-0.0435767137,
-0.0171815511,
-0.0181386862,
-0.0628373176,
0.0235578455,
0.0169753805,
-0.0006898571,
-0.0201760363,
-0.0343855806,
-0.0064101568,
-0.0030379598,
-0.0072464868,
0.033500243,
-0.036666695,
-0.0231820028,
-0.0258500017,
-0.0187080987,
-0.0035896918,
-0.0212684609,
-0.0234687757,
-0.0293582398,
0.0362807438,
-0.0159208309,
-0.0085457815,
0.0519154146,
0.0111203017,
0.0499627255,
0.0634118766,
0.005281148,
-0.037833035,
-0.0489431918,
0.0736115053,
-0.0720721185,
-0.0321170427,
-0.0781521201,
0.0460490063,
0.0342873484,
0.024685543,
0.0106224362,
-0.027918078,
0.0207326375,
-0.0135558248,
-0.014665395,
0.0153771704,
-0.0019377971,
-0.0649190471,
0.0060102064,
-0.0015018473,
-0.0827106535,
0.0376450345,
-0.0630029887,
-0.0015314633,
0.0102498578,
-0.0499444902,
-0.018472394,
0.0632939786,
-0.0330193825,
0.0254763793,
0.0678570718,
-0.0503304191,
-0.0097423121,
0.0099083316,
0.0324111618,
-0.0132285673,
0.0434272029,
-0.0540696122,
-0.032134179,
-0.0229460578,
-0.0195245594,
-0.0023025011,
-0.0690759569,
-0.0192226712,
-0.0559951179,
0.0578972474,
-0.0336198062,
0.0445775315,
-0.0240845252,
0.0186526552,
0.0194240324,
0.0021441353,
-0.0150667327,
-0.0235831272,
0.0125183035,
-0.0064627971,
-0.0694124252,
-0.0220452063,
-0.0292664021,
0.0009932083,
0.0748059377,
0.0528669395,
-0.0222496036,
0.0070921364,
0.0036134017,
0.0280112755,
0.0026101137,
-0.0062113698,
0.0588092506,
0.044217702,
-0.0315574631,
-0.0184928123,
0.0512935929,
0.0311644282,
-0.0294674635,
0.0167108458,
0.0050362442,
0.0558312833,
0.0184412692,
0.0330130123,
-0.1052362621,
-0.0143926926,
0.0091291554,
0.0911822766,
-0.0278056022,
-0.0195573252,
-0.020937752,
-0.0785490349,
0.0074031651,
0.0488453321,
-0.0025988875,
0.0304834116,
-0.0295458063,
-0.0278256815,
0.016599454,
0.0054500182,
-0.047826767,
-0.0267420653,
0.024086969,
0.0180697106,
-0.0646428466,
-0.0108932536,
0.0172446873,
-0.017452348,
0.069691591,
0.0927609578,
-0.0489555001,
-0.0303914007,
0.0195252858,
0.0484334528,
0.0162567236,
-0.0329151489,
0.0103385877,
-0.0226696022,
0.02799052,
0.006886832,
0.0045295032,
0.0286003537,
-0.0089754965,
-0.0450904593,
0.0228876043,
0.0546055064,
-0.0054312767,
-0.0500546247,
0.0021444843,
-0.0524221547,
0.0208428781,
0.0268429406,
0.0239758492,
-0.0461021252,
-0.0586879775,
-0.0993610173,
-0.0376022942,
-0.0093106441,
-0.0262945183,
-0.0255645141,
0.0476671755,
-0.0144128725,
-0.0290234089,
0.0051616435,
-0.0242501516,
0.0410768501,
0.0555794165,
-0.0020519311,
-0.0066263587,
0.0057458789,
0.012530583,
-0.0121270195,
-0.0306661651,
0.0599341877,
-0.0946936682,
0.0273600258,
-0.0323656909,
0.0031907745,
0.0060259518,
0.018053377,
-0.0418804139,
-0.0841863155,
0.0403054878,
0.0639375523,
0.0342471413,
-0.0331155621,
-0.0439568013,
-0.0470838957,
0.0295216162,
0.096551843,
-0.0821998194,
0.0370653234,
0.0602217652,
-0.0248386413,
-0.0016052121,
-0.0008864985,
-0.0376298092,
-0.0471112803,
0.0762332752,
-0.0194927976,
-0.0643714219,
0.0005890252,
0.0057139746,
0.0610545278,
-0.0272700991,
-0.0213486776,
0.0282394607,
0.0143679325,
0.0203470942,
0.0040129558,
-0.0266327485,
0.0054241037,
0.0119768679,
0.0148941018,
-0.0608599037,
0.0384280682,
0.0255302321,
0.0065075927,
0.0058133216,
-0.0212855004,
0.0325245671,
0.0168838687,
0.0534451455,
0.0756547302,
0.0182297118,
-0.0246198848,
0.0578232743,
-0.013890354,
0.0454292633,
-0.0027912802,
0.0529675484,
-0.0148678282,
-0.0187685881,
0.026540231,
0.0766554326,
-0.0622935556,
-0.0497413762,
0.0153647074,
0.0778034106,
-0.0144594153,
0.0134197548,
-0.0105115091,
-0.0172859952,
0.0234760195,
-0.0573724173,
-0.0200536456,
-0.0054827579,
-0.053134229,
-0.0144042131,
-0.0245847814,
-0.018967839,
-0.0098059028,
0.0539820939,
0.0085866312,
0.0369178616,
0.0201859046,
-0.0125773968,
-0.0417324789,
0.0016137725,
0.0459094718,
0.0161724277,
-0.0723100007,
-0.0656852573,
-0.0795386732,
-0.0672558397,
-0.0466295294,
0.0182376243,
0.0385091305,
-0.0012576646,
-0.0405500345,
0.0385955945,
0.0098693268,
0.0308005307,
-0.0623001643,
0.0046780538,
-0.0130059151,
-0.0449277535,
-0.0014034286,
-5.660627577e-33,
0.0228610355,
-0.0397522114,
-0.075845696,
-0.0221059788,
0.0349164642,
-0.0096666459,
-0.0455217622,
0.0299799368,
-0.0071251439,
-0.0510117523,
-0.0223258622,
-0.0033335562,
0.015827259,
-0.0287910849,
-0.0054716556,
-0.0242974721,
0.0195031203,
0.0397376791,
-0.0386577062,
0.0455704816,
0.0535989739,
0.0050122081,
0.0038795131,
-0.0461989157,
0.0524461605,
-0.0454767272,
-0.0138954353,
0.0173540805,
-0.0444386415,
0.0533110611,
0.0206216797,
0.0115218861,
-0.0075013191,
-0.0256419443,
-0.0184726901,
0.0522089154,
0.0129740555,
0.0118042147,
0.0383539721,
0.0042295754,
0.0357611217,
-0.0481155775,
0.0070242099,
0.003951055,
0.0018254364,
0.0016105322,
-0.0110156843,
0.0117837703,
-0.0035247649,
0.0031737282,
0.0068047796,
-0.0196728054,
-0.0326099545,
0.0375668108,
-0.0164071415,
-0.0121476809,
-0.0003945835,
-0.0297590382,
-0.0157912299,
0.0394938849,
0.0895695314,
-0.0061252643,
0.0478578433,
-0.0012544468,
-0.0232242085,
0.0479217321,
-0.0328922421,
-0.0154069429,
0.007778883,
-0.0047864607,
-0.0073152748,
0.0418305509,
0.0367835164,
0.0767235607,
0.0326294899,
-0.0216634739,
-0.0000327379,
0.0047061052,
0.0344358161,
0.0072569577,
0.0150530376,
-0.0269090179,
-0.0117223924,
-0.0083290823,
0.000045422,
-0.0029986906,
-0.0134940166,
-0.0482177697,
0.0133550102,
-0.0082254568,
-0.0172418505,
-0.0511826426,
-0.000350981,
-0.065988116,
-0.0320423655,
-0.0108788814,
-0.0062003904,
0.0051556299,
-0.0116899125,
0.0300635751,
0.0141451545,
0.0167319309,
-0.0009201716,
-0.0670473427,
0.0494356453,
0.0066611292,
0.0031438426,
0.0411246493,
-0.0757325888,
0.0149518838,
-0.0145580759,
0.0377873518,
-0.010990222,
-0.0015095538,
0.0092440853,
-0.0411817282,
0.0176509917,
-0.0089743556,
0.0081158299,
0.0011001764,
-0.0569370501,
0.0264607426,
-0.0056904526,
0.0209383536,
-0.0033520912,
0.0150100682,
-0.0037144835,
0.0411948785,
0.0725711882,
-0.017882999,
-0.0000677594,
-0.0114385094,
2.952e-7,
-0.0173155386,
-0.0181711204,
0.0153586725,
-0.0232858937,
0.0222945549,
0.0672951043,
-0.0239396468,
0.0801988989,
-0.0082781631,
-0.0423963442,
-0.0433282554,
-0.0550618283,
0.0598110259,
0.0317284614,
-0.0650570914,
0.0378778614,
-0.0530308969,
0.0133304698,
-0.0846608207,
0.01823535,
0.0263160914,
0.0495149083,
0.0016105567,
-0.0317673311,
0.0300394129,
-0.0430013761,
-0.026586635,
-0.017239796,
0.004156474,
-0.0238637235,
0.0243206527,
0.016964145,
0.0224782899,
0.0093000261,
-0.032354176,
-0.0350896157,
-0.0724003837,
0.0389823616,
0.0269849412,
0.0062997369,
-0.0267079081,
-0.0686222762,
-0.015234855,
-0.0636476874,
0.0536966398,
0.0692924261,
0.0024440601,
-0.029628545,
0.0310451929,
-0.0943648964,
-0.0087949513,
-0.0136358142,
0.0251879673,
-0.0017853124,
0.0027301894,
0.0159652755,
0.0203808565,
-0.0334549919,
-0.0097440099,
0.0009447063,
-0.0095628491,
-0.0339362323,
-0.0209926907,
0.049545113,
0.0311210994,
-0.0386488177,
0.0336133428,
3.069954796e-34,
-0.0159515198,
-0.0193920881,
0.021352211,
0.0163843408,
0.0251985341,
0.0186799038,
0.0406332575,
0.0224897824,
-0.0007795428,
-0.0158219542,
-0.0142021477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14964v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14964v2 | Detecting Multidimensional Political Incivility on Social Media | 2023-05-24T09:57:12 | 2023-11-14T22:41:40 | Sagi Pendzel, Nir Lotan, Alon Zoizner, Einat Minkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of social media has been argued to intensify uncivil and hostile
online political discourse. Yet, to date, there is a lack of clarity on what
incivility means in the political sphere. In this work, we utilize a
multidimensional perspective of political incivility, developed in the fields
of political science and communication, that differentiates between
impoliteness and political intolerance. We present state-of-the-art incivility
detection results using a large dataset of 13K political tweets, collected and
annotated per this distinction. Applying political incivility detection at
large-scale, we observe that political incivility demonstrates a highly skewed
distribution over users, and examine social factors that correlate with
incivility at subpopulation and user-level. Finally, we propose an approach for
modeling social context information about the tweet author alongside the tweet
content, showing that this leads to improved performance on the task of
political incivility detection. We believe that this latter result holds
promise for socially-informed text processing in general. | [
0.041489467,
0.0534965917,
0.0003734391,
0.0294738617,
-0.0114103043,
0.0238074902,
0.0389027074,
0.0410604551,
0.0404361226,
-0.051503472,
0.0046865526,
-0.0032520012,
-0.0246315077,
0.0004876495,
0.0138791297,
-0.0525031351,
0.0334897041,
0.0545954816,
0.0618293956,
-0.0426193736,
0.0535416715,
0.0120523321,
0.0268148221,
0.0159083996,
-0.0528636761,
-0.0030558847,
0.0072768265,
0.0366662666,
0.0777100027,
0.0132538499,
0.0496462956,
0.0620966516,
0.0174859408,
0.0729238614,
0.0000017849,
-0.023865154,
-0.0293626357,
-0.0179378577,
0.0269587729,
-0.0328588709,
0.0865112469,
-0.0457273461,
0.0074461331,
0.0294906832,
-0.0433760174,
0.0331908055,
-0.0048942682,
0.0342020541,
0.0774007514,
0.0443006232,
-0.0245894883,
-0.0132595729,
-0.025987139,
0.0039508916,
-0.0201580022,
0.0011305592,
0.0204730053,
-0.0630324557,
-0.0694770291,
0.0124381082,
0.031626828,
0.0033074513,
0.0003477887,
0.0487301238,
0.0098547079,
-0.0153438626,
0.0142355189,
0.0030141922,
0.0023076446,
0.0501291268,
-0.0066957939,
0.0007467981,
0.0471423082,
0.0052298424,
-0.0224815514,
-0.0096806707,
-0.0278307032,
-0.0157869123,
-0.0312522873,
0.0587950274,
0.0229625665,
0.0212100632,
0.0223150086,
0.0890156254,
0.0218871478,
0.0277265459,
-0.029084364,
-0.0443975143,
-0.0283327922,
-0.0105851339,
0.0126286289,
-0.0043988251,
0.0060139853,
-0.0038195229,
-0.0036220097,
-0.0119171822,
-0.0562667325,
-0.0368405245,
0.0227160789,
-0.0373594128,
-0.0312283412,
-0.0211253967,
0.0382874422,
0.0513343178,
0.0882580504,
-0.0265718475,
-0.0241573453,
0.0296682436,
0.0112397419,
-0.045090206,
-0.0109827947,
0.0387123823,
0.0276696812,
-0.0549844354,
0.0054741655,
0.0164020602,
0.0000193553,
-0.0214289501,
-0.050844986,
-0.027351629,
-0.0353069939,
0.0104299756,
0.00233016,
-0.0291400701,
-0.0345618092,
0.001067572,
-0.0587169193,
0.0094919503,
-0.04767875,
-0.0219976138,
-0.0042621852,
0.0229547676,
0.0238438509,
-0.0019335126,
0.0038823723,
0.0226115976,
0.014059511,
-0.0095651923,
-0.0109499535,
-0.0235356595,
-0.0025737616,
-0.0374776386,
0.0362634547,
-0.0637413114,
0.0723195896,
0.0109175341,
-0.0459174067,
-0.0416771583,
0.0135174105,
0.0323081464,
-0.0337282866,
0.0486136042,
-0.0093654348,
0.0127014285,
0.0401535407,
0.0518208854,
0.0065031624,
0.0598375313,
0.0100793662,
0.0010559431,
0.0741446242,
0.0360337906,
0.0035747336,
0.0472246557,
0.0412995033,
0.0389718562,
-0.0228185169,
-0.0028178722,
-0.0664085895,
-0.0558765605,
0.0006407846,
0.0341912396,
-0.0009975519,
-0.0543520041,
0.0411229171,
0.0822623223,
-0.0379480533,
0.0307315271,
0.0259632468,
0.0611448251,
-0.0250204522,
-0.026099015,
-0.0217991825,
-0.0010257845,
-0.030096503,
-0.0563135482,
0.0519350953,
0.0786860585,
-0.0264130458,
-0.0001080352,
-0.0324075297,
-0.0057922611,
0.0612243339,
-0.0503852665,
0.0137058869,
-0.0202844255,
-0.0147293787,
-0.0030235697,
0.0491693579,
-0.0512761213,
0.0074001495,
-0.005450523,
0.028334273,
0.0920627713,
0.0202811472,
-0.0276150722,
0.0235883296,
-0.0546075813,
0.0409331098,
0.0323867463,
0.0272936281,
-0.0348712802,
-0.0304115415,
-0.0282696299,
-0.0201315936,
0.0568095595,
0.0001005402,
0.0232633837,
0.0721976385,
0.020580437,
-0.0199795961,
0.0369845033,
0.0154173309,
0.0033836209,
0.0005284664,
0.005520287,
-0.0050805449,
0.0365321822,
0.0589207076,
0.0221446324,
-0.0159070231,
-0.0758204758,
0.030475704,
0.0061762803,
-0.0433280468,
-0.0212762449,
-0.0159929022,
0.0171169154,
0.0168774687,
-0.0175071862,
-0.0435746685,
0.0179502442,
0.0030032913,
0.0468068197,
0.0784819499,
0.0091532394,
-0.0197524317,
-0.0214417037,
-0.0592010282,
-0.052813556,
0.0087244408,
-0.0453981385,
0.0875072628,
-0.0392109118,
-0.0318114944,
0.0495271012,
-0.065299876,
0.0223536752,
0.057772819,
-0.0042941812,
-0.0461185649,
-0.0173351876,
0.019220382,
-0.027208956,
-0.043042127,
-0.0413328186,
-0.0259951018,
-0.0610991381,
-0.0181697048,
-0.0415787511,
-0.0007019281,
0.0042729219,
0.0084943241,
0.0030058101,
0.0488872528,
0.0109880911,
-0.0115287313,
0.0271016024,
-0.0050357864,
0.0008471188,
-0.0581501685,
-0.0150719117,
-0.0237785839,
0.0007252411,
-0.0608577058,
0.0472076982,
-0.0105678029,
-0.0488101654,
0.05555382,
-0.0133314747,
-0.050228782,
0.0416084267,
-0.0328816921,
-0.0238464568,
0.0182951875,
0.0189669617,
0.0213093888,
0.0364289507,
0.0649905428,
0.0794828311,
-0.0080453372,
0.0035017959,
-0.0304316226,
0.0202332735,
-0.0278431084,
0.0515172854,
-0.0397626273,
-0.0257481001,
0.0034909572,
0.0673428923,
0.0227370784,
0.0045740376,
-0.0281676296,
0.0737686455,
-0.0484286323,
-0.0245808437,
-0.0259497687,
-0.0194155686,
0.0172094014,
-0.0131331757,
-0.0128691383,
-0.035617128,
0.0211999509,
-0.008466078,
0.0757465884,
0.0032379925,
-0.0485305339,
0.0139068635,
0.0485903807,
0.0142526962,
0.0024017305,
-0.0358601622,
0.0148088662,
0.0082255257,
-0.0106219826,
0.0429006815,
-0.0250238776,
0.026408717,
-0.0261066016,
0.0059173461,
-0.0109250639,
-0.0353433341,
-0.0251265112,
-0.08180774,
-0.0136738569,
-0.0099990685,
-0.0024293491,
-0.022947086,
0.0292796176,
0.0031447881,
0.008455581,
-0.0614333786,
0.0163117219,
-0.0210533347,
0.0256576091,
0.0232210681,
-0.0244517457,
-0.0026613711,
0.02095972,
-0.0057087885,
-0.0342537686,
0.0197052434,
0.0022619003,
-0.0076326649,
0.0080209868,
-0.0267092902,
0.0138372593,
0.0270544924,
0.017450761,
-0.0432968698,
0.0437113531,
-0.0079614576,
0.0150891254,
0.0736389905,
0.0250357445,
0.0041490314,
-0.0029729835,
0.0198215824,
-0.0010244568,
0.011026253,
-0.0105927037,
-0.090051055,
0.0080702296,
-0.0260750838,
-0.0105185071,
-0.0407800488,
-0.0475070812,
0.0035098461,
-0.0374119803,
0.0065621482,
-0.0147957653,
0.0083513316,
-0.0487314127,
0.0171824973,
0.0132053047,
-0.0169944707,
0.004043608,
-0.0196368564,
0.0303932037,
-0.0024795367,
-0.0142336953,
-0.0617985018,
-0.0257118512,
0.0230849478,
-0.0292485654,
0.039050445,
-0.0117990542,
0.0736096203,
-0.0226798635,
-0.0162255019,
0.0157069881,
-0.0149527313,
-0.0246209074,
-0.0451422483,
0.076637581,
-0.0346074961,
-0.0089364648,
-0.0378099754,
0.0324301571,
0.0103820283,
-0.0445519127,
-0.0379454866,
0.0191306882,
0.0096702101,
0.0069500376,
-0.0400682651,
0.032541126,
0.0344193764,
0.0530697256,
0.0304904245,
-0.0420657136,
-0.0071699051,
-0.0526527241,
-0.000502278,
-0.0368218049,
-0.0429747365,
-0.0144412462,
-0.0008682953,
-0.0461611897,
-0.0196876302,
-0.040729817,
0.0300926697,
-0.0290231649,
-0.034456525,
-0.0227205306,
-0.0007632512,
-0.0411794744,
-0.0219383165,
-0.0276532825,
-0.00370377,
0.0348766893,
0.052309718,
-0.0329579487,
-0.0551076941,
0.0204318948,
-0.0430943593,
0.0179652497,
-0.0555239394,
-0.030334197,
0.0490863174,
0.0042479252,
0.0168256611,
0.0351399854,
-0.0206022467,
-0.0043177693,
0.0422838368,
0.0619380698,
-0.0171716493,
0.0097751245,
0.0367476456,
0.0353507735,
0.04621635,
0.031300094,
-0.0020273221,
0.0168897361,
0.0451861359,
-0.0780810863,
-0.098105289,
-0.0231537912,
-0.0603428595,
-0.0738153458,
0.0816073269,
0.0334121883,
-0.1071628779,
-0.0495088808,
-0.0478731878,
-0.009902182,
-0.0465241745,
0.0218016785,
-0.0098343845,
-0.0188292097,
-0.007590631,
-0.0793405473,
0.0093194069,
-0.0170308724,
0.0200838838,
-0.0679510683,
0.0168993939,
-0.007896428,
-0.000003593,
0.0118801482,
-0.0275187716,
-0.0022156728,
-0.0095127486,
-0.0235427897,
-0.0373795107,
-0.0045902589,
0.0046779835,
-0.0274910145,
-0.0056824256,
0.0155066764,
-0.027428316,
-0.0030991603,
0.0058162562,
0.0081456359,
0.0287834741,
-0.0039837393,
-0.0121051371,
0.0313936137,
0.0315940566,
-0.0010525173,
0.0090614948,
0.0251069143,
-0.0343784094,
-0.0602914169,
-0.0060147308,
0.0376922153,
-0.0427281074,
0.033463221,
0.0702098981,
-0.0207015593,
0.0068723951,
0.0329028517,
-0.0434025787,
0.0085021788,
-0.0009747154,
0.0456209369,
0.0511313789,
0.0026857988,
0.0116086965,
-0.0576908253,
-0.0021316465,
0.0283688568,
-0.0216592904,
0.0040960866,
0.0148325479,
-0.0358276926,
0.0862031579,
-0.0363510847,
0.0347612128,
-0.0168758072,
-0.0088962223,
-0.0090308953,
-0.0889134184,
0.0280109663,
-5.850991172e-33,
0.0046384307,
-0.0554524995,
0.0036838325,
-0.0002259449,
-0.0169307441,
0.0181247424,
0.0119571406,
-0.0026264598,
-0.0102116251,
0.0146960216,
0.0121783251,
0.0559238829,
0.0074397861,
-0.0084821004,
0.0033144157,
-0.0555968583,
-0.0066757379,
-0.0214914326,
0.0052253879,
0.0263345689,
0.0254597999,
-0.0272165369,
-0.0008674049,
-0.0889437646,
-0.0002209464,
-0.0485945977,
-0.0053230557,
-0.0060165026,
0.0206910372,
0.0106357597,
-0.0238417368,
0.0515374057,
0.0518364534,
0.002615632,
0.0133653348,
0.0799425319,
-0.0166794695,
0.004826929,
-0.0293010734,
-0.0361371376,
-0.0261154417,
-0.0194515735,
0.0162050258,
0.0288174711,
-0.0351725109,
-0.0235348344,
0.0622629598,
0.0323872976,
0.0565507784,
-0.0471807867,
-0.0641372725,
0.041093003,
-0.0452260673,
-0.0022021024,
-0.0201849584,
0.0296052843,
0.0866853446,
0.035025008,
-0.0899340063,
0.0314879008,
-0.0296257399,
-0.0272508282,
0.0078908857,
-0.0412337035,
0.0287400335,
0.0606118552,
0.0360528417,
0.0685717389,
-0.022416763,
-0.027782483,
-0.0013052773,
0.0506713018,
0.0317219533,
0.0874869004,
0.0013917292,
-0.1189457402,
-0.0906309038,
-0.0069124233,
0.0626461878,
-0.0298960116,
-0.0029665264,
-0.0203660019,
-0.0037489159,
-0.024504954,
0.0320352688,
-0.0849864855,
-0.0245643668,
0.0072175828,
-0.0232663546,
0.0308052432,
0.0067750039,
-0.0098977219,
0.050399825,
-0.0289677661,
-0.0096902261,
0.0564797707,
-0.0076598534,
0.0094791669,
0.0208714902,
0.0291787833,
-0.0323347487,
-0.0437057316,
-0.0219908189,
-0.0119654201,
0.0166037269,
-0.0326018631,
0.0567566603,
0.0168694109,
-0.0486502536,
0.0148346983,
0.0152085405,
0.0284472182,
-0.075460121,
0.0113603622,
0.0136531228,
0.0557874031,
0.0125860218,
-0.0143509591,
0.042313721,
-0.0112559097,
0.0278957319,
-0.0073692151,
-0.0557387546,
-0.0467718355,
0.0116183357,
-0.0097658411,
-0.0284784473,
-0.0190333687,
-0.0058731269,
-0.0393872522,
0.0070290435,
-0.0678431988,
2.466e-7,
0.0002158592,
0.0805338621,
0.0041736066,
-0.0134088434,
0.0490470752,
0.0386914089,
0.0426405519,
0.0530258045,
-0.0777463615,
-0.0339953639,
0.0162500311,
0.0506537296,
0.0143042104,
0.0655938312,
-0.0491022468,
-0.0175217036,
-0.0410193838,
-0.0149492826,
-0.0727562457,
0.0052538095,
0.0069658053,
0.0149462838,
0.0793858841,
-0.0208070297,
0.0027899488,
-0.0150534473,
0.0284469612,
-0.0489826538,
-0.036483068,
0.0218875818,
0.0449834689,
-0.0353913084,
0.0237849969,
0.0278658532,
-0.0138159059,
0.0214865766,
0.0131773734,
0.0328135788,
0.0277506374,
0.0318528302,
0.0244919397,
-0.0420196392,
0.001775342,
-0.0314900167,
0.0393054448,
-0.0098930215,
-0.0121134333,
-0.0487806648,
0.0086260373,
-0.0304178819,
0.0599012449,
0.010560059,
-0.0314195044,
-0.0045864237,
0.0132602975,
0.0069360593,
-0.0082919719,
-0.0543723591,
0.0210632384,
-0.0116136279,
-0.0539718494,
-0.0251986925,
0.0167734139,
-0.0139126973,
0.0831146762,
0.0536772944,
0.0463375449,
2.011376904e-34,
0.0028148133,
-0.00683566,
-0.0172882471,
-0.0456252769,
0.0367119238,
0.0085510658,
-0.0313816629,
-0.0277812295,
0.0150366351,
-0.0451691486,
0.0267516244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14963v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14963v1 | PESCO: Prompt-enhanced Self Contrastive Learning for Zero-shot Text Classification | 2023-05-24T09:57:06 | 2023-05-24T09:57:06 | Yau-Shian Wang, Ta-Chung Chi, Ruohong Zhang, Yiming Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present PESCO, a novel contrastive learning framework that substantially
improves the performance of zero-shot text classification. We formulate text
classification as a neural text matching problem where each document is treated
as a query, and the system learns the mapping from each query to the relevant
class labels by (1) adding prompts to enhance label matching, and (2) using
retrieved labels to enrich the training set in a self-training loop of
contrastive learning. PESCO achieves state-of-the-art performance on four
benchmark text classification datasets. On DBpedia, we achieve 98.5\% accuracy
without any labeled data, which is close to the fully-supervised result.
Extensive experiments and analyses show all the components of PESCO are
necessary for improving the performance of zero-shot text classification. | [
0.008146978,
0.0191628207,
0.0193869248,
0.0152291907,
-0.0456940755,
0.0331273228,
0.0558415316,
0.0217514709,
0.0479256548,
-0.0804228187,
-0.0519606471,
-0.0218376499,
-0.0266314913,
0.0122914733,
-0.0191698447,
-0.0365058891,
0.033057183,
0.0174693316,
0.0028741506,
0.0146204447,
-0.02444892,
0.0157714915,
-0.0368651673,
-0.0227252673,
0.0171675775,
-0.0428059101,
-0.0269519184,
0.0277138632,
0.0122907124,
-0.0515229627,
0.0385631733,
0.069446139,
0.0028010854,
0.0306514334,
0.0000017401,
-0.0797302574,
-0.0121130673,
-0.017020775,
-0.0507819951,
-0.043078471,
0.0701848567,
-0.005884273,
0.0308763143,
0.0133274961,
-0.0113929631,
-0.0389774591,
0.0244677104,
0.0767079741,
0.0188298523,
0.0755382255,
-0.0251466725,
-0.0396706946,
0.0180037078,
-0.0046619968,
0.0421018079,
-0.0059454856,
0.0341433771,
-0.0802860111,
0.0345310904,
0.0689224675,
-0.0014216034,
0.0068409694,
0.0215431284,
0.0089245066,
0.0145882191,
0.0537287816,
-0.0150022553,
0.004221743,
-0.0058623385,
0.0909384564,
0.0208466686,
-0.0327861644,
-0.0118786348,
-0.0387486257,
-0.0221637748,
-0.0489078388,
-0.0062029785,
0.0004087186,
-0.0045926757,
0.0135605764,
0.0201602858,
0.0473626629,
-0.0168010201,
0.0050529386,
-0.0053235572,
0.0022660193,
-0.0105308807,
-0.0377097875,
0.0105357058,
0.016550025,
0.0277037602,
-0.0586108267,
-0.0103601916,
0.0325477831,
0.0000293468,
-0.0340624601,
-0.0692933649,
-0.0558236614,
0.0439328477,
-0.01721761,
-0.0050424822,
0.0170290004,
-0.0402094014,
0.0728572235,
-0.0101647126,
-0.0021093613,
0.0003944148,
0.0240452383,
-0.0293675996,
-0.0033459202,
-0.0716555864,
0.0310596749,
-0.0345734954,
0.0722611994,
-0.0172153786,
0.0009081299,
-0.0103939194,
0.005466782,
0.0114321541,
0.0130663523,
-0.0133198835,
0.0101544512,
-0.045561146,
-0.0042161713,
-0.0245680772,
0.0411214791,
-0.0283976048,
0.0302702412,
-0.0316275172,
-0.0265987422,
-0.0057654935,
0.0175465681,
0.0241222158,
-0.0394794084,
0.0188149288,
0.0367866009,
-0.0217258576,
-0.0970712826,
-0.058633782,
0.0132416179,
-0.009787865,
-0.0173343457,
-0.0386100598,
-0.0326651558,
0.0148030352,
-0.0066333143,
-0.0351290852,
0.0005177913,
-0.0104273576,
0.0353306234,
-0.0184536446,
0.1159259602,
-0.0419333205,
-0.0641112775,
0.0436189137,
0.0112992655,
-0.0169714931,
0.0422844067,
-0.0171096176,
0.0063855941,
0.0164509993,
0.0316130109,
0.0251549166,
-0.0082617775,
0.0310278479,
0.0012149268,
-0.0213825963,
0.0463129058,
0.0383743271,
0.015669575,
0.024933245,
0.012394229,
-0.0079175429,
-0.0510203317,
0.0223572664,
0.0336563699,
0.0501778796,
-0.0224774033,
0.0050528855,
0.0488067679,
-0.0252447464,
0.015468603,
-0.0196671225,
0.0399477333,
-0.0273116268,
-0.0128096845,
0.0257782415,
-0.0189977922,
-0.0822825357,
-0.0224644989,
0.0168709047,
-0.0259416196,
-0.026638696,
0.0046530962,
0.0507686548,
0.0019182402,
-0.0367850736,
-0.0124959154,
0.0289259013,
-0.009144594,
-0.0100640841,
-0.0488879345,
0.0464738272,
0.0481403619,
0.0203290489,
-0.064156726,
-0.0184796192,
-0.0491797142,
0.0322055556,
0.0493148379,
-0.001602395,
-0.0045676157,
0.0241357386,
-0.0402499586,
-0.0562623926,
-0.0435437374,
-0.013723731,
0.0144937197,
-0.0377219915,
0.060287904,
0.0216009449,
0.0160594378,
0.0017759925,
0.0385066718,
-0.0156386085,
-0.0886431485,
0.0737773702,
0.0414849743,
-0.0155918421,
0.01509941,
-0.0220605582,
-0.0079726754,
0.0079999315,
-0.0144419717,
-0.0075117494,
-0.0667349994,
-0.0341685824,
-0.0752687901,
0.0207023304,
0.000926949,
0.0043594856,
0.0054287915,
-0.0441155434,
-0.0501372665,
-0.0097213583,
0.0355923511,
-0.0117057292,
-0.0317970477,
-0.0086178761,
0.0086719142,
0.0081732841,
-0.0341024175,
0.0662540272,
0.0516703092,
0.0333010703,
-0.0068010199,
0.0362559259,
0.05206839,
-0.0477047823,
-0.0326871686,
-0.0158984363,
-0.0136142168,
0.0180122834,
0.0039282362,
0.0108480807,
-0.055268798,
0.0147345634,
-0.0589456558,
0.016395634,
0.0085510863,
0.0006645538,
0.0302609466,
0.0039488352,
-0.0071636657,
-0.0384604745,
-0.0546623431,
-0.0231381822,
-0.0100737968,
0.0217919145,
0.0614975952,
-0.0003913838,
0.0153524084,
0.0008990534,
-0.0094772438,
-0.0182412732,
0.0290182568,
0.0127131948,
-0.0169803798,
0.0018861946,
0.0490340181,
-0.0138912629,
0.0351432823,
0.029630255,
0.0033984645,
-0.0002125745,
-0.0064893076,
-0.0498741008,
0.0714174435,
0.0310959313,
-0.0537917875,
-0.0013190557,
0.0268032383,
-0.0583055727,
0.0119247157,
-0.0172801875,
0.0323161893,
0.0408196039,
0.0130670033,
0.0062894132,
0.0564688295,
0.0052675647,
-0.0133461561,
-0.0360632949,
0.0087481178,
0.0279389098,
0.0248023104,
-0.0458676592,
0.0415633395,
0.0167929251,
0.0083737681,
-0.0281482451,
-0.0027115003,
0.0782231018,
-0.0114452969,
0.0071593169,
-0.0412332527,
-0.0290328674,
-0.0408475772,
0.02712938,
-0.0120978514,
0.0114599569,
0.0539563969,
-0.0127408793,
-0.0172687881,
-0.0711114034,
0.0119680781,
-0.0034831224,
0.0125729702,
0.0346495137,
0.0591152869,
-0.0508484133,
-0.0625988171,
-0.0481376275,
-0.0620838106,
-0.0209471509,
0.029907275,
-0.0565199852,
0.0145035209,
-0.0381046608,
0.0004290053,
0.0200059582,
0.0827973783,
-0.0200746208,
-0.040884804,
-0.0128570506,
0.0576729365,
0.0257311352,
-0.0221406315,
-0.0161738973,
0.0004164965,
0.0378330424,
0.0398539193,
0.0300215539,
0.0233649928,
-0.0232453626,
0.0010459945,
0.0213179197,
-0.0602836013,
-0.0138865551,
-0.0113817276,
-0.0316799134,
-0.0019545571,
-0.005706274,
0.0993894488,
0.0337726325,
-0.0874387026,
-0.0552904531,
-0.0313362442,
-0.0228738394,
0.0354886502,
0.0274620503,
-0.1002985314,
-0.0524367057,
-0.0251105335,
0.0423007198,
0.0152321057,
-0.0257753953,
-0.0128421225,
-0.1227690652,
0.0342187956,
-0.0265847035,
-0.027420219,
0.0112429634,
-0.05939845,
0.01343814,
-0.0214505456,
-0.0316054076,
0.002426055,
-0.009922279,
-0.009971003,
0.0086422628,
0.0336511955,
-0.0392609015,
0.0273180529,
-0.0264218599,
0.0079396917,
0.0118499799,
0.0086038467,
0.0101436563,
-0.0348498113,
-0.0146360435,
-0.061358165,
-0.0306154173,
-0.0396634042,
0.1091389805,
-0.0664539859,
0.0125474948,
-0.0071274992,
0.0073293466,
-0.0218725801,
-0.0105414558,
0.0021300355,
0.0369932838,
-0.0093656341,
0.0342218205,
-0.0632312,
-0.0150286769,
0.023672035,
0.0775399059,
0.0044239759,
-0.0395487733,
-0.039713148,
-0.0100625977,
-0.0061933715,
-0.0661307275,
0.008147981,
0.0038171248,
-0.0365786478,
-0.0080205984,
-0.0257054791,
-0.0293194372,
0.0036941054,
0.0523665287,
-0.0219676867,
-0.0167806186,
-0.0612584949,
-0.0266370345,
-0.0440352075,
-0.0048446092,
-0.0346368067,
0.0092718238,
-0.0814787298,
0.0049494477,
0.07860028,
-0.0486362539,
-0.0117231971,
-0.0522982627,
-0.0192499682,
-0.030856235,
-0.0189666934,
0.0244597942,
0.0074648997,
0.0334389992,
-0.0059646997,
-0.0519197062,
0.0713444501,
0.135084793,
-0.0419418477,
-0.0218648668,
0.020779537,
0.0215758644,
0.0056471587,
0.0245325211,
-0.0310922172,
0.0415399447,
0.0166634228,
-0.0114456601,
-0.0406253487,
-0.0416931398,
0.0153014241,
-0.0010328887,
0.090043731,
0.006563277,
0.0093214083,
-0.0321616419,
0.0275429916,
-0.0064657331,
-0.0334446989,
-0.0181407761,
0.0244419798,
-0.0036151831,
-0.0266476106,
-0.013626501,
0.0236181151,
-0.0738255084,
0.0379470252,
-0.0287233889,
-0.0345202051,
0.0614427775,
0.015944507,
-0.0031710605,
0.00074357,
-0.0109679522,
0.0299239364,
0.0549992509,
0.0581964664,
-0.0244122017,
0.047922451,
0.0417282283,
0.0466237888,
-0.0392044447,
0.0120354751,
-0.049661845,
0.0023865546,
-0.0158714876,
-0.0057123932,
0.0603268147,
-0.0250681434,
-0.0484747291,
0.0159813091,
-0.0226160474,
-0.0095187509,
0.0146262916,
-0.0048707942,
-0.004526474,
0.0163275339,
0.0172695983,
0.0061232015,
0.0657625496,
0.0573029704,
-0.0282812901,
0.0184465889,
0.0375910737,
0.0018761648,
-0.0262421984,
0.0463132858,
0.0294311345,
0.0227065571,
0.0061320658,
-0.0038424465,
-0.0108232331,
-0.0357759409,
0.0739950165,
-0.0183881186,
-0.0202325676,
0.0325475708,
0.0533137061,
0.0102087976,
0.0314410776,
-0.031747546,
-0.0247659534,
0.0389550105,
-0.0019481186,
-0.0223933905,
-0.0143926358,
-5.92460871e-33,
-0.0177259315,
-0.0343479589,
0.0291269571,
0.0096765198,
0.045500014,
0.0121000987,
0.0054840408,
-0.0319403857,
-0.0138019128,
0.0002722449,
-0.018075211,
0.0070061469,
0.0023361775,
0.0381888263,
-0.003607102,
-0.0298708808,
0.025772946,
-0.0266504586,
-0.0107169496,
0.0087964805,
0.0255747512,
0.0411893949,
0.006902189,
-0.0647458583,
0.0169490632,
-0.0110922381,
0.0060665971,
0.0243347194,
0.0592827648,
0.0480193757,
-0.019361699,
0.0263943803,
0.0457805358,
-0.023065703,
0.0335586853,
0.0446374752,
-0.0952536911,
-0.0670577809,
-0.0584094487,
-0.0275630429,
-0.0246367604,
-0.0080534425,
0.0030741363,
-0.0040079076,
-0.0058942232,
-0.0172971431,
0.0499276891,
0.0122394795,
-0.0032081623,
0.0042011975,
-0.0241977312,
0.0215673018,
0.0085649444,
-0.0221050363,
0.0283424705,
0.0874231905,
0.0313869379,
0.0681656972,
-0.1149697453,
0.0060370457,
-0.0116345882,
0.0156635828,
0.0093573984,
0.0291719045,
-0.0269377101,
0.0409705266,
0.0498721935,
-0.0044515007,
-0.0017985112,
-0.000874528,
0.0181175321,
-0.0167539865,
0.0251093823,
0.0822366998,
0.0691436678,
-0.0036331741,
-0.0873908922,
0.0374500938,
-0.0060769585,
-0.0095563158,
-0.0300397128,
0.0037008794,
-0.0488916934,
-0.0116231423,
-0.0105178328,
-0.0423586518,
-0.0745681077,
-0.0106174946,
0.0082741408,
0.0212927088,
-0.010151404,
0.0047439714,
0.0354181491,
-0.0153619265,
-0.0473225154,
0.0206030048,
-0.0180053711,
0.0187457204,
0.0202411525,
-0.0077400971,
-0.0917929783,
-0.0348159224,
0.0159286,
0.0278261527,
0.0029642943,
0.0347711816,
0.0559513234,
-0.0000063774,
-0.0612683184,
-0.0087181441,
0.0262084045,
0.0133904908,
-0.0097674187,
0.0295533389,
-0.0057950453,
0.0369691551,
0.015286373,
0.1065824553,
0.0333076343,
-0.0057542813,
0.0017321083,
-0.0311126243,
-0.0036753104,
0.0241974052,
0.0057172687,
0.0058041518,
0.0033863282,
0.0550386943,
0.0113012148,
-0.0538835526,
0.0118918773,
0.010214367,
2.549e-7,
0.0141136888,
0.0061434377,
-0.0009453595,
-0.0004094242,
-0.003174233,
0.0826498419,
0.004486423,
0.0562406369,
-0.0036813943,
0.0124703022,
-0.0010779902,
0.0178797059,
0.012904292,
0.0232537799,
-0.0868077576,
0.0168795679,
-0.0319087841,
0.0148831047,
-0.0516378209,
0.0038354921,
0.0837620199,
0.0449079759,
0.0370537862,
-0.0154659534,
0.0117571773,
-0.0216627903,
0.0469773524,
0.0361323245,
0.0189185906,
-0.0203443803,
0.0207844172,
0.027498316,
-0.0276195947,
0.0413687266,
-0.0148296906,
0.0432783924,
-0.0173804946,
0.0228250492,
-0.0218940414,
-0.0634381548,
0.0237103868,
-0.0005704418,
0.0099429134,
-0.0166625492,
0.1111543477,
-0.0666830018,
-0.001633044,
-0.0129320286,
-0.0461188182,
-0.0104763927,
0.0696992055,
0.0027067233,
-0.0426720381,
-0.0011160689,
0.0245939177,
0.00288891,
-0.0444662757,
-0.0794852749,
0.0264839698,
0.0160838235,
0.0144577781,
0.0458188578,
-0.0188920069,
0.029424401,
0.0396939479,
-0.0400472209,
0.0167534724,
1.74537539e-34,
0.0095293708,
-0.0142003661,
-0.0050700069,
-0.0259835068,
-0.051949922,
0.0026631656,
-0.0351697393,
-0.0364043638,
0.0583317168,
-0.0563068725,
-0.001491524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14956v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14956v3 | Editing Common Sense in Transformers | 2023-05-24T09:50:54 | 2023-10-26T15:38:38 | Anshita Gupta, Debanjan Mondal, Akshay Krishna Sheshadri, Wenlong Zhao, Xiang Lorraine Li, Sarah Wiegreffe, Niket Tandon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Editing model parameters directly in Transformers makes updating open-source
transformer-based models possible without re-training (Meng et al., 2023).
However, these editing methods have only been evaluated on statements about
encyclopedic knowledge with a single correct answer. Commonsense knowledge with
multiple correct answers, e.g., an apple can be green or red but not
transparent, has not been studied but is as essential for enhancing
transformers' reliability and usefulness. In this paper, we investigate whether
commonsense judgments are causally associated with localized, editable
parameters in Transformers, and we provide an affirmative answer. We find that
directly applying the MEMIT editing algorithm results in sub-par performance
and improve it for the commonsense domain by varying edit tokens and improving
the layer selection strategy, i.e., $MEMIT_{CSK}$. GPT-2 Large and XL models
edited using $MEMIT_{CSK}$ outperform best-fine-tuned baselines by 10.97% and
10.73% F1 scores on PEP3k and 20Q datasets. In addition, we propose a novel
evaluation dataset, PROBE SET, that contains unaffected and affected
neighborhoods, affected paraphrases, and affected reasoning challenges.
$MEMIT_{CSK}$ performs well across the metrics while fine-tuning baselines show
significant trade-offs between unaffected and affected metrics. These results
suggest a compelling future direction for incorporating feedback about common
sense into Transformers through direct model editing. | [
0.0668664798,
0.0318166651,
-0.0126170404,
-0.0015302424,
-0.0221227743,
-0.0016399459,
-0.0255116001,
0.0037663651,
-0.0179748964,
-0.075647749,
-0.0404007398,
0.0304374062,
0.0062915348,
-0.0311187692,
0.0226778742,
-0.0632525682,
0.0670367256,
-0.0001041429,
-0.0313712433,
0.0006034718,
-0.0388263911,
0.0013662942,
-0.013984154,
0.0448362194,
0.0128239803,
-0.0418636575,
0.010497096,
-0.0042177681,
0.056234166,
0.0205762573,
-0.0051765312,
0.0821506605,
-0.0167086907,
0.04143494,
0.0000019548,
-0.0562888309,
-0.0308772661,
0.0064464668,
-0.0232601389,
0.0026771447,
0.0171370655,
-0.0043998994,
-0.0083584981,
0.0130625712,
-0.0308553595,
0.0023645454,
0.0433137752,
0.069145672,
0.0798119083,
0.0552929714,
-0.0103931902,
-0.0269003399,
0.0135433991,
-0.0124686798,
0.022458842,
-0.0285950676,
0.0293926224,
-0.0067874868,
-0.0606626831,
0.0099835023,
-0.0341332033,
0.0383451134,
0.0328113362,
0.0047820155,
0.0033725707,
0.0200548936,
-0.0572361536,
0.0060829427,
-0.0018313406,
0.0562530942,
0.036018692,
-0.0093380436,
-0.0363837518,
0.0070247804,
0.0563731454,
0.0374442302,
-0.0176076442,
-0.0176011082,
-0.0011780248,
-0.0072603803,
-0.0171890613,
-0.0482135937,
0.0004977185,
0.0207071938,
-0.0146312015,
0.0790896192,
0.0220691431,
-0.0487504229,
-0.0016072399,
0.0107215811,
-0.039952375,
-0.0451783948,
0.0170799885,
0.0155284442,
-0.0062551647,
0.0153727829,
-0.0249135196,
-0.0154693602,
0.0079021119,
-0.0322108753,
0.0091478573,
0.0364544503,
-0.0286845323,
0.0437590815,
-0.0099491505,
0.0644046888,
-0.0014598125,
0.108245872,
-0.0145822782,
-0.0231469199,
-0.0759915337,
-0.0266874749,
-0.0361177176,
0.035298232,
-0.0248087216,
0.0286721289,
-0.0696088597,
0.001545374,
-0.0002023152,
-0.0142056132,
0.0403350927,
0.0331196524,
-0.0493062995,
0.0020344658,
-0.0570868626,
0.0677536875,
-0.0305934194,
0.0252954829,
0.0200543758,
-0.0295465011,
-0.0203762166,
-0.0290770661,
0.0314934701,
-0.0385553576,
0.0109460372,
0.0561076328,
-0.0372511186,
-0.0232251026,
-0.042324286,
-0.024318574,
-0.0057450067,
-0.0193011463,
0.0185398404,
-0.0384874828,
-0.0046515795,
0.0062404904,
0.012046257,
-0.0546494946,
-0.0210049152,
0.0325773694,
-0.0412144437,
0.0882061347,
-0.0052885292,
0.0040912102,
0.016268719,
0.0223524757,
-0.0419808403,
0.0405123532,
0.0140628191,
-0.0078126509,
0.0618563071,
-0.028227644,
0.0217459444,
-0.0170242041,
0.0037498318,
-0.0162642971,
0.0253390316,
0.0130789541,
-0.0458850749,
0.0306647457,
0.0254563913,
0.0331641883,
-0.0429758243,
-0.012717274,
0.0950282589,
0.0325699858,
0.0378335677,
0.0490821898,
0.0048208656,
0.0178330746,
0.0198288858,
0.0232018027,
-0.071448274,
0.0299644917,
-0.0450239927,
0.0149274189,
-0.0275107883,
0.0079980511,
-0.0137012657,
-0.0162686184,
0.0099583501,
0.0323970206,
0.0293060187,
-0.0193413068,
0.0324876308,
0.0429225229,
-0.0113124279,
0.1030511931,
0.0080246311,
-0.0676876679,
-0.0213223808,
-0.0583075695,
-0.0246832501,
0.0127319749,
0.0516013205,
-0.0048637837,
-0.0542178303,
-0.0153290378,
-0.022542784,
0.0294413622,
0.040000733,
-0.0087272516,
0.0042854501,
-0.0449361689,
-0.0316314809,
-0.0191527158,
0.0205627289,
-0.0211299323,
0.0584296063,
-0.0049626995,
0.0221170932,
-0.0647893995,
0.0341050327,
0.0136567596,
0.0030024038,
-0.0180748571,
-0.039300058,
0.0099075446,
0.0114127705,
-0.0047597098,
0.0117017981,
-0.0103593012,
-0.0031740773,
0.0206116159,
-0.0395647585,
0.0521449111,
-0.0358060934,
-0.0153562548,
0.0305558443,
-0.0626005083,
-0.0602502562,
0.0784899965,
-0.0356423035,
-0.0245652776,
-0.0005973159,
-0.046012938,
0.055825863,
-0.0601287931,
0.0016932375,
-0.0400038995,
-0.0378695577,
-0.0150586106,
0.0577138588,
-0.0188025814,
-0.0145006189,
-0.00275223,
-0.0222994406,
-0.0070544844,
-0.0164816249,
-0.0069191591,
-0.017807046,
-0.0043216464,
0.0051894151,
-0.0017749747,
0.0229455233,
-0.0554723032,
-0.0272690821,
-0.0844902769,
-0.0205039009,
-0.0233746003,
-0.0030077819,
0.0348076336,
0.0016189134,
0.0027500235,
-0.0097484775,
-0.0089768209,
0.0131993797,
-0.0161976311,
0.0446344092,
0.0297739245,
0.0005757331,
0.016815111,
0.0064336816,
0.0071390891,
-0.0229085851,
0.0344163328,
0.0119970571,
0.0480772629,
-0.045294188,
0.0184984729,
-0.0538237505,
-0.0075354753,
0.0028545477,
-0.0579396375,
-0.0010904614,
0.0418343246,
0.0545051172,
0.0566812605,
-0.0022866423,
0.0220228359,
0.0212307684,
-0.0251322761,
-0.0222484916,
0.0159750544,
-0.0083929682,
-0.0404039212,
-0.0443069749,
-0.0189770516,
0.0090143746,
0.0490787886,
-0.0041677631,
-0.0310844872,
-0.0759573579,
0.0333920605,
-0.0117420442,
-0.0438019969,
-0.0213257931,
0.0114897359,
-0.0027516268,
0.0221407656,
-0.017684944,
-0.0367008112,
0.1087172329,
0.0094558122,
0.0089476928,
-0.0684084445,
0.0304275807,
-0.0170872919,
0.0456233397,
-0.0354152955,
0.0218977071,
-0.0038815958,
-0.0206207819,
-0.0841909498,
-0.0149651412,
0.0298750326,
-0.0255051609,
0.0633511245,
-0.0599892847,
-0.0205898117,
-0.0135854324,
-0.0656501949,
-0.0331697986,
-0.0206873417,
-0.0175633002,
0.0306259077,
0.0512890555,
-0.0427295417,
-0.077064015,
-0.0095839081,
0.0502131097,
0.0633734167,
-0.0127870338,
-0.0347863212,
-0.0147471903,
-0.0022820143,
0.053523168,
0.0822725669,
0.0705551431,
-0.0175643284,
-0.0128720859,
0.0689321011,
0.0271860976,
-0.0665244237,
0.0195678566,
0.0088857114,
0.0083028981,
-0.0594194271,
0.0078238463,
-0.0072987154,
0.0631180331,
-0.0385530367,
-0.0244629476,
0.069576025,
0.0462401472,
-0.0396601669,
0.003138215,
-0.063119933,
-0.0152458875,
0.0177484192,
0.0233673118,
-0.061845012,
-0.0555782914,
0.0214290284,
0.0340427943,
-0.0220420621,
-0.0511412062,
0.0059614405,
-0.0977673158,
0.0169084873,
-0.0242136549,
-0.0553166904,
-0.0572259948,
-0.0179389827,
0.0133578656,
-0.0338486098,
0.021178076,
0.0227060914,
-0.0160620697,
-0.002493978,
-0.0112519767,
0.0246456303,
-0.0784996673,
0.0258208644,
-0.0006991628,
0.0217080563,
0.0464389399,
0.0034453629,
0.0040532215,
-0.0918646604,
0.0008635421,
-0.0217563901,
0.035062667,
-0.0086002592,
0.0185844116,
-0.0024002767,
0.0030073514,
-0.038728077,
0.0297316164,
-0.0097481329,
-0.0404912755,
0.0053490233,
0.0642917007,
-0.0177677907,
-0.0161967799,
0.0029543135,
-0.0028232585,
-0.0177804865,
0.0794281065,
0.0326696895,
-0.0027901304,
0.0033256072,
-0.0515556224,
-0.0091334442,
-0.0237584487,
-0.042017255,
0.0085270889,
0.024932202,
-0.0023946133,
-0.0661767498,
-0.031609349,
0.0323648788,
0.0127212126,
0.0152466726,
-0.0275219847,
0.0244607646,
0.0351746865,
-0.0406709164,
0.0429303199,
-0.0482683703,
-0.0175357535,
-0.0574607849,
0.0104758535,
0.0365776159,
-0.0061290367,
-0.0607415214,
0.0192334838,
-0.0219795965,
-0.0403645895,
0.0528580211,
0.0563005731,
0.0297949556,
0.0259900615,
-0.0023612303,
-0.0594806895,
0.0420403965,
0.0339492075,
-0.038458623,
0.0514757745,
0.0324098095,
-0.0269156825,
-0.0056785708,
0.0491454639,
-0.0088208411,
0.0046935747,
0.0364555344,
0.0629175529,
-0.0241579432,
-0.0034029239,
0.0250061098,
0.0125782993,
0.0683676675,
0.0213395935,
0.0229945295,
-0.0173624493,
0.0484496467,
-0.0083615705,
-0.0071237353,
-0.017578369,
-0.0063855536,
-0.007592144,
-0.0096600512,
-0.0196583401,
0.0458695441,
-0.0242327731,
0.0594822839,
-0.0246001501,
-0.0056625768,
0.0142899128,
0.0289634299,
0.0034370357,
-0.0045160186,
-0.0152013702,
-0.0172815435,
-0.0049094036,
0.0302041341,
0.0011778657,
0.0799226984,
0.047909569,
-0.0414547287,
-0.0326038487,
0.0356627144,
-0.0881918222,
-0.0040883715,
0.0009777078,
0.0537369587,
0.0203699023,
0.0178265516,
0.0118349791,
-0.0285336021,
-0.0408202112,
0.0059709819,
0.0203970373,
0.0286754165,
0.0103536118,
0.0499427617,
0.0095601277,
0.0154154645,
-0.0099471733,
0.0618517138,
-0.059530694,
0.0627605468,
-0.0652170107,
-0.0445288494,
-0.0337613076,
-0.0419719256,
-0.0156162046,
-0.0046638241,
0.0047241109,
0.0120718423,
-0.0853782669,
-0.0608536564,
0.0220844839,
0.0152386976,
0.0128940335,
-0.0211305078,
0.0305504762,
0.0881308764,
-0.004800675,
-0.058839906,
0.0017753715,
0.0149750188,
-0.0532629378,
0.016374927,
-0.0164968651,
-6.335809491e-33,
-0.0355194584,
-0.0113504026,
0.0156789925,
-0.0072781318,
-0.0194170307,
-0.0030400811,
-0.0263757743,
0.00300194,
-0.0072083254,
0.0317279771,
-0.03509067,
0.0284767002,
0.0080342516,
0.0011703228,
0.0041363202,
-0.016431462,
0.0637439713,
0.0378133692,
-0.0595985278,
-0.0096100671,
0.0490269661,
0.00360459,
0.1122407988,
-0.0316683091,
0.0196000431,
0.0229895636,
0.0034097601,
0.0150983268,
-0.0601076744,
0.059077505,
0.0218679737,
0.0492195413,
0.0202245954,
-0.0562749468,
0.0008724949,
-0.0112901367,
-0.0671586916,
-0.0261527263,
0.0396936722,
0.0253944509,
-0.021966381,
-0.0592295043,
0.0330722183,
0.0057200333,
-0.0208583213,
-0.0251955353,
0.0324243493,
-0.0302819945,
0.0146566229,
-0.0073314845,
-0.0253730044,
0.0045519937,
0.0106035136,
-0.0069538886,
-0.0490514003,
0.0577009097,
0.0027369398,
0.0306063145,
-0.0827464312,
0.0131934229,
0.05850292,
0.0174407698,
0.046527911,
-0.0140514672,
0.002753895,
0.030254133,
-0.0302419905,
-0.0145589607,
-0.0302467775,
-0.0440574512,
0.0306335781,
0.0173407551,
0.0632974654,
0.0959890634,
0.0133742727,
-0.0077715758,
-0.0483721904,
0.0260690339,
-0.083706826,
0.0618579723,
0.0168108884,
0.0021803821,
-0.0148061533,
0.01306736,
-0.0542383678,
0.0130886408,
-0.0499041267,
-0.0192802828,
0.0213847533,
0.0003690249,
-0.0412345231,
0.0441121459,
0.0172473285,
-0.0026763731,
0.0188441016,
-0.008767968,
-0.0191417839,
0.0256403238,
-0.0202252455,
0.0040940554,
-0.0234388392,
0.0149324397,
0.0545591079,
0.0308285337,
0.011836566,
0.0184915438,
0.0664115325,
0.01998532,
-0.0436822586,
-0.0077028326,
-0.0027538615,
0.0142612541,
-0.0336796045,
-0.0276734307,
0.0201576985,
0.0470087565,
-0.0053826757,
-0.0164912753,
0.0217178818,
0.0271499716,
-0.0297997147,
0.042642992,
0.0279200785,
0.0259128362,
-0.0117348116,
0.0044856141,
-0.0009922376,
-0.0413025394,
-0.0042205648,
-0.0416166745,
-0.0196696445,
0.0430690646,
2.704e-7,
0.0445564762,
0.054575514,
0.0050741239,
-0.0116230771,
0.0104824826,
0.0591190159,
-0.0005707711,
0.0084737493,
0.0574734919,
0.0062055704,
0.007754927,
0.0265802946,
0.0279067289,
0.031869933,
-0.0916194096,
0.0095990701,
-0.0481414422,
0.0263046194,
-0.0296863895,
0.0070460686,
0.0442779399,
0.0571747385,
0.007412272,
-0.0120204901,
0.0032241119,
-0.009608929,
0.0624169335,
-0.0456819721,
0.0224955454,
-0.0190369133,
0.0257061832,
0.018059276,
0.0334113017,
0.0673863441,
-0.0026116318,
-0.0163919181,
0.0133015728,
0.037654791,
-0.0131488061,
-0.0411784425,
-0.0168436207,
-0.0157604013,
0.0081524123,
-0.0810604766,
0.053389553,
-0.1130113825,
-0.0405045263,
-0.0028147148,
-0.0208954867,
0.0082729002,
0.0255629998,
-0.0231272988,
-0.042874366,
-0.0103434464,
0.0055079889,
0.0466984212,
-0.001383538,
-0.0536829494,
-0.0118352305,
-0.0000565317,
-0.0001773301,
-0.0911820158,
-0.0607526638,
-0.060077209,
0.0231509842,
-0.0589173511,
-0.0026563092,
2.409118045e-34,
0.007672498,
0.0050256681,
0.0260080211,
-0.0178726222,
0.0348993167,
-0.0028800927,
0.0630713552,
-0.0188471451,
-0.0074106241,
-0.0779128745,
-0.013487339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14950v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14950v2 | Adversarial Demonstration Attacks on Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T09:40:56 | 2023-10-14T05:03:53 | Jiongxiao Wang, Zichen Liu, Keun Hee Park, Zhuojun Jiang, Zhaoheng Zheng, Zhuofeng Wu, Muhao Chen, Chaowei Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | With the emergence of more powerful large language models (LLMs), such as
ChatGPT and GPT-4, in-context learning (ICL) has gained significant prominence
in leveraging these models for specific tasks by utilizing data-label pairs as
precondition prompts. While incorporating demonstrations can greatly enhance
the performance of LLMs across various tasks, it may introduce a new security
concern: attackers can manipulate only the demonstrations without changing the
input to perform an attack. In this paper, we investigate the security concern
of ICL from an adversarial perspective, focusing on the impact of
demonstrations. We propose a novel attack method named advICL, which aims to
manipulate only the demonstration without changing the input to mislead the
models. Our results demonstrate that as the number of demonstrations increases,
the robustness of in-context learning would decrease. Additionally, we also
identify the intrinsic property of the demonstrations is that they can be used
(prepended) with different inputs. As a result, it introduces a more practical
threat model in which an attacker can attack the test input example even
without knowing and manipulating it. To achieve it, we propose the transferable
version of advICL, named Transferable-advICL. Our experiment shows that the
adversarial demonstration generated by Transferable-advICL can successfully
attack the unseen test input examples. We hope that our study reveals the
critical security risks associated with ICL and underscores the need for
extensive research on the robustness of ICL, particularly given its increasing
significance in the advancement of LLMs. | [
-0.0020399755,
0.0737261921,
-0.007537629,
0.0582212768,
-0.0398716927,
0.0008147532,
0.0598285347,
-0.0067098099,
0.0248275064,
-0.0277493075,
-0.0282207187,
-0.0298070218,
0.0043806303,
0.0033088024,
0.0957646519,
-0.0382741317,
0.0547554716,
-0.0454712436,
-0.0439591445,
-0.0118443109,
-0.0152643453,
-0.0410370603,
0.0037770376,
0.0138262305,
-0.025092788,
-0.0390172414,
-0.0281793475,
-0.0016154222,
0.0150435744,
-0.0244230703,
0.006421871,
0.0514999777,
0.0271666218,
0.0709536299,
0.0000022698,
-0.0292594209,
-0.0376215056,
0.0490646511,
-0.0418339148,
0.0603805967,
0.021936819,
0.0025920193,
-0.0311066266,
0.0119009148,
-0.028297253,
-0.0212530736,
0.0254830737,
0.0723471195,
0.0827674866,
0.1265892237,
-0.0032668007,
-0.0149067985,
0.0293048788,
-0.0546224602,
0.000414019,
-0.0813402012,
0.0419087,
-0.036792472,
-0.0116446409,
0.0271444228,
-0.002127595,
0.0305729583,
0.0360850841,
0.0030370513,
-0.0706510916,
0.0173604079,
-0.0288371332,
0.017810639,
-0.0004743485,
0.0416509062,
-0.0442182608,
-0.0087276846,
-0.0103999916,
0.0236629173,
0.0321045369,
-0.0024909303,
-0.0385521576,
-0.000838622,
0.0276006218,
0.0040149987,
-0.0094940141,
-0.0231880303,
0.0693448633,
0.0126286773,
-0.0151549093,
0.0347762704,
0.0220768712,
-0.0178922359,
-0.0117517486,
-0.0364919677,
-0.0469600484,
-0.0529249012,
-0.0241912622,
0.0008498284,
-0.0295013133,
0.0183953885,
-0.1003893986,
-0.0467274785,
0.0122099314,
-0.0286568459,
0.0479972847,
-0.0005399418,
-0.0052264938,
0.0362330452,
-0.0159897413,
0.0791850239,
-0.0130814677,
0.0734089836,
0.0039617512,
0.0178814679,
-0.0138851674,
-0.0121033667,
-0.0165738426,
0.0185591951,
-0.0253981519,
-0.0041397805,
-0.0204228107,
0.0447652079,
-0.0440414026,
0.0443320572,
-0.0434916764,
-0.0313087665,
-0.0310736727,
-0.0109100929,
0.0417677127,
-0.0195881799,
0.0158462431,
-0.0073321345,
0.0041215494,
-0.0814154819,
-0.0494991653,
0.0115636969,
-0.0484087653,
-0.0128091648,
-0.0194156617,
0.1176695377,
-0.0064349072,
-0.0414142534,
-0.029152602,
-0.0379940122,
0.0015259052,
-0.0435761735,
0.0067933751,
-0.0700900406,
-0.0206958596,
-0.0219511259,
-0.0076828124,
-0.0713038221,
-0.0034315158,
0.0111799957,
-0.0177783053,
0.0911718979,
0.0388393663,
-0.0086245378,
0.0120172203,
0.049660407,
-0.0356587134,
0.0544616133,
-0.0060342252,
0.027885193,
0.0342673585,
-0.0021370596,
0.0280745719,
0.0508078299,
0.0609829053,
0.0597973876,
-0.0305883959,
0.0103534674,
0.0548970439,
0.0058533326,
-0.039434813,
0.0696586594,
-0.0290911049,
-0.0421209969,
0.1124875769,
0.0191857573,
-0.0375411063,
0.0050782193,
-0.0061160633,
0.0134814307,
0.0125112543,
0.0040744389,
-0.1051698476,
-0.0162368938,
-0.068524532,
-0.0343056805,
0.0037277325,
0.024808092,
-0.0177868493,
-0.0046993671,
0.0183244795,
-0.0092805261,
0.0277054794,
0.008467433,
0.0137300463,
0.0599194095,
-0.0291009042,
0.0219446849,
0.0215114336,
-0.0130187161,
-0.0185872074,
-0.0997171775,
-0.030255232,
-0.0199989863,
0.0539496318,
-0.023834765,
0.0163374506,
-0.0364052691,
0.0518421344,
0.0258842092,
0.0373337306,
0.0072187749,
-0.0009150031,
0.0022642815,
0.0026463473,
-0.0577479713,
0.027511254,
0.0126041928,
0.048107136,
0.0232762005,
-0.0115155336,
-0.0313650034,
-0.010350544,
0.0245481804,
0.0147029012,
-0.0757452101,
0.0167995617,
0.0226140916,
0.0383152626,
-0.0112476964,
-0.0223886929,
0.0155799221,
0.050627213,
0.0228121895,
0.0219631493,
-0.028483456,
-0.0333126746,
-0.0435526706,
0.0182040054,
-0.0249162819,
-0.0276191365,
0.042275887,
-0.0574715734,
-0.0043715667,
0.0256285444,
-0.0270148646,
0.0374050699,
0.0128117912,
0.0117480997,
0.0009574411,
0.0383876972,
-0.0303843915,
0.0519807488,
0.0002068314,
-0.0365131274,
0.0131174074,
0.0548583306,
-0.0246424302,
-0.0344020836,
-0.0478814431,
0.0248006079,
-0.0229979306,
0.0243681893,
-0.0220295545,
0.0120074498,
0.0000325309,
0.0022117519,
-0.0480836742,
-0.0158547442,
-0.0382255539,
0.029890772,
0.0184525866,
0.0016247175,
-0.0299210213,
-0.0246710982,
-0.0133675579,
-0.010808032,
-0.0262718778,
0.0160916466,
0.0029352149,
0.0154216923,
-0.0245483369,
0.0253892671,
-0.0072539733,
0.018322492,
0.0768486559,
-0.0391559973,
-0.0091097318,
-0.0274802241,
0.0204361361,
0.0274013691,
0.0539955981,
-0.0235507805,
-0.0149996802,
0.0354731977,
0.0156555399,
-0.0025196492,
0.0741932243,
0.0381789245,
0.088829495,
0.0251751095,
0.0133034708,
-0.0214733928,
-0.010127753,
0.0057938267,
-0.0392579995,
-0.0569850616,
0.0156610291,
0.0234595127,
0.0262668841,
0.0240274761,
-0.0242246892,
-0.0138489669,
0.045110438,
-0.0133423833,
-0.036704585,
-0.0332499556,
-0.0203824174,
-0.0458434448,
-0.0486031659,
0.0007009532,
-0.0640910491,
0.0640352517,
-0.0529162884,
0.0159508921,
-0.0244677924,
-0.0452137925,
0.0376891494,
0.0558091998,
-0.0017789199,
0.0080468329,
0.0213676486,
-0.029905241,
-0.0590957701,
-0.0219337903,
0.0315264799,
-0.0318206139,
0.0206648633,
-0.0450251885,
-0.0074109551,
-0.0029432019,
-0.0429201201,
-0.0576454699,
-0.036070127,
0.0159985721,
0.0242807269,
-0.0140976915,
-0.0280913953,
-0.0191945378,
-0.0339082181,
0.0483448207,
0.0204239413,
-0.0216444209,
0.0067187278,
-0.0295798536,
0.0032662675,
0.0310652945,
-0.0333575942,
-0.0186761543,
-0.0389209948,
0.0041947556,
0.071577616,
0.0362208821,
0.0006674501,
-0.0355052277,
-0.0097479196,
-0.000575239,
0.0092795659,
0.0173487645,
0.0212730728,
0.0458303839,
-0.0476021729,
-0.017572457,
0.0298538543,
-0.0142965885,
-0.0331905745,
0.022966899,
0.0584242865,
-0.0063967062,
-0.0066902824,
0.014317167,
-0.0774826035,
-0.022317443,
0.0463995449,
0.0486723632,
-0.0101280827,
-0.0016071952,
-0.031434644,
-0.1015519351,
0.028585596,
0.0191892665,
-0.0660881773,
-0.039112322,
-0.0096241077,
-0.0093827853,
0.0156039624,
0.0772553459,
-0.0131367594,
0.0131239779,
-0.0135380374,
0.0177572109,
0.0340439379,
-0.0971842781,
0.0107323667,
-0.0247967448,
0.0529789776,
0.0637729242,
0.0015507041,
-0.0208417997,
-0.00270076,
0.0892363936,
0.0054107215,
-0.0326283798,
0.0206111018,
0.0379784815,
-0.0048487987,
-0.0236398727,
0.0230713822,
0.0625902489,
0.0189935975,
-0.0223358274,
0.0326729417,
0.0368607864,
0.0041923346,
-0.019870067,
-0.0039362721,
-0.0521794409,
0.0673247874,
0.0620584264,
0.0206608735,
-0.0370733216,
-0.0170782041,
-0.0641168356,
0.0162670203,
0.0245588105,
-0.0494550541,
0.0051878076,
0.0086552836,
-0.0241720658,
-0.0372939184,
0.0101266671,
-0.016419787,
0.0474548005,
0.0031859395,
0.0034277383,
-0.0412499979,
0.0066355318,
-0.0182426926,
0.0246737991,
-0.0386447608,
0.058468055,
-0.0503238551,
-0.0058962274,
0.0169247035,
-0.0407048911,
-0.0243765395,
0.014639454,
-0.0764550567,
-0.0907807872,
0.0061037047,
0.0326281302,
0.0197446346,
0.0613284968,
-0.0392138474,
-0.0502894111,
0.1011534035,
0.0675975159,
0.0069379434,
0.0233703852,
0.0813257098,
-0.0283892825,
0.0121754315,
0.0496570393,
-0.0328729004,
-0.0231171977,
0.0630570203,
-0.0171404723,
-0.0345488489,
0.0148192123,
0.0137249706,
0.0227127466,
0.0673723891,
0.003363078,
-0.0225043986,
0.0076897405,
0.0400922112,
-0.0054526804,
-0.0202536136,
-0.0189420264,
0.0112889837,
-0.000947594,
0.0192676764,
0.0352373831,
-0.0080659129,
0.0608192645,
0.0008548896,
0.006544983,
0.0148554407,
0.0286864899,
0.0047768862,
0.058880955,
0.0313317552,
-0.013694549,
0.0268404447,
-0.0015608378,
0.0284155738,
-0.0235371813,
0.0464454591,
0.0473787263,
-0.0138587803,
0.0041512251,
0.0332271196,
-0.0688602552,
-0.0356323868,
-0.0311324652,
0.0660435408,
0.0117800944,
0.0068385839,
0.0171987265,
-0.0522831492,
-0.0161761492,
-0.0333142914,
-0.0128635336,
-0.0100612352,
-0.0571961068,
0.0261870101,
-0.0042095431,
0.0212704781,
0.0410773121,
0.0691648424,
0.0090429895,
0.0567235611,
-0.0045436588,
-0.0047742357,
-0.0408411101,
-0.0395814627,
0.070807986,
-0.0107685914,
-0.0111181373,
-0.0244759284,
-0.0136906654,
-0.0911636427,
-0.0529353432,
-0.0113638081,
0.0096875019,
0.0000992843,
0.0094764289,
0.0516031086,
0.0010533411,
0.0231262874,
-0.0487558059,
0.0062362379,
0.0587670207,
-0.0691589639,
0.0294192657,
-6.720842666e-33,
0.0019839276,
-0.021155512,
-0.0220146962,
-0.0050176489,
0.0095475055,
0.0069386745,
-0.021970924,
-0.0184269324,
-0.0163256414,
0.0046935193,
-0.0224285834,
0.0001484924,
0.0001830273,
0.0456516817,
-0.05212944,
-0.0524310656,
0.0146937193,
-0.0151347993,
-0.0338494405,
0.0496632718,
0.03964369,
-0.0059101037,
0.0478853844,
-0.0744731128,
0.0358520374,
-0.0143408002,
-0.0557031929,
0.002025055,
-0.0743732154,
0.0258743614,
-0.0101145431,
0.0120241186,
-0.0106921261,
-0.0262285974,
-0.0069334861,
0.0454747006,
-0.0039331079,
-0.0077404887,
-0.0169836786,
0.0243666768,
-0.0166053679,
-0.0255411938,
0.025909774,
-0.0374168195,
-0.0030518302,
-0.0075991317,
-0.0283971112,
-0.0045507904,
-0.0138115752,
-0.0144933462,
-0.0192107297,
0.0165802892,
-0.0060944883,
-0.0222478602,
0.0169626642,
-0.0031635328,
0.0259599481,
-0.0483332537,
-0.0473162234,
0.0323097445,
0.0301157776,
0.007069834,
0.0658446923,
0.0033100904,
0.0129869133,
0.0556871593,
-0.0105058122,
-0.0110906651,
0.0239889435,
-0.0302271452,
-0.0000734598,
0.0413608588,
0.0530453771,
0.062704213,
0.0463324003,
-0.0352138802,
-0.0459613875,
-0.0130911525,
0.0326755047,
-0.0045289453,
0.0425059758,
0.0101706469,
-0.0594163612,
-0.0188073628,
-0.0285063107,
-0.0458222851,
-0.0269632004,
-0.029304048,
0.0286921412,
0.0255425088,
-0.0282744262,
0.0050611012,
0.0123044625,
-0.0604467206,
-0.0356609263,
0.0205861405,
-0.0008590617,
-0.018100014,
-0.0096223829,
-0.0034094751,
-0.0093729682,
-0.028584538,
0.0111121638,
-0.0425987318,
0.0195476674,
0.0046748337,
0.0556402691,
0.0581725612,
-0.0522451587,
-0.01074827,
-0.0269871205,
0.0521725863,
0.037445046,
-0.0191295315,
0.0529857837,
-0.0147102177,
-0.0065311049,
0.0068441234,
0.0264346618,
-0.0232523922,
-0.0240724199,
0.0199956503,
-0.055335287,
-0.0041911015,
-0.0218533985,
-0.0024995776,
-0.0103763444,
0.044417128,
0.0573124103,
-0.0662455112,
0.0039488664,
-0.0315272473,
3.158e-7,
-0.023757223,
0.0220184326,
0.0029380885,
0.0130577758,
0.0399670824,
0.0634376556,
-0.0477172434,
0.0854568854,
-0.0045327297,
-0.0370968208,
-0.02906432,
0.0162140373,
0.0692216977,
0.0391522124,
-0.0650412589,
-0.0175891872,
-0.0667496175,
-0.0059619332,
-0.0577012114,
0.0032407325,
0.0280810986,
0.1103990376,
0.0335164964,
-0.0078462157,
0.0000334883,
-0.0521434285,
0.0307212751,
-0.0397400372,
0.0098995697,
-0.0152749028,
0.00709874,
0.0373536125,
0.0286249015,
0.0354303457,
-0.039657034,
-0.0082510347,
-0.0155711593,
0.0424658135,
0.0360294618,
-0.0114694592,
-0.0327288546,
-0.0318230875,
-0.0088616023,
-0.0399022959,
0.0847649202,
-0.0547199994,
-0.0215785801,
-0.0175646413,
-0.0008053788,
-0.0665474534,
0.0185526777,
-0.011121301,
-0.0008467395,
0.0046536112,
0.0033000663,
0.0124215866,
0.0075838608,
-0.0636252761,
-0.0185511392,
-0.0202038568,
-0.0367228575,
-0.0331578851,
-0.0077400068,
0.036729306,
0.00793433,
-0.0129407197,
-0.0119949533,
2.989715139e-34,
0.0002167078,
-0.0334121734,
0.0173050612,
-0.0129408715,
0.0182608645,
-0.0067365547,
0.0314719565,
0.0099053504,
0.0060954867,
-0.0345744863,
-0.036593169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14949v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14949v2 | Cross-lingual Data Augmentation for Document-grounded Dialog Systems in Low Resource Languages | 2023-05-24T09:40:52 | 2023-09-20T07:39:19 | Qi Gou, Zehua Xia, Wenzhe Du | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes a framework to address the issue of data scarcity in
Document-Grounded Dialogue Systems(DGDS). Our model leverages high-resource
languages to enhance the capability of dialogue generation in low-resource
languages. Specifically, We present a novel pipeline CLEM (Cross-Lingual
Enhanced Model) including adversarial training retrieval (Retriever and
Re-ranker), and Fid (fusion-in-decoder) generator. To further leverage
high-resource language, we also propose an innovative architecture to conduct
alignment across different languages with translated training. Extensive
experiment results demonstrate the effectiveness of our model and we achieved
4th place in the DialDoc 2023 Competition. Therefore, CLEM can serve as a
solution to resource scarcity in DGDS and provide useful guidance for
multi-lingual alignment tasks. | [
0.0246649813,
0.0767242238,
0.0075634364,
0.0653747395,
-0.0072949105,
-0.0162683111,
-0.0043294448,
-0.0423478112,
0.0197434034,
-0.0083870534,
-0.0694259629,
-0.0209281519,
-0.0085510109,
0.0330225751,
0.0155169228,
-0.0429444909,
0.0484938994,
0.0039181993,
0.0027035272,
-0.0155038647,
0.0315161012,
0.0269108415,
-0.0290769245,
0.0240797605,
-0.0083961692,
-0.0351183787,
-0.0349045992,
0.0079619959,
0.0350735746,
-0.0111083016,
0.0200415459,
0.015683962,
0.0392278358,
0.1053477824,
0.0000017724,
-0.0287315026,
-0.016322637,
0.0013154026,
-0.0486439168,
-0.0162855871,
0.0104517303,
-0.0528803058,
-0.0284321681,
0.0130611528,
-0.0230526961,
-0.0352628678,
0.0535435453,
0.0556301363,
0.0694204718,
0.0912661329,
-0.0219231881,
-0.0144708855,
0.0584004335,
-0.0328062847,
-0.0181915537,
-0.0579088293,
-0.037438184,
0.0332611054,
-0.006557378,
0.0213466901,
0.0169275496,
0.0370602906,
0.0381922387,
-0.0486521088,
-0.0221905243,
0.0120190224,
-0.0459371582,
0.0032203388,
-0.0133232949,
0.0864609256,
0.0202984568,
0.0000485304,
-0.0219748951,
0.0121021792,
0.0087680146,
-0.0560751371,
-0.0732084289,
-0.0034138248,
0.0140826097,
0.0159572307,
0.0181255266,
0.016841691,
0.0120260734,
0.025045272,
-0.0059814597,
0.024907928,
0.0193018615,
-0.0231397431,
-0.0146538028,
0.0103233252,
0.0166827235,
-0.0498265289,
-0.007038895,
0.001865592,
-0.0550674349,
0.0074262791,
-0.0684459284,
-0.031548012,
0.0277829077,
-0.0396603495,
-0.003134852,
0.0299524181,
-0.0219136607,
0.0537246019,
-0.0252543595,
0.0574375205,
-0.0344003625,
0.0058032856,
-0.0251376946,
-0.0445446968,
-0.0002393109,
-0.0025383658,
-0.0311728101,
-0.0131961489,
-0.0885356516,
-0.0283644162,
-0.0226546526,
0.0500579849,
0.0379475728,
0.0456510372,
-0.0088117281,
0.0163068417,
-0.060884092,
-0.007200215,
-0.0109397182,
0.0653235242,
-0.0188314281,
-0.0069060298,
0.0273435898,
-0.0730495378,
-0.0219486207,
0.0520650037,
-0.0077510965,
-0.0392060131,
-0.0261281542,
0.0783354342,
-0.0543923862,
-0.0034780302,
-0.0148263294,
0.0017366793,
-0.0172904879,
-0.0757450312,
-0.0047017504,
-0.0404841863,
0.0639326498,
0.0057095685,
-0.0147356363,
-0.0282651242,
0.0140424557,
-0.0060553527,
0.0366369672,
0.056311734,
0.0016491917,
-0.0261051916,
0.0600853823,
-0.0151753603,
-0.0035500589,
0.0740000606,
0.0081231454,
0.01388615,
0.0485472903,
0.0117403939,
-0.0354998745,
0.0326517075,
0.0238570627,
0.0176410004,
0.0128501579,
0.0190205108,
-0.0105607081,
0.0196157973,
0.0273601376,
0.029098779,
-0.0488340855,
0.0010996615,
0.0519737452,
0.0157775506,
0.0089507475,
0.0099124527,
-0.0006801742,
0.0229898281,
-0.0280969534,
0.0013114553,
-0.0201549716,
0.0470677912,
0.0257993918,
0.0179180857,
0.0410554782,
0.0448859334,
-0.0441208109,
-0.0380557291,
0.0158303585,
-0.0081999088,
0.0003424333,
-0.0150882807,
0.039721936,
0.0362175591,
-0.0368647166,
0.0380787849,
-0.0103433141,
-0.0570849255,
-0.0152632147,
0.0044356841,
-0.0099390214,
0.0389342941,
0.0719268844,
-0.0129597699,
-0.0473910198,
-0.0293652918,
0.0123454537,
0.0584662706,
0.046397876,
-0.009161084,
0.0368049964,
-0.0580062717,
-0.0272264499,
-0.0503661036,
-0.0097208302,
0.0543893054,
-0.0112706581,
0.0205709245,
0.0321478099,
-0.0179437082,
-0.0197717473,
-0.0013180746,
-0.0372927152,
-0.0085856244,
0.0101096062,
0.0222013202,
0.0334382579,
0.0390356965,
-0.017318802,
0.0075575435,
0.036497619,
-0.0351688936,
-0.0078864619,
0.0362707078,
-0.0424990542,
-0.0551371723,
0.0186363738,
-0.0287237987,
-0.0230663866,
0.0027068146,
-0.0348312967,
-0.063315168,
0.043913424,
-0.0616569109,
0.0283860639,
-0.0572114885,
0.0224285852,
0.0337674655,
0.0109450035,
-0.0213137455,
0.0429717079,
0.010448494,
0.0069729886,
0.0509732962,
0.0387535542,
0.067535691,
-0.0649570152,
0.002827765,
0.0479604751,
-0.0221971702,
-0.0022036936,
0.0344837829,
0.0046385229,
-0.0178785063,
-0.024064336,
-0.0864692554,
0.0265482347,
-0.0216290336,
0.0186602846,
0.0275512375,
0.038737271,
0.010067787,
-0.0161930919,
-0.0769452527,
-0.0090673324,
0.0812465101,
0.0136201587,
0.0435800217,
0.0188412108,
0.0113860015,
-0.0590046532,
0.0243874788,
0.0411126502,
0.0248477031,
0.0024623689,
-0.0009252409,
-0.0446282439,
-0.0017297961,
-0.0547935143,
0.0533508919,
-0.0297692828,
-0.0491132513,
0.0175742172,
0.0269168951,
0.0359558761,
0.0482329465,
0.0016430729,
0.0147443656,
-0.0113744922,
-0.0109081371,
-0.0749004111,
0.0198878534,
0.0126675917,
-0.0031381031,
-0.0105326707,
0.0343334749,
-0.0003193922,
0.0278163254,
0.0104206726,
0.0262139551,
-0.0181042627,
0.02815626,
0.0390660018,
-0.0290534087,
-0.0073195142,
-0.0036284861,
-0.0152901327,
0.0314512216,
-0.0486741029,
-0.0434183665,
0.0810192376,
-0.0492072105,
-0.0389785022,
-0.0683363229,
-0.0214716084,
-0.0427091159,
0.0183008462,
-0.0408046879,
0.0323821343,
-0.052637253,
-0.0461268909,
-0.0439886115,
0.0097128395,
0.03753189,
-0.035890907,
0.0393749885,
-0.0065610074,
0.0107624736,
-0.0503502712,
-0.0820538923,
-0.0743749365,
-0.0120437266,
0.0213602092,
-0.0081630619,
0.0261274185,
-0.0309648961,
-0.0632608086,
-0.0047276407,
0.0305123273,
0.0511527956,
-0.0237511173,
0.0175324287,
-0.0256713908,
0.084327966,
0.0424694195,
-0.0040427977,
-0.0026842912,
-0.0202465989,
0.0745975152,
0.0522837229,
0.0266717281,
-0.0520131923,
-0.0143543649,
-0.0282988884,
0.0109300502,
0.0349217355,
-0.0207503848,
-0.0626908243,
0.0453834571,
-0.0482288748,
-0.0236574877,
0.0750861764,
0.0076687397,
-0.0250204448,
-0.0275149066,
-0.0526980013,
0.0361097902,
0.0190055557,
0.0314908773,
-0.0809435695,
-0.017257642,
-0.0051119523,
0.0188245922,
0.0179787539,
0.0064815525,
-0.015362435,
-0.1085752696,
0.0361777842,
0.0301500857,
-0.0297030751,
-0.0583985932,
-0.0059013306,
-0.025541259,
0.0091843884,
0.0480744541,
0.0052153477,
0.0589510873,
-0.0046602734,
-0.0123706041,
0.0563796796,
-0.0301308054,
-0.0409564301,
-0.025518829,
0.0308863316,
0.0689051896,
0.0708710551,
0.0353721455,
-0.0371217765,
0.0147345765,
-0.035476625,
-0.0133329257,
0.0245951526,
0.0312999375,
-0.0259517431,
-0.0259866323,
-0.002312623,
0.0497745611,
0.0022182744,
0.0088143349,
0.0140683958,
0.047713358,
-0.0297945943,
0.0594657212,
0.0114957113,
0.0147534711,
0.0425431952,
0.06704849,
0.0154662915,
-0.0141462097,
-0.0339936763,
-0.0241769068,
0.0169431791,
-0.0610988364,
0.0281138755,
-0.0012249761,
-0.0055839866,
0.0002735826,
-0.0810442865,
-0.0666902438,
-0.0028252499,
0.0284249168,
-0.0259796008,
-0.0108282873,
-0.0645171553,
-0.0172484089,
-0.0027286238,
0.0288293622,
0.0033670277,
0.0094905766,
-0.0585179403,
-0.0149825681,
0.0382603817,
-0.0410018489,
0.0003122993,
0.0517607965,
-0.0396005362,
-0.0778494403,
-0.0498556942,
0.030112572,
0.0142404335,
0.0862276331,
-0.0075238384,
-0.0130776651,
0.004784795,
0.0149914464,
-0.0611013733,
-0.0184020512,
0.0653876886,
0.0232252553,
-0.016687436,
0.0466622077,
-0.0492617376,
-0.0013471814,
-0.0119493734,
0.0212165713,
-0.0293832198,
-0.0660900101,
0.0040002875,
0.007533839,
0.0168722216,
0.0035478759,
0.0039350805,
-0.0438365862,
0.0545634478,
-0.0462942533,
-0.0360434279,
-0.0382884443,
-0.0071547912,
0.0033019667,
-0.0252962876,
0.0305227991,
0.0037539317,
-0.0115903988,
0.0369041711,
-0.0211769473,
0.0029758734,
0.0384866558,
0.0163199306,
0.0032319846,
0.017475659,
-0.023130551,
0.0495870486,
0.0040704575,
0.0505194739,
-0.035933286,
0.0742901564,
0.0186282713,
-0.0166073069,
0.0461298078,
0.0260243528,
-0.0505094714,
-0.0195372347,
-0.020045463,
-0.0171306413,
0.05284632,
0.007272365,
0.07876461,
-0.0101467008,
-0.0017135115,
-0.0027044935,
0.0334799848,
-0.0044446983,
-0.0575441234,
-0.0012652262,
0.0100691253,
-0.0127920266,
0.0404052623,
0.0650671199,
-0.0036287797,
0.0092457263,
-0.0155278007,
0.0113662248,
-0.0562029071,
-0.0516084321,
0.0349868238,
0.0025416298,
-0.0146322036,
0.0171308294,
-0.008665083,
-0.0525447689,
-0.0158649012,
0.0222379901,
-0.0369304605,
0.0124241188,
0.0257289074,
0.0616778061,
-0.0300908741,
0.0167104993,
-0.0338312201,
0.0458508469,
-0.0241543315,
-0.0505884774,
-0.0165246092,
-5.665218984e-33,
-0.0324078165,
0.0121700494,
0.019487394,
-0.0188945346,
-0.0459795408,
0.0065548182,
-0.0665645674,
-0.0064144372,
-0.0057011507,
0.0098718153,
-0.000366207,
-0.0024218212,
0.005018618,
0.0635524765,
-0.0275953915,
-0.0011628161,
0.0561462939,
0.0017951946,
-0.0147863925,
0.0526393875,
0.0722557455,
0.0059255906,
0.0346275494,
-0.06709335,
0.0237533879,
0.0001015021,
0.0135684973,
0.022085255,
0.0229703821,
0.0436277315,
0.0008076176,
0.0297957305,
-0.0055998247,
-0.0305983778,
-0.0221645534,
0.0214749333,
-0.0792795122,
-0.001816232,
0.0191330612,
0.0401007086,
-0.0058016176,
-0.0128460964,
0.0006765964,
-0.0498577058,
0.0297136419,
0.0210727938,
-0.0164943859,
-0.0243003592,
-0.0126633802,
-0.0028342106,
-0.0662856847,
0.0313346162,
-0.0351288132,
-0.0202677324,
0.0110091846,
0.0922205299,
0.043843355,
-0.0172885302,
-0.0738334581,
0.0088870972,
-0.048035033,
0.0157816298,
0.0761174485,
0.0117905755,
-0.0171566904,
0.063208133,
-0.0034835779,
-0.0117976619,
-0.0025768045,
-0.0009635831,
-0.0129782893,
0.0287265331,
0.0407048389,
0.0855479315,
-0.0123347277,
-0.0042602262,
-0.0491301939,
0.0600602999,
0.031898953,
0.0528327785,
-0.0016457395,
0.0361573398,
-0.0149548873,
-0.0004218896,
-0.0146887219,
-0.0384901352,
-0.0105045913,
-0.0531193949,
0.0335439928,
0.0151626496,
-0.0281951092,
-0.0331652835,
0.0527734086,
-0.0273733791,
-0.0006806786,
0.0822017193,
-0.0002306813,
-0.0124297971,
-0.0260789488,
0.0190927032,
-0.0453909338,
-0.017865818,
0.0514015295,
0.0130546736,
-0.0032403539,
0.0115426928,
0.0302513801,
-0.0114330137,
-0.0578304864,
0.0272407029,
-0.0441685133,
0.0716415048,
-0.0317567736,
0.0657060072,
-0.0056463168,
-0.0366656184,
-0.025262421,
0.0652019233,
-0.0053644232,
0.0103188641,
-0.0305632632,
-0.0667862073,
0.019072935,
0.0055021876,
-0.0461977944,
0.016409073,
-0.0159464516,
0.0001257233,
0.0250723455,
-0.0572283119,
0.0032276281,
-0.014963354,
2.536e-7,
0.0026382059,
-0.0190093555,
0.0646011531,
-0.0233526845,
0.0316939242,
0.0302588549,
-0.022841353,
0.0253058616,
0.0005738422,
-0.0262898933,
-0.0111010876,
0.0021496573,
0.080053851,
0.0239047334,
-0.101792708,
-0.0216300301,
-0.0909716263,
-0.0143143153,
-0.0384171195,
-0.0076501695,
-0.0193342976,
0.0914964527,
-0.0343337171,
-0.0008668695,
-0.000245026,
-0.0250597391,
0.0463821702,
0.0104216039,
-0.039689362,
0.0117501253,
0.0510669239,
0.0005736444,
-0.0083253458,
-0.0229618512,
-0.034108784,
0.0640186071,
0.0199765824,
0.0455344692,
0.0056368448,
-0.0618713498,
-0.0031544208,
-0.0034717063,
-0.0235016178,
-0.0560980961,
0.0469624177,
-0.0177164972,
-0.0197831485,
-0.0273819137,
-0.0388561487,
-0.0120053357,
0.0346245319,
-0.0469638258,
-0.0507145487,
0.0326647162,
0.0446033515,
-0.0276417807,
0.0146254199,
-0.0450552553,
-0.0201542675,
-0.0291899573,
-0.0440590344,
-0.0323924385,
-0.0178194884,
0.0032537279,
-0.0121281967,
0.016912479,
-0.0046123648,
2.22586743e-34,
0.0399881899,
-0.0119037349,
0.0219217464,
0.0113696642,
0.0437809974,
-0.0244145636,
0.0147422198,
0.0163451862,
0.0289376192,
-0.0406053513,
-0.0231341235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14947v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14947v2 | How Predictable Are Large Language Model Capabilities? A Case Study on BIG-bench | 2023-05-24T09:35:34 | 2023-10-31T17:27:07 | Qinyuan Ye, Harvey Yiyun Fu, Xiang Ren, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We investigate the predictability of large language model (LLM) capabilities:
given records of past experiments using different model families, numbers of
parameters, tasks, and numbers of in-context examples, can we accurately
predict LLM performance on new experiment configurations? Answering this
question has practical implications for LLM users (e.g., deciding which models
to try), developers (e.g., prioritizing evaluation on representative tasks),
and the research community (e.g., identifying hard-to-predict capabilities that
warrant further investigation).
We study the performance prediction problem on experiment records from
BIG-bench. On a random train-test split, an MLP-based predictor achieves an
$R^2$ score greater than 95%, indicating the presence of learnable patterns
within the experiment records. We then formulate the problem of searching for
"small-bench," an informative subset of BIG-bench tasks from which the
performance on the full set can be maximally recovered. We find a subset as
informative as BIG-bench Hard for evaluating new model families, while being
$3\times$ smaller. Additionally, we find competitive subsets by clustering task
representations learned by our MLP-based predictor and selecting tasks close to
cluster centroids, highlighting the importance of task diversity in
constructing "small-bench." | [
0.0231216718,
0.0620548576,
-0.0270614829,
0.0422654599,
-0.0526667088,
-0.0039908066,
0.0310458802,
0.0250566248,
-0.0009104127,
-0.0413413867,
-0.0431890227,
-0.0298673324,
0.0090325475,
0.0324705727,
0.0494454429,
-0.0219593253,
0.0036582928,
-0.0363079123,
-0.0065480415,
-0.0198492259,
-0.0324520729,
0.0056209252,
-0.0035126905,
0.0996620208,
0.0154719763,
-0.0019328282,
0.0270191785,
-0.00859991,
-0.0371767581,
-0.0190322679,
0.0111562498,
0.0208813995,
0.0205958821,
0.0417554453,
0.0000017375,
-0.0490738377,
-0.0347516164,
0.0225625318,
-0.038041342,
-0.0073028086,
0.0416750312,
0.0132637983,
-0.0063851043,
0.033173196,
-0.0127704367,
-0.0088506332,
0.0438278988,
-0.0107298754,
-0.021268975,
0.0478665903,
0.0014478666,
0.026206078,
0.0049295095,
-0.0318609141,
0.0295133851,
-0.0367306024,
0.007265151,
-0.0319981053,
0.0262151752,
-0.0135956183,
-0.0245795082,
-0.0000648426,
0.0045993673,
0.0358285494,
0.0064203963,
0.0547200479,
-0.0377481915,
-0.0112185972,
-0.0168046951,
0.0321963094,
-0.0609491877,
-0.0271709021,
0.0020118961,
-0.0265708808,
-0.0401236825,
0.0170252901,
-0.0538795479,
0.0426169895,
0.0040424298,
0.0181479473,
0.0381326154,
0.0028175476,
0.0535659082,
-0.0025570479,
-0.0226038713,
0.096384652,
0.0129029062,
-0.0250077266,
0.0054126554,
0.0359526686,
-0.0043689501,
-0.0272841379,
-0.0256505869,
-0.0075643556,
-0.0429322869,
0.04510938,
0.0074676382,
-0.0180331506,
0.012070898,
-0.0173702352,
0.0735912621,
0.0224495716,
0.003504606,
0.0423612744,
-0.0364097469,
0.0703314096,
-0.0223057549,
0.0114571722,
-0.0177486427,
-0.0136657013,
-0.0565884933,
0.0172630418,
-0.0014979223,
0.0232008453,
-0.0269669555,
0.0138424719,
-0.0202480145,
0.0237823706,
-0.0204194002,
0.0133768125,
0.0202083457,
-0.0046638926,
-0.0541649312,
0.0100680189,
-0.0313532166,
0.0016975168,
-0.0135410363,
0.0287218988,
0.0020344171,
-0.0565683432,
0.0004663533,
0.0110851247,
-0.034125071,
-0.0470321216,
0.0277291555,
0.06485641,
-0.0070846025,
-0.022497654,
-0.0261352938,
-0.0050377911,
-0.0269842707,
-0.0632746741,
0.0004557009,
-0.0385331362,
-0.0061363736,
0.0264725965,
0.0124000171,
-0.0250783768,
-0.0272481348,
-0.0102532497,
-0.0132468399,
0.0512605309,
0.0298038963,
0.0036603892,
0.0145126926,
-0.0162184462,
-0.0715913698,
0.1066163853,
0.0084957341,
0.0430277027,
0.0360105708,
0.0030592699,
-0.0008799218,
0.0353371277,
-0.0006371989,
-0.0011731751,
-0.0316605829,
0.0106474431,
0.0562698394,
0.0110992314,
-0.0125068547,
0.0068756244,
-0.0052200453,
0.005642816,
0.0477462597,
0.0863508061,
0.0148242787,
0.0196545571,
0.0274173319,
-0.0152455568,
-0.0172110014,
-0.026673995,
-0.0556623898,
-0.0068025766,
-0.0015943638,
0.0008350244,
0.0126026869,
0.0449175537,
-0.038255576,
-0.0305787362,
-0.0214085076,
0.0023181515,
0.0008878222,
0.0363138057,
0.0983870327,
-0.0284429919,
-0.0367310531,
0.0464034416,
0.0026000207,
-0.0004172248,
0.0028009759,
-0.0805418193,
0.0221495554,
-0.0005481649,
0.0349950194,
-0.0529209338,
-0.0213180874,
0.006319013,
-0.0165306255,
-0.0127710523,
0.049828887,
-0.0109781548,
0.0433791168,
-0.0209879335,
-0.0330414325,
-0.007375434,
0.0191888679,
0.005874149,
0.0332400724,
0.0039011755,
-0.0067659705,
-0.072574012,
-0.0559941418,
0.0375628062,
-0.0622483157,
-0.0108595053,
0.0231632367,
-0.0056497413,
0.058505021,
-0.0100061726,
-0.006758126,
0.0056149759,
0.0566158593,
-0.0428160504,
0.0014213696,
0.0061902874,
-0.0179104581,
-0.0193385892,
0.0037112613,
-0.0052347262,
0.0122045483,
0.0542127416,
-0.0286844298,
-0.0536978655,
0.0456425436,
0.0023921127,
0.0387812518,
0.001676993,
0.0401987359,
-0.0462775454,
-0.0173188802,
-0.0558312796,
0.0499043576,
0.0144598605,
0.0468851887,
-0.0158186276,
0.0165295545,
0.0055024475,
-0.0349130481,
-0.0549674816,
0.0397120975,
-0.0258927699,
0.0296855792,
0.033706367,
-0.0170831978,
-0.0336730741,
-0.0366384499,
-0.0811335221,
0.024344869,
-0.0405793898,
0.0153009677,
0.0208031498,
-0.0183728058,
0.0150312772,
-0.0161802042,
-0.0255633667,
-0.0138553679,
0.0167799611,
0.0379255973,
0.0157740768,
0.0296085551,
-0.0323058851,
-0.019320881,
-0.0409072861,
-0.0026392292,
0.0698985085,
-0.0114584072,
0.0031858371,
-0.060038466,
0.061193835,
-0.0016207499,
0.0230758525,
-0.0420371182,
0.0258163959,
0.0341602378,
-0.0155062322,
0.0054642754,
0.0789432079,
-0.0389642902,
0.0113685038,
0.0521912873,
0.0247758143,
-0.0666444749,
0.0037379991,
-0.0083559295,
-0.0485234596,
-0.0481830984,
-0.0272591654,
0.0247041099,
0.0646450892,
0.0032239072,
-0.0282323882,
-0.0428279601,
-0.0134742735,
-0.0424976014,
-0.0372597501,
-0.0296817068,
0.016752556,
-0.0125223817,
0.0428807996,
-0.0394232236,
-0.0859436765,
0.0468540043,
-0.0013062288,
-0.0033475661,
-0.0555436313,
-0.0452959277,
-0.0681721494,
0.0845832974,
-0.005562244,
-0.0017682895,
-0.0240113791,
-0.021375237,
-0.0501124188,
0.0141807999,
-0.0151134282,
-0.0190487187,
0.0627209768,
-0.04970688,
0.0252236556,
-0.0119514856,
-0.0681950971,
-0.0290923864,
-0.0108095463,
-0.0214327611,
0.0138998069,
0.0745965168,
0.0027721731,
-0.0400772281,
0.0163120627,
-0.0076198829,
0.0464520417,
-0.0204076376,
-0.0112201488,
0.0023422989,
-0.0355362594,
0.028783951,
0.0188495088,
0.0280393641,
-0.045768369,
0.0001480339,
0.0252611917,
0.096671775,
-0.0099295462,
-0.0595556162,
0.0194683336,
0.0371079072,
-0.0335827358,
-0.0437576659,
0.0426378064,
0.0583599992,
-0.0508876257,
-0.0328727625,
0.0885062888,
0.0013876954,
-0.0451436713,
0.0072125057,
0.0350095741,
0.0068646665,
0.0517458431,
0.0336050764,
-0.0272425748,
0.0057588415,
0.0031838659,
0.0159887653,
-0.008316963,
-0.046608042,
-0.0103775281,
-0.1303266883,
0.0334223248,
-0.0093661789,
-0.0434609912,
0.01757643,
-0.044529859,
0.0025926125,
-0.0753442049,
0.0171168949,
-0.0038351852,
-0.014726745,
-0.0143968398,
0.0345503688,
-0.0329290852,
-0.0606832355,
0.0354914293,
-0.0371123888,
0.0540079363,
0.0227711387,
0.0081890468,
-0.0142145241,
0.0273311492,
0.0294006038,
-0.0068406076,
0.0282943361,
0.0076759425,
0.0542519912,
0.0127807101,
-0.0049635512,
0.0172453262,
0.0041597909,
-0.0270091426,
0.017635107,
0.038820114,
0.0849569812,
-0.017105123,
-0.0373163372,
0.0122617399,
-0.0542488545,
0.0104223872,
0.0858755931,
0.0074539669,
-0.0392384194,
-0.045725435,
-0.0171403941,
-0.0197697598,
-0.0272509195,
0.0187698901,
0.0205078088,
-0.0080108941,
0.0333052278,
-0.0145621439,
0.0227010529,
0.0665417388,
0.0595342033,
0.0058378754,
0.0546349399,
0.0105046062,
-0.0011653538,
-0.0433395728,
0.0420624241,
-0.0054405918,
0.0149104334,
-0.0814527646,
-0.0023336695,
0.0385569558,
-0.0246037096,
-0.018675914,
-0.0084441286,
-0.1096067727,
-0.0705466941,
-0.0162722524,
0.0527682528,
0.0328382216,
0.0285339914,
-0.004091721,
-0.084902823,
0.0471791215,
-0.0012301501,
-0.049256973,
0.0184231997,
0.0063966946,
-0.0364794806,
-0.0214995518,
0.0075500445,
-0.0589728914,
0.0236559566,
0.0415141433,
-0.0124882404,
-0.0177513063,
-0.0014798272,
-0.0227046087,
0.0283202585,
0.0742882341,
-0.0132797221,
-0.020745622,
-0.0279750135,
-0.0113930441,
0.0227568485,
0.0166995358,
-0.0440779552,
-0.0038953435,
0.0270779841,
0.0074521285,
0.0050048749,
0.0015482417,
0.024738526,
0.0420386568,
-0.0834017172,
0.0094581489,
0.0074377079,
0.0126428287,
0.0635118857,
0.0565857254,
-0.0241926685,
-0.0084565543,
-0.0060005914,
0.0479614027,
0.0210940652,
0.0178238694,
0.000077472,
0.0408323742,
-0.0138964895,
0.0135763669,
-0.0924130306,
-0.0794430524,
-0.00881558,
0.0203812551,
0.0497774594,
-0.0183826126,
0.0316370018,
-0.0257063285,
0.0002016721,
-0.0424940027,
0.0012533749,
0.002625057,
-0.0227375031,
0.0320596248,
0.0151787773,
-0.0527628846,
0.0130121,
0.0891785324,
0.0477794781,
0.0225060433,
0.0159468278,
0.0080897789,
-0.0438943431,
-0.0019447237,
0.0376218297,
0.0195546541,
-0.0162322838,
-0.0184466094,
-0.0482602641,
-0.0475893244,
0.0308286995,
-0.0294253137,
0.0150339464,
-0.0409113355,
-0.0019235292,
0.075393714,
-0.0044122939,
0.0141160749,
-0.0373880938,
-0.0339896083,
-0.0056799026,
-0.0205943175,
-0.0288052075,
-5.974494854e-33,
0.0166268814,
-0.0025990203,
0.012032168,
-0.0461061411,
0.0363713354,
0.0548293293,
-0.0209773406,
-0.0021253675,
-0.0153912613,
-0.0353031941,
-0.0447335616,
-0.0269498862,
0.007882948,
0.0237641558,
0.0488213152,
-0.005131599,
0.057110928,
-0.0156805236,
-0.0208095461,
0.0130865006,
0.024503747,
0.0319962576,
0.0467105061,
-0.0375651829,
0.0052476837,
0.007760141,
-0.0202749465,
0.0024387045,
-0.009226473,
0.0821218416,
-0.0085107507,
0.070969753,
0.0367906243,
-0.1115447134,
-0.0488074012,
-0.0688442886,
-0.0283037554,
-0.015109499,
-0.0032676598,
-0.0057694046,
-0.0202842988,
0.0235087778,
0.0509388633,
0.0153983133,
-0.0595869869,
-0.0175842308,
0.0217060652,
-0.0236444119,
-0.0445471108,
0.0058225472,
0.0000587026,
-0.0031865507,
0.0313408338,
0.022577079,
0.0333098397,
0.0168333557,
-0.014344776,
0.0251688436,
-0.0273350179,
-0.0026729912,
-0.0149953188,
0.0386216417,
0.0756691992,
0.0597850494,
0.0135912895,
0.0690999329,
0.0388349928,
0.0588988028,
0.0219614394,
-0.0598708875,
0.0500363149,
0.0826950744,
0.0335731693,
0.0227864515,
0.043155171,
0.007749964,
-0.0616397969,
0.0117705166,
0.0942678079,
-0.0140943965,
0.0649827272,
0.034412656,
-0.0586264022,
-0.0584940575,
-0.0356347151,
0.0192984249,
-0.0185481682,
0.0094067445,
0.0487906486,
0.0351913087,
0.0019127564,
0.0285136644,
0.0534611754,
-0.0646776482,
-0.0082955416,
0.0194965918,
-0.0172266569,
0.0265199151,
0.0121602062,
0.0360062271,
-0.0854097456,
-0.0524599068,
-0.0144999437,
0.0080376882,
0.0277099181,
-0.0117514068,
-0.0125877755,
0.0219294019,
-0.0562815815,
-0.0052210535,
-0.049725689,
0.0178679042,
0.0494800024,
0.0486900359,
0.0661404356,
-0.0201547891,
0.0109393029,
0.0577468537,
0.0082830153,
-0.0108948369,
0.0046853465,
0.010802906,
-0.0054958584,
-0.0101721985,
-0.0086808559,
-0.0256492067,
-0.0265545063,
0.0058392086,
0.061148338,
-0.0140806967,
-0.0367304981,
-0.0078743584,
2.493e-7,
0.0260909442,
0.0269884672,
-0.0157278106,
0.0060297446,
0.0141736008,
0.0384223089,
-0.0317230932,
0.0209254473,
-0.0077256034,
0.0052578892,
-0.0087885251,
-0.0061207861,
0.0732383803,
0.0237488374,
-0.082503587,
-0.0136008849,
-0.0569962375,
0.0426450484,
-0.057060428,
0.0129292775,
0.0004578523,
0.1005656272,
0.0267400891,
-0.0141173666,
-0.00907679,
-0.0660598278,
0.0256436635,
-0.0739294291,
-0.0047772923,
0.0257902164,
0.0212235916,
0.0353582539,
-0.0197229311,
0.037753731,
0.000459263,
0.0199136809,
-0.009979073,
0.036611516,
0.0105982777,
0.0014882218,
0.0225720629,
0.0014548483,
-0.0070920317,
-0.0658706352,
0.0594566315,
-0.0376414135,
-0.0399577059,
-0.0215509031,
0.0213387944,
-0.0224427506,
0.0158928093,
-0.0104066879,
0.0286284667,
0.0040231119,
-0.0100848665,
-0.0285244826,
-0.0310310703,
-0.0744914189,
-0.0230385493,
0.0220566746,
-0.0674921796,
-0.0616331808,
-0.0529211946,
0.0205262918,
0.0261791684,
-0.0784201175,
0.0004474805,
2.771663232e-34,
0.0188150238,
0.0031433064,
0.0178113449,
0.0132189328,
0.0368704535,
-0.0163286515,
-0.0401052237,
0.0098851528,
0.0014971455,
-0.0568714477,
-0.0111782737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14938v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14938v2 | Do LLMs Understand Social Knowledge? Evaluating the Sociability of Large Language Models with SocKET Benchmark | 2023-05-24T09:21:06 | 2023-12-07T23:13:50 | Minje Choi, Jiaxin Pei, Sagar Kumar, Chang Shu, David Jurgens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have been shown to perform well at a variety of
syntactic, discourse, and reasoning tasks. While LLMs are increasingly deployed
in many forms including conversational agents that interact with humans, we
lack a grounded benchmark to measure how well LLMs understand \textit{social}
language. Here, we introduce a new theory-driven benchmark, SocKET, that
contains 58 NLP tasks testing social knowledge which we group into five
categories: humor & sarcasm, offensiveness, sentiment & emotion, and
trustworthiness. In tests on the benchmark, we demonstrate that current models
attain only moderate performance but reveal significant potential for task
transfer among different types and categories of tasks, which were predicted
from theory. Through zero-shot evaluations, we show that pretrained models
already possess some innate but limited capabilities of social language
understanding and training on one category of tasks can improve zero-shot
testing on others. Our benchmark provides a systematic way to analyze model
performance on an important dimension of language and points to clear room for
improvement to build more socially-aware LLMs. The associated resources are
released at https://github.com/minjechoi/SOCKET. | [
0.0521986596,
0.0362550914,
-0.0363025405,
0.0625675619,
-0.0298043117,
0.026928775,
0.0098986616,
0.024454087,
0.0525569469,
-0.0562018566,
-0.0650831684,
-0.0245643929,
-0.0267115831,
0.025647793,
0.0382395722,
-0.0312846676,
0.0483695827,
0.0176798925,
0.0133829806,
-0.0290288012,
0.0032192899,
-0.0067761815,
-0.010478681,
0.0042049387,
-0.0027077086,
0.0193074252,
-0.0016160414,
0.0225293264,
0.0306307841,
-0.0191682316,
0.038789507,
0.0518440232,
0.0320664905,
0.0179046355,
0.0000016792,
-0.0605143309,
0.0270707831,
-0.0243270174,
-0.0193899199,
-0.0008712018,
0.0721748024,
-0.0171250515,
-0.0035681329,
0.0115489773,
-0.081889756,
0.0019450213,
0.0102863321,
0.0250528231,
0.0420692004,
0.0913374722,
-0.0087325796,
-0.0012902871,
-0.0161790736,
-0.0345375761,
-0.0027669393,
-0.0580781251,
0.0374335684,
0.006804388,
-0.0110732717,
0.0007321313,
-0.0255872291,
0.009610218,
-0.0003831433,
0.0104223937,
0.0540463626,
0.0240873974,
-0.0344681628,
-0.0166826844,
-0.0403465703,
0.0901782289,
0.0375081785,
-0.0095746722,
0.0058729025,
0.0139491297,
0.0286309272,
-0.012383692,
-0.039017532,
-0.0038695084,
0.0259481221,
0.003881857,
-0.0162280276,
0.0302939638,
0.0359350964,
0.0296679623,
0.0313828886,
0.0673910677,
-0.021088751,
0.005194148,
0.0268772244,
0.0228535291,
-0.0179331768,
-0.0493193679,
0.0016366596,
0.0466312841,
0.0031339533,
0.0342301354,
-0.0295024924,
0.0452933758,
0.0450903289,
-0.0307076704,
0.0004613217,
0.0232962165,
0.0137115261,
0.0605647266,
-0.0002431426,
0.0209075604,
-0.0161577649,
0.0233412869,
0.0132616721,
-0.0143751949,
-0.0694335103,
0.0077807046,
-0.0088001043,
0.0126812253,
-0.0182561185,
-0.021367969,
-0.0211372375,
0.02598981,
-0.0286610276,
0.0122649027,
0.0121252295,
0.0215416458,
-0.020289002,
-0.0035247242,
-0.0474695675,
0.025908906,
-0.0434561819,
0.0241852272,
-0.0099679418,
-0.0875367224,
-0.0124561759,
-0.0144369975,
0.0401662812,
-0.0381744653,
0.0230470505,
0.0486529022,
0.0143578742,
-0.0824023113,
-0.0034142302,
0.0161260087,
-0.0442303717,
-0.0955032557,
0.0200844742,
-0.033841528,
0.0621233396,
0.0138645181,
-0.0154352086,
-0.0390696898,
0.0135666588,
-0.007340678,
-0.0405640267,
0.0617419854,
-0.0114462543,
0.0196632482,
-0.0040016226,
0.0497655272,
-0.0155061511,
0.0450740494,
-0.0045433389,
0.0068420721,
0.0399818309,
-0.0137965409,
0.0145695871,
0.0278227329,
0.0185030941,
-0.0139144277,
0.02230216,
0.0069383634,
-0.022806922,
0.0164744817,
0.0373833627,
0.0593261048,
-0.0257211644,
-0.0562950931,
0.0778146535,
0.0576070957,
-0.0287462305,
0.0349515863,
0.0242744982,
0.0347096398,
0.0162169691,
-0.0225889161,
-0.0758524612,
0.0339055806,
-0.0441426411,
-0.0326695107,
-0.0392082259,
0.0029791605,
-0.0469540767,
-0.0075674183,
-0.0240524057,
-0.0344655178,
0.0773797035,
0.0066305283,
0.0156776421,
0.0149052814,
-0.0295395311,
0.0262700915,
0.0460302494,
-0.065294601,
-0.0122582307,
-0.0369093269,
0.019978961,
0.0418899842,
0.027432682,
-0.0241365284,
-0.0390192419,
0.0005021669,
0.008366283,
0.0429573059,
0.0724335983,
-0.0083472235,
0.0452365763,
-0.0167198665,
0.0341452174,
-0.0194000285,
0.0179874636,
0.0168797951,
0.0520504192,
0.0369191952,
-0.0144544728,
-0.0275225956,
0.0239522196,
0.0199357495,
-0.067286469,
0.0039846809,
-0.0453423485,
0.0056064702,
0.0570721179,
-0.0133985812,
-0.0034057626,
-0.0449499935,
0.0100067249,
-0.02008228,
-0.0389105938,
0.0481818058,
-0.0428110436,
-0.0475776568,
0.0432718694,
0.0112511627,
-0.0523089617,
0.074966073,
-0.0154563244,
-0.003403618,
0.0567577593,
-0.0260244329,
0.054792881,
-0.0312153157,
-0.0053751813,
-0.0436098352,
0.0366727859,
0.0292140972,
0.0543960631,
0.0092250668,
-0.0355577655,
-0.0275218543,
-0.0093495343,
-0.0300931092,
-0.0070215203,
-0.0343672968,
-0.0019645377,
0.0015077016,
-0.0180140566,
0.0025818704,
0.0119811296,
-0.0626970753,
-0.0605644286,
-0.1296906173,
-0.0094239451,
-0.0002223151,
0.0034611123,
0.0201940425,
-0.011775976,
-0.0058887727,
0.0089193117,
-0.0473303273,
0.0639542341,
0.0106131826,
0.0040534232,
0.0463824496,
-0.0302638188,
-0.027698623,
-0.0658153072,
0.0109653622,
-0.006047566,
0.0078759771,
-0.0018435861,
0.0047185551,
0.01270115,
0.0632247254,
-0.0747413337,
0.03928224,
-0.0317764543,
-0.0772131905,
0.0144804884,
0.0202165805,
0.0183954705,
0.0845998973,
0.0436303541,
0.0441734828,
0.0042281197,
-0.0150567666,
-0.0553683564,
0.0212338753,
-0.0311378185,
0.0226377062,
-0.0716399103,
-0.036617253,
-0.0383284725,
0.062377464,
-0.0061970172,
0.0036736154,
-0.0594247468,
-0.0066317525,
0.0222366098,
-0.0558945499,
-0.0077039232,
-0.0110522714,
-0.0096677542,
0.0072061005,
-0.046087157,
-0.030024847,
0.056082163,
-0.0141063146,
-0.0578837842,
-0.0023847604,
-0.0102210194,
-0.026760174,
0.1067312881,
-0.0026085638,
0.0084439619,
-0.0271761753,
-0.0021454608,
-0.0226783194,
-0.0360851213,
0.0104870433,
-0.028328035,
0.0078724977,
-0.01022973,
-0.0068224072,
0.0301801097,
-0.045318719,
-0.0233516358,
-0.0512401387,
-0.0716265291,
0.0024252511,
-0.0152456425,
-0.0325197317,
0.0218952633,
-0.0310008693,
0.0187304784,
-0.0335347243,
-0.0240002461,
-0.0197209269,
-0.0216897428,
-0.0051521738,
0.058054015,
0.030123882,
0.0385424607,
-0.0192875788,
0.0194346346,
0.0479726419,
0.0242063645,
-0.0045931758,
-0.0465569012,
-0.0053482912,
-0.0010766368,
0.0229052007,
-0.0087658111,
-0.011640395,
0.0942920148,
-0.0053756353,
-0.0156067945,
0.1104085818,
-0.0009812437,
0.0048355763,
0.0205022953,
0.0110882558,
-0.0101363873,
0.0365640298,
0.0030647689,
-0.063387759,
-0.0338448808,
0.0040831193,
-0.0106019117,
0.0044081425,
-0.0550333783,
-0.0217952076,
-0.1087749898,
0.0236688573,
-0.0100322356,
-0.0261431392,
-0.0018857919,
-0.0125229694,
0.0329144448,
-0.0111284349,
0.0218578279,
-0.0168187469,
0.0127009349,
-0.0376837105,
-0.0009939617,
-0.0221811756,
-0.0473283045,
0.0871934369,
-0.0532108508,
0.1224568635,
0.0081588477,
0.0960856751,
-0.0023815725,
-0.0190751515,
0.0115034832,
0.0099256067,
-0.0035184447,
-0.0226708874,
0.0652506575,
-0.0362095572,
0.008709373,
0.0077381353,
0.0138096446,
-0.0574492589,
0.0088277068,
-0.0199792087,
0.029569922,
-0.0016108433,
-0.0837769285,
0.0123188877,
0.0460241698,
0.0017402844,
0.0984753221,
0.0339764208,
-0.0092314631,
-0.0154029662,
0.0076617538,
-0.0439400449,
-0.0135712521,
-0.0270872284,
-0.0166940652,
0.0362632126,
-0.0435759984,
-0.0678169429,
-0.0452733822,
0.012324526,
0.0341209359,
-0.0047965217,
-0.0347510986,
0.0288677793,
0.0137093496,
-0.0107444916,
0.0056187916,
-0.0478006713,
0.0076726144,
0.0139281992,
0.0047482396,
0.0187216066,
-0.0494476035,
-0.0163856875,
-0.0273535401,
-0.0693340898,
-0.0711870044,
0.0354911834,
0.0577358156,
0.0273595788,
0.0184314344,
-0.0452061072,
-0.0526646338,
-0.0234171879,
0.0438099131,
-0.0557248294,
0.0926259011,
0.0321802385,
0.0203578528,
0.0227049161,
0.0551604182,
-0.020058617,
0.050722871,
0.0442661792,
-0.001170467,
-0.0226582512,
-0.0369713716,
-0.0333074704,
0.0174323861,
0.0249676332,
0.0413716435,
-0.0337130129,
-0.0046592033,
-0.0408398174,
-0.023734441,
-0.0094196098,
-0.0351099558,
-0.0378154889,
0.010308818,
0.0327752382,
-0.0306698047,
-0.0324286558,
-0.0309151914,
0.0609581769,
-0.0147306193,
-0.022007674,
0.0478923954,
-0.0126963891,
-0.004804695,
0.0270335339,
-0.0243643578,
0.0036849831,
-0.0132676233,
0.0208196044,
0.0136253927,
0.0417595133,
0.0045370017,
-0.0408227853,
0.0083808629,
0.0266857427,
-0.0604025237,
-0.0207330026,
0.0396022424,
0.0484537743,
0.0324962214,
0.0080468366,
0.0571518876,
-0.0487612784,
0.0228680484,
-0.0036250423,
0.0307054054,
-0.0378371924,
-0.052895464,
0.0412620902,
0.0151771512,
-0.0361706242,
0.0323110707,
0.0319149904,
-0.0272510778,
0.0271671526,
0.0217887107,
-0.0022422166,
-0.0271937363,
-0.0192381386,
0.0337046757,
-0.0061375792,
-0.0077399882,
0.0312752947,
-0.0580852069,
-0.0665498376,
0.0247784387,
-0.0085367393,
-0.0019814186,
-0.0239091609,
0.0231283903,
0.0884299278,
-0.0038426011,
0.0054425439,
-0.028424928,
0.0187082738,
-0.0468079746,
0.0113231512,
-0.003832744,
-5.966111742e-33,
-0.0154368877,
-0.0035963003,
-0.0113322036,
0.0197438095,
-0.0134620797,
0.0076900874,
-0.0809732303,
0.0209824387,
-0.04170724,
0.0116206082,
-0.0309134778,
0.062094029,
-0.003769086,
-0.0227680281,
-0.0361410864,
-0.0387276411,
0.0281245504,
-0.0196668953,
-0.0194716174,
0.0125508998,
0.0109212231,
0.0229415838,
0.0527649261,
-0.0668090656,
0.0269803889,
-0.0043723905,
-0.015524447,
0.025138827,
0.017853003,
0.023036262,
-0.0138175962,
0.0415517949,
0.0342512019,
0.0181548633,
0.0136381611,
0.0231257658,
-0.0513572544,
-0.021295527,
0.0108595183,
-0.0140270162,
-0.0655821189,
-0.0089288559,
0.04669673,
-0.0180752128,
-0.0499486104,
-0.0012307178,
0.0057485136,
0.0021423555,
0.0374199264,
0.0030885045,
-0.0549797118,
-0.0197871495,
-0.0084723635,
-0.0263975449,
-0.0233985595,
0.0162395164,
0.0021206061,
0.0241060369,
-0.0434953272,
0.0289187599,
-0.0654909611,
-0.0273230895,
0.0248962156,
-0.047042422,
0.0273590088,
0.0958065093,
0.0155997481,
0.0677837804,
0.0049021337,
-0.0247974414,
0.0633993521,
0.0546844453,
0.0350251533,
0.0903034881,
-0.0158411991,
-0.0346562676,
-0.0222869646,
-0.0065693692,
0.0877857879,
0.0020920611,
0.0173836127,
-0.0008208785,
-0.0514812171,
0.0141407037,
-0.0237219296,
0.0069295303,
-0.0158380046,
-0.0429532453,
0.024766406,
0.0174201354,
-0.0210291743,
-0.0091209291,
0.0249929037,
-0.0530001707,
0.0061695222,
0.0371723846,
-0.020956682,
0.0296484642,
0.0100725172,
0.0178231541,
-0.0556689128,
-0.0359945707,
0.0094077997,
0.0284252632,
0.0096267564,
0.0012416104,
0.0390506871,
0.0366398394,
-0.0231481027,
-0.0064841933,
-0.035057202,
0.0453244075,
-0.0170614813,
0.0305380896,
-0.0018525586,
0.0535070859,
-0.0286590289,
0.0116416467,
0.0068480526,
-0.0037702955,
-0.0462945178,
0.0115970988,
-0.0009992592,
0.008493769,
-0.0443748645,
-0.0528730638,
-0.0415859669,
-0.0337907895,
0.0045654681,
-0.0148950247,
-0.0000694556,
-0.0253887735,
2.523e-7,
0.0063414192,
0.0659643933,
-0.0049397899,
0.0226752926,
0.0489936508,
0.0404191762,
-0.0248602573,
0.0776048228,
0.0112238433,
-0.0553012863,
0.0163996257,
0.0780474693,
0.0593689717,
0.0215982273,
-0.061053589,
-0.027971074,
-0.0703374147,
-0.0243971255,
0.0206086263,
-0.0415067859,
-0.0160700139,
0.0594829991,
0.0581935421,
-0.010894903,
-0.0005098635,
-0.0623532012,
0.0573450513,
-0.0572365113,
0.0046285386,
0.0044941264,
-0.0078488197,
0.0016512608,
-0.0004240892,
0.0332393758,
0.0202326141,
0.010035878,
-0.045951318,
0.0846291855,
-0.0134519814,
-0.0302834455,
-0.0058472441,
-0.0010189727,
-0.0118081393,
-0.0467805676,
0.0468264744,
-0.0509727113,
-0.046218738,
-0.0184011087,
0.002596491,
-0.0253185984,
0.0072181891,
0.019181272,
-0.0188543443,
0.0090068076,
0.0238157921,
-0.0280173346,
-0.016706327,
-0.0689299032,
0.0081004323,
-0.0232161228,
-0.0460188985,
-0.0815160647,
-0.0065259291,
-0.0072537595,
0.0185446665,
-0.0545887724,
0.0169126112,
1.767815393e-34,
0.0170252137,
0.0032271196,
0.0100292098,
0.0046635196,
0.05529828,
0.0145804007,
-0.0530759916,
-0.0100512281,
0.0568521284,
-0.0490115806,
0.0276631843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14937v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14937v2 | A Fair and In-Depth Evaluation of Existing End-to-End Entity Linking Systems | 2023-05-24T09:20:15 | 2023-11-17T15:28:00 | Hannah Bast, Matthias Hertel, Natalie Prange | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing evaluations of entity linking systems often say little about how the
system is going to perform for a particular application. There are two
fundamental reasons for this. One is that many evaluations only use aggregate
measures (like precision, recall, and F1 score), without a detailed error
analysis or a closer look at the results. The other is that all of the widely
used benchmarks have strong biases and artifacts, in particular: a strong focus
on named entities, an unclear or missing specification of what else counts as
an entity mention, poor handling of ambiguities, and an over- or
underrepresentation of certain kinds of entities.
We provide a more meaningful and fair in-depth evaluation of a variety of
existing end-to-end entity linkers. We characterize their strengths and
weaknesses and also report on reproducibility aspects. The detailed results of
our evaluation can be inspected under
https://elevant.cs.uni-freiburg.de/emnlp2023 . Our evaluation is based on
several widely used benchmarks, which exhibit the problems mentioned above to
various degrees, as well as on two new benchmarks, which address the problems
mentioned above. The new benchmarks can be found under
https://github.com/ad-freiburg/fair-entity-linking-benchmarks . | [
0.0309452005,
0.0070549021,
-0.006613736,
0.0060787844,
0.0016222069,
0.0428163894,
0.0075511029,
0.0057752091,
0.0361618251,
-0.0265273619,
-0.0010257899,
0.0204222538,
0.0003357487,
-0.0241659898,
0.0325117968,
-0.0248693284,
0.0311377179,
0.0442203358,
-0.039926637,
-0.0009048486,
-0.0018782289,
0.0105880545,
-0.0049867984,
0.0144855008,
-0.0313918479,
0.0445359871,
-0.0103909615,
0.0367317982,
0.0561145097,
-0.0202715136,
-0.0376499146,
0.0131993825,
-0.055200696,
0.0713304132,
0.0000018653,
-0.0726718232,
-0.0463592708,
0.042084571,
-0.0630136728,
0.0246518869,
-0.0139735471,
-0.0267199874,
-0.0123008182,
-0.0249850694,
0.0159868877,
-0.0245042816,
0.0291435495,
0.0257762615,
0.050545644,
0.0289426781,
-0.0140707185,
-0.0495981835,
0.0395687968,
-0.0016005471,
-0.0009814056,
-0.0360056274,
0.0162123833,
0.0187406242,
0.0181117821,
-0.0095138345,
0.0173820984,
0.0717038363,
-0.003432557,
0.0165491104,
0.0047039329,
0.0053484822,
-0.0437082723,
0.008500075,
0.0184095241,
0.0820609927,
0.0251910277,
-0.0060170679,
0.0269531906,
0.0195960086,
0.016474301,
-0.0022437684,
-0.0471442044,
-0.0109481942,
-0.0151242437,
-0.0079180477,
-0.0274026692,
0.0239633061,
0.0374322608,
-0.0031118763,
-0.0015190538,
-0.0016758876,
0.0130223799,
-0.0230534617,
0.0218408313,
0.0445579737,
-0.002539393,
-0.0589263365,
0.0476559959,
0.0119234081,
-0.0269452818,
0.0075878007,
-0.0463111177,
-0.0313774124,
0.0281138178,
-0.0412207283,
-0.0245565064,
0.0108980983,
0.0293434784,
0.030624846,
-0.063630335,
0.0211341064,
-0.0071228724,
-0.0022608112,
0.0487607233,
-0.0669002235,
-0.0329028741,
0.0223743673,
-0.0275061969,
0.0550779738,
-0.0434633307,
0.0047202371,
-0.0731472075,
-0.0178498011,
-0.0305830128,
0.1038104147,
0.0035734912,
-0.0360213481,
0.031978853,
-0.0023997284,
-0.0736600012,
-0.0135527477,
-0.0417001396,
-0.0323523544,
-0.010047337,
-0.0277016051,
0.0248036776,
-0.024967365,
-0.0111831008,
-0.0260429233,
0.0155816954,
0.0689065158,
0.0578213409,
-0.0155824581,
-0.0488722399,
-0.0597285889,
0.0348941162,
-0.0410930589,
-0.0620921738,
-0.046463415,
0.029973235,
0.0603965893,
-0.0172199402,
-0.0644277856,
-0.0071304883,
-0.003244654,
-0.0620278642,
0.0711911097,
-0.0512377881,
-0.0059836335,
0.0245787054,
0.0251711868,
0.0235183053,
0.0122817624,
0.0498208255,
-0.0126052741,
0.0460357629,
0.0533603095,
-0.0262164939,
0.009708182,
0.0401426256,
-0.0200239047,
0.0395327955,
0.0409214571,
-0.0171627048,
0.0516299941,
-0.0042479783,
0.0972224995,
-0.0212837476,
-0.061606098,
0.0338374488,
-0.0062379404,
0.044827193,
0.0105109466,
0.0409372821,
0.0022982862,
0.0274130367,
-0.0478220992,
-0.0515225381,
0.0481419712,
0.0026516423,
-0.0189369675,
0.0507875681,
0.0247077346,
-0.0229065008,
0.0146475071,
0.0143056167,
-0.004022738,
-0.0290708467,
0.0226855054,
0.0125338053,
0.00412243,
-0.0182519797,
0.1028628871,
-0.0030859017,
-0.0397248119,
-0.0090513341,
-0.0059709493,
-0.0470819138,
0.0536759198,
0.0458504073,
0.017359931,
-0.0230841227,
-0.0146778123,
-0.013779751,
0.009605282,
0.0389487445,
-0.0436163358,
0.0172837991,
-0.0218740925,
-0.0108707827,
0.0646785721,
-0.0136190765,
0.0068064048,
0.0325825736,
0.0714707971,
0.0271858703,
-0.0650410354,
0.00997453,
0.0161929168,
0.0000974874,
0.0402075537,
-0.0432900004,
0.0346091166,
-0.0424762964,
0.0606572255,
0.0154405236,
-0.0139661497,
0.0307759438,
0.0153958509,
-0.0024314078,
-0.0104872901,
0.0507262759,
0.0210134052,
0.0301067755,
-0.0331609547,
-0.0197273828,
-0.0091766939,
0.001433167,
-0.046148289,
-0.0339106619,
0.0003798072,
0.020457264,
0.0080596758,
0.0544646382,
0.0052323192,
-0.015172041,
-0.0273923483,
0.0446422026,
0.013885838,
0.0346807763,
0.0138321593,
0.0199932177,
0.031347055,
-0.0539469272,
-0.0381721593,
0.0027900038,
0.0058302768,
-0.007911833,
-0.0315884762,
-0.0747217312,
-0.0937194675,
-0.0022051451,
-0.0414646603,
0.0504682809,
0.009535349,
0.0391383953,
-0.0301738791,
0.0184466708,
-0.0024772014,
-0.0056143315,
-0.0105082318,
-0.0314756632,
-0.0167349782,
0.0096741021,
0.0257559475,
0.0479938015,
-0.0130645465,
-0.0411247611,
-0.0126729198,
-0.0253149755,
0.0351803564,
0.0349922553,
-0.0561194532,
-0.0494391508,
0.0151847219,
-0.0594906844,
-0.0085610235,
0.0023349589,
0.0403635502,
-0.0005463534,
0.0372943617,
0.0248788241,
0.0187623501,
-0.0460121036,
-0.0129903331,
-0.0077090519,
-0.0127422558,
-0.0861609429,
0.0014321513,
0.0311389565,
0.0441131219,
-0.0075197071,
0.0080666225,
0.0103239659,
-0.0227056127,
-0.0399169065,
-0.020794712,
-0.0329456031,
0.0227913838,
0.0231217183,
0.0401223414,
-0.0247349273,
0.0022148539,
0.0184727386,
0.0113692963,
-0.0011492182,
0.0131941531,
0.0036539317,
-0.0212378632,
0.0332917795,
0.0249884874,
0.0134920264,
-0.0226987675,
0.0278151762,
-0.0037954005,
0.0030572461,
-0.006349049,
-0.0331545249,
-0.0260088705,
0.0838526413,
0.0404695906,
-0.0347307138,
0.0699364915,
0.0119147524,
0.0510729589,
-0.0173832681,
-0.0211296584,
-0.0140501121,
0.0207987595,
-0.051416155,
0.0307551809,
0.0067005721,
-0.035276439,
-0.0133977253,
0.0272271633,
0.0235579312,
0.0099956095,
0.0332177505,
-0.0606965944,
0.0170079991,
-0.0192523431,
-0.0035574138,
-0.0284622498,
0.0788948238,
0.0150606697,
0.002239476,
0.0384261385,
0.0436704792,
-0.0236790404,
0.0280526057,
-0.0225252062,
-0.0041893022,
-0.0889490098,
-0.0407181866,
0.0172012765,
0.027847141,
-0.0652431473,
0.0131756673,
0.0879302621,
0.041716788,
-0.0259339511,
-0.0248982105,
0.0313853323,
-0.0029678494,
0.0191866532,
0.0074712746,
-0.0938128829,
-0.0276587047,
0.0021232229,
0.000464551,
-0.0069508967,
-0.1182390451,
0.0190087464,
-0.0925461575,
-0.0212573502,
-0.0385037698,
-0.0635560676,
-0.0514896885,
-0.0694730282,
0.0072715255,
-0.017916264,
-0.0244337395,
0.0139236478,
-0.0131541947,
0.0243702233,
-0.0125357164,
-0.0205661524,
-0.0032899091,
0.0036007245,
-0.122495383,
0.074055776,
0.0375017747,
0.0443014055,
0.0368378237,
-0.0184070263,
-0.0122095263,
-0.0585543141,
-0.0707370192,
-0.0025983972,
0.1030758843,
-0.0417391583,
0.0039277622,
-0.0306651574,
-0.0280558094,
0.0327239819,
0.0421423987,
-0.0315182097,
0.0301700346,
0.0269598719,
0.0446190052,
-0.001728031,
-0.0129130725,
-0.0021028791,
0.0735891089,
0.0058940584,
-0.0046900823,
-0.0098078223,
-0.0434943363,
0.0285587106,
-0.0280887336,
-0.0065418319,
0.0640756413,
-0.0711971,
-0.0242097285,
-0.0586428605,
-0.0650125891,
0.0335478373,
0.0575011857,
-0.0069535165,
0.0218239836,
-0.0004048626,
-0.0079567712,
-0.0459648669,
-0.0129385293,
-0.0381361395,
0.040848922,
-0.0309404358,
0.0246685315,
0.01657537,
0.031644851,
-0.01501677,
0.0152115598,
-0.0553439707,
-0.0392088667,
-0.002904084,
0.0136680659,
0.0246207956,
0.0152762961,
-0.0058137868,
-0.0352384299,
-0.0301905461,
0.0314238928,
-0.0123123098,
-0.0265591927,
-0.0044424408,
0.018722672,
-0.0092323972,
0.0406393223,
-0.0753761679,
-0.0191202257,
0.0080325864,
0.0259734951,
-0.0280124992,
-0.0340005867,
-0.0248060338,
0.0610255301,
-0.0032115211,
-0.0073742769,
-0.0096448166,
0.028844744,
0.0446091481,
-0.0270266552,
0.000474687,
-0.0030966604,
-0.0008417997,
0.0237013698,
0.0599494204,
-0.0175879151,
0.0370047092,
0.0298270732,
0.0106262024,
-0.0499237068,
0.0137737412,
-0.0242356993,
0.0201088488,
0.0186064262,
-0.0387519188,
-0.0116790906,
-0.0181607269,
0.0816658586,
0.0823538378,
-0.0370003805,
-0.025157053,
0.0438316837,
0.0181519482,
0.0005207047,
0.0248805769,
-0.0300262198,
0.013125998,
0.0184352752,
0.0174359865,
0.0488206781,
0.0505487397,
0.0961751789,
-0.0187846534,
-0.0187127572,
0.0253991336,
0.0056066778,
0.0181652587,
-0.0199699216,
0.0036000814,
-0.0020403955,
0.0027790356,
0.0487105288,
0.0012633216,
-0.0496935286,
0.0545834005,
-0.0272892416,
-0.0271724518,
-0.0325193554,
-0.0216358639,
-0.01581957,
-0.0383641757,
-0.0218009688,
-0.0834065452,
-0.0757338181,
-0.0431604125,
0.0528687686,
0.0105630904,
-0.007394833,
-0.0093679642,
0.0262012389,
-0.0370520912,
0.0766476169,
-0.0350383557,
0.0075252326,
-0.0429906994,
-0.0180861522,
-0.0505672619,
-0.0027110972,
-5.504522661e-33,
-0.0564405993,
-0.0060523096,
-0.0047802329,
-0.0306733754,
-0.0260002166,
-0.004159058,
-0.0005802842,
-0.0265610293,
-0.0564338043,
-0.0154826557,
-0.0082537942,
0.0290651098,
0.026112752,
-0.0144481771,
-0.0180254541,
-0.0464074686,
0.0320564248,
0.0337750912,
-0.0301506352,
-0.0128237437,
0.0425585993,
0.007445531,
0.0283252504,
-0.0641982704,
0.0539382175,
0.0084473714,
-0.0163041186,
0.0136131234,
0.0361847393,
0.0739447325,
0.0516813062,
0.0029578181,
-0.0133867729,
-0.0348217785,
0.0053357496,
-0.0280332826,
-0.1511665434,
0.0003053625,
-0.0185438152,
0.0350096859,
0.0358069427,
-0.0133768674,
0.0619649962,
0.001848141,
0.0124078132,
-0.010310648,
0.0085933981,
-0.0033706196,
-0.0377479754,
-0.0508180298,
-0.0224944204,
0.0339693204,
0.0173260961,
0.0639577135,
0.0312130228,
-0.0229819547,
0.0136808772,
-0.0072166761,
-0.0884639621,
-0.029699007,
0.000005732,
-0.0337944999,
0.0041061826,
-0.0372814499,
0.0279592872,
0.0512495004,
0.0437709987,
0.015385,
-0.0281021502,
0.0644040927,
0.019977143,
-0.0104231909,
0.0342851803,
0.0696257204,
0.0176417325,
-0.0005736735,
-0.0784444809,
0.0667466596,
0.0018525854,
-0.0030122183,
-0.0482128076,
-0.0096634477,
-0.0764489919,
-0.0172597002,
-0.0402498581,
0.0153080197,
-0.0060306885,
-0.0430840477,
0.0233213846,
-0.0232268926,
-0.0263646599,
0.0452339053,
-0.0121773742,
-0.0323703513,
-0.0599616244,
0.0024236301,
0.0238671433,
0.0260433946,
-0.015302131,
-0.0253227688,
-0.0284995716,
-0.0049114092,
0.0292330645,
0.0121182622,
0.0279644653,
-0.0065558045,
0.0404722355,
-0.0360609554,
-0.085413307,
0.0186217874,
0.0256992728,
0.0128459102,
-0.0496852286,
-0.0501375347,
-0.0012532361,
-0.004659879,
0.0174730308,
-0.0350017473,
0.0538968444,
-0.0054856106,
-0.0085350769,
0.0336000063,
0.0300610401,
-0.0093380688,
-0.0010812617,
0.0373340026,
-0.0263143629,
0.0258380789,
0.0236547347,
-0.0662357956,
-0.0066241208,
-0.0028013748,
2.483e-7,
0.0635350719,
0.0088553447,
0.0180342458,
0.0398406237,
-0.0280310437,
-0.0128527591,
0.0757620335,
0.0273972917,
0.0063656154,
0.0221654661,
-0.0230942313,
-0.0170314573,
0.0211921744,
0.0481747873,
-0.0754072666,
-0.0576585233,
0.0084409891,
-0.0106098382,
-0.0357167423,
0.0060300888,
0.0239910986,
0.0091797998,
0.0286600739,
0.0179082379,
-0.0179861337,
-0.0158505999,
0.0204626936,
-0.0141779575,
0.0240619592,
0.0100459326,
0.0435526781,
-0.000169311,
-0.0016003661,
0.0562727042,
-0.0041538575,
0.0127295163,
0.0456858985,
0.0191034097,
0.0062573953,
0.0009920569,
-0.0148904258,
-0.1182562485,
0.0002269041,
0.0170211848,
0.0473017953,
-0.0010951572,
-0.0044612936,
0.0869504511,
-0.0399090685,
-0.0075242766,
-0.0041014506,
0.0435992964,
-0.0344614498,
0.0108296042,
0.017996924,
-0.0064799958,
0.0150319804,
-0.0810867697,
-0.0130793778,
0.031390775,
0.0486873128,
-0.0573904067,
0.0206723381,
-0.0352724604,
-0.014808313,
-0.0367019698,
-0.0445583239,
2.052117656e-34,
-0.0456587635,
-0.0043011862,
0.0228262637,
-0.0022263823,
0.0494438782,
-0.0253825616,
-0.0327447653,
-0.0170492884,
-0.0075069088,
-0.0158705618,
-0.0012178255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14936v1 | Trade-Offs Between Fairness and Privacy in Language Modeling | 2023-05-24T09:18:28 | 2023-05-24T09:18:28 | Cleo Matzken, Steffen Eger, Ivan Habernal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Protecting privacy in contemporary NLP models is gaining in importance. So
does the need to mitigate social biases of such models. But can we have both at
the same time? Existing research suggests that privacy preservation comes at
the price of worsening biases in classification tasks. In this paper, we
explore the extent to which this tradeoff really holds when we incorporate both
privacy preservation and de-biasing techniques into training text generation
models. How does improving the model along one dimension affect the other
dimension as well as the utility of the model? We conduct an extensive set of
experiments that include bias detection, privacy attacks, language modeling,
and performance on downstream tasks. | [
0.0416673012,
0.1152876765,
-0.0361868553,
0.0394930393,
-0.03850789,
0.0000902621,
0.1024896801,
-0.0198618323,
0.0192748606,
-0.0514392667,
-0.0206165984,
-0.0529766865,
0.0172123108,
-0.0015632974,
0.023636153,
-0.014662873,
0.0293568838,
0.0038391659,
0.0107537471,
-0.0368572585,
0.0096961707,
0.0117317243,
0.0235241707,
0.0334295183,
0.0023591768,
0.0337294899,
0.0245716795,
0.0106386319,
0.0086362986,
-0.0052642925,
0.019180635,
0.0873256773,
-0.0081332624,
0.0636197627,
0.0000015683,
-0.0639716238,
-0.0173284877,
0.0375310518,
-0.0140751814,
0.0309161749,
0.050528165,
-0.0368751958,
0.0352563374,
0.0515849441,
-0.0463339835,
0.0192159433,
0.0256046876,
0.0250736233,
0.0129381269,
0.0627614632,
-0.0068924641,
-0.0106729586,
-0.0015914678,
-0.0699867532,
0.01221924,
-0.0217799656,
0.0201523192,
-0.0724742487,
-0.0594494417,
0.0026446958,
0.0143618416,
0.020893259,
0.0012153528,
0.017808985,
0.0167740695,
0.0441661328,
0.0190973971,
-0.0464503057,
-0.0006434636,
0.0287293885,
0.015306076,
-0.0378554091,
0.0495759957,
0.0069042314,
0.048170045,
0.0130894864,
-0.0027824088,
0.0743950531,
-0.0257195923,
0.0127985794,
0.0512423627,
-0.0080340533,
0.0307250004,
0.0483551808,
0.0352236517,
0.0327171013,
0.0109481597,
-0.0074409363,
-0.0381890684,
0.0244601257,
0.0067253974,
-0.0637203082,
0.0749773085,
-0.0187870171,
0.0276844893,
0.0004549403,
-0.091137059,
-0.0294226166,
0.0309782587,
-0.0496035591,
-0.0101147583,
0.0120869307,
0.0462771095,
-0.0195692852,
-0.0178626589,
0.0119798006,
0.014662955,
0.0369612128,
0.0084846038,
0.0309638362,
0.0088910116,
-0.0082168411,
-0.029055275,
0.0354407765,
-0.0688503385,
0.0150514375,
-0.0306278951,
0.0012339726,
-0.0247466266,
-0.0087709576,
-0.002541176,
0.0246075895,
-0.0443680771,
0.0094255675,
0.0045631249,
-0.0690237433,
-0.0147176916,
0.005282368,
-0.0014496382,
-0.0434438623,
-0.0249268617,
-0.0228683203,
0.0035450915,
-0.0185220502,
-0.0366429463,
0.0564535186,
0.0047959629,
-0.038171798,
-0.0172733329,
-0.1075789407,
-0.0030012035,
-0.01686172,
-0.0180401653,
-0.0261938814,
0.0288417991,
-0.0068084057,
-0.0108979372,
-0.0668443888,
-0.0086580943,
0.0163488779,
-0.0420462266,
0.0382481143,
0.0235641636,
-0.0040319944,
0.0486510396,
0.0354894213,
0.0223526862,
0.0506798252,
0.0221791826,
-0.0012185635,
0.0498666652,
-0.0110173738,
0.041641932,
0.0014969858,
0.0616735257,
0.0046546352,
-0.0041889562,
-0.0014126623,
-0.0192368757,
-0.018022811,
0.0387365744,
0.0541067719,
-0.0181386452,
-0.0655882955,
0.079228051,
0.0345630981,
-0.0030008862,
0.0226014182,
-0.0459683053,
0.0268702004,
-0.0606352277,
0.0193718895,
-0.0578726418,
-0.0134435259,
-0.0549893416,
-0.0322999768,
0.0205111094,
0.0258714426,
-0.0227833856,
-0.0027966185,
0.0148989605,
-0.0293631759,
0.0587061979,
0.0219548363,
-0.0316876993,
0.0116671752,
0.0136601822,
0.0554954,
0.0161995478,
-0.0535892397,
0.0486930422,
-0.053519167,
0.029017482,
0.0389130414,
0.0401015468,
0.0075091645,
0.0420763828,
-0.0439180434,
-0.0488965698,
0.055494938,
0.0540896058,
-0.0147004435,
0.0485190861,
-0.0548390038,
-0.0298962388,
0.0211718548,
0.0413742214,
0.0233701989,
0.0254917759,
0.0034712136,
0.0651071668,
-0.0318008102,
-0.0161867943,
0.0391581692,
0.0029967036,
-0.0495881177,
0.0348510779,
0.0080691911,
0.0106000099,
0.0229670573,
-0.0201354306,
0.0205141008,
-0.0265996177,
0.0112325996,
-0.0070137307,
0.003696156,
-0.0334268324,
-0.0457784869,
-0.0399845392,
0.0023687999,
0.0483147912,
0.0637538061,
-0.0023129932,
-0.0176925939,
0.025977632,
-0.0169785004,
0.028899407,
-0.0238852389,
0.0266404878,
-0.0134999538,
0.0364230461,
-0.0725750253,
0.0190010872,
-0.0391443297,
-0.0129330829,
-0.0428793654,
-0.0514942855,
0.0086847348,
-0.0441739522,
-0.0055015357,
-0.003997202,
-0.0350938104,
0.0280264765,
0.0732164234,
-0.0087507423,
-0.0057192957,
-0.0182254538,
-0.0140418326,
0.0182608776,
-0.0259346142,
0.0280408785,
0.0287118759,
0.0286181793,
0.0022765882,
-0.0144937243,
-0.0643444285,
-0.05964531,
-0.0062686596,
0.0420870893,
0.0158392899,
-0.0043354272,
-0.0156223783,
-0.0155533962,
-0.0312090106,
0.0033093691,
0.0454336219,
0.0069981809,
-0.0153210284,
-0.0390683636,
0.0106668342,
-0.0235833116,
0.0232040025,
0.0177929085,
-0.0055346154,
-0.037044704,
0.0510008521,
-0.0252429098,
0.0310920719,
0.0348496325,
0.0156314708,
0.0482112467,
0.0496457107,
-0.0425482094,
-0.0289469007,
-0.0301004983,
0.0439600982,
-0.0037501887,
-0.0372732878,
0.0381531641,
0.0124914851,
0.0556089059,
-0.0567363463,
-0.0323548503,
0.046569366,
-0.0384397171,
-0.0727423951,
0.0203780327,
-0.0503956638,
0.0072253854,
0.0278401822,
-0.0425482951,
-0.063248381,
0.048027005,
-0.0260508396,
0.0331405252,
-0.0411870256,
0.0032421716,
-0.0104563823,
0.0234964155,
0.0107638519,
0.0492036454,
0.0326668397,
-0.0400150418,
-0.0022806355,
-0.0008028513,
0.0634535402,
-0.0179790743,
-0.0105480496,
-0.0127300378,
0.0017174584,
-0.0073830849,
-0.0507914163,
-0.0560181141,
-0.1118231341,
0.0229978487,
0.0013560032,
0.02066084,
-0.0324123465,
0.0065825642,
-0.0070255902,
-0.0082150558,
0.0268020853,
-0.0184375606,
-0.0017859248,
0.0074424767,
0.0439402387,
-0.0155246491,
-0.0345771946,
0.0392751582,
-0.0179218855,
-0.0105249165,
0.0516776554,
0.0826901048,
0.0666472986,
0.0457731634,
-0.0176863577,
0.0247187,
-0.0335514694,
-0.0380269438,
0.0068080318,
0.0549165644,
-0.025752183,
-0.0066059451,
0.100682281,
-0.0006007171,
-0.0427004099,
0.0034240144,
0.0562632605,
0.052356571,
0.00020676,
-0.0214801896,
-0.0689853057,
0.0131577523,
0.0288876146,
0.0603877194,
-0.0608873293,
-0.0507326163,
-0.0312450081,
-0.1155853122,
-0.0133507838,
0.0093189236,
-0.0132234097,
-0.0178457536,
-0.0415570512,
-0.0073943725,
-0.0028883736,
0.0237671714,
-0.0389228277,
0.0248660874,
-0.012801989,
0.0379997455,
-0.0144206341,
-0.0567663983,
-0.0350412093,
-0.045482941,
0.0541237406,
0.0679509714,
0.0164252389,
0.0027937049,
-0.0252754875,
0.0375908203,
0.0178975295,
-0.0124869123,
-0.0245430283,
0.0714522377,
-0.0144728357,
0.0010051655,
-0.0242056325,
0.0761514381,
0.0015200195,
0.0085841008,
-0.0068725795,
-0.0195047092,
0.0141606797,
-0.0625184253,
-0.0007807843,
0.0009452083,
0.0086484235,
0.0676278993,
0.0066479426,
-0.0306979977,
-0.001992129,
-0.0512026139,
0.0408222526,
-0.0475505404,
0.0186985768,
0.0309716482,
0.0239652004,
-0.0806211904,
-0.0776866525,
-0.0077043963,
-0.0265889056,
0.0244284216,
0.0414381586,
-0.0173436888,
0.0335410684,
-0.0420039631,
-0.0210634824,
-0.0028741232,
-0.0465156138,
0.0058602802,
-0.0056283786,
-0.0101724053,
-0.0228032079,
-0.037349727,
-0.0113424649,
0.007687761,
-0.057322409,
-0.087525703,
0.0413175002,
0.0052545336,
0.021848321,
0.0658558235,
-0.0265583433,
-0.1058318689,
0.0716972575,
0.0752277523,
-0.0336643197,
0.0170929395,
0.0443746597,
-0.0440432541,
-0.0040375451,
0.0323219262,
-0.0100497399,
-0.0164623354,
0.032891769,
-0.015033056,
-0.0059260987,
-0.0273268595,
-0.0114043429,
0.0282156244,
0.0221697781,
-0.0489472523,
0.0589955971,
-0.0571366623,
-0.0286868587,
-0.0433472916,
0.0007415629,
-0.0004474472,
-0.0398703255,
0.0323712826,
0.0411967076,
-0.0005706894,
-0.0198162105,
-0.0243120622,
0.0152804097,
-0.0626265705,
0.0162276346,
-0.0084392345,
0.0366383716,
-0.0109783076,
0.0129679944,
-0.0240928121,
0.0552342646,
0.0032168105,
0.0235148091,
-0.0140162082,
0.0215777401,
0.0056176456,
0.0255234484,
-0.0115784369,
0.0269568842,
-0.0688286051,
-0.0067900904,
-0.0383636877,
0.0225570817,
-0.0119804936,
-0.0144551639,
0.014106892,
-0.0190721601,
0.0167704485,
0.009753447,
0.0097130835,
0.0206277929,
-0.0386733972,
0.0138000064,
-0.027360633,
-0.0204145685,
0.0409342125,
0.0926164836,
0.0320642628,
0.0378059447,
-0.0175048038,
-0.0406206548,
-0.0366197564,
-0.0404792204,
0.009300082,
0.0297959205,
-0.0328465402,
-0.02167877,
-0.0488427356,
-0.0620828718,
-0.0404050685,
-0.00199473,
0.068247959,
-0.0259081665,
0.0233711824,
0.0378705561,
-0.0174467023,
-0.0111806048,
-0.0567597523,
-0.0200209208,
-0.0211672951,
-0.0050613061,
-0.0121920062,
-5.424582066e-33,
0.0039945156,
-0.0257050693,
-0.0487133898,
0.0112720365,
0.0087433755,
-0.0108099869,
-0.0061274962,
-0.0074463277,
-0.0232328475,
-0.0236177314,
-0.0344596133,
-0.0111761689,
0.0017196682,
0.0457898267,
-0.0041084476,
-0.0188945644,
0.0842092112,
-0.0266084429,
-0.0480120219,
0.0374344476,
0.0186615847,
0.0137400441,
-0.0120331151,
-0.0407543592,
0.0653799027,
0.0111580696,
-0.0369300619,
0.0049867816,
-0.0416509844,
0.0232916232,
-0.0361867808,
0.0194474012,
0.0253003016,
-0.0012792932,
-0.0012842099,
0.0409956612,
-0.0467121005,
0.0038106123,
-0.0140303504,
-0.0048835827,
0.0502526984,
-0.0516085215,
0.041735813,
-0.0065363054,
-0.0489853323,
0.0117524453,
-0.0047777365,
0.0304135289,
-0.026704343,
-0.0402064361,
-0.0107966391,
0.0243962072,
-0.016560873,
-0.0316287875,
0.0330596678,
0.0208404977,
0.0098742116,
-0.0159293488,
-0.0033783556,
0.0073137372,
0.0343110375,
-0.0159066021,
0.0348922201,
-0.0101179117,
0.0039799483,
0.0340375081,
0.0589970388,
0.0511768907,
-0.0123202642,
-0.02456191,
0.0167000983,
-0.0091207922,
0.0025749796,
0.0467974991,
0.0171269402,
-0.0425451547,
-0.0354270823,
0.0349926017,
0.0061162082,
-0.0517209023,
0.0744698495,
-0.0299206935,
-0.0655787066,
-0.0525642559,
-0.0600043051,
-0.0764782056,
-0.0351206437,
0.0433061048,
0.0060413252,
0.0574746057,
-0.064782463,
-0.0165815447,
0.0065467427,
-0.0348888189,
-0.0374678262,
0.038998615,
0.022243375,
-0.0402331203,
-0.0168709271,
-0.0094339959,
-0.048059281,
-0.0291822795,
0.0084001366,
0.0320229717,
-0.0065006856,
-0.0055049914,
0.0287848692,
0.0092452765,
-0.0420985259,
-0.004260073,
-0.0345031619,
0.0919084921,
0.0305236876,
0.0343739986,
0.0307982992,
-0.0166734103,
0.00029812,
-0.0046997769,
0.0323243067,
0.0143054835,
-0.0371151529,
0.0568205677,
0.0045736101,
-0.0009603467,
-0.0028983222,
-0.0165184494,
0.0376161225,
-0.0108655887,
0.0866843686,
0.0037099693,
-0.0107413782,
-0.0645694211,
2.3e-7,
-0.02722748,
0.0096626021,
0.014266504,
-0.0056648464,
0.0023152989,
0.0722448453,
0.0461704209,
0.1075995639,
-0.0105700288,
0.0703612864,
-0.0412940271,
-0.0204868969,
0.035939578,
0.0185448099,
-0.0262893084,
-0.0231092386,
-0.0416553691,
0.0610757843,
-0.0193444509,
-0.0177552067,
0.0004557018,
0.0423580594,
0.0258878525,
-0.0114564179,
-0.011786744,
-0.057159394,
0.0428211801,
-0.0446852036,
-0.012183642,
-0.0119173704,
0.0458196104,
0.0587334111,
0.0425567999,
0.0073695262,
-0.0470723063,
0.020740319,
-0.0755919144,
0.0570563637,
0.0321300179,
-0.0144678112,
0.0183757544,
-0.0216304585,
0.0106228143,
-0.0685079843,
0.0316407904,
0.0280254018,
-0.0188341811,
-0.0344797485,
0.0407412238,
-0.043391712,
0.0218864121,
-0.0370458513,
-0.0250545293,
0.00678008,
0.0096854009,
0.004763132,
0.0021049508,
-0.06978634,
-0.0539147444,
-0.0606532022,
-0.0277246889,
-0.0099225761,
0.0275802072,
0.0591526777,
-0.0003026347,
-0.0005996951,
0.0480710566,
2.008424163e-34,
0.0056843515,
-0.0010631634,
0.0047046598,
-0.0040602931,
0.04245276,
0.0043956828,
0.0456962585,
0.0033899134,
0.0334873945,
-0.0453042798,
-0.0262018256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14935v1 | Modeling Appropriate Language in Argumentation | 2023-05-24T09:17:05 | 2023-05-24T09:17:05 | Timon Ziegenbein, Shahbaz Syed, Felix Lange, Martin Potthast, Henning Wachsmuth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online discussion moderators must make ad-hoc decisions about whether the
contributions of discussion participants are appropriate or should be removed
to maintain civility. Existing research on offensive language and the resulting
tools cover only one aspect among many involved in such decisions. The question
of what is considered appropriate in a controversial discussion has not yet
been systematically addressed. In this paper, we operationalize appropriate
language in argumentation for the first time. In particular, we model
appropriateness through the absence of flaws, grounded in research on argument
quality assessment, especially in aspects from rhetoric. From these, we derive
a new taxonomy of 14 dimensions that determine inappropriate language in online
discussions. Building on three argument quality corpora, we then create a
corpus of 2191 arguments annotated for the 14 dimensions. Empirical analyses
support that the taxonomy covers the concept of appropriateness
comprehensively, showing several plausible correlations with argument quality
dimensions. Moreover, results of baseline approaches to assessing
appropriateness suggest that all dimensions can be modeled computationally on
the corpus. | [
0.0677423924,
0.0311181601,
-0.0181203783,
0.0452840999,
-0.0396493152,
0.0013100046,
0.0174617283,
0.0346624367,
-0.0205598343,
-0.0641418844,
0.030158665,
-0.0465365723,
0.0221843719,
-0.0012729804,
-0.0106059015,
-0.0759374797,
-0.0099715916,
0.0252142493,
0.1053838655,
-0.0011947997,
0.0670185536,
-0.0137195867,
-0.0195482001,
0.033984933,
-0.0382305644,
-0.0149808889,
0.029584026,
-0.0018038735,
0.0267634988,
-0.0002953712,
0.0318348296,
0.0534175187,
-0.0114372158,
0.0165256578,
0.0000017823,
-0.0599076524,
0.0318877064,
0.0004673847,
-0.008848683,
0.0189208966,
0.1285147667,
0.0320081972,
-0.0193112399,
0.0419710986,
-0.0002897678,
0.0178843979,
0.0474227145,
0.0698946714,
0.0624818839,
0.0834560692,
-0.004706183,
-0.0004350351,
-0.0110295769,
0.0055733682,
-0.0747007132,
0.0124147329,
0.0223605409,
0.0184556674,
-0.044618845,
0.0223077741,
0.0283160768,
-0.0156241991,
-0.0063698934,
-0.0075350977,
-0.0058608744,
-0.0383955389,
-0.0563666634,
-0.03936252,
0.0131273819,
0.0240321662,
0.0465847813,
-0.0208253767,
0.0173073672,
-0.0227617994,
-0.0023247132,
0.0084282765,
-0.0427913927,
0.0288453791,
-0.0198927503,
0.010410279,
0.027008485,
0.0271952935,
0.0260894708,
0.0722753629,
0.0789861679,
0.0278227311,
-0.0380989984,
-0.0363177061,
-0.0333799534,
-0.0350740775,
-0.016323721,
-0.0315356031,
-0.0019659037,
0.022194121,
-0.0216255262,
0.0397439972,
-0.0138084199,
-0.0054420121,
0.0735568404,
-0.1059570909,
0.0178763308,
-0.0166028254,
0.0113873528,
0.0197078343,
0.0388808437,
-0.0126484875,
-0.0187280532,
-0.0002252759,
0.0403241217,
-0.015585647,
-0.0190699846,
0.0117671061,
-0.0156771038,
-0.0144584002,
-0.0178307239,
0.0121800201,
0.0112103531,
-0.0359117836,
-0.0815356225,
-0.0382202789,
0.0292184595,
0.0201435145,
0.0033557378,
-0.0226449668,
-0.0535699837,
-0.0144182378,
-0.0622707941,
0.0381110571,
-0.0114334738,
-0.037743859,
0.0289048236,
0.0409331284,
0.0020120905,
-0.0119823804,
0.0044299886,
0.0677629039,
0.0153188994,
0.0354840308,
0.0027043868,
-0.0435561091,
-0.0593847483,
-0.0271755792,
-0.0030470609,
-0.0402960517,
0.0124625759,
-0.0334397927,
-0.0359047092,
-0.0490457118,
0.0203009862,
0.0344896913,
-0.0364185721,
-0.0152701894,
-0.0254630167,
-0.0074636107,
0.0745666549,
0.0335241258,
-0.0503894687,
0.0172281154,
0.0236044228,
-0.0024199903,
0.0601771139,
0.0098942081,
-0.0013587433,
0.0154441204,
-0.0000705817,
0.0153260846,
-0.00426692,
0.0116343452,
-0.0530719496,
-0.0032062375,
-0.0359326787,
0.0822145268,
-0.0416566581,
-0.0690056235,
0.0281421114,
0.0504486114,
-0.0100867646,
0.0331740305,
0.0231062565,
0.0324368663,
0.0167612247,
-0.0179016627,
0.0132128121,
-0.0179856494,
0.0184638649,
-0.0602184944,
0.0484643504,
0.0242478028,
0.0178609286,
-0.0826709196,
-0.0140248938,
-0.0065899058,
0.0512850732,
-0.0396415628,
0.0056377342,
0.0066658026,
0.0019447417,
-0.0279214531,
0.034997385,
-0.0557948425,
-0.0148004247,
-0.0201261323,
0.0312100276,
0.0409652144,
0.0278111789,
0.0366409123,
-0.0029786029,
-0.0583705492,
0.0833702311,
0.0775004849,
0.0528207347,
-0.0025935767,
-0.0168259367,
-0.0515945219,
-0.0216269121,
0.022541577,
0.0244128965,
0.0158830285,
0.014185614,
-0.0096061388,
0.0121267149,
0.040632505,
-0.0538609438,
0.0239742193,
0.051429905,
0.0049699149,
-0.0070061227,
0.0026085326,
0.0812555775,
0.0136754047,
-0.0274378266,
-0.0257603098,
0.0046303188,
0.0038178135,
-0.0384584405,
0.0160786342,
-0.0156430788,
0.073573947,
0.0327083617,
-0.0425812192,
0.011072861,
-0.0475802459,
0.0063838507,
0.0361455455,
0.0522188507,
-0.0349424742,
-0.0404015258,
-0.0311455186,
-0.0341013819,
-0.0615437105,
-0.0011035706,
-0.0194480009,
0.0335663818,
0.0217584372,
0.0363619663,
0.021742614,
-0.0323872864,
0.0462854244,
-0.0194309987,
-0.043702513,
-0.0096600056,
-0.0174270142,
0.0391904823,
0.0471878797,
-0.0318185389,
-0.0349792354,
-0.0118671702,
-0.071021162,
-0.0346525498,
-0.014861186,
0.0324123763,
0.0076702395,
-0.0683064461,
-0.0002651253,
0.0338578075,
-0.0020603794,
-0.0692047551,
-0.0138933044,
0.0139212124,
0.0435482971,
-0.0269135237,
-0.0154627832,
-0.0253673065,
-0.0084693357,
-0.0128331436,
0.0198723134,
0.0081878472,
-0.0210633297,
0.0174268205,
0.0008108446,
-0.0477954634,
-0.0130125647,
-0.0039476906,
-0.061989557,
0.0492477715,
0.0567066595,
0.0040895669,
0.0258579087,
0.0947906971,
0.0403970778,
-0.0014654406,
-0.0148475096,
-0.0347409658,
-0.0347224623,
-0.003055051,
0.0307688881,
-0.0088265063,
-0.0217916481,
0.045288384,
0.055662781,
0.0173084084,
0.0485442318,
-0.0731719136,
0.0614479817,
-0.0720694885,
-0.0279233307,
-0.0022747559,
-0.0449084789,
-0.0186141469,
0.0382100418,
-0.0171726476,
-0.0306465384,
0.0351434648,
-0.0296609271,
0.0438857079,
-0.0008193859,
-0.041903954,
-0.0025713041,
-0.0036580104,
-0.0124939773,
0.0257912334,
0.033810176,
-0.0140229156,
0.0072202827,
-0.0646588057,
0.1102926433,
-0.0640420169,
-0.0103009082,
-0.0334398821,
-0.007337858,
0.0227592569,
-0.030418139,
0.0108076148,
-0.0130414059,
-0.0043361261,
-0.0282785799,
0.0032000716,
0.0197430085,
0.0016572488,
0.0089810034,
0.0072419625,
-0.0473491773,
0.0238844585,
0.0312449392,
0.0515044443,
-0.0086269611,
-0.031267982,
0.0363277383,
0.0182841979,
0.0216084383,
-0.0023589467,
0.0788737908,
-0.0304947067,
-0.0264380947,
0.0028070398,
-0.0286889561,
-0.0279312842,
0.0012587985,
-0.0107127437,
0.003638756,
0.0396525562,
-0.0550245419,
0.0077583645,
0.07263574,
0.0201334376,
0.0292274039,
-0.0354496017,
-0.0387471057,
-0.0255188029,
-0.0004553387,
-0.0164774824,
-0.0761126652,
0.0169319287,
-0.0265804157,
0.0040179566,
-0.0850755423,
-0.0518594645,
0.0015958763,
-0.0380571,
0.0308454335,
0.0107249347,
0.0412469022,
0.0077585801,
-0.0212112349,
0.0221628454,
-0.0132267391,
0.0180681441,
-0.0030775513,
0.0573809557,
-0.0173417516,
0.04274863,
-0.0522128195,
-0.0013276433,
0.004965859,
0.0007578255,
0.0523300581,
-0.0172733534,
0.0883761123,
-0.0233002901,
-0.0533310026,
0.0239673927,
-0.0286229309,
-0.0498564877,
-0.0169744492,
0.0294806138,
0.0104914606,
-0.0013577272,
-0.0574002042,
0.0133390892,
0.051178582,
-0.0706673637,
0.0039629275,
0.0383734107,
0.0053468416,
0.0032872679,
-0.0457158424,
0.0211478397,
0.0270636976,
0.0497929603,
0.0347167812,
-0.0257816482,
-0.0194753557,
-0.0549176037,
0.0056230146,
-0.0315998048,
-0.0257066898,
-0.0330818035,
0.0263267849,
0.0060486533,
-0.1030286923,
-0.0201676954,
-0.0408120714,
0.0094515383,
0.0014231092,
-0.0201879293,
0.0029566374,
-0.0055464259,
0.0075835525,
-0.0263864044,
-0.0154152913,
0.0021814364,
-0.0309095494,
0.0386840329,
-0.0400056057,
0.0203314666,
-0.0265287943,
0.0386523157,
0.0638365149,
-0.0452218577,
0.0255074129,
0.0345407091,
0.0242685433,
-0.0201381464,
-0.0014052882,
-0.0448753573,
0.000935662,
0.0318925865,
0.0224257018,
-0.0101480307,
0.0637436658,
0.0130747491,
0.0213429984,
0.0067522191,
0.024277674,
0.0503626503,
-0.019978771,
0.0123655125,
-0.0385359935,
-0.0099454457,
-0.0111667197,
0.010854491,
0.0231271125,
0.0283806678,
-0.0787013322,
-0.0138028925,
-0.0367028564,
-0.0283861812,
-0.045278836,
0.0176976323,
0.0357524939,
-0.0491059422,
-0.0125039071,
-0.03180141,
-0.032338798,
-0.0767005011,
0.050521832,
0.0184995607,
0.0131052611,
0.0043065026,
0.0117836623,
-0.0209137835,
-0.0018782624,
-0.0459501743,
0.0211029202,
-0.0120316502,
0.0127846552,
-0.0002864058,
0.0449251905,
-0.0004633544,
0.0161350071,
0.048516877,
-0.0255657844,
-0.0100031849,
-0.0259303655,
-0.009714283,
-0.0039328001,
-0.0414389819,
-0.0127727557,
0.0538455881,
0.0086573018,
-0.021684017,
-0.0214957669,
0.0186885726,
-0.0009834004,
-0.0523276813,
0.0491291992,
0.0352425911,
-0.0576790087,
-0.0072134063,
0.0189681109,
-0.0645762905,
0.0003011809,
0.0041879877,
-0.0250657238,
-0.0321598984,
-0.0345580243,
-0.0302337036,
0.027065672,
0.0251675602,
-0.0121817654,
-0.0506306514,
0.0095128482,
-0.0254897103,
0.004808743,
0.0557826199,
-0.0152476914,
-0.0202202201,
0.055424504,
0.0092390738,
0.0661963522,
-0.0431372598,
-0.0042249281,
-0.0117281014,
0.0027056569,
-0.0304812063,
-5.628070424e-33,
0.0026065758,
-0.0562935211,
-0.0228575245,
0.0750536472,
0.0061606015,
-0.0180120952,
-0.0111428788,
0.0366541892,
-0.0407223888,
0.045899719,
0.0242726803,
0.0059035197,
0.0136606283,
-0.0096099824,
-0.0171657596,
-0.0357248709,
0.0041068592,
-0.0181937851,
-0.0412824005,
0.0091464343,
0.0473474152,
-0.0433247611,
-0.0134463599,
-0.067165032,
0.0744026303,
0.0278958865,
-0.0286892019,
0.0124877309,
0.0361773781,
0.0800981373,
0.014034179,
0.0793567672,
0.0306159072,
-0.0097289737,
0.0287086014,
0.0485493988,
-0.013109345,
-0.0174262226,
0.045387134,
-0.0473833121,
0.0166633669,
-0.0268983748,
0.0380493514,
0.01475331,
-0.0251507703,
-0.0403885096,
0.0302049033,
-0.0328595191,
0.0139912665,
-0.0614406429,
-0.0454002768,
0.0491192564,
-0.0278268158,
-0.0151261808,
-0.0026557748,
0.0331836008,
-0.0081109721,
0.0451799706,
-0.0342878364,
0.0256065112,
-0.0397270285,
-0.0016891016,
-0.012682382,
-0.0585050248,
0.0202761181,
0.0694061443,
-0.025689695,
0.06827382,
-0.0148640266,
0.0144204851,
-0.0084235882,
0.0589001775,
0.0582364909,
0.0887078345,
0.0188088249,
-0.073532939,
-0.0606501102,
-0.0402017497,
0.0188745465,
0.0537178814,
0.0116001302,
-0.0166627411,
-0.0351028517,
-0.0247954205,
-0.0314353928,
-0.0874016881,
-0.0188443139,
-0.046032615,
0.0006272611,
-0.0135012316,
-0.0201071873,
-0.0309675541,
0.00796053,
-0.0149165737,
0.0193337761,
0.0283785556,
-0.0014995396,
0.0025961818,
0.0333519243,
0.0093789073,
-0.0356864557,
-0.0284850225,
-0.0111190202,
-0.0016089841,
0.037879914,
-0.0431679077,
0.042129606,
-0.0051695188,
-0.0525441207,
-0.0120814582,
-0.0081342366,
0.0488064028,
-0.0332463868,
0.0573919564,
-0.0013935376,
0.0396207161,
0.0003284795,
0.0086262124,
-0.0002406137,
-0.0169390868,
-0.020682836,
-0.0425559506,
-0.0358521566,
-0.0262332186,
-0.0368096605,
-0.0157133862,
0.013195266,
-0.0052030724,
0.0445555747,
-0.0332246274,
0.0046449779,
-0.0364018679,
2.502e-7,
0.0307970326,
0.0765632316,
0.0127005847,
-0.02313588,
0.0356066339,
0.0387460776,
0.0142336227,
0.021447124,
0.0101645794,
-0.06335143,
-0.0158424731,
-0.0032144836,
0.0511283875,
0.0461774953,
-0.0319063179,
-0.0885988399,
-0.097824052,
-0.0361269303,
0.0045766844,
0.0082915956,
0.0559689887,
-0.0000614121,
0.0221264455,
-0.0097257979,
-0.0579363666,
0.0056301635,
0.0470118262,
-0.0809903741,
-0.0179754626,
-0.0047372654,
0.0607349165,
-0.0422028825,
0.0449209027,
0.011326205,
0.0012323802,
0.0193089396,
0.0129774343,
0.0838542804,
0.0363944247,
0.001111139,
-0.0012305955,
-0.0281078424,
0.0244938303,
-0.0396044962,
-0.0099427681,
-0.0646668896,
-0.036198087,
-0.0543718562,
-0.0694875792,
-0.0347809158,
0.0513755307,
-0.0257518534,
-0.0368539616,
0.0018895594,
-0.0009889334,
0.0269675869,
0.0287850145,
-0.0298148878,
-0.0278829895,
0.0141599653,
-0.0269757845,
-0.063312158,
0.0081000384,
-0.0098286169,
0.0314072557,
0.0135081066,
0.0556317009,
1.548510966e-34,
0.041971989,
-0.0401986465,
0.0245236568,
-0.0028004835,
0.0633838028,
0.0516118705,
0.0396983698,
-0.0056365309,
0.0104126437,
0.0019567057,
0.0078885257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14934v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14934v2 | GRACE: Discriminator-Guided Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2023-05-24T09:16:51 | 2023-10-24T01:21:05 | Muhammad Khalifa, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Moontae Lee, Honglak Lee, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the context of multi-step reasoning, e.g., with chain-of-thought, language
models (LMs) can easily assign a high likelihood to incorrect steps. As a
result, decoding strategies that optimize for solution likelihood often yield
incorrect solutions. To address this issue, we propose Guiding chain-of-thought
ReAsoning with a CorrectnEss Discriminator (GRACE), a stepwise decoding
approach that steers the decoding process towards producing correct reasoning
steps. GRACE employs a discriminator trained with a contrastive loss over
correct and incorrect steps, which is used during decoding to score next-step
candidates based on their correctness. Importantly, GRACE only requires
sampling from the LM, without the need for LM training or fine-tuning. Using
models from FLAN-T5 and LLaMA families, we evaluate GRACE over four math and
two symbolic reasoning tasks, where it exhibits substantial performance gains
compared to greedy decoding, verifiers, and self-consistency in most settings.
When further combined with self-consistency, GRACE outperforms all the
baselines by sizeable margins. Human and LLM evaluations over GSM8K show that
GRACE not only improves the final answer accuracy but also the correctness of
the intermediate reasoning. Our implementation can be accessed at
\url{https://github.com/mukhal/grace}. | [
-0.0016071784,
0.071231924,
0.0035443427,
0.0381481238,
-0.023600325,
0.0253819767,
-0.0046948642,
-0.0203968007,
-0.006166047,
-0.0100681633,
-0.0089543536,
0.0112975286,
0.0214226805,
-0.0150003852,
0.016945811,
-0.042379003,
0.0514720008,
-0.0444868542,
0.0373972207,
-0.0278947372,
-0.028301172,
0.014147439,
-0.0415370129,
0.0171150267,
0.0017132212,
-0.0550912097,
-0.0084423833,
-0.0282968711,
0.0312965624,
-0.0456916653,
0.006661477,
0.0577070341,
0.0076256082,
0.0527364202,
0.0000024807,
-0.0309851635,
0.0171975866,
-0.0142161446,
-0.0602415539,
0.0061213365,
-0.0326970071,
-0.0373490378,
0.0103966706,
0.0304152388,
-0.0356444232,
-0.0339551456,
0.0124786878,
0.054779578,
0.0654365793,
0.063506186,
0.0265608057,
-0.062336497,
0.0480895378,
-0.0018267625,
0.0102132903,
-0.0470513292,
-0.005972825,
0.0211043861,
-0.0124835921,
0.0151867829,
-0.0251112394,
0.0500745103,
0.043020267,
0.0316047408,
-0.0064684916,
0.0410969704,
0.0275645535,
-0.0231301021,
-0.0101886075,
0.0227491688,
0.0215562973,
-0.0630047917,
-0.0288830549,
-0.0131921945,
-0.0271217823,
-0.0156049971,
-0.0175291579,
0.0411360152,
-0.0387934819,
0.0356840678,
0.0386638418,
0.0076284371,
0.028466776,
0.0193394255,
-0.0308054872,
0.0809477642,
-0.02668765,
-0.0496171191,
0.0240983404,
0.0327113941,
-0.0069650048,
-0.0680909902,
0.0449994877,
0.0424435697,
-0.023936158,
0.0107490225,
-0.0140315229,
-0.0389414616,
0.0019845809,
-0.0299321972,
0.0096669821,
0.069488354,
-0.0088607632,
0.014567636,
-0.0540552251,
0.0433487482,
-0.0133939702,
0.0425911918,
-0.0200440977,
0.0054311804,
-0.0195885934,
-0.0000053054,
-0.0043358509,
0.0475179441,
-0.0053162379,
0.0106129777,
-0.03450628,
0.0086551979,
0.003132571,
0.0164487865,
0.01266592,
0.0067999088,
0.0053748167,
-0.0198877472,
-0.0332180299,
0.0522610843,
-0.0452597663,
0.0598650575,
0.0498752706,
-0.043841958,
-0.0251271594,
-0.0089777224,
-0.0208285097,
-0.0192874707,
0.0289847814,
0.0523064733,
-0.0281186029,
-0.0107333949,
-0.0613645054,
-0.0182821993,
0.0301169679,
-0.0967783853,
0.0016599252,
-0.0810560361,
0.0143330349,
0.0091660917,
-0.0060807639,
-0.0230474863,
0.0213011969,
0.0405217968,
0.0025507885,
0.0677175522,
-0.0020078425,
-0.0240290239,
0.0420993492,
0.0051795943,
-0.0551289544,
0.0670130402,
0.0379870459,
0.0062910924,
0.0035951945,
0.0119257895,
0.0112284431,
-0.0030585208,
0.0228499193,
-0.0493031926,
0.005357591,
-0.0136417905,
-0.0061031925,
0.0504244976,
0.0630319491,
0.0536546484,
-0.0620633438,
-0.0195839871,
0.0469953269,
0.0477331802,
0.0548512675,
-0.0068622115,
0.0449039899,
-0.0065920521,
0.0206555761,
0.0283949375,
-0.0715090856,
0.0190217942,
-0.0481610298,
0.003178349,
0.0163270328,
0.0140855135,
-0.0110878935,
-0.0613612905,
-0.007981956,
0.0078673176,
-0.0037724751,
0.0327745788,
0.0621627308,
0.0035658916,
-0.0481702499,
0.0512466542,
-0.0029412156,
-0.0223767888,
-0.0088229263,
-0.032310307,
0.0463580899,
0.0340723805,
0.0368342809,
0.0213847216,
-0.003735306,
0.0026003395,
-0.0016334502,
0.0058924421,
0.0135652423,
0.0098903179,
0.0013949045,
-0.0506587513,
-0.0110534681,
0.0151675697,
0.0233862568,
0.0009898719,
0.0135178501,
0.0230855327,
-0.0103591895,
-0.0174457673,
0.0271173306,
0.0538215078,
0.022776667,
-0.025698347,
0.0083976211,
0.0081746699,
-0.0068870839,
-0.0002362281,
0.0168340784,
0.012350535,
-0.0038244205,
-0.0351751074,
-0.0311290622,
-0.0243765414,
-0.0856961757,
-0.0964118987,
0.0492912568,
-0.0423473641,
-0.0343572944,
0.0487762094,
-0.0588635914,
-0.0233294182,
0.0353173986,
-0.0286583286,
-0.0217117295,
-0.0245518629,
0.0261189863,
0.0340796709,
-0.0026962347,
-0.0197213758,
0.1232438534,
-0.0508985184,
0.0019777378,
-0.0294268429,
0.0122097721,
0.0225251149,
-0.0376962535,
0.0355652757,
0.0169989374,
-0.0127487006,
0.0214889441,
-0.0434370264,
0.0250962246,
-0.0434882008,
-0.0082214372,
-0.0324801803,
0.012946425,
-0.0116294008,
0.0440034978,
-0.0079858536,
-0.0344530046,
0.020829659,
-0.0068540489,
-0.0301378798,
0.0204517562,
0.021450283,
-0.0197198037,
0.0170797221,
-0.0162958782,
-0.030477291,
-0.0163933579,
-0.0110237105,
-0.0392719582,
0.0308917761,
-0.0195353311,
-0.0275000036,
-0.0585826822,
0.0457634479,
-0.0263599847,
0.011161143,
0.0081937816,
-0.0015210786,
0.0459733978,
0.0055070664,
-0.010325958,
0.0636129752,
0.0023999345,
-0.0139083257,
0.0384859778,
0.009764513,
-0.040681567,
0.0200061295,
0.0085016359,
0.01526081,
-0.0047233645,
-0.0187475644,
-0.0263571125,
0.0903512016,
0.0208505653,
0.0208213814,
-0.0743746236,
-0.0273293909,
0.003017751,
-0.0190610141,
-0.0016504992,
-0.0084255617,
-0.0145915393,
0.0882570148,
-0.0144391386,
-0.0200964082,
0.0927601457,
-0.0447410867,
0.0059246877,
-0.0340936072,
0.0010359905,
-0.0237308852,
0.0253871195,
-0.048323974,
-0.0176462233,
-0.0085952999,
-0.0236562863,
-0.04474397,
-0.023984462,
0.0405839421,
-0.0425782576,
0.0645670295,
-0.074899666,
0.0121501358,
-0.0349067897,
-0.0690547377,
-0.0652851462,
0.0505939499,
-0.0677524954,
0.0018672504,
-0.0461142138,
0.0205798671,
-0.0165706947,
-0.0244903453,
-0.0037325453,
0.0560100153,
0.0117380517,
-0.0236191582,
-0.0233059432,
0.027511077,
0.0062054172,
0.0039927843,
0.0825982317,
-0.0225121565,
0.0408069454,
0.0577124357,
0.0622846074,
0.0141614154,
-0.0228689685,
0.0233761743,
0.0266638752,
-0.0065877116,
-0.0315155573,
0.0501338467,
0.0416613482,
-0.0931852609,
-0.0333450325,
0.1024694592,
0.0270730089,
-0.0580566116,
0.0031722523,
-0.0557141677,
0.0098846881,
-0.0022476681,
0.0099067008,
-0.1160495803,
-0.0689270124,
0.0438769571,
0.0373607203,
0.0206040405,
-0.0227508005,
0.0105468128,
-0.090731591,
0.0385782272,
0.0327892527,
-0.0062068929,
-0.0449805893,
-0.0420974642,
-0.0246291179,
0.0107142068,
0.0117355669,
0.0446874462,
0.0199043937,
0.0158539489,
0.0300443973,
-0.0084587717,
-0.0348969735,
0.0459193178,
-0.046322763,
0.0328310244,
0.0435020626,
0.0039845305,
0.0418558121,
-0.1088529527,
0.0280447043,
-0.0477797389,
-0.0228156764,
-0.0262674261,
-0.0222553853,
-0.0234951843,
0.0046924637,
-0.0064360448,
0.0482987538,
-0.05557907,
-0.0327181667,
0.0018119082,
0.1124264225,
-0.0332619064,
-0.0241798721,
0.0026206395,
0.0256037638,
-0.0498632528,
0.0410748385,
0.0421266258,
-0.0072306218,
-0.0765066594,
-0.0444853455,
0.0115149189,
-0.0055606752,
-0.0454277024,
0.0247940216,
0.0702569485,
-0.0121874185,
-0.051320117,
-0.0563469976,
0.0237060413,
0.0502147302,
-0.0556154139,
0.0043132831,
-0.0144956131,
-0.0073912297,
-0.0393629,
0.0028245701,
-0.0484816656,
0.0356059,
-0.0478028245,
0.0255878232,
-0.0235830471,
-0.0243037771,
0.0034935076,
0.0392830633,
-0.0924411714,
-0.0336054452,
-0.0355111435,
0.0421752036,
0.0263263844,
0.0539252535,
-0.0246624481,
-0.0237630513,
0.0065153046,
0.0108268997,
-0.0277206693,
0.0368946977,
0.0505951755,
0.0043512569,
0.0148729226,
0.0299242698,
-0.0206660051,
-0.0071594012,
-0.0138453459,
0.068018049,
0.0069715218,
-0.0088355644,
0.0420915969,
-0.0214721896,
0.0334990956,
-0.0184301641,
-0.0036881643,
-0.01165915,
0.0577920787,
-0.0006216237,
-0.0116961207,
-0.0119078597,
0.0032339855,
0.0306016803,
-0.0134205623,
0.0027932818,
-0.0596052557,
0.0205462892,
-0.0071053663,
0.0160755198,
0.0132987322,
0.0362220891,
0.0558547676,
0.0007773089,
-0.0300352685,
-0.0507738143,
-0.0138252862,
0.0094828336,
0.0717103183,
-0.0183543079,
0.0875557214,
0.0251788236,
0.0116537036,
-0.0379760489,
-0.0372844338,
-0.0597789362,
-0.0526157208,
-0.0161802415,
-0.0515612811,
0.0440936536,
0.0457817949,
0.0173928272,
-0.0099340808,
-0.0047379821,
-0.0011727668,
0.0111850975,
-0.0157287922,
-0.019041311,
0.028445648,
0.0359056331,
0.0169921424,
-0.0405772887,
0.0516536869,
-0.0270202253,
0.0449918732,
-0.017877847,
-0.0064452803,
-0.0366804264,
-0.0653955713,
-0.0638342947,
0.0209253449,
-0.0113075329,
-0.0188914593,
-0.0665646419,
-0.0984407663,
0.0155039914,
0.0152727095,
0.0216687731,
-0.0202626046,
0.017243268,
0.0537573323,
0.0048485282,
-0.0536692142,
-0.0020028492,
-0.0066112154,
0.0278229415,
-0.019247964,
-0.0631695315,
-6.991734604e-33,
-0.039597746,
-0.0210843775,
0.0609787814,
0.0000820666,
-0.0042662625,
-0.0067160521,
-0.0516869165,
-0.0066173035,
-0.0424601771,
0.0401363261,
-0.0150066707,
0.03088025,
0.0135891791,
0.0418010764,
0.0264745802,
-0.0105676185,
0.0156751107,
-0.0179124884,
-0.0418775156,
-0.0188461859,
0.0099810231,
0.0167820882,
0.0297405627,
-0.0318302102,
-0.0077508758,
0.0063780481,
-0.0163746942,
0.031636782,
-0.063881427,
0.0369641855,
-0.0438431688,
0.019061422,
0.0147059401,
-0.0413761176,
-0.0101289134,
-0.028396327,
-0.1087580174,
-0.023943102,
0.0170950405,
0.0433848165,
-0.0588573925,
-0.0374554358,
0.0293945167,
0.0180088766,
-0.0391130224,
-0.0299359951,
-0.0090596173,
-0.0345949754,
-0.0092205973,
-0.0196718555,
-0.0297916476,
0.0195410606,
-0.0188127905,
-0.0432488024,
0.0267282184,
0.0089503787,
-0.0413435996,
-0.0031888105,
-0.064211458,
-0.0110898418,
0.0205913987,
-0.0073146787,
0.0778655708,
-0.005062669,
-0.0160064343,
0.0521053821,
0.0580944568,
-0.0590683855,
-0.0299567413,
-0.0024905885,
0.0221434645,
0.0238845311,
0.0791781917,
0.0011775495,
0.0333981253,
0.0125199668,
-0.0680088997,
-0.0111836828,
-0.0011625242,
0.0400413908,
0.0061765895,
0.0306680892,
-0.0304225273,
-0.0230702981,
-0.0460967012,
-0.0288955495,
-0.0521025732,
-0.0094647622,
0.0410296097,
0.0247756802,
0.001503926,
-0.0534984618,
0.0411503315,
-0.0248217136,
-0.0024481006,
0.0207497571,
-0.0021476648,
0.0246023089,
0.0066109188,
0.0267679766,
-0.0442093611,
0.0272214655,
0.0326138251,
-0.0019438382,
0.0230156127,
-0.0046817213,
0.0303860269,
-0.0043574744,
-0.0480402857,
-0.002238123,
-0.0669211671,
0.003833371,
0.0321409404,
0.0213901084,
0.055556085,
-0.0049656769,
-0.0157571826,
0.0440298617,
-0.039908994,
0.0050950567,
-0.0217150785,
0.0746702328,
-0.0346787609,
0.043669384,
-0.018598171,
0.0066768113,
-0.0339754894,
0.0028367098,
-0.0006404512,
-0.0628053471,
-0.001966398,
0.0580470636,
3.18e-7,
0.0196471475,
0.0344625786,
0.0396877229,
0.0231766738,
0.0138634443,
0.0608185865,
-0.0032192622,
-0.0098243114,
0.0274598859,
-0.0583835207,
-0.0138285896,
0.064010717,
0.047195714,
0.0379063897,
-0.0152791627,
0.0093167163,
-0.0151742268,
0.0003260776,
-0.0315908417,
-0.0361563973,
0.0458098538,
0.0829165354,
0.0255864356,
-0.0265113972,
0.0285941586,
0.0270164516,
0.0356230401,
0.0137429442,
0.0216621999,
-0.0219712574,
0.0020959403,
-0.0330911092,
0.030405188,
0.0333477408,
0.0099372035,
0.0274948142,
-0.0215984378,
0.0529945754,
0.0146213351,
-0.032322824,
-0.0350871235,
-0.0003377835,
0.0049105664,
-0.0310620256,
0.0843641013,
-0.0364519879,
-0.0348671116,
-0.0053059496,
-0.0356356725,
-0.0309379045,
0.0174932741,
0.0271683931,
0.0144453375,
0.0171123408,
-0.0013078719,
0.0204749908,
-0.0243047774,
-0.0881724581,
-0.0334194563,
0.029018458,
-0.0309970416,
0.0093468642,
-0.0274974424,
0.0186690185,
0.0582766943,
-0.0373573564,
-0.0073148161,
2.878098047e-34,
0.015174889,
-0.0350052379,
0.0204425696,
0.0627398938,
0.046933867,
-0.009106365,
-0.0192931704,
0.0273197442,
0.0413186662,
-0.0502958968,
-0.0037015805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14930v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14930v2 | In-Context Impersonation Reveals Large Language Models' Strengths and Biases | 2023-05-24T09:13:15 | 2023-11-26T18:36:30 | Leonard Salewski, Stephan Alaniz, Isabel Rio-Torto, Eric Schulz, Zeynep Akata | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In everyday conversations, humans can take on different roles and adapt their
vocabulary to their chosen roles. We explore whether LLMs can take on, that is
impersonate, different roles when they generate text in-context. We ask LLMs to
assume different personas before solving vision and language tasks. We do this
by prefixing the prompt with a persona that is associated either with a social
identity or domain expertise. In a multi-armed bandit task, we find that LLMs
pretending to be children of different ages recover human-like developmental
stages of exploration. In a language-based reasoning task, we find that LLMs
impersonating domain experts perform better than LLMs impersonating non-domain
experts. Finally, we test whether LLMs' impersonations are complementary to
visual information when describing different categories. We find that
impersonation can improve performance: an LLM prompted to be a bird expert
describes birds better than one prompted to be a car expert. However,
impersonation can also uncover LLMs' biases: an LLM prompted to be a man
describes cars better than one prompted to be a woman. These findings
demonstrate that LLMs are capable of taking on diverse roles and that this
in-context impersonation can be used to uncover their hidden strengths and
biases. | [
0.0649797246,
0.0365279354,
-0.0610138476,
0.0610675216,
-0.0290494803,
0.0030909244,
0.0295371283,
0.0072995038,
0.016848743,
-0.0459321328,
-0.047205992,
-0.0544303879,
0.0039388039,
-0.0055752052,
0.0548779853,
-0.0579117127,
0.0135082621,
-0.067673035,
0.0534394532,
-0.0262669958,
-0.049906265,
0.0085458811,
0.0011880021,
0.0203456376,
0.0021418922,
0.0074280365,
0.0425396077,
0.0049380208,
0.0227561109,
0.0237065405,
0.0235774592,
0.0148470597,
0.0851199105,
0.0192448441,
0.0000017784,
-0.0581246652,
0.0403470285,
-0.0425026417,
-0.0339329168,
-0.0110048568,
0.0343198515,
0.0331073329,
0.0108061396,
-0.0000082558,
-0.0876333043,
-0.0011750219,
0.0003403196,
0.033231359,
0.0075867241,
0.0396044962,
0.0214971118,
-0.001973205,
-0.0484100133,
-0.026488699,
0.0406518877,
-0.0293143056,
0.0146766184,
-0.0093769496,
0.0052479622,
0.0279901996,
0.0109022297,
-0.0098707294,
0.0146134505,
-0.0058060857,
0.0422259197,
0.0294353049,
0.0288933441,
0.0018781265,
0.0161889978,
0.0090347929,
0.0009441341,
-0.0222476758,
-0.0173775591,
0.0280360002,
0.0445075184,
0.0576774441,
-0.0158707052,
0.0687347651,
0.0232438389,
-0.0061862469,
0.0053073931,
0.0370042808,
0.0253173243,
0.0466252007,
-0.0200697146,
0.0439877398,
-0.0110861696,
-0.0180856623,
-0.0070298086,
0.0007588125,
-0.0276590884,
-0.0738997385,
-0.0316056237,
0.0132002933,
-0.065772295,
0.0389664434,
-0.042680949,
0.0467258468,
-0.0030957027,
0.0185763203,
0.0542465299,
0.0029449407,
-0.0049270676,
0.0188874733,
-0.0227236897,
0.0419354737,
-0.01587338,
0.0399765,
-0.0207234416,
-0.0078608114,
-0.0316222496,
-0.0813087747,
-0.0008258415,
0.0089209732,
-0.0061286809,
-0.0076804892,
-0.0130908117,
0.0185928904,
-0.0369501561,
-0.0192032531,
-0.0456667654,
0.0452767238,
-0.015552219,
-0.025911605,
-0.085480608,
-0.0053077061,
-0.0134492246,
0.0398866199,
0.0160097349,
-0.0574572235,
-0.0062508984,
-0.0010328994,
-0.0093288748,
-0.0495097451,
0.0056602187,
0.0660783798,
-0.0318712555,
-0.0461884588,
0.0032361457,
-0.0588524938,
0.0039150966,
-0.0516360849,
0.0395828299,
-0.0511559397,
0.0208440907,
-0.0123544419,
0.0025233231,
-0.0254438501,
0.0069648321,
0.0135553805,
-0.0196690112,
0.0727103502,
-0.0050533074,
0.0330555663,
0.0450108722,
0.054671254,
-0.0137332184,
0.0657258555,
0.0192191172,
-0.0163129345,
-0.0095698079,
0.010003414,
0.0123479879,
0.00974249,
-0.0198271964,
-0.0054969369,
0.0181791373,
-0.0308261625,
0.0027387755,
0.0499711037,
0.0840913355,
0.0052391957,
-0.028882917,
-0.0334808826,
0.0848464966,
0.0718027577,
-0.0098976009,
-0.0116919242,
0.0397537313,
-0.0050951908,
0.0118692787,
0.0488220379,
-0.0537634939,
0.0315850861,
-0.0078725684,
-0.0491513871,
-0.0494287685,
0.0088985115,
0.0022446024,
0.0250512604,
0.008342959,
0.0211232137,
-0.0134000545,
0.0080988351,
-0.0257620085,
0.0580137037,
0.0092812581,
0.0231027883,
0.001800064,
-0.0321113132,
0.0214421824,
-0.0560831688,
-0.0223251171,
0.0737463608,
-0.0003052553,
-0.0020447958,
0.0280457549,
-0.0221250113,
0.0192795098,
0.0772581473,
0.0282327924,
-0.0081013646,
-0.0086942716,
0.0064793783,
0.0112465974,
-0.0602077879,
0.0216505025,
0.0314183459,
0.0158482995,
-0.0169087145,
0.0231364742,
-0.0526029542,
0.0139276301,
0.0314843841,
-0.0719776452,
-0.0319558382,
-0.0202763788,
0.0243824534,
-0.0146072954,
-0.0130655253,
-0.0019955789,
0.010692901,
0.0151702715,
-0.0075287647,
-0.0225641374,
0.0399691276,
-0.0777700618,
0.0065951711,
0.004576223,
-0.0774578601,
-0.0190165099,
0.0130305458,
0.0301092193,
-0.0077809789,
0.0262975413,
-0.0495380796,
0.0501911156,
-0.0108148502,
0.0078003751,
-0.0249475203,
0.0165249705,
-0.0250356626,
0.0747470483,
0.0172267985,
0.0061073103,
0.0561977066,
0.0251630507,
-0.0540414751,
-0.051616855,
0.0322809108,
-0.0368308388,
0.0048994082,
0.0045871828,
-0.0153839355,
-0.040836025,
-0.0432600453,
-0.0312456749,
-0.0863575488,
-0.02838731,
0.0146103781,
-0.0258771591,
0.0439615175,
-0.0455665551,
0.0003729341,
0.0393763818,
-0.0456212759,
-0.0129081579,
-0.0034479152,
0.0295818765,
0.0052404702,
-0.0100309374,
0.0104686068,
0.0185583699,
0.0287954696,
-0.0208908003,
0.0621836819,
0.0130425468,
0.0101091098,
-0.0577539653,
-0.0299629457,
-0.0373770073,
0.0270427223,
-0.0350088626,
0.0313655101,
0.057700254,
0.0157167949,
0.0140452143,
0.0805746764,
0.0514222831,
0.0474501848,
0.0359145962,
-0.0186621137,
-0.0472923964,
-0.0305891857,
0.0344400853,
-0.0058357073,
-0.0250780359,
-0.0658202395,
0.0108802011,
0.0349914432,
0.0041656476,
0.0214264188,
-0.0324427709,
0.0809262693,
0.0107775787,
-0.1015767604,
0.0191768724,
-0.0437530763,
-0.0364303216,
0.0355536379,
-0.0281356275,
-0.025180202,
0.0652018562,
-0.0099219987,
-0.0156375244,
0.0463396758,
0.0060573095,
-0.0099404035,
0.0703262165,
0.0259362236,
0.0188972875,
0.0358352959,
-0.0276748557,
-0.1058922485,
0.0285445992,
0.0294939,
-0.0465264395,
0.0185778756,
-0.0537089445,
-0.0030767259,
0.0095612872,
-0.0203380715,
-0.0587849878,
-0.0143702235,
-0.0121126566,
0.0086075859,
-0.0204217751,
-0.0159870852,
-0.0506172404,
-0.0478383265,
0.021661751,
-0.0258901808,
0.0103235589,
0.0018141863,
-0.0214130767,
-0.0048430846,
0.0031390958,
0.0758865476,
0.0113275368,
-0.0419081934,
0.0133348238,
0.0220461935,
-0.021670064,
-0.0037843634,
-0.031099841,
0.0180245861,
0.0222688913,
0.0117351748,
-0.0139833745,
0.018714942,
0.03594644,
-0.0556824207,
-0.0008328907,
0.0806646198,
0.0290127341,
-0.0127496226,
0.0107803252,
-0.0131776519,
0.0351080187,
0.0439979583,
-0.0158115644,
-0.0912937075,
0.0079813134,
-0.0050248848,
0.0080858972,
-0.0837738067,
-0.0458189659,
-0.0303394608,
-0.140450865,
0.0335316174,
0.0193263572,
-0.0404996499,
0.0377408005,
-0.0045658126,
0.004114537,
0.0306102391,
0.0199625883,
0.0094960611,
-0.0243312232,
-0.0062164348,
-0.0073478683,
0.0317740552,
-0.0761971772,
0.0126737729,
-0.015581239,
0.081012167,
0.0242251568,
-0.0016985482,
-0.018037945,
-0.071528174,
0.0198130514,
0.0027861984,
0.037688721,
0.0048310128,
0.019804582,
-0.0501064695,
0.0069472804,
-0.0230456013,
0.035644386,
0.0202668943,
-0.0376626439,
-0.01654852,
0.069216758,
-0.0095457193,
-0.0740864277,
0.0212786216,
-0.0113689676,
0.0125503819,
0.0519543104,
0.0348252617,
-0.0194213483,
0.0168094505,
-0.0065735676,
-0.0136462627,
0.0214011464,
-0.0847218856,
0.0493913479,
0.0641843677,
-0.0227550846,
-0.0713701397,
0.0008156638,
0.0407252349,
0.0204907227,
0.0230142549,
0.0027343237,
-0.0445910767,
-0.0374530926,
-0.0344189331,
0.0370824374,
-0.0702605471,
0.0464569144,
-0.0036869694,
-0.0342065357,
0.0174596254,
-0.0554153845,
0.0122135226,
-0.0150929987,
-0.0273400135,
-0.0714367256,
0.0248557217,
0.0320133381,
0.0339229777,
0.0503213741,
0.0315664373,
-0.0891929343,
0.0870508701,
0.024654096,
-0.0074043931,
0.0688952133,
-0.0326617844,
0.0131189339,
-0.0184807554,
0.0304486118,
-0.0083513549,
-0.0146023473,
0.0331213884,
-0.0240612403,
-0.0370045677,
-0.0307422187,
0.0188926868,
-0.0047621937,
0.0131193846,
-0.0060276543,
0.0465732031,
-0.0137812132,
-0.0145606324,
-0.0211473722,
-0.0215595271,
0.0132951532,
-0.0518749952,
0.0303599238,
0.0524954945,
0.0637510493,
-0.0173610151,
-0.027610857,
0.0033618845,
-0.0085427454,
-0.0006128277,
0.0105169723,
0.0015255741,
0.0085208854,
0.0431511216,
0.0103696818,
0.0424027219,
-0.0286665708,
0.0631603971,
0.0422728546,
0.0380957089,
0.0386193283,
-0.0190033671,
-0.0382776707,
0.0049483217,
-0.0545312911,
-0.0595231913,
0.0207807645,
0.0359224826,
0.0116270576,
-0.0313831121,
0.0090348339,
-0.0481462479,
0.0316485055,
0.0226607472,
-0.0205497537,
0.0070139421,
-0.0415680595,
0.0592692718,
0.0151845627,
-0.0279484671,
0.0160324201,
0.0628662258,
0.0291139744,
0.0388717055,
-0.0474901795,
0.0045703789,
-0.0097780367,
-0.0610278174,
0.0127481585,
0.0233286079,
-0.0177033674,
0.0100066205,
-0.0537453592,
-0.0604379214,
-0.0229601525,
-0.0027560969,
0.0272599664,
-0.048992265,
0.0065283016,
0.0285162143,
-0.0015308317,
-0.0129580842,
-0.0102642765,
0.0138883544,
0.0358153619,
0.0084497454,
-0.024850294,
-6.09798825e-33,
-0.0247829128,
-0.0738088936,
0.0053091953,
-0.0220275708,
-0.0173320696,
-0.0041289558,
-0.008373851,
0.0411377698,
0.0266280081,
-0.0203969385,
-0.0108702173,
-0.0227217264,
0.0096727796,
-0.0033697044,
0.0021350419,
0.0025354298,
0.0195196476,
-0.0007798558,
-0.0289039798,
-0.0338651612,
0.0141204344,
-0.007248098,
0.0303025674,
-0.0820175931,
0.0475263521,
0.0041121021,
-0.0295233596,
0.0110986549,
-0.0421952419,
-0.0031351389,
0.0027525323,
0.0124674728,
0.0449571908,
-0.0176635832,
-0.0066684536,
0.1026175842,
-0.0011865775,
-0.0152196568,
0.0824436396,
0.0079450291,
-0.051343333,
-0.0571400672,
0.0414645113,
-0.029928105,
-0.0165324304,
0.0081318663,
0.0334416442,
-0.0187089294,
0.0446632579,
0.0200797245,
-0.0606181845,
-0.0254389588,
0.0101729762,
-0.0049067,
-0.0060899793,
0.0120189171,
-0.0144370794,
-0.0369673744,
-0.0335480236,
0.0466195866,
-0.009293952,
-0.031547647,
0.037324857,
0.0807821155,
0.0005815127,
0.0687776953,
0.0361084826,
0.0631067455,
-0.0443909727,
-0.0419350564,
0.0272546671,
0.0492867976,
0.0398885719,
0.0433375798,
0.0117714694,
-0.0084545957,
0.0225732941,
-0.0171472691,
0.0176373087,
-0.0207985118,
0.0429846197,
-0.0002230501,
0.0405973569,
-0.0177504402,
-0.0507260226,
-0.0302418675,
-0.0385864004,
-0.0399076715,
0.0204443056,
0.0086764069,
-0.0326189883,
0.0046566487,
0.0210613236,
-0.0464316681,
-0.0515599251,
-0.0607624985,
-0.0189657528,
0.0143375704,
-0.0130217131,
-0.0129953511,
-0.0262750704,
-0.0659360141,
0.0684271455,
0.0170375742,
0.0387933142,
0.0333156511,
0.0165472105,
-0.0145617304,
-0.0405904055,
-0.013909271,
-0.0477106832,
0.0253559612,
0.0361162573,
0.0116850166,
0.0520447269,
-0.0108672893,
-0.0396555476,
-0.0745999739,
0.0014702502,
-0.0597556941,
-0.052040115,
0.0508370176,
-0.0711653382,
0.0077354345,
-0.0343542844,
0.0030190295,
-0.0203517247,
0.0100039057,
0.0289376602,
-0.0024939466,
-0.0068295253,
-0.044256378,
2.658e-7,
-0.009422252,
0.0499617122,
-0.0363634937,
0.0033736315,
0.0318550766,
0.0242265966,
-0.0043905112,
0.0378702357,
0.0498023033,
-0.0869286135,
-0.0345337167,
0.0267152656,
0.0320721641,
-0.000482769,
-0.0822771043,
-0.0129109407,
0.0065379976,
0.031029392,
-0.0388349183,
-0.0156191196,
0.0429391898,
0.0283161514,
0.0315261148,
-0.0440050438,
-0.0051132068,
-0.079295367,
0.064582929,
-0.0176719371,
0.0172781553,
-0.0252017658,
0.0179508235,
0.0523792133,
0.013771724,
0.0861919597,
0.0115198968,
0.0287542026,
-0.0325403735,
0.0187193695,
-0.0055121463,
0.006259433,
-0.0271985196,
0.0001727596,
-0.0106164124,
-0.0368153602,
0.0557902493,
-0.0570481867,
-0.0160296168,
-0.0286719836,
-0.0178838074,
-0.0194007605,
-0.0177072585,
-0.0341904387,
-0.0294497292,
0.0537735671,
0.0059980606,
0.0314769782,
-0.0022086662,
-0.0833403468,
-0.0398658998,
-0.0158267748,
-0.0609506778,
-0.0325784832,
-0.0145799909,
0.0270788316,
0.0140383383,
-0.0222469475,
0.0299854819,
1.921391434e-34,
-0.0358887427,
0.0663778856,
0.0294863768,
0.0173006449,
0.0283440426,
0.0065831151,
-0.0019494016,
0.0342984609,
0.02520735,
-0.0165447239,
-0.0029967215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14929v1 | Aligning Language Models to User Opinions | 2023-05-24T09:11:11 | 2023-05-24T09:11:11 | EunJeong Hwang, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Niket Tandon | cs.CL | cs.CL | An important aspect of developing LLMs that interact with humans is to align
models' behavior to their users. It is possible to prompt an LLM into behaving
as a certain persona, especially a user group or ideological persona the model
captured during its pertaining stage. But, how to best align an LLM with a
specific user and not a demographic or ideological group remains an open
question. Mining public opinion surveys (by Pew Research), we find that the
opinions of a user and their demographics and ideologies are not mutual
predictors. We use this insight to align LLMs by modeling both user opinions as
well as user demographics and ideology, achieving up to 7 points accuracy gains
in predicting public opinions from survey questions across a broad set of
topics. In addition to the typical approach of prompting LLMs with demographics
and ideology, we discover that utilizing the most relevant past opinions from
individual users enables the model to predict user opinions more accurately. | [
0.0304204263,
0.0894141868,
-0.0098079266,
0.0274603665,
-0.0261825174,
-0.0036291822,
-0.0155772408,
-0.0362197421,
-0.0017965108,
-0.0514799356,
-0.0348965004,
-0.0511277914,
-0.0183619913,
-0.0258258171,
-0.004708108,
-0.0285950098,
0.0436799079,
0.0352976806,
0.0415099822,
-0.0313753076,
0.0500448681,
0.0662891939,
0.0028678644,
0.0330119394,
-0.0093820635,
-0.0065005836,
-0.0158609413,
0.0039751548,
0.0449606143,
0.0390078239,
0.0277037211,
0.0382152647,
-0.0068580187,
0.0071511418,
0.0000016891,
-0.0383018926,
-0.0111096967,
-0.0295662805,
0.0255149864,
-0.0318310447,
0.0871298686,
0.0329717919,
-0.0356123634,
0.0273606759,
-0.0725531727,
0.0503805801,
0.0299266577,
0.033443816,
0.0593788102,
0.0324925743,
-0.0023600287,
-0.0297558922,
-0.0214789938,
0.0271095671,
-0.0064797895,
0.0235768594,
0.0162984077,
-0.0323958136,
-0.0550629236,
0.0109821716,
-0.0035873619,
0.0195492618,
-0.0041347053,
-0.0097475508,
-0.0008252537,
-0.01640971,
-0.0088460911,
-0.0367404632,
0.0107287951,
0.0511910282,
0.0351773426,
-0.0376096927,
0.017024368,
0.005205635,
0.0025348258,
0.0328472704,
-0.0240735281,
-0.0109396689,
-0.0156642701,
0.0346089862,
0.0339123197,
-0.0087407893,
0.0384700783,
0.0535786971,
-0.0245043039,
0.123835437,
-0.0090588471,
-0.0207162313,
-0.0066882647,
0.0194419194,
0.0301009584,
-0.0263817236,
0.016310703,
-0.0163030066,
-0.0199234951,
0.0506202355,
-0.0433618352,
0.0246406421,
0.0272595659,
-0.0580771714,
0.0180653036,
0.0381114259,
0.0124278003,
0.0421998091,
0.0503145084,
-0.0040246244,
-0.015295662,
0.0293116961,
-0.0073395213,
-0.0216530636,
-0.0294227377,
-0.0074229054,
0.0278057605,
-0.0002990068,
0.0475117899,
0.0263874736,
-0.0534283966,
0.0336065218,
-0.0338256583,
0.0265388396,
0.0007244876,
0.0026516647,
-0.0106601715,
-0.0320938863,
-0.0687560737,
0.0808440596,
-0.0193510652,
0.0305441786,
-0.0153967254,
-0.0429499336,
0.0584592111,
0.0406069681,
-0.031985525,
-0.0239517521,
-0.0082365116,
0.0151302395,
0.0266095828,
0.0316914842,
-0.0463780388,
-0.0251162108,
-0.0109568378,
-0.0587911233,
-0.0085770069,
-0.0825708359,
0.0489876457,
0.0203825571,
0.002615429,
-0.0564864464,
-0.0003786543,
0.0477790274,
-0.0296801366,
0.0661537796,
0.0018747842,
0.0268318411,
0.0524187498,
0.0138481595,
0.0522737131,
0.0850089118,
0.0180197507,
-0.0087371189,
0.0343807861,
-0.0419379137,
-0.0110874008,
0.0530340523,
-0.0258549098,
0.0101470919,
-0.0245999079,
0.0234288387,
-0.0437681638,
0.0017190913,
0.0474225469,
0.0785159469,
0.0423180498,
-0.0249383729,
0.0782947987,
0.0761180446,
-0.0114672994,
0.0292852633,
0.0146972919,
0.034317147,
-0.0021002486,
0.0088711251,
-0.0324592665,
0.0228228364,
-0.0143517544,
-0.0184171721,
0.0101488093,
0.0651211217,
-0.0200737733,
-0.0436180979,
-0.0310895406,
-0.0198000055,
0.0421963185,
0.020089969,
0.021368796,
-0.031206347,
0.0133320447,
0.0694450438,
0.0351056606,
-0.0753280073,
0.0116481772,
-0.0362572409,
0.0230635498,
0.0634574443,
-0.0181742609,
0.0021896753,
-0.0331956074,
-0.035656862,
0.0160178896,
0.0492344685,
0.0824576467,
-0.0196191873,
-0.0472739823,
-0.03598563,
-0.015146167,
0.0407364182,
-0.0064603523,
0.0269508325,
0.0439369939,
0.0164587181,
-0.0041409256,
-0.0544865578,
-0.0107416064,
0.0191681255,
-0.0534072071,
0.0028250501,
-0.0230106954,
0.0158249177,
0.0625887588,
0.0391146392,
0.0161471814,
-0.0165889673,
0.0188930761,
0.0054536685,
-0.0381970145,
0.0169756562,
-0.0241127517,
0.0094794463,
0.0430639908,
-0.0123642581,
-0.0219111405,
0.0328890234,
-0.017744448,
-0.0153309256,
0.0444307365,
-0.02537705,
0.0370419174,
-0.0385802947,
-0.0012993747,
-0.0346812196,
-0.0157848746,
-0.0565163866,
0.0258819442,
-0.0239550322,
0.0021080452,
0.019701574,
-0.0425309204,
0.0191342477,
0.0003842687,
-0.0591321476,
-0.0003890856,
0.0277773701,
0.0489710607,
0.0655730814,
-0.0222545769,
-0.058965195,
-0.0328223854,
-0.0455866195,
-0.0160889253,
-0.0207655951,
0.0254727192,
0.019975055,
-0.015550293,
-0.0034970997,
0.0097940322,
-0.0845733136,
-0.017882511,
-0.0007592078,
0.0186429042,
0.062032897,
-0.027529845,
-0.0079611233,
-0.0594155528,
0.0020131413,
-0.0315682925,
0.0101066902,
-0.0110554602,
-0.0336784162,
-0.0089516221,
-0.0065367674,
-0.0852312446,
0.0010850547,
-0.0288950652,
-0.0413161367,
0.0234566554,
-0.0052456548,
0.0344274044,
0.0350518934,
0.0409089252,
0.0403019376,
0.0360650532,
0.0328504555,
-0.0915376917,
-0.0210755207,
-0.0351723321,
-0.0153481597,
-0.0376904905,
-0.0535238646,
0.031335365,
0.076657474,
0.0254477989,
-0.0039179991,
-0.0546235032,
0.0393754654,
-0.0201350413,
-0.0250936504,
0.0092067402,
0.0056134909,
-0.0229934882,
0.0308004282,
-0.0000780811,
-0.043097619,
0.0683493391,
0.0136995129,
0.0255679563,
-0.0008026909,
-0.0369496644,
-0.0394144543,
-0.0033852358,
-0.0022740168,
0.0238920748,
0.0077505219,
0.0028910621,
-0.074574694,
-0.0277960859,
-0.0015020783,
-0.070402056,
0.0524108112,
-0.0310783572,
0.0238712095,
0.0388762169,
-0.0324228108,
-0.031880904,
-0.0483229011,
-0.0346489064,
-0.0188346133,
0.025234608,
-0.034784697,
-0.0079094134,
-0.0236670133,
0.0199345797,
-0.0738445893,
0.0046630581,
-0.0043634619,
0.0099507524,
0.0010232058,
0.0613076687,
0.0129635101,
-0.0045604259,
-0.0268546585,
0.0053998078,
0.0299443528,
0.0057712281,
0.0125115765,
-0.0456275903,
-0.049176801,
0.0644372031,
-0.0244983267,
-0.0350278541,
0.0118799964,
0.0531004891,
-0.01777808,
0.0424577557,
0.1146579534,
0.0313299336,
-0.0503577068,
-0.0201717559,
-0.0312881544,
0.0173598807,
0.0246611182,
0.0261825491,
-0.0776633546,
0.0082747461,
-0.0185499247,
0.0082568666,
-0.0290320814,
0.0033309243,
-0.0232969467,
-0.1174166873,
-0.0229413304,
0.0180750918,
0.0023005877,
0.0188529082,
-0.025067579,
0.0353258103,
-0.0278670229,
0.0420154184,
-0.0262915157,
0.0226509944,
0.008317776,
0.0081161559,
-0.1025869697,
-0.0526398048,
0.0220164489,
-0.0186068155,
0.0505020656,
0.0484041832,
0.068087548,
0.0029237431,
-0.06201813,
0.0368254259,
0.0061178347,
-0.0085720131,
-0.0127809718,
0.022632705,
-0.0380049944,
0.0090371035,
-0.0451347418,
0.0356754437,
-0.017242847,
-0.0091754617,
-0.0154653089,
0.0446686335,
-0.0487682745,
-0.0192598961,
-0.0289461371,
0.0497203469,
0.0169814546,
0.0712509081,
0.0160191152,
-0.0882013142,
0.0089728078,
-0.0664027706,
-0.0141908703,
-0.015905872,
-0.0684457049,
-0.0302872211,
-0.0079894019,
-0.0056774626,
-0.036511369,
-0.0576398186,
-0.0122150173,
-0.0127306674,
0.012705965,
0.0047393912,
0.0436185189,
-0.0297976751,
-0.0161928162,
0.0313330106,
-0.0250179358,
0.0339113399,
-0.0435602665,
-0.0443318672,
0.0557294264,
-0.0160694122,
0.0013657251,
-0.0190890227,
-0.0344534591,
-0.078734301,
0.0399438329,
0.0363518707,
0.0205577575,
0.0521311462,
0.0052499864,
-0.0500431508,
0.0344632044,
0.0466270559,
0.003839236,
-0.000881947,
0.0038758812,
0.0866008475,
-0.0045907455,
0.042632889,
-0.0102591943,
0.0071948566,
0.0210734718,
-0.0393066071,
-0.1233717352,
-0.0760842487,
0.0143309636,
0.0078196926,
0.0439893231,
-0.0048031425,
-0.0071566859,
-0.0102425972,
-0.0504108667,
-0.0159279313,
-0.0327263549,
0.0059304684,
-0.0482336842,
0.042008739,
-0.0116819814,
-0.0087738587,
0.0064556804,
-0.0376135483,
0.0134345731,
-0.0267652217,
0.0335735567,
-0.019404456,
0.0231320634,
0.0138428863,
0.0143265277,
-0.0092101162,
0.0370785482,
0.0057492037,
0.027942067,
0.0297286659,
0.0458232313,
-0.0121536627,
0.0240887385,
0.0336680897,
0.0136265121,
-0.0342057012,
-0.0516495593,
-0.0156874023,
0.0072040041,
0.0025208862,
0.0046880897,
0.0506124534,
-0.000771984,
-0.0076707765,
-0.0235647373,
0.0594357178,
0.0148233315,
-0.0409699529,
0.0582798831,
-0.0032290958,
-0.0409090221,
-0.031526383,
0.0400117487,
-0.0090717608,
-0.0039407825,
-0.0019875616,
-0.028753927,
-0.0389196984,
-0.0109088793,
0.0026178434,
-0.0086816773,
-0.0288057532,
-0.031420406,
-0.0574557669,
-0.0455945656,
0.0191660039,
0.0225644428,
-0.0132377371,
-0.0305200797,
0.0329336748,
0.0641792715,
-0.0338543728,
0.0354749411,
-0.06805861,
-0.0002119979,
-0.0589498356,
-0.0177071486,
-0.0228989013,
-5.847505464e-33,
-0.0360872895,
-0.0220011119,
0.0206985325,
0.0064612739,
-0.0335708633,
-0.0459579825,
-0.0256193317,
0.063733831,
-0.0335300863,
0.0034746756,
-0.0008620907,
0.0326529816,
0.0095534967,
0.0201604217,
0.0361637697,
-0.0228369087,
0.0296698082,
-0.0048285569,
-0.0086796619,
-0.020580722,
0.0282830279,
0.0037341171,
0.0495296977,
-0.1039583385,
0.055127874,
0.0178467426,
-0.0214311033,
-0.0050910208,
-0.0012797831,
0.0439854898,
-0.0123184798,
0.0696498752,
0.0182541646,
-0.0322891586,
-0.0093366625,
0.0795997083,
-0.0140729016,
-0.0244301707,
0.0350851007,
0.0424335822,
-0.0041280417,
-0.0316102691,
0.0334041528,
-0.0248944238,
-0.0505937338,
0.0023981666,
0.0584586412,
-0.0052955905,
0.0424579158,
-0.0130543597,
-0.0203149896,
0.0034982003,
-0.0153014716,
0.0115898298,
-0.020565521,
0.0333314799,
0.0025758618,
0.0397919454,
-0.0556811094,
0.0539784618,
-0.037129838,
0.0181424823,
0.0972379521,
0.0153171262,
0.0008111339,
0.0867285579,
0.014434699,
0.014653299,
-0.0569198653,
-0.0217399914,
0.0503741354,
-0.0096423728,
0.0200220365,
0.0639401674,
-0.0206762981,
-0.0100580258,
0.0118428329,
0.0236846413,
0.0815436319,
-0.0019370983,
0.0278019365,
-0.0064308695,
-0.0323337764,
-0.0427922159,
-0.0174705014,
-0.0467268154,
-0.0108244726,
-0.0332464688,
-0.013594673,
-0.0413000248,
-0.0191681087,
-0.027769478,
0.0046609356,
-0.0483094342,
-0.0499382503,
0.0139617808,
-0.0500496738,
-0.0106299408,
-0.0020507025,
0.0353935175,
-0.0621009208,
0.0244972184,
-0.0585536063,
0.0024853013,
0.0023355898,
0.0127403103,
0.0085730189,
0.0182501506,
-0.0975092128,
-0.0248561092,
-0.013715799,
0.0042515737,
-0.0069808476,
0.0245397426,
0.0455071926,
0.0139658228,
-0.0035687794,
0.0250554234,
0.0158166774,
0.0120901437,
0.0015524023,
-0.0355883874,
-0.0431399569,
0.0164367352,
-0.039073009,
-0.0335351452,
-0.0331607424,
0.0428341031,
0.020456735,
-0.0313478485,
-0.0234948844,
-0.0229565203,
2.374e-7,
0.0721833259,
0.0492135212,
-0.0298293047,
0.0185879264,
-0.0138428053,
0.0396028906,
0.0105060628,
0.0209436994,
0.0065645324,
-0.0434639305,
0.0043944502,
0.0151778776,
0.0615333244,
0.0282440484,
-0.1133284941,
0.0118562151,
-0.0230799485,
0.0416214541,
-0.0461162589,
0.0523070879,
0.0239945129,
0.0481487624,
0.044534754,
-0.0140024349,
-0.0392527841,
0.0034550985,
0.0499148928,
-0.0632096455,
-0.0330507755,
0.0436970443,
0.0356324054,
-0.0167555157,
0.0150495013,
0.0158987287,
-0.0159284845,
0.0021707108,
-0.0213900357,
0.0765826777,
0.0104470858,
-0.0468328334,
-0.0074570081,
0.008905231,
-0.0142356772,
-0.0152324447,
0.0461834259,
-0.0361244753,
-0.0268198624,
-0.0592844225,
-0.0169231277,
-0.0038758698,
0.011252637,
-0.0201146621,
-0.0422225744,
0.0010070144,
0.023391813,
-0.0345329233,
-0.0281267073,
-0.0503045917,
-0.024913324,
-0.0211857148,
-0.0465956144,
-0.0589747094,
0.0196684115,
0.05340508,
0.0106996372,
-0.0209310912,
0.0238148551,
1.763064972e-34,
0.0312593356,
0.0225649551,
0.0167052597,
-0.0150038777,
0.0369481482,
0.0245353635,
0.0139945131,
0.0095333429,
0.0458919369,
-0.0404326469,
0.0070541534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14928v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14928v3 | Towards Reliable Misinformation Mitigation: Generalization, Uncertainty, and GPT-4 | 2023-05-24T09:10:20 | 2023-10-31T07:19:01 | Kellin Pelrine, Anne Imouza, Camille Thibault, Meilina Reksoprodjo, Caleb Gupta, Joel Christoph, Jean-François Godbout, Reihaneh Rabbany | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Misinformation poses a critical societal challenge, and current approaches
have yet to produce an effective solution. We propose focusing on
generalization, uncertainty, and how to leverage recent large language models,
in order to create more practical tools to evaluate information veracity in
contexts where perfect classification is impossible. We first demonstrate that
GPT-4 can outperform prior methods in multiple settings and languages. Next, we
explore generalization, revealing that GPT-4 and RoBERTa-large exhibit
differences in failure modes. Third, we propose techniques to handle
uncertainty that can detect impossible examples and strongly improve outcomes.
We also discuss results on other language models, temperature, prompting,
versioning, explainability, and web retrieval, each one providing practical
insights and directions for future research. Finally, we publish the LIAR-New
dataset with novel paired English and French misinformation data and
Possibility labels that indicate if there is sufficient context for veracity
evaluation. Overall, this research lays the groundwork for future tools that
can drive real-world progress to combat misinformation. | [
0.0513698906,
0.0527266935,
-0.005982534,
0.0311395247,
-0.027011035,
0.0134359207,
-0.0003554161,
0.0273013189,
-0.0060618371,
-0.0271823835,
0.0227769762,
-0.0608569942,
0.0189375672,
0.0083969636,
0.0118479189,
-0.0328789651,
0.0674086511,
-0.0026596787,
0.052663181,
-0.0325761251,
0.0191996675,
0.0102509893,
0.0199134871,
0.0419617742,
-0.0349027216,
-0.0089236349,
0.0152484262,
0.0044048633,
0.0256517138,
-0.0134842228,
0.0022785505,
0.0531873628,
0.0279531386,
0.0897658989,
0.0000018984,
-0.0172732044,
-0.0200669691,
0.0128041431,
-0.0546350628,
0.0137823429,
0.0165766478,
-0.0390932895,
0.0043625413,
0.0426739715,
-0.0028212029,
-0.0424632244,
0.0556133017,
0.0658851117,
0.0677213892,
0.0943730474,
-0.0011362558,
-0.0183000732,
0.0167092886,
-0.0171721689,
0.0519999787,
-0.0471884646,
0.0515105836,
-0.0097179729,
-0.0548909865,
0.0531351566,
0.036049813,
0.0264479294,
0.010298498,
0.0104684457,
-0.0750979185,
0.0238278192,
-0.0011154093,
-0.0500426292,
0.02342242,
0.0247630514,
0.0134391952,
-0.0588160567,
0.0093771638,
0.0068304627,
0.0179956686,
0.0701418072,
-0.0011908403,
0.0209546741,
-0.0321426578,
0.0238510016,
0.0110072047,
-0.0017309341,
0.0694530457,
0.0130558945,
0.0436002575,
0.0813726857,
-0.0037231112,
-0.0130942836,
0.010716862,
-0.0159495566,
-0.0329353884,
-0.0492810011,
-0.0111428089,
-0.0093686311,
-0.0323248692,
0.0159936715,
-0.0627629608,
0.0209798981,
0.0679206774,
-0.0678066611,
-0.00775882,
0.0033705961,
0.0116539681,
0.0459748134,
0.0195092149,
0.0321030207,
-0.0142264469,
0.0134709589,
0.00439703,
-0.0527854599,
-0.0350321531,
0.0046285796,
-0.0235107429,
-0.0098580644,
-0.0016336514,
0.0345035829,
-0.0504044704,
-0.0160370748,
-0.0564794131,
0.0366699472,
-0.0216079783,
0.003489553,
-0.0395751446,
-0.0298332162,
-0.0389484689,
0.0059589096,
-0.0258072875,
0.0238358304,
-0.0167687628,
-0.0665579215,
-0.0032409898,
0.0121389106,
-0.0379617438,
-0.0006814796,
-0.0018191143,
0.0183593817,
0.0159899462,
0.0043110633,
-0.0242454708,
-0.0313963443,
-0.0240671411,
-0.0612732023,
-0.0421940908,
-0.0539487414,
-0.0171490442,
-0.0137170423,
-0.0004153388,
-0.0404801369,
-0.0054671629,
-0.0027044674,
-0.0647848994,
0.0899046585,
-0.0396830179,
-0.0009319395,
0.0636292472,
0.0418497734,
-0.0304134861,
0.0590963028,
0.0001329385,
0.0390591957,
0.0769774392,
0.0095408894,
0.0795898736,
-0.0074711982,
0.0464822091,
0.0175906122,
0.0413221009,
-0.0122073628,
0.0035025475,
-0.0270718783,
-0.0172986165,
0.0613611192,
-0.0271103848,
-0.0734560937,
0.0677917898,
-0.0443038344,
-0.0418072864,
-0.0025539692,
0.0196531173,
0.0234962925,
-0.0082106413,
-0.0094511425,
-0.052054666,
-0.0141093498,
-0.0886650309,
-0.0032768638,
0.0439075008,
0.0073904889,
-0.0163952745,
-0.0383097865,
-0.0385821387,
-0.021681169,
0.024803929,
-0.0005405402,
0.0197622906,
-0.0332794823,
-0.0464856327,
0.0344724655,
0.0496042706,
-0.0260640141,
-0.006706865,
-0.0481029153,
0.0061149793,
0.0504436158,
0.0269266833,
-0.0416498184,
-0.0039013396,
-0.041225452,
0.0145674767,
-0.0030128765,
0.0621520802,
0.0003764837,
0.0145933125,
-0.0275047794,
-0.0077981036,
0.0055745025,
0.0489748903,
0.012123974,
0.0469956994,
0.0272298027,
-0.0022353958,
-0.0672926903,
-0.0260916986,
0.0134265777,
0.0177929979,
-0.0100144194,
-0.0148089109,
0.0008813794,
0.0394404717,
0.0025122487,
-0.0165222809,
-0.0214193854,
0.0414962545,
0.0037384839,
-0.055316139,
-0.0301671643,
0.0114272237,
0.0001197435,
0.0364596918,
-0.0246112719,
-0.0378363207,
0.0257642046,
-0.0445493832,
-0.0094721522,
0.0169192329,
-0.0396871381,
0.0316085778,
-0.0432923436,
0.0003760501,
-0.0363709889,
0.0204753354,
0.0008883344,
0.0741518065,
-0.02428459,
0.0219831709,
-0.0110676475,
-0.0302805789,
0.0238967724,
-0.0324027836,
-0.0190669149,
-0.0151747456,
0.0159411076,
0.0253737085,
0.0573310219,
-0.0235838015,
0.0116645787,
-0.0232067239,
-0.0651674122,
-0.0262506567,
-0.0225430559,
0.0065665487,
0.0066945832,
-0.0258869007,
-0.001671246,
-0.0022434818,
-0.0181165244,
-0.001584956,
-0.0119827464,
0.0125101907,
0.0248604212,
0.0033920091,
-0.0292678792,
-0.0045601102,
0.0079398593,
0.0052748728,
0.0371227935,
0.0137938363,
-0.0380776152,
-0.0628531799,
0.0123383924,
-0.0617836863,
0.0316044316,
-0.0360531509,
-0.0268957708,
-0.0094007086,
0.0270678774,
-0.0239932369,
-0.0248079393,
0.0415505692,
0.0332326293,
0.0311511029,
0.0274917986,
-0.0316506177,
-0.015170766,
-0.0614517815,
-0.032804843,
-0.0178765412,
-0.095272921,
-0.0023405163,
0.005686875,
0.0543006659,
-0.0116391573,
-0.0586723611,
0.0381076857,
-0.0178148318,
-0.0272227079,
-0.0163748059,
-0.0408093072,
-0.0041285693,
0.0398428105,
-0.0257348903,
-0.0661311448,
0.1061981469,
-0.0355353951,
0.0546876751,
-0.0218921527,
-0.0190071724,
0.0419239402,
0.0210490096,
-0.0098439427,
0.0305641871,
0.0554357842,
0.0081491834,
0.0051703923,
-0.0314265154,
0.0798176602,
-0.0275072288,
0.0205076262,
-0.0472571813,
0.0203337613,
0.0388624407,
-0.0398157686,
-0.0407802425,
-0.0864821896,
0.0143167824,
-0.0313248187,
0.0117138121,
-0.0450692512,
-0.0729540437,
-0.0162038393,
0.0160835739,
0.0354215503,
-0.0058227954,
-0.0040169125,
0.0003238246,
-0.0126269879,
0.027212901,
-0.0321842805,
0.0791609511,
-0.0519445129,
-0.0318231806,
0.0572799221,
0.0139898704,
0.004474706,
0.009710866,
-0.0494840965,
-0.0007748191,
-0.0059307981,
-0.0317812301,
0.0183818191,
0.0311609656,
-0.0397907943,
-0.0103639932,
0.1126544103,
0.0306901373,
-0.0316451825,
-0.0249686204,
0.0000057318,
0.0360328592,
0.016029289,
-0.0160111263,
-0.0582423098,
-0.0241781902,
0.0303447004,
0.0248787701,
-0.0428161696,
-0.0175918192,
0.0007331833,
-0.0484871902,
0.0373360813,
0.0057225963,
-0.0228465367,
-0.0622987933,
-0.0818143785,
-0.015380688,
0.0025751085,
0.0229683463,
-0.0216455832,
0.0443517603,
-0.0090401703,
-0.0000824733,
-0.0401841551,
-0.0681934059,
0.0141191594,
-0.022261057,
0.0817870125,
0.0347895063,
0.0135855759,
-0.0175548121,
-0.0482973717,
0.0161952116,
0.0083368989,
-0.0569523089,
-0.0093559735,
0.0767630339,
0.013124275,
0.0054472955,
-0.0231051557,
0.0037153098,
-0.0036557461,
-0.007999666,
-0.0102725197,
0.0516373888,
0.0028862476,
-0.0547923781,
-0.0008237414,
-0.0132226786,
0.0456835367,
0.0959827974,
-0.0130380942,
0.0264164098,
-0.0220421441,
-0.0582299158,
0.0651546717,
0.0284480359,
0.0016048938,
0.0279106274,
0.0175443143,
-0.0715053082,
-0.0348677151,
0.0026928594,
-0.0172940996,
0.0066083353,
-0.0148878982,
-0.0027797727,
0.0269521624,
0.0095539326,
-0.0464066304,
-0.0106613757,
-0.0228315126,
0.0339022353,
-0.0451302752,
-0.0100027248,
-0.002850923,
-0.0130851744,
-0.0007036497,
0.0357914194,
-0.043184597,
-0.0779471919,
0.0179020539,
0.0066032456,
0.0382277407,
0.048754178,
-0.0361733511,
-0.0515453853,
0.0397818871,
0.0326758176,
-0.0014947284,
-0.0040676892,
0.0451702885,
-0.0073252651,
0.0302343983,
0.0426305979,
-0.0326711014,
0.0192561615,
-0.0089916112,
-0.0222467761,
-0.0694227964,
-0.0100508388,
0.0440981872,
0.0183473155,
0.029025713,
-0.0060015051,
0.011554162,
-0.0314978398,
-0.0240911879,
-0.0073674438,
-0.0182424206,
0.0134713827,
0.0224892329,
0.035713207,
-0.0235407464,
0.0100192297,
0.0110824648,
-0.0185085647,
-0.0007267691,
-0.0201248098,
-0.0505057089,
0.0154382018,
0.0529034808,
0.0103876665,
-0.0319840088,
-0.0072438079,
0.0191583447,
0.0057020304,
0.0335362107,
-0.0060714399,
0.0227882545,
0.0262524355,
-0.0265426692,
0.0124880308,
-0.0241519604,
-0.0510327034,
-0.0388691016,
-0.0387896001,
0.0308630373,
0.0345303044,
0.0484437346,
0.0444684327,
-0.0266290549,
-0.0398294702,
-0.0171431322,
-0.0075004958,
0.0438250639,
-0.0172700286,
0.0228540357,
0.0031548524,
-0.0482568964,
0.0594053827,
0.0787583888,
0.0069016735,
0.0460346267,
-0.0130947074,
-0.1040068194,
-0.0218804423,
-0.0070178416,
-0.0268463995,
0.0404808074,
-0.0046820459,
-0.0054133427,
-0.0804313794,
-0.054907538,
0.0109283393,
0.0314941034,
0.0083245365,
0.0167090446,
-0.0218111947,
0.0931281745,
0.0159538984,
-0.0198945999,
-0.0712042376,
-0.0134230694,
0.026367873,
-0.0003509918,
-0.0046508308,
-6.674517168e-33,
0.0053455192,
-0.0384436511,
-0.0525697917,
-0.0267442968,
0.0196956974,
0.0436303541,
0.0065065897,
-0.0146545591,
-0.0555710606,
0.0677665696,
0.0430495702,
0.0255601536,
0.0087590162,
0.0021667753,
-0.0173305701,
-0.0331731215,
0.0439532995,
0.0217383076,
-0.0465700366,
0.0345490798,
0.073993817,
-0.029904766,
0.0515695177,
-0.0889287367,
0.0800371021,
-0.0241389461,
-0.0382054038,
0.0562829413,
-0.0417369902,
0.0365214869,
0.002852225,
0.0749954507,
0.0044142003,
-0.019954361,
0.0101666506,
-0.0280758422,
-0.0483411625,
-0.0297547225,
0.032633014,
-0.0166053865,
0.0093062911,
-0.0051304428,
0.0254286043,
-0.0056671458,
-0.0385920405,
0.0357984602,
0.012849628,
0.0089384364,
0.0091394596,
-0.000936435,
-0.0160943754,
0.0133415218,
0.0269337595,
-0.0070744017,
-0.016048722,
0.0582317896,
0.0112306764,
0.0069693923,
-0.1342904866,
0.0120686842,
0.0070848796,
-0.0150865745,
0.0348895192,
-0.042843163,
-0.0236390997,
0.0674389675,
0.0190292299,
0.0218669958,
-0.0522072166,
-0.0186044555,
-0.0278495699,
0.0077449135,
0.0644989461,
0.0993014872,
0.0183930118,
-0.0661304072,
-0.0733649135,
0.0291258972,
0.0289039984,
-0.013495029,
0.0539150499,
-0.0204587113,
-0.0850565732,
-0.0489487424,
-0.038092304,
-0.0015947319,
-0.0446398929,
0.0042890431,
0.0048332107,
0.0335602537,
0.0015900598,
0.0093764709,
-0.0033702482,
-0.0259311106,
-0.0158691257,
0.0270028301,
0.0057532135,
-0.004416178,
0.0273628235,
0.0363584869,
-0.0306987874,
-0.0006681947,
0.0094187884,
0.0004628469,
-0.012562667,
-0.0087231426,
0.0476427078,
0.0092619136,
-0.0552357435,
0.0291519817,
-0.0235907845,
0.0500419214,
0.0038910806,
-0.0779109821,
0.0243093614,
-0.0041998448,
0.0052080168,
0.0162782222,
0.0358156301,
0.0286249407,
-0.0090380972,
0.0329275876,
-0.0274021085,
0.0152610736,
0.0067995982,
0.0061740372,
-0.0047908956,
-0.0005800489,
0.0230944995,
-0.0439995714,
-0.0078252973,
-0.0148429368,
2.774e-7,
0.0286280904,
0.05209741,
-0.0032423188,
0.0027335305,
0.0371301919,
0.0851791203,
0.0169756263,
-0.0170258638,
-0.0275949351,
-0.0432643406,
-0.0362101533,
0.0033500497,
0.0183304455,
0.0807014182,
-0.0007612385,
-0.0258362573,
-0.0385576636,
-0.0281675402,
-0.0315575972,
0.0160934646,
0.0500444286,
0.1101852283,
0.066649355,
0.0030382934,
-0.000178479,
-0.0255255252,
0.0546496697,
-0.0242277738,
-0.0422821492,
0.0349298529,
0.0550066829,
0.00857215,
0.0336982347,
0.0235320479,
0.0007068894,
-0.0362209417,
-0.0393364467,
0.0130649116,
-0.0059699798,
-0.0202729572,
-0.0505531915,
-0.0400512218,
0.0098124603,
-0.087937519,
0.0379443392,
-0.0004086063,
-0.0345401876,
0.0018362493,
-0.0307586119,
-0.0013790049,
0.0494582467,
0.0001457733,
-0.0639667585,
0.0227258503,
-0.0212195981,
0.0471425839,
-0.0014428857,
-0.0469100177,
-0.0001064961,
-0.0081225326,
-0.0464374311,
-0.0225058775,
0.0324454531,
-0.0248624384,
0.0174691416,
-0.037344519,
0.053350728,
2.576823207e-34,
0.0591251031,
-0.0184160322,
-0.0150615023,
-0.0296002794,
0.0630617142,
0.0074604396,
0.0138647109,
-0.0206452198,
-0.0014573394,
0.0213995744,
-0.0036042645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14926v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14926v2 | Universal Self-Adaptive Prompting | 2023-05-24T09:09:48 | 2023-10-21T02:25:33 | Xingchen Wan, Ruoxi Sun, Hootan Nakhost, Hanjun Dai, Julian Martin Eisenschlos, Sercan O. Arik, Tomas Pfister | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A hallmark of modern large language models (LLMs) is their impressive general
zero-shot and few-shot abilities, often elicited through in-context learning
(ICL) via prompting. However, while highly coveted and being the most general,
zero-shot performances in LLMs are still typically weaker due to the lack of
guidance and the difficulty of applying existing automatic prompt design
methods in general tasks when ground-truth labels are unavailable. In this
study, we address this by presenting Universal Self-Adaptive Prompting (USP),
an automatic prompt design approach specifically tailored for zero-shot
learning (while compatible with few-shot). Requiring only a small amount of
unlabeled data and an inference-only LLM, USP is highly versatile: to achieve
universal prompting, USP categorizes a possible NLP task into one of the three
possible task types and then uses a corresponding selector to select the most
suitable queries and zero-shot model-generated responses as
pseudo-demonstrations, thereby generalizing ICL to the zero-shot setup in a
fully automated way. We evaluate USP with PaLM and PaLM 2 models and
demonstrate performances that are considerably stronger than standard zero-shot
baselines and often comparable to or even superior to few-shot baselines across
more than 40 natural language understanding, natural language generation, and
reasoning tasks. | [
0.0221025031,
0.0196186733,
0.014681384,
0.0319396183,
-0.0523198992,
0.0133539205,
0.0679443628,
-0.022316834,
0.0196256675,
-0.0930737108,
-0.0257828832,
-0.0196480732,
-0.0349126682,
0.0232095905,
0.0260859337,
-0.0003170395,
0.0520902686,
-0.0416096039,
0.0115532819,
0.0021073495,
-0.0325223245,
0.0228635781,
-0.032851439,
0.0337995589,
-0.0092776148,
-0.0409290604,
-0.0506273992,
0.0078509087,
-0.0231010709,
-0.0602201857,
0.005569634,
0.0792804956,
0.0545805208,
0.0472236834,
0.0000021501,
-0.0708542541,
0.0027454388,
-0.0068469797,
-0.0789957792,
-0.0246065967,
0.0291679278,
-0.0135061089,
0.0123162139,
0.0212724637,
-0.0333425626,
-0.0188011471,
0.0191653855,
0.0511665531,
0.0285012946,
0.0628804713,
0.0000409344,
-0.0102866963,
-0.012169457,
-0.0356880799,
0.0314188004,
-0.0205460973,
0.0095800599,
-0.0496044829,
0.0610789917,
0.0470708571,
-0.0103203161,
0.0234027598,
0.0360608548,
-0.0043993779,
0.0148491943,
0.0498782322,
-0.0395930335,
-0.036014881,
-0.030007042,
0.0888467133,
0.0276571382,
-0.012981995,
0.0047910032,
-0.0148239275,
0.0049306294,
-0.0160625204,
-0.0477621146,
0.0537680946,
0.0396711268,
-0.0021176427,
0.0274328999,
0.0236599799,
0.0188258495,
0.0115419943,
-0.0216027927,
0.0616671145,
0.0150405131,
-0.0447343625,
0.0033335101,
0.0009064293,
-0.0063029095,
-0.086512886,
-0.0596081838,
0.0674430728,
-0.0765694976,
0.0166753475,
-0.0415468886,
0.0015663875,
0.0424361043,
0.0178644173,
0.0644892678,
0.0523955487,
-0.0237633251,
0.0643252805,
-0.0294232331,
0.045284573,
0.0067747547,
0.012215523,
-0.030153174,
0.0147899222,
-0.0385532118,
-0.0011644707,
-0.0318315253,
0.0360086374,
-0.064116329,
-0.0455377474,
-0.0077798232,
0.0451630317,
0.0047770781,
0.02336636,
0.0117335804,
0.0237921625,
-0.0476930812,
-0.004624967,
-0.0067825979,
0.02456926,
-0.0420872532,
0.0046117133,
0.0448497906,
-0.0763680786,
-0.0345660225,
0.0053792847,
0.0212311391,
-0.0299516656,
0.0025533258,
0.0746050403,
-0.0085008796,
-0.074130103,
-0.043971464,
-0.0329531021,
-0.0260436926,
-0.0759163946,
0.0059365425,
-0.0580931865,
0.0262812264,
0.0052990187,
-0.0003376356,
0.0179047026,
0.020070482,
0.0364326946,
-0.0050842925,
0.054959923,
-0.0149867292,
0.0021494341,
0.0073135742,
-0.0138129229,
-0.0232875068,
0.0895041898,
-0.0225153025,
-0.0012613451,
0.0275503807,
0.0136344079,
-0.0038674048,
0.0030147259,
0.0254667085,
0.0159537569,
-0.0175741836,
0.0006319596,
0.0157478582,
0.0345131718,
0.0114192097,
0.0110885035,
-0.0202875007,
-0.0011419627,
0.0435360409,
0.059615843,
-0.0019695451,
-0.0104230996,
0.0682246834,
0.0190334674,
-0.0340331644,
-0.0101299705,
-0.0677778646,
0.0284101106,
-0.0584249943,
0.0191917568,
0.0267637782,
0.010028542,
-0.0593378805,
-0.0236798134,
-0.0181016028,
0.0031792512,
-0.0153318057,
0.0363979191,
0.0410392731,
0.0349577256,
-0.046913635,
-0.0112672942,
0.0049118618,
-0.0343170911,
-0.0139394263,
-0.0476539396,
0.0905263126,
0.044599887,
0.0428994372,
-0.0011121882,
-0.0193620883,
-0.0330809169,
0.0414791368,
0.0752126127,
0.0140076056,
-0.0138516733,
0.0158510525,
-0.0342669375,
-0.0249225907,
-0.0533189625,
0.03435551,
-0.0051742103,
0.0006012704,
0.0030073286,
0.0245642029,
-0.0136939166,
0.0187895913,
0.0385268405,
-0.05410989,
-0.0817010403,
0.0434864052,
0.0033006482,
0.0114947977,
0.0131919654,
-0.0032249484,
0.0086501027,
0.0358202644,
-0.0343533866,
-0.022902282,
-0.0155553399,
-0.0697116852,
-0.0864315331,
0.013007449,
0.0198896714,
-0.0116090514,
-0.0116526438,
-0.0360955186,
-0.0527931303,
0.0072239228,
0.0241509639,
0.011669687,
-0.0539349616,
0.0184520781,
0.0311500467,
-0.0118077062,
-0.0475928299,
0.0622233525,
0.0282778554,
0.0061693769,
0.0535235666,
0.0420091711,
-0.0039629275,
-0.0626575574,
-0.0383887812,
-0.0114196977,
-0.0272417478,
-0.008963285,
0.0097985826,
0.0505512469,
-0.0618871413,
0.0029448534,
-0.0979272872,
0.0286680162,
-0.0365480557,
-0.0137147969,
0.0143927047,
0.0240443051,
-0.0128147695,
-0.0287769306,
-0.0373810306,
-0.0124932602,
0.0298153739,
0.0266537443,
0.030963691,
-0.0050021298,
0.0161686931,
-0.0128809297,
0.0027218808,
-0.0020723033,
0.0476364121,
0.0183792282,
0.0209989417,
-0.0220714584,
0.0435248092,
-0.0154736424,
0.0104786884,
0.0101195564,
0.0133924484,
0.0333870798,
-0.0213994402,
0.0221984312,
0.0656527653,
-0.0192206819,
0.0134413587,
0.0057522338,
-0.0023193678,
-0.0699695572,
0.0280972701,
-0.0326014385,
-0.0260739606,
0.0357211456,
0.0255022049,
0.0197149515,
0.0865389928,
0.003781362,
-0.0133269075,
-0.0569797419,
0.0039904639,
0.0010174835,
-0.024860356,
-0.0557906255,
0.0073233284,
-0.0029017373,
0.0270164069,
-0.0175063852,
-0.0292104091,
0.0502243228,
-0.0215280391,
-0.0036132447,
-0.0303559341,
-0.0044007488,
-0.0296679437,
0.0562478788,
-0.0168768335,
0.0030896398,
0.0400962494,
-0.0025653942,
-0.0414842851,
-0.0134110991,
-0.0119960969,
0.0044431156,
0.0275167543,
-0.0390824601,
0.026000781,
-0.0085253222,
-0.0464433804,
-0.068536371,
-0.0456767529,
-0.0442608818,
0.0306832884,
-0.0510992743,
0.017803736,
0.0152775021,
-0.0127158519,
0.0239338055,
0.0617730133,
-0.0249902792,
-0.0201395378,
-0.0324889831,
0.0331965685,
0.0473253019,
0.0194819923,
-0.000008689,
-0.0257120002,
0.054565493,
0.0454824753,
0.0470664538,
0.0289565101,
-0.0222619157,
0.0383599363,
0.0304855369,
-0.0256989822,
-0.0128625277,
0.0448799394,
0.0670278445,
-0.0590991527,
-0.0210047495,
0.1357306838,
0.0335985087,
-0.0635444224,
0.0061207577,
-0.0346098803,
0.0120473076,
0.0389448665,
0.0227077007,
-0.0901379138,
-0.05840832,
0.0113208191,
0.0114769554,
-0.0265341699,
-0.0421719812,
-0.015164827,
-0.1596234441,
0.0486113131,
-0.0067704008,
-0.0319830924,
0.0273207575,
-0.0386156663,
0.0238086209,
-0.0004804717,
-0.003303414,
0.0305718575,
-0.0104865637,
0.0002398816,
0.0179263875,
0.0386826061,
-0.0760850161,
0.0347665958,
-0.0198137835,
0.0592773631,
0.0380519368,
0.0012250424,
0.0293170251,
-0.019984249,
0.0245445445,
-0.027378615,
0.0281812642,
-0.0408580191,
0.0357771963,
-0.0200531166,
-0.0043806527,
-0.0187327452,
0.0609022826,
-0.0510033034,
-0.0217672661,
0.0186696108,
0.079073891,
-0.018232774,
0.0052377577,
-0.0152029712,
-0.0065761292,
0.0317918509,
0.095187068,
0.0315753706,
-0.0460305549,
-0.0400660597,
-0.0101446453,
-0.0145538021,
-0.0403395481,
0.016628569,
0.0185992382,
-0.0024504606,
-0.022423543,
-0.0609748997,
-0.0337552801,
0.0510841943,
0.0657700375,
0.0133384494,
-0.0033762031,
-0.0219959468,
-0.0059334859,
-0.0104001611,
0.008677572,
-0.0532645583,
0.0034088152,
-0.0827839151,
-0.00091356,
0.0318615735,
-0.0307788923,
0.0078961784,
0.0019391333,
-0.0462755635,
-0.0602731518,
-0.030840015,
0.0395122208,
0.0200401023,
0.0342877172,
-0.0201769862,
-0.0426869318,
0.0595586449,
0.0541632324,
-0.0287145842,
0.0211527348,
0.0044837049,
0.0226501767,
-0.0111419763,
0.0456591956,
-0.0306850486,
0.0288469996,
0.0086041726,
0.0673549175,
-0.0157830101,
-0.032316003,
0.0349037535,
0.0217857827,
0.0397479944,
-0.0182313584,
0.0170237981,
-0.0252682548,
0.0055715921,
-0.0355852321,
-0.0222297497,
-0.0449503548,
0.0105858743,
0.0017040821,
-0.0198954009,
0.0011283655,
-0.0343459211,
-0.0448801219,
0.0835301429,
-0.0368792377,
-0.0205913559,
0.0163404234,
0.0018625532,
-0.0080443509,
0.0027165562,
-0.0345176831,
0.0159224998,
-0.0037902908,
0.0297228824,
-0.0196158886,
0.102944389,
0.023602983,
0.0003953315,
-0.0294979606,
0.0247422848,
-0.0499225669,
-0.0198855549,
0.0021837975,
0.0485996231,
0.030459512,
-0.0074894209,
0.0037112804,
-0.0036735791,
-0.012701299,
-0.0209187046,
0.0508322418,
0.0057417154,
-0.047553096,
0.0338943265,
0.0385164097,
-0.0176570266,
0.0085957227,
0.0443895832,
0.0075919628,
0.0273795798,
0.0259936582,
0.0525800958,
-0.0503974631,
0.0066348803,
0.054639671,
0.0101396963,
0.0050344635,
0.0382789709,
-0.0806293041,
-0.0640853718,
0.0134085594,
0.0059053465,
-0.0173785295,
-0.0227252301,
0.0449763127,
0.0488076508,
-0.0127121089,
-0.0113237463,
-0.0411985032,
0.0195203871,
-0.0029555478,
-0.0329095274,
-0.0340137072,
-6.954952651e-33,
-0.0330484062,
-0.0307327323,
0.0446264222,
-0.0397641882,
-0.0072555733,
0.0099509461,
-0.03631768,
0.0069576525,
-0.0226198118,
0.0033981961,
-0.0344071239,
-0.0223331694,
0.0001979917,
0.0310980845,
0.0144981984,
-0.033982832,
0.0387162566,
-0.0270337816,
-0.0260599684,
0.022707615,
0.0420152955,
0.0209352039,
0.020671811,
-0.0093524251,
0.0294024646,
-0.0132280374,
-0.0144508863,
0.0275924578,
-0.0254933983,
0.0404844768,
-0.0422651432,
0.0382908955,
0.0336597189,
-0.0205904059,
-0.0084145265,
0.0343205705,
-0.0649746358,
-0.0565567948,
0.0068288534,
-0.0332443565,
-0.0537299402,
-0.022986386,
-0.0148145081,
-0.0187362731,
-0.0288953818,
-0.0061972565,
0.0118521424,
0.0057150638,
-0.0592534244,
-0.0124021554,
-0.0547125898,
0.0025963953,
-0.0022906419,
-0.0738361776,
-0.0036558206,
0.0882726312,
-0.0177655928,
0.0413299613,
-0.0279673487,
0.0101133781,
0.016717786,
-0.0030082359,
0.0573670939,
0.0183622632,
0.0029788786,
0.0531115644,
-0.0008008613,
0.0032496117,
-0.0121841859,
-0.0211075265,
0.0217199922,
0.0397644192,
0.0107704895,
0.0779052377,
0.053515736,
0.0265370328,
-0.0548547432,
0.0022947383,
0.0264928956,
0.0107291406,
0.0265089944,
-0.0196076389,
-0.0365884006,
-0.0188450012,
-0.0450650491,
-0.0298636444,
-0.054944817,
-0.0219670422,
0.0753772333,
0.0430064909,
-0.0349370204,
-0.0156865567,
0.0565262027,
-0.0238677468,
0.003360721,
0.0205318034,
-0.0107587101,
0.0105468817,
0.0016848515,
0.0110463295,
-0.0780986026,
-0.0346656516,
0.0333611108,
0.0320304595,
-0.0085586971,
0.0135858953,
0.0263819415,
0.0273723044,
-0.0548639223,
-0.0234580394,
-0.0506843291,
0.0446711034,
-0.0124484859,
0.013062926,
0.0253691692,
0.0054490655,
-0.0216099136,
0.0795249343,
-0.0074691945,
-0.0523733385,
-0.0117334593,
0.0188720636,
-0.0168854557,
0.0021831521,
-0.0192476511,
0.0078844037,
-0.0024157241,
0.0319126733,
0.0190222524,
-0.0428782441,
-0.0081731323,
0.0273420475,
2.884e-7,
-0.0055030775,
0.0213413574,
0.0081240823,
0.0112867123,
0.0165701844,
0.0586900674,
-0.0035043634,
0.0329501331,
0.0188984778,
-0.0172939785,
-0.0066939634,
0.0243282132,
0.0327815711,
-0.0029740972,
-0.1046494767,
0.0288879499,
-0.0553906299,
0.0233308859,
-0.0629703552,
-0.0027791455,
0.0769396573,
0.0750891641,
-0.0059723645,
-0.0221200213,
0.0257061217,
-0.0262515917,
0.0632843897,
-0.0114803547,
-0.0192500278,
-0.0114794308,
-0.0103104189,
0.0184087437,
0.0078927344,
0.0247701965,
0.0021784324,
0.0194786154,
-0.0378569216,
0.0733021572,
0.0155858994,
-0.0390703082,
0.0181145091,
-0.0004477513,
0.0250834841,
-0.0638556257,
0.0984939486,
-0.0901575312,
-0.0247541722,
-0.0229461603,
-0.0118672643,
-0.0098451274,
0.0100605823,
-0.0323074684,
-0.0292505119,
0.0213850159,
0.0248563122,
-0.0017480886,
-0.0171379913,
-0.0543863215,
0.0050174426,
-0.021927176,
-0.0352293216,
-0.0121334912,
-0.0405100398,
-0.0122141223,
0.0178499911,
-0.0603736453,
-0.0120159574,
2.791968979e-34,
0.0120004704,
-0.0136479056,
0.0233382788,
0.0296812076,
-0.0116597163,
0.0019845366,
-0.0197609924,
0.0034582892,
0.0542394929,
-0.0776220486,
-0.0239274725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14919v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14919v2 | Frugal Prompting for Dialog Models | 2023-05-24T09:06:49 | 2023-11-05T06:05:19 | Bishal Santra, Sakya Basak, Abhinandan De, Manish Gupta, Pawan Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL | The use of large language models (LLMs) in natural language processing (NLP)
tasks is rapidly increasing, leading to changes in how researchers approach
problems in the field. To fully utilize these models' abilities, a better
understanding of their behavior for different input protocols is required. With
LLMs, users can directly interact with the models through a text-based
interface to define and solve various tasks. Hence, understanding the
conversational abilities of these LLMs, which may not have been specifically
trained for dialog modeling, is also important. This study examines different
approaches for building dialog systems using LLMs by considering various
aspects of the prompt. As part of prompt tuning, we experiment with various
ways of providing instructions, exemplars, current query and additional
context. The research also analyzes the representations of dialog history that
have the optimal usable-information density. Based on the findings, the paper
suggests more compact ways of providing dialog history information while
ensuring good performance and reducing model's inference-API costs. The
research contributes to a better understanding of how LLMs can be effectively
used for building interactive systems. | [
0.0728055388,
-0.0008147749,
-0.0215951148,
0.0459717661,
-0.0622470751,
0.0084769372,
0.023305947,
-0.0171304755,
0.0669738874,
-0.0785791427,
-0.0196223017,
-0.0265706684,
-0.0284655057,
0.0407697149,
-0.0047762324,
-0.0689037517,
0.0529032871,
-0.0550953224,
0.0389939062,
0.0080278004,
0.0021193044,
-0.0058498816,
-0.027251035,
0.0573439896,
0.0023294138,
-0.0220373869,
-0.0482785553,
-0.0077579594,
-0.029686125,
-0.0506627113,
-0.0177656412,
0.0451303422,
0.0281834658,
0.0246825889,
0.0000021131,
-0.0767524764,
0.0322708152,
-0.0179827716,
-0.08980643,
0.0193839893,
0.028776072,
0.0384310596,
0.0073124343,
0.010569253,
-0.0010979465,
-0.0099298963,
0.0288116205,
0.0667256638,
0.0711107701,
0.0438066833,
-0.0040191454,
0.00629983,
0.0127168894,
0.0013795779,
0.0179392323,
-0.0583929121,
0.0089759398,
0.0006180201,
0.0455404073,
0.0459759869,
0.0276183002,
0.0300008841,
0.0092685707,
-0.051970493,
-0.0236404259,
0.0131073436,
0.0002068013,
-0.0390764773,
-0.0554649606,
0.06010928,
0.0430437066,
0.0344527625,
-0.0019948408,
-0.0103519578,
0.0004163001,
-0.023680158,
-0.0703121349,
0.0290556978,
-0.0183425359,
-0.0235936362,
0.001971303,
0.0273068137,
-0.0154678505,
0.0456266366,
-0.0243668314,
0.0364942513,
0.0113400659,
-0.0118212327,
-0.0037398171,
-0.0267823562,
-0.0085557625,
-0.0798295662,
0.0042360243,
0.0374426246,
-0.0758468211,
0.0266563762,
-0.0198296737,
0.0322055742,
0.0321980566,
-0.0307835899,
0.0031068379,
0.0398797356,
0.0011641948,
0.0711063966,
0.0181409121,
0.0529505201,
-0.0024417765,
-0.0170090534,
-0.0032783791,
-0.0060274503,
-0.0456802286,
-0.0207240283,
-0.0532904565,
0.0300431289,
-0.0505045541,
-0.0523074381,
0.0139925573,
0.0710910335,
0.0331611782,
0.0073314724,
-0.0001136799,
0.013251516,
-0.0059327255,
-0.0100151272,
-0.0848301128,
0.009116089,
-0.0284809452,
0.017787572,
0.025995424,
-0.0750773251,
0.0011925157,
0.0217430964,
0.0130961146,
-0.0266267285,
-0.0326065794,
0.0610637888,
0.0025752003,
-0.0171381012,
-0.0385160297,
-0.0181175042,
-0.0096602747,
-0.0417403206,
-0.0413762666,
-0.0181467533,
0.0198155493,
0.0213354714,
-0.0093876868,
-0.0124697303,
0.0196603816,
0.0354710184,
-0.0186885539,
0.0506880768,
-0.005303517,
0.0193627514,
0.0539238937,
-0.0046496536,
-0.0312733725,
0.059415374,
0.0188720804,
0.013856506,
0.0432515368,
-0.0112435091,
-0.0016759582,
0.0212226752,
-0.0376571305,
-0.0004872194,
-0.0116689838,
0.0391998999,
-0.0408861749,
0.0175883807,
-0.0035012839,
0.0806088224,
-0.0439666025,
0.0188015047,
0.0697543025,
0.0804785043,
0.006757414,
-0.0225303825,
0.0306099653,
0.0333588161,
0.0210540853,
0.0005209198,
-0.0383863486,
-0.0073879445,
-0.0125178313,
0.010580794,
0.0271536279,
-0.0041584228,
-0.0246240627,
-0.0406870991,
0.0060855024,
0.0152971074,
-0.0160595886,
0.0226096325,
0.0203521363,
0.0065122233,
-0.0343950391,
0.0281939879,
0.0045564952,
-0.0161819849,
-0.050918784,
-0.0649581999,
0.0432790928,
0.0778921172,
0.057109423,
-0.000778401,
-0.0302218255,
-0.0434156992,
0.0163342338,
0.0389228463,
0.0513637699,
-0.010389464,
0.0019932913,
-0.0300249979,
-0.011397128,
0.0143514732,
0.006239933,
0.0008914923,
-0.0113078626,
-0.0389549024,
0.0417988896,
0.032139957,
-0.0210166145,
0.0047897035,
-0.0102328043,
-0.0508226827,
0.0039074696,
-0.0010832961,
0.0434596278,
0.0272073224,
0.0097376592,
0.0072832834,
0.0238963533,
0.0194114093,
0.0164867714,
0.0143136065,
-0.0714883283,
-0.0350606292,
0.0055639073,
0.0402264223,
0.0126744788,
-0.0345125683,
-0.0074153999,
-0.047106605,
-0.027579654,
-0.064519532,
0.0289683733,
-0.0474996604,
0.032213673,
0.0097457385,
-0.0438315161,
-0.0636949688,
0.0612045787,
0.0177777745,
0.0149069298,
0.0792133585,
0.0437486358,
0.0126336934,
-0.0566505231,
-0.0163195245,
0.0088120019,
0.0065821828,
-0.0069336547,
0.0284634773,
0.000795878,
-0.0408346839,
-0.0200326499,
-0.1015737355,
0.0173001215,
-0.0036576078,
-0.0047700163,
-0.0019974103,
0.0135660879,
-0.0207567066,
-0.0288128722,
-0.0165740587,
-0.0227190107,
0.0447084047,
0.0208599903,
0.0448086001,
0.0343917459,
-0.0356455818,
-0.0511978455,
0.0156987198,
-0.0055824462,
0.0395545959,
0.0205704384,
-0.0469672084,
-0.0621070713,
0.0380180776,
0.0119164335,
0.0386154503,
-0.0330947973,
-0.0104430513,
0.0329563282,
-0.0022013548,
0.06465213,
0.0645992979,
0.0403848216,
0.0281217471,
0.0022305909,
-0.0083657084,
-0.0871788636,
0.0434678756,
-0.0115980068,
-0.0204262733,
-0.0215795487,
-0.0136712305,
0.0412868224,
0.0560861714,
0.004168666,
0.0350606665,
-0.0019063025,
0.0257002153,
0.0306541137,
-0.0291550457,
-0.0212293509,
-0.0520721674,
-0.0464863554,
0.0681011602,
0.0025007462,
-0.0591263436,
0.057213977,
-0.0464969985,
-0.017110303,
-0.0363903046,
-0.0312064029,
-0.0419115201,
0.073138155,
-0.0016925979,
0.0042091231,
0.0455656685,
-0.0690154657,
-0.027752256,
-0.0019019488,
0.0150715299,
-0.0173058677,
0.0500002913,
-0.0321554095,
-0.0063953116,
-0.0030862412,
-0.0434242338,
-0.0487224087,
-0.0623810366,
-0.0422088914,
-0.0180171654,
0.0331541598,
0.0059860013,
-0.0078597125,
0.0319597423,
0.0366105549,
0.0474526398,
-0.0068435827,
-0.0057212464,
-0.046116069,
0.0082171084,
0.0314889289,
0.0362911746,
-0.0142416041,
-0.0019977354,
0.0948152021,
0.0126265604,
0.0185745377,
-0.0245299488,
-0.0149982348,
-0.02569893,
0.0213964656,
-0.0241484791,
-0.032057602,
0.052540902,
0.0536297485,
-0.0692590773,
-0.003367645,
0.1370312274,
0.0483483821,
-0.042007722,
-0.0226199757,
-0.036208272,
0.0180856939,
0.0326956138,
0.0086552259,
-0.0506302267,
-0.0437884852,
0.0079601472,
-0.0056107226,
-0.0354197398,
-0.0157472752,
-0.0020800887,
-0.1203622743,
0.0335244909,
-0.0215937104,
0.0330794342,
-0.017913647,
-0.0332262069,
-0.0010259044,
0.020573698,
0.0222214572,
0.0274448916,
-0.0271589011,
-0.0262280349,
0.0255285818,
-0.0242999475,
-0.0098485239,
0.0115264319,
-0.0247384682,
0.0610972494,
0.0466045216,
0.0060059605,
0.0399666429,
-0.0034138157,
0.0379219912,
0.0068429122,
0.034733586,
-0.0172026958,
0.0317527652,
-0.0063106925,
0.0004471911,
-0.0607941486,
0.0121855857,
0.0130527886,
-0.0175938439,
0.0487763882,
0.0601768233,
-0.0657227263,
0.0332519226,
-0.021020636,
0.010534782,
0.0235293973,
0.0772309378,
0.0461391695,
-0.0403086506,
-0.0485915802,
-0.0316216871,
-0.0158516113,
-0.0141192954,
-0.013173664,
-0.0069086738,
-0.0037401111,
0.0064149229,
-0.0410091951,
-0.037084084,
0.0384600721,
0.0201696623,
0.0233256239,
0.0140122762,
0.0110750301,
0.0216692183,
0.0492818691,
0.0313749276,
-0.0260366239,
0.0179398693,
-0.0752299726,
0.0096887676,
0.0562854595,
-0.012883178,
-0.0095327757,
0.0213590022,
-0.0396883301,
-0.0527481437,
-0.0445103273,
0.0395324379,
0.0220860448,
0.0266569778,
0.0009105123,
-0.0522868782,
-0.0256760512,
0.0130834971,
-0.0467846617,
-0.0314322375,
0.007435055,
0.0794784948,
-0.0116751213,
0.0221213512,
-0.0233918224,
0.0009003829,
-0.0602741539,
0.0370420106,
-0.0536169112,
-0.1036517099,
0.018956529,
0.0466262847,
0.031787917,
0.0255932994,
-0.0073432778,
-0.0328861848,
0.0414356664,
-0.0346148871,
-0.0447642915,
-0.0456692576,
0.0141501985,
-0.0324243791,
-0.016337676,
0.0124909375,
-0.0387705974,
-0.0540846661,
0.0569273643,
-0.0227488838,
0.0378273129,
0.0235744696,
0.0029750639,
0.0208941754,
-0.0071228268,
-0.0417903215,
0.0249663591,
0.0056368564,
0.0115647353,
0.0034345777,
0.1197827905,
0.0020897321,
-0.0333857834,
0.0085384632,
0.0128787719,
-0.0777878836,
-0.0769164637,
0.0302133113,
0.0213012751,
0.0029788401,
-0.013159655,
0.0171806775,
-0.0349819064,
0.0118583739,
-0.0335035808,
0.0543966368,
0.0460257158,
-0.04234666,
0.0506391339,
0.0444060564,
-0.0232873093,
-0.0038281186,
0.049560491,
-0.0092529068,
0.0288871508,
-0.0081362259,
-0.0256936941,
-0.0466026999,
-0.0279191472,
0.0155523662,
0.0195495561,
-0.0193994381,
-0.0002337441,
-0.0555074215,
-0.0232150052,
-0.0145620471,
-0.0105336197,
0.0012043252,
-0.0398026854,
0.052540455,
0.0466035418,
0.0239262972,
-0.0354858972,
-0.0219325423,
0.0476252437,
-0.0355138704,
-0.0154453171,
-0.0443708338,
-5.803249571e-33,
-0.0345118269,
-0.030025648,
0.0272015072,
-0.0055974619,
-0.0225599688,
-0.0196293835,
-0.048507981,
0.0138562294,
-0.0012447214,
-0.0239096154,
-0.0466568433,
-0.0125634121,
0.0122538367,
0.018447984,
-0.0202479754,
-0.0148295369,
0.0519229621,
-0.0032707546,
-0.0030381023,
0.0066515137,
0.0325869881,
-0.0065183691,
-0.0351335332,
-0.0502049662,
0.0431758761,
-0.007475303,
0.0103790071,
0.0412903577,
0.0107862763,
0.0594349839,
-0.0229689386,
0.0310256463,
0.0151692303,
-0.0400332175,
-0.0172679108,
0.0800907537,
-0.0198051371,
-0.0279564112,
0.0765307322,
0.0014587928,
-0.008720085,
-0.0204256419,
-0.0073686494,
-0.0279187765,
0.0037568051,
0.0413026437,
0.0009529844,
-0.0204141755,
-0.03552524,
0.0284548085,
-0.0465939678,
0.0375761651,
-0.0215205215,
-0.0395353399,
-0.0002048841,
0.0603741333,
-0.0082428837,
-0.0053146421,
0.0161271188,
0.009797656,
0.0574407354,
0.0040985858,
0.0283876229,
0.0339407735,
0.00784274,
0.0558453873,
0.004952318,
0.0125935217,
-0.043208383,
-0.0182580408,
-0.0294535402,
0.0387286246,
-0.0068811709,
0.0306870937,
-0.0127596846,
-0.0026341102,
-0.0248572305,
0.0072452896,
0.0345348343,
0.0579325818,
0.0294704977,
0.0022790337,
-0.026136294,
-0.0114791039,
-0.0712610483,
0.0096169477,
-0.0253201369,
-0.0322472677,
0.0567271225,
0.0155592468,
0.016949391,
-0.0366017334,
0.0375508144,
-0.0003772808,
-0.0129532088,
0.0093090162,
-0.0031148619,
0.0330645517,
-0.0104814535,
0.0116609093,
-0.0333209299,
-0.0253789239,
0.0216308367,
-0.0044894316,
0.0149436658,
0.0224153679,
-0.0200679209,
0.0022608833,
-0.0601980016,
-0.0002542297,
-0.0409337543,
0.0315115377,
-0.0431716181,
0.0153618408,
0.0301805325,
-0.0211922843,
-0.0428579152,
0.0662265271,
-0.0476740822,
-0.0460161343,
-0.0517922863,
-0.0532159097,
0.0135668684,
-0.0006935373,
-0.0427308977,
-0.0078517934,
0.0093232272,
0.0297020394,
0.0316415578,
-0.0118999472,
0.0093979333,
0.0000996132,
2.743e-7,
0.0096745137,
0.0463205762,
0.0160679668,
0.0420820676,
0.00924931,
0.0435950644,
-0.0013645181,
-0.0097335083,
0.0242104717,
-0.0318523906,
-0.0034784519,
0.0106059723,
0.0309905689,
0.0051292256,
-0.1155208275,
-0.0410133488,
-0.0575761683,
-0.0140064247,
-0.0721790269,
0.0088131269,
0.0850603133,
0.0712149665,
-0.0413302332,
0.0060438206,
-0.0173450038,
-0.0627241507,
0.0132878153,
-0.0672093853,
-0.0223200805,
0.0163776763,
0.059986271,
0.0058681574,
0.0220038481,
0.0209331363,
0.0159578044,
0.0151777798,
-0.0242549665,
0.0917791128,
0.0129808001,
-0.0255709942,
-0.0089700874,
-0.0176041275,
0.0113431923,
-0.0424150787,
0.0605803356,
-0.0403090678,
-0.014035061,
-0.0561867394,
0.0104625775,
-0.0439554714,
-0.0115567148,
-0.0357544385,
0.002089201,
0.0120367203,
-0.0083485972,
-0.0126923127,
0.0189830717,
-0.0629100427,
-0.0120020043,
-0.0237029307,
-0.030717887,
-0.064912349,
-0.0704570487,
-0.0196377691,
0.0350883417,
-0.0286841821,
0.0256827623,
2.425465452e-34,
0.0252419487,
-0.011225027,
0.0358731151,
0.0722256079,
0.0597375818,
0.0278245993,
0.0158628952,
0.0182355717,
0.0633498207,
-0.0988569036,
-0.0199926738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14917v1 | Structural Ambiguity and its Disambiguation in Language Model Based Parsers: the Case of Dutch Clause Relativization | 2023-05-24T09:04:18 | 2023-05-24T09:04:18 | Gijs Wijnholds, Michael Moortgat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper addresses structural ambiguity in Dutch relative clauses. By
investigating the task of disambiguation by grounding, we study how the
presence of a prior sentence can resolve relative clause ambiguities. We apply
this method to two parsing architectures in an attempt to demystify the parsing
and language model components of two present-day neural parsers. Results show
that a neurosymbolic parser, based on proof nets, is more open to data bias
correction than an approach based on universal dependencies, although both
setups suffer from a comparable initial data bias. | [
0.0525624007,
0.0458003171,
-0.0158870611,
0.0476072133,
-0.0374282673,
0.0284106098,
-0.0208719578,
-0.0511034057,
-0.0013854374,
-0.0372600295,
-0.0181965344,
0.0259219632,
0.0132847494,
-0.0270083863,
0.0322208777,
-0.0366054624,
0.0998960286,
-0.0136736864,
0.0324953645,
-0.0061840857,
-0.0053185546,
-0.0141549064,
-0.0013562921,
0.0055394606,
-0.0428861976,
-0.0316683352,
-0.0154401055,
0.0028553836,
-0.0293909106,
-0.0262002908,
-0.012091619,
0.0215714071,
0.0139487907,
0.0299458075,
0.0000018431,
-0.0579145066,
-0.0090211304,
-0.021790877,
-0.0524467491,
0.0026744818,
0.0240560938,
-0.0605194531,
-0.0077661159,
-0.0339558125,
-0.0377403498,
-0.0481900685,
0.022320956,
0.0446343757,
0.0745812953,
0.0635510534,
-0.0065353075,
-0.0769031346,
0.0138732772,
-0.021318756,
-0.0009806182,
-0.0109638032,
0.0094075948,
0.0193653256,
0.0012360178,
-0.0293847453,
-0.041684214,
0.0518951491,
0.0617569573,
0.005280613,
-0.0398689918,
0.0166607033,
-0.0099022472,
-0.0007159818,
-0.0084911976,
0.0193777997,
0.0044444399,
-0.0413115472,
-0.016284341,
0.0138232876,
0.0282921214,
0.003063187,
-0.0188136566,
0.0608590208,
-0.0085357176,
0.0415788256,
0.0473573096,
-0.0329530127,
0.0174426436,
0.0218659956,
-0.0157078858,
0.1262524724,
-0.0253714658,
-0.0371424779,
0.030867774,
0.0428039208,
-0.0374408849,
-0.0495260842,
0.043580994,
0.0088807018,
-0.0219556447,
0.0136401579,
-0.0155078722,
-0.0522490293,
-0.0116944015,
-0.0824073851,
-0.016085349,
0.0342862569,
-0.0337876268,
0.0280555878,
-0.0195435826,
0.0541612022,
-0.0363757201,
0.037665341,
-0.0432367697,
-0.0015347041,
-0.0236467086,
-0.0374782048,
-0.0632634982,
0.0847743228,
-0.0238753911,
0.0066020992,
-0.0288892779,
0.0046584844,
-0.0091406358,
0.0296570584,
0.0041660648,
0.0039792471,
-0.0764734596,
0.0237115826,
-0.0320225358,
0.0245234985,
-0.0623364374,
0.0310090706,
-0.0109582655,
-0.058175765,
-0.0277697556,
0.0073444322,
-0.0444149151,
-0.0343782678,
-0.0206008926,
0.0469218977,
0.0002289929,
0.0517674387,
-0.0909324735,
-0.0520655476,
-0.0136202183,
-0.014274911,
0.0121469526,
-0.0817670375,
0.019189015,
0.0293359589,
-0.0055491934,
-0.049827721,
-0.0024271002,
-0.0100927688,
-0.0210014526,
0.0382606685,
-0.0021046379,
-0.0282712542,
0.0072505055,
-0.0096416539,
-0.0054770196,
0.0338459164,
0.0064464607,
-0.00188927,
0.0168885551,
0.032376118,
-0.037481308,
0.001407026,
0.0133628882,
-0.058757972,
-0.0547917373,
-0.0217617638,
-0.0184615441,
0.0056244158,
0.0289892796,
0.063282609,
-0.0301380828,
-0.0400481597,
0.0013791504,
-0.012287748,
-0.0196071845,
0.0195272509,
0.0522310212,
-0.0163327027,
0.0252208114,
0.0616794489,
-0.0852039084,
0.0088476008,
0.0128429038,
0.0299924407,
-0.0847769752,
-0.0007097519,
-0.0030419375,
-0.054682292,
0.0259534921,
-0.0019532242,
0.0021865414,
-0.0254237037,
0.0221577194,
0.0419884808,
0.0141962757,
0.1017886996,
0.014770397,
-0.0289531145,
0.0289634783,
0.0016548837,
-0.0109084975,
0.0028003121,
-0.0053560878,
-0.0383733697,
-0.0292026158,
-0.0077742827,
-0.0029004738,
0.053887289,
0.0342061408,
-0.0276819058,
0.0427530557,
-0.0295905918,
0.0030666012,
-0.0187615789,
0.0325995907,
-0.0078756688,
-0.0207140688,
-0.0335735343,
0.0118258093,
-0.0426058136,
0.0264596324,
0.0523151532,
0.0178817213,
0.0217346121,
-0.0102669364,
0.010113379,
0.041882325,
0.0369477272,
-0.022514537,
0.0313199721,
0.0119296107,
-0.0437666215,
0.0272042807,
0.0509331189,
-0.0486345515,
-0.0624437593,
0.0415780321,
-0.0474266037,
-0.0195632465,
0.0163867772,
-0.0592507683,
-0.0481535755,
0.0559795834,
-0.0486944802,
0.0024842529,
0.0009937792,
0.0028423467,
0.0002221897,
-0.0198274367,
-0.0354371704,
0.0842127278,
0.0052263825,
0.0000095351,
-0.0356773883,
-0.0042596338,
0.0268039405,
-0.0365587808,
-0.0256408788,
0.015739359,
-0.0118313916,
-0.0197297446,
0.0023114933,
-0.000137925,
-0.0311678294,
-0.0302850977,
-0.0431768298,
-0.0008916948,
0.0052821673,
0.0441394523,
0.0487584174,
0.0209480599,
0.0355037563,
-0.0529824458,
0.0001815195,
-0.004799298,
0.0064707282,
-0.0051498362,
0.0503064319,
0.0053784149,
-0.0278680306,
-0.0130664129,
-0.0392096676,
-0.059260875,
0.0497703403,
0.0014853445,
-0.0950593129,
-0.0592220128,
0.0675743222,
-0.0409434028,
0.0392632782,
0.0218040086,
-0.019223325,
0.0299547166,
0.0112779336,
-0.0297319535,
0.0733096227,
-0.0524280891,
0.0049994965,
0.0287661757,
-0.0435472354,
-0.0183108654,
0.0148233846,
-0.0056757485,
0.0273315534,
-0.0303064529,
-0.0172668062,
-0.0112272818,
0.0774250627,
0.0121336589,
-0.0090496102,
0.0171694085,
0.0294127855,
-0.0530144796,
-0.0095112249,
0.0059981686,
-0.0304626264,
0.0040134438,
0.0204428528,
-0.0557248592,
-0.0166675858,
0.0931588039,
0.0118662082,
-0.0134723736,
-0.0721696094,
0.0121960388,
-0.0255477875,
0.0237810686,
0.0040874584,
0.0114824688,
0.0078368988,
-0.079330802,
-0.0484953262,
-0.0457320735,
0.0240933802,
0.0258669388,
0.0782959908,
-0.0611821823,
0.010111535,
0.0018382538,
-0.0410851836,
-0.0427989922,
-0.0238293372,
-0.02373836,
0.0266034361,
-0.0196360499,
0.0375777669,
0.0029286752,
-0.0223180577,
0.0185983889,
0.0321520716,
-0.0108348448,
-0.0072900932,
-0.0457616262,
0.0172540117,
-0.0261269175,
-0.0018020927,
0.0699598268,
0.0045505418,
0.0175269283,
0.0200622566,
0.0128571158,
-0.0053482805,
-0.0301700514,
0.0580400415,
0.0007941768,
-0.0252121855,
-0.0623851903,
-0.0080625415,
0.0163902398,
-0.0475401282,
-0.0027767487,
0.0911565349,
0.0421488695,
-0.0318240412,
0.030473873,
-0.0368381701,
0.0006816334,
0.0151492562,
0.0412307605,
-0.0708424598,
-0.0002749985,
0.0324748196,
-0.0294340551,
0.0157958493,
-0.043526832,
-0.0010361288,
-0.1105796173,
0.0344831981,
0.0198076442,
-0.0468339846,
0.0055297017,
0.0327443071,
-0.0143470159,
-0.0046596592,
0.042144984,
0.0061562792,
0.0006898107,
0.0145205567,
-0.0153953917,
0.0204653703,
-0.0485093072,
-0.0327222385,
-0.0700392872,
0.0319136605,
0.0406978689,
-0.021593703,
-0.0347581245,
0.0198803544,
0.0729363561,
-0.0208883658,
0.0163581967,
-0.0452596322,
0.0092543298,
0.0432935543,
-0.0254678223,
-0.0330236331,
-0.0055671944,
-0.0214181505,
-0.0145511692,
-0.0183394887,
0.0361113511,
-0.0237264223,
0.0208463147,
0.034139201,
-0.0070115854,
-0.0320817754,
0.0453834273,
0.0313250422,
0.008324123,
-0.0592747405,
-0.0651749298,
0.0185817908,
-0.0098285312,
0.0399259925,
0.0242206175,
-0.0233439058,
0.0024317806,
-0.0534104444,
-0.0432652012,
0.0124903535,
-0.0158939175,
0.0096982559,
-0.010080006,
0.0891978145,
-0.0651669577,
-0.0251829959,
0.0364694633,
0.001923135,
0.0132720182,
-0.0143130226,
0.0366426967,
0.0108777015,
0.0036240395,
-0.0379078798,
-0.0424965359,
-0.0452645235,
-0.0394818895,
0.0536232479,
0.0283322725,
0.0322542526,
0.0680492967,
-0.0638181344,
-0.0317265019,
-0.0710800514,
0.0196969081,
-0.0281091519,
0.0359731093,
0.0266460236,
0.0205311645,
0.0225183312,
0.037163686,
-0.0167999472,
0.0258232094,
0.0488759577,
0.0295182019,
-0.0002279221,
0.0289132167,
0.0443426482,
0.0330898575,
0.0210978147,
0.0492002927,
0.0533228554,
-0.0305733848,
0.0062161107,
-0.0326375216,
-0.012455387,
-0.0398988947,
0.0095985951,
0.03438944,
0.0167288259,
-0.0020109222,
0.0002445485,
0.0240109954,
0.0242164824,
0.020695664,
-0.0065362467,
0.0457279943,
-0.0125263976,
-0.0339646339,
0.0078831669,
-0.0081835045,
0.0546082184,
0.0099904994,
0.0494698733,
-0.0375632346,
0.0004932334,
0.0299456138,
-0.015109065,
-0.1064253226,
-0.0206366964,
-0.0465703085,
0.011025086,
0.0231956095,
-0.0060730106,
0.0615876466,
-0.0382028967,
0.066587992,
-0.0095737008,
0.0221902113,
0.0198810063,
0.0337449387,
0.0445889197,
-0.0037416688,
0.0416824408,
0.0166553538,
0.0120795891,
-0.0202402435,
0.0604765303,
-0.0259497445,
0.0319706351,
-0.0053711091,
-0.0024589701,
-0.0227676518,
-0.0319409557,
-0.0183987468,
-0.0187197421,
-0.0381745398,
0.0185620803,
-0.0370588899,
-0.0686817318,
-0.0117403083,
0.019957142,
0.0346183553,
-0.0404318571,
0.0009144146,
0.0513021462,
0.0519804955,
-0.0995759815,
0.0204568412,
0.0104434267,
0.0192928556,
-0.0516054407,
-0.058400318,
-5.708290199e-33,
-0.0689316317,
0.0160603914,
-0.0100762462,
-0.0059298952,
-0.0464416072,
-0.0096487319,
-0.0443448946,
-0.0124086495,
-0.0399833247,
0.047754582,
-0.0039887656,
0.0554678515,
0.0470575131,
0.0002595106,
0.025673613,
-0.0230932999,
0.0403037444,
-0.0093245283,
0.0081997216,
-0.046354726,
0.0092633329,
0.015094107,
0.0655866042,
-0.0581099316,
0.0294831097,
-0.0033504665,
-0.0167063139,
0.0832666531,
-0.0430912003,
0.0182742886,
0.0223980825,
-0.0082404623,
0.0441940203,
-0.0068887542,
-0.0550820418,
0.0027384353,
-0.1043121591,
-0.0670724064,
0.0851013884,
0.0650382638,
-0.0046071596,
-0.0444298498,
0.0632224232,
-0.0351449698,
0.0092598721,
0.0370498635,
0.0072562909,
-0.0176207721,
0.0150556769,
0.0344804712,
-0.0262844507,
-0.0117145758,
0.0049199546,
0.0348532498,
0.0439842716,
-0.0029541792,
-0.0424203053,
-0.0293720588,
-0.0672829598,
-0.0191233028,
-0.0149882268,
0.0523875989,
0.0046473029,
-0.0028190119,
-0.0075760316,
0.0195086338,
0.054872226,
-0.010101716,
-0.0377047211,
0.0406384394,
0.0190424751,
0.0388442464,
0.0300548263,
-0.0084042698,
0.0342956707,
0.032519076,
-0.0680354312,
-0.0502300188,
0.0411792323,
0.1046990305,
-0.0280577466,
-0.0010789266,
0.0050376812,
-0.0541083254,
-0.0386975147,
-0.0521234572,
-0.0371359475,
-0.0262502059,
0.0208868291,
-0.0312584527,
0.0138492463,
-0.0217932239,
0.0013699353,
-0.04897945,
-0.0166716427,
0.0093898326,
0.0536390208,
0.053664878,
0.0250709429,
0.0200376138,
0.0029784115,
-0.00464343,
-0.0213379897,
0.0113645578,
0.0385504812,
0.0443036668,
0.0393578,
0.0011026317,
0.0120053627,
0.0145038636,
-0.0342024453,
-0.0287702605,
0.0012860479,
0.0437717326,
0.0560535081,
0.0345164835,
-0.0247430466,
0.006998586,
0.0220147371,
0.0111605786,
0.004380384,
0.057329189,
0.0094355047,
0.0790033787,
-0.0093325153,
-0.0154485973,
-0.0082084322,
0.0462655537,
0.0203468129,
-0.0291619264,
-0.0151883997,
0.0162544046,
2.705e-7,
0.0467519611,
0.0238796361,
0.0445576794,
0.0590797476,
0.0286646076,
0.0039051226,
-0.0211605038,
-0.0231231097,
-0.0013060793,
-0.0505387262,
-0.0437557027,
0.0016871253,
0.0187739823,
0.0448589213,
-0.0426519588,
0.0286965128,
-0.0163685605,
0.0146212466,
-0.0048412415,
0.049317278,
0.0367043428,
0.0894528851,
0.0091211954,
0.0008302515,
-0.0591980442,
-0.0311913509,
0.0147297764,
0.0073210564,
0.0027398795,
-0.0073776301,
0.0305163357,
-0.0296409745,
0.0313510001,
0.0632639304,
0.0237903912,
0.0194385126,
-0.019095365,
0.0354713947,
0.0048999372,
0.070106931,
-0.0172438249,
-0.0238736179,
0.0008507196,
-0.057352405,
0.0168013331,
-0.0681051537,
-0.0371150523,
0.0227341168,
-0.005046193,
0.0045856815,
-0.0229275506,
0.0045212521,
-0.0058808234,
-0.014530574,
0.0355804823,
-0.0031008807,
-0.029738484,
-0.0083175916,
-0.0825089216,
0.0189164095,
-0.0058159526,
0.0044654449,
0.0347268023,
0.0117768869,
0.0186354052,
-0.0534423403,
-0.0213492084,
2.2386569e-34,
0.0364550538,
0.0047204522,
0.0595748164,
0.0172519311,
0.0412753336,
-0.0201756526,
-0.0301756859,
0.0439341962,
-0.0286484584,
-0.0493793599,
-0.0069654607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14913v1 | CoLaDa: A Collaborative Label Denoising Framework for Cross-lingual Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-24T09:03:01 | 2023-05-24T09:03:01 | Tingting Ma, Qianhui Wu, Huiqiang Jiang, Börje F. Karlsson, Tiejun Zhao, Chin-Yew Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual named entity recognition (NER) aims to train an NER system that
generalizes well to a target language by leveraging labeled data in a given
source language. Previous work alleviates the data scarcity problem by
translating source-language labeled data or performing knowledge distillation
on target-language unlabeled data. However, these methods may suffer from label
noise due to the automatic labeling process. In this paper, we propose CoLaDa,
a Collaborative Label Denoising Framework, to address this problem.
Specifically, we first explore a model-collaboration-based denoising scheme
that enables models trained on different data sources to collaboratively
denoise pseudo labels used by each other. We then present an
instance-collaboration-based strategy that considers the label consistency of
each token's neighborhood in the representation space for denoising.
Experiments on different benchmark datasets show that the proposed CoLaDa
achieves superior results compared to previous methods, especially when
generalizing to distant languages. | [
0.0240079686,
0.05510097,
0.0249222536,
0.0497903861,
0.0253075846,
0.0460557714,
0.0396675244,
0.0245156474,
-0.0001360954,
0.0274218228,
-0.0603473783,
0.0115218842,
-0.0233169422,
-0.008916094,
-0.0025481288,
-0.0288149137,
0.0215739347,
-0.0044087134,
0.0683636218,
-0.0194822866,
-0.0245195739,
-0.0029391362,
0.0093105575,
0.0050641596,
-0.0106765162,
-0.0092250453,
-0.0107910801,
-0.0178629812,
0.0282705147,
-0.0074778954,
0.0117166396,
0.0229001921,
-0.0187434945,
0.0309650358,
0.0000020503,
-0.0312985219,
-0.0511791483,
0.039144516,
0.0132774115,
-0.0028971804,
-0.0043623643,
-0.013363082,
0.0086300112,
-0.0298132617,
-0.0053717135,
-0.070456095,
0.053760875,
0.06751661,
0.0523291491,
0.0569413528,
-0.0214993954,
-0.0222012866,
-0.0333027653,
-0.0279942323,
-0.0198534671,
-0.0513535365,
0.0294107739,
0.0353752188,
-0.0192942303,
-0.0190697648,
0.0206983592,
0.0611922182,
0.007971636,
0.0015256022,
0.0238707121,
0.019324854,
-0.0217193812,
-0.0510043874,
0.012243297,
0.067221567,
-0.0036991374,
0.0044626836,
0.0486563779,
0.0167263802,
-0.018576026,
-0.0057843374,
0.0002158004,
-0.0217741337,
-0.0306226723,
0.0473284088,
0.0363208018,
0.022237597,
0.0596076362,
-0.0125331534,
0.007681903,
0.0418077782,
-0.0069220373,
-0.0135286208,
0.0007583636,
-0.0047115604,
0.0163597111,
-0.0347557776,
0.0713440105,
0.0290393718,
0.0078713009,
0.0059085526,
-0.0100161815,
-0.0399836041,
-0.0206958279,
-0.0215790253,
-0.0271413121,
-0.0164934397,
-0.0064840713,
0.0505820923,
-0.0379403718,
-0.0223278664,
0.0296089761,
0.0329132788,
-0.017946953,
-0.0575569086,
-0.0662098899,
0.045413699,
-0.0454821773,
0.0633875728,
-0.0398556776,
0.0200518444,
-0.0451247655,
-0.0176962931,
-0.0319875404,
0.040767733,
0.019728804,
-0.0049842577,
-0.0025496581,
-0.0099611925,
0.0164705738,
0.0477194153,
-0.0064145569,
-0.0270382371,
-0.0287354067,
-0.0237120036,
0.0066405507,
-0.0179250427,
0.0043947869,
-0.0372676551,
0.0241527446,
0.0676386282,
0.0168528371,
-0.0366402529,
-0.0206548516,
-0.0092293201,
0.0163130593,
-0.073800981,
-0.0177253783,
-0.0361107662,
0.0233733375,
-0.0005357621,
0.0375566818,
-0.121004954,
0.0282605793,
-0.0528567843,
-0.0381440558,
0.0996569842,
-0.0693793297,
-0.0126687586,
0.0260547847,
0.0277985651,
0.0173395071,
0.0688782558,
0.0382911377,
0.0058910158,
0.0526674762,
0.0073743975,
-0.0117384531,
0.0267284643,
0.0262967143,
-0.0020455474,
-0.0245946962,
0.0099126101,
0.0365216397,
-0.0225802213,
0.0076285508,
0.0422436558,
-0.0126242163,
-0.0184801593,
0.0422917083,
-0.0363235958,
0.0124787185,
0.0181063674,
0.0089884633,
-0.002289986,
-0.0292619076,
0.0144657213,
-0.0192782488,
-0.0144894058,
0.008821222,
0.0106558064,
0.0294794943,
0.0566555411,
-0.0467563756,
-0.0465093292,
0.024747394,
-0.0256768242,
-0.0113967219,
0.0263937991,
0.0710985661,
0.0181595068,
-0.0272693262,
0.0658054352,
0.0559506528,
-0.0442428924,
0.0304164067,
0.0124738608,
0.0567878075,
0.0168030784,
0.0103289513,
-0.0554845631,
-0.0238521732,
-0.0214012954,
-0.0335493572,
0.0134084355,
0.0067623169,
-0.0419891626,
0.0702994466,
-0.0460195467,
-0.0494298972,
0.0408641249,
0.0034751897,
0.0367514454,
-0.0206674058,
0.0289883707,
0.0385983475,
-0.0641721562,
-0.0561970025,
0.0277084876,
-0.0201299991,
-0.0303167515,
0.0334294289,
0.0504599586,
0.0347445644,
0.0697326213,
-0.0096693151,
-0.0382252038,
0.054458946,
-0.0274412166,
0.0115889059,
0.0074484688,
0.0024742037,
-0.0495825708,
0.0253437161,
-0.0249989051,
-0.0331486352,
-0.0217790138,
-0.0214445759,
-0.0447156131,
0.0051914328,
0.0256917663,
0.0017317352,
-0.0394006185,
-0.0083763627,
0.0109749306,
0.0224357899,
-0.0012987728,
0.0529141575,
-0.0040780744,
0.0296409149,
0.0322784483,
-0.0168738458,
0.0182082895,
-0.0174344126,
-0.0501926467,
0.040376097,
0.0194867607,
-0.0381293148,
0.0273743812,
0.0068975212,
-0.0333852582,
0.0133665903,
-0.0595721975,
-0.0135549493,
-0.0079729967,
0.0322901569,
-0.0018868987,
0.0468265675,
-0.0048500048,
-0.0351980738,
-0.0210737884,
0.0042031407,
-0.0231460184,
0.00365529,
0.0210621338,
0.0361853279,
-0.0202453434,
0.015283118,
0.0266236868,
0.0268792249,
0.0066997292,
0.0084048873,
-0.0898891613,
-0.0692349747,
0.0437772721,
-0.0712046847,
0.046509292,
0.019932026,
0.0079213297,
-0.0219225883,
0.053294763,
0.003095753,
-0.0006703147,
-0.0850078389,
-0.0028670731,
0.04647756,
-0.0238397922,
-0.0318215452,
0.0415217392,
-0.0182688683,
0.0497152507,
-0.0281207021,
-0.0691452548,
-0.0021645059,
0.069501318,
-0.0527261756,
-0.0003624887,
-0.0383014642,
0.0004583065,
-0.0136327455,
-0.0527936034,
-0.0164154824,
0.0207155086,
0.0017913057,
0.0099987024,
-0.02760363,
-0.0234020054,
0.0686890483,
-0.0271131936,
-0.0240427889,
-0.011665876,
-0.0311238747,
-0.0191243868,
0.0276387352,
-0.0018639774,
0.0199911948,
0.064781785,
-0.0476589799,
0.0102471625,
0.0022982892,
0.004382248,
-0.0220385138,
-0.0346247964,
-0.01754147,
0.0012916861,
0.0031592839,
-0.0045691482,
-0.0304587707,
0.0273064058,
-0.0350251272,
0.038959071,
-0.0338309593,
-0.0017753169,
-0.0302204713,
0.0441941954,
0.0003457243,
0.0238042902,
0.0267790295,
0.0162721407,
-0.0017471706,
0.0512972176,
-0.0061788871,
-0.0301410705,
-0.0165345725,
-0.0009804982,
0.0027643011,
0.0216813684,
0.0334338062,
-0.060137935,
0.0105698314,
-0.0273533668,
0.0243089627,
0.0039647985,
-0.0290559214,
-0.0223590061,
0.0643601567,
-0.0064325826,
-0.0037775065,
0.0925320089,
-0.0080762273,
-0.0632424131,
-0.0297450516,
0.0258096624,
0.0165319107,
0.0294261612,
-0.0001050354,
-0.0730432197,
-0.0301764086,
0.0204728916,
-0.0149988821,
0.0141748115,
-0.0626431331,
-0.0000848714,
-0.0853690505,
-0.0055114198,
-0.0023169429,
-0.0703301057,
0.0029659215,
-0.1017585769,
0.0345445611,
-0.0634274781,
0.0013904948,
-0.0621038117,
0.0264149662,
-0.0009681213,
0.0275752507,
0.033575017,
-0.079499431,
-0.0518647172,
-0.0442393832,
0.060056299,
0.0114708664,
0.0534057133,
-0.0079053538,
-0.0291053113,
-0.0308127198,
-0.0084701777,
-0.0230193231,
-0.0574545749,
0.0499690026,
-0.0100884298,
-0.0417855717,
0.0342482068,
-0.0204174481,
-0.0183172226,
0.0116938474,
0.0336950421,
0.050841216,
0.0247483347,
0.0118142068,
0.0172464941,
-0.0287556089,
0.0530641265,
0.0594031438,
0.0154490396,
-0.0044804537,
0.0110537698,
0.0289237984,
-0.0115556736,
-0.0126150483,
0.0259464141,
0.0086491117,
-0.0928472355,
-0.0914835259,
-0.0411520489,
-0.0739949718,
0.0612727776,
0.0163745284,
0.0315426737,
0.0370003469,
-0.0033375844,
0.0153175835,
-0.033607915,
0.0095421355,
-0.0390695818,
0.0040726075,
-0.0297072735,
-0.0024427904,
-0.0394747406,
0.01945691,
-0.006726014,
0.0332832187,
-0.0492459908,
-0.0918378085,
-0.0036132312,
0.0208341666,
0.008968561,
0.0607138425,
-0.0124381669,
-0.059987165,
0.0364921615,
0.0768195018,
-0.0621716417,
-0.0310323127,
0.0497287959,
-0.041576542,
0.0230069458,
0.0498370863,
-0.0276670195,
0.0350329168,
0.0631430224,
0.0085913632,
-0.0631817728,
-0.0413222872,
-0.0074529527,
0.0302637704,
0.0604988746,
-0.0265352484,
-0.0085012326,
-0.047717426,
0.0124395732,
-0.0025869973,
-0.0142157972,
-0.0264816787,
-0.014717333,
0.0125993229,
-0.0222021267,
0.0162223894,
0.0888086408,
-0.0162405074,
0.0073922914,
-0.0578139089,
0.0413688868,
0.0195544586,
0.0318058394,
0.0194298252,
0.0111460928,
0.0143502299,
0.0325427428,
0.0864867792,
0.0192270316,
-0.0140561741,
-0.0195758864,
-0.0026953351,
0.0438070595,
-0.0011083776,
-0.0064857672,
-0.0083817504,
-0.0011971833,
-0.0116565246,
0.0258624777,
0.0425952412,
-0.0024231665,
0.06453567,
-0.0075582713,
-0.016473487,
-0.0112952823,
0.0089340741,
-0.0142888892,
-0.0113848625,
-0.010474721,
-0.0126968725,
-0.0111235194,
0.0056396965,
0.097343646,
-0.007700298,
0.0247079581,
0.0060449205,
-0.0038202205,
-0.0594598837,
0.0017288203,
0.0300654136,
-0.0019958802,
-0.0463560149,
0.0066858297,
0.0040851082,
-0.0999129638,
-0.0029439833,
-0.0556096509,
-0.0260034241,
0.0073900498,
-0.0101053929,
0.0008670745,
0.0175058842,
-0.0123305591,
-0.0418028124,
0.0190464072,
0.0528949052,
-0.0285235085,
0.0011318207,
-6.00277137e-33,
-0.0152871711,
-0.0406797566,
-0.020122787,
-0.0272675604,
0.0140455263,
0.0352986343,
-0.0220091641,
-0.0017102744,
0.0093897879,
0.0290681105,
-0.0115299337,
0.0078467503,
0.0510990098,
-0.0227338634,
-0.0313266702,
0.0012930391,
0.0712808818,
0.0178326108,
0.003953293,
0.0322822034,
0.0056290478,
0.0724067092,
0.1032215953,
-0.149312675,
0.0900143459,
-0.00053625,
-0.0339464508,
-0.0026788129,
0.1046762019,
0.0266280957,
-0.0361914299,
0.0360844247,
-0.0171368383,
-0.0592599586,
-0.0038456279,
-0.0282161515,
-0.1438076794,
0.0067447815,
-0.0036290642,
0.0337029546,
-0.0222931392,
-0.0338957645,
0.0282503832,
0.0144266579,
0.0053525371,
0.031982936,
0.0478908718,
-0.0586454868,
-0.021139903,
-0.0097079994,
-0.0272867829,
0.0407052077,
-0.0054964563,
0.0130223352,
0.1115280092,
0.0118324766,
0.0174512304,
-0.029868979,
-0.0675284788,
0.0231905337,
-0.01772823,
-0.0013528706,
0.0469993427,
0.0252812002,
-0.0085728439,
0.0182705894,
0.0525730401,
-0.0143947937,
0.0129403779,
-0.0115668485,
0.0050564636,
0.0471670441,
0.0097083254,
0.0503919236,
-0.000931945,
-0.0415313542,
-0.0800116584,
0.0447013676,
-0.0374722257,
-0.012122795,
-0.0314446576,
-0.0090762284,
-0.0150239039,
0.0099217892,
-0.0013319596,
-0.0652603507,
-0.0345949903,
-0.0020691019,
-0.0203638095,
0.0078137992,
-0.0764425918,
0.0381857827,
-0.0172209516,
-0.0262547899,
-0.0411815085,
0.0150408521,
0.0695457235,
-0.030209668,
0.0069506122,
-0.0244105812,
-0.0808250234,
-0.0423146375,
-0.0148638021,
0.0348100252,
0.0234682672,
-0.0391507894,
0.0622198321,
-0.0275616627,
-0.0384189002,
0.0017022965,
-0.0359514207,
0.0361879542,
0.0035132407,
0.0470039248,
0.0081681041,
-0.0396744572,
-0.0293721668,
0.0026509927,
0.063107729,
0.0037665099,
0.0136524225,
0.017312102,
0.0327838063,
0.0193022359,
-0.0266302265,
-0.0306631848,
0.0074391589,
-0.0086856196,
0.0368914641,
0.0011461873,
-0.0143006723,
-0.0354420058,
2.696e-7,
-0.0055927369,
0.0085759964,
0.0222304668,
-0.0181628801,
-0.01646512,
0.0339171626,
-0.0033774739,
0.0326379687,
0.0053199786,
-0.0587172471,
0.01366363,
-0.014872754,
0.0293905009,
0.0634359643,
-0.0827679634,
-0.0197512433,
-0.0140246963,
-0.0054908306,
-0.0229215994,
0.0509416722,
-0.0419347361,
0.0516189113,
0.0410420671,
-0.0379801579,
-0.0307394043,
-0.016162619,
0.020813873,
-0.0348971114,
-0.0155603969,
0.0235245135,
0.0344929621,
0.0215777792,
-0.0211650487,
0.0287190583,
-0.0215342939,
-0.0016403769,
0.0357338674,
0.0335703157,
0.0041886242,
0.0316993371,
0.0045745303,
-0.0072178752,
0.0012924691,
-0.0276230276,
0.0691022575,
-0.014942049,
-0.0259544253,
0.0277716927,
0.0003542129,
0.0142009053,
0.0493645035,
0.0248755328,
-0.0306969099,
0.0353107601,
0.0151531957,
-0.0156455133,
-0.0318296663,
-0.020457413,
-0.0128228916,
-0.0287466403,
-0.0055045788,
0.0139896367,
0.008335893,
-0.0443234183,
-0.0424626209,
-0.0133183049,
0.0503298305,
1.974526763e-34,
-0.0073974649,
-0.0082912007,
-0.0398729332,
0.0194695666,
0.0018620794,
-0.0528382622,
-0.0899273157,
-0.0030980066,
-0.0173573215,
0.0056829797,
0.0170231573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14910v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14910v3 | From Shortcuts to Triggers: Backdoor Defense with Denoised PoE | 2023-05-24T08:59:25 | 2024-04-02T23:01:17 | Qin Liu, Fei Wang, Chaowei Xiao, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Language models are often at risk of diverse backdoor attacks, especially
data poisoning. Thus, it is important to investigate defense solutions for
addressing them. Existing backdoor defense methods mainly focus on backdoor
attacks with explicit triggers, leaving a universal defense against various
backdoor attacks with diverse triggers largely unexplored. In this paper, we
propose an end-to-end ensemble-based backdoor defense framework, DPoE (Denoised
Product-of-Experts), which is inspired by the shortcut nature of backdoor
attacks, to defend various backdoor attacks. DPoE consists of two models: a
shallow model that captures the backdoor shortcuts and a main model that is
prevented from learning the backdoor shortcuts. To address the label flip
caused by backdoor attackers, DPoE incorporates a denoising design. Experiments
on SST-2 dataset show that DPoE significantly improves the defense performance
against various types of backdoor triggers including word-level,
sentence-level, and syntactic triggers. Furthermore, DPoE is also effective
under a more challenging but practical setting that mixes multiple types of
trigger. | [
0.0265729222,
0.0529390201,
-0.009031943,
0.036685925,
-0.0402808487,
-0.0254808106,
0.0188739132,
0.0001450063,
0.0049631638,
-0.0399423614,
0.0039600474,
0.0065022241,
0.010261857,
0.061524231,
0.0662057698,
0.0359263383,
0.0627453029,
-0.0088887028,
0.0016044792,
-0.0343750603,
-0.0185991265,
-0.0341005735,
0.0027859388,
0.049303785,
0.0328516848,
0.0186913498,
-0.0173225775,
-0.0188696589,
0.0456644073,
-0.0131832631,
0.0171898883,
0.0245243721,
-0.0153286532,
0.06017581,
0.0000018325,
-0.0190891046,
-0.0498774834,
0.0154545214,
-0.0167801213,
0.0110298917,
-0.0599337034,
-0.0019394319,
-0.0270592161,
0.0189025849,
-0.0242584068,
-0.0314018019,
0.0268035401,
0.0597090945,
0.0849445537,
0.0963991061,
-0.0140386159,
-0.0234614909,
0.0688486993,
-0.0213583708,
-0.0172771588,
-0.0479337014,
0.0411509573,
-0.06170775,
-0.0193025321,
-0.0023216237,
0.0153608145,
0.0058788131,
-0.028235076,
-0.0042956257,
-0.0258901808,
0.0469638817,
0.0251440257,
-0.0105548473,
-0.0381727815,
0.0516560338,
-0.0511097275,
-0.0101570692,
-0.0063986275,
-0.0030861136,
0.0094023943,
0.0060459324,
0.0260600094,
-0.0075640334,
-0.0028086579,
-0.0067229527,
0.0129521033,
0.0157967042,
0.0599978715,
0.001278937,
0.0183627661,
0.068095766,
0.0286269281,
-0.0106581682,
-0.0116987359,
-0.0710978284,
0.016971454,
-0.0499860905,
0.020752633,
0.0112430751,
0.0181529578,
0.0280928127,
-0.0437053889,
-0.1023080349,
0.0135202138,
-0.0346539393,
-0.006647144,
0.0147005199,
-0.0099699013,
0.0100424569,
-0.0265385229,
0.0396397933,
-0.0257250536,
0.0017928361,
0.0440176949,
0.0022504046,
-0.0478839464,
-0.0297390465,
-0.0383340865,
0.0542439595,
-0.0056273849,
-0.0129834786,
-0.0359553173,
0.0001216422,
-0.0372559614,
0.0090475306,
0.008468111,
0.0014635976,
-0.0334303007,
0.0091788359,
0.0644606948,
-0.0086948136,
0.023210464,
-0.022386618,
-0.0267395359,
-0.068639338,
-0.0309152044,
-0.0069454638,
-0.0586492419,
-0.0402714014,
-0.0270846859,
0.0389666632,
0.0268352646,
-0.0111826491,
-0.0352076627,
-0.0761982799,
-0.0416730493,
0.0133140497,
-0.0188946649,
-0.0749503598,
-0.0501584634,
-0.027590761,
0.0078388937,
-0.1076928377,
-0.0030131661,
0.0072978605,
-0.0321866646,
0.0878675729,
-0.0184568036,
-0.0320062116,
0.0190724563,
0.0200992636,
-0.010851996,
0.0465070345,
0.0065495181,
0.0324618928,
0.0209091976,
0.0004601921,
0.0487297773,
0.0358186811,
0.0500684455,
0.0285040792,
-0.0733284205,
0.0110897385,
0.037608996,
-0.0675394237,
-0.0151509615,
0.038944561,
-0.0123290233,
-0.0521364585,
0.0752531514,
-0.0191764981,
-0.0011919729,
0.0407836922,
-0.0061661825,
0.0242108162,
-0.0551721416,
-0.0222863927,
-0.0611446649,
-0.0105243912,
-0.0912273154,
-0.0409527645,
0.0293817054,
0.0094530489,
0.0007045882,
-0.0201226622,
0.0211980846,
0.0023748511,
-0.0130102187,
-0.0164010227,
0.01772107,
0.0479428433,
-0.0138514871,
0.0363541692,
-0.0076464475,
-0.0069760028,
-0.0369382873,
-0.0740631595,
-0.0630282015,
0.0182110313,
0.0603468865,
0.0109348977,
-0.0015541222,
-0.0625675842,
-0.0791316777,
0.0305009987,
-0.0214623455,
0.0355237015,
0.0091762254,
-0.0234549753,
-0.0170803629,
-0.0072973091,
0.0324822813,
0.01766387,
-0.0094261998,
-0.0041143666,
0.0094510252,
-0.0129652312,
0.0008863174,
0.030628603,
0.0399282202,
-0.0532682464,
0.039596729,
0.0183601044,
0.0435004681,
-0.0089915777,
-0.0251625963,
0.0402495191,
0.0174287315,
0.0116226878,
-0.0465023071,
-0.0243865959,
-0.0068631582,
-0.0232121218,
0.0265804641,
0.0038865451,
0.0130076259,
0.0548533127,
-0.0040986901,
-0.0452566892,
0.0531626381,
-0.0532578751,
-0.0020830736,
-0.0154236238,
-0.0203971677,
0.0019743193,
0.0679716989,
-0.0239102934,
0.0429522172,
-0.0103368321,
-0.0267865714,
-0.0380167738,
0.0197990201,
0.0676336512,
0.0000763725,
-0.0557552651,
0.0065284641,
-0.0346408188,
0.0129114836,
-0.0072703864,
-0.0213738214,
-0.0242153723,
0.0149381422,
-0.007659134,
0.0030957679,
-0.017443981,
0.014056148,
0.0456296243,
0.01241004,
-0.0189128034,
-0.042006582,
0.0038900119,
-0.0207395945,
-0.0240849052,
0.012799859,
0.0026342138,
-0.0037876982,
-0.0476378947,
0.0084865214,
-0.0121836336,
-0.0322927609,
0.0676352009,
-0.0285212565,
-0.0409139954,
-0.026090214,
0.0221373029,
-0.0068743154,
0.0271762069,
-0.0081782844,
-0.0551674329,
0.0139827365,
0.0153422747,
-0.015970543,
0.0220417362,
0.0027803564,
-0.0308558289,
0.0772783309,
0.0004572861,
-0.049451977,
-0.0057686754,
0.0204029009,
0.0060299714,
-0.059662044,
0.0197662003,
0.0084645599,
0.0670458004,
0.0585691407,
-0.040080376,
-0.0399586782,
0.0010231426,
0.021707708,
-0.014188827,
-0.042435959,
-0.1016031355,
-0.0368254371,
0.0025638528,
-0.0072038365,
-0.0408612639,
0.0990816131,
-0.0339387543,
0.0307808854,
-0.0391409807,
-0.0270464066,
0.0154230138,
0.0322873443,
-0.0147197954,
0.0085799694,
0.0510166027,
-0.027211016,
-0.0323644429,
-0.0624807142,
0.0408315174,
-0.017906798,
0.0109114638,
-0.0034330529,
0.0095888907,
0.0061473767,
-0.0161931701,
-0.0658741891,
-0.0529318489,
-0.0532023199,
0.0061206454,
-0.0192012731,
-0.024066776,
-0.0213476941,
0.0076083993,
0.0163213834,
0.0037310317,
-0.0179553628,
-0.0195707232,
-0.0242842473,
0.0228912774,
0.0324667469,
-0.0922414735,
-0.0216782223,
0.0139385276,
0.0563160926,
0.0617620088,
0.0270143282,
0.0025191433,
-0.0496489257,
-0.0004730086,
0.0062255897,
-0.0031282494,
-0.0252305474,
0.0277654789,
0.0000239011,
-0.0087936632,
-0.035366945,
0.0426298827,
-0.0031362958,
-0.0801687017,
0.0026736204,
0.0150018269,
0.0338522643,
0.0020471129,
-0.0009936967,
-0.0490261465,
-0.0311881118,
0.0230970923,
0.0288021043,
-0.0422711484,
-0.0040180883,
-0.0277774502,
-0.1239692345,
-0.0183878876,
0.0227236431,
-0.033192046,
-0.0104026534,
-0.0454498567,
0.0041251397,
0.0144592524,
0.0241001491,
-0.0057195211,
0.0533305742,
0.0012920878,
0.0111048492,
-0.0052602412,
-0.0203466918,
0.00819284,
-0.0019904261,
0.0684122741,
0.0723204017,
0.0158048514,
-0.033204753,
0.0166001264,
0.0209994242,
-0.0240264311,
-0.0088137202,
0.0081487382,
0.0626453012,
0.0003860352,
-0.0165537912,
0.0361705013,
0.053118363,
-0.0302062184,
0.0125348633,
0.0376303867,
0.0373639464,
-0.0326289013,
-0.0077298274,
-0.0296411719,
-0.0184328407,
0.0475208014,
0.0419052206,
0.0331322551,
-0.0232014898,
-0.0166873969,
-0.0604821146,
-0.0014296183,
-0.0322821215,
-0.0648881644,
0.0320666134,
0.0188041124,
-0.104498744,
-0.050158184,
0.0104016541,
-0.0086306706,
0.035869088,
0.042010095,
0.0254173223,
-0.0364225805,
0.0387127362,
-0.0314263776,
-0.0265563689,
-0.0014825286,
0.0660967603,
-0.0284907371,
0.0207161009,
0.0254009198,
-0.0006385942,
-0.0403287895,
0.0347111225,
-0.0484894589,
-0.083154574,
0.0436282977,
0.0381705537,
0.0278583709,
0.0292305276,
-0.0566564575,
-0.0710515529,
0.126432538,
0.0657445192,
-0.0109715713,
-0.0392437801,
0.0882990435,
-0.0719105601,
0.0125091476,
0.0379527695,
-0.0009002553,
0.0079724947,
0.0812957436,
0.0036347106,
-0.0240294766,
-0.0159368161,
0.0299656168,
0.038532529,
0.0942720026,
-0.0310323928,
-0.0058241086,
0.0230394788,
0.0369795002,
-0.0147346631,
-0.0331605449,
0.0334734023,
0.0593116805,
0.0113506662,
-0.0253058188,
0.0400887355,
0.0088393763,
0.0099487249,
-0.0122058913,
-0.0137408935,
0.0238178391,
0.037687704,
0.063991487,
0.0679850206,
-0.0067878445,
-0.0043316633,
0.043469172,
0.0803430527,
0.0134332813,
0.0108932443,
0.0069327927,
0.0183290038,
-0.0164924767,
-0.0446059257,
0.0402239859,
-0.0792016909,
-0.0111504905,
0.030232517,
-0.0075255949,
0.0100260032,
0.0396090671,
0.0264511853,
-0.0113987196,
0.0007148579,
-0.005616074,
-0.0287192892,
-0.0085977502,
-0.0114812423,
0.0201522522,
-0.0119712697,
0.0153105641,
0.060243383,
0.0820477456,
-0.0035747981,
0.0801436007,
0.0021336819,
-0.0153772132,
-0.0397983603,
0.0057831882,
-0.0174822863,
0.0487359501,
-0.0498538427,
-0.0121554146,
-0.0425048657,
-0.0916511863,
-0.0116483578,
0.0106701469,
0.0576003306,
0.0403926,
0.0085652815,
0.0316639058,
0.0294395294,
0.020327786,
-0.083839193,
0.0543963797,
0.0369415358,
-0.0344913602,
-0.0136120291,
-5.377138012e-33,
0.0380447395,
-0.0479910038,
-0.036608018,
0.0189871471,
0.0340222977,
0.0106506357,
-0.0178014375,
0.0250317473,
-0.0081667602,
0.0054947855,
-0.0092137912,
0.0193570629,
0.0019292422,
0.0106608151,
-0.0338170975,
0.0012687498,
0.0174925439,
-0.04206343,
-0.0185567159,
0.0449382327,
0.0723475665,
0.0154033061,
0.025995139,
-0.0560606867,
0.0533360541,
0.013721019,
-0.0653593764,
0.0049034823,
-0.0777962133,
0.0521222539,
0.0015817333,
0.0333930813,
0.0022897748,
-0.0203556418,
-0.01484772,
0.0412576534,
0.0097019095,
-0.0115097575,
-0.0405472182,
-0.03090108,
0.0338220187,
-0.0421015806,
0.0614157058,
-0.0020807821,
-0.0077443351,
0.0247950274,
0.0257204305,
-0.0292467065,
-0.0181039572,
-0.0181744602,
0.0122872172,
0.0280665178,
-0.0222529601,
-0.0112047885,
0.0029323457,
-0.0072252224,
0.0072484179,
-0.0077819843,
-0.057187181,
0.042378623,
0.0379235409,
0.0330192558,
0.0108876824,
0.0162739735,
0.0058823936,
0.0402857661,
0.0115164323,
0.0011184722,
-0.0045432942,
-0.0278340131,
0.0205857642,
0.0492589027,
0.078350395,
0.0426214263,
0.0713012815,
-0.0298356116,
-0.0589859411,
0.0268581714,
0.0312113576,
0.016040802,
0.0288761239,
0.0127286278,
-0.0534543507,
0.0183849744,
-0.0254119411,
-0.0414684005,
-0.0130108707,
-0.0186246168,
-0.0241357032,
0.0102644134,
-0.0410310514,
-0.0151612544,
0.0043155001,
-0.0597099103,
0.0086252084,
0.0101467026,
0.0146856047,
-0.0175448265,
0.020353999,
-0.0059193214,
0.0266886652,
-0.0073386319,
-0.0019049939,
-0.0059870873,
0.0205076709,
-0.0364525616,
0.0248149764,
0.0197015256,
-0.0813596025,
-0.03080534,
-0.0349307433,
0.0214228742,
0.0201360863,
0.0469567552,
0.0115931872,
-0.0176897869,
0.0032283165,
-0.0232316032,
0.0235525873,
-0.004094732,
-0.0202726983,
0.0690571517,
-0.0136080021,
0.0141474837,
-0.0196237639,
-0.0080756079,
-0.006263054,
0.0048169014,
0.0473528802,
-0.0209714584,
0.0035989971,
-0.012122741,
2.788e-7,
-0.0049495846,
0.0019930338,
0.0341498181,
0.0079074353,
0.0266239736,
0.0818457976,
-0.0341976993,
0.0662698969,
-0.0203920137,
-0.0546507947,
-0.0037273823,
-0.0182749126,
0.0254743584,
0.0120119406,
-0.0423468277,
0.0391050056,
-0.066547133,
0.031656079,
-0.0487574264,
-0.010141395,
0.0213090274,
0.0917866006,
0.0407802276,
-0.0160906706,
-0.0185139161,
-0.0314608961,
0.0071506537,
0.0344005078,
0.017599348,
0.0051310584,
0.0788742006,
0.0378931314,
0.0180797316,
0.0527155101,
-0.0530308522,
0.0313445032,
-0.0706922933,
0.0010056244,
-0.0187749621,
-0.0477103367,
-0.0466950685,
-0.0302740876,
0.022273371,
-0.0462421738,
0.0594910458,
0.009510424,
-0.0352777056,
-0.00855505,
-0.0401161872,
0.0022543601,
0.0336553827,
-0.0296053365,
-0.0161892977,
0.0064502684,
-0.0064170551,
0.0036086608,
0.0315245576,
-0.1017876044,
-0.0478238575,
-0.0320930295,
-0.027784165,
-0.0030114097,
0.0185221843,
0.0063880575,
0.0134615358,
0.044678662,
0.0112967724,
2.512865294e-34,
0.0003232681,
-0.0449271612,
-0.022416506,
-0.0003632891,
0.0199654903,
-0.0255988222,
-0.0057576359,
0.0151751274,
0.0121508045,
-0.0256238952,
-0.0444010235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14908v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14908v1 | PURR: Efficiently Editing Language Model Hallucinations by Denoising Language Model Corruptions | 2023-05-24T08:59:00 | 2023-05-24T08:59:00 | Anthony Chen, Panupong Pasupat, Sameer Singh, Hongrae Lee, Kelvin Guu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The remarkable capabilities of large language models have been accompanied by
a persistent drawback: the generation of false and unsubstantiated claims
commonly known as "hallucinations". To combat this issue, recent research has
introduced approaches that involve editing and attributing the outputs of
language models, particularly through prompt-based editing. However, the
inference cost and speed of using large language models for editing currently
bottleneck prompt-based methods. These bottlenecks motivate the training of
compact editors, which is challenging due to the scarcity of training data for
this purpose. To overcome these challenges, we exploit the power of large
language models to introduce corruptions (i.e., noise) into text and
subsequently fine-tune compact editors to denoise the corruptions by
incorporating relevant evidence. Our methodology is entirely unsupervised and
provides us with faux hallucinations for training in any domain. Our Petite
Unsupervised Research and Revision model, PURR, not only improves attribution
over existing editing methods based on fine-tuning and prompting, but also
achieves faster execution times by orders of magnitude. | [
0.0633858964,
0.0917865857,
-0.0118493298,
0.029010348,
-0.0538446791,
-0.0005768118,
0.0018289523,
-0.0095138634,
-0.0490087643,
-0.0696808472,
-0.0166231003,
-0.024861373,
0.0226528589,
0.0117852818,
0.0510828085,
-0.0555453487,
0.0621024072,
-0.0401418395,
0.0159314629,
-0.0070300815,
-0.0096989525,
0.0030058087,
0.0179913584,
0.0428611599,
-0.0083317896,
-0.0393285267,
-0.0155120287,
0.027589513,
-0.004797156,
0.0443036221,
-0.0089863138,
0.1093834415,
-0.0092371907,
0.1038489789,
0.0000021827,
-0.0345160402,
-0.0255927667,
0.0196285825,
-0.0004890496,
0.0368529037,
0.062856704,
0.0107571464,
-0.0516918153,
-0.003622042,
-0.0031363617,
-0.0071387039,
0.0675875694,
0.0502530336,
0.0625078157,
0.0875335559,
-0.0109332399,
-0.0165202618,
-0.0127122542,
-0.017231511,
0.010599277,
0.0340058468,
0.0545390397,
0.0043449714,
-0.0257111266,
0.0115040485,
-0.0092437528,
0.0259279851,
0.0023311509,
-0.0628606752,
-0.0083507551,
-0.0003688316,
-0.0682642162,
-0.0306705236,
0.0209502149,
0.0289585702,
-0.0478652455,
-0.0600299127,
0.0113955261,
0.023168873,
-0.0049709198,
0.0233333129,
-0.0021732501,
0.0391269289,
-0.0022570407,
0.0017836677,
0.0304435231,
-0.0526467897,
0.0465337783,
0.0089891413,
0.0119185131,
0.0423402637,
0.0405827835,
-0.0400605127,
-0.0244836938,
-0.0126313902,
0.0150466152,
-0.0907727331,
-0.0100989966,
-0.005272652,
-0.0215047486,
0.0028141583,
-0.0668309033,
-0.0196672641,
0.0320927016,
-0.0434789769,
0.0033774038,
0.005248697,
-0.0337108187,
0.0615985394,
-0.0138336085,
0.0023039107,
-0.0145939067,
0.0256101433,
-0.0056219543,
0.0065070307,
-0.0187192224,
0.0023249949,
-0.0417588092,
-0.0054159011,
-0.0465147421,
0.0113086291,
-0.0356769413,
-0.010648449,
-0.024326371,
0.0177703965,
-0.0279371943,
0.0056350399,
-0.0372063555,
-0.0348306336,
0.0149884373,
0.0108317947,
0.0198719446,
0.003487786,
-0.014546792,
-0.0583933294,
-0.0305672605,
0.0264687687,
-0.0082832994,
-0.0382721499,
-0.007279722,
0.0222615898,
0.0119906636,
0.0038674623,
-0.0367066823,
-0.0445855074,
-0.017421402,
-0.0542174727,
-0.0360594131,
-0.0756352469,
-0.0077392072,
-0.0135767562,
-0.0278154258,
-0.0778138414,
0.0222704411,
0.0089255404,
-0.0690110698,
0.0807711035,
-0.0836042762,
0.0041740262,
0.0424274355,
0.0084445132,
-0.0085993828,
0.066989392,
0.024289418,
0.0191220399,
0.0372111276,
-0.0078205448,
0.0456583761,
0.0495365635,
0.018202357,
0.0482870862,
-0.0550601184,
-0.032521192,
0.029431751,
-0.016143728,
0.0357494093,
0.0676060989,
-0.0168746728,
-0.0036064098,
0.0908291414,
0.0001394394,
-0.0130536528,
0.025398409,
0.0341106951,
-0.0215341058,
0.0085315518,
0.0190071799,
-0.0573420897,
-0.0088683786,
-0.0336772017,
0.0004817578,
0.0523224361,
0.0006275658,
-0.0064647133,
-0.024310166,
-0.003588906,
0.0074202875,
0.0223686919,
-0.00986767,
0.0338867567,
0.03904026,
-0.0315718129,
0.0026292875,
0.0572214238,
-0.0189670976,
0.0041853474,
-0.0593380369,
0.0098141041,
0.0496267788,
0.0790304989,
-0.0170210097,
0.0131415343,
-0.0716506615,
0.0265912674,
0.0760382637,
0.0287412275,
-0.0246350672,
-0.0068814522,
-0.0211629309,
-0.0053994521,
-0.029004477,
0.0631737933,
0.0229497757,
0.0083739581,
-0.0336252078,
0.0037110476,
-0.0282279514,
-0.08319249,
0.016015809,
-0.0047574556,
-0.0191839617,
-0.005345088,
-0.0117787104,
0.0070874668,
-0.0133199431,
-0.0565259419,
0.011878348,
-0.0169109385,
-0.0240024198,
0.0095168613,
0.0258722324,
0.0274503678,
-0.0166252907,
0.054674536,
-0.0150329759,
-0.0471757762,
0.0283716153,
-0.0109952725,
-0.036354132,
0.0049568228,
-0.0546320938,
0.0407216325,
-0.0538670681,
0.0581849515,
-0.0326049477,
-0.0062576276,
-0.0193675458,
0.0613145269,
-0.0066328971,
0.0197140519,
0.0630312935,
0.021404393,
-0.0037190269,
-0.0135617144,
-0.0316244587,
-0.0038623209,
0.0027061771,
-0.010274549,
0.0247902311,
-0.0257665534,
-0.0264990795,
-0.0267332979,
-0.0380289666,
-0.0144080939,
-0.0381223224,
-0.0061975052,
0.051711984,
0.0110385381,
-0.0114465915,
-0.0142019754,
0.0020122093,
-0.0419430733,
-0.0008273982,
0.0420275666,
0.023227321,
-0.0002860853,
-0.0368503407,
-0.0520033203,
0.0115863401,
-0.00730982,
0.0518482961,
0.0224890932,
-0.0630030259,
-0.0937193781,
0.0494619273,
-0.0338572487,
0.0234638397,
-0.0000677647,
-0.0485544614,
-0.0143227018,
-0.0046725441,
0.0813524723,
0.0549507067,
-0.0005294352,
0.016020393,
0.0830350071,
-0.0110304225,
-0.0147085944,
-0.0276631415,
-0.0023593761,
0.0093795313,
-0.0067085894,
-0.0687555373,
0.0263802931,
0.0760184973,
0.0133776963,
-0.0155587383,
-0.0404302143,
0.062118683,
-0.0212170389,
-0.0536759943,
0.0039566238,
-0.0511349626,
-0.0204879511,
0.0593265817,
-0.0630243793,
-0.0645487681,
0.0730687529,
-0.0360109992,
0.0234241616,
-0.025517581,
-0.0030135838,
0.0154700466,
0.0230644662,
0.0282926336,
0.0378395803,
0.0081342123,
-0.0278598517,
-0.0446944311,
-0.0176592432,
0.0288686324,
-0.0252343528,
0.0071528004,
-0.0740430877,
0.0163527057,
0.0025097707,
-0.0068996064,
-0.0394769162,
-0.0755871534,
0.0035688009,
0.0132204415,
0.0244123694,
-0.0134114753,
-0.0455393083,
0.0152289448,
0.0310592372,
0.0744465142,
-0.015470163,
-0.0017295311,
-0.0128864935,
0.0135772126,
0.0733421966,
-0.021147918,
0.0362051092,
-0.0481667817,
0.016130168,
0.0589598827,
0.0095214974,
0.015320247,
-0.015524189,
-0.0284783244,
-0.0180763993,
-0.0511590987,
-0.0083992481,
0.0024756785,
0.0578554645,
-0.043280948,
-0.0427465625,
0.1168309599,
0.0363391973,
-0.0559276268,
0.0015949507,
-0.0484570786,
0.0460513793,
0.0265334044,
0.0238067694,
-0.0693328232,
-0.007283309,
0.0281659774,
0.0104313008,
-0.0275986455,
-0.0348239467,
-0.0141598089,
-0.103592217,
0.0562458523,
0.0194598958,
-0.0038831895,
-0.0115505476,
-0.0516888537,
0.0237979107,
0.004808547,
-0.0046837456,
0.019407779,
0.0266783945,
0.0067739808,
0.0033965828,
0.0005270545,
-0.0532016121,
-0.0151974438,
-0.0254716389,
0.0650667548,
0.0778762251,
0.0156461969,
-0.0093164016,
-0.0338475332,
0.0283354912,
0.0335801579,
-0.0023025235,
-0.007336278,
0.0604172498,
0.0234675724,
-0.0037201899,
0.0112763802,
0.0336340964,
0.0125129251,
-0.0274600796,
0.0056808321,
0.0639639497,
-0.0328953825,
-0.0117943846,
0.0007915934,
0.0062320037,
0.046131406,
0.0727533996,
0.0536623746,
-0.0348860845,
-0.0126270959,
-0.0588242561,
0.0024594909,
-0.0165635962,
-0.0563937388,
0.0157828573,
0.0124509269,
-0.0515928604,
-0.0601510927,
-0.0535232946,
0.0284472629,
0.017415924,
0.0662439242,
0.0128461709,
-0.0086879255,
-0.023923343,
-0.0315926373,
0.0137978578,
-0.0544773266,
0.0010228629,
-0.0324465111,
-0.0222180039,
0.0040044086,
-0.0092193848,
-0.0026741291,
0.0149816656,
-0.075584352,
-0.0854179636,
0.0427832045,
0.0552972667,
0.0321749449,
0.0623392314,
-0.0300946478,
-0.0729814321,
0.0213681255,
0.027391566,
-0.0215804484,
0.0329195634,
0.0099981697,
-0.0440635569,
-0.0016008073,
0.0331302211,
-0.0296791196,
0.0197161008,
0.0395358726,
0.0115382448,
-0.0468060933,
-0.0203168653,
0.0510653406,
-0.0024787697,
0.0485193022,
-0.020318063,
0.0125295697,
-0.0490694009,
0.0170097779,
-0.0549395196,
-0.0284515377,
-0.0248592384,
0.0219953954,
0.0123956688,
-0.0150299324,
0.0042984714,
0.0032743956,
-0.0684766918,
0.0218365826,
-0.0383988768,
-0.0098625394,
-0.0027847348,
0.0215464439,
0.0588874146,
0.0037399649,
-0.0147467591,
0.0486313067,
0.0061017945,
0.0409769528,
-0.0028373979,
0.0328476727,
0.0254973918,
-0.021472156,
-0.0024804305,
0.0107001383,
-0.0705804229,
-0.019928908,
-0.0252320766,
0.0010775779,
0.0411411896,
-0.0111804483,
0.0810842738,
-0.043967817,
-0.0225541219,
-0.0210615657,
0.0397377014,
0.060556028,
-0.0391571298,
-0.0020836254,
0.0018478328,
-0.0270224418,
0.0292306207,
0.0624115057,
-0.031271331,
0.075225845,
0.0114672929,
-0.0301197618,
-0.0346323438,
-0.0526458062,
-0.0451485217,
0.0004541966,
-0.0332354307,
-0.0187110696,
-0.0547712408,
-0.0524980016,
-0.0303904526,
0.0090817697,
0.0020973897,
-0.0009987375,
-0.012189853,
0.0510638729,
-0.0254750252,
0.0094881067,
-0.0496216156,
0.0283772387,
0.0436696857,
-0.0388004482,
-0.0162269045,
-6.481251938e-33,
0.0079291621,
-0.0390808396,
-0.0129643911,
-0.0444837771,
0.000290343,
-0.0022889581,
-0.0455174744,
0.0146943694,
0.0091218632,
0.0250612888,
-0.0174801946,
0.0246544089,
0.0123961661,
0.0027966027,
0.0060720881,
0.0527700745,
0.097154513,
0.016282592,
-0.0211697351,
0.0334134027,
0.0133592468,
0.0134273199,
0.0413843803,
-0.0747942403,
0.0622465685,
-0.0102093099,
-0.0495992042,
0.0150614148,
-0.0029274554,
0.0368912108,
-0.0162386578,
-0.0013033838,
-0.0051175165,
-0.0447077863,
-0.0307312049,
-0.0242274962,
-0.0221765582,
0.0131267952,
0.006549913,
0.0314293876,
-0.0195367578,
-0.0420144051,
0.0429576412,
-0.0198768061,
0.0095528346,
0.0073724436,
0.0410295874,
-0.0468640253,
-0.0064742062,
0.0286002252,
-0.0881877616,
0.0331329666,
-0.0011417303,
-0.0186523572,
0.0167272668,
0.0199520588,
0.0002816101,
-0.01546745,
-0.0903477818,
0.0309900325,
0.0533387028,
0.0467914082,
0.0430205986,
-0.0150159961,
0.0010313282,
0.0629697964,
0.0323100723,
0.0538716242,
-0.0120288283,
0.0177272018,
0.0174227469,
0.0241874866,
0.041888956,
0.0659273714,
0.0423817039,
0.0010080532,
-0.0611416735,
0.0118464157,
-0.0366386138,
0.0158893503,
0.027669549,
-0.0037739794,
-0.0075008459,
-0.0178686436,
-0.0308972895,
-0.0242419466,
-0.0351870619,
-0.0347986519,
0.0109176217,
0.0028879384,
-0.0485370308,
-0.0093318168,
0.0322233476,
-0.0374569669,
-0.0033796455,
0.0080416529,
-0.0296763293,
0.0253245328,
-0.010853285,
-0.0029834358,
0.0004751221,
0.023911532,
0.0237834658,
0.0389116667,
0.0213972814,
0.0254659001,
0.0360198691,
0.0118967975,
-0.0818133205,
0.0255424026,
-0.0258206222,
0.0491056778,
0.0159819033,
0.0035521456,
0.0314796716,
-0.0172225013,
0.0037789675,
-0.0036686438,
0.0595867485,
0.0184918456,
-0.0079396376,
0.0395673104,
-0.021055745,
0.0190475192,
-0.0298213772,
-0.0121724736,
-0.0167565439,
0.0223898645,
0.0553872921,
-0.0553158782,
-0.0023431086,
-0.0155933453,
2.793e-7,
0.0238840431,
0.0630461425,
0.0257367454,
0.0003553379,
0.0383618139,
0.0275479369,
0.0039274571,
-0.0032439129,
0.0230198223,
-0.0339929871,
-0.0274814349,
-0.0129698822,
0.0515920036,
0.0523965172,
-0.0712509602,
-0.0099533116,
-0.0586116277,
0.0104841003,
-0.0642779544,
-0.0329746194,
0.0012848945,
0.0792780071,
0.0243159756,
-0.0297240056,
-0.0177873839,
-0.0437981077,
0.0567742586,
-0.0031376891,
-0.0274461377,
0.0452427641,
0.0412565023,
0.0056155897,
0.0185874924,
0.0071908101,
-0.0397149362,
-0.0264666509,
-0.0378504656,
0.0385168716,
-0.0252852608,
0.0263528954,
0.0029575168,
-0.0080103381,
0.0045342166,
-0.0587292053,
0.0544408299,
-0.0179017335,
-0.021181399,
-0.0352425836,
-0.0396561362,
0.0040395604,
0.035817638,
-0.0439779833,
-0.0190497395,
0.0203871708,
0.0044969893,
0.0501421876,
-0.0174095426,
-0.0278087817,
-0.038991265,
-0.0084082484,
-0.0168811344,
-0.048220858,
0.0031895065,
-0.0232707858,
0.0097964425,
-0.0859051272,
0.0368777737,
2.861260697e-34,
0.0447222181,
0.0134900426,
0.0256864112,
0.0216851924,
0.0250494592,
0.0013424549,
0.0360560529,
-0.0036989064,
0.0190101862,
-0.0706327856,
-0.0430894196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14907v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14907v3 | Coverage-based Example Selection for In-Context Learning | 2023-05-24T08:58:28 | 2023-11-06T20:32:31 | Shivanshu Gupta, Matt Gardner, Sameer Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL), the ability of large language models to perform
novel tasks by conditioning on a prompt with a few task examples, requires
these examples to be informative about the test instance. The standard approach
of independently ranking and selecting the most similar examples selects
redundant examples while omitting important information. In this work, we show
that BERTScore-Recall (BSR) selects better examples that demonstrate more of
the salient aspects, e.g. reasoning patterns, of the test input. We further
extend BSR and many standard metrics to easily optimizable set-level metrics,
giving still better coverage of those salient aspects. On 15 datasets spanning
6 tasks and with 7 diverse LLMs, we show that (1) BSR is the superior metric
for in-context example selection across the board, and (2) for compositional
tasks, set selection using Set-BSR outperforms independent ranking by up to 17
points on average and, despite being training-free, surpasses methods that
leverage task or LLM-specific training. | [
-0.0323731788,
0.0126928808,
-0.012152046,
0.0187088028,
-0.038820751,
0.0394605771,
0.0137765538,
0.0124811549,
-0.012643829,
-0.0424478091,
-0.0103323804,
-0.021009814,
-0.0185144134,
-0.012154677,
0.0515908562,
0.0029925311,
0.0471986011,
-0.0278948471,
-0.0213978533,
0.0116912648,
-0.0404877067,
0.0098960875,
-0.0156037239,
0.0374549255,
0.021586528,
-0.025869498,
-0.0004574328,
0.0221884176,
0.0349505246,
-0.0424547121,
0.0483420752,
0.0344054662,
0.0294780489,
0.0080716508,
0.0000019171,
-0.0707501248,
-0.026286494,
-0.0082101999,
-0.015183948,
-0.0152728492,
-0.0357050411,
0.0289176051,
0.0250113625,
0.0378452986,
-0.0321183726,
0.0280870702,
0.0111620799,
0.0509998463,
0.0235387087,
0.0845325142,
-0.0115672415,
0.0149864219,
-0.0210500006,
-0.024003217,
0.044676099,
-0.0136873359,
0.0144390492,
-0.0158739071,
-0.002179371,
-0.0211238489,
0.0125871301,
0.0052189394,
0.0208382178,
0.0001699685,
0.0005126101,
0.0246662367,
-0.0979498997,
0.0332238711,
0.0256814677,
0.0537918322,
-0.0336519219,
-0.0406829417,
-0.002183828,
-0.0214474648,
0.0064134831,
0.0229912754,
-0.0457419232,
-0.0126155419,
-0.027486667,
0.0274561252,
-0.0087066675,
0.0006761753,
0.0333543345,
-0.008291808,
-0.0424350426,
0.0172535274,
0.0183925387,
-0.0497955605,
0.0334748626,
-0.0078235986,
-0.0474736467,
-0.0368637517,
-0.0028309035,
0.0150461188,
-0.0547212623,
0.026065262,
-0.0373790897,
-0.0120214522,
0.0532921627,
-0.0325986408,
0.0667896271,
0.0363704413,
-0.0286443401,
0.0361407585,
-0.0247894749,
0.044933632,
0.0317167379,
0.0341430157,
-0.0376665816,
-0.0031800265,
-0.0736553818,
0.019044308,
-0.0447497293,
0.0367504545,
0.0333870724,
-0.0044659344,
-0.0109683219,
0.0330849141,
-0.0266151298,
0.0395922586,
-0.0091567533,
-0.0313719213,
-0.0492713526,
0.0194820538,
-0.0059007984,
-0.0352574438,
-0.0313022211,
0.0079009859,
0.0003852003,
-0.0227999799,
-0.0323617384,
-0.0076782135,
0.0029830886,
-0.0465550385,
0.0308220852,
0.0672568381,
-0.0163823888,
-0.0766239837,
-0.0289274622,
0.0123034278,
0.0222806465,
-0.0310910065,
-0.0076319124,
-0.065732047,
-0.0039056982,
0.0144916633,
-0.000099204,
0.0117994081,
0.0022637865,
0.0562126599,
0.0171403047,
0.0433771908,
0.0703495592,
-0.0099981111,
0.0032051913,
-0.0062496122,
-0.0306548048,
0.0616317838,
0.0044893548,
-0.0028872672,
0.0254767034,
0.0280676801,
0.0217251405,
0.0341703594,
0.0225334391,
0.0347960778,
-0.0186238047,
0.0262544733,
0.0224972498,
0.0320051536,
0.0400923342,
0.0017774418,
-0.0394790992,
-0.0028856292,
0.057880953,
0.0396487676,
0.0146434242,
-0.0062492872,
0.0149576291,
0.0032407516,
0.0145396562,
0.018934017,
-0.0505025014,
0.0148154469,
-0.0299200714,
0.0049974155,
-0.0145581281,
-0.0161983371,
-0.0436082669,
-0.0060103824,
-0.03431293,
-0.0210669246,
-0.0136046074,
0.0402024314,
0.0360544175,
0.0395134948,
-0.0529798456,
0.1014840528,
0.0215742774,
-0.0441549979,
-0.018406149,
-0.0354207829,
0.054465428,
0.0253604837,
0.0573711284,
-0.0836043954,
-0.0476995371,
-0.0097881006,
0.0198137779,
0.0031065471,
0.0258825496,
-0.0306762252,
0.0281606149,
-0.0678061768,
-0.0394376777,
-0.0508808345,
0.0012313536,
-0.0146519532,
0.0327608287,
-0.0079309978,
-0.0196412727,
-0.0927991346,
-0.0297748316,
0.0508435853,
-0.0080309799,
-0.0493206233,
0.0134892426,
0.0276991893,
0.0256382618,
-0.0227316301,
-0.009461185,
-0.0017058477,
0.0268048532,
-0.0477865413,
0.0064307326,
0.0212115292,
-0.0839281231,
-0.1014967635,
-0.009576085,
-0.0574915186,
-0.0656881854,
0.0312042218,
-0.053308107,
-0.0221994389,
-0.0619018413,
-0.0330460146,
0.0596376993,
-0.0422561504,
0.0144778136,
-0.0188626703,
-0.0342705473,
-0.0365705267,
0.105226256,
-0.0225000102,
0.0294543933,
0.017577609,
0.0272679403,
0.0164341871,
-0.0395021625,
-0.0288682971,
0.0005883902,
-0.030888021,
-0.0017586858,
0.025463365,
0.0399129167,
-0.0782472268,
-0.0128217945,
-0.0984502658,
0.0159999114,
-0.036809735,
0.0236480162,
0.0059897876,
0.0111048138,
-0.0053120544,
-0.0341232754,
-0.0391548462,
-0.0489182994,
-0.0403818488,
0.0207058042,
0.0375043154,
-0.0072369128,
0.0044135102,
-0.0255037863,
-0.0066598379,
-0.0067574251,
0.0642775819,
-0.0242197905,
0.0289676469,
-0.0549481027,
0.0790550038,
-0.001045587,
0.0013408556,
-0.0256357547,
0.0002860158,
0.024846578,
-0.0126927216,
0.0117235044,
0.0645555556,
-0.0039012148,
-0.0008349932,
0.0498481281,
0.0394497849,
-0.0679911524,
0.0240305532,
0.0017357997,
-0.0054136897,
-0.0145747988,
-0.019092802,
0.0293399878,
0.007459722,
-0.0057602958,
-0.000609763,
-0.0273805391,
-0.0258939117,
-0.0057392684,
-0.0015649229,
-0.0458216444,
-0.0030942701,
-0.0150827793,
0.0193144474,
-0.0297977012,
-0.0560821369,
0.0773608387,
0.004930431,
0.0092265448,
-0.0734507218,
0.0154651757,
-0.0526571758,
0.058413174,
0.0013064798,
-0.007824895,
-0.0113194436,
-0.0414757133,
-0.0468856618,
-0.0080600139,
0.0249779914,
-0.0265332628,
0.0774309412,
-0.0393791348,
0.0239947233,
0.0053654606,
-0.070843786,
-0.0641256571,
0.0175760053,
0.0158523489,
0.0413016379,
-0.036755532,
0.0062017059,
-0.0333983079,
-0.0332064331,
0.0232022684,
0.0535334423,
0.0105444966,
-0.0059284391,
-0.0103957755,
0.0306870453,
0.0118390927,
0.0153125189,
0.0081961565,
-0.0439278185,
0.0010998374,
0.0172605198,
0.1012967974,
0.022965651,
-0.0184103269,
0.0302063599,
0.0209315699,
-0.065361701,
-0.018628737,
0.0322555788,
0.0628796518,
-0.0410610549,
-0.0251019038,
0.0959025323,
0.0332714878,
-0.0474680811,
0.0012969036,
-0.0321959704,
0.0251310617,
0.0513341948,
0.0227865111,
-0.0569736771,
-0.0184053052,
0.0266644098,
0.0084214034,
-0.0083826222,
-0.0309721287,
0.0101632308,
-0.1359833181,
0.0269174594,
0.0023195753,
-0.046665594,
-0.0068028783,
-0.0752921775,
0.0510677844,
-0.0119583476,
0.0181761365,
-0.0154919336,
-0.0184404533,
-0.0185520463,
0.0341529921,
0.0013598703,
-0.073363319,
0.0761095434,
-0.0252522826,
-0.0070134839,
0.0493176393,
0.0312473178,
-0.0218538679,
-0.0284696855,
0.0118991174,
-0.0215980969,
0.0117967548,
-0.0044995197,
0.0534015521,
0.0264421403,
-0.0070444895,
0.0096198283,
0.0391505584,
-0.0077416645,
-0.0258227978,
0.0201681927,
0.0586176962,
-0.0215165056,
0.0155855222,
0.0091917785,
-0.0578468107,
0.0542913266,
0.0918251798,
0.0557604022,
-0.0297569167,
-0.0038763811,
0.0002323914,
0.003125716,
-0.069608815,
0.0536700264,
0.0386865996,
-0.0404113568,
0.019109726,
-0.0764059201,
-0.024648292,
0.0754416734,
0.0461119711,
0.0049190163,
0.0078647723,
-0.0009343428,
-0.0058389399,
-0.0525648557,
0.0412474722,
-0.0022294642,
0.0277945474,
-0.0306187999,
-0.0464316681,
-0.0003050544,
-0.0186326262,
-0.0295208711,
0.0049279416,
-0.0274692681,
-0.0402269587,
-0.0201318339,
0.060867656,
0.0149129266,
0.0569558814,
-0.0011733159,
-0.0374107882,
0.0945404544,
0.019182222,
0.0161422491,
0.0088030389,
0.0614107475,
-0.0072160908,
-0.0154133504,
0.0487644039,
-0.0689457878,
-0.0002616228,
0.0160922278,
0.0508551039,
0.0044410592,
0.0255526584,
0.0311737414,
-0.0243409947,
0.0174641535,
-0.0252310596,
0.0034387838,
-0.0351322033,
0.057955429,
0.0223728027,
-0.0005118204,
-0.0159941278,
0.0332157873,
-0.0134081068,
-0.0194267444,
0.003333366,
0.0313556157,
-0.0255968515,
0.0454252101,
-0.0553650409,
0.039125476,
0.0019979931,
0.0212767646,
0.0204456951,
0.0220942367,
-0.0441943705,
-0.0093697459,
0.0204319358,
0.0316424146,
-0.0251220837,
0.0409312099,
0.0337550528,
0.0371307507,
-0.0171048231,
0.0085080573,
-0.0397447906,
-0.0149812857,
-0.0073550628,
0.0231098533,
0.0520613529,
-0.052527301,
0.0526650771,
-0.0027452291,
-0.0132790525,
-0.0169457532,
-0.0126410117,
0.0020553777,
-0.0056485394,
-0.0169740263,
0.0485352129,
0.0105197849,
0.0155138867,
0.0799774304,
-0.0260349382,
0.0717370883,
-0.0138585269,
0.0135793984,
-0.0534764901,
0.0142668216,
0.0793010965,
0.0455958992,
0.013224978,
-0.017870672,
-0.0257502757,
-0.0695941895,
0.0561315529,
0.0017344201,
-0.0203528907,
-0.0074546817,
0.0489874072,
0.0679765046,
-0.0095133334,
-0.0012604558,
-0.0062769642,
-0.0322249532,
-0.0143385371,
-0.0243756231,
-0.0435936041,
-5.600049577e-33,
-0.0070307851,
-0.009012443,
0.0119532803,
-0.0050249477,
0.0202278513,
0.0235990454,
-0.0431109667,
-0.039725624,
-0.0109620001,
0.0139795635,
-0.0315993987,
-0.0026534961,
0.0079612704,
0.0340078957,
0.0088366196,
-0.0215236824,
0.0468482375,
0.0143446838,
-0.0483433045,
0.0321914889,
0.0234726891,
0.0269148443,
0.0769629031,
-0.0440304764,
-0.0315094776,
-0.0094732158,
0.0110861193,
0.0057151839,
-0.0267298501,
0.0697545558,
0.0147756729,
0.0390443839,
0.0282525718,
-0.0235999133,
-0.0274491534,
0.0064055398,
-0.0844393075,
-0.0904682577,
0.0134733161,
-0.0353286341,
-0.0329913236,
-0.006177891,
0.0419717394,
-0.0110998107,
-0.0166129209,
-0.0011187458,
0.0367317311,
-0.0312153753,
-0.0750292912,
-0.0647714958,
-0.0342126898,
0.0005687575,
0.0008095676,
-0.0577436611,
-0.0103847906,
0.0234279223,
-0.0077177701,
0.0223983135,
-0.0151498038,
0.0076862467,
-0.011219346,
0.011067003,
0.0150058465,
0.0031811353,
0.006614082,
0.0975470096,
-0.0072104572,
0.008978257,
0.0608153306,
-0.0693436489,
0.0240295865,
0.0812566429,
-0.0130567998,
0.0291192587,
0.0284439344,
0.0168485269,
-0.0965657532,
0.0454872698,
0.0515135266,
0.0223069955,
0.0279089119,
0.0272087269,
-0.0540303178,
-0.0072015305,
-0.0437440984,
0.0126247816,
-0.0369448625,
0.0015423492,
0.0503739826,
0.0049635,
-0.0148696899,
0.0165557507,
0.0254978407,
0.0071600913,
-0.0256415028,
0.0254245773,
-0.0308719389,
-0.0131831281,
-0.0006653642,
0.0227898601,
-0.0265410691,
-0.0424504429,
0.0105002327,
0.0040900563,
0.040760912,
-0.0112497984,
0.1016662344,
0.0281408522,
-0.0531113259,
-0.0041719354,
-0.0374841876,
-0.0122161433,
-0.0207141805,
0.0331289656,
0.0112845637,
0.0181715861,
0.025553558,
0.0395506322,
0.007786788,
-0.0545995273,
-0.0415740535,
-0.0018212909,
-0.0269170031,
0.0210889336,
-0.0102046607,
-0.0175551791,
-0.0297658332,
0.0353441052,
0.0409515761,
-0.0483714752,
0.0028864371,
0.0161690973,
2.634e-7,
0.0165725276,
0.0582014211,
-0.0240523126,
0.0246259626,
0.0169960205,
0.0342510231,
-0.041676864,
0.0518108346,
0.0151390098,
-0.0003164578,
0.0146175455,
-0.0094664562,
0.0442150794,
0.025174655,
-0.0956105664,
0.0372069292,
-0.0769212022,
-0.0127225714,
-0.0345682502,
-0.0108789019,
0.0426317714,
0.0645392239,
0.0201754291,
-0.0344442464,
0.013322372,
-0.0525705665,
0.0568338409,
-0.0352727324,
-0.0103220269,
0.0178021453,
-0.0155557813,
0.0307351425,
0.0109783215,
0.0571656041,
-0.0301643442,
0.0238863602,
0.0141511653,
0.0310105812,
-0.0004411266,
-0.0635623932,
-0.025814794,
0.0009897464,
0.0183500145,
-0.0513077155,
0.0724986717,
-0.0611686222,
-0.0182947256,
-0.0195554923,
0.0073815621,
-0.0349088982,
0.0244332589,
0.0152868424,
-0.0286152139,
0.027273003,
0.0046633799,
-0.014652852,
-0.0213860571,
-0.0884545371,
-0.0084825186,
0.0290317237,
-0.051599469,
-0.0355223715,
-0.0263919942,
-0.000643939,
0.0114185335,
-0.0835904405,
0.0245094504,
2.472507956e-34,
0.0388365388,
-0.0098581519,
-0.0080345869,
0.0341901965,
0.0047057564,
-0.0283253193,
-0.000830157,
0.0049825655,
0.0015557043,
-0.0335875787,
-0.0099918405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14904v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14904v1 | Identifying Informational Sources in News Articles | 2023-05-24T08:56:35 | 2023-05-24T08:56:35 | Alexander Spangher, Nanyun Peng, Jonathan May, Emilio Ferrara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | News articles are driven by the informational sources journalists use in
reporting. Modeling when, how and why sources get used together in stories can
help us better understand the information we consume and even help journalists
with the task of producing it. In this work, we take steps toward this goal by
constructing the largest and widest-ranging annotated dataset, to date, of
informational sources used in news writing. We show that our dataset can be
used to train high-performing models for information detection and source
attribution. We further introduce a novel task, source prediction, to study the
compositionality of sources in news articles. We show good performance on this
task, which we argue is an important proof for narrative science exploring the
internal structure of news articles and aiding in planning-based language
generation, and an important step towards a source-recommendation system to aid
journalists. | [
0.0506659746,
0.0264148377,
-0.0011836539,
0.0071298848,
-0.0369047076,
0.0006927098,
-0.0060789865,
-0.0185443014,
-0.0249247812,
-0.0329309851,
0.0097191837,
0.0031042846,
-0.0234503038,
0.023728488,
0.0049464297,
-0.009184448,
0.0154870301,
0.039725136,
0.0216865931,
0.0352998152,
0.0382266678,
0.0866902098,
0.0047714142,
0.0296557695,
-0.0382548757,
-0.0403594673,
-0.0107188188,
0.0331263766,
0.0059917741,
-0.0412206724,
-0.0029918589,
0.0279574338,
0.0224129763,
-0.0015748782,
0.0000016337,
-0.0076265829,
-0.0168965757,
-0.018826155,
-0.0138481604,
-0.0151405344,
0.0116462708,
-0.0701578483,
0.0147758089,
-0.0040275841,
-0.0210227724,
0.0028017932,
0.0304739345,
0.0535269231,
0.0707155243,
0.1174889952,
-0.0311620738,
-0.0028262748,
0.015412963,
-0.0157273803,
0.0570911616,
0.0033471345,
0.0352713987,
-0.0019960469,
-0.0376037918,
-0.008349021,
0.0165102836,
0.0089579988,
0.0296282582,
-0.014319662,
0.0005234465,
0.0116902338,
-0.0200253967,
-0.0097873928,
0.0155514646,
0.0702521801,
0.0329461507,
-0.0633159503,
0.0376315936,
-0.0025658431,
-0.0080734566,
0.0298909191,
-0.0290854592,
0.0386503078,
-0.0605292618,
-0.0009982734,
0.009904094,
-0.0509363301,
0.0200439282,
0.0344402008,
0.055133868,
0.0662303194,
0.0080027878,
0.0052653914,
-0.0102037489,
0.0227486044,
0.046963051,
-0.0783639699,
0.0037451829,
-0.0218935553,
-0.009242204,
0.0326002128,
-0.0541747808,
-0.003754314,
-0.0160811692,
-0.0765433162,
-0.0240871087,
-0.0149066728,
-0.0186341051,
0.0352836475,
0.0102462759,
-0.046916008,
-0.0244324505,
-0.0130600585,
-0.0060788174,
0.0236735772,
-0.0185191389,
0.0301532652,
-0.0055445745,
0.0219603982,
-0.0129646882,
-0.0329252183,
-0.0169103071,
0.0129519068,
-0.0006570431,
-0.0049300804,
-0.0175671596,
0.0235461891,
-0.0455592796,
-0.0066245738,
0.0032353012,
0.0336397812,
-0.0491528511,
0.0494439788,
0.0016021598,
-0.0016436211,
-0.0266129598,
0.0379330143,
-0.0035758878,
-0.0178210773,
-0.0283266474,
0.0217634924,
-0.028995771,
0.0073471088,
-0.0748300105,
-0.0623725541,
-0.0009870575,
-0.0519730635,
0.0450341739,
-0.0668839961,
0.0349062011,
0.0088207051,
0.0033611541,
-0.0791305453,
-0.007642535,
0.0475892909,
-0.048466634,
0.0180765595,
-0.0132843433,
-0.009851383,
0.0245580431,
0.0072277668,
0.0336585417,
0.0975659117,
0.047139857,
0.0625238717,
0.0507577024,
0.0455094203,
-0.0089401705,
-0.0114461109,
0.0231024176,
0.0563023463,
0.0135318851,
0.0028407262,
-0.0576897599,
0.0257892553,
0.0326619297,
0.0053023198,
-0.040112406,
0.0021898025,
0.0774368197,
0.001743002,
0.0122239077,
0.0058677387,
0.0914783701,
0.0182876885,
-0.006283164,
0.0464334525,
-0.0042929882,
0.058053337,
0.0048097991,
-0.008070848,
0.0284735728,
0.0318787582,
-0.0374719501,
-0.0055542313,
-0.0083198342,
-0.0003547578,
-0.0310564265,
-0.0220404323,
-0.0069356458,
0.0271462761,
-0.0349720307,
0.0307006259,
0.0487447977,
-0.0439613499,
0.0245241392,
0.0374714173,
0.0636935011,
0.0215829071,
0.0300736818,
-0.0026633881,
-0.0006708709,
-0.0385048352,
0.0764300227,
0.0109154759,
-0.0129684508,
-0.0306822192,
0.0004024049,
-0.0191491246,
-0.0160820968,
-0.0286427867,
0.0306833033,
0.0198413543,
0.0233303551,
0.0069914651,
-0.0011617402,
0.0058862758,
-0.0371146165,
0.0436574258,
-0.0220888667,
-0.0339462385,
0.009728021,
0.0145102609,
0.0091976803,
0.027688019,
-0.0004521618,
-0.0021486327,
0.0108433068,
0.0123171313,
-0.0099168373,
0.046284996,
0.0113690523,
-0.0279478058,
0.0198154356,
-0.0782105997,
-0.0019191361,
-0.029687874,
-0.0097919293,
-0.0585472286,
0.0556659028,
-0.0412827544,
0.0058842194,
-0.0280739497,
-0.0234059971,
0.0337005109,
0.0022759812,
0.0140355974,
0.0702822208,
0.0083994381,
0.0042936993,
0.0142104952,
-0.0185259916,
0.0161831547,
-0.011120677,
0.0165830087,
-0.0039113141,
-0.0155731589,
0.0023750125,
0.0518994555,
-0.0411616042,
-0.0360709019,
-0.0308962855,
-0.0385228693,
0.0440856516,
-0.0332273431,
0.0062018912,
0.051826328,
-0.0118821748,
-0.0002280912,
0.0015189401,
-0.0171864312,
-0.0249057412,
-0.0288499333,
0.0127472114,
0.0055770194,
0.0323623009,
0.0329815038,
-0.0329440981,
-0.0000379666,
-0.0539311767,
0.0565622672,
0.0338290967,
-0.02464737,
-0.0574689656,
0.0108705759,
-0.0195632521,
-0.0208624881,
-0.0212753471,
-0.0122347521,
0.0101219043,
0.0107289823,
-0.0093442826,
0.0919125527,
0.0197538864,
0.0325020514,
0.0580305718,
-0.004034712,
-0.0274674874,
0.0344203189,
-0.026626531,
0.0455819778,
-0.0286867842,
-0.082401447,
0.0175422747,
0.0106179751,
0.0211963784,
0.0302767716,
-0.021702854,
0.0478296168,
0.0145988967,
-0.0072569544,
0.0250661299,
-0.0386624895,
0.0079603856,
0.034172684,
-0.0121806543,
0.0002475145,
0.0432760157,
-0.0204806663,
0.0354812071,
-0.0150804231,
-0.0023019623,
-0.0511611849,
0.0102210538,
-0.0255857743,
0.0180848278,
0.0152161568,
0.008426982,
-0.0425022468,
0.0040179756,
0.0694372281,
0.0156831685,
0.0386392251,
-0.0188000072,
0.0125618242,
0.035829436,
-0.041790545,
-0.0180539563,
-0.0652809367,
-0.0085031837,
-0.0230097212,
0.0296491422,
-0.0507997833,
-0.0787019506,
-0.0298482291,
0.0640944391,
0.0280370731,
-0.0389491431,
-0.0036206176,
-0.0012483475,
0.0492765978,
0.0536357313,
-0.0300563276,
0.0124256741,
0.0155434031,
-0.0197387803,
0.0201107077,
0.0309004169,
0.042100396,
0.0021139714,
-0.0018323506,
0.0034244906,
-0.0278207231,
-0.0437310338,
0.0059210258,
0.0303128548,
-0.0188709926,
-0.0221598931,
0.0922090709,
0.0370304026,
-0.0907913595,
-0.0052769086,
0.0444917157,
0.0018594029,
0.0379431434,
0.0413541123,
-0.1084711924,
-0.0011220967,
-0.0016702523,
-0.0007321158,
-0.0072566802,
-0.0483164787,
-0.0625225753,
-0.0813895985,
0.006401421,
0.0042320262,
-0.0250704736,
-0.0192906577,
-0.0681285709,
-0.0259027295,
-0.0308104064,
-0.0357576981,
-0.0114481198,
-0.0316647962,
0.012357479,
0.0059809997,
-0.0514456034,
-0.0391437598,
-0.0260840598,
-0.0217838045,
0.0111962445,
0.0543421917,
0.053814359,
-0.0121190967,
0.0136281541,
-0.0290194117,
-0.0080602998,
-0.0494972318,
-0.0044147102,
0.1048389599,
-0.0679818168,
-0.002156686,
-0.017681485,
0.0595956147,
-0.0103602698,
-0.0194583461,
0.0223026928,
0.0157644898,
0.0052836603,
-0.0004741384,
0.0053341142,
0.0553923026,
0.0760807544,
0.0739519596,
0.0433141477,
-0.0177915022,
0.0162789412,
-0.053525161,
0.0343334302,
-0.0865127668,
-0.0142600266,
0.0219023395,
-0.0417591371,
-0.0388266966,
-0.1010206267,
-0.0484540574,
-0.003307235,
0.0346280262,
0.0237096921,
0.0130866924,
0.003182462,
-0.0388471112,
-0.0347844325,
0.0117541291,
0.0182435326,
-0.0131508363,
-0.0045249285,
-0.0157089885,
-0.0034837925,
-0.039331764,
-0.0048120772,
0.0651323199,
-0.0830327868,
-0.0479158983,
-0.0117915925,
-0.0070401602,
0.0194644108,
0.0564371832,
-0.0079801176,
-0.0434419736,
-0.0172751807,
0.0388938971,
-0.0413437746,
0.0226253644,
-0.003151472,
-0.0180167407,
0.0211276636,
0.016981924,
-0.0357612744,
0.0231207497,
-0.0258728713,
-0.0159128197,
-0.0361418054,
0.0715027675,
0.0382915735,
-0.0194207095,
0.0062498115,
-0.0271701571,
0.0029271462,
-0.0677355006,
-0.003985072,
-0.0383382998,
-0.0328683294,
-0.0270885509,
0.0405021571,
0.0180186834,
-0.0107790921,
-0.0431900732,
0.0332471579,
-0.0164230615,
0.0495538674,
-0.0444182642,
-0.0077842465,
0.0519158542,
-0.0180349462,
-0.0423452035,
0.0064707836,
-0.0131554222,
0.0486214869,
-0.0269203465,
0.0335616879,
-0.0058232429,
0.0100254333,
0.0232440345,
0.003861726,
0.0342522264,
-0.0398396142,
-0.1069016755,
-0.0012292335,
-0.0406913273,
0.0071847779,
0.0490382314,
-0.0683653206,
0.0876589343,
-0.0214318112,
-0.003432255,
-0.0086712455,
0.0379483961,
-0.0140666086,
-0.0346169583,
-0.0003311984,
0.019297678,
-0.0405145139,
0.0058661425,
0.1022378653,
0.028568564,
0.0720921531,
0.0159926508,
-0.0471256897,
-0.0274983905,
-0.0346552804,
-0.0076957517,
0.0562633872,
0.0130051486,
-0.0340677872,
-0.0486334153,
-0.0180370416,
0.0339086466,
-0.0288254246,
0.019684758,
-0.010729054,
-0.0096054757,
0.0873275548,
0.0165615287,
-0.008651169,
-0.0488857068,
-0.0276004747,
-0.0471405499,
-0.0447813421,
-0.0052000238,
-5.610349846e-33,
-0.023108637,
-0.0044957963,
-0.0020495488,
0.0090871435,
-0.0104734283,
0.066911146,
-0.0393453203,
-0.0274490323,
-0.0397995822,
0.0427796468,
-0.0050289519,
0.0361036658,
0.0203405488,
-0.0080162277,
0.0107555743,
0.0136543959,
0.0320454277,
-0.0022188593,
-0.0463971049,
0.0325143039,
0.072358124,
-0.0023711137,
0.0627908036,
-0.048498828,
0.0397467911,
-0.0186496824,
-0.050392285,
-0.0174017958,
0.065863885,
0.0547897257,
0.0114100417,
-0.005563831,
0.0279297177,
-0.0320905559,
-0.0032574052,
0.0330415554,
-0.0591079891,
-0.0212040078,
0.0556983948,
-0.0057585221,
-0.0414033085,
-0.0517145991,
0.0334727988,
-0.0221476723,
0.0302823503,
-0.0319865979,
0.066916205,
-0.0217282176,
-0.0070917308,
-0.0572146513,
-0.0594320856,
0.0170311388,
-0.0343751423,
-0.0027796463,
-0.0176770557,
0.0391088426,
0.0159428921,
-0.0325090028,
-0.0422764011,
0.0229284391,
-0.0547313727,
0.08080744,
0.0183775779,
-0.0329943486,
-0.0233624745,
0.0648602769,
0.0040399968,
0.0149975801,
-0.0410251133,
0.017527841,
0.0077294414,
0.0428942479,
0.009241093,
0.0758448392,
-0.0077876449,
-0.034380056,
-0.0996133313,
0.0366185829,
0.0619700179,
0.0107196206,
0.0274730865,
-0.0304411221,
-0.0023855323,
-0.0187052544,
-0.0231547672,
-0.0460532755,
-0.0111143254,
-0.0605949014,
-0.0088847056,
0.0250837933,
0.0086984904,
0.0576943867,
0.0309513472,
-0.03009988,
0.0000053732,
0.0957122892,
-0.0767539069,
0.0237887651,
0.0040634335,
0.0299202688,
-0.0946365222,
0.0320524424,
0.02377248,
0.0220979173,
0.0139197856,
-0.0025531689,
0.0834363103,
0.0211545136,
-0.0405943282,
-0.0125334784,
-0.032970503,
-0.0037183377,
-0.0201705229,
0.0046539721,
0.0312516019,
0.0299034324,
-0.0170814339,
-0.0129729081,
0.0182972234,
0.0017510613,
0.0226466153,
-0.0745878667,
0.0051651425,
0.0339516178,
-0.0328532234,
-0.0147722727,
-0.0015829373,
-0.0091994451,
0.0380964577,
-0.0451538675,
-0.0036842099,
-0.0187632442,
2.445e-7,
0.0310514942,
0.0361059532,
0.0118883643,
0.0292581636,
-0.0076209386,
-0.0178562179,
0.0085980836,
0.0563048981,
-0.0350021273,
-0.0817568973,
0.0142702525,
0.0090997694,
0.0470950529,
0.0491308048,
-0.1211783886,
-0.0026105111,
-0.0887823775,
-0.0193509012,
-0.069188945,
-0.058013998,
-0.0202758815,
0.0412067249,
0.0495852605,
-0.0052060629,
-0.0127743073,
-0.0329209007,
0.0579385459,
-0.0087018572,
-0.0394129716,
0.0457052924,
0.0476319827,
0.0013447955,
-0.0316073522,
-0.0262108389,
-0.0526319295,
-0.0000396973,
-0.0052813552,
0.0218936745,
0.0398351736,
-0.0174662862,
0.020612089,
-0.0107196216,
-0.0033194236,
-0.0099775074,
0.049837973,
-0.0018921607,
-0.0126987817,
-0.0491032973,
-0.0353687443,
-0.0014639973,
0.0070201689,
-0.0078928806,
0.0137421647,
0.0469444953,
-0.0229982566,
-0.0197917484,
0.0207630824,
-0.050340265,
-0.0383867994,
0.0449022092,
-0.0198496599,
0.0084502464,
-0.0135513507,
-0.0316856205,
0.0023554908,
-0.0621576309,
0.0448037609,
1.9769402e-34,
0.0241538286,
0.0210082419,
-0.0161410421,
0.0132147828,
0.0616755038,
-0.0035788724,
-0.0446349718,
-0.0198191106,
0.0013414068,
-0.0295328666,
-0.0022156555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14902v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14902v2 | M4: Multi-generator, Multi-domain, and Multi-lingual Black-Box Machine-Generated Text Detection | 2023-05-24T08:55:11 | 2024-03-10T01:04:48 | Yuxia Wang, Jonibek Mansurov, Petar Ivanov, Jinyan Su, Artem Shelmanov, Akim Tsvigun, Chenxi Whitehouse, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Tarek Mahmoud, Toru Sasaki, Thomas Arnold, Alham Fikri Aji, Nizar Habash, Iryna Gurevych, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capability to
generate fluent responses to a wide variety of user queries. However, this has
also raised concerns about the potential misuse of such texts in journalism,
education, and academia. In this study, we strive to create automated systems
that can detect machine-generated texts and pinpoint potential misuse. We first
introduce a large-scale benchmark \textbf{M4}, which is a multi-generator,
multi-domain, and multi-lingual corpus for machine-generated text detection.
Through an extensive empirical study of this dataset, we show that it is
challenging for detectors to generalize well on instances from unseen domains
or LLMs. In such cases, detectors tend to misclassify machine-generated text as
human-written. These results show that the problem is far from solved and that
there is a lot of room for improvement. We believe that our dataset will enable
future research towards more robust approaches to this pressing societal
problem. The dataset is available at https://github.com/mbzuai-nlp/M4. | [
0.0639014319,
0.0474506579,
-0.0169004612,
0.0698694363,
-0.0410075709,
0.008595258,
0.0211167615,
0.0200376511,
0.0341024548,
-0.0548298061,
-0.0241033342,
-0.0300408639,
-0.0278959274,
0.0441112369,
0.0231161714,
0.0316452309,
0.0087195234,
0.0045161485,
-0.0221002679,
0.0157905873,
0.0282679945,
0.0471953116,
0.0180125702,
0.0415604599,
-0.0140456241,
-0.0315020271,
0.0363114923,
0.0133129694,
0.0242858138,
-0.0262270346,
0.0341102518,
0.0752704591,
-0.0171419811,
0.0919303298,
0.0000016665,
-0.0348186158,
-0.012312822,
-0.0213620365,
-0.0071580028,
-0.0011977385,
0.0749723986,
-0.0320373885,
-0.0197371989,
0.0270188805,
-0.0412806943,
-0.0190019365,
-0.0053594597,
0.0364721529,
0.0520178191,
0.0885008797,
-0.0275005307,
-0.0075064693,
0.0367034152,
-0.0019572007,
-0.0141485352,
-0.019107284,
0.0683666095,
-0.0336806998,
-0.0109351603,
0.0219012611,
0.0255076364,
0.0191691797,
-0.00515727,
-0.0369861498,
-0.0247094817,
-0.0030236645,
-0.0242111217,
-0.0320901088,
0.0020836203,
0.0492956005,
-0.014171063,
-0.0456167497,
0.0532838777,
-0.0013551284,
0.0097784307,
0.0258358959,
0.0338750444,
0.0428761914,
-0.0608522892,
-0.0006532281,
0.0026033707,
-0.0193487648,
0.0325730778,
0.0729417875,
0.0238971487,
0.0248071067,
0.0120030474,
-0.0499937125,
0.0140872616,
0.0164697003,
0.0000944716,
-0.0550793745,
0.0552395731,
-0.0052048853,
0.0030887434,
0.0092754066,
-0.0876206383,
-0.0602936819,
0.0396659896,
-0.0646444634,
0.0086747892,
-0.0121282348,
-0.0299936235,
0.0317865387,
-0.0472037978,
0.0218064841,
-0.048423972,
0.0014790439,
-0.0171187427,
0.0016313241,
-0.0103364298,
-0.0248182211,
-0.0093315179,
-0.0085865464,
-0.0220304746,
0.0036909757,
-0.0548878759,
0.0369659923,
-0.0008888368,
0.0033695605,
-0.0489854477,
-0.0187415145,
-0.0151143754,
-0.0200072899,
-0.0105297491,
0.0064821239,
0.0131342504,
0.0284041949,
-0.0134195797,
-0.0858098194,
0.0008522708,
0.0700906515,
-0.0025060407,
-0.0190682672,
0.0156976208,
0.0522325039,
-0.0012963247,
-0.0445805714,
-0.0543143824,
-0.0759521797,
-0.0374236964,
-0.0407272503,
0.0210722592,
-0.0744518414,
-0.0238271393,
0.0036380661,
-0.0045361915,
-0.047696542,
0.011438434,
0.0624635778,
-0.0213112719,
0.0250429176,
0.0043983823,
0.0066461377,
0.0547809862,
0.0091919489,
-0.0017179769,
0.069288373,
0.0200463198,
0.0809523985,
0.0513376296,
0.0101626096,
0.044900801,
0.0694546625,
0.0107049132,
0.0326220393,
0.003685222,
-0.015483004,
-0.0277183931,
0.0270602088,
0.0232106932,
0.0421555601,
0.0083052646,
-0.000055428,
0.0643724576,
0.0339586474,
-0.0294860937,
-0.0201519933,
0.0825036392,
0.0197216216,
-0.0121212685,
0.0275387838,
-0.001937459,
-0.0566504374,
-0.0508852638,
-0.0314855017,
0.0171499345,
0.0614035241,
0.0178330112,
-0.0149453422,
-0.0204336364,
-0.0167956445,
-0.0159741528,
-0.0207503047,
0.0585814118,
0.0155191412,
-0.0302211531,
-0.0026475182,
0.0049462039,
-0.0359973237,
0.037697956,
-0.0509569943,
0.0468139052,
0.0473842211,
0.0552450828,
0.0125291003,
0.0453171507,
-0.0540258363,
0.0391073674,
0.0841119736,
0.0277788453,
-0.0025263403,
-0.0211790893,
-0.0236467812,
-0.0473284572,
0.010722613,
0.0159700308,
0.023085691,
0.0436167791,
0.0077351173,
0.0287459753,
-0.0151993642,
-0.0677658394,
0.0476686694,
-0.0381730087,
-0.0207891557,
0.0046761092,
0.0106397578,
0.0263658538,
0.0113499826,
-0.0184069313,
-0.019909123,
0.0479195639,
-0.0429217741,
-0.0275124311,
-0.0154310716,
-0.0064239157,
0.0065092747,
0.022493396,
-0.0617065579,
-0.0279064663,
0.0408924893,
-0.0127062425,
-0.0051071732,
-0.0088160047,
-0.0272326861,
0.0014107974,
-0.0690742359,
0.0165650621,
-0.03448328,
0.0459908508,
-0.0172304101,
0.0812649801,
-0.0123945177,
0.0216916073,
0.0234629102,
-0.0270612203,
0.0528462008,
0.0061821393,
-0.029353125,
-0.0118783088,
-0.0232132506,
0.0266605821,
0.0340518951,
0.0076914607,
-0.0235240106,
0.0002362148,
-0.0565034896,
0.0020919342,
-0.0274020638,
0.0090083079,
0.049676016,
-0.0072210818,
-0.0225687157,
0.0165771116,
-0.0142211057,
-0.0485629849,
0.055752337,
0.0290403198,
0.0343275033,
-0.0297265779,
0.0438414663,
0.0108961156,
0.0225654915,
-0.026485322,
0.0417875648,
0.0359313153,
-0.0226929784,
-0.0556393526,
0.0505900234,
0.0133414278,
-0.0115560247,
-0.0002271887,
-0.0275341179,
-0.0238931738,
-0.0105652353,
0.0164735559,
0.0511276238,
0.0228888281,
0.0259423573,
0.046209801,
0.0608431734,
-0.025233889,
-0.0218971949,
-0.0132658193,
-0.0039719511,
-0.0231047049,
-0.0655581653,
0.0493489951,
0.0304186139,
0.0248384178,
0.0014413652,
0.0041770292,
0.0310178474,
-0.0269518942,
-0.0502637178,
-0.0099944808,
-0.0319630578,
-0.0421565026,
0.0592847914,
-0.0228200741,
-0.0489544235,
0.0579916798,
-0.0238012336,
0.0278793667,
-0.0394096449,
-0.0122996541,
-0.0168525428,
0.004531268,
-0.001702234,
0.0481916927,
0.0335168578,
-0.007955716,
-0.0173645727,
0.0217916146,
0.0372333489,
-0.0259522256,
0.0450454764,
-0.0202297419,
0.0031774975,
-0.0110942516,
-0.0259453319,
-0.0759984255,
-0.0621402413,
-0.0121787693,
-0.029647816,
0.0288554225,
-0.0182238892,
-0.0325732864,
-0.0112431832,
0.0145268487,
0.0209990963,
-0.0223968923,
-0.0007738699,
-0.0175043363,
0.0901697949,
0.0535681061,
-0.0449302606,
0.0203169119,
-0.0240227114,
-0.0136675956,
0.039029099,
-0.0198108554,
0.0334826149,
0.0129921837,
-0.0253001619,
0.0228199065,
0.0125883836,
0.0101270908,
-0.0129085723,
0.0195668824,
-0.0373600349,
-0.0043750945,
0.084152557,
0.0116571859,
-0.0536011979,
-0.0155117484,
-0.0143395336,
0.0096903276,
0.0169641934,
-0.0023858624,
-0.0949795917,
-0.0354727507,
0.0032436103,
0.0090332655,
-0.0404245183,
-0.017862862,
-0.0047799014,
-0.1319729835,
0.0026330871,
0.0009320472,
-0.0258364473,
-0.0206272602,
-0.0125945499,
-0.0107674114,
0.0139203724,
-0.0175047629,
-0.0403397195,
-0.0086891437,
-0.0145055875,
0.0132275214,
0.0042794649,
-0.0950129256,
-0.0159725901,
-0.0422416255,
-0.0050982153,
0.0584664121,
0.0467372611,
-0.0355530344,
-0.0332508422,
0.0352819003,
-0.0091214031,
-0.0420505144,
0.0039200746,
0.0464449897,
-0.0259662829,
-0.0140779559,
-0.0062486613,
0.0438381545,
-0.054270111,
0.0166555066,
0.0325522833,
0.068511419,
0.0147589818,
-0.0440386496,
-0.0389373563,
0.0010196317,
0.0226302948,
0.0833845064,
0.0106069092,
-0.0540469326,
-0.0273523871,
-0.0303516947,
0.0226667803,
-0.0882028267,
-0.0344490744,
0.0192176104,
-0.0401036106,
-0.0181604568,
-0.0768428519,
-0.0301827248,
-0.0034877888,
-0.0091793761,
0.0346308462,
0.0050192112,
-0.0162535794,
-0.0126958713,
-0.0348963961,
-0.0057200394,
-0.030435646,
0.0340412445,
-0.0879271999,
0.001719365,
0.0088591967,
-0.0424533449,
-0.0203141198,
0.0534627549,
-0.0769113824,
-0.0478925891,
0.0003118018,
-0.0098408936,
0.0160758421,
0.0096755,
-0.0183437709,
-0.0255130902,
0.0534990281,
0.0605121814,
-0.0489786789,
0.004442242,
-0.0023329034,
-0.0187644549,
-0.0196538325,
0.016873721,
-0.0372112542,
0.0266582612,
0.0125185391,
-0.0358052403,
-0.0285583399,
-0.0184035506,
0.0241278596,
0.0157430284,
0.0399526656,
-0.0357232913,
0.0050895526,
-0.0497696139,
-0.0431069061,
-0.0059882035,
-0.0412625745,
-0.0255417898,
0.0273653977,
0.0506989807,
-0.0009701622,
-0.0065280953,
0.0216031838,
-0.0392376631,
0.0577344783,
-0.0015119364,
0.0020198671,
0.0166973472,
0.0619922355,
0.0256228782,
-0.0091148242,
0.0022962075,
0.0502824672,
-0.000245858,
0.0265963413,
-0.0085226828,
0.0303270798,
0.0110407993,
-0.0181044396,
0.0573907457,
0.0047059604,
-0.0331275128,
0.0014779004,
-0.0452934504,
-0.0262719095,
0.0733651221,
-0.0149551928,
0.0635586604,
-0.0172218587,
-0.022387797,
-0.0349581502,
0.0171785355,
0.008182914,
-0.0398851894,
-0.015143373,
-0.0013339982,
-0.0538185462,
0.0175332073,
0.0904300362,
0.0418125577,
0.0633571669,
0.0356171802,
-0.052864179,
-0.0344535112,
-0.0282720886,
0.0354164839,
-0.0008531741,
-0.0205427129,
0.0161677636,
-0.0627442896,
-0.0608116426,
0.0114261135,
-0.0152074229,
0.0013267638,
-0.0033522779,
-0.0138479555,
0.0892947614,
-0.0004990892,
0.0320967957,
-0.0705893412,
0.0248902477,
-0.0331973359,
-0.0232859477,
-0.0035005074,
-5.503864017e-33,
-0.0025004726,
-0.0857848674,
-0.0200592242,
-0.0131702591,
0.0151400827,
0.0111555429,
-0.0008064263,
-0.0381609313,
-0.0148359938,
0.0155978575,
0.0095116841,
0.0090967258,
0.0015116108,
0.036207065,
-0.0017593318,
0.0004846774,
0.0534260757,
-0.0132190287,
-0.0402782597,
0.0274234861,
0.0635760948,
0.0173761919,
0.0320186578,
-0.0590420477,
0.0423898622,
-0.0390935726,
-0.0509060808,
0.0161562208,
-0.0344861858,
0.0749319717,
-0.0328872204,
0.0597463027,
0.0524642617,
0.0065091653,
0.0106502362,
0.0631161034,
-0.0150706619,
0.0200658236,
-0.0048492886,
0.0082118222,
-0.0078297704,
-0.0643779188,
0.0557642467,
-0.0304325968,
-0.0116452398,
0.0248405263,
0.065512985,
-0.0328923203,
-0.0029665781,
-0.0494371392,
-0.0474686883,
0.0278590545,
0.019433761,
0.0051721875,
-0.0135941049,
0.1007934436,
0.0130934259,
0.0475119017,
-0.0605286136,
0.0222604703,
-0.0101590874,
-0.0028769325,
0.0407835543,
0.0167388003,
-0.0097542154,
0.0528455861,
0.0096865064,
0.0119120274,
0.0023068183,
-0.0165432803,
-0.0038910839,
-0.0026704662,
0.038772665,
0.1207396016,
0.0181984715,
-0.0466960222,
-0.0542847775,
0.036664661,
-0.0061845058,
0.0126786185,
0.0414203629,
-0.0619355664,
-0.0331928618,
-0.0068781641,
-0.0111646522,
-0.0527594425,
-0.0394246019,
-0.0120367454,
0.0380638018,
0.0144177685,
-0.0268928371,
0.013903005,
0.0128533514,
-0.0541915409,
-0.0082063125,
0.0390555598,
-0.0410631932,
-0.0214574337,
0.0294163991,
0.0508147292,
-0.0288850944,
-0.0112555288,
0.007535222,
-0.0104679326,
0.0158101134,
-0.0133708389,
0.051242549,
0.001545205,
-0.0521812327,
0.0248783194,
-0.0299780164,
0.0245581176,
-0.0138644269,
0.0400596634,
0.0220720656,
-0.0260393005,
-0.0061866445,
-0.0017459446,
0.0527277067,
0.0020241281,
-0.0440101586,
-0.037475083,
-0.0181927104,
0.034607131,
-0.0258770678,
-0.0072185057,
-0.0281891935,
0.0437760688,
0.0701801777,
-0.0585182868,
0.0286272503,
-0.0536114946,
2.371e-7,
0.0354196094,
0.0284696259,
-0.0092498036,
0.0030130064,
0.0044155577,
0.0563632287,
-0.0079319356,
0.0513571948,
-0.0378178619,
0.0167357288,
-0.0284800529,
-0.0224959422,
0.0663344413,
0.0114060221,
-0.1006564647,
0.0123893684,
-0.0523457043,
0.011597652,
-0.0735503659,
-0.0078553837,
0.0655498952,
0.0580869913,
0.0102090267,
-0.0543418862,
-0.0114258463,
-0.0831007883,
0.0599952899,
-0.0086499508,
-0.0126555422,
0.0146971373,
0.038368348,
0.0364061333,
0.0104175759,
0.0094522275,
-0.026633393,
0.0128862029,
0.0283062477,
0.0780563205,
0.0589880869,
0.0157455448,
-0.0142113203,
-0.0437308997,
0.0005326585,
-0.0452760272,
0.0594870783,
0.0099769142,
0.0131829437,
-0.0427944511,
-0.0168557744,
-0.0700903311,
0.0200478509,
-0.0435614362,
-0.0293956678,
0.016908776,
0.0072356579,
0.0093546947,
-0.0181322992,
-0.040475294,
0.0055283993,
-0.029065907,
-0.0601314642,
-0.0121546602,
-0.0437643528,
0.0017124178,
0.0329759531,
-0.0581401438,
0.0439052396,
2.129273018e-34,
0.0287404098,
-0.0279504508,
-0.0145810256,
0.0174203888,
0.031939473,
0.0115331765,
-0.0318544582,
-0.0086826487,
-0.0200182702,
-0.0234669689,
0.0293561146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14901v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14901v3 | Chain-of-Questions Training with Latent Answers for Robust Multistep Question Answering | 2023-05-24T08:55:08 | 2023-12-23T06:05:26 | Wang Zhu, Jesse Thomason, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We train a language model (LM) to robustly answer multistep questions by
generating and answering sub-questions. We propose Chain-of-Questions, a
framework that trains a model to generate sub-questions and sub-answers one at
a time by leveraging human annotated question decomposition meaning
representation (QDMR). The key technical challenge is that QDMR only contains
sub-questions but not answers to those sub-questions, so we treat sub-answers
as latent variables and optimize them using a novel dynamic mixture of Hard-EM
and MAPO. Chain-of-Questions greatly outperforms strong neuro-symbolic methods
by 9.0 F1 on DROP contrast set, and outperforms GPT-3.5 by 24.3 F1 on HOTPOTQA
adversarial set, thus demonstrating the effectiveness and robustness of our
framework. | [
0.0332492217,
0.0579915382,
-0.0119631374,
0.0305538271,
-0.0109150382,
0.0390742682,
-0.0081740562,
-0.0083742086,
0.0056349477,
-0.0465606041,
0.0165730622,
-0.0392879546,
-0.0404828377,
0.0307923481,
0.045408003,
-0.0588010773,
0.0558926091,
-0.0356460139,
-0.0303020291,
-0.015440722,
0.015768839,
0.0164861605,
-0.0142039442,
0.0169865023,
-0.0091294646,
-0.0441993289,
-0.0499156862,
-0.0154363606,
0.023397781,
-0.003501991,
0.0270153098,
0.0585654005,
0.0509675816,
0.0385056511,
0.0000018544,
-0.0025303187,
-0.0141002303,
0.0008224022,
-0.0162644815,
-0.0016350421,
-0.0151539305,
-0.0071240328,
0.0481633395,
0.0343917571,
-0.0453988463,
-0.0304908808,
0.0066186772,
0.032364767,
0.0935066044,
0.0476746298,
0.0159014259,
-0.0238851886,
0.0265037343,
-0.0196064804,
0.0087216496,
-0.0541915856,
0.0020151152,
0.0026462078,
-0.0090284618,
0.0239021257,
-0.0123919649,
0.0303468555,
0.0553082004,
0.0236868542,
-0.0499111898,
0.0308978967,
-0.0102904895,
0.0224298071,
-0.0041335733,
0.1000470221,
-0.0168760698,
0.0072498503,
-0.0156546943,
-0.0173268281,
0.0177799277,
0.0025792804,
-0.0573419929,
0.010116064,
-0.0045038657,
-0.0066535338,
-0.0167209655,
0.0024621133,
0.0004733877,
0.0054431972,
-0.0202800371,
0.0302128419,
0.0330990106,
-0.0354113467,
0.0021812392,
-0.0176743101,
-0.0706029683,
-0.0504485741,
-0.0034023817,
0.0615025312,
-0.0139951212,
0.0239728019,
-0.027453823,
-0.0455334,
0.0279204361,
-0.049661722,
-0.0114071127,
0.0422558375,
-0.0008132098,
0.0379893407,
0.0005818566,
0.0310164671,
-0.0359550752,
-0.0031625896,
-0.0641674697,
-0.0455973968,
-0.0232331362,
-0.0315003432,
-0.0537499823,
0.0659437552,
-0.044513166,
0.0008742384,
-0.0232336763,
0.0415772162,
0.0086696018,
-0.020836398,
-0.007943009,
0.054515671,
-0.0242758915,
0.0010853081,
-0.0202018581,
0.0383218303,
-0.1159856394,
0.034402445,
0.0249391794,
-0.0125053655,
-0.0437496342,
0.0194740538,
0.0108473813,
-0.0423080288,
0.0122380182,
0.0597987399,
-0.0256968793,
-0.0247478485,
-0.0404842161,
-0.0453966223,
-0.008967326,
-0.0516816229,
0.0108882915,
-0.0676132515,
0.0544948354,
-0.0109747918,
-0.0270472355,
-0.0041275872,
0.0023702173,
0.0443077758,
-0.0003295961,
0.043922402,
0.0250136796,
-0.0417323261,
0.019918384,
0.0230551921,
-0.0056428867,
0.0778807923,
0.0324941352,
0.0272324719,
0.0318999961,
0.0152952252,
-0.0146015733,
0.0220632385,
0.0420885533,
0.0279343333,
0.0026930952,
0.0572097115,
0.0018479204,
0.0202385951,
0.0278521907,
0.0610260516,
-0.0340830199,
-0.0654855743,
0.0229489747,
0.0243588723,
-0.0203981288,
0.0368564278,
0.0480194576,
-0.0034106642,
0.0223940872,
0.0334091596,
-0.0317599364,
0.040476691,
-0.035327211,
0.0039851065,
0.0207124259,
0.0368761197,
-0.0569217019,
-0.0187832285,
0.0125813661,
0.0142879346,
0.0104434509,
0.0338595286,
0.0095964046,
0.0141992327,
-0.0243451633,
0.0517727435,
0.0025181829,
0.0027465057,
0.013130581,
-0.0509026758,
0.0389550701,
-0.0206884667,
0.02343156,
-0.02090865,
-0.0316380486,
-0.0427288823,
0.0370507948,
0.0373783633,
-0.0135297645,
-0.035105262,
0.0408846885,
-0.02324499,
-0.0224462636,
-0.0491799898,
-0.000500746,
0.0192484427,
0.0234879535,
0.0133997928,
0.0178613141,
-0.059011545,
0.0633410141,
0.0323677994,
-0.0211668983,
-0.0467231683,
0.0263319369,
-0.0048353681,
0.0249699205,
0.0233762152,
0.0183345806,
0.0127676027,
0.0303566605,
-0.0421722159,
-0.0437493175,
-0.0088493144,
-0.0405820645,
-0.0802216232,
0.0261684787,
-0.0036400768,
-0.0353151821,
0.0663169473,
-0.0701712221,
-0.0295853317,
-0.0105374036,
-0.0507140048,
-0.0110784415,
-0.0706755295,
-0.0500818416,
0.0376265123,
0.0195727982,
-0.0479424447,
0.0708391219,
-0.056302648,
-0.0126586286,
0.0169992149,
0.0118782558,
0.0348412208,
-0.0176689345,
-0.0159018319,
0.0152306529,
-0.0023722961,
0.0244608745,
0.0086542498,
0.0150856171,
-0.0609916635,
-0.0295572262,
-0.0430547968,
0.0286268108,
-0.044361826,
0.022466464,
0.0509467386,
0.0308282766,
0.0144512644,
-0.0165920779,
-0.068709366,
0.0197544564,
0.0175253246,
0.0303469729,
0.0390897989,
0.0183356833,
0.0264148023,
-0.0175521187,
-0.0304515287,
-0.0316226035,
0.0612886623,
-0.0355988741,
0.0434493199,
-0.0254466552,
-0.0344019048,
-0.0555766448,
0.051772099,
-0.0105797071,
-0.0332269147,
0.0102438889,
-0.0272027738,
0.0147612989,
0.0448500663,
0.0085105756,
0.0192965716,
0.030607935,
0.0183155052,
-0.0436211564,
0.0472447053,
-0.0303568095,
-0.0015658039,
0.0123607758,
-0.0199841931,
-0.0044688624,
0.0572575368,
0.0340218171,
-0.0189190432,
-0.0597521327,
0.0070049157,
0.021452032,
-0.0334830396,
-0.0407750234,
0.0389428698,
-0.0260630343,
0.0119734285,
-0.018206181,
-0.0130677009,
0.1125491709,
0.0045387303,
-0.009260606,
-0.0660958216,
-0.0330513753,
-0.0487144813,
0.0576323606,
-0.0202694461,
0.0117221167,
0.0050954623,
-0.0077106901,
-0.0850933492,
-0.0390204862,
-0.0123607442,
-0.0202016737,
0.0193582997,
-0.0135438414,
-0.0076290234,
-0.0131027484,
-0.0330503099,
-0.056164287,
-0.037676435,
0.0037025393,
0.0419529341,
-0.0268956851,
0.0113585703,
-0.0025466394,
-0.0071784118,
0.0263407119,
0.0286408272,
-0.0353120714,
0.0019041378,
-0.0254520867,
0.1023702994,
0.1010267437,
0.0393257551,
0.0317956395,
-0.0255336836,
0.0581710413,
0.0799833834,
0.0491940081,
0.0168311223,
0.0085666096,
0.0399080105,
0.0053295144,
-0.018320499,
-0.0021136238,
0.0266554728,
0.02189634,
-0.043947991,
-0.0251035206,
0.0848153681,
0.0381479003,
-0.0292049367,
0.0135306055,
-0.0379696079,
0.0618521906,
0.0178423766,
0.0521688759,
-0.1050796434,
-0.0312176831,
-0.0422004722,
0.0276028123,
0.0283071212,
-0.0276630018,
-0.0050560674,
-0.0721696839,
-0.0009922388,
-0.0112332776,
-0.0790149868,
0.0115795536,
-0.0319585167,
0.0032986091,
0.0272825118,
0.0215245988,
0.0177008267,
-0.0082709324,
0.0087053347,
0.0185183622,
0.0116334232,
-0.0209961981,
0.0478857607,
-0.0318705328,
-0.0166154969,
0.0431571193,
0.0163744483,
-0.0137945274,
-0.003093441,
0.0354253091,
-0.0600294396,
-0.0313891843,
-0.0058251107,
0.0152831273,
-0.0346462764,
-0.0030873821,
-0.0214039423,
0.064059265,
-0.0174355283,
-0.0004678942,
0.0201761648,
0.0846283808,
-0.0148195252,
-0.006891984,
-0.0466578417,
-0.0001878755,
-0.0029095856,
0.0521187223,
0.0462344997,
-0.037847966,
-0.0482802205,
-0.0374047644,
-0.0069212127,
-0.0166368484,
0.0051445146,
0.00855364,
0.0378848761,
0.0654200464,
-0.0816237554,
-0.0924421027,
0.0470647961,
0.0296773426,
-0.0600982793,
0.0152899828,
-0.0157136749,
0.0171045698,
-0.0272165462,
0.0133193713,
0.0003452114,
0.0014746978,
-0.0252372548,
0.0087873125,
0.0151275359,
-0.0354902558,
-0.0294511169,
0.0164052658,
-0.1037165299,
-0.0469706319,
-0.0138018038,
0.0555225313,
0.0152344825,
0.0289000887,
-0.0163047016,
-0.0640217289,
0.0243881475,
0.0005393716,
0.0082999263,
0.0008923954,
0.0285615139,
0.0202219803,
0.0048426669,
0.0432654545,
-0.0637906268,
-0.008372114,
-0.007075096,
0.0834137127,
-0.022014359,
-0.0056988094,
0.0348737389,
-0.0135992924,
0.0004482487,
-0.0029378729,
-0.0110152466,
-0.0193617977,
0.0276855659,
-0.035799101,
0.0017978551,
-0.0626263246,
0.0306444392,
0.0127889365,
-0.041547209,
-0.0118938349,
-0.0162800942,
-0.0023760828,
0.0500742532,
-0.0212940406,
-0.0182384104,
0.0357229002,
-0.0171085969,
-0.0023401256,
0.0020152337,
-0.0314716958,
0.0086964574,
-0.004454555,
0.0446590111,
-0.016111305,
0.0684557855,
0.0335314386,
-0.019569464,
-0.0364751108,
0.0110692857,
-0.0875288993,
-0.0400565267,
-0.0337241106,
0.0132592069,
0.0377261974,
0.0262389798,
-0.0020214918,
0.0044446965,
-0.0248928107,
0.0034219653,
0.0135263279,
-0.000878356,
-0.0024027578,
0.069700405,
0.0414090864,
-0.0028130268,
0.0191766862,
0.0592270792,
0.0417563058,
0.0520572625,
0.0195750222,
0.0177659113,
-0.0303402413,
-0.0210855026,
-0.0102074416,
0.0310538132,
-0.021683827,
0.0331540443,
-0.0458754413,
-0.0693422332,
-0.0159182716,
0.0161923207,
-0.0188797619,
-0.0089205792,
0.0531356521,
0.0405084342,
0.025714457,
-0.0582560487,
-0.0335838348,
0.0169757232,
-0.0075152195,
-0.0512125976,
-0.0058877878,
-6.167052583e-33,
-0.0162587762,
-0.0084779654,
0.0323589072,
-0.0457903855,
-0.013293026,
-0.0054974076,
-0.0353647359,
0.0107523175,
-0.0577905588,
-0.0090997936,
-0.0225167125,
0.0123682218,
-0.0141081912,
0.0550013743,
-0.0220268555,
-0.0374796726,
0.0320751332,
-0.0417292267,
-0.0207366329,
0.0117734643,
0.0221456345,
0.0171928834,
0.0247845929,
0.0122621637,
0.010914389,
-0.0295962263,
-0.003069554,
0.0504959077,
-0.0304040667,
0.0517312996,
-0.045642294,
0.0227735825,
0.0309107415,
-0.0097584566,
-0.0007302739,
0.0150490375,
-0.1185798123,
-0.0526242033,
0.0036338661,
-0.0286332201,
-0.080160141,
-0.0114202844,
0.0147217661,
-0.0177869089,
0.0762711763,
-0.0531775244,
-0.0049203797,
-0.0031690651,
-0.0362099409,
-0.0452302881,
0.0005616972,
-0.0012155477,
-0.0052263811,
-0.0032168077,
-0.0334864743,
0.0632226169,
0.0133636771,
0.021354042,
-0.0165176056,
-0.0478533767,
0.011486995,
-0.0057268348,
0.0195152611,
-0.0004339311,
-0.0023101964,
0.0260284301,
0.0156574026,
-0.0062860907,
-0.03203924,
0.0039996617,
0.011473489,
0.0090230256,
0.0879731998,
0.0664268881,
0.0241076108,
0.0579634383,
-0.0981673673,
0.0396682546,
0.0399023965,
0.0433654189,
-0.0383024402,
0.0010128232,
-0.008806047,
-0.007677726,
-0.0516335629,
0.0197774507,
-0.0270787645,
-0.0432487354,
0.0397512168,
-0.0032059201,
-0.0239261091,
-0.0255307388,
0.0599728152,
-0.0399825945,
0.0222007129,
0.0272741746,
-0.0079196924,
0.0094692912,
0.0345383622,
0.0766472965,
-0.0176957548,
0.0440870896,
0.0301403161,
-0.0191129185,
-0.0102892434,
0.0158455614,
-0.0039787381,
0.0128051452,
-0.0421602912,
0.0064444235,
-0.0255358461,
0.0276279803,
-0.0112200985,
0.0200529657,
0.0065294569,
-0.0043309219,
0.0104062213,
0.031831719,
-0.0169339553,
-0.0059784725,
-0.0185272228,
0.0086666895,
0.0170409176,
0.0434959009,
-0.0244683102,
0.017966453,
-0.0385809578,
0.0086945808,
0.0152993873,
-0.0877032802,
0.0017660427,
0.048845388,
2.438e-7,
0.0377633087,
0.0081813736,
0.0310595576,
0.0532437973,
0.0001943752,
0.0252225604,
-0.0010638483,
0.0298350193,
0.0107006356,
-0.0159659833,
0.0119074574,
0.0265710317,
0.0277415961,
0.0553582981,
-0.0701550543,
0.0155630456,
-0.079362601,
-0.0121105313,
-0.0407204553,
-0.0350687094,
0.0646085069,
0.1046652272,
0.013978445,
0.0049723587,
-0.0145703051,
-0.0116076879,
0.0644917488,
0.0371235609,
0.0012075533,
-0.019158829,
0.0124238022,
-0.0027524671,
0.0368925966,
0.0057033347,
-0.0166632477,
0.0335125923,
0.0203820914,
0.0850283056,
0.0101960124,
-0.0816894397,
-0.0146596301,
-0.0389564522,
0.0205755476,
-0.0776550323,
0.1039527208,
-0.0599156134,
-0.0147237917,
-0.0066816127,
-0.0484298021,
-0.0181731787,
0.0354853496,
-0.0326994099,
-0.0061956113,
0.0101047885,
0.0067745051,
-0.0077238493,
0.032815773,
-0.086218141,
-0.0228569489,
0.0035055038,
-0.0482672155,
-0.0015978378,
-0.0096600382,
-0.0033311374,
0.0365716964,
-0.0460305698,
-0.0306673255,
2.213513719e-34,
0.0532942005,
-0.0187559444,
0.0113894641,
0.056282986,
0.0156624541,
-0.017655896,
-0.0338791497,
-0.0218099505,
0.0519605614,
-0.0890446529,
-0.0464073867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14898v1 | PIVOINE: Instruction Tuning for Open-world Information Extraction | 2023-05-24T08:52:08 | 2023-05-24T08:52:08 | Keming Lu, Xiaoman Pan, Kaiqiang Song, Hongming Zhang, Dong Yu, Jianshu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We consider the problem of Open-world Information Extraction (Open-world IE),
which extracts comprehensive entity profiles from unstructured texts. Different
from the conventional closed-world setting of Information Extraction (IE),
Open-world IE considers a more general situation where entities and relations
could be beyond a predefined ontology. More importantly, we seek to develop a
large language model (LLM) that is able to perform Open-world IE to extract
desirable entity profiles characterized by (possibly fine-grained) natural
language instructions. We achieve this by finetuning LLMs using instruction
tuning. In particular, we construct INSTRUCTOPENWIKI, a substantial instruction
tuning dataset for Open-world IE enriched with a comprehensive corpus,
extensive annotations, and diverse instructions. We finetune the pretrained
BLOOM models on INSTRUCTOPENWIKI and obtain PIVOINE, an LLM for Open-world IE
with strong instruction-following capabilities. Our experiments demonstrate
that PIVOINE significantly outperforms traditional closed-world methods and
other LLM baselines, displaying impressive generalization capabilities on both
unseen instructions and out-of-ontology cases. Consequently, PIVOINE emerges as
a promising solution to tackle the open-world challenge in IE effectively. | [
0.0413296632,
0.0577286854,
0.0304457322,
0.0544638857,
-0.0433691964,
0.0441330858,
-0.0233257059,
0.0170896836,
0.0468929633,
-0.0595145226,
-0.0136400014,
0.0001664685,
-0.0510674119,
0.0427746177,
-0.0179288462,
0.0118149677,
0.0394692682,
-0.0290399734,
-0.0331200361,
0.0403800122,
-0.0328290723,
0.0287699811,
-0.006229599,
-0.0013366087,
0.0610574,
0.0009961415,
-0.0206315033,
0.0192290377,
0.0403053761,
-0.0002304152,
0.0147595033,
0.0222196132,
-0.0177851301,
-0.0340305082,
0.0000020296,
-0.0476077013,
-0.0505336225,
0.0244447887,
-0.0187104791,
0.0121150268,
-0.0018944696,
-0.0104110818,
-0.0120959878,
-0.0095141623,
-0.0181979705,
-0.0279015284,
0.019161284,
0.0751766711,
0.0144365318,
0.082897529,
0.0035338271,
-0.0716109648,
0.0590703413,
0.0173660889,
0.0258258022,
0.0012599773,
0.0481015779,
-0.0772615746,
-0.0032537677,
0.0192503277,
0.0013714079,
-0.0095968805,
-0.021590488,
0.0106624719,
0.0169475228,
0.0278994441,
-0.0055476674,
-0.0139157884,
0.0081546009,
0.1144209355,
0.0332056247,
0.0351411961,
0.0402387045,
-0.0029037397,
-0.0225956589,
-0.0189401098,
0.0083337966,
0.0403880849,
-0.0272582546,
0.0217764266,
0.0222713258,
0.0019420815,
0.0101718288,
-0.0005894466,
-0.0293767806,
0.0674197897,
0.009793262,
-0.0149772614,
0.0443069674,
0.0212543309,
-0.0006662387,
-0.0334217548,
0.0000107385,
0.0351486504,
0.0140753854,
0.0395939276,
-0.013606702,
0.011486466,
-0.0002085386,
-0.0287871845,
0.0150130084,
0.0354933143,
-0.038386073,
0.0558839701,
-0.0149425957,
-0.0225224476,
-0.0127352122,
-0.0003882258,
0.0156430267,
-0.0115652736,
-0.0751673281,
0.0446406268,
-0.0294112358,
0.048740644,
-0.0650424957,
0.0123174116,
-0.0065255403,
0.0185954496,
0.0137379635,
0.0181899276,
0.0324751362,
-0.0230054986,
-0.0170984939,
0.0173335895,
-0.0231369548,
-0.0008812779,
-0.0341100916,
-0.0281896051,
-0.0232893433,
-0.064930588,
-0.0134935379,
-0.0043777931,
0.0535077117,
-0.0480393805,
0.0232756343,
0.0617273077,
0.0332084335,
-0.0567648374,
-0.0741565973,
-0.0436952263,
0.0422864556,
-0.0385608189,
0.0007372966,
-0.0475051403,
0.0465991981,
0.009972956,
-0.0066174176,
-0.050712347,
0.0396962613,
0.0077566947,
-0.0787964389,
0.0295603033,
-0.0180024821,
-0.0225009713,
-0.002004155,
0.0168354362,
0.0439654104,
0.0599377975,
0.0312837735,
-0.0368388891,
0.0770552829,
0.0119632436,
-0.0207178202,
0.0527048185,
0.0025451425,
-0.0057001123,
0.0594335161,
0.0514951013,
0.0181815512,
-0.0007616773,
0.0381988287,
0.0260548871,
-0.0243025664,
-0.0007348903,
0.0011173537,
-0.0081780525,
0.0015921678,
0.0095307846,
0.0852987543,
0.0259702262,
0.0314409509,
0.0189679824,
-0.0297999308,
-0.0236269794,
-0.0122319646,
0.0338671356,
0.00839948,
0.0346738808,
0.0096979085,
-0.025929248,
-0.0111082802,
-0.0250910968,
-0.0096533075,
-0.019651575,
0.0710235462,
0.026050685,
-0.0680419877,
0.0771926343,
0.0816221163,
-0.0306627825,
0.0181928147,
-0.0019130564,
0.0015451007,
0.0201893728,
0.0666193441,
-0.0694203153,
0.0005266644,
-0.0304649919,
-0.0006013029,
0.0507561043,
0.0203718003,
-0.0459711924,
0.0335202143,
-0.0212566964,
-0.0404346511,
-0.008369972,
0.0034480719,
-0.0108436886,
0.0497428365,
-0.0139529724,
0.0033551608,
-0.0122469058,
-0.0664934441,
0.0574772693,
-0.0520266443,
-0.089542605,
-0.0072445828,
-0.0022595178,
-0.0105530154,
0.0432123989,
-0.0234362278,
-0.0124226538,
0.0515511893,
-0.019833684,
0.0002182683,
-0.0433641821,
0.0089714592,
0.0015024219,
0.031397894,
-0.0231413729,
-0.0085946163,
-0.0384985171,
-0.0371489115,
-0.0129296156,
-0.0207459517,
0.0409570932,
0.092383869,
-0.0065417117,
-0.0027155541,
0.0173658766,
-0.01065809,
-0.0334916189,
0.0756019875,
-0.0034306564,
-0.0001245174,
0.001979793,
-0.0574305765,
-0.0273841508,
-0.0133525832,
-0.0198881198,
0.0158771649,
-0.0016547719,
-0.0047986298,
-0.0049158693,
0.0120970439,
-0.0953629166,
-0.0326919854,
-0.0986012518,
0.0648559928,
-0.0101174992,
0.0521547534,
0.0075435634,
0.0315265022,
-0.0295047853,
-0.0098322015,
-0.007354042,
-0.0228487272,
-0.0466669872,
-0.0148159983,
0.0581637844,
0.0561408736,
0.0036484315,
-0.0101247542,
0.0005427112,
-0.0401304252,
0.0282293428,
0.0034207474,
0.0072615552,
-0.0440668836,
0.0170453787,
-0.0532045364,
0.0267432798,
0.0057785115,
0.0219188146,
-0.017037848,
-0.0155158658,
0.0058901622,
0.0559357442,
-0.0008575908,
0.0250374023,
-0.0021545743,
-0.0162796956,
-0.0255652871,
0.0298224445,
-0.0406072326,
-0.0036519079,
-0.0298943873,
-0.002694095,
0.03848508,
0.0631209239,
-0.0455580913,
-0.0243637599,
0.0007825568,
0.0087634521,
-0.0144504765,
0.0034833236,
-0.0197695084,
0.0425057895,
0.0113122985,
-0.0004767754,
-0.0059948652,
0.0023908033,
0.0479460135,
-0.0125694927,
0.0145084281,
-0.0382978059,
0.017529618,
-0.0680081695,
0.0319528319,
-0.0151698124,
0.0182867907,
0.0306661967,
-0.0158712603,
-0.0050841412,
0.0437123999,
0.0052272677,
-0.0220189039,
0.0343232527,
-0.0384872034,
-0.0095335823,
-0.0160711147,
-0.0245973691,
-0.0556777678,
-0.0154149318,
-0.0073677753,
0.0079574771,
0.0153673692,
-0.0287694316,
-0.0187830403,
-0.0166995265,
0.0050435723,
0.0144962836,
-0.0112875048,
-0.0222670678,
-0.0372631215,
0.0093557583,
0.0600614622,
-0.0317615159,
0.0056047169,
-0.0138682388,
-0.0027719999,
0.056353271,
-0.0176749527,
-0.0518819913,
0.0440780744,
0.0246953238,
0.0180652365,
-0.1008469537,
-0.0143490937,
0.0129034994,
0.0470964573,
-0.0417410731,
-0.0409102365,
0.1081838682,
0.0479153544,
-0.014863831,
0.0025981772,
0.0161091965,
0.0118797412,
0.0002609625,
0.0367408507,
-0.0731191114,
-0.0345042087,
-0.0323948599,
0.0307473484,
-0.0171245504,
-0.0922176167,
-0.0122504588,
-0.1123925671,
-0.0106557831,
-0.0106380517,
-0.0469102114,
-0.0098401718,
-0.0388470367,
0.0065732407,
-0.0485838316,
-0.0345399752,
0.0100151841,
-0.0500708893,
0.0162108671,
-0.0169160962,
0.0382903405,
-0.0346041732,
0.0338462219,
-0.0584397353,
0.0304122381,
0.0190770123,
0.0213154163,
0.0167692881,
-0.0044580298,
-0.0075403475,
-0.0401260331,
-0.0097989691,
-0.0189507585,
0.0822728202,
-0.0489708446,
-0.0003488497,
-0.0567465052,
0.0451112092,
-0.0539630353,
-0.0179350246,
0.0063022645,
0.0565783456,
0.0184877068,
0.0033077789,
0.0083946502,
-0.0473065972,
0.0345078707,
0.0713075548,
-0.0142197367,
-0.0567632727,
-0.0298690032,
-0.0214097016,
-0.0268440451,
-0.0644657612,
-0.0344262682,
0.0057143122,
-0.0598373599,
-0.0047824681,
-0.0610746406,
-0.0567868985,
0.0447733738,
0.0175057966,
0.0101974308,
-0.0323514529,
0.0398243554,
-0.0044286647,
-0.0602390952,
0.0492511727,
-0.0555638075,
-0.0235925447,
-0.0581831113,
-0.0403842628,
0.0294713583,
0.0010320722,
-0.0359585993,
0.0326103345,
-0.0152479038,
-0.0540357679,
0.0390319936,
0.0129645998,
0.0162612274,
0.042731896,
-0.0171180759,
-0.0156438481,
0.0022221096,
0.0259697642,
-0.0509071611,
0.0089624701,
0.047789149,
0.0090221427,
0.0078176539,
0.0532333478,
-0.0309272185,
0.0058607459,
0.0283678956,
0.033584442,
-0.0456612334,
-0.0492393039,
0.0222736206,
0.020933684,
0.044189658,
0.0116787311,
-0.0163984075,
-0.07540638,
0.0121389274,
-0.0127713578,
-0.0170001574,
-0.0213497914,
0.0271531139,
0.0341316871,
-0.0352807716,
-0.0193577297,
0.0604253635,
-0.0300243665,
0.0139764901,
-0.0417281911,
0.0028186315,
0.0301308576,
0.0164613388,
0.0173396189,
-0.0426549092,
-0.0368418209,
0.0281118285,
0.0204432979,
0.0673007444,
-0.0188918915,
0.0421325564,
0.0009555958,
0.0141229089,
0.0152472844,
0.0043556239,
-0.0243403241,
0.0704726726,
-0.0265192091,
0.0862196535,
0.0139433537,
-0.0254412368,
0.0610833988,
-0.0120159471,
-0.0201090947,
0.0082440628,
0.0103809992,
-0.0007685995,
0.0125976,
-0.0015359868,
0.0384070501,
-0.0523803905,
-0.0039905473,
0.0369555131,
0.0011271613,
0.074294135,
0.0064978162,
0.0255560465,
-0.0469288789,
0.0079900362,
0.0071012978,
0.0339444242,
-0.0249118675,
0.0060150018,
-0.0625720248,
-0.009731981,
0.0161572061,
-0.0000891165,
-0.0416700765,
0.0033857385,
0.0249962267,
-0.011940022,
0.027147511,
-0.0687121302,
-0.0819461942,
0.0056659975,
-0.0204246733,
-0.0237369351,
0.0400812998,
-6.594205925e-33,
-0.0708164051,
-0.0066305031,
0.014051009,
0.0240842961,
-0.0026965826,
0.0056622019,
-0.0103917457,
-0.0068765394,
-0.0267886482,
-0.0044642426,
-0.0218317229,
0.0112819504,
0.0258679092,
0.0136335492,
-0.0174977779,
-0.022171963,
-0.0074345544,
0.0218267944,
-0.0268475208,
0.0178580321,
0.074687846,
0.0382939428,
0.0613922775,
-0.0950081572,
0.0636638701,
-0.0587468147,
0.0142225372,
0.0222533699,
0.0503805131,
0.0586500652,
-0.0421356857,
0.0127536515,
-0.013165364,
-0.0196339022,
0.0253857579,
-0.0116904695,
-0.1415196359,
-0.0272115506,
-0.0106280958,
-0.0178010315,
-0.0214003827,
-0.0391175076,
0.0255384967,
-0.0043938118,
0.0336570069,
-0.0323138982,
0.0378926508,
-0.0106963459,
0.0369903557,
0.0160616096,
-0.0935533643,
0.0440337956,
0.0477351025,
0.0209483746,
-0.0117549682,
-0.012347728,
0.0381936133,
0.0069670421,
-0.0717777535,
-0.011392531,
0.0377594829,
-0.0160362832,
0.0298032332,
0.0130748963,
0.0098008467,
0.0540785417,
-0.0050140237,
-0.0048001325,
-0.0376633443,
0.0092267562,
0.0056256689,
0.0701696724,
-0.0456146114,
0.0447107218,
0.0029402201,
0.0004179399,
-0.0831562877,
0.0252050962,
0.0271357857,
0.0016072682,
-0.0498501658,
-0.0360945873,
-0.0510453172,
0.0119331433,
0.0053244866,
-0.0124823311,
-0.0103279166,
0.0064497399,
0.0060586887,
0.0084438669,
-0.084719263,
0.0325932987,
-0.0019892198,
-0.031753093,
-0.0041402718,
0.0027290441,
0.0170460902,
0.0122091267,
-0.0280045252,
-0.0149342297,
-0.067882508,
-0.0704782978,
0.0207571592,
-0.0612777621,
0.0342390351,
0.0317248441,
0.024959201,
0.0117371734,
-0.056010481,
-0.0158388652,
-0.0257256944,
0.0378310457,
-0.0192759708,
0.0365465544,
0.0160030127,
0.0171158947,
-0.005816835,
0.0440563895,
0.0786032751,
0.0071318331,
-0.0303881336,
-0.0177092161,
0.0515941679,
-0.0001987751,
0.0084183495,
-0.0027751788,
0.0237391554,
0.0229690056,
-0.0078680543,
-0.0592605509,
-0.0021582954,
0.0346191637,
2.798e-7,
0.0580779575,
0.0264205001,
0.0398595966,
0.0307193715,
-0.0174350087,
0.0287310053,
0.0457243286,
0.0406967439,
-0.0192108247,
-0.0472480655,
0.0060941768,
-0.0025702503,
-0.0045442074,
0.0186743233,
-0.0961868092,
-0.039905306,
0.0282153487,
-0.0243431311,
-0.0727377832,
-0.017092051,
0.029575089,
0.0511028133,
0.0313542411,
0.0168681461,
-0.0250144284,
-0.0235238634,
0.0504653417,
-0.0015216153,
-0.006077358,
0.0687450916,
0.0178673547,
0.0452343039,
-0.0092334757,
0.0249245111,
-0.0266606044,
0.0577020273,
0.0132258246,
0.0908827037,
-0.0021963087,
-0.0162419453,
0.0135497153,
-0.0699247122,
0.005608628,
-0.0357486084,
0.0982753634,
-0.0036084903,
-0.0084358202,
0.0066888221,
-0.0011552847,
-0.0205165856,
-0.0213613287,
-0.0277563203,
-0.0146635165,
0.0404240862,
0.0128223076,
-0.0261188298,
-0.0267487876,
-0.078907676,
0.0090250084,
0.0167906806,
0.032760825,
-0.0328602158,
0.0129432371,
-0.0000877997,
0.0038544864,
-0.0723012909,
0.0105525972,
2.725665587e-34,
-0.0259453133,
0.0328358859,
-0.0153678162,
0.0250805039,
0.0325008854,
-0.0067365579,
-0.0510873385,
-0.0070343097,
-0.0254016388,
-0.0592136793,
0.0066144755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14897v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14897v2 | Text encoders bottleneck compositionality in contrastive vision-language models | 2023-05-24T08:48:44 | 2023-10-30T17:57:47 | Amita Kamath, Jack Hessel, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Performant vision-language (VL) models like CLIP represent captions using a
single vector. How much information about language is lost in this bottleneck?
We first curate CompPrompts, a set of increasingly compositional image captions
that VL models should be able to capture (e.g., single object, to
object+property, to multiple interacting objects). Then, we train text-only
recovery probes that aim to reconstruct captions from single-vector text
representations produced by several VL models. This approach does not require
images, allowing us to test on a broader range of scenes compared to prior
work. We find that: 1) CLIP's text encoder falls short on more compositional
inputs, including object relationships, attribute-object association, counting,
and negations; 2) some text encoders work significantly better than others; and
3) text-only recovery performance predicts multi-modal matching performance on
ControlledImCaps: a new evaluation benchmark we collect and release consisting
of fine-grained compositional images and captions. Specifically, our results
suggest text-only recoverability is a necessary (but not sufficient) condition
for modeling compositional factors in contrastive VL models. We release our
datasets and code. | [
0.0084001599,
0.0875545591,
0.0124401813,
0.0812228099,
-0.0461604483,
0.0048154281,
0.0024035657,
0.0296294522,
-0.0560489409,
-0.0645914748,
-0.0189203992,
-0.0434899367,
0.0444306135,
0.0744145662,
-0.0000292886,
-0.0769228339,
-0.0225101635,
-0.0245607588,
-0.0342276655,
0.0033734711,
0.0323086828,
0.0100117456,
-0.0057783662,
0.0322479755,
-0.0059919744,
0.0040580244,
-0.0147899752,
0.0167357158,
0.0119054606,
-0.0020696095,
-0.0011182022,
0.055834312,
0.0388045274,
-0.0175664723,
0.0000018151,
-0.0112094292,
0.0060043493,
0.0120483851,
0.0366867855,
-0.0215781033,
0.0885069445,
-0.0911431164,
0.0126843676,
0.0075433776,
0.0124080395,
-0.004086785,
0.0732691959,
0.0433832444,
0.0242281202,
0.0543504991,
-0.0409409665,
-0.0531006753,
0.0072559528,
-0.0324106328,
0.0055588023,
-0.0026528684,
0.0240066946,
0.0103842886,
-0.0163862519,
0.015716793,
-0.0532566197,
0.0679046661,
0.0295132436,
0.0093116779,
-0.013876914,
0.0504735895,
-0.0087723378,
-0.0412625261,
-0.0027507781,
0.0721403286,
-0.0075264224,
0.0243788511,
-0.0308435764,
-0.0138256457,
-0.0040193223,
-0.0205780417,
-0.0261997338,
0.0322049782,
0.0099245301,
0.0176502094,
-0.0502335988,
0.0260368288,
-0.0083540212,
-0.0234172791,
0.0037915192,
-0.064204447,
0.0395070538,
0.0316894986,
-0.0240659826,
0.0237660687,
-0.014000508,
-0.0254009888,
0.0065086731,
-0.0149203371,
0.0172259454,
-0.0086492477,
-0.0563266873,
-0.0456013791,
-0.0170382988,
-0.0099328263,
0.0294564087,
0.0185496677,
-0.0639774129,
0.0717568249,
-0.017432183,
0.0587564632,
-0.0025005001,
0.0394831225,
-0.0402081683,
-0.0538731329,
-0.0220814515,
-0.0079322988,
-0.0068893163,
0.022008352,
-0.0458421595,
-0.0362113342,
0.0030550542,
-0.0229690578,
-0.0085948678,
0.019606676,
-0.0277332719,
0.019270191,
-0.0196622051,
-0.0273567308,
-0.0027712665,
0.0443254337,
0.0308488961,
0.0142535856,
-0.0077018859,
-0.0632494092,
-0.0328510478,
0.0347543471,
0.0480220355,
-0.0281950757,
0.0067716972,
0.051740814,
-0.0779517367,
-0.0706982464,
0.0087590544,
-0.0257448852,
-0.0611842684,
-0.0453376137,
0.0243750121,
-0.0675323308,
0.0440368392,
0.0105924001,
0.0020051983,
-0.0797012374,
0.0194949564,
0.0074904212,
-0.0224352237,
0.1151849851,
0.00991078,
-0.029859677,
-0.0411199592,
0.0160510354,
-0.0163751785,
0.0569604747,
0.0087599838,
0.0479819812,
-0.0140142413,
0.0065072007,
0.0401421674,
0.0414913632,
0.0235131029,
0.0175830014,
-0.0841072947,
-0.0143427532,
0.0185938552,
-0.0095724408,
0.0477679409,
0.0785313845,
-0.0276281219,
-0.0201715715,
0.081604518,
0.0339124314,
-0.0335133113,
0.0151082966,
0.0112416996,
0.0246314593,
-0.0102628423,
0.0008019037,
-0.0281896815,
0.0618603863,
-0.0074494481,
0.0044508013,
0.0188689027,
0.0185486302,
-0.0471848808,
-0.0151921241,
-0.0049611349,
-0.0268765353,
0.015767023,
-0.0191968307,
0.0764354095,
0.0154865738,
-0.0579230711,
0.0090917889,
0.0074001625,
-0.0485556535,
-0.0144373095,
-0.0336687043,
-0.0198366251,
0.0397231691,
0.0443656705,
0.0097191725,
-0.0052583446,
0.0100235706,
-0.0009898313,
0.0751428455,
0.0030636075,
0.0201828051,
0.0735907108,
-0.038108319,
-0.0451143794,
-0.0310812797,
-0.0001567819,
0.0270841233,
-0.0068762098,
0.0000306623,
0.0198360458,
0.0180869736,
-0.0214171223,
0.0430018939,
0.0537610725,
0.0038834729,
-0.0196564775,
0.0130201718,
0.0069828443,
0.0004974813,
-0.0379990265,
0.0000870202,
0.0119977826,
-0.048662249,
-0.0251191258,
0.0417810716,
-0.0424361974,
-0.0932345688,
0.015394113,
-0.0890541896,
-0.0161846895,
0.0239861868,
-0.0180699676,
-0.0489319488,
0.0267723575,
-0.0669568777,
-0.0027231965,
-0.0303479694,
-0.0124330902,
-0.0079157203,
0.0126009583,
0.02687498,
0.0382088944,
-0.0306954607,
-0.0217278246,
0.0225734096,
-0.0061223237,
0.0069560464,
-0.0106685385,
-0.0375349075,
-0.0172018148,
-0.0119530307,
0.0358666852,
0.036870949,
0.0172356032,
-0.015719587,
-0.0405547284,
-0.0466072746,
-0.0390784405,
-0.0411126092,
-0.0400065929,
-0.0073851785,
-0.0020737981,
0.0281536132,
-0.0337228253,
-0.0234158449,
-0.0131027866,
0.0131553086,
0.0313327163,
0.0145203285,
0.0217718575,
-0.0120701659,
-0.0320243202,
-0.0026336869,
0.039179232,
0.061461553,
-0.0118232435,
-0.0382288508,
-0.0157556552,
0.0495113097,
0.0169845745,
0.0066057374,
-0.0344093367,
-0.0325160883,
-0.0051348992,
-0.0205430612,
0.0051327175,
0.0603091568,
-0.0118572246,
0.0307339579,
0.0196359977,
-0.0122616617,
-0.053718254,
-0.0067913961,
-0.0107894558,
-0.0602269694,
0.0039507677,
-0.0168905482,
-0.0210877731,
0.0539070219,
-0.0380148403,
0.0563736968,
-0.0754327402,
0.0296972599,
0.0129335485,
-0.0401099361,
-0.0559168234,
0.0211199131,
0.0050639044,
0.0163893066,
-0.0430540033,
-0.0413013697,
0.0253488515,
-0.0503212921,
-0.0444993228,
0.0082162907,
0.0122735603,
-0.0150845312,
0.0855204836,
0.0318911299,
0.024940148,
0.020518152,
-0.02071427,
-0.033534646,
0.0037829645,
0.0001338521,
-0.0153474966,
0.0478420407,
-0.0337809213,
0.0219799075,
-0.0445427857,
-0.0740106627,
-0.0158856381,
-0.0082614208,
-0.0256308224,
0.0201734863,
-0.007375997,
-0.021048123,
-0.0831994265,
0.0184271969,
0.0297018681,
0.0362383015,
-0.0085137766,
0.0034191846,
-0.0256225504,
0.0326022767,
0.0623153895,
0.0130320331,
-0.0337058827,
-0.0729894266,
0.000152462,
0.0547739491,
-0.0033872037,
0.002649741,
-0.0380902365,
0.0168762766,
0.0226418693,
0.0703707859,
0.0151918205,
0.0215242673,
0.0532731302,
-0.0489386581,
-0.0313726105,
0.0605373271,
-0.0080570485,
-0.0768205374,
-0.0549224466,
0.0229016505,
0.0259504486,
0.0252415556,
-0.0101134861,
-0.0688906386,
-0.0643133819,
-0.0040138089,
-0.0138486251,
0.0328586139,
0.0229535978,
-0.0630818531,
-0.0944915488,
0.0278699826,
0.0064103655,
-0.0434312597,
-0.0946030766,
-0.0028253,
-0.0017213516,
-0.0262788907,
-0.0010455158,
-0.0035491853,
0.002674412,
-0.0036973523,
-0.0031515686,
0.0328107662,
-0.0460719764,
0.0048727654,
-0.0253371913,
0.0002311732,
0.0444930978,
0.0124738794,
-0.0114331599,
-0.0338764675,
0.0049287728,
-0.0248513762,
0.0047819647,
0.0193519145,
0.1058850586,
-0.0349558033,
-0.0293790791,
0.0256897807,
0.04600944,
-0.0412673913,
-0.0231430028,
-0.0398056135,
-0.0293651409,
0.0128174443,
-0.0171491113,
-0.0469492413,
-0.0093929078,
-0.0048377793,
0.0692854822,
0.0272182822,
-0.0349411443,
-0.0219415873,
-0.0136704985,
0.0041728388,
-0.0775272623,
-0.0338490829,
-0.0078533441,
0.0395280309,
0.0329257697,
-0.0455225669,
-0.0329414085,
0.0368215404,
0.0244259574,
-0.0296258125,
-0.027680492,
-0.0064311936,
0.0065878681,
-0.0765758902,
0.0418785401,
-0.0634398386,
0.0224192329,
-0.0221176818,
0.011547829,
0.0249190535,
-0.0418930911,
-0.0264725573,
0.002053234,
-0.0871127099,
-0.0278528165,
-0.0353186801,
0.0618912876,
0.0109194107,
0.0433990471,
0.0125759793,
-0.0411662981,
0.008095487,
0.04152859,
0.0236385111,
0.0357119702,
0.0041501345,
-0.0380838849,
-0.019506881,
0.0232799295,
-0.052742999,
0.0328347161,
0.0249899216,
0.0233798847,
0.026617147,
-0.028403651,
0.0149689373,
-0.0364231654,
0.0440328829,
-0.0077777877,
0.0588564835,
-0.0127438148,
-0.0028732577,
0.0017215461,
-0.0044917697,
-0.0746935457,
0.0135462275,
-0.0008266449,
0.016978113,
-0.0001756519,
0.0121089006,
0.004924499,
0.0372425802,
-0.0158794355,
-0.0104291961,
0.0334416814,
-0.0565394014,
0.0068041882,
0.0207804814,
-0.0060656057,
0.0382325388,
-0.0216542352,
0.0458141565,
-0.0071097533,
0.0337928385,
0.0289557464,
-0.0180936996,
-0.0404613093,
0.0235096551,
-0.0003753327,
0.0100207897,
-0.0587457605,
0.0415030681,
0.0507368296,
-0.0136597436,
0.04108027,
-0.0167106725,
-0.0012122637,
-0.030540131,
0.03262439,
0.0119803883,
-0.0312526412,
0.0527507514,
0.0123997293,
0.0117985765,
0.0031971955,
0.0714503229,
0.009983738,
0.0298123527,
0.0125618987,
0.0101884175,
-0.0143234525,
-0.0066553992,
0.0151524227,
0.00968068,
0.0072727916,
0.0260237753,
-0.0201016758,
-0.0468660779,
0.0143814776,
0.0099528534,
0.0115640042,
0.02341168,
0.0496261604,
0.0183663554,
0.0089933919,
-0.0222500432,
0.0094921896,
-0.0258761086,
-0.0169542599,
0.0030447582,
0.0152869839,
-5.725766127e-33,
-0.0334452912,
-0.0201592073,
0.0022245122,
-0.0025948694,
0.0031259353,
0.0411714464,
-0.0331960805,
0.031559173,
-0.0130556803,
0.0140670883,
0.0354999416,
0.0059173903,
0.0096008712,
0.0657941177,
0.0082107568,
0.0151410503,
0.049922999,
-0.0070861946,
-0.0145925945,
-0.0042554578,
0.0229880456,
0.0031170421,
0.0417587757,
-0.0538231991,
-0.0146487383,
0.0005583097,
-0.0256959405,
0.0076154098,
0.0444255657,
0.0515465699,
-0.012531315,
0.0089870254,
0.0134549476,
-0.0215674657,
-0.0396358967,
0.01263359,
-0.0512400791,
0.0054935487,
0.0141512295,
0.0170769729,
-0.0747099295,
-0.0154834474,
0.0413624458,
-0.0161618218,
0.0063912258,
-0.0531873554,
0.0479144529,
-0.0185438637,
0.0192692783,
-0.0189896487,
-0.0551321134,
0.0179842841,
-0.0040704245,
-0.0378441438,
0.0845230445,
0.0323764496,
0.031584464,
0.0461341143,
-0.051821433,
-0.0076058689,
-0.0074142786,
0.03827025,
0.0581963249,
0.0703353137,
-0.0106367255,
0.0892450958,
0.0099212695,
-0.0154051017,
-0.0197861586,
-0.0269269459,
0.0372375809,
0.0647836924,
0.0662167892,
0.0796626881,
0.0548651665,
0.0325755477,
-0.0195284616,
0.0169401523,
-0.0773786008,
0.0199160203,
0.0544781499,
0.0389401428,
-0.0120871449,
-0.0077824672,
-0.0668643713,
-0.0300599039,
-0.0518859141,
-0.0116384849,
0.0490434654,
0.04674346,
-0.0157688837,
0.0121450834,
0.0932455212,
-0.0233902149,
0.0030671225,
0.0139796985,
-0.0565979667,
0.0629089996,
-0.0134709636,
0.021283336,
-0.0519518107,
-0.0187330283,
0.0708335191,
0.0292852726,
-0.0013713109,
0.0135480119,
0.0702050477,
0.0125126736,
-0.0403090417,
-0.0200067516,
-0.0307481736,
-0.0030976441,
-0.0436316356,
0.0330203623,
0.047701478,
0.045338545,
-0.0530941747,
0.0252142809,
-0.0073318933,
0.0164593309,
-0.0416026935,
-0.0239420775,
0.0014844157,
0.0035980528,
-0.0110384729,
0.0112758661,
-0.0364499241,
-0.0264198519,
0.0500435382,
-0.0136350906,
-0.0055843452,
0.0306606051,
2.414e-7,
0.022774091,
0.0203125961,
0.0555918403,
-0.0025982822,
0.0310380254,
0.0806409717,
-0.0228531156,
0.0292347427,
0.0042698793,
-0.0379497148,
0.0053024543,
0.0393733904,
0.0723283961,
-0.0150132552,
-0.0210209135,
0.0567837134,
-0.0622940287,
-0.0417266414,
-0.0296880882,
-0.032405246,
0.061915122,
0.0770705342,
-0.0241004098,
-0.0102252569,
0.0175261162,
-0.0270919502,
0.110420689,
-0.0239863023,
0.0119041884,
-0.0137836467,
-0.0333243161,
0.0447720028,
-0.0189786032,
0.0231224969,
0.0171822701,
0.0160116237,
0.0652110949,
0.0335141346,
-0.0373775326,
-0.0237999167,
-0.0254452806,
0.0608542189,
-0.0434541292,
-0.024551874,
0.0761772245,
-0.075222075,
-0.0118104257,
-0.0531069264,
-0.028548738,
0.0359785408,
0.0203603972,
0.002953046,
-0.0308211949,
0.0276775807,
0.0247700773,
-0.0003656643,
-0.0410975181,
-0.0851920471,
-0.0268477127,
0.0083739106,
-0.0180926546,
-0.0047436976,
-0.070448041,
0.0088858046,
0.0235198848,
-0.0459921658,
-0.0358926728,
1.77043523e-34,
0.0068464424,
-0.0176399183,
-0.0028701678,
0.0150811682,
0.0071081342,
-0.0122389533,
-0.0291901454,
0.0060757869,
-0.0349813364,
-0.0584160835,
-0.0133055216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16342v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16342v2 | InterFormer: Interactive Local and Global Features Fusion for Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-05-24T08:43:44 | 2023-05-29T11:28:27 | Zhi-Hao Lai, Tian-Hao Zhang, Qi Liu, Xinyuan Qian, Li-Fang Wei, Song-Lu Chen, Feng Chen, Xu-Cheng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | The local and global features are both essential for automatic speech
recognition (ASR). Many recent methods have verified that simply combining
local and global features can further promote ASR performance. However, these
methods pay less attention to the interaction of local and global features, and
their series architectures are rigid to reflect local and global relationships.
To address these issues, this paper proposes InterFormer for interactive local
and global features fusion to learn a better representation for ASR.
Specifically, we combine the convolution block with the transformer block in a
parallel design. Besides, we propose a bidirectional feature interaction module
(BFIM) and a selective fusion module (SFM) to implement the interaction and
fusion of local and global features, respectively. Extensive experiments on
public ASR datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed InterFormer
and its superior performance over the other Transformer and Conformer models. | [
-0.0104361819,
0.0020643289,
0.0231756903,
0.0543716922,
-0.022515092,
0.000686426,
0.0757762939,
-0.0463995002,
0.0201293118,
-0.0234040376,
-0.0574405976,
-0.0588316694,
0.0618748963,
0.0428446531,
0.014211433,
-0.0515678525,
-0.0024360511,
-0.0270997435,
-0.036747124,
-0.0299077705,
0.0060545481,
0.0321609713,
-0.0393120684,
0.0618596375,
-0.019249225,
0.0417511575,
-0.011247132,
-0.0015855787,
0.0526580177,
0.045703847,
-0.0515586622,
-0.0066899927,
0.0314785801,
0.0051951953,
0.0000021315,
0.004104252,
-0.0201970115,
0.0191149618,
-0.0204777326,
-0.0298862308,
-0.0023731315,
0.0037368585,
-0.0464908741,
0.0452446714,
-0.0420341827,
-0.043989405,
0.0467520393,
0.085929729,
0.0337314121,
0.0126564177,
-0.0226745624,
-0.07344684,
0.0355835296,
-0.0153413415,
-0.0675927401,
-0.0126253888,
0.0045292098,
-0.048228588,
-0.0312915109,
-0.0479953289,
-0.0184120554,
0.0524245016,
0.0275146794,
-0.0120483814,
0.0758717954,
0.0061235945,
-0.0373950005,
-0.0431798995,
-0.0067822561,
0.0473895334,
-0.0068518203,
0.0003338772,
-0.0123318033,
0.0025522222,
-0.0120750591,
0.0170665719,
0.0067003183,
-0.0092608221,
-0.0158773381,
-0.0000498363,
-0.0428165831,
-0.0013352033,
0.0207595155,
0.0010268061,
-0.0954542533,
-0.0151058948,
-0.0019191073,
-0.0014016071,
-0.0116633894,
-0.0182805657,
-0.0433673188,
0.0150815882,
0.049971465,
-0.001119098,
0.0135053461,
-0.0456890874,
-0.0294726174,
-0.0561079755,
-0.0243326239,
-0.0611398704,
-0.0076377406,
0.054761216,
-0.0631812289,
0.0180916991,
-0.0202364121,
0.0997905135,
-0.0228942167,
0.0171747878,
-0.0350717492,
-0.0063838288,
-0.0228005219,
0.0109591037,
-0.021716021,
0.0361336544,
-0.0189055353,
-0.0655292943,
-0.0339399278,
0.0215397384,
-0.038930513,
-0.0008631258,
0.0255121943,
0.0108133992,
0.0048946687,
0.0095192501,
0.0310033448,
0.0496183857,
0.0264681522,
0.035394799,
-0.0248234235,
-0.0420245044,
0.0113158021,
-0.0040355166,
0.0445144363,
0.0087733613,
0.0028016616,
0.0687257797,
-0.0088747209,
-0.0417139791,
-0.0225891471,
0.0646728128,
-0.0043794136,
-0.0250889976,
0.0298640672,
-0.0291287694,
0.0610389337,
-0.0014871522,
0.0186960865,
0.0091531221,
-0.0173610989,
-0.0457964987,
0.028770186,
0.0751338154,
0.0076214299,
-0.0114566665,
0.0556948148,
-0.0158172287,
0.0551113002,
0.0364813395,
0.0434093997,
-0.0157808736,
-0.0488245338,
-0.0364593379,
-0.0063948943,
0.0277065355,
-0.0269051809,
-0.0108016497,
-0.03298131,
-0.0222430248,
0.0338123143,
-0.0273657255,
0.0235432759,
0.0394155383,
-0.0381823778,
-0.0144390129,
0.0272760671,
0.0132526103,
0.0449824966,
0.0278134253,
0.0249217656,
0.0299089793,
-0.0228049252,
0.0181074534,
0.0018686559,
0.0274544321,
-0.0275982451,
-0.0103508951,
0.0457279161,
0.1142778173,
-0.0480291881,
-0.0101150861,
0.003963178,
-0.0092361653,
0.0003057241,
0.0694173202,
0.0453075469,
0.0254818983,
-0.0356035978,
0.0342336707,
-0.0120890914,
-0.0627589896,
0.011005708,
-0.0487803519,
0.0129988454,
0.0458649695,
0.0173359271,
-0.0175484251,
-0.0016127272,
-0.0256437995,
-0.0741145536,
0.0168994218,
-0.0184800699,
0.0091699054,
0.0505273081,
-0.0606687628,
-0.0525046177,
0.0576312728,
-0.0312486235,
0.0583548732,
-0.0367823504,
-0.0170484595,
0.03020842,
0.0500893965,
0.0597202852,
-0.0219473075,
0.017331915,
-0.0013245294,
0.0449897684,
0.0389147103,
0.0341833569,
0.0309716631,
-0.0206395313,
-0.0088958126,
0.0480793081,
-0.0179819912,
-0.030779399,
0.0452101342,
-0.053765092,
-0.0261887591,
0.0441497341,
-0.0070418203,
0.0604897439,
-0.0025997998,
0.0083378255,
-0.0979355648,
0.0071919323,
-0.0266137961,
0.0774008855,
-0.0185548011,
0.0701005906,
0.0494719371,
0.0316711515,
-0.0182694364,
-0.0021646351,
-0.0141573232,
-0.0217932127,
-0.0083320243,
-0.0095072193,
-0.0260554738,
-0.0444840118,
-0.0338788591,
0.0469897501,
-0.0130040525,
0.0099581359,
-0.0099866008,
-0.044817891,
0.0320493579,
-0.0418463945,
-0.1024273783,
-0.0379956253,
-0.0043950602,
-0.0172894914,
-0.0100844931,
0.054453481,
0.0212916993,
-0.0340695083,
-0.0227638353,
-0.0311288685,
-0.0148549443,
0.0207705591,
-0.0507214032,
0.0268485304,
-0.0354387574,
-0.0161683932,
-0.0257604867,
0.0259921942,
0.0097384611,
-0.0283000171,
-0.0177064631,
-0.0227660052,
-0.0672115758,
0.0059173075,
0.0494129024,
-0.0244171601,
-0.0338608362,
-0.0234793928,
-0.0064149424,
0.0108283032,
0.0231301747,
0.0112940501,
-0.0370653644,
0.0118894754,
-0.0194189269,
-0.0216777883,
0.0389893316,
0.0012109606,
0.0393139981,
0.0042285183,
0.0564466156,
-0.0836127177,
0.0229369905,
0.0317334533,
0.0157035291,
-0.0361162536,
-0.0611067265,
0.0329996422,
-0.0192973986,
-0.0282948613,
-0.0585161932,
-0.0151469447,
-0.0244736671,
-0.0349977538,
-0.0446282253,
0.0089425826,
-0.0897117034,
-0.029704826,
-0.0063490677,
-0.0482526422,
-0.0474371202,
0.0013557207,
0.007553522,
-0.0212049801,
-0.0447703749,
-0.0353303738,
-0.0022776132,
0.0348823182,
0.024053568,
-0.0519355237,
0.0933895111,
-0.0103956275,
0.0146228895,
-0.0352971889,
-0.0321726166,
-0.0129048834,
-0.0262931995,
-0.022478791,
0.0023683852,
0.0146235246,
-0.0695982948,
-0.0155403204,
0.0511226729,
0.0329022706,
0.0475099646,
0.0199298672,
0.0145283602,
-0.0119304648,
0.0373998657,
0.0181919336,
0.0858839825,
-0.0433878377,
0.0198590718,
0.0436607227,
-0.0130785536,
0.0558533743,
-0.0239072256,
-0.0631292537,
-0.0115605965,
0.052607622,
0.013280509,
-0.0330289863,
-0.0231044758,
0.0074822325,
-0.0371110924,
0.0751280561,
0.0555441119,
0.0030823888,
-0.0355611891,
-0.0372049399,
0.0162316207,
-0.0133920293,
0.0141307628,
-0.0191857368,
-0.0252963621,
-0.0142780831,
0.0404531173,
-0.0280904435,
0.0000381167,
0.0552969128,
0.0133607285,
-0.0496257357,
0.022112038,
0.0390005782,
-0.0215745326,
-0.0170992389,
-0.0382823385,
-0.0204112623,
-0.0592780635,
0.027239915,
-0.0242298935,
-0.0247862972,
-0.0651649684,
0.0019357023,
-0.0198251493,
-0.0168882608,
-0.0011947807,
0.005219976,
-0.028462613,
0.0750708133,
0.0184437614,
-0.0138668576,
-0.0540497713,
0.0021367818,
0.0070541003,
0.0276562702,
-0.0389362052,
0.0207748637,
0.0155257713,
-0.0318156853,
0.007074588,
-0.0004545103,
-0.0141391046,
-0.0076926774,
-0.0287702736,
0.0569976829,
-0.0491062254,
0.0683633462,
-0.0036332232,
0.0096097458,
-0.0178246256,
0.0052644932,
-0.018138133,
-0.0114291888,
0.0121051939,
0.0349215008,
0.0057155369,
0.0216843188,
-0.003937366,
0.0046391189,
0.005706118,
-0.0700108483,
-0.0053053177,
0.01366001,
0.0275065694,
0.0285213739,
0.0101478873,
-0.0264903493,
-0.0262679625,
0.0465023182,
0.004195251,
0.0386285409,
0.0026864582,
0.0494301021,
-0.0292537697,
0.0322153717,
0.0434614792,
-0.0683880299,
-0.0178466253,
0.0177953951,
-0.0241247211,
-0.0618052781,
0.0229754876,
-0.0119517418,
0.0126385279,
0.052396033,
-0.0472532026,
0.0128381206,
0.0508070998,
0.0155611606,
-0.0317609124,
0.0289544985,
0.0571184419,
-0.0689458922,
-0.0183009487,
-0.0036889403,
-0.0240130983,
0.0203938652,
-0.0384630077,
-0.0352576226,
-0.0511656255,
-0.0550018102,
-0.0022420113,
0.0173113588,
0.0626115277,
0.0042114966,
0.0156332832,
-0.0355296656,
0.0724950805,
0.0283166692,
0.0538584068,
-0.0557568818,
-0.0109579694,
0.0216428861,
0.0218205824,
0.0396819226,
0.0654618517,
0.0254514832,
-0.0456036367,
0.0015357337,
0.0510074757,
-0.007139862,
0.0108627984,
-0.0183291156,
0.032404203,
0.0004076682,
0.0293623153,
0.0848004147,
-0.0198566448,
0.018290339,
0.0511245802,
-0.0311100315,
-0.0087697757,
-0.0148363151,
0.0487649553,
-0.070846945,
-0.0147030447,
-0.0478064083,
0.0031444642,
0.0749976337,
-0.0203332789,
0.0312814601,
0.0384589657,
0.0345545858,
-0.0463141687,
0.0204758402,
-0.0029940491,
-0.0158726405,
0.0157163702,
-0.0082539003,
-0.0132235475,
-0.0010414283,
0.0428432524,
-0.0729792193,
0.0135927005,
-0.0274849162,
0.0621594563,
-0.0397343598,
-0.0573484488,
0.0361247994,
0.0146277184,
-0.0139263654,
0.0034624287,
-0.0012132457,
-0.0254771393,
0.0488062054,
-0.0490319915,
0.0049159275,
-0.0483836643,
0.0263241995,
-0.0285443161,
-0.0247822758,
0.0101218689,
0.0045872633,
-0.0562958755,
0.0094125457,
0.0174305942,
0.0154569307,
-6.533064055e-33,
-0.0559561439,
0.0183385666,
0.0072702789,
0.0320528895,
-0.0542483069,
0.0077885287,
0.0333075076,
0.0403981917,
-0.021739874,
-0.0385999903,
-0.0251102913,
0.0290565416,
0.0341893584,
-0.0079171974,
-0.0189384483,
-0.0190997329,
0.1097351909,
0.042560555,
0.0459443033,
-0.0040136627,
0.05271722,
0.0290867705,
0.0195162743,
-0.0774454698,
-0.0843530297,
0.0027749802,
-0.0294317584,
-0.0160314105,
-0.043230284,
0.019875098,
-0.0014216547,
0.0264383815,
-0.0123203071,
-0.019154923,
-0.0127015738,
0.0358003788,
-0.0550424568,
0.0348791704,
-0.0111265732,
0.0665580854,
-0.0085085863,
-0.0311947558,
0.0331048593,
0.0281648953,
0.0214831978,
-0.0647755116,
0.032720387,
-0.0197005384,
-0.0444155075,
-0.007491969,
0.0001827278,
0.0437945426,
-0.0210982021,
0.0039357715,
0.0667836517,
0.0122096604,
0.0038652264,
-0.0258148946,
-0.0488376133,
0.00709042,
0.037596412,
0.0438624322,
0.0298314691,
0.0681002587,
0.0288508162,
0.0213773809,
0.0317948237,
-0.0694518834,
-0.0042899284,
-0.0355128869,
0.0107120564,
0.0619322918,
0.0311545171,
0.0336818174,
0.0159073044,
-0.0524141677,
-0.0111680208,
0.0003552664,
0.0179720931,
0.0426513702,
-0.0438737236,
0.0304583684,
-0.0030441175,
0.0183206294,
-0.0277658794,
-0.0001080308,
-0.036961209,
-0.0149314525,
0.0007072403,
0.0513679981,
0.0259019881,
0.0133789042,
0.0046249437,
-0.0244924743,
0.0876507685,
0.0346561,
0.0083171157,
0.0168922544,
0.0238605831,
-0.0417227969,
-0.0176522285,
-0.0416647717,
0.00685259,
-0.0017480723,
-0.0071073282,
-0.0050489269,
0.0114995213,
0.0734234452,
-0.0397715792,
-0.0257455464,
-0.0150838969,
0.0119114257,
-0.0162841137,
0.0116679436,
0.0398325622,
0.0084067388,
-0.0215846747,
0.0436973497,
-0.0712251961,
0.0516892709,
-0.0127841458,
-0.0052753082,
0.0322887637,
0.0256535299,
0.0168847609,
-0.0177045595,
0.0110793067,
-0.0405308679,
0.0423207544,
-0.0491020754,
-0.0276948884,
0.008947649,
2.96e-7,
-0.0603732541,
-0.0276422706,
0.0355712958,
-0.0486957245,
-0.0119136255,
0.0325244181,
0.0035586613,
0.0126894368,
0.0342869982,
0.0656725094,
0.017815562,
0.001891669,
0.0461974703,
0.0241690576,
-0.0818787292,
0.0201239772,
-0.0628006309,
0.0185120255,
0.0047808168,
0.0145345628,
0.0149761196,
0.0872780755,
-0.0179080535,
-0.0240510274,
0.0370109193,
-0.0247981176,
0.049868878,
0.0146169811,
0.0005000593,
-0.0140476217,
-0.0299203396,
-0.0074041965,
-0.0154049853,
0.0593113452,
-0.0273335371,
0.0582166165,
0.0061887377,
0.0245550424,
-0.018561149,
-0.0838750303,
0.0078219855,
0.0726872459,
-0.0375275649,
0.0126058273,
0.0661594495,
0.0154392952,
-0.0151531985,
-0.0204882845,
-0.0610098764,
0.0089140348,
0.0155183496,
0.0037427116,
0.0405098051,
0.0218342934,
0.0090198414,
-0.0429844968,
-0.0130341752,
-0.0684993193,
0.0074558291,
0.018779099,
-0.081730172,
-0.0075356993,
-0.0372435823,
-0.0214939974,
0.0341093577,
0.0400987752,
-0.0352940671,
2.140811e-34,
0.0153403329,
0.0012859636,
0.0258112177,
0.0506081656,
-0.0297164973,
-0.0479642339,
-0.0346094966,
0.0150140142,
0.0032439393,
-0.0688052773,
-0.0411976203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14891v1 | Extracting Psychological Indicators Using Question Answering | 2023-05-24T08:41:23 | 2023-05-24T08:41:23 | Luka Pavlović | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | In this work, we propose a method for extracting text spans that may indicate
one of the BIG5 psychological traits using a question-answering task with
examples that have no answer for the asked question. We utilized the RoBERTa
model fine-tuned on SQuAD 2.0 dataset. The model was further fine-tuned
utilizing comments from Reddit. We examined the effect of the percentage of
examples with no answer in the training dataset on the overall performance. The
results obtained in this study are in line with the SQuAD 2.0 benchmark and
present a good baseline for further research. | [
0.0901647136,
0.046353057,
-0.0175123494,
0.0175852198,
-0.0135046495,
0.0329452604,
0.0186794847,
0.0275204591,
-0.0219892208,
-0.0165626295,
-0.0099540548,
0.000919915,
-0.027072249,
-0.0373951048,
0.0259786751,
-0.0290643461,
0.0239456259,
0.0059670545,
0.0268403068,
0.0027798321,
0.0295580458,
-0.0007057646,
0.0005714245,
0.0088303639,
-0.0087577142,
-0.0380725116,
0.0123117175,
-0.0061817653,
0.0184670519,
-0.0071396967,
0.0360617042,
0.0463722609,
-0.0415645912,
-0.0031970388,
0.0000018327,
-0.0354394838,
-0.0134866377,
-0.0134167308,
0.0101892473,
-0.0257264543,
0.0274284817,
0.0380539931,
0.0562646016,
0.0500582196,
-0.0302429721,
-0.0123256175,
0.0197996944,
0.1049975231,
0.0629632697,
0.0451721027,
-0.0024645037,
-0.0262286402,
-0.0214798059,
0.0002831732,
0.0687854365,
-0.0189087,
0.0577871576,
-0.0115649365,
0.0237302426,
0.0076767006,
-0.0005543953,
-0.0012077423,
0.0090385703,
0.0385789648,
-0.0160913691,
0.0080457646,
-0.0040788744,
-0.0486424156,
0.0062321969,
0.0703556538,
0.041419398,
0.0103014139,
0.0098541118,
0.0122256139,
0.0488569401,
0.0283771399,
-0.0391488671,
-0.0032843377,
-0.0208294038,
-0.0431212261,
0.0163358953,
0.0483056344,
-0.0200047828,
-0.0117866378,
0.0210400559,
0.0190013852,
-0.0218973812,
-0.0458060429,
0.0209143665,
-0.0077760299,
-0.0427779257,
-0.0537213199,
0.041180227,
0.0336068608,
0.007264073,
0.0002421313,
-0.0194080807,
-0.0304634906,
0.0493419729,
-0.026556585,
0.0050368994,
-0.0050024749,
0.0026494726,
0.0243140552,
0.0080773477,
0.0243273713,
-0.0053536077,
-0.0112108532,
-0.0667950734,
-0.0325517654,
-0.0600242354,
-0.0177977215,
-0.0414723493,
0.04236928,
0.0194802433,
-0.0298576858,
-0.0178752188,
-0.0013965296,
0.0063055642,
-0.0155504197,
-0.0285927877,
0.0181416981,
-0.0156048853,
0.0437925942,
-0.0377165638,
0.0115757603,
-0.0945094898,
-0.0048869327,
0.021478394,
-0.0365669839,
0.0038905402,
-0.015242639,
0.0237468854,
-0.0258091986,
0.0474580042,
-0.0010601691,
0.0432819054,
-0.0245162211,
-0.0019304064,
-0.027369298,
-0.0123235751,
-0.0658317134,
0.002862375,
-0.0494337901,
0.0359459706,
0.0119398665,
-0.0451921001,
-0.003410961,
0.0173061118,
0.0626168996,
-0.0012960829,
0.032886792,
-0.0478015281,
0.0045600459,
0.013328664,
0.0114125563,
0.0303489398,
0.070681788,
0.0042185928,
0.0019299407,
0.0568991117,
-0.0077928999,
0.0185690541,
0.026922103,
0.0426996313,
-0.0293400344,
0.0235563386,
0.054021433,
-0.0014125101,
-0.0040685381,
-0.0067497715,
0.0339771472,
0.019706307,
-0.0391594656,
0.0336888582,
0.0837036967,
0.0006245652,
0.0377390981,
-0.0230988301,
0.0419303961,
0.0431057699,
-0.0283253044,
0.001814926,
0.0301827285,
-0.0419656299,
0.0211942252,
0.0067163771,
0.0115882512,
-0.0436502807,
-0.0563296117,
-0.0568048395,
-0.0071327244,
0.0201226156,
0.0686620921,
0.0304661151,
0.0094227577,
-0.0376842022,
-0.0015363017,
0.0124805756,
-0.0411576517,
-0.017285917,
-0.0710150748,
0.0805426538,
0.0064597703,
0.0241756812,
-0.0469071493,
-0.0228913277,
-0.0188110173,
0.0071065687,
0.0103714392,
0.0510001592,
-0.0109248115,
0.0260620583,
-0.0307824109,
-0.0025320556,
0.0050579547,
-0.0061686044,
-0.0368787758,
0.0015148912,
0.0096565234,
-0.0140494788,
-0.0266550966,
-0.0179585349,
0.0244321376,
0.0299778972,
-0.024797976,
0.0063155792,
-0.0083685862,
0.046819862,
0.0375617035,
-0.0031587665,
0.0098054763,
0.0379612669,
-0.0180152096,
-0.0410338268,
-0.0253381822,
-0.026682267,
-0.0382187292,
0.0123486342,
-0.0372257456,
-0.0111306002,
0.1023907587,
0.0104135023,
-0.0003004051,
-0.0122534251,
-0.0605814494,
0.0131740132,
0.0277282558,
-0.0085828295,
-0.0062682615,
0.0401287749,
-0.0366986543,
0.0774363354,
-0.0146944113,
0.0610313378,
-0.0170303471,
-0.0258695185,
-0.0111898063,
-0.0337469727,
-0.0505543016,
-0.0409266241,
0.0172828548,
0.0255188104,
0.0254582651,
-0.0046236194,
-0.0717439801,
-0.0172287244,
-0.1213502213,
0.040715687,
-0.0064334534,
0.0192683917,
0.0127225434,
0.012739175,
-0.0240624566,
-0.0310000032,
-0.0568949729,
0.0255862325,
0.0075973496,
0.0429227762,
0.0438160151,
0.0140978079,
0.0134908166,
-0.0505615473,
-0.0247415341,
-0.020198144,
0.0000323649,
0.0392018333,
0.0156028531,
-0.0171186365,
0.0416984558,
-0.0741483867,
0.0156863555,
0.0040576691,
-0.0283321515,
0.0103333797,
-0.0351678319,
-0.0007397634,
0.0870382488,
0.068871215,
0.0023107999,
-0.0415943712,
0.0185723118,
-0.0263148341,
0.02250701,
-0.0477904342,
0.0153716179,
-0.0127660194,
-0.0529315658,
0.0143240932,
0.0475905947,
0.0282845199,
0.0200914778,
-0.0378893875,
0.032220237,
0.0021670822,
-0.0321120992,
0.0052533764,
0.03272992,
-0.004592909,
0.0561263934,
-0.0116214203,
-0.0040164269,
0.0441711769,
0.0101774884,
-0.0170402881,
-0.0612857379,
-0.0265874397,
-0.0568398125,
0.0464023761,
0.0267246608,
-0.0118767908,
0.0468492322,
-0.0179482047,
0.0251191873,
-0.046963606,
-0.0247486625,
-0.0322079882,
-0.0101030366,
0.041176267,
-0.0210339036,
-0.0025190515,
-0.0179009158,
-0.0500798225,
-0.0766133219,
-0.047088854,
-0.0253029633,
-0.0098519661,
-0.0138765229,
-0.024315726,
-0.0339912288,
0.0586227477,
-0.0110983141,
-0.0439277925,
-0.0278584603,
0.0152080916,
0.0210977327,
0.1137186214,
0.0213988163,
0.0424907543,
-0.089641422,
0.0017635174,
0.0646527782,
0.00572235,
0.0144250514,
0.0153082702,
-0.0331469961,
0.0010846745,
-0.0137842717,
0.0103106685,
0.0257903617,
0.0372642316,
-0.0151503794,
-0.0210402887,
0.109817788,
0.0349348113,
-0.0331463106,
0.0144850351,
-0.0227380842,
0.0146753676,
0.0212264825,
0.0371443182,
-0.0253124982,
-0.0587592237,
-0.0251968391,
0.0264324211,
-0.0338761322,
-0.0568936393,
0.0036223975,
-0.0828420967,
0.0176659282,
-0.0378006659,
-0.0731020048,
-0.009301668,
-0.05465905,
0.0198294371,
0.0041536349,
-0.0307851229,
-0.0297386479,
-0.0062846243,
0.0178058427,
0.035462793,
-0.0649624169,
0.0099796709,
0.0571493655,
-0.0205075331,
0.0403100774,
0.0387098901,
0.0221803449,
-0.0227711871,
-0.0218030661,
-0.0333681591,
-0.0468846112,
-0.0012124489,
-0.0137035241,
0.1360216588,
-0.0353963636,
0.0176825318,
-0.0945570618,
0.0220693666,
-0.0452392995,
0.0486487113,
0.0676915646,
0.0609678365,
0.0234919619,
-0.0345127732,
-0.0415943526,
0.0373536833,
0.0109188221,
0.0932280943,
0.0308775716,
-0.0852759033,
-0.0456204116,
0.0121090394,
-0.0117239309,
-0.069080241,
-0.0572815947,
-0.0285755862,
0.0435748845,
0.0032075248,
-0.0431476831,
-0.0847056285,
0.0315752923,
0.0170939155,
-0.0467391871,
-0.0100827385,
-0.0216897521,
0.0498016737,
-0.0585047193,
0.0192461777,
0.0131288432,
-0.0126058543,
-0.0291215498,
-0.0128909098,
0.0524713621,
-0.0383988544,
-0.0240587555,
-0.0041344538,
-0.0784790069,
0.0001764282,
0.0203878805,
0.0232723355,
0.0181515682,
-0.005885093,
0.0031774887,
-0.0444891602,
0.035180632,
0.0193155091,
-0.0553669408,
0.0200662259,
-0.0022855047,
0.0117754331,
0.0293611847,
0.015253976,
-0.0480778404,
0.0192660782,
-0.0014943841,
-0.0152911106,
-0.0587089695,
-0.0164952874,
0.0099238353,
0.0281330813,
-0.0317652524,
0.0592372902,
-0.0504502468,
-0.010038984,
-0.0396771729,
-0.0202439837,
-0.0074680182,
-0.0164676234,
-0.0149222184,
-0.0110659376,
-0.0125627378,
0.0073989737,
-0.0210282281,
-0.0048112995,
0.0094922176,
-0.0536026843,
0.0015301162,
0.0548321195,
0.017263025,
-0.0168387536,
0.0110847913,
-0.0514235906,
-0.0509159826,
0.0479816906,
0.0507884026,
0.0478246771,
0.0630741566,
-0.0081597008,
-0.0267002713,
0.0220355522,
0.0221065469,
-0.072873354,
-0.0459751748,
0.0057681222,
0.0131793674,
-0.028799912,
0.013663833,
0.038103193,
0.00960596,
-0.0019040423,
-0.0068089664,
0.0077418736,
-0.0188246891,
-0.0219396614,
0.07314872,
0.014030749,
-0.0095612593,
0.0055611343,
0.0392742492,
-0.0031320888,
0.0035467036,
-0.0093008559,
-0.0508372746,
-0.0582653806,
0.05342035,
-0.0045773289,
0.0684118122,
0.0002820563,
0.0131248049,
-0.0473930053,
-0.0519538708,
0.0293406919,
0.0029630901,
-0.0001588814,
-0.0084123863,
0.0249858648,
0.0407997333,
0.0022148285,
-0.0551502667,
-0.0726754591,
0.0447336137,
-0.0400976762,
-0.0098722121,
-0.0281211622,
-5.903401323e-33,
-0.0105479714,
-0.0389096402,
-0.0058111087,
0.0563523211,
-0.0274931863,
0.021647213,
-0.0292059109,
0.0271333847,
-0.0472300649,
-0.0000852606,
-0.0085155675,
0.0028058658,
-0.0066489065,
0.0154894562,
0.0064229919,
-0.0375731736,
0.0121159451,
-0.0616433844,
-0.0097128619,
0.045707982,
0.0313018076,
0.0214354545,
0.0326188058,
-0.0334887542,
0.0209619571,
-0.0665620342,
0.0079281107,
0.0168792326,
0.0235285126,
0.0729643703,
-0.0234184545,
0.0481728204,
0.0288356785,
-0.0132332174,
0.0117599731,
0.060121078,
-0.0819363222,
-0.0637505352,
-0.0008625695,
0.0125205209,
-0.0745799989,
-0.0184472855,
0.0455567464,
0.0115915723,
0.0265752487,
-0.0450614952,
0.071871005,
0.0220485181,
0.0571689717,
-0.0014060279,
-0.0312431026,
0.0043111024,
-0.0201914292,
-0.0281594079,
-0.0128953969,
0.0944842175,
-0.026747968,
0.0191515889,
-0.0492341034,
0.0204777736,
-0.029036127,
0.0092443507,
0.0183550175,
0.0237984173,
-0.0105226412,
0.0648304075,
0.0817524642,
0.0082418164,
-0.0146472119,
-0.0358404927,
0.0001664916,
0.0236010905,
0.081466265,
0.0344961211,
0.0293131676,
-0.0031600108,
-0.0709129274,
0.0107339928,
0.112739712,
-0.022483224,
0.0542184748,
-0.0285335556,
-0.0686029494,
-0.0031768633,
0.0083124861,
0.0194604285,
-0.0219579656,
-0.0249905884,
0.0406719744,
0.0035424118,
-0.0255695228,
-0.0099267587,
0.0219475497,
-0.0114392722,
0.0464131571,
0.0621131212,
-0.0300093554,
0.0386710726,
0.0293184258,
-0.0194267072,
-0.0863404647,
0.0712457076,
0.0043230266,
0.0161745604,
0.0294322092,
0.0108912224,
0.0098925652,
-0.0140700946,
-0.0507940017,
-0.0495536849,
0.0040063127,
0.0225190353,
-0.0102872895,
0.0050656251,
-0.009785858,
0.020326985,
-0.0145292301,
0.0282450356,
-0.0028482967,
-0.012541539,
-0.0467357412,
-0.0225116368,
0.0242871605,
-0.0278781019,
-0.0207661446,
-0.0360723138,
-0.0261792801,
0.0380339548,
-0.0489464253,
-0.0271289442,
0.0112886932,
0.0350949168,
2.433e-7,
0.0271032769,
0.0069724019,
-0.0027213788,
0.0011383523,
0.0093965363,
0.0607946068,
0.0490517169,
0.006363919,
0.0819508284,
0.0263958592,
-0.0158952437,
0.0304848049,
0.0307871774,
0.0523981862,
-0.0497870147,
-0.0740569383,
-0.0150226206,
-0.0129570756,
-0.0238800608,
-0.0114905303,
0.0624539591,
0.0718957558,
0.0322584696,
-0.0014200219,
-0.0290024225,
-0.0309142377,
0.0319689661,
-0.009679256,
-0.0359443612,
0.0027149748,
-0.0025994647,
0.0067611695,
-0.0078139473,
0.0458054729,
0.0212074388,
-0.0109142978,
0.0171058178,
0.0086590583,
-0.0100623425,
-0.0503121279,
0.0112286406,
0.0170322079,
-0.0064072828,
-0.0311846156,
0.0749526843,
-0.025766775,
-0.0573864467,
-0.0351169258,
-0.0289574582,
-0.0317373201,
0.0219910443,
0.0326594301,
-0.0262073297,
-0.0150831304,
0.0109941652,
-0.0261048097,
-0.0200611111,
-0.0412044451,
0.0254234932,
0.0151952291,
-0.0623362586,
-0.0608625077,
-0.0045679128,
0.0135093117,
-0.0197418723,
-0.0575390756,
0.0103844106,
1.933273111e-34,
-0.015165085,
0.0281209238,
0.0048096729,
0.0053826333,
0.0276290067,
0.0032724484,
-0.0368801318,
-0.0223746151,
0.0373024493,
-0.0784804225,
-0.0270178746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14889v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14889v2 | Evaluating Evaluation Metrics: A Framework for Analyzing NLG Evaluation Metrics using Measurement Theory | 2023-05-24T08:38:23 | 2023-10-23T01:02:48 | Ziang Xiao, Susu Zhang, Vivian Lai, Q. Vera Liao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We address a fundamental challenge in Natural Language Generation (NLG) model
evaluation -- the design and evaluation of evaluation metrics. Recognizing the
limitations of existing automatic metrics and noises from how current human
evaluation was conducted, we propose MetricEval, a framework informed by
measurement theory, the foundation of educational test design, for
conceptualizing and evaluating the reliability and validity of NLG evaluation
metrics. The framework formalizes the source of measurement error and offers
statistical tools for evaluating evaluation metrics based on empirical data.
With our framework, one can quantify the uncertainty of the metrics to better
interpret the result. To exemplify the use of our framework in practice, we
analyzed a set of evaluation metrics for summarization and identified issues
related to conflated validity structure in human-eval and reliability in
LLM-based metrics. Through MetricEval, we aim to promote the design,
evaluation, and interpretation of valid and reliable metrics to advance robust
and effective NLG models. | [
0.0194998272,
0.0049552899,
0.0080259871,
-0.0088689486,
-0.0230467208,
-0.0075790584,
-0.0043723462,
-0.0307412054,
-0.011232784,
-0.0612601563,
-0.0112852249,
-0.0508368164,
0.0471498743,
-0.0112264398,
0.0215787832,
-0.0796522722,
0.0110529279,
0.0012961614,
0.0001617306,
0.0324502438,
0.0120750917,
0.0064376616,
-0.0150958393,
0.0621968508,
0.020975573,
0.0068546706,
0.0223022923,
-0.0105275773,
0.0250953622,
-0.0652301088,
0.0003380193,
0.0300620217,
-0.0209784731,
-0.0092976522,
0.0000020108,
-0.1039393544,
-0.0050119762,
-0.0031716218,
0.007427196,
0.0269877631,
0.0507482328,
0.0330280364,
0.0091248611,
0.0167396367,
-0.0157524031,
0.0216682367,
-0.0036446583,
0.0040319203,
0.0523489863,
0.0381616876,
0.0176310353,
-0.0076628393,
0.0008817587,
-0.0120007284,
-0.0314121172,
-0.0133252917,
-0.0286958888,
0.0697427019,
0.0170942098,
-0.011441364,
0.0028082796,
0.0223785155,
0.0048295516,
0.0106677124,
0.0260974932,
0.0029798055,
-0.0025339858,
-0.0255421922,
0.0044435579,
0.0376550443,
0.0112731578,
0.00074131,
0.0004657519,
-0.0096036317,
0.0269705039,
-0.0006536536,
-0.0503625758,
0.067208536,
-0.0017505027,
0.0035690235,
-0.0128133409,
0.0428809039,
0.0104704788,
0.0211824924,
0.0274163857,
0.0479632802,
0.0065906337,
-0.00778226,
-0.0319810733,
0.0270369351,
-0.0351962335,
-0.0403426662,
-0.0003976611,
0.0452733897,
-0.0533979796,
0.0129099116,
-0.0319496281,
-0.0459116437,
0.0477694646,
-0.0505614765,
0.0107357707,
-0.0018634174,
0.0177499093,
-0.0194975827,
-0.0130067915,
0.0992396399,
0.0551746637,
-0.0001435531,
-0.0691556558,
0.0572720356,
-0.0447079539,
-0.0104441009,
-0.0160058327,
0.0345371738,
0.0090919919,
-0.0247444957,
-0.0823399499,
-0.0176464058,
-0.030370893,
-0.0059272759,
-0.0107495887,
0.0136567689,
-0.0259081665,
0.0198972262,
-0.0306577031,
0.0019949221,
-0.0299954209,
0.009555635,
0.0475736782,
-0.0173268206,
0.0269865673,
0.0584911592,
-0.0036999492,
0.0325914547,
-0.0015175418,
0.0689435303,
-0.0200411268,
-0.026591951,
-0.023853099,
-0.082241632,
-0.0213859938,
-0.0412898287,
-0.0197067615,
-0.0740407035,
-0.0223593544,
0.0202310681,
0.0050609545,
-0.0271131024,
0.0156795681,
0.0162500329,
0.0227350984,
0.0044066957,
-0.0119247166,
0.0159632955,
0.021359304,
0.0228066128,
0.0062563792,
0.0365845971,
0.0784245431,
0.0296953712,
0.0540854819,
0.0130602922,
0.0028799933,
0.0060722432,
-0.0124166077,
-0.0315489098,
0.0083559072,
-0.0234243758,
-0.0634590164,
0.0442458093,
0.0138863353,
0.0828191489,
-0.0221150871,
0.069488585,
0.0196853038,
0.0368346944,
0.0259193815,
-0.0059585264,
0.0754921734,
0.0234092381,
0.0220994018,
0.0423977003,
0.0214550551,
0.0080383103,
-0.0386386141,
0.056750495,
0.0426928587,
0.0347597189,
0.0181615334,
-0.1050395519,
-0.0394145772,
0.0208807979,
0.0045854985,
-0.018610809,
0.0178834852,
0.0211917292,
-0.047782056,
0.0530248545,
-0.036251884,
-0.0910758153,
0.067343533,
-0.0339568928,
0.0350407138,
0.046835836,
0.0640551001,
0.025430033,
-0.0157692358,
0.0060163196,
-0.01918648,
0.0406684801,
0.0403207727,
-0.0328886323,
-0.0219452772,
-0.0306484587,
-0.0212052427,
-0.0138502177,
0.0176787451,
-0.0218099412,
0.0028965301,
0.008120819,
0.0554434434,
-0.0550358221,
-0.0857983157,
0.0477750823,
-0.0120958602,
-0.0205692444,
-0.021044746,
-0.0131490137,
0.0230172165,
0.0412051491,
-0.0301388428,
0.0637346506,
-0.0062248241,
-0.0016737011,
-0.0122471247,
0.0170290358,
-0.0096012205,
-0.0056267809,
0.0171296876,
-0.0842603147,
0.03529533,
-0.0120146759,
-0.0219973363,
-0.0358121432,
0.0200720057,
-0.0677381381,
-0.0186811443,
-0.0247058943,
0.0479002334,
-0.0114582898,
-0.0234864615,
-0.0650039315,
0.0485336743,
0.0029807014,
0.0495016351,
0.0169826467,
0.0246652756,
0.0524265319,
-0.016266631,
-0.037257947,
0.0071018138,
-0.0231136791,
0.0430431515,
0.081674546,
0.0498307198,
-0.0717844367,
-0.0621836074,
-0.0578883067,
-0.0048846346,
-0.0213648956,
0.0630362257,
0.0504619479,
-0.0500564836,
-0.0077738808,
0.0419287533,
-0.047456909,
-0.0692483261,
0.0400631763,
-0.0202805996,
0.0520333536,
0.0056077638,
0.0081556905,
-0.0472398922,
0.012778786,
0.0088269422,
0.0457000136,
0.0583758391,
0.026464425,
-0.0492094681,
0.0646172464,
-0.035387449,
-0.0721601397,
0.0361763425,
-0.0423014425,
0.0606160015,
0.0547821373,
0.0394210294,
0.0087589016,
0.0535685755,
0.0264840499,
0.0413041562,
-0.0254541673,
-0.013087729,
-0.0320000909,
-0.0285530146,
-0.0020128291,
0.0226684939,
-0.0490059331,
0.0242147353,
0.0241314787,
0.0350475684,
-0.0070801461,
-0.0520258397,
0.041546762,
-0.0862909183,
-0.028012231,
-0.037539117,
-0.0363486521,
-0.0100798598,
0.041973155,
-0.0157488026,
-0.0366017297,
0.0332609676,
-0.0415291041,
0.0475373827,
-0.0649279281,
0.0055940519,
-0.0369917564,
0.0233235359,
0.0052565183,
0.0302158948,
-0.0012179817,
-0.0095380452,
-0.0636992827,
0.0033511925,
0.0262170043,
-0.0533172376,
0.0564014651,
-0.0650775731,
-0.0193824116,
0.0233916156,
0.0399080738,
-0.037196856,
0.0131513784,
-0.0092938887,
-0.0015866059,
0.0292030144,
0.0191444959,
-0.0003643501,
0.0254017115,
0.0350960642,
-0.0255335905,
-0.0273693558,
-0.0225823428,
0.0186680239,
0.0326434858,
0.0402005613,
0.005349597,
0.0355684422,
-0.0325833224,
0.0255605374,
0.0296437554,
0.0066345916,
0.050895825,
-0.0121296057,
-0.0042504361,
0.0020915908,
-0.0337779969,
-0.0200100876,
0.0674295574,
0.0754802078,
-0.0360546485,
-0.0262829382,
0.1017910838,
0.030635085,
0.0395400412,
0.0247768406,
0.0055567697,
0.0460824668,
-0.0005695426,
0.0022228663,
-0.01889617,
0.0011226757,
-0.0121861724,
0.0634646267,
-0.0449233092,
0.0022165643,
-0.023245478,
-0.0985563025,
0.0110862581,
0.0267778784,
-0.0441040657,
-0.0248639677,
-0.022524029,
-0.010614113,
-0.0103292288,
0.0302860904,
0.0271184333,
-0.0255748071,
0.0492548235,
0.061615739,
-0.1145997196,
-0.0645784438,
-0.0106176957,
-0.0202171709,
0.0305240136,
0.0459620021,
0.0215589441,
-0.0066011795,
-0.0220374055,
-0.0109992949,
-0.0192855336,
0.006304903,
0.0104144961,
0.0397995971,
0.0199283175,
0.0152819948,
-0.049331408,
-0.0075819399,
-0.0005547282,
-0.00574564,
-0.0056118923,
0.0092524467,
0.0169211384,
-0.0121805687,
-0.0384542234,
0.0498173386,
-0.0275227316,
0.0774075016,
0.0539782457,
-0.0307046529,
-0.0069032493,
-0.026877813,
0.0330144614,
-0.083499454,
-0.032741636,
0.0266551673,
-0.0383963287,
-0.0104682725,
-0.0857344642,
-0.0646465644,
-0.0127802296,
0.0054787206,
0.0103534376,
0.0006784119,
-0.0196271092,
0.0167654473,
-0.0100969551,
0.0243271794,
0.0173447169,
0.0168976057,
-0.0647746325,
0.0162354298,
0.0022184378,
-0.0232068859,
-0.0210481025,
0.0571812652,
-0.0739862993,
-0.0437707715,
-0.0204465669,
0.0311711244,
0.0226486493,
-0.0278854277,
0.0132506667,
-0.0334440432,
0.0290059317,
0.0276412182,
0.0040229834,
0.0388530567,
0.0023689021,
0.021352509,
-0.0133344429,
-0.0046287929,
-0.0524472408,
-0.0182110369,
-0.0264400225,
0.0653022677,
-0.0078366073,
-0.0473188944,
0.0151807722,
0.0682784244,
-0.0056948257,
-0.0700782463,
0.0091801183,
-0.0165349357,
-0.0788735822,
-0.0121679157,
-0.0273640491,
-0.0534960255,
-0.0025101562,
-0.0098427385,
0.0144598307,
-0.0244392417,
0.0079987319,
-0.0496396683,
0.0248847194,
-0.0059669856,
0.0353970118,
-0.0260660555,
0.0062148762,
-0.0241044499,
-0.0049665147,
-0.0452485867,
-0.0598814338,
-0.0426906943,
0.0130472612,
0.0249598175,
0.0445418619,
0.0053760884,
0.0327917449,
0.0383857004,
0.03704172,
-0.0172255244,
0.0260075107,
-0.0743067637,
0.0187781099,
0.0281372312,
0.0134848384,
0.0918895081,
-0.0282430537,
0.0291911121,
-0.0153488666,
0.0469263941,
-0.0133990943,
-0.0451147035,
-0.0081126522,
0.0014234287,
0.0013346588,
-0.0393352993,
0.0712935552,
-0.0217254218,
-0.0143673914,
-0.03540558,
-0.0266662724,
-0.0432236195,
-0.0188020449,
-0.0176813491,
-0.0051411381,
0.0122364368,
-0.0066559273,
-0.0776108801,
-0.0545255989,
0.0078196991,
0.0636048093,
0.0614398308,
-0.0202187877,
0.0463090837,
0.0590932854,
-0.0375835411,
0.0103012826,
-0.0397382006,
-0.0385231301,
-0.0166031495,
0.0447512604,
-0.0275373328,
-5.710451272e-33,
-0.048297558,
-0.0739248097,
0.026293952,
-0.010009001,
-0.0340917036,
-0.0168192815,
-0.0293961763,
0.0563245341,
0.0263539255,
0.0004251318,
0.0372557379,
-0.0307332892,
-0.0080276644,
0.0220830794,
0.0072126775,
-0.0013281397,
0.0220267419,
-0.0102684358,
-0.0668000579,
-0.0135754887,
0.0054309457,
-0.032568913,
0.0513521321,
-0.0423423238,
0.0712293312,
-0.0079262741,
-0.0550930165,
-0.0302843507,
0.0262139868,
0.0396814123,
0.0131638097,
0.0500305556,
0.0247003064,
-0.0488088951,
-0.0275297165,
-0.0087689627,
-0.0106857093,
-0.070388034,
0.0335732363,
-0.0058704945,
-0.0381837673,
-0.0385019518,
0.0552132092,
-0.0095538357,
-0.0738402605,
-0.0036989087,
0.0384045914,
-0.0311674252,
-0.0118105393,
-0.0564520061,
-0.0178889409,
0.0388745591,
-0.0321889743,
-0.0187131967,
-0.0075639039,
0.0548990071,
-0.0375232957,
-0.0307211261,
-0.0141114546,
0.0368080214,
0.0420383587,
0.0349049829,
0.0815059692,
0.0346708782,
-0.0299596395,
0.0635977983,
-0.005222125,
0.0073948135,
-0.0120659769,
-0.0052681873,
0.0161078963,
0.0027323689,
0.0586645938,
0.0498578921,
0.0195004568,
0.0205349345,
-0.0519536734,
0.0674677044,
-0.0155118508,
0.0187118463,
0.0045424192,
-0.0478534885,
-0.0550763495,
-0.0394226126,
-0.0676507056,
-0.0274522435,
-0.002701171,
-0.0397493094,
0.038393911,
-0.0171620995,
-0.0280784369,
-0.0660336614,
-0.0083195744,
-0.0021204546,
0.0178100206,
-0.0074382992,
-0.037725091,
0.0216529705,
-0.018912524,
-0.0143293506,
-0.0279270597,
0.0283875894,
0.0032223,
0.0470875986,
0.0361218452,
-0.0210458692,
0.0108933263,
-0.0063676569,
-0.0174023304,
0.0156962518,
-0.0043360284,
0.0172614511,
0.0162688158,
-0.0592133179,
-0.0090760225,
-0.0228827037,
-0.0373501293,
0.036294762,
-0.0161991827,
-0.0149394674,
0.0126818893,
0.0066686268,
0.0083419438,
0.0173781887,
-0.0304865465,
0.0062790657,
-0.0147861717,
0.0289053358,
0.0398132019,
-0.0114707444,
-0.027547881,
-0.0013914133,
2.657e-7,
0.055158034,
0.0549644157,
0.0169343892,
0.0266852155,
-0.0398158059,
0.0059191496,
-0.004223635,
-0.0064180898,
0.0236862041,
-0.0120222708,
0.0101339715,
-0.0154135954,
0.0340458043,
0.011366779,
-0.041576799,
-0.0140367085,
-0.0602530017,
0.0339864604,
0.0023718718,
0.0104890298,
0.1032975689,
-0.016508555,
-0.0375261195,
0.008857321,
-0.0323620923,
-0.0542886667,
0.033722613,
-0.0239420719,
-0.0202664398,
0.0515970699,
0.1110102683,
0.0323898755,
0.0273149498,
0.0164827239,
-0.0138395345,
-0.0242267102,
0.0689029321,
0.0075900946,
0.0506407097,
-0.0185883213,
0.0199366603,
-0.0006352882,
0.0127223702,
-0.0363736674,
0.0188205056,
-0.0454794466,
-0.0124866683,
-0.0052193208,
-0.0371173546,
0.0110566365,
0.0049757645,
-0.0223696642,
-0.0393517874,
0.0180559177,
0.0064586303,
0.0097787371,
0.0046976907,
-0.0027111659,
-0.05751222,
0.004435394,
0.010759145,
-0.059166573,
-0.0218806695,
0.0114089679,
-0.0328746513,
-0.0505311415,
-0.0053180768,
2.311612855e-34,
0.0524017774,
-0.0351199582,
0.0210136902,
-0.0408268608,
0.059750367,
0.0061718402,
-0.0193527173,
-0.0138113406,
0.0165200904,
-0.0502233692,
-0.0063320328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14888v1 | Privacy Implications of Retrieval-Based Language Models | 2023-05-24T08:37:27 | 2023-05-24T08:37:27 | Yangsibo Huang, Samyak Gupta, Zexuan Zhong, Kai Li, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Retrieval-based language models (LMs) have demonstrated improved
interpretability, factuality, and adaptability compared to their parametric
counterparts, by incorporating retrieved text from external datastores. While
it is well known that parametric models are prone to leaking private data, it
remains unclear how the addition of a retrieval datastore impacts model
privacy. In this work, we present the first study of privacy risks in
retrieval-based LMs, particularly $k$NN-LMs. Our goal is to explore the optimal
design and training procedure in domains where privacy is of concern, aiming to
strike a balance between utility and privacy. Crucially, we find that $k$NN-LMs
are more susceptible to leaking private information from their private
datastore than parametric models. We further explore mitigations of privacy
risks. When privacy information is targeted and readily detected in the text,
we find that a simple sanitization step would completely eliminate the risks,
while decoupling query and key encoders achieves an even better utility-privacy
trade-off. Otherwise, we consider strategies of mixing public and private data
in both datastore and encoder training. While these methods offer modest
improvements, they leave considerable room for future work. Together, our
findings provide insights for practitioners to better understand and mitigate
privacy risks in retrieval-based LMs. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/Princeton-SysML/kNNLM_privacy . | [
0.0605744496,
0.1129736304,
-0.0289900713,
0.0598827489,
-0.0466909893,
-0.0330444984,
0.0375626236,
0.0009136571,
0.0142150512,
-0.0055068117,
-0.0579667054,
-0.039349664,
-0.0160550401,
0.0141396923,
0.0067094164,
0.0278662778,
0.0234203916,
-0.0275723543,
0.0107226819,
-0.0200666394,
-0.0445534959,
0.0060518868,
0.0469201542,
0.0155465622,
0.0244666636,
-0.0010401554,
-0.02125917,
-0.0026905786,
-0.0026898975,
-0.0024448656,
0.0156713482,
0.0576085262,
0.037601009,
0.0616813041,
0.0000016868,
-0.0080492208,
-0.0543963388,
0.0510478392,
-0.0413715914,
0.0268594213,
0.0448420271,
-0.0493018851,
0.0422696397,
0.0106917024,
-0.0269907936,
0.0040310351,
0.0144332172,
0.0205129664,
0.0603274368,
0.0745802522,
-0.0012240515,
-0.0123419976,
-0.0021706531,
-0.0513805747,
-0.010866452,
-0.0507042594,
0.0237516481,
-0.0708138123,
-0.0462809429,
0.0643803924,
0.0175487734,
0.0646683201,
0.0116229178,
0.0423733704,
0.0028883477,
0.0032040279,
0.0067909234,
-0.0311501808,
0.0113239978,
0.0182494912,
0.0538763739,
-0.0085074883,
0.0341507383,
0.0298771262,
0.0377381109,
0.0291713085,
-0.0060882759,
0.0648767948,
-0.0056328294,
0.0188152026,
0.0065642884,
-0.0080046626,
0.0398761258,
0.0266863983,
0.0386962369,
0.0599500723,
0.0022670263,
-0.0191957783,
-0.0384701565,
-0.0283363871,
0.0114358524,
-0.0336663984,
0.0632526204,
-0.0101097235,
0.0676785782,
0.0303505305,
-0.044502411,
-0.0390987545,
0.0166074615,
-0.0439910032,
-0.0213476438,
-0.0068563628,
0.0177474413,
0.0160355121,
0.0253179614,
0.0599754043,
-0.0029170923,
0.0541848242,
0.0117362542,
0.0066242451,
0.0087084556,
-0.0325524062,
-0.0045062038,
0.0504876077,
-0.0439206474,
0.0241209939,
-0.0139810406,
0.0233026445,
-0.0158570427,
-0.0004935928,
-0.0117491009,
0.0131528853,
-0.0399465263,
-0.0108017959,
-0.0169196483,
-0.0635888726,
0.0168742798,
0.0114098005,
0.0116942413,
-0.0633390546,
-0.0283673834,
-0.0446253568,
0.0003828949,
-0.0269828402,
-0.0436739661,
0.0464183055,
0.0231229831,
-0.0450488441,
-0.0176569298,
-0.1015830636,
0.0136468895,
-0.0101732938,
0.0093783168,
-0.0195702221,
0.0283154622,
-0.0228839796,
-0.0182608627,
-0.0889847651,
-0.0187638458,
0.0408987626,
-0.0491192341,
0.0317992009,
0.0226030387,
0.0001431189,
-0.0134127401,
0.0471429192,
0.0071082404,
0.0398339406,
0.0304632094,
0.0339283124,
0.0806944296,
-0.013703404,
0.0404056758,
-0.0041671088,
0.0666551888,
0.0098609217,
-0.0264542587,
0.0356946252,
-0.0102072153,
-0.0493571647,
-0.02813676,
0.0711097866,
-0.0049321479,
-0.0776457042,
0.0467417873,
0.0727967545,
0.0213503707,
0.0043643536,
-0.0565396324,
0.0335437059,
-0.0301011167,
-0.0054834238,
-0.0452586636,
-0.009812043,
-0.0644694194,
-0.0440940149,
0.0101896264,
0.0048536216,
-0.0025378838,
0.0013576882,
0.0179842226,
-0.0565297976,
0.0440353081,
0.0276317727,
0.0036736501,
0.0030623616,
0.0163644329,
0.0598135702,
-0.0179755539,
-0.0608449094,
0.0267343633,
-0.0457367674,
0.0061935014,
0.062245179,
0.0668476745,
0.0211245343,
0.0415022597,
-0.0291883219,
-0.0572855994,
-0.0011264619,
-0.0062368331,
-0.0038719722,
0.0898639634,
-0.0483386256,
-0.0540897772,
-0.0157764349,
0.0421432294,
-0.0304805525,
0.0141361719,
0.0012291395,
0.0538123064,
-0.0503171422,
0.0070944899,
0.0197786726,
-0.0195027385,
-0.0366337784,
0.0014362084,
0.0120543158,
0.0232568439,
0.0293454546,
0.0088023003,
0.0183825493,
0.0317602679,
0.0288006607,
-0.0064225034,
-0.0209371671,
-0.0112779737,
-0.0108003244,
-0.0564836822,
0.002288525,
0.0628141835,
0.0560035221,
-0.0046198722,
-0.0215030294,
0.0023218826,
-0.0137706753,
0.0430900306,
-0.0151654035,
0.0053932127,
-0.031029271,
0.0152233448,
-0.0359391905,
0.0141617619,
-0.0562484637,
0.0030635444,
-0.0640824884,
-0.0457324311,
0.0104765529,
-0.0497634485,
-0.0197399482,
0.0110775894,
-0.0204293318,
0.0292925667,
0.0365352184,
-0.0306965578,
-0.007345499,
-0.0144936331,
-0.004725249,
0.0160863679,
-0.0183015671,
0.0409051739,
-0.0235243216,
0.0150865307,
-0.0161459949,
-0.0320098512,
-0.0398370661,
-0.0332421921,
-0.0165156927,
0.0530987754,
0.0023830023,
0.0325437896,
-0.0239657164,
0.0027000185,
-0.0512081496,
0.0185750648,
0.0564243197,
-0.0586988591,
-0.0056232084,
0.0004159175,
0.0469733402,
-0.0280114822,
0.0207728241,
-0.0166473165,
-0.0139516946,
-0.0211455803,
-0.0126812086,
-0.0615456775,
0.0281344745,
0.0066418448,
0.0276821125,
0.0414835475,
-0.0070476569,
-0.0605632663,
-0.0256161913,
-0.0248467382,
-0.0443497859,
-0.0256632641,
-0.0064249947,
0.0627412125,
-0.0094468547,
0.0120345829,
-0.0620524064,
-0.0296622738,
0.0192316398,
-0.0037089121,
-0.0475431792,
-0.030423047,
-0.023011703,
0.0072232648,
0.072381489,
-0.0055906167,
-0.0563558154,
0.0785013735,
-0.0141581632,
0.0309335161,
-0.000352734,
-0.026075419,
-0.0061559454,
0.0415834822,
-0.0088102417,
0.0314445794,
0.0483928733,
-0.0563260168,
0.0003614684,
0.007054253,
0.049958799,
-0.0706911385,
0.0305990893,
0.0062721032,
-0.0254972894,
0.0265397951,
-0.0501623712,
-0.0420997478,
-0.0794982314,
0.0104190577,
-0.008629784,
-0.0126754846,
0.0018807795,
-0.0169134978,
-0.0168776866,
0.0327376463,
-0.0054880651,
-0.0076726694,
0.0234245434,
-0.019242445,
-0.0057055796,
-0.0189720821,
-0.0392218344,
-0.0236802474,
-0.0198590457,
-0.032918267,
0.0736006722,
0.0602069981,
0.0182677452,
0.0698139966,
-0.0278541204,
0.0535678267,
0.0048085866,
-0.0406026468,
0.0215786975,
0.0206728205,
-0.0633644909,
-0.0008952492,
0.059667673,
0.0055574821,
-0.0395014435,
-0.0280117989,
0.0223164391,
-0.0030084839,
-0.0209401939,
-0.0125340251,
-0.0923361555,
0.0202336665,
0.0342214108,
0.0774586052,
-0.0474425033,
-0.0421475209,
-0.0238605216,
-0.0872451514,
-0.023267081,
0.0095917759,
0.0167851914,
-0.0452548526,
-0.0593124889,
-0.0000986465,
-0.0278679859,
0.0050578718,
-0.0032339005,
0.014467489,
-0.0112734567,
-0.0005829146,
0.0296739805,
-0.0614324734,
-0.024252696,
-0.0370525159,
0.0013265711,
0.0588782132,
-0.006035021,
-0.0071737361,
-0.0525133833,
-0.0136580272,
0.040208783,
-0.0164066851,
0.0176615976,
0.0410439856,
-0.0262631532,
0.0188905112,
-0.0174015388,
0.0193095393,
-0.0004829766,
0.0058115018,
-0.0051033949,
0.0129807331,
-0.0253502261,
0.0003446598,
-0.0074790716,
-0.0361923054,
0.0239324886,
0.0713413879,
-0.0226116497,
0.0029181214,
0.0221919958,
-0.0397159979,
0.0582822897,
0.0128789041,
0.0094569018,
0.0248685312,
0.0129287411,
-0.045707047,
-0.0287087783,
0.0038617144,
-0.0550260022,
0.0034892946,
0.0284347478,
-0.0030426402,
0.0482036732,
-0.0141310766,
-0.0224414729,
0.0131605193,
-0.0797075853,
-0.0260841735,
-0.0121792676,
0.0325557925,
0.0329633504,
0.0270559397,
-0.0081242723,
-0.0112450402,
-0.0216397513,
-0.068990767,
-0.0038150144,
0.0248180553,
0.0213339962,
0.0352053903,
-0.0200227052,
-0.0705681816,
0.058724001,
0.0657033771,
-0.0742880628,
-0.0033780388,
0.0426327325,
-0.0398593396,
-0.0012609026,
0.0379700884,
-0.0604423136,
-0.0403447971,
0.0181083363,
-0.0205013119,
-0.0302306991,
-0.0485659018,
-0.0252263136,
0.0325182416,
0.0682461262,
0.0441163853,
0.021770183,
-0.0639604107,
0.0194760766,
-0.044153288,
0.0038513849,
-0.0235004164,
0.0166646428,
0.047918383,
0.0105647147,
0.026229836,
-0.0000828692,
0.0339981727,
0.0452932641,
-0.0546209104,
0.020793587,
0.034254171,
-0.003024234,
0.0142327258,
0.0108190654,
-0.0362700708,
0.0802901909,
0.0025866542,
0.0373347439,
-0.0290634409,
0.0114246802,
-0.016842369,
-0.0020709103,
0.0092757773,
0.0377469845,
-0.0688889772,
-0.0391148441,
-0.0270394608,
0.0048394441,
-0.0259511918,
0.0167923439,
0.0113274613,
-0.0253355596,
0.012596325,
-0.0402009711,
0.0167221427,
0.0080427313,
-0.0569960102,
0.0155074531,
0.0010431613,
-0.0220805909,
0.0515047126,
0.0768193975,
0.0202096961,
0.0220794547,
-0.0420594327,
-0.051271148,
-0.0223569404,
-0.0070284065,
0.0183151308,
0.0465440825,
-0.0134380292,
-0.0132322339,
-0.0240836162,
-0.0719819814,
-0.0139609203,
-0.0129938675,
0.0106954193,
-0.0219263267,
0.0069120973,
0.032574188,
0.0218501445,
-0.0460337996,
-0.0745422393,
-0.0109044164,
-0.0223381761,
-0.0236930102,
-0.0291959736,
-5.429676365e-33,
-0.0093380883,
0.0054287477,
-0.0514712185,
-0.0021278723,
0.0251688566,
0.0248919949,
0.0016910955,
-0.017156519,
-0.0440100543,
-0.0591349564,
-0.048071865,
0.0254261084,
0.0072561973,
0.038661588,
-0.0138197402,
-0.0221010912,
0.0436709933,
-0.0347286165,
-0.0227709599,
0.0280975569,
0.0586503968,
0.0291346516,
0.023127757,
-0.0707856417,
0.0772109851,
-0.0134259947,
-0.0396371856,
0.0440378934,
-0.0589085929,
0.0488836095,
-0.0052864505,
0.0129181985,
0.0151436292,
-0.0291141085,
0.0145942336,
0.0241989158,
-0.0454166196,
-0.0051450543,
-0.0187693834,
-0.0054292609,
0.0189979561,
-0.0921441242,
0.0595011041,
-0.0311169699,
-0.0110730557,
0.0097147925,
-0.0312396884,
-0.000086095,
-0.0229808856,
-0.035903126,
0.0624535233,
0.003646312,
-0.0091268066,
0.0068765129,
0.0831804946,
0.0465833806,
0.0361605547,
0.0110556101,
-0.0336499587,
0.012466724,
0.0280586667,
0.0027645407,
0.0551758669,
0.0074486267,
0.0468406007,
0.0221411549,
0.0203181058,
0.0086215204,
-0.0138260825,
-0.0178141426,
0.0157521702,
0.022399256,
0.0019242653,
0.0430861413,
0.014112018,
-0.0441827402,
-0.0288593248,
0.0053421119,
-0.0348162502,
0.0015660053,
0.0647092015,
0.0285012443,
-0.074346669,
-0.0288152266,
-0.0663866177,
-0.0307919681,
-0.0357704759,
0.0178205594,
0.0017526021,
0.0346136354,
-0.0439782776,
-0.0077989837,
0.0350639783,
-0.059963055,
-0.0303078704,
0.0749252588,
0.0540271252,
-0.023137534,
-0.0226761717,
0.0255497023,
-0.0270634945,
-0.0028656984,
0.0251828972,
-0.0323702581,
-0.002863904,
0.0149769271,
0.0234710835,
-0.0016029067,
-0.051397074,
-0.0361503251,
-0.0113933841,
0.0604245253,
0.0155271851,
0.0007615884,
0.0443675406,
0.0027313814,
0.0114690792,
0.0130776642,
0.023767719,
0.0482502729,
-0.0297410209,
0.0153775429,
-0.0006837206,
-0.0187571365,
0.032975059,
-0.014655578,
0.0247667506,
0.0081891688,
0.1003004685,
0.0346210636,
0.0148565173,
-0.0097207353,
2.463e-7,
0.0210083053,
-0.0209256914,
0.0047140634,
-0.0013767983,
0.006035991,
0.0693475977,
0.0209267493,
0.0705793127,
0.0102770459,
-0.0091504846,
-0.0367071256,
0.0033805936,
0.061137259,
0.0407819264,
-0.0575060546,
-0.0255556274,
-0.0187014677,
-0.0001480087,
-0.0138226217,
-0.0035628995,
0.0377769731,
0.0682688206,
0.0184552763,
0.0013319494,
-0.0455386005,
-0.0575685985,
0.0442526937,
-0.0585753694,
-0.0352765359,
-0.0118893599,
0.0659543797,
0.1123523712,
0.0303499829,
-0.0276303422,
-0.0128199141,
0.0476570353,
-0.0603651516,
0.1048737764,
0.0467451327,
-0.0562529899,
0.0143390875,
-0.0421925299,
-0.0411641151,
-0.0298848413,
0.0596489124,
0.0066594332,
-0.0538463406,
0.0013564578,
0.0435345285,
-0.0538695753,
0.0080276793,
-0.0170923863,
-0.0117193973,
-0.0041103815,
0.0001335954,
0.0150727918,
0.02742384,
-0.0671050549,
-0.0275327135,
-0.0476640314,
-0.0140299518,
-0.0054254634,
0.0129587101,
0.0213489085,
-0.0516154468,
-0.0051937499,
0.0721730292,
2.148675104e-34,
-0.0144197289,
-0.0220108274,
-0.0020361852,
0.0203812607,
0.0428904071,
-0.0113081383,
0.0317884833,
0.0023447932,
0.0139598986,
-0.0841818154,
-0.0295190997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14882v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14882v2 | Dynamic Clue Bottlenecks: Towards Interpretable-by-Design Visual Question Answering | 2023-05-24T08:33:15 | 2024-04-13T17:13:55 | Xingyu Fu, Ben Zhou, Sihao Chen, Mark Yatskar, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Recent advances in multimodal large language models (LLMs) have shown extreme
effectiveness in visual question answering (VQA). However, the design nature of
these end-to-end models prevents them from being interpretable to humans,
undermining trust and applicability in critical domains. While post-hoc
rationales offer certain insight into understanding model behavior, these
explanations are not guaranteed to be faithful to the model. In this paper, we
address these shortcomings by introducing an interpretable by design model that
factors model decisions into intermediate human-legible explanations, and
allows people to easily understand why a model fails or succeeds. We propose
the Dynamic Clue Bottleneck Model ( (DCLUB), a method that is designed towards
an inherently interpretable VQA system. DCLUB provides an explainable
intermediate space before the VQA decision and is faithful from the beginning,
while maintaining comparable performance to black-box systems. Given a
question, DCLUB first returns a set of visual clues: natural language
statements of visually salient evidence from the image, and then generates the
output based solely on the visual clues. To supervise and evaluate the
generation of VQA explanations within DCLUB, we collect a dataset of 1.7k
reasoning-focused questions with visual clues. Evaluations show that our
inherently interpretable system can improve 4.64% over a comparable black-box
system in reasoning-focused questions while preserving 99.43% of performance on
VQA-v2. | [
0.0251184143,
0.0407036059,
-0.014843679,
0.0491372608,
-0.0121898074,
0.0079099936,
0.020438049,
0.0201751702,
0.0077024279,
-0.0247222967,
-0.0023635747,
0.0215765424,
-0.020703759,
0.0532395318,
0.0500969216,
-0.0934624523,
0.0212335195,
-0.0557608493,
0.011904194,
-0.0046591409,
0.0349223129,
-0.0031368022,
-0.0096242819,
0.0501853488,
-0.0111361025,
-0.0694323257,
-0.0343443975,
0.0139541114,
0.0031111359,
-0.0330728255,
-0.056422025,
0.0244996622,
0.0617729276,
-0.0229610205,
0.0000021852,
-0.0034207976,
0.010601501,
-0.0004569242,
-0.0621597096,
0.0275451187,
-0.0302415285,
-0.0265909042,
0.0434523784,
-0.0119252242,
-0.0207333285,
-0.0158475712,
0.0626462325,
0.0271080546,
0.0964424461,
-0.0004615138,
-0.0023844275,
0.0065244432,
-0.0116248094,
0.0053224857,
0.0162422676,
-0.0731719956,
-0.0175162703,
0.0808137357,
0.0217490587,
0.0044952864,
-0.0730601177,
0.0427585542,
0.0446567424,
-0.0246085078,
0.0123316506,
0.028255526,
0.0205747951,
-0.0422764458,
-0.0047222176,
0.1029696688,
0.0039956849,
0.0041855192,
-0.0036055439,
-0.0018341978,
0.0143355615,
0.0667971447,
-0.0832691267,
0.022565363,
-0.0224448461,
-0.0378310271,
-0.0355207175,
0.009851452,
0.0288032312,
0.0163197014,
0.0156742763,
-0.0019282469,
-0.0071123191,
0.0185819417,
-0.0508170538,
0.0046015922,
-0.0596977212,
-0.0602631196,
-0.019618772,
0.0684536323,
-0.0196898133,
0.0128666516,
0.0050368193,
0.0236982144,
-0.0106724976,
-0.0248960797,
0.0629099458,
0.0148098245,
-0.0467592739,
0.0752804205,
0.0186618939,
0.0591521338,
-0.0412086323,
0.0213669762,
-0.0138692865,
-0.0045994367,
-0.0321981497,
-0.0309565552,
-0.0337219611,
-0.0213075224,
-0.0694932118,
-0.0554812141,
-0.0000221492,
0.0261925813,
-0.0282044429,
-0.0130021349,
0.0110750739,
0.0262456182,
-0.011760368,
-0.0129796322,
-0.0533140786,
0.0430169068,
-0.0692469478,
-0.0002320062,
0.0070511606,
-0.0342174917,
-0.0113623515,
0.0317877382,
-0.0051058899,
-0.0183066055,
-0.0072537642,
0.0678033009,
-0.0164634082,
0.0043543945,
-0.0086303353,
-0.0572905876,
-0.0078177908,
-0.0291450527,
0.01513521,
-0.0231626779,
0.0029747291,
-0.0066683278,
-0.0021376524,
-0.0171692353,
-0.0152391111,
0.0141717345,
-0.0234671198,
0.0979939327,
-0.0321686231,
0.0041139321,
0.0124053191,
0.0389164165,
-0.0395958275,
0.0543060005,
0.016955683,
0.0526192747,
0.0732787177,
-0.0415523872,
0.0346373022,
0.0259105582,
0.0176426116,
-0.00052166,
-0.0417125374,
0.0267716628,
-0.0146458093,
0.0323245861,
0.0447953455,
0.006153408,
-0.0480540134,
-0.0074770339,
0.0596819147,
0.0204840098,
0.0181993004,
-0.0128212189,
0.0252544191,
0.0024852189,
0.0138248634,
0.0042758849,
-0.0509240851,
0.078178972,
-0.0018760709,
0.0108690755,
-0.0015347559,
0.0334278084,
-0.014847572,
-0.0397142656,
0.0040678969,
0.0181620475,
0.0033877329,
0.044813931,
0.0474073812,
0.0265223365,
-0.0376074947,
0.0091951378,
-0.0061635068,
-0.0116178077,
-0.0086220484,
-0.0466377474,
0.0947443098,
0.0874729306,
0.0757809058,
0.0222055092,
-0.0119946916,
0.0213304479,
0.0657800585,
0.0211136602,
-0.0240484364,
0.0034136639,
0.0281674322,
-0.0524846986,
-0.052175872,
-0.0205947347,
-0.0042921775,
0.0072400821,
0.0128555112,
-0.0297614504,
-0.0274152849,
-0.0370869227,
0.0194147918,
0.0046082297,
0.0360327587,
-0.0120877875,
-0.0540577285,
0.0086186295,
-0.0103558116,
0.0038974169,
0.0086431177,
0.0023156977,
0.0126567874,
-0.030409459,
0.0116605423,
0.0299892183,
-0.0425675325,
-0.0310721006,
0.010617842,
-0.0539163463,
-0.0170974787,
0.0212256387,
-0.0442198962,
-0.0113219749,
0.0270706248,
-0.0356834307,
-0.017311383,
-0.0363143124,
-0.0347275548,
0.03696559,
0.0148979053,
-0.041859109,
0.0604393892,
-0.0306235906,
-0.0457143672,
-0.0067945193,
0.0222408455,
0.0098847384,
-0.0370164551,
0.0445484407,
0.0403640829,
0.0167107861,
0.0037675193,
-0.0155616608,
0.0080412365,
-0.0407275446,
0.0211444292,
-0.0418077111,
-0.0294807833,
0.0017320784,
-0.0190731622,
0.0040919967,
-0.003390017,
0.0101128537,
-0.0327777416,
-0.0181361232,
0.0409949385,
0.0079202922,
0.0047782394,
0.0318338946,
0.0163073819,
-0.0162928738,
-0.0161492825,
-0.0263980906,
0.0325272866,
0.0916477889,
0.0142853903,
0.0348277949,
-0.0611773171,
-0.0131687745,
-0.0121825971,
0.0127533469,
-0.0063056056,
-0.0285340659,
0.0314331986,
-0.0291760154,
0.0009395492,
0.0678386167,
-0.0151800402,
0.0434878059,
-0.0112369312,
-0.0218038335,
-0.0719572455,
-0.0044273436,
0.0196699016,
-0.0140549475,
0.0023304627,
-0.0472081304,
-0.0323185325,
0.0556054115,
-0.0289105754,
0.0117921652,
-0.0567937344,
0.0674097836,
0.0334230699,
-0.0406659618,
-0.0931567177,
-0.0392650999,
0.0300581884,
0.068154946,
-0.037181735,
-0.0663885102,
0.0492638536,
-0.0222347509,
-0.005567837,
0.0512629896,
0.002336303,
-0.0319682322,
0.0945745036,
-0.0036147535,
-0.0016977778,
0.001495586,
0.0126311593,
-0.0371072553,
-0.0366774648,
0.0407225564,
-0.0043582083,
0.0445962846,
-0.0761965141,
-0.0279532317,
-0.0030711938,
-0.0169239566,
-0.0236241948,
-0.030057339,
-0.0646221116,
-0.0292764828,
-0.0096866759,
-0.0244993288,
0.0102247735,
0.034584552,
0.0286728162,
-0.0400278121,
-0.0092244791,
-0.0080656465,
-0.021883022,
0.0353667103,
0.0752302483,
0.0651190728,
0.0092122573,
-0.0487554893,
0.0327107832,
0.0716538206,
0.0122591238,
-0.0241303016,
-0.0612396598,
0.0244462732,
0.0095207132,
0.0395720527,
-0.0258275662,
0.0166731868,
0.0662333295,
-0.0788752511,
-0.0024416675,
0.0739828274,
-0.0061782571,
-0.0158390179,
-0.0011795021,
-0.0180962887,
0.0499460101,
0.0073584048,
0.0329166539,
-0.0626712814,
-0.0745876804,
-0.0109571451,
0.0390511751,
0.0033857611,
0.0090905391,
-0.0046128412,
-0.0786164626,
0.0513126925,
-0.0103769321,
-0.0024661561,
-0.0045246636,
-0.0174996089,
-0.0529975072,
-0.0231026113,
-0.0042088777,
0.0224646647,
0.0099681299,
0.0262942817,
0.0086220186,
-0.003817328,
0.0014686362,
0.047946956,
-0.0394043252,
-0.0091182571,
0.0488750003,
0.0026416541,
0.0063871639,
-0.0680385157,
0.0329562537,
-0.0059534321,
0.039912492,
-0.0147276707,
0.0532993488,
-0.0038173976,
-0.042169068,
-0.0438403524,
0.0252233874,
-0.0012045396,
-0.0345099233,
0.0106957247,
0.0735950172,
-0.0019468422,
0.0016186949,
-0.0429809727,
0.0275628027,
-0.0131311147,
0.059668839,
0.0559041947,
-0.0322943293,
-0.0544703193,
0.0052583981,
0.0035338076,
-0.0598675162,
-0.0245036706,
0.0168552604,
0.0155681428,
0.0083514452,
-0.0509221815,
-0.0230083913,
0.0234134756,
0.085931018,
-0.0371449217,
0.0030752998,
-0.0411527604,
0.0356682315,
-0.0275133643,
0.0929756165,
-0.0133582419,
0.0129899969,
-0.0403012559,
0.0051207757,
-0.0172409005,
-0.055894807,
-0.019273201,
0.0290824771,
-0.0276099704,
0.0103838677,
-0.0144115975,
0.0633974299,
0.0271585677,
0.0296870563,
0.0349952802,
-0.0926568806,
-0.0287106968,
-0.0119956387,
0.0336375423,
-0.0148978466,
0.002059147,
0.0023146812,
0.0094819758,
0.0092231864,
-0.033370629,
0.0022112015,
-0.0169958137,
0.0235317834,
-0.0521668978,
0.0037619623,
0.0121139819,
0.0230855383,
-0.0104608722,
-0.0297854599,
-0.0131081557,
0.0013676849,
0.013289771,
0.0046551623,
0.0160684418,
-0.072469309,
0.0382998623,
0.0051107337,
-0.052348651,
0.0167280044,
-0.0470571108,
-0.0039907112,
-0.0097741485,
-0.0548608117,
0.0230209846,
0.0310818702,
0.007376682,
-0.0151780872,
0.0106277047,
0.0100851832,
0.0110380314,
-0.0355175845,
0.0595977865,
0.0256552082,
0.1112642065,
0.045647908,
-0.0327469818,
-0.0346839651,
0.039426636,
-0.0282520354,
-0.0807491317,
0.0355795287,
0.0467606559,
0.0374050438,
0.0398894511,
0.0047549382,
0.0083361557,
-0.0274771154,
0.0187570639,
0.0291066337,
0.0267206375,
-0.0436666533,
0.071172297,
0.0542653836,
0.0034678665,
-0.0194519162,
0.0546441786,
0.0051713483,
0.009005487,
-0.0203448087,
-0.0142517118,
-0.030376045,
-0.0155278165,
0.0146146305,
0.0155240251,
0.0259414352,
0.0207071248,
-0.0723356679,
-0.0704011321,
-0.0034806367,
0.0460441001,
-0.0168230403,
-0.004989028,
0.0068553882,
0.0305783004,
0.0424062535,
-0.057056006,
-0.0112534799,
0.012677893,
-0.0235779993,
0.009733744,
0.0128417974,
-6.410271915e-33,
-0.0254704636,
-0.0643754974,
0.0426292568,
-0.0600917637,
-0.0061412039,
0.0211401768,
-0.0357953385,
-0.0119325751,
0.0059962249,
0.0274758227,
0.0101847844,
-0.0180322248,
-0.0006214933,
0.0350204818,
-0.0099685807,
-0.0360617302,
0.003953475,
0.0312050786,
-0.0309242923,
0.0234986637,
0.0394881368,
0.0001137522,
-0.0062297657,
-0.0292021595,
0.020845633,
0.0267672092,
-0.0292836763,
0.0312389005,
-0.0083028181,
0.0751677305,
-0.0350425877,
-0.0229052026,
0.0185541511,
-0.038148623,
-0.0204057172,
0.0355837904,
-0.0922534391,
-0.0037810523,
0.0522207767,
0.0212589242,
-0.111376211,
-0.0165685266,
0.0212483406,
-0.0021675529,
0.0158046167,
-0.0392499827,
0.0263302159,
-0.0287041161,
-0.0360742696,
0.0143756289,
-0.0053225202,
0.0315488577,
-0.0391472802,
-0.0494467467,
-0.0112268329,
0.0465246961,
-0.0006485823,
0.0424718,
-0.0288823079,
-0.008968587,
0.0256940853,
-0.026780976,
0.1074169204,
0.0295242704,
0.0183520969,
0.0383590423,
0.0442711748,
-0.039921023,
-0.0642690808,
-0.0030419859,
-0.0230697691,
0.0601222403,
0.0840851516,
0.0649793968,
0.0439300314,
0.0262095798,
-0.0588089786,
0.0240191109,
-0.0664824769,
0.0576620698,
0.0251437183,
0.0174442213,
-0.0463519506,
-0.0074468954,
-0.0457953662,
0.0026253439,
-0.0362412669,
-0.0093429079,
0.0628068522,
0.0118657714,
-0.0450355746,
0.0088757528,
0.0417477936,
-0.0432836115,
0.0373688191,
-0.0056878668,
-0.002850963,
0.0299592558,
0.0136146089,
0.0151323965,
0.0115932012,
0.0210038964,
0.0401429273,
-0.0006373778,
0.0176467132,
0.0247451365,
-0.0146404468,
0.0035554308,
-0.0007897148,
-0.0137006259,
-0.0537541136,
-0.000772903,
-0.03726146,
-0.0380058065,
0.0396870375,
-0.0174053498,
-0.063569814,
-0.0079768542,
0.0133946007,
0.0000989436,
0.0182665605,
-0.0105618853,
-0.0292971544,
0.0071281609,
-0.0201193839,
-0.0164878927,
-0.0142351408,
-0.0864692703,
-0.0030677016,
-0.0670586377,
-0.0069022332,
0.0553146973,
2.672e-7,
0.0191336647,
0.0092833322,
0.0056188158,
0.0237979591,
0.0298075974,
0.0481711142,
0.005136366,
-0.0175177902,
0.009950567,
-0.0554549284,
-0.0050547705,
0.0657237843,
0.0369269922,
-0.0069813249,
0.0263475664,
0.0050033508,
-0.0041590808,
0.0035260601,
-0.0536857434,
0.0065448917,
0.0621160008,
0.0318869762,
-0.0274237953,
-0.034728013,
0.0578630716,
-0.0571220629,
0.0481514931,
-0.034849301,
0.0023187452,
-0.0416367538,
0.035855636,
-0.0178801846,
0.0137898652,
0.0128234811,
0.0033096171,
-0.0513399877,
0.004014499,
0.0392416753,
-0.0131497774,
-0.0277678668,
-0.0572631136,
-0.0251004156,
0.0062291045,
-0.0534810722,
0.0747721866,
-0.0354997441,
-0.0544557534,
-0.0010034692,
-0.0266524553,
-0.0548074283,
-0.004331802,
-0.0097336704,
0.0039489279,
0.0274409484,
0.0012115247,
-0.0356910378,
-0.005404402,
-0.0483066142,
-0.0142402779,
-0.0206604246,
-0.0297880694,
-0.0038275979,
-0.0635203496,
-0.0153873013,
0.0291978642,
-0.0117217563,
-0.0741201639,
2.052939813e-34,
0.0327466168,
-0.0050810957,
0.0198902637,
0.0434267744,
0.0445469506,
-0.0013993325,
-0.0132977115,
-0.0234958343,
0.055669453,
-0.0681362376,
-0.0142975505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14879v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14879v2 | ByteSized32: A Corpus and Challenge Task for Generating Task-Specific World Models Expressed as Text Games | 2023-05-24T08:31:30 | 2023-10-23T18:10:31 | Ruoyao Wang, Graham Todd, Eric Yuan, Ziang Xiao, Marc-Alexandre Côté, Peter Jansen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we investigate the capacity of language models to generate
explicit, interpretable, and interactive world models of scientific and
common-sense reasoning tasks. We operationalize this as a task of generating
text games, expressed as hundreds of lines of Python code. To facilitate this
task, we introduce ByteSized32 (Code: github.com/cognitiveailab/BYTESIZED32), a
corpus of 32 reasoning-focused text games totaling 20k lines of Python code. We
empirically demonstrate that GPT-4 can use these games as templates for
single-shot in-context learning, successfully producing runnable games on
unseen topics in 28% of cases. When allowed to self-reflect on program errors,
game runnability substantially increases to 57%. While evaluating simulation
fidelity is labor-intensive, we introduce a suite of automated metrics to
assess game fidelity, technical validity, adherence to task specifications, and
winnability, showing a high degree of agreement with expert human ratings. We
pose this as a challenge task to spur further development at the juncture of
world modeling and code generation. | [
0.0093554705,
0.0170191173,
-0.0226460807,
0.049857609,
-0.0510069057,
0.0056124665,
0.0114163989,
0.0045838631,
0.0319446363,
-0.0140974345,
0.0013533019,
-0.0035933696,
0.0071307956,
0.0489020385,
0.0175863821,
-0.0628451109,
0.0219694842,
-0.072082229,
0.020579109,
-0.0016545295,
-0.0611102022,
-0.0065389904,
-0.0374660231,
0.0373411179,
0.051518295,
-0.0320484005,
-0.0334594436,
0.0192724876,
0.0300520379,
-0.0380699784,
-0.0026825804,
0.0303508826,
0.0639262497,
0.0153677454,
0.0000023099,
-0.0394369103,
0.0033044368,
-0.0054932479,
0.0202048887,
0.0093608266,
0.0458532348,
0.0250291545,
-0.001090489,
-0.020445846,
-0.0360901281,
0.003551146,
0.052191101,
-0.0289686788,
0.0968280286,
0.0402269401,
0.0079300199,
0.0002783081,
-0.0045741671,
0.0077023851,
0.0405489653,
-0.0375028327,
0.0018680539,
0.0744248852,
0.061980173,
0.0209089573,
0.0093120066,
0.018865956,
0.0411198772,
0.0169360377,
-0.0224909615,
0.0714188293,
-0.019294342,
0.0181492921,
-0.0056968373,
0.0488243476,
-0.0146153616,
-0.0556668229,
0.0144229662,
-0.0111487191,
-0.0032554215,
-0.0234205406,
-0.0596750453,
0.0714588985,
0.0056026434,
0.0195239205,
0.0028723825,
0.0075283539,
0.0337691307,
-0.029525483,
-0.0037817166,
0.068464838,
0.0116121173,
-0.0060850955,
-0.0383563712,
0.0287397671,
-0.0392023996,
-0.0650191233,
-0.0216744803,
0.0144481044,
-0.0362719335,
0.0048217112,
-0.0385899544,
0.0096626328,
-0.0034107983,
-0.0139468601,
0.0446724184,
0.0438896865,
0.0428942405,
0.0569378883,
0.0195328258,
0.0291836113,
-0.0202778,
-0.0003146605,
-0.0191025641,
-0.0059654643,
-0.0767863393,
-0.0126830405,
-0.0357128046,
0.0102337524,
-0.0155915003,
0.0104740988,
-0.0008631656,
0.0202931985,
-0.0314611048,
0.0472163223,
-0.0156023018,
0.0070350934,
-0.0333262458,
-0.0043483381,
-0.0299143605,
-0.0324036218,
-0.0470503308,
-0.0050123171,
0.0079664066,
-0.0122390781,
-0.0369384401,
-0.0009199828,
-0.0149232727,
-0.0336227864,
0.0230677444,
0.0715626776,
0.0312398002,
-0.0007572972,
-0.0095411437,
-0.0306357872,
-0.0015181047,
-0.0717507079,
0.0124708582,
-0.0927946344,
0.0001376264,
0.0025000614,
0.0163654275,
-0.0246864017,
-0.0003245871,
0.0114847496,
0.0034992821,
0.0980819389,
-0.0101064593,
-0.0119427945,
0.0249338765,
0.0295945127,
-0.0087388996,
0.0975074843,
0.0709788799,
0.0129853459,
0.0152492458,
-0.025599923,
0.0205929354,
0.0329565592,
0.0240028631,
0.030245373,
0.0079740314,
0.0008637169,
0.0160405617,
0.0696978867,
-0.0262517128,
0.0039967648,
-0.0469040833,
0.0169752054,
0.0310640987,
0.0702711642,
-0.0093002683,
0.0028842853,
0.0728537366,
-0.0014879545,
-0.0026088608,
-0.000524541,
-0.0548452623,
0.0585181303,
-0.0194916986,
0.0047472282,
-0.0075818165,
0.0282793082,
0.0059842444,
-0.0478402264,
-0.0041223983,
0.0069732824,
0.0336913466,
-0.0115101151,
0.0537124239,
-0.0196213406,
-0.0501989871,
0.0215308852,
0.0161531977,
-0.0668588802,
-0.0052833827,
-0.045961529,
0.0382755399,
0.0452967323,
0.0682737976,
-0.0677884147,
-0.0481812805,
-0.0103213219,
0.0199705865,
0.0597484447,
0.0273763929,
0.0031854636,
0.0270446036,
-0.0283027925,
-0.02383429,
-0.0605475344,
-0.0017518757,
0.0259681251,
0.0364771821,
-0.0075439205,
0.0026138916,
-0.063633658,
0.0073884097,
0.0267938375,
-0.0480771549,
-0.0394866429,
-0.0307870861,
-0.0296528842,
0.0307087246,
-0.0159613919,
-0.0126101226,
0.015840875,
0.0349959359,
-0.0297171529,
0.005905909,
0.0129704913,
-0.0365726054,
-0.0210723989,
0.0411901064,
-0.0634528175,
-0.0064545223,
0.0316095017,
-0.0238023531,
-0.0130300038,
0.0410565995,
-0.0114046549,
0.0257951841,
0.0125960214,
-0.007107472,
-0.0196629688,
-0.0374376476,
-0.0178897567,
0.0553075634,
0.0278253201,
0.0294554755,
0.0062750885,
-0.0002825916,
0.0347508974,
-0.0544096902,
0.0115575008,
-0.0129318396,
0.0012840132,
-0.0219669975,
0.044061143,
0.0160793923,
-0.0502343364,
-0.0284508821,
-0.0905484334,
0.0157634839,
-0.0043541226,
-0.0071900249,
0.042649243,
-0.0167374518,
-0.0210791118,
0.0192483328,
-0.0009174563,
-0.0044069905,
0.0069748755,
-0.0103967497,
0.0405312441,
-0.0069369744,
0.0065588756,
-0.0285761394,
-0.0135268699,
-0.0481342189,
0.0448904708,
0.0213065986,
0.0447470471,
-0.0891130343,
0.0209575016,
-0.0072630635,
0.0232958905,
-0.0207308177,
-0.0206846464,
0.0597868599,
-0.0477852076,
0.0609635524,
0.0605106056,
-0.0338513069,
0.0252633151,
0.0830567032,
-0.0536177531,
-0.030248113,
0.0325315818,
0.0094344262,
-0.0095493179,
-0.0075833141,
-0.0608004667,
0.0174493063,
0.0942906588,
-0.0116845025,
-0.0085045034,
-0.0734448507,
0.0794438124,
-0.0268967543,
-0.025111638,
-0.0382061265,
-0.0238818042,
0.0030783943,
0.031410709,
-0.0164665058,
-0.0176121145,
0.0853125826,
-0.0184943229,
0.0074138138,
-0.0588908195,
0.009858246,
-0.0125879226,
0.0893860683,
0.0267119668,
-0.0109493034,
0.0461519323,
0.0025363853,
-0.0506205596,
-0.0072946823,
0.0468595028,
-0.0000442416,
0.0148926657,
-0.1019700319,
-0.0187865961,
-0.0041091153,
-0.0380611867,
-0.0006271748,
0.0289556831,
-0.0274819136,
0.0009714288,
0.0172659755,
-0.0313783512,
-0.0226399489,
-0.0013116434,
0.0578118972,
0.0211450942,
-0.0006473594,
-0.0204990041,
-0.0197381079,
0.0265933704,
0.0659993365,
0.0035749481,
-0.0232606437,
-0.0392959937,
-0.0074992883,
0.0498439632,
0.0160114374,
0.0010966423,
-0.0186944194,
0.0158914905,
0.0295530111,
-0.026338486,
-0.0304259993,
0.0510109439,
0.0676027611,
-0.0713888407,
-0.058238849,
0.0961001292,
0.0407829508,
0.0143535202,
0.0068388577,
-0.0418708362,
0.0186654478,
0.0188988503,
0.0217587221,
-0.0561179668,
-0.0364878662,
0.0059681842,
-0.0039736447,
0.0032887654,
-0.0554225445,
0.010394115,
-0.0874526724,
0.0514899157,
0.0209662132,
-0.0338863805,
-0.0110609373,
-0.0463472791,
-0.039013315,
-0.0382861942,
-0.0662821084,
0.0102957115,
0.0344674587,
0.0322981589,
-0.0125062205,
0.0037269746,
-0.0097172111,
0.0598195828,
0.0009305177,
0.042119354,
0.0572596863,
0.036099121,
-0.0312230177,
-0.0392747037,
-0.0067292689,
0.0073889773,
-0.0215471108,
0.0109334197,
0.0405639261,
0.0250433758,
-0.0036943369,
-0.003688673,
0.0217472259,
-0.0464111641,
-0.0655589104,
0.0207860842,
0.0946718156,
0.0153517593,
-0.0453022905,
-0.0401206277,
-0.0149298413,
0.040527042,
0.0848976895,
-0.0117389597,
-0.0277664382,
-0.0620214045,
-0.0571594983,
0.0058463421,
-0.0647705048,
-0.0502435565,
-0.0526782386,
0.0436821617,
0.0038703789,
-0.0462449491,
-0.0099188685,
0.0456486866,
0.0231402647,
-0.0169992354,
-0.0541327111,
0.0052126502,
0.0242367908,
-0.0781522319,
0.0128040407,
-0.0452834032,
0.0203973949,
-0.0275927726,
-0.0340868272,
0.0323053189,
-0.043937169,
-0.0232554935,
0.0713300258,
-0.0731081367,
-0.0342829674,
-0.0171398073,
0.0671407729,
0.0274918359,
0.0045504197,
-0.0088377493,
0.0243942812,
0.0131997177,
0.0180889908,
-0.032902766,
0.0319763869,
0.0159376841,
0.012573313,
0.0417531431,
-0.021774672,
-0.0240992885,
-0.0053131306,
-0.005650091,
0.0400351696,
0.0057841148,
0.0006666421,
0.0149614029,
0.0010621822,
0.0300032012,
-0.0240967441,
-0.0473669432,
-0.0146250585,
-0.0204492938,
-0.0363478623,
-0.031213332,
-0.0381090455,
0.0166638847,
-0.0102140773,
-0.0189280733,
0.0366854146,
0.0243571568,
-0.0285962354,
0.0136504266,
-0.012749237,
0.0049506202,
0.0403237566,
0.0267480891,
0.0557909347,
-0.016771039,
-0.0175406951,
-0.0383441709,
-0.0571663193,
0.0709005818,
-0.0276754592,
0.0270921495,
0.0404098667,
-0.0182197653,
0.0158037096,
0.041395355,
-0.060791336,
-0.0363043398,
-0.0153044192,
0.0492312536,
0.059929356,
0.018950738,
0.0150097413,
-0.0867908373,
0.0025909164,
0.0021170333,
0.0040824567,
0.0649299324,
-0.051058054,
0.0095335161,
0.0660310686,
-0.0031768174,
-0.0357173309,
0.0746922567,
0.020058047,
0.0471315831,
0.048297178,
0.0050736526,
-0.0561840273,
-0.0220780428,
-0.0124807348,
0.0548550114,
-0.0084435334,
0.0127608497,
-0.0628394559,
-0.0454670005,
-0.0041485848,
0.0865254849,
-0.0097916992,
0.0051674773,
0.0407776907,
0.0671534389,
-0.0285636205,
-0.0282478556,
-0.005674467,
0.053045813,
-0.0190454982,
-0.0392582342,
-0.019057367,
-6.227351035e-33,
-0.0313423537,
-0.0312776305,
0.0527431481,
-0.0303948876,
0.0082207033,
-0.0493740775,
-0.0771762654,
0.005661774,
-0.0077509112,
0.0096429503,
0.0195096731,
0.0062618754,
-0.0159052294,
-0.002357285,
0.0143642342,
0.0009541701,
0.0114494534,
0.0319106281,
-0.0767775625,
0.0366122983,
0.0373652764,
-0.0295386948,
0.0519769415,
-0.0353006981,
0.0111201927,
-0.013134947,
-0.0027694367,
-0.0085048201,
-0.0210187733,
0.0206830204,
-0.0394303799,
0.0152763091,
0.0088588884,
-0.0321894772,
0.0063435738,
-0.0057285703,
-0.0479368605,
-0.0530399233,
0.0157334041,
-0.0384577513,
-0.0406454802,
-0.0447858125,
0.0122508043,
0.013133971,
-0.0037813117,
-0.0417990983,
0.0451000929,
-0.0384447165,
-0.0130661381,
0.0145255821,
-0.0858623683,
-0.004531791,
-0.0386449993,
-0.0302353892,
-0.0058363234,
0.0057886536,
-0.0059443018,
0.0671987683,
-0.0293555465,
0.0618361011,
0.0533879511,
0.0060603842,
0.0564772449,
-0.0162686612,
0.0462030694,
0.0551641174,
0.0124956286,
-0.0024756766,
-0.0580224209,
-0.022683369,
0.03085679,
0.0179020762,
0.0371979997,
0.0710795447,
0.0298856646,
0.0213509668,
-0.0734737515,
0.022499999,
-0.0147455009,
0.0218251292,
0.0108910613,
0.0033352918,
-0.0217219684,
-0.0290041864,
-0.0347896181,
0.0248026978,
-0.0029605622,
-0.0148885623,
-0.0012236495,
-0.0544389933,
-0.037094377,
-0.0148408832,
0.002101843,
-0.0392965414,
0.0098929293,
0.0252778251,
-0.0132076675,
0.0229987726,
0.0031799972,
0.0067176051,
0.0017461436,
-0.0156046739,
0.0034861283,
0.0326831713,
0.0338423215,
0.0216774046,
-0.0350279622,
0.0446739309,
-0.0310437717,
-0.0138470558,
-0.0616200007,
0.0036006751,
0.0236268435,
0.0096345283,
0.0132110054,
-0.0194237065,
-0.0003357277,
-0.0028745257,
0.0204472542,
-0.0626977608,
0.0044106469,
0.0293943249,
-0.0381451286,
-0.0047997516,
0.0035294241,
-0.0327684022,
-0.0687416941,
0.0346099399,
0.0161093138,
-0.0288597532,
-0.0163053367,
0.0169349555,
2.978e-7,
0.0097189602,
0.0551770702,
-0.0027699654,
0.0172180161,
0.012926192,
0.063710548,
-0.0323844515,
-0.0038475955,
0.015902631,
-0.0384138115,
0.00296222,
0.0203373581,
0.0235771872,
0.0518653169,
-0.0970006436,
0.0353322923,
0.0116921812,
-0.020142151,
-0.0426739641,
0.0053580962,
0.0631329715,
0.001534564,
0.0407028645,
0.0250325091,
0.0401191637,
-0.0367212556,
0.0397273302,
-0.0680907369,
0.0457661748,
0.0338861793,
-0.0515688732,
-0.0085401628,
-0.0007216749,
0.0001727787,
-0.0105583891,
-0.034277156,
-0.0040507982,
0.0541081242,
0.0053612832,
0.008412011,
-0.0310779102,
-0.0603927374,
0.0249142088,
-0.1200925931,
0.0636691079,
-0.0647749007,
-0.0244296379,
0.009202349,
-0.0116645088,
-0.0182944983,
-0.0206162352,
-0.0153042777,
-0.0332691446,
-0.0305733997,
-0.0313720703,
0.039018508,
0.0081027336,
-0.0363603197,
-0.0273459405,
0.0210723858,
-0.0345394835,
-0.0530671217,
-0.0351559632,
-0.0147990929,
0.0326102227,
-0.0935730115,
-0.0023763005,
2.948084501e-34,
0.0248865243,
-0.0204247497,
0.0283828527,
-0.0252950191,
0.0238217805,
0.0161012337,
0.0064446633,
-0.0073036565,
0.0547950901,
-0.0074934349,
-0.0245609805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14878v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14878v2 | Leveraging GPT-4 for Automatic Translation Post-Editing | 2023-05-24T08:30:05 | 2023-10-23T23:18:18 | Vikas Raunak, Amr Sharaf, Yiren Wang, Hany Hassan Awadallah, Arul Menezes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Neural Machine Translation (NMT) represents the leading approach to
Machine Translation (MT), the outputs of NMT models still require translation
post-editing to rectify errors and enhance quality under critical settings. In
this work, we formalize the task of direct translation post-editing with Large
Language Models (LLMs) and explore the use of GPT-4 to automatically post-edit
NMT outputs across several language pairs. Our results demonstrate that GPT-4
is adept at translation post-editing, producing meaningful and trustworthy
edits to translations that help improve its general quality as well as remove
different classes of major errors in translations. In particular, human
evaluations on assessing edit trustworthiness show that GPT-4 exhibits a large
improvement over the prior state-of-the-art LLM. Notably, we improve upon
state-of-the-art performance on WMT-22 English-Chinese, English-German,
Chinese-English and German-English language pairs using GPT-4 based
post-editing, as evaluated by state-of-the-art MT quality metrics. However, we
also show that GPT-4 could produce hallucinated edits, thereby urging caution
in its use as an expert translation post-editor. | [
0.0620022938,
0.0629512891,
-0.001194007,
0.0302004647,
-0.0128358882,
-0.0089216223,
-0.0119716367,
0.0039297873,
-0.0103726666,
-0.0090833306,
-0.0531817824,
-0.0529397354,
0.0233728904,
-0.0025406466,
0.0497241691,
-0.0419470333,
0.0284638796,
0.0164296757,
-0.0313226171,
0.0150705874,
0.0098220864,
0.0291559231,
0.0524559356,
0.0459647849,
-0.0249207821,
-0.0334265344,
0.0088030649,
0.0478260554,
0.0581239685,
0.0011045105,
0.000158177,
0.0554456972,
-0.0062942132,
0.1171649843,
0.0000020777,
-0.0204047579,
-0.0420626029,
0.0316418298,
0.0275787525,
0.0388150923,
0.029423777,
-0.0507911704,
-0.0400325283,
0.0085294563,
-0.0217362233,
-0.0187652502,
0.060156215,
0.0400607139,
0.1095011532,
0.088067621,
-0.0171327796,
-0.0139125902,
0.0389925763,
-0.0633120835,
-0.0074641258,
-0.0463528857,
-0.0039677722,
-0.0193445347,
-0.069700323,
0.0276710801,
0.0336837918,
0.0367628485,
0.0455780625,
-0.0467075817,
-0.0285368077,
-0.0039062835,
-0.0209666397,
-0.015270032,
-0.0266553555,
0.0657097995,
-0.0321485139,
-0.0208370425,
-0.0353496261,
-0.0144495601,
0.0126208868,
-0.0163814425,
-0.0256153531,
0.0043304963,
-0.0015742622,
-0.0157390311,
-0.0104377139,
-0.0035795034,
0.0391291976,
0.0071857264,
0.0146099338,
0.0132740708,
0.0491016023,
-0.0281281434,
-0.016195422,
0.0190835148,
-0.0313281864,
-0.0538899638,
0.0481192544,
-0.0081262132,
0.0031661456,
0.0091139125,
-0.0325903259,
-0.0082338098,
0.0026092848,
-0.036916621,
0.0000033566,
0.0479432121,
-0.0187818501,
0.0334050916,
-0.0102263642,
0.0598282069,
-0.0253442656,
0.0105896359,
-0.0183190666,
-0.0028112505,
-0.0435043983,
0.0090517439,
-0.0446154475,
0.0067386813,
-0.0358461253,
0.024634948,
-0.0478896648,
0.0063949726,
-0.0164665394,
0.0311379749,
0.0424535982,
-0.0111011239,
-0.057971824,
-0.0594113581,
-0.0046417946,
0.0380975083,
0.0210085176,
-0.0080771092,
-0.006133866,
-0.03179501,
-0.0224020164,
-0.0083345296,
-0.0225178115,
-0.0438066274,
-0.0126324343,
0.0567496382,
-0.019167034,
-0.0130307022,
-0.0096260961,
-0.0269424245,
-0.0021884579,
-0.0490286574,
-0.0231770799,
-0.0430647768,
0.0469675697,
-0.0254246835,
0.0018966063,
-0.0822640508,
-0.0016442416,
-0.0011883788,
-0.0134505266,
0.0521044396,
-0.0358427279,
0.0104656564,
0.0228068568,
0.0160061102,
-0.0197697561,
-0.0033193033,
0.0652970001,
0.045045048,
0.0535153896,
0.0112631498,
0.0351607203,
0.0616460815,
-0.0062996219,
0.0345116779,
-0.0032416864,
0.0013105368,
-0.0029888342,
0.0196309667,
0.0317963324,
0.0852818787,
-0.0314907245,
0.0198264439,
0.1264508814,
0.0017054648,
-0.0100369779,
0.0616259314,
0.041180376,
-0.0128345741,
0.0057332409,
0.0089255339,
-0.0787407085,
0.0432978943,
-0.0180390067,
-0.0009367622,
0.03839444,
0.0209185611,
0.0068463371,
-0.0482842289,
0.0112349661,
-0.0185048059,
0.0333312154,
-0.0267572999,
-0.0014553693,
-0.0208654217,
-0.0615242384,
0.0130936056,
-0.0321445689,
-0.0548267588,
0.0167225115,
-0.0460044406,
-0.0207819156,
0.0729472861,
0.0657772943,
0.0105711101,
-0.0343273841,
-0.0411893912,
-0.0164726339,
0.0713152066,
0.0613954738,
-0.0016970534,
0.010191801,
-0.0317144804,
-0.0256988313,
-0.0073489384,
0.0202611424,
0.0214496031,
0.0354998372,
0.027866859,
0.0424094684,
-0.0162172839,
-0.0918835551,
-0.002205292,
0.0205055922,
-0.0239176806,
0.0096824346,
0.0046829665,
0.0078265071,
0.0236481465,
-0.0457054004,
0.0021264271,
-0.0111608468,
0.0089957919,
-0.0423242934,
0.0401518606,
-0.0147297764,
0.0165688489,
0.0302020237,
-0.0228039436,
-0.0476268455,
0.0342052281,
-0.0751057938,
-0.0366002806,
-0.0348344892,
-0.0210554171,
0.0117448159,
-0.0777258724,
0.0310944077,
-0.0066472255,
-0.0140192471,
-0.0041608652,
-0.0041779266,
-0.0079646343,
-0.0291269552,
-0.0185748078,
0.0072221188,
0.0203248709,
-0.0080806455,
-0.0365094021,
0.0438182168,
0.0401827693,
0.0534785949,
0.0416435562,
0.0470710397,
-0.0105230482,
-0.0323834755,
-0.0485249199,
0.0015111627,
-0.0376939848,
0.0239659622,
0.0646162704,
-0.0019764793,
-0.0118755819,
0.0096490262,
-0.0176690444,
0.0075137476,
-0.0037876999,
0.016132364,
0.0384170115,
-0.0090820929,
0.0385213941,
-0.0391072258,
0.0023068457,
-0.0009637148,
-0.0055232169,
0.0513359383,
-0.0351020023,
-0.0827538371,
0.0213537831,
-0.0455577038,
-0.0017536574,
0.0256472751,
-0.1078261435,
-0.0088075409,
-0.0199900735,
0.0370601974,
0.0380352363,
0.0025601857,
-0.0141241364,
0.03754244,
0.0063748504,
-0.014972074,
0.0047712694,
-0.0014392522,
-0.0507406965,
0.0057905321,
-0.034091197,
0.0357405581,
0.0374733843,
0.0205139834,
-0.0272978246,
-0.0649846047,
0.0305899549,
-0.0076670749,
-0.0159368534,
0.0240107104,
-0.0095772864,
-0.0182300787,
0.0489320345,
-0.0306133498,
-0.0620673485,
0.0834454149,
-0.0155649949,
0.0122490367,
-0.0409461781,
0.0310184471,
-0.0008279483,
0.0440165289,
-0.0047741663,
0.0323008001,
-0.0266695283,
-0.0119323535,
-0.0517708324,
-0.0045782989,
0.0084580593,
-0.0090111019,
0.0391696766,
-0.0760893673,
-0.012345151,
-0.0231387187,
-0.009958229,
0.0059686247,
-0.0113766212,
-0.020551119,
0.0116642704,
0.0302706622,
-0.0506786332,
0.0175924208,
0.0084777353,
0.0318200365,
0.0834340826,
-0.0232148338,
-0.0086826049,
-0.0054267445,
0.005492121,
0.0126975346,
-0.0061630299,
0.0191029143,
-0.0514488406,
0.0242934246,
0.0497961976,
-0.0179945882,
-0.0266052354,
-0.0406869613,
-0.0364801921,
0.0074172267,
-0.0326233096,
-0.0368588902,
-0.00495402,
0.0463562906,
-0.0707077459,
0.0229304768,
0.1215516999,
0.0321804844,
-0.0745469034,
-0.0286861174,
-0.0055343304,
-0.0032875002,
0.0109649776,
0.0347770452,
-0.0840717331,
-0.0176990665,
0.0175953917,
0.0153014874,
0.0161675755,
-0.0016785332,
-0.0146352807,
-0.0923567191,
0.0549100973,
0.0445725322,
-0.0480094403,
-0.0322677232,
0.0069141206,
0.0092265988,
-0.028389046,
0.0141497217,
-0.0128279291,
0.0260607153,
-0.0044145766,
-0.0325610712,
0.014241009,
-0.0436732695,
0.0370974876,
-0.0505377986,
0.0011004334,
0.0961528942,
0.0579956956,
-0.0099912696,
-0.0388905928,
0.0467441455,
0.025367748,
-0.0079717543,
0.0042916914,
0.044432193,
-0.0119774425,
0.0195172075,
0.0179982856,
-0.0079493439,
0.0360003598,
0.0175013151,
0.0320598222,
0.0719619691,
-0.0158535689,
-0.0001432573,
0.0268760584,
-0.022162633,
0.0034787911,
0.0337825008,
0.0361882076,
-0.0319051109,
-0.0130846426,
-0.0528245494,
0.0139248399,
-0.0558509864,
-0.0111909648,
-0.0073557091,
-0.0447337739,
-0.006192321,
-0.11582499,
-0.0704321191,
0.0005307473,
-0.0060124518,
0.0540160686,
-0.0216587037,
0.0252632573,
-0.0120538631,
-0.0010994565,
0.012221653,
-0.0201317966,
0.0137840202,
-0.0652814358,
0.0368737243,
0.0339084007,
-0.0465860441,
0.0112212924,
0.0364934206,
-0.0457556993,
-0.0660206676,
-0.0333456136,
0.0762234256,
0.0228666291,
0.0539626628,
-0.0361664742,
-0.0457396358,
-0.0088736145,
0.0116412155,
-0.0265825931,
-0.0159798879,
0.0404277481,
0.0207818244,
-0.0307192467,
0.0429891199,
-0.0163270608,
0.0004284312,
0.0077220164,
0.0308209863,
0.0100754565,
-0.0665613487,
0.0381564759,
0.0237754509,
0.0260404367,
-0.0034445226,
0.0354502127,
-0.0713729784,
0.0300936457,
-0.040150553,
-0.0072445441,
-0.0420622602,
0.0286214221,
0.0449954309,
-0.0086926008,
-0.0212041344,
0.0029783978,
-0.028021628,
-0.0162569117,
-0.0344505347,
-0.040220473,
-0.0346773863,
0.0190179348,
0.0036205717,
0.0099419216,
-0.0159347467,
0.0003036962,
-0.0119627649,
0.0099971564,
-0.0246079471,
0.0612298436,
0.015047445,
-0.0174808186,
0.016836239,
0.074189283,
-0.0671634972,
-0.0361155383,
-0.042921301,
0.0020318918,
0.0751591474,
0.0167959146,
0.0905037075,
-0.0472218208,
-0.044561971,
-0.0160062686,
0.0488782898,
0.0297583248,
0.0074576619,
-0.0158441029,
-0.0137124453,
0.0044561364,
0.0331568308,
0.0400135778,
-0.044156868,
0.0336203389,
0.0030162239,
-0.0576379597,
-0.0158604831,
-0.0157889389,
-0.0234955773,
-0.0333134644,
-0.0385224558,
-0.0427242965,
-0.0337174647,
-0.0558260716,
-0.0139692826,
0.0391367748,
-0.0125551596,
-0.0002636857,
-0.0117284115,
0.0763498321,
-0.0369568914,
0.016947154,
-0.0460275523,
-0.0086340625,
0.0255607534,
-0.0184111297,
-0.0441125371,
-6.00967593e-33,
0.0040445034,
-0.0223258715,
-0.0011220581,
-0.0068094162,
-0.0387279987,
-0.0256125815,
-0.0614032522,
-0.038398847,
0.0138113471,
0.0102246748,
-0.0396756195,
0.0252371505,
0.009153964,
-0.0258285739,
0.0273340512,
0.0430337563,
0.1031447574,
0.0043366398,
-0.0250559561,
0.0350451022,
0.005230417,
0.0070824097,
0.1142697632,
-0.0198822394,
0.0783559978,
0.0046901978,
-0.0391171649,
0.0206540059,
-0.0438929759,
0.0277573578,
0.0134011442,
-0.0033159447,
0.0114757987,
-0.0320779756,
-0.0201420058,
-0.0559288487,
-0.0330326147,
0.0071220142,
0.0018556701,
0.0054622064,
-0.0360131525,
-0.0576053225,
0.0391702317,
-0.0735919252,
-0.0201478731,
-0.0252107531,
-0.0018221756,
-0.0364681631,
0.0137654711,
-0.0067921192,
-0.0414015613,
0.0126525881,
0.0082126986,
-0.009190225,
-0.0076253829,
0.0293106586,
-0.0051446757,
0.0105025815,
-0.1202982068,
-0.0042272015,
0.0186752081,
0.0076555605,
0.0513311774,
-0.0533647016,
-0.0213414524,
-0.0072376686,
0.0253175329,
0.0091519244,
-0.0029600561,
0.0274476502,
-0.0072126719,
-0.0131590087,
0.065218322,
0.0901060775,
0.0253480226,
-0.0223195739,
-0.03108643,
0.0498296656,
-0.0756936073,
0.0326937027,
-0.0069857454,
0.0116875377,
0.0039934856,
0.0140981758,
-0.0313388295,
-0.0450579487,
-0.0313955247,
-0.0499289632,
-0.001315697,
0.0133273546,
-0.0095003685,
-0.0010256192,
0.0529966503,
-0.0285232216,
0.0478793085,
0.0029084675,
-0.0597811826,
0.0034199397,
-0.011390226,
0.0312604569,
0.016256433,
0.0367098711,
-0.0066526225,
0.031503588,
0.0129634049,
-0.0216215141,
0.0491411276,
0.0469522662,
-0.0456278771,
0.0439715646,
-0.0312451515,
0.0238884743,
0.0085644126,
-0.0156583562,
0.0076352372,
-0.0098783132,
-0.0021724233,
0.0003466597,
0.0400436446,
0.0174166057,
-0.0410869233,
0.0360369608,
0.0184856318,
0.0243449174,
-0.0217860043,
0.0365076251,
-0.0014232625,
0.0156030683,
0.0441037863,
-0.0372572094,
-0.0263595749,
-0.0227805823,
2.722e-7,
0.027701091,
0.0534571558,
0.0177233834,
0.0032557393,
0.0146541735,
0.0145054227,
-0.030208556,
0.0226998422,
0.0089518465,
0.0499308072,
0.0420475043,
0.0050708023,
0.0794350281,
0.0490603,
-0.0364010148,
-0.009890289,
-0.0568605475,
0.0187924001,
-0.0542542227,
-0.0220447108,
0.0384813882,
0.0509768687,
0.008937235,
-0.0085997088,
-0.018427711,
-0.0267677996,
0.0885509104,
0.0062830807,
-0.027455844,
0.0205998626,
0.0675386116,
0.0345499441,
-0.0228851289,
0.0005506538,
-0.0357910767,
-0.0214600582,
0.0251881536,
0.0785275698,
-0.0095025478,
0.0274836775,
-0.002094686,
-0.007713526,
0.0169515721,
-0.0725969374,
0.0410579257,
-0.0443621799,
0.0137251355,
0.0210122801,
-0.0307207908,
-0.0331764892,
0.0626078993,
-0.0713395104,
-0.014757813,
0.0351919755,
-0.0036510553,
0.0330842547,
0.0020834841,
-0.0158844087,
-0.0419059619,
-0.0139939524,
0.0233833846,
-0.0337598994,
-0.007011333,
-0.0243286267,
-0.0123753762,
-0.047720518,
0.0174823664,
2.112527504e-34,
0.0391903929,
-0.0288444739,
0.0328871757,
-0.0258615799,
0.0667767227,
0.0056878417,
-0.0227204245,
-0.0218868386,
-0.0071241264,
-0.0266246349,
-0.0602743998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14877v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14877v2 | Improving Probability-based Prompt Selection Through Unified Evaluation and Analysis | 2023-05-24T08:29:50 | 2024-03-08T18:51:03 | Sohee Yang, Jonghyeon Kim, Joel Jang, Seonghyeon Ye, Hyunji Lee, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous works in prompt engineering for large language models have
introduced different gradient-free probability-based prompt selection methods
that aim to choose the optimal prompt among the candidates for a given task but
have failed to provide a comprehensive and fair comparison between each other.
In this paper, we propose a unified framework to interpret and evaluate the
existing probability-based prompt selection methods by performing extensive
experiments on 13 common and diverse NLP tasks. We find that each of the
existing methods can be interpreted as some variant of the method that
maximizes mutual information between the input and the predicted output (MI).
Utilizing this finding, we develop several other combinatorial variants of MI
and increase the effectiveness of the oracle prompt selection method from
87.79% to 94.98%, measured as the ratio of the performance of the selected
prompt to that of the optimal oracle prompt. Furthermore, considering that all
the methods rely on the output probability distribution of the model that might
be biased, we propose a novel calibration method called Calibration by
Marginalization (CBM) that is orthogonal to the existing methods and helps
increase the prompt selection effectiveness of the best method to 96.85%,
achieving 99.44% of the oracle prompt F1 without calibration. | [
0.0496819168,
0.0099176802,
-0.0052910736,
-0.0008377492,
-0.0733567998,
-0.0121792853,
0.0519580208,
-0.0059080902,
0.0292290822,
-0.0444689021,
-0.0219930578,
-0.0288311727,
0.0275809448,
0.0084155696,
0.0156444237,
-0.0630990937,
0.0576691814,
-0.0203229859,
0.0154091287,
-0.0030151131,
-0.0159392543,
0.0025073357,
-0.0396156348,
0.053440325,
-0.0082274741,
-0.0226050504,
0.005201973,
0.0079927668,
0.0076232785,
-0.022805091,
-0.0129741132,
0.0591854006,
-0.0495396592,
0.0111493329,
0.0000022191,
-0.0580112189,
-0.0340232328,
-0.0174334589,
-0.0533059798,
-0.0206948556,
0.006179736,
0.0068020499,
0.0167183783,
0.0238218866,
-0.0119738057,
0.0123674273,
0.0447169095,
0.0321586691,
0.0109919496,
0.0480193086,
0.0154298432,
0.0414681174,
0.0158454701,
-0.003183123,
0.0076122354,
-0.0251190159,
0.0197617915,
-0.0565630011,
0.0001030159,
0.0321724303,
0.0062530856,
0.0105599053,
-0.0002996146,
-0.0339112729,
0.0292549171,
0.0211777296,
0.032014437,
-0.0510643944,
-0.0634704232,
0.0525730997,
-0.0027621137,
0.0095449565,
-0.0189564619,
-0.0571551621,
0.0314779989,
0.0245532952,
-0.0127897477,
0.0294850748,
-0.0118512707,
0.0046273465,
0.0245432053,
0.0406719409,
-0.0090669207,
-0.0071769268,
0.0093850149,
0.0933071524,
0.0259422213,
-0.0287265275,
0.0340056196,
0.0086134328,
-0.0195149053,
-0.0485726409,
0.0177367143,
0.0136396233,
-0.1042889208,
0.0050165276,
-0.0164417103,
-0.0216528699,
0.0150118647,
0.0253487956,
0.0645219609,
0.0528345108,
-0.0135620479,
0.0236618053,
0.0176008716,
0.0554617718,
0.0251361318,
0.0153486151,
-0.0261979643,
0.0352919698,
-0.0222258661,
0.000884958,
-0.0194376893,
0.0075857225,
-0.0326605588,
-0.0381943136,
-0.0268500298,
0.0307847448,
-0.0219245721,
0.0080798222,
0.0408056118,
0.0191056076,
-0.0347165428,
0.0098727988,
-0.0473057963,
0.0102015361,
-0.0526488684,
0.002982436,
0.024990404,
-0.0629891902,
-0.014524987,
0.0215711854,
-0.0069077713,
-0.0530647002,
-0.0304367989,
0.0409476943,
-0.0047596539,
-0.0531369373,
-0.0216376279,
-0.0410353802,
-0.0275577363,
-0.0252655447,
-0.0306937192,
-0.0256725103,
0.0412763953,
-0.0020968078,
0.0277331546,
-0.027443001,
-0.0113277165,
0.0263472684,
-0.0040083299,
0.0926959291,
-0.0191573109,
-0.0081691584,
0.0221003108,
-0.0300519262,
-0.0319656804,
0.0637464449,
-0.016302757,
0.0195475947,
0.0670244843,
0.0045139762,
0.0081491154,
0.0254229903,
-0.0101646921,
-0.0209049005,
0.0166600067,
0.009151441,
0.1013863534,
0.0486341678,
0.0306017343,
0.035125047,
-0.0052617565,
-0.0006337258,
0.04591332,
0.0200394243,
-0.0356496349,
-0.0607805103,
0.0532298759,
0.014951569,
0.0081183268,
0.0299787447,
-0.0325511098,
-0.0094374865,
-0.0426329821,
0.0060869162,
0.0492238104,
0.0211233143,
-0.0115466071,
-0.0177306179,
0.003122929,
0.0125920111,
-0.0425870717,
0.0362833627,
-0.0016315918,
0.0083971852,
-0.0431559421,
0.0407924168,
0.0175164193,
-0.0027296364,
0.0117433611,
-0.0353954695,
0.0349595509,
0.0286954455,
0.01856515,
-0.0459407978,
0.022371687,
-0.0301593877,
-0.0073515871,
0.035250891,
0.0683084577,
-0.023105504,
-0.011732812,
-0.0380914882,
-0.0398418531,
0.0136634419,
0.0117251687,
0.0460908934,
-0.0040284484,
-0.0204149745,
0.0015882172,
0.0114941485,
0.0235387031,
0.0547061786,
-0.0076760347,
-0.0510700606,
0.0470349416,
0.0282947272,
0.0342671238,
0.0250845291,
-0.002885856,
0.0315663815,
0.0037919683,
-0.0094710272,
0.00760011,
-0.041407641,
-0.0464833677,
-0.0457370654,
0.0355569981,
0.0090586683,
-0.0262378287,
0.0132367313,
-0.0378931277,
-0.0472197458,
-0.047548674,
-0.0248788521,
0.0094506955,
-0.0411762856,
0.0412903987,
-0.0000512409,
0.0054270695,
-0.0925820246,
0.0756191537,
0.0148954419,
0.0483107306,
0.071455054,
0.0462970249,
0.0215289015,
-0.0925605148,
-0.0419714637,
0.0081596831,
-0.0102392063,
-0.0186848473,
0.0674678013,
-0.0055611469,
-0.0458180718,
-0.0364490859,
-0.0909007043,
0.0162759684,
-0.0235321578,
0.0031693114,
0.0246224795,
0.0388800837,
-0.0244174451,
-0.0215186551,
-0.0226571634,
-0.0365791842,
-0.0287634227,
0.0493314117,
0.031233836,
0.0254065301,
-0.0106176771,
-0.0185951255,
-0.0192734227,
-0.0164859686,
0.0553843491,
0.0426965877,
-0.0092673805,
-0.0610613152,
0.0355923213,
0.028469786,
-0.0054584448,
0.0039292108,
0.0457882844,
-0.0031420116,
-0.0251011252,
0.0323672928,
0.0331589691,
0.0130449552,
0.0035720323,
0.0255960617,
0.0105934273,
-0.0610131733,
0.0018878448,
-0.0301730558,
-0.0375070088,
0.027492173,
-0.0210233591,
0.0395122319,
0.0382184274,
0.0405678414,
-0.0158691444,
-0.0484329276,
-0.0097912094,
-0.0290123355,
-0.0217565242,
-0.0866372362,
-0.0176170543,
-0.0486593619,
0.0495706014,
-0.006227266,
-0.0461088382,
0.0775578022,
-0.0394581929,
0.0383128151,
-0.0734510869,
0.0296486448,
-0.0229711458,
0.0334379226,
-0.011721448,
-0.0171763021,
0.0639141276,
-0.0635396093,
-0.0358125195,
0.003905698,
0.0230644885,
-0.0091706561,
-0.000797631,
-0.0311564617,
0.0118987756,
-0.0040292321,
-0.0464719459,
-0.03898938,
-0.0972866043,
-0.0041486439,
0.0121012004,
0.0300148651,
0.027107209,
0.0024434982,
0.0041719186,
0.010045222,
0.0027838773,
-0.0431619957,
-0.0030918212,
-0.0331069678,
0.0394931734,
0.0463862196,
0.0316345282,
0.0167588182,
0.0008097778,
0.0138736907,
-0.0096554756,
0.0426262096,
0.0524834581,
0.0044528213,
0.0091407793,
0.04816062,
-0.0888600424,
-0.0555424839,
0.0784537345,
0.0560624488,
-0.02261311,
0.0068051605,
0.1205503047,
0.0468586795,
-0.0847781301,
-0.017831428,
0.0230425708,
-0.0027897262,
0.0035263423,
0.0329941586,
-0.0403384231,
-0.0243352521,
0.0255073402,
0.0367280319,
-0.045187898,
-0.0547339059,
-0.0056789289,
-0.1366670877,
0.0223230924,
-0.0311740153,
0.0175023396,
-0.0609609559,
-0.0768877044,
0.0346206315,
-0.011382998,
0.0448224172,
0.0303599145,
-0.0059420103,
0.0192277897,
0.0303406175,
-0.0397300683,
-0.0381273925,
-0.0026078115,
-0.019914601,
0.0402618013,
0.0796714202,
-0.0006546252,
0.0162001308,
-0.0128208073,
0.0113655999,
-0.0578573458,
0.0088774627,
-0.0043119844,
0.03792331,
0.0192113519,
0.0120644206,
0.0002956431,
0.0278614871,
-0.0140934307,
-0.0116319135,
0.0071713785,
0.0603490546,
-0.0441539735,
0.034465313,
0.0074466891,
0.0018722741,
0.0631197318,
0.0866076648,
0.0277645197,
-0.0566563644,
-0.0262891203,
-0.0368662551,
0.0161864068,
-0.0231098626,
0.0263631418,
0.0222397149,
-0.0034738597,
-0.0428395048,
-0.0453524999,
-0.0309586041,
0.0360837169,
0.0501442105,
0.0248514619,
0.0183515623,
-0.0151311345,
0.0089725871,
0.0351031534,
0.0353171825,
-0.0342563167,
0.0310503803,
-0.0615001023,
-0.0019088895,
-0.0010973783,
-0.025161393,
-0.0189834777,
0.0020034772,
-0.0289997347,
-0.0536362901,
-0.0189092457,
0.0358019508,
0.0193428714,
0.008815797,
-0.0438524634,
-0.06525065,
0.0400488824,
0.047976274,
-0.0063048536,
-0.0090452274,
-0.0308222435,
0.0380954444,
-0.0439904667,
0.0079431133,
-0.0285746269,
-0.0269742347,
0.0450543649,
0.0531125441,
0.0131973438,
-0.0846438482,
0.028277155,
0.040297173,
0.0959067643,
-0.0482749827,
-0.0361721106,
-0.0541624799,
-0.0201087967,
-0.0072895149,
-0.0278677829,
0.0116800712,
0.0349245444,
0.0425642841,
-0.0363909155,
0.006414772,
-0.0308473073,
-0.0195210651,
0.0443179086,
-0.0688285381,
-0.0183946993,
0.0228712149,
0.0264294986,
0.025696177,
-0.0141094252,
-0.0314284004,
0.0177095197,
0.0323915705,
0.0303610023,
0.007862336,
0.0686523393,
0.0213586185,
-0.003409666,
-0.0068820105,
0.0064908769,
-0.0800088197,
-0.0381848067,
-0.0156770889,
0.0760802925,
0.0502606593,
-0.0059022442,
-0.0284738075,
0.0147924563,
-0.0193653442,
-0.0295458585,
0.0252245553,
0.0859719589,
-0.0249743592,
0.0384871364,
0.0049259728,
-0.0293678883,
-0.0200346503,
0.0512776449,
-0.0684937313,
0.030596029,
-0.0174377598,
-0.0209999885,
-0.0529763512,
0.0089982171,
0.0029386608,
0.0597709902,
-0.0328904279,
0.0051150317,
-0.069171533,
-0.011797078,
0.0101748863,
0.0366742127,
-0.0055043045,
0.0276717711,
0.0572497696,
0.0521197915,
-0.0190867763,
-0.0174409449,
-0.0498986542,
0.0054413164,
-0.0078114811,
-0.0372171029,
-0.0519893877,
-5.998565305e-33,
-0.0361848772,
-0.0017180586,
-0.02625921,
0.0151508227,
0.0062572751,
0.0234512016,
-0.0221388489,
0.0047118994,
-0.0108444886,
0.0006231064,
-0.0627870858,
-0.0479127951,
0.0307423379,
0.0118879918,
0.0015157028,
-0.025245579,
0.0344664752,
-0.0045289029,
-0.0554434136,
-0.0071510137,
0.0226733182,
0.0245844554,
-0.0129378736,
-0.0260713249,
0.0696505606,
0.0241810028,
-0.0235283021,
0.0081421044,
0.0038330138,
0.0508185476,
-0.0228063855,
0.0686661825,
0.0181260873,
-0.0754367486,
-0.0248417575,
0.0843433961,
-0.0375919417,
-0.0628872961,
0.015014302,
0.0231165458,
-0.0287421625,
-0.0412277915,
-0.0388277881,
-0.0300157517,
-0.0405882411,
0.0034003069,
0.0360396951,
-0.0013232782,
-0.0377110504,
-0.0231972095,
-0.0111676417,
-0.0057389624,
0.0046750666,
-0.0325937159,
0.0097891456,
0.0385754295,
0.0109970765,
-0.0179030653,
-0.0259919669,
0.0005096996,
0.0111000482,
0.0368719809,
0.0158228483,
0.0408305973,
0.0060657957,
0.0412172303,
0.0273344591,
-0.0091199046,
0.0219489206,
-0.0254142154,
-0.0319140926,
-0.0249464568,
0.0049322736,
0.0254168231,
0.0080228634,
0.0025890034,
-0.0355933234,
0.0513417609,
0.103125602,
-0.0305047948,
0.040661037,
-0.0053431527,
-0.043266736,
-0.0368291363,
-0.0653442442,
-0.0411695279,
-0.0219826195,
-0.004424239,
0.0353549384,
0.0025728205,
-0.0136032291,
0.0013928626,
0.0463343114,
-0.0284985173,
-0.0179677438,
0.0104320748,
0.0093074096,
0.0165858027,
-0.0062986622,
0.0045810682,
-0.0234494861,
-0.0170336384,
0.0194898658,
-0.0363160633,
0.0075949989,
-0.0028273941,
-0.0136583922,
-0.0021403208,
-0.0584083423,
-0.0019402831,
-0.0230263416,
0.0346178114,
0.0181935485,
0.0410050638,
0.0475760251,
0.0009610859,
-0.0097550284,
0.0239132214,
0.0119986022,
-0.005729144,
0.0089240503,
-0.0104421256,
-0.0157999322,
-0.0043240176,
-0.0195832886,
0.0103781177,
0.0116661619,
0.0178850982,
-0.0268900935,
0.0165677257,
-0.0243111737,
0.0246305317,
2.677e-7,
0.0556017943,
0.01795117,
0.0165697727,
0.0341593586,
-0.0021761935,
0.0327560641,
0.0283887666,
0.0262410399,
0.0222240128,
-0.0495653152,
-0.0263390839,
-0.0435597897,
0.0376087911,
-0.0216776878,
-0.1355977505,
-0.0259101912,
-0.017306691,
0.0478723273,
-0.0533556938,
0.0049836491,
0.0795700252,
0.0763084739,
0.0064685373,
-0.0149554564,
-0.0183853563,
-0.0118992208,
-0.0016517731,
-0.0388191193,
-0.0084027192,
0.044466991,
0.0906189457,
-0.0613082238,
0.0120733706,
0.0819300041,
-0.009419769,
-0.0075464305,
0.0074174348,
0.0515195616,
0.0291425865,
-0.0370223187,
-0.0169006865,
-0.0005990887,
0.0308361221,
-0.0784684569,
0.0881983563,
-0.0023398499,
0.0023217234,
-0.0204466134,
-0.0306458697,
-0.0437933505,
0.0405575521,
-0.0198129173,
-0.0150370989,
0.029120924,
0.0087536564,
0.0200548638,
-0.0263913218,
-0.0488493033,
-0.01072782,
-0.0092205284,
-0.0500923842,
-0.0482717268,
0.0203931183,
-0.0240845382,
0.0283708945,
-0.1106020212,
-0.0003195702,
2.866599095e-34,
0.0007590128,
-0.0028942521,
0.0348320939,
-0.0001514825,
0.0187177118,
0.0084052878,
0.0086236456,
0.0105104474,
0.039403785,
-0.0850216523,
-0.0271095317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14874v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14874v2 | From Words to Wires: Generating Functioning Electronic Devices from Natural Language Descriptions | 2023-05-24T08:28:59 | 2023-10-13T23:47:33 | Peter Jansen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we show that contemporary language models have a previously
unknown skill -- the capacity for electronic circuit design from high-level
textual descriptions, akin to code generation. We introduce two benchmarks:
Pins100, assessing model knowledge of electrical components, and Micro25,
evaluating a model's capability to design common microcontroller circuits and
code in the Arduino ecosystem that involve input, output, sensors, motors,
protocols, and logic -- with models such as GPT-4 and Claude-V1 achieving
between 60% to 96% Pass@1 on generating full devices. We include six case
studies of using language models as a design assistant for moderately complex
devices, such as a radiation-powered random number generator, an emoji
keyboard, a visible spectrometer, and several assistive devices, while offering
a qualitative analysis performance, outlining evaluation challenges, and
suggesting areas of development to improve complex circuit design and practical
utility. With this work, we aim to spur research at the juncture of natural
language processing and electronic design. | [
0.0225415956,
0.0481004342,
-0.0313630141,
0.0657477155,
-0.029602088,
-0.0296128746,
0.0449306108,
-0.0203036945,
0.026263833,
-0.0224065129,
0.0100979963,
0.0200006682,
0.0113100065,
0.0829631761,
0.0401451103,
-0.0265522096,
0.0205403827,
-0.0218331646,
0.004345241,
0.018970551,
0.0069031268,
0.0215590764,
-0.0109238354,
0.0686488152,
-0.0087731471,
0.0210997965,
-0.0469539203,
-0.0005219813,
0.0051847296,
-0.0125737535,
-0.0264522042,
0.0730840638,
-0.0149682257,
0.0187046789,
0.0000020969,
-0.020352751,
0.0179924071,
0.0189914275,
-0.0209723711,
-0.0162806194,
0.037586391,
-0.0135630257,
-0.0154117718,
0.0153522771,
0.0016269028,
-0.0135503458,
0.1124695614,
0.0321462154,
0.026628457,
0.0309480168,
-0.0070440839,
-0.0301413629,
0.0890991166,
-0.0012120865,
0.0256599113,
0.0378500111,
-0.0215862785,
-0.0036397274,
0.0870651603,
0.0018202851,
-0.0004105708,
0.0369839631,
0.0500737242,
0.0091266567,
0.0462802052,
0.0175175928,
-0.0340769291,
0.0036912472,
-0.0421415828,
0.066505529,
-0.0267964378,
-0.0206322484,
0.0037696615,
-0.0054389816,
-0.0518287085,
0.0013039781,
0.0033064119,
-0.0135626988,
-0.0479797721,
-0.010220686,
-0.0107607571,
-0.0323660076,
0.0269468967,
-0.0087575316,
0.0397215001,
0.0649352893,
0.0307144653,
-0.0035781499,
-0.0140085304,
-0.0108208312,
0.0157387219,
-0.0668055788,
0.0431093052,
0.0247432794,
0.0012313985,
0.0160125028,
-0.0472801253,
-0.0020755664,
-0.0104374969,
-0.0518355928,
0.0229650661,
0.0348366015,
0.0197011139,
0.0233949926,
0.0024475474,
0.0317402259,
-0.0201041587,
-0.0071823215,
-0.0733716562,
0.0203042924,
-0.061192289,
-0.0715027973,
-0.036285378,
0.0403940082,
-0.033287663,
-0.0433049649,
-0.0299789365,
0.0314833373,
-0.0008944806,
-0.0026596624,
-0.0209489372,
0.0037315707,
-0.0138127012,
-0.0221349727,
-0.0067428173,
0.0249027237,
-0.012861507,
-0.0028629461,
0.0172400456,
-0.0704499409,
0.0096569788,
-0.0182135701,
-0.0002369734,
-0.0129953213,
-0.0246620942,
0.1019533947,
0.012288942,
-0.0445179529,
-0.0210333709,
-0.0168079697,
-0.0144015132,
-0.0260440223,
0.0141881611,
-0.0707185343,
-0.000368799,
0.0282663479,
0.0347362123,
-0.0335310921,
0.0315461345,
0.0420667827,
0.0074627087,
0.0893389508,
-0.0333592668,
-0.0271243788,
0.0008094019,
0.0023090297,
0.025108574,
0.0391747728,
0.0694175959,
0.0076280562,
0.0154826622,
-0.0214119293,
0.0314414315,
0.04333717,
-0.0152386352,
-0.0619872957,
-0.0318128467,
-0.0409503654,
-0.0317726769,
-0.0009102506,
-0.0405903943,
0.0590865202,
0.0236315653,
0.0406215526,
0.0597871281,
0.0766113326,
0.024022717,
0.0752549842,
0.0157670639,
0.0124075375,
-0.0013119414,
-0.0349060483,
-0.0415426679,
0.0684654787,
-0.0740521252,
0.016090028,
0.0264604148,
0.006083935,
-0.0053573786,
-0.0581217892,
-0.021189576,
-0.0446821488,
0.0365100913,
-0.0375550352,
0.0205696728,
0.0047723432,
-0.0238332674,
0.0154803786,
0.0259193499,
-0.0715987384,
-0.0400652438,
-0.0480178297,
0.0052107885,
0.0961413234,
0.051615078,
-0.0247031413,
0.0159638878,
0.0384170711,
-0.0131412726,
0.045840621,
0.0452549309,
-0.0091548646,
-0.020197412,
0.0076103909,
-0.0324593969,
-0.0259582438,
0.019317789,
0.0298465211,
-0.0532870777,
0.0061772866,
0.0126192477,
-0.0151684014,
-0.0204187334,
0.0139679825,
-0.018736843,
-0.0330929868,
0.0058203256,
0.0332576185,
-0.0077605313,
-0.0042577181,
-0.018415086,
0.0409494005,
0.0275305863,
-0.0701617897,
0.0023506854,
0.0015632366,
-0.0291920751,
0.0236914754,
0.037569087,
-0.0760991424,
-0.0053460565,
0.0388588011,
-0.0110963471,
-0.0306641124,
0.0600606725,
-0.063497901,
0.0148457102,
-0.0136582907,
-0.0178611856,
0.016467303,
-0.0165384393,
0.0141629791,
0.0567141473,
0.0335424766,
0.0264318846,
-0.0050708274,
0.0236924775,
0.0122380154,
-0.0282559246,
-0.0262841284,
0.0137199927,
-0.0000520659,
0.0368622839,
0.0412187465,
0.0038568897,
-0.0281233899,
0.0100099733,
-0.0986696631,
-0.0364970118,
-0.0025981183,
-0.0002070976,
-0.0062564886,
0.0079722675,
0.0178904049,
0.0120979492,
-0.007352191,
-0.0122336848,
-0.0166102499,
-0.0254353005,
0.0326578617,
-0.003934334,
-0.0666437149,
-0.0131879067,
-0.0270031318,
-0.0409192592,
0.0309915263,
0.038640894,
-0.0099852988,
-0.0679675564,
0.0346617065,
0.012306761,
0.0017902533,
-0.0002827624,
-0.0384619124,
0.0555235185,
-0.0119726704,
0.0241548531,
0.0439276807,
0.0196683221,
0.0209381655,
0.0549135283,
-0.0624829493,
-0.0067203562,
0.031128183,
0.0217749886,
0.0153805148,
-0.0047998731,
0.0027895959,
-0.0009197397,
0.0857578814,
-0.0097317146,
0.0283407737,
-0.0560556389,
0.0334350355,
-0.0157560669,
-0.0176166203,
-0.0045466009,
-0.0094955759,
0.0103903711,
0.0445392914,
-0.0329245813,
-0.0439005308,
0.100731492,
-0.0388828926,
0.0082289698,
-0.0332472771,
-0.0283477698,
-0.0045730532,
0.1032045186,
0.0120647149,
0.0377047621,
0.0625228435,
0.0412632376,
-0.0162980463,
0.0402899422,
-0.0218470339,
-0.0199460555,
0.0121959848,
-0.0772785395,
0.0187110957,
-0.0158817172,
-0.0440377332,
-0.0218103491,
0.005291882,
-0.0496995151,
0.0006402904,
0.0266470443,
-0.019286437,
-0.0244894978,
0.0596819818,
0.014962323,
0.0087281065,
0.0153812114,
-0.023153929,
-0.0266965106,
0.0120162452,
0.008515195,
-0.0257695522,
-0.0103365611,
-0.0037898992,
0.0062002274,
0.0226092208,
0.0085280081,
0.0199946165,
-0.0728273094,
0.0180984959,
0.0255866274,
0.0264331568,
-0.0182479024,
0.0302257724,
0.0411773063,
-0.0424834192,
-0.0349744409,
0.0881670266,
-0.0051895371,
-0.006074884,
0.0298777279,
0.0253861267,
0.0137289111,
0.0044151614,
0.0338788293,
-0.1104866415,
-0.0200384315,
-0.0134430146,
0.0357553028,
-0.0082011418,
0.0220429227,
-0.0526524521,
-0.1288410574,
0.0177785438,
0.0200356487,
-0.0492654145,
-0.0742046908,
-0.0447206944,
-0.0194687862,
0.0167434588,
0.0088082077,
0.0183772203,
-0.0047198883,
0.0044903266,
-0.0039093727,
-0.0627079979,
-0.0585662127,
0.0347047001,
0.0273931362,
0.0228381436,
0.0962585807,
0.0068861982,
-0.0070431316,
0.0081080766,
-0.0094724037,
0.0017928901,
0.011861125,
-0.0254260823,
-0.0163857732,
0.0436707623,
-0.0572352707,
-0.0139755085,
0.0291423667,
-0.058751367,
-0.0227106512,
-0.0066574719,
0.0393318161,
-0.0161696915,
-0.0224939398,
-0.0285234414,
-0.0353051424,
0.0418526977,
0.0108735319,
0.0136092976,
-0.0442374311,
-0.0727985278,
-0.0769822672,
0.025451649,
-0.0587271713,
-0.0480703227,
-0.0242245644,
0.0225785989,
-0.0527328178,
-0.0215097871,
-0.0163327493,
-0.0222444795,
0.0111137582,
0.0451775789,
-0.0421800949,
0.0963903219,
0.0248549636,
-0.0463858247,
0.0116092935,
-0.002043851,
0.0064270827,
-0.0535159223,
-0.0355530456,
0.0030964976,
-0.0380925909,
-0.0358413905,
0.0496989675,
-0.0352518894,
-0.0790998861,
0.0278866719,
0.0870775953,
0.0297135245,
-0.0491719507,
-0.0135106249,
-0.0411637984,
-0.0387652442,
0.0590278506,
-0.0239279792,
0.0115613723,
0.0118334815,
0.0037619004,
-0.0154229049,
-0.002941282,
-0.0329244807,
0.033256609,
-0.0082754474,
0.0304292794,
-0.0488266423,
-0.0436246768,
0.0649332628,
0.0324732363,
0.030963866,
0.005905509,
0.0397550836,
-0.0246072672,
0.025187809,
-0.0240637437,
-0.0090149557,
-0.067413047,
-0.0199313723,
-0.0300915074,
-0.0158719011,
0.029277768,
-0.0688638985,
0.0036966132,
0.0231158566,
-0.027432546,
0.0521513857,
0.0203128085,
0.048231326,
0.0139284423,
-0.0431974493,
-0.0124971801,
0.033559829,
-0.0309451036,
0.05203446,
-0.0437013246,
-0.0083769886,
0.0283218008,
-0.0033300167,
-0.0327218585,
0.038010519,
-0.0385094248,
-0.0783716366,
-0.0259597935,
0.0552091151,
0.0174120944,
0.0212551337,
-0.0102773113,
-0.0786397681,
-0.0133650992,
-0.0480125509,
0.055837471,
0.012287409,
-0.0067825252,
0.044697661,
0.0436964743,
0.0059482623,
-0.0798170045,
0.0188801195,
-0.0064143129,
0.0126465736,
0.0162630081,
-0.0087161614,
-0.0665262341,
0.022568075,
-0.0148936827,
-0.0061482838,
-0.019049203,
-0.0038267223,
-0.0607905313,
-0.0538123958,
0.0264093503,
0.0368336663,
0.0415278152,
-0.0193375479,
0.063462764,
0.0458736718,
-0.010357135,
-0.0247956291,
0.0479209684,
-0.0002126612,
-0.0531538948,
-0.0139290197,
-0.0292105861,
-6.150169913e-33,
-0.043199528,
-0.0450971797,
0.0246253684,
0.0204456616,
0.0362807363,
0.0064453939,
-0.0634975135,
0.0436119996,
0.0265357681,
-0.0286447536,
-0.0030700681,
-0.0276226308,
0.0055341423,
0.030314479,
0.023134565,
-0.0223755017,
0.0625181049,
0.0227223542,
-0.0284622684,
0.0354309306,
0.020596059,
-0.010229391,
0.0153572969,
-0.0668592155,
0.0396334864,
0.0025470136,
-0.0156173408,
-0.0508166514,
-0.0220420975,
0.0375617407,
-0.0323176533,
0.0632022098,
-0.00321596,
0.0372893848,
-0.0064152032,
0.0712536201,
-0.0636551678,
-0.0246618316,
-0.0153917298,
0.0286389627,
-0.0225404706,
-0.0533458479,
0.047105711,
0.0035733285,
-0.0662498921,
0.0197254326,
0.0457226261,
-0.0256204959,
0.01823554,
0.0061635999,
-0.0654147789,
0.0110362247,
-0.0135062784,
-0.0243324805,
0.0035695992,
-0.0146643464,
-0.0239660069,
0.008381851,
-0.0050508496,
0.0371787846,
0.0412335806,
0.0651232675,
0.0755107179,
-0.0065811365,
0.0117357438,
0.0482762232,
0.0272332374,
-0.0109255118,
-0.0219769329,
0.0264487918,
0.0102560278,
0.0702929124,
0.0506782718,
0.027524434,
0.0492151119,
-0.0259151477,
-0.0688361377,
-0.0014035827,
-0.0054627536,
0.0737899989,
0.0099568265,
0.0279655457,
-0.0446583182,
-0.0169106852,
-0.0140003664,
0.0137032755,
-0.0126570528,
-0.0360625908,
-0.0125304041,
0.0182999913,
-0.0627609268,
-0.0247802846,
-0.0052961521,
-0.0388598219,
-0.0147671783,
0.0035012802,
0.0415988043,
0.0028863144,
-0.0009265681,
0.0132253058,
-0.0169649795,
-0.0379695781,
-0.0467537269,
0.0160301607,
0.0342202932,
-0.0152091309,
-0.0614911355,
0.0795741752,
-0.0345063694,
0.0105075436,
-0.0303477086,
-0.0191741381,
-0.0057451488,
0.0305323359,
0.0262238514,
0.0104597853,
-0.0090701105,
0.0211310368,
-0.0497391969,
-0.0572564602,
-0.0312304161,
0.0137674967,
-0.0224639028,
0.007489773,
-0.0125666168,
-0.0180251021,
-0.0769693926,
0.0463185459,
0.0415102467,
-0.0362271629,
-0.0264815763,
0.0391451716,
2.906e-7,
0.0228333417,
0.0328396112,
0.0341639593,
0.0336235613,
0.0014734542,
0.0168030653,
-0.0010198486,
0.0074590174,
-0.0353028178,
0.0019995093,
-0.0254788715,
0.0204119422,
0.0615003966,
0.0161686968,
-0.0686709881,
0.0121654691,
-0.0213310216,
0.0547166839,
-0.0117696142,
0.0278839469,
0.1079964638,
0.0746573731,
-0.0088910842,
0.0117504792,
-0.0149674676,
-0.0691821203,
0.0224736147,
-0.0363603048,
0.0417177118,
-0.0088928808,
-0.0123417946,
0.0150011526,
-0.0385234803,
0.0379267111,
0.0115728937,
-0.0207216889,
0.0067145848,
0.0497494116,
0.0046063783,
-0.0049363654,
-0.0079593537,
-0.0282616373,
-0.0427049249,
-0.042461738,
0.0293010455,
-0.0256322343,
-0.0150248138,
-0.0381998084,
0.0170341805,
-0.0000847135,
-0.0149515197,
-0.0273145549,
-0.0172642134,
-0.0458583608,
-0.0229652021,
-0.0197790954,
0.0151154306,
0.007974864,
0.0050984193,
0.0179715492,
-0.0198887661,
-0.032924328,
-0.0567826629,
0.0224368274,
0.0288771763,
0.0069890949,
-0.0112097198,
2.455497726e-34,
0.0097377496,
-0.0377116725,
-0.0098632164,
0.0592104867,
0.0300525613,
0.0110185146,
0.0033034435,
-0.009778671,
-0.000922878,
-0.059049584,
-0.0553037561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14871v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14871v2 | ClusterLLM: Large Language Models as a Guide for Text Clustering | 2023-05-24T08:24:25 | 2023-11-03T19:40:21 | Yuwei Zhang, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce ClusterLLM, a novel text clustering framework that leverages
feedback from an instruction-tuned large language model, such as ChatGPT.
Compared with traditional unsupervised methods that builds upon "small"
embedders, ClusterLLM exhibits two intriguing advantages: (1) it enjoys the
emergent capability of LLM even if its embeddings are inaccessible; and (2) it
understands the user's preference on clustering through textual instruction
and/or a few annotated data. First, we prompt ChatGPT for insights on
clustering perspective by constructing hard triplet questions <does A better
correspond to B than C>, where A, B and C are similar data points that belong
to different clusters according to small embedder. We empirically show that
this strategy is both effective for fine-tuning small embedder and
cost-efficient to query ChatGPT. Second, we prompt ChatGPT for helps on
clustering granularity by carefully designed pairwise questions <do A and B
belong to the same category>, and tune the granularity from cluster hierarchies
that is the most consistent with the ChatGPT answers. Extensive experiments on
14 datasets show that ClusterLLM consistently improves clustering quality, at
an average cost of ~$0.6 per dataset. The code will be available at
https://github.com/zhang-yu-wei/ClusterLLM. | [
0.0224598069,
0.0193596072,
-0.0268028863,
0.0587155037,
-0.0384805426,
0.0186488368,
0.0480165258,
0.0298393462,
0.0890760422,
-0.0165094901,
-0.0082328096,
0.0067726946,
-0.0108773252,
-0.0144672124,
0.0328773111,
-0.0731552467,
0.0368753076,
-0.0114933122,
0.0143400729,
-0.0075239944,
0.0511181094,
0.0151571007,
0.0108140083,
0.0216607526,
0.0021068361,
-0.0153557248,
-0.0183159858,
-0.0239580087,
-0.0148169324,
0.0187134836,
0.0124507686,
0.0402065702,
0.0328758992,
0.0485225655,
0.0000020256,
-0.0375891626,
-0.0562368855,
-0.0012629839,
0.0155922789,
0.0225294195,
0.074980922,
0.0001764249,
0.0380747728,
0.0164232422,
-0.0308474805,
-0.0376834199,
0.0245283153,
0.0241309274,
0.0840968713,
0.0417142697,
-0.0217360053,
-0.0154201305,
0.0095674591,
-0.0023084925,
0.0181739144,
-0.0129498029,
0.0168708432,
0.0626536086,
0.0101823192,
0.0514213145,
-0.003141715,
0.0185784157,
0.0111617232,
-0.0000100737,
0.005646714,
0.0458868034,
-0.0593255796,
0.0026750041,
0.0303930361,
0.0781265497,
-0.0044122459,
-0.0282939039,
0.0310409721,
0.0334988981,
0.0077175633,
0.0300916974,
-0.0446005575,
-0.0074817115,
-0.0180952363,
-0.0016300321,
0.0249071363,
0.0192247089,
0.0301733948,
-0.0204229206,
-0.0199631173,
0.0568500236,
0.0189346243,
0.0060117729,
-0.0431155041,
-0.0014034485,
-0.0532857329,
-0.0431794561,
0.026377555,
0.0433218479,
-0.0153801991,
0.0018536858,
-0.044629328,
0.01854725,
0.012065582,
-0.0435736887,
-0.0211410243,
0.0155737624,
0.0060306191,
0.0792729333,
-0.0072446354,
0.0008740188,
0.0075214775,
-0.0079264576,
-0.05673052,
-0.0386506245,
-0.0405369215,
0.0033695684,
-0.0335308537,
0.0310695153,
-0.0229347888,
0.0098565388,
-0.0069402838,
0.0479826517,
-0.0048368801,
0.0322834477,
-0.0008418994,
-0.0098314071,
0.0173509922,
-0.0246572811,
-0.0142862694,
-0.0233219676,
-0.0853754804,
0.0134296399,
-0.0260471497,
-0.0226514805,
0.001589876,
0.0576478727,
0.0278852787,
-0.0162186567,
-0.0205758587,
0.0304049347,
-0.0284068566,
-0.0180411004,
-0.0323853008,
-0.0224117413,
0.006975126,
-0.0247281734,
-0.0609419458,
-0.0972837359,
0.0617176704,
0.0322057903,
0.0033481724,
-0.0233816989,
-0.0262974203,
0.0100594973,
-0.0326885097,
0.0747387931,
-0.0293659884,
0.0162894018,
0.0757118016,
0.0204325654,
-0.0265730396,
0.0378116108,
-0.0006359393,
0.0078590289,
0.0818261206,
-0.0265638474,
0.0082604261,
0.028312033,
-0.0080935536,
0.0227827355,
0.0029622072,
0.0419646576,
0.025399182,
0.0238224193,
0.0053703492,
0.0653211623,
-0.046969831,
-0.0333622992,
0.011871187,
0.0928943977,
0.0258718282,
0.0244398918,
-0.0091069741,
0.0415493548,
-0.0191468112,
0.0014545571,
0.0038417946,
0.0190908443,
-0.0603026785,
-0.0291625056,
0.1170573756,
0.0137767075,
-0.049616579,
-0.0483204983,
-0.0130807254,
0.0133326519,
0.0426764712,
0.0091032451,
0.0174557362,
-0.0327911861,
0.0087014157,
0.0327604525,
0.0439085402,
-0.0351745412,
0.0211389419,
-0.0305927433,
0.0636234209,
0.0264956951,
0.0400062352,
-0.0535128042,
0.0008693692,
0.0345080495,
0.0269018244,
-0.0180013888,
0.0281626899,
-0.0552472621,
-0.0142029496,
-0.0625227988,
-0.0060845604,
0.0263419803,
0.0102247745,
-0.0162263121,
0.0163113009,
0.0029125847,
0.0017844798,
-0.0539008304,
-0.0050649978,
0.0302555989,
-0.0070249364,
0.0036737602,
0.0044145109,
0.0009170374,
0.0062932172,
-0.027197849,
0.015042115,
-0.025350485,
0.0425606184,
-0.0213890933,
-0.0093802204,
-0.0476447344,
-0.0351245552,
-0.0903328285,
0.0202496406,
0.0071492549,
-0.0281743072,
-0.0384016968,
-0.0523763895,
-0.0323885828,
0.0142932218,
-0.0270957071,
0.0705452189,
-0.0366740078,
0.014290683,
-0.0325115845,
-0.0374920331,
-0.065717414,
0.0456348695,
0.0012066376,
0.0382678546,
-0.0210269801,
0.0095565626,
-0.000104524,
-0.0090018269,
-0.0413368233,
-0.0115735289,
0.0233385246,
0.060123492,
0.021466298,
-0.0073645464,
-0.0444030315,
-0.0420471132,
-0.0885664597,
-0.0021418298,
-0.0164695159,
-0.0297628734,
0.0348521061,
0.0044082124,
-0.0123175299,
-0.0061337445,
-0.067659162,
-0.0010367777,
0.0185318794,
0.0258605909,
0.0608056001,
-0.0190181062,
-0.0051225494,
-0.0514247976,
-0.0241821706,
-0.0026100872,
0.0418018177,
-0.0077522271,
0.007134899,
-0.053672377,
0.0336949229,
-0.0343725868,
-0.0193832032,
-0.0187865924,
0.0111002568,
-0.0138487518,
-0.0478295721,
0.0343776904,
0.033825174,
0.0101880496,
0.0053705606,
0.0511954166,
-0.0204892363,
-0.0514479615,
-0.0008725907,
-0.0217193253,
0.0106415059,
-0.0177002531,
-0.0490518287,
0.0319999829,
0.0385625139,
0.0256278031,
-0.0397811197,
-0.0590859465,
0.0172416717,
-0.0354814716,
0.0356655158,
-0.0741709471,
0.0109634725,
0.0474015065,
0.0376735665,
-0.038980227,
-0.0593009703,
0.0807798952,
-0.0396596193,
-0.004589817,
-0.0389819853,
-0.0335893407,
-0.0563292094,
0.0223033112,
0.0097487522,
0.0204576086,
-0.0308431163,
-0.0030957884,
-0.0352243893,
0.0225120168,
-0.0000859439,
-0.0124494238,
0.0751610994,
-0.0271812342,
-0.0010852059,
0.0175524317,
-0.0147384983,
-0.0131831886,
-0.0251387395,
0.0108444169,
-0.0137904324,
0.0488247834,
-0.0055083861,
-0.0461920798,
0.0495767146,
0.0087876664,
0.0403677858,
-0.0240629148,
-0.0378014743,
-0.0002461421,
0.0605977327,
0.0186800826,
-0.0125472117,
0.0006044721,
-0.0253607072,
0.010529629,
0.0808117688,
0.0279048495,
-0.0366370603,
-0.025159508,
0.003530944,
0.0245053153,
-0.0428558737,
-0.0036667993,
-0.0273986515,
0.0597061664,
0.0055580819,
-0.0339328982,
0.1603633165,
0.0669883564,
-0.0861617923,
-0.007878596,
-0.0309601016,
0.070038572,
0.0304808561,
0.0359751992,
-0.0060061831,
-0.0095428135,
-0.0115763163,
0.0258393921,
0.0341424383,
-0.0376193747,
0.005519399,
-0.07739079,
0.0241667479,
0.0166514497,
-0.0420104451,
-0.0013092761,
-0.086992763,
-0.0045524328,
-0.0212442558,
0.0027788011,
0.0277764946,
0.0154792592,
0.0219556689,
0.0013537516,
-0.0847380161,
-0.0053752009,
0.0207540467,
-0.0444433875,
0.0434147343,
-0.0133978967,
0.0164515879,
0.0204996951,
0.0091076903,
0.0207695793,
-0.0267606061,
-0.0421769992,
-0.0329819731,
0.026042033,
-0.0067239166,
0.0137761422,
-0.0412803553,
0.0456410721,
-0.0337674692,
0.0059070722,
0.0736061558,
0.0563182272,
-0.0038983345,
0.0032978961,
-0.0231279917,
-0.0080396924,
-0.0292620901,
0.0629361421,
0.0081168301,
-0.0128797134,
0.0322340578,
-0.0472504497,
0.0033060689,
0.0518451408,
-0.0278764572,
-0.0284887422,
0.0004946881,
0.0496703535,
-0.0636265203,
-0.0255970489,
0.0709506646,
0.0223172624,
-0.0119848279,
0.007161187,
-0.0062680687,
-0.036484126,
-0.0574806742,
0.0289099067,
-0.0553966835,
-0.0192770679,
-0.0409933217,
-0.0194974616,
0.0621316768,
-0.0071971547,
-0.0118639441,
-0.0346589461,
-0.0680700988,
-0.0594412684,
-0.0333951749,
-0.0041723186,
0.0095140086,
0.0564085282,
-0.0587964244,
-0.0831544176,
0.0444740541,
0.0375315472,
-0.0654129758,
-0.0071365098,
-0.049069941,
0.0129752252,
0.0094133783,
0.0205920562,
-0.0312904753,
0.0109398747,
-0.0160277039,
-0.0041973828,
-0.1246046498,
-0.0137273334,
0.0106750121,
0.0426367074,
0.0507225767,
0.0488446616,
-0.0020999662,
-0.0323404446,
-0.0187713765,
-0.0082523162,
-0.0572678261,
0.0081745684,
-0.0019422664,
0.020700369,
-0.0154381208,
-0.028795626,
0.0225534961,
0.0001411746,
0.0210339669,
-0.0074986438,
0.0113837952,
0.0343940109,
0.0185829736,
0.0048327916,
0.0215050466,
-0.000460771,
-0.018515775,
-0.02458423,
0.0297941826,
-0.0468725786,
0.0319920667,
0.0165554173,
0.0189133938,
-0.0373697691,
0.0664309114,
-0.0337505564,
-0.0132498387,
-0.0186659489,
0.0178420413,
-0.0079641873,
-0.0191889331,
0.0088109076,
0.0054386416,
-0.0321210288,
-0.0307431351,
0.011341881,
0.020258192,
-0.0354818478,
0.0312203877,
0.0448365882,
-0.0506483987,
0.0280886702,
0.0766589716,
-0.021760188,
0.0061488552,
0.037171077,
-0.0513309948,
-0.0574020147,
0.0101793101,
0.0407137126,
0.0397912152,
-0.0193697661,
-0.0034934178,
0.0010167966,
-0.0290588457,
0.0115154078,
-0.0126196258,
-0.0249690134,
0.0215749871,
0.0470065139,
0.0752179399,
0.0053505446,
0.0141186388,
-0.0452404208,
0.004241338,
-0.0165182091,
-0.0752981454,
0.0295971408,
-6.773156572e-33,
-0.0180627108,
-0.0466091335,
0.012588976,
-0.0438645408,
0.0034324809,
0.0088695614,
-0.0160955023,
0.0268834587,
-0.0065153628,
-0.0097459462,
-0.0113144275,
0.0128341755,
-0.0059824274,
0.0117826946,
0.0061139739,
0.0008296016,
0.0152757168,
0.0405110978,
-0.0281614214,
0.0601799078,
0.0453452133,
-0.0000064095,
-0.0135579864,
-0.0067380816,
0.0068182363,
-0.0111324266,
0.0159623884,
0.0425941125,
0.0188314356,
0.0406757481,
-0.0557434931,
0.0404450484,
0.0397001691,
0.0316067711,
-0.0062686112,
-0.0255569946,
-0.0498103797,
-0.0465748087,
-0.0081927571,
-0.026240088,
-0.0159923732,
-0.0342032351,
0.0348458216,
-0.0055493573,
0.0222544018,
0.0077040615,
0.056807071,
-0.0113525977,
-0.0623475537,
0.0545346066,
0.0026757864,
0.0516346507,
-0.0516511872,
0.0034621095,
-0.0002067465,
0.0307020489,
0.0014090971,
0.0609994754,
-0.0688686743,
0.0503165536,
-0.030182356,
0.0456517227,
0.0163380839,
0.0172439218,
0.0141008943,
0.0458588377,
-0.0039680996,
-0.0043333918,
-0.0440789945,
0.0262240581,
0.0331350006,
0.0493706279,
0.0481344238,
0.0423585922,
-0.0386802256,
-0.0031067422,
-0.0376879424,
0.0987736583,
0.0174468737,
-0.0361496322,
0.0146351662,
0.039204631,
-0.0501331426,
-0.0845552236,
-0.0281605069,
-0.0194791518,
-0.0526109636,
-0.0013735754,
-0.0060620909,
-0.013909827,
-0.0687864497,
-0.0292671304,
0.0200337544,
-0.0165954251,
-0.0016641729,
-0.0356198549,
-0.0134162717,
0.0115299867,
0.0145446165,
0.0359978043,
-0.0604733489,
-0.0463918038,
0.0049318215,
-0.0422880761,
-0.0133242412,
0.0048002782,
0.0121022789,
-0.0316199623,
-0.0740852579,
-0.0077546528,
0.0256708618,
-0.0337064937,
-0.0273939762,
-0.0161348302,
0.0107902708,
0.0218827911,
0.0214378368,
0.0896486267,
0.0513354801,
-0.0053199874,
-0.0265585724,
0.0126364958,
-0.0456294343,
-0.0145670092,
-0.0030075836,
0.0065707727,
-0.0306029823,
0.0021964263,
0.0386912338,
-0.058196146,
-0.0275630783,
-0.0247685164,
2.659e-7,
0.0448224135,
0.0717233643,
0.0115420967,
-0.0154897477,
0.0109212594,
0.0417797007,
-0.0180498939,
0.0048908284,
0.0140972314,
0.0096074715,
0.030043235,
0.0545193143,
0.0475303195,
0.0622589514,
-0.0180903133,
0.0303613916,
-0.055022303,
-0.0153674865,
-0.0507943556,
-0.0052464241,
0.0291046184,
0.0900863707,
0.0351450667,
0.0141184172,
-0.0203018766,
-0.0587099828,
0.0360626541,
-0.0244727228,
-0.0485657975,
0.0650455803,
0.003920991,
0.0199432578,
0.0188066345,
0.0148715833,
0.0218518972,
-0.0128778005,
0.0125443852,
0.0431183167,
0.0081463074,
-0.0178514645,
0.0138093652,
0.0043087457,
0.0090557188,
-0.0841452703,
0.0902510509,
-0.0381922089,
-0.0171498936,
0.0394045897,
-0.0056569888,
-0.0249089971,
0.0254438855,
-0.0206286497,
-0.0671602935,
0.0488271788,
0.0185532458,
0.0042053419,
-0.004647485,
-0.05646291,
0.0122652445,
-0.0050175278,
-0.0583057106,
-0.0693373904,
0.0030443785,
0.0299195908,
0.0032262986,
-0.0097386977,
0.0572966114,
2.637450935e-34,
0.0362435803,
0.0202473886,
-0.0128823379,
-0.0250756294,
0.0345115848,
-0.0387562849,
-0.0198882427,
-0.0000704382,
0.012182489,
-0.1238868162,
0.0123399477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14869v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14869v2 | CAR: Conceptualization-Augmented Reasoner for Zero-Shot Commonsense Question Answering | 2023-05-24T08:21:31 | 2023-10-20T04:49:21 | Weiqi Wang, Tianqing Fang, Wenxuan Ding, Baixuan Xu, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of zero-shot commonsense question answering evaluates models on
their capacity to reason about general scenarios beyond those presented in
specific datasets. Existing approaches for tackling this task leverage external
knowledge from CommonSense Knowledge Bases (CSKBs) by pretraining the model on
synthetic QA pairs constructed from CSKBs. In these approaches, negative
examples (distractors) are formulated by randomly sampling from CSKBs using
fairly primitive keyword constraints. However, two bottlenecks limit these
approaches: the inherent incompleteness of CSKBs limits the semantic coverage
of synthetic QA pairs, and the lack of human annotations makes the sampled
negative examples potentially uninformative and contradictory. To tackle these
limitations above, we propose Conceptualization-Augmented Reasoner (CAR), a
zero-shot commonsense question-answering framework that fully leverages the
power of conceptualization. Specifically, CAR abstracts a commonsense knowledge
triple to many higher-level instances, which increases the coverage of CSKB and
expands the ground-truth answer space, reducing the likelihood of selecting
false-negative distractors. Extensive experiments demonstrate that CAR more
robustly generalizes to answering questions about zero-shot commonsense
scenarios than existing methods, including large language models, such as
GPT3.5 and ChatGPT. Our codes, data, and model checkpoints are available at
https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/CAR. | [
0.0154395504,
0.0263340212,
0.0188648328,
0.0342012011,
-0.0030340247,
0.0083796727,
-0.0095686503,
-0.0026395631,
-0.0206058193,
-0.0491687581,
0.0022128851,
0.0250160582,
-0.0395527259,
0.0025530348,
0.0236037746,
-0.0292452723,
0.0357746072,
-0.0106816087,
-0.001360263,
0.0027522445,
0.0316580087,
0.027146358,
-0.0163986441,
0.0250554681,
-0.002111291,
-0.0468936302,
-0.0211710893,
-0.0148398895,
0.0032609305,
-0.0150540434,
-0.011379892,
0.0402831919,
0.0375887156,
0.0012563886,
0.0000019482,
-0.0382995196,
0.029837193,
0.002906343,
-0.0453766845,
-0.0248102453,
-0.0269479044,
-0.0092989327,
0.0154269021,
-0.0021555489,
-0.0277968328,
0.0122845117,
0.0297644287,
0.0502404571,
0.0591146685,
0.0339557305,
0.0043724668,
-0.0298000965,
-0.0070188325,
0.0159678385,
0.0737485141,
-0.0510451421,
0.0145079494,
0.0371981412,
0.0152708646,
-0.0224235561,
-0.021430159,
0.0148733668,
0.0447226316,
0.0054614842,
-0.0016239731,
0.0486085005,
-0.0832258239,
0.0067720646,
0.0072529176,
0.1166809052,
0.0204986017,
-0.0659602061,
-0.0181211717,
-0.0107379602,
0.0008677132,
0.0024893328,
-0.0571881644,
0.0263194162,
0.0122948317,
-0.009039931,
0.0149651384,
0.0145724518,
0.0049902024,
0.0532130264,
-0.022142563,
0.046338968,
0.0094497157,
-0.0167404637,
0.0108303437,
-0.0102746552,
-0.0620009899,
-0.0505319238,
-0.0250667483,
0.0805609599,
-0.008848628,
0.0129787121,
-0.0178468637,
-0.0135095399,
0.0243381765,
-0.0458394028,
-0.0273556504,
0.0613066852,
0.010170579,
0.0612912886,
-0.0148548624,
0.0136749875,
-0.0177723262,
0.0320937186,
-0.0226058699,
-0.0385133885,
-0.0576032102,
-0.0154145723,
-0.0480892844,
0.0507750884,
-0.0247843061,
-0.0060741426,
0.0278916638,
0.0157336146,
-0.0271503646,
-0.0062407241,
-0.0033940293,
0.0679534152,
-0.0389182121,
-0.0415594466,
-0.0327828005,
0.0577800572,
-0.082211487,
0.0152835697,
0.0155816218,
-0.0309757199,
-0.039833311,
0.0122891413,
0.0285129175,
-0.0343633443,
-0.0031043538,
0.0053767329,
-0.0316409543,
0.0050935405,
-0.0263788346,
-0.0242680982,
0.0188243091,
-0.0252052508,
-0.049727343,
-0.0520022064,
-0.0032530115,
0.0113840345,
-0.0257014055,
-0.0007700791,
0.018977752,
0.0263750181,
-0.00803148,
0.1037604362,
-0.0232729763,
-0.0456947796,
0.0053807148,
0.0454985276,
-0.0145064322,
0.0781276748,
-0.0053763161,
-0.0308180135,
0.0466958433,
0.0146244355,
0.007198438,
-0.0255892817,
0.0349435993,
0.0096789012,
-0.0029816029,
0.0638575181,
-0.0239439979,
0.0387181267,
0.0442864336,
0.0066115786,
-0.0530467741,
-0.0141524216,
0.0209020786,
0.053537,
-0.0245895218,
0.0079502659,
0.0380812548,
0.0380284898,
-0.0195298176,
-0.0109808734,
-0.0380439982,
0.0148814218,
-0.0675182641,
0.0017705547,
-0.0257956386,
-0.0145669524,
-0.0577846691,
0.0066064303,
0.0137310317,
-0.0083416654,
0.0268097892,
-0.0148238372,
0.0449850596,
0.0013377263,
-0.032141041,
0.0692872033,
-0.0008349945,
-0.0639105216,
-0.0081180446,
-0.0198494997,
0.0920294672,
0.0314156935,
0.0573180169,
-0.0287782922,
-0.1093244702,
-0.0110032996,
0.0190063156,
0.0571812205,
-0.0046790568,
-0.0369717181,
0.0387705266,
-0.0432972685,
-0.0058558527,
-0.0136671877,
0.0022520779,
-0.0233613215,
0.0243421905,
0.0348716751,
0.0206300803,
-0.0377391987,
0.0312401317,
0.00030014,
-0.0126936203,
-0.0446129441,
0.0075017433,
-0.024017144,
0.0131824538,
0.0082426537,
0.0097144386,
0.0082052164,
0.0203585457,
-0.0209273193,
-0.0321822837,
0.0263740085,
-0.025758449,
-0.0752515271,
0.0543819256,
-0.0179433692,
-0.0216715448,
0.0262925476,
-0.045673769,
-0.037488658,
0.0243392494,
0.0165873393,
0.0329964012,
-0.0531447306,
-0.0432376228,
0.0170814805,
-0.0133351758,
-0.0007882944,
0.0840373114,
0.0026272249,
-0.0066268141,
-0.005130189,
0.000834524,
0.0269902591,
-0.0379501432,
0.0091205509,
-0.0249221977,
-0.0037168723,
0.0035874939,
0.0068401019,
0.0174069889,
-0.0595935285,
0.0412480459,
-0.0876015499,
0.0270968247,
-0.0131035317,
0.0054485793,
0.0226569753,
-0.0040697372,
0.029745575,
-0.0169019569,
-0.0269390922,
0.0347566828,
0.0122832535,
0.0031640751,
0.0335348994,
0.0185094494,
0.0058125597,
0.0159924589,
0.0124484664,
-0.0224239118,
0.0189372208,
-0.0133211352,
0.0425558463,
-0.0026908172,
0.0130707677,
-0.0404143594,
0.0358996764,
-0.001662968,
-0.0179252848,
0.0283648055,
-0.0063041323,
-0.0365394242,
0.0338285752,
-0.0176844578,
-0.0120513514,
0.0193451811,
-0.0111291818,
-0.0337338634,
0.0295481235,
0.0166865587,
-0.000897322,
0.0075449287,
0.0053424025,
-0.0224615019,
0.0534471646,
-0.0100511247,
-0.0210935734,
-0.0889878646,
0.0426788479,
-0.0006503418,
-0.0084810685,
-0.0654530749,
0.0127724428,
-0.0076091113,
0.0476168357,
-0.0391865596,
0.0153746651,
0.066422306,
-0.0070761852,
-0.0038127888,
-0.0460615829,
0.0368193313,
-0.0179571025,
0.0313531794,
-0.049469389,
-0.0170454513,
0.0261327978,
0.0268686246,
-0.016692942,
-0.0781166703,
0.0235194173,
0.0003872091,
0.0396756195,
-0.061632093,
0.0344021544,
-0.019995125,
-0.044207707,
-0.0438240394,
-0.0706389695,
-0.0145247094,
0.0219202321,
-0.0402117893,
0.0088313678,
-0.0245542899,
-0.0011649521,
0.0259300154,
0.0343453027,
-0.004733942,
-0.0094926152,
-0.0139795877,
0.0516636409,
0.0828239322,
0.0609795861,
0.0237607732,
0.0521136299,
0.0215381254,
0.0634931177,
0.0270011146,
-0.0141808754,
0.0046219951,
-0.0005267149,
-0.0046704686,
-0.0217341408,
0.0218850877,
0.0158228204,
0.0632602349,
-0.0318580642,
-0.0354154892,
0.1026966199,
0.0586864613,
-0.0030127601,
0.0109854899,
-0.0557523482,
0.0133719547,
0.0143946782,
0.0067172232,
-0.0825040415,
-0.0773033053,
-0.0077837575,
0.0140759712,
-0.0297028832,
-0.0406703576,
-0.0002275313,
-0.1389978081,
-0.0048403097,
-0.0075537642,
-0.0830717236,
-0.0122848675,
-0.0500274003,
0.0011370314,
-0.0404356904,
-0.0166681185,
0.012658841,
0.0209870506,
0.0139715476,
-0.0088166855,
0.0025395257,
-0.0512862802,
0.0511914752,
-0.0241940934,
0.0400903337,
0.0112295393,
0.0341456681,
0.0006984852,
-0.0536511168,
-0.0264775679,
-0.0969394967,
0.0050310097,
-0.026670374,
0.0093371077,
-0.0092573054,
-0.0028074335,
-0.0308056939,
0.0572874136,
-0.064282909,
-0.0397754386,
0.0134039335,
0.0916785449,
-0.0199002866,
0.0171081871,
-0.0166585762,
0.0075256703,
0.0159222353,
0.0944182053,
0.0281393006,
0.025665842,
-0.031510938,
-0.0221701991,
-0.0297590178,
-0.0811983943,
-0.0015795561,
-0.0289054364,
0.0283240583,
-0.0046549691,
-0.0518939421,
-0.0525646545,
0.0535454527,
0.0474571176,
-0.0355295204,
0.005019045,
-0.0304482598,
0.0150304185,
-0.0313220695,
0.0441885665,
-0.0416362174,
-0.0085476795,
-0.0073060631,
0.0118940333,
0.0136737544,
-0.0057923631,
-0.0174058806,
0.0421896726,
-0.0268287696,
-0.0487164818,
-0.0491355918,
0.0592320785,
0.0167923849,
0.0147260996,
-0.0487184972,
-0.0396721549,
0.0526559949,
0.0369975381,
-0.0397859067,
-0.0205436461,
0.0561337657,
0.0134187359,
0.0203862544,
0.0605336316,
-0.0279865302,
-0.0055294712,
0.0004318706,
0.0511710607,
-0.0633956417,
0.0350489989,
0.0040815505,
0.007226788,
-0.003008045,
0.0165107474,
0.024405336,
-0.009940071,
-0.0001218267,
-0.0496490076,
-0.0232709181,
-0.0142580764,
0.0126401242,
0.0301436,
-0.0701280683,
-0.0163410865,
-0.0041941032,
-0.0859256834,
0.0208323319,
-0.0176448021,
-0.008448422,
0.0929560438,
0.0078619374,
0.0096088024,
-0.0405990258,
-0.026177289,
-0.0237199739,
-0.0160173941,
0.0348047391,
-0.0070744585,
0.073752597,
0.0254548546,
-0.0006611393,
-0.0266123489,
-0.0049744234,
-0.047131557,
0.00128052,
0.0181130599,
0.0588465743,
0.025453819,
0.0103765354,
0.0367882363,
0.0157101657,
-0.0387755707,
0.0211442746,
0.018945422,
0.0064562769,
-0.0256446227,
0.0570680909,
0.0360585973,
-0.0097915586,
-0.0090888785,
0.0931980684,
-0.0317848064,
0.0329272039,
0.0125730447,
-0.0156267714,
-0.0176618304,
0.0022311124,
0.002868047,
0.0766068101,
0.0230396092,
0.0504943728,
-0.0746541023,
-0.0468387716,
0.0037685907,
0.0148048094,
-0.0319518149,
0.0087554371,
0.0193690825,
0.026302455,
0.0308137275,
-0.0574992076,
0.0095252218,
0.0466724224,
-0.0906360969,
-0.0103674922,
-0.0460502915,
-6.638087863e-33,
-0.0230025444,
-0.0286150593,
0.0179316662,
-0.0306297075,
-0.0140810125,
-0.006636377,
-0.0518164001,
-0.012290962,
-0.0127179148,
0.0232944861,
-0.0268378612,
0.0249285791,
-0.005657379,
0.0340237878,
-0.0179008935,
-0.0352706537,
-0.0134592503,
0.0175542589,
-0.0390944444,
0.0211248528,
0.0800839886,
-0.0036287259,
0.0516948774,
0.0072754836,
0.023906583,
-0.044659853,
-0.0064665582,
0.0441726334,
-0.0132806776,
0.0498014428,
-0.0302626584,
0.0769034028,
0.03005578,
-0.0478568412,
0.0184432399,
0.0132975485,
-0.0825737417,
-0.0759858042,
0.053017173,
-0.0211286768,
-0.0417623669,
-0.0251836758,
0.0138436547,
0.0120656658,
0.0324930102,
0.0143759111,
0.0107129347,
-0.0222094245,
-0.0086108185,
0.0014395358,
-0.0441306457,
0.018110862,
-0.0140572181,
-0.0428959504,
-0.032175459,
0.0241744909,
-0.0198536292,
0.0027327645,
-0.0604205467,
-0.0264414158,
0.0237091035,
-0.0086648967,
0.0542502217,
-0.0179582387,
0.0108662723,
0.0270167273,
-0.0509072989,
-0.0389969163,
-0.0717249736,
0.0008375501,
-0.0309316218,
0.0238508806,
0.0559354983,
0.0959132612,
0.0826053545,
0.0366816111,
-0.0749799386,
0.0344110355,
-0.0168827735,
0.0838893801,
0.0011446626,
0.0014536168,
-0.0343611762,
-0.0301763136,
-0.0329077169,
-0.015355112,
-0.0373221934,
-0.0116115706,
0.0281543378,
-0.016090598,
-0.0550899766,
0.0487549677,
0.0254206937,
-0.0231762938,
0.040194314,
0.0749351084,
0.0029864965,
-0.0185491592,
0.0214588735,
0.0178736001,
-0.0626261756,
0.0314860344,
0.070126608,
0.006120591,
-0.0056710793,
0.0428982303,
0.0433687642,
-0.0074454318,
-0.0070442515,
-0.0120176896,
-0.0341271348,
0.013346985,
-0.0471086204,
0.0295131151,
0.0182140358,
0.050681062,
-0.0083275586,
0.0215097759,
0.0201680195,
-0.0110459151,
0.0145344744,
0.0211766977,
-0.0133195529,
-0.0121040503,
-0.0093039647,
0.0198220629,
-0.0124744652,
-0.0278954916,
0.0101210317,
-0.0561911389,
-0.0169970095,
0.0398352407,
2.555e-7,
0.0174444634,
-0.0050561442,
0.0127604706,
0.0120450621,
0.0210328195,
0.0642798617,
0.0175917987,
0.0096496334,
-0.0132396147,
-0.0318619125,
0.0058106934,
0.0617043264,
0.0061366539,
0.0420940369,
-0.0241481774,
0.0128560467,
-0.0158739276,
-0.0172814149,
-0.033602491,
-0.0193759706,
0.0788601413,
0.0669752732,
0.0199367553,
-0.0194416046,
0.0316892304,
-0.0400821567,
0.0169906113,
0.0121034309,
-0.0024673839,
-0.0219028201,
0.0159106553,
-0.0103109218,
0.000323566,
0.0730429068,
0.0028301077,
-0.0071158144,
-0.0255791321,
0.0379267521,
-0.0611928292,
-0.0447341092,
-0.0269473754,
-0.0621810555,
0.0225397497,
-0.0632559359,
0.1300514042,
-0.0797907487,
-0.0328345932,
0.0339844041,
-0.0386616886,
0.0183396731,
0.0005939518,
-0.0049287244,
-0.0197776482,
-0.0347473547,
0.013397268,
-0.0043913703,
-0.0063220509,
-0.052592013,
0.00411948,
0.005415902,
-0.0027712253,
-0.0072940742,
-0.0048151598,
-0.0388028212,
0.0447314344,
-0.0726634413,
0.018703036,
2.004628832e-34,
0.0150622791,
0.0233483575,
0.0111610731,
0.001650818,
0.0398835391,
0.0050339373,
-0.0219796021,
-0.055249013,
0.0539988317,
-0.0559165739,
0.01399065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14864v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14864v2 | How To Train Your (Compressed) Large Language Model | 2023-05-24T08:18:35 | 2023-11-19T01:14:34 | Ananya Harsh Jha, Tom Sherborne, Evan Pete Walsh, Dirk Groeneveld, Emma Strubell, Iz Beltagy | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increase in the size of large language models (LLMs), we need
compression methods that can reduce the model size while preserving the
generality and zero-shot promptability of the model. This goal is more
ambitious than the typical compression setup, which reduces the model's size at
the expense of specializing it to a specific end-task. To study this, we
develop a task-agnostic compression pipeline with a large-scale evaluation
comprising language modeling perplexity and 12 zero-shot end-tasks. Our results
show that a simple layer-wise pruning followed by continued language model
pretraining matches or outperforms three existing state-of-the-art baselines
while being 1.5x more computationally efficient. However, unlike typical
task-specialized compression, our best-compressed model significantly
underperforms a similar-sized model trained from scratch. We posit the
half-sized pretrained model as an upper bound for task-agnostic compression and
call for future work to bridge this gap under a reasonable token budget. Our
findings highlight the inadequacy of existing compression methods for LLMs and
establish a requirement for new methods that preserve a model's generality and
zero-shot promptability under compression. We release our code and evaluation
setup to facilitate reproducibility and help iterate on method design. | [
-0.0103424489,
0.0798968747,
-0.0027286236,
0.0213197023,
-0.0260666274,
0.0232188664,
-0.0090632653,
0.0300286859,
-0.0639136881,
-0.0064962665,
-0.0325372629,
-0.0381439142,
0.0120185083,
0.0048469566,
0.0297115855,
-0.0139687993,
0.0269088186,
-0.0233479403,
-0.0150373727,
0.0010713125,
-0.0080632642,
0.0186948515,
0.0325421616,
0.0527394488,
0.0204236675,
-0.021248797,
-0.0344908796,
0.0259978101,
-0.0229553692,
-0.0099707339,
-0.0138048744,
0.0757179111,
0.0587869026,
0.0400276333,
0.0000020278,
-0.0296206456,
0.0032767302,
-0.0037024759,
-0.0795181692,
0.0416596271,
0.0546825416,
-0.0178992208,
0.0003533111,
0.0118024983,
-0.0104127098,
-0.0736811385,
0.0549166203,
0.0411790349,
0.0511322394,
0.0638168156,
0.002721299,
-0.026670957,
0.0054170061,
-0.0665197372,
-0.014619967,
-0.0468464456,
0.003562452,
-0.0024559891,
-0.003931961,
0.0293634403,
-0.039635025,
0.0084065022,
0.0377630666,
0.0306342263,
-0.0141508589,
0.0362116545,
-0.017005574,
-0.0347811505,
0.0141364094,
0.0685428008,
-0.0565099344,
-0.0328199007,
-0.0141712707,
0.0095725562,
-0.0066821389,
-0.0492593385,
-0.0546093918,
0.0400414281,
0.0442637801,
0.0403667688,
0.0011506855,
-0.0013068857,
0.0577574335,
-0.0049844468,
-0.0267900229,
0.003568355,
0.0303307883,
-0.0114349751,
-0.0046353466,
0.0052549425,
-0.0197817069,
-0.06110866,
-0.0343337432,
0.0137822414,
-0.018534014,
-0.0108388085,
-0.0594726242,
-0.0555351377,
0.0302899797,
-0.0051030167,
0.0828822851,
0.0297739077,
-0.0090609631,
0.0579363704,
-0.0284548718,
0.0528504774,
-0.0090616196,
-0.0034424581,
-0.0434933156,
-0.0125372764,
-0.0230591428,
0.0104425838,
-0.0579581037,
0.0178402159,
-0.0076067699,
-0.0187523831,
-0.019002974,
0.0152729815,
0.0191419441,
0.0091457674,
0.0362279601,
-0.0101847798,
-0.0310350638,
-0.0302312151,
0.0553633906,
0.0545923337,
-0.0313007012,
0.0265062209,
-0.0012884028,
-0.0434955023,
-0.0562042482,
0.0341021121,
0.015066402,
-0.0297934059,
0.020723721,
0.0043127667,
-0.0040970566,
-0.0398558564,
-0.0145373577,
0.0077839815,
0.0036363676,
-0.0832913592,
-0.0148078948,
-0.0798238739,
0.049270656,
-0.0278322063,
0.0134840701,
-0.0326681882,
0.005480919,
0.0122950198,
-0.0373469777,
0.0563167371,
0.0132477637,
0.0306341555,
0.0029035655,
0.0050067091,
0.0297863875,
0.0879002661,
0.0202666372,
0.0139265498,
0.0259868428,
-0.0399540849,
-0.0231269822,
0.0471096858,
0.0564884655,
0.0357613489,
-0.0273308158,
-0.0023765718,
0.0139097683,
0.0093501937,
0.0664599985,
0.0558185838,
-0.0643958226,
-0.0314499214,
0.0416563526,
0.0506244749,
0.0213152543,
0.0312443953,
0.0442158468,
0.0326836705,
-0.0195605047,
0.001478691,
-0.0507932864,
0.0145956445,
-0.0317401141,
0.0061460389,
0.0391371399,
0.0370898321,
-0.0590012819,
-0.0047640428,
-0.0258501787,
-0.0376506411,
0.0398751646,
0.025391141,
0.0462598428,
0.0143225007,
-0.0346871465,
0.0819984749,
0.0271945633,
-0.0660423636,
-0.0131399557,
-0.0621643625,
-0.0022086685,
0.0197859015,
0.0301036648,
0.0134912012,
-0.0277577396,
0.002245198,
0.0289650057,
0.0103078168,
0.0194166284,
-0.0031768472,
0.0601229854,
-0.0620420948,
-0.006811135,
-0.0134652667,
0.0248695575,
-0.0081331022,
0.0404337868,
0.0101123946,
0.025807092,
-0.0551358424,
0.0009330842,
0.0271197893,
-0.049359519,
-0.03094716,
0.0189746618,
0.0030097745,
0.0121091632,
-0.0220453776,
-0.0244461298,
0.0044424403,
0.0505635999,
-0.0657215416,
0.0066172816,
-0.0317077599,
-0.0560128018,
-0.047707554,
0.0428648517,
0.0191451646,
0.0138841476,
0.0862594619,
-0.0606854148,
-0.0349797532,
0.0248253867,
-0.0288122427,
0.0490998141,
-0.0505097099,
0.0113074528,
-0.0155515205,
0.0564125143,
-0.0230632555,
0.0159042906,
-0.022345135,
0.0100006294,
0.0034384753,
-0.0166388769,
0.0143518699,
-0.0339925289,
-0.0529353134,
0.0202516597,
-0.0314348601,
0.0058323219,
0.0071282084,
0.0132093029,
0.0027500351,
-0.0241071843,
-0.1030930132,
0.00228426,
-0.0374943912,
0.0024255256,
-0.000892652,
0.0314780101,
0.0013191681,
-0.0160248242,
-0.0208540894,
0.0149944434,
0.0231504776,
0.0175792687,
-0.0045068716,
-0.0057735471,
-0.0245879963,
-0.0277285278,
-0.0510440804,
0.0326155499,
0.0814772844,
-0.0635069311,
-0.0140380878,
-0.0441878513,
0.062227536,
-0.0203279778,
0.0118557047,
0.0063149626,
-0.0547155738,
-0.0158484709,
-0.032489717,
0.0253588818,
0.0572658069,
-0.0046350793,
0.0229270719,
0.0806422457,
-0.002220019,
-0.0514720045,
0.017472079,
-0.0217086375,
-0.0542944968,
-0.0399662368,
-0.0463027321,
-0.0359221809,
0.0881794021,
-0.0248601586,
-0.0171956979,
-0.0737861767,
-0.0387805291,
-0.0185440406,
-0.0251958054,
-0.0229834449,
-0.002977943,
0.0010778001,
0.0326504856,
-0.0275710858,
-0.036668703,
0.0402157567,
-0.050278645,
-0.0227313302,
-0.0092205554,
-0.0187696926,
-0.0403649472,
0.1036337018,
0.0030427342,
0.0298683494,
0.0083786855,
0.0017425304,
-0.0556957349,
0.0015546733,
-0.0262822825,
-0.0228993483,
0.0147165013,
-0.0161106493,
0.0104397479,
-0.050804399,
-0.0562523156,
-0.0094674071,
-0.0455529802,
-0.0289856289,
0.0418355353,
0.0244970061,
-0.0148850176,
-0.0261528902,
0.006044033,
0.0096107721,
0.0403607525,
0.0074937353,
0.02728533,
0.0070031602,
0.0231950134,
0.0591809154,
0.0327740833,
0.0240379199,
-0.0262844227,
0.0325175412,
0.0655932873,
0.041325029,
0.0452156402,
-0.0442988276,
-0.0020719264,
0.049503129,
0.00834742,
-0.0225742087,
0.0163940042,
0.0465552174,
-0.0501996018,
-0.0117390165,
0.1143809482,
0.0114794709,
-0.0611172542,
0.0142347375,
-0.011012529,
0.0502246581,
0.0048485151,
0.0352016874,
-0.0886768326,
-0.0353462696,
0.0260905698,
-0.0103535727,
0.0389163941,
-0.0095902253,
-0.0267285798,
-0.1113399267,
0.0289701317,
0.0238302946,
0.0020098882,
0.0076814019,
-0.0528048053,
-0.0054734219,
-0.0070932694,
0.0161125008,
0.0150020756,
-0.0028734338,
-0.0051219463,
0.0059233657,
-0.0095145283,
-0.0510498546,
0.0413570963,
-0.0097586252,
0.0596051924,
0.0565384142,
0.010095451,
0.0115784379,
-0.004510669,
0.0375428945,
0.0328498706,
-0.019272957,
-0.0162283517,
0.0350543074,
0.0068164105,
-0.0065264697,
0.029251555,
0.0138326902,
-0.0384950042,
-0.0151153952,
-0.0049127229,
0.0817786083,
0.0067677111,
-0.0243807547,
-0.0019832614,
-0.0248274244,
-0.0181821678,
0.1033536792,
0.0510247573,
-0.0277002398,
-0.0296294559,
0.0035014106,
-0.0100869481,
-0.0548490882,
-0.0254703052,
0.0147988116,
0.0296946689,
-0.0357627384,
-0.0263239723,
-0.0062456839,
0.0144714145,
0.0238720309,
-0.0237026904,
-0.0190975871,
-0.021459531,
0.0267180987,
-0.0873847604,
0.0208254382,
-0.0366072841,
0.0097620776,
-0.0848177299,
0.0201087054,
0.0101019796,
0.0058491221,
-0.004779466,
0.0080248145,
-0.1406678408,
-0.0469022803,
-0.0227049384,
0.0387135185,
0.0183024779,
0.0384551249,
0.0023286883,
-0.0607190356,
0.0217393115,
0.0070971828,
-0.0456276163,
0.0771154687,
0.0450519435,
-0.0619288385,
0.0192246325,
0.0915800035,
-0.0425718166,
0.029796904,
0.0206358731,
0.0505331606,
-0.0132425195,
-0.0257672071,
-0.0016776788,
0.0097123785,
0.0363554358,
-0.0151120154,
0.0172016043,
0.0046014325,
0.0211887639,
-0.0217906237,
0.0119263083,
-0.0536470711,
0.0093976008,
0.0419061631,
0.0048665972,
0.0216271672,
0.0140228635,
0.0210021865,
0.0592695437,
-0.0283097737,
0.0018851723,
-0.0360557586,
-0.0430341773,
0.0572930612,
0.0260640029,
-0.0355535485,
-0.016584387,
-0.0085647153,
-0.0043401993,
-0.0524015911,
0.012733195,
0.0047969706,
0.0274325274,
-0.0515507869,
0.0469713509,
-0.0377899893,
-0.0554387458,
-0.0066017061,
0.0187937096,
0.0620301366,
-0.0086857788,
0.0347670615,
-0.0018687951,
-0.0125234826,
-0.0510149822,
0.0047798143,
-0.0186431743,
-0.0284342822,
0.0078511182,
0.016218463,
-0.013004953,
0.0090902252,
0.1118174419,
0.0241361428,
0.034284912,
0.0204005111,
0.029312795,
-0.0242535435,
-0.0287512466,
-0.0170312747,
0.0430837423,
-0.0145021938,
0.0109575512,
-0.016396651,
-0.0801956132,
0.009884282,
-0.0123754432,
-0.0237980746,
0.0001791149,
0.0259707887,
0.0415007211,
-0.0083924765,
-0.0050522331,
-0.007712543,
-0.0107052661,
0.0007492232,
-0.0373004004,
0.0045847269,
-6.262582071e-33,
-0.0083054537,
0.0356616564,
0.0203032233,
-0.0672943369,
-0.0395984426,
0.0351751335,
-0.0428466089,
0.0045457515,
-0.0359012298,
0.0034044271,
-0.0311450735,
0.0001797694,
-0.0035288802,
0.0499874204,
-0.0102776615,
0.0123300105,
0.0800698474,
-0.0186291132,
-0.0144891236,
0.0301620122,
-0.0009899011,
0.0196653511,
0.0403000601,
-0.0078940457,
-0.040757779,
-0.0012824413,
-0.0083808862,
0.010936439,
0.0264528655,
0.0454617813,
-0.0351678059,
0.0210803263,
0.0142021161,
-0.0584057234,
-0.0346042514,
0.0321669988,
-0.0664342418,
-0.0379318222,
0.0093612755,
-0.0133197829,
-0.0280393586,
-0.035527356,
0.0208026469,
-0.0021357427,
-0.0062786764,
-0.0413886271,
-0.0100501357,
-0.0135952523,
-0.0383328795,
-0.0113900481,
-0.0320192836,
0.0024332218,
-0.0076651946,
-0.0455306806,
0.0472096093,
0.0390103348,
-0.0326946937,
0.0348922983,
-0.0280893873,
0.0089139342,
-0.0079144761,
0.066260539,
0.047180526,
0.0170074962,
0.02081706,
0.0350801907,
-0.0036147179,
0.0129242633,
-0.05733243,
0.0105103031,
0.0436796807,
0.0302247871,
0.0255827904,
0.0491458811,
0.047903765,
-0.0150493104,
-0.0761252269,
-0.0156947765,
0.0432796143,
0.0543807931,
0.0234881267,
0.0283436626,
-0.0088912081,
-0.0356947444,
-0.0505766422,
-0.0219739415,
-0.021181494,
-0.0339596905,
0.0197513923,
0.0427133627,
-0.0136273149,
-0.0226178169,
0.0606612004,
-0.0577651598,
-0.0147525566,
0.034167327,
-0.008175469,
0.0256043617,
0.0251831207,
0.0391835198,
-0.0450453609,
0.0012651333,
0.01773935,
-0.0231110975,
-0.0024737834,
-0.008255885,
0.0349531844,
0.0423702411,
-0.0609887689,
-0.0202565584,
-0.0178467352,
-0.0049341279,
0.0092050433,
0.045523379,
0.0444788672,
0.0333810225,
0.0118431579,
0.0497490428,
0.0106329741,
-0.0162832476,
-0.0138566075,
-0.0107234204,
0.0296883341,
0.0372933783,
-0.0110588744,
-0.0130543998,
-0.0595577061,
-0.0147896633,
0.042335283,
-0.0405079834,
-0.0280658714,
0.0202175304,
2.591e-7,
0.0136454822,
0.0133218132,
-0.0123361275,
-0.0085739084,
0.0158385709,
0.016127592,
-0.0106868893,
0.0206586551,
-0.0254288949,
0.0041925679,
0.0062634414,
0.0620527528,
0.0576485544,
0.0022905141,
-0.0970926508,
0.0130676078,
-0.0509086549,
0.019740805,
-0.0326907486,
-0.0104290564,
0.01247265,
0.154671371,
0.0226556007,
-0.0209675264,
0.0036236318,
-0.0227471869,
0.0524526462,
-0.0437500551,
0.0062690079,
0.0120483255,
-0.0108995745,
0.0310679171,
-0.0094268033,
-0.0220596865,
-0.0176307037,
0.0189316384,
-0.0162815824,
0.098298721,
-0.0172122158,
-0.0169470608,
0.0133736823,
-0.0149033982,
-0.0351007096,
-0.0573990978,
0.0703697354,
-0.0349934176,
-0.0198756326,
-0.0561158843,
-0.0042078872,
-0.000418967,
0.0154153211,
-0.0201312266,
0.0142864855,
0.0169527438,
0.0371988565,
-0.0216819104,
-0.0199076887,
-0.0921178907,
-0.0275364332,
-0.0076289093,
-0.0473242253,
-0.0213059559,
-0.0465555005,
-0.0196017567,
0.0542945899,
-0.0436698981,
0.013966958,
2.532282762e-34,
0.0495451465,
-0.0030481925,
0.0191348176,
0.0190390516,
-0.0023202905,
-0.0442250483,
-0.0078390604,
0.0117847137,
-0.0133259986,
-0.1038935408,
-0.0244939942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14859v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14859v2 | Utility-Probability Duality of Neural Networks | 2023-05-24T08:09:07 | 2023-05-25T09:25:24 | Huang Bojun, Fei Yuan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE | It is typically understood that the training of modern neural networks is a
process of fitting the probability distribution of desired output. However,
recent paradoxical observations in a number of language generation tasks let
one wonder if this canonical probability-based explanation can really account
for the empirical success of deep learning. To resolve this issue, we propose
an alternative utility-based explanation to the standard supervised learning
procedure in deep learning. The basic idea is to interpret the learned neural
network not as a probability model but as an ordinal utility function that
encodes the preference revealed in training data. In this perspective, training
of the neural network corresponds to a utility learning process. Specifically,
we show that for all neural networks with softmax outputs, the SGD learning
dynamic of maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) can be seen as an iteration
process that optimizes the neural network toward an optimal utility function.
This utility-based interpretation can explain several otherwise-paradoxical
observations about the neural networks thus trained. Moreover, our
utility-based theory also entails an equation that can transform the learned
utility values back to a new kind of probability estimation with which
probability-compatible decision rules enjoy dramatic (double-digits)
performance improvements. These evidences collectively reveal a phenomenon of
utility-probability duality in terms of what modern neural networks are (truly)
modeling: We thought they are one thing (probabilities), until the
unexplainable showed up; changing mindset and treating them as another thing
(utility values) largely reconcile the theory, despite remaining subtleties
regarding its original (probabilistic) identity. | [
-0.0240016058,
0.0883521661,
-0.0034587341,
-0.0203416776,
-0.0391368791,
0.0149174444,
0.0116039542,
-0.0095019378,
-0.0690986216,
0.0267785732,
0.0044455226,
-0.0471095443,
0.0353462398,
0.0188323669,
0.0224945303,
-0.0345254838,
-0.0111152492,
-0.001833102,
0.0187274329,
-0.0252721235,
-0.0448620021,
-0.0486078486,
-0.0348770432,
0.0487238504,
-0.0019407043,
0.0479363389,
0.0176251866,
-0.0484176949,
0.0157647636,
0.013051264,
-0.0006261723,
0.0071918303,
0.0015490466,
0.035911236,
0.0000017795,
-0.0641251504,
-0.0045679421,
-0.0056097033,
-0.029030079,
-0.0206725355,
-0.0023749084,
0.0043740477,
-0.0220626872,
-0.0012843841,
-0.0131630227,
0.016556032,
0.0828565136,
-0.0084947394,
-0.0489687361,
0.0495819412,
0.0220893379,
-0.0460721217,
0.0307299104,
-0.0634218454,
-0.001022589,
0.0123765487,
-0.0103420569,
-0.020293396,
-0.0286038816,
-0.0168952104,
0.0002638702,
0.0173487291,
0.0722938254,
0.024642162,
0.0102916425,
0.079596512,
0.0031710563,
-0.0217523277,
0.0093059232,
0.0297971815,
-0.0599456765,
0.0058901818,
0.0172690116,
-0.029891327,
0.0074482434,
-0.0119023109,
0.0045768255,
0.0641832799,
0.037543539,
0.0871899799,
0.0165868867,
0.0616577715,
0.0452037975,
0.0269007739,
-0.0371970907,
0.0846175402,
-0.0266661346,
0.0006768674,
0.0262659714,
0.0553429089,
-0.0480399691,
-0.0221249722,
0.0389154926,
0.0203372426,
0.0176365469,
-0.0018048459,
-0.0156970955,
-0.007883315,
0.0019796095,
-0.0459314696,
0.0493065529,
0.0413533971,
-0.0265427064,
-0.0196881443,
-0.025824517,
0.0263765734,
0.0118561741,
-0.0149379019,
-0.0246910509,
0.0784526169,
0.0106838122,
-0.0030456018,
0.0292641539,
0.0573063418,
-0.0306838732,
-0.0318066403,
-0.0737640709,
-0.0061295531,
-0.0262402128,
0.0034354862,
0.010320805,
0.0618331991,
-0.074457407,
0.0283871256,
-0.0606928505,
0.0365526229,
-0.0197061412,
0.0420304947,
0.0599021241,
0.0100522405,
0.0347197726,
0.012732002,
0.0081883725,
0.0033361013,
-0.0046523591,
0.0487508848,
-0.0463666134,
0.0160159823,
-0.0342537053,
-0.0652713627,
-0.0393692963,
-0.0213430841,
0.0384458117,
-0.0567520559,
-0.0375006013,
0.0053435303,
-0.0027074306,
-0.063374877,
0.0080885971,
-0.0293182749,
-0.0207018889,
0.0474677682,
0.0246618371,
-0.0191106144,
0.0456660204,
0.0046347473,
0.0318244249,
0.064718321,
0.0331445709,
0.0427672826,
0.0100116413,
-0.0130608641,
-0.0122856693,
0.0187618993,
0.0118957944,
-0.0155127095,
-0.0442918018,
-0.0817809403,
-0.0580354184,
0.059791021,
0.0517167971,
0.0224529281,
-0.0467045605,
-0.0067393198,
0.0736348331,
-0.0007912857,
0.0428405888,
0.0128035778,
0.0280739032,
-0.033032041,
-0.0278628562,
0.0975857824,
-0.0309827253,
0.0388169475,
0.0197591763,
0.0258197822,
-0.0116411038,
-0.0095950607,
-0.0088199181,
-0.0653052852,
0.0648810267,
-0.059098836,
0.0073346039,
-0.0115259951,
0.0609424151,
-0.0041922121,
-0.0053171259,
0.0132665588,
0.0164810494,
0.0043322407,
0.0283377096,
-0.0557767414,
0.0208107866,
0.0310910251,
0.0096872319,
-0.005032029,
0.0107971961,
0.0173717737,
-0.0788654163,
0.0269775223,
0.0323689915,
0.0089058941,
-0.0032805,
-0.0613303445,
-0.0029312107,
-0.019512713,
0.0242786836,
0.0550837666,
-0.0323082246,
0.010751619,
0.0279477313,
0.0113433879,
-0.0327551961,
-0.0044084699,
0.0044568102,
-0.0239858534,
0.0848026648,
0.0223346334,
0.0193721205,
-0.0299174283,
-0.0097424928,
0.0458345078,
-0.002498185,
-0.0294427704,
-0.0253970157,
0.0115850214,
-0.0892628506,
0.0101760346,
0.0204201657,
-0.0301354267,
0.0378340147,
0.042762883,
0.0106384233,
-0.035361167,
0.0323457643,
-0.0205524135,
0.0000240079,
-0.0036054731,
0.0041567921,
0.0211426113,
0.0417911559,
-0.052486755,
0.0367765054,
-0.0082602482,
-0.0109072244,
-0.0082196118,
0.0015199226,
0.0158843305,
-0.0351135433,
0.03325174,
-0.0108967712,
-0.0180805717,
0.0313839987,
0.0394137762,
0.0229901187,
0.0100258291,
-0.0038830184,
-0.0116671547,
-0.0095433397,
-0.0441967212,
0.0403695516,
-0.010841947,
-0.0035101257,
0.0242208652,
0.0024846203,
-0.0709962547,
0.0481146984,
0.0127671808,
0.0258218758,
0.0348164178,
0.0180104654,
0.0514377244,
-0.0244124066,
-0.051662676,
0.0120435115,
0.0095918281,
-0.0041339975,
0.0488457568,
-0.0406625904,
0.0599304028,
-0.0102756638,
-0.0143434424,
-0.0001312211,
-0.0111639323,
0.0188567881,
-0.0179265458,
0.061043296,
0.0708773211,
0.0078574587,
0.0257182568,
0.0643588901,
0.052354347,
-0.0508350432,
-0.0274860393,
-0.0680034086,
-0.0256458949,
-0.0175965056,
-0.0330341309,
-0.0276253242,
0.0215860717,
0.0180053618,
-0.0124671254,
-0.0356320031,
0.0227478594,
-0.0149897942,
-0.0780942366,
-0.0175854731,
0.0037612049,
-0.0077224541,
0.0605073273,
0.0152188903,
-0.0374402441,
0.0581489019,
0.0126713766,
0.0401905403,
-0.0450104102,
-0.0454094969,
-0.0048643984,
0.0047508744,
0.0516614653,
0.0165127646,
-0.0090530226,
-0.0169465393,
-0.0772359297,
-0.0093689729,
0.0190875698,
-0.001235877,
0.0389895886,
-0.0608498789,
-0.0246221032,
-0.0472907536,
-0.0450943559,
-0.0223308187,
-0.046044901,
0.0010049748,
0.0261578038,
0.005882273,
-0.031145284,
0.017112188,
0.0042327903,
0.0001052819,
0.0301845744,
-0.0195780862,
-0.0214836728,
-0.0198208354,
0.0481487401,
0.0313156322,
0.0108384723,
0.0727315694,
-0.001707514,
-0.0391535945,
0.0252527557,
0.0119687645,
0.0599763058,
-0.0545316897,
0.0350746438,
0.0007683569,
-0.0242652502,
-0.055878669,
0.0571711734,
-0.0082021905,
-0.038900055,
0.0052601863,
0.0832911506,
-0.0301559791,
-0.0447487645,
0.0296109542,
0.0510669425,
0.0175666437,
-0.0017451512,
0.0060301549,
-0.0446718335,
-0.0057514249,
0.0087675145,
0.0428803787,
-0.0513169058,
-0.0450321771,
0.0094369277,
-0.0718147233,
0.0044929697,
-0.0086893318,
-0.0282214954,
-0.0195868593,
0.0086075859,
-0.0464029424,
-0.0275976807,
0.0124025401,
0.0119838426,
0.0253899451,
0.0268405229,
0.0550790094,
0.0242685825,
-0.0211965516,
-0.0378692299,
-0.0526024029,
0.0178347174,
0.1171933338,
0.0110564763,
-0.0582319796,
-0.0107159512,
0.0075551383,
0.0022120266,
-0.0043413923,
0.0483069308,
0.0166613869,
0.054010082,
-0.0416443236,
0.0032812969,
0.0647845119,
-0.0364524238,
0.0150455432,
-0.0106668016,
0.0198594444,
-0.0231168848,
-0.0682483017,
-0.0199836195,
0.0268618017,
0.0299408697,
0.0182954185,
-0.0066448068,
-0.0436956398,
-0.0285608359,
-0.06076793,
0.0259076189,
-0.0444303565,
-0.0356811769,
0.0316574536,
0.0184560977,
-0.0900747105,
-0.0690268651,
-0.0267978534,
-0.0403425395,
0.0685928687,
0.0103228446,
-0.0552798845,
0.0136137074,
-0.0021757009,
-0.0240940377,
0.00177948,
0.0364603177,
-0.0162351709,
-0.0374373794,
0.0018733845,
0.0385091528,
-0.0678497627,
-0.033499945,
-0.0326160043,
-0.0354826897,
-0.0322351791,
-0.0172371268,
0.0496543013,
0.0296098776,
-0.0141824065,
0.0257897992,
-0.0956629738,
0.0478595272,
0.1045344993,
-0.0182732083,
0.0190126393,
0.0282945111,
-0.0069669182,
-0.0088909985,
0.0180217568,
-0.0078097871,
0.0093128802,
-0.0472197346,
0.0146139488,
-0.032149151,
-0.0230828952,
0.0266681761,
-0.0346837677,
0.0311530735,
-0.0633127168,
0.009763225,
-0.0398163311,
-0.0203142464,
0.0464005657,
0.0052982583,
-0.0112779923,
-0.0322158448,
0.0571607724,
0.0606011562,
-0.0239956602,
-0.0191613119,
0.0741998032,
0.0101911118,
0.0042724819,
-0.0395758413,
0.0327666663,
-0.006082891,
0.0470404588,
0.001503926,
0.0003136142,
0.045512747,
-0.005464782,
0.0481448732,
0.0082937414,
0.0245042853,
0.0333647951,
0.0316787995,
-0.0030470726,
-0.0325055756,
-0.0705810636,
-0.0763697624,
0.0113016609,
0.005701167,
0.0442534946,
-0.011132109,
0.0121816276,
-0.0770389065,
-0.0162454806,
-0.0445461757,
-0.009101674,
-0.0218987875,
0.0054398882,
0.0032276118,
-0.0136227179,
-0.0093559278,
-0.0182889607,
0.0857549757,
0.016312547,
0.0101009002,
-0.0326460302,
0.0204676706,
-0.0086133573,
-0.0719920397,
0.0046114088,
0.0541847721,
-0.0083848797,
-0.0415860862,
-0.0070936717,
-0.0421055257,
-0.0658452809,
0.0441945232,
0.0623702742,
-0.0686526299,
0.039477095,
0.0596803315,
-0.0837404355,
0.0450283997,
-0.0411582477,
0.0194283202,
-0.0387514085,
0.0199020617,
-0.0175663121,
-5.542034523e-33,
0.0407461785,
-0.0301512238,
0.0176987071,
0.0324672237,
0.02959227,
0.0008749921,
-0.0105630942,
0.0051890435,
-0.0188213196,
0.017281821,
0.003430181,
-0.0198686924,
0.0227555856,
0.0495318025,
0.0299533233,
-0.0256392192,
0.034470614,
-0.03829493,
-0.0025130713,
-0.0084425239,
0.0417509414,
-0.0023413829,
0.0351305194,
-0.0536061302,
-0.0155066187,
0.074828282,
-0.0082973102,
-0.0070600412,
-0.0168615971,
0.0375308692,
-0.0246421639,
0.0534162894,
0.0117424233,
-0.0620283484,
0.0043745129,
-0.0225286931,
-0.013057258,
-0.023364557,
-0.045457229,
0.034136571,
-0.0582113229,
-0.0312844552,
0.0952351689,
0.008458483,
-0.0172322989,
-0.0020966011,
0.0327294692,
-0.0182929523,
-0.0574898869,
-0.0623499341,
-0.0075369752,
0.0056007649,
-0.017283123,
-0.0294799879,
0.0222575478,
0.0199830886,
-0.0309262797,
-0.0057221111,
-0.0417341292,
0.0434125923,
0.0181389768,
0.0403070413,
0.0488811173,
0.0175829064,
-0.0075480407,
0.0329960585,
0.0530365966,
-0.0351226591,
-0.0129392277,
-0.0098708756,
0.0395292267,
0.0140870698,
0.016378114,
0.0251885206,
0.0558391735,
-0.0358520709,
-0.071212247,
0.0408748984,
0.0796507373,
-0.0800179243,
0.0397832803,
0.0150212301,
-0.0197272804,
-0.0367954187,
-0.0456061289,
-0.0692989007,
-0.01709635,
-0.0115994522,
0.0092809983,
0.0184547231,
0.0180602167,
-0.016784044,
0.0279573053,
-0.054741364,
-0.025135491,
0.0236710031,
-0.0481986776,
0.0261365995,
0.0023883299,
0.0046747052,
-0.0730630532,
-0.0341161415,
-0.026269896,
0.0245572682,
-0.0157828908,
0.0458300859,
0.0265717972,
0.0096165128,
0.0221166071,
0.0058710114,
-0.0414916836,
0.0016693156,
0.0456116647,
0.0448631085,
0.0377527066,
-0.0566880181,
0.0014414758,
0.0207152758,
-0.0038921242,
0.0029411963,
-0.0285652224,
0.0045015253,
0.0005869066,
0.0363435522,
-0.0364181101,
-0.0029292018,
-0.0385831371,
0.0168417804,
0.0034945954,
-0.0522164069,
-0.0314918421,
0.0151129682,
2.534e-7,
0.0312948897,
-0.0122105628,
-0.0129051488,
0.0218733903,
0.0486944206,
0.0798896477,
0.0018321986,
-0.0133103654,
0.0224729143,
0.0020210757,
0.0363151133,
-0.0149561679,
0.0148427151,
-0.0053869789,
-0.0345403366,
-0.0558908209,
0.0040447684,
0.0268675014,
0.0003779666,
-0.0200447366,
0.0178390052,
0.0473466218,
-0.0124045182,
-0.0608550273,
0.0630171672,
-0.0008048579,
0.0463319123,
-0.033907868,
0.0462819822,
0.0051074526,
0.0104987752,
0.0100591918,
-0.0144881448,
-0.0111549962,
-0.0111452192,
-0.0051554246,
-0.0059937485,
0.0535776243,
0.0383265242,
-0.0703804791,
-0.0065575414,
-0.0046072216,
0.0202760808,
-0.0613183901,
0.0588224605,
-0.0650967285,
-0.0491908975,
0.0124256629,
-0.0233141202,
-0.0152559197,
0.0030608666,
-0.033247944,
-0.0320236757,
-0.0218339153,
-0.0189209338,
0.0019558121,
-0.0143567529,
-0.0390721001,
0.0037880722,
0.0480356254,
-0.0494247302,
-0.0394732952,
-0.0287880301,
0.0507032797,
0.0370039083,
-0.013570847,
-0.0542515852,
2.042489163e-34,
0.0101058111,
0.0174180679,
0.0210415218,
-0.0522191003,
-0.0117501616,
0.0021593578,
-0.0174383167,
0.0137734702,
0.0602240302,
-0.0181766991,
-0.0711358041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14857v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14857v1 | BUFFET: Benchmarking Large Language Models for Few-shot Cross-lingual Transfer | 2023-05-24T08:06:33 | 2023-05-24T08:06:33 | Akari Asai, Sneha Kudugunta, Xinyan Velocity Yu, Terra Blevins, Hila Gonen, Machel Reid, Yulia Tsvetkov, Sebastian Ruder, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite remarkable advancements in few-shot generalization in natural
language processing, most models are developed and evaluated primarily in
English. To facilitate research on few-shot cross-lingual transfer, we
introduce a new benchmark, called BUFFET, which unifies 15 diverse tasks across
54 languages in a sequence-to-sequence format and provides a fixed set of
few-shot examples and instructions. BUFFET is designed to establish a rigorous
and equitable evaluation framework for few-shot cross-lingual transfer across a
broad range of tasks and languages. Using BUFFET, we perform thorough
evaluations of state-of-the-art multilingual large language models with
different transfer methods, namely in-context learning and fine-tuning. Our
findings reveal significant room for improvement in few-shot in-context
cross-lingual transfer. In particular, ChatGPT with in-context learning often
performs worse than much smaller mT5-base models fine-tuned on English task
data and few-shot in-language examples. Our analysis suggests various avenues
for future research in few-shot cross-lingual transfer, such as improved
pretraining, understanding, and future evaluations. | [
-0.0228509009,
0.0286628827,
-0.0001803201,
0.0588278845,
-0.0634072796,
0.0267647579,
0.0150121413,
-0.0342256427,
-0.0165895093,
-0.0339874513,
-0.0808906555,
-0.0448083542,
-0.0042762905,
-0.0228099469,
0.0321147218,
-0.0607269853,
0.0624909177,
-0.0358335525,
-0.0479632989,
0.0184365902,
-0.0207165964,
0.0034021644,
-0.0067173573,
0.0254562795,
0.0265742987,
-0.0245021004,
0.0172934178,
-0.000802588,
0.0365571082,
-0.0002539217,
-0.0172352307,
0.0383592695,
0.0178459641,
0.0400494821,
0.0000017652,
-0.0443917923,
-0.0199622791,
0.0159426704,
0.0026218037,
0.0278424919,
0.0542918965,
-0.0410726704,
-0.0076168585,
0.009767266,
-0.0029724347,
-0.053321328,
0.0516950339,
0.0503799282,
0.0281557906,
0.1019740179,
-0.0181238912,
-0.0508379489,
0.0222438909,
-0.0589318462,
0.0324176587,
-0.0816450268,
0.0322164036,
0.02376578,
-0.0012212817,
0.0076355068,
-0.0218015723,
0.0304737389,
0.0176081192,
0.0208442137,
-0.0289219115,
0.0081784939,
-0.0509987846,
-0.0116394069,
-0.0318015479,
0.072693944,
-0.0524007455,
-0.0128192147,
-0.015590406,
-0.0106059024,
-0.0003843489,
-0.0248075239,
-0.0781132057,
-0.0068993438,
0.02912407,
0.0144150117,
0.019956056,
-0.0059888568,
0.0368316285,
-0.0116724921,
-0.0228767078,
0.0066891983,
0.0418419838,
-0.0074765463,
0.0349133313,
0.0373279676,
-0.0282660238,
-0.0429840423,
-0.0040550102,
0.014355747,
-0.0286879018,
-0.0075184568,
-0.0390395187,
-0.0203286596,
-0.0025387625,
-0.0197894461,
0.0496759303,
0.0494905524,
-0.045821026,
0.0579437055,
-0.0514421128,
0.0412907638,
-0.0393724777,
0.0101168547,
-0.0426153541,
-0.0428476557,
-0.0760650262,
0.028940862,
-0.0233873203,
0.0024111448,
-0.0233224425,
-0.02951671,
-0.0378836431,
-0.0056049353,
0.0042609642,
-0.029816987,
0.0240335204,
-0.0422287881,
-0.0559698045,
-0.0047175433,
0.030663427,
0.0834324211,
-0.0208448749,
0.0274455566,
0.0366989337,
-0.0544440262,
-0.0407941081,
0.0205558613,
0.0218650792,
-0.0653307363,
0.0178464241,
0.07273449,
-0.0429394729,
-0.0419536605,
-0.0299684405,
0.0181692969,
-0.0457024276,
-0.094581157,
0.0067013097,
-0.0588691942,
0.0461324863,
-0.0111490013,
0.028991336,
0.0132640898,
-0.0217470042,
0.0028142673,
-0.0234568045,
0.0432529785,
0.0390273407,
-0.0017225768,
-0.0039910534,
-0.0073785377,
-0.0220680702,
0.0934565961,
0.0076858662,
0.0254364703,
0.0146871181,
-0.033578001,
-0.0318860188,
0.0671183616,
0.0207803547,
0.0155675095,
-0.0313263834,
-0.0101457518,
0.0540653132,
0.0398036018,
0.0266374797,
0.0319085531,
-0.0451083481,
0.0225276705,
0.0623134673,
0.0362152085,
0.0419118144,
0.0287708919,
0.0658934265,
-0.0105327079,
-0.0127079263,
-0.0000455348,
-0.0287090596,
0.0376612023,
-0.020421356,
0.0068364209,
0.0211044997,
0.0494862869,
-0.0371907167,
0.0338378958,
0.0197875313,
0.0115527436,
0.0069754603,
-0.0056520305,
0.0670538992,
0.0244687777,
-0.0383166336,
0.0169252697,
0.0534447543,
-0.0148049258,
0.0348857976,
-0.0118534537,
0.0064180805,
0.0447927713,
-0.0068075419,
0.0177700687,
-0.0461557284,
-0.0104720192,
0.0438926183,
0.0130041791,
0.0746139959,
-0.0092371432,
0.05328504,
-0.0478979573,
-0.0061149094,
-0.0163487662,
0.0059432555,
0.0459895693,
-0.0148744537,
0.0576623343,
0.0159967411,
-0.0276793428,
0.0032595391,
0.0232465304,
-0.0571998544,
-0.0275391284,
0.028499309,
0.0009508054,
0.0391224436,
0.0061602485,
-0.0182927307,
-0.0102914544,
0.0029904256,
-0.0442979857,
0.0017841543,
0.0123537797,
-0.0594222546,
-0.0755125657,
0.0179289449,
-0.0112111075,
-0.008563906,
0.0138131622,
-0.0617748275,
-0.0345491543,
-0.0003176238,
0.0255557466,
0.0135993268,
-0.0332090743,
0.0199235324,
0.0210881364,
0.0626314282,
-0.0083666639,
0.0224535409,
0.0417422131,
-0.0017487301,
0.0004418141,
-0.0225228518,
-0.0109648472,
-0.0236781929,
-0.007905608,
0.0440152213,
-0.0148850624,
0.00962824,
0.0108613195,
0.0451844931,
-0.043652527,
-0.0245870184,
-0.1090026796,
0.0506450608,
-0.0159699786,
0.0384939685,
0.0233590268,
0.0231151655,
-0.0044762697,
0.003883563,
-0.0395780317,
0.0262765381,
0.0053506834,
0.0358063802,
0.0196618512,
-0.0001453731,
0.0192411896,
-0.0327252075,
-0.0126594184,
0.0228060558,
0.0570134595,
-0.0565050207,
-0.0274663959,
-0.0360753275,
0.0179524273,
-0.0206056628,
-0.0137563255,
0.0028978088,
-0.0291828364,
-0.0231539812,
-0.0088304635,
0.0278752185,
0.0386652648,
-0.0162187684,
-0.0224644747,
0.0057568667,
-0.0516850688,
-0.0462067239,
0.0080898739,
0.0082703987,
-0.0405527949,
-0.0424004197,
-0.000418053,
-0.0175432302,
0.0749737099,
-0.0336039886,
-0.0063368469,
-0.0797087103,
-0.0070092869,
-0.0138562871,
-0.0194157269,
-0.0350932553,
0.0405486897,
-0.0069452981,
-0.0110194078,
-0.031547755,
0.0125329643,
0.0260162391,
-0.0521763861,
-0.018543331,
-0.0484877415,
-0.001515695,
-0.0377957188,
0.0531541631,
0.0016033814,
0.0136302067,
0.0140843308,
-0.0246511921,
-0.0586169921,
0.0006979639,
0.0327257589,
-0.0044356044,
0.0268011075,
-0.0330492817,
0.009856727,
-0.0218287427,
-0.0253457054,
0.0046072765,
-0.0239610355,
-0.0135416202,
0.0355159566,
0.0157461818,
0.0079832133,
-0.0498160981,
0.0041812803,
0.0439717844,
0.0505976304,
0.0042999084,
0.0025530972,
-0.0234801117,
0.0467072688,
0.033086814,
0.0061353664,
0.0017882165,
-0.0374243632,
0.03380429,
0.0212823115,
0.0278666243,
0.0171402227,
-0.0322853513,
0.017694721,
0.0255189054,
-0.0186363645,
-0.038734246,
0.0123441378,
0.0780488253,
-0.0512850769,
-0.0097609321,
0.0770641863,
-0.0204361174,
-0.041701775,
0.0139291994,
0.0084517058,
0.010173616,
0.000720843,
0.0243724398,
-0.0914386436,
-0.0602099523,
0.0212570708,
-0.032673642,
0.0318022706,
-0.0195737332,
-0.0210181549,
-0.1336072683,
0.0258535836,
0.0148080112,
-0.1048178822,
-0.0123459687,
-0.0269594975,
0.0013809821,
-0.0251939502,
0.0516191237,
-0.0295055881,
-0.0253401473,
-0.0104844682,
0.0392210782,
0.0240046177,
-0.0859157741,
0.0554116294,
-0.0615944602,
0.0512908436,
0.041340109,
0.0164727177,
-0.0095881289,
0.0097981198,
0.0699290931,
-0.0242931023,
-0.017479891,
0.002596179,
0.0407913588,
-0.0136551894,
-0.0341280587,
0.0414903723,
-0.0015128488,
-0.0315363817,
-0.0065664849,
0.0266918764,
0.0891376212,
0.0553987697,
-0.0450677276,
0.0409368277,
-0.0144157875,
0.0215925053,
0.0663333014,
0.0227762368,
-0.0371192433,
-0.0077478229,
0.0133939451,
-0.0310576186,
-0.0343855955,
-0.0335569121,
0.0170937777,
-0.0445815735,
-0.0605426244,
-0.0869026259,
-0.0419899076,
0.0258686058,
0.0533575825,
0.0160569698,
-0.0002114549,
0.0062147062,
0.0023873991,
0.0094510503,
0.0221739169,
-0.0460278168,
0.0077209752,
-0.042567715,
0.0099920342,
0.0348059349,
-0.010611685,
-0.0041716751,
0.0065761916,
-0.0926162153,
-0.0539643727,
-0.0251940545,
0.0616068579,
0.0084920488,
0.0489712097,
-0.014112086,
-0.0234750435,
0.0287045185,
0.0137083689,
-0.0198300537,
0.0012036255,
0.0381168947,
-0.0142140463,
-0.0053769848,
0.0463833213,
-0.0438209698,
0.025988346,
0.0313297734,
0.0596723817,
0.0111347754,
0.0060621747,
-0.0050130635,
0.0011589483,
0.0252050161,
0.0048741489,
-0.04634111,
-0.0089094397,
0.0157501474,
-0.0340463221,
0.0043360582,
-0.0490518399,
-0.0485934764,
0.070759736,
0.0040106704,
-0.0038741154,
0.0061982651,
0.0211777892,
0.0042263884,
-0.0415998287,
-0.0105668604,
0.007388751,
0.0290621519,
0.022411203,
0.0291014165,
-0.0276785642,
-0.0292362329,
0.027100388,
0.0273642521,
-0.0695030913,
0.0383332856,
0.0077418224,
0.0259922184,
0.0075679356,
0.0017200022,
-0.0344258361,
-0.0121059828,
-0.0196295045,
0.0207516085,
0.0808389038,
-0.0311790481,
0.11089544,
0.0151412087,
-0.0279000234,
-0.0447785184,
0.0513671748,
-0.0449360423,
0.0048053758,
-0.0128101222,
-0.0095675001,
-0.0068193721,
0.0181434061,
0.0807770565,
-0.0055023846,
0.0413055308,
0.0381026193,
0.0106332041,
-0.0206315499,
-0.0308838002,
0.0327971503,
-0.0258435532,
-0.0104270363,
-0.0065191034,
-0.0096344333,
-0.0640365407,
-0.0017075506,
-0.036337588,
-0.0070469622,
0.024498621,
0.0047065937,
0.0708486959,
-0.0211807117,
-0.0151425377,
-0.0197387319,
-0.004145564,
0.0228498932,
-0.0091185542,
-0.0027511665,
-6.094554337e-33,
-0.0378266424,
0.0496448241,
0.0315730982,
-0.0160423964,
-0.0417426042,
-0.0311857145,
-0.035249304,
-0.0049736449,
-0.0207679886,
0.0178274345,
-0.0051879105,
-0.0277330093,
0.0276927929,
0.0442158245,
0.0291964617,
-0.0161182992,
0.0489295051,
0.0122257285,
-0.0332135297,
0.0320294797,
0.0198204033,
0.0455901138,
0.1127022654,
0.0003461938,
-0.0159235578,
0.0330854021,
0.0074192286,
0.0019704991,
0.0118703758,
0.022368487,
0.0005002181,
0.0269624572,
0.0169661492,
-0.0570629127,
-0.0308873784,
0.0115157729,
-0.0760267302,
-0.0383154936,
0.0288016573,
0.0182779785,
0.0130454078,
-0.0320144631,
-0.0000946109,
-0.0282576885,
0.0164954606,
-0.0332236513,
0.0005852678,
-0.0316634141,
-0.0305443462,
-0.0043578055,
-0.0927864388,
0.0137663269,
-0.0217804816,
-0.0233149417,
0.0378467068,
0.0627674535,
-0.0146445371,
0.0089262379,
-0.03065826,
-0.0130466335,
-0.0286453571,
0.0282729324,
0.0720272213,
0.0014990533,
-0.0024278418,
0.036663767,
0.0447265916,
0.0102852574,
0.0291818287,
-0.0127943549,
0.0351469554,
0.0344247781,
0.0247367173,
0.067485407,
0.0296757445,
0.0109903971,
-0.0988848582,
0.0022360238,
0.0227791574,
0.0410895497,
0.0152710062,
0.0311713405,
0.0054359878,
-0.0096679963,
-0.0227080379,
-0.0321164988,
-0.0181732476,
-0.0353199765,
0.0443889536,
-0.0043411255,
0.0049256431,
0.0027326199,
0.0968027338,
-0.0221449882,
-0.0274939444,
0.0081115561,
-0.032097958,
0.0020054455,
-0.029049065,
0.036486119,
-0.0951080918,
-0.0775317922,
0.0127502382,
0.0260542259,
0.0297139138,
-0.0253386106,
0.07166408,
0.0090661505,
-0.0605749786,
-0.009348223,
-0.0529123098,
0.0229932461,
-0.0095089702,
0.0568942912,
0.0312803537,
-0.0000038412,
-0.0175109319,
0.0614995994,
0.0149681717,
-0.0426508561,
0.0247170981,
-0.0103241894,
0.026286792,
0.0048061763,
0.0002427374,
0.0175342206,
-0.0227381941,
-0.0074091409,
0.0420581065,
-0.006617168,
-0.0256029665,
0.0073818681,
2.55e-7,
0.0433969758,
0.0308745503,
-0.0036279587,
-0.0086380765,
-0.0049542817,
0.0272210892,
-0.0496887229,
0.0359124169,
0.0211350396,
0.03387288,
0.0060455059,
0.0216430631,
0.0937186554,
0.027260093,
-0.0526200682,
-0.0274093803,
-0.0570202582,
0.0354544707,
-0.034608759,
-0.0208158717,
0.0160683542,
0.0861698985,
-0.0115023302,
0.0011202822,
0.0118860528,
-0.0515467152,
0.0836814418,
-0.0722800344,
-0.040592365,
0.0214089416,
-0.0362082347,
0.0208795425,
0.001046635,
0.0162547752,
-0.032187134,
0.0296450127,
0.0493430495,
0.0688719377,
0.020458011,
-0.0160412416,
-0.0137955472,
0.0190592855,
-0.0086432463,
-0.0493374653,
0.0727276132,
-0.1109551862,
-0.031257987,
-0.0367358439,
-0.0496450178,
-0.0092036603,
0.0476447158,
-0.0216008238,
-0.0167292431,
0.0196636152,
0.0653342083,
0.0307835676,
-0.0825358927,
-0.0370605662,
0.0028601903,
0.044972986,
-0.0295815822,
-0.0253908783,
-0.0235790703,
-0.0275447536,
-0.0055791414,
-0.0244289618,
0.0109521439,
1.977649859e-34,
0.0138346869,
-0.0098469593,
0.0263855457,
-0.0092695542,
0.0203817859,
-0.0086619519,
-0.0210005529,
0.0011951528,
-0.0287207253,
-0.060480196,
-0.0029897431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14847v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14847v1 | Drafting Event Schemas using Language Models | 2023-05-24T07:57:04 | 2023-05-24T07:57:04 | Anisha Gunjal, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL | Past work has studied event prediction and event language modeling, sometimes
mediated through structured representations of knowledge in the form of event
schemas. Such schemas can lead to explainable predictions and forecasting of
unseen events given incomplete information. In this work, we look at the
process of creating such schemas to describe complex events. We use large
language models (LLMs) to draft schemas directly in natural language, which can
be further refined by human curators as necessary. Our focus is on whether we
can achieve sufficient diversity and recall of key events and whether we can
produce the schemas in a sufficiently descriptive style. We show that large
language models are able to achieve moderate recall against schemas taken from
two different datasets, with even better results when multiple prompts and
multiple samples are combined. Moreover, we show that textual entailment
methods can be used for both matching schemas to instances of events as well as
evaluating overlap between gold and predicted schemas. Our method paves the way
for easier distillation of event knowledge from large language model into
schemas. | [
0.0151759293,
0.0357437469,
-0.0319243968,
0.0539204031,
-0.0285153612,
-0.023748396,
-0.0310455579,
0.0019753976,
0.0510708503,
-0.055790145,
0.0365591906,
-0.0256876666,
-0.0122970361,
0.0664373487,
-0.01285352,
-0.0953869149,
0.036306452,
-0.0150601659,
-0.006265427,
0.036199268,
0.0085980808,
0.0291360263,
0.0176653769,
0.0272316951,
-0.0100266095,
0.0090369117,
-0.0459624343,
-0.0062217223,
-0.0042871339,
-0.055010777,
-0.0549346097,
0.0186566357,
0.0585492663,
-0.007192235,
0.000002168,
-0.0847793296,
-0.0132934656,
-0.0385284834,
-0.0040230709,
-0.011824606,
-0.0304471515,
-0.0238791294,
0.0276217982,
-0.029525945,
-0.0265494399,
-0.0226667598,
0.0353768542,
0.0665779486,
0.0305533316,
0.0671284571,
-0.0287217349,
-0.0376140662,
0.0210476425,
-0.0015300889,
-0.0025200613,
-0.0235136896,
-0.0094022136,
0.028120067,
0.0115940236,
0.021303108,
0.0111308135,
-0.0021837978,
-0.0167836025,
0.010707303,
0.0037223443,
0.0420462154,
-0.0325824916,
-0.0094756819,
0.0084437365,
0.0217981543,
0.0234939326,
-0.0426770374,
0.0519129485,
-0.0135459155,
-0.0005827785,
0.0501358211,
-0.0477673188,
0.0546387359,
-0.033097364,
0.0241397284,
0.0502051003,
0.0368394405,
0.0390364751,
-0.0051833731,
0.0074477331,
0.0661294907,
0.004832475,
0.0041997577,
-0.0924740881,
-0.0193392169,
-0.0149184223,
-0.0994576141,
0.0079817614,
0.0587648004,
-0.0434725434,
0.0292689372,
-0.0351381451,
0.0329589956,
0.003000431,
-0.0669988245,
0.034698233,
0.0461371653,
0.0197270606,
0.0435384773,
0.0021868164,
0.0424599536,
0.0028675664,
-0.0252804384,
-0.0320766233,
-0.0081932042,
-0.0715018362,
0.0157799236,
-0.023811359,
0.0068980907,
-0.0252560768,
-0.0063949265,
-0.0104031432,
0.0296218116,
0.0194715653,
0.0290993433,
-0.0054871594,
-0.0137559883,
-0.0305571742,
-0.0238470081,
-0.1069447547,
-0.0274165068,
-0.0561249964,
-0.0000984929,
-0.0264373366,
-0.013547794,
0.0109474743,
0.0185519233,
0.0164921265,
0.0028760596,
-0.0210732296,
0.0823907852,
0.0230635349,
0.0420836322,
-0.0846948028,
-0.1009540185,
0.0126454737,
-0.0278151948,
-0.0260521229,
-0.049599424,
0.0354243778,
0.0152821587,
-0.0080547305,
-0.0389576629,
-0.0002863274,
0.0256411005,
-0.0217639524,
0.0569401532,
-0.0512652136,
0.0298857167,
0.0085313087,
-0.0037465226,
-0.0324411169,
0.0186146051,
0.051449351,
0.0618165582,
0.0305998158,
0.015116564,
0.0280821975,
-0.0020807432,
-0.0095916176,
-0.0165731516,
-0.0224858373,
0.0120355971,
0.0442086644,
0.0219761319,
0.010694012,
0.0199985653,
-0.00398253,
0.0037688427,
0.0524294153,
0.0373462252,
-0.0114786457,
-0.0085008163,
0.0292092878,
-0.0327373594,
-0.0089779338,
-0.0019618503,
-0.0168690756,
0.0260684248,
-0.0130440779,
0.0136210723,
-0.0225380436,
-0.0078246994,
-0.0266662259,
-0.0408213213,
-0.0215288885,
-0.0158417653,
0.000283545,
-0.0121132517,
0.0172921978,
-0.0152237574,
-0.0339046493,
0.077719532,
0.0263705775,
-0.0395131446,
0.0358784162,
0.0051436247,
0.0380996987,
0.1273022592,
0.0310856048,
-0.0503539853,
-0.0109762903,
0.0057499222,
0.0408460759,
0.033998359,
0.0248374511,
-0.02287535,
-0.0253229402,
-0.0361291505,
-0.0000511752,
0.0101092579,
0.0100080306,
0.0111147696,
0.0205197148,
-0.0155887995,
0.000222288,
-0.0145539101,
-0.0527773835,
0.0338053182,
-0.038709674,
-0.0428852327,
-0.0536579974,
-0.0017584621,
0.0175234918,
0.0198425967,
0.027990561,
0.0311858859,
0.02128339,
-0.0385417305,
-0.0521876141,
0.0462084711,
-0.0281063113,
-0.0070520872,
0.0186619721,
-0.0100799771,
-0.0016161529,
-0.0260082148,
-0.0098247984,
-0.0603505336,
0.0105895828,
-0.0022414702,
0.0392667539,
-0.0109193781,
-0.0077356193,
0.0070330165,
-0.0512322299,
-0.0270292796,
0.0940397456,
0.0137764895,
-0.0135574304,
-0.0116860867,
-0.0349505693,
0.0182739906,
-0.0364449099,
-0.0325293988,
0.0494663939,
0.039493002,
0.0295751635,
0.0497697629,
-0.0584008321,
-0.0205980409,
0.0085354745,
-0.0857241079,
0.0293256808,
-0.0097022075,
0.0143086314,
0.0160920676,
-0.0165170133,
-0.0036067783,
-0.0267978553,
-0.0196536276,
-0.0378454179,
-0.0127078034,
0.0059539797,
0.05573963,
0.0335674845,
-0.0301276129,
-0.0297829211,
0.0112142209,
-0.0603631474,
0.0778648108,
0.0585431047,
-0.0158891696,
-0.063169308,
0.0606084168,
-0.0348951481,
0.0279196445,
-0.0162533019,
0.0108447755,
0.0200256351,
0.0006115996,
0.0283596423,
0.0043775705,
-0.0082482779,
0.0344006754,
0.0782066137,
-0.0447165407,
-0.0182284061,
-0.0245496277,
-0.0532178022,
-0.0038798747,
-0.0091383923,
-0.0411443561,
0.0135128852,
0.0267402753,
0.0369402803,
0.0243629981,
-0.0809792653,
-0.0110337716,
-0.0347769819,
0.0300937071,
-0.0354823321,
-0.0837035179,
-0.0196931753,
0.0819458514,
0.0102630053,
-0.0467022061,
0.0446904004,
-0.030192906,
0.0516725257,
-0.0040126396,
-0.0124507938,
-0.0513776056,
0.1270756721,
-0.0295512937,
0.0351160839,
0.0250648744,
-0.0241159964,
-0.0335072391,
-0.0383704528,
0.0280986391,
-0.0149471788,
0.0282743759,
-0.0722013935,
0.011701758,
0.0167220756,
0.0048425556,
-0.0607720949,
-0.0186005849,
-0.0329004899,
0.0118712746,
-0.0102606853,
0.0163536426,
-0.067196168,
0.0401174165,
-0.0030717147,
0.0221575256,
0.0210753903,
-0.0111387707,
-0.0063951379,
0.0101584243,
0.007771567,
-0.0144428052,
-0.0409332141,
-0.0374566726,
-0.0047619678,
-0.005001225,
0.0220966563,
0.0147431502,
-0.0326248929,
0.0086481739,
-0.0153594613,
-0.050286904,
-0.0322906971,
0.0507631339,
0.0095242234,
-0.0479832962,
0.0324840248,
0.1333298981,
0.036553897,
-0.0061902446,
0.0214148015,
0.0054909145,
-0.0059255254,
0.030286802,
0.0192207415,
-0.0781820044,
-0.0090570888,
0.0072655594,
-0.0335543938,
0.0082957521,
-0.065610908,
-0.0283743665,
-0.0831305161,
0.0239177812,
0.0130843828,
-0.0323572643,
-0.0500985235,
-0.0575245507,
-0.0111821312,
-0.0140213231,
-0.0443446413,
0.0055730473,
-0.0057356362,
-0.0183202736,
0.0043570194,
-0.0965728611,
-0.0484975465,
0.0298004001,
-0.0355417356,
0.0362432636,
0.0036762964,
0.0504093729,
0.006065378,
0.0226430707,
-0.0203322023,
0.0253589917,
0.0477860197,
0.0188900921,
0.0612768866,
0.0012903605,
-0.0066021001,
-0.0295177344,
0.0342096612,
-0.0307878796,
-0.0749842823,
0.0363581851,
0.1043899953,
-0.0370869488,
-0.0185593497,
0.0075880801,
-0.0268554073,
0.0378164463,
0.0863913968,
-0.0063605742,
0.0074334885,
0.0196507871,
0.00177419,
0.0195616409,
0.0029562579,
-0.0227902364,
0.0196650568,
-0.0166287869,
-0.0172903296,
-0.0631205887,
-0.0620656013,
0.0192036722,
0.0267008543,
0.0300159007,
0.0463202782,
0.0345694833,
0.0019188685,
-0.0371190086,
0.0539845601,
-0.0526270792,
0.0002163793,
0.0096565168,
-0.0203640629,
0.000061127,
0.0182825606,
-0.0195961408,
0.0399480611,
-0.043665491,
-0.0191970915,
-0.0019362293,
-0.0155287031,
0.032446865,
0.0267859716,
0.031851884,
-0.0037209124,
-0.0121821407,
0.0159610733,
-0.0272904597,
-0.0308827367,
-0.032827843,
0.0045329146,
0.0090345191,
0.0339607,
-0.0157038718,
0.0494343489,
-0.0413607433,
0.0439976417,
-0.0513897315,
-0.0280319992,
0.0254336465,
0.0208725557,
-0.0015424772,
-0.0472260378,
-0.0483741462,
-0.0288154427,
-0.0184467752,
-0.0427428335,
-0.033465974,
0.0076066623,
0.0251747929,
-0.0144298654,
-0.0202719662,
-0.0074052638,
-0.0133938985,
-0.0445023589,
0.0227793511,
-0.0507581905,
-0.0006724572,
0.0465793572,
-0.0018595863,
0.0311439503,
0.0022729039,
-0.0212011747,
0.0187086016,
-0.0279506706,
0.0185158662,
-0.0128798168,
-0.0032142811,
0.0264687501,
0.0263630934,
-0.0424831584,
-0.0350029245,
-0.0384689905,
-0.0568759739,
0.0021847894,
0.0073267794,
0.0584309995,
-0.033877641,
0.0076883547,
-0.0547912233,
0.0160773266,
0.0032113711,
0.0445434935,
0.0454840772,
-0.0047230292,
0.0244215038,
0.0162804145,
-0.057466235,
-0.0099375034,
0.0784023106,
-0.0034538417,
0.0605860353,
0.0114573259,
-0.0342285782,
-0.0359055251,
-0.0378026776,
0.0288479198,
0.0334459059,
-0.0316306241,
-0.0219358038,
-0.0895838067,
-0.0095538097,
0.0529109053,
-0.0105720134,
-0.0012985797,
-0.0097729219,
0.0394495428,
0.0296860691,
0.0448607393,
0.0061496049,
-0.0073333331,
0.0283249952,
-0.0320166536,
-0.0031596895,
-0.0426122621,
-6.097196995e-33,
-0.0442613848,
-0.0657726377,
0.0492614284,
0.0167910252,
0.0123098353,
0.0101059917,
-0.0609565899,
-0.0193159934,
0.0007987297,
0.0239244979,
0.0274403915,
-0.0245978851,
0.0185663085,
-0.0243422184,
0.0234142244,
-0.0388197266,
0.0485958159,
0.0255118664,
-0.0361933783,
0.0012876203,
0.1000569239,
0.0028652884,
0.0363855772,
-0.0605189465,
0.0419176556,
-0.0242202617,
-0.0043107965,
0.0042347065,
0.0908807665,
0.0456454083,
-0.0298161954,
0.0265497062,
0.0424689688,
-0.0333714336,
-0.0074169654,
0.0355769061,
-0.0069469414,
-0.0415561795,
0.068002969,
-0.0153934415,
0.0207598694,
-0.0212153737,
-0.0066863224,
-0.0143235875,
-0.0081515107,
0.01688933,
0.0678833649,
-0.0257451143,
-0.0073294765,
-0.0316092558,
-0.0664923489,
0.0422758162,
0.0176468417,
0.0011992619,
0.0035880406,
0.0172387324,
0.0263514742,
0.024823118,
-0.0243244041,
0.0260096788,
-0.0472945161,
0.0244053416,
0.0035553139,
-0.0141313821,
-0.007884915,
0.0853838176,
-0.0241655167,
0.0375135541,
-0.0452772342,
0.0473973788,
-0.0041444115,
0.055310268,
0.0103953956,
0.0355881006,
-0.0115867648,
0.0125304079,
-0.0745227337,
0.0406137668,
-0.0231239349,
0.0096732136,
0.0451164581,
0.0285304245,
-0.0272615999,
-0.0344621241,
-0.0544011034,
0.0370301306,
-0.0241378974,
0.0087288404,
0.0263833255,
-0.0343842469,
0.006110759,
0.0336273871,
0.0091862911,
-0.0183088277,
-0.0421694741,
0.0319673792,
-0.0022668981,
-0.0010498407,
-0.0149880638,
0.0322945081,
-0.027015049,
-0.0318152457,
0.0180622097,
0.0008219394,
0.0418321081,
0.0347798951,
-0.0065376787,
0.043016281,
-0.0331981406,
-0.005394923,
-0.0226568375,
-0.0504478887,
-0.0286211371,
-0.0665169954,
0.044960022,
0.0157914385,
-0.009572478,
0.0012020038,
0.0176008232,
-0.0069737253,
0.0256174691,
-0.0225966498,
-0.0027446984,
0.0250027906,
0.0051583005,
0.006833761,
-0.0371154137,
-0.0089013176,
0.0476661623,
0.0050367303,
-0.0004728824,
-0.0006570627,
2.788e-7,
0.0227195956,
0.0550003387,
0.0127075743,
0.0852478594,
-0.0062753875,
0.0217223261,
-0.0093927933,
0.0256370939,
-0.0011827066,
-0.0361172408,
0.0207919125,
0.0222228672,
0.0317807272,
0.0753201023,
-0.0694415644,
-0.0226410013,
-0.0616182201,
-0.0317785367,
-0.0797196999,
0.0198723096,
0.0872890204,
0.0527954437,
0.0659811869,
0.0047784233,
-0.0095183449,
-0.0329262801,
0.0454222597,
-0.0512632281,
-0.0430299938,
0.0208696816,
-0.0109054893,
0.0402262248,
-0.0340434648,
0.0623253323,
-0.0233824737,
-0.0236770343,
-0.0065715401,
0.0234660264,
-0.0381798707,
0.0461111516,
-0.009888988,
-0.0527919568,
-0.0289518014,
-0.038277328,
0.0408473164,
-0.0121809458,
-0.0191255528,
0.0132466936,
-0.0409430154,
0.0166218095,
-0.0306534283,
0.0323859639,
-0.0172215607,
0.0213409346,
-0.0105419327,
0.0255962741,
0.0121109346,
-0.0493850075,
-0.0453696512,
0.0728160664,
-0.0171504784,
-0.0483102947,
-0.0182839856,
-0.0439996719,
0.0110836774,
-0.0750943944,
0.0352564342,
2.626919241e-34,
0.0273363907,
0.0712295696,
-0.0353765339,
0.0208341237,
0.061463505,
-0.0049522738,
-0.0037007621,
0.0174815394,
0.048685506,
-0.0321113057,
-0.0262032971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14843v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14843v2 | Meta-learning For Vision-and-language Cross-lingual Transfer | 2023-05-24T07:51:42 | 2023-10-24T13:08:27 | Hanxu Hu, Frank Keller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current pre-trained vison-language models (PVLMs) achieve excellent
performance on a range of multi-modal datasets. Recent work has aimed at
building multilingual models, and a range of novel multilingual multi-modal
datasets have been proposed. Current PVLMs typically perform poorly on these
datasets when used for multi-modal zero-shot or few-shot cross-lingual
transfer, especially for low-resource languages. To alleviate this problem, we
propose a novel meta-learning fine-tuning framework. Our framework makes
current PVLMs rapidly adaptive to new languages in vision-language scenarios by
designing MAML in a cross-lingual multi-modal manner. Experiments show that our
method boosts the performance of current state-of-the-art PVLMs in both
zero-shot and few-shot cross-lingual transfer on a range of vision-language
understanding tasks and datasets (XVNLI, xGQA, MaRVL, xFlicker&Co) | [
-0.0224358775,
-0.0165418647,
-0.0133649008,
0.0425420329,
-0.0049992204,
0.0128505342,
0.0004805125,
-0.0468923263,
-0.0705849454,
-0.0556512214,
-0.0860775039,
0.0229538474,
0.0211595148,
0.0194716137,
-0.0076279338,
-0.0686262473,
0.0500738025,
-0.0383010022,
-0.0270111579,
-0.0043329415,
-0.0073782532,
0.0025780266,
-0.0247503091,
0.0013509777,
0.0492418371,
-0.0221977811,
0.0045357179,
0.0220772121,
0.0378569253,
0.0013335909,
-0.0375523046,
0.0222906657,
0.0070592305,
0.0437599123,
0.0000020189,
-0.0191059802,
0.0160700679,
-0.0100414613,
0.0147570781,
-0.0200282559,
0.0382447504,
-0.0826330408,
-0.0000567375,
-0.001119207,
-0.0060102297,
-0.1033983752,
0.0725507364,
-0.0254292488,
0.0419331752,
0.0181287043,
-0.0330790952,
-0.0010294372,
-0.0009679996,
-0.0230262857,
0.0143210422,
-0.019964058,
0.0160679594,
0.0333378576,
-0.0203852598,
-0.0265906602,
-0.0503357463,
0.0674828067,
0.0113074016,
0.0105108004,
-0.0556891784,
0.0018347938,
-0.006065493,
-0.0075555467,
-0.049899064,
0.089603506,
-0.0572279878,
-0.0058045359,
-0.0485806987,
-0.0162117742,
0.0115377083,
0.029767571,
-0.0510231666,
-0.0030864996,
0.0053848177,
-0.0168981962,
-0.0435890816,
-0.0125898644,
0.0181673802,
-0.0144684194,
-0.0284833517,
0.0002130342,
0.0238997601,
0.0247683059,
0.0252116323,
-0.0168869123,
-0.0030380699,
0.0035118221,
-0.0234890748,
0.0031213325,
-0.0004145616,
-0.0048200698,
-0.0520655178,
-0.0281362738,
-0.0088416459,
0.0012331008,
0.1042800248,
0.0397689082,
-0.0732285902,
0.045869384,
-0.0318862982,
0.0117804119,
-0.0159493312,
0.0435425602,
-0.0430615842,
-0.0485910401,
-0.0492172316,
0.0305730123,
-0.0197163131,
-0.0226011984,
-0.0720584095,
0.0116752824,
-0.0126715209,
0.0098606152,
0.0224175863,
-0.0311218258,
0.0037768465,
-0.0603642501,
-0.0409312621,
-0.0319948569,
-0.0118519021,
0.08236821,
0.0037528928,
0.0227917973,
-0.0268644895,
-0.0389133394,
0.0045046206,
0.0304236319,
0.0074573192,
-0.0617826618,
0.001108723,
0.0933427587,
-0.0222931691,
-0.0221200828,
-0.0329932757,
0.0264665429,
-0.0041924464,
-0.0468604304,
0.0253865141,
-0.0394135416,
0.0384011529,
-0.024252126,
0.0141478097,
0.0401124358,
-0.0299188253,
-0.0271795355,
-0.0085923811,
0.0854295343,
-0.0316352546,
-0.0037571057,
-0.0350240692,
-0.0241653435,
0.0032271619,
0.0983303338,
0.0053914394,
0.0107727284,
-0.0006689505,
-0.0069511123,
-0.008661082,
0.0253973734,
0.0198243205,
0.024708407,
-0.0437775776,
-0.0345055535,
0.0464436822,
-0.0255549047,
0.0133746006,
0.0066237096,
-0.0256914254,
-0.0121212052,
0.033174444,
-0.0107427659,
0.0199596621,
-0.0245349724,
0.0588677786,
-0.0157894883,
-0.0006130802,
-0.0025235037,
-0.0278202221,
0.0614676438,
-0.0257016718,
-0.0168146901,
-0.0543601662,
0.0732717067,
-0.0457282476,
-0.0189204235,
0.027920004,
0.0078813517,
-0.0386160873,
0.0114359492,
0.0403741039,
0.0214312896,
0.0028115034,
-0.0073319627,
0.0514450148,
-0.0267980415,
0.0361459292,
-0.013054274,
-0.0220051911,
0.0475042202,
-0.0068754121,
0.015836468,
-0.0530160442,
-0.0423819795,
0.0378298424,
0.0465298183,
0.0272847097,
-0.0072439108,
0.0898576826,
-0.0526226833,
-0.0282957833,
0.0014688484,
-0.019293163,
0.0407493971,
-0.0748385265,
0.0206307266,
0.0031958476,
-0.039018292,
0.0276699085,
0.0449740253,
-0.0387433209,
0.0088707795,
0.0156844724,
0.0211054534,
0.002709958,
-0.0196576882,
0.0007545782,
-0.0346950032,
0.0020724488,
-0.0576370582,
0.03405568,
0.0729021132,
-0.0150223188,
-0.0593241081,
0.0465902463,
-0.0492240973,
0.0244657136,
-0.0231457707,
-0.0369546451,
-0.0443201587,
-0.0061748577,
0.0201737117,
0.0088643581,
-0.038080994,
-0.0024204152,
-0.0119915884,
0.0439730026,
-0.0009775821,
0.0130838491,
-0.0146824485,
-0.0141804153,
0.0590774752,
-0.048378028,
0.0400701575,
0.0176718961,
-0.0229821466,
0.0487512462,
-0.0255417284,
0.0424736738,
0.0095021846,
0.0300322808,
-0.0156026334,
-0.0293303374,
-0.0620199591,
0.0127819125,
-0.0288993269,
0.0183289628,
0.0245933328,
0.0272384621,
-0.0122501953,
-0.0391075984,
-0.0153879942,
0.0695999637,
-0.0066074561,
0.0243374594,
0.0226554237,
0.0272164661,
0.0447217189,
-0.0078201517,
-0.0190466233,
0.0365285911,
0.0392501578,
-0.0186925661,
0.0108977994,
-0.0034255625,
0.0106120156,
0.0022388417,
0.0165333338,
-0.0247442927,
-0.0378055349,
-0.0351072699,
-0.0238234866,
0.0127427038,
0.0350963213,
-0.0078793764,
-0.018216297,
0.0501014628,
-0.0478601716,
-0.0389329195,
0.0188013744,
0.0113473125,
-0.0332954489,
-0.0836858973,
0.0191896446,
-0.0402659476,
0.0316437967,
-0.053535074,
0.0001183405,
-0.0802048668,
-0.0019150279,
0.0147980368,
-0.0620203018,
-0.0073678875,
0.0810778365,
0.0167933404,
0.0333191156,
-0.040806748,
-0.0040158946,
0.0057359021,
-0.0080770459,
-0.0298499223,
-0.0154868867,
0.0266919006,
-0.0191039462,
0.0249800254,
-0.022125585,
0.0251876283,
-0.0217154454,
-0.0008098405,
-0.079494454,
-0.0635934174,
0.0295823589,
0.0095842546,
0.0307987854,
-0.0258389283,
0.0035408502,
-0.056735415,
-0.0261527561,
-0.0103299478,
0.0212796256,
-0.0039707455,
-0.0067197457,
-0.0743831247,
-0.0051022614,
-0.0711632296,
0.0010261663,
0.0194377676,
0.0330613479,
-0.0072649,
-0.0118526639,
-0.0234340057,
0.0175610855,
0.0281894356,
0.0334548093,
-0.0149063375,
-0.0334511846,
0.0368154757,
0.01681282,
0.0077591487,
0.0092804376,
-0.0401107147,
0.0265826881,
0.052253183,
0.0432170592,
-0.0215026755,
0.0200469047,
0.0210110508,
-0.0554744713,
0.0359859131,
0.0425162613,
-0.0085011981,
-0.0426599756,
-0.038612511,
-0.0267890207,
0.0348163694,
0.0405438729,
0.0401563011,
-0.0650487021,
-0.0568101853,
-0.0007862223,
-0.0009933674,
0.0444459282,
0.0066474434,
-0.0260339957,
-0.0859018266,
0.022785265,
0.0036476264,
-0.0643770769,
-0.0396064781,
0.0151069332,
0.0078422483,
-0.0351864919,
0.0262977462,
-0.0111375609,
-0.0496425219,
-0.0137964133,
0.0362507701,
0.0488239415,
-0.0762709752,
0.0140317399,
-0.0206592698,
0.0241806637,
0.0254372228,
0.0569713116,
-0.0289520714,
-0.0490459092,
0.055586677,
-0.0312999301,
-0.0105900103,
-0.0203934535,
0.0721347705,
-0.0345273688,
-0.0221259743,
0.0664260834,
0.0113189416,
-0.0388840474,
-0.0299159829,
0.0095049683,
0.0361292027,
0.0439293273,
-0.0048915143,
-0.0002784071,
-0.0236629918,
0.008886815,
0.0083489409,
0.0173138808,
-0.0400935821,
-0.0158335511,
-0.0053194524,
-0.0070160413,
-0.0573258027,
-0.0259956475,
0.0337754823,
0.0192220584,
-0.0503236577,
-0.0291277133,
-0.0519777909,
0.0348267779,
0.0918886662,
0.0310959723,
0.0115421154,
-0.0279054195,
0.013410043,
-0.0415158235,
0.0248763524,
-0.0457871072,
0.0215164945,
-0.0501851849,
0.0026215732,
0.0274712183,
-0.0624476783,
0.0119157368,
-0.0318026282,
-0.0565403886,
-0.0403579175,
-0.0188293327,
0.0799603239,
0.0091067459,
0.0400939435,
-0.0096472548,
-0.0325087197,
0.0686933771,
0.0558038466,
0.0066820281,
-0.0103456806,
0.0886266753,
-0.012558138,
-0.0085542602,
0.020496456,
-0.0230122115,
0.0144417565,
0.0475651398,
0.0108340904,
-0.0011133584,
0.0009530959,
0.0252545848,
0.0131086688,
0.0488831177,
-0.0256091394,
0.0025594379,
-0.0390403457,
0.0012163848,
0.0026643453,
0.0063284496,
-0.0703428984,
-0.0037245115,
0.044139415,
-0.0302153472,
0.0261666439,
0.0184134953,
0.0244464837,
-0.0277333837,
0.0015178384,
0.0507421121,
0.0272575542,
0.065929167,
0.0119901225,
0.0458180718,
0.0062211985,
0.0078065805,
0.0406210609,
0.0423635989,
-0.0476028956,
0.0398426726,
0.0111119784,
-0.0089600189,
-0.0213669613,
0.0510032363,
-0.0213788468,
-0.0306641813,
-0.0214675125,
-0.0128245223,
0.0410943441,
0.0238924194,
0.0721100345,
0.0232722405,
0.0035293465,
-0.0498291515,
0.0543202423,
-0.0167876147,
0.0100061847,
0.0134934373,
-0.0144182332,
-0.0103258602,
-0.0027122705,
0.0609093197,
-0.028896736,
0.033506047,
0.0151066929,
0.0530262068,
-0.0371438153,
-0.0283919703,
0.0229655541,
-0.0190404765,
-0.0054137395,
0.0291523375,
-0.0622743778,
-0.047427129,
0.0080515221,
0.0005138028,
0.0048356284,
0.0430493169,
0.0008162232,
0.0475124493,
0.0131254671,
0.003838347,
-0.0265159663,
-0.0221010335,
0.048838716,
0.0336972065,
0.0399113782,
-5.60458772e-33,
-0.0556184389,
0.0440913737,
0.0404809974,
-0.0129417023,
-0.0138345929,
-0.0123179676,
-0.0294185691,
0.0213698708,
-0.0531660393,
0.0147179719,
0.0276441909,
-0.0279762857,
0.0210743025,
0.0389569849,
0.0032715022,
-0.0110762771,
0.0535415001,
0.0072803856,
-0.0078848014,
0.0018722146,
0.0497266017,
0.0405204147,
0.0620151125,
-0.0475740656,
-0.0406522118,
0.0620289221,
-0.0117413914,
0.0152965281,
0.010272583,
0.0426100343,
-0.0044149584,
0.035351377,
0.0125245973,
0.0466442443,
-0.0510495454,
-0.0120120216,
-0.0532821901,
-0.0221740622,
0.0262691043,
0.0436115786,
-0.0481887683,
-0.0220958795,
0.0048146546,
-0.0199288111,
0.0318184532,
-0.0397609547,
0.0365591869,
-0.0643434599,
-0.0458899103,
0.024070736,
-0.0752957538,
0.0116563216,
-0.0015410001,
-0.0217805728,
0.1159346625,
0.0802297667,
0.005081316,
-0.0026091042,
-0.0172452368,
0.0304371528,
-0.0588640235,
0.0317715779,
0.0894530937,
0.0548262671,
0.003658771,
0.0324103385,
0.0640324131,
-0.0248458833,
0.0890527442,
0.0080866618,
0.0756153464,
0.0319507569,
-0.0007697143,
0.1347147822,
0.0264777616,
-0.0158189368,
-0.019802548,
0.0053775217,
-0.0303112995,
0.0513246842,
-0.0007716757,
0.0010678596,
0.0176968779,
-0.0105844801,
-0.063256003,
-0.08567442,
-0.0287830085,
-0.0111560831,
0.0377734788,
-0.0030563194,
-0.0232705642,
0.0007533964,
0.1096764058,
-0.0271960963,
-0.0129050473,
0.0194316674,
-0.0519924611,
0.0367358476,
-0.0125305513,
0.0388543159,
-0.0433169641,
-0.0527362674,
0.0341281183,
0.0003768987,
0.0181605984,
0.0000355427,
0.0566426963,
0.0485159755,
-0.0462969951,
-0.003809192,
-0.044694826,
-0.0148679037,
0.0160756055,
0.0485835299,
0.0009974578,
0.003689989,
-0.0565830655,
0.0206933413,
-0.0036135358,
-0.067052871,
-0.0089388546,
-0.0410668254,
0.0283699855,
0.04723759,
-0.0109578418,
0.0022547045,
-0.0318032913,
-0.0410580486,
0.0520546176,
-0.0187050328,
-0.0025412564,
0.0370495357,
2.62e-7,
0.0481701344,
0.0226498097,
0.0073094037,
-0.0551607385,
0.0039941859,
0.0419465825,
-0.0384203233,
0.0120460773,
0.0126485163,
-0.018705992,
-0.0023834861,
0.0454731062,
0.0485116281,
0.0191846229,
-0.0090098968,
0.0400199778,
0.0116520291,
0.021682173,
-0.0072597256,
-0.0175199229,
0.0201437753,
0.0661164448,
-0.0229008924,
-0.0061345054,
0.0427784473,
-0.0306719691,
0.0738868862,
-0.0496128686,
-0.0054445593,
0.0105892038,
-0.0493917651,
0.0342245996,
-0.0303062294,
0.0080931755,
-0.0062675029,
0.0032215335,
0.0343788192,
0.0328291878,
-0.0097211935,
-0.0241431352,
0.0172788482,
0.0336279534,
-0.0255902223,
0.0135075748,
0.0583548397,
-0.0588646494,
-0.0121743325,
-0.0371639244,
-0.05810472,
0.0613538437,
0.0356882326,
-0.0345792025,
-0.0300006568,
0.0358334556,
0.0368605219,
-0.002168661,
-0.0775137842,
-0.0211602971,
-0.0287980083,
-0.0161041785,
-0.0190576445,
-0.0087592443,
-0.0147256805,
-0.0390483998,
0.0228352062,
-0.0221434329,
-0.0021186606,
1.810854443e-34,
0.0042187911,
-0.0253883339,
0.0206409227,
-0.0318822861,
-0.0393507294,
-0.0385349616,
-0.0580121353,
0.0094699506,
-0.0003720502,
-0.024267124,
-0.0110860271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14842v1 | Exploring Sentiment Analysis Techniques in Natural Language Processing: A Comprehensive Review | 2023-05-24T07:48:41 | 2023-05-24T07:48:41 | Karthick Prasad Gunasekaran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Sentiment analysis (SA) is the automated process of detecting and
understanding the emotions conveyed through written text. Over the past decade,
SA has gained significant popularity in the field of Natural Language
Processing (NLP). With the widespread use of social media and online platforms,
SA has become crucial for companies to gather customer feedback and shape their
marketing strategies. Additionally, researchers rely on SA to analyze public
sentiment on various topics. In this particular research study, a comprehensive
survey was conducted to explore the latest trends and techniques in SA. The
survey encompassed a wide range of methods, including lexicon-based,
graph-based, network-based, machine learning, deep learning, ensemble-based,
rule-based, and hybrid techniques. The paper also addresses the challenges and
opportunities in SA, such as dealing with sarcasm and irony, analyzing
multi-lingual data, and addressing ethical concerns. To provide a practical
case study, Twitter was chosen as one of the largest online social media
platforms. Furthermore, the researchers shed light on the diverse application
areas of SA, including social media, healthcare, marketing, finance, and
politics. The paper also presents a comparative and comprehensive analysis of
existing trends and techniques, datasets, and evaluation metrics. The ultimate
goal is to offer researchers and practitioners a systematic review of SA
techniques, identify existing gaps, and suggest possible improvements. This
study aims to enhance the efficiency and accuracy of SA processes, leading to
smoother and error-free outcomes. | [
0.0780737028,
0.057568159,
-0.0002627171,
0.0274680834,
-0.0806130841,
-0.0040583736,
-0.0279325489,
0.0055073993,
0.0499054715,
-0.0700636655,
0.0261318479,
-0.0207162835,
-0.0140018575,
0.0433050618,
-0.0472034812,
-0.0185322706,
-0.0016094421,
0.081787318,
0.0455718823,
0.0028604425,
0.0187821649,
0.0455276854,
0.0079087764,
0.0208689552,
0.0007289666,
-0.003700891,
0.030699309,
0.0116715292,
0.0251863878,
-0.0476315096,
0.0459471904,
0.0351927876,
-0.0361717641,
0.0317519866,
0.0000018334,
-0.0244935937,
-0.0258599911,
-0.0196533576,
0.0147655709,
-0.0209685899,
0.1147762612,
-0.0240552556,
-0.0121177295,
0.0539641865,
-0.0425829478,
-0.0079021892,
0.0519688018,
0.0279255137,
0.042432148,
0.0661789253,
-0.0321136191,
-0.0322859623,
-0.0679988191,
0.0406332538,
-0.0750845522,
0.0042414647,
0.0380162187,
-0.0473499969,
-0.0383334048,
-0.0275410749,
0.0016994451,
0.0076207677,
-0.0395003781,
0.0109881554,
0.0025291562,
-0.0310705323,
-0.0392739102,
-0.0361812785,
-0.0350127965,
0.0271788295,
-0.0064226445,
0.0087545235,
-0.0087203812,
-0.0135207726,
-0.0250490326,
-0.0267080627,
-0.0064260047,
0.0110232197,
-0.0171546191,
0.049213402,
-0.0105289277,
0.045107279,
-0.0044326037,
0.0644669607,
0.0306700878,
0.0547453463,
-0.0263669156,
-0.0357305966,
0.0392844975,
0.0623673946,
-0.0018473582,
0.0223604627,
0.0396610908,
-0.0158223212,
0.0225471128,
0.0505306758,
0.0167459026,
-0.0416762382,
0.0569856726,
-0.0949134454,
-0.0247086454,
-0.0093588606,
0.0138786444,
0.0217800699,
-0.0026788551,
-0.0625263676,
0.0204214118,
-0.0043876707,
0.0090487581,
0.0216790643,
-0.0655268356,
0.026240455,
0.0047224606,
0.0362817794,
-0.0600081123,
-0.0173198003,
-0.1051094681,
-0.0173769053,
-0.0107287457,
-0.004470197,
0.0250707082,
0.0471784696,
0.0435783193,
0.0239749681,
-0.0119862556,
0.0513565652,
-0.0341474861,
0.0245647468,
-0.0583244041,
-0.0215347093,
0.0523692481,
0.0296165105,
0.0561464764,
0.0243384186,
0.0164640695,
0.0505210236,
0.045943372,
-0.0595653541,
-0.0505359434,
-0.0251221228,
-0.0162464827,
-0.0260611773,
-0.0017975019,
-0.0456682742,
0.0332452431,
-0.0081607476,
-0.0249227956,
0.0224825647,
0.0263826549,
0.0197114795,
-0.038846571,
0.0167761464,
-0.054797031,
-0.0255733505,
-0.0230064187,
-0.0023919025,
0.0180785451,
0.0325526334,
-0.0011506113,
0.0626220703,
0.0664615333,
0.0118850339,
-0.0175208226,
-0.0181021914,
-0.0046357438,
-0.0543119237,
0.0009130172,
-0.0044157472,
-0.0887705088,
-0.010838557,
-0.0468690731,
0.0498411581,
-0.0052190782,
-0.0013442358,
0.0039270781,
0.0091286451,
-0.0210634358,
0.0232488681,
0.0024638111,
0.0282475762,
0.0415011048,
-0.0448534302,
-0.0073171952,
-0.0290127862,
-0.0037658587,
-0.0335021056,
-0.0199699644,
0.0302110557,
0.006474867,
-0.065415442,
-0.0447095707,
-0.0227688663,
0.0633257031,
-0.021510778,
0.0470617525,
-0.0282438789,
-0.0740433782,
-0.0506223291,
0.0399564207,
-0.0777166188,
-0.0279527996,
0.0026185042,
-0.0220130291,
0.1129755229,
-0.0041762558,
-0.0179132521,
-0.0312476922,
-0.0348558128,
-0.0008520681,
0.0539257899,
-0.0006912458,
0.0346856304,
0.0049230903,
-0.0331857987,
-0.0044147652,
0.006609194,
-0.0064434195,
0.0182970054,
0.0098770969,
0.0521335751,
-0.0405344032,
0.0134837516,
0.0006549682,
0.0097648716,
0.0525186136,
-0.0098301377,
0.031939514,
-0.0048576789,
0.0448632836,
0.0610682778,
0.0120486654,
-0.0198337939,
0.0204751585,
0.0136673702,
-0.0853861645,
0.0433118232,
-0.0044308049,
-0.0511614121,
0.0049299067,
-0.0462271981,
-0.0197833534,
0.0336310863,
-0.0405781157,
-0.0008760848,
0.0496678762,
-0.0016665026,
0.0170036647,
-0.0319067091,
-0.019158937,
-0.057963077,
0.0228392053,
-0.0003428065,
0.0605486855,
-0.0019975991,
-0.0225469191,
-0.0444874056,
-0.0495520681,
0.0162934214,
0.0238105152,
-0.0426209718,
0.0132621741,
0.011483469,
0.0386147946,
0.0287705995,
0.0132445628,
-0.0471553244,
-0.0144569138,
-0.0882459655,
0.0086032301,
-0.0014193326,
0.026766248,
-0.0348034427,
0.013699797,
-0.0135112423,
0.0390825123,
0.0045232042,
-0.0013859612,
0.0021702994,
0.0000710241,
0.0258527007,
0.0079594906,
0.0191771127,
-0.035247542,
-0.0135289701,
-0.0304430891,
0.0048143854,
0.0348592363,
-0.0361439325,
0.0293365605,
0.0272530578,
-0.0498574488,
0.0177242365,
0.0112427594,
-0.0398900956,
-0.0140033392,
0.0166229848,
-0.0479984283,
0.0101938425,
0.0321361013,
0.048832532,
-0.0265399218,
0.0158519577,
-0.0145560056,
0.007092725,
-0.0614214987,
0.027152935,
-0.0132403094,
-0.0025856015,
-0.0066984021,
0.0365785994,
0.0352177843,
-0.011917674,
-0.0157314315,
-0.0044542956,
-0.0394298844,
-0.0025913243,
0.0012976276,
-0.0161499809,
0.0018310804,
-0.0224602204,
0.0351581424,
-0.0215550084,
0.029057391,
0.0507485271,
-0.0013644398,
-0.0997442976,
-0.0241649579,
-0.0505844615,
0.0165037718,
-0.0252365619,
0.0088801179,
-0.0040274919,
-0.0150382081,
0.0576274842,
-0.0412917733,
-0.0255997702,
-0.034187451,
-0.0063399277,
0.0166985728,
0.0034634301,
0.0231577121,
-0.0191461369,
-0.0029243815,
-0.0505523086,
-0.0744351745,
-0.0169481207,
0.0393433645,
-0.027190242,
0.0074451892,
-0.0118317446,
-0.0495258234,
-0.0619891994,
0.0047004214,
-0.021858301,
0.0283617731,
-0.0206746142,
0.0158083141,
-0.0597971566,
0.0387590192,
0.0584389903,
0.0075576319,
0.0617444068,
-0.002535261,
-0.0033724313,
-0.0383253992,
-0.0049717482,
-0.0149503695,
-0.0369759426,
0.015762968,
-0.0512669794,
0.0141567867,
-0.0328153223,
0.0801958516,
0.1033576801,
0.0341370776,
-0.0235170387,
-0.0019518328,
0.0266922731,
-0.0434832163,
0.0212640576,
0.0050662551,
-0.0595235452,
-0.0415515788,
-0.0594330095,
0.0394637883,
-0.0391627848,
-0.0475366414,
0.0273736678,
-0.08849933,
0.0410174876,
-0.0308929551,
-0.0038330399,
0.0143628586,
-0.0246020705,
0.0000605943,
-0.0340582654,
-0.0107791256,
-0.0762923211,
-0.0095691616,
-0.0052432576,
-0.0026812635,
-0.0651816502,
-0.0331510492,
0.0225915667,
-0.0081107253,
-0.0004684136,
0.0078064403,
0.0965337008,
-0.0280745476,
-0.0063585797,
-0.0030753927,
-0.0123216398,
0.0388790257,
-0.0396492444,
0.0637286529,
-0.0245130938,
-0.0080882637,
-0.0374701917,
-0.0120346015,
-0.0539653301,
0.0544918738,
-0.0205984265,
0.0435921401,
-0.0188694969,
-0.0700770319,
-0.0353245176,
0.0461162515,
0.0412462428,
0.0373136476,
-0.0181775633,
-0.0414708517,
-0.0219673868,
0.0100072464,
0.0387078524,
-0.078231506,
0.003610617,
-0.0258303508,
-0.0003694793,
-0.025751384,
-0.058930397,
-0.0513280332,
0.0199042186,
0.0228027012,
-0.0213012453,
0.0262171626,
0.0405461714,
0.0108213974,
-0.0512827374,
-0.0066021504,
0.0234781355,
0.0261321403,
0.0459785871,
-0.0092363674,
0.0270078592,
0.0056755869,
0.0026344585,
-0.0196030382,
-0.0199789926,
-0.0368114151,
0.017699929,
0.0059546917,
0.0045139948,
-0.0073101488,
0.0059449393,
-0.0222648531,
0.0323908888,
0.0594115108,
-0.0064064977,
-0.0198303349,
0.0369915031,
0.0856495798,
0.0063686138,
0.0053619114,
0.0086715836,
0.0263206102,
-0.0241013598,
-0.0041100923,
0.0146118067,
0.0039146324,
-0.0116172452,
-0.0124681313,
0.0517698489,
-0.0034865132,
-0.0565446131,
0.0034722895,
-0.0473303497,
0.0066993581,
-0.0237486009,
-0.0308325551,
-0.0160624236,
-0.017217597,
0.0473577268,
-0.089088358,
-0.0247964133,
-0.0380528755,
-0.0137847699,
0.0194345545,
0.0907828808,
0.0381054766,
0.0436347388,
-0.0091292411,
0.0246802531,
-0.0068510929,
0.0150876632,
0.0118779885,
-0.0254342295,
0.003525483,
-0.00187301,
0.0140233561,
-0.0167309325,
-0.0198693015,
0.0531544648,
-0.0017951449,
0.0291091669,
-0.0129937707,
0.0307563338,
0.0159969218,
-0.0300252382,
0.0361520015,
-0.0338951163,
0.0229875781,
0.0194778237,
0.0212943088,
-0.0454302765,
-0.0260285921,
0.0044022785,
-0.0116714463,
-0.0405228809,
-0.0046022795,
0.0096298745,
-0.0968438089,
0.018421663,
0.0414361469,
-0.0404896922,
-0.0405728742,
0.0286619812,
0.0467128828,
0.012562071,
0.016649615,
0.0402378887,
-0.0559106991,
-0.0247137882,
0.0946907178,
-0.0818187445,
0.0093583623,
-0.0077109034,
0.023727363,
0.0561519936,
0.0268640034,
0.0542749129,
-0.06882938,
-0.0121056316,
-0.0553290434,
-0.0274465811,
0.003961843,
-6.051084923e-33,
0.0465973467,
-0.0475734957,
-0.0489683002,
0.0576846413,
-0.0052750614,
0.0148363318,
0.0038478049,
0.0202169921,
0.0170574822,
0.0403884947,
-0.0161159523,
0.0282444414,
0.0139531074,
0.0197968781,
0.0358426198,
-0.041723039,
-0.0077393162,
-0.0365847796,
0.0129663087,
0.0204001982,
0.0402715765,
0.0235470645,
0.0673473254,
-0.1129592881,
0.0789427161,
0.0200679619,
-0.0264641475,
0.0133472979,
0.0400922745,
0.0159603767,
0.0013125817,
0.099285312,
0.0214123502,
-0.0100042587,
0.0419302694,
0.0152827762,
0.021999754,
-0.0314836241,
-0.0075202966,
0.0078131575,
-0.0364270732,
-0.0007761917,
0.0400447957,
0.0368211307,
-0.0355883539,
0.039148815,
0.0443762504,
0.0106235892,
0.0511036664,
-0.0393230319,
-0.0699970499,
0.045284953,
-0.0326120928,
0.0145476814,
-0.0059472807,
0.0430047028,
-0.0070192041,
0.0354253426,
-0.0637086108,
0.0066675949,
-0.0498591326,
-0.0409072638,
-0.0297866538,
-0.0634918436,
0.0019924534,
0.0645835921,
0.0016377455,
0.0065265689,
-0.0464021564,
0.0613470227,
0.0164984483,
0.0306253582,
0.0480888709,
0.0505085923,
-0.005814326,
-0.0239551254,
-0.0274504051,
0.0186668858,
0.0754499435,
0.0203030091,
0.032501962,
-0.0220054369,
-0.0461411774,
-0.0130771203,
0.0536766499,
-0.0368220098,
0.0042221854,
-0.0281706341,
-0.0110226087,
-0.0051673246,
-0.033954747,
0.031458132,
-0.0211192816,
-0.0406740531,
-0.0177296214,
0.0324095562,
-0.0022325169,
0.0601611473,
0.0119924685,
0.0292234477,
-0.0500092059,
0.0236893073,
-0.042428717,
0.0255082007,
0.0010521532,
-0.0457886197,
-0.0003238502,
0.0444902666,
-0.0263651554,
0.0064268517,
0.0070286277,
0.0342231989,
-0.0289793164,
0.0015564772,
-0.0444002599,
0.0134407077,
0.0051082936,
0.0363765918,
0.0311029181,
0.0750188604,
-0.0124401059,
-0.0183096509,
0.0334214605,
-0.0251834076,
-0.0372801051,
-0.028770091,
0.0250526741,
-0.0333918817,
-0.0351766497,
-0.0562148653,
0.0085487803,
-0.0418653749,
2.666e-7,
0.0752363652,
0.0917845517,
-0.037433438,
-0.0326475427,
0.0282978676,
0.053740453,
0.0443441272,
-0.0077524013,
0.0041953642,
0.0055318349,
0.0245706905,
0.0076302621,
-0.0052145836,
0.0209535491,
-0.0887641981,
0.0033639991,
-0.0150592187,
-0.0132507225,
-0.0087649468,
0.0391190909,
0.0552212484,
0.0523248725,
0.0192967393,
-0.0355565548,
-0.0465085357,
0.003200588,
0.0050017624,
-0.024130825,
-0.0043368796,
0.0008767918,
0.0219648462,
-0.0121118817,
-0.0178284869,
-0.0204222556,
-0.0048321974,
0.0386515781,
0.0177497678,
0.0112454183,
-0.0092269285,
0.007184091,
0.0423345007,
-0.0063663642,
0.0092496164,
0.0193176456,
0.0310343094,
-0.0392772108,
-0.0458518155,
-0.0788378119,
0.0391565934,
-0.0050650719,
0.0629902408,
-0.013281133,
-0.0316569209,
0.0153490165,
-0.00702012,
-0.0444151722,
-0.0494347475,
-0.0558556318,
0.0120002963,
-0.0060321633,
-0.0113273486,
0.0016914412,
0.031514585,
0.0535666756,
0.0398942195,
-0.0178645384,
0.0234432556,
1.810541628e-34,
0.0240573529,
-0.0288549382,
0.016082488,
0.0105281472,
0.0099027082,
0.0455348007,
-0.0402039029,
-0.0150673361,
0.0190625619,
-0.0217892658,
0.0309987087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14839v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14839v2 | PaCE: Unified Multi-modal Dialogue Pre-training with Progressive and Compositional Experts | 2023-05-24T07:43:29 | 2023-06-13T06:31:46 | Yunshui Li, Binyuan Hui, ZhiChao Yin, Min Yang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Perceiving multi-modal information and fulfilling dialogues with humans is a
long-term goal of artificial intelligence. Pre-training is commonly regarded as
an effective approach for multi-modal dialogue. However, due to the limited
availability of multi-modal dialogue data, there is still scarce research on
multi-modal dialogue pre-training. Yet another intriguing challenge emerges
from the encompassing nature of multi-modal dialogue, which involves various
modalities and tasks. Moreover, new forms of tasks may arise at unpredictable
points in the future. Hence, it is essential for designed multi-modal dialogue
models to possess sufficient flexibility to adapt to such scenarios. This paper
proposes \textbf{PaCE}, a unified, structured, compositional multi-modal
dialogue pre-training framework. It utilizes a combination of several
fundamental experts to accommodate multiple dialogue-related tasks and can be
pre-trained using limited dialogue and extensive non-dialogue multi-modal data.
Furthermore, we propose a progressive training method where old experts from
the past can assist new experts, facilitating the expansion of their
capabilities. Experimental results demonstrate that PaCE achieves
state-of-the-art results on eight multi-modal dialog benchmarks. | [
0.063886717,
0.0690004304,
-0.0029258335,
0.0067646713,
-0.0148959029,
-0.0044200099,
0.0171672851,
-0.0339691006,
-0.0170093141,
-0.041455768,
-0.0561918654,
-0.043322295,
-0.0302569848,
0.0614085831,
-0.0068378258,
-0.0821099579,
0.0551357083,
-0.0250800382,
0.0393632576,
0.0008881108,
0.0206545424,
0.0005234053,
-0.0830522105,
0.0354637392,
-0.0387046151,
-0.0294835232,
-0.0691840425,
0.0040222467,
0.0125018544,
-0.0298198592,
0.0333656929,
0.0778621286,
0.0295457859,
-0.0068919896,
0.0000017863,
-0.0235303566,
0.0208579712,
-0.0419877842,
-0.0336478017,
-0.0282137133,
0.0096884286,
0.00559881,
0.0123060467,
0.0177576933,
-0.0495635532,
-0.0008997034,
0.02646688,
0.0732520521,
0.1022271812,
0.088879846,
-0.0214787927,
0.0009395969,
0.0306369998,
-0.0084302444,
-0.0036193707,
-0.0749923661,
-0.01691043,
-0.0001267495,
0.0106347753,
0.0189375598,
-0.0050231814,
0.0070478339,
0.0284008346,
-0.0222147759,
-0.0160197187,
0.0157702733,
0.0073347571,
-0.0093886005,
-0.0865936801,
0.1189823672,
0.0313128754,
0.0386284105,
-0.012662081,
0.0000795769,
0.0008474513,
-0.0579783358,
-0.0374818519,
-0.014727545,
-0.0024108875,
-0.0348571949,
-0.0431265719,
0.0214054026,
-0.0358297266,
0.0100660073,
0.0012382348,
0.0345542356,
-0.011672236,
-0.0309839435,
0.0169279333,
-0.0140518984,
0.0253132526,
-0.0544504263,
0.0092994822,
0.0264639612,
-0.0737256408,
0.0248211417,
-0.043915458,
0.0272420011,
0.0140694221,
0.0020024756,
0.0055675912,
0.0351851508,
-0.0407409742,
0.0701981112,
0.0474116914,
0.006586697,
-0.0327835269,
-0.0108182095,
-0.0238779001,
0.0048227087,
-0.0547350757,
-0.0055772373,
-0.0476044826,
0.0084429663,
-0.061486572,
-0.0609044582,
-0.0103489561,
0.0609307401,
-0.0035118281,
0.003514125,
0.031267792,
0.0399585143,
-0.0393756665,
-0.0222433396,
-0.0356021188,
0.0577685945,
-0.0509259365,
0.0520900413,
0.020911539,
-0.0461796597,
-0.0304083005,
0.0375223383,
0.0085364692,
-0.0043243435,
0.0054621599,
0.0487473644,
-0.0656544566,
-0.0072017936,
-0.015397775,
-0.0218518879,
-0.0473546349,
-0.0799217522,
0.0044110226,
0.015339666,
0.0534044057,
-0.031123599,
-0.0059144902,
0.0053139944,
-0.0113401841,
0.0008901104,
0.0013809961,
0.0487212241,
0.0088718347,
0.0255668052,
0.0245282054,
0.0209157392,
-0.0262709148,
0.0657699704,
0.0255369134,
-0.0083982414,
0.0167858358,
0.0044823787,
0.0071170898,
0.0187606327,
0.000038672,
0.003421816,
0.0468991511,
0.0283554886,
-0.0182963815,
0.044620458,
0.0239497758,
0.038466271,
-0.0443868861,
-0.0390660875,
0.049076654,
0.0176523309,
0.002488055,
0.0276431199,
0.0555674508,
0.0527681857,
0.0351823755,
0.0117762312,
-0.0351156406,
0.0167082977,
-0.0035921396,
-0.0187252332,
0.0025959671,
0.0138682481,
-0.054512646,
-0.0291793272,
0.0505050682,
-0.0053606415,
0.0026571585,
-0.0196852554,
0.0241049379,
-0.0116440812,
-0.082773596,
0.0392916761,
-0.003749775,
-0.031602446,
-0.0431323424,
0.00168778,
-0.0254582595,
0.0483140983,
0.0133896302,
-0.0389664099,
-0.0876925662,
-0.0161971729,
0.0285376236,
0.014159766,
0.0470978692,
-0.0257834252,
0.0685536712,
-0.0604982749,
-0.0267337561,
-0.0331410393,
-0.0093638385,
0.0442849733,
-0.0130589465,
-0.0091729406,
0.0078758299,
0.0426345915,
0.0638603121,
0.0043347999,
-0.0049227988,
0.0221581105,
-0.0131372139,
0.000968377,
0.0366643667,
0.0345788151,
-0.0249517336,
-0.0192045439,
0.0379536115,
0.0143871671,
0.0175906997,
0.0780332312,
-0.105521813,
-0.041953247,
0.0511726029,
-0.0075821117,
-0.0218758993,
-0.0150323678,
-0.0131653026,
-0.065071024,
0.0233383812,
-0.0275772214,
0.0025369087,
-0.0382161476,
0.0207954906,
0.0430375673,
0.0160005856,
0.0066501945,
0.0327703729,
0.0012176177,
-0.0255376212,
0.0840814486,
0.029154256,
0.0338440388,
-0.0373451337,
-0.0033135894,
0.013436473,
-0.0093284966,
0.0114942743,
0.0045349305,
0.0060942904,
-0.0742008165,
-0.0521668009,
-0.1600902826,
-0.0058331075,
-0.0035426219,
-0.0164906718,
-0.005991844,
-0.0021948076,
-0.0237187929,
-0.0549242161,
-0.0536366701,
0.0086120628,
0.0392405428,
-0.0321452841,
0.001739568,
0.0492130779,
-0.004365426,
-0.0201035943,
0.0380212851,
0.0003722423,
0.0258813277,
0.0016287958,
0.0081070308,
-0.0001127723,
-0.0101337638,
-0.0280958489,
0.0544040799,
-0.0279375874,
-0.0584227033,
0.0171704385,
0.0147061758,
0.0506518073,
0.0419316664,
0.0431339517,
0.0124203926,
-0.0100858407,
-0.0684859529,
-0.0468412265,
0.093961142,
-0.0015552856,
-0.0067599919,
-0.0562586077,
0.0397686772,
0.0249355435,
0.021098325,
0.0142274695,
0.0485007241,
-0.0513146445,
0.0074996538,
0.0533670411,
-0.0770654976,
0.0171858761,
-0.0003022223,
-0.0375304446,
0.0066092722,
-0.0196305942,
0.0012518094,
0.0716632232,
-0.0307980329,
-0.0596518815,
-0.0355235413,
-0.0085668275,
-0.0224639121,
0.0417319946,
-0.0419209115,
0.0170231052,
0.0154970288,
-0.0285925996,
-0.0489977822,
0.0165614616,
0.0225369465,
-0.00327773,
0.0263499152,
-0.0420144647,
0.0003655547,
0.0108082565,
-0.0592291392,
-0.055383265,
-0.058845073,
-0.0106748361,
-0.0140187768,
-0.0049050008,
-0.0170467831,
-0.0304271076,
-0.0059287543,
0.0001390866,
0.0309925489,
0.0059210551,
0.0013184435,
-0.0279881097,
0.0362095945,
0.0258679036,
0.0621561632,
-0.0558191873,
-0.0274285953,
0.0613484941,
0.0160109736,
0.0333161205,
-0.0340021886,
-0.0183542594,
0.0258851871,
0.0077877459,
0.0071949135,
0.0053530303,
0.0179443434,
0.0506874062,
-0.0187365524,
0.0137683498,
0.0831620395,
0.0215835422,
-0.0431149676,
-0.0070638354,
0.003375818,
0.0151732741,
0.0058089243,
0.0102047203,
-0.0697982311,
-0.0391703062,
-0.0142595377,
-0.010453851,
-0.0151994405,
-0.0288039371,
-0.0372993127,
-0.0647331327,
0.0153660234,
-0.0088843126,
-0.0188198891,
0.0034056955,
0.0197192039,
0.0088497838,
-0.0116314273,
0.0314867646,
-0.0070965006,
0.0041833553,
-0.0270894151,
0.0305241868,
0.0007044415,
-0.0613039322,
0.0195943229,
-0.0059163598,
0.0588206463,
0.031327717,
0.0254486948,
0.0187416878,
0.0040539247,
0.0041493201,
0.0284214504,
0.0284950286,
0.0204494223,
0.0406815931,
-0.0435191318,
-0.0162847657,
-0.0150642022,
0.0277853366,
0.0028253014,
-0.0251591299,
0.0491948873,
0.0113494564,
-0.060051769,
0.0244672671,
-0.0077933273,
0.0592176169,
0.0422306769,
0.0475761406,
0.0091710538,
-0.0595027842,
-0.0154446503,
-0.0003690746,
-0.0059991581,
-0.050564155,
-0.0026349435,
0.001921198,
0.014999399,
0.0209237188,
-0.0497728027,
-0.0595838577,
0.0048009316,
0.0458989479,
-0.0031329382,
-0.0335037038,
0.0005160662,
0.0153448815,
-0.0159752984,
0.0193241835,
-0.0005234117,
-0.0156331286,
-0.0788030177,
-0.029190436,
0.0622689165,
-0.0191948917,
-0.0064897467,
0.0025951262,
-0.0741697997,
-0.0452279039,
-0.0206758212,
0.0775733143,
0.0160264373,
0.0650068298,
0.00385795,
-0.0276158154,
-0.0004120644,
-0.0225933753,
-0.0431440398,
-0.0046071708,
0.071290262,
0.0338085815,
-0.0255169105,
0.0176584031,
-0.0020570164,
0.0325289071,
-0.026124794,
0.0211126041,
-0.0351829529,
-0.081619814,
0.0072064162,
-0.0167593807,
0.018555453,
0.0388860069,
-0.0052712127,
-0.0281449258,
0.0379838906,
-0.0073027578,
-0.0309142061,
-0.0542940944,
0.0172130372,
-0.0105492417,
-0.0206300169,
0.0055378266,
-0.0002521363,
-0.0162807629,
0.0002156572,
-0.0333677046,
0.0065312949,
0.0498781465,
-0.0181119088,
-0.0188459884,
-0.0173973013,
-0.0102648744,
0.0255010352,
0.0114760883,
0.0038587661,
0.0085760215,
0.1193850115,
0.0151317148,
-0.0532676913,
0.0099118017,
0.0406549834,
-0.0629977509,
-0.0130638145,
-0.0198232085,
0.0328407809,
0.03408603,
0.0446052589,
0.0118702902,
-0.0198009443,
0.0240589567,
0.00623124,
0.0721467733,
-0.0045673195,
-0.0058874846,
0.0200490784,
0.0210191216,
-0.0108557837,
0.0396989025,
0.0602476224,
-0.0222463291,
0.0513093472,
-0.0084888954,
0.0263567343,
-0.0807897896,
-0.0404648148,
0.0104696229,
0.0391754732,
-0.000344459,
0.0316710472,
-0.0217343159,
0.0049855774,
0.0246695075,
-0.0002650627,
-0.0159627423,
-0.004123087,
0.0424869694,
0.0500343554,
-0.0243495181,
0.0006489409,
-0.0006984773,
-0.0220245905,
0.0028865433,
0.0081868228,
-0.0235096067,
-5.513251074e-33,
-0.025432393,
-0.0103468914,
0.047432974,
-0.021075055,
-0.060377147,
0.0041772248,
-0.0262992568,
0.0103757884,
-0.030066615,
-0.0044413824,
-0.0190160405,
0.0161726736,
0.018176401,
0.0152098332,
-0.0021098095,
-0.0098158512,
0.0572723672,
0.0000976323,
-0.0125005422,
0.036789719,
-0.0006995853,
0.0193108227,
0.0239792112,
-0.0912519321,
0.0061705941,
0.0207108054,
-0.0544056408,
0.0501032956,
0.0064313496,
0.0729701668,
-0.0044711037,
0.0161252897,
0.0091829943,
-0.0134120453,
-0.0241706427,
0.0364532433,
-0.040082898,
-0.0046416447,
0.0280975178,
0.0182975419,
-0.0390454493,
0.0025855042,
-0.0384573415,
-0.0231299195,
0.0451538339,
0.0153004527,
-0.0033176153,
-0.0054759751,
0.0251827482,
-0.0057141567,
-0.0464472584,
0.0136211086,
-0.060674198,
-0.0568828806,
-0.0005590268,
0.0870189816,
0.03078858,
-0.0639826208,
0.0020121404,
0.019800676,
-0.004683766,
-0.0256706104,
0.0219046921,
0.0237169992,
-0.0157494377,
0.0675258264,
0.0325739272,
0.023775626,
-0.0042848191,
-0.0275260676,
-0.0008364863,
0.064548187,
-0.0243035145,
0.0709233508,
-0.0368452184,
0.0273674913,
-0.0152077163,
0.0185584892,
0.0580073111,
0.0473444648,
-0.0087801088,
0.0134021929,
-0.0005567744,
0.0013130888,
-0.0417353809,
0.009316965,
-0.0158349518,
-0.0371379741,
0.0345298946,
0.050555449,
0.0043610199,
0.0121948868,
0.052256912,
-0.0153719187,
0.0224269237,
0.0367007293,
-0.0416389853,
0.0210872274,
-0.03739319,
0.0170579236,
-0.0403080322,
-0.0452460945,
0.0834642127,
0.000454959,
0.0227468703,
0.0058253133,
-0.0091117192,
0.0150162159,
-0.0340183191,
-0.01980903,
-0.005149079,
0.0479855165,
-0.0234784819,
0.0313333832,
0.0189330075,
0.0153154051,
-0.0650449842,
0.0708729178,
-0.0124896904,
-0.0007315319,
-0.0335696265,
-0.0701634958,
0.0629752651,
0.0326499864,
-0.030141877,
0.0181176327,
-0.0001414649,
-0.0902592838,
-0.0058125616,
-0.0215641186,
-0.0087415846,
0.0201697052,
2.515e-7,
-0.0284765847,
0.0193804055,
0.0432144403,
-0.0148092695,
0.0117623424,
0.0331176743,
-0.0289018694,
0.0210373532,
0.0025141095,
-0.0247394163,
0.0564267822,
0.0353100598,
0.0396066681,
-0.0022393803,
-0.0956595093,
-0.0804804191,
-0.0607003644,
-0.0358745232,
-0.055545602,
-0.0074024857,
0.0785832554,
0.0479120612,
-0.0243932344,
0.0166956969,
-0.0051791333,
-0.012326993,
0.0626181364,
-0.0257465281,
-0.0333075114,
0.0364702195,
0.037207704,
-0.0104856631,
-0.0237162821,
0.0174783412,
0.0001435218,
0.0474982336,
0.0023620124,
0.0849163979,
-0.0062302169,
-0.0692346841,
0.0083745671,
0.0401772037,
-0.0122699831,
0.0254896227,
0.0440916866,
-0.0426297151,
-0.0284947902,
-0.0477003045,
-0.0418553874,
-0.0022787824,
0.0102649909,
-0.0202981569,
-0.024079334,
0.0244760457,
0.0147667266,
-0.0041779173,
-0.0026451978,
-0.098228097,
0.0035901845,
0.0061843945,
-0.0453939736,
-0.0248199925,
-0.0150711611,
-0.0771570355,
0.037037015,
-0.0480645597,
0.013456746,
1.702550431e-34,
0.0378769636,
-0.0128144529,
0.03861681,
0.0639583766,
0.0194355883,
0.0019190292,
0.0033510777,
-0.021195678,
0.032130219,
-0.0652054101,
-0.0202747863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14838v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14838v2 | ComSL: A Composite Speech-Language Model for End-to-End Speech-to-Text Translation | 2023-05-24T07:42:15 | 2023-10-14T08:47:43 | Chenyang Le, Yao Qian, Long Zhou, Shujie Liu, Yanmin Qian, Michael Zeng, Xuedong Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Joint speech-language training is challenging due to the large demand for
training data and GPU consumption, as well as the modality gap between speech
and language. We present ComSL, a speech-language model built atop a composite
architecture of public pretrained speech-only and language-only models and
optimized data-efficiently for spoken language tasks. Particularly, we propose
to incorporate cross-modality learning into transfer learning and conduct them
simultaneously for downstream tasks in a multi-task learning manner. Our
approach has demonstrated effectiveness in end-to-end speech-to-text
translation tasks, achieving a new state-of-the-art average BLEU score of 31.5
on the multilingual speech to English text translation task for 21 languages,
as measured on the public CoVoST2 evaluation set. | [
-0.0107000554,
0.0452047624,
0.0104307886,
0.0112731587,
-0.0105324602,
-0.0074390587,
0.0483312458,
-0.039879214,
-0.0382593647,
-0.0448823385,
-0.0848549753,
-0.0460877605,
0.0446267314,
0.0102600493,
0.0279339571,
-0.0460852906,
0.0537612997,
-0.052214656,
-0.0172412414,
0.0189169478,
-0.0051542218,
0.0205947198,
-0.0195279103,
-0.0048204516,
-0.0078981798,
0.0012273468,
-0.0010577965,
0.029611893,
0.0176122822,
-0.0074063949,
-0.0040737134,
0.0040745782,
0.0403679647,
0.044164598,
0.0000019277,
-0.0414914675,
-0.0200243983,
0.0122528011,
0.0132934535,
-0.0126136765,
0.0796929374,
-0.0278303307,
-0.0012024117,
0.0480884984,
-0.0116604511,
-0.019073166,
0.0635246858,
0.0234759394,
0.0536687188,
0.0843633488,
-0.0378813818,
-0.0027459497,
0.0125654815,
-0.0465172455,
0.013402367,
-0.0608890355,
-0.0060806051,
-0.0226891767,
-0.0400442369,
-0.0032664204,
-0.0420538224,
0.0829190686,
-0.0044690571,
-0.0012639145,
-0.0340586305,
-0.0032106081,
0.0114606675,
-0.0283216033,
-0.0452148616,
0.0975340158,
-0.0230529867,
-0.0078416634,
0.0052849851,
0.0076203835,
-0.0109450705,
-0.0412746333,
-0.043014247,
0.0226806384,
0.0374914259,
-0.0093738083,
0.0007582101,
0.0329480805,
0.0380472951,
-0.0347576886,
-0.0273469593,
-0.0160528105,
0.0422984213,
-0.0115185967,
0.0279094949,
0.0044001173,
0.009698323,
-0.0138163762,
0.0440192968,
0.0067127114,
-0.0495485999,
0.0037262612,
-0.0598395392,
-0.0526361465,
-0.0301923044,
0.0178787559,
0.0502389111,
0.0564847887,
-0.0359401219,
0.0423831083,
-0.0345926769,
0.0230146963,
-0.0142279984,
0.0270884987,
-0.0549343005,
-0.0473905019,
-0.0387192927,
0.043241147,
-0.0406471081,
-0.0014104072,
-0.069550924,
-0.035351336,
-0.0088727959,
-0.0243807323,
-0.0155593343,
-0.0137795452,
0.0740202367,
-0.0112934504,
-0.0945675448,
-0.0242974591,
0.0212088749,
0.0626030937,
0.0380431376,
0.0390734747,
0.0086685875,
-0.0336707011,
-0.0177474432,
0.0390363783,
0.0191295967,
-0.0453863665,
-0.0014246486,
0.0660382584,
-0.0572515689,
-0.0072162547,
-0.0226579532,
0.0101182973,
-0.006762587,
-0.0657564253,
0.0252651908,
-0.0338953994,
0.0622433946,
-0.0205553584,
0.0174660552,
-0.0123781599,
-0.0034441978,
0.0020726388,
-0.0051316954,
0.0874583051,
0.0045864936,
0.0144881085,
0.0249575172,
-0.0017253637,
-0.008981932,
0.0617051944,
0.0544634238,
0.030992087,
0.0090705575,
-0.0119322687,
-0.0243960321,
0.0487423688,
0.0358833149,
0.0528331213,
-0.0072097918,
0.007688045,
0.0146371741,
0.0552961342,
0.0406776778,
0.0472562499,
-0.0170093104,
0.0056374278,
0.0748792514,
0.0191768408,
0.054721646,
0.0469500571,
0.0492549203,
0.0205515046,
-0.0268195886,
-0.0604467578,
-0.0216635596,
0.0201950707,
-0.0399734192,
-0.001624085,
0.0376794077,
0.0401421152,
-0.0371169411,
0.000586311,
0.0344567075,
-0.0417647138,
0.021094013,
-0.0066357451,
0.0364776216,
0.0230480563,
-0.0810344443,
0.0404907279,
0.0229248405,
-0.0712580308,
0.0587723628,
-0.0129210576,
-0.0262301434,
0.0397022814,
0.0047982638,
-0.0007919933,
-0.0374329537,
-0.0510686375,
0.0357394293,
0.0500755124,
0.0337899253,
0.0081688417,
0.091873996,
-0.0657227188,
0.009331272,
-0.0013608304,
-0.0085626142,
0.0336459838,
-0.0549517125,
0.0457705632,
0.0171435401,
-0.0282847509,
-0.0086513702,
0.0193487611,
-0.0386206619,
0.0038633221,
0.0339614004,
0.0200194195,
0.00384741,
-0.0082500223,
-0.0202474389,
0.0109632267,
-0.0008487641,
-0.0602928326,
0.0133475745,
0.0178182051,
-0.0720518976,
-0.0173602216,
0.0525121428,
-0.0446862429,
0.0224614441,
0.0419173054,
-0.0233716872,
-0.0729230419,
0.0242234934,
-0.00117578,
0.0356392004,
-0.0278737154,
0.0189154837,
0.0323810205,
0.0031638485,
0.0099626575,
-0.0101068811,
0.0137156658,
-0.0453617759,
0.0426926985,
0.0072820568,
0.0169353746,
-0.0319863968,
-0.0091744401,
0.0236182213,
-0.0019360853,
0.046638757,
0.0013027878,
0.037875019,
-0.0053235721,
-0.0208142605,
-0.1073039323,
0.0318922326,
-0.0021198634,
0.0201855674,
0.0583256967,
0.0362693183,
-0.0080464305,
-0.0070686913,
-0.0164406765,
0.0141091626,
0.0188164413,
-0.0104717826,
-0.0153541472,
-0.0111849885,
0.0263320487,
-0.0369398221,
-0.0003439323,
0.0281343386,
0.0189974289,
-0.022963874,
-0.0270846672,
-0.0265729483,
0.0517769568,
0.0005564144,
0.0280040223,
0.0074309413,
-0.0387183651,
-0.0343618169,
-0.0114529617,
0.0385614075,
0.0491806343,
0.0116840387,
-0.0187391024,
0.0022294752,
-0.0736863464,
-0.0606382564,
0.0189129487,
-0.0011418669,
-0.0240118112,
-0.0416362658,
0.0037996131,
-0.0005252467,
0.0580984727,
-0.0103727765,
-0.0045039128,
-0.0629902259,
-0.0357627384,
0.0025461758,
-0.0208910462,
-0.0416659154,
0.0363426656,
-0.0060096327,
0.0033356885,
-0.0415442511,
-0.0230388809,
-0.0040486269,
-0.0974512473,
-0.0229579937,
-0.0463881008,
0.0141349789,
-0.0242652539,
0.0242577698,
-0.0433497392,
0.0264712684,
-0.0248188209,
-0.0234367587,
-0.03658171,
0.0086408826,
0.004637002,
-0.0354542807,
0.0219120514,
-0.0457902662,
0.0111487973,
-0.0325754806,
-0.0224291701,
0.0002690736,
0.0200282186,
-0.0223819576,
0.0068012867,
-0.0095295347,
-0.0226229783,
-0.0504521467,
0.00176227,
0.0234034956,
0.0821837112,
0.0141240424,
0.0016113108,
-0.0303674489,
0.0399124175,
0.0008910964,
0.0385986678,
-0.0093662795,
-0.066341646,
-0.023926504,
0.0108531695,
0.0606571548,
0.0027828051,
-0.0479475521,
-0.0047216951,
0.0521835014,
0.0346979052,
-0.0403370522,
0.0160094239,
0.0570648611,
-0.0410287082,
-0.0080591878,
0.0848282129,
-0.0253793839,
-0.0331588648,
-0.0307856258,
0.0191121828,
0.0232354645,
0.0241697673,
0.035149537,
-0.0701439977,
-0.0676942095,
0.0206074584,
0.0190754253,
0.0505214855,
0.0270342585,
-0.0507999174,
-0.0824722126,
0.0157108735,
0.0311777182,
-0.0383123793,
-0.0585720986,
-0.0048024352,
-0.0106214872,
-0.0298547372,
0.014263412,
-0.0308223162,
-0.0063095433,
-0.0076678144,
0.0188685432,
0.0221890695,
-0.0419754498,
0.0293113012,
-0.0306543615,
0.0564682297,
0.0460593402,
0.0413517542,
0.0009098553,
-0.0464749932,
0.0459185094,
-0.0147688454,
-0.0131014157,
-0.0187733769,
0.0167031419,
-0.0268719308,
0.0100940922,
0.0314364284,
0.0310719647,
-0.0522926599,
-0.0023460854,
0.0334102958,
0.0659928098,
0.0384632945,
-0.0055492278,
0.0394244418,
0.0027257453,
0.0507798381,
0.0485779084,
-0.018555291,
-0.0515453778,
-0.0170045886,
-0.0126400348,
-0.0272852909,
-0.0529470332,
-0.0298134647,
-0.0005390289,
-0.0236680079,
-0.0064092223,
-0.052598238,
-0.0050262534,
0.0100133279,
0.0807121396,
0.0226863753,
-0.001705153,
0.0224895496,
-0.0040798816,
-0.0137683274,
0.0396005586,
-0.0519295707,
0.0621591136,
-0.0742811859,
0.0008385644,
0.013795062,
-0.0724386051,
0.0026489804,
0.0210087039,
-0.0715111569,
-0.0523061752,
-0.0317304172,
0.0545462593,
0.0212900732,
0.0521610156,
-0.0407315791,
-0.0127628287,
0.0484013967,
0.0046096868,
-0.0804085433,
0.0199237391,
0.0515683554,
-0.0293032192,
0.0025001066,
0.0373528749,
0.0073253326,
0.0127544999,
0.0373776071,
0.0538164228,
0.0281966291,
-0.0347495154,
0.0091849649,
0.0170901548,
0.0280659981,
0.0139981611,
-0.0053935735,
-0.0691818446,
0.0311100185,
0.012998282,
0.0192440227,
-0.0718470737,
0.0080227191,
0.0643276647,
-0.0030701705,
0.0137331784,
0.021682281,
0.027238965,
-0.0182714611,
-0.0282929093,
0.0141707351,
0.0081739165,
0.0411624238,
0.0169259794,
0.0047144485,
0.0117379064,
0.0085282717,
0.0100704646,
0.0301559605,
-0.0414286181,
0.0395577587,
-0.0249290187,
-0.0097051272,
-0.0032818983,
0.0235926472,
-0.0169404317,
-0.0238950402,
-0.0410510786,
-0.0036536038,
0.0343698636,
0.0105961561,
0.1341495961,
0.0193918385,
0.009272268,
-0.0407252535,
0.0668667704,
-0.0522214957,
0.0185535755,
0.0042114849,
-0.0487067401,
0.0161762778,
0.0491375066,
0.0448817275,
-0.0106350165,
0.0285822358,
-0.0136708822,
0.0220818985,
-0.0315243639,
-0.0411469564,
0.0236469135,
-0.0182608105,
-0.0349379592,
-0.0195457786,
-0.0062994016,
-0.0451505072,
0.0161469635,
-0.0022565101,
-0.0098074293,
-0.0155086825,
0.0133188637,
0.0524773933,
-0.0377811193,
0.0160339065,
-0.0304804631,
-0.0130269472,
0.0281321201,
0.0010189513,
-0.0103671048,
-6.106283934e-33,
-0.0568401776,
0.0468710475,
0.0586480163,
-0.0521632954,
-0.0471316352,
-0.0066773002,
-0.0303909983,
-0.0103007471,
0.0043204571,
-0.0141953556,
0.0072730542,
-0.0036551452,
0.0246065482,
0.0492649265,
-0.0048795491,
0.0208670441,
0.0614679083,
-0.0210694689,
-0.0213103089,
0.0515460148,
0.0299837627,
0.0539051257,
0.0587413646,
-0.0839180872,
-0.030422559,
0.0254098941,
-0.0258469377,
0.0160315409,
0.012591186,
0.0029313443,
0.0013409246,
-0.0061909733,
-0.0090926029,
-0.0293629598,
-0.0495970398,
0.024491908,
-0.0762533545,
0.0181104057,
0.0228695534,
0.0159183238,
-0.0535573512,
-0.0313828178,
-0.0005942715,
-0.0185867287,
0.0411172286,
-0.0440070853,
0.0017368644,
-0.0294124428,
-0.0201980099,
-0.0138660697,
-0.0900030956,
0.0117188273,
-0.0256042182,
-0.0261937808,
0.0501860417,
0.0658738911,
-0.0269976463,
-0.0157481804,
-0.0764589235,
0.0266931877,
-0.0312926956,
0.0134850768,
0.0899719372,
0.027181685,
-0.021840008,
0.0091122249,
0.0347026475,
-0.031283468,
0.0413497686,
0.0212633442,
0.039970357,
0.0460004583,
-0.011848852,
0.0550084226,
-0.0060894564,
-0.0324551016,
-0.0533175245,
0.0076193544,
-0.0034012769,
-0.0074654585,
0.0105772233,
0.0283282809,
0.0252244174,
0.0109127257,
-0.0509571992,
-0.0195327196,
-0.0044153053,
-0.0088625699,
0.0521315336,
0.0377586111,
-0.0298345517,
-0.0383766368,
0.0985690504,
-0.0041575455,
0.010650632,
-0.020843504,
-0.0124726081,
0.0089365039,
-0.0485645607,
0.0583661199,
-0.0772284493,
-0.0737564489,
0.0382547118,
0.0077280896,
0.0234992225,
-0.0223099254,
0.0239677653,
0.0566291623,
-0.05475289,
0.0032224755,
-0.0565079302,
0.0207250752,
-0.0032809665,
0.0645055249,
0.0316198878,
-0.012573625,
-0.0279102996,
0.0413171314,
-0.025758829,
0.0067508142,
-0.0105138803,
-0.0303075947,
0.0343827382,
0.0318939015,
-0.0435743108,
0.0087052267,
-0.0499772057,
-0.0339650288,
0.0535683446,
-0.0401984565,
-0.0278051049,
0.0104969162,
2.691e-7,
0.0112603148,
0.0125190699,
-0.003362766,
-0.0183270797,
0.006517272,
0.0324352235,
-0.036915049,
0.0373019837,
0.0222932566,
0.0211500097,
0.0040699295,
0.0119911795,
0.0957640409,
0.0259722266,
-0.0274560396,
-0.0486448593,
-0.0079109184,
0.0468223877,
-0.0108693801,
-0.0213058889,
0.0058139176,
0.0744414106,
-0.0429702215,
-0.0066802856,
0.0156200221,
-0.0209180117,
0.0952526182,
-0.0420528799,
-0.012925324,
-0.0130353989,
-0.0073375884,
0.0133332042,
-0.0632555932,
0.007909067,
-0.0279070884,
0.0217369702,
0.0421472862,
0.0829276443,
-0.0005838331,
-0.0352479629,
0.0179262217,
0.0203341451,
-0.0382343605,
0.0106676035,
0.0462716259,
-0.0408322103,
0.0045281877,
-0.0504752807,
-0.0139083331,
0.0566732287,
0.0110576963,
-0.0366256014,
-0.0114397574,
0.0097423289,
0.0445774905,
-0.0076678204,
-0.0407074317,
-0.0359087475,
-0.0250760969,
-0.0028669958,
-0.0447887816,
-0.0377943255,
-0.0533629246,
0.0073911659,
0.0091494285,
-0.0559844188,
0.000201208,
2.079636392e-34,
0.0207400285,
-0.0396580435,
0.0302778427,
-0.0635841116,
0.0321176536,
-0.0395327434,
-0.007857631,
-0.0094585009,
-0.0053062546,
-0.0558149815,
-0.0574269183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14835v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14835v2 | SummIt: Iterative Text Summarization via ChatGPT | 2023-05-24T07:40:06 | 2023-10-09T07:26:40 | Haopeng Zhang, Xiao Liu, Jiawei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text summarization systems have made significant progress in recent years,
but typically generate summaries in one single step. However, the one-shot
summarization setting is sometimes inadequate, as the generated summary may
contain hallucinations or overlook essential details related to the reader's
interests. This paper addresses this limitation by proposing SummIt, an
iterative text summarization framework based on large language models like
ChatGPT. Our framework enables the model to refine the generated summary
iteratively through self-evaluation and feedback, resembling humans' iterative
process when drafting and revising summaries. Furthermore, we explore the
potential benefits of integrating knowledge and topic extractors into the
framework to enhance summary faithfulness and controllability. We automatically
evaluate the performance of our framework on three benchmark summarization
datasets. We also conduct a human evaluation to validate the effectiveness of
the iterative refinements and identify a potential issue of over-correction. | [
0.0639210716,
-0.0309795123,
0.0229095202,
-0.0133064995,
-0.0441523865,
0.0161935631,
-0.0579540208,
-0.0151746329,
0.0192926135,
-0.0396905355,
0.0044085253,
0.0054190196,
0.0119481413,
-0.005918012,
-0.0092021842,
-0.111603789,
0.0173116177,
-0.0315093696,
-0.0025582765,
0.008483828,
0.0515521057,
0.0031051347,
0.0184540022,
0.0375667959,
0.0271605663,
0.0048837215,
-0.0024454219,
-0.0291284099,
0.0218614433,
-0.0044971965,
0.0222505517,
0.0080201058,
0.0046799737,
-0.0005569361,
0.0000020278,
-0.0374261625,
-0.0253253728,
-0.0150289116,
0.0227608588,
0.0311829019,
0.093170017,
-0.0170470681,
0.0069027049,
0.0158651453,
-0.0104069961,
0.0220927317,
-0.026839342,
0.0528625175,
0.0939205065,
0.047768075,
-0.0102713387,
-0.0206146035,
-0.0040811314,
0.0054747891,
-0.0418457948,
-0.0346503891,
-0.0069169891,
0.0725664198,
0.0078620855,
0.0180933811,
0.0101528009,
0.0425930321,
-0.010340753,
-0.0131750535,
0.0137966629,
0.0249628592,
-0.0684552938,
-0.0302224327,
-0.0058906078,
0.0366092175,
0.0255066175,
-0.0247861519,
0.0393776447,
0.0294316038,
0.0008896348,
-0.0097096013,
-0.095356904,
0.0440045595,
-0.0401506126,
0.0205514412,
0.0059714494,
0.0325691588,
-0.0237100683,
0.0123047493,
-0.0084942961,
0.0171670951,
0.0012081073,
-0.0193312932,
-0.0323386155,
0.0054192571,
-0.0100780921,
-0.0748418644,
0.024952177,
0.049015671,
-0.0184159931,
-0.0373723172,
-0.0255384129,
-0.0593915991,
0.0239277165,
-0.0724569038,
-0.0300064217,
0.0014220008,
0.0171934608,
0.0512311384,
0.0087178741,
-0.0027906541,
0.0505444184,
0.0006270452,
-0.0831705406,
-0.0152031034,
-0.0395394564,
-0.0126865534,
-0.0499518923,
0.036896389,
-0.0262866672,
-0.0312111769,
-0.0499662682,
0.0414070487,
0.0210476164,
-0.0070229736,
0.0019480312,
0.0058684689,
-0.0064457525,
-0.0162758436,
0.0176570863,
0.0128854401,
-0.0304311011,
-0.0520186797,
0.0293700397,
0.0225716326,
-0.0044374471,
0.0238258317,
0.0036833961,
0.0339852348,
-0.0094064847,
0.0347280279,
-0.0622285716,
-0.0144919548,
-0.0095492033,
-0.0223266669,
-0.0085893627,
-0.0304452199,
-0.0234484598,
-0.0641731173,
-0.009668692,
0.0075475536,
-0.0313953832,
0.0075733899,
-0.006668814,
0.012580255,
-0.052613765,
0.0145206209,
-0.0491189994,
0.0199243855,
0.0876571089,
0.017965164,
-0.0210472289,
0.0521243699,
0.0255161077,
0.0678294525,
0.0557234772,
0.0250734761,
0.0299000144,
0.0174629092,
-0.0154453693,
0.0129698934,
0.014311485,
-0.0028745786,
-0.0198642872,
-0.0173193756,
0.0076398766,
0.0654994696,
-0.0506199822,
0.0685098544,
0.0568804853,
0.0646721423,
0.0293927863,
0.0480795167,
0.0033213641,
0.057091672,
0.060256727,
0.0600278638,
0.0097396122,
0.0172785372,
-0.0452619977,
0.0523732007,
0.0748041943,
0.013010323,
-0.0122540854,
-0.0617353022,
0.0076532969,
0.0430924706,
0.0424682163,
-0.017531326,
0.0290802121,
0.0068235034,
-0.0390060544,
0.0122360783,
0.0180141423,
-0.0579437949,
0.0262290295,
-0.0273373369,
0.0167046767,
0.0809184164,
0.0652724057,
-0.028379038,
-0.0093703922,
0.0029591457,
0.0389382429,
0.0245667081,
0.0311866887,
-0.0285300054,
-0.0375761613,
-0.0434968397,
-0.0165669788,
0.0160042811,
0.0068591326,
-0.0038789308,
-0.0106529286,
-0.0386391021,
0.0212281402,
-0.0035243675,
-0.0539605692,
0.0299919527,
-0.0048707658,
0.0025639958,
-0.0163887218,
-0.044290334,
0.0103943544,
0.013810656,
-0.0016146076,
0.0119499108,
0.0117041878,
-0.0162202287,
-0.0339116603,
0.0371195413,
-0.0183264352,
-0.0484742299,
0.0338299423,
-0.0420486033,
-0.0060702232,
-0.0317198262,
-0.0160029065,
-0.0534407794,
0.0140413865,
-0.0370022878,
0.0119076436,
-0.044378344,
0.0326342732,
-0.0000092402,
-0.0247087032,
-0.0345594138,
0.0545032918,
0.0331176333,
-0.0292965155,
0.0474068969,
-0.0341782235,
-0.0101792254,
-0.0144918179,
0.0096277799,
-0.0021733753,
0.0031909558,
0.0203964617,
0.071742557,
0.0132588828,
-0.0314646289,
-0.0456576124,
-0.1537754089,
0.0083348826,
-0.029634349,
0.0111703211,
0.0671753213,
0.0149597004,
-0.0151849594,
0.00865738,
-0.020338485,
-0.0339747369,
0.0206704009,
0.0028131162,
0.0126325469,
0.0050069131,
0.0437854119,
-0.0665332749,
0.0060102618,
-0.0001698239,
0.039211072,
0.0446995609,
-0.0393121392,
-0.0457584225,
0.0170912538,
-0.0141575728,
-0.0403831638,
0.0004230021,
0.0049627195,
-0.0119905546,
-0.0169643033,
0.0781221241,
0.0099816304,
0.0672873855,
0.0181629602,
0.0234923474,
-0.0340334587,
-0.0249749497,
-0.0182159804,
-0.0309743173,
0.0025912563,
0.0320078693,
-0.0269534141,
0.05334289,
0.0441774875,
0.0290582776,
0.0248442162,
-0.0369126499,
0.0238568597,
-0.0477384329,
0.0172274821,
-0.0757636279,
-0.0028715169,
-0.0137863243,
0.0136412932,
-0.0268481877,
0.0226125922,
0.0529925562,
-0.0101154773,
0.0218931101,
-0.0780943558,
-0.000056354,
-0.0445776917,
0.0403834805,
0.0055571464,
0.0330190323,
-0.0199536812,
-0.0068183527,
-0.0211638976,
-0.0352616906,
0.0597167909,
-0.013733184,
0.0633980706,
-0.054404255,
0.0243385211,
-0.0159526113,
0.0090965508,
-0.0107397521,
-0.0382909514,
-0.0182001442,
0.01098793,
0.0471187904,
0.0094975475,
-0.0213879105,
0.0411322042,
0.0404560864,
0.0565042309,
-0.0374356024,
-0.046127934,
0.0043671345,
0.0377671272,
0.0587217137,
-0.0359536409,
0.0003211741,
-0.0266967565,
0.0430717878,
0.0663887039,
0.0293569416,
-0.0145447282,
0.0182660967,
-0.0169225819,
-0.0124459788,
-0.1003951281,
0.0180160347,
-0.0266950857,
0.0609680451,
-0.039693635,
0.0098070735,
0.118067421,
0.0195591003,
-0.0370776132,
-0.0225637313,
-0.0015726287,
0.0346579552,
-0.0096427072,
0.0043160203,
-0.0490803607,
-0.0086393608,
0.0098032849,
0.0335774086,
0.0210334286,
-0.0210259836,
-0.0116982963,
-0.0350306071,
0.0337055326,
0.0257562585,
-0.0765374228,
0.0033119933,
-0.0100431908,
-0.0079666348,
-0.0278098993,
0.0035457918,
0.0717270821,
-0.0485836454,
0.0208107326,
0.0120098684,
-0.0952069685,
0.0310219843,
-0.020600481,
-0.0274491981,
-0.0100194179,
0.0486513488,
0.0371649116,
0.0155503275,
0.0815097913,
0.053993836,
-0.0023920469,
-0.016065333,
-0.0048871804,
0.0589683354,
0.0005593619,
0.0217999853,
-0.0439250953,
0.0442132391,
0.0334722064,
-0.0155354561,
0.0627222285,
-0.007060302,
0.0008596854,
-0.0212105792,
-0.0260808785,
0.0477319956,
-0.0407582559,
0.0604839325,
0.0400520228,
-0.019033853,
-0.0281341076,
-0.0586094037,
0.0097445808,
-0.040045768,
-0.0388020985,
-0.0116333012,
-0.0262241904,
-0.0142374476,
-0.0874384046,
-0.0683045387,
0.0236336421,
-0.0305396393,
0.0080284541,
0.0039498596,
0.0063800011,
0.0197234321,
-0.0288254712,
-0.016167257,
-0.0255371537,
-0.0494800992,
-0.023962412,
-0.0253939498,
0.0493929759,
-0.0272813831,
-0.0116278054,
0.042739816,
-0.0594260804,
-0.0298540816,
-0.0115416059,
0.0379658937,
0.0177964028,
0.0588550195,
-0.003317866,
-0.0100201331,
0.0602187216,
0.035497468,
-0.001857875,
0.0313793346,
-0.009299566,
0.0592488162,
-0.0217931028,
-0.0022506965,
-0.05117549,
0.0520704463,
-0.0614096411,
0.0414354615,
-0.0255543496,
-0.0474722534,
0.0207415298,
0.0404509753,
-0.0102544036,
-0.0188984983,
0.0056281565,
-0.0382165089,
-0.0477802679,
-0.0236360431,
-0.0310296379,
-0.031865593,
0.0682570487,
-0.0144288521,
-0.0233419184,
-0.0081839301,
0.0544103123,
-0.0229820218,
0.0084155118,
-0.0475162081,
-0.0130145429,
-0.05876901,
-0.022722384,
-0.0258538704,
-0.0202109497,
-0.0429376513,
-0.0269163661,
-0.0191966705,
-0.0086051626,
-0.0120890355,
0.0280112457,
0.0356313176,
-0.0241366718,
-0.0050348951,
0.040755067,
-0.0802571774,
0.0022176604,
-0.0695354789,
0.0582201667,
0.0503768288,
0.0006687117,
0.0767653883,
-0.0233038664,
-0.0154112624,
-0.0260111783,
0.0433700942,
0.030633999,
0.0022679695,
-0.074522391,
0.0054404093,
-0.0011406041,
-0.0047645229,
0.0912876576,
-0.0481565408,
-0.0093444176,
0.0390662104,
-0.0392573401,
-0.0533941835,
-0.0522603057,
-0.0272632968,
0.0132773528,
0.0176125336,
-0.0413798317,
-0.0256509334,
0.0020744607,
0.0268866885,
0.0195794608,
0.0093780914,
-0.0255179275,
0.0288697518,
0.0458357148,
-0.016336035,
-0.0046324963,
-0.0666972846,
0.0112293372,
-0.0095926719,
0.0153256496,
-0.0208288617,
-6.14147199e-33,
-0.0442407168,
-0.0110546993,
0.0037147813,
0.0602287166,
-0.0357520767,
-0.0272917245,
-0.058966551,
0.0024284141,
0.055150833,
0.0144186597,
-0.0273975953,
0.0042234142,
0.0113154789,
0.0267209914,
0.0135289142,
0.0192232542,
0.0505898483,
-0.0027040183,
-0.0534057692,
0.0506864302,
0.0288461838,
0.0288285352,
0.0220324341,
-0.043686498,
0.0312736966,
-0.0331192389,
-0.0394962654,
-0.0028849149,
0.0723481551,
0.0001036242,
-0.0071469825,
0.0168668274,
0.0346186385,
-0.0350566208,
-0.0444075987,
0.0037552658,
-0.0883745775,
-0.0269708727,
0.0173989218,
-0.0221337639,
-0.0191225372,
-0.0290467609,
0.0494338647,
-0.0381249674,
-0.0036956456,
-0.0197227336,
0.0526647791,
-0.0456352942,
-0.0392570049,
-0.0606850237,
-0.0340303779,
0.0432665236,
-0.0235850047,
-0.041846443,
0.0088342102,
0.0467444658,
-0.0107364673,
-0.0272880457,
-0.0192257967,
0.0425660014,
0.0290845912,
0.0331250615,
0.034596853,
0.021865081,
0.0270952657,
0.0601641051,
-0.0208927691,
0.0080582323,
-0.0480718762,
0.0020457786,
-0.0085666412,
-0.0204528645,
0.008864861,
0.0189306363,
0.0007555392,
0.0265919641,
-0.0100306794,
0.1005249023,
-0.0111380173,
0.0120045748,
0.0305392891,
0.0140127139,
-0.0022051905,
-0.0362751223,
-0.0145536857,
0.0269439053,
-0.0001766646,
-0.0324491821,
-0.0017509038,
0.0160524528,
-0.0542569049,
-0.0209417585,
0.003389176,
-0.0306410007,
0.0401164964,
0.0077359197,
-0.0524721555,
0.0263365768,
-0.0135119036,
-0.0185576845,
-0.0312173143,
0.010399309,
0.0093594566,
0.0351195745,
-0.0171973724,
0.0065098675,
0.0291490685,
-0.0158969983,
-0.0305162631,
0.007702935,
0.0137030119,
0.016575262,
-0.052283749,
0.0092596831,
-0.0177133027,
-0.005254861,
0.0075364248,
0.0257941969,
0.0155970743,
0.0123683885,
-0.0280045066,
0.0048772716,
0.0046793944,
0.0107370308,
-0.0013578917,
0.0482672453,
-0.0177584775,
0.0039744852,
0.0160211585,
-0.0348071456,
-0.0066345274,
0.0012331558,
2.613e-7,
0.0287259873,
0.0677916929,
0.0558781177,
-0.0367970243,
-0.0097950613,
0.0202411003,
-0.0086978683,
0.0118204216,
0.0331089497,
0.0145947486,
0.0618538074,
0.0475061946,
0.0372274071,
0.0306522325,
-0.1023961604,
-0.0457551144,
-0.0992432088,
-0.0586301573,
-0.0201007929,
-0.0309371892,
0.052089531,
0.0314183421,
-0.0151134348,
0.0114598442,
-0.0181858242,
-0.0399530157,
0.0637110323,
-0.0116442265,
-0.0751720667,
0.0695745945,
0.0676277056,
0.0298863593,
-0.0101332245,
-0.0292763636,
-0.0004247202,
-0.0449272133,
0.0583284646,
0.048166994,
0.0033506982,
0.0247167014,
0.0069768527,
-0.0162207298,
0.0448650457,
-0.0058748634,
0.0309650879,
-0.083069168,
0.011207833,
-0.0441588014,
-0.0300524831,
-0.0038256624,
-0.0241134353,
0.0004815088,
-0.053739503,
0.0754051358,
-0.0160217527,
0.020018097,
-0.0074860365,
-0.0626618117,
-0.043997407,
0.0236112513,
-0.010330122,
-0.0199678112,
-0.0054149432,
0.0086917393,
-0.0208813455,
-0.0712885484,
0.0207249299,
2.1466561e-34,
0.0991372913,
0.0011343821,
-0.0396045372,
-0.0174264368,
0.0358427465,
-0.0087007051,
0.0299118385,
0.0178988446,
-0.0010086027,
-0.0430786423,
0.0027804426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15444v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15444v2 | PromptNER: Prompting For Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-24T07:38:24 | 2023-06-20T14:41:38 | Dhananjay Ashok, Zachary C. Lipton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In a surprising turn, Large Language Models (LLMs) together with a growing
arsenal of prompt-based heuristics now offer powerful off-the-shelf approaches
providing few-shot solutions to myriad classic NLP problems. However, despite
promising early results, these LLM-based few-shot methods remain far from the
state of the art in Named Entity Recognition (NER), where prevailing methods
include learning representations via end-to-end structural understanding and
fine-tuning on standard labeled corpora. In this paper, we introduce PromptNER,
a new state-of-the-art algorithm for few-Shot and cross-domain NER. To adapt to
any new NER task PromptNER requires a set of entity definitions in addition to
the standard few-shot examples. Given a sentence, PromptNER prompts an LLM to
produce a list of potential entities along with corresponding explanations
justifying their compatibility with the provided entity type definitions.
Remarkably, PromptNER achieves state-of-the-art performance on few-shot NER,
achieving a 4% (absolute) improvement in F1 score on the ConLL dataset, a 9%
(absolute) improvement on the GENIA dataset, and a 4% (absolute) improvement on
the FewNERD dataset. PromptNER also moves the state of the art on Cross Domain
NER, outperforming prior methods (including those not limited to the few-shot
setting), setting a new mark on 3/5 CrossNER target domains, with an average F1
gain of 3%, despite using less than 2% of the available data. | [
0.0346069112,
0.0195110124,
0.019115353,
0.0228949934,
-0.0014358762,
0.0543781593,
0.0265300293,
-0.0108335614,
0.0294470228,
-0.0762346759,
-0.02638584,
-0.0349993706,
0.0010637086,
0.00478672,
0.0209005717,
-0.0040871412,
0.0185225159,
-0.0137727233,
0.0243094806,
0.0212666281,
-0.0159474667,
0.0255987365,
-0.0292144194,
0.0223998427,
0.0343694836,
-0.0109736845,
-0.0275416933,
0.0086222794,
0.0391617939,
-0.0687962174,
0.019767113,
0.0568794608,
0.0041897334,
0.060937129,
0.0000021753,
-0.0686085895,
-0.076824002,
0.0147101041,
-0.05467375,
-0.013125685,
-0.0002815332,
-0.0590325035,
-0.0082042823,
0.004290706,
-0.0116275428,
-0.038612023,
0.0052131005,
0.0630400553,
0.0184716973,
0.0955524892,
0.0044327565,
-0.0298210755,
0.0337130353,
-0.0196892917,
-0.0115674725,
-0.0356584452,
0.0282866247,
-0.0585774444,
0.0015066072,
0.0440812111,
-0.0061336951,
0.0153214028,
-0.0153662488,
0.0096156374,
-0.0030475517,
0.0301161483,
-0.0077492753,
0.0047661392,
-0.0162335727,
0.0792223662,
0.0099706184,
0.0088617261,
0.0500563607,
-0.0086602522,
-0.0299533308,
-0.0327140875,
-0.0186638609,
0.0027460947,
-0.0265048444,
-0.0006966211,
0.032220792,
-0.0110694217,
0.021496214,
-0.0100806067,
-0.0023551099,
0.0052098646,
0.0202183221,
-0.0316351913,
0.0088766189,
0.0224909652,
-0.0062957024,
-0.0651478097,
-0.0085601099,
0.0303893816,
-0.0261558872,
0.0173982643,
-0.0219744351,
-0.0032388708,
0.0070168143,
0.0124062374,
0.0032279589,
0.0183933564,
0.0153646544,
0.0460580289,
-0.0570159107,
0.0168900881,
-0.0024018453,
-0.0031836065,
0.0337192416,
-0.0151819093,
-0.0834803432,
0.0047460911,
-0.0324771367,
0.0429200791,
-0.0391180515,
-0.0165647194,
-0.0172042605,
0.0107474271,
0.0133630205,
0.0262448154,
0.0219118744,
-0.0304541029,
0.0303675476,
-0.0002597375,
-0.031359449,
0.021867577,
-0.0392868556,
-0.0044192309,
-0.0197240319,
-0.051584214,
-0.0134537946,
-0.0299841873,
0.0172147043,
-0.0394616723,
0.0175194424,
0.0578170083,
0.0512886643,
-0.1137384325,
-0.0865633637,
-0.0004306825,
-0.0077743297,
-0.056894917,
-0.0146505749,
-0.0164089147,
0.0303704496,
0.0176845919,
0.0118621569,
-0.0508828983,
0.0190864354,
-0.0097710034,
-0.0490875654,
0.0982105657,
-0.0403675772,
-0.0078890901,
0.0114120999,
-0.0067826184,
0.0318564177,
0.0678802729,
0.020639658,
-0.0304711815,
0.036303129,
0.0036886756,
-0.0135176554,
0.0007367391,
0.0231746696,
-0.0014957689,
0.0189007111,
0.0064500561,
-0.0078763943,
0.0047857906,
0.0317674093,
0.0310874637,
0.0120913191,
-0.0137233892,
0.0045345412,
0.016352592,
0.0067619686,
-0.0196928699,
0.0621529147,
0.0164750628,
-0.0101527814,
-0.0141891371,
-0.057837382,
0.009441698,
-0.0408207364,
-0.0104684848,
0.0275686868,
0.0589641742,
-0.0387447439,
0.0170888808,
0.0001910945,
0.0032427132,
-0.0302936584,
0.0276139453,
0.0560666472,
0.0171720479,
-0.0814080015,
0.0708023161,
0.0396950394,
-0.0085846633,
0.0046326714,
-0.0134998364,
0.0462956727,
0.0595064871,
0.0347772464,
-0.0200531725,
-0.0480271615,
-0.0634627044,
-0.0028192066,
0.0693442747,
0.028951209,
-0.0124585917,
0.0305637326,
-0.0264045931,
-0.0223558154,
-0.0231075957,
0.034267921,
0.032088533,
0.0055191242,
0.0578401871,
0.0218510386,
-0.0240486097,
0.0003630582,
0.0509248972,
-0.050148882,
-0.0538593717,
0.0193732083,
0.0401074886,
-0.017691426,
0.0736326054,
0.0003007809,
-0.0116283437,
0.002211279,
-0.0280924458,
-0.0120476205,
-0.0536438525,
0.0120909866,
-0.0797904953,
0.0014360113,
0.0111305173,
-0.0226132926,
-0.0180446915,
-0.0396985374,
-0.0449145995,
-0.0347267687,
0.02430268,
0.0216666013,
-0.0256532971,
0.0451414771,
0.0222555045,
0.016583968,
-0.0242768861,
0.068648532,
0.0018869813,
0.0325478353,
0.0534514971,
0.0126719642,
0.0007584477,
-0.0258117951,
-0.0562730432,
-0.0124342749,
-0.0256830472,
-0.0422238074,
0.0112795029,
0.0068116556,
-0.06130879,
-0.0050931321,
-0.0792153999,
0.011592349,
-0.0125812357,
0.0533107407,
0.0010842152,
0.0385167226,
-0.0300980825,
-0.0088450322,
0.0021340754,
-0.003575827,
-0.0311966445,
0.0146300914,
0.0308003239,
-0.0100500081,
-0.0476323292,
-0.007960015,
0.0188989174,
-0.0647952557,
0.0316266455,
0.0070101083,
-0.0489992201,
-0.0654836372,
0.061376255,
-0.0202015359,
-0.0044651111,
0.0083521111,
0.0347273722,
-0.0152160162,
0.0276844073,
0.009072151,
0.0549078584,
-0.0209210776,
0.009726814,
-0.0183193348,
-0.0172464531,
-0.0700417534,
0.0178012345,
-0.0248545967,
0.0233410466,
-0.0110212052,
-0.0224466771,
0.0458423384,
0.1120487601,
-0.0208120439,
0.009092724,
-0.0567776002,
0.0254518222,
-0.0133225797,
0.0029760716,
-0.0023442202,
0.029288806,
0.005787468,
0.0104100434,
-0.0167872794,
0.0180276893,
0.073676914,
-0.0613295138,
-0.0062224874,
-0.0073302523,
0.0020414442,
-0.0630670637,
0.0257965978,
-0.0024006928,
-0.0122824768,
0.1000560895,
-0.0688314214,
-0.0003411545,
0.0450039208,
-0.0039290884,
-0.0126062632,
0.0341501087,
0.0044025122,
0.0294737499,
-0.0115194404,
-0.0255515948,
-0.0349470973,
-0.0406774469,
-0.0636709481,
0.0111787859,
-0.0245838743,
0.0125247035,
-0.0107560419,
0.0317889862,
-0.0075609009,
0.0257391669,
-0.0064972718,
-0.016491048,
-0.0335453264,
0.0563613586,
0.0426099151,
0.0065772557,
0.0255776141,
-0.0078984294,
0.0489059463,
-0.0001435328,
-0.014083148,
0.0155908372,
-0.0034105284,
-0.004446221,
0.0148221133,
-0.0697858408,
0.002747956,
-0.0150940465,
0.0638606697,
-0.0281392243,
0.0038865602,
0.1381397098,
0.0159468707,
-0.0239382479,
-0.0216611829,
0.0086960178,
0.0076190443,
0.0348068736,
0.0349895433,
-0.0949357972,
-0.0647207201,
0.0217809137,
0.00453855,
-0.006946987,
-0.0908797607,
-0.0025753255,
-0.1422692835,
0.0043978076,
-0.0529839769,
-0.0510129221,
0.0316573679,
-0.0684167519,
0.0150869358,
-0.0304046385,
-0.0006233387,
-0.0389181077,
-0.0225060899,
0.0017957257,
0.0093748234,
0.0364272483,
-0.057913363,
0.0230723862,
-0.0584362671,
0.0714927688,
0.0364363678,
0.0329463109,
0.0027233802,
-0.0084210904,
0.0042060008,
-0.0408453383,
-0.0060408111,
-0.0308148265,
0.0553594008,
-0.0535054877,
-0.0054181358,
-0.0136894491,
0.0111754816,
-0.0416855887,
-0.0083190203,
0.019677883,
0.0530069023,
0.0046789208,
0.0090898955,
-0.0108626736,
-0.0105956225,
0.0319852829,
0.0969868898,
0.0288100392,
-0.0325479954,
-0.0123234838,
-0.0000514476,
-0.0124540171,
-0.023708649,
-0.0243467912,
0.0092568891,
-0.0116946315,
-0.0170410834,
-0.029437596,
-0.05019629,
0.0621363372,
0.0323989727,
0.017587781,
0.0211495981,
-0.0127228526,
0.0143432468,
-0.0559860654,
0.0298465304,
-0.0244648047,
0.0255234297,
-0.081933409,
0.0080925021,
0.0376131199,
0.0163220074,
-0.0409439802,
0.000814232,
-0.0669768825,
-0.0466030762,
-0.042137906,
0.0237624943,
0.0105286771,
0.0247110613,
-0.0254643783,
-0.0117171621,
0.0416266657,
0.0482521802,
-0.040246021,
-0.0206293929,
0.0020649356,
0.0256834552,
-0.0033782227,
0.0416402929,
-0.0411785059,
0.0153666455,
0.0270021353,
0.0833966285,
-0.0152943237,
-0.0207061321,
0.0024823255,
0.0104505401,
0.0710693747,
-0.0268778615,
-0.0337494798,
-0.0338237286,
0.0087601431,
0.0088180909,
0.0048587532,
-0.0141313411,
-0.0078233965,
0.0097000236,
-0.0202868767,
-0.0081816539,
0.0632366762,
-0.0232691504,
0.0581920221,
-0.0654411316,
0.0373727642,
0.0279189758,
0.0313646495,
-0.0004706688,
-0.0195908919,
0.0134192836,
0.0569729581,
0.0832248181,
0.0420661978,
-0.0326995701,
0.0539365038,
-0.0030473552,
0.0174134523,
-0.0179263633,
0.0164000746,
-0.0234925617,
-0.0007014006,
-0.0232480932,
0.0429595858,
0.0476843715,
-0.0027058348,
0.0507101566,
0.0321989954,
-0.0034901842,
0.0080916686,
0.0254678819,
-0.0038889572,
-0.0123120146,
0.041958265,
0.0262952019,
-0.0283406787,
-0.0203934908,
0.0546188504,
-0.0174571648,
0.0475550853,
0.0400273874,
0.0073865075,
-0.0506452173,
-0.010036584,
0.0287379678,
-0.0093371207,
-0.0261291396,
0.0246198811,
-0.0600763448,
-0.0372140035,
0.0345474221,
-0.0648323148,
-0.0519768186,
0.0174348019,
0.0037246279,
-0.0033142699,
0.0109224375,
-0.0125628011,
-0.0480096675,
-0.0149282431,
-0.0054889061,
-0.0624110922,
0.0121301096,
-6.468624924e-33,
-0.04881211,
-0.0162335038,
0.0242462419,
-0.0255042966,
-0.0063176802,
0.04969595,
-0.0430678651,
-0.0101485122,
-0.0085533755,
-0.0387963019,
-0.0089029325,
-0.0103182532,
0.0236656647,
0.0079902373,
-0.0113388337,
-0.0431457087,
0.0535586216,
0.0275931042,
-0.0376559347,
0.000391268,
0.0201934781,
0.0872536376,
0.0636605248,
-0.0436569043,
0.0600156859,
0.0190797504,
-0.0033427533,
0.0102922777,
0.0732152313,
0.067275621,
-0.0408321209,
-0.000871915,
0.0205389801,
-0.0828381702,
0.0234590173,
0.0335261747,
-0.1512480527,
0.0043453085,
-0.0186773706,
0.01618113,
-0.0093853287,
-0.0336548798,
-0.0059688585,
-0.0059656599,
0.0282667466,
0.0110687194,
0.0359853469,
0.0018757273,
0.0122429803,
-0.0307379737,
-0.0675152391,
0.0432778336,
0.0070854803,
-0.0039373487,
0.0471507423,
0.0409243926,
0.0392453223,
0.0283661447,
-0.0648264363,
-0.0021235694,
0.0193218626,
-0.0321465097,
0.0302046183,
-0.0077196211,
-0.0227466561,
0.0431126878,
0.0283136256,
-0.0028666682,
-0.0424896702,
-0.0008923757,
0.0301923528,
0.0179172251,
-0.0424844809,
0.0730363131,
0.023952093,
-0.0161277447,
-0.0618345551,
0.037387155,
0.0272762869,
0.0059357914,
-0.0055502532,
-0.0446968898,
-0.0671087056,
-0.0126238782,
-0.0139554041,
-0.0447316095,
-0.0617363639,
-0.0078418721,
0.0506487601,
0.0215827003,
-0.0574984662,
0.0098949568,
0.0352170616,
-0.0512323342,
-0.0580013059,
0.0315162763,
0.0405772217,
-0.0091876136,
0.0072636865,
0.0177562069,
-0.0618429668,
-0.0527536944,
0.0107377004,
-0.0217964482,
0.0232776031,
-0.0109058637,
0.0483756997,
-0.0125135351,
-0.0742686018,
-0.0017394336,
-0.0132532874,
0.0365729965,
-0.0412054509,
0.0567379706,
0.0045220968,
0.010547841,
-0.0086592743,
0.0284880269,
0.0701820776,
-0.028829461,
0.007747551,
0.0527413264,
0.0171357151,
0.0301379468,
-0.0132037587,
-0.0341992266,
0.0344347209,
0.013005008,
0.0064378274,
-0.0654387996,
-0.0107110022,
-0.0279404167,
2.821e-7,
-0.0095497416,
0.0240305867,
-0.0076331152,
-0.0111474972,
-0.0078467736,
0.0259157661,
0.0087049548,
0.0413687192,
-0.032326553,
-0.0133618955,
-0.0062563531,
-0.0201996602,
0.0324923098,
0.0043296148,
-0.1130704358,
-0.0030992003,
0.0138758272,
0.0054013142,
-0.0664291158,
0.0296433885,
0.0260845777,
0.0749363899,
-0.0030156521,
-0.0177055579,
-0.0350717567,
-0.0170662012,
0.054599911,
0.0055781156,
0.0150935901,
0.0380335078,
-0.0089851301,
0.0483299308,
-0.0193953477,
0.0187193938,
-0.0142114284,
0.0591327734,
-0.0107760141,
0.0699486583,
0.02090781,
-0.0190936085,
-0.0010299181,
-0.0417860895,
0.0270829722,
-0.0315353684,
0.0854245424,
-0.0459456332,
-0.0241815932,
0.0106313676,
-0.0441703498,
-0.0329747982,
0.0028822625,
-0.0042140963,
-0.0006628239,
0.0349684916,
0.0210506693,
-0.0460429266,
-0.0152755706,
-0.0646210089,
0.0181024224,
0.0119621186,
0.0096681025,
0.0138926245,
-0.0090093371,
-0.0311105344,
0.0080639683,
-0.066988498,
0.0041298298,
2.694026881e-34,
-0.0132279955,
0.0115843462,
-0.0231511649,
0.0561950915,
0.0045007397,
0.0017478975,
-0.0481164232,
-0.021505598,
0.0231188107,
-0.0663177818,
0.0195132867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14828v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14828v2 | Towards Few-shot Entity Recognition in Document Images: A Graph Neural Network Approach Robust to Image Manipulation | 2023-05-24T07:34:33 | 2024-02-23T05:36:02 | Prashant Krishnan, Zilong Wang, Yangkun Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent advances of incorporating layout information, typically bounding box
coordinates, into pre-trained language models have achieved significant
performance in entity recognition from document images. Using coordinates can
easily model the absolute position of each token, but they might be sensitive
to manipulations in document images (e.g., shifting, rotation or scaling),
especially when the training data is limited in few-shot settings. In this
paper, we propose to further introduce the topological adjacency relationship
among the tokens, emphasizing their relative position information.
Specifically, we consider the tokens in the documents as nodes and formulate
the edges based on the topological heuristics from the k-nearest bounding
boxes. Such adjacency graphs are invariant to affine transformations including
shifting, rotations and scaling. We incorporate these graphs into the
pre-trained language model by adding graph neural network layers on top of the
language model embeddings, leading to a novel model LAGER. Extensive
experiments on two benchmark datasets show that LAGER significantly outperforms
strong baselines under different few-shot settings and also demonstrate better
robustness to manipulations. | [
0.019647656,
0.0432916991,
0.0322259627,
0.0532164425,
-0.0207888372,
0.0145825893,
0.0302099213,
0.0397759303,
0.0262420811,
-0.0236911438,
-0.0306739304,
-0.003843026,
0.0050872345,
0.0152882785,
0.030759234,
-0.0195668377,
-0.0020975263,
-0.0328329429,
-0.0041551222,
-0.0109580113,
-0.0070883506,
0.0143087991,
0.0066559808,
0.0022741926,
-0.0559684038,
-0.0182830542,
-0.0164604504,
0.0672357902,
0.0264397692,
-0.0341464169,
-0.0301581863,
0.0093534505,
0.0205078553,
0.0598496608,
0.0000018519,
0.0345977172,
-0.0308635216,
0.0301028118,
-0.0407819226,
-0.0284239259,
0.0396776311,
-0.0804873258,
-0.0023767336,
-0.0450063013,
-0.0125619695,
-0.0796879008,
0.0497017317,
0.0394376442,
0.034851905,
0.1042538658,
-0.0476064049,
-0.0507272519,
0.0274937805,
-0.0324864388,
-0.0004906802,
-0.0563229024,
0.0015261025,
-0.0007944843,
-0.0031585582,
0.0069042617,
-0.0613235943,
0.0151364449,
0.0047866874,
-0.0294903349,
0.0237128194,
0.0396210514,
-0.0327453539,
0.0209445339,
-0.0016115357,
0.1196777076,
-0.0628172681,
0.0041496269,
0.0108479522,
-0.0345222689,
0.0064931349,
0.0126365228,
-0.057734333,
-0.0205270741,
0.0056366627,
-0.0052274032,
-0.0415564179,
-0.0043528802,
0.0234710835,
-0.0164179578,
-0.0373186804,
0.03814568,
-0.0011609509,
0.0078619393,
-0.0327950418,
-0.003203718,
-0.0359581374,
-0.0304948483,
0.0267636068,
0.0592750013,
0.0491306521,
0.0086623542,
-0.0237258822,
-0.032887727,
-0.0286624711,
-0.0226520002,
0.0336987041,
-0.0207278449,
-0.023492476,
0.066301465,
-0.0650672242,
0.0698165819,
-0.0092745833,
0.0895187259,
-0.0316497795,
0.0147364996,
0.0006658424,
0.0050794389,
-0.0457710177,
0.0295563266,
0.0051574595,
-0.0599224009,
-0.0122435121,
0.0282671228,
0.0188715011,
0.0410542712,
-0.0067355977,
0.0073979385,
0.028122725,
-0.0731579661,
0.0476028323,
0.0021869896,
-0.0094292266,
-0.012568255,
-0.0185768735,
-0.0019143965,
0.0015434785,
0.0251786448,
0.0781284347,
-0.0233353507,
0.0221221726,
0.0483792722,
0.045980271,
-0.0718098283,
-0.0151691213,
-0.0020454254,
-0.0201568566,
-0.0405322611,
0.0511155128,
-0.0255133528,
0.0517430902,
-0.0157575756,
-0.0146665769,
-0.0467202589,
0.0097878855,
-0.0013619344,
-0.0798503533,
0.070993349,
-0.0093984008,
0.0121143395,
0.0445021614,
-0.0340683907,
0.0312790163,
0.0056183906,
0.0417112112,
0.0588748045,
0.0485012718,
-0.0108493539,
-0.0133508788,
0.0436870605,
0.037977796,
-0.0530940853,
0.0078406753,
0.0268388186,
-0.0097253826,
0.0055459682,
0.0065364237,
0.0150681688,
-0.0562987626,
-0.0340830646,
0.0603944287,
0.0795400217,
-0.0152630992,
-0.0053255646,
-0.0014613267,
-0.0027346516,
-0.0179106947,
-0.004174225,
-0.077949807,
-0.0087975468,
0.0390111208,
0.0128158592,
-0.0384030007,
-0.0071974555,
-0.0223931409,
0.0218283813,
0.005393608,
-0.0185201,
0.0343286581,
-0.0155956782,
0.0884620771,
0.0095499372,
-0.0749804825,
0.0374611877,
-0.0262629222,
-0.0117242113,
-0.0230571255,
0.0211014468,
-0.0258502364,
0.036257647,
0.0523336753,
-0.0148696415,
-0.0394664183,
0.0067730881,
0.0154096084,
0.0186985228,
0.0518185012,
-0.0234369542,
0.0132040484,
-0.0410243571,
-0.0403161272,
-0.0114907324,
-0.0140159726,
0.0215312708,
-0.0064573498,
0.0144857559,
0.0328730308,
-0.0700270236,
-0.0226040334,
0.0384054706,
0.0422380082,
-0.0489162244,
-0.0087146545,
0.0536313988,
-0.0432148166,
0.0266520251,
-0.0007200335,
-0.0069641056,
0.0451687574,
-0.0182446502,
0.0513858646,
-0.0011743999,
-0.0257896073,
-0.0755845979,
0.0277478062,
0.003384596,
-0.0145341782,
-0.0315818079,
-0.0584341772,
-0.0354925357,
0.0190623086,
-0.0026797962,
0.0303391777,
0.0079280548,
0.017964242,
-0.0041069034,
0.0330427364,
-0.0260488875,
0.0308245961,
0.0151041904,
0.0183728263,
-0.0123165948,
0.0216274001,
-0.0043966351,
-0.0236983038,
-0.0043592686,
-0.0129433833,
0.0055325325,
-0.0275456626,
0.0122253122,
0.0240905564,
-0.017032817,
-0.0237156898,
-0.0830387026,
-0.0580954291,
-0.0029714936,
0.0260303356,
-0.0104282871,
0.0107477801,
0.0093227364,
-0.0697465613,
-0.0399991497,
0.0253079459,
-0.021959221,
-0.0082333302,
0.071346961,
0.0075122379,
-0.023242496,
0.0138222352,
-0.0314201191,
-0.0024314425,
0.071176596,
0.0280598886,
-0.0366182141,
-0.0128040295,
-0.0001789725,
0.0033291623,
0.0078931255,
-0.002329061,
0.0239555426,
-0.0057026735,
-0.003829923,
0.0120468801,
0.1128520891,
-0.0408431068,
0.0227354225,
-0.0479433089,
-0.0010479323,
-0.0487224497,
-0.0163151715,
-0.0372460634,
0.0404372141,
0.0027157103,
-0.0132738138,
-0.0193618815,
0.0384012684,
-0.0642439276,
0.0324996412,
-0.0353798829,
-0.0016970009,
0.0036428557,
0.0404009372,
-0.0383503959,
0.0011816025,
0.0041525019,
0.0088073332,
-0.0481990837,
-0.0348063372,
0.018004626,
-0.0473185144,
-0.0210657604,
0.0599772036,
0.0272569805,
-0.0457323529,
0.0702875406,
0.0928620249,
0.0361436233,
-0.0029612284,
-0.0547908023,
-0.0405451767,
0.0382696092,
-0.0096673639,
-0.0207789354,
-0.0071192542,
0.0160390399,
0.0648892745,
-0.0345764197,
-0.0352913886,
0.0103142206,
-0.0036434631,
0.0156686492,
0.0171571523,
-0.0220060442,
-0.0288173892,
-0.0040154089,
0.0591068417,
-0.0325518511,
0.0824953839,
-0.0339504331,
0.0109181497,
-0.0208776221,
0.0831736475,
0.0454719029,
-0.0452355295,
-0.0046449769,
-0.0281640161,
-0.0065824692,
0.0071345037,
0.0169454142,
0.0032352984,
-0.012736476,
-0.0101777418,
0.0065866229,
-0.0020705524,
-0.0079006525,
-0.0286177993,
0.0230489746,
-0.0327964723,
-0.0204737131,
0.0836334676,
0.0007210909,
-0.026593769,
-0.0268513206,
-0.0005011029,
0.0075413939,
-0.0024281999,
0.023930762,
-0.1011108011,
-0.0047570197,
0.0015686225,
-0.0148634119,
0.0593517795,
-0.0462819263,
-0.0033880922,
-0.0849571228,
0.0124389865,
0.0235554762,
-0.0286858194,
-0.0209843908,
-0.0013020033,
-0.0053534186,
-0.0099106207,
-0.0059363032,
-0.0167932622,
-0.0172169283,
-0.0637731478,
-0.0014661733,
-0.0092938123,
0.0013172459,
-0.0233472586,
-0.0281256158,
-0.02551632,
-0.0084821247,
0.048975084,
0.0148024391,
0.0023073861,
0.0431807749,
0.0606398396,
0.0041886903,
0.0101872133,
0.0402292572,
-0.0381252505,
-0.0087528164,
0.0199443139,
0.0035506187,
-0.0427477062,
-0.0172616672,
-0.0617898926,
0.0382770188,
-0.0037991658,
-0.0298402067,
-0.0029952941,
-0.0448204428,
-0.0256360006,
0.0064143748,
0.0309817623,
-0.0213173777,
-0.0526581667,
-0.0211969335,
0.0623122714,
-0.0444107056,
0.0203126166,
0.0111209145,
-0.0301250294,
-0.0194758344,
-0.0498326495,
-0.028219616,
0.0294527169,
0.0528312586,
-0.0134111354,
-0.0196813196,
0.0390127301,
-0.0352663323,
-0.0587852709,
0.0232111029,
-0.025231678,
0.0176881347,
-0.0410354733,
0.0405842438,
0.0210885834,
-0.0014658935,
-0.0431755446,
-0.0198395327,
-0.0816044733,
-0.0522840545,
-0.0088769402,
0.0371253528,
0.001420674,
0.0608331859,
-0.0350536108,
-0.0313194506,
0.0363160893,
0.0260643307,
-0.0151789915,
-0.0242644809,
0.0027288066,
-0.0402281284,
-0.0372613259,
0.0177617855,
-0.0461260863,
0.0547599196,
0.0686668977,
-0.017382944,
-0.0743364841,
-0.034338221,
-0.021080276,
0.0100788884,
0.0278047174,
-0.0229581669,
0.0254337806,
-0.0448956229,
0.0175002944,
0.020832425,
0.0187467597,
-0.0148747731,
-0.0437723882,
0.0122661833,
-0.0011550054,
-0.0077852015,
-0.0071249325,
0.0215128269,
0.046192497,
-0.0193012059,
0.0056764022,
0.0069018216,
0.0259572659,
0.018008627,
0.0157157276,
0.0013509295,
0.0569346845,
-0.0119853746,
0.0311348606,
-0.0414396562,
0.0001938852,
0.019518517,
-0.0171063673,
-0.0289485399,
0.0378588066,
-0.0181601774,
0.0247263554,
-0.0850219578,
0.0266636945,
0.0399895087,
0.0018924141,
0.0022328149,
-0.0154022714,
-0.0283053741,
0.0134715447,
0.0210782252,
0.0159787759,
-0.040349476,
0.0069996174,
0.0554974899,
0.0072041643,
0.024470374,
0.0223181881,
0.0602995716,
0.0052646482,
0.0207392126,
-0.0235373396,
-0.0547178388,
0.0082473047,
0.0317365713,
0.0089942971,
-0.0065614344,
0.0293384828,
-0.0215715207,
-0.0555885956,
0.0289162379,
-0.0155072622,
-0.0026348054,
0.0731290132,
0.0084410897,
-0.0045060692,
0.0362461507,
0.0056506866,
-0.035711471,
0.0293005127,
0.0141579174,
-0.0109488908,
-0.0025510057,
-5.68945731e-33,
-0.034971945,
-0.0731053725,
-0.0088799549,
0.0048904419,
-0.0196784157,
0.0262386389,
-0.0256576166,
-0.0240730252,
-0.0476058014,
-0.002878184,
-0.0215390548,
-0.0046073999,
0.0314280428,
0.0282893367,
-0.0544132814,
0.0073335073,
0.0221745614,
-0.021671921,
0.0002640314,
0.0269226879,
0.0061947969,
0.0650542602,
0.0774145052,
-0.0529271103,
0.0259721614,
-0.017324701,
0.0034427957,
-0.0090879435,
0.0588696636,
0.0143458713,
-0.0088308882,
-0.0215377305,
0.0295643229,
0.0030142923,
-0.0008394825,
0.0420949459,
-0.1274608672,
0.0164195169,
-0.0486094281,
0.0863083154,
0.0130261937,
-0.0207677428,
0.0544492751,
-0.03995426,
0.011345895,
-0.0190875344,
0.0312110912,
-0.0010330623,
-0.0294303428,
0.0067202076,
-0.0659138411,
0.0538975149,
0.011325499,
0.0097991116,
0.0712415799,
-0.0177103821,
0.0226817299,
0.0014811936,
-0.090705134,
0.0019136844,
-0.0217411593,
-0.0182261989,
0.0253256802,
0.0435505249,
0.0075805006,
0.0334785283,
0.0137831531,
-0.002453815,
-0.0259062219,
0.0301481783,
0.0565315969,
0.0487287678,
0.0188317876,
-0.0091905287,
0.0436463542,
-0.0144485161,
-0.0769465268,
-0.0094083333,
-0.0313152783,
0.0078598326,
0.007121813,
0.0036845934,
-0.0138849691,
-0.0106671574,
0.013009117,
-0.0719718561,
-0.0300396904,
-0.0051907622,
0.0082998015,
0.0474904999,
-0.037546277,
0.0560652316,
0.0496212579,
-0.0475287065,
-0.0427439213,
0.0162349362,
0.0233341083,
0.0691478848,
-0.0194494519,
0.0042033712,
-0.0256381873,
-0.0595102124,
0.0073724398,
0.0086572934,
0.0230553895,
0.0057426128,
0.1070980355,
0.0172949135,
-0.0402784608,
-0.034478195,
-0.0072050779,
-0.0362922885,
0.0033898633,
0.0092245946,
0.0449727885,
-0.0110872369,
0.0100011136,
0.057071209,
0.0521524996,
0.0195553936,
0.0301046837,
0.0182733461,
0.0043620598,
0.0406132787,
-0.004284773,
-0.015186389,
0.0182848405,
0.0496014953,
0.049954664,
-0.0415232778,
-0.0074933134,
0.0090218913,
2.549e-7,
0.0799186677,
0.0534456447,
0.0662285686,
0.0009084584,
-0.0039381874,
0.0012481102,
0.0020070865,
0.0334452912,
-0.0537866466,
0.0211002585,
0.0495896228,
0.0015138204,
0.0311128106,
-0.0095959539,
-0.0912454501,
0.0658301041,
-0.0934112668,
0.0036592782,
-0.0740437433,
0.007255211,
-0.0159303565,
0.0702590868,
-0.0268980172,
-0.0363133885,
-0.0206684805,
-0.0646115988,
0.0608164147,
-0.0082093114,
0.0456133857,
0.0164141022,
-0.0174877048,
-0.0013383314,
-0.0468511321,
0.0274621379,
0.0112490375,
0.049599003,
0.0791566521,
0.0431448072,
-0.0589988232,
0.0324802883,
-0.0139940055,
-0.0532773621,
-0.0201891772,
-0.0524369925,
0.0693194643,
-0.0624088012,
-0.0180267859,
-0.041471988,
-0.0467625335,
-0.0066974796,
0.023024857,
-0.014381554,
0.0204630531,
0.0443490706,
0.0742459074,
-0.0656220317,
0.0117294379,
-0.0775667205,
0.0034407752,
0.0085132439,
0.0279008988,
0.034777008,
-0.053418193,
-0.0231447574,
0.0065114689,
0.0002014427,
-0.0230910368,
2.290154344e-34,
0.0071059507,
0.0034422013,
-0.0277986377,
0.0526219457,
0.0247144531,
-0.0447983406,
-0.0112080546,
0.0174970683,
-0.0133491941,
-0.0759539977,
0.0037672308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14827v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14827v2 | Pre-training Intent-Aware Encoders for Zero- and Few-Shot Intent Classification | 2023-05-24T07:34:32 | 2023-11-14T02:23:01 | Mujeen Sung, James Gung, Elman Mansimov, Nikolaos Pappas, Raphael Shu, Salvatore Romeo, Yi Zhang, Vittorio Castelli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intent classification (IC) plays an important role in task-oriented dialogue
systems. However, IC models often generalize poorly when training without
sufficient annotated examples for each user intent. We propose a novel
pre-training method for text encoders that uses contrastive learning with
intent psuedo-labels to produce embeddings that are well-suited for IC tasks,
reducing the need for manual annotations. By applying this pre-training
strategy, we also introduce Pre-trained Intent-aware Encoder (PIE), which is
designed to align encodings of utterances with their intent names.
Specifically, we first train a tagger to identify key phrases within utterances
that are crucial for interpreting intents. We then use these extracted phrases
to create examples for pre-training a text encoder in a contrastive manner. As
a result, our PIE model achieves up to 5.4% and 4.0% higher accuracy than the
previous state-of-the-art text encoder for the N-way zero- and one-shot
settings on four IC datasets. | [
0.0238222014,
0.0083947284,
0.0002437987,
0.0269144941,
-0.0141552873,
0.0368313417,
0.0209144391,
-0.0075143455,
0.0079177022,
-0.0515260324,
-0.0318211354,
-0.0228994768,
-0.0194568094,
0.0285781957,
0.0013442527,
-0.0431131199,
0.0271857996,
0.01390009,
0.0433583297,
0.0290109031,
0.0273268223,
0.0174163934,
-0.0318582915,
0.06921608,
-0.0095377248,
-0.0288602021,
-0.038990438,
0.0328953154,
0.0263665188,
-0.0558639467,
0.0249644928,
0.0457373634,
0.0398707278,
-0.0090328595,
0.0000016962,
-0.0438070633,
-0.0081220707,
-0.0224858318,
-0.0706432164,
-0.0407270119,
0.0197691545,
-0.0200526789,
0.0237949342,
0.0373895615,
-0.0199447647,
-0.0114874486,
0.0490544476,
0.0751006305,
0.0402902551,
0.0731062144,
-0.0370075256,
-0.0425985865,
0.0183155797,
-0.0290358122,
0.0526613034,
-0.0411380418,
0.0020224294,
-0.0125259897,
-0.0262647569,
0.0657145604,
-0.0171467792,
0.0247847401,
0.0178414173,
0.0132699842,
0.0205641631,
0.0192493666,
0.0484076515,
-0.0237833224,
-0.0390997976,
0.0660771504,
-0.0026455717,
0.011041156,
-0.0136333173,
-0.0490933545,
-0.0263292976,
-0.0699465126,
-0.0163220894,
-0.0224868581,
0.010358952,
0.0112396991,
0.0449139625,
0.0751708746,
-0.0100432783,
-0.0053278287,
-0.0036371439,
-0.0084293569,
0.004017625,
-0.0310735982,
0.0047813002,
0.0003849527,
0.014811716,
-0.0594118834,
-0.0008362264,
0.007298131,
-0.0325585864,
0.0171674192,
-0.0614678189,
-0.0121947443,
0.0091300821,
-0.0175650548,
-0.0066205179,
0.0686497241,
0.0006002344,
0.0534961224,
0.0245723072,
0.0214135721,
0.0283019841,
0.0252375789,
-0.0498163849,
-0.022508394,
-0.0704614371,
0.0175141878,
-0.0651040971,
0.022552859,
-0.0456752814,
-0.0271010213,
-0.0246119052,
0.0460250787,
0.0024384402,
-0.0064510135,
0.0150402691,
0.0062333327,
-0.0497329049,
0.0001128923,
-0.0024379864,
0.0546903014,
-0.0184012745,
0.0491016917,
-0.0043573217,
-0.0292556267,
-0.0506224968,
0.0367076844,
0.0314568356,
-0.0260970332,
0.0050184005,
-0.0084569091,
-0.0431779064,
-0.0834030509,
-0.0316514522,
-0.0191123188,
-0.0352557227,
-0.0214283448,
-0.0492656305,
-0.0151087446,
0.0426482596,
-0.0089006862,
-0.0134482328,
-0.0458504073,
-0.0046157432,
0.0076736533,
0.0004698997,
0.0903754085,
0.0017384554,
-0.0228863936,
-0.0240954831,
0.0109081119,
-0.0392990522,
0.0687937513,
0.0175994374,
0.0142197898,
-0.0088852914,
0.0030406504,
0.0069747181,
0.0172749832,
0.0076820883,
-0.0011122616,
0.0563520789,
0.0230311584,
0.0145777836,
0.0075656413,
0.0236989632,
0.0427877121,
-0.0513310917,
-0.0060552042,
0.0386696309,
0.0499700494,
-0.0139797861,
-0.0010367996,
0.0568550043,
0.0723060668,
-0.0447595678,
-0.0298171286,
0.002285511,
0.008981348,
-0.0317462385,
-0.0040399651,
0.0367887504,
-0.0229370538,
-0.0694776252,
-0.0319896415,
0.0005613764,
-0.0359571762,
0.0379519351,
-0.0143002477,
0.0530786179,
0.0221240912,
-0.0844205692,
-0.0124676861,
-0.0151930498,
-0.0408073701,
-0.0061758347,
-0.0314493552,
0.0208829492,
0.0620693117,
0.0463155322,
-0.0253070295,
-0.0565997362,
-0.0550481714,
-0.0282452069,
0.0138886543,
0.0145805301,
-0.0365149677,
0.0492327027,
-0.0713046342,
-0.0347541086,
-0.0422946289,
-0.0151001094,
0.0020232403,
-0.0441925451,
0.0150889847,
-0.0001769593,
-0.0007833408,
0.0304631889,
0.0092300531,
-0.0105025349,
-0.0434481762,
0.0468781069,
0.0281009376,
0.0219600573,
0.0551668182,
0.0191289503,
-0.0344301537,
0.016416803,
-0.0232775956,
0.0052274731,
0.0255027674,
-0.0155042224,
-0.0971067995,
-0.0062996652,
0.0043931408,
-0.0312533118,
0.0082868729,
-0.0316803567,
-0.0525199622,
-0.0250712149,
-0.0211494938,
0.02692548,
-0.05773196,
-0.0005366878,
0.0187249593,
0.01236773,
0.0007528754,
0.0222667735,
0.0071766884,
-0.0145774661,
0.0370868556,
0.0157492086,
0.0283218417,
-0.0196708161,
-0.0264329668,
-0.0287347939,
-0.0232787207,
-0.0162520539,
0.0153064961,
0.0455499142,
-0.028220186,
0.0004307354,
-0.1031401157,
0.0071605835,
-0.0494753644,
0.0103797344,
0.0230834708,
0.0208701789,
0.0157085806,
-0.0322310701,
-0.023393359,
-0.00700264,
-0.0065282094,
-0.0065118507,
0.0287394151,
-0.0044122543,
-0.021219857,
-0.0163225494,
0.0364337265,
0.0017463698,
0.0186459646,
-0.0181788746,
-0.003515891,
-0.0480382256,
0.0578523614,
0.0068734419,
-0.0006610153,
-0.0050697778,
-0.0430634543,
0.0320532322,
0.0154460529,
0.0097660935,
0.0436981097,
0.012847905,
0.0593965985,
-0.0207174104,
0.0137614505,
-0.068875365,
0.0284583289,
-0.0254714862,
0.0089670848,
-0.0253572706,
-0.0273702908,
0.0100528905,
0.0731526017,
0.0251886565,
0.0486276187,
-0.0853869841,
-0.0535667837,
0.0229644589,
-0.0556654446,
-0.0143807046,
0.0093493685,
-0.0156344958,
0.0022598745,
0.0111519396,
-0.0208896082,
0.070645377,
-0.0225599445,
-0.0611312091,
-0.0639527142,
-0.0313554183,
0.0053264946,
0.0700926483,
-0.0417721011,
0.0169841517,
0.0612745173,
-0.0332502052,
0.0039292127,
-0.0084363306,
-0.0162708517,
-0.0075097205,
0.0397462733,
0.0033701353,
-0.0020557879,
-0.0136112962,
-0.0474533886,
-0.062227793,
-0.0924451798,
-0.0312260259,
0.0190768354,
0.016804887,
0.0056687938,
-0.0025384482,
0.0309299733,
0.0111659886,
0.0427607074,
0.0176681913,
-0.0120587228,
-0.0448368937,
0.0237654168,
0.0364642367,
-0.0142029906,
-0.055711709,
0.004968273,
0.0594522841,
0.0261647347,
0.0138868643,
-0.0297836997,
-0.0177221708,
-0.0085539818,
0.0344963819,
0.0058430289,
-0.0039042768,
0.0327001996,
0.0785980299,
0.0014381332,
-0.0276496988,
0.1336553544,
0.035510648,
-0.051054243,
-0.0212969817,
-0.0045997612,
0.0100708641,
0.0121437814,
0.0008648919,
-0.0861855745,
-0.0981354266,
-0.0033535701,
0.0042438107,
-0.0007954414,
0.0069532557,
-0.0343403071,
-0.0928985327,
0.0049753799,
0.0003082265,
-0.0068217404,
-0.0316232555,
-0.0130952364,
0.0014008774,
-0.0408051945,
-0.0096849548,
-0.0283845142,
0.0336567909,
-0.014552339,
0.016064046,
-0.0004637669,
-0.0544740595,
0.0314582102,
-0.0187855083,
0.0783684328,
0.0434242673,
0.0334303565,
0.0233191177,
-0.0318306535,
-0.0323927067,
-0.0340012424,
-0.0147980182,
-0.0223700963,
0.0518538468,
-0.0616265237,
0.0331661291,
0.0163929462,
0.0213786457,
-0.0566690713,
-0.0401402339,
0.0124820909,
0.0588978902,
-0.0551304705,
0.0264250394,
0.0124648185,
0.0070609623,
0.0736334026,
0.0913586393,
0.0167967845,
-0.0420986004,
-0.0102083469,
-0.0385234356,
0.0065785302,
-0.059868969,
0.03503282,
-0.022006778,
0.011922746,
0.0074541387,
-0.0417496562,
-0.0876238048,
0.0411015935,
0.0237417743,
-0.0073844134,
-0.0207673982,
0.0161074493,
-0.0068518282,
-0.0162567012,
0.0035993953,
-0.009042914,
0.0294543225,
-0.0464459434,
-0.0395117067,
0.0679018721,
-0.0449849106,
0.0022222591,
-0.0068793544,
-0.0547041073,
-0.042872604,
-0.0524954125,
0.07033737,
0.0054442519,
0.0541624092,
-0.0489230454,
-0.008332192,
0.020009784,
0.0135305477,
-0.0173855796,
-0.0127071999,
0.0882719234,
0.0286481772,
-0.0035204436,
0.0285859015,
-0.031321831,
0.0299559571,
-0.0143561931,
0.0247836914,
-0.0801917091,
-0.0834241211,
0.0096700871,
-0.0164911952,
0.0761867687,
-0.0010937843,
-0.0335549042,
-0.0298811197,
0.0310095958,
-0.0174824111,
0.0169836394,
-0.0461688414,
-0.0059064715,
0.0065870844,
-0.0106751332,
-0.0168116614,
0.0406599566,
-0.0551730022,
-0.0048256968,
-0.01914379,
0.0053193173,
0.0319972597,
0.0070014177,
-0.0251030829,
0.0063045588,
-0.044413805,
0.0202078987,
0.0109942416,
0.0159488507,
0.0109305214,
0.1018575802,
0.0154695939,
0.0153166903,
0.0099279191,
0.0672643706,
-0.0240069889,
0.0065184212,
-0.0112643279,
-0.0276373774,
0.02734836,
0.0290393084,
0.028579656,
-0.0048301388,
0.0364057161,
-0.0044738343,
0.0825353712,
-0.0650298744,
-0.0580680817,
0.0322426558,
0.0012834668,
-0.0341768749,
0.0133148078,
0.0454141684,
-0.0910068229,
0.0233435296,
0.0010323364,
0.0259427056,
-0.053019207,
-0.0020327733,
0.0397419184,
0.0399623103,
-0.0088231228,
0.014184922,
-0.0182448905,
-0.0316403806,
0.02878551,
-0.0243292786,
-0.0134245884,
0.0023794454,
0.0608192012,
-0.0040374575,
-0.023357356,
-0.0130957905,
-0.0173126832,
-0.0211990029,
-0.0396227725,
-0.0139627531,
-0.0636368692,
-5.219090593e-33,
-0.018217111,
0.009340426,
0.0312302746,
-0.0158982668,
-0.0011251599,
0.0017204882,
-0.0301826634,
-0.0206718128,
-0.016733421,
0.0027113182,
0.0029341979,
0.0069293426,
0.0053683766,
0.0368412882,
0.0004164675,
-0.0367493853,
0.0599850565,
-0.0157678258,
-0.0069292323,
0.0370492972,
0.0343811922,
0.0026699691,
0.0319716111,
-0.0545967929,
0.0061171828,
0.0230351277,
-0.0298094284,
0.0307597462,
0.0543420613,
0.0580952354,
-0.0161344148,
0.0138092749,
0.0088931322,
-0.0450103097,
0.0013784781,
0.0450495519,
-0.0413641408,
-0.0204114355,
-0.0103067113,
0.0045238254,
-0.0432970002,
-0.0437584184,
-0.015832385,
-0.0033058876,
-0.0150656123,
0.0098814992,
0.0018740853,
0.0193875767,
0.0265663266,
-0.0125408256,
-0.0376531444,
0.0009301577,
-0.0278745089,
-0.0603388697,
0.023544807,
0.0803390741,
0.0455075726,
0.0007088454,
-0.072752513,
-0.0024877517,
-0.0512891524,
-0.0189695377,
0.0265299007,
0.0260783769,
-0.0030104856,
0.0670237914,
-0.0013304254,
-0.0159824584,
0.0191179626,
0.0254746098,
-0.0119074425,
0.0164084658,
0.016063951,
0.0460579395,
0.0314443335,
-0.0050235721,
-0.0292830393,
0.0421160385,
0.0250127856,
-0.019004019,
0.0170113146,
0.0387134999,
-0.0568900406,
0.0022364075,
-0.003654765,
-0.0330741182,
-0.0209690798,
-0.0425966457,
0.0332222208,
0.0171802584,
0.0177621245,
0.0377084315,
0.0868214965,
-0.0261973068,
0.0611197203,
0.0543820225,
-0.0146266771,
0.038693063,
-0.0064393035,
0.0151970731,
-0.0674263686,
-0.0282832719,
0.0801557675,
0.0042343396,
0.0168041829,
0.0336737968,
0.0403679237,
-0.0038562911,
-0.0276925042,
-0.0233492963,
0.0021452608,
0.030872792,
-0.0477913357,
0.0430634394,
0.0189827774,
0.0544746108,
-0.0378458761,
0.0929633901,
-0.002022614,
-0.0257603303,
-0.0474105626,
-0.0650446042,
0.0167964809,
-0.0072658909,
-0.0102853067,
0.0174139943,
0.0030082655,
-0.0233329255,
-0.0124397781,
-0.0338786803,
-0.0105756177,
0.0209825747,
2.476e-7,
0.0047430382,
0.0117608979,
0.0226905774,
0.0525628999,
0.0036894723,
0.0963289365,
0.0334904939,
0.0514945835,
0.0002992706,
-0.0119873928,
0.071613811,
0.0048399903,
0.0376426131,
-0.0118153431,
-0.0829499662,
0.0003649885,
-0.0006293839,
-0.0032725532,
-0.0325868838,
0.03378978,
0.1190353408,
0.0978528485,
0.0391018391,
0.0221133269,
0.0346948877,
-0.0022389153,
0.0414408669,
-0.0028267929,
0.0064717173,
0.0034949048,
-0.0076580788,
-0.025039142,
-0.002198766,
0.0434458852,
-0.0231100097,
0.0255954638,
-0.0308383498,
0.0547221303,
-0.0336929671,
-0.0790492743,
-0.0512819104,
0.0179287437,
-0.0004948985,
-0.0123387137,
0.074792549,
-0.0602643639,
-0.0300335102,
0.0243297759,
-0.0254557841,
0.0232631546,
0.0079319626,
0.0094042206,
-0.009502043,
-0.0069159777,
0.0330122933,
-0.0137399901,
-0.0074598179,
-0.0822533369,
0.0375613831,
0.0206818487,
-0.0219612774,
-0.0189000294,
-0.0016727627,
0.0023656676,
0.029252287,
-0.0646148548,
0.0093828663,
1.82229772e-34,
0.0146022271,
-0.0232562907,
0.0285119563,
0.0457784571,
0.0237453524,
0.0033218088,
-0.0429312028,
-0.0144886905,
0.0752882361,
-0.0743584633,
-0.0283935741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14825v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14825v2 | Large Language Models are In-Context Semantic Reasoners rather than Symbolic Reasoners | 2023-05-24T07:33:34 | 2023-06-08T16:38:51 | Xiaojuan Tang, Zilong Zheng, Jiaqi Li, Fanxu Meng, Song-Chun Zhu, Yitao Liang, Muhan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The emergent few-shot reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs)
have excited the natural language and machine learning community over recent
years. Despite of numerous successful applications, the underlying mechanism of
such in-context capabilities still remains unclear. In this work, we
hypothesize that the learned \textit{semantics} of language tokens do the most
heavy lifting during the reasoning process. Different from human's symbolic
reasoning process, the semantic representations of LLMs could create strong
connections among tokens, thus composing a superficial logical chain. To test
our hypothesis, we decouple semantics from the language reasoning process and
evaluate three kinds of reasoning abilities, i.e., deduction, induction and
abduction. Our findings reveal that semantics play a vital role in LLMs'
in-context reasoning -- LLMs perform significantly better when semantics are
consistent with commonsense but struggle to solve symbolic or
counter-commonsense reasoning tasks by leveraging in-context new knowledge. The
surprising observations question whether modern LLMs have mastered the
inductive, deductive and abductive reasoning abilities as in human
intelligence, and motivate research on unveiling the magic existing within the
black-box LLMs. On the whole, our analysis provides a novel perspective on the
role of semantics in developing and evaluating language models' reasoning
abilities. Code is available at {\url{https://github.com/XiaojuanTang/ICSR}}. | [
0.0415303707,
0.0342302024,
-0.0129105318,
0.0596832931,
-0.0611280464,
0.0347240753,
0.020475084,
-0.0020441983,
-0.0113568092,
-0.0666547641,
-0.0019724937,
0.0136851938,
0.0059556421,
-0.007381991,
0.0205891915,
-0.0096663702,
0.0344863795,
-0.0547215454,
0.012552687,
-0.0053304685,
-0.0205390938,
0.0356650613,
0.0149088353,
0.0325035751,
0.0026685114,
0.0014459401,
0.0137580708,
-0.0164897572,
-0.016308507,
-0.0270591173,
-0.0495193042,
0.0171533432,
0.0388207175,
0.0435395166,
0.0000019967,
-0.0894767717,
0.0160392225,
-0.0074380748,
-0.0481958091,
0.0054456042,
0.0284171775,
-0.0306569338,
-0.0080230199,
0.0012914934,
-0.015150073,
0.0041221594,
0.0172126368,
0.0423450656,
0.0292141456,
0.0500800051,
-0.0102067487,
-0.0432648063,
0.0251241811,
-0.0041539758,
0.0586011931,
-0.0431428552,
0.0125037711,
0.0273098927,
0.0022204614,
-0.018312512,
-0.0103484085,
0.017088471,
0.0443316996,
0.0065454138,
-0.0597881377,
0.0683195442,
-0.0670541972,
-0.041473411,
0.0049992544,
0.0375465602,
-0.0038929482,
-0.0445308313,
-0.0130717522,
0.0215148032,
0.0177322142,
0.0382274985,
-0.0492301919,
0.0696811154,
-0.0249690954,
0.0302515589,
0.0707798898,
-0.0163596217,
0.0639711618,
0.0418915637,
-0.0682995915,
0.1005368084,
-0.0013032849,
-0.0108230561,
0.0276043303,
-0.0202858113,
-0.0528585874,
-0.0585152581,
-0.0335354172,
0.0539455004,
-0.0195743237,
0.0532409139,
-0.0034449094,
0.031324055,
0.0183595642,
-0.0318680406,
-0.009726882,
0.0468954183,
-0.0028228164,
0.0885551125,
-0.0607166104,
0.0276889242,
-0.0284971353,
0.0687834546,
-0.0201737266,
-0.0437374301,
-0.0529984385,
-0.0393879563,
-0.0003467084,
0.0340041742,
0.0119460449,
-0.002122916,
0.0086141936,
0.0324949473,
-0.0048163463,
0.0348967016,
-0.0389615558,
-0.0083740344,
0.007157641,
-0.0457202531,
-0.0490967073,
0.0083743613,
-0.0252081677,
0.035406094,
0.0174479205,
-0.0493930504,
-0.0141201038,
-0.0139129888,
0.0041339705,
-0.0208627749,
0.0324419178,
0.0578708872,
0.0228983182,
-0.01840025,
-0.0525563881,
-0.0412286818,
0.0088309962,
-0.0791766644,
-0.0150401415,
-0.0670949295,
-0.005396157,
0.0636346117,
-0.0113266231,
-0.0449329019,
0.024581166,
0.0277162846,
-0.0514670238,
0.0839963704,
0.0075212531,
0.0195551254,
0.0354318693,
0.0101148123,
-0.0154710971,
0.0636048242,
0.0247384291,
0.0231592804,
0.0133819729,
0.0007275615,
0.0006080024,
0.0089756586,
0.0088420929,
-0.0010097547,
-0.068166703,
0.0054810448,
0.0042999126,
0.0054573743,
-0.0028201879,
0.0273826383,
-0.027075259,
-0.0078176325,
0.041903615,
0.0974341929,
-0.0259215664,
0.0040172264,
0.0375495069,
-0.0371566676,
-0.0080974279,
-0.0280901734,
-0.0949645564,
0.0233855098,
-0.0281828437,
-0.0135453967,
-0.0207463,
0.0155100785,
-0.0145016797,
-0.0260455888,
-0.041115839,
-0.0053129746,
0.0045803478,
0.0006244695,
0.0659945831,
0.0295662358,
-0.0172847379,
0.0589874201,
0.0423589908,
-0.0305304192,
-0.0224959571,
-0.0606036037,
0.0423636101,
0.0338140838,
0.0423968472,
-0.0055474201,
-0.02024181,
-0.0040821438,
0.0135521265,
0.0483661219,
0.0184796471,
0.0006098156,
-0.0124660293,
-0.0247176476,
-0.0034647167,
-0.034558177,
0.0173534062,
-0.0108552733,
-0.0145912096,
-0.0055468325,
0.0060237278,
-0.0474085137,
0.0028488573,
0.0333355963,
-0.0278880112,
0.0005734378,
-0.0419513769,
0.0262798294,
0.0155826183,
-0.020425614,
0.0153824277,
0.0230004676,
0.0141354501,
-0.0538872294,
-0.0300109256,
0.0491698124,
-0.0270644985,
-0.0419769995,
0.0471130237,
-0.0120904362,
-0.0288063847,
-0.0069947965,
-0.0263408218,
-0.0126212621,
0.0361089222,
-0.0290053468,
0.0689584464,
-0.0353502035,
0.0022387342,
-0.0287315417,
-0.0058198776,
-0.0210589767,
0.1204513013,
-0.0176545046,
-0.0185048077,
0.0034742951,
0.0322027057,
0.0053562508,
0.0106044272,
0.0308989771,
0.0223358851,
-0.0092473682,
-0.024572812,
0.0154366735,
-0.0177382752,
-0.0424567722,
-0.013247869,
-0.078711085,
0.0084765283,
-0.0060390411,
0.0042992192,
0.0252397936,
-0.0116529781,
0.0107096722,
0.016403053,
-0.0007924212,
-0.0150368614,
0.011660127,
0.0363607369,
0.032154765,
-0.015792625,
-0.0345648453,
-0.0012569018,
0.0008878069,
-0.0483409129,
0.0708411038,
0.0115680527,
0.0371007025,
-0.0248039626,
0.018597642,
-0.0468490198,
-0.0105684409,
-0.0173684116,
-0.0149719156,
0.0231230445,
-0.0177838821,
-0.0197981577,
0.0919504166,
-0.0182918441,
0.0512710921,
0.0479023829,
0.0014399658,
-0.0509758219,
0.0082372613,
-0.015778115,
0.0030273991,
-0.0419198982,
-0.0035961471,
-0.0342221521,
0.0525490046,
-0.0139007922,
0.0145012373,
-0.0463133827,
0.0680268928,
-0.0086460644,
0.0052331034,
-0.0493049808,
-0.0257394258,
0.0066643013,
0.0852642953,
-0.0398632661,
-0.0335597061,
0.0554546975,
-0.0053897235,
-0.0094824145,
-0.0192020573,
-0.0193724167,
-0.0497851036,
0.0964073688,
-0.0167324524,
0.0064798407,
-0.0268537551,
-0.0025005979,
-0.040508166,
-0.0224528238,
0.0097841593,
-0.0221151076,
0.033722803,
-0.023370102,
0.0058916714,
-0.0133158723,
-0.0360902101,
-0.0386667885,
-0.0397370607,
-0.0920331776,
0.0151711144,
-0.052858226,
0.0033130066,
-0.0220161341,
0.0005527868,
0.028237015,
0.0107882284,
0.0178375449,
-0.0250387602,
-0.0188453924,
-0.0067660846,
0.0193304028,
0.0044283159,
0.0211544018,
0.0023397824,
0.0541754067,
0.0419650823,
0.0286199041,
0.0070445789,
-0.020291483,
0.0290780514,
0.0040571163,
-0.0058407658,
-0.0397325158,
0.0053110188,
0.0214423668,
-0.0744845867,
-0.0211130381,
0.1312516481,
0.0355386883,
-0.0009241771,
0.0177739728,
-0.0352797173,
0.0181460436,
0.0536001213,
0.0064011272,
-0.0810624585,
-0.0675089657,
0.0338532366,
-0.031870082,
-0.0136305345,
-0.0403081886,
-0.0196404979,
-0.123037979,
0.030239651,
-0.0083909463,
-0.0817872062,
0.0040270626,
-0.0581453778,
0.0075557744,
-0.008239246,
0.0121471733,
0.0219721701,
0.0079995859,
-0.0088328244,
0.0063502542,
0.0119891986,
-0.0340765789,
0.049239058,
-0.0294434447,
0.0198987499,
0.0535884425,
0.0280898344,
-0.0080652218,
-0.0442453511,
0.064968504,
-0.0083580287,
0.0168817099,
-0.0165304393,
0.0101826042,
-0.0040249834,
-0.0090471013,
-0.0085980128,
0.0611390546,
-0.0702475011,
-0.0555952527,
-0.003308492,
0.1077562496,
-0.0220177155,
-0.0213204119,
-0.0010116779,
-0.008440108,
-0.0541987829,
0.0943207219,
0.0159944668,
-0.0169538986,
-0.0466142818,
-0.0441990867,
-0.0470319986,
0.0057690484,
-0.0587129928,
0.0142131876,
0.0252537653,
-0.03431632,
-0.0469960086,
-0.0207521673,
0.0491765067,
-0.0029123097,
-0.0060891956,
0.0286948998,
-0.0118753687,
-0.0045194095,
-0.0416196957,
0.0464633703,
-0.0378771164,
0.0050145052,
-0.0084138718,
0.026180828,
0.0175048094,
-0.0453164726,
-0.0284733474,
0.0074889278,
-0.0386302173,
-0.0609433204,
-0.0026627181,
0.0013335482,
0.0277116746,
0.0211590026,
-0.0240810048,
-0.0407675095,
0.0499274842,
0.0540716462,
-0.0129891848,
-0.0037513645,
0.0241370909,
0.0186496768,
0.0266580004,
0.0666633844,
-0.0296571665,
0.0134470472,
0.0399823226,
0.0225275531,
-0.0174412038,
0.0472299792,
0.0428907089,
0.0108851492,
0.0370133333,
-0.0111617632,
-0.000561048,
0.0004586397,
0.0160135012,
-0.0251377337,
-0.0474069305,
-0.0220048595,
0.0040227659,
0.0125656296,
0.0035133217,
-0.0008908274,
-0.0293934979,
0.0079339277,
0.0543280467,
0.0047126794,
-0.0119498773,
0.0312228687,
0.0329570882,
0.0195168499,
-0.008015397,
-0.0027370232,
0.0036512557,
-0.0350040719,
0.0292742327,
-0.0401629694,
0.060403455,
0.0542600416,
-0.0157689415,
-0.0426415764,
-0.0157652386,
-0.0720259547,
-0.0656257793,
0.0559275188,
0.0228070393,
0.0391271338,
-0.03226991,
0.0072316499,
-0.0392734893,
-0.010499334,
0.0093283448,
0.0140096536,
0.0359948091,
-0.0429204889,
0.0335014947,
0.0281398296,
-0.0281470213,
0.0262148846,
0.0462448224,
-0.054270599,
0.0689503551,
0.0156015735,
-0.0188163072,
-0.0076654935,
-0.024367379,
0.0030321551,
0.0283205677,
0.0047750208,
0.0367077366,
-0.0899547711,
-0.0736214891,
-0.0274747275,
0.0112162866,
-0.0044597681,
-0.0013318843,
-0.0107227862,
0.0707890689,
0.0025835435,
-0.0527012236,
-0.0156878605,
0.0144648803,
-0.0367166027,
0.0029663257,
-0.0046267603,
-6.254307325e-33,
-0.0183558762,
-0.0257073157,
0.008410438,
0.0210953895,
0.0223564971,
-0.0318435729,
-0.0528905354,
-0.0011281274,
-0.0216917638,
0.0424853824,
-0.0108834486,
0.0147607028,
-0.0037754218,
0.0061711022,
0.0076640556,
-0.0223760065,
0.0048655546,
0.0290229265,
-0.0431605764,
-0.0080768829,
0.0652990788,
-0.0101050837,
0.024693083,
-0.0429285616,
0.0090224547,
-0.0076228995,
0.0176448543,
0.0509295687,
-0.0682644099,
0.0435479432,
-0.0017775045,
0.0173497833,
0.0398734808,
-0.0463340282,
0.0170809198,
0.0383228399,
-0.0631771833,
-0.0200599004,
0.0706051067,
-0.0147089893,
-0.0130805308,
-0.0584364124,
0.0449350215,
0.0034175159,
-0.0208760221,
-0.0131744128,
0.0224388074,
-0.0278005302,
-0.0022248079,
0.0053517511,
-0.0735493153,
0.0127926329,
-0.0226963442,
-0.0192976389,
0.0049742186,
-0.0204718523,
-0.0332782455,
0.0280455295,
-0.0252405088,
0.0141447568,
-0.0211924519,
-0.0173964687,
0.0796784237,
0.0087964116,
0.0012138325,
0.0729300529,
0.0189460982,
0.0070691584,
-0.0318108313,
0.0120037058,
0.0226642881,
0.0776742101,
0.0252234917,
0.0067408145,
0.0294172075,
0.0247017238,
-0.0828296915,
-0.0195806138,
-0.0122585231,
0.0609319061,
0.0728915632,
0.0103844684,
-0.0244770423,
-0.012726129,
-0.0693890452,
0.0093387822,
-0.0451451614,
-0.002752475,
0.0167713165,
-0.0149409454,
-0.0282263234,
-0.0024691196,
0.0191375371,
-0.0526095331,
-0.0051891226,
0.0417550355,
-0.0115948925,
-0.0185120944,
-0.0046913829,
0.0139098745,
-0.030492764,
-0.0236793198,
-0.0009907511,
0.0019920596,
0.0294360127,
0.0252768211,
0.0542751513,
0.0035017161,
-0.0187671147,
-0.0173270889,
-0.075260736,
-0.0128963487,
-0.0232574493,
-0.0186011493,
0.0474987775,
0.0361453369,
-0.0069954298,
0.0045905649,
0.0322234146,
-0.007198656,
-0.0353993438,
0.0423296578,
-0.0275376979,
-0.0218337271,
-0.0358909331,
-0.031728141,
-0.0367450677,
-0.0149533274,
0.0388469882,
-0.0311284307,
-0.0158280302,
0.0073622623,
2.715e-7,
0.0249367654,
0.0866443887,
-0.0156016126,
0.0114458334,
0.0381099842,
0.0518904552,
-0.0248337071,
-0.0189090259,
0.0314188674,
-0.0414086059,
-0.0137273688,
0.0597453229,
0.0381187834,
0.0280495472,
-0.0341834724,
0.0367470011,
-0.044813592,
-0.031726148,
-0.0597969443,
0.03672662,
0.042955149,
0.0946257487,
0.0509439968,
-0.035769064,
0.0065721185,
-0.0818675682,
0.041625414,
-0.0495612584,
0.0137716467,
-0.0123391999,
-0.0140113086,
0.0468357801,
0.0256927367,
0.0444819294,
0.0291619655,
0.0288604032,
-0.0096063558,
0.0475719944,
-0.020407239,
-0.0050584353,
-0.0457903892,
-0.0297939014,
0.0055799605,
-0.082402952,
0.1176279485,
-0.0749467313,
-0.0494507663,
-0.0289183818,
0.0206709113,
-0.0155728227,
-0.0006517489,
0.0235783979,
-0.0057357983,
0.0027448945,
0.0182394907,
-0.0088251093,
-0.0154724577,
-0.0880645737,
-0.0325564519,
0.0230457857,
-0.0177933704,
-0.0338683091,
-0.0158813894,
0.0175545625,
0.0458557829,
-0.0692814887,
-0.0142904911,
2.578062068e-34,
-0.0034249511,
0.002110481,
0.0112830382,
0.0470299721,
0.0566754602,
0.0132433046,
-0.0208950918,
0.0371809825,
0.0329652019,
-0.0775374025,
0.0228880551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14824v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14824v3 | Mitigating Temporal Misalignment by Discarding Outdated Facts | 2023-05-24T07:30:08 | 2024-03-05T16:32:58 | Michael J. Q. Zhang, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models are able to retain vast amounts of world
knowledge seen during pretraining, such knowledge is prone to going out of date
and is nontrivial to update. Furthermore, these models are often used under
temporal misalignment, tasked with answering questions about the present,
despite having only been trained on data collected in the past. To mitigate the
effects of temporal misalignment, we propose fact duration prediction: the task
of predicting how long a given fact will remain true. In our experiments, we
demonstrate that identifying which facts are prone to rapid change can help
models avoid reciting outdated information and determine which predictions
require seeking out up-to-date knowledge sources. We also show how modeling
fact duration improves calibration for knowledge-intensive tasks, such as
open-retrieval question answering, under temporal misalignment, by discarding
volatile facts. Our data and code are released publicly at
https://github.com/mikejqzhang/mitigating_misalignment. | [
0.0332690775,
0.0504346415,
-0.0017500427,
0.0019108334,
-0.0290896297,
-0.0089051537,
-0.0124559375,
0.0174924321,
-0.0210027136,
-0.0246305466,
0.0213996675,
-0.0699863136,
0.0249164887,
0.0073472722,
-0.0140848858,
-0.0303568877,
0.0912098885,
-0.0256991517,
0.0343412533,
-0.0152526209,
0.0199769232,
-0.0281452555,
-0.0295370296,
-0.00507385,
-0.0237782598,
-0.0621783845,
-0.0324310511,
-0.0546405837,
0.0205506403,
0.0075272019,
0.0420846567,
0.07349848,
0.0089115528,
0.0113882767,
0.0000016656,
-0.0533079691,
0.0179231614,
-0.0093942033,
-0.0785190091,
0.037131235,
-0.0215329695,
0.0100005856,
0.0227985829,
0.0247073006,
-0.0565320179,
-0.0232534688,
0.0000200331,
0.0331376083,
0.0263659731,
0.0670240968,
0.0362794586,
0.046479322,
0.015135536,
-0.0318996087,
0.0168333128,
-0.0417931229,
0.0072509302,
-0.0128260003,
-0.0311835743,
0.0311729386,
-0.0477567762,
0.0344613828,
0.0122042298,
0.0056442865,
0.0416557416,
0.0575506613,
-0.0265996326,
0.0277242381,
-0.0266063958,
0.0296041351,
0.0446947142,
-0.0397365168,
-0.0275310483,
0.0105095692,
0.0191280898,
-0.0002990112,
-0.0299942605,
-0.0203592516,
-0.0084762042,
-0.0092970431,
0.0198213365,
0.0069747358,
0.0151561769,
0.0287032221,
0.0428936966,
0.0675697103,
-0.0037251643,
-0.060829103,
-0.0339030027,
-0.0028520988,
0.0163306128,
-0.0759442523,
-0.0352698602,
0.056854248,
-0.016526483,
0.016231101,
-0.0211640242,
-0.0013244398,
0.0190984067,
-0.0661352128,
-0.0654377192,
0.0241528116,
-0.0523015298,
0.0603972152,
-0.011718004,
0.0472108573,
0.0081845308,
-0.0309224334,
-0.0301242806,
0.0083333803,
-0.0478756316,
-0.0049831695,
-0.0070769391,
0.0060629961,
-0.0172228441,
0.0092440089,
-0.0053753825,
0.0161839873,
0.0087744948,
0.0071865846,
-0.0163974781,
0.0513000861,
-0.0225766152,
-0.0149622448,
-0.0923049003,
0.0749888942,
-0.0265693571,
-0.0134493578,
-0.0187134109,
-0.0542275384,
-0.060122624,
0.0093821976,
-0.015137163,
-0.0412573181,
-0.0190060902,
0.0279892497,
-0.0341250114,
0.0061052237,
-0.0611718856,
-0.0350334086,
-0.0482295901,
-0.0773517862,
0.0076511013,
-0.031982597,
0.0281750802,
-0.001051491,
-0.0203407034,
-0.0222619213,
-0.0108824624,
0.0094749974,
-0.0200456269,
0.0374955274,
-0.0032964977,
0.0248065572,
0.0367185809,
-0.0070874467,
0.0449120849,
0.0674698576,
-0.0105830031,
-0.0403480567,
0.0482518636,
0.0126399249,
-0.0137085654,
0.0242480915,
0.0447472446,
0.0014693366,
0.0315303877,
0.061495889,
0.0640992224,
0.0414399803,
0.031077208,
0.0062610167,
0.0127389207,
-0.0588206761,
0.0571686327,
-0.0398439206,
-0.0012347279,
0.0120047182,
0.0215904955,
-0.0381648839,
0.0278335493,
0.0282402579,
-0.0532162152,
0.0355146006,
-0.0251617897,
0.0150193302,
-0.0240223501,
0.0499196276,
-0.0425163545,
-0.0363050178,
-0.0161259882,
-0.0007464581,
-0.0270281322,
0.0124311438,
0.0014683967,
0.0058284872,
-0.0189788807,
0.1274909228,
0.0069309711,
0.0022365542,
0.0269324593,
0.015135183,
0.0469078906,
0.0800090432,
0.0370311588,
-0.0443477295,
-0.0729333237,
-0.0268207695,
0.0763514042,
-0.0001037712,
0.1061308905,
-0.0230021439,
0.0344471335,
-0.0270863753,
-0.0151455877,
0.0045024571,
0.0164987165,
-0.043660108,
0.0804087296,
0.0648159981,
0.0125701707,
-0.0435998105,
0.0116977859,
0.0369527228,
-0.0282947328,
-0.0339054614,
-0.0302186087,
0.0118726753,
0.0093474025,
-0.0175671205,
0.0028303314,
-0.0072103105,
0.0282067172,
0.0041962247,
-0.0011918562,
0.0447676294,
-0.0541126505,
-0.023882743,
0.0775798559,
0.0502117388,
-0.0241532512,
-0.001769879,
-0.036882326,
-0.0338566042,
-0.006114569,
-0.0087911766,
0.0498691127,
0.0024528936,
0.0125285359,
-0.0132212806,
0.0190782752,
-0.0227177981,
0.0549687892,
-0.0410537496,
0.0137847625,
-0.0043701469,
-0.0398046635,
0.0250670239,
-0.0336574055,
-0.0075288233,
0.0219334755,
0.006597783,
-0.0193328522,
0.0426331945,
-0.0258868542,
-0.0668767989,
0.0233158097,
-0.0812981278,
-0.0023516912,
-0.0295703262,
0.0307815857,
0.0312837549,
-0.0094549526,
-0.0114785992,
-0.0306676906,
-0.0458044186,
-0.0004531743,
-0.0250383709,
0.0124346241,
0.0502155237,
0.0298189782,
0.0110745979,
-0.0373020172,
-0.0027093571,
-0.0381212123,
0.05283935,
-0.0154042421,
0.0003709746,
-0.0429864787,
-0.0032272306,
-0.1022742838,
0.0575253852,
-0.0243629795,
-0.0013127431,
-0.0162253007,
0.0204662606,
0.0689534098,
0.0528250411,
0.0417556688,
-0.0328514054,
0.056820605,
-0.0183451343,
-0.041351594,
0.0529848784,
-0.0439949259,
-0.0163871087,
-0.0330724977,
-0.0002442148,
-0.0176844075,
0.0117838914,
-0.0081976792,
-0.0343150012,
-0.0439558923,
-0.0069162603,
-0.0292164087,
-0.0341868885,
-0.0199353378,
0.0246384703,
-0.0296615716,
-0.0077103963,
-0.0473556221,
-0.0401427411,
0.0922642127,
0.0091767646,
0.0061798841,
-0.0195950568,
0.0028785067,
-0.0293753613,
0.0532539897,
-0.0253740009,
-0.0110892318,
0.0278242882,
0.0181746576,
-0.0813420191,
-0.033043772,
0.0182214398,
-0.043602407,
0.0586876534,
-0.0348187797,
-0.0018827826,
0.0085267192,
-0.0339188464,
-0.0528648607,
-0.0760610774,
-0.0201231781,
-0.0312282462,
-0.0727128386,
-0.0094853723,
-0.0149608618,
-0.0399080403,
0.0311402138,
0.022749817,
-0.0423808619,
-0.0040760385,
0.0084243454,
0.0223408565,
0.073565647,
0.0615563095,
-0.0035161038,
-0.0052803117,
0.0073812809,
0.047330495,
0.0376551971,
-0.0153364772,
-0.0380467549,
-0.0388986953,
-0.0176148973,
-0.0212142467,
-0.0197651908,
0.0342099071,
0.0381566845,
-0.0430614389,
-0.0195564013,
0.0988035277,
0.0414202772,
0.01016552,
0.0071026278,
-0.0225911625,
0.0331005082,
0.0165773463,
0.014164662,
-0.0678025633,
-0.0156970806,
0.0075852657,
0.0138627505,
0.0151760625,
-0.0317371786,
-0.0240962394,
-0.0885253474,
-0.0303100031,
-0.0012221227,
0.0048714103,
-0.0083313053,
-0.0102518769,
-0.0117148906,
-0.0221193843,
0.0126792314,
0.0420949906,
-0.0045655076,
0.0176141933,
0.0504152514,
-0.0573192015,
-0.007661141,
0.0770391151,
0.0257726666,
0.060590703,
0.0154379169,
0.02127284,
0.0068320506,
-0.0414556526,
0.0167863537,
-0.0018002512,
0.0001532609,
-0.0031484885,
0.0719553754,
0.0021967415,
-0.0129358023,
0.0041742031,
-0.0029138033,
0.0107261557,
-0.0139941499,
0.0182285756,
0.0923592225,
-0.0082008634,
-0.0093766088,
-0.0136212008,
-0.0090943342,
0.0170864146,
0.0567284003,
-0.0059704646,
-0.0014143215,
-0.0272075217,
-0.000904364,
0.0227875039,
-0.0269592442,
0.0008727331,
-0.0105934907,
0.0030679018,
0.0064669149,
-0.0838482305,
-0.0287148934,
-0.023885021,
0.0024375839,
-0.0010475508,
0.0034360401,
0.0040674927,
0.0073444871,
-0.0522050224,
0.0268507879,
-0.0514406115,
0.0238754712,
-0.0119179543,
0.0016469045,
0.0221786797,
0.0115938699,
-0.0084913187,
0.0237139668,
-0.1054438353,
-0.0425918773,
0.0329952352,
0.0303664152,
0.0188755188,
0.0673039854,
-0.0220315848,
0.0019847236,
0.0452594049,
0.020822376,
-0.0178715549,
0.0495448932,
0.0298155304,
-0.0029973642,
0.0105506564,
0.027166117,
-0.0443233214,
-0.0429113582,
0.025672324,
-0.0012366804,
-0.0389698632,
-0.0360773876,
0.0210539903,
-0.0194032732,
0.0398920625,
0.0294088405,
-0.028913321,
0.0030252866,
0.0066479244,
0.0310669374,
0.0000165924,
0.0154600805,
0.0208870322,
0.0174080394,
0.0034545667,
0.0231223702,
0.0334796719,
0.0074448194,
0.0056204661,
-0.0063327127,
-0.0595546998,
0.0271064732,
-0.0175138768,
0.0217066891,
0.0253019929,
-0.0350820273,
0.0244659018,
-0.021026127,
0.0140888374,
0.0120057883,
0.0190101117,
0.0278290715,
0.000425736,
-0.0366688706,
-0.0368834659,
-0.0928320587,
-0.0056835911,
-0.0143857608,
0.0115272617,
0.0519123115,
-0.0320177712,
0.0348221436,
0.0096248826,
0.0151144043,
-0.0397940502,
0.0000283646,
0.0048888549,
0.0049427939,
0.0021313902,
0.022950422,
-0.0086295186,
0.0368148759,
0.1017420515,
-0.002551927,
0.0992687121,
0.0104106329,
-0.0142304981,
-0.0086625647,
-0.0335284956,
-0.0633412227,
-0.0171486493,
-0.0195804499,
0.0165184606,
-0.0686972365,
-0.0689777732,
0.0574187785,
0.0285028294,
0.0063592331,
-0.0100840004,
0.0334196165,
0.0692419112,
0.0033590244,
-0.0656069219,
-0.0288644731,
0.0328857489,
0.0287673716,
0.0159265902,
-0.0695309043,
-6.131103395e-33,
-0.0153074292,
0.0097241094,
0.0221338086,
-0.0091897473,
-0.0563322529,
0.0470801406,
-0.0156876147,
0.0022125484,
-0.0606162399,
-0.0053295647,
-0.022476662,
0.0450439751,
0.0032455395,
-0.0189970173,
0.0245532431,
-0.0670581236,
0.0431630798,
-0.0150062935,
-0.0427254848,
-0.0164541453,
0.0702964365,
0.0407673493,
0.0749343783,
-0.0438996702,
0.0578352809,
0.0189144965,
-0.0029307825,
0.0482203364,
-0.0434788577,
0.0506231226,
-0.0042213043,
0.0580109693,
0.0151279895,
-0.0477956198,
-0.0439157076,
-0.0201671403,
-0.104565233,
-0.0482340157,
0.0503408462,
0.0307312887,
0.0114210574,
-0.0111781564,
0.0265348591,
-0.0067418576,
-0.0094564538,
-0.0264136773,
0.0317722298,
-0.0465502478,
-0.0196296163,
-0.0049397796,
-0.0221955348,
-0.0023887011,
-0.011469461,
-0.0360855982,
-0.0252604466,
0.0183678512,
0.0522628687,
-0.037698064,
-0.0867970958,
0.0035432503,
0.0222189557,
0.0603646562,
0.0310431458,
-0.0134319225,
0.0049078204,
0.0581260063,
-0.01600408,
-0.0017234132,
-0.02420629,
0.0193597488,
0.0210465398,
-0.036345467,
0.0241567772,
0.0296771117,
0.038735278,
-0.0473798551,
-0.0397493504,
-0.0047397069,
0.0191141143,
0.0612839274,
-0.0213308148,
0.0033647276,
-0.0053233653,
-0.0210958719,
-0.0303678047,
0.0756994933,
-0.0129199037,
-0.0006802915,
0.0101809502,
0.0469347872,
0.0157557838,
0.0010006912,
0.0251659099,
-0.0157041419,
0.0140591934,
0.0625288188,
-0.0083801849,
0.0026242957,
0.0255790036,
0.0439472385,
-0.061559096,
0.0278147403,
0.0122291474,
-0.0013869317,
-0.0127909994,
0.0002402682,
0.0387960933,
0.0358056761,
-0.0424822979,
-0.0049572755,
-0.0265238546,
0.0120474473,
0.018592136,
-0.0385555178,
0.0236547142,
0.0070710774,
-0.0302104615,
0.0290437825,
0.0333290584,
0.0254360922,
-0.0296335518,
-0.0133890016,
0.0314282179,
0.0171711855,
-0.0100152623,
-0.0229492579,
-0.0113440435,
0.0051918891,
-0.0424315743,
-0.0341936424,
0.001890035,
0.0139357261,
2.416e-7,
0.0435988195,
0.0210718382,
0.0345792472,
0.0279786717,
0.0366919935,
0.0129531492,
-0.0052135051,
0.017584566,
-0.0123023288,
-0.0267650932,
0.0007611616,
0.0487490222,
0.0168671738,
0.0263802446,
-0.0637294427,
-0.0498751141,
-0.0911175013,
-0.0135210669,
-0.0389384069,
-0.0355261564,
0.0182607826,
0.0805900544,
0.068448171,
0.0135133574,
-0.0153077412,
-0.061657194,
0.0569557324,
0.0056061745,
-0.0402846187,
0.009189751,
0.0842316523,
0.0222377591,
0.0069825044,
0.0038752446,
-0.014691175,
-0.0024155695,
-0.0265783593,
0.0219548624,
0.0092895953,
-0.0343877859,
-0.0591305979,
0.0020888969,
-0.0332724415,
-0.003710815,
0.0937748328,
-0.0132662822,
0.0273265056,
-0.0629052967,
0.0006363824,
0.0507204682,
0.0377842002,
0.0380057395,
-0.0160411354,
0.0028739627,
0.0004820838,
0.0363103822,
-0.0091088321,
-0.0842319578,
-0.0759532526,
0.0435013659,
-0.0315592773,
-0.0669262335,
-0.0186417643,
-0.0298733078,
0.0056848349,
-0.0646583959,
0.0329870656,
1.774124492e-34,
0.0351647101,
0.008628617,
0.0071184356,
0.028073933,
0.0073404284,
-0.0566092916,
0.0114350403,
-0.0736535788,
0.0360212773,
-0.0299384128,
-0.0348386988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18330v1 | #REVAL: a semantic evaluation framework for hashtag recommendation | 2023-05-24T07:10:56 | 2023-05-24T07:10:56 | Areej Alsini, Du Q. Huynh, Amitava Datta | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Automatic evaluation of hashtag recommendation models is a fundamental task
in many online social network systems. In the traditional evaluation method,
the recommended hashtags from an algorithm are firstly compared with the ground
truth hashtags for exact correspondences. The number of exact matches is then
used to calculate the hit rate, hit ratio, precision, recall, or F1-score. This
way of evaluating hashtag similarities is inadequate as it ignores the semantic
correlation between the recommended and ground truth hashtags. To tackle this
problem, we propose a novel semantic evaluation framework for hashtag
recommendation, called #REval. This framework includes an internal module
referred to as BERTag, which automatically learns the hashtag embeddings. We
investigate on how the #REval framework performs under different word embedding
methods and different numbers of synonyms and hashtags in the recommendation
using our proposed #REval-hit-ratio measure. Our experiments of the proposed
framework on three large datasets show that #REval gave more meaningful hashtag
synonyms for hashtag recommendation evaluation. Our analysis also highlights
the sensitivity of the framework to the word embedding technique, with #REval
based on BERTag more superior over #REval based on FastText and Word2Vec. | [
0.072251305,
0.012095103,
0.0118105421,
-0.0094906455,
-0.0175142847,
0.0156455077,
-0.0330783054,
0.0308773443,
0.0349633284,
-0.0128647257,
0.0122231571,
-0.0238602441,
-0.0090458188,
0.0396778621,
-0.0306190234,
0.0155435326,
0.0143683106,
0.0423041172,
-0.0020802503,
-0.0093761068,
0.0392091572,
0.0081899874,
0.0190517306,
0.0268966798,
-0.0502002984,
0.0368160531,
0.043736998,
0.0203387644,
-0.0052308515,
-0.0199368745,
0.0116450284,
0.0209209342,
-0.0119483219,
0.0500720441,
0.0000017689,
-0.0245133154,
-0.0233331863,
-0.0344522744,
0.0637062714,
-0.0002884633,
0.0682671443,
0.0072926888,
0.0184641369,
0.0291417055,
-0.0519267917,
0.0298633669,
0.0664057955,
0.0409649834,
0.0287710894,
0.0287037455,
-0.0197105166,
-0.0251372214,
0.0060952157,
-0.0387710482,
0.0403046533,
-0.0379748605,
0.0247114953,
0.0179717913,
-0.0127335247,
0.0219590832,
-0.0125792753,
0.0427006856,
-0.0130442232,
-0.0123622781,
0.0929704756,
0.0236631725,
-0.0376374014,
-0.0225768704,
0.0186858475,
0.0934414491,
-0.0239410289,
-0.0506899431,
0.0132863726,
0.0146195842,
-0.0194594879,
0.0171171166,
-0.028054079,
-0.0675852299,
0.0338763371,
0.0573034249,
-0.0106341653,
0.0238194298,
0.0434628092,
0.0068095233,
0.0229862276,
0.0250936169,
0.0322874002,
-0.0218884144,
0.0029045525,
0.0157933887,
-0.019627979,
-0.0334349051,
0.0058177048,
-0.0132844234,
-0.0492005199,
0.0287895594,
-0.0709102377,
-0.0272954386,
0.0273411702,
-0.0969136134,
0.0045497585,
-0.0004757612,
0.0495374836,
0.0620118752,
-0.0488789119,
-0.0346828885,
-0.0104971007,
0.0103703653,
-0.0475400202,
-0.0722931251,
-0.0696610957,
0.0336507522,
-0.0007288375,
0.0342165194,
-0.0114830509,
-0.0548808239,
-0.0704951212,
0.0288621634,
-0.0102696372,
0.0163476728,
-0.0468539223,
0.0337545499,
0.0449741147,
0.0344417877,
-0.0292051546,
-0.0469091311,
-0.0700277388,
-0.0223896988,
-0.0059869429,
-0.0000182635,
0.031732168,
-0.0090456624,
0.0433196463,
-0.0005627621,
0.0277550668,
0.0252807271,
0.0158589743,
-0.039141871,
0.0000273681,
-0.0286936667,
0.0332725272,
-0.0090597607,
-0.0018967666,
-0.0971863568,
0.0382648148,
0.0362403877,
-0.0047926377,
0.0249730013,
0.021597622,
0.0260490961,
-0.0741022676,
0.0657669157,
-0.0128483344,
0.006240664,
0.0066442285,
0.0225532744,
0.0202575009,
0.0332943425,
-0.0119344899,
0.0824240521,
0.0710585117,
0.0109776733,
-0.0281428974,
-0.0023446907,
0.0159197487,
0.0551583841,
-0.0410126001,
0.0115662338,
0.0392372906,
0.0260745138,
-0.0228287205,
0.0481844507,
-0.0209139846,
-0.0255165864,
0.0415354036,
0.020606555,
0.0597343147,
0.0201998092,
0.0071705766,
0.0309920292,
-0.0441623218,
-0.0464590676,
-0.0222922247,
0.0245494284,
-0.0395900868,
-0.0337423533,
0.0852436498,
0.0059268838,
-0.0375418365,
-0.0018195761,
0.0129616363,
-0.0264217779,
0.0376034826,
-0.0358316265,
0.0075035146,
-0.0129780872,
-0.0395771004,
0.0269793775,
0.0360633396,
-0.0162021685,
-0.0144483447,
-0.0045868135,
0.0181451887,
0.0868355706,
0.0754521117,
0.0198348667,
0.00549349,
-0.0038006241,
0.0230652373,
0.0154350763,
0.0207243431,
-0.0029623243,
-0.0363722518,
-0.0590803847,
-0.0246629138,
0.0299624801,
-0.0206118654,
0.0025892863,
0.0316588432,
0.0556700975,
-0.0060858098,
-0.0238033552,
-0.0331924818,
-0.0004260947,
-0.0113949841,
0.0246581007,
0.0279045571,
0.0036824276,
-0.0065569463,
0.0265181158,
-0.0003123327,
0.0271046218,
0.0023555567,
-0.0348179005,
-0.0778474063,
-0.0344882421,
0.0038688111,
0.0350504741,
0.0519688241,
-0.064367637,
0.0112551413,
0.0767600387,
-0.0268645864,
-0.0292046033,
0.0521647334,
-0.0338529944,
0.0732877776,
-0.0369206667,
-0.0135011263,
-0.0703388825,
0.0443185754,
0.0089915907,
0.0361561291,
-0.0198572148,
0.0382376276,
-0.0257043466,
0.0208647121,
0.0271803644,
0.069355011,
-0.0826820135,
0.0022775016,
0.0062047113,
0.0113166934,
0.0191543065,
-0.0032869477,
-0.0373511463,
-0.0289694108,
-0.0707225055,
0.0185592789,
0.0073751118,
-0.0074113845,
0.0173022281,
0.0147579797,
0.0189906098,
-0.0275357962,
-0.0249703061,
0.0535322502,
-0.0091990605,
0.0399961583,
0.0064854901,
-0.0242394991,
-0.047042191,
-0.0333403312,
-0.0325585343,
-0.005016434,
0.0473358072,
0.0250910278,
-0.0064134998,
0.0256742276,
-0.0436443128,
-0.0725820065,
-0.0117727658,
0.0117677646,
-0.020465767,
-0.001702195,
0.0112600066,
0.0184615497,
-0.0415280126,
0.0413945168,
-0.0013356863,
0.0038214719,
0.0232012048,
-0.0474050492,
-0.0477355011,
-0.0386203155,
-0.0175887384,
0.0080464128,
-0.0231418051,
-0.0091635268,
-0.0098339096,
-0.0024562881,
0.0064847982,
-0.0508514717,
0.0011651618,
-0.0011112065,
0.0130939614,
-0.0540212058,
0.0207822155,
-0.0082775764,
0.0130116399,
-0.0024407625,
-0.0225934573,
0.0811160952,
-0.002745755,
0.0155251622,
-0.018922044,
-0.0605601296,
-0.0162285119,
0.0327888355,
-0.0061107301,
0.0162472334,
-0.0690415502,
-0.0077655008,
0.0350629091,
-0.0044596237,
0.0092300661,
-0.0566653162,
-0.0024376181,
0.0735852867,
0.0001174222,
0.0367897078,
0.0097856987,
-0.0229143072,
-0.097981669,
-0.038516432,
0.0136141255,
0.0159900226,
-0.0619820058,
-0.0080072349,
0.0140004735,
-0.0506874435,
-0.0195412096,
0.001999649,
-0.0323595367,
-0.021056518,
-0.0033578018,
0.0593127571,
-0.0727034658,
0.0156385936,
0.0597358197,
0.0408547558,
0.0461346023,
0.0707597733,
-0.0207738951,
-0.052453462,
-0.0335744433,
0.026368225,
-0.0328167304,
0.0144968741,
-0.0124186054,
-0.0063317195,
0.0607854463,
0.0154947815,
0.0874927118,
0.0479049012,
-0.0496042371,
0.0170619953,
0.0051304367,
0.0148074664,
0.0191997513,
-0.0070173633,
-0.0872381479,
-0.0284119546,
0.0021792476,
0.0231444556,
0.0347124077,
-0.0726885274,
0.0221482404,
-0.0795353577,
0.0014463038,
-0.0074842386,
0.0369065069,
-0.0184142999,
-0.0914474353,
0.0064300629,
0.0041021085,
-0.0185432285,
-0.0330710448,
-0.0192695577,
0.0180384777,
-0.0167461038,
0.0389322862,
-0.0041440367,
0.0681431144,
-0.0792607889,
0.0473542511,
0.0652484521,
0.046786122,
0.0104923379,
-0.0584507994,
0.0178027879,
0.0000020518,
-0.0254210401,
-0.0182992853,
0.0216595195,
-0.0194347184,
-0.0037725428,
-0.0313399285,
-0.0281669144,
-0.0279860441,
0.0048114541,
-0.0165156648,
0.0421094671,
-0.0112986872,
-0.0165575296,
-0.0557285324,
0.039002005,
0.0244847219,
0.0731430575,
0.0854726285,
-0.0429866463,
0.0022754306,
0.0055623497,
0.008658383,
-0.0298277698,
-0.006695006,
-0.0471039005,
-0.0256441459,
-0.0404808596,
-0.0617486611,
-0.0095555456,
0.0320768319,
-0.0006218162,
-0.0029547433,
0.0195890758,
-0.024350442,
-0.0747195184,
-0.0510843843,
0.000550943,
-0.007131753,
0.0562265404,
-0.0148033174,
-0.0087523758,
0.0223855525,
0.0103882374,
0.0024881572,
0.037836194,
-0.0369073786,
-0.038959831,
-0.0122533916,
0.0131865581,
0.0150380041,
0.0199469682,
-0.1096049845,
-0.0759442747,
0.0192080252,
0.0282301903,
-0.017261751,
-0.0113773914,
-0.0284028426,
0.0224139225,
0.0314112864,
0.0523478799,
-0.0468043424,
-0.0065645897,
-0.0140060382,
0.0203893334,
0.0141506465,
0.0018172633,
-0.0206248686,
0.0264429525,
0.0654534623,
-0.0135141993,
-0.0214673523,
-0.0078186058,
-0.0317616947,
-0.0004206694,
-0.0081433319,
-0.0285495035,
0.0073969117,
0.0395813547,
-0.0097503457,
-0.0481564142,
0.0171918571,
-0.0340805873,
0.0592817999,
-0.0055777258,
0.0081495102,
-0.0432215184,
0.0415137671,
0.0131479809,
0.017425552,
-0.0049886135,
-0.0325697213,
0.0407276116,
-0.0165016111,
-0.0365537666,
-0.0230753198,
-0.0012826513,
-0.0111354962,
-0.0064036767,
0.0900288597,
-0.0239781532,
-0.0447474681,
-0.0065461821,
0.0043461211,
0.0448450223,
-0.0209425613,
0.026879305,
-0.0068453252,
-0.0034295435,
-0.0048996084,
0.0056299679,
-0.0689671487,
-0.050275445,
0.0026635253,
-0.0145169329,
-0.0108177867,
0.0516906902,
0.0400158465,
-0.0582955256,
0.0003352726,
0.0265167672,
-0.0610885657,
0.0048273029,
0.0344281234,
0.0161739234,
0.0802599266,
-0.0518739671,
0.0031909505,
-0.0233684182,
-0.0613471791,
0.0027981482,
-0.0494266376,
-0.0396088772,
0.0551243238,
0.0429619253,
0.0493609272,
0.0460551493,
0.0517595671,
-0.0600314178,
-0.0151940919,
0.0067854295,
-0.0659188628,
-0.0076325629,
-6.56115984e-33,
0.0631817803,
-0.0410242081,
-0.0247474052,
-0.0187418666,
-0.0270544272,
0.000840807,
-0.0094913282,
0.01569359,
0.0027012827,
-0.0007586924,
-0.0069482978,
0.0229362398,
0.0074590966,
-0.0022788586,
0.0016194182,
-0.0386496745,
0.0090825772,
0.0237782337,
-0.0025071888,
0.0270079486,
0.0346463956,
0.0260027703,
0.0242284294,
-0.0626915768,
0.01224613,
-0.0326419547,
0.0191187914,
-0.0065367422,
0.0829769373,
0.0495863333,
-0.0108557399,
0.0680252686,
0.0149679594,
-0.0277199149,
0.0166411363,
0.0522885807,
-0.0490089133,
-0.0327056497,
0.0298814401,
-0.0270017199,
-0.024877267,
0.0067152889,
0.0342803001,
0.0017764221,
-0.0274190344,
0.0195541922,
0.0244871043,
0.0185185168,
-0.034032315,
0.0212365482,
-0.0183977634,
0.0222374108,
-0.0118254069,
-0.0200094711,
0.0036260022,
-0.031650845,
0.0374788716,
0.0614900775,
-0.0853521824,
0.0109786168,
-0.0449453071,
-0.0172987543,
0.0301658604,
-0.0022415111,
-0.0286556184,
0.0682841837,
0.012735703,
-0.0133848879,
0.0122495908,
0.029505467,
0.0055746939,
0.0282184072,
0.0447572097,
0.0381003022,
0.0375917777,
-0.0478362218,
-0.036717467,
0.0450129323,
0.0220535807,
0.0207257271,
0.0169285126,
0.0245699957,
-0.0519093238,
0.0078921011,
-0.0071425238,
-0.0002208655,
-0.0902496204,
-0.0824547708,
0.0072552599,
0.0045724981,
-0.0216961578,
0.0398576446,
-0.0108700963,
-0.0683270916,
-0.009273638,
0.0397075973,
-0.0158151034,
-0.0024493288,
0.0101025607,
0.0194146428,
-0.0248813815,
0.0119205397,
0.00436824,
-0.0413586125,
-0.0274143517,
-0.0247687288,
0.0096038533,
-0.017379228,
-0.0327437446,
0.003631904,
0.0013944742,
-0.0504874922,
-0.0607232042,
-0.0784977973,
0.0075956685,
0.0544491597,
-0.0262847506,
0.0224000923,
0.0500329696,
0.0869643837,
0.0004420584,
-0.0298013147,
0.0057834629,
-0.0079203872,
-0.0008100221,
-0.0205965135,
-0.0505716205,
-0.0148680685,
0.0408035889,
-0.0420427173,
-0.0178659335,
-0.0252785888,
2.652e-7,
0.0227819309,
0.0144883748,
-0.017820593,
-0.0139812399,
-0.0173815452,
0.048387181,
0.0423529185,
0.0479647107,
-0.0296280831,
0.0222020652,
0.006734238,
0.0022187801,
0.0283603724,
0.0108698299,
-0.0312143043,
0.0277324487,
-0.1137893945,
-0.0212507062,
-0.045720838,
-0.028657347,
-0.0118016768,
0.0694895685,
0.084548004,
-0.0132120829,
-0.04269436,
-0.0068749557,
0.0321641117,
-0.0341144688,
-0.0548487529,
-0.0081358738,
0.0482282937,
0.0030392248,
0.0168122165,
-0.0211603194,
-0.0354519896,
0.0094671948,
0.0609373599,
-0.0195637438,
-0.038942188,
-0.0222182963,
-0.0477511175,
-0.0470746011,
0.0170644708,
-0.0486082211,
0.0651354343,
0.0084388899,
-0.0342427604,
-0.0217876695,
-0.0465493612,
0.0615610331,
0.084753409,
0.0062244819,
-0.0451693013,
0.0214011353,
0.0270565301,
0.0208120383,
-0.0232546646,
-0.052891504,
0.0366240293,
0.0005950113,
0.0003384539,
0.0036978654,
-0.0454375073,
0.0212057419,
0.0294277836,
-0.0253775455,
0.0343583338,
1.817403806e-34,
0.0163930431,
0.0178738963,
0.0172943696,
-0.0109643331,
0.0435619503,
0.0042289873,
-0.0324320011,
0.0407990664,
0.0363539346,
-0.0576402843,
0.0269447584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14815v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14815v4 | Machine Reading Comprehension using Case-based Reasoning | 2023-05-24T07:09:56 | 2023-12-05T20:59:58 | Dung Thai, Dhruv Agarwal, Mudit Chaudhary, Wenlong Zhao, Rajarshi Das, Manzil Zaheer, Jay-Yoon Lee, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Andrew McCallum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | We present an accurate and interpretable method for answer extraction in
machine reading comprehension that is reminiscent of case-based reasoning (CBR)
from classical AI. Our method (CBR-MRC) builds upon the hypothesis that
contextualized answers to similar questions share semantic similarities with
each other. Given a test question, CBR-MRC first retrieves a set of similar
cases from a nonparametric memory and then predicts an answer by selecting the
span in the test context that is most similar to the contextualized
representations of answers in the retrieved cases. The semi-parametric nature
of our approach allows it to attribute a prediction to the specific set of
evidence cases, making it a desirable choice for building reliable and
debuggable QA systems. We show that CBR-MRC provides high accuracy comparable
with large reader models and outperforms baselines by 11.5 and 8.4 EM on
NaturalQuestions and NewsQA, respectively. Further, we demonstrate the ability
of CBR-MRC in identifying not just the correct answer tokens but also the span
with the most relevant supporting evidence. Lastly, we observe that contexts
for certain question types show higher lexical diversity than others and find
that CBR-MRC is robust to these variations while performance using
fully-parametric methods drops. | [
0.0071775839,
-0.002531091,
-0.0375260599,
0.0646587089,
-0.0646286011,
0.0402827337,
0.0224688556,
-0.0329197794,
0.019485468,
-0.0083687939,
-0.002961051,
0.0243611466,
-0.02779066,
0.041223906,
-0.0099155232,
-0.0182052255,
0.0213847253,
-0.024851568,
0.0110065378,
0.0018233049,
0.0024130139,
0.0226497781,
-0.0224991739,
0.0124488017,
0.0430991352,
-0.0628788248,
-0.0221722666,
-0.0273715965,
0.041425135,
-0.0202713721,
0.0262672249,
0.0232401658,
-0.0111661293,
0.0056896489,
0.0000018964,
-0.047950279,
-0.0374381132,
-0.0174843278,
-0.0303131528,
-0.0162294246,
-0.0202895124,
0.0226499755,
0.0590256937,
-0.0107781338,
-0.0352745131,
0.0101170298,
-0.0216031279,
0.0377813913,
0.0494624488,
0.010596469,
0.0099285068,
-0.0298432503,
0.0281171147,
0.0324794017,
0.0395652205,
-0.0816089958,
0.0060870955,
0.0360285193,
0.0499730371,
0.0175970178,
-0.0270405095,
0.0452391766,
0.0468720049,
0.0080176359,
-0.0398406461,
0.0465281159,
0.0091979634,
0.0139244823,
-0.0010507066,
0.1169177964,
0.0329053514,
-0.0674729794,
-0.0089058168,
0.0091288621,
0.0014356185,
0.0410069935,
-0.0129250996,
0.0329229645,
-0.0647181347,
0.0065795942,
0.055358097,
0.0487910509,
-0.0005394409,
0.0085717971,
-0.016028706,
0.0581896529,
0.013521486,
-0.0310130417,
-0.0113612944,
0.0356226414,
-0.0083043724,
-0.0011836519,
0.074220039,
0.0501376428,
-0.016616391,
0.0401477553,
-0.0286996681,
-0.0369556583,
0.0204432905,
-0.0164921265,
-0.0046808589,
0.0468474664,
-0.0251839459,
0.0699989945,
-0.0427728929,
-0.0054876255,
-0.0252266284,
0.0075163213,
-0.0683481395,
-0.0326829068,
-0.0290028229,
-0.0117318472,
-0.0265188478,
0.0551516153,
-0.0677850246,
-0.0063813548,
0.0111105302,
0.0348224342,
0.0300712828,
0.0042717145,
0.0125798611,
0.0340899527,
-0.0533246063,
-0.0199995879,
-0.0140656065,
-0.0164010935,
-0.0981198624,
0.04110137,
0.0120994616,
-0.0271882154,
-0.0166869368,
-0.018211579,
0.0326739587,
-0.0453277417,
-0.0205463581,
0.0488590486,
-0.022952266,
-0.030824637,
-0.0222982895,
-0.0447831601,
-0.0057626329,
-0.0136245023,
-0.0372493528,
-0.0534975491,
0.0461770967,
0.0571933128,
-0.0183644164,
-0.0047995322,
-0.0174396895,
0.046778474,
-0.0173024181,
0.0736232772,
0.0114727532,
-0.0318092406,
0.0507800616,
0.037094295,
-0.0016116913,
0.0363189541,
0.0364082158,
0.0040728734,
0.0636884794,
0.0073547959,
0.0044944012,
-0.0053647826,
0.0245341845,
0.005314169,
0.0091285044,
0.0369043648,
0.0015492184,
-0.0051535568,
0.0164742488,
0.018536292,
-0.0094380872,
-0.092775546,
0.0387568995,
0.0552210025,
0.027679855,
0.0154815009,
0.0232501179,
-0.0049064616,
0.0187423993,
0.0324123986,
-0.0082088178,
0.0030998921,
-0.062494617,
0.0312424749,
-0.0078215739,
-0.0121826986,
-0.015709972,
-0.0282665547,
0.0340152904,
0.025168512,
-0.017198531,
0.0526988916,
0.0229939409,
-0.0046233889,
-0.0310608242,
0.0154063115,
0.0063821659,
-0.0303369407,
-0.0020974886,
-0.0145567534,
0.0927579924,
-0.0077329888,
0.059704639,
-0.0499568321,
-0.0449983291,
0.0367097668,
-0.0082607055,
0.0039826459,
0.0150401844,
-0.0188957024,
0.028678963,
-0.0233213119,
0.0071528442,
0.0332655571,
-0.0288438089,
0.0347398929,
-0.0025112149,
0.0248877071,
0.0005534752,
-0.0575491637,
-0.0372265913,
0.0293057654,
-0.0523955636,
-0.0610092357,
0.0062232199,
-0.0016171766,
0.0340767838,
0.0164267346,
0.0253341421,
0.0087399259,
0.0126825143,
-0.0556992292,
0.0032293759,
0.0331510492,
-0.0815498978,
-0.0588636659,
-0.0004606274,
-0.0179432072,
-0.0140695069,
-0.0091638751,
-0.017170947,
-0.0319971256,
-0.0223541446,
-0.0265569873,
0.0080541819,
-0.0562607795,
-0.0252781045,
0.0103910407,
-0.0147342272,
-0.0597056374,
0.0713100955,
0.021455612,
-0.0236649048,
-0.0331750996,
0.0484582148,
-0.0065422049,
-0.019979842,
-0.0095566707,
-0.0203086659,
0.0231173709,
-0.0163460914,
0.0022515934,
-0.02699624,
-0.0845886543,
0.0119824,
-0.0604618937,
0.0248753838,
-0.0017189841,
-0.0056186686,
0.0292536542,
0.0141040264,
-0.0233011041,
-0.0212563407,
-0.0142170172,
-0.0127256867,
-0.015781058,
0.004750446,
0.042754788,
0.0311372839,
0.0430562757,
-0.0458835885,
-0.0203759298,
-0.0460184105,
0.0534647964,
0.0339217894,
0.0257200971,
-0.072629936,
0.035592936,
-0.0015291638,
-0.0019506312,
-0.0265008993,
0.0133537669,
-0.0011321689,
-0.0421022773,
0.0026408162,
0.0941702798,
0.011276911,
-0.028558895,
0.0275556613,
-0.0155210225,
-0.0693306327,
0.0267350525,
-0.0176673401,
0.0027692856,
0.0063548111,
-0.037912339,
0.020955652,
0.0289553683,
0.0132673793,
-0.0255265515,
-0.0106496327,
0.0297508854,
0.0010948452,
-0.029815007,
-0.0948695019,
-0.0062445984,
-0.0117238648,
0.0700278282,
-0.0141728073,
0.0000012612,
0.1028965414,
-0.0221092533,
0.0238855053,
-0.07697054,
0.0293296669,
-0.060346812,
0.0663765296,
-0.025805084,
0.0020603403,
-0.048904337,
-0.0533183925,
-0.0149651263,
-0.0024617773,
0.0159598868,
-0.0156890173,
0.0442456566,
-0.05131137,
0.0178589318,
-0.0036705481,
-0.0217178166,
-0.0594969951,
0.0121230371,
-0.025017757,
-0.0353058726,
-0.0270429999,
0.0229002275,
-0.0246458929,
0.0234952495,
0.0270255227,
0.0173512567,
-0.0363759547,
-0.0203833934,
-0.0417084135,
0.0796408653,
0.0379767865,
0.0338737704,
0.0145045714,
-0.0219098832,
0.0490742065,
0.0656887814,
-0.0082726069,
0.0041008471,
0.0101179257,
0.003105962,
0.0115588857,
-0.0550254881,
0.0342977755,
-0.0083776573,
0.0419470929,
-0.061436519,
-0.0471746437,
0.0807723999,
0.0557432696,
-0.063032195,
-0.0206696037,
-0.033882618,
0.0192932133,
-0.0038498796,
0.0537472665,
-0.0394500867,
-0.0535897762,
-0.0046072942,
0.0399035513,
-0.0114043746,
-0.0541955754,
0.0075939498,
-0.0842526853,
0.0152435508,
-0.0176926833,
-0.0446709432,
-0.0571934395,
-0.0240403209,
0.011771515,
0.0142162116,
0.0076535447,
0.0527964011,
0.0106505062,
0.008970296,
-0.0053910664,
0.0073345229,
0.0229747687,
0.0199306514,
-0.0296066739,
-0.0167927332,
0.0041595483,
0.0146386763,
-0.0036594146,
-0.0052445452,
-0.0407782942,
-0.0688533485,
0.0017572949,
-0.0023473995,
0.0205780156,
-0.0043242583,
0.0008633046,
-0.0354264714,
0.0619770437,
-0.0358128436,
-0.0345969982,
0.0868985653,
0.0314063616,
-0.0183947422,
-0.047750216,
-0.0420979075,
0.0134311775,
0.004295479,
0.0836777911,
0.0296598263,
-0.0152124064,
-0.0477860197,
-0.0077222455,
0.0161738452,
-0.0539874956,
-0.0209537502,
0.0027575728,
0.0030528291,
0.0401995406,
-0.0499897972,
-0.0687251091,
0.0262483507,
0.0404849984,
0.0085657164,
0.0033791226,
0.0594892763,
0.0103001669,
-0.0686311647,
0.0033856507,
-0.0267880764,
-0.0048396462,
-0.0202475358,
0.0269163065,
0.0228332151,
-0.047429949,
-0.04946528,
0.009877081,
-0.0176744014,
0.007277566,
-0.0026128937,
0.0039854595,
0.0082579879,
0.0118144304,
-0.0138395978,
-0.0213915817,
0.0384182893,
-0.0108536007,
-0.0029683134,
0.0111595225,
-0.0163295995,
-0.0181240421,
-0.0179513022,
0.0125403656,
-0.0154211596,
0.0257015582,
-0.0045437128,
0.0562796183,
-0.0346442163,
0.0259623006,
0.0291709192,
0.0141706066,
0.0087912278,
0.059886653,
-0.0190819465,
-0.0373970233,
0.0295930058,
-0.0351617448,
0.0004597049,
0.017159475,
0.0204710886,
0.0092047751,
-0.0703454763,
-0.0162876919,
-0.0391940288,
-0.04135089,
0.0231278054,
-0.0249251984,
0.0207591243,
0.0496129729,
0.0343075097,
-0.0078658424,
-0.047454156,
-0.0371040627,
0.0055091069,
0.0088457847,
0.1074205637,
-0.0038670339,
0.0702756345,
0.0317326151,
-0.0317189917,
-0.0271925051,
0.0243418012,
-0.0742448345,
0.0083657298,
0.0212517381,
0.0453069061,
-0.030687701,
-0.0090574306,
-0.0403277352,
-0.0167057682,
0.0011679938,
-0.0065067336,
0.0018357033,
0.0399600975,
0.0225000829,
0.0307483207,
0.0300964881,
0.0237861983,
-0.0128474254,
0.0388657935,
-0.0158920251,
0.0103566376,
0.0065547447,
-0.0268681683,
-0.0413427614,
-0.0236681066,
-0.0041331174,
0.067163907,
-0.021341756,
-0.0030305551,
-0.0509256721,
-0.0444651358,
0.0201522782,
0.0288813468,
0.0132503016,
0.0118121905,
-0.0249641966,
0.0648403615,
0.0229260921,
-0.0403831378,
-0.0379025079,
0.0815898329,
-0.0767030343,
-0.0493634641,
-0.020921573,
-5.948453246e-33,
-0.0104377959,
-0.0534724593,
0.0151378335,
-0.0069987057,
0.038608294,
0.0294791441,
-0.0311746784,
-0.0269896276,
-0.0202678256,
0.0039214059,
-0.0195991844,
0.0252363198,
0.0003995143,
0.020593632,
-0.0148527995,
-0.034696158,
-0.0062625241,
0.0126815708,
-0.0082567325,
0.0504314303,
0.0472000912,
0.0367532633,
0.00786376,
-0.0639335066,
0.0265174322,
-0.0511933826,
0.0499289669,
0.0292596593,
0.010266914,
0.0299328566,
-0.0287795756,
0.0194111746,
0.0477548204,
0.0031934441,
0.0580845252,
0.0653272197,
-0.1087841168,
-0.0591199845,
0.0118802944,
-0.0207232032,
-0.0672746673,
-0.0102837747,
0.0040414776,
0.0021407073,
0.0459474586,
-0.0210318286,
0.0285674799,
0.0006462266,
-0.0013027827,
-0.0025724052,
-0.0581198297,
0.014597889,
-0.0056153461,
0.0024267116,
-0.0303193629,
0.052580893,
0.0132465987,
0.1088009626,
-0.0573327392,
-0.0250959061,
-0.0058274469,
-0.0142167285,
0.0273416638,
0.0080633545,
-0.0199567545,
0.0327100754,
-0.0008224804,
-0.0347694941,
-0.0263693482,
-0.0036783069,
0.0053738118,
0.0250713788,
0.0249833167,
0.0532965809,
0.0349979289,
0.0281001572,
-0.0700569525,
0.060631685,
0.0512588657,
0.0183481798,
0.0212574713,
-0.0447907113,
-0.0861888081,
0.0100672711,
-0.0438079834,
-0.0083698248,
-0.0473189466,
0.0375583246,
0.0451216772,
-0.042047061,
-0.0696645603,
0.0142623745,
0.0329467803,
0.0028633005,
0.0169498511,
0.0119029395,
0.0384942703,
-0.0043014935,
-0.0101000704,
0.0705428198,
-0.0016189493,
0.0065880711,
-0.027335532,
-0.0302922223,
0.0154456571,
-0.0140185105,
0.0062146373,
-0.0543010756,
-0.0162854251,
-0.0275738649,
0.0040895515,
0.0024431073,
-0.0326148532,
0.0121888118,
0.0272171013,
0.0680781975,
0.0026701472,
0.0203481093,
0.0200799499,
0.017482901,
-0.0511578433,
-0.0412946492,
-0.0157274418,
0.0012908983,
-0.0095555326,
-0.028043896,
-0.0025008386,
0.0410964042,
-0.0105623761,
-0.0763398558,
0.0368676968,
0.0752859488,
2.569e-7,
0.0454307497,
0.0412136763,
0.0186975542,
0.0154060274,
0.0179502964,
0.0324944109,
0.0388407372,
0.0377942324,
0.0716702566,
-0.0419584885,
0.0095592495,
0.0430612825,
0.009440681,
0.0540415756,
-0.0761466026,
-0.0754192322,
-0.024504913,
-0.0109482547,
-0.067160219,
-0.0038937847,
0.0894514918,
0.0453564413,
-0.0213738866,
-0.0265496019,
0.0292703286,
-0.0248143543,
0.0244885907,
-0.0028183169,
0.0137622803,
0.0153536825,
0.0308922213,
-0.0285731461,
0.0421285592,
0.0333467424,
0.0082153725,
0.0340994522,
0.0003782128,
0.0127521027,
0.0315638036,
-0.0754895955,
-0.050847698,
-0.0104960492,
0.050600566,
-0.0881136283,
0.0887894034,
-0.0443038791,
-0.0134979021,
0.0038090781,
-0.0591499656,
-0.0204067416,
-0.0394542851,
0.0344753787,
-0.0202245414,
0.0248327572,
0.0046745278,
-0.0391228423,
0.014297748,
-0.0862682164,
0.0078003015,
0.0011382648,
-0.0044406708,
-0.0037228216,
-0.0077534183,
-0.0613149665,
0.042760171,
-0.0558214486,
0.0170302261,
1.995760049e-34,
-0.0019639425,
0.0221182667,
0.0285875108,
0.0188871454,
0.0283820145,
0.01142048,
-0.009536338,
-0.0005861003,
0.0301129669,
-0.1042337418,
-0.0190709569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14806v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14806v2 | AWESOME: GPU Memory-constrained Long Document Summarization using Memory Mechanism and Global Salient Content | 2023-05-24T07:00:00 | 2023-11-16T11:47:05 | Shuyang Cao, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long document summarization systems are critical for domains with lengthy and
jargonladen text, yet they present significant challenges to researchers and
developers with limited computing resources. Existing solutions mainly focus on
efficient attentions or divide-and-conquer strategies. The former reduces
theoretical time complexity, but is still memory-heavy. The latter methods
sacrifice global context, leading to uninformative and incoherent summaries.
This work aims to leverage the memory-efficient nature of divide-and-conquer
methods while preserving global context. Concretely, our framework AWESOME uses
two novel mechanisms: (1) External memory mechanisms track previously encoded
document segments and their corresponding summaries, to enhance global document
understanding and summary coherence. (2) Global salient content is further
identified beforehand to augment each document segment to support its
summarization. Extensive experiments on diverse genres of text, including
government reports, transcripts, scientific papers, and novels, show that
AWESOME produces summaries with improved informativeness, faithfulness, and
coherence than competitive baselines on longer documents, while having a
smaller GPU memory footprint. | [
0.0444729254,
0.028813798,
0.0361652337,
0.0016422514,
-0.002551402,
0.0021035261,
-0.0644722208,
-0.0274758637,
-0.0275342204,
-0.032543987,
0.0224648211,
-0.0138162766,
0.0332266539,
0.0461931974,
-0.0182617884,
-0.141165331,
0.0185913406,
-0.0338527821,
0.0072915792,
0.0256627779,
0.0382633172,
-0.0316067562,
0.0209325943,
-0.0405400731,
0.0071659926,
-0.0185870323,
-0.0268802866,
-0.0090698684,
0.0427754484,
-0.0045683836,
-0.0261114128,
-0.0136465281,
0.029212825,
0.0056353165,
0.0000023508,
-0.0373726673,
-0.0288424827,
-0.0069529605,
0.0365576372,
0.0418514796,
0.0474002548,
-0.0564262383,
-0.014317967,
-0.0383603163,
0.0010374971,
0.0247939844,
-0.0132169258,
0.03258707,
0.0518271774,
0.0313009471,
-0.0173013881,
-0.0322115384,
0.0279433299,
-0.0332889371,
0.0303713549,
-0.0382568613,
-0.0120134614,
-0.0181253459,
0.0261223037,
-0.0150185842,
-0.0385766067,
0.0226818528,
0.0193034019,
-0.0063111195,
0.0368926823,
0.0502782539,
-0.0418711863,
-0.0017959718,
0.0228227321,
0.0280206818,
-0.0125560723,
0.0221259855,
0.0528295301,
0.0061770091,
-0.0180528108,
-0.0389747173,
-0.0920500234,
0.0661839917,
-0.0453981124,
0.0096705137,
0.0210015681,
0.0534820631,
-0.0453590341,
0.0245575439,
-0.0475625545,
-0.0050005065,
-0.0111065805,
-0.0039039711,
-0.0282677393,
0.0271074101,
-0.022335384,
-0.0326121673,
0.0415183492,
0.0419090576,
0.0028512997,
0.0108280061,
-0.0431522839,
-0.0735567212,
0.0429858789,
-0.0477504618,
-0.0397703946,
0.0170269143,
0.0053997934,
0.0834163427,
-0.0019867641,
0.0155656599,
0.003001133,
-0.0114577189,
-0.0419626571,
-0.0288721547,
-0.0244610589,
0.0216739792,
-0.0227568094,
0.0510095097,
-0.0532303341,
-0.0555367731,
-0.0152686704,
0.0213309545,
0.0196509007,
0.0306883845,
-0.0249459129,
0.0330759026,
-0.0171095617,
0.0244745854,
0.0171310045,
0.0078406455,
-0.0820154175,
-0.0756361783,
0.0284942817,
0.0265655033,
-0.0000796449,
0.0251302756,
0.0183001067,
0.0016002102,
-0.0066444911,
0.0115017183,
-0.0271528121,
-0.0271373931,
-0.0185903497,
-0.0440612398,
-0.0149719212,
-0.0282594264,
0.0092374776,
-0.0452168211,
0.0072667608,
0.0241396595,
0.0030419752,
0.0162499659,
0.0063246093,
0.0125730252,
-0.0538934357,
-0.007432519,
-0.0506388247,
-0.0281984191,
0.0619159415,
0.0429092199,
0.043063432,
0.0498159677,
0.0099199917,
0.0813425556,
0.0446542054,
0.0149476556,
0.0126984892,
-0.0042607244,
0.0124622593,
0.0273066685,
0.0050180252,
0.0109756691,
-0.0288672354,
0.0070865364,
0.0535929799,
0.0453648232,
-0.0271489359,
-0.0030525858,
0.053760957,
0.0784301236,
-0.0461262204,
0.0310123153,
-0.0166685544,
0.0462575629,
0.0126586678,
0.0613030121,
0.0067755901,
0.0397334807,
0.0029104503,
0.0755602643,
0.1154708117,
0.0243344828,
-0.0122419354,
-0.0096861031,
0.0104232365,
0.0030521303,
0.0080429642,
-0.0140303085,
0.0527579002,
-0.0036608905,
-0.0246437881,
0.0372487418,
0.0103552127,
-0.0737469643,
-0.0073777931,
0.0111411922,
0.0194017459,
0.049002029,
0.0465468578,
-0.0491217636,
-0.0430723317,
-0.0140410215,
0.040305566,
0.0476238504,
0.0092411451,
0.0059433468,
0.0072784857,
-0.0728344545,
-0.0028275778,
-0.0423221961,
-0.0181612354,
-0.0113607589,
0.0283431057,
0.0353447236,
0.0223954692,
-0.0164379068,
-0.0250394456,
0.0127079487,
0.0155401742,
-0.0105228163,
-0.0338955782,
-0.0182545464,
-0.0083337016,
0.0076076221,
-0.0121522322,
0.0074652103,
0.0636161938,
-0.0270027407,
0.0175624341,
-0.009681765,
-0.0546125732,
0.0300515387,
-0.0011396883,
-0.0598827004,
-0.0073847892,
-0.0113579789,
-0.0178970154,
-0.0424628071,
0.0220520254,
-0.0515679605,
0.0268930551,
0.0125114219,
-0.0069741444,
0.0154936304,
0.0108697182,
-0.0072778459,
0.0735413507,
-0.0233977363,
-0.0064494354,
0.0600869432,
-0.0090238182,
-0.0046432042,
-0.0113444738,
0.03457807,
-0.0006880839,
0.0280941091,
-0.0110181905,
0.052427426,
-0.0375748351,
-0.0617843494,
-0.0277135372,
-0.0943532735,
0.0125202043,
0.002701971,
0.0085927863,
0.0572376363,
0.0147129036,
-0.0202671327,
-0.0011236781,
-0.0118086627,
-0.0303416569,
-0.0216714386,
0.0028906979,
0.0174167547,
0.0160360634,
0.0399581976,
-0.0250090733,
-0.0134886736,
0.0114961769,
0.0398645923,
0.0276085455,
-0.0955002084,
-0.0044657541,
-0.0185384005,
0.0063115722,
-0.0200155415,
0.0025215701,
0.0187988952,
-0.0193823408,
-0.0170700252,
0.0680085793,
0.0930811837,
0.0623035803,
0.0339790806,
0.0152726509,
-0.0482423753,
0.0158784371,
-0.0001668768,
-0.0131193874,
0.0513567701,
0.0515409671,
0.0082039908,
0.0400430709,
0.0669548213,
-0.0081473729,
0.0075687421,
0.0080219293,
-0.0044985651,
-0.02127208,
0.0090342201,
-0.0256900098,
-0.0134801036,
-0.0001917136,
-0.0004890563,
-0.0183444545,
-0.0188054461,
0.0269791149,
-0.0415966772,
-0.0008639341,
-0.0735446289,
0.0194438249,
-0.0567955002,
0.066609621,
0.0045837592,
0.0111404778,
-0.0510210097,
-0.014672176,
0.0325007327,
-0.011635202,
0.0114973979,
-0.0074482271,
0.042301856,
-0.0342088193,
0.0020414414,
-0.050784748,
-0.0080687432,
0.0037406399,
0.0018038746,
-0.0014520993,
-0.0000854276,
0.0564552024,
-0.0394269526,
-0.0643256977,
0.0160732642,
0.0611131489,
0.0839617327,
-0.0328292362,
-0.039009653,
0.0031917426,
0.0414782539,
0.0462534539,
-0.0017535686,
0.0144052217,
-0.0710682943,
0.0061630337,
0.1128759161,
0.0317084193,
-0.0286238939,
0.0273070093,
-0.0200201329,
-0.027982926,
-0.0571641214,
0.0121920872,
-0.0315362476,
0.0155059844,
-0.1012633145,
-0.0139237465,
0.0693885386,
0.0338947549,
-0.0723359659,
-0.0317747518,
-0.0261415355,
0.0175377652,
0.0009975166,
0.018791087,
-0.0541551299,
-0.0347752348,
0.0149407918,
0.0325468592,
0.0189486574,
-0.0421812534,
-0.0044635972,
-0.0331244655,
0.0169111844,
-0.0052190372,
-0.0472776443,
-0.0055773784,
-0.0334098451,
-0.0040029008,
0.0358447619,
-0.0577092469,
0.005831318,
-0.0174838211,
-0.0078781573,
-0.0244398061,
-0.0520535409,
0.0639762878,
-0.0450628474,
-0.0203279573,
-0.0629452392,
0.0718203932,
0.056344375,
0.039287962,
0.0150879733,
0.0365849473,
-0.0429661721,
0.0032353096,
-0.007468293,
0.0789210498,
-0.0332410187,
0.0291492101,
-0.0280328821,
0.0411698036,
-0.0002620255,
-0.0329076089,
0.0490316525,
0.0348496884,
0.008233916,
-0.0157892052,
-0.0605189204,
0.0280891061,
-0.0242535509,
0.051945243,
0.0394761227,
-0.0192474909,
-0.0578598268,
-0.0301350392,
-0.0194327291,
-0.0605425164,
-0.0080020493,
-0.03485227,
-0.0226174016,
-0.0262019634,
-0.0394859798,
-0.0440817401,
0.0289808996,
0.0117830392,
-0.0038318455,
0.014528132,
0.0019516763,
-0.0261835437,
-0.0824201778,
0.0007332797,
-0.0443515219,
-0.0438801199,
-0.0345781147,
-0.0286274999,
0.0185546484,
-0.013185665,
-0.0097045228,
0.0628455803,
-0.0351509713,
-0.0120055247,
0.0118021751,
0.001771225,
0.0175121911,
0.0516323447,
0.0031804673,
0.0066784187,
0.0562473424,
0.0339728631,
-0.0499759801,
0.0394631959,
-0.0071525448,
0.0115422821,
-0.0028331517,
-0.0090011852,
-0.0237085298,
0.002614924,
-0.0111734075,
-0.0049208687,
-0.0109473122,
-0.0147323236,
-0.0144964224,
-0.0064975177,
-0.0043173935,
-0.0008456382,
0.0006559158,
0.0038854494,
0.0024081324,
-0.0030711147,
-0.0082850996,
0.0016476786,
0.0509549044,
-0.0198874027,
-0.0099584572,
0.0096162874,
0.1079043448,
0.0234899279,
-0.0239415839,
-0.0555881001,
-0.0111892615,
-0.0416181311,
-0.0260689855,
-0.0198483597,
-0.0175378807,
-0.0192955006,
-0.023361899,
-0.0499981046,
0.0632826909,
-0.0329485573,
0.0263088401,
0.039816197,
-0.0127036935,
-0.0062898812,
0.0420738757,
-0.1028573513,
-0.0065641254,
-0.0382596701,
0.0291548651,
0.0406062901,
-0.0491153859,
0.0578850843,
-0.0125711327,
0.0018232575,
-0.0177721139,
0.0170384441,
0.0552455336,
-0.0168734342,
-0.0922442228,
0.0370914638,
0.0018629069,
0.0297259074,
0.0601886064,
-0.0584522337,
-0.0269596688,
0.0630765185,
-0.0306153074,
-0.0371282846,
0.0028177928,
-0.0160988439,
0.0490816869,
-0.0072926311,
-0.0435469635,
-0.0427716002,
0.0148400711,
0.0380091853,
-0.0041404832,
0.0017618999,
0.0045073237,
0.0342973173,
0.0187382642,
0.0058559724,
-0.0000588141,
-0.0187767092,
0.0507766344,
-0.0327531882,
-0.0047464208,
0.0539790057,
-6.608422794e-33,
-0.0230020564,
-0.0245116577,
-0.0145727713,
-0.001000491,
-0.0371511281,
0.041721072,
-0.0787887201,
-0.0340834931,
0.0617335364,
-0.0011249853,
-0.0271287765,
0.0125102885,
0.0180459265,
0.0310597904,
-0.0109401364,
0.0204345454,
0.0206036363,
0.0365429185,
-0.0378154367,
0.0858780891,
0.0642075613,
0.0284388568,
0.0211405642,
-0.0345726199,
0.0117436871,
-0.0087260855,
0.0375483334,
-0.0518568605,
0.0522508584,
0.0104523599,
-0.0272337254,
-0.0160501488,
0.0328888446,
-0.0502340645,
-0.0589819215,
0.0293550435,
-0.0984758735,
0.0030142451,
0.0139038712,
-0.0328483842,
-0.0530538522,
-0.0348938704,
0.0285278,
0.0114187952,
0.0660898089,
-0.0673312172,
0.0388214067,
-0.0185037982,
-0.0504700504,
-0.0820271447,
-0.0703486353,
0.0477585942,
-0.0482141897,
0.0072825085,
0.0635523275,
-0.0202455353,
0.0253879242,
0.0524871573,
-0.0443891659,
0.0117286937,
0.0230954736,
0.0604454093,
0.0327358246,
-0.0117575945,
0.0157166738,
0.0787995607,
0.0162134524,
0.0097726183,
-0.0447568335,
0.0369341522,
0.004000809,
-0.0278868172,
0.010424193,
-0.0177483186,
0.1028946564,
0.0157196745,
-0.0425849333,
0.0553150885,
-0.0252887905,
0.0286626387,
0.0429697186,
0.0137305204,
-0.0064549427,
0.0033183133,
0.0011755183,
0.0371022075,
-0.0225079823,
0.0210205652,
0.0003583184,
0.0328876562,
-0.065443702,
0.0086052567,
0.0056780721,
0.0122832134,
0.0376483016,
0.0175751988,
-0.0065758983,
0.0403649397,
0.0029948615,
-0.0437540896,
-0.0050891405,
0.0031022499,
0.0083216419,
-0.0162733719,
0.0004656322,
0.0007929541,
0.0296382159,
-0.0203779303,
-0.0408693179,
0.008890559,
-0.0127016325,
0.0288253147,
-0.0193730351,
0.0145564983,
0.0063342964,
0.0067657945,
0.0015860846,
0.0833460391,
-0.008074061,
0.0092161428,
-0.012527246,
-0.019280171,
0.0015398181,
0.0297189392,
-0.0106398975,
0.0033365509,
-0.0058679287,
-0.0114016226,
0.022723157,
-0.0785358623,
-0.0181178041,
0.0203390997,
2.847e-7,
0.0249081906,
0.0478400886,
0.0883131474,
-0.0566637889,
-0.0076717255,
0.0028948688,
0.0058066696,
0.0250064358,
-0.0104171429,
-0.0230896324,
-0.0075763832,
0.0432645604,
0.022863416,
0.02989907,
-0.1172421798,
0.0010885263,
-0.0661263019,
-0.04560614,
-0.0416578576,
0.0112760011,
0.0266989656,
0.0493262596,
-0.0170709174,
0.015966177,
0.0364128388,
-0.038218081,
0.0107765486,
-0.0076359245,
0.0055455929,
0.018053811,
0.0125300186,
-0.025455039,
-0.0528027751,
-0.0367424823,
-0.0009432674,
-0.0269926284,
0.0207002107,
0.0630350113,
0.0181328915,
0.0224717706,
0.0385282077,
-0.0247364026,
0.0158011746,
0.0024421462,
0.0253691487,
-0.0161224212,
-0.0144680459,
-0.0333420672,
-0.0067738588,
0.0195636917,
-0.0305455811,
0.0246584248,
-0.0151904281,
0.0305696577,
-0.0105017349,
-0.0116560841,
-0.0172241628,
-0.0722857788,
-0.0253479797,
0.020859085,
-0.0051533459,
-0.0094133252,
-0.0719852149,
0.0217113849,
0.0118564973,
-0.0704619065,
-0.0237035155,
3.176248184e-34,
0.0845092386,
-0.0138874603,
-0.0480821617,
-0.0036682151,
0.0463853404,
-0.0495701656,
-0.0276645515,
-0.0211261995,
0.0026600137,
-0.0739407986,
-0.0161904376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14802v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14802v2 | Estimating Large Language Model Capabilities without Labeled Test Data | 2023-05-24T06:55:09 | 2023-10-26T06:09:05 | Harvey Yiyun Fu, Qinyuan Ye, Albert Xu, Xiang Ren, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have the impressive ability to perform
in-context learning (ICL) from only a few examples, but the success of ICL
varies widely from task to task. Thus, it is important to quickly determine
whether ICL is applicable to a new task, but directly evaluating ICL accuracy
can be expensive in situations where test data is expensive to annotate -- the
exact situations where ICL is most appealing. In this paper, we propose the
task of ICL accuracy estimation, in which we predict the accuracy of an LLM
when doing in-context learning on a new task given only unlabeled test data for
that task. To perform ICL accuracy estimation, we propose a method that trains
a meta-model using LLM confidence scores as features. We compare our method to
several strong accuracy estimation baselines on a new benchmark that covers 4
LLMs and 3 task collections. The meta-model improves over all baselines across
8 out of 12 settings and achieves the same estimation performance as directly
evaluating on 40 collected labeled test examples per task. At the same time, no
existing approach provides an accurate and reliable ICL accuracy estimation in
every setting, highlighting the need for better ways to measure the uncertainty
of LLM predictions. | [
0.0007836396,
0.0366637595,
0.0053874613,
0.0380883776,
-0.0097126653,
0.0210835412,
0.0307786129,
-0.0317608528,
-0.018633699,
-0.0724346712,
-0.0778657272,
-0.0441737399,
0.0175227299,
0.0223717149,
0.0354378782,
-0.0085817566,
0.0196188241,
-0.0326216035,
-0.0007169555,
0.0175080169,
-0.030719813,
0.0035260704,
-0.0064364518,
0.0598453656,
0.0041520991,
-0.0219888501,
-0.0004998499,
0.0047233109,
0.0024478813,
-0.030350551,
0.0364216939,
0.0632213205,
0.0326642096,
0.0498143435,
0.0000019437,
-0.0630169511,
-0.0184586514,
-0.0030119277,
-0.0428321473,
-0.0250203591,
0.042595163,
-0.001552942,
-0.0173301641,
0.04932696,
-0.0334859826,
-0.0213763155,
0.039774999,
-0.0019313638,
0.000532179,
0.0787757337,
0.0045189993,
0.0367463231,
-0.012533321,
-0.030123055,
0.0116645508,
-0.0411936566,
0.0085524209,
-0.0079515288,
-0.0242626965,
-0.0008636241,
-0.0150443781,
0.0498056337,
0.0116748586,
0.0051405625,
-0.0329206176,
0.0210273899,
-0.0496323332,
0.0026298226,
0.0012189627,
0.0519089326,
-0.0314980634,
-0.0382080376,
-0.0265367851,
-0.0155569054,
-0.0070057292,
0.0112069966,
-0.0373086222,
0.0258125756,
0.0192883555,
0.0189750884,
-0.0077685998,
0.0120269004,
0.0515755825,
0.0001784342,
-0.0065441434,
0.0783690214,
0.0034647868,
-0.0174342468,
0.0272443462,
0.0100555103,
-0.0479220375,
-0.0288797468,
-0.0468295999,
-0.0044618971,
-0.0609898046,
0.0522875451,
-0.0344179645,
-0.0485345051,
0.0144815417,
-0.0415303819,
0.047543101,
0.0146607412,
-0.0379275717,
0.0505037345,
-0.0173178669,
0.0473390594,
0.0220861044,
0.0148409856,
-0.0421683267,
-0.0212008674,
-0.064009212,
0.0345271751,
-0.0102503449,
-0.0090131946,
-0.0023916981,
0.0034621272,
-0.0485196412,
0.0338289328,
-0.0195656177,
0.0364143588,
0.0265557077,
-0.0182087291,
-0.0477513224,
-0.0116674276,
-0.0048661977,
0.006276872,
0.0231840685,
0.0214248877,
0.0012552497,
-0.0668377355,
0.0118342573,
0.0130791683,
0.0033754269,
-0.0176045448,
0.0254617836,
0.0697894692,
0.0001614808,
-0.0770717859,
-0.0072822603,
0.0007178202,
-0.0314450711,
-0.0719347671,
-0.0099100331,
-0.0780398101,
-0.0180834308,
0.0268012155,
0.0273948163,
-0.0243085772,
-0.0036095318,
0.016703384,
0.0118103428,
0.0681736767,
-0.0206942242,
0.0116619114,
0.0147424182,
-0.0119487233,
-0.0340576693,
0.0998805612,
0.0172623321,
0.0122464215,
0.047106117,
0.0314017683,
0.0135809015,
0.0461117886,
0.0168210007,
0.0113130733,
-0.0272674561,
-0.0034679701,
0.0529515706,
-0.0078527266,
-0.0108026806,
0.0008494129,
0.0201048944,
0.0211450309,
0.0674865469,
0.0444384553,
0.0174945462,
-0.0167160928,
0.0399865992,
0.0121352142,
0.0225603729,
-0.0427369997,
-0.0847755373,
-0.0029126392,
-0.0465950072,
0.0194493216,
0.0234589931,
-0.0025435996,
-0.0245835092,
-0.0462501086,
-0.0341945961,
-0.034712743,
-0.0359458104,
0.0320937335,
0.0775596052,
0.0121537531,
-0.025569832,
0.0166842267,
0.0342962444,
-0.0226223636,
-0.0004628783,
-0.040567331,
0.0172150452,
0.0318718068,
0.0361518376,
-0.0516589396,
-0.0384348184,
-0.0198680162,
0.0443022475,
0.0359113812,
0.027033167,
-0.0319594666,
0.0332534797,
-0.0358534791,
-0.0276611131,
-0.0154320132,
0.0468589365,
-0.0055702091,
0.0287485905,
-0.0099720452,
0.0185298193,
-0.1103034243,
-0.0474054664,
0.0371857882,
-0.0482522249,
-0.0299051777,
0.0096966941,
0.0112799024,
0.0293102432,
-0.0187109169,
-0.0051387656,
0.009438959,
0.033912614,
-0.0134073552,
0.0033747919,
0.0086367819,
-0.0406660102,
-0.0449595265,
0.0472201966,
-0.0139925526,
-0.0327874273,
0.0227122605,
-0.0516367853,
-0.0527234226,
-0.0235981625,
-0.014602188,
0.0383474752,
-0.037062224,
0.0215543825,
-0.038354639,
-0.0013271259,
-0.0322349891,
0.0599454604,
0.0029363716,
0.031515345,
0.0240400098,
-0.0067800763,
0.000267206,
0.0127611794,
-0.0682059601,
0.0024154468,
-0.0144800525,
0.0132587431,
0.0156501587,
0.0318617746,
-0.0590606928,
0.0060171578,
-0.1189226359,
0.0105329622,
-0.0517391302,
0.0228030663,
0.0354226306,
-0.0150484592,
-0.0058980263,
-0.0317808278,
-0.0321230665,
-0.0305842403,
0.0067092921,
0.0125610288,
-0.0050064842,
0.0369092822,
-0.0155258821,
-0.0493490323,
-0.0026920261,
-0.0132965278,
0.0622549728,
-0.0074734911,
-0.0056611481,
-0.020370923,
0.0624127872,
-0.0007051638,
0.0351482816,
-0.0148236351,
0.0046270667,
-0.0023999112,
-0.0296588764,
-0.0065746927,
0.0404053628,
-0.0060221017,
-0.0069623501,
0.0836046264,
0.0183810461,
-0.0639006719,
-0.0059713242,
-0.0072719967,
-0.0510570183,
-0.0535386913,
-0.0211050306,
-0.0133455861,
0.0575088821,
-0.0121235643,
-0.0118304249,
-0.0412228219,
-0.0066471393,
-0.0306048319,
-0.0115156323,
-0.0509139337,
0.0383579843,
-0.0020576094,
0.0413825847,
-0.0270161033,
-0.0836724788,
0.0532346554,
-0.042751044,
0.0012622304,
-0.0316070132,
-0.0205616076,
-0.0210745651,
0.0637641773,
-0.006958317,
0.0034314552,
0.0121395653,
-0.0158578381,
-0.0646616817,
-0.0015613673,
0.0186306518,
-0.0459973328,
0.074866727,
-0.082507059,
0.0245583709,
0.0135431327,
-0.0225577001,
-0.062386021,
-0.0050089168,
-0.0510620736,
0.0389310531,
-0.0322048068,
-0.0109600211,
-0.0064639375,
-0.0109895207,
0.0105736386,
0.0613473095,
0.0100733917,
-0.0158895887,
0.000827736,
-0.0091651343,
0.0405890718,
0.0078362636,
-0.002186174,
-0.0259907339,
0.027122749,
0.0261105467,
0.0600862578,
0.02036402,
-0.0561489426,
-0.0238258075,
0.0228705294,
-0.0128142433,
-0.009602855,
0.0609772578,
0.0221754741,
-0.0567250364,
-0.0327201188,
0.1496579051,
0.03094423,
-0.0591986366,
-0.0087140836,
0.0044019469,
-0.0112929381,
0.0606077574,
0.0255330503,
-0.046708446,
-0.0427070148,
0.0084374966,
0.0259322487,
-0.0028664155,
-0.0192867666,
-0.0130862109,
-0.1364081651,
0.0104579814,
-0.0076837619,
-0.0505748913,
-0.028833149,
-0.0381108299,
0.024215484,
-0.0317558087,
0.0455320477,
-0.0209296905,
-0.008540567,
0.0043043932,
0.0401503406,
-0.0187480878,
-0.1276441813,
0.0538065471,
-0.0357848443,
0.0770200044,
0.0640177727,
0.0180670172,
-0.0146790482,
0.0095983893,
0.0750520676,
-0.0007912309,
0.0002203757,
-0.0149324322,
0.0750763342,
-0.007659093,
0.0013217726,
0.0487934127,
0.0167830046,
-0.0467493162,
-0.0113502406,
0.0271457992,
0.0651454106,
0.0044925176,
0.0098146126,
0.0327569544,
-0.0520097464,
0.0332341045,
0.0653698072,
0.0173695553,
-0.0493094362,
0.0130684413,
-0.0131579665,
-0.0122313825,
-0.0095395511,
0.0021488925,
0.0449797027,
-0.0068839705,
0.0039757378,
-0.0626708642,
-0.0176769085,
0.0546040572,
0.035886094,
0.0027785168,
0.0183784645,
0.0113256285,
0.0113552539,
-0.0740156919,
0.037118651,
-0.0450524166,
0.0354467779,
-0.0655324087,
0.0055272533,
0.0532505624,
-0.010924954,
-0.0215616673,
0.0339025036,
-0.0931309387,
-0.0564594455,
-0.0077841221,
0.0550674424,
0.0144203668,
0.0500940084,
-0.0223500729,
-0.0508615896,
0.0677872896,
0.0011467725,
-0.0233768858,
0.0052033607,
0.0524947345,
-0.0072845793,
-0.0129463859,
0.0450872257,
-0.0736021772,
-0.0107827066,
0.049561657,
0.0044258488,
-0.0170095544,
-0.0135278963,
0.0323384106,
-0.0190624259,
0.0746433139,
-0.0288549308,
-0.0261805952,
-0.0298330151,
0.0175788254,
0.0137353698,
-0.030160455,
-0.0292651784,
0.0134361638,
0.0165112428,
-0.0100625996,
-0.0056780428,
0.0447034538,
-0.0315212943,
0.0291471146,
-0.0094821574,
0.0052087721,
0.0060682236,
0.0325095728,
0.026337754,
0.016565172,
-0.018222928,
-0.0203262176,
0.0236036014,
0.0316469073,
0.0045168344,
0.0305873137,
-0.0020207288,
-0.0073029068,
-0.0102368668,
0.0310933664,
-0.0641443133,
0.001139052,
-0.0568685979,
0.0412042104,
0.0522850156,
-0.0325152241,
0.0417609513,
-0.0405187607,
0.0116961217,
-0.0633647591,
0.0211103782,
-0.0086735925,
-0.0320573561,
0.0187667701,
0.00858727,
-0.0186471175,
0.031325683,
0.0930674598,
0.03056846,
0.0341176502,
0.0001472193,
-0.014533272,
-0.0349398442,
0.0107222944,
0.0235115495,
0.0243091751,
-0.0224561822,
0.0150453607,
-0.0266864114,
-0.0947862715,
0.0437837541,
-0.0014017046,
-0.0167965423,
0.0098150661,
0.0106953643,
0.0616472885,
-0.0218079519,
0.0056527089,
-0.0474707596,
-0.0318624713,
0.0160349756,
0.0109913014,
-0.0393532366,
-5.827815199e-33,
-0.0243354011,
-0.0436292551,
-0.0025210364,
-0.0113423374,
0.0406662747,
0.0306071304,
-0.0346485898,
0.0312083382,
-0.0049852473,
0.0058659757,
-0.0075800475,
0.0109053124,
0.0222995654,
0.0426409282,
0.0301455632,
-0.0157831181,
0.0354771391,
-0.0132127199,
-0.0216830466,
-0.004107249,
0.0322813094,
0.0224445481,
0.0992094278,
-0.0701181293,
0.0274627171,
-0.0059700524,
-0.0246993564,
0.0167135838,
-0.0236702859,
0.0513816886,
0.0150814047,
0.0557413623,
0.0315361097,
-0.0524492338,
-0.033820495,
-0.0119045405,
-0.0410498865,
-0.0183696058,
0.0042044646,
0.0171353426,
-0.0191253554,
0.0254494008,
0.0060493164,
-0.0126439715,
-0.0151749682,
0.0069443393,
0.0546785481,
-0.0501413457,
-0.0211041067,
-0.0207625758,
-0.0366623811,
0.028703358,
0.0052267029,
-0.0211556796,
0.0341916531,
0.048344072,
0.0084290113,
-0.0135981636,
-0.0434426889,
0.0025917429,
-0.019470403,
0.0600480251,
0.0869278833,
0.0534812883,
-0.0016015148,
0.0602224246,
0.0042578252,
0.0293138735,
0.0677860379,
-0.0389217436,
0.0755028799,
0.0252615549,
0.0124108056,
0.0778185353,
0.0312671401,
0.0335204005,
-0.0589149483,
0.0378157236,
0.0053513586,
0.0178441629,
0.0361064784,
-0.0073058908,
-0.0358788855,
-0.0242016595,
-0.0794722959,
-0.0120665524,
-0.0368512124,
-0.0149680087,
0.0571545064,
0.025240723,
-0.0072009875,
0.0000306733,
0.0217421576,
-0.0503784977,
-0.0261432938,
0.0193743035,
-0.0114889722,
0.0260083266,
-0.00434577,
0.0247820634,
-0.0460164584,
-0.0473634601,
0.0045710681,
0.0223272517,
0.0156309716,
-0.0315161347,
0.0800878555,
0.0269350298,
-0.0776018426,
0.012757726,
-0.0487091616,
-0.0065759183,
0.0061427387,
0.0210774727,
0.0320961922,
-0.0055699348,
-0.0241142195,
0.0330467597,
0.0000628215,
-0.035301771,
-0.0065903175,
-0.0277273748,
-0.0261576064,
-0.0097188028,
-0.0364596844,
-0.025119761,
-0.0217211973,
-0.011747581,
0.0450439826,
0.0061751287,
0.0089471349,
0.0041518896,
2.514e-7,
0.0553216301,
0.0396457016,
-0.0264313035,
0.0132412473,
0.0099167395,
0.0378937498,
-0.0471978597,
-0.0010646145,
0.0451180525,
-0.0378356762,
0.0145683456,
0.0040326659,
0.0777881891,
0.0313807428,
-0.0894056857,
-0.0123437131,
-0.0362208299,
0.0318324603,
-0.0110129099,
0.0123547511,
-0.0003563634,
0.1197422892,
0.0065594669,
-0.0139401881,
-0.0054182047,
-0.0506922156,
0.0525233261,
-0.0605221502,
-0.0133106578,
0.0136360312,
-0.0179686714,
0.0553449094,
0.011713692,
0.0249054618,
-0.046658989,
0.0194064174,
-0.0075425534,
0.0530717336,
0.0052577364,
0.0066300342,
-0.0020569875,
0.0255204979,
0.0066093742,
-0.0178823527,
0.054083664,
-0.064580217,
-0.0021319704,
-0.0553855039,
0.0259773787,
-0.0115147969,
0.0134220216,
-0.011687954,
0.0018580707,
0.015742816,
0.0084681008,
-0.0157340448,
-0.0418837294,
-0.0758012086,
-0.0520974956,
0.0295240134,
-0.0315134451,
-0.0439453237,
-0.0197016858,
-0.019654423,
0.0100475764,
-0.083428055,
0.0505292229,
2.313768923e-34,
0.0243075602,
0.0131597221,
0.0119296601,
0.0074564572,
-0.0074330992,
-0.0171889439,
-0.015330812,
0.0129778888,
0.0142800575,
-0.048952613,
0.0135016618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14795v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14795v2 | MQuAKE: Assessing Knowledge Editing in Language Models via Multi-Hop Questions | 2023-05-24T06:48:41 | 2023-10-29T20:28:17 | Zexuan Zhong, Zhengxuan Wu, Christopher D. Manning, Christopher Potts, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The information stored in large language models (LLMs) falls out of date
quickly, and retraining from scratch is often not an option. This has recently
given rise to a range of techniques for injecting new facts through updating
model weights. Current evaluation paradigms are extremely limited, mainly
validating the recall of edited facts, but changing one fact should cause
rippling changes to the model's related beliefs. If we edit the UK Prime
Minister to now be Rishi Sunak, then we should get a different answer to Who is
married to the British Prime Minister? In this work, we present a benchmark,
MQuAKE (Multi-hop Question Answering for Knowledge Editing), comprising
multi-hop questions that assess whether edited models correctly answer
questions where the answer should change as an entailed consequence of edited
facts. While we find that current knowledge-editing approaches can recall
edited facts accurately, they fail catastrophically on the constructed
multi-hop questions. We thus propose a simple memory-based approach, MeLLo,
which stores all edited facts externally while prompting the language model
iteratively to generate answers that are consistent with the edited facts.
While MQuAKE remains challenging, we show that MeLLo scales well with LLMs (up
to 175B) and outperforms previous model editors by a large margin. | [
0.0598372333,
0.0590240099,
0.0013768515,
0.0172124412,
-0.0530638918,
0.0065666246,
-0.0172044802,
-0.0200672243,
0.0132665196,
-0.071816884,
-0.0197496656,
-0.0470743068,
-0.0270528849,
0.0135360789,
0.0241499543,
-0.0275751501,
0.0662314743,
-0.0178016648,
-0.0072132456,
-0.0246354267,
-0.0205266252,
-0.0115868794,
0.0040819966,
0.0013924381,
-0.0089335851,
-0.0376389623,
-0.0484367833,
0.0000177543,
0.0180685017,
0.0165201891,
-0.0030073398,
0.0714858025,
-0.0086804824,
0.0521255769,
0.000002084,
-0.0566799939,
-0.0323186219,
0.0039799865,
-0.062577039,
0.0373243019,
-0.0093587404,
0.0258264206,
-0.0299958289,
0.0014790873,
-0.0241596755,
0.0231372342,
0.0376152843,
0.0400572494,
0.1029562578,
0.0833206028,
0.0220701527,
-0.0065708426,
0.0136794169,
-0.0307411663,
0.0159902014,
-0.0355404839,
0.0599071011,
0.0339412764,
-0.0600843057,
0.0365763716,
-0.0233887564,
0.0446890928,
0.0327576399,
-0.0435401127,
-0.0044322866,
0.0133961551,
-0.0281301197,
0.0304025691,
-0.0075907032,
0.040718019,
0.0197563134,
-0.0210681241,
-0.0129967472,
0.0111454548,
0.0326114371,
0.0259008911,
-0.0249437746,
-0.00810258,
0.0102166478,
-0.0283832438,
-0.0053866142,
-0.0823507756,
0.0404297598,
0.0186996907,
-0.0135188,
0.0738671049,
0.0369757004,
-0.0380190536,
-0.0297884829,
-0.0123963663,
0.0123241879,
-0.1061005145,
-0.013319958,
0.0387602821,
-0.0128753362,
0.0200827438,
-0.0207887478,
0.0153556531,
0.0272992942,
-0.0787140206,
0.0311953221,
0.042292539,
-0.015831966,
0.0754364133,
0.0028589962,
0.0517223291,
-0.0096798539,
-0.005133464,
-0.0219302308,
0.0055422471,
-0.0644738674,
-0.0316062756,
-0.0474047102,
0.0374689326,
-0.0280949995,
0.0315088406,
-0.0253144726,
0.0234248172,
-0.0119577479,
0.0276811942,
-0.0102259126,
0.0095132207,
-0.0283731986,
-0.0393378362,
-0.0654574707,
0.0709169954,
-0.0190802831,
0.0189280976,
0.0198698491,
-0.0345000476,
-0.0282775648,
-0.0211544074,
-0.0068872906,
-0.0183979403,
0.0202188119,
0.046189025,
-0.0357719027,
-0.0091553554,
-0.0143061448,
-0.063182801,
-0.0210098643,
-0.0664089173,
-0.0042238804,
-0.0615528263,
0.0489667021,
-0.0184248853,
-0.0442315787,
-0.0624878071,
0.0078339092,
0.0041141706,
-0.0265851952,
0.0573267229,
0.0366613902,
0.0141266808,
0.047501117,
0.0152716897,
-0.0275909621,
0.0744670928,
0.0203130674,
-0.002221951,
0.0379639082,
0.0047463882,
0.0133207059,
0.0221064184,
0.0268342867,
0.0387256704,
0.0032585789,
0.0610000193,
0.0494184121,
0.0327331126,
0.0011401527,
0.0420654342,
-0.0098026525,
-0.0307784583,
0.0753225908,
-0.0345955901,
0.002433761,
0.0173905846,
0.0361320488,
-0.0563743748,
0.0338983722,
0.0265842918,
-0.0538021475,
0.0399362333,
-0.0474993251,
0.0066250064,
0.0150562776,
0.0142136784,
-0.0215099007,
-0.0282256305,
0.0097535355,
0.0212845914,
0.0026596326,
0.0143541237,
0.0334658846,
0.0137253432,
-0.0187617075,
0.078173399,
0.0162340496,
-0.032266248,
-0.0016160475,
-0.0641748309,
-0.0094543425,
0.0537802652,
0.0450905412,
-0.0259320922,
-0.058800865,
-0.0395459048,
0.0099758236,
0.0136958715,
0.1046189889,
-0.0414157286,
-0.0092147477,
0.0102333901,
-0.0039352337,
-0.056165915,
0.0395127572,
0.0133657847,
0.0396354198,
0.0171430279,
0.0116429552,
-0.0220256448,
0.0161069948,
0.012592298,
-0.0330043808,
-0.0200109873,
-0.0183247924,
-0.0146152815,
0.0023652047,
0.006109837,
-0.0204045344,
0.0126161017,
0.0279056337,
0.0072162985,
-0.0508492813,
-0.0155964205,
-0.0079744486,
-0.0377910323,
0.0641021952,
0.0068694879,
-0.0296313558,
0.0017958474,
-0.0487627275,
-0.0391150825,
0.0068351855,
-0.0033092627,
0.0444166176,
-0.0545484461,
0.0318393894,
-0.0088628251,
-0.0443332307,
-0.022767324,
0.0578415692,
-0.0179281477,
0.0019687295,
-0.0003372418,
0.0144276535,
-0.0140809081,
-0.0357209258,
-0.0102876658,
0.0205437429,
0.0287313852,
0.0072660623,
-0.0045791571,
-0.0103748478,
-0.0566018,
-0.0355821252,
-0.0849167407,
0.0051442808,
-0.0428302176,
0.0068763224,
0.0447482541,
0.0143098626,
-0.0016040289,
-0.0162436161,
-0.0277660061,
-0.0131558804,
-0.0082689896,
0.0437572598,
0.020269407,
0.0189424865,
0.0311497673,
-0.027434798,
0.0052139442,
-0.0180856995,
0.0369441211,
0.0001684349,
0.0217362791,
-0.0475939699,
-0.0299768131,
-0.0953436717,
0.0124343261,
-0.0068178042,
-0.0321652144,
-0.0098795379,
-0.0035973128,
0.0848998949,
0.0520299412,
0.0084461328,
-0.0098348232,
0.079916954,
-0.031350702,
-0.0282552596,
0.0363778435,
-0.0006992963,
-0.0094071832,
-0.0080212764,
-0.0073925639,
0.0076223994,
0.0626454502,
-0.0102504157,
-0.04152577,
-0.0153574394,
0.0606936775,
-0.0016890414,
-0.0342526697,
-0.0533997864,
-0.0080066221,
-0.0190269314,
0.0276928172,
-0.0203833804,
-0.0231918506,
0.0855059922,
-0.006390715,
0.0370148495,
-0.0488343388,
0.0226483867,
-0.0021942782,
0.0696375668,
-0.0228459798,
0.0503117368,
-0.0325444117,
0.033769615,
-0.0780871511,
-0.030252276,
0.02073621,
-0.0408827253,
0.0278928652,
-0.0898104534,
0.0171330068,
-0.0117298355,
-0.026887035,
-0.053357482,
-0.0373586267,
-0.0239380579,
0.0176391732,
-0.0120373117,
-0.0178815052,
-0.0150674935,
-0.001275913,
0.0696738213,
0.0470923148,
-0.0096020233,
0.0039229165,
0.0138383647,
0.0161178671,
0.0849002898,
0.0394355766,
0.0368460752,
-0.0140249478,
0.049205441,
0.0557570159,
0.0223743301,
-0.0140366117,
0.034923628,
-0.0027553905,
-0.0339913517,
-0.0700477883,
-0.0016613067,
-0.0180828013,
0.069885619,
-0.066967532,
-0.0356269851,
0.0911321789,
0.0682677105,
-0.0097684925,
-0.0093907872,
-0.0466535054,
-0.0147084128,
0.0288002305,
0.0588973947,
-0.0975722224,
-0.0184071884,
0.0188024808,
-0.0354395993,
-0.0205334611,
-0.0403490961,
-0.0201051272,
-0.0915102065,
-0.0038404933,
-0.0103884116,
-0.0330157243,
-0.0217717402,
-0.0249596443,
-0.0045450968,
0.0262267627,
-0.0041143764,
0.0586116575,
0.0203476064,
-0.0027417126,
-0.0197702087,
0.0263733827,
-0.0211247131,
0.0662816092,
0.000048107,
0.0419759415,
0.0513637699,
0.0073196068,
0.0005497003,
-0.0272856038,
0.0274388548,
0.0086471252,
-0.0136758145,
0.0056512156,
0.0204143263,
0.0072498149,
-0.0142209344,
0.002762726,
0.0081110625,
0.0526242517,
-0.0204572808,
0.0309555214,
0.0823240429,
-0.0385665707,
-0.0035653326,
0.0302105844,
-0.0232178029,
0.0130738011,
0.0847469196,
0.0251927748,
-0.0322575606,
-0.0023217292,
-0.0743752941,
-0.0319097489,
-0.0196943823,
-0.0318888612,
0.0316790156,
-0.0018137995,
0.0420469679,
-0.0882917568,
-0.049708914,
0.0341947414,
0.0096360575,
0.0202487353,
-0.0223738551,
0.032574825,
-0.0065057119,
-0.0322744437,
-0.015407552,
-0.0750360414,
0.0056917043,
-0.0274518616,
-0.010513233,
0.0434086621,
-0.006874233,
-0.019746149,
0.0040208432,
-0.0860112906,
-0.0446766913,
0.039137084,
0.0498292185,
0.0240511261,
0.0396239385,
-0.0173505209,
-0.012892697,
0.0046866098,
-0.0128165912,
-0.0217733756,
0.0305436198,
0.0182601623,
0.0081164967,
-0.0117527153,
0.0548250899,
-0.0578794256,
-0.0134618869,
0.0329287611,
0.0389865264,
-0.0369539,
-0.0354567096,
0.0202824622,
0.0031997582,
-0.001550953,
0.0275073964,
-0.0186259933,
-0.013713886,
0.0641666055,
-0.0308608469,
-0.030352829,
0.0065092822,
0.0062079504,
-0.0018181524,
-0.0229495522,
0.0064699915,
-0.0117018381,
-0.0067667789,
0.025554385,
-0.015735643,
-0.0527346358,
0.0142503092,
-0.0021489139,
0.0490716659,
-0.0087260753,
-0.0283203144,
0.02537347,
0.0088331429,
0.0393086374,
-0.0069607478,
0.0485007279,
0.0345696732,
-0.0338216051,
-0.045298323,
-0.0049386504,
-0.0948176682,
-0.0297194589,
-0.0159610156,
0.0376948453,
0.0503009036,
0.0160345379,
0.0102452049,
-0.0182850957,
-0.0475819595,
-0.0232150294,
-0.011306257,
0.0560785979,
-0.0271503758,
0.0373522267,
0.0124930115,
-0.011898852,
0.0591315739,
0.0507403798,
-0.0261833277,
0.119277142,
-0.0033808446,
-0.0039740703,
-0.0292133726,
-0.0552348234,
-0.0455158055,
0.0009597354,
-0.0195536688,
-0.0098867128,
-0.0744262263,
-0.055010546,
-0.0101878401,
0.0351258665,
-0.0200833753,
0.0015994584,
0.0064564431,
0.0446107611,
0.0148716271,
-0.0085674133,
-0.0485735759,
0.031963855,
-0.01286125,
-0.0038550005,
0.012093408,
-6.664404243e-33,
-0.0218714848,
0.0033114303,
0.0422444642,
-0.0337397605,
-0.0262392145,
-0.0085976608,
-0.0452564508,
-0.0131984772,
-0.0391351096,
0.0034314555,
-0.0219725426,
0.0209462643,
-0.0119553246,
-0.0007504818,
0.0221068338,
-0.020792935,
0.0678113624,
0.013148874,
-0.044146616,
0.0281557944,
0.0485664047,
0.010796464,
0.0737572759,
0.0181321893,
0.0565937869,
0.0069313366,
-0.0056018126,
0.0473098047,
-0.0832106099,
0.0331330448,
-0.0219370052,
-0.0034527893,
0.0009867754,
-0.0714428127,
-0.0254776347,
-0.0389794484,
-0.0316177942,
-0.0288241003,
0.0204021093,
-0.0021478967,
0.0060279518,
-0.0569027774,
0.0434187241,
0.0096210511,
0.0140991351,
-0.0259515066,
-0.0056819245,
-0.0216095727,
0.0007779238,
0.007987882,
-0.032705579,
-0.0036852178,
-0.0057850699,
-0.0185676385,
-0.080053784,
0.0264913961,
0.0358962566,
-0.0366994888,
-0.1036595553,
-0.0081287744,
0.0595059954,
0.0402591936,
0.0531414822,
-0.0075561623,
0.0144560868,
0.0404679291,
-0.0041338806,
0.0233276822,
-0.0182869826,
0.029771043,
-0.0028111038,
-0.0052406508,
0.0589175634,
0.0654943958,
0.014167781,
-0.0119147887,
-0.0635255277,
-0.0004362606,
-0.0067805462,
0.0406364091,
-0.0083897905,
0.010360417,
0.0149261933,
-0.0071285744,
-0.0659324005,
0.029443698,
-0.0476211235,
-0.0332853459,
0.0272976756,
0.0131846005,
-0.0214502215,
0.0112699382,
0.033270549,
-0.0275175627,
-0.0094598234,
0.0143794864,
-0.0316116624,
0.0252562948,
0.0011464267,
0.0296032801,
-0.0095550055,
0.0522844046,
0.0393174328,
0.0249999277,
-0.0123202996,
0.0194737148,
0.0313251689,
0.0092736408,
-0.0732578859,
0.0161576681,
-0.0413516648,
0.0318379365,
0.0052554002,
-0.0140259992,
0.0039227451,
0.0152906869,
-0.0048187468,
-0.0054004719,
0.0461941957,
0.0050530224,
-0.0239359401,
0.0209456403,
0.0061552366,
0.0321887545,
-0.0136128366,
0.0384408608,
-0.0353552848,
0.0399285294,
-0.0127637284,
-0.0275850203,
0.0015767908,
0.0261603836,
2.862e-7,
0.0367416665,
0.0595708378,
0.006033014,
-0.0175081361,
0.0194477048,
0.0318044461,
-0.0354334228,
0.0006060874,
0.0440253839,
-0.0063859983,
-0.010650672,
0.0365755633,
0.023249682,
0.0485378765,
-0.086844489,
-0.0039245472,
-0.0752172023,
-0.0244522877,
-0.0484256111,
-0.01748427,
0.0180820413,
0.0537801348,
0.0306170471,
-0.0063217627,
-0.0064727413,
-0.0259119347,
0.0758374706,
-0.0035003384,
-0.0472203493,
0.0049804985,
0.0443579853,
0.0294289421,
0.0315307081,
0.0210129693,
-0.0318538696,
-0.0139746107,
-0.0492897928,
0.0781731904,
-0.0084004449,
-0.0066232611,
-0.0287751779,
-0.000869879,
0.0117902663,
-0.0512215421,
0.0954453871,
-0.0273154061,
0.0172911342,
-0.0353235267,
-0.0076518171,
-0.0008048142,
0.0397538431,
-0.0325724222,
-0.0100604733,
0.0320013277,
-0.016773792,
0.0521388203,
0.0095942905,
-0.0355791822,
-0.0541474335,
0.0191573203,
-0.0136733437,
-0.0753062814,
-0.026255399,
-0.0604296625,
-0.0034303826,
-0.096151121,
0.0101228366,
2.425567849e-34,
0.0135044958,
0.0167451967,
0.0144615313,
0.031543985,
0.0385825261,
-0.0176296774,
-0.0049861171,
-0.0308236312,
-0.0005696297,
-0.1004488021,
-0.0265883915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14794v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14794v2 | Debiasing Made State-of-the-art: Revisiting the Simple Seed-based Weak Supervision for Text Classification | 2023-05-24T06:45:33 | 2023-10-23T11:22:58 | Chengyu Dong, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances in weakly supervised text classification mostly focus on
designing sophisticated methods to turn high-level human heuristics into
quality pseudo-labels. In this paper, we revisit the seed matching-based
method, which is arguably the simplest way to generate pseudo-labels, and show
that its power was greatly underestimated. We show that the limited performance
of seed matching is largely due to the label bias injected by the simple
seed-match rule, which prevents the classifier from learning reliable
confidence for selecting high-quality pseudo-labels. Interestingly, simply
deleting the seed words present in the matched input texts can mitigate the
label bias and help learn better confidence. Subsequently, the performance
achieved by seed matching can be improved significantly, making it on par with
or even better than the state-of-the-art. Furthermore, to handle the case when
the seed words are not made known, we propose to simply delete the word tokens
in the input text randomly with a high deletion ratio. Remarkably, seed
matching equipped with this random deletion method can often achieve even
better performance than that with seed deletion. | [
0.0604575239,
0.0183117501,
0.0063764746,
0.0073618242,
-0.0342853554,
-0.0009276927,
0.0316964909,
0.0172634739,
0.0403492972,
-0.0371941328,
-0.0298662186,
-0.0325197019,
0.008851246,
0.0284254178,
0.0221418105,
-0.0247710384,
0.0193028413,
0.018283125,
0.0328611657,
-0.0053431815,
0.0180820189,
0.0165872779,
0.008720044,
0.0129007781,
-0.050627891,
0.0013192541,
0.0167623255,
0.0149035398,
-0.0002407087,
-0.0232845079,
0.0738398656,
0.031213386,
-0.0112269409,
0.0547850579,
0.0000019599,
-0.0522811897,
-0.0269393958,
-0.0095090913,
-0.0142946299,
-0.0148698334,
0.017081568,
-0.0437293462,
0.0222251751,
0.0228908639,
-0.0026839988,
-0.0688337386,
0.0333450623,
0.096457921,
0.0141191613,
0.0610499009,
-0.0152171981,
0.0054105208,
0.0122933155,
-0.0299506765,
0.0187708195,
-0.0360110439,
0.0718926787,
-0.0612558015,
-0.0178042576,
0.0636530668,
0.0167989805,
-0.001466152,
0.0290392935,
-0.002649853,
0.0350920595,
0.0392409936,
-0.0390451849,
-0.0085588843,
-0.0165081713,
0.0533800311,
-0.0215269458,
-0.0806075931,
0.0344778374,
-0.0121173877,
0.0071787727,
-0.0256757829,
0.0063023875,
-0.0215397216,
-0.032998763,
0.0233540218,
0.0169818755,
0.0176497325,
0.0241000876,
0.0309047326,
0.0610146374,
0.0379942916,
0.0109593617,
-0.0520997085,
0.0266371276,
0.0254092813,
-0.0382144898,
-0.0501188748,
0.0072673392,
-0.0059460015,
0.0059510726,
-0.0169401169,
-0.0889758468,
-0.0320229568,
0.0054599596,
-0.0100655649,
-0.0405747965,
-0.0292348545,
-0.0201834943,
0.0363609642,
-0.0221009143,
-0.0160038322,
0.0610576347,
0.0431033373,
-0.0335418135,
0.0001373934,
-0.0398235507,
0.0070294645,
-0.0199627709,
0.0463523977,
0.0216286574,
0.0063155168,
-0.0470227823,
-0.0215230957,
-0.0298090652,
-0.0143304635,
-0.0374589711,
0.0121423323,
-0.036996074,
0.0582155585,
-0.0059158471,
-0.0263426993,
-0.0279527381,
0.0433380343,
-0.0479471833,
-0.0635028854,
-0.0107696662,
0.0271808263,
-0.0052091368,
-0.0242515672,
0.0143328086,
0.0538021103,
-0.0219995566,
-0.0754472539,
-0.0428801887,
-0.0250654127,
-0.0720881522,
-0.0004321614,
-0.0207767524,
-0.0348347053,
0.0018679466,
-0.0287165567,
-0.0195469037,
-0.0588031299,
0.0142774992,
-0.0031642118,
-0.0470042266,
0.053701207,
-0.0456464402,
-0.0245387834,
0.0461462438,
0.0212422181,
-0.0040116627,
0.0239037946,
-0.0478098579,
0.0763795078,
0.0451243781,
0.0320287086,
0.0470021628,
0.0216227528,
0.0526171327,
0.0096449098,
0.0066885091,
-0.0137461489,
0.0520906337,
0.0047979443,
0.0243667495,
0.0221758708,
-0.0148871513,
-0.0148040289,
0.0477403104,
0.0035081499,
-0.0237749778,
0.0423131064,
0.038460128,
0.0357590541,
-0.0253099855,
0.0053286045,
-0.0359159894,
-0.0119116008,
-0.0593811162,
-0.0248379335,
0.0046442514,
-0.0196266398,
-0.0522621721,
-0.0287483018,
-0.0113064256,
0.0011837875,
-0.0348302461,
-0.0045842621,
0.0502361022,
0.03313829,
0.0210232716,
0.0166989658,
0.0490756817,
0.011733871,
-0.0079121077,
-0.0462326147,
0.0159470811,
0.0187280551,
0.0255551934,
-0.0230265893,
0.0051522646,
-0.0160670821,
0.0661225617,
0.0243406203,
0.0948672742,
-0.0430224501,
-0.0001747814,
-0.0279473979,
-0.04054524,
0.0194177777,
0.022548968,
0.0037598251,
-0.0058692452,
0.0374533199,
0.0488445163,
-0.0632408634,
-0.0387862995,
0.0644631758,
0.011795233,
-0.0759430677,
0.0268867631,
0.0341615863,
0.0039681508,
-0.0095517058,
0.0030898154,
-0.0146677783,
0.021679664,
0.0299102869,
-0.0039768955,
-0.0467172526,
-0.0204101894,
-0.0548979081,
0.0081785945,
-0.0455245934,
-0.029630458,
0.0248478185,
-0.0422702469,
-0.0410184823,
-0.0088585466,
-0.0059833559,
0.0076647084,
-0.0334895439,
0.0055617709,
-0.0368916988,
-0.0090326481,
-0.0476878732,
0.068942301,
0.0451524854,
0.0347976647,
-0.0439690091,
-0.031478595,
0.022418445,
-0.0134012112,
-0.0235062316,
-0.0252942462,
-0.0363116115,
-0.0149312438,
0.0409219339,
0.025760306,
-0.0439579822,
-0.0340767689,
-0.0567630306,
-0.0097750481,
-0.0015382844,
-0.0225271434,
-0.0046954867,
-0.025598852,
0.002678144,
-0.0138298646,
-0.0569231808,
-0.0402019881,
-0.0356834754,
0.0145007502,
0.0192211233,
-0.0167260449,
0.0112433806,
0.0149529027,
0.0095665222,
-0.0441612341,
0.0338490419,
0.0351884142,
-0.0188041907,
-0.0471785963,
0.0468408912,
-0.0182605088,
-0.0179696027,
0.0123044057,
0.0164725482,
-0.0081041064,
0.0223241691,
-0.0237913597,
0.0028974537,
-0.0108103259,
0.0147058237,
0.0100343777,
0.0337223038,
-0.0348565243,
-0.008350377,
0.0022004081,
0.034803845,
-0.0119576994,
-0.032396052,
-0.0086972555,
0.0167179573,
0.0182487443,
-0.0254588295,
-0.0440163799,
0.0511815436,
0.0109321829,
-0.0220225584,
-0.0352542363,
0.0012293217,
0.0194694865,
-0.014553804,
-0.0656385869,
-0.0545708947,
0.0817019045,
-0.0134471646,
0.035544876,
-0.0448825769,
-0.0192203838,
-0.0012696197,
0.0212229397,
-0.0217936616,
0.0189579576,
0.048665788,
0.0056686206,
-0.0335514508,
-0.0279836245,
-0.0172148105,
-0.0038998034,
0.0020301153,
-0.0153795416,
0.0269241389,
-0.0078490544,
-0.0450899974,
-0.0347258374,
-0.1102517918,
0.0026994084,
0.0005457762,
0.0512885153,
0.0187541265,
-0.0526289083,
-0.0036491756,
-0.0107558714,
0.038366843,
-0.0071309633,
-0.0167342909,
0.0144782709,
0.0292995684,
0.0182530042,
-0.0615484342,
-0.0120651582,
-0.0238182768,
-0.003477993,
0.0325300768,
0.0803849548,
0.0020890327,
-0.0108036697,
-0.0038194861,
0.0038603712,
0.006767693,
-0.016121421,
0.0020335405,
0.037090119,
0.0069939797,
-0.037684273,
0.1025118828,
0.0216195844,
-0.0529968105,
0.014504265,
0.0273751337,
0.0488708764,
0.032131359,
0.0186704155,
-0.022486046,
-0.0496123135,
0.0083078155,
0.026903348,
-0.0299896821,
-0.0404716693,
0.0065578758,
-0.0972934663,
-0.0195000432,
-0.0207017884,
-0.0300894231,
0.0006370037,
-0.0369335636,
0.0354118347,
-0.0059047956,
-0.0558708981,
-0.0300791543,
0.0103952866,
0.0245751515,
0.031960994,
-0.0034504402,
-0.0680601075,
0.0105874622,
-0.0568511225,
0.040526107,
0.0365678594,
0.0569264963,
-0.0345553458,
-0.0337166339,
0.0292842519,
-0.0348993056,
-0.0290368404,
-0.0136473924,
0.0910901353,
-0.0466539264,
-0.0312229227,
-0.0162817594,
0.0500845164,
-0.0152090816,
-0.0076829409,
0.0085661216,
0.0409585349,
-0.0110659115,
-0.0328097902,
-0.0031465366,
-0.0424206257,
0.0318212621,
0.0829572752,
0.0088425996,
-0.0566062331,
0.0019817194,
-0.0043475884,
0.0135711087,
0.0228054188,
-0.0070612468,
0.0014029177,
-0.0221526343,
0.0151923038,
-0.066304639,
-0.0380632132,
0.0508745238,
0.0806189254,
0.0212254673,
0.0019481205,
-0.0377358571,
-0.0309163444,
-0.0053381654,
0.0186320115,
-0.0380571261,
0.0175366811,
-0.0174218137,
-0.0285431501,
0.0178232174,
-0.0440077521,
-0.0210081041,
0.0495993234,
-0.0224220417,
-0.0436053984,
0.0181106627,
0.0256441813,
0.0165854543,
0.0289164763,
-0.028931655,
-0.032652773,
0.0894938558,
0.0663567111,
0.0387387089,
0.0119711822,
0.0218649395,
-0.0445624217,
-0.0084524592,
0.0386365764,
-0.0405097306,
0.0594099574,
0.0958900452,
-0.0115512712,
0.0250889715,
-0.0420303568,
0.00848513,
0.00488667,
0.0902504325,
-0.03167063,
0.0249002539,
-0.0222816989,
0.0051293084,
0.0250166189,
-0.027791176,
0.0324371979,
0.0167714488,
0.0227993391,
0.04186951,
-0.0377464779,
0.0045321323,
-0.019855909,
0.0520569757,
-0.0157096609,
-0.0557999462,
0.0221570507,
0.0129016247,
-0.0218258072,
0.0052232328,
0.0003868746,
0.0290745776,
0.0503065623,
0.0418084189,
-0.0219977181,
-0.0114063686,
0.0451549739,
0.0093630077,
-0.0284335092,
-0.0429840833,
-0.0818227157,
0.0194097552,
-0.0809151977,
0.0355561525,
0.0197013337,
-0.0741760209,
-0.0460701287,
-0.0229456909,
-0.021233229,
-0.015337375,
-0.0326820761,
0.0114653176,
-0.0313528739,
-0.0020106505,
0.0103713525,
-0.0407291874,
0.0534127951,
0.0646205246,
0.0715193674,
0.058431115,
-0.0101585612,
-0.036121171,
-0.0240357351,
0.0375495479,
0.0447021388,
0.0266152173,
-0.0018833998,
-0.0287038367,
-0.0132823009,
-0.0394324921,
0.0796445161,
-0.032122992,
0.0340757854,
0.0416782647,
0.0447618216,
0.0473942719,
-0.0009213009,
-0.00039799,
-0.018306287,
-0.0179268774,
0.0334625803,
-0.0226371605,
-0.029734537,
-6.20873194e-33,
0.0310614388,
-0.0148322964,
-0.0386684425,
-0.0182099398,
0.0289552901,
0.0203204844,
0.0037465347,
-0.0604020022,
0.0091529554,
0.0439550467,
-0.0013186592,
0.0011061251,
0.0102832885,
0.0407817326,
-0.0139490236,
-0.0257313084,
0.0704114139,
0.0064016939,
-0.0092814649,
0.0250109453,
0.0185965002,
0.0575556308,
0.014300311,
-0.0839994177,
0.0386583544,
-0.0294501483,
-0.0187484063,
0.0055725784,
0.0156061631,
0.0391797796,
-0.00289348,
0.0312046017,
0.0265662875,
-0.0039641089,
0.0270668045,
0.0443991758,
-0.0503407978,
-0.0434145629,
-0.0329115391,
-0.0294700544,
-0.0090308106,
-0.0129196867,
-0.0008348726,
-0.0044446131,
-0.0200550146,
0.0440137945,
0.0580961928,
-0.0209270939,
-0.0329284742,
-0.0736915693,
-0.0175701659,
0.0155666806,
0.0052191806,
0.0038717187,
0.0020032749,
0.0144935222,
0.0004630347,
-0.0036213559,
-0.0147388568,
-0.0042951428,
0.0222135261,
0.0206390973,
-0.0132312281,
0.0404801518,
-0.0064568487,
0.0661692098,
0.0093495911,
0.0530290343,
0.0672033057,
-0.0484879203,
0.0215569157,
-0.0015843213,
0.037265595,
0.0824801177,
0.0613045208,
-0.0299184844,
-0.068010956,
0.0467888229,
0.0062812315,
-0.0110993423,
-0.0024197972,
0.0096981013,
-0.0755406916,
-0.0272317585,
-0.0470548198,
-0.0530447885,
-0.0374181941,
-0.0238200426,
0.01277084,
0.0299985111,
-0.0487853475,
0.0562376231,
-0.0137372985,
-0.0341316462,
-0.0540904142,
-0.0045747235,
0.006086641,
-0.0074632321,
-0.0087425103,
-0.0150861582,
-0.0742780492,
-0.0864790976,
0.0598579645,
0.0371814631,
0.0162530411,
-0.0103643192,
0.0994305387,
-0.0225760974,
-0.0671924427,
-0.0054151234,
-0.0009966136,
0.0230264291,
0.0395813137,
0.0063157869,
0.0246646143,
0.0201687943,
0.0177737698,
0.0120203504,
0.0637403354,
0.004310871,
0.0041877148,
-0.0115898829,
-0.0286541544,
-0.0178276915,
-0.006752321,
-0.0110803507,
0.0196175687,
0.0046742759,
-0.0101017533,
-0.0933432803,
0.019987734,
-0.0309548117,
2.695e-7,
-0.0275811907,
0.0411632657,
0.0019430333,
-0.1021715179,
0.0049362001,
0.0465848297,
-0.0120597398,
0.0572534613,
-0.0576797575,
-0.0519567616,
0.0372825675,
-0.0224218685,
0.0593244173,
0.0201635044,
-0.1128166467,
0.0387092754,
-0.0854631811,
0.0141558498,
-0.0447113961,
0.0123995012,
0.0559579656,
0.1036351696,
0.0383986346,
-0.0433006361,
-0.0174947884,
-0.0427985415,
0.0296793059,
0.0204088967,
0.0233888216,
0.0120824734,
0.05391635,
0.0080362651,
0.0108442958,
0.0626932606,
-0.0640905201,
0.0047026859,
0.0316307507,
0.0254439693,
-0.0100455433,
0.012851052,
0.0004725432,
0.0443403013,
0.0570099168,
0.0118628955,
0.0813236982,
-0.037177965,
-0.006070083,
-0.0397375673,
-0.0140485242,
-0.0339407027,
0.0057501239,
-0.0431450792,
0.0140003748,
0.0436506011,
-0.0032314709,
0.0253114086,
-0.0380897075,
-0.0860493407,
-0.0063713761,
-0.0005125717,
-0.0129349697,
0.0077578402,
0.0050421278,
0.0717948675,
0.0667974427,
-0.0271563493,
0.0338452756,
2.299289679e-34,
0.0132819833,
-0.0001600042,
-0.0334261991,
-0.064577207,
0.0033978301,
0.0088134678,
0.0019312756,
0.0137813408,
0.0002284055,
-0.0172263924,
0.0172893777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14793v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14793v2 | Faithful Low-Resource Data-to-Text Generation through Cycle Training | 2023-05-24T06:44:42 | 2023-07-11T16:15:00 | Zhuoer Wang, Marcus Collins, Nikhita Vedula, Simone Filice, Shervin Malmasi, Oleg Rokhlenko | cs.CL | cs.CL | Methods to generate text from structured data have advanced significantly in
recent years, primarily due to fine-tuning of pre-trained language models on
large datasets. However, such models can fail to produce output faithful to the
input data, particularly on out-of-domain data. Sufficient annotated data is
often not available for specific domains, leading us to seek an unsupervised
approach to improve the faithfulness of output text. Since the problem is
fundamentally one of consistency between the representations of the structured
data and text, we evaluate the effectiveness of cycle training in this work.
Cycle training uses two models which are inverses of each other: one that
generates text from structured data, and one which generates the structured
data from natural language text. We show that cycle training, when initialized
with a small amount of supervised data (100 samples in our case), achieves
nearly the same performance as fully supervised approaches for the data-to-text
generation task on the WebNLG, E2E, WTQ, and WSQL datasets. We perform
extensive empirical analysis with automated evaluation metrics and a newly
designed human evaluation schema to reveal different cycle training strategies'
effectiveness of reducing various types of generation errors. Our code is
publicly available at https://github.com/Edillower/CycleNLG. | [
0.0161199179,
0.0805497617,
0.0169421788,
0.0121377446,
-0.0215731077,
0.0047927056,
-0.0051664948,
0.0083970297,
0.036033567,
-0.066654712,
-0.0282216407,
-0.0166330263,
-0.0094828578,
0.0379344784,
0.0529991202,
-0.0526661426,
0.0243182778,
0.0052168234,
-0.048528187,
0.0193167012,
0.0328495279,
0.0253052711,
0.0040591927,
0.0056164577,
-0.0096151941,
-0.0167535674,
-0.0154441232,
0.0261137653,
0.0218639094,
-0.0427567214,
0.0150116067,
0.0305804368,
0.0141642299,
0.0194583926,
0.0000019545,
-0.0262255948,
-0.0284259319,
0.0135159492,
0.0159117561,
-0.0005777947,
0.0609710813,
-0.0325939991,
0.0003182035,
0.0438425951,
-0.0280022267,
-0.0136793759,
0.0317152366,
0.0302896947,
0.0866242945,
0.0996550918,
-0.011404315,
-0.0065702898,
0.010542227,
-0.0353949293,
0.0077228337,
0.01702548,
-0.0127019919,
0.0151888439,
-0.0157440081,
0.0178304911,
0.0057003358,
-0.0021449823,
-0.0074303891,
0.0140795624,
0.0039210687,
0.0499353334,
-0.0343682282,
0.0178615991,
0.0110008055,
0.0708643124,
-0.010397573,
-0.0419669151,
0.0302094668,
-0.0075375126,
-0.0295631066,
-0.0228814539,
0.0075377584,
0.0451540239,
0.0043506017,
0.0259175226,
-0.008716532,
0.021114232,
0.0144148264,
-0.0134715587,
-0.0265030041,
0.019341737,
0.0014119749,
-0.0224000309,
-0.0048765619,
0.0164422523,
0.0286648534,
-0.0571409613,
0.0006862987,
0.0494659171,
-0.0241775159,
0.0259853788,
-0.08872886,
-0.0221260916,
0.0032597668,
-0.0068610986,
0.0281221867,
0.0196005348,
0.0043410105,
-0.0113365753,
-0.0470577218,
0.0141179468,
0.0240006018,
-0.0015083969,
-0.0234308951,
0.0242257733,
-0.0758357272,
0.0110651413,
-0.0523851216,
0.0180449374,
-0.0393873639,
-0.0208919477,
-0.0365637727,
0.0146814557,
0.0090457387,
0.0368638486,
0.031010313,
0.0075661265,
-0.0591240153,
-0.0028478908,
-0.005168593,
0.0025480706,
-0.010552994,
0.0028925475,
0.0412824303,
-0.0693356842,
0.0172129665,
0.0248214491,
0.0224285461,
-0.0064932904,
0.0013898916,
0.0871995687,
-0.017706614,
0.0118222004,
-0.0906607881,
-0.0788356885,
0.00070826,
-0.0681689084,
-0.0112547958,
-0.0758977085,
0.0374933295,
0.0219058022,
-0.0148781855,
-0.0291229822,
0.0336835124,
0.0194609147,
-0.012536509,
0.0594816916,
-0.0844133496,
-0.0100731635,
-0.0058584209,
-0.0201001037,
0.0277383812,
0.0397423431,
0.053353779,
0.0311752409,
0.004720048,
0.0112041123,
-0.0113928709,
0.0178087559,
0.046192199,
0.0205027033,
-0.0065442119,
0.0064073405,
-0.0449298359,
0.0285241995,
0.0737119019,
0.0706850439,
-0.026725024,
0.060279917,
0.0527968854,
-0.0287336279,
0.0310713965,
0.048924759,
0.0760317072,
0.0304274373,
0.0087146843,
0.0243981294,
-0.0489807725,
-0.0018518502,
0.0149494102,
0.0558756031,
0.0193931796,
-0.0081608538,
-0.0288480688,
-0.0413364172,
0.0125507228,
-0.0221935585,
0.0068711448,
-0.0321142897,
0.0274559464,
0.0757147297,
-0.0628976151,
0.0329907835,
0.0485702679,
-0.0484939516,
0.0496157259,
0.0120670963,
-0.0124694137,
0.0613202825,
0.0131531106,
0.0151407719,
-0.009497663,
-0.0162235815,
0.0162217095,
0.0388466828,
0.021267876,
-0.0120966379,
-0.0248693358,
-0.043550875,
-0.0372659266,
0.0069807451,
0.0124107543,
-0.0061588963,
0.0074024661,
0.0061246338,
0.0577493943,
-0.0749570802,
-0.0776051506,
0.046562463,
-0.0198976155,
-0.0377799049,
0.0111244973,
-0.0065796399,
-0.0105805574,
0.0126800705,
-0.0364670828,
0.0520494543,
0.0160283875,
-0.0218455512,
-0.0187785849,
0.0148055237,
-0.0380202197,
-0.0538964905,
0.0038098539,
-0.0652952641,
0.0173000563,
0.001694735,
-0.0599409156,
-0.0514585599,
-0.0182852857,
-0.054321751,
0.000643186,
-0.0449986123,
-0.0094021894,
0.0688054189,
-0.0190810561,
-0.0359708592,
0.0641352609,
0.0138842147,
0.0230944492,
0.0212437809,
-0.0058999402,
0.0196379889,
-0.0287597813,
0.0371457562,
-0.0133066485,
0.0028697399,
0.0279562287,
0.015279864,
0.0487159044,
-0.0682532862,
0.0014124735,
-0.0580078177,
0.0029797389,
-0.0102523901,
0.0559884161,
0.0621536784,
0.0093937088,
0.018020086,
-0.0265326574,
-0.0777089,
0.0145968245,
0.0256587025,
-0.000635824,
0.0620985292,
0.0092112487,
-0.0048834942,
-0.0295613073,
-0.0007505284,
-0.01854272,
0.0271294378,
0.0178545974,
-0.0036797191,
-0.078874968,
0.0561726652,
-0.0247697439,
0.0113708312,
0.0167565346,
-0.0166690145,
-0.0116422847,
0.0295231845,
0.0535832308,
-0.0011644039,
0.0420582667,
-0.0192515384,
0.0082709054,
0.0221797805,
-0.0666050911,
-0.021795122,
-0.031165069,
-0.0197112728,
-0.0027303563,
-0.0516628772,
0.051646553,
0.0374286771,
0.0277418904,
0.0044626016,
-0.0229209494,
-0.0028070363,
-0.0109361848,
0.0076558641,
-0.0151061052,
0.0252504516,
-0.001464095,
0.0151323965,
-0.0125186397,
-0.0355294086,
0.0513843559,
-0.037025623,
0.0206708219,
-0.0380418673,
0.0082142781,
-0.0290300958,
0.0103626819,
0.0190980881,
0.0642669648,
0.0237366725,
-0.0316975899,
-0.0689708814,
0.009462053,
0.0340957865,
-0.0161455683,
0.0255543906,
-0.0126528153,
0.0165172555,
-0.0347875245,
-0.0232553817,
-0.0669208691,
0.0147862509,
0.0004253175,
0.013819431,
0.0452378951,
0.0035320132,
-0.0227085836,
-0.0126621015,
-0.0049982104,
0.0287007093,
-0.0043050926,
-0.0396640822,
-0.0198657513,
0.0685472712,
0.0451055579,
-0.0124887656,
-0.0080040386,
-0.0355520844,
-0.0192346126,
0.0501732416,
0.0155283948,
0.019607313,
-0.0210670363,
-0.0116350185,
-0.0057555437,
-0.0453804173,
-0.0282987617,
0.0438544452,
0.0332414135,
-0.0471536517,
-0.0553546436,
0.1037393957,
0.0123819401,
-0.0151656084,
0.0192695763,
0.0279019102,
0.0542343296,
0.015379291,
0.0322918259,
-0.0916582048,
-0.0118813692,
-0.0191075355,
0.0729306266,
0.0288646538,
-0.033269044,
-0.0115764793,
-0.136771813,
0.0160607565,
0.0271744318,
-0.0471879393,
-0.0373430029,
-0.0390966125,
-0.0447612926,
-0.0139154922,
-0.0063617486,
0.0386559777,
-0.0392055437,
0.0420741625,
0.0467958674,
-0.0355286002,
-0.0520944782,
-0.0238331482,
-0.0480595157,
0.0372809842,
0.0811931938,
0.0205551945,
0.0172152482,
-0.0158036854,
0.0213182904,
-0.0084847631,
-0.0038248149,
-0.006822201,
0.061526902,
-0.0085561387,
-0.0144249154,
0.0095605841,
0.0461322889,
-0.0414009616,
0.0232324675,
0.0072378833,
0.0282706898,
-0.0064875446,
-0.0025473381,
-0.0084048398,
-0.0073988391,
0.0553762317,
0.0554779172,
0.0357183814,
-0.0199265648,
-0.0585872643,
-0.0307278316,
0.0335511602,
-0.0846535638,
-0.0379220471,
0.040062841,
-0.0338970013,
0.0151562523,
-0.1046000943,
-0.0644326136,
0.0201785937,
0.0537235849,
0.0038938457,
-0.0010352642,
0.0245297384,
-0.0243775155,
-0.0684503913,
-0.0015020171,
-0.0693907812,
0.0105302669,
-0.0481922701,
-0.063054271,
-0.0193204395,
-0.05208157,
-0.0064679915,
0.0136446357,
-0.0837552994,
-0.0182975773,
-0.0226275939,
0.0329969861,
0.0169362742,
0.0604891144,
0.0022358305,
0.0026049295,
0.0162652712,
0.07187213,
-0.0700850412,
-0.0397862159,
0.0180664696,
0.0430739373,
-0.016243916,
0.0303896256,
-0.0449028425,
0.0303769801,
0.0074443971,
0.0625948757,
0.0113194082,
-0.0087002171,
0.0692516118,
0.0261837319,
0.0099045886,
-0.0408403799,
-0.0163845774,
-0.0118089467,
-0.0266258754,
-0.028094979,
-0.0481777638,
-0.0645668805,
0.0469623208,
0.014629242,
0.0285665337,
0.0163515732,
0.0026925821,
-0.0193766989,
0.0463900305,
-0.0303059369,
-0.0154337008,
0.0051832818,
0.0293708015,
0.0379084162,
-0.012092053,
-0.0348730981,
-0.0083862571,
0.0099220406,
0.0309610125,
-0.0313996524,
0.0204268526,
0.0456831232,
0.0284933858,
-0.0282156263,
0.0101151466,
-0.0156869236,
0.0287385359,
-0.085755527,
-0.0394272767,
0.0341777951,
0.0045094872,
0.0660655126,
-0.0475389548,
0.0119985417,
-0.0332025215,
0.0613799021,
0.009752756,
-0.0092938067,
0.0000726138,
-0.0165476706,
-0.03095535,
-0.0307555608,
0.1110376939,
0.0570110157,
0.0288532786,
-0.0044948631,
-0.0064251237,
-0.0633296371,
-0.0099172276,
-0.0116526568,
-0.0003340681,
-0.0078049018,
-0.0498402491,
-0.0235537384,
-0.0738555714,
0.0067174467,
0.0284178816,
0.0262788385,
0.0253756959,
0.0601837151,
0.0325651504,
-0.0019133822,
0.0190499667,
-0.0560351871,
0.0291003734,
0.0294804554,
-0.0446176939,
-0.0402941555,
-5.906591688e-33,
-0.044494167,
-0.0474944524,
0.0311728306,
-0.0240530819,
-0.0221674107,
0.0036395031,
-0.0491171032,
-0.0156031158,
0.0206427574,
0.0153273707,
-0.0027628532,
-0.0341707282,
0.0226578806,
0.0443202853,
-0.0013772763,
0.0096534612,
0.0626357943,
-0.0107325613,
-0.0458904989,
0.0514155962,
0.0361487232,
0.0463584512,
0.059004724,
-0.0991166383,
0.0120734954,
-0.0291069187,
-0.0381346866,
-0.0196335204,
0.0560106337,
0.019655522,
-0.0103248525,
0.0334401354,
0.011385127,
-0.0146679208,
-0.0414033979,
-0.0240166523,
-0.1129776612,
-0.008725442,
-0.0125642708,
-0.0034852978,
-0.0574002936,
-0.0183718167,
0.0435797721,
-0.0499646403,
-0.0097155469,
-0.0102856066,
0.0411028415,
-0.0369269773,
0.0001971808,
-0.0866382644,
-0.0765915886,
0.0252510905,
0.0271089952,
-0.0131687345,
-0.0194875114,
0.0667846128,
-0.0284809191,
0.0066132392,
-0.0645894557,
0.0366787463,
-0.0083721904,
0.0644980446,
0.0448873825,
0.0217468776,
0.0033776017,
0.038184166,
0.0388805903,
0.0130789476,
-0.0159874707,
0.075302422,
0.0037465901,
0.0376936384,
0.01697612,
0.0664868504,
0.0182733908,
-0.0138680143,
-0.0573842153,
0.0622291937,
-0.056268312,
-0.0214830376,
-0.0165856294,
-0.0181888342,
-0.0272076,
-0.0180355739,
-0.0249391142,
-0.0216262508,
-0.0125463614,
-0.0354339145,
0.0337679982,
0.0453436896,
-0.0323237218,
-0.0152918836,
0.0038695412,
-0.0276024193,
-0.0630432367,
0.0036501405,
-0.0322445258,
-0.0197732057,
-0.0198890641,
-0.0141790044,
-0.0536241271,
-0.060934823,
0.035232529,
0.0317379162,
0.0109273084,
0.0095511451,
0.0666449741,
0.0350741632,
-0.0699902922,
0.0263931435,
-0.0416542664,
0.0419422835,
0.0070531447,
0.0008428356,
0.0290625766,
-0.0529513843,
-0.0176096223,
0.0387826934,
0.0010196047,
-0.0443908423,
0.0029533522,
0.0118329618,
0.0197855942,
0.0486047342,
-0.0212677214,
0.0067301458,
-0.0333924443,
-0.0020256231,
0.0309437681,
-0.0358319581,
-0.0111887408,
0.0036601969,
2.553e-7,
0.0381960087,
0.0283828676,
0.045034118,
0.0426621512,
0.0146526778,
0.011829054,
-0.0149351517,
0.0511092916,
-0.0054451907,
-0.0085995914,
0.0135402847,
-0.0278359782,
0.0466655083,
0.0182001144,
-0.0315778404,
-0.0059794849,
-0.041660402,
-0.0046177278,
-0.0370602831,
-0.0071452921,
0.0716991723,
0.0451406352,
-0.0333964452,
0.0028409311,
0.0551815256,
-0.0132918125,
0.0587152652,
0.0077570034,
-0.0068666255,
0.0273016021,
0.0258855578,
-0.0022528218,
-0.0112523157,
-0.0121822897,
-0.0489918739,
-0.0401916392,
0.0037678205,
0.0418547317,
0.0359368064,
0.0058508157,
0.0155940056,
-0.0423578545,
0.024022229,
-0.0302040726,
0.0299359094,
-0.0537430793,
-0.0055456688,
0.0275716912,
-0.0611246414,
0.0149838775,
-0.0293528885,
-0.0121538518,
-0.0344223902,
0.0201869532,
0.0439721458,
0.0405959971,
-0.0253399666,
-0.0096034836,
-0.0470248312,
-0.0159561522,
-0.0317724086,
-0.0259992797,
-0.0256271735,
0.0328817368,
0.0134347696,
-0.0374361016,
-0.0183122046,
2.639008924e-34,
0.0073417723,
-0.0082330247,
0.005118852,
-0.0191620681,
0.0153469974,
-0.0125653418,
0.0527421758,
-0.0023429852,
0.0065724547,
-0.0215811729,
-0.0385595113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14791v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14791v2 | Prompting Large Language Models for Counterfactual Generation: An Empirical Study | 2023-05-24T06:44:32 | 2024-02-23T07:02:09 | Yongqi Li, Mayi Xu, Xin Miao, Shen Zhou, Tieyun Qian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have made remarkable progress in a wide range of
natural language understanding and generation tasks. However, their ability to
generate counterfactuals has not been examined systematically. To bridge this
gap, we present a comprehensive evaluation framework on various types of NLU
tasks, which covers all key factors in determining LLMs' capability of
generating counterfactuals. Based on this framework, we 1) investigate the
strengths and weaknesses of LLMs as the counterfactual generator, and 2)
disclose the factors that affect LLMs when generating counterfactuals,
including both the intrinsic properties of LLMs and prompt designing. The
results show that, though LLMs are promising in most cases, they face
challenges in complex tasks like RE since they are bounded by task-specific
performance, entity constraints, and inherent selection bias. We also find that
alignment techniques, e.g., instruction-tuning and reinforcement learning from
human feedback, may potentially enhance the counterfactual generation ability
of LLMs. On the contrary, simply increasing the parameter size does not yield
the desired improvements. Besides, from the perspective of prompt designing,
task guidelines unsurprisingly play an important role. However, the
chain-of-thought approach does not always help due to inconsistency issues. | [
0.0882270038,
0.0219724309,
-0.0344500355,
0.0392875671,
-0.0780619234,
0.0051680417,
0.0173715279,
-0.0513038971,
0.028739024,
-0.0683562458,
0.0068993834,
-0.0365568809,
-0.0336427838,
0.0468196161,
0.0252114739,
-0.015563583,
0.0488212593,
-0.0398585424,
0.0196554679,
-0.0291562844,
-0.0215030797,
0.023708066,
-0.0201975126,
0.0165529512,
0.0118382983,
-0.0056974329,
-0.0089841494,
0.0339123979,
0.0180036724,
-0.0509761721,
0.0199521668,
0.0248766784,
0.0184685979,
0.0511471927,
0.0000022234,
-0.0738078207,
-0.014003884,
-0.0100219669,
-0.0598101653,
-0.0074473354,
0.0033263001,
-0.0171004944,
-0.0143035231,
-0.0067368066,
-0.0440161452,
0.0492347069,
0.0343440063,
0.0460739695,
0.052039206,
0.0812158957,
-0.0062873769,
-0.0034319186,
-0.0166100431,
-0.0311266612,
-0.0082381722,
-0.0329999551,
0.0059562288,
-0.0029310712,
0.0066780187,
0.0131649878,
-0.0145209543,
0.0218607858,
0.039730221,
-0.0108586373,
-0.0187581629,
0.0178870037,
0.0085804146,
-0.0199713726,
-0.0315907672,
0.0489196703,
0.0415837914,
-0.0291605666,
-0.023224717,
-0.03743634,
0.0294154175,
0.0301190522,
-0.0269853976,
0.0318627991,
-0.0192162544,
0.0000029787,
0.0178090166,
0.0332780443,
0.0276708193,
0.028610358,
-0.000837991,
0.0420201346,
0.0354327336,
-0.0514235906,
-0.0227862075,
0.0194146037,
-0.0284170564,
-0.0742970929,
-0.0085341837,
0.0257772021,
-0.0759897381,
0.0044969483,
-0.0343604349,
-0.0257118065,
0.039832294,
-0.0566475317,
0.029614754,
0.0136062326,
0.0036895683,
0.0389002301,
-0.0105716093,
0.0478813127,
-0.0506873913,
-0.0240902193,
-0.0157497432,
-0.0029526551,
-0.0027690714,
-0.0404702574,
-0.0267549008,
0.0157408733,
-0.0701706037,
0.0174239688,
-0.0072573693,
0.0135351066,
-0.0382916033,
0.0325978659,
-0.009193806,
0.0413101129,
-0.046817705,
-0.0448120572,
-0.0587072037,
0.0153198503,
-0.0384472348,
0.0267358366,
0.0026879902,
-0.0492854193,
-0.004948718,
0.0153005328,
-0.0446937382,
-0.0636966377,
-0.0041364874,
0.0907436907,
-0.0020235016,
0.0235387478,
-0.0239165332,
-0.044603087,
-0.0302345473,
-0.0977886245,
0.0112715699,
-0.0525654331,
-0.0087162983,
0.0165023506,
-0.011060575,
-0.0154318977,
0.0273177251,
0.0002930387,
-0.0042889458,
0.0475986563,
-0.0110596512,
-0.0082073733,
0.0294701513,
-0.0145008648,
-0.0184727106,
0.0642650798,
0.022526551,
0.0000354205,
0.0124871619,
0.0151319336,
-0.0072053457,
-0.0124887358,
0.016905576,
-0.0064468505,
-0.048621688,
0.0309271477,
0.0003667936,
0.0263178926,
0.0391678624,
0.038253773,
-0.0114923753,
-0.0301590711,
0.0507584475,
-0.0508563966,
-0.0251219701,
0.0253226496,
0.0666386262,
0.0127928648,
-0.056183625,
0.0580878891,
-0.0326320678,
0.0436393842,
-0.0535488985,
0.0226660036,
-0.0070673688,
0.0378332883,
-0.0146622593,
-0.0450618081,
-0.0008603582,
0.0210983586,
0.0131011512,
0.0185671169,
0.0423854813,
0.0543669574,
-0.0539721921,
-0.0158183314,
0.0028719741,
-0.0297420435,
0.0037494327,
-0.0430250019,
0.0049259057,
0.0726777092,
0.0571882091,
-0.0295044091,
-0.0320436694,
0.0072827018,
-0.048192326,
0.0718473718,
0.086216487,
0.0053906064,
-0.034142077,
-0.0252239984,
0.0014378777,
-0.0765313208,
0.03573744,
0.0314937383,
0.000993904,
0.0014940394,
0.0227285624,
0.0261158235,
0.0012095781,
0.0287291575,
-0.0262590107,
-0.0133235641,
0.0101311039,
0.0127314739,
0.0064644651,
0.0303090699,
-0.0053036995,
0.0381312855,
0.03010289,
-0.0206623245,
-0.0230536945,
0.0268848073,
-0.0316134579,
-0.0857031792,
-0.003057057,
-0.0311690867,
-0.0379827507,
0.0343705602,
-0.0177204125,
-0.0489928238,
0.0479934998,
-0.0287370682,
0.0789001659,
-0.0291592162,
0.029729886,
0.0321829692,
-0.0055454336,
-0.0439389311,
0.0701194778,
0.0037364969,
-0.0008328781,
0.0416673385,
0.00773384,
0.0266608186,
-0.0548709482,
-0.0067962073,
-0.0040826495,
0.0059141149,
-0.0344650559,
0.0353120789,
0.0041396269,
-0.0207259897,
-0.022917252,
-0.0622935854,
0.00113375,
-0.0324398652,
0.0000713349,
0.0296631958,
-0.0082969395,
-0.0051363916,
-0.0356220044,
0.0007029873,
-0.0128713865,
0.0258216057,
0.0266966391,
0.0425471477,
0.0100034205,
-0.0243465081,
-0.038805414,
0.0017843511,
-0.0414184183,
0.0569084771,
0.0408037119,
-0.0031834801,
-0.0160991419,
0.0303299576,
-0.032374002,
0.0158359781,
-0.000685297,
-0.0110850707,
0.0225264356,
0.0263235457,
0.0769112408,
0.0166381598,
0.0087250145,
0.0114885056,
0.0552895926,
-0.0428727791,
-0.0358768404,
0.0242346302,
-0.0177885145,
-0.0103194797,
-0.0162656642,
-0.0454888046,
-0.0178017151,
0.0360627845,
0.041125644,
-0.0077071036,
-0.0649318174,
0.0327071957,
0.000654413,
-0.0416689105,
0.0034159261,
-0.0733116567,
-0.0153294131,
0.0553412698,
-0.0196780749,
-0.015793534,
0.0989818871,
-0.005240568,
0.0261106063,
-0.0509954132,
0.0167850424,
-0.035005115,
0.0649229363,
-0.0017838565,
0.0139924595,
0.0322583914,
0.0209780298,
-0.0368259698,
0.0107713062,
0.0251645911,
0.0076909121,
0.0083564501,
-0.0886377692,
0.0099235121,
-0.0163354129,
-0.0448475406,
-0.0610555187,
-0.0708356425,
-0.0127995266,
0.0069100442,
0.0117023112,
0.017154038,
-0.0244384129,
0.0432370566,
0.0002800955,
0.0172948427,
-0.0027577882,
0.0020047296,
-0.0219064485,
0.0054942127,
0.0619975887,
0.0441438705,
0.0559041649,
-0.0198675841,
0.0363399237,
0.0064488752,
0.0030888345,
-0.021782646,
-0.008739897,
0.0074843732,
-0.0164438654,
-0.0166504849,
-0.0103346715,
0.0238488894,
0.0359266102,
-0.0519697331,
-0.0228827298,
0.0898751318,
0.0557630584,
-0.0010002039,
0.0181303658,
-0.0084754378,
0.0243051499,
0.0361936167,
-0.0103569608,
-0.0654409081,
-0.0211577155,
-0.002031429,
-0.0389687307,
-0.0654651299,
-0.027571829,
-0.0379354954,
-0.1545474678,
0.0512362048,
0.0036294789,
-0.0026741643,
-0.0379953347,
0.0004870131,
-0.0166888032,
0.0202047359,
-0.0209309105,
0.0226565152,
0.0013520085,
0.0023982821,
-0.0147823989,
-0.0047132666,
-0.0251854882,
0.0053200498,
-0.0200218391,
0.0475181863,
0.076358296,
0.0017068618,
0.026418535,
0.0201072469,
0.0155923534,
-0.031463813,
0.0244586952,
-0.0092668813,
0.0271900184,
0.0025097048,
0.0103261825,
-0.0611550137,
0.0073770531,
-0.0025070056,
-0.0434917808,
0.0345137604,
0.0770377517,
-0.0442757495,
-0.0134255895,
-0.0630215779,
0.0222104378,
0.0284111183,
0.0921572298,
0.0145653067,
-0.0569394305,
-0.0411517657,
0.0017740278,
-0.0124774631,
-0.0537616499,
0.0202075876,
-0.025623776,
0.0444569811,
0.0161614027,
-0.0657630265,
-0.0686610863,
-0.0153664332,
0.0100639192,
0.0073429984,
-0.0129801631,
-0.0085704466,
-0.0201925971,
-0.0209721513,
-0.0057666758,
-0.0153815504,
0.0437360108,
0.012779586,
-0.0170610715,
0.0145899635,
-0.0468584634,
-0.0147294486,
0.0171771422,
-0.0774637312,
-0.0663816482,
-0.0008922302,
0.0289434493,
0.0287910812,
0.0453602672,
-0.0080473553,
-0.0310456064,
-0.0250325259,
0.0434241667,
-0.0513386168,
0.0215995386,
0.0221515205,
0.0447411016,
-0.0035511397,
0.0520140454,
-0.0298014749,
-0.0125053162,
0.0159565266,
0.0775399432,
0.0024085538,
-0.0386368372,
0.0552165769,
-0.0126180006,
0.0101473695,
-0.0397180133,
0.0017062529,
-0.0288419742,
0.0414069034,
-0.0616263896,
-0.0614246614,
-0.005382021,
-0.0069039385,
0.0053418288,
-0.006783016,
-0.0119950725,
-0.0106213512,
-0.0459577292,
0.0557861477,
-0.0358722024,
0.0162881371,
0.0414357297,
0.0307910312,
0.0225824099,
-0.0141444709,
-0.0301514156,
0.0326951928,
0.0084930444,
0.0352097638,
0.0162352733,
0.083638072,
0.0230435207,
-0.0274305176,
-0.0289308578,
-0.007649425,
-0.0801122785,
0.0103952559,
-0.026011344,
0.0296885259,
0.0360833071,
-0.0096718781,
0.0348169282,
-0.0432150252,
-0.0027622292,
0.0147384973,
0.028204063,
0.0399635993,
-0.0355388597,
0.072725445,
0.016003361,
-0.0275017601,
0.0302987155,
0.032777492,
-0.0093456637,
0.0557910688,
0.0003794153,
0.0108301649,
-0.0391504318,
-0.0745157301,
0.0065400135,
0.0085361842,
-0.0103742853,
0.036002703,
-0.1286068261,
-0.0505116768,
0.0037823042,
0.0261405203,
0.0187021475,
-0.0078413142,
0.0310897548,
0.040737588,
0.0173070077,
-0.0450450554,
-0.0283358935,
0.0536612794,
-0.025645053,
0.025898112,
-0.079144299,
-6.546031962e-33,
-0.0382665172,
-0.0548004247,
0.0379864536,
-0.0617633909,
0.0051680547,
-0.0339632779,
-0.0425121076,
-0.0148668457,
-0.0145745026,
0.0095734559,
0.0178087614,
-0.0067866743,
0.0131896921,
0.0214164369,
-0.0061087338,
-0.0126333311,
0.0661328956,
0.0232975036,
-0.017532913,
0.0201671533,
-0.0063607339,
-0.0192583259,
0.017404275,
-0.0600505769,
0.0479544736,
-0.0439110398,
-0.0172289871,
0.0260209274,
-0.06102705,
0.0258539021,
-0.0377336815,
0.0411818959,
0.0268677138,
-0.0113624902,
0.0000487468,
0.0026014326,
0.0084515978,
-0.0121830236,
0.0614878908,
-0.0153552415,
-0.0006840756,
-0.0357516184,
0.0124815004,
0.0099187503,
-0.034163624,
0.0408139341,
0.0202973224,
-0.0184562635,
0.0404964834,
0.0265638512,
-0.131839335,
0.0254837237,
-0.0283633377,
-0.0207406152,
-0.0214608759,
0.0871982947,
0.0048769689,
-0.0280770771,
-0.0447831191,
0.0430889092,
0.0514380187,
-0.0396029465,
0.0731422678,
0.0062102531,
-0.009837186,
0.0303642061,
0.0088909538,
0.0557873994,
-0.0291731898,
-0.0047673131,
-0.0298624709,
0.0340062976,
0.0331199095,
0.1084252074,
0.030974444,
0.0062599708,
-0.0675242022,
-0.0234977975,
-0.0229661018,
0.0281606521,
0.0591985621,
-0.0139149129,
-0.0334508866,
-0.0053244182,
-0.0416753218,
-0.028079845,
-0.0265016165,
-0.0062555806,
0.0543213189,
0.0124205081,
-0.0199447926,
-0.0131564969,
0.012721193,
-0.0361888856,
-0.0107816001,
0.0233816616,
-0.0232887249,
-0.0196229201,
0.0200021416,
0.0356443301,
-0.04557411,
0.0123085426,
0.0572955571,
0.0170448162,
-0.002100419,
0.0105754677,
0.0048441566,
0.0101235155,
-0.0371896215,
0.0192000996,
-0.0458223037,
0.0286733415,
-0.0354540497,
-0.0488262326,
0.0371361114,
0.0218158849,
-0.043316111,
0.0238130223,
0.0084534576,
-0.0531308427,
-0.0277040545,
0.0400058553,
0.0072869603,
0.0198300742,
-0.0188469663,
0.0150485858,
0.0224582981,
0.0230350513,
0.0019047771,
-0.0420852937,
-0.0293539297,
0.0217057373,
2.82e-7,
0.0249970015,
0.0326346122,
0.0468139946,
0.0286294799,
0.017722914,
0.0484307595,
-0.0306012686,
0.0139549254,
0.0232701488,
0.0154741285,
0.0190783385,
0.0221072417,
0.0179839749,
0.0166468695,
-0.0129278749,
0.0715578347,
-0.0855625346,
-0.0332442224,
-0.0606763847,
-0.0119891753,
0.1078500524,
0.0479699858,
-0.0122632366,
0.0028646362,
-0.0105166445,
-0.0129622081,
0.0604571961,
-0.0283632055,
-0.0159861315,
-0.0101920534,
0.0001785645,
-0.0047274777,
-0.0175331607,
0.052287288,
0.0237686969,
0.024430519,
-0.044961419,
0.0241810456,
-0.0131491739,
-0.0726057142,
-0.0355261229,
-0.0171631388,
0.0079105264,
-0.0753890052,
0.063587442,
-0.0339771099,
-0.0185229797,
-0.0244252253,
-0.0268672444,
0.0269463938,
0.0127285095,
-0.024850348,
-0.0334106795,
-0.0071415817,
0.0155389514,
0.0316515528,
-0.0165942218,
-0.0402683318,
-0.0240977928,
0.0644823238,
-0.0424981155,
-0.0329035372,
-0.0585807003,
0.0232798029,
0.0386106409,
-0.0449102223,
0.033261776,
2.5955177e-34,
0.0665896684,
0.0054798932,
0.0017659678,
0.0046647745,
0.0562873147,
0.0193232689,
-0.0559397265,
0.0331949517,
0.0525605306,
-0.0368506089,
-0.0311834663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14790v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14790v2 | Advancing Topic Segmentation and Outline Generation in Chinese Texts: The Paragraph-level Topic Representation, Corpus, and Benchmark | 2023-05-24T06:43:23 | 2024-03-26T11:29:21 | Feng Jiang, Weihao Liu, Xiaomin Chu, Peifeng Li, Qiaoming Zhu, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Topic segmentation and outline generation strive to divide a document into
coherent topic sections and generate corresponding subheadings, unveiling the
discourse topic structure of a document. Compared with sentence-level topic
structure, the paragraph-level topic structure can quickly grasp and understand
the overall context of the document from a higher level, benefitting many
downstream tasks such as summarization, discourse parsing, and information
retrieval. However, the lack of large-scale, high-quality Chinese
paragraph-level topic structure corpora restrained relative research and
applications. To fill this gap, we build the Chinese paragraph-level topic
representation, corpus, and benchmark in this paper. Firstly, we propose a
hierarchical paragraph-level topic structure representation with three layers
to guide the corpus construction. Then, we employ a two-stage man-machine
collaborative annotation method to construct the largest Chinese
Paragraph-level Topic Structure corpus (CPTS), achieving high quality. We also
build several strong baselines, including ChatGPT, to validate the
computability of CPTS on two fundamental tasks (topic segmentation and outline
generation) and preliminarily verified its usefulness for the downstream task
(discourse parsing). | [
0.0151342964,
-0.0027300091,
0.019928962,
0.0152328368,
-0.0452068299,
-0.0001574517,
0.0161403511,
-0.0192828886,
-0.0490776002,
-0.0398933478,
0.0298793558,
-0.0405574478,
-0.0013942531,
-0.004578162,
-0.0101651931,
-0.08283557,
0.0082550943,
-0.0102864401,
0.0250284839,
0.0243391674,
0.0510418601,
-0.0213445518,
0.028133234,
0.011895786,
0.018385198,
-0.0431850702,
-0.0307590216,
0.0054478631,
0.0302397981,
-0.0555487834,
0.0352515727,
0.0125064338,
-0.0074687246,
-0.0057812873,
0.0000016849,
-0.025204543,
-0.0873122215,
0.0021614919,
0.0354615338,
0.0476804785,
0.0318524651,
-0.0346813761,
0.0268841218,
0.0272786468,
0.0059440848,
0.021082174,
-0.0212497432,
0.1304135472,
0.0727340654,
0.0664197579,
-0.0334763601,
-0.0208106935,
0.0215827283,
-0.0033144222,
-0.0501827784,
-0.0247217622,
-0.0145977624,
0.0248323344,
-0.023060225,
0.0435737297,
0.0243279971,
-0.0464635119,
-0.0208095945,
-0.026855113,
0.0549069159,
0.0288743265,
-0.0765906125,
0.0000673784,
0.009418021,
0.0523162261,
0.0310224406,
-0.0165333748,
0.060604021,
0.0036362854,
-0.0288126338,
-0.0231342576,
-0.0420996249,
0.0591167212,
-0.0543568805,
0.0457669944,
0.0714590475,
-0.0290650353,
0.0053730798,
0.0044872956,
-0.0055510672,
0.0567984805,
0.001769157,
-0.0388848893,
-0.001032427,
0.0010270668,
-0.0271217935,
-0.0601248629,
0.0585665293,
-0.0051284544,
-0.0226772986,
-0.0126396837,
-0.0076966914,
-0.0415769406,
-0.0154440375,
-0.042570021,
0.0127070537,
0.0121111739,
-0.0295382105,
0.0116840322,
-0.0090003256,
0.0013587694,
-0.0208527576,
-0.0431022011,
-0.0489228033,
-0.0159056038,
-0.0452128164,
0.0017169965,
-0.0705123916,
0.040837653,
-0.0324970111,
-0.0183688495,
-0.0032471225,
0.019351732,
0.0271632057,
-0.0184371024,
-0.0241904147,
-0.0162154492,
-0.0477691106,
0.0066917469,
0.0236613881,
0.0154127432,
-0.0851201564,
0.0035590113,
-0.0097857518,
0.0431050435,
0.0201518293,
0.0350500047,
0.0305203963,
0.0249191914,
-0.0252330396,
-0.0160783492,
-0.0495947115,
-0.0182900373,
-0.0463193506,
-0.0168512892,
-0.0161611196,
-0.000754054,
0.0429542772,
-0.0640307367,
-0.0375912823,
-0.0163423903,
0.0058959774,
0.043276038,
0.0340665579,
-0.0052255937,
0.0061799437,
0.023365939,
-0.0217551906,
-0.0177945029,
0.0424901769,
0.0218114872,
-0.0039811013,
0.0435576662,
0.0501217023,
0.0479768477,
0.0752321556,
0.0474639982,
-0.019897379,
-0.0202984903,
-0.0285901781,
-0.0102307405,
0.0476631261,
-0.0293960702,
-0.0409728773,
-0.0163453333,
-0.0084497016,
0.042943757,
-0.0468499474,
0.0152950333,
0.0217129476,
0.030771561,
-0.0166640077,
0.033424411,
-0.005508408,
0.0244021062,
0.0035060963,
0.0595166571,
0.0448447578,
-0.0282070115,
0.0181388613,
0.0299126748,
0.056624122,
-0.0215965863,
-0.0068498407,
-0.0446250737,
-0.0291489251,
0.0148366001,
0.0017177382,
-0.0597861148,
0.0546957739,
0.0130020101,
-0.0029376417,
0.0118427863,
-0.0018830342,
-0.0403769463,
0.030758163,
0.0393290408,
0.02330322,
0.0339796729,
0.0260870494,
-0.0315108225,
-0.0179112274,
0.0164549686,
0.0838343874,
0.0624594539,
-0.0006056777,
-0.0394067727,
-0.0248228274,
-0.0404605828,
-0.0095138866,
-0.0135918343,
0.002412823,
0.0076017003,
-0.0116017805,
-0.0449095257,
0.006087014,
-0.0319235735,
0.0073596477,
0.0458624959,
-0.0361744612,
0.0351083055,
0.0081450865,
-0.0171354525,
0.0303867031,
0.0455966592,
-0.0305016562,
0.0137274722,
0.0231820121,
-0.0587190129,
-0.0136584127,
0.0314173847,
-0.0159006547,
-0.0182126667,
0.0104637844,
-0.0773867667,
0.0034271637,
-0.0290351417,
-0.0359292291,
-0.0682959482,
-0.0135530643,
0.0079490524,
0.006866172,
-0.0536088794,
0.0331210345,
0.0063252528,
-0.0068346211,
-0.024071008,
0.0716261864,
0.0042288508,
-0.0124691194,
0.0597027466,
-0.0071111424,
0.0196567252,
-0.0578207709,
-0.0076046926,
-0.0082451785,
0.0161594618,
-0.0105967782,
0.0632470921,
0.0130835352,
-0.0269755088,
-0.0114083672,
-0.1313902736,
0.0499514081,
-0.0665508211,
0.0279235896,
0.0644307286,
-0.021428857,
0.0051163011,
0.00617419,
-0.0265565291,
-0.0036992498,
-0.0473726727,
-0.0031849139,
0.053029038,
-0.0475399755,
0.0305037741,
-0.0174469333,
0.008231259,
-0.0219154507,
-0.0120865637,
0.0386872627,
-0.0686585903,
-0.0665129945,
0.0028313918,
0.0186906215,
-0.0128943743,
-0.0099485284,
0.0010910658,
0.0213889834,
-0.0180773996,
0.0905133411,
0.0126253683,
0.050903894,
0.0365188457,
0.0554341152,
-0.0128084496,
0.0342648625,
0.0103582582,
0.0152993845,
0.0909162015,
0.0092691109,
-0.0463545322,
0.0197101682,
0.0648654401,
0.0176658183,
0.0200796053,
-0.0090113645,
-0.0600857027,
-0.0625355393,
0.0115067624,
-0.0088300109,
-0.0010037485,
-0.0450730175,
0.0025424638,
-0.04003172,
0.0065750363,
0.0165374354,
-0.0438620895,
-0.0070526064,
-0.0559027195,
0.005126813,
-0.060531456,
0.0394936539,
0.0153155681,
0.0043845885,
0.0183081236,
-0.0457486622,
-0.0216004588,
0.0466749556,
0.0353974178,
0.0168572236,
0.0324653536,
-0.0454930142,
0.0166405272,
-0.0387090817,
-0.0012331486,
-0.0178298019,
-0.0124838389,
0.0106560048,
0.0488515757,
0.0343321227,
0.0031049945,
0.0206023492,
0.050019864,
-0.0026773149,
0.048809886,
-0.0241410844,
-0.0023482719,
-0.0272062682,
0.0560965389,
0.0268790871,
0.0021155693,
-0.0092333462,
-0.0315058269,
0.0534433536,
0.0619089603,
0.0430802293,
0.0062230937,
-0.0160451829,
0.0070238328,
-0.0132035986,
-0.0797092691,
-0.0322348885,
-0.0054917852,
0.0768531561,
-0.0392740145,
-0.0268356614,
0.1082761213,
0.0397340022,
-0.0133325588,
-0.0238509737,
-0.0114333667,
0.0047868202,
-0.0245498549,
-0.0349929072,
-0.06013209,
0.0158512406,
0.0170133244,
0.0379095152,
0.0066327052,
-0.0400708579,
0.0145387743,
-0.0409647077,
0.0381436124,
0.0154572073,
-0.0089369323,
0.0032528143,
-0.0513273366,
-0.0019595549,
-0.007671902,
-0.0054953364,
0.0218475722,
-0.0106739169,
-0.0046799388,
0.0239210762,
-0.0773230195,
0.0265726224,
-0.0133836055,
-0.0337865762,
-0.0158851519,
0.0230478607,
0.0439772829,
0.0107334042,
0.0825651884,
0.042948097,
-0.029240137,
-0.0295155793,
0.0129017681,
0.015162589,
-0.0082305437,
0.0223143231,
-0.0096617294,
0.0579240546,
-0.0005777832,
-0.0058587459,
0.0451297686,
-0.0114077311,
-0.0279661324,
-0.0057697445,
-0.0106004002,
0.0316627398,
-0.044735834,
0.0680098459,
0.0040147328,
-0.0205960218,
-0.0454645455,
-0.0255042445,
0.0374489352,
-0.0544018745,
0.048762653,
0.0213549137,
-0.050493367,
-0.0111189755,
-0.1167633682,
-0.0517704114,
0.0087234834,
0.0033665004,
-0.0160976946,
-0.0051909108,
0.0512790792,
-0.0007632321,
-0.012720068,
-0.0309044123,
-0.0186600089,
-0.0388806723,
-0.0587628372,
-0.0674057528,
0.0239102244,
-0.0313007981,
0.0190153122,
0.0025269545,
-0.0427556075,
-0.0457642376,
0.0204139352,
-0.0492606126,
-0.002846393,
0.0387720838,
-0.0139859011,
0.0059969001,
0.0353920124,
-0.0057350164,
-0.0023261833,
-0.003962385,
0.0091881631,
0.0341356397,
-0.0264304969,
-0.00156668,
-0.0420148261,
0.0368892364,
-0.0578151196,
0.0703225732,
-0.0444376357,
0.003485681,
0.0098442174,
0.0283653643,
0.0533978678,
-0.0171310119,
0.007245874,
-0.0747128576,
-0.0049880822,
-0.0671982095,
-0.0331921205,
-0.0308761857,
0.0334719196,
0.0274359658,
-0.0121434536,
-0.0174499229,
0.0568760447,
-0.0060817231,
0.0306110643,
0.0112458318,
-0.0139015093,
-0.0264137611,
0.0517510362,
-0.0777132288,
-0.0205415096,
-0.016855577,
-0.0194063857,
-0.0299412813,
0.0290464237,
-0.0104386657,
0.0841050595,
0.0109772785,
-0.0058529638,
0.0026980189,
0.0115965726,
-0.082852751,
0.0590966754,
-0.0275137704,
0.0372046866,
0.0600928403,
-0.0214869156,
0.0801715776,
-0.0619722717,
-0.0124556581,
-0.0320869088,
0.0658876523,
0.0236025788,
-0.0192726962,
-0.0475427918,
0.0215793476,
-0.0148876961,
-0.0195500255,
0.0774399713,
0.0404825173,
-0.005047665,
0.0520732962,
-0.0152940694,
-0.0480366312,
-0.007477337,
-0.0022979781,
0.0213695373,
-0.0112421531,
-0.0204634164,
-0.0323290303,
0.0557962097,
0.0335731246,
-0.0171771813,
0.0183321573,
0.0046527828,
0.0041851993,
0.0619434007,
-0.0196769126,
0.0059529589,
-0.098240532,
0.003602657,
0.0029382645,
-0.0005690185,
-0.0232179891,
-5.897951804e-33,
-0.0433375426,
-0.0581775494,
-0.0155141791,
0.0269650519,
-0.0363772176,
0.0261343997,
-0.0746697485,
-0.0018241946,
0.0526745319,
0.0143643897,
-0.0212031398,
0.0096172774,
0.022304941,
0.0328541622,
0.0007063647,
-0.0053150905,
0.080060184,
-0.0098617049,
-0.0311709046,
0.0427294411,
0.1025068611,
0.0215339828,
0.0219009705,
0.0122489696,
0.0376941636,
-0.0532603934,
0.011728256,
0.0016823121,
0.0673002675,
0.0190839227,
0.0098671354,
-0.0329581909,
0.0749529973,
0.0017992968,
-0.0065954379,
0.0040676412,
-0.0922237113,
-0.0402929857,
-0.0255939364,
-0.0174974762,
-0.0299680941,
-0.0271898881,
0.0162677225,
-0.0132731283,
0.0843124539,
-0.0188992955,
0.0511242114,
-0.0484209545,
0.0003501185,
-0.0622850545,
-0.0221057832,
0.0423604362,
-0.0237622764,
0.0095256204,
0.0235119443,
-0.0092400322,
0.0132080894,
0.0064977701,
-0.0086449003,
0.0087483134,
-0.0034395785,
0.0368467048,
-0.0208171215,
0.0172978286,
-0.0029299413,
0.0263095312,
-0.0051612668,
0.0400653109,
-0.0220321845,
0.0308270883,
-0.0101894625,
0.003806595,
0.0000962916,
0.0232522115,
0.0170523506,
0.0479626097,
-0.0370671339,
0.0714095086,
0.0596335828,
0.0134151261,
-0.0012316249,
0.0270576254,
0.0081404569,
-0.0175303333,
0.0055990154,
-0.0480813906,
0.023085013,
-0.0079502603,
-0.0023700222,
0.0230595395,
-0.0553656071,
-0.0212536622,
0.0464263856,
-0.0029771249,
0.0259752478,
0.0210067127,
-0.0220127776,
0.0150166126,
-0.0259768534,
0.0104749287,
-0.0771027356,
-0.070866175,
0.0127793541,
-0.0176972952,
-0.0210096352,
-0.0278113149,
0.0112394281,
-0.0492889322,
-0.0108334543,
0.0081912754,
-0.0040064557,
-0.0225298256,
-0.0210174378,
0.0776727051,
-0.0025631452,
-0.0092519447,
0.0257255491,
0.0514505021,
0.0427005105,
0.0408429578,
-0.0445614308,
-0.0036249796,
-0.0341241099,
0.0098538911,
-0.0040713563,
0.0641827807,
-0.01313427,
0.0465505123,
0.0343111642,
-0.0396831334,
-0.0102655413,
-0.0190043654,
2.298e-7,
0.0205514971,
0.0393258221,
0.0916696712,
0.0076415446,
0.0152878463,
0.0029365625,
-0.0259280205,
0.0471141376,
-0.0018633027,
-0.0146797057,
0.0468495339,
0.0058961194,
0.0450335033,
0.0550652966,
-0.0944532603,
0.0035450973,
-0.0416950136,
-0.0347957797,
-0.0197585896,
0.0091120079,
0.000721089,
0.0151207261,
-0.0334128067,
0.0640666261,
-0.001768061,
-0.0188150406,
0.0375713967,
0.0090269707,
-0.0277828425,
0.0848795399,
0.0471942015,
0.0164090972,
-0.0665251315,
-0.0238188785,
-0.0070838714,
0.002188945,
0.0562534593,
0.0613888502,
0.0498093404,
0.0044286074,
0.0004955228,
-0.0234354306,
0.029017454,
0.0145313079,
0.0059453263,
-0.0048802518,
-0.005251382,
-0.0278049745,
-0.0072693494,
0.0164294653,
-0.0316903293,
0.0096555501,
-0.0199237186,
0.0539100952,
-0.0454276912,
-0.0192912556,
0.0119039854,
-0.0299820565,
-0.0311318375,
0.0140385553,
-0.0181700625,
-0.0331513062,
0.003198283,
-0.0123878624,
-0.0307034776,
-0.0695500672,
-0.0113394847,
1.855193883e-34,
0.033329621,
-0.0460186712,
-0.0880526751,
0.0128647452,
0.0297741611,
-0.0483830646,
-0.0416806713,
0.0014078044,
-0.053213343,
-0.0131761404,
-0.0068560732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14788v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14788v2 | Adapting Language Models to Compress Contexts | 2023-05-24T06:42:44 | 2023-11-04T04:09:43 | Alexis Chevalier, Alexander Wettig, Anirudh Ajith, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models (LMs) are powerful and widely-applicable
tools, but their usefulness is constrained by a finite context window and the
expensive computational cost of processing long text documents. We propose to
adapt pre-trained LMs into AutoCompressors. These language models are capable
of compressing long contexts into compact summary vectors, which are then
accessible to the model as soft prompts. Summary vectors are trained with an
unsupervised objective, whereby long documents are processed in segments, and
summary vectors from all previous segments are used in language modeling. We
fine-tune OPT and Llama-2 models on sequences of up to 30,720 tokens and show
that AutoCompressors can utilize long contexts to improve perplexity. We
evaluate AutoCompressors on in-context learning by compressing task
demonstrations and find that summary vectors are good substitutes for
plain-text demonstrations, increasing accuracy while reducing inference costs.
Finally, we explore the benefits of pre-computing summary vectors for large
corpora by applying summary vectors to retrievalaugmented language modeling and
a passage re-ranking task. Overall, AutoCompressors emerge as a simple and
inexpensive solution to extend the context window of LMs while speeding up
inference over long contexts. | [
0.0233690869,
0.0521515496,
-0.0076779197,
0.0258935355,
-0.0130183306,
0.0245084018,
0.0081008924,
-0.0079528233,
-0.030611055,
-0.0457979739,
-0.0157081876,
-0.0276990887,
0.0008088978,
0.0188922025,
0.0231984723,
-0.0409669913,
0.0173907094,
-0.0303803608,
-0.0160004403,
0.0022465966,
0.0034569034,
0.0115116071,
0.0376188867,
0.0393719152,
0.0158487819,
-0.0006211582,
-0.0308021363,
-0.0037870933,
-0.0154857645,
-0.0092152823,
0.0168580916,
0.0655628964,
0.0527170487,
0.0072557051,
0.0000020506,
-0.0461945347,
-0.0289374534,
-0.0026286892,
-0.0409961566,
0.0424296148,
0.0740054175,
-0.0333192311,
0.0268482808,
0.0229338575,
-0.0383229107,
-0.0523158163,
0.0129282754,
0.0522619709,
0.0512322523,
0.0612340309,
-0.0082730697,
-0.0237294324,
0.0044868118,
-0.0667114332,
0.0089824144,
-0.0610700287,
0.0207085107,
-0.0339673758,
0.0045942976,
0.0583126917,
-0.0377525054,
0.0321504958,
0.0396497324,
-0.0107310135,
-0.0034484975,
0.0184667446,
-0.0098948982,
-0.0084241945,
0.0091843456,
0.0472764075,
-0.0235103313,
-0.0628857687,
0.0117635978,
0.0107152509,
0.0098221553,
-0.0011562309,
-0.0683468729,
0.0401544794,
0.0168324094,
0.0139291435,
0.0345729776,
0.0053228,
0.0181095377,
0.0080711208,
-0.0785259679,
0.0163345039,
0.007541493,
-0.0162328649,
-0.0150115332,
-0.010547745,
-0.0312337559,
-0.0523296967,
-0.0023669489,
0.0412103571,
-0.0221504364,
-0.0001337235,
-0.0394106731,
-0.077729255,
0.0368578397,
-0.0227018725,
0.0214731544,
0.0259038862,
-0.0296290964,
0.0497230329,
-0.0339472704,
0.0715427622,
0.0005415327,
0.0088873627,
-0.0724930763,
-0.0295598637,
0.0087569123,
-0.0064743059,
-0.0656999052,
0.0241381321,
-0.0534662567,
-0.0140083153,
-0.0347157158,
0.0200634152,
0.0047311159,
-0.0298628509,
0.0106608989,
0.0015910459,
-0.0418939553,
-0.00585393,
0.0071812449,
0.0279752873,
-0.0221263096,
0.0275481101,
-0.00673038,
-0.0120041575,
-0.0436897203,
0.020263508,
0.0383961201,
-0.0303528327,
0.01087722,
0.0273131132,
-0.0163830183,
-0.0702226683,
0.0005320649,
0.0025145232,
-0.013654233,
-0.0455014892,
-0.0147843286,
-0.0829942077,
0.0451291203,
0.0220325198,
0.0018435235,
-0.0069464617,
0.002265194,
0.0236120541,
-0.031619601,
0.0670499802,
0.0469707511,
0.005450028,
0.0219899584,
0.0073525086,
0.0371825062,
0.065703176,
0.0098079089,
0.0327230915,
0.0301516969,
0.0018675081,
0.0211799201,
0.0299499687,
0.0444450341,
0.0124830566,
-0.0026664396,
0.008542899,
0.0005468692,
-0.009512187,
0.0391192324,
0.0731210858,
-0.0347018838,
-0.0050556445,
0.0312558152,
0.054407686,
0.0445228219,
0.0133634098,
0.0516155288,
0.0235715397,
-0.0109613305,
0.0197320394,
-0.0578330234,
0.0152954003,
-0.0220681429,
0.0152753433,
0.0599596165,
0.0348702557,
-0.0424213707,
-0.0401596427,
0.0061328504,
-0.0416348167,
0.0596452802,
0.0208910182,
0.0463345163,
0.0370431356,
-0.0514137186,
0.0749717504,
0.0276596751,
-0.0822438598,
-0.0001043796,
-0.0441330485,
0.0169971697,
0.0220487621,
0.0418660901,
-0.0280405581,
-0.011760206,
-0.0125484467,
0.0223571975,
0.0112249283,
0.0295963828,
-0.0181497261,
0.0132367229,
-0.0535216331,
-0.0000391546,
-0.0253012124,
0.0418619104,
0.0062262975,
0.0316307209,
0.000952956,
0.0550602451,
-0.0629744157,
-0.0012470247,
0.0450796336,
-0.0628436878,
-0.0508877784,
0.0055646282,
0.0023598964,
0.00043503,
-0.0042669671,
0.0055410867,
0.0103470292,
0.0714009106,
-0.0665597916,
-0.0057168426,
-0.004896238,
-0.0741941035,
-0.0662050173,
0.0327246562,
-0.0122381868,
0.0202369727,
0.0561280288,
-0.0390274264,
-0.042666208,
0.0030343332,
-0.0323679261,
0.0578937866,
-0.0590874813,
0.0286629163,
-0.0027528498,
0.0399485976,
-0.044426512,
0.0660454407,
-0.0046292725,
0.0417382531,
0.0391669571,
-0.0167240631,
0.0047179647,
-0.0153374728,
-0.050183244,
-0.0162714478,
-0.0186583567,
-0.0020811695,
0.0282314364,
0.015918443,
0.0138808461,
-0.0351669937,
-0.134989962,
-0.0101341354,
-0.0491935648,
-0.0069929557,
0.0008802977,
0.0425867289,
-0.004590882,
-0.0034182603,
-0.0214694012,
-0.0261920802,
0.0184898395,
0.0133731822,
0.0187889114,
0.0254718512,
0.0062443106,
-0.0443709381,
-0.0327442773,
-0.0068479874,
0.0836253911,
-0.0194420647,
-0.0094873616,
-0.029124558,
0.0496689267,
0.0160708372,
0.0142922215,
-0.0429213345,
-0.0148079023,
-0.0161584411,
-0.0388516337,
0.0621062405,
0.076148048,
0.0361346304,
0.0504839644,
0.0434045792,
0.0039071855,
-0.0550261363,
0.014671118,
-0.0301379394,
-0.0354330763,
-0.0283431429,
-0.0164935328,
0.0044657271,
0.0668017939,
-0.0215469319,
-0.0199964829,
-0.0339271016,
-0.0115058944,
-0.0117544876,
-0.0041902205,
-0.0143632209,
-0.0369921178,
-0.0097506326,
0.0468623936,
-0.0193739366,
-0.0277527645,
0.0692461282,
-0.0593765453,
0.0017518944,
-0.0448629856,
-0.0244809017,
-0.0864481032,
0.0720277801,
0.0239026304,
-0.0026537576,
-0.0251028314,
-0.0134136211,
-0.0396216959,
0.0133009162,
-0.027253069,
-0.043987561,
0.0923596844,
-0.0166531894,
0.0159048066,
-0.0250788443,
-0.0516950451,
-0.0441046655,
-0.0730668977,
-0.0053900168,
0.0147924954,
0.0525526553,
0.0018786386,
-0.0394690894,
0.017103767,
0.0352975726,
0.0897181705,
-0.0130204801,
0.0123934262,
-0.0132615743,
0.0136859315,
0.0605974644,
0.0131573556,
0.0101418765,
-0.0569140576,
0.0173919238,
0.0324593857,
0.0505673364,
-0.0141455065,
-0.008241565,
-0.0223497767,
0.031935975,
-0.0218772292,
0.0007752668,
0.0097869756,
0.0472894721,
-0.0453637652,
-0.0334018804,
0.1201911196,
0.0252943188,
-0.0785369053,
-0.0037959584,
-0.0103439204,
0.009818173,
0.0123098055,
0.0506502911,
-0.09233661,
-0.0231565312,
0.0145746944,
0.0032067334,
0.0329837389,
0.0002496613,
-0.0052674105,
-0.1117847711,
0.0207775589,
-0.0070009762,
-0.0420938283,
-0.0045359959,
-0.0466114879,
0.0056631831,
0.0054324931,
0.0106435176,
0.0232605375,
-0.0308109429,
-0.0089423843,
-0.0046103122,
0.0128055476,
-0.022348186,
0.015762521,
-0.0225042719,
0.0114439894,
0.0173334237,
0.010659311,
0.0013584996,
-0.0154640358,
0.0574228801,
-0.0364987776,
-0.0015565058,
-0.0097446907,
0.0089962678,
-0.0153667927,
0.0122106932,
0.0142591028,
0.0514989048,
-0.0208421163,
-0.0204937328,
-0.0167863071,
0.0448358208,
0.0004409136,
-0.0097550647,
-0.0295925103,
-0.0170088056,
-0.0112133883,
0.0844022259,
0.0426159613,
-0.0412131511,
-0.0272618383,
-0.0210746992,
-0.0008736415,
-0.0307650976,
-0.029105952,
-0.0244352259,
0.0328793973,
-0.0273214411,
-0.0536856242,
-0.0169676952,
0.0245628152,
0.0273933578,
-0.0078508882,
0.013499584,
-0.0311673712,
-0.0157650802,
-0.0744896978,
0.0357608348,
-0.0204791483,
0.0124173174,
-0.0601255856,
0.0234467164,
0.0423977412,
-0.0328052938,
-0.0210921504,
0.0235685799,
-0.0939818174,
-0.0700979307,
0.0073917019,
0.0415539518,
0.0217811391,
0.0523993112,
-0.0091170091,
-0.0453784987,
0.0737336576,
0.0681249946,
-0.0478610918,
0.0523265712,
0.0114349844,
-0.0003470539,
0.0030529134,
0.0443734229,
-0.0664559305,
0.0308470652,
-0.0142938932,
0.0255136322,
-0.0195231512,
-0.0597928055,
0.0151749644,
-0.0201747958,
0.0440746583,
0.0161036476,
0.0069862064,
-0.0279949419,
0.0291364584,
-0.0163850579,
-0.0143384626,
-0.0247888174,
0.0130092977,
0.0068013789,
0.0287460312,
0.0119196335,
0.0372532569,
-0.0011347359,
0.055002071,
-0.0357645303,
0.0355010368,
-0.0324820504,
-0.0481584147,
-0.0005129136,
0.0149152521,
-0.0197302569,
-0.0493765697,
0.0018207344,
0.0395847224,
-0.0384834222,
0.0316513851,
0.0189328957,
0.0205454156,
-0.0358065367,
0.048415117,
-0.0897535533,
0.002776199,
-0.0365222171,
-0.0015384405,
0.0264649633,
-0.0603132918,
0.0488526821,
-0.0127634443,
-0.0010973548,
-0.0291018598,
0.0048222728,
0.0050637941,
-0.0109854722,
0.0188269708,
0.0445126332,
-0.0048019555,
0.0143184327,
0.0991377756,
0.0085335635,
0.0194351561,
0.0338516757,
0.0157810468,
-0.0328189395,
-0.0164855402,
0.0105847623,
0.046148587,
-0.0237551909,
-0.0167035311,
-0.0118864542,
-0.0566187836,
0.0377368256,
-0.0075452137,
-0.0339349136,
-0.0380322859,
0.0292978566,
0.0610859469,
0.0027042194,
-0.0041973675,
-0.0355061926,
0.0200325716,
0.0338995382,
-0.0405690037,
-0.0204792991,
-6.926566667e-33,
-0.0191338137,
-0.0207004193,
0.0086750295,
-0.0203770194,
-0.0105957091,
0.0169610176,
-0.0355550423,
-0.0058217836,
-0.016572535,
-0.0006837328,
-0.0441120863,
0.0243635587,
0.000547271,
0.0450716354,
-0.0262639765,
0.0151861329,
0.0483388975,
0.011106181,
-0.0164405387,
0.0280720834,
0.005407217,
0.0435238369,
0.0122057339,
-0.0515516326,
0.0056786779,
-0.0210812707,
0.0124821095,
0.0075221593,
0.0103404168,
0.0572955422,
-0.0207389183,
0.0166913029,
0.025836017,
-0.0439854637,
-0.0031993759,
0.0698885545,
-0.0929737464,
-0.0118876779,
0.0091524934,
-0.0259621013,
-0.0165062957,
-0.0467192158,
0.0376824141,
-0.0157960244,
0.012936065,
-0.0011624487,
0.030943295,
-0.0095890062,
-0.0251996126,
-0.045108594,
-0.0270428266,
0.0058487207,
-0.0006050866,
-0.0409844555,
0.0227683894,
0.0463726707,
0.0009704011,
0.0603522658,
-0.0259998813,
0.0264634024,
0.0146546653,
0.0561806709,
0.0318673849,
0.0025282565,
0.0040606703,
0.0336430296,
-0.023036683,
-0.0084105451,
-0.0670877695,
-0.0267222598,
0.0479111858,
0.0234326925,
0.0284730624,
0.0286450274,
0.0483481325,
-0.0102245044,
-0.0662313551,
0.0391414054,
0.0088898754,
0.0443167463,
0.0491010249,
0.0135598751,
-0.0201952048,
-0.0410853438,
-0.040216323,
-0.0059607681,
-0.0313097052,
-0.0133159729,
0.0093542878,
0.0599120036,
-0.0334945321,
-0.0018808132,
0.0508568324,
-0.0539353043,
-0.0185827855,
0.0419979952,
0.0000252213,
0.0199453756,
0.0003558249,
0.0244785603,
-0.027327396,
-0.0160853714,
0.0258453675,
-0.0068113892,
-0.0146350348,
0.0000140119,
0.0509537943,
0.0240347926,
-0.0859548822,
-0.0064403242,
-0.0081597846,
0.0037401991,
-0.0156842433,
0.0366320834,
0.0356001444,
0.0486671627,
0.0014436195,
0.0546411313,
0.0192596298,
-0.0208913032,
-0.0430478454,
-0.027151797,
0.0119211562,
0.0102249533,
-0.0179217607,
-0.0135476375,
-0.0238691289,
0.0550604276,
0.0434828401,
-0.0680151582,
-0.0108703207,
0.0398682877,
2.799e-7,
0.0567888431,
0.0472046323,
0.0262669865,
-0.0056762942,
0.0045378772,
0.0172140244,
0.0122396043,
0.0349369757,
0.0105029074,
-0.0050119832,
0.0070087393,
0.0312284399,
0.0302100256,
0.0022560393,
-0.1048932523,
0.0029712887,
-0.0577827133,
-0.0239839014,
-0.0399305709,
-0.0317049697,
0.0317726731,
0.1463314146,
-0.0174107477,
0.0082950015,
-0.0124768727,
-0.042317912,
0.0582751036,
-0.03297925,
-0.0164302588,
0.0153514855,
0.0110451402,
0.0267337896,
-0.0104925204,
-0.007860003,
-0.0050912439,
0.0600509606,
0.0099425586,
0.0751331151,
0.0182374269,
-0.0570122935,
0.0334941447,
-0.0190586112,
-0.0226341765,
-0.0527554005,
0.0722617507,
-0.0665322766,
0.0114836441,
-0.0371302143,
-0.0260557104,
0.0100812772,
0.0013452044,
-0.0002562249,
-0.007171988,
0.0485454276,
0.022879649,
-0.0117711704,
-0.0043525789,
-0.1158565357,
-0.032929413,
0.0006978259,
-0.0443421416,
0.0077438666,
-0.0475981496,
-0.0186969414,
0.0289439689,
-0.0490802824,
0.0347967558,
2.955026117e-34,
0.0640159026,
-0.0233112294,
-0.0164503027,
0.0074112103,
0.0165409278,
-0.0432989635,
0.0042032111,
0.0290529821,
0.0053694113,
-0.1321954429,
-0.0256279875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14785v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14785v2 | Simple Linguistic Inferences of Large Language Models (LLMs): Blind Spots and Blinds | 2023-05-24T06:41:09 | 2024-04-11T11:16:45 | Victoria Basmov, Yoav Goldberg, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We evaluate LLMs' language understanding capacities on simple inference tasks
that most humans find trivial. Specifically, we target (i)
grammatically-specified entailments, (ii) premises with evidential adverbs of
uncertainty, and (iii) monotonicity entailments. We design evaluation sets for
these tasks and conduct experiments in both zero-shot and chain-of-thought
setups, and with multiple prompts and LLMs. The models exhibit moderate to low
performance on these evaluation sets. Subsequent experiments show that
embedding the premise in syntactic constructions that should preserve the
entailment relations (presupposition triggers) or change them (non-factives),
further confuses the models, causing them to either under-predict or
over-predict certain entailment labels regardless of the true relation, and
often disregarding the nature of the embedding context. Overall these results
suggest that, despite LLMs' celebrated language understanding capacity, even
the strongest models have blindspots with respect to certain types of
entailments, and certain information-packaging structures act as ``blinds''
overshadowing the semantics of the embedded premise. | [
0.0385386012,
0.0414064601,
-0.033966057,
0.0541296266,
-0.0608669557,
0.0379439741,
-0.0224660635,
-0.0371111594,
0.0316426605,
-0.0762211531,
-0.0105611654,
0.0073688682,
0.003466333,
-0.0154599557,
0.0414259173,
-0.0177766513,
0.0537046529,
-0.0593932047,
0.0088536264,
-0.0306142736,
-0.0164682288,
-0.020236697,
-0.0029960533,
0.0185569022,
-0.0003045825,
-0.0167170968,
0.0108856168,
-0.0135253463,
-0.0096919145,
-0.0419312865,
-0.0325378962,
0.0409922041,
0.0350970551,
0.0157022495,
0.0000021456,
-0.0815961286,
0.0384737588,
-0.0338564515,
-0.0620697327,
0.0490502864,
-0.0123324776,
-0.0500195734,
0.0160130709,
-0.0232493095,
-0.008731273,
-0.0182801504,
0.0192462653,
0.0449657887,
-0.0037342091,
0.0190332066,
-0.0003784614,
-0.0168680586,
-0.006222256,
-0.0194058884,
-0.0037097316,
-0.0430748612,
0.044020243,
0.0321977921,
-0.0234791115,
0.0083997343,
-0.0208245907,
0.029708378,
0.0321420506,
0.0197904781,
-0.0296101682,
0.0434509031,
-0.016396543,
-0.0577214472,
0.0024370083,
0.0178731233,
0.0158836525,
-0.0413479395,
-0.0411090441,
-0.0147593524,
0.0164260082,
0.0229194593,
-0.0452126749,
0.0859431848,
-0.0221220162,
0.0149636557,
0.0627126768,
-0.0041747745,
0.0197869744,
0.0281104874,
-0.0224861857,
0.1041241139,
-0.009284582,
-0.042566184,
0.017511839,
0.0237718225,
-0.0742523447,
-0.0493288711,
-0.0380224921,
0.0030483827,
0.0082824212,
0.0587412156,
-0.0113518732,
0.0041771578,
0.0249988362,
-0.0621556938,
0.0262934119,
0.0437922552,
-0.0320901386,
0.0782681555,
-0.038684383,
0.0512465201,
-0.0329310745,
-0.0028534431,
-0.0099438271,
-0.0114431083,
-0.0004235157,
-0.0345083177,
-0.0043509677,
0.033420898,
0.0189840887,
-0.0007669486,
0.0013804962,
0.0095189326,
-0.0232879389,
0.0223552939,
-0.0723292381,
-0.032920897,
-0.0095902123,
-0.036212679,
-0.0786856711,
0.0355664119,
-0.0277850125,
0.0591577999,
-0.0228342153,
-0.0830053389,
-0.0271065254,
0.0133612053,
-0.0265466645,
-0.0045912163,
0.0111433147,
0.0276018959,
0.0024697685,
-0.0075291232,
-0.0393640064,
-0.0264083687,
-0.0248558763,
-0.0465858318,
-0.0104175191,
-0.0617107339,
-0.0113619212,
0.058410909,
-0.0087090554,
-0.0172205754,
0.0186102334,
0.0193517078,
-0.0459821299,
0.062849313,
0.0294162482,
0.0344938077,
0.0020889305,
0.0053060595,
-0.0490490347,
0.0712178126,
-0.0064801504,
0.0381440036,
0.0106680235,
0.0333081,
-0.0151259294,
0.0206231084,
-0.0056139352,
0.003794088,
-0.0446073189,
0.0223287884,
0.0283798389,
0.0164289642,
0.0212939065,
0.0444311202,
-0.0178113002,
-0.0101023158,
0.0865457952,
0.0407183394,
-0.0337688737,
-0.0161996782,
0.0290279277,
-0.0129811205,
0.0336149521,
0.041530814,
-0.0657240376,
-0.005270394,
-0.0485525951,
-0.0197279733,
-0.0183005407,
0.0018090738,
0.0026539075,
-0.0458588041,
-0.0652602687,
0.0140917841,
-0.0218802858,
0.0207976997,
0.0629359484,
0.0170195196,
-0.0104088327,
0.0428539217,
0.0534778498,
-0.0203992873,
-0.0161088016,
-0.0229749177,
0.0403205454,
0.0016404983,
0.0027913703,
-0.0032094708,
-0.0116373738,
0.0004252967,
0.0218786709,
0.0579270013,
0.0291861184,
0.0233765785,
0.0011137882,
0.0110097164,
0.009890914,
-0.0297579709,
0.0468483232,
0.0042285863,
-0.0304666776,
-0.0103535121,
0.0067996848,
-0.0350828916,
0.0344164297,
0.0403093472,
-0.0228806455,
0.0000929095,
-0.0436884575,
0.0071994783,
0.0351826027,
-0.0262161251,
0.0075670895,
0.0162386894,
0.0222639963,
-0.0508883707,
0.0076301512,
0.0295567326,
-0.0500954203,
-0.023302095,
0.0125713162,
-0.0473590903,
-0.0427133814,
-0.0011600516,
-0.0006749578,
-0.0164703894,
0.0125981653,
-0.0516129136,
0.0269361846,
-0.0275217984,
0.0170570463,
-0.0306791048,
-0.0073662396,
-0.0324385613,
0.0959446505,
-0.0066719656,
0.0264037531,
0.021337159,
-0.0086901113,
0.0137818484,
-0.0105280802,
0.0001757978,
-0.0193167105,
0.0144048994,
-0.0546206981,
0.0110245049,
-0.0306015369,
-0.036681328,
-0.0304350499,
-0.0969699174,
-0.0084042074,
0.0023982308,
0.0165044796,
0.0184753705,
-0.0328332633,
-0.0163108148,
0.0015967123,
0.0207622685,
-0.0139530227,
-0.0295645408,
0.0476802103,
0.0350707024,
-0.0180345904,
0.0174901411,
-0.0109169502,
0.0222440101,
-0.0482847877,
0.0620773211,
0.029968176,
-0.0141684534,
-0.0473264195,
0.0277717784,
-0.026182225,
-0.0030752704,
-0.02463549,
-0.0174109396,
0.0061726714,
0.0093526868,
0.0444285013,
0.0713460222,
-0.0193923153,
0.0450888686,
0.0944702625,
-0.0148240803,
-0.0392895713,
0.0024358516,
-0.0172148347,
0.0014915876,
-0.0210370943,
-0.0396496765,
-0.0294399466,
0.0882872641,
0.02724557,
0.0010204293,
-0.0415638089,
0.0541367643,
-0.0519962236,
-0.0124513488,
-0.0375680812,
-0.0403710082,
0.0017193272,
0.0742619112,
-0.0243304633,
-0.0342183374,
0.0692000687,
-0.0114835026,
-0.0135706291,
-0.0054226145,
-0.0067622014,
-0.0344765559,
0.0850351825,
0.0374616347,
-0.0014165214,
0.0401512608,
-0.0071500856,
-0.0632090569,
-0.005899461,
0.0421052501,
-0.0111107696,
0.0474999622,
-0.0412223525,
-0.0037158527,
-0.0080859344,
-0.0417473689,
-0.0633367449,
-0.0656469017,
-0.0571208894,
-0.0002473473,
-0.0185714457,
0.0306620058,
-0.001655284,
0.0166052803,
0.0492563024,
-0.016437022,
-0.0076166461,
-0.0080141714,
-0.0331384949,
-0.0226164758,
0.0364695489,
0.0044550234,
0.0605649464,
-0.0291990098,
0.0173996221,
0.040944282,
-0.0297802836,
0.0553714149,
-0.0212132502,
0.0188949853,
0.0094722901,
0.0102318181,
-0.0508538149,
0.0053102719,
0.0510781035,
-0.055439312,
0.004116036,
0.1050392836,
0.019853808,
0.0058418452,
0.0329264738,
-0.0609993078,
0.0422638431,
0.0187439658,
-0.0073517901,
-0.0955612808,
-0.0322225653,
0.0346579365,
-0.0406642072,
-0.0519128144,
-0.0347045995,
-0.0144689651,
-0.1378811449,
0.0406269543,
-0.0050274483,
0.0100221317,
0.0020814133,
-0.0565884747,
0.0273072943,
0.0173769072,
0.0261872988,
0.0245146938,
-0.0176711008,
0.0039531579,
0.0066222847,
0.00066024,
-0.0314781219,
0.01772701,
-0.0103179989,
0.0285856724,
-0.0124037769,
-0.0021474743,
-0.0160117391,
-0.0207315795,
0.0491372719,
-0.0455795377,
-0.0023752465,
-0.0230982825,
-0.0170715563,
-0.00061248,
0.0008019137,
-0.0462813824,
0.016307164,
0.0000277493,
-0.0274182204,
0.0262601748,
0.0831595957,
-0.017131824,
-0.0581495576,
-0.0075308909,
0.0140165817,
-0.048263479,
0.1044269353,
0.0540466309,
-0.0091867009,
-0.0114162527,
-0.01911279,
0.0004922918,
0.0493752509,
-0.0084058745,
0.0436170176,
0.0148407798,
-0.0260710455,
-0.0366531275,
-0.0407247357,
0.0212710705,
-0.0173457563,
0.0093079666,
0.0066243587,
0.0418371893,
-0.0051754261,
-0.0015283028,
0.0414059423,
-0.0184016824,
-0.0045505958,
0.0127402851,
0.0349783972,
0.0410294011,
-0.0333718471,
-0.0266782977,
0.0212367345,
-0.0669833422,
-0.0681453049,
0.0140724555,
0.0147965783,
0.0283988602,
0.0309900194,
-0.0027016725,
-0.0284367818,
0.00478072,
0.0240584314,
-0.0021392135,
0.054081291,
0.0173863862,
0.0234876182,
0.0294398069,
0.0600391291,
-0.0274368562,
0.0475752987,
0.029043071,
0.0175578296,
-0.0335313939,
-0.0351510905,
0.0527834818,
0.0257439055,
0.0607407801,
0.0135938423,
-0.0208468251,
-0.0195194669,
0.0108843837,
-0.0306167733,
-0.0308009945,
-0.0229133274,
-0.0015643102,
0.0201962478,
0.0139249312,
-0.0182669181,
-0.0183988083,
-0.0018151755,
0.0425167605,
0.0086830137,
-0.0070727039,
0.0078641474,
0.0069331066,
0.0143576879,
-0.0148623353,
-0.0450407863,
0.0270729922,
-0.0543212555,
0.0306262765,
0.0097339218,
0.032920789,
0.0440598205,
-0.0019084276,
-0.0205146205,
-0.0481077209,
-0.0506989732,
-0.0320904888,
0.0482879877,
0.0345197506,
0.0568714514,
-0.0260753706,
0.0561497472,
-0.0613661297,
0.0069432063,
0.0041116574,
0.0164480824,
0.0131950174,
-0.0259521902,
0.0760781169,
0.0284579732,
-0.0298522003,
0.0205461625,
0.050869938,
0.0039162282,
0.0509136952,
0.0291862395,
-0.0028319894,
-0.0186590124,
-0.0450275354,
-0.0252668522,
0.0172264986,
-0.0070952103,
0.0721391439,
-0.0857087821,
-0.068300046,
-0.0176052637,
0.0043242658,
-0.0049821008,
-0.053615801,
-0.007739983,
0.0616177432,
0.0266692415,
-0.0653178021,
0.0005765324,
0.0362906568,
-0.0135037489,
0.025340246,
-0.030225357,
-7.210051823e-33,
-0.0443990566,
-0.0372407995,
-0.0144500844,
-0.0027775371,
-0.0026505899,
0.0124413399,
-0.0553163849,
0.0302827638,
-0.034530215,
0.0441141799,
0.0097897258,
0.0084792469,
0.0054732757,
-0.0045473576,
0.0123412088,
-0.0244809091,
0.0101061258,
0.0402782038,
-0.0337668024,
-0.0466748066,
0.0547222048,
-0.0135140512,
0.0302844029,
-0.0455737188,
0.0229999479,
-0.0441244394,
-0.0055238181,
0.0506077893,
-0.0459585339,
0.0282643903,
-0.0086831516,
0.0279866531,
0.0438049659,
-0.0022083786,
0.0084892455,
0.0295412205,
-0.0357043669,
-0.0453004725,
0.0947990268,
-0.001559382,
-0.0269675795,
-0.03186303,
0.0595078617,
0.0019832719,
-0.0342478901,
0.0071205334,
0.0336822867,
-0.0324186161,
0.0055419835,
0.0161705967,
-0.0666165501,
0.0205576774,
0.0063276449,
-0.0076434743,
-0.0117858807,
0.044027403,
-0.0184133947,
-0.015901342,
-0.0431031287,
-0.0038431024,
0.0127697727,
0.0180956926,
0.0560909696,
0.016753301,
0.0326610506,
0.0670129731,
-0.0138649605,
0.0269128848,
-0.0538569242,
-0.029091591,
0.0337831266,
0.0259211492,
0.0321209356,
0.0054656123,
0.0418253876,
0.0450364985,
-0.0798367113,
-0.0657909289,
0.0675512701,
0.0377190039,
0.0473001488,
0.0027673303,
-0.0278964657,
-0.0367207751,
-0.0758598298,
-0.0162985083,
-0.0298269987,
-0.0224015098,
0.036544349,
-0.0249195583,
0.0020466277,
0.0010865298,
0.0125340726,
-0.0197012182,
-0.0173512101,
-0.0107818488,
-0.010376459,
0.0025305722,
0.0120451851,
0.073906377,
-0.0607194975,
-0.0053176195,
-0.0113353962,
0.0172145907,
0.0249535888,
0.0413092114,
0.0296282358,
-0.0236033779,
-0.0133942449,
-0.031190468,
-0.043292392,
-0.020066211,
-0.0372982696,
-0.0318423398,
0.0928576291,
0.0279596727,
-0.0088761114,
0.021964401,
0.0092563191,
0.0002742823,
-0.0399927273,
0.0397125445,
-0.029121507,
0.0265452582,
-0.0328184702,
-0.0369199775,
-0.0288217701,
0.0005347219,
0.0398305058,
-0.0484046303,
-0.0146042472,
0.0370665155,
2.976e-7,
0.0404741168,
0.0831045285,
-0.0378344543,
0.0452065542,
0.0257569496,
0.0469889492,
-0.0327191316,
-0.0051522152,
0.0465437174,
-0.0471982993,
-0.0287576001,
0.0347453356,
0.0405914225,
0.0381060392,
-0.0567933619,
0.0146910371,
-0.0631470233,
0.0009619185,
-0.0395473763,
0.033759173,
0.0604313351,
0.0782603323,
0.0251179077,
0.0152640352,
-0.0158067085,
-0.0498551615,
0.05132984,
-0.0500306264,
-0.0307002235,
-0.0213631112,
0.0072593479,
0.0425307862,
0.0078071188,
0.0631702766,
0.0466968343,
0.0103366459,
-0.0200881567,
0.0443178453,
0.0092429025,
0.0519047901,
-0.047842402,
-0.0210604854,
-0.0153593123,
-0.0827659965,
0.0860039443,
-0.101667583,
-0.0590768121,
-0.0282238498,
0.009546008,
-0.045364812,
0.0071336101,
0.0288139805,
-0.0199785493,
-0.0125914216,
0.0299667045,
-0.0288291555,
-0.020444002,
-0.0347347409,
-0.0310283341,
0.0209190585,
-0.0390071422,
-0.0566989332,
-0.0239058211,
0.0014872116,
0.0550308004,
-0.0823748261,
-0.0055973488,
2.818917187e-34,
0.0311462414,
-0.0207208917,
0.0297260117,
0.0185063593,
0.0363969319,
0.0010606135,
-0.0038773653,
0.030197382,
0.0365882069,
-0.0845930278,
0.0106788781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14784v1 | Anthropomorphization of AI: Opportunities and Risks | 2023-05-24T06:39:45 | 2023-05-24T06:39:45 | Ameet Deshpande, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Karthik Narasimhan, Ashwin Kalyan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Anthropomorphization is the tendency to attribute human-like traits to
non-human entities. It is prevalent in many social contexts -- children
anthropomorphize toys, adults do so with brands, and it is a literary device.
It is also a versatile tool in science, with behavioral psychology and
evolutionary biology meticulously documenting its consequences. With widespread
adoption of AI systems, and the push from stakeholders to make it human-like
through alignment techniques, human voice, and pictorial avatars, the tendency
for users to anthropomorphize it increases significantly. We take a dyadic
approach to understanding this phenomenon with large language models (LLMs) by
studying (1) the objective legal implications, as analyzed through the lens of
the recent blueprint of AI bill of rights and the (2) subtle psychological
aspects customization and anthropomorphization. We find that anthropomorphized
LLMs customized for different user bases violate multiple provisions in the
legislative blueprint. In addition, we point out that anthropomorphization of
LLMs affects the influence they can have on their users, thus having the
potential to fundamentally change the nature of human-AI interaction, with
potential for manipulation and negative influence. With LLMs being
hyper-personalized for vulnerable groups like children and patients among
others, our work is a timely and important contribution. We propose a
conservative strategy for the cautious use of anthropomorphization to improve
trustworthiness of AI systems. | [
0.0464831553,
0.0933060944,
-0.0440763049,
0.0060826419,
0.0037556607,
0.0090018949,
0.0395984016,
-0.0222376939,
0.0196339116,
-0.0311126504,
-0.045791246,
-0.0434651375,
0.0221489128,
0.0004679805,
0.0250581149,
-0.0637204349,
0.019737998,
0.0019556915,
0.0299450122,
-0.0104862452,
-0.0052275076,
0.0355146825,
0.0304310322,
0.0650193766,
-0.0126381945,
-0.0536721237,
0.0546978638,
0.0120909521,
0.0188419353,
-0.0295290332,
0.0032874525,
0.0096569294,
0.025022557,
0.0292945839,
0.0000019708,
-0.0668296516,
0.054605078,
0.0390648022,
-0.0192955062,
-0.0087917475,
0.0614119358,
-0.004231663,
-0.0277060699,
-0.0021679678,
-0.0476983301,
0.0194905363,
0.0434875712,
0.016465975,
0.0327004194,
0.0440326221,
-0.0263528507,
0.0094188098,
0.0057282168,
0.0149674509,
0.0096169645,
-0.0070105791,
-0.0043829423,
-0.0200600233,
0.0379696265,
-0.0262060687,
0.0365291536,
0.0413014255,
0.006687304,
0.0079894066,
0.0208110083,
-0.0091070915,
0.0013291929,
-0.0675694197,
0.009450376,
0.0767588764,
0.0235000271,
-0.0171291586,
0.0070150658,
0.0525217764,
0.0412249267,
0.0106117986,
0.0047295569,
0.0704858005,
0.0016484347,
-0.0005366559,
-0.0214804579,
-0.0083329855,
0.0222007167,
0.0446492992,
-0.0239193905,
0.054319676,
-0.0024329142,
-0.0286209434,
-0.0078512803,
-0.0215423536,
-0.0003651099,
-0.043012049,
0.0140671693,
0.0323347561,
-0.0228512026,
0.017909782,
-0.1117726713,
-0.0099343788,
0.0097951973,
-0.0720884204,
0.0045127724,
0.0204603821,
-0.0088839838,
0.0188773908,
0.0305332486,
0.0569750927,
-0.0139487348,
0.0243704468,
-0.0110687744,
0.0268399641,
-0.0040986906,
-0.0260632299,
-0.0082809748,
-0.0074645653,
-0.0042029265,
-0.0110950088,
0.0044203033,
0.0463181622,
-0.0697728395,
0.0230371151,
-0.0645114109,
0.0175136384,
-0.006657395,
-0.0332894661,
-0.0058012311,
-0.0365312137,
-0.0375680365,
0.0334546641,
-0.0391485468,
-0.0771834329,
0.0354573429,
-0.0030220712,
-0.0149398427,
-0.0042019556,
0.0097426521,
0.0723744556,
0.0269449838,
-0.0315627716,
0.0365887582,
-0.0146521088,
0.0034214335,
-0.0428435653,
0.0019606908,
-0.0193407834,
0.0095242234,
-0.0128673268,
-0.0072446498,
-0.0910534412,
-0.0064686607,
0.0169399232,
-0.0441928133,
0.0619255416,
-0.0174223986,
0.0250290725,
0.0201242361,
0.0361182392,
0.0154727716,
-0.0008205744,
0.0517445132,
0.0187895503,
0.0266314596,
-0.0144852092,
0.0135282492,
0.0346869417,
-0.0413004495,
0.0065277135,
0.0328791477,
0.0083070146,
-0.013958592,
0.0335679837,
0.0154956523,
0.0455994159,
0.0097590135,
-0.0035018148,
0.0838469416,
0.0908724144,
-0.0608069375,
0.0436369516,
0.004283784,
-0.0000412946,
0.0206949338,
-0.0058863298,
-0.0610739626,
0.0040030526,
-0.0049829362,
-0.0491664894,
-0.0580797195,
0.0410249829,
-0.0266975071,
-0.015428246,
0.014932354,
-0.0149026355,
0.0589961857,
0.0223973896,
-0.010642495,
0.0138107939,
0.0278065708,
-0.0418387391,
-0.007320825,
-0.0559461527,
0.004043431,
-0.0752869025,
-0.0039169341,
0.0945292339,
0.0396928228,
-0.0229865126,
0.030366376,
-0.0306086298,
-0.0193456244,
0.0694387183,
0.0229275338,
-0.0193918087,
-0.0497047789,
0.0169976857,
0.0239026956,
0.0074058492,
-0.0010130217,
0.0175715499,
-0.039187897,
0.0304044783,
-0.0029046645,
0.0135271577,
-0.0324042104,
0.0216880254,
-0.0165332537,
-0.04486233,
-0.0565717407,
0.0213770028,
0.0066199047,
0.0279405862,
-0.0136160022,
0.0087611629,
0.0236268956,
-0.0109422673,
0.0029980966,
0.0479373857,
0.0072969734,
0.0864755288,
0.0490113571,
-0.0513004027,
-0.0160070956,
0.0348571427,
0.0250363462,
0.0078892196,
0.038833607,
-0.0313098617,
0.0513124652,
-0.0033371153,
0.0395601578,
-0.0408604406,
0.0135058658,
-0.0183047708,
-0.0368376486,
-0.0052894591,
-0.0615569726,
-0.0248173438,
-0.0125971325,
0.0029763239,
-0.0011648844,
-0.0562193803,
0.0341143459,
-0.0200393964,
0.0507907867,
0.021097973,
-0.0469620787,
-0.0279481616,
0.0231886189,
-0.0787746683,
-0.051706098,
0.0298216045,
0.007683822,
0.0144296885,
-0.0095209293,
-0.0131812226,
-0.0032866276,
-0.047935497,
-0.0508366376,
-0.0505658165,
0.0320522338,
0.0089792749,
-0.0353463441,
-0.032019306,
-0.0296696518,
0.0119339423,
-0.0398214534,
0.0227627344,
0.01666338,
-0.0268210303,
-0.0503161252,
0.004247711,
-0.0601767451,
0.011841041,
-0.0108855888,
-0.0100850156,
0.0483817756,
0.0244060457,
0.0108586019,
0.0719070062,
0.0194936823,
0.0445493199,
0.0521962047,
0.0710909963,
-0.0295454171,
-0.0281096268,
0.0618628375,
-0.0079757972,
0.0136295911,
-0.0591911115,
0.0286057405,
0.0224942062,
-0.0148250572,
0.0060962443,
-0.0540097244,
0.0913530588,
-0.0450167283,
-0.0611172318,
0.0113083962,
-0.0497575141,
-0.0364204645,
0.0227376837,
-0.015380919,
-0.052737698,
0.0529532842,
-0.0191675518,
0.0216145925,
0.0182427894,
-0.0063303639,
0.0129012875,
0.0493973009,
0.0134255784,
0.0556146055,
0.0592588037,
0.0027140134,
-0.056573458,
0.0135540189,
0.0025420331,
-0.0633858442,
0.0500812456,
-0.0160266422,
0.0092142019,
0.0309022181,
-0.0484961197,
-0.0202552695,
-0.0436267443,
-0.0384124815,
-0.0144766821,
-0.0063194772,
-0.0587900281,
-0.0237089209,
-0.0399308093,
0.0404409245,
0.0097048478,
0.0131569374,
0.0053481739,
0.0026598638,
-0.0556933954,
0.0464918241,
0.0243709236,
-0.0019396513,
0.0051778676,
0.0111049423,
0.0150153683,
0.0290895924,
0.0069925012,
-0.0108964005,
-0.0000171732,
0.0158815794,
0.0160681829,
-0.0095581301,
0.0171294976,
0.0543967523,
-0.0342158899,
0.0381682701,
0.0570341535,
-0.0044146311,
-0.0313581005,
0.0605131388,
0.0030782714,
-0.0325182565,
0.0158399753,
0.0088699553,
-0.0794033557,
0.0352461226,
-0.0081322994,
0.033205945,
-0.0544258729,
-0.0342304371,
-0.0056014191,
-0.0523916334,
0.0127087822,
0.0214559548,
-0.0038690299,
-0.0240238514,
-0.0009630558,
0.0133150145,
0.0335026085,
0.0308692344,
-0.0101870866,
-0.0264038686,
-0.0200705137,
-0.0208607484,
-0.0342777036,
0.0045398418,
0.0163457803,
-0.0306915641,
0.0625521839,
0.0853490606,
0.063495636,
-0.0222106706,
-0.0291380528,
-0.0147610651,
0.0482960939,
0.0009023475,
0.0361450985,
-0.0024175972,
-0.0410506353,
0.0006850902,
-0.0513478294,
0.0152261341,
0.0073222374,
-0.0025129993,
0.0092298975,
0.0635089129,
-0.0371542685,
-0.0618610159,
-0.0433940291,
-0.039253287,
-0.0007471228,
0.0436523035,
0.0225842036,
-0.0619810969,
-0.0075964672,
-0.0198361333,
0.0184852108,
0.0361144207,
-0.085534513,
0.0233235769,
-0.0049031107,
-0.062821351,
-0.0953302383,
-0.0594227538,
-0.0245480891,
0.0013258709,
0.0438807346,
-0.058162231,
0.0382330567,
0.0054902704,
-0.0103206551,
0.0383288302,
-0.0212294012,
0.0348034129,
0.0029896714,
0.0122924903,
0.0047640819,
-0.0078064767,
0.0427964032,
-0.0011059662,
0.0637900233,
-0.0521533675,
0.0463387929,
0.0243581831,
0.0277123395,
0.0214107744,
0.0001359725,
-0.0633726418,
0.0365229324,
0.0163548104,
-0.0160995983,
0.0272977855,
0.028686529,
0.0162527617,
-0.0277867615,
0.0165349953,
-0.0282545295,
0.0097776391,
-0.0037003078,
-0.0211939029,
-0.0324175954,
-0.0369128622,
0.0183128901,
0.0681748539,
-0.0228815228,
-0.0517970957,
0.0457514673,
0.0140930153,
-0.0433959588,
-0.0309993867,
-0.0081129903,
-0.0043724412,
-0.0484698042,
0.0220408328,
0.043753203,
0.0117634134,
-0.0105937412,
-0.0452987812,
0.0129201747,
-0.0116110779,
0.0533995591,
-0.03417328,
0.0649185032,
0.0036523694,
0.0051793624,
-0.0111529753,
0.0775472894,
-0.0533205047,
0.0436179079,
0.0414993279,
0.0346708894,
-0.0014134964,
0.0017437965,
-0.0529765375,
0.0956248641,
-0.0283685531,
-0.0750108212,
0.0005494009,
0.011209894,
-0.0163392052,
0.0263883006,
0.0467294529,
-0.014518179,
0.0048313234,
-0.0039089345,
-0.0105610518,
0.0088848406,
-0.0080785397,
-0.0181838851,
0.0272575356,
-0.0202018395,
0.0114387209,
0.0137419589,
-0.0265374444,
0.0589618944,
-0.0349092185,
-0.0139731467,
-0.0160120204,
-0.0510330014,
-0.0152814202,
-0.0333942287,
-0.0313463621,
-0.0427402183,
-0.0695435554,
-0.0739257634,
-0.0388228185,
-0.0124772843,
-0.0132647529,
-0.0483453274,
0.0054078177,
0.0071904566,
-0.010288436,
-0.0227088071,
-0.0113837896,
0.0099606486,
-0.0388887823,
-0.0117197447,
-0.0050473413,
-5.834053034e-33,
0.010811775,
-0.0038953105,
-0.0295545179,
-0.0160132144,
-0.0338061936,
-0.031715598,
-0.0296040624,
0.0214008093,
-0.0174730271,
-0.0083492948,
-0.015964441,
-0.0229421761,
-0.0007252858,
-0.0314472839,
0.007744615,
0.0039605619,
0.0506099239,
-0.0132835796,
-0.0110383686,
0.0050234115,
-0.0070910635,
-0.0225772727,
-0.0050768126,
-0.1134450957,
0.0824762732,
-0.0051254798,
-0.0492650233,
-0.0342703201,
-0.0026706643,
0.0067305919,
-0.0073886812,
0.0539498851,
0.0160039477,
0.026081346,
0.0008544439,
0.1155283228,
-0.0211096276,
0.0042396723,
0.0151107665,
0.0005242724,
0.0055683078,
-0.0601328798,
0.0247672256,
-0.0341584273,
-0.0448393375,
0.0382546335,
0.0355062447,
-0.0365817733,
0.0199235696,
0.0051632067,
-0.0947937816,
-0.0229074992,
-0.0295717716,
-0.0003703195,
0.0167535506,
0.0584096238,
-0.0307965949,
-0.014765854,
-0.0705991238,
0.0373821333,
-0.042919714,
-0.0726876631,
0.050971061,
0.0183156133,
0.0725497901,
0.062054731,
0.0644832924,
0.0592941046,
-0.068760246,
0.0023577709,
0.0379151627,
0.0381519459,
0.0161051545,
0.0359701402,
-0.0200168565,
-0.0405217819,
0.0262168124,
0.0063282871,
0.0078827087,
0.0161266774,
0.0186246503,
0.0140773132,
-0.1026700139,
-0.0241979398,
0.0021002174,
-0.0554729626,
-0.0101276953,
-0.0556229502,
-0.0168363806,
-0.0443865396,
-0.0387889892,
0.004087992,
-0.0095682684,
-0.0663862228,
-0.0079197856,
-0.0530592836,
-0.0029564342,
0.0065713958,
0.0029932603,
-0.0024569302,
0.008489904,
-0.0313948207,
0.0262136329,
0.0102757448,
0.0851208493,
0.0316926539,
0.0117057823,
-0.0077941031,
-0.0278875902,
-0.0311980359,
0.0088190576,
-0.0036885706,
0.0549833216,
0.0268992148,
0.0430376008,
-0.0004883521,
0.0012916628,
-0.0109922541,
0.0369751863,
0.0142636513,
-0.0612874106,
0.0569494851,
-0.0649850219,
-0.0328828655,
-0.0532993227,
-0.0292832498,
-0.0628887042,
0.0722067431,
0.082446292,
-0.0904757753,
-0.0293764155,
-0.0630972534,
2.821e-7,
-0.0276754927,
0.0582103617,
-0.0085332245,
-0.0425386466,
0.0204559062,
0.0815994143,
0.0243765973,
0.073781386,
0.0054717404,
-0.0322224051,
0.0242904183,
0.0054307897,
0.0452741385,
0.0247867368,
-0.0229908247,
0.01333474,
-0.0423078947,
0.0213994756,
-0.0486035496,
0.0444849245,
0.0347197242,
0.0495193116,
0.0158913676,
-0.0363855995,
-0.0013609868,
-0.0178791657,
-0.007946155,
-0.0372184068,
0.017808266,
-0.0132257091,
-0.0286134798,
0.0471782871,
-0.0200663637,
0.0053327018,
0.002289074,
0.0323790163,
0.0130729759,
0.0547903106,
-0.0470593162,
0.0183785688,
0.0095048472,
-0.0099875294,
-0.0150538431,
-0.0382884741,
0.0415840335,
-0.013358851,
-0.0443702303,
-0.0300413314,
0.0024518364,
-0.0296190176,
0.0106287189,
-0.0095020076,
-0.0110213142,
0.017911924,
0.0086815283,
-0.0155793251,
0.0344559923,
-0.0753440559,
0.0077011222,
-0.0044074329,
-0.0144107863,
-0.031410329,
0.0019940159,
0.043934375,
0.0146712046,
-0.0323587917,
0.0558526032,
2.095276206e-34,
-0.0164765157,
0.0043579596,
0.0352914445,
-0.0080508869,
0.0256425757,
0.0457143374,
0.0401818492,
0.013800892,
0.060020756,
-0.0577095672,
-0.0149072725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14783v1 | Disentangled Phonetic Representation for Chinese Spelling Correction | 2023-05-24T06:39:12 | 2023-05-24T06:39:12 | Zihong Liang, Xiaojun Quan, Qifan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chinese Spelling Correction (CSC) aims to detect and correct erroneous
characters in Chinese texts. Although efforts have been made to introduce
phonetic information (Hanyu Pinyin) in this task, they typically merge phonetic
representations with character representations, which tends to weaken the
representation effect of normal texts. In this work, we propose to disentangle
the two types of features to allow for direct interaction between textual and
phonetic information. To learn useful phonetic representations, we introduce a
pinyin-to-character objective to ask the model to predict the correct
characters based solely on phonetic information, where a separation mask is
imposed to disable attention from phonetic input to text. To avoid overfitting
the phonetics, we further design a self-distillation module to ensure that
semantic information plays a major role in the prediction. Extensive
experiments on three CSC benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of our method
in using phonetic information. | [
0.0153825944,
0.0323360525,
0.0163341295,
0.0211197734,
-0.0217097457,
0.0242853705,
0.0317577161,
0.0082659991,
0.0268869922,
-0.0002838045,
-0.0307700671,
-0.0376308858,
0.072941415,
-0.0177220218,
0.0253246613,
-0.0219626967,
0.0474151224,
-0.0118571958,
-0.0054787472,
-0.0324856788,
0.0246692169,
0.0159460865,
0.01078289,
0.0150702298,
-0.0034017349,
-0.0491938218,
-0.0163061153,
0.0185288433,
-0.0070578917,
0.009371439,
0.0140640838,
0.0516287982,
0.0081024766,
0.0565798692,
0.0000018021,
-0.0330852419,
-0.0424439907,
-0.0140290949,
-0.0350202322,
0.0174350236,
-0.018186843,
-0.0254094414,
-0.0466451459,
0.0462170057,
0.0221109353,
-0.0102511421,
0.0815606266,
0.0524336547,
0.0514976494,
0.0680232123,
-0.0176878162,
-0.0429619923,
0.0217478164,
-0.0400489531,
0.0229094196,
0.0255825762,
0.0163643006,
-0.0279552452,
-0.0742755607,
-0.0539145842,
-0.0801744536,
0.0193887837,
-0.0111954184,
0.0157048889,
0.0008883807,
0.0146866944,
0.0011111591,
-0.0458175577,
0.0013783945,
0.0603018552,
-0.0301936604,
-0.033693973,
-0.0174600445,
0.0199773554,
-0.0346121415,
-0.0061043212,
0.0010017651,
-0.0356992967,
-0.0279041175,
0.058802139,
0.0345226303,
-0.0031178989,
0.0320343338,
0.0301041007,
-0.0463807099,
0.0018683695,
0.0181823988,
-0.0550735481,
-0.0381593034,
0.0330030732,
0.0442061983,
-0.0206569787,
0.0418542586,
0.0092210304,
0.0013112513,
-0.0172193795,
0.0059863827,
-0.0464815907,
-0.0214992408,
-0.0121610705,
0.0039699487,
0.0204693396,
-0.022600146,
-0.0015127643,
-0.036995735,
0.0472947024,
0.0138351917,
0.0292347614,
0.0151903275,
-0.0221502297,
-0.052400969,
-0.0027426518,
-0.0326155499,
0.0438687056,
-0.0029475447,
-0.0025344205,
-0.0205130391,
-0.057628803,
-0.0580185801,
0.0345713049,
0.0319415629,
0.002693143,
-0.077343367,
-0.0211055633,
-0.007212169,
0.0825819969,
0.0031041519,
-0.0183692649,
-0.0262336489,
-0.006678395,
-0.02637472,
0.0027787401,
0.0395419635,
-0.0228418037,
0.0071561425,
0.0526704863,
-0.046396587,
-0.029749034,
-0.0000590423,
0.0149679361,
-0.0481686518,
-0.022296736,
-0.0282029882,
-0.0717774183,
-0.0041118395,
-0.0545653179,
0.0395381302,
-0.0736173689,
0.0305099227,
-0.0259473864,
0.0013582639,
0.0876332819,
-0.0251862425,
0.0052958811,
0.0125688938,
0.0029342638,
0.029177634,
0.0400513709,
0.0309921931,
0.0155850304,
0.0348149613,
0.0036646421,
0.0207852554,
0.0007177122,
-0.0146390507,
-0.0184706356,
-0.0285132434,
-0.0311738718,
-0.031125715,
-0.002344687,
0.0493238419,
0.0767512619,
-0.0283173509,
-0.0159988534,
0.0653143227,
0.0170260184,
0.1152776033,
0.0217415337,
-0.0386440493,
-0.0128443586,
-0.0013450661,
0.0411367528,
-0.0254203752,
0.0327390805,
0.0073375041,
0.0384354815,
0.0489530079,
0.0470276698,
-0.0553999133,
-0.065624103,
0.0064962679,
-0.0209309235,
0.0125268651,
0.0001104177,
0.0581228212,
0.0279038604,
-0.0228374396,
0.0063790213,
0.0040738317,
-0.0431216173,
0.0467741787,
-0.0395816639,
0.0426353067,
0.1339903772,
0.0788805112,
-0.0089920135,
0.0152821224,
-0.0269164052,
-0.0781747028,
0.0567018837,
-0.0102532683,
-0.0251389742,
0.0591973104,
-0.0555560701,
-0.0280673113,
0.0437056087,
0.0087047499,
-0.0039639189,
0.023592744,
0.0122453002,
0.007217065,
-0.0027248303,
-0.0133532574,
0.0299471971,
-0.0288274847,
-0.0478272289,
-0.0113210259,
0.0518100709,
0.0016262113,
0.0178603772,
-0.0510521829,
0.0027852161,
-0.019889079,
-0.0633250475,
-0.0198113248,
-0.0150243798,
-0.0260776524,
-0.1110899895,
0.0443060696,
-0.0605128072,
-0.0143209137,
0.061836578,
-0.0213530101,
-0.074491404,
0.01605957,
-0.0082230791,
0.0236335825,
-0.0930421576,
0.0276317615,
0.0195952598,
0.0342518315,
-0.0179145038,
0.0100385277,
0.0060097864,
0.0033289834,
-0.0188982058,
0.0295184664,
-0.0070601502,
-0.0222861022,
-0.0480782166,
0.0419850014,
0.0273074992,
0.0512336791,
0.0254730973,
0.0061807171,
0.0163081139,
-0.0679290891,
-0.0202072039,
-0.0225398596,
-0.0635715872,
-0.0209365599,
0.0326807089,
0.0268209036,
0.0234086458,
-0.0538037121,
-0.0398804322,
-0.0314975567,
-0.0221069343,
-0.0145415682,
0.0460445136,
-0.0453802645,
0.0125448797,
-0.0448316708,
-0.0262149461,
0.0060564643,
-0.0060001845,
-0.0410770215,
-0.068027541,
-0.040588133,
-0.0072046123,
-0.0332316421,
0.0397688821,
0.0427302308,
-0.0458283946,
-0.0050591631,
-0.0401887074,
0.0197306741,
0.0305747595,
-0.0087232832,
0.0134446686,
0.0531734824,
-0.0093079815,
0.0019278298,
0.022637574,
-0.022230573,
0.0479927845,
0.001637242,
0.0011455804,
-0.0534953699,
0.064133741,
0.0039614812,
-0.0100532584,
-0.0631340742,
-0.0710937381,
0.0058609946,
-0.0207398124,
-0.0497036316,
0.0143967383,
-0.0305509549,
0.0093289679,
-0.0627055243,
-0.0430287197,
0.0879641399,
-0.0303899292,
0.0081960037,
-0.0543606468,
-0.0082115782,
-0.0139114037,
0.0089070536,
-0.032898549,
0.0322268456,
-0.0166180227,
-0.041890569,
-0.070638679,
0.0264253132,
0.0319893733,
-0.0676127225,
0.0484122522,
-0.0049783145,
0.0024704712,
0.0120350104,
-0.0047613233,
-0.0348928198,
-0.0191202946,
-0.0030807357,
0.0095107583,
0.0227498598,
-0.0177332256,
0.0455843508,
0.029507814,
-0.0157791264,
0.0698694885,
0.0177022256,
0.0058262884,
-0.0154955229,
0.0278034993,
0.0168390516,
0.03404852,
0.0173619334,
-0.0239037834,
0.0969956741,
0.0195765104,
0.0232657213,
-0.0124011179,
0.0176442508,
0.000366368,
0.0128072249,
-0.0168778915,
-0.0070769014,
-0.0160123482,
0.017661931,
-0.0424561314,
-0.0460821763,
0.1115022972,
0.0003510266,
-0.0040503386,
-0.0137481745,
0.0391800627,
0.0355706848,
-0.0162641518,
-0.0209752936,
-0.0674351156,
-0.032152798,
0.0214845464,
0.0127015337,
0.0426424108,
0.013371394,
0.0250662398,
-0.0928199738,
0.0023851274,
0.0596070737,
0.019232817,
-0.0904766172,
0.0073591303,
0.002505814,
-0.031757582,
0.0494953357,
0.0191809982,
-0.0074617909,
-0.0182741582,
-0.0026692851,
-0.0431229807,
-0.0304440185,
-0.0127792656,
-0.0312003996,
0.0329037979,
0.0610069484,
0.0163615197,
0.0019521628,
-0.0100237019,
-0.0733212903,
-0.0297047067,
-0.0232919436,
0.0160997529,
0.0905699059,
0.0134638743,
-0.0456462763,
-0.0205373503,
0.0089483596,
-0.0348911211,
-0.0122229625,
-0.0199602805,
0.0039092205,
-0.0128708249,
-0.0051160213,
0.0275418498,
0.024024779,
-0.0205576085,
0.0605065115,
0.0133889299,
-0.0466720015,
-0.0831987783,
-0.0316702388,
0.0136912018,
-0.0540316142,
0.0135123692,
0.044972159,
-0.0214142427,
-0.0699922144,
-0.1084750667,
-0.0482076332,
-0.0199217871,
0.0060849325,
-0.0013289931,
0.0480993837,
0.0164397955,
0.0216384288,
-0.028201839,
-0.0631720126,
0.0093745152,
0.0363516808,
-0.0168036278,
0.0116468696,
-0.0276190657,
-0.0371565893,
0.0231867861,
0.0051350212,
-0.0639463365,
-0.0707486644,
0.0501314513,
-0.0133523447,
0.0159904379,
0.0618472807,
-0.0338253379,
-0.0243550986,
0.0775750279,
0.0069163479,
0.0055661425,
0.0219390318,
0.0225420296,
-0.0309174359,
-0.0086527048,
0.032404121,
-0.0084454147,
0.0344912894,
-0.0243272856,
0.043866165,
-0.0457383282,
0.0181169175,
0.0426235236,
0.0166113023,
0.0668509677,
-0.0151790632,
0.065944843,
-0.063799344,
0.0399278291,
0.0265710223,
0.0036686396,
0.0037051209,
-0.0128399841,
0.0622136369,
-0.0139264511,
-0.0054499093,
0.0454740413,
0.0196956731,
-0.0357218869,
-0.0208598673,
-0.0292287897,
-0.0117789349,
0.0383006111,
-0.0185594652,
0.029279884,
0.0170117542,
0.0739397705,
0.0418236479,
-0.0019641437,
0.0161860287,
-0.0120377857,
-0.0067201499,
0.0516157411,
-0.0137665663,
-0.0024724568,
-0.0623565875,
0.0406915881,
-0.0384230465,
-0.001248037,
0.0782578662,
-0.0036034372,
0.0557990931,
-0.0236898009,
-0.0105775343,
-0.0199167561,
-0.0015104321,
-0.021858478,
0.0600942783,
-0.0295766387,
0.0084472662,
-0.0030912824,
-0.0385093577,
0.0628903732,
0.0072514056,
0.0373549424,
0.0045999195,
0.0051579587,
-0.0176824536,
-0.0463369489,
-0.0026562926,
0.0066495724,
-0.022942882,
-0.026079094,
-0.0309626833,
-0.0884616226,
0.0076939538,
0.0190266352,
0.0076035657,
0.0015076848,
-0.0000052191,
-0.0274384804,
0.0119785555,
0.0417545736,
-0.0371434726,
-0.0231708568,
0.05893334,
0.0030831071,
0.0227418151,
-6.232500435e-33,
-0.0148584684,
0.0320445448,
-0.0186723266,
0.0045560035,
-0.0178330317,
-0.000418904,
-0.0115652066,
-0.0085351216,
-0.0341968648,
0.0383941196,
-0.0009112894,
0.0593900718,
0.0173207913,
0.0101689752,
-0.0002659599,
0.0231836475,
0.107543923,
-0.0103654619,
0.0191975739,
-0.0104917726,
0.0838552266,
0.0621414259,
0.0385435559,
-0.0550415926,
-0.019327281,
-0.0100489166,
-0.0264750738,
-0.0075238403,
0.0031288629,
0.0316292681,
-0.0000194308,
0.0809704065,
-0.0003567901,
0.0167851523,
-0.0539194532,
0.0208780039,
-0.1348509043,
-0.0349672548,
-0.0360872857,
0.0226910971,
-0.0111038079,
-0.0177698396,
0.0527432039,
-0.0225924458,
0.0180027261,
-0.0565686896,
0.0125545748,
-0.026835179,
0.004627943,
-0.0005865975,
-0.0340412557,
0.0309361536,
0.0079955487,
-0.0235537104,
0.0648119897,
0.0006694442,
-0.0001556975,
-0.0037310901,
-0.0830409303,
0.003224767,
0.0438982844,
0.0684429333,
0.0125164036,
0.0226868466,
-0.0312460251,
0.0238539241,
0.0468290821,
-0.0240822807,
-0.011849652,
-0.0157952644,
0.041643884,
0.0236080363,
0.0540704578,
0.0503867269,
0.07073237,
-0.0615459904,
-0.0526574291,
0.0192438085,
-0.0105857337,
0.0155121693,
-0.0183121562,
0.0082001053,
-0.0099476818,
-0.0369065516,
-0.0052289749,
0.0139858294,
-0.0168104954,
-0.0119139617,
0.0098432489,
0.0429196879,
-0.0269106962,
0.0241111442,
-0.0100685488,
-0.0581101477,
0.0175546501,
0.0103480518,
-0.0019347066,
-0.0055484138,
0.0082608098,
-0.0079595624,
-0.0527273789,
-0.0448214635,
0.0388111286,
0.0329133049,
-0.0274103656,
-0.0049215485,
0.0547448397,
0.0207915809,
-0.072095111,
0.0051104086,
-0.0209492855,
-0.001925821,
0.0380963273,
0.0160659086,
0.0068492163,
-0.0124378148,
0.009248754,
-0.0384219699,
0.0137285022,
0.0131563256,
-0.0079920655,
-0.0114172231,
-0.0041669244,
0.023510538,
-0.000950667,
0.0109158196,
-0.0194264315,
-0.0214550942,
0.0552621596,
-0.0299717896,
-0.0001395125,
0.0101146856,
2.537e-7,
0.0483896807,
0.0246777162,
0.0626384616,
-0.0103208171,
0.0389849879,
0.0006003433,
-0.0501061603,
0.0237022694,
-0.0412456766,
-0.0114659155,
0.0506245829,
0.0314210318,
0.0895730034,
0.0201182086,
-0.0257399939,
0.0100187417,
-0.0333394744,
0.0141367009,
0.0052050692,
-0.0325992778,
0.0180227142,
0.0823114067,
-0.006711991,
-0.0258586612,
0.0368769206,
0.0023114588,
0.0446946099,
0.035545934,
0.0350004993,
-0.0037234214,
-0.0049684928,
-0.0065015671,
0.0079788147,
0.0032227384,
-0.0276573133,
0.0178080872,
0.0467719473,
0.0343984254,
-0.036649406,
-0.0243310556,
-0.0215117801,
0.0534204468,
-0.0144348508,
-0.0234131981,
0.035498593,
0.015144364,
0.0368500985,
-0.0133174285,
-0.0155840907,
0.042674955,
0.0500756539,
-0.0059205759,
-0.0322624892,
0.0382392816,
0.0171636306,
0.0315359011,
-0.0215219129,
-0.0651905984,
-0.0457233712,
0.0055498555,
0.005232736,
-0.0164182503,
-0.0019659847,
-0.0410139374,
-0.0242268555,
-0.0299610887,
-0.0067231734,
1.970013278e-34,
-0.0143070761,
-0.0373359583,
-0.0109264776,
-0.0085789394,
-0.0075060818,
-0.0514148213,
-0.0315592475,
-0.0125008198,
-0.0040869094,
-0.0356841311,
-0.0281922389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14779v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14779v3 | Alt-Text with Context: Improving Accessibility for Images on Twitter | 2023-05-24T06:35:26 | 2024-02-29T22:31:53 | Nikita Srivatsan, Sofia Samaniego, Omar Florez, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work we present an approach for generating alternative text (or
alt-text) descriptions for images shared on social media, specifically Twitter.
More than just a special case of image captioning, alt-text is both more
literally descriptive and context-specific. Also critically, images posted to
Twitter are often accompanied by user-written text that despite not necessarily
describing the image may provide useful context that if properly leveraged can
be informative. We address this task with a multimodal model that conditions on
both textual information from the associated social media post as well as
visual signal from the image, and demonstrate that the utility of these two
information sources stacks. We put forward a new dataset of 371k images paired
with alt-text and tweets scraped from Twitter and evaluate on it across a
variety of automated metrics as well as human evaluation. We show that our
approach of conditioning on both tweet text and visual information
significantly outperforms prior work, by more than 2x on BLEU@4. | [
0.0385435931,
0.0391657986,
0.0107115936,
0.0219011158,
-0.0173648782,
0.0347689204,
0.0172199011,
0.0583208241,
0.0071478696,
-0.0563370883,
0.0164092146,
-0.0531787798,
-0.0090187695,
0.0444871895,
0.0436737761,
-0.1094647422,
-0.0238513891,
-0.0017315233,
-0.0078163771,
0.0101160174,
0.0382229351,
0.003146891,
0.0257309433,
0.0141250286,
-0.0334026404,
0.0071173999,
0.012757265,
0.0556781515,
0.0156388935,
-0.0166392233,
-0.0016227348,
0.0628339648,
0.0348610431,
0.0050864434,
0.0000018252,
0.0218869317,
0.0311243087,
-0.0109544918,
0.0520325787,
-0.0133910645,
0.0978984982,
-0.0245799664,
0.017311614,
-0.0133732436,
-0.041965276,
0.0029620922,
0.0732858777,
0.0415880717,
0.0446678028,
0.0511686839,
-0.039737124,
-0.0080220848,
-0.0411083512,
-0.0117044151,
0.0621575229,
-0.0367267057,
-0.0091596162,
-0.0150270946,
-0.0112295998,
0.0765447468,
-0.0012710292,
0.0805227011,
0.0136421528,
-0.0157239921,
0.0279986709,
0.0479140542,
0.0053339829,
0.0025000682,
-0.0272851195,
0.0807566419,
0.0074842437,
-0.01766924,
-0.0136497421,
-0.0132827498,
0.0085559413,
0.0322073959,
-0.0522619896,
0.0027032096,
-0.002532488,
0.0082178842,
-0.0501477495,
0.0690782815,
0.013505362,
0.0284680203,
0.0432278961,
-0.042264469,
0.0093664611,
-0.0301895905,
-0.043731112,
0.0201885104,
-0.0247071311,
-0.0517732352,
0.0278749168,
0.0114418892,
0.023416074,
0.018152833,
-0.0445074476,
-0.0703697875,
0.0149070108,
-0.0272133369,
0.0107915718,
-0.0147279119,
-0.0831379071,
0.0532360151,
-0.0143386144,
-0.0019341822,
-0.0244270936,
-0.0105402526,
-0.0277519189,
0.0033792579,
-0.0167692583,
-0.0242451485,
0.0015502527,
-0.032906767,
-0.0747709796,
-0.0357298069,
-0.0201650783,
0.015579246,
0.0038443119,
-0.0220179893,
0.0124552073,
0.0247366633,
-0.0519349687,
-0.0082803853,
0.0029140818,
0.0136919618,
0.0187982507,
-0.0087243356,
0.0006429015,
-0.0172538422,
0.0020129099,
0.0316149294,
0.0484143198,
-0.0329776667,
-0.0426374897,
0.08349742,
-0.034851674,
-0.0312764421,
-0.0196633134,
-0.0511365235,
-0.0371683054,
-0.0081353318,
-0.002784994,
-0.0645304099,
0.0367172696,
0.004227018,
-0.0038012026,
-0.01297832,
-0.0014246982,
0.0617987067,
-0.0437388569,
0.0705156624,
-0.0445253737,
0.0197316147,
0.0131198205,
0.0306121372,
0.0064971908,
0.0569628589,
0.0084027369,
0.0816205516,
0.0666965395,
-0.0048876577,
0.0366203673,
0.0389052778,
0.0086765364,
0.0083453543,
0.0173314735,
-0.0233625192,
-0.0360081643,
0.0020069343,
0.0058491924,
0.0753520802,
-0.0151243927,
-0.0126254838,
0.0942275003,
0.0364972502,
0.0355276316,
0.0152964555,
0.0490738787,
0.0399561897,
-0.0059494227,
0.0038700092,
-0.021560546,
0.0759666413,
-0.0217418615,
0.0177625678,
0.0445531532,
0.0324526913,
-0.0347863287,
-0.0161072481,
0.0086517455,
-0.0207977537,
0.0603047572,
-0.0398026481,
0.0368105546,
0.0136610353,
-0.0613365583,
0.0004034087,
0.0316596106,
-0.0388199501,
-0.0027704539,
-0.0097720455,
-0.0362994857,
0.0854151994,
0.0245673265,
0.0074114515,
0.0644902438,
0.0027160239,
0.0704512969,
0.0823547095,
-0.0197927002,
0.0315105058,
-0.0043790867,
-0.0604635067,
-0.0334464014,
-0.0249378979,
0.0152302692,
-0.0015078131,
0.0002010408,
0.0157064535,
0.0287037082,
-0.0075758463,
-0.0474337898,
0.0192111135,
0.0399551615,
-0.0214474816,
-0.0008499212,
0.0449657775,
-0.0461670123,
0.041972775,
-0.006024044,
0.0119667063,
-0.0360918827,
-0.0021962349,
-0.0437612049,
0.0725633278,
-0.0668809414,
-0.0304085091,
0.0076664975,
-0.0842360035,
-0.0065045017,
0.0001665269,
-0.0327639431,
-0.0358951576,
0.0755977631,
-0.0573371314,
0.0232193973,
-0.0514119081,
-0.0384898111,
-0.0057275495,
0.0118155004,
0.0080365669,
0.0725243837,
-0.0145749459,
-0.0240605343,
-0.0142616117,
-0.0135889882,
-0.0004298961,
-0.0185369663,
-0.0083878031,
-0.0195257608,
-0.00078728,
0.0414547101,
0.0110289743,
0.0209408998,
-0.0470275395,
0.0100584794,
-0.1086144,
-0.0652685985,
-0.0321668051,
-0.0240425635,
0.0194410738,
0.0235542394,
0.0112254908,
-0.0368700288,
-0.0107139749,
-0.0006783823,
-0.0119393459,
0.0201331787,
0.0353036337,
0.0087338826,
0.0336380154,
-0.0315415673,
-0.0204299595,
0.0208378658,
0.0814203694,
0.0306516383,
-0.0632597357,
-0.0031958274,
-0.0145280771,
0.0089697652,
-0.0098892897,
0.0122839175,
-0.001591653,
-0.0024935473,
0.0063091083,
0.0200471692,
-0.009305778,
0.0139011964,
0.0179372616,
-0.0313754939,
0.0054093744,
-0.0355053693,
-0.0110983504,
0.0099707367,
-0.018548362,
0.0206669476,
-0.0682748854,
0.0107423393,
0.0535125546,
0.0044490485,
0.0330201127,
-0.0775959566,
-0.0176195931,
-0.0314551406,
-0.0370132923,
-0.0673713684,
0.0192457065,
-0.0094138095,
0.0076572937,
-0.0524484068,
-0.0424813293,
0.0632700399,
-0.0025216073,
-0.014963205,
0.0286312569,
-0.0411468223,
-0.0166191831,
0.0586495213,
0.0073754489,
0.0315700658,
0.0099092247,
0.0086463364,
0.0295919515,
0.0010484608,
-0.0018194994,
-0.0226752032,
0.0372335725,
-0.0190009717,
0.009990287,
0.0037423105,
-0.0337002724,
0.0178172085,
-0.086322099,
-0.0294270962,
-0.0371283218,
-0.0314085148,
-0.0264382903,
-0.0102753667,
0.0271159261,
0.0206657816,
0.032355547,
-0.0074670482,
-0.0190441757,
0.0122066308,
0.0445707813,
0.0199994706,
-0.0273486134,
-0.0712338388,
-0.0388026685,
0.0005962641,
0.0391215235,
0.0069717527,
-0.0310831107,
-0.0325695463,
-0.0028113162,
-0.0308415219,
0.0461877584,
0.0010952804,
0.0129747018,
0.0859321132,
-0.0053565251,
0.0027627384,
0.0718489811,
0.0131691219,
-0.0413384698,
-0.0167388972,
0.036381755,
0.0049695596,
-0.01013448,
-0.0053782333,
-0.1000610515,
-0.0593552552,
-0.0356144756,
0.0134002008,
-0.0082520917,
0.0037790353,
-0.0104600508,
-0.0440776013,
0.0111755459,
0.0186567903,
0.0035072814,
-0.0194358695,
-0.0119154258,
0.0151575301,
-0.0334430896,
-0.0119675603,
-0.0022918743,
-0.0203102697,
0.0045632422,
0.0137939723,
0.0467931852,
-0.070883356,
-0.0078365235,
-0.0192075986,
-0.0046041058,
0.0156347789,
0.0139196599,
-0.0091578364,
-0.0698058009,
-0.0085972119,
0.0185280778,
0.0453191102,
-0.0202785246,
0.0987265036,
-0.0325052515,
-0.0102399914,
-0.0494793504,
0.0417381562,
-0.0143176699,
-0.034072578,
-0.0237462856,
0.0167698655,
0.0188887659,
-0.0181603953,
-0.050941661,
-0.0042985436,
0.0547987558,
0.0349407233,
0.0605093576,
-0.0737938955,
-0.0065110326,
-0.0376863629,
-0.0082481541,
-0.0915123373,
-0.0367639102,
-0.0070808632,
-0.0307017174,
-0.0431672037,
-0.0658544898,
-0.0287686083,
0.0127211437,
0.0091046439,
-0.0172776468,
-0.005979978,
-0.0236186031,
-0.0050200569,
-0.0831079707,
0.0283795316,
-0.0204232726,
0.0399749652,
0.0401130207,
-0.0221840497,
0.0164414532,
-0.0472678505,
0.0092233121,
0.0371954255,
-0.0523442887,
-0.0187676903,
-0.0172392353,
0.0068174112,
0.0168566089,
-0.0095627792,
0.0076947319,
-0.0800768137,
0.0266577285,
0.085005261,
0.0108421007,
0.0174861513,
0.0001181297,
0.0156266801,
0.0074876589,
0.0294635613,
-0.0411225557,
0.0067324759,
0.0187222585,
0.0030731927,
-0.0205937624,
0.0334208906,
0.0220246539,
-0.0011906368,
-0.0088625681,
-0.0410566144,
-0.0256667528,
-0.0278096423,
-0.0447660126,
0.0016616129,
-0.0131297316,
-0.0450403839,
0.0376769342,
-0.000183066,
0.0238727406,
-0.0118825641,
-0.0267213229,
-0.0031084861,
0.0141155152,
-0.0681622252,
-0.011051896,
0.0166152138,
0.0141229723,
-0.0180935282,
0.0115770735,
-0.0005366929,
0.0222268365,
-0.0035013584,
0.0067245592,
0.0112458402,
0.0332634039,
0.0113039985,
-0.0594136119,
-0.0178402476,
0.0742277578,
-0.0119167818,
0.0512185059,
-0.0470503159,
0.0502063856,
0.0313082896,
-0.0169029795,
0.0460280105,
-0.0145476768,
-0.0124180559,
0.0213705711,
0.0143801793,
-0.0080094123,
-0.0431257151,
0.0132205216,
0.0003343555,
0.0123311486,
0.0236695129,
0.0734546557,
-0.0297135729,
0.0073259803,
0.0056463773,
0.0025426978,
-0.0383996628,
0.0352194868,
-0.0029261792,
0.0491941273,
-0.0029876484,
0.0252933614,
-0.0422075726,
-0.0767749995,
0.0080335932,
-0.0014201499,
0.0130225625,
0.0724198446,
0.034447331,
0.0554297082,
0.0359497741,
0.02838232,
-0.0172353126,
-0.0106946537,
0.0131163849,
0.0049340455,
-0.0131414728,
-6.199406596e-33,
-0.0072767735,
-0.0689759329,
-0.0247551668,
-0.0115526747,
-0.027644597,
0.0371840261,
-0.0427146666,
0.0174415987,
0.0199906453,
0.0068180994,
0.0185717754,
-0.0210783742,
0.0160099827,
0.0502177514,
-0.000426024,
0.0181659199,
-0.0212735385,
0.0042359256,
-0.0164171252,
0.0462567322,
0.0414080769,
-0.0061893561,
0.0402249098,
-0.0949893743,
0.0375787541,
-0.0204370227,
-0.032663025,
-0.0062233722,
0.0722184107,
0.044603277,
-0.0497734509,
0.0691290274,
0.0427889563,
0.0094639799,
-0.0294023417,
0.084410876,
-0.0308534615,
0.0042169928,
0.0288553666,
-0.0082776602,
-0.0990200713,
-0.0222769957,
0.043522507,
-0.0317330062,
-0.0284770261,
-0.0097519383,
0.0472258627,
-0.003413009,
0.0315148123,
0.0006425404,
-0.04100582,
0.0399000458,
-0.0262414068,
-0.02869666,
0.034975823,
0.0296305045,
0.0362710357,
0.0648088083,
-0.0411718823,
0.065088369,
-0.0092634866,
-0.033189524,
0.0573430918,
0.0115287043,
-0.004959418,
0.0353017636,
0.0080771651,
0.0043880614,
-0.0243081022,
-0.0091815935,
-0.0129309827,
0.0182731487,
0.035978619,
0.0814311951,
0.0258582048,
-0.0307008475,
-0.0091729462,
0.0291898753,
-0.0397196561,
-0.0105133932,
0.0288834218,
0.0420955941,
-0.0098853763,
0.0395063125,
-0.0301189069,
-0.0517063737,
-0.0767311081,
-0.0483880863,
-0.007673556,
0.0253967568,
-0.0316888615,
0.0713915378,
0.0470727086,
-0.0162461251,
-0.0053181048,
-0.0418986902,
-0.0004478591,
0.0705491006,
-0.0176235065,
-0.0079325289,
0.0113202836,
-0.0457335524,
0.0885660201,
0.0546162464,
0.0015128192,
-0.0195555296,
0.045656383,
0.0153206782,
-0.0344146639,
-0.009666455,
-0.0282622036,
-0.004422287,
-0.0261433404,
-0.0428401791,
0.0103177642,
0.0174283553,
-0.0900462866,
0.0126256095,
0.0121378116,
0.0054559954,
-0.0238882732,
-0.0643488839,
-0.0103407064,
-0.0005529267,
-0.0151511393,
0.0397509933,
0.0037072527,
-0.0757577419,
0.0281457081,
-0.0581717603,
-0.0091810944,
0.0482799001,
2.474e-7,
0.0229209997,
0.0439322591,
0.0196491685,
-0.0231678896,
0.0404416509,
0.0448875576,
0.0001097887,
0.0312382262,
-0.0182670113,
-0.0575492568,
0.0001640226,
0.0232212115,
0.0521779731,
-0.037754938,
0.005002345,
0.0243443977,
-0.0493452325,
-0.032830894,
-0.0458219647,
0.019513404,
0.0664868653,
0.0517592914,
0.0011834126,
-0.0229804553,
0.0258468427,
-0.0912563875,
0.0856113136,
-0.0225628745,
-0.0257490501,
-0.0305104423,
0.0334897563,
0.0157617144,
-0.0130282845,
-0.0029709956,
-0.0047605061,
-0.029515136,
0.0731142759,
0.0233148243,
-0.0076580825,
-0.0124604404,
-0.0218009595,
0.0021780434,
-0.0107306419,
-0.0314226784,
0.0389412828,
-0.0344218835,
-0.0290343277,
-0.0298948903,
-0.0112217916,
0.0348555706,
0.0289193429,
-0.0297945607,
-0.0827347189,
0.0287629496,
0.0220156908,
0.0114398934,
-0.0553582385,
-0.0885125622,
-0.036986772,
-0.0157074034,
-0.0271167848,
-0.0029982638,
-0.0684054196,
-0.0066237031,
0.0293150656,
-0.0479939803,
-0.0051014423,
1.584644789e-34,
0.0469199643,
-0.0142114945,
-0.0117705707,
0.0176767167,
-0.0146176405,
0.0149568543,
-0.011151772,
-0.0121911792,
0.0000192773,
-0.0713652596,
-0.0026716657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14775v1 | Measuring the Knowledge Acquisition-Utilization Gap in Pretrained Language Models | 2023-05-24T06:26:11 | 2023-05-24T06:26:11 | Amirhossein Kazemnejad, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Prasanna Parthasarathi, Sarath Chandar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While pre-trained language models (PLMs) have shown evidence of acquiring
vast amounts of knowledge, it remains unclear how much of this parametric
knowledge is actually usable in performing downstream tasks. We propose a
systematic framework to measure parametric knowledge utilization in PLMs. Our
framework first extracts knowledge from a PLM's parameters and subsequently
constructs a downstream task around this extracted knowledge. Performance on
this task thus depends exclusively on utilizing the model's possessed
knowledge, avoiding confounding factors like insufficient signal. As an
instantiation, we study factual knowledge of PLMs and measure utilization
across 125M to 13B parameter PLMs. We observe that: (1) PLMs exhibit two gaps -
in acquired vs. utilized knowledge, (2) they show limited robustness in
utilizing knowledge under distribution shifts, and (3) larger models close the
acquired knowledge gap but the utilized knowledge gap remains. Overall, our
study provides insights into PLMs' capabilities beyond their acquired
knowledge. | [
0.0329581685,
0.0643955842,
-0.0165443942,
0.0126827955,
-0.0128439404,
0.0194009449,
0.0058905035,
0.0050363354,
-0.0456884988,
-0.0291187149,
-0.0707603097,
-0.0239232108,
-0.0005802704,
0.0286264606,
0.0347309932,
-0.0396892428,
0.0287033878,
-0.0450910777,
0.0110869706,
0.0008251705,
-0.0095655993,
-0.0088204099,
-0.0150142908,
0.0027758772,
-0.0107001197,
0.0037087251,
-0.0191303883,
-0.013375436,
-0.0066385265,
-0.0078546815,
0.012424062,
0.0574914105,
0.0241655167,
0.0191458482,
0.0000019106,
-0.0497498438,
0.0240788497,
-0.02155325,
-0.0641575828,
0.0891818181,
0.0307102762,
-0.0013412873,
0.0104462644,
0.0055364608,
-0.0484466292,
-0.0224519409,
0.0255321693,
0.0126605751,
0.0009315539,
0.0806478187,
0.0025138687,
0.0325708278,
0.0176247228,
-0.0561916083,
-0.0140335681,
-0.0197719671,
0.0342651978,
0.0063802963,
-0.0137780868,
-0.0125124846,
-0.0081614899,
0.0717397407,
0.0312640034,
0.0326775052,
-0.0107967053,
0.0598511174,
0.0087187914,
-0.0198627133,
0.0011591441,
0.0494677611,
-0.0505958237,
-0.0336959958,
0.0138995871,
-0.0516283177,
-0.0094524184,
0.0165293682,
-0.026798971,
0.0131513542,
0.0127702598,
0.0218749642,
-0.0292810071,
0.0114444532,
0.0538853444,
0.0127629666,
-0.0446946099,
0.0582183748,
-0.000428608,
-0.0348283388,
0.0065310965,
0.0018249924,
-0.0258280132,
-0.0397078618,
-0.0110816844,
0.021147633,
0.0411830731,
0.058131367,
-0.0309274737,
-0.0272798073,
0.0169044193,
-0.045347359,
0.0626639277,
0.0268322565,
-0.0460920408,
0.0472689159,
-0.0278388076,
0.022673348,
0.0061304923,
0.0574970618,
-0.038773533,
0.0219595805,
-0.0368635692,
-0.0255111475,
-0.0242303964,
-0.0082953926,
0.0026176549,
-0.0112195592,
-0.0021457484,
0.028554609,
0.0395509303,
-0.0349922292,
0.0280328523,
-0.0121441595,
-0.0060140323,
-0.0112163899,
-0.0355470814,
0.0289938878,
-0.0037317257,
0.0479205064,
-0.0130402073,
-0.0772257224,
-0.0172171649,
0.0202184729,
-0.002217341,
-0.0194142461,
0.0225893948,
0.0351399034,
-0.0146243982,
-0.0541393235,
-0.0667929724,
0.0031786053,
-0.012291763,
-0.0988812298,
0.0073311431,
-0.0367237665,
0.0367794782,
0.0196275711,
-0.002020878,
-0.0397259779,
-0.0114192367,
-0.007114592,
-0.0455960296,
0.04306015,
-0.0056492109,
0.058303725,
-0.0012701364,
0.0109405173,
-0.00513545,
0.0874020606,
0.0181706827,
-0.004652244,
0.0208606292,
-0.0226030685,
-0.0075235181,
0.0516663827,
0.0573606528,
0.0083169257,
-0.0176056884,
-0.0118538262,
-0.007090962,
-0.0133625781,
0.0593093857,
0.0101483455,
-0.0236854944,
0.0106353424,
0.0902650505,
0.0421817861,
0.0431961603,
0.0068595167,
0.0778844953,
-0.0009542646,
0.0558305494,
0.0023588536,
-0.0534899011,
-0.0108867744,
-0.0431976281,
0.0142545197,
0.0060083852,
0.0387439355,
-0.0458652973,
-0.0468158126,
0.0058623618,
-0.0343838036,
-0.0025049779,
0.0301862471,
0.0726291537,
0.0152199967,
-0.0154513111,
0.0763372406,
0.0252967682,
-0.0461229905,
0.0430478454,
-0.0263674539,
0.0297859926,
0.039930474,
0.0099816434,
-0.0463011526,
-0.0023678837,
0.0550023578,
0.0345754959,
0.0216541067,
0.0772115067,
0.0174213108,
0.0558359176,
-0.0146828201,
-0.0285308659,
-0.0239944402,
0.0361522809,
0.0297854505,
0.0301462486,
0.0379257277,
0.0232000779,
-0.0755911469,
-0.0293112267,
0.0403147154,
-0.0525274426,
-0.018079849,
-0.0364129245,
-0.0005351311,
0.0124115925,
0.0024877999,
-0.0328820571,
0.0336420462,
0.0273754895,
-0.0084549477,
0.0098731602,
0.0176541116,
-0.0641415566,
-0.0125402836,
0.0207063146,
0.0309477933,
0.0269951504,
0.0054567251,
0.0032544595,
-0.0428537279,
0.0425735563,
0.0233677011,
0.1095545441,
-0.0598195903,
0.0349070579,
-0.0256355759,
0.0137518123,
-0.0031773518,
0.0730666816,
0.002532392,
0.0090454947,
-0.0143678263,
0.003089112,
0.0084365979,
0.0074572419,
-0.0241030604,
-0.0157937035,
0.0031015328,
0.0174052399,
0.0089911148,
-0.0019553967,
-0.0418088846,
0.0114711458,
-0.0943238288,
-0.0121976817,
-0.0252447687,
0.0246063061,
0.0386671908,
0.0011592463,
-0.0554680489,
-0.0105347587,
-0.0200086776,
-0.004060593,
0.0008862942,
0.000511532,
-0.001980393,
0.0435994379,
0.0107333697,
-0.045146618,
0.011267988,
0.0068089217,
0.027074201,
0.0031199348,
0.0021102002,
-0.0315879434,
0.0775717646,
-0.0199095979,
0.0263992567,
-0.0081935208,
-0.0615165383,
0.0099910526,
-0.0344951302,
0.0243512113,
0.0275151618,
-0.0061320351,
0.0214489046,
0.0864669606,
-0.018615216,
-0.047365725,
0.006956873,
-0.0407964885,
-0.0412978753,
-0.0659665987,
0.0275811814,
0.0344327055,
0.0925410017,
0.0097939512,
-0.0172932725,
-0.0401593857,
-0.0154706491,
-0.0267930944,
-0.0360269062,
-0.0330948494,
0.0076594427,
-0.0238456279,
0.0742089897,
-0.0230938494,
-0.0809246376,
0.0437706076,
-0.0773613304,
-0.0178524312,
-0.0090411063,
-0.0263711698,
-0.0033447118,
0.0590524487,
0.0122101773,
0.00869135,
0.013572935,
0.0106603689,
-0.05972692,
0.0233054552,
0.0227973238,
-0.0259114038,
0.0313231274,
-0.0815424398,
0.0144541236,
0.0097407075,
0.0035021668,
-0.0671923533,
-0.058053568,
-0.0122680757,
0.0070249364,
0.0125253387,
-0.0198965073,
0.0075332429,
0.0039249142,
0.0283893328,
0.0445046648,
0.0139891086,
-0.0075546107,
-0.0026084706,
-0.002016654,
0.0293229204,
-0.0073956535,
0.0070983358,
-0.0471934304,
-0.0079355463,
0.0092110839,
0.0242925808,
0.0015221827,
-0.0244366862,
0.0097552082,
-0.0001928429,
-0.005813567,
-0.0317110047,
0.0293761268,
0.0327532515,
-0.0386309549,
0.0160351899,
0.118398495,
0.0204045065,
-0.0366512537,
0.0074783913,
0.0151609723,
0.0107469698,
0.0115820784,
0.0180260967,
-0.060455367,
0.0077702124,
-0.0344215035,
0.0063156574,
-0.0021174955,
-0.0218374114,
-0.0527819954,
-0.1190415099,
-0.0277075209,
0.0086851576,
-0.0333764851,
-0.0215899367,
-0.0021061278,
-0.0043698819,
-0.0008824744,
0.0156478658,
0.0115898764,
-0.0279247463,
-0.0065588122,
0.0402402803,
-0.0387639403,
-0.1038773954,
0.0289187711,
-0.0345987529,
0.0467494093,
0.0182036161,
-0.0104812086,
-0.0286169536,
-0.0333009139,
0.0135037564,
-0.036249727,
0.0161964502,
0.0274581425,
0.037788868,
-0.0218749307,
-0.0240242798,
0.0437903628,
-0.004248803,
-0.0622872263,
-0.0114354081,
0.0045847306,
0.044096373,
-0.0090948474,
-0.0351039208,
0.0184023995,
-0.0150307324,
0.0008731543,
0.0838023946,
0.0632844269,
-0.0240854751,
-0.0073164934,
0.0210136622,
0.0007707712,
-0.0241476484,
-0.0252471752,
0.0479524285,
0.0060947333,
-0.0144750532,
-0.0374179855,
-0.019809911,
0.0301563069,
0.0549450815,
0.0195400305,
0.0199977625,
0.0289336219,
-0.0246998947,
-0.0489932373,
0.0496513881,
-0.022394184,
-0.0183406509,
-0.0586694218,
-0.081084691,
0.0151150879,
-0.0106789032,
-0.0215042308,
-0.0413355902,
-0.0939309299,
-0.0830108896,
0.0160942562,
0.0475312509,
0.0289691556,
0.0270427167,
-0.021281248,
-0.037606284,
0.0778449774,
-0.0062777558,
-0.0724818781,
0.0533905253,
0.0451347791,
-0.0441164747,
0.0027719641,
0.0183061436,
-0.0376830138,
0.0040601371,
0.0499613322,
0.0011045334,
-0.0304411594,
-0.0418165736,
0.0058001461,
-0.0063791913,
0.0735518336,
-0.0199221671,
-0.0067120851,
-0.0547334328,
-0.0061078034,
-0.005564278,
0.0288923606,
-0.0460788608,
-0.046647504,
0.0376771539,
0.0446202829,
-0.0012216521,
0.0021984288,
-0.0097401477,
0.0184674636,
-0.0033222088,
-0.0278517455,
0.0117429281,
-0.0006808426,
0.0508514084,
0.0020333896,
-0.0091280797,
0.0218316577,
-0.0410383381,
-0.0123630902,
-0.0046953307,
0.0308872294,
-0.0066398769,
-0.0007371295,
-0.0146033829,
0.0301040933,
-0.0546626709,
-0.0928732827,
0.0032153458,
0.0178469867,
0.0709120557,
-0.0710496753,
0.0433072783,
-0.046880234,
0.0321788192,
-0.0298163537,
0.0208356213,
-0.0215592533,
-0.0033438406,
0.0238506161,
0.02116042,
-0.0359441005,
0.0280900747,
0.1012450755,
0.0429599769,
0.0781331658,
-0.0329963714,
0.008068217,
-0.0079754777,
-0.0215014759,
0.0218168702,
0.0044907355,
-0.0519557744,
0.0546790324,
-0.0467338376,
-0.087763235,
-0.0253256764,
-0.0023722639,
-0.0248802453,
0.0014452436,
0.0423938856,
0.0770983323,
-0.0339451432,
0.0192033239,
-0.0334541202,
-0.0216247533,
0.0138118248,
0.0112870531,
0.0245855879,
-6.810870839e-33,
-0.0342364982,
0.0170533713,
0.0231229812,
-0.0074148518,
0.0030206176,
0.0245588515,
-0.0336377211,
0.0208252389,
-0.0205219742,
-0.0204868466,
-0.010213729,
0.0147247128,
0.0118362345,
0.0276248362,
-0.0045876685,
-0.0054636672,
0.0388570949,
-0.0149341421,
-0.0226051956,
0.002283585,
0.0209834166,
0.0510670245,
0.0866590068,
-0.0081396429,
0.0109941065,
0.0007527888,
-0.0070841769,
-0.0000621751,
-0.0363249741,
0.0654934719,
-0.0281932,
0.0422259383,
0.0240141042,
-0.009966258,
-0.0481244326,
-0.009026099,
-0.0733778998,
-0.0405489765,
0.0615005903,
0.034572091,
-0.0294069797,
0.0041683926,
0.0279760901,
-0.002679978,
0.0201305188,
0.0060205436,
0.0210491922,
-0.0140990689,
-0.0081526078,
-0.0200315062,
-0.0131621994,
0.0105845863,
-0.0089095468,
-0.0227610748,
0.0385273546,
-0.0128876977,
-0.0211293697,
-0.0077389511,
-0.0500990413,
0.0075191995,
0.0538093746,
0.0552251153,
0.0554680601,
0.0337100737,
0.0504732542,
0.0508825816,
-0.0084857671,
-0.0118031409,
0.0029017262,
0.0169901419,
0.1061736718,
0.0045593986,
-0.0158902761,
-0.0019066395,
0.0283120871,
-0.0395694375,
-0.0460839495,
-0.0179973468,
0.0229648706,
0.0187477209,
0.0158675201,
-0.0066036265,
0.0142515451,
-0.0465735756,
-0.048222214,
-0.0265412815,
-0.0254158098,
-0.0357356146,
0.039307557,
0.0436547697,
-0.0048434874,
-0.0375842154,
0.0282057226,
-0.0218623281,
-0.0072207665,
0.0189784877,
-0.0197674725,
0.0138590001,
-0.00752977,
0.0398092829,
-0.1160411388,
-0.0340066552,
0.0329103023,
-0.0041627595,
0.0006092336,
-0.0026423556,
0.013100164,
0.0564688556,
-0.0420183912,
-0.0255349651,
-0.0333328061,
0.0108851269,
0.0475592539,
0.0128519088,
0.0520613007,
0.0171548612,
-0.0267228968,
0.0153829651,
-0.0214862786,
-0.0627724454,
-0.0356667861,
0.0061245724,
-0.0005806816,
0.0456505083,
-0.0421180837,
-0.0474516824,
-0.0346426852,
-0.0267090779,
0.0530867092,
-0.0210152864,
-0.0057116123,
0.0163240284,
2.652e-7,
0.0802016258,
-0.0064178533,
-0.0165619794,
0.0171123967,
0.005285372,
-0.0027878953,
-0.0773800537,
-0.0060927034,
-0.0159178618,
-0.0419363379,
0.0245289169,
0.0441083983,
0.051242739,
-0.004712475,
-0.0752468035,
-0.0442340896,
-0.0595456362,
-0.0020705578,
-0.0478761382,
-0.0397092886,
0.0384731032,
0.0549768806,
0.0335978568,
0.0044206567,
-0.0230776686,
-0.0596230142,
0.0613317639,
-0.0435327552,
0.0031329191,
0.0026932135,
0.0683197528,
0.0303132497,
-0.0111220712,
0.0676187724,
-0.013309354,
0.0184742995,
-0.0015115193,
0.0768620446,
0.0312597305,
-0.0198949315,
-0.0172958355,
0.0108613288,
-0.0221675057,
-0.0640611276,
0.0900547728,
-0.0699232444,
0.0040990799,
-0.0042082868,
0.0155448224,
-0.0233426895,
0.0041981838,
-0.0141021619,
-0.0204673801,
0.0183767043,
0.0127955638,
-0.0000710758,
-0.0192441586,
-0.0857787654,
-0.0198330544,
0.0570299327,
-0.0248206984,
-0.0679659098,
-0.0687861368,
-0.0440875851,
0.0511773303,
-0.0345266424,
0.0354511924,
2.184369035e-34,
0.0318912528,
-0.0226440243,
0.0104591101,
-0.003494577,
0.0037709977,
-0.0187007394,
0.0114256879,
-0.0018189626,
-0.0119568296,
-0.0856808349,
0.0227237251
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.