id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15718v1 | Towards Higher Pareto Frontier in Multilingual Machine Translation | 2023-05-25T05:01:33 | 2023-05-25T05:01:33 | Yichong Huang, Xiaocheng Feng, Xinwei Geng, Baohang Li, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual neural machine translation has witnessed remarkable progress in
recent years. However, the long-tailed distribution of multilingual corpora
poses a challenge of Pareto optimization, i.e., optimizing for some languages
may come at the cost of degrading the performance of others. Existing balancing
training strategies are equivalent to a series of Pareto optimal solutions,
which trade off on a Pareto frontier. In this work, we propose a new training
framework, Pareto Mutual Distillation (Pareto-MD), towards pushing the Pareto
frontier outwards rather than making trade-offs. Specifically, Pareto-MD
collaboratively trains two Pareto optimal solutions that favor different
languages and allows them to learn from the strengths of each other via
knowledge distillation. Furthermore, we introduce a novel strategy to enable
stronger communication between Pareto optimal solutions and broaden the
applicability of our approach. Experimental results on the widely-used WMT and
TED datasets show that our method significantly pushes the Pareto frontier and
outperforms baselines by up to +2.46 BLEU. | [
0.0035633459,
0.0656447113,
0.0153723061,
0.0407239944,
-0.0175881628,
0.0196669828,
-0.0022163545,
0.0099345203,
-0.076832965,
-0.0079612574,
-0.0499641411,
-0.0396825224,
0.0006494177,
0.0129583227,
0.0273300074,
-0.0670913383,
-0.0155016864,
0.0025729113,
-0.0283113383,
-0.0260214601,
0.007694561,
0.0159297828,
0.0261181127,
0.0070463815,
-0.0041600782,
0.0017573719,
0.0276070945,
0.0362718962,
0.02718338,
-0.019610906,
0.034990754,
0.0143700726,
0.0197188761,
0.0646591634,
0.0000020785,
-0.0355443582,
-0.0385403819,
-0.0091207931,
0.0187688451,
-0.020396933,
0.0055740844,
-0.0552038886,
0.0317486525,
0.0022440657,
-0.0330206752,
-0.0160096996,
0.0511915796,
0.0018637764,
0.0645457134,
0.0717098862,
-0.0132315243,
-0.0528336763,
-0.0092241541,
-0.0842990875,
-0.0574316569,
-0.0292874537,
-0.0283747073,
-0.0204394646,
-0.0801396966,
-0.017406676,
-0.0278769005,
0.0251262411,
0.0260114819,
0.0200608615,
-0.0149618927,
0.0161587503,
-0.0058375276,
-0.0770491213,
-0.0282550696,
0.0757451057,
-0.0632111728,
0.0087910034,
0.0064584659,
-0.0108364196,
-0.0005528747,
-0.0422212593,
-0.0367565118,
0.0049870498,
0.001764795,
0.0342967995,
0.0010126798,
0.0109740524,
0.0566234961,
-0.0079976991,
-0.0647388622,
0.0389970765,
0.0211094916,
-0.0267073158,
0.0345682204,
0.0222432446,
-0.0393125303,
0.000993162,
0.0408401527,
-0.0054715108,
-0.0269172285,
-0.0007984928,
-0.0082470765,
-0.0689711049,
-0.0087172985,
-0.0387534872,
0.056161575,
0.0472650416,
-0.0181327797,
0.0226168949,
0.0162710398,
0.0077869897,
-0.015061602,
0.0137292491,
-0.0654971823,
-0.0232261475,
-0.0391152352,
0.0230926517,
-0.0271223728,
0.0350744091,
-0.0431994386,
0.0076900558,
-0.0044100392,
-0.0125223622,
-0.030010812,
-0.0174031369,
0.0805215612,
-0.0186854377,
-0.0596813969,
-0.0234088544,
0.0394526869,
0.105428718,
-0.0671048537,
0.0032643776,
0.0092271809,
-0.0330516137,
-0.0417433977,
0.0438400991,
-0.0271796826,
-0.0469408818,
0.0175658166,
0.0811212733,
-0.0587926358,
-0.0182796698,
0.0021284027,
-0.0163757093,
-0.0228618085,
-0.0795155019,
-0.0018101183,
-0.0656799674,
0.0853742361,
-0.0097035049,
0.0103933066,
-0.0531617627,
-0.0105362693,
-0.0276229531,
-0.014019208,
0.053408023,
0.0298594665,
-0.034607593,
0.0372172743,
0.0070796916,
-0.0728024468,
0.1136595234,
0.034964364,
0.0122465659,
-0.0060271085,
0.0118416464,
-0.0809801444,
0.0520948246,
0.0282057431,
0.0590606667,
-0.0019015208,
-0.0173561256,
0.0248745736,
0.0239872709,
0.0766383708,
0.0504285172,
-0.0431608222,
0.000240623,
0.0635387748,
0.0254121851,
0.053574115,
0.0101644741,
0.0146714784,
-0.0172061268,
-0.0555080324,
0.0445305407,
-0.0040527098,
0.0054338542,
0.044245366,
-0.0119520845,
0.0384001508,
0.083091788,
-0.0279051512,
-0.0420258343,
0.007889987,
-0.0291828141,
0.0098706577,
-0.0272203814,
0.0455461927,
0.0101446742,
-0.0103310021,
0.081985727,
0.0239209272,
-0.0609130301,
0.0609390438,
0.0036591454,
-0.0461144708,
0.0108142504,
-0.0030100842,
-0.0094934516,
-0.0189038552,
-0.0065372493,
0.0306022726,
0.0203408692,
0.0524495542,
0.0153395636,
0.0725086555,
-0.0529425703,
-0.0521206483,
-0.0254396163,
0.0007898118,
0.0451198556,
-0.0205564108,
0.0346184783,
0.0282917861,
-0.015169262,
-0.0240789205,
0.0177526474,
-0.0303069465,
-0.0207342301,
0.0292903297,
0.0353407636,
0.0251284093,
0.0154256998,
-0.0103562139,
-0.0258103628,
0.0109587871,
-0.0464861542,
-0.0336630866,
0.0615183786,
-0.0352975354,
-0.027885776,
0.0484942682,
-0.0651138201,
0.0108753638,
0.0300447755,
-0.0531823002,
-0.0472372212,
0.0088007813,
-0.0063351388,
0.0177813079,
-0.0483505204,
0.0123155974,
0.0108912718,
0.020519089,
-0.0218007993,
0.0327279121,
-0.0243275594,
-0.0144781154,
-0.0376300327,
-0.0712271109,
0.0156865362,
-0.0346415341,
0.0109841675,
0.0303533468,
0.0298893731,
0.0507348999,
0.0466699935,
0.0396860987,
0.0058893641,
-0.0552649125,
-0.0249939803,
0.0153274238,
-0.0494130142,
0.0227535609,
0.0422767028,
0.0368289091,
0.0142704621,
-0.038504269,
-0.0199850388,
0.0050373948,
-0.003921689,
0.0182940792,
0.040783491,
0.0232496653,
0.0361419991,
0.0034703407,
-0.0253911559,
0.0242888927,
0.0328408703,
-0.0145918783,
0.0208455883,
-0.0496726111,
0.0265880357,
-0.0528530255,
0.0157693736,
-0.0036370286,
-0.0247607939,
-0.0066886689,
-0.021209307,
-0.0250898805,
0.0377816707,
-0.0126167992,
0.0063203704,
0.0437641479,
0.0311710238,
-0.0487234704,
0.0145799192,
-0.0265365411,
0.0031552997,
-0.0258989464,
-0.0214954671,
0.0310984775,
0.0337864906,
-0.0189705342,
-0.0175014697,
-0.0483329035,
-0.0086321309,
0.0192820374,
-0.0220497251,
-0.012400168,
0.0457781479,
0.0042458847,
0.004715845,
-0.0340186581,
-0.0419331565,
0.0927280635,
-0.0364331976,
-0.0170838851,
-0.0738803223,
0.0115294345,
-0.0496564806,
0.0080076689,
-0.0267112236,
0.0318201482,
-0.0578521974,
-0.0056531457,
-0.0646583736,
-0.0087653687,
0.0055188979,
0.0351053327,
0.0372081734,
-0.047249008,
-0.0238221716,
-0.0387178883,
-0.0743803754,
-0.0001431711,
0.0063990452,
0.0141671849,
0.0204902533,
0.0536829717,
-0.0278684832,
-0.0206762161,
-0.0210405216,
-0.0215915851,
0.0791536644,
0.0111029083,
0.0021245447,
-0.0175298434,
0.0196092073,
0.0020013405,
0.0295826849,
-0.0007757533,
-0.0602895617,
-0.0129269091,
0.0252587553,
0.0424204022,
-0.0286913607,
-0.0128255999,
-0.0106790215,
0.0330032036,
-0.0235588197,
-0.0074451868,
-0.040856462,
0.020861607,
-0.0103933727,
0.0291828383,
0.086086601,
-0.0210616719,
-0.0523255505,
0.004882501,
-0.0011621378,
0.0572269894,
0.0287866853,
0.0042097028,
-0.0611172691,
-0.0213896446,
-0.0308142491,
0.0491000935,
0.0698043481,
0.0145017169,
-0.0223777797,
-0.0702072978,
-0.0186773408,
0.0428150371,
-0.0124460105,
-0.0126129072,
-0.0003649892,
-0.0404047854,
-0.0600191876,
0.0472951382,
-0.02317518,
0.015910482,
-0.0087192114,
0.0128832813,
0.0445004217,
-0.0421804339,
-0.0221350975,
-0.0687675625,
-0.045961339,
0.0490421765,
0.0302176233,
-0.0199250747,
-0.0546780638,
0.0128443157,
0.0415839218,
-0.0159888454,
-0.0133562861,
0.0093711084,
0.0049834829,
-0.0188823529,
0.0576103702,
0.0362017676,
-0.039383322,
0.0507071912,
0.0359579474,
0.0417959392,
0.0035586695,
-0.0158523489,
0.0428838022,
-0.0271614976,
-0.0045939479,
0.0395850688,
0.020518953,
-0.0288233273,
-0.0195571762,
-0.0079373196,
-0.0210170839,
-0.0891819224,
0.0686210543,
0.000979195,
-0.0148007013,
-0.0237201992,
-0.0837275013,
-0.0582942851,
-0.0248232521,
0.0568658747,
0.00764377,
0.0154618295,
-0.0025362915,
0.000512796,
-0.0258309394,
0.0333853513,
-0.0178957544,
-0.0385766439,
-0.0466843024,
0.0042086015,
-0.0165189654,
-0.0235831365,
-0.0073415646,
-0.0052279853,
-0.100329496,
-0.0886094272,
-0.0277656522,
0.0818098187,
0.0158816855,
0.0454373248,
0.0070980811,
-0.0512595624,
0.0374964736,
0.0467926934,
-0.0058866022,
0.009584236,
0.0499277599,
-0.0255772173,
-0.0118399691,
0.0529683307,
-0.0163418911,
0.0015183021,
0.0020487837,
0.0567098148,
-0.0231969804,
0.0119733373,
-0.0172893628,
0.001760439,
0.0459397472,
-0.0616782978,
-0.0315662511,
-0.0352517813,
0.0443670079,
0.007004749,
-0.0018784059,
-0.039992772,
0.0054410654,
0.033668641,
-0.0091773663,
0.0179304201,
0.054497201,
0.035841126,
0.0009775813,
-0.0358232856,
-0.0093778148,
-0.017203059,
-0.0212515518,
0.0115701454,
0.0218021963,
0.0247722697,
0.0489839986,
0.0059556249,
0.0198819656,
-0.0414529555,
0.0412287079,
0.0233729333,
0.0393380821,
-0.0011653086,
0.046873685,
-0.0314908735,
-0.0499887466,
-0.0148677919,
0.0028041853,
0.0967132673,
0.029339565,
0.0946804509,
-0.0053528002,
-0.0207243096,
-0.0120650344,
0.0126650417,
-0.030896062,
-0.002536373,
-0.0004573399,
-0.0171341393,
0.0011300922,
0.0146451984,
0.1043793783,
-0.0204517208,
0.0281521939,
-0.0386702344,
0.0227805413,
-0.0212400109,
-0.0621088073,
0.0277586076,
-0.0031889281,
-0.004308003,
-0.0268801749,
-0.0100205746,
-0.0422081463,
-0.0063768425,
-0.0163283441,
-0.0058313785,
0.0100982804,
0.027687652,
0.0881576613,
-0.0628846586,
-0.0085691148,
-0.0145252664,
-0.0164736323,
0.0334306844,
-0.0221484471,
-0.0053354669,
-6.681392341e-33,
0.007320174,
0.042689696,
0.0092175053,
0.0029807214,
-0.0006553228,
-0.0170626119,
0.0299123134,
-0.0395920165,
-0.0140464967,
0.0113489395,
0.0052627586,
0.0108892955,
0.0216132682,
0.0252305344,
0.0211339109,
0.0192649495,
0.0730318353,
-0.0049860566,
-0.0568077751,
0.0209232904,
0.0313379802,
0.0341880098,
0.0782522485,
-0.0078645376,
0.0053331852,
0.0080920625,
-0.0026814849,
0.0555123091,
0.0020611342,
0.0031686537,
0.0266935248,
0.0087475218,
0.0227837525,
-0.0232591573,
-0.0356911793,
-0.0349041894,
-0.0711314753,
-0.0282906294,
0.0167200435,
0.0454509594,
0.0082527436,
-0.0313363262,
0.0735634938,
-0.0337235741,
0.0081337392,
-0.0485823303,
0.0045110495,
-0.0043883254,
-0.0114826337,
-0.0029128632,
-0.0236871392,
-0.0112005956,
-0.000579235,
-0.0319952704,
0.0442614779,
0.0119264638,
-0.0078714415,
-0.0179521479,
-0.0913911983,
-0.0018660856,
-0.0354476459,
0.0630581006,
0.0800106674,
0.0216782875,
-0.0360645577,
0.0058782855,
0.0010251544,
0.0131744239,
0.0318583623,
-0.0110706566,
0.065301992,
-0.0077547957,
0.0266586617,
0.024402719,
0.0403183624,
-0.0243458971,
-0.0882441923,
0.0482681356,
0.0134063112,
0.0137626976,
-0.0032606306,
0.013686101,
0.0129808746,
-0.0249023382,
-0.0545517765,
-0.0521559753,
-0.0270729251,
-0.0120000076,
-0.0142740207,
0.0299568474,
-0.0099245431,
0.012124639,
0.053448692,
-0.0248539727,
-0.0003443578,
0.0280764177,
-0.019963121,
-0.0017881796,
0.0115870368,
0.0046290602,
-0.0206320956,
-0.046632126,
-0.0269979276,
0.0514755212,
0.0021358735,
-0.0092800548,
0.0834762156,
0.003392983,
-0.0142591512,
0.0198658127,
-0.0545767881,
0.0025444189,
0.0106515037,
0.0736301243,
0.0222423878,
-0.0026529429,
-0.0057182563,
0.0098950732,
0.0581990257,
-0.0135432677,
-0.0313226283,
0.0291069057,
0.0289962757,
0.0445976146,
-0.0196668748,
0.0275720134,
0.0047822464,
-0.0350441784,
0.0481909215,
-0.0367978327,
-0.0375405028,
-0.0295402259,
2.74e-7,
0.0550366528,
0.0293330196,
-0.0044014934,
-0.0198077876,
-0.0116542857,
0.0256426465,
-0.0511609651,
0.0512741357,
-0.0211191177,
0.018249318,
0.0234554056,
0.0394556224,
0.0621935837,
0.049591668,
-0.0732492059,
-0.0459858477,
-0.0745379031,
0.0054604933,
-0.0341200493,
-0.0622597337,
0.0098226136,
0.0530396141,
0.0140574882,
-0.0225894619,
-0.0069608404,
-0.0211557616,
0.0875883624,
0.0259247664,
0.0298491381,
0.0192397758,
-0.0007208314,
-0.0381585024,
-0.0280893892,
-0.0254556481,
-0.0314426012,
0.0305267498,
0.0134422369,
0.093455106,
-0.0029853885,
-0.028104255,
0.0256764367,
0.0291181151,
-0.0305757243,
-0.044643715,
0.0319402628,
-0.0378506891,
0.0215881318,
0.0024733106,
0.0011818269,
0.0058050356,
0.0675183535,
-0.0460910015,
-0.0212085359,
0.0584861003,
0.0187363978,
-0.0062776236,
-0.0050790017,
-0.0310563594,
-0.0482183434,
0.0061456067,
-0.0101900483,
-0.0447457284,
-0.0122059416,
-0.0388852768,
-0.0097233746,
-0.0210017171,
-0.0102093872,
2.146173046e-34,
0.0308304522,
-0.0169623382,
0.0149057284,
-0.0291785058,
0.015005758,
-0.0322910398,
-0.0608861707,
-0.0002311844,
-0.0215172693,
0.0069419295,
-0.0008812319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15717v1 | The False Promise of Imitating Proprietary LLMs | 2023-05-25T05:00:12 | 2023-05-25T05:00:12 | Arnav Gudibande, Eric Wallace, Charlie Snell, Xinyang Geng, Hao Liu, Pieter Abbeel, Sergey Levine, Dawn Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | An emerging method to cheaply improve a weaker language model is to finetune
it on outputs from a stronger model, such as a proprietary system like ChatGPT
(e.g., Alpaca, Self-Instruct, and others). This approach looks to cheaply
imitate the proprietary model's capabilities using a weaker open-source model.
In this work, we critically analyze this approach. We first finetune a series
of LMs that imitate ChatGPT using varying base model sizes (1.5B--13B), data
sources, and imitation data amounts (0.3M--150M tokens). We then evaluate the
models using crowd raters and canonical NLP benchmarks. Initially, we were
surprised by the output quality of our imitation models -- they appear far
better at following instructions, and crowd workers rate their outputs as
competitive with ChatGPT. However, when conducting more targeted automatic
evaluations, we find that imitation models close little to none of the gap from
the base LM to ChatGPT on tasks that are not heavily supported in the imitation
data. We show that these performance discrepancies may slip past human raters
because imitation models are adept at mimicking ChatGPT's style but not its
factuality. Overall, we conclude that model imitation is a false promise: there
exists a substantial capabilities gap between open and closed LMs that, with
current methods, can only be bridged using an unwieldy amount of imitation data
or by using more capable base LMs. In turn, we argue that the highest leverage
action for improving open-source models is to tackle the difficult challenge of
developing better base LMs, rather than taking the shortcut of imitating
proprietary systems. | [
0.0500864908,
0.0734295025,
-0.0135845272,
0.0699613914,
-0.0519204624,
-0.0077182236,
-0.0359205939,
0.0205203164,
-0.0321785212,
-0.0353992209,
-0.0925735906,
-0.0000100652,
-0.0107395258,
0.0121461479,
0.024840178,
-0.0209412612,
0.018464718,
-0.0288040992,
-0.0241943244,
-0.0205894634,
0.0092932759,
-0.0167477205,
0.0110141542,
0.0600374565,
0.0305627733,
0.0363284871,
-0.0206641871,
0.0048141358,
-0.0173592363,
-0.0024036106,
0.0155387456,
0.0422522798,
0.0111479498,
0.0467728302,
0.0000019811,
-0.0462020151,
0.0321380906,
-0.024036603,
-0.0377602503,
0.0206624269,
0.0497839414,
0.0296200998,
-0.0071013789,
-0.0004361183,
-0.0370960161,
-0.0084455637,
0.0106159793,
0.0200997815,
0.0636742488,
0.0915636793,
0.0271997675,
0.0094477488,
0.001784585,
-0.0206675529,
0.0136120189,
-0.0414205715,
-0.0068245931,
0.0078053349,
0.0554860942,
0.0110202432,
-0.000181324,
0.0387749448,
0.030102063,
0.0024818783,
0.0127170337,
0.0310162641,
-0.0527415983,
-0.0184489302,
-0.0285020694,
0.0666651577,
-0.0264599286,
-0.0615355633,
0.0042317789,
-0.0169269498,
0.0177990366,
0.0167244095,
-0.0454948656,
0.0400539488,
0.0287204068,
0.0396068841,
0.0155761307,
0.0094459979,
0.0325753503,
0.0143257668,
0.0601953864,
0.0583549328,
-0.0142736025,
-0.0525853522,
-0.0112539856,
0.0335129127,
-0.0128012868,
-0.0396460742,
-0.0123318508,
0.0019201479,
-0.0201270673,
0.0032503458,
-0.0558384955,
0.0241060983,
0.0209236927,
-0.0104406578,
0.0757446736,
0.034952689,
-0.0161883328,
0.0352619402,
-0.0409542471,
0.0373645052,
-0.0136481468,
0.0770922452,
-0.0344988443,
0.0282516815,
-0.069049038,
-0.013100462,
-0.0305911023,
0.0253162384,
-0.0170886666,
-0.0104825487,
-0.0097661847,
0.0095659727,
-0.0294948854,
-0.0108052259,
0.0296424571,
0.0333474651,
0.0022213936,
-0.0223328695,
-0.0585676283,
-0.0136280451,
-0.0069291797,
0.0285210591,
0.0008231931,
-0.11737106,
-0.0112294639,
0.0146026304,
-0.0124220252,
0.0088493098,
0.0230554137,
0.08235652,
0.0172861237,
-0.0380075909,
-0.0025403881,
-0.0184494946,
0.0244946163,
-0.0510587543,
0.0126210591,
-0.0800793618,
0.038898699,
-0.0057304576,
-0.0059183598,
-0.0153057706,
-0.0184098277,
0.0238861777,
-0.0353945382,
0.0592475459,
-0.0051536281,
0.0392397679,
-0.0134604713,
-0.0081623793,
-0.0441930145,
0.0368630625,
0.0239221882,
0.010140066,
0.0100883497,
0.0099125011,
0.0619211905,
0.0532805324,
0.0011626227,
0.0105760749,
0.026225511,
0.002789929,
-0.009804708,
0.0684189722,
0.0834895298,
0.0774457604,
-0.0321415588,
-0.0315003432,
0.1023613214,
0.0483631864,
-0.0159172118,
-0.0044225492,
0.046894066,
0.0329035409,
0.0289966669,
0.0030700122,
-0.0638855994,
0.0240397807,
-0.0165896211,
0.0240947586,
0.0264485013,
0.0111733479,
-0.0095988829,
-0.0194822717,
-0.0173191968,
-0.0053944378,
-0.0198113192,
-0.0123884054,
0.0229156837,
0.007434736,
-0.03693505,
0.0133238705,
0.0257803183,
-0.0362902395,
0.0128097609,
-0.1075804681,
0.0330143198,
0.0541958213,
0.0637928322,
0.0083096772,
0.0364518389,
0.0016868521,
-0.0170059707,
0.0736543387,
0.0430442058,
-0.0161988847,
-0.027598232,
-0.0112436414,
-0.0046952078,
-0.022018712,
0.0217047837,
0.0172041282,
0.0320450142,
-0.0241590552,
-0.0140468841,
-0.0516480021,
-0.0332039073,
0.0509171672,
-0.0421708748,
-0.0162773263,
-0.0361154266,
-0.0273506623,
0.0411034785,
0.0049309949,
-0.0016362715,
0.0396537967,
0.013773961,
-0.01707468,
-0.0482781827,
0.0200653002,
-0.0578788519,
-0.038611412,
0.0316958241,
-0.0383575149,
-0.0256684981,
0.0640643239,
-0.031338539,
-0.0208105035,
0.0202631559,
-0.0346153118,
0.0571022853,
-0.0505986847,
0.0291849598,
-0.0016271627,
-0.0324945077,
-0.0159451235,
0.029487377,
-0.0150074828,
0.0494346097,
0.027466014,
-0.0059986138,
-0.0046672854,
-0.0499087535,
-0.0424549989,
-0.0166933127,
-0.0126146134,
0.0470570624,
-0.0031136218,
0.0409788676,
-0.054444328,
-0.0295278169,
-0.0666970238,
-0.0025224746,
-0.0046462822,
0.0060713752,
0.0518444516,
-0.0207310971,
-0.0181046817,
-0.0111423098,
-0.0356542133,
-0.0284050889,
0.0123074222,
0.0211677179,
0.0356952436,
-0.0075712833,
-0.0197861344,
-0.038377285,
0.0061151781,
0.0161427893,
0.0110637406,
-0.0330340266,
0.0328502506,
-0.0563481413,
-0.0006161251,
-0.0024356071,
0.0242906231,
-0.0134065673,
-0.0392195806,
0.0356408581,
-0.0051446827,
0.0158023555,
0.0449843444,
-0.011757249,
0.0137215639,
0.0397110991,
0.0325674936,
-0.0727688298,
-0.0161340963,
-0.0075338534,
-0.052302897,
-0.0204934496,
-0.0360954553,
0.0228431281,
0.0755136535,
0.0160711128,
0.0249440279,
-0.0596589111,
0.0340245478,
-0.0119553935,
-0.0362318158,
-0.0230200905,
-0.0059046326,
-0.0667399094,
0.0026991623,
-0.0528219827,
-0.0528363101,
0.0509975925,
-0.0530197211,
-0.010458258,
0.0127877863,
0.0009065255,
-0.0338152647,
0.0338763185,
0.0215728059,
-0.0134118358,
-0.0111002205,
0.011782865,
-0.037396092,
0.0656270757,
0.0313947052,
-0.0480646789,
0.0038891139,
-0.0594124831,
0.0292368382,
0.0080520753,
-0.0545900203,
-0.0276001133,
-0.0319203585,
-0.0459497906,
0.0065609855,
0.0312829055,
-0.0004761111,
-0.0052810507,
-0.0122697717,
0.0114420746,
0.0354361497,
0.0145313954,
-0.005746155,
-0.0279523674,
0.0122563075,
0.0405882038,
0.0402765721,
-0.0003987623,
-0.0363642201,
0.0031123271,
0.0459857695,
0.0582192689,
0.003184248,
-0.0344260409,
0.0246044211,
0.0365148932,
0.0051754853,
-0.0165674184,
0.0308431517,
0.0676307082,
-0.0411866792,
-0.0080445455,
0.0966937169,
-0.0011136283,
-0.0108943554,
0.0116922632,
-0.0133920936,
0.0370202549,
0.018600136,
0.0128402878,
-0.0713312998,
-0.0417870469,
0.0245236121,
0.0743222684,
-0.0168841574,
-0.0166954491,
0.0110213421,
-0.1644472778,
0.0342982709,
-0.0092848493,
-0.0643788129,
0.0138521111,
-0.0501694158,
0.0114866151,
-0.0522171818,
-0.0026306328,
0.0333157033,
0.0020820883,
0.0110768834,
0.0187642369,
-0.0545543656,
-0.0519651659,
0.0399380066,
-0.0464005135,
0.1324529946,
0.0545791164,
0.0086774835,
0.0144319562,
-0.06325984,
0.0583907664,
0.0146211274,
0.0169087555,
-0.0169798955,
0.0350425839,
-0.0134754833,
-0.0161724295,
-0.0118304398,
0.036316596,
-0.048290357,
-0.0024400081,
-0.0366382226,
0.0511340722,
0.0044590109,
-0.0509701632,
0.0029247224,
-0.0161453709,
-0.0211271141,
0.0998786837,
0.0470664762,
-0.0438456647,
-0.0495875888,
-0.0209887158,
-0.0471346006,
-0.0508451797,
-0.0815756619,
0.0388975553,
-0.0003227419,
-0.0231331624,
-0.0744806677,
-0.045429416,
0.0279624555,
0.0112668369,
0.0035540771,
-0.0064951298,
0.0136225559,
-0.0253073368,
0.007607996,
0.0456977263,
-0.0639389828,
0.0049869795,
-0.0807446614,
-0.03163011,
0.0232555997,
-0.0267111883,
-0.0085340524,
-0.0155809317,
-0.0842194483,
-0.0699105188,
0.0273184758,
0.0920001566,
0.0254492946,
0.0187475719,
-0.0145375067,
-0.0463279225,
0.0283255111,
0.0560663119,
-0.0326727256,
0.0364722423,
0.0163968205,
0.0164988339,
-0.00681123,
0.0375605561,
-0.0209321752,
0.0020193707,
0.036166124,
0.0511738434,
0.0067053377,
-0.0283013564,
0.0525133833,
0.0402936675,
0.0395943969,
-0.0205995236,
-0.0085287951,
-0.0303354077,
-0.0385436006,
-0.0029101809,
-0.0080646481,
-0.0593803115,
-0.0281876717,
0.0190550219,
0.0410776101,
-0.0019098653,
-0.0283270702,
-0.0286900904,
0.0542466678,
-0.0379286632,
0.0028523679,
0.0223073475,
0.0359694287,
0.0125495093,
-0.0004279853,
-0.0160932746,
0.0075997743,
-0.037243478,
0.0332019068,
0.0108176135,
0.0098606534,
0.019543428,
-0.0040548174,
0.0274498556,
0.0513452254,
-0.0565012321,
-0.065094009,
-0.0401491113,
0.0713316649,
0.0321468003,
-0.0075583044,
0.0438704789,
-0.0308560841,
0.0131335258,
-0.0116550149,
0.0080206702,
-0.0040650349,
-0.0330266915,
0.0342987515,
0.0282146856,
-0.0261111893,
-0.0074921302,
0.0742996559,
0.0195029676,
0.0714376047,
-0.0289514586,
0.035477668,
-0.0315193422,
-0.0161794554,
-0.000117287,
-0.0252357423,
-0.016196277,
0.0045010527,
-0.0494135953,
-0.0574515164,
-0.0372415669,
0.0657100528,
0.0247766692,
-0.0338369347,
0.0472611785,
0.0284853764,
-0.0032720161,
0.0144590819,
-0.0342827663,
-0.011108188,
0.0164127927,
-0.0346271917,
-0.0106263496,
-6.68626403e-33,
-0.0034388204,
-0.0322721153,
0.0323628373,
-0.0050536916,
-0.0181530807,
-0.0074409302,
-0.0268572886,
0.0343835242,
-0.0029334044,
-0.0065465895,
-0.0194319151,
-0.0278279856,
0.0142967105,
0.0011724547,
0.0395941325,
-0.0108011374,
0.0343689024,
-0.0501411669,
-0.0506283231,
-0.0247597955,
-0.0002680419,
0.0010171719,
0.0345044173,
-0.0434362218,
0.0501750372,
-0.0330299027,
-0.0204218719,
0.0106526343,
-0.038054768,
0.0311603881,
-0.021192614,
0.0201703403,
0.0383047052,
-0.0393353663,
-0.01883897,
-0.0023030592,
-0.039155066,
-0.0027266725,
0.0280480273,
-0.0011637987,
-0.0364070088,
0.0145853888,
0.0535563827,
0.0054314588,
-0.0695016608,
0.0377575196,
0.0101879584,
-0.0305689555,
-0.0023661575,
0.0258098282,
-0.0243960787,
0.0124786869,
0.0158881545,
-0.0482047573,
-0.0013515984,
0.0225919001,
-0.0382095762,
0.0174153913,
-0.0546654128,
0.0308985766,
-0.0317522138,
0.0334263854,
0.082154423,
-0.0026588826,
0.0263223536,
0.0709129646,
-0.0031665945,
0.00486736,
-0.0069882162,
-0.0140307257,
0.0434525348,
0.0736896098,
0.060000971,
0.0414353497,
0.03556161,
0.0183909759,
0.044255197,
0.0351943746,
0.0179512314,
0.0006046749,
0.0088248337,
0.0499802791,
-0.0401248261,
-0.0066250004,
-0.0299357567,
-0.0368770212,
-0.0321812108,
-0.021179093,
0.0430260971,
0.033118628,
-0.0219074879,
-0.0587771311,
0.0127429692,
-0.0340726934,
-0.0051021064,
-0.0725677162,
-0.0184665024,
0.0471436456,
-0.0115336729,
-0.0251966212,
-0.0695381388,
-0.048929859,
0.0007026523,
0.0311887264,
0.0353290774,
0.0057138354,
0.0260926895,
0.0337263308,
-0.056356743,
0.0160295628,
-0.0343112759,
0.0322707891,
0.0069243857,
-0.0609951578,
0.0373758711,
-0.0278609004,
-0.0273550097,
0.0125473831,
-0.0100943297,
-0.0274720713,
-0.0433838181,
-0.0058171693,
-0.0260593239,
-0.0292483103,
-0.0264542587,
0.0311188512,
-0.0390597731,
0.0212856289,
-0.0161921196,
-0.027029708,
-0.0293222833,
-0.0085611818,
2.703e-7,
0.0073712296,
0.0087843118,
0.0335725397,
0.0314036347,
0.0004669135,
0.0419889167,
-0.0580631979,
0.0272484608,
0.0017629362,
-0.0478468835,
-0.0061623594,
0.0352983363,
0.0699396431,
-0.0139817009,
-0.1016962752,
0.0167750362,
-0.0969276354,
0.0145645123,
-0.016257748,
-0.0488406122,
0.0035041678,
0.0320120193,
0.0205238778,
-0.0095020374,
-0.0241818074,
-0.0390420146,
0.0494538732,
-0.047728911,
-0.047564622,
-0.0058290586,
0.0676268041,
0.0087684654,
-0.000608476,
-0.033142142,
-0.0006737013,
-0.0036651262,
0.0258359928,
0.0470954329,
0.0301461667,
-0.0404058881,
0.0105775278,
-0.026957931,
0.0273618475,
-0.0299837291,
0.0500941351,
-0.0085874153,
-0.0051131644,
-0.0423589349,
-0.0136294551,
0.0046127224,
-0.0104851713,
-0.0225069821,
-0.0335878208,
0.0035643266,
0.0229326505,
-0.0185811259,
-0.0153403915,
-0.0445402227,
-0.0379567593,
-0.0465596728,
-0.0453520045,
-0.0610460527,
-0.0392412841,
0.0294210762,
0.0112858536,
-0.025115313,
-0.0196859911,
2.101342171e-34,
0.0462286137,
-0.0060284371,
0.0680181831,
0.0387929119,
0.0309710447,
0.0315180682,
0.0358771421,
0.0255862009,
0.0049123918,
-0.0293412525,
-0.0151746217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16355v1 | PandaGPT: One Model To Instruction-Follow Them All | 2023-05-25T04:16:07 | 2023-05-25T04:16:07 | Yixuan Su, Tian Lan, Huayang Li, Jialu Xu, Yan Wang, Deng Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We present PandaGPT, an approach to emPower large lANguage moDels with visual
and Auditory instruction-following capabilities. Our pilot experiments show
that PandaGPT can perform complex tasks such as detailed image description
generation, writing stories inspired by videos, and answering questions about
audios. More interestingly, PandaGPT can take multimodal inputs simultaneously
and compose their semantics naturally. For example, PandaGPT can connect how
objects look in an image/video and how they sound in an audio. To do so,
PandaGPT combines the multimodal encoders from ImageBind and the large language
models from Vicuna. Notably, only aligned image-text pairs are required for the
training of PandaGPT. Thanks to the strong capability of ImageBind in embedding
data from different modalities into the same space, PandaGPT displays emergent,
i.e. zero-shot, cross-modal behaviors for data other than image and text (e.g.,
video, audio, depth, thermal, and IMU). We hope that PandaGPT serves as an
initial step toward building AGI that can perceive and understand inputs in
different modalities holistically, as we humans do. Our project page is at
https://panda-gpt.github.io/. | [
-0.0131155262,
0.0727144033,
-0.0132481968,
0.0450977683,
0.0014878201,
0.0135885524,
0.0209936798,
-0.0355627835,
-0.0347320363,
-0.0570662878,
-0.0574344248,
-0.0200523753,
0.0208691247,
0.0721217096,
0.0538747981,
-0.0939020291,
0.0204619542,
-0.0307269972,
-0.0426281095,
0.0148745626,
0.0297386684,
0.0280595515,
-0.058060009,
0.0595847555,
-0.0180403367,
-0.0077199168,
-0.0570137538,
0.0047764028,
0.0080295485,
-0.0206879321,
-0.0277221762,
0.0207909308,
0.0607955083,
0.0253965352,
0.0000018358,
0.0098582953,
0.0517724268,
-0.0139416791,
0.0465827473,
-0.0216165334,
0.018863868,
-0.0547320805,
-0.012349044,
0.008386841,
-0.0283232294,
-0.0568740442,
0.076499261,
0.0309042148,
0.0801330432,
0.054506667,
-0.0307713281,
-0.0500554554,
0.0314696394,
-0.0205869526,
0.0245875828,
-0.0059574815,
-0.017037563,
-0.0325152986,
0.0456906296,
0.0180581436,
-0.0570058636,
0.0494309999,
0.0540716164,
-0.0056430828,
0.0163834952,
0.058902394,
-0.0052100271,
-0.052695401,
-0.0397271961,
0.0840106308,
0.0184758287,
-0.0181115177,
-0.0391809791,
0.0169114526,
0.0043125176,
-0.0038353542,
-0.048950199,
0.0462621897,
0.0068654837,
0.0296204258,
-0.0393510871,
-0.0056226966,
0.0046529965,
-0.0021987448,
0.0351279192,
0.0003949365,
0.0312462188,
-0.0021337047,
-0.005073647,
0.0140569024,
-0.0305330642,
-0.0670167357,
0.0071463306,
0.0708399415,
-0.0192348342,
0.0002969976,
-0.0773924962,
-0.0218373053,
-0.0238548126,
-0.0147356745,
0.0461885594,
0.0500334874,
-0.0637735799,
0.0337782875,
-0.0005662926,
0.0630711541,
-0.0272363927,
0.025315769,
-0.0245880391,
-0.0059022233,
-0.0339810103,
-0.0399511643,
-0.0413985439,
-0.0012980604,
-0.0598142371,
-0.0778954849,
-0.0116356872,
0.0350720212,
-0.0355081856,
0.015230149,
-0.0105782039,
0.0196968932,
-0.0205338839,
0.0168383513,
-0.0025295613,
0.0548014119,
-0.019279981,
0.0542283468,
0.0158180166,
-0.0170720033,
-0.0058599506,
0.0328827389,
0.0117098233,
-0.0068164268,
-0.0082677146,
0.0827216581,
-0.04135409,
-0.0102007454,
-0.0329988748,
-0.0112567563,
-0.0042516105,
-0.0395737886,
0.0269559063,
-0.0323705897,
0.0467106067,
-0.0202034712,
-0.0021304821,
-0.0280076135,
0.0102681629,
0.0320063829,
0.0314474925,
0.0815114602,
0.0128266923,
0.0054630819,
0.0213920642,
0.0310118496,
0.0242156833,
0.0408915877,
0.0615333095,
0.0216037165,
-0.0146742053,
-0.0100913858,
-0.0037225913,
0.0384973027,
-0.0073151817,
0.0079178503,
-0.0371500477,
-0.0262491684,
-0.0095666237,
0.0414604768,
0.0352018923,
0.06047979,
-0.0339621603,
-0.005351678,
0.0925981179,
0.0153566739,
-0.0044003483,
-0.0185791124,
0.0672967881,
-0.0117305992,
-0.006668556,
0.0163037349,
-0.0446197949,
0.0773395598,
0.0175790358,
0.0243855715,
0.0234037377,
0.0299126003,
-0.0573485456,
-0.0312705189,
0.0010065918,
-0.0137063488,
0.0105489204,
-0.0009846218,
0.0181496292,
0.0361885056,
-0.0550301634,
-0.0291214418,
0.0079302173,
-0.0452430435,
0.031465821,
-0.0089933965,
0.0390646532,
0.0676143989,
0.0182914063,
0.0178840589,
-0.0086053135,
0.0006058198,
0.0197462067,
0.0653243884,
-0.0097671608,
-0.0168960262,
0.0378982909,
-0.0646812767,
-0.027193021,
-0.0313080773,
0.0090530673,
-0.0037821166,
-0.0188732836,
0.0234164018,
-0.0113356262,
0.0409391411,
0.0210307799,
0.0531440862,
0.0092946282,
-0.0257361066,
-0.0402832702,
0.0119750435,
0.0319686234,
-0.016119767,
-0.0229605492,
0.0058944845,
0.0153912352,
-0.0270163435,
0.0059389914,
0.0428612791,
-0.0630912185,
-0.0337922461,
-0.0005133412,
-0.0508187562,
-0.004319285,
-0.0042937826,
-0.0115721272,
-0.0269322284,
0.0190696754,
-0.0355755277,
0.0076846173,
-0.0362289771,
-0.0075925342,
0.0420795158,
0.0086495746,
0.0176318269,
0.0034473795,
0.0058651129,
-0.0353271849,
-0.0008534986,
0.0308067761,
0.0133431358,
-0.0279398989,
-0.0097411992,
0.0116183888,
0.0064527281,
0.0257037319,
-0.0122342724,
0.0225267299,
-0.0396168604,
-0.0230692737,
-0.083562918,
-0.0166083649,
-0.0052444735,
-0.0221029613,
0.0216133315,
0.0024485448,
0.0082980571,
-0.0268699639,
-0.0386877693,
0.023406202,
0.0053744963,
0.0041108481,
0.0018235714,
0.0030119668,
0.0217721015,
-0.0101899542,
-0.0004348856,
0.0172789861,
0.029646311,
0.0031729282,
-0.0047926498,
-0.0384397171,
-0.0168589279,
-0.026036419,
0.0464099869,
-0.0049870918,
-0.0391969532,
0.0544000491,
0.0029620447,
0.0607535578,
0.0640206188,
0.0038808892,
0.0614497662,
0.0387759246,
-0.0052717114,
-0.0337201022,
0.0094455965,
0.0014730621,
0.0127360206,
-0.01766764,
0.0392162502,
-0.0353185721,
0.0492062755,
0.0038599041,
0.0163034592,
-0.092523776,
0.011627825,
-0.0193949528,
-0.0486267172,
-0.0365412422,
-0.0153762875,
-0.0280469637,
0.0082344413,
-0.0519765876,
-0.0640957206,
0.0429734699,
-0.0490201712,
-0.0585107058,
-0.0112058399,
0.0083104037,
-0.0106686456,
0.0702199936,
0.0353663117,
0.0247187521,
0.0191173833,
-0.0152624231,
-0.0608555079,
0.0267755371,
0.0136916563,
-0.0031684232,
0.0272747148,
-0.0637336448,
0.0048343139,
-0.0029474325,
-0.0121564586,
-0.0261023566,
0.0300510544,
-0.013808839,
0.0123115815,
-0.0596932992,
-0.0224103518,
-0.034954913,
0.0059349807,
0.0426096357,
0.0372045338,
-0.0268011373,
-0.0095964558,
-0.0525887348,
0.0219817609,
0.0880352482,
0.0040457491,
-0.0706426278,
-0.063175559,
0.0144937439,
0.0523640513,
0.0165959746,
-0.01350684,
-0.060284704,
0.0680912882,
0.0234365351,
0.0412183814,
-0.0022649053,
0.0277665425,
0.0601801276,
-0.0491462015,
-0.0271338876,
0.0667126402,
-0.0030471932,
-0.0412912965,
0.0173103139,
0.0543314032,
0.0514324494,
0.0296218488,
0.0021088333,
-0.0914180726,
-0.0482901968,
0.0065636602,
-0.0010436943,
0.0369324051,
0.0373951346,
-0.0256254431,
-0.0859153792,
0.0545702055,
0.0266972538,
-0.0419578142,
-0.0525485016,
0.0022945064,
0.008669435,
0.0148046371,
0.0327107385,
0.0011531431,
-0.0100299297,
0.0145428637,
0.0156679899,
0.0609327145,
-0.0640974715,
-0.007357446,
-0.0217562038,
0.0397891402,
0.0610898882,
0.0101235211,
-0.0012465212,
-0.0495111458,
0.0066438303,
0.0287978686,
-0.011461528,
-0.0006152386,
0.070631206,
-0.0173327941,
-0.0311174411,
0.014277474,
0.0682335943,
-0.0297350362,
-0.0103596039,
-0.0053939554,
0.064548865,
-0.0315621942,
-0.0116752405,
-0.0291218292,
0.0146297812,
-0.0041497094,
0.031273555,
0.0293706097,
-0.0399193764,
-0.0231398772,
-0.0314414278,
-0.0269233827,
-0.0573682897,
-0.053409826,
0.0164057706,
-0.0028610313,
-0.0356971882,
-0.0628461316,
-0.0510731824,
0.0610358268,
0.0498355106,
0.0244423449,
-0.0356444567,
0.020974068,
-0.0113633014,
-0.0521960557,
0.0384084806,
0.012207916,
0.0446412489,
-0.0440366231,
-0.0575400032,
0.02143039,
-0.043162737,
-0.0051143905,
0.0383480601,
-0.0536805466,
-0.0654871166,
-0.0425903723,
0.0482203364,
0.0210148506,
0.0527392998,
0.012353234,
-0.024295114,
0.0330905281,
0.0163210575,
-0.0184275974,
0.0351000354,
0.0065453486,
-0.0291044246,
0.0060024518,
0.001921117,
-0.0255762171,
0.0284438021,
-0.0274913628,
0.0285006668,
0.0178738255,
-0.009169871,
0.0362356938,
-0.0463646725,
0.0025315585,
-0.0299084149,
0.0303352606,
-0.0749725252,
-0.0142373452,
-0.0116346423,
0.0256546829,
-0.0938525945,
0.0160653852,
0.0342133492,
0.0310592204,
-0.0003547217,
-0.0272701681,
0.0273920652,
0.0047794981,
-0.0549747273,
0.0103882346,
0.0289823208,
0.0102219274,
-0.006809473,
0.0240947753,
0.0150387799,
0.0098937126,
-0.0401822664,
0.0349088982,
-0.017714873,
0.0804825872,
0.027328901,
-0.0132937739,
0.0007504004,
0.0412010625,
-0.0366775356,
-0.0012757634,
-0.0327071771,
0.0444656573,
0.0362818837,
0.0184289552,
0.0100199403,
-0.0244550593,
-0.0077875643,
-0.003725552,
0.0795321912,
-0.0098470906,
-0.0463099256,
0.0512506627,
0.0181319397,
0.0130096562,
-0.0299213789,
0.0442159027,
0.0025304584,
0.0453182086,
-0.0155337434,
0.053735029,
-0.0349245183,
-0.0268157199,
0.0189227425,
0.0291186981,
-0.0269978605,
0.0623921417,
0.0125668058,
-0.0598677285,
-0.0795742497,
0.0327014141,
-0.0105190407,
-0.0159869771,
0.0589986481,
-0.0097924164,
-0.0152450185,
-0.0151542732,
-0.0053930385,
-0.0226485785,
-0.0334025323,
-0.0093177948,
-0.0274946541,
-5.578666233e-33,
-0.051568564,
-0.0206571501,
0.0524537787,
0.0102396077,
-0.0378332883,
-0.0080977399,
-0.0527920425,
0.0232244115,
-0.0089282561,
0.0158176403,
0.065165773,
0.001894386,
-0.0051646419,
0.0631417707,
0.0133061251,
0.0161904991,
0.0138576711,
-0.029682504,
0.0054030018,
0.0351597071,
0.0468933173,
-0.0044675414,
0.0474698208,
-0.0543859452,
-0.0147238653,
0.0180742703,
-0.0463748015,
0.0077481838,
-0.0364083536,
0.0699806586,
-0.0391948894,
0.0196528751,
-0.0053136256,
0.0204686839,
-0.0272378847,
0.0228661541,
-0.0663788319,
-0.0044783135,
0.0077205384,
0.053165745,
-0.1069123,
-0.0126506779,
0.042529542,
-0.0535726212,
0.0071846405,
-0.0431186818,
0.0495131053,
-0.0087209735,
0.0013659986,
-0.0008309644,
-0.0878085196,
-0.0256246924,
-0.0099592237,
-0.0779613554,
0.0252923016,
0.0508424789,
0.0156167727,
0.0192625932,
-0.0270167943,
0.0379918702,
-0.0227593966,
0.0388886742,
0.068876408,
0.0373268574,
0.0033621774,
0.0525249541,
0.021343844,
-0.0898918286,
-0.0530800559,
0.0121143041,
0.0234385338,
0.0482611842,
0.0128341466,
0.0053635631,
0.0122506674,
0.0156338885,
-0.0064014527,
0.0124806594,
-0.0101870392,
0.0253475439,
-0.0047670347,
0.0293532759,
-0.0044714678,
0.0036721469,
-0.0196116269,
-0.0103871459,
-0.029552456,
-0.0239965785,
0.0613414906,
0.0206074528,
0.0215279181,
-0.0008781881,
0.0560360812,
-0.01679511,
0.0087539451,
0.011099387,
-0.048833061,
0.0527961254,
0.0051565114,
0.0278467182,
-0.0354214236,
-0.040745113,
0.0915473551,
0.0130170416,
0.0303123947,
0.0324864388,
0.0335044563,
0.0589414313,
-0.0254151803,
-0.0046304176,
-0.0500325747,
0.0168840718,
0.0217490867,
0.0178962201,
0.0233862959,
0.0050687026,
-0.0699932575,
0.0265320167,
-0.0417734683,
-0.0134106753,
-0.0503044203,
-0.0352150761,
-0.0253104772,
0.0296232272,
-0.0353367925,
0.0260140318,
-0.076151073,
-0.0414717607,
0.0161540918,
-0.0488012806,
-0.0151694743,
0.0540515445,
2.551e-7,
0.0129793594,
-0.0274706036,
0.0242876187,
0.0301624723,
0.040919289,
0.0307043381,
-0.0441704132,
0.0281176716,
-0.0153478272,
-0.0295335688,
-0.0134357549,
0.0620993115,
0.0522887073,
-0.0215117838,
-0.0323753767,
0.0211268831,
-0.0509997085,
0.0084228218,
-0.0489783697,
0.0086415866,
0.0625916049,
0.0874511823,
-0.0111371092,
-0.0017488695,
0.0634594038,
-0.0069086892,
0.0827837214,
0.0152433291,
0.0187852271,
-0.0396052487,
-0.0348620452,
0.0097314771,
-0.0385316759,
-0.0128753781,
-0.0262839142,
-0.0227931123,
0.0161340758,
0.0379097797,
-0.042231068,
-0.0441966951,
-0.0166125111,
0.0478881486,
-0.04688273,
-0.0465009399,
0.0488309264,
-0.0437412336,
-0.0433736406,
-0.0166613255,
-0.0056004841,
0.006133623,
-0.018351268,
-0.0115329316,
-0.0425727479,
-0.0233810954,
0.0401365645,
-0.0203028526,
-0.038339965,
-0.045423843,
-0.0057931086,
0.0004499181,
-0.0486590862,
-0.000780755,
-0.071386829,
-0.0150354085,
-0.0002710222,
-0.0214179028,
-0.0944970176,
1.917778626e-34,
-0.0058997218,
-0.0402934998,
0.0331554078,
0.0160770826,
0.0095152818,
-0.0053121792,
-0.0229463447,
0.0095177116,
0.0132067781,
-0.0352026969,
-0.0566097721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15689v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15689v2 | Zero-shot Approach to Overcome Perturbation Sensitivity of Prompts | 2023-05-25T03:36:43 | 2023-07-01T23:02:18 | Mohna Chakraborty, Adithya Kulkarni, Qi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent studies have demonstrated that natural-language prompts can help to
leverage the knowledge learned by pre-trained language models for the binary
sentence-level sentiment classification task. Specifically, these methods
utilize few-shot learning settings to fine-tune the sentiment classification
model using manual or automatically generated prompts. However, the performance
of these methods is sensitive to the perturbations of the utilized prompts.
Furthermore, these methods depend on a few labeled instances for automatic
prompt generation and prompt ranking. This study aims to find high-quality
prompts for the given task in a zero-shot setting. Given a base prompt, our
proposed approach automatically generates multiple prompts similar to the base
prompt employing positional, reasoning, and paraphrasing techniques and then
ranks the prompts using a novel metric. We empirically demonstrate that the
top-ranked prompts are high-quality and significantly outperform the base
prompt and the prompts generated using few-shot learning for the binary
sentence-level sentiment classification task. | [
0.0548870899,
0.0118092457,
0.014373729,
-0.0001915058,
-0.0414769463,
0.0181408729,
0.0589825697,
-0.0041075065,
0.0389337167,
-0.0872878432,
-0.0270928703,
-0.0248563401,
-0.0230294708,
-0.0110732531,
0.0024179379,
-0.0457245521,
0.0534392036,
0.0093129855,
0.0740077421,
0.0104452642,
0.0043020938,
0.0059362734,
-0.0297021996,
0.0156291891,
-0.0150203863,
-0.0320300385,
0.0004730196,
0.0256813932,
0.0284371283,
-0.0510118976,
0.0292394683,
0.074993372,
-0.0148164164,
0.0193561539,
0.0000017718,
-0.060680896,
-0.0104249762,
-0.0206460487,
-0.0511326864,
-0.0258930363,
0.047384318,
-0.002348487,
0.0067803822,
0.0143335359,
-0.0310144834,
-0.0214117337,
0.0327850655,
0.0373663865,
0.0764596984,
0.0751655772,
-0.0068238541,
-0.0061663403,
-0.0456337892,
-0.0237415601,
0.0446057282,
-0.0246224254,
-0.003215105,
-0.0482654534,
0.0216627885,
0.0729964823,
0.0124721043,
-0.0000203798,
-0.0125106666,
-0.0051408685,
0.0204711929,
0.0225847848,
-0.0177860148,
-0.0096631628,
-0.0347806364,
0.0985875726,
-0.0215421915,
0.0007403184,
-0.024112979,
-0.0446443632,
0.0274312217,
-0.0360772908,
-0.0452390201,
0.0162232798,
0.0169766434,
-0.0172551554,
-0.0251910128,
0.0356330834,
-0.0132030789,
0.0139738014,
0.0128153963,
0.0322577693,
-0.0001439196,
-0.054604616,
-0.0115119582,
0.0136299329,
-0.0142825283,
-0.051176291,
-0.0330605954,
0.0315142609,
-0.0453571528,
0.0032872641,
-0.0422388986,
0.0126998741,
0.0423047766,
-0.0017207474,
0.080177404,
0.0244272258,
-0.0171243642,
0.0620414093,
-0.0380479172,
0.0332899503,
0.0359383188,
0.0254692566,
-0.0167778879,
0.037889827,
-0.0677776039,
-0.007496817,
-0.0294997338,
0.0537921712,
-0.0169849657,
-0.0098213376,
-0.047955934,
0.021102367,
-0.0057785511,
0.0363429114,
-0.0145159727,
0.0113955019,
-0.0040385048,
-0.00368585,
-0.0314870477,
0.0416370519,
-0.0611171126,
0.0152510302,
0.0115576005,
-0.0416828692,
-0.0240372252,
0.0027684912,
0.0410111994,
-0.0139212692,
-0.0098280152,
0.0395140164,
0.0006954905,
-0.0538564213,
-0.0351784378,
-0.0339052267,
-0.0482950918,
-0.0506306365,
-0.0319388658,
-0.0326022282,
0.0313613527,
-0.0014413693,
-0.024364382,
0.015932139,
0.0128006041,
0.0300958194,
-0.0266900752,
0.0792659894,
-0.0293693487,
-0.0428743437,
-0.0123734223,
-0.0086611835,
-0.0143994596,
0.0322555155,
-0.0279417206,
0.0583296306,
0.0450479053,
0.0105480747,
0.0163474176,
-0.0232205782,
0.0024558685,
-0.0205517132,
-0.0136255343,
0.0132404426,
0.0002782899,
0.0215650871,
-0.0158267003,
0.0061620306,
-0.0280827358,
0.0314061791,
0.0466946699,
0.031406533,
-0.011572985,
-0.0215686243,
0.0339997225,
0.0323302336,
-0.0188507829,
0.0152902119,
-0.0465112813,
0.0238108374,
-0.049093347,
-0.0057448079,
0.0141162593,
-0.0275599305,
-0.0305543914,
-0.0490946472,
0.0033920442,
-0.0353383236,
-0.0328367203,
0.0175207444,
0.0094595719,
0.0147884591,
-0.0753970593,
0.0194732398,
0.0067062047,
-0.0422225334,
-0.0183569007,
-0.0126841748,
0.0445538536,
0.0918284506,
-0.0020814948,
-0.0472707078,
-0.0169025119,
-0.0412758701,
0.0512565896,
0.0431604236,
0.0463184379,
-0.0181818493,
0.0356805064,
-0.0306152739,
-0.0289541166,
-0.0421998203,
0.0112738227,
0.0107147973,
-0.0364303663,
0.0247268584,
0.0293473154,
0.0439724401,
0.0001491049,
0.0095284423,
0.0440062247,
-0.0740603954,
0.0625757426,
0.0208656006,
0.0001666029,
0.0392024778,
-0.0112762935,
0.0155157419,
-0.0067581013,
-0.025422141,
-0.0241210405,
-0.0188227594,
-0.0509319901,
-0.091628924,
0.0016831699,
0.0385200679,
0.002224948,
0.0037122602,
-0.0710554272,
-0.0213586781,
-0.0214929488,
0.021533167,
-0.0022689113,
-0.0359829068,
0.004320459,
-0.0041667549,
0.0042935023,
-0.0637632683,
0.0743262693,
0.0397715718,
0.0365446769,
0.0302910097,
0.0129685812,
0.0365484692,
-0.0314428248,
-0.0229921546,
-0.0159234274,
-0.0062898463,
0.0167046357,
0.0445314758,
0.0268641096,
-0.0341226161,
-0.0294181574,
-0.1052415594,
-0.0182734057,
-0.0111310948,
-0.009162833,
0.0352910981,
-0.0023556973,
-0.0086433124,
-0.0263816696,
-0.0309036113,
-0.0129218511,
0.0050045578,
0.0272234008,
0.0819343999,
0.0264166761,
0.0219457932,
-0.0393227264,
0.0039313417,
-0.0239852946,
0.0409226269,
0.0258245971,
-0.0101664821,
-0.0490990393,
0.0351878926,
-0.0258219987,
-0.0049260068,
0.0306162275,
-0.0310808215,
0.0160824899,
-0.0110177528,
0.0023945842,
0.0843363553,
0.0189725682,
-0.0044327364,
0.019201478,
0.0279038008,
-0.0540696792,
0.0071131028,
-0.0369638801,
-0.0025027948,
0.0366150104,
0.0032119155,
0.0104371579,
0.0451755822,
0.0389195271,
0.0021197416,
-0.0628506988,
0.0734895617,
0.0016388636,
0.0054929554,
-0.0733261704,
0.0186751559,
-0.0133000463,
0.0536537766,
-0.0193159841,
-0.0115354899,
0.0703842491,
-0.0075045521,
0.0087004406,
-0.0570398159,
0.0020921421,
-0.0231200662,
-0.0016461491,
0.0006750136,
0.0255309157,
0.0311658271,
0.0009468282,
-0.037642654,
-0.0585018545,
0.0325033665,
0.0080712764,
-0.0144035295,
0.0074285367,
0.0090164049,
-0.0101716146,
-0.0655114353,
-0.040468175,
-0.1024762616,
-0.023236325,
0.0122754239,
-0.0385299996,
0.0170267187,
0.0191214494,
-0.0203252006,
0.0212084185,
0.0287796427,
-0.0388719589,
-0.0238531046,
-0.0347275548,
0.0564346239,
0.0434818082,
-0.0182787757,
0.00214674,
0.005133681,
0.053395804,
0.0085095447,
-0.0108573437,
0.0525443628,
-0.0051371004,
-0.0072086249,
0.0071469042,
-0.0409682207,
-0.0100343525,
0.0149429888,
0.0534376055,
-0.0174938291,
0.0120482333,
0.1410553753,
0.0485570766,
-0.0464517698,
-0.0062996387,
-0.0075005237,
-0.0018240402,
0.0268379133,
0.0334904455,
-0.0618506521,
-0.0521598943,
-0.0325054415,
0.0285109431,
-0.02299322,
-0.0224358737,
-0.0241684392,
-0.1631315351,
0.0231609046,
-0.0268091019,
-0.0182967316,
0.0031830226,
-0.0232153013,
0.0059433863,
0.008800515,
-0.0105585093,
-0.0198118314,
-0.0176140033,
0.0017156141,
-0.0059825056,
0.0009796555,
-0.0641364157,
0.040248733,
-0.021486355,
0.0273504537,
0.0776073337,
0.0249417145,
0.0047180783,
0.0013897937,
0.0048542866,
-0.0259753093,
0.0386510119,
0.0021267696,
0.0521050729,
-0.0279855318,
-0.011441661,
-0.010716971,
0.0045138104,
-0.0054062777,
-0.0182713345,
0.0085920459,
0.0236888994,
0.0034193466,
-0.0135324858,
-0.0059189647,
0.056269303,
0.050083328,
0.0782056302,
0.0217430424,
-0.0674489439,
-0.0286565982,
-0.0289153177,
0.0252414104,
-0.0686162785,
-0.0027852594,
-0.0061889319,
0.0004486107,
-0.002411142,
-0.0844069347,
-0.0583703108,
0.0190235712,
0.0605382249,
-0.0065854494,
0.0070385905,
-0.0424439833,
0.0160079803,
0.0199526418,
0.0059622056,
-0.0031625978,
0.0148554156,
-0.0494656377,
-0.0020754349,
0.0683496967,
-0.0011399862,
-0.0284075625,
-0.0599379838,
-0.0286589749,
-0.0388698801,
-0.0298504774,
0.0973090455,
0.0087301573,
0.0179965738,
-0.0051427749,
-0.0472856164,
0.0690566897,
0.0944611356,
-0.0064128526,
-0.0050534657,
0.0275311302,
0.0641388819,
-0.0142309116,
0.0271431208,
-0.0377955027,
0.0487120561,
0.029465314,
0.0161747113,
-0.0292475671,
-0.0418069698,
0.0174973775,
0.0094553819,
0.0726487339,
-0.0137586845,
-0.0304760821,
0.0014189275,
0.0193922836,
-0.0207750462,
-0.0360542536,
-0.034322232,
0.010749897,
-0.0004028981,
-0.0417511575,
-0.0133267744,
-0.0075131296,
-0.0611803345,
0.0566866659,
-0.0314708948,
-0.01338581,
0.0266891774,
0.0189338475,
-0.0044851638,
0.0140086887,
-0.0488340221,
0.0412263349,
-0.0004504597,
0.0135795996,
-0.0128833717,
0.0789466128,
0.0229087453,
-0.0029202376,
-0.0363829359,
0.0583789311,
-0.0498205908,
-0.0146863405,
-0.0065651513,
0.0374245755,
0.0457204096,
-0.0109726116,
-0.0177533645,
0.005508678,
-0.0126092564,
-0.0055318605,
0.0145765804,
0.0181654226,
-0.0307585541,
0.0171425752,
0.0340331011,
-0.0067613036,
0.0171935018,
0.0539826937,
-0.0494966246,
0.0098210908,
0.0237710606,
0.0197566357,
-0.0505580157,
0.0315441601,
0.0341745615,
0.0269268714,
0.0189103987,
0.0341032892,
-0.0688627511,
-0.0258145165,
0.0435467288,
-0.0179954935,
0.0048146639,
0.0060480121,
0.0427196473,
0.0311811883,
-0.0003235896,
0.0309727117,
-0.0532534458,
0.0098119248,
0.0141394269,
-0.036766924,
-0.0471878052,
-5.978208314e-33,
-0.0365476906,
-0.0113461139,
-0.0323387869,
0.0015739719,
0.0487722084,
-0.0062487661,
-0.0087307403,
0.0184058379,
-0.0074875914,
0.0269897096,
-0.0189438388,
-0.0302426405,
0.0110139269,
0.034325622,
-0.0007042947,
-0.0233545918,
0.0455270931,
-0.0137190055,
-0.0481514148,
0.0157990493,
0.0332953483,
0.0307314526,
0.0180442221,
-0.033093255,
0.0367292911,
0.0002721648,
-0.0246933419,
0.0104884515,
0.0422649719,
0.0275623053,
-0.0048761284,
0.0605428442,
0.0337400548,
-0.0457853079,
0.009057587,
0.0802368224,
-0.0369615145,
-0.0739830062,
0.0052536181,
-0.0219834987,
-0.0052283825,
-0.0421365835,
-0.048429884,
-0.059882503,
-0.0009747179,
0.002052645,
0.0272972379,
-0.007672233,
-0.0146046299,
-0.0543348081,
-0.0426162258,
-0.0165754855,
0.0053470097,
-0.0415595323,
-0.0147882374,
0.0946225673,
0.0131050078,
0.070181042,
-0.0414640717,
0.0264313798,
-0.0021873401,
0.0229894314,
-0.00584159,
-0.0107271411,
-0.0424816199,
0.0689612925,
0.037824817,
0.0213369224,
-0.0234820545,
0.0319318995,
-0.0087066339,
-0.0096859876,
0.030725833,
0.09661486,
0.0615067258,
0.0054027094,
-0.0585238598,
0.0055268784,
0.0279763546,
-0.0271541122,
0.0410508253,
-0.0308762211,
-0.0199033562,
-0.0202560406,
-0.0178600457,
-0.0545887463,
-0.0591301508,
-0.0283938684,
0.0331758261,
0.020468384,
-0.0382442102,
-0.0409382619,
0.0261232946,
-0.0248530619,
-0.0299084801,
0.0226868726,
-0.0214059521,
0.020425804,
0.0148315392,
-0.0112501942,
-0.0420074649,
-0.0098607754,
0.0254659764,
0.0372326374,
0.0172806568,
0.0316877328,
0.0789512396,
0.0182582084,
-0.0825648233,
-0.0022671081,
0.0006356896,
0.0403257273,
-0.0285220314,
0.0225522481,
-0.0199255534,
0.0210355427,
-0.0146460012,
0.0843931064,
0.0115101403,
-0.0173052642,
0.0302915312,
0.0217155255,
-0.0146519896,
0.0218545329,
-0.0305265896,
-0.0321813524,
0.0185357202,
0.0248063263,
-0.0109323906,
-0.0352690443,
0.0052762539,
-0.0063501038,
2.606e-7,
-0.0045622326,
0.0592265949,
-0.0290531963,
0.0101287477,
0.0151635343,
0.0661992058,
0.0073839654,
0.0385524519,
0.0048304736,
-0.0139572117,
0.0286909379,
0.0000653454,
-0.0043732678,
-0.0133791985,
-0.1397059411,
-0.0083986716,
-0.037333373,
0.0183935985,
-0.038761165,
0.006252713,
0.1254487038,
0.0759591162,
0.005534518,
-0.0043553119,
-0.0059628692,
-0.0356509835,
0.0465287529,
-0.0037185585,
-0.0022558025,
-0.0020731681,
0.0276745521,
-0.0349112749,
-0.0119463606,
0.0054713599,
-0.0094450358,
-0.0127315503,
-0.013623165,
0.068821758,
-0.0053823884,
-0.0428855903,
-0.0000580709,
0.0365192667,
0.0161892418,
-0.0224667806,
0.086341098,
-0.1108838394,
0.0058236872,
-0.0602785312,
-0.0347590819,
-0.0125151463,
0.0555855893,
-0.0285732113,
-0.0650229007,
0.0031900594,
0.0204306133,
0.0112158917,
-0.0248909816,
-0.0746117011,
-0.0129570207,
0.0106789358,
0.0177919026,
-0.0227004364,
0.008069315,
-0.0200641286,
0.0244006272,
-0.0682103634,
0.0208026413,
2.139639868e-34,
0.0377136134,
-0.0230960622,
0.0332942829,
-0.0082452362,
-0.0094528217,
0.0266866777,
-0.0379583463,
-0.0262806229,
0.0707989782,
-0.0382883064,
-0.0083387848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15685v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15685v2 | RewriteLM: An Instruction-Tuned Large Language Model for Text Rewriting | 2023-05-25T03:26:26 | 2023-12-19T23:57:01 | Lei Shu, Liangchen Luo, Jayakumar Hoskere, Yun Zhu, Yinxiao Liu, Simon Tong, Jindong Chen, Lei Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities in
creative tasks such as storytelling and E-mail generation. However, as LLMs are
primarily trained on final text results rather than intermediate revisions, it
might be challenging for them to perform text rewriting tasks. Most studies in
the rewriting tasks focus on a particular transformation type within the
boundaries of single sentences. In this work, we develop new strategies for
instruction tuning and reinforcement learning to better align LLMs for
cross-sentence rewriting tasks using diverse wording and structures expressed
through natural languages including 1) generating rewriting instruction data
from Wiki edits and public corpus through instruction generation and
chain-of-thought prompting; 2) collecting comparison data for reward model
training through a new ranking function. To facilitate this research, we
introduce OpenRewriteEval, a novel benchmark covers a wide variety of rewriting
types expressed through natural language instructions. Our results show
significant improvements over a variety of baselines. The public repository is
available on GitHub under Google Research
(https://github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/rewritelm). | [
0.0510003306,
0.024424335,
0.0193118025,
0.0174735319,
-0.0577409863,
0.0033253154,
-0.0223830901,
0.0032985744,
-0.0112450561,
-0.0528963245,
-0.0302300155,
-0.0036178997,
0.0003331384,
0.0177956801,
0.0109613733,
-0.0631745234,
0.0099394526,
-0.0431322083,
0.0295770057,
0.0291742198,
-0.0048050294,
0.034201175,
0.0136286011,
0.0371586643,
0.0125551075,
-0.0188684873,
0.0214259867,
0.0366365574,
0.0327035561,
-0.0133425891,
0.0273931418,
0.0305988695,
0.0349598266,
0.0657414943,
0.0000018185,
-0.059102986,
-0.0305066798,
-0.0015699833,
0.0236921944,
0.0305100475,
0.0412924401,
-0.0197937451,
-0.0317807011,
0.0172205325,
-0.0108521068,
0.0194792394,
0.0256668162,
0.0559664033,
0.0817252398,
0.1319494992,
0.0007693492,
-0.0543334335,
0.0278221387,
-0.050008934,
0.0548462905,
0.0042305766,
0.0230248403,
0.0078414418,
-0.0056760628,
0.0067712455,
-0.0306483544,
0.0086199287,
0.0317127183,
-0.0647699833,
0.0007346047,
0.0246914774,
0.0114234257,
0.0245798137,
-0.018979514,
0.0387688726,
-0.0217112638,
-0.0097571081,
0.0150924921,
0.0157638285,
0.0128158433,
0.0060788682,
-0.0263575409,
0.0403647386,
0.0102168601,
0.0105521176,
0.0132222669,
-0.004570778,
0.0161820613,
0.0164601412,
-0.0059084524,
0.0308469869,
0.0489472672,
-0.0357570499,
-0.0484889783,
-0.0091022337,
0.0218593869,
-0.0873829126,
0.0109843342,
0.0214598048,
-0.0492132865,
-0.0075574024,
-0.0816164762,
-0.0083293375,
-0.0079010082,
-0.0211911481,
0.072520636,
0.0144588305,
0.0541011132,
0.0304878857,
-0.0279526226,
0.0683827996,
-0.0169853847,
0.0185817555,
-0.0480944738,
0.0343892947,
-0.0621051155,
0.0043395492,
-0.0443361439,
0.0132988142,
-0.0512948856,
-0.0222602095,
-0.0696358755,
0.0239346083,
0.0335424542,
0.0023506235,
0.0036825472,
-0.002505451,
-0.0400092714,
-0.0474222824,
-0.0213214438,
0.0495964661,
0.0248914659,
0.0038095114,
0.0293670781,
0.027937416,
0.0021401641,
-0.0071676383,
0.0108813364,
-0.0417145006,
0.0121735791,
0.0483913645,
-0.0406065136,
-0.0105652306,
-0.0418259054,
-0.0354709178,
-0.008958973,
-0.0330973528,
-0.0312519483,
-0.0727193877,
0.0265470352,
-0.0098366914,
-0.0029948321,
-0.0239984225,
0.0333361737,
0.0202783514,
-0.0451623909,
0.0297022182,
0.0409622081,
0.0098278988,
0.0268123187,
0.0042307852,
0.0165187307,
0.0108935051,
0.0812276825,
0.0492929928,
0.0434666574,
0.0165486373,
0.0309333298,
0.0125443153,
-0.0264561009,
0.027704658,
-0.0046380069,
0.0153257763,
0.0107392659,
0.0850533843,
0.0545235053,
0.0621615984,
-0.0437708646,
0.0286059845,
0.1100482196,
-0.011396436,
0.0355816819,
0.001736843,
0.1014517695,
0.0203797147,
-0.0148022762,
0.028373396,
-0.0474869385,
0.0239938684,
0.0021099669,
0.039091751,
0.0283036772,
0.0168604162,
-0.0053983694,
-0.0235101823,
0.0152359409,
-0.019805558,
-0.0073043732,
-0.0499368943,
0.0141978292,
0.0475962684,
-0.1100763083,
-0.0277440585,
0.0209254175,
-0.0658184811,
0.0378445275,
-0.0359345414,
0.028974155,
0.091001451,
0.075634785,
0.0046995594,
-0.0170025397,
-0.0345219038,
-0.0018550727,
0.0400841497,
0.0418746397,
-0.0248701293,
-0.017245464,
-0.0291805062,
-0.0044706608,
-0.0774019286,
0.0175932907,
0.0309582315,
0.0434001945,
0.002808566,
0.0205421988,
-0.0293425787,
-0.0684997067,
0.0506925918,
-0.0244797692,
-0.0331408679,
0.00751385,
-0.0008658161,
-0.0169237312,
-0.0249578226,
-0.0530345775,
0.0222282708,
-0.0139094712,
-0.037631426,
-0.0401048735,
-0.0108739696,
-0.0334343798,
-0.0494510196,
0.0126041193,
-0.0791009441,
-0.0002598796,
0.0373071767,
-0.0336896069,
-0.0278398655,
0.0145124355,
-0.0378693826,
0.0439147614,
-0.0128204022,
0.0384717993,
0.0077602086,
-0.0305368304,
-0.050664708,
0.0266766138,
0.0005577707,
-0.0103112413,
0.0270163007,
-0.0489165261,
-0.0340990536,
-0.0088889254,
-0.0013163767,
-0.0217664056,
0.0032774804,
0.0134486808,
0.0200333688,
0.0546371192,
-0.0259952508,
-0.0942380056,
-0.0585618615,
0.0302275103,
-0.0239029508,
0.0113695171,
0.0480373725,
0.0354950652,
-0.024029633,
-0.0032105613,
-0.0080156969,
-0.0299109761,
-0.0096494574,
0.0240818914,
0.0445512459,
0.0097112563,
-0.0204639956,
-0.0303090345,
-0.0236588046,
0.0066850241,
0.0515570678,
0.0239140615,
0.0415930338,
-0.0550574102,
0.0423442125,
-0.0431627706,
-0.0285505001,
0.0088198138,
-0.0323297903,
-0.0084997173,
-0.003685324,
0.1225853413,
0.0772190988,
0.0311224386,
0.0062107746,
0.0266177617,
-0.0232985839,
-0.002049736,
0.008941222,
-0.0153475022,
-0.0340976007,
-0.0373497382,
-0.0550047979,
0.0328847654,
0.0582219549,
0.0148883788,
-0.0088614868,
-0.0385754555,
0.0174106117,
-0.0149426125,
-0.0306059513,
-0.0192940161,
-0.0119334618,
-0.0035482303,
-0.0014347539,
-0.0392424054,
-0.0535998344,
0.0678196475,
-0.0067564263,
0.0121140368,
-0.0497218482,
0.0011616095,
-0.0546986833,
0.0321046263,
0.0095961299,
0.0411504582,
-0.0139506571,
0.0078587877,
-0.068474479,
-0.0075633065,
0.0320525169,
-0.0069999415,
0.0133476444,
-0.050495971,
-0.009888337,
-0.0233733524,
-0.0385987721,
-0.0218979325,
-0.0261830632,
0.0299250931,
-0.0092598367,
0.0340444632,
-0.0376983397,
-0.0122568961,
-0.013911048,
0.0652929395,
0.0749601498,
-0.0101372749,
-0.0376861133,
-0.0344518833,
0.0480749235,
0.0622603483,
-0.0149379773,
-0.0191482324,
-0.0515801869,
0.0268950369,
0.0172911454,
0.0124668423,
-0.0247410182,
0.0022656999,
-0.0042565321,
0.0021859622,
-0.073679924,
-0.03089731,
0.0271185506,
0.0511086285,
-0.0755969435,
-0.0235972833,
0.1022295877,
0.0328841992,
-0.041664131,
0.0006335272,
0.005890314,
0.0399429314,
0.0102572795,
0.0561253056,
-0.0727063045,
-0.0063532051,
0.0100280568,
0.0116121667,
0.009627549,
-0.0309204105,
-0.0165642481,
-0.0990890786,
0.0476422012,
0.0044709719,
-0.0141677288,
-0.0158002377,
-0.0228040665,
-0.0347816199,
0.0191581547,
-0.0200874135,
0.0360848345,
-0.0378456824,
0.0007771004,
-0.044396162,
0.0063018417,
-0.0304480288,
0.007977264,
-0.0560419112,
0.0226645954,
0.0773382559,
0.0434865803,
0.0087898085,
-0.0194198787,
-0.0268052686,
0.0201560501,
-0.0135299014,
-0.0143910851,
0.0332047418,
0.0071710744,
0.0228653941,
-0.0095000444,
0.0505716354,
-0.0073730135,
-0.0057352819,
0.0258814003,
0.0591303632,
0.018385414,
-0.0353231654,
-0.0160261896,
-0.0136486534,
0.0258173142,
0.0610647351,
0.0116224559,
-0.0626495555,
-0.0689558163,
-0.035265848,
-0.022429537,
-0.101158157,
-0.0404688045,
-0.032771755,
-0.0351719484,
0.0462719686,
-0.1036149859,
-0.0165959764,
0.0141558526,
0.0299443752,
0.0304631274,
-0.0164385159,
-0.0172660369,
-0.0401971154,
-0.0516763777,
-0.0076986281,
-0.0475830436,
0.0520589799,
-0.0583517402,
-0.0147378352,
-0.0033300275,
-0.0504397377,
-0.0004145637,
-0.00721265,
-0.0526478365,
-0.0624096021,
-0.0243490692,
0.0460144915,
0.0133947665,
0.0459080823,
0.0120711857,
-0.03836146,
0.0490805879,
-0.0067343866,
-0.0434620418,
0.070086576,
0.013220679,
0.0505496264,
-0.0000059521,
0.0421108268,
-0.0368858688,
-0.0002110068,
0.0303231031,
0.0499578305,
0.0306194052,
0.0006609173,
0.0266110301,
0.0050106375,
-0.0328017659,
-0.0269969702,
0.0093413917,
-0.0608640499,
0.0272408947,
-0.0396494046,
-0.0166574325,
-0.0383826233,
0.0124057485,
0.0724577755,
0.0310745258,
-0.0175960083,
0.0418810025,
0.0085196737,
-0.0150568355,
-0.0760352835,
-0.0176586658,
0.0116729317,
0.0082612671,
0.0462836213,
-0.0010377746,
-0.0107131582,
0.0154468892,
-0.0244319998,
0.0436936915,
-0.0006527238,
0.0480263159,
0.0277129617,
-0.0089871464,
-0.0336949304,
0.058458209,
-0.0652310327,
0.0047085388,
-0.0083348928,
0.0086530149,
0.058803644,
0.0294994619,
0.0866222754,
-0.0328219272,
-0.0156413447,
-0.01172172,
0.0505138636,
-0.0062964694,
-0.0160633307,
0.0058246143,
-0.0055700256,
0.0005872336,
0.0495852232,
0.0862066224,
0.007566832,
0.0564495958,
0.034518972,
-0.0057382192,
-0.042225793,
-0.0328903273,
0.0313280262,
0.0004075099,
0.0020083454,
-0.0336648747,
-0.0328990594,
-0.012308307,
0.0346286334,
0.0229648259,
0.0069255736,
-0.0120648127,
0.0156835578,
0.0353042819,
-0.0172918439,
-0.0045945444,
-0.0632268935,
-0.0143926917,
0.0030436534,
-0.0629941821,
-0.0309848618,
-5.472600276e-33,
-0.0151946992,
0.0017384199,
0.0370676517,
-0.0034426302,
-0.0684392229,
0.0342101716,
-0.0259955619,
-0.0132086901,
0.0282783173,
0.0258510616,
-0.0059678745,
-0.0132762222,
-0.0102398964,
0.0262481701,
-0.00255512,
0.0339344963,
0.0641282126,
-0.0002174583,
-0.0715765357,
0.0366509855,
0.015553805,
0.0168929938,
0.0455020331,
-0.0237134714,
-0.0019333955,
-0.0035732235,
-0.0389970541,
0.0145309903,
-0.0123178018,
0.0157738887,
-0.0152958017,
0.0053116498,
-0.0008636095,
-0.0249281265,
-0.0247784238,
0.0213304944,
-0.0274638273,
0.0039006865,
0.0196028072,
-0.0200160556,
-0.0544197597,
-0.0657468811,
0.0231851656,
0.0058220327,
0.013240342,
-0.0189949628,
0.0209032632,
-0.0099052731,
0.0133145759,
0.0109107802,
-0.1036423668,
-0.0058873864,
-0.0012525587,
-0.0637774989,
-0.0429658666,
0.0120802717,
0.0069361562,
0.0130017279,
-0.0463108681,
0.0565219112,
0.0051758033,
0.0633116961,
0.0216432977,
-0.0019132133,
-0.028441485,
0.0332463421,
-0.0104788644,
0.025217358,
-0.0148769738,
0.026728021,
0.0026962089,
0.0491269156,
0.0286180489,
0.0556633174,
0.006937752,
0.0224156827,
-0.0562512614,
0.0278381612,
-0.030426085,
0.0082767047,
0.0299277008,
0.030681178,
0.0032892665,
-0.0015928691,
-0.0499512888,
0.0053063761,
-0.0244650394,
-0.0078326073,
0.0439333171,
0.0535229854,
-0.0221210774,
-0.0139371371,
0.0133192614,
-0.018573571,
0.0075785914,
0.0215414595,
-0.0524960309,
0.0742786527,
-0.0227196626,
-0.0134262089,
-0.0424699597,
0.0083592916,
0.043653138,
0.0064610518,
-0.0057271849,
0.0025378731,
0.040291708,
0.0563077629,
-0.0604408048,
0.0202205814,
-0.0196268838,
0.0273842737,
-0.0025528516,
0.0029607061,
0.0045298128,
-0.0089124944,
-0.0025650708,
-0.0082722716,
0.0430378169,
-0.046327278,
-0.0215389039,
-0.02103482,
0.0181967299,
0.0165866315,
-0.0135550676,
0.0411436558,
-0.0298659019,
0.0134544158,
-0.0064878808,
-0.0480052345,
-0.0241736956,
-0.0057581733,
2.574e-7,
0.0102344817,
0.0620982759,
0.0303867329,
0.0426502787,
-0.0023478062,
0.0165201873,
0.0023817881,
0.0427666008,
0.0305046141,
0.0232017953,
0.0233704038,
0.0018572953,
0.0432680994,
-0.0158960801,
-0.0994098857,
0.0212978553,
-0.0786904171,
0.0130876424,
-0.0843610987,
-0.067038171,
0.0304157082,
0.0242685322,
0.0191143453,
-0.0156831108,
-0.0010999346,
-0.0371488594,
0.0829537362,
-0.0453503318,
-0.0308961086,
0.0355518535,
-0.0133011723,
-0.0027754689,
-0.0107550612,
-0.0328917466,
-0.0338349976,
-0.0013750771,
0.0004932751,
0.0769800395,
-0.0072439383,
0.0304514002,
0.0264722779,
-0.0126691367,
-0.0253420826,
-0.0418108515,
0.0339923538,
-0.0363315158,
0.0098679895,
0.0126989791,
0.0003102742,
-0.0106578264,
0.0413859524,
-0.0838022009,
-0.0213589408,
0.0141400378,
0.0226895828,
0.048551634,
-0.0135025661,
-0.014493674,
-0.0295854378,
-0.0105735054,
-0.0137794195,
-0.0192323662,
-0.0601961315,
0.005143587,
-0.0187430009,
-0.0747476444,
-0.0005330129,
2.719765386e-34,
0.0238461811,
-0.03087328,
0.0019094571,
-0.0018582798,
0.0488685183,
0.0202472042,
-0.0131319538,
0.0036455705,
-0.0014935558,
-0.0912624672,
-0.0383668467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15684v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15684v1 | Perturbation-based Self-supervised Attention for Attention Bias in Text Classification | 2023-05-25T03:18:18 | 2023-05-25T03:18:18 | Huawen Feng, Zhenxi Lin, Qianli Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL | In text classification, the traditional attention mechanisms usually focus
too much on frequent words, and need extensive labeled data in order to learn.
This paper proposes a perturbation-based self-supervised attention approach to
guide attention learning without any annotation overhead. Specifically, we add
as much noise as possible to all the words in the sentence without changing
their semantics and predictions. We hypothesize that words that tolerate more
noise are less significant, and we can use this information to refine the
attention distribution. Experimental results on three text classification tasks
show that our approach can significantly improve the performance of current
attention-based models, and is more effective than existing self-supervised
methods. We also provide a visualization analysis to verify the effectiveness
of our approach. | [
0.0248065088,
0.0177461877,
-0.0036562434,
0.0137619134,
0.0191811826,
-0.0099801952,
0.0111918729,
-0.0370646603,
0.0487991944,
-0.0426245295,
-0.0464863814,
0.0196920913,
-0.029169539,
-0.0069292155,
0.0324972868,
-0.03606195,
0.0597041063,
-0.002410864,
0.0377972201,
0.0333944969,
-0.0005686362,
-0.0226133447,
0.0263938848,
-0.0106421374,
-0.0296903793,
-0.0183335077,
0.0005793929,
0.0347626358,
0.006376707,
-0.0264746677,
0.0206342079,
0.0986778587,
-0.0298520736,
0.0263719987,
0.0000019381,
-0.0381435342,
-0.0068795173,
-0.014287943,
-0.0282931048,
0.057729423,
0.0701818764,
0.019978093,
0.0126883974,
-0.0046522147,
-0.0095286751,
-0.0046310741,
0.0443099961,
0.0669882372,
0.0508230142,
0.0519025996,
-0.0179485474,
-0.0087939957,
-0.0232581459,
-0.0749950856,
0.0644896999,
-0.0430327915,
0.0230329651,
-0.0319170579,
-0.0419763364,
0.0294800941,
-0.0355342105,
0.0343107693,
0.0018701316,
-0.0136034153,
0.1251805872,
0.0578154474,
-0.0181208383,
-0.0036810122,
-0.0190500226,
0.0854402408,
-0.0489173792,
-0.0560806245,
-0.0282528624,
-0.0138861705,
0.0717671439,
-0.0208064895,
-0.0240803119,
-0.0338121727,
0.0268280003,
0.0164079964,
0.0240826365,
0.0271689147,
0.0157162622,
-0.0077945488,
-0.0458597727,
0.0053966907,
-0.0440907776,
-0.0482263193,
-0.0109489076,
0.0020587328,
0.0225421414,
-0.0151787242,
0.0006171841,
0.0185461622,
0.0609318428,
-0.0284657162,
-0.0757469609,
-0.0550175197,
0.0169451684,
-0.092473574,
0.0204917397,
-0.0130113903,
-0.0513916723,
0.0738423467,
0.0124409217,
-0.0352178961,
-0.0091870269,
0.025100993,
-0.0239747241,
0.0401748009,
0.0071326774,
0.0461311638,
-0.0723037049,
0.0324243233,
-0.0097961668,
-0.0086852191,
-0.0213056821,
0.0214015879,
0.0058801444,
-0.0338691175,
0.0250038244,
0.0081517687,
-0.057285089,
-0.0046088276,
-0.0130160451,
-0.0177670997,
-0.0473559499,
-0.0010520169,
-0.0018452889,
-0.0058331983,
-0.0487817489,
0.0393455476,
0.0101319123,
-0.0215835236,
-0.0169745162,
0.0742344931,
0.0155867608,
-0.0452521183,
-0.0302267987,
0.0099080056,
-0.0466780216,
-0.0214329176,
-0.0286641624,
0.0079605952,
-0.0094986325,
-0.0329247527,
-0.0214090813,
-0.019432798,
0.0255646799,
0.0049034655,
-0.0310510714,
0.041926194,
0.0119505534,
-0.018845832,
0.0160112549,
-0.0107144527,
-0.0077889902,
0.0331904404,
0.0178748667,
0.0236475095,
0.0089233806,
-0.0362635702,
0.0260944683,
-0.0342823453,
0.0456423499,
-0.0201119557,
-0.0182835348,
0.0123113161,
-0.0243780017,
-0.0230089407,
0.0533770025,
0.0113002826,
-0.003597992,
-0.0284282733,
0.0620676912,
0.0173432846,
0.0101989079,
0.0695377663,
-0.0550589785,
0.0384689569,
-0.0023416728,
0.0077115404,
-0.0847435817,
0.0720222592,
-0.0226083342,
-0.0174643472,
0.0670978352,
-0.0362379886,
-0.0570391975,
-0.0642717332,
0.023097191,
-0.0199452136,
0.0168474615,
0.0302606132,
0.0738890171,
0.0165269729,
0.0139726941,
0.0434666388,
0.0330560543,
-0.041020371,
0.0054659708,
-0.0193958357,
0.0119631719,
0.0434608497,
0.0035293477,
-0.0994672626,
0.0147160366,
-0.050743252,
0.055657398,
0.0195286255,
0.0510465801,
0.0588614717,
-0.0080475528,
-0.020541396,
-0.0206807498,
-0.0549669452,
0.0157904737,
-0.0033923073,
-0.0143195875,
0.0212204289,
0.024306301,
-0.0433864407,
-0.0897674412,
0.0545045994,
0.0639680699,
-0.0872705951,
0.0428443551,
0.0233733058,
0.0448930562,
0.0213502683,
-0.003246272,
0.0290122982,
0.0432281494,
-0.0177158359,
0.0160352997,
-0.0212323945,
0.0025567785,
-0.0227881391,
0.0098256459,
-0.0192164388,
-0.0341472924,
0.0221477188,
-0.0038169571,
-0.0170555301,
0.0697551295,
-0.0651679039,
0.0242150575,
-0.0114523526,
0.0059566735,
0.0055251191,
0.0747416914,
-0.0515945256,
0.0558050834,
0.0093729058,
0.0147759207,
-0.0493358113,
0.0063163997,
0.0251033828,
-0.0164664164,
-0.0195623282,
-0.1080826819,
-0.0066315667,
-0.0047226083,
0.0279457774,
-0.0262616985,
-0.0114758136,
-0.0378441773,
-0.0083671901,
-0.0357093923,
-0.0317176692,
0.0107766828,
0.0019042359,
0.0266449992,
-0.0037630138,
-0.0732039437,
-0.0039339243,
-0.0014102845,
-0.0544592477,
-0.0031482487,
0.0469534695,
-0.0394018032,
0.0466619879,
-0.0478417352,
-0.0151284449,
0.0066220714,
0.0194355361,
0.0432904623,
-0.0513126403,
-0.0551481172,
-0.0168012939,
-0.0016321715,
0.0494988561,
0.0235118791,
-0.0389291979,
0.0031935254,
-0.0126347682,
0.031527102,
0.1334721297,
0.041323144,
-0.0109134624,
0.0634681359,
0.0236087851,
-0.0274096485,
0.0528218225,
-0.010477894,
0.0505890846,
0.0143511584,
0.0011127408,
0.0191876739,
0.0579159856,
-0.0196999162,
-0.0165607966,
-0.0321250558,
0.0083289696,
0.0314160399,
-0.0064000669,
0.0034577346,
0.0608550385,
-0.0109793879,
0.0174144693,
-0.0193201117,
-0.0572615378,
0.0612436011,
0.0249716062,
0.0001761531,
-0.053601969,
0.0029546963,
-0.0043960959,
0.0108341174,
-0.0040948004,
0.0267701428,
-0.0191242043,
-0.0289075337,
-0.0023728367,
-0.0169608835,
0.0401038416,
-0.0026852801,
0.0270370971,
0.0386513695,
0.0305911601,
0.0004569821,
-0.0028554476,
-0.0479681231,
-0.0595016368,
0.002493511,
-0.0602398738,
0.0032285368,
0.0124473879,
-0.0670479983,
0.0214982163,
0.0216643903,
0.0512406528,
-0.0255901068,
-0.0183613878,
0.0124905128,
0.0379044674,
0.0187215451,
-0.0115916105,
0.0060829311,
-0.0047581433,
-0.0162880551,
0.0513501763,
-0.0018897369,
-0.0114223659,
-0.0041928678,
-0.02629558,
0.0104321362,
-0.0426869802,
0.0202025119,
-0.0061259745,
0.0093031349,
-0.0537639111,
-0.0366601311,
0.0838904381,
0.014460816,
-0.0756186321,
-0.0025834143,
-0.000587341,
-0.0009032155,
0.0517361909,
0.0499121584,
-0.0110290237,
-0.0351704359,
-0.0362509266,
0.0352288969,
0.0576158203,
0.0101806428,
-0.0032602574,
-0.0279449951,
0.0542472526,
0.0167980175,
-0.0323494747,
-0.0436704755,
-0.0639572218,
0.0293356273,
-0.0182427093,
-0.0436653718,
0.0125534702,
0.0056951051,
-0.0097412728,
0.0126880668,
-0.0262136701,
-0.027653465,
-0.0283969156,
-0.0031036914,
0.0242646467,
0.0268477146,
-0.0151368957,
-0.028290255,
-0.0493488759,
0.0479343943,
0.0283087585,
-0.0032222206,
-0.0113134189,
0.0999693945,
-0.0248296633,
-0.0038125294,
-0.0279674642,
-0.0027968432,
-0.0204873011,
0.0082629416,
-0.0058968444,
0.056674961,
-0.0102573931,
-0.0130027849,
-0.0466644317,
-0.0239411108,
0.0214632265,
0.0383194461,
0.0554014742,
-0.0671225414,
-0.0608625039,
-0.0407958478,
-0.0114708934,
-0.0372846276,
-0.0155772679,
0.0375305377,
0.0107348338,
-0.1039625183,
-0.0084378095,
-0.0647678226,
-0.0197276175,
0.0265297126,
0.0120197907,
0.0160797294,
-0.0074066529,
-0.03995106,
-0.0288042203,
0.0404134728,
-0.0321565382,
-0.0361153334,
-0.0120054027,
-0.0588584505,
0.0324744433,
-0.0126438234,
0.0000380508,
-0.0008354625,
-0.0775547624,
-0.029790679,
0.0179327782,
0.0341624692,
-0.0034183057,
0.0463541076,
-0.0420729071,
-0.0573884808,
0.0440588742,
0.0240017939,
-0.0522388071,
-0.0061698454,
0.047475405,
-0.031963829,
0.013967149,
0.0187787786,
-0.0132189831,
0.0604328588,
0.032047756,
-0.0214860123,
-0.0676521063,
-0.0377309546,
0.0030469792,
-0.0194456298,
0.0629330352,
-0.0057330402,
0.0164694618,
-0.0197707042,
0.00440655,
0.0336631648,
-0.0246442426,
-0.0175540783,
0.0003133569,
0.0264837798,
-0.0649201348,
-0.0073142587,
0.0099694282,
-0.0546058752,
-0.0534665026,
-0.043866273,
0.014742271,
-0.0438828245,
0.0115925893,
-0.0407726578,
0.0201112311,
-0.0206747912,
-0.0009974039,
0.0221579745,
0.0454500876,
0.0406989641,
-0.0327089168,
0.0059233978,
0.015351194,
-0.0309697147,
-0.0075506913,
-0.0932535902,
0.0466761738,
-0.0089246808,
-0.0005289771,
0.0272607282,
-0.0413071811,
0.0048166607,
0.0061259246,
-0.0061725578,
-0.0034526477,
0.0036483521,
-0.0040718368,
0.0258514415,
-0.0186616369,
-0.0065279128,
-0.0113276355,
0.0238008164,
0.0702767223,
0.0168200377,
-0.0246414244,
0.0414478034,
-0.0112994518,
-0.070501551,
0.0325004198,
-0.0070717805,
0.0520320311,
-0.012363039,
0.0481618568,
0.0119005125,
-0.0619631708,
0.0232456848,
-0.0396592915,
-0.0033027874,
-0.0134698842,
0.0395226404,
0.0089668278,
-0.0182063058,
-0.0093450965,
-0.023716379,
0.0512216166,
0.0127968285,
-0.0166736804,
-0.0101730749,
-6.35334052e-33,
0.0060864668,
-0.0369619988,
-0.0431644581,
0.0260957051,
0.0184322149,
-0.00854077,
-0.0253019389,
0.0204267055,
-0.0292104632,
0.0263251252,
0.0048423628,
0.0527974814,
-0.0086772405,
0.020243058,
0.026471924,
-0.021976918,
0.0330328494,
-0.0173920058,
-0.0079984991,
0.0426110737,
-0.0394503288,
0.014131763,
0.0608939976,
-0.0806410909,
0.0124441553,
0.0216747131,
0.014099244,
-0.0143073788,
0.0294075012,
0.0377636142,
0.0016684316,
0.0597889908,
-0.0098373676,
-0.009088737,
-0.0172527153,
0.0221849345,
-0.0512284115,
-0.0814833865,
-0.056530647,
-0.0176624171,
-0.0124264993,
-0.0207763258,
0.0714114159,
0.0347649381,
0.024265999,
-0.034548711,
0.0552611835,
-0.0063321255,
-0.0614048764,
0.0242546424,
-0.0175845474,
0.0293636154,
-0.0467353016,
-0.0110542206,
0.0399200246,
0.0395260826,
0.0138622811,
0.0332455002,
-0.0733237118,
0.0210791249,
0.0466964282,
0.0188467819,
0.0027875022,
0.0086487737,
-0.0034164253,
-0.0016573023,
0.0363399982,
0.0435576662,
-0.0305676553,
-0.0320688337,
0.0112126553,
0.0137290787,
0.019456856,
-0.0006139543,
0.0277278796,
0.0026812926,
-0.1112586036,
0.0047232914,
0.0055649509,
0.0357376151,
0.0674746707,
0.0062453039,
-0.0647264645,
-0.0125815133,
0.0293031409,
-0.032472793,
-0.048384551,
0.0134602357,
0.0029355893,
0.0403671078,
-0.030473426,
0.0116915833,
-0.0092011048,
-0.0091409264,
-0.0042029177,
-0.0236977264,
0.023916021,
-0.000065811,
0.0251927953,
-0.0344943739,
-0.0556646474,
0.0309226513,
0.0001170349,
0.0150212068,
-0.0018509459,
0.0195991583,
0.0540411659,
-0.0269464422,
-0.0517055616,
-0.0318142213,
0.0146111585,
-0.0047674715,
0.0242680479,
0.0395992361,
0.0205051359,
-0.0127235586,
0.0058542574,
0.0813238621,
0.0349093266,
0.0102265859,
0.0022777871,
0.0232538749,
0.0245906264,
0.0081240917,
-0.0128913568,
-0.0251278821,
-0.0114000589,
0.0396439806,
0.0090516107,
-0.0755982473,
-0.0123714702,
0.0163229611,
2.666e-7,
0.0386439525,
0.0695011914,
-0.0168484766,
0.0014036651,
0.0290598348,
0.0180914812,
0.0356898122,
0.0294522028,
-0.0041603413,
0.0112270834,
0.0068827616,
0.0425608791,
0.0295196176,
-0.0105422372,
-0.0765292272,
-0.0568957999,
-0.0280770846,
0.0682034194,
0.0114955269,
-0.027517302,
0.0232545696,
0.1124020964,
0.0187781714,
0.0307964962,
0.0150795141,
-0.0443294384,
0.0276542678,
0.0271219537,
0.0339277461,
0.0214840937,
0.0369479805,
0.0202607084,
-0.0440074429,
0.0258987304,
-0.0387998,
-0.0097057354,
-0.0200811177,
0.0413644947,
-0.0861804113,
-0.0479439721,
0.0132619739,
0.0348037444,
0.0405068696,
-0.0528268106,
0.032262098,
-0.0481985696,
-0.0282151438,
-0.0041948468,
-0.0021367038,
0.0196031928,
0.0687498972,
0.0146237426,
-0.0350669213,
-0.0510477386,
0.0274795741,
-0.0127557116,
-0.0302476771,
-0.0859452412,
-0.0259973072,
0.0009270569,
-0.0154612744,
0.0209285524,
-0.0533048399,
-0.0092754383,
0.0429329015,
0.0200184323,
0.0164323207,
1.694990304e-34,
0.0423149429,
-0.0209707655,
0.0163139571,
-0.0063190521,
-0.0258566029,
-0.019279968,
0.0149579914,
-0.0509490073,
0.0770964324,
-0.0611108802,
-0.0178609006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15678v1 | Revisiting non-English Text Simplification: A Unified Multilingual Benchmark | 2023-05-25T03:03:29 | 2023-05-25T03:03:29 | Michael J. Ryan, Tarek Naous, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in high-quality, large-scale English resources have
pushed the frontier of English Automatic Text Simplification (ATS) research.
However, less work has been done on multilingual text simplification due to the
lack of a diverse evaluation benchmark that covers complex-simple sentence
pairs in many languages. This paper introduces the MultiSim benchmark, a
collection of 27 resources in 12 distinct languages containing over 1.7 million
complex-simple sentence pairs. This benchmark will encourage research in
developing more effective multilingual text simplification models and
evaluation metrics. Our experiments using MultiSim with pre-trained
multilingual language models reveal exciting performance improvements from
multilingual training in non-English settings. We observe strong performance
from Russian in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer to low-resource languages. We
further show that few-shot prompting with BLOOM-176b achieves comparable
quality to reference simplifications outperforming fine-tuned models in most
languages. We validate these findings through human evaluation. | [
-0.0272956062,
-0.0212573353,
-0.0002050807,
0.0329452306,
-0.0561161265,
0.0015447638,
0.0351421535,
0.035295777,
-0.0083402656,
-0.0045473939,
-0.0039637526,
0.0124870352,
0.0466061011,
-0.0651137456,
0.0407154299,
-0.0651228726,
0.0430210009,
-0.0172773767,
-0.017250156,
0.0172019098,
0.033575248,
0.0087467991,
0.0103380512,
0.0235375464,
-0.0020801807,
-0.0199042447,
0.0384020731,
0.0298373438,
0.0291222464,
0.0202380959,
0.0029718126,
0.0528471544,
-0.0336286835,
0.0036052547,
0.0000020575,
-0.0245334413,
-0.0099212378,
0.002352013,
0.0231798794,
0.0836671218,
0.1053988412,
-0.0578738078,
-0.0486808643,
0.0216058772,
-0.0034783208,
-0.0001628345,
0.0285409,
0.030126771,
0.0491695441,
0.0635471418,
-0.0438357629,
-0.0309083387,
-0.0382149108,
-0.0371833704,
-0.0356203429,
-0.0167438053,
0.0235618278,
-0.0222347658,
-0.0398009047,
-0.0435346365,
-0.0163598284,
0.0533448383,
0.0178112928,
-0.0567777753,
-0.0475827903,
-0.0099785393,
-0.0447227582,
-0.0097680483,
0.0234316196,
0.0643304065,
-0.0693986192,
-0.0280551258,
0.0077005466,
-0.0124022616,
0.0028662374,
-0.0008543777,
-0.0601103678,
-0.0403056741,
0.018487975,
0.0112491669,
-0.0348095074,
-0.0215981863,
0.0167296845,
0.0072690244,
0.022446841,
-0.0053130942,
0.059634272,
-0.0146637848,
-0.0080105262,
-0.0124576762,
0.026917357,
-0.0507182032,
0.0725216642,
0.0132514779,
-0.014334213,
-0.0077766688,
-0.0709544122,
-0.0952049866,
0.0240777265,
-0.0111852838,
0.021207843,
0.0479960516,
-0.0126968203,
0.0249961279,
-0.0828205422,
0.0611869916,
0.0193622038,
-0.0022663914,
-0.0328628384,
-0.009768445,
0.0216218196,
0.041222427,
-0.0453871414,
0.0058704987,
-0.0383872204,
-0.0102562364,
-0.0633039325,
-0.0290323645,
0.0273063779,
-0.016888693,
-0.010485013,
-0.0403339453,
-0.0022294843,
-0.0431172661,
0.0327684656,
0.0891277492,
-0.0493652634,
0.0142326187,
-0.0186984204,
-0.0491744131,
-0.0111534903,
0.0306167826,
0.0478707291,
0.0002696767,
-0.0002725019,
-0.0211746451,
-0.069929935,
-0.0192470253,
-0.0362124182,
0.0032928386,
0.0320065692,
-0.0370929055,
-0.0204416513,
-0.0599947311,
0.0273855533,
-0.0221653674,
0.0057321461,
-0.0109967664,
0.0003028112,
-0.0009257247,
-0.0331323259,
0.0275302771,
-0.0198221151,
0.0222245399,
-0.0199586861,
0.0003424999,
0.0367740653,
0.0637158155,
-0.0118934521,
-0.0059457533,
0.0736818463,
-0.0109107131,
0.0374958552,
0.0830397606,
0.0035226806,
0.0269303843,
0.0277767833,
-0.0407810286,
-0.0510195941,
0.0034653966,
0.0774403811,
0.0774872005,
-0.0593397245,
0.0128809875,
0.0486850142,
0.0243579447,
-0.0033511906,
0.0302531663,
0.0560375787,
0.0337032042,
0.0316682495,
0.04843463,
-0.0027522217,
-0.0156641379,
-0.008286071,
0.0492168851,
0.0586738177,
0.0358742662,
-0.0324902162,
-0.018006973,
0.0230964292,
-0.0427149944,
0.0455918834,
0.0012957794,
0.0424896292,
0.0183767732,
-0.0805570111,
0.0267398693,
0.0020918115,
-0.0529391877,
0.0137083158,
-0.0150368968,
-0.0265064351,
0.0574872643,
0.037210267,
-0.0000185819,
-0.0218019318,
-0.0030036066,
0.0294728912,
0.0178028345,
0.0399282053,
-0.0165390782,
0.0647800863,
-0.0871545747,
0.0225154851,
0.0010851055,
0.0088433279,
0.0198581442,
0.0243237689,
-0.0058451951,
0.0313345641,
-0.0265730992,
-0.0307967998,
0.0369329602,
-0.0293110851,
-0.0003496034,
0.0130275581,
0.0162192825,
-0.0229077395,
0.0202287622,
-0.0115179149,
0.0082645137,
-0.0024890683,
-0.0458632819,
0.0224812776,
0.0004518065,
-0.0099341655,
-0.0675919428,
0.0362583771,
-0.0588702634,
-0.0375240222,
0.0566319376,
-0.0365802795,
-0.0313167833,
0.0031617805,
-0.0113969091,
-0.0241137631,
-0.0266602375,
0.0621651784,
0.0061561801,
0.0387123488,
-0.0049037621,
-0.0070967167,
0.0325131938,
0.036103256,
0.0578266531,
-0.0575288162,
0.0516926982,
-0.0229092631,
0.0078244582,
-0.0399283431,
-0.0528382026,
-0.0265053399,
0.0328199007,
0.037431255,
-0.0200809892,
0.0270561781,
-0.0852155015,
-0.0214389116,
-0.0241802335,
0.019119598,
0.0191849638,
0.0558630377,
-0.0071897684,
-0.0226298328,
-0.0067069498,
-0.008052526,
0.0259652715,
0.0268755946,
0.0551598854,
-0.027627768,
-0.0192270409,
-0.0484160632,
-0.0162264239,
0.0233776607,
0.0272883773,
-0.0070422045,
-0.0317106657,
-0.018900115,
0.0358439572,
-0.0036215894,
-0.0105921514,
0.0232328381,
-0.0487208106,
-0.0353181697,
-0.0089094061,
0.0820590183,
0.0699118525,
-0.0024300718,
-0.0354269035,
0.0138003547,
0.0081878668,
-0.0153068434,
0.0069089113,
0.0049883723,
0.0158230104,
-0.0302428547,
-0.053530287,
0.0268297531,
0.0262411181,
-0.0170396026,
0.0189246349,
-0.0419255532,
-0.0349436924,
0.0044540795,
-0.0320159197,
-0.0511757173,
-0.0068616462,
-0.0145445829,
0.0331680179,
-0.0242795888,
-0.0009050067,
0.0488651879,
-0.0163467154,
-0.0227347035,
-0.0418445319,
0.0081805149,
-0.0295909643,
0.0067651318,
-0.010639593,
0.0323796682,
0.0084144454,
0.0019194582,
-0.0424376838,
-0.0223170202,
0.0256776828,
0.0046702907,
0.0025589867,
-0.0436094962,
0.0009215357,
-0.051641915,
-0.0511120446,
0.0304244049,
-0.0547250435,
-0.0158887934,
-0.0067718835,
0.0294805411,
-0.006905667,
-0.0232572351,
-0.0192895979,
0.0327292755,
0.0759622231,
0.0002047129,
0.0101802526,
0.0019094899,
0.046262566,
0.0491807945,
-0.0222701915,
0.003564677,
-0.0253331028,
0.0420295633,
0.0088150725,
0.0288395397,
-0.0337264612,
0.0275279861,
-0.024216406,
0.0106112668,
-0.0309414174,
-0.0217751414,
0.0111135859,
0.0272537395,
-0.0457261764,
0.0261470173,
0.0714708492,
-0.005672866,
-0.0009578404,
0.0034100369,
-0.0237719808,
0.0185283888,
-0.0225325841,
0.0127420779,
-0.1173172072,
-0.0291859861,
0.0164940804,
-0.0297761932,
0.0222230647,
-0.0005291634,
-0.0176836494,
-0.0809358135,
0.0163514502,
0.0087921815,
-0.0780582279,
-0.0290202126,
-0.0229503158,
-0.0067054201,
-0.0022178802,
0.0202582385,
0.0092389332,
-0.0303371977,
-0.0094229346,
-0.0514092967,
-0.0410581268,
-0.096767731,
-0.0389406756,
-0.0429810062,
0.0129643632,
0.0010143578,
0.0533631779,
0.0159021318,
-0.0007613963,
0.0564513877,
0.0149632888,
-0.0038875204,
-0.0188440718,
0.0203478821,
0.0535945632,
0.004396033,
-0.0088254865,
0.0180414431,
0.0052051214,
-0.0142022986,
0.021314729,
0.0172322746,
0.0650264025,
-0.0487812124,
0.0223800242,
0.0026225646,
-0.0258388855,
0.0444408506,
0.0422303528,
0.0292830765,
-0.0547244512,
-0.0076702968,
-0.0159455035,
-0.0884487331,
-0.0433663242,
0.0080788517,
-0.0680796728,
-0.0670765564,
-0.0546372011,
-0.0518604778,
0.0325982608,
-0.0070983754,
-0.0022982885,
0.0290912334,
-0.0177480858,
0.0085109444,
0.0080806259,
-0.0065742675,
-0.0176397506,
0.0369674191,
-0.0311881881,
0.0294009428,
-0.0242031179,
0.0130058341,
0.0258811843,
0.0268709697,
-0.0484988093,
-0.0665411204,
-0.0202944949,
0.045614481,
0.0181335565,
0.055001013,
-0.0189931914,
-0.0611166768,
0.0163186938,
0.020786643,
-0.0216085184,
0.0635628179,
0.0334949158,
-0.0196697135,
-0.0039903335,
0.0578014404,
-0.0151096918,
0.0281092022,
-0.0094346348,
0.0229707751,
-0.0117626349,
0.00125887,
-0.0266208593,
0.0805374086,
0.0067207934,
-0.0180596393,
-0.0112530105,
-0.0021729064,
0.0078164432,
-0.0696318895,
0.0197988413,
-0.0154738734,
0.0204171687,
0.0242497344,
0.033624541,
-0.0210725162,
0.0574071519,
-0.0005061789,
-0.0416827351,
0.0038331093,
-0.009141813,
-0.0064909323,
-0.0040964419,
0.0284277797,
-0.0224791337,
-0.0176248346,
0.0011067588,
-0.0074101249,
-0.0043138564,
-0.0302174333,
-0.026273055,
-0.0067570931,
0.0284713469,
-0.0170527678,
0.032040555,
-0.0010988452,
-0.0057227588,
0.0008165751,
0.0306383912,
0.0713072494,
0.0116429413,
0.1335104555,
-0.0132372472,
-0.030559998,
-0.0286837164,
0.0303509813,
0.0155296652,
-0.0145044178,
-0.0303837433,
-0.0137970522,
-0.0078597423,
0.0632228106,
0.0790231228,
-0.0464430489,
0.0386804044,
0.0141747342,
0.0092773689,
-0.0336713977,
-0.0279616676,
-0.0348250121,
0.0222882032,
-0.0179848876,
-0.0478561781,
-0.0446056835,
-0.0359216519,
-0.0038170018,
0.0124120014,
-0.0110803209,
-0.0321774743,
0.0206179023,
0.0371104926,
0.0067117577,
-0.003887635,
-0.0208836589,
-0.0263068117,
-0.0346506424,
-0.0653017908,
-0.0314573422,
-6.328110003e-33,
0.0055196048,
0.0439069718,
0.0041758446,
-0.0667480081,
-0.0436450541,
0.0179971457,
-0.0941772014,
-0.0153994365,
-0.031070333,
0.0377745517,
-0.0432082042,
-0.0062864833,
0.0285048001,
-0.0008921012,
-0.0178746171,
0.0411404334,
0.0842954367,
-0.0004228239,
-0.0317919403,
0.0087805036,
-0.0211040396,
0.0228119772,
0.0475575626,
-0.0534335189,
-0.0138675524,
0.0052890512,
-0.0646630824,
-0.0140702939,
0.0521791168,
0.0131933736,
-0.0230998546,
0.0181591548,
0.008922413,
-0.0311041493,
-0.0274192244,
0.0124114295,
-0.0767351091,
-0.014919647,
0.0711252317,
0.0012175848,
-0.0590954758,
-0.0638227612,
0.0541323945,
-0.0225951578,
-0.00063355,
0.0098703187,
0.0108333351,
-0.0461120121,
0.0093373181,
-0.066737622,
-0.0930733904,
0.0346541293,
-0.042130392,
-0.0001169374,
0.0222339742,
0.0584509037,
-0.0469901487,
0.0106150107,
0.0057555474,
0.0332030207,
0.0481187068,
0.0630981848,
0.0637000725,
-0.0373173021,
-0.0032247412,
0.0093822367,
0.0284956824,
0.0134845916,
0.0190273412,
-0.0025213214,
0.05835592,
0.0179404523,
0.0808038935,
0.0939752683,
0.0112878941,
-0.0004813891,
-0.056129761,
0.0559834205,
0.0571260042,
0.0119747259,
-0.0265398994,
0.0145131517,
0.0258029625,
-0.0375573486,
-0.0123040285,
0.0033956484,
-0.0091516729,
-0.0269495547,
0.0120816845,
0.0256107766,
-0.0156360585,
0.0088460762,
0.0487038381,
0.0041869888,
-0.0224514268,
0.0376620442,
0.0004021411,
0.0506989807,
0.0084418571,
-0.0131912818,
-0.0294191316,
0.0125448639,
0.0265430417,
0.0235210359,
0.009517014,
-0.0016522655,
0.0389843695,
0.0117940241,
-0.0682455152,
0.0210407693,
0.0417527966,
0.0004258718,
0.0287819784,
-0.0206196867,
0.0138005149,
0.0145774353,
0.0066065979,
0.0246581491,
0.0359948725,
-0.0387709551,
0.0023460514,
0.0162737612,
0.0596087761,
0.0412764288,
-0.0200107619,
0.0250365809,
-0.0411192738,
-0.0315638408,
0.0459772348,
-0.0287630614,
-0.039727252,
-0.0182301365,
2.601e-7,
0.0622764304,
0.040560808,
0.0410740934,
-0.0267212093,
-0.0031353452,
0.009531958,
0.0110068666,
-0.0226491019,
-0.036318548,
0.0842989534,
0.0666987002,
-0.0191465337,
0.0631796718,
-0.033831235,
-0.0732243955,
0.0004499298,
-0.0345375016,
-0.0505338795,
-0.03893115,
-0.0277646277,
-0.0115873143,
0.0690339059,
-0.0177458096,
0.0044669858,
-0.0061621466,
-0.0473737419,
0.0206258558,
-0.0655739829,
-0.0052486318,
0.0246151108,
0.0116489204,
-0.0305616781,
-0.001606352,
-0.0187595617,
-0.0341606252,
-0.0189991426,
0.0255544838,
0.096851781,
-0.0081813959,
0.0700878873,
0.0152446898,
-0.0456344709,
-0.0285052154,
-0.0372125879,
0.0883991271,
-0.0251924563,
0.0230600741,
-0.0058320719,
-0.0427278616,
0.0049470579,
0.0532430969,
-0.0109337037,
-0.0666092634,
0.0528175309,
0.0414199233,
-0.0027170021,
-0.0256854668,
-0.0518632308,
-0.0460506007,
0.0010332176,
0.015454052,
0.0086144414,
-0.0149875125,
0.0266145244,
0.0258693304,
-0.0379651263,
0.0195984505,
2.387384486e-34,
0.0653357357,
-0.0122680999,
0.024645716,
0.0254505314,
0.0246308502,
-0.0437173098,
-0.0728207901,
0.0168269761,
-0.0187577941,
-0.0519915223,
-0.0130974185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15676v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15676v2 | Enhancing Grammatical Error Correction Systems with Explanations | 2023-05-25T03:00:49 | 2023-06-10T05:41:34 | Yuejiao Fei, Leyang Cui, Sen Yang, Wai Lam, Zhenzhong Lan, Shuming Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction systems improve written communication by
detecting and correcting language mistakes. To help language learners better
understand why the GEC system makes a certain correction, the causes of errors
(evidence words) and the corresponding error types are two key factors. To
enhance GEC systems with explanations, we introduce EXPECT, a large dataset
annotated with evidence words and grammatical error types. We propose several
baselines and analysis to understand this task. Furthermore, human evaluation
verifies our explainable GEC system's explanations can assist second-language
learners in determining whether to accept a correction suggestion and in
understanding the associated grammar rule. | [
0.0539600812,
0.0070718382,
-0.0133402059,
0.021570364,
-0.0090646818,
0.0315090008,
-0.0244582351,
-0.0277309511,
-0.0132345147,
-0.0585451499,
0.0220228918,
-0.0142713003,
0.0478081703,
-0.0024622679,
0.0389977209,
-0.0695378855,
0.0467957258,
-0.0027302832,
0.0319052637,
0.021801779,
0.0527010486,
0.0405470133,
-0.0517693572,
0.0630542785,
-0.0516584553,
-0.0492882542,
-0.0258172825,
0.0272346307,
0.0038096865,
-0.0322269127,
0.0425528623,
0.0372565724,
-0.0254559088,
0.0169382598,
0.0000018366,
-0.0571434982,
0.0232536551,
-0.0119897407,
-0.0805341899,
0.0417301506,
0.004197604,
-0.0015099372,
-0.0432221144,
-0.0061658076,
0.0100774337,
-0.0150071401,
0.0644940808,
0.0486572832,
0.0410454907,
0.0636460558,
-0.0023726269,
-0.0226962585,
0.0052781026,
0.0238669403,
0.0073179207,
0.0230577644,
0.0061264066,
-0.0244892202,
-0.0119061638,
-0.0232959762,
0.0010338585,
0.0050244983,
-0.0037418497,
-0.0976944044,
-0.0132167377,
-0.0076245004,
-0.0148027521,
-0.0195213091,
-0.013562995,
-0.0104892747,
0.0607131124,
-0.0586995631,
-0.0222020876,
-0.0074599134,
0.040183343,
0.0575724281,
-0.0181648023,
0.0061151716,
-0.0333249643,
0.0010058482,
0.0761148706,
-0.0741590038,
0.0031307314,
0.0082774954,
0.0523482896,
0.0732200518,
-0.0061799255,
-0.0428641699,
-0.0525419563,
0.0496466309,
-0.0231624562,
-0.0709294602,
0.0147837866,
0.0040334603,
-0.056128975,
0.0126587003,
0.0075427261,
-0.0742998496,
-0.0028818997,
-0.0115980729,
0.0347144939,
-0.0103212399,
-0.0230740421,
0.006084492,
0.0129527533,
0.0294708107,
0.0371804722,
0.0121109718,
0.0056796116,
0.0051687211,
-0.0426132008,
-0.0315949135,
-0.0440158546,
-0.0143556213,
-0.0265654195,
0.0392976031,
-0.0310359523,
-0.0086184097,
-0.0383863449,
0.0424169339,
0.0454259478,
-0.0022872568,
-0.0266393125,
-0.0494672209,
-0.0361043215,
0.0156508572,
-0.0331557952,
0.053497728,
0.0319604464,
-0.0469809286,
-0.0137244985,
0.0380271152,
0.0346985906,
0.0299759302,
-0.0524695031,
-0.0055791307,
0.0221840069,
-0.0116136251,
-0.0335788392,
-0.0344510488,
-0.0340801366,
-0.0196539909,
-0.0854804888,
-0.0398166142,
-0.0246876292,
-0.0009092231,
0.0061867717,
-0.0288859997,
-0.0130301462,
-0.0000114901,
-0.0227935389,
0.0605276339,
-0.0672330707,
-0.0116299158,
0.0311095379,
-0.0168931242,
0.004416401,
0.0045309872,
0.01658695,
-0.0576343462,
0.061669156,
-0.0056087459,
0.0454838611,
-0.0160540622,
-0.033495944,
-0.0349204056,
0.0251759719,
-0.0218552705,
-0.0370755605,
0.0627488121,
0.0298546068,
0.0341972224,
-0.0131745543,
0.0501413345,
0.0472423509,
0.0512311347,
-0.0006500453,
0.0076185311,
0.0353964232,
-0.0103440611,
0.0106095299,
0.0420175344,
-0.0248937141,
-0.00010636,
-0.0362725668,
0.0014723045,
-0.0224666893,
-0.0025067369,
-0.0103172148,
-0.0812229216,
-0.032322146,
0.0109177483,
0.0015057309,
-0.0190539826,
0.0191488434,
0.0480625704,
0.0055668368,
0.0458987691,
0.0231289193,
-0.0895936191,
-0.0036346561,
-0.0317944959,
0.0552553013,
0.0736594945,
0.046715036,
-0.0070256591,
0.0016136498,
-0.0374612771,
0.0138133699,
0.0198627859,
0.0459299535,
-0.01131522,
-0.0148171382,
-0.022994265,
0.0007370715,
0.0001031786,
0.0371852778,
-0.0280568395,
-0.0161135737,
-0.0165987201,
-0.0033194066,
-0.0173046496,
-0.0597560182,
0.0326214768,
0.0353271551,
0.0046756109,
-0.0255906004,
-0.0184934847,
0.0216500349,
0.043497432,
-0.0002737668,
0.0055591413,
-0.0175271612,
0.0270200856,
0.0050006039,
0.0370254852,
-0.0170677677,
-0.0831596777,
0.0151698068,
-0.0542017221,
-0.0400988869,
-0.0081595778,
-0.0201967563,
-0.0577340275,
-0.0130099431,
-0.0693774074,
0.0394739062,
-0.0303894114,
0.0362383574,
0.00937906,
-0.0126226759,
-0.003336774,
-0.007380663,
0.0179982744,
0.0062970486,
-0.046486102,
-0.0213723406,
0.0065983697,
-0.0325370692,
-0.0090462863,
0.0173587371,
0.004292381,
-0.000482207,
0.0057004988,
0.0061152084,
-0.0414490141,
0.0220729727,
-0.0718505457,
-0.0154409269,
-0.0227114279,
0.0394462645,
0.0398374423,
-0.0205410346,
-0.0121698976,
-0.0236454047,
0.0166278034,
0.0472101085,
-0.0042406777,
-0.0169940591,
0.0750028193,
-0.0320022106,
-0.0318444893,
-0.0625239015,
0.0076309661,
-0.0435482152,
0.0254426748,
0.0285440367,
-0.0040638703,
-0.1019213796,
0.0507813394,
-0.0138267828,
-0.0119129363,
0.0634826571,
-0.066122666,
0.0207138099,
0.0179234203,
0.0425845943,
0.0205140244,
0.0052122111,
0.0804589763,
-0.0019940475,
-0.0249970574,
-0.0170297753,
-0.0259901844,
0.0113776736,
0.0169034209,
-0.0154804951,
-0.0348952897,
0.0012983663,
0.083166793,
0.0270528551,
-0.032146018,
-0.0087874001,
0.0130861672,
-0.0253905319,
-0.0025262628,
-0.0342619084,
-0.0516943969,
-0.0284079667,
0.0192611702,
-0.019218592,
-0.0164417066,
0.104615517,
-0.0091273542,
-0.0271635316,
-0.0356410407,
-0.0011590092,
0.0021186317,
0.005002859,
-0.0093256366,
0.0186653435,
-0.0089221494,
-0.0307005234,
-0.006585307,
-0.0178028774,
0.0952482373,
0.0123513555,
0.0263558701,
-0.1037940308,
-0.007545393,
0.0471917801,
-0.0319719873,
0.0240095798,
-0.0362176672,
-0.0277273376,
-0.0152205769,
0.0353509523,
-0.0442384295,
-0.0243322682,
-0.0118078059,
0.0204816554,
0.0446925424,
0.0015622689,
-0.0257134736,
-0.0206572227,
-0.0192688573,
-0.0107037844,
0.0432545543,
-0.0040867897,
-0.0085103111,
0.0273772255,
0.0602980629,
-0.0284966808,
0.0422411673,
-0.0402907096,
0.0085329683,
0.0348037891,
-0.0340366922,
-0.0579735488,
-0.011265533,
0.1057094708,
-0.0547689684,
-0.0138223609,
0.0977301747,
0.0197067056,
-0.0198527202,
-0.0097492347,
-0.0595862418,
0.0129559143,
-0.0007615904,
0.013131272,
-0.0484840386,
-0.0030766013,
0.0354723893,
0.0252772737,
-0.0188890286,
0.0103604151,
0.0099718254,
-0.0878791958,
0.0783583969,
0.006964209,
-0.0089012282,
-0.0380458459,
-0.0403417088,
-0.0040671141,
0.0193709284,
0.0222510099,
0.023097571,
0.0084528774,
0.001606195,
0.0368649848,
-0.0743523166,
-0.0641671345,
-0.0231493153,
-0.0246962961,
0.0487688556,
0.0421224758,
0.0287801921,
0.023257805,
-0.0500807278,
0.0213853065,
-0.021932831,
0.0029575953,
-0.0061036027,
0.0186331384,
0.0209527779,
-0.0119502572,
-0.0703191459,
0.0769414455,
-0.0181895327,
-0.0305790901,
0.0092769191,
0.0836796165,
-0.0224472303,
0.0113792289,
0.0086418865,
-0.0119280983,
0.0405084565,
0.0361623764,
0.0625140443,
-0.0177818201,
0.0096256891,
-0.083971709,
0.0006077646,
-0.0244626384,
0.0377576798,
0.0384880155,
-0.0145369163,
0.0001274499,
-0.0240473431,
-0.0788914561,
0.0205496307,
0.0046587191,
0.0175585337,
-0.0062098405,
-0.0188876502,
-0.0104853828,
0.0161962453,
0.0153543726,
0.0341917761,
0.0226126555,
-0.0478410609,
-0.0264236275,
-0.0679383129,
0.0396750271,
-0.0115063945,
-0.0397826955,
0.0183718354,
-0.0298027303,
0.0303741544,
0.0385808498,
0.0126488032,
0.0114509454,
-0.0067985877,
-0.1210884005,
-0.0696977377,
-0.0062089819,
-0.0007297398,
-0.0037697752,
0.0260616858,
-0.0317173898,
0.018709695,
0.0294725448,
0.0440278351,
0.0134454649,
-0.0166048743,
0.0225847885,
-0.0168034118,
-0.0190399811,
0.0537552796,
0.0355273522,
0.0813987851,
-0.0291897301,
-0.0133068021,
-0.088271834,
0.0127117475,
-0.0563926101,
0.0035652397,
-0.009082594,
0.0416406132,
-0.0023348483,
-0.062119972,
-0.0303438958,
-0.016913116,
-0.0553510748,
-0.031383682,
-0.023267474,
0.0620026886,
0.0424363203,
0.0196196623,
0.0014492712,
0.0145819373,
-0.0088409847,
-0.0025335301,
-0.0066284873,
0.0362744145,
0.0269443151,
0.066060625,
0.0407167561,
0.0079564722,
0.0318010934,
-0.0159273408,
-0.0023376504,
0.013869362,
0.0013860757,
0.026265813,
0.0519694984,
-0.020548081,
0.0977144688,
0.0007606352,
-0.0128492163,
-0.0164257307,
0.0868200883,
0.0153857572,
-0.018880479,
0.0250828732,
0.0122143906,
-0.0272284877,
-0.0433879159,
0.0282324534,
-0.0368424915,
0.0117077967,
-0.0385404304,
-0.0354170166,
-0.0026369605,
0.0166099295,
-0.0051777372,
0.0028412004,
0.0018923557,
-0.0221742373,
-0.0363579094,
-0.0496050566,
-0.0662552193,
0.0570426024,
0.0069015143,
-0.0213571824,
0.0132591054,
0.0528957769,
-0.0193152186,
-0.0522717796,
-0.043497365,
-0.0113152713,
-0.0213059727,
0.0041338243,
-0.0296645388,
-5.61481195e-33,
-0.0357824191,
-0.0418449566,
-0.0178333018,
0.0042648735,
0.0297167264,
-0.0049061165,
-0.0588440187,
0.004325991,
0.0323252156,
0.0960398465,
-0.0212471653,
0.0548917018,
0.0176747944,
0.0145669533,
0.0568105131,
0.0179819744,
0.0616323166,
0.0409321636,
-0.0262406431,
-0.0267440099,
0.0585855506,
0.008189504,
0.1041104421,
-0.0429831967,
0.1035289168,
0.0022822521,
-0.0198302586,
0.0186620243,
-0.026450891,
0.0424227715,
0.0219510328,
0.0614048205,
0.0062577724,
0.0002111787,
-0.0255180802,
0.0378251635,
-0.0456466451,
-0.0607478991,
0.0480974838,
0.037323866,
-0.030253619,
-0.0272928141,
0.0213632751,
-0.0025049082,
-0.0319809504,
0.0375344269,
0.035676714,
-0.0079492107,
0.022098083,
0.0524553023,
-0.0238637198,
0.0341126136,
-0.0316038579,
0.0036753321,
-0.0182008725,
0.0365930274,
-0.0194665696,
-0.0892833024,
-0.0253405683,
-0.0005712094,
0.037008334,
0.0330219232,
0.0397358239,
-0.0554974601,
-0.062356066,
0.0186295975,
0.0123209646,
0.0028404682,
-0.0370195359,
0.0177764036,
-0.0246042181,
0.0135288388,
0.033176057,
0.0465005934,
0.0170567222,
-0.0343231,
-0.0112182209,
0.0113646835,
-0.0100647565,
0.0677853972,
-0.0219629426,
-0.0228104983,
-0.0715838149,
-0.0653401762,
-0.0230910238,
-0.001666156,
-0.0009576822,
-0.012239405,
0.0487673767,
-0.0446271002,
0.013459268,
-0.0085033998,
-0.0512878522,
0.0032769067,
-0.009094731,
-0.0058764368,
0.0146606956,
0.0040005646,
-0.0270917993,
0.0034431794,
-0.0244259629,
-0.0058163488,
-0.0145209963,
0.0272955298,
0.0407152213,
0.032630533,
0.045861546,
0.0185974911,
-0.0302759465,
0.0265051089,
-0.0245244689,
-0.0117122727,
-0.0559392162,
-0.0547249205,
0.0260802787,
0.0178886764,
-0.0076830625,
0.0133068562,
0.0088370498,
-0.0076574986,
-0.0200696606,
-0.0331843682,
-0.0200149845,
0.0150939235,
0.0075458279,
-0.0089472821,
-0.0315753147,
-0.031098282,
0.0290083624,
-0.0254746526,
0.0137455752,
-0.0030973654,
2.431e-7,
0.0413075015,
0.0595332868,
0.0260756053,
-0.0021753446,
0.0068726148,
0.0036360868,
0.0242149793,
-0.023666637,
0.0052596931,
0.0524608865,
0.0061726365,
-0.0053087948,
0.0373649932,
0.0159607399,
-0.0243063793,
-0.0600364693,
-0.0569220409,
0.0213119444,
-0.0341359526,
0.0101127727,
0.0827692896,
-0.0084088622,
0.0526976958,
-0.0003389429,
-0.0251663122,
-0.0188696757,
-0.0098992446,
-0.0364897214,
0.0214816537,
0.0216147099,
0.1327686161,
0.0142727112,
0.0477981083,
0.045772735,
-0.0347457193,
-0.0401553996,
-0.0440882184,
0.0061406875,
-0.0325320102,
0.072293669,
0.002086598,
-0.0111055933,
-0.0120711625,
-0.0632446706,
0.0228486229,
0.0030481596,
0.0035669697,
0.036574319,
-0.0276457015,
-0.0475313254,
-0.0324947722,
-0.0007098502,
-0.0048755761,
-0.0057913894,
0.0055039129,
-0.0045222305,
-0.01253107,
-0.0222617444,
-0.0243606698,
0.0769402161,
0.0358345769,
0.011201133,
0.0213545319,
0.001632869,
0.0326061398,
-0.0343307517,
-0.0263932496,
1.39837095e-34,
0.0326986723,
0.0281202495,
0.0585620925,
0.0009054688,
0.0558588468,
0.002410772,
0.0335428044,
0.0186563283,
0.0101665398,
-0.0155979227,
-0.0399845019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.09194v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.09194v1 | Undetectable Watermarks for Language Models | 2023-05-25T02:57:16 | 2023-05-25T02:57:16 | Miranda Christ, Sam Gunn, Or Zamir | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in the capabilities of large language models such as GPT-4
have spurred increasing concern about our ability to detect AI-generated text.
Prior works have suggested methods of embedding watermarks in model outputs, by
noticeably altering the output distribution. We ask: Is it possible to
introduce a watermark without incurring any detectable change to the output
distribution?
To this end we introduce a cryptographically-inspired notion of undetectable
watermarks for language models. That is, watermarks can be detected only with
the knowledge of a secret key; without the secret key, it is computationally
intractable to distinguish watermarked outputs from those of the original
model. In particular, it is impossible for a user to observe any degradation in
the quality of the text. Crucially, watermarks should remain undetectable even
when the user is allowed to adaptively query the model with arbitrarily chosen
prompts. We construct undetectable watermarks based on the existence of one-way
functions, a standard assumption in cryptography. | [
0.0294124056,
0.1101786643,
-0.01484726,
0.0489502139,
-0.0363286808,
-0.0043032593,
0.0048087188,
0.0498069897,
0.0134284236,
0.0081625935,
0.0141417924,
0.0125770764,
-0.0047418564,
0.0296873171,
0.051193364,
-0.01954001,
0.0186306592,
-0.0222999994,
0.0051579787,
-0.0282389484,
-0.0290685054,
-0.0194266792,
0.0746425316,
-0.015915757,
0.0090194726,
-0.0495718904,
-0.0357994512,
-0.0122595634,
-0.0354008451,
0.0100966832,
-0.0686349794,
0.0629991218,
-0.0507442355,
0.1037031487,
0.0000019681,
0.0033282014,
-0.05236369,
0.0402394868,
-0.091864951,
0.0502434224,
0.0093246959,
0.0227537435,
-0.0433909558,
0.0200123154,
-0.0524049029,
0.0486061759,
0.0551880971,
0.0220618136,
0.0779364482,
0.0436587967,
-0.0022397758,
0.0058214543,
0.0357153453,
-0.0024607121,
0.032210622,
-0.023995813,
-0.0115937842,
-0.0295971222,
-0.0267767422,
0.0370518491,
0.0040123644,
0.0779032856,
0.0261815879,
-0.0284869764,
-0.0375042371,
0.0252138413,
-0.0301354472,
-0.0182183161,
-0.0099495817,
0.0112267425,
-0.0511676557,
-0.0413633697,
-0.0025126168,
-0.0088877166,
0.0351669192,
0.053776294,
0.0048750206,
0.0241100919,
0.013683375,
0.0209913328,
0.0130911032,
-0.0261146538,
0.059619274,
0.0035514357,
0.0186755732,
0.0879489705,
0.0532835014,
-0.0079649985,
-0.0546573177,
-0.0000534651,
-0.0289155226,
-0.0607743636,
0.0256862286,
0.0033239156,
0.0477439202,
0.0044176118,
-0.1028410867,
-0.0367520861,
-0.0088244537,
-0.0297270529,
0.0530742779,
0.0035022877,
-0.0186392087,
0.0440826677,
-0.0309911538,
0.0882704332,
-0.0429504104,
0.0351631381,
0.040170949,
0.0017167926,
0.0122485058,
-0.0768333972,
-0.0602735989,
0.0285351425,
-0.0153359771,
0.0037528127,
-0.0031410181,
0.0559833497,
-0.0081083644,
0.04350207,
-0.0388674028,
-0.0325078033,
-0.0163138546,
-0.0268599801,
0.0478279144,
-0.0503840782,
0.0200996567,
-0.0288494229,
-0.033274658,
-0.0400469676,
-0.0275309924,
0.0309102871,
-0.000008702,
0.036257416,
-0.0229702666,
0.0729163885,
0.0224651936,
-0.010958272,
0.0011216868,
-0.0750032514,
0.0156791732,
-0.0092770476,
0.0048566088,
-0.0220778175,
-0.0502228923,
-0.0129796937,
0.0059127291,
-0.0805291086,
-0.0101584224,
-0.0028271351,
-0.0065891375,
0.05736899,
-0.0349846408,
-0.020164961,
-0.0071954685,
0.0067200474,
-0.0162750091,
0.0419692025,
0.038212385,
0.0184445698,
0.0847275779,
0.0001763287,
0.0546564423,
0.0455338806,
0.0147801545,
0.0323216729,
-0.0237460677,
-0.0208189879,
0.0557714961,
-0.0475601777,
-0.0439726338,
0.0404108688,
0.0226434525,
-0.0494862497,
0.0615857914,
0.0485672392,
-0.0402739383,
0.0138193062,
-0.0165154245,
-0.0064951112,
0.0067062648,
0.0636343732,
-0.0245381892,
-0.01071118,
-0.0391776673,
-0.0227420479,
0.032413464,
-0.0635898337,
-0.0120412009,
-0.001519999,
-0.0041191112,
-0.0364801921,
0.0128743742,
-0.0245676562,
0.0120242676,
0.0245955717,
-0.0291127302,
-0.0180130117,
-0.0250365976,
-0.0300454255,
0.0225708112,
-0.0950051174,
0.0222747438,
0.0326908603,
0.0621537231,
0.0112763578,
0.0965078473,
0.0032674174,
-0.0161009915,
0.0599688143,
-0.0174262356,
-0.0136379991,
0.0379929654,
0.0092732469,
0.009103734,
-0.0041508018,
0.0384472609,
0.0279455446,
-0.0166052952,
0.0373943485,
0.0166381449,
-0.0356644541,
0.0254730377,
-0.0067656385,
-0.0069468627,
-0.0710182637,
0.0011311804,
-0.0246730447,
0.0186715387,
0.0370632336,
-0.0179843437,
0.0593336858,
-0.0018242532,
0.0173816159,
-0.0161150862,
-0.0177036561,
0.0202714019,
0.0610783473,
0.0288996734,
-0.0455411933,
-0.0206277631,
0.069084093,
0.0092651155,
-0.0286189094,
0.0353874564,
-0.0293628369,
0.0591394752,
-0.0193526596,
0.042002622,
-0.005094022,
0.013326535,
-0.0084279533,
0.005769161,
0.0006258534,
0.0287747215,
-0.011980352,
0.014078036,
0.0157509297,
-0.0239485931,
-0.0529083461,
0.0299920645,
-0.0194102321,
0.0180314798,
0.0148040252,
0.0012874965,
-0.0050747343,
-0.0101620536,
-0.0203689653,
-0.0119597865,
-0.0002538477,
0.0457002036,
0.0140042417,
0.0026411212,
0.0052304445,
-0.0466885865,
-0.0521061495,
-0.0772376806,
0.0116558196,
-0.0011394749,
0.0203147251,
0.0028520026,
-0.0078252312,
0.0018595653,
0.0022593606,
0.009355586,
0.0382323675,
-0.0248933733,
-0.022261247,
-0.0726286471,
0.0090067694,
-0.031325344,
0.0173701663,
0.0105541805,
-0.0059255757,
0.0152505469,
-0.0101083675,
-0.0271579735,
0.0672126561,
0.0125122787,
0.0208968967,
0.0037379665,
0.0174645986,
-0.0022734427,
-0.0475741997,
-0.0088048242,
-0.0307046138,
-0.0015165161,
-0.0054576644,
0.0374289267,
0.0138747087,
0.0087280385,
-0.0223622415,
-0.040814817,
0.0670139119,
0.0018843552,
0.0090095913,
-0.0208287574,
-0.0289079156,
-0.0241708569,
0.017159367,
-0.0062841363,
-0.0649055839,
-0.0002454271,
-0.0573551096,
0.0052372436,
0.0007059451,
-0.0077330298,
0.048815541,
0.0214221347,
-0.0075461161,
0.0254852176,
0.0165416747,
-0.0273648705,
-0.020927608,
-0.0285097435,
0.0767808855,
-0.0431367867,
-0.0371978804,
-0.0409733579,
-0.0349503048,
0.0000769494,
-0.027671067,
-0.0209790729,
-0.0462103225,
0.0025151824,
-0.0054077893,
0.0252249017,
-0.0350941978,
0.0103220865,
-0.0067903628,
0.027225893,
0.0413739197,
-0.0146235665,
-0.0048686331,
-0.0467392467,
0.0162735321,
-0.0023932573,
-0.0493139401,
-0.0130223902,
-0.0488201417,
-0.0101592941,
0.0622672737,
0.0183554944,
0.0204863865,
0.0461642966,
-0.0099207815,
0.0268097334,
-0.0001460161,
-0.0500043891,
0.0269149914,
-0.0114790471,
0.0030816733,
0.0031768992,
0.0419629812,
0.0201466121,
-0.0323306993,
0.0207645092,
0.003910719,
0.0100026568,
-0.002967471,
-0.0189611707,
-0.0879232734,
-0.0076209013,
0.0362398326,
0.0454364009,
-0.0441673771,
0.0005647687,
-0.0368817635,
-0.0586499572,
0.006497147,
0.028093081,
0.0007416966,
-0.0347436294,
-0.0300722066,
-0.0238623992,
0.058329694,
-0.0413045473,
-0.0483244509,
0.037401773,
0.0275072064,
0.0260733105,
0.0148915881,
-0.0048599225,
-0.0197250918,
0.0155078191,
0.0243746005,
0.052168332,
0.0449408256,
-0.0198759064,
-0.0437313989,
0.0191275124,
0.025634069,
-0.0322146565,
0.0231816489,
0.0020704623,
0.0180399306,
-0.0452359095,
-0.00295966,
-0.0056788516,
0.0390056185,
-0.0067194584,
0.0000921583,
0.0409513786,
-0.0015034208,
-0.0238204878,
0.0234593973,
-0.0688396469,
0.0427294262,
0.0374843478,
0.0065561659,
-0.0243348293,
-0.029041728,
-0.0868041515,
0.1111810505,
0.0112553509,
-0.0593305491,
-0.0183921866,
0.0066786599,
-0.0582268164,
-0.0247617904,
-0.0034523124,
-0.0746165812,
0.0059963744,
0.046469707,
0.026186211,
0.0422529764,
-0.0271756388,
-0.0147169372,
-0.0320610702,
-0.1233953983,
0.0081114657,
-0.0674129501,
-0.0220336448,
-0.0246215146,
-0.0333888903,
-0.0391929597,
0.0342609994,
-0.034402024,
-0.0586462058,
0.0296120681,
0.0158208162,
0.0380243771,
-0.0492309816,
-0.0348727405,
-0.0329900272,
0.0359684825,
0.0067084734,
0.0051609087,
0.0108319093,
0.0631075203,
-0.0570544302,
0.0061122347,
0.0297801681,
-0.0251385439,
-0.0212202128,
0.0589384511,
-0.0436132811,
-0.0313960873,
0.0081638349,
0.0007111512,
0.0830234811,
0.0495777987,
0.0095893741,
0.0205775443,
0.002286613,
0.0206591096,
-0.0203365423,
-0.0161176417,
-0.0262977015,
0.0318702385,
0.0085761435,
-0.0284401942,
0.0198919512,
-0.017571779,
0.0056690383,
-0.0096362829,
-0.0056585558,
-0.0077902018,
-0.0126045449,
0.0223397184,
0.0420125648,
0.0028037408,
0.0176543407,
0.0736690983,
0.0441422574,
0.0212949589,
0.0007059807,
-0.0110533563,
0.049551893,
-0.0031668735,
-0.009917995,
0.0573228151,
-0.0974635705,
-0.060448274,
-0.0073116957,
0.0306651182,
0.027860906,
0.0300922766,
-0.0072324574,
-0.0355730467,
-0.0075918641,
-0.0313259736,
0.0047588735,
0.043075271,
-0.0698643252,
-0.0210040323,
-0.018413065,
-0.0211978257,
0.0417073108,
0.0317263678,
0.0117119318,
0.0600537807,
-0.0224756598,
-0.0317360833,
-0.0491602756,
-0.0213929228,
0.0314961784,
-0.0026428541,
-0.0155433295,
0.010605651,
-0.0282072145,
-0.0678479299,
-0.0290070437,
-0.0006951729,
0.0351393446,
-0.0002352286,
-0.0362802483,
0.0383603126,
-0.00342002,
-0.0097379675,
-0.064268209,
0.0126458425,
0.0296843518,
-0.0332363844,
0.015072437,
-5.323485878e-33,
-0.0240102634,
-0.0240999665,
-0.0669911206,
-0.0015987813,
0.0758036971,
0.0267003737,
-0.0371680968,
0.0286331605,
-0.0226065945,
-0.002585277,
-0.0214340091,
0.0182054397,
0.0209090803,
-0.0250745602,
-0.0266728271,
-0.0080729108,
0.0388589948,
-0.003967803,
-0.0570786633,
0.0318634026,
0.0507091694,
-0.0577985831,
0.0499944277,
-0.0315963961,
0.0593050681,
-0.0459604263,
-0.0748718083,
-0.0037786691,
-0.076146096,
0.0457893349,
-0.0198688433,
0.0067764283,
-0.0286173988,
-0.0226006899,
-0.0360755213,
0.0075190584,
0.0368064195,
-0.0418514274,
0.0171351656,
0.0125273792,
0.0300263111,
-0.071985282,
-0.0092493435,
-0.0275186244,
-0.0216173921,
0.0504735336,
-0.0124089941,
0.0183539242,
0.0054558334,
0.008775074,
0.0066937702,
0.0150324535,
-0.0309725758,
0.0264115054,
0.0678503364,
-0.0056027812,
0.0308895092,
-0.0292981416,
-0.0554616787,
0.0596109256,
0.0691127554,
0.0015724557,
0.0234881137,
-0.0324095711,
-0.0079794442,
0.0146565549,
0.0133168679,
-0.0040930277,
0.0392107703,
-0.0101183848,
0.0099951373,
-0.0198080763,
0.0722926632,
0.0198480226,
0.073656477,
-0.023573529,
0.040829625,
0.007704956,
-0.0666365698,
-0.0248343758,
0.0485991947,
0.002742257,
-0.0654041469,
-0.0183564592,
-0.0525781177,
-0.0926654041,
-0.0092839301,
0.0043453495,
0.001921581,
0.0094913766,
-0.0261421315,
-0.0164694637,
0.0281222742,
-0.0647933558,
-0.0220198575,
0.0127182044,
-0.002137997,
0.0144627113,
-0.0028047492,
0.0322598219,
0.0545752011,
0.0131494887,
0.0115567157,
-0.0446070656,
0.0307993889,
0.0050926143,
0.0115963835,
0.0405639671,
-0.0984134078,
0.0152618112,
0.0107907681,
0.009229959,
0.0359001122,
0.0080422843,
0.0093540773,
-0.050915014,
0.0147732673,
-0.0312905721,
0.0031308506,
-0.0126789408,
-0.028872231,
0.0601345561,
-0.0222993102,
0.0023117093,
-0.0045945104,
0.0122705046,
0.0042470954,
0.0553429984,
0.0811185986,
0.0171400607,
-0.0120752519,
-0.0205485355,
2.679e-7,
0.0261087995,
-0.006560843,
0.0397143066,
0.0269282591,
0.0595030412,
0.0765849724,
-0.0172665995,
0.0196338724,
-0.0369037502,
0.004447069,
-0.0546264909,
-0.0145136314,
0.0554775707,
-0.0059495741,
-0.0384573452,
0.0166494716,
-0.0365967005,
-0.0245240256,
-0.0294409264,
0.0083086044,
0.0336411148,
0.0560736433,
0.0434340686,
-0.0021578898,
-0.0042528878,
-0.0432855301,
-0.0034995987,
-0.0127385668,
0.0306137409,
-0.0471737683,
0.0073113982,
0.0327767394,
0.0286068469,
0.0050663101,
-0.052436132,
-0.0242825821,
0.0108970804,
0.0723221228,
-0.005273425,
0.0212774239,
-0.0546898507,
-0.0211760104,
-0.0136250053,
-0.0440766849,
0.0419755727,
0.1048991233,
-0.0393033363,
-0.0543914586,
-0.0175764933,
-0.0689748079,
0.0527250469,
0.003653835,
-0.0468541048,
-0.0082973549,
-0.0149800405,
0.0451144017,
0.013019979,
-0.0199519303,
-0.0343732871,
-0.0734772533,
-0.0247615371,
-0.0088094603,
-0.0241933577,
0.0288002994,
0.0449680835,
-0.0468057655,
0.0358746946,
2.393025941e-34,
-0.0041672946,
-0.0439938791,
0.0278599188,
0.0461640134,
0.0482602008,
0.0126687968,
0.0448707417,
-0.0044090282,
0.0451938324,
-0.0467792377,
-0.0344402753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16353v1 | Betray Oneself: A Novel Audio DeepFake Detection Model via Mono-to-Stereo Conversion | 2023-05-25T02:54:29 | 2023-05-25T02:54:29 | Rui Liu, Jinhua Zhang, Guanglai Gao, Haizhou Li | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL | Audio Deepfake Detection (ADD) aims to detect the fake audio generated by
text-to-speech (TTS), voice conversion (VC) and replay, etc., which is an
emerging topic. Traditionally we take the mono signal as input and focus on
robust feature extraction and effective classifier design. However, the
dual-channel stereo information in the audio signal also includes important
cues for deepfake, which has not been studied in the prior work. In this paper,
we propose a novel ADD model, termed as M2S-ADD, that attempts to discover
audio authenticity cues during the mono-to-stereo conversion process. We first
projects the mono to a stereo signal using a pretrained stereo synthesizer,
then employs a dual-branch neural architecture to process the left and right
channel signals, respectively. In this way, we effectively reveal the artifacts
in the fake audio, thus improve the ADD performance. The experiments on the
ASVspoof2019 database show that M2S-ADD outperforms all baselines that input
mono. We release the source code at \url{https://github.com/AI-S2-Lab/M2S-ADD}. | [
-0.0220411904,
0.0468627773,
-0.0043494957,
0.0646988451,
-0.041992709,
-0.0324480645,
0.0607421435,
-0.0153224599,
-0.0327592716,
-0.0250858981,
-0.0695997924,
-0.0164761543,
0.0017736745,
0.0989715606,
0.0132896528,
0.0108421352,
0.0281915795,
-0.0467789806,
-0.0193128474,
-0.0135367448,
-0.0168773476,
0.0036620351,
-0.0539975092,
-0.0016367319,
-0.0631937459,
-0.0061360938,
0.0032466014,
0.0449590459,
0.0009462598,
0.0294155031,
-0.0025697942,
0.0032221496,
0.0278371237,
0.077802442,
0.0000022322,
-0.0285465512,
-0.0491029769,
-0.0061847889,
-0.0649434179,
-0.0039200713,
-0.0169905555,
0.039763473,
-0.0746866167,
0.0255772881,
-0.0350347944,
-0.0143056316,
-0.0209738407,
0.0525445528,
0.0708909631,
0.0476970449,
-0.0311338287,
-0.0501411818,
0.0383403338,
-0.0057831742,
-0.0366281047,
-0.0122075872,
-0.0053849132,
-0.0540957861,
-0.0367043391,
-0.0108103203,
0.0192629807,
0.0025982538,
0.0257786866,
-0.0277234856,
-0.0178522263,
-0.0268509425,
-0.0473034009,
-0.0287162662,
0.0141790248,
0.0425403044,
-0.0718256161,
-0.004077604,
0.0308468211,
-0.0118283369,
0.0178680792,
-0.0137533611,
0.0367308632,
0.0140718762,
0.0103829047,
0.0071848179,
-0.0565563254,
0.0091432063,
0.048913613,
-0.038106408,
0.0019089878,
-0.0081348876,
0.0096042547,
0.0206148028,
0.0127930176,
-0.037927106,
-0.0171760004,
-0.0134885488,
0.0461174361,
-0.0182260666,
-0.0244558584,
-0.0747256204,
-0.0422536209,
-0.0523220599,
-0.0652621314,
-0.0299394801,
0.0156030655,
0.0084813852,
-0.0964969322,
0.0220103394,
-0.0042836391,
0.0213237535,
-0.0198426265,
0.0286329575,
-0.0471995287,
-0.0034220517,
0.0058047012,
0.0224652123,
-0.0465579927,
0.0011540912,
-0.0106885647,
-0.0006759934,
0.003752528,
-0.0601698235,
-0.0833817422,
0.0170091242,
-0.0425714999,
0.0196047034,
-0.0245138705,
-0.0181018505,
0.01634687,
-0.0034897209,
0.0291656367,
0.0573016591,
-0.0228009578,
-0.0589909293,
-0.0183706675,
0.0426717848,
0.0261872821,
0.002044417,
0.0759786814,
0.0145825809,
0.0165009629,
-0.0185086783,
-0.0236133728,
-0.0191171002,
-0.0350483507,
-0.0295938179,
0.0117007131,
-0.0740701333,
0.0290410742,
-0.0874228179,
-0.0154038658,
-0.017245857,
-0.0286820475,
-0.0192450453,
0.0215897411,
0.0342298932,
0.0075558391,
0.0414526463,
0.0670150965,
0.0105351573,
-0.0308728255,
0.0196057167,
0.0568205565,
-0.0094356174,
0.0406654999,
-0.0165753812,
0.0181284938,
0.0741477832,
0.0350750275,
0.0213972107,
-0.0076460452,
-0.0358182192,
-0.0198173411,
0.0127605256,
0.051014524,
0.0084068524,
0.0160038713,
-0.0809249729,
0.0487896167,
0.0004708848,
0.0180174187,
-0.0123603744,
0.0642962903,
0.0127466405,
-0.0334149264,
-0.0016618293,
0.0143107679,
0.0072268276,
-0.0100658927,
-0.0009694868,
0.0171545409,
0.0141801108,
-0.0255262908,
0.0090689315,
0.041109167,
-0.0538544357,
-0.0381907523,
-0.0075436989,
0.0073282938,
0.0378473364,
-0.0166645218,
0.0417910255,
-0.0685939193,
-0.0248963144,
-0.0016371502,
-0.0739406571,
0.0265739616,
0.0086851064,
0.0116152195,
-0.0013198575,
0.0762856752,
-0.0702405572,
-0.0435671285,
0.0289358124,
0.0034051316,
-0.0277203284,
0.0696045458,
0.0153345587,
-0.0437654555,
-0.0421923958,
-0.0270439815,
0.0291407462,
-0.0282348562,
0.0181785785,
0.0139278322,
-0.0142976036,
0.0490413867,
-0.0336632691,
-0.0615744479,
-0.0228463467,
0.034525875,
0.0290850662,
0.0406045541,
0.0310025252,
-0.0124330167,
0.0251894798,
0.0071245516,
-0.0279613733,
-0.0023167955,
-0.0033594912,
-0.0309802219,
-0.0227926262,
0.0484681651,
-0.058290422,
0.0355306901,
0.1013021693,
0.0160639063,
-0.0354702994,
0.0231495723,
0.0210625939,
-0.0166284032,
-0.0350724496,
0.0197921451,
0.0000196023,
0.0314103775,
0.0287471209,
-0.0175919887,
0.0034815974,
-0.0494760126,
-0.0337651782,
0.0168965198,
0.0454146005,
-0.0226126965,
-0.0315355286,
0.0295047499,
-0.0128080724,
-0.0179162212,
-0.0216496717,
-0.0331061184,
-0.0492939055,
0.0053829621,
-0.0010664349,
-0.0075268992,
-0.028196251,
-0.0079683643,
-0.0317341462,
-0.0346693285,
-0.0088419318,
0.0169020202,
-0.0362421982,
-0.0255087391,
-0.0151597699,
-0.0208531301,
-0.0482838899,
-0.0185578801,
0.0095339632,
-0.00168936,
0.0263312198,
0.015287905,
-0.0196446031,
-0.0378928445,
-0.0132821118,
-0.0069496953,
-0.0370756686,
0.0466473624,
0.0460556634,
0.0173767116,
-0.0114644887,
-0.0238804519,
0.0152037088,
0.0259340908,
0.0509413928,
0.0070716641,
-0.0409597233,
0.0220663138,
0.0372576751,
0.0236328356,
0.0078616375,
0.0556118861,
0.0713538602,
-0.0102462275,
-0.0081430832,
-0.0089138122,
0.0002435206,
0.0527497046,
0.0074697174,
0.0292519704,
-0.0246404465,
0.020318523,
-0.0367921777,
0.0954626277,
-0.0502636805,
-0.0084807016,
0.0121342167,
-0.0164635573,
-0.0262254998,
0.0179795586,
-0.067748189,
-0.0359005705,
0.033348795,
-0.0312571265,
0.0244373325,
0.0133057823,
-0.0034129866,
0.0211034045,
0.0119159138,
-0.0174648631,
-0.0376310758,
-0.0067570158,
0.0376839414,
-0.076752767,
0.0177996568,
-0.0054782336,
-0.0075918981,
-0.0083934208,
0.00156148,
-0.0342784189,
-0.0357826464,
-0.023470901,
0.0010235293,
-0.046129562,
-0.0365037434,
-0.0129825342,
0.0220149867,
-0.0120208329,
0.0983377695,
0.0053686392,
0.0423957594,
-0.0220905542,
0.0617470816,
0.0427547917,
0.0341583714,
0.0165093672,
-0.0115119154,
0.0285837594,
0.0038187827,
0.0087254876,
0.0850946233,
-0.0656741783,
-0.029521931,
-0.009018858,
0.0470082313,
-0.020465998,
-0.0178951211,
-0.0148269469,
-0.002045824,
-0.0400062315,
0.0772726685,
-0.0058565615,
-0.0290479511,
0.0056020087,
0.0093656695,
-0.0099540465,
0.009763441,
-0.0390249602,
-0.0385798588,
-0.0358195677,
0.0596793592,
0.0231855158,
0.0184310619,
0.0227870066,
-0.0010173687,
-0.0992480665,
0.0354471952,
0.0240540691,
-0.0712718889,
-0.0491991378,
0.0288452059,
-0.016795611,
-0.009385691,
0.0561849959,
-0.0349069051,
0.029664861,
-0.0117176818,
-0.00390981,
-0.0238798968,
-0.0249462835,
0.023240529,
-0.0390377566,
0.1100903898,
0.0553112887,
0.0285252873,
-0.0444753133,
0.02899299,
-0.0124160377,
0.0024733492,
-0.0061202347,
0.0235899761,
0.1004088446,
0.0093133748,
0.0102658253,
0.0721651465,
0.0362450257,
0.0067176265,
0.0031456158,
-0.0137778344,
0.021908097,
0.0052456693,
-0.0342063755,
-0.0256707333,
0.0412999578,
0.0303185582,
0.0641239956,
0.0159241371,
-0.0133220963,
0.0487412736,
0.0159314126,
0.0583570153,
-0.05638358,
-0.0575202033,
0.0443745367,
0.0466635302,
-0.063319698,
-0.0209731515,
0.0518504307,
-0.0699533597,
0.0313721374,
-0.0223529078,
0.0050535169,
-0.020768825,
-0.0029432124,
-0.0706925318,
0.0030630811,
-0.0150805181,
0.095237352,
-0.0296406113,
0.0157887768,
0.0130415959,
-0.0702630952,
-0.0194418486,
0.039648246,
-0.0614968948,
0.0162823163,
0.0278798454,
0.0096268421,
0.0117702857,
0.050949011,
-0.031809248,
0.0173449125,
0.0263486672,
0.0034062727,
-0.0198166892,
0.0398215577,
0.1145690903,
-0.0056200922,
-0.0243008044,
0.0360601246,
-0.0237146057,
0.0327540077,
0.0370957442,
0.0022863662,
0.0110788783,
-0.0452480093,
0.007133909,
0.0016753543,
0.0498231426,
-0.0124264518,
0.124817282,
-0.0245523062,
0.0193382781,
-0.0093769645,
0.0028185621,
-0.0507663749,
0.0119606089,
0.0379563421,
-0.013947255,
0.0262390729,
-0.0276131164,
0.0032374456,
0.0302443095,
0.0173897706,
-0.0128948344,
0.0545799993,
0.0186675414,
-0.0364504755,
-0.008945995,
0.0315063708,
0.0445927009,
0.057395611,
0.0275228508,
0.0123674199,
0.0024595822,
0.0165442806,
-0.0249535497,
-0.0105000753,
0.0235762093,
-0.0010616642,
-0.0004716732,
-0.0250220038,
0.0104194432,
0.0252785739,
-0.0460581668,
0.0457474738,
0.0206894502,
0.0139772277,
-0.0141947512,
0.0301271547,
-0.0103021767,
-0.0133267874,
-0.0269870069,
-0.0195846241,
0.0047679199,
0.0123631153,
0.0014793754,
0.0052645756,
0.0093624312,
-0.0347227491,
0.0483502485,
-0.0314124599,
-0.0102388216,
-0.0491408519,
0.0334212743,
-0.023472514,
-0.0079332255,
-0.0070644682,
-0.0660413504,
-0.0264205728,
-0.0047834199,
0.0257238522,
0.0103016095,
0.0251203161,
0.0110085886,
-0.012803101,
0.0192441233,
0.0196364708,
-0.0188841801,
0.0471576601,
-0.006083692,
0.0364342444,
-5.824263737e-33,
0.0093258666,
0.0141993053,
-0.0426207334,
0.0095567042,
-0.0159860738,
-0.0018873062,
-0.0089421347,
-0.0198381674,
-0.0455978513,
0.0097869998,
-0.0046794796,
0.0709619299,
0.0044402992,
0.0068529802,
-0.0289528593,
-0.0313373506,
0.0807416961,
-0.0192852933,
-0.0300780386,
0.0217557065,
0.0681232661,
0.0170210619,
0.0300778169,
-0.077921316,
-0.0713065788,
-0.0574061424,
-0.0704665482,
-0.0184953976,
-0.0498636253,
0.0409830734,
0.0297450479,
-0.0058062202,
-0.0186129995,
-0.0099622905,
0.0036163281,
-0.0028588569,
-0.0335692726,
-0.0025576192,
-0.0506625026,
0.0115096895,
-0.0076028937,
-0.0041668112,
0.0388540514,
0.0221872311,
-0.0526195876,
-0.0318190791,
0.0454045534,
-0.0570229068,
0.0254428424,
-0.0273664594,
-0.0063340971,
0.0060844016,
0.00332343,
-0.0669708401,
0.0590782203,
0.0751863271,
-0.0122379791,
-0.0333951972,
-0.0651869848,
0.0234342944,
-0.0045360392,
-0.0215714164,
0.0235161837,
-0.0038494414,
-0.0336348899,
0.0432835482,
0.049034588,
-0.071196042,
0.038825918,
-0.0159673933,
0.0505761094,
0.0654228032,
0.0557298474,
0.071552299,
0.0827480704,
-0.0603996515,
-0.0379721224,
0.0387672484,
0.0002703077,
-0.028013628,
-0.0173893292,
0.0239358414,
-0.0539337732,
-0.0073610567,
-0.06566827,
-0.0579975024,
-0.0359429643,
-0.0192283019,
0.004947803,
-0.0019577842,
-0.0025450636,
-0.0189107768,
0.0433613695,
-0.0427970365,
0.0342590064,
-0.0134206945,
-0.0366794989,
0.0082181105,
0.0109863607,
0.0362430401,
0.0239356179,
-0.036976397,
0.0899120718,
0.0305861253,
0.0255835522,
-0.0002896955,
0.0238156207,
0.0975977778,
-0.0382119529,
-0.0228926465,
0.0319451354,
0.0213723928,
0.0206069089,
0.0205105878,
-0.0219843742,
0.0143381525,
0.0028085697,
0.0598993562,
-0.0158575829,
0.0077991248,
-0.0366638191,
0.0246089809,
-0.0283594932,
0.0224502906,
-0.034981437,
0.0090879202,
0.0072126295,
-0.073116295,
0.0589386374,
-0.0659205541,
-0.0187167823,
-0.0489644445,
2.9e-7,
-0.0719331354,
-0.0153756337,
0.0114278449,
-0.024855908,
0.0089080194,
0.0716741681,
-0.0370488875,
0.0082191657,
-0.021778807,
-0.041135326,
-0.0112574166,
-0.0177716296,
0.0656666234,
0.0325889029,
-0.0384370685,
0.0247723181,
-0.0189651344,
0.0108642271,
-0.0163511746,
0.0202041063,
0.0191354472,
0.0472392365,
0.0398113206,
-0.097943835,
0.0669602677,
-0.0019698113,
-0.0045996369,
0.0303219724,
0.0186173934,
-0.0333795659,
0.0269798469,
-0.0127594145,
0.0085374508,
0.0417544469,
-0.0461440086,
0.0396213643,
0.0425110832,
0.0378363989,
0.0146903526,
-0.0359056555,
-0.0427736975,
0.0158736371,
-0.0042940774,
-0.0073775467,
0.0436502174,
0.0155099863,
0.0084953886,
-0.0817854181,
-0.0925898477,
0.0151678091,
-0.0350274667,
-0.0077927322,
0.0213184804,
-0.0034324857,
0.0201106071,
0.0305126365,
0.0029530488,
-0.0206407048,
-0.0067479094,
-0.0107358303,
-0.0076562655,
0.0158411562,
-0.0015144947,
-0.0130507853,
0.0227636881,
-0.0200493895,
-0.0129927006,
2.230432113e-34,
0.0154476501,
-0.0311449002,
0.0197424889,
-0.0266435165,
-0.0070400089,
0.0130342646,
-0.0052033383,
-0.012960243,
-0.0322173424,
0.0393162668,
-0.0529338866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15673v1 | BookGPT: A General Framework for Book Recommendation Empowered by Large Language Model | 2023-05-25T02:45:22 | 2023-05-25T02:45:22 | Aakas Zhiyuli, Yanfang Chen, Xuan Zhang, Xun Liang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | With the continuous development and change exhibited by large language model
(LLM) technology, represented by generative pretrained transformers (GPTs),
many classic scenarios in various fields have re-emerged with new
opportunities. This paper takes ChatGPT as the modeling object, incorporates
LLM technology into the typical book resource understanding and recommendation
scenario for the first time, and puts it into practice. By building a
ChatGPT-like book recommendation system (BookGPT) framework based on ChatGPT,
this paper attempts to apply ChatGPT to recommendation modeling for three
typical tasks, book rating recommendation, user rating recommendation, and book
summary recommendation, and explores the feasibility of LLM technology in book
recommendation scenarios. At the same time, based on different evaluation
schemes for book recommendation tasks and the existing classic recommendation
models, this paper discusses the advantages and disadvantages of the BookGPT in
book recommendation scenarios and analyzes the opportunities and improvement
directions for subsequent LLMs in these scenarios. | [
0.0546829887,
-0.0226471648,
-0.0133267436,
0.0175559483,
-0.0144481314,
-0.0005233175,
0.0152141685,
0.0108265784,
0.0417521149,
-0.0737067685,
-0.0966830179,
-0.0066864258,
-0.0443067029,
0.0334996358,
0.001046585,
-0.0358426906,
0.0251284372,
-0.0278665181,
0.0040604169,
-0.0116234655,
0.0387861133,
0.03181234,
0.0462305509,
0.0247747675,
0.0254459046,
-0.0334793143,
0.0004550882,
-0.013644414,
-0.0146402335,
-0.0029587832,
0.027965568,
0.0153693082,
0.0221226346,
0.004900163,
0.0000019438,
-0.0207114462,
-0.0431235544,
-0.0100887269,
0.033785779,
-0.0056735193,
0.0663125291,
0.088908039,
0.0093642827,
-0.0036253226,
-0.036760319,
0.0118212765,
0.025837237,
0.1105583236,
0.0230511576,
0.036910437,
-0.0136286467,
-0.0377866067,
0.0127823241,
-0.0151674682,
0.0387549512,
-0.0138171371,
0.0126762679,
0.056436222,
0.0605659522,
0.0699488744,
-0.0230694413,
-0.0081732031,
-0.010297263,
-0.0226529799,
0.0380661823,
0.032373447,
0.0042704833,
0.0193907302,
-0.0114104133,
0.0616186671,
-0.0096297283,
0.0064094681,
-0.022277832,
0.0267874319,
-0.0425446555,
0.0177322663,
-0.0391941927,
-0.0168788098,
0.0077037071,
0.0258382335,
0.0049417568,
0.0059057889,
0.0383563749,
-0.0116484398,
0.0191990994,
0.0746880844,
0.0348139144,
-0.0139163453,
-0.0120714223,
0.0021245226,
-0.0071734013,
-0.0427571498,
0.0460375287,
0.0078015467,
-0.0321819484,
-0.006039877,
-0.015275972,
0.0313282907,
-0.0076137879,
-0.026715856,
0.0046722079,
0.0130396029,
-0.0236367546,
0.0465288088,
0.0025716287,
0.0097352602,
-0.02863173,
-0.0098677473,
-0.0816569328,
0.0163475312,
-0.0308596361,
-0.0217982847,
-0.018874215,
0.0430558287,
-0.0169252679,
-0.0538901351,
-0.0620077029,
0.0320757926,
0.0450560972,
0.0024836054,
0.0686203986,
0.0212591477,
0.003447325,
0.0151473964,
-0.0612016469,
0.0071551464,
-0.0272177588,
-0.0086891744,
-0.0383934639,
0.0121416245,
0.0723800585,
-0.0007324161,
-0.0081730997,
-0.0526749641,
0.0134881288,
0.0640654191,
0.0155240651,
-0.0431114361,
-0.0492955148,
-0.0081624212,
0.0214975178,
-0.0837627947,
-0.0379680768,
-0.0563731715,
0.0262582228,
0.0500707142,
0.0393061861,
0.0445617102,
-0.0049461741,
-0.00035284,
0.0069416976,
0.0563973896,
0.0056201257,
-0.014030966,
0.0294124391,
0.0084351217,
0.0112346336,
0.0110606607,
-0.0224481095,
0.0274167098,
0.0527363531,
0.0012694976,
0.0112607926,
0.0390010849,
-0.046290312,
-0.0009451584,
0.0015572518,
0.0258091521,
-0.0189888179,
-0.0210157186,
0.0102071585,
0.0668008775,
-0.0606473163,
0.0037370662,
0.0747160763,
0.0515518449,
0.0469850451,
0.1359799504,
0.0320042036,
0.0408084728,
-0.0070399703,
0.0003575056,
0.02731256,
0.0601376407,
-0.0306508951,
-0.0270638764,
0.0295403097,
0.0447745547,
-0.033836294,
-0.0136540607,
0.0296006147,
-0.0350027308,
0.0297739077,
0.0087811826,
0.0625790358,
-0.0191734582,
-0.0331940055,
0.0149084209,
0.044555299,
-0.0273935776,
0.0236563217,
-0.0531211905,
0.0459477007,
0.1076537371,
0.0861275867,
-0.0328578316,
0.0089065721,
-0.0273991004,
-0.0476360992,
-0.0262063183,
0.0407640971,
-0.019154096,
-0.0602935292,
-0.0504997522,
-0.0122868521,
0.0318896919,
-0.0168914385,
0.0138718635,
-0.014993784,
0.0220998619,
0.0046561649,
-0.028465949,
-0.0437023491,
-0.0058803358,
-0.0000632393,
0.0094810501,
0.0178381316,
-0.0039188429,
0.0244265683,
0.0351006947,
0.0156046422,
-0.0294299126,
0.0124310991,
-0.0005749852,
-0.0365429185,
-0.0059382222,
-0.0256327614,
-0.0018280704,
0.04268023,
-0.0212960262,
0.0377463624,
0.0351460651,
0.0301889032,
-0.0324387215,
-0.0192133989,
0.0002357678,
0.0773896277,
-0.0449905843,
0.0313894637,
-0.0058261552,
-0.0012564447,
-0.0394102857,
0.0569943078,
0.0477824733,
0.0257617012,
-0.028826369,
-0.0085046384,
0.0253790487,
-0.0015752912,
-0.0942257568,
0.0352125503,
0.0422298759,
0.0192131307,
0.0428802967,
-0.0045725857,
-0.0215265639,
-0.0254304241,
-0.0628135055,
-0.0011713461,
0.0112007363,
0.0212000012,
-0.0039943452,
0.0104556587,
0.0102614658,
0.0047625261,
-0.0716005936,
0.0203259941,
-0.0244719852,
-0.0070050647,
-0.0033284777,
0.0060509285,
-0.0125173954,
-0.0272045955,
-0.0272301696,
-0.0069913487,
0.0362214856,
0.0140937101,
0.0368385315,
-0.076409325,
0.0117650656,
-0.0363011062,
0.0080011934,
-0.0162226837,
-0.0185048003,
-0.0156095149,
-0.0293262769,
0.0652606562,
-0.0213737786,
-0.0074427207,
0.0099701341,
0.0527212359,
-0.0412537865,
-0.0586408265,
0.0155610824,
-0.0453767106,
-0.050489448,
-0.0318325162,
0.022261817,
-0.0127825867,
-0.0141270431,
-0.0244059525,
-0.0373585597,
-0.0576308928,
-0.0113965515,
-0.0166309569,
0.0491694435,
-0.0456037708,
-0.0159204826,
-0.0006156512,
0.0181716289,
0.0181824043,
0.0023196382,
0.0605398417,
-0.0299661793,
-0.014984048,
-0.0971690789,
-0.0015623636,
-0.0533448048,
0.011435736,
0.0206747744,
0.0226622112,
-0.0479797386,
-0.0264981575,
-0.0097038662,
0.0568405315,
0.0334607773,
-0.0422876216,
0.0279774219,
0.0340373665,
0.00458503,
0.0017746772,
-0.0007961192,
-0.0261978898,
-0.0051305685,
-0.0358643644,
-0.0223148633,
0.061547,
-0.0069265123,
-0.0385398418,
0.0364252478,
-0.0113988481,
0.0196827184,
-0.024036834,
-0.0345041007,
0.0344065279,
0.0214732382,
0.0549483076,
-0.0660069287,
0.0010033215,
-0.0111836214,
0.0004993962,
0.051787857,
-0.0477593131,
-0.0392382443,
-0.0542212017,
0.0008682343,
0.0665140375,
-0.0478403047,
-0.0254636668,
0.0112555521,
-0.0389517359,
-0.0394277647,
0.0334445573,
0.1020919383,
0.0321105719,
-0.135503158,
-0.0237950142,
-0.0069816289,
-0.016934799,
0.0173788965,
0.0574545488,
-0.0770145357,
0.0193613749,
-0.0205940027,
-0.0028700754,
0.0255713463,
-0.0010218662,
-0.0204410274,
-0.0571181849,
0.0274555981,
-0.0104727466,
0.0118335355,
0.0051333359,
-0.0215822272,
-0.0044905734,
-0.0136480322,
0.0068737678,
-0.0051767067,
-0.0282060634,
0.0070286389,
-0.0339800976,
0.0080977101,
-0.0019253555,
0.0587622076,
-0.0241895393,
0.0375344828,
0.0854537711,
0.0171510521,
0.0032656307,
0.0125472061,
0.0094259223,
0.016453281,
-0.037950255,
0.009431784,
0.0269196965,
-0.0274846237,
0.0059143058,
-0.0467388183,
-0.0097675286,
-0.0076129702,
-0.0064508868,
0.0213840604,
0.061953906,
-0.0127026662,
-0.0154938968,
-0.037042696,
0.0089541255,
0.00612908,
0.0559557267,
-0.041830413,
-0.0603267998,
-0.0045449105,
-0.0279874895,
-0.0085898479,
0.0234925151,
-0.0527261831,
-0.0041648429,
-0.0172826797,
-0.0242314003,
-0.0470852032,
-0.0025746196,
-0.0106688635,
-0.0095796371,
0.0476015545,
0.0689800605,
0.0594416708,
-0.0002925331,
0.0340057313,
-0.0010831876,
-0.0105944118,
-0.0075170179,
-0.0926564336,
-0.0199910663,
0.0941641927,
-0.0752830058,
0.0123117967,
-0.0489141494,
-0.0376095958,
-0.0282468963,
-0.019964505,
0.0383060984,
0.0196269955,
0.0116170319,
-0.0548011251,
-0.0809405521,
0.0191646349,
0.0234211087,
-0.067702882,
-0.0151448511,
-0.0154038165,
0.0515252277,
-0.022826124,
0.0228463542,
-0.0527855493,
0.0330972709,
-0.0408856981,
-0.0152675081,
-0.0178346392,
-0.0333297998,
0.0062618516,
0.012175072,
0.0115499403,
-0.0097133555,
0.0521420427,
-0.0365698487,
0.0247355793,
-0.0465799682,
-0.0275873411,
-0.0459295213,
-0.0128758857,
0.0582606159,
-0.0180018805,
-0.0513120666,
0.0034830859,
0.006101035,
0.0353067331,
-0.0301221199,
0.0516627505,
-0.0118494909,
-0.0479662679,
0.0401575901,
0.0129225329,
-0.0022274018,
-0.0318491012,
0.0404613726,
0.0023337626,
-0.0278076902,
0.0727848783,
0.0241286326,
-0.0373465084,
-0.0195728727,
0.0320920609,
0.0092058899,
-0.0215549916,
-0.0229549482,
0.0501048975,
0.0228943489,
-0.0130085647,
0.0304134116,
-0.032011196,
-0.0297515579,
-0.0409249589,
0.0185622871,
-0.0067477343,
-0.011880869,
0.0204419121,
0.0281352699,
-0.000530079,
0.0394173153,
0.0751138926,
-0.0240234621,
-0.0432997756,
0.0385538228,
-0.0852370858,
-0.0404765457,
0.0162243601,
-0.0315048732,
0.0008713726,
-0.0103208413,
0.0136866421,
-0.0128508927,
-0.0368594714,
0.0036310751,
-0.0282185003,
0.0038053386,
-0.0269033145,
0.0687602162,
0.0747357681,
-0.0123841371,
0.0030648166,
-0.0557211228,
-0.0027868436,
-0.0139505723,
-0.0073514306,
-0.0173485782,
-5.956250079e-33,
0.0239229668,
-0.0187282041,
0.0277118031,
0.0486612767,
-0.0301467162,
-0.0295937173,
0.0217934232,
0.0021633115,
0.0600072742,
0.0005371217,
-0.013995803,
-0.0117314477,
-0.0052242302,
0.0180761013,
-0.0136501668,
-0.0257536806,
0.054867465,
0.0101987617,
0.0042283521,
0.0511838086,
0.0069403485,
0.058694277,
0.0515922531,
-0.0804825798,
-0.0285793506,
-0.0853716284,
-0.0294196997,
-0.0364983305,
0.0101439357,
0.0807892308,
-0.0460901223,
0.0490767844,
0.0114338649,
-0.0359437987,
0.0216538515,
0.0056633367,
-0.0680710971,
-0.0010665056,
0.0202060249,
0.045042567,
0.0240166057,
-0.0168686863,
-0.0013145161,
-0.0036527931,
0.0016895689,
0.0097602559,
0.0438863672,
-0.0107163517,
-0.0137744145,
-0.0231720805,
-0.0292389542,
0.0067124525,
0.0052821287,
0.0062546972,
0.0387358963,
0.0170772895,
-0.0210519824,
0.0357238129,
-0.038804777,
0.0338712707,
0.0423880368,
0.0367815569,
-0.0065210913,
-0.0122306393,
-0.0335365087,
0.0312908068,
-0.0090475045,
-0.0285789464,
0.0030084606,
0.0055115721,
0.0153515935,
0.0115095014,
-0.0087173702,
0.0312023014,
-0.006827937,
-0.011895298,
-0.0431364477,
0.0342527106,
0.0472055636,
-0.0067923567,
0.0652518645,
0.0126141952,
-0.0094453488,
-0.035713587,
0.0129086282,
0.0041560475,
-0.04952728,
-0.0732060075,
0.0133515988,
0.0033828651,
-0.0074560372,
-0.0202707369,
0.0198652484,
-0.0617567077,
-0.0586415231,
0.013949303,
-0.036510855,
0.002699038,
-0.0137556652,
0.0145279439,
-0.0359654799,
-0.0310912542,
-0.0141532188,
-0.0701708272,
-0.0689919516,
-0.0172656942,
0.0154426871,
0.0515254289,
-0.031359721,
0.0105275344,
0.028083805,
-0.0402857065,
-0.0025262227,
0.0421668813,
0.0070115165,
0.0106673455,
-0.018766338,
0.0854177549,
0.022808956,
0.0398362279,
-0.0462397262,
-0.0450764559,
0.036166653,
-0.0099800285,
-0.0149020329,
-0.0003384015,
-0.0223024692,
0.0023499136,
0.0398634523,
-0.0738913715,
-0.0160976537,
0.0270752963,
2.696e-7,
0.0371520445,
0.0312358811,
-0.0326551758,
-0.0297089741,
0.0076935529,
0.0077665788,
0.0472275354,
0.0266638268,
0.0594063886,
0.0757861286,
0.0341117978,
0.0001636084,
-0.0092287259,
0.0222427882,
-0.1046814322,
-0.0131439446,
-0.0688408017,
-0.0169363469,
-0.0509103648,
-0.0271278415,
0.0162000842,
0.0896258354,
0.052113615,
0.0080248835,
-0.0087998258,
-0.0042903689,
0.0584326796,
-0.0527001843,
-0.0432323441,
0.0492689721,
0.0556225441,
0.0569697469,
-0.0261700917,
-0.0138584469,
-0.0120360749,
0.0275220051,
0.0381610654,
0.0325355381,
-0.0115220854,
-0.0558800846,
0.0370622277,
0.0312593281,
-0.0000863751,
-0.0370638296,
0.0781672373,
-0.0127442181,
-0.0033197918,
0.0100672925,
-0.0493229777,
-0.0456784256,
-0.009863751,
-0.0457456596,
-0.0346245803,
0.0383904092,
0.0139769958,
-0.01742387,
-0.0113125844,
-0.0824376941,
0.0377923213,
0.0078204386,
-0.0357845873,
-0.0564824864,
-0.0422448032,
-0.0029987285,
-0.00023919,
-0.0232555438,
0.04626913,
2.147588231e-34,
0.0431381315,
0.0096886205,
-0.011269547,
-0.0033989684,
0.010562527,
0.0064485529,
0.0255447421,
0.0139892846,
0.0197595134,
-0.0791417137,
-0.0470469818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15663v1 | Mixture-of-Expert Conformer for Streaming Multilingual ASR | 2023-05-25T02:16:32 | 2023-05-25T02:16:32 | Ke Hu, Bo Li, Tara N. Sainath, Yu Zhang, Francoise Beaufays | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | End-to-end models with large capacity have significantly improved
multilingual automatic speech recognition, but their computation cost poses
challenges for on-device applications. We propose a streaming truly
multilingual Conformer incorporating mixture-of-expert (MoE) layers that learn
to only activate a subset of parameters in training and inference. The MoE
layer consists of a softmax gate which chooses the best two experts among many
in forward propagation. The proposed MoE layer offers efficient inference by
activating a fixed number of parameters as the number of experts increases. We
evaluate the proposed model on a set of 12 languages, and achieve an average
11.9% relative improvement in WER over the baseline. Compared to an adapter
model using ground truth information, our MoE model achieves similar WER and
activates similar number of parameters but without any language information. We
further show around 3% relative WER improvement by multilingual shallow fusion. | [
-0.0247284342,
0.0213570241,
0.0217864942,
-0.0056216721,
0.007379971,
-0.0220518056,
0.0536169074,
-0.0260122307,
-0.0076987804,
0.0123109827,
-0.0281996485,
-0.0451510213,
0.0469310693,
0.0098785702,
0.0294908918,
0.0105754044,
-0.0013504003,
-0.0705426633,
-0.0012552958,
-0.0645013675,
0.0291353744,
0.0214713123,
-0.019779481,
0.0434827879,
-0.0183402225,
0.0619898811,
0.0047613895,
-0.0017401096,
0.0235560052,
0.0297942851,
-0.0222385023,
0.0252013616,
0.0548149124,
0.0024491269,
0.0000021524,
0.0053720139,
-0.0288098063,
0.0044201175,
-0.0286272895,
-0.0124585889,
-0.0361942239,
-0.0285636187,
-0.0293725096,
0.02877043,
0.0029152201,
-0.0156333204,
0.092711769,
0.0362736322,
-0.0034672413,
0.0777016729,
-0.0086006643,
-0.0365276933,
0.0551761948,
-0.0081468876,
-0.0559197254,
-0.0643765926,
-0.023665918,
-0.0333787315,
-0.041687116,
-0.0437348559,
-0.0312097743,
0.0456296392,
0.0294182412,
0.0226637106,
0.0215754602,
-0.01658253,
0.0305518452,
-0.0241461471,
-0.0190362521,
0.0428934358,
-0.0261494685,
-0.0312682018,
0.0142506966,
-0.0168739762,
-0.049683731,
-0.0193343535,
0.0193268787,
0.0199048389,
-0.0257803965,
0.0050644577,
0.0006747974,
0.0096179014,
0.0384251587,
0.0247485414,
-0.0717170238,
0.0248259455,
0.006901681,
-0.0064045261,
0.0050261128,
-0.0003968847,
0.0037460313,
0.000871269,
0.0691486374,
-0.0332722403,
-0.0523327626,
-0.010538172,
-0.0374167413,
-0.0356427133,
-0.0367871188,
-0.0552718975,
0.03505788,
0.097542271,
0.0068153031,
0.0401400998,
-0.0178281497,
0.0446301438,
-0.0031662774,
-0.0169782341,
-0.0145410094,
-0.0319663957,
-0.0208712444,
-0.0007674419,
-0.0058143125,
0.0190039128,
-0.0247508138,
-0.0514957905,
-0.0372163951,
-0.0060536461,
-0.0208495967,
-0.0256593265,
0.0378067344,
-0.0140984347,
-0.0524759106,
-0.0479148701,
0.0136934454,
0.0994827375,
-0.0185353961,
0.0373800136,
0.0080978852,
-0.1022001281,
0.0252128541,
0.0299561527,
0.028711943,
0.0184621606,
0.0136729944,
0.0134097049,
-0.0570802502,
0.0030750649,
-0.0226858649,
0.0087742954,
-0.0272000302,
-0.0276800152,
0.0036104214,
-0.0641292036,
0.0879212767,
0.0035978185,
0.0265941154,
-0.0911645442,
0.0060708052,
-0.0456922427,
0.0468193702,
0.0416724756,
-0.0417916775,
0.0042173984,
0.0161691941,
-0.0248318203,
-0.0325310156,
0.1031505242,
0.0274920613,
-0.0335408375,
-0.0062115951,
-0.0357631706,
-0.0173659436,
0.0345563404,
-0.0324665755,
0.0001425066,
-0.0214020945,
-0.043862123,
0.0053716321,
0.0135015845,
0.0207886156,
0.0429505669,
-0.0313389227,
-0.0059747738,
0.0299085174,
0.0024788377,
0.0558535382,
0.0532976426,
0.0027039063,
0.0128582204,
-0.0036206383,
0.0014842163,
0.0210161023,
0.0464069881,
0.0004502022,
0.0115430886,
0.0682465434,
0.1067215279,
-0.0373714045,
-0.0184174702,
0.0275319368,
-0.0152923428,
-0.0287129227,
0.0728615001,
0.0500327013,
-0.0162665043,
-0.0274954699,
0.0423227586,
0.0436004139,
-0.053214211,
0.0267555118,
-0.0512152389,
0.0037531788,
0.044552736,
-0.0168993305,
-0.0126765091,
-0.0579938106,
0.0050982684,
-0.0251021944,
-0.002183137,
0.0385604128,
0.0404850431,
0.0847530961,
-0.0919452906,
-0.0306887701,
0.0228615329,
0.0061233891,
0.1234953254,
-0.0340488218,
0.0353127681,
0.0152132018,
0.0003166907,
-0.0088054528,
-0.0339885503,
-0.0403631777,
0.0208788887,
0.0604121871,
0.0295702089,
0.0357143804,
0.0218024012,
-0.0249574762,
-0.0082956497,
-0.0059580966,
-0.0318897329,
-0.0064959126,
0.0261169337,
-0.1047167704,
0.0119125061,
0.0408063941,
-0.0281703472,
0.0297053512,
-0.0024710796,
0.0340562798,
-0.0906236842,
0.0283307787,
-0.0008189803,
0.0686907023,
-0.0311368201,
0.0030604105,
0.0638475195,
0.0379765183,
0.0614947751,
0.0057872566,
0.0426005796,
-0.0017214424,
0.0098060491,
-0.0472110063,
-0.0026418474,
-0.0270197839,
0.0003238104,
0.0143849142,
-0.0116683831,
0.0175463371,
0.0081481216,
-0.0462214127,
0.0146334348,
-0.0542430133,
-0.0607854947,
-0.028641412,
-0.0466197394,
-0.0153288683,
-0.0331241302,
0.0536463931,
0.0170454662,
-0.0041565867,
-0.0342997834,
-0.0270164404,
-0.0151265776,
0.0188862886,
-0.0885040537,
0.0165772289,
-0.0237274747,
0.0001073557,
-0.025521487,
0.0289871376,
0.0053796535,
-0.0128142396,
-0.049701944,
-0.0542321168,
-0.0901923925,
-0.0141356299,
0.0381431915,
-0.0225855522,
-0.0061088097,
-0.0002082906,
0.0083043016,
0.0596247315,
0.0347944573,
-0.0079613663,
-0.0159149989,
0.0240310039,
-0.0234436523,
-0.0511828251,
0.0295395888,
0.030277567,
0.0284766052,
-0.0375681818,
0.0373481736,
-0.0360549614,
-0.0073580206,
-0.0068423166,
-0.0018087843,
-0.0689994916,
-0.0391180255,
0.0206754599,
-0.0510801934,
-0.0094260937,
-0.0331908204,
-0.0071147098,
0.0082250172,
-0.0090836706,
-0.0063819853,
0.0466677099,
-0.0677871332,
-0.0294987541,
-0.0169887748,
-0.0510878079,
-0.0093919011,
-0.0310867224,
-0.0242966525,
0.0424579494,
-0.0537391827,
-0.0130536221,
-0.0094374856,
0.0312748589,
0.027005503,
-0.0150321694,
0.0542802103,
-0.0184844546,
0.01812944,
-0.0195711926,
-0.0320088491,
0.0358083211,
0.0205680653,
-0.0278747305,
0.0225940477,
0.0433888026,
-0.0174515583,
-0.0441535152,
0.0412655957,
0.0377697907,
0.0566867515,
-0.0008200238,
0.0252912641,
-0.0368525796,
-0.0091570383,
-0.0057325447,
0.0577569343,
-0.0166350473,
-0.032885842,
0.0337417312,
-0.0165714938,
0.0606497489,
-0.065722689,
-0.0624026172,
0.0108247856,
0.0649973899,
0.0337682068,
-0.0109113231,
0.0125439046,
0.072379522,
-0.0428093411,
0.0697543323,
0.0701812878,
-0.0311416574,
-0.0513064675,
-0.0323095173,
0.0082418155,
0.0208464712,
-0.0117065124,
0.0172235537,
-0.0311088283,
-0.0352982879,
0.0222087242,
-0.0078991316,
0.0375245623,
0.0247737672,
-0.017255038,
-0.0525187328,
0.0002598691,
0.021617623,
-0.037529178,
-0.0362250246,
-0.0281723533,
-0.0327517688,
-0.0148254456,
0.027639905,
-0.0083809765,
0.0314579494,
-0.0569097772,
0.0342639089,
-0.0400025211,
-0.0789584965,
0.0025589205,
-0.0366498828,
0.0833305269,
0.0467112251,
-0.0048871958,
-0.028526606,
-0.0599723868,
0.037273638,
-0.0132428203,
0.0272725411,
-0.0067430479,
-0.03809705,
0.0142567577,
-0.0233652219,
0.0257291254,
0.0050085401,
0.0295057893,
0.0303070769,
0.001715285,
0.0377641991,
-0.016989924,
-0.0113333073,
0.0444973484,
-0.0183459576,
-0.0302520636,
0.0124368425,
-0.0170988534,
-0.0263264757,
0.008623438,
-0.0154809421,
0.0206135586,
0.0086897444,
0.0114513831,
-0.0295973998,
-0.0060586305,
-0.1011019722,
0.0128528234,
0.0211860351,
0.0189378094,
0.0449476801,
0.0297392607,
0.0109711699,
0.0131665198,
0.0380729027,
0.0532268099,
0.0097459927,
-0.0097762197,
0.0237305649,
-0.0602661557,
-0.0082321698,
0.0500322133,
-0.0524367914,
0.0267219972,
0.0249001123,
-0.0223087408,
-0.0847283974,
-0.0122827645,
0.0050091161,
0.0082384218,
0.0552606732,
-0.0294958893,
-0.0349763259,
0.0316243656,
0.0204797555,
-0.0391966999,
0.0280387793,
0.0804524645,
-0.0391896293,
-0.02076222,
0.0380497873,
-0.0321634784,
-0.0001624917,
-0.024267409,
0.0163103566,
-0.02394359,
-0.0462473221,
-0.0042456859,
-0.0048056603,
0.0116234273,
-0.0423269197,
-0.0031528128,
-0.0422748178,
0.0307478923,
-0.0047906865,
0.033020027,
-0.0267666467,
0.0085894382,
0.0067709675,
0.0168869812,
0.0326113664,
0.0491286516,
0.0555471405,
-0.0654198974,
0.0197476707,
0.0621886998,
0.0350320265,
-0.030264182,
-0.0024199102,
0.0070261653,
-0.0422179736,
0.0473962352,
0.0733545944,
-0.0114593972,
-0.0610454753,
0.0074414033,
-0.003459936,
-0.0145319505,
0.0032300705,
0.0225075651,
-0.0253802873,
-0.0370715074,
-0.0023269255,
0.0725043714,
0.0331588201,
0.0122655574,
0.0488244817,
0.009610272,
0.0154156759,
-0.0414305627,
0.0220856145,
-0.0223002452,
0.0137260733,
0.0356996506,
0.0064872233,
0.001539348,
0.0462261587,
0.0423002057,
-0.0375032723,
0.0052531529,
-0.0069986079,
0.0417380445,
-0.023690246,
-0.0399211831,
-0.0090143476,
0.0186531805,
-0.0348309949,
-0.0062195403,
0.0333530791,
-0.0440093353,
0.0193779841,
-0.0398864411,
0.0016765133,
-0.0124404253,
-0.022321159,
0.0286189374,
-0.0411854461,
0.0183411166,
0.0034556899,
-0.0849883333,
0.015865149,
0.0243302789,
0.0513396151,
-7.131114439e-33,
-0.0066320756,
0.0538322031,
0.0005834901,
-0.0699094459,
0.013225073,
0.0008110057,
0.0004967364,
0.0226764772,
-0.0300469548,
-0.0169529188,
-0.0450097919,
0.0103386967,
0.0395953357,
0.0116948057,
-0.0199514013,
0.0088980934,
0.0913901553,
0.0187282078,
0.0160665251,
0.0095289759,
0.009373785,
-0.0005389094,
0.0482646152,
-0.0324340276,
-0.0432042293,
0.045644816,
-0.0509235449,
-0.0435412191,
-0.0222787503,
0.0454740487,
0.0323263779,
0.0417015962,
-0.0066747651,
-0.0355722532,
-0.0163847655,
-0.0269600973,
-0.0445271842,
-0.0027047663,
-0.0112543292,
0.036517553,
0.0074457289,
-0.0290715713,
0.0535111949,
0.0214970894,
-0.0150506273,
-0.0295009799,
0.0387374796,
-0.0108548477,
-0.0409824215,
-0.0580660142,
0.0260164589,
0.0546562448,
-0.0167334341,
0.020216208,
0.0429632962,
0.0088280709,
-0.0317639075,
-0.0528601483,
-0.0757756755,
0.0480509251,
0.0287172105,
0.05417303,
0.0536678098,
0.0088764327,
0.016482152,
-0.0052610086,
0.0176232625,
-0.0274586789,
0.0141577292,
-0.0547002517,
0.0430604406,
0.0254141241,
0.0224013645,
0.0427279323,
0.0473514162,
-0.0390299745,
-0.0140085369,
-0.0185350832,
0.0352823026,
0.0218941513,
0.0570571199,
0.0154087329,
-0.0252659693,
-0.0028907214,
-0.0357213728,
-0.0001841974,
-0.0332525708,
-0.02107393,
0.0225201603,
0.0399037078,
0.0052141845,
-0.0141146109,
0.0643798932,
-0.0384641886,
0.0354810171,
-0.0101491474,
0.0083545297,
0.0142495343,
0.0202054903,
0.012174502,
-0.0851332769,
-0.0229028501,
0.010876419,
0.0013664997,
-0.0324132368,
-0.0010505097,
0.0045566978,
0.0975642428,
-0.064719364,
-0.0020561884,
-0.0011930194,
-0.0199771207,
0.0352364294,
0.0206281897,
0.0436486527,
-0.0211689416,
-0.0115363495,
0.0295981467,
-0.0537134223,
0.0324341208,
0.0060136332,
-0.0326406285,
0.0341546945,
0.0362963602,
-0.0345817842,
0.0137934741,
-0.0244788341,
-0.0668441281,
0.0216285679,
0.0007845431,
-0.041339118,
0.0247348975,
3.03e-7,
-0.070197016,
-0.0045385798,
-0.001062677,
-0.0503022261,
-0.0385488532,
0.0024659019,
0.0029726666,
-0.0237936154,
0.0094576608,
0.0174807403,
0.0261111278,
0.0463757515,
0.0296477601,
0.0268320236,
-0.0995772779,
-0.0008594234,
-0.0522092618,
0.0555824488,
0.0068201181,
-0.0125880511,
-0.0185677297,
0.1112869456,
-0.0165294241,
-0.0242095981,
0.0235181488,
-0.0046943384,
0.0250110794,
-0.0007844329,
0.0254450757,
-0.0068782,
0.0757036507,
-0.0350375213,
-0.0541837178,
0.0159889013,
-0.0284047294,
0.0518040471,
0.0162708834,
0.0332848988,
-0.03493708,
-0.0486293808,
0.0344082303,
0.0377688669,
-0.038060151,
-0.0014553341,
0.0514270253,
0.0543492846,
-0.0137175713,
-0.0295561664,
-0.0393629782,
-0.0147868618,
0.0096497843,
-0.0156383608,
0.004384839,
0.0107142683,
-0.0026296177,
-0.0245775599,
-0.0291968789,
-0.0411255434,
0.0420859084,
-0.0253609046,
-0.0319662318,
-0.0104225045,
-0.0123398667,
-0.0131627014,
0.0537650101,
0.0021899219,
0.0135133183,
2.127647989e-34,
0.0488967784,
-0.0109458631,
0.0255257655,
0.0031674427,
0.0162569825,
-0.0478896201,
-0.0610798188,
0.0326983146,
-0.0077850944,
-0.0565747172,
-0.0530952737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15645v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15645v3 | ConvGQR: Generative Query Reformulation for Conversational Search | 2023-05-25T01:45:06 | 2024-01-27T17:42:14 | Fengran Mo, Kelong Mao, Yutao Zhu, Yihong Wu, Kaiyu Huang, Jian-Yun Nie | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | In conversational search, the user's real search intent for the current turn
is dependent on the previous conversation history. It is challenging to
determine a good search query from the whole conversation context. To avoid the
expensive re-training of the query encoder, most existing methods try to learn
a rewriting model to de-contextualize the current query by mimicking the manual
query rewriting. However, manually rewritten queries are not always the best
search queries. Training a rewriting model on them would limit the model's
ability to produce good search queries. Another useful hint is the potential
answer to the question. In this paper, we propose ConvGQR, a new framework to
reformulate conversational queries based on generative pre-trained language
models (PLMs), one for query rewriting and another for generating potential
answers. By combining both, ConvGQR can produce better search queries. In
addition, to relate query reformulation to retrieval performance, we propose a
knowledge infusion mechanism to optimize both query reformulation and
retrieval. Extensive experiments on four conversational search datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of ConvGQR. | [
0.0710871294,
0.0462417938,
-0.0064217355,
0.0072775055,
-0.0112794088,
-0.0125039369,
-0.0337443426,
0.0157124251,
-0.0155120892,
-0.0338773504,
-0.0352668911,
-0.015386248,
-0.0390416943,
0.0498538539,
0.0270024668,
-0.042333845,
0.0308272876,
0.0123458114,
-0.0052711535,
0.0349275805,
0.0286875814,
0.00906156,
0.035736151,
0.0472892523,
0.0079480093,
0.0034655069,
-0.0499756224,
0.0610159971,
-0.0345384292,
0.0090298923,
0.0490452759,
0.043853987,
0.0229407512,
0.0309003294,
0.0000016427,
-0.0305500738,
-0.032758344,
-0.0329348743,
-0.0140271354,
0.0075608059,
0.0278611798,
0.0155215319,
0.0293382257,
0.0597787462,
-0.0640070811,
0.0069432538,
0.031770952,
0.0550589748,
0.0535580553,
0.0972752795,
-0.001843275,
-0.030356409,
-0.013152861,
-0.0343257487,
0.0534067638,
-0.0592724644,
0.0079583703,
0.0074328845,
0.0025207372,
0.0391009077,
0.0014567643,
0.0359726325,
0.0152397025,
-0.0630977899,
0.0482296757,
0.0150868148,
-0.0403759181,
0.0120907826,
0.0059583974,
0.0804153532,
-0.0468329936,
-0.0331265591,
-0.0092758853,
0.0106603168,
-0.0142264841,
0.0088675227,
-0.0405447297,
-0.0430870391,
-0.0049542049,
-0.0007064761,
-0.032482814,
0.0209722146,
0.0262825266,
-0.00708006,
-0.0415129066,
0.0385430045,
0.0299037155,
-0.034847226,
-0.0230876189,
-0.0229254961,
0.0169362035,
-0.0608381331,
0.0115697719,
0.0229540616,
-0.0532800555,
0.0284833852,
-0.0445543155,
0.0139577799,
0.0035210222,
-0.04834833,
-0.0366060697,
0.0246042553,
0.0370267779,
0.052578371,
-0.0032233109,
0.0361776538,
-0.0007002963,
0.0193131492,
-0.1049362347,
-0.0397638455,
-0.0461932942,
-0.0323770829,
-0.0943420678,
0.0088304458,
-0.0622032546,
-0.0323834382,
-0.023843538,
0.070546113,
0.0726908967,
-0.0605640113,
0.0136268251,
0.044255469,
-0.0359620899,
-0.0027816235,
-0.0349823907,
0.0220541898,
0.0015475692,
-0.0015198203,
0.0131481132,
-0.0884607434,
-0.0214290135,
0.0183981229,
0.0370495841,
-0.0508575179,
-0.0217175297,
-0.0004648574,
-0.0353912078,
-0.0554768592,
-0.0166211911,
-0.033774551,
0.02362643,
-0.0069750515,
-0.0222687051,
0.0072691748,
0.0615207702,
-0.0288813338,
-0.0261022206,
-0.007665975,
-0.0008111011,
0.0707447976,
0.0108312601,
0.0548641942,
0.0109353624,
0.0212508217,
0.0466360115,
0.0250553116,
0.0221898817,
0.0680835918,
0.0103838686,
0.0415830649,
0.0340665393,
-0.0201931391,
0.0650033876,
-0.009791242,
0.0232024137,
0.0029003434,
0.0053092344,
0.0682542995,
0.0118023129,
0.0354411341,
0.0162423588,
0.051882945,
-0.0571584776,
-0.0110283727,
0.03786847,
0.0288562942,
0.056107346,
-0.0162614845,
0.0226690415,
0.0286178533,
-0.0251224246,
-0.0068947198,
-0.0359419398,
0.011566801,
-0.017506795,
-0.0022242896,
0.0362799503,
-0.0065649431,
-0.0373774245,
-0.0523674227,
0.0426477008,
0.0388990045,
0.0037910412,
0.0244525224,
0.00060769,
0.0295649674,
-0.0681246668,
0.0036616682,
-0.0121757863,
-0.0591902249,
0.0233312491,
-0.0522422828,
0.0168183912,
0.0763640702,
0.0956594646,
-0.0041163834,
-0.0247140061,
-0.0074196216,
-0.0332099013,
-0.0070031872,
0.0381143503,
-0.0181112289,
0.0427201428,
-0.0430165976,
-0.027325362,
0.001277803,
0.0061325976,
0.0066959821,
0.0286481045,
-0.0044110762,
0.0536728427,
-0.0450556986,
0.0104274079,
0.0218722206,
-0.0030348771,
-0.0257465485,
0.0473387837,
0.0065372023,
-0.0138169955,
0.0027914224,
0.0133467671,
0.0419181809,
0.0393848196,
0.0141180502,
-0.0324217379,
0.0061181984,
-0.0543206632,
-0.0812757537,
-0.0042989613,
-0.0392915122,
0.0250874683,
-0.0279526599,
-0.0256992821,
-0.0639324188,
-0.0043966901,
-0.0266834386,
0.0955285951,
-0.068557471,
0.0094013186,
0.0073200897,
-0.00654225,
-0.0566538721,
0.0275598746,
0.0241651554,
-0.0050678682,
0.0047492534,
0.0082645165,
0.004750154,
-0.0640718415,
-0.0247570816,
-0.001657752,
0.0057384865,
-0.0017927126,
0.0325305499,
0.0189267248,
-0.0628800392,
0.0045310552,
-0.1257212609,
0.0030729051,
-0.0369129218,
-0.0207814667,
0.0370956548,
0.066106528,
-0.0089120613,
-0.0376357138,
-0.0545523129,
-0.0384037867,
0.0217107702,
0.0371848457,
0.0207597632,
0.0406909212,
-0.0262385327,
-0.0576232225,
-0.0165702496,
0.0320765302,
0.0431713052,
-0.0034078893,
0.0056152768,
-0.0191927124,
0.0243605562,
-0.0383018889,
0.0183514096,
-0.0393629707,
-0.0194511451,
-0.0120599912,
-0.0480452813,
0.0222654454,
0.0394289531,
0.0490967035,
-0.0031471471,
-0.0133670811,
-0.0160782207,
-0.0517668203,
0.0278944839,
-0.065005891,
-0.0398949347,
-0.0093632396,
-0.030030895,
0.067717284,
-0.0073562539,
0.0077778199,
0.0113395043,
-0.0530085005,
-0.0161966179,
0.0357263088,
-0.0293598995,
-0.0815841258,
0.0066111032,
0.0174051803,
0.044693172,
-0.0084421132,
-0.0575449169,
0.0549706183,
-0.008377932,
-0.0303105526,
-0.0448511988,
-0.0260490552,
-0.0340536162,
0.058278624,
-0.0170122664,
0.0272080023,
0.023857126,
-0.04402918,
-0.0288574807,
-0.0022567008,
0.0085371099,
-0.0500292443,
0.0467727408,
-0.0171523318,
0.0279791467,
0.0518418327,
-0.0484746844,
-0.0539028607,
-0.0601647869,
0.0100443829,
-0.0036287731,
0.0362484828,
-0.0276306272,
-0.038672749,
0.0362317003,
-0.007831498,
0.0345401578,
-0.0203123577,
-0.0249811765,
0.0055532418,
0.0347431675,
0.0711526796,
0.0021572281,
-0.0366882756,
0.0092189675,
0.0215122607,
0.0356102698,
0.0293152463,
-0.0637635738,
0.0290970597,
-0.0428920016,
0.0132400114,
-0.0102269091,
-0.0005572938,
-0.0019974769,
0.0245014224,
0.0048714769,
-0.0469603091,
0.0997179151,
0.0304913521,
-0.0435656235,
-0.0201251227,
-0.009634804,
0.0381440856,
0.0165426023,
0.0660603866,
-0.0499711074,
-0.0341946632,
0.0070816916,
0.0202596951,
0.0085923141,
-0.0023413177,
-0.0223976821,
-0.0938576385,
0.0170664936,
-0.0233533923,
0.0060165036,
-0.0251845326,
-0.0416346565,
-0.0140972463,
-0.0205613077,
0.0125615951,
0.0477929264,
-0.0167115293,
0.0277001355,
-0.0039056067,
0.0147859631,
-0.0485306717,
-0.0184169244,
-0.0065022423,
-0.0034024778,
0.075612545,
0.0117964381,
0.0527641997,
-0.0110815382,
0.022587331,
-0.0254945047,
0.0001170454,
-0.0236730222,
0.0382161103,
-0.0288801659,
0.0206783265,
-0.02176328,
-0.0113989459,
-0.0473593324,
0.0074662184,
-0.0004571373,
0.0053215236,
-0.0501011685,
0.0289611593,
-0.0101122856,
-0.0117404293,
0.0207952466,
0.0947037712,
0.040757522,
0.0269721486,
-0.0400365293,
-0.0523503497,
0.0214285329,
-0.0357845575,
0.0015756496,
-0.0379591212,
0.0334999412,
0.0330681168,
-0.0493369028,
-0.0508997403,
0.0118011199,
0.0272056181,
-0.0093044434,
0.0126242721,
-0.0081531014,
-0.0164022427,
-0.0252597928,
-0.0205586068,
-0.0255994909,
0.0210320875,
-0.0411683023,
-0.0073869112,
0.0299728326,
-0.0373211429,
-0.0063575963,
-0.0061160862,
-0.0562101156,
-0.0381112248,
-0.0551443584,
0.038465485,
0.0175015461,
0.0320976339,
-0.0504265726,
-0.0244200211,
-0.0021856036,
0.0295204874,
-0.0378302634,
-0.011558136,
0.0059031392,
0.0325502604,
0.0101079009,
0.0456578135,
-0.0294619463,
-0.0256441794,
-0.0191338174,
0.047439497,
-0.0589009821,
-0.0663954094,
0.0505778827,
-0.0037863972,
0.0509801805,
0.0095444517,
0.0145574426,
-0.0255508497,
0.0577807203,
-0.0438881554,
-0.0221628826,
-0.0548074394,
0.0131927449,
0.0317185298,
-0.0003579521,
0.0151821198,
0.0041937754,
-0.0608683154,
0.0274438746,
-0.0512745492,
-0.0291919652,
0.0078924829,
-0.0343531482,
0.0404677354,
0.0113389967,
0.0150262695,
0.0462603942,
0.0288829599,
0.0405036509,
-0.0230838899,
0.0182438325,
0.0207388476,
-0.0263581425,
-0.0077776145,
0.0300749727,
-0.1047963798,
-0.0475971512,
-0.0346202366,
0.0320908353,
0.0193162244,
0.0108582275,
0.0004181958,
0.0172009952,
0.0186675731,
-0.0263294149,
0.0451777875,
0.00267947,
-0.0327347852,
0.0435931459,
0.0083350819,
-0.0267037861,
0.0008953525,
0.0844563246,
-0.0119252205,
0.0576993935,
-0.0250818804,
-0.0340586528,
-0.0288427118,
-0.0018968628,
0.047785081,
0.056802202,
-0.0276158117,
0.0094669648,
-0.0039326581,
-0.0251288693,
0.0024836222,
-0.0361474529,
-0.0035477418,
0.0062043914,
0.0949842036,
0.097767368,
0.0026720462,
-0.0225571543,
-0.0443175547,
0.0168619193,
-0.029994268,
-0.0324716754,
-0.0385514013,
-6.083626647e-33,
0.0090291137,
0.0053645563,
0.0427550152,
-0.0418744497,
-0.0482466705,
-0.0213288777,
-0.0384819955,
-0.038728416,
-0.0165854208,
-0.0084144752,
-0.0341495648,
0.043426156,
0.0055457558,
0.0450241268,
-0.030622771,
-0.0314234868,
0.0535965525,
0.0108452654,
-0.010924818,
0.0378701165,
0.0202084016,
0.0566516817,
0.0089215515,
-0.0290403143,
-0.028289387,
-0.045614209,
-0.0276702903,
0.0791492239,
0.0252086651,
0.051402498,
-0.0189399421,
0.0091248024,
0.0173051935,
-0.019832423,
0.0046542692,
0.0142166624,
-0.0402346626,
-0.0100868968,
0.0291498564,
0.0077650095,
-0.0285377223,
-0.0116717024,
0.0255931672,
-0.0281504467,
0.0260330457,
0.0214046147,
0.0021086836,
0.0147551745,
-0.0437470749,
-0.0280932784,
-0.0045553669,
0.0104517415,
-0.01637749,
-0.0452782772,
-0.0244363192,
0.0689636469,
0.0026249066,
0.0208543129,
0.0109936735,
0.0499342866,
0.0000811772,
0.0596143194,
0.0205310248,
0.0541127771,
0.0222445987,
0.0216358472,
0.019210944,
-0.0042540785,
-0.0183853153,
-0.0133971954,
-0.0089277336,
0.0213049278,
-0.0228789356,
0.0310917348,
-0.0005363576,
0.0045980811,
-0.017648194,
0.0583415851,
-0.0021818017,
0.0135999294,
-0.0081891939,
0.0459642634,
-0.0364560708,
-0.0491780899,
-0.0319192261,
0.0175722316,
-0.0423553847,
-0.0091473963,
0.0373645686,
0.0570595562,
-0.0017788163,
-0.0135442158,
0.0348878056,
-0.0320248865,
0.0016737157,
0.0426883772,
-0.0215862375,
-0.03352331,
0.0034857676,
0.0183539987,
-0.0154866464,
0.0132512748,
0.0678763241,
-0.0021382452,
-0.0580245443,
-0.0072724526,
-0.0012351415,
0.0207265038,
-0.0357653536,
-0.0143130273,
-0.0204026103,
0.0115293609,
-0.0463542603,
-0.0031385338,
0.0006856431,
0.0560700521,
-0.0247335155,
0.0413643643,
0.0178582352,
0.0375815853,
-0.0574628003,
-0.067627266,
0.0412803367,
0.0284256488,
-0.0089100096,
0.0333103761,
-0.0146379313,
0.0136595769,
0.0253874362,
-0.0420704558,
-0.0163194612,
0.0210240968,
2.499e-7,
0.0541083105,
0.0188226309,
0.0073998393,
0.0429830477,
-0.0100186905,
0.0275229141,
0.0291606411,
0.0226658192,
0.0406778157,
-0.0055322745,
0.0609737337,
0.0126530221,
0.0055649364,
-0.0364370942,
-0.092040211,
-0.0153033072,
-0.0664823055,
-0.0631181747,
-0.0118793063,
-0.0464448668,
0.0634016693,
0.1141642258,
0.0037733847,
-0.0056882841,
-0.0176931284,
-0.037580438,
0.0437662825,
-0.0134507176,
-0.0323215649,
0.0319290459,
0.0188949574,
0.0330351628,
0.0194479842,
-0.0139775965,
-0.0305792093,
0.0102387443,
0.0363424197,
0.0536583252,
-0.0101586021,
-0.0435672104,
-0.0227037091,
0.0080467053,
0.0031956441,
-0.0614931621,
0.0689355358,
-0.0017250895,
0.031321533,
0.0186764151,
-0.0111644734,
0.0021207146,
0.0440813564,
-0.0332613997,
-0.0612500012,
0.004424938,
0.0266329031,
0.0429019742,
0.0139338579,
-0.0951803625,
-0.0010959308,
-0.0298149697,
-0.0587829649,
-0.0190946255,
-0.0558399633,
0.0072258874,
-0.0090041421,
0.0081690038,
0.0159611739,
2.101930836e-34,
0.0521328188,
0.0302199833,
-0.0158186611,
0.0315851979,
0.0474127047,
-0.0020330935,
0.0251271669,
-0.0045404402,
0.0396404937,
-0.1303444654,
-0.0433567539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15637v1 | Morphological Inflection: A Reality Check | 2023-05-25T01:27:29 | 2023-05-25T01:27:29 | Jordan Kodner, Sarah Payne, Salam Khalifa, Zoey Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Morphological inflection is a popular task in sub-word NLP with both
practical and cognitive applications. For years now, state-of-the-art systems
have reported high, but also highly variable, performance across data sets and
languages. We investigate the causes of this high performance and high
variability; we find several aspects of data set creation and evaluation which
systematically inflate performance and obfuscate differences between languages.
To improve generalizability and reliability of results, we propose new data
sampling and evaluation strategies that better reflect likely use-cases. Using
these new strategies, we make new observations on the generalization abilities
of current inflection systems. | [
0.0054271827,
0.0703296438,
-0.0355491675,
0.0551248044,
-0.0534073301,
-0.00232225,
0.0028458114,
0.0495555587,
-0.0796100572,
0.0087206755,
-0.0363685936,
-0.0843438357,
0.0362644717,
-0.0067744302,
0.0454725549,
-0.0431999788,
0.0730981007,
-0.0333062038,
-0.0627660304,
0.0039160354,
0.0469845496,
0.013880319,
-0.019909583,
0.015391767,
-0.0711009353,
0.0067615057,
0.0222683419,
0.0164347962,
0.0285589658,
-0.0183965098,
-0.012306422,
0.0007682432,
-0.0319391489,
0.0201718416,
0.0000015737,
-0.0614947341,
0.0043504983,
-0.0146210324,
-0.0121385651,
0.0288552176,
0.0622527339,
-0.0664448291,
-0.0287741665,
0.0108317435,
-0.0073365518,
-0.0238863416,
0.0681872144,
-0.033106681,
0.0109045422,
0.0673561543,
-0.0266928282,
-0.0372796394,
-0.0093369251,
0.007844598,
-0.0873135179,
0.0751044005,
-0.0073815952,
-0.0436375253,
-0.001508475,
-0.0607014,
-0.0146537563,
0.0095761819,
-0.0218788572,
0.00979794,
-0.0259337854,
-0.0060788207,
-0.0202195551,
-0.0173383262,
-0.0000010109,
0.0335223489,
-0.0623214282,
-0.0301991142,
-0.0202796794,
-0.0486901104,
-0.019784661,
0.0443252884,
-0.0247453824,
-0.0032001853,
-0.023960894,
0.0439478867,
0.0307230931,
0.0613262132,
-0.0031642048,
-0.0283181928,
-0.0320413038,
0.0363186449,
0.0556536987,
-0.0143266702,
-0.0025722601,
0.0080159064,
-0.041730836,
-0.0047343671,
0.0327109881,
-0.0049151359,
-0.0360113233,
0.0429130122,
-0.0122183962,
-0.0803658813,
0.0416035019,
-0.0074202572,
0.1069491282,
-0.0079451855,
0.0027541551,
-0.0162613578,
-0.0237082783,
0.0173809584,
0.0092007108,
-0.0042005284,
-0.046101667,
-0.0543556251,
-0.0136648091,
0.0077478215,
-0.0489585809,
0.0016503077,
0.0054348591,
0.0251337495,
-0.0479856469,
-0.0114852358,
0.0294923522,
-0.0286582559,
0.0191918407,
-0.0061405483,
-0.0549966432,
-0.0189579744,
0.0265050884,
0.055113256,
-0.0620764494,
0.0049944655,
-0.0344781354,
-0.0869722143,
0.0003518242,
0.0063184127,
0.0266896635,
-0.0106588686,
0.0374091268,
0.0658894554,
-0.0112167168,
-0.075205639,
0.0046172785,
-0.0109336209,
-0.0525594056,
-0.0579332374,
-0.0277528912,
-0.059894193,
0.0131877922,
0.0407159217,
-0.0158308409,
-0.0176282302,
-0.0200290736,
-0.0035466217,
-0.0069464366,
0.0686035156,
-0.0329214633,
-0.0071455901,
-0.0168665294,
-0.0379849784,
0.0321802348,
0.0580387749,
0.024351757,
-0.0420537852,
0.0475418232,
0.003618343,
-0.0051737246,
0.0755839497,
-0.0298120901,
-0.0042052045,
-0.0480469503,
-0.0223302171,
-0.0076240432,
0.0432799421,
0.0340568163,
0.0771107078,
-0.0187947005,
-0.0050614565,
0.050640028,
0.0976121053,
-0.0201918911,
0.0068499269,
-0.0149617512,
-0.0238389689,
0.0339672789,
-0.0114513682,
0.0428437181,
-0.0422581472,
-0.0119342022,
0.0242232904,
-0.1001988351,
0.0639204234,
0.0117864776,
-0.0298327953,
-0.0580796711,
-0.0073022596,
-0.0265408047,
-0.0189142954,
0.062326625,
0.0583050586,
-0.0059630084,
-0.0302267224,
0.0676870123,
-0.0477021299,
0.0358106121,
0.0092233,
0.005256495,
0.01521092,
0.0235674847,
-0.0101097077,
-0.0138229821,
0.0493354723,
-0.0345782749,
0.0401111394,
-0.0385952219,
-0.0315654799,
-0.0124116838,
-0.0643039346,
0.0283415671,
0.0396140404,
0.0248987991,
-0.0054374863,
-0.0168571137,
0.0269983057,
-0.0201231316,
-0.0476657823,
0.0084579336,
0.0266465265,
0.009662671,
0.017378075,
0.0206107758,
-0.0033274905,
0.0159453359,
0.013186275,
-0.0069839484,
0.0178601798,
0.0168860648,
-0.0645393059,
0.0261715557,
0.0241930243,
-0.0132566513,
-0.0684569553,
0.0364970267,
-0.048131831,
-0.0260478761,
-0.044279851,
0.041481927,
-0.030389389,
0.016921794,
-0.0752588883,
0.0830727667,
-0.0324702039,
0.048941154,
0.0031756076,
0.0282379147,
-0.0484493114,
0.0429762192,
0.0103146285,
0.0267757848,
0.0006092344,
-0.0424819328,
0.0153301591,
-0.0114537636,
0.006829191,
0.0412608869,
-0.0049880473,
-0.0489474572,
-0.040365722,
-0.0300031248,
-0.0183696281,
-0.0002598104,
-0.0444234721,
-0.0280355923,
-0.0233431831,
0.0864376277,
0.0281023253,
0.0538459718,
-0.0159377623,
0.0019274148,
-0.0152691267,
0.0359650739,
0.0289026815,
0.0313073099,
0.0609077588,
-0.0301681012,
0.0017741049,
-0.0507072583,
-0.0288066715,
0.0109948236,
0.0557918027,
0.0115279984,
-0.0307186078,
-0.0257434268,
-0.0111563774,
-0.0165363289,
0.0011100244,
-0.014043726,
-0.0729488879,
0.0323164687,
0.0134250037,
0.0829278454,
-0.0108019095,
-0.0158942938,
-0.0323527455,
0.0201358628,
-0.0081884693,
-0.0339460783,
-0.0457175933,
0.0047562071,
-0.0107939681,
-0.0459716357,
-0.0035694016,
0.0022724266,
0.084126167,
0.0208013635,
0.0114102792,
0.0115510551,
0.0146164233,
-0.0648716688,
0.0079463813,
0.0287528932,
-0.0051461314,
-0.0481091738,
0.0500013083,
-0.0079003284,
-0.0274504274,
0.0488239005,
-0.0351186469,
-0.0399172045,
-0.0434745513,
-0.0259847101,
-0.0194740389,
0.0349511057,
0.0109757315,
0.0052303164,
0.0563240163,
-0.0466755591,
0.0013606048,
0.0393832773,
0.0280568171,
0.0016308347,
0.0810955614,
-0.0242291447,
0.0195452292,
-0.0007736913,
-0.058932066,
-0.0100426469,
-0.0047167968,
-0.023591334,
0.0296171755,
0.0461088829,
-0.0511172377,
0.0310039409,
-0.0012541318,
-0.0083794128,
0.0284931827,
-0.0030835641,
-0.0044104755,
-0.0195844527,
0.0508225262,
0.0304410383,
-0.0004093571,
0.0048474418,
0.0110131456,
-0.0410177261,
0.0131040933,
-0.0126925325,
-0.0366113447,
-0.0295918584,
0.0159646682,
0.0315210074,
-0.0576968938,
-0.0167139452,
-0.0223686248,
0.0510246418,
-0.013875735,
-0.0308010448,
0.0500213541,
0.0400168858,
-0.0249278545,
0.0565830506,
0.031673111,
0.0314217024,
0.0223785229,
-0.0434561484,
-0.0444489047,
-0.022647921,
0.0131444791,
0.0180504955,
-0.012593857,
-0.0330290608,
0.0544316769,
-0.1313185245,
0.0496411398,
0.0040684794,
-0.0237951856,
0.0055319904,
-0.052897308,
0.040807005,
-0.0239447542,
0.00444728,
0.0118976245,
-0.0386171602,
0.0073067052,
0.0468334556,
-0.0080204438,
-0.0373518132,
-0.016312167,
-0.0418733284,
-0.0522849448,
0.0010694555,
0.0252875015,
-0.0230256002,
-0.0123271551,
0.0253946576,
-0.0593738668,
-0.0019117929,
-0.0243412927,
0.0395901725,
0.0649691299,
-0.048068393,
-0.0623321235,
0.0102976412,
-0.0392130427,
0.0037732692,
-0.048847232,
0.071179226,
0.0148872714,
0.0059552607,
-0.0005029927,
-0.0414680354,
-0.0001229544,
0.018358767,
0.003238197,
-0.0314699858,
-0.0151929623,
-0.0107880346,
-0.0028410316,
-0.000938919,
-0.0376790725,
-0.0102155441,
0.001894318,
0.0222470369,
-0.1049802825,
-0.0540628023,
0.0372551344,
0.021042509,
-0.0240449831,
-0.0155007495,
0.0207234733,
-0.0042800573,
-0.0354345366,
-0.0007172658,
0.0138716521,
0.0119776214,
-0.0543764569,
-0.0105389142,
0.0585113987,
0.0292812958,
-0.003601396,
0.0276189707,
-0.0159333833,
-0.0702568665,
0.0369442627,
-0.0073023932,
0.0223817434,
-0.0053458028,
-0.005244717,
-0.0388700143,
0.074039571,
0.0134325055,
0.0068058595,
-0.0069611445,
0.0222574808,
-0.004254851,
-0.0149323139,
0.0378861912,
0.0095300591,
0.0049426742,
0.0146706132,
0.0277745202,
-0.0611435249,
-0.0365588404,
0.0492870361,
0.0157469846,
0.0449264087,
-0.0433576256,
0.0157629568,
-0.0337599628,
-0.0131733166,
-0.0386902541,
-0.0007628544,
-0.0166235473,
-0.0253996439,
0.0460919254,
0.0167009644,
-0.0845866874,
0.02095972,
-0.0337171257,
0.0128001794,
0.0180179048,
0.0626601055,
0.0604137778,
-0.0099464469,
0.0142792705,
0.0200230964,
0.0215464272,
0.0097871711,
-0.0349282511,
0.0100243492,
-0.0412120931,
-0.0377683714,
-0.0116434442,
-0.0044009537,
-0.0470077172,
0.0112269418,
0.012794788,
0.0529009812,
-0.0376012512,
0.0195889231,
0.0446805358,
-0.0365130641,
0.0630309284,
-0.0449766628,
0.0190154426,
-0.0021143153,
0.0166171808,
-0.0260637607,
0.0046219197,
0.0025731365,
0.0044627138,
-0.0252206959,
-0.0041410169,
0.0664011464,
-0.0205292106,
0.0414838307,
0.0092468066,
0.0143267326,
-0.0238255151,
0.0018375565,
-0.012983745,
-0.0019808016,
-0.0280816611,
-0.021298375,
-0.0645911917,
-0.0623067766,
0.0047195363,
-0.0001049653,
0.0278510675,
0.0107204746,
0.050522007,
0.001422968,
0.0189908724,
-0.0192776285,
0.001319356,
-0.001071341,
0.0013977056,
-0.0073056696,
-0.0365830399,
-5.57265762e-33,
-0.0021113339,
0.01468179,
-0.0458082668,
-0.0055934903,
0.0299754031,
0.0197618976,
-0.0127989883,
0.058206711,
-0.0119751822,
0.0031417338,
-0.0199924,
-0.0157320071,
0.0337975882,
0.0096944058,
0.0576915033,
0.013932866,
0.0154845808,
-0.0352068134,
0.0073655006,
-0.0433065966,
0.0302715562,
0.0208357181,
0.1469199359,
-0.0319533311,
-0.0159247331,
0.0093851108,
-0.0005058927,
-0.005063545,
-0.0336962827,
0.0361166075,
0.0051418687,
0.109309867,
0.0168402381,
0.0015486972,
-0.0193427149,
-0.0290974677,
-0.0834381357,
-0.0297716483,
0.0384458527,
0.0312216133,
-0.03205714,
0.0249278266,
0.02166727,
-0.0316507258,
-0.0438893996,
0.0106864925,
0.0058596036,
-0.0213741716,
0.0066522886,
-0.0172193237,
-0.0773686618,
0.0337850265,
0.0193603337,
0.0390453041,
0.0098679652,
-0.0219203066,
-0.0001325592,
-0.0110925045,
-0.012676686,
-0.0088467784,
0.0280031133,
0.0574821793,
0.0421205014,
0.0135909654,
-0.0424920432,
0.0103751356,
0.0611906014,
0.0011601924,
0.0869815275,
0.0142387217,
0.0519961007,
0.0211707614,
0.0558147579,
0.079198584,
0.0771680549,
0.0126721459,
-0.0472327247,
-0.0296713915,
0.0677215829,
0.0325734466,
-0.0405500196,
0.0291475132,
-0.0490021557,
-0.0101973517,
0.0078538712,
-0.0711900815,
0.0008144195,
-0.033244472,
0.0055828015,
-0.0152881099,
0.0240785182,
0.0894536376,
0.000915358,
0.0313265435,
-0.0458098538,
-0.0287786499,
0.0205784459,
0.0592169464,
-0.0113548376,
0.0003685481,
-0.0321582593,
-0.0000306439,
-0.0238548573,
0.054030478,
0.0398280621,
-0.0224234629,
0.0302598979,
-0.0179955866,
-0.04693361,
0.014322334,
-0.0157820415,
0.0387664363,
-0.0163467135,
0.0336523093,
0.0452048071,
-0.029859893,
-0.0007059101,
0.0090571195,
0.0233078375,
-0.0190260168,
-0.0306424163,
-0.0309132449,
0.0103566237,
-0.0005254184,
-0.0114136152,
0.0284014922,
-0.0232182238,
0.0109511251,
0.0339034051,
-0.008726716,
-0.0001707379,
0.0058399276,
2.346e-7,
0.0772552416,
0.0827740207,
0.0436592586,
0.0466359258,
0.0223364979,
-0.0313401446,
-0.0222775247,
-0.0036695574,
-0.0041303188,
-0.0048715104,
0.0000562666,
-0.0256810021,
0.0224574693,
0.0480289981,
-0.0552996695,
-0.0008366225,
-0.0513085574,
-0.0144423414,
-0.0543889105,
0.0187426396,
0.0218223576,
0.0668933615,
-0.0215748828,
-0.04160944,
0.0080055287,
-0.0198742375,
0.0354015641,
-0.0351095945,
-0.008651847,
0.0308571775,
0.0545538403,
0.0097466335,
0.0323429517,
0.0338412151,
-0.0185929593,
0.0308892746,
0.0428234115,
-0.0268662274,
-0.0328377187,
-0.0214304645,
0.0185364,
-0.022939695,
-0.0266155787,
-0.0551647469,
0.0668140575,
0.0062128087,
-0.0074491678,
-0.0046891361,
-0.030408591,
0.0327756628,
0.0288186632,
-0.0309412573,
-0.0027509136,
0.0257185027,
0.0640760362,
-0.007687096,
-0.0806774348,
-0.0233671479,
-0.0081850411,
0.0774185732,
-0.0162088443,
-0.0171901938,
0.0072461497,
0.0439680852,
0.0095930165,
-0.0212341491,
-0.0226273239,
1.973432314e-34,
-0.0102309901,
0.0290795323,
0.0525882915,
0.0311291739,
-0.0222542826,
-0.0261675064,
0.0153445723,
0.0568420067,
-0.0456175506,
-0.0354037918,
-0.0210632421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15605v1 | Revisiting Sentence Union Generation as a Testbed for Text Consolidation | 2023-05-24T22:34:01 | 2023-05-24T22:34:01 | Eran Hirsch, Valentina Pyatkin, Ruben Wolhandler, Avi Caciularu, Asi Shefer, Ido Dagan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tasks involving text generation based on multiple input texts, such as
multi-document summarization, long-form question answering and contemporary
dialogue applications, challenge models for their ability to properly
consolidate partly-overlapping multi-text information. However, these tasks
entangle the consolidation phase with the often subjective and ill-defined
content selection requirement, impeding proper assessment of models'
consolidation capabilities. In this paper, we suggest revisiting the sentence
union generation task as an effective well-defined testbed for assessing text
consolidation capabilities, decoupling the consolidation challenge from
subjective content selection. To support research on this task, we present
refined annotation methodology and tools for crowdsourcing sentence union,
create the largest union dataset to date and provide an analysis of its rich
coverage of various consolidation aspects. We then propose a comprehensive
evaluation protocol for union generation, including both human and automatic
evaluation. Finally, as baselines, we evaluate state-of-the-art language models
on the task, along with a detailed analysis of their capacity to address
multi-text consolidation challenges and their limitations. | [
-0.0032525391,
0.0633177757,
0.0069043594,
-0.0196715537,
-0.0356971212,
-0.0090315659,
-0.0015218277,
-0.0141012352,
-0.0189612228,
-0.0452152975,
0.0176459029,
-0.0182623472,
0.0433138087,
-0.0357896462,
0.0329116695,
-0.0718745664,
0.0480188765,
-0.0089266663,
-0.040453054,
0.0017247131,
0.0363532528,
0.0207463615,
0.0247743521,
0.0391027033,
-0.0134712905,
0.0039357007,
-0.0237435829,
0.0002737399,
0.0109610297,
0.0118643623,
0.0248230863,
0.0816795751,
-0.0098681692,
0.0126577681,
0.0000018609,
-0.0457533188,
-0.0275984574,
-0.0020804189,
0.0032790273,
0.0310886987,
0.0448422842,
-0.0062356959,
0.0275142528,
0.0498199202,
-0.0135221221,
0.0212172866,
0.0166838281,
0.0195234194,
0.1037843078,
0.0484807231,
-0.0085578859,
-0.0162827186,
-0.0298782531,
-0.0356922224,
-0.048988644,
0.0029654521,
0.0068070921,
-0.0030231241,
0.0141487308,
-0.0430070125,
0.0099389795,
0.0060830396,
0.0025283399,
-0.0292130187,
-0.0107354745,
0.0068739513,
-0.1025206819,
-0.0258763656,
-0.0096924482,
0.0611338839,
0.0355857983,
-0.040417403,
0.0278780255,
0.024188973,
0.0171718001,
0.0016275096,
-0.0609595142,
0.0452813543,
-0.0190421846,
0.0204922426,
-0.0347388536,
0.0156362597,
0.011879921,
0.0352837667,
-0.0230541676,
0.0033494195,
0.0207642708,
-0.0180154163,
-0.009841634,
0.0309601836,
-0.0149404006,
-0.0781494081,
0.0152241047,
0.0089947274,
-0.0628751293,
-0.0080624707,
-0.0837433711,
-0.0978638828,
0.0496480167,
0.0131798796,
-0.0089253215,
0.0194143467,
0.0242331922,
0.0365260281,
0.0054285889,
0.0053850869,
-0.0037561813,
-0.0024740479,
-0.0666093305,
-0.0038586659,
-0.0357426591,
-0.007105133,
-0.0218243375,
0.0472013429,
-0.0451047942,
-0.0355737843,
-0.03079555,
-0.0141565856,
-0.0080717849,
-0.0264495667,
-0.0103345495,
0.0048211189,
-0.0016005653,
-0.0062394133,
0.0019513564,
0.0290048588,
-0.0338281058,
0.0054791267,
0.0728771836,
-0.0020584359,
-0.0254963897,
0.0290252343,
-0.0026401302,
0.0015440434,
-0.009202539,
0.0182516966,
-0.0535427183,
0.0143718198,
0.0150243575,
-0.0708610415,
-0.0305807702,
-0.029483337,
0.0147498976,
-0.0786274597,
0.0624476038,
-0.0181764625,
-0.0232142545,
-0.0060979701,
0.0124910055,
0.0646379888,
-0.0331438519,
0.0237834211,
-0.0394818448,
0.0196303055,
0.0513940044,
-0.0183414109,
0.0242303759,
0.0372433141,
0.0298342593,
0.0553112663,
0.0370600186,
0.0254964046,
0.0054069404,
0.0130321374,
0.0271210242,
0.0147548616,
0.0217937585,
-0.0249114353,
-0.0470343269,
0.0134423804,
0.0036500134,
0.0943986326,
-0.0276147146,
0.0026373032,
0.0461110547,
0.0240050796,
-0.0242026933,
0.0043785861,
0.0122484164,
0.047906559,
0.0208920632,
0.063230738,
-0.0051913965,
0.0013330176,
-0.0611870587,
0.0389254764,
0.1028354615,
0.055759348,
-0.003945271,
-0.0440380424,
-0.0319417194,
-0.0231223814,
0.028107157,
-0.013293162,
0.0082577784,
0.0258280709,
-0.0472717062,
0.0432670228,
0.0032850781,
-0.1032245532,
0.017412968,
-0.0066046678,
0.0202532988,
0.0165414587,
0.0391849093,
0.0001733073,
-0.0221590661,
-0.0096226176,
0.0273714401,
0.0343997553,
0.0438513905,
-0.0101358304,
-0.0142199723,
-0.0566537268,
-0.0208718926,
0.0021060579,
-0.0026214197,
0.0043683792,
0.0165824238,
-0.0524234995,
0.038460996,
-0.0101059619,
-0.0351804756,
0.0515863299,
0.0188403483,
0.018927481,
0.0007857315,
0.0030140923,
0.0048181489,
0.0021539528,
-0.0142780989,
0.0424949303,
0.0255893189,
-0.027925102,
-0.0859800801,
0.0237391014,
-0.0421739519,
-0.0364318378,
0.0139525179,
-0.0631950647,
-0.0182808954,
0.0325039662,
-0.0268790163,
-0.0680508912,
-0.0415656902,
-0.057572186,
-0.0046636071,
-0.037661992,
0.0218603741,
0.0510788523,
-0.0110948058,
-0.0315277018,
0.0796960741,
-0.0006353626,
-0.0353407897,
0.0556320846,
-0.0424257293,
0.0298574474,
-0.0364984758,
-0.0094800638,
-0.0069373352,
-0.0204516985,
0.0380455405,
0.0753907412,
0.0126521001,
-0.0424524061,
-0.0280397404,
-0.114090994,
0.047100503,
-0.0275280382,
0.0036788441,
0.0263555013,
0.0046672104,
-0.0033857396,
0.014409814,
-0.0310957283,
-0.058543615,
0.0220732763,
0.0201105345,
0.0424580351,
-0.0052791168,
0.0594066605,
-0.0578584597,
-0.0233335812,
-0.0190498587,
0.0412295647,
0.0038751215,
-0.0418446213,
-0.0233806521,
0.0492123812,
-0.0183273721,
-0.0113689881,
0.0273867007,
-0.0587807782,
0.0114175109,
-0.0007397715,
0.0703414977,
0.0438933298,
0.0579181872,
-0.0041642771,
0.0593744963,
0.0104898112,
0.0081121363,
0.0279050767,
-0.0042914394,
0.0161113106,
0.0417106114,
-0.0171340555,
0.0450576544,
0.0489996336,
0.0173993967,
0.0008222167,
-0.0665555149,
-0.0408354625,
-0.0356994309,
-0.0249637328,
-0.0669342056,
-0.048615206,
-0.0187105853,
0.0424931645,
-0.0545583256,
-0.0198878609,
0.0547298156,
-0.0248852018,
0.0098606134,
-0.0501320586,
0.0238151159,
-0.0708602816,
0.0432031453,
0.0021617473,
0.0165234134,
-0.0173852053,
0.009868117,
-0.0649830475,
0.0122332452,
0.0151360119,
-0.0247027148,
0.0526193269,
-0.0781855881,
0.0054193418,
-0.0199611634,
-0.0585555658,
0.0034235662,
-0.0535670146,
-0.0127751278,
-0.0087230913,
0.0366638377,
0.0154372603,
-0.0219869968,
-0.0199393276,
0.0218488872,
0.0313653201,
-0.0170020107,
0.0104693044,
-0.0054143895,
0.0788499117,
0.0526401773,
0.0591025725,
0.0258718263,
-0.0741493702,
0.0019790384,
0.0470115542,
0.041788727,
0.0385991745,
0.0017409628,
-0.0399259776,
-0.0042767036,
-0.0452529266,
-0.0235481113,
-0.0048499643,
0.0907652304,
-0.0473602898,
0.0302060135,
0.0938188359,
0.0337863006,
0.0168840755,
-0.0217436831,
0.0124394549,
0.0775310695,
0.0104548521,
0.0229774043,
-0.0552740246,
-0.0330851562,
0.0121071059,
0.0184797086,
0.0217491817,
-0.0110257762,
0.0016430403,
-0.1181734055,
0.0142942816,
0.0324232019,
-0.0409819223,
0.0385343954,
-0.0053305174,
-0.0022966196,
-0.0082406346,
-0.0031610662,
0.00393327,
-0.0192538984,
0.0109104803,
0.0317455158,
-0.065770708,
-0.0168704167,
-0.0361477062,
-0.0278285015,
0.0054124524,
0.0432953089,
0.0352618843,
0.0021629273,
-0.005501397,
0.0603590719,
-0.0354018919,
0.0118927192,
0.0150370263,
0.083944425,
0.021582555,
0.0097272852,
-0.0250957366,
0.0493777432,
-0.0207651388,
-0.0190288592,
0.0199528132,
0.0109060239,
0.0308479443,
-0.0258604269,
-0.0388637669,
0.0447717048,
-0.020030247,
0.0849613771,
0.0299150962,
-0.026516417,
-0.0596198849,
-0.0163253397,
0.0059481226,
-0.0833095461,
-0.0049468926,
0.0552295409,
0.0002987693,
-0.0319667719,
-0.1119674295,
-0.0461050607,
0.0502449311,
0.0147502199,
-0.0061937883,
0.0295810737,
0.0019658797,
0.012152019,
-0.0102081737,
0.0161871985,
-0.0031674861,
-0.0145131601,
-0.0627409145,
0.0125454608,
-0.0040857783,
-0.0191001501,
-0.0167851318,
0.0489844903,
-0.1032111943,
-0.0727871358,
-0.0049142241,
0.0381806754,
0.0184714179,
0.015526942,
-0.0025373588,
-0.0346283466,
0.0225171782,
0.039001774,
-0.0031396064,
0.0440200046,
0.008088368,
0.0035103662,
-0.0244650338,
0.0175213218,
-0.0542222448,
0.0054518357,
-0.0687516406,
0.0237374846,
-0.0245855302,
-0.0340260975,
0.0437371805,
0.0239761416,
-0.027069401,
-0.0334241875,
0.0450839885,
-0.0210107472,
-0.0188438147,
-0.0219916459,
-0.0299541466,
-0.0285199992,
0.0067478972,
-0.0181618091,
-0.0110476231,
0.0084741209,
0.0357180908,
0.0244123172,
0.0288506262,
-0.0197976511,
-0.0386710241,
0.0000454856,
0.012241032,
0.0092947148,
0.0069400081,
-0.0318035372,
-0.0199001636,
-0.0577747263,
0.0233694986,
-0.0120612765,
0.0238537546,
0.0300021693,
0.0101605542,
0.0081235245,
0.0305682197,
-0.0571978912,
-0.004832976,
-0.0272036884,
0.0196621288,
0.0110619301,
-0.0232106689,
0.0911494792,
0.0003065015,
-0.0264681932,
-0.0295786168,
0.0270258356,
-0.0043795616,
-0.0020288872,
-0.0415085107,
0.0113761267,
-0.0293461252,
-0.0010168994,
0.0857830122,
-0.0377041399,
0.0008086091,
0.0076670498,
0.0066687642,
-0.0510885753,
-0.0230881888,
-0.023566246,
0.0253127627,
0.0066371402,
-0.0367139727,
-0.0542843305,
-0.0165784229,
0.0268672053,
0.0470247678,
0.0282129236,
0.0042991191,
0.0329819769,
0.0601502992,
-0.023731485,
0.0269299671,
-0.0422209837,
-0.0180046391,
-0.0470634364,
0.0114700412,
-0.027075164,
-5.785762991e-33,
-0.0470520556,
-0.0216898043,
-0.0021489968,
-0.0106551917,
-0.0368483216,
0.0099690063,
-0.0452284478,
0.0151229603,
0.0151612526,
0.0192978419,
-0.0009329157,
0.001277163,
0.0070008724,
0.0453171991,
0.0145678213,
0.018473614,
0.0851113871,
-0.0135094263,
-0.0357741378,
-0.0020944264,
0.0114866244,
-0.0153342597,
-0.0337031782,
-0.0392122306,
-0.0163968354,
-0.021695435,
-0.0337091237,
-0.0075241029,
-0.0057194442,
0.049378451,
0.0061919312,
-0.0023132337,
0.0290961992,
0.0136512322,
-0.0438634232,
0.0605901293,
-0.0449599624,
-0.0384040475,
0.0102554578,
-0.050198704,
-0.0940208212,
-0.0412681326,
0.0632773116,
-0.0119358348,
0.0409641899,
-0.0219612271,
0.0495875999,
-0.0065135797,
-0.0262350012,
-0.0443437248,
-0.0283227917,
0.0102573214,
-0.0306165963,
-0.0459684916,
-0.0264258739,
0.04430639,
0.0071413554,
0.0222728774,
-0.0362028144,
0.0315911137,
0.0013685251,
0.0310268905,
0.0456333756,
-0.0218083877,
-0.0199932586,
0.0844833031,
-0.0504429862,
0.0361934602,
-0.0384848826,
-0.0225215871,
-0.0073907319,
0.0563604571,
0.0422547758,
0.0716357753,
0.0101021286,
-0.0053420081,
-0.0177104641,
0.089414306,
0.0384298861,
-0.0059902617,
-0.042292282,
0.0089108199,
0.0109694181,
0.0092457831,
-0.0332600586,
0.0004468721,
0.0062307422,
0.016811166,
0.0266012903,
0.0127441827,
-0.0456820317,
-0.0401567146,
0.0083121341,
-0.0049731242,
0.0297057666,
0.0128558697,
-0.0452323221,
0.040000312,
-0.0044020871,
0.0027725173,
-0.035431616,
0.0207971819,
0.020443853,
0.0428266153,
0.0289821606,
0.0256800372,
0.0277375188,
0.0041810041,
-0.0395077057,
0.0242136922,
0.0013668318,
0.0281177815,
-0.0320416912,
-0.0462388098,
0.045972608,
0.0394319259,
0.0143462298,
0.0123385629,
-0.0019048945,
0.0149392299,
-0.0298061855,
0.0027221045,
0.0262589138,
-0.0049244016,
0.0320811868,
0.000923765,
-0.0025906514,
0.0065610628,
0.0618238971,
-0.0102605103,
-0.0095866313,
0.0024332667,
2.403e-7,
0.0354674645,
0.0455289558,
0.0764745101,
-0.0021805903,
-0.0166249983,
0.0130388197,
-0.0227535646,
0.0172410291,
-0.005874082,
-0.001706226,
0.0156956632,
-0.0147427758,
0.0831729397,
0.0362530388,
-0.111031495,
-0.0217767432,
-0.076315999,
-0.0145343095,
-0.0523174368,
-0.0327813961,
0.0840564966,
0.0527910255,
0.0064164726,
-0.0021156378,
-0.0420499183,
-0.0298863705,
0.061011456,
-0.0098724924,
-0.0533347875,
0.030318249,
0.0394712649,
0.0020248878,
-0.0233733132,
-0.0243476536,
-0.0214922596,
0.0112929465,
0.058444377,
0.0342908092,
0.0164056569,
-0.009794754,
0.0003470508,
-0.0088362815,
-0.0053453292,
0.0043521221,
0.0548037812,
-0.0395690575,
0.0222645253,
-0.0529607348,
-0.0164365638,
0.017423708,
0.0171936974,
0.0250714179,
-0.0087986616,
0.0412678495,
-0.0172592178,
0.0095192594,
-0.0177355781,
-0.0665003657,
-0.0545845479,
0.0139339929,
-0.0537862293,
0.0198145546,
-0.0473892055,
-0.0147017594,
-0.0058331969,
-0.0862938389,
-0.0243753493,
2.204760648e-34,
0.0520143136,
-0.0464029983,
0.0221645832,
-0.009668896,
0.0474673435,
-0.0512871444,
-0.0454946719,
0.0381716602,
-0.0190592539,
-0.042774763,
-0.000465262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15597v1 | Text-Augmented Open Knowledge Graph Completion via Pre-Trained Language Models | 2023-05-24T22:09:35 | 2023-05-24T22:09:35 | Pengcheng Jiang, Shivam Agarwal, Bowen Jin, Xuan Wang, Jimeng Sun, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The mission of open knowledge graph (KG) completion is to draw new findings
from known facts. Existing works that augment KG completion require either (1)
factual triples to enlarge the graph reasoning space or (2) manually designed
prompts to extract knowledge from a pre-trained language model (PLM),
exhibiting limited performance and requiring expensive efforts from experts. To
this end, we propose TAGREAL that automatically generates quality query prompts
and retrieves support information from large text corpora to probe knowledge
from PLM for KG completion. The results show that TAGREAL achieves
state-of-the-art performance on two benchmark datasets. We find that TAGREAL
has superb performance even with limited training data, outperforming existing
embedding-based, graph-based, and PLM-based methods. | [
0.0414502025,
0.0299803019,
0.0147485631,
0.0201077703,
-0.0196994152,
-0.0145909376,
-0.0338008553,
0.0319913141,
0.1075859293,
-0.0286632311,
0.0128961205,
0.031246027,
-0.0203953739,
0.0575365461,
0.0153444437,
-0.0051748231,
0.0356667563,
0.0090543237,
0.0275243465,
-0.0297705811,
-0.0096695833,
0.0439499095,
0.0051316004,
-0.0002314571,
0.0102862939,
-0.009220507,
-0.0112498794,
-0.0090434216,
-0.0269273315,
0.0077740117,
-0.0316270366,
0.0401300229,
-0.0011930866,
0.0087864241,
0.0000016571,
-0.0519043691,
0.0127385594,
-0.0165947266,
-0.0456074327,
-0.0030080264,
0.0248838607,
0.0083339754,
0.0668496192,
-0.0023519082,
-0.0444490686,
-0.0426410325,
0.0185628571,
0.0355851687,
0.0266618207,
0.0330099761,
0.0172881316,
-0.0032603254,
0.0179829393,
-0.0254379511,
0.0113703767,
-0.0165639911,
0.0360286199,
0.0118913576,
0.0541580245,
0.0307064261,
-0.0220228266,
0.0411943123,
-0.0062671895,
-0.0182569437,
0.0539666079,
0.0213403441,
-0.0167694762,
0.0173029248,
0.0218406785,
0.1202218458,
0.0037862938,
0.0092179049,
-0.0210399423,
-0.0172814783,
-0.003624399,
0.0402899422,
-0.0231699087,
-0.0072586895,
-0.0018809628,
-0.0062175947,
-0.0312843509,
-0.0271496475,
0.0583392009,
-0.0126750795,
-0.0394766293,
0.110477373,
0.0068112994,
-0.0215872396,
0.0547451936,
0.0186326541,
-0.049517367,
-0.047098428,
-0.0121539086,
0.0181330405,
-0.0246850494,
0.042162139,
-0.0369548947,
-0.0029952584,
0.0247569345,
0.0040129442,
0.0004541023,
0.0091840494,
-0.0520564057,
0.0724034905,
-0.0323706456,
-0.0073196543,
-0.0115135955,
0.0392724052,
-0.0520765856,
-0.0324141867,
-0.0205578096,
0.0184331909,
-0.0269290712,
0.0261827745,
-0.0392047279,
-0.0216635503,
0.0071114106,
0.0275925994,
-0.0060667195,
0.0493152551,
0.0293888599,
0.0200209022,
0.0019620142,
-0.0353470966,
-0.0727471039,
0.0121615799,
-0.0366001874,
0.0274506789,
-0.0186007116,
-0.0046218149,
-0.029830303,
0.0006331134,
0.0347592682,
-0.0088286959,
0.0131454552,
-0.0137260249,
0.0152723063,
-0.0179270431,
-0.0438134782,
-0.0386372358,
0.0011763746,
-0.0423925184,
-0.0282067601,
-0.059953548,
0.0576655194,
0.0310514886,
-0.0323081464,
-0.0332981646,
0.0127242086,
0.0231080167,
-0.0704551414,
0.0647418275,
-0.0678698644,
-0.0227906741,
-0.0110080643,
-0.0120156547,
-0.019012196,
0.045649156,
-0.0159692802,
0.0189604424,
0.067528531,
0.0307090003,
-0.033765886,
0.0063782125,
0.0672325864,
0.0097574936,
0.0350435972,
0.0482551977,
0.0237451233,
0.0562044382,
0.006992551,
0.0307796691,
-0.0202523358,
-0.0021376321,
0.0130939996,
0.0172654837,
0.0308779571,
-0.0143671669,
0.031135682,
0.0056812367,
0.0169189516,
0.0128238313,
-0.0296953376,
-0.0046556219,
-0.0634225085,
0.0220008697,
0.0385518,
0.0108973291,
-0.0153409261,
-0.0204678364,
0.0065111867,
-0.0338816158,
0.0217448045,
0.0400109813,
0.082277067,
0.032885544,
-0.0257212669,
0.0148078231,
0.0583749115,
-0.021195177,
0.0367568992,
0.0191128626,
0.0515765212,
0.0485722236,
0.0779267848,
-0.0651875213,
-0.0090867216,
-0.0037816872,
0.0102303056,
-0.0093084555,
0.0239470173,
-0.0369410254,
-0.0196429733,
-0.0530192554,
-0.0624867901,
-0.0144877499,
-0.0002515595,
0.0057177385,
0.0463027172,
0.0252528749,
0.0264142267,
-0.0899395123,
-0.0189446136,
0.0185527112,
-0.0246615242,
-0.0180531461,
0.0107007818,
0.007221228,
-0.0169077925,
0.0481877476,
0.019615883,
0.0231112223,
0.0299878009,
-0.0148157962,
-0.0430973135,
-0.0337698832,
-0.0007955987,
-0.0531732962,
0.0486605912,
-0.0018929488,
-0.0207924265,
0.000546882,
-0.0507744588,
-0.0533465557,
0.0118600596,
0.0103514157,
0.0738868117,
-0.0485049635,
-0.0288851317,
0.0064604674,
-0.035781946,
-0.019960342,
0.0792794377,
0.0050338176,
0.025243191,
0.0221401807,
-0.0004040184,
0.0231139548,
-0.0033015334,
-0.0694761202,
0.0177518763,
0.0290246438,
0.019863233,
0.0258458368,
-0.0229503904,
-0.08507137,
0.0308025964,
-0.1036670506,
0.0159343723,
-0.0000845263,
-0.0110681811,
-0.0205089878,
0.0108021507,
0.0108164204,
-0.0234139469,
-0.0403750725,
0.0084506813,
-0.0045539765,
0.0077909217,
0.0287073106,
0.0219372027,
0.0340418145,
-0.0091322521,
-0.0355251543,
0.0068986951,
0.0624934509,
0.005863952,
0.0151608186,
0.0009672208,
0.0367290266,
-0.071173206,
0.0360464565,
-0.0180303622,
0.03772448,
0.001600949,
-0.0518588834,
0.0102871219,
0.035397388,
-0.0338660888,
-0.0372269414,
0.0434246734,
0.0139552914,
-0.0633350909,
-0.0114578903,
-0.0718363747,
-0.0252942629,
-0.0223341472,
0.0338126644,
-0.0086881323,
-0.0242897868,
0.0140157156,
-0.0512780771,
-0.0620853566,
-0.0360996611,
0.0064257234,
0.0110416291,
-0.0555963702,
0.0009118314,
0.0221876279,
0.0290693864,
-0.0228886418,
-0.0090172626,
0.0914706364,
-0.0038242829,
0.0106640756,
-0.0079389336,
0.0093030659,
-0.0366744623,
0.0649846643,
0.0025903608,
0.01307113,
0.0258466154,
-0.0216571819,
-0.0256769266,
0.0003191556,
0.0110257193,
-0.0376657434,
0.0171134956,
0.0093037533,
0.0078439182,
0.0447903015,
0.0167360567,
-0.0315077193,
-0.038422484,
-0.0374197252,
0.0039803139,
0.0134464987,
-0.0227855835,
0.0153973019,
-0.0383467823,
0.0091147302,
0.0054961327,
0.0115123568,
0.0023195453,
-0.0319740139,
-0.0022216756,
0.0491931923,
-0.0102491872,
0.0131409606,
-0.0170270111,
0.0096827988,
0.059473455,
0.0099507896,
-0.058669094,
0.0010464969,
0.0121655809,
0.0229568947,
-0.0508741364,
-0.0180274192,
-0.0101933032,
-0.0068834992,
0.0039674663,
0.0251412522,
0.0914596319,
0.0219359659,
-0.0334359929,
-0.0180009399,
-0.0074896323,
0.014477306,
0.0253711659,
0.0240635797,
-0.1194630638,
-0.0059674224,
-0.0090880878,
0.0460625812,
0.0528334938,
-0.0788247585,
-0.0171155501,
-0.106901899,
-0.0061660111,
-0.0020327044,
0.0220683105,
-0.0483265892,
-0.0408598557,
0.0277899113,
-0.003798242,
-0.0437176824,
0.0214080662,
0.0103518777,
0.0175845604,
-0.0179073084,
-0.0045254552,
-0.0435476191,
0.0388806574,
-0.0595756993,
0.0272215251,
-0.0146982213,
0.0125625124,
0.0072704474,
-0.0288297348,
-0.0220320597,
0.0159191992,
-0.0288626868,
-0.0073958058,
0.0582907386,
-0.0229340121,
0.0028797192,
-0.0332161747,
0.0074995439,
-0.0388967618,
-0.0034705887,
0.003279093,
0.1243154109,
0.0129381856,
-0.0118874609,
-0.0121688694,
0.0000245696,
0.01634451,
0.0497927032,
0.0036731362,
0.0088616861,
0.0034138041,
-0.0221422967,
0.0154885706,
-0.0166858193,
-0.0054079234,
0.050611686,
-0.025759602,
0.0312146805,
-0.0305682849,
-0.0381823666,
0.0988817811,
0.0326641873,
0.0062001897,
0.0247620065,
0.0150780091,
-0.0358724482,
-0.0247947183,
0.0479004309,
-0.0558617078,
0.0015851333,
-0.0350285545,
-0.009376918,
-0.0060788295,
-0.044039119,
-0.012804565,
-0.0122698015,
-0.0192493815,
-0.057506822,
-0.0332345404,
0.0176235233,
0.0126685444,
0.0530507565,
-0.0708120242,
-0.0468314216,
0.0590670705,
0.0365400985,
-0.0598572046,
-0.0042268597,
0.0112877935,
-0.0428019688,
0.0081960447,
0.0438817665,
-0.0551187731,
-0.0273831841,
-0.0166279227,
0.0465377979,
-0.0188768171,
-0.0765096769,
0.0291632898,
0.0692021772,
0.0380108356,
0.0070850402,
0.0297499485,
-0.0920010358,
-0.001993418,
-0.0314155072,
-0.0247494467,
-0.0343369469,
0.0113581894,
0.035402149,
-0.0460138172,
0.0232559741,
-0.0260309614,
-0.0255296696,
0.0593613833,
-0.0472806394,
-0.0510877445,
0.0090937885,
-0.01334274,
0.0790777504,
-0.0011499304,
-0.0264793113,
0.0207379926,
-0.0141261211,
0.0162449945,
-0.034165673,
0.007504547,
0.026212832,
-0.0029770145,
-0.0047367867,
-0.0075896038,
-0.0532614812,
-0.0510983132,
-0.0041183126,
0.0358839892,
0.0473328233,
-0.0097375922,
-0.001708087,
-0.0262703709,
-0.0393183716,
-0.0202955883,
0.0159937106,
0.0143105183,
-0.0272773374,
0.0269396715,
0.0213412922,
-0.0344316363,
0.0313923247,
0.0496256165,
0.0026460642,
0.0543006249,
-0.0138229206,
-0.0441670306,
-0.0200457685,
-0.0405622572,
0.0073725716,
0.0786895528,
-0.0519845523,
0.0277564004,
-0.0464490764,
-0.0743784606,
0.0085152686,
-0.0129832048,
-0.0832727104,
0.0228648093,
0.0428924859,
0.0511659458,
0.0493424647,
-0.0215457622,
-0.037792854,
0.035789106,
-0.009650738,
-0.0165017024,
0.0630461276,
-5.72607102e-33,
-0.0232808609,
-0.0323081389,
0.0193572082,
-0.0097651761,
-0.0163389277,
0.0011683984,
-0.0088869417,
-0.0030662955,
-0.0467317365,
0.0391557403,
-0.0144660696,
0.0145543739,
-0.0140775125,
0.0142240273,
-0.0173314344,
-0.0028490885,
0.0108540468,
-0.0042612958,
0.0202963613,
0.02550718,
0.0678384528,
0.0549880862,
0.0190959647,
-0.0533509962,
0.0742677003,
-0.0336709134,
0.0151608912,
0.0122651616,
0.0049647726,
0.0503833555,
-0.0079409089,
0.079100512,
-0.002224376,
-0.0072036521,
-0.0108322799,
0.0107727703,
-0.1041132435,
-0.0681448951,
0.0361638106,
-0.0132258488,
-0.0675942153,
0.0245795567,
-0.0003756525,
-0.0173520464,
0.0679689422,
-0.0351411104,
0.0269223023,
-0.0013287064,
-0.0675050318,
0.0023388239,
-0.0067894123,
0.03038566,
0.0332266726,
0.0140694706,
0.0129911164,
0.0141938552,
0.0283982791,
0.0184170883,
-0.0410422422,
0.0298361853,
0.0027369121,
-0.0244375039,
-0.0049273488,
0.0003963738,
0.0083260024,
0.0296919979,
-0.0506495982,
-0.0194033161,
-0.071496442,
0.0368922949,
-0.0050301976,
0.0641563162,
-0.0050556646,
0.0438453555,
-0.0419151969,
-0.0307768099,
-0.0700841099,
0.0167530645,
-0.011069038,
-0.004926533,
-0.0243276116,
-0.0138551677,
-0.0211538598,
-0.0367356315,
-0.0603422895,
0.0035203777,
-0.0333791971,
-0.0357261151,
-0.0084159421,
0.002309853,
-0.0180318914,
-0.0328357778,
-0.0201669745,
-0.034504801,
0.0001013291,
0.0488699637,
-0.0021721532,
-0.0115356715,
-0.0058124783,
0.0646026433,
-0.0629898012,
0.0040928498,
0.0231150277,
-0.0702876672,
-0.0476683863,
0.0332779437,
0.0120675694,
0.0239394996,
-0.0169984885,
0.0052153482,
-0.0257417224,
-0.0120804831,
0.0059057074,
-0.0203486644,
0.049891673,
0.0508084409,
0.0156017672,
0.0630704612,
0.0596006811,
0.0514735579,
-0.0251749139,
-0.0315331072,
0.0445359871,
-0.0062631103,
-0.0085124187,
-0.0043860227,
-0.0184142236,
0.009378952,
0.0191314034,
-0.0207090043,
0.0000521579,
0.0114794532,
2.456e-7,
0.0651247874,
-0.008677531,
0.0109607847,
0.0666892678,
-0.0442971885,
0.0182827394,
0.0183295999,
0.0332456268,
0.0103064729,
-0.0501747802,
0.045534946,
0.0038340534,
-0.0149242152,
0.0313703418,
-0.0913935006,
0.0044259517,
-0.0213122591,
-0.0369588435,
-0.0511198528,
-0.0474435948,
0.0755672231,
0.0374403,
0.0564421043,
0.0039507179,
-0.0166298356,
-0.0617811903,
0.0818134695,
0.0039912993,
-0.0426459908,
0.0107336864,
0.1015306041,
0.047129415,
-0.0172287077,
0.0458190031,
-0.005123686,
0.0179190226,
0.0362441689,
0.0229586158,
0.0338875428,
-0.0215787422,
-0.0107296649,
-0.0505068749,
0.0159097034,
-0.0640914217,
0.1078421324,
-0.0155841699,
0.0100113517,
0.0268611852,
-0.0553256497,
-0.0397271626,
0.0385318995,
-0.0156805273,
-0.0030398157,
-0.0187237002,
0.0085572628,
0.0223490521,
0.0071261162,
-0.0873323008,
0.0001999932,
0.0184508711,
-0.0228998438,
-0.0455940738,
0.036677409,
-0.0158253666,
0.0128484545,
-0.0416587107,
0.0391467176,
2.255876285e-34,
0.0458891131,
0.0275075417,
0.0096321432,
-0.0328721367,
0.0262792557,
-0.0275957901,
-0.0164265726,
-0.0158639736,
0.0438522696,
-0.1206992865,
-0.0235174913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15594v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15594v1 | Flocks of Stochastic Parrots: Differentially Private Prompt Learning for Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T22:06:08 | 2023-05-24T22:06:08 | Haonan Duan, Adam Dziedzic, Nicolas Papernot, Franziska Boenisch | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Large language models (LLMs) are excellent in-context learners. However, the
sensitivity of data contained in prompts raises privacy concerns. Our work
first shows that these concerns are valid: we instantiate a simple but highly
effective membership inference attack against the data used to prompt LLMs. To
address this vulnerability, one could forego prompting and resort to
fine-tuning LLMs with known algorithms for private gradient descent. However,
this comes at the expense of the practicality and efficiency offered by
prompting. Therefore, we propose to privately learn to prompt. We first show
that soft prompts can be obtained privately through gradient descent on
downstream data. However, this is not the case for discrete prompts. Thus, we
orchestrate a noisy vote among an ensemble of LLMs presented with different
prompts, i.e., a flock of stochastic parrots. The vote privately transfers the
flock's knowledge into a single public prompt. We show that LLMs prompted with
our private algorithms closely match the non-private baselines. For example,
using GPT3 as the base model, we achieve a downstream accuracy of 92.7% on the
sst2 dataset with ($\epsilon=0.147, \delta=10^{-6}$)-differential privacy vs.
95.2% for the non-private baseline. Through our experiments, we also show that
our prompt-based approach is easily deployed with existing commercial APIs. | [
0.0165232196,
0.1267889738,
-0.0155928563,
0.0589483194,
-0.0457628369,
-0.0209456272,
0.0696432069,
-0.0264556594,
0.0204872098,
0.0291887838,
-0.0612756535,
-0.0224313624,
0.0313033611,
-0.0033729703,
0.0186886974,
0.0136261815,
0.0310929529,
-0.0429654978,
-0.0069048642,
-0.058792904,
-0.0490981974,
-0.0075089359,
0.0154834939,
0.0074398075,
0.0361829288,
-0.0454405844,
-0.0283920262,
-0.0153748719,
0.0276929736,
-0.0019404793,
0.0230552293,
0.0855661035,
0.0381951258,
0.1220218539,
0.0000018735,
-0.0399945304,
-0.0388703793,
0.0329838842,
-0.0557933562,
0.0271086209,
-0.0309119374,
-0.004065623,
0.0427197851,
0.0043615159,
-0.0360975936,
0.017276939,
0.0183453187,
-0.0066068405,
0.0721434057,
0.0830246881,
0.035285987,
0.0079894681,
-0.0079629645,
-0.0608688071,
0.0085618999,
-0.0827145204,
0.0026624443,
-0.0860159174,
-0.0310263913,
0.0372824594,
-0.0061641457,
0.0326434039,
0.0004946404,
0.0217094757,
-0.0071835611,
0.0482373014,
0.0126115251,
-0.0307481289,
-0.0330653116,
0.0266227908,
0.0157787353,
-0.0117841968,
0.0187871922,
0.0156771187,
0.0451343022,
0.0080656894,
-0.0273375288,
0.0471436158,
-0.0186512899,
0.0143114915,
0.0143428072,
-0.023008218,
0.0236963723,
-0.0085825333,
0.0483321771,
0.0326414369,
0.0023208512,
0.0128843151,
-0.0301590785,
0.0033559746,
0.0028147714,
-0.0527980886,
0.0394122452,
0.0002574664,
0.0144500947,
0.009004605,
-0.0392317697,
-0.0551856831,
0.017952444,
0.0140417293,
0.0476341881,
-0.0244439095,
0.0284172855,
0.0356978364,
-0.0041458602,
0.0183934197,
-0.0305358972,
0.0334154032,
0.0360252,
0.0538455136,
-0.0260023251,
0.0114984931,
-0.0178038608,
0.0665398613,
-0.0497251414,
0.0129521852,
-0.0200089775,
0.0181396138,
-0.0165034514,
0.0430024043,
-0.0136106778,
-0.0063255983,
-0.0416943617,
-0.0290504526,
0.0260655973,
-0.0565884896,
-0.0015591223,
-0.0051077013,
0.0351379439,
-0.0471647866,
-0.0461343713,
-0.0587890297,
0.0024880304,
0.0169989653,
-0.0495740548,
0.0614532828,
0.005903664,
-0.012013278,
0.0153760929,
-0.074878253,
0.0114085004,
-0.0432174541,
-0.0312984996,
-0.0555232503,
0.0193807408,
-0.0248498395,
0.0019750772,
-0.0561639182,
0.0077509363,
0.0091243898,
-0.0005721987,
0.0635567456,
-0.005523839,
-0.0132451281,
-0.0104896063,
0.035842482,
-0.0442930087,
0.0448867194,
-0.0046868762,
0.023195276,
0.0595374405,
0.0012401439,
0.0403969623,
-0.0107624419,
0.082317017,
0.0431727841,
-0.0021905461,
0.029908631,
0.0489574149,
-0.0246196315,
-0.0344413072,
0.0498985723,
0.0000698727,
-0.0623577237,
0.0713664666,
0.0494584702,
-0.0197321773,
0.0086127259,
-0.0467049032,
0.0450702161,
-0.0227221586,
0.0085114911,
-0.0545432791,
-0.0202869903,
-0.0761505887,
-0.0352166407,
0.0130258407,
0.0102496194,
-0.001517149,
0.0120603228,
0.0339656956,
-0.0578695722,
-0.0069736913,
0.0483429357,
-0.0069690761,
-0.0152132139,
0.0078926021,
0.0244306121,
0.0191725716,
-0.0426134318,
-0.0181487333,
-0.0558830164,
0.0549510494,
0.0412986875,
0.019001605,
-0.0065882578,
0.0312521718,
-0.0712681264,
0.005311497,
0.0186721943,
-0.0009014055,
0.002937027,
0.0659853667,
-0.0254322719,
-0.0327514149,
0.0253571384,
0.0348393992,
0.0243459903,
0.0031185786,
0.0039867996,
-0.0019870473,
0.005256658,
0.0063658692,
0.0292737018,
-0.0169647485,
-0.0588387437,
0.0354676582,
0.0140897809,
0.0616718903,
0.0019012785,
-0.0225683153,
0.0028091264,
-0.0095981993,
0.0251313318,
-0.0046342267,
-0.0407528169,
-0.0041013919,
-0.0473118983,
-0.0278043561,
0.0072642011,
-0.0040539117,
0.0491584167,
-0.0187786855,
-0.0208005644,
0.0018862446,
-0.0035222559,
0.0245701578,
0.0134473415,
0.0059435973,
-0.0254386757,
0.0401511081,
-0.0254962239,
0.0161403567,
-0.0286443196,
-0.0040127845,
-0.0551622286,
0.0089039002,
-0.0029171961,
-0.0528055392,
-0.0052022873,
-0.011048723,
0.009586676,
0.0132726412,
0.0155627551,
0.0039898194,
-0.0144723924,
-0.0458306894,
-0.0195118207,
0.012978388,
-0.0403464846,
0.032898955,
-0.0078912936,
-0.0081334161,
-0.0079240864,
-0.0401194096,
-0.024201965,
0.0205474403,
-0.0650531799,
0.0302395411,
-0.0168705769,
0.0299292877,
-0.0480690263,
0.0211900324,
-0.0303878728,
0.0198267251,
0.0362669155,
-0.0216426998,
0.0037264386,
-0.0285579525,
0.0157058667,
-0.0199254788,
0.0169110894,
-0.0142180789,
-0.0018205993,
0.016568888,
0.0054686186,
-0.0227752235,
0.0883149877,
0.0323740914,
0.0069830818,
0.0348440893,
0.014127586,
-0.0442239977,
-0.0026600927,
-0.0194877796,
-0.0539782494,
-0.0538882613,
0.0168539584,
0.0122622373,
0.0213829018,
0.0069991555,
-0.0612797961,
-0.0346090756,
0.0580019951,
0.0252344422,
-0.0277578924,
-0.0360384956,
-0.0052786889,
-0.0051650712,
0.0442538299,
0.0153696481,
-0.0804883689,
0.0823871046,
-0.0101478659,
0.0028746363,
-0.0018521691,
-0.0320232473,
-0.0127933444,
0.075550653,
-0.0065786024,
0.0098927449,
0.029257277,
-0.0306391902,
-0.0047877603,
0.0086724563,
0.0561337546,
-0.035469126,
0.0319853276,
-0.0177362077,
-0.0141646937,
0.0048864488,
-0.0541177467,
-0.0348921418,
-0.0848558024,
-0.0305130705,
-0.0195737034,
-0.0356188528,
-0.0250233561,
0.0158979706,
-0.0339314118,
0.0235389937,
0.0036449619,
-0.0111874742,
0.0171215199,
-0.0255096462,
-0.0256182589,
-0.0069272127,
-0.0274614114,
-0.0079310583,
-0.0700739101,
0.0177310761,
0.0395395979,
0.0889728069,
0.0167518388,
0.0421426781,
-0.0522422828,
0.0372778624,
0.0050669136,
-0.0353134722,
0.023847064,
0.0436564237,
-0.0432927385,
0.0013394825,
0.0574434251,
-0.0032096819,
-0.0852943137,
-0.0139108514,
0.0424888879,
0.0522363558,
-0.0114920987,
-0.0263174269,
-0.0799337924,
0.0004905117,
0.0342068635,
0.0578634515,
-0.0186570436,
-0.050247848,
-0.0432405882,
-0.0970326662,
0.0019995542,
0.0035635203,
-0.0267239846,
0.0096763289,
-0.06863565,
0.0121459309,
-0.0140714142,
-0.0020518401,
-0.0270587262,
0.0149389161,
-0.0112439813,
-0.014735613,
0.0160162374,
-0.0105484249,
-0.0024006783,
-0.0227212589,
0.0465475768,
0.0532148816,
-0.018431345,
-0.0056649637,
-0.0475944392,
0.033639919,
-0.0182207413,
-0.0329278298,
0.0081809927,
0.0317142829,
-0.0143426927,
-0.0117884949,
0.0150083434,
0.0664982349,
0.007114674,
0.0141696855,
0.0410401821,
0.0230399147,
-0.0065400833,
-0.0405989513,
0.0329994373,
-0.0071266033,
0.0434855372,
0.0430340469,
-0.0020321235,
-0.0444897562,
0.022036368,
-0.0438166596,
0.0310670696,
0.0217379387,
0.0140145393,
0.0202434491,
0.0250123385,
-0.0450585634,
-0.0253567863,
0.0221154094,
0.0037440779,
0.042596098,
0.024909934,
0.0405603126,
0.0094670588,
0.0125237778,
-0.002458371,
0.0229060706,
-0.0787969753,
0.0160660427,
-0.0358598456,
-0.020645706,
0.0162917264,
0.0192757864,
-0.0190582965,
-0.0117831398,
-0.101234071,
-0.0953273475,
0.0313680582,
0.0291231368,
0.0140012857,
0.0577515289,
-0.0221108235,
-0.0511380769,
0.0932559669,
0.0579334684,
-0.0322239548,
0.0257980227,
0.056522917,
-0.005661089,
0.0020296047,
0.0652849078,
-0.0245598406,
-0.0311561208,
0.0774345919,
-0.0454860292,
-0.0267945919,
-0.0302095432,
-0.0182683151,
0.0194427632,
0.0508484058,
-0.0040826243,
-0.0052274792,
-0.040553011,
0.0537868924,
-0.0058975653,
0.0022594421,
-0.0302419029,
-0.0235836618,
0.0374065712,
-0.0433789752,
0.0483748652,
0.0026261476,
0.0574292764,
0.0072212582,
-0.0629084632,
0.0487969667,
0.0421215333,
0.0019296699,
0.0478949547,
0.0044575185,
-0.0296151899,
0.0613193884,
0.0203962028,
0.039158769,
0.0047320104,
0.0161018632,
0.0181410834,
-0.0007714593,
0.0096131694,
0.0179541744,
-0.080662176,
-0.0716464967,
0.0034280645,
0.06705755,
-0.0119892275,
0.0320833772,
-0.0350828022,
-0.0223066192,
-0.0037328117,
-0.0210379008,
0.0056094131,
-0.0310342647,
-0.050936494,
0.0164829679,
-0.0135005265,
0.0056610615,
0.0550956763,
0.0726990774,
-0.0085337898,
0.015358502,
0.0159551054,
0.0113053499,
-0.0463401526,
-0.0040642922,
0.0093502058,
0.0350661911,
0.0002955149,
0.0306388605,
-0.005406626,
-0.0585886277,
-0.0120716952,
-0.0141711626,
-0.0062467665,
-0.0060200938,
0.001366535,
-0.0042781895,
-0.0166638941,
-0.0170555115,
-0.0768513903,
0.0043194098,
0.0209528822,
-0.0343332179,
-0.0180671141,
-5.736756264e-33,
-0.0094072167,
-0.0152403144,
-0.0570969284,
0.0416558385,
0.0493433066,
0.0084432587,
0.0003680653,
0.0077760867,
-0.0192477591,
-0.0268014949,
-0.0669249147,
0.0238825977,
0.0132867014,
0.0505240001,
-0.0128001012,
-0.025135396,
0.036151953,
-0.0634489357,
-0.0277394634,
0.0420245528,
0.0332402922,
0.0370696262,
0.0217451584,
-0.0452499501,
0.0645347014,
-0.0154846134,
-0.049418889,
0.0252919141,
-0.0764543712,
0.0203574523,
-0.015226569,
-0.0171600431,
-0.0172824152,
0.0147593394,
-0.0089343144,
0.0260972623,
-0.0150652304,
-0.0105216801,
-0.0315366238,
-0.0031815625,
0.0030402374,
-0.0497809798,
0.0179588888,
-0.037433736,
0.0006312942,
-0.0168375988,
-0.0226525944,
-0.0034905002,
-0.0157185551,
-0.0021990426,
0.0400090478,
0.0039715255,
-0.0050206687,
-0.0103378156,
0.0492562987,
-0.0032689285,
0.0027598208,
-0.0047360733,
-0.0244758017,
0.0152993705,
0.0397281684,
0.0000161824,
0.0408481956,
0.0230646972,
0.0428630672,
0.019240696,
0.0826771334,
0.0407592878,
0.0007985018,
-0.0214894228,
-0.0118965041,
0.0306746978,
0.0398480631,
0.0266819634,
0.0217221361,
-0.0125105642,
-0.0290758908,
-0.0059761107,
-0.0022649916,
-0.0486389957,
0.0685495958,
-0.003805415,
-0.0435099974,
0.0113069462,
-0.0601795241,
-0.0317005701,
-0.0180561282,
0.0340197608,
-0.0164751839,
0.0517836958,
-0.0424534753,
-0.0485157743,
0.0326692909,
-0.0403421149,
-0.0462046936,
0.0178977363,
0.0749630481,
-0.0184614509,
0.0127725713,
-0.0005715071,
-0.0398243628,
-0.0061933747,
-0.0217789654,
-0.0245886315,
0.0102806371,
0.0061385664,
0.0491512455,
0.0140200825,
-0.0863383934,
-0.0074081551,
-0.035359852,
0.0656157956,
0.032909438,
0.0307331644,
0.078984201,
-0.068021968,
0.003877877,
0.0238066148,
0.0153732784,
0.016708089,
-0.017689582,
0.0534246303,
-0.0550444871,
-0.0146479225,
0.0004071832,
-0.015272052,
0.0300495327,
0.0327642374,
0.0601149462,
0.0268502571,
0.0233468898,
-0.0278882943,
2.544e-7,
-0.0606501698,
-0.0213252399,
-0.0154693909,
-0.0008726415,
0.0348553807,
0.0606228486,
-0.0377393365,
0.0715411305,
-0.0199137647,
-0.0356781594,
-0.0379604585,
0.0001310232,
0.0651035756,
0.0273199975,
-0.0707910284,
-0.0322041772,
-0.0254091639,
0.0536996685,
-0.0473005027,
-0.0230700988,
-0.0202689543,
0.1104105413,
0.0361122899,
-0.0002577584,
0.0042988486,
-0.0524952151,
0.0402226895,
-0.0542178415,
-0.0351599306,
-0.0099402042,
0.0353947878,
0.0407133587,
-0.0123963095,
0.0082126083,
-0.0210684817,
0.0347847156,
-0.0789924935,
0.0872479156,
0.0423836485,
-0.0008969313,
-0.0040574903,
-0.0224654116,
-0.0295423046,
-0.0155226588,
0.0298783388,
-0.0082017053,
-0.0483593009,
-0.0368260443,
0.0428302661,
-0.1029573604,
0.0564715937,
-0.0137505196,
0.0188467465,
0.0104154367,
-0.0219522864,
-0.0008580158,
0.0268572848,
-0.0719620436,
-0.0328044817,
-0.0554247499,
-0.0410969853,
-0.0419877805,
0.017116474,
0.0269877166,
-0.0255393777,
0.0036016218,
0.0524349399,
2.089475876e-34,
0.0197229106,
-0.0384189487,
-0.0009926284,
0.0282422695,
0.0277209152,
-0.0346290469,
0.0337136351,
-0.0112912497,
0.0581745133,
-0.054244969,
-0.0236301217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15587v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15587v1 | How do humans perceive adversarial text? A reality check on the validity and naturalness of word-based adversarial attacks | 2023-05-24T21:52:13 | 2023-05-24T21:52:13 | Salijona Dyrmishi, Salah Ghamizi, Maxime Cordy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural Language Processing (NLP) models based on Machine Learning (ML) are
susceptible to adversarial attacks -- malicious algorithms that imperceptibly
modify input text to force models into making incorrect predictions. However,
evaluations of these attacks ignore the property of imperceptibility or study
it under limited settings. This entails that adversarial perturbations would
not pass any human quality gate and do not represent real threats to
human-checked NLP systems. To bypass this limitation and enable proper
assessment (and later, improvement) of NLP model robustness, we have surveyed
378 human participants about the perceptibility of text adversarial examples
produced by state-of-the-art methods. Our results underline that existing text
attacks are impractical in real-world scenarios where humans are involved. This
contrasts with previous smaller-scale human studies, which reported overly
optimistic conclusions regarding attack success. Through our work, we hope to
position human perceptibility as a first-class success criterion for text
attacks, and provide guidance for research to build effective attack algorithms
and, in turn, design appropriate defence mechanisms. | [
0.0631335005,
0.062222302,
-0.030647805,
0.0470284894,
-0.0187925268,
-0.0025085253,
0.0037281839,
0.0137117011,
0.0319590569,
-0.0690487847,
-0.0007902694,
0.003183624,
0.0392628014,
0.0068389308,
0.0776361972,
-0.0334330648,
0.024805408,
0.012081543,
-0.016979875,
0.0228033382,
0.0162421707,
-0.0191682838,
-0.0117842834,
0.0298655275,
0.0195679441,
-0.0315227211,
0.0060152574,
-0.0050699278,
0.0326752439,
-0.0092375698,
0.0000949246,
0.0479770713,
-0.0216986127,
0.0652942583,
0.0000017512,
-0.0206994843,
-0.0018122212,
0.0242747404,
0.0051806606,
0.037950512,
0.0662678704,
-0.0317045934,
-0.019096842,
0.0148016019,
-0.027524218,
0.0375760607,
0.0141402893,
0.0748556703,
0.0521539412,
0.0905281603,
-0.0205616411,
-0.0185180251,
0.0393393971,
-0.0015966045,
-0.0113992002,
-0.0534128472,
0.0363048166,
-0.0456458852,
-0.0353525616,
0.0101161543,
-0.0066275452,
0.0159937963,
0.0115914969,
0.0187920798,
-0.0145287029,
0.0277521536,
-0.014088301,
-0.0232227482,
-0.0043714875,
0.0669316128,
-0.0137718581,
-0.022486994,
-0.0075337328,
-0.0214803256,
0.0337883383,
0.011332768,
0.0021960519,
-0.0095921271,
0.0050858036,
-0.0239427723,
-0.0603917763,
-0.0042728717,
0.0600302964,
0.046847228,
0.0356223546,
0.0377886817,
0.005566386,
-0.0246683732,
-0.0064988863,
-0.001502072,
-0.008142652,
-0.0100201201,
0.0047206129,
-0.0183042139,
0.0113005443,
0.0078276563,
-0.0979573503,
-0.0701373219,
0.0492554307,
-0.0730721578,
0.0560042411,
0.0082476903,
-0.0190185402,
0.0260235723,
-0.0085009774,
0.0366347097,
-0.0243863054,
0.0366615802,
0.0044996697,
0.0381702408,
-0.0220013056,
-0.018476218,
0.0195929166,
-0.0309121925,
-0.0249952078,
0.020191513,
-0.0374999046,
0.0021779595,
-0.0550182164,
0.0177342147,
-0.0760087669,
0.0134187853,
0.0067564924,
0.0103600584,
0.0072289803,
-0.0249335114,
-0.0019166755,
0.0215411391,
-0.0293824673,
-0.0915836915,
-0.0186411366,
0.0268162135,
-0.047946889,
-0.0252704825,
-0.0223007444,
0.1035039052,
0.0212762114,
-0.0440448634,
-0.014500143,
-0.0578359142,
-0.0405292995,
-0.0128202178,
0.0135090584,
-0.0322992615,
-0.0137380203,
-0.0101650767,
-0.0093309991,
-0.0724701881,
-0.0083430549,
0.033019226,
-0.0255310126,
0.0926871747,
0.0068544783,
-0.0161528885,
0.0127910888,
0.0292418171,
-0.0170548875,
0.0398622751,
0.0192712583,
0.0511108153,
0.0458256602,
0.0203393437,
0.0357616134,
0.0121213887,
0.0357187502,
-0.0030767685,
-0.018092474,
-0.002878089,
-0.0280160923,
-0.0079363016,
-0.0058547608,
0.0533359163,
-0.0079793744,
-0.08543019,
0.1251531839,
0.0384714417,
-0.0586366653,
0.0467592962,
-0.0106634069,
0.008978907,
0.0255285557,
0.0045433869,
-0.0770876259,
-0.0250484962,
-0.0803987384,
-0.0360448025,
-0.0046272073,
0.0158343799,
0.0117591759,
-0.0277997237,
-0.0460236929,
0.0080323415,
0.0717101246,
-0.0258523077,
0.0380864516,
0.0366462879,
-0.0324372463,
-0.0341250747,
0.0061652451,
-0.0154218506,
0.0031576538,
-0.0527044199,
-0.0248696767,
0.0306053646,
0.0479182117,
-0.0198480189,
0.0831815526,
-0.0319425501,
0.0121281352,
0.01781209,
0.0498117134,
0.0235584509,
0.0163145754,
0.0113166375,
-0.009598325,
-0.0366756693,
0.0278921276,
0.0242221076,
0.0246473812,
0.0085715856,
-0.0078048492,
0.0032100196,
-0.0589919575,
0.0733571798,
0.0135162314,
-0.0263341349,
-0.0274834316,
0.0133678196,
0.0270893555,
0.0309088398,
-0.0375551209,
0.0359084159,
0.0273676459,
0.0134674748,
-0.0336740948,
-0.0128142694,
0.0307158083,
0.0045677782,
0.003280797,
-0.059559457,
-0.0366861075,
0.0841317102,
-0.0266392436,
0.0462240316,
0.0199567452,
-0.078820616,
-0.0119680474,
-0.0273942016,
-0.0295218136,
-0.0331239775,
0.0429624766,
-0.0233385954,
0.0360806286,
-0.028553497,
-0.0011632045,
-0.0157119054,
-0.015380281,
0.0086196074,
-0.0251702089,
-0.0640223771,
0.0063089342,
-0.0207101721,
0.0185088199,
0.0058920337,
-0.0286078658,
-0.028960431,
0.0194531456,
-0.0312355198,
-0.0600647144,
-0.0157698616,
-0.0025247335,
0.0338780917,
-0.0452135429,
-0.006579075,
-0.0043065329,
0.025019303,
-0.0176748671,
-0.0149298152,
0.0509041026,
0.0226407312,
-0.0355070308,
0.010866968,
-0.0172231589,
-0.0033657246,
-0.0115463482,
0.0859197602,
0.0488356315,
-0.0442772061,
-0.0123866359,
0.0273474716,
0.0051279501,
0.0391863547,
-0.0211438648,
-0.0560122915,
0.0295388084,
0.0622484684,
-0.0343282111,
0.0895005167,
0.0365924649,
0.0618001409,
0.0501565225,
0.0658821091,
0.0106438622,
-0.0175529253,
0.0043186066,
0.0047580339,
-0.0159374606,
-0.0437417924,
0.044948563,
0.0516610742,
0.0476131514,
-0.0174464062,
-0.0290582776,
0.0660575032,
-0.0451091155,
-0.0748810396,
-0.0369904041,
-0.0233002547,
-0.0378703326,
0.0020886145,
-0.0432407297,
-0.0468419865,
0.0846792683,
-0.0157582425,
0.0187713169,
-0.0083419178,
-0.015058117,
0.0386765935,
0.0401976854,
0.0240620822,
0.0197805408,
0.0176433306,
0.0090076104,
-0.0423867255,
-0.0235508159,
0.0411941372,
-0.0101223197,
0.0003498153,
-0.021311963,
-0.0121202301,
0.0206336435,
-0.0311158095,
-0.0654388964,
-0.0709306672,
-0.0362751298,
0.0059980773,
0.0181946233,
-0.0318219215,
-0.0470487662,
-0.0199449081,
0.0492272079,
-0.0146104777,
0.0032735001,
-0.0126188369,
-0.0115510058,
0.0378970876,
0.0391945466,
-0.0372242257,
0.0385276116,
-0.0226715859,
0.011970914,
0.1029219702,
0.0086303903,
0.0298542678,
-0.0206144694,
-0.0130031519,
-0.0081492011,
0.0184000935,
0.0268632919,
0.0294096451,
0.0461408496,
-0.0260901675,
-0.0000347023,
0.0183205344,
0.0007266853,
0.0018787461,
0.0382383019,
0.0219515972,
-0.0115835778,
0.0055355118,
-0.0255308077,
-0.0420766808,
-0.0251825955,
0.0236633569,
0.0433610119,
-0.037885692,
-0.0052328398,
-0.0105068898,
-0.0720447674,
-0.0061925813,
-0.0246087797,
-0.0251080599,
-0.0321397036,
-0.051916182,
-0.0018904477,
-0.0218629278,
0.0213275757,
-0.0143259689,
0.0252933558,
0.0050174617,
-0.0103967562,
-0.0383449309,
-0.0439643934,
0.0084371874,
-0.0268571936,
0.0074137561,
0.0948980302,
0.0576808266,
-0.0370185077,
-0.0491601676,
0.0261642821,
-0.0073753544,
0.0062216781,
0.0245787352,
0.0917931721,
-0.0170389377,
-0.0086611668,
-0.0241229758,
0.0408980027,
-0.0083809933,
-0.0317247398,
0.0095677394,
0.0130485836,
0.0141719701,
-0.0445295386,
-0.0482786112,
0.007499428,
0.0098553989,
0.0740327686,
0.0196617134,
-0.057452973,
-0.0357916206,
-0.0676504821,
0.0124747194,
-0.0484404117,
-0.1021918058,
0.0382342674,
0.0264925603,
-0.032210622,
-0.0650638491,
-0.0490275025,
-0.0371187069,
-0.0017786812,
0.0178396832,
-0.0128815984,
-0.0013154552,
0.0079098959,
-0.0235816482,
0.0032379187,
0.0232292153,
0.0550885387,
-0.0116539048,
-0.008776024,
-0.0054334421,
-0.0186669324,
-0.0405977704,
0.0253467821,
-0.079912059,
-0.0785408616,
0.03903348,
0.0290662758,
0.0137172919,
0.0120139578,
-0.0607572794,
-0.0945936218,
0.0748099536,
0.0577258952,
-0.0209727846,
0.0394699462,
0.0459969081,
-0.0190895367,
0.0265677795,
0.0248038974,
-0.0072471793,
-0.0190740116,
0.0629640743,
-0.0223554615,
-0.0203722883,
-0.0002385527,
-0.0002800046,
0.009945319,
0.0797075182,
-0.0208004694,
-0.0226221383,
0.037917953,
-0.0276744366,
0.0049180123,
-0.0175704043,
-0.0154975103,
-0.0089348936,
0.0091886325,
0.0137454029,
-0.0156244785,
-0.0043451684,
-0.0359847993,
0.0173506252,
-0.02354303,
0.014991493,
0.0384809896,
0.0514841527,
0.01216082,
0.0245918781,
-0.0060954252,
0.0430754311,
-0.0513998792,
0.0057537421,
0.0417744033,
0.0236900579,
0.0107509168,
-0.0234788954,
-0.0130986786,
0.0039391583,
-0.085916847,
-0.0120085916,
-0.0347862989,
0.0127760945,
0.0050037284,
0.0003853562,
-0.011614982,
-0.0174452476,
-0.0175730344,
-0.0186097249,
-0.0133851999,
-0.005976561,
-0.0150075369,
0.0055160183,
0.0137652159,
-0.020632904,
0.0216555502,
0.0569384322,
0.032531295,
0.0273143873,
0.012465396,
-0.0576100387,
-0.0124269295,
-0.0259920359,
0.0259118527,
0.0068828925,
-0.0360357948,
0.007503002,
-0.0628137365,
-0.0760934353,
0.0136809004,
0.007354965,
0.0631421581,
-0.0168632921,
-0.0285059232,
0.0585187972,
-0.0048398515,
0.0466828234,
-0.0471466184,
0.0345563143,
-0.002315986,
-0.0401009955,
-0.013522882,
-5.498934655e-33,
0.037190225,
-0.0690546706,
-0.0594014004,
-0.0351931341,
0.0378529914,
0.0231848676,
-0.0261464603,
0.012478739,
-0.0187753029,
0.0281522013,
0.0155770872,
0.0329623632,
-0.021182118,
-0.0009488101,
-0.0240213517,
-0.0512541831,
0.0227349401,
-0.0365600884,
-0.0244214945,
-0.0307409335,
0.0194698311,
0.0180511046,
0.0175511017,
-0.0808051452,
0.1087326482,
0.0106644183,
-0.0325541869,
-0.04212071,
-0.0270932131,
0.0453164354,
-0.0166572984,
0.0282799434,
0.0231667589,
-0.0109455707,
-0.0158758275,
0.0336494483,
0.0067714406,
0.006020301,
-0.0200342201,
0.031567391,
-0.0364894234,
0.0131861344,
0.0481253304,
-0.0384475626,
-0.0308188964,
0.0011954813,
0.0344567634,
-0.0209183414,
0.0000883839,
-0.0052113845,
-0.0119034797,
0.0192601252,
-0.0116590001,
0.0126480274,
0.0035824317,
0.0556580871,
0.0177504085,
0.0113243787,
-0.0925395265,
0.0047839852,
0.0260749329,
-0.0249244869,
0.0332455561,
-0.0267033745,
0.0101342015,
0.0891475677,
0.0641967058,
0.0252563991,
-0.0419665053,
-0.0111579243,
0.0108582238,
0.001105747,
0.0958079472,
0.1180044934,
0.0419438072,
-0.0376142785,
-0.0489699952,
-0.0112491688,
-0.0297431722,
0.0021312584,
0.0494456738,
0.0102114892,
-0.0875797421,
0.001825036,
-0.0066674831,
-0.0951892361,
-0.046922829,
-0.0166317094,
0.0164617263,
-0.0055557135,
-0.0216512717,
-0.0079996716,
-0.0219341386,
-0.0498638898,
0.0103774909,
0.02348754,
-0.0275470018,
-0.0201903023,
0.011777957,
0.0117393229,
-0.0131972246,
0.0203151554,
0.0197707154,
-0.0027375729,
0.0364147313,
-0.02548928,
0.0558388717,
-0.0015520331,
-0.0334930681,
-0.02424323,
-0.0149061456,
0.0095514413,
0.0537354648,
0.0437920466,
0.0546140075,
-0.0066379826,
-0.0339139476,
-0.0038924229,
0.0208723992,
-0.0033681653,
-0.0154145174,
0.0361328498,
-0.0440790765,
-0.0078150928,
-0.0132885855,
-0.0711223632,
-0.0072080474,
0.0166931655,
0.0333658718,
-0.0802199841,
-0.0015312028,
-0.0370401554,
2.541e-7,
0.0008002205,
0.0316025317,
-0.0010099971,
-0.0087222848,
0.0454389229,
0.080619961,
-0.0045560738,
0.0636683404,
-0.0116524221,
-0.0248640869,
-0.0233616754,
0.000928444,
0.0627421364,
0.0092299422,
-0.0355409943,
-0.0041496381,
-0.0645978376,
0.0344581455,
-0.0153654087,
0.0025136785,
0.0399924144,
0.0612338856,
0.0399365313,
0.0024588658,
-0.0142582133,
-0.0614458174,
0.018898949,
-0.036724817,
0.0308468938,
-0.0446262658,
0.0738334879,
0.0019080205,
0.035181988,
0.0260109436,
-0.0411205143,
-0.0359289795,
0.0265050866,
0.0438436382,
-0.0171957295,
0.0010484172,
-0.0271446798,
-0.0053145909,
0.0181163792,
-0.0409595221,
0.0605357848,
-0.0274707917,
-0.0306006391,
-0.0093392981,
-0.0213948246,
-0.0293963943,
0.0741434768,
-0.0216566641,
-0.0226459261,
-0.0122465249,
0.0106862774,
0.0157590378,
0.0060358872,
-0.0443097129,
-0.0148165142,
-0.0269160718,
-0.0243737455,
-0.0249215811,
-0.0421659946,
0.0139401946,
0.0488526486,
-0.022835847,
-0.017218098,
1.932263839e-34,
0.0159043055,
-0.0115193799,
-0.0146365147,
-0.009297641,
0.0489295237,
0.0153460773,
0.0370123088,
-0.0241632052,
0.0406619757,
-0.028790677,
-0.0164025091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15582v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15582v1 | Balancing Effect of Training Dataset Distribution of Multiple Styles for Multi-Style Text Transfer | 2023-05-24T21:36:15 | 2023-05-24T21:36:15 | Debarati Das, David Ma, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text style transfer is an exciting task within the field of natural language
generation that is often plagued by the need for high-quality paired datasets.
Furthermore, training a model for multi-attribute text style transfer requires
datasets with sufficient support across all combinations of the considered
stylistic attributes, adding to the challenges of training a style transfer
model. This paper explores the impact of training data input diversity on the
quality of the generated text from the multi-style transfer model. We construct
a pseudo-parallel dataset by devising heuristics to adjust the style
distribution in the training samples. We balance our training dataset using
marginal and joint distributions to train our style transfer models. We observe
that a balanced dataset produces more effective control effects over multiple
styles than an imbalanced or skewed one. Through quantitative analysis, we
explore the impact of multiple style distributions in training data on
style-transferred output. These findings will better inform the design of
style-transfer datasets. | [
0.0044572963,
0.0603724793,
-0.0103280768,
0.0004007496,
-0.0220337883,
-0.0141153913,
0.0095320912,
0.0230748784,
-0.0673127249,
-0.0263511799,
-0.0644086972,
-0.0681023672,
0.0136068203,
-0.0116301049,
0.0510425791,
-0.0732716694,
-0.0177887753,
0.0077825575,
0.0153017538,
-0.017723497,
0.0636494383,
0.0297667757,
0.0117792226,
0.0043377625,
-0.0179691594,
-0.0048407344,
-0.0015630639,
0.0825725943,
0.0238549728,
0.0205521695,
0.0258694813,
0.0599550307,
-0.005756536,
-0.0418440737,
0.0000017382,
-0.0040150224,
-0.0180322193,
-0.0091784177,
0.0796019733,
0.0163594205,
0.0889187902,
-0.0029074906,
-0.0074226824,
0.0124385059,
0.0083743269,
-0.0162847638,
0.054450471,
0.0629773289,
0.0849717483,
0.0780227333,
-0.0313594677,
-0.0711894557,
-0.0227043293,
-0.034434285,
-0.0069339299,
0.032534793,
0.0048765666,
0.0051206821,
-0.0256645698,
0.0066323057,
0.0045679132,
0.0040452001,
-0.0322657786,
0.0030821268,
0.0059910193,
-0.0150479963,
-0.0559637956,
0.0460963063,
-0.0046692477,
0.0737767816,
-0.0018780894,
-0.0092120264,
0.0230187252,
-0.0208784249,
0.0386836119,
0.0180784948,
-0.0613815673,
0.0205945838,
-0.0194454119,
0.0193628725,
-0.0086576464,
0.0184700862,
-0.0073729428,
-0.0389535204,
0.0022534113,
-0.0146515956,
0.0208479092,
-0.0186442453,
-0.0313058905,
0.0278314706,
-0.0043457388,
-0.0210546404,
0.0165076833,
-0.0264411997,
0.0393223353,
0.004435529,
-0.0917275771,
-0.0798614025,
0.0107366554,
-0.0016757193,
0.0854283422,
-0.0038005407,
0.0017878425,
-0.0284357294,
-0.0198268052,
-0.0108163189,
-0.0100692064,
-0.0011213532,
-0.021690093,
0.0169529561,
-0.0653694049,
0.0010763394,
-0.0237584133,
0.0033909229,
0.0225437041,
0.0158487055,
-0.0107399477,
-0.0093701426,
-0.018722048,
-0.0635473132,
0.0543022193,
0.0122240484,
-0.051358927,
-0.001717234,
0.0301379859,
0.0365677662,
0.0012378509,
0.0526786298,
0.0261772498,
-0.0133419409,
-0.0050965901,
0.0384078696,
0.056821961,
-0.0477451794,
-0.0107558621,
0.0138222976,
-0.0441890806,
0.0193575397,
-0.0656201839,
-0.016832782,
-0.015515957,
-0.0112912282,
0.0077559613,
-0.0892907083,
0.0088500632,
-0.0053402209,
0.0053929584,
-0.0247762427,
-0.0248717442,
0.0071272603,
-0.0404645726,
0.0183755513,
0.011239036,
0.0128888264,
0.0321357995,
-0.0398996137,
0.0019895113,
0.0550191402,
0.0236315131,
0.0172907282,
0.0050553018,
-0.035501942,
-0.0179755297,
0.0231374204,
0.0440858006,
0.0693130642,
-0.0327326171,
-0.0670110658,
0.0365629569,
0.0447084606,
0.0826470554,
0.0651983097,
-0.0251750629,
0.0138242794,
0.0973458439,
-0.0446375869,
0.0692398995,
0.0204948224,
0.0520004481,
0.0008949709,
-0.0086460635,
0.0422907658,
0.0199164934,
0.0018346368,
0.0129311783,
0.0414031558,
0.0405394211,
0.0608616397,
-0.0364909172,
0.0190876368,
0.0187294465,
0.0266030841,
-0.0146662742,
-0.0684454292,
-0.012605669,
0.0501416288,
-0.0335288942,
0.004064701,
0.0184843466,
-0.0796868205,
0.013968179,
0.0054445406,
-0.0159702338,
0.0997323617,
0.0052716541,
0.0329880975,
0.0337000452,
0.0007539333,
0.0232582502,
-0.0005748706,
0.0337114967,
-0.0005471124,
0.0323841535,
-0.0688558072,
-0.0125685446,
-0.0302230008,
-0.004037865,
0.0392387658,
-0.0591853373,
0.0440955758,
0.0136229545,
-0.0117736235,
-0.0328536928,
0.0395616367,
0.0051758704,
-0.0192077439,
0.0367217995,
-0.0023765743,
-0.0026381456,
-0.013892754,
-0.0804527923,
0.0068074791,
-0.0403212868,
-0.0509807728,
-0.0087821214,
0.0509657376,
-0.0311913043,
-0.0443061404,
-0.0204464644,
-0.0665532351,
0.0276145805,
-0.0014299601,
-0.0311577842,
-0.0759238899,
-0.0087713841,
-0.0279699024,
0.0077391304,
-0.0309246071,
0.0195241868,
0.0263269097,
0.0414841659,
-0.0296564717,
0.0290611871,
0.042125728,
-0.0241968837,
-0.0168709457,
0.0024916278,
0.0059669139,
-0.0274324212,
0.0287092272,
-0.0289388932,
0.0048372527,
0.023334749,
0.0094011966,
0.0182890557,
-0.0229707323,
-0.0498762093,
-0.0337892324,
0.021918064,
-0.0161156394,
0.0356629565,
0.0321519822,
0.0085507464,
-0.0203265604,
0.0279710814,
-0.0767887086,
0.0008509105,
-0.0235567726,
0.0252401084,
0.0641606525,
-0.013325775,
-0.0147805009,
-0.0158834085,
-0.024359921,
0.0162727591,
0.0349875651,
0.0225529317,
0.0293985642,
-0.0391799137,
0.0056759808,
-0.0066777333,
-0.037657097,
0.0410620458,
-0.0428151749,
-0.0207665283,
-0.0123699866,
0.0658093765,
0.0257450957,
0.0600119047,
-0.039582435,
0.0184158236,
0.0053778305,
-0.0142310588,
-0.0123628313,
-0.0095629627,
0.0447161496,
0.0174764171,
-0.0623855591,
0.0390617326,
0.0163713284,
0.0587358922,
-0.0155251613,
-0.0689516291,
0.0063730017,
0.0458636209,
-0.0185801797,
0.0377702191,
0.0218193848,
-0.003745124,
0.0078638047,
-0.0106607052,
-0.0135677699,
0.0205689631,
-0.0230145119,
0.0205228105,
-0.0010772615,
0.0101701543,
-0.0234482512,
0.0044900933,
-0.022451058,
0.0329578742,
0.0148590896,
-0.0045871348,
-0.0627168417,
0.0127006946,
0.0917964056,
0.0092503186,
0.0070402385,
-0.0405195281,
0.0178482402,
-0.0154683637,
-0.0142159397,
0.0060999398,
-0.048560448,
0.0404838771,
-0.0119810151,
0.0611780509,
-0.0296724644,
0.0178753305,
0.0202751812,
-0.0295942631,
0.0647196174,
-0.0380043276,
-0.0120167676,
0.013970078,
0.0477716997,
0.0194756184,
-0.0208413061,
-0.0486153997,
-0.0549726039,
-0.0619355291,
-0.0172029361,
-0.0061206417,
0.0464665033,
-0.0195655599,
0.0058892863,
0.0239268094,
-0.0245041009,
-0.0646841824,
-0.0061726146,
0.0871458128,
-0.0180054307,
-0.0022512646,
0.0714456812,
0.0085427221,
-0.0282180477,
-0.0177914146,
0.0054056509,
0.0619966537,
-0.020983465,
0.0264990367,
-0.0696816072,
-0.0109851798,
-0.0335854515,
0.0242332444,
-0.0083109392,
-0.0068717222,
-0.0165277757,
-0.0904548168,
0.0063235741,
0.0259805713,
-0.0815583766,
-0.028554894,
-0.000490855,
-0.0001818043,
-0.0031958169,
-0.0056563155,
-0.009042494,
-0.026979696,
0.0090907561,
0.0507418811,
-0.0182948634,
-0.0707482547,
-0.0414507017,
-0.0313392766,
0.0451511182,
0.0533772931,
0.0320279412,
-0.0309927203,
-0.069360584,
-0.0303320065,
-0.031955298,
-0.004805021,
-0.0031920657,
0.061541643,
0.0015637819,
-0.0040178811,
-0.0030183848,
0.0309188887,
-0.0039813924,
0.0258042775,
0.0322862342,
-0.0097557548,
-0.0123090427,
-0.0596932955,
-0.0238736439,
-0.0002952019,
0.0500501134,
0.0314878598,
0.048575405,
-0.0494817272,
-0.0191169307,
-0.0542365424,
0.0028822494,
-0.0976198092,
0.0121873906,
0.0230410174,
-0.0603026412,
-0.0374141894,
-0.1337690502,
0.0104628569,
-0.0483223572,
0.077370204,
0.0274776425,
-0.0258410797,
-0.0537807085,
-0.0010433756,
-0.0113452608,
-0.0305436086,
-0.0008959529,
0.0249762349,
-0.0031360842,
-0.0452367514,
-0.0081391707,
-0.0591912791,
0.0154767707,
0.0021694929,
-0.0645297095,
-0.0659003109,
-0.0101826172,
0.0445295759,
0.0070070955,
0.0276464429,
0.0076523214,
-0.0713785812,
0.0287359785,
0.0828144997,
0.0420212783,
0.0131108155,
0.0217071269,
-0.042176988,
0.0137743801,
0.0174464434,
-0.0054316651,
0.0435527675,
0.018781485,
0.0240274556,
0.0273020603,
-0.034292195,
0.0014807399,
0.0203019958,
-0.0509842783,
-0.0231220406,
0.0248464849,
-0.0057079722,
0.0013496493,
-0.0436345041,
0.001365331,
-0.0547374822,
-0.0136702219,
0.0313721895,
0.048082158,
-0.0172020942,
-0.0180749279,
0.0402961932,
0.0427260473,
-0.0720157474,
-0.0073590139,
0.0081944345,
0.0549039803,
-0.0122349672,
0.0266433246,
-0.004416435,
0.0040885089,
-0.0083398428,
0.0128445411,
-0.0068314015,
0.014263426,
0.0482188724,
0.0260851067,
-0.007605759,
0.0062831552,
-0.0541896112,
0.0190831032,
-0.0401851386,
-0.0378759988,
0.0219417159,
-0.0297303274,
0.0972613022,
-0.0032123832,
0.0207313485,
-0.0216487329,
0.0683123618,
0.0104018664,
0.0110391648,
-0.0092596682,
-0.0067341067,
-0.0125283543,
-0.0583156385,
0.0852683708,
-0.0014891851,
0.0068137618,
-0.0555273965,
-0.0128871789,
0.0056007891,
0.0018707871,
0.0411403105,
-0.0117923515,
0.0502342209,
-0.0368982442,
-0.0066701509,
-0.0367811061,
0.0172742922,
-0.0270249322,
0.0594152287,
0.0020070006,
0.03446839,
0.0496759973,
-0.0275626928,
0.0197548438,
-0.0331321806,
-0.0035325487,
0.0167713035,
0.0338846408,
-0.0044643767,
-5.551378968e-33,
-0.0292697027,
0.0224488284,
-0.0411365069,
0.020908786,
-0.0425001048,
-0.0392138027,
-0.0293552037,
-0.0382554047,
0.0026726737,
0.0250214115,
-0.0317757092,
-0.0116639389,
0.0140750296,
0.032490395,
0.0511654951,
0.0523724183,
0.0556733273,
0.0110874632,
-0.0584537387,
0.0316667818,
0.0630062893,
0.0228502471,
0.078089647,
-0.0455508158,
-0.0289466456,
-0.0169781521,
-0.0172591507,
-0.044047229,
0.0446203798,
-0.008419442,
0.0384465866,
0.0460107699,
0.0132907359,
-0.0549352691,
-0.0377765074,
-0.0076643522,
-0.006374774,
-0.0445915498,
0.0219572317,
0.0148640834,
0.0259958934,
-0.0475816503,
0.0503304973,
-0.0151489694,
0.021304084,
-0.0293874312,
0.0662220046,
-0.023954194,
-0.0232510623,
-0.0863421038,
-0.0343812965,
0.0229360387,
-0.0067929197,
-0.0068382379,
-0.009980469,
0.0099285096,
-0.0151056089,
-0.0216703862,
-0.0208064783,
0.0270629022,
-0.0194888767,
0.0127382111,
0.0112298531,
0.0419582017,
0.0081347506,
0.0193326101,
-0.0293126926,
0.0927470028,
-0.0410555042,
0.0061543393,
0.0173381716,
0.0316959359,
-0.0051981099,
0.0888722688,
0.0128336018,
-0.040627338,
-0.0062817615,
0.0495659001,
0.0402624905,
-0.0521678589,
-0.0076943692,
0.0297440067,
0.0002007982,
-0.0242308546,
-0.0362923965,
-0.0373891518,
0.0097865937,
-0.0084035983,
-0.0015226017,
-0.0110077951,
-0.0257571694,
0.0324774794,
0.0207133908,
0.0079270788,
-0.0765324458,
-0.008513513,
-0.0819412023,
0.0413776636,
-0.0409065075,
-0.0475583896,
-0.0173595361,
-0.0418448523,
0.0611822903,
0.0461744815,
0.0134496558,
0.0068450146,
0.0718623027,
0.0406206809,
-0.0721956044,
-0.0309980009,
-0.0019178749,
0.0150860082,
0.0303243734,
-0.0127980774,
0.004715276,
-0.0082382997,
-0.0158494413,
0.0201990474,
0.034437798,
-0.0122974515,
0.0001025111,
-0.0387560241,
0.0131384823,
0.0133724799,
-0.0491843335,
-0.003037625,
-0.0193689112,
-0.0845025629,
0.0292877499,
-0.034106601,
-0.0495787375,
-0.0358371995,
2.48e-7,
0.0275385976,
-0.007133753,
0.0309753809,
0.0113895955,
0.0139740845,
0.0158556011,
-0.0026280636,
0.085797675,
-0.0071963393,
-0.0033870914,
0.020146355,
0.018634025,
0.0530302525,
-0.0009850139,
-0.0627717599,
-0.0240714625,
-0.053370811,
0.0358122289,
-0.0300747324,
-0.0275024921,
0.0611027405,
0.0075847222,
-0.0036755386,
-0.030105304,
0.0430199914,
0.0283847153,
0.0757702291,
-0.0002683513,
0.0235791132,
0.0204596426,
0.0464563854,
-0.0905135646,
-0.0304632783,
0.0534411184,
-0.0280778781,
-0.0283538941,
0.0410055183,
0.0484977812,
-0.0053220079,
0.0530471094,
0.0356418043,
0.0210315362,
-0.0145571232,
-0.0270623025,
0.0379466824,
0.022755228,
-0.0218940098,
-0.0498998724,
-0.0636861622,
0.0234538149,
0.0132311005,
-0.0036056966,
-0.0049381764,
0.034247987,
0.014674834,
0.0266117528,
-0.0207830649,
-0.0309343785,
-0.0411314778,
-0.0061782291,
-0.0149111599,
-0.0366937518,
-0.0246476289,
0.0100571793,
0.0208312795,
-0.0452699475,
0.0092664668,
2.024543359e-34,
0.0225057378,
-0.0372365899,
0.0408598222,
0.0086788367,
0.0057769925,
-0.0168784913,
0.0120175248,
0.0235866904,
0.0035729252,
-0.0459874347,
-0.0120119555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15542v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15542v2 | TOAST: Transfer Learning via Attention Steering | 2023-05-24T20:03:04 | 2023-07-11T17:57:06 | Baifeng Shi, Siyu Gai, Trevor Darrell, Xin Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Transfer learning involves adapting a pre-trained model to novel downstream
tasks. However, we observe that current transfer learning methods often fail to
focus on task-relevant features. In this work, we explore refocusing model
attention for transfer learning. We introduce Top-Down Attention Steering
(TOAST), a novel transfer learning algorithm that keeps the pre-trained
backbone frozen, selects task-relevant features in the output, and feeds those
features back to the model to steer the attention to the task-specific
features. By refocusing the attention only, TOAST achieves state-of-the-art
results on a number of transfer learning benchmarks, while having a small
number of tunable parameters. Compared to fully fine-tuning, LoRA, and prompt
tuning, TOAST substantially improves performance across a range of fine-grained
visual classification datasets (e.g., 81.1% -> 86.2% on FGVC). TOAST also
outperforms the fully fine-tuned Alpaca and Vicuna models on
instruction-following language generation. Code is available at
https://github.com/bfshi/TOAST. | [
-0.0011555511,
0.0330605507,
-0.0040906677,
0.0206036642,
0.0416878201,
0.0136067541,
0.0003483037,
-0.0506524183,
-0.0006077391,
-0.0400492474,
-0.0805257559,
0.0046718586,
-0.0117794946,
0.0645619631,
0.0277099796,
-0.078127332,
0.050031364,
-0.01384468,
-0.0087243943,
0.0453850292,
-0.0242326055,
0.0366405845,
0.0161266234,
0.0296572596,
0.0123802368,
-0.0046312972,
-0.0048242314,
0.053134121,
0.0493573472,
-0.0021775141,
0.0389427692,
0.0309852287,
0.0070003206,
-0.0193633772,
0.0000023442,
-0.0152145689,
-0.0259052143,
-0.0430918261,
-0.0098354574,
-0.0175625123,
0.0529996119,
-0.0001577031,
-0.009650927,
0.0103719598,
-0.015457768,
-0.0007463991,
0.063789323,
0.0360913724,
0.053533718,
0.0747990459,
-0.034028925,
-0.0046096374,
0.0000307706,
-0.0236447733,
0.0248671696,
-0.0513649844,
0.0087543586,
-0.0095773265,
-0.0388145298,
-0.0086485595,
-0.0149568021,
0.0304185264,
0.0300102271,
-0.0038877972,
0.0443308018,
0.0122966869,
-0.0431905091,
-0.0190908406,
-0.0366650596,
0.1117478311,
-0.0830047503,
-0.0069201263,
-0.0137635479,
-0.0311371647,
0.0411258154,
-0.03044427,
-0.0268907659,
-0.0252562221,
0.0269171968,
0.0377180241,
-0.0113017298,
0.0193774477,
0.0107176704,
-0.0199838895,
-0.0220842734,
0.0074226623,
0.0228657294,
0.0298623536,
0.0364639983,
0.0478254408,
-0.0258654244,
-0.032342419,
-0.0089221839,
0.0360824913,
-0.0195375886,
-0.0074723912,
-0.1039443687,
-0.0245120563,
-0.0339445807,
-0.0115195187,
0.0907474086,
0.0233324189,
-0.0731198788,
0.0243084263,
-0.0574736558,
0.0160322338,
-0.0206798147,
0.0457153395,
-0.0448947959,
0.0146806231,
-0.0529573001,
0.029551845,
-0.0656497031,
0.0143992435,
-0.0271581151,
-0.034472324,
-0.0109081389,
0.0331931077,
-0.0128840022,
-0.0312823094,
0.0170118734,
0.0322633199,
-0.0625147223,
-0.0100985924,
0.0148976352,
0.0570102558,
-0.0195949301,
0.0422019772,
0.0466791317,
-0.0367581062,
-0.0252444819,
0.0508471914,
-0.0054660495,
-0.0392843857,
0.0326674618,
0.0333482958,
-0.0430652723,
-0.0104917483,
-0.0324230082,
0.0002407693,
-0.0078620249,
-0.0529509671,
0.0686351806,
-0.0036813507,
0.0041907313,
-0.015658075,
0.0139846243,
-0.0248658471,
-0.0102136219,
0.0104767596,
-0.0191713404,
0.0420662351,
0.0257328954,
-0.0261908155,
-0.0044854046,
0.0010385112,
-0.0302131921,
0.0372548588,
0.0267368965,
0.0817140713,
-0.0209622178,
-0.0457801446,
-0.0008754007,
0.0221359376,
0.0453417376,
0.0177182704,
-0.0164528377,
-0.0110406857,
0.0006496547,
-0.0036959925,
0.052997414,
-0.0056358138,
0.0189232659,
0.0217789523,
0.0622402057,
0.004968957,
0.001541073,
0.0186678413,
0.0627912283,
0.0162354279,
-0.0153279575,
-0.0063010929,
-0.0664298683,
0.083626546,
-0.0011506695,
-0.0178348348,
-0.0153972385,
0.051335901,
-0.0534330271,
-0.0080492664,
0.0648211911,
-0.0074673649,
-0.0158287045,
0.0272067375,
0.0312726423,
0.0493874289,
-0.0597069077,
0.0288235079,
0.0252224971,
-0.0222729463,
0.0127802053,
-0.0745981336,
0.0255863518,
0.0358290821,
-0.0144464392,
-0.0017500016,
-0.0559200197,
-0.001919989,
0.0661887974,
-0.0036241331,
0.0297682378,
0.0136858709,
0.027823424,
-0.0482823029,
-0.0367788151,
-0.0452229045,
0.018180063,
0.0051181857,
-0.017449094,
0.0365127847,
0.006055831,
-0.0172505099,
-0.010371319,
0.0515374094,
-0.0037873925,
-0.0225918014,
0.0224315412,
0.0227200035,
0.0057796123,
-0.0350950956,
0.0184216537,
-0.0088062575,
0.0083657568,
-0.0414521061,
0.0539012104,
-0.002596861,
-0.0480500609,
-0.0106690302,
-0.0186129548,
-0.0183094405,
-0.0018457115,
0.037771754,
-0.0540927015,
-0.0139624951,
0.0256595556,
0.0056649847,
0.0053764032,
0.0192217492,
0.0338859074,
0.0112258075,
0.0469540358,
-0.029471077,
0.0240328237,
0.0246968903,
-0.0392386615,
0.0071749878,
-0.0150206499,
0.0071596606,
-0.0139044328,
0.0351217128,
-0.0096004754,
-0.0310030598,
-0.0126977954,
-0.0204101559,
0.0490180254,
-0.0487277806,
-0.0287660845,
-0.0534797907,
0.0284747314,
-0.0185416825,
0.0229089297,
0.027084332,
0.0013040155,
-0.0002694318,
-0.0263255555,
-0.0445438288,
0.0510769114,
-0.0297385249,
-0.0112968776,
0.0038599863,
-0.0246094633,
0.033157263,
-0.0536097549,
0.0017928302,
0.0312270373,
0.0231209062,
-0.0185757745,
-0.0098916367,
-0.032702677,
0.0029989935,
0.0094477544,
0.0005681154,
0.0023433757,
-0.0138922324,
-0.0098560667,
-0.031914331,
0.0006699269,
0.0933109373,
0.0162723232,
0.0186752453,
0.0238157585,
-0.0137823494,
-0.0298634414,
0.0194355231,
-0.008965387,
0.0042091357,
-0.0309222881,
0.0103749223,
0.0255688298,
0.0555158332,
-0.0259801708,
-0.0113900639,
-0.0906790718,
0.0199714769,
0.0129164886,
-0.0128697222,
-0.0178938899,
0.0722075403,
-0.0023235977,
-0.0194166023,
-0.0633963943,
-0.0426578671,
0.0461284257,
-0.0000344949,
-0.0166697372,
-0.0155603848,
0.014682807,
-0.0158604402,
0.0037192602,
0.0085955989,
0.0070251664,
0.0101275388,
-0.029408209,
-0.0506348982,
0.0016200964,
-0.01012831,
-0.0123969344,
0.0567839369,
-0.0290974956,
-0.0183985084,
-0.0452004187,
0.0109915091,
-0.0277035087,
-0.0145355128,
0.0047110296,
0.0092432359,
0.0192414839,
-0.0226934273,
-0.0651624426,
-0.0226670112,
-0.0014832141,
0.0547889695,
-0.0122058196,
-0.0166161656,
-0.0364619456,
0.0124679506,
0.0568090566,
0.0123303803,
-0.0039640693,
-0.0529464148,
0.0036024773,
0.0397421606,
0.033364851,
-0.0212223232,
-0.0427979566,
0.0506710224,
0.0400146283,
0.0284308624,
-0.0068452763,
0.0411039554,
0.1064182892,
-0.0640302971,
-0.0328797698,
0.0684386715,
-0.01678738,
-0.040875636,
-0.023140192,
0.0157981627,
0.0487609431,
0.0178957414,
0.0483275205,
-0.0280797854,
-0.0849349871,
-0.0180320218,
0.0420583673,
0.0462675989,
0.0084559657,
-0.0420903787,
-0.0495487377,
0.0624894872,
0.0107629225,
-0.0612773746,
-0.0353186466,
-0.0053148498,
0.0090358779,
-0.0055681411,
-0.0136775002,
-0.040532954,
-0.0499080047,
0.0019855383,
0.0285406802,
0.023955835,
-0.032382369,
0.0325427316,
-0.0082188481,
0.0068050055,
0.0919620544,
0.0154065862,
0.008053977,
-0.0491233654,
0.0199999698,
-0.008524809,
0.0029044291,
0.0096680811,
0.0733717903,
-0.021907635,
-0.0365618803,
0.0148825441,
0.0257197861,
-0.0489642285,
-0.0044237184,
0.0286492631,
0.0549561642,
-0.0013739626,
-0.0603233054,
-0.0222464446,
-0.0332292914,
0.0220701899,
0.0446078144,
0.0482847691,
-0.0615112744,
-0.0397378504,
-0.0156407673,
-0.0218266491,
-0.0592065901,
-0.0411187112,
0.0015318338,
-0.0454032905,
-0.0283879507,
-0.0738755018,
-0.0437104553,
0.0577463061,
0.0460568815,
0.0127986865,
-0.0370616242,
0.0037427975,
-0.0204299707,
-0.0249841716,
0.0617928393,
-0.0444038361,
0.0132396771,
-0.1029124036,
-0.0473394729,
-0.0040129567,
-0.06032525,
0.0063845888,
0.0183148663,
-0.0682022646,
-0.0313828215,
-0.0128905,
0.0899349749,
0.0075935614,
0.0394275673,
-0.028516015,
-0.0110419905,
0.0315387547,
0.0326082557,
0.0014580759,
0.008304907,
0.0613987446,
-0.0777505562,
-0.0175528917,
0.0203882549,
-0.0343934968,
0.0616089739,
0.0287912339,
-0.0045515988,
0.0062527894,
-0.0071675261,
0.0032590064,
-0.0156928133,
0.0526611991,
0.0035892746,
-0.0049451971,
-0.0239929501,
-0.0109573249,
0.0386510603,
-0.0002210688,
-0.0998762995,
-0.0273236074,
0.0230813231,
-0.0123932557,
0.0192677472,
0.0043375152,
0.0003824348,
0.0079809278,
-0.0792895406,
-0.0020137792,
-0.0251714922,
0.0757236108,
0.0233208705,
0.0180147793,
0.0031743818,
-0.0052249045,
0.0363845564,
0.0470616445,
-0.0242338255,
0.03832734,
0.0025048922,
0.0229775626,
-0.0323965885,
0.0513801612,
-0.0215136632,
-0.0552348569,
-0.0784070268,
-0.0054364898,
0.0253290515,
-0.0368349887,
0.0972859189,
0.0344772637,
-0.0053975866,
-0.0367461964,
0.0486883,
-0.0021444184,
-0.0155844213,
-0.0018239856,
-0.0235723685,
0.0287551507,
-0.0092930766,
0.0616478175,
-0.0209399108,
0.0467342809,
-0.0030095691,
0.0240615159,
-0.0366880447,
-0.0136163598,
0.0491338558,
-0.0330587886,
0.0180135258,
0.0556518249,
0.0112978742,
-0.045938313,
-0.0051618111,
-0.072026521,
-0.0084314784,
0.0048724762,
0.0476183146,
0.0129273245,
-0.0363220163,
-0.0359528959,
-0.0303349011,
-0.0244007576,
0.0112398639,
0.0179319549,
0.0123410206,
-7.017846007e-33,
-0.051237274,
0.0149973659,
0.0315170996,
0.00741731,
-0.0112739978,
-0.0103756245,
-0.0687339976,
-0.0111008259,
-0.0363284424,
0.034915451,
0.0202173721,
-0.0078661963,
0.0295689702,
0.0580089204,
0.0030512258,
-0.0154147269,
0.0552641675,
-0.0022633963,
-0.0227077473,
0.0832261816,
0.0147469761,
0.0334531814,
0.0570067577,
-0.0575148687,
-0.0460215025,
0.0425825901,
-0.0197689515,
-0.0190121885,
-0.00054793,
0.0146528659,
0.0140841631,
0.0096918838,
0.0056074262,
-0.0444439836,
-0.0656601265,
0.0254477896,
-0.0389341787,
-0.0483430251,
-0.0293528736,
0.0038656639,
-0.0562223829,
-0.0435295328,
0.0322994627,
0.0141547183,
0.0464577973,
-0.0624853931,
0.0450869799,
-0.0369199067,
-0.0329740904,
-0.006632877,
-0.0944015756,
-0.019128656,
-0.010578868,
-0.0628326163,
0.0382161513,
0.0839351565,
-0.0208074357,
-0.0059641092,
-0.0247064494,
0.0090574846,
-0.0088536534,
0.037042886,
0.0646908358,
0.0682743341,
-0.0233630259,
0.0198410116,
0.0225059688,
-0.0140869142,
0.0098084081,
0.0117903594,
0.0411209166,
0.1079882234,
0.0064793085,
-0.0130766621,
0.0193250142,
-0.0032240802,
-0.0573252924,
0.033397641,
-0.0060994499,
0.0233885273,
0.0045229839,
-0.0165172443,
0.0074116988,
-0.0059722564,
0.0008296817,
-0.0094497334,
-0.0109925829,
-0.0085689742,
0.0579859652,
0.0190472957,
-0.0209042765,
-0.0112432055,
0.0580514483,
-0.0085737817,
0.0322490521,
0.0149929309,
-0.0510513186,
0.0068657189,
-0.0049633244,
-0.0086794859,
-0.0609123111,
-0.0625415742,
0.0641413257,
-0.0271073561,
0.0372168459,
0.0358362868,
0.0490778983,
0.0303267259,
-0.0353379995,
-0.0075866939,
-0.0450787321,
0.0530044325,
0.0365753807,
0.0837463066,
-0.0030450861,
-0.0359523445,
-0.0400907211,
0.081118077,
-0.0396784693,
-0.017669389,
-0.0011555043,
-0.0093097594,
0.0292349719,
0.0361429565,
-0.0499196351,
0.0052718902,
-0.0769295245,
-0.009195812,
-0.0034381622,
-0.0684453994,
-0.0327669829,
0.0160894766,
3.016e-7,
0.0053960844,
0.0176631361,
-0.0201475993,
-0.0234174952,
-0.0162157714,
0.0589053109,
-0.0122582037,
0.04689347,
0.0442535952,
0.0028578455,
-0.0050070677,
0.0462389216,
0.0852767602,
0.0064043212,
-0.0303234607,
-0.0053312746,
-0.0195811484,
0.0485391654,
-0.0054121949,
-0.0295058005,
0.0054959608,
0.0687234029,
0.0005622748,
-0.0266266223,
0.0752071813,
0.0009838073,
0.0498337708,
-0.0173184834,
0.0270019937,
-0.0031964376,
-0.0026081281,
0.0238535665,
-0.0621780381,
0.0004679049,
-0.0441686325,
-0.0015516013,
-0.0052243769,
0.0533581488,
-0.0105359182,
-0.0494969152,
-0.0050418121,
0.0329158977,
0.0332419276,
-0.0128354942,
0.0600323118,
-0.1034107804,
-0.0161543079,
-0.0267029013,
-0.0306117125,
0.0108608287,
0.0114129474,
-0.0120863281,
0.0334229097,
-0.0221674722,
0.047321137,
-0.0076488485,
-0.0812262148,
-0.0711977929,
-0.0138101866,
0.0133555271,
-0.0270762034,
0.0052684662,
-0.0704230368,
0.0031373096,
0.0082625514,
-0.0344298296,
0.0074249487,
2.578463159e-34,
-0.0182748213,
-0.0311446227,
0.0446729399,
0.0014628004,
-0.0130873676,
0.0149550634,
-0.0098525733,
-0.0144942645,
0.0265779532,
-0.0450297929,
-0.0160079747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15541v1 | Harnessing the Power of Large Language Models for Natural Language to First-Order Logic Translation | 2023-05-24T19:59:51 | 2023-05-24T19:59:51 | Yuan Yang, Siheng Xiong, Ali Payani, Ehsan Shareghi, Faramarz Fekri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Translating natural language sentences to first-order logic (NL-FOL
translation) is a longstanding challenge in the NLP and formal logic
literature. This paper introduces LogicLLaMA, a LLaMA-7B model fine-tuned for
NL-FOL translation using LoRA on a single GPU. LogicLLaMA is capable of
directly translating natural language into FOL rules, which outperforms
GPT-3.5. LogicLLaMA is also equipped to correct FOL rules predicted by GPT-3.5,
and can achieve similar performance as GPT-4 with a fraction of the cost. This
correction ability was achieved by a novel supervised fine-tuning (SFT) +
reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) framework, which initially
trains on synthetically perturbed NL-FOL pairs to encourage chain-of-thought
reasoning and then fine-tunes with RLHF on GPT-3.5 outputs using a FOL verifier
as the reward model.
To train LogicLLaMA, we present MALLS (large language $\textbf{M}$odel
gener$\textbf{A}$ted N$\textbf{L}$-FO$\textbf{L}$ pair$\textbf{S}$), a dataset
of 34K high-quality and diverse sentence-level NL-FOL pairs collected from
GPT-4. The dataset was created by implementing a pipeline that prompts GPT-4
for pairs, and dynamically adjusts the prompts to ensure the collection of
pairs with rich and diverse contexts at different levels of complexity, and
verifies the validity of the generated FOL rules. Codes, weights, and data are
available at $\href{https://github.com/gblackout/LogicLLaMA}{{\small
\text{https://github.com/gblackout/LogicLLaMA}}}$. | [
0.0605618805,
0.0563763194,
-0.0243719295,
0.0318129286,
-0.0559092723,
0.0044846209,
-0.0151413959,
0.0054154256,
0.0386178382,
-0.0385136567,
-0.0210708193,
0.0196340289,
0.0002168015,
0.0565733798,
0.0203680508,
-0.0514675006,
0.031089263,
-0.0356281325,
0.0422103107,
0.0005476389,
0.0083458181,
0.0392154455,
0.0136928167,
0.0107290437,
-0.0064205145,
-0.0144678419,
-0.0161253549,
0.0285640527,
0.0337088071,
-0.0157196224,
-0.010438446,
0.0442708284,
0.0110229207,
0.0305622388,
0.0000025418,
-0.0571464188,
-0.0324410796,
0.0004251954,
0.0204247907,
-0.0038279351,
0.0356920511,
-0.024682058,
-0.0179006532,
0.0204576496,
-0.050407812,
-0.0168783069,
0.0273363572,
0.0555076972,
0.0634299666,
0.0928017125,
-0.0051774797,
-0.0601576157,
0.0540411882,
-0.0512882508,
0.0017906139,
-0.0608178303,
0.0116111655,
0.0293235406,
-0.0042949654,
-0.0231151655,
-0.017045768,
0.0270093698,
0.0463344827,
-0.0195139572,
-0.0402519144,
0.0139839603,
-0.0240971781,
-0.0074295914,
-0.0131683564,
0.0749689639,
-0.032102868,
-0.0272732954,
-0.01058177,
-0.0105040185,
-0.0070082764,
-0.0378002077,
-0.000008717,
0.0425977856,
-0.0304302443,
0.0355655625,
0.081840463,
-0.0310540069,
0.0249621999,
0.001738744,
-0.0546323396,
0.0770981759,
0.00863434,
-0.0439149477,
0.0166655369,
0.0024193148,
-0.0288155768,
-0.045816958,
0.0261609554,
0.0146679049,
-0.0499594212,
0.0031714074,
-0.044817932,
-0.0100519247,
0.02664751,
-0.0334989578,
0.0364434272,
0.0472984128,
0.0219040848,
0.0258731898,
-0.0483894944,
0.0447920486,
-0.0400306359,
0.0732517987,
-0.0369404592,
-0.0162582584,
-0.0418784469,
0.0137118557,
-0.0307931919,
0.0304648485,
-0.087673679,
-0.0031533951,
-0.0298752189,
0.0095165763,
0.0016518565,
0.0370572358,
-0.0087414188,
-0.0272068772,
-0.0039064111,
-0.0445461012,
-0.0552363992,
0.0438788682,
-0.0477746464,
0.0389615521,
0.0197093915,
-0.04734198,
-0.0062374189,
-0.0134178801,
0.0001746621,
-0.0269249752,
0.0438129008,
0.0789916515,
-0.001385456,
-0.0142040346,
-0.0534113683,
-0.0308579467,
0.01975815,
-0.0859816298,
0.0015275329,
-0.0675231069,
0.0241485517,
-0.0166983716,
0.0109199649,
-0.0271900427,
0.0077046989,
0.0566926524,
-0.0156188924,
0.0827273205,
-0.0298832338,
-0.0215879064,
-0.0290444363,
-0.0314093493,
0.001666022,
0.0552914478,
0.0467530116,
0.0405943692,
-0.0037457207,
0.0091250623,
-0.0249110591,
0.0255934373,
0.0277077481,
0.0010782602,
-0.0136837158,
0.0429331064,
-0.0155754667,
0.0609642193,
0.0436014049,
0.0507722758,
-0.0321340784,
0.0432675816,
0.0396819673,
0.0071467012,
0.0337238237,
0.0209574029,
0.040324498,
0.0116953524,
-0.0011213265,
-0.0332213417,
-0.0751348361,
0.0371478386,
-0.0304496307,
0.0037044538,
0.0041400525,
0.0708356872,
0.0232296009,
-0.0626327395,
0.015518737,
-0.0084118424,
0.0081473766,
0.0152424444,
0.0141437957,
0.0375118107,
-0.0613251701,
0.0232643653,
0.0141859753,
-0.033699397,
-0.0492963977,
-0.0464256927,
0.0250491872,
0.0513213575,
0.0322380103,
-0.0074374895,
-0.0385962874,
-0.0333669446,
-0.0392215252,
0.0508373715,
0.0154881878,
0.0247154906,
-0.0291720089,
-0.0503297299,
0.0094216755,
0.0165937115,
0.0158813484,
0.0257936325,
0.0257132389,
0.0110513885,
0.0172965471,
0.0137174111,
-0.0226911642,
0.0281415451,
0.0248771217,
0.002619534,
0.0319571421,
0.008155263,
0.0461494066,
-0.008474689,
0.0143097984,
0.009238651,
0.0022711842,
-0.0296727791,
-0.0344276875,
-0.019902546,
-0.0384256952,
-0.0377199613,
0.0455347486,
-0.0014183521,
-0.021982329,
0.0295713805,
-0.0850227028,
-0.0093566468,
-0.0153440526,
-0.0122568468,
0.0177617427,
-0.039390713,
-0.018789079,
0.0434444882,
0.0016795637,
-0.0446606502,
0.0623660237,
-0.0002711159,
-0.0343267769,
-0.0142415091,
-0.0118399374,
0.0260654669,
-0.0410962179,
0.0549388304,
0.0142290285,
-0.0068186647,
0.0313031524,
0.0145403203,
0.1014747918,
-0.0482410006,
-0.059564881,
-0.0334002636,
0.043458242,
-0.0053892573,
0.0153428586,
0.0192093905,
-0.0040372629,
-0.0246241186,
-0.0033904456,
-0.0249375328,
0.0144560011,
0.0195061974,
-0.0081800558,
0.0361133479,
-0.0118065486,
-0.0345456302,
-0.0306489021,
-0.0077598863,
-0.0411032252,
0.0055735605,
0.00015671,
0.0248058476,
-0.0295453891,
0.0110873124,
-0.0227586478,
0.0190036688,
0.0073331152,
-0.0171636026,
0.0051327357,
-0.0196572579,
0.0377004296,
0.0748751983,
-0.0301198922,
-0.0222710352,
0.0395002738,
-0.0162358712,
-0.0313458331,
0.0596929975,
0.0019174926,
-0.0582366027,
-0.0505304523,
0.0175353847,
0.0172848329,
0.0130924219,
0.0042699985,
-0.0038306315,
-0.0763002411,
0.038959872,
-0.0184209216,
-0.0201496724,
0.0266950652,
0.0274820346,
0.0042757853,
0.0566709265,
-0.0123630017,
-0.022861395,
0.0498797297,
-0.0095782718,
0.0134596806,
-0.0766697377,
0.0103652747,
-0.0682511777,
0.0355539173,
0.0042540152,
0.0062411004,
-0.0095225722,
-0.0098042507,
-0.0037764797,
-0.0455015674,
0.0020968388,
-0.022209065,
0.0656688884,
-0.0580838583,
0.0089825261,
-0.0337015986,
-0.0552576557,
-0.0101723932,
0.0084627056,
-0.0572261102,
-0.0223317351,
-0.0219049007,
-0.0161097329,
-0.0114589585,
-0.0383416303,
0.0021391651,
0.0292006657,
-0.0285963509,
-0.0252212267,
-0.0461791568,
0.0341133811,
0.0457466356,
0.0050407206,
0.0005288086,
-0.0051903641,
-0.016459411,
0.0194792915,
-0.0093182968,
-0.0184940882,
-0.0432771333,
0.0446562208,
0.010990981,
-0.0029059467,
-0.0194476191,
0.0418973006,
0.0333336927,
-0.0863131508,
-0.0019216813,
0.1128475294,
0.0060559623,
-0.028298011,
-0.0230865031,
-0.0109737609,
0.0496517383,
0.0155256335,
0.0696632937,
-0.0748533681,
-0.0490450375,
0.021998506,
0.0039626537,
0.0024983375,
-0.0156331006,
-0.0124343559,
-0.1142920256,
0.0540572405,
0.0176824965,
-0.0241324641,
-0.0761951879,
-0.0425145105,
-0.0130690644,
-0.02404554,
-0.0027124472,
0.0097416835,
-0.0182042494,
0.0167041551,
-0.0240821559,
0.0336817801,
0.0332233608,
0.0510283336,
-0.0252515264,
0.0553871877,
0.0758741274,
0.0408615209,
-0.0116771087,
-0.0533195212,
-0.0146421045,
0.0251918528,
-0.008320746,
-0.0358005315,
0.002335402,
0.0004879359,
-0.0117199812,
-0.0415161736,
0.0588535592,
-0.0467162393,
-0.0180434249,
0.0179021712,
0.0794180557,
0.0221708193,
-0.0149253616,
-0.0207057912,
0.0043369858,
-0.0376581065,
0.0294852797,
0.0179307647,
-0.020648839,
-0.0448885821,
-0.0561270937,
-0.0527499206,
-0.0553290881,
-0.051021453,
-0.0161380302,
0.0238679238,
0.0335267559,
-0.0325422697,
-0.0454098433,
0.0233404953,
0.0299918596,
-0.0017211126,
0.0058589997,
0.0104533937,
-0.012497575,
-0.0040192194,
0.0296872985,
-0.063803196,
0.0379502028,
-0.0404654704,
0.0489491709,
0.0087643228,
-0.0180160087,
-0.0317260139,
0.0897349641,
-0.0363907032,
-0.0294343792,
-0.0224944148,
0.0689036697,
0.0216650143,
0.0280284192,
-0.0156118367,
0.0086317807,
0.0151455998,
0.0591335222,
-0.0350612476,
0.0083714016,
0.0441782549,
0.0056826044,
0.016837988,
0.0597712733,
0.0056565604,
0.0143448729,
0.0107739642,
0.0727954581,
0.0286817551,
-0.0342301801,
0.0619088523,
0.051967755,
0.0207225028,
-0.0070086722,
-0.0459373295,
-0.003362545,
0.0414106138,
-0.0297961216,
-0.0155808162,
-0.0272085164,
0.0073162564,
0.0467538647,
-0.0144320047,
-0.005706579,
-0.0917723775,
0.029700378,
0.0149567127,
0.0046997522,
-0.0213231537,
0.0207614023,
0.0360269323,
0.0106378971,
-0.0196781289,
-0.0086985044,
-0.0184577741,
0.0005190198,
0.0565360151,
-0.0459480584,
0.0604339615,
0.0482399203,
-0.0056677563,
-0.0639343038,
0.0364722684,
-0.0125644999,
-0.0600426309,
-0.0033166085,
-0.014303701,
0.0891666561,
0.0179321561,
0.069204554,
-0.0327897295,
-0.0128249191,
0.0140993875,
0.052958101,
0.0090126581,
-0.0236462131,
0.0045571011,
-0.0103880502,
-0.0140031818,
-0.0391046964,
0.0277302936,
0.0002524656,
0.0498544089,
0.0354828052,
0.0195231792,
-0.0429789461,
-0.035921447,
-0.0300306417,
-0.01903609,
0.0071497071,
-0.0252736099,
-0.0482706316,
-0.0648253858,
0.0209172666,
0.0286824163,
-0.0043612937,
-0.0018164163,
0.0355370268,
0.0612590685,
0.0062432736,
-0.0760003328,
-0.028456809,
0.0110896369,
0.0183575954,
-0.0423916616,
-0.0271772817,
-7.202172338e-33,
-0.048748102,
0.007455478,
0.0624008402,
0.0125770131,
-0.0302521996,
-0.0309639219,
-0.0430080853,
-0.0345887206,
-0.0203760341,
0.0459364206,
-0.0213212892,
-0.0123225953,
0.0106505807,
0.0081265811,
0.0126490677,
0.0031406893,
0.0177059826,
0.0194631144,
-0.0067165443,
0.0294991191,
-0.0015889916,
0.0109448442,
0.0584198534,
-0.0761532858,
-0.0107041253,
0.0548976064,
-0.0443969443,
0.0381714217,
-0.1096004844,
0.0127143795,
-0.0148913804,
0.0391935781,
0.000616644,
-0.0509371199,
0.0004461981,
-0.0026590347,
-0.1075405926,
-0.0350306034,
0.047468964,
-0.0079250596,
-0.038645599,
-0.0730660707,
0.0478679538,
0.0087251673,
0.0008779617,
-0.0305265225,
0.0028333208,
-0.0336598456,
-0.015233757,
-0.0075127804,
-0.0744266585,
0.0102365883,
0.004840279,
0.0002244932,
-0.0040485612,
0.0122645805,
-0.0109677995,
-0.0113570187,
-0.0325598828,
-0.0000642581,
0.0265139472,
0.0181096196,
0.0394447818,
-0.0249627773,
-0.0052997274,
0.0083818557,
-0.0150397951,
-0.0108177755,
-0.0195550397,
0.0429396704,
0.0245736651,
0.0616727509,
0.0038390416,
0.0565523989,
0.0145025644,
0.0006957211,
-0.1004631147,
-0.0048865764,
-0.0301002041,
0.0826349556,
0.0149878748,
0.0056876079,
-0.0456596315,
0.0001029444,
-0.0623567402,
0.001343546,
-0.0084290458,
-0.0303641763,
0.0189178232,
0.0160035212,
-0.015788205,
-0.0660069808,
-0.0039577605,
-0.0273995437,
-0.0031481693,
-0.0120704686,
-0.0135328379,
0.0022362166,
-0.00773323,
0.0489359796,
-0.0345369279,
-0.0238821767,
-0.0018526922,
-0.0327552781,
0.0180955753,
-0.0104001341,
0.028221583,
0.0529430993,
-0.0807780102,
0.0260260068,
-0.0439362004,
0.0189137235,
-0.0040336079,
0.0304054711,
0.0138210105,
0.034621384,
-0.0062559759,
0.0480712131,
0.0004019954,
-0.0183394253,
-0.0379408002,
0.0213491675,
0.0172280576,
0.028377505,
-0.0339608639,
-0.0023214291,
-0.0627693906,
0.0024855791,
0.0146672567,
-0.0744940937,
-0.0169971399,
0.0071422476,
3.368e-7,
0.0203108415,
0.0857684463,
0.0208361298,
0.0776242316,
-0.0069284174,
0.0582530685,
0.0056836833,
0.0347079672,
0.0484201014,
-0.0020876226,
0.0110343024,
0.0280005746,
-0.0024611081,
0.0176119171,
-0.0679377317,
0.0035812319,
-0.0225296393,
-0.0204599407,
-0.0420834534,
-0.0113711823,
0.0513967797,
0.1091714725,
0.0497804917,
-0.0254999343,
0.0281402133,
-0.0316421725,
0.0395889096,
-0.0084599201,
-0.0192668978,
-0.0076329899,
0.0239176136,
-0.0074853473,
-0.0113898991,
0.0097710304,
0.040006347,
0.0197890271,
-0.0503803566,
0.0754650161,
-0.0024592306,
0.0038085864,
-0.0079049682,
-0.0282691121,
-0.00183696,
-0.0747122616,
0.0666894764,
-0.0398673527,
-0.0346220993,
0.017063681,
-0.0214320291,
-0.0277877264,
0.0109261172,
0.0025891222,
0.0028879584,
0.0095405402,
0.0265584178,
0.0259745866,
-0.0276016425,
-0.04930095,
-0.0342958234,
-0.0019796079,
-0.0074803717,
0.0110499905,
-0.0579893142,
0.0528246202,
0.0065676677,
-0.0623438284,
0.0103822174,
3.589539141e-34,
0.0540857986,
-0.0318800285,
0.0245451089,
0.0025713551,
0.07428132,
0.0255236216,
-0.0472895019,
0.0074092713,
0.013115691,
-0.0973773599,
-0.005790838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15533v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15533v1 | Automated Refugee Case Analysis: An NLP Pipeline for Supporting Legal Practitioners | 2023-05-24T19:37:23 | 2023-05-24T19:37:23 | Claire Barale, Michael Rovatsos, Nehal Bhuta | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce an end-to-end pipeline for retrieving,
processing, and extracting targeted information from legal cases. We
investigate an under-studied legal domain with a case study on refugee law in
Canada. Searching case law for past similar cases is a key part of legal work
for both lawyers and judges, the potential end-users of our prototype. While
traditional named-entity recognition labels such as dates provide meaningful
information in legal work, we propose to extend existing models and retrieve a
total of 19 useful categories of items from refugee cases. After creating a
novel data set of cases, we perform information extraction based on
state-of-the-art neural named-entity recognition (NER). We test different
architectures including two transformer models, using contextual and
non-contextual embeddings, and compare general purpose versus domain-specific
pre-training. The results demonstrate that models pre-trained on legal data
perform best despite their smaller size, suggesting that domain matching had a
larger effect than network architecture. We achieve a F1 score above 90% on
five of the targeted categories and over 80% on four further categories. | [
0.0296303518,
0.0582917221,
-0.0156631339,
0.0088873571,
-0.0335133262,
0.0404655002,
0.0337534957,
-0.010954828,
0.0035754154,
-0.0436160155,
0.0199632365,
-0.0197211429,
-0.0412064455,
0.0146269714,
-0.0188551173,
-0.0364091508,
0.0185932685,
0.0410742387,
0.0462471768,
0.0428860523,
-0.0294726826,
0.025264889,
-0.004734783,
0.0491666272,
-0.0336519964,
0.0034419049,
-0.0311571602,
-0.0091545051,
0.0068279086,
-0.0310621671,
-0.0051970226,
0.0716241747,
0.0111579578,
0.0115393084,
0.0000017639,
-0.0348705649,
0.0048521198,
-0.0204583202,
-0.0214682557,
-0.0596641041,
0.0315336473,
-0.0757611766,
-0.0491216779,
-0.0356408395,
-0.0247449763,
-0.03651594,
0.0262376331,
0.06678202,
0.0237518344,
0.0845667124,
0.0036938186,
-0.0488623828,
0.0559723116,
-0.0088430326,
-0.0070010801,
-0.0368258916,
0.0074157408,
-0.0408193171,
0.0279231705,
-0.0141796181,
0.0400338396,
0.0315288082,
0.042030707,
-0.0226340145,
-0.0264893211,
0.0289137699,
-0.0496950001,
-0.0312360357,
-0.0021783104,
0.0618999377,
-0.0067246226,
0.0063429624,
-0.001639459,
-0.0082802391,
0.021196004,
-0.035392791,
-0.0043090209,
0.0672053024,
-0.0288260765,
0.0031284902,
0.0516795963,
0.047051169,
-0.0012043171,
-0.0037287741,
-0.0250034351,
0.0106054395,
-0.0164576322,
-0.0265129916,
0.0230197851,
0.0226830896,
0.0501091145,
-0.0438161604,
0.0639953986,
0.0106543498,
0.017406987,
0.0242804494,
-0.0121832443,
-0.0372168534,
-0.0008910655,
-0.0773300007,
0.0204786286,
0.0238247607,
-0.0426022708,
0.0690791234,
-0.0575013049,
-0.0002041969,
0.0008118729,
-0.0028817453,
0.0073641287,
-0.041272454,
-0.0570926219,
0.0086716022,
-0.0281630792,
0.0357459262,
-0.0885333419,
0.0407803357,
-0.0108733997,
0.0302452184,
-0.0068827388,
0.0237129629,
0.0292109363,
-0.0130311921,
-0.0094605861,
0.0028634178,
-0.0611314997,
-0.0274648741,
-0.0397071801,
0.0145587437,
-0.0114045488,
-0.0666387603,
0.0192326903,
-0.0197580177,
0.015276812,
-0.0193597935,
-0.0014454609,
0.1030983776,
0.0016235607,
-0.0489528179,
-0.0849706382,
-0.0263283532,
0.0370478146,
-0.033195693,
0.0081371833,
-0.0561234914,
0.0348039493,
-0.0296470486,
-0.0116389804,
-0.0863754228,
0.0148365758,
0.0254780445,
-0.0596682765,
0.066846244,
0.0204595849,
-0.025975043,
0.0211628955,
0.041022025,
0.0645512938,
0.0354841501,
0.0039533381,
0.015211137,
0.0624012537,
-0.0437847078,
0.0339324921,
0.0225416329,
-0.0140407821,
0.0016600031,
-0.0059510013,
0.0041140686,
-0.0233180765,
0.0371661,
0.0442981012,
-0.0033563965,
-0.0010880742,
-0.0378659405,
-0.0019769354,
0.0884800851,
0.0357984565,
0.058463756,
0.0250354446,
-0.0235974789,
-0.0058868448,
-0.0267514978,
-0.0580920093,
0.057473857,
0.0088711977,
-0.0088121472,
-0.0661177859,
0.0508354604,
-0.0291599985,
-0.0384258851,
0.0091495309,
0.002073139,
-0.0022228293,
-0.0122778155,
0.0049303966,
0.0304843131,
-0.0341262557,
0.0522358455,
0.0273126885,
-0.0559798144,
-0.0131653119,
-0.002530863,
-0.0359204076,
0.0197101869,
0.0270062312,
-0.0261390917,
-0.0383175127,
-0.050756149,
-0.0178579129,
0.0703383237,
0.0438451357,
0.0183978267,
0.0330390483,
-0.0245695002,
-0.0332566015,
0.0631838515,
0.0348808095,
0.0226577036,
0.0329621993,
0.0515154973,
0.0466589592,
-0.035278108,
-0.0274180435,
0.050498385,
-0.0248809047,
-0.0585218333,
0.0448963493,
0.0308166724,
0.0383926667,
0.0453435853,
0.0204207413,
-0.0527185164,
0.0204292834,
-0.0348523483,
0.004869618,
0.0290882289,
-0.0397039764,
-0.0141194835,
-0.0003076133,
-0.034393657,
-0.0572154075,
0.0295687653,
-0.0564847551,
0.0160091426,
0.008810048,
0.0687969178,
-0.0033094315,
-0.0574924462,
-0.0052569546,
0.0288005825,
-0.0014587995,
-0.03260874,
0.048227746,
0.0005562004,
0.001531829,
-0.0425491408,
-0.0240337253,
0.0418979749,
0.0074469019,
-0.045040112,
0.0034441981,
-0.0221374817,
-0.0178095978,
-0.0030625267,
-0.0021487158,
-0.041026637,
-0.0073572658,
-0.0495327301,
0.0066385018,
-0.020881189,
0.0214411262,
0.0184336491,
0.0193592943,
-0.0260745212,
-0.0200439524,
-0.0153947985,
-0.0353799462,
-0.0279368367,
-0.0133788241,
0.0271157436,
0.0016003067,
0.0102436682,
-0.0302698426,
-0.0076407767,
-0.0389061794,
0.0443830825,
0.0145727741,
-0.0288670007,
-0.0141275097,
0.0618664064,
-0.0012355298,
0.0184896961,
-0.0213152673,
0.0151150329,
-0.0019593781,
0.0344393402,
-0.0003769538,
0.0284922719,
0.0328019485,
0.0302782431,
-0.0093747899,
0.0040125614,
-0.0381114408,
0.0150298253,
-0.0114770811,
0.0271369778,
-0.0126353661,
-0.0165508296,
0.0356207676,
0.0304204933,
-0.0080901887,
0.0091313049,
-0.0122321965,
-0.0127038201,
-0.0272307079,
-0.0213052612,
-0.0504448116,
0.0112575321,
-0.0120139821,
0.0240869801,
-0.0046305489,
0.0033271005,
0.0557504706,
0.0265924651,
0.0426015072,
-0.0398377851,
0.0003690027,
-0.0507103875,
0.1058266908,
-0.002932946,
0.0040893755,
0.0121992612,
-0.0803396031,
0.0274812263,
-0.0007566114,
-0.0022485559,
-0.0363857187,
0.0534948111,
0.0001687873,
0.0048588961,
-0.0384543203,
-0.0448921248,
-0.0483348854,
-0.0200260784,
0.003383422,
0.0265851375,
-0.0315560214,
0.0329050869,
-0.037658304,
0.0026517105,
0.0116281603,
0.0455686785,
0.0443773307,
-0.0369250141,
-0.0283401161,
0.0521990396,
-0.0370277427,
0.0031142407,
0.0204250067,
0.0085695526,
-0.0101645449,
0.0078906845,
-0.0164211299,
0.0204755161,
-0.0070755491,
0.0085257059,
0.0178068243,
-0.0819548815,
0.0027554573,
-0.0131435944,
0.0035832955,
-0.0475322679,
0.0213770401,
0.0907079205,
0.0180365238,
-0.0512926206,
-0.0115995239,
-0.004742485,
-0.045079492,
0.0567291901,
0.0365947597,
-0.0783763304,
-0.00030482,
0.0098831877,
-0.0354310423,
-0.0469176136,
-0.0594560616,
-0.0035399462,
-0.0773766935,
0.0595692322,
-0.0297203604,
-0.0297819693,
-0.0307474714,
-0.0271409471,
0.013610376,
-0.0062428531,
0.0063712699,
-0.0275224186,
-0.0243734866,
-0.0138228517,
-0.0049914303,
-0.0273330361,
-0.0374350138,
0.0003366571,
-0.0937612951,
0.0494744405,
0.0160689745,
0.0538996607,
-0.029260613,
0.0114772394,
0.0303996261,
-0.0330970958,
-0.0052854386,
0.015495291,
0.0190309882,
-0.005065457,
-0.0087748859,
-0.0302927345,
-0.0000341236,
-0.0426424779,
-0.0102696829,
0.0523568951,
0.0689607114,
-0.0389994234,
0.0191788562,
-0.0001284659,
-0.0377315059,
0.0091233617,
0.070345208,
0.0195853468,
0.0132316845,
-0.0010063291,
-0.0055936673,
-0.0168125331,
-0.0574321486,
-0.0596764795,
0.0227650274,
-0.0328545198,
-0.0263864156,
-0.0425764285,
-0.0508820638,
0.0106308777,
0.0437107794,
0.0190346036,
-0.0135566583,
0.0586243719,
-0.0006381877,
-0.0674409047,
0.0687387958,
-0.0318270959,
0.0227595232,
-0.0084794201,
0.0342448726,
-0.0189133417,
0.0180343222,
-0.0299876742,
0.024303386,
-0.0069890488,
0.007098461,
0.0294346474,
-0.0550375842,
0.0075464868,
0.0100679193,
-0.0307937618,
-0.0226903297,
0.0160824675,
0.0672806278,
-0.0331980921,
-0.0436348915,
0.0247106776,
-0.0164119266,
-0.0215676073,
0.0042970865,
0.0278794989,
0.0754798502,
0.0242712256,
0.0060188156,
-0.0194555763,
0.0103877727,
-0.0203231536,
-0.0130230682,
0.0334383138,
0.0370715037,
-0.0548291691,
-0.0850737318,
-0.0033879613,
0.0031469457,
0.0104683563,
0.0168175381,
-0.0192368217,
0.0160403196,
0.0133976992,
-0.0239323862,
0.0728371069,
-0.023383949,
0.0322947763,
-0.0667787865,
0.034976013,
0.0217886996,
0.0562183261,
-0.0213830508,
-0.0146528976,
0.0061483341,
0.0432901643,
0.0178342965,
0.0765767992,
-0.058655899,
0.0180115178,
-0.0047902414,
0.0200811215,
0.0224013682,
0.0478148498,
-0.025799809,
-0.0040158546,
-0.0141274314,
0.0375698283,
0.053981211,
-0.0224906709,
-0.0361528955,
0.0054172389,
0.0155203743,
0.0187746435,
-0.0185824279,
-0.0127973231,
-0.0222809259,
0.0129325185,
0.025404511,
-0.0122346291,
0.0092623858,
-0.0128066018,
-0.0218365267,
0.0184349939,
0.0002911003,
-0.0296505727,
-0.018504519,
-0.0152410194,
-0.0081856791,
0.0009351819,
-0.0436948203,
-0.0370542556,
-0.0437388569,
-0.0373657905,
-0.0053480407,
-0.0188408829,
-0.0138118565,
0.0408196785,
0.0106065059,
0.0474089421,
0.021017082,
-0.0122862309,
-0.0449824221,
0.0463203974,
-0.0180084463,
-0.0367002971,
-0.0033540106,
-5.590536154e-33,
-0.0330235958,
-0.0250772927,
0.0133467531,
-0.0003726531,
-0.0259402152,
0.0044937241,
-0.0122624161,
-0.0165709183,
-0.0421959311,
-0.0318333432,
-0.025981538,
0.0072426526,
0.0295700822,
0.0027624844,
-0.0124056106,
0.0092979576,
0.0346169733,
0.0423439033,
-0.0170024931,
-0.0001901324,
0.0215284601,
0.0582693703,
0.0587871782,
-0.0947755203,
0.0200748481,
0.0441567674,
0.0262829941,
-0.0307713673,
0.0582985543,
0.0624266751,
-0.0259953197,
0.0212199502,
0.0339381658,
-0.0924631134,
0.0213739909,
0.0349098556,
-0.1581991762,
0.0138133466,
-0.0336382426,
0.0196321569,
-0.0024527062,
-0.042458985,
0.0259354897,
-0.0118595799,
-0.016491035,
0.0307033714,
0.035329137,
-0.0083547132,
-0.0081414664,
-0.0384426191,
-0.0922108144,
0.0519070998,
-0.0003173872,
0.0725078136,
0.0090581682,
-0.001699065,
0.0074259993,
0.0546984039,
-0.1261763722,
-0.0266488176,
-0.0484890454,
-0.0053151781,
0.0279946383,
-0.0504275337,
-0.0416503884,
0.0249427594,
-0.0180113651,
0.0016762288,
-0.0333676934,
-0.036136549,
0.0366613194,
0.0122160967,
0.0292080157,
0.0557883941,
0.0335966013,
-0.061071001,
-0.0707871467,
0.0214143209,
0.0094683664,
0.0288591962,
0.0251889434,
-0.0216021724,
-0.045244284,
0.033267498,
-0.0475932769,
-0.0601676293,
-0.0053391713,
0.0064303991,
0.0364193879,
0.0422862545,
0.0373538882,
0.0223526731,
0.0254234262,
-0.0021412552,
0.0485148504,
-0.0016828659,
0.0145189203,
0.0124240611,
0.0069079669,
0.036935363,
-0.0571062043,
-0.032042969,
0.0189767294,
-0.0296382681,
0.0393303782,
-0.0500071235,
0.0552445166,
-0.042857144,
-0.0759778693,
-0.0048204996,
-0.0041158167,
0.0626051053,
0.0102688652,
0.0785921589,
-0.0037073605,
-0.0002566645,
-0.0022371714,
-0.0099629099,
0.0479597673,
-0.0071326592,
-0.0226370599,
-0.0036116135,
0.024458006,
0.0108611137,
-0.0185732376,
-0.024877267,
0.010703627,
0.0814808607,
0.045734372,
-0.0409007333,
-0.001266556,
0.041330535,
2.509e-7,
0.0517843626,
0.0023696895,
-0.0031709764,
-0.0363334939,
-0.0079538086,
0.0112065589,
0.0439988226,
0.0451721288,
0.0174267199,
-0.0072536762,
-0.0145494696,
0.008715257,
0.049729459,
0.0666644648,
-0.0914879888,
-0.0643999502,
-0.0017752042,
-0.0260200053,
-0.0703252181,
0.027382629,
0.0238058865,
0.0921283886,
0.0415316336,
-0.0113437399,
-0.0326275639,
0.0000885989,
0.0007249704,
-0.0259083249,
-0.0144883422,
-0.0140160955,
0.0600378476,
0.0348884985,
-0.0243841894,
0.007623136,
-0.0258804038,
0.0485488623,
-0.0221264735,
0.0530484058,
0.0010388799,
-0.0003160028,
-0.0337833278,
-0.0356432274,
0.0041979062,
-0.0523344353,
0.0519230999,
-0.0528245345,
-0.0090855947,
0.0013866375,
-0.0377969369,
0.00726787,
0.0277100746,
0.0660178661,
-0.0376719199,
0.0224729832,
0.0458577573,
-0.0127807902,
0.0052063987,
-0.1050554886,
0.0417151786,
0.0264441036,
0.0019546854,
0.0400005952,
-0.0001221643,
-0.0453120582,
0.0647114068,
-0.0176722687,
0.0425270982,
2.078913876e-34,
-0.0069048763,
0.0585302673,
0.0177686382,
0.0089233965,
0.0199478138,
0.0337030292,
-0.0233804137,
-0.0274488535,
-0.0226695519,
-0.0416478068,
0.0544751137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15525v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15525v1 | Large Language Models are Few-Shot Health Learners | 2023-05-24T19:25:16 | 2023-05-24T19:25:16 | Xin Liu, Daniel McDuff, Geza Kovacs, Isaac Galatzer-Levy, Jacob Sunshine, Jiening Zhan, Ming-Zher Poh, Shun Liao, Paolo Di Achille, Shwetak Patel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) can capture rich representations of concepts
that are useful for real-world tasks. However, language alone is limited. While
existing LLMs excel at text-based inferences, health applications require that
models be grounded in numerical data (e.g., vital signs, laboratory values in
clinical domains; steps, movement in the wellness domain) that is not easily or
readily expressed as text in existing training corpus. We demonstrate that with
only few-shot tuning, a large language model is capable of grounding various
physiological and behavioral time-series data and making meaningful inferences
on numerous health tasks for both clinical and wellness contexts. Using data
from wearable and medical sensor recordings, we evaluate these capabilities on
the tasks of cardiac signal analysis, physical activity recognition, metabolic
calculation (e.g., calories burned), and estimation of stress reports and
mental health screeners. | [
-0.0149312252,
0.0713057145,
0.0015846797,
0.002686966,
0.0095415264,
0.0291412268,
0.0324348174,
0.033743117,
0.0194283742,
-0.0151560241,
-0.0073461528,
-0.0075791823,
0.014432041,
-0.0119132837,
0.0183684174,
-0.0290701501,
0.0353570431,
-0.0026594992,
0.0528619587,
0.0356700867,
0.0071354308,
0.0060169473,
-0.014391806,
0.0534811802,
-0.0034448884,
-0.0043225246,
0.0284069218,
-0.018513307,
0.052729208,
-0.0943375826,
-0.0224540737,
0.0342754163,
0.0180960987,
0.0148059567,
0.0000016302,
-0.0220623165,
0.0091338167,
0.0296375249,
-0.0366802737,
-0.071652092,
0.0572075322,
-0.0864588916,
0.0269254465,
0.001641417,
-0.0552988462,
-0.0453198403,
0.0485581197,
0.020831937,
0.0432085171,
0.0608688518,
-0.0226420965,
-0.0049976665,
-0.0303612128,
-0.03270109,
0.0373780839,
-0.0131484987,
0.0436986983,
-0.0235405266,
0.0431284606,
-0.0069844523,
-0.0113463076,
0.0178506766,
-0.0128435129,
0.0719651654,
0.0216995049,
0.0603996627,
-0.0188444927,
-0.0080170929,
-0.0003886182,
0.0740785375,
-0.0347131155,
0.0138683775,
0.0256814659,
-0.0015384522,
-0.0131620038,
-0.0227274373,
-0.0415510125,
-0.0317322016,
-0.0021702785,
0.0318213515,
-0.014845782,
0.0106335115,
0.0573753789,
-0.0011171063,
-0.016660599,
0.0107462248,
-0.0038254983,
-0.0143309738,
0.0292873383,
0.0114372671,
-0.0038109764,
-0.0361466669,
0.0168015361,
0.0322337411,
0.0029823966,
0.0000703514,
-0.0374563597,
-0.0075799953,
0.0268142708,
-0.0605297685,
0.0253883544,
0.0495324805,
0.0018535793,
0.0152063007,
0.0239505358,
-0.0088961264,
-0.0114403469,
-0.0166993309,
-0.0428722389,
0.0088569392,
-0.0455908068,
0.0165157057,
-0.0122343767,
0.0007018427,
-0.0089141224,
-0.0138076739,
-0.0869113654,
-0.0151051143,
-0.0141187264,
-0.016899934,
-0.0083701173,
0.0070413882,
-0.0007771305,
0.0011885228,
0.0162395127,
0.0134528307,
0.0139575787,
0.047892224,
-0.0032773339,
-0.0503060855,
-0.0107736988,
-0.0095439991,
0.020741323,
-0.0482781008,
0.0282409769,
0.0261013824,
0.0528006814,
-0.0244512763,
-0.0478740111,
-0.0045675915,
-0.0415488593,
-0.0424837992,
-0.006379317,
-0.0698330253,
0.0303243231,
-0.012959661,
0.0330380462,
-0.0399595276,
0.0315492153,
0.0061031431,
-0.0453118943,
0.1004979312,
-0.0142638301,
-0.0083829882,
0.0039698156,
0.0068930909,
0.0564668551,
0.0784597844,
0.0622121729,
-0.052264791,
0.004801373,
-0.0470364578,
-0.0235576015,
0.0302224737,
0.0159716662,
-0.0606318191,
-0.0280207302,
-0.0170361921,
0.0139768459,
0.0639514774,
-0.0159627292,
0.039937295,
-0.0035220578,
0.018898081,
0.0701923743,
0.0839831606,
0.0292693563,
-0.0081440164,
0.0151914153,
-0.049295906,
-0.0176573377,
-0.0523840599,
-0.0581652746,
-0.0025681006,
-0.0013154055,
-0.027388962,
-0.0282251481,
-0.0074860859,
-0.0460915416,
-0.0516014919,
-0.0522737317,
-0.0426133201,
0.0201810449,
-0.0046892241,
0.0674716085,
-0.0357622877,
0.016468076,
0.0522253625,
0.0556434542,
-0.0048532235,
0.0030904012,
-0.0151479272,
-0.0138074756,
0.0767704472,
-0.0092264321,
-0.0159727372,
0.0166477226,
-0.0209119022,
0.0795577094,
-0.0068195877,
0.044785127,
-0.0014859443,
0.0589348115,
-0.0597327575,
-0.0139322542,
0.0218760539,
0.0146753695,
-0.0428985693,
-0.0287096184,
0.055944182,
0.0034153361,
-0.0003696785,
-0.0335848182,
0.0387490019,
-0.0334014855,
-0.0596411899,
0.0436874591,
0.0081222095,
0.0250217207,
0.0048082899,
-0.0044804136,
0.0180039592,
0.0137001351,
-0.0817754716,
-0.019957399,
0.0427236371,
-0.0205442347,
-0.0312439427,
0.0118740154,
0.0177806132,
-0.0043348935,
-0.022478085,
-0.0494138859,
-0.0243640281,
-0.0246399473,
-0.0711752921,
0.016609652,
0.0092061982,
-0.0369770452,
0.0339208394,
0.029215971,
-0.0384794921,
0.0062072715,
0.0091984281,
0.0138050485,
-0.0145712215,
-0.0305025633,
-0.0115668941,
-0.0405351929,
-0.0399491526,
-0.0103570065,
-0.0054889456,
0.0035263966,
0.0045108977,
0.0169201549,
-0.0095290532,
0.0061599799,
-0.0952940807,
0.00460822,
0.0082091987,
0.013070167,
-0.0143892141,
0.0179046597,
0.0061957287,
-0.0173786189,
-0.0282368585,
0.000263893,
-0.0025917545,
0.0347012281,
0.0087260511,
0.0116168158,
0.0090372982,
0.0028588183,
0.015338352,
-0.0564917289,
0.0284393001,
-0.0020088756,
-0.011317919,
-0.0108642681,
-0.0271498412,
-0.0048129186,
0.0062303506,
0.0159275793,
-0.0073145763,
0.014895401,
0.0169373844,
0.0535387024,
0.0794779733,
-0.0051262402,
0.0405749641,
0.0407638326,
-0.0116814058,
-0.0153046921,
0.0132623957,
-0.0496729873,
0.012455387,
-0.0413995087,
-0.0437816232,
-0.0355765335,
0.0945484862,
0.0330983363,
0.0312898085,
-0.0379490778,
0.0254191868,
-0.0516922586,
0.0092606898,
-0.0618662424,
0.0691403672,
-0.0391348116,
0.0244801827,
-0.0016798996,
-0.0427754708,
0.0516284257,
0.0186574832,
0.0119559877,
-0.0127843721,
-0.0270506963,
-0.0240846314,
0.0069425451,
-0.0117920712,
0.0168105215,
0.0423548482,
0.0100631062,
0.0032958298,
-0.0291766971,
-0.0316182747,
-0.054906074,
0.0428420082,
-0.0830961168,
0.0119614992,
0.0091726184,
-0.0700504854,
-0.0354731344,
-0.0009018406,
-0.0771039054,
0.0017991266,
-0.0815170407,
0.0279837865,
-0.0630001128,
0.0100163138,
-0.0098225577,
0.0113721089,
-0.0108470479,
-0.0161154736,
0.0093099419,
0.0125560211,
0.0835812762,
0.0185871683,
-0.0019610683,
-0.0454696231,
0.0450465903,
0.058501903,
0.0046116733,
0.0424468555,
-0.0184164494,
0.0162114594,
-0.0163319483,
-0.0073313355,
0.0101187937,
0.0145488018,
0.022869885,
-0.047689613,
-0.0148011846,
0.1314928085,
0.0009716818,
-0.03392056,
0.045812048,
0.0081827966,
-0.0249766279,
-0.0115970289,
-0.025122527,
-0.0620434806,
-0.0472124815,
-0.0187026784,
0.0647291839,
-0.0212564189,
-0.009250774,
0.001747684,
-0.0504990257,
0.0162936375,
0.053509295,
-0.046647083,
-0.0373528227,
-0.0728526711,
0.0184558704,
-0.0599964671,
0.0118264025,
-0.0551817045,
-0.0153757073,
0.0025773027,
0.0341180451,
-0.0458424985,
-0.0746005401,
0.0314588062,
-0.0059488886,
0.0354947411,
0.0263385214,
0.0627933145,
-0.0054584313,
-0.0045799632,
-0.0137469461,
-0.0074947383,
0.0092236437,
-0.0362116843,
0.0353015028,
0.0337369256,
-0.0275741089,
-0.0166410636,
0.0929243043,
-0.0692617297,
-0.0437101722,
-0.0043890034,
0.0849668309,
-0.0122941667,
-0.0325990655,
-0.036517892,
0.0033902337,
0.0567599535,
0.0706952512,
0.0046674437,
-0.0567868985,
-0.022106126,
-0.0011115337,
-0.0059558367,
0.00517753,
-0.0863138735,
0.0051416154,
-0.0337073542,
-0.030271966,
-0.026076993,
-0.0399570875,
0.0298622865,
0.0312624723,
-0.0070861746,
0.0300515778,
0.0695441738,
0.0125480825,
-0.0542227477,
0.0741122738,
0.0048858258,
0.046382159,
-0.0260350127,
-0.0222209282,
0.0278910268,
0.0270485692,
0.004359412,
0.0243233219,
-0.0918852091,
-0.0227330457,
0.0048691947,
0.0681190342,
0.0192207042,
0.0354683325,
-0.0286461655,
-0.0230917539,
0.0168265849,
0.0608109534,
-0.044027783,
0.022038823,
-0.0066004181,
0.0145012029,
0.0126785487,
0.0323672667,
-0.0063034613,
0.0469099507,
0.0217719097,
0.0210186411,
-0.0490848571,
-0.0160974786,
0.0026687384,
0.0028341638,
0.074154973,
0.0001902369,
-0.0146113485,
-0.0020429087,
0.0029257073,
-0.0334344767,
0.0161083471,
-0.0292991381,
-0.0097275153,
0.0308839213,
0.0265547894,
-0.0525333174,
-0.0193641018,
-0.0267769117,
-0.0345316902,
-0.0757010728,
0.0500532985,
-0.0011177291,
0.0325609595,
0.0292361882,
-0.001327835,
-0.007772489,
0.0314039178,
-0.0253547169,
-0.0078800656,
0.0051511377,
0.0275001042,
-0.0120477863,
0.0254289396,
-0.0164759103,
0.027340861,
-0.0467273369,
0.0073843552,
0.0008069656,
-0.004981657,
0.004990573,
-0.019241197,
0.0120747788,
0.0100088427,
-0.0177236609,
-0.0410930738,
0.0314346626,
-0.0401516296,
0.0234923158,
0.0717660338,
0.0039977171,
-0.0340937674,
-0.025318915,
0.0942074433,
0.0239591394,
0.0506924279,
0.0392750315,
-0.0349704325,
-0.0229847003,
0.0029839766,
0.0149121443,
0.0000260992,
-0.0608447045,
0.0169744156,
-0.0699246973,
-0.0727211833,
0.0528074168,
-0.0116336886,
-0.0237385649,
0.0054149753,
0.0443469435,
0.0058726994,
-0.0444339477,
-0.0209731963,
-0.0196947996,
0.0354181714,
-0.042068392,
-0.0473771505,
-0.0119924126,
-5.107670258e-33,
0.0033763482,
-0.00737218,
0.0305410679,
0.0032299913,
0.0117481118,
0.051898092,
-0.0342588611,
0.0198764354,
-0.0124564795,
0.020043036,
0.0275106691,
0.0023141974,
0.0248821471,
0.0076619559,
0.0250630714,
-0.0248550754,
0.0427591689,
-0.0014356016,
0.0112511897,
0.0047887564,
0.0286247078,
0.0547851473,
0.0758503228,
-0.0667026415,
-0.0207975879,
0.062566936,
0.0064053936,
0.0184720233,
-0.0032880283,
0.0451857522,
-0.0488734506,
0.087409988,
0.0223469306,
0.0168640539,
-0.0186354537,
0.0383927301,
-0.0597438365,
-0.0383934751,
0.0045311516,
-0.0045542098,
0.0132562323,
-0.0486655384,
0.0458666235,
-0.0222510397,
-0.0318953395,
-0.014188908,
0.022283094,
-0.0754805505,
-0.012650514,
-0.0312189404,
-0.0266542211,
0.0357166901,
-0.004574744,
-0.009815204,
-0.0000437872,
-0.004775248,
-0.0639432222,
0.033476986,
-0.0420650281,
-0.0228171833,
0.0116786985,
0.012755055,
-0.0162771717,
0.0083123473,
0.011898662,
0.0402573608,
0.0090614175,
-0.0264392775,
-0.0118259788,
0.0334865972,
0.0140500991,
0.0581654087,
0.0479683951,
0.0374969542,
0.0373697914,
-0.0282653701,
-0.1043501422,
0.0071792277,
-0.0164603442,
0.0101613747,
0.0036338323,
0.0084762797,
0.0022415956,
-0.0101069305,
0.0058957282,
0.0284504276,
-0.0457360558,
-0.0083919382,
0.0076184543,
0.010475439,
0.0322566442,
0.0336520635,
0.0080743507,
-0.0466381125,
-0.0046084011,
0.0076110605,
0.0629668608,
-0.04649866,
0.0084359376,
-0.021418415,
-0.0885863379,
-0.0366120301,
0.0122365709,
0.0474910252,
0.0579134747,
-0.0148836309,
0.0302008241,
0.0101340441,
-0.0239442512,
-0.0508356281,
0.0039949683,
-0.0149620129,
0.0260152444,
0.0168845151,
0.048232764,
0.0065372111,
0.0089944219,
0.1025989875,
-0.0239445399,
-0.0308983456,
-0.0349141434,
0.0203774218,
0.0068877768,
0.0286069419,
-0.0179749168,
-0.0309445709,
-0.0225005951,
0.0325552188,
0.0315629169,
-0.0576592609,
-0.0046021231,
0.0072355825,
2.475e-7,
0.0572597645,
0.0418006107,
-0.0503838807,
-0.0428245291,
0.0202555936,
0.0135175483,
-0.0330265798,
0.0456932597,
-0.0167237725,
0.0054732477,
0.0323050283,
0.0305489562,
0.0635670573,
0.0313523114,
-0.0220125988,
-0.0006020886,
-0.0536984839,
-0.0075181536,
-0.0416299477,
-0.0136292698,
0.0344424732,
0.1161433235,
0.0025979527,
-0.0121058067,
0.0479783975,
-0.0320753418,
0.0646896809,
-0.0412979536,
0.0017446912,
-0.0175652001,
-0.0093051698,
-0.0095609529,
0.0227618329,
-0.0127622718,
-0.0191845465,
0.0148061598,
-0.0069893645,
0.1090649217,
-0.0589158535,
0.0196853299,
-0.0122291585,
0.0194228832,
-0.0330404788,
-0.0131297242,
0.0846397206,
-0.1134281829,
-0.0747030526,
-0.0549144894,
-0.0028553784,
-0.0048417766,
0.035706725,
-0.0175561048,
0.0064161601,
0.0292152911,
0.036912553,
0.0050519477,
-0.0204308964,
-0.0473569706,
-0.0434694141,
0.0383034945,
-0.0405711904,
-0.0427565686,
-0.0205109306,
0.0089882724,
-0.0070938859,
-0.0524418578,
-0.0112301353,
1.7247279e-34,
-0.0094429515,
0.0054227076,
-0.0212621279,
0.0202961061,
0.0044578826,
0.0016269179,
-0.0153632313,
0.0361412987,
0.0090919947,
-0.0970477909,
-0.0132371597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15520v1 | Exploring Automatically Perturbed Natural Language Explanations in Relation Extraction | 2023-05-24T19:17:13 | 2023-05-24T19:17:13 | Wanyun Cui, Xingran Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous research has demonstrated that natural language explanations provide
valuable inductive biases that guide models, thereby improving the
generalization ability and data efficiency. In this paper, we undertake a
systematic examination of the effectiveness of these explanations. Remarkably,
we find that corrupted explanations with diminished inductive biases can
achieve competitive or superior performance compared to the original
explanations. Our findings furnish novel insights into the characteristics of
natural language explanations in the following ways: (1) the impact of
explanations varies across different training styles and datasets, with
previously believed improvements primarily observed in frozen language models.
(2) While previous research has attributed the effect of explanations solely to
their inductive biases, our study shows that the effect persists even when the
explanations are completely corrupted. We propose that the main effect is due
to the provision of additional context space. (3) Utilizing the proposed
automatic perturbed context, we were able to attain comparable results to
annotated explanations, but with a significant increase in computational
efficiency, 20-30 times faster. | [
0.0657881722,
0.0629841834,
-0.0011198322,
0.0788804963,
-0.0221574772,
0.0553794242,
0.0272075366,
-0.0128128761,
-0.0379750393,
-0.0547396988,
0.0241484605,
-0.0309488885,
0.0060904361,
-0.0317413546,
0.0120704258,
-0.083757177,
0.0457231142,
-0.0229676459,
0.0401946604,
0.026424367,
-0.007571449,
0.02551594,
-0.018203361,
0.0072644521,
-0.0340640023,
0.0308232568,
0.0136049557,
-0.0048328727,
-0.0083169332,
-0.0452814847,
-0.0187909007,
0.0644036457,
0.0314716585,
-0.0156766661,
0.0000019553,
-0.0569939166,
-0.0160181466,
0.011284844,
-0.0719570071,
0.0256703775,
-0.0043726787,
-0.054847192,
0.0345834829,
-0.003309292,
-0.0073849424,
-0.0507775284,
0.0602064915,
0.0550204031,
-0.0110172024,
0.0676138476,
-0.0182757471,
-0.0433107503,
-0.0464276336,
-0.0031255665,
0.0007054414,
-0.0489301868,
0.0280814711,
0.012759354,
-0.0278834198,
-0.0101354355,
-0.0117420275,
-0.0086846333,
0.0308537111,
-0.0122870449,
0.0332832411,
0.0525612049,
-0.0480246805,
-0.043907091,
-0.0001763455,
0.0826542303,
0.0062077888,
-0.0164396707,
0.0050744186,
0.0053192545,
-0.0051629287,
0.0484105758,
0.0004451668,
-0.0079698218,
-0.018603798,
0.0270408876,
0.0195714254,
-0.004806289,
0.0608373284,
0.0394083634,
-0.0569472276,
0.0531383306,
-0.0173594952,
-0.0217732508,
0.0261647291,
0.0067126281,
-0.0402337164,
-0.032896176,
-0.0184933841,
0.0426239371,
-0.0174416471,
0.0425405949,
0.0035951536,
0.0070718024,
-0.0135379033,
-0.0420700386,
-0.0127158398,
-0.000282764,
-0.0336111784,
0.0538935512,
-0.0272364039,
0.0557822958,
0.0085269995,
-0.0138511695,
-0.0328876451,
-0.0112215402,
-0.0544099808,
0.0026214167,
-0.0179236252,
0.0141893569,
-0.0518592335,
-0.0118454844,
-0.0276980698,
-0.0012772194,
-0.0072109792,
0.0198228415,
-0.0208503138,
0.0321584642,
-0.034335915,
-0.0203069579,
-0.0441946015,
0.0075033298,
-0.0476816148,
0.0046072467,
-0.0155936144,
-0.0500921123,
-0.0438816585,
-0.0021749043,
0.0237115342,
-0.0381329656,
0.0057435255,
0.0794929713,
0.017408777,
-0.0411504507,
-0.0086768949,
-0.0266776141,
-0.0136847384,
-0.0643783286,
-0.0246960185,
-0.0127766244,
0.0381558575,
0.0198723562,
-0.0278940033,
-0.0565348454,
0.0508293398,
-0.0319310129,
-0.1109368131,
0.086141102,
-0.06927526,
0.0064689568,
-0.0331044346,
-0.002629044,
0.0179049801,
0.0760403723,
0.0197893269,
-0.0492416807,
0.0387367532,
-0.0432759337,
0.023447115,
-0.0037637753,
0.0143933557,
-0.0154519081,
-0.0129328175,
0.0087755853,
-0.0179290343,
0.0107064452,
0.0428824313,
0.0314231068,
-0.0046067322,
-0.0142903049,
0.0088455621,
0.0315527543,
-0.0041819876,
0.0599174686,
0.011465597,
-0.009489838,
0.0216228738,
0.0568572097,
-0.100906916,
0.0091284849,
-0.0078523438,
0.0169986133,
-0.0173809901,
-0.002597783,
-0.0070236018,
-0.0538572967,
-0.0367491879,
0.0102365101,
0.0116013894,
0.0177054219,
0.0794484615,
0.0181282405,
-0.0218487866,
0.0554014146,
0.0753497183,
-0.0218785703,
-0.0009674868,
-0.0086758109,
-0.0057776663,
0.0735752061,
0.0271484703,
-0.0413845703,
-0.0228405222,
-0.0156456847,
0.0026672047,
0.0229375158,
0.0314903036,
-0.0083804736,
0.0360845998,
-0.0200785585,
-0.0493141152,
0.0055039003,
0.0411553457,
0.0202074964,
0.0417708084,
-0.0345993564,
0.0341733694,
-0.0120232357,
-0.0328144878,
0.0537774861,
0.0116226738,
-0.0576411113,
0.0262605194,
0.0142914634,
0.0251002703,
0.0284593608,
-0.0300267786,
-0.0046753734,
0.0089323381,
-0.0265552122,
-0.0043407194,
0.0778565109,
-0.0346506611,
-0.0430954322,
0.0052069239,
0.013506555,
-0.0158681702,
-0.0458349362,
-0.0508337133,
-0.020656975,
0.0060621831,
-0.0215955656,
0.076758422,
0.0007044199,
0.0061245253,
0.005541034,
0.0103842048,
-0.0311806202,
0.091507718,
-0.008833535,
0.0096968012,
0.0376311317,
-0.0417846702,
0.00561332,
0.0036709076,
0.0439247377,
0.0199794304,
-0.0195443481,
-0.0385626964,
0.0070688245,
-0.0534827188,
-0.0426756367,
0.0137973521,
0.0046763779,
-0.0348623395,
-0.0412889756,
0.0288024247,
0.0361184441,
0.0138482004,
0.0001898497,
-0.0177092087,
0.0177915841,
-0.0108569143,
-0.0248693563,
0.0216943827,
0.0521022603,
0.0180911273,
-0.0542074144,
-0.0737229288,
0.0081899678,
-0.0390831791,
0.0768284425,
0.0333257802,
-0.0297122747,
-0.0334531143,
0.0231761895,
-0.0240502711,
0.0023102646,
-0.0404210612,
-0.0342433862,
-0.0190499462,
-0.0129120732,
-0.0224983785,
0.0177819822,
-0.0008495367,
0.0786650851,
0.0249496493,
0.0230987575,
-0.0324247293,
-0.0035517886,
-0.0561008677,
-0.010342584,
-0.0146825165,
-0.0370290466,
-0.0274989586,
0.067488946,
-0.0009460714,
-0.0004734604,
-0.0186226871,
0.0111002736,
0.0148351137,
0.0039404044,
-0.0315016918,
-0.018657105,
0.0201274026,
0.0569689721,
-0.0588868223,
-0.0478505604,
0.0903130621,
0.0017977258,
0.0080843447,
-0.0169611387,
-0.026121458,
-0.0227273963,
0.0764582455,
-0.0023690269,
-0.0014565949,
0.0204257984,
-0.0292611588,
-0.0063862191,
-0.0571319051,
0.0434248783,
0.013109793,
0.0247840229,
-0.0654056594,
0.0158733316,
0.0278758425,
-0.0006809064,
-0.0569230989,
-0.0695216656,
-0.0311414618,
-0.0109656816,
0.0191216804,
-0.0356034562,
0.0215333607,
0.0145371323,
0.0079751899,
0.013972397,
-0.0057385173,
0.0071898168,
-0.0162899606,
0.000075998,
0.030467974,
0.0233158916,
0.0217108727,
0.0044276738,
0.0376508497,
0.0165731255,
0.0393994972,
-0.0135318767,
-0.0392026082,
0.0141962254,
-0.0203810502,
-0.0347265527,
-0.0337995365,
0.0073247259,
0.0035066439,
-0.0903185755,
-0.0057495423,
0.1332281381,
0.025010461,
-0.0018860226,
0.0225850176,
0.0474601276,
0.0218747109,
0.0392699987,
0.0112917405,
-0.06518507,
-0.0283704475,
0.0018358461,
-0.0061398917,
0.02305126,
-0.019510692,
-0.01258073,
-0.062517345,
0.0291727725,
-0.0045258384,
-0.0475526936,
-0.0424609445,
-0.0764736906,
-0.0088140788,
-0.0131333275,
-0.0089625614,
0.0030942259,
-0.009923514,
0.0262623914,
0.0187543817,
-0.0694662035,
-0.0757031068,
-0.0263012517,
-0.0349363945,
0.0417158976,
0.0619219244,
0.0395269841,
-0.0204596873,
-0.0058200392,
0.0307096876,
0.0072598774,
0.0286474228,
-0.0453652069,
0.0982658044,
0.0309148319,
-0.03620499,
-0.0084660295,
0.023158621,
-0.0451896973,
-0.0047058351,
-0.0258981921,
0.0527121946,
0.0023636213,
-0.0234796163,
0.0355233438,
-0.0227797478,
0.018948311,
0.0881795958,
0.0265285764,
0.0426939279,
-0.0478550643,
-0.0337798484,
-0.0155752925,
-0.0199452806,
0.0000366923,
-0.0107493773,
-0.020063905,
-0.0306902677,
-0.0109777022,
-0.0413755588,
0.0277527794,
0.0184706245,
0.0315049477,
0.0167936664,
0.0005205724,
0.0257723164,
-0.0456868112,
0.0534241274,
0.0227528661,
0.0005781287,
0.0468229093,
-0.0487290435,
-0.0110446718,
-0.0129034761,
-0.0049486207,
-0.0255491454,
0.0134271383,
-0.0439051464,
-0.0066113309,
0.0037186053,
0.0237289276,
0.096997574,
0.0172936097,
-0.0502276421,
-0.0081804497,
0.030806141,
-0.0274804756,
-0.0184213221,
0.0408472605,
-0.0226949919,
0.0239854436,
0.0302850418,
-0.0419186205,
0.0167533271,
-0.0114842253,
0.0351656042,
-0.0305613205,
-0.0158508345,
0.0425098017,
0.0007810082,
0.0575432666,
-0.0066831955,
-0.0201428253,
-0.0163200907,
0.0126245543,
-0.0549620353,
-0.0311708301,
-0.0340788476,
0.0444799699,
0.0130874319,
0.0101822298,
-0.0174042042,
-0.0423370451,
-0.0476253144,
0.0307090059,
-0.0054570413,
0.0033344496,
0.0278481059,
-0.0299255867,
0.0033747794,
0.020701725,
-0.0095202345,
0.0185460616,
0.0181784872,
0.0521712638,
-0.0077749416,
0.0375937037,
0.0070363488,
-0.0119330548,
-0.0319095068,
-0.0461455248,
-0.0791859254,
0.0228443928,
0.0091056004,
0.0075001805,
0.050156083,
-0.0602051914,
0.083405979,
-0.0097517623,
0.0041773221,
0.0114289522,
0.0818383545,
0.0294570271,
-0.0152683491,
0.0234554522,
0.0316291153,
-0.0432416871,
0.0290834978,
0.0639649108,
0.0058582234,
0.0464968942,
0.0046623568,
-0.0320405327,
-0.0085402466,
-0.0165875163,
-0.0404857695,
0.0285369363,
-0.0026121426,
0.0257869959,
-0.0492936745,
-0.0838136524,
-0.0354486406,
-0.0324527919,
-0.015769165,
-0.0302087516,
-0.0021637494,
0.059367124,
0.0132215153,
-0.0478622168,
-0.0365075953,
0.0165450033,
-0.0401691981,
0.0124917254,
-0.039345827,
-6.629965197e-33,
-0.0189991929,
-0.0602593757,
-0.0154486625,
-0.0016386221,
-0.0124367671,
0.0197567753,
-0.0346193016,
-0.0060743596,
-0.0139350053,
0.0668840259,
0.0050842729,
0.0208470672,
0.0146088498,
-0.0154679473,
-0.0199980922,
-0.0714166611,
0.0238997731,
-0.0016429562,
0.0081219338,
-0.0025398224,
0.0365538038,
0.0528607741,
0.0759450868,
-0.1240117624,
0.0604057163,
0.0219474565,
-0.0030441643,
0.0191094745,
0.0151533205,
0.0324575119,
-0.020934986,
0.0325586051,
0.0318043977,
-0.0275191087,
0.0206037592,
0.0232571289,
-0.1399870366,
-0.0067722457,
0.0499590673,
0.0231615193,
-0.0234066546,
-0.0243005101,
0.0488097705,
-0.0039966619,
0.0210347045,
-0.0269586276,
0.0475805625,
-0.03420531,
-0.0284310002,
-0.0078583825,
-0.062113937,
0.0331324264,
-0.0267838389,
0.0015393739,
0.0388727747,
0.0339177623,
-0.0200309865,
-0.0066952375,
0.0193998758,
-0.0400038362,
0.0200843234,
0.0236655194,
0.0318422019,
0.0110406457,
-0.0045888945,
0.0550466664,
0.0144763058,
-0.0103529431,
-0.0708433464,
-0.0276036728,
-0.0175666958,
0.0547233373,
0.047216218,
0.0303444937,
0.0507830344,
0.0259848703,
-0.0921872929,
-0.0108582303,
0.0206901338,
0.0179136582,
-0.0056381682,
-0.0320570767,
-0.0809124932,
-0.0369187482,
-0.0224485807,
-0.011900316,
-0.0252156164,
-0.0433305688,
0.0180078782,
-0.0052883956,
-0.038923569,
0.0211116616,
-0.018054232,
-0.0434246287,
-0.0214354564,
0.0052534398,
-0.0074132578,
-0.0239144228,
0.0203862563,
-0.0389661938,
-0.020289395,
-0.0378269181,
-0.0282963309,
0.0162497647,
0.0620319508,
0.0101497965,
0.0609285198,
-0.0139463805,
-0.0382082872,
-0.0200975258,
-0.0610866174,
-0.0152290743,
-0.0190092996,
-0.0108455271,
0.0177127589,
0.0453161374,
-0.0282129198,
0.0372436866,
0.0633307844,
0.0285445563,
-0.0079491716,
0.0537620597,
-0.0260830559,
0.0321723931,
0.0087106936,
-0.0254226588,
0.0186632667,
-0.0356717668,
0.0416213311,
-0.0452244841,
-0.0270725638,
-0.0153661584,
2.528e-7,
0.0560762361,
0.0799826831,
0.0500802509,
0.003404452,
0.005902708,
0.0116565786,
0.0183488503,
-0.0310118198,
0.0129693625,
-0.0084552681,
0.0123918522,
0.0248775482,
0.0462372415,
0.0246044844,
-0.0186187532,
-0.03800961,
-0.0653636083,
-0.0588555597,
-0.0359676071,
-0.0194162894,
0.0794848874,
0.0615637526,
0.0282807164,
0.0241115689,
-0.0436170585,
-0.0273668505,
0.035957925,
-0.076717414,
0.0266847964,
0.0160522386,
0.0251017995,
0.0237828549,
-0.0037551175,
0.0325069986,
-0.0243368037,
0.0342257321,
-0.0171825066,
0.0496514626,
-0.0291826986,
-0.0279727504,
-0.0179888513,
-0.0219814908,
0.0319312289,
-0.0452095568,
0.0869100019,
-0.034659788,
-0.0027106351,
-0.0171646792,
-0.0177282523,
0.0046226471,
-0.005757241,
0.0336685479,
0.0352485776,
0.0290443636,
0.0080385441,
-0.0269543305,
-0.016534077,
-0.101966247,
-0.040406771,
0.0228669718,
0.0145377507,
0.0287404042,
0.0215983037,
-0.0253732838,
0.0306748096,
0.0236245077,
-0.0066723265,
2.241195004e-34,
0.0095553761,
0.0207779314,
0.0343969911,
0.0647687092,
0.0512323901,
-0.0062781665,
-0.0158912819,
0.0240147747,
0.0224558134,
-0.0712437332,
0.0186573956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15516v1 | Free Lunch for Efficient Textual Commonsense Integration in Language Models | 2023-05-24T19:14:57 | 2023-05-24T19:14:57 | Wanyun Cui, Xingran Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent years have witnessed the emergence of textual commonsense knowledge
bases, aimed at providing more nuanced and context-rich knowledge. The
integration of external commonsense into language models has been shown to be a
key enabler in advancing the state-of-the-art for a wide range of NLP tasks.
However, incorporating textual commonsense descriptions is computationally
expensive, as compared to encoding conventional symbolic knowledge. In this
paper, we propose a method to improve its efficiency without modifying the
model. We group training samples with similar commonsense descriptions into a
single batch, thus reusing the encoded description across multiple samples. One
key observation is that the upper bound of batch partitioning can be reduced to
the classic {\it graph k-cut problem}. Consequently, we propose a spectral
clustering-based algorithm to solve this problem. Extensive experiments
illustrate that the proposed batch partitioning approach effectively reduces
the computational cost while preserving performance. The efficiency improvement
is more pronounced on larger datasets and on devices with more memory capacity,
attesting to its practical utility for large-scale applications. | [
0.0343819596,
0.0242635496,
-0.0103216022,
0.0274778754,
-0.0790801272,
-0.0091491891,
-0.0282823183,
0.0105912751,
0.0605642125,
-0.1134766564,
0.0084737567,
0.031205155,
0.0138716977,
0.0153197618,
0.0112575116,
-0.0572537519,
0.0552298613,
-0.0197874233,
-0.0285884328,
0.0025824215,
0.015531864,
0.0331006832,
0.0084463805,
-0.0111168167,
-0.0318558998,
-0.0329139195,
-0.0087948451,
-0.0212213229,
0.02089037,
0.0256290026,
-0.0494946167,
0.0288473368,
0.0312877558,
0.0187003147,
0.0000019472,
-0.0225058738,
-0.0432737768,
0.0109530324,
0.0124242473,
0.0081229201,
0.0934123546,
-0.0447368138,
0.0302426573,
-0.0068353121,
-0.015550633,
0.0397350341,
0.0325249359,
0.0206364524,
0.0407786034,
0.0321055353,
-0.0161788221,
-0.0093420744,
0.0000324771,
0.0457885824,
-0.0227348562,
0.0174138416,
0.0389918499,
-0.0006381675,
0.0104658408,
-0.0330926254,
-0.0492480583,
0.0573006347,
-0.0024382381,
0.0085330224,
0.0182790048,
0.0499813668,
-0.0671072081,
0.0176953971,
-0.0370429792,
0.0734308437,
0.0469810478,
-0.0317444764,
0.0155737642,
0.044511091,
0.0094502429,
0.0304814316,
-0.0312226638,
0.0056441557,
-0.0015469171,
0.0195036735,
0.030689083,
-0.0135491835,
0.0234123096,
0.017410554,
-0.0004269783,
0.072645627,
0.0260257423,
-0.0207198635,
-0.0068243537,
-0.0040289983,
-0.0451726094,
-0.0174040943,
0.0126124499,
0.0203375835,
0.0058561815,
0.0463954695,
-0.051456701,
0.0069731828,
0.0106093334,
-0.0348905884,
-0.0021967972,
0.0108732414,
0.034941826,
0.0619433112,
-0.0285434164,
-0.0352044366,
0.0394565947,
0.006001743,
-0.0533604398,
-0.0074903038,
-0.1028850675,
-0.0186893456,
-0.0592745319,
0.0527182966,
-0.0293431226,
-0.0433321595,
-0.0262678564,
-0.0036225796,
-0.0212647133,
-0.0082364874,
0.0499998443,
0.0031892359,
-0.0112634134,
-0.0010783429,
-0.0003494495,
-0.0123236878,
-0.0529501028,
0.0226327442,
-0.0136890793,
-0.0001279172,
-0.0093936156,
0.0087106228,
0.0279193446,
-0.0080710854,
-0.027993286,
0.0142101934,
-0.0164480768,
-0.0234782789,
-0.0513174497,
-0.0136110736,
-0.0375059471,
-0.019417176,
-0.0617165156,
-0.064547576,
0.0529240631,
0.0150027536,
0.0122777373,
-0.0006731648,
-0.0093936501,
0.0090745082,
-0.0248474088,
0.0855114982,
-0.0401257612,
0.017082965,
0.0317889228,
0.0030058867,
-0.01895223,
0.0624898039,
0.0167402234,
-0.0432859026,
0.062273372,
-0.0067219124,
-0.0346000716,
0.0169864725,
0.0213788897,
-0.0268835369,
-0.0344154164,
-0.0147688184,
-0.0169687979,
-0.0078579951,
0.0599924028,
0.053534247,
-0.0302920006,
0.0019793215,
0.0006436714,
0.1207743958,
-0.021618614,
0.0415307097,
0.004954977,
0.0615393817,
-0.0186391808,
-0.0114315618,
-0.0372299813,
-0.0233923402,
-0.0222719405,
0.0080976607,
0.0009622425,
0.0083706677,
-0.0297513772,
0.0209546592,
-0.0287109464,
-0.0344178937,
0.052665554,
-0.0085826237,
0.0590326749,
-0.0189530905,
0.0079647042,
0.1042438596,
0.0793504938,
-0.0363707431,
0.0457073599,
0.0032621475,
-0.0176847354,
0.0466051176,
0.031441763,
-0.020843951,
0.0377625562,
0.0270375982,
-0.0070081945,
-0.0202181675,
0.0081783542,
-0.0701892897,
0.000488279,
-0.0501530953,
0.000871357,
-0.0192733221,
0.0065966398,
0.0117615117,
0.0365088098,
-0.0013209562,
-0.000190723,
-0.0826845393,
-0.038348861,
0.0207284261,
0.0106742997,
-0.0165377166,
-0.046182394,
-0.0190647449,
0.021535622,
0.0117737511,
0.0074620866,
-0.0063007129,
0.036460761,
-0.0602888726,
-0.0037333586,
0.0295096934,
-0.0142816734,
-0.1211594045,
0.0637400448,
-0.037869297,
-0.0399244353,
0.0400824137,
-0.0342843495,
-0.0355203226,
0.0595373288,
-0.0402819812,
0.0347881019,
-0.0422297269,
-0.0052281539,
0.0049557467,
-0.0428795815,
-0.000640674,
0.1037577093,
0.0062386473,
-0.0054639028,
-0.0245220531,
-0.0366657376,
-0.0307882652,
-0.0378090739,
-0.0055895881,
0.0001673932,
-0.0184571631,
0.0123360073,
-0.0052520507,
-0.030047847,
-0.0502848476,
0.0200574715,
-0.1233285815,
-0.0063929115,
0.015785113,
0.0044035222,
-0.0007360189,
-0.0020463027,
0.0357801281,
0.013831079,
-0.0259553809,
0.0043078177,
-0.0118749058,
0.0177369826,
0.0130145717,
0.0074787051,
-0.0478792153,
0.0013134171,
-0.0133414175,
-0.0137012312,
0.0647210181,
-0.0021916435,
0.0120207323,
-0.0379535407,
0.016743673,
-0.0274988301,
-0.0056261737,
-0.0059610419,
-0.0081900852,
-0.0488436893,
-0.0170504134,
0.0407382809,
0.0688296258,
-0.011016503,
0.0299149714,
0.0851116404,
-0.0184579957,
-0.0148654105,
0.0072171269,
-0.0031836201,
0.0224688519,
-0.0062235673,
-0.0185784139,
0.029234197,
0.0281714071,
0.0290814806,
-0.0147561403,
-0.0566068329,
-0.0546622127,
-0.0534686223,
-0.0422524512,
-0.0659223497,
-0.0057207085,
-0.0280426666,
0.0035960535,
-0.0349757597,
-0.0072847069,
0.0785132796,
-0.0257610958,
0.0128183579,
-0.0454106368,
-0.0538499542,
-0.0342798159,
0.0351165123,
-0.0402055047,
0.0412761346,
-0.0166729279,
-0.005234987,
-0.0378440358,
-0.0253937412,
0.0217563715,
-0.004918607,
0.0531173572,
-0.0389950611,
0.0506098382,
-0.011966655,
-0.0108130109,
0.0063711922,
-0.0342160575,
-0.011282688,
0.017542161,
0.0473959371,
0.0038939815,
-0.0215380359,
0.0514642559,
0.0217624065,
0.0313490331,
-0.003210529,
-0.0025507926,
0.0072909896,
0.0597321913,
0.0187408924,
-0.0303655285,
0.0173607394,
0.0178167224,
0.0201350618,
0.0848732442,
0.0931238309,
-0.0262413844,
0.0093793105,
0.0137352226,
0.0128157856,
-0.0671577603,
-0.0201483034,
0.0013393472,
0.0485454872,
-0.0238394365,
-0.0232094415,
0.0854168236,
0.0543818511,
-0.0438338257,
0.0020182736,
0.0045285579,
0.0396359861,
0.0047937939,
-0.0001469699,
-0.0521667711,
-0.0482639298,
-0.0052683642,
0.0080315853,
0.0246285684,
-0.063620083,
0.0076455963,
-0.0754250363,
-0.0128961895,
0.0230783187,
-0.0654674619,
-0.0657259673,
-0.0413504131,
0.0126611209,
-0.000336167,
-0.0352055617,
-0.0125814676,
-0.0284778122,
0.0068712463,
0.0315579586,
0.0096599814,
-0.0436178446,
0.0246496685,
-0.0244455412,
0.0161413718,
-0.0315951668,
0.0671043918,
0.0188833494,
-0.0501699336,
-0.0432020724,
-0.0790025368,
-0.0103619555,
-0.0358769558,
0.01438527,
-0.0273436289,
0.0400364324,
-0.0020576606,
0.0526115298,
-0.0882885233,
-0.0420693718,
0.0212553758,
0.093189925,
0.0227067918,
0.0065050628,
-0.0054120882,
-0.0135906525,
0.006061404,
0.1137037873,
0.0414509438,
0.0083929989,
0.0212327391,
-0.0167214274,
-0.0094891367,
-0.010448873,
-0.0073207985,
-0.0144995721,
-0.0144278156,
0.0171083976,
-0.049453795,
0.0025205011,
0.0785743892,
0.0594735965,
0.0015062235,
0.0332966968,
0.0304168947,
0.0192648936,
-0.0670037493,
0.0397134498,
-0.043411538,
-0.0403303877,
-0.0198103711,
-0.0278290585,
0.0482649766,
0.0151791917,
-0.0346047655,
0.0158164725,
-0.0389386602,
-0.0611302629,
-0.0235908329,
0.0013478369,
0.0160376597,
0.0445025153,
-0.025031263,
0.0072827563,
0.0643088818,
0.0453106351,
-0.0579797253,
0.0081242435,
0.0043146987,
0.0191771742,
0.0074918494,
0.0688034371,
-0.031727165,
-0.0153559418,
-0.0372249149,
0.0379348621,
-0.0785253495,
0.0197858587,
0.0032630803,
0.007399451,
0.0354140252,
-0.0305780135,
0.0087118531,
-0.0401729345,
-0.0216418207,
-0.0234806743,
-0.0648633242,
-0.0044370927,
0.0230797362,
0.0306103844,
0.0055371122,
-0.0306715705,
0.061712645,
0.0071102744,
0.0154867973,
-0.0053471797,
-0.0272225738,
0.0600066446,
-0.0073943194,
0.0124439495,
0.013818806,
-0.0253493562,
-0.0257593598,
-0.0458349735,
-0.022136284,
-0.0395630747,
0.0055378634,
0.0298057757,
-0.024186369,
-0.0445230715,
0.0366605334,
-0.0404087342,
0.0052104001,
0.0242991485,
0.0342987031,
0.0096893264,
-0.0241537187,
0.0198017247,
-0.0265317839,
-0.0475022607,
0.0080802711,
0.0520914458,
0.0402223878,
-0.0237240829,
0.0741666481,
0.0524928272,
-0.0218848828,
-0.0052323574,
0.0592504963,
-0.024039086,
0.0411190763,
0.0070943688,
-0.0567137264,
-0.0437307619,
-0.0196769573,
-0.0000475213,
0.0566796511,
-0.0075088851,
0.0320935026,
-0.0732556134,
-0.0680469349,
0.0187730175,
-0.0189741235,
0.0154117951,
-0.0084958216,
0.0633943081,
0.0639090911,
0.0346960872,
-0.0252282266,
-0.0147677371,
-0.0057764743,
-0.0346217379,
-0.0211902745,
-0.0048286412,
-6.439711437e-33,
-0.0345150568,
-0.0257966872,
-0.0119594065,
0.0140787913,
0.0123543749,
0.0237431731,
-0.0169075895,
-0.0253334139,
0.0070452662,
0.0084761269,
-0.0198444519,
0.0394687131,
-0.0085299239,
0.0289675258,
-0.0199147463,
-0.0083100526,
0.0352203213,
0.011329242,
-0.0063774404,
0.0174857881,
0.0741670877,
0.0006362907,
0.0646223277,
0.0253907014,
-0.0061562043,
0.0333198793,
0.016302865,
0.0183029938,
0.0109824101,
0.0501290709,
-0.0206130985,
0.0781805217,
0.0226956476,
0.0163304023,
0.0233535711,
0.0294474009,
-0.088446781,
-0.0474180095,
0.0348365046,
-0.0097511513,
-0.0311535932,
-0.0066659767,
0.009892121,
0.0205578655,
-0.0155028263,
-0.0149180265,
0.0394080542,
-0.0227543563,
-0.0469895899,
-0.0394120999,
-0.0013405626,
0.0327020809,
-0.0056653735,
-0.0171231888,
0.0509546213,
-0.0135280136,
-0.0067208419,
0.026428923,
-0.0613137744,
0.0146882618,
0.0197949037,
0.0234715771,
0.0404431559,
-0.0047722431,
0.0085881772,
0.0627326965,
-0.055526942,
-0.0599763282,
-0.0102714617,
0.038097553,
0.0336784087,
0.0213345997,
-0.0112839984,
0.069554396,
0.0267010126,
0.0103589334,
-0.0388688631,
0.0423476622,
-0.0159524605,
0.0424063206,
0.019605469,
0.0469348878,
-0.0442323275,
-0.0566680171,
-0.0275585968,
-0.0608425885,
-0.0212580543,
0.0180170648,
-0.0261939727,
-0.0192856397,
-0.0638963804,
0.0230194535,
0.0110046389,
-0.0142460493,
-0.017988611,
0.0483984202,
0.023723321,
0.026469022,
0.0041879592,
0.008232886,
-0.0783188865,
-0.0207912624,
0.0252268706,
0.0118516097,
-0.0154723898,
-0.0010344234,
0.034783382,
-0.0070010708,
-0.0257389303,
0.0207156297,
0.0093678311,
-0.0114123002,
-0.0407084115,
0.0077362182,
0.054889068,
0.0431013443,
0.0331530236,
0.0631841272,
0.0409594327,
-0.006968223,
0.0091928747,
0.0280929822,
0.0077133761,
0.0052320212,
-0.0128132962,
0.0082212714,
-0.0426162966,
-0.0637978092,
0.0714814961,
-0.0581619292,
-0.0158462282,
0.0454259552,
2.716e-7,
0.0200327411,
0.0339562967,
0.0041877618,
-0.0236129295,
0.0091763409,
0.0538257398,
0.0121512106,
0.0151499175,
-0.0088930707,
-0.0406583771,
0.0036435146,
0.0537591018,
0.0090471711,
0.0416614041,
-0.0784465224,
0.0207863804,
-0.0549304374,
0.0041470425,
-0.0446343422,
-0.0175139103,
0.0407930575,
0.0841878355,
0.0203420464,
-0.0125784706,
-0.0203026887,
-0.0726201385,
0.0381515361,
-0.0295932908,
-0.0257901698,
-0.0003014659,
-0.0239530653,
0.0000176045,
-0.004221221,
0.062158443,
-0.0048607225,
0.0004063428,
0.0037909891,
0.0408071429,
-0.0151438033,
-0.0014000954,
-0.0045840419,
-0.0251321588,
-0.0088275131,
-0.0392155014,
0.04640669,
-0.0684605762,
-0.0205721073,
-0.0234227385,
-0.0011825077,
0.0072120177,
-0.0389217511,
0.013829764,
-0.0255038738,
0.0363121442,
0.0075459927,
-0.0172530599,
-0.0081814667,
-0.0797651485,
0.0202488322,
0.0127729625,
0.0014918285,
-0.0417838097,
0.0182840507,
-0.0271712784,
0.0399282426,
-0.089529939,
0.0043400931,
2.943879813e-34,
-0.004754595,
0.0403027795,
-0.0225588903,
0.0427308828,
0.0488788448,
-0.033528585,
-0.0208075885,
-0.0261015389,
0.0226687193,
-0.0967227444,
0.0027655526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16349v1 | Lexinvariant Language Models | 2023-05-24T19:10:46 | 2023-05-24T19:10:46 | Qian Huang, Eric Zelikman, Sarah Li Chen, Yuhuai Wu, Gregory Valiant, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Token embeddings, a mapping from discrete lexical symbols to continuous
vectors, are at the heart of any language model (LM). However, lexical symbol
meanings can also be determined and even redefined by their structural role in
a long context. In this paper, we ask: is it possible for a language model to
be performant without \emph{any} fixed token embeddings? Such a language model
would have to rely entirely on the co-occurence and repetition of tokens in the
context rather than the \textit{a priori} identity of any token. To answer
this, we study \textit{lexinvariant}language models that are invariant to
lexical symbols and therefore do not need fixed token embeddings in practice.
First, we prove that we can construct a lexinvariant LM to converge to the true
language model at a uniform rate that is polynomial in terms of the context
length, with a constant factor that is sublinear in the vocabulary size.
Second, to build a lexinvariant LM, we simply encode tokens using random
Gaussian vectors, such that each token maps to the same representation within
each sequence but different representations across sequences. Empirically, we
demonstrate that it can indeed attain perplexity comparable to that of a
standard language model, given a sufficiently long context. We further explore
two properties of the lexinvariant language models: First, given text generated
from a substitution cipher of English, it implicitly implements Bayesian
in-context deciphering and infers the mapping to the underlying real tokens
with high accuracy. Second, it has on average 4X better accuracy over synthetic
in-context reasoning tasks. Finally, we discuss regularizing standard language
models towards lexinvariance and potential practical applications. | [
0.00792831,
0.0847085938,
-0.0181643236,
0.0546052344,
-0.0692215562,
0.0294459499,
0.0167532098,
0.0145826023,
-0.0545630045,
-0.0431934409,
0.034478724,
-0.0481103919,
0.018477371,
0.0384981856,
0.0476879738,
-0.0194072928,
0.0268323701,
-0.0587524548,
-0.0191603303,
-0.0239871368,
-0.0320268273,
-0.0139442012,
-0.0120433532,
0.0415156446,
-0.0208763406,
0.0000039299,
-0.0361580737,
-0.0096083842,
-0.0220728517,
0.0116393939,
-0.0273585245,
0.0545639209,
0.0297382995,
0.0118452441,
0.0000020516,
-0.0172842517,
0.0065249535,
-0.0143966721,
-0.0315919444,
0.0173269492,
0.0265433528,
-0.0345949233,
0.0048377472,
-0.0060388455,
-0.0032604686,
-0.0556724854,
0.052693896,
0.002380651,
-0.0106747681,
0.0474689528,
-0.0123272846,
-0.056015186,
0.029991176,
-0.0309435967,
0.0382577851,
-0.0725696236,
0.0374497473,
-0.0030119058,
0.0203794241,
0.0415381119,
-0.0552805774,
0.0250887293,
0.0306216776,
0.0420486592,
0.0072696246,
0.0524326488,
-0.0096761826,
0.0072953231,
0.0018112008,
0.0372585133,
-0.0473564602,
-0.0504230186,
0.0081156567,
0.0181632098,
-0.0039974567,
0.0245982166,
-0.046579171,
0.0269067809,
0.0068065841,
0.012572363,
0.0560688153,
-0.0210023746,
0.068382062,
0.0149370153,
-0.0866518244,
0.0654599741,
0.051325582,
0.0020095555,
-0.0671897084,
-0.0341372117,
-0.0547197685,
-0.0480893478,
-0.0041753529,
0.0170908738,
0.0002606476,
0.0388879552,
-0.0473248325,
-0.0511338711,
0.0068001538,
-0.0573288873,
-0.0124510154,
0.0470617712,
-0.0103938188,
0.0625804961,
-0.0532208011,
0.0699965507,
-0.0336172692,
0.0682822242,
-0.0501520634,
-0.0186132863,
-0.0449655652,
-0.0383381583,
-0.0448001027,
0.049656298,
0.0029550879,
-0.0515555851,
-0.0064309547,
0.044191964,
0.0268835761,
0.0098523675,
-0.0517736934,
-0.0144611215,
-0.0213500448,
0.0195070989,
0.0287226588,
-0.0152506568,
-0.0369900987,
0.0269370563,
-0.0116983326,
-0.0337706767,
-0.0246365294,
0.0142039834,
0.0228996649,
-0.0438010916,
0.003447935,
0.0783261731,
0.0372168012,
-0.0410810411,
0.0135221025,
0.0053908043,
-0.049012024,
-0.0146647934,
-0.0278890245,
-0.095070824,
0.0136117944,
0.0367522016,
-0.0051167291,
-0.0453630947,
-0.0009891049,
-0.0055085081,
-0.0552343875,
0.0973202959,
0.0473285317,
0.0146807609,
-0.0111448532,
-0.0087577729,
0.0070080794,
0.0481558405,
0.0347870886,
-0.0075665503,
0.0379249752,
-0.0297704004,
0.0132142548,
0.0418378375,
0.0203780476,
0.0024214587,
-0.0723877698,
-0.0206030775,
0.0799525976,
0.0240742024,
0.0185495373,
0.0617665201,
-0.0385702811,
-0.0271840394,
0.0352367572,
0.0889272466,
-0.0154252099,
0.0231426693,
0.049456615,
-0.0262488201,
-0.018058775,
0.0279976446,
-0.0519614853,
-0.0109835202,
0.0059094001,
0.0216266718,
0.0141844191,
-0.004845588,
-0.0381092392,
-0.0090370197,
-0.0275322199,
-0.0330352001,
0.0324028321,
-0.0202084035,
0.0764067024,
-0.0136702266,
-0.0550019071,
0.0486643165,
0.0055156201,
-0.0490600914,
0.0262475032,
-0.0415061451,
0.0400493704,
0.0606239177,
0.0636171028,
-0.006071554,
-0.0187371764,
-0.0066355872,
-0.0011330019,
0.0188963581,
0.0069221598,
0.0152112879,
0.0328774229,
-0.0415216014,
0.00238322,
0.0042639645,
0.0269047543,
0.0477662645,
-0.042840343,
0.025815703,
0.0139291007,
-0.090887174,
0.0087570036,
0.0360207371,
-0.0233497657,
-0.0267615132,
-0.0058919583,
0.0083565069,
0.0432365127,
0.0069999914,
-0.0000428583,
0.0518292561,
0.0379695669,
-0.0862392485,
-0.0291821249,
0.01406225,
-0.0714190528,
-0.0490728766,
0.0468935333,
-0.0255917069,
0.0346901678,
0.0112021221,
-0.0321329236,
-0.0368025824,
0.0638629049,
-0.0303185321,
0.0741080195,
-0.0181906801,
0.0067444206,
0.0021850574,
0.0421440862,
-0.0184397642,
0.0594475307,
-0.0147145493,
0.0363693051,
-0.0011091207,
0.016157981,
0.0196406581,
-0.0249038208,
-0.0115382103,
0.0251913536,
-0.0036940342,
0.000243984,
0.0056417719,
-0.0135562699,
0.0381738804,
-0.0473260917,
-0.0820177943,
-0.0313539207,
-0.0319127552,
-0.0137671791,
0.0042598569,
0.0343324505,
0.0236458387,
0.0268353801,
-0.0417264253,
-0.0347682722,
0.0004966509,
0.0121420389,
0.0249887314,
-0.0001192366,
-0.080448404,
-0.0054873182,
-0.025024401,
-0.0063403072,
0.0812736526,
-0.0286692269,
-0.0164479334,
-0.0458250716,
0.0042567193,
-0.0259001944,
0.0080647701,
-0.0420769975,
-0.0214162022,
0.0147242155,
-0.0279544909,
0.0440282933,
0.0508347675,
0.0085576484,
0.0303105284,
0.0181365721,
0.0021172205,
-0.024431577,
-0.0205352176,
-0.0354092233,
-0.0148436883,
-0.0331226364,
-0.0047769831,
-0.0088710682,
0.0562015697,
0.0063600158,
-0.0189729296,
-0.0777457282,
0.0153772868,
-0.0148279229,
-0.0050214529,
-0.0490531102,
-0.0243328679,
-0.0346113108,
0.0364551954,
-0.0277181081,
-0.0482764542,
0.0437795371,
-0.0388852097,
0.019859625,
-0.0409183837,
-0.023961924,
-0.0360977501,
0.065991573,
0.0108717512,
0.027530428,
-0.0370806456,
-0.033916574,
-0.045217488,
-0.0039659706,
-0.0275766309,
-0.0371974744,
0.0224609673,
-0.0243780855,
0.0490718521,
0.0215686951,
-0.0112946583,
-0.0323786065,
-0.0365393274,
-0.0205968339,
0.0270496085,
0.0392721966,
-0.0220172796,
0.0039254348,
0.0668583512,
0.0016308513,
0.0489874706,
-0.0020888685,
0.0287434924,
-0.0280141123,
0.0231137294,
0.0199197996,
-0.0313983485,
0.0126302429,
-0.0225747041,
-0.0158966519,
0.0354202762,
0.0287847202,
0.0093712518,
-0.0202043541,
0.0199688338,
0.0203424357,
0.0059817941,
-0.0459734872,
0.0278114583,
0.0112230051,
-0.0094397273,
-0.0429140404,
0.112512812,
0.0217898991,
-0.0304256398,
0.0559570827,
-0.0130505962,
0.0085174916,
0.0116806952,
-0.0196698438,
-0.0760035291,
-0.034807045,
0.0406965241,
-0.0145800188,
0.0199205838,
-0.0300703533,
0.0046567139,
-0.0655175,
-0.0158867501,
0.0219374504,
-0.0522496812,
-0.048773095,
-0.0335523672,
-0.009793858,
0.0023527255,
0.020054087,
0.0141858226,
0.0325112455,
0.0051603802,
0.0087794363,
0.006188977,
-0.0424437299,
0.0189158525,
-0.0396915562,
0.0425420031,
0.042276334,
0.0200547874,
-0.0259154476,
-0.0654312894,
0.0404242389,
0.0062017497,
0.0013819976,
0.0041661938,
0.0053710286,
-0.0144793391,
-0.0046618981,
0.0189859997,
0.0438356437,
-0.0707786307,
-0.0410889536,
-0.0133769773,
0.0521344915,
-0.0083487639,
-0.0218865573,
-0.0237899125,
-0.0511011668,
-0.0091261975,
0.0942443609,
0.0432760939,
-0.0432286486,
-0.0329904072,
-0.0256004333,
0.0303347092,
0.0035727201,
-0.0043353359,
-0.0322954394,
0.0657934919,
-0.0391296521,
-0.0436247773,
0.0158801861,
0.0346359983,
0.0534536764,
0.000735783,
0.0181343779,
-0.0161538702,
-0.0437667184,
-0.0325251222,
0.0080322111,
-0.0217114426,
0.0460715331,
-0.0450148769,
0.0206209738,
0.0181412622,
-0.0267596319,
-0.0361996405,
0.0386201926,
-0.0874450058,
-0.0591592342,
0.0103672734,
0.0159148946,
0.0240436029,
0.021722503,
-0.021107113,
-0.0211505108,
0.0819071978,
0.004718266,
-0.0113511076,
0.0377500579,
0.0197853372,
0.0216903724,
0.0325711407,
0.0476179533,
-0.0493184254,
-0.0174056031,
0.0102730878,
0.0461545102,
-0.0290058982,
0.0038203562,
0.0176416691,
-0.0227004737,
0.0082305344,
-0.0031806743,
0.0083512189,
0.0095961057,
0.0159706399,
-0.0232671238,
-0.001898521,
-0.0342759639,
-0.0077942242,
0.0255486276,
0.0117598139,
-0.0107553061,
-0.048750408,
0.0027538708,
0.0512905382,
0.0307053197,
-0.0152420187,
-0.0198813379,
-0.0188164152,
0.027980797,
0.0092662377,
-0.0040682429,
0.0024297878,
-0.0539910384,
0.0200803597,
-0.0582517199,
-0.017322531,
0.0180610716,
0.0149987796,
-0.0536339469,
0.0026237729,
-0.0753412396,
-0.0430509821,
0.0160166267,
0.0434045456,
0.0284284968,
-0.0067320396,
0.0019723875,
-0.0514682643,
-0.0155006433,
-0.0352538787,
0.033482708,
0.0347881205,
-0.0252641588,
0.0518921539,
0.0586550683,
-0.0223411396,
-0.0065289089,
0.0856401548,
0.0215506237,
0.0469492339,
-0.0180173237,
0.0060192887,
-0.0417402647,
0.0328257382,
0.0270966534,
0.0706163198,
-0.0189962536,
0.03685968,
-0.0514783971,
-0.0965819582,
0.045593407,
-0.0025728676,
0.0185164418,
-0.0170840248,
-0.017484257,
0.0702954829,
-0.0147068081,
-0.01384502,
-0.018799169,
0.0394372568,
0.0326879062,
-0.0653702617,
-0.0264056791,
-6.638659448e-33,
-0.0031112079,
-0.0424319804,
-0.0292082448,
-0.0246151015,
0.0295064934,
0.0100740707,
-0.0350592472,
0.0108835744,
0.0053949631,
-0.0049235979,
-0.0048813475,
-0.0049589216,
-0.0087665031,
0.0467505865,
-0.0166382324,
-0.0240028799,
0.0183522366,
0.0111140646,
0.0124558238,
-0.0157912783,
0.0399952978,
0.0138033945,
0.0514977388,
-0.0314589366,
0.0165263936,
-0.050778348,
0.0097933486,
0.0293842852,
0.0176492017,
0.0419588462,
-0.0255969577,
0.0028356744,
0.0170239769,
-0.0323662162,
-0.007568995,
0.0135344667,
-0.044370953,
-0.0285761245,
0.0456464812,
-0.0006879472,
-0.0098343203,
-0.0480787866,
0.052464921,
-0.0058498639,
-0.027882563,
0.0239838324,
0.0197550952,
-0.0215093363,
-0.0556379631,
-0.0005571457,
-0.033879403,
0.0344164558,
-0.0258533228,
-0.0004397171,
0.0155672152,
-0.0223067068,
-0.0113517502,
0.0297051612,
-0.0268281642,
0.0139550837,
-0.0330047905,
0.0378342718,
0.0475743078,
0.0364277102,
0.0345750675,
0.0412130021,
0.0364553593,
-0.0389841646,
-0.0463594943,
-0.0031721629,
0.0492394678,
0.0033084906,
0.0173823852,
0.029690193,
0.063371323,
-0.0092647616,
-0.0576028638,
-0.016617883,
0.0101274848,
0.0281535257,
0.0773351789,
0.0274207462,
-0.0640326515,
-0.0398738459,
-0.0546373054,
-0.0556664094,
-0.0420810245,
-0.0057101031,
0.01992785,
-0.0002054028,
-0.0171364229,
-0.0407974236,
0.0567225441,
-0.0399719328,
-0.0587971918,
0.044779554,
0.009110217,
0.0184209775,
0.001175085,
0.0242063552,
-0.0188774597,
-0.0328818969,
-0.0036089544,
0.0008928092,
0.0165267922,
0.0123720234,
0.0272378884,
0.0314622931,
-0.0510023683,
-0.0317685567,
-0.0407820418,
-0.0470573977,
-0.0049946746,
0.0113424631,
0.0721259937,
0.0257976111,
0.0074874642,
0.0399919674,
0.023928564,
-0.0149973733,
0.0058396198,
-0.0021946183,
-0.008037257,
0.0329307579,
-0.0590659156,
-0.0273596607,
-0.0126153324,
0.0005651728,
0.0828764066,
-0.0421163887,
-0.0044260942,
0.032486856,
2.886e-7,
0.036429368,
0.0338536426,
0.0399521999,
-0.0133601669,
0.0332963131,
0.033561781,
-0.0003073579,
0.0162979383,
-0.0404966697,
-0.0380659029,
0.007967067,
0.0602866039,
0.0283756834,
-0.0188544858,
-0.0693714842,
0.0511379912,
-0.0341565609,
0.0419986472,
-0.0303195529,
0.0362764522,
0.0375077166,
0.1515156627,
0.0246070474,
0.012080011,
0.0013936083,
-0.0639422685,
0.0380298011,
-0.0273854528,
0.0080775004,
-0.0342015661,
-0.0403904058,
0.02880897,
0.0237422474,
0.0255900268,
0.0230809711,
0.0246131457,
0.0640293956,
0.0483780168,
-0.018084785,
-0.0148853166,
-0.0385931171,
-0.049561426,
-0.0266531128,
-0.0598839372,
0.0773677975,
-0.0145867579,
-0.0343295485,
-0.0614947453,
-0.0317052379,
0.0501087867,
0.0177516993,
0.035410665,
-0.027732173,
0.0316718109,
0.0337374248,
0.0035627047,
0.0122478316,
-0.0848800465,
-0.00526021,
-0.0278928392,
-0.0633378252,
-0.0057381876,
-0.0381040461,
0.008609225,
0.0685161576,
-0.0194242317,
-0.0020153839,
3.080421288e-34,
0.0368942954,
-0.002366995,
0.0005958569,
0.0294955708,
0.0101393899,
-0.0481472984,
0.01568201,
0.0267615542,
0.0458158888,
-0.0879305825,
-0.037411809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15507v1 | The Larger They Are, the Harder They Fail: Language Models do not Recognize Identifier Swaps in Python | 2023-05-24T18:54:39 | 2023-05-24T18:54:39 | Antonio Valerio Miceli-Barone, Fazl Barez, Ioannis Konstas, Shay B. Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have successfully been applied to code
generation tasks, raising the question of how well these models understand
programming. Typical programming languages have invariances and equivariances
in their semantics that human programmers intuitively understand and exploit,
such as the (near) invariance to the renaming of identifiers. We show that LLMs
not only fail to properly generate correct Python code when default function
names are swapped, but some of them even become more confident in their
incorrect predictions as the model size increases, an instance of the recently
discovered phenomenon of Inverse Scaling, which runs contrary to the commonly
observed trend of increasing prediction quality with increasing model size. Our
findings indicate that, despite their astonishing typical-case performance,
LLMs still lack a deep, abstract understanding of the content they manipulate,
making them unsuitable for tasks that statistically deviate from their training
data, and that mere scaling is not enough to achieve such capability. | [
0.0327646285,
0.0665498152,
-0.0201552119,
0.0205239188,
-0.0083999969,
0.0293991435,
0.0082144728,
0.0163510423,
-0.0016674123,
-0.0162455887,
-0.0369568728,
-0.0225580931,
0.0178814139,
0.0364350304,
0.0467561483,
-0.0204678755,
0.0375238732,
-0.0748219565,
-0.0547490194,
0.0010249065,
-0.0459012426,
0.003208152,
0.0216373689,
0.0593134947,
0.0232458767,
0.0016349263,
0.0254901908,
0.0134154111,
-0.0402052552,
-0.0136400778,
0.005902498,
0.0365075469,
0.0027864226,
0.0645329207,
0.0000017461,
-0.0329586454,
0.0348721668,
-0.0004219176,
-0.0000411044,
0.0427380018,
0.0005568581,
-0.0591251813,
-0.0085006012,
0.0226784907,
-0.0101344651,
-0.0281025749,
0.0625806004,
-0.0509044379,
0.0242024735,
0.046820417,
0.0287340526,
-0.0211869776,
0.0075155701,
-0.0284359846,
0.0317274369,
-0.0091611911,
0.0081052165,
0.0175161846,
-0.0185176246,
-0.0123284301,
-0.0105836093,
0.0224894565,
0.0123368884,
0.0133442804,
-0.0078250282,
0.0468105748,
-0.0390472375,
-0.0276858117,
0.0192727447,
0.0196714662,
-0.0746634528,
-0.0709852576,
0.0098336935,
-0.0170191899,
-0.015945429,
-0.020052813,
-0.0426644683,
0.0692835003,
0.0151079334,
0.0092322333,
0.0367864668,
-0.0275767427,
0.0579052493,
-0.0068224198,
-0.0404123887,
0.0713729039,
0.0196058359,
0.0041927835,
-0.0449992195,
-0.0070170383,
-0.0084303459,
-0.0666445717,
-0.0112857092,
0.0244988576,
-0.0248714909,
0.0114874728,
-0.0518995486,
-0.0222099964,
0.0090026204,
-0.0667404681,
0.0393353589,
0.0480496213,
0.0036755151,
0.0013637599,
-0.0580283403,
0.0792772397,
-0.0218840651,
0.0215473697,
-0.0315732434,
-0.0030788162,
-0.0371719114,
-0.032603737,
-0.0218084753,
0.0196530167,
0.0089679072,
0.0291963425,
-0.036366459,
0.0608416982,
-0.0077079018,
0.0529170483,
-0.0378201231,
-0.0125766816,
-0.0387568697,
0.0054736263,
0.0294555817,
0.0322302207,
0.015134084,
-0.0273903608,
0.0030653586,
-0.0497482717,
-0.0123093789,
0.0297864527,
-0.0488990359,
-0.0246543419,
0.0255090259,
0.1148887351,
0.0063363519,
0.0400241055,
-0.0157216489,
-0.0216494128,
0.0124801844,
-0.0286767799,
0.0112633295,
-0.0890252739,
-0.0471202433,
0.0646850765,
-0.0033009534,
-0.0942998976,
0.0145141594,
-0.0238483604,
-0.0391176641,
0.0595662482,
-0.0116893584,
0.0312019289,
0.0258303229,
0.0002235937,
-0.0044340445,
0.029525442,
0.0414409079,
-0.0074619884,
0.0211237315,
-0.0680512711,
0.0474976227,
0.0218641795,
-0.0198437609,
0.0183291268,
-0.0156051926,
-0.0169261787,
0.056803368,
0.0127607808,
0.0360654816,
0.0477301963,
0.0127233006,
-0.0393440351,
0.0161168631,
0.0343459621,
-0.0302406419,
0.0529570244,
0.073612839,
-0.0072400635,
-0.0149949798,
0.0168316364,
-0.0503516234,
0.0295753144,
-0.0420220569,
0.025212964,
0.0038197262,
0.0334726125,
-0.0064733899,
-0.0529453903,
-0.032800924,
-0.0113152592,
-0.0162549485,
-0.0330772027,
0.0239719637,
-0.013590089,
-0.0130226063,
0.0583347715,
0.000324437,
-0.054728765,
-0.0304106493,
-0.0705327317,
-0.0129598174,
0.0295984875,
0.031408757,
-0.0350425206,
-0.0298836362,
0.002892185,
-0.0048126788,
-0.0193611961,
0.0543352813,
0.005975815,
-0.0060784696,
-0.0278018303,
0.0197826605,
-0.0233434159,
0.0039612497,
0.0418362617,
0.0137260444,
-0.0168615822,
0.0547289588,
-0.0188663751,
-0.0746712685,
0.0404326022,
-0.0641314238,
-0.0239447001,
0.0154156582,
-0.0231811926,
0.0165324453,
-0.0627380759,
-0.0432874262,
0.0342941321,
0.0185439624,
-0.0093302736,
0.0138648329,
-0.0090018641,
-0.0470206812,
-0.0095835365,
0.040030092,
-0.0062787598,
-0.0076274066,
0.027643064,
-0.0161634814,
-0.0173562877,
0.1002757177,
-0.0049456777,
0.042375423,
0.0340091288,
0.059075702,
-0.0134127419,
0.0039733946,
-0.0213219076,
0.0148018114,
0.0027921319,
0.0564769022,
-0.0053163236,
0.042271886,
0.0114203813,
0.0118246833,
-0.0422048606,
0.0455312133,
-0.0219788142,
0.0351451114,
-0.0044188043,
0.0154383043,
0.0015090234,
-0.0496775098,
-0.0385753587,
0.0188224111,
-0.0160191823,
0.0134329107,
0.0306840856,
0.008055835,
-0.0088600367,
-0.0294917785,
-0.0316782594,
-0.033986561,
-0.0121930521,
0.0496833324,
0.0360473022,
0.0060886382,
-0.0746104866,
-0.0316352919,
-0.0182588026,
-0.0445495285,
0.076474309,
-0.0205727164,
-0.0005969855,
-0.0917900354,
0.0857126042,
-0.0244110469,
0.0129557606,
-0.0270745698,
-0.0410839468,
0.006989785,
-0.0010395955,
0.0502050109,
0.0470697992,
-0.0167237651,
-0.015150303,
0.0778160766,
0.0208703782,
-0.0415503569,
-0.03497269,
0.0182116516,
-0.0791429579,
-0.007883314,
-0.0561295711,
-0.0118085686,
0.0962731987,
-0.0097194174,
-0.0254956186,
-0.0233591907,
0.0192400459,
-0.0077628461,
-0.0059318743,
-0.0018708297,
-0.0279261135,
0.0006270432,
0.0548085794,
-0.0186815597,
-0.1069620103,
0.0385000966,
-0.0235866774,
-0.0114529664,
-0.0288183987,
-0.0405039154,
-0.0452776439,
0.0890603513,
0.0234028045,
0.0139688021,
0.0129158543,
-0.0333772004,
-0.0783471987,
0.0179775823,
-0.0104475413,
-0.0124100149,
0.0394842327,
-0.0724814311,
0.0183262173,
-0.0039884807,
-0.0543158539,
-0.0393717587,
-0.0105623724,
-0.0243900064,
0.0113515733,
0.0284427814,
-0.0475612693,
0.0197983198,
0.02716868,
0.0531095937,
0.0303992797,
0.0196155868,
-0.0188285131,
0.0121266991,
-0.0481215827,
-0.0376370288,
-0.0469405875,
-0.0024513134,
-0.0368116014,
-0.0125228362,
-0.0138082793,
0.0268398188,
0.0574555025,
-0.0530940816,
0.0083364025,
0.0176142883,
-0.0268383063,
-0.0878909677,
0.0426754504,
0.0396168344,
-0.0586547218,
-0.0221342128,
0.08473216,
0.0189216286,
-0.0233538784,
0.0402059965,
-0.0274964105,
0.0617183745,
0.0696549118,
0.0424227379,
-0.0400953218,
-0.0139018949,
0.0125157917,
0.0217529666,
-0.0145938722,
-0.0256147534,
-0.0144756343,
-0.1043805927,
-0.0008183143,
0.0357195288,
-0.0273586214,
-0.037047375,
-0.0192663688,
-0.016905643,
-0.0168928839,
-0.0186220016,
0.0537265353,
-0.0491698645,
0.035874065,
0.0451182909,
-0.0394155309,
-0.0016457357,
0.0011469771,
-0.0136860032,
0.0105343573,
0.078017503,
-0.0093152812,
-0.0131823691,
-0.0052917064,
0.0519361645,
0.0137263024,
0.016634509,
-0.0081430683,
0.0427869782,
0.0358655863,
-0.029826628,
0.0349009298,
0.0065817498,
-0.0640506968,
-0.0104009546,
0.0010029922,
0.0345694162,
-0.0092794038,
-0.0534782484,
0.028105434,
-0.0159711391,
-0.0279996097,
0.0413857438,
0.0621733181,
-0.0253821798,
-0.0525089912,
-0.0720514283,
0.0001769132,
-0.0071597658,
-0.0281583499,
0.0116152624,
0.0276653171,
-0.0443318821,
-0.0526229143,
0.0127767008,
0.0187809747,
0.0131296124,
0.0230566021,
-0.0166529045,
-0.0186773799,
-0.0042037582,
-0.0637491643,
-0.0022188674,
-0.0152587434,
0.0072030099,
-0.0750888512,
-0.0336990952,
0.0400508791,
-0.0025555508,
-0.0303931087,
0.0033258796,
-0.1118546128,
-0.0652423799,
0.0049054762,
0.0508539863,
0.0298951641,
0.0168890003,
0.0136874998,
-0.035870038,
-0.0229438227,
0.0602368563,
0.0104813175,
0.0410947278,
0.0185543485,
-0.0025345152,
0.0262956973,
0.0231085327,
-0.0290403608,
-0.0060374811,
0.0610226318,
-0.0144400727,
-0.0314907506,
-0.0177099705,
0.0066111544,
0.0646118224,
0.0030102958,
0.0052292631,
-0.0105800107,
0.0115539683,
0.0120602883,
0.0288399663,
-0.0180153232,
-0.016291922,
0.0098712696,
0.0215144418,
0.0196171589,
0.0202733669,
0.0170634314,
0.0181311313,
0.0522369444,
-0.0040365737,
0.0451062843,
-0.0088041779,
0.0529311262,
0.0914062858,
0.0140185496,
-0.0140239671,
0.0346151441,
0.0160546452,
0.0609715506,
0.0020659259,
0.003919431,
0.0084857224,
0.0285003018,
-0.0089329323,
0.0231289845,
-0.0765757337,
-0.1193804666,
-0.0100588799,
0.0152594279,
0.0347563513,
0.0046064379,
0.0173903517,
-0.0323153175,
0.0190808102,
-0.029328689,
0.0428775214,
-0.0082569765,
-0.0182755273,
-0.0140992533,
-0.0042047016,
-0.0464813113,
-0.0162486732,
0.1109064072,
0.0217706878,
0.0598972626,
0.0045703705,
-0.004891743,
0.0028119909,
0.0089468909,
0.039505098,
-0.0388971977,
0.0057733636,
-0.0131713133,
-0.0425016806,
-0.0728048086,
-0.019850947,
0.0096106101,
0.0477461815,
-0.0365866125,
0.0000718577,
0.0836849809,
-0.0081034191,
0.0094396435,
-0.0228641834,
0.0117286118,
0.0193981212,
-0.0489823222,
-0.0362794325,
-5.227716884e-33,
-0.0360594653,
0.0018952695,
-0.0044693989,
0.0117063019,
0.025276361,
0.0010810421,
-0.0493500717,
0.0421695411,
-0.0161647815,
-0.0414092317,
0.0082341777,
-0.0091141295,
-0.00995846,
-0.0079402309,
0.0821341798,
0.0077898027,
0.0329671204,
0.0222711079,
-0.0580716617,
0.0178417172,
0.0285318196,
0.0344273634,
0.079437688,
-0.0452845879,
-0.0470516905,
0.0095308665,
0.0313258357,
-0.0160533618,
-0.0135754505,
0.0238919295,
0.0084251361,
0.0061046099,
0.0169059522,
-0.0255392268,
-0.0564727634,
-0.0346803293,
0.0292994641,
-0.0283987354,
0.0078519564,
0.0204187967,
0.0277404003,
-0.0599943437,
0.1158440039,
-0.0005355993,
-0.0411542505,
0.0117942691,
0.0030944292,
-0.026925195,
-0.0267530903,
0.0013874474,
-0.0576775223,
0.0235244744,
-0.0151107665,
-0.0055464013,
-0.0151618551,
-0.0050511109,
-0.0243838672,
0.0324557871,
-0.0017161991,
0.0069436762,
0.049008362,
0.0787475109,
0.080679208,
0.0489644445,
0.0074757542,
0.0320418105,
0.0645295754,
0.0358626917,
-0.0016195446,
0.0037438509,
0.0236612484,
0.044424206,
0.0188643374,
0.0026888056,
0.0280093066,
-0.0068008378,
-0.0392835177,
-0.0065965052,
-0.0042267158,
-0.0131473206,
0.022601869,
0.0265016388,
-0.0497807041,
-0.0381682962,
-0.0591911003,
-0.0183633454,
-0.0179127473,
-0.0320594646,
0.0222882945,
-0.0418898128,
-0.0208106283,
0.0273967274,
0.0268858615,
-0.0372331627,
-0.0512776822,
0.0098355692,
-0.0636687651,
0.0403739251,
-0.0012656499,
0.0165197514,
-0.0477731712,
-0.0336918235,
-0.0292212106,
0.0043495079,
0.0774127916,
0.0273074266,
0.0285765622,
0.0032903606,
-0.0760051608,
-0.0154197905,
-0.0616927706,
-0.0016178243,
0.0193999391,
0.0382665768,
0.0222644154,
-0.0163459741,
0.0069471495,
-0.0034663999,
0.0003501876,
-0.0515787601,
-0.0488630347,
0.0022054131,
-0.0044190879,
0.0406957455,
-0.0473762266,
-0.0395370275,
-0.0614970624,
0.0280037671,
0.0582593791,
-0.0095873382,
-0.0517258272,
0.0027164614,
2.52e-7,
0.0133151943,
0.0505204089,
-0.0146873072,
0.0232265759,
0.0152261872,
0.057452593,
-0.035578914,
0.0209574364,
0.001212894,
0.0037850931,
-0.0102447132,
0.0035467395,
0.0349726975,
0.0227231253,
-0.0379171073,
0.0214576367,
-0.062997669,
0.0270953439,
-0.0494389459,
-0.0193956029,
-0.0212629326,
0.0766194537,
0.0332848541,
-0.0082556251,
0.0227054395,
-0.0513453186,
0.0148763536,
-0.0358352326,
0.0445626564,
0.0317406952,
-0.0377289653,
0.0366817489,
0.0110192578,
0.0130367447,
-0.0089354096,
-0.0412530825,
-0.0019535252,
0.0291094128,
-0.0121173067,
0.0708070174,
-0.0008807997,
-0.0282718316,
-0.0032553989,
-0.0820074752,
0.0429809317,
-0.0128223076,
-0.0249436591,
-0.0346739031,
-0.0091599273,
0.0261216052,
-0.0107678873,
-0.0001620162,
0.0215227455,
0.0348750874,
-0.0149579337,
0.006250354,
-0.0130211478,
-0.0134050036,
-0.0436839461,
0.0232399348,
-0.0241139811,
-0.0526483618,
-0.0632238686,
0.0106711872,
0.0153081696,
-0.0275493916,
0.0210286099,
2.551506457e-34,
0.0223837905,
-0.0070528747,
0.0233375896,
0.0178107452,
0.0388541184,
0.0002336748,
0.004057026,
0.0358951055,
-0.0142784482,
0.0094874557,
-0.0153134996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15501v1 | Deriving Language Models from Masked Language Models | 2023-05-24T18:42:45 | 2023-05-24T18:42:45 | Lucas Torroba Hennigen, Yoon Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Masked language models (MLM) do not explicitly define a distribution over
language, i.e., they are not language models per se. However, recent work has
implicitly treated them as such for the purposes of generation and scoring.
This paper studies methods for deriving explicit joint distributions from MLMs,
focusing on distributions over two tokens, which makes it possible to calculate
exact distributional properties. We find that an approach based on identifying
joints whose conditionals are closest to those of the MLM works well and
outperforms existing Markov random field-based approaches. We further find that
this derived model's conditionals can even occasionally outperform the original
MLM's conditionals. | [
0.0151289636,
0.0880401582,
-0.013814264,
0.0510823317,
-0.0380048975,
-0.0019896145,
0.0183508061,
0.0385659896,
-0.0094937878,
-0.0838415027,
-0.0137610929,
-0.0393764488,
0.0042729937,
0.0422275588,
0.0224562231,
-0.0565400794,
-0.009347667,
-0.0435069315,
-0.0251516122,
-0.0150565356,
0.005154585,
0.0125953555,
-0.0078360289,
0.037488237,
-0.0117292898,
0.0194249768,
0.0225536246,
0.0058402354,
0.0314901695,
0.0043165744,
-0.0112672308,
0.0561220497,
-0.0210064873,
0.0248454828,
0.0000018922,
-0.0291527286,
-0.0225652754,
-0.0082948692,
0.0351318344,
0.0178645533,
0.0470296666,
-0.0175806992,
-0.0205278285,
0.0063743233,
-0.0219170786,
-0.0261592641,
0.0637326166,
-0.0089488281,
0.0224915426,
0.0641711354,
-0.0075314324,
-0.0432257392,
-0.0153823132,
-0.0125848297,
-0.0289110895,
-0.024640983,
0.0340884253,
0.0243005361,
-0.0166811291,
-0.0653400868,
0.0032480529,
0.0464438237,
-0.0187738445,
-0.009850583,
-0.0252434667,
0.0637225434,
-0.0212556385,
0.0140876276,
-0.0113897501,
0.0413732342,
-0.0550366342,
-0.0498088636,
0.0268251039,
-0.0038748814,
-0.0283048786,
0.0641080961,
-0.0357460082,
0.0311270636,
-0.0033437179,
0.0373464748,
0.0660164878,
0.002545903,
0.0456665903,
-0.0054928861,
-0.0394069962,
0.0932748392,
0.0680329427,
0.0063264929,
-0.0652604923,
-0.0448372886,
-0.0148120886,
-0.0702393949,
0.0108001474,
0.0093386211,
0.0360586457,
0.0211504623,
-0.0485881791,
-0.0552034378,
0.01746995,
-0.0169240478,
0.0223355554,
0.0089493934,
-0.0043536662,
0.0230004936,
-0.0466736369,
0.0136385616,
0.0042702369,
0.0049471455,
-0.0500045121,
0.0059436713,
-0.0158364475,
-0.0192392562,
-0.0314760171,
0.0206895247,
-0.0589390695,
-0.0005866938,
-0.028043123,
0.0310927331,
-0.0137957186,
-0.0150806168,
-0.0051388755,
-0.0234797206,
-0.0322172381,
-0.0072661997,
0.0224938951,
-0.0629441291,
0.0009993982,
-0.0011056635,
-0.0152303651,
-0.0433768779,
0.0180286523,
0.0364718772,
-0.0068467655,
-0.0222919583,
-0.0095142564,
0.0970211402,
0.0163734276,
-0.0005951039,
0.0051302053,
-0.0114068603,
-0.0239256248,
-0.0432527363,
0.0062167784,
-0.101200372,
-0.0098842708,
0.0144207776,
0.0372872315,
-0.0315292925,
0.0080713965,
-0.0057856673,
-0.0250538923,
0.0416615531,
0.0166100152,
0.0115644755,
0.021905452,
-0.0155503219,
0.0068784929,
0.0712536573,
0.0370549597,
-0.0078531895,
0.0595171824,
0.0004073517,
0.0413883105,
0.0833535492,
0.0148629295,
0.0412069559,
-0.0240104087,
-0.0352175348,
0.0498967879,
-0.0479941964,
0.0287693106,
0.0567027628,
-0.0167645384,
-0.0083834343,
0.010052857,
0.029612137,
0.0166062601,
-0.0334393196,
0.0797612742,
-0.0153527977,
0.025387194,
0.0537918061,
0.0155552849,
-0.0374314375,
-0.062849462,
0.0307722017,
0.0012494255,
0.0467060953,
-0.0193428118,
-0.016724823,
-0.0158814266,
-0.0107809501,
-0.0104848761,
-0.0232876707,
0.083911635,
0.0157525167,
-0.0003060971,
0.0369992629,
0.0393904112,
-0.0280423127,
0.0273915865,
-0.0615261272,
-0.0263622906,
-0.0113166878,
0.0471068583,
-0.027319964,
0.0097233877,
0.0379431322,
-0.0510480553,
0.0638574064,
-0.0034020089,
-0.0214669202,
0.0118369004,
-0.01809383,
0.0085019264,
0.0119831264,
0.0488768853,
0.0592274256,
-0.0179858692,
0.0000783896,
0.0245224442,
-0.078236483,
0.0082196454,
0.0494993962,
-0.0381167307,
-0.0109150549,
0.0259154718,
-0.0006835581,
0.0446719155,
0.0271782801,
-0.0395007022,
0.0405894108,
0.0227546021,
-0.0481527224,
-0.0062507242,
0.0462960601,
0.0059011597,
-0.034741953,
0.0477662981,
-0.0153736323,
0.0289624222,
0.052291695,
-0.0235624574,
-0.0529127829,
0.0360327847,
0.0071596843,
0.0662167072,
-0.0410584249,
0.0626043305,
0.0123445718,
-0.0131104859,
-0.0520022325,
0.049808953,
-0.0140962144,
0.0612164773,
0.0004152673,
0.0065209647,
0.0450959988,
-0.0465826504,
-0.0196044706,
0.0166773461,
-0.0211504083,
0.0105498424,
0.0227533542,
0.021955939,
-0.0094808508,
-0.0692808107,
-0.0504772924,
-0.012414353,
-0.0313353725,
0.0251437556,
0.0473193415,
-0.0023359687,
-0.0344948769,
0.0090464689,
-0.0529600829,
-0.0517602786,
0.0308204815,
-0.0170322042,
0.0093276929,
-0.0051072477,
-0.086573489,
-0.0363967456,
-0.0150667811,
-0.0061538313,
0.0592125915,
-0.0044477135,
-0.0507243909,
-0.0787285566,
0.0182524007,
-0.0358943418,
0.0558018386,
-0.0120596392,
-0.0324800052,
0.0028338155,
-0.056970384,
0.0607130006,
0.0132603245,
0.0167847965,
0.0069853822,
0.0667597577,
-0.0273285117,
-0.0415136255,
-0.0382621437,
-0.0392275937,
-0.0054138354,
-0.0313980877,
-0.0826929882,
0.0092561739,
0.0601530299,
0.0339679681,
-0.0332071669,
-0.0424723253,
0.0022082163,
-0.0326530263,
-0.0304392613,
-0.0265538748,
0.017793702,
-0.0205073487,
0.0409467295,
0.0066082585,
-0.085069567,
0.0439365096,
-0.0816463605,
0.0344673991,
-0.0353140198,
0.0002302265,
-0.0282824524,
0.0467193089,
0.0199585259,
0.0407477319,
0.0163206477,
-0.0305763185,
-0.0217816774,
0.0229612384,
0.0213992503,
-0.0475423262,
-0.0066078869,
-0.0610346347,
0.0339978188,
0.0201473068,
-0.0023761694,
-0.0342117734,
-0.0570963249,
-0.0121765006,
0.0440864787,
0.0166447852,
-0.0166309848,
0.0051070247,
0.0751306787,
-0.0184349939,
0.0131988041,
0.0049408292,
0.0057469485,
-0.0122069437,
0.0549832173,
0.0602704547,
-0.0617222562,
-0.0231390931,
-0.0262779016,
0.0004362085,
0.0029906067,
0.0978709459,
0.07551305,
0.0126069514,
-0.0166370589,
0.0446316078,
-0.025483083,
-0.0083348798,
0.0224717651,
0.0098941363,
0.0027267584,
0.0030289807,
0.1097527891,
0.0462232642,
0.003978868,
0.0231570005,
-0.0002896225,
0.0489514209,
-0.003770883,
0.0248083081,
-0.11290209,
0.0083428593,
0.0172224771,
0.0278863534,
-0.024123,
-0.0172883086,
0.0165091343,
-0.1241874993,
0.0141663477,
0.0193788782,
-0.0667166561,
-0.0485980622,
-0.0466468595,
-0.0002164164,
0.0132380379,
-0.0305249281,
-0.0072614122,
0.0038285262,
0.0086409785,
0.0270530246,
-0.0076103127,
-0.0495810769,
0.0104271723,
-0.046853926,
0.0794129744,
0.038091518,
0.0274147782,
-0.0161609054,
-0.0371226668,
0.0123904292,
-0.025055632,
-0.0385711119,
-0.0279748365,
0.0141338073,
-0.0183509998,
-0.0256954934,
0.0382290371,
0.0062232045,
-0.001495472,
-0.0093443338,
-0.0073945024,
0.0128147416,
-0.0044083293,
-0.0228044819,
-0.0132705616,
-0.0105312373,
0.0345400013,
0.0716068223,
0.0239640642,
-0.0127517842,
0.0137958061,
-0.0566958413,
0.0227769464,
0.0079383226,
-0.0202965196,
0.0188260227,
-0.0544777475,
-0.0609101988,
-0.0792753324,
0.0008805703,
0.0141069153,
0.0614400022,
0.0232489612,
0.0240675993,
-0.0336209573,
-0.0300300121,
-0.0296815429,
-0.0019231476,
-0.05306869,
0.0213395786,
-0.0642078891,
-0.0484215878,
0.021634724,
-0.0286387857,
-0.0400409289,
0.0197497141,
-0.0585774332,
-0.0801831484,
0.0081514865,
0.0506330095,
0.0330034196,
0.0070783505,
-0.0420825817,
-0.0150851496,
0.0287594199,
0.0369535498,
0.0005341268,
0.0208964646,
0.0380537026,
-0.0339456536,
0.0034736732,
0.0293112826,
-0.0561920181,
0.0240235887,
0.0384708829,
0.0736020431,
-0.0385969207,
-0.0354140997,
0.017187601,
0.0550361127,
0.0427794158,
-0.0837791339,
-0.0199151188,
-0.0335783325,
0.0013795994,
-0.0660098046,
-0.0399539471,
-0.0240777954,
-0.0024347182,
0.0179460589,
-0.0014899352,
-0.0051623117,
0.0196935628,
-0.0439957343,
0.0694729239,
-0.0017762879,
-0.0112475753,
0.0163805932,
0.022464605,
0.0209855996,
-0.0334249288,
0.0073214048,
-0.0207160804,
0.0149326148,
0.017486345,
0.0043719066,
0.0199159794,
0.0080707269,
-0.0307986625,
-0.0184618272,
0.0189412832,
-0.0250698254,
-0.027575938,
-0.0347435884,
0.0165272448,
0.054567486,
-0.0037036319,
0.0689183176,
-0.0251961965,
-0.005174716,
-0.0294189248,
0.0294246189,
0.0509621948,
-0.0326038748,
0.04223511,
0.0077652526,
-0.0166212451,
0.0092042126,
0.08724875,
0.0442853719,
0.042135451,
-0.0228168592,
-0.0197296664,
-0.0331919938,
0.0143867135,
0.0145393666,
0.030376818,
-0.0096616065,
0.0059365276,
-0.0956921875,
-0.0786176473,
-0.006249317,
0.0269443002,
0.0373801924,
0.0150720179,
-0.0010928053,
0.069109261,
-0.0062228357,
0.0174108185,
-0.0929450765,
0.0373664722,
0.0331930518,
-0.0212151892,
-0.0336719975,
-6.197721231e-33,
-0.0493765548,
-0.0391249917,
-0.0242714975,
0.0269228555,
0.0238980688,
0.0220281165,
-0.0204528701,
-0.0054481868,
-0.0090681594,
-0.0113079157,
0.0063479124,
-0.0275533367,
0.0193855055,
0.0041221092,
-0.0248113424,
0.0208512731,
-0.0073344791,
-0.0052843876,
-0.0269444901,
-0.016700929,
0.0456376672,
-0.0065228711,
0.0511670597,
-0.0541283935,
0.0496815257,
-0.0475014485,
-0.0472263284,
0.0303199887,
-0.0037980059,
0.0439215563,
-0.0371879339,
0.0098685063,
0.0178315323,
0.0046438994,
0.0008593908,
-0.0148196714,
-0.025161745,
-0.0013704905,
0.055632025,
-0.0083706053,
-0.00594432,
-0.0220752973,
0.0216322076,
0.000039721,
-0.021078879,
0.0181346629,
0.0456804521,
-0.0343163125,
-0.0083649857,
-0.0401188619,
-0.0609080046,
0.0561842471,
0.0194341056,
0.0026636459,
0.0299583431,
-0.0030110728,
0.0031568285,
0.0117402589,
-0.0167505238,
0.0299725048,
0.0316895656,
0.0541192442,
0.0987984017,
0.0664109513,
0.0266552679,
0.0526598021,
-0.0097556757,
-0.0135975955,
0.0035128181,
0.0168341771,
0.0475324206,
-0.0113066798,
0.0328425802,
0.0209576134,
0.0166295525,
0.0009035561,
-0.0631620958,
0.0413674451,
0.0156840049,
-0.0340998359,
0.0093538538,
0.0046631768,
-0.0340767801,
-0.0090109343,
-0.0646788701,
-0.0410685055,
-0.0243754033,
-0.0001256212,
0.0170256253,
-0.0039957562,
-0.0577243716,
-0.0368878134,
0.0193383675,
-0.0291025229,
-0.0647146627,
-0.0183226392,
-0.0038280708,
0.0259287357,
-0.023053728,
0.0283422433,
-0.0184357185,
-0.0380780846,
0.0160626397,
0.0090124644,
0.0079804212,
0.0021913052,
-0.0058439942,
0.0289058462,
-0.0670724437,
-0.0051022433,
-0.0257366747,
-0.0005290746,
0.0048339106,
0.0271039996,
0.0256171823,
-0.0076000062,
0.0060358131,
-0.0180810411,
0.0557817593,
-0.0159971099,
-0.0045987102,
0.0615684204,
-0.0280364603,
0.0353600085,
-0.0327724367,
0.0134062795,
-0.0148247071,
0.0201791562,
0.0871122256,
0.0140948538,
-0.0058794245,
-0.0067919316,
2.53e-7,
0.0912752002,
-0.0090419371,
0.0076565738,
0.042330239,
-0.0145278918,
0.0205008611,
-0.0186467115,
-0.0018677914,
0.0627081469,
-0.014511372,
-0.045189403,
-0.0010040684,
0.027405601,
0.018698696,
-0.0819252059,
0.0138487136,
-0.01325785,
-0.0109416451,
-0.0105664665,
-0.0086627286,
0.0008729637,
0.0783376917,
0.0311605446,
0.002777454,
-0.031848453,
-0.0546026863,
0.0231119152,
-0.0199945681,
-0.0188723225,
0.0468983799,
0.0237416625,
-0.0364153571,
0.0227226429,
0.0328121409,
-0.0412033834,
0.0141542954,
0.0352341756,
0.0426950902,
-0.009805873,
0.0275058988,
-0.0027573917,
-0.0467530154,
0.0007904764,
-0.0540349409,
0.0346479192,
0.0011472264,
-0.0049472512,
-0.0342052877,
-0.069096759,
0.0396546535,
-0.0240272656,
-0.0357531346,
-0.0739926845,
0.0651860461,
0.0122448299,
0.0058261454,
0.0347321108,
-0.0251710787,
-0.0668371096,
-0.0228150412,
-0.0238550771,
-0.0596960858,
0.0251400284,
-0.0342445076,
-0.0098258369,
-0.0760993436,
0.0122498283,
2.633121351e-34,
0.0178971086,
0.0317217782,
-0.0291653853,
0.0400886349,
0.0311036669,
-0.0134466449,
-0.0087419832,
0.0451113135,
-0.0031071086,
-0.0636622533,
-0.0076763891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15498v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15498v1 | Large Language Models for User Interest Journeys | 2023-05-24T18:40:43 | 2023-05-24T18:40:43 | Konstantina Christakopoulou, Alberto Lalama, Cj Adams, Iris Qu, Yifat Amir, Samer Chucri, Pierce Vollucci, Fabio Soldo, Dina Bseiso, Sarah Scodel, Lucas Dixon, Ed H. Chi, Minmin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in natural
language understanding and generation. Their potential for deeper user
understanding and improved personalized user experience on recommendation
platforms is, however, largely untapped. This paper aims to address this gap.
Recommender systems today capture users' interests through encoding their
historical activities on the platforms. The generated user representations are
hard to examine or interpret. On the other hand, if we were to ask people about
interests they pursue in their life, they might talk about their hobbies, like
I just started learning the ukulele, or their relaxation routines, e.g., I like
to watch Saturday Night Live, or I want to plant a vertical garden. We argue,
and demonstrate through extensive experiments, that LLMs as foundation models
can reason through user activities, and describe their interests in nuanced and
interesting ways, similar to how a human would.
We define interest journeys as the persistent and overarching user interests,
in other words, the non-transient ones. These are the interests that we believe
will benefit most from the nuanced and personalized descriptions. We introduce
a framework in which we first perform personalized extraction of interest
journeys, and then summarize the extracted journeys via LLMs, using techniques
like few-shot prompting, prompt-tuning and fine-tuning. Together, our results
in prompting LLMs to name extracted user journeys in a large-scale industrial
platform demonstrate great potential of these models in providing deeper, more
interpretable, and controllable user understanding. We believe LLM powered user
understanding can be a stepping stone to entirely new user experiences on
recommendation platforms that are journey-aware, assistive, and enabling
frictionless conversation down the line. | [
0.0590678602,
0.0426645875,
-0.0189450104,
0.0536420345,
-0.0029266009,
-0.0159839466,
0.0169687085,
-0.036612533,
0.0226791725,
-0.0139473155,
-0.0274070129,
-0.0094474014,
-0.0193638541,
0.0617961735,
-0.0283421203,
-0.0697269589,
0.0069948952,
-0.0547368042,
-0.0046872203,
0.0124389641,
0.0043215994,
0.0420673564,
0.0125689423,
0.0481646173,
0.0328745507,
-0.0082941195,
-0.0150313815,
-0.0172620043,
-0.005627553,
-0.0292563215,
-0.0102739353,
0.0078705065,
0.0534976609,
0.0277514104,
0.0000021683,
-0.0523107834,
0.001687086,
-0.0352584906,
0.004026514,
-0.040778093,
0.0721145049,
0.0935354158,
0.0268016271,
-0.0163311064,
-0.0257648248,
0.0412540697,
0.0107455431,
0.0306764282,
0.0254666004,
0.0264682975,
-0.0069640265,
-0.0167667698,
-0.0367696024,
-0.0076721846,
0.0570490137,
-0.0128559731,
0.0095425993,
-0.02812282,
0.0339836106,
0.028519677,
-0.004364999,
-0.0251117665,
-0.0105629005,
-0.0233949423,
0.0544056632,
0.0446756408,
0.0121388063,
-0.0438462794,
0.0118668834,
0.0829851106,
0.0097046103,
0.0106192362,
0.0161666423,
0.0083899181,
0.0000070186,
0.0097677941,
-0.057518892,
0.0185558107,
-0.0181288347,
0.001344508,
0.034020599,
0.0139304437,
0.0365616605,
0.0461116582,
-0.0122464905,
0.0659230724,
0.0173329264,
-0.0100637628,
0.0021668549,
-0.0123178791,
0.0810311511,
-0.0650229603,
0.0368841439,
0.0367507078,
-0.0606591292,
0.0206123479,
-0.0225114226,
0.0940312743,
0.0108401459,
-0.0296283178,
0.0109422104,
0.0205396377,
-0.0326998867,
0.05673429,
0.0298074819,
0.0037373863,
0.0010063131,
-0.0455375947,
-0.0335725583,
0.0052013975,
-0.0447344296,
-0.0036481675,
-0.0187041946,
0.0178515334,
-0.0618499033,
-0.0272262208,
-0.0136914076,
0.0741558149,
0.0169143453,
0.0278749485,
-0.0079613887,
0.0283423699,
-0.0124263996,
-0.0016793633,
-0.0562246367,
0.0275110714,
-0.0883430913,
0.0123757934,
0.0268813092,
-0.006067161,
0.0189113431,
0.007795671,
0.0258180983,
-0.0275561027,
-0.0032649022,
-0.0097733168,
0.0405159742,
-0.0369530097,
-0.0516463406,
-0.0933130831,
0.009110936,
-0.0533010587,
-0.0441184193,
-0.0578717291,
0.0508077368,
0.0279227067,
0.0145736625,
-0.0585260503,
0.0089766588,
0.0214502811,
-0.0395494439,
0.0565029196,
-0.0236966237,
-0.0000165605,
-0.000383248,
0.0295770466,
0.0224549323,
-0.0103516802,
0.0134702083,
0.0969245359,
0.0606186129,
0.0012160542,
0.0024136209,
0.0063789994,
-0.052673202,
-0.0314277932,
0.0019395606,
0.0024053499,
-0.0382398702,
0.0226170905,
0.030693192,
0.0401668474,
-0.0256132204,
0.0265567694,
0.0841618702,
0.079026185,
-0.0028988789,
0.0319139659,
0.0640437752,
0.0100461282,
-0.0343094021,
-0.0116298357,
-0.0024237623,
0.0218432695,
-0.0136916908,
-0.0336224735,
0.0556931384,
0.0210619848,
-0.0358137637,
-0.0075001461,
0.0414232276,
-0.0281926617,
0.0737957135,
0.0423109047,
0.0373469591,
-0.0440632664,
-0.0076976065,
0.0223376993,
0.037950132,
-0.0556114987,
0.0464728512,
-0.0214710999,
0.0731560215,
0.1576093435,
0.0348123237,
0.0038820656,
-0.0041746832,
-0.0089334315,
0.013399248,
-0.0115361884,
0.0600327514,
-0.0291757789,
0.0185359363,
-0.0359111205,
-0.0310945306,
0.002109597,
-0.0200506616,
0.0082165431,
-0.0284873191,
-0.0178440791,
0.0025445991,
-0.0397867039,
-0.0290399604,
-0.0243497174,
-0.04998485,
-0.0268523898,
0.0229934398,
0.0186537802,
-0.0018446137,
0.0585114397,
0.0277886931,
-0.0044908104,
0.0258249119,
-0.0259144586,
0.0072111604,
0.0318313278,
-0.0098860608,
0.0393582284,
0.038257394,
0.0004544376,
0.013369686,
-0.0080858497,
0.0156151075,
-0.0357425772,
0.0022540467,
-0.0028178468,
0.0165203363,
-0.0057189493,
0.0155099854,
0.0018253509,
-0.0032097849,
-0.037615981,
0.0731958523,
0.0124160033,
-0.0006627796,
-0.0153852673,
-0.0295719467,
-0.0015468833,
-0.062110167,
-0.0337492637,
0.0455699377,
0.0360062532,
0.008217359,
0.061583437,
-0.0335786529,
-0.0721052662,
-0.0055736667,
-0.0906457454,
0.0039344444,
0.0028360132,
0.0159345623,
-0.0078796614,
0.0666407943,
-0.0029908412,
-0.0252640992,
-0.0432382934,
0.0116919698,
-0.0143052153,
0.0196022578,
0.0346869044,
0.0309455656,
-0.0195431113,
-0.0213788208,
0.0009111973,
-0.0237582475,
0.0319392979,
0.0250613485,
0.0185692851,
-0.0641878918,
-0.0594321191,
-0.0550597385,
-0.0311238896,
-0.0331802554,
0.0328872353,
0.0123141771,
-0.0313134566,
0.0597515628,
0.0177139938,
0.0307469051,
0.0655812994,
0.0395590439,
-0.0334032662,
-0.0338950679,
-0.0013973836,
-0.0457822159,
0.0116450498,
-0.0435676016,
-0.023509115,
0.0296936613,
0.0085455533,
-0.016668098,
0.0277690999,
-0.0751331002,
0.0217041019,
0.0030037512,
0.027700793,
-0.0290753581,
0.0093305605,
-0.0199811235,
0.0695332363,
0.0198978148,
-0.0063175638,
0.081956327,
-0.0015098484,
0.0055061639,
-0.0167048816,
-0.0613214634,
-0.0367820561,
0.0776233748,
-0.0195914898,
0.0538744479,
0.0058700112,
-0.0274135396,
0.0055384343,
-0.0061426545,
0.0030867788,
-0.0678342655,
0.03557311,
-0.021982925,
-0.0202244613,
0.0420861058,
-0.031721238,
-0.0400507487,
-0.0959522724,
-0.0539955124,
-0.0239456948,
-0.0127704516,
-0.0300954599,
-0.0306945853,
-0.0196111929,
0.0169902965,
-0.0015340305,
-0.001792929,
-0.0296325907,
-0.0038280946,
0.0088384543,
0.075822033,
-0.001111009,
-0.0047146464,
-0.0076701581,
0.0417363234,
0.0207827482,
-0.0165447295,
-0.0225958303,
-0.0405685939,
0.0034495324,
0.0423517637,
-0.0503568389,
-0.0126237804,
0.0642830655,
0.0429483801,
-0.012303994,
-0.0116868848,
0.1195046008,
0.02003414,
-0.0818745345,
0.0323582627,
-0.0012897028,
0.0157031305,
0.0227334592,
0.0534241907,
-0.069848597,
-0.0251722615,
-0.0115199424,
0.0446410812,
0.0102649424,
-0.0485483967,
-0.0405443907,
-0.0995160937,
0.015365894,
0.0073239957,
-0.0052477294,
-0.0040570246,
-0.0694504827,
-0.0135796545,
0.00524054,
0.0045686797,
0.0111535005,
-0.0243796669,
-0.0059615667,
0.0076057087,
-0.0204177555,
-0.055810269,
0.0451790318,
-0.0380975604,
0.0514495224,
0.0276463162,
0.0418282337,
0.028003443,
-0.0434967875,
-0.0246323459,
0.0258937441,
0.0168205611,
-0.0176407248,
0.029274568,
-0.0099881208,
0.0166780259,
-0.0463337079,
0.0557680428,
-0.0510180704,
-0.0349389277,
-0.0036897596,
0.0621032305,
-0.0338007212,
-0.0007960189,
-0.0050660772,
0.0268727336,
0.0458449274,
0.0708685294,
0.0021116785,
-0.0848002955,
0.0034902308,
-0.0575815998,
-0.0128355557,
0.0158588719,
-0.0541054718,
-0.0167387221,
-0.0088381805,
0.0022718715,
-0.0373923108,
-0.0559328981,
0.020405313,
0.0101165595,
0.0009437726,
0.0336068943,
-0.0069332789,
-0.0101483194,
-0.0213114116,
0.0709296539,
-0.0309967753,
0.0332244672,
-0.0532177128,
-0.0070474911,
0.0158554651,
-0.0701584443,
0.0106998971,
-0.0219919328,
-0.0679301694,
-0.0408650897,
-0.0268108062,
0.0181195084,
0.0167447105,
0.0391765572,
-0.0080489609,
-0.0901363343,
-0.0115715452,
-0.000315333,
-0.0299460609,
-0.0444372855,
-0.0291863251,
0.0627400354,
-0.0241821278,
0.0327228568,
-0.060126394,
-0.0240057968,
-0.0469834358,
0.0305774268,
-0.0421885289,
-0.0508370139,
0.0252095237,
0.0085531306,
0.0415448099,
-0.0186599456,
0.020947611,
-0.0104316054,
-0.0107058641,
0.0085524209,
-0.0555799268,
-0.0223197043,
-0.0331456326,
0.0255248621,
-0.0445162654,
-0.0086754058,
-0.0377206206,
-0.0387655832,
0.0166592132,
-0.0853608027,
-0.0031023833,
-0.0233571865,
-0.0151266959,
0.0261649713,
0.0198415909,
-0.0202212259,
0.0189707931,
0.0137831056,
0.0442655832,
-0.0266012494,
0.0736896098,
-0.0048472085,
0.0059145251,
-0.0409813672,
0.0198409483,
-0.0236634184,
-0.0633468702,
0.0542181097,
-0.0039093066,
0.0402774364,
-0.0312910229,
0.038581863,
-0.0196127277,
0.0039595976,
-0.0249921829,
0.00910044,
0.0147282146,
-0.0422586203,
0.0192535967,
0.0323298052,
0.0005754529,
0.0086929612,
0.0648417696,
-0.0313692167,
0.008421638,
0.0201850198,
-0.0505250767,
-0.050942678,
0.0153312609,
-0.0028088146,
0.0699560046,
-0.0382422283,
0.0112227248,
-0.0508863889,
-0.0265426096,
-0.0066178138,
-0.0281933006,
0.0085352203,
-0.0473310575,
0.068224214,
0.0321787074,
-0.0119118709,
-0.0052240151,
-0.0690759048,
0.0126221171,
-0.0459393449,
-0.0123079149,
-0.0465136394,
-6.747197249e-33,
0.0172838811,
-0.0249318257,
0.0431682952,
0.0237850193,
-0.0287239067,
-0.0312859863,
-0.0357946418,
0.0290536713,
0.020840764,
0.0020593014,
-0.0128085613,
-0.0272960756,
0.0004345438,
0.0226103198,
0.0034001549,
-0.0268360041,
0.0785283819,
0.0476056635,
-0.0283790343,
0.0621152222,
0.0763590634,
0.0182805285,
-0.0056995056,
-0.0700535402,
0.0543257967,
-0.0051285014,
0.0056279837,
0.026386166,
0.0487427749,
0.0632866323,
-0.0110924663,
0.0480587147,
0.0112020597,
-0.0208733492,
-0.0081130993,
0.0197077524,
-0.0753048211,
-0.0207800213,
0.0550921448,
0.0130495485,
0.0034172346,
-0.0476983078,
0.0072257896,
-0.0155133596,
-0.0033339066,
0.0183134042,
0.0299805235,
-0.0055338386,
-0.025455771,
-0.0228384957,
-0.0145416614,
0.0066520427,
-0.0219065268,
-0.0383418016,
0.0429490842,
0.0093152113,
-0.0070160842,
0.0504872687,
-0.0217269566,
0.0716003031,
-0.0453575514,
0.0088307559,
0.0236831084,
-0.0038164123,
-0.0150758196,
0.0566702895,
-0.0063369935,
0.0047791419,
-0.0060337065,
0.0273541491,
-0.0254820958,
0.0612063929,
-0.0567314886,
-0.0036014481,
-0.0080916006,
0.000101079,
-0.0049716113,
0.0507872887,
0.0474522039,
0.0035784624,
0.0490801334,
0.0234954562,
-0.0098070819,
-0.0298487004,
-0.0213130843,
-0.0064110053,
-0.0469080545,
-0.0259891469,
0.008006053,
0.0119436691,
-0.0415180698,
-0.0127389915,
0.0102411341,
-0.0389424786,
-0.0460540764,
0.0368135087,
-0.0272824485,
-0.0269713923,
0.0105165998,
-0.0039039347,
-0.0177923404,
-0.0050907978,
-0.0131773353,
-0.0558563285,
-0.0109458575,
0.0283974689,
-0.0241120234,
0.0078751678,
-0.0127110872,
-0.008167332,
-0.0045829765,
-0.026940288,
-0.0453726128,
0.021995673,
0.0689965561,
0.025044091,
-0.0440041758,
0.0823851079,
0.0321085677,
0.028560698,
-0.0071649398,
-0.057525713,
0.0186382346,
0.0118127717,
-0.0260928478,
-0.0275757965,
-0.0326499715,
0.0123008909,
0.0666431189,
-0.0301504564,
-0.0229017735,
-0.017980244,
2.893e-7,
-0.0267013647,
0.0621767342,
-0.0375808068,
0.0285333097,
0.007781242,
0.0339500681,
0.0207214653,
0.0297668725,
0.0046902481,
0.0149055449,
0.0089358687,
0.0268377066,
0.024284834,
0.0247694254,
-0.0473572351,
-0.0003744989,
-0.0069667827,
0.0229656678,
-0.097762756,
0.0266504493,
0.0544698723,
0.0482023917,
0.0447978154,
0.0009965056,
0.0117143253,
-0.023227429,
0.0324743465,
-0.0580829196,
-0.0328715108,
-0.0064955126,
0.0109003,
0.0085666524,
-0.0120390421,
-0.038742315,
-0.0184073839,
0.0218610335,
-0.0232669562,
0.0498294681,
-0.0194025524,
-0.0219409745,
-0.0118111549,
0.0012537792,
0.0143254362,
-0.0410236977,
0.0388302766,
0.0196400397,
-0.0397087522,
-0.0322055481,
0.0011213361,
-0.0223259609,
-0.0062292628,
-0.0222396869,
-0.0406471714,
-0.0189537741,
0.0102529749,
0.0081242556,
-0.022415949,
-0.0895381197,
0.0176004674,
0.0097569646,
-0.0492600389,
-0.031688869,
-0.0525069982,
0.0373904854,
-0.0015906859,
-0.0342409424,
0.03919385,
2.407212459e-34,
0.0027857593,
0.0593089424,
-0.0215307791,
-0.0039788401,
0.0432227403,
0.004604944,
0.0083347736,
0.0168519933,
0.0874580517,
-0.0764506012,
-0.0185319465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15408v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15408v5 | Towards Revealing the Mystery behind Chain of Thought: A Theoretical Perspective | 2023-05-24T17:59:21 | 2023-12-23T02:39:56 | Guhao Feng, Bohang Zhang, Yuntian Gu, Haotian Ye, Di He, Liwei Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CC, cs.CL, stat.ML | Recent studies have discovered that Chain-of-Thought prompting (CoT) can
dramatically improve the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs),
particularly when dealing with complex tasks involving mathematics or
reasoning. Despite the enormous empirical success, the underlying mechanisms
behind CoT and how it unlocks the potential of LLMs remain elusive. In this
paper, we take a first step towards theoretically answering these questions.
Specifically, we examine the expressivity of LLMs with CoT in solving
fundamental mathematical and decision-making problems. By using circuit
complexity theory, we first give impossibility results showing that
bounded-depth Transformers are unable to directly produce correct answers for
basic arithmetic/equation tasks unless the model size grows super-polynomially
with respect to the input length. In contrast, we then prove by construction
that autoregressive Transformers of constant size suffice to solve both tasks
by generating CoT derivations using a commonly used math language format.
Moreover, we show LLMs with CoT can handle a general class of decision-making
problems known as Dynamic Programming, thus justifying its power in tackling
complex real-world tasks. Finally, an extensive set of experiments show that,
while Transformers always fail to directly predict the answers, they can
consistently learn to generate correct solutions step-by-step given sufficient
CoT demonstrations. | [
0.0022416948,
0.0915053263,
-0.0142391194,
0.0227041952,
-0.0595842488,
0.0052442411,
0.0125255324,
-0.009772718,
-0.0257993154,
-0.0115649952,
0.0099845817,
-0.0232343506,
0.0274770912,
0.0234672092,
0.0358177274,
-0.0545320734,
0.0230231881,
-0.08515203,
-0.0348470323,
-0.0380838253,
-0.0474955887,
-0.0599699467,
-0.0448548496,
0.0307794549,
-0.0259535145,
-0.03308158,
-0.0262239445,
-0.0633150637,
0.0100428443,
-0.0207528416,
-0.0399830639,
0.0357451327,
0.0217710752,
0.0789866596,
0.0000022996,
-0.0336791202,
-0.0001482131,
0.0230524372,
-0.0623447709,
-0.0182820391,
-0.0590113886,
0.0235891435,
0.0136058107,
0.0234318227,
-0.0499118492,
0.0209234878,
0.0525377244,
0.0234439168,
0.0457625464,
0.035519179,
0.0061443951,
-0.0247839931,
0.0372397266,
-0.0307018347,
0.0005465726,
-0.0455290042,
0.0244429149,
-0.0027159001,
0.0002130368,
-0.0181914326,
-0.0515356772,
0.0160918124,
0.0447300263,
-0.0011550935,
-0.0067868,
0.0352619737,
-0.0006755086,
0.0010216675,
-0.0080987317,
0.0367906541,
-0.0263202209,
0.0105835628,
-0.0025264325,
-0.0072499015,
-0.0168081801,
0.0226886962,
-0.0314028673,
0.02468515,
-0.0136244316,
0.0041646804,
-0.0289820172,
0.01099505,
0.0205535982,
-0.0214564092,
-0.0512421913,
0.0914984271,
-0.0146344285,
-0.0514689758,
0.0269009005,
0.036792174,
-0.0006827624,
-0.0734470636,
0.0036266115,
0.0453243442,
-0.0031169979,
0.0059514656,
0.0129147675,
-0.0216977485,
-0.0515952483,
-0.0239434931,
0.0633136183,
0.0455581844,
0.0212571844,
0.0073409597,
-0.0186138861,
0.0750083998,
-0.0762838721,
0.002027492,
-0.0209732968,
0.0578723475,
-0.0172478948,
-0.014315539,
-0.0479291938,
0.0864054635,
-0.0069912691,
-0.0084846038,
-0.0461063571,
0.0202963389,
-0.0435208417,
0.0130437184,
-0.0305396728,
-0.0045939833,
0.0011858232,
-0.0339288227,
-0.0756686702,
0.0468970314,
-0.0213704053,
0.0177157372,
0.0322757587,
-0.0027823932,
-0.0161624271,
-0.0229642186,
-0.0058542066,
0.0056876685,
0.0082824873,
0.1159847155,
-0.0259829666,
-0.0230303947,
-0.0111196833,
-0.0226530805,
0.0104194526,
-0.0717161372,
0.0254602022,
-0.078744404,
0.0067128087,
0.0177458264,
-0.0167180449,
0.0030880587,
0.023440972,
0.024654096,
0.0102918213,
0.0618289374,
0.0505268872,
0.0044194576,
0.0247531757,
-0.0209653452,
-0.0452965461,
0.0364762433,
0.0567335114,
0.0172737408,
-0.0322053656,
0.0076651718,
0.04798517,
0.0333938636,
0.0131344441,
-0.0020664458,
0.0012368844,
-0.0142945731,
-0.0025208627,
0.0398795903,
-0.0544308424,
0.0735793188,
-0.0320299678,
0.0295923594,
0.0392124131,
0.0513193645,
0.0420331322,
0.0621527545,
0.0338594578,
-0.0104659088,
0.0315767936,
0.0437633544,
-0.0621779002,
0.0481270552,
-0.0348367542,
0.0177180208,
0.0181096364,
-0.007992682,
-0.0152434921,
-0.0706119984,
0.0152786076,
0.012585531,
-0.0100883842,
0.0015081194,
0.040765781,
-0.0098194005,
-0.0279737189,
0.0552829616,
-0.0106669636,
0.0080553731,
-0.0213716924,
-0.0729734227,
0.0110114263,
-0.0070993942,
0.0546499714,
-0.0340072922,
0.0229497217,
-0.0314820707,
-0.0073892688,
0.0430768356,
0.0107797356,
0.0050299345,
-0.0258854274,
0.0042549917,
-0.0099596921,
-0.0055666151,
0.0135442214,
0.0089900922,
-0.0016478142,
-0.016493883,
0.0041806726,
0.0397538766,
0.0311581269,
-0.0053444635,
-0.0460361019,
-0.0222964548,
0.0259800367,
0.0300606545,
0.0257475972,
-0.0127493748,
-0.0054180534,
0.0442724079,
-0.0137249362,
-0.0313653536,
-0.0474897549,
-0.0253948346,
-0.0835495293,
-0.0054395534,
0.0122184614,
-0.0660805553,
0.0031307787,
0.0090782261,
-0.0200158171,
-0.0345729515,
0.0591591224,
-0.0800813884,
0.024062328,
0.0181350317,
-0.0006649127,
0.0000788532,
-0.0219353121,
-0.0185848009,
0.0835008398,
-0.0082587339,
0.0150110582,
0.0295991153,
-0.020718243,
-0.0017405483,
-0.0062447996,
-0.0004448139,
-0.0139955264,
-0.0209925435,
0.0063515897,
0.0150060914,
-0.003907064,
0.0013133439,
-0.0430447087,
0.0014165237,
-0.0444057547,
-0.0012557742,
0.0416517518,
-0.0447063223,
-0.0168264434,
0.0220297072,
0.0092306463,
-0.0456822626,
0.0216910616,
-0.0049212007,
0.0137424245,
0.0450528376,
0.0157869644,
-0.0380618833,
-0.0220479481,
-0.0283023287,
-0.0161941834,
0.0658122227,
0.0078493012,
-0.0108411554,
-0.0185969677,
0.0485073403,
-0.002175279,
0.0415315628,
-0.0291159973,
0.0168133229,
0.033020027,
-0.0249474645,
0.0754942223,
0.0538568757,
0.0288999882,
-0.0141482279,
0.0314483494,
-0.0339492299,
-0.0353992544,
0.0379493497,
-0.0530432835,
-0.0170180984,
-0.0254119933,
0.0116867442,
-0.0121893585,
0.090996623,
-0.0215018,
-0.0121274265,
-0.052961342,
-0.0064833602,
-0.0016777827,
-0.0031582396,
-0.0273656677,
-0.0260373745,
-0.0185881015,
0.076419495,
0.0296064541,
-0.0415334627,
0.0765091628,
0.0066309567,
0.0021442184,
-0.0085450606,
0.0108601023,
-0.0660610646,
0.0577195399,
0.0140221287,
-0.0187223218,
-0.0095694084,
0.0003307223,
-0.0686538294,
0.0091396598,
0.0106053958,
-0.0300096422,
0.1010100991,
-0.0381298251,
0.0089923544,
-0.0196368732,
-0.0737952515,
-0.0678653046,
0.0095307911,
-0.0393143818,
-0.0049036802,
0.0205543749,
-0.0422332883,
-0.0373144969,
-0.0017095725,
0.0734333694,
0.034521725,
-0.0230133589,
-0.0602419563,
-0.000778434,
0.0054957289,
0.0128833586,
0.0341570973,
0.0699331015,
-0.0475107431,
0.0672085807,
0.0249043349,
0.0378650241,
0.0287235416,
-0.0228148792,
0.0121513605,
-0.0028895854,
0.0077708703,
-0.0334640704,
0.0535010882,
-0.0225537103,
-0.0255993418,
-0.0378290303,
0.0731644109,
0.0089233108,
-0.0509303771,
0.0187214315,
-0.0700222105,
0.0179026276,
0.0254887994,
0.0290277023,
-0.1094861105,
-0.0088544153,
0.0211170334,
-0.0045281081,
-0.0243235715,
-0.0446516573,
-0.0184808224,
-0.1174455583,
-0.00177499,
0.0014655971,
0.0355377533,
0.0013692663,
0.0119465785,
-0.0090358714,
0.0101764724,
-0.0492100753,
0.0029881592,
-0.0052900077,
-0.0030260209,
0.0256887004,
-0.0415542349,
0.0098206736,
0.0261688083,
0.0169543009,
-0.0327005312,
0.0331311598,
-0.0078789741,
-0.0119777489,
-0.0512828156,
0.0219551511,
0.0429467373,
-0.0045917928,
0.0123436982,
-0.0069392854,
0.0212026946,
-0.0137174837,
-0.0132336114,
0.0373157896,
-0.0132932849,
-0.0042017745,
0.0366441645,
0.1035199389,
-0.014425789,
-0.0232568532,
-0.0135532217,
0.0016826382,
-0.0141157629,
0.0217713043,
0.0145671451,
-0.0440827087,
-0.045925796,
-0.0495304838,
-0.0253537353,
-0.0035759641,
-0.0619325526,
-0.0089946557,
0.0770087242,
0.0166823491,
-0.0284648221,
0.0236343294,
-0.0071650161,
0.0565611161,
0.018358659,
-0.0429010876,
0.0609232001,
0.0345482938,
0.0062150364,
-0.0093717314,
-0.0200232938,
0.0407023132,
-0.0723469183,
0.0312134642,
-0.0066450089,
-0.0537245683,
-0.0380445644,
0.0081992783,
-0.1073234379,
-0.0439270698,
0.0128603298,
0.0376570858,
0.0301882289,
-0.0198916979,
0.0241005532,
-0.0001108356,
0.0362330787,
0.052881632,
-0.0195356719,
0.012302421,
0.0664937794,
0.0399496444,
0.0214767829,
0.0326778069,
-0.0312911905,
0.0250992794,
0.0213350393,
0.0389652289,
-0.02012177,
-0.0387938246,
0.0401456058,
0.0137761822,
0.0159135256,
0.0360296369,
0.052049242,
-0.0125775663,
0.055539947,
-0.0032375318,
-0.0064456556,
-0.0726334155,
-0.0263195299,
0.0035818687,
0.0093056159,
0.0352415554,
-0.0571750291,
0.0579341389,
0.0133566214,
0.0225516111,
0.0138811469,
0.0096095735,
0.0117215058,
0.0709830597,
-0.0113107627,
0.0054558045,
0.0032061921,
0.0158374012,
0.0246445462,
0.0156346262,
0.0724096149,
0.0312482268,
-0.0026646473,
-0.0526653901,
-0.0184966363,
-0.0816765502,
-0.0893789902,
0.0317465551,
0.0295398142,
0.0248466302,
0.0399779044,
-0.0740987584,
-0.0744522437,
0.0180778224,
0.0258825179,
0.0175254066,
-0.008336693,
-0.0270191487,
0.0203340352,
0.0351636671,
0.035414312,
-0.0427909084,
0.0613635369,
-0.0192671679,
0.0023408895,
-0.0053567337,
0.0461940765,
-0.0305108819,
-0.0469330847,
-0.0408062041,
-0.0011026844,
0.024189366,
0.0107710082,
-0.1009157151,
-0.0562091507,
-0.0271526743,
-0.0138755022,
0.0357837677,
-0.0513481237,
0.0622521564,
0.0485047735,
0.0202509072,
0.0028676053,
0.0237916764,
0.0420796648,
0.0110750189,
-0.006163999,
-0.0436264686,
-6.089344325e-33,
-0.0033514898,
-0.0345628485,
0.0504606366,
0.0456707254,
-0.007101764,
0.0163662955,
-0.0385935903,
0.0261523277,
-0.0012595918,
0.0011709788,
-0.0334373936,
-0.0043073315,
-0.0054075499,
0.0309273247,
0.0333020203,
-0.0165957306,
0.0145067796,
-0.0211412497,
-0.0364096388,
-0.0152830044,
0.0160391033,
-0.0163018983,
0.0214882046,
-0.0267200638,
-0.0084083481,
0.0029767342,
-0.0001491636,
0.0245629642,
-0.059005022,
0.0463548079,
-0.0279596336,
0.031927567,
-0.0051222467,
-0.061662212,
-0.0205782633,
0.0464791693,
-0.0244075786,
-0.0220675152,
-0.013255137,
-0.0094836848,
-0.0610916838,
-0.0010494246,
0.015346596,
0.0188926347,
-0.0406750739,
-0.0438957065,
0.0030364904,
-0.0212490316,
0.0008973528,
-0.0289579201,
-0.0302651841,
0.0023796926,
-0.0158745535,
-0.0387384929,
0.0262236893,
0.0732050836,
-0.0267650094,
-0.0236154795,
-0.0141058452,
0.0380124748,
0.0728950277,
0.0259906873,
0.0397308208,
-0.007013686,
0.0011181998,
0.0299734939,
0.0187423248,
-0.0057301782,
-0.0622624755,
-0.0393416099,
-0.0092178276,
0.0552313663,
0.0694763958,
-0.0217724405,
0.0416010655,
0.0485734046,
-0.0673890337,
-0.0560280755,
-0.0131420344,
0.0605364479,
0.0445152633,
-0.0256806202,
-0.038276948,
-0.0294675231,
-0.0338439308,
0.036908105,
-0.0384836718,
-0.0112594971,
-0.0040460136,
0.0216947403,
0.0213851612,
-0.0229117032,
0.0199890118,
-0.0453813784,
-0.0034595777,
0.0188975185,
0.0126440031,
0.045980487,
0.0129121915,
0.0074668042,
-0.0557922013,
-0.0114010479,
-0.0522417836,
0.0231386721,
0.0123447264,
0.0129794562,
-0.0129256248,
0.0383622758,
-0.0388517678,
-0.0406375378,
-0.0691123605,
0.025690563,
0.0236800462,
0.0224376135,
0.0315596908,
0.0031516645,
-0.0254146401,
0.0045086103,
-0.0666479617,
-0.0342440233,
-0.0108387852,
0.0677139834,
-0.0233677793,
0.0534658581,
-0.0060967351,
-0.0358887315,
-0.0573634431,
0.025349699,
0.0521393977,
-0.0650866702,
-0.037762735,
0.0310174525,
3.08e-7,
-0.0231696907,
0.0405685045,
0.0326425284,
0.0474675447,
0.0384671837,
0.0463070534,
-0.0098119983,
0.002714487,
0.0064578662,
-0.0315166563,
0.0037934,
0.0349751338,
0.0273648798,
0.0266111158,
-0.0488810316,
-0.0389324017,
-0.0798353553,
0.0171635635,
-0.0062905205,
-0.018231554,
0.0399379134,
0.0456692465,
0.0147971874,
-0.0017046341,
-0.0343312211,
-0.0021878751,
0.050434012,
0.0137540884,
0.0385914147,
-0.0123122325,
-0.022582287,
-0.0231577158,
0.0110594239,
0.0310674496,
0.018698629,
0.0357888639,
-0.021473214,
0.0307539199,
0.0706294924,
0.0073570157,
-0.0089404788,
-0.0165050719,
-0.0049430714,
-0.0317180529,
0.0428317152,
-0.0949619934,
-0.0252839066,
-0.0289795548,
0.0208978932,
-0.0376112014,
0.0235795528,
0.0202170685,
0.0356261507,
-0.0288416687,
-0.005038925,
-0.0001300992,
0.0500617474,
-0.032432504,
-0.0057509383,
0.0295816474,
-0.0587357357,
-0.032239221,
-0.0572561845,
0.0153530519,
0.0228268169,
0.00153802,
-0.0186269656,
2.848373422e-34,
0.0348568298,
-0.0361454077,
0.0299295746,
0.0360249504,
0.0289618503,
-0.0129399914,
-0.0264902804,
0.0122747524,
0.0647841245,
-0.0812163576,
-0.0521521829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15405v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15405v2 | Textless Low-Resource Speech-to-Speech Translation With Unit Language Models | 2023-05-24T17:59:05 | 2024-02-20T18:55:52 | Anuj Diwan, Anirudh Srinivasan, David Harwath, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Existing speech-to-speech translation models fall into two camps: textless
models trained with hundreds of hours of parallel speech data or unsupervised
models that leverage text as an intermediate step. Both approaches limit
building speech-to-speech translation models for a wide range of languages, as
they exclude languages that are primarily spoken and language pairs that lack
large-scale parallel speech data. We present a new framework for training
textless low-resource speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) systems that only
need dozens of hours of parallel speech data. We reformulate S2ST as a
unit-to-unit seq2seq translation task, and start by pretraining a model on
large-scale monolingual speech data. Then, we finetune it with a small amount
of parallel speech data ($20-60$ hours). Lastly, we improve model performance
through an unsupervised backtranslation objective. We train and evaluate our
models for English-to-German, German-to-English and Marathi-to-English
translation on three different domains (European Parliament, Common Voice, and
All India Radio) with single-speaker synthesized speech data. Evaluated using
the ASR-BLEU metric, our models achieve reasonable performance on all three
domains, with some being within 1-2 points of our supervised topline. | [
0.0020382921,
0.0613639392,
0.0275853407,
0.0078155734,
-0.0259414669,
0.0068092798,
0.0736429468,
-0.0108477566,
-0.0716882572,
-0.0208730772,
-0.0368199348,
-0.0431566052,
0.052573543,
-0.0150374128,
0.0246720929,
-0.0442196317,
0.0143433101,
-0.0298972744,
-0.0181753151,
0.004045011,
0.0028716915,
0.0264110845,
-0.0453740694,
0.0137505978,
-0.0322564617,
0.0237466078,
-0.0141606266,
0.0542102754,
0.0291315019,
-0.0090131816,
-0.0438755229,
-0.0022951476,
0.0406665392,
0.055157721,
0.0000016328,
-0.0337871797,
-0.021596808,
0.0147690317,
-0.0351623595,
0.0063177641,
0.0700260997,
-0.0534910411,
-0.0277992245,
0.0566881523,
-0.0018822878,
-0.0155854803,
0.0637111142,
0.0264113732,
0.0114776213,
0.1026602983,
-0.0380471721,
-0.0384195969,
-0.0032322225,
-0.0675142929,
-0.0361573435,
-0.0181197971,
-0.04031891,
-0.0266793761,
-0.0375358053,
0.0197333824,
-0.0287200958,
0.0601275936,
-0.0255263001,
-0.0057431394,
-0.0058224602,
-0.0081934035,
-0.0198688917,
-0.0492838062,
0.0133358417,
0.0787806362,
-0.0449003391,
-0.0104912613,
0.0255227536,
0.0030365726,
-0.0569312833,
-0.0291102882,
-0.0234050192,
0.0206375737,
0.0402028374,
0.0009496296,
-0.0024858944,
0.0551751629,
0.0394248217,
-0.0509556942,
-0.0290789604,
-0.0140413065,
0.0232932251,
-0.0250095148,
0.0179206952,
-0.0167351589,
-0.0182651095,
-0.0095184445,
0.0258025713,
-0.0001753447,
0.0129141295,
0.0214486457,
-0.0223906487,
-0.0561688915,
-0.0274140853,
-0.0428970531,
0.0150380423,
0.0703380629,
0.0042080437,
0.0229952354,
-0.0146952216,
0.0306717996,
0.0001301043,
-0.0087926295,
-0.0488107018,
-0.0096989069,
0.0095219323,
0.0485741533,
-0.0527303889,
-0.0166070256,
-0.086259678,
-0.019470742,
0.0179414004,
-0.0276009757,
0.0235105883,
0.0212606844,
0.0664327815,
-0.0027119955,
-0.0980679542,
-0.0399650075,
0.0307745971,
0.0854656175,
0.0141256191,
0.0117734708,
-0.0009247445,
-0.0743943825,
-0.0266843066,
0.0291447863,
0.0128070107,
-0.0241540838,
-0.008645962,
0.0441454388,
-0.0278203301,
-0.0012844973,
-0.0496299379,
0.0042147771,
-0.0105481679,
-0.0658426955,
-0.0211068392,
-0.0823614672,
0.0401104353,
0.0163167454,
0.0473982245,
-0.0130779631,
0.0177605189,
-0.0064328625,
-0.0034395121,
0.0774427503,
0.0150640979,
0.0206169225,
0.0380104817,
0.0096222237,
0.0259302333,
0.0633899346,
0.0706200227,
-0.0052909823,
0.007516433,
-0.0029496248,
-0.0486645512,
0.0781949535,
0.0273647327,
0.0624468662,
-0.0502921268,
-0.0008423612,
0.0238308273,
0.0342126489,
0.0260402393,
0.0477109849,
0.0036413926,
0.0099069541,
0.0471598469,
0.0383163616,
0.0487189293,
0.0445456281,
0.0647258535,
0.0161913317,
-0.0251023471,
-0.0263357591,
0.0037282971,
0.0101874322,
0.0252962802,
-0.0053320676,
0.0585759059,
0.0197096579,
-0.0451060906,
0.0076473621,
-0.0084506301,
-0.0415476076,
0.0050163469,
-0.0279300641,
0.0472664759,
0.0323083773,
-0.0608967803,
0.0237987246,
-0.0116262585,
-0.0792112276,
0.0476702154,
0.0256632306,
-0.0299785528,
0.0218561832,
0.0188214555,
0.0396974571,
0.0007237996,
-0.0624745488,
0.0127943614,
0.0627855808,
0.0443424508,
-0.002756719,
0.080542624,
-0.0751550943,
0.0005482126,
0.0482256413,
-0.0045064292,
0.0076363636,
-0.0222463589,
0.045887094,
0.0425874889,
-0.0301604606,
-0.0158458203,
-0.0080255894,
-0.0275039226,
-0.038243182,
0.0443017967,
0.036327105,
0.0406347886,
0.0235764384,
-0.0121587384,
0.009279279,
0.0143796541,
-0.0479232371,
-0.0068143671,
0.0273458846,
-0.0535661019,
-0.0541417859,
0.0011246251,
-0.0202561319,
0.0478334539,
0.0512130186,
-0.0006068225,
-0.110714376,
0.0132952305,
-0.0231208839,
0.0263805203,
-0.0082598068,
0.026296638,
0.0486662798,
-0.0070464448,
0.0031315584,
-0.0189104974,
0.037745744,
-0.0019366193,
0.0154071376,
0.0443205647,
0.0626672655,
-0.0646084026,
-0.0123236692,
-0.002710348,
-0.0113487178,
0.0391514748,
0.0290920381,
-0.004593086,
-0.0002669698,
0.0096703488,
-0.0962185264,
0.0226420257,
-0.0240711533,
0.0159680676,
0.0180018824,
0.0873001367,
0.0415398739,
-0.0292132907,
-0.0146768084,
-0.0522716865,
0.0178147871,
-0.018169554,
-0.049533613,
-0.0098749064,
-0.0112219136,
-0.0099460436,
-0.0110664796,
0.0125012295,
0.0074825943,
-0.0111795207,
0.0003079122,
-0.0282850862,
0.0673972443,
0.0013188152,
0.0318489671,
-0.004202296,
-0.0520003103,
-0.0119056152,
-0.0151507528,
0.0577736609,
0.0499878116,
-0.0044427589,
-0.0310620256,
-0.0092416555,
-0.0034426595,
-0.0735992789,
-0.0042858059,
-0.0036036698,
-0.0039907582,
-0.0151517522,
-0.0060187262,
-0.0161147341,
0.054014992,
0.0060495455,
0.027238071,
-0.0672614425,
-0.0382802561,
-0.017889915,
0.0034955209,
-0.0202029254,
0.0311575197,
0.0011993719,
0.0116174929,
-0.012596353,
-0.0228962079,
0.0034522044,
-0.0903525874,
-0.0408867039,
-0.0566060171,
-0.004543399,
-0.0296612624,
0.0080783721,
-0.0335633345,
0.0243333578,
-0.0714312494,
-0.004914375,
-0.0313208364,
0.027969474,
-0.0129410662,
-0.0144310417,
0.0301053878,
-0.0360129252,
0.0261691753,
-0.0577315465,
-0.0367571861,
-0.0092427125,
-0.0036766932,
-0.0165557619,
0.0261582043,
0.0074718953,
-0.0436399467,
-0.0498324819,
0.0512390919,
0.0007768306,
0.0703908429,
0.0010760605,
0.0227729362,
-0.0155321574,
0.0451215357,
0.0229920335,
-0.0102560492,
0.002852753,
-0.0466901921,
0.0353668928,
-0.0191898067,
0.0759724304,
0.0116867134,
-0.0441443175,
-0.039632678,
0.0049878699,
0.0324832834,
-0.016029004,
0.004635558,
0.0399899073,
-0.0078630233,
-0.0165378209,
0.1026936993,
-0.001117816,
-0.0135183642,
-0.0233784206,
-0.0011831914,
0.0210553762,
0.0248156972,
-0.0193592794,
-0.0394663885,
-0.0301754102,
0.0290549565,
0.0303593501,
0.025203513,
0.0329172127,
-0.042818822,
-0.0813907236,
-0.0064769215,
0.0739134178,
-0.0353622139,
-0.0177311525,
-0.02404272,
-0.0431189984,
-0.0558824986,
0.001818361,
0.0097329877,
-0.0175183713,
-0.0223010201,
0.0397074521,
-0.0013878477,
-0.0317658037,
-0.024913922,
-0.0277789906,
0.0889883935,
0.0357319042,
0.0051162634,
-0.0040096818,
-0.0119180661,
0.0305241551,
-0.0133204432,
-0.0167670213,
-0.0138523094,
-0.0061520953,
-0.0042495541,
-0.0071902727,
0.0359273255,
0.0476051532,
-0.0165644195,
0.0508593656,
-0.0014198464,
0.0334014371,
-0.0123773813,
0.0108715305,
0.0277811848,
-0.0080659604,
0.0301607568,
0.0630572066,
-0.0067841094,
-0.0266603548,
-0.0134235322,
0.0156649631,
0.0067719119,
-0.0591580011,
-0.0201145485,
-0.0079221902,
-0.0116341459,
-0.0424814448,
-0.0269663054,
-0.0203069132,
0.0167110655,
0.0805066898,
0.0273231044,
0.0200663786,
0.004933707,
0.0077517331,
-0.0134946303,
0.0186183415,
-0.0638349131,
0.0599567257,
-0.0742137358,
0.0020400642,
0.0215070955,
-0.0098635107,
0.0007713225,
0.0009893976,
-0.0871471167,
-0.0485431366,
-0.0019162844,
0.0268678591,
0.0257447381,
0.0284366067,
-0.0348456539,
-0.0084171174,
0.0702174678,
-0.021687638,
-0.0601469278,
0.0030854142,
0.0389136486,
0.0284501985,
0.0008352252,
0.0483949222,
0.0040962268,
0.0358414389,
-0.0223284923,
0.0561241247,
-0.035493657,
-0.0366745852,
-0.0124019692,
0.0156130958,
0.0418611839,
-0.0058355271,
0.0268501714,
0.0012817695,
0.0303392448,
0.0014433878,
0.042842254,
-0.0660431162,
-0.0073807794,
0.0581605062,
0.0287488028,
0.0095585836,
0.0090373876,
-0.0149744945,
-0.033714138,
0.041999951,
0.006772582,
0.0013567057,
0.0305165052,
0.0537683591,
0.0022896922,
-0.0172964837,
0.0473150201,
0.0254750401,
0.0002930608,
-0.0168548822,
0.0255691502,
0.011087697,
0.0493656211,
0.0224037413,
0.0018384198,
0.0153972208,
-0.0022315695,
-0.0191564057,
-0.016546594,
0.024581803,
0.0011913088,
0.1201054379,
0.0035826198,
0.0314811207,
-0.0550797321,
0.0355981737,
-0.0379171334,
0.0153724309,
0.0177788399,
-0.0223815776,
-0.0067486535,
0.0978835449,
0.0426072776,
0.0190666933,
0.0080770943,
-0.0121945068,
0.0286857653,
-0.011088212,
-0.0255810451,
-0.016788898,
-0.0350244045,
-0.0263972376,
-0.0244978834,
-0.0244197939,
-0.0573634766,
-0.0014222832,
-0.0074074352,
0.0039934772,
-0.0533745289,
0.0250436831,
-0.0025042349,
-0.0479761325,
0.0301479734,
-0.0142063564,
0.0056569204,
-0.0080121057,
-0.0524259582,
-0.0016984085,
-5.996386232e-33,
-0.0176237244,
0.0067338985,
0.0104481606,
-0.0413370244,
-0.0324646793,
-0.0172516052,
-0.0334990919,
-0.0024172768,
-0.0099420156,
-0.0023341109,
-0.010613719,
0.0066319304,
0.0195969138,
0.0214384217,
-0.0052684783,
0.025276985,
0.1050483733,
-0.0082852431,
-0.0379545391,
0.035170421,
0.0570997745,
0.0175278205,
0.0165373925,
-0.0667296797,
-0.0173849408,
-0.0377430953,
-0.0258022193,
0.0269070193,
0.0011100495,
0.0060028089,
0.0248953328,
-0.0146735385,
-0.0259936955,
-0.0414550938,
-0.0160581656,
0.0244965926,
-0.1016312465,
0.0355943739,
-0.0004221455,
0.0414020047,
-0.0233614538,
-0.0124647738,
0.0128680542,
-0.0120838117,
-0.0228691194,
-0.0206018835,
-0.0091733811,
-0.0182261169,
-0.0331234746,
-0.0130905155,
-0.0318911411,
0.025642138,
-0.0193489026,
-0.023417132,
0.0390399396,
0.0861977562,
-0.0240095481,
-0.0649929047,
-0.0661392361,
-0.0037191242,
0.0038676618,
0.0658839867,
0.0527564362,
0.0113976011,
-0.0406902544,
-0.0357181653,
0.0292529743,
-0.063292481,
0.0446276367,
-0.0173922554,
0.0337136388,
0.010430688,
0.0375346579,
-0.0042938385,
0.0308346152,
-0.042357564,
-0.0596548803,
0.0237490814,
-0.0001261548,
0.0105221532,
0.0113572441,
-0.0022270267,
-0.0160121862,
0.0019234624,
-0.0386737213,
-0.0301836804,
-0.013567158,
-0.0370434374,
0.0435617827,
0.0548596643,
0.0003619436,
-0.0011755858,
0.0989706665,
-0.0106924139,
0.0340595841,
-0.0291742589,
-0.0106196236,
0.0010977396,
-0.0438323207,
0.0404485315,
-0.0642893091,
-0.0331300311,
0.0513927042,
0.0555498302,
0.0057051773,
-0.0327481292,
0.0131526012,
0.0490907617,
-0.0551341809,
-0.0209780503,
-0.0285563618,
0.0284070224,
-0.044347398,
0.038912721,
0.0158939362,
-0.0226537865,
-0.0083835926,
0.0393944792,
-0.0319969505,
-0.0085674617,
0.000663971,
0.005926637,
0.0465712696,
0.0244292766,
-0.0664057732,
0.0028863694,
-0.0243005548,
-0.0196707509,
0.0690970644,
-0.0150059927,
-0.0246543456,
0.0282102339,
2.474e-7,
-0.0292577986,
0.0119322632,
0.0079283901,
-0.0455365181,
-0.0027473255,
0.0439001918,
-0.0575983338,
0.0239288006,
-0.0322477892,
0.0545834191,
0.0170242097,
0.0016613456,
0.1057379246,
0.0048795282,
-0.095702827,
-0.0345866866,
-0.0596500188,
0.0475810654,
-0.0431045257,
-0.0251013488,
-0.026729675,
0.0719420984,
-0.007108964,
-0.0196162295,
0.0105100898,
0.0192604885,
0.0558099672,
0.0165722333,
-0.0165595189,
-0.0223694891,
0.0180635639,
0.0198920704,
-0.0716303289,
-0.0334105566,
-0.0289708804,
0.0286239758,
0.0214987788,
0.1029505208,
-0.0108326692,
-0.0370732546,
0.0207973886,
0.0109380502,
-0.0424208976,
0.014804882,
0.0424252562,
-0.0065728952,
-0.0037918745,
0.0194017719,
-0.0127737699,
0.061414808,
-0.0039912807,
0.007192221,
-0.0182247851,
-0.0062558879,
0.0499346815,
-0.0177618228,
-0.0157784112,
-0.0129952133,
0.0102915186,
-0.0242686588,
-0.0113725634,
-0.0643639937,
-0.0253432989,
0.0717133582,
-0.0234380495,
0.0043607606,
-0.0120900115,
1.869423564e-34,
0.051661253,
-0.0319198444,
0.0203479454,
-0.045261316,
0.0139877629,
-0.0573203936,
-0.0153084099,
-0.0211100709,
-0.0029579548,
-0.0566265583,
-0.0741293505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15403v1 | AV-TranSpeech: Audio-Visual Robust Speech-to-Speech Translation | 2023-05-24T17:59:03 | 2023-05-24T17:59:03 | Rongjie Huang, Huadai Liu, Xize Cheng, Yi Ren, Linjun Li, Zhenhui Ye, Jinzheng He, Lichao Zhang, Jinglin Liu, Xiang Yin, Zhou Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Direct speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) aims to convert speech from one
language into another, and has demonstrated significant progress to date.
Despite the recent success, current S2ST models still suffer from distinct
degradation in noisy environments and fail to translate visual speech (i.e.,
the movement of lips and teeth). In this work, we present AV-TranSpeech, the
first audio-visual speech-to-speech (AV-S2ST) translation model without relying
on intermediate text. AV-TranSpeech complements the audio stream with visual
information to promote system robustness and opens up a host of practical
applications: dictation or dubbing archival films. To mitigate the data
scarcity with limited parallel AV-S2ST data, we 1) explore self-supervised
pre-training with unlabeled audio-visual data to learn contextual
representation, and 2) introduce cross-modal distillation with S2ST models
trained on the audio-only corpus to further reduce the requirements of visual
data. Experimental results on two language pairs demonstrate that AV-TranSpeech
outperforms audio-only models under all settings regardless of the type of
noise. With low-resource audio-visual data (10h, 30h), cross-modal distillation
yields an improvement of 7.6 BLEU on average compared with baselines. Audio
samples are available at https://AV-TranSpeech.github.io | [
-0.0323501155,
0.0320001654,
0.0092404475,
0.0021543545,
0.007818941,
-0.039781902,
0.0403120108,
-0.0006244445,
-0.0507422313,
-0.0293643083,
-0.0788533986,
-0.0116091371,
0.0487927534,
0.0202800706,
0.0403856002,
-0.0863694027,
0.0113324383,
-0.063280575,
-0.0007540383,
-0.0033768411,
0.0126066972,
-0.0040918784,
-0.0473019518,
-0.0153665887,
-0.0127465557,
0.0013472413,
0.0058804471,
0.0568459518,
0.0182539504,
0.0018192295,
-0.0524502322,
-0.0026095018,
0.0681352615,
0.01390881,
0.0000017483,
-0.0248226058,
-0.0088820774,
0.0093288403,
-0.0044568023,
0.013786952,
0.0293025877,
-0.0580309927,
-0.0243337452,
0.0478193946,
-0.0047974335,
-0.0691611841,
0.0404138938,
0.0029907685,
0.0501484945,
0.0488531664,
-0.0465813205,
-0.0365952328,
0.0141497143,
-0.051934544,
0.0021592265,
-0.0240771063,
-0.0339930728,
-0.0076921731,
-0.0230251569,
0.0020802729,
-0.0722270384,
0.0844604969,
-0.0212269798,
-0.0393164568,
-0.0015290495,
-0.0024942178,
-0.0511209294,
-0.0685316995,
-0.0146280518,
0.099083893,
0.0016803039,
0.0285921916,
-0.0020044942,
0.0219811294,
-0.0056372499,
0.0104913563,
-0.0265113153,
0.0178051703,
0.0399897471,
-0.0062528742,
-0.0666963607,
0.0796595663,
0.0351745561,
-0.0833063349,
-0.0003495908,
-0.0818264708,
0.0269801542,
0.0110996319,
0.0292787831,
-0.0118804155,
-0.0373018384,
0.0026605632,
0.074390091,
-0.0098183043,
0.0213811472,
-0.0199028794,
-0.0286107734,
-0.0371832624,
-0.0546735153,
-0.005809423,
0.0039186343,
0.0504999012,
-0.1022452414,
0.0344526246,
-0.0154151348,
0.0304797459,
-0.013405581,
0.0309446026,
-0.0076932535,
-0.0299591683,
-0.0149523187,
0.035246674,
-0.0430701002,
-0.0228320435,
-0.0708076805,
-0.0371570811,
-0.0107749579,
-0.0298719425,
-0.0435019657,
0.0152832614,
0.0414247327,
0.0002601735,
-0.0548667386,
-0.0223633591,
-0.0188089535,
0.068806991,
0.0260877442,
0.0460676737,
-0.0311069321,
-0.0447564125,
-0.0191479828,
0.0218547378,
0.0276824906,
-0.0248918086,
0.0075286655,
0.0742615759,
-0.031870164,
-0.0116918739,
-0.0103725474,
0.0487646572,
-0.0405495316,
-0.0445192866,
0.0126647195,
-0.0610477217,
0.0182919912,
-0.0160911437,
0.0175031815,
-0.0255025346,
-0.0138639668,
-0.0163091812,
0.0148776639,
0.0939200744,
0.0130623262,
0.0230259933,
0.0430733934,
0.0137332324,
0.0003365212,
0.0516174622,
0.0555456467,
0.0028323759,
0.0129831815,
0.0005153576,
0.0263340212,
0.0691069216,
0.0398447402,
0.0497791693,
-0.0636983067,
-0.0142002627,
0.0131515535,
0.0261997934,
0.0552744642,
0.0878904015,
-0.0251100957,
-0.0382309705,
0.077999033,
-0.0016648681,
0.0269154869,
-0.014347339,
0.0369110256,
-0.0055609862,
-0.0155143719,
-0.0091053564,
0.0051777391,
0.0334170349,
0.0253630988,
-0.0088065397,
0.0312316734,
0.0263443459,
-0.0443877093,
-0.0146258213,
0.0197605602,
-0.0105016353,
0.0041220384,
0.0268366188,
0.0053446279,
0.0478958338,
-0.0367174484,
0.0295886118,
-0.0322867036,
-0.0553724468,
0.0467753895,
-0.0046978071,
-0.0251574591,
0.0281920303,
0.0224082787,
-0.0123628229,
0.0214667749,
-0.0360536017,
0.0445044562,
0.0281629078,
0.0185872652,
-0.0183958318,
0.1019247547,
-0.0584228784,
-0.0242165141,
0.0173664298,
-0.0184004959,
-0.0053891386,
-0.0334239379,
0.0408018269,
0.0049878131,
-0.0350934714,
0.0258107577,
-0.0015076371,
-0.014954173,
-0.0129705891,
0.034231957,
0.0602021925,
0.012228963,
0.0216314457,
-0.0354317054,
0.0023748321,
0.003403472,
-0.030029349,
0.0670444295,
0.0559540689,
-0.0488873199,
-0.0454455204,
0.0466342904,
-0.0544694252,
0.0211889129,
0.0346494392,
0.0207572766,
-0.0752837881,
0.0286140833,
-0.0097291246,
0.000475451,
-0.0211675633,
0.0242836289,
0.0290259458,
0.0226553977,
0.0039074421,
-0.0528386794,
0.0180625208,
-0.0607879721,
0.021921711,
0.0491746478,
0.0162389167,
-0.0453896075,
-0.0300379638,
0.0421055257,
0.0124270925,
0.015461986,
0.0003107647,
-0.021427609,
-0.021460183,
-0.0009817984,
-0.0673369095,
0.0022283937,
-0.0078693442,
-0.0153021468,
-0.0046800687,
0.0378763713,
0.017796874,
-0.03255862,
-0.01963377,
-0.0040918933,
0.0022143859,
-0.0302494578,
-0.0371190719,
0.0229564887,
0.0178380385,
-0.0421912037,
0.0011128976,
0.0520238355,
-0.0303304568,
-0.0343744755,
-0.019356329,
0.0067100101,
0.0387059562,
0.0224185511,
0.0568367429,
-0.0211708061,
-0.0196237452,
-0.0239634551,
-0.0034705084,
0.0499226004,
0.0064308229,
-0.0295802038,
-0.0479984805,
0.0228886344,
-0.0549933575,
-0.0224915147,
0.0062292423,
0.0263164714,
0.0028869673,
-0.030195741,
0.0226931106,
-0.0605121553,
-0.0223206691,
0.0169990584,
0.0294468086,
-0.0651686415,
-0.0463703275,
0.0228382405,
-0.0183426719,
-0.0206800736,
0.0082858521,
0.0085382182,
0.0318283141,
-0.0255426336,
-0.0459350422,
0.0203486923,
-0.0859361961,
-0.0656663552,
-0.0106067481,
-0.0136696799,
-0.0053100395,
0.0373353474,
-0.0336520337,
-0.0064524855,
-0.0343640521,
-0.0207762271,
-0.0913015008,
-0.0220712759,
0.0254537705,
-0.0396427549,
0.0441937894,
-0.0490257479,
-0.0148105323,
-0.0399399363,
-0.017985696,
-0.0051108659,
-0.003714927,
0.0064099682,
-0.0189891178,
-0.0139395026,
-0.0291155558,
-0.0296156388,
0.0372111015,
0.0360704996,
0.0640736297,
0.0191830434,
0.009810945,
-0.0333133526,
0.0702394992,
0.0155226188,
0.0236901604,
-0.0051041534,
-0.0555954874,
0.038836129,
0.0009268027,
0.0383986905,
-0.0152847935,
-0.0536296032,
0.0358813293,
0.040148478,
0.0914342254,
-0.0422101207,
0.0047508576,
0.0413739122,
-0.0234059487,
0.004258458,
0.0558585674,
-0.0303618778,
-0.0325893499,
-0.0376713835,
0.0259857383,
0.0218314808,
0.0231589191,
0.0013739055,
-0.062115103,
-0.0398693047,
0.036319185,
0.0241107661,
0.072046116,
0.0451175198,
-0.049389258,
-0.0628241077,
0.0576844104,
0.0549095236,
-0.0182418507,
-0.0472405404,
0.0110652614,
-0.0035663845,
-0.0616160855,
0.0504543707,
-0.0073945397,
-0.022054866,
0.0095635159,
0.0215366967,
0.0139253689,
-0.0329046845,
0.0094823586,
-0.0357241929,
0.0576157756,
0.0258607063,
0.0302827433,
-0.021452168,
-0.0291128121,
0.0532612614,
-0.0141949402,
-0.0322486758,
0.0072377147,
0.0724174008,
-0.0174564421,
-0.0156247374,
0.0585004427,
0.0339696333,
0.0011101898,
-0.0001931032,
0.0135508571,
0.0197685491,
-0.0016568664,
0.026804287,
0.0108563825,
0.0285876039,
0.0075374413,
0.0331021324,
0.0046501518,
-0.0191091094,
-0.008575622,
0.0316493064,
0.0324499495,
-0.0480327383,
-0.0316817164,
-0.0137139345,
0.0161617864,
-0.0520832986,
-0.0523296557,
0.010418063,
0.0150836688,
0.0708432943,
0.0147871505,
0.0001107789,
0.012614117,
0.0439209007,
-0.0346435755,
0.0055409805,
-0.016341025,
0.0580743924,
-0.0392497219,
-0.0201120172,
-0.0001348713,
-0.043431282,
0.0233486593,
0.0405123308,
-0.0587560944,
-0.0404348671,
-0.02081131,
0.0283995178,
0.018868098,
0.0657529235,
0.0057232557,
-0.0117341997,
0.059731707,
-0.007399586,
-0.0187106337,
0.0168248471,
0.0625542924,
-0.0171306431,
-0.0058238297,
0.0187569745,
-0.0060884701,
0.010643742,
-0.0167335384,
0.0302860644,
0.0041426471,
-0.0455290154,
-0.0213876795,
0.0048323758,
0.0368531682,
-0.0198703017,
0.0529670045,
-0.0546101667,
0.0137803117,
-0.0040710745,
0.0547615848,
-0.0834005848,
0.0075865653,
0.0631332546,
0.0205835141,
0.0191616584,
0.0211969744,
0.0028825728,
-0.0280982926,
-0.0286391247,
0.0243313462,
0.0027653319,
0.021327991,
0.0020021419,
0.036706619,
0.0644084364,
0.0321661532,
0.0184167717,
0.0258189049,
-0.0056319553,
0.0094750356,
0.0012850693,
0.0003099639,
0.0036356002,
0.012344148,
-0.0144425221,
0.0146438247,
-0.0064247167,
0.0181444734,
0.0298055727,
-0.0176919363,
0.0830194652,
0.0212916415,
0.0070911054,
-0.0299488567,
0.0469575822,
-0.0287214294,
0.0107083581,
-0.0003794842,
-0.0276149474,
-0.0035386963,
0.064630501,
0.037712872,
-0.0190126486,
-0.0071213851,
-0.0476046577,
0.0384461246,
-0.0274705775,
-0.0545923114,
0.0016052909,
-0.0285255704,
-0.0229897462,
-0.0093104606,
0.0172300674,
-0.0777560249,
-0.0070070657,
-0.0052037868,
-0.0164209511,
-0.0238651522,
0.0333285369,
-0.0195762143,
0.0081398692,
0.0229005851,
0.0048708827,
-0.0451241173,
0.0427714959,
-0.0059434106,
0.0165633056,
-4.70433978e-33,
-0.0383068509,
0.0216073338,
0.0431727283,
-0.026199596,
-0.0331159085,
-0.0201296527,
-0.0412739255,
0.0103885559,
-0.0145124923,
0.0160947647,
0.0228518359,
0.0373348221,
0.0251803622,
0.0362745114,
-0.0291729756,
0.0149387429,
0.0727681667,
-0.0288221817,
-0.0212729406,
0.0428341925,
0.0382649787,
0.0334585421,
0.0214344878,
-0.0961468741,
-0.0486930944,
0.0092744501,
-0.0364965573,
0.0010594293,
0.0214061756,
-0.0085077817,
0.0223173909,
0.0036261897,
-0.0482784174,
0.0007036427,
-0.0227934383,
0.0097372411,
-0.0841733664,
0.0338019878,
0.0017586632,
0.0460519008,
-0.0521181449,
0.0357690044,
0.0404596888,
0.0033766432,
0.0034106236,
-0.0400360599,
0.0262514874,
-0.066170603,
-0.0066439747,
-0.0276500173,
-0.0390086845,
0.0153915947,
-0.0422090553,
-0.0400423072,
0.091201067,
0.0709317923,
0.0016273675,
-0.0154545549,
-0.058129169,
0.0348226018,
-0.0424109437,
0.0389329195,
0.068863526,
0.0230051875,
-0.0196485613,
-0.0011696449,
0.0669326931,
-0.0937118605,
0.056646809,
0.0027737485,
0.0477528125,
0.0445321612,
0.0014384142,
0.0461050868,
-0.0008359668,
-0.0375808962,
-0.0330875516,
0.02177478,
-0.0454619303,
-0.008783997,
0.013661162,
0.0447124615,
0.0192655362,
0.0079586832,
-0.0579931848,
-0.0185650103,
-0.0045773876,
-0.0084300656,
0.027207071,
0.0302766673,
0.0142927803,
-0.0039950046,
0.0970740095,
-0.027854966,
0.0141719915,
0.0054230294,
-0.0633762851,
0.0046030204,
-0.0215865094,
0.0281426795,
-0.0122801466,
-0.0291844402,
0.0935307965,
0.0354658291,
0.0085513918,
-0.0310190041,
0.0033592717,
0.0643712357,
-0.0477365553,
-0.0137633914,
-0.0066293213,
0.0300230142,
-0.0016938593,
0.0648283586,
0.0149757136,
-0.0076947892,
-0.0183737688,
0.0058509298,
-0.0226589683,
-0.0061117378,
-0.0124912066,
-0.0070998664,
-0.0021233328,
0.0264841877,
-0.0557759851,
0.0354119577,
0.0111718476,
-0.0444427282,
0.0492774211,
-0.0330333859,
-0.0279981792,
0.0018169617,
2.518e-7,
-0.0060353982,
0.0026504935,
0.030939335,
-0.0450980589,
0.0121091921,
0.020245906,
-0.0580864362,
-0.0093216989,
0.006533843,
-0.0343040153,
0.0442658626,
0.0196479503,
0.0979922116,
0.0207809061,
-0.006429289,
-0.0181155801,
-0.0350939929,
0.0157949217,
0.0149674378,
-0.0052991495,
0.0239366591,
0.0720740259,
-0.0257361215,
-0.0495972596,
0.0497195236,
-0.0082838256,
0.0604715273,
-0.0131448535,
-0.0063113607,
-0.0422457382,
-0.047075022,
0.0066216984,
-0.057733655,
-0.0158722345,
-0.0445326008,
0.0208322983,
0.06480138,
0.0679116845,
-0.0013998713,
-0.0783284605,
-0.0382904299,
0.0729108155,
-0.0420035832,
0.0144825391,
0.0386726558,
0.0033854889,
-0.0098356958,
0.0143767036,
-0.0478332937,
0.0237996206,
0.0197447259,
-0.0102319457,
-0.0255999435,
0.0176701657,
0.0551020615,
0.0098409541,
-0.0565171316,
-0.0580188297,
-0.0282971952,
-0.0217716377,
-0.0377558768,
-0.0305010453,
-0.0292804092,
0.0021675869,
-0.0266402382,
0.0097129047,
-0.0352052897,
1.76571546e-34,
0.0436808616,
-0.0534251444,
0.0208711401,
-0.0891881287,
-0.0112743201,
-0.0298880078,
-0.0102519859,
-0.009741812,
-0.0138002606,
-0.0148617271,
-0.065374136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15389v1 | Comparing Humans and Models on a Similar Scale: Towards Cognitive Gender Bias Evaluation in Coreference Resolution | 2023-05-24T17:51:44 | 2023-05-24T17:51:44 | Gili Lior, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Spurious correlations were found to be an important factor explaining model
performance in various NLP tasks (e.g., gender or racial artifacts), often
considered to be ''shortcuts'' to the actual task. However, humans tend to
similarly make quick (and sometimes wrong) predictions based on societal and
cognitive presuppositions. In this work we address the question: can we
quantify the extent to which model biases reflect human behaviour? Answering
this question will help shed light on model performance and provide meaningful
comparisons against humans. We approach this question through the lens of the
dual-process theory for human decision-making. This theory differentiates
between an automatic unconscious (and sometimes biased) ''fast system'' and a
''slow system'', which when triggered may revisit earlier automatic reactions.
We make several observations from two crowdsourcing experiments of gender bias
in coreference resolution, using self-paced reading to study the ''fast''
system, and question answering to study the ''slow'' system under a constrained
time setting. On real-world data humans make $\sim$3\% more gender-biased
decisions compared to models, while on synthetic data models are $\sim$12\%
more biased. | [
0.0476128608,
0.0497739837,
-0.0330159292,
-0.0070487149,
-0.0215341225,
0.0050243437,
0.0012513031,
-0.017743472,
0.0221881494,
-0.0704495087,
-0.0173431486,
-0.0163121149,
0.0355764702,
-0.0237493198,
0.0113482354,
-0.0318023637,
0.0170113984,
-0.0103057995,
0.0619344078,
-0.0353520252,
0.0070070503,
0.0103877578,
0.0002150204,
0.0349739641,
0.0183741171,
-0.021038156,
0.0286720861,
-0.004109446,
-0.0122460024,
-0.0033657826,
0.0067936992,
0.0962887183,
-0.0334132239,
0.0310796592,
0.0000019258,
-0.086370863,
0.0535627231,
0.0095094061,
-0.0493756533,
0.0464315116,
-0.0217147414,
0.0375730582,
0.0041766344,
-0.01671483,
-0.0306295697,
0.0118569536,
0.0127668669,
0.0473943688,
0.0049813353,
-0.0208044779,
0.0005396139,
0.0430535637,
-0.040774703,
-0.0174770597,
-0.0555408038,
-0.0579891801,
0.0205213279,
-0.0038545502,
0.0050693676,
-0.0121607743,
-0.0326080099,
0.0158643611,
-0.0031927524,
0.0221397299,
0.0178764854,
0.0390293486,
-0.0508114249,
-0.0747889578,
0.0009772647,
0.0605883822,
0.0379334465,
0.003828859,
0.0157965496,
0.0042030807,
0.0115927756,
0.0333328992,
-0.0576134361,
0.0133216223,
-0.0457683168,
-0.0314900875,
-0.009958162,
-0.0222480502,
0.0109436139,
0.0427524261,
0.0314535983,
0.1038976386,
-0.0128748817,
-0.0155560412,
0.0593488179,
0.0435346365,
-0.0064863935,
-0.0926708803,
0.0154667636,
-0.0326408558,
-0.01641961,
-0.0043470608,
-0.0046640569,
0.0298916399,
0.0370153785,
-0.0996425375,
0.0131902313,
0.0285106637,
0.0309626143,
0.0128992638,
-0.0208192151,
0.0320270807,
-0.0300140362,
0.0354683027,
0.004221641,
-0.0138848107,
-0.0392188542,
-0.0181604922,
-0.001565964,
0.0144025283,
-0.0114782397,
0.0212980416,
-0.0586483255,
-0.038402468,
-0.0560892895,
-0.0207337104,
0.0008877661,
0.0358531736,
-0.0077640163,
0.0022523808,
-0.0796398968,
0.0103140697,
-0.0839383677,
0.0326361842,
-0.0367697291,
-0.0765089989,
0.0010946327,
-0.0104298061,
-0.0061599663,
-0.0278342459,
-0.0035440053,
0.0366820358,
-0.0041864426,
-0.0070397686,
-0.0166750792,
-0.0555880703,
-0.0092353923,
-0.0402590856,
-0.0125977071,
-0.0458282046,
0.0055193002,
0.0720816776,
-0.00812303,
-0.0485157371,
-0.0043302691,
0.0481256247,
-0.0538949333,
0.0535066836,
0.0554298386,
0.0133567108,
0.0624422282,
0.0114627481,
-0.0136484923,
0.0914330706,
0.0380525291,
0.0154355476,
0.0251629855,
0.0034285979,
-0.0102869524,
0.0210201964,
0.0531363934,
0.0057197278,
0.0131960381,
0.0476117358,
-0.0320998617,
0.0248090178,
0.0882853568,
0.0406749845,
0.0007170982,
-0.030346686,
0.0467509553,
0.0928816795,
-0.0202649999,
0.0241202284,
0.0194612239,
-0.011404112,
0.0165304579,
0.0721922889,
-0.0621123128,
0.0189723242,
-0.0255778972,
-0.0328406133,
0.0282133464,
0.0380827226,
-0.0209110156,
-0.0302696619,
-0.0302792992,
0.045930896,
-0.0048081507,
0.0178894307,
0.0179318283,
0.0244679451,
-0.0136756599,
0.0338799134,
0.0029539184,
0.0105522331,
-0.0222530998,
-0.0571173243,
-0.0239684898,
0.0035125962,
0.0023620739,
0.0263445023,
-0.0144679174,
-0.0043640151,
-0.0088261431,
0.0114990314,
0.0530537032,
0.0021176718,
-0.027223995,
0.0157617647,
-0.0095070135,
0.0342496,
0.0199913923,
0.0111519536,
0.0692917481,
0.0218866523,
0.0083345175,
-0.0153442575,
-0.0429873168,
0.0196440164,
-0.0247500688,
-0.0120665999,
-0.0208717436,
0.0050216173,
0.0303352829,
-0.0055742529,
-0.0054936414,
0.012649091,
-0.0039322111,
0.0339191407,
-0.0096337069,
0.0458469316,
-0.0390736908,
0.0420262441,
0.0018341523,
-0.0477737859,
-0.0923364535,
0.0091956221,
0.030499449,
-0.0081466138,
0.0263183005,
-0.0209768489,
-0.0319301076,
-0.0190909412,
-0.009538956,
0.0059525915,
0.012728109,
-0.0264293589,
0.0460744761,
-0.0114371777,
-0.002777637,
0.0447892323,
-0.0276653171,
0.0073582008,
-0.0549825653,
-0.0041450611,
0.0224627871,
0.0266887024,
-0.0233712904,
0.0397165082,
-0.0672859922,
-0.0915448815,
-0.0001555718,
-0.0700368583,
-0.0245076194,
0.0172119495,
-0.0224240869,
-0.0132788578,
-0.0202900041,
-0.0263917018,
-0.023443263,
0.0048757712,
-0.0327233858,
0.0205376875,
0.074660629,
0.0207105037,
-0.0002293656,
0.0229568202,
-0.054966148,
-0.0101274885,
-0.0347824208,
0.0391791724,
0.0543687455,
-0.0182612967,
-0.0262995809,
0.0028910332,
-0.0114509417,
0.0214929711,
0.0075388206,
-0.0111193452,
0.0318371244,
0.0541879348,
0.0516849197,
0.0892609805,
0.0091915261,
0.021898007,
0.0419170447,
-0.016611388,
-0.0700382739,
-0.0061939457,
0.0197182689,
-0.018583551,
0.0093909483,
-0.0650075004,
-0.0162703861,
0.0585424677,
0.0185956005,
-0.0091467649,
-0.0408213995,
0.065044336,
-0.0719614029,
-0.0947995707,
-0.0448745452,
-0.0575656593,
-0.0107430415,
0.078277193,
-0.0426487215,
-0.0271818247,
0.0477865487,
0.0252527092,
0.0120886983,
0.003863791,
0.0289346334,
-0.0285879746,
0.0568189472,
-0.0062953271,
0.0048947781,
0.043714691,
-0.0187455118,
-0.0804201216,
-0.0422407277,
0.0224851482,
-0.0325520039,
0.0098716188,
-0.0564465746,
0.0417401306,
0.0063124555,
-0.0431279875,
-0.0504474007,
-0.0048585515,
-0.0541834906,
-0.0154845091,
-0.0023023367,
0.0017620876,
0.0029990992,
0.0117116133,
0.0242680814,
-0.011384218,
-0.0006543323,
-0.0214851201,
0.0121836942,
0.0177308656,
0.0537591055,
0.0318664871,
0.0466743186,
-0.0223098099,
-0.002133945,
0.0624307916,
0.0314632691,
0.0360984132,
-0.0214162469,
-0.0002294765,
0.0422913767,
-0.051949285,
-0.0273494776,
-0.0006858649,
0.0221147165,
-0.0335005075,
0.0013051304,
0.0895872563,
0.0372370332,
-0.0540990345,
0.0000618722,
-0.0291424561,
0.0012518213,
0.0382157229,
-0.0018545125,
0.0058592842,
-0.0027897945,
0.0545019582,
-0.0071137212,
-0.046530135,
-0.0559490286,
-0.0050005983,
-0.1144873947,
0.0022588077,
-0.0202634484,
-0.0188786723,
-0.0111791315,
-0.0623253137,
0.0456714034,
-0.0112168062,
-0.0016486587,
0.009497622,
0.0003737822,
0.0473325364,
-0.0070499736,
-0.0377645567,
0.0213883538,
0.0669466779,
-0.0536297709,
0.0457397774,
0.0384177081,
0.064179413,
0.0067618429,
-0.0092864037,
0.0560851358,
-0.0103844879,
0.0111459382,
-0.0231998656,
0.0162418038,
-0.0171114709,
0.0215213187,
-0.0745078251,
0.0494590104,
0.0127533609,
-0.008833928,
-0.0052017677,
0.0356498994,
0.0298663992,
-0.0257347915,
-0.0599655584,
0.01338802,
-0.0098042088,
0.0747277811,
0.0026627355,
-0.0388423689,
-0.0454594567,
0.001179189,
0.0165716615,
0.0120936111,
-0.1261074841,
0.0127190249,
0.0292476956,
0.0050442331,
-0.0324807763,
-0.0732452944,
0.0068049608,
0.0142890383,
0.0194707327,
-0.0270873122,
0.0336506739,
0.0240421593,
-0.0375252329,
0.0413658135,
-0.019324379,
0.0094460305,
-0.0349516422,
-0.0024508694,
0.0026690967,
0.0257535987,
-0.0343405083,
0.0767561644,
-0.0399884023,
-0.0230366159,
0.0432771668,
0.0121900979,
0.0278229509,
0.0153609021,
0.0045643058,
-0.0396640562,
-0.0417174622,
0.0197904054,
-0.0406137742,
0.036392089,
0.0018626013,
0.0375259593,
-0.0017728319,
0.0298172925,
-0.0147754746,
0.0216606539,
0.0049150428,
-0.005492317,
-0.0278914571,
-0.0844659433,
0.0278642103,
0.0256706811,
0.0266749412,
-0.0456543528,
-0.0097341202,
-0.0162706766,
-0.0265178438,
0.014118202,
-0.0324578471,
0.0188332535,
-0.0530133806,
0.0104175732,
0.021545019,
-0.0111130895,
-0.0209357627,
-0.0119728744,
0.0320166387,
-0.0045086099,
-0.013704855,
0.0433123298,
0.0299619641,
-0.0100741619,
0.0060332678,
0.0160465371,
-0.0072550252,
-0.0082967514,
0.073179625,
0.0137540447,
0.0230232701,
0.0206703711,
0.0007035066,
-0.0109287398,
-0.0526845045,
-0.0680009276,
-0.0358093679,
0.0036571301,
0.020486854,
0.0051132264,
-0.0641645417,
0.0391509086,
-0.0082341973,
-0.0123765841,
-0.0016062841,
-0.0363909528,
0.0005873065,
0.0361082256,
0.0015858426,
0.0112696588,
0.0028472107,
0.0067077116,
0.0542187989,
0.0294356905,
0.0322572738,
-0.0239691157,
-0.0674468279,
-0.0172807071,
-0.0460552536,
-0.0421781279,
-0.0531115942,
0.0107860379,
0.0170833059,
-0.1124749184,
-0.0364756137,
0.0177716855,
-0.0189709794,
0.0282236543,
-0.0337633453,
0.0132211978,
0.0749161914,
-0.00723967,
-0.055351723,
-0.0167523809,
0.0386937894,
-0.0136349909,
0.0009391377,
-0.0585347489,
-6.196730877e-33,
-0.0469849333,
-0.0795602947,
-0.0185622163,
-0.027701728,
0.0015582615,
0.00567591,
0.0035860033,
0.0275482759,
-0.007701763,
0.0357052423,
-0.0327789225,
0.0200701784,
0.0156457871,
-0.0358506143,
0.0294906963,
0.0066354657,
0.0287406556,
-0.0160166025,
-0.0314633176,
-0.0639081448,
0.0144978231,
0.0081905555,
0.0034459766,
-0.075733304,
0.1009423584,
0.0367595665,
0.0277198683,
-0.0222302731,
-0.0107767088,
0.0184517205,
-0.0256952848,
0.0624356344,
0.028716052,
-0.0534579828,
-0.0005418404,
0.0652848184,
-0.0895335823,
-0.0332211368,
0.0529162064,
0.04493827,
-0.0026855248,
0.0027117978,
0.0343019292,
0.0259043742,
-0.0615088828,
-0.0249644332,
0.0578836091,
-0.0061244681,
0.0241369344,
0.0366527885,
-0.0650013164,
0.0205752067,
-0.0129115852,
0.0133316619,
0.0124126766,
0.054035455,
-0.0402048603,
0.0020653685,
-0.0836142972,
0.005683579,
-0.0262303539,
0.019344613,
0.0341950879,
0.0171787664,
0.0390650108,
0.0427543744,
0.0495730229,
0.0592228472,
-0.062087357,
-0.0516495742,
0.0115029393,
-0.0118960515,
0.020938674,
0.0721552074,
0.046357397,
0.0125972377,
-0.0390558206,
-0.0196221489,
-0.0056422725,
0.0428316742,
0.0251163319,
-0.0027502198,
-0.0734769031,
-0.0285364967,
-0.059271846,
-0.0431296304,
-0.0251611676,
-0.0154891536,
0.015550103,
-0.0014343208,
-0.0179018565,
0.0013236769,
-0.0038874329,
-0.0287134163,
-0.0294950549,
-0.0277636759,
0.0039864271,
-0.0099734543,
0.0436608344,
0.0159685221,
-0.0593137741,
0.0524413958,
-0.0200107433,
0.0691618323,
0.0509757213,
0.0130616501,
-0.0408155918,
-0.0268582199,
-0.0446313918,
-0.0178617723,
-0.0387431495,
0.0079898546,
-0.0071506393,
-0.0497262925,
0.0674046576,
0.0303275082,
-0.0210815053,
-0.016574895,
0.0344127826,
0.0469227843,
-0.022351278,
0.0180432089,
-0.0203334391,
0.0229549222,
0.0093470076,
-0.0063394597,
-0.0107281702,
0.0221826062,
-0.0045813434,
-0.0267063156,
-0.0049411175,
-0.0121511733,
2.583e-7,
0.0045108385,
0.0606094748,
0.0373634174,
0.0169610232,
0.01390866,
0.0245518349,
0.0131225223,
0.0134194829,
0.070895344,
-0.0569098219,
-0.0286112409,
0.0414271839,
-0.0117631964,
0.0357547849,
-0.0462877564,
-0.0301562808,
-0.0570637248,
0.0676716343,
0.006955334,
-0.0011033978,
-0.0394038521,
0.0089283083,
0.0279402137,
0.0170027409,
-0.0500433967,
0.0030753931,
0.0489261411,
-0.0211202987,
0.0204429347,
0.0094817532,
0.0254867785,
-0.0132088261,
0.0164792836,
0.0643759146,
0.0287497211,
-0.0330855995,
0.0476041175,
-0.0008714905,
0.0001154649,
-0.0158190019,
-0.0521489978,
-0.0109105175,
0.0231367778,
-0.0487880297,
0.0660180673,
-0.0424101166,
-0.0698697194,
-0.0463770144,
-0.0141137158,
0.0160244424,
0.0369537584,
0.0376010612,
-0.0077259936,
0.0100053297,
0.0062016551,
0.0307758823,
0.0044674356,
-0.0422755405,
-0.0329764485,
-0.0087337466,
-0.0180866383,
-0.0679707602,
-0.0355840921,
0.0041130832,
0.0037386543,
-0.0226835124,
-0.0049319603,
1.781871045e-34,
0.0011147513,
0.0500551574,
0.0370630696,
0.0087854471,
0.0071157319,
-0.0128714824,
-0.0098538687,
-0.0049158982,
0.0837631673,
0.0101767816,
0.0024918916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15387v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15387v1 | Peek Across: Improving Multi-Document Modeling via Cross-Document Question-Answering | 2023-05-24T17:48:40 | 2023-05-24T17:48:40 | Avi Caciularu, Matthew E. Peters, Jacob Goldberger, Ido Dagan, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The integration of multi-document pre-training objectives into language
models has resulted in remarkable improvements in multi-document downstream
tasks. In this work, we propose extending this idea by pre-training a generic
multi-document model from a novel cross-document question answering
pre-training objective. To that end, given a set (or cluster) of
topically-related documents, we systematically generate semantically-oriented
questions from a salient sentence in one document and challenge the model,
during pre-training, to answer these questions while "peeking" into other
topically-related documents. In a similar manner, the model is also challenged
to recover the sentence from which the question was generated, again while
leveraging cross-document information. This novel multi-document QA formulation
directs the model to better recover cross-text informational relations, and
introduces a natural augmentation that artificially increases the pre-training
data. Further, unlike prior multi-document models that focus on either
classification or summarization tasks, our pre-training objective formulation
enables the model to perform tasks that involve both short text generation
(e.g., QA) and long text generation (e.g., summarization). Following this
scheme, we pre-train our model -- termed QAmden -- and evaluate its performance
across several multi-document tasks, including multi-document QA,
summarization, and query-focused summarization, yielding improvements of up to
7%, and significantly outperforms zero-shot GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. | [
0.0311311968,
0.0197428819,
0.0327582583,
-0.0093225557,
-0.005396815,
0.0166314933,
-0.0161033981,
-0.0282391049,
-0.0135108847,
-0.0575766191,
-0.0304947104,
-0.0248083044,
-0.0201078244,
0.0007295087,
0.041918423,
-0.05203126,
0.052535139,
-0.0243113451,
-0.0245999172,
-0.0040714322,
0.0212430898,
0.0402724519,
0.0337384231,
0.0042794989,
-0.0108833173,
-0.0535598062,
-0.0332541987,
-0.0050993622,
-0.0100158369,
0.0014428208,
0.0408304222,
0.0160980523,
0.0493943505,
0.0017572989,
0.0000016453,
-0.0364142247,
-0.0434732214,
0.0127806626,
0.0246647708,
0.000969422,
0.0304884128,
-0.0541999303,
0.0462798253,
0.0224797837,
-0.0132728554,
-0.0225003827,
0.0042318776,
0.0653121099,
0.081283249,
0.0723484382,
-0.010616241,
-0.0039074221,
0.0535027981,
-0.0310083721,
0.0625278354,
-0.07438384,
-0.0016918411,
0.0229676254,
0.0346946493,
0.0202706847,
0.0021735539,
0.0250187516,
0.0301845577,
-0.0119478703,
0.0085239299,
0.0218246933,
-0.0181037169,
0.0198151711,
-0.0122110127,
0.0747330487,
-0.0120323701,
0.0053535113,
0.0202436764,
0.0027264394,
0.0057325554,
0.0046572755,
-0.0844330862,
0.0188458525,
0.0089468779,
-0.01824723,
0.0211436972,
-0.0139829488,
0.0047677676,
0.0210327581,
-0.0101060951,
0.0293848123,
0.0433723293,
-0.0195082985,
0.0057648332,
0.014852575,
-0.032433413,
-0.0448482372,
-0.0039898236,
0.0759376958,
-0.0254723523,
0.0094227856,
-0.0684090704,
-0.0299043544,
0.0535759442,
-0.0071292892,
0.0120135052,
0.0225821901,
0.0033923776,
0.05917079,
-0.0241100807,
0.012025659,
-0.0270296857,
-0.0168681405,
-0.0825822428,
-0.0488617197,
-0.0294524487,
-0.0428810194,
-0.063232407,
0.0507842563,
-0.0251019578,
-0.0207052417,
-0.0129992003,
0.0393914878,
0.0373356119,
-0.0380063653,
0.0008373327,
0.0224491339,
-0.0604599267,
-0.025112154,
0.0038145173,
0.0239969734,
-0.0715276226,
0.0334233269,
0.028846724,
-0.0009272486,
-0.0375250503,
0.0276508071,
0.0184094943,
-0.0323192514,
-0.0039009545,
0.0330486558,
-0.0561509207,
-0.0269267615,
-0.0142999077,
-0.0478798449,
-0.0019948205,
-0.0648411065,
0.039632,
-0.0436156765,
0.0395285301,
-0.0027874501,
-0.0301106982,
0.0250675753,
0.0021549342,
0.0396221653,
-0.0313126445,
0.0433436669,
0.0162547231,
-0.0100623751,
0.0602496043,
0.0166756287,
0.0111483764,
0.0826532021,
0.0133079747,
-0.0080831274,
0.0377639458,
0.0294512939,
-0.014279481,
0.0060087387,
0.0349490419,
0.0053472868,
0.030849006,
0.0273980852,
0.019280199,
0.0096956892,
0.0399423465,
0.0494495295,
-0.0532272942,
-0.0028409001,
0.0072401515,
0.0352091305,
-0.0001725302,
0.0155466478,
0.0406082012,
0.0260231551,
-0.0241252724,
0.0590470023,
-0.0117213214,
0.046071656,
-0.0377911851,
0.0278130323,
0.0654095933,
0.0155986212,
-0.0695682019,
-0.0049113133,
0.0323330313,
-0.0236516185,
-0.0167739317,
-0.0012856403,
0.0417912006,
0.0468437672,
-0.039630875,
0.0512638204,
0.0047511254,
-0.0557927154,
0.0424885936,
-0.0298333541,
0.0500271022,
-0.0024988018,
0.0420343839,
-0.039927166,
-0.04629834,
-0.0196535084,
0.0228393953,
0.0193096828,
0.0684120655,
-0.0392457917,
0.0215014648,
-0.0345373489,
-0.0082398551,
-0.1014523283,
0.0053265193,
0.0489305407,
0.0047161141,
-0.0061010038,
0.0625273064,
-0.0459097922,
0.0384925529,
0.0396870859,
-0.050546851,
-0.0341399312,
0.0166250337,
-0.0171888601,
-0.0251696724,
0.0131677836,
0.013580027,
0.021883605,
0.0230230298,
-0.0338622518,
-0.0010873564,
-0.0257376693,
-0.0262507927,
-0.0434008613,
0.0309516359,
-0.0374922976,
0.0048437943,
0.0248756632,
-0.0453548282,
-0.0687958002,
0.0138183078,
-0.0282535143,
0.0097096507,
-0.0676704347,
-0.0174844507,
0.0423756987,
0.0139956763,
-0.0225203689,
0.0501665138,
0.0209528636,
0.0295878779,
0.0289153028,
-0.0111826109,
0.0273398682,
-0.0317248143,
0.0156138977,
-0.0073770899,
-0.0056897141,
0.0271300506,
0.0433596708,
0.0299906116,
-0.0467293449,
-0.0428780913,
-0.0904527754,
0.0321437493,
-0.0336528011,
0.007169412,
0.0419638939,
0.0380100794,
-0.0015120549,
-0.0247785505,
-0.0827185288,
-0.010100984,
0.0559288263,
0.0268624425,
0.0426657163,
0.0172239468,
0.0792225599,
-0.0243112762,
-0.0135251405,
-0.0047369255,
0.0480474904,
0.0039538373,
0.0183715485,
-0.0150612453,
0.0055318852,
-0.0340104736,
-0.0094883488,
-0.0120083159,
0.0208186172,
-0.0010669347,
-0.0331585892,
0.0624365099,
0.0335450098,
0.0026310289,
-0.0105578816,
0.0321880728,
-0.0112949004,
-0.0448302515,
0.0351447463,
-0.0188852064,
0.0096970322,
0.0165353566,
-0.0084981816,
0.0072589549,
0.0433953106,
-0.0094220322,
-0.037482623,
-0.0177015401,
0.044993218,
0.010695491,
-0.0309263077,
-0.0604742654,
-0.0169887003,
0.0278278794,
0.0165948253,
-0.0266703479,
0.0016748455,
0.0759088695,
-0.0181168709,
-0.0198671985,
-0.0579420589,
0.025188107,
-0.0610877648,
0.0419189408,
-0.0050324448,
0.0076585556,
0.0095436508,
-0.0112198573,
-0.0627656281,
-0.0132084535,
0.0008011727,
0.0072240424,
0.0334207155,
-0.0207992438,
0.0154306637,
-0.0405172035,
-0.0338309221,
-0.0238551218,
-0.0334096365,
0.0276730619,
0.0359088778,
-0.010627808,
0.0272335839,
-0.0263366848,
0.0038947309,
0.0239309855,
0.0534115173,
-0.0751477033,
-0.0119304368,
-0.0212624334,
0.1077587008,
0.0866074935,
0.0070009287,
0.00567709,
-0.0658905581,
0.0155942403,
0.0504447371,
0.0477589257,
-0.0182964057,
0.0356641896,
0.0250395928,
-0.0149175348,
-0.047000587,
-0.0238193721,
-0.030660525,
0.0462405123,
-0.059046872,
-0.0379969254,
0.0744110122,
0.0574731044,
-0.0362166427,
-0.0225053616,
-0.0307898149,
0.0439750329,
0.013378202,
0.0617846884,
-0.0394779779,
-0.0218193233,
-0.026542075,
0.0198443849,
0.0263586845,
-0.0034571462,
-0.0345719829,
-0.0826945007,
0.0084619103,
-0.0073575638,
-0.0548356511,
0.0058146664,
-0.0205850936,
-0.0137729133,
0.036534138,
0.0010229981,
0.0251277946,
-0.0198451821,
0.0013969246,
-0.0084684025,
0.0256191641,
0.0044981069,
0.0118873483,
-0.0143014742,
-0.0263909008,
0.053898029,
0.0334184356,
0.0262847114,
0.0224850625,
0.0253527537,
-0.0632791445,
-0.0000688904,
0.0154024391,
0.0555268191,
-0.0362637341,
0.0228792597,
0.0076546902,
0.0474891178,
-0.0277174879,
0.0058269002,
0.0279601607,
0.0337749347,
0.0128278323,
-0.0177869927,
-0.0431002304,
0.0233495217,
-0.0015111383,
0.0698169991,
0.0324355029,
-0.0208570957,
-0.0722059906,
-0.0416034721,
0.0075641959,
-0.0762753636,
0.0359036438,
-0.0155147575,
0.0016407464,
0.0043948679,
-0.0812268034,
-0.0881736279,
0.0262887124,
0.0189566165,
-0.0375264771,
-0.0052997661,
-0.0183862988,
-0.0012521527,
-0.0192797221,
0.0193918552,
-0.0191102196,
-0.0107610542,
0.0015564412,
0.0055530616,
0.0681277886,
-0.0454826131,
-0.0158637948,
0.0050431266,
-0.0809410885,
-0.0470983796,
-0.0481742322,
0.0327527262,
0.0181653518,
0.0686905459,
-0.0331764072,
-0.0464768969,
0.0592556372,
0.001352315,
-0.0736797452,
0.012197379,
0.0237450115,
-0.0140633453,
-0.0156952031,
0.0458961986,
-0.0835884735,
0.0215006415,
-0.0289773233,
0.0390907973,
-0.0254604872,
-0.0308962483,
0.0185337905,
-0.0085290372,
-0.0115656685,
0.0201517157,
0.0462763049,
-0.0398211926,
0.0058110277,
-0.0405581146,
-0.0341486745,
-0.0467429496,
0.0222085193,
0.0122959884,
-0.0352340043,
-0.0223912969,
0.0285620447,
-0.0214715302,
0.0562517792,
-0.0314831324,
-0.0403311029,
0.0179962162,
0.0093166986,
-0.0343394279,
-0.0113022383,
-0.0258753821,
-0.0255671982,
-0.0120058376,
0.0459333807,
-0.0329236239,
0.0474948958,
0.0132999327,
-0.0083043184,
-0.0007280376,
-0.0022578973,
-0.110182412,
-0.0124180997,
-0.0554392152,
0.0198783912,
0.0138884159,
-0.0066763959,
0.0436338857,
0.003431797,
-0.0420227833,
-0.0161674321,
0.0219512433,
0.0189463347,
-0.0284030028,
0.0217718836,
0.0225750618,
-0.0026247585,
0.0208391864,
0.0916399285,
0.0012764258,
0.0240141265,
0.0183301847,
-0.0016441499,
-0.0549646318,
-0.0413415134,
0.0326303095,
0.0467902906,
-0.003581557,
0.0230754223,
-0.0298097208,
-0.0273725577,
0.0238716807,
0.0134326257,
-0.0270189662,
0.0046206717,
0.0512711927,
0.0749935657,
-0.0017504137,
-0.0129946554,
-0.0723544136,
0.0080878781,
-0.0326734595,
-0.0293477215,
0.0161188059,
-5.739407739e-33,
-0.0492013507,
-0.0014326263,
0.0326048434,
-0.0034158509,
-0.0383687876,
0.0064942813,
-0.0512475483,
-0.0125055285,
-0.0108350255,
-0.0089579243,
-0.0275166091,
0.0170342382,
-0.0090120956,
0.0440285578,
-0.0052312906,
0.0117653692,
0.0281735361,
-0.0277443659,
-0.0308980476,
0.0814862698,
0.0139324712,
0.0266753137,
0.0373782851,
0.0389738791,
0.0171764549,
-0.030367814,
-0.0105216717,
0.0018538551,
0.0121371886,
0.0430169962,
-0.0508040749,
-0.0028782983,
0.0409889929,
0.0030526977,
-0.0321292207,
0.0525399148,
-0.0815104991,
-0.0523303896,
0.0009639016,
-0.040405836,
-0.0599040091,
-0.0510084368,
0.008782641,
-0.0194601733,
0.0910878554,
-0.0461081713,
0.0448057055,
-0.0048723714,
-0.0390034765,
-0.0596897267,
-0.0488323458,
0.0061431881,
-0.0203791,
-0.0445512161,
-0.0113669373,
0.0884085074,
0.0226102509,
0.0457276665,
-0.0228394084,
0.0118147386,
0.0108338641,
0.0296662245,
0.0177644454,
0.0032261391,
-0.0191682838,
0.0202282704,
-0.0047094817,
-0.0192548037,
0.0159571767,
0.0055857655,
0.0079285819,
0.0085251639,
0.0148803843,
0.0546093471,
0.050229691,
0.0380314328,
-0.0800009444,
0.0885382965,
0.0008029215,
0.0095237363,
0.0017065785,
-0.018261686,
0.0271269679,
-0.0137823941,
-0.0388219506,
0.0120218769,
-0.0403496474,
-0.016721461,
0.011116365,
0.0291296151,
-0.0309464671,
-0.0009137146,
0.0449579097,
-0.0325341262,
0.0173442289,
0.0351774096,
-0.0394052379,
0.0250285529,
0.0180551466,
0.0638958514,
-0.050777331,
0.0091106975,
0.0481342189,
-0.0138211651,
-0.0208659861,
0.0272737145,
0.0323660932,
0.0105627393,
-0.0685091615,
0.000372328,
-0.0146655021,
0.0341073126,
-0.0356132016,
0.0170386694,
0.000153722,
0.007105696,
0.0061694281,
0.0648793653,
0.0105330665,
-0.0001292244,
-0.0333910994,
-0.066000089,
0.0023461957,
0.0409061871,
-0.0168473311,
0.0300115831,
-0.0209051427,
0.0073032519,
0.0265554078,
-0.0588353761,
0.0006471376,
0.0452342927,
2.291e-7,
0.0608219504,
0.013162164,
0.0415080972,
0.026553927,
0.0083868876,
0.0186009314,
-0.0215207636,
0.0739172101,
0.0361650549,
-0.0038919435,
0.025649922,
0.0180924442,
0.0395263061,
0.0299133789,
-0.0867522582,
0.0160063412,
-0.042823825,
-0.0086934594,
-0.0454451106,
-0.0546523556,
0.0122110015,
0.0753992274,
-0.0410237052,
-0.0149309961,
-0.0304436274,
-0.0380043946,
0.1124057993,
-0.0000779968,
-0.0735746101,
0.0453425609,
0.0386786386,
0.0110855289,
-0.0171814803,
-0.0158157405,
-0.0230295826,
0.0441729799,
0.0395169295,
0.0429061688,
0.0229625106,
-0.0528717116,
0.0144491205,
-0.0105857411,
0.0195468999,
-0.0323273875,
0.0900700912,
-0.0627557784,
0.0002803565,
-0.0235503204,
-0.0459377654,
-0.0000291696,
0.0128709022,
-0.0429729894,
-0.0455528237,
0.0363187194,
0.0087559391,
-0.0113396123,
0.0210842285,
-0.0559101887,
-0.021472659,
0.0305860564,
-0.0272447951,
-0.0214645509,
-0.0137196546,
-0.0316317007,
0.0086745946,
-0.0717805699,
-0.0117420265,
1.990114002e-34,
0.0709054694,
-0.0463045128,
-0.0237653609,
-0.0165910888,
0.0169574413,
-0.0297632553,
-0.019453764,
-0.0176425707,
0.0180715416,
-0.0864082649,
-0.0355133116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15386v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15386v2 | Vistaar: Diverse Benchmarks and Training Sets for Indian Language ASR | 2023-05-24T17:46:03 | 2023-08-02T13:29:31 | Kaushal Santosh Bhogale, Sai Sundaresan, Abhigyan Raman, Tahir Javed, Mitesh M. Khapra, Pratyush Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Improving ASR systems is necessary to make new LLM-based use-cases accessible
to people across the globe. In this paper, we focus on Indian languages, and
make the case that diverse benchmarks are required to evaluate and improve ASR
systems for Indian languages. To address this, we collate Vistaar as a set of
59 benchmarks across various language and domain combinations, on which we
evaluate 3 publicly available ASR systems and 2 commercial systems. We also
train IndicWhisper models by fine-tuning the Whisper models on publicly
available training datasets across 12 Indian languages totalling to 10.7K
hours. We show that IndicWhisper significantly improves on considered ASR
systems on the Vistaar benchmark. Indeed, IndicWhisper has the lowest WER in 39
out of the 59 benchmarks, with an average reduction of 4.1 WER. We open-source
all datasets, code and models. | [
-0.0142578995,
0.0340470336,
0.0157827251,
0.0634766966,
-0.0235759113,
0.00601529,
0.0189631041,
0.012954439,
0.0124280062,
-0.0112688961,
-0.0775553733,
-0.0267406199,
0.0136885699,
0.0215804093,
0.0178685598,
-0.0096606091,
0.0369850062,
-0.0778178573,
-0.0189430527,
-0.011069838,
0.0226665139,
0.0159026887,
-0.0741651878,
0.0467666388,
-0.0307881199,
-0.0050525679,
0.0123046832,
-0.0006042928,
0.0312378313,
-0.049641367,
0.0029477715,
-0.0037933113,
0.0180598814,
0.0042119538,
0.0000017136,
-0.0443324037,
-0.0040803519,
0.0064198533,
-0.0497119091,
0.0110099763,
0.0246901307,
-0.0049483133,
-0.0115350736,
0.0540524535,
-0.0220338888,
0.0206310283,
0.0355506912,
0.025820924,
0.0107100448,
0.0797533318,
-0.0080292048,
-0.0306146033,
0.0272409543,
0.0027056136,
-0.0302665569,
-0.030511491,
-0.0154167106,
-0.0285662264,
-0.0346859992,
-0.0163588449,
-0.0018051855,
0.0339562334,
0.0294031557,
-0.0183284953,
0.0102488799,
-0.0033706957,
-0.0192420911,
-0.020392254,
-0.0110824155,
0.0297452789,
-0.0066776918,
-0.0385821834,
0.0292726923,
0.0252638552,
-0.0613561906,
-0.0649895817,
-0.0340945981,
0.0207630526,
-0.0466963574,
0.0343257599,
0.0358688869,
0.0338830054,
0.0205582138,
-0.0117027136,
0.047836557,
0.0400881246,
0.0204125103,
-0.0288662631,
0.0063592386,
-0.0244218577,
0.0515851639,
-0.0119816512,
0.0416102484,
0.0221454129,
-0.0494213067,
0.0151255028,
-0.0239768885,
0.0105692018,
0.0118456259,
-0.0601974539,
0.0470740721,
0.0629936084,
-0.0233597644,
-0.0062931506,
0.0124616371,
0.0567792058,
0.0269742776,
0.0076246355,
0.0049853413,
0.0052258717,
0.0248726066,
-0.0182015263,
-0.024443021,
0.0306240227,
-0.0389675088,
-0.015260838,
-0.0592322573,
0.0056274761,
0.0111995395,
-0.0012210894,
0.0598831065,
-0.0198819172,
-0.032357391,
-0.0412198231,
0.0368434452,
0.0277766883,
0.0033025914,
0.0487528332,
0.0133661479,
-0.0866747051,
-0.0049264813,
0.0338959396,
-0.0311438516,
0.0077231494,
-0.0176741332,
0.0603859872,
-0.0156588145,
-0.0277016237,
-0.0905336961,
0.0197726376,
-0.0097496519,
-0.0851963758,
-0.0360290371,
-0.0520954952,
0.0128976731,
0.0276517775,
0.007902001,
-0.0507890806,
0.0100102387,
-0.0122695463,
0.0795981288,
0.0915190578,
-0.0244414639,
-0.0164789446,
0.031117294,
0.027098,
0.0243041422,
0.0635657087,
0.0335545167,
-0.0085154865,
0.0244716164,
-0.0406424105,
0.0042586918,
0.0645954385,
-0.0188606493,
-0.0079234028,
-0.0104247639,
0.0178495161,
0.0128458999,
0.0310354792,
0.0211507753,
0.0536729544,
-0.0008358,
-0.0049357093,
0.0285800211,
0.0552528091,
0.0516001657,
0.0341000706,
0.0209961571,
0.000444743,
0.0153515106,
-0.0281235725,
-0.012999597,
-0.02174576,
-0.0109158633,
0.0119013404,
0.0304275546,
0.0131046819,
-0.0227759387,
-0.0283038616,
-0.0389895402,
-0.0521253794,
-0.0668445975,
0.0427621678,
0.0483630374,
0.0113531556,
-0.03819938,
0.0403460823,
0.0384553708,
-0.060510233,
0.0381564274,
-0.0643620938,
0.0097712213,
0.0251028016,
-0.0068810764,
-0.0582578368,
-0.0057595139,
0.0027003856,
0.0035056961,
0.046557609,
0.0145825455,
-0.0025476168,
0.0392474234,
-0.0839231461,
-0.0069382768,
0.0680286735,
-0.0125528099,
0.01868793,
-0.0173877887,
0.0252623409,
-0.0006983891,
-0.0368643552,
0.0016581506,
0.0161925927,
-0.0262660589,
-0.0166076627,
0.0035943305,
0.0004306083,
0.0626936853,
0.0292096417,
-0.0070781047,
-0.0394662768,
0.0476063862,
-0.016963765,
0.0143066579,
0.0271971878,
-0.0611702837,
-0.0479571596,
0.0277628675,
-0.0083408933,
0.0290374551,
0.044394467,
-0.001821034,
-0.0577955022,
0.0062237871,
-0.0342979059,
0.0379075855,
-0.0242547989,
0.0691791698,
0.0364230722,
0.0009706515,
0.0084431302,
0.0032180427,
0.0168268159,
-0.0120689636,
-0.0137886889,
0.0089116869,
0.0548020042,
-0.0978122354,
0.0188443232,
0.0155795338,
-0.0210871156,
0.0167108458,
0.0056884694,
0.003782965,
-0.0506118387,
-0.0318043903,
-0.064469032,
-0.0050619617,
-0.0382314175,
0.0408378728,
-0.0339286067,
0.051192306,
0.0036516995,
-0.0430095904,
-0.0095153833,
-0.0063405987,
0.0171179064,
-0.0076780571,
-0.0126173198,
-0.0235650074,
-0.0361774489,
-0.0259889551,
-0.0221959595,
0.010850098,
0.0241380967,
-0.0059066853,
-0.0459346399,
-0.0780923367,
0.0070752637,
0.0119983843,
0.0147538837,
-0.0362183452,
-0.0506898351,
-0.0051826341,
-0.0018110888,
-0.016644543,
0.0257215332,
-0.0198827814,
0.0207098853,
-0.0342018045,
0.0163754746,
-0.0826076418,
-0.0185254421,
0.0304671638,
0.0174033549,
-0.0312954299,
0.0339946561,
-0.0064232787,
0.0410773605,
-0.0029589594,
0.0367330872,
-0.0126780272,
-0.0388020985,
-0.0315696895,
-0.035268303,
-0.0323124975,
0.0163958911,
-0.0558185093,
0.035459958,
0.0014105452,
-0.0384858847,
0.0202032719,
-0.0706181452,
-0.0207237042,
-0.0388261974,
-0.055518005,
-0.0601738915,
-0.0197250098,
-0.0215155855,
-0.0040445714,
0.0008642845,
-0.0669721887,
0.0030086564,
0.021848565,
-0.0279903691,
-0.0426107422,
0.0514446162,
-0.0404135585,
0.0522206575,
-0.0171758384,
-0.0510641783,
-0.0346847288,
0.0287622977,
-0.0225201994,
0.0527621619,
0.000890791,
-0.0418791063,
0.0070414236,
0.0572464019,
-0.014043089,
0.0478646308,
0.0103773978,
0.0126386629,
-0.0117988847,
-0.0073131379,
0.0629034564,
-0.0127547812,
-0.0011875133,
0.0145124663,
0.0506047271,
-0.0061853272,
0.1032043099,
0.001399057,
-0.0631751493,
0.0191580541,
0.0566082858,
-0.0310143344,
0.0211548507,
0.0186194703,
0.0517128855,
-0.0081141312,
-0.0094602099,
0.0898570791,
0.0142405108,
-0.0195774883,
-0.0132339336,
-0.0166740548,
0.0290364474,
0.0077061881,
-0.0141449152,
-0.092371285,
-0.0247717611,
0.0409830511,
0.0251298919,
0.0477680527,
0.0078271963,
0.0022471689,
-0.106670551,
-0.0053680302,
-0.0034476083,
-0.0405949838,
0.0036510688,
-0.0358208269,
-0.0370577797,
-0.0344697721,
0.0842379853,
0.0306296274,
-0.0386793688,
-0.0502118841,
0.0603229553,
-0.0976342931,
-0.0297808629,
-0.0111123901,
-0.0372067653,
0.0743498951,
0.0478264578,
-0.0352752768,
0.009899376,
-0.0478782989,
0.0316122808,
-0.005919809,
-0.0078180833,
-0.0264745802,
0.0420618579,
0.0083142072,
-0.033770144,
0.0095848897,
0.0302385483,
-0.0386456773,
0.013173365,
0.017940728,
0.0042352374,
-0.0261228122,
0.0001875134,
0.0255701803,
-0.0097103203,
0.0018773249,
0.0409236699,
-0.0041948543,
0.0056819054,
-0.015967194,
-0.0187010672,
0.0433649495,
-0.0290815532,
-0.0375596546,
0.0136041539,
-0.0233758166,
-0.0458566509,
-0.0047315564,
-0.0310606491,
0.0394540168,
0.03281397,
0.0279095527,
0.0524514578,
-0.0234359,
0.006600311,
-0.0221561883,
-0.0026289467,
-0.031185504,
0.0458163768,
-0.1147222966,
0.0022770979,
0.0552439466,
-0.005050919,
-0.0211367831,
-0.0206399392,
-0.036444705,
-0.0761003569,
0.0226151068,
0.0544459745,
0.0277212858,
0.0210018381,
-0.0313625485,
-0.0823832825,
0.0288881864,
-0.005929749,
-0.0290268082,
0.0092827315,
0.0509118065,
0.0111566121,
0.0035000618,
0.0194092449,
-0.0494504869,
0.0044473866,
-0.0125055015,
0.0207335614,
-0.0344494469,
-0.0269198902,
0.0065142852,
0.0455246828,
0.0464547761,
-0.0619025752,
-0.0277495086,
-0.0111745792,
0.0351905935,
0.0024987969,
0.0487020239,
-0.0248276684,
0.0104702618,
0.0337907448,
0.0399976745,
-0.011349611,
0.0258810781,
-0.0179893151,
-0.0060242387,
-0.014979762,
0.0937685072,
0.0287806951,
0.0264243186,
0.0373173393,
0.0068409923,
-0.0273888912,
0.0397940725,
0.0613928102,
0.0275069252,
0.0084692659,
0.0380097479,
-0.0089699924,
0.0417137966,
0.0600898601,
0.0389118902,
0.0327239484,
-0.0301686991,
-0.0014330233,
0.0693502352,
0.0393300578,
0.0364771336,
0.0451760218,
0.0192223564,
0.0355338901,
-0.0512192734,
0.0504492521,
-0.032450866,
0.0124585144,
0.0888587236,
0.0099629005,
-0.0435837209,
0.0425642505,
0.0427791178,
-0.010860282,
0.0517767668,
0.0056439601,
0.0349792056,
-0.0603061505,
-0.0405060053,
-0.0052231369,
-0.0066431039,
-0.002423529,
-0.0208200272,
-0.0062454701,
-0.0780425742,
0.0283283945,
-0.0120640742,
0.0167388227,
-0.030557571,
0.0126412977,
-0.0038242089,
0.0020745459,
-0.0273115281,
0.0116431136,
-0.0597813316,
-0.0385689586,
-0.0449580848,
0.0161743071,
-6.017188809e-33,
-0.0324969962,
0.0401964188,
0.0238308813,
0.025314467,
-0.0197268799,
0.0172378533,
-0.0206216797,
0.0029707719,
-0.016983645,
-0.0157282185,
-0.0203546267,
-0.006337753,
0.0520772375,
0.021937415,
0.0115199173,
-0.0155729586,
0.0869828761,
0.0199671388,
0.0173871443,
-0.0255757775,
0.0115331728,
0.0286193006,
0.0782287419,
-0.0292275976,
-0.0404302552,
-0.0265381467,
-0.0165644009,
0.0250638165,
-0.013992548,
0.0699654818,
-0.017040642,
0.0678566396,
0.0060343905,
-0.0146002304,
-0.0200830512,
0.021028921,
-0.0975209922,
0.0094335461,
0.0065064738,
0.1060836911,
0.0182946324,
-0.0276550055,
0.0301210955,
0.0008885259,
-0.0829966441,
0.0197777674,
0.0136432061,
0.0015868788,
-0.0343194231,
-0.0432919972,
-0.020542616,
0.0387520976,
-0.006666238,
-0.0147529179,
0.0633337498,
0.0224527419,
-0.0203251448,
-0.0734708756,
-0.0802143812,
-0.0061566634,
0.0072074579,
0.0706116781,
0.0657973364,
0.0265870728,
-0.0449412093,
0.0069053164,
0.0729242638,
-0.0917458311,
0.0418374427,
-0.0257791411,
0.0197042879,
0.0548596233,
-0.0011912945,
0.0117235538,
0.0162427928,
-0.0207265336,
-0.0116719548,
0.0059668631,
0.0110944835,
0.0500919484,
-0.0013739063,
0.0139928823,
-0.0588062033,
-0.0206640512,
-0.002081532,
-0.0011924177,
-0.0366534777,
-0.0240940042,
0.0942614973,
0.0100318538,
0.0311848801,
0.047080759,
0.0481838174,
-0.0317578316,
0.0144115919,
0.0089652874,
0.0294063482,
0.0080761313,
-0.016422553,
0.0140193431,
-0.0671724454,
-0.033267349,
-0.0102773495,
0.0669424832,
0.0148542216,
-0.0369810574,
0.0241588447,
0.0208124872,
-0.0823883936,
-0.002125337,
-0.0116434898,
0.0388963036,
0.035727188,
0.0411138795,
0.0321603641,
-0.0564362407,
-0.0345323272,
0.0422595069,
-0.0362525322,
0.0020685976,
-0.0110354088,
0.0225812607,
0.0165563878,
0.0219894461,
-0.0381275341,
0.0318405479,
-0.041739542,
-0.0179179385,
0.010102584,
-0.0079245884,
-0.0081380773,
0.0144759025,
2.336e-7,
-0.021352455,
0.0198935457,
0.0532626919,
-0.0136025297,
-0.0431319922,
0.0102737779,
-0.0286082793,
-0.0260967389,
-0.0108874962,
0.0425131805,
-0.045753628,
-0.0026669758,
0.094868727,
-0.0080208303,
-0.1054862589,
-0.0188743621,
-0.0821625218,
0.0245266482,
-0.0262736026,
0.0003362386,
-0.0181886237,
0.0581837408,
-0.00659901,
-0.0513955802,
-0.0085549997,
-0.0194617864,
0.022213662,
-0.0102404505,
0.0046543102,
0.0279303696,
0.0148839187,
-0.0189289059,
-0.0180037953,
-0.0201580152,
-0.0246628225,
-0.0055191829,
-0.0047090389,
0.0488795266,
-0.0372237861,
-0.0550722554,
0.0204765555,
0.049106352,
-0.0079437746,
-0.0264775865,
0.030237684,
0.0298260227,
-0.0232848208,
-0.0022158516,
-0.026985554,
-0.035228163,
-0.008654749,
0.0086648157,
0.026430808,
0.0106045865,
0.0138160167,
-0.067615144,
-0.061017476,
-0.0422051996,
-0.0050267843,
0.0103129745,
-0.0205436312,
-0.0177294444,
-0.0067992914,
0.0237712562,
-0.0404434837,
-0.0212228205,
-0.0133047523,
1.649165998e-34,
0.0584785379,
-0.0102625815,
0.0386943631,
0.0662009045,
0.0210881066,
-0.0199885312,
-0.0081418417,
0.0282740593,
-0.00031706,
-0.0734196529,
-0.0191102121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15380v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15380v1 | Sentiment Analysis Using Aligned Word Embeddings for Uralic Languages | 2023-05-24T17:40:20 | 2023-05-24T17:40:20 | Khalid Alnajjar, Mika Hämäläinen, Jack Rueter | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present an approach for translating word embeddings from a
majority language into 4 minority languages: Erzya, Moksha, Udmurt and
Komi-Zyrian. Furthermore, we align these word embeddings and present a novel
neural network model that is trained on English data to conduct sentiment
analysis and then applied on endangered language data through the aligned word
embeddings. To test our model, we annotated a small sentiment analysis corpus
for the 4 endangered languages and Finnish. Our method reached at least 56\%
accuracy for each endangered language. The models and the sentiment corpus will
be released together with this paper. Our research shows that state-of-the-art
neural models can be used with endangered languages with the only requirement
being a dictionary between the endangered language and a majority language. | [
-0.0136291031,
0.0955578834,
0.0198046975,
0.0487555824,
-0.0229810253,
0.0222311802,
-0.0289999805,
-0.0586719848,
0.0065356349,
-0.0173719451,
-0.0089508519,
-0.061760284,
0.0016674375,
-0.0130765466,
0.010194418,
0.0050184266,
0.0657932609,
0.0458531007,
0.037214756,
-0.0296499357,
0.0425912626,
0.0121038808,
-0.0135672558,
0.0085773319,
-0.0469616093,
-0.0125098079,
-0.0110707935,
-0.0042803455,
-0.0036876223,
-0.0221616589,
0.0132380296,
0.012030948,
0.0168986917,
0.0481656566,
0.0000018115,
-0.0053213192,
-0.0009877245,
-0.025804719,
0.0320971236,
0.0143833756,
0.0759666413,
-0.0404189453,
-0.0334161371,
0.029818235,
-0.0260407329,
-0.0607760623,
0.078861855,
0.042576056,
0.0374948569,
0.0907106251,
-0.0077619869,
-0.0395620838,
0.0054625198,
-0.0266271513,
-0.0593290292,
0.0241700653,
0.0216342006,
-0.0249683298,
-0.043510288,
-0.0198022351,
-0.0307105556,
0.0362193137,
-0.0129578253,
-0.0018412214,
-0.0081495335,
-0.0139537938,
-0.0574407987,
-0.0410938635,
0.0272187144,
0.0294488855,
-0.0233838111,
-0.0125871636,
-0.0431315154,
0.0310332719,
-0.0245331284,
-0.0175347496,
-0.0130847823,
-0.0149388155,
0.0328381024,
0.0593839586,
0.067426078,
0.0574245229,
0.0457518809,
-0.0004659284,
-0.0164811388,
0.0333341323,
0.0158003569,
-0.0416897386,
0.007372316,
0.0112130884,
-0.0161269326,
0.0226438772,
0.03280285,
0.0009849707,
0.0147569114,
0.0190403052,
0.0130077507,
-0.0881837532,
0.0118085537,
-0.100241825,
-0.0206804313,
0.0204651691,
-0.015101145,
0.0239982791,
-0.046895083,
0.0008924062,
0.0269899331,
-0.0183308925,
-0.0062946621,
-0.0096671069,
-0.0040562195,
-0.0002594297,
-0.001879286,
0.0138322357,
-0.0254006553,
0.0183863696,
-0.0298833624,
0.0014900077,
-0.0065430091,
0.0312613659,
0.023549499,
0.0112043358,
0.0331729762,
0.0285762362,
-0.0088021224,
0.0323043875,
-0.066189982,
-0.0080071967,
-0.0879051983,
-0.0221238844,
0.0232630167,
0.0329762138,
-0.0228497237,
0.0013004869,
0.0048407838,
0.0490235463,
0.0502831899,
-0.0407559313,
-0.0275708493,
0.0393236876,
-0.0160380118,
-0.0367660709,
-0.0076453597,
-0.0583524108,
0.0599918328,
-0.0063151568,
-0.0015639365,
-0.0505619906,
0.0049913977,
0.0076490361,
-0.0571302772,
0.0843124017,
-0.0132624814,
0.0006357692,
-0.0127826249,
-0.0174582899,
0.0600357167,
0.0613708384,
0.0094071152,
0.0227645561,
0.0651655048,
-0.0282396749,
-0.0138044283,
0.0051482026,
0.0150257796,
-0.0206741244,
-0.042999614,
0.0215449017,
-0.0182202142,
0.0197351389,
0.0213558357,
0.0448618904,
0.0259778257,
-0.0405355394,
0.0310264044,
0.0409817658,
0.0227789264,
0.0618119687,
-0.0536621697,
-0.0183448028,
-0.0342939384,
-0.0020457245,
-0.0090600736,
0.0146791236,
0.0207957644,
-0.0154435653,
0.0375554785,
0.0182749182,
-0.0244920086,
-0.032541275,
-0.0269172881,
-0.0362116024,
0.0520541258,
-0.0144859329,
0.0514739007,
-0.0409027152,
-0.0303660817,
0.0090163937,
0.055468373,
-0.0575676002,
0.0170151256,
0.0344205275,
0.0386335365,
0.0384675376,
0.0326070748,
-0.0213213768,
0.0113342321,
-0.0267957542,
-0.0372791551,
0.0469390266,
0.0450792499,
-0.014957563,
-0.019298112,
-0.0749838576,
0.0201067012,
0.0009105369,
0.0317125432,
0.0268146489,
-0.0246782377,
0.0765346214,
-0.0072448407,
-0.0075241947,
-0.0400015377,
0.0231862534,
-0.0059565939,
-0.0122893704,
-0.0270061158,
0.0363171138,
-0.0079973014,
0.0619956069,
-0.034708064,
0.0166351553,
0.0500440858,
-0.02726629,
-0.0140767675,
0.0289337356,
-0.0139460173,
-0.0727790445,
0.0367743038,
-0.0421791375,
-0.0001109068,
0.0438084416,
-0.0354466029,
-0.0182092581,
0.0570322946,
-0.0056812153,
0.0362725072,
-0.0459917262,
0.0168656092,
-0.0343810283,
0.0158307124,
-0.0146970693,
0.0425125286,
-0.0279395673,
0.0323363803,
-0.0403395109,
-0.0964577943,
0.0411243215,
-0.0187937301,
-0.1016245633,
0.0417579114,
0.0308983568,
0.0040369267,
0.0113954823,
-0.0131595396,
0.0282831863,
0.0066472664,
-0.0703874305,
0.0002597929,
-0.027560031,
0.0592200384,
-0.0013206732,
0.0239275843,
0.0082816109,
0.0082361782,
-0.0433435068,
-0.0055674175,
0.0014633533,
0.0035639019,
0.0339714214,
-0.01570829,
0.0293942504,
-0.0706807449,
-0.0162280519,
-0.0053059841,
-0.0003194926,
0.0023245842,
-0.0507051945,
-0.0093846843,
0.0406795368,
-0.0400905944,
0.0428907722,
-0.0007535045,
-0.0797752514,
0.0039878683,
0.00791441,
-0.0151582537,
0.0039653275,
-0.0092500858,
0.0221866351,
0.0441184118,
0.0090839388,
-0.0081181461,
0.0023010809,
-0.0555352792,
0.0533014201,
0.000187595,
0.0148142464,
-0.025152877,
0.0245588608,
0.0031131122,
-0.0454969369,
-0.0554082468,
-0.0265666209,
-0.0459913723,
0.0361288041,
-0.0291272867,
0.0018862076,
0.0071646958,
0.008229401,
-0.0066537922,
-0.026902454,
0.0523412824,
0.0289268345,
0.0218860619,
-0.0906942859,
-0.0288350172,
-0.0483996607,
0.0016944768,
-0.0080987466,
0.0064452235,
-0.0649754256,
0.0120418798,
-0.0227755327,
-0.0219128057,
-0.0416172035,
-0.0378889814,
0.038950853,
0.0217463709,
-0.0061567239,
-0.0223915745,
-0.0281701814,
-0.0191113222,
-0.0900163502,
-0.0022120234,
-0.0029546968,
0.0364582203,
-0.0223374292,
-0.0108573558,
0.025927918,
-0.0312618278,
-0.0303120632,
0.0128300097,
0.0316843763,
0.0083376355,
0.0063913735,
0.00714709,
-0.037979044,
0.055115778,
0.0388408564,
0.0485772006,
0.0184546076,
0.0061439904,
-0.0057362397,
-0.0366465524,
-0.0349835642,
0.0256133378,
-0.0071377144,
0.000193988,
-0.0841499045,
0.0205286648,
0.0075741112,
0.0468428843,
0.0867733434,
0.0229274575,
-0.0220244415,
0.0208812188,
-0.044709526,
0.0126829445,
0.0257476922,
0.0110203978,
-0.0266512465,
0.0075709093,
-0.0155904964,
0.0214916207,
0.0266013462,
-0.016174309,
0.0241658632,
-0.1114833057,
-0.0423860811,
0.0320886075,
-0.0105421059,
-0.0678904727,
-0.0087579824,
0.0013361496,
-0.0415131636,
0.0185596086,
-0.0241662785,
0.0272940714,
0.0119165983,
-0.0001628974,
-0.0352600105,
-0.048711095,
-0.0113402866,
-0.0487166122,
0.0457204729,
0.0211784076,
0.0716052949,
-0.0728294626,
-0.038019076,
0.0271376111,
0.0144691532,
-0.0424313396,
0.0093521085,
0.023794705,
-0.0168682225,
-0.0513570569,
-0.0000117686,
-0.0206387844,
-0.0553664006,
0.0296453424,
-0.0054362519,
0.0531934015,
-0.0011698959,
-0.0068874941,
-0.0310342927,
-0.0107308058,
0.0358876698,
0.0521269627,
-0.0040658792,
-0.0497242697,
0.0015141872,
-0.001822432,
-0.0121325599,
-0.0175934955,
0.0198562574,
0.0109434901,
0.019351339,
-0.0452484526,
-0.1004419103,
-0.0614723861,
0.0329526961,
0.0185271334,
0.0213798992,
0.0296424311,
0.0010175275,
-0.0347149521,
-0.0320447199,
0.0493827872,
0.0353503898,
0.0120425569,
-0.0107006542,
0.0176034067,
0.0417685062,
0.0092480136,
0.0047597936,
-0.0483793095,
0.001336464,
-0.0617499128,
-0.0089185229,
0.0253281947,
0.0034580277,
-0.0148226107,
-0.0232423916,
-0.0553285442,
0.0051015005,
0.0292897634,
-0.0177662671,
0.0064720134,
0.0449867994,
0.0182746537,
0.0011813903,
0.0347430371,
0.0032598467,
0.0260864608,
-0.0282155853,
0.0042757401,
-0.0038347228,
-0.0057286513,
-0.0279324669,
-0.0249921568,
0.0378985256,
-0.019202169,
-0.0065314299,
-0.061294809,
-0.0131592713,
0.0102995047,
0.0003473099,
0.004151931,
-0.0123277046,
0.016114803,
0.008882557,
-0.060571339,
-0.0375328958,
-0.0021531298,
-0.014243721,
-0.0160377808,
0.0688055754,
0.0742610022,
0.0185415186,
-0.0136941476,
0.0517671145,
-0.0226075947,
0.023269292,
-0.0515232272,
-0.0134228216,
-0.0384558253,
-0.0090096919,
-0.0162105318,
-0.00159266,
0.0290330667,
0.0348788872,
0.0433066823,
0.0218481459,
-0.0170796327,
0.014631887,
0.040566273,
-0.0387289785,
0.0236419719,
-0.0082279714,
0.0105279535,
-0.0268043485,
0.0097604599,
-0.0291396454,
-0.0131237106,
0.0487206914,
-0.0018608314,
-0.0384259596,
-0.0048845806,
-0.0026592824,
-0.0601914302,
0.0382154472,
0.0008428411,
0.0082622878,
-0.0277313255,
0.0350718573,
0.0609249435,
0.0381613225,
-0.0237946585,
0.0184885077,
-0.03823236,
-0.0689119324,
0.0149761774,
0.0176828802,
-0.0328697711,
0.0271551982,
0.0085174469,
-0.00642853,
0.0068954537,
0.0870664865,
-0.0403494351,
0.0387194157,
-0.0864855573,
-0.0530938804,
-0.0263674092,
-5.653734772e-33,
0.0125538474,
0.0118585024,
-0.0369403698,
-0.0429631285,
0.0118713519,
-0.0212733708,
0.0099094594,
0.0206693001,
-0.066950351,
0.0304305051,
0.0157300178,
0.0084179519,
-0.0093167117,
-0.000530733,
0.0118882339,
-0.0116347112,
0.0123886159,
-0.0170955565,
0.0252434332,
-0.0069897235,
0.0431934893,
0.0342426859,
0.0888656303,
-0.1020245552,
0.0529876575,
-0.0178173315,
-0.000652828,
0.0150700072,
0.0297936238,
0.0324775241,
-0.0324537307,
0.0520077944,
0.0176488422,
0.0105235623,
0.0234749913,
0.0366404541,
-0.0307617914,
-0.0308459848,
0.014374733,
0.0425317697,
-0.0089945905,
-0.0044538886,
0.0056232307,
-0.0034713969,
-0.0294917077,
0.0760881305,
0.0081534088,
-0.0025620605,
-0.0090742325,
-0.0083236275,
-0.0473691188,
0.0413280763,
0.0163496789,
0.0102314008,
0.0422648303,
0.0525759831,
0.0588615648,
0.0082767457,
-0.0977377743,
-0.0153245004,
-0.0905957744,
0.0103420066,
0.0249653067,
-0.0247287527,
-0.0074211084,
0.0715285689,
-0.0080477661,
-0.0596135482,
0.0050255042,
0.0518154465,
0.0195824038,
-0.0206221528,
0.0539447144,
0.0427860245,
0.0168254878,
-0.0500486679,
-0.0589689165,
0.0003441983,
0.0680254623,
0.0161070321,
0.0682751611,
0.01368667,
-0.0802820921,
-0.0110880323,
0.0207722355,
-0.0617713854,
-0.0222683791,
-0.031049544,
0.0067635272,
-0.0329795554,
-0.0034638299,
-0.0196393505,
-0.0093143452,
-0.0764479265,
-0.0313626043,
0.0480701253,
-0.0303249732,
0.0048385947,
-0.0042562266,
0.0189314336,
-0.0140141193,
-0.0077563408,
-0.0491527393,
0.0178255849,
0.0193780344,
0.0025476506,
0.0477101468,
0.0395455621,
-0.0574358739,
-0.0031102162,
-0.0105748689,
0.0095161041,
0.0303908587,
0.0890960321,
0.0058827628,
0.004091315,
-0.003522794,
0.0223325044,
0.0641133934,
0.0299138762,
0.0068703536,
-0.0110350307,
0.0136425579,
-0.013775426,
-0.0177375823,
-0.0090722907,
0.0397464149,
0.0374035947,
-0.0242852569,
-0.0309891831,
0.0082105286,
-0.0078459559,
2.671e-7,
0.080060102,
0.0309949331,
0.0080057848,
-0.0299340375,
0.0181844514,
0.0172471944,
-0.0465790369,
0.0217632875,
-0.0389438346,
-0.0087407343,
-0.0019254194,
-0.0111075258,
0.0379537828,
0.0141952019,
-0.1118741259,
0.0188188814,
-0.0487658307,
0.005307517,
-0.0012541681,
0.0147020621,
0.0588061921,
0.1569541991,
0.0389203615,
0.0088429144,
-0.0775623471,
-0.0162334796,
0.0375694782,
-0.0246305093,
-0.0203468874,
-0.0336783156,
-0.003779029,
0.0404086187,
-0.0212185346,
-0.0540378317,
0.0012959149,
0.0822891518,
0.0249220822,
0.0328630768,
-0.0315446928,
-0.038239114,
0.0289975405,
-0.0112114968,
-0.0161879528,
-0.0352249444,
0.0436905436,
0.0037246398,
-0.047885146,
-0.0928260759,
0.0603162162,
0.067620717,
0.1059454605,
0.0021913091,
0.006558388,
-0.0128633296,
0.0461316817,
-0.060412325,
-0.0466316119,
-0.076938048,
-0.0354768001,
0.009522507,
-0.0163124148,
-0.0059378771,
0.0238850191,
0.0591238625,
0.0383252762,
0.0018911787,
0.0178938005,
1.948874125e-34,
0.0513470322,
-0.02161384,
-0.030319782,
0.0282144342,
0.0040965853,
-0.0267630424,
-0.0071344115,
-0.0174251199,
0.0397245847,
-0.0105596874,
0.0006856952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15377v1 | Uncovering and Quantifying Social Biases in Code Generation | 2023-05-24T17:37:33 | 2023-05-24T17:37:33 | Yan Liu, Xiaokang Chen, Yan Gao, Zhe Su, Fengji Zhang, Daoguang Zan, Jian-Guang Lou, Pin-Yu Chen, Tsung-Yi Ho | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the popularity of automatic code generation tools, such as Copilot, the
study of the potential hazards of these tools is gaining importance. In this
work, we explore the social bias problem in pre-trained code generation models.
We propose a new paradigm to construct code prompts and successfully uncover
social biases in code generation models. To quantify the severity of social
biases in generated code, we develop a dataset along with three metrics to
evaluate the overall social bias and fine-grained unfairness across different
demographics. Experimental results on three pre-trained code generation models
(Codex, InCoder, and CodeGen) with varying sizes, reveal severe social biases.
Moreover, we conduct analysis to provide useful insights for further choice of
code generation models with low social bias. (This work contains examples that
potentially implicate stereotypes, associations, and other harms that could be
offensive to individuals in certain social groups.) | [
0.027923556,
0.0686289743,
-0.0392650664,
-0.0192481298,
0.0210891906,
0.0233655293,
0.0360973775,
-0.0046642604,
0.0106005669,
-0.0122846412,
-0.0235043485,
0.019428961,
0.0269016493,
0.0326342434,
0.0143782282,
0.0072479788,
0.0323645957,
0.0375464223,
0.0013903809,
-0.0153733846,
-0.0087003922,
0.0395844057,
0.0382932462,
0.0718697906,
-0.0050127367,
-0.0328568332,
0.0361138545,
0.0340808928,
0.0151693635,
-0.0184020065,
0.0810621157,
0.0839840621,
-0.0381587297,
0.016120946,
0.0000021846,
-0.0547262095,
0.0039012777,
-0.0032451788,
0.0102308709,
0.0221081264,
0.0210586805,
0.0171222016,
-0.0029521685,
0.0357080959,
-0.0647010058,
-0.014088274,
0.0457728356,
-0.0420033634,
0.0700137466,
0.0208005421,
0.0040221848,
0.0153905554,
-0.0717099234,
-0.0078408327,
0.0267504361,
0.0330001377,
-0.0027912962,
0.0256822705,
-0.0204912722,
-0.0164156891,
0.0198836531,
-0.0098327929,
0.0221787002,
0.0065329983,
0.0658016577,
0.0330621302,
-0.0332870334,
-0.0519784316,
-0.0040624696,
0.0381890163,
-0.0229177251,
-0.0372213982,
0.0221848283,
-0.0289751869,
0.0273855105,
-0.0436321273,
0.0140439877,
0.0289124083,
-0.0282475334,
-0.012456825,
-0.019245211,
0.0160099566,
-0.0102031473,
0.0219422206,
0.0347107872,
0.0125144701,
-0.0160332788,
0.008990935,
-0.0298179388,
0.0384073928,
0.0234561265,
-0.0863279924,
-0.0015990511,
0.0133325923,
-0.0114598516,
-0.0231000688,
-0.043274276,
0.0010134856,
0.0394704714,
-0.033247456,
-0.0095759574,
0.031330552,
0.0038740097,
-0.0172166601,
-0.0293992609,
0.0172193274,
0.0109210564,
0.0124359885,
0.0046914015,
0.0531597994,
0.0131031619,
-0.0085559459,
-0.0406555124,
-0.0071253753,
0.0248877481,
0.0731807724,
-0.0413652994,
0.0147355823,
-0.0466057509,
0.0498210415,
-0.0040768161,
0.0327524915,
-0.0356378108,
0.0175476559,
0.028869357,
-0.0574955456,
-0.0553523488,
-0.0168413017,
-0.0383309722,
-0.0734947026,
0.0187370796,
-0.0094202105,
-0.0115842298,
-0.0124099115,
-0.0154950796,
0.0361786224,
0.0239649713,
0.0232025925,
-0.0342916958,
-0.0786785781,
0.009468778,
0.0023016832,
-0.014946647,
-0.0736775324,
-0.0325151794,
0.0332103558,
-0.0015519364,
-0.0617960356,
-0.0222369879,
0.0132999811,
-0.0163340122,
0.0183110274,
-0.0338246711,
0.0135213593,
0.0431613401,
0.0446360148,
-0.0286680218,
0.0398052931,
0.024335999,
-0.0018274244,
0.0322258733,
-0.0803851038,
0.049076993,
0.0263701454,
0.0013298023,
-0.0138339149,
0.0167330243,
0.0399747379,
0.0278282706,
-0.033908952,
0.0511445031,
0.0042197141,
-0.01045187,
-0.0093656713,
0.0104199667,
0.0129749468,
-0.0130075188,
0.0474566557,
0.0436192416,
0.0131175788,
-0.0272497535,
-0.0009575087,
-0.065259248,
0.0468909666,
-0.0290899277,
-0.0350162387,
-0.030291656,
0.0724085793,
0.0015590149,
-0.0440624133,
0.01107099,
0.010659378,
0.0214416757,
0.0014729132,
-0.0195294246,
0.0102631636,
-0.0204953812,
-0.0050683231,
0.0067600748,
-0.094501555,
-0.0247100666,
-0.0299807601,
0.0337060913,
0.0608176887,
0.0319906659,
-0.0277109705,
0.0353802629,
-0.017495675,
-0.0246032234,
-0.0292599741,
0.0889278427,
-0.0208841451,
-0.0153323002,
-0.0587068163,
-0.028176995,
0.0060207988,
-0.0103961341,
0.0400971361,
0.0778215528,
0.0073585836,
0.0353440866,
0.0223461371,
-0.0703083128,
0.0357316583,
0.0126831355,
-0.0226770584,
0.0000627041,
0.0121986885,
0.0033749971,
-0.0023492654,
-0.0498233587,
0.0257501137,
-0.0356633328,
0.0190107357,
-0.0050245416,
0.002953162,
-0.0669245943,
-0.0008385083,
-0.0097124828,
-0.0615036115,
-0.0820395574,
0.0022731998,
-0.0030359835,
0.0499710441,
0.0687003806,
0.0085371006,
0.0183553789,
0.0246955771,
-0.0039472044,
-0.0316334516,
-0.0196564645,
-0.024839431,
0.0191643052,
0.014553831,
-0.0153373703,
0.0315702483,
0.0330187753,
0.0374293886,
-0.0197709389,
-0.0257309731,
0.0019309041,
-0.0602461584,
0.0124798659,
0.0218611807,
0.0434974767,
-0.0083187185,
-0.0106328288,
-0.0875290856,
-0.0361196548,
-0.0024601382,
-0.017202951,
0.0093974005,
0.0121314591,
-0.0286874678,
-0.0258094445,
-0.0380037427,
-0.018433651,
-0.0217911936,
0.0300844721,
0.0161963925,
-0.0386688784,
-0.0268310886,
-0.0310383663,
-0.030737089,
-0.0524939559,
0.0489415042,
0.0642430112,
0.0134117566,
-0.0584466904,
0.0651533753,
-0.022715129,
-0.0206038747,
0.0154404026,
-0.0389695019,
0.0205451176,
0.0158354621,
0.0444379672,
0.0801015347,
0.0264117457,
0.0252632238,
0.0426698066,
0.0158768483,
-0.0371516943,
-0.0102234492,
0.0271168146,
-0.0019250911,
0.0704593286,
-0.1110451147,
0.0405493379,
0.0631761551,
0.0461444966,
-0.0200685412,
-0.0792013109,
0.0704633147,
-0.0330964588,
-0.0214087926,
0.0255039185,
-0.0773128793,
0.008819771,
0.041190505,
-0.0444477312,
-0.0916114673,
0.0355827734,
-0.0145652322,
0.0032406023,
0.010944197,
-0.0073369648,
-0.0266105551,
0.0408546925,
-0.0152953006,
0.0379784629,
0.0461961441,
-0.0126414085,
-0.0582677349,
-0.0017840354,
0.0305386893,
-0.0300722811,
-0.0086546391,
-0.0199270044,
-0.0060179094,
-0.0165119022,
-0.0320789702,
-0.0219163708,
-0.040755447,
-0.030562913,
-0.0376584381,
0.043314632,
-0.0056275595,
0.1016776785,
-0.0167144444,
-0.0130083393,
0.0218319744,
0.0164088756,
-0.0312412772,
0.0157983657,
-0.0429932736,
-0.0294704083,
-0.0543207116,
0.0183533449,
-0.0162829626,
-0.0438247211,
0.0107958643,
0.0204016101,
0.0267972555,
-0.0510730222,
0.0210903268,
0.0317845978,
0.0130878873,
-0.0091141034,
0.0365105793,
0.0784083456,
-0.0019857597,
0.0297298003,
0.0516870655,
-0.0056718346,
-0.0405946523,
0.0389541425,
0.0206541177,
0.0522656888,
0.0418578237,
0.0263018701,
-0.0905598998,
-0.0011838265,
-0.0030168416,
0.0538159572,
-0.0749958009,
-0.0519983433,
-0.019194616,
-0.098430723,
0.0213404372,
0.0163736083,
-0.0234911498,
-0.0257346313,
-0.016750982,
-0.0150466617,
-0.011878496,
-0.0461074635,
0.0045991954,
0.0120924832,
0.052524142,
0.028529441,
-0.088288717,
0.0203147009,
0.0348672085,
-0.0276205894,
0.0435106158,
0.0930267349,
-0.0003953415,
0.0069032982,
0.010874467,
0.0289744027,
0.0015423322,
0.0257709417,
-0.0322918594,
0.0422523059,
-0.0466745161,
-0.0181949493,
-0.0073846122,
0.022268299,
-0.0353873037,
-0.0084669078,
0.0234397668,
-0.0011423023,
0.0237054974,
-0.0840644538,
-0.041206114,
0.0110493721,
0.0018186172,
0.0449433848,
0.0383834019,
-0.0154237617,
0.0028241121,
-0.0810643882,
0.0426646918,
-0.0262494013,
-0.0268416423,
-0.0136850746,
-0.011033752,
-0.0561124496,
-0.0288800318,
-0.0430127308,
0.0117062824,
0.0066038687,
0.0255718641,
-0.1071840972,
0.0090274401,
0.0019156394,
-0.0560740419,
0.0252025705,
-0.0075607109,
0.0353994742,
0.0017332787,
-0.0249078032,
-0.0474888831,
-0.006760851,
-0.010765397,
0.0020521951,
-0.020224724,
-0.0430494696,
0.0196367428,
0.0680731237,
0.029980287,
-0.0058931573,
-0.0141421659,
-0.0363388918,
-0.0054147444,
0.0515038185,
-0.0136918165,
0.0482374802,
0.0162060428,
-0.0216163397,
0.0152345672,
-0.0163260363,
-0.0468156189,
0.0116564836,
0.0437257215,
-0.0229750164,
-0.0269470047,
0.004049513,
0.0117163016,
-0.0038451746,
0.0121625923,
-0.0259452555,
-0.0028533284,
-0.0184067003,
-0.0213886984,
0.006228603,
-0.0348248966,
-0.0217856877,
-0.0103633543,
-0.0047387104,
0.0130730262,
0.0019815497,
-0.0107680066,
-0.0445841774,
0.0558857247,
-0.00969755,
0.0746113956,
0.0039694165,
0.0826506764,
0.0761303902,
-0.0004792997,
-0.0405250192,
0.0375807695,
-0.0231931973,
0.0127515495,
0.0544988252,
0.0514459983,
0.0054465658,
0.0388102718,
0.0342652574,
0.0245970432,
-0.0260043629,
-0.0278104004,
-0.0137198931,
0.0067601306,
-0.0267435405,
0.0063249762,
0.0098277451,
0.0216072798,
0.0294655915,
-0.002727143,
0.0408884846,
0.0020621617,
-0.051892288,
-0.0166101176,
-0.0147466529,
-0.0168279503,
-0.055410549,
0.1002737284,
-0.0191885307,
0.0329983085,
-0.042773474,
-0.0413093269,
-0.0148285422,
0.0111196246,
0.0910368338,
-0.0346130878,
-0.0118240183,
-0.0305732936,
-0.0841401666,
-0.0609933808,
-0.0260842144,
0.0370754302,
0.0453577861,
0.0079412591,
0.0337373689,
0.0775375739,
-0.0537101701,
-0.0359279513,
0.0305830315,
0.0157522392,
-0.0509920195,
-0.0315149762,
-0.0361782461,
-5.843806698e-33,
-0.0334755182,
-0.0588058829,
-0.0283963904,
0.0229282156,
0.0244234055,
-0.0079919249,
-0.0417967513,
0.0300737824,
-0.0062952694,
-0.0321233384,
0.0159347598,
0.0118993949,
0.0028760957,
-0.0700491816,
0.070080556,
0.0068467963,
0.0645186678,
0.0055463887,
-0.0620486997,
0.0249770507,
-0.0725626349,
0.0123303058,
-0.016569281,
-0.0496865101,
0.0392234363,
-0.0269566476,
0.0253752749,
-0.0328232534,
0.0251816064,
-0.0139255384,
0.0178801063,
0.0038753017,
0.0162076559,
0.030460136,
-0.033334814,
0.0674283057,
0.0066696592,
-0.0459188409,
-0.0198350698,
0.0099155875,
0.0403873175,
-0.083398059,
0.0545873418,
0.003522255,
-0.0800630003,
-0.0178871583,
0.0505580269,
0.0390646793,
0.0475039035,
-0.0132705914,
-0.0519939698,
0.0257223397,
-0.0718779117,
0.0136834439,
-0.0637407899,
0.0253495071,
0.0108810905,
0.0056273839,
0.0348227024,
0.0263276063,
0.016883228,
0.0008111665,
0.039573878,
0.0033004011,
0.0206604153,
0.0204072464,
0.0544352159,
0.067753695,
-0.0469157249,
-0.0351296142,
0.028920861,
0.0007007378,
0.0295637697,
0.0606584996,
0.0200555939,
-0.0319311284,
0.0198932514,
0.0271912478,
0.0160517395,
-0.0248297323,
-0.0076513961,
-0.0173604675,
-0.0916315541,
-0.0440533906,
-0.0010328174,
-0.0831680447,
0.0100270323,
-0.0396493822,
0.0248337388,
-0.0119176172,
-0.0362979025,
0.0129113784,
0.0000101112,
-0.0255062524,
0.0057734135,
-0.0121791419,
-0.0211542118,
-0.0314224474,
-0.0207204223,
-0.0118435239,
-0.0307433289,
0.013969874,
0.0168013107,
0.0102736037,
0.0892781839,
0.0355834514,
0.0042268368,
-0.0069135558,
-0.0631103143,
0.0009039739,
-0.0086375158,
0.0030257995,
0.0111064054,
-0.0089433808,
0.0045127305,
0.0166972373,
0.0239383914,
-0.0395054519,
0.0091959778,
0.0063635958,
-0.0693152174,
-0.006213672,
-0.0057303216,
0.0340349749,
-0.0255986322,
-0.0430054665,
-0.0199265182,
0.0276717693,
0.067069605,
-0.0211981516,
-0.0598904565,
-0.0635454878,
2.744e-7,
-0.031094823,
0.022266943,
0.0137112876,
0.0097157815,
0.0042826035,
0.0568864383,
0.0328905731,
0.0713540241,
0.0345368162,
0.0126551352,
-0.0116965007,
0.0156868212,
-0.000931259,
0.0361710899,
-0.014526153,
-0.0082984939,
-0.0536865182,
0.0184936095,
-0.0410070419,
0.0131333312,
0.0288161561,
-0.023640031,
-0.0012903218,
0.0150628323,
0.0061383774,
-0.0141649768,
-0.0056880889,
-0.0238648485,
0.0623024665,
0.0225825459,
-0.0396166891,
-0.0059535918,
0.0205861628,
0.0215503667,
0.0008928366,
-0.0467644781,
0.0236384533,
0.0102261174,
0.0003088721,
0.0903649628,
0.0410027541,
-0.0040092776,
-0.0085517215,
-0.0826929584,
0.0217152182,
0.0042546112,
0.0086166486,
-0.0239080209,
-0.0310599618,
-0.0171613786,
0.0217155535,
0.0039979853,
0.0204045735,
-0.0210333429,
0.0193012878,
-0.0042330953,
-0.0079770554,
-0.0257869493,
-0.0455441773,
-0.0259107109,
0.001675149,
-0.0776975006,
-0.0005093786,
0.0606253333,
0.0161960628,
0.0338496268,
0.036851503,
2.320059654e-34,
0.0089600272,
-0.0116794137,
0.027363969,
-0.0672228709,
0.0624796599,
-0.0005255428,
-0.0193299837,
-0.014662087,
0.0364214592,
0.0329884663,
-0.0255519226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15374v1 | ASPER: Answer Set Programming Enhanced Neural Network Models for Joint Entity-Relation Extraction | 2023-05-24T17:32:58 | 2023-05-24T17:32:58 | Trung Hoang Le, Huiping Cao, Tran Cao Son | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A plethora of approaches have been proposed for joint entity-relation (ER)
extraction. Most of these methods largely depend on a large amount of manually
annotated training data. However, manual data annotation is time consuming,
labor intensive, and error prone. Human beings learn using both data (through
induction) and knowledge (through deduction). Answer Set Programming (ASP) has
been a widely utilized approach for knowledge representation and reasoning that
is elaboration tolerant and adept at reasoning with incomplete information.
This paper proposes a new approach, ASP-enhanced Entity-Relation extraction
(ASPER), to jointly recognize entities and relations by learning from both data
and domain knowledge. In particular, ASPER takes advantage of the factual
knowledge (represented as facts in ASP) and derived knowledge (represented as
rules in ASP) in the learning process of neural network models. We have
conducted experiments on two real datasets and compare our method with three
baselines. The results show that our ASPER model consistently outperforms the
baselines. | [
0.0256861895,
0.0546895526,
-0.0021224746,
0.0562132709,
-0.0084313788,
0.0277303997,
-0.0250173677,
0.0017302753,
0.02156776,
-0.0469372123,
0.020888675,
0.019148834,
-0.0362461172,
-0.0164445881,
-0.0277958028,
0.0110351453,
0.0308369584,
0.0215870701,
0.0343741141,
0.0156323332,
0.0057281591,
0.0473061353,
-0.0296972841,
-0.0045840261,
-0.0471704714,
-0.0188865326,
0.0051653669,
-0.0253152456,
0.0180164129,
-0.0210589729,
0.0133389188,
0.0353476256,
0.0016907168,
-0.023196917,
0.0000020821,
-0.0495202355,
-0.0564312711,
0.0077714361,
-0.0715374351,
-0.0201148856,
-0.0505105145,
0.0263875946,
0.0398034453,
0.0077941874,
-0.0531103835,
-0.0554670468,
0.0364905261,
0.0777411312,
0.0707198083,
0.0371362492,
-0.0198091045,
-0.0462334417,
0.0203236975,
-0.0062437863,
-0.0058732824,
-0.0311606284,
0.0510650054,
0.0111606251,
0.0016089205,
-0.0106468881,
0.0397827215,
0.0029452548,
0.0416518934,
-0.0060267802,
-0.0086972145,
0.0287304055,
0.007539676,
0.0008287391,
-0.0126897618,
0.1031854302,
0.0224802196,
-0.0023192898,
0.0058116983,
-0.0147414003,
0.0287337303,
0.0472852774,
0.0213007908,
0.0006652407,
-0.0587035418,
0.009861026,
0.0120452447,
-0.0134145888,
0.0119872261,
-0.0078484816,
-0.0335587971,
0.0474623777,
-0.0186866652,
-0.0386040211,
0.015675908,
0.010706001,
-0.0074204844,
-0.0348554924,
0.0440155827,
0.0590539686,
0.0241253972,
0.0552499592,
-0.0193411913,
-0.0197262838,
0.0121108582,
-0.0660953894,
-0.0011897502,
0.0152763724,
-0.0024698635,
0.0757100061,
-0.0671586022,
0.0046195015,
0.0126395645,
-0.0188255813,
-0.0114927813,
-0.0033532935,
-0.0679871812,
-0.0192301106,
-0.0207075924,
0.1186974272,
-0.0528925508,
0.0067073316,
-0.02231667,
-0.0219648238,
-0.0211156663,
0.0530702509,
0.0131882923,
0.0107050026,
0.0410484485,
0.0061166482,
-0.0600960813,
0.0131730773,
-0.0787880048,
0.0228008162,
-0.0081886277,
-0.0287453942,
0.0008250555,
-0.0627483726,
0.0288221817,
-0.0311432015,
0.0092558023,
0.1103975847,
0.051006496,
-0.0097223688,
-0.0494279414,
-0.0663262457,
0.0529817715,
-0.0406910926,
0.0217062961,
-0.0305926632,
0.0820630714,
0.0452993698,
-0.0495259762,
-0.0579420924,
0.0554082729,
0.0402672924,
-0.0486868843,
0.0601710565,
-0.0397127531,
0.0111502474,
0.0136868944,
0.0150003685,
0.0454700552,
0.0541514419,
0.0347487964,
-0.026026668,
0.0384210758,
0.0164159983,
-0.012142634,
0.0086211255,
0.0495040715,
-0.0479487181,
0.0565402322,
0.0473932736,
0.0050622919,
-0.0058080098,
-0.0266782083,
0.0267516617,
-0.0354538709,
-0.0401726291,
-0.010154509,
-0.0117002791,
0.0321739614,
0.058971487,
0.0019787438,
-0.0132484036,
0.0514037274,
-0.0297372583,
-0.0479429066,
0.0195516404,
0.0028138724,
0.0123064453,
-0.0527586266,
0.030866906,
0.0030447571,
-0.0304391198,
-0.0062432266,
-0.0001938579,
-0.0013268358,
0.0358193032,
0.0538462289,
0.0204966944,
-0.0508768708,
0.0892540887,
0.0335141234,
-0.0288535859,
-0.0229783375,
-0.0107687423,
0.0295907427,
-0.0076593999,
0.0189976804,
-0.0664337724,
-0.0203509163,
-0.0188861042,
-0.0332842432,
0.0029484446,
0.0265817065,
-0.0240039006,
0.012718101,
-0.0304390304,
-0.0368601792,
0.0216839407,
0.0057326611,
0.0200812127,
0.051334206,
0.0039595733,
-0.0030493494,
0.0012857834,
0.0115087861,
0.0490085334,
-0.0023544389,
-0.0193224289,
0.0223668627,
0.0357984789,
0.0130679784,
0.0896338895,
0.0030397766,
0.0200759731,
0.0438564047,
-0.0085069649,
-0.0287272558,
-0.0206593275,
-0.038498953,
-0.0296136122,
0.0451824479,
0.0121491784,
-0.0299884491,
-0.0446195677,
-0.0131134568,
-0.0193521697,
-0.0412403941,
0.0113372151,
0.0343356617,
-0.0078408308,
-0.0218293797,
0.0649091229,
-0.0006866119,
-0.0425773263,
0.1027793139,
0.0007235331,
0.0119671365,
0.0124589633,
-0.0442663059,
0.0253072735,
-0.0102636293,
0.0129104452,
0.0001557979,
-0.0266483761,
-0.0355917886,
-0.0043526818,
0.0065019717,
-0.0479231402,
0.0201414302,
-0.0226021875,
-0.0078741563,
0.0362356044,
0.0409622043,
0.0006127457,
-0.0077736438,
-0.009333537,
-0.0191420913,
-0.0204717238,
-0.0022106173,
-0.0243866369,
-0.018412685,
0.0198248643,
0.0264369678,
-0.0176035948,
0.0024849118,
-0.0159333888,
-0.040781837,
0.0294470303,
0.0568864904,
-0.0085474364,
-0.0096858032,
0.0192312337,
-0.060074348,
0.0178900566,
0.0468439236,
-0.0121007115,
-0.0175424889,
-0.0004217549,
-0.0362867564,
0.0096543385,
-0.0239651129,
0.0354066342,
-0.0211061649,
-0.0245789886,
-0.042140834,
0.0305839665,
-0.0483717285,
0.0475293435,
0.0168256406,
-0.0094654486,
-0.0478395633,
0.0178412721,
0.0329135433,
0.0150818322,
-0.0184107386,
0.0523714274,
0.0349117629,
0.0108281486,
-0.0397540666,
0.0175595023,
0.0078506442,
0.0229826253,
-0.032753028,
0.0445453301,
0.0901291072,
0.0216300432,
0.007918708,
-0.0090339612,
0.0008747681,
-0.0322408229,
0.0287552122,
-0.0090689687,
0.0107097439,
0.0277024191,
-0.0216867849,
-0.0211298801,
0.0046432479,
0.0335769244,
-0.0472436398,
0.0298505183,
-0.0187295005,
0.0148984296,
-0.0093022864,
-0.0106301317,
-0.0562827513,
0.0061843419,
-0.0189208835,
0.0410934053,
-0.0317645408,
-0.002522764,
0.0448776037,
0.0083269551,
-0.0042494559,
-0.0086756712,
-0.0033413412,
0.0104200793,
-0.0066578449,
0.0427701361,
0.0359304622,
0.0501421504,
0.0395790599,
0.0315719545,
0.0375835933,
0.0386207439,
0.0162977036,
-0.0390940458,
0.0292965714,
0.0202824753,
-0.0049210335,
-0.0854027793,
0.0322501995,
-0.0006685307,
0.0076335035,
-0.0719411448,
0.0112758912,
0.0683134422,
0.0323740765,
0.0412012003,
0.0078546079,
0.0271616671,
-0.0207614936,
0.0232969169,
0.0503947251,
-0.107879512,
-0.0058284812,
-0.0277400222,
-0.0086169848,
0.0230047293,
-0.0894615427,
0.0189710502,
-0.1188640445,
-0.0171088651,
-0.0172869693,
-0.0678074881,
-0.0359947756,
-0.0551601835,
0.0019791711,
-0.0267439615,
-0.0540249757,
-0.0009783667,
-0.0284990333,
-0.0017935496,
-0.0106819607,
0.0243171155,
-0.010498086,
0.0293000247,
-0.0279420298,
0.0445865989,
0.0400317535,
0.0016735507,
-0.0190609004,
0.0285943169,
0.0001918753,
-0.0808727369,
-0.0280603655,
-0.0365678295,
0.0612739399,
-0.0421569422,
-0.0141409375,
-0.0164705459,
0.0104350355,
-0.0628013611,
0.0004552632,
0.0466612056,
0.0687157586,
0.0194017179,
0.0158457737,
-0.0113639189,
-0.0322839394,
0.0087988088,
0.0762688667,
0.0083248625,
0.0170372464,
-0.0340628698,
-0.0438872017,
0.0049333437,
-0.0418785177,
0.0124262581,
0.0030069172,
-0.0665923432,
0.0241569132,
-0.0513982475,
-0.0654260665,
0.0455028675,
0.0059951213,
0.0258286074,
-0.0064727236,
0.0466188081,
0.0242400765,
-0.0636573359,
-0.0340521261,
0.0150151961,
0.0001207252,
0.0137114767,
-0.0180927999,
-0.0156289563,
-0.0442505181,
-0.0606360696,
-0.0496509075,
-0.0124574276,
-0.0356867127,
-0.0027665137,
0.02138534,
0.0155853275,
0.0242897645,
-0.0224185456,
-0.0036670871,
-0.0129731167,
0.0553103387,
-0.0948183984,
-0.0709596276,
-0.0013187048,
0.018233113,
-0.0037982382,
0.0169377904,
-0.0356981903,
0.0215041805,
0.0177585687,
0.0536939278,
-0.051312875,
-0.0378468856,
0.0379301272,
0.0170506556,
-0.0010983961,
0.0481848978,
-0.0282257926,
-0.0605074614,
0.0150306942,
-0.0545084849,
-0.0053870007,
-0.0449965633,
0.0205471814,
-0.0424440876,
0.0014459328,
0.0049242214,
-0.0298222862,
0.0241531674,
0.0059088301,
0.001174073,
0.0001409111,
0.0525018983,
0.0218220782,
-0.0269471891,
-0.0326473378,
-0.0080433302,
0.0134921353,
0.0284061171,
0.0029110278,
-0.0117168725,
0.0523651354,
0.0181192942,
-0.0302337036,
-0.0066720173,
-0.0307103023,
0.0001036599,
0.0125799887,
-0.0383169167,
0.0753592923,
0.0408151112,
-0.0114970729,
-0.0015241371,
-0.0314899869,
-0.0188788641,
0.0308628287,
0.0307194032,
0.0088010868,
0.0279088989,
0.0632062256,
0.0226374753,
-0.0123962704,
-0.0225497782,
0.0430455543,
-0.0042103562,
0.0525281765,
-0.0158365667,
-0.0353765525,
-0.0697616339,
-0.0287496578,
-0.0150885265,
-0.0054962151,
-0.0209543183,
0.0187521689,
-0.0402249619,
-0.0739649087,
-0.0446411483,
0.0147963632,
-0.0089059314,
0.0378385186,
0.0238549635,
0.0030644455,
0.0333944559,
-0.0892314836,
-0.040705286,
0.0274543054,
-0.0830658302,
-0.0034856936,
0.0003652607,
-5.925488127e-33,
-0.0504339933,
-0.0298530385,
0.0441164747,
0.0013061888,
-0.0028493451,
0.0159733631,
-0.0048107868,
-0.0248987544,
-0.081968762,
0.0210597087,
0.0121071292,
0.0054794229,
0.0080916313,
-0.0167284049,
-0.0130221881,
-0.0657290518,
0.0060678525,
-0.0173935108,
0.0234445091,
-0.0228330642,
0.006402859,
0.0413121954,
0.0694458336,
-0.1286931038,
0.002242727,
-0.0039642062,
-0.0079477364,
0.0403855033,
-0.0159648228,
0.0618109293,
0.000828371,
0.0233702231,
0.0138155222,
-0.0237628296,
0.0363063738,
-0.0022697398,
-0.1789262891,
-0.0522746556,
0.010366519,
-0.017924631,
-0.0366557278,
-0.0085642887,
0.0524949245,
0.0085301837,
0.0400214195,
-0.0122468174,
0.0524487905,
-0.0296625011,
0.029726252,
-0.0014285892,
-0.0189451911,
0.0224878434,
0.0360241458,
0.016355468,
0.0251552593,
0.0105766831,
0.0189106334,
-0.0518006086,
-0.0576410443,
-0.0144045446,
0.0284009837,
-0.0261723027,
0.0126941735,
0.0166371353,
0.0075918096,
0.0169811957,
0.0222778525,
-0.0484287515,
-0.0287297536,
0.01301328,
-0.0364096351,
0.0785066038,
-0.0169871319,
0.0205394328,
0.0080301724,
0.0187773891,
-0.0856361836,
-0.0066110548,
0.0180087574,
0.0570556149,
-0.0161655303,
-0.0433736518,
-0.0536746904,
0.0033772325,
0.0103261694,
0.006080505,
-0.045164369,
-0.0497146808,
0.0114682131,
-0.0024224287,
-0.0472451709,
0.0461399667,
-0.0216438137,
-0.0382825136,
-0.0469264723,
0.0425010547,
0.0373865776,
-0.0267536659,
0.0073491279,
-0.0134333214,
-0.0766639635,
0.0047892877,
-0.0112362243,
-0.0180335566,
0.011731158,
0.0226572864,
0.0121170366,
-0.0397702493,
-0.0284314547,
-0.009437358,
-0.0206874181,
0.002289399,
-0.0179277193,
-0.0274693947,
0.0077803102,
0.037336871,
0.0025023371,
0.0059726518,
0.0342544578,
0.0285962913,
-0.0194677021,
0.0024466892,
0.0496964976,
0.0384047478,
0.0229508225,
-0.0056301919,
-0.0016749657,
-0.0080923075,
-0.0238173194,
-0.0448666252,
-0.0056992499,
0.0225770753,
2.597e-7,
0.0442731678,
0.0030886699,
0.0577932298,
0.0656199157,
0.0008010541,
0.014360344,
0.0542175025,
0.0079949582,
0.023533769,
-0.0053229621,
0.0139788371,
0.0090324953,
-0.0179527961,
0.0380910411,
-0.0481286421,
-0.0751398951,
0.0012304886,
-0.038898237,
-0.06253694,
0.0260449387,
0.1203261837,
0.028707074,
0.0540369228,
0.0324193723,
-0.0545367636,
0.0067553013,
0.0162598677,
-0.0154098906,
0.022583684,
0.001983962,
0.0029428452,
0.0132928984,
-0.0019135172,
0.0820063278,
-0.019842336,
0.0494984984,
0.0473345779,
0.0554487072,
0.0171008371,
-0.0258504599,
0.0019860258,
-0.0251079109,
0.0290753394,
-0.0332842134,
0.0749272406,
-0.0568533652,
-0.0124992011,
0.0172608141,
-0.0615317412,
-0.049195338,
-0.0255693216,
0.0215747226,
0.0006155354,
-0.0182162672,
0.0162751824,
-0.0113546271,
-0.0151526537,
-0.0439808257,
-0.0000054638,
0.0526931062,
-0.0003074599,
-0.0026157212,
0.001643697,
-0.0485987552,
-0.005159582,
-0.0465546139,
-0.0184677355,
2.241072403e-34,
-0.0176674742,
-0.0238218922,
-0.016253192,
0.0758983642,
0.0543710515,
-0.0266803466,
-0.0438882187,
0.0142897088,
-0.0005191027,
-0.0449049585,
-0.0058109718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15358v1 | Context-Aware Transformer Pre-Training for Answer Sentence Selection | 2023-05-24T17:10:45 | 2023-05-24T17:10:45 | Luca Di Liello, Siddhant Garg, Alessandro Moschitti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Answer Sentence Selection (AS2) is a core component for building an accurate
Question Answering pipeline. AS2 models rank a set of candidate sentences based
on how likely they answer a given question. The state of the art in AS2
exploits pre-trained transformers by transferring them on large annotated
datasets, while using local contextual information around the candidate
sentence. In this paper, we propose three pre-training objectives designed to
mimic the downstream fine-tuning task of contextual AS2. This allows for
specializing LMs when fine-tuning for contextual AS2. Our experiments on three
public and two large-scale industrial datasets show that our pre-training
approaches (applied to RoBERTa and ELECTRA) can improve baseline contextual AS2
accuracy by up to 8% on some datasets. | [
0.0359245986,
0.0644394979,
-0.0067437715,
0.0371716991,
0.0035810089,
0.0204071179,
0.0178357661,
-0.0207802933,
-0.0187872853,
-0.0494014733,
-0.0376850441,
0.0121518048,
-0.0570866056,
-0.0262568332,
0.0019790945,
0.0071187811,
0.0251473393,
0.0080978181,
-0.0234768614,
0.0125701595,
0.0009126102,
0.0380295739,
0.0044877115,
0.0163162444,
0.0223588273,
-0.0125260204,
0.0268571991,
-0.0073381918,
0.0484305657,
-0.025953209,
0.0826164111,
0.0596456975,
0.0131971203,
-0.0099684857,
0.0000017294,
-0.0653257072,
-0.0308012217,
-0.0250729527,
-0.0503639504,
-0.0340926647,
-0.0318842828,
0.0281129405,
0.0175896175,
0.0263083447,
-0.0799553841,
0.0189978555,
0.0409320705,
0.0674542412,
0.0723601133,
0.0220474694,
-0.0089191701,
-0.0288950484,
-0.0126929302,
-0.0279379282,
0.0262248646,
-0.0510729775,
0.0359583944,
-0.0163593534,
-0.0285796802,
0.0382690765,
0.000215038,
0.0280449893,
0.0108427508,
-0.0112321805,
0.0153047843,
0.0114358924,
-0.0359246098,
-0.0143839177,
-0.0015577823,
0.1230169386,
0.0006764825,
-0.0183176659,
-0.0280682612,
-0.0271487013,
0.0000860373,
-0.0247292891,
-0.0339394324,
-0.0008527628,
0.0002557791,
0.0227824487,
-0.0046202587,
0.0290753637,
-0.021177372,
0.0062206793,
-0.0325566791,
0.0759658366,
0.0023226195,
-0.0448965244,
0.0279549137,
0.0465059727,
-0.0387956537,
-0.0520507582,
0.0240249019,
0.0270809699,
-0.0409053452,
0.012506675,
-0.0238569453,
0.0030761843,
0.0319222398,
-0.0178385284,
0.0100853583,
0.0000406716,
-0.0057958285,
0.0473497733,
-0.00471419,
0.0454087295,
-0.0147723053,
0.0271630771,
-0.072717309,
-0.032544449,
-0.0241476223,
-0.0161436088,
-0.0439559892,
0.0347819477,
-0.050843481,
-0.017237341,
-0.0484404452,
0.0127069373,
0.0039395471,
-0.0307999495,
0.0260580964,
0.0421173275,
-0.0206025541,
0.0291973371,
-0.0492083393,
0.056527447,
-0.0128047345,
0.0436951369,
-0.0103249094,
-0.0660876483,
-0.0099989148,
0.0108919712,
0.0291944202,
-0.0584437847,
0.0332793146,
0.0210355036,
-0.0165874157,
-0.0385874249,
0.0185549017,
0.0153754484,
-0.0081628598,
-0.0370682441,
-0.0164205842,
-0.0194397308,
0.0179537535,
0.0352255441,
-0.0167293921,
0.0113132475,
0.0085383635,
0.052546531,
0.0187521242,
0.0470523164,
0.0363246314,
-0.0209429432,
0.0035641978,
-0.002526788,
0.0535601899,
0.0223918203,
0.0269356389,
0.0243281908,
0.0603466704,
-0.0157640334,
0.0389850289,
0.0229483414,
0.0111690452,
-0.0134514077,
0.0533902645,
0.0619743355,
-0.0096213389,
-0.0024889079,
0.0307666585,
0.0114884591,
0.007901499,
-0.0054305089,
0.0473909527,
0.0149428062,
0.0512033552,
0.0280142874,
0.0383458957,
0.0272966903,
-0.0156253166,
-0.0140308216,
-0.0370299593,
0.0459483489,
-0.0107484236,
0.0050741225,
-0.014405353,
0.0338918976,
-0.0292436276,
-0.0157623105,
0.0445722938,
0.0173035022,
-0.0208928958,
0.0618254505,
0.0025963332,
0.0283799917,
-0.0710753873,
0.1055713892,
-0.0052204193,
-0.0524023883,
-0.0126335695,
-0.0523209535,
0.0191668253,
0.0059076124,
0.0187981464,
-0.0457970761,
-0.0389625132,
-0.026301587,
0.0196637772,
0.0187323522,
0.0268245377,
-0.0216784459,
0.0392334014,
-0.0394240208,
-0.0393702425,
-0.0223720316,
-0.0280543193,
-0.0226230714,
0.0328887813,
0.0152529832,
0.0319220088,
-0.0314760096,
0.0153205991,
0.0340345018,
0.0052223294,
-0.0267421547,
0.0244939923,
0.0035928702,
0.027651703,
-0.0034438777,
-0.0028807612,
-0.0190413333,
0.0421709493,
-0.0109275384,
-0.0273053069,
0.0159355421,
-0.0807902664,
-0.0454178341,
0.0152883781,
-0.0299046058,
-0.0397706069,
0.0568845533,
-0.0776786059,
-0.0131546361,
-0.0465606377,
-0.0210226532,
0.0177938957,
-0.0557647236,
-0.0014241905,
0.0104488479,
0.0457236767,
-0.0807062984,
0.0450530238,
0.0148847578,
0.0249685142,
-0.0069113555,
-0.001353791,
0.0137501517,
-0.051237911,
-0.0125045646,
-0.0322264209,
-0.0093088001,
0.0057854336,
0.0429310277,
0.0266439933,
-0.0609427989,
-0.0217934996,
-0.0884834975,
0.0141279949,
-0.0299771205,
0.031573575,
0.0075113517,
0.0263063945,
-0.0158152673,
-0.0454042293,
-0.0474602766,
0.0016068658,
0.0155427279,
0.0016831295,
0.0572904237,
0.001219201,
0.0252842363,
-0.0245084297,
-0.0171115436,
0.0008569792,
0.04631868,
0.0306391306,
0.0413330384,
-0.03563907,
0.0251106843,
-0.0240516588,
0.0221821293,
0.0034884566,
-0.0272647087,
-0.0119562503,
-0.0145990113,
-0.0130602997,
0.0518410876,
0.0261975974,
-0.0015113063,
0.003031814,
0.0321832746,
-0.0183501169,
0.0383835956,
-0.0410782844,
-0.0284531936,
-0.0449976958,
0.0026736001,
0.0477856547,
0.0500546172,
0.0081665413,
-0.0197005346,
-0.0116497427,
-0.0005950402,
0.0388866961,
0.0133793112,
-0.0325713493,
0.0182329062,
-0.0178223811,
0.0520264395,
-0.006560219,
-0.0090176137,
0.0755365193,
-0.019073518,
-0.0306367315,
-0.0779285878,
-0.0016043842,
-0.077285856,
0.0177432336,
0.0108562168,
-0.0284461379,
-0.0155154439,
-0.0029110524,
-0.0503111444,
-0.0044175354,
-0.0020526317,
-0.0315226838,
0.0395672955,
0.0046291645,
0.0115550952,
-0.0296352301,
-0.0596543327,
-0.0670386702,
-0.0585269444,
-0.0527304038,
0.0204507262,
0.0139567461,
0.0055967341,
-0.0195165053,
-0.0278578438,
0.006379622,
0.0542529039,
-0.0084129767,
-0.0088957753,
-0.0319214351,
0.0757293478,
0.0956976414,
0.0795478299,
0.0377419479,
-0.0062787053,
0.0377310216,
0.0494416542,
0.0199797377,
-0.0094235791,
-0.0177347884,
0.0014671092,
0.043227531,
-0.0565652624,
0.0025308295,
0.0182613377,
0.0558522828,
0.0041081789,
-0.012547099,
0.1028217152,
0.0196893681,
-0.0336235873,
-0.0054282378,
0.021905398,
0.0022365132,
0.0519488752,
0.0518990718,
-0.1003137082,
-0.0608436167,
-0.0251634326,
-0.0014295439,
0.0037270407,
-0.0166574474,
-0.012309893,
-0.1129008457,
0.0216351934,
-0.057258632,
-0.0821736157,
-0.0125131169,
-0.0340078585,
0.036196541,
-0.0223764982,
0.0311716031,
0.000807332,
-0.047113739,
-0.0047200699,
0.0229202844,
-0.0162081774,
-0.0396803878,
0.0589774102,
0.0040044282,
0.0003515027,
0.0602425784,
0.0162250828,
-0.0025383299,
-0.0042283651,
0.0169163346,
-0.1061651856,
0.0310239941,
-0.0160160549,
0.0566461608,
-0.0170877203,
-0.0093346313,
-0.0328347199,
0.0323100537,
-0.0153550943,
-0.010608457,
0.0306352861,
0.046534691,
-0.0144058103,
-0.0138460789,
0.0115575045,
0.0446996577,
0.0352622829,
0.0693357214,
0.0197396632,
-0.0347108319,
-0.0532954857,
-0.0071062665,
0.0006972583,
-0.0570917986,
-0.0329259224,
-0.0002903327,
0.0176578164,
0.0230662394,
-0.0548086092,
-0.0255135726,
0.0470883921,
-0.0042057307,
-0.039389383,
-0.0023843725,
-0.0325221606,
0.0207106657,
-0.0492696054,
0.0273286048,
-0.02430344,
0.0302355364,
-0.0388121754,
0.0083382586,
0.0555323772,
-0.0511268899,
-0.0493199416,
-0.0121051045,
-0.1059862599,
-0.0284073446,
0.0073594321,
0.0601908825,
0.0163321625,
0.0203238092,
-0.0067559849,
-0.0501334146,
0.0811887681,
0.0434942767,
-0.0534095727,
0.0112239765,
0.0451794229,
0.0110152196,
-0.0259026643,
0.0276944675,
-0.0394472964,
0.050968118,
0.0562333018,
0.0347491652,
-0.04229315,
-0.0842123255,
0.0131265065,
0.0003097975,
0.0390363894,
0.008911917,
-0.0003708898,
-0.0348796658,
0.0692200065,
0.0202369187,
0.0031904203,
-0.0250793044,
-0.0209106803,
-0.0257751662,
-0.0344297662,
-0.0043374421,
0.0090541262,
-0.043667715,
0.023642825,
-0.0730415061,
0.0288097803,
0.0399557427,
-0.0086639449,
0.0277451612,
0.0163673013,
-0.030653134,
-0.0203173086,
0.0624954887,
0.0762752295,
0.0303208027,
0.0694226325,
0.0139770433,
-0.000853021,
-0.0318917632,
0.0343647711,
-0.0986993015,
0.0008620455,
-0.0456071123,
0.0259104092,
0.0261334088,
-0.0312148631,
0.0411921553,
0.0228858199,
-0.007530259,
-0.0194820035,
0.0218154751,
0.0000278478,
-0.0002204319,
0.052187819,
-0.0109975496,
-0.008884565,
0.0556564666,
0.0427793227,
-0.0374892168,
0.0206327308,
0.0068907156,
0.0125880875,
-0.0601390451,
-0.0112304119,
-0.0184239019,
-0.0101971598,
0.002418722,
0.0050780224,
-0.0035673564,
-0.0695001334,
0.0164121408,
-0.0273230206,
-0.0390982479,
-0.0336246975,
0.0365184024,
0.0408385508,
0.0264958367,
-0.0492500663,
-0.0348370001,
-0.0053171203,
-0.0269779786,
0.0015976962,
-0.0516564324,
-6.292630645e-33,
-0.0029267878,
-0.0157809518,
0.0125897042,
0.0364833921,
-0.0009749946,
0.0279867854,
-0.0221609175,
-0.0357801653,
-0.0530700348,
-0.0045105484,
-0.0378486849,
0.0081019914,
0.0197551064,
0.054731071,
-0.0329303555,
-0.0652728155,
0.0409707129,
0.0136216804,
-0.0188115854,
0.0288840737,
0.0026371654,
0.0343117155,
0.0556403175,
-0.0398205705,
-0.019975869,
-0.0056836023,
0.0009858637,
0.0429510213,
-0.032825049,
0.0744133145,
-0.0232687443,
0.0469102822,
0.0378296152,
-0.0677942857,
0.0049242089,
0.0487097763,
-0.0909960642,
-0.0541400462,
-0.0216187555,
0.0007285261,
-0.019097833,
-0.0167709291,
0.0088866372,
-0.0302173067,
0.011076224,
-0.0195339024,
0.0525464118,
-0.0142646572,
0.0083013503,
-0.049369432,
-0.0232719909,
-0.0151342154,
-0.0103352964,
-0.0079771364,
-0.0350974463,
0.068230167,
-0.0028088328,
0.0475405343,
-0.0301003717,
0.0092703374,
0.0294351242,
0.0201133303,
0.0256104339,
0.0044012344,
-0.0152476188,
0.0397957824,
0.0128347864,
-0.0252193362,
-0.0099005327,
-0.0119912932,
-0.025602391,
0.0419906937,
0.0382984765,
0.0468560159,
0.0214119647,
0.0332878307,
-0.0920173824,
0.038790077,
0.0081028221,
0.030745456,
0.0134524787,
-0.0144795347,
0.0108273672,
-0.0128424931,
-0.03933274,
0.0298766885,
-0.0420700088,
0.0097885616,
0.0290710349,
0.0162748285,
-0.043324478,
0.041897364,
0.0280280709,
-0.0479609184,
-0.0115471082,
0.0416370444,
-0.0299596842,
-0.0141931688,
0.0122233713,
0.0096162595,
-0.0437004566,
0.0211181063,
0.0559391156,
-0.0216999017,
0.0024650842,
0.0009660389,
0.0118210372,
0.0129836844,
-0.0552198589,
-0.016279012,
-0.0194971804,
0.0143160615,
-0.0343256108,
0.0127711343,
-0.0213240311,
0.0398033187,
-0.0277284235,
0.0466406234,
-0.0035559798,
0.0094341356,
-0.0236469172,
-0.0257975161,
0.0419742242,
0.0529494882,
-0.024002701,
0.0077596768,
-0.0146434139,
0.0205965079,
-0.0079687778,
-0.0677389577,
-0.0260331966,
0.0196411274,
2.39e-7,
0.0713890493,
0.0118289227,
0.0185190085,
0.0132593503,
0.0153623167,
0.0275256969,
0.039668493,
0.0402852632,
0.0760421455,
0.0350165367,
0.03221054,
0.0109311417,
0.0504691266,
0.0123671899,
-0.0699502155,
-0.0157832038,
-0.0514425039,
-0.0095476033,
-0.0306746904,
-0.0172650218,
0.0621687993,
0.0952305645,
-0.0064814356,
-0.041126065,
-0.028980501,
-0.0218239054,
0.0275575817,
-0.0429063141,
0.0361088067,
0.0301879551,
-0.0100233424,
0.0014054885,
-0.004393138,
0.0443102717,
-0.0234685671,
0.0068502463,
0.001189398,
0.0576930791,
0.0135489181,
-0.0802543908,
-0.0264146775,
0.026983019,
0.0181287695,
-0.0511180349,
0.1057182327,
-0.1023044512,
-0.0040800199,
-0.0234716665,
-0.049808111,
-0.0356990471,
-0.0023792973,
-0.0108612096,
-0.0192993451,
0.0045862547,
0.0341099799,
0.0159052443,
-0.0388837233,
-0.0825433657,
-0.0029586046,
0.0004762373,
-0.043996606,
-0.0452127494,
-0.0251881983,
-0.0489932075,
0.0094366828,
-0.0133767147,
0.0291531999,
1.974874131e-34,
0.0142043782,
0.0131745273,
0.0168422181,
0.0346259065,
0.0205388647,
-0.0039331112,
0.0172849391,
-0.0031623901,
0.0364199951,
-0.1112024486,
-0.0122095803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15344v1 | Learning Answer Generation using Supervision from Automatic Question Answering Evaluators | 2023-05-24T16:57:04 | 2023-05-24T16:57:04 | Matteo Gabburo, Siddhant Garg, Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Alessandro Moschitti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent studies show that sentence-level extractive QA, i.e., based on Answer
Sentence Selection (AS2), is outperformed by Generation-based QA (GenQA)
models, which generate answers using the top-k answer sentences ranked by AS2
models (a la retrieval-augmented generation style). In this paper, we propose a
novel training paradigm for GenQA using supervision from automatic QA
evaluation models (GAVA). Specifically, we propose three strategies to transfer
knowledge from these QA evaluation models to a GenQA model: (i) augmenting
training data with answers generated by the GenQA model and labelled by GAVA
(either statically, before training, or (ii) dynamically, at every training
epoch); and (iii) using the GAVA score for weighting the generator loss during
the learning of the GenQA model. We evaluate our proposed methods on two
academic and one industrial dataset, obtaining a significant improvement in
answering accuracy over the previous state of the art. | [
0.0761399493,
0.0472549498,
-0.0230893027,
-0.0052385447,
-0.0041078432,
0.0137191508,
-0.006762661,
-0.0021540858,
0.0091792755,
-0.0592449084,
0.0152510218,
-0.0310062729,
-0.0592426695,
0.035280358,
0.0383198299,
-0.0084789181,
0.032427378,
-0.0150997816,
0.0252013486,
-0.0002715013,
0.0053452021,
0.0011100069,
0.0108859809,
0.0021325853,
-0.0121970652,
-0.0133214947,
-0.0114079174,
-0.0437739156,
0.0379762501,
-0.0057368558,
0.0520657599,
0.0517931581,
-0.0035779383,
-0.0152270189,
0.000001822,
-0.0315379836,
-0.025084693,
-0.0138802566,
-0.034446273,
0.0057860613,
-0.0189114269,
0.0447546616,
0.0199003015,
0.0369016416,
-0.0604531877,
0.0010155281,
0.0240929741,
0.0497057363,
0.0873728618,
0.016918797,
0.0029711742,
-0.0464293286,
0.0234631896,
-0.0138317924,
0.0235898308,
-0.0542879216,
0.0232273173,
0.0543729961,
-0.0021492073,
0.0482940152,
0.003545711,
0.0328872241,
0.023972163,
-0.0489844419,
0.056296736,
0.0450997241,
-0.0147994785,
0.0116090244,
-0.0294234399,
0.1114983633,
0.0308015961,
-0.0052794064,
0.0122148497,
0.005148794,
0.0288453028,
0.0048969341,
-0.0397022739,
0.0148335397,
-0.0163169056,
0.0001379787,
-0.0014071867,
0.0229255203,
-0.0408475362,
-0.0296822377,
0.0052273776,
0.0487939306,
0.019748928,
-0.0476307645,
0.0057623084,
0.0296339542,
-0.053029608,
-0.0300321635,
-0.0060078567,
0.0467405394,
-0.0166339111,
0.0142812748,
-0.0077544381,
-0.0463060066,
0.0322773568,
0.0108514028,
0.0284505058,
0.0140527999,
0.0202362742,
0.002364014,
-0.0274107959,
0.0817372724,
0.0181024335,
0.0095992526,
-0.0832103044,
-0.0017539716,
-0.0699488968,
-0.0646172687,
-0.0064250957,
0.0857634768,
-0.0278330278,
-0.0023858934,
-0.0549484901,
-0.0083217844,
-0.0140677327,
-0.0248385686,
-0.0114951888,
0.069258526,
-0.046324417,
0.0473839492,
-0.0476879925,
0.0147428624,
-0.0422689207,
0.0493128784,
0.0237156507,
-0.0377744511,
-0.0182639621,
0.0165817123,
0.0410736725,
0.0148081556,
0.0085129859,
0.0608008243,
-0.0533357076,
0.0010965347,
0.0034179592,
-0.0285069067,
-0.0130550554,
-0.0339675136,
0.0062344787,
-0.0282127969,
0.0543985851,
-0.0075718672,
-0.0572888777,
0.0140538951,
0.0368476063,
0.0586285889,
0.0170851704,
-0.0109799188,
0.0132272169,
0.0137975449,
0.0529315509,
-0.0136946971,
0.0443704464,
0.0190723501,
0.0248419177,
0.0199725442,
0.0239223111,
0.0038272226,
0.0504208803,
-0.0079203593,
0.0456792153,
0.0114476867,
0.0099186283,
0.049290698,
0.0354287885,
0.0002163289,
0.0137100928,
0.0471436791,
-0.0189494248,
0.014356236,
0.0306918491,
0.0074009281,
0.0032113616,
0.0438061878,
0.0405530594,
0.0049577518,
0.0304011423,
0.0109122824,
0.011066244,
0.0493812263,
0.0000930386,
0.0011572256,
0.0022690608,
-0.0086801825,
-0.0275922809,
-0.0481720306,
0.0343270488,
0.0319691785,
-0.0387931168,
0.0172701869,
-0.0028614644,
0.041008424,
-0.0578646287,
0.0053706327,
-0.0048003467,
-0.0600343086,
0.0065250807,
-0.0613898635,
0.0686589852,
0.0034458083,
0.03320067,
-0.012876207,
-0.036880061,
-0.0109865014,
-0.0209178403,
0.0020771148,
0.012074193,
-0.053132616,
-0.0141883455,
-0.0391771793,
-0.0290166773,
-0.0527690426,
-0.0179098472,
0.00944285,
0.0040663225,
0.0243142899,
0.0531418435,
-0.0403741524,
-0.0692671537,
0.0502558015,
0.0116907153,
-0.0729531348,
0.0599115118,
-0.0216479376,
0.0105005912,
0.0138160829,
-0.0055993409,
0.0290493313,
0.027681116,
-0.0343527161,
-0.0547951236,
-0.0152390972,
-0.0402909294,
-0.0525443926,
0.0100868586,
-0.0219903123,
0.0256201141,
0.0203121956,
-0.0587738119,
-0.0448394828,
-0.0147135397,
-0.0529881045,
-0.0110295704,
-0.038495712,
-0.0420265608,
0.0145395603,
0.013559103,
-0.0650878847,
0.1037907824,
0.0167370066,
-0.0088107884,
0.0260521229,
-0.0010826163,
0.0140054561,
-0.0479755551,
0.0334598199,
-0.0311987195,
-0.0188970007,
0.0248858072,
0.0391792618,
0.0201815031,
-0.0643333718,
-0.0279111601,
-0.0805849209,
0.028942991,
-0.0169897117,
0.0516859107,
0.0233559646,
-0.0000325319,
-0.0043463474,
-0.0194490496,
-0.110111244,
-0.009626993,
0.0408853367,
-0.0170212165,
0.0468830727,
0.0327728353,
0.0422612913,
-0.0325733796,
-0.0090192845,
-0.0078298664,
0.033954639,
0.0391184241,
0.0383025482,
-0.0154012898,
0.006228595,
-0.054420013,
0.006810246,
0.0114332512,
-0.036627125,
-0.0148078706,
-0.0157001615,
0.0213852823,
0.0775697902,
0.0392494425,
0.001693546,
0.0050421259,
0.01036161,
-0.0287349671,
0.0502970666,
-0.0495993122,
-0.0427946337,
0.0403489098,
-0.0469184853,
0.0298596434,
0.0234321076,
0.0376737379,
-0.0114147086,
-0.0370069072,
0.051644627,
-0.0002980561,
-0.0198363215,
-0.0503745079,
0.0250951629,
0.0010164415,
0.0413869545,
0.0000045017,
-0.0268193502,
0.0623134077,
0.0168246496,
-0.0125689814,
-0.0689626485,
-0.0115226498,
-0.060602434,
0.0254961215,
-0.0095323222,
0.007277987,
0.0029739195,
0.0022353674,
-0.0657933876,
-0.0044743642,
0.000716014,
-0.0529583879,
-0.0270436648,
-0.0385376923,
0.0028946309,
-0.0044042482,
-0.034409564,
-0.0593734309,
-0.0109534124,
0.0207456127,
0.0355854519,
-0.0234659798,
0.0077478127,
-0.0022909092,
-0.009760337,
0.0242198035,
-0.0113725374,
-0.0695594773,
-0.0103420382,
-0.0222036988,
0.102225773,
0.1082247496,
0.0272845235,
0.0292874314,
-0.0407408997,
0.0408806093,
0.0593992025,
0.0249510892,
0.0326987877,
0.0347906947,
-0.0086406134,
0.0113677029,
-0.0215126816,
-0.0005475146,
0.0323250256,
0.0452765599,
-0.0343809649,
-0.0417143293,
0.059869647,
0.0423570126,
0.0323677137,
-0.0062405323,
0.0041890037,
0.0295778811,
0.0131551418,
0.0870586634,
-0.0627381429,
-0.0190367196,
-0.043339368,
0.0797518417,
-0.0360044129,
0.0034561071,
0.0120437127,
-0.1289299428,
0.0377245322,
-0.0299449358,
-0.0627844483,
-0.0122966375,
-0.0070751142,
0.0053272657,
-0.0092657963,
-0.0288933963,
0.0072261929,
-0.0277874004,
0.0397038162,
0.0635617152,
0.0034948098,
0.0069590509,
0.0208414569,
0.0061205109,
0.0172180738,
0.0753360465,
0.0305512659,
0.0010044329,
-0.0292769168,
-0.0228077341,
-0.1136242077,
-0.0010954078,
0.0249265134,
0.0478867516,
-0.0025095099,
-0.0028028747,
-0.0305315722,
0.059963908,
0.0036634719,
0.034083657,
0.0615026057,
0.0393139347,
0.0065819025,
-0.0280361157,
-0.038643904,
0.016044775,
0.0324366093,
0.0571659803,
0.0243021064,
-0.044106625,
-0.0742297918,
-0.0315338261,
0.0441388413,
-0.0870349109,
-0.0387094244,
0.0160688963,
0.0256996416,
0.0259726774,
-0.1021591797,
-0.0442716852,
0.0097086141,
0.0130723855,
-0.0014259247,
0.0022491361,
-0.0368493795,
-0.0030407603,
-0.0261577945,
-0.0331507958,
-0.0045076571,
-0.0234865919,
-0.0206356701,
-0.0158501174,
0.0297596268,
-0.0412162803,
-0.0500965044,
-0.0055023674,
-0.0435577072,
-0.0345132537,
-0.0304132551,
0.0862103477,
0.0036464066,
-0.0171174891,
0.0020568001,
-0.0084783854,
0.0822449848,
0.0344329327,
-0.0356228612,
0.0051413975,
0.0012886042,
-0.0109030446,
-0.0056739799,
0.016299421,
-0.0507261418,
0.0265792888,
-0.0043597808,
0.0603141859,
-0.0037437503,
-0.0245500039,
0.0394727439,
0.0094429022,
-0.044250302,
0.0213582497,
0.0009633457,
-0.0268858895,
0.0302849114,
-0.0194050483,
-0.0134675363,
-0.0529179573,
0.0332689621,
-0.0194804557,
-0.0155358128,
0.0208416879,
-0.0197218787,
-0.0416610129,
0.0528070889,
-0.044422552,
-0.0127031794,
0.0154506918,
0.0039486666,
-0.0120238159,
-0.0255691297,
-0.0283442941,
-0.0416777916,
0.0445968546,
0.0712698177,
0.0227112249,
0.0509292185,
0.0252034757,
-0.0128802331,
0.0083263358,
0.0098428586,
-0.0980481803,
-0.0417733304,
-0.0436911732,
0.0168878995,
0.0098764021,
0.008627722,
0.0086315488,
0.0004156438,
0.0042685871,
0.0003797082,
0.019419292,
0.0080341203,
-0.001753221,
0.044589933,
0.001584419,
-0.0089092702,
0.0011592314,
0.0535402559,
0.0197294932,
0.023996165,
-0.0479523912,
0.0072476226,
-0.043104738,
-0.0116003891,
0.0120040169,
-0.0174147822,
0.0342961513,
0.0213565491,
-0.0261115711,
-0.0422695056,
0.0103513822,
0.0067028468,
-0.0058878381,
-0.0287173465,
0.0568066277,
0.0432125777,
0.0071823597,
-0.0761820525,
-0.0906085968,
0.0207774378,
-0.056343466,
0.0030898126,
-0.0212832373,
-6.355748814e-33,
-0.0099564567,
-0.0442632958,
0.0282426868,
0.0115493899,
-0.0225880574,
0.0275005903,
-0.0278165322,
-0.0487596393,
-0.0151599804,
-0.0044077886,
-0.0067268643,
0.0086544603,
-0.0130422916,
0.0248391759,
0.0276335254,
-0.0261946823,
0.0161774047,
-0.0152290827,
-0.0345499031,
0.0719475597,
0.0326762162,
0.0187988915,
0.0145946061,
-0.014168513,
-0.0117199076,
-0.0349882953,
-0.000858227,
0.0249840692,
-0.0175963026,
0.0561260879,
-0.0209853053,
0.0156881623,
0.0218052231,
-0.049343612,
0.0465692729,
0.0578120723,
-0.0493003577,
-0.0638565868,
-0.0338834412,
-0.0593219995,
-0.0634448677,
-0.0374383479,
0.0094324797,
-0.0165068712,
0.0278806165,
-0.0143768955,
0.0451981165,
0.0135831693,
-0.0073772082,
-0.0684187934,
-0.0506088734,
-0.0114330715,
-0.0228718147,
-0.0042180913,
-0.0539949462,
0.0951069593,
-0.0009612815,
-0.0106344651,
0.0138374325,
0.0000728813,
0.0567011535,
0.0268291738,
0.0368675552,
0.0310068075,
-0.0204791799,
0.0275513958,
-0.0094871689,
-0.0289678592,
-0.0353187136,
-0.0249644369,
-0.0469851382,
0.0173933003,
0.038269043,
0.0066428566,
0.0011271455,
0.0186901186,
-0.0986409411,
0.0545161963,
-0.0004233955,
0.0632343665,
-0.0023031894,
-0.0529275537,
-0.0089660985,
-0.0069665266,
-0.0450597219,
0.0176403336,
-0.022686433,
-0.0228615627,
0.0694469884,
0.0071298173,
-0.0567815602,
-0.0306661613,
0.0064382562,
-0.016101487,
0.0080928272,
0.0124019571,
-0.0719013363,
0.0126670897,
-0.0066726366,
0.0038458493,
-0.0626628101,
-0.0072617652,
0.0334329605,
-0.0007011805,
0.0019895481,
0.0057756994,
0.0060213511,
0.0105736349,
-0.039842315,
0.0141105717,
-0.0297846757,
0.0460687615,
-0.0157650728,
-0.0193717927,
-0.0135979662,
0.0351557471,
-0.000999658,
0.0013311392,
0.0125978282,
0.0587525144,
-0.0280189533,
-0.0417765155,
0.0427101292,
0.0275085866,
-0.0398549438,
0.0231812857,
-0.0203561038,
0.0476815216,
-0.0601941235,
-0.0440314487,
-0.0254990812,
0.0355545841,
2.535e-7,
0.0408291519,
0.0124460552,
0.0088000093,
0.0133827301,
0.0061807781,
0.033986751,
0.0393277779,
0.037444815,
0.0478898659,
0.0224709213,
0.005425428,
0.0114082498,
0.0298082568,
0.0190493204,
-0.0824629068,
0.0250559915,
-0.0722971335,
-0.029126307,
-0.034088172,
-0.0228132494,
0.1100775227,
0.0478789993,
-0.0363301486,
-0.0223743878,
-0.037094377,
-0.0053374269,
0.0728407577,
0.0671630055,
-0.01577623,
0.0589725301,
0.0556332469,
0.0360158607,
0.0034507941,
0.0247762501,
-0.0335191451,
0.0234164558,
0.0215708148,
0.030308051,
-0.0002497085,
-0.045481693,
0.009562389,
0.0226099472,
0.0395063721,
-0.0567533821,
0.0746679604,
-0.03430181,
-0.0134231253,
-0.030689653,
-0.0453890525,
-0.0030504179,
0.0000879038,
-0.0375426337,
-0.0173390731,
0.02803519,
-0.0081405342,
0.0102223139,
-0.02940863,
-0.0144096874,
0.0141677018,
0.017701881,
0.0017004559,
-0.0272724293,
-0.0401103646,
0.0087015452,
-0.036330726,
-0.039179001,
0.0290642362,
2.034630341e-34,
0.0105175031,
-0.0302373618,
0.018315224,
0.0318153799,
0.0096492944,
-0.0139191709,
0.0002963734,
0.0151906004,
0.0106056826,
-0.0619282052,
-0.0207893308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15338v1 | Measuring and Mitigating Constraint Violations of In-Context Learning for Utterance-to-API Semantic Parsing | 2023-05-24T16:50:36 | 2023-05-24T16:50:36 | Shufan Wang, Sebastien Jean, Sailik Sengupta, James Gung, Nikolaos Pappas, Yi Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In executable task-oriented semantic parsing, the system aims to translate
users' utterances in natural language to machine-interpretable programs (API
calls) that can be executed according to pre-defined API specifications. With
the popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), in-context learning offers a
strong baseline for such scenarios, especially in data-limited regimes.
However, LLMs are known to hallucinate and therefore pose a formidable
challenge in constraining generated content. Thus, it remains uncertain if LLMs
can effectively perform task-oriented utterance-to-API generation where
respecting API's structural and task-specific constraints is crucial.
In this work, we seek to measure, analyze and mitigate such constraints
violations. First, we identify the categories of various constraints in
obtaining API-semantics from task-oriented utterances, and define fine-grained
metrics that complement traditional ones. Second, we leverage these metrics to
conduct a detailed error analysis of constraints violations seen in
state-of-the-art LLMs, which motivates us to investigate two mitigation
strategies: Semantic-Retrieval of Demonstrations (SRD) and API-aware
Constrained Decoding (API-CD). Our experiments show that these strategies are
effective at reducing constraints violations and improving the quality of the
generated API calls, but require careful consideration given their
implementation complexity and latency. | [
0.0142819406,
0.0874553546,
-0.009563297,
0.0504683331,
-0.0091394996,
-0.0234650858,
-0.0353102833,
-0.0310123973,
-0.0201396197,
-0.0575641654,
-0.0151337199,
0.0103809666,
0.0008493084,
0.0061683445,
-0.0000682143,
-0.0269938335,
0.0350669548,
-0.0448373444,
0.0034532589,
0.0267580748,
-0.0102674114,
0.0080411658,
0.000245366,
0.0794090852,
-0.0257293005,
-0.0275509413,
0.0186523739,
0.0248226728,
-0.0329117775,
-0.0157526527,
0.0091778999,
-0.0006208464,
0.0518778786,
0.011655909,
0.0000019001,
-0.0613056049,
-0.0182901565,
0.0232987627,
-0.0510031469,
-0.0061560497,
0.0497476757,
-0.0126805548,
-0.0031043575,
0.0149628483,
-0.0279780757,
-0.0500717573,
0.0265666824,
-0.0214472711,
0.09462405,
0.0869670957,
-0.000850253,
0.0020462298,
-0.0032317366,
-0.004989305,
-0.0317000523,
-0.0429111049,
-0.0074068131,
0.0015971747,
0.0155841112,
-0.0073184199,
-0.0250342116,
0.0335306078,
0.0177135095,
0.0323694609,
-0.0164057575,
0.0058016372,
-0.0601857118,
-0.0451495275,
-0.0415576734,
0.0626264364,
0.0217956118,
-0.0210268386,
0.0096248407,
0.0102655254,
-0.0012911611,
-0.0187930372,
-0.042591881,
0.0528216921,
0.0012757122,
0.0400414318,
0.0185106304,
0.054959204,
0.030002147,
0.0013246834,
-0.01844294,
0.0428655036,
-0.0170089584,
-0.0290955361,
-0.0133389914,
-0.0034877523,
-0.0329509228,
-0.0055544768,
0.0271624234,
0.0065413471,
-0.0856284574,
0.0155906538,
-0.0512739867,
-0.0591620468,
-0.0046815234,
0.0006910054,
0.030592259,
0.0601172149,
-0.0100276973,
0.0239699557,
0.0066498755,
0.0859710127,
0.0084665744,
0.0255794004,
-0.039653156,
0.0015569333,
-0.0541565344,
-0.0248375963,
-0.0517350994,
0.050427556,
-0.0740405694,
-0.0238631573,
-0.000576006,
0.0389477611,
-0.0377820544,
0.0429668352,
-0.0294602737,
-0.0016446166,
-0.0789816007,
-0.0013871217,
0.0068994681,
0.0204923879,
0.0228097644,
0.0167199522,
0.0241511874,
-0.0485910773,
-0.0258211177,
0.0081341341,
-0.0134539511,
-0.0126775801,
-0.0059284321,
0.0708545223,
-0.0051420452,
-0.020949902,
-0.0040794411,
-0.0621277168,
-0.0060877516,
-0.0309526753,
-0.0108556915,
-0.0671508461,
0.0292539652,
0.0068273186,
0.0199235883,
-0.0598935224,
0.0057863998,
0.015474,
-0.0093276994,
0.0565362684,
0.0250714887,
0.0538398251,
0.0116372425,
0.0330087245,
-0.04760281,
0.0938010365,
0.0343519822,
-0.0096038906,
0.0338643342,
0.0078205084,
-0.0136799375,
0.0530346744,
0.0199105442,
-0.0211249478,
-0.0140483519,
0.015794877,
0.0352808759,
0.0321434289,
0.049386099,
0.0617679767,
-0.034979403,
0.0119274938,
0.0455342382,
0.0556970835,
-0.037320815,
-0.0418737568,
0.0669188648,
0.0241036564,
-0.019243693,
-0.0245642979,
-0.0682457089,
-0.053427957,
0.0118060429,
0.0195168443,
0.0384727381,
0.0278241709,
-0.0233878773,
-0.0283213481,
0.0165616553,
-0.0297742523,
-0.0056196265,
0.0132508902,
0.0430516303,
0.032983724,
-0.0613210797,
0.0567994006,
-0.0083217965,
-0.0392373167,
0.0302324295,
-0.0634080172,
-0.0132085672,
0.0512084141,
0.0547327846,
-0.0356058851,
-0.0005527572,
-0.0071277926,
0.0272874571,
0.0453014746,
0.0032413846,
-0.0390053131,
0.0375781953,
-0.0166377071,
-0.0052227881,
-0.0101248557,
0.0305077117,
-0.0410207137,
0.0204878747,
-0.0076466398,
0.0303680245,
-0.0747216493,
-0.0329914689,
0.0260324422,
-0.0105093708,
-0.034492638,
0.0160920694,
0.0049675228,
0.0300140362,
0.0315298066,
-0.0088499468,
0.0175637174,
0.0235413909,
-0.0510189384,
0.0281673744,
0.0294663832,
-0.0796819329,
-0.0437159948,
0.0180769805,
-0.0228795856,
-0.0224917866,
0.0547887012,
-0.0326483771,
-0.0307370443,
0.0204673689,
-0.0353467539,
0.0805360302,
-0.0000516759,
0.0136525473,
0.0287587605,
-0.0297499038,
-0.02785445,
0.030274244,
-0.0105540613,
-0.0054811025,
0.0239140596,
0.0102204168,
-0.0158707947,
-0.029949367,
-0.0200399626,
0.0141253956,
-0.0321486779,
0.0291940533,
0.0052453857,
0.0112331025,
-0.0390361026,
-0.0127226934,
-0.0940559208,
0.0288086757,
-0.0398971327,
0.0326861516,
0.0047604907,
0.0309560373,
0.0026493703,
-0.0270723049,
0.0052952534,
-0.0434193462,
0.0094217677,
0.0268190559,
-0.0051407581,
0.0340566114,
-0.0517371781,
0.0073826886,
0.0179950912,
-0.0051366831,
0.0498694703,
-0.0344839469,
0.0075703561,
-0.0613306016,
0.0323335677,
0.0278110765,
0.0231829602,
-0.0053854915,
0.026576357,
0.0338423178,
-0.0001417757,
0.0248334687,
0.0468562618,
-0.0467137992,
0.0419139899,
-0.0017058784,
-0.0186722297,
-0.0912966654,
0.0195623972,
0.0011856912,
-0.0517378412,
-0.052713532,
-0.0205784161,
0.0377000459,
0.0574798584,
0.0154632293,
0.0345400497,
-0.0681336671,
0.0130083924,
-0.0372944623,
-0.0587298125,
-0.0015596264,
-0.0275776349,
-0.0428574085,
0.0048403433,
-0.0239325166,
-0.0550785884,
0.0516162962,
-0.0349252261,
-0.0207220148,
-0.0396935567,
-0.0035501949,
-0.0106109167,
0.0872360617,
-0.003782575,
0.0103489999,
-0.0006241146,
-0.0678429976,
-0.0142965894,
0.0420417301,
-0.0118131293,
-0.0574916191,
0.0812040865,
-0.0701246709,
0.0062704268,
-0.0096834097,
-0.0674315169,
-0.0380784906,
-0.0198239461,
-0.0293444265,
0.0190721881,
-0.0221709367,
0.0010546882,
0.0197237059,
-0.0220868755,
-0.0361267067,
0.0333990827,
0.0149062229,
-0.0287588779,
-0.0495632142,
-0.0357469954,
0.0376889296,
0.034304779,
-0.0394888781,
0.0016194833,
0.0207938869,
0.0209392309,
0.0821260661,
0.0061656353,
-0.0473604128,
0.0062784897,
0.0353679731,
0.0011048594,
-0.0117674433,
0.0748124644,
0.0832406133,
-0.060875833,
-0.0318606049,
0.0895705372,
0.0413727947,
-0.0359576941,
0.0338587351,
-0.0013440477,
0.0385992229,
0.0202505793,
0.0237056129,
-0.091081582,
-0.067310825,
0.0337413214,
0.0875097066,
-0.0020979226,
-0.0096331071,
-0.0232511796,
-0.1491695791,
0.035403017,
0.0318621695,
-0.0541652478,
-0.0391547233,
-0.0431603678,
-0.0110586146,
-0.0362702049,
0.0420575552,
0.0100797266,
-0.0066031348,
0.0205479283,
0.0197902285,
-0.0124960653,
-0.0672303438,
0.0207077768,
-0.021366816,
0.070508182,
0.0580076054,
-0.0119912457,
0.0148686776,
-0.01199352,
0.0352058783,
-0.0081924852,
-0.0114244232,
-0.021630194,
-0.0095902318,
-0.0107493959,
0.0002163348,
0.0140367365,
0.069433853,
-0.065136455,
-0.0412428714,
-0.0111446911,
0.1140435934,
-0.0269980393,
0.0499530993,
-0.0124203805,
-0.0217856243,
0.0687937215,
0.0935823768,
0.0205607284,
-0.0387624204,
-0.0418278985,
-0.0333355777,
0.0104327463,
-0.0614597946,
0.0172210764,
0.0201250017,
0.0082252854,
-0.0102993445,
-0.0486910529,
-0.0136317872,
0.0115446215,
0.0264568832,
-0.0051668235,
0.0123831825,
0.0358923785,
0.0105277086,
-0.0505627468,
0.0398392342,
-0.0231291149,
0.0306620058,
-0.0562042072,
-0.0351818688,
0.0336163305,
-0.0229470301,
-0.0070286803,
0.0581569858,
-0.0685008615,
-0.0596761256,
0.0048155561,
0.0604413114,
0.0253650025,
0.0723067969,
-0.0098811453,
-0.0026796695,
0.0085436329,
0.094050616,
-0.0582237802,
0.0376466475,
0.0428226776,
0.0327900611,
-0.0063564433,
0.0327262841,
-0.0739882439,
-0.0289723892,
-0.0128738536,
0.0708232448,
-0.0124789616,
-0.033027757,
0.0497412421,
0.0240237191,
0.0197356977,
-0.0203868244,
-0.029406311,
0.0088449735,
0.0008386184,
-0.0014877194,
-0.0078520114,
-0.0649046302,
-0.016021423,
0.0065760682,
-0.021283241,
0.0328747071,
0.0198995005,
0.0065744077,
0.0626945868,
-0.0197778549,
0.0190906301,
0.0104985172,
-0.0109760556,
0.0244470146,
0.0089720348,
-0.0379118696,
-0.0012807401,
-0.0212800801,
0.0382802971,
-0.0214914158,
0.0519808047,
0.0329680219,
0.0230218824,
-0.0097163562,
0.0219181366,
-0.0044384929,
-0.0329587385,
0.0048935674,
-0.0298888758,
0.0052784653,
-0.0128195081,
0.0586705171,
-0.0287985783,
0.0316765755,
-0.0272728298,
0.0389791057,
-0.0015839082,
-0.0410732217,
0.0330200531,
0.0101783155,
0.0055210995,
0.0020009638,
0.0875510499,
-0.0118559403,
0.0405526534,
-0.0063329707,
0.0039012993,
-0.0495240688,
-0.0773154721,
0.0383556224,
0.0019565867,
-0.0371945351,
-0.0297506806,
-0.0496935323,
-0.0575356595,
-0.0182003472,
0.0092676198,
-0.011257153,
-0.0218837876,
0.0198362507,
0.0613961816,
-0.011553295,
-0.0500789657,
-0.0278711915,
-0.0378608741,
-0.0228755921,
-0.0340592638,
-0.0270262472,
-5.887798105e-33,
-0.0449232459,
-0.0119874785,
0.0283233225,
0.0059067369,
-0.0357251056,
0.0095577892,
-0.0521822125,
-0.0113573698,
0.025423184,
-0.0379080437,
-0.0023204554,
-0.0281155501,
0.012523856,
0.0552438647,
0.0048360266,
-0.0201217737,
0.0377640985,
-0.0245539565,
-0.0390801206,
0.0201103315,
0.042506583,
0.0111204945,
-0.011716526,
-0.0793458074,
0.018625766,
0.0195943844,
-0.0139312539,
0.0359152965,
0.0144828595,
0.0459810756,
-0.0012937437,
0.0481399819,
0.0223511308,
-0.0515659414,
-0.046611689,
0.0400239527,
-0.0711648241,
-0.0000365333,
0.0401644483,
0.042090293,
-0.0202126335,
-0.0230732635,
0.0423680246,
0.0049511022,
-0.027871998,
0.0087986467,
-0.0047051865,
-0.0245454274,
0.0025022535,
-0.0201756861,
-0.0507845208,
-0.0010065146,
-0.01867803,
-0.0326314941,
0.0279417485,
0.0305998977,
-0.0034804549,
-0.0009592441,
-0.0313275456,
0.0168075487,
-0.0168901086,
0.0227200408,
0.0731584057,
0.0515298769,
0.0184365902,
0.0559042469,
-0.0268690139,
-0.02765196,
0.0050460598,
-0.0037143526,
0.0224226639,
0.0446938723,
-0.0371059328,
0.0065387823,
0.0152115664,
0.0102721602,
-0.0222486835,
-0.0094302706,
-0.0111162625,
0.0050349166,
0.0178992357,
0.0287194997,
-0.0543331355,
-0.0060489653,
-0.0322930329,
0.0273805186,
-0.0108438432,
0.0013422366,
0.0677497387,
0.0386538468,
-0.0132951634,
0.0093813585,
0.052630797,
-0.0539384335,
0.0179190654,
-0.0077425716,
-0.0172055326,
0.0209904388,
-0.0324448012,
-0.0042188829,
-0.0404592268,
-0.0395345949,
0.0304575115,
-0.001262716,
0.0715703294,
0.0089024156,
0.0042017177,
0.0489420556,
-0.0442960374,
0.0135322269,
-0.0402650721,
0.0434804782,
-0.0210916642,
0.0000011319,
0.0670281351,
-0.0037988634,
-0.0386450551,
0.044261869,
-0.0182879716,
-0.0008144344,
-0.0247312784,
0.0099309701,
0.0052741016,
-0.0155431004,
-0.0483671427,
-0.0089245774,
0.0034891381,
0.0068268273,
0.0012840526,
-0.0275115222,
-0.0192536656,
-0.0007065936,
2.737e-7,
0.0106339101,
0.0190137327,
0.0167420451,
0.0380783044,
0.0379601941,
0.0439090692,
-0.0091469083,
0.0369412899,
-0.0190965887,
-0.0419577248,
-0.0015297503,
0.0053775823,
0.0575437024,
0.0185947288,
-0.0868852288,
0.0066024712,
0.0017917287,
0.0283285081,
-0.0575172529,
0.0065787435,
0.082226418,
0.0605204888,
-0.0247252453,
-0.0004440623,
-0.0021200788,
-0.0755209029,
0.0297488999,
-0.0234929677,
0.002692953,
0.0321281925,
-0.0355875976,
0.0214639865,
0.0184918921,
0.024864817,
-0.0083782142,
0.0173330083,
0.0230223946,
0.0752166286,
0.0197187029,
-0.0328532681,
-0.0435513295,
-0.001226644,
-0.0164119452,
-0.0134567199,
0.0341428071,
-0.0673018098,
-0.0156685058,
0.0176354218,
-0.0174391028,
-0.0092622163,
-0.0728136897,
0.0065652085,
0.0249962509,
-0.0072635203,
0.023331942,
0.0115673319,
0.0021537822,
-0.0534682423,
-0.0212160759,
0.0023161408,
-0.0510686114,
-0.0419764593,
-0.0271646567,
0.0423933752,
-0.0089199152,
-0.0792645365,
-0.0037509617,
2.981025205e-34,
0.0132711567,
-0.0088125067,
0.0500697531,
0.0214077421,
0.0233191624,
-0.0004920913,
-0.007673047,
0.0380801521,
0.0177654047,
-0.0506247096,
-0.0156251267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15334v1 | Gorilla: Large Language Model Connected with Massive APIs | 2023-05-24T16:48:11 | 2023-05-24T16:48:11 | Shishir G. Patil, Tianjun Zhang, Xin Wang, Joseph E. Gonzalez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have seen an impressive wave of advances
recently, with models now excelling in a variety of tasks, such as mathematical
reasoning and program synthesis. However, their potential to effectively use
tools via API calls remains unfulfilled. This is a challenging task even for
today's state-of-the-art LLMs such as GPT-4, largely due to their inability to
generate accurate input arguments and their tendency to hallucinate the wrong
usage of an API call. We release Gorilla, a finetuned LLaMA-based model that
surpasses the performance of GPT-4 on writing API calls. When combined with a
document retriever, Gorilla demonstrates a strong capability to adapt to
test-time document changes, enabling flexible user updates or version changes.
It also substantially mitigates the issue of hallucination, commonly
encountered when prompting LLMs directly. To evaluate the model's ability, we
introduce APIBench, a comprehensive dataset consisting of HuggingFace,
TorchHub, and TensorHub APIs. The successful integration of the retrieval
system with Gorilla demonstrates the potential for LLMs to use tools more
accurately, keep up with frequently updated documentation, and consequently
increase the reliability and applicability of their outputs. Gorilla's code,
model, data, and demo are available at https://gorilla.cs.berkeley.edu | [
0.0124761825,
0.0887559056,
-0.0306607317,
0.0535242967,
-0.0274559818,
-0.0080000646,
-0.0220697615,
0.0009765764,
0.0486354455,
-0.0234862473,
-0.018495487,
-0.0097528426,
-0.0016703162,
0.0256308317,
0.0233972929,
-0.0515478551,
0.0314163789,
-0.059169732,
0.0011511947,
-0.0238833874,
-0.0038464272,
0.0237043221,
0.0208311416,
0.034089189,
0.0132046901,
-0.0532067902,
-0.0053071273,
-0.0086872047,
-0.0107053332,
0.0223643538,
0.012275151,
0.0212161597,
0.0159817077,
0.0903123394,
0.0000021733,
-0.0413433909,
-0.0034043929,
0.0321958363,
-0.0052911835,
0.0118510993,
0.0186461806,
-0.0245721973,
-0.0120982695,
0.0270152297,
-0.0443816073,
-0.0089815911,
0.0425229557,
-0.0442720763,
0.0842860043,
0.0754931197,
0.003044141,
-0.0077254097,
0.024824515,
0.0009906815,
-0.0026314205,
-0.0243401621,
-0.000693546,
-0.0065933582,
0.0391592532,
0.0057267072,
0.0130005376,
0.0295782946,
0.0445638932,
-0.0108446265,
-0.0319397561,
0.0302834474,
-0.0969988927,
-0.0268722642,
0.004154488,
0.0391240604,
-0.0204261951,
-0.0561861284,
0.0058930651,
0.0152194407,
-0.0331793763,
0.0005294158,
-0.0579040758,
0.0429237373,
-0.0000119077,
-0.0034021379,
0.0276165158,
-0.0330748372,
0.0323059484,
0.0183101688,
-0.031041678,
0.0611357465,
0.0460123718,
0.0107099675,
-0.0246307123,
-0.0100717871,
-0.0092191063,
-0.0519645028,
0.0306596588,
0.0473668464,
-0.0266906209,
0.0189515799,
-0.0404211506,
-0.0517607369,
0.040678788,
-0.044827275,
0.0351950824,
0.0575139336,
-0.0439506099,
0.0443149768,
-0.035704039,
0.0535853915,
-0.0269709621,
-0.0045938231,
-0.0038749874,
-0.0209176186,
-0.017665524,
-0.014223855,
-0.0440053381,
0.0454820469,
-0.0109481085,
-0.0060667833,
-0.0067102374,
0.0700648874,
-0.0136817088,
0.0332178026,
-0.0306530483,
-0.0271692146,
-0.0575096756,
-0.0344137065,
0.0022963141,
0.0193325281,
-0.000593938,
-0.0417397507,
0.0112515809,
-0.0665360168,
-0.0427304395,
-0.0019790477,
-0.026100019,
-0.031819202,
0.0271935984,
0.0796597525,
0.0091178147,
-0.0002962591,
-0.013660823,
-0.0391016006,
0.0364147201,
-0.0755540431,
0.0046744556,
-0.1095904112,
0.0293571055,
0.0341305882,
-0.017963117,
-0.0509721488,
0.0002798669,
0.0238258056,
0.0007195271,
0.0464972816,
-0.0097291442,
-0.009841471,
0.0444037132,
0.0189546905,
-0.041003909,
0.0584050603,
0.0196025353,
0.0376751907,
0.0381916426,
-0.0037000449,
0.0074690399,
0.0550658889,
-0.0056551327,
-0.0094591063,
-0.0267507564,
0.0352704823,
0.0491940565,
0.0273052957,
-0.0129939513,
0.0682562068,
-0.0181943085,
-0.0077012042,
0.030112844,
0.0357682928,
-0.004579776,
0.0054527102,
0.0443911292,
0.0038080683,
0.0231663063,
-0.0205577184,
-0.0601203218,
0.0413767546,
-0.0243615657,
0.0223794617,
0.0334744379,
0.0295389947,
-0.0038190898,
-0.0447502732,
-0.016416179,
-0.0058907378,
-0.068547383,
-0.0018176758,
0.0649816692,
-0.0074286172,
-0.027770156,
0.055303324,
0.0191656649,
-0.0491359644,
-0.0251199864,
-0.045039624,
0.0477890037,
0.0559824593,
0.0797942132,
-0.0700815171,
-0.0461493731,
0.0237731524,
0.0047727432,
0.0420676991,
0.05231319,
-0.0071296836,
0.0085046012,
-0.0446435027,
0.0307662804,
-0.0260621887,
0.0152915278,
0.0155384047,
0.0522823855,
0.0198309142,
0.0298173148,
-0.0480660871,
-0.0295203347,
0.0311305448,
-0.0542175062,
-0.0383281261,
0.0023335845,
-0.0204441641,
0.0216908436,
-0.0218223892,
-0.0201782435,
0.0243576411,
0.0492492616,
-0.0294504613,
0.0012754581,
-0.0231299475,
-0.0412996672,
0.0274589267,
0.0695824921,
0.0166733041,
-0.018311806,
0.0403825939,
-0.0578398965,
-0.0289576314,
0.0699185506,
-0.001006593,
0.0553912632,
-0.0189493112,
0.0139018493,
0.0025099912,
0.0003762092,
-0.0061116987,
0.0292540696,
0.0206063967,
0.0088140611,
0.0145993512,
0.0326710343,
0.0305655599,
0.0175984818,
-0.0516020134,
0.0482487455,
-0.0073014232,
0.0470469631,
0.0022289883,
0.0215240829,
-0.0074060042,
-0.0375418626,
-0.0876902193,
0.044921834,
-0.0299174469,
0.0258199759,
0.0250001494,
0.020778155,
-0.0121416505,
-0.007526645,
0.001920074,
-0.0114320563,
-0.014055443,
0.0326174572,
0.008947419,
0.0100239152,
-0.0403302759,
-0.0443892442,
-0.0264858902,
-0.0229488667,
0.0336016864,
-0.032342568,
-0.0215764362,
-0.0421235263,
-0.0000965401,
-0.0273477193,
0.0617761686,
-0.031493444,
0.0095718447,
0.0359845534,
-0.0587457307,
0.0550300665,
0.0636705682,
-0.0250633489,
0.0144641092,
0.0540607646,
-0.0054612122,
-0.0646941811,
0.0133896815,
0.0026845976,
-0.0578021519,
0.0129693877,
-0.0232544634,
-0.0105568217,
0.0301076882,
-0.0247552544,
-0.0309034586,
-0.0440140702,
0.0087154014,
0.0012702119,
0.0014713813,
0.0262429304,
-0.0115018422,
-0.0259488672,
0.0111300917,
-0.0015195685,
-0.0887231678,
0.06540896,
-0.063376449,
-0.0173419751,
-0.035046488,
-0.010336767,
-0.0383140929,
0.1206815913,
0.0104430905,
-0.0036065916,
-0.0337649062,
0.0003010601,
-0.0261219181,
0.0232401304,
0.0007611823,
-0.0385928415,
0.0631139874,
-0.0780169889,
0.0191563517,
-0.029536441,
-0.0419985726,
-0.0206888914,
0.0343399793,
-0.037389975,
0.0224529468,
-0.0464563668,
-0.048100289,
0.00571481,
-0.0186481811,
0.0156596471,
0.0802595913,
-0.0276214182,
-0.0167286098,
-0.0280314423,
-0.0602125823,
0.0255105086,
-0.0163890384,
-0.0030780677,
-0.0130374925,
0.0124624809,
0.0530097224,
0.0622207224,
-0.0148535147,
-0.0709534213,
-0.0436220318,
0.0328436941,
-0.0244279597,
-0.0408880711,
0.0267470088,
0.0186427739,
-0.091238834,
-0.0256543569,
0.0797587037,
0.02880756,
-0.052532658,
-0.0099925976,
-0.0460546948,
0.0576898754,
0.0285611562,
0.0657326728,
-0.0666211843,
-0.038427487,
0.0255836435,
0.0423518829,
0.0178625155,
-0.0103449291,
-0.0058755381,
-0.1092060059,
0.0558050722,
0.0166564547,
0.0000636368,
-0.0061809984,
-0.0414336883,
-0.0021157649,
0.0261915568,
-0.0072616371,
0.0339153893,
-0.0063480567,
0.0286734123,
-0.0009342445,
0.0116789816,
0.0059697269,
0.0235979855,
-0.0082341712,
0.0150405224,
0.0354989953,
0.0186331943,
-0.0012725301,
-0.0227770098,
0.0578421988,
0.0141127538,
-0.0232552718,
-0.0211175922,
-0.0140666226,
0.0197178442,
-0.0229074135,
0.0112256082,
0.0334914476,
-0.0435450263,
-0.0208868124,
0.003300725,
0.092736505,
-0.039798148,
-0.0127389692,
-0.0337286778,
-0.0191433951,
-0.0249238536,
0.0408687331,
0.0157795511,
-0.0059867147,
-0.0536910035,
-0.0467468128,
-0.0254987683,
-0.0165324509,
-0.0028806154,
-0.0261150282,
-0.0150286481,
-0.0073702438,
-0.0345807932,
0.0246540736,
0.0323500782,
0.0368074812,
0.0248101614,
0.0088686757,
0.0124201467,
-0.0249345023,
-0.0723241717,
0.0641247705,
-0.0372530445,
0.0322521254,
-0.0500234514,
-0.0216653999,
0.0281263366,
0.0047213254,
-0.0269567072,
0.0884931386,
-0.0500783212,
-0.0922506526,
-0.0060240664,
0.0775576383,
0.0329058319,
0.0246176627,
-0.017916603,
-0.0395502225,
0.0079101436,
0.080051221,
-0.0400834531,
0.0226052161,
0.0226126723,
-0.0241451915,
0.0062112208,
0.0366206653,
-0.0598922595,
-0.0428647958,
0.000454901,
0.0137082804,
0.0171169098,
-0.0076670763,
0.0062717777,
0.0439859517,
-0.0045972271,
0.0115901949,
0.015695475,
-0.0128428061,
0.0253969412,
-0.0009848339,
-0.0217562038,
-0.0519978628,
0.0164196491,
-0.011996937,
-0.0462216027,
-0.0041333782,
0.000757593,
0.018950386,
0.0642284527,
0.0066596321,
0.0002187407,
-0.0138112223,
0.0499870703,
0.0812953189,
-0.0311263725,
-0.0309578963,
0.0079988455,
-0.0351334363,
0.0676673874,
-0.0690903962,
0.0350702666,
0.0302391239,
0.0068963119,
-0.0127524221,
0.0300514027,
-0.0454122275,
-0.1378295571,
-0.0164736006,
-0.0018570683,
0.014431281,
0.0050762752,
0.0512777455,
-0.0578010231,
-0.0063439496,
-0.0378416628,
0.024711892,
0.0222737528,
-0.0234663952,
0.013152252,
0.0208241325,
0.0003336759,
-0.0042099054,
0.0696176291,
-0.0466063805,
0.0320359804,
0.028213514,
-0.0063619306,
-0.0294358339,
-0.0509893149,
0.0181498658,
0.0067014834,
-0.0120683275,
-0.0612245053,
-0.0480871499,
-0.0670189038,
0.005068942,
0.024906829,
-0.0412812494,
-0.0200079232,
0.0160335284,
0.1005550697,
0.0262833443,
-0.0096862055,
-0.015601988,
0.0503427945,
-0.0240746178,
-0.0399495587,
-0.0152747892,
-5.944354077e-33,
-0.0447104163,
0.0068697929,
0.0205705855,
0.0137146544,
-0.0066500367,
-0.008901896,
-0.0653306097,
-0.0059803771,
0.0064849895,
-0.0152110429,
-0.0167944618,
0.0118610635,
0.0106245121,
-0.0138357431,
0.0349830687,
0.0204409845,
-0.0036292309,
0.0142307654,
-0.0410436802,
0.0396260358,
0.0534095578,
0.0119055258,
0.0559758022,
-0.0652594417,
-0.0091881491,
-0.0103641767,
0.0319258757,
0.0172344595,
-0.0496562235,
0.0499329567,
-0.0170585066,
0.0437922664,
-0.008777488,
-0.0075075384,
-0.022748325,
-0.012250687,
-0.0290865786,
-0.0255371667,
0.0501629375,
0.0169281494,
-0.0154871959,
-0.0452292785,
0.0413054638,
0.0096235555,
0.0098852357,
-0.0132678105,
0.0095177423,
-0.0096582593,
-0.0253884345,
0.0211298224,
-0.0623187311,
0.0189758148,
0.0085827522,
-0.0000388459,
-0.0129765999,
-0.0134421447,
0.0106087457,
0.046828948,
-0.03855085,
-0.0225103572,
0.0016996027,
0.0585661344,
0.0713386089,
-0.0179924481,
0.0285801142,
0.0445588268,
0.0076258169,
0.0043933671,
-0.0066739121,
-0.0175680202,
0.0387765281,
0.0531284064,
0.0229537599,
-0.0050345645,
0.005945283,
-0.0009388442,
-0.0208343584,
-0.0076948805,
0.0320859551,
0.0263013262,
0.023168182,
0.0072227013,
-0.0117384838,
0.0016689,
-0.0394486114,
0.003217848,
-0.0463656224,
-0.0009330533,
0.0170383099,
0.0087668374,
-0.0153182512,
-0.0185133293,
0.0247441158,
-0.0389342606,
-0.0087138964,
0.0038202226,
-0.0647887811,
0.0163636655,
0.0127127999,
0.0505400933,
-0.0092490027,
-0.0395698026,
-0.0229652748,
-0.0306802001,
0.0457618982,
0.0161147024,
0.0086665656,
0.0503745638,
-0.0620137192,
0.0165445376,
-0.0902489573,
0.0233832896,
-0.0094636623,
0.0148494197,
0.0168193877,
0.0176108312,
0.0249677338,
0.0503910184,
0.0095170029,
0.0030144397,
-0.046525754,
0.0304734483,
0.0124596702,
-0.0005611404,
-0.0314490646,
-0.0040456923,
-0.0306857005,
0.0305328388,
0.0409286134,
-0.0487520657,
-0.0115075782,
0.0270890556,
2.895e-7,
0.0334633738,
0.0262277797,
0.0301109385,
0.0600180998,
0.0202351585,
0.0412771292,
-0.0302137267,
0.0114715211,
0.0317305475,
0.0111680869,
-0.0477333292,
0.0323892534,
0.0362098739,
0.0410011895,
-0.088968493,
0.0228551887,
-0.0201888867,
-0.0344009176,
-0.0988543183,
-0.050975021,
0.0033157207,
0.0826088414,
0.0394702926,
-0.0239596721,
0.0015937774,
-0.0592165887,
0.0290985536,
-0.0071315295,
0.0075326087,
0.0328066051,
0.0017212671,
0.0386264138,
0.0022230868,
-0.0266326871,
-0.0260683037,
0.000844678,
-0.0210354999,
0.0814451575,
-0.0044774814,
0.0037211285,
0.0258254204,
-0.0538757145,
-0.0026590766,
-0.0785367489,
0.0520246774,
0.0175422933,
-0.0035549966,
-0.0337558463,
-0.0279712621,
-0.028743444,
-0.0183680877,
-0.0285978261,
0.0268855244,
0.0527391993,
0.0033006701,
-0.0187236462,
-0.0016648456,
-0.0719989762,
-0.0556541048,
-0.0091237212,
-0.0398185402,
-0.0401478596,
-0.0694970042,
0.0042634523,
-0.0060218726,
-0.0502802543,
0.0189994238,
3.183307579e-34,
0.0422128886,
-0.0056767799,
0.0298645981,
0.0479059778,
0.0425289199,
-0.0123804938,
0.0119124744,
0.0419683531,
-0.0240419153,
-0.060039442,
-0.0461458415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15328v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15328v2 | Visual Programming for Text-to-Image Generation and Evaluation | 2023-05-24T16:42:17 | 2023-10-27T01:44:27 | Jaemin Cho, Abhay Zala, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | As large language models have demonstrated impressive performance in many
domains, recent works have adopted language models (LMs) as controllers of
visual modules for vision-and-language tasks. While existing work focuses on
equipping LMs with visual understanding, we propose two novel
interpretable/explainable visual programming frameworks for text-to-image (T2I)
generation and evaluation. First, we introduce VPGen, an interpretable
step-by-step T2I generation framework that decomposes T2I generation into three
steps: object/count generation, layout generation, and image generation. We
employ an LM to handle the first two steps (object/count generation and layout
generation), by finetuning it on text-layout pairs. Our step-by-step T2I
generation framework provides stronger spatial control than end-to-end models,
the dominant approach for this task. Furthermore, we leverage the world
knowledge of pretrained LMs, overcoming the limitation of previous
layout-guided T2I works that can only handle predefined object classes. We
demonstrate that our VPGen has improved control in counts/spatial
relations/scales of objects than state-of-the-art T2I generation models.
Second, we introduce VPEval, an interpretable and explainable evaluation
framework for T2I generation based on visual programming. Unlike previous T2I
evaluations with a single scoring model that is accurate in some skills but
unreliable in others, VPEval produces evaluation programs that invoke a set of
visual modules that are experts in different skills, and also provides
visual+textual explanations of the evaluation results. Our analysis shows that
VPEval provides a more human-correlated evaluation for skill-specific and
open-ended prompts than widely used single model-based evaluation. We hope that
our work encourages future progress on interpretable/explainable generation and
evaluation for T2I models. | [
0.0186741427,
0.0341983847,
0.0149581255,
0.0299142711,
-0.0047456818,
0.0252438635,
0.01987046,
0.0006282529,
-0.0117382361,
-0.0083803423,
-0.0517700426,
-0.011877235,
0.0435157605,
0.0756342858,
0.0394695811,
-0.1019641533,
-0.0280350074,
-0.043606326,
-0.0560498312,
0.0289578401,
0.0276942253,
0.0356091,
-0.0263459552,
0.042334985,
-0.0381455719,
-0.0083931675,
-0.0342677087,
0.0054620462,
0.0128390733,
-0.0270539671,
-0.0631903186,
0.0278791897,
0.0611982718,
-0.025999181,
0.00000211,
-0.0007704467,
-0.0046431883,
0.0116793457,
0.0214843024,
-0.0102637159,
0.0427218564,
-0.0755045041,
0.0076873288,
-0.0113392882,
-0.0100408215,
-0.006678578,
0.0845577866,
0.0231072921,
0.0957921967,
0.0307906419,
-0.0107947616,
-0.0160034504,
-0.0022014685,
-0.0131204175,
0.017836282,
-0.0069541996,
-0.0285193175,
0.0220195334,
0.0068098838,
0.0297914203,
-0.0311269853,
0.0470213443,
0.0488498323,
-0.0519744754,
0.0226280447,
0.0406512581,
0.0102271242,
-0.046138946,
-0.0088975113,
0.0495510064,
-0.0377049595,
-0.0193045009,
0.0056917765,
-0.0190760307,
-0.0053835241,
0.0137680331,
-0.0618824176,
0.0281113535,
0.014047252,
0.0043176846,
-0.0511013791,
0.0254930984,
-0.0085246032,
-0.0310999285,
-0.0035901377,
-0.0434153602,
0.0182000697,
0.0285383631,
-0.0508192703,
0.0513545796,
-0.0228764489,
-0.0771684721,
0.0311709493,
0.0495814309,
-0.0242074765,
0.0122578181,
-0.0562121756,
-0.037474934,
-0.0489413291,
-0.0173868481,
0.074733384,
0.0239410885,
-0.0443564318,
0.0151272081,
-0.0223324094,
0.0993488431,
0.0090514747,
0.0181192569,
-0.0552294366,
-0.0211386159,
-0.0565504432,
-0.0297176559,
-0.035170503,
-0.0286798608,
-0.0385986939,
-0.0203609262,
-0.0254178289,
0.0258937906,
-0.0199560728,
0.0223596487,
0.0159872435,
0.0135032516,
-0.0649783984,
0.0066257128,
-0.0326128714,
0.0094193071,
-0.010224143,
-0.0300807245,
-0.0149109466,
-0.0263915081,
-0.0036353122,
0.0376188904,
0.0288132131,
0.0029626018,
-0.0360648297,
0.0957332179,
-0.071440354,
-0.0051633581,
0.0132017275,
-0.0065766526,
-0.0357045494,
-0.0305069648,
0.0090743257,
-0.0535972416,
0.0044506863,
-0.0114548169,
-0.0130938962,
-0.0471604653,
0.0049281218,
0.0042459695,
-0.0062326477,
0.0150429048,
-0.0173503179,
0.0248110127,
0.0070380257,
-0.0051940884,
-0.0050501516,
0.0248732027,
0.0572619736,
0.0657535642,
-0.0121997902,
-0.0065073534,
0.0465342142,
0.0546344556,
0.0009373809,
-0.0006637,
-0.0576731861,
0.0056341165,
-0.0107274018,
0.0261791591,
0.0331296809,
0.0254553836,
-0.0114131141,
0.0331879593,
0.069328323,
0.0145379594,
0.0349606834,
0.0251073614,
0.0986540318,
0.0166946258,
-0.0022015385,
-0.0016413961,
-0.0484898202,
0.0735899732,
0.0297904629,
0.0180968754,
-0.0106101539,
0.0090373335,
-0.0245344564,
-0.0566155277,
0.0176019873,
0.0068556024,
-0.0072318348,
-0.0232832022,
0.0619498082,
0.0542242527,
-0.0328823701,
0.0222565681,
-0.0293594375,
-0.0655752867,
0.0353161097,
-0.0365388952,
0.010212698,
0.1065296158,
0.0232916288,
0.0299043804,
0.0146079408,
0.0339905284,
0.0285159163,
0.0730659813,
0.0086150989,
0.0102469092,
0.0390220657,
-0.0296788532,
-0.0309064891,
-0.0216891579,
-0.0152570577,
0.0294625163,
0.0001184587,
0.0044957823,
0.0082186256,
-0.0341756791,
-0.0360998176,
0.0627515912,
0.0268608145,
0.0041181161,
-0.0235490333,
0.0206072833,
-0.0341837928,
-0.0073487018,
-0.0284390785,
0.0067429962,
0.001285924,
-0.0297851749,
0.0390801169,
0.0183426291,
-0.0168651305,
-0.0383623764,
-0.0126961265,
-0.0257874448,
-0.0350270122,
-0.0049237758,
-0.0265189502,
-0.0293993261,
0.0078087007,
-0.0254820138,
-0.0134244701,
-0.0150346532,
-0.0258581024,
0.0001010593,
-0.0339792334,
-0.015916558,
0.0533699505,
-0.0217585061,
-0.0257210676,
0.0030827166,
0.0319651216,
-0.0183618926,
-0.0184519161,
0.0080335662,
-0.0021342025,
0.0087873992,
-0.0041426904,
-0.0168201756,
0.0587134697,
-0.0371463783,
-0.0311279539,
-0.039370738,
-0.0227477066,
-0.012616206,
-0.0068884664,
0.0218299255,
-0.0485901237,
0.0121763265,
-0.0188244339,
-0.0591942184,
0.0220397096,
0.019397473,
-0.0207958575,
0.047023382,
-0.0118501745,
0.0053012352,
-0.0368501209,
0.0039145974,
0.0212259702,
0.0517379083,
0.0485412143,
0.0125136254,
-0.0637558997,
0.058349777,
-0.0145098949,
0.0034604296,
0.0027843197,
-0.0238870475,
0.0557677299,
-0.0248440802,
0.0212228447,
0.0567867197,
-0.0008634761,
0.0516789705,
0.026516268,
-0.011188061,
-0.0428165421,
-0.0173011683,
0.0138394283,
-0.0382104702,
0.0156438798,
-0.042026598,
-0.0106294155,
0.0650305375,
0.0036561124,
0.0537828654,
-0.0912833512,
0.0319828875,
-0.0115389554,
-0.045311328,
-0.0303668939,
-0.0046141916,
0.0190060399,
0.048433397,
-0.0616690554,
-0.0636130944,
0.041298151,
-0.0707314014,
-0.0211814214,
0.0304413084,
0.009519699,
-0.0007108131,
0.1074647382,
0.0430425182,
0.0159332976,
-0.0215459615,
0.0078830365,
-0.0613170527,
0.0023161639,
-0.0089977216,
-0.0162016563,
0.0367644839,
-0.1089903563,
-0.0085400641,
-0.0257551167,
0.0080105932,
-0.022476498,
0.0370701924,
-0.0048555853,
0.0016630396,
0.0184584223,
-0.0297740921,
-0.0203157533,
0.0314797051,
0.028216714,
0.015126857,
-0.0056414264,
-0.0250801016,
-0.026401028,
0.0173004959,
0.0361591652,
0.0263746902,
-0.046766825,
-0.0671397224,
0.0061629973,
0.0414208509,
-0.0137485657,
0.0011690378,
-0.0693934709,
0.0284575541,
-0.0011081874,
0.0422506928,
0.0019466417,
0.0298570059,
0.0847038552,
-0.065325737,
-0.0460702553,
0.0622580126,
0.0064573414,
-0.0105247907,
-0.0115819918,
0.0403297357,
0.0448713787,
0.0138476733,
0.032723356,
-0.0598349981,
-0.0222014152,
-0.0177778844,
0.0069253379,
0.0227160193,
0.0002931216,
-0.0523821749,
-0.0843956098,
0.0669466183,
0.0031382709,
-0.0736957118,
-0.0456311777,
0.0202103928,
0.0133173047,
-0.0030000196,
-0.0558333583,
0.0055927793,
-0.0018168088,
0.053894408,
0.0281517077,
0.0084788343,
-0.0144409072,
-0.0062468965,
-0.0039180955,
0.0049406295,
0.0686383396,
0.0027301407,
0.0365887694,
-0.0269747172,
0.0073921075,
0.0395520739,
0.0284888875,
-0.028283814,
0.0705596805,
0.0153882243,
-0.0504141934,
-0.0262277387,
0.020947773,
0.013551333,
-0.0264213029,
-0.024332745,
0.001345704,
-0.0100310827,
-0.0054155802,
-0.0236747172,
0.0168496408,
0.0063020401,
0.0194457248,
0.0466043651,
-0.0467334725,
-0.0468310267,
-0.0561709777,
0.0057737739,
-0.0835881382,
-0.0621511191,
0.0067464411,
-0.0026897225,
-0.0348592475,
-0.0534710847,
-0.0103784446,
0.0750946328,
0.0430155247,
-0.0103621529,
-0.0331426226,
-0.0161349066,
-0.0021430685,
-0.0510895178,
0.0399964191,
-0.0095510213,
0.0356184393,
-0.0283608474,
-0.0300422534,
-0.0068432647,
-0.0548160374,
-0.0106231151,
0.0181680489,
-0.0730839297,
-0.00424485,
-0.0549653545,
0.1060229018,
0.0195245277,
0.0282122362,
0.0136208478,
-0.0366848968,
0.0019368191,
0.0407636166,
0.0010542586,
-0.0003902754,
-0.0197698846,
0.0327705964,
0.0073444922,
0.0131356511,
-0.0451690517,
0.0242325012,
0.0322741531,
-0.0001254293,
-0.0122472579,
-0.0027679293,
0.0121382922,
-0.0260654744,
-0.0030352639,
-0.0189844277,
0.0116114337,
-0.0355804451,
-0.0326681472,
-0.0325133093,
-0.0186073445,
-0.1133826151,
0.0242488571,
0.0261926092,
0.0235504527,
0.0389959849,
-0.0090160901,
0.0105736963,
0.0296323393,
-0.0349644534,
0.0134110712,
0.0065021906,
0.022386428,
0.0111058773,
0.0459226631,
-0.0189357307,
0.0114197657,
-0.0509052873,
0.0553578846,
0.0099525126,
0.0616394654,
0.0176423937,
-0.0231768154,
-0.0022862435,
0.050041385,
-0.0100102574,
-0.0567449033,
-0.0282936972,
0.0581057072,
0.0391245149,
0.0031033156,
0.0680076852,
-0.0247163605,
0.0105422465,
0.0072740102,
0.0681302771,
0.0252432302,
-0.0366448611,
-0.0076415702,
0.0027925326,
0.0242701508,
-0.1000647023,
0.0737979934,
0.0262797289,
-0.0245891493,
-0.0258514993,
-0.0042503104,
-0.0228546876,
-0.0074371183,
0.0314414315,
-0.0051440201,
0.0011921182,
0.0146172429,
-0.0253017992,
-0.0515186489,
-0.037869893,
0.0748553798,
-0.0045809061,
-0.0071551334,
0.0601092428,
0.0251479801,
-0.010939572,
0.009916734,
-0.0074346373,
-0.0012421838,
0.0175085999,
-0.0166805107,
-0.0117817856,
-5.388627e-33,
-0.0723453239,
-0.0736833662,
0.0415410958,
-0.0144635467,
-0.0101247402,
0.0049622152,
-0.0428604744,
0.0278899111,
0.0102110635,
0.0141392024,
0.04782781,
-0.0288467892,
-0.0033950421,
0.0352056064,
0.0024153467,
0.0294393189,
0.0430695824,
0.005842356,
-0.037653435,
0.0270244591,
0.0141497701,
0.0163654815,
0.0370020047,
-0.0584420599,
-0.0027813977,
0.0155400187,
-0.024127854,
-0.0071256384,
0.0120059671,
0.031688828,
-0.0030211615,
-0.0164736789,
0.0238172878,
-0.0327604823,
-0.025294302,
0.0394373015,
-0.0493889563,
-0.0170845445,
0.0000181757,
0.0369942188,
-0.1006199047,
0.0005301325,
0.0527662411,
-0.0331638455,
-0.0074370075,
-0.044548694,
0.0605565645,
-0.0319674462,
0.0133409156,
0.0214544851,
-0.0288160406,
0.0015150099,
-0.0479034297,
-0.0919108912,
0.0208486747,
0.0336583667,
0.0268155728,
0.0250042789,
-0.050587967,
0.0265351292,
0.0309234001,
0.0169968847,
0.0982870534,
0.0474122129,
-0.0196734071,
0.0435606912,
0.0458183661,
-0.0114162993,
-0.0297045894,
0.000025478,
0.0063571879,
0.0713418573,
0.0538714379,
0.0312641785,
0.0073500606,
0.0362227298,
-0.0384174623,
0.0647945032,
-0.0680667907,
0.0391960219,
0.0125145679,
0.0164339934,
-0.0104895709,
0.0101818237,
-0.0273228548,
-0.039103508,
-0.0441670828,
-0.0140029639,
0.0534135699,
-0.0153247342,
-0.0183421168,
-0.0013930853,
0.0330197774,
0.0087918462,
-0.0058895024,
-0.0020459869,
-0.0689319447,
0.0751801208,
-0.0335154645,
0.0046183327,
-0.0235834047,
-0.0351659134,
0.0606944673,
0.0295394417,
0.0156046432,
0.0426303931,
0.0183825716,
0.0135349492,
-0.0175806284,
0.0080621485,
-0.0655288771,
0.0047403211,
0.0003401602,
0.033494845,
0.0120757781,
-0.0385091379,
-0.0663761348,
-0.0014086252,
-0.025558522,
-0.0556160398,
-0.0156773478,
-0.0231331103,
-0.0111585883,
-0.0090286294,
-0.0395821817,
0.0045595514,
-0.0497504137,
-0.0205007866,
0.045764368,
-0.0278202165,
-0.0125756254,
0.0336451344,
2.586e-7,
0.0574920736,
0.0071359961,
0.004924213,
0.034364108,
0.0010707218,
0.0413760208,
-0.0306041222,
0.0099648703,
0.0113652507,
-0.0037179566,
0.0006318006,
0.0712405592,
0.0602365993,
-0.009888758,
0.0042550317,
0.048538927,
-0.0287426636,
0.0145146195,
-0.0506435074,
0.0215639733,
0.0899470672,
0.0316420905,
-0.0372948572,
-0.023671234,
0.0455245376,
-0.0307358559,
0.0738614351,
-0.0247495193,
0.0299124252,
-0.0318413228,
-0.0238094982,
0.0145993093,
-0.0344627127,
0.0224332493,
-0.0091406135,
-0.0461029559,
0.0436047465,
0.0524474829,
-0.0482798107,
0.0367449075,
0.0131689068,
-0.0033762278,
-0.0190283712,
-0.0610077679,
0.0420851074,
-0.0565508232,
0.0109883398,
0.0003373356,
0.0127502847,
0.0015578881,
-0.0276278667,
-0.0181217957,
-0.0446220823,
0.0318329409,
0.0500811785,
-0.0343255475,
-0.03233511,
0.0041909413,
-0.0764096007,
-0.0298200492,
-0.0036996847,
-0.0095621189,
-0.1049156636,
-0.0010371887,
-0.0166793447,
0.0325423554,
-0.0595912673,
1.991431153e-34,
-0.0118207689,
0.0113061229,
0.0198765136,
-0.0049618976,
0.0541237667,
0.0143201165,
-0.0158061273,
0.0226679258,
0.0029224558,
-0.0324745961,
-0.0343219526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15321v1 | Towards Foundation Models for Relational Databases [Vision Paper] | 2023-05-24T16:37:35 | 2023-05-24T16:37:35 | Liane Vogel, Benjamin Hilprecht, Carsten Binnig | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL | Tabular representation learning has recently gained a lot of attention.
However, existing approaches only learn a representation from a single table,
and thus ignore the potential to learn from the full structure of relational
databases, including neighboring tables that can contain important information
for a contextualized representation. Moreover, current models are significantly
limited in scale, which prevents that they learn from large databases. In this
paper, we thus introduce our vision of relational representation learning, that
can not only learn from the full relational structure, but also can scale to
larger database sizes that are commonly found in real-world. Moreover, we also
discuss opportunities and challenges we see along the way to enable this vision
and present initial very promising results. Overall, we argue that this
direction can lead to foundation models for relational databases that are today
only available for text and images. | [
-0.0096520763,
0.0569486208,
-0.0097944383,
0.0271568634,
-0.018766325,
0.0535073839,
0.0166211445,
0.0176938996,
0.0136563173,
-0.0250384919,
0.0193408839,
-0.0548788421,
-0.0402428582,
0.0395420715,
0.019823961,
-0.0467809848,
-0.022645738,
0.0344460681,
-0.0601808503,
0.0238749478,
0.0062453616,
0.0023479806,
0.0165841114,
0.0063689467,
-0.0830097049,
-0.0064626904,
-0.0476957932,
0.0193609428,
-0.0498431809,
0.005607503,
-0.0141082779,
0.0333670415,
0.0719000697,
-0.0233121775,
0.000002027,
0.0298985951,
-0.0544469915,
-0.0205902532,
0.0137324361,
-0.0125558451,
0.0412565656,
-0.0878985226,
0.0054326318,
-0.007466177,
-0.0351855047,
-0.0403158925,
0.0387935452,
0.0491983071,
0.0304563846,
0.0120306518,
-0.0475805327,
-0.0623786822,
0.024789406,
-0.0293473583,
0.0593110323,
-0.01755438,
0.0010481364,
0.0472221635,
-0.0221003033,
-0.0097910585,
-0.0393262357,
0.0229491778,
0.020745948,
-0.0136353122,
0.0625789165,
0.04092554,
-0.0011473043,
0.0136100249,
0.0253609773,
0.0934120864,
0.0106275789,
0.0149948644,
0.0164208114,
0.008285746,
-0.0032469265,
-0.0195434336,
-0.015912408,
-0.019875899,
-0.0197174717,
0.0123656364,
-0.060021434,
-0.0203105509,
0.0223508403,
-0.0068805725,
-0.0468885116,
-0.0148505745,
-0.0485550798,
0.0062452294,
-0.0138205495,
-0.0143954065,
0.0243687555,
0.0034247108,
-0.0021188813,
0.0136669017,
-0.031154912,
0.019161839,
0.0000892138,
0.0525524169,
0.0076404735,
-0.0478491858,
0.0141415084,
-0.0022204367,
-0.0209590625,
0.0718148649,
-0.0274889451,
0.0081245136,
-0.0601296425,
0.0324499086,
-0.0255503375,
-0.0272665769,
-0.0704411864,
0.02616271,
-0.017919546,
0.0358460769,
-0.012873413,
-0.0375627875,
-0.0191651657,
0.0371062607,
-0.0286283735,
0.0683046952,
-0.0448553264,
0.0714327022,
0.0086411228,
-0.0112399422,
-0.01213519,
-0.0204094052,
-0.0305996723,
0.0253854897,
-0.0141793881,
-0.0309700985,
0.0211165454,
-0.0402224362,
0.0290083475,
0.0090736877,
0.0170533266,
0.0303678103,
0.0016776323,
0.0034809753,
-0.0469053313,
-0.0389225408,
0.0139975604,
-0.013463093,
-0.0182965603,
-0.0500616021,
0.0452390462,
0.0083901649,
-0.0128921047,
-0.0222478509,
-0.0289994273,
-0.0015479659,
-0.034906581,
0.1197925135,
-0.0021262919,
0.0083846301,
-0.0272903889,
0.0042676819,
-0.029558856,
0.0475068204,
0.0283432007,
0.0429240577,
-0.0089095216,
-0.0285395905,
-0.0713507533,
-0.0208995976,
0.0610111468,
0.0002191488,
-0.0187412445,
0.0460238531,
0.0199731514,
0.0333769359,
-0.0237328708,
0.0081835631,
-0.0382874645,
-0.0147677744,
0.0082493927,
0.0124146538,
-0.0005559674,
0.0746627003,
0.0069340807,
-0.003423654,
-0.0188168138,
0.0116205383,
-0.0376570933,
0.034060739,
0.012975798,
-0.0114969192,
-0.0112776682,
-0.0184572916,
-0.0382421352,
-0.048059471,
0.0397745036,
-0.0226857252,
0.0140731456,
0.0072451066,
0.0468434021,
0.0117866844,
-0.0013528654,
0.0114044612,
0.0389934368,
-0.0238076244,
0.006716616,
-0.0029255804,
0.0065540615,
0.065202646,
0.0166986082,
-0.074092336,
0.0412219092,
-0.025863681,
0.0157103259,
-0.0386423059,
0.0484074056,
-0.0674406737,
0.0165674053,
0.0006382504,
-0.0505586751,
0.0427860171,
0.014736237,
-0.0121429609,
-0.0173641276,
-0.0008034307,
0.0382786691,
-0.0435090475,
0.0033815466,
-0.0062293452,
0.0292294063,
0.005345393,
0.0319472291,
0.0391099527,
-0.0033693111,
0.0328164808,
-0.0203306153,
-0.0081679085,
0.0848965421,
-0.0122468779,
-0.0005434291,
-0.0275128409,
-0.0423312038,
0.0050450275,
0.0218986496,
0.0115924226,
0.0032436128,
-0.03503941,
-0.0552771129,
-0.0203503259,
0.0575113595,
-0.0179469921,
-0.0169006698,
-0.0126128132,
0.0048749787,
-0.0080327094,
0.0185713228,
-0.011764124,
0.0842765048,
-0.0330660567,
0.0037899064,
0.0111708613,
-0.0507688411,
0.0388576239,
-0.03160768,
0.0183758922,
-0.0447827168,
0.0022952324,
0.0738802627,
0.0209328253,
-0.0379593,
-0.0578663014,
0.0289070588,
-0.0538000688,
0.0106626246,
0.0107084867,
0.0034926939,
0.001629296,
-0.0015708127,
0.0448323339,
-0.0437852032,
-0.0575193949,
0.0091462526,
-0.0647165999,
0.0054806028,
0.0461975113,
0.0050087152,
-0.0138726579,
-0.0100876577,
-0.0451598614,
-0.0411740541,
0.0272915866,
-0.027424207,
-0.0594533086,
0.0413585678,
-0.031812951,
0.0072134468,
0.0413566306,
0.0110939331,
0.0471976399,
-0.0018894944,
-0.0749817342,
-0.0264608599,
0.067894496,
-0.0247582383,
0.0790816993,
-0.0288914572,
0.0034981545,
-0.0529822744,
0.0081711775,
-0.0053672283,
0.0677884817,
0.003936213,
-0.0528950542,
-0.007149376,
-0.0231827032,
0.0065512056,
0.0187816583,
-0.0498055592,
0.0303696562,
0.0505966656,
0.0184067544,
-0.086790666,
0.0508842692,
0.0277729239,
-0.0062062046,
-0.0490818694,
-0.0189742967,
0.0002795222,
0.0018129342,
0.0553428717,
0.0470125191,
-0.0122325504,
-0.0339325108,
0.0840948895,
0.0408990532,
0.0093283122,
0.0221476462,
-0.020165354,
-0.0228460468,
-0.005116628,
0.0197889991,
-0.0186003335,
0.0672962666,
0.0009016038,
0.0061228056,
0.011770634,
-0.0728502721,
-0.0175148044,
-0.0200524945,
0.013331295,
0.0402427576,
-0.0275339112,
0.0122870253,
-0.0453436859,
-0.0388186909,
-0.0021423672,
0.0398941897,
0.0383066647,
-0.0266589597,
-0.0357864313,
0.0793457776,
0.0106104026,
-0.01715816,
-0.0182154104,
-0.0146137355,
0.0022268449,
0.0543665662,
0.0022853413,
-0.0370496437,
-0.0309305694,
0.0555722192,
-0.0234283917,
-0.0038112896,
-0.0273009408,
0.0287241545,
-0.0849663317,
-0.0325311422,
-0.0080622565,
0.0428029411,
0.0281270891,
-0.0221450739,
-0.0283663068,
0.0472785495,
0.0009928797,
0.0408366509,
-0.0030591481,
-0.1216836646,
-0.0216430072,
-0.0408147164,
-0.0313676409,
0.0613410138,
-0.0535500422,
-0.0032239098,
-0.0640475675,
0.0411213674,
0.0094074802,
-0.0267976131,
-0.0597423688,
-0.0023998038,
-0.0115852272,
-0.0529230982,
-0.0084269959,
0.0297859479,
-0.0403226018,
-0.0284602549,
0.0107057681,
-0.0055533927,
-0.0430019982,
-0.015997339,
-0.1059858128,
0.0012998362,
0.0351533517,
0.0293137357,
0.017029386,
-0.0169174746,
-0.0492043085,
0.013899534,
0.0001121963,
-0.0218186863,
0.1040146425,
-0.0047587124,
0.0167457387,
0.022501979,
-0.0077845119,
-0.0372850113,
0.0147074116,
-0.0061520957,
0.1074659899,
-0.0416784137,
0.0182137061,
0.0124362223,
-0.046853818,
0.0131998323,
0.0322179347,
0.0214213487,
-0.0128253801,
-0.0523064435,
-0.0165628176,
-0.0029189002,
-0.0165792406,
0.0426303074,
0.0196152441,
-0.0237703286,
-0.0024578145,
-0.0530440286,
-0.0212842412,
0.0195129812,
0.0329306833,
-0.0204230156,
0.024629768,
-0.0056235506,
-0.0492042005,
-0.0869062915,
-0.0309779309,
0.0016942939,
0.0140893953,
0.0382025018,
-0.031858325,
0.0306109115,
-0.0731914118,
-0.0084531475,
-0.0709319189,
-0.0425591953,
-0.013873403,
-0.0199700277,
0.0250582825,
0.0150507521,
0.0473957881,
0.0229297597,
-0.0424760617,
-0.027712889,
0.0308300816,
-0.0309624448,
-0.0612082258,
0.0064552431,
-0.0413505249,
-0.0051843044,
0.056825038,
-0.0289801713,
0.0314905047,
-0.0431451574,
-0.0038364658,
-0.0457731262,
0.0274947397,
0.032915391,
-0.023138592,
0.0144046433,
0.0538331829,
-0.036540553,
-0.0270755962,
0.02941636,
-0.0373411067,
-0.0557550676,
-0.0207912978,
0.0094946297,
0.0239905473,
0.0279743541,
-0.0238200482,
-0.016659366,
0.0452278815,
0.0367168225,
-0.0644754469,
-0.0058670617,
0.0735766143,
-0.0272775386,
0.0115610678,
0.0070407968,
0.0071129589,
-0.0044898163,
-0.004847277,
0.0353168324,
0.0072938511,
-0.0169016998,
0.0018817998,
0.0136811137,
-0.0981703326,
0.0175728463,
-0.045653861,
-0.0150238369,
0.0036355455,
0.0076713278,
0.0521696955,
0.0025671076,
-0.0172253642,
-0.0087592686,
-0.017479958,
0.0161199775,
0.0208765455,
0.0285864752,
-0.0586935058,
0.0367403924,
0.0114930002,
-0.0016786131,
0.005490798,
0.0427620634,
0.0275679193,
0.006159218,
-0.026041273,
-0.033229392,
-0.0621772893,
0.0139156915,
0.0160646513,
0.0291080661,
-0.0169929508,
0.0278534703,
-0.0318419375,
-0.0309125911,
0.0703183487,
-0.0005108998,
-0.0097132949,
0.0100841951,
-0.0030888787,
0.0108369589,
0.0811894387,
-0.0089697428,
-0.0294517912,
0.0025931944,
-0.0532331355,
-0.0251376703,
0.011020625,
-5.572062159e-33,
0.000757744,
-0.0020101701,
0.0078663146,
-0.0364319794,
-0.0135996267,
0.0292507261,
-0.0291247461,
-0.0378958657,
0.0050330395,
-0.0082614236,
-0.0420201495,
0.0283233579,
0.0129394773,
0.0036120578,
0.0145912804,
-0.0468001291,
0.04483274,
-0.0106319729,
0.0258163475,
0.0471221358,
0.0154208206,
0.0196761042,
0.0026512619,
-0.0673437193,
0.0034878717,
-0.0136671467,
-0.0458020344,
0.025699297,
0.0347972959,
0.0485226773,
-0.0365346223,
0.0242937598,
0.0506679267,
-0.0229760185,
-0.0337529592,
-0.0061360048,
-0.1651386172,
0.0266450737,
-0.0442533046,
0.0379961245,
-0.0374250785,
0.0257669687,
0.0250460636,
-0.0050330879,
0.0509430058,
-0.0543602519,
0.0334685668,
-0.0656467453,
-0.0548888259,
-0.011653726,
-0.0037319651,
0.0217027646,
0.0088759102,
0.0244256165,
0.0970166624,
0.0078720488,
0.0318532549,
-0.0033265515,
-0.0646604225,
-0.0123966364,
-0.0369953178,
-0.0039846203,
-0.0018575094,
0.0066568269,
0.0244888049,
0.0495050848,
0.0394243002,
-0.0147716049,
-0.027538579,
-0.002911072,
-0.0303342286,
0.0753648579,
0.0214197058,
0.0420409627,
0.0265331715,
0.0016443972,
-0.0843283534,
0.0253681764,
0.0287022553,
-0.0136224246,
-0.0080406526,
-0.0028966239,
-0.0321885496,
-0.0079727368,
-0.0217366852,
-0.0232059769,
-0.0223358199,
-0.0002993281,
0.0146736624,
0.0426519215,
0.0173615515,
0.0397055708,
0.0035065527,
-0.0514681339,
-0.0553240813,
0.0645340458,
-0.0061212173,
-0.0002523989,
0.0236886013,
-0.0382481478,
-0.0579980873,
-0.0527151041,
0.0083410721,
-0.0044229431,
0.0278857425,
0.041302599,
0.0909532532,
0.0073957732,
-0.0297148954,
0.0045500202,
-0.0016488095,
-0.0069251568,
0.0067788372,
0.0268426165,
0.0084138103,
0.0317714252,
-0.0053663095,
0.0728966147,
0.0476154089,
-0.0023897826,
0.0279086009,
-0.0076871128,
-0.0048243469,
0.0420197509,
0.0209049024,
-0.0184777398,
-0.0371280015,
-0.0263479073,
0.0543763153,
-0.0425445363,
-0.019704815,
0.0203769282,
2.35e-7,
0.036493253,
-0.0014994746,
0.0829241872,
0.0083260434,
0.0353668258,
0.0491418429,
-0.0249662846,
0.0522531942,
-0.0415594578,
-0.0188991651,
0.0642725304,
-0.0009594175,
0.0356070325,
0.0279577114,
-0.0466996506,
0.0312600471,
-0.0383449495,
-0.0056914701,
-0.0341580324,
0.0125243505,
0.0472102053,
0.0988873765,
-0.0373774394,
-0.0304838847,
0.0698705018,
-0.0144006135,
0.0548398569,
-0.0439996533,
0.0614586584,
-0.0058067506,
0.021198038,
0.0309390388,
-0.0303913634,
0.0511668138,
-0.0106846457,
0.0220343899,
-0.0064805811,
0.0227974635,
-0.0181750413,
0.0526949875,
-0.0088549247,
-0.0691257268,
0.038433332,
-0.0158997234,
0.0949938074,
-0.0456811786,
0.0232742857,
0.0640968084,
-0.0181074291,
0.0293262713,
0.0129446825,
0.0463954918,
-0.0353930332,
-0.0007135603,
0.0195902456,
-0.0010604953,
-0.0046931086,
-0.0649709031,
0.0257667098,
0.0546439551,
0.0151732927,
0.0544490218,
0.0079842163,
-0.0095353778,
-0.008572923,
-0.0494334027,
-0.010484511,
1.834611252e-34,
0.024685761,
0.0194447171,
0.0379377231,
0.0185885578,
0.0182165056,
-0.0468021035,
-0.0012406362,
-0.023453841,
0.0169609394,
-0.0436932519,
0.0051655639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15299v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15299v4 | Science in the Era of ChatGPT, Large Language Models and Generative AI: Challenges for Research Ethics and How to Respond | 2023-05-24T16:23:46 | 2023-07-29T12:54:20 | Evangelos Pournaras | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models of artificial intelligence (AI), such as ChatGPT, find
remarkable but controversial applicability in science and research. This paper
reviews epistemological challenges, ethical and integrity risks in science
conduct in the advent of generative AI. This is with the aim to lay new timely
foundations for a high-quality research ethics review. The role of AI language
models as a research instrument and subject is scrutinized along with ethical
implications for scientists, participants and reviewers. New emerging practices
for research ethics review are discussed, concluding with ten recommendations
that shape a response for a more responsible research conduct in the era of AI. | [
0.0464548394,
0.1243569925,
-0.0405705012,
0.0247412808,
-0.0834517851,
0.0088214939,
0.0551191904,
0.0067160041,
0.0412717015,
-0.0301709641,
-0.0203160867,
-0.0168563072,
0.0046938676,
0.052472394,
0.0096973311,
-0.0128133614,
0.0185982883,
-0.0261438061,
0.0744220838,
-0.0064068893,
-0.0367943943,
0.0115171177,
0.0288535524,
0.0459917001,
-0.0186743643,
-0.0231809542,
0.0216295999,
-0.0482167974,
-0.0188403446,
-0.0066543249,
0.0167828035,
0.0339066647,
0.036258541,
0.110534586,
0.0000017901,
-0.0343378261,
-0.0101923831,
0.0730314627,
-0.0028051343,
-0.0074791792,
0.071623221,
0.0229289774,
-0.0017225622,
-0.0119271968,
-0.0589088686,
0.0330183953,
0.0912091807,
-0.0090749469,
-0.0439186506,
0.0473040454,
-0.0074774944,
0.0088243764,
0.0741916895,
0.0116178701,
-0.0062840553,
0.0317717232,
0.0493077748,
0.021138303,
0.0225835536,
0.0478779562,
0.0104586473,
0.0607641265,
0.0279165152,
-0.0300472323,
-0.0279030669,
-0.0012430353,
-0.0374920815,
-0.0581922978,
0.0238082055,
0.022489313,
0.0330164656,
-0.0126259737,
0.0156006031,
0.0425311662,
-0.0198745187,
0.0081888121,
-0.016463697,
0.0641312152,
0.0067594317,
-0.0239885021,
0.0452401675,
-0.0083259372,
0.0201504491,
0.0450052284,
0.0429750979,
0.0081147281,
0.013796607,
-0.0158358105,
-0.0393459536,
0.0185988322,
0.0179521833,
-0.0198911112,
-0.0201084428,
0.0137432031,
-0.0253871977,
0.0313970111,
-0.0061353431,
0.0195752997,
0.0521896109,
-0.0362464003,
-0.0127813751,
0.0262599457,
0.051979851,
-0.0157860089,
0.0405795574,
0.0180538222,
-0.0495084003,
0.0660903007,
-0.024342075,
0.0169209912,
-0.0503496304,
-0.0591094568,
-0.0302007236,
0.0020990237,
-0.036075104,
0.0144180954,
0.0011491119,
-0.0000593789,
-0.0401523411,
-0.0096884212,
-0.0549424924,
0.0196222346,
-0.0463627577,
0.0177361183,
0.0054180492,
-0.022816889,
0.0119460393,
0.032041911,
0.0040641706,
-0.0542204641,
-0.0159303192,
-0.00125988,
-0.0536771975,
0.0098710395,
0.0154285431,
0.1023305207,
0.0280460063,
-0.0155440252,
0.054482352,
-0.0386147201,
-0.0073997681,
-0.0892400965,
0.0552258827,
-0.0094244797,
0.0443425886,
-0.0257288683,
-0.0320603587,
-0.066565372,
-0.011376434,
-0.0057633286,
-0.0182128493,
0.0693938956,
-0.0346186906,
-0.0018991648,
0.0095079402,
0.0405744389,
-0.0082428111,
0.0133043639,
0.0505578667,
0.0067026005,
0.018313108,
-0.0252502225,
0.0437852331,
-0.0185107924,
-0.0123138931,
0.0061078947,
-0.0193740688,
-0.0054827519,
-0.0134954015,
0.0377259292,
-0.0016113905,
0.082752727,
-0.0388065651,
-0.0091449739,
0.0276213083,
0.1082047075,
-0.0612095483,
0.0707399324,
0.0334931165,
-0.0382337756,
0.00059509,
0.0064744647,
-0.0318743587,
0.0327123441,
-0.0156433247,
-0.0192320701,
-0.0575308762,
0.0447571985,
0.0095536578,
-0.0371606015,
0.0218545906,
-0.0194635242,
0.0369228832,
0.0144325411,
0.0022264991,
-0.0171509981,
0.0155018577,
-0.0860057771,
0.0393463224,
-0.0211300943,
-0.0329417959,
-0.078738153,
0.0346213579,
0.0530269071,
0.0292528812,
-0.0290167294,
-0.022857951,
-0.0324883722,
-0.0433684774,
0.0595087223,
0.0041599558,
-0.0233012401,
-0.0160355866,
0.0019469314,
-0.0111465203,
-0.0405010507,
-0.0076165982,
0.0097137494,
-0.0494475961,
0.0236418638,
-0.0238251798,
0.0107572414,
-0.065364562,
0.0086291526,
-0.071597822,
-0.0148058003,
-0.0356582738,
-0.0385512859,
0.0287605878,
-0.0234749634,
-0.0376467034,
0.0460544191,
0.0284884106,
0.0033901175,
-0.0175241157,
0.0247295704,
0.008339365,
0.026299756,
0.0015113484,
-0.0812690705,
-0.0079558101,
0.0177223664,
-0.0017925689,
0.021390032,
0.0149372024,
-0.0182474349,
0.0348877199,
-0.0350836292,
0.0002878411,
-0.0772433877,
0.0107428534,
-0.038677711,
0.0064290278,
0.0072913454,
0.0190974604,
0.0056725224,
-0.012158379,
0.0343419388,
-0.0029453933,
-0.048457738,
0.0922700688,
0.0298272166,
0.0211619288,
0.0474719442,
0.0061399336,
-0.0084632384,
-0.0209140982,
-0.0437222458,
-0.0245446227,
0.0171161033,
-0.0057927915,
-0.0421674475,
-0.0342860147,
-0.0092869587,
0.0052380702,
-0.0006776451,
-0.0276820511,
0.0139470948,
0.026798876,
0.0127485162,
-0.0228661504,
-0.0280314833,
-0.0274902619,
-0.0228936132,
-0.0255650133,
0.0357417949,
0.0650925264,
0.010656463,
-0.0429623015,
0.0142322304,
-0.0570342913,
0.016410131,
0.0036423951,
-0.0244951695,
0.041759748,
0.0108990325,
0.014433166,
0.0428744256,
-0.0036383751,
0.068211183,
0.0703636333,
0.0346965753,
-0.0274698231,
-0.028955983,
0.0065669399,
0.0007353143,
0.0308230482,
-0.0203343667,
0.014223597,
0.0143186543,
-0.0114597064,
-0.0315188058,
-0.02646585,
0.0980638862,
-0.0505186245,
-0.0670433342,
0.0428673364,
-0.0745036379,
-0.0306960326,
0.0309931375,
-0.0185609143,
-0.0638920441,
0.0796199441,
-0.0004416619,
0.0051216874,
-0.0687812418,
-0.0099211643,
0.0085799797,
0.0835468993,
0.0090057552,
0.0351220444,
0.0721038803,
0.020359356,
-0.0284670014,
0.0433956757,
-0.0038247383,
-0.0468354523,
-0.0105166882,
-0.0550264642,
0.0531408414,
0.0080822594,
-0.0539010875,
-0.0345293768,
0.006015846,
-0.0006432452,
0.0272249337,
0.0555074811,
-0.0080715921,
-0.0366730317,
0.0000627102,
0.0665458217,
0.0028770792,
0.0130200032,
-0.013078413,
-0.003071161,
-0.0311075449,
0.045484677,
-0.0264691003,
0.0352907591,
0.0350175463,
0.0288610887,
0.0451824106,
-0.0284727495,
0.0338888802,
-0.0051179668,
0.002712579,
0.0223114081,
0.0183705091,
-0.0041627754,
0.0124813626,
0.0230990257,
-0.0418822989,
-0.0316386856,
0.0510492176,
-0.0068785618,
-0.0327930562,
0.0204169545,
-0.0382005051,
-0.0320929289,
-0.0156815238,
0.0242234599,
-0.0669474453,
0.0683523864,
-0.0182834379,
-0.0131558254,
-0.0879390165,
-0.0588946491,
0.0011421819,
-0.0493297726,
0.0787093639,
0.0016122186,
-0.0519298799,
-0.0323946998,
-0.04161622,
-0.0136180902,
-0.0066528032,
0.0561638251,
-0.0022690874,
-0.0012137404,
-0.0080840029,
0.0373560414,
0.0224648938,
-0.0256803725,
0.037808381,
-0.0038620369,
0.1040984988,
0.0702819973,
0.0314196162,
-0.0392309427,
-0.0212484747,
-0.0402702168,
0.0344394408,
-0.0156957749,
0.0208642725,
-0.0195355583,
0.0383515842,
-0.0156342834,
-0.0754645914,
0.0063232402,
-0.0165770892,
-0.0190238561,
0.0146297067,
0.0917263478,
-0.0834059343,
-0.0658204556,
-0.0514919758,
-0.0306003951,
0.0031397939,
0.0568060726,
-0.0024905112,
-0.0214856733,
-0.037404675,
-0.03378148,
0.0054664328,
0.0198920052,
-0.0446121506,
-0.0101397298,
0.0171097759,
-0.0033373102,
-0.0688702762,
-0.0759392455,
0.00946075,
-0.0034611064,
0.0245916191,
-0.036967624,
0.0367760733,
-0.0266224816,
-0.0153441885,
0.0369190983,
-0.0107252914,
-0.0188652314,
0.0087006055,
-0.0276018828,
0.0390405208,
-0.0186039917,
0.0148851722,
0.0109199453,
0.0521919616,
-0.0373426899,
0.029774135,
0.0705824867,
0.0260478649,
0.0085520102,
0.0064384509,
-0.0115130693,
-0.014929072,
0.0498946868,
-0.0338136107,
0.0129249217,
-0.0108414562,
0.0043529146,
-0.01093568,
-0.0191413891,
-0.0016326281,
0.0335284062,
0.004241236,
-0.0129436888,
-0.0674547255,
-0.0259479061,
0.0543023832,
0.0446887501,
-0.0014239383,
-0.054716859,
0.0191342849,
-0.0168632343,
-0.0840898603,
-0.0397891738,
-0.012372734,
-0.0537137464,
0.003818468,
0.0050637512,
0.053137809,
-0.0104161855,
-0.0078070909,
-0.0508664437,
0.0103692068,
-0.0056439703,
0.0567311272,
0.012748302,
0.0668852329,
0.0204868037,
0.0334120989,
-0.0142976036,
0.0423412807,
-0.0419669934,
0.0357975215,
-0.0165792406,
0.0244925208,
0.0308823641,
-0.0086126337,
0.0111402273,
0.0394374244,
-0.0763256177,
-0.0667626858,
-0.0049439427,
0.048634883,
-0.0315732397,
0.0462287366,
-0.0147612421,
-0.055151023,
0.000712162,
-0.0150226979,
-0.0022191487,
0.0121492455,
-0.0277343839,
0.0012057831,
0.0213087816,
-0.0569601916,
-0.0431866162,
0.0470640846,
0.0145141063,
0.0624325387,
-0.0137077356,
-0.0005994646,
0.0241515823,
-0.0899930894,
-0.0071889567,
-0.0682372302,
0.0186137632,
-0.0228896681,
-0.0579502136,
-0.0621584766,
-0.0453855991,
0.009712195,
0.0139004095,
-0.0376638733,
-0.0026766115,
0.0286459997,
0.001514721,
-0.0248927232,
-0.0056754425,
0.0289888792,
-0.0434068404,
-0.0356241949,
-0.019042844,
-5.746328462e-33,
0.0349454209,
-0.05216543,
0.0324494429,
-0.0077752122,
-0.0523921214,
0.0333991162,
-0.0380750038,
-0.0176433511,
-0.0390982553,
0.0252210144,
-0.0194693413,
-0.0161652267,
-0.0122670783,
-0.013462469,
0.0324964859,
-0.0183449928,
0.0297940541,
-0.0377600528,
0.0153198242,
0.0348164141,
-0.0186772998,
-0.0306388475,
0.0307769086,
-0.0754161552,
0.0682614669,
0.0076463209,
-0.0028672577,
0.016822869,
-0.0481618308,
0.023257494,
-0.0315606408,
0.0450259969,
0.0166458935,
-0.0276677478,
0.0042439969,
0.0060730712,
0.0091824932,
0.0053505423,
0.0017323721,
-0.0399331301,
-0.0328765996,
-0.0595439151,
0.0617316701,
-0.0223562922,
-0.0415977053,
0.0098047461,
0.011399461,
-0.0399513468,
-0.0271791033,
-0.0389812291,
-0.0944185778,
-0.0244980659,
-0.0207747389,
0.0138873626,
0.0225060321,
0.0003707733,
-0.01456198,
-0.0116011556,
0.0111460071,
0.032034032,
0.0142016513,
-0.0751863644,
0.0230643712,
-0.011545063,
0.0579666048,
0.0491775014,
0.0462753996,
0.0420103669,
-0.0297767837,
-0.0178455934,
0.0063506551,
0.0555227213,
0.0379992649,
0.0428853817,
-0.0223005991,
-0.0326692387,
-0.034805391,
-0.0142923314,
0.0196548402,
0.0277634412,
0.0165482946,
-0.0096014692,
-0.0446052402,
-0.0343314819,
0.0192731358,
-0.0394529738,
-0.0230212212,
-0.0234062336,
0.0073814974,
-0.0483180955,
-0.008814848,
0.0085619614,
0.030762149,
-0.0644426793,
0.0485979803,
0.0029115861,
0.0051207035,
0.0107746189,
0.0070676184,
0.0273727886,
-0.0293157734,
-0.0128669459,
0.0288111549,
0.0423737727,
0.050713513,
0.0238037407,
-0.0081650605,
0.0288747828,
0.0112508535,
0.0105937645,
-0.0273409765,
0.0380305462,
0.0737822205,
-0.0313852206,
-0.0099996747,
0.0356228016,
0.0133934328,
-0.0248536449,
0.0310633704,
0.0619935766,
-0.0313447528,
0.0384873934,
-0.0559473224,
0.0058450252,
-0.0321742222,
0.0013205295,
-0.0271198638,
0.0458016545,
0.0417611971,
-0.0724987611,
-0.012078777,
-0.0126793347,
2.786e-7,
0.0201358385,
0.0409508012,
0.0365119874,
-0.0235526804,
0.0081574712,
0.0125804394,
0.0158097539,
0.040380694,
0.008372372,
0.0262536798,
0.0391638018,
0.0000651929,
-0.0191445574,
0.0232447311,
-0.0207143519,
-0.0444968939,
-0.0596607029,
-0.0596782155,
-0.0411185399,
0.0375901088,
0.0314455517,
0.0155655658,
0.0109701548,
-0.0242045242,
-0.0204990264,
-0.0012523618,
0.0158227421,
-0.0301764645,
0.0373431854,
0.0353221707,
-0.0080794897,
0.0429997556,
0.024787005,
0.0326040648,
0.0260024611,
-0.0275144149,
0.0358260535,
0.0416604653,
-0.0266701113,
0.0015146934,
0.0073140627,
-0.0369569063,
0.0163536053,
-0.0417750478,
0.0336950235,
-0.0468977802,
-0.0357296094,
-0.038348645,
0.0139924781,
-0.0171770342,
0.0252135992,
-0.0194191262,
-0.0045099673,
0.0358818844,
-0.0258236304,
0.0216224827,
0.0378095657,
-0.0327268578,
0.0234233048,
-0.0074444511,
-0.0418257229,
-0.0595991723,
-0.0108708479,
-0.0190804265,
0.0236757528,
-0.0293967016,
0.0504131205,
2.444636112e-34,
0.0132492231,
-0.0442911871,
0.0144087039,
0.0029885417,
0.0128626842,
0.0720880479,
0.0306492094,
-0.0137089202,
0.033494778,
-0.0230719857,
-0.0393463857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15294v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15294v2 | Enhancing Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models with Iterative Retrieval-Generation Synergy | 2023-05-24T16:17:36 | 2023-10-23T09:58:13 | Zhihong Shao, Yeyun Gong, Yelong Shen, Minlie Huang, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models are powerful text processors and reasoners, but are
still subject to limitations including outdated knowledge and hallucinations,
which necessitates connecting them to the world. Retrieval-augmented large
language models have raised extensive attention for grounding model generation
on external knowledge. However, retrievers struggle to capture relevance,
especially for queries with complex information needs. Recent work has proposed
to improve relevance modeling by having large language models actively involved
in retrieval, i.e., to improve retrieval with generation. In this paper, we
show that strong performance can be achieved by a method we call Iter-RetGen,
which synergizes retrieval and generation in an iterative manner. A model
output shows what might be needed to finish a task, and thus provides an
informative context for retrieving more relevant knowledge which in turn helps
generate a better output in the next iteration. Compared with recent work which
interleaves retrieval with generation when producing an output, Iter-RetGen
processes all retrieved knowledge as a whole and largely preserves the
flexibility in generation without structural constraints. We evaluate
Iter-RetGen on multi-hop question answering, fact verification, and commonsense
reasoning, and show that it can flexibly leverage parametric knowledge and
non-parametric knowledge, and is superior to or competitive with
state-of-the-art retrieval-augmented baselines while causing fewer overheads of
retrieval and generation. We can further improve performance via
generation-augmented retrieval adaptation. | [
0.0400780402,
0.0460960492,
0.0020738884,
0.0303679742,
-0.0449131839,
-0.0159872659,
-0.0404895507,
0.0124404905,
0.0144154746,
-0.0615839846,
-0.0109534208,
-0.0192556027,
-0.0476995185,
-0.0084414212,
-0.0048137787,
-0.0053298413,
0.0443549901,
-0.0240391884,
0.0026543858,
-0.0181974526,
-0.023984544,
0.0452219807,
0.0104463324,
0.0144201275,
-0.0254521929,
-0.0046105399,
0.0124825193,
0.0068973,
-0.0076982123,
-0.0154966414,
-0.0027363985,
0.0115707517,
0.0337644368,
0.0200810675,
0.0000020382,
-0.036488384,
-0.0160118137,
0.0124928243,
-0.039848417,
-0.0143579217,
0.0010273254,
0.0186165813,
0.022053048,
-0.000593481,
-0.0431699194,
0.0116840322,
0.0186707918,
0.0670405924,
0.057971403,
0.0564467423,
-0.0008289677,
-0.0390199907,
-0.0013320907,
-0.015372009,
0.0410606526,
-0.0365604758,
0.0214845836,
0.0659239292,
0.0364443362,
0.0408285707,
0.002422885,
0.0382352024,
0.0274890382,
-0.0063244994,
0.0103476774,
0.038196288,
-0.0200956054,
0.0093670683,
0.0103395367,
0.054919865,
0.0435045213,
-0.0460605696,
-0.0077522462,
0.0486636683,
-0.0068055578,
0.0527154654,
-0.0704790056,
0.0183341801,
-0.0243657455,
-0.0002333899,
0.0145212486,
-0.0333155245,
0.0447043143,
0.0289947167,
-0.030479813,
0.0894465297,
0.0309672486,
-0.0313086398,
-0.0187159125,
0.0073038517,
-0.0268632695,
-0.0378277637,
-0.0175536219,
0.0688715056,
-0.0583672859,
0.0098452382,
0.0203224141,
-0.0008992652,
0.0282170884,
-0.0611866154,
-0.0058896383,
0.0250371546,
-0.0169514511,
0.0728746802,
-0.0391472057,
0.0084353359,
-0.0391304828,
-0.0274607278,
-0.0711415634,
-0.0337089486,
-0.0476680808,
-0.0397752002,
-0.0547744557,
0.0463893898,
-0.0590333641,
-0.0071449042,
-0.0075298361,
0.036169935,
0.0009750311,
-0.0111754965,
-0.0057495884,
0.0289151259,
-0.0294609647,
-0.0358066037,
-0.0520570949,
0.0609220862,
-0.0371785723,
0.0006331888,
0.0168820508,
-0.042343244,
-0.0198854227,
0.0036187628,
0.0095150303,
-0.0380833708,
0.0190072991,
0.0271447543,
-0.0185789801,
-0.0048072222,
-0.0352358967,
-0.0448980704,
-0.0125483852,
-0.0844613239,
-0.0014747825,
-0.0668615177,
0.0202328637,
0.0220450014,
-0.0326554254,
-0.0277817659,
0.0079028243,
0.0336400755,
-0.0258737225,
0.0473147035,
0.0270913783,
0.0029703546,
0.0294569954,
0.0286824182,
0.0257463995,
0.0635012835,
-0.0096928626,
0.0020133939,
0.0409113914,
0.0082255621,
-0.0072037871,
-0.0116716009,
0.0443327725,
0.0247478709,
-0.026051579,
0.0568533875,
0.0354954861,
-0.0065641254,
0.0116027193,
0.0366080366,
-0.0476604588,
0.0185878742,
0.0411021821,
-0.0014984299,
0.043880593,
0.0170087442,
0.0573857874,
-0.0027359987,
-0.019506963,
-0.0057399226,
-0.043118082,
0.0361666158,
-0.0699664354,
0.0078125019,
-0.0009771439,
0.0404389128,
-0.0390196294,
-0.034141928,
-0.0059592105,
0.0277108364,
-0.0202566124,
0.0345017612,
0.0638988912,
0.0363652892,
-0.0184609443,
0.0860272199,
0.0297731198,
-0.0434304662,
0.0281799529,
-0.0499998406,
0.0464092456,
0.0596668832,
0.0835721269,
-0.0358268805,
0.0003849749,
0.0352327824,
0.0158266015,
0.0079088872,
0.0555973612,
-0.0114637306,
-0.0143237431,
-0.0286173914,
-0.0263364203,
-0.0249814782,
0.0141172772,
-0.010809157,
0.0429364108,
0.0150389122,
0.0372270532,
-0.0673682019,
0.0202999096,
0.0062085404,
-0.0390395448,
-0.0258264076,
0.0028027622,
-0.0063870237,
-0.0072053825,
0.0259404145,
-0.0133797014,
0.0380057953,
0.0515216179,
-0.0283788722,
-0.0499776416,
0.0053946492,
-0.0229611695,
-0.0412399694,
0.0452409796,
0.0409844257,
0.006926354,
-0.0147767607,
-0.0124356672,
-0.0423294269,
0.0354746506,
-0.0352929831,
0.057963267,
-0.063082166,
-0.0160611402,
0.0116515504,
-0.0093849106,
-0.0353460982,
0.1087841764,
0.0137174511,
-0.0009507871,
0.0144316312,
-0.0052601183,
0.0050840518,
-0.0218768995,
-0.0091407085,
0.025640931,
-0.0004594636,
0.0302303825,
0.0488361977,
-0.0056228777,
-0.0411237888,
-0.0220645368,
-0.0839863867,
-0.0066104815,
-0.030037351,
-0.0018429236,
0.0084245028,
0.0243903287,
0.0254812166,
0.004255082,
-0.0220265929,
-0.0071941563,
0.0401611477,
0.0412127785,
0.0046960646,
0.0366033614,
-0.0338048898,
-0.0016080849,
-0.0209912136,
0.0142171513,
0.0561966226,
-0.0020298376,
0.0325844623,
-0.0441005044,
-0.0121208495,
-0.0890525281,
0.0219564643,
-0.0096079204,
0.0181386713,
0.008448435,
-0.0461033657,
0.0533102453,
0.0252890363,
0.0060599134,
-0.0004087388,
0.0340304896,
-0.0435721353,
-0.0607854351,
0.0386814103,
-0.0469895899,
-0.032795094,
-0.0071969586,
-0.0097884499,
-0.0031164233,
0.0005370469,
-0.0152577683,
-0.0191669036,
-0.0610552803,
0.0209890902,
-0.0036162627,
-0.005554867,
-0.0652663261,
-0.025675837,
0.0278856363,
0.0375885814,
-0.0360942446,
-0.0284303166,
0.0594584905,
-0.0198622122,
0.0034142304,
-0.0426906198,
0.0064843828,
-0.030288687,
0.0715695545,
-0.0180112701,
0.0367398523,
-0.0506733283,
0.0147281373,
-0.0175715368,
-0.0218652729,
0.0198982283,
-0.0652537793,
0.0487246178,
-0.0357508957,
0.052483011,
0.0222313255,
-0.0626163334,
-0.0432501175,
-0.0252670925,
-0.0096911499,
0.0178567767,
-0.0420675054,
-0.0230048243,
-0.0449743196,
-0.0007247045,
0.0610303953,
-0.0027872981,
-0.0020461106,
-0.0186559148,
0.0173557624,
0.0468004718,
0.0670495778,
0.0307210814,
0.0238784607,
0.0131472927,
0.0245001707,
0.0697913468,
0.0540016517,
-0.0479607172,
0.018066749,
-0.0044617048,
0.0263170954,
-0.0178971756,
-0.0081662871,
0.0016792293,
0.0434596129,
-0.051651299,
-0.0543434545,
0.0763367414,
0.023730902,
-0.0046867756,
-0.0166555587,
-0.0559973232,
0.0542471707,
0.0111822784,
0.0495061763,
-0.049185805,
-0.0236197524,
0.0047121188,
0.0106755374,
-0.0105824154,
-0.0264639314,
-0.0183653142,
-0.1104621887,
0.0515197515,
-0.0037963768,
-0.0268801711,
-0.0462404862,
-0.0554594621,
-0.0031668292,
0.0202539619,
0.0013550286,
0.0584496371,
-0.0031367205,
-0.0159177259,
-0.0019608813,
0.0578503832,
-0.0299150832,
0.0290180668,
-0.004618614,
-0.006343673,
0.0579509921,
0.0121677779,
0.0285441019,
-0.0540439636,
0.0335416682,
-0.0390560925,
0.0243409742,
-0.0297159906,
-0.0046031997,
0.001934772,
0.0041493885,
-0.0495798402,
0.0182830021,
-0.0426231474,
-0.0384298936,
-0.0202038232,
0.0968905538,
-0.0281231347,
0.006220459,
-0.0415281542,
0.0017232016,
0.0035080051,
0.0968653187,
0.0160674993,
0.0021121227,
-0.0255836174,
-0.0196414962,
0.0033064121,
-0.0250383504,
-0.029749766,
0.0223465282,
0.0044021495,
0.0151248537,
-0.059656959,
-0.0235639066,
-0.009995102,
0.0525422767,
-0.0328425616,
0.01714883,
-0.0216955822,
-0.0179137979,
-0.0501814261,
0.0397344902,
-0.0649545044,
-0.0205590874,
-0.0109640649,
0.0188407488,
0.0353721194,
-0.0554959401,
-0.0168371182,
0.0145268673,
-0.04278519,
-0.0385808237,
-0.0250701699,
0.0312513784,
0.0245562717,
0.047378391,
-0.042065043,
-0.0055376217,
0.0513001494,
0.0550249927,
-0.0485774539,
0.0132537447,
0.0014390369,
-0.0135420356,
-0.0118217738,
0.0590797849,
-0.0715638921,
0.0086112879,
0.0105127906,
0.0680257902,
0.0137222363,
-0.0453896634,
0.0485503785,
0.0413088724,
0.0041384096,
0.0197939444,
0.0116759501,
-0.0050983345,
0.0017347173,
-0.0494128279,
-0.043617785,
-0.0324930921,
0.0376481749,
0.0090568056,
-0.033000771,
0.0020439336,
0.0070722941,
0.0126816249,
0.0620601065,
-0.0371107198,
-0.041059725,
-0.0131598702,
-0.0225939732,
0.0312488191,
-0.0338380858,
-0.0160865355,
0.0120017137,
-0.0104917111,
0.0466351211,
-0.0367408507,
0.0451285429,
0.0383246802,
-0.0452917218,
-0.0418146029,
-0.0208529737,
-0.0805057064,
-0.0590041019,
-0.0381143279,
0.019274801,
0.042943988,
0.0048838961,
0.0465188064,
-0.0223663822,
-0.0367546864,
-0.0155376177,
-0.0106780902,
0.0651285574,
-0.0422700569,
0.0068033286,
0.0410937518,
-0.007293079,
0.0098105874,
0.0675034672,
-0.0469413064,
0.0547072478,
-0.0270871148,
-0.0466464981,
-0.025714146,
-0.0711342022,
-0.0327441134,
0.0184007306,
-0.0097947093,
0.029614117,
-0.0618610345,
-0.0487790592,
-0.0112211816,
0.0102679124,
-0.0295742191,
-0.0100840889,
0.0289745554,
0.10220249,
0.0171972793,
-0.0771650746,
-0.0244552363,
0.0456880704,
-0.0591597036,
0.0071016075,
-0.0082426546,
-6.66629532e-33,
-0.0186078064,
-0.0323619656,
0.0538605899,
-0.0628427565,
-0.0345154144,
0.0021835722,
-0.0369083285,
-0.0225622617,
-0.0429303721,
0.015463626,
-0.0133344522,
0.0438957848,
-0.0081638144,
0.0355859846,
-0.0099338815,
-0.011661144,
0.0437723622,
0.0317314938,
-0.0496360697,
0.0452679582,
0.065465197,
-0.0069068405,
0.0231351741,
-0.0190253593,
0.002130389,
-0.0229974519,
0.009038358,
0.0705890283,
-0.0293390453,
0.0685944483,
-0.0042345622,
0.0636639446,
0.0405162908,
-0.0600336455,
0.0177566018,
0.0088424692,
-0.103757754,
-0.0176896565,
0.0285128132,
-0.032890372,
-0.0367550477,
-0.021398671,
0.0339716822,
0.0052130353,
0.0219615363,
-0.0123034129,
0.0041256244,
-0.026423879,
-0.0030661926,
-0.0176870152,
-0.0425416157,
0.0186498966,
0.0136261852,
-0.0212659501,
-0.0416749567,
0.0638196915,
0.0017422002,
0.020184774,
-0.0360981598,
0.022112539,
-0.0389942043,
0.0462609567,
0.0434732363,
-0.0007588831,
-0.0035273558,
0.0331846364,
-0.034569893,
0.0085761053,
-0.0742775649,
-0.0337470733,
-0.0231254455,
0.0348285697,
0.0063889143,
0.0531744547,
0.0064650732,
0.0136448946,
-0.0822085813,
0.0359926857,
-0.0303238723,
0.0689280182,
0.0516283847,
0.0061875558,
-0.0270582251,
-0.0229018331,
-0.0462823473,
0.0463820919,
-0.0495738238,
-0.0064018215,
0.0181033723,
0.0335984342,
-0.0309083797,
-0.0028881598,
0.0421194211,
-0.033147376,
0.0104168868,
0.0795585215,
-0.034739431,
-0.0229165927,
-0.0207395237,
0.0337132439,
-0.014101278,
-0.0128433015,
0.0405014865,
0.0084964726,
-0.0546141677,
0.0275212619,
0.0113200257,
0.0004580329,
-0.0325289331,
0.0084975129,
-0.0303902645,
0.0440537483,
-0.0309195593,
-0.0373906642,
0.0481342673,
0.0483789667,
0.0179316662,
0.0567541383,
0.02875093,
0.0261457358,
-0.0003989094,
-0.0028957266,
0.0233878959,
0.0009118006,
0.0054890793,
0.0316252932,
-0.0383486114,
0.0271131396,
-0.0058860234,
-0.0529633611,
-0.034241993,
0.038670972,
2.817e-7,
0.0311800987,
0.0111649428,
0.0172296744,
0.0295623951,
0.0048971223,
0.0220957194,
0.0256459024,
-0.0043322365,
0.0284731947,
-0.0354055576,
-0.007537364,
0.0890578628,
0.0203413945,
0.0470401235,
-0.0315988474,
-0.0175443124,
-0.0792137459,
-0.0366619416,
-0.045913849,
-0.0276553798,
0.0761767626,
0.063835904,
-0.0001494144,
-0.0243901126,
0.0073517128,
-0.0967285186,
0.0798847675,
-0.0031853041,
-0.0442795195,
0.010434079,
0.0525082052,
0.0131317247,
0.0375633352,
0.017138619,
0.0017032899,
0.0166914966,
-0.0098165553,
0.0345037356,
0.0067135906,
-0.0256755408,
-0.0151603846,
-0.0281987358,
0.0201283209,
-0.0510152392,
0.0933111012,
-0.027310269,
-0.0129212774,
-0.0166050531,
-0.0386623442,
0.000311359,
-0.0004567441,
-0.0212513767,
-0.0294669382,
0.0038159096,
0.0155684547,
0.0301868245,
0.005330544,
-0.0757357106,
-0.0279388782,
0.036179401,
-0.0496670455,
-0.0425996929,
-0.0140508991,
-0.0218830258,
0.004634616,
-0.0670861676,
0.0217274632,
2.694387565e-34,
0.0357760563,
0.0286835078,
0.0026819331,
-0.0035151599,
0.0595107637,
-0.006967722,
-0.0243539084,
-0.0102803437,
0.0204569846,
-0.0965500996,
-0.0007928001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15282v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15282v2 | A Simple and Effective Framework for Strict Zero-Shot Hierarchical Classification | 2023-05-24T16:04:26 | 2023-05-26T13:57:52 | Rohan Bhambhoria, Lei Chen, Xiaodan Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have achieved strong
performance on benchmark tasks, especially in zero or few-shot settings.
However, these benchmarks often do not adequately address the challenges posed
in the real-world, such as that of hierarchical classification. In order to
address this challenge, we propose refactoring conventional tasks on
hierarchical datasets into a more indicative long-tail prediction task. We
observe LLMs are more prone to failure in these cases. To address these
limitations, we propose the use of entailment-contradiction prediction in
conjunction with LLMs, which allows for strong performance in a strict
zero-shot setting. Importantly, our method does not require any parameter
updates, a resource-intensive process and achieves strong performance across
multiple datasets. | [
0.0199449342,
0.0764543265,
-0.0007229417,
0.0700778514,
-0.0440786146,
0.0472516641,
-0.0021756589,
0.0121923164,
0.0250720978,
-0.0821963474,
-0.0051352722,
-0.0534210652,
0.0216733795,
0.0023745645,
-0.0043985196,
-0.0028170783,
0.0622830614,
-0.0004602789,
0.0081807571,
-0.0088676307,
-0.0257278625,
0.0119114956,
0.0206938311,
0.0135775255,
0.0248504933,
0.0007291902,
0.0010050025,
0.0354317427,
0.0145124644,
-0.0237084925,
0.0294519495,
0.0394832306,
0.035206642,
0.1300875992,
0.0000017035,
-0.0574145056,
0.014030572,
-0.0028527407,
-0.0588532239,
-0.0114411945,
0.0093581341,
-0.0718454123,
0.0075980462,
0.0075522936,
0.0163622908,
-0.0286273863,
0.0055480222,
0.0095931124,
0.0475445688,
0.0612670332,
-0.0041584675,
-0.048825793,
0.0204410907,
-0.0269870181,
0.0184167847,
-0.0133912703,
0.040213272,
-0.0209790859,
-0.0188109279,
0.0091537721,
0.0025143845,
0.0245651379,
0.0224152394,
0.0084220497,
-0.0320848562,
0.0293562748,
-0.0689990669,
-0.0325329863,
0.0387175456,
0.0511137359,
-0.0557718463,
-0.0462965332,
0.0162441432,
-0.0164274704,
-0.0447200797,
-0.0435988493,
-0.01332545,
0.0462647825,
-0.0104886768,
0.0402913764,
0.0407219753,
0.0009879392,
0.0397008173,
0.0105885584,
-0.0155114289,
0.0451512001,
0.0188501384,
-0.0275674406,
-0.0063965898,
0.01869471,
-0.018531695,
-0.0534222387,
-0.0416023545,
0.0235131495,
-0.0313727148,
0.0178410448,
-0.0545609072,
-0.0103639429,
0.0388830118,
-0.06629958,
0.0199706405,
0.0133111142,
0.027071489,
0.0641222447,
-0.0268753525,
0.0335109197,
-0.0051824832,
0.0032120163,
-0.0060689906,
-0.0437108614,
-0.0504268967,
-0.0006620022,
-0.0051746629,
0.0145996949,
-0.0000633462,
-0.0162572991,
-0.0437378064,
0.0168744568,
-0.0024387001,
0.0550283529,
-0.0404548831,
-0.0201223604,
-0.0258314945,
-0.0237588286,
0.0053892969,
0.0302665532,
-0.0041035158,
0.0153351752,
-0.0290246364,
-0.0250006896,
-0.0103743607,
0.0523562059,
-0.0077400943,
0.0141087873,
0.0294564161,
0.0654199719,
0.0106281759,
-0.0361695774,
-0.0495796502,
-0.0004521035,
-0.0342015475,
-0.0856420249,
0.0082510794,
-0.054993134,
0.0287075024,
-0.0251035616,
-0.0018047757,
0.0160926133,
0.0054265871,
0.03598639,
-0.0359256454,
0.0653504282,
-0.0159813687,
-0.0321522877,
0.0268898532,
0.001383228,
0.0012553596,
0.0812648758,
0.01532833,
0.0073885429,
0.0393590294,
0.042035196,
-0.010526252,
0.016163459,
-0.0013945025,
0.0277544428,
-0.0496195443,
0.0512265302,
0.0000683933,
0.0171788149,
-0.0105135171,
-0.0000917553,
-0.0070693879,
-0.0484600663,
0.0196241681,
0.0030758637,
-0.0084684649,
-0.0641592965,
0.017048547,
0.0006263791,
-0.027548492,
-0.0147207258,
-0.0522708669,
-0.015752269,
-0.0411494337,
-0.0051143346,
0.0232253801,
-0.0395849496,
-0.0450631455,
-0.0224022679,
-0.0591959544,
-0.0252103172,
-0.0412538014,
0.0057087657,
0.0329664238,
0.0082820728,
-0.0226904545,
0.018807536,
0.0578270629,
-0.0361987129,
-0.0117382882,
-0.0270790402,
0.0445828624,
0.0453777984,
0.0383212529,
-0.0259228535,
-0.0223234426,
-0.0113407746,
0.0231248569,
0.0637510419,
-0.0424258336,
-0.0229725,
0.0445851237,
-0.0296368711,
-0.0093784146,
0.007674282,
0.0452293679,
-0.0220121536,
0.0104500791,
0.0095354319,
0.025103474,
0.0010408798,
0.0083166007,
0.0443724021,
-0.0189015288,
-0.0081600435,
0.0600602627,
0.0055499543,
0.0331168361,
-0.0315794013,
-0.0347510614,
0.0001322757,
0.0177178774,
-0.0303172469,
-0.0545354933,
-0.0801730752,
-0.0081114871,
-0.109080717,
0.041513592,
-0.0104160141,
-0.0117991595,
0.0235878788,
-0.0649064556,
-0.0230139215,
-0.0061107506,
-0.0165876765,
0.0342952646,
-0.0390993468,
0.0265425052,
-0.0221537966,
0.0110332416,
-0.0292482711,
0.0602057315,
0.0043003643,
0.0280750282,
-0.0259421058,
-0.0052950042,
0.0341786072,
-0.0318432786,
-0.0384289138,
0.0275820047,
-0.0259704012,
0.0092681041,
-0.006048494,
0.000602377,
-0.0199995507,
-0.0122624841,
-0.0671138018,
0.0109629761,
-0.0178897418,
0.0163327493,
-0.0075499699,
-0.05358316,
0.0066399509,
-0.0398641676,
0.0045633153,
0.0270899199,
0.0035937463,
0.0219773538,
0.0475266576,
-0.024448622,
-0.0100362543,
-0.0196175277,
-0.0274772253,
-0.0235551186,
0.0717214718,
-0.0355987474,
0.0053863819,
-0.0005358546,
-0.0185871366,
-0.0544844158,
0.0293956529,
0.0022598968,
-0.0037139424,
-0.0136130592,
0.0009077165,
-0.0104179485,
0.0334174931,
0.0122839659,
0.0061638374,
0.0467313826,
0.0285933428,
-0.0057156929,
-0.0083331577,
-0.0092646955,
0.0026228339,
-0.0125040347,
0.0176520869,
-0.0182331372,
0.0862957612,
0.0119898105,
-0.0011657212,
-0.0511140563,
0.0208635945,
-0.0192243177,
0.02257476,
-0.0288874097,
0.0021615888,
-0.0063784923,
0.0211200807,
-0.0244313572,
-0.0302801449,
0.043257907,
-0.038498003,
0.0099987257,
-0.0069155553,
-0.0191220921,
-0.0564030781,
0.0680549592,
0.0237778034,
-0.0226909984,
0.066054374,
0.0233335197,
-0.0100710355,
-0.0081279995,
0.0259726848,
0.0083614644,
0.0393400714,
-0.0167248771,
0.0329897329,
-0.0577040203,
-0.0385574549,
-0.0379687324,
-0.0541629754,
-0.0261455234,
0.0085165873,
-0.056194555,
-0.0067424062,
-0.0381934792,
-0.0022151137,
-0.0188027062,
0.0767403916,
0.0060957037,
-0.0191343147,
-0.0322611965,
0.0410909504,
0.0668657273,
-0.0308729373,
-0.0067046839,
-0.0228460599,
0.023249317,
0.0306521077,
0.0114417318,
0.0584320389,
0.0004174506,
-0.0420496464,
0.0206007585,
0.0141535914,
-0.0472828709,
0.000670446,
-0.0344590321,
-0.0503328852,
0.0240825694,
0.1244896874,
0.0288691111,
-0.0256791301,
0.0016059874,
0.001375154,
0.06129767,
0.0365989469,
-0.0102037778,
-0.1317938268,
-0.0635818914,
0.0043192622,
0.0134879099,
0.0097957887,
-0.034798719,
0.0195883028,
-0.1158968583,
0.0463750996,
0.0121452678,
-0.0383438729,
-0.0167965386,
-0.0398591422,
0.001505226,
-0.0110240644,
-0.0033154755,
-0.000979444,
-0.0119827418,
-0.0421368517,
-0.0067694527,
-0.0310047232,
-0.0326573737,
0.080494374,
-0.0203389619,
0.0004615116,
0.004085205,
0.0379172973,
0.010669888,
-0.0040877215,
-0.013409744,
-0.0382102616,
-0.0595770963,
-0.0156460926,
0.0209719185,
-0.0523730218,
0.0119174002,
-0.0039396631,
0.0134556843,
-0.042713616,
-0.0058072698,
0.0270857643,
0.09643659,
-0.0138753811,
-0.0647821352,
-0.0334599763,
-0.0137802903,
-0.0270585064,
0.089873448,
-0.0083690332,
-0.0276229847,
-0.037174467,
-0.0123120183,
-0.035877984,
0.0022576207,
0.0188200939,
0.0323656984,
-0.0071298936,
-0.0154900532,
-0.0668939948,
-0.0104552144,
0.0032472601,
0.0248446483,
-0.0554110482,
0.0049528428,
-0.0095138391,
-0.0118125351,
-0.026970312,
-0.0423639603,
-0.047180973,
0.0268730279,
-0.0209555812,
0.0491302423,
0.0746742189,
0.0361972041,
-0.0141894966,
0.0144361081,
-0.0916301161,
-0.0593971908,
-0.0442579538,
0.0071120402,
0.0138708344,
0.0434011631,
0.0034245895,
-0.0240321271,
0.0427349769,
0.0357300118,
0.0090863975,
0.0377958119,
0.0529857874,
0.0144602917,
-0.0042481846,
0.0803438723,
-0.0515874997,
0.0087137446,
0.0090813544,
0.0003571657,
-0.0229145829,
-0.0144355875,
-0.0163303185,
-0.0224099495,
0.054297749,
-0.0188840628,
-0.0464515314,
0.004935103,
0.0444510467,
-0.0206527319,
-0.0470385253,
-0.0017776273,
0.0088065751,
0.0235354658,
-0.0196095761,
-0.0225855429,
0.0174227729,
-0.0207963586,
0.0586368181,
-0.0232283026,
0.0071756714,
0.0318726636,
0.0139486557,
0.0245549046,
-0.0172393508,
-0.0477845669,
0.0139036747,
-0.0071609374,
0.0189218111,
-0.0337241739,
0.022000581,
0.0335389152,
0.0229752734,
-0.0593770333,
-0.0255203731,
-0.0417699628,
0.0336143747,
-0.006563128,
0.0217577107,
0.0723428354,
0.0041994429,
0.0012782702,
-0.0049444265,
-0.0205697939,
-0.0282346439,
0.0356981941,
-0.0194332413,
-0.0624441095,
0.0321943089,
0.0365052782,
-0.0445861593,
0.0561791174,
0.0760097727,
0.0793007985,
0.0440428406,
0.0472906791,
0.0192826781,
-0.0484107286,
-0.0323170051,
0.0261202827,
0.0364798382,
-0.0028192473,
0.0354300924,
-0.0530631319,
-0.0738568306,
0.0353597701,
-0.0037822193,
-0.0018655757,
0.0215561576,
-0.0118341865,
0.0256327819,
0.0372115076,
-0.029482333,
-0.0435841456,
-0.0117682433,
-0.0004558363,
0.0012205545,
-0.0321321897,
-5.819163194e-33,
-0.0182355475,
0.0009599085,
0.0028419667,
-0.0045653898,
0.0191236027,
0.0009965512,
-0.0258592628,
-0.012690492,
-0.0251141284,
0.0169008318,
0.0124679608,
0.0032410598,
0.0054114256,
0.0599505566,
0.0211767014,
-0.0287237354,
0.0244870055,
-0.0047591296,
-0.012459809,
-0.0058504101,
0.0592616983,
-0.0161016081,
0.0534249768,
0.0063470355,
0.0084869657,
-0.0440953523,
0.0050803525,
0.0724623129,
-0.0169169512,
0.0319560952,
-0.0196603257,
0.0460382439,
0.0480297357,
-0.002683071,
0.0175541174,
-0.0000749176,
-0.0514245145,
-0.0130835986,
-0.0237648915,
-0.0228180252,
-0.0404828042,
-0.0092639225,
0.0076454622,
0.0168853533,
0.007661636,
-0.0820227712,
0.0004658377,
-0.0161760226,
-0.0319622606,
-0.0488765016,
-0.0764478892,
0.0630979761,
0.0130268475,
-0.0057831011,
-0.022042945,
0.0431766585,
0.0367840417,
0.0327397026,
-0.0710739791,
-0.0366755649,
0.0128186271,
0.0186370052,
0.0349770337,
0.0193591956,
-0.0013298304,
0.0670637861,
0.0014569777,
0.041264154,
-0.0320281386,
0.0030109668,
0.049501203,
0.0112046134,
0.0449584909,
0.049006369,
0.0714139268,
0.0296594147,
-0.0999383107,
-0.0173699856,
0.0223347265,
0.0332887806,
0.0147267245,
0.0324169844,
-0.0181315634,
-0.0261886176,
-0.02467007,
-0.014055267,
-0.0210848507,
-0.0065864921,
0.0111656059,
0.0286279097,
0.010325118,
-0.0008083306,
0.042487327,
-0.0465102904,
-0.0257365033,
0.0530055724,
-0.0170663334,
-0.0029201296,
0.0262831077,
0.0489844456,
-0.0598349944,
-0.028906012,
0.0262724236,
-0.0100049814,
0.016184127,
-0.0178450439,
0.0820029974,
0.0130555872,
-0.0668220073,
-0.0227448326,
-0.0048659965,
0.0054241186,
-0.0224113334,
0.0417027585,
0.0257576853,
0.0211585201,
0.0200693831,
0.0734006539,
-0.0051827002,
-0.0200471636,
-0.0075676199,
0.0754552335,
-0.0112132505,
0.0110674994,
-0.0002331255,
-0.0014269087,
-0.0366400443,
-0.0054625366,
0.011604636,
-0.0725702494,
0.0075534228,
0.0075260396,
2.362e-7,
0.0122258822,
0.0472244881,
0.0067877132,
0.0173421763,
0.0518837236,
0.0603861846,
-0.027981218,
0.0408194475,
-0.0420318916,
0.0020991571,
-0.0082039218,
-0.000470654,
0.0681492984,
0.040267285,
-0.0902807564,
0.0273586623,
-0.1107966527,
-0.0347065292,
-0.0533492602,
-0.0011605694,
0.0763782486,
0.1452120841,
0.0475456491,
-0.0184489097,
-0.0018592508,
-0.0373706818,
0.0671826303,
0.0497543849,
-0.0061803539,
0.0036487177,
-0.0324789807,
0.0309691392,
-0.0059379949,
0.0288319215,
-0.0127284108,
0.0418414809,
-0.0179017186,
0.0768016577,
-0.0384415835,
-0.004721994,
-0.0011570654,
-0.0258314144,
-0.0116336094,
-0.0497543961,
0.1098116264,
-0.0722855106,
-0.0317501463,
-0.0368115455,
0.0034115845,
0.011289374,
0.0431681797,
0.0051837289,
-0.0214497112,
0.0050886022,
0.0206150487,
-0.0219312124,
-0.0203529727,
-0.0975220129,
-0.0121396827,
0.0217808709,
-0.0481622517,
0.0130064543,
0.0038398667,
0.0018075145,
0.0488326959,
-0.0530699268,
0.0290472824,
2.229104861e-34,
0.0481628254,
-0.0236433111,
-0.0264331158,
-0.0214741174,
0.0340471044,
-0.008298141,
-0.0422092825,
0.0099683721,
0.0340251215,
-0.0451223999,
0.0268087722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15275v1 | Self-Evolution Learning for Discriminative Language Model Pretraining | 2023-05-24T16:00:54 | 2023-05-24T16:00:54 | Qihuang Zhong, Liang Ding, Juhua Liu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Masked language modeling, widely used in discriminative language model (e.g.,
BERT) pretraining, commonly adopts a random masking strategy. However, random
masking does not consider the importance of the different words in the sentence
meaning, where some of them are more worthy to be predicted. Therefore, various
masking strategies (e.g., entity-level masking) are proposed, but most of them
require expensive prior knowledge and generally train from scratch without
reusing existing model weights. In this paper, we present Self-Evolution
learning (SE), a simple and effective token masking and learning method to
fully and wisely exploit the knowledge from data. SE focuses on learning the
informative yet under-explored tokens and adaptively regularizes the training
by introducing a novel Token-specific Label Smoothing approach. Experiments on
10 tasks show that our SE brings consistent and significant improvements
(+1.43~2.12 average scores) upon different PLMs. In-depth analyses demonstrate
that SE improves linguistic knowledge learning and generalization. | [
0.012367445,
0.010966517,
0.000570631,
0.0423494503,
-0.0115971444,
0.0048993016,
0.0060849804,
0.0193902049,
0.0266232211,
-0.0560017005,
-0.0441966616,
0.0436239392,
-0.0678225905,
0.0507296175,
0.0351803526,
-0.025019018,
0.0608696342,
-0.0152365416,
0.0389048569,
-0.0151938889,
0.004910998,
-0.0208377279,
-0.0129221249,
0.0149722416,
-0.0452411659,
0.0004647029,
0.0207308494,
0.0007793805,
0.0157669503,
-0.0049421913,
0.0484480187,
0.0547686294,
0.0172557849,
0.0322333388,
0.0000019344,
-0.1026075706,
-0.0492353775,
-0.0184067506,
-0.0230314881,
0.0202469118,
0.049524311,
0.0577153973,
-0.0017116516,
0.0099710673,
-0.0441968702,
0.0008452708,
0.0071362336,
0.0368648581,
0.0531851351,
0.0383512378,
-0.0206538104,
-0.0293390322,
-0.0228828266,
-0.0208193585,
-0.0138573861,
-0.0483360812,
0.0515893213,
-0.0583316609,
-0.0607774518,
-0.0273448061,
-0.0347660296,
0.0199786518,
-0.0329588056,
0.0084538851,
0.0481798947,
0.0414670184,
-0.0183626972,
-0.0304930732,
0.0042910012,
0.0471137054,
-0.0476710238,
-0.036923971,
0.0095501682,
0.0062067066,
0.0405198298,
-0.0248528011,
-0.0024200906,
-0.0391645245,
0.0177448727,
0.040813148,
0.0235853922,
-0.0345977172,
-0.0022365116,
0.0276944134,
-0.0592265576,
0.0673756227,
0.0283640251,
-0.0332974233,
-0.0290214419,
-0.0449852012,
0.0007200079,
-0.0281411447,
0.0436530747,
0.0245036315,
0.0159241781,
0.0287373308,
-0.0576993935,
-0.0722047836,
0.0244486183,
-0.0312884934,
-0.0119940303,
0.0207776856,
-0.05925541,
0.0567851625,
-0.0727014989,
0.0199265927,
0.0238460414,
0.0539652333,
-0.0492880158,
-0.0082360823,
-0.0204939786,
-0.0223779455,
-0.0793249384,
0.0793904215,
-0.0247580558,
-0.004367047,
-0.0295645837,
0.009846732,
0.0178760067,
-0.032372199,
0.0338875875,
-0.0116395568,
-0.0314946547,
0.0110253887,
0.0052926228,
-0.0284209009,
-0.0210311208,
0.0062599215,
-0.0236072838,
-0.011655638,
-0.0243534204,
-0.0187679268,
0.0397899672,
-0.0201751366,
0.030166598,
0.0657229871,
-0.018996885,
-0.0637210682,
-0.0686891675,
0.0445647798,
-0.0376025103,
0.0058882548,
-0.004079741,
-0.0173624493,
0.0143356789,
-0.0244902726,
0.0066514174,
-0.0501980782,
-0.0073608696,
-0.0473082587,
-0.0126455845,
0.0674631447,
-0.0858854949,
0.0004608638,
0.0673094392,
0.0115255583,
0.0038209013,
0.0764113441,
0.0168242231,
-0.0043333997,
0.0508901104,
-0.0073345331,
0.0145385442,
0.0495629683,
0.0473703258,
0.0067072371,
0.0042625354,
-0.0225521289,
0.016577905,
-0.0075820498,
0.0369863324,
0.0338177793,
-0.0352555104,
-0.0508427285,
0.0356755406,
0.0429629646,
0.0308306105,
0.04726886,
0.0231012534,
0.0294910986,
-0.0032000863,
-0.0122111933,
0.0150075098,
-0.0202742796,
-0.0243588127,
-0.0113747567,
0.0025068375,
-0.0010739879,
-0.0325335339,
-0.0351544395,
-0.0128187481,
-0.0117402179,
0.0134812519,
-0.0104875956,
0.0535578243,
0.0449087955,
-0.0334854051,
0.0790582448,
0.0324991941,
-0.0139675764,
0.0258558448,
-0.1010387763,
0.0271526277,
0.0440643653,
0.0147607848,
-0.0768575817,
-0.0611662865,
0.019468369,
0.0315331928,
0.0269022267,
0.024753144,
-0.0202150419,
0.0422189832,
-0.0479796343,
-0.0355343521,
-0.0375663042,
-0.0023047766,
0.0253197793,
-0.0024941748,
0.0033920505,
0.0189009234,
-0.0631957352,
0.0219081286,
0.0840443969,
-0.0005839415,
-0.0633622408,
0.064984411,
0.0075508207,
0.0370581448,
0.0019956457,
-0.0178176071,
-0.0031451457,
0.019749295,
-0.0210327171,
-0.0293074697,
0.0172051471,
-0.0381264426,
-0.0535205677,
0.0525070801,
-0.0161447357,
-0.0030251411,
0.0019990713,
-0.0212456845,
-0.0449674726,
0.0064094947,
-0.0354486369,
0.0830882192,
-0.0669444874,
0.0402459092,
-0.0197682455,
0.0314612575,
-0.0308058895,
0.0643847361,
0.0166193452,
-0.0107436907,
-0.0129683046,
0.0041042822,
0.0430231169,
-0.0146835782,
-0.0334025472,
-0.0465642214,
-0.0229188111,
-0.0216310974,
-0.0103670368,
0.02069626,
-0.0689581856,
0.0038568769,
-0.0809735581,
-0.0239192229,
-0.0196223874,
0.0273172371,
0.004094772,
0.0027359524,
-0.0416558869,
-0.0460198633,
-0.0016001915,
-0.0455595329,
-0.0371277072,
-0.0045991922,
0.0249536671,
-0.0033691935,
-0.0204055458,
-0.0269478504,
-0.0071766367,
-0.0274263974,
0.0343794487,
-0.0163269639,
-0.0309506729,
-0.0481338575,
-0.0149132945,
-0.0212454814,
0.0680511743,
0.0053315009,
-0.022418322,
-0.0241014753,
-0.0085199438,
0.0564623401,
0.0430915616,
0.0441628918,
-0.001910544,
0.0305545516,
-0.0139697129,
-0.0381076373,
0.0376676433,
-0.0300098453,
0.0406172536,
-0.0104692578,
0.0013988732,
0.0401593,
0.0672059134,
-0.0132968063,
-0.0481245704,
-0.0455543175,
-0.0058336034,
-0.022324359,
-0.0643248856,
-0.0143980309,
0.0055601732,
-0.0434169918,
-0.0368884951,
-0.0222632159,
-0.0153006827,
0.0838232934,
-0.0246636923,
-0.0127016883,
-0.0581184477,
0.0029089288,
-0.0347734652,
0.0391461477,
0.0052828174,
0.0280010477,
0.0063095479,
-0.0388137586,
-0.0204505511,
-0.0043056998,
0.0015371328,
-0.0308074709,
0.0096780099,
-0.0417530201,
0.0212849434,
0.0270814076,
-0.0263816956,
-0.0261396691,
-0.0604320727,
0.0063954545,
0.0036289052,
0.0103137959,
0.0264463052,
0.008163128,
0.0165641308,
-0.005300344,
0.066781953,
0.0160214249,
0.001519784,
-0.0001893739,
0.0160312559,
0.0316309892,
0.0047262888,
0.0134149194,
-0.0016462356,
0.0231994074,
0.0192344245,
0.065020293,
-0.0234216359,
-0.0154975038,
0.0405078158,
0.042396374,
-0.0570073985,
-0.0003087288,
-0.0092246663,
0.035720069,
-0.0017306601,
-0.0074454029,
0.1164347604,
0.0297977999,
0.0064495457,
0.0101607135,
-0.0468396209,
0.0167824905,
0.0438902564,
0.0382109098,
-0.0435469858,
-0.0185860228,
0.000955868,
0.0143609531,
0.006246041,
-0.0355777033,
0.006391427,
-0.0719643012,
-0.010833337,
-0.0068198862,
-0.0535236672,
0.0384531878,
-0.0452153683,
0.0015634686,
-0.0253338199,
0.0021014055,
0.0138705997,
0.0041879108,
-0.039765358,
0.0325320549,
-0.0364983343,
-0.0297828373,
0.0232346561,
-0.0530408472,
0.0265082866,
0.0392032638,
0.027389124,
-0.0183979496,
-0.0587100685,
0.0637159646,
-0.0100320727,
-0.024370797,
-0.025965523,
0.0368376672,
-0.0417163037,
-0.0243329592,
0.0223765802,
0.0178473275,
-0.0056797503,
-0.0132152503,
0.0027233027,
0.0106953559,
0.0339834429,
-0.0119801974,
-0.0196063854,
-0.0456360467,
-0.0103674578,
0.0459824428,
0.0104839662,
-0.0645239353,
-0.0020613319,
-0.0124697527,
0.0334806181,
-0.0462529399,
0.0306238774,
0.0247264225,
-0.0499740653,
-0.0190467834,
-0.0728190094,
0.0087229675,
0.0409704633,
0.0621112697,
0.0355704762,
0.0173348151,
-0.0399650112,
-0.0111154485,
-0.0556103811,
-0.0009951078,
-0.0488090478,
-0.0196533501,
-0.036133904,
-0.0406762324,
0.0551149696,
-0.0109431725,
-0.038754154,
-0.000689448,
-0.0468439646,
-0.0526430719,
0.0429911166,
0.0782700032,
0.0065924698,
0.0531944595,
-0.0220262073,
-0.0815117881,
0.0863730907,
0.0465196483,
-0.0256657917,
-0.0138550578,
0.0235339236,
-0.0211147591,
-0.0101149296,
0.0022714045,
-0.0522711687,
0.0151968095,
0.0516317636,
0.0600924976,
-0.0010646271,
-0.0037389824,
0.019577818,
0.0306701139,
0.0546195917,
-0.0564871915,
0.0133077437,
-0.0445347726,
0.0365200527,
0.0054867463,
-0.0218545571,
-0.0131825395,
-0.0057245693,
-0.0060465736,
-0.0132228015,
-0.0154465791,
0.0558947101,
-0.0293876547,
0.0162928663,
-0.0023308955,
-0.015976876,
-0.0183707718,
0.0123870634,
-0.0084249908,
-0.0170930307,
0.0061656833,
0.0124416724,
0.0600546561,
-0.0138179706,
-0.0233131852,
0.0251700021,
0.015193468,
0.0215795934,
-0.0155195808,
0.0318318531,
-0.0098893028,
0.0213815439,
-0.0742684454,
0.0435489863,
0.0432306305,
-0.0125687663,
0.0109451255,
0.0059678396,
-0.0294942968,
-0.0082449345,
-0.0170216057,
-0.0316923968,
-0.0098611526,
0.0309218448,
-0.0011142177,
-0.0243588146,
0.0147665078,
0.0749182627,
0.0405806452,
0.0600354224,
-0.0141408881,
0.0033871781,
-0.0640758947,
0.0112138782,
0.0480076894,
0.0233250391,
-0.0131011242,
0.0054583135,
-0.0159455314,
-0.0706275776,
0.0252196211,
0.01274742,
0.0150125027,
0.0300954152,
0.065531373,
0.0621881001,
-0.014686483,
-0.0587407611,
-0.0139758894,
-0.0147361634,
0.0928326845,
-0.0091033587,
0.045738589,
-6.507585215e-33,
-0.0272375718,
-0.006769632,
0.0147295361,
0.0049629542,
0.023068171,
-0.0055680112,
-0.002429212,
-0.0116143329,
-0.0197055731,
-0.0093972096,
-0.0279501509,
0.008036796,
0.0264685322,
0.0222179685,
-0.0541251339,
0.0022135831,
0.04595837,
-0.0027807953,
0.0051461468,
-0.0251133926,
-0.0216267016,
0.094220832,
0.0563635342,
-0.032739073,
-0.0182194244,
0.0353749134,
-0.0112209776,
0.0329521485,
0.0069944132,
0.0620334595,
-0.0342805535,
0.029024804,
0.0061321552,
-0.0148646645,
-0.021350652,
-0.0421014801,
-0.1196110994,
-0.0344018526,
-0.0165798068,
0.0177576505,
-0.0382180326,
-0.0013329964,
0.0476375185,
0.0162409488,
-0.0428150818,
0.0710736141,
0.0521810465,
-0.0159384999,
-0.0083760433,
-0.0494033806,
-0.0367078446,
0.0297707897,
-0.0013481701,
-0.0267418437,
0.048755426,
-0.0568197854,
0.0229534637,
-0.0262095351,
-0.0399825014,
0.0162509531,
0.0222859923,
0.0044925269,
0.0289923809,
0.0482520312,
0.0356607437,
0.0173705351,
0.060043361,
-0.0118358517,
0.0265880302,
-0.0351710208,
0.0842387378,
0.0308315866,
0.0307681989,
-0.0244091023,
-0.0119109498,
-0.029665282,
-0.0443209596,
0.0363539346,
-0.0417963266,
0.0018384589,
-0.0047634495,
0.0443746932,
0.0222363081,
-0.00747255,
-0.0362077653,
0.0091993092,
-0.0412802808,
0.0284013227,
0.0126440581,
0.0426633544,
-0.0757090673,
0.0033911241,
0.0141129326,
-0.0375390761,
-0.0416871384,
-0.0176528767,
0.0118753994,
-0.0324340053,
0.0012923552,
0.0580345206,
-0.0485186689,
-0.0588049293,
0.0297363251,
0.0037443193,
0.0191075411,
-0.0280761942,
0.035603486,
0.0070750862,
-0.0552241355,
0.0231019091,
-0.0158507861,
-0.0219230484,
0.0230541583,
0.0134564694,
0.0158614442,
0.0089283297,
0.0149133252,
0.0097450837,
0.0971673578,
-0.0264592953,
-0.0312262699,
0.0534660779,
0.0293017067,
0.0435420424,
-0.0129144602,
-0.0049675857,
0.024998175,
0.0163716245,
0.0146876769,
-0.0508589707,
-0.02105131,
0.0133721922,
2.666e-7,
0.0519135892,
0.0480183139,
0.0378988646,
-0.0367720351,
0.0155246537,
0.040266484,
0.0016231657,
0.0255773254,
0.0230699349,
0.0187880173,
0.0196035858,
-0.0013028404,
0.0043796641,
0.0006086026,
-0.1110762581,
-0.0064922757,
-0.019509716,
0.0223125666,
-0.052457083,
0.0199987311,
0.0124712978,
0.0917489007,
0.0487207286,
-0.0163909532,
-0.0168159995,
-0.062380299,
0.055115182,
-0.0074839848,
0.0380265974,
0.0534666404,
-0.001295637,
0.0561316945,
-0.0215606038,
0.0406179614,
-0.0396235771,
0.0593663082,
0.0270846784,
0.048425924,
-0.0321460627,
-0.0320893563,
0.0253233388,
0.04457644,
0.0078947442,
-0.0578799583,
0.086893566,
-0.0393277071,
-0.0019878368,
-0.0284071006,
-0.0243879128,
-0.0081322007,
0.0141696176,
-0.0664006397,
-0.0617680661,
0.040628586,
0.0300772674,
0.0146772917,
-0.0517280474,
-0.1196290478,
0.0077537526,
-0.0045376956,
-0.0655705631,
-0.0070870752,
-0.0160753913,
0.0417649783,
0.0147299338,
-0.0371177197,
0.0500684716,
2.068058002e-34,
-0.0080208071,
-0.0350649729,
-0.0043856599,
0.04777807,
0.0134122092,
-0.0175034087,
0.0252782665,
0.0007215666,
-0.0064388318,
-0.040457122,
-0.0210636333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15273v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15273v1 | Revisiting Token Dropping Strategy in Efficient BERT Pretraining | 2023-05-24T15:59:44 | 2023-05-24T15:59:44 | Qihuang Zhong, Liang Ding, Juhua Liu, Xuebo Liu, Min Zhang, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Token dropping is a recently-proposed strategy to speed up the pretraining of
masked language models, such as BERT, by skipping the computation of a subset
of the input tokens at several middle layers. It can effectively reduce the
training time without degrading much performance on downstream tasks. However,
we empirically find that token dropping is prone to a semantic loss problem and
falls short in handling semantic-intense tasks. Motivated by this, we propose a
simple yet effective semantic-consistent learning method (ScTD) to improve the
token dropping. ScTD aims to encourage the model to learn how to preserve the
semantic information in the representation space. Extensive experiments on 12
tasks show that, with the help of our ScTD, token dropping can achieve
consistent and significant performance gains across all task types and model
sizes. More encouragingly, ScTD saves up to 57% of pretraining time and brings
up to +1.56% average improvement over the vanilla token dropping. | [
0.0067484635,
0.0499499105,
0.0042883046,
0.0157140158,
-0.0282494873,
-0.0016729655,
-0.0003665098,
-0.0015725876,
-0.0517920926,
-0.0381125063,
-0.0399237052,
0.0210880041,
-0.001393245,
0.0179047734,
0.0221223161,
-0.0643601492,
0.0787160769,
0.0104685398,
0.0165520348,
-0.0094067333,
0.021252824,
-0.0132913226,
-0.0155746136,
0.0473781079,
-0.0753088295,
-0.0039540105,
0.0024115427,
0.0108834626,
0.0085586663,
-0.0102435444,
0.0159978662,
0.0367578752,
0.0162904859,
0.0469508991,
0.0000020075,
-0.0514228791,
-0.0155792963,
-0.0106205419,
-0.0274155475,
0.0495161191,
0.005092985,
-0.0008766941,
-0.0009091841,
0.0366687328,
-0.0111403065,
-0.0255199354,
0.0470562354,
0.0620286427,
0.0621967241,
0.0540131703,
-0.0131591773,
0.0043174583,
0.0007771864,
-0.0247586463,
-0.0094690947,
-0.0247609261,
0.0174559802,
-0.0719416514,
-0.0645475686,
-0.0587127395,
-0.0205019917,
0.0165754426,
0.0183461402,
0.0282810964,
0.0103208227,
0.0762456134,
-0.0808234066,
-0.0274719447,
-0.0123302564,
0.0475407615,
-0.0464618988,
-0.0361077338,
0.0088102678,
-0.0014364746,
-0.0128385592,
-0.0275661442,
-0.0103217522,
-0.0024685734,
0.01269037,
0.0315073691,
-0.0123209897,
-0.0269856304,
0.0239507817,
0.0187170804,
-0.0660623387,
0.0347874574,
0.0403379537,
-0.0442090183,
-0.0071381917,
-0.0012035888,
-0.057077799,
-0.0491588898,
0.0316228122,
0.0067261495,
-0.0124689685,
0.018604273,
-0.0728617907,
-0.0752279758,
0.0004430079,
-0.0151255233,
-0.0001304234,
0.0743091106,
-0.0327944271,
0.0151995858,
-0.0674099922,
0.0477160737,
0.0077761961,
0.0703361332,
-0.0343838669,
-0.0126428241,
-0.0162699055,
-0.0258560702,
-0.1172135323,
0.0782606378,
-0.0338898636,
-0.0473269895,
-0.026090648,
0.0264994539,
-0.0040181489,
0.0021822918,
0.0159062576,
-0.004745028,
-0.0372249112,
0.0285330992,
0.0119682709,
0.0082806777,
-0.0386892445,
0.0210217386,
-0.0026557527,
-0.0310256854,
-0.0278090667,
0.0090583302,
0.0244910028,
-0.0367602445,
0.018633958,
0.0695472881,
-0.0148556959,
-0.0408722088,
-0.0220511593,
0.027701918,
-0.0023375938,
-0.0295985322,
0.0003110702,
-0.0149950245,
0.0291639883,
-0.0200256612,
0.0147821074,
-0.0120193362,
-0.0248325467,
0.0026497443,
0.0024483441,
0.0747159645,
-0.0361645669,
-0.023290772,
0.0446992591,
0.0132543035,
-0.0309418235,
0.0530582257,
0.0161320753,
0.0066920719,
0.0229262356,
-0.0031965529,
-0.0267305616,
0.0407179445,
0.0645831004,
-0.0225365907,
-0.0178514477,
-0.0237516575,
0.033171609,
0.029770188,
0.0511710458,
0.0609923862,
-0.0709098205,
-0.0128763337,
0.0323355198,
0.0484815389,
0.0011145645,
0.0298004784,
0.0387869924,
0.0098317759,
0.01200906,
0.0127114402,
-0.041826725,
-0.0187841319,
0.0209412761,
0.000789009,
-0.0068948902,
-0.0159266219,
-0.0426047221,
0.0004729275,
-0.0044073835,
-0.0162797663,
0.0048475042,
-0.0270982701,
0.0303195771,
0.0373845883,
-0.068144694,
0.1307925284,
0.0240162443,
-0.0514256619,
0.0208125394,
-0.0654854178,
0.0144004505,
0.0386228301,
0.0158623066,
-0.0381931476,
-0.0617060959,
0.0387240127,
0.0315950885,
0.0169323049,
0.0121962102,
-0.0026725107,
0.0547755286,
-0.0429523028,
-0.0241797324,
-0.0151344733,
0.0108669279,
0.0280889515,
0.0148199005,
0.0116305575,
0.0016084131,
-0.0584769063,
0.0333476663,
0.0594929904,
0.0260528494,
-0.0340951458,
0.0090658795,
0.0353644826,
0.0335221142,
-0.0041354597,
-0.0370090306,
0.0226015747,
0.0468302295,
-0.0393429846,
-0.0075999596,
0.0002654132,
-0.0861866772,
-0.0555990003,
0.0194479078,
-0.0175213814,
-0.0099231005,
0.0772419646,
-0.0284010842,
-0.0303526223,
-0.0048745922,
-0.0464036092,
0.1210992932,
-0.0633252412,
0.0152657721,
-0.0095132766,
-0.0002520747,
-0.0119722495,
0.0291378163,
-0.0130458446,
0.0091242986,
0.0030101377,
0.0376069844,
0.0149076935,
-0.0530029275,
-0.0156335514,
0.0121606486,
-0.0131715694,
0.0126989782,
0.0178977977,
0.0131810261,
-0.037011154,
-0.0192346908,
-0.1299132556,
-0.0175285023,
-0.0243364759,
0.0265015513,
0.0118080713,
0.0146241654,
-0.0248198546,
-0.0247123316,
0.0082873208,
-0.0450298078,
-0.0595183596,
0.0132040847,
0.0173783302,
0.0119844135,
-0.0218301881,
-0.0124017745,
-0.0057909046,
0.0009454953,
0.0353123322,
-0.0353521369,
-0.0264660958,
-0.0199461654,
-0.0291870236,
-0.0368335955,
0.0498596653,
0.0075147701,
-0.0363350846,
0.0090992544,
0.0076051881,
0.0463833995,
0.0299726278,
0.0195272136,
0.0322126001,
0.016664112,
-0.0026779801,
-0.0662293732,
0.0331791155,
-0.0251978673,
0.0185747147,
-0.0032726247,
0.0019413313,
0.0348089039,
0.0706926659,
-0.006569929,
0.016980106,
-0.0704077631,
-0.0227162894,
-0.023508219,
-0.0420992523,
-0.0384891741,
-0.0348533466,
-0.0503935404,
-0.0319464915,
-0.0425683483,
-0.0283233542,
0.0615897253,
-0.0566891842,
-0.0095031457,
-0.0640567616,
0.0251319688,
-0.0019650264,
0.0160689633,
-0.0061150575,
0.0316230766,
0.0021413139,
-0.0659171492,
-0.030465886,
-0.0098449476,
0.0011844598,
0.0045453473,
-0.0067806668,
-0.0112365512,
0.0062993364,
-0.0028044733,
-0.0432811864,
-0.0352861322,
-0.041905988,
-0.0208889078,
0.027794363,
0.0138043193,
-0.0259032715,
-0.0184499044,
-0.0269975271,
-0.0009317129,
0.0694876164,
0.0109059326,
0.0154435216,
-0.0290121641,
0.0431976467,
0.0175721813,
-0.0096006114,
-0.014690211,
-0.0350499116,
0.0018645908,
0.0639569759,
0.1000667289,
0.0111738583,
-0.0277447645,
0.025593413,
0.0352824628,
-0.0434825756,
-0.0062886821,
-0.0126389386,
0.0271646343,
-0.015255929,
-0.003152302,
0.1264804304,
0.0201956928,
0.0099417791,
-0.0031010967,
0.0013309222,
0.0541272387,
0.0003278783,
-0.0022954668,
-0.0630724207,
-0.0506937541,
0.0269092713,
0.0246745665,
0.0190069638,
-0.0136351902,
0.0060951095,
-0.06634406,
-0.0095709777,
-0.0180777963,
-0.0800490305,
0.0165062882,
-0.0643104091,
-0.0085846744,
-0.0058392594,
0.0732735619,
-0.0130743422,
0.0033707449,
-0.0225556232,
0.0568712652,
-0.0174724162,
0.0048927367,
0.0339809433,
-0.067550391,
-0.003305306,
0.0617005117,
0.040476419,
-0.0119563024,
-0.0527036041,
0.0832416713,
0.0004858187,
-0.0138610275,
-0.0263598226,
0.0401202925,
-0.0684556067,
-0.0250306707,
0.0154520143,
0.0050672237,
0.0086756796,
-0.0162527598,
-0.0129735759,
0.0453467928,
0.0188023765,
-0.0166795775,
0.0014929797,
-0.0099934936,
-0.0236110743,
0.0799632445,
0.0433959998,
-0.0618477464,
-0.019421773,
0.0137723135,
0.0325744376,
-0.0480534397,
0.0616160184,
0.0016310654,
-0.0619637407,
-0.0391415805,
-0.0626209155,
-0.0204054341,
0.0510582849,
0.0638324022,
0.0048519983,
-0.0041360781,
-0.0111986184,
0.0004122516,
-0.0608873442,
0.0454766415,
-0.013334916,
0.0133512272,
-0.0631152838,
-0.0140699353,
0.0241500065,
0.0050923419,
-0.0276516192,
-0.0129177067,
-0.0306093786,
-0.041019123,
0.0292477161,
0.0381315947,
0.0157962218,
0.0805331096,
-0.007592014,
-0.0281110555,
0.077295512,
0.0319445431,
-0.0268084332,
0.018728245,
0.0538364798,
-0.0269025061,
0.0161371473,
0.0293198992,
-0.0471805856,
-0.0086137233,
0.0386903994,
0.0571592934,
0.0173525102,
0.0526422933,
0.0200074296,
0.026985148,
0.0874185264,
-0.0200596545,
0.0087939836,
-0.0296026282,
0.040857628,
-0.0031155145,
-0.0062854183,
-0.0419878997,
0.0216276404,
-0.0077467873,
0.0459369943,
-0.0233415533,
0.0507964119,
0.0056150109,
0.0373829938,
-0.0213116687,
-0.0126650827,
-0.0266655236,
0.040728081,
0.0312022772,
-0.0063679977,
-0.0284069553,
-0.0341562852,
-0.0060022771,
-0.0266237296,
-0.0441793315,
0.0023744381,
0.0696856976,
0.0168373473,
-0.0409952514,
0.0409120768,
-0.0249382686,
-0.0328289382,
-0.0564057007,
0.0228495393,
0.0332682841,
0.0012083502,
0.0098461797,
-0.0293274652,
-0.0289610811,
0.0030129841,
0.0118729472,
-0.0034538717,
-0.0213517193,
0.0215232819,
-0.0013417121,
-0.011399054,
-0.0332648829,
0.0374829359,
0.0111254836,
0.061466217,
-0.0114503363,
0.0054766047,
-0.0443781689,
0.0008645051,
0.0660434365,
0.0509610586,
-0.0277293622,
-0.0100909108,
-0.018039437,
-0.0618755035,
0.0366689935,
-0.0002347927,
-0.0029147759,
0.0206107888,
0.0685427338,
0.0460733995,
-0.0076374072,
-0.0422151051,
0.0152329328,
-0.0176024828,
0.064454481,
-0.0300292205,
0.0175261442,
-6.281254798e-33,
-0.0130430218,
0.040111959,
0.0172928497,
-0.0061242818,
-0.0486172736,
0.0345817395,
-0.0346885361,
-0.0297506694,
0.0007059621,
0.0136361951,
-0.0120783402,
0.0128773302,
0.0323831253,
0.0268375576,
-0.0460350886,
-0.0056508831,
0.070535399,
-0.0130900424,
-0.0456451587,
-0.0064545302,
0.0139985168,
0.0661674514,
0.0542369112,
-0.0007899904,
-0.0315702781,
0.0297653768,
-0.0042955847,
0.0329036601,
0.0220647473,
0.0304641631,
-0.0296758153,
0.0199644081,
0.0030299099,
-0.0060802819,
-0.0325146429,
0.0495276079,
-0.1225863248,
-0.0466917232,
0.009380036,
0.0330268666,
-0.0463453084,
-0.001499082,
0.0314930156,
0.0006661885,
-0.0212514289,
0.0381395258,
0.0128916483,
0.024866052,
-0.0529441275,
-0.0310624391,
-0.0591182262,
0.0109604476,
0.0130313924,
-0.0349813066,
0.0181484371,
-0.0145543618,
0.0090833949,
-0.0166311674,
-0.0479793921,
-0.0206035245,
-0.005061788,
0.0101576354,
0.0283233877,
0.04235176,
0.0114246933,
0.0576211624,
0.066373609,
-0.028394755,
0.0167792123,
-0.0074036936,
0.0968641117,
0.0019450132,
0.0135995485,
-0.0439744256,
0.0394850858,
-0.0391955189,
-0.048912067,
0.005748421,
-0.0177653003,
0.0397156551,
0.0027118279,
0.043760214,
0.0015312694,
-0.012131216,
-0.0395429991,
0.0141396588,
-0.0396456085,
0.0224144813,
0.0331267156,
0.0380308032,
-0.036451336,
0.0132069243,
0.0250168163,
-0.0051697106,
0.0002899911,
0.0003454194,
0.0117574558,
-0.0093412753,
-0.0070734946,
0.0392846353,
-0.0614768378,
-0.0606089234,
0.0325268582,
0.005520876,
0.0177691281,
-0.0209387243,
0.057687059,
0.0294391736,
-0.0500432774,
-0.00377467,
-0.0566992126,
-0.0135334432,
-0.0003940809,
0.0134531911,
0.0402509645,
0.0254089814,
0.0085208546,
0.0043655764,
0.018729968,
-0.0219189189,
-0.0430463552,
0.0348870605,
0.0261971299,
0.050047636,
-0.0086656241,
-0.0141296359,
-0.0197754372,
0.0009093606,
0.0225900523,
-0.0744548738,
-0.0304703899,
-0.0125171086,
2.674e-7,
0.0198597983,
0.0114752678,
0.0438968763,
-0.0228047203,
0.0002313205,
0.0187641867,
-0.0214986298,
0.0738965943,
-0.0083873775,
0.0515906624,
0.0138037195,
-0.0023778998,
0.020920543,
-0.0063445172,
-0.1073397025,
-0.0223528259,
-0.0697075352,
0.0046135802,
-0.0385848545,
0.024332827,
0.010179515,
0.0906941667,
0.0165492631,
-0.0223236065,
0.0155092385,
-0.020398913,
0.0651502311,
-0.0282474849,
0.0392398052,
0.0108711431,
-0.004786937,
0.0208974276,
0.0154689448,
0.0030862156,
-0.0377986729,
0.0101104584,
0.0512763634,
0.0481954291,
-0.0258413088,
-0.0510713942,
0.0053199087,
0.0248605832,
-0.0105189886,
-0.0307660718,
0.051700905,
-0.0554815382,
0.0185578242,
0.0195683129,
-0.0421827137,
0.026335353,
0.0013912009,
-0.0285984837,
-0.0546015389,
0.0524458997,
0.0432834662,
-0.000085061,
-0.0382964797,
-0.1035237461,
-0.0169805586,
-0.0196625758,
-0.0569383837,
-0.0515656807,
-0.0353081413,
-0.0085174432,
0.0315207019,
-0.0794405937,
-0.0108929742,
2.368964352e-34,
0.0082421079,
-0.0404691175,
0.0143045643,
0.058594346,
0.00101255,
-0.0220105387,
0.038591519,
-0.0020696805,
0.0038845844,
-0.0170253925,
-0.0156817194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15269v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15269v3 | Testing the General Deductive Reasoning Capacity of Large Language Models Using OOD Examples | 2023-05-24T15:55:51 | 2023-11-03T18:45:56 | Abulhair Saparov, Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Vishakh Padmakumar, Nitish Joshi, Seyed Mehran Kazemi, Najoung Kim, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Given the intractably large size of the space of proofs, any model that is
capable of general deductive reasoning must generalize to proofs of greater
complexity. Recent studies have shown that large language models (LLMs) possess
some abstract deductive reasoning ability given chain-of-thought prompts.
However, they have primarily been tested on proofs using modus ponens or of a
specific size, and from the same distribution as the in-context examples. To
measure the general deductive reasoning ability of LLMs, we test on a broad set
of deduction rules and measure their ability to generalize to more complex
proofs from simpler demonstrations from multiple angles: depth-, width-, and
compositional generalization. To facilitate systematic exploration, we
construct a new synthetic and programmable reasoning dataset that enables
control over deduction rules and proof complexity. Our experiments on four LLMs
of various sizes and training objectives show that they are able to generalize
to compositional proofs. However, they have difficulty generalizing to longer
proofs, and they require explicit demonstrations to produce hypothetical
subproofs, specifically in proof by cases and proof by contradiction. | [
0.0292940866,
0.062407434,
0.0013612586,
0.0480045229,
-0.0394708961,
0.0296748783,
0.0224795379,
-0.027461268,
0.0024833502,
-0.0073572877,
0.0108941086,
0.0387567952,
0.0126545075,
-0.0027861877,
0.0253905393,
-0.0642905831,
0.0095204059,
-0.0686952546,
0.0174366757,
-0.0203204397,
0.002672852,
0.0023402525,
-0.0195671879,
0.0081932778,
0.0074816402,
-0.0351124741,
-0.0123520633,
0.0015055138,
0.0000182476,
-0.0216791816,
-0.0384074748,
0.0493499674,
0.0391202681,
0.0719950795,
0.0000021172,
-0.0654824451,
0.0175176449,
0.0116685973,
-0.0930055305,
0.0277973656,
-0.031073058,
-0.0252387803,
0.0044349516,
0.0070227305,
-0.0130876992,
-0.0283790361,
0.0231458507,
0.0535329394,
0.0430081598,
0.092229791,
0.0105941463,
-0.0835398883,
0.0462918356,
-0.028170215,
0.0086688753,
-0.0185469724,
0.031577412,
0.0599976815,
0.0553289689,
-0.0153316269,
0.0158630069,
0.0144809196,
0.0695380941,
0.0078689652,
-0.0853191689,
0.0436434522,
-0.0468117036,
-0.0014502801,
0.0176426321,
0.0583272092,
-0.0146580935,
-0.0469267629,
-0.0379618816,
0.0197528824,
0.0151863107,
-0.0025658826,
-0.0319217443,
0.0680003017,
-0.0382721871,
-0.0056219506,
0.0392848887,
-0.0064619905,
0.0589930192,
-0.0134753436,
-0.062520206,
0.064025715,
-0.0095587354,
-0.0484274216,
0.0243836585,
-0.0113827614,
-0.0465685576,
-0.0598197617,
-0.0090787429,
0.0259603802,
-0.0004370098,
0.0511875525,
-0.0276649054,
0.008409326,
0.0418348387,
-0.0236767512,
0.0525921062,
0.0145546058,
0.0265414584,
0.047720179,
-0.0475724377,
0.0127820829,
-0.050238356,
0.0313070603,
0.0191934798,
-0.0137782712,
-0.0562887602,
-0.0099587981,
-0.0065158107,
0.0544148386,
0.0291644335,
0.0193066001,
-0.0092611564,
-0.0019100588,
-0.0279348139,
0.0414186791,
-0.0077942172,
-0.0474038012,
0.0255687498,
-0.0449580736,
-0.0342267193,
-0.0035937454,
-0.051713936,
0.0475551188,
0.0606074072,
-0.0395758115,
-0.0065078344,
-0.032574255,
-0.0095625808,
0.0011024452,
0.0305340793,
0.0831830129,
-0.0090643214,
0.0219180603,
-0.0496505201,
-0.0486079305,
0.0160502866,
-0.0811228678,
-0.0060138963,
-0.0967842191,
0.0129952962,
0.0195499454,
-0.0076279356,
-0.0226132777,
0.0058069197,
0.0300580878,
-0.0044818381,
0.0842695758,
0.0100499392,
-0.0054425173,
0.0191759784,
0.0211636834,
-0.030304255,
0.0593878254,
0.0141909653,
0.0456625447,
0.0229970086,
0.0414404869,
0.0124365371,
0.0188341923,
0.027175108,
0.0088203438,
-0.03354517,
0.0440608561,
0.008058521,
0.022538662,
-0.0213320423,
0.0144941416,
-0.044220563,
-0.0259524267,
0.0403677858,
0.0264233537,
0.0371085405,
-0.0194167793,
0.0503195412,
-0.0275496151,
0.046793703,
0.001511519,
-0.0640069097,
0.0085463841,
-0.0426362231,
0.0167156644,
0.0099833263,
0.0089890324,
-0.0330032818,
-0.0570963435,
-0.0234099068,
0.0188867617,
-0.03656324,
0.0282852184,
0.042883411,
0.0298517589,
-0.0102100987,
0.0376392119,
0.0233961381,
-0.0670129284,
-0.0676662624,
-0.0363171995,
0.0690927133,
-0.0056457627,
0.0654210672,
-0.0335284993,
0.0017877816,
-0.0268141106,
0.034315303,
0.0391274355,
0.0502645709,
0.0041569979,
0.0020518003,
-0.0003138318,
-0.0144899525,
-0.0651222244,
0.0378932394,
0.0036304556,
0.0422472544,
0.001685595,
0.0248703063,
-0.0631150976,
0.0309600309,
0.0314073414,
-0.0234294832,
-0.0059565459,
-0.0317247361,
0.0057283565,
0.0171396807,
0.0030227043,
-0.019455051,
0.0058679259,
0.0168510843,
-0.0148119666,
-0.0033408492,
-0.0089913402,
-0.0224384144,
-0.0582352579,
0.0210207459,
-0.0553315505,
-0.036291562,
0.0076985499,
-0.0551533848,
0.0043388372,
0.0301816631,
-0.0259491168,
0.0001421335,
-0.0145092402,
-0.0052353004,
-0.0011185172,
-0.0079032518,
0.0293636415,
0.0954564139,
-0.012797744,
0.002469141,
-0.0033567185,
0.015569292,
0.0220047589,
-0.0467776209,
0.0196454953,
0.0162014831,
-0.0033966494,
0.0016620457,
0.0014095032,
-0.0071460805,
-0.013094645,
-0.0271575674,
-0.0497523695,
0.0118589969,
-0.0116392383,
0.0122126229,
0.0073257331,
-0.0314770974,
0.0063382052,
0.0137202376,
0.0118656131,
-0.0315354168,
-0.0049706581,
0.0043838127,
0.0230596811,
-0.0163361095,
-0.0572358519,
0.0074753477,
-0.0215440933,
-0.0111271534,
0.0675238818,
-0.0272900946,
0.0200280827,
-0.0003842247,
0.0314570591,
-0.0358008556,
0.0210893434,
-0.0163097698,
-0.0050504785,
0.0529275015,
-0.0057484442,
0.008727232,
0.1269045472,
-0.0331540518,
0.0028252352,
0.0646760166,
-0.0189297386,
-0.0200106353,
0.0085139265,
0.0127004217,
0.0365674123,
-0.0473064333,
-0.0130464286,
-0.016051963,
0.0209724121,
-0.0370815173,
0.0058334223,
-0.0143117197,
0.0395737402,
0.0003150264,
0.0065863188,
-0.0055760914,
-0.0285970513,
0.0048725326,
0.0605800413,
-0.016237257,
-0.0477081351,
0.0459481142,
0.0010804222,
0.021477472,
-0.0359525569,
0.0061771316,
-0.034743201,
0.0922244936,
-0.0219412483,
-0.0103359483,
0.0053510186,
0.0089782653,
0.0038996018,
-0.0358104818,
0.0526400767,
-0.0246476606,
0.0454444513,
-0.0463453904,
0.0090414137,
-0.0129094431,
-0.0409187414,
-0.0578693524,
0.011553348,
-0.0858938247,
0.0216001701,
-0.0625149161,
-0.0302030742,
-0.0395877361,
-0.0177857466,
0.0229966752,
0.0262876377,
0.0249984097,
-0.0030604838,
0.00593259,
-0.0239149537,
-0.0419236012,
0.0100913467,
-0.0020931787,
-0.050298661,
0.0497458801,
0.0384547189,
0.0200448353,
0.0023506067,
-0.0444020368,
0.0305023473,
-0.0532712303,
-0.002736534,
-0.0135610038,
0.0181443077,
0.0235357396,
-0.0871816128,
0.011154959,
0.0943884328,
0.0015468238,
-0.0210417192,
0.0095735518,
-0.0176477619,
0.0354862399,
0.0272217877,
0.0200833175,
-0.1202204227,
-0.0722316131,
0.0509221368,
-0.0325720049,
-0.0119601861,
-0.0297016688,
-0.0092891958,
-0.1367863119,
0.0293839481,
0.0038489085,
-0.0164545886,
-0.0145279728,
-0.0526223443,
0.0263884775,
0.0105223618,
-0.0420222543,
0.0087990826,
0.0091138007,
-0.0148958387,
-0.0021632414,
-0.00685836,
-0.0278122798,
0.0667520389,
-0.0180674046,
0.0162561834,
0.0025329983,
0.0161573682,
0.0098737003,
-0.0652912408,
0.0332537182,
0.0211559776,
-0.0181046631,
0.0106002819,
0.0158582237,
-0.0185930952,
0.0211805087,
-0.0224413536,
0.0649690554,
-0.0033921492,
-0.0421903171,
0.050024353,
0.0826175064,
0.0152070355,
-0.0579995215,
-0.0297992043,
0.0142158493,
-0.0480232276,
0.0348033533,
0.0368049666,
0.0141944261,
-0.0429920554,
-0.0396562964,
-0.0837934017,
-0.0406283103,
0.0049565169,
0.0169627331,
0.0141512593,
0.0087494869,
0.0043849866,
0.0095562534,
0.024185285,
0.0529300869,
-0.0178493802,
0.0156412292,
-0.0041935886,
0.0305010416,
-0.0246461872,
0.0264431424,
-0.045503322,
0.0471649431,
-0.031083541,
0.0341861695,
-0.0403315425,
-0.0221757516,
-0.0201280545,
0.0457094833,
-0.0639886335,
-0.0614563785,
0.0038745133,
0.0340844542,
0.0262350924,
0.0265328139,
0.0031717853,
-0.0542413071,
0.0436790138,
0.0000743415,
-0.0010927714,
0.0036957974,
0.0904486105,
0.0002540313,
0.0458138809,
0.036751207,
0.0184710566,
0.0257334989,
0.0425743014,
0.0056289914,
-0.0178568866,
0.0222286284,
0.0217384696,
0.0235110614,
-0.0318737291,
0.03720944,
-0.0201318413,
-0.0361360051,
0.0650550425,
-0.0511260927,
-0.0093923332,
-0.0272611566,
0.0217089523,
0.0094769616,
-0.0191709734,
0.0103534814,
-0.0410809442,
-0.0063819066,
-0.0120545765,
0.003864832,
0.0417858884,
0.0458659306,
0.0095851263,
0.0372601599,
-0.0344264768,
-0.0271186493,
0.0068121734,
-0.0556852743,
0.02868402,
-0.0115545746,
0.0405068099,
0.0513333306,
0.0030957262,
-0.0637594312,
-0.0092299646,
-0.0742536783,
-0.0309193749,
0.0533040687,
0.0153988376,
0.0360388011,
0.0164156407,
-0.0188948624,
-0.0462652035,
-0.0066467086,
0.0100360084,
0.0328263752,
-0.0151072061,
-0.0393978246,
0.0270981267,
0.0235104654,
-0.0105101615,
0.0022933171,
0.0458814055,
-0.0155990366,
0.03325966,
0.0225981344,
0.0277894773,
-0.0378575139,
-0.012878417,
0.00033733,
0.0306884646,
-0.0029005131,
0.0008957755,
-0.050877329,
-0.1100447625,
-0.0577464253,
0.0314134732,
0.0013885484,
0.0290617999,
-0.0323640406,
0.0604660027,
0.0187500846,
-0.056395933,
0.0072259037,
-0.0033983793,
-0.0153090758,
-0.0171588268,
0.0211334042,
-5.80943157e-33,
0.0015123169,
-0.0038535967,
0.0306155365,
-0.0039646998,
-0.0194225721,
-0.0193881597,
-0.0475047342,
0.0006729314,
-0.0433027782,
0.0672042221,
-0.0268393345,
0.0396712683,
0.0016200169,
-0.0024924276,
-0.0349579304,
0.0148489289,
0.005393635,
0.0159594901,
-0.0352781899,
0.003083501,
0.0312991068,
-0.0202710889,
0.0240194462,
-0.0346413068,
0.0251679067,
-0.014262748,
-0.0296812151,
0.0294443816,
-0.0912122503,
0.062578775,
0.0068639577,
0.0016545154,
0.0067252289,
-0.0273643062,
-0.0043441481,
0.0212052986,
-0.06792669,
0.0014346986,
0.0463519916,
-0.0354311652,
-0.0450868867,
-0.0299290754,
0.0173031166,
0.0259036887,
0.0019674117,
-0.0657221302,
-0.0111047914,
-0.0232115798,
0.0101853143,
0.0328649804,
-0.0326308794,
0.0514281131,
-0.0267517455,
-0.0377765708,
0.0174846742,
-0.0235639624,
-0.0316111408,
-0.0541660003,
-0.0207141712,
0.0052223755,
0.0431394465,
-0.024697639,
0.0504549854,
-0.0379039161,
0.0127518103,
0.0406535342,
0.012704581,
0.0307942498,
-0.0478063338,
-0.0011974805,
0.0024428577,
0.0984145328,
0.0442795828,
-0.0100333933,
0.0641627461,
0.0165905915,
-0.0831046477,
-0.0529455356,
0.0009214164,
0.0589717142,
0.0698679462,
-0.013212665,
-0.0289394706,
0.0003440415,
-0.0581649169,
0.0144952023,
-0.0244789012,
-0.001526875,
0.0212659016,
0.0211015325,
-0.017142117,
-0.0713435486,
-0.0025922109,
-0.0525652841,
0.0071616699,
0.0547218025,
-0.0014193094,
-0.0101268655,
-0.0101618245,
0.0175546966,
-0.0678874999,
-0.0164477825,
0.0176534727,
0.0053201541,
0.0010707624,
-0.0137286317,
0.0564428493,
-0.0038243064,
-0.028944565,
-0.0196678843,
-0.0484906323,
0.0157183371,
-0.0163375866,
0.0575970151,
0.0584015846,
0.0359240994,
-0.0039594346,
-0.0142217381,
-0.0156973675,
-0.0201817881,
-0.0476357825,
0.0566727705,
0.0052861813,
0.0147822052,
-0.0025227978,
-0.0232363734,
-0.0359574854,
-0.0165396407,
0.0248348415,
-0.0284045581,
-0.0027160149,
0.0483216569,
2.708e-7,
0.0034072096,
0.035834074,
0.0260863788,
0.0731445625,
0.0192926414,
0.0306834374,
-0.0467479005,
-0.010224266,
0.0185543709,
-0.053116288,
-0.0134124877,
0.0766291097,
0.0605184808,
0.0504974164,
-0.0542127453,
-0.0352650136,
-0.0378459543,
-0.0418000743,
-0.0603184178,
-0.0293872748,
0.0123533579,
0.067149736,
0.0364768766,
-0.0103054931,
0.0183964055,
-0.0235441811,
0.0391183868,
0.0069760862,
0.0175007973,
-0.0380737074,
0.05195738,
0.0049887099,
0.0282393415,
0.0664995536,
0.0127398623,
0.0238938201,
-0.0487384498,
0.0432599075,
-0.0136722438,
0.0007102845,
-0.0327890776,
-0.0528905094,
0.0074025732,
-0.0660582259,
0.078201659,
-0.0400208421,
-0.0446440764,
0.0028469942,
0.0224834569,
-0.0442141108,
0.0149167562,
0.0097255269,
0.0014497094,
-0.0069095301,
0.0221597515,
-0.0228363406,
0.0044327686,
-0.0756399632,
-0.0391026884,
0.0206223428,
-0.0334623009,
-0.0376926102,
-0.0068167299,
-0.0157309286,
0.0309178419,
-0.0416720696,
-0.0125728967,
2.414275986e-34,
0.0416662358,
-0.0273257121,
0.0194806941,
-0.0039661545,
0.0658460483,
-0.0290622786,
0.0097877281,
-0.0037491941,
0.0231167134,
-0.1025849134,
-0.0095415432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15268v1 | EvEval: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Event Semantics for Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T15:55:40 | 2023-05-24T15:55:40 | Zhengwei Tao, Zhi Jin, Xiaoying Bai, Haiyan Zhao, Yanlin Feng, Jia Li, Wenpeng Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Events serve as fundamental units of occurrence within various contexts. The
processing of event semantics in textual information forms the basis of
numerous natural language processing (NLP) applications. Recent studies have
begun leveraging large language models (LLMs) to address event semantic
processing. However, the extent that LLMs can effectively tackle these
challenges remains uncertain. Furthermore, the lack of a comprehensive
evaluation framework for event semantic processing poses a significant
challenge in evaluating these capabilities. In this paper, we propose an
overarching framework for event semantic processing, encompassing
understanding, reasoning, and prediction, along with their fine-grained
aspects. To comprehensively evaluate the event semantic processing abilities of
models, we introduce a novel benchmark called EVEVAL. We collect 8 datasets
that cover all aspects of event semantic processing. Extensive experiments are
conducted on EVEVAL, leading to several noteworthy findings based on the
obtained results. | [
0.0154613378,
0.0262907986,
-0.0004436056,
0.094468534,
-0.0583160892,
0.0244709328,
0.0040640789,
0.0010553296,
0.0237678271,
-0.0725283846,
0.0089309439,
-0.0064912848,
-0.0396197848,
0.0549775213,
-0.0168112647,
-0.0176631343,
0.0553931147,
0.0241958741,
-0.0076266783,
0.0389332473,
0.0226290636,
0.0191367753,
0.0101503944,
0.0608843006,
-0.0303491391,
-0.0032140317,
0.0128581058,
-0.0054463027,
0.029665973,
-0.0707783625,
-0.0265902374,
-0.0117324889,
0.0250078533,
0.047927212,
0.0000016789,
-0.0716985166,
-0.0113310497,
-0.0142965596,
-0.0300108008,
0.0307399724,
0.0163820237,
-0.0290533621,
0.0126026953,
-0.023570098,
-0.0243061781,
-0.0303664058,
0.0026228402,
0.0612991266,
0.0022201294,
0.0767629892,
-0.0276974887,
-0.0431178473,
0.0244077127,
-0.0057702013,
-0.0177040771,
-0.0827594921,
0.0277667996,
-0.0060543618,
-0.0079606818,
-0.0216686223,
-0.0039948216,
0.004490559,
0.0066816513,
0.0422186218,
0.0001843174,
0.0521081872,
-0.055424042,
0.0090706469,
-0.0051331329,
0.0236448124,
0.0165236127,
-0.0143918032,
0.0232459884,
-0.0028362169,
-0.0202819183,
0.0150279179,
-0.0456323959,
0.0124949245,
-0.0058255452,
0.0538060814,
0.0653322116,
0.0266420636,
0.0331061333,
0.0424297713,
-0.0260905363,
0.1014222503,
0.0309645217,
0.006525815,
-0.0337148495,
-0.0060094283,
-0.0577479005,
-0.0505510867,
0.0160799902,
0.0397146977,
-0.0481216125,
0.0343512557,
-0.0243154168,
0.0639282539,
0.0146173881,
-0.0924681276,
-0.0078521241,
0.0439945348,
0.0443466641,
0.0868528038,
-0.0100395875,
0.0149777634,
-0.010087098,
0.0312407501,
-0.0270856302,
-0.0331480429,
-0.0452310666,
0.037475463,
-0.0214727148,
0.0135360258,
-0.0529851839,
-0.0330525078,
-0.0212462805,
0.018855406,
0.0443137512,
0.0006314293,
-0.0198698156,
-0.011975687,
-0.0342793427,
-0.0136431074,
-0.0555380024,
-0.0249833018,
-0.0440613776,
0.0267721005,
-0.0202889685,
-0.076600939,
0.0117058568,
-0.0288731959,
0.0214210488,
-0.0198190454,
-0.0205761828,
0.0500811264,
0.0306889899,
-0.0346692204,
-0.0667519569,
-0.0462401398,
0.0005553643,
-0.0395867787,
-0.0523223281,
-0.0510485172,
0.025486026,
0.022289725,
0.0157728978,
-0.0391232856,
0.0196379628,
-0.0003778501,
-0.0356377065,
0.043188639,
0.0000939854,
0.0217508096,
-0.0030569346,
0.003608586,
0.0280513223,
0.0612558722,
0.0630609617,
0.0317803249,
0.0644870996,
0.0378314033,
-0.0524344817,
0.0281450879,
0.0047790287,
-0.0006902197,
-0.0306189284,
0.0170343332,
0.0000406761,
0.0169686414,
0.012379949,
0.0012393601,
-0.0249557123,
-0.0454217382,
0.0254064389,
0.0284071043,
-0.0425227433,
-0.002439661,
0.0323875248,
-0.0254970584,
-0.012688566,
-0.0268581621,
-0.0300732199,
-0.0265096333,
-0.0050450084,
-0.0308983643,
0.0186557919,
-0.0232608896,
-0.0240279641,
-0.0110759037,
-0.0257204026,
0.0039543323,
-0.0175352171,
-0.0053201229,
0.0517631806,
-0.0056059491,
-0.0202566907,
0.0568522885,
0.0247598048,
-0.013199918,
0.0247228127,
-0.0288660284,
0.017804293,
0.0460635796,
0.0519684777,
-0.0573207065,
-0.0343911648,
0.0158371944,
-0.0016633592,
0.017956445,
0.0398172475,
-0.0044901874,
0.0210643634,
-0.0322056189,
-0.0011053849,
-0.0145132393,
0.0180385392,
-0.0109825293,
0.0313978605,
0.0058537452,
-0.0103300968,
0.0073655159,
-0.0171633139,
0.055670023,
-0.0213600099,
-0.0385633782,
-0.0358535945,
-0.0272230767,
0.026141258,
-0.0291562993,
-0.0062858635,
0.0077811354,
0.045631282,
-0.0463874005,
-0.0336393639,
0.0393495187,
-0.01117991,
-0.0628408268,
0.0682976022,
0.0023424251,
-0.0339719355,
0.0418837927,
-0.0607486926,
-0.0075510144,
0.0114793871,
0.0054569831,
0.0402696282,
-0.0230496228,
0.0218125526,
-0.0103884432,
-0.0157572329,
-0.0364802592,
0.0707297549,
-0.0068261181,
0.0215008482,
-0.0376694128,
0.0486311577,
0.0366089679,
-0.0252469238,
-0.0625203326,
0.0115118725,
-0.0023616771,
-0.0267874543,
0.0369689129,
-0.0515802912,
-0.0663538203,
-0.005892979,
-0.1070259884,
0.065689221,
-0.0293461625,
0.0406311266,
0.0573696494,
0.014454308,
-0.0091470089,
0.0121581564,
-0.0173721816,
-0.0681920052,
-0.0131796915,
0.0370706916,
0.0253365654,
0.0326781422,
-0.016157154,
-0.049008958,
-0.0065238015,
-0.0579799153,
0.0889267996,
0.0111174695,
-0.0032274337,
-0.011704484,
0.0277942475,
-0.0187782347,
0.0279580951,
-0.0033784548,
0.0004054052,
-0.0120934714,
-0.0102528064,
0.0395209715,
0.0407550074,
-0.0126909725,
0.0624088719,
0.0104066236,
-0.044438079,
-0.048157014,
0.0082913432,
-0.062267188,
0.0079842443,
-0.0560813397,
-0.0227981452,
-0.0132259997,
0.0596941784,
0.0038270776,
0.009239722,
-0.0301634017,
-0.0111707076,
-0.0509036556,
-0.0193223562,
-0.0456754193,
-0.0241540708,
-0.0346373878,
0.0483116992,
-0.0558832698,
-0.0101132421,
0.0343684182,
-0.0011882293,
0.0007709712,
-0.0230150465,
0.0021823631,
-0.0744374469,
0.0934880152,
-0.0097527225,
0.0084544281,
-0.064936474,
-0.0190785434,
0.0025689458,
-0.0095538301,
0.0091612991,
-0.0309906807,
0.0333488621,
-0.0197965391,
0.0204702727,
0.0013468295,
0.0022940661,
-0.0349953063,
-0.0510451905,
-0.0418821461,
0.0157915931,
-0.0322007164,
0.0493691489,
-0.0414335094,
0.0145277195,
-0.0399539247,
0.0260759369,
0.0030751859,
-0.0113297021,
-0.026397422,
0.0705810115,
0.0267514996,
-0.0167759247,
0.0142776202,
0.0021836166,
0.0274528619,
0.0481714793,
0.0387558565,
0.0129121309,
-0.0527709126,
0.0105355633,
0.0050542289,
-0.0636727363,
0.006502796,
0.0021989562,
0.0402460881,
-0.0872572809,
0.0117870942,
0.1134243459,
0.0546618178,
0.0163600277,
0.0233919844,
0.0149870189,
-0.0058066952,
0.0322900228,
-0.0278545506,
-0.0530075617,
-0.0477782786,
-0.0050942861,
-0.0606605597,
-0.0103834998,
-0.0583262481,
0.0057144002,
-0.0466849431,
0.0019671968,
-0.0314711109,
-0.0306143742,
-0.0409574658,
-0.0610622205,
0.0304864533,
-0.0508205853,
-0.0217011236,
-0.0033297893,
0.0044867741,
-0.009159998,
-0.005509377,
-0.0297924038,
-0.0556241497,
0.0699615926,
-0.046573583,
0.0319765694,
0.0255734418,
0.0559800528,
-0.0052425521,
0.0166408103,
0.0284363572,
-0.034452524,
-0.0116897915,
-0.0060084881,
0.0188121013,
-0.0060249623,
-0.0132582262,
-0.0065959399,
0.0141022988,
-0.015072478,
-0.0534293093,
-0.0141834226,
0.0790795162,
0.0071776048,
0.0144506805,
-0.0232075956,
-0.003163785,
-0.0167067349,
0.0783554465,
0.0002417299,
0.0340866596,
-0.028162118,
0.0273161735,
-0.0103617515,
-0.0231819041,
-0.0354054868,
0.0135723464,
0.0131353978,
-0.0549837053,
-0.0387546197,
-0.0542488806,
0.0128806653,
-0.009536895,
-0.0368789993,
0.0264372118,
0.0215029698,
-0.0046346691,
-0.0522208251,
0.0755257681,
-0.0637493655,
0.043034751,
0.0266936533,
0.0271177758,
0.0298046935,
0.0592554249,
-0.0441821739,
0.0714804083,
-0.0634679869,
-0.0482418165,
-0.0104159489,
-0.0451287739,
0.0150887612,
0.016112823,
-0.0276207365,
-0.0237942617,
-0.0263456404,
-0.0065666935,
-0.0488659032,
0.0072359131,
-0.0193920657,
0.0224273596,
0.0022312696,
0.0490354411,
-0.0078494065,
0.0521324165,
-0.0001874519,
0.0674462542,
-0.0302163064,
-0.0414139815,
0.0199065525,
0.0051377169,
0.0586742833,
-0.0075889751,
-0.0438918844,
-0.0112943202,
-0.0203325227,
-0.0322874039,
-0.0041840323,
-0.0281477738,
-0.0026912028,
0.0049414365,
0.0082840472,
-0.0644451305,
0.0386854932,
-0.0347975641,
0.0072382451,
-0.0368310586,
0.0041903527,
0.0200479776,
0.014007384,
-0.0005039613,
0.0240974184,
-0.0269245245,
-0.0139268693,
-0.0215366594,
-0.0063508344,
-0.0376133546,
0.0233330261,
0.0417041928,
0.0146448631,
-0.0252675768,
-0.0249329712,
-0.0571409166,
0.0212693084,
0.0139880776,
0.0128241591,
0.0786020085,
-0.0296610929,
0.0277427379,
-0.0129394429,
-0.0076409206,
-0.0157942194,
0.0171486717,
0.0150583936,
-0.0079591749,
0.0406956859,
0.0131320152,
-0.0219365507,
0.0146013228,
0.0347709469,
-0.0065006162,
0.0967798606,
0.0415408239,
-0.035215009,
-0.0252977666,
-0.0324039124,
0.0494643897,
0.0237883404,
-0.0063797296,
0.0284506269,
-0.107711032,
0.0001909372,
0.030902762,
0.0055687106,
-0.0109777497,
-0.0158718433,
0.0268480144,
0.048962649,
0.0157285016,
0.0048469347,
-0.0162555706,
-0.0036506087,
-0.0128097897,
-0.0146882003,
-0.0383522138,
-5.686945426e-33,
-0.0199457146,
-0.0002359763,
0.030422831,
0.0396329649,
-0.0256343819,
0.0167234596,
-0.0261961054,
-0.0202912036,
-0.0109665142,
0.0288450643,
0.0096105095,
0.0224492885,
0.0103117302,
-0.019186886,
-0.0015298076,
-0.0554348677,
0.0463299528,
-0.0047275862,
-0.0047040805,
0.0135766063,
0.0398118198,
0.0193301681,
0.0332676247,
-0.075818345,
-0.0121316845,
0.0174165424,
0.0099952826,
-0.0060815271,
0.0435911976,
0.0411276035,
-0.0304900967,
0.0376203395,
0.0608236305,
-0.074764058,
0.0080791386,
0.0122991614,
-0.0461291634,
-0.0287627466,
0.0544615239,
0.0083387243,
-0.0101493578,
-0.0306177456,
0.0201788917,
0.0319551863,
-0.0134298904,
-0.0053041237,
0.0303423367,
-0.0108221723,
-0.0146842962,
-0.0291548744,
-0.0665303171,
0.0815629065,
-0.0031941512,
-0.0090373773,
0.0423468947,
-0.0259065218,
0.0225461833,
0.043738015,
-0.0031767862,
0.006663905,
-0.0413215607,
0.0267198496,
-0.0137521839,
-0.0131027158,
-0.0075559462,
0.0856873989,
0.0070034978,
-0.0087658176,
-0.0167386364,
0.0553475916,
0.0267827529,
0.0717834458,
0.0027012229,
0.0628630146,
0.0160080995,
0.0318224728,
-0.1144192815,
0.0415998213,
0.0260874834,
0.0087713925,
0.0196092203,
0.0137642138,
-0.0208336227,
0.0221785232,
-0.0882791206,
0.0550748482,
-0.045556806,
0.0432160757,
0.0358815007,
-0.0132140005,
0.0347991884,
0.0902495533,
0.0046416898,
-0.0524776913,
-0.0228558388,
0.041301582,
0.0112923691,
-0.0077500208,
0.0007273501,
0.0611737557,
-0.0507996567,
-0.0347809978,
-0.0001352574,
-0.0288337134,
0.0342841931,
-0.0261091851,
0.0128371837,
-0.000709801,
-0.0257732105,
0.0121994903,
-0.0308674444,
-0.038164515,
-0.0381324291,
-0.0233678408,
0.0223992206,
0.0140299294,
-0.0082105715,
0.0348732546,
0.0346008912,
0.0265267845,
0.0069023846,
-0.0415890329,
0.01110176,
0.0426877253,
-0.0103027392,
-0.0101257553,
-0.0572601184,
0.0128023261,
0.0067509697,
0.0058193952,
-0.0166421384,
0.003521817,
2.31e-7,
0.0622058772,
0.0314938761,
0.0084614381,
0.0648758635,
0.0115629863,
0.0177424438,
-0.0131584601,
0.0609909594,
0.0169224571,
0.0066368952,
-0.0307536945,
0.0417281687,
0.020105334,
0.0261439644,
-0.0399024673,
-0.0136218583,
-0.0658605099,
-0.0018090321,
-0.0778561607,
0.0078944322,
0.0906428173,
0.1020509079,
0.0617206134,
0.0135111278,
-0.0053528375,
-0.041732505,
0.0496292599,
-0.0289085601,
-0.0618039705,
0.0414408334,
-0.0346011706,
0.0689041317,
-0.0022483615,
0.024367759,
0.0093070082,
0.034788236,
0.009360265,
0.076937519,
-0.0427119993,
0.0439270549,
0.0007399392,
-0.0535212383,
-0.045773834,
-0.0437791571,
0.0879708901,
-0.0286580082,
-0.0308802053,
-0.0040961322,
-0.0229805149,
0.0302988999,
0.0095618349,
0.0271585062,
-0.0484124087,
-0.0044628978,
0.0215536691,
-0.01005108,
-0.030198779,
-0.0907375813,
-0.0174344238,
0.0277866367,
-0.0272975694,
-0.0523567311,
-0.0232306533,
-0.0154364239,
0.0140787326,
-0.083813794,
-0.0129545759,
2.012213526e-34,
-0.0012308373,
0.0358342826,
-0.0388866737,
0.0181663558,
0.0482840016,
-0.0287463814,
-0.0070067998,
0.0231939331,
-0.0011568478,
-0.0520606413,
0.0459560715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15265v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15265v2 | Winner-Take-All Column Row Sampling for Memory Efficient Adaptation of Language Model | 2023-05-24T15:52:08 | 2023-12-09T17:32:13 | Zirui Liu, Guanchu Wang, Shaochen Zhong, Zhaozhuo Xu, Daochen Zha, Ruixiang Tang, Zhimeng Jiang, Kaixiong Zhou, Vipin Chaudhary, Shuai Xu, Xia Hu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | With the rapid growth in model size, fine-tuning the large pre-trained
language model has become increasingly difficult due to its extensive memory
usage. Previous works usually focus on reducing the number of trainable
parameters in the network. While the model parameters do contribute to memory
usage, the primary memory bottleneck during training arises from storing
feature maps, also known as activations, as they are crucial for gradient
calculation. Notably, neural networks are usually trained using stochastic
gradient descent. We argue that in stochastic optimization, models can handle
noisy gradients as long as the gradient estimator is unbiased with reasonable
variance. Following this motivation, we propose a new family of unbiased
estimators called WTA-CRS, for matrix production with reduced variance, which
only requires storing the sub-sampled activations for calculating the gradient.
Our work provides both theoretical and experimental evidence that, in the
context of tuning transformers, our proposed estimators exhibit lower variance
compared to existing ones. By replacing the linear operation with our
approximated one in transformers, we can achieve up to 2.7$\times$ peak memory
reduction with almost no accuracy drop and enables up to $6.4\times$ larger
batch size. Under the same hardware, WTA-CRS enables better down-streaming task
performance by applying larger models and/or faster training speed with larger
batch sizes. | [
0.013099839,
0.0817143768,
-0.0016749022,
0.0433607325,
0.0159102175,
0.0034042939,
0.0277379677,
-0.0166554786,
-0.0268044937,
-0.0261355489,
-0.0898197666,
-0.0642612651,
-0.0087450268,
0.0122656412,
0.0269347429,
-0.0163239352,
0.0173510909,
-0.0267421585,
-0.027754385,
-0.027323639,
-0.0214444883,
0.0217374507,
-0.0003274146,
-0.0030702706,
-0.0072756642,
-0.0053910357,
-0.0128731923,
-0.0083134966,
-0.0326905921,
0.024551155,
0.0169901308,
0.0479575917,
0.016999891,
0.0243327767,
0.0000022895,
-0.0107325744,
-0.0003281634,
-0.0376107432,
-0.0184802748,
0.0346223526,
0.0428729914,
0.0081577785,
-0.0298173781,
0.0105317179,
0.0027232131,
-0.0746464282,
0.0520924367,
0.0293563865,
0.0201398395,
0.0588628985,
-0.004718557,
-0.0112957004,
0.0124772508,
-0.039453499,
0.0039550643,
-0.0532621183,
0.0044483906,
-0.0382628813,
-0.0473811999,
-0.0099190334,
-0.0354637317,
0.0393402092,
0.0177945103,
-0.0006372444,
-0.0063614151,
0.0248056948,
-0.0342983417,
-0.0010344803,
-0.014163781,
0.0688516796,
-0.0441021547,
-0.0073967231,
-0.0015968345,
-0.0177149139,
-0.0017518974,
-0.0308620688,
-0.0100555848,
0.0308025051,
0.01716616,
0.0216767993,
-0.0485129952,
-0.0073749698,
0.0370593406,
0.0145125026,
-0.0151823377,
0.0184009373,
0.0122665418,
0.0109644393,
0.0196571536,
0.0160427317,
0.0174138993,
-0.0274862722,
0.0158502162,
-0.0019825087,
-0.0299171135,
0.0234150309,
-0.0764775127,
-0.097641319,
-0.0541996136,
-0.0626801178,
0.0813856795,
0.0349692591,
0.0304324925,
0.0335316062,
-0.0406302474,
0.0166823044,
-0.0595241152,
0.025522314,
-0.0510955863,
-0.0292310063,
0.0347525552,
0.0203714874,
-0.0607840605,
0.0195987243,
-0.0346158296,
-0.0046172352,
-0.0345386192,
0.0259635802,
-0.0024522126,
-0.0316437744,
0.0183118563,
0.0135103008,
-0.0542942807,
-0.0039264318,
0.0023142248,
0.0356607251,
-0.0025053204,
-0.0011714384,
-0.0063426136,
-0.0751131922,
-0.0466920249,
0.0043489062,
0.0354328156,
-0.0291513558,
0.0506408773,
0.0681036487,
-0.0235251263,
-0.0574771799,
-0.0598678626,
0.0278993286,
-0.0178712513,
-0.0388395898,
0.0294147804,
-0.0710380822,
0.0684991702,
0.0081749232,
0.0077443835,
-0.0560461134,
0.0026239273,
0.0320560597,
-0.0578747317,
0.0490552746,
0.0014305159,
-0.0225266609,
0.0127207628,
-0.0344622955,
0.0161377918,
0.0630298182,
0.0580646545,
0.0618225858,
0.0348386467,
0.0131726488,
-0.0016165146,
0.0544639416,
0.050202135,
0.0030363812,
-0.0243287235,
-0.016562406,
0.0175277069,
0.016822828,
0.0847331807,
0.0422937274,
-0.0364092998,
0.0029107952,
0.0604066551,
0.0535176955,
-0.0131346257,
0.0771561489,
0.0200355891,
-0.0216300227,
0.0271066912,
-0.0493103266,
-0.0158923194,
0.0433282703,
0.0350582898,
-0.0111864638,
0.020697074,
0.0618412867,
-0.0626631007,
-0.0404387638,
-0.0008632719,
-0.0109017873,
-0.034649197,
0.0244760569,
0.0686615482,
0.0139759947,
-0.0412362367,
0.0885378122,
0.0226827599,
-0.0559677035,
-0.0089763021,
-0.0665310249,
0.0069255736,
0.0425437689,
0.0187104288,
-0.0099435532,
0.0015502524,
-0.0213127397,
0.0322078802,
0.0046614395,
0.0329888165,
0.00026257,
0.0296039563,
-0.0452969372,
-0.0102100288,
-0.0056829066,
-0.0047768769,
0.0447291546,
0.0221029166,
0.0225206167,
0.0129951565,
-0.0331368595,
-0.0453775525,
0.0083323345,
-0.0361797139,
-0.0402718969,
0.0585554242,
-0.0130741522,
0.0334097482,
-0.0045306482,
-0.0167104043,
-0.0254155044,
0.0034627474,
-0.0366862081,
0.0233822968,
-0.0134499259,
-0.0725232586,
-0.0198428091,
0.0037594878,
0.0068225521,
0.0128852651,
0.0486606434,
-0.0279868133,
-0.0433359258,
0.0539682768,
-0.0130078653,
0.010318758,
-0.0333872624,
0.026277313,
0.0022031602,
0.0583257452,
-0.0040804385,
0.0121382093,
-0.0513014309,
-0.0302776787,
-0.0037374438,
-0.0069785137,
-0.0087783495,
-0.0209645946,
-0.0634720623,
0.0318467282,
0.0043216664,
0.0238301959,
-0.0066471403,
0.0031096502,
-0.0006875907,
-0.0137071628,
-0.0556550734,
0.0408672318,
-0.0586202107,
0.0096361637,
0.0230321735,
0.0450931005,
0.014183633,
-0.024209436,
-0.0161465295,
0.020809425,
-0.0361507162,
0.0051296107,
-0.0168544985,
0.0007610812,
0.0254567284,
-0.0250021238,
-0.0798624977,
0.0114752147,
0.0665505752,
-0.0291818921,
-0.0472899675,
-0.0255199056,
0.0061689443,
0.0343195088,
0.0482376032,
-0.0116624478,
-0.0319609977,
-0.0334022604,
-0.0251821242,
0.0361150466,
0.0688535571,
0.0018008604,
0.0290214475,
0.0475239195,
0.0048900279,
-0.0328665078,
0.0496783629,
-0.0247183293,
-0.0389820002,
-0.0266052987,
-0.0022584666,
0.0182572585,
0.0766282752,
-0.0393718407,
-0.0068949596,
-0.0347359665,
-0.0362096988,
0.008627031,
-0.0232753549,
-0.0334163122,
0.0035060165,
-0.0363627784,
0.0026401209,
-0.0146916583,
-0.0250671245,
-0.0027867381,
-0.0192630496,
-0.0007401392,
-0.0556036532,
0.0081612617,
0.0027550359,
0.0341342874,
0.0352613516,
0.026060449,
-0.0480496734,
0.0064442363,
-0.028064657,
-0.0196544491,
-0.0001592251,
-0.0360774808,
0.05292546,
-0.0167259164,
0.0094292853,
-0.0370437317,
-0.0389914922,
-0.0365323313,
-0.0080473004,
-0.0096183289,
0.0046650036,
0.0718599856,
-0.0370990708,
0.0027607931,
0.0001137048,
0.0363069177,
0.1141334027,
0.0029628507,
-0.0133306822,
-0.0197543092,
0.026579449,
0.0271797013,
0.0073926384,
0.0280624125,
-0.0241360143,
0.0035029133,
0.0548313037,
0.0416821018,
-0.0166146737,
-0.0336777903,
-0.0065519656,
0.0532033369,
0.0116800042,
-0.0005411175,
-0.002523453,
0.0223199371,
-0.0421718545,
-0.038255956,
0.0800876617,
0.0037198213,
-0.0904296339,
-0.0155913169,
0.0432393327,
0.0505456366,
0.0192838572,
0.0598173104,
-0.0453613475,
-0.0214961749,
0.0164256655,
0.0231864508,
0.0299443603,
-0.0399347618,
-0.0407094657,
-0.116784744,
0.010269477,
-0.0243944675,
-0.0212404542,
-0.0155682396,
-0.0085061342,
-0.0049323365,
-0.0246596374,
0.0602480248,
0.0267084334,
-0.0042327894,
0.0010764622,
0.0492093749,
0.0152834551,
-0.0566538759,
-0.0132618202,
-0.0440603644,
0.0320905298,
0.0381758697,
-0.0028859375,
-0.0246921815,
-0.0238276795,
0.0448408909,
-0.0088046519,
-0.0216793455,
0.0017478269,
0.0740905255,
-0.0168125983,
-0.0507342517,
0.0050092898,
0.0173191242,
-0.0316342376,
0.0071110441,
-0.0194978025,
0.045126386,
0.0161235854,
-0.0110426629,
0.0157182328,
-0.0647167638,
-0.0141221751,
0.0509296283,
0.0400594361,
-0.0505110286,
-0.0137724541,
0.003077494,
-0.0441987105,
-0.0701601207,
-0.0328919031,
0.0122964708,
-0.0121797509,
-0.0677659363,
-0.0290962383,
0.0016775416,
0.0313228033,
0.0607006475,
-0.0382256433,
-0.0175431222,
0.0476249754,
0.0214044452,
-0.0619484894,
0.0048037511,
-0.0290350411,
0.0076999213,
-0.0329722725,
-0.020727396,
0.0289523434,
-0.0158116519,
-0.0125720548,
0.0273326673,
-0.1149401218,
-0.0402195118,
0.0375367478,
0.0491788536,
0.0080631198,
0.0467802286,
0.0190045126,
-0.035760846,
0.0442696325,
0.0247087479,
-0.0076140543,
0.0476548336,
0.0352915712,
-0.0398640707,
-0.0072464761,
0.0406473316,
-0.0446194485,
0.0281683281,
0.0389477722,
0.0132062519,
0.0074370755,
0.0077223987,
-0.0194003284,
-0.0152817266,
0.0532996841,
-0.0141267153,
0.0059351958,
-0.0367933847,
0.0389007106,
-0.0019779617,
0.0055401642,
-0.0553382263,
-0.0085680895,
0.003197928,
-0.0004512508,
-0.0425182916,
0.0309051145,
0.0836369693,
-0.0133709768,
0.0253422186,
-0.0249851923,
-0.0213095006,
-0.0209468026,
0.0236372538,
0.0175445955,
-0.0249890033,
0.0075761932,
0.0341552533,
0.0201492943,
-0.0103511037,
-0.0147336842,
0.0061887894,
-0.0432425514,
-0.0477904826,
0.0369398668,
-0.0505001694,
-0.0628212243,
-0.0506474115,
0.0278759822,
0.0297787227,
-0.0500769839,
0.0390347689,
-0.0179273169,
-0.0113190366,
-0.004937103,
-0.0256855786,
0.0149724483,
0.020841375,
0.036941763,
-0.0005725909,
-0.0116795944,
-0.0022364545,
0.0578846224,
0.0174312498,
0.0491511561,
-0.0080891335,
-0.0193740632,
-0.0129810739,
-0.0223174896,
-0.0478258431,
0.0072121532,
-0.0095537044,
-0.0205028113,
0.0014026453,
-0.0602571853,
0.013913434,
0.0054366784,
0.0075188461,
-0.0231559034,
0.0374950878,
0.0405966118,
0.0089368019,
0.0175544526,
-0.0248748865,
0.0058540413,
0.0055334414,
-0.0226570852,
0.009946188,
-6.334931544e-33,
-0.0164089855,
0.027028352,
0.0000265912,
-0.0010481193,
-0.0087035596,
0.0073671099,
-0.0309948921,
-0.0020686581,
-0.0436112322,
-0.0057161101,
-0.0500225499,
0.0261373091,
0.0364385843,
0.0401196107,
-0.0138137117,
0.0003785257,
0.0749585927,
-0.0519994795,
0.0125971921,
0.0494484864,
0.0279679652,
0.0614767037,
0.0877863094,
-0.0092114927,
-0.0491168164,
-0.0056285523,
0.0132234115,
-0.012042732,
0.034445215,
0.0233069658,
-0.0475490578,
0.0704223514,
0.0081214439,
-0.0664090589,
-0.0431116596,
-0.013429787,
-0.0998459011,
-0.005783977,
-0.0191852618,
0.0672608167,
-0.0447083451,
0.0026795743,
0.0377317332,
0.0564421564,
-0.0282531604,
-0.0048449435,
0.0123211518,
-0.0032558681,
-0.0459922105,
-0.0552324541,
0.002062907,
0.0146601507,
0.023919953,
0.0174267292,
0.0464265756,
-0.0132584181,
-0.0248995628,
0.005501525,
-0.0772150531,
-0.0260030497,
0.0378137156,
0.0773472339,
0.0407171883,
0.0659386888,
0.0323943757,
0.0531091876,
0.0496386699,
0.0022436297,
0.0041036541,
-0.0188459381,
0.0553603359,
-0.0066267778,
0.014322768,
0.0319455564,
0.0646034405,
-0.0067262091,
-0.0788898095,
-0.0239550695,
0.0281648822,
0.0382961035,
0.0468097068,
-0.0229170676,
-0.0209357217,
-0.0252371281,
-0.0432322994,
-0.0293081161,
-0.0228438247,
-0.0050669499,
0.0282748267,
0.0239331815,
-0.0098733306,
-0.002059709,
0.0375060029,
-0.0419910811,
-0.0010811863,
0.0307762809,
-0.0055229291,
0.0311466362,
0.005558602,
0.0137339281,
-0.0472455397,
-0.0163267292,
-0.0514552183,
0.0103159882,
-0.0064366716,
0.0249840058,
0.053899508,
0.0489044152,
-0.0731285438,
-0.0138950516,
-0.0367783159,
0.0444816127,
0.0339026041,
0.0871413127,
0.0208922345,
-0.0060607735,
0.0001234726,
0.074961029,
0.0177690275,
-0.008074495,
0.0154263917,
-0.0348539352,
0.0440058224,
0.0115827834,
-0.04544238,
-0.0052352254,
-0.0493314303,
0.0444777869,
0.0232919287,
-0.0784362406,
-0.007199253,
0.012777484,
2.891e-7,
0.0161894113,
0.0205609072,
-0.0065194699,
-0.0112172272,
0.017910853,
0.0039363392,
0.0394831076,
0.038499549,
-0.0055404897,
-0.0007474978,
0.0064882408,
0.0372516997,
0.0410110503,
0.0111503704,
-0.0810495839,
-0.0073733781,
-0.0760497525,
0.0818613917,
-0.0280856639,
-0.0424108878,
-0.0160242543,
0.1243537739,
0.0024870019,
-0.0310406201,
0.0148961619,
0.0030435065,
0.049612239,
-0.035873156,
0.0338795856,
0.0199088007,
0.0482792407,
0.0340840705,
-0.0337738171,
0.003592666,
-0.0389831886,
0.0341287106,
-0.0222687032,
0.0595656931,
-0.0186902266,
-0.0097844908,
0.052362524,
-0.0043595694,
-0.0086499788,
-0.0067288224,
0.08238215,
-0.0291715208,
0.0105375443,
-0.0636186972,
0.0216915738,
-0.0131068891,
0.0172598939,
-0.0167025458,
0.0185820647,
0.0168905091,
0.0224060193,
-0.0343955904,
-0.0252518803,
-0.1084040999,
0.0248056743,
-0.0135107134,
-0.034576267,
-0.0585307702,
-0.067522265,
-0.0399000533,
0.060499683,
-0.0207495764,
0.0210435688,
2.459621599e-34,
0.0353787765,
0.0109586129,
0.0182855371,
0.0293975435,
-0.0203079842,
-0.0242880695,
0.0386875346,
-0.0175463762,
-0.0052797473,
-0.1033717319,
-0.0527218059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15262v1 | Revisiting Parallel Context Windows: A Frustratingly Simple Alternative and Chain-of-Thought Deterioration | 2023-05-24T15:48:29 | 2023-05-24T15:48:29 | Kejuan Yang, Xiao Liu, Kaiwen Men, Aohan Zeng, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We identify two crucial limitations in the evaluation of recent
parallel-integrated method Parallel Context Windows (PCW), which extends the
maximum context lengths of language models, e.g., 2048 for LLaMA, by harnessing
window-wise attention and positional embedding techniques. We first show that a
simple yet strong baseline, weighted sum ensemble, is missing for the
in-context few-shot classification. Moreover, on more challenging
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning (e.g., HotpotQA), PCW would present unexpected
deterioration regarding question miscomprehension and false inference. Based on
our findings, we suggest that the existing PCW design may not guarantee
sufficient improvement and practicality in handling lengthy documents in
real-world applications. More community efforts on enabling language models'
long context understanding ability should be paid. | [
0.0423273109,
0.049820371,
0.0056073708,
0.0610256456,
-0.04374744,
0.047978349,
0.0556701943,
-0.0359712802,
0.0048365388,
-0.0781248808,
-0.0310137849,
-0.0768360421,
0.0317191184,
-0.0398703106,
0.022684928,
-0.0359858945,
0.0312629491,
-0.0132749854,
0.0098229907,
-0.0117101464,
-0.0228000991,
-0.0099527538,
0.0036356188,
0.0178064983,
0.0281451046,
-0.060156215,
-0.0306182541,
-0.0193895381,
0.0379446261,
-0.0132638467,
-0.0067521841,
0.0583711192,
0.0214135032,
0.0621172711,
0.0000019073,
-0.0541298054,
-0.0060164556,
-0.007645587,
-0.0181141887,
0.0222687218,
0.0075542578,
-0.0139098633,
0.0384639688,
0.0172422379,
-0.0007635473,
-0.0099033229,
0.0128634563,
0.0467930436,
0.0252812691,
0.0350327604,
-0.0023479867,
-0.0444704518,
0.0249122418,
-0.0395857282,
0.0315263793,
-0.0861211792,
0.024407573,
-0.0226021707,
0.0475063138,
0.023733478,
-0.0122399414,
0.0560662746,
0.0480313487,
-0.0090744905,
-0.0171372034,
0.0441220887,
-0.0388244838,
0.0086462712,
-0.0026914566,
0.0746177286,
-0.0211962126,
-0.0222548619,
-0.0297941994,
-0.0036630908,
0.00848627,
-0.0336403325,
-0.0627482086,
0.0293275472,
-0.0057421243,
0.0073097483,
0.0780727267,
0.0439730324,
0.0302447639,
0.0168281533,
-0.0510011055,
0.0571565069,
-0.0028172659,
-0.0458159447,
0.0235234499,
0.0147203906,
-0.0367953852,
-0.0267569162,
0.010477473,
0.0453135185,
-0.0277490318,
0.0451998487,
-0.0087062204,
-0.0405477732,
0.0500357039,
-0.0769556463,
0.0050888364,
0.0375478975,
-0.0158230066,
0.0842796788,
-0.0275632795,
0.0166194923,
-0.0131427301,
-0.0143554863,
-0.0287973899,
-0.0224866848,
-0.0216647573,
-0.0048389463,
-0.0451986715,
0.0208745357,
-0.0249719266,
-0.0360123776,
-0.0129169282,
0.0720951036,
0.0051277103,
0.0078196563,
0.006923236,
-0.0012730471,
-0.0137648173,
0.0013576624,
0.0230395366,
0.0226272792,
-0.0420202799,
0.0264486559,
-0.0035188105,
-0.0299095139,
-0.0369610637,
0.0309290644,
-0.0281035472,
-0.0323405899,
-0.0109458771,
0.0259572603,
-0.0159775596,
-0.0504835099,
-0.0204958972,
-0.0124810003,
-0.0593511686,
-0.0602396429,
-0.0224823207,
-0.0688344091,
0.0257695522,
0.0076634348,
-0.0063561616,
0.0236599259,
-0.0108292894,
0.0259137359,
-0.0191505793,
0.0997510999,
0.0159562752,
-0.0328894481,
0.045498725,
0.045437403,
0.0156541262,
0.1159429699,
-0.0087800035,
0.0168204475,
0.0209829062,
0.0239943899,
-0.0096756555,
0.0080286218,
0.0075624003,
0.0021693625,
-0.0393696278,
0.0598400198,
0.0118087521,
0.0409014374,
-0.0122493077,
0.0278705973,
-0.0206884891,
-0.0269209482,
0.0155421318,
0.0627331659,
0.0089948662,
-0.0111837452,
0.0252629947,
-0.0249305088,
0.0095302891,
0.0285952389,
-0.0388533399,
0.019042613,
-0.0156664811,
0.0168341007,
0.053614568,
0.0079910103,
-0.036392469,
-0.029712325,
-0.0120969592,
0.0170613695,
-0.027008865,
0.0247055665,
0.0367690399,
-0.0176434703,
-0.0241569802,
0.0238100756,
0.023024004,
-0.0251565184,
-0.0429421291,
-0.0272745714,
0.0093373135,
0.0262138695,
0.0315452293,
-0.0488572791,
-0.0330326594,
-0.0268033464,
0.0337416083,
0.0127632339,
0.0556918792,
-0.0120627442,
0.0149488682,
-0.0273329876,
-0.0121860709,
-0.0243476611,
0.0190555137,
-0.0100856898,
-0.0008163131,
0.0081786066,
0.0233949255,
-0.0058789994,
0.0325382054,
0.0318513848,
-0.0036821156,
-0.0336250141,
-0.0141872307,
0.0216862317,
0.0477229096,
-0.0033295583,
0.0329577997,
0.0049475622,
0.0355915017,
-0.0440832451,
0.0026662503,
0.0046784207,
-0.0816992074,
-0.0948075429,
0.0449862741,
-0.0109623419,
-0.020982191,
-0.01133148,
-0.0506214909,
-0.0416673534,
-0.0041526416,
-0.0184386987,
0.0342100523,
-0.0406046622,
0.022541495,
-0.0277736876,
0.0292089097,
-0.0724266618,
0.083855547,
-0.0297948048,
0.0269901827,
0.0403720811,
0.0198973026,
0.0253494661,
-0.0209875181,
-0.0054500266,
0.0445711613,
0.0159515142,
-0.0145161925,
-0.0338384323,
-0.0140230423,
-0.0561708994,
-0.0230192598,
-0.1120770723,
0.012827063,
-0.0389888287,
0.0395630263,
0.0198694933,
0.0148847699,
-0.0067907912,
-0.0098810866,
-0.0396756791,
0.0083820838,
-0.019861253,
0.0230566319,
0.0412588082,
0.0096397419,
0.0084193172,
-0.019377524,
-0.0149436807,
-0.0216228012,
0.0815878659,
0.001091562,
-0.0307731256,
-0.0396020487,
0.0327290297,
-0.0105080931,
0.0049623814,
-0.0336697847,
0.0297925156,
0.0037194199,
-0.0298553891,
0.0186774302,
0.0766500309,
-0.0175820217,
0.0266165528,
0.0522748269,
0.0249775518,
-0.0341809653,
0.0344111174,
0.0211160257,
0.0106624989,
0.0030341321,
0.0050434954,
0.00165779,
0.0652156994,
-0.0281658638,
-0.0270251725,
-0.0122244265,
0.0096275685,
-0.0047743055,
-0.0095541719,
-0.0511891656,
-0.0221603215,
-0.005188948,
0.0145436404,
-0.0148603385,
-0.0461094752,
0.0856489763,
-0.0481129289,
0.0094141914,
-0.0808052942,
-0.0165050309,
-0.0712446943,
0.0625645295,
-0.0279845856,
0.0018524256,
-0.0317923613,
-0.0137684131,
-0.0441288017,
0.0039001869,
-0.0394716784,
0.012293973,
0.0645382181,
-0.0091315405,
0.0197943505,
-0.0442770272,
-0.0253967736,
-0.053600207,
-0.0508246347,
-0.0403333232,
0.0099738874,
0.0201640166,
0.0164389666,
-0.0296121426,
0.0321180448,
0.0272195209,
0.0520415232,
-0.0213654395,
-0.0190560352,
0.0007370982,
0.0620900057,
0.0299797859,
-0.0073694307,
0.0361622237,
-0.0350538231,
0.0644507557,
0.0577621609,
0.0427222401,
0.0077119726,
-0.0019091554,
-0.0280652139,
0.0108366469,
-0.0368123241,
-0.0383800082,
-0.0092086401,
0.0233811736,
-0.0928690955,
-0.0098258993,
0.116880931,
0.0635813251,
-0.099031955,
-0.0083373925,
-0.0349835418,
0.0046768356,
0.0237190556,
0.0403055362,
-0.0665240809,
-0.0497893021,
0.004930058,
0.0108763967,
-0.0029908696,
-0.0251858886,
-0.0138400039,
-0.0738383979,
0.0201453697,
-0.0051649469,
-0.0536614917,
0.0118877059,
-0.0436361656,
0.0216936991,
0.0552182347,
0.0129435305,
0.0473784469,
-0.0068930089,
-0.0106385341,
-0.0014195521,
0.0032326009,
-0.0020771744,
0.0422883332,
0.0023502761,
0.0107679889,
-0.0001830573,
0.0133838244,
0.0156840235,
-0.0463085435,
0.041951105,
-0.0910218209,
-0.0000301721,
-0.0148876989,
0.0094825039,
-0.0217400212,
0.010592727,
-0.0037952471,
0.0207169391,
-0.0566510335,
-0.0024378914,
0.0160707477,
0.1057253107,
-0.0267642438,
-0.0231180973,
-0.0315777063,
-0.0106663425,
0.0025136527,
0.0789718032,
0.0481724031,
-0.0424953327,
-0.0462687463,
-0.0090358807,
-0.0421863794,
-0.0288070086,
0.0424366631,
-0.0049199187,
0.0362608731,
-0.0033071227,
-0.0248176772,
-0.0692427531,
0.0493484624,
0.0487259999,
-0.0328926779,
0.02872058,
-0.0316634141,
-0.007488932,
-0.0421877801,
-0.0026931211,
-0.0150998877,
0.0311305821,
-0.0175518449,
0.0664392561,
0.0357516259,
-0.0029391304,
-0.0040919296,
0.04699222,
-0.1119803265,
-0.0530757904,
-0.0272017196,
0.0078529743,
0.0129528521,
0.0360009968,
-0.0244886391,
-0.0516074523,
0.0282087028,
0.0049098674,
0.0051681693,
0.0214381665,
0.0112525309,
0.0158543196,
0.0144033274,
0.0493881255,
-0.0223617461,
0.0151221091,
0.0101115694,
0.019314358,
-0.0385632701,
-0.0067271478,
-0.0027615367,
-0.0349021927,
0.0027880683,
-0.0020097322,
-0.0006766082,
-0.0031736339,
0.0707686841,
-0.0044254484,
-0.0175839812,
-0.0094554285,
0.0030792998,
0.0005141542,
-0.0377419442,
0.007744119,
-0.0080492357,
0.0035208866,
-0.0077141179,
-0.0178147443,
0.0440091081,
0.0193659198,
0.0112349084,
-0.0043912297,
0.0156499427,
-0.0393357165,
-0.0137268454,
-0.0047823871,
0.0482018851,
-0.0079109995,
0.0744873807,
0.021586474,
-0.0148667609,
-0.0357393585,
0.0283083059,
-0.1045985222,
-0.0027012874,
0.0190588348,
0.0385082066,
0.0409668609,
-0.0111889355,
-0.0024922173,
0.0246648081,
-0.0262464155,
-0.0058746599,
0.0192992557,
0.0088217314,
-0.0366523787,
0.0207986441,
0.0489755981,
-0.0101099759,
0.0227069333,
0.0668326095,
-0.0134711694,
0.0059000733,
0.0461583473,
-0.0151203927,
-0.0444372185,
-0.0104107708,
-0.006376843,
0.0801651701,
-0.0155599955,
0.0051964363,
-0.0660734177,
-0.0800033361,
0.0164406467,
-0.001168696,
-0.0156647917,
0.0065770615,
0.0026959789,
0.0529949479,
0.0354900323,
-0.0149893388,
-0.0174234379,
0.027095018,
-0.0146702994,
-0.0221764576,
-0.0258529969,
-6.132734026e-33,
-0.013055996,
-0.0367633887,
0.0045215758,
-0.0323386863,
-0.0262764338,
0.0253104493,
-0.0435413048,
-0.0193745829,
-0.0142287062,
0.006909715,
-0.0348808914,
0.0183574222,
-0.0035404791,
0.0261921529,
-0.0037848952,
-0.0099722082,
0.0112789972,
0.0152502274,
-0.0061606485,
0.0121873002,
0.0405851528,
0.0253225416,
0.037178807,
-0.0304034576,
0.0588614978,
-0.0172441322,
0.0126834717,
0.0322742239,
-0.0332682095,
0.0526162349,
-0.0224675015,
0.0320523456,
0.0426090136,
-0.0371130966,
-0.0124160899,
0.0407361202,
-0.0713563263,
-0.0239579715,
0.0403338186,
0.0031366451,
-0.0367771946,
-0.0485746711,
0.03796947,
0.0181815904,
0.0599850528,
-0.0572953261,
0.0200471431,
-0.0341128521,
-0.0318846814,
-0.0087168189,
-0.0407687686,
0.0161770787,
-0.0246716402,
0.02608856,
0.0173231252,
0.0304874051,
0.0164627265,
0.0658241883,
-0.0762009844,
-0.040208891,
0.0044728769,
-0.0027796377,
0.0750183016,
0.015990762,
0.0160008129,
0.011263309,
0.0030399619,
0.0009647626,
-0.0366661474,
-0.0651914254,
0.003592473,
0.0025263398,
0.0432527512,
0.0074834065,
0.0477224626,
0.0227628518,
-0.1072414592,
-0.0062976689,
0.0273774639,
0.0338214114,
0.0269230101,
0.0017515207,
-0.0458213687,
-0.0323762931,
-0.0222164616,
-0.0119335447,
-0.0457479917,
0.0068671112,
0.0408265516,
0.0030048094,
0.0114817517,
0.0214141551,
0.0341736898,
-0.0451895706,
-0.0044626747,
0.0313747153,
0.0060056872,
0.0200588088,
0.0330697782,
0.0310468916,
-0.0433031023,
0.0312744752,
-0.0011850125,
0.0313395858,
-0.0017575804,
-0.0128129916,
0.0779171363,
-0.0240254961,
-0.0620275065,
-0.0349321328,
-0.0406604111,
0.0092740795,
-0.0131931081,
0.0678803548,
0.0264946856,
-0.0012118816,
0.0115470281,
0.0473780632,
0.0259737633,
-0.0300433375,
-0.0194024816,
-0.0042069065,
-0.0317096822,
-0.0039070901,
-0.0123726511,
-0.0078782532,
0.0217470452,
0.0270415638,
0.0521054268,
-0.081640549,
0.0007545405,
0.0247896165,
2.549e-7,
0.0701534227,
0.0402845256,
0.0012045545,
-0.0168096554,
0.0298784692,
0.0250816029,
-0.0233053062,
0.0293813236,
0.0065322951,
0.0000803845,
0.0022955611,
0.0231214724,
0.0262600426,
0.0250937976,
-0.0913736895,
-0.0098049836,
-0.057463441,
0.0146921705,
-0.0464421175,
-0.0166444834,
0.0715318471,
0.1134617776,
-0.0139298514,
-0.0137016876,
-0.0106125502,
-0.0290667657,
0.0435439125,
-0.0043641673,
0.0091098668,
0.0183860138,
0.0194915123,
-0.0047302162,
0.0019812207,
0.0271891579,
0.0149419252,
0.0482790433,
-0.0126955267,
0.0521094613,
0.0033973886,
-0.0433358103,
-0.0045032185,
-0.0469800867,
0.0233703516,
-0.0982810259,
0.1037103161,
-0.0628640801,
-0.0141091254,
-0.0290006585,
-0.0024513768,
-0.0098248469,
0.0558665246,
0.0414810032,
0.0318930522,
0.0142022697,
-0.0258680936,
-0.0585642457,
-0.0068120873,
-0.1202629134,
-0.0531311259,
-0.0131193977,
-0.0344991684,
-0.0029132133,
-0.0456297547,
-0.0276801772,
0.0531516932,
-0.0577272475,
0.0190737229,
2.490145422e-34,
0.033085417,
-0.0101828314,
0.0132509377,
0.0089027919,
-0.0113540627,
-0.0347777866,
0.0004761179,
-0.0023807276,
0.0533201993,
-0.1096604615,
0.0117530152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15255v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15255v4 | Spoken Question Answering and Speech Continuation Using Spectrogram-Powered LLM | 2023-05-24T15:39:43 | 2024-05-31T01:29:27 | Eliya Nachmani, Alon Levkovitch, Roy Hirsch, Julian Salazar, Chulayuth Asawaroengchai, Soroosh Mariooryad, Ehud Rivlin, RJ Skerry-Ryan, Michelle Tadmor Ramanovich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We present Spectron, a novel approach to adapting pre-trained large language
models (LLMs) to perform spoken question answering (QA) and speech
continuation. By endowing the LLM with a pre-trained speech encoder, our model
becomes able to take speech inputs and generate speech outputs. The entire
system is trained end-to-end and operates directly on spectrograms, simplifying
our architecture. Key to our approach is a training objective that jointly
supervises speech recognition, text continuation, and speech synthesis using
only paired speech-text pairs, enabling a `cross-modal' chain-of-thought within
a single decoding pass. Our method surpasses existing spoken language models in
speaker preservation and semantic coherence. Furthermore, the proposed model
improves upon direct initialization in retaining the knowledge of the original
LLM as demonstrated through spoken QA datasets. We release our audio samples
(https://michelleramanovich.github.io/spectron/spectron) and spoken QA dataset
(https://github.com/google-research-datasets/LLAMA1-Test-Set). | [
-0.0059467317,
0.0771594942,
0.0144571392,
0.0097845439,
-0.0161239766,
-0.034351889,
0.0211551692,
-0.0303121153,
-0.0630477145,
-0.0158810262,
-0.0609942861,
-0.0276409667,
-0.0018917701,
0.0449661873,
0.0068678376,
-0.0459012017,
0.0520602316,
-0.0878092498,
-0.0241658371,
-0.0418266356,
0.0087324791,
-0.003371509,
-0.0232952368,
-0.0061583137,
-0.0136362361,
-0.0024095511,
-0.0234468337,
0.0006532595,
0.0067681954,
-0.0012672632,
-0.0061460189,
0.0011461375,
0.0242184717,
-0.0395324528,
0.000001921,
-0.0563514009,
-0.0011349719,
-0.0179596227,
-0.047403384,
0.0028309531,
-0.0319993645,
-0.0016352467,
0.0140149146,
0.0391639285,
-0.0112010902,
0.0089347418,
0.0037467692,
-0.0044659218,
0.0908492729,
0.0512883365,
0.0044851033,
-0.0361684151,
0.0531503335,
-0.0271329861,
0.0061638891,
0.0076340158,
-0.0230542794,
-0.0084436554,
0.0097881621,
0.0348001681,
-0.0218009464,
0.0628821552,
0.0026139342,
0.0028053024,
0.0069099823,
0.0046301894,
-0.0152605232,
-0.0405663997,
-0.0195517037,
0.1064147726,
0.0577675812,
-0.0011660589,
0.0281279162,
0.0295087509,
-0.0326974466,
0.00210544,
-0.0259668045,
0.0104560116,
0.0359314568,
-0.0039487616,
-0.0029650545,
-0.006526731,
-0.021141177,
0.0101695852,
-0.0279751327,
0.0421959497,
0.0223367624,
0.0029460941,
-0.0065053534,
-0.027758589,
-0.0185323916,
-0.0364145786,
0.0454754271,
0.0630099252,
-0.0314774215,
0.0238972362,
-0.041461397,
-0.0147161856,
-0.0278779063,
0.0278758723,
-0.0091019459,
0.0233358201,
-0.0533894897,
0.0531913675,
-0.0367533714,
0.0040410645,
0.0043744678,
0.0279274713,
-0.053624168,
-0.0353474766,
-0.0169964153,
-0.0108186994,
-0.0397308096,
0.0302028321,
-0.0335932933,
-0.0280186273,
-0.0117661189,
0.0052136038,
0.0164413415,
0.0391171426,
-0.0147091551,
0.0232184362,
-0.0282486975,
-0.0128064053,
-0.0060190214,
0.0619283579,
0.0011910332,
0.0169002991,
0.0274539888,
-0.0111904237,
-0.0222488735,
0.0253817029,
0.0085589532,
0.0183502603,
0.0575455949,
0.0608336814,
0.0028546643,
-0.0354132056,
0.0008478499,
-0.0546868406,
-0.0270813648,
-0.09928298,
0.0126627907,
-0.0436537936,
0.0499993451,
0.0073765921,
-0.0343867354,
-0.0089575006,
0.0033126732,
0.0053822072,
0.0171739422,
0.0860182196,
-0.0272456855,
0.0454607084,
0.0664943457,
0.0164380483,
0.0095458003,
0.0063110655,
0.069843255,
-0.0314987674,
0.0128998179,
-0.0462114997,
-0.0198754333,
0.0538856313,
0.0146843437,
0.0084625073,
-0.0416544303,
0.0124120712,
0.0033260644,
0.0196864568,
0.0397235453,
0.0263417829,
-0.0281568225,
0.0121048968,
0.0468778871,
0.0658283383,
0.0121161239,
0.0195982624,
0.0489429459,
0.0151028568,
0.0306308065,
-0.0031917379,
-0.0262307562,
-0.0072935778,
-0.0300848167,
0.0257852916,
0.0188149232,
0.0067895516,
-0.0680620149,
-0.0174112637,
0.0484273806,
-0.0184212346,
0.0130382003,
0.0428048223,
0.0678572878,
0.0136479577,
-0.036399696,
0.061268229,
0.0082101952,
-0.0596294887,
0.0365313478,
-0.0145933824,
0.063486591,
0.0773125738,
0.0221278314,
-0.0441100448,
-0.0322254002,
-0.0121272029,
-0.0105370451,
0.0204875022,
0.0162270386,
-0.0174814891,
0.0574919246,
-0.0495277494,
-0.0110356323,
-0.0046166559,
-0.0313026421,
0.0293674711,
-0.0335633941,
0.0399123915,
0.0331757739,
-0.0226984695,
0.0663815588,
0.0039464002,
-0.0602870733,
-0.0162683185,
-0.0135313803,
-0.0203686263,
0.0327652544,
0.032837458,
-0.0276235547,
0.0358878598,
0.0676064417,
-0.0284035653,
0.0036258544,
-0.0081729684,
-0.0859147459,
-0.0893661231,
0.0522843376,
-0.0358303301,
0.0129715623,
0.0501694679,
-0.0030489552,
-0.1020117998,
0.0348047093,
-0.030659318,
0.0214088038,
-0.0620774291,
0.0303619932,
0.048837468,
0.0312287472,
-0.0154386628,
0.0067521073,
0.0229680818,
-0.009904705,
0.0314079486,
0.0324429385,
-0.006296793,
-0.0384547226,
-0.0037648266,
0.0340076424,
0.0190412514,
0.0267688259,
0.0023655209,
-0.0072836513,
-0.0489410721,
0.0102667548,
-0.1119424328,
0.0387682989,
0.0054641888,
0.0132347867,
0.0259665567,
0.0139693655,
-0.0063648652,
-0.026450377,
-0.0497335903,
0.0217579883,
0.0367747471,
-0.0351417884,
-0.0325643905,
0.0241679139,
-0.0426876023,
-0.0258981809,
-0.0209242366,
0.0366424583,
0.0130672241,
-0.0427331962,
-0.010969081,
-0.088906914,
0.0158376712,
-0.0410118736,
0.0362637863,
-0.0192442182,
-0.0373863578,
-0.0316903591,
-0.0261614695,
0.0270936918,
0.0320597515,
0.0252071861,
-0.0464316495,
0.0215024725,
-0.0242657922,
-0.0392883867,
0.0181223582,
-0.0061562122,
0.0396085009,
-0.0106402123,
0.031310942,
0.0188495424,
0.0229842942,
0.0137885576,
0.0171303675,
0.0007257806,
-0.0422959588,
0.0333557278,
-0.049551297,
-0.0176515579,
-0.0431226492,
-0.041757226,
0.0294050388,
0.0102284802,
-0.0090027936,
0.0392543599,
-0.0743623823,
-0.0254881736,
-0.0513525344,
-0.0549382679,
-0.0168162845,
0.0571558475,
-0.0079955393,
0.0201968085,
0.0090756845,
-0.0154158138,
-0.0352120064,
-0.0286464579,
-0.0116535127,
-0.0467591844,
0.0349072218,
-0.0501936264,
0.0196273234,
-0.011710939,
-0.0219826214,
-0.0598033182,
-0.0335834026,
-0.05995363,
0.0287291054,
-0.0109213237,
-0.0011512409,
0.0117445197,
0.024844313,
0.029118875,
0.0523162037,
0.0064919353,
0.0360959694,
-0.0433239378,
0.0820717737,
0.057167612,
0.0181978177,
0.0097742183,
-0.0470754839,
0.0631349161,
0.0299434606,
0.0282746032,
0.0127430735,
-0.0254955087,
-0.0054201935,
0.02552527,
0.0181948692,
-0.0629044101,
0.0062605455,
0.0515889786,
-0.0600713156,
-0.0123069007,
0.1110728905,
-0.0021978221,
0.0101028671,
-0.0173599329,
-0.0024081501,
0.0318604074,
-0.0059028338,
0.0057912553,
-0.0693721324,
-0.07282684,
0.0529813208,
-0.0007775237,
0.0549574606,
0.0015162901,
-0.0420884229,
-0.0723664463,
0.0132899126,
0.0336697847,
-0.0204471257,
0.0088178711,
-0.0109162955,
-0.0089093512,
0.0329726264,
0.0203919243,
0.0266812742,
-0.012258417,
-0.0243035406,
0.019855151,
-0.0369509608,
0.0292711649,
0.0123155406,
-0.0034010611,
0.0429358259,
0.067334488,
-0.0161840152,
-0.011214233,
-0.0088835768,
0.0708549768,
-0.0331266522,
0.0109118931,
-0.0054961843,
0.0739302784,
-0.0102811139,
-0.0176959839,
0.0077470015,
0.0772568658,
-0.042909041,
0.0127327433,
0.030747354,
0.0356745496,
-0.0556754954,
-0.049304653,
-0.0105783083,
0.0272684861,
-0.0283387043,
0.0764090121,
0.0206778906,
-0.0717674941,
-0.0490430221,
0.0030149356,
0.0033854507,
-0.0275180526,
0.0029151996,
-0.0055912002,
0.0180642363,
0.0258052275,
-0.0443970263,
-0.0125436196,
0.0396936759,
0.0201149881,
-0.007141259,
0.0154042682,
0.03462236,
-0.007567598,
-0.031124346,
0.036901325,
-0.0687013492,
0.0126171652,
-0.0883333236,
-0.001199454,
0.0795195103,
-0.0623435788,
-0.0127442749,
-0.0154012693,
-0.0684358999,
-0.0481056497,
-0.0140901161,
-0.0013920849,
0.0182213224,
0.0644560829,
-0.033762034,
-0.0314046033,
0.084428288,
-0.0335476026,
-0.0822665021,
0.0415920988,
0.0507610217,
0.0183675252,
-0.0259625558,
0.0197712984,
-0.0372333489,
0.0339003168,
-0.0028544525,
0.0349224657,
-0.0090526193,
-0.0668864399,
0.0115354825,
0.0100696022,
0.0692165419,
-0.0123089142,
0.0381133258,
-0.0105994036,
0.007350741,
-0.0047178864,
0.0144192781,
-0.065431796,
0.0077657071,
0.0129261222,
-0.0085173398,
-0.0032689334,
-0.0411694534,
-0.0234928243,
0.0139979701,
0.004534388,
0.0335312895,
-0.0056086001,
-0.0354619548,
0.0290022716,
-0.0313921012,
-0.0080457125,
0.0001282234,
0.0214711335,
0.0433564447,
-0.0228882413,
0.0425313301,
0.0220808014,
-0.0127838114,
-0.0212251898,
0.0330272019,
-0.0707421526,
-0.0790130794,
0.0015099819,
0.0373301916,
0.0274252351,
0.030364925,
0.0113514969,
0.0134648504,
0.0018308364,
-0.0392588936,
0.0468066223,
-0.0036597855,
0.0232699513,
0.0660688952,
-0.0045803678,
-0.0094648972,
0.046602156,
0.0488940403,
0.032793209,
0.0377621055,
-0.0037989777,
0.0536359139,
-0.0547728688,
-0.0152765391,
-0.0577322058,
0.0126205264,
-0.0380703472,
-0.0023198398,
0.0104573369,
-0.0567199849,
0.0116845155,
-0.0187642835,
-0.0317515768,
-0.0115893679,
0.0559755452,
-0.0158638712,
-0.0189571269,
-0.0002085403,
0.0340397432,
0.0017135147,
0.0299376883,
-0.0187722016,
0.0596432239,
-6.240086047e-33,
-0.0542992614,
0.0220512394,
0.0346321799,
0.0162633229,
-0.0671871454,
-0.0171592869,
-0.0418347158,
-0.0016324468,
-0.0215002745,
-0.0415023901,
-0.0372048914,
0.0199655145,
0.0027756493,
0.0680248365,
-0.0125135835,
-0.0535270348,
0.0573912933,
-0.0038964385,
0.0051106117,
0.0238525663,
0.0206664167,
0.0582189411,
0.0179264955,
-0.045046676,
-0.0459632128,
-0.0093674483,
-0.0052196132,
-0.0178062674,
-0.0205703843,
0.0265103001,
-0.0398696139,
0.0485859215,
-0.0047229715,
-0.0213008728,
-0.0362801999,
0.0891515091,
-0.1093196645,
-0.0249141846,
0.0042016716,
-0.0075615137,
-0.067961067,
-0.0221794508,
0.0107892677,
0.0156110805,
0.0165534988,
-0.0228226278,
0.0195913706,
-0.012554843,
0.022737395,
-0.0049956958,
-0.0121493666,
0.0115603246,
-0.017272329,
-0.0513969138,
0.0370551795,
0.0697875097,
-0.0062143863,
-0.0151749263,
-0.0244766846,
0.0463231169,
-0.0048882803,
0.0341387652,
0.0348416194,
0.0471421853,
0.000535056,
0.0450388007,
0.0357171036,
-0.0851540715,
0.0488600321,
-0.0406268537,
0.0139368717,
0.0276682898,
0.005092191,
0.0052935458,
-0.012683426,
-0.0396416932,
-0.0417843945,
-0.0231451616,
0.021664286,
0.0098840874,
-0.0067077135,
-0.0061319913,
0.0369745046,
-0.0191746317,
-0.0856781229,
0.0332316943,
-0.0092075691,
0.0039218315,
0.0449343137,
0.0205736347,
-0.0219401643,
-0.037088234,
0.065093711,
-0.0429046862,
0.0125778913,
0.0255365297,
-0.0389998071,
0.0303325094,
0.0078217452,
0.0592762008,
-0.0496967807,
-0.0264089778,
0.0535370111,
0.0007439304,
-0.0108055742,
0.0018501513,
0.0003888411,
0.033839386,
-0.0315709636,
-0.0046296171,
0.0075691878,
0.0381642692,
-0.0141431866,
-0.0224397872,
0.0222647451,
0.0437283441,
-0.0221365392,
0.0657778978,
-0.0343166254,
0.0043245931,
-0.0309598446,
-0.0704003423,
0.0163927041,
0.0429902561,
-0.0465818085,
0.0312852748,
-0.0207664613,
-0.0376721174,
0.0326067992,
-0.0443818271,
-0.0166782886,
0.0180541817,
2.712e-7,
0.017417457,
-0.0109922159,
0.0414400771,
-0.0167959146,
0.0305159185,
0.0374548547,
-0.0159541927,
-0.0008599473,
0.0116252787,
-0.0530364625,
0.0037717375,
0.0211579781,
0.0732118338,
-0.0291656815,
-0.087160334,
-0.0346348621,
0.0028946586,
0.0071765226,
-0.0451423973,
0.0091042137,
0.0385021418,
0.0854329169,
-0.0374594554,
-0.0265627094,
-0.0060195411,
-0.0104376115,
0.0714136139,
-0.0435411856,
-0.0325447991,
0.004943348,
-0.0234175026,
0.0101549299,
-0.0015525407,
0.0195127986,
-0.0212406125,
0.0403160751,
0.0172674749,
0.0643099993,
0.0350443199,
-0.0528378189,
0.0130833331,
0.0371583141,
0.012203929,
0.017301904,
0.0866877437,
-0.0012121588,
-0.0053454302,
-0.010039675,
-0.0682770386,
-0.0200308673,
-0.0094421757,
-0.0141854882,
-0.0259442348,
-0.0043760301,
0.0242846459,
0.0068895277,
-0.0336235054,
-0.0677899867,
0.004231405,
0.0238717161,
-0.0796943009,
-0.0226287041,
-0.0120654181,
-0.0050340765,
0.0292296652,
-0.0554723144,
-0.0096773077,
2.267663831e-34,
0.0353733674,
-0.0003232564,
0.0347913355,
0.0267017502,
-0.0074601662,
-0.0402963609,
-0.0384069793,
0.0010770651,
0.0336299576,
-0.0753164887,
-0.0347950943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15233v1 | Boosting Cross-lingual Transferability in Multilingual Models via In-Context Learning | 2023-05-24T15:14:49 | 2023-05-24T15:14:49 | Sunkyoung Kim, Dayeon Ki, Yireun Kim, Jinsik Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing cross-lingual transfer (CLT) prompting methods are only concerned
with monolingual demonstration examples in the source language. In this paper,
we propose In-CLT, a novel cross-lingual transfer prompting method that
leverages both source and target languages to construct the demonstration
examples. We conduct comprehensive evaluations on multilingual benchmarks,
focusing on question answering tasks. Experiment results show that In-CLT
prompt not only improves multilingual models' cross-lingual transferability,
but also demonstrates remarkable unseen language generalization ability. In-CLT
prompting, in particular, improves model performance by 10 to 20\% points on
average when compared to prior cross-lingual transfer approaches. We also
observe the surprising performance gain on the other multilingual benchmarks,
especially in reasoning tasks. Furthermore, we investigate the relationship
between lexical similarity and pre-training corpora in terms of the
cross-lingual transfer gap. | [
-0.0323368981,
0.0105458628,
0.0088092601,
0.0681991354,
-0.0312897526,
0.0101323798,
0.0068237009,
-0.0167853106,
-0.0080634607,
-0.0133693861,
-0.0665013343,
-0.0435951278,
-0.0362777226,
-0.015483235,
0.0247471705,
-0.0523284897,
0.0784441531,
-0.0662617609,
-0.0293541607,
-0.0112123489,
-0.0177350044,
0.0005832743,
-0.0051057097,
-0.0175676215,
0.0079211118,
-0.0299898703,
0.0134636154,
-0.0062009748,
0.0326888748,
-0.015559,
-0.0001717406,
0.0404985286,
0.0205043592,
-0.0034773638,
0.000002078,
-0.0616585948,
-0.0247607995,
-0.0006457195,
-0.0123916995,
-0.013954726,
0.0022962282,
-0.0344357714,
0.013756182,
-0.0008000717,
-0.0340188071,
-0.0121621024,
0.0423059426,
0.0291821752,
0.0464332439,
0.0650209263,
-0.0156530719,
0.0243145619,
0.0080147367,
-0.0212844908,
0.0088907778,
-0.0472041592,
-0.0106008435,
0.037731573,
0.007296802,
0.0028474499,
-0.0311241169,
0.0462196693,
0.0373404883,
0.0279836394,
-0.0251904614,
0.0119485585,
-0.0273651443,
0.026025584,
-0.0333730839,
0.0925001279,
-0.0343117379,
-0.0341511406,
-0.0493058711,
0.0127093419,
0.0144879054,
-0.0011343405,
-0.085583128,
0.0057585821,
0.0068317498,
0.0130116483,
0.0454009101,
0.0135190487,
0.0258844141,
-0.0063315127,
-0.0218503159,
0.0739783049,
0.0406527855,
-0.0233902745,
0.0582881719,
0.0196819678,
-0.0105131315,
-0.0371656008,
-0.0184917729,
0.0304977614,
-0.0479453392,
0.0248551518,
-0.0435827002,
0.0021541023,
0.0129635744,
-0.0168054421,
0.047189232,
0.0405569524,
-0.0527465641,
0.0805313438,
-0.0689899102,
0.037242718,
-0.0199849531,
0.035964746,
-0.0534672029,
-0.077713117,
-0.0510425344,
0.0034750123,
-0.0477113314,
0.0188998524,
-0.0027761373,
-0.0107630678,
-0.0291172527,
0.0086326478,
-0.0164358523,
-0.0125240926,
-0.0012779577,
-0.0487939194,
-0.0269615371,
-0.0089909341,
-0.014454551,
0.0394572355,
-0.0721666813,
0.0111743016,
0.0097689526,
-0.0777688622,
-0.0446266569,
0.0118804565,
0.005414506,
-0.0647733435,
0.0233562253,
0.0616095439,
-0.0542121641,
-0.0136509798,
-0.0299093574,
0.0226593539,
0.0200120583,
-0.0485184453,
0.0204009563,
-0.0791608691,
0.0488169715,
0.0038256808,
0.0254479945,
-0.0031923514,
-0.0132191768,
0.0251320414,
-0.0112916296,
0.0771456882,
-0.0165664125,
-0.001036395,
0.0005796295,
-0.0074994336,
-0.0405057147,
0.0808083862,
-0.0110542867,
-0.0363526568,
0.0654858649,
-0.0160879623,
-0.0143131679,
0.0489902236,
0.059298683,
0.0236802567,
-0.0082963081,
0.0246354192,
0.0589364693,
0.0031062854,
0.0185284056,
0.003736102,
-0.0214189906,
0.0038821844,
0.02653208,
0.041256275,
0.0120595898,
0.0078495499,
0.055471316,
-0.0329201967,
-0.0298257563,
0.0174453687,
-0.0428386405,
0.0261412635,
-0.0358962864,
0.0185111836,
0.0026989719,
0.0534368455,
-0.0527794287,
0.0160217658,
0.0241356734,
-0.0190143306,
0.0215918794,
0.0150189428,
0.0508876219,
0.0655064508,
-0.0311059803,
0.0534933247,
0.073753044,
-0.0565543212,
0.0181154832,
-0.0213756394,
0.05212247,
0.0321536399,
-0.0134313237,
-0.003318897,
-0.0364007093,
-0.0118323117,
0.0535617657,
-0.0165900253,
0.0618663244,
-0.0318942219,
0.0582623854,
-0.0404713862,
-0.0029310931,
-0.0384299047,
-0.0200768672,
0.0597507879,
0.0098371888,
0.0736344978,
0.0052364604,
-0.0727399886,
0.019246662,
0.0093323924,
-0.0755692571,
-0.0186769851,
0.0331544876,
0.019920921,
0.0051745549,
0.0227304865,
0.0161034912,
-0.0065946896,
0.0113630807,
-0.0657391623,
-0.0042718295,
0.0347190686,
-0.0732290596,
-0.0748847574,
0.0093025398,
-0.0198703818,
-0.0061526056,
0.0166475419,
-0.0244266465,
-0.0382871814,
-0.0084259678,
0.0254324581,
0.0433742329,
-0.042665638,
-0.0030665419,
0.0063259783,
0.041417215,
-0.0037437757,
0.056359347,
0.0436485931,
0.0412067585,
0.0371888019,
0.0024010055,
0.0383471549,
-0.0358839594,
-0.0018816167,
0.0356432572,
-0.0238843821,
-0.0059426748,
0.0361633338,
0.0384808071,
-0.0338526666,
0.0291073434,
-0.0805437341,
0.0146400761,
-0.0279378202,
0.0293276347,
0.0236957557,
0.0348853432,
-0.0143368114,
-0.0362913944,
-0.059741471,
-0.0031059014,
0.0284137297,
0.0453182757,
0.0303729326,
0.0031300462,
0.0222202819,
-0.0264871791,
-0.0170640815,
0.0254878253,
0.0596579835,
-0.0600881316,
-0.0036006202,
-0.0484490171,
0.0262858514,
-0.0352625027,
0.0072455155,
-0.0196983628,
0.0109604653,
-0.0219005607,
-0.0097451461,
0.0350457877,
0.0456006005,
-0.0267875195,
-0.0477397628,
0.0191685781,
-0.0208067764,
-0.0577650107,
0.0190523826,
0.0123809893,
-0.006361987,
-0.0233924538,
-0.0118829226,
0.0174222309,
0.0450154953,
-0.0121815074,
-0.0306025222,
-0.0554602854,
-0.0106918439,
-0.0225386377,
-0.0159201324,
-0.0677355155,
0.0439849421,
0.0143241417,
0.0394412093,
-0.0130909933,
-0.013751681,
0.0572333261,
-0.0350424983,
-0.0213470384,
-0.0639177561,
-0.0087730493,
-0.0434172973,
0.0469205193,
-0.0278462302,
0.0257543474,
-0.0080090137,
-0.01669975,
-0.0433574654,
-0.0287780948,
0.0236319229,
0.0099024028,
0.0336426385,
-0.0269974004,
-0.0024455409,
-0.0028361399,
-0.0403569005,
-0.0460346527,
-0.0156403705,
0.0050648428,
0.0429682322,
-0.0219345782,
0.013172484,
0.0023357398,
-0.0184525643,
0.0423304662,
0.0336304642,
-0.0045336904,
0.0186908431,
-0.0066550202,
0.0564581603,
0.0286162272,
0.0236848872,
-0.0012529906,
-0.0460283495,
0.0260411128,
0.0120935477,
0.0365983248,
-0.0210358966,
-0.0132801291,
0.0213139188,
0.0513048247,
-0.0088940151,
-0.0424040668,
0.0051158769,
0.0816842392,
-0.01922407,
-0.015711138,
0.0825367421,
0.002502948,
-0.0264301337,
0.0034205983,
-0.0573362522,
0.0224749371,
0.0402582586,
0.0448667407,
-0.0726926774,
-0.0500440225,
-0.0015244838,
-0.0197517052,
0.0427751057,
-0.0080515724,
-0.0289644152,
-0.1482468098,
0.0084756557,
-0.01588252,
-0.1104871631,
-0.0395228826,
-0.0683784932,
-0.0000725429,
-0.0036810308,
0.0203331392,
-0.0337555073,
0.0005877191,
0.0072763017,
0.0202145241,
0.0174931753,
-0.0539602377,
0.0396958627,
-0.0455038399,
0.0118687656,
0.0444939137,
0.0355160087,
-0.0233620536,
-0.0420381129,
0.0276038907,
-0.038031105,
-0.0068186997,
-0.0206248909,
0.0382410213,
0.0145707913,
-0.0272886902,
0.0360701121,
0.0340313278,
-0.0276632346,
-0.0186885986,
0.0635654852,
0.1069481075,
0.0540482923,
-0.0289503206,
0.0192932114,
-0.0203193165,
0.0386187807,
0.0684773102,
0.0164754745,
-0.0250796694,
0.0013899278,
0.0122876586,
-0.0222103428,
-0.0375598446,
0.0147004109,
0.0113807106,
-0.0261566155,
-0.0057708006,
-0.0763912722,
-0.0641622916,
0.0189142209,
0.0519109406,
0.0150460498,
0.0173461977,
-0.0524443388,
0.0083973072,
-0.0051916996,
0.0295399558,
-0.0473169126,
0.0294054206,
-0.0444313847,
-0.0003726204,
0.0152259879,
-0.044037886,
-0.0292302519,
-0.018371081,
-0.0295168813,
-0.0431719311,
-0.0548372678,
0.0727330968,
-0.0001031678,
0.0854294598,
-0.0201365221,
-0.006525334,
0.0489957221,
-0.030009767,
-0.0033834251,
-0.0097814975,
0.0677194372,
0.009742558,
0.007404611,
0.0583605431,
-0.0356559269,
0.0154371867,
0.0305743497,
0.0332630612,
-0.0341128632,
-0.0301581845,
0.027926933,
0.0102497255,
-0.0061887447,
0.0224162973,
-0.0123315426,
-0.0355117805,
0.0280021057,
-0.0113202967,
-0.0222621132,
-0.038749855,
-0.001142226,
0.0374982134,
-0.0506838411,
0.023011934,
0.0084528243,
-0.0067099552,
0.0001747936,
-0.0319471993,
-0.0057951971,
0.0656434819,
0.0519498512,
-0.012110821,
0.0088406419,
-0.0078858491,
-0.0430112705,
0.0198514629,
0.0431708954,
-0.0642910376,
0.0375993922,
0.0226933006,
-0.0185190775,
0.0136011634,
-0.003225693,
-0.0326028392,
-0.0341062918,
-0.0045557618,
0.0126451394,
0.051845625,
-0.0364050865,
0.0821072161,
0.0014975237,
-0.024969317,
-0.019016657,
0.0201292634,
0.0084302947,
-0.0204463303,
0.0396373421,
0.0061106654,
0.0260242652,
0.0140669523,
0.0693033263,
-0.0557322726,
0.0285972785,
0.0105772987,
0.0117861638,
-0.0431757495,
0.010087356,
0.0467517897,
-0.0099932561,
-0.0020172563,
0.0554887392,
-0.0142065287,
-0.0602613762,
0.0057689748,
-0.0157901384,
-0.0327125825,
0.0321696848,
0.0320849232,
0.1105555966,
-0.0057379315,
-0.0206230953,
-0.0235050898,
-0.0159475412,
0.023778107,
-0.0020887586,
-0.0079255179,
-6.203887434e-33,
-0.0290175546,
0.0249772463,
0.0296369344,
-0.0184009373,
0.0140395276,
-0.0216203127,
-0.0524819233,
-0.0113729099,
-0.0508862883,
0.0239086635,
-0.0167671219,
-0.0305495001,
0.01828162,
0.0419346951,
0.0139050083,
-0.0278591122,
0.0084846495,
0.037505351,
-0.0334816352,
0.0242907014,
0.0369879529,
0.0533706322,
0.1126098484,
-0.0398563519,
0.0419369116,
0.0199800711,
0.0229767505,
0.0116695818,
0.0031033652,
0.0306329224,
-0.0071357181,
0.0293179564,
0.0328471437,
-0.0554836579,
-0.0187097527,
0.0361158811,
-0.0806389302,
-0.0776166692,
0.0416680537,
0.000740931,
-0.0316813104,
-0.0295293238,
-0.0354539603,
-0.0504929349,
0.0467988104,
-0.026600657,
0.0222796611,
-0.0331003554,
-0.0046925056,
0.0019600803,
-0.1042304337,
0.0050624353,
-0.0107009374,
-0.0280767195,
0.0118606435,
0.1163476259,
-0.0204914846,
0.0033605206,
-0.0296961684,
0.0215912815,
-0.0284400079,
0.0289950613,
0.0837429762,
-0.0058095315,
-0.0365125164,
0.0182186887,
0.0170780383,
-0.024096258,
0.0431433097,
-0.0035011887,
0.0156722087,
0.0253272019,
0.0378936119,
0.0958398506,
0.0399363674,
0.0019796875,
-0.0756450817,
0.0235685967,
0.0049876766,
0.0028459372,
0.0092071509,
-0.0151888439,
-0.0093380567,
-0.024977807,
-0.0540946499,
-0.023100134,
-0.0245764516,
-0.0550494678,
0.0376084074,
-0.0304345191,
-0.0341692083,
-0.0016031248,
0.0536027513,
-0.0174109917,
-0.0371355712,
0.0377058722,
-0.0101313861,
-0.0158378966,
0.0028058435,
0.031513568,
-0.0618465766,
-0.0522547774,
-0.0244455319,
-0.0072163329,
0.0224104431,
0.0050540166,
0.0707049519,
0.0109492466,
-0.0691633001,
-0.0042795041,
-0.0494122095,
0.0224696323,
-0.0081541268,
0.0391819142,
0.0088912183,
0.0056682355,
-0.0312739909,
0.0688321963,
0.0196568929,
-0.0362481438,
-0.0212282538,
-0.0429637693,
-0.0102924649,
0.020552909,
-0.0085380143,
0.0044055479,
-0.0389903486,
0.0256841406,
0.0130126234,
-0.0287730526,
-0.0269644596,
0.0187997706,
2.687e-7,
0.0360004865,
-0.0109469425,
0.0006341388,
0.0072725355,
-0.0134707158,
0.0243656859,
-0.0434115566,
0.0369102247,
0.0055059688,
-0.0147135984,
-0.0158664361,
0.0352216586,
0.0503344387,
0.0505483709,
-0.0712872967,
-0.02113894,
-0.0275510233,
-0.0077862088,
-0.0217479318,
-0.0018874652,
0.0103980964,
0.0684512928,
-0.0055407737,
-0.0103295399,
-0.0034023996,
-0.0496910848,
0.0637000278,
-0.0651775524,
-0.0285872631,
0.0065528122,
-0.0240394399,
-0.0056357244,
0.0050091748,
0.0370401479,
-0.0381828472,
0.0318139307,
0.055857908,
0.0211313348,
0.0260797348,
-0.0262291264,
-0.0226760395,
0.0078282328,
-0.0024494214,
-0.0582388565,
0.0939459279,
-0.0262322873,
-0.0069592688,
-0.0369345397,
-0.0042941808,
0.0076415814,
0.0642433465,
-0.0394747742,
-0.0303675234,
0.0119285872,
0.0538112298,
0.024686249,
-0.0361268409,
-0.0045202612,
-0.004291201,
0.0250455849,
-0.0195430387,
-0.0333863273,
0.0013272463,
-0.0216062125,
-0.0049606324,
-0.0370298997,
0.0393644795,
2.002304935e-34,
-0.0007215914,
0.0077850209,
0.0412873887,
0.0259631705,
0.0077552511,
-0.0332938768,
-0.0205961652,
-0.0234044883,
0.0196274295,
-0.0336294025,
-0.0134511758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15225v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15225v2 | SAIL: Search-Augmented Instruction Learning | 2023-05-24T15:07:30 | 2023-06-25T17:56:37 | Hongyin Luo, Yung-Sung Chuang, Yuan Gong, Tianhua Zhang, Yoon Kim, Xixin Wu, Danny Fox, Helen Meng, James Glass | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been significantly improved by instruction
fine-tuning, but still lack transparency and the ability to utilize up-to-date
knowledge and information. In this work, we propose search-augmented
instruction learning (SAIL), which grounds the language generation and
instruction following abilities on complex search results generated by in-house
and external search engines. With an instruction tuning corpus, we collect
search results for each training case from different search APIs and domains,
and construct a new search-grounded training set containing
\textit{(instruction, grounding information, response)} triplets. We then
fine-tune the LLaMA-7B model on the constructed training set. Since the
collected results contain unrelated and disputing languages, the model needs to
learn to ground on trustworthy search results, filter out distracting passages,
and generate the target response. The search result-denoising process entails
explicit trustworthy information selection and multi-hop reasoning, since the
retrieved passages might be informative but not contain the
instruction-following answer. Experiments show that the fine-tuned SAIL-7B
model has a strong instruction-following ability, and it performs significantly
better on transparency-sensitive tasks, including open-ended question answering
and fact checking. | [
0.0586733706,
0.0253815055,
0.0030868538,
0.0119327381,
-0.022346396,
-0.03170285,
-0.0178584475,
-0.0285285339,
0.0001790004,
-0.0862255991,
-0.038445957,
0.0040743984,
-0.0570478626,
-0.0022044769,
0.029669648,
0.0008608442,
0.085926801,
-0.0237691589,
0.0150638996,
-0.0077822218,
0.0049679251,
0.043088004,
0.0007009644,
0.0150080305,
0.0384593569,
-0.0447002612,
-0.0099556679,
-0.0311556906,
-0.0158896986,
-0.0115969107,
0.0678695142,
0.0500876717,
0.0413937531,
0.0380945802,
0.0000020831,
-0.0352218375,
-0.0148839885,
-0.0247926302,
-0.0247739423,
0.0263243169,
0.0049528787,
0.0443424359,
0.0310731921,
0.0338594988,
-0.055284705,
0.038864743,
0.0153430244,
0.0337268598,
0.1146557406,
0.0684449822,
0.0286670327,
-0.0201279316,
0.0127276964,
0.0053283167,
0.031477578,
-0.0213787258,
0.0105823446,
-0.0109783169,
0.0310147852,
0.0574921258,
-0.0128090912,
0.0249665007,
0.0281841252,
-0.0426848866,
0.000367739,
0.0096364049,
-0.0376418568,
0.0022275003,
-0.0061095157,
0.0841648951,
0.0120295584,
-0.0615996942,
-0.0274620298,
0.0049357451,
-0.0034230589,
0.008940585,
-0.0391433313,
0.0432880148,
-0.0003177441,
0.0063497671,
0.04440042,
-0.0325978361,
0.0205851011,
0.0549134947,
-0.0040239631,
0.0987686813,
-0.0139036933,
-0.0432259142,
0.00958372,
0.0137967747,
-0.007182145,
-0.0226891171,
0.0017499323,
0.0493189767,
-0.0464271978,
0.0389665067,
-0.0272336006,
-0.0109720547,
0.0299474727,
-0.017482888,
0.0099455742,
0.0515853129,
-0.0475763455,
0.0327970013,
-0.031127831,
0.0206226837,
-0.0025928309,
0.0495506264,
-0.0395904928,
-0.0070068319,
-0.0320707373,
-0.0145307388,
-0.0185744539,
0.0526801161,
-0.0768832117,
0.0058470536,
-0.0262581594,
0.0241366364,
-0.0353240781,
-0.0203067623,
0.0046278792,
0.0279369727,
-0.03555125,
0.000740878,
-0.0479778796,
0.0262025613,
-0.0139876464,
0.0455479734,
0.0254455153,
-0.0570985228,
-0.0193951223,
0.0070092003,
-0.0152403265,
-0.0086637689,
0.0327252336,
0.0124005014,
-0.0217511375,
-0.0257566925,
-0.0716533065,
-0.0490042865,
0.0390890017,
-0.062646836,
0.0262621269,
-0.0448351949,
0.0210571531,
-0.034144748,
-0.0287586842,
-0.0322050415,
0.0290396754,
0.0636653081,
0.0180125274,
0.0436619334,
-0.0076816087,
-0.0155738974,
0.0240240302,
0.0138927232,
0.0169722661,
0.0836877152,
-0.0136982054,
0.0062814383,
0.0469379388,
-0.0037377339,
-0.0091050994,
-0.017874429,
0.0565860346,
0.0081167454,
0.0231959373,
0.0214612242,
-0.0198605824,
0.0154287722,
0.024557909,
0.0398448072,
-0.034004692,
-0.0235198885,
0.0617331862,
0.0015680355,
-0.0103976503,
-0.0094478587,
0.0554129221,
0.012889591,
0.0187132861,
0.0283290502,
-0.0858625099,
0.0280968286,
-0.0256776158,
0.0090092635,
0.00566477,
0.0255828463,
-0.0335363001,
-0.0490164049,
0.0167169366,
0.0126234265,
-0.0074457545,
0.0573983639,
0.0357757509,
0.0258777216,
-0.0727147609,
0.024551658,
0.0430801548,
-0.025007382,
0.0377251543,
-0.0703822598,
0.0787974596,
0.0529215932,
0.0716966391,
-0.0164756645,
-0.0406975038,
-0.0275281873,
0.0628469884,
0.0476918593,
-0.0086885858,
-0.0340056419,
0.0037735661,
-0.0749286637,
-0.0367549174,
-0.0360637344,
0.008463461,
0.0028527852,
0.0491110124,
-0.0284126513,
0.0113077052,
-0.0125071928,
-0.0474597067,
0.0464281701,
-0.0148513261,
-0.028974304,
-0.0266341101,
0.0026515725,
0.0065580793,
0.0265715588,
0.0110703958,
0.0123031037,
0.048323907,
-0.0024565242,
-0.0335452408,
-0.0247905925,
-0.0423516184,
0.0002113985,
0.0189567022,
-0.0568305776,
0.0088689905,
0.047460299,
-0.0385614894,
-0.0221580137,
-0.0124274939,
-0.0528880507,
0.0398350395,
-0.0319137983,
-0.0009985304,
-0.002920724,
-0.0043389746,
-0.0589561537,
0.0641271919,
-0.0249636043,
0.0132787041,
-0.0012065208,
0.0055034799,
-0.0142120523,
-0.0350443944,
-0.0071614138,
0.0024240713,
0.0056589702,
0.0165592041,
0.0308978651,
0.0347247161,
-0.0545012988,
0.0124682179,
-0.056991253,
0.0157192051,
-0.0253454205,
0.0318346694,
0.0417757742,
-0.0171969384,
0.0106197335,
-0.0202399231,
-0.0330012441,
-0.0136884786,
0.0157624781,
0.0295004398,
0.0126085365,
0.0262322966,
0.0085985176,
-0.0499654412,
-0.0051497766,
-0.0183771159,
0.0020730931,
0.0172691718,
0.0343253762,
-0.098462075,
0.0466560572,
-0.0624616556,
0.0395487919,
-0.0026176416,
-0.0339032784,
0.0054205698,
-0.02574086,
-0.0359508209,
0.0801221728,
0.0057781162,
0.0134200109,
0.0812806264,
0.0088092713,
-0.0752842724,
0.0339993984,
-0.0348280556,
-0.015556369,
0.0052953889,
-0.0500362068,
0.0058914497,
0.0356591456,
0.0099982899,
-0.0205687284,
-0.0630459562,
0.0032974379,
-0.0212484915,
-0.0311655011,
-0.0212512817,
-0.0169934444,
-0.0045090909,
0.0276870467,
-0.026498476,
-0.0618321262,
0.1160117313,
0.0111408718,
0.0092197536,
-0.0898673832,
-0.0100758104,
-0.0255142916,
0.0034863721,
-0.0302126687,
0.0136767523,
-0.0039533316,
-0.0189743191,
-0.0699130669,
-0.0108182626,
0.0777420476,
-0.0572982989,
0.0796605647,
-0.0829321295,
0.0038945046,
0.0379990675,
-0.0262031648,
-0.0680028424,
-0.0426955856,
0.0136597976,
0.0077842004,
0.0161602069,
-0.0181175899,
-0.0465426557,
-0.0394494608,
0.0541750342,
0.0461847521,
-0.0196940266,
-0.0157939084,
-0.0297152027,
-0.0067821085,
0.0618581884,
0.0127466759,
0.0328452922,
-0.0184677169,
0.0310057309,
0.0538068525,
0.055756405,
-0.0566922799,
0.0168378763,
-0.024249766,
0.0398569033,
-0.0213961732,
0.0138216717,
0.0216989275,
0.0553124957,
-0.0693759471,
-0.0327143334,
0.0820799246,
0.039072793,
-0.0147312516,
-0.0179829933,
-0.0397425964,
0.0034775294,
0.0442111902,
0.0428359061,
-0.0477790833,
-0.0147810718,
-0.0196072217,
0.0560696088,
-0.0110872006,
-0.0124918679,
-0.0231653713,
-0.1233066097,
0.0075926669,
-0.0100161843,
-0.0071712174,
-0.0613857135,
-0.085122779,
0.0001892866,
0.0087957289,
0.0225458816,
0.0080810506,
-0.0191426873,
-0.0032890851,
0.0362553895,
0.0701143891,
-0.0492730103,
0.0306844432,
-0.0031934909,
0.0071239308,
0.0568130687,
0.0037868449,
0.0027853774,
-0.0302055161,
0.0050803414,
-0.0450568646,
0.0038476624,
-0.0340504125,
0.0184237454,
-0.017962724,
0.0041997549,
-0.0307721458,
0.0574873351,
-0.0210614167,
0.004116327,
0.0066842861,
0.089314498,
-0.0271006413,
0.0176587794,
-0.0271605756,
0.0165886637,
0.0174046997,
0.0554014295,
0.0137557061,
-0.0262093339,
0.0038608164,
-0.030031573,
-0.0016491078,
-0.0277202781,
-0.0182920285,
0.0287470166,
-0.0467359759,
0.0782499909,
-0.0874360055,
-0.047918912,
0.0161329489,
0.0326041132,
0.0130032916,
0.0059239012,
-0.0003520368,
-0.0030361654,
-0.0065339259,
0.027257219,
-0.035220366,
0.0209755301,
-0.032519605,
-0.0077700978,
0.0265679248,
-0.0223577954,
-0.0092748245,
0.0423649549,
-0.0151594654,
-0.0739342198,
-0.0090218419,
0.0572033077,
0.0226102881,
0.0581111945,
-0.0152592054,
-0.0245840475,
-0.0016570984,
0.0153041678,
-0.0591604859,
-0.0003343721,
0.040610373,
-0.0340628102,
0.0073403632,
0.0183084831,
-0.0425605811,
0.0059828656,
-0.010299433,
0.0514597967,
-0.0168209523,
-0.0047270558,
0.0720716268,
0.0095462706,
0.0416677482,
-0.0092662321,
0.0208908655,
-0.0425246283,
0.0258017704,
-0.0252271015,
-0.0113004902,
-0.0018874812,
0.0339849219,
0.0030497627,
-0.0485225059,
0.0211968012,
0.0338831618,
-0.01830988,
0.069506526,
-0.0407448858,
0.02408587,
-0.0408757105,
0.0356093273,
-0.0177488904,
0.0075387233,
-0.0322374105,
0.0182489939,
0.0272828173,
0.0634499267,
0.0048066201,
0.0813149959,
0.0347581059,
-0.0117553109,
-0.0023678173,
-0.0065985955,
-0.0823180601,
-0.0106562823,
-0.0558185019,
-0.0251816269,
0.0356073081,
-0.0056181033,
0.0177930612,
-0.0162060056,
-0.0274498221,
0.0085148625,
0.0179363061,
0.0088903159,
-0.0095200054,
0.0452204756,
0.0319487676,
0.0257849023,
0.01216821,
0.0665533766,
0.0001815301,
0.0879820809,
-0.0241914596,
0.0034489131,
-0.0409253798,
-0.0586900376,
-0.0097658802,
0.0813976228,
-0.0132786175,
0.0379999466,
-0.0273260511,
-0.0599965751,
-0.0413971841,
0.0142992595,
0.0033912419,
-0.0428886525,
0.0657185689,
0.0863852948,
-0.0218369011,
-0.0422365591,
-0.0404565185,
0.0246656351,
-0.0055405139,
-0.0195619818,
-0.0329144672,
-6.655908358e-33,
-0.019525582,
-0.0378008857,
0.0333064087,
-0.0089149456,
-0.0055585694,
0.0078475354,
-0.0264105797,
-0.0232042726,
-0.0674504265,
0.0229069907,
0.0086554466,
0.0495210066,
-0.0033368447,
0.01772305,
-0.0166295283,
-0.00320403,
0.0427993089,
-0.0245342907,
-0.0179548617,
0.0506376922,
0.0678985566,
-0.0113938982,
0.0581699908,
-0.0492338203,
0.0317112841,
-0.0207610056,
-0.0298686288,
0.0624426752,
-0.0587170273,
0.0576013289,
-0.0045777168,
0.0416693948,
0.0071971999,
-0.0486123301,
0.009053492,
-0.0266334973,
-0.061610166,
-0.0530122034,
0.0617161132,
-0.0221825093,
-0.0478791259,
-0.0257317051,
0.0134248249,
-0.0349272527,
0.0150502017,
-0.0079242485,
0.0168679375,
0.0016579998,
-0.0117225144,
0.0020146284,
-0.0601329654,
-0.0004831981,
-0.004110714,
-0.0541452616,
-0.011915667,
0.0971321538,
0.0008276526,
0.0032337778,
-0.0196611583,
0.0382955037,
0.0050481167,
0.0195394773,
0.0736122355,
0.0041235695,
-0.0259224046,
0.0474374481,
0.0040555834,
-0.0344372764,
-0.0332972109,
-0.0302559007,
0.0044360021,
0.0296654459,
0.0319994763,
0.0386171713,
-0.03256955,
0.020421857,
-0.0849732235,
0.0135969799,
0.0233517811,
0.0504180193,
0.0189215075,
-0.0129938154,
-0.0439136811,
-0.0013293094,
-0.0528312549,
0.0031953056,
-0.0271363407,
-0.0040022903,
0.0382756554,
0.037701603,
-0.0334912315,
-0.0206823777,
0.0072509898,
-0.0316650867,
0.0280795787,
0.0515986457,
-0.0235204473,
-0.0078971498,
-0.0036273699,
0.0133238602,
-0.0593984686,
-0.010548044,
0.0118658943,
-0.041003447,
-0.0145898312,
0.0213105902,
0.0175051559,
0.0219841562,
-0.034216363,
0.015268595,
-0.0508681238,
0.0357957818,
0.0144956168,
-0.0320293754,
0.0265387651,
0.0338842794,
-0.0226834994,
0.0434372164,
0.0272225551,
0.0317418873,
-0.0098506566,
-0.0339479148,
-0.0111519983,
0.0399972908,
-0.0274098087,
-0.0019314286,
-0.0313175246,
0.0093483599,
-0.0282138139,
-0.0776985139,
-0.01441113,
0.04177792,
2.811e-7,
0.009596033,
0.0390475355,
-0.010424952,
0.0467941649,
0.0011316505,
0.0159099381,
0.0292197764,
-0.0130842738,
0.0220000912,
-0.0652801469,
-0.0292936433,
0.0237604659,
0.0141594941,
0.0227108281,
-0.0587739088,
-0.0146538587,
-0.0092723984,
-0.0544644631,
-0.0515752733,
-0.0328626297,
0.0392128974,
0.0816950649,
0.0129874162,
-0.0084865419,
-0.0224341583,
-0.0019569281,
0.0567451902,
0.0197424777,
-0.0319739692,
0.0245811138,
0.0278502218,
0.0150515772,
-0.0080423225,
0.0266594999,
-0.0414243266,
0.0286395382,
-0.0028218671,
0.0561896674,
0.0071532857,
-0.002353726,
-0.0054654032,
-0.0196237508,
-0.0019409772,
-0.0585113131,
0.041994635,
-0.034305457,
-0.0099996375,
-0.0100102294,
-0.0219814163,
-0.0044781105,
0.007555523,
-0.0503666848,
-0.0169087406,
-0.0060661151,
-0.0216802321,
0.0116437068,
-0.0255624019,
-0.072728917,
-0.0055406881,
0.0012915481,
-0.0257663541,
-0.052504871,
-0.0220859069,
-0.0123415031,
-0.0023303316,
-0.0557190999,
0.0357868336,
2.663539563e-34,
0.0187816285,
-0.0367946737,
0.0189701021,
0.032940425,
0.0187052842,
0.0269244425,
-0.024507815,
-0.0084992833,
0.0594958104,
-0.0639769584,
-0.0182500724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15222v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15222v1 | Neural Summarization of Electronic Health Records | 2023-05-24T15:05:53 | 2023-05-24T15:05:53 | Koyena Pal, Seyed Ali Bahrainian, Laura Mercurio, Carsten Eickhoff | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Hospital discharge documentation is among the most essential, yet
time-consuming documents written by medical practitioners. The objective of
this study was to automatically generate hospital discharge summaries using
neural network summarization models. We studied various data preparation and
neural network training techniques that generate discharge summaries. Using
nursing notes and discharge summaries from the MIMIC-III dataset, we studied
the viability of the automatic generation of various sections of a discharge
summary using four state-of-the-art neural network summarization models (BART,
T5, Longformer and FLAN-T5). Our experiments indicated that training
environments including nursing notes as the source, and discrete sections of
the discharge summary as the target output (e.g. "History of Present Illness")
improve language model efficiency and text quality. According to our findings,
the fine-tuned BART model improved its ROUGE F1 score by 43.6% against its
standard off-the-shelf version. We also found that fine-tuning the baseline
BART model with other setups caused different degrees of improvement (up to 80%
relative improvement). We also observed that a fine-tuned T5 generally achieves
higher ROUGE F1 scores than other fine-tuned models and a fine-tuned FLAN-T5
achieves the highest ROUGE score overall, i.e., 45.6. For majority of the
fine-tuned language models, summarizing discharge summary report sections
separately outperformed the summarization the entire report quantitatively. On
the other hand, fine-tuning language models that were previously instruction
fine-tuned showed better performance in summarizing entire reports. This study
concludes that a focused dataset designed for the automatic generation of
discharge summaries by a language model can produce coherent Discharge Summary
sections. | [
0.0352418832,
0.0286878143,
0.0174849872,
-0.0533967316,
-0.0215967093,
0.0179023463,
-0.004172626,
0.0022183019,
-0.0159365647,
-0.0225700662,
0.0148716802,
-0.0661174208,
0.0490836687,
0.0356480479,
0.0391726457,
-0.0711633861,
0.0402616672,
0.0406947657,
0.0082225855,
0.0345633961,
-0.0089325672,
0.0019959763,
-0.000695693,
0.0473540574,
-0.0044299113,
-0.0004255066,
-0.0057287994,
0.0251758005,
0.0113500468,
-0.0541337542,
0.0205070507,
0.0100101875,
-0.0063282251,
-0.0242362469,
0.0000020836,
-0.0323797353,
-0.0019966613,
0.0395925306,
-0.0297062118,
-0.0036952978,
0.0418532044,
-0.0864676386,
-0.0010564048,
0.0313582309,
-0.0076879887,
-0.0610857978,
0.0222198796,
0.0929430574,
0.0711030141,
0.0672949851,
-0.0251707844,
-0.0237695072,
0.0167696215,
-0.039361544,
-0.0274369922,
0.0039941785,
-0.0040486087,
0.0333695449,
0.0330730863,
-0.0683403239,
0.0147297187,
0.0472147949,
0.0043971054,
0.0038383629,
0.0130055696,
0.056975536,
-0.0219654236,
0.0362806246,
0.0139271496,
0.0455216356,
-0.0168143604,
0.0213098228,
0.0238346867,
-0.0065350472,
0.0137318783,
-0.0373938978,
-0.0717248768,
0.0290660448,
-0.034290839,
-0.0056695049,
0.0079554245,
0.0294941608,
0.0019281264,
0.0029000333,
-0.0063692792,
-0.0346145891,
-0.0268433858,
-0.0419499278,
-0.013931876,
-0.012420211,
0.0209242515,
-0.0483342595,
0.0419406742,
0.0522450618,
0.0069028288,
0.0057995622,
-0.0462737232,
-0.0596953407,
0.0729655847,
-0.0549966022,
0.0342608057,
0.008712138,
0.0164829567,
0.0102502396,
-0.0302265175,
0.0306274742,
0.0051631145,
0.0108036213,
-0.063667722,
0.0171403978,
-0.0291874669,
-0.0196250472,
-0.0382265076,
0.0413601361,
-0.0056329579,
-0.0155700166,
-0.0815138072,
-0.0179748815,
0.0362574719,
0.0168142449,
0.066537194,
0.0416025743,
-0.0322617143,
0.0180672035,
0.0030203557,
0.0045146989,
-0.0007776349,
-0.0067394902,
0.0188876297,
-0.02576706,
0.0141305551,
0.0087004025,
0.0019657509,
0.0364866108,
-0.000228279,
0.0457398221,
-0.0137356343,
0.0101479655,
-0.0427381955,
-0.0477001183,
-0.0095693571,
-0.0219656974,
0.0048728161,
-0.0438021831,
0.0157343559,
0.0030313493,
-0.0205818973,
-0.024967866,
0.0065249996,
0.0290942583,
-0.0433945991,
-0.003749527,
-0.0838965103,
0.0224050451,
0.0546107665,
0.0041178558,
0.0152339907,
-0.0047111418,
0.0626817793,
0.0131115615,
-0.0137671186,
-0.0159559548,
0.0055007846,
0.0204543099,
0.0056600757,
-0.0674108416,
-0.0063404744,
-0.0120588662,
-0.0304316096,
0.02956485,
0.0021287568,
0.0902321935,
-0.0134723624,
0.009944072,
0.0496816561,
0.0556016006,
0.0586412512,
0.0270958394,
0.0322155468,
-0.0091128303,
0.0351216719,
0.0052545778,
-0.0085429978,
0.0309400447,
0.033025749,
0.069089435,
0.034005899,
-0.0010553065,
-0.0450984314,
-0.0789329559,
-0.0370072722,
-0.0282032005,
0.0002395298,
-0.0336229689,
0.0266005211,
0.0144403651,
-0.0771906972,
0.0513269603,
0.0342657566,
-0.066114448,
-0.009026139,
-0.0390105173,
-0.0294533614,
0.1186485216,
0.0618238337,
-0.0154982116,
-0.0493522659,
-0.0502287261,
-0.0099277599,
0.0222554486,
0.0604246557,
-0.0114555769,
0.0105485264,
-0.0779932439,
-0.0164885651,
0.0105661349,
0.0180000383,
-0.0006601012,
-0.0373069346,
-0.0195359122,
0.0294684172,
-0.006452532,
-0.1257492602,
0.0531029925,
-0.0446558483,
-0.0193461888,
-0.0036929273,
-0.0230252426,
0.0133950561,
0.0351264514,
-0.0085867215,
0.0540161654,
0.0198965389,
-0.0182604808,
0.001062268,
0.0150712235,
-0.0673829019,
-0.0242211036,
0.0088261217,
-0.0080737323,
0.0293662678,
-0.0057710125,
-0.015208384,
-0.0434296094,
-0.0392374247,
-0.0867661983,
-0.0152875632,
-0.0339324921,
0.029527396,
0.0575338118,
-0.0247761495,
-0.0270259008,
0.0356041417,
-0.0286208205,
-0.0052572782,
0.0205720961,
0.0039607994,
0.0108889071,
-0.0192087833,
0.0028750242,
-0.0128880274,
-0.0205777567,
0.028520789,
-0.0038851153,
0.0234075636,
-0.013967379,
-0.0163297039,
-0.1358383149,
-0.0045873784,
-0.0113777677,
0.0003216861,
0.0479385592,
0.026174685,
-0.0119560705,
-0.0175471399,
-0.0439801142,
-0.0227123536,
0.0200242903,
0.0023077196,
0.0458649471,
0.055888541,
0.0229353178,
-0.0573122837,
-0.0457326286,
-0.0327242017,
0.0253209956,
0.0421769135,
-0.0381485336,
-0.037229307,
0.0267304629,
-0.0137550663,
-0.0249808952,
0.0118427752,
-0.0441920795,
-0.0092038289,
-0.010827167,
0.0445666276,
0.0369229689,
0.0310920198,
-0.00208516,
0.0416361429,
0.0132133067,
-0.0165859535,
0.0101511888,
-0.0379914828,
0.0356157944,
0.0347988717,
-0.0710267946,
0.0188570432,
0.0496793687,
0.0524867214,
0.0167670976,
-0.0233544726,
-0.0070174057,
-0.0273546372,
0.0221753158,
-0.014601103,
-0.0107590146,
-0.022157453,
0.016259769,
0.0062425579,
-0.0209322814,
0.0380926058,
-0.0135658877,
0.0443318933,
-0.0645158887,
-0.0203021169,
-0.0362070389,
0.0136157582,
-0.0076313592,
0.0198993627,
0.0560612194,
-0.026278859,
0.0046916883,
-0.0029393474,
-0.0132618649,
-0.0318305753,
0.0794578493,
-0.0211404245,
0.009195148,
-0.0250555184,
-0.0176973734,
-0.0303336531,
-0.0319190733,
0.0176059268,
0.0398442075,
-0.0098834792,
0.0287088137,
-0.0663965642,
0.056837786,
0.0112502305,
0.1162062585,
-0.0268342346,
-0.0231618546,
0.0049760523,
0.0371434502,
0.0074754888,
-0.0364270732,
0.0156562813,
-0.0562916398,
0.0009988669,
0.0263352096,
0.0046304245,
0.0567542948,
-0.0030554044,
-0.0433353595,
-0.0537872761,
-0.0791194662,
-0.0252247714,
0.0332068466,
0.0300873313,
-0.0803171396,
0.0030374227,
0.1032251045,
0.0117696477,
-0.0235904269,
0.01297196,
0.0103962822,
-0.0189769883,
-0.0183279477,
0.0211380776,
0.0083711967,
0.0081622545,
-0.0012970972,
0.0608779602,
-0.0050976314,
-0.0225029159,
0.0042008981,
-0.0409843959,
0.0129235508,
0.0111913783,
-0.064128235,
-0.0487506017,
-0.0172281172,
-0.0069476506,
0.0022052533,
-0.0011108686,
0.0112411855,
-0.0382243283,
-0.0207476169,
0.021261571,
-0.0800082907,
-0.0514435172,
-0.0483775362,
-0.0385328978,
0.0404563993,
0.0912177563,
0.0354433879,
-0.0257810596,
0.0069552003,
0.0407622531,
-0.0195446257,
0.0378086641,
-0.0002344297,
0.1033485755,
0.0144168139,
0.0078239152,
-0.0341464579,
0.0146768475,
0.0213265289,
0.0099900179,
-0.0028117555,
0.0033417002,
-0.0301792137,
-0.0276987758,
-0.0645923615,
0.0529551283,
0.0145173725,
0.0381203294,
0.0324503854,
-0.0142592378,
-0.0304719023,
-0.0096774874,
0.0505371094,
-0.0591569692,
0.0252385661,
0.0102749383,
-0.0603390224,
-0.0523202419,
-0.0783562288,
-0.0753601938,
0.023913376,
-0.0061077392,
0.0169344619,
-0.0063441689,
0.0298982486,
0.0076511186,
-0.0635514259,
0.0134883691,
0.0309897624,
-0.0137676261,
-0.0430060178,
-0.060617771,
0.0533562787,
0.0172111243,
-0.0085194008,
-0.0115523655,
-0.0212158039,
0.0017025766,
0.0182870794,
0.0542447306,
0.0197808612,
0.0097092269,
0.0236855689,
0.0059922514,
0.0174086839,
0.0492698289,
-0.0159453303,
-0.0213467535,
-0.0169223938,
-0.0059244577,
-0.0144590829,
-0.0009288394,
-0.0328906141,
0.0416554138,
0.0018846189,
0.0423138142,
0.0041776821,
-0.0010438968,
0.0026558479,
0.0321443602,
-0.0170447435,
-0.0150985578,
-0.0452876277,
-0.0429994017,
0.0057107122,
-0.0454817489,
0.0132572474,
-0.0252287053,
0.0217493977,
0.0063805962,
0.0328062139,
-0.0007664356,
0.0321873277,
-0.0298696738,
-0.0056236396,
-0.0536636971,
0.002950635,
-0.0468025319,
0.0249901768,
-0.0126538547,
-0.0318782926,
-0.0569480769,
-0.0040727337,
-0.0139243575,
-0.0119811604,
-0.0173424333,
0.0408560969,
-0.0015322131,
0.0327677727,
-0.0217679646,
0.0744451508,
-0.0277083982,
-0.0022297218,
-0.0642672926,
-0.0041759424,
0.0354097374,
-0.0154467002,
0.0309320018,
-0.0413708724,
0.0167349521,
-0.0422028713,
0.026740361,
0.0261792466,
0.0358547904,
-0.0091666533,
0.0202412289,
0.0095077204,
-0.0482613631,
0.0773199424,
-0.0048044203,
0.0373760499,
0.0004969477,
-0.0253609028,
-0.0580138937,
-0.0010212327,
0.0341923796,
0.0088839484,
-0.0609901063,
-0.0413360186,
-0.0652953014,
-0.0050855265,
0.0828694403,
0.0342850238,
0.0078429636,
-0.0014018797,
0.0786230937,
-0.0081752446,
0.0126320515,
0.0015835265,
-0.0373775065,
0.0221589301,
0.0117396247,
0.0029616847,
-0.0090037938,
-5.494846506e-33,
-0.0299347229,
-0.0244733617,
0.0122358417,
-0.0056042559,
-0.0309561603,
0.0212747958,
-0.0630363971,
-0.039787747,
-0.0038188493,
0.0074152397,
-0.0261406843,
-0.0042954297,
0.0190964527,
0.0348358303,
0.0041793948,
-0.0132525973,
0.0632942244,
-0.003711465,
-0.0321007334,
0.0385161489,
-0.0139511591,
0.0472810119,
0.0473281853,
-0.0670133829,
0.0182733554,
-0.0181999989,
0.0196563657,
-0.0378292426,
0.0082784928,
0.0394938886,
-0.0051290677,
-0.0021012616,
0.0670381933,
-0.0010136556,
-0.0402602069,
0.027683964,
-0.0853902996,
-0.0146505469,
0.0093895551,
-0.0371469073,
-0.0401184149,
-0.0531900339,
0.0712048635,
-0.0308818445,
-0.0177761577,
-0.0239338018,
0.0466662049,
-0.0406788886,
-0.0137761859,
-0.0851130188,
-0.0105537772,
0.0496751778,
0.0087119052,
-0.0150065767,
-0.0282034948,
0.031131193,
-0.0461726934,
-0.0078212572,
-0.0548869036,
-0.0027977445,
0.0443284921,
0.0390622169,
0.0006727497,
-0.0135215661,
0.0081170984,
0.0335503295,
0.0531846136,
0.0440183245,
-0.04429489,
0.0274032447,
-0.0190533977,
-0.0083053736,
0.0790595263,
-0.0153537728,
0.0735242963,
-0.0433953889,
-0.0799212977,
0.0804121867,
-0.0526243784,
0.0364581682,
0.039430622,
-0.0369526185,
-0.0278712083,
-0.0105861407,
-0.0045422181,
-0.0187961627,
0.0059937215,
-0.0154526448,
0.0199736804,
0.0229487028,
0.0073529962,
-0.0180169847,
-0.0194121003,
-0.0073506478,
0.0471737497,
0.0042863139,
0.0382153168,
0.0283843912,
-0.0367693864,
-0.0447010361,
-0.0460606031,
0.0191585682,
0.009451475,
0.0323036946,
0.0235496648,
0.0380707011,
0.0595718473,
0.0030685703,
-0.0381558537,
-0.001288669,
0.0498220623,
0.0123268841,
-0.0115141897,
0.0211575981,
0.0069287959,
-0.0038472498,
0.0200174507,
0.0550135449,
-0.0131909568,
-0.0329067335,
-0.0327222198,
-0.0251589343,
0.0623965152,
0.0156220775,
-0.0348607115,
0.0194267351,
-0.048246365,
0.074943006,
0.0396429785,
-0.0140337665,
-0.0094253784,
0.0422648117,
2.615e-7,
0.0906776488,
0.0344784968,
0.066730082,
-0.0064486885,
0.0140735991,
-0.0202705804,
-0.0037835375,
0.0034954161,
-0.0046599489,
0.0325075239,
0.0527514778,
-0.0228151809,
0.051633317,
0.031041028,
-0.0734561756,
-0.0332344994,
-0.0771313459,
-0.0393518507,
-0.0259323549,
-0.0039584981,
0.0582482778,
0.039909862,
-0.06574402,
-0.0243032966,
-0.0074552316,
-0.0001776681,
0.0214035846,
-0.011699846,
-0.0133140106,
0.0286826249,
0.0549648069,
0.0201142523,
-0.0096487552,
-0.0018796282,
-0.0120257437,
-0.0225320794,
0.0138742551,
0.1007255763,
-0.0283132885,
0.0214787126,
0.0533816032,
-0.0181544628,
0.0162014719,
0.0044715586,
0.0319241211,
-0.0602046065,
-0.0180487037,
0.0186585039,
-0.0347881056,
0.0270185173,
0.036972072,
-0.019110335,
-0.0544428341,
0.0464189202,
0.0150074139,
-0.0214755982,
-0.0118464688,
-0.0481733233,
-0.0489083827,
0.0310189724,
0.009721796,
0.0008778848,
0.0208592173,
-0.0271055084,
0.004412476,
-0.0581226982,
0.0007119271,
2.704194448e-34,
0.0542208739,
-0.029511936,
-0.0124899466,
0.008766992,
0.0144792935,
-0.0351321846,
0.0103745488,
0.0251994524,
-0.0006368028,
-0.0678163543,
-0.0263156109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15212v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15212v1 | Towards Adaptive Prefix Tuning for Parameter-Efficient Language Model Fine-tuning | 2023-05-24T14:51:01 | 2023-05-24T14:51:01 | Zhen-Ru Zhang, Chuanqi Tan, Haiyang Xu, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Songfang Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-tuning large pre-trained language models on various downstream tasks
with whole parameters is prohibitively expensive. Hence, Parameter-efficient
fine-tuning has attracted attention that only optimizes a few task-specific
parameters with the frozen pre-trained model. In this work, we focus on prefix
tuning, which only optimizes continuous prefix vectors (i.e. pseudo tokens)
inserted into Transformer layers. Based on the observation that the learned
syntax and semantics representation varies a lot at different layers, we argue
that the adaptive prefix will be further tailored to each layer than the fixed
one, enabling the fine-tuning more effective and efficient. Thus, we propose
Adaptive Prefix Tuning (APT) to adjust the prefix in terms of both fine-grained
token level and coarse-grained layer level with a gate mechanism. Experiments
on the SuperGLUE and NER datasets show the effectiveness of APT. In addition,
taking the gate as a probing, we validate the efficiency and effectiveness of
the variable prefix. | [
0.0346359052,
0.0320185386,
-0.018978687,
0.0362524725,
-0.0205669105,
0.0167290829,
0.0083505046,
0.0027315798,
-0.0620868616,
-0.0416226089,
-0.0518847369,
-0.0246793963,
0.0023338853,
0.0353513993,
0.0631623939,
-0.0274689477,
0.0627172664,
-0.0271612927,
0.0183787812,
0.0209885258,
-0.009776663,
0.0091487505,
0.0071766637,
0.0755643845,
-0.004636494,
0.0308442451,
0.0009860626,
0.0264468584,
0.0018313858,
0.0253139697,
0.0396979377,
0.05725611,
-0.0157827325,
0.0323029384,
0.0000020387,
-0.0403651372,
-0.0380340368,
-0.0014161746,
-0.0238147806,
0.0037019975,
0.056762442,
-0.0188864078,
-0.0283125434,
0.0254442599,
-0.0269847251,
-0.0490383878,
0.0764060467,
0.0340846106,
0.0450510457,
0.0852917433,
-0.0154755227,
-0.0267777964,
0.0088985646,
-0.037829455,
-0.0461459011,
-0.030221248,
0.0166869219,
-0.0419979207,
-0.0266529806,
0.000103633,
-0.0355101563,
0.0072244448,
0.0026102061,
0.0097193951,
0.0001934653,
0.0051320419,
-0.0345873013,
-0.0216849763,
-0.0116396341,
0.0495280698,
-0.1184348911,
-0.0312745236,
0.0016755864,
-0.0365507752,
-0.0211897548,
-0.0431720279,
-0.0231736172,
-0.0169848185,
0.0421358831,
0.013907617,
0.0276096016,
-0.0455494113,
0.0324897245,
-0.0056970022,
-0.0418526717,
0.0733838975,
0.0336310267,
-0.0020918539,
-0.0267067552,
-0.0221895576,
-0.0088415863,
-0.0450626202,
0.0013805308,
0.0126331504,
-0.023251107,
0.0191318281,
-0.0705335736,
-0.0396881104,
-0.0184212383,
-0.0255596153,
0.079248175,
0.0576808825,
-0.0094022229,
0.0150304986,
-0.0572357215,
0.0409013629,
0.0114873899,
0.0718267187,
-0.0477934927,
-0.018962957,
-0.0014569435,
-0.0069964956,
-0.088434048,
0.0137359574,
-0.0538439713,
-0.0221248865,
-0.0146318013,
0.0286315922,
0.0419209637,
-0.0421332046,
0.0325467363,
-0.0383199714,
-0.0487145148,
-0.0316146202,
0.0042416523,
0.0145313563,
-0.0211922508,
0.0279560406,
-0.0059240423,
-0.0418863147,
-0.0304618292,
-0.0014307477,
0.0233883597,
-0.0347850099,
0.0248122327,
0.0441854075,
-0.0021822643,
-0.028000176,
-0.0388138331,
0.0131598115,
0.0055703712,
-0.0299308561,
0.0099744257,
-0.029781986,
0.0023395375,
-0.0014903262,
0.0036740378,
-0.0635597259,
-0.0202586409,
-0.0049881455,
-0.0503078923,
0.0374953151,
-0.0282753631,
-0.0164484549,
-0.012911384,
-0.0074801263,
0.0198388286,
0.0798451006,
0.0307757072,
0.0326253101,
0.0433379523,
-0.025010094,
-0.0294609834,
0.0321433023,
0.0453392155,
0.0065705511,
-0.0493581444,
-0.016839996,
0.0473352745,
-0.0068352502,
0.0366108418,
0.0274174009,
-0.017225299,
-0.035381943,
0.0367364846,
0.0296674389,
0.017579617,
0.0388229527,
0.0420645177,
-0.0112357792,
-0.0129318424,
-0.0031690623,
-0.0462036319,
0.0065631461,
-0.0412416011,
0.0159252342,
-0.0111217033,
0.0672962591,
-0.0350005664,
-0.0324553959,
-0.0075394008,
0.0089651598,
0.0106064789,
-0.0134669608,
0.0225641243,
0.0465546325,
-0.0705464706,
0.0870578587,
0.0402802341,
-0.0394519418,
-0.0092443088,
-0.0909210742,
-0.0355793163,
0.0228601098,
0.0054708496,
-0.002753247,
-0.0879952982,
0.0219553839,
0.0088305529,
0.0070294272,
0.0364155918,
0.0107659772,
0.0488904119,
-0.0591397807,
-0.0207574517,
0.0017557793,
0.0269624554,
-0.004750812,
0.0079276543,
-0.0077446238,
0.031511683,
-0.0226760432,
-0.012537878,
0.0509403311,
-0.0207036417,
-0.0040595033,
0.0121696563,
0.007449375,
0.0221556854,
-0.0106554283,
-0.0026599243,
-0.0010648774,
0.0234929863,
0.0031313188,
0.0158421751,
-0.0081615821,
-0.0423698388,
0.0015550036,
0.013531913,
0.0200114828,
0.0301609393,
0.0212584287,
-0.0513599813,
-0.0444025435,
0.0069130114,
0.0042181448,
0.0902682468,
-0.0185795501,
0.0466072746,
-0.0333842896,
0.0269338153,
-0.042677775,
-0.0018720394,
0.0172694661,
0.0096082073,
0.00018893,
0.0332801118,
-0.0081186602,
-0.0118172159,
-0.0393070392,
-0.0050925459,
-0.0143913701,
0.0160160661,
0.011323628,
0.0076323329,
-0.0296532586,
-0.0500401445,
-0.0699596703,
0.0172082577,
-0.0589331165,
0.0122854533,
0.0294787865,
0.0448234342,
-0.0136384908,
-0.0146351717,
-0.0029133221,
0.0198545493,
-0.0281083342,
0.0102622882,
-0.0148535073,
0.017685743,
-0.034849342,
-0.044413276,
-0.0365788974,
-0.0024051035,
0.0418021306,
-0.0144575601,
0.0195723232,
-0.066734165,
-0.0152572645,
0.0001719356,
0.0264136307,
-0.0079996493,
-0.0693028346,
-0.0221855007,
-0.0182373598,
0.0346786976,
0.0836596638,
-0.00630415,
0.0183838792,
0.0276166331,
0.0062710387,
-0.0277747847,
0.0126807615,
-0.0604720935,
-0.0310572796,
-0.0604381375,
0.0246609971,
0.0112630334,
0.0943727866,
-0.0404128172,
-0.0140941981,
-0.0682976916,
0.0387265347,
-0.0204861965,
-0.0125485454,
0.0290584508,
0.0061588343,
-0.0152224302,
0.0089843748,
-0.014780906,
-0.0344617814,
0.0470537953,
-0.0318835154,
-0.0179908611,
-0.0498256572,
-0.0179642998,
-0.0277908184,
0.0532690845,
0.0101639628,
0.0268975161,
0.0555012375,
-0.0314215608,
-0.0545135848,
0.0087760556,
-0.0107953483,
0.0022786499,
0.0288319048,
-0.0059666005,
-0.0050324346,
-0.0066824113,
-0.0369165726,
-0.0146907028,
-0.0245012026,
-0.0270740222,
0.0220798366,
0.0670050308,
-0.0360816121,
-0.0266912971,
0.0342657194,
-0.0357664265,
0.0671761259,
-0.0192219168,
0.0214340016,
-0.0458099321,
-0.0136849955,
0.057699725,
0.027659351,
0.0165836252,
0.0249948539,
-0.0155905467,
-0.0055459868,
0.0146595277,
-0.0363826081,
-0.0553506091,
0.0253312215,
0.0671880394,
-0.0320788734,
-0.0104266191,
0.0130634159,
0.0306731779,
-0.0539334714,
-0.0052017327,
0.105305627,
0.0227711517,
-0.0388728715,
0.0175810941,
0.0216774736,
0.056937959,
0.0263140406,
0.0206997972,
-0.0553684607,
-0.0380285233,
0.0314930901,
-0.004860091,
0.0189100895,
0.0082821669,
-0.0059098545,
-0.0956933796,
0.0064036176,
0.0108899307,
-0.0487156138,
0.001409641,
-0.0266957395,
0.0081484327,
-0.0213997643,
0.049340222,
0.0203336347,
-0.0258043632,
-0.0125344461,
0.0101492284,
0.0160857681,
-0.0764824823,
0.0202599857,
-0.0409060009,
0.0411831737,
0.0251670778,
-0.0080263317,
0.0058363471,
-0.0357760191,
0.0825362951,
-0.0038850876,
0.0003293529,
-0.0351540893,
0.0153303659,
-0.0015167776,
-0.0228662677,
0.0185614768,
0.0008981783,
-0.0000548016,
0.0005168418,
-0.0481556356,
0.050921917,
-0.0051482804,
0.0173955001,
0.0165253971,
-0.0483550094,
-0.0100662252,
0.0458013304,
0.0296970326,
-0.0301798079,
-0.0284845904,
-0.0071647968,
-0.0053709936,
-0.0418508388,
-0.0439457409,
-0.0119902883,
-0.0254586227,
-0.0259911474,
-0.0316447467,
0.0172463376,
0.0299873818,
0.0581626892,
-0.0015130806,
-0.0156305209,
0.0398484282,
0.0201098006,
-0.0591044426,
0.0434622057,
-0.0261939839,
0.0005160978,
-0.107347481,
-0.0327031277,
0.0556623042,
0.0072260564,
-0.0335110798,
0.012547289,
-0.0757017657,
-0.073248513,
0.0229647998,
0.0519381426,
0.0147948489,
0.0636136755,
-0.0214598719,
-0.0773027986,
0.0080974763,
-0.0019729559,
-0.0273112692,
0.0259117745,
0.0495896041,
-0.0910326317,
-0.0193277989,
0.0359294564,
-0.0524721704,
0.0395191051,
0.0344801024,
0.0521562994,
0.0129357344,
-0.0437612571,
0.0079815891,
-0.0059194001,
0.0822443962,
-0.0058269571,
0.0252004024,
-0.0307492856,
0.0584061295,
-0.0128924837,
0.0225558951,
-0.0386802964,
-0.0029242865,
-0.0008183332,
-0.0000959826,
-0.0040475405,
-0.0113890516,
-0.0179465413,
0.0419903845,
-0.0310277287,
0.0393540151,
-0.0554545,
0.0182877686,
0.0428148992,
0.0254307296,
-0.0036661522,
0.0217192825,
0.0309577305,
0.0115934582,
-0.0559824929,
-0.0062739803,
0.0355284736,
0.0394907668,
-0.0884069651,
0.0664845407,
-0.0414923504,
-0.064752005,
-0.0540382564,
-0.0110048736,
0.0468776301,
-0.0057460801,
0.0444734171,
0.0039753015,
-0.0328059681,
-0.0024143334,
0.0262240209,
0.017608745,
-0.0166248269,
0.0190456808,
0.0035519095,
-0.0314355008,
-0.0172511023,
0.0398780294,
0.0299945325,
0.0335643813,
0.0164093282,
0.0239262059,
0.0022845548,
-0.0211874787,
0.0273541193,
-0.0093782386,
-0.0197322108,
0.0023798102,
-0.0196261574,
-0.0770426244,
-0.0026892463,
-0.0012622143,
0.0046238378,
-0.00492698,
0.0434679538,
0.054251343,
0.004322696,
-0.0171720088,
-0.029317895,
-0.0393053778,
0.0402940102,
-0.0095770499,
0.0189252365,
-6.813805167e-33,
-0.0305509418,
0.0489884987,
0.0031933156,
0.0263087079,
-0.0213956907,
0.0015168133,
-0.0240185466,
-0.0059350608,
-0.0122660231,
-0.0217904169,
-0.0243527964,
-0.0157151427,
0.0275744703,
0.030851718,
-0.0373231322,
0.0089679677,
0.0700457245,
0.00984657,
-0.0209509395,
0.0138353035,
-0.0018334184,
0.0335314088,
0.0766223744,
-0.0087577645,
-0.024747001,
0.0207870062,
-0.0079531725,
0.0188339353,
0.0254474171,
0.0746263191,
0.0024477623,
0.0070570586,
-0.0135847535,
-0.0664676353,
-0.0389180556,
0.0006356353,
-0.1041384488,
-0.0444153063,
0.0467091352,
0.024618037,
-0.0229813084,
-0.0275348146,
0.0458567478,
0.0048765806,
-0.0565181412,
0.0123098399,
0.0045352532,
-0.0042931591,
-0.0096088648,
-0.0503695607,
-0.0841110125,
0.0200868919,
0.0209003258,
0.0032603322,
0.046341598,
-0.0211867001,
0.0011656475,
0.0209914576,
-0.0414841138,
-0.009163104,
0.0367559232,
0.0854476988,
0.041185379,
0.0627412423,
-0.0107677989,
0.0052767689,
0.0164040662,
0.045881331,
0.0414961092,
0.0259401035,
0.1036298871,
0.0243643112,
0.0327627733,
-0.0333550982,
0.0448646285,
-0.0698591694,
-0.0381209441,
-0.0122285532,
0.0099890754,
0.0340196677,
0.0283929519,
0.042003084,
0.0203526225,
-0.0085813832,
-0.0841209888,
0.01021834,
-0.0358438119,
-0.0134699531,
0.0264351964,
0.0349731632,
-0.0166723672,
0.0320138559,
0.0505941361,
-0.0097903805,
0.0101025747,
-0.0008639134,
-0.0167327374,
0.0079490207,
-0.0121604819,
0.0477591828,
-0.0310304575,
-0.070551157,
0.0272623412,
-0.0028872893,
0.0271747392,
-0.0286019407,
0.0389382355,
0.05878051,
-0.0662374347,
0.0080463644,
-0.0066361325,
0.0067308848,
0.0259101391,
0.0503393561,
0.0259349979,
0.021400325,
0.0039432845,
0.0401248001,
0.01540103,
-0.0312943533,
-0.0288567152,
0.0196097437,
0.0397364423,
0.0525382347,
-0.0287018083,
-0.0129394298,
-0.0301952101,
0.0045027356,
0.0221106652,
-0.073764585,
-0.0307033341,
0.0212690905,
2.85e-7,
0.0340914391,
0.0679139048,
-0.0017729689,
0.0184041578,
-0.0179520845,
0.0087386053,
0.00704668,
0.0190700702,
0.0073430506,
0.0276794825,
-0.0061360565,
-0.0058735344,
0.0088345036,
-0.02245331,
-0.0923570991,
0.0306294858,
-0.0667536855,
0.0484092236,
-0.0351349115,
0.0078456244,
0.0058106603,
0.1548366547,
0.0063654282,
-0.0015482912,
-0.0233513806,
-0.013730078,
0.0180185549,
-0.0282770898,
0.0265907049,
0.0648863986,
-0.0028735225,
0.037505094,
-0.0236217286,
0.0004013917,
-0.0293455701,
0.0418203287,
-0.0188566409,
0.076830253,
-0.0431596003,
-0.0100795552,
0.0311727226,
-0.0068591032,
-0.0015564229,
-0.0697307736,
0.0570882633,
-0.0617438927,
-0.0206184462,
-0.0542960837,
0.025509363,
0.0221693981,
-0.0026518053,
-0.0346649997,
-0.0176915135,
0.0436302274,
0.0616808608,
0.0104406206,
-0.0164111611,
-0.1109569669,
-0.018289566,
0.027832441,
-0.0056750155,
-0.0219646804,
-0.0323135816,
-0.0340787843,
0.0505784862,
-0.0108495774,
0.0101390006,
3.067574191e-34,
0.0464762896,
-0.0169804189,
0.010228686,
0.0313662142,
0.0352492295,
-0.0104839224,
0.0033825173,
0.0598567203,
-0.0052126576,
-0.0844674334,
-0.0404435247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15186v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15186v1 | SciReviewGen: A Large-scale Dataset for Automatic Literature Review Generation | 2023-05-24T14:26:30 | 2023-05-24T14:26:30 | Tetsu Kasanishi, Masaru Isonuma, Junichiro Mori, Ichiro Sakata | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic literature review generation is one of the most challenging tasks
in natural language processing. Although large language models have tackled
literature review generation, the absence of large-scale datasets has been a
stumbling block to the progress. We release SciReviewGen, consisting of over
10,000 literature reviews and 690,000 papers cited in the reviews. Based on the
dataset, we evaluate recent transformer-based summarization models on the
literature review generation task, including Fusion-in-Decoder extended for
literature review generation. Human evaluation results show that some
machine-generated summaries are comparable to human-written reviews, while
revealing the challenges of automatic literature review generation such as
hallucinations and a lack of detailed information. Our dataset and code are
available at https://github.com/tetsu9923/SciReviewGen. | [
0.0359828249,
0.0242037158,
0.0212855972,
-0.0129748099,
-0.0103608919,
0.0093550114,
-0.00699588,
-0.0348509625,
-0.0164041799,
-0.0304407589,
-0.0202194657,
-0.0074696504,
0.0450126342,
0.0400012694,
0.017052684,
-0.0399114601,
0.0158273745,
0.0015982854,
0.0224887412,
0.0106109055,
-0.0151165798,
0.0187388901,
0.0083874343,
0.0571206249,
0.0687845647,
-0.0533769391,
0.0223543551,
-0.005298865,
0.0460974649,
-0.0509454161,
0.0175215509,
0.0274742879,
-0.0084036076,
0.0441751108,
0.0000016602,
-0.0070181903,
-0.0095472718,
0.0128225572,
0.0658388436,
0.0262716133,
0.0719287992,
-0.0848836377,
0.0069957976,
0.0366267376,
-0.0148698185,
-0.0378259979,
0.0168817081,
0.0742500424,
0.0413903147,
0.0628217012,
-0.0136404522,
-0.0542695895,
0.02890951,
-0.0047530965,
-0.0328395627,
0.0476904139,
-0.0031506747,
0.0298197493,
0.0195394214,
0.0276077185,
0.0177041739,
0.0163185392,
0.0088100219,
-0.024258418,
0.0417360105,
0.0373548605,
-0.0526452735,
-0.0110857002,
0.0160494577,
0.0555638932,
-0.0040506418,
-0.0372935422,
0.0426489078,
0.0102726147,
-0.035898339,
0.0288249627,
-0.0363798216,
0.0557435267,
-0.010600836,
0.0103725465,
0.0249049738,
0.0529059209,
0.0092724403,
0.0173284933,
-0.0044731312,
0.0273029767,
0.0164433867,
-0.024025891,
-0.0295761954,
0.0266244076,
0.0120215099,
-0.0425687134,
-0.0196306258,
0.0145781422,
-0.0399568193,
-0.0400921889,
-0.0483943485,
-0.055416394,
0.0400952771,
-0.019562887,
0.025328232,
-0.0128490711,
0.0153150195,
0.0134649994,
-0.011964526,
-0.0152560063,
-0.0055212528,
0.0029449486,
-0.0329725295,
-0.0157067981,
-0.020460831,
-0.0133551992,
-0.0101317279,
-0.0160230584,
-0.050320711,
-0.0233672336,
-0.0524221882,
-0.0011721908,
0.0084315892,
-0.005166891,
0.012339795,
0.043992646,
-0.0087919617,
-0.0128207654,
0.0170368385,
0.0700296238,
0.0048760064,
-0.0089770071,
0.0361137465,
-0.0005829455,
-0.0285004806,
0.0297254063,
-0.0134522477,
0.0091263428,
0.0031139052,
0.0032377874,
-0.021080276,
-0.015760202,
0.0480554998,
-0.0370604992,
-0.0121113788,
-0.0548047014,
0.0220588632,
-0.0612271242,
0.0270913448,
0.0149219325,
0.0027037731,
-0.012158636,
0.0071817483,
0.0497761369,
-0.000862508,
0.034855295,
-0.0771948025,
-0.0077629117,
0.039965421,
-0.0035164598,
0.0179128237,
0.0261378251,
0.0237099882,
0.0183689743,
0.0000731323,
-0.0035085729,
0.0388493016,
-0.0054688724,
-0.0096159102,
-0.0075717447,
0.0003099277,
-0.0283042546,
-0.0654746443,
0.0090120528,
0.0098652942,
0.0472863503,
-0.0306712445,
0.0296614002,
0.0407762751,
0.0290485155,
-0.0065122629,
0.0486427806,
0.004046015,
0.030264033,
0.0317960493,
0.0066019101,
0.0120244967,
0.0549124591,
0.001148099,
0.0393469781,
0.043841213,
0.0569847822,
-0.0173141118,
-0.02179523,
0.014434889,
0.0050743306,
0.0037418809,
-0.0299915057,
0.049442295,
0.0468143113,
-0.0607299618,
0.0085070552,
0.0117463097,
-0.0508016311,
0.0239768382,
0.0084810071,
0.0207705628,
0.0513550267,
0.1067203805,
-0.0086506261,
-0.0060178996,
-0.0200617872,
-0.0284126662,
0.0747064725,
0.0323857553,
-0.0132510029,
-0.0359332785,
-0.0493806526,
-0.0193833895,
-0.0212777965,
0.0150611596,
-0.0397279486,
-0.0309611131,
-0.0322851017,
0.030150868,
-0.0015536755,
-0.0815880224,
0.0379570946,
-0.0371675417,
-0.0181717146,
0.0093305605,
-0.0633569509,
0.0201583933,
0.0127921775,
-0.0312888846,
0.0587500595,
0.0512305871,
-0.0475709997,
-0.0177174639,
0.0429979004,
-0.0050996994,
-0.0415608883,
0.0153653454,
-0.0989430621,
0.0065989159,
0.0459780991,
-0.0142375901,
-0.053723257,
0.0289618559,
-0.0478943437,
0.0205145832,
-0.0063862065,
0.0037553243,
0.0146671552,
0.028666636,
0.0032455355,
0.0527435802,
-0.0099993479,
0.0221164431,
0.0569281839,
-0.0642710775,
-0.0022234241,
-0.0059187897,
-0.0333667621,
-0.0074013188,
0.0002890149,
-0.0105981268,
0.0430566333,
-0.0088354833,
-0.0073389318,
-0.0255475268,
-0.077828154,
0.0077381423,
0.0034153394,
0.0045743794,
0.0613985918,
-0.0043413909,
0.0292714983,
0.0283238422,
-0.016315287,
-0.0107505526,
0.0350797363,
0.0016105622,
0.0360999927,
-0.0144583294,
0.0202473868,
-0.0564393401,
-0.0244001299,
-0.037251424,
0.0533835143,
0.0280196723,
-0.0112103149,
-0.060776867,
0.0268441942,
0.008213955,
-0.0198407415,
-0.0118658077,
-0.015823286,
0.0278538391,
0.0215601996,
0.0613887496,
0.0569455102,
0.0596898198,
-0.004373075,
0.055082567,
0.0148892682,
-0.0196689293,
-0.0223060232,
-0.0330356807,
0.0346211269,
0.0067292079,
-0.0391399041,
0.0602206849,
0.0393037833,
0.0148714092,
0.0149796708,
-0.0017494761,
-0.0061365664,
-0.0090571949,
-0.0285700317,
0.0126768956,
-0.035247203,
-0.0049277954,
0.0245863032,
-0.00756932,
0.0302495006,
0.0314838439,
-0.0271821413,
-0.0074763014,
-0.0836675838,
0.0292913616,
-0.044752147,
0.0033358771,
0.0269668438,
0.0076328847,
0.0000504226,
0.0037773424,
-0.0091692246,
0.0061937394,
-0.0020841872,
-0.0239388458,
0.0353158079,
-0.0274783783,
0.0160521455,
-0.0210761353,
0.0102627045,
-0.0258182641,
-0.0265328828,
-0.0219944343,
0.019127937,
0.0280138291,
-0.0439859927,
-0.0781745166,
-0.0030303113,
0.0498066694,
0.0516616963,
-0.0401882268,
-0.0431393124,
-0.0229246374,
0.0339652449,
0.0928059965,
-0.0109767066,
0.0401977636,
-0.0348653235,
0.0263034664,
0.0811668336,
-0.024037797,
0.0304727126,
-0.0321707688,
-0.0642922148,
0.0016579486,
-0.0556079596,
0.0204025544,
-0.0079806177,
0.0477881655,
-0.0499424413,
-0.019865999,
0.0990549698,
0.0207817405,
-0.0829981044,
-0.0152935712,
-0.0151773309,
0.028079588,
0.0165947396,
0.0039401674,
-0.0830742791,
-0.0096292654,
-0.0237218551,
0.0255746935,
0.0094524855,
-0.02358751,
0.0153396875,
-0.0657550618,
0.0199743565,
0.0251618475,
-0.0120238289,
-0.074388966,
-0.018987095,
-0.0305844545,
-0.0243117549,
0.0009641469,
0.0407250077,
-0.0348492973,
0.0156990681,
0.0096026752,
-0.0198731422,
-0.0138353352,
-0.0121651711,
-0.0365366749,
0.0251152366,
0.0753379017,
0.0415710099,
0.0102226213,
-0.0088050757,
0.0097794728,
-0.0572474524,
-0.0272190887,
0.0270843394,
0.0566346087,
0.0144317951,
0.0052841641,
-0.0286194254,
0.0680677295,
-0.0758326203,
-0.0259832665,
0.0261056423,
0.04428849,
-0.0236899387,
-0.0330327377,
-0.0913721845,
0.0597927421,
-0.0256526321,
0.0866506323,
0.0165848844,
-0.0127443569,
-0.0548094586,
-0.0090369424,
0.0300993621,
-0.0554779842,
-0.0430680588,
-0.0022799862,
0.0257555135,
-0.038959302,
-0.0957005471,
-0.0293487441,
0.0201903265,
-0.0318622738,
0.0001213773,
-0.0007704917,
0.0516913086,
-0.0158824194,
-0.0453562662,
0.0151326312,
0.0166640654,
-0.0178841446,
-0.0138157271,
-0.0218220446,
0.0882046893,
0.0110166268,
-0.0089735994,
0.04262143,
-0.0069737867,
-0.0415671952,
-0.0123403231,
0.0278585162,
0.0237437878,
0.0304864924,
-0.0109496787,
0.006311838,
0.0566388816,
0.0400750153,
-0.0218133051,
0.0018732394,
-0.0087729115,
0.0131709501,
-0.0254916474,
-0.0228505787,
-0.0232663732,
0.0220326558,
-0.0636695027,
-0.0103215529,
-0.04405123,
-0.0388141647,
0.0490349568,
0.0010755671,
0.0013098714,
-0.051358033,
0.0708350614,
-0.0098218601,
-0.0325470343,
-0.0631835461,
-0.0042966655,
-0.0461856015,
0.033940658,
0.0111016734,
-0.0049966541,
-0.0021068284,
0.0486985631,
-0.0429084152,
0.0167256817,
-0.0244362894,
0.0373227224,
-0.0013872958,
0.0100113396,
0.0113068921,
-0.0340403952,
-0.0344181806,
-0.0347648822,
-0.0501900092,
0.0067060431,
-0.0020057233,
0.0181441009,
0.0322087258,
0.0086772973,
-0.0176867172,
0.0309481006,
-0.0883550718,
0.0016972179,
-0.0553795435,
-0.0292787235,
-0.0094389739,
0.0000182418,
0.0959292427,
-0.037232168,
0.0012358497,
-0.0362776034,
0.0565864667,
-0.0005082267,
0.0375181958,
-0.0172596499,
0.0056182542,
-0.0039399453,
-0.0468177162,
0.1141324788,
-0.021155769,
0.0120511381,
0.0361789577,
-0.0484592915,
-0.0401734859,
-0.0309562944,
-0.055789452,
0.0013338823,
-0.0031660709,
-0.020107463,
-0.0359658748,
0.0187683888,
0.0405778177,
0.0289208684,
0.0277415216,
-0.0460702553,
-0.0020454577,
0.016328251,
-0.0191854369,
-0.0299945008,
-0.0452504605,
0.0601637997,
0.000231721,
-0.0484811999,
-0.0459526591,
-5.362244866e-33,
0.0213433877,
-0.0300606359,
-0.0057579051,
-0.0191827212,
-0.023487784,
0.0030099628,
-0.0887222812,
-0.0117269056,
0.0348801054,
0.0488907509,
-0.0202798378,
0.0219874717,
-0.0145854624,
0.0569211766,
0.0450283103,
0.0327822156,
0.0601826496,
-0.0054992009,
-0.0086210258,
0.0603391044,
0.0258458089,
-0.000712367,
0.0228926037,
-0.0434840992,
0.0271263812,
-0.0244495198,
-0.0263517052,
-0.0415890738,
0.0094772382,
0.0316638686,
-0.0557623282,
0.0129340412,
0.0144142443,
-0.0499628372,
-0.0354062915,
0.0151972966,
-0.0762050673,
0.0163725894,
-0.0013087729,
-0.0247107372,
-0.0491832048,
-0.0310815219,
0.0579654351,
-0.0160487313,
-0.0049099559,
-0.0240463503,
0.0503222048,
-0.0605409965,
-0.0316344798,
-0.1134943515,
-0.0692434162,
0.0207186602,
-0.025735775,
-0.0013634093,
-0.0087105976,
0.0792270303,
-0.0283295363,
0.0583373569,
-0.0496738404,
0.0416448489,
0.0243595019,
0.0476139113,
0.0126046697,
-0.0352898762,
0.0225313157,
0.0693761781,
-0.0157827865,
-0.0022617846,
-0.0315732621,
0.0137770083,
-0.0216323659,
0.0196978599,
0.0448855385,
0.038043566,
0.0437766053,
0.0055095013,
-0.0567371547,
0.0820380896,
-0.0106725637,
0.0178041682,
0.062686719,
-0.0185096804,
0.0416793264,
-0.000087325,
0.0306383129,
-0.0362597182,
0.0099828728,
-0.0147109525,
-0.0202002767,
0.0163107347,
-0.0531857945,
-0.0244906079,
0.0070452308,
-0.0688310787,
0.0381500274,
0.0444641151,
-0.0384890288,
0.0312508084,
0.0101771746,
-0.0390460789,
-0.05461777,
0.0021443954,
0.030153323,
0.0275673829,
0.0051122312,
0.0090836957,
0.0407630578,
-0.0153425429,
-0.0418423191,
-0.0049749445,
-0.005310169,
0.0313353874,
0.0057371226,
0.0672337785,
-0.0267382581,
0.0107344687,
0.0032229347,
-0.0036162185,
-0.0390788689,
0.0486050844,
0.0107447486,
0.0325445086,
0.0232554115,
0.0362261571,
0.0026084871,
0.0164322443,
-0.0448870845,
0.0015676318,
0.0318252183,
-0.0337681659,
-0.0148866624,
-0.0130703775,
2.362e-7,
0.0579657927,
0.0588376187,
0.0498851985,
-0.0296730176,
0.0311823245,
0.0250930414,
0.0379222929,
0.0471887439,
0.0265983939,
-0.0070237084,
0.0202319156,
-0.0139721455,
0.0090470482,
0.0254571959,
-0.0979824141,
-0.0412223153,
-0.094438225,
-0.0365153477,
-0.0284510925,
-0.0386559218,
0.0312135778,
0.0445737503,
-0.0617374219,
-0.0095221261,
-0.0149850948,
0.0030275811,
0.0480915643,
-0.0124541773,
-0.030647479,
0.0452689193,
0.0728729144,
-0.0192900896,
0.0109755397,
-0.0324254297,
-0.037902195,
-0.0073446715,
0.0124149648,
0.0103237601,
0.0100804474,
-0.0477002412,
0.0551439673,
0.0000971679,
0.0389467515,
-0.0148555944,
0.0379992872,
-0.0978335738,
-0.0285191927,
-0.0601228811,
-0.0829508603,
0.0356461518,
0.0303377807,
-0.0240849406,
-0.0198966842,
0.0601080358,
-0.0028106864,
-0.0093241632,
-0.0050306995,
-0.0427039862,
-0.0320665874,
0.0475031659,
-0.0301705562,
-0.0096337693,
-0.0052655577,
-0.0397613049,
-0.0061839554,
-0.0475849919,
0.0130661475,
2.139436223e-34,
0.0921239927,
-0.0098049594,
-0.0125346947,
0.0044906787,
0.0154392431,
-0.0382038392,
-0.0381460711,
0.0176621284,
-0.0021743588,
-0.0893722773,
-0.0089812763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15183v1 | Are Pre-trained Language Models Useful for Model Ensemble in Chinese Grammatical Error Correction? | 2023-05-24T14:18:52 | 2023-05-24T14:18:52 | Chenming Tang, Xiuyu Wu, Yunfang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Model ensemble has been in widespread use for Grammatical Error Correction
(GEC), boosting model performance. We hypothesize that model ensemble based on
the perplexity (PPL) computed by pre-trained language models (PLMs) should
benefit the GEC system. To this end, we explore several ensemble strategies
based on strong PLMs with four sophisticated single models. However, the
performance does not improve but even gets worse after the PLM-based ensemble.
This surprising result sets us doing a detailed analysis on the data and coming
up with some insights on GEC. The human references of correct sentences is far
from sufficient in the test data, and the gap between a correct sentence and an
idiomatic one is worth our attention. Moreover, the PLM-based ensemble
strategies provide an effective way to extend and improve GEC benchmark data.
Our source code is available at
https://github.com/JamyDon/PLM-based-CGEC-Model-Ensemble. | [
0.0805313513,
0.0722962245,
0.0054730377,
0.0200503469,
-0.0155272596,
0.0284868497,
-0.0267546382,
-0.0114558591,
-0.0271497723,
-0.0669099912,
-0.0369084664,
-0.0713917688,
0.0413840078,
-0.0458918586,
0.0127797769,
-0.0293550584,
0.0656675845,
0.0202083364,
-0.0236101449,
0.0055594449,
0.0080680121,
-0.0139839882,
-0.0142714353,
0.0542635955,
-0.0000366086,
-0.03931899,
0.0072143213,
0.0477002375,
0.0050665517,
-0.0247025993,
0.0249230731,
0.0817366987,
-0.0568590574,
0.066894412,
0.0000018038,
-0.0530181788,
-0.0213794094,
-0.0191290658,
-0.0110718496,
0.0888259858,
0.0144802332,
0.0391803347,
-0.0498374961,
0.012923508,
-0.0054846518,
-0.0266295392,
0.0635149777,
0.0695009306,
0.0468179472,
0.0813745186,
0.0062836017,
0.0203659553,
0.0186922569,
-0.0030486353,
-0.0393245444,
-0.0179243647,
0.0351442993,
-0.0013107813,
-0.0262964219,
-0.0408455431,
-0.0157475211,
0.03393526,
-0.0149892317,
-0.0399776846,
-0.0083186645,
0.023087075,
-0.0255099721,
0.0076771672,
-0.0374583602,
0.0255270805,
-0.0241585877,
-0.0398403071,
-0.0518133491,
0.0046202238,
0.0214899071,
0.0164987762,
0.0044729067,
-0.0097762477,
0.0039248522,
0.0449545868,
0.0293530878,
-0.0635618716,
0.0324386805,
0.0235664565,
0.0055798502,
0.0757703185,
0.0287361387,
-0.0586638525,
-0.0089656478,
0.0493920185,
-0.0455592759,
-0.0341318697,
0.0124544762,
-0.0222591348,
-0.0396243222,
0.0087148631,
-0.0390232392,
-0.0606129542,
-0.0098121101,
-0.0352509767,
0.0742550269,
0.0048613623,
-0.0397057347,
0.0130061582,
-0.0175272506,
0.0483763888,
0.0214434229,
0.0229300689,
-0.0324965604,
-0.0010868064,
-0.0600938648,
-0.011288397,
-0.0618054867,
0.0457142107,
-0.0110358559,
0.0112883886,
-0.0727383792,
-0.004058925,
-0.004738885,
-0.0089706266,
0.0274366606,
0.007607711,
-0.0443199836,
-0.041347485,
-0.0057799872,
0.0317711122,
0.0231754649,
0.0602289662,
-0.0143819526,
-0.0760162026,
-0.0236012992,
0.0201658364,
0.0072316942,
-0.0017680568,
-0.0030560431,
-0.0307966769,
-0.0176784396,
-0.0465638041,
-0.0046325307,
0.025693085,
-0.0351413377,
-0.0526942164,
-0.0711463168,
-0.0440628864,
-0.015611371,
-0.016604038,
0.0409782045,
-0.0279366355,
0.0132904602,
-0.0255379342,
-0.0146791311,
0.0597817004,
-0.0186313111,
0.039162524,
-0.0105670737,
-0.0189677365,
0.016602695,
0.031404078,
0.0200986471,
-0.0711342022,
0.0590711609,
-0.0030660578,
0.0491938069,
0.013239285,
-0.056843251,
-0.0412361957,
0.0131123485,
-0.0285281837,
0.0046646982,
-0.0058265426,
0.0147891529,
0.0662592798,
-0.0151042864,
0.056456279,
0.075257808,
-0.0018477722,
-0.0054386226,
0.0104135638,
0.0045247916,
-0.0430354327,
0.0440894663,
0.0410341248,
-0.0361940898,
-0.0361332968,
-0.0924111605,
0.0068086721,
0.0422202423,
0.0329606384,
-0.0356319584,
-0.054633636,
-0.0004217937,
-0.0088897552,
-0.0186683629,
-0.0334792882,
0.049039986,
-0.0021827111,
-0.0163070019,
0.0726258606,
0.0161460154,
-0.0906007513,
-0.0024888611,
-0.0299328268,
-0.0148328738,
0.0535883382,
0.0390043557,
-0.0000894384,
-0.0175148621,
-0.0099863335,
-0.041251149,
0.0303724706,
0.0491773859,
0.011391283,
0.0255876239,
-0.0203274395,
0.0052107484,
0.0268624276,
0.0482212529,
-0.0120807132,
0.0473403931,
0.0000325397,
0.0097099179,
-0.0291012377,
-0.0568215735,
0.051356677,
-0.0049808463,
-0.0036039373,
-0.0059532034,
-0.0189708117,
0.0427395105,
0.010293602,
-0.0615783222,
0.0211366341,
-0.0066883615,
-0.0286836457,
-0.0410069115,
0.0305450447,
-0.0461167768,
-0.0944012776,
0.0781646222,
-0.0173394736,
-0.0251262188,
0.0223227702,
-0.0501767434,
-0.0638649538,
-0.0030086294,
-0.036128629,
0.0149690956,
-0.101251252,
0.0882821679,
-0.0353665836,
0.0275611393,
-0.0245170258,
0.034864191,
0.0045364932,
0.0307862274,
-0.0384038314,
0.0303247254,
0.0230129045,
-0.0340162888,
-0.0647441,
-0.02798675,
0.0203347541,
0.0421930142,
0.0030387242,
0.008951379,
-0.0437850803,
-0.0382063203,
-0.1114852503,
-0.0133253094,
-0.0414701179,
-0.0189962853,
0.0475787148,
-0.0039916411,
-0.0246491563,
-0.0272199344,
0.0339777693,
0.018352164,
0.036635045,
-0.0083888723,
0.0428777821,
-0.0278086029,
-0.0414426289,
-0.0446252115,
0.0185440499,
-0.0068146163,
0.0065181851,
0.0034858615,
-0.0473248474,
-0.0757964477,
0.0428218655,
-0.0325005241,
0.0109601747,
0.0571451783,
-0.065561533,
-0.0212852675,
0.0032126904,
0.0511312932,
0.0014850204,
-0.00696322,
0.0169597156,
0.006341612,
-0.0136162927,
-0.0093676364,
-0.0085822949,
0.0083347205,
-0.0263459254,
-0.031602487,
0.0112137282,
0.0054024747,
0.0430592448,
0.021135984,
-0.0441763438,
-0.007049846,
0.0009813913,
-0.0217431579,
-0.0120050963,
-0.0117834806,
-0.0284073353,
-0.0221021976,
-0.0138620082,
-0.0258665346,
-0.042014122,
0.0748779029,
-0.0225416329,
-0.0175353847,
-0.0603459254,
0.006522676,
-0.016601583,
0.0036613315,
0.0163601786,
0.0207580701,
-0.0039691795,
-0.0291254912,
-0.0443384275,
0.0022338789,
0.0272723883,
-0.0243324563,
0.0366320089,
-0.0608926602,
0.0467368588,
0.0273316763,
-0.0441519581,
-0.0314172283,
-0.0579543188,
-0.0452740975,
0.0008134719,
0.0189984534,
0.0030722504,
-0.0409578234,
0.034636043,
-0.0085188616,
0.0205106232,
-0.0332301296,
0.002511296,
-0.0037007025,
0.0201981459,
0.0014775294,
0.044948861,
0.0242697373,
-0.0245021284,
0.0488371179,
0.0394944958,
0.0080801519,
0.0188898519,
-0.0270602591,
0.0097367857,
0.0224837922,
-0.0133194821,
-0.0409265123,
-0.0020222052,
0.0533890873,
-0.0239336696,
-0.0331320576,
0.1191010103,
0.034334708,
-0.0406679399,
-0.0071071289,
0.008165068,
-0.005086387,
-0.0084759025,
0.0152928643,
-0.0128723467,
-0.0213426072,
0.0197550245,
-0.0074606333,
-0.0143594351,
0.0002742381,
-0.0008856034,
-0.1167500466,
0.0506492406,
0.0532468893,
-0.0303674918,
-0.0436949581,
-0.0155241331,
0.0246380959,
0.0202577095,
0.0252754502,
0.0599707179,
0.0075086174,
-0.006567623,
0.0141998138,
-0.06953872,
-0.1088010669,
-0.0233700071,
-0.0776489675,
0.0477227084,
0.1067332029,
-0.0056527145,
0.0031617901,
-0.0293092448,
0.0388260633,
-0.0110047422,
-0.0139612304,
0.0167562049,
0.038842164,
0.0272817165,
-0.0114338798,
0.0075438614,
0.0295884833,
-0.0608197227,
0.0039674845,
-0.0085098576,
0.0453888252,
-0.0393887684,
0.0016457947,
0.0329274759,
0.0092147542,
0.0114268223,
0.05914573,
0.0330985896,
-0.0312887579,
-0.0288105309,
-0.0474677086,
0.0004674,
-0.0537779033,
0.0592075698,
0.0791925415,
0.0115408227,
0.0000192201,
-0.0396808274,
-0.0618049987,
0.0171001796,
0.0059062359,
0.0105078211,
0.0428905822,
-0.0302393138,
0.0518146008,
0.0352422632,
-0.0286179911,
-0.0018496905,
0.0086985631,
-0.0832515731,
-0.0325538702,
0.0007054466,
0.0478397571,
0.0058648158,
-0.0360330269,
-0.0205810145,
-0.0537808947,
0.0488142855,
0.0287946239,
0.0056421338,
0.0108260792,
-0.0084999437,
-0.0610474274,
0.0068366365,
0.066685617,
0.0304469801,
0.0635789633,
0.0011903701,
-0.064603284,
-0.0110513428,
0.032520581,
0.0072114011,
0.0326090269,
0.0423007421,
0.0921311677,
-0.0121069867,
-0.0361214615,
0.0695582926,
0.0525165871,
0.0587413795,
-0.0311847646,
-0.0064410563,
-0.047537636,
0.0410797037,
-0.0191942677,
-0.0297280289,
-0.0297955088,
-0.0056850896,
0.0518601164,
-0.0319446214,
-0.0330235921,
0.0031803132,
-0.0340332612,
0.0411729068,
0.0030631931,
-0.0134851988,
0.015624145,
0.0009349984,
0.0004112062,
-0.0006731876,
-0.0086071752,
0.0096871909,
0.0425752141,
0.0051082107,
0.0159761719,
0.0249165893,
0.0108906589,
0.0167245008,
-0.0201541949,
0.0205365662,
-0.0639289171,
0.0067735929,
-0.0476356745,
0.016031215,
0.120028995,
0.0110505102,
0.0692096353,
-0.0395282805,
-0.0148523655,
-0.0512955077,
0.0252786335,
0.0341738872,
0.0015186521,
0.0254582521,
-0.0119629595,
-0.019864887,
-0.0013651013,
0.0734522194,
-0.0090177013,
0.0394644216,
0.0121598737,
-0.031973511,
-0.0304303151,
0.0104785422,
-0.0147878658,
-0.0290348623,
-0.0295823105,
0.0335323177,
-0.0147468233,
-0.051024422,
0.0035861128,
0.029452337,
0.0152901607,
-0.0133779468,
-0.0126628606,
0.0580302142,
-0.0035517025,
0.0120756291,
-0.0559425578,
-0.0161503423,
0.0077169719,
0.0200611204,
-0.0648557916,
-5.896360846e-33,
-0.0729499087,
0.0025522748,
-0.0421729609,
-0.0469262414,
0.0143252192,
-0.0349450745,
-0.0383360647,
0.0315452702,
0.0199780371,
0.0353709906,
-0.0315857455,
0.0448101312,
0.0073336218,
0.0328465551,
0.025499355,
0.0432869978,
0.0704547837,
-0.019948462,
-0.0097846128,
-0.0306797102,
0.0365050808,
0.0651068985,
0.0647162497,
-0.0492044427,
0.0135671794,
0.0051590614,
-0.0315228216,
0.0156240845,
-0.0034289614,
0.0342969298,
0.0222823787,
0.0454939157,
0.0180229824,
0.0417819768,
-0.0443532318,
-0.0223198812,
-0.0522127226,
-0.0307476334,
0.0041539376,
0.0390177481,
0.0165384971,
0.0029582228,
0.0300667211,
-0.0112793744,
-0.0189091749,
0.0111588603,
-0.0005239254,
-0.0639956668,
0.0152399,
0.0274973791,
-0.0181937758,
0.0231456067,
0.0214208569,
0.0405429043,
-0.0259510614,
-0.0008590125,
-0.0620910749,
0.0277391598,
-0.0313354433,
-0.0213493556,
0.0684218481,
0.0575175211,
0.0180103965,
0.0083161388,
-0.0101045007,
0.0125109833,
0.0168622509,
-0.0316991918,
-0.0275465939,
-0.007235745,
0.0250586141,
0.0158776436,
0.0411198959,
0.0353051275,
0.0309400428,
-0.0089008799,
-0.0320496187,
0.0319046043,
-0.0058411495,
-0.0035640907,
0.0234423354,
0.0059746797,
-0.0358323827,
-0.043030154,
-0.006696437,
-0.0091761183,
-0.0187041406,
-0.0194768589,
0.0491878912,
-0.0071883183,
-0.0288329348,
-0.0261717234,
-0.004669114,
-0.0401474722,
-0.0640487373,
-0.0181276333,
0.0013808152,
0.0098549193,
-0.0046680081,
0.0287932288,
-0.0311195198,
-0.024002187,
0.0009518259,
0.0225844122,
-0.0083955703,
-0.0205772519,
0.0390721969,
0.0197541807,
-0.0670464262,
0.027635714,
0.0243448559,
-0.0298508443,
0.0186156854,
0.0115009574,
-0.0032724382,
0.0073241978,
0.0060137031,
-0.0232495777,
0.0178961027,
-0.0116061307,
-0.0138553465,
-0.0310515333,
-0.0114350822,
0.0423935354,
0.0135640865,
0.0011731078,
-0.0273318402,
-0.0310549103,
0.0305288453,
-0.0299843401,
0.0043395651,
0.0123503814,
2.477e-7,
0.0702956766,
0.0369047821,
0.002190304,
-0.0258330386,
0.0059617055,
0.0038523746,
-0.0614189468,
-0.0158798918,
0.0068621249,
0.0593620464,
0.0544954613,
0.0195022132,
0.067841135,
0.0049084569,
-0.0139341047,
-0.010110708,
-0.0474484339,
0.0478625298,
-0.0092877718,
-0.0027388427,
0.0135433991,
0.0857303515,
0.0131965578,
-0.0072938381,
-0.0341214128,
-0.0710278526,
0.0575258136,
-0.0004002699,
-0.0086490512,
0.0608861558,
0.0851724967,
0.0156080937,
0.0069410624,
0.0481827147,
-0.0089472877,
0.0245577693,
0.0217683818,
0.0081161782,
-0.029198369,
0.0139035825,
-0.0247784145,
0.020440096,
0.0104558617,
-0.0565512441,
0.0325542465,
-0.0240464825,
0.0187731963,
0.0032754061,
-0.0409752503,
0.0010624522,
0.036639113,
-0.0073494385,
-0.0429765247,
0.0206660815,
0.0278661735,
0.0107582519,
-0.0253889877,
-0.0299310684,
-0.0377573557,
0.0146386838,
-0.0037874861,
-0.0459256545,
0.0350347795,
-0.0043498003,
0.0251650661,
-0.0234757457,
0.0168320294,
2.175693566e-34,
0.0576051027,
-0.0203705803,
0.0286693852,
0.053239163,
0.0342265032,
-0.027023647,
0.030284889,
0.0035272294,
-0.047129374,
-0.0769583806,
-0.0072299796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15182v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15182v2 | HiTIN: Hierarchy-aware Tree Isomorphism Network for Hierarchical Text Classification | 2023-05-24T14:14:08 | 2023-06-09T08:53:14 | He Zhu, Chong Zhang, Junjie Huang, Junran Wu, Ke Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hierarchical text classification (HTC) is a challenging subtask of
multi-label classification as the labels form a complex hierarchical structure.
Existing dual-encoder methods in HTC achieve weak performance gains with huge
memory overheads and their structure encoders heavily rely on domain knowledge.
Under such observation, we tend to investigate the feasibility of a
memory-friendly model with strong generalization capability that could boost
the performance of HTC without prior statistics or label semantics. In this
paper, we propose Hierarchy-aware Tree Isomorphism Network (HiTIN) to enhance
the text representations with only syntactic information of the label
hierarchy. Specifically, we convert the label hierarchy into an unweighted tree
structure, termed coding tree, with the guidance of structural entropy. Then we
design a structure encoder to incorporate hierarchy-aware information in the
coding tree into text representations. Besides the text encoder, HiTIN only
contains a few multi-layer perceptions and linear transformations, which
greatly saves memory. We conduct experiments on three commonly used datasets
and the results demonstrate that HiTIN could achieve better test performance
and less memory consumption than state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods. | [
0.0063943733,
0.0512515418,
-0.0045838407,
0.062909402,
-0.0137490416,
0.0409360901,
-0.0413322039,
0.027924927,
0.0105987322,
-0.0734421015,
-0.0610824116,
-0.01274342,
-0.0048446273,
0.0143733881,
-0.020837862,
-0.0765414834,
0.0000475795,
0.0028131178,
0.0008625444,
0.0037280857,
0.0010349803,
0.0296952054,
0.0465221815,
-0.0270572752,
0.0022599506,
-0.0365339033,
-0.0212155748,
0.0572452322,
0.0308572184,
-0.0319115929,
0.0403614454,
0.001099086,
0.0478092954,
0.0290027075,
0.0000021784,
0.0069648391,
0.0060761566,
-0.0063810498,
-0.002975771,
0.0246031806,
0.0619091094,
-0.0446207076,
0.0160313435,
0.0125588207,
0.0332322419,
-0.0210858788,
0.0212409962,
0.0400890633,
0.0172730722,
0.0444384329,
-0.0393279977,
-0.1036282107,
0.0459666848,
-0.0209662933,
0.0295452923,
-0.0515519381,
0.0216118619,
-0.0163181052,
-0.0477646068,
0.0633232519,
-0.0159788989,
-0.0051544397,
0.0545766279,
0.0043527707,
0.0403941199,
0.0366778597,
0.0448939912,
0.0165830348,
0.004501218,
0.0488107465,
-0.0360151865,
-0.040559303,
-0.0038864268,
-0.0294630826,
-0.0182497706,
-0.0443940535,
0.0355084352,
0.023690043,
-0.0305923,
0.0233826116,
0.0292478595,
0.0507074669,
0.0159296449,
-0.0098062642,
-0.0247392077,
0.0380837806,
0.0047726701,
-0.0333908498,
0.0260036364,
0.0292984433,
0.0329618007,
-0.0338502936,
0.0057528215,
-0.0217969324,
0.0028456107,
0.0152418604,
-0.0489153527,
-0.0338051692,
-0.0152601777,
-0.0885641873,
-0.0225545727,
0.0108122835,
0.0106016304,
-0.0006936358,
-0.0240612552,
0.0313468687,
-0.0206720177,
0.058388453,
-0.0432476364,
-0.0358704887,
-0.0857088193,
-0.0129785407,
-0.0241739172,
0.0332903415,
0.0018816296,
-0.004257821,
-0.0447355434,
0.0033340743,
-0.0074896435,
-0.0014788555,
-0.0313791893,
0.0235060826,
-0.0075221867,
0.0128224408,
0.0217880737,
0.0249480791,
-0.0231032744,
-0.0053493944,
0.0085087139,
0.05395234,
0.0121117011,
0.0734049007,
0.0177468285,
0.0041529341,
0.0250865202,
0.0277151037,
-0.0455831513,
-0.0190174822,
-0.059223026,
-0.0017939468,
-0.019737497,
-0.0181794316,
0.045812618,
-0.0199811719,
0.0159271974,
-0.0378890485,
-0.005219968,
-0.041083239,
-0.0100687481,
0.0197538473,
-0.0434702821,
0.05500241,
-0.0135618998,
-0.0703606084,
0.0572078936,
0.0279328879,
0.0201390088,
0.0326614156,
0.040775422,
0.0745488256,
0.018570276,
-0.0069944975,
-0.023867609,
0.0148495603,
-0.0081599047,
-0.0105845351,
-0.014727301,
0.0123575479,
-0.0792406648,
0.0091082733,
0.0379966199,
0.0221827962,
-0.0090052383,
-0.0097656036,
0.0294262357,
0.0055487156,
-0.0054713078,
-0.0012143442,
0.02676557,
-0.0002264282,
-0.0352696478,
-0.0071936594,
-0.0038663964,
0.0141200218,
-0.0288067944,
-0.0043863612,
-0.0002576637,
-0.0311255939,
-0.0344361886,
-0.01605043,
-0.009724292,
-0.0246938821,
0.0037538961,
-0.0301360618,
0.0717862323,
0.0464889631,
-0.00213783,
0.0426808335,
0.0223989151,
-0.0193601549,
0.0088848667,
0.0111384355,
-0.0205074549,
0.0400318578,
0.0120395264,
-0.018547222,
0.0468210466,
0.0115864519,
-0.0114304181,
0.0398776717,
-0.0209063683,
-0.031856332,
0.0017362167,
-0.0662031174,
-0.0284573697,
-0.003279249,
0.0396036878,
0.0510933883,
-0.0373675786,
0.0018198648,
0.0584845096,
-0.0031114623,
0.0129579632,
0.0294250175,
0.0046252264,
0.0310310964,
0.0810372233,
0.011879337,
0.0673869774,
0.0141706141,
-0.0202632565,
-0.0174280629,
0.0231731553,
-0.04193753,
-0.065831244,
-0.0869529322,
-0.0588920675,
-0.0883755311,
-0.0231446866,
-0.0178157464,
0.0069104787,
0.045942504,
-0.0477758907,
-0.0353247896,
-0.0174491927,
-0.0334261209,
0.0129946936,
-0.0243007839,
0.0045317938,
-0.0346190035,
-0.0009625064,
-0.0147147002,
0.102213107,
-0.0017720499,
-0.0013932127,
-0.016684005,
0.0060164607,
0.0315012969,
0.0198646206,
-0.0089324061,
0.0175391342,
-0.0102801146,
-0.001468396,
0.0155325746,
0.0286600571,
-0.0286282152,
-0.0019419281,
-0.0203551911,
-0.0035895312,
-0.0217656437,
0.0421183482,
0.0259657633,
-0.0127903083,
0.0489942096,
-0.0026317304,
-0.0536796711,
0.0660533533,
-0.0770143494,
0.0079988437,
0.0316345133,
-0.0336406156,
0.0015896156,
0.0250358544,
-0.0304073971,
-0.0207255557,
0.0607726872,
-0.0242207199,
-0.0654726848,
-0.0055550635,
0.0227234215,
-0.0051843273,
-0.0053198473,
-0.0003735046,
-0.0043979017,
-0.0259141102,
-0.0024599682,
0.0263179373,
0.0466419645,
0.0169290248,
0.0122800097,
0.0241366792,
0.0395733863,
-0.0189857092,
-0.0069029531,
0.0172588956,
0.0527143814,
-0.0052444707,
-0.0489574485,
0.0034876403,
0.1106181517,
0.0119460998,
0.028691614,
-0.0266820136,
-0.0605803728,
-0.0208748542,
-0.0186306722,
-0.0612633862,
-0.0439074673,
0.0112862429,
0.0010282581,
-0.0052349833,
-0.0136314966,
0.0642853379,
-0.0143141383,
-0.0319016166,
-0.0301439129,
-0.0306037571,
-0.0610274002,
0.0875029042,
0.0687605888,
0.0278005488,
0.059360113,
-0.0429561622,
-0.0204486046,
0.0237332359,
0.0211598352,
0.0173574034,
-0.025274612,
0.0040970105,
0.0311587341,
-0.0279258676,
-0.0389699787,
0.0099306172,
-0.0046343189,
0.0113001047,
0.0175250527,
0.0251556858,
-0.0110047944,
-0.0337427109,
0.0084435986,
0.0078105666,
0.0739798397,
0.0230483469,
-0.0358146727,
-0.008883995,
0.0739152357,
0.0306844357,
-0.0476957075,
-0.0174726974,
-0.0198793523,
0.0162553359,
0.0551092476,
-0.0026985311,
0.0116063179,
-0.007375346,
0.0093894461,
0.0152580896,
0.0218456089,
-0.0161614697,
0.0016976923,
-0.0219543688,
-0.0249888971,
-0.0241383761,
0.0774324536,
0.0545079224,
-0.0986035913,
-0.0094276937,
-0.0129217934,
0.0614424646,
-0.0028402791,
-0.0174314659,
-0.0736420378,
-0.0375596099,
-0.0079819793,
-0.0061108032,
0.0032599883,
-0.0167178735,
0.0429723486,
-0.0664358735,
-0.0149785634,
-0.0043508955,
-0.0082907761,
-0.0253021047,
-0.0085107442,
-0.0375195481,
0.0063750721,
-0.0318577699,
-0.0199856386,
0.0284053199,
-0.046106223,
0.0076571642,
-0.0726621523,
-0.0132945757,
0.0517872125,
0.0119540701,
-0.0267382152,
0.0452187806,
0.0437855944,
-0.0015152812,
0.0074777212,
0.0017172172,
-0.0384108163,
-0.0250360593,
-0.0090041636,
0.0270803198,
-0.0061352109,
0.0264634769,
-0.0061314027,
0.0206284057,
-0.0777674839,
0.0099872248,
0.0318896547,
0.0496828295,
-0.0108361533,
-0.0750062838,
-0.0422441363,
-0.0415982418,
-0.0251332596,
0.0337803662,
0.0035298315,
-0.0421458036,
0.0005040831,
-0.0357368812,
-0.0046205949,
-0.0121685741,
-0.010854627,
0.087960273,
-0.0234625433,
-0.0629603714,
-0.0639241561,
-0.0193509012,
-0.0163482465,
0.0113084279,
-0.0298497509,
-0.0288005527,
-0.0033537499,
-0.0340881199,
-0.0128111541,
-0.0561613813,
-0.0385213308,
0.0044350084,
0.0018596803,
0.0114115402,
0.0761056989,
0.0313389599,
-0.0399676338,
-0.004224122,
-0.0251941904,
-0.0296582207,
-0.0509610437,
-0.0139193665,
0.0033798974,
0.0406175964,
-0.0192458685,
-0.0239113513,
0.0479920246,
0.0024696689,
-0.0532876849,
0.0107406173,
0.0073387232,
-0.0261849761,
-0.0230483077,
0.0378802866,
-0.0699981526,
0.0539867543,
-0.0053944183,
-0.0103784716,
-0.0053179283,
-0.0422726013,
0.0013210532,
-0.0325475931,
0.0081008254,
0.0076854788,
-0.0285126064,
-0.0093755731,
0.0660380647,
-0.0481495485,
-0.0265368707,
-0.0314114019,
0.00303988,
0.0406698026,
0.0048334813,
-0.044255469,
0.0301961079,
0.073545292,
0.0058525717,
0.0220790915,
-0.0243705995,
0.0142945414,
0.0716435984,
-0.0106529603,
0.0149575397,
-0.0441067815,
-0.0370197594,
0.0343739614,
0.0359026566,
-0.0219720956,
0.0622654296,
0.0264696367,
-0.0034834058,
-0.0321292989,
0.0001876219,
-0.0427714996,
0.0577691831,
-0.0468268022,
-0.0759560242,
0.0650722161,
0.0282143764,
0.0234789308,
-0.0381538905,
0.0104072588,
0.00438528,
0.0102825332,
0.011101733,
-0.0907043293,
0.0122973453,
-0.0216493141,
-0.0284472592,
-0.0090051964,
0.0570302568,
0.1095151603,
-0.0036451947,
0.0028222208,
-0.0218229983,
-0.0206249226,
0.025270503,
0.0192751661,
0.0521324463,
0.002923511,
0.0016793235,
-0.0193145871,
-0.0339208767,
0.0319743492,
-0.0375780091,
0.0359150991,
0.0162537377,
0.0554433614,
0.0225133225,
0.0010104703,
-0.0211869627,
-0.0100581143,
-0.0178977251,
-0.0132106338,
-0.0177127589,
-0.0423513465,
-6.336026958e-33,
-0.0250663888,
-0.0329436474,
-0.0351281539,
-0.0014454937,
-0.0152450716,
0.0018185786,
-0.035828013,
-0.0238617826,
-0.0060046702,
0.0269716699,
0.0131021766,
0.0196437649,
-0.0079780612,
0.0647976995,
0.0527055524,
-0.0048254258,
0.0110994801,
-0.0154851256,
-0.0085309772,
0.0420369133,
0.0320148841,
-0.0009228553,
0.055721119,
-0.083388783,
-0.0066410382,
-0.0055240346,
-0.0055160834,
-0.00931961,
0.0456460454,
-0.0044098035,
-0.0107865725,
0.0532290377,
0.0520291589,
-0.0071931076,
0.0024170282,
0.0327938758,
-0.1014378369,
-0.024961913,
-0.0432991236,
0.0039525838,
-0.0198216829,
-0.0458307154,
0.0404264145,
0.0373938493,
0.0654745847,
-0.0748192444,
0.0457268693,
0.0050973375,
-0.0132290926,
-0.0962223485,
-0.0659865662,
0.0381774642,
0.0028608746,
0.0262065474,
0.0074597714,
0.0552466325,
0.0193868782,
0.0499687903,
-0.0762822628,
-0.0119907409,
-0.0265016053,
0.0203073882,
0.0081810663,
0.0314518847,
-0.0056530656,
0.0392332152,
0.0238066614,
0.0407101661,
-0.0365843661,
0.0126213282,
0.0178442169,
0.0125301061,
0.0687378943,
0.0328756273,
0.054253988,
-0.0143170711,
-0.0989840925,
0.0369215868,
-0.0067083947,
-0.0226681512,
0.0127382213,
0.0506098345,
-0.0250089914,
-0.0410965718,
-0.0168094225,
0.0226815958,
-0.0415056981,
-0.0567561164,
0.0209318828,
0.0090223588,
0.031388063,
0.0226926412,
0.0136612467,
-0.0067250151,
-0.0116830971,
0.0158201866,
0.0110806497,
0.0697407648,
-0.000809629,
0.0193076208,
-0.029560199,
-0.0591743998,
0.040682368,
-0.0000882216,
0.0224692207,
0.0082713496,
0.0735648721,
-0.0215061754,
-0.0480801314,
-0.0275031831,
0.0116096754,
-0.0500152037,
-0.0095622893,
0.0526736155,
-0.005013172,
0.0288390517,
0.0064561493,
0.0780760795,
0.0136844441,
0.0216590371,
-0.0051640547,
0.0150651103,
0.0157827064,
0.0317686535,
-0.0061994703,
-0.0291896593,
-0.0308370125,
-0.0441140868,
0.0543822832,
-0.0526559949,
-0.0040217456,
-0.0137459887,
2.807e-7,
0.0396631807,
0.0338339731,
-0.0048894286,
-0.049715817,
0.0641485229,
0.0560763068,
0.0300329756,
0.0561306328,
-0.0448445231,
-0.0569686517,
0.0351555645,
-0.0487274639,
0.0523552001,
0.0208137576,
-0.1081820205,
-0.0411037728,
-0.0816183314,
-0.0244301166,
-0.0331105627,
0.0200160015,
0.0956356749,
0.1056427583,
0.0032318104,
-0.0057952367,
0.0139869312,
-0.0132196294,
0.0670863017,
0.0116094742,
0.0390515327,
0.0195706598,
-0.0519222431,
-0.0040438385,
-0.0383811891,
0.0272613764,
-0.0412777476,
0.0056826063,
0.019858133,
0.0350859873,
-0.037857756,
-0.0008934135,
0.0140358806,
0.0039175595,
-0.012804077,
-0.0219235402,
0.0470110551,
-0.0820216611,
-0.0464035384,
0.0442879237,
-0.0108713899,
0.0338425562,
-0.0129376827,
0.0401741229,
-0.0015045144,
0.0114804925,
0.0080426279,
0.0045984741,
-0.0117362021,
-0.1044063568,
0.0214940794,
0.0280886684,
-0.0342017449,
0.0203030705,
-0.0528617874,
0.0284257792,
0.0427141078,
-0.0423805192,
0.0097553795,
2.566178095e-34,
-0.0012024831,
-0.0370368734,
-0.0410402305,
0.0191054139,
0.0274724774,
-0.0221171789,
-0.0268792547,
0.0109942649,
0.0048172078,
-0.0610384606,
0.0165272281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15175v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15175v1 | Pre-training Multi-party Dialogue Models with Latent Discourse Inference | 2023-05-24T14:06:27 | 2023-05-24T14:06:27 | Yiyang Li, Xinting Huang, Wei Bi, Hai Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-party dialogues are more difficult for models to understand than
one-to-one two-party dialogues, since they involve multiple interlocutors,
resulting in interweaving reply-to relations and information flows. To step
over these obstacles, an effective way is to pre-train a model that understands
the discourse structure of multi-party dialogues, namely, to whom each
utterance is replying. However, due to the lack of explicitly annotated
discourse labels in multi-party dialogue corpora, previous works fail to scale
up the pre-training process by putting aside the unlabeled multi-party
conversational data for nothing. To fully utilize the unlabeled data, we
propose to treat the discourse structures as latent variables, then jointly
infer them and pre-train the discourse-aware model by unsupervised latent
variable inference methods. Experiments on multiple downstream tasks show that
our pre-trained model outperforms strong baselines by large margins and
achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) results, justifying the effectiveness of our
method. The official implementation of this paper is available at
https://github.com/EricLee8/MPD_EMVI. | [
0.0413594432,
0.0889153704,
0.0051850625,
0.0526563041,
0.0132340509,
0.033993341,
0.0193259511,
-0.0309362803,
-0.0089275511,
-0.0777501911,
-0.0320848115,
-0.0000019348,
-0.0298745222,
0.020842785,
0.0118615003,
-0.0333700962,
0.0437453799,
-0.0145252738,
0.0443882868,
-0.0331177264,
0.0134580294,
0.0112713333,
-0.0518921129,
0.0097557409,
-0.0410391204,
-0.0374235287,
-0.0484097824,
-0.0076206201,
0.012236272,
-0.0025022614,
0.0450362451,
0.0888864696,
0.0314944685,
0.001296247,
0.0000018114,
-0.0382652171,
-0.0065181577,
-0.0677519143,
0.0156242633,
0.0357855856,
0.0399118736,
-0.0057648425,
0.0225393809,
0.0167928729,
-0.0313775018,
-0.0241993163,
0.0277957823,
0.0892780051,
0.0713452473,
0.0396722592,
-0.0179312546,
-0.0352866799,
-0.0536550544,
-0.0209420752,
-0.0498560444,
-0.0948084518,
0.0286377855,
0.0190791301,
-0.0658460036,
0.0199269503,
0.0019272697,
0.001297246,
-0.0217543989,
-0.0226484146,
-0.0077445288,
0.0316290967,
0.0060210708,
-0.0145276003,
-0.0263345893,
0.1128202006,
0.0709593371,
-0.0200470053,
0.0127673838,
-0.0123864608,
-0.0427928343,
0.0035100684,
-0.0156637561,
-0.0108690169,
0.0201700088,
0.0063683381,
0.0062184329,
0.0205250252,
-0.0005756515,
0.0111300014,
-0.0295324773,
0.0519064404,
-0.0196553729,
-0.0155742206,
0.0141924014,
0.0041386103,
-0.0143653369,
-0.0571322963,
-0.0346184522,
-0.016132541,
-0.0172114018,
0.0178377908,
-0.0000918112,
-0.0289628468,
-0.0072421539,
-0.0745051876,
0.0145841567,
0.0085089877,
-0.0243908744,
0.0729515404,
0.0267643649,
-0.0098086707,
-0.0369522646,
0.0008510437,
0.0019862209,
-0.0383298658,
-0.030988574,
-0.0022760818,
-0.0400988758,
0.0450929962,
-0.0640718192,
-0.0012341506,
-0.0066313036,
0.002965474,
-0.0109323198,
-0.0259092953,
0.0204387829,
0.0147980172,
-0.0276499148,
-0.0010256591,
-0.0206150357,
0.0525530428,
-0.0562964901,
0.0448971316,
-0.018163329,
-0.0285662562,
-0.013110606,
0.0595408008,
-0.018743651,
-0.0119527904,
-0.013636739,
0.0500610434,
-0.0359548628,
-0.0206370112,
0.0179616641,
0.0089824758,
-0.0290193167,
-0.0503926314,
0.0458945148,
-0.0130361812,
0.0506744273,
-0.0056535262,
0.0000284743,
-0.027295595,
0.0368136689,
-0.0259270798,
-0.0413878337,
0.0622788817,
0.0089990692,
0.0080214478,
0.0324655995,
0.0255213249,
0.0043385569,
0.0815295205,
0.0472776443,
-0.0213873498,
0.026610747,
-0.0001639419,
0.0006513908,
0.0236633122,
0.0193780214,
0.0016969248,
0.0589469299,
0.0293761082,
-0.0086671812,
-0.0111121191,
0.0358991623,
0.0071844249,
-0.0220982991,
-0.0416489281,
0.0347533338,
0.0365346521,
-0.0461391062,
0.0296734665,
0.0342296064,
0.0330347605,
-0.0071270545,
0.0376234017,
-0.0090009132,
0.0141408797,
0.0100809988,
-0.051991988,
0.0808654726,
-0.007092285,
-0.0521856658,
-0.0417329334,
0.0296921432,
-0.0008163152,
0.0099629052,
0.003195595,
0.0490975007,
-0.0061495444,
-0.0292218868,
0.0572010726,
0.0668762624,
-0.043485336,
-0.0426613763,
-0.0262095723,
0.0288950689,
-0.0110506797,
0.0260781124,
-0.0142536685,
-0.014570347,
-0.0219850298,
0.0581959896,
0.0239314139,
0.053870365,
-0.0267815869,
0.0664169267,
-0.0326241255,
-0.0220268015,
-0.0282953475,
0.0177845713,
0.0839860588,
0.0126835685,
-0.0349878669,
-0.0099904174,
0.0311553888,
0.0275098514,
-0.0119889993,
-0.0325271301,
-0.0160120241,
0.0464096926,
0.0059369542,
0.0628203675,
0.0205938369,
-0.0185486861,
-0.0388236046,
0.0440654643,
0.0039608241,
0.0113835195,
0.0279797111,
-0.0696383119,
-0.0364075378,
0.0029053111,
-0.0060070883,
-0.0159030817,
-0.0186446141,
-0.0416842289,
-0.0475932769,
0.0625765324,
0.0018678817,
-0.0007068379,
-0.0582874045,
-0.0203265324,
0.0127616581,
-0.0048474469,
0.0052914172,
0.0611400902,
0.0084505221,
0.002085994,
0.0251898784,
-0.0038752563,
0.0175780728,
-0.0155322729,
0.0016510495,
0.0174578596,
0.0090677906,
0.0021416908,
0.0412079804,
0.0132271983,
-0.0191924553,
-0.0306099914,
-0.1454775333,
-0.0039092163,
-0.0356439464,
0.0242565554,
0.0152609665,
0.0096401609,
-0.0082358662,
-0.0245977547,
-0.014388917,
-0.0081522688,
0.0162449926,
-0.0094017982,
0.0469768457,
0.0256919563,
0.0188018102,
-0.0277910214,
0.0468644761,
-0.035765186,
0.0359944627,
0.0024928194,
-0.0982673019,
0.003894418,
-0.005730649,
-0.0289777368,
0.0324592106,
-0.0435328223,
-0.0417281352,
0.005088544,
0.0258368459,
0.0806760713,
0.0479982831,
0.0522926338,
0.0551350936,
-0.0288298186,
-0.0407022908,
-0.0487566628,
0.0571858697,
-0.0423451401,
0.0037405875,
-0.0465613827,
0.021056788,
0.0177097004,
0.093584843,
-0.0103468848,
0.0026664147,
-0.0337788723,
0.0219004117,
0.0320122465,
-0.0534684248,
0.0117075462,
-0.0057836473,
-0.0049851411,
0.0162949469,
0.0062407791,
0.0063339639,
0.0449349023,
-0.0360351764,
-0.0156706646,
-0.0481322594,
-0.0212020762,
-0.0239224657,
0.0613349378,
-0.0079703731,
-0.0126144104,
0.0011526662,
-0.0395152941,
-0.0241094921,
-0.0043410272,
0.0561318919,
-0.0107605383,
0.0404560231,
-0.0574412644,
0.0292356014,
-0.002399862,
-0.0524134524,
-0.0468106158,
-0.0581876673,
-0.006124862,
0.006795438,
-0.0142370267,
-0.0046289191,
-0.0426444449,
0.0264300853,
-0.0028322386,
-0.0052817087,
0.018862905,
0.0352370963,
-0.0323160514,
0.0457714386,
0.0026716501,
-0.0070840833,
0.005475584,
-0.0568297468,
0.0465358868,
0.0468690991,
-0.008168282,
-0.0232562292,
-0.0106484992,
-0.0251782797,
-0.0025714906,
0.012705694,
-0.0158429891,
-0.019505186,
0.0672016814,
0.0057658176,
-0.0022225825,
0.0936130062,
0.0119911088,
-0.0289798733,
-0.01996677,
0.0244476311,
0.0101508172,
0.0031265747,
0.0098088775,
-0.0890086442,
-0.0118038598,
-0.0105209872,
-0.009662983,
-0.0131187681,
-0.0622262061,
-0.0152183175,
-0.0646600947,
0.013600749,
-0.025908215,
0.0190293938,
0.0156108802,
-0.016965203,
0.0301546678,
-0.0176708549,
-0.0197751038,
-0.0381701216,
0.0198379289,
-0.0024474033,
0.0136179496,
-0.0380599312,
-0.0426991582,
0.0284134205,
0.0024871069,
0.0418077782,
0.0204988699,
0.055653818,
0.0262237769,
0.0406569727,
0.0489794165,
-0.0431459621,
-0.0472133458,
-0.0092642885,
0.0410563573,
-0.0463571548,
0.0007327347,
0.0046894285,
0.0355202965,
0.0095941434,
-0.0159788299,
0.0252464935,
-0.0228048284,
-0.0552258529,
-0.0147550767,
0.0164961666,
0.0563577972,
0.0556034893,
0.0562471226,
0.0440519862,
-0.0110762389,
-0.0452785939,
-0.0307528619,
0.0069723953,
-0.0049941516,
0.011741098,
-0.0410081148,
-0.0053824931,
0.0103917671,
-0.0383928008,
-0.0723073259,
0.0377859324,
0.0106487619,
-0.0240827892,
0.0011419323,
0.0208173078,
0.0214408953,
0.0015027705,
0.0110418862,
-0.0551481061,
-0.0215427708,
-0.0240317099,
-0.0668224245,
0.0796651244,
0.0004779771,
-0.0429717153,
-0.0007909034,
-0.0705050752,
-0.0506713688,
-0.0519629121,
0.0589548796,
0.012381223,
0.0649504662,
-0.0324232951,
-0.0125931874,
0.0129924025,
0.014919864,
-0.058896739,
0.0007845857,
0.0324981436,
0.0548482426,
-0.0026740145,
0.0273920055,
0.0014011808,
0.0679301918,
0.0148364296,
0.0153273027,
-0.0608278438,
-0.0945200846,
-0.0098742694,
-0.0222626515,
0.0822127089,
0.0520920381,
-0.005353943,
-0.05885984,
0.0080001764,
-0.0357873589,
-0.0395454913,
-0.054083813,
0.0208850875,
-0.0491479859,
-0.0343473218,
-0.0129518779,
-0.018872546,
-0.0260338224,
0.0695437193,
-0.0125748878,
0.0100551657,
0.0297346003,
0.0121252099,
-0.0219123736,
-0.0348882973,
-0.0057499688,
0.0315048099,
0.0341063477,
0.0384826213,
0.0141519904,
0.0898954868,
0.0120125748,
-0.0273822509,
0.0540986806,
-0.0030259332,
-0.0837843418,
0.0183449984,
-0.0459388681,
0.0765223801,
0.0352076516,
0.002628292,
0.0514234118,
-0.0394943692,
0.0181797221,
-0.0132910348,
0.1073051244,
-0.0100351041,
-0.0216078497,
0.0422506295,
0.0110788271,
-0.0530096106,
0.0194804035,
0.0734450072,
0.0344023928,
0.0141131748,
0.0361032747,
0.0104484288,
-0.0639135391,
-0.0587834083,
0.0265954081,
0.0254418068,
-0.0185442679,
0.0732330531,
-0.0070533492,
0.0148181235,
0.0042565186,
-0.01783715,
-0.0259235129,
0.0244333223,
0.0113246748,
0.072340861,
-0.0017212461,
0.0028947019,
-0.0694243535,
-0.0015317097,
-0.0194979142,
-0.0130855413,
-0.0356502943,
-6.224265363e-33,
-0.0742982924,
-0.0299918167,
0.0274625663,
0.0279376581,
-0.0025343366,
-0.0122090532,
-0.0460518338,
0.0054833139,
-0.014030504,
0.0319411568,
0.0012078919,
0.0343311615,
0.0218104981,
0.0148610575,
-0.0060807783,
-0.0348899029,
0.0427595191,
-0.0174968969,
-0.0115009369,
0.0578023382,
0.0366119295,
0.0156994164,
0.0604210645,
-0.081561625,
-0.0077545587,
-0.0136738848,
0.0035375138,
0.0232270174,
0.0261899661,
0.0225480068,
-0.0293900259,
-0.031945236,
0.0082151871,
0.0067494432,
0.0069525619,
0.0456637144,
-0.069208622,
-0.0156575181,
0.007807421,
-0.0116197681,
-0.0320203528,
-0.0203654822,
-0.0333715864,
0.0059125926,
0.0413092561,
-0.0067191124,
0.0428749174,
-0.0014587682,
0.0232987981,
-0.0231700558,
-0.0269603077,
0.0327624492,
-0.0425481685,
-0.008787347,
-0.0006337576,
0.0750214234,
0.0466271937,
-0.0204867348,
-0.0638994426,
0.0419083908,
-0.0343694054,
-0.0338617936,
0.0215310659,
-0.004126783,
0.0215099324,
0.0592832863,
0.0065099094,
0.0268383753,
-0.0491660126,
-0.0208684281,
-0.0116868895,
0.0304307584,
-0.0055884738,
0.0268214028,
-0.0494751893,
0.0108704166,
-0.0904657766,
-0.0169915892,
0.0450975224,
-0.0092068072,
0.0047976193,
-0.0309939608,
0.0006614602,
-0.0328169279,
-0.036445383,
-0.0189241059,
0.0003316864,
-0.0326681696,
0.0305791441,
0.0125549156,
-0.0229978468,
0.0001326052,
0.0540959723,
-0.0681661963,
-0.0340643227,
0.0111508789,
0.0057748486,
-0.0136808883,
-0.0115791671,
0.0308714658,
-0.0457659848,
-0.0301666949,
0.0403998271,
-0.0098674092,
0.0251172818,
-0.0090062311,
0.0165211242,
-0.0473562554,
-0.0388955399,
-0.0362817384,
-0.0005381473,
0.0261480436,
-0.0593362488,
0.0878407583,
0.0072911424,
0.0078143822,
0.0010104445,
0.0509405695,
0.0067021749,
0.0012571004,
-0.0038503564,
-0.0408182219,
-0.0152373519,
0.0298748165,
-0.0335063525,
-0.0251649115,
-0.0201811083,
-0.0233535245,
-0.0048209503,
0.0094106961,
0.0038074346,
0.0063728648,
2.427e-7,
0.015972428,
0.0202612076,
0.0331610404,
-0.0083657447,
0.0082235504,
0.0405636169,
-0.0091619063,
0.0342898518,
-0.0050155502,
-0.0613922775,
0.024953736,
0.0382629633,
0.0603075996,
0.0239254292,
-0.0606871359,
-0.0415869243,
-0.0704448745,
-0.0235256273,
-0.0280379411,
-0.0475470982,
0.0375664234,
0.0569690317,
0.0100076878,
0.0305315219,
-0.0372698419,
0.022066189,
0.0888345987,
-0.0279405471,
-0.058382839,
0.054356955,
0.0299406182,
-0.0296085719,
-0.0089392234,
0.0315172151,
-0.0080891121,
0.0550488681,
-0.0203043539,
0.0864893198,
0.0244091228,
-0.0432866178,
-0.0067475638,
0.0183727909,
0.0160985179,
0.0121843945,
0.0466648862,
-0.0717236474,
-0.0400185399,
-0.0044833738,
-0.0351732075,
-0.0073691076,
0.0428902023,
0.0149447983,
0.0045172614,
0.0310031734,
0.0069237887,
-0.0360919237,
0.0310396738,
-0.0728173479,
0.0370387994,
-0.0249078553,
-0.0529369041,
-0.0383236818,
0.0196419749,
-0.0262698662,
0.0471273549,
-0.0073380135,
0.0107794264,
1.756759203e-34,
0.0442839637,
-0.0333390199,
-0.0475722924,
0.0163670927,
0.0523862951,
-0.037854217,
-0.0242039468,
-0.0295051914,
0.0287988223,
-0.0684618205,
0.0147846444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15138v1 | Topic-Guided Self-Introduction Generation for Social Media Users | 2023-05-24T13:35:08 | 2023-05-24T13:35:08 | Chunpu Xu, Jing Li, Piji Li, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Millions of users are active on social media. To allow users to better
showcase themselves and network with others, we explore the auto-generation of
social media self-introduction, a short sentence outlining a user's personal
interests. While most prior work profiles users with tags (e.g., ages), we
investigate sentence-level self-introductions to provide a more natural and
engaging way for users to know each other. Here we exploit a user's tweeting
history to generate their self-introduction. The task is non-trivial because
the history content may be lengthy, noisy, and exhibit various personal
interests. To address this challenge, we propose a novel unified topic-guided
encoder-decoder (UTGED) framework; it models latent topics to reflect salient
user interest, whose topic mixture then guides encoding a user's history and
topic words control decoding their self-introduction. For experiments, we
collect a large-scale Twitter dataset, and extensive results show the
superiority of our UTGED to the advanced encoder-decoder models without topic
modeling. | [
0.0273913797,
0.0285599194,
0.0000688251,
-0.0068465765,
0.024847459,
0.0183504205,
0.0119654359,
-0.0311211515,
-0.0091917133,
-0.0016395077,
0.049776461,
-0.0050553484,
-0.0210019723,
0.0450957492,
0.0220590532,
-0.0611190423,
0.0030803587,
-0.0031792673,
0.0433981121,
-0.0063672769,
0.0099690268,
0.0028090908,
0.0054403911,
0.0291735493,
-0.0143660037,
-0.0112558575,
-0.0140950894,
0.0118628433,
0.0052396003,
-0.0240744017,
0.0493326522,
0.0780099109,
0.0392890722,
-0.023727484,
0.0000017459,
-0.016416125,
-0.000946634,
-0.0539136529,
0.0427821986,
-0.0372851938,
0.0839171559,
0.0018245928,
0.0188602675,
0.0274501443,
-0.056279894,
0.0223062467,
0.0333297402,
0.0536541715,
0.0683072433,
0.0614558719,
-0.0349042192,
-0.0361717269,
-0.0035374735,
-0.0332726911,
0.0633850992,
-0.0173724033,
0.0043980912,
-0.0179002807,
-0.0265337955,
0.0446050614,
-0.0090728998,
0.0348132066,
0.0129098594,
-0.0032522539,
0.1493703276,
0.0242100637,
0.0315375067,
-0.0174599681,
-0.0146040674,
0.0663790405,
0.0287100505,
-0.0070178523,
0.0393776484,
-0.0046672337,
0.006538868,
-0.011626374,
-0.0401662849,
-0.0030881425,
0.0044261217,
0.0176761523,
0.0298654512,
0.0488857254,
-0.0080689723,
0.0122693246,
0.0026268312,
0.0309425034,
0.0116441203,
-0.039041061,
-0.0315387957,
0.0356474072,
0.0553556569,
-0.0712670609,
0.0391014405,
0.0047133914,
0.0115685733,
-0.0060652629,
-0.0404514559,
-0.0432825461,
-0.0403115898,
-0.0086812116,
-0.0540890582,
0.002747565,
0.0120945442,
0.0102916323,
0.044220496,
-0.0046881321,
-0.0007707448,
-0.0534310266,
0.0071710041,
-0.00807105,
-0.0268447306,
0.0005447723,
-0.0336426124,
0.0284397658,
0.0057141548,
-0.0335736051,
-0.0339335613,
0.0708197951,
0.0170433018,
-0.0344915539,
-0.0162233524,
0.0238269214,
-0.0329636969,
-0.0106077278,
-0.0031848554,
0.015394425,
-0.0559486188,
-0.0253563765,
0.0265505593,
0.0124845253,
-0.0138623537,
0.018644657,
0.0789689645,
-0.0337460712,
-0.0315074362,
-0.0278769825,
-0.0222085342,
-0.0757534653,
-0.0202837288,
-0.0450663157,
0.0080272937,
-0.00526179,
0.00142322,
-0.047699444,
0.0633378476,
0.0238666385,
0.0032544935,
-0.0434201173,
-0.0078447461,
0.0291953254,
-0.0323897749,
0.0322767049,
-0.0586331934,
0.0468009785,
0.0442637503,
0.0452946499,
0.0622644275,
0.0393872783,
-0.0092970217,
0.0977056101,
0.0230556186,
-0.0030054257,
0.0176660847,
0.0089662382,
0.003152817,
-0.0027404814,
0.0340414979,
-0.0230472498,
-0.0507583395,
0.0291593429,
0.0166336298,
0.0394498706,
-0.0186777972,
0.024256967,
0.0411134399,
0.0713741332,
0.0103911227,
0.0656793565,
0.0412083864,
0.071523048,
-0.0056595337,
-0.0198383741,
-0.0066728783,
0.0413555615,
-0.0064579821,
-0.0242978595,
0.0830995515,
0.0254003927,
-0.0568462797,
-0.0048752893,
0.0490058251,
-0.0361422561,
0.0325953253,
-0.0081284232,
0.0097892806,
0.0356993936,
-0.0337710455,
0.0537135564,
0.0163307711,
-0.0938129127,
0.0247711558,
0.0101506989,
0.016780721,
0.0967496857,
0.0261949636,
0.0291057993,
0.0080046281,
-0.0325896889,
0.0468739457,
0.019595746,
0.0180502124,
-0.0054407837,
0.0219641384,
-0.0373747721,
-0.0250553843,
-0.0133456234,
0.0002088473,
0.0066417647,
0.0216456838,
0.0412607454,
0.025165746,
-0.0110981548,
0.0357605256,
-0.0012665337,
-0.0075757313,
-0.037142612,
0.0632559881,
0.0239623189,
-0.0237150937,
0.0809653774,
0.0383360274,
-0.0279975869,
0.0150848217,
0.0032586434,
-0.0296684187,
0.0123576382,
-0.0410511047,
-0.046146851,
0.0138222901,
-0.0463126823,
-0.0319688804,
0.0076073194,
-0.0329750851,
-0.0637123436,
0.0880620405,
-0.0357200988,
0.0264051687,
-0.0068910206,
-0.023506619,
-0.0061743497,
0.0288422797,
0.0227140207,
0.0564670675,
-0.0050399085,
-0.0363740884,
-0.0107713928,
-0.0416348614,
-0.0132815531,
-0.0673686042,
-0.0092609301,
-0.0527008437,
-0.0189685188,
0.0015599789,
0.0611753315,
0.008091554,
-0.0604912192,
-0.0475773923,
-0.0968286768,
-0.0234261323,
-0.0399373695,
-0.0119825369,
0.0113146966,
0.0633379817,
0.001074821,
-0.0387587585,
-0.0529082306,
0.0072247847,
0.0058799777,
0.0081603918,
0.053828422,
-0.0036603191,
-0.0006944325,
-0.0279447306,
-0.0158047918,
-0.0115277078,
0.0438461639,
0.0285227597,
-0.0283939876,
-0.0063534938,
-0.0290485471,
-0.0270847473,
-0.0309580751,
-0.0154757565,
0.0046783453,
-0.0078847948,
-0.008546819,
0.0838911384,
-0.0160756856,
0.0645235628,
0.0835589617,
-0.0101068402,
-0.0129706459,
-0.0107827932,
-0.0048810146,
-0.0421135314,
0.0193492807,
-0.0224152859,
-0.0472244024,
0.0357090086,
0.0209817514,
-0.0040160576,
0.0268269833,
-0.0718242452,
0.0200294908,
0.0245518759,
-0.0179741122,
-0.0198240429,
0.0092711318,
0.0101028327,
0.018085761,
-0.0028363769,
-0.0037282165,
0.0483586639,
0.0119913043,
-0.0190045349,
0.0197508242,
-0.0471945815,
-0.0274133105,
0.0238375962,
0.0177917071,
0.0321094356,
0.0183031447,
-0.0535743944,
0.0428853445,
0.033655908,
0.0031453364,
-0.0097527504,
0.014449589,
0.029449733,
-0.0009203305,
0.0501474887,
-0.023856286,
-0.0294151511,
-0.1134483516,
-0.0224394947,
-0.0404136516,
-0.0281467233,
-0.0346701816,
-0.0205265824,
-0.0244249254,
-0.0103276074,
-0.0441320762,
-0.0521309339,
-0.0138915647,
-0.0373953208,
0.0477306135,
0.0491810441,
-0.0481272377,
-0.0507138446,
-0.0213965904,
0.0294881873,
-0.0085004382,
0.0199066531,
-0.0212362874,
-0.0335531346,
-0.0006020457,
0.0170202404,
-0.0247065201,
0.0210551806,
0.047577966,
0.0752916485,
0.0257596094,
0.0020948634,
0.1295295656,
0.0251362137,
-0.0502060317,
-0.009791553,
0.0153787993,
0.0234532189,
-0.0185285788,
0.0301026534,
-0.0717906728,
-0.0149352578,
-0.0238085017,
0.0358367376,
0.0308966339,
-0.0367440581,
-0.0303234588,
-0.0240039919,
-0.0024626215,
0.0465179905,
-0.0126612671,
-0.0075620702,
-0.0521942526,
-0.0565986782,
-0.0418724157,
-0.0143678356,
0.0025896719,
-0.0541110635,
0.02302921,
0.0008045442,
-0.0233344324,
-0.0756801441,
-0.007331463,
-0.0360250846,
0.0700755492,
0.0030216505,
0.0482989326,
0.0297205783,
-0.0028600884,
-0.0588075258,
0.0392789356,
0.0089563932,
0.00367697,
0.054712072,
-0.0479559936,
0.0360379256,
-0.0497247279,
0.0252037123,
-0.05539608,
-0.0374132805,
-0.0067314599,
0.0144161014,
-0.0342171192,
-0.0289109591,
0.000455956,
0.0205210131,
0.0537689999,
0.0590725578,
0.0567037798,
-0.0468001589,
-0.0200585127,
-0.0403528139,
0.044307366,
-0.0332932621,
-0.025664378,
-0.0501811206,
0.0116786137,
-0.0673481673,
-0.0425780751,
-0.0642055422,
0.0089942235,
-0.0297149774,
-0.0282679945,
0.0088176616,
0.0289732032,
-0.0231338535,
-0.0678034425,
0.005632428,
-0.0555197969,
-0.0062079593,
-0.0368191488,
-0.0460235327,
0.0161301903,
-0.0471003167,
0.0254597664,
0.0052477913,
-0.0796627253,
-0.0473780893,
0.0000585946,
0.0126963491,
0.0086705508,
0.0433658808,
-0.0321350284,
-0.0940678045,
0.0228451118,
0.0280914567,
-0.0348136202,
0.0096614212,
-0.0076702135,
0.0254262742,
-0.0060732975,
0.0272698477,
-0.0230322517,
-0.004899418,
-0.0554291196,
-0.025217196,
-0.0610353909,
-0.0667715743,
-0.0172458421,
0.0015742872,
0.0491417795,
-0.0081435349,
-0.0176046919,
-0.028282119,
-0.0575315617,
-0.0226979759,
0.0033188444,
-0.0305594448,
0.0039052777,
0.0252974983,
0.0034070252,
-0.0129185794,
-0.0234492123,
-0.0468298271,
0.0217918549,
-0.0443400405,
-0.0041607833,
-0.0538124107,
0.03022868,
0.0153867984,
0.0007551922,
-0.0131942285,
0.0216262639,
0.0676320866,
-0.000909498,
-0.0218959637,
0.0181150474,
-0.0452551618,
0.0190429688,
0.016749721,
0.0589451753,
-0.049211707,
0.0013528521,
-0.0113940202,
0.0017397648,
0.0267386977,
0.0210530516,
0.0675349012,
0.005068948,
0.0391566232,
0.0008760192,
0.0513133891,
-0.0421727858,
-0.0628477335,
0.0119593143,
-0.0205405056,
-0.025899861,
0.0130009931,
0.060396634,
0.0178961046,
-0.0246266872,
0.0455754697,
0.0076099383,
-0.0266908873,
0.0321331955,
0.0025026514,
0.0574604124,
-0.0055728969,
0.0310415421,
-0.0063814097,
-0.0122808842,
0.0365216956,
-0.0550848842,
-0.0173953213,
0.0219517015,
0.0614396408,
0.04701823,
-0.0398042314,
-0.01478012,
-0.0569810048,
-0.0052322731,
-0.0235626977,
-0.0640420914,
-0.0110986037,
-6.669483113e-33,
-0.0048728446,
-0.0298071131,
0.0141293192,
0.0111971376,
-0.0218414087,
-0.0453160629,
-0.0680149049,
0.0358950794,
0.0455819741,
-0.0151563948,
-0.0272030029,
0.0185295492,
0.006112922,
0.0630426258,
-0.0116042104,
0.0182366241,
0.080946371,
0.0039255815,
0.0143658109,
0.0844579041,
0.0027136323,
0.0324168541,
-0.019805925,
-0.0798476413,
0.0068515749,
-0.0374926291,
-0.0028387655,
0.0019419476,
0.1210242733,
0.0153025072,
-0.0260290373,
0.0360930599,
0.0103569049,
0.0073894472,
-0.0094243204,
0.072106652,
-0.0671206042,
-0.0596290268,
-0.0535352156,
-0.0109388717,
-0.0252151061,
-0.0731777027,
0.0132679604,
-0.0187455043,
-0.020366339,
0.0072653517,
0.0592504218,
0.0387746282,
0.0412345044,
-0.0405565314,
-0.0187415611,
0.0350606926,
-0.032107573,
-0.0162539575,
0.0336893164,
0.0023326871,
0.0350525305,
-0.0131266806,
-0.0115126604,
0.0893131495,
0.008898275,
-0.0252845138,
0.0325955972,
-0.0227063727,
-0.0275527406,
0.0207082164,
0.0147649581,
0.0124263437,
-0.0155716743,
0.0299571697,
-0.027961785,
0.0151456688,
-0.0328647383,
0.0299889278,
-0.0082547823,
-0.0225141887,
-0.006199853,
0.0623923689,
0.0266999286,
-0.0144962249,
-0.0252196305,
0.003824685,
0.0021063369,
-0.0006084314,
0.0026376157,
-0.0214135554,
-0.0206206962,
-0.0546142161,
-0.0105957063,
0.0350625478,
-0.0379004218,
-0.0064227507,
0.0026530237,
-0.0327421948,
-0.0059681698,
0.0408090949,
-0.0345508866,
0.0269455668,
-0.0071174619,
0.0107033784,
-0.0425738804,
-0.0028167916,
0.0662722662,
-0.029804267,
-0.0175299346,
0.016628664,
-0.0356150158,
0.00533868,
-0.0545883887,
-0.0276603047,
0.0152939335,
0.0223886296,
-0.0356106758,
-0.0208317768,
-0.0025978626,
0.0557755977,
-0.0578631088,
0.065432094,
0.0177111663,
0.0512463264,
-0.0281038955,
-0.0620509945,
0.028961014,
0.0108516663,
0.0091659632,
0.0203963425,
-0.0459807329,
0.0220272206,
0.0671794936,
-0.0307543855,
-0.0202311166,
-0.001885482,
2.525e-7,
-0.0176692158,
0.0691024661,
0.0079387538,
-0.0073335352,
0.0236090794,
0.0376761071,
0.0347560495,
0.0596436299,
-0.0263612997,
-0.0148228407,
0.0389380381,
0.0505306534,
0.024796268,
-0.0097944997,
-0.0569629744,
0.0213894192,
-0.0501181222,
-0.0006046214,
-0.0475356169,
-0.0115197478,
0.0462563336,
0.024923604,
0.0293830093,
0.0103728883,
0.0072100246,
-0.0107063362,
0.0869143084,
0.0050296681,
-0.0412934907,
0.0329464935,
0.0166340843,
-0.0111247683,
-0.0059558665,
-0.0433347896,
-0.0273752194,
0.0053688181,
0.0210129805,
0.0422203615,
-0.011722791,
-0.0393412933,
0.0093426816,
0.0459913574,
-0.0220076889,
0.0059268209,
0.0245158151,
-0.0381090157,
-0.0450165793,
-0.0014766437,
-0.0008076761,
0.034928292,
0.0143828196,
0.0032688167,
-0.0572846085,
0.0130725009,
0.0236497764,
0.0114687728,
-0.0099623753,
-0.0877070948,
0.0424639061,
-0.0021210802,
-0.0277340021,
-0.0117344344,
-0.0359640531,
0.0214518234,
0.0304514822,
0.0009880548,
0.0476338603,
1.651184198e-34,
0.0041519431,
0.0057254131,
-0.0287927259,
-0.0188232474,
0.0069763851,
-0.0190112405,
-0.037019074,
-0.0027197436,
0.0391940437,
-0.0744744465,
-0.0153732374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15130v1 | On Degrees of Freedom in Defining and Testing Natural Language Understanding | 2023-05-24T13:25:20 | 2023-05-24T13:25:20 | Saku Sugawara, Shun Tsugita | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural language understanding (NLU) studies often exaggerate or
underestimate the capabilities of systems, thereby limiting the reproducibility
of their findings. These erroneous evaluations can be attributed to the
difficulty of defining and testing NLU adequately. In this position paper, we
reconsider this challenge by identifying two types of researcher degrees of
freedom. We revisit Turing's original interpretation of the Turing test and
indicate that an NLU test does not provide an operational definition; it merely
provides inductive evidence that the test subject understands the language
sufficiently well to meet stakeholder objectives. In other words, stakeholders
are free to arbitrarily define NLU through their objectives. To use the test
results as inductive evidence, stakeholders must carefully assess if the
interpretation of test scores is valid or not. However, designing and using NLU
tests involve other degrees of freedom, such as specifying target skills and
defining evaluation metrics. As a result, achieving consensus among
stakeholders becomes difficult. To resolve this issue, we propose a validity
argument, which is a framework comprising a series of validation criteria
across test components. By demonstrating that current practices in NLU studies
can be associated with those criteria and organizing them into a comprehensive
checklist, we prove that the validity argument can serve as a coherent
guideline for designing credible test sets and facilitating scientific
communication. | [
0.0598394237,
0.0035860017,
-0.0283760596,
0.0298145395,
-0.0331385806,
0.0128985867,
-0.0058321995,
-0.0176284537,
0.005848845,
-0.0516387075,
-0.0164943282,
-0.0030159459,
0.0493072085,
0.0246085301,
0.0051514623,
-0.0544432178,
0.0202030428,
0.0099757835,
0.0173081569,
0.0402632877,
0.0146432202,
0.0215124637,
-0.0266664084,
0.02614557,
0.0439016335,
0.0080423094,
0.0087376442,
-0.0545895398,
-0.00183602,
-0.0308870897,
-0.0414169133,
0.0156178055,
0.0588472709,
0.0308424756,
0.0000022341,
-0.0855048224,
0.0056810481,
0.0159341246,
-0.0607347749,
-0.0295841023,
0.0415444337,
0.007685408,
0.0152020948,
0.0198026523,
-0.0350113735,
-0.0055631571,
0.0346042439,
-0.0054266299,
0.0100460229,
0.0488321446,
0.009950256,
-0.0090954565,
-0.0191131029,
0.0253959,
-0.0035690884,
-0.0253474209,
-0.0021168692,
0.0232294109,
0.0338080116,
-0.0194533095,
-0.0285738148,
0.0454938449,
0.0296260118,
-0.0095035052,
-0.0180638377,
0.0119108874,
-0.0207249839,
-0.0548024289,
0.0235349983,
0.0328469388,
0.0733421072,
0.0205236431,
-0.0298054218,
0.0041041137,
-0.0060701086,
0.0400584228,
-0.0199714173,
0.0543870255,
-0.040413063,
-0.0225617122,
-0.0046958211,
0.0205752179,
0.0260386169,
0.0252692867,
-0.0132754492,
0.0617877357,
-0.0391870849,
-0.0368948877,
0.030164564,
0.0034110586,
0.0425236188,
-0.0052479347,
0.0131791448,
0.0133194933,
-0.032416977,
0.03758936,
0.052121859,
0.0086646201,
0.0387470089,
-0.0383762643,
0.0198943727,
0.0159205478,
-0.0078398632,
0.0158715937,
0.0183354784,
0.0455475785,
0.000752756,
0.0152192311,
-0.0099292556,
0.0191702507,
-0.0839815736,
-0.0518165305,
0.0165102202,
-0.0087748934,
-0.0140702892,
0.0279360097,
0.0169378147,
0.0011832543,
-0.0065939627,
0.0369509123,
-0.0527793877,
-0.001704738,
-0.0376466624,
0.0054655643,
-0.0394632071,
0.0425116569,
-0.0210323539,
0.0506560095,
-0.0159622114,
-0.0642422512,
0.0256398488,
0.0157827903,
-0.0080750026,
-0.0059522288,
0.0084299473,
0.0491208173,
0.0095819524,
-0.0161187481,
-0.0121126529,
-0.0208307896,
-0.0163329244,
-0.0514828861,
0.0346239917,
-0.0396092832,
-0.0355511084,
0.0253621936,
0.0029599206,
-0.0087769367,
0.0094261086,
0.0075461841,
-0.0224036481,
0.0709779114,
-0.0375471003,
-0.0082073612,
0.0250352975,
0.0295345653,
0.0198211744,
0.0459562726,
0.0264697708,
-0.0138142798,
0.0211636201,
0.0032526429,
-0.001048085,
-0.0162553117,
-0.0663510263,
-0.038520202,
0.0378529578,
0.0241319444,
-0.0285804793,
0.0198781472,
-0.0068218815,
0.0264691114,
-0.013486186,
0.03448686,
0.0330162309,
0.0675119832,
0.0095634833,
0.023804199,
0.0417652987,
0.0456906967,
0.0242782701,
0.0075137871,
-0.0084219063,
-0.0097494181,
-0.0161999315,
0.0236492474,
0.0079987338,
-0.0081421342,
0.0105067138,
-0.0748833492,
-0.02504039,
0.0142795183,
0.0519064888,
0.0017998707,
0.0486247689,
-0.0053652502,
-0.0147590172,
-0.0298635643,
-0.0333354473,
-0.0478702039,
0.0520101637,
-0.0349812172,
-0.0071037281,
0.0637546331,
0.0088551333,
-0.0031457182,
-0.0234354585,
-0.0308671147,
-0.0302681848,
0.0879570022,
0.0346997194,
-0.0133589776,
0.0109152757,
-0.0024529763,
-0.0483190641,
-0.0310891587,
-0.0296731312,
0.0179658495,
-0.0946980715,
-0.0012255854,
0.0063793729,
-0.0484583713,
-0.0581405349,
0.0416601598,
-0.005487191,
-0.0247984659,
-0.0701540038,
0.0273018051,
0.0396935418,
0.0553759485,
-0.0239713416,
0.0023011519,
-0.0184318852,
-0.0050086915,
0.0087851789,
0.0465864614,
0.0026948934,
0.0239092465,
0.005423794,
-0.139724806,
-0.0295582376,
0.0833920836,
-0.0142683061,
-0.0440071933,
0.0451218039,
-0.0381595716,
-0.0451973304,
-0.0215795022,
-0.0290076435,
-0.0736783296,
-0.0422890447,
-0.0327203572,
0.0292044245,
0.0251019523,
0.0249725617,
-0.0294409115,
-0.0284155421,
0.0676170513,
0.0059258938,
-0.0751717985,
0.0556955487,
0.0115672182,
0.0168360677,
0.0838405862,
0.0213591047,
-0.0864691809,
0.0169930849,
-0.0669863075,
0.0095640924,
-0.0225319192,
0.0490348823,
0.0372065902,
-0.0428241119,
-0.017354155,
-0.0018797141,
0.0050172894,
-0.045120623,
0.0144599713,
-0.0032129444,
0.0429827422,
0.018528942,
-0.0168205947,
0.0107777733,
0.0156963617,
-0.0416033641,
0.0165076219,
0.087899141,
-0.0246010106,
-0.0354100578,
0.0213018842,
-0.0274672601,
-0.0286971759,
0.012693896,
0.0037292847,
0.0809039772,
0.0488938317,
-0.0539933406,
0.016274171,
0.0349242017,
0.0163977202,
0.0254834667,
-0.0031472761,
0.0033965264,
-0.007113487,
0.002601587,
-0.0137189431,
-0.0365210883,
-0.0670304969,
0.0257672481,
0.0402973965,
0.0204843078,
0.0239782799,
-0.0492610633,
0.0326489173,
-0.0616465136,
-0.032462135,
-0.0547494367,
-0.0280620232,
-0.0340943336,
0.0392186567,
-0.0264931936,
-0.0334332846,
0.0621363185,
-0.033182174,
-0.0026926748,
-0.097125642,
0.0301567465,
-0.0441166945,
0.0850321427,
-0.0280661359,
0.0001080278,
0.0343854502,
-0.0576708689,
-0.017104065,
0.0075853155,
0.0341265947,
-0.023667179,
0.0530199558,
-0.0630019903,
0.0142334439,
-0.0046347948,
0.019210251,
-0.0317132287,
0.0292534921,
-0.0140137505,
0.0326806046,
0.0075703212,
0.0080851605,
-0.0261833053,
0.0041880817,
0.0728451684,
0.0109515311,
0.0280752368,
-0.0324590392,
-0.0304268505,
-0.0547802486,
-0.0019421777,
0.0520542078,
0.0502936058,
0.0093834819,
0.0052599083,
0.0046671629,
0.0007981205,
0.0271642413,
-0.022338111,
0.0166565906,
0.0076947822,
-0.0534007438,
-0.0068010367,
0.0393533595,
0.0559263825,
-0.043340724,
-0.0287007391,
0.1021147668,
0.0155496355,
0.0141914021,
-0.0140757654,
-0.0274625421,
-0.0486108512,
0.0471162051,
0.0184662417,
-0.0504815504,
0.0016971463,
-0.0334404595,
0.047320772,
-0.0216257926,
-0.0232531372,
-0.0464791246,
-0.0466882735,
0.0245073121,
-0.0083973408,
-0.0672097728,
-0.016270984,
-0.062622577,
0.0156620722,
0.0066761989,
0.0695051104,
0.0022995784,
0.002020464,
0.0047312626,
0.0524803214,
-0.0583204888,
-0.0807346255,
0.0331516601,
-0.0275339894,
0.0714713708,
0.040305879,
0.0147090554,
-0.0334826447,
-0.0319227502,
-0.0487341993,
-0.0250489879,
0.0093433224,
0.0086494479,
0.0076956954,
0.0207494479,
0.0005709257,
-0.0458509177,
-0.0354898348,
-0.0416904353,
0.000580397,
0.0045432886,
0.0561215803,
-0.0398424864,
-0.0361031853,
0.0264280606,
0.0169173647,
-0.0229452848,
0.0743583217,
0.0448563509,
-0.0035168412,
-0.0075277719,
-0.0497952327,
-0.0098038558,
-0.0217237454,
-0.0806050897,
0.0591314994,
0.0051390054,
-0.0071325041,
-0.0317553207,
-0.0917223841,
0.0427831933,
0.03486434,
0.0160481129,
0.0273691695,
0.0235550068,
-0.009295783,
-0.0332086645,
0.0684687495,
0.0023470519,
-0.0107519114,
-0.0183373708,
-0.0014690742,
-0.04592558,
-0.0262647681,
-0.0255828444,
0.0051334994,
0.0454928875,
-0.0243665949,
0.0360440426,
0.0145094879,
0.0314079002,
-0.0312363058,
0.0175640155,
-0.0381326154,
-0.0082024317,
-0.0115892617,
0.0028384288,
-0.0214755498,
0.0291787107,
-0.0051728575,
-0.0002377122,
0.0054284842,
-0.0215609595,
-0.0280991383,
-0.0431568474,
0.0357577801,
0.0421877205,
0.0015377508,
0.0580128729,
0.0418338515,
0.0263763629,
-0.0159253795,
0.0177896339,
-0.0378355458,
-0.0471013561,
0.0231423955,
-0.0196647663,
-0.0142825628,
-0.0440933742,
-0.0007157471,
-0.0131528266,
-0.0099566495,
0.023887096,
-0.1162229106,
0.0101525793,
0.0036937289,
0.0661296621,
0.0484885089,
0.0606906153,
-0.0439722985,
-0.0145680774,
-0.0288389456,
-0.0155895995,
-0.0180754606,
0.0482833274,
0.0316848941,
0.0697342679,
0.0101799229,
0.0103133628,
0.0062776301,
0.0152883697,
-0.0207777079,
-0.0634288564,
0.0264982693,
-0.0185064394,
-0.0278120581,
-0.0069134831,
0.0101707503,
-0.0297990553,
0.0647023842,
-0.0083111329,
-0.0315054208,
-0.0149284191,
-0.0500934273,
0.0314036943,
0.0070671835,
-0.0156823173,
-0.0572161078,
0.0219541136,
-0.02821365,
-0.0073386328,
-0.0375123173,
0.0056093493,
-0.0400041565,
-0.0490367711,
-0.0378480703,
-0.0065525849,
-0.0198612958,
-0.0015770515,
-0.0592971295,
-0.0530974939,
0.0104843015,
0.0267836563,
0.0374539122,
-0.0215042606,
0.0238707624,
0.0541865192,
-0.0044749887,
-0.0496417843,
-0.0093352888,
0.0157076381,
-0.0061595943,
0.0334298685,
-0.0181375612,
-6.426308597e-33,
-0.0022481328,
-0.0270860307,
0.0451825149,
-0.047259979,
0.0096840989,
0.0113216527,
-0.0485330299,
0.0131680286,
-0.0307983849,
-0.0047607291,
0.0152846072,
-0.0224629175,
0.0076765232,
-0.0112762405,
0.0073791831,
-0.038104929,
0.0064907526,
0.0062680538,
-0.0584993325,
-0.0308288019,
0.0371663608,
-0.0436331965,
0.1136290878,
-0.0534733199,
0.1264523715,
0.0028042244,
-0.0075075831,
0.0132193547,
0.0162727144,
0.0095876344,
0.0045034331,
0.0646019429,
0.0632190779,
-0.0953038931,
-0.0095098326,
0.0610527396,
-0.048509866,
-0.0511540286,
0.1026761159,
0.0316071846,
-0.0187345855,
0.0085755531,
0.0681653991,
-0.0191637352,
-0.0254914295,
0.0238917675,
0.0330897421,
-0.0119151166,
0.0432431176,
0.0114722364,
-0.0390014723,
0.0173643529,
-0.0617790408,
0.0159011055,
0.0144092254,
0.037457291,
-0.0405197516,
-0.0583989732,
-0.0728453398,
0.0193212871,
0.0044694855,
-0.0008317356,
0.1116432846,
-0.0062562334,
-0.0266240966,
0.0658672154,
-0.0103727113,
0.0359187275,
-0.0111805396,
-0.049533613,
0.0560777932,
-0.011295354,
0.01123825,
0.028085079,
0.0127334632,
-0.0078008035,
-0.0524160974,
0.0349607058,
0.0008585317,
0.0654643327,
0.0071624485,
-0.0173797365,
-0.0677345842,
-0.0465940014,
-0.0760987774,
-0.0071800686,
-0.0272428859,
-0.0351386629,
0.0583383255,
-0.0551238246,
-0.0238020141,
-0.0309104268,
0.0242640711,
-0.0258626752,
0.0191917326,
-0.0111472448,
0.0133198714,
0.0183008965,
0.034772668,
0.0162491407,
-0.0510268062,
-0.0194701143,
0.0037544819,
0.0295020528,
0.0442903526,
-0.0128902234,
-0.0366024561,
0.0010739219,
-0.0139588322,
-0.0174603984,
-0.0492563546,
0.0085261473,
0.0259224605,
-0.0108980602,
0.055004213,
0.0403258055,
-0.0161131285,
-0.0082504433,
0.0039506117,
-0.038004376,
-0.0299082752,
0.0433217287,
-0.0575679019,
-0.0087840287,
-0.0498041026,
-0.0137659246,
-0.0014846688,
0.0471609049,
0.0155856069,
-0.0256044362,
0.001799591,
0.0248035435,
3.007e-7,
0.0629656464,
0.0639061183,
-0.011936673,
0.0044380459,
-0.012713409,
0.0230656564,
-0.0262051448,
0.0229922645,
0.0157073867,
-0.0469745956,
-0.0017612687,
0.0183820464,
0.0004323809,
0.0247100461,
-0.0270423107,
-0.0582469068,
0.0382482484,
0.0459573604,
-0.0300707277,
0.0665029883,
0.0563132018,
-0.0081341928,
-0.0422886759,
0.0047473819,
-0.0402498953,
-0.0656393245,
-0.0196778271,
-0.039072331,
0.0410632007,
0.0008282556,
0.0403401405,
0.0206389911,
0.0461940356,
0.0548892282,
0.0404353514,
0.0160506945,
-0.0149685545,
0.0376268849,
-0.0049589868,
0.012556727,
-0.0185590293,
-0.0112813348,
0.0338187627,
-0.034172602,
0.0358693786,
-0.0536181964,
-0.0658458397,
-0.0067945584,
-0.0144011304,
-0.0058154622,
-0.0078783864,
0.013231135,
-0.0088426303,
0.0351783559,
0.0041306866,
-0.0314341411,
0.0113579305,
-0.0149875814,
0.0350234658,
-0.0017021374,
-0.0062574707,
-0.0163143966,
-0.0439048596,
-0.0031042234,
0.0255380161,
-0.0511135422,
0.0284837559,
2.247178546e-34,
-0.01571027,
-0.0048092254,
0.0535270981,
-0.0257244539,
0.0391843133,
0.0278960094,
-0.0148094548,
0.028454287,
0.0236007478,
-0.0414352268,
-0.0074099875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15119v1 | Another Dead End for Morphological Tags? Perturbed Inputs and Parsing | 2023-05-24T13:11:04 | 2023-05-24T13:11:04 | Alberto Muñoz-Ortiz, David Vilares | cs.CL | cs.CL | The usefulness of part-of-speech tags for parsing has been heavily questioned
due to the success of word-contextualized parsers. Yet, most studies are
limited to coarse-grained tags and high quality written content; while we know
little about their influence when it comes to models in production that face
lexical errors. We expand these setups and design an adversarial attack to
verify if the use of morphological information by parsers: (i) contributes to
error propagation or (ii) if on the other hand it can play a role to correct
mistakes that word-only neural parsers make. The results on 14 diverse UD
treebanks show that under such attacks, for transition- and graph-based models
their use contributes to degrade the performance even faster, while for the
(lower-performing) sequence labeling parsers they are helpful. We also show
that if morphological tags were utopically robust against lexical
perturbations, they would be able to correct parsing mistakes. | [
0.0388499647,
0.0516781434,
-0.0212823693,
0.0435772575,
-0.0342234112,
-0.0015888804,
0.0081563704,
-0.0141985975,
-0.0417724997,
-0.055863142,
0.004170428,
-0.0264140163,
0.0249343105,
0.0224667341,
0.0534719676,
-0.0379253589,
0.0778416991,
-0.0150081022,
-0.0182941109,
0.0159641374,
0.0229665898,
-0.0120855467,
0.0291487891,
0.0205863286,
-0.0737066194,
-0.0096899979,
-0.0096407318,
0.0100895315,
-0.0236542597,
-0.0342592746,
-0.0000401015,
0.0199849829,
-0.0457619615,
0.0584677905,
0.0000017535,
-0.0196673255,
-0.0224555749,
0.0149410386,
-0.0394324027,
0.0431652367,
0.0655291975,
-0.0216206014,
-0.0559554659,
-0.0236699805,
-0.0157150403,
-0.0277666245,
0.0359157175,
0.0256443359,
0.0464441702,
0.0992041305,
-0.0140071139,
-0.078758426,
0.0443158709,
-0.0375883766,
-0.0378701761,
-0.001707236,
0.0235210136,
-0.0499380492,
-0.0033635341,
-0.0084530814,
-0.0556990318,
0.0070745214,
-0.0127971536,
-0.0132686533,
-0.0272227265,
0.0313946381,
-0.0199697725,
-0.0317550413,
0.0297182351,
0.0342217647,
-0.0455151014,
0.0044195103,
0.0072627994,
-0.0066668037,
0.0165420491,
-0.0183875691,
-0.0178195462,
-0.0028222143,
0.0051644505,
0.0441029072,
0.0464802831,
-0.0376248248,
0.0329870321,
-0.0345494375,
-0.0036096899,
0.0882024765,
0.0187235326,
-0.0485980511,
-0.0289965719,
0.0043174387,
-0.0135037238,
-0.0771332383,
0.0129835736,
-0.0360275544,
0.0280830786,
0.0289006606,
-0.0660911202,
-0.0567468554,
0.0303379204,
-0.0378822908,
0.0262693204,
-0.0306817517,
-0.0434121974,
0.0084861945,
-0.0176915396,
0.0053272373,
0.000071021,
0.0432431586,
-0.0171676818,
0.0239156056,
-0.0150051573,
-0.0216383934,
-0.0112647507,
0.0074057989,
-0.0100428769,
0.0263416674,
-0.0192152485,
-0.0051948223,
0.0268087834,
0.0099239564,
0.0079160547,
0.020075459,
-0.060271427,
0.0170456581,
-0.0129935853,
0.0321891867,
-0.0190415792,
-0.0080865622,
0.0015369228,
-0.0812142417,
-0.0331889018,
0.0310223531,
0.0031182007,
-0.0433012098,
0.0010096311,
0.0974794105,
0.0198743381,
-0.0384433605,
-0.0342516005,
-0.0413875617,
-0.0920219049,
0.0146901999,
0.0148230586,
-0.0217303056,
-0.0124409916,
-0.0105239479,
-0.0233537462,
-0.04370673,
0.0149785597,
0.0146557745,
-0.0459297188,
0.0526905321,
-0.0179694649,
-0.0527300537,
-0.0171154775,
-0.0138656404,
0.0285534188,
0.0166761056,
0.0292751603,
0.0003122135,
0.0405508913,
-0.0040605091,
-0.0301437974,
0.0270665511,
-0.0135031184,
-0.0320666581,
-0.037316367,
-0.0394289717,
0.0068399953,
0.0069707027,
0.0600266047,
0.0783959553,
-0.0119569451,
-0.0661267489,
0.0314829759,
0.0675457045,
-0.0409228206,
0.0320733562,
0.039043121,
-0.0390359536,
-0.0078030298,
0.0702532455,
-0.0169426966,
-0.0659364909,
-0.0303932894,
0.0399367623,
-0.077780582,
0.0081184097,
0.033007361,
-0.0335799903,
-0.0344042443,
-0.0030226691,
0.0150597198,
-0.0588551089,
0.0428967364,
0.0365994312,
-0.0207836125,
0.0041699843,
0.0315194391,
-0.0254985932,
0.0273780152,
-0.0159166977,
-0.0225763824,
0.0109976819,
0.0724021867,
-0.0279793665,
-0.0185142923,
0.0085385228,
-0.0097732702,
0.0275025256,
0.0237012897,
-0.0265825391,
-0.0131550329,
-0.0043512746,
0.0218604691,
-0.0460569113,
0.0383815803,
0.0372250751,
-0.0569112338,
-0.0087693976,
-0.0160229877,
-0.0096595762,
-0.0418921001,
0.0440999418,
0.0464728624,
-0.0240359772,
-0.0302272718,
-0.0029595334,
0.0200424362,
0.0117473667,
-0.0652984604,
0.0369644128,
0.0211817622,
-0.0252441522,
0.0231571458,
0.0221367441,
-0.0255332366,
-0.038671542,
0.0643862113,
0.0082812337,
-0.0572065338,
-0.0303613655,
-0.0201320536,
-0.0386794396,
0.0346702524,
-0.0610245652,
0.06909623,
-0.0126579497,
0.0191853214,
0.0165940411,
0.0374233052,
-0.0432669893,
0.0554900914,
0.0080312807,
0.0402003564,
-0.0175567437,
0.0102956109,
0.0211943612,
-0.0201974344,
-0.0417922474,
0.0485598184,
0.0165730137,
-0.0524484925,
-0.0170548521,
-0.0242730621,
-0.0032522043,
0.0111763608,
-0.0277530346,
-0.0416486189,
-0.0316127613,
0.0760307088,
0.0290684607,
-0.0025639604,
-0.0130526805,
-0.0260561239,
-0.0032398866,
0.036904525,
-0.0040529552,
0.0166727174,
0.0411586687,
0.0221849326,
0.0016414486,
-0.0467140973,
-0.0404053256,
-0.0475262441,
0.0805475563,
0.0210140049,
-0.0800662935,
-0.0248887986,
0.0028739097,
-0.0145491073,
0.0663380846,
0.0069903745,
-0.058839187,
0.0113952365,
0.0013149332,
0.0500083752,
0.0608107895,
-0.0204136521,
0.038999483,
0.0302213188,
-0.0373370051,
0.0164118912,
-0.0210837238,
0.0078146234,
-0.0046477681,
-0.0775714293,
-0.0144486818,
0.0340152942,
0.1178581119,
0.0019729782,
-0.0148885874,
0.037242312,
0.0019336127,
-0.0602330454,
-0.0166682638,
0.0400134102,
-0.0474793017,
-0.0400054902,
0.0386340544,
-0.0287093036,
-0.0282242242,
0.0785531029,
-0.0680482388,
-0.0367715061,
-0.0263798181,
-0.0227961261,
-0.0014921626,
0.0511372164,
0.0702940822,
0.0085839331,
0.0763108209,
-0.0840566754,
-0.0260661133,
0.0265401546,
0.0451616384,
0.0037423628,
-0.0096249962,
-0.040499527,
0.0022517217,
-0.0251779668,
-0.0384246856,
0.0073425309,
-0.013434506,
-0.0008361875,
0.0329728872,
0.0477489084,
-0.0254914947,
0.0180131774,
0.0175705068,
-0.0332705043,
0.0157697089,
-0.0154430903,
0.0295333862,
-0.0256422963,
0.0848444998,
0.0049266336,
-0.0324214399,
0.0093744891,
0.014235951,
-0.0118113421,
0.0355181023,
-0.0501444787,
0.0093655866,
-0.023775734,
0.0132426061,
0.0072755488,
-0.036139518,
-0.0620385818,
-0.0309958439,
0.0182270948,
-0.0810584798,
-0.065621458,
0.0596842282,
0.0328877456,
0.0075519681,
0.0284694918,
0.0169189628,
0.0150363585,
-0.0002654596,
0.0175676476,
-0.0432897955,
-0.0303992182,
0.0356412902,
0.0486653969,
-0.0021037729,
-0.0345443785,
0.0376088247,
-0.1121307984,
0.0229500867,
0.0148983477,
-0.0212821569,
0.0060787038,
-0.0073745768,
-0.0088582775,
-0.0094838897,
0.0378311761,
-0.0043802168,
0.0016679879,
0.0336941592,
0.049811203,
-0.0206145681,
-0.0741775408,
-0.0344342291,
-0.0308168903,
0.0112610748,
0.1253771037,
0.0117825801,
-0.0531137474,
-0.0219669864,
0.1027849093,
-0.0057990979,
-0.0019468358,
0.0057585319,
0.0209381152,
0.0014531148,
-0.0335927755,
0.0099291783,
-0.0046456866,
0.0044445274,
-0.0098508568,
-0.0692010522,
0.0464281328,
0.0097944541,
-0.0136585282,
0.0004151325,
-0.0228308793,
-0.0409063324,
0.0200820342,
0.0413421988,
-0.0131517481,
-0.0938059241,
-0.0833675787,
0.0030125401,
-0.0144893294,
-0.0315002576,
0.0330444947,
-0.0067873294,
-0.0513254367,
-0.1057577729,
-0.0814264417,
0.0194729045,
0.0060216286,
0.0001202418,
-0.025165135,
0.0052086748,
-0.0238815509,
-0.0319064111,
0.0126268733,
0.0402317494,
0.0284111686,
-0.0444787219,
-0.007195076,
0.0608428866,
0.0840977058,
-0.0215217117,
0.0081799552,
-0.0199659448,
-0.0784811974,
0.0438129976,
0.0292647425,
0.0156609155,
0.0119547751,
-0.0448138043,
-0.0682561174,
-0.0148055572,
0.0603622347,
0.0212838873,
0.0258590262,
0.0434231609,
-0.024599677,
0.0010286124,
0.0157572012,
0.0082210638,
0.0018949175,
0.0230926052,
0.0403108746,
-0.0284127444,
0.0019851369,
0.032905668,
0.0059474148,
0.0660784692,
0.0038801208,
0.0491254702,
-0.017594859,
-0.00177602,
-0.024245793,
-0.0157718025,
-0.0039958106,
-0.0234666709,
0.005292566,
0.0101697734,
-0.0116864247,
0.0251607597,
-0.0301061478,
0.0545990393,
-0.0062728534,
0.0183933452,
0.0550277233,
-0.0011309796,
-0.0091079567,
0.0297617279,
0.0106512625,
0.0038316608,
-0.0010931421,
0.0236481857,
-0.027093228,
0.0020096409,
0.0018400641,
0.0099144839,
-0.0037299604,
0.0122694531,
-0.0543568432,
0.0468528159,
-0.0404044464,
-0.0167930536,
0.0260441173,
-0.0336708724,
0.0213066582,
-0.0350112244,
-0.0055420054,
-0.0227206592,
-0.0101486677,
-0.0187676325,
-0.0347714983,
0.051788941,
0.0046568094,
-0.033710964,
-0.0225183535,
0.0704247206,
0.0648566782,
0.040840771,
-0.0039628707,
-0.0397587642,
0.0060303914,
-0.0575289875,
-0.0039744172,
-0.0037993926,
-0.0184340049,
-0.0242214464,
-0.059159372,
-0.0860705003,
-0.0357995331,
0.0482205935,
0.0650278777,
0.0211412981,
0.0246472992,
0.0055746757,
0.0226794146,
0.0046684057,
-0.0210151412,
0.0420560651,
0.0322590433,
-0.0303235222,
-0.0192852505,
-5.445285828e-33,
-0.0362425968,
-0.014785938,
-0.050790146,
-0.0085026249,
0.0028370209,
-0.0107460022,
-0.0380718522,
0.0261652432,
0.0199817028,
0.0167556815,
-0.006539999,
0.0225442518,
-0.0018502777,
0.0120468857,
0.0204527751,
-0.0312811136,
0.0503768437,
-0.0203564856,
0.0126932897,
-0.0223918557,
0.0341451764,
0.0564867519,
0.0816509202,
-0.0090524238,
0.0493690595,
0.0245956089,
-0.0029319832,
-0.0200937502,
0.0105392942,
0.0331128314,
0.0025998522,
-0.0056655612,
0.000935421,
-0.0026899022,
-0.0499959588,
0.0044121672,
-0.0879104435,
0.006481254,
-0.0002518221,
0.0432244986,
-0.0255787037,
-0.0058043418,
0.0460985713,
-0.0189215951,
0.0204555094,
0.0380756445,
0.0050138305,
-0.0058571594,
-0.0283149127,
-0.0090950737,
-0.0375460796,
0.0428719781,
0.0058439863,
0.0678291619,
0.0182763971,
-0.0329670534,
0.0427015275,
-0.0022275762,
-0.0145341093,
-0.0273049958,
0.0056807958,
0.055636894,
0.0387198664,
-0.0118931439,
-0.0010701072,
0.0526606441,
0.0568900555,
0.0004439307,
0.046519693,
0.0357675999,
0.01080391,
0.0210617799,
0.0542505533,
0.0015417425,
0.0657854378,
-0.0016560929,
-0.0424768887,
-0.0021139013,
-0.002223334,
0.0610306635,
-0.0434043668,
0.0283847693,
-0.0326431729,
-0.019153554,
0.030182125,
-0.0928437263,
-0.0087198308,
-0.0190000609,
0.0035737909,
-0.0340774395,
-0.0022878523,
0.0596416183,
0.0028461441,
-0.0111658704,
-0.0215721708,
-0.0422484502,
0.0056955726,
0.0457788408,
-0.0218869392,
0.0256608427,
0.0078900196,
-0.0216184203,
0.0072354134,
-0.0020556482,
0.0581304953,
-0.0013574926,
0.0494198427,
0.0175253414,
-0.0499527082,
0.0068568191,
-0.0126168942,
0.0132900523,
0.0053841891,
0.0484789014,
0.0827513784,
-0.0130892461,
-0.0019024187,
-0.0025742797,
0.060598217,
0.0379240289,
-0.0265293904,
0.0234324187,
-0.0072261416,
-0.0049676918,
-0.0168908555,
-0.0238238424,
0.0108998548,
0.0802892521,
0.0407292172,
-0.0440579019,
0.0072691948,
0.0136195794,
2.602e-7,
0.0671606287,
0.0468489006,
0.0663289353,
-0.0127465753,
0.0678027868,
0.0150255505,
-0.04005735,
0.0419479311,
-0.0407567509,
-0.0358580574,
-0.0120588886,
-0.0690193921,
0.0150241274,
0.0575603656,
-0.0775792897,
-0.0032266174,
-0.0427561365,
0.0036162513,
-0.0516478494,
-0.0067890109,
0.0285694785,
0.0878682882,
-0.0132303312,
-0.0051432955,
0.0177654345,
-0.0535770021,
0.0209543388,
0.0230939947,
0.0258992836,
-0.0210891012,
0.0650357753,
0.0072181229,
-0.0037507352,
0.0170125701,
-0.0425611138,
-0.0037835741,
0.0046614823,
0.0038856464,
-0.0141587909,
-0.0159121323,
-0.0028840981,
-0.0395378359,
-0.0067787622,
-0.005096491,
0.0498975068,
-0.0134174861,
-0.0246699229,
-0.0223691966,
-0.0147337681,
0.0230591483,
-0.0023079002,
-0.0122888424,
-0.0251499731,
0.019760929,
0.034275692,
-0.0022330917,
-0.0193189848,
-0.0427002236,
0.0227139257,
0.0523204394,
-0.0268689636,
-0.0452371761,
-0.0058491947,
0.0749141872,
0.0105102276,
-0.0118760383,
-0.0495983325,
2.588264532e-34,
0.0143364677,
-0.0042241719,
0.0129324505,
0.0170090832,
-0.00059765,
-0.0070372494,
0.0199603681,
0.0277840476,
-0.0186773017,
-0.0646211058,
-0.0552516095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15108v1 | The Role of Output Vocabulary in T2T LMs for SPARQL Semantic Parsing | 2023-05-24T12:55:04 | 2023-05-24T12:55:04 | Debayan Banerjee, Pranav Ajit Nair, Ricardo Usbeck, Chris Biemann | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we analyse the role of output vocabulary for text-to-text (T2T)
models on the task of SPARQL semantic parsing. We perform experiments within
the the context of knowledge graph question answering (KGQA), where the task is
to convert questions in natural language to the SPARQL query language. We
observe that the query vocabulary is distinct from human vocabulary. Language
Models (LMs) are pre-dominantly trained for human language tasks, and hence, if
the query vocabulary is replaced with a vocabulary more attuned to the LM
tokenizer, the performance of models may improve. We carry out carefully
selected vocabulary substitutions on the queries and find absolute gains in the
range of 17% on the GrailQA dataset. | [
0.069339186,
0.0232462529,
0.0214161295,
0.0362884589,
-0.0223234724,
0.0221716594,
-0.0401240624,
-0.0083322711,
-0.0486937463,
-0.0792012438,
-0.0188789517,
0.0162494667,
-0.047446169,
0.0421776138,
0.0286034718,
-0.0204129033,
0.0279979389,
-0.0155778751,
-0.0347751901,
0.0344527736,
0.0132865831,
0.0689078122,
0.0263876095,
-0.0062088706,
-0.0283287931,
0.0172596406,
0.0089573404,
0.0152799049,
-0.0539973117,
0.0124851707,
0.0044760341,
0.0337516665,
0.0086931428,
0.0072686127,
0.0000014942,
-0.0553050041,
-0.0124692675,
0.0251560435,
-0.0102915149,
0.0000243421,
0.0306097697,
-0.0172043536,
0.0628804266,
0.0386363007,
-0.0397083759,
-0.0363851786,
0.0147585934,
0.0658177063,
0.0494111255,
0.0498258136,
0.0031386551,
-0.0210397951,
0.0472736359,
-0.0265629031,
0.0384263694,
-0.0330737345,
0.0093502002,
-0.01532757,
0.0093948804,
0.0192720369,
-0.0194167551,
0.0092515778,
0.0074925213,
-0.0011298266,
0.0501155443,
0.0107673034,
-0.0160064679,
0.0222967975,
0.022371592,
0.0454272665,
0.0081610763,
-0.0290147197,
0.009706975,
0.0315919183,
0.0027458253,
0.0372212492,
-0.0241504274,
-0.0094278771,
-0.0095216427,
0.0193300657,
-0.0050882464,
-0.0733474717,
0.0252548493,
0.0107133547,
-0.0513359047,
0.1123102009,
0.0112464149,
-0.0123029696,
0.0307927877,
0.0170214102,
-0.039881032,
-0.0322117098,
0.0264829304,
0.0374744199,
-0.0369229279,
0.0324342437,
-0.0372663103,
-0.0012467032,
0.0025364528,
-0.0346020348,
-0.0000978159,
0.0517091453,
0.0244015548,
0.0166851114,
-0.0332898349,
0.0229957774,
-0.0021282756,
0.0848025084,
-0.0986176878,
-0.0588087291,
-0.0758087188,
-0.0348807946,
-0.0888619721,
0.0458264612,
-0.0226062629,
-0.0281196665,
0.0052374266,
0.0354031809,
0.0286619421,
-0.0160988104,
0.0413275138,
0.0331167877,
-0.0413197912,
0.0241944585,
-0.05543622,
0.0343586355,
0.008812055,
0.0161077566,
0.0113089746,
-0.044482477,
0.0012146458,
-0.0200212505,
0.0103020128,
-0.058882758,
-0.0116747431,
0.0423708037,
-0.0133152427,
-0.0065595387,
-0.0451224744,
-0.0439054258,
0.029286569,
-0.0016612421,
0.017066272,
-0.0570170805,
0.0349550955,
0.0214269832,
0.0002694342,
-0.0405636206,
0.0135863256,
0.0282242764,
-0.0780334175,
0.0761777833,
-0.0344690457,
0.0097099245,
0.0456000939,
-0.0193901919,
-0.0180482361,
0.0638824925,
0.0220546369,
-0.0035368653,
0.0368777439,
-0.019913001,
-0.053355936,
0.0274835639,
0.0387902968,
-0.0063371952,
-0.0463789776,
0.0549359135,
0.004033688,
0.0256841779,
0.0622088984,
0.0641668811,
-0.0196483396,
-0.0198967978,
-0.001345621,
0.0425040871,
-0.0042150584,
-0.0267440826,
0.0359424278,
-0.0023883141,
-0.0240657795,
0.0114067802,
-0.0822931081,
-0.0029150408,
0.0348609425,
0.0270000119,
0.0106717665,
-0.0373946317,
-0.0527633242,
-0.0130863097,
-0.0229336284,
0.0125117796,
0.0299460329,
-0.0000120578,
0.0283301622,
0.0384496227,
-0.0148975728,
0.1131006405,
0.0165192485,
-0.0028369152,
0.0692452863,
-0.0463516004,
0.0190542601,
0.0399792157,
0.013915767,
0.0094723729,
-0.0150182722,
-0.0071840626,
-0.0112019563,
0.021996282,
0.0354369506,
-0.021638548,
-0.0061770324,
-0.007585187,
-0.0391370952,
-0.0335736386,
0.0121640004,
-0.0310320072,
0.0179588646,
0.0091071436,
0.043278154,
-0.0913501903,
-0.0098473653,
0.0421846509,
-0.0211116653,
-0.0065077771,
-0.0125659024,
-0.0266393535,
0.0000113313,
0.0135038467,
-0.0104625197,
0.0492642894,
0.0191374142,
-0.015936099,
-0.0562221333,
-0.0027917945,
0.0083032139,
-0.045817852,
0.0441325977,
-0.016841067,
0.000807589,
0.0571041107,
-0.08459308,
-0.0351502933,
-0.0164057594,
-0.0512254275,
0.0487697572,
-0.0224144906,
-0.0215808153,
0.0380755365,
-0.0390135944,
-0.0429270454,
0.0040551014,
-0.03576627,
0.0319277272,
-0.0648858547,
0.0199663658,
0.0068934662,
-0.040260233,
0.0176455509,
-0.0063299541,
0.0039570341,
0.0000272797,
-0.0073863198,
0.0128180943,
-0.0749062002,
0.0173494592,
-0.1018010974,
0.0004169057,
-0.0173380394,
0.0347598158,
0.0366852023,
0.0038223453,
0.0365749113,
-0.017217543,
-0.0763527378,
0.0008863832,
0.0303113684,
0.0505251661,
0.0384714045,
0.028734101,
0.0063088359,
-0.0266782101,
-0.0462059118,
-0.0050704498,
0.0411866121,
-0.0005204355,
-0.001558379,
-0.0032973478,
0.0536591001,
-0.0348353311,
0.0179186035,
0.0009203472,
-0.0003732758,
-0.0159080457,
-0.0421173088,
-0.0052382564,
0.03177974,
0.0198083743,
-0.0058837566,
-0.0013845057,
0.0321116038,
-0.0477984808,
-0.0030097913,
-0.0137521084,
-0.0217791703,
-0.0453486703,
-0.0474850275,
0.0684545115,
0.0307677574,
0.0095612658,
0.0107200965,
-0.0306971502,
0.0049929568,
-0.0173572302,
-0.0167513862,
-0.0426233262,
0.0085443705,
0.0158283617,
0.024329355,
-0.0367199667,
0.0012083396,
0.0496371277,
-0.0181309804,
0.0097531704,
-0.0236949399,
0.001579844,
-0.0637478456,
0.0261701178,
0.0344478786,
0.0204962939,
-0.0710991323,
-0.0659506842,
-0.0284130927,
-0.0598824918,
0.0100232242,
-0.0193309505,
0.0277355444,
-0.0119051542,
0.0111739142,
-0.0057301605,
0.0007482984,
-0.0141790062,
0.0079204449,
-0.044162821,
0.0542283505,
0.0398453511,
0.0232034475,
0.0267996918,
0.0165747236,
-0.03073157,
-0.0061422819,
-0.0082940403,
-0.0266794581,
-0.0116815381,
0.0536883995,
0.0983846933,
0.0310469773,
-0.0560365841,
-0.0102448994,
-0.0272283908,
0.0499017648,
0.0452419706,
-0.0423626229,
-0.0073259971,
0.0243670102,
0.0266585387,
-0.0505937859,
-0.0135223307,
-0.0397006795,
-0.0038926548,
-0.0139904944,
-0.0212446246,
0.0987821519,
0.0350702107,
0.05047746,
0.0018565393,
-0.0136734145,
0.0290987398,
0.0250518899,
0.0106209936,
-0.075163886,
-0.0394109301,
-0.0138767213,
0.0517817438,
0.0448145866,
-0.0301470049,
0.0077521838,
-0.1265045106,
-0.0014662739,
-0.0303292386,
-0.0775172114,
-0.0335598662,
-0.0403139703,
-0.0214634556,
-0.0670166388,
0.0140093248,
0.0333950147,
-0.0441266447,
0.0454993844,
0.0510959253,
0.0248678513,
0.0168066956,
0.0030087687,
-0.0633665547,
0.0050755232,
0.0317519382,
-0.0066521186,
-0.0358255059,
0.0096902745,
0.0305877309,
0.0066184057,
0.0146528091,
-0.0316377059,
0.0586560443,
-0.0260667372,
0.0070703002,
0.0130202789,
-0.0060436809,
-0.0447430313,
0.0352149978,
-0.0117146987,
0.0549889319,
-0.0002518287,
-0.0046571246,
-0.0011841984,
-0.0289476085,
-0.0461547263,
0.0790641531,
0.0207283124,
0.0117719788,
-0.0868633389,
-0.0346850976,
-0.041088596,
-0.0448008217,
-0.0100684427,
0.0267289672,
-0.0231889375,
-0.0121719129,
-0.0399909504,
-0.0635017008,
0.0588174798,
0.0155706415,
-0.0269334409,
0.0342758223,
-0.0286448654,
0.0171353165,
-0.0301953088,
0.0455258749,
-0.0251086298,
0.0174588859,
-0.0424635522,
0.0006422643,
0.0162851661,
-0.010297983,
-0.0386110917,
-0.0186552387,
-0.0613899566,
-0.0339442343,
-0.0225418694,
0.0163621102,
0.0198051352,
0.0300700404,
-0.0152917923,
-0.0271696225,
0.0422900692,
0.0388321057,
-0.0707891136,
0.0178786311,
0.0096641704,
0.0208610352,
0.0019428928,
0.050670173,
-0.0779038146,
-0.03347544,
-0.0064344103,
0.0750400573,
-0.0126578705,
-0.0466272533,
0.0524541587,
0.05833048,
0.0196088515,
0.0433009341,
0.0407355763,
-0.0208035205,
0.0071534817,
-0.0192202665,
-0.0141468728,
-0.0584220402,
0.0041830591,
0.0431604125,
-0.000200832,
-0.0121964822,
-0.0233100969,
-0.0212332215,
0.0914930999,
-0.0211039204,
-0.0664654449,
0.0347033069,
-0.0101322802,
0.0360465273,
0.0055569806,
-0.0501039401,
-0.0128123974,
0.0068281391,
0.0013168962,
-0.0254374072,
0.0023419396,
0.0294322111,
0.0091926502,
-0.0188488681,
0.0026641462,
-0.0569483675,
-0.0918252617,
-0.023826411,
-0.0190727971,
0.0192960575,
-0.0123948436,
0.0429635495,
-0.0188565813,
-0.0108933588,
-0.0290289801,
0.0043072277,
0.014199567,
0.0057846284,
0.0807805285,
0.0027221607,
-0.0134228524,
-0.0429631881,
0.0575942509,
0.0653207749,
0.0454382971,
0.0052689961,
-0.0541681796,
-0.0048370026,
-0.0228168759,
0.0324904136,
0.0048603374,
-0.0180273429,
-0.0018476435,
-0.0047305059,
-0.0832870379,
0.0001256398,
-0.013286571,
-0.0067173783,
-0.0103175147,
0.070606716,
0.0708620995,
0.0523349978,
-0.0250418391,
-0.0292361826,
0.0341187194,
-0.0094854441,
-0.0536934622,
-0.0439459383,
-5.85871013e-33,
-0.0469767079,
-0.0221696291,
0.0313298255,
0.0187350083,
-0.0377118066,
-0.0517487265,
-0.0097212782,
-0.0252462458,
-0.0280291345,
0.0219793599,
-0.0123184538,
0.0249354485,
-0.0018645076,
0.0350725241,
0.0057312506,
-0.0433290228,
0.0414776355,
-0.0429534689,
0.0164670665,
-0.0016443087,
0.0657078028,
0.0626921877,
0.010785575,
0.0045343367,
-0.0024716973,
-0.0207426678,
0.0105789946,
0.0632878244,
0.0078078667,
0.0556621142,
0.0082566058,
0.0373846553,
0.0453525335,
-0.0260406248,
-0.0106547279,
-0.0179563612,
-0.1270866096,
-0.0235126056,
0.0397031941,
0.0227020159,
-0.0468053184,
-0.0146893784,
0.0533795618,
-0.0187794492,
0.0394012183,
-0.0325216278,
0.0313074812,
0.0121915704,
-0.0299395192,
-0.0409883223,
-0.0294533893,
0.0038666108,
-0.0012498234,
-0.0089855939,
-0.0011074969,
0.0045848116,
-0.0250977892,
0.0053597861,
-0.0190986469,
-0.0240889601,
-0.0108122639,
0.0531202704,
0.0291874334,
0.0259278696,
-0.0169923436,
-0.0141090145,
-0.0266586635,
-0.0351613015,
0.0207257066,
0.0373776518,
0.0002905025,
0.0533815362,
0.0140165901,
-0.0104359845,
0.0505543798,
-0.0092335828,
-0.0461440869,
0.0161974225,
-0.0498710983,
0.0648771524,
-0.0325544477,
0.0129419398,
-0.0130879171,
-0.0367238149,
-0.0552497692,
0.0382137634,
-0.0508870967,
-0.0288330615,
0.0445687063,
-0.0167279709,
0.0184517298,
-0.0299513228,
0.025770355,
-0.0232501775,
0.0072281361,
0.0635789409,
-0.0011558513,
-0.0136187524,
-0.0218243115,
0.0365898907,
-0.0446004756,
-0.0363740101,
0.0181761272,
-0.0191383194,
-0.0293479171,
0.0185515899,
0.0062813237,
-0.0000594669,
-0.0324569494,
0.0054715676,
-0.0418407731,
0.0130684953,
-0.0383779183,
0.0394296646,
0.0099227037,
0.0139355799,
-0.0116499737,
0.0276833978,
-0.0117667075,
-0.0349628888,
-0.0343729593,
-0.0006036249,
0.0298972894,
-0.0071838493,
-0.0100739449,
0.0095992498,
-0.005233943,
0.0286450833,
0.0086475713,
-0.0307027865,
-0.0012648788,
0.0221531205,
2.335e-7,
0.0791487619,
-0.0018437573,
0.024564676,
0.0634823516,
0.0085619446,
0.0099754278,
0.0051576146,
0.0899568796,
0.0337747335,
0.0067029945,
-0.0262258686,
0.0177829545,
0.0207182299,
0.0535755083,
-0.0418500751,
-0.001878303,
-0.0658630133,
-0.0298936255,
-0.0222430173,
-0.0059455363,
0.060040988,
0.0760447159,
0.0034501306,
-0.0047279727,
-0.0414091796,
-0.1003541872,
0.0410603434,
-0.0190222766,
-0.0045111342,
0.0280424152,
0.045166295,
-0.0054692668,
0.0295762215,
0.0303464495,
-0.013584177,
0.0196061172,
0.0423268601,
0.0618075877,
-0.0216665622,
-0.0202819556,
-0.0143886544,
-0.0626245141,
0.0374288112,
-0.0562101081,
0.0701519102,
-0.0390455723,
0.0183165055,
0.0589561723,
-0.0190449338,
-0.0060302676,
-0.0082171243,
-0.0257552676,
-0.0033558358,
-0.0048186253,
0.061804615,
0.0228575338,
-0.012969966,
-0.0404105,
0.014724914,
0.0086713145,
-0.0294010732,
-0.0545252189,
-0.0092410697,
0.0476309657,
0.0016130328,
0.0074754963,
-0.0220511798,
1.800256741e-34,
0.0473845117,
0.0312592909,
0.0217843987,
0.0302259587,
0.0577481836,
0.0123440744,
0.0202495474,
0.0155256931,
0.0144887818,
-0.1202604547,
0.0114204763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15099v1 | Fourier Transformer: Fast Long Range Modeling by Removing Sequence Redundancy with FFT Operator | 2023-05-24T12:33:06 | 2023-05-24T12:33:06 | Ziwei He, Meng Yang, Minwei Feng, Jingcheng Yin, Xinbing Wang, Jingwen Leng, Zhouhan Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The transformer model is known to be computationally demanding, and
prohibitively costly for long sequences, as the self-attention module uses a
quadratic time and space complexity with respect to sequence length. Many
researchers have focused on designing new forms of self-attention or
introducing new parameters to overcome this limitation, however a large portion
of them prohibits the model to inherit weights from large pretrained models. In
this work, the transformer's inefficiency has been taken care of from another
perspective. We propose Fourier Transformer, a simple yet effective approach by
progressively removing redundancies in hidden sequence using the ready-made
Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) operator to perform Discrete Cosine Transformation
(DCT). Fourier Transformer is able to significantly reduce computational costs
while retain the ability to inherit from various large pretrained models.
Experiments show that our model achieves state-of-the-art performances among
all transformer-based models on the long-range modeling benchmark LRA with
significant improvement in both speed and space. For generative seq-to-seq
tasks including CNN/DailyMail and ELI5, by inheriting the BART weights our
model outperforms the standard BART and other efficient models. \footnote{Our
code is publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/LUMIA-Group/FourierTransformer}} | [
-0.0110819507,
0.0955072939,
-0.0063463422,
0.0385009907,
-0.0280885566,
-0.001241932,
0.0861577019,
-0.0131625077,
-0.0179154184,
-0.0051970226,
-0.0123940986,
-0.0480216593,
0.0028391471,
0.0430442952,
0.021708779,
-0.0342375375,
0.0225727689,
-0.0246431716,
-0.0751648769,
-0.0017329011,
-0.0346251763,
-0.0342006236,
0.0330952145,
0.0226111244,
-0.0080614025,
-0.0116303293,
-0.0482789502,
-0.0124079054,
0.0275659822,
-0.0136843501,
0.0274213031,
0.1011291519,
0.029695496,
0.0326607972,
0.0000022523,
0.009691976,
-0.0251905899,
0.0001363947,
-0.0144612323,
0.0142090116,
-0.0083017377,
-0.020868849,
-0.0176443197,
0.0130079119,
-0.0175514519,
0.0110476865,
0.0370124355,
0.050125815,
0.0324499495,
0.0839099959,
0.0038674294,
-0.0746935233,
0.0256452747,
-0.0835738406,
0.0454020686,
-0.0525510237,
0.0045334846,
-0.0384404548,
-0.0141210472,
0.0347404294,
-0.0351741426,
0.0752304867,
0.0661128983,
0.0143286549,
0.0180682205,
0.0185933318,
-0.0103018563,
-0.039633017,
0.0030976126,
0.0420425609,
-0.0714709684,
-0.0403206833,
0.0271461066,
0.0237734765,
-0.0033956396,
-0.040362753,
-0.0519080162,
0.0205774605,
0.0232518017,
-0.0010747302,
-0.0111560691,
0.0177301075,
0.0069385152,
-0.0140954219,
-0.0214190371,
-0.0214954223,
0.0037988566,
0.0052298703,
-0.0486822575,
-0.020142775,
-0.0274706688,
-0.0417155474,
0.0303952787,
0.0395551883,
0.0139424615,
-0.0262407027,
-0.0780443922,
-0.0550737977,
0.0069979886,
-0.0222641248,
0.0440358222,
0.0225466769,
-0.038911622,
0.0201614909,
-0.0398515947,
0.0382998548,
-0.0543149412,
-0.0375607051,
-0.007600008,
0.0226320606,
-0.0246591214,
0.0039165188,
-0.0310393702,
0.0190410521,
-0.025958715,
-0.0419828519,
-0.0449691452,
-0.0033688769,
0.0027490952,
-0.0224612877,
0.0331587829,
0.0317388549,
-0.0723114535,
0.0251229275,
0.0432148017,
0.0370881446,
0.0001362387,
0.0012009082,
0.0330593362,
-0.0530167595,
-0.0438254625,
0.0180060379,
0.0056260796,
-0.0314077735,
0.0009768804,
0.048763942,
-0.0035019685,
-0.0696980283,
-0.0104546947,
-0.0126113612,
-0.0507018268,
-0.058605928,
0.0212073773,
-0.0731845871,
0.0171292201,
-0.0077140853,
-0.0045590512,
0.012657485,
0.0047685518,
0.0413651802,
-0.0071669216,
0.0517112017,
0.048344668,
-0.0249385256,
0.0484274849,
0.0308378097,
0.0223076213,
0.0524974354,
0.0045894971,
0.0485495403,
-0.0100083314,
-0.0496180803,
-0.0135953147,
0.0133940252,
0.0409868695,
-0.0148259243,
-0.0292025246,
-0.0005477657,
-0.0287490636,
0.0150388088,
0.0607149117,
0.0203399155,
-0.0117811663,
-0.0556046739,
0.0436679348,
0.0237884894,
0.0806213692,
0.0780132413,
0.0326912776,
0.0049819648,
-0.0059097693,
0.0001285111,
-0.0555438921,
0.1147509217,
-0.0246911682,
0.0033460318,
0.0171994567,
0.0546104684,
-0.0314942785,
0.0014078766,
0.0304732975,
-0.0386131592,
-0.0140902456,
0.0075150551,
0.0268228576,
-0.0162097942,
-0.0493050106,
0.0357370265,
-0.0105698332,
-0.0643150136,
-0.0390365645,
-0.0378806479,
0.0068733981,
0.0255830083,
0.0019733468,
-0.0047300756,
-0.0239626076,
-0.0287490971,
0.0117841596,
0.0340206176,
-0.0093323188,
0.0442557074,
-0.0070383796,
-0.0310449079,
-0.0631415844,
-0.0033591799,
-0.0298054852,
0.0145270703,
0.013839459,
0.0465866365,
0.049563475,
0.0004908848,
-0.0121415192,
0.0083401501,
-0.0278754309,
-0.0385626629,
0.0077658733,
0.0202756636,
0.0404658876,
0.0277492665,
0.0102399914,
0.0155981397,
0.0388093852,
-0.0541418605,
-0.0316477567,
-0.0533776022,
-0.0777211785,
-0.0458254367,
0.0163573548,
-0.0427674837,
0.0029167766,
0.084942773,
-0.0230615828,
-0.0544958524,
0.0440866575,
-0.0409158394,
-0.0204518419,
-0.0199910179,
0.0182198305,
0.0487308763,
0.0575701296,
-0.0143084927,
0.0179292392,
-0.0125094801,
-0.0093804877,
-0.0312063769,
0.0080093713,
-0.0180250891,
-0.0598969087,
0.0201208182,
-0.0251658186,
-0.0118412152,
-0.0176205542,
0.0194826163,
-0.0099360878,
-0.0008491325,
-0.0451475941,
-0.042181991,
0.0068043489,
-0.0314939655,
0.0113660982,
-0.0110278996,
0.0174289588,
0.0238902271,
0.0034774807,
-0.0541530736,
0.0198970977,
-0.0182357114,
-0.0104125068,
0.0132938782,
-0.0338662416,
-0.0531772822,
-0.0359164886,
-0.0386151969,
0.0208804328,
0.0555953123,
-0.0283955876,
-0.0493142605,
0.0032855712,
-0.0245277211,
0.0032724347,
0.0422290154,
-0.0031820619,
-0.0245329477,
-0.0170986596,
-0.0262258109,
0.0111264316,
0.0542347133,
0.0783726573,
-0.0054689539,
-0.0346743688,
0.0016614492,
0.0015882,
0.0321559533,
-0.048475232,
0.0285105221,
-0.0377625749,
0.0123351058,
-0.0057939636,
0.0687040612,
-0.0160874501,
0.0112510566,
-0.0594558902,
0.0043355767,
0.0425100215,
-0.0095881252,
0.0157830864,
0.0087809134,
-0.0187823325,
-0.0095544625,
0.0035521335,
-0.0280889291,
0.0199598316,
-0.0292239152,
-0.0079034129,
-0.0217122138,
0.0066688373,
-0.0279523414,
0.0378565527,
0.0253955275,
0.0237563904,
0.0245215949,
-0.0069608302,
-0.0280540138,
0.0143081108,
0.0195856988,
-0.039094083,
0.0401378125,
0.0225106385,
0.0340046175,
-0.0152998185,
-0.0318439305,
-0.0467327535,
0.0137330163,
-0.0029951525,
0.0209955052,
0.0024708544,
-0.0204404332,
-0.0712127611,
0.0202957187,
0.031913083,
0.0744307935,
-0.0086965645,
-0.0032801495,
0.002496083,
0.0517206863,
0.0597575344,
0.0077630635,
0.0224720277,
-0.0152203003,
0.0337212831,
0.0430372208,
0.0094344458,
0.0084465686,
-0.0278322343,
-0.0059631318,
0.0068215067,
-0.0428547375,
-0.0082504274,
0.0099759959,
0.0266277436,
-0.0469771512,
-0.0057988381,
0.0979399234,
-0.0143040614,
-0.0424214713,
0.0414966568,
0.0309951957,
0.0052133505,
0.0089704469,
0.0126862684,
-0.0788101554,
-0.0473234057,
0.0153119238,
0.0113576474,
0.0179906189,
-0.0041903057,
0.0159544796,
-0.0575898699,
0.0217777658,
0.0095503889,
0.0003514533,
-0.0528497212,
-0.0442142971,
-0.0163414776,
-0.0282298196,
-0.0040670102,
0.0161298458,
-0.0177464522,
0.010488499,
0.025362011,
-0.0146819791,
-0.0062084971,
0.002263054,
0.0066472804,
0.001015582,
0.0753392726,
-0.0224049445,
0.0077582165,
-0.0448957309,
0.014098499,
-0.0144576691,
0.0160533916,
0.0052979081,
0.0767998695,
-0.017450247,
-0.0193987507,
-0.0079285456,
0.0700736493,
-0.0530388802,
-0.0116833672,
0.0118283983,
0.0458917245,
0.017017046,
-0.0474115238,
-0.0140779885,
-0.005586762,
0.0075095524,
0.0675042793,
0.0467223674,
-0.0118314251,
-0.0318664275,
0.0059251389,
-0.0042447643,
-0.0279517192,
-0.0749083757,
-0.0009758504,
0.0597163141,
-0.0764446259,
-0.0488973185,
-0.012540794,
-0.0172701757,
0.0637344196,
-0.0314489901,
-0.0145271812,
0.0144650163,
-0.0236794986,
-0.0625439957,
0.0101506785,
-0.0042313216,
-0.0131244222,
-0.0641821995,
0.0192515925,
0.0258163027,
-0.0267406981,
-0.0061288597,
0.0222814269,
-0.1646311134,
-0.0448237993,
0.0277254451,
0.0493770428,
0.0133548416,
0.0110353446,
0.020043727,
-0.0107811429,
0.0598181561,
0.0542796217,
-0.0492658578,
0.051775109,
0.0467690043,
-0.0656243041,
-0.0014876194,
0.0381618775,
-0.0034299942,
0.0816390663,
0.0200493727,
0.057399787,
-0.0142009798,
-0.0359159075,
0.0035187779,
-0.0171926022,
0.0384669304,
0.0010288816,
0.0278722532,
0.0296718851,
0.0502468012,
-0.0050435038,
0.0242080018,
-0.0473237112,
-0.0183902066,
0.0107979011,
0.0363902263,
0.0210013352,
0.0312655158,
0.0209962893,
-0.0467628166,
-0.0338055715,
0.0556741729,
-0.0282082632,
-0.0097711328,
-0.0282554831,
-0.0090512326,
0.0016091993,
0.0064129201,
0.0333258025,
0.0164569598,
-0.0301019307,
0.0240113717,
0.0041483748,
0.0770965219,
-0.0067853383,
0.0236045979,
-0.0516006872,
-0.0293639544,
-0.0414583124,
0.0158858225,
0.0386530049,
-0.0143665606,
0.0649468601,
-0.0082088262,
-0.0118411714,
-0.0449021831,
0.0451752804,
-0.0074384641,
0.0087998938,
-0.0064239977,
0.009637027,
-0.0060912818,
-0.0189738497,
0.0856601968,
0.0084572649,
0.020943379,
0.0226653237,
-0.0037042249,
-0.0226061884,
-0.0367787108,
0.0164946839,
-0.0650276393,
0.0074866042,
-0.0058525009,
0.0130522177,
-0.0816554949,
0.0628155768,
-0.0569322668,
0.0291407295,
-0.016363332,
0.0346650407,
0.0316160843,
-0.0118170884,
-0.0166854784,
-0.0153574822,
0.0325976387,
0.0202773716,
-0.0598591007,
-0.0102658486,
-7.040020239e-33,
-0.0107700778,
-0.0032655294,
-0.010395878,
0.0201708637,
-0.0346967839,
0.0350626856,
-0.043216534,
-0.0085577257,
0.0175330415,
-0.0304635782,
-0.0038272068,
-0.0007517998,
0.0074772909,
0.0525220223,
0.0446804725,
0.0074476725,
0.0678173453,
-0.0124370204,
0.0039227149,
0.0485813133,
0.024811998,
0.0376064479,
0.0260551851,
-0.009430781,
-0.0767530799,
0.01956884,
0.0002386694,
-0.0532453991,
0.0296966955,
0.0428972319,
-0.031099366,
-0.002118753,
0.0035909289,
-0.0779182091,
-0.0275131818,
0.0153803872,
-0.111981675,
-0.0136388727,
-0.0611348301,
-0.0166423004,
-0.0097062914,
-0.0333453119,
0.0552754067,
-0.0112387156,
-0.0112654865,
-0.0521883965,
0.0066905674,
0.0019662392,
-0.0276716687,
-0.0614081211,
-0.0595183112,
0.0534305014,
-0.0328548588,
-0.0051207836,
0.0467442721,
0.0605255738,
-0.0386311933,
0.0144419391,
-0.0637134835,
-0.0294041932,
0.0473018065,
0.07512898,
0.0462792516,
0.015460073,
0.0267089792,
0.0018144019,
0.0303145181,
-0.0209176391,
-0.0392322019,
0.0091551486,
0.0094496105,
0.0160877574,
0.0619649962,
0.0021166969,
0.0634458885,
0.0048161857,
-0.1102877185,
0.0138884019,
-0.0282120649,
0.0396501645,
0.0390437022,
0.0220202003,
0.0078247199,
0.017128801,
0.0153651144,
-0.0107270926,
-0.0208910406,
-0.0205939636,
0.0331654176,
0.043307282,
-0.0132879941,
0.0087681552,
0.0529151186,
-0.0074032396,
0.0231392495,
0.0001057973,
0.0207914636,
0.0058217645,
0.0196217448,
0.0044305096,
-0.0397125594,
-0.0298833866,
0.0475456491,
0.0355181769,
0.0132671306,
-0.0361274034,
0.0753243491,
0.0408327356,
-0.0629925877,
-0.0409829021,
-0.0308048092,
0.0388691425,
0.011550134,
0.0445702896,
0.0347644687,
-0.0508862808,
-0.0014757933,
0.065245904,
-0.039625518,
-0.0098638041,
-0.0197444074,
0.0287284795,
0.0421550833,
0.046497155,
-0.0299182981,
-0.0047282274,
-0.0534837544,
0.0130029973,
0.0316513591,
-0.0629042089,
-0.0403927602,
0.0159380194,
3.091e-7,
0.0096330019,
-0.0110604158,
0.0329685435,
-0.0063508945,
0.0237061549,
0.0157852545,
0.0265987329,
0.0599726923,
-0.0216472913,
0.0305420514,
0.0133614605,
0.027844293,
0.0454488434,
-0.0081784045,
-0.0263092928,
-0.0274399165,
-0.055292882,
0.0447938442,
-0.0349964164,
-0.0095211603,
0.0021509454,
0.1196301058,
-0.0109750163,
-0.0037089724,
0.0456668884,
0.0126711437,
0.0506971702,
0.039136216,
0.0193080176,
-0.0266632829,
-0.0167707503,
-0.0276549421,
-0.0103632882,
-0.0231408458,
-0.0334912837,
0.0047578788,
0.0024417106,
0.075171344,
0.0185603872,
-0.0310270414,
0.0285570659,
0.0169246718,
-0.003448504,
-0.0369033664,
0.0631025583,
-0.0880223736,
-0.0364016294,
-0.0152009735,
-0.0459795892,
0.0163489357,
-0.0093869837,
0.0048283762,
0.0300887618,
0.010780612,
0.0208059829,
-0.020261785,
0.0210851338,
-0.0751669407,
-0.0042030411,
-0.0068936595,
-0.0653399155,
0.0055886782,
-0.0968000591,
-0.0314752422,
0.0272176526,
0.0598320998,
-0.0209203251,
3.242853026e-34,
0.0144606577,
-0.0059688366,
-0.008013648,
-0.0117875133,
0.0018134856,
-0.0280800983,
-0.0099397991,
0.0195385776,
0.0148165664,
-0.0779757872,
-0.066907227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15098v1 | Referral Augmentation for Zero-Shot Information Retrieval | 2023-05-24T12:28:35 | 2023-05-24T12:28:35 | Michael Tang, Shunyu Yao, John Yang, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose Referral-Augmented Retrieval (RAR), a simple technique that
concatenates document indices with referrals, i.e. text from other documents
that cite or link to the given document, to provide significant performance
gains for zero-shot information retrieval. The key insight behind our method is
that referrals provide a more complete, multi-view representation of a
document, much like incoming page links in algorithms like PageRank provide a
comprehensive idea of a webpage's importance. RAR works with both sparse and
dense retrievers, and outperforms generative text expansion techniques such as
DocT5Query and Query2Doc a 37% and 21% absolute improvement on ACL paper
retrieval Recall@10 -- while also eliminating expensive model training and
inference. We also analyze different methods for multi-referral aggregation and
show that RAR enables up-to-date information retrieval without re-training. | [
0.0029901117,
0.0056217723,
0.0268105511,
-0.0247924514,
-0.0065971012,
-0.0053844792,
0.0202622563,
0.0193449706,
0.0126622962,
-0.0334854275,
-0.0407009348,
0.0167861544,
-0.0359064117,
-0.0019438951,
0.0108111603,
-0.0296573825,
0.0593093596,
0.0386055298,
0.0070289979,
0.0278433599,
-0.0184583776,
0.0231986921,
0.0160599481,
-0.0206114091,
0.0140744997,
0.0165345166,
-0.0385463275,
0.0275242459,
0.0153826345,
-0.0327420346,
-0.0368163362,
0.0056988909,
0.0440407395,
0.0503135696,
0.0000018941,
-0.0163401403,
-0.0552106947,
0.0290446486,
-0.0134370793,
0.0046896893,
0.0836676583,
-0.0136570148,
0.0438317992,
-0.0000577383,
-0.0027315398,
-0.0298165176,
0.0095807659,
0.0944777429,
0.0285299793,
0.0418765843,
-0.0305641908,
-0.0394239537,
0.0583897084,
-0.0375647061,
0.0936066955,
-0.055286821,
0.0157105811,
-0.0156255905,
0.0195841566,
0.0447825305,
0.0124014895,
0.0208981298,
-0.0145971319,
-0.0268689059,
0.1058554649,
0.0185491703,
-0.0478315279,
0.0219449233,
0.0398195386,
0.0391307622,
-0.012520479,
-0.0244705789,
0.0119899455,
0.0295380689,
-0.0218960848,
0.0549584776,
-0.0758520961,
-0.0333655439,
0.003462363,
-0.0022285546,
-0.0414263308,
0.0242921822,
0.024511965,
0.0043971394,
0.0104825189,
-0.0006978837,
0.0002797685,
-0.026420908,
0.0151370661,
0.023540847,
0.0632214546,
-0.0016819512,
0.0018179219,
0.0076083029,
0.039174214,
0.0061146379,
-0.0136317248,
-0.0252031796,
0.0871942714,
-0.0354136638,
0.0214485005,
0.0042112991,
-0.0185007304,
0.100995101,
-0.0505751893,
-0.0154815456,
-0.0361157954,
-0.0383322649,
-0.0076131173,
-0.0184585731,
-0.0613226816,
-0.0219800547,
-0.0177672692,
0.0644818172,
-0.0134493085,
-0.0288740899,
-0.01967231,
0.0040547894,
-0.0058059203,
-0.0214072205,
-0.0110551883,
0.0281856898,
-0.0337785669,
-0.0083088661,
-0.0174157247,
0.0512677543,
-0.0213031191,
0.014735884,
-0.0123434793,
-0.0215100497,
-0.0129994135,
-0.0042504268,
0.0322237983,
-0.0492488481,
-0.0239831526,
0.0262300782,
-0.0226743016,
-0.0491294079,
-0.0248798877,
-0.0675084442,
0.0168687422,
-0.0590789057,
0.0370766632,
-0.0316391177,
0.0240160599,
-0.0009632322,
-0.0207882281,
-0.012206912,
-0.0021153132,
0.0373949558,
-0.0671447664,
0.0429563895,
-0.0240621157,
-0.0599221699,
0.0128505817,
0.013958185,
0.0235199314,
0.0352514051,
-0.0357673988,
0.0277000815,
0.0019342125,
0.0567623898,
0.0032228797,
-0.0462238155,
0.0520971604,
0.0258097369,
0.0352826081,
-0.0231040455,
-0.0292001646,
-0.0282712746,
0.0148530575,
-0.0019406906,
-0.0836393386,
-0.0045868326,
-0.0055629537,
-0.0035065869,
0.0227958504,
-0.0294145346,
-0.0179722514,
0.0202271231,
-0.0412262678,
-0.0152916433,
-0.0016032014,
0.0658624619,
-0.0220453348,
0.004112816,
0.0819637999,
-0.0134916212,
-0.0427127965,
-0.0054625156,
0.0217653681,
0.0238975901,
-0.020594852,
-0.0106100366,
0.0638634488,
-0.0002838082,
-0.0105006853,
0.0238374546,
0.0296289679,
-0.0515021421,
0.000990961,
0.0046469136,
0.0095376968,
0.0171848871,
0.0688484311,
-0.0437253453,
-0.0136562837,
-0.0195064321,
0.0107327197,
0.0056131966,
0.0064448612,
-0.0016270857,
-0.017481735,
-0.065141581,
-0.0564410202,
-0.0059636775,
0.020180665,
0.0347134359,
-0.0104816286,
0.0410261266,
0.053958904,
-0.0322984718,
-0.0154791819,
-0.0161229596,
0.0121308798,
-0.0196084864,
0.0271055307,
-0.0045960112,
-0.0017872967,
0.035199184,
-0.0036191083,
0.0013615518,
0.0595348328,
0.017794352,
-0.0208188575,
-0.0131887924,
-0.0107121682,
0.0178203452,
0.0218361802,
-0.0416987166,
0.0478194579,
-0.0540465303,
-0.0011091651,
-0.0650558919,
0.0389622971,
0.0071865078,
0.0180412941,
-0.0265276972,
-0.0033297967,
0.006920259,
0.0171293281,
-0.0182871725,
0.0511227921,
0.0266099479,
-0.0056943083,
0.0482218713,
-0.0420503095,
0.0360137708,
-0.0291621145,
-0.0267540999,
-0.0282798838,
0.0029799803,
0.0266076569,
0.049565468,
-0.0502236076,
-0.0379845276,
0.0067363111,
-0.0464932621,
0.0129084568,
0.0103889313,
-0.0283923354,
-0.0374390148,
0.0137697645,
0.0274190363,
-0.0301724244,
-0.0121025303,
-0.013312499,
-0.0167183019,
0.0086013591,
0.0157468487,
0.0332508944,
0.019795429,
-0.0452305041,
-0.054794576,
-0.0160813779,
0.0197740644,
0.0544387698,
-0.0346520916,
0.0245181732,
0.0120973019,
-0.0342477448,
-0.0003489921,
-0.0450463928,
0.035184335,
-0.0029500129,
-0.043127045,
-0.0339776725,
0.0333270803,
-0.0143583016,
-0.0072867577,
0.028518308,
-0.0036618821,
-0.0909537449,
0.0195585135,
-0.0083697373,
-0.0171561055,
0.0435059741,
0.0080576371,
-0.0200080443,
-0.020170467,
-0.0299984235,
-0.0165047366,
-0.0231831204,
0.0108302012,
0.041182328,
-0.0175668467,
-0.080262363,
0.0065554497,
0.034963429,
0.0092343017,
-0.0149206137,
-0.0095697083,
0.0286018122,
-0.0186352991,
0.0130603379,
0.0156268086,
0.0063263234,
-0.0594129823,
0.0191441923,
0.0355209671,
-0.0171010699,
0.0202364922,
0.0133983307,
0.0413191803,
0.0430365689,
0.0313744247,
-0.0181213152,
0.0360175259,
0.0297455173,
0.0670778602,
-0.0196924396,
-0.0367064327,
-0.0123439189,
-0.0236569997,
0.0262259357,
0.0170459617,
-0.0383688733,
-0.0076350584,
-0.1061332375,
0.0053013139,
0.0775642246,
0.043281991,
-0.0409014411,
-0.0527326725,
0.0040839352,
0.0338251851,
0.0535173528,
-0.0491235889,
-0.0409644917,
0.0100711519,
-0.0529617369,
0.0540111363,
0.0387836955,
-0.0233207587,
-0.0045220079,
-0.0018488134,
-0.0024666565,
-0.0172209069,
-0.0324874856,
-0.0258997492,
-0.0430812985,
-0.0337591618,
0.0008672322,
0.0530102178,
0.0372550786,
-0.1032592952,
-0.0739246085,
-0.0520864688,
0.0201290883,
0.0387067758,
0.028773671,
-0.0996436104,
-0.0186921116,
-0.0142608369,
0.0319699124,
-0.0044451104,
-0.0271307882,
0.0013891801,
-0.1303071976,
0.0347252861,
-0.0078894971,
0.0206904691,
0.0085005816,
-0.0932784379,
0.0119214123,
-0.0110051008,
-0.064678371,
0.0518833995,
-0.0190281421,
-0.0190807711,
-0.0070105814,
0.0334024131,
-0.0068363291,
-0.0269586556,
-0.0103263101,
-0.0092866346,
0.0108633116,
0.0296155103,
0.016386345,
-0.0154570164,
-0.0441262089,
-0.0361258723,
0.0019657866,
-0.0229262188,
0.1244479418,
-0.0301041324,
0.0385930017,
0.0137702711,
-0.0025458771,
0.0079235462,
0.0281041395,
-0.0006976451,
0.0562519394,
0.0097107561,
0.021660585,
-0.0567164049,
-0.0335045941,
-0.0258877855,
0.0114169158,
-0.0106710661,
0.0439348966,
0.0058081802,
-0.0070984215,
0.0375725478,
-0.0105923573,
-0.0061971205,
-0.0225051437,
-0.0766671523,
-0.0419232361,
-0.0558899008,
-0.0211312473,
-0.0080672177,
0.0408313982,
-0.0183780715,
0.0175700039,
-0.0205456913,
-0.0389709696,
-0.0341491885,
0.0021006395,
-0.0342769399,
-0.016936902,
-0.0115458919,
0.0138246454,
0.0626502112,
-0.0393105857,
-0.0111971209,
-0.0019395932,
0.064471215,
-0.0267767776,
-0.0498190485,
0.0315220952,
0.0196027234,
0.0535880774,
-0.0336238295,
-0.0472053215,
0.0339199789,
0.0672060698,
-0.0239635892,
0.0019024179,
0.0272403918,
-0.0468971618,
-0.0305588786,
0.00304708,
-0.0772917643,
0.0268296618,
-0.0360023193,
-0.0231607258,
-0.0688391402,
0.0021788364,
-0.0001564415,
0.0202517416,
0.0630720183,
0.0172003917,
0.1009740084,
-0.0124121699,
0.0309087858,
-0.0531560518,
-0.0154519416,
-0.0083780903,
0.0115913432,
0.0003301629,
-0.0314491652,
0.011787707,
0.0274190959,
-0.0160079505,
0.0727602616,
-0.0407263562,
-0.0326868631,
0.0390546098,
-0.0286497325,
-0.0107836388,
-0.0069551901,
-0.0342068039,
-0.0071329274,
0.0263694339,
0.0492152572,
-0.0333000347,
0.0132757751,
0.0139941154,
0.0158898663,
-0.0235755071,
0.0047023068,
-0.0833485648,
0.029383637,
0.0030714588,
0.0016394594,
0.0454506762,
-0.0115326317,
0.0693297312,
-0.0201997068,
-0.0344649255,
-0.0253269169,
-0.0208296012,
0.0201060977,
-0.0386407934,
-0.0259492286,
0.061554499,
0.0129326219,
0.0702755973,
0.0744563937,
0.0158735625,
0.01661589,
-0.0611166582,
-0.0296758842,
-0.0177669451,
0.014041556,
0.020542061,
0.0590819716,
0.0208645705,
-0.0156938192,
-0.0226669889,
-0.0254192241,
0.0827906355,
-0.025535306,
-0.0061263074,
-0.0151781058,
0.0573653989,
0.0280103888,
0.0104486179,
-0.0115501471,
-0.0303995907,
-0.0085830325,
-0.0381271169,
0.0042322674,
-0.0028791341,
-6.353995858e-33,
-0.028555274,
-0.0094189048,
0.0188297573,
-0.0266706366,
-0.0272923168,
0.0403097123,
-0.0164817255,
-0.0239798259,
-0.0185758136,
0.0087398821,
-0.0277819149,
-0.0032279817,
0.0095074736,
0.0156570934,
0.0214257631,
0.0113954423,
0.0598424524,
0.0255046841,
-0.0004810781,
0.0315138213,
0.0568865575,
0.0141998753,
-0.0059347735,
-0.0527368523,
0.0276457798,
-0.0011582142,
0.005013071,
-0.0125491899,
0.0622908063,
0.0382889658,
-0.0028015377,
0.036836125,
0.0177516565,
-0.0420755707,
0.0209038742,
-0.0084740957,
-0.1269650161,
-0.0219365191,
-0.0109852813,
-0.0633284748,
-0.0020160591,
-0.0175792892,
0.0451004095,
0.0031718481,
0.0150373988,
-0.0475446694,
0.0379334502,
-0.003770669,
-0.0687637627,
-0.0417200401,
-0.0258262493,
0.0247090422,
-0.0082795583,
0.0355244391,
0.0086323246,
0.0455091633,
0.0164141618,
0.0681970119,
-0.0917952657,
0.0133883692,
-0.0463729762,
0.0446035713,
0.0000600459,
-0.0202424675,
0.0101218363,
0.0444479734,
0.0119806556,
-0.0071021901,
-0.032445956,
-0.0068071331,
0.0076342295,
-0.0028531749,
0.0248128232,
0.0568467416,
0.0687987655,
-0.0034130192,
-0.052143652,
0.0357457511,
0.035014879,
0.0728528276,
0.0044317674,
0.0630463138,
-0.0461259373,
-0.0130768595,
0.0150604267,
-0.0174129773,
-0.0583846718,
-0.0486740954,
-0.0133188888,
0.0723492131,
-0.0003806457,
0.0509995557,
0.037341781,
0.0190790948,
-0.0316538885,
0.0916770622,
0.0065176073,
0.0349975191,
-0.0191468634,
-0.0405525602,
-0.0436579362,
0.0028242487,
0.0301001705,
0.0030849809,
-0.0305052511,
-0.002750068,
0.0552368462,
-0.0312192775,
-0.0393186882,
-0.0202468373,
0.0109541034,
-0.0101914313,
-0.0175438933,
-0.0114353709,
0.0127303954,
0.033446312,
0.0105195045,
0.0717476308,
0.0151857128,
0.040643882,
0.0121852942,
-0.0619695149,
-0.0014284514,
-0.033549998,
-0.002343049,
0.0250825286,
0.0259588193,
0.0120197861,
0.0270002689,
-0.0954183117,
-0.0030017986,
0.0094699357,
2.814e-7,
0.0256767832,
0.043924585,
0.0278281253,
-0.0066501242,
-0.0130389845,
0.0174719654,
0.0210181195,
0.0437649563,
0.0351899564,
0.0112816617,
-0.0153747089,
0.0263163187,
0.0030201182,
0.0366533063,
-0.1011563316,
-0.0403813757,
-0.0855074003,
-0.0473127402,
-0.0197082348,
-0.0400764942,
-0.011007187,
0.0606383756,
0.0060950778,
0.0037502891,
0.0298283212,
-0.0437269136,
0.0561378486,
0.041051425,
-0.0197534151,
-0.0271645132,
0.0865735859,
0.0323716477,
-0.0408380032,
-0.0121588772,
-0.0197244287,
0.0535328612,
0.0228137579,
0.0104606636,
-0.0435745567,
-0.0463240445,
0.0345528945,
-0.0488756523,
0.0103558591,
0.0331225917,
0.0981758833,
0.0004407019,
0.0245298557,
0.0468003713,
-0.0814600289,
0.0140673807,
-0.0008498795,
0.0256969966,
-0.0430332571,
0.0246916804,
-0.014118203,
-0.0025932051,
-0.0029456266,
-0.0652994663,
0.0213471502,
0.0135878501,
0.0147053087,
0.0196425654,
0.0041928189,
-0.0079619801,
0.0003265713,
-0.0267261881,
0.0258810464,
2.218126846e-34,
0.0595741756,
0.0160068385,
0.0094920173,
-0.0202562325,
0.0113418307,
-0.0052099759,
-0.0828010589,
0.0152010052,
0.0511080176,
-0.0861425027,
-0.0074683777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15096v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15096v3 | Dynamic Masking Rate Schedules for MLM Pretraining | 2023-05-24T12:24:12 | 2024-02-10T20:56:20 | Zachary Ankner, Naomi Saphra, Davis Blalock, Jonathan Frankle, Matthew L. Leavitt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Most works on transformers trained with the Masked Language Modeling (MLM)
objective use the original BERT model's fixed masking rate of 15%. We propose
to instead dynamically schedule the masking rate throughout training. We find
that linearly decreasing the masking rate over the course of pretraining
improves average GLUE accuracy by up to 0.46% and 0.25% in BERT-base and
BERT-large, respectively, compared to fixed rate baselines. These gains come
from exposure to both high and low masking rate regimes, providing benefits
from both settings. Our results demonstrate that masking rate scheduling is a
simple way to improve the quality of masked language models, achieving up to a
1.89x speedup in pretraining for BERT-base as well as a Pareto improvement for
BERT-large. | [
0.0118414741,
0.0295161232,
-0.0068990602,
0.022164762,
-0.0085526314,
0.0074800043,
0.0452953801,
0.023736326,
-0.0343327932,
-0.0452108234,
-0.0287330709,
-0.0336260609,
0.0054981243,
0.0240426585,
0.0283696949,
-0.1106906235,
0.0287474804,
-0.0265170783,
-0.0494645238,
-0.0095289601,
0.0064611523,
0.0014223073,
-0.0225570109,
0.0504188053,
-0.0027294301,
-0.0110555934,
0.0076979469,
-0.0040790234,
0.0376828127,
-0.0021131106,
0.0380188189,
0.0425122194,
0.0053637205,
0.0498114377,
0.0000019302,
-0.0632468238,
-0.0096203424,
0.0221076347,
-0.0342288949,
0.065482527,
-0.0139031345,
-0.0158114899,
-0.0299700331,
0.0762724876,
-0.0202782452,
0.0136618959,
0.0522102639,
0.0062640761,
0.0587770678,
0.0486389026,
-0.0279822573,
-0.0220638327,
0.0024797784,
-0.0291059203,
-0.0484413654,
-0.0086480649,
0.0227471795,
-0.0307590533,
-0.0460266583,
-0.0859344229,
-0.0179423112,
0.0237150732,
0.0086407196,
0.0052067302,
0.0110061429,
0.0715706646,
-0.041984804,
-0.0347750075,
-0.0235281829,
0.0385651216,
-0.0834176615,
-0.0017797638,
0.0044913911,
-0.0009802155,
-0.0196561813,
0.0105904406,
-0.0106548592,
0.0250404924,
0.0234099999,
0.0226448178,
-0.0193681847,
-0.0275673848,
0.020426577,
-0.0070585837,
-0.0522221364,
0.0345400348,
0.043807108,
-0.0363609865,
-0.010280245,
-0.0085378569,
-0.0061973641,
-0.0637885928,
0.0435597189,
0.0448085964,
0.028020082,
0.0176225342,
-0.0790767968,
-0.0750734732,
-0.0011349755,
-0.0270184875,
0.0129585648,
0.0439411439,
-0.0234819725,
-0.0011530992,
-0.0496283509,
0.0314180553,
-0.0029503063,
0.0701596215,
-0.013047765,
0.0097994041,
0.0008814236,
-0.0203563794,
-0.0590460487,
0.0336942412,
-0.0411227569,
-0.0028671338,
-0.0296069514,
0.0086122444,
0.0161981508,
-0.0105928024,
0.022552263,
-0.0320151448,
-0.0625814274,
0.0039208252,
0.0116160661,
-0.0145744234,
-0.0110407872,
0.011994157,
-0.0259883106,
-0.0557044037,
-0.0177962556,
-0.0045762165,
0.0151142115,
-0.0477653891,
0.0344927683,
0.0652688742,
-0.033599779,
-0.0192457605,
-0.0287783295,
0.0268241074,
0.0085271541,
-0.0162839666,
0.0042606047,
-0.0311212633,
-0.0205449406,
0.0025311171,
0.03572198,
0.0206929445,
-0.0138423862,
0.0029028938,
0.0109916488,
0.0543541014,
-0.0222799238,
0.0027450451,
0.0162958596,
0.0011239852,
0.0005539733,
0.0391844288,
0.0477248505,
0.0098205637,
0.0109195467,
-0.0429209433,
0.0009315284,
0.0805715322,
0.0273989029,
0.0006549005,
-0.0276375879,
-0.0516991019,
0.0212678947,
-0.0264879484,
0.0485160761,
0.0505531244,
-0.0446090475,
-0.0333784372,
0.0616840497,
0.0343500935,
0.0289460756,
0.0147617245,
0.0114995223,
0.0201364383,
0.0420244709,
0.0040412615,
-0.0152947614,
-0.0066537107,
-0.0258339066,
0.006549648,
-0.0448549129,
0.0815645382,
-0.0265688393,
-0.0027113848,
-0.0224425495,
-0.0010359542,
-0.0136195505,
-0.0112885339,
0.0365086757,
0.0234921444,
-0.0599235855,
0.1141738892,
0.005966723,
-0.0307209007,
0.0139555121,
-0.0766554177,
-0.0378580689,
0.0128237763,
0.0393117145,
-0.0139961392,
-0.0838076845,
0.0072131176,
-0.0307105165,
0.0536101796,
0.0058184653,
0.0082271574,
0.0653554946,
-0.0588441752,
-0.0160699375,
0.0029684324,
-0.0023727752,
0.027457634,
0.0120311948,
0.0061447271,
-0.0098712416,
-0.0165625922,
0.0168131646,
0.0711865351,
-0.0345327109,
-0.0244979039,
-0.0160227586,
0.0143791744,
0.0230007228,
-0.0068500182,
-0.0618044063,
-0.0162941366,
0.0258654039,
-0.0422814228,
0.0070143249,
0.0494118333,
-0.0366150439,
-0.0348572843,
0.0494170859,
-0.0271296799,
-0.0150037268,
0.0923080519,
-0.010760597,
-0.0310102385,
-0.0423033014,
-0.0384783819,
0.0762658268,
-0.0404774696,
0.0468573757,
-0.0279203486,
0.021626493,
-0.0281911027,
0.0190579183,
-0.0130044241,
-0.0039029096,
0.0319287628,
-0.0013546349,
0.0293719787,
-0.0177802183,
-0.0241711959,
0.0203527175,
-0.0096758166,
-0.0086827651,
-0.0102486815,
0.0189516228,
-0.0370444357,
-0.0387643427,
-0.0426685736,
-0.0209922791,
-0.029768914,
0.0318104513,
0.0176252443,
-0.0014160728,
-0.0204900112,
-0.0101663107,
-0.0061115921,
-0.0572063029,
-0.0388876647,
-0.007467798,
0.0065606106,
0.015722733,
-0.0487907976,
-0.0207463037,
-0.0209674686,
0.0088898148,
0.0294513535,
-0.0129096583,
-0.0621145107,
-0.0670904517,
0.0080379182,
0.0018587305,
0.0467565209,
0.000673556,
-0.0820620805,
-0.0009835202,
0.0065079499,
0.0712011531,
0.0464844108,
0.0206954759,
-0.0033697581,
0.0552609041,
0.0044226372,
-0.0528210774,
0.0254640728,
-0.0248422399,
-0.0031994849,
-0.0492793061,
-0.0262530893,
0.0198997594,
0.0918427557,
-0.0299501698,
0.0041537127,
-0.0608284324,
-0.0266630147,
-0.0130434949,
-0.0343664065,
0.0018427483,
-0.0065914611,
-0.0436729826,
0.0112383962,
-0.0105657429,
-0.0518986434,
0.0563981608,
-0.0387362503,
-0.0422604382,
-0.0337437317,
0.000652773,
-0.0081587248,
-0.0014041011,
0.0097893979,
0.0274271946,
0.0003492778,
-0.0800586864,
-0.0393559001,
0.0139380908,
0.0092692086,
-0.0451393612,
0.0095838765,
-0.0244040284,
-0.0000764544,
-0.0094810696,
-0.0447542965,
-0.0536306016,
-0.0318618938,
-0.0155955069,
-0.0026529953,
0.0313417502,
-0.049681548,
-0.0381614305,
0.0222721174,
0.0068439096,
0.062407963,
0.0110308118,
0.0046428461,
-0.0062890183,
0.0286759231,
0.0315367281,
0.0253250804,
0.0080727432,
-0.0392097607,
0.0161704272,
0.0074539268,
0.100971207,
0.0440632477,
-0.0455236286,
0.0102457302,
0.0527529195,
-0.0066268384,
-0.023711307,
0.0028557049,
0.0096990587,
-0.0178590305,
0.0208710004,
0.1017740443,
0.0246322509,
-0.0182719268,
-0.0079098996,
-0.0151078179,
0.0806409493,
0.0077375807,
0.0427917019,
-0.0713884085,
0.0046350104,
0.040972542,
0.0585597456,
0.0011548256,
0.0137919337,
0.0001501055,
-0.1121576056,
0.0089330757,
0.0013944355,
-0.0036000016,
-0.0139037091,
-0.0586832799,
-0.0155709563,
-0.0139625464,
0.0532992594,
-0.0013884996,
-0.003347358,
-0.0236409232,
0.0731789395,
-0.0586258061,
-0.0568193607,
0.0246863179,
-0.030239936,
0.0395674966,
0.0499056652,
0.0076498771,
-0.0310412962,
-0.0760140419,
0.06366238,
0.0144519545,
-0.0131715192,
-0.0152409133,
0.0696596056,
-0.0270866267,
-0.0360227786,
-0.0082936082,
0.0086386586,
0.0363053679,
-0.0126629593,
-0.0341595523,
0.0283921827,
0.0213136878,
-0.0002488141,
-0.0126957884,
0.0087457439,
-0.0361196622,
0.0580292195,
0.02004705,
-0.0613176562,
0.0136423139,
-0.0095442999,
0.04398489,
-0.0743645728,
-0.0234313998,
0.0552617311,
-0.0840882733,
-0.0487371273,
-0.0450831801,
0.0089782719,
0.0184091404,
0.0744862556,
0.0465774089,
-0.0371709988,
0.0099082729,
0.0380557142,
-0.0443076193,
0.0409157202,
-0.0099570611,
0.035562139,
-0.0786564499,
-0.0448191389,
0.0266496036,
-0.0125148445,
-0.0301966183,
-0.0062710401,
-0.0585044771,
-0.0553241447,
0.0595798977,
0.055743929,
0.0293011554,
0.0495687574,
0.005270815,
-0.0875624418,
0.047542613,
0.0340549685,
0.0252043959,
0.0328910351,
0.0634300038,
-0.0471708179,
0.0048195915,
0.015743712,
-0.0507207066,
0.0160172451,
0.005041359,
0.0210102405,
-0.0190157089,
0.0310666189,
0.0021334917,
0.0285501424,
0.049508892,
-0.0396721214,
0.0253199358,
-0.0326999389,
0.053700231,
0.0031717315,
0.0054022609,
-0.0437215753,
0.0084796688,
0.0210024491,
0.0201556627,
-0.0204706583,
0.0662321523,
-0.0006278316,
0.0025495035,
-0.0218510404,
0.0038535183,
-0.0471654795,
0.0182769634,
0.0357342772,
0.0206648167,
-0.0066380184,
-0.0101521704,
0.013749891,
-0.0024080027,
0.0067801434,
-0.0126667256,
0.025542181,
0.024024155,
-0.0272190627,
0.0096363379,
-0.035640005,
-0.0229646843,
-0.051468581,
-0.0244081002,
0.0301204324,
-0.0043029478,
0.0730917975,
-0.029533999,
0.0006777611,
0.0253258068,
-0.0143303471,
0.0038115089,
-0.0048256894,
0.0294336621,
-0.0059840754,
-0.0114219505,
-0.003352246,
0.0814290419,
0.0228303075,
0.0726381242,
-0.0194330439,
0.0084194141,
-0.0347659066,
0.0110270558,
0.0521460325,
0.0174021162,
-0.002177743,
-0.0301562902,
-0.0269309245,
-0.0517469309,
0.042260468,
-0.0124600884,
0.0241447538,
-0.0059979782,
0.0254449192,
0.0294801146,
-0.0201940574,
-0.0481336378,
-0.0082553392,
0.010003713,
0.0816472769,
0.0043892902,
0.0256509911,
-6.328292939e-33,
-0.0348088332,
0.0052398699,
-0.0150856888,
0.0520072095,
-0.0222406834,
0.0282252543,
-0.0155965174,
-0.0158416424,
-0.0125055229,
-0.0056053833,
-0.0246358439,
0.0041220798,
0.0380530059,
0.0140030021,
-0.0541160963,
0.020484345,
0.0760194585,
-0.0248459,
-0.0205242597,
-0.0314119942,
-0.0151037965,
0.0653738901,
0.0615903065,
-0.0417801999,
-0.0480800048,
0.0249533784,
-0.042298656,
-0.0015436471,
-0.0073738466,
0.0430823192,
-0.0202920642,
0.0122904843,
-0.0028998025,
-0.0205583051,
-0.0322280638,
0.0009541948,
-0.0949432179,
0.0031686912,
-0.0041407053,
0.049227912,
-0.0270846207,
-0.0099943038,
0.0582903922,
-0.0001334218,
-0.0240420848,
0.0156105179,
0.0269709937,
-0.0365266427,
-0.0336405709,
-0.0557252914,
-0.0356185809,
0.020041246,
-0.000756455,
-0.0310025122,
0.0659159496,
0.0215238556,
0.0106331548,
0.0270416699,
-0.0598359592,
0.0018920619,
0.0652402714,
0.0379501022,
0.0482252799,
0.0696166009,
0.0109476177,
0.0497156009,
0.0541039854,
-0.0002290643,
0.0263794698,
-0.0012688879,
0.1013592407,
0.0151684312,
0.0316391513,
-0.0162199941,
0.0556635596,
-0.0132228183,
-0.0338087417,
0.0359534547,
-0.0044692829,
-0.0020625317,
0.0244097151,
0.049695719,
0.003588014,
0.0042985035,
-0.048867166,
0.0253801849,
-0.0188679732,
0.034487471,
0.0100314599,
0.0296257343,
-0.0385022685,
0.0362915881,
0.0289544594,
0.0012974571,
0.0009302894,
-0.0329860449,
-0.0161408279,
0.0360580496,
-0.0270755067,
0.0291991699,
-0.066245012,
-0.0476736799,
0.0323546007,
0.0091973711,
0.0169215221,
-0.0179814566,
0.0485115163,
0.0563039556,
-0.0794243515,
0.0042120111,
-0.0364261828,
0.0226457398,
0.0570673235,
0.0503720902,
0.0382046774,
-0.030870989,
-0.0008816891,
-0.0022260852,
0.0068941149,
-0.0150075005,
-0.0256855488,
0.0430599302,
0.0207117554,
0.0283489581,
-0.0335537866,
-0.0094571617,
-0.0305221211,
0.0141139571,
0.0488913655,
-0.0545227341,
-0.0357790664,
-0.0396658294,
2.685e-7,
0.0434134454,
0.0452273153,
0.02192224,
0.0258342959,
0.0093788439,
-0.0004102655,
-0.0133939013,
0.033737272,
0.0136888782,
0.0276574548,
-0.0212866627,
-0.018006973,
0.0561398827,
-0.001164497,
-0.0325347111,
-0.0666315034,
-0.0510648601,
0.0062168674,
-0.0395996422,
0.0155828595,
-0.017241599,
0.0889784247,
0.0306724552,
-0.0275982395,
0.0491528772,
-0.0317677222,
0.047078982,
-0.0334984213,
0.0161876101,
0.0256266408,
0.0257497374,
0.0733773336,
0.001770497,
0.0083779888,
-0.0367809124,
0.024695266,
0.00119009,
0.0464579314,
-0.0380864106,
-0.0281403791,
0.0237815101,
0.0235559735,
-0.0390749015,
-0.0380538404,
0.0335056223,
-0.0328610614,
-0.0044179237,
-0.0051787249,
-0.0413485691,
-0.0191143118,
0.0011513461,
-0.05476854,
-0.0420175083,
0.0485082567,
0.0323635899,
-0.0152988322,
-0.0503762178,
-0.0809400231,
-0.0378983952,
-0.0148479603,
-0.0583010055,
-0.0436172187,
-0.0286066718,
-0.0442172401,
0.0034068287,
-0.0671629757,
-0.0049975971,
2.758614097e-34,
0.0216867328,
-0.039335873,
-0.0009095953,
0.0824923962,
0.0147234797,
-0.0116942786,
0.044806391,
0.0038501488,
-0.0189605169,
-0.0709065422,
-0.0263216347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15093v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15093v2 | C-STS: Conditional Semantic Textual Similarity | 2023-05-24T12:18:50 | 2023-11-06T18:48:43 | Ameet Deshpande, Carlos E. Jimenez, Howard Chen, Vishvak Murahari, Victoria Graf, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Ashwin Kalyan, Danqi Chen, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Semantic textual similarity (STS), a cornerstone task in NLP, measures the
degree of similarity between a pair of sentences, and has broad application in
fields such as information retrieval and natural language understanding.
However, sentence similarity can be inherently ambiguous, depending on the
specific aspect of interest. We resolve this ambiguity by proposing a novel
task called Conditional STS (C-STS) which measures sentences' similarity
conditioned on an feature described in natural language (hereon, condition). As
an example, the similarity between the sentences "The NBA player shoots a
three-pointer." and "A man throws a tennis ball into the air to serve." is
higher for the condition "The motion of the ball" (both upward) and lower for
"The size of the ball" (one large and one small). C-STS's advantages are
two-fold: (1) it reduces the subjectivity and ambiguity of STS and (2) enables
fine-grained language model evaluation through diverse natural language
conditions. We put several state-of-the-art models to the test, and even those
performing well on STS (e.g. SimCSE, Flan-T5, and GPT-4) find C-STS
challenging; all with Spearman correlation scores below 50. To encourage a more
comprehensive evaluation of semantic similarity and natural language
understanding, we make nearly 19K C-STS examples and code available for others
to train and test their models. | [
0.0498060472,
0.0276578609,
-0.0198533684,
0.0646601394,
-0.0660166368,
0.0233072229,
0.0065604551,
-0.006091577,
0.0097571397,
-0.0781233236,
0.0072428351,
0.0087262839,
-0.005797422,
0.0107444013,
-0.0204456802,
-0.0309527554,
0.0340871513,
0.0440092124,
-0.0056569721,
0.0182387903,
0.0548668914,
0.0390949175,
0.0040931921,
0.0156310014,
-0.0030858596,
-0.0132923461,
0.0436639972,
-0.0061519761,
0.0296820998,
-0.0373811573,
0.0137812542,
0.0096928654,
0.0385000221,
-0.0201081317,
0.0000019714,
-0.0613896661,
-0.0100818677,
-0.0341865346,
0.0355403461,
0.0208251216,
0.0547013469,
-0.0041517806,
0.0609181114,
-0.0126282508,
-0.0372034349,
0.0163769983,
-0.0014180831,
0.0316030383,
0.0386467613,
0.0414574333,
-0.0199608523,
-0.0114238113,
-0.0274007656,
0.0188895743,
0.0257373769,
-0.0146685792,
0.0193232428,
0.0454092175,
-0.030750582,
0.0483276881,
0.0201215502,
0.007108097,
-0.0282184724,
0.0652983338,
-0.012368219,
0.0179413911,
-0.0390526243,
0.0070900531,
0.0151449656,
0.0365646519,
0.0029098971,
-0.0853666663,
0.0329979248,
0.0100197578,
-0.0193614569,
0.0413303189,
-0.0566097572,
-0.005364486,
-0.0177127849,
0.0378056243,
0.0066080661,
0.0519430898,
-0.0131433411,
0.0294278041,
0.0307844188,
0.0364277028,
0.0255135987,
-0.0360266492,
-0.0642107129,
0.0163537189,
-0.0181553587,
-0.0039082468,
0.0475990884,
-0.016843114,
-0.0381392464,
-0.0112892389,
-0.0200779829,
-0.0397417434,
0.026528703,
-0.0773909837,
0.0539169014,
0.0383070298,
0.0133158453,
0.0619986616,
-0.0805116668,
0.0320842601,
0.0158134159,
0.0164406151,
-0.0486564338,
-0.0221780874,
-0.093944259,
0.0113837086,
-0.027147809,
0.0370923318,
-0.0115315681,
-0.0357871056,
-0.0083881151,
0.0019126295,
0.003838365,
-0.0053503071,
-0.0014114995,
0.0114127602,
-0.006866938,
0.0100590317,
-0.0234822184,
-0.0161056668,
-0.0694430396,
0.0464371257,
-0.0370602123,
-0.0287062824,
-0.0150889466,
0.0137262642,
0.0325914398,
-0.0344444849,
0.0185027998,
0.01394853,
0.0129455831,
-0.0074058739,
-0.0144981742,
-0.0245952234,
-0.0086391885,
-0.0349887386,
-0.0250312854,
-0.0921931937,
0.038166441,
0.0105758803,
-0.0029875198,
-0.0202037115,
0.0042857975,
0.061081253,
-0.0244881641,
0.0733729377,
0.0254353043,
0.0180481672,
-0.0093162376,
-0.015004999,
0.0055503072,
0.0229340792,
-0.0085066063,
-0.0185132232,
0.0670876205,
0.0566976108,
-0.0319456048,
-0.0010534991,
-0.0349317715,
-0.0084716137,
-0.0123336958,
0.0315957777,
0.0321789943,
0.0477291308,
0.0169004407,
0.0492294095,
-0.0232021939,
-0.0413470082,
0.020912081,
0.0868543163,
-0.0037950859,
-0.0044332664,
0.0875941738,
0.053614784,
-0.0422573239,
0.0185789242,
-0.029220337,
0.0036662836,
-0.0373878218,
0.0188196562,
-0.0163509324,
0.0454259999,
-0.0371848978,
-0.0411641262,
-0.0369452164,
-0.0081086652,
0.0234338809,
-0.0037160951,
0.0205039699,
0.0187884308,
-0.0058007133,
0.0547077619,
0.0160782821,
-0.0614539161,
-0.0179317743,
0.0128402906,
-0.0158632305,
0.0638465956,
0.043546889,
-0.0264878552,
-0.0115495669,
0.0201853663,
-0.0100862533,
0.0315974951,
0.0476051979,
0.0121733649,
-0.000643181,
-0.0444737673,
-0.0020646949,
-0.0074375831,
0.0251852702,
-0.0053663934,
0.0281704459,
0.0276156999,
0.0406966135,
-0.03619425,
-0.0232699644,
0.0660604015,
0.0010377002,
0.0102403881,
-0.0174428858,
-0.0117493933,
-0.0017375195,
0.0132189393,
0.0133001879,
0.0364296585,
-0.002386811,
-0.0607393496,
-0.0570910573,
0.0130564868,
-0.0544605739,
-0.0573548228,
0.0449650958,
-0.074838303,
-0.0018168982,
0.067916587,
-0.0488500074,
-0.0015372869,
0.0305146836,
-0.00669582,
0.0128851244,
-0.0467903316,
0.0266884547,
-0.0080338391,
-0.0120691461,
-0.037645299,
0.0743837953,
0.0338938124,
0.039112851,
-0.0330118462,
-0.0080557661,
0.047597263,
-0.0268088095,
-0.0259529445,
-0.0518493466,
-0.0044197137,
-0.0126920929,
0.0612843968,
0.0105683878,
-0.0342014506,
-0.0006946011,
-0.0877812952,
0.0639145374,
-0.00636217,
0.0120067066,
0.037586052,
0.011913972,
-0.0180293731,
-0.0019811189,
-0.0249283537,
-0.0253322963,
0.0142632164,
0.002775307,
0.0590396151,
-0.0536057949,
-0.0023832517,
-0.0915731117,
-0.0149646383,
-0.0525336824,
0.0507581457,
0.0168790221,
-0.0129659809,
-0.0360759012,
0.0720361397,
-0.0525293536,
-0.0014018395,
0.0216863696,
0.0082682045,
-0.0079808068,
-0.0303502344,
0.0062166913,
0.0455656834,
0.0320639051,
-0.0208360963,
0.043491289,
-0.0232691076,
-0.0530412756,
-0.0048653735,
-0.0335160494,
0.019381687,
-0.0180400331,
-0.0375417024,
0.0467957892,
0.0364928357,
0.0257573426,
-0.0260583386,
-0.049785655,
0.0186108705,
-0.0236326922,
0.0436089896,
-0.0193039235,
-0.0006241937,
0.0095748194,
0.0062687574,
-0.0417041257,
0.0271296948,
0.0874363482,
-0.0570950843,
0.0296619609,
-0.0742081255,
-0.0091419592,
-0.0672706664,
0.0659069717,
-0.0027238291,
0.0151624642,
0.0038024855,
0.048736956,
-0.0104640443,
0.0218319334,
0.0616460554,
-0.0042279484,
0.0294658653,
-0.019094117,
0.0213741586,
0.0246647671,
-0.0283568613,
-0.0044490299,
-0.0390328653,
-0.0517759211,
-0.0229365528,
0.0121165905,
0.0154410545,
-0.0409884863,
-0.025618393,
-0.0212323852,
0.0161503498,
-0.005848967,
-0.0401057899,
-0.0301218871,
0.0569520295,
0.0435458831,
-0.0221947357,
-0.0254364051,
0.0076755979,
0.0250161849,
0.0349658094,
0.0164180491,
0.0471031852,
-0.0230035372,
-0.0010950923,
0.000839274,
-0.059760347,
-0.0082077393,
0.0132272393,
0.058152657,
-0.028744353,
-0.0376532525,
0.1251259446,
0.0787084773,
0.0103219263,
-0.0140508432,
-0.0132577112,
0.03216343,
0.0333518237,
-0.0120977601,
-0.054456424,
-0.0630381852,
-0.0081269806,
-0.0243798476,
-0.0148035288,
-0.0257409681,
-0.0093662348,
-0.0725122467,
-0.0060927984,
-0.0296439454,
-0.0066524236,
-0.0117286732,
-0.0678331032,
0.0283563789,
-0.0268576387,
-0.0369443782,
-0.0190815944,
-0.0433271676,
0.0353283249,
-0.0191573687,
-0.0289379843,
-0.0272055566,
0.0606347471,
-0.0894073769,
-0.0043155504,
0.0359629244,
0.0373840183,
0.0146448519,
-0.0411580913,
-0.0284233913,
-0.0511527471,
0.0047484301,
-0.0008236532,
0.0157928653,
-0.0295988396,
0.0233929809,
-0.0599359907,
0.0296761561,
-0.0206180625,
-0.0155174388,
0.0341608711,
0.0429896824,
0.0071611209,
-0.031532459,
-0.0486050285,
0.0355693176,
-0.0521029644,
0.1331842393,
0.0361678638,
0.008535088,
-0.0358868204,
0.0092653017,
0.0021441604,
-0.0111353686,
-0.0619097352,
-0.0158394165,
0.0496539213,
0.0308952983,
-0.0572429225,
-0.0530783571,
0.0073034698,
-0.0397973433,
-0.0273220204,
0.0382180549,
-0.0241687745,
-0.06066145,
-0.0751731321,
0.0203447733,
-0.0482006408,
0.0149032883,
0.024491448,
0.0440145954,
0.0821381956,
0.0119770123,
-0.0452767722,
0.0070110527,
-0.1001559272,
-0.0336554423,
-0.0294934716,
-0.0042799176,
0.0088816304,
0.0302090719,
-0.0207834803,
0.0286556799,
-0.0385339111,
0.0307991784,
-0.0171773136,
0.0004785224,
-0.0142503856,
0.0128202271,
0.0268228427,
0.0250745863,
-0.0200082343,
0.0403836854,
-0.0026455813,
0.0453729816,
-0.0277465992,
-0.0289044473,
0.0611324497,
0.0297218282,
0.0710672736,
0.0440060608,
-0.0125497887,
-0.0153239453,
-0.0377527848,
-0.0391920768,
-0.017021805,
-0.0254823491,
0.0065046144,
-0.0105685545,
0.0160143245,
-0.0497688502,
0.0310273655,
-0.0363464355,
0.0324354842,
-0.0576712862,
-0.0071857814,
0.0173604861,
0.00521512,
-0.0625745356,
-0.0600799732,
-0.0469880328,
0.00325211,
-0.0278062858,
0.0077095013,
-0.0254686438,
0.0210704859,
0.0388523228,
0.0003185348,
-0.0253336895,
0.0333148129,
-0.0552170053,
-0.0069497549,
-0.000869813,
0.0284035914,
0.0308013167,
-0.0589400865,
0.0343908183,
-0.0190365426,
0.0059852316,
0.0046118596,
0.0269740056,
-0.0024791176,
-0.0242022872,
0.0362526439,
0.0061328337,
-0.001024666,
0.0007529189,
0.0506138392,
-0.0491918884,
0.0386216976,
0.0104484335,
-0.09547396,
-0.0328317136,
-0.0189159978,
0.0204453189,
0.0371719636,
-0.0033361539,
0.0102722701,
-0.0616623238,
-0.0076803574,
0.046246089,
0.0057891468,
0.0091269165,
0.0285629705,
0.0595186763,
0.0575505383,
-0.0122622782,
-0.0378575847,
0.0004897771,
-0.0218862463,
0.005786045,
-0.0724066645,
-0.0679962635,
-6.487908175e-33,
-0.0103572179,
0.0016350108,
-0.0027075256,
0.0055882065,
-0.0211172383,
-0.009034534,
-0.0321782418,
-0.0273033623,
-0.0427542478,
0.0365405232,
0.0432854295,
0.0217497237,
0.0051548388,
0.0021638998,
0.0355226174,
-0.0403892696,
0.0483482666,
0.0121086258,
-0.0198079683,
-0.0255210362,
0.0280130189,
-0.0022743312,
0.0279115271,
-0.034556862,
0.0168440025,
-0.0508991368,
0.0085645672,
0.0030268449,
0.0506323911,
0.0422832668,
-0.0158798937,
0.0138641316,
0.0493859909,
-0.0041577979,
0.0000053864,
0.0046921102,
-0.0371017531,
-0.0685876682,
0.0284003783,
-0.0325949565,
-0.024905296,
0.0024814154,
0.0429496616,
-0.0148877464,
-0.0322396792,
-0.0140388431,
0.0852320939,
0.0111510316,
0.0226818454,
-0.0276634507,
-0.064683266,
0.0265976023,
-0.0267552491,
-0.0177130997,
-0.0079414127,
0.0904322043,
-0.0125016989,
0.0568296015,
-0.0071548522,
0.0338715427,
-0.0521273576,
0.0395527929,
0.0112104323,
-0.0509131327,
0.0229031071,
0.0818731636,
0.0073055513,
-0.0577523448,
-0.0261839889,
-0.0042302855,
0.023747554,
-0.0004002864,
0.0464589708,
0.0467772149,
0.0201209337,
0.0204033293,
-0.0449245349,
0.061811734,
-0.0016275728,
0.0435574576,
-0.0106015811,
0.0099775903,
-0.0781340078,
-0.0161430817,
-0.0303541385,
0.0209798831,
-0.0374229215,
-0.0278212056,
0.0615749657,
-0.0372130051,
0.0029346608,
0.0183475353,
0.0094168177,
-0.0246904269,
-0.0132939294,
0.0058427774,
-0.0093711549,
0.0004985735,
-0.0089976881,
0.0267176311,
-0.0378595144,
-0.0284943059,
0.0042784936,
0.0117617594,
0.0362336002,
-0.0151756369,
0.0430742018,
-0.0397369638,
-0.0432809591,
-0.0047533107,
0.0031749883,
-0.0811823383,
-0.0797568783,
-0.0400931016,
0.0054104012,
0.0651326329,
-0.0091045871,
0.0614709258,
0.0313255228,
-0.0469670296,
-0.0482454412,
-0.024633022,
0.0027158845,
0.0346826874,
0.0076575959,
0.0281763002,
-0.0389381088,
-0.0195518006,
-0.0371501558,
-0.027859509,
-0.008555294,
0.01323062,
2.732e-7,
0.0311940704,
0.0340150967,
0.0003931556,
0.0194530953,
-0.0218381938,
0.0399076343,
0.0119798845,
0.052253861,
-0.0032925259,
0.0205052067,
0.0170634985,
0.0470580049,
0.0231714956,
0.0119746104,
-0.0473673381,
0.046403531,
-0.0755852088,
-0.0710223913,
-0.0587614961,
-0.0100266412,
0.1114499718,
0.0450283699,
0.0381855518,
0.0281386487,
-0.0126937805,
-0.050632786,
0.0513725877,
-0.0427651666,
-0.0145391375,
0.0109960679,
0.0061363317,
-0.0155882584,
0.0152220791,
0.0219763778,
-0.0056477948,
0.0109371999,
0.0613409914,
0.009541071,
-0.0210561324,
0.0233677607,
-0.0222203694,
-0.0258990582,
-0.0328736082,
-0.078349635,
0.0797478408,
-0.0446713828,
0.0149653666,
-0.0170658715,
-0.0383888893,
0.0321728587,
0.015256457,
0.0367747061,
-0.0611933358,
0.0324648507,
0.0328160115,
0.0164448135,
-0.0346286856,
-0.0364677422,
-0.0161919687,
0.0029013385,
-0.0317700803,
0.031191472,
-0.0176229104,
0.010639078,
0.0288887005,
-0.0483255312,
0.0065728822,
2.471491796e-34,
0.024474008,
0.0428798757,
0.0072101071,
-0.0102416174,
0.0317287445,
0.0146919312,
-0.0216845702,
0.0298230983,
0.0070409575,
-0.0325222984,
0.0207236968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15090v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15090v3 | STAR: Boosting Low-Resource Information Extraction by Structure-to-Text Data Generation with Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T12:15:19 | 2024-02-20T20:00:21 | Mingyu Derek Ma, Xiaoxuan Wang, Po-Nien Kung, P. Jeffrey Brantingham, Nanyun Peng, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Information extraction tasks such as event extraction require an in-depth
understanding of the output structure and sub-task dependencies. They heavily
rely on task-specific training data in the form of (passage, target structure)
pairs to obtain reasonable performance. However, obtaining such data through
human annotation is costly, leading to a pressing need for low-resource
information extraction approaches that require minimal human labeling for
real-world applications. Fine-tuning supervised models with synthesized
training data would be a generalizable method, but the existing data generation
methods either still rely on large-scale ground-truth data or cannot be applied
to complicated IE tasks due to their poor performance. To address these
challenges, we propose STAR, a data generation method that leverages Large
Language Models (LLMs) to synthesize data instances given limited seed
demonstrations, thereby boosting low-resource information extraction
performance. Our approach involves generating target structures (Y) followed by
generating passages (X), all accomplished with the aid of LLMs. We design
fine-grained step-by-step instructions to obtain the initial data instances. We
further reduce errors and improve data quality through self-reflection error
identification and self-refinement with iterative revision. Our experiments
show that the data generated by STAR significantly improve the performance of
low-resource event extraction and relation extraction tasks, even surpassing
the effectiveness of human-curated data. Human assessment of the data quality
shows STAR-generated data exhibits higher passage quality and better align with
the task definitions compared with the human-curated data. | [
0.0252376869,
0.054810904,
0.0319124907,
0.0662635937,
-0.0215418283,
0.0227051675,
-0.0178839341,
0.0031494987,
0.0077635767,
-0.0603884459,
-0.0368581489,
-0.0146667203,
-0.0181390438,
0.0277869888,
0.0252766106,
-0.0303237773,
0.0325436629,
-0.025512591,
-0.0009452234,
0.0440564007,
-0.0067183878,
0.0190795548,
0.0158912931,
-0.0046591759,
-0.0256316587,
-0.0073792837,
-0.0019801294,
0.0005519984,
0.0254101045,
-0.0628700256,
0.0067098709,
0.0413998477,
0.0132831242,
0.0203946736,
0.0000019239,
-0.0385147855,
-0.0070123444,
0.0196949299,
-0.0751077086,
0.0145007707,
0.0107451072,
-0.0217347424,
-0.0178557895,
0.00765337,
-0.0087109068,
-0.0600152686,
0.0086148605,
0.0706224516,
0.0436571315,
0.0992030948,
-0.0200515725,
-0.0209600125,
0.0016935921,
-0.0391607322,
0.028612772,
-0.0275564138,
0.0352575816,
0.0245511495,
-0.0072071496,
0.034731172,
0.0312371999,
0.0146453856,
0.0155117912,
-0.0217532218,
0.008375261,
0.0555066541,
-0.044127617,
-0.0173128583,
-0.0023112802,
0.0939720273,
0.0078450739,
-0.0192881022,
0.0341081917,
-0.0018313717,
-0.0084545249,
-0.0103217242,
-0.0404115096,
0.048820395,
-0.0385210477,
0.0280275904,
0.0569767542,
-0.0043734466,
0.030381754,
-0.0035745634,
0.0012705718,
0.0041718301,
0.0129568381,
-0.014837875,
0.0020738763,
0.0288462881,
0.0003093766,
-0.0669596419,
-0.0074249143,
0.0165814646,
-0.0209752731,
0.0127363596,
-0.0964592546,
-0.0395666212,
-0.0382191911,
-0.0677437037,
0.0378997624,
0.0119830118,
-0.0098986886,
0.0481916554,
-0.0489942059,
0.0281467345,
-0.0099452399,
0.0151206981,
-0.0249999445,
0.0003086519,
-0.0314412042,
0.0487520285,
-0.0293389242,
0.0595718361,
-0.085479632,
0.0032069676,
-0.0119608967,
0.0251022708,
0.0266760755,
0.0258102324,
0.00271263,
-0.0211821403,
-0.0586678535,
-0.0062967152,
0.0128283668,
-0.0326738581,
-0.028621804,
-0.0281569455,
0.0127847409,
-0.0376538523,
-0.0282237139,
0.0240138471,
0.0334526338,
-0.0055017425,
0.0247644261,
0.056493599,
-0.0370438471,
-0.0335414484,
-0.0927048549,
-0.0480411872,
0.0112513015,
-0.0615699217,
-0.0085741058,
-0.0514492057,
0.0543617941,
0.0201103799,
-0.0326686427,
-0.0354678482,
0.0483049601,
-0.0104664583,
-0.0584191792,
0.0472177379,
-0.0425795652,
0.0196622666,
-0.0129042985,
-0.0051744115,
0.007949885,
0.0634719208,
0.0738490224,
0.058929801,
0.0529655293,
0.019811932,
-0.0095210979,
0.0389830023,
0.0083814245,
-0.0042397967,
0.0007895553,
0.0145066883,
0.0065840981,
0.0100322822,
0.0717910007,
0.0323406793,
-0.029827904,
0.0429499894,
0.0550584197,
0.0158468299,
0.0046340153,
0.0384760089,
0.0536440648,
0.0172110572,
0.0013284354,
0.0056368108,
-0.0474130623,
-0.0052530575,
-0.0082870964,
0.0206770599,
0.0066414243,
0.0085360715,
-0.0147392508,
-0.0177710708,
-0.0023487154,
-0.012953341,
-0.0400733128,
0.0172254834,
0.0683726594,
0.0271593239,
-0.0574671924,
0.0533460528,
0.0427317396,
-0.071430929,
0.0469584167,
-0.0065200306,
0.0229191631,
0.0456259362,
0.0398399048,
-0.0217282735,
-0.0224312134,
0.0121000456,
0.0447873175,
0.0436251871,
0.0230460297,
-0.0513020307,
0.0344279073,
-0.0297147352,
-0.024553163,
0.0091155227,
-0.0054091597,
-0.0165667292,
0.0488497429,
-0.0309574362,
0.0392333604,
-0.0433273278,
-0.0613930821,
0.058531817,
-0.0415056385,
-0.0759220198,
0.0177805629,
-0.0084590632,
0.0072894162,
0.0222470723,
-0.0348598287,
0.0003045402,
0.0536445864,
-0.0600354001,
0.0043143695,
0.0073978398,
-0.0333980173,
-0.0475545041,
0.0024576471,
0.0104572345,
-0.0319578946,
0.0089831669,
-0.0450546518,
-0.0536515638,
-0.0457854755,
-0.0167292003,
-0.0055841669,
-0.0091183521,
0.0200028401,
0.0497595891,
-0.0285084918,
-0.0284786765,
0.0649032965,
0.0163491238,
-0.0143092629,
-0.0086075282,
0.0214043241,
-0.00024508,
-0.0304875709,
-0.0023963258,
0.025445262,
-0.003215658,
-0.0241165571,
0.0392961875,
0.0108608445,
-0.0540325902,
-0.0150355892,
-0.0712208375,
0.0207159314,
-0.0184734724,
0.0643843412,
0.0572828576,
0.011669076,
-0.0178958513,
-0.0113048004,
-0.0289201755,
-0.0351045392,
0.002723577,
-0.0018197739,
0.0417677946,
0.0498815812,
-0.0158108734,
-0.0521183163,
0.0119515546,
-0.0154721998,
0.0502434522,
0.0353233553,
-0.0391677506,
-0.0788328126,
0.059519276,
0.0186264515,
0.0534268953,
-0.0048478581,
-0.0327180699,
-0.0110845957,
-0.007111649,
0.0588002577,
0.0421293676,
-0.0057020299,
0.0392013378,
0.0225779805,
-0.0294986684,
-0.0400699824,
0.0135165239,
-0.0329594575,
0.0155528076,
-0.0348044224,
-0.0341337807,
0.0254159328,
0.0507782623,
0.0142301535,
0.0511149652,
-0.0290241316,
-0.0118263243,
-0.01060885,
-0.0199555513,
-0.0099559799,
-0.0145899858,
-0.0255788658,
0.0027113918,
-0.0471133776,
-0.0141645288,
0.0474898443,
-0.046804145,
-0.0197980329,
-0.0126064699,
0.0022690909,
-0.0539816022,
0.0872964188,
-0.011008271,
0.0285723452,
0.01254554,
-0.0324918739,
-0.0333631299,
0.014888674,
0.0201811977,
-0.0269765742,
0.0452884994,
-0.0765438527,
0.0196619183,
-0.0347540975,
-0.0371458232,
-0.0720872357,
-0.0494486205,
0.015967207,
-0.0099368664,
0.0165849905,
-0.0103252502,
-0.0166223459,
0.0128675383,
0.0130324392,
0.0732800066,
-0.0190190412,
-0.0149742113,
-0.0164950136,
0.0663244352,
0.0395924747,
-0.0214157738,
-0.017056914,
-0.0328266434,
0.0124268224,
0.0648819506,
0.0424453206,
0.0189620368,
-0.0001228472,
-0.0075988281,
0.0104998173,
-0.0340070091,
-0.0127230268,
0.005250297,
0.0649374053,
-0.0872535184,
-0.0344555564,
0.1158026308,
0.0140413539,
-0.0144514432,
0.0022343786,
0.0417055637,
0.027663352,
0.0144248251,
0.0187412743,
-0.0611928627,
-0.0223146491,
0.0068151909,
0.0430368595,
0.0028963555,
-0.0509116352,
-0.0070787924,
-0.104750216,
0.0435644835,
0.0248945821,
-0.0618617535,
-0.0736455321,
-0.0473529473,
0.0103513449,
-0.0112139191,
-0.0221821126,
0.0421386845,
-0.0412498005,
0.0107851699,
0.0281754062,
-0.0348100774,
-0.0783012956,
0.0108857835,
-0.0501974262,
0.0401834659,
0.0436506569,
0.0036277131,
0.0169614535,
0.045542907,
0.0385842882,
-0.0055974736,
-0.0157868043,
-0.0053708148,
0.0569172502,
-0.0180375241,
-0.0080446405,
-0.0056923549,
0.0658372119,
-0.0282109249,
-0.0167467128,
-0.0154200504,
0.044315841,
-0.0031583433,
0.0018353102,
0.0117327534,
-0.0378707163,
0.0362781435,
0.0853708312,
0.0248912517,
-0.02092053,
-0.0187857375,
0.0082005151,
0.0014620022,
-0.0867340416,
-0.0006888228,
0.039673645,
-0.0594251826,
-0.0298397765,
-0.0809514746,
-0.0769073516,
0.0449354537,
0.0353438929,
-0.0179027691,
0.0038148304,
0.0103363264,
0.0043550036,
-0.0550916567,
0.0469086356,
-0.054843206,
-0.0227301121,
-0.0547887497,
-0.047568839,
-0.0011377278,
0.0116876252,
-0.0063563343,
0.0431745164,
-0.0736236945,
-0.0315751582,
-0.0066240258,
0.0141199175,
0.0114590907,
0.0466604829,
0.024675617,
0.016970994,
0.0095819775,
0.0245334432,
-0.033922933,
0.0015473817,
0.0156310368,
-0.0147579517,
-0.0078372834,
0.0342066251,
-0.0426643193,
0.0336483791,
0.0069527803,
0.0564933047,
-0.0277850553,
-0.0384225883,
0.0289374236,
0.0464000329,
0.0430395566,
-0.0285661537,
-0.0081540933,
-0.0525182784,
-0.0049044695,
-0.039484933,
-0.0121835293,
-0.0622600615,
0.04269474,
0.0115872221,
-0.0031327519,
0.0110183954,
0.0344616361,
-0.0045018466,
0.0353671052,
-0.0671253279,
-0.0041118977,
-0.0148867266,
0.0136143938,
0.0381629057,
-0.0160605591,
-0.0316389278,
0.0026772926,
0.0234339889,
0.022796113,
-0.0538295358,
0.029524887,
0.0403819084,
-0.0198955685,
-0.0060054306,
0.0142814089,
-0.0152882971,
0.0282691903,
-0.0875756964,
0.0028989464,
0.0593262538,
-0.0043469365,
0.0664486811,
-0.051790487,
-0.0138350632,
-0.0138270855,
0.0506086163,
-0.0058705537,
-0.0029296572,
0.0162402261,
0.0129306996,
-0.0321465619,
-0.0048243026,
0.093507424,
0.0413459353,
0.0565450937,
0.0006355581,
-0.0107402885,
-0.0546704605,
-0.0232074726,
-0.012124869,
-0.0112319011,
-0.0307613295,
-0.0120457755,
-0.0548832268,
-0.01815404,
0.0171621405,
0.0175414998,
-0.0028156466,
-0.0134626143,
0.0328699164,
0.0472263396,
-0.0002748299,
-0.0135609731,
-0.0515574515,
0.0184218977,
0.0031733888,
-0.0587606765,
-0.0235952027,
-6.263901563e-33,
-0.0643595904,
-0.0487926975,
0.0321149044,
0.0218613632,
-0.0305074379,
0.0383771397,
-0.0666324943,
-0.0060967314,
0.0187795311,
0.0099034496,
-0.0037627204,
-0.0205475241,
0.0255394485,
0.0184592083,
0.0029102219,
-0.0027471939,
0.0729017779,
-0.0042308541,
-0.0317002051,
0.0420172922,
0.0443857946,
0.0304296575,
0.0461587533,
-0.1156356633,
0.0206302963,
-0.024056254,
0.0091053303,
0.0031089168,
0.0874930173,
0.0244913548,
-0.0052800034,
0.0074839811,
0.016463872,
-0.0525835678,
0.0003364274,
0.0168108735,
-0.1277510673,
0.0095118703,
-0.0027659549,
-0.0268687177,
-0.0406069681,
-0.0194915347,
0.0076026684,
-0.014060095,
0.0295847859,
-0.0070243911,
0.014963422,
-0.0300826151,
0.0014595818,
-0.0433431454,
-0.100157924,
0.0513894856,
0.0304256584,
-0.0245439149,
0.035678748,
0.0080220662,
0.0209447388,
-0.0141521925,
-0.0245330576,
-0.0148046017,
0.0020103133,
0.0479109585,
0.0402070023,
0.0590995587,
-0.011062149,
0.0585073791,
0.0143289892,
0.013138921,
-0.0131756645,
0.0202099159,
-0.0083682435,
0.0698069111,
-0.0089272726,
0.0472087376,
-0.0082121827,
0.0172599908,
-0.1058367118,
0.040333394,
0.0185043979,
-0.0002519679,
-0.0112366742,
-0.0012966184,
-0.0559045002,
0.0080787987,
-0.0209560134,
0.0196924899,
-0.0010910004,
0.000342921,
0.0269532632,
0.0313239321,
-0.0255228747,
0.0404214114,
0.0280907247,
0.009364184,
-0.0006138433,
0.0066093616,
-0.025575649,
0.0144331809,
-0.0319482721,
-0.0249979421,
-0.0739904568,
-0.0437725261,
0.0148690874,
-0.0088299504,
0.0327256136,
0.0283678062,
0.0279188305,
0.0249899905,
-0.0519746765,
0.0050331848,
-0.0542199537,
0.0248189177,
-0.0044011315,
0.0087348456,
0.0245595928,
-0.0053803618,
-0.0102775907,
0.0677768737,
0.0294412915,
0.0354054309,
-0.0019030841,
0.0033573795,
0.026507169,
0.0234123319,
0.0174011122,
0.0204764381,
-0.0408066511,
0.0285931397,
0.0244549476,
-0.0349372439,
0.0100761075,
0.0244394764,
2.606e-7,
0.0290475767,
0.0467596427,
0.0426572561,
0.0619960241,
-0.0076121325,
0.0399982929,
0.0142856212,
0.0062223743,
-0.0166950151,
-0.0276989061,
0.0064489208,
-0.0075493874,
0.0474865437,
0.0612640716,
-0.0695652664,
-0.0360658765,
-0.0459297225,
-0.0323318765,
-0.0648651272,
-0.0214710943,
0.044488471,
0.0616218671,
0.007617801,
0.0020663638,
-0.0069790762,
-0.0503048673,
0.0564650483,
-0.0071094828,
-0.0492197275,
0.0534765087,
0.0006723241,
0.0372291692,
-0.0574179217,
0.0238536522,
-0.040076375,
-0.004083063,
-0.0047443304,
0.0639652684,
-0.0125915324,
0.0083639501,
0.0057217376,
-0.0406939089,
0.011649901,
-0.0006925761,
0.0435614921,
-0.0478870459,
-0.0008871203,
0.0071610925,
-0.004349546,
0.0395840146,
-0.0897651911,
-0.0049608331,
-0.0167362429,
0.0308734905,
0.0327786505,
-0.0164511465,
-0.0348166861,
-0.0599876121,
-0.0021565824,
0.0485005006,
-0.009484739,
-0.0423805602,
-0.0141982203,
-0.0221899953,
-0.0189809836,
-0.054161232,
-0.0200772211,
2.766600112e-34,
-0.0150071923,
0.0067182574,
-0.0302369129,
0.0290723108,
0.0512030981,
-0.0117509039,
-0.0182374381,
0.000225096,
-0.02739821,
-0.0451703668,
-0.0109724067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05535v2 | Detecting Check-Worthy Claims in Political Debates, Speeches, and Interviews Using Audio Data | 2023-05-24T12:09:42 | 2024-01-17T19:39:42 | Petar Ivanov, Ivan Koychev, Momchil Hardalov, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Developing tools to automatically detect check-worthy claims in political
debates and speeches can greatly help moderators of debates, journalists, and
fact-checkers. While previous work on this problem has focused exclusively on
the text modality, here we explore the utility of the audio modality as an
additional input. We create a new multimodal dataset (text and audio in
English) containing 48 hours of speech from past political debates in the USA.
We then experimentally demonstrate that, in the case of multiple speakers,
adding the audio modality yields sizable improvements over using the text
modality alone; moreover, an audio-only model could outperform a text-only one
for a single speaker. With the aim to enable future research, we make all our
data and code publicly available at
https://github.com/petar-iv/audio-checkworthiness-detection. | [
-0.0012770045,
0.0916610584,
0.0014362659,
0.0491538756,
-0.0459747575,
-0.0173018686,
-0.0205012504,
0.0036704007,
-0.0336589031,
-0.047841724,
0.0153788617,
-0.0139674004,
0.0278789122,
0.0306475665,
0.030375002,
-0.0459343754,
0.0405702069,
-0.0026009956,
0.0870866552,
-0.0172165185,
0.0411765426,
0.0090528633,
-0.0852031857,
0.010353731,
-0.0809202567,
0.0006582326,
-0.0094566699,
0.0158725027,
0.0611462072,
0.0152920866,
-0.0202349816,
0.0450760573,
-0.0021499,
0.0414078832,
0.0000014644,
-0.0205323938,
0.0060449918,
0.0005340438,
0.0035338567,
0.0021773344,
0.0568386242,
0.0229229182,
-0.0321133435,
0.0304051954,
-0.0026532779,
0.006530981,
0.0351316184,
0.0521731749,
0.0637572929,
0.0743741021,
-0.0117399953,
0.0160847213,
0.0255577452,
0.0011036568,
-0.0218742602,
-0.0282214358,
0.0198469572,
-0.0011713577,
-0.0155335125,
0.0208882447,
0.0113645475,
0.0488969088,
0.0000698368,
-0.0175482333,
-0.0685012117,
-0.0131428605,
-0.0686185807,
-0.016770618,
-0.0219741501,
0.0373763181,
0.0564582385,
-0.0146388197,
0.0293322653,
-0.0028056602,
0.0036412515,
0.0315382071,
0.0093690986,
0.0547446869,
-0.0336376764,
-0.0195669811,
-0.0294196866,
0.0055980412,
0.0002098191,
0.0105671976,
0.0689327866,
0.0241895746,
-0.003497316,
-0.0400284864,
0.0208576359,
-0.0346096717,
0.0123562235,
-0.0485481396,
-0.0052470509,
-0.0049732067,
0.0073877629,
0.0075566368,
-0.0188388582,
-0.0053688716,
0.0498777367,
-0.0494606495,
-0.007932337,
-0.0114900144,
-0.0963884071,
0.0696332306,
0.0081914235,
0.0216419455,
-0.0115215862,
-0.0225506574,
0.0383155867,
-0.0367308371,
-0.0207843464,
0.0079434589,
-0.0208466277,
-0.0114884768,
-0.0423659645,
-0.0216273256,
-0.0226538051,
-0.0416229814,
-0.0523978025,
0.0559901632,
-0.0298459064,
-0.0002718166,
0.0140248546,
-0.0157051887,
-0.0276353341,
0.06071271,
-0.0259620436,
0.0660444349,
-0.0244866647,
-0.0435670316,
0.0104466146,
0.0646883249,
0.0400864966,
0.005721034,
0.0081354566,
-0.0011573331,
-0.0016149821,
0.0151856579,
0.0019421177,
-0.0414518081,
-0.0598456189,
-0.0771027431,
0.0159675051,
-0.0639072582,
0.0254467111,
-0.0453762375,
0.0010157572,
0.019968804,
0.0000486548,
0.0305600353,
0.016403161,
0.0361779146,
0.0518784374,
0.0345932432,
0.0397974327,
0.022128243,
0.0170720406,
0.0465219133,
0.0354155526,
-0.0030913344,
0.0607638583,
0.0049394304,
0.0217908639,
0.0329935551,
0.0331885442,
0.0224206802,
0.0250928644,
-0.0009920221,
-0.040869344,
0.0078204079,
-0.0072513665,
0.0436314121,
-0.0238892697,
-0.0637239367,
0.0720785335,
0.0339923128,
-0.0048891869,
-0.0462266542,
0.0051209969,
0.0019581201,
0.0501539186,
0.0263510551,
0.0050906963,
0.012757781,
-0.0399611257,
-0.0296548754,
0.0532335415,
0.0309207998,
-0.0048965053,
-0.0069717159,
-0.0011023858,
0.0016664915,
0.021426104,
0.0109272758,
-0.0282702167,
0.0058534243,
-0.0447691418,
0.0090121962,
0.0134920646,
-0.0730978325,
-0.0422712527,
-0.0416382477,
0.0325968899,
-0.0341389477,
0.0029928675,
-0.0081281569,
0.052816838,
-0.0551209562,
0.0637189597,
0.0640502572,
0.079605855,
-0.0336449444,
0.0086193839,
-0.0391002037,
-0.0127247125,
-0.0165289156,
0.0349292159,
0.0242095012,
0.0445149876,
0.0404985361,
-0.0125435516,
-0.015471207,
0.0253414083,
-0.0292725768,
0.0572764352,
0.0118172709,
-0.0097637391,
0.0146517698,
0.0360035561,
0.0246038847,
-0.0315040126,
-0.0269902274,
0.0279795006,
0.0038237551,
-0.0088600684,
0.0314976908,
-0.0031283402,
0.0234729201,
0.0246799812,
-0.0676368997,
-0.0401289687,
0.043867439,
-0.0179833248,
-0.0075160088,
0.008565289,
-0.0563150905,
-0.0241411217,
-0.0367631279,
-0.0155333718,
-0.0159468856,
0.0023135999,
0.0028678852,
0.0327564441,
0.0200818907,
-0.001970791,
-0.0103826057,
0.0217735935,
0.0534290411,
-0.0447876528,
-0.0308281947,
0.0155676734,
0.0010822847,
0.0495025888,
0.0218538232,
-0.0808407813,
-0.0289535448,
-0.0086128423,
-0.1017419696,
-0.0247042961,
-0.0089907367,
0.0236749444,
-0.000292755,
-0.054138191,
0.0087116938,
-0.0075992234,
-0.0322624296,
-0.0389290191,
0.0333831832,
0.0004853306,
0.0068529746,
-0.0255958308,
-0.0101053398,
0.0139513481,
0.0371550247,
-0.0359324738,
0.013897852,
0.0157331191,
-0.0422456972,
-0.0103660449,
-0.0194642581,
-0.0305149797,
0.0192104243,
-0.0161158536,
-0.0245790835,
-0.0038873146,
0.0408495367,
0.0205577984,
0.022011945,
0.0403019823,
-0.0002971751,
-0.0129595986,
-0.0028670642,
0.0048440797,
-0.0080363536,
0.0071054152,
0.0423700511,
-0.0024388379,
-0.0519002602,
0.0305811837,
0.0330979377,
0.0475262441,
0.0343751945,
0.0001884584,
0.0098889172,
0.0029775919,
-0.0068392358,
0.0325072892,
-0.018596679,
-0.0332725793,
0.0515196621,
-0.0271293353,
-0.0190826263,
0.051943507,
-0.0557374619,
0.0189696122,
-0.0184487067,
-0.0252152123,
-0.0226100609,
0.0473324507,
-0.0135612888,
0.0211541038,
0.0379302055,
-0.0106620463,
-0.0128406053,
-0.0609679967,
0.0878692269,
-0.0483249053,
0.0069860551,
-0.0214013886,
0.0251639225,
0.0080237463,
-0.0420174822,
-0.0203397516,
-0.0569573008,
-0.0307693779,
-0.0162900034,
-0.0553344749,
-0.0366117395,
-0.0770862848,
-0.0176038146,
0.0596829094,
0.0192596,
0.0071564182,
0.0322562344,
0.0232672747,
0.0750818551,
-0.0162638482,
0.041390568,
-0.0200776085,
-0.021094596,
-0.0461426601,
0.0612906143,
-0.0483878069,
0.0539481081,
-0.0344549716,
-0.0487598293,
-0.0205243025,
0.0326795466,
0.00572279,
-0.0136323068,
0.0380443372,
-0.0370052382,
0.0429136194,
0.0411803909,
0.0008624193,
0.0381650515,
-0.0248108041,
0.0137454951,
-0.0149735296,
0.0302368905,
-0.0069181821,
-0.1239088401,
-0.0347546823,
0.0032213742,
-0.0070728967,
-0.0308623221,
0.0249971524,
-0.0263276994,
-0.0651022717,
0.0677971467,
-0.0068620089,
0.0046703019,
-0.0427168272,
-0.0455754399,
0.0212930571,
-0.0256284233,
-0.0213389359,
0.0027188135,
0.01660043,
-0.0330368467,
0.0201348551,
-0.0542891324,
-0.0498337857,
0.0399773605,
-0.0055401009,
0.0323444046,
0.0283714924,
0.0575137399,
-0.0277645942,
-0.080298461,
-0.0138933929,
0.0299342573,
-0.0504170097,
0.0507995896,
0.0621748567,
-0.0212015286,
0.001745067,
-0.0061774547,
0.0208731014,
0.0823375955,
-0.0461440459,
0.0300620086,
0.0545495637,
0.0003902412,
-0.0150656095,
-0.029914055,
0.0749560073,
0.042969536,
0.0645932481,
0.0182325691,
0.0167689212,
-0.0125188874,
-0.0076345145,
-0.0271541271,
-0.0644387305,
-0.0543948077,
0.0352649055,
0.0252288412,
0.0032808532,
-0.0752340034,
0.0093921609,
-0.0602346435,
0.0078546442,
-0.0161733776,
-0.0312175974,
0.0330789797,
0.0217546094,
-0.0800889656,
0.0238385759,
-0.0306257326,
0.0552264452,
-0.0298689008,
-0.024586346,
0.0219725762,
-0.0321563445,
-0.0211292058,
0.0823943019,
-0.066703856,
-0.0216440242,
-0.0250211097,
-0.0312832333,
0.0211897083,
0.0332120396,
-0.0010932129,
-0.0200114194,
0.0197316948,
0.0404318422,
-0.0502606258,
0.0217412896,
0.049262017,
-0.0190154873,
-0.0058719106,
-0.0115458909,
0.0132612763,
0.0596421883,
-0.0100971628,
-0.0300449282,
-0.0455178283,
-0.0167629514,
-0.0046240399,
0.0145110432,
0.0371976309,
0.0277757477,
-0.0243121516,
-0.045987267,
-0.0051644244,
0.0025635653,
-0.0318986997,
0.002603685,
0.0388661176,
-0.0267889351,
-0.0390465818,
-0.0111793084,
0.0007142278,
-0.0375657678,
0.0386803634,
-0.0148209166,
0.0412363335,
0.0227658376,
-0.0125200832,
-0.0146837207,
-0.0207487531,
-0.0095970724,
0.0374059901,
-0.0045037488,
0.0414046384,
0.0422143787,
0.0403774343,
0.0105043491,
-0.0426789671,
0.0502771474,
-0.0253791492,
-0.0576381385,
0.0066053164,
-0.0207162108,
0.0136905154,
0.0098710302,
-0.0058584777,
0.0072564506,
-0.0017875133,
-0.0127627235,
-0.0008805831,
0.030983733,
-0.0301728435,
-0.017036207,
0.04055731,
0.0304761883,
-0.0217237528,
0.037501622,
0.012296279,
-0.0241712127,
0.0198679958,
0.0002451963,
-0.0167500507,
-0.0465329215,
-0.0646720156,
-0.0123960171,
0.0281986352,
0.0090086497,
-0.0175847076,
-0.0498959385,
-0.014628361,
0.0269426387,
0.048938036,
0.0344005488,
0.0376535654,
-0.0020750533,
0.0618341528,
-0.0043983115,
0.0268194173,
-0.0168235824,
-0.0272327736,
-0.0079842648,
0.0122493291,
0.0117977513,
-5.05285659e-33,
0.0046415725,
-0.068439506,
-0.0144859813,
-0.0040618265,
0.0191990901,
0.0469579324,
-0.0190898012,
0.0012615373,
-0.0044846092,
0.055601228,
0.0547371432,
0.0319994204,
0.0185609628,
-0.0108378083,
-0.0351121686,
0.0174819957,
0.0486595184,
0.0018234191,
-0.0338280722,
0.0039796229,
0.0477945656,
-0.0407583043,
0.0263298657,
-0.075958319,
0.0059087118,
0.0245994478,
-0.0779482797,
-0.0221291129,
-0.0442721099,
0.0611086823,
0.0054992968,
0.014399373,
-0.0001147361,
-0.015410603,
0.0094141578,
0.0760001317,
-0.0491269492,
0.0187556315,
0.0318496376,
0.0087483106,
-0.014109836,
0.0386308394,
0.0053374455,
-0.0246136822,
-0.0094075929,
-0.0065128789,
0.0339781418,
-0.0400879793,
0.0413212255,
-0.025412472,
-0.0388917886,
0.0507774986,
-0.0117259072,
-0.0250389241,
-0.0281917844,
0.0600056723,
0.0383424051,
-0.0100879939,
-0.0604771711,
0.0744863003,
-0.0340246484,
-0.0228275973,
0.0178070497,
-0.0560005009,
-0.055409845,
0.0599084906,
0.0305112395,
-0.0270394254,
-0.0198762305,
0.000538636,
-0.0151719553,
0.0456853956,
0.0690306351,
0.1288667321,
0.0195865985,
-0.0377423167,
-0.0503515266,
-0.0215951297,
0.042025093,
-0.0095242169,
0.0193661544,
-0.0278939828,
-0.022625627,
-0.0013815351,
-0.0591296144,
-0.0024838299,
-0.0429869071,
0.0253213737,
-0.0000153216,
0.0438569151,
0.0019965163,
0.0434595309,
0.0303446595,
-0.024609616,
0.0346663222,
0.0251117274,
-0.0536577553,
0.0293749273,
-0.0093345856,
-0.000157141,
-0.0263850745,
0.0276895724,
0.054209061,
0.0254627019,
0.0477533564,
-0.0330318175,
0.0365558043,
0.0222446993,
-0.0915557817,
0.021661045,
0.0128027536,
0.0328949802,
-0.0310982801,
0.0169383381,
0.0185706411,
0.0082220994,
-0.0101700211,
0.020560123,
-0.0458397083,
-0.0085076159,
-0.0441212021,
-0.0389113203,
-0.0379507653,
0.0445204861,
-0.0241679698,
-0.0112750297,
-0.018965289,
-0.0382919498,
0.0119983619,
-0.0473134667,
0.030283235,
-0.0083701843,
2.317e-7,
-0.0429256,
0.0278712362,
0.0103744296,
-0.0481511019,
0.0409895368,
0.0368529856,
-0.0130607011,
0.0041580293,
-0.0281393807,
-0.0752513111,
-0.0342635922,
-0.0087611862,
0.069053255,
0.068419449,
-0.0750589818,
-0.0568574145,
-0.0536248423,
-0.0337830521,
-0.0437088422,
0.0190621056,
0.0217828825,
0.0434582159,
0.0435137264,
-0.0263083801,
0.0045560976,
-0.0137594985,
0.0545281731,
0.0438843928,
-0.0511556454,
-0.0262057167,
0.0362961888,
-0.0560595989,
-0.0013392455,
0.0593842156,
-0.0263888333,
0.0096311076,
-0.0089957835,
0.0772990659,
0.0457250588,
-0.0542990528,
-0.0706821829,
0.0318197161,
-0.038862288,
0.0255729761,
0.0320056714,
-0.0000752504,
-0.0531171225,
-0.0929205492,
-0.0497803502,
0.0059144804,
0.0394776277,
0.0023460831,
-0.0202943478,
-0.0216693319,
0.0010443503,
-0.0019385169,
-0.0215190537,
-0.0381029099,
0.0164296981,
0.0231901966,
-0.052696079,
-0.0636381581,
0.0327563025,
-0.0595908239,
0.0328545459,
-0.1156565771,
-0.0055920226,
1.616707661e-34,
0.0392784551,
0.0051328936,
-0.0049399785,
-0.0658864677,
0.0547061265,
0.0228257123,
-0.0116236117,
-0.0476097427,
0.0121627823,
0.0057283402,
-0.0112662474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15087v1 | Pento-DIARef: A Diagnostic Dataset for Learning the Incremental Algorithm for Referring Expression Generation from Examples | 2023-05-24T12:05:53 | 2023-05-24T12:05:53 | Philipp Sadler, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | NLP tasks are typically defined extensionally through datasets containing
example instantiations (e.g., pairs of image i and text t), but motivated
intensionally through capabilities invoked in verbal descriptions of the task
(e.g., "t is a description of i, for which the content of i needs to be
recognised and understood"). We present Pento-DIARef, a diagnostic dataset in a
visual domain of puzzle pieces where referring expressions are generated by a
well-known symbolic algorithm (the "Incremental Algorithm"), which itself is
motivated by appeal to a hypothesised capability (eliminating distractors
through application of Gricean maxims). Our question then is whether the
extensional description (the dataset) is sufficient for a neural model to pick
up the underlying regularity and exhibit this capability given the simple task
definition of producing expressions from visual inputs. We find that a model
supported by a vision detection step and a targeted data generation scheme
achieves an almost perfect BLEU@1 score and sentence accuracy, whereas simpler
baselines do not. | [
0.0527949631,
0.043614924,
-0.0361756831,
0.012070274,
-0.0449835956,
0.0134564014,
-0.0057568289,
0.0157030951,
-0.063877292,
-0.0664331466,
0.0205323286,
0.0032495449,
-0.0055307662,
0.0846091434,
0.0665986091,
-0.0406175666,
0.049706772,
-0.0217396077,
0.0084017562,
0.0286609326,
-0.0091330241,
-0.0303294566,
-0.014275277,
0.0374648124,
-0.0671585351,
0.0029918016,
-0.0153670413,
-0.01240528,
-0.0170723032,
-0.0510200374,
-0.0736033767,
0.0244681649,
0.0101711052,
-0.0034072699,
0.0000019249,
-0.0329193287,
0.0060403822,
-0.0251553617,
-0.0126397442,
-0.057978265,
0.0013224923,
-0.0226686783,
0.0149694066,
-0.0144720413,
-0.0572614037,
-0.018512927,
0.0868178681,
0.0341465734,
0.0824481547,
0.0720613301,
-0.018600475,
-0.0114648268,
0.0279394519,
-0.0181595199,
0.0838724524,
-0.0295084007,
0.0058810492,
0.0125428233,
0.0174310207,
-0.0032017515,
-0.0068977061,
0.0157712139,
0.029261088,
-0.0027831639,
0.0285689235,
0.0168893766,
-0.0075737825,
-0.0004066132,
-0.0109163923,
0.0806903988,
0.0106416559,
-0.0229627993,
-0.032465525,
0.0113266623,
0.015645422,
0.0073399344,
-0.0573667251,
0.0400387086,
-0.0078238957,
0.0002150929,
0.0024140025,
-0.0262998641,
0.0097119696,
0.0054094396,
0.0349902213,
0.0197275113,
-0.0092591895,
-0.0292791147,
0.018715376,
-0.0002092813,
-0.0594324805,
-0.0558287166,
-0.0104856985,
0.0383001827,
-0.0125871645,
0.0305606741,
-0.0467460379,
-0.0469039604,
-0.033491116,
-0.0116185592,
0.0555800945,
0.0328919254,
0.0113738934,
0.0074892445,
-0.0237014014,
0.0794811621,
-0.0305919256,
0.0456345342,
-0.053314928,
0.0294066053,
-0.0409428999,
-0.0211698711,
-0.09045472,
0.0697853863,
0.0094348565,
-0.0501312204,
-0.0234507266,
0.0337885506,
-0.0437460206,
-0.0046371883,
-0.0221640021,
0.0103398534,
-0.0464832634,
0.0331383049,
-0.0681724995,
-0.0298683848,
-0.0366540141,
0.0273851398,
-0.00447552,
-0.0494142845,
-0.040651191,
0.0213002712,
0.0264536198,
-0.0400567241,
-0.0222993009,
0.0863063335,
-0.0191295445,
-0.0175058395,
-0.005437104,
-0.048316054,
-0.0062141954,
-0.0684623495,
0.0740678385,
-0.048440814,
-0.0086864242,
-0.0267039668,
-0.0138738565,
-0.0799237564,
0.0197999366,
0.0372059792,
-0.0233867373,
0.0622212216,
-0.0379316434,
-0.0188327711,
-0.0682346374,
-0.0080353199,
-0.0105390325,
0.0630144551,
0.0407432914,
0.0122329853,
-0.0053781616,
0.0137253981,
0.0369657613,
0.0196667314,
0.0423654877,
0.0056114187,
-0.0697842389,
-0.0245686099,
0.0371213704,
0.0525881462,
0.0155210262,
0.0516184717,
-0.0446982868,
-0.0075878971,
0.025514029,
0.0070352666,
-0.0296219885,
-0.0159483608,
0.0844169632,
-0.0259415377,
0.0008536202,
0.0625481606,
-0.061957635,
0.052349776,
0.010138277,
0.0084777642,
-0.0122487908,
-0.0223739278,
-0.0145408083,
-0.0465249307,
0.0038348825,
0.0259393938,
-0.004814662,
-0.0250992421,
0.0421977937,
0.0946747661,
-0.0395369977,
0.0400054902,
0.0031656639,
-0.0349871404,
0.0028393052,
-0.0634839386,
0.0249510929,
0.0047893804,
0.0495184101,
-0.0164859239,
0.0089557758,
-0.0103588123,
-0.0044714971,
0.0506147929,
-0.0090507129,
0.0152995978,
0.0223215166,
0.0030830589,
-0.0422344282,
-0.0573111549,
0.0111321853,
-0.0037492942,
-0.0359676555,
-0.0407449715,
-0.0123470994,
-0.0634706691,
-0.0010730152,
0.0800699219,
0.0222970936,
-0.0336932465,
0.0101783993,
0.0271067582,
0.0123744085,
-0.0113568837,
8.314e-7,
0.0451688655,
0.0213271026,
-0.0246671606,
0.0056400942,
0.0490444563,
-0.0286517311,
-0.049851615,
0.0263368487,
-0.0902029946,
-0.0104934545,
-0.0179504883,
-0.0313884914,
-0.0502270311,
0.0793986619,
-0.0938865021,
-0.0035777001,
-0.0132250059,
0.0140357213,
0.018865468,
0.0030465317,
-0.0094712302,
0.0854374915,
-0.001619291,
0.0161201041,
0.0138705531,
0.0097934315,
-0.0021518013,
-0.0536204241,
0.0228954833,
-0.0201177001,
-0.0033996324,
-0.0028056246,
-0.0071105044,
0.0304720588,
-0.0450707152,
-0.0180925205,
-0.0000635138,
-0.0246941634,
-0.0016183613,
-0.0067315898,
0.0221178327,
-0.0183792766,
0.0305762459,
-0.0382427946,
-0.0004747688,
0.0451994538,
0.0101708602,
0.0254960973,
0.0678583458,
0.0516413972,
-0.0537471846,
-0.0343216732,
-0.0226718858,
-0.0191003196,
0.0535607859,
0.0587828308,
-0.0070591047,
-0.031696979,
0.0712389648,
-0.0158578195,
0.01936212,
-0.0056249602,
-0.0003581679,
0.0437272415,
-0.0263234992,
0.0004745998,
0.0453808829,
-0.0310162045,
0.0292801969,
0.013431875,
-0.015489324,
-0.0248167329,
0.012337924,
-0.022526525,
-0.0262843594,
0.0114936987,
-0.0517194904,
0.0160863679,
0.0307326391,
-0.001259994,
-0.0111873979,
-0.0447173305,
0.1091251597,
0.0449671485,
-0.0428290963,
-0.0574497283,
-0.0125612263,
-0.0226945318,
0.036786411,
-0.0370224044,
-0.0477155782,
0.0212976392,
-0.0079446109,
0.0327429995,
-0.0009379599,
0.0323465951,
-0.0233498644,
0.0849074945,
0.0567260496,
0.0036015324,
0.0400124341,
-0.0204235837,
-0.0596506298,
0.0367257744,
0.0038448945,
0.0309070665,
0.0581915602,
-0.0616986081,
0.033240851,
0.008930726,
-0.03657398,
-0.0635874346,
0.0289250892,
0.0068080337,
0.0070966473,
-0.0162663218,
0.0208895653,
-0.069988817,
0.0233751889,
0.0259000491,
0.0161013585,
-0.0143574011,
-0.022402091,
-0.0500561222,
0.0077443742,
0.0532254837,
0.0538525283,
0.0185289811,
-0.0116065023,
-0.0284593701,
0.0300988387,
0.0382146053,
0.0247297548,
-0.0311920661,
0.0373471677,
-0.0364167131,
-0.0140795829,
-0.0144537184,
0.0333262868,
-0.0098600844,
-0.0521649942,
-0.0602057725,
0.0187762938,
0.0162863769,
-0.0375132523,
0.0001294587,
0.0070600072,
0.0126634305,
0.0674575418,
0.0099880276,
-0.0971362814,
-0.0311799701,
0.0124170696,
-0.0262584891,
-0.0294606723,
-0.0478939451,
-0.0340497643,
-0.1239888445,
0.0329305641,
-0.0089332713,
-0.0527898259,
-0.0154781817,
-0.0018966376,
0.0103551066,
0.0130185373,
-0.0182170309,
0.0054149181,
-0.0300952028,
0.0368205719,
0.006911058,
0.0139114568,
-0.0214373246,
-0.0552931763,
-0.0283860266,
-0.0051922007,
0.0300665889,
0.0305461492,
-0.0121181691,
-0.0193584859,
0.0439793505,
-0.0169854853,
0.0284498148,
-0.0127262101,
0.0833989903,
0.0189698189,
-0.0244638585,
0.0263801217,
-0.00459518,
-0.0390834957,
-0.0485756546,
0.0008532691,
0.0377986506,
-0.0069091949,
0.0064083664,
-0.0322017334,
0.0134470444,
-0.0119361728,
0.024135543,
0.0613836125,
-0.0167554151,
-0.0175584462,
-0.0064807534,
0.0259098187,
-0.0647143349,
0.0101936636,
0.0172898453,
-0.0046170279,
0.0100216055,
-0.0973860025,
-0.0132762855,
0.0057313731,
0.0949471295,
0.0134208724,
-0.0239988938,
-0.0438410901,
-0.0139400382,
-0.0360074267,
0.0289942473,
-0.0131755024,
-0.003851613,
-0.0338977426,
-0.0122933043,
-0.0276522581,
-0.0421338156,
-0.0357349068,
0.0286914892,
-0.026572058,
-0.0024008199,
-0.0153006883,
0.095735319,
0.0257728714,
-0.0247434806,
0.0161744971,
0.008394273,
-0.0350952297,
0.0082826996,
0.0148791326,
0.0271817204,
-0.0266912207,
-0.0213231184,
-0.0016294811,
0.029117655,
-0.0024969685,
0.0118700592,
0.0370784588,
0.0578741357,
0.0160882138,
0.0280247796,
0.0719274431,
0.0003953989,
0.0273697432,
-0.0018573045,
0.0209753104,
-0.0312707052,
0.0037901679,
0.0029217564,
-0.024881117,
-0.0686993897,
0.0275981892,
-0.0276970901,
0.0631481409,
0.0117231896,
-0.0410751328,
-0.0030953654,
0.0514479987,
0.0053048404,
-0.0380251333,
0.054899551,
0.0073143905,
-0.0397892669,
0.0262525771,
0.0033828132,
0.0433975421,
-0.0263349358,
0.0434377044,
-0.0078340713,
0.0392490514,
0.0505082719,
0.0022921606,
-0.0323984921,
-0.0097030597,
-0.0173170567,
-0.0111573348,
-0.0110939723,
-0.0232137404,
0.0464545153,
0.0445596054,
0.0339957438,
-0.0246913135,
-0.0053490358,
0.0174568631,
0.021286957,
-0.0140346102,
-0.0629845858,
0.0309519805,
0.0338585041,
0.0256113503,
-0.0357449986,
0.0420171805,
-0.0201309472,
0.0414508805,
-0.0243731309,
0.0205330905,
-0.0277181678,
-0.0155378692,
0.0128753595,
0.0301473625,
0.0550187305,
0.0498375967,
-0.0339451209,
-0.066863507,
0.0258063916,
0.0222489219,
0.0199681837,
0.0229335576,
0.0868227184,
0.0322326683,
0.0189106073,
-0.0452547744,
-0.0053516133,
-0.0045012552,
-0.0132372808,
-0.0052725496,
-0.0453278981,
-5.752839231e-33,
-0.0770110488,
-0.0551565029,
0.0303882696,
0.0079977242,
-0.0173107218,
-0.0034569758,
-0.0520780645,
0.0039594583,
0.015408962,
0.0215060133,
0.0068069077,
0.0056012189,
-0.0033913304,
0.0023015563,
-0.0008552889,
-0.0312521383,
0.0122132832,
-0.0138598969,
-0.034000136,
0.007523614,
0.0627550334,
-0.0128066363,
0.0894600227,
-0.0708716884,
-0.0068886192,
0.0523189567,
-0.0483150855,
0.0298514515,
-0.006955442,
0.0666402429,
0.0102761816,
0.0125609925,
0.0334698297,
0.0082474966,
-0.0141649479,
-0.0099440636,
-0.052901797,
-0.0369628519,
0.0253904331,
0.033446759,
-0.0598729476,
-0.0371600576,
0.0594042279,
-0.0476240069,
-0.0481407084,
-0.0021441302,
0.0527321137,
-0.049464833,
-0.0146535086,
0.012906488,
-0.0835925043,
-0.0242711324,
0.0064944853,
0.0159038529,
-0.0150682218,
0.0243271254,
-0.0321199335,
-0.0933468789,
-0.0147617599,
0.0274087619,
0.0198211074,
0.0254937354,
-0.0057435655,
0.0046350476,
0.0391789377,
0.0580868125,
0.1025640517,
-0.049037721,
0.0238734819,
-0.0347499289,
0.0288624503,
0.0515069179,
0.0456453003,
0.0222290885,
0.0649134815,
0.0279827043,
-0.0219444837,
-0.0277095791,
0.024581233,
0.0785614103,
0.0091369338,
-0.0357054099,
0.0081898496,
0.0000714904,
-0.046282012,
0.0297255181,
-0.0551677719,
-0.0393676274,
0.0459663123,
0.0248047654,
0.0317577012,
0.0021812504,
0.0253952388,
-0.020174874,
-0.0117449304,
-0.0017140387,
-0.0111344038,
0.0643415675,
0.0061520422,
-0.0424001887,
-0.0251605008,
-0.0602229498,
0.0422092229,
0.0063547511,
0.0459727272,
-0.0019571453,
0.0360732526,
0.025175171,
-0.0398049578,
-0.011196916,
-0.0484750606,
0.0274239313,
-0.0005455683,
-0.0446444936,
0.0433047302,
-0.0044016042,
-0.0286874548,
0.0149626462,
-0.0068640332,
-0.0386791527,
-0.0314455442,
0.0187488012,
-0.0171825327,
0.0387131087,
-0.0270300694,
-0.0312491003,
-0.0139865279,
-0.0156712439,
0.0085500591,
-0.0772586241,
-0.0105815008,
0.0426547416,
2.851e-7,
0.0220967848,
0.0290937889,
0.0166460834,
0.0366608948,
0.0229977667,
-0.0025626267,
-0.0371919312,
-0.0203015283,
-0.0001336349,
-0.0045950483,
0.0166807361,
0.0259636603,
-0.0194465201,
-0.0162552111,
-0.0457553566,
0.0427783243,
-0.0093466649,
-0.0201824903,
-0.0088971136,
0.0184687618,
0.0380073339,
0.0752521753,
-0.0214465354,
-0.0128890341,
-0.0142660337,
-0.0822784752,
0.0701665506,
-0.0016191141,
0.0224007107,
-0.0081932824,
0.0000154696,
-0.0004611009,
-0.0183627494,
0.0426725633,
0.02852148,
0.0246344972,
0.0555725694,
-0.0039905496,
-0.0182462838,
0.0124491369,
-0.0093004899,
0.0047579734,
0.0266654324,
0.0108929016,
0.051849436,
-0.0838693082,
-0.0424479991,
0.0097220307,
-0.0333398394,
0.014157515,
0.0098378565,
-0.006784271,
-0.0255835969,
0.0087283943,
0.05013429,
0.0278829634,
-0.0305907857,
-0.0358447358,
-0.006940593,
0.0204729419,
-0.0437521227,
-0.003764411,
-0.058096692,
0.0125537599,
-0.0023345503,
-0.030105764,
-0.0465567857,
2.500682397e-34,
0.0438159741,
-0.0224444866,
0.0344585516,
0.0097274184,
0.0301925186,
-0.016324088,
-0.0129879331,
0.0348921455,
0.0224818215,
-0.0428226069,
-0.020449549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15083v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15083v4 | Eliciting the Translation Ability of Large Language Models via Multilingual Finetuning with Translation Instructions | 2023-05-24T12:00:24 | 2024-04-15T06:02:59 | Jiahuan Li, Hao Zhou, Shujian Huang, Shanbo Cheng, Jiajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale Pretrained Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT4, have
shown strong abilities in multilingual translations, without being explicitly
trained on parallel corpora. It is interesting how the LLMs obtain their
ability to carry out translation instructions for different languages. In this
paper, we present a detailed analysis by finetuning a multilingual pretrained
language model, XGLM-7B, to perform multilingual translation following given
instructions. Firstly, we show that multilingual LLMs have stronger translation
abilities than previously demonstrated. For a certain language, the performance
depends on its similarity to English and the amount of data used in the
pretraining phase. Secondly, we find that LLMs' ability to carry out
translation instructions relies on the understanding of translation
instructions and the alignment among different languages. With multilingual
finetuning, LLMs could learn to perform the translation task well even for
those language pairs unseen during the instruction tuning phase. | [
0.0186967216,
0.0071887053,
0.0036295319,
0.0536196753,
-0.0499060489,
0.0480228625,
0.0398413017,
-0.0164645165,
-0.014346255,
-0.0159710962,
-0.0886968076,
-0.0543379746,
0.0100456253,
-0.0596059114,
0.0327852778,
-0.0186195448,
0.0509534664,
-0.0281011965,
-0.0389375687,
-0.0118606007,
0.0123785306,
0.0394565351,
0.0304352287,
0.0042801057,
0.0204010867,
-0.0173834711,
0.0143505028,
0.038527295,
0.0357054099,
-0.0044427062,
-0.0141633451,
0.0202780757,
0.0079461727,
0.0648742095,
0.0000020107,
-0.0278180838,
-0.038652543,
0.0155359814,
0.0352855735,
0.024016384,
0.0348435491,
-0.0688493252,
-0.0074667297,
0.0201927479,
-0.0339286774,
-0.0146995503,
0.0695388019,
0.0080484785,
0.0546769015,
0.0953170508,
-0.0179140903,
-0.0693328604,
-0.0141598536,
-0.0715428665,
-0.0273165796,
-0.0849565715,
-0.0016758976,
0.0198428165,
-0.0378360562,
0.032636296,
-0.0202074852,
0.063531585,
0.0060673566,
0.0301250853,
-0.0695162788,
-0.0123788752,
-0.0121763097,
-0.0403353609,
-0.0218279567,
0.0703154728,
-0.0721117109,
-0.0272321254,
-0.0176398307,
-0.0121835554,
-0.0115985796,
-0.0157013163,
-0.0346185826,
0.0177708194,
0.0011088293,
0.0288633537,
0.0350636952,
0.0084832935,
0.0492011532,
-0.0090312026,
-0.0534954444,
0.0139982654,
0.0398738645,
-0.029140519,
0.0114203952,
0.0128301252,
-0.0165931769,
-0.0054075294,
0.0143655734,
0.0139367832,
-0.0376778431,
0.0248176884,
-0.0441820845,
-0.0307731628,
0.0278141648,
-0.0671013519,
0.0555783473,
0.0727165565,
-0.0202119146,
0.0598090403,
-0.041230686,
0.0567155108,
-0.0478286594,
0.0430090912,
-0.0921850652,
-0.0270208102,
-0.0290217996,
0.0306909587,
-0.0520924143,
-0.0253851097,
-0.0461984947,
-0.0068008499,
-0.0189129394,
0.0164201632,
0.0216198862,
0.0184223969,
0.0245282855,
-0.0644531995,
-0.0742474794,
-0.0536949337,
0.0275947899,
0.0498150438,
-0.0217364822,
-0.0154437795,
-0.0198976751,
-0.0588828735,
-0.0137575362,
0.0184222311,
-0.0228217319,
-0.051616881,
0.0209932942,
0.0623144358,
-0.0328934155,
-0.0227518305,
-0.035433311,
0.0057362476,
0.0079114884,
-0.0867890045,
-0.0082558785,
-0.0465495028,
0.0715557486,
0.0368682072,
0.0467891768,
-0.002612676,
-0.0100255786,
-0.0276318043,
-0.0490802936,
0.075486578,
0.0096694361,
0.0094339522,
0.011790026,
-0.0284825135,
0.0130346017,
0.1030997112,
0.015564872,
0.0164939649,
0.037358664,
-0.0136156539,
-0.0254947077,
0.0764747784,
0.0030559695,
0.0449205786,
-0.0031285312,
0.0175880939,
0.0470824055,
0.0437310785,
0.0101117929,
0.0351994932,
-0.0214624088,
0.0241158307,
0.0441071615,
0.0286815166,
0.0182196852,
0.0504293777,
0.0649244785,
-0.0192075055,
-0.0072676279,
0.0368909203,
-0.0387777984,
0.0049918853,
0.0013923986,
0.006819054,
0.0317936242,
0.0742989257,
-0.0335264653,
0.0043802792,
0.0068947538,
-0.0322381072,
0.0202495996,
-0.005457859,
0.0344390757,
0.0041279192,
-0.0563533939,
0.0302557461,
0.0367264263,
-0.0339249261,
0.0077015399,
-0.0348349102,
-0.0385291167,
0.0490952693,
0.0153358094,
0.0041493163,
-0.0631334186,
-0.0022717691,
0.0337832645,
0.032232672,
0.1147055775,
0.0226838905,
0.0276817456,
-0.0558288172,
-0.0059466679,
-0.0135906031,
-0.0016118095,
0.061020866,
0.00712841,
0.0412822515,
0.0233859979,
-0.004057236,
-0.0585903935,
0.0327838957,
-0.047236573,
-0.00531743,
0.0020974998,
0.0109260017,
0.007160021,
-0.0176346973,
-0.0125004388,
-0.0087793432,
-0.0055656368,
-0.0251708496,
0.0109862303,
0.0305269696,
-0.0202258807,
-0.036984358,
0.0419907756,
-0.0008713135,
-0.0090775462,
-0.0093460958,
-0.0667016581,
-0.0490698852,
-0.0146621084,
0.0209475607,
0.0398760326,
-0.0382024236,
0.0330455787,
-0.0043629976,
0.0002480636,
-0.0276841465,
0.0106046628,
0.0318009332,
0.013828842,
-0.0061940411,
0.0116568236,
0.0394595563,
-0.0047271862,
-0.0281355716,
0.0472909026,
0.0325201787,
0.0374725461,
0.0300839078,
0.0390495025,
-0.0230399203,
-0.0394862592,
-0.0889734626,
0.0374933258,
-0.033446312,
0.0346401855,
0.0480281077,
0.0295767821,
-0.0003238806,
-0.0238913801,
-0.0264426153,
0.0221464112,
0.0250180904,
0.0163836647,
-0.0197918881,
0.0015401153,
-0.00208612,
-0.0159594957,
0.0027294448,
0.0400527865,
0.0255051143,
0.0232221521,
-0.0142019168,
-0.0741376951,
0.016503457,
-0.0448081121,
0.006398723,
0.007282679,
-0.0980840921,
-0.0036730429,
-0.0248958059,
0.0358275436,
0.051200185,
-0.0092745461,
0.0072781313,
0.0301764868,
-0.0036640184,
-0.0313761085,
0.0201289691,
-0.0268578064,
-0.0739544854,
-0.0747752786,
-0.0075745597,
-0.0073820865,
0.0488476269,
-0.0070600868,
-0.0171111636,
-0.0826920941,
-0.024069,
-0.01183159,
0.0038492878,
-0.0049896929,
0.0443063825,
0.0004974263,
0.0305035654,
-0.0236940552,
-0.0522089638,
0.0379288234,
-0.0580577515,
-0.0156044308,
-0.0544517934,
0.0073384978,
-0.0214612149,
0.055360835,
-0.0087294644,
0.0500054471,
-0.0465447903,
0.0075630271,
-0.0366765149,
0.0172922183,
0.0158835966,
-0.0180233456,
-0.0003628794,
-0.0390824862,
0.0015960638,
-0.0234783404,
-0.0160345342,
-0.0009396788,
-0.0336110145,
-0.0115970513,
-0.0053302455,
0.0418078005,
-0.0127776051,
-0.0402111188,
0.031388212,
0.0207519326,
0.0550226495,
-0.0338291302,
0.0239099134,
-0.0240401309,
-0.0135677801,
0.0206674263,
0.0001066425,
-0.012849723,
-0.0674720779,
-0.0012946362,
-0.020174928,
-0.0220467672,
-0.0417325348,
-0.0326386057,
-0.0222302023,
0.0426454097,
-0.0257763304,
-0.0419942699,
-0.0376565084,
0.0631800666,
-0.0304313693,
-0.0018537039,
0.1020829603,
0.0074442672,
-0.0414280146,
-0.0215101801,
0.0181176923,
-0.0013256711,
0.0086621735,
0.0363562889,
-0.0958356038,
-0.0293496121,
-0.0031896972,
-0.0136647653,
0.0539972782,
0.0329848751,
-0.0469446778,
-0.0818964839,
-0.00049204,
0.0494272225,
-0.0823456943,
-0.0455538034,
0.0123279374,
-0.0215832591,
-0.0232823491,
0.0436665565,
-0.013985849,
0.0102829468,
-0.0010459962,
-0.0008207874,
0.0319500342,
-0.0517203994,
0.0128984274,
-0.0501725934,
0.0309311338,
0.0728437006,
0.0412121527,
-0.0028712398,
-0.0296795424,
0.0475313701,
-0.001100915,
-0.008075309,
0.0013617516,
0.0019548654,
0.000772549,
-0.0407040417,
0.0510206483,
-0.0046229754,
-0.0239350125,
0.035949301,
0.0140965274,
0.0344638638,
-0.0220777616,
0.0074214931,
0.065096803,
-0.021685876,
0.0095938956,
0.0449459404,
0.0025570116,
-0.0323778614,
-0.0173771288,
-0.0226244461,
-0.0091175446,
-0.0603974462,
0.010886671,
0.0093696434,
-0.0577082299,
-0.013706875,
-0.0564188138,
-0.0451906249,
0.0229619499,
0.0340249911,
0.0330963098,
-0.0036281138,
0.0075809429,
0.0123544615,
0.0227007642,
0.0271628946,
-0.0470943935,
0.0172809344,
-0.067939803,
-0.0364667699,
0.0525515787,
-0.03168175,
0.0132373953,
0.0269109271,
-0.0623943731,
-0.0753656328,
-0.0253528412,
0.0534088984,
0.016275486,
0.0544247292,
-0.0500229187,
-0.0237441491,
-0.0067547471,
0.0099162674,
-0.0476854816,
0.0167498961,
0.0412857719,
0.0022781214,
-0.0169446524,
0.0601035841,
-0.0027956965,
0.0367643796,
0.0038029242,
0.0459079817,
-0.0096932538,
-0.0830890164,
0.0067496025,
0.0403881483,
0.023271028,
-0.0561889075,
0.0064994637,
-0.0225092638,
0.0214253198,
-0.0081437416,
-0.0197765939,
-0.0418942831,
-0.0219044462,
0.0632789209,
-0.0266965404,
0.0136816837,
-0.0245091673,
0.0046512815,
-0.0243382994,
-0.0107705938,
-0.0125715379,
-0.027621964,
-0.0002638098,
0.0395690575,
0.0343005657,
-0.0147514297,
0.0234348532,
-0.002378793,
0.0058670128,
-0.0543811843,
0.0419564135,
0.0192985889,
0.028003823,
-0.0185617041,
0.039938923,
-0.0136215528,
-0.0606125034,
-0.0143635198,
0.0204264317,
0.1040597335,
0.0043686982,
0.1104726791,
-0.0068400358,
-0.0415889509,
-0.0116431499,
0.0578868762,
0.0078586498,
0.0078503387,
-0.0135115255,
-0.0243614987,
-0.0316647626,
0.0182916466,
0.0678380057,
-0.0365845114,
0.0226958934,
0.0259985272,
-0.0148599967,
-0.011289577,
-0.0288337786,
0.005075865,
-0.0094400002,
-0.0101340553,
-0.0047263061,
0.0016460611,
-0.0455758534,
-0.0227181166,
0.0229539219,
-0.0416397713,
0.002064585,
-0.0003890842,
0.0960451365,
-0.0278973766,
0.0220767092,
-0.0393672325,
-0.0166783724,
0.0263369828,
-0.001258874,
0.008227854,
-6.117254235e-33,
-0.0436844565,
0.0342931189,
0.0150487535,
-0.0164601021,
-0.0312358029,
-0.0388784334,
-0.0152124362,
-0.0170756951,
-0.0051741796,
0.009217212,
0.0058737169,
-0.015998764,
0.0291149467,
0.0034570601,
0.0070933672,
0.0066762976,
0.0590536073,
-0.0161834899,
-0.0154383155,
0.0474749468,
0.0417828076,
0.0359947272,
0.0998937339,
-0.0281342119,
0.0255428124,
-0.0430772938,
-0.0354154781,
0.0177797135,
-0.0107398322,
0.0290041063,
-0.0033163063,
-0.0140356151,
0.0070302943,
-0.0377513319,
-0.0209756922,
-0.0267201196,
-0.0706288666,
-0.0049057254,
0.0563967153,
0.0476831533,
-0.0118521983,
-0.0304732341,
0.0165866874,
-0.0442239344,
0.0039163157,
-0.0126781436,
-0.0110595189,
-0.0388879925,
-0.0092390059,
0.0137193063,
-0.0837802663,
0.0072811088,
0.0179203171,
-0.0201440752,
0.0512326621,
0.0135037871,
-0.024927007,
0.0087143388,
-0.0204917602,
0.0074420022,
-0.0009294286,
0.0334443264,
0.0541600958,
0.0284286588,
0.003912176,
-0.0081039211,
-0.0008746586,
-0.013748453,
0.0418674536,
0.0282444321,
0.040754687,
0.0018218445,
0.0189475287,
0.0482900441,
0.0218354464,
-0.0196160357,
-0.0633563325,
0.0192897376,
-0.0094135068,
-0.0172300227,
0.0304553285,
0.0004091402,
0.0275226347,
-0.0128449919,
-0.0376925208,
-0.0063962289,
-0.0147082126,
-0.0399653912,
0.017119728,
0.0069027864,
-0.0035081245,
0.0190930143,
0.0852483064,
-0.0256062746,
-0.0145389307,
0.00911023,
-0.0406168252,
-0.0145935649,
-0.0389345512,
0.0715606958,
-0.0151952002,
-0.0906577855,
-0.0040286393,
-0.0198151767,
-0.0002332933,
-0.0197953004,
0.0653548241,
0.026110677,
-0.0633053258,
0.0341028199,
-0.0360566303,
-0.0107775284,
-0.0105166091,
0.0300381593,
0.0143935811,
0.0047389343,
-0.0037745184,
0.0470142961,
0.0421643518,
-0.0184140913,
-0.0277912766,
-0.0250503458,
0.0070093591,
0.0294926818,
-0.0557317324,
0.0308666155,
-0.0389202237,
-0.0069144401,
0.0264401753,
-0.0342367627,
-0.0220954008,
0.0079184566,
2.717e-7,
0.061966341,
0.0279748347,
-0.012601655,
0.0288933255,
-0.0016025166,
0.0088004963,
-0.0624258667,
0.0219186116,
0.0224304385,
0.0228707492,
0.0482928641,
0.0378788486,
0.0757745355,
0.0275024399,
-0.0454170071,
0.0010716595,
-0.035949301,
0.0421500131,
-0.0638976619,
0.0060164039,
-0.0027752696,
0.1117667928,
0.0019023324,
0.0184636842,
-0.0033887161,
-0.0435834154,
0.0837870538,
-0.0361636654,
-0.0369213149,
0.0280030984,
0.0095208557,
0.0474141687,
-0.0625136346,
-0.0034806752,
-0.0117985252,
0.0114701921,
0.0242943075,
0.0969199762,
0.0042143282,
0.0116770742,
0.0271359961,
-0.0211087838,
-0.0267619938,
-0.045771312,
0.0574924834,
-0.0662613586,
0.0149964858,
-0.0060661468,
0.0227310546,
0.0153692439,
0.0362523012,
-0.0522514097,
-0.0223047268,
0.0430195928,
0.0623105951,
-0.0059404452,
-0.0263445359,
-0.0414888412,
-0.0222959984,
0.0216101874,
-0.0150623517,
-0.052505143,
0.0037057379,
0.0007714243,
0.001630449,
-0.0506637171,
0.0244034603,
2.275332554e-34,
0.051088769,
-0.0290848278,
0.0219402704,
-0.0135459499,
0.0354172029,
-0.0316414647,
-0.0283619445,
0.0259160232,
-0.0263391975,
-0.0528599285,
-0.0141619947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15080v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15080v2 | Visually-Situated Natural Language Understanding with Contrastive Reading Model and Frozen Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:59:13 | 2023-10-26T12:51:07 | Geewook Kim, Hodong Lee, Daehee Kim, Haeji Jung, Sanghee Park, Yoonsik Kim, Sangdoo Yun, Taeho Kil, Bado Lee, Seunghyun Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have stimulated a surge of
research aimed at extending their applications to the visual domain. While
these models exhibit promise in generating abstract image captions and
facilitating natural conversations, their performance on text-rich images still
requires improvement. In this paper, we introduce Contrastive Reading Model
(Cream), a novel neural architecture designed to enhance the language-image
understanding capability of LLMs by capturing intricate details that are often
overlooked in existing methods. Cream combines vision and auxiliary encoders,
fortified by a contrastive feature alignment technique, to achieve a more
effective comprehension of language information in visually situated contexts
within the images. Our approach bridges the gap between vision and language
understanding, paving the way for the development of more sophisticated
Document Intelligence Assistants. Through rigorous evaluations across diverse
visually-situated language understanding tasks that demand reasoning
capabilities, we demonstrate the compelling performance of Cream, positioning
it as a prominent model in the field of visual document understanding. We
provide our codebase and newly-generated datasets at
https://github.com/naver-ai/cream . | [
0.0331566855,
0.0536048077,
0.0054445183,
0.0834819674,
-0.0276701171,
0.0208935235,
0.0130756591,
-0.028957475,
0.0172641333,
-0.0334476344,
-0.0441198312,
-0.03078923,
0.0353939384,
0.0665338561,
0.0206796266,
-0.0764570385,
-0.0040459228,
-0.0392451994,
0.0029693311,
0.0059732818,
0.0344325826,
0.0119789587,
-0.0138697736,
0.0117648542,
0.0183577351,
-0.0645795986,
-0.0189136751,
0.0246571396,
0.0272302162,
-0.0239690617,
-0.0092142224,
0.0356638245,
0.0622415878,
0.0297700614,
0.0000017428,
0.0009390757,
0.0169218201,
0.0012509067,
0.0068916935,
-0.0169485025,
0.0597191527,
-0.0853757411,
0.0107664512,
-0.0322744623,
-0.0194932837,
-0.0077153598,
0.0616989173,
0.0693306699,
0.0428309515,
0.0549602769,
-0.0302613117,
-0.0533934794,
0.0200154204,
-0.0207267646,
0.0085484646,
-0.0601770952,
-0.0063523003,
0.038032718,
-0.0048716152,
0.0238068253,
-0.0531480126,
0.0508488119,
0.0429904386,
-0.0324438848,
0.0150348879,
0.0569817983,
0.0076875738,
-0.0322786197,
-0.028568184,
0.0976196751,
-0.024357792,
0.0196880642,
-0.0354499146,
-0.0083325915,
-0.0104822302,
-0.0100654708,
-0.0397195928,
0.0005300985,
-0.0095093679,
0.0229281597,
0.0003158962,
0.02139947,
0.0091737406,
0.0273728203,
0.0039915885,
-0.0020555686,
0.0032062421,
-0.0076228012,
-0.0116827898,
0.0420497209,
-0.0418639481,
-0.0006276125,
0.0354046375,
0.0322215892,
0.0128906062,
0.0104929507,
-0.0195107181,
-0.0456173569,
0.0086720465,
-0.03686966,
0.0317658447,
0.0144121572,
-0.0978782028,
0.0974169299,
-0.0218885597,
0.0714028329,
-0.0424644686,
0.0098726768,
-0.0218302477,
-0.0217208732,
0.0207603127,
-0.0200321339,
-0.0094920797,
-0.0227716919,
-0.0909754932,
-0.0834216774,
0.0086607495,
0.0268796589,
0.0134815071,
0.0441040769,
0.0219538044,
0.0195431765,
-0.0427935906,
-0.0389817543,
-0.010910484,
0.0335506313,
-0.0118010296,
0.0120185576,
-0.0551288016,
-0.033430513,
-0.0112682721,
0.0474154763,
0.0237525105,
-0.0223884303,
-0.028650729,
0.0614829734,
-0.0390242413,
-0.0540484339,
-0.0216856319,
0.0297674537,
-0.021612756,
-0.0395527706,
0.0255621523,
-0.0377542898,
0.0321133956,
0.0009619321,
-0.0079614138,
-0.0552851185,
-0.0168127362,
0.0087853232,
-0.0415853746,
0.1258547157,
-0.0199115518,
-0.0219490882,
0.0319795944,
0.0186869241,
0.0014603096,
0.0434807464,
0.0275028106,
0.0408434495,
0.0116443448,
-0.0073705669,
0.0170792174,
0.0396933593,
-0.0256932173,
-0.0329921842,
-0.032114923,
0.0085040145,
-0.0423510559,
0.0175283737,
0.060933575,
0.0404782668,
-0.0210365672,
-0.034865655,
0.0828403682,
0.061313726,
0.0010592351,
0.0344258398,
0.0014357313,
0.0359274931,
-0.022735009,
0.0035032118,
-0.0474753603,
0.0689670146,
0.0167532526,
0.0312642641,
0.0051285825,
0.0236747526,
-0.0250654761,
-0.0307927839,
0.0043987404,
0.0098055443,
-0.0065637245,
0.0183408838,
0.0547160544,
-0.0048309676,
-0.0625380576,
-0.0083958507,
0.0092914598,
-0.0158761293,
-0.02164221,
0.001343183,
0.0273143593,
0.1094377711,
0.0312677063,
-0.003604793,
-0.0117688403,
0.0251028705,
0.0047666882,
0.0876091197,
-0.0045240941,
0.026213279,
0.0254098717,
-0.070387274,
-0.04790828,
-0.0353383161,
-0.0033392741,
0.0143739805,
0.0030451526,
0.0184262134,
0.0206592474,
-0.0131710647,
-0.0430052429,
0.027082555,
-0.0032062109,
-0.0318033434,
-0.0496284403,
0.0361625776,
-0.0152929155,
0.0096176062,
-0.0156403147,
-0.0237225499,
-0.0141218659,
-0.0460691787,
0.0343626179,
0.0373119935,
-0.045023866,
-0.0549271032,
0.0217143111,
-0.0639291182,
-0.040536765,
0.0301395264,
-0.0594414361,
-0.028542554,
0.0041624098,
-0.0396717452,
-0.0213877223,
-0.0511395521,
-0.0097371945,
0.0329054743,
0.0396596305,
-0.0048996685,
0.0478022471,
-0.0223592445,
-0.0237388592,
0.0118509354,
0.0118838195,
-0.0126073789,
-0.0255409889,
-0.008049055,
0.0029482828,
0.0229349453,
0.0062265671,
-0.0121451821,
0.0409404486,
-0.0460671335,
-0.0242781844,
-0.0698046088,
-0.0300377682,
-0.0355172269,
-0.0108231977,
0.0240872987,
-0.0106960433,
0.0105422959,
-0.0370616019,
-0.0366527997,
-0.0112060644,
-0.0098015703,
-0.0100916335,
0.0554335229,
0.0029738294,
-0.0029292009,
-0.035091456,
0.0016431611,
0.0311355218,
0.0681604967,
0.0378978699,
-0.0099451998,
-0.0622339733,
0.0301638041,
0.0186812673,
0.0255835075,
-0.0188665073,
-0.0145013807,
0.0095356349,
-0.0212221984,
0.0118742967,
0.1109568253,
0.0006627662,
0.0571283139,
-0.0094054053,
-0.0155438622,
-0.0327554792,
0.0028734694,
0.0049353335,
0.0061223456,
-0.0055592693,
-0.0467498526,
-0.0667982548,
0.0639508963,
-0.0299908035,
0.0333438404,
-0.0476974882,
0.0209687855,
0.0037922761,
-0.0260721743,
-0.066882953,
0.0122566279,
0.0145656364,
0.0240420904,
-0.0912400037,
-0.0492630191,
0.0575190261,
-0.0533797964,
-0.029670069,
-0.0151928877,
-0.0165304579,
-0.0369969942,
0.0563620143,
0.019198861,
0.0047110789,
-0.0530139841,
-0.0476899147,
-0.0302158464,
-0.0202625617,
-0.0206564963,
-0.0050027124,
0.0557890758,
-0.0474958159,
0.0146899233,
-0.0266631264,
-0.0375174657,
-0.0320628397,
-0.016778646,
-0.0567893647,
0.0019055986,
-0.013909529,
-0.026687704,
-0.0303591248,
0.0299347825,
0.0219206885,
0.0814267248,
-0.003861658,
-0.0021904591,
-0.03819675,
0.0696425214,
0.0706911758,
0.0202830695,
-0.0100937067,
-0.0459264442,
0.0488744155,
0.0500191674,
0.0003159559,
-0.0299311969,
-0.0667318106,
0.0280135963,
0.0217492655,
0.0198379271,
0.0355048403,
-0.0100307595,
0.0275108591,
-0.0923835561,
-0.0256528333,
0.0926082283,
0.002356186,
-0.058386974,
-0.0477233902,
-0.0215741135,
0.0291153695,
0.0121265957,
0.0218572952,
-0.0499321371,
-0.0511034168,
-0.0117985215,
-0.0189360194,
0.0521561764,
0.0270487405,
-0.0252020583,
-0.0568097904,
0.0568989478,
0.01274163,
-0.0002809681,
-0.0637847036,
0.0394106545,
-0.0078254808,
0.0011828115,
0.0402756743,
0.0057415986,
0.0055598156,
-0.0292104818,
-0.0101454845,
0.0410760045,
-0.0276151132,
0.0037522707,
-0.0212657861,
-0.0253773499,
0.0416707732,
0.0403162725,
-0.0048093884,
-0.0419084728,
0.0382341705,
-0.019227935,
0.032028541,
0.0143527817,
0.0805056095,
-0.0232301299,
-0.0342533924,
0.0033042347,
0.0363068283,
-0.0374251641,
-0.0185431093,
-0.0421140343,
-0.0082176477,
-0.015040054,
-0.0115011083,
-0.0208638795,
0.0049526254,
-0.0008698018,
0.046765931,
0.0379866958,
-0.0207607169,
-0.0522219501,
-0.0238693878,
0.0046957866,
-0.051905863,
-0.0128567135,
0.0065346528,
0.0183858052,
0.0004680551,
-0.0318023786,
-0.0518098921,
0.0243449006,
-0.0020464819,
-0.0026139705,
-0.0185613055,
0.0182307139,
-0.011536479,
-0.0653583705,
0.0897422582,
-0.0293253548,
0.011549918,
-0.0310823992,
0.0080614947,
0.03371007,
-0.0512739085,
-0.0513502955,
0.01432826,
-0.0699417815,
-0.0285866279,
-0.0225396678,
0.0378445089,
0.0135995103,
0.0671707019,
-0.0044922936,
-0.0459598787,
0.0278812572,
0.0142393867,
-0.0049093631,
-0.014067444,
-0.0104168756,
-0.024787087,
0.0077459314,
0.0121478764,
-0.0232948698,
0.0155563857,
0.0171518438,
0.0105567798,
-0.0348621793,
-0.0288407225,
-0.0292592123,
-0.0331193469,
0.0356883705,
0.011167869,
0.0442167222,
-0.0503874011,
0.0336754471,
0.0045648501,
0.007890976,
-0.0612805746,
-0.0004342009,
0.0114523759,
0.0274798367,
-0.0190838911,
0.0247868728,
0.0200840961,
0.0087331645,
-0.0098229926,
0.0159779377,
0.0356206298,
0.0028681611,
-0.0178574417,
0.0014977651,
-0.0315334573,
0.047388345,
-0.0477620549,
0.0556829423,
0.014372332,
0.0772738159,
0.0388679318,
-0.0360019207,
-0.0301671717,
0.0396464244,
-0.0265778638,
-0.0425674208,
-0.0360987,
0.0400638506,
0.0513376929,
-0.0321598314,
0.0246245302,
-0.0121356184,
-0.0180772748,
0.0061382749,
0.0382985584,
-0.0031495222,
-0.0585669838,
0.0426428095,
0.0279655792,
0.0320165232,
-0.0064065843,
0.0395528339,
0.0115438364,
-0.0033720208,
-0.0026168476,
-0.0063740937,
-0.0376614109,
-0.0152299432,
0.0260762908,
-0.0354356579,
-0.0097586541,
0.0630947053,
-0.0063361567,
-0.0691743642,
0.0312311277,
0.0120825926,
-0.0098467451,
0.0343945846,
0.0169515498,
0.0279777683,
-0.0018361189,
-0.0391788147,
-0.0116383303,
0.0152303735,
-0.0287411194,
-0.0168441162,
-0.0214571878,
-5.940181806e-33,
-0.0271856878,
-0.0686888322,
0.0244501811,
-0.0105670011,
-0.0086151678,
0.0253464226,
-0.0438882671,
-0.0360126905,
-0.0167530961,
0.0261474792,
0.0118679907,
0.0317051336,
0.0249617528,
0.0704209581,
-0.0365720466,
-0.0059567913,
0.038045112,
-0.0024370877,
0.027473582,
0.0011934546,
-0.000383469,
0.0362058841,
0.0407504216,
-0.0663570687,
0.0110768583,
0.0120694116,
0.0011038216,
0.0409128368,
0.0344727524,
0.0308170058,
-0.0492130257,
-0.006093137,
0.0262252577,
-0.0069889557,
-0.0052805184,
0.0674773902,
-0.0935217664,
0.0149796912,
0.0084273377,
0.072728239,
-0.0766359568,
-0.0133827096,
0.0443288982,
-0.0316627249,
0.0181137919,
-0.0484612547,
0.0621677451,
-0.0346429907,
-0.002225328,
0.0129829738,
-0.0502154306,
0.0245669596,
-0.034212362,
-0.0059624002,
0.0704194903,
0.0090670986,
0.0344053619,
0.0625007004,
-0.0727058873,
-0.0330041535,
0.0043320665,
0.0095610376,
0.0750050545,
0.0465672389,
-0.0084330551,
0.04347663,
-0.0085137188,
-0.0289157443,
-0.0349868946,
-0.009505935,
0.0123896571,
0.0421704277,
0.0360409357,
0.042340301,
0.0272406545,
0.0531134941,
-0.0280547366,
0.0084501421,
-0.0649618953,
0.0485089347,
0.0337331444,
-0.0063973595,
-0.0306738038,
0.0215301793,
-0.0307353083,
-0.0303126089,
-0.0730537549,
0.0085999267,
0.0351307541,
0.0078691877,
0.0029857478,
0.026840901,
0.0489041284,
-0.0391657278,
0.0083902543,
0.0459673516,
-0.0078029037,
0.0469886512,
-0.0128651876,
0.0215032473,
-0.0218871757,
-0.0261791665,
0.0074972254,
0.0286598857,
-0.0017884391,
0.0013049729,
0.051208768,
-0.015518127,
-0.0389862061,
-0.0006333942,
-0.0373850837,
0.0083578806,
-0.0096033569,
0.0298777297,
0.0196094699,
-0.0012188563,
-0.0646928772,
0.0568001978,
-0.0054743332,
0.0255440529,
-0.0278630126,
-0.0250424724,
-0.0069654137,
0.0494712107,
-0.0215599835,
0.0188467689,
-0.0078599602,
-0.0128929541,
0.033393506,
-0.0613310337,
0.0073517379,
0.0427370258,
2.325e-7,
0.0248804092,
0.026200695,
0.0374854468,
0.0289699789,
0.0178608,
0.0425291397,
-0.0196951553,
0.0214433298,
0.0178418495,
-0.0387559198,
0.0234141406,
0.0708381236,
0.0549672171,
-0.0285517368,
-0.0525766201,
0.0210015401,
-0.0434504524,
0.0036675429,
-0.0388489626,
0.0094541209,
0.0610910207,
0.089255929,
-0.0402632914,
-0.0349956602,
0.0364241488,
-0.0877778605,
0.0741392821,
-0.0214267317,
0.0318800844,
-0.0167217702,
0.009876756,
0.0223297011,
-0.016607089,
0.0114019029,
0.0382226929,
0.0142857376,
0.0455673076,
0.0518414415,
0.0010929073,
-0.016292654,
-0.0329430476,
0.0319045633,
-0.0205425341,
-0.0645404458,
0.048470065,
-0.0634909421,
-0.0300241262,
-0.0251298808,
-0.0568804629,
-0.0190469716,
0.0143806711,
-0.0115729487,
0.0040677446,
0.0254711304,
0.0462626293,
-0.0620906875,
-0.0103789074,
-0.0873930231,
-0.040270377,
0.0035792557,
-0.0099463165,
0.019520741,
-0.0463639796,
-0.0101225469,
0.0493347868,
-0.0116034783,
-0.0338537693,
1.561240858e-34,
0.0346858688,
-0.0047507007,
-0.0073785777,
0.0595864467,
0.0330426246,
-0.0072201015,
-0.0185003001,
-0.021001514,
0.0089137414,
-0.0852732807,
-0.0059589106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15077v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15077v2 | Contrastive Learning of Sentence Embeddings from Scratch | 2023-05-24T11:56:21 | 2023-10-24T09:56:46 | Junlei Zhang, Zhenzhong Lan, Junxian He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contrastive learning has been the dominant approach to train state-of-the-art
sentence embeddings. Previous studies have typically learned sentence
embeddings either through the use of human-annotated natural language inference
(NLI) data or via large-scale unlabeled sentences in an unsupervised manner.
However, even in the case of unlabeled data, their acquisition presents
challenges in certain domains due to various reasons. To address these issues,
we present SynCSE, a contrastive learning framework that trains sentence
embeddings with synthesized data. Specifically, we explore utilizing large
language models to synthesize the required data samples for contrastive
learning, including (1) producing positive and negative annotations given
unlabeled sentences (SynCSE-partial), and (2) generating sentences along with
their corresponding annotations from scratch (SynCSE-scratch). Experimental
results on sentence similarity and reranking tasks indicate that both
SynCSE-partial and SynCSE-scratch greatly outperform unsupervised baselines,
and SynCSE-partial even achieves comparable performance to the supervised
models in most settings. | [
0.0083976295,
0.0619273372,
-0.0069554611,
0.04144191,
-0.0525811762,
0.0302024782,
-0.0082698269,
-0.0566619746,
0.0358993411,
-0.0411548801,
-0.0037505068,
-0.0292427167,
-0.0419716127,
0.001668788,
0.0401083007,
-0.0352899991,
0.0194734819,
0.0217495002,
0.0119293882,
0.0039198096,
0.0249518249,
0.0210220758,
0.0011091176,
0.0228077564,
-0.0047921618,
-0.0212759506,
0.0009383925,
0.0021840539,
0.0520727932,
-0.0280042551,
0.0574990436,
0.0277766902,
0.0481089428,
0.0087424172,
0.0000014966,
-0.0310461354,
0.0112633798,
-0.0351883024,
0.0008778081,
-0.0037389544,
0.0657462776,
-0.0439144298,
0.0166654922,
0.0296012573,
-0.0421633944,
-0.0370286554,
0.020141203,
0.0528939776,
0.074883379,
0.0709012449,
-0.01396609,
-0.0516315475,
-0.0103431474,
-0.034628652,
-0.060821116,
0.0153757427,
0.014474445,
0.0023061624,
-0.0060878186,
0.0501136035,
-0.0163202621,
0.017496787,
0.0495846532,
0.0102253687,
0.0266743135,
0.0314043425,
-0.0434223264,
0.0249047186,
-0.0212417711,
0.1141973808,
-0.0012743821,
-0.0161554869,
-0.0023150272,
-0.0296667758,
-0.0049460586,
-0.0140655059,
-0.019424649,
0.0190744214,
0.0397561863,
0.0857632309,
0.0381971039,
0.0204825401,
0.0305406041,
-0.0036449975,
0.0029119384,
-0.0018383595,
0.033304207,
-0.0612085089,
0.0211027488,
0.0326012932,
-0.0382755473,
-0.0056893327,
-0.0111962361,
-0.0299170353,
-0.0208887644,
-0.008992712,
-0.0367085822,
-0.0628929436,
0.0113363778,
-0.0293859821,
0.0200974829,
0.0198552031,
-0.0064690635,
0.0398079455,
-0.0261991974,
0.0242644288,
-0.0141730728,
-0.0092456099,
-0.0712176561,
-0.0268966984,
-0.0122141605,
0.015560138,
-0.0038016953,
0.0359878317,
-0.0530815832,
-0.0474170893,
-0.0264094025,
-0.0043297876,
-0.0264403522,
0.0222408399,
0.0158282276,
0.033916764,
-0.0114727039,
0.0110204704,
0.0164025668,
-0.0036169514,
-0.0446892604,
0.0258594863,
-0.0196605343,
-0.0190299768,
-0.020002488,
0.0142753646,
0.0191003662,
-0.0312447157,
0.0124537172,
0.0308296289,
-0.0083690882,
-0.0394910313,
-0.0226194244,
0.0141546037,
-0.0199316852,
-0.0331897326,
-0.006968698,
-0.0553757958,
0.0418743677,
0.0167976692,
-0.0128371371,
-0.0164184161,
0.023611119,
0.0277647115,
-0.0238774773,
0.0660925508,
0.0035913431,
-0.0390030779,
-0.0640893281,
-0.0129850954,
0.0349932015,
0.0593152978,
0.012660508,
0.0014630753,
0.0188792404,
0.0488019511,
-0.0239802636,
0.0087541081,
0.0082245087,
0.0015507636,
-0.0047863461,
0.0208621081,
0.0163854808,
0.0273376703,
0.0377547182,
0.0450684018,
-0.0115316855,
-0.0415035896,
0.0458422527,
0.0358145535,
0.0191909466,
0.0289737657,
0.0497243069,
0.0355272591,
-0.0454231426,
0.0047644749,
-0.013269823,
0.0158503372,
0.033740297,
0.015860023,
0.0476659983,
0.0209700391,
-0.040516831,
-0.0049648248,
-0.0054164748,
-0.0496027693,
0.0066877785,
-0.0289427731,
0.0466239378,
0.0396283381,
-0.0304544643,
0.0087390579,
0.0560191721,
-0.0731034279,
-0.036576461,
0.0508322529,
0.0159903578,
0.0680317283,
0.0324107297,
-0.013310818,
-0.0074571306,
-0.0246209148,
0.0076667694,
0.0651880428,
0.0343591608,
-0.0211793464,
0.0235459618,
-0.0572407804,
-0.0237458181,
-0.0623602085,
0.020551974,
0.0025972403,
0.0045082057,
-0.0128673306,
0.0281248782,
-0.0214632004,
-0.0245276224,
0.0306743495,
-0.0488840491,
-0.0230542105,
0.0350144953,
0.030394977,
0.0042541157,
0.0166569185,
-0.0162528567,
0.0157561861,
0.0484817438,
-0.0696126744,
-0.0342360623,
0.0095007345,
-0.0493915007,
-0.1065851972,
0.0148866549,
-0.0590985008,
-0.0247508921,
0.0991520807,
-0.0791967437,
-0.0134798056,
0.0239380393,
-0.0416474342,
0.0187512245,
-0.0335508659,
-0.030201165,
0.0444359295,
0.0241081323,
-0.0117482301,
0.0639177561,
-0.0348420069,
0.0274036303,
0.0085242232,
-0.0070206784,
0.0063723414,
-0.0214133356,
-0.0325364806,
-0.0507964715,
0.0337139443,
-0.0024219197,
0.0103558786,
0.0001083037,
-0.0483967178,
0.0178475361,
-0.0868085995,
0.023200307,
-0.012910434,
0.0131258648,
0.0479967929,
0.0034217122,
0.0226122811,
-0.0275096223,
-0.0385809727,
-0.0162356235,
0.0087820133,
0.0092916926,
0.0669913366,
-0.0233981647,
-0.0056111021,
-0.0487505235,
-0.0098614981,
-0.0388577022,
0.0718787983,
-0.0444914661,
0.0184288826,
-0.0236101691,
0.0437052511,
-0.0152360378,
0.0268408395,
0.0108940136,
-0.0375150554,
-0.0080938153,
-0.0027073151,
0.0474680513,
0.0599996448,
0.0226265267,
0.0114116138,
0.0333335958,
0.0160103459,
-0.0221744869,
0.0086973533,
-0.0491145849,
0.0596135408,
-0.0033836151,
-0.0293077212,
-0.025162369,
0.0775734633,
0.0109164892,
-0.0108861197,
-0.0422196053,
0.0292713959,
0.0307171773,
0.012860206,
-0.007088677,
0.0249827988,
-0.0135428943,
-0.020441331,
-0.0462750979,
-0.0211915392,
0.053184852,
-0.0168427136,
-0.0056575476,
-0.0580973774,
-0.0299027693,
-0.014362609,
0.0275753401,
0.0113932248,
-0.0028004013,
-0.007032495,
0.038220983,
-0.0266376473,
-0.0180571843,
0.0283269063,
-0.0043099928,
-0.0037650692,
-0.0151839517,
-0.0013985792,
-0.0201576781,
-0.0897788405,
-0.0585412122,
-0.0775560662,
-0.0282956641,
0.0315151252,
0.0218960475,
0.0005706263,
0.0020971189,
-0.0430325456,
-0.0022685365,
0.0240406282,
0.0031062649,
0.0085791992,
-0.0407949276,
0.0918873399,
0.0806532055,
-0.0158102233,
0.0273550432,
-0.0092038792,
0.0432922542,
0.0488930717,
0.0351438299,
0.0244847648,
-0.0632007867,
-0.0101617649,
0.0019950261,
-0.0214791391,
0.0044041714,
-0.0026151752,
0.0218522716,
0.0010135919,
-0.0404668376,
0.1049070284,
0.0244344417,
-0.010426918,
0.002496528,
0.0118506299,
0.020188855,
0.0335521661,
-0.0106450999,
-0.073566936,
-0.056416072,
-0.0155117624,
-0.0015538199,
0.0089304978,
-0.019523235,
-0.0141062904,
-0.1418449879,
0.0023549364,
0.0019142083,
-0.0090148132,
-0.0178955048,
-0.0148111247,
0.003955638,
-0.0215278659,
-0.0160080735,
0.0153303556,
-0.0138963293,
0.0281011481,
0.0071707098,
-0.0237439722,
-0.0429124385,
0.010057156,
-0.0670202449,
0.0408592038,
0.0198930968,
0.0339541808,
0.0120228222,
-0.0271875933,
0.0145320706,
-0.0715115517,
-0.0345272347,
0.0032114461,
0.0583921857,
-0.0506122932,
-0.0143400328,
-0.0427455865,
0.0466694683,
-0.0477409549,
-0.0314855091,
-0.0021289466,
0.0686404929,
0.0275970213,
0.0034654266,
-0.0284478832,
0.0235223435,
0.0135775981,
0.0719039142,
0.0378552079,
-0.0562168434,
-0.0367929153,
0.0079144789,
0.0175054427,
-0.0676713958,
0.0116119413,
-0.0156832244,
0.0315284394,
0.0449182689,
-0.0640067309,
-0.0830336586,
-0.0050775521,
-0.0171786509,
-0.0017495499,
-0.010220509,
-0.0357597731,
-0.0211265124,
-0.0582318455,
0.0206690282,
-0.017604975,
0.0206240397,
0.0285351016,
-0.0156892873,
0.0256504677,
-0.0151439346,
-0.0532385893,
-0.0171571951,
-0.0745144114,
-0.0609362535,
-0.0241807308,
0.06237543,
0.0006691435,
0.0324793905,
-0.0056371475,
0.0260691866,
0.0183617938,
0.0664892793,
-0.0407165028,
0.0033810115,
0.0491587445,
0.0186390523,
0.046132382,
0.0577420183,
-0.0442931838,
0.0105520459,
0.038599398,
0.0585005246,
0.0012741976,
-0.0321179107,
-0.0020083259,
-0.0212204717,
0.0863744318,
-0.0032014414,
-0.0053251255,
-0.0404318422,
0.0101360725,
-0.0301456004,
-0.0383344069,
-0.052067332,
0.0245389976,
0.0063770567,
0.0527001917,
-0.0393512435,
0.0267591774,
-0.0232403707,
0.027320087,
-0.0340302065,
-0.021832021,
0.0486907847,
-0.0006967899,
-0.0158825833,
-0.0074182125,
-0.0485176407,
0.0038436835,
-0.0204055682,
0.0131588615,
-0.0162603594,
0.0150071019,
0.0237819739,
-0.0300666988,
-0.0418395214,
0.0417268164,
-0.0642075911,
0.0410256535,
-0.0460057706,
-0.0170339961,
0.0745295882,
-0.0469247289,
0.0336354002,
-0.0251969248,
-0.0099607967,
0.0038666325,
0.0525431223,
-0.0412239209,
-0.0147659862,
0.0104802344,
0.0051818215,
-0.028529983,
0.0221747793,
0.0664967746,
-0.0106506292,
0.0351544656,
0.0052490886,
-0.0144983614,
-0.039912384,
-0.0061283545,
0.030014446,
0.0500591509,
0.011235184,
0.0173661485,
-0.0278301481,
-0.0620538592,
0.0408674702,
0.0378774405,
-0.0270438828,
0.0147668356,
0.0381942652,
0.0180754494,
-0.0045045153,
-0.0323782153,
-0.0258324128,
0.0350229666,
-0.0091111986,
-0.0539498329,
-0.0537431389,
-5.509549736e-33,
0.0159976762,
0.0171509143,
-0.0364347883,
-0.009901721,
-0.0150848031,
-0.0076503516,
-0.0228933692,
-0.0404677875,
0.0045100045,
0.0475541279,
0.0269549843,
0.0084413877,
-0.0128597496,
0.0688470602,
0.003315358,
-0.0226051211,
0.0566943102,
-0.0019597861,
-0.004479582,
-0.0035134659,
0.0410088636,
0.0510444343,
0.0488134995,
-0.0311053898,
-0.016443722,
-0.0598745607,
0.0329751037,
0.0538552627,
0.030149335,
0.0274642911,
-0.0194299743,
0.043912001,
0.021156393,
-0.0330649279,
0.0110899741,
0.0351883918,
-0.0745803043,
-0.0288800783,
0.0128343608,
-0.0312095881,
-0.0563340038,
-0.0208741035,
0.0033171338,
-0.0090167057,
0.008849333,
0.0021922828,
0.0418536142,
-0.0322726108,
0.0242142286,
0.0030573988,
-0.0552996546,
-0.0078939255,
-0.0028257901,
-0.0198513214,
-0.0054843603,
0.0697504804,
0.0120115355,
0.0601323694,
-0.0349266976,
-0.0046413718,
-0.0189738441,
0.0087562762,
0.0037701123,
0.0026790276,
0.0022357036,
0.0912725925,
0.016994454,
-0.0559631474,
-0.0073121167,
-0.0060383691,
-0.0374049172,
0.0204120856,
0.052583497,
0.098765865,
0.0140657527,
0.026868498,
-0.0980310142,
0.0166427735,
-0.0016693863,
-0.0099127376,
0.0339877121,
0.0024073042,
-0.0173453856,
-0.0156224761,
-0.0096871117,
-0.0642732903,
-0.0132572353,
-0.0033172069,
0.0464468375,
0.0164835602,
-0.0177757386,
0.0035218291,
0.0003667835,
-0.0497042798,
0.0000934565,
0.0304979328,
-0.0348263532,
-0.0240389612,
0.0273135323,
-0.0096940007,
-0.087430805,
-0.0112631796,
0.0095182471,
0.0344824679,
0.0053906641,
-0.0075099114,
0.0797623247,
-0.0209842194,
-0.048531089,
0.0111857578,
-0.0240841191,
-0.0255416017,
-0.054202117,
-0.0066607175,
0.0238215793,
0.0459254198,
-0.0129379062,
0.0714942813,
0.0388318598,
0.0006831975,
-0.0357759483,
-0.024399383,
0.0179827493,
0.0216503572,
0.0126466155,
-0.0052809324,
-0.0223532747,
0.0657368526,
-0.0138886338,
-0.0690034851,
0.0002940768,
-0.0117380014,
2.135e-7,
0.0256676394,
-0.0066441759,
0.0322316289,
-0.0037653863,
0.0253404789,
0.0520179719,
-0.0201952457,
0.0569406934,
-0.0017547805,
0.0114268204,
0.0107893329,
0.0331624299,
0.0529765189,
0.0149661629,
-0.092780672,
0.0715637058,
-0.0994710624,
-0.0488872938,
-0.0386423804,
-0.0394962281,
0.0849357843,
0.0981004015,
0.0486795902,
0.0065548359,
0.0133438986,
-0.0224276055,
0.0724523664,
-0.0283911023,
-0.0283816308,
-0.0702227056,
-0.0244171247,
0.0192894526,
-0.0077321241,
-0.008173638,
-0.0065612337,
0.0550950617,
-0.0000426761,
0.0281424895,
0.0309629478,
-0.020002909,
-0.0113755204,
-0.0098466007,
-0.0066127661,
-0.010043581,
0.0683931708,
-0.0948077068,
-0.0062198872,
-0.0547108017,
-0.0516037382,
0.0049853409,
0.0554316826,
-0.0073212567,
-0.0304298569,
-0.0158026442,
0.0360957831,
0.0259865895,
-0.022003049,
-0.0697654337,
-0.0262676347,
0.0528375208,
-0.0375197418,
-0.0174239594,
-0.0204983931,
0.0197295211,
0.0403634086,
-0.040213313,
0.0283875242,
1.831962372e-34,
0.0347408354,
-0.0029122955,
-0.0042527621,
-0.0022258658,
-0.0004571831,
-0.0372308828,
-0.0275110602,
-0.0510035269,
0.0537913963,
-0.0608734451,
0.0098987948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15076v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15076v2 | Meta-Learning Online Adaptation of Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:56:20 | 2023-10-20T22:49:24 | Nathan Hu, Eric Mitchell, Christopher D. Manning, Chelsea Finn | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models encode impressively broad world knowledge in their
parameters. However, the knowledge in static language models falls out of date,
limiting the model's effective "shelf life." While online fine-tuning can
reduce this degradation, we find that naively fine-tuning on a stream of
documents leads to a low level of information uptake. We hypothesize that
online fine-tuning does not sufficiently attend to important information. That
is, the gradient signal from important tokens representing factual information
is drowned out by the gradient from inherently noisy tokens, suggesting that a
dynamic, context-aware learning rate may be beneficial. We therefore propose
learning which tokens to upweight. We meta-train a small, autoregressive model
to reweight the language modeling loss for each token during online
fine-tuning, with the objective of maximizing the out-of-date base
question-answering model's ability to answer questions about a document after a
single weighted gradient step. We call this approach Context-aware Meta-learned
Loss Scaling (CaMeLS). Across three different distributions of documents, our
experiments find that CaMeLS provides substantially improved information uptake
on streams of thousands of documents compared with standard fine-tuning and
baseline heuristics for reweighting token losses. | [
0.0462433361,
0.0362076871,
-0.0089674629,
-0.0050936248,
0.0163005088,
0.0249759667,
-0.0188164506,
-0.011903516,
-0.0818633363,
-0.0576961711,
-0.0375690125,
0.0342886113,
-0.002978751,
0.0278168768,
-0.0074662068,
-0.0439069122,
0.0535316356,
-0.0399558134,
0.0134589169,
-0.0220513549,
0.0123645049,
0.0164894927,
-0.0191352107,
0.0025395055,
0.026054224,
-0.0304207243,
-0.0159087181,
-0.0021775076,
0.0046403282,
0.0137828281,
0.0422821157,
0.048757568,
0.0372724123,
0.0204911679,
0.0000019479,
-0.0458881222,
0.001278203,
-0.0216109809,
-0.0546784997,
-0.0274917688,
0.0396423824,
-0.0080563677,
0.0149330255,
0.0327329785,
-0.0448784791,
-0.0322525017,
0.0553201251,
-0.0011425192,
0.0513184518,
0.0642636195,
0.0119747194,
0.0119215734,
0.0530425571,
-0.0262011178,
0.0283297356,
-0.0709864423,
0.0360375047,
0.0183940213,
-0.0487652868,
0.0146507453,
-0.0396528691,
0.032681942,
0.0148206642,
-0.0245411862,
0.0518996008,
0.0068518119,
-0.0526041314,
0.0462336838,
-0.0209214054,
0.0748990402,
-0.0296105556,
-0.0247593187,
-0.0136309471,
-0.0168446917,
0.030134568,
-0.0023717515,
-0.0602975711,
-0.0260788295,
0.0072217132,
-0.0244953576,
-0.0203481372,
-0.0558645241,
0.0393403992,
0.0427920818,
-0.0129133379,
0.0426451154,
-0.0189560112,
-0.0198088344,
0.0027400055,
-0.0242366605,
-0.0565426834,
-0.0165520329,
0.0065334081,
0.0428669602,
-0.0191327259,
0.0370760188,
-0.0120526813,
-0.0071875239,
0.0059781554,
-0.049259536,
0.0436100103,
0.0174690709,
0.0097538941,
0.0863344818,
-0.0179933347,
0.0185539741,
0.0183991306,
0.0040015141,
-0.045653265,
-0.0034103601,
-0.0932920203,
-0.0360841453,
-0.0514752232,
0.0716276541,
-0.0222340282,
0.0131393205,
-0.0274800975,
0.0468961149,
0.0180690661,
-0.0182043668,
0.0076743723,
-0.0187629163,
-0.0341080241,
-0.0152168237,
-0.0171807092,
0.0635487139,
-0.0482092053,
0.0307734609,
0.0200667307,
-0.0450646281,
0.0002579261,
-0.0195467435,
0.0102286264,
-0.0220383387,
0.0180225279,
0.0473492667,
0.0043642484,
-0.0322364867,
-0.0241903849,
-0.007935497,
-0.0206861198,
-0.0378609747,
-0.0107627222,
-0.0174942743,
0.0290331673,
-0.0180512238,
-0.0122305602,
0.0118666841,
-0.0350356922,
0.0117624737,
-0.0085186819,
0.0330106728,
-0.0057000658,
0.0125979176,
0.0468654707,
-0.0129263541,
-0.0391713753,
0.1114798784,
0.013942197,
-0.0077652871,
0.0160126667,
-0.0096132867,
0.0073250048,
-0.0069449516,
0.0639336407,
0.0353154354,
0.0104261432,
0.0186350308,
0.0252688024,
0.0365903899,
0.0496900417,
0.010280231,
-0.0398863517,
0.0032637599,
0.0651267171,
0.0193809159,
0.0150141846,
0.0286190156,
-0.0015031275,
-0.0021350465,
0.0102469521,
-0.0008981237,
-0.0536056384,
0.0393366665,
-0.0184901655,
0.0008536683,
-0.0059303124,
0.0267758239,
-0.0510876291,
-0.051353734,
0.0242400691,
0.0075406204,
-0.0497608967,
0.0059144334,
0.0475562103,
0.0260340441,
-0.0010329077,
0.0324813128,
0.0298367627,
-0.0062008193,
0.0356800966,
-0.0537707694,
-0.002192819,
0.052371081,
0.0426243395,
-0.0560615733,
-0.0405606814,
-0.0463698655,
0.0900516957,
0.0138868559,
0.0506463051,
-0.026913017,
0.0337889679,
-0.0428019464,
-0.0227230955,
0.0100471871,
-0.0007522134,
0.024486348,
0.0048783687,
0.0410864279,
0.006796279,
-0.0779465735,
-0.0081188958,
0.0281286445,
-0.0535820052,
-0.0372890756,
0.0141800018,
0.0028571605,
-0.0063153347,
-0.0215891879,
0.016786145,
-0.0145636508,
0.0076061063,
-0.0254369956,
-0.0365861654,
0.0193725098,
-0.0523188487,
-0.0056888857,
0.0373439975,
-0.0100044552,
0.004063346,
-0.0089160558,
-0.0668438002,
-0.0288239103,
0.0151037406,
-0.0019525964,
0.0808939412,
-0.0426008813,
-0.0038700537,
-0.0384488069,
0.0113080963,
-0.053087119,
0.0475942828,
-0.0304559302,
0.00330814,
-0.002394428,
-0.0543814413,
-0.0159537103,
-0.0099748131,
0.0075561469,
0.0212177094,
-0.0177264586,
0.0323881134,
0.0223951172,
-0.0006577888,
-0.0574614704,
-0.017541524,
-0.0707099959,
0.0027094111,
-0.0228843298,
0.0517732538,
0.0402563624,
0.0227114931,
-0.0100386543,
-0.0229142327,
-0.0162805058,
0.012411668,
-0.0436606146,
0.0530379973,
0.0445777513,
0.0209677424,
0.0681330115,
-0.0298011247,
-0.0229975712,
0.0040848725,
0.051866211,
-0.0100666024,
0.0324303135,
-0.041684404,
-0.0595423356,
-0.0388959795,
0.0076947496,
-0.0244633853,
-0.0189114008,
-0.0472791195,
-0.0249941871,
0.0021844197,
0.1042784154,
0.035930749,
0.0078498861,
0.0235103946,
0.0473341085,
-0.0727161989,
0.0271741282,
-0.0117445337,
-0.0425146073,
-0.0676256195,
0.0085609118,
0.0111101493,
0.0271050278,
-0.0394045338,
-0.0021540751,
-0.058091715,
0.0466228388,
-0.0182728637,
-0.0459572114,
-0.0599662736,
0.019374311,
-0.0200213417,
-0.0058887186,
-0.0312911458,
-0.0239194352,
0.07375101,
0.0429851934,
0.0025155058,
-0.0455558971,
0.0049320562,
-0.0292452052,
0.0117996261,
-0.0220643338,
0.025875153,
0.0129199773,
-0.0220842306,
-0.0896448418,
-0.0800459087,
0.0656169876,
-0.0282258708,
0.012544388,
-0.0242080111,
0.0036582004,
-0.0075043016,
-0.0560283028,
-0.0118882144,
-0.0091633471,
-0.0170468371,
-0.0170571264,
-0.0372790024,
-0.000357346,
-0.0554975756,
-0.0183839891,
0.0213737581,
0.0479506105,
-0.0460236482,
-0.0508217178,
0.0015412874,
0.0600452125,
0.0709815919,
0.046888113,
0.0155256959,
-0.0214010235,
0.0524914935,
0.0489540324,
0.0470247939,
-0.0022174192,
-0.0101380488,
-0.006930266,
0.0219556503,
-0.0413944051,
0.0150938705,
-0.0036610877,
0.031407658,
-0.0611155033,
-0.0197552517,
0.0920385569,
0.0230468195,
-0.0532769263,
-0.0235510077,
-0.0351530127,
0.0315154828,
0.0103730373,
0.0501541868,
-0.0393809415,
-0.0480813235,
0.0113971177,
0.0540796816,
0.0117022106,
-0.0122687006,
-0.0115824929,
-0.0590086579,
-0.0301505774,
-0.0156315621,
-0.0434584394,
0.0143350288,
-0.050952483,
-0.0027457934,
-0.038493108,
0.044819884,
0.0149374185,
-0.0449566655,
0.0045958236,
0.0493260399,
-0.0010026648,
-0.0404823162,
0.0100073544,
0.0103214616,
0.0447362214,
0.0676760226,
0.0231412742,
-0.01825146,
-0.0179546829,
0.1431921422,
-0.0158451125,
0.0243837424,
-0.0299707763,
0.0771005079,
-0.0357754976,
0.027706597,
-0.0049734921,
0.0371865742,
-0.0389219783,
0.0069452114,
0.0355197713,
0.0591498576,
0.036769595,
-0.023075616,
-0.0292113498,
-0.0606763363,
0.0082480656,
0.044321768,
0.0257724356,
-0.0631919205,
-0.0103109423,
-0.0232894886,
0.0002084742,
-0.0044307071,
0.021835072,
0.0065022432,
0.0236191191,
-0.0001218291,
-0.0722554326,
-0.0006464935,
0.0084326901,
0.0427171811,
-0.0013466533,
0.028620841,
0.0071138903,
0.0024919824,
-0.0602464229,
0.0181756355,
-0.0658332705,
-0.0227523092,
-0.0602525696,
0.0205360558,
0.0794894695,
-0.0276736673,
-0.022791069,
-0.0328726359,
-0.0944237113,
-0.0666136295,
0.0080532385,
0.0523106456,
0.0206754245,
0.0486734621,
-0.027496757,
-0.0667122602,
0.0937572122,
0.059917789,
-0.0167743266,
0.0134895425,
0.0514571778,
-0.0062776497,
-0.0273425467,
0.0377603397,
-0.0446439944,
-0.012369019,
0.0284201615,
0.0137737207,
-0.0031376022,
0.040471781,
0.0103451991,
-0.0079631824,
0.0112527767,
0.02932976,
-0.0616460033,
0.0033792725,
0.0496398434,
0.0682115853,
-0.0066966917,
-0.0036194122,
0.0051002582,
0.0095357979,
-0.022531379,
0.0126410751,
0.0137421768,
0.0132378833,
0.0068904655,
-0.0218910687,
-0.0035249286,
-0.0118365148,
0.0514248013,
0.0363914594,
0.0192892011,
-0.0112371277,
0.0016879435,
0.0311008133,
0.0260698982,
-0.0427933782,
0.0153554576,
0.0490269139,
-0.0016302321,
-0.0101920208,
0.0275412574,
-0.1157091185,
-0.0281722844,
-0.0464370921,
0.0278121307,
0.0259369649,
0.024204338,
0.0204840656,
-0.0066811619,
-0.0235043298,
-0.0311958734,
-0.0087563666,
0.0097518936,
0.0099377241,
-0.0040446697,
0.0304494314,
-0.0049975524,
0.0205746107,
0.0591301695,
-0.0130223604,
0.0615491867,
0.0161917266,
0.016493259,
-0.0204534307,
-0.0000677298,
-0.0538461804,
0.0409071557,
-0.0110282516,
0.0421325974,
-0.0308313984,
-0.0595557243,
-0.0079975137,
-0.0079668621,
-0.0028395257,
-0.011542351,
0.0357722305,
0.0311157815,
0.0061625321,
-0.038773641,
-0.0311855879,
0.0624025166,
-0.0004826196,
0.0007948584,
0.021804098,
-6.347917083e-33,
-0.0148019856,
0.0165392198,
0.0111573609,
0.0023112053,
-0.030052077,
0.0130748879,
-0.0215449724,
-0.0019678122,
-0.0643829703,
-0.0076076677,
-0.0144747635,
0.046193324,
0.0021007785,
0.0368430018,
-0.0005358088,
-0.0536309555,
0.0389309712,
-0.0088068526,
-0.0307207257,
0.0144861722,
0.0381551981,
0.0401259251,
0.0452972353,
-0.0093396772,
-0.0055351979,
0.0256882738,
-0.0216709301,
0.0404424332,
-0.0157135036,
0.0565999299,
-0.0048026862,
0.058711227,
0.029242292,
-0.0011113342,
-0.0265764613,
-0.0038374555,
-0.1251953691,
-0.0425761528,
-0.0090314643,
0.0129507333,
-0.0131257214,
-0.0336236991,
0.0471829623,
0.0200407989,
0.0273122005,
-0.0193302389,
0.0461676829,
-0.0430274159,
-0.0706434548,
-0.0111002354,
-0.0199201517,
0.0058428221,
-0.023648316,
-0.0049616909,
-0.0085474318,
0.0448492877,
0.0284066331,
0.0185555983,
-0.0056525716,
0.0107205762,
-0.0110132424,
0.0493075959,
0.0470195413,
0.0261986237,
0.0009771223,
0.0383837819,
0.0108981086,
0.0302854776,
0.0462146513,
-0.0342231989,
0.0624419041,
-0.0427856594,
0.008304094,
0.0490028225,
0.0627144724,
-0.0358011834,
-0.0331823342,
-0.0004662773,
0.0142538762,
0.0700236186,
0.0380109213,
0.0058718231,
-0.0146156438,
-0.005816584,
-0.0882339105,
-0.0074638291,
-0.0562369376,
-0.0094003426,
0.0228256639,
0.0200552512,
-0.0245371256,
-0.0267671552,
0.0072226482,
-0.0392377675,
-0.0481689833,
0.0340893418,
-0.0059832884,
0.0111278445,
0.0103068473,
0.0379173532,
-0.0284214802,
-0.0184069499,
0.0037453675,
0.0226782747,
0.0062286779,
0.0003288072,
0.0700570866,
0.0188738387,
-0.0736299902,
-0.0054156748,
-0.0209578667,
0.0157051813,
0.0246700738,
0.0168536697,
0.0010899062,
0.0089651244,
-0.0190507118,
0.0345994495,
0.0420871451,
-0.0282896291,
-0.0355675481,
-0.0140914377,
-0.006956595,
0.0168404374,
-0.0485765189,
-0.0084506525,
-0.0234494917,
0.0066482308,
0.0354921445,
-0.0642293766,
-0.0275326576,
0.025866827,
2.711e-7,
0.0331187733,
0.0664712861,
0.0313950181,
-0.0345341153,
0.0264984816,
0.0342469215,
-0.0260141622,
0.0156922303,
0.0509633198,
0.0012635088,
0.013568351,
0.0367910787,
0.0523782633,
0.0095084719,
-0.0838252157,
-0.0008825367,
-0.0792769417,
0.0383061878,
-0.0185206681,
-0.0046214554,
-0.0336002745,
0.0722022727,
0.028123999,
-0.0235493518,
0.0094477767,
-0.040948458,
0.0601220317,
-0.0116254995,
0.0257200599,
0.0023233884,
-0.0325782783,
0.0306250621,
-0.0065670204,
0.0243372656,
-0.0253894795,
-0.0080399495,
-0.0154571319,
0.0493544228,
-0.0084554572,
-0.0121794324,
-0.0210163966,
0.021261828,
0.0333104208,
-0.0090581216,
0.0717130974,
-0.0688260421,
-0.0074591613,
-0.0970093384,
-0.0275615845,
-0.0175753571,
0.0358896106,
-0.0273467824,
-0.0245329291,
0.0345964655,
0.002419001,
0.0374191664,
-0.0145264911,
-0.0984561816,
-0.0146550955,
0.011751431,
-0.0070609199,
-0.0785270706,
-0.0585405454,
-0.0113889249,
0.0298922602,
-0.0706972778,
0.0415019579,
1.98346075e-34,
0.0368085988,
-0.0168942008,
0.0153713543,
0.0167983864,
-0.0253981985,
0.0131788207,
-0.0243848413,
-0.0343520045,
0.0573233292,
-0.0820011944,
0.0024523553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15075v1 | HuatuoGPT, towards Taming Language Model to Be a Doctor | 2023-05-24T11:56:01 | 2023-05-24T11:56:01 | Hongbo Zhang, Junying Chen, Feng Jiang, Fei Yu, Zhihong Chen, Jianquan Li, Guiming Chen, Xiangbo Wu, Zhiyi Zhang, Qingying Xiao, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we present HuatuoGPT, a large language model (LLM) for medical
consultation. The core recipe of HuatuoGPT is to leverage both
\textit{distilled data from ChatGPT} and \textit{real-world data from doctors}
in the supervised fine-tuned stage. The responses of ChatGPT are usually
detailed, well-presented and informative while it cannot perform like a doctor
in many aspects, e.g. for integrative diagnosis. We argue that real-world data
from doctors would be complementary to distilled data in the sense the former
could tame a distilled language model to perform like doctors. To better
leverage the strengths of both data, we train a reward model to align the
language model with the merits that both data bring, following an RLAIF
(reinforced learning from AI feedback) fashion. To evaluate and benchmark the
models, we propose a comprehensive evaluation scheme (including automatic and
manual metrics). Experimental results demonstrate that HuatuoGPT achieves
state-of-the-art results in performing medical consultation among open-source
LLMs in GPT-4 evaluation, human evaluation, and medical benchmark datasets. It
is worth noting that by using additional real-world data and RLAIF, the
distilled language model (i.e., HuatuoGPT) outperforms its teacher model
ChatGPT in most cases. Our code, data, and models are publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/FreedomIntelligence/HuatuoGPT}. The online demo is
available at \url{https://www.HuatuoGPT.cn/}. | [
0.0793114379,
0.0520662479,
0.0130779985,
-0.0087816399,
-0.0039571631,
0.0272639487,
-0.0186376125,
0.0412743725,
-0.0032547661,
-0.0222370941,
-0.0746207312,
-0.0380130783,
0.0085133007,
0.0276492853,
0.0133975782,
-0.0905966088,
0.0373871475,
0.0025845796,
0.0378280915,
0.0016278775,
-0.0020115213,
0.0103387609,
-0.0552423336,
0.0726559311,
0.0048820069,
-0.0016477935,
0.0447976962,
-0.0046288511,
0.0226877872,
-0.0529238135,
0.0337423757,
0.0445224643,
-0.013085993,
0.0045220982,
0.0000021363,
-0.019560216,
0.0189051554,
0.0106507996,
-0.0118123526,
-0.0326227807,
0.0531828105,
-0.0509477369,
0.0042802924,
0.0346637033,
-0.0391303152,
-0.0386352837,
-0.0008126064,
0.0634506494,
0.0715843141,
0.088150464,
0.0021728817,
-0.0035938621,
0.0272779427,
-0.0404648148,
0.0038522589,
-0.0378353223,
0.0111881243,
0.0388641842,
0.0449231006,
-0.0051129269,
-0.0136887217,
0.0307350419,
-0.0031627137,
0.0035680255,
0.0063339393,
0.0568388514,
-0.0302462764,
-0.0103679337,
-0.0126562761,
0.0840200856,
0.0048606112,
-0.0041800844,
0.0056623402,
0.0060880524,
0.0101470351,
-0.0332591198,
-0.0425271764,
-0.0013764591,
-0.0075743375,
0.0239167158,
0.0194667634,
0.008214945,
0.0443154611,
0.0165439267,
0.0223650746,
-0.0051641203,
0.0062578269,
-0.0247876253,
0.0256540198,
0.0007027207,
-0.0023057794,
-0.0333838537,
0.0178090278,
0.0615441576,
-0.0846168026,
0.0085695805,
-0.0129232761,
-0.0096302442,
0.0509109497,
-0.0275436882,
0.0067951912,
0.0314278416,
-0.0132915173,
0.050194446,
-0.0100598475,
0.0327261314,
-0.0007930148,
0.0646981597,
-0.0524005368,
0.0072267302,
-0.0739263147,
0.0041349996,
-0.0211067926,
0.0140531436,
0.0105806263,
-0.0046363589,
-0.0766605809,
-0.0354354195,
-0.0409231856,
0.030082915,
0.049384512,
0.0472156145,
-0.0335304178,
0.014269216,
-0.0442156531,
0.0322849378,
-0.0046799732,
-0.0007354564,
-0.0097985584,
-0.0489086211,
0.0112205781,
0.0014033583,
-0.0253425017,
0.0036948796,
0.0274800602,
0.0576126799,
-0.008597523,
-0.013726823,
0.0087838611,
-0.0240289401,
-0.0305303112,
-0.0485762544,
-0.003180122,
-0.0781951025,
0.0285415519,
-0.0032722156,
0.0423998125,
-0.0431667008,
0.0210664701,
-0.001533136,
-0.0578693226,
0.062103916,
-0.0287816022,
0.0321707502,
0.0348516405,
0.0541783385,
-0.0214267522,
0.0262658596,
0.0310793649,
-0.0289755072,
-0.0065010125,
-0.0261293426,
0.0312844068,
-0.0022896957,
0.0346785225,
-0.0078293253,
-0.0019327379,
0.0024001715,
-0.0080155786,
0.0873326287,
-0.0083284862,
0.0668730438,
-0.0226366408,
0.0110110678,
0.0205928124,
0.0345402732,
0.0226790886,
0.0030879744,
0.0153525481,
-0.0247883592,
0.0113008302,
-0.0130170621,
-0.0478365123,
0.0077899452,
0.0110771935,
-0.0232808758,
0.0032433192,
-0.0325203799,
-0.0485540517,
-0.0555283166,
-0.0276624989,
-0.0281932149,
0.0041275625,
0.0073234718,
0.0355146192,
-0.0144267064,
-0.0140027199,
0.0471824594,
0.0653752908,
-0.0077744764,
-0.0109887505,
-0.0915443525,
0.0071903737,
0.073503837,
0.051215753,
-0.0508144349,
-0.0356067419,
-0.010144772,
0.0024116733,
0.0231970809,
0.0630961135,
-0.0129571054,
0.024811089,
-0.0390036292,
-0.0168521758,
0.0309784487,
0.0351943709,
-0.0267590005,
0.018299602,
0.0409487039,
-0.0000476498,
-0.0250173714,
-0.0695293397,
0.0472633876,
-0.0466903038,
-0.027354341,
0.0119930645,
-0.0324569196,
0.0403833129,
0.0082619889,
-0.0201375466,
0.0338604786,
0.0033500937,
-0.0054667494,
-0.0167697407,
0.0051267482,
-0.0663203299,
-0.046769537,
0.0203610621,
-0.0377314091,
-0.0068101431,
0.0166151412,
-0.0451782048,
-0.0418783352,
-0.034164872,
-0.0487472415,
0.0268255528,
-0.0052572745,
0.0256674942,
0.0315732583,
-0.023237789,
-0.0341110192,
0.0070945709,
-0.0040975953,
0.0113518173,
0.0101035479,
0.0094206706,
-0.0004616096,
-0.0268068071,
-0.0243426058,
0.0052046785,
0.0030304524,
0.0286077037,
-0.0012876255,
0.0648679957,
-0.0296923313,
-0.0590310246,
-0.1041469574,
-0.0185004789,
-0.0037824521,
-0.0305858273,
0.025889134,
0.0083219213,
0.0008565283,
-0.0164419077,
-0.0799667686,
-0.0013882205,
0.0471812449,
0.0005272275,
0.0206071418,
0.0438393019,
0.017206626,
-0.0467172153,
0.0048656752,
-0.0309949014,
-0.0349491611,
0.0246141739,
0.0027659757,
-0.0119641693,
-0.0338971168,
-0.0621457063,
0.0040942542,
-0.0188584775,
-0.0597409047,
0.0115792062,
-0.0197148044,
-0.0077692945,
0.0354203731,
0.0049847374,
0.0148882028,
0.0272542462,
0.0292471722,
-0.052296035,
0.0236379523,
-0.0277732164,
-0.0479488,
-0.0135725364,
-0.0476282984,
-0.002837617,
0.0733683929,
0.0063670073,
0.0226799417,
-0.0683178976,
-0.0203414448,
-0.0177030098,
0.0107870232,
-0.0315267034,
0.0417939276,
-0.0302533675,
0.0353671722,
-0.0175011493,
-0.0600673035,
0.1010456011,
0.0087412475,
0.036924988,
-0.078202486,
-0.0338987373,
-0.0285612363,
0.0032549957,
-0.0142197795,
0.0343009047,
-0.0132901808,
-0.0185502376,
-0.0099736741,
0.0212186575,
-0.0121680815,
-0.0924806148,
0.0372182317,
-0.0412214026,
0.0027549153,
0.0029050785,
-0.0559175871,
-0.0451412499,
-0.0010673375,
-0.0275752246,
0.0181159806,
0.0129277632,
0.0095030749,
-0.0442595445,
0.0057125515,
0.0033015304,
0.0913472176,
0.0123976627,
-0.0025432955,
0.0143726002,
-0.0180107821,
0.0361117534,
0.0165755879,
-0.009031415,
-0.0311837457,
0.028246332,
0.0522677228,
-0.0003848927,
0.0189455468,
0.0099641941,
-0.0145343533,
-0.0004030599,
-0.0009799625,
-0.00380771,
0.0316412412,
0.0196841806,
-0.0425527357,
-0.026531253,
0.128850162,
0.0228324048,
-0.0764483139,
0.0186233241,
-0.0079096872,
0.0137451077,
-0.00833923,
0.0116248699,
-0.0686523169,
-0.0344555005,
-0.0292367879,
0.0407273546,
0.0163841639,
0.0024139939,
0.02088416,
-0.0736433193,
0.0146798287,
0.0068062656,
-0.0368505605,
-0.0299554169,
-0.0228892639,
-0.0026554686,
-0.0246127546,
-0.0059666177,
-0.0157655291,
-0.012261251,
0.0034299167,
0.0048842337,
-0.0515148267,
-0.0784257129,
0.0540432148,
-0.0214979332,
0.066101335,
0.0701727942,
0.0351525135,
-0.0164092947,
-0.0365111418,
-0.0049238577,
0.0427245907,
0.0030094881,
-0.0086091468,
0.0798869357,
0.000902293,
0.0029429989,
-0.0217045713,
0.0483070314,
-0.0421459675,
0.0126378108,
0.0229109004,
0.0528679229,
-0.0296839103,
-0.0068443287,
-0.0435989201,
0.0454010442,
0.0525201745,
0.0653171763,
-0.0168749671,
-0.0117431842,
-0.0215201043,
0.0166153871,
0.032681942,
0.0105853463,
-0.0248593092,
0.0481028929,
-0.0273397379,
-0.0008435869,
-0.0751072392,
-0.0326237306,
0.0337015614,
-0.0127601558,
0.0075262967,
0.0100815007,
-0.0207733717,
0.0166442301,
-0.0295451768,
0.0465802997,
0.0083190398,
0.0288289972,
-0.1035572663,
-0.0520389713,
0.0547489114,
-0.0231233798,
-0.0100237848,
0.0151650207,
-0.033467859,
-0.021189034,
-0.0138828903,
0.0778185576,
0.015131481,
0.03767699,
-0.0303525329,
-0.0241562463,
0.0411620513,
0.0232548621,
-0.0545946918,
-0.0204951409,
0.0235028677,
0.0299724117,
0.0026148313,
0.0311284941,
-0.0284419693,
0.0301521737,
0.0347404629,
0.0333526433,
-0.0038502119,
-0.0144093586,
0.0218695272,
0.0347784907,
0.0517438799,
-0.0321311839,
-0.0069921096,
-0.0303668026,
-0.0006090258,
-0.0050435951,
0.0075250012,
-0.0553825013,
-0.0028737136,
0.0350155197,
-0.0217938107,
-0.0049615162,
-0.0335658938,
-0.0505888537,
-0.039035622,
-0.059971001,
0.0117053315,
0.0126865134,
-0.0485928766,
0.0452139527,
-0.004354279,
-0.0051174392,
0.0154918069,
0.0078928536,
0.0136871217,
0.0142765017,
0.0975801274,
0.0191705432,
0.0356656574,
0.0264470987,
0.0375679918,
-0.0395046175,
-0.0682556778,
-0.0226212237,
0.0389590934,
0.0542521141,
0.0167187676,
0.0204598736,
-0.0313733146,
0.0149009684,
-0.0257191509,
0.0199602433,
-0.0363514721,
0.0148930773,
0.0728867128,
0.0043396954,
0.0180935245,
-0.0080388943,
0.0954066589,
-0.0153832315,
0.0456697755,
0.0121379979,
-0.0146564581,
-0.0450597405,
-0.0152318357,
0.0386053212,
0.0156463236,
-0.0546773486,
0.0393501148,
-0.0259187333,
-0.0559765771,
-0.0478748679,
0.0048117102,
-0.0361724608,
-0.023930775,
0.0607528239,
0.0193226673,
-0.0304533001,
-0.0113482932,
-0.0581695735,
0.0208321959,
-0.0197622739,
-0.0266411919,
0.0240773223,
-5.901835711e-33,
-0.0018359683,
-0.0032443898,
0.0399942361,
-0.0018737557,
-0.0091206878,
0.0309507009,
-0.0264771897,
0.0092941662,
-0.0363369659,
0.0533123165,
-0.0115856575,
0.0072978619,
-0.0003392512,
0.0434502251,
0.0007664585,
-0.0303091947,
0.0322097391,
0.0162477326,
-0.0330380537,
0.0422276109,
-0.0295289923,
0.0273493733,
0.06407547,
-0.0912001953,
0.0078328289,
-0.0034053263,
-0.0097010667,
0.0343237296,
-0.0307709798,
0.0681519583,
-0.0277675986,
0.0407598726,
0.0433733501,
-0.0270050392,
0.0051525789,
-0.0187848955,
-0.0828101411,
-0.0190260708,
-0.00818701,
-0.0239136294,
-0.0793260932,
0.001846568,
0.0387588739,
-0.0359539203,
-0.015925277,
-0.0211803988,
0.0255845971,
-0.0454010032,
-0.012234726,
0.0038184414,
-0.0256733615,
0.0409714133,
-0.0007215228,
-0.0387232751,
-0.0313864872,
0.0203226265,
-0.0532585606,
0.0511641055,
-0.0366006494,
0.0016929072,
0.0670889243,
0.0364313908,
0.021048313,
-0.0095149027,
-0.0318823718,
0.0362023562,
0.0209476743,
-0.0191523917,
-0.0267181676,
-0.0288810562,
-0.0223390441,
0.0587564036,
0.0544989184,
0.0158406366,
0.0093233716,
-0.0337190963,
-0.0711158663,
0.0287900511,
-0.028385615,
0.052804634,
-0.0040278314,
-0.0166644622,
-0.0704303458,
-0.0223732013,
-0.0262546018,
-0.0049791704,
-0.0137663418,
-0.0392805487,
0.0445174761,
0.0337011404,
0.0046623382,
-0.0047645052,
0.0011470208,
-0.0369128995,
0.0270624496,
-0.0064893547,
0.0081568332,
-0.0063929074,
-0.0436570235,
-0.0066542099,
-0.0728114396,
-0.0311219841,
0.0172131956,
0.0025928798,
0.0463980399,
0.0214551967,
0.0340646692,
-0.0129396776,
-0.0412119515,
0.002890755,
-0.0031235586,
0.000031432,
0.0051855207,
0.0358150043,
0.027453931,
-0.0085685421,
-0.0270829555,
0.0494924709,
-0.0057928325,
-0.0205188803,
-0.0488084964,
-0.0674707517,
0.0030472216,
-0.0184592549,
-0.0806167573,
0.0042241677,
-0.027927706,
0.012217382,
0.0455498658,
-0.0207512714,
-0.0168486387,
-0.0036950884,
2.76e-7,
0.0558278896,
0.0379701592,
-0.0131247155,
-0.0124363257,
0.0185358934,
0.0048040627,
-0.0195324924,
0.0373570286,
-0.0128260562,
-0.0160970725,
0.0295754783,
0.0140461437,
0.054337468,
0.0318431892,
-0.06351275,
-0.0136811454,
-0.116513826,
-0.0369372629,
-0.0031478922,
-0.0428160913,
0.0364221446,
0.1050825492,
-0.0149323037,
-0.0452387929,
0.0156067424,
-0.002622413,
0.0516941324,
-0.0485003032,
0.0060908399,
0.0706611946,
0.0464089513,
0.035583958,
0.0265285373,
0.0158713814,
-0.0342125967,
-0.0082275756,
0.0266181305,
0.133713156,
-0.0635245219,
0.0218308344,
0.0220672879,
0.0338264219,
0.022101339,
-0.0767265335,
0.0398360416,
-0.0386992581,
-0.0251154788,
-0.0014538693,
0.0000610319,
-0.0507671759,
0.0841946602,
-0.0536442026,
-0.0303774644,
0.0374145582,
0.037847124,
0.0242691617,
-0.043836385,
-0.0733742863,
-0.0451920219,
0.0095419241,
-0.0188453682,
-0.0210225731,
0.0408318602,
-0.0141728409,
-0.0398110934,
-0.0697785616,
0.0111342473,
2.098567361e-34,
0.0348755457,
-0.0088664396,
0.0087761162,
0.0171195399,
0.0365170799,
0.0208925959,
0.0316106975,
0.0298369471,
0.0465972088,
-0.0229758285,
-0.0335078761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15074v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15074v3 | Have LLMs Advanced Enough? A Challenging Problem Solving Benchmark For Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:55:59 | 2023-10-23T11:55:58 | Daman Arora, Himanshu Gaurav Singh, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The performance of large language models (LLMs) on existing reasoning
benchmarks has significantly improved over the past years. In response, we
present JEEBench, a considerably more challenging benchmark dataset for
evaluating the problem solving abilities of LLMs. We curate 515 challenging
pre-engineering mathematics, physics and chemistry problems from the highly
competitive IIT JEE-Advanced exam. Long-horizon reasoning on top of deep
in-domain knowledge is essential for solving problems in this benchmark. Our
evaluation on various open-source and proprietary models reveals that the
highest performance, even after using techniques like self-consistency,
self-refinement and chain-of-thought prompting, is less than 40%. The typical
failure modes of GPT-4, the best model, are errors in algebraic manipulation,
difficulty in grounding abstract concepts into mathematical equations
accurately and failure in retrieving relevant domain-specific concepts. We also
observe that by mere prompting, GPT-4 is unable to assess risk introduced by
negative marking for incorrect answers. For this, we develop a post-hoc
confidence-thresholding method over self-consistency, which enables effective
response selection. We hope that our challenging benchmark will guide future
re-search in problem-solving using LLMs. | [
-0.0239672754,
0.0480475985,
0.0060997335,
0.0485741124,
-0.0736319199,
0.0011227459,
-0.002753986,
-0.0036615753,
-0.0003457679,
-0.0286989529,
0.00615928,
-0.0305548143,
-0.0555841476,
0.0098687513,
0.0146334553,
-0.0028994295,
0.0377032682,
-0.0730231628,
-0.0011846416,
-0.0283889789,
-0.036550045,
-0.0285130348,
-0.0378691293,
-0.0003941634,
-0.009310469,
-0.0637922734,
0.0083509302,
-0.0299641732,
-0.0020976551,
-0.0551821142,
0.0078067314,
0.0730730966,
0.0207410716,
0.0413471572,
0.0000023831,
-0.0705894977,
-0.0302863512,
0.0026127945,
-0.0539986268,
0.016849611,
-0.0582176894,
0.0170356799,
-0.0044187894,
0.0365798213,
-0.041376587,
0.0284531638,
-0.0025125986,
0.0239271391,
0.0795773491,
0.0273185167,
0.0157743897,
-0.0173192546,
0.0555635951,
-0.0144356173,
0.0435881391,
-0.0832882449,
0.0322377943,
0.0450876169,
0.0282958765,
-0.0011265571,
-0.0395461209,
0.0389213413,
0.062727727,
0.001244865,
-0.0275435373,
0.0163048729,
-0.0548283532,
0.0278203897,
0.0153729161,
0.0562431924,
-0.0028249363,
-0.0173622612,
-0.0583575182,
0.0015019331,
-0.0217501558,
0.0325221419,
-0.0646975487,
0.0231012087,
-0.0113202985,
0.0038650578,
0.0038740146,
0.0083173783,
0.0181962978,
0.0172748882,
-0.0430101119,
0.1329241991,
0.0204176791,
-0.0485330895,
0.0337717272,
-0.002647025,
-0.0584289953,
-0.0308512468,
0.0211318471,
0.0519117974,
-0.0046865316,
0.0134011908,
0.0133590084,
-0.0038259546,
-0.0097008618,
-0.0095933527,
0.0428553522,
0.0644989386,
0.0210993867,
0.0642679483,
-0.0216133427,
0.0821924433,
-0.0152218472,
0.0176114589,
-0.0205769558,
0.0037722928,
-0.0396450125,
-0.0199529547,
-0.0216404274,
0.0541768186,
0.0162202735,
0.009424095,
-0.0467305146,
0.0057569519,
-0.0199677479,
0.0121581238,
0.0032486613,
-0.0156496745,
0.0091476096,
-0.0445885435,
-0.0626588315,
0.0269781351,
-0.0258376468,
-0.0021829384,
0.0100463917,
-0.0469250344,
-0.0291913226,
-0.0114610819,
-0.043249283,
-0.0506098866,
0.0277766455,
0.0627060756,
-0.0161324199,
-0.0124709643,
-0.032067176,
-0.0180945713,
-0.0013054011,
-0.1082412824,
0.031642627,
-0.0885526389,
0.0248969477,
0.023027055,
-0.0166053623,
-0.0468976498,
0.019831894,
-0.0068395026,
0.0497084372,
0.0714343563,
0.0320787802,
0.0065978519,
0.0327299871,
0.0428565368,
-0.023636004,
0.0520878993,
0.0252745207,
-0.0004558722,
0.0099571627,
-0.0237191096,
0.0423508659,
0.0314491764,
0.0168996621,
0.0038116602,
-0.0132802585,
0.036630135,
0.015310239,
0.0499015003,
-0.0419796184,
0.0384132825,
-0.0156514458,
-0.0028634286,
0.0443388857,
0.0570267998,
0.0009122439,
0.0225791764,
-0.0109554064,
-0.0139912069,
0.0452770293,
-0.0044317595,
-0.0518011265,
0.0420348309,
-0.0488303751,
0.0045762039,
0.0336604528,
-0.0002332892,
-0.0229407828,
-0.0562447757,
-0.019146625,
0.0360098742,
-0.0466578938,
0.025378054,
0.0848280862,
-0.045455683,
-0.0120051522,
0.0477521233,
-0.0171091985,
-0.0170389991,
0.0020926432,
-0.0396726392,
0.0369321518,
-0.0054614358,
0.0613350496,
-0.0548497997,
-0.0708714426,
-0.0048782211,
0.0295402929,
0.0100608356,
0.0503082201,
0.013082684,
-0.0098916069,
-0.0224947017,
-0.0147331059,
-0.0280497335,
-0.0053378358,
-0.0129931411,
0.0271874219,
0.0230124593,
0.0165691338,
-0.0483666733,
0.0171068497,
0.0064902082,
-0.0734663904,
-0.0434740782,
-0.0116713252,
-0.0133159189,
0.0253876466,
-0.007414585,
0.0044345218,
0.0358239785,
0.0212622229,
-0.036353562,
-0.0155837936,
-0.019121103,
-0.07017003,
-0.0149079161,
0.0640847385,
-0.0651537925,
-0.0358385965,
0.0332958438,
-0.0472571403,
-0.0483553335,
0.0536114573,
-0.0088299001,
-0.020902833,
-0.0206454489,
0.0391838625,
-0.0236110147,
-0.0078536477,
-0.0311416425,
0.0498682894,
0.0132979155,
0.0350283869,
0.0005493119,
0.0066919625,
0.031169083,
-0.0329950787,
-0.0359621346,
0.004166516,
-0.0129531575,
-0.0053796638,
0.0032043052,
0.012755719,
-0.0763762742,
-0.0128286183,
-0.0160126165,
0.0250287075,
0.0041592745,
0.0547973849,
0.0034344767,
-0.0324759372,
-0.0219630022,
0.0021226059,
-0.0153383082,
-0.0106606632,
0.0145142861,
-0.0063936869,
0.0237419344,
0.0021386191,
-0.0048130327,
-0.039279297,
-0.036505077,
-0.0605193228,
0.0250770561,
-0.0016605995,
0.0283085313,
-0.0272329357,
0.0641903281,
-0.0483744033,
0.0232606232,
-0.0126747182,
-0.0008372255,
0.0326544046,
-0.0351218432,
0.0418946669,
0.0667070597,
-0.0122650638,
0.001953884,
0.0385321639,
-0.0451396182,
-0.066877991,
0.0425507016,
-0.0146490531,
-0.0245121904,
0.00852009,
-0.0006785702,
-0.0164895486,
0.0624391697,
-0.0137615576,
-0.0206767581,
-0.0127401594,
0.0598889142,
-0.0306161698,
0.0238823537,
-0.0428445488,
0.0194659848,
0.0101580853,
0.0464825816,
-0.0055582887,
-0.0324870683,
0.0905348212,
-0.012747651,
0.0019912724,
-0.0486252159,
0.0265547857,
-0.035886623,
0.0597424842,
-0.0160854049,
-0.0269471109,
0.0066437754,
0.0078207105,
-0.0480052084,
-0.0042833653,
0.0164485462,
-0.027652014,
0.0536601655,
-0.0710041821,
0.0243559182,
-0.0013174748,
-0.0710223541,
-0.0355817601,
0.0113875754,
-0.0142708831,
0.0234664101,
-0.0163685624,
-0.0151650421,
-0.013528253,
0.0195574164,
0.0301273651,
0.0007130238,
-0.033374615,
-0.0313320495,
-0.011376719,
0.015735399,
0.019975964,
0.0155858994,
0.0713725239,
-0.0450751781,
0.0539464802,
0.0423463881,
0.0650918782,
0.0027920578,
-0.0110087525,
0.0371202603,
0.0191851128,
-0.0263080113,
-0.0012770224,
0.0179704484,
0.0138843926,
-0.0645347089,
-0.0209541228,
0.1135297492,
0.0366469547,
0.0048614326,
-0.0125189247,
-0.0561559312,
0.00970071,
0.0405950099,
0.0262946934,
-0.0680237263,
-0.0278952271,
0.0271255355,
-0.0005269274,
0.0149187101,
-0.0583391301,
0.0021072982,
-0.1329702884,
0.0268648062,
0.0164615661,
-0.0173114184,
0.0034422879,
-0.0404600725,
0.0052161855,
-0.0016809222,
0.0000784673,
0.0403543115,
0.007743638,
0.0021387255,
0.021868553,
-0.0337892585,
-0.039166227,
0.0691250414,
-0.018952705,
-0.0061574914,
-0.0004356408,
0.0007693557,
-0.0296351518,
-0.0555260256,
0.0747505054,
-0.0237842295,
-0.0183590036,
-0.0293347929,
0.0008960837,
0.003486061,
-0.0086891484,
-0.0297177844,
0.0310610756,
-0.0571562238,
-0.0270084478,
0.0392936207,
0.1422505081,
-0.0029253177,
-0.0173526797,
-0.0243267752,
-0.013899033,
-0.0386783481,
0.0542911924,
-0.0082506211,
-0.0024538492,
-0.0621663965,
-0.0389177576,
-0.0099877156,
0.0053427238,
0.0025051318,
0.0203141421,
0.0453932472,
0.0447693318,
0.0095463051,
-0.0136571135,
0.0684598461,
0.0346577503,
-0.0044131652,
-0.00375643,
0.0085854707,
0.0226947274,
-0.0289535485,
0.0612852685,
-0.0445299558,
0.0150705418,
-0.0817143768,
0.054150328,
0.0173738413,
-0.0270420313,
-0.0277853683,
0.0321620665,
-0.0769541338,
-0.0534261167,
-0.02117154,
0.0416109264,
0.0291314349,
0.0125865499,
-0.0036914535,
-0.0360212401,
0.0121558942,
-0.0309093613,
-0.0438392758,
0.0111717386,
0.0116447695,
0.0128419735,
0.0033700091,
0.0038767983,
-0.0069784159,
0.0170370098,
0.0285344683,
0.0653156266,
0.0057306597,
-0.0226291046,
0.0389316939,
0.0673805475,
0.0177867934,
0.0275888965,
0.0094084227,
-0.0221182089,
0.0422540531,
-0.0205651708,
-0.0104621239,
-0.0376006886,
0.0056921467,
0.0362897366,
-0.0392026491,
0.0096361581,
-0.0162947364,
0.0067674243,
0.032120239,
-0.0063538365,
0.0297484063,
0.0119520193,
0.0092206532,
0.067935355,
-0.0427649729,
0.0151516721,
-0.04044706,
0.0095144371,
0.0572559834,
-0.0028374959,
0.0830934271,
0.0144429412,
0.0051905536,
-0.0185898691,
-0.0200172402,
-0.0613578185,
-0.0978756398,
-0.010533453,
0.0383889377,
0.0396999419,
0.0380432196,
-0.0097280005,
-0.0619218424,
-0.0145009123,
-0.0262542125,
0.006158147,
0.0159837697,
-0.0024398814,
0.0587334335,
0.0522567444,
0.0281309523,
0.0059923432,
0.0439148247,
0.0025901161,
0.0221162606,
0.0343757384,
0.0101837404,
-0.0309015773,
-0.0172433704,
-0.001298439,
0.0094598047,
0.0097466446,
0.0106184445,
-0.0739018619,
-0.0710471794,
0.0237497427,
0.0316814594,
-0.0234397054,
-0.0027415175,
0.0330297984,
0.0914328992,
-0.0163169,
-0.0220253896,
0.0312013868,
0.0206951331,
-0.0353013538,
-0.0228130445,
-0.0164207257,
-6.579526204e-33,
-0.0403515734,
-0.0224421304,
0.053689003,
-0.0006765106,
-0.0006145863,
-0.0202863514,
-0.0491962396,
0.0285358969,
-0.0214387849,
0.0049776137,
-0.0294835139,
0.0176588055,
0.0024503502,
0.0097209876,
0.0232399367,
-0.0256262459,
-0.0050954465,
0.0048610778,
-0.0331410989,
-0.0064149047,
0.0016462159,
0.00892065,
0.06113974,
-0.0392774381,
-0.0120315617,
-0.0038106481,
0.0004635608,
0.0525024086,
-0.0643227547,
0.0502612069,
-0.0232229549,
0.0309889298,
0.0144844446,
-0.0563569069,
0.0138631724,
-0.029674679,
-0.0461378731,
-0.0578844287,
-0.0033488087,
-0.0104190521,
-0.0420875326,
-0.0222326051,
0.0305249635,
0.0375016592,
-0.0618904307,
-0.0411745198,
-0.0052325064,
-0.0265080314,
0.0104830824,
0.018830061,
-0.0350522511,
0.0214722138,
-0.0402128883,
-0.0255470444,
0.020543009,
0.0262639131,
-0.0075731156,
0.0044391612,
-0.0332776867,
0.0047413488,
0.0272515062,
0.021219315,
0.0929696858,
-0.0289752372,
0.0073996773,
0.041068662,
0.0194940753,
-0.0068402207,
0.0064703533,
-0.0405562334,
0.013058465,
0.0583630949,
0.0740741268,
0.0190822817,
0.0448618457,
0.0332800299,
-0.1010929346,
0.0165738221,
-0.0063015907,
0.0550955124,
0.0290802941,
0.0028481446,
-0.0423149019,
-0.0247439463,
-0.0595243201,
0.0446994193,
-0.0469680578,
-0.0148272701,
0.0504400693,
-0.039439749,
0.0047408747,
-0.0241942685,
0.0360064581,
-0.0342434049,
-0.0299422368,
0.0104778353,
0.003640498,
0.0254445951,
-0.0079062376,
0.066608794,
-0.0652150363,
-0.0020676481,
-0.0506580323,
-0.0015552358,
0.0203261971,
-0.0019392958,
-0.0022035483,
0.0193550717,
-0.0372701921,
-0.0345056131,
-0.0679179952,
-0.0003248448,
0.0495935157,
0.0238726959,
0.0285187103,
0.0133603299,
0.0019802675,
0.0347636454,
-0.0163342152,
-0.0334087424,
0.0028761108,
0.0334363878,
-0.0106334258,
0.0059863408,
0.0236871913,
-0.0019071808,
-0.0283889193,
0.0089066578,
0.0250998233,
-0.0624784082,
-0.0044901841,
0.0230490249,
3.084e-7,
0.0453776196,
0.0487495959,
0.0217597913,
0.0168605838,
0.0074412129,
0.0259864479,
-0.0591302849,
-0.0511587523,
0.0483781211,
0.0010749528,
-0.0077740098,
0.0638505518,
0.0390948206,
0.0537449457,
-0.0440471619,
0.0074805128,
-0.0185880493,
-0.0238447376,
-0.0566191785,
0.0107244151,
0.0675091743,
0.0564567707,
0.0144337956,
-0.0163696148,
0.0021077178,
-0.0590292588,
0.0513571948,
-0.0469884761,
0.0026658664,
0.0435766913,
-0.0187020674,
0.0079624103,
0.0191344209,
0.0555568822,
0.0100037735,
-0.010571626,
0.0090338262,
0.0308410935,
0.0369357429,
0.001361991,
-0.0255289748,
-0.0153398877,
0.0028046961,
-0.0662888139,
0.078959845,
-0.0699662194,
-0.0523529835,
0.0116363196,
-0.0079819001,
-0.0813460052,
0.0429884158,
-0.0105945244,
0.0274146032,
-0.0084064323,
-0.00414791,
0.0035443252,
-0.0049747922,
-0.0399551988,
-0.0161177833,
0.0171686709,
-0.0506318696,
-0.0397022478,
-0.0514784791,
-0.0067151436,
0.0367360823,
-0.0475198776,
-0.0086124772,
3.127197009e-34,
0.0337763242,
-0.0193187408,
0.0505317375,
0.0315193199,
0.0338422768,
-0.0017409533,
-0.0254179779,
0.0062979246,
-0.0029224739,
-0.0679861382,
-0.0280974936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15070v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15070v3 | Annotation Imputation to Individualize Predictions: Initial Studies on Distribution Dynamics and Model Predictions | 2023-05-24T11:54:46 | 2023-10-05T07:10:25 | London Lowmanstone, Ruyuan Wan, Risako Owan, Jaehyung Kim, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Annotating data via crowdsourcing is time-consuming and expensive. Due to
these costs, dataset creators often have each annotator label only a small
subset of the data. This leads to sparse datasets with examples that are marked
by few annotators. The downside of this process is that if an annotator doesn't
get to label a particular example, their perspective on it is missed. This is
especially concerning for subjective NLP datasets where there is no single
correct label: people may have different valid opinions. Thus, we propose using
imputation methods to generate the opinions of all annotators for all examples,
creating a dataset that does not leave out any annotator's view. We then train
and prompt models, using data from the imputed dataset, to make predictions
about the distribution of responses and individual annotations.
In our analysis of the results, we found that the choice of imputation method
significantly impacts soft label changes and distribution. While the imputation
introduces noise in the prediction of the original dataset, it has shown
potential in enhancing shots for prompts, particularly for low-response-rate
annotators. We have made all of our code and data publicly available. | [
0.0754636601,
0.0486504398,
-0.007561909,
0.0008928417,
-0.0092757577,
-0.0028490061,
-0.0041504409,
-0.0359872319,
0.0036295271,
-0.0762704164,
-0.0285659172,
0.0098316763,
-0.0059635304,
-0.0280954372,
-0.0105697475,
-0.0624781251,
0.0163426101,
0.027784586,
0.0521185286,
-0.0184905026,
0.0447212905,
0.0003603031,
-0.0115116229,
0.0569939688,
-0.0248735677,
-0.0016282551,
0.0003407327,
0.0170702208,
0.0216483679,
-0.0130208917,
0.0413637571,
0.1013305485,
-0.0255552474,
0.0291731507,
0.0000018536,
-0.0005006524,
-0.0132983001,
0.0062820064,
-0.0161840562,
0.0035189544,
0.0343347304,
0.0183046628,
0.0418172814,
0.0149945403,
-0.0533407144,
-0.0193097088,
0.051597327,
0.0218339693,
0.0721061975,
0.0393523425,
0.0054137753,
0.0201935265,
-0.058420714,
0.0051008584,
0.0386610627,
-0.0054563899,
-0.0076742806,
-0.0216343701,
-0.0255921055,
0.0038438099,
-0.0154675134,
0.0264801383,
0.0317349806,
0.0004640644,
0.0345807821,
0.0022636708,
-0.0650866628,
-0.0418394804,
-0.0371583998,
0.0688561574,
0.0718127638,
-0.0266369525,
-0.0226345938,
-0.0202206541,
0.0506328717,
0.0285303053,
-0.0288087577,
0.012295478,
0.009249079,
0.0240860581,
-0.0194706768,
0.0184231475,
0.016908681,
0.003156746,
0.0609083474,
0.0721212178,
-0.0147188203,
-0.009411376,
0.0016848461,
0.0663106143,
-0.0516680479,
-0.0487023257,
-0.0046515763,
-0.0025048652,
-0.0040663192,
0.0014749762,
-0.0394505635,
-0.0456158519,
0.0379875153,
-0.0512420833,
0.0630333945,
0.0056805722,
-0.0168499388,
0.0267739464,
0.0315869227,
-0.0667084455,
0.0353317969,
0.0371251181,
-0.0064021461,
0.0062549124,
-0.0587009527,
-0.0087990519,
-0.0078035272,
0.0542012751,
-0.0204753671,
0.0399146713,
-0.043233268,
0.0009848155,
-0.063447617,
-0.0241545029,
-0.0045123352,
0.0424590707,
-0.0149449157,
0.0263397601,
-0.0863010362,
0.0644788072,
-0.0520061776,
0.0205485467,
0.0211704466,
-0.0746551827,
0.0149053745,
0.0040191547,
0.0056218193,
-0.0334682502,
0.0052775075,
0.025277961,
0.0515822284,
-0.0054371618,
-0.0477329902,
-0.0551608428,
-0.0195718631,
-0.0421363041,
-0.0013062676,
-0.0648435801,
0.0232963562,
0.0121203689,
0.0055769617,
-0.0363736227,
0.0075548841,
0.0342002437,
-0.0096566528,
0.0909434929,
-0.0608414486,
-0.0329644978,
0.0104126353,
-0.0071535488,
0.002377507,
0.0786438584,
-0.0383457951,
-0.0191672333,
0.0265674461,
0.0090655982,
0.0427465811,
-0.012863501,
0.0364203937,
0.0125580244,
0.0322398469,
-0.0093506724,
-0.0288135,
-0.000334691,
0.0222320557,
0.0338651948,
-0.0150623368,
-0.0446629673,
0.036478322,
0.0089895586,
-0.0326482616,
-0.015063243,
0.0227702595,
0.012942344,
0.0197826289,
0.0028379047,
-0.0242369939,
0.0378555544,
-0.0176372211,
-0.0390826352,
0.0058467691,
-0.0335317813,
-0.0126173003,
-0.0732738003,
-0.015207313,
0.0124821384,
0.0004910771,
0.0125603992,
0.0212966148,
0.0521833301,
0.0285226312,
0.0494683869,
0.0425386429,
-0.0572436377,
0.0066644708,
-0.00465059,
0.0248101316,
0.0266888365,
0.0114202555,
-0.0175938345,
-0.0295980033,
-0.011081554,
-0.0029645818,
0.0066677625,
0.063306354,
-0.0209117886,
-0.0335184895,
-0.0081116837,
-0.0364468768,
0.0151765672,
0.0288735516,
0.0207667891,
0.0216194373,
-0.0267179329,
0.0122299204,
-0.0632037371,
-0.0613067821,
0.0264743213,
0.0038985203,
-0.0069392468,
0.026661586,
-0.00104808,
0.0402014554,
0.0545179211,
0.0036472674,
0.0158971213,
0.0377865471,
0.0142609356,
-0.0534595586,
-0.0092161773,
-0.0044220276,
-0.0418811403,
0.041242905,
-0.0616753697,
-0.0137300445,
0.0228124075,
-0.0133760152,
-0.0267816447,
-0.0106476462,
-0.0136867939,
0.0121035473,
-0.0372275114,
-0.0474595837,
0.0026992264,
-0.0104387822,
-0.0434537493,
0.0278203283,
0.0057980204,
0.0386317484,
0.0243227184,
-0.0251039043,
0.0145046972,
-0.0308844261,
-0.0579975992,
-0.0397304446,
0.0048759603,
0.0193078257,
0.0435182899,
-0.0209341794,
-0.0555484146,
0.0171012133,
-0.1059870049,
-0.015637299,
-0.0021196341,
-0.0201685168,
0.0273355823,
0.0017766346,
0.0266524293,
-0.032493718,
-0.0405804776,
-0.0418415405,
-0.0280239321,
0.0621664114,
0.0243588928,
0.0232045725,
0.0244735703,
-0.0288361609,
-0.0222942997,
-0.0179956593,
0.0186535921,
0.0515015088,
-0.0229471885,
-0.0257055201,
-0.0147796581,
-0.0711305067,
0.0306104105,
0.0090994928,
-0.023419762,
0.0024535514,
0.0179966688,
0.0070478646,
0.0163405947,
-0.022710884,
0.0494586341,
0.0396220423,
0.0249239057,
-0.0506213009,
-0.0034172148,
-0.0392955653,
-0.0128216576,
-0.0054860385,
-0.0349045582,
-0.007684371,
0.0499634743,
0.0276885387,
-0.0381928012,
-0.0808000192,
0.0183438268,
-0.0582058057,
-0.0375591144,
-0.0412267335,
0.0203688797,
-0.0113282343,
0.0500859059,
-0.0174690858,
-0.0111107007,
0.0773788169,
0.0263908356,
0.0089349365,
-0.0284866877,
0.0274620112,
-0.03403835,
0.0068649985,
0.0066064317,
-0.0109410873,
0.0127897263,
0.0358238481,
-0.0132057872,
0.015722977,
0.0370723978,
-0.0249046795,
-0.0377920195,
-0.0362439193,
0.0112600205,
0.0046592937,
-0.042513825,
0.001818486,
-0.0734756365,
-0.0175479297,
0.0050879037,
0.0237255078,
-0.010824197,
0.0061380253,
-0.0241949204,
0.004607813,
0.0017417023,
0.007128384,
-0.0238366127,
0.0069167609,
0.016241448,
0.0370917805,
0.0199690275,
0.0040356503,
-0.0258512106,
-0.0334117785,
0.0572965182,
0.0454854406,
0.032987427,
-0.008749974,
-0.0183150209,
0.0239730254,
-0.0013517006,
-0.0223690644,
-0.0073220567,
0.0782634318,
-0.0365879796,
0.0146227526,
0.0836849064,
0.0264355745,
-0.0543276817,
-0.0059307236,
-0.0037959707,
0.0655565113,
0.0509572104,
-0.0043337564,
-0.1075395048,
-0.0316419266,
-0.0299746953,
0.062135078,
-0.0428952836,
-0.0504586957,
0.0206873808,
-0.1271644235,
0.0207577683,
-0.028607972,
-0.0264399834,
0.0235849079,
-0.0654879957,
0.0323416479,
-0.0359334573,
-0.0279079378,
-0.0244780146,
0.0509035327,
0.0423043892,
0.0615704842,
-0.0496004783,
-0.0354051851,
0.0189706907,
-0.035021618,
0.0930031911,
0.0570528693,
0.0269437581,
-0.0206750371,
-0.0250417814,
0.0552862473,
-0.0114317462,
-0.0144782392,
-0.0039931517,
0.1222888455,
-0.0097072702,
-0.0119474335,
-0.0259162541,
0.0375600792,
-0.0496088937,
0.0063153384,
-0.0065723374,
0.0581662469,
0.0114728939,
-0.0101179397,
-0.0485537983,
0.0207876917,
0.0193704329,
0.083840929,
0.0154255908,
-0.0852334127,
-0.0143230818,
-0.0283781197,
-0.0058726734,
-0.0287023149,
-0.0459145531,
0.0482721105,
-0.0187810119,
-0.0534212068,
-0.0460054167,
-0.0760952607,
0.0423702896,
0.0334249176,
0.0401037745,
-0.0025055285,
-0.0151167493,
-0.0057210498,
-0.0192668717,
0.0358855613,
-0.0310606286,
-0.0048738015,
-0.0165033955,
-0.0536285006,
0.0228555053,
0.0134408344,
-0.0367076732,
0.0273407437,
-0.0760584027,
-0.0541802123,
0.0402240865,
0.0575430542,
0.0172683336,
0.0453563593,
0.003084017,
-0.0447368361,
0.0182009414,
0.0805996582,
0.0066811657,
0.0030670762,
-0.0045674867,
0.0229031891,
-0.00365552,
0.0174230244,
-0.0170015823,
0.0025039699,
0.04993397,
0.010888122,
-0.0031076418,
-0.0234102253,
0.0441792458,
0.0174931735,
0.0657539591,
-0.0000712509,
-0.0274716932,
-0.0084142797,
-0.0366866924,
-0.0122338571,
-0.0608685948,
-0.0411624983,
-0.006868314,
0.0225648433,
-0.0186129138,
-0.0350158252,
0.0096519431,
-0.0002896267,
0.0716089681,
-0.0529252999,
0.0237896442,
0.097282812,
-0.0156412516,
-0.0056347968,
-0.001248288,
0.0042831912,
0.0111335218,
0.0047824904,
0.0268799849,
0.0371938832,
-0.0018070161,
0.0366636962,
0.0136527885,
0.0084966281,
-0.0259108692,
-0.0424533598,
-0.0199602041,
-0.0315933451,
0.0703706145,
-0.0352942422,
-0.0036303417,
0.0083868066,
-0.0139878001,
-0.0207089297,
-0.0153184514,
0.0251829103,
0.0118208164,
-0.0127476947,
0.0335684419,
-0.0019054577,
-0.0435065329,
-0.0004080948,
0.0715811178,
-0.0175164063,
0.0567494333,
-0.03440037,
-0.0402928963,
-0.0537941419,
0.0512745902,
-0.0297413338,
0.0101725943,
0.0157543235,
0.0180253964,
-0.0517002828,
-0.0420837328,
0.0165041406,
-0.0029655513,
0.0128259743,
0.0197236594,
0.0345806256,
0.0511055738,
-0.026644703,
-0.0223999452,
-0.0602341369,
0.0022315453,
-0.0128098736,
-0.0225617904,
-0.0421959944,
-6.586834106e-33,
-0.0126623157,
-0.0469825156,
-0.0446234494,
0.0315485038,
0.0132801626,
0.0010602862,
0.0125640249,
0.0391949564,
0.012043938,
0.0430250913,
0.00129396,
0.0335591622,
0.0180474706,
0.0216964092,
0.0424903929,
-0.0269897338,
0.0563346371,
-0.0181937348,
-0.0351489037,
0.0093575027,
0.0240328293,
0.001022534,
0.0696434304,
-0.0956157893,
0.1126351058,
0.012776155,
-0.0268244725,
0.0077227745,
-0.0365894586,
0.0415431783,
-0.0007578627,
0.0837850347,
0.0179419648,
-0.0362862274,
-0.018933773,
-0.0029105064,
-0.0486872308,
-0.0220900495,
0.0032965187,
0.027904477,
-0.0443753004,
-0.019518977,
0.0490294881,
0.0047708182,
-0.0409653224,
0.0076076561,
0.0771641582,
-0.0244749747,
-0.0024167986,
-0.0198197197,
0.0011912114,
0.0247816853,
-0.0220245402,
-0.0090624988,
-0.0199276656,
0.0660511702,
0.0009329725,
0.0140581457,
-0.0639249831,
0.0175695308,
0.0117541673,
0.0228749756,
0.0000771622,
-0.0170735978,
0.0203736201,
0.0634284541,
0.0300300661,
0.0519142449,
0.0024385278,
-0.0405992754,
0.0052513848,
-0.0101134349,
0.0391066261,
0.0900036767,
0.037668515,
0.0155670205,
0.0076782838,
0.0328384675,
-0.0082339542,
-0.0236150827,
0.059811037,
0.0134603567,
-0.0508179106,
-0.0274561159,
-0.0331422202,
-0.0773579702,
-0.0352476835,
-0.0050192894,
0.0131007163,
-0.0008982318,
-0.0458298102,
0.0167463664,
0.0048306081,
-0.0417579636,
-0.0405391045,
-0.0183236208,
-0.0049267528,
0.0400623232,
0.0045699133,
-0.0358431228,
-0.038567923,
0.0471755564,
-0.0016464774,
0.0314547196,
0.028916005,
-0.0275879856,
0.0825588331,
0.0129357986,
-0.0631110817,
-0.0302224867,
-0.0208030697,
0.0381077528,
-0.0049142698,
0.0011641039,
0.0303327926,
0.0299003012,
-0.0367777944,
-0.0018643187,
0.0272666793,
0.036293719,
-0.0303660817,
-0.0080387741,
-0.0215142295,
-0.0410021432,
-0.010074703,
-0.0370342322,
-0.0012411476,
-0.0098716058,
-0.0368774831,
-0.005029507,
-0.0130068604,
-0.0285728872,
2.5e-7,
0.0764151067,
0.0164927002,
0.0145509513,
-0.0298451167,
0.0081925467,
0.0410803072,
0.0207715798,
-0.0024732372,
0.0391456746,
-0.055480551,
0.0064346767,
-0.0223272443,
0.0240471456,
0.0290801078,
-0.1211371347,
-0.02178308,
-0.057861656,
0.0257766414,
-0.0161295552,
0.0006960937,
0.0240758415,
0.076567322,
0.0644099861,
-0.0069960984,
-0.0153228147,
0.0290669817,
0.058686886,
-0.0358484052,
-0.0192293078,
0.0164931398,
0.0625394657,
-0.0303053483,
0.033945214,
0.0179474987,
-0.032022424,
-0.0444691591,
0.0207502563,
0.0121878283,
0.0000122847,
-0.0666618422,
0.0238647033,
0.0540049821,
0.031226391,
-0.0042613209,
0.0447116978,
-0.0384198949,
-0.0657565668,
-0.0410960205,
-0.0336015634,
-0.007573917,
0.0669855922,
-0.0082411803,
-0.0281932093,
-0.0106018353,
-0.011495471,
0.0009475052,
-0.0605317764,
-0.0327291489,
-0.0380241312,
-0.0142300241,
-0.03555087,
-0.0658586025,
0.0026560193,
-0.0083271256,
-0.030816704,
-0.0889001265,
0.0274991002,
1.925759704e-34,
0.0376612768,
0.0237162448,
0.0217514783,
0.025530776,
0.0308559593,
0.0117061865,
-0.0026265075,
-0.0067386664,
0.0396819338,
-0.0103173871,
-0.0206415933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15068v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15068v2 | ToMChallenges: A Principle-Guided Dataset and Diverse Evaluation Tasks for Exploring Theory of Mind | 2023-05-24T11:54:07 | 2023-10-23T22:16:15 | Xiaomeng Ma, Lingyu Gao, Qihui Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Theory of Mind (ToM), the capacity to comprehend the mental states of
distinct individuals, is essential for numerous practical applications. With
the development of large language models (LLMs), there is a heated debate about
whether they are able to perform ToM tasks. Previous studies have used
different tasks and prompts to test the ToM on LLMs and the results are
inconsistent: some studies asserted these models are capable of exhibiting ToM,
while others suggest the opposite. In this study, We present ToMChallenges, a
dataset for comprehensively evaluating the Theory of Mind based on the
Sally-Anne and Smarties tests with a diverse set of tasks. In addition, we also
propose an auto-grader to streamline the answer evaluation process. We tested
three models: davinci, turbo, and gpt-4. Our evaluation results and error
analyses show that LLMs have inconsistent behaviors across prompts and tasks.
Performing the ToM tasks robustly remains a challenge for the LLMs. In
addition, our paper wants to raise awareness in evaluating the ToM in LLMs and
we want to invite more discussion on how to design the prompts and tasks for
ToM tasks that can better assess the LLMs' ability. | [
0.0471071303,
0.0367157757,
-0.0530189797,
0.034329433,
-0.0450373143,
0.0243672486,
0.0209189691,
0.00605735,
0.0107120583,
-0.0084379837,
-0.0479936786,
-0.0465556569,
0.0110990712,
0.0041011735,
0.035038013,
-0.0651852936,
0.0323490798,
-0.0358892083,
0.0285468344,
-0.0106589096,
-0.0255620442,
0.0178651549,
-0.0145498104,
0.0179816559,
0.0364555605,
-0.0222196747,
-0.0191549864,
-0.0368757173,
0.0460946858,
-0.0514582321,
-0.0391058736,
0.0481462367,
0.00192326,
0.0517736077,
0.0000021982,
-0.0642535165,
0.0202273112,
-0.0136633897,
-0.0051561068,
0.0131991226,
0.0007677077,
0.043716222,
0.0466359816,
0.019840328,
-0.0566110425,
-0.0214178134,
0.008852114,
0.0585965253,
0.0434108265,
0.0327335298,
-0.0033303576,
0.004819782,
0.0287982225,
-0.0240389407,
0.0670421794,
-0.039607428,
0.0350204147,
-0.0074505638,
0.0251228064,
-0.0269225724,
-0.0168148521,
0.0179565828,
0.0049347323,
0.020301329,
-0.00923065,
0.0041332976,
-0.0213398188,
-0.0249000136,
-0.0043708687,
0.0670411512,
0.0939707011,
0.0128418682,
-0.0197081324,
0.0094937319,
0.0143576553,
0.044278387,
-0.0381840765,
0.0129464502,
-0.0038602038,
-0.0082927747,
0.0096185384,
0.0295208935,
-0.0135456808,
0.0043772361,
-0.0176072046,
0.0536061414,
-0.0145267528,
-0.0216137636,
0.0177262705,
-0.003798811,
-0.058399532,
-0.0597613007,
-0.0437211394,
0.0108725885,
-0.0180348977,
-0.0005549025,
-0.0157845635,
0.0130370548,
0.0099850018,
-0.0098495986,
0.1152779311,
0.0434205085,
-0.0215898491,
0.0229175054,
0.0068191239,
0.0738711879,
0.004264751,
0.0238331016,
-0.0227637477,
0.0356722437,
-0.0745688528,
-0.0037707922,
-0.0022136196,
0.0489462353,
0.0415255092,
-0.0108071342,
-0.0293574836,
-0.0153939361,
-0.0315941684,
-0.0269386806,
-0.0234826617,
-0.0128512755,
0.0339936726,
0.0072954562,
-0.0517902337,
0.0397784524,
-0.065830186,
0.0274201985,
0.0142470505,
-0.0591351129,
-0.0132191554,
-0.0132191423,
0.0175412148,
0.0069438624,
0.0100688748,
0.0173623562,
0.0171997137,
-0.027877178,
-0.0063988427,
-0.039216686,
0.0008763097,
-0.0863008425,
0.0104028052,
-0.0399255753,
-0.0024594103,
0.024022501,
-0.0027666562,
0.0027761988,
0.0224720929,
0.0232346132,
-0.0527515598,
0.0579431728,
-0.0061682179,
0.0101945084,
-0.0162408967,
0.0181956273,
-0.0074010082,
0.0338012017,
0.003358915,
-0.0059284298,
0.0187402572,
-0.0031494754,
0.026130164,
0.0034826288,
-0.0070644338,
-0.0250541996,
-0.0075279935,
0.0176512152,
0.0126111889,
0.0506663024,
-0.0061103366,
0.04822791,
-0.009603411,
0.0015899347,
0.0532887131,
0.0803685561,
-0.0286623742,
-0.0189745706,
0.0354496539,
0.0222560018,
0.0679137111,
0.0352068543,
-0.0438622348,
0.0241973754,
-0.0450346656,
-0.0166610759,
0.0236042347,
0.0117348088,
-0.0414659195,
-0.0132551212,
-0.0372305736,
0.0248682965,
0.0286105573,
0.0245527755,
0.0251323022,
-0.0350295082,
0.0009984151,
0.0081043318,
0.0231077988,
-0.0496306457,
-0.0341618583,
-0.0661688298,
0.0195815209,
0.0378792658,
0.0366615094,
-0.0256968886,
-0.0382532887,
-0.0212217402,
0.0067084809,
0.041291073,
0.0723343864,
0.0086675799,
-0.0399414301,
-0.0337854326,
-0.0067225238,
-0.0388191044,
0.0033178688,
0.0168672688,
-0.0340059288,
0.0024451723,
-0.0028612912,
-0.0420430265,
0.0070387353,
0.0189617723,
0.0067088539,
-0.0293813813,
-0.0623912513,
0.0126671363,
0.0414174683,
0.0277293362,
-0.006819597,
0.0129158506,
0.0150633072,
-0.0004890978,
0.0180874877,
0.0304771867,
-0.0344969854,
0.0107519757,
0.0371163189,
-0.0470341519,
-0.0357442386,
0.076262787,
0.0230727289,
-0.0494068973,
0.0059798295,
-0.0426837988,
0.0001917539,
-0.0335779823,
0.0319131166,
-0.0477484204,
0.0169200301,
0.0056444989,
0.0630980134,
-0.0186406001,
0.0579351857,
0.0069253286,
-0.0690040886,
0.0709684864,
-0.0090417434,
-0.0252971407,
-0.0110465186,
-0.0006140916,
-0.0024651068,
0.0202818923,
-0.0030560347,
-0.0498130172,
-0.020488847,
-0.1049652919,
-0.0460676849,
0.0247607119,
0.0010488166,
0.0035363396,
-0.0230124854,
-0.0299475398,
0.0208152402,
-0.0659939572,
0.0671864673,
0.0471899658,
0.022914229,
0.0083359983,
-0.0275578666,
-0.0060495688,
-0.0219464079,
0.0123250624,
-0.0543853566,
0.033869274,
0.0097296145,
0.0099247545,
-0.0243324395,
0.0260244943,
-0.0556733385,
0.0056176959,
-0.0145824682,
-0.0563734882,
0.0502712652,
0.0007429896,
0.0126927951,
0.061288815,
-0.0048874533,
0.0041725999,
0.0501435511,
-0.0117405355,
-0.0420002863,
0.0098388437,
0.0445221886,
0.0041120932,
-0.0290315244,
-0.0660846159,
-0.0291369874,
0.0733712837,
0.0384869538,
0.003980075,
-0.0764194801,
0.0656226575,
-0.0262331497,
-0.0398308747,
-0.0198632665,
0.0170093104,
-0.0265331753,
0.0561316572,
-0.0101654921,
-0.0248025991,
0.0951433182,
-0.036384739,
-0.0022279392,
-0.0329414941,
0.0496651866,
-0.0424423069,
0.0783729255,
0.0173522048,
-0.0015522673,
0.034653496,
-0.0099587487,
-0.0735755935,
-0.0035223051,
-0.0262964554,
-0.0256266445,
0.009833944,
-0.0410886072,
-0.0261481963,
0.004174408,
0.0167715345,
-0.0473818816,
0.0077752583,
-0.0689210221,
0.0110489922,
0.0029591597,
-0.0090077119,
-0.0369392075,
-0.0169051532,
0.0624745339,
-0.0019041516,
-0.034171734,
-0.0158575717,
-0.0119794216,
-0.0088303098,
0.0557368137,
-0.007335851,
0.0345911756,
-0.039444875,
0.030745361,
0.036662329,
0.0287757181,
0.0527623706,
0.0366250686,
0.0068275002,
0.0433197841,
0.0302366335,
-0.0058076414,
0.0388816781,
0.0902419463,
-0.0133979432,
-0.0070272041,
0.1205430627,
0.0335430577,
-0.0318741314,
0.0030491396,
-0.0283597652,
-0.0196966641,
0.0393060073,
0.0089214751,
-0.0712139681,
-0.0141083114,
-0.0117158573,
0.0089683216,
-0.0291129723,
-0.0709711537,
-0.0101956809,
-0.0849917978,
0.005213907,
-0.0083840387,
0.0119398106,
-0.0013648684,
-0.0002144849,
0.0569411069,
0.0544570163,
-0.0005803402,
0.0029243864,
0.003349856,
0.0209620986,
-0.009187784,
-0.0027194961,
-0.013525351,
0.0984924361,
-0.0141670834,
0.0891167372,
0.0555729158,
0.0425643101,
-0.0122366464,
-0.0998528451,
0.007291785,
0.0187990554,
0.0059623523,
-0.0078065037,
0.0108874552,
0.0198410284,
0.0216859337,
-0.0136969564,
0.032364469,
-0.047748547,
0.0123582203,
0.0329425484,
0.0973798782,
-0.0134047084,
-0.0421480983,
0.0028980135,
0.0384582318,
-0.0461788923,
0.0839687437,
0.0635927394,
-0.0684464797,
0.0215863958,
-0.0071052252,
-0.0233738087,
-0.0016112769,
-0.0644344613,
0.0259470548,
0.0410918444,
-0.0131272115,
-0.0562642217,
-0.063232936,
0.0319335759,
0.0276213326,
0.006517096,
-0.0217866618,
0.0001555899,
0.0257122852,
-0.0370364115,
0.0188575201,
-0.0173781738,
0.0134742344,
-0.0480683818,
-0.0038165657,
0.00550257,
-0.048127804,
-0.0089667616,
-0.0005017116,
-0.03080016,
-0.0561773367,
0.0416507162,
0.0219147652,
0.0318727158,
-0.0155253792,
0.0186967682,
-0.0415328108,
0.0280812643,
-0.0498082861,
-0.0520611405,
0.0601086654,
0.0054576932,
0.0477468409,
0.0087456238,
0.0504145473,
0.0002796641,
0.0241860189,
0.0227370709,
-0.005623288,
0.0257092845,
-0.0254679956,
0.0113039939,
0.0273679122,
0.0359865464,
0.021177236,
0.0130184693,
-0.0188005026,
-0.0286045112,
-0.046637971,
-0.0040877522,
-0.0559568182,
-0.0317800753,
0.0348476656,
0.0071696299,
-0.0179947075,
-0.0819526389,
-0.0458876006,
0.0030561732,
-0.0172488354,
0.0302994959,
0.000126433,
0.0397778861,
-0.004371223,
-0.0014446914,
-0.0227660164,
-0.0343272947,
-0.0535391308,
0.0064035365,
0.0240556169,
0.1264825761,
0.0155966925,
-0.0143278949,
-0.0065616439,
0.0151744252,
-0.0721904263,
-0.0752463192,
0.0307416078,
-0.0017780459,
-0.0192282386,
0.0178166702,
0.0013915239,
-0.0352369547,
0.0287766308,
0.0072271251,
-0.0063683894,
-0.0055135498,
-0.0267559495,
0.0124263372,
0.0220585484,
0.0018678773,
-0.0248375162,
0.0572969988,
-0.0430309139,
0.0066240756,
0.0022960221,
-0.0147510208,
-0.0521118827,
0.0439036787,
-0.041510161,
0.0741764754,
0.0095840842,
0.0470777154,
-0.0810380355,
-0.0402771309,
0.0408743359,
0.0155744636,
-0.0085780695,
-0.0159211271,
0.0252001062,
0.0674088001,
-0.0102929799,
-0.0561971441,
0.0008240307,
-0.0115063954,
-0.0360888727,
-0.0318501294,
-0.0253330376,
-6.729510467e-33,
-0.0173497871,
-0.0015112882,
-0.0004583927,
0.0101639992,
-0.0303008035,
-0.0079406565,
-0.049984362,
0.0473492332,
-0.0316965878,
0.0079332553,
-0.0311388578,
0.0025661315,
-0.0019536684,
0.0147813139,
0.0352446362,
-0.0118914396,
0.0019978676,
-0.0229514614,
-0.0433770157,
-0.0023482689,
0.0040468588,
-0.0211449098,
0.0670481697,
-0.0781902894,
0.0611745603,
0.020517366,
0.0275505278,
0.0121861957,
-0.0255192146,
0.0024381692,
-0.0467285998,
0.0713893548,
0.0436907858,
-0.0400753543,
-0.0071399659,
0.00884273,
-0.0182908047,
-0.0694985464,
0.0628683195,
-0.0126221534,
-0.0201853178,
-0.0455662198,
-0.011359904,
-0.025559321,
-0.03988415,
-0.0136763649,
0.0301858988,
-0.0072818724,
0.0482718721,
0.0526354648,
-0.0514074601,
-0.0293294713,
-0.0047853505,
-0.029953355,
-0.0163907614,
0.0301560163,
-0.0169686675,
-0.0508941822,
-0.0602543391,
0.0403653793,
0.0389090292,
0.0042886529,
0.0350418761,
-0.0302753486,
0.0313077196,
0.0686966851,
0.0704503432,
0.0135494899,
-0.0232768785,
-0.0330533758,
0.0325614549,
0.0396290049,
0.0701526254,
0.0362942182,
-0.0131642325,
-0.0265223999,
-0.0158574693,
-0.0033758387,
0.0607416406,
0.025124548,
0.0573559776,
-0.0231428798,
-0.0392178334,
-0.0153436689,
-0.0467449613,
-0.0493606217,
-0.0424363539,
0.0031190622,
0.0244362205,
-0.0284843817,
0.0013034499,
-0.0483127572,
0.0460550077,
-0.0400660373,
0.0242299959,
-0.014185546,
-0.0241079573,
0.0544797108,
0.0157538448,
0.0056394376,
-0.0449250229,
0.0067675896,
-0.0053589866,
0.0295082089,
0.0467471257,
-0.0103330268,
-0.0270425789,
-0.0175219681,
-0.054029163,
-0.0286927298,
-0.0337344445,
0.0188475568,
0.0068183732,
-0.0518092103,
0.0248003136,
0.0134552289,
-0.0107671758,
-0.0313605368,
-0.0164224673,
-0.0693852603,
-0.0621900596,
0.027795149,
-0.0199604612,
0.0072404305,
-0.0214796551,
-0.0039499695,
-0.0307030547,
-0.0177308563,
0.0336265601,
-0.0063312631,
-0.0030585548,
0.0149598476,
2.976e-7,
-0.0108941672,
0.0565277673,
-0.0212882888,
-0.0117948214,
0.0176406298,
0.0622888394,
-0.0203863084,
0.0103801601,
0.0566827916,
-0.0453755818,
-0.0277506169,
0.0199842993,
0.0583503209,
0.0411617719,
-0.060723763,
-0.0236880127,
0.0147115765,
-0.0005371666,
-0.0347837694,
0.0319897272,
0.0493489318,
0.0144152315,
0.0383863151,
0.0085389353,
-0.0111043928,
0.0306622684,
0.0169417467,
-0.0383878127,
0.0198414885,
0.0061470415,
0.0338223465,
-0.0302334279,
0.0276389103,
0.0446652211,
0.0367531925,
0.0298629086,
-0.0088359658,
-0.0054568043,
-0.0156898275,
-0.0435598604,
-0.0091381688,
-0.0006006802,
-0.0199619643,
-0.0685116425,
0.0586562678,
-0.061624784,
-0.0673138797,
0.0327342227,
0.0119189313,
-0.0063062832,
0.0153823942,
0.0424735323,
-0.0034373393,
0.0268518124,
0.0152475992,
-0.024274705,
0.0080051022,
-0.056696564,
0.0203106273,
-0.0269962996,
-0.0398809277,
-0.0677456558,
-0.0451260805,
-0.025199255,
-0.0038197064,
-0.0955780894,
0.0048631686,
2.624419249e-34,
0.0166399125,
-0.0073421933,
0.045940984,
-0.0429275297,
0.0478937998,
-0.0312565789,
-0.0069264523,
0.0223898813,
0.037564978,
-0.1254247278,
-0.0269843638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15067v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15067v3 | Not All Metrics Are Guilty: Improving NLG Evaluation by Diversifying References | 2023-05-24T11:53:29 | 2024-05-25T03:39:55 | Tianyi Tang, Hongyuan Lu, Yuchen Eleanor Jiang, Haoyang Huang, Dongdong Zhang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Tom Kocmi, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most research about natural language generation (NLG) relies on evaluation
benchmarks with limited references for a sample, which may result in poor
correlations with human judgements. The underlying reason is that one semantic
meaning can actually be expressed in different forms, and the evaluation with a
single or few references may not accurately reflect the quality of the model's
hypotheses. To address this issue, this paper presents a simple and effective
method, named Div-Ref, to enhance existing evaluation benchmarks by enriching
the number of references. We leverage large language models (LLMs) to diversify
the expression of a single reference into multiple high-quality ones to cover
the semantic space of the reference sentence as much as possible. We conduct
comprehensive experiments to empirically demonstrate that diversifying the
expression of reference can significantly enhance the correlation between
automatic evaluation and human evaluation. This idea is compatible with recent
LLM-based evaluation which can similarly derive advantages from incorporating
multiple references. We strongly encourage future generation benchmarks to
include more references, even if they are generated by LLMs, which is once for
all. We release all the code and data at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/Div-Ref to
facilitate research. | [
0.0346723497,
0.0485610552,
0.0170468818,
0.0083247032,
-0.0343925506,
-0.0155785168,
0.0286377445,
-0.0015570441,
-0.0180750303,
-0.088066183,
-0.0286720358,
-0.0467719734,
0.0246436242,
-0.0049581933,
0.0325138122,
-0.0463726856,
0.0351189896,
-0.0135598499,
0.0086799106,
0.0157514606,
-0.0042999792,
0.0199974775,
0.0089990534,
0.0595214181,
-0.0233770814,
0.0223668348,
0.0339638554,
0.016904423,
0.0252134521,
-0.0561394989,
-0.0072139474,
0.0446838327,
-0.023453407,
0.0163940191,
0.0000019841,
-0.0552505478,
-0.0179369636,
0.0125100017,
0.0089693647,
0.0513806418,
0.0732869431,
0.0027820074,
0.0261152387,
0.0117156096,
-0.0324094221,
-0.0294115711,
0.0149725303,
0.0274238698,
0.0843073279,
0.0591978692,
0.0155160734,
-0.011486317,
-0.0121453041,
-0.0310483929,
0.012617371,
-0.0467021503,
-0.0075681675,
0.0478479005,
-0.0041742153,
-0.0009480969,
0.012379284,
0.0050572944,
-0.0076436014,
0.0023412183,
0.0400236025,
0.0328448825,
-0.056909129,
-0.0360979848,
0.0080416156,
0.0797036961,
-0.0381445922,
0.007145341,
0.0090850275,
-0.0008299021,
0.0029783433,
-0.0014899643,
-0.0273604672,
0.0320201591,
-0.0079186372,
0.0175354965,
0.0186167322,
0.0432442725,
0.039204441,
0.0477448627,
0.0195461512,
0.0459603332,
0.0415918939,
-0.0068711312,
0.0093350112,
0.0197636262,
-0.0077750674,
-0.0326079838,
-0.0175221581,
0.0017113825,
-0.0524128117,
0.0412120484,
-0.0601614751,
-0.0209547542,
0.0564449131,
-0.0276923887,
0.0614689253,
0.0211560056,
-0.0026981356,
0.0160438903,
-0.0439120419,
0.0547667928,
-0.0027189506,
-0.0351970345,
-0.0562844314,
-0.0049663158,
-0.0487885401,
0.0076693571,
-0.0495976768,
0.0377639309,
-0.0464792401,
-0.0531307608,
-0.069671914,
-0.013030434,
-0.0160413999,
-0.0347405821,
0.0179707352,
0.0184919257,
-0.030547725,
0.0260083098,
-0.0178887192,
0.0027069745,
-0.0463410765,
0.0068758787,
0.033774361,
-0.0735163093,
0.0069752927,
0.0356987268,
-0.0066201827,
-0.0292232987,
-0.0156394746,
0.0725479126,
-0.006632241,
-0.0067259674,
-0.0389941894,
-0.0711308494,
-0.045115035,
-0.0694247112,
-0.008711298,
-0.0932082906,
0.0222117379,
0.0174863636,
0.0004250072,
-0.0669092238,
0.0388242193,
0.0234860666,
-0.0289578456,
0.0183880199,
-0.0233780798,
0.0000516058,
0.0236316174,
0.0249280352,
0.0198722798,
0.0574747548,
0.051876761,
-0.0005399842,
0.045086991,
0.0096935565,
0.0007106622,
0.0206651911,
0.0093395673,
0.0033360529,
0.0244822074,
-0.0303867646,
-0.024516074,
0.0492879376,
0.029773673,
0.0835760608,
-0.0350184254,
0.019871112,
0.0359612815,
-0.0193796847,
0.0029100142,
0.0102814995,
0.1070585698,
0.0444906503,
0.0087319389,
0.0080887536,
-0.0023926923,
0.0170698334,
0.0048867487,
0.0317454003,
0.0909176394,
0.0427932739,
0.0054793046,
-0.0396011472,
-0.0216497015,
0.0114316586,
-0.0074879355,
-0.0408311449,
0.0132206492,
0.048118785,
-0.0605209619,
0.0979860574,
0.0328193828,
-0.0782381967,
0.0501298383,
-0.0252839588,
0.0305913091,
0.0406008102,
0.057800442,
0.0439395234,
-0.0301939081,
0.00931904,
-0.0148453703,
0.0629405454,
0.0526972637,
0.0056226412,
0.0138118407,
-0.0615783222,
-0.0259662271,
-0.036234118,
0.0265007578,
0.0120401867,
0.0326959193,
-0.0011673118,
0.0715857819,
-0.0667473003,
-0.0511852764,
0.037111979,
-0.0106254676,
0.00729706,
0.0307475384,
-0.0176369678,
0.0344719738,
0.01126449,
-0.0374779329,
0.0431232192,
0.0067094923,
-0.0333044454,
0.0062120869,
0.0178375095,
-0.0331329815,
-0.0275041871,
0.0172700807,
-0.0763391405,
0.0270595942,
0.0050495579,
-0.0388720892,
-0.0480169281,
0.012256817,
-0.0540033542,
-0.0040791538,
-0.027661778,
0.0173831675,
0.0373319499,
0.033940427,
-0.0346269496,
0.0689808428,
0.0046531796,
0.0303369127,
0.0296686813,
0.0331940129,
0.0454342589,
-0.0329193175,
-0.0334434286,
-0.0272549894,
-0.0309220031,
0.0180343017,
0.0433750935,
0.0440616198,
-0.0816493034,
-0.0422724746,
-0.0588913932,
0.0240961034,
-0.0065304022,
0.0117884008,
0.0200050976,
-0.0072247651,
0.0159457326,
0.0202417858,
-0.0324668251,
-0.0415353253,
0.0348975807,
0.0108344248,
0.0311424639,
0.0216178782,
-0.012802653,
-0.0472618192,
0.0137765398,
0.0288140159,
0.0587133393,
0.043765977,
0.0414893851,
-0.0330576114,
0.0120305223,
-0.0555524528,
-0.060009934,
0.0256689917,
-0.0406097993,
0.0127393324,
0.025422683,
0.0701459423,
-0.0130882645,
0.0356677286,
-0.0032830543,
0.0556638762,
-0.0145163331,
-0.0443814844,
-0.0169587079,
-0.0188547764,
-0.0066331411,
0.0021072328,
-0.0539295711,
0.0098173255,
0.0359314531,
0.0227341671,
-0.0016727824,
-0.0439710915,
0.0408421122,
-0.0442159474,
-0.0405604579,
-0.0288281944,
-0.0143306712,
-0.0072363317,
0.0291422736,
-0.021587057,
-0.0622416101,
0.0449566059,
-0.0591387525,
-0.0048582153,
-0.0388544872,
0.0201492291,
-0.0481993593,
0.0381254852,
-0.0077849557,
0.0166783221,
0.0069893347,
0.0068043107,
-0.0514136739,
0.0189715959,
0.0144893853,
-0.0353148766,
0.0493210517,
-0.0616135746,
0.0010462902,
-0.0016065072,
-0.0087314397,
-0.0528465211,
-0.0411117151,
-0.0239461958,
0.0138875125,
0.0420227833,
0.0119253229,
-0.0393759422,
0.010054783,
0.0278035328,
-0.0136866663,
-0.0177080203,
-0.0091325082,
0.0026760534,
0.0563438423,
0.0514989644,
-0.019460341,
0.014853349,
-0.0151997656,
-0.0101065449,
0.0036126908,
0.0066834758,
0.0472304262,
-0.028106926,
-0.0093297726,
-0.0003480723,
-0.0060307421,
-0.045961041,
0.0334235951,
0.0301168393,
-0.0427959077,
-0.0403097235,
0.1165634096,
0.0385551788,
-0.0058149984,
0.0102267126,
-0.0087790303,
0.0786680952,
0.0024123304,
0.007197089,
-0.0691622198,
-0.0456703268,
-0.0151521079,
0.0319062881,
-0.0047397688,
-0.0080529293,
-0.0260645989,
-0.1524283588,
0.020570701,
0.0353901759,
-0.0305763222,
-0.0011185292,
-0.0302849002,
-0.0185075346,
-0.0209491197,
-0.01171913,
0.0275208764,
-0.0089308098,
0.0388493501,
0.0154597843,
-0.0299699008,
-0.0431810953,
0.0005118956,
-0.0369958654,
0.0424697921,
0.0560647771,
0.0428904966,
0.0244302005,
-0.0078758169,
0.0071322913,
-0.0735092685,
0.0122194719,
-0.013319714,
0.0454599559,
0.0082074106,
0.0013290646,
-0.010264487,
0.0063865441,
-0.0164780039,
-0.003127238,
-0.0034647959,
0.0373381525,
0.0112873865,
-0.0218382273,
-0.0236841086,
0.0477472097,
0.0186924469,
0.0905837789,
0.0332167111,
-0.032000076,
-0.0236574076,
-0.0057766917,
0.0024002967,
-0.0863108262,
-0.0119345421,
0.0378814191,
-0.0393793471,
-0.0204569902,
-0.1102331728,
-0.0408660471,
-0.0240173135,
0.0161072444,
-0.0046446724,
0.0056387922,
-0.012943415,
0.0153804179,
-0.0041094809,
0.0371006466,
-0.008916039,
0.0038284303,
-0.0484680384,
-0.0125434007,
0.0363345183,
-0.0373789817,
-0.0292098708,
0.0798557699,
-0.0520123281,
-0.0470189974,
-0.0218928345,
0.0571727008,
0.0203843135,
0.0055670119,
-0.0035540278,
-0.0393404216,
0.0050210399,
0.0414962843,
-0.0260269493,
0.0299111269,
-0.0062811705,
-0.0042043249,
-0.0171653423,
0.0248000585,
-0.0703439564,
0.0205737948,
-0.0213569924,
0.0848866031,
0.0226882026,
-0.0439413302,
0.0188786332,
0.0337249376,
0.0106494967,
-0.0903143063,
0.0470021404,
0.0073811994,
-0.0480386652,
-0.0027910888,
-0.0462591536,
-0.0606166013,
0.0218072031,
0.0251946747,
0.0028020062,
-0.0099393139,
0.0126738651,
-0.0267081074,
0.0630496591,
0.0128436526,
-0.0187639818,
0.0299130138,
0.0062735812,
-0.0108945947,
-0.0246143304,
-0.0296993386,
-0.0176661313,
-0.0527210608,
-0.0127630057,
-0.0305994265,
0.0193894394,
0.0065723932,
-0.0000379825,
0.0023661649,
0.0024484762,
-0.0221451707,
0.0238621999,
-0.043359153,
0.0025484674,
0.072893396,
0.0254225954,
0.11884664,
-0.0296731759,
-0.0003530873,
-0.0264118835,
0.0604050718,
0.0053452589,
-0.0530690849,
0.0069280802,
0.0066729682,
-0.035772752,
-0.018688878,
0.0895835236,
0.02948137,
0.0256280694,
-0.0050184461,
-0.0083818398,
-0.0493316874,
-0.0228765216,
-0.0524325706,
0.0054565854,
0.0030298654,
0.0282470062,
-0.0760071129,
-0.0444434248,
0.0278196577,
0.0163181238,
0.0375904106,
0.0012936024,
0.0701915771,
0.0333528742,
-0.0327320397,
0.0088494532,
-0.047764197,
-0.0207530241,
-0.0372939333,
-0.0041317027,
-0.0487770326,
-6.406391315e-33,
-0.0435174927,
-0.0665052906,
0.0074514234,
-0.0653918386,
-0.0448904894,
-0.0056992625,
-0.0411225632,
0.0249693617,
0.0006671593,
0.0147592118,
0.030483149,
-0.0349104106,
0.0174732152,
0.0405405052,
0.008505553,
-0.0050908141,
0.0408773348,
0.0158661753,
-0.0576087013,
0.020517841,
0.0259196684,
0.0133734979,
0.0150148133,
-0.0586120598,
0.0010671186,
-0.0021542679,
-0.0474853292,
-0.0229233466,
0.0259556323,
0.0693475753,
0.0005465219,
0.0556214899,
0.0228035115,
-0.0295941737,
-0.0233538635,
0.0008804426,
-0.0536782555,
-0.0159946922,
0.0427188389,
-0.0330784954,
-0.0222103205,
-0.0351584181,
0.0301465392,
-0.0089364201,
-0.0275019016,
0.0042188596,
0.0400896519,
-0.0514336266,
-0.0435943939,
-0.0481750183,
-0.0621938333,
0.0435538813,
-0.0078935986,
-0.0170574784,
-0.021247562,
0.0628602132,
-0.0374060497,
-0.0042349389,
-0.0059111947,
0.0459119454,
-0.0145851886,
0.0408214107,
0.0680672899,
0.0155846691,
-0.0216279421,
0.0380463265,
-0.005099664,
-0.0230537839,
-0.0070291185,
-0.0439092219,
-0.0061964761,
0.0630620793,
0.047960069,
0.0822997168,
0.0176064651,
0.0058833486,
-0.0576591194,
0.042937696,
0.0051221615,
0.0108358944,
0.0322215818,
-0.0220509265,
0.0048924838,
-0.0007510961,
-0.0696570575,
-0.0148409465,
-0.035099566,
-0.0401916392,
0.0529160909,
0.0307663176,
-0.0161935128,
-0.0204463452,
0.0355233327,
-0.005206767,
0.0030148795,
0.0687971264,
-0.0556896292,
0.0062626419,
-0.0208956134,
-0.0134439496,
-0.0170376021,
-0.0416288525,
0.0359824859,
0.0360990167,
0.0113920653,
-0.0164147802,
0.029406758,
-0.0153776892,
-0.0425854847,
0.0352273136,
-0.0367689468,
0.0304280501,
-0.0278524011,
-0.0350175612,
0.010797753,
-0.0226597078,
-0.0462511592,
0.027780449,
0.0055728205,
0.0251900442,
0.0196320787,
-0.0182860084,
0.0173460748,
0.0212494917,
-0.0529118665,
0.0395270698,
-0.0134469168,
-0.0229791086,
0.030151695,
-0.0041707954,
-0.0305125732,
-0.002116303,
2.646e-7,
0.0360885449,
0.038051635,
0.0102695264,
0.0268553458,
-0.0163591933,
0.0020801083,
-0.0023235311,
0.0204598308,
-0.0155947777,
0.0155318277,
-0.0135173295,
-0.0189473424,
0.0686759055,
0.0126148965,
-0.0477070212,
-0.0205051061,
-0.0764198601,
0.0183686484,
-0.0327119678,
-0.0267783813,
0.0221179463,
0.0760399252,
-0.0119054634,
-0.001834392,
-0.0285705775,
-0.0670646727,
0.0828559548,
-0.0159274936,
-0.0175883714,
0.0355354585,
0.0620428436,
0.0223803744,
-0.0071680248,
-0.0169217754,
-0.0259549562,
0.0028960339,
0.0530707203,
0.0605679713,
0.0416943878,
-0.0198796429,
0.0247123111,
-0.0034931293,
0.0003344592,
-0.03809857,
0.0288111027,
-0.0407470986,
-0.0241052173,
-0.0247124601,
-0.0562145039,
0.0247774608,
0.0047175707,
-0.0443917476,
-0.0347217135,
0.0138310613,
0.0222033355,
0.0022150003,
-0.0219550859,
-0.029397767,
-0.0598744676,
0.0254882611,
-0.0310580004,
-0.0391118899,
-0.0178009328,
0.0018251031,
0.0276450254,
-0.0549902879,
-0.0049669389,
2.181218848e-34,
0.0480978265,
-0.0288750641,
0.0090512326,
-0.0055965395,
0.049395524,
0.0045011281,
-0.0566210151,
0.01196789,
0.001234706,
-0.0539970174,
0.0000901196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15066v2 | GPT4Graph: Can Large Language Models Understand Graph Structured Data ? An Empirical Evaluation and Benchmarking | 2023-05-24T11:53:19 | 2023-07-11T15:08:00 | Jiayan Guo, Lun Du, Hengyu Liu, Mengyu Zhou, Xinyi He, Shi Han | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models~(LLM) like ChatGPT have become indispensable to
artificial general intelligence~(AGI), demonstrating excellent performance in
various natural language processing tasks. In the real world, graph data is
ubiquitous and an essential part of AGI and prevails in domains like social
network analysis, bioinformatics and recommender systems. The training corpus
of large language models often includes some algorithmic components, which
allows them to achieve certain effects on some graph data-related problems.
However, there is still little research on their performance on a broader range
of graph-structured data. In this study, we conduct an extensive investigation
to assess the proficiency of LLMs in comprehending graph data, employing a
diverse range of structural and semantic-related tasks. Our analysis
encompasses 10 distinct tasks that evaluate the LLMs' capabilities in graph
understanding. Through our study, we not only uncover the current limitations
of language models in comprehending graph structures and performing associated
reasoning tasks but also emphasize the necessity for further advancements and
novel approaches to enhance their graph processing capabilities. Our findings
contribute valuable insights towards bridging the gap between language models
and graph understanding, paving the way for more effective graph mining and
knowledge extraction. | [
0.0332791917,
0.0153044825,
-0.009013528,
0.0525341555,
-0.0394302271,
0.0228151754,
-0.0387867205,
0.0122249993,
0.090812549,
-0.0338109955,
-0.0302593298,
-0.0428940654,
-0.0088360757,
0.0543148555,
0.013343744,
0.0011610555,
0.016037723,
-0.0296669099,
0.0321197994,
-0.0041144816,
-0.0136160105,
0.0420185924,
0.0352185778,
0.0065795686,
-0.0074155731,
-0.0188427344,
0.0089948168,
0.0123937968,
-0.021209985,
-0.0509448387,
-0.0317757055,
0.0053567444,
0.0083624329,
0.0303787626,
0.0000017059,
-0.0122955954,
-0.037511088,
0.0046710749,
-0.0113507491,
0.0051633082,
0.0343764164,
-0.0457820483,
0.0255371816,
-0.0086917048,
-0.0494035073,
-0.0341090299,
0.0304702148,
0.0114957951,
0.0230701771,
0.0681425557,
-0.0252966452,
-0.0368097462,
0.0082480181,
-0.0098408787,
-0.0043326174,
-0.044043161,
0.03817527,
0.0389532037,
0.0505811833,
-0.0011181498,
-0.0485181287,
0.0045787725,
-0.0218093693,
0.0031727583,
0.0268290062,
0.0382936597,
-0.0369743742,
0.0162437875,
-0.0077125919,
0.1025517732,
0.0066486881,
-0.0186285004,
0.021763023,
0.0063642175,
-0.0150716724,
0.0424468294,
-0.0535801947,
-0.0075330934,
-0.0384892114,
0.0402955674,
0.0080924248,
-0.0566259585,
0.0783696324,
-0.0111610359,
-0.0153244128,
0.1275600046,
-0.020810198,
0.0003501956,
0.0441481024,
0.0049116882,
-0.0454972461,
-0.0145932641,
0.0142122852,
0.0337439254,
-0.0247631893,
0.0370753706,
0.0142363887,
0.0442941263,
-0.0081578335,
-0.016665753,
0.0178217199,
-0.0099141058,
0.0155366594,
0.0688243136,
-0.0037338771,
0.0359883234,
-0.023911804,
0.057424996,
-0.0176828336,
-0.0421520881,
-0.0894178003,
-0.0139545714,
-0.0374003313,
0.0246777125,
-0.0039555826,
-0.0404629745,
-0.0168548636,
0.0470948406,
0.0001316071,
0.0057721832,
0.0286338702,
0.0049069957,
0.0148319816,
-0.0145225702,
-0.0282418393,
0.0047853189,
0.0173385963,
-0.0258028563,
-0.0353079699,
-0.0368234068,
0.0127188759,
-0.0044969842,
0.0600765869,
-0.0414626338,
0.0065334463,
0.0912153497,
0.0670080334,
-0.0510164313,
-0.0098537933,
-0.0106700808,
-0.0187773108,
-0.0613048188,
0.0348561667,
-0.0682638213,
0.0407281518,
0.0588595904,
0.0066306666,
-0.0257101879,
0.0160768796,
-0.0382907018,
-0.0675883815,
0.0646395609,
-0.0352573618,
0.0327764414,
-0.0129594179,
-0.0288258065,
-0.0035677555,
0.0294144694,
0.0327374265,
0.020833673,
0.0393826924,
-0.0143336235,
-0.0256708898,
0.0346087664,
-0.0019422956,
-0.0067663118,
0.016653154,
0.0030789962,
-0.0228309464,
-0.0277334619,
-0.0046485495,
0.0727389455,
-0.0215536486,
-0.0209445991,
0.0377191603,
0.0589513369,
-0.0057444526,
0.0024927086,
0.0338049792,
0.0183151942,
-0.0010618516,
0.0041410737,
-0.0622592643,
-0.0238007754,
0.0053716856,
0.022207683,
-0.0212899521,
-0.0125695653,
0.0169710256,
-0.0035070381,
-0.0399413109,
-0.0137492185,
0.1016787738,
-0.0090465583,
0.072533302,
-0.0280317757,
-0.0344319195,
0.0076229218,
0.040010009,
-0.0130708991,
0.0113172233,
-0.0014079133,
-0.0315983184,
0.0676172376,
0.0502980575,
-0.0171265919,
-0.0299816784,
0.0323615186,
-0.0038455832,
-0.0248264112,
0.0546323508,
-0.0226364117,
-0.0117314216,
-0.0276487172,
-0.020064719,
-0.0102259228,
-0.0101784095,
0.0284320507,
0.016312059,
-0.0029187312,
-0.0140926633,
-0.0902431533,
-0.0573651455,
-0.0155039625,
0.0215946324,
0.0063578589,
-0.0191463288,
-0.0122797452,
0.0124987373,
0.0301345792,
-0.0085876901,
0.0146091264,
0.0171913859,
-0.0004143433,
-0.0146216387,
0.003746877,
-0.0001707832,
-0.0209990256,
0.0658667758,
-0.0303822458,
-0.0475149676,
0.017287828,
-0.035702467,
-0.033162389,
0.0442770757,
-0.069060877,
0.0647353977,
0.0043843132,
0.0097943526,
0.0047931243,
-0.0088851685,
0.0094735529,
0.0746943876,
0.0216370337,
-0.0153454971,
-0.0146749327,
0.008447648,
0.0119713154,
-0.0641754642,
-0.0068494701,
0.0495461337,
0.0308047663,
-0.0090751257,
0.0384975597,
-0.0089239329,
-0.0525776036,
0.0383084416,
-0.1003683507,
0.0127443532,
0.0081537487,
0.0348584913,
-0.0047147134,
-0.0004595059,
0.0021369259,
-0.0146494294,
-0.0566246286,
0.0394000039,
0.0371095687,
0.0022270768,
0.0434112474,
-0.0136899725,
-0.045335032,
-0.0228020586,
-0.0508818999,
-0.0663387179,
0.0529226176,
0.0502449833,
-0.0618015341,
0.0035429709,
0.0288962815,
-0.0540094338,
0.0177619364,
-0.0172903445,
0.0109496256,
0.0051807412,
-0.0365488976,
0.0182451457,
0.0327409171,
-0.0386651941,
0.0527676865,
0.0456022769,
-0.0213683527,
-0.0068648332,
-0.0120591931,
-0.058425311,
-0.0019245961,
-0.0581292734,
-0.0259373151,
-0.0240035392,
0.0203375686,
0.0129630584,
-0.006023868,
-0.0492534377,
-0.0188206434,
-0.0255639274,
0.0414810255,
-0.0174437165,
-0.0124340197,
0.0236514024,
0.02747133,
-0.0472263619,
-0.0315163024,
0.0768303126,
-0.009448221,
-0.0008194896,
0.0350991823,
-0.0334395245,
-0.0757745728,
0.0808006823,
0.0645305067,
0.0212643575,
-0.0225635991,
-0.0472129099,
-0.0180109106,
0.0071197767,
0.0366900638,
-0.0300316755,
0.0061315228,
-0.0146219451,
0.0435845368,
0.0318921134,
-0.0006657709,
-0.0035440237,
0.0158104748,
-0.0591611341,
0.0418499187,
0.0363282748,
-0.0475161374,
0.0094049089,
0.0113130268,
-0.0325665176,
-0.0209133551,
-0.0112807285,
0.0152640175,
-0.0285325833,
0.0177931115,
0.0552031323,
-0.0510865748,
0.0201595332,
-0.0355806984,
0.010276773,
0.0374862701,
-0.0029268172,
-0.0231860671,
-0.0371346548,
0.0240156893,
0.0068717436,
-0.0221242476,
-0.0156793464,
-0.0285418034,
0.0324894637,
-0.0422348864,
-0.0004604704,
0.0860183537,
0.0259039719,
-0.0288323201,
0.0220850911,
0.0315083154,
0.003196744,
0.0190533064,
-0.0027430772,
-0.1133165658,
-0.0105270538,
-0.0268161725,
0.0129044708,
0.0245062653,
-0.0753866658,
-0.0208006334,
-0.0948153734,
0.0368694775,
0.0372464322,
-0.0075714849,
-0.0447792932,
-0.0654647574,
-0.0192732662,
-0.0242299438,
-0.0093580196,
-0.0370157883,
-0.0313039497,
0.006461157,
0.0176883638,
-0.0234216824,
-0.0234060958,
0.0442528874,
-0.0026802742,
0.0248104669,
-0.0171028096,
0.055931516,
0.0055012326,
0.0138997864,
0.0653090477,
0.049208127,
-0.0157309677,
-0.0226287339,
0.03142263,
-0.0061240792,
0.0004055752,
-0.0295100082,
-0.0089812726,
-0.0556999967,
-0.0085321367,
-0.0324898846,
0.1033994928,
-0.0081493305,
-0.0496961772,
0.0108176805,
-0.0174233913,
-0.0348897353,
0.0340710059,
0.043469198,
0.0486607477,
-0.0698296353,
-0.0608600713,
0.0234263726,
-0.0347349085,
-0.0516864546,
0.03339931,
-0.0161702074,
0.0411696993,
-0.0115060117,
-0.0387094244,
0.0519801304,
-0.0432219058,
-0.0110122748,
0.0069088861,
0.0503770262,
-0.0237486493,
-0.0685856864,
0.0301850829,
-0.0342031941,
0.0151536344,
-0.0216427632,
-0.0401100405,
-0.0002699726,
0.0012678932,
-0.0158649944,
0.0175300222,
-0.0596926734,
-0.0877684876,
-0.025554467,
-0.0245538838,
0.0250625256,
0.0499678291,
-0.0228479002,
0.0086298008,
-0.0041047679,
0.0136468494,
-0.0294189341,
-0.0406610481,
0.0025903084,
-0.0010344995,
0.000755559,
0.0342946425,
-0.0543132797,
0.0211639088,
0.0183134135,
0.0430597365,
-0.0229809806,
-0.0153981065,
0.0397874825,
0.1130052954,
0.0296278372,
0.0341460854,
0.0126894014,
-0.0457918048,
-0.0445474796,
-0.0394455381,
-0.0233528186,
-0.0066633718,
-0.025713345,
0.0266368128,
-0.0040401267,
-0.0284730811,
-0.0563642047,
-0.0155380685,
0.0423085093,
-0.0328532904,
-0.0008141517,
-0.0023240265,
-0.0531885177,
0.0354067907,
-0.0289434623,
0.0064408341,
0.0204127524,
0.0277340487,
0.0006216328,
-0.002000202,
0.0089459438,
0.0218984149,
-0.0328335352,
-0.0398945846,
0.0152407773,
-0.0710268691,
-0.0322107896,
0.0268041566,
0.0219776109,
0.0424016155,
-0.0093495278,
0.0486251079,
-0.0245387014,
-0.0011786734,
-0.0155213708,
0.0565791763,
0.0035104388,
-0.0336617753,
0.0440406911,
0.0290799905,
-0.0128097981,
0.009611303,
0.0552248061,
0.0702028051,
0.0100344392,
0.0228744391,
-0.079094328,
-0.0199103076,
-0.0281336624,
-0.0230984557,
0.0192334149,
-0.0134717375,
0.0391211361,
-0.0489662737,
-0.0954877138,
-0.0057138596,
-0.0046021692,
0.0177972782,
-0.0165703297,
0.0103183165,
0.0229968894,
0.0287353378,
-0.0268156286,
-0.0607747212,
0.0239416435,
-0.0231172517,
-0.0066034058,
0.0167026706,
-6.075769937e-33,
-0.0107724397,
-0.0935489759,
0.0324703455,
0.0541801751,
-0.0395494103,
0.031483613,
-0.0600050502,
-0.00272876,
-0.0145559013,
0.0173232537,
-0.0079753147,
0.0267478619,
-0.0005921451,
-0.0031524284,
-0.0347150676,
-0.0201666206,
0.007078812,
0.0175352581,
0.0048756315,
0.0278375298,
0.0386302993,
0.0450420864,
0.056856744,
-0.0574643165,
0.0533150993,
-0.0346139297,
0.0220981296,
0.0030166225,
0.0206376016,
0.0477915108,
-0.0191960689,
0.0286362208,
0.0469564721,
0.0057355389,
0.0158607606,
0.0095126033,
-0.0832858756,
-0.0155865662,
0.0356962308,
0.0162933562,
-0.0298071504,
-0.0217204988,
0.0430486053,
-0.0113309855,
0.0217472333,
-0.0377631523,
0.0504294224,
-0.0004981702,
-0.026766343,
0.0382149406,
-0.0242476091,
0.0500417463,
-0.0147805111,
0.039306473,
0.0447775126,
-0.0109047787,
-0.0137766665,
0.0454259329,
-0.0292889476,
0.0499679111,
-0.0290903766,
-0.0286954101,
0.0044170264,
0.0056245411,
0.0264462847,
0.0432099923,
-0.0001729257,
-0.0146010304,
-0.0085051237,
0.0102910884,
-0.0124996239,
0.0734580979,
-0.0582489744,
-0.0108292596,
-0.0175698586,
0.0148417875,
-0.0944219008,
-0.0192680135,
0.0177686177,
0.0070148776,
-0.0243343171,
0.021190742,
-0.0283089038,
-0.0503658354,
0.0065998589,
-0.0404234603,
-0.0190667138,
-0.0289665498,
-0.0119753974,
-0.0525825582,
-0.0166528858,
0.0415987633,
-0.012959973,
-0.0751743391,
-0.036600329,
0.071228385,
-0.0035175181,
0.0111012179,
-0.0091649452,
0.0436426997,
-0.0428522676,
-0.0435526222,
-0.0244923923,
-0.0187221821,
0.0250148773,
0.0125063583,
0.03466741,
0.0162718464,
-0.0133563532,
-0.0093119098,
-0.0464139022,
-0.0244742054,
-0.0548744276,
-0.0030357705,
0.0489880964,
0.0626231804,
0.0108807916,
0.0586664043,
0.0511571616,
0.0482152626,
-0.0087384051,
0.0436672755,
-0.0016698166,
0.0124933412,
-0.0197509378,
-0.0383247323,
-0.0156018091,
0.0252562482,
0.0425552987,
-0.03185286,
-0.0223286673,
-0.0338372104,
2.587e-7,
0.0870168284,
0.0640534163,
0.0322050042,
0.0462334044,
0.0169814769,
0.0041501182,
-0.0394799039,
0.026666671,
0.0005374209,
-0.0065819905,
0.0455513485,
0.070105873,
-0.0325423442,
0.050372228,
-0.0301501527,
0.0607507192,
-0.0576976687,
-0.076501511,
-0.0601533838,
0.0447777621,
0.0237927958,
0.0522863194,
0.0217326116,
0.0018016207,
-0.0473592691,
-0.0634316206,
0.0456365384,
-0.0327349342,
-0.0309804883,
-0.0067506963,
-0.0032581983,
0.0103452103,
-0.0289172698,
0.0233459864,
0.0256447699,
0.0240175612,
0.0431596823,
0.0465251096,
-0.0348943286,
0.0291529205,
0.010177223,
-0.0417298637,
0.0014388113,
-0.0291658901,
0.0845076814,
-0.0409180485,
-0.0761369839,
-0.0092954431,
-0.022221636,
-0.0287956707,
-0.020496333,
0.0116086211,
-0.0057692262,
0.0236842185,
0.0059989234,
-0.0337215997,
0.0226522554,
-0.0303241573,
0.0537286699,
0.0274637248,
0.010746331,
-0.0463289022,
0.0093975887,
0.0433046594,
0.023763271,
-0.0028609927,
0.0259803291,
2.198410912e-34,
0.0471720248,
0.0189016573,
-0.0049520917,
-0.0085235424,
0.0667900518,
-0.0391367488,
-0.0161788408,
0.0345443301,
0.002528887,
-0.0940807238,
-0.0086454563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15065v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15065v2 | Inference-Time Policy Adapters (IPA): Tailoring Extreme-Scale LMs without Fine-tuning | 2023-05-24T11:52:55 | 2023-12-06T09:00:19 | Ximing Lu, Faeze Brahman, Peter West, Jaehun Jang, Khyathi Chandu, Abhilasha Ravichander, Lianhui Qin, Prithviraj Ammanabrolu, Liwei Jiang, Sahana Ramnath, Nouha Dziri, Jillian Fisher, Bill Yuchen Lin, Skyler Hallinan, Xiang Ren, Sean Welleck, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | While extreme-scale language models have demonstrated exceptional performance
on a variety of language tasks, the degree of control over these language
models through pure prompting can often be limited. Directly fine-tuning such
language models can be effective for tailoring them, but it can be either
extremely costly (e.g., GPT-3) or not even feasible for the broader community
(e.g., GPT-4).
We propose Inference-time Policy Adapters (IPA), which efficiently tailors a
language model such as GPT-3 without fine-tuning it. IPA guides a large base
model during decoding time through a lightweight policy adapter trained to
optimize an arbitrary user objective with reinforcement learning.
On five challenging text generation tasks, such as toxicity reduction and
lexically constrained generation, IPA consistently brings significant
improvements over off-the-shelf language models. It outperforms competitive
baseline methods, sometimes even including expensive fine-tuning. In
particular, tailoring GPT-2 with IPA can outperform GPT-3, while tailoring
GPT-3 with IPA brings a major performance boost over GPT-3 (and sometimes even
over GPT-4). Our promising results highlight the potential of IPA as a
lightweight alternative to tailoring extreme-scale language models. | [
0.036628101,
0.0748555586,
0.0194479153,
-0.0024546431,
-0.0074398327,
0.0081556141,
0.0142599074,
0.0159155261,
-0.0093527064,
0.0055848076,
-0.0276423991,
0.0010488858,
-0.0234148949,
0.0329745375,
0.017256368,
-0.0517495647,
0.0408522263,
-0.0074006366,
0.016268678,
0.0166684389,
0.0213001408,
0.0328579247,
0.0084051518,
0.0606148839,
0.0303490888,
-0.0094604027,
-0.0141325798,
0.0167573951,
0.0497857705,
-0.0331315808,
0.0211856999,
0.0273058917,
0.036580231,
0.0337069519,
0.0000017998,
-0.0056572868,
-0.0289950334,
-0.002066053,
0.0154068246,
0.0235086456,
0.067021735,
-0.0167141967,
-0.0337179303,
0.048306223,
-0.0334490873,
0.0070687425,
0.0807547197,
0.0062226988,
0.073939316,
0.0883716792,
-0.0050316579,
0.0053619216,
0.0316595323,
-0.0625012517,
0.0230513699,
-0.0223372262,
0.0037176884,
-0.042238161,
0.0189852268,
0.0041266531,
-0.0269755796,
0.0183481071,
0.0353571475,
0.0181974974,
-0.0276349504,
0.058975555,
0.0112755261,
-0.0227360446,
-0.0257870648,
0.0535346568,
-0.0281429999,
-0.0317819379,
0.0055005234,
-0.0180241466,
-0.0124540888,
-0.027100144,
-0.0173730124,
0.0157675948,
-0.0019549208,
0.0550294667,
0.0589073412,
0.011072712,
0.0343817398,
0.0220796429,
-0.0203078836,
0.0456191599,
0.0256860666,
-0.0115803089,
-0.0030270731,
0.0108469594,
-0.0056315144,
-0.0336125046,
-0.0037725875,
0.0349128731,
-0.0518371612,
0.0015046918,
-0.0723294467,
-0.0107306195,
0.0210167151,
-0.0032779865,
0.0616729632,
0.0518482141,
0.022973856,
0.0176691543,
-0.0109650912,
0.0329461917,
-0.0178359468,
-0.0013663877,
-0.0168558378,
0.0198906381,
-0.0151800131,
-0.0170286391,
-0.0467761196,
-0.0068685175,
-0.0598277897,
-0.0167366415,
-0.0349169336,
0.0291308165,
-0.0142857721,
-0.014663144,
0.0259686932,
0.0287123099,
-0.1008133218,
-0.0141327763,
-0.0113446927,
0.0388306044,
-0.0336078182,
0.0051881867,
0.0278992876,
-0.0481400862,
-0.0358334407,
0.0225133393,
-0.0143788392,
-0.0383388177,
0.0161075648,
0.118583262,
-0.0490590557,
-0.027531825,
-0.0128902355,
-0.0106900996,
-0.0138448859,
-0.0531605966,
-0.0200985819,
-0.0437480584,
0.0119626001,
-0.0216205716,
0.016620256,
-0.0712745488,
0.0136483442,
-0.0008199766,
-0.038502831,
0.0576220565,
0.024769919,
-0.0140490653,
0.017875215,
0.0059715286,
0.0007085488,
0.056886483,
0.0514333993,
0.0394349657,
-0.0266068969,
0.0062961276,
0.0049907821,
0.0409848914,
0.0440128408,
0.045307748,
-0.0321947709,
-0.0240592081,
-0.0511746332,
0.0376838818,
0.0685330853,
0.068111971,
-0.0238706712,
-0.0030683475,
0.0931470394,
0.0275689475,
0.0127346469,
0.0156553686,
0.0815297291,
0.0138625978,
-0.0564095229,
-0.021864675,
-0.0460479036,
0.0251804143,
0.0073135095,
0.0203432404,
0.0266182926,
0.0602817647,
-0.0121610649,
-0.0290002339,
0.0207456052,
0.0087940758,
0.0249582455,
0.0031659328,
0.0173857901,
0.0292876493,
-0.0521536283,
0.0271806754,
0.0360142775,
-0.0254933815,
0.0117494818,
-0.081559509,
0.024987936,
0.0831955448,
0.0651150718,
-0.0077572246,
-0.0181951746,
-0.0217397176,
0.0133438595,
0.0895103961,
0.0318698399,
-0.0053358204,
0.0104415445,
-0.0423045829,
-0.0228986107,
0.004936737,
0.0160182323,
0.0246921796,
0.0452382378,
0.0304394234,
0.006287992,
-0.013728343,
-0.0593779832,
0.0302409567,
-0.034838859,
-0.0607892051,
0.0314353779,
-0.0110558001,
0.0177639909,
-0.0200428776,
-0.0339252613,
0.0056824512,
-0.0003313225,
-0.0365886316,
0.0054395502,
0.0072143464,
-0.0407204777,
-0.0208116919,
-0.0003134397,
-0.0491140559,
0.0162317902,
0.0109119071,
-0.0439919047,
-0.0302710887,
-0.0017850653,
-0.0352524258,
0.027753897,
-0.0220497847,
-0.0081096701,
0.0044154376,
0.0021188857,
-0.0409627892,
0.0214429181,
-0.0085222358,
-0.0394398309,
0.0318745784,
0.0185518023,
-0.0476918295,
-0.0483698435,
-0.0025403509,
-0.0018284336,
0.0234906394,
0.0041679032,
0.0407309271,
0.0773881897,
-0.0057200468,
-0.0429154336,
-0.0597905517,
0.0314533971,
-0.030886896,
0.0141818943,
0.0347566791,
0.0256272554,
-0.0228173248,
0.0066009602,
-0.0484347455,
0.0032261938,
0.0005831777,
0.0119501147,
0.0215421319,
0.014220803,
-0.0099440096,
-0.042681776,
0.008326022,
0.0072786463,
-0.0024523987,
-0.0186109412,
-0.0267782584,
-0.0234502628,
0.0266903955,
-0.0073622423,
0.0031881081,
-0.00987525,
-0.0628415123,
0.0481998809,
-0.011890661,
0.0583914518,
0.0652941093,
0.0220956765,
0.0625221655,
0.0400964543,
0.021708928,
-0.0641743466,
0.0371380337,
-0.0468508676,
-0.0441907533,
-0.0433277637,
-0.0159801841,
0.0282172207,
0.0985892564,
-0.001402111,
0.0054058935,
-0.1053110436,
0.0516433045,
-0.0096535617,
-0.039588403,
0.011772017,
0.0264146943,
-0.0394983925,
-0.0230034664,
-0.0341397077,
-0.0813838616,
0.0877690688,
-0.0092340177,
0.00811774,
-0.0346542634,
-0.043009676,
-0.000524369,
0.0166490879,
0.0276281647,
0.039816007,
-0.0199669283,
-0.016615618,
-0.0471049845,
0.016159622,
0.0260467865,
-0.0096648419,
0.02268943,
-0.047047317,
-0.0042241453,
-0.0167242009,
-0.0757818371,
-0.024892427,
-0.0111030424,
-0.0114791216,
-0.0097039752,
0.0071280887,
-0.0675027817,
-0.0103883361,
0.0100871548,
0.0199449752,
0.0600852221,
-0.0407464877,
-0.0395694338,
-0.0267645307,
-0.0143842129,
0.0938045308,
-0.0080735469,
0.0037955635,
-0.0249992125,
0.0215854477,
0.05056905,
0.0297833011,
-0.0065235873,
-0.0081882458,
0.0349567942,
0.0149631258,
-0.0147673292,
0.0122901006,
0.0580251887,
0.0672045648,
-0.0530450381,
-0.0456606746,
0.0952444673,
0.0046645477,
-0.0576205514,
0.0214353185,
0.026665125,
0.0840850398,
0.0002967053,
0.0231901295,
-0.0671532005,
-0.0413458645,
0.0018391524,
0.0721394643,
-0.0545233935,
-0.0081564793,
-0.0344572738,
-0.0642692745,
0.0025940828,
0.037070632,
-0.0523733869,
-0.0229387786,
0.0009105813,
-0.0087883407,
-0.0510932468,
0.0237808786,
0.0092455316,
0.0005465153,
0.0060007693,
0.0249675885,
0.0138305603,
-0.0594506525,
-0.0186195225,
0.0143811554,
0.0709750429,
0.0773257986,
-0.0117976163,
0.0063159484,
-0.0088967336,
0.0272654034,
0.01899294,
-0.0055913818,
-0.0262534022,
-0.0036329718,
-0.0189648513,
-0.0127479285,
-0.021648556,
0.0929537043,
-0.0108970767,
-0.0178438853,
-0.0128586832,
0.0785475224,
-0.0105948625,
-0.034065742,
-0.015332032,
-0.0309970938,
0.0447894782,
0.0743139982,
0.0394887403,
-0.0725239664,
-0.0585809946,
-0.0537092313,
-0.0224330109,
-0.1007585153,
-0.0384636261,
-0.0181653369,
-0.0172373559,
-0.0391406417,
-0.0654960275,
-0.0402696691,
0.0029871664,
0.0366656408,
-0.0163963381,
-0.0161078423,
-0.0224353448,
0.0097388299,
-0.0287405774,
0.0126581341,
-0.0131623223,
-0.0011512443,
-0.0516230986,
-0.0371111855,
0.0114815813,
0.0026091321,
-0.0215638001,
0.0703169554,
-0.0415551178,
-0.0927967355,
-0.0048414255,
0.0649551898,
0.025562793,
0.0491911098,
-0.0100513697,
-0.0465982482,
0.0839670077,
0.0721668527,
0.0058557489,
0.0145411063,
0.0264494605,
0.0091368472,
0.0094634658,
0.0471341349,
-0.0262508839,
0.0189060904,
0.0319161154,
0.0619073585,
-0.0153629435,
-0.0144691244,
0.0189284664,
-0.0221993998,
0.0079486286,
-0.0567187518,
-0.004516731,
-0.0261523463,
-0.020440191,
-0.0056922147,
0.0082142856,
-0.0424012989,
-0.0035623966,
0.0402256697,
-0.0255370308,
-0.0320684388,
-0.0013505627,
0.0042104349,
0.0328285098,
-0.035284467,
0.0027874864,
-0.0172664188,
0.0038563123,
0.0609117113,
0.0064390004,
-0.0141111659,
0.028065145,
-0.0289886426,
0.0044974582,
-0.0160995051,
0.0382696316,
0.0316644609,
0.0135503393,
0.002172407,
0.0427388959,
-0.0201975536,
-0.0248632431,
-0.0579446852,
0.0294484943,
0.0309054777,
0.0431342497,
0.0670433342,
-0.0514212847,
-0.0139457528,
-0.0127295163,
0.0244179983,
-0.0015240569,
-0.0168883316,
0.017372869,
0.0162324961,
-0.0152678806,
-0.031098187,
0.0792265236,
0.0446302183,
0.0730403215,
-0.0072858627,
0.0063647814,
-0.0229281131,
-0.0489798039,
-0.0189709961,
-0.0059495713,
0.0123792524,
-0.0041789818,
-0.0332020819,
-0.0532058328,
-0.0546145141,
0.0342945606,
-0.0039329352,
-0.0239985157,
0.035567753,
-0.0053035822,
-0.0310825389,
-0.0298311263,
-0.0271892957,
0.0114869578,
0.0152596412,
-0.0473200232,
-0.0208521727,
-6.176632128e-33,
-0.0289388672,
-0.0144388592,
0.0282646492,
-0.0355194137,
-0.0323517881,
-0.0270016491,
-0.0414946936,
-0.0189627018,
0.0152123654,
0.014898343,
-0.0079917563,
0.0130346259,
0.0104011539,
0.0352565646,
-0.0110751232,
0.0235211216,
0.0503277481,
-0.0139301084,
-0.0620223507,
0.054144159,
0.0371119902,
0.0119906813,
0.0235937815,
0.0013170965,
-0.0140992003,
0.0426773392,
-0.03542215,
0.0020434309,
-0.0233917162,
0.0588900037,
-0.01385317,
0.0213485658,
0.0056942622,
-0.0472721197,
-0.0362256207,
0.0121335015,
-0.0668842047,
-0.0175780561,
-0.002103159,
-0.0501213931,
-0.0303927325,
-0.066374518,
0.0492362529,
-0.0010982979,
-0.0429420471,
-0.013232613,
-0.0168162435,
-0.0177475084,
0.0026157836,
-0.0407704078,
-0.0543183647,
0.0210577138,
0.0050147409,
0.0111807026,
-0.0113514317,
-0.012359485,
-0.012288955,
0.0227131285,
-0.0028964286,
0.0073856837,
0.0116802724,
0.0324184373,
0.0602491498,
0.0273326021,
0.0024173972,
0.0390377864,
-0.0269368012,
-0.0214779936,
-0.019837074,
0.0153741958,
0.0221993364,
0.0065606092,
0.0275882948,
0.0579914525,
0.0113555193,
-0.0288951956,
-0.0459850915,
0.0401702374,
0.0184313934,
0.0350959823,
0.040206112,
0.0202276371,
-0.030718023,
-0.0101075303,
-0.0356241502,
-0.0098764552,
-0.016341649,
-0.0523995832,
0.040701244,
0.0449726321,
-0.0290299375,
-0.0373510085,
0.0281591136,
-0.0069788992,
0.0237227418,
0.0137606077,
-0.0462547578,
-0.0067773457,
-0.0018668176,
0.0169276968,
-0.0669929087,
-0.0285009034,
0.036896605,
-0.0059859809,
-0.0086005516,
-0.0154388621,
0.017717611,
0.0465532281,
-0.0686269924,
0.0062145251,
-0.0582028851,
0.0562118292,
0.0204837937,
0.0201975163,
0.0298865028,
-0.0248506647,
0.0047937245,
0.0009107084,
-0.0012347526,
-0.0292864032,
-0.0040408568,
-0.0222269632,
-0.0088284677,
0.0230785534,
-0.052224718,
0.0326130912,
-0.0390026793,
0.0350294299,
0.0072800978,
-0.0822818652,
-0.0253534466,
-0.0084971162,
2.568e-7,
0.0068901628,
0.0362482518,
0.0216689277,
0.0324613117,
0.0388254598,
0.0114185512,
0.020713903,
0.071535103,
-0.038488023,
0.0054277703,
0.0263703652,
0.0392967798,
0.0631347448,
0.0180349331,
-0.047380209,
0.0245428663,
-0.0901461691,
0.039071545,
-0.0642887801,
-0.0288127605,
0.0245689824,
0.0793241113,
0.0126253683,
-0.0115721766,
0.0560572408,
-0.0260630045,
0.0381624214,
-0.0317791626,
-0.0032955045,
0.0133763207,
0.0170346368,
0.0288493987,
-0.0103891576,
-0.0384148881,
-0.0107603418,
-0.0073977485,
-0.0513392612,
0.0944117755,
-0.0048199277,
-0.0569480844,
0.0264753103,
-0.0041272906,
0.009372402,
-0.0568788834,
0.0589016564,
-0.0523529053,
0.0059692306,
-0.0095220273,
0.0054751276,
-0.031833984,
-0.0209912173,
-0.0666321069,
-0.0471092686,
0.0139771504,
0.0093492111,
0.0340261646,
-0.0004519574,
-0.0543750413,
-0.0082618948,
-0.0018227856,
-0.0449958034,
-0.0695529059,
-0.0974225551,
0.0435494594,
-0.0128274756,
-0.0536983423,
-0.0201086216,
2.484664679e-34,
0.0044781789,
-0.0421443544,
0.0176104326,
-0.0151653262,
0.0225700531,
0.0455356762,
0.0133067593,
0.0079956474,
0.0537839495,
-0.0899881124,
-0.0557886474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15064v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15064v3 | AutoPlan: Automatic Planning of Interactive Decision-Making Tasks With Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:52:23 | 2023-10-26T16:44:39 | Siqi Ouyang, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent large language models (LLMs) are promising for making decisions in
grounded environments. However, LLMs frequently fail in complex decision-making
tasks due to the misalignment between the pre-trained knowledge in LLMs and the
actual rules in the environment. Existing methods require either costly
gradient computation or lengthy in-context demonstrations. In this paper, we
propose AutoPlan, an approach to guide LLM-based agents to accomplish
interactive decision-making tasks. AutoPlan augments the LLM prompt with a
task-solving plan and optimizes it through iterative experience collection and
reflection. Our experiments show that AutoPlan, though using no in-context
demonstrations, achieves success rates on par with the baselines using
human-written demonstrations on ALFWorld and even outperforms them by 8% on
HotpotQA. The code is available at https://github.com/owaski/AutoPlan. | [
0.0157969147,
0.0268478673,
-0.0046875407,
-0.0003465531,
-0.0322757885,
0.0080898581,
0.002048607,
-0.0127335442,
0.0203902088,
-0.0296706278,
-0.0524926223,
0.0142256115,
0.0051404461,
0.0445280336,
-0.0116218654,
-0.0583456978,
-0.0026267036,
-0.0857932717,
-0.0237797797,
-0.010217783,
-0.0192151517,
-0.011786947,
-0.05185543,
0.0568813607,
-0.0186620839,
0.0018369826,
-0.0573882796,
-0.0234148428,
0.0150430687,
-0.0230226479,
-0.0060025705,
0.0511279739,
0.0686974972,
0.0265793204,
0.0000021031,
-0.0277101081,
0.0178905111,
-0.0413343385,
-0.0603808388,
0.0002497809,
0.0152499601,
0.0206712689,
-0.0137616415,
0.0296094976,
-0.0607487485,
-0.0037457347,
0.0029803347,
0.0422313027,
0.0640993416,
0.0321222134,
0.0175041631,
0.0029351944,
-0.0112225115,
-0.0209836122,
-0.0123576289,
-0.0620142557,
0.0205151513,
-0.0173606649,
0.0162204094,
-0.004700894,
-0.0111407861,
0.0173218474,
0.0649778619,
-0.0502687134,
-0.0333393998,
0.056389723,
-0.0231636446,
-0.0221676752,
-0.0338662826,
0.0823127702,
-0.018799182,
-0.009818105,
0.0034138672,
-0.0145126525,
0.0132867005,
-0.0249460619,
-0.0283529442,
0.0299673509,
0.0209778473,
0.0294740293,
-0.0259485673,
0.0059215687,
0.0113740116,
0.0223957077,
-0.0400379226,
0.1254740059,
-0.0219139196,
-0.0267727226,
0.0430281535,
-0.0013562281,
0.0235549659,
-0.0734186843,
0.0031509548,
0.0739865974,
-0.1081416532,
0.0164944101,
-0.0025776371,
0.0022458998,
-0.0168667864,
-0.0164237618,
0.090532288,
0.0382629409,
0.0041846354,
0.0676485971,
-0.0179852862,
0.0722877607,
0.011079411,
-0.0163963512,
-0.0110716866,
0.0182512999,
-0.0277110822,
0.0143185258,
-0.0659518093,
0.0105624031,
-0.0800182298,
-0.0296233986,
-0.0127284629,
0.0371429473,
-0.0222500339,
0.0550273135,
-0.0011164781,
0.0260756724,
-0.025369525,
-0.0130964769,
-0.0635188296,
-0.0145418737,
-0.035794951,
0.0215285402,
0.0251947399,
-0.0274093859,
0.0132276071,
0.0292286482,
-0.0050734878,
-0.0049794419,
-0.0036529116,
0.0854098201,
-0.0084539177,
-0.040894296,
-0.0275420677,
-0.0115980636,
0.0186294671,
-0.0851925686,
-0.0120104719,
-0.0609384067,
0.0181756839,
-0.0230236165,
-0.034051165,
-0.0306575745,
0.0200606864,
-0.0027093785,
0.0276703425,
0.0780732632,
0.0306179523,
0.0195498355,
0.0429306999,
-0.0016734406,
-0.0300585702,
0.0662703663,
0.0241536684,
0.0870854035,
-0.0084197726,
0.0356882177,
0.05069286,
0.0515132919,
-0.0000160753,
0.0289773028,
-0.0288604628,
0.0063387514,
-0.0273321886,
0.0777991191,
0.0043674107,
0.0319257863,
-0.0378298834,
0.03574856,
0.0522240661,
0.0485929027,
-0.0025770804,
-0.0157503448,
0.0373919234,
0.0338942334,
0.0183901172,
-0.043048542,
-0.058457654,
0.0358240753,
-0.0033010324,
-0.0136578754,
-0.0168423038,
0.0144757917,
-0.0192896072,
-0.0454157591,
0.0211630203,
-0.0129106203,
0.0423084721,
0.0271448083,
0.0382124931,
0.0022367388,
-0.0526223853,
-0.0350027233,
0.0226745941,
-0.0082370397,
-0.0296009742,
-0.0667919964,
0.0587893166,
0.0803495646,
0.0309517216,
-0.0352282375,
-0.0063936161,
-0.0159743614,
0.033730533,
0.052791588,
0.0272244643,
-0.0410242081,
-0.0133776544,
-0.026844671,
-0.0417436771,
-0.0096383486,
0.0040051374,
0.0341298208,
0.0544841886,
0.012566532,
-0.0155261382,
0.0163418818,
-0.019992955,
0.0247884504,
-0.0415363573,
-0.0478327647,
-0.0057737855,
-0.004700765,
0.0305519439,
-0.0139998756,
-0.0061950269,
-0.0008029239,
0.0207510628,
-0.0030754472,
-0.0188641399,
-0.0033993039,
-0.0265946835,
-0.0324135125,
0.042876292,
-0.0088602267,
-0.0400767401,
0.0009127842,
-0.0229750779,
-0.0346237421,
-0.0116045075,
-0.0179681797,
0.0369594842,
-0.0157047976,
0.0181623567,
0.0001633553,
-0.0105551491,
-0.0317078084,
0.0532756895,
0.0103273885,
-0.0312045719,
0.0612416789,
0.0164864939,
-0.0185507368,
-0.0557041392,
0.0004919211,
0.0008956484,
0.0292651542,
0.0070754928,
0.0072968188,
0.0520315133,
-0.0363086797,
-0.0260934532,
-0.0985941365,
-0.0174161028,
-0.02968877,
-0.0122904582,
-0.0128419194,
-0.0267510489,
-0.0316617042,
-0.030717086,
-0.0175690819,
0.0452145115,
0.003270997,
0.0091329319,
0.0288040992,
0.0421904176,
-0.0146162733,
-0.0353405327,
-0.0015530278,
0.002016878,
0.0154217565,
0.0204775799,
0.0274663512,
-0.0551171787,
0.0200170893,
-0.0064373594,
0.0451554693,
-0.0166672748,
-0.034862373,
0.0442572609,
-0.0254765414,
0.0423641019,
0.071125485,
0.0160807651,
0.0898535699,
0.0591974221,
-0.0123696132,
-0.0676960871,
0.0388685279,
-0.0332643725,
0.0054669082,
-0.0475858264,
0.0276826844,
0.0147946496,
0.0648799762,
-0.0311530922,
0.022635337,
-0.0406585149,
0.0176894218,
-0.0158524327,
-0.0445730053,
-0.0475442596,
-0.0091995848,
-0.0509709753,
0.0561559126,
0.0061533265,
-0.0354356803,
0.078198038,
-0.0176827498,
-0.0191551633,
-0.0360752679,
-0.0147417346,
-0.0254376605,
0.0786406249,
-0.0139021575,
0.0192191489,
-0.0435568467,
-0.0195798017,
-0.0201659501,
-0.0184838418,
-0.004762568,
-0.0171697177,
0.0473770425,
-0.0694114342,
0.0042178272,
-0.0043706438,
-0.05683887,
-0.0464087799,
-0.0084033087,
-0.0487429537,
0.0125458306,
0.0056925514,
-0.0467888191,
-0.0344182774,
-0.0139363548,
0.0727503374,
0.0547899194,
-0.0161772575,
-0.0232094452,
-0.0345083885,
-0.0576396212,
0.0662211031,
0.0734624639,
0.0035884599,
-0.0227148905,
0.0378118493,
0.0265800357,
0.0513706431,
-0.0104273651,
-0.0245277639,
0.0252980236,
0.0111411279,
-0.0299056564,
0.0166534986,
0.0504852682,
0.0139890835,
-0.0703881159,
0.0020472524,
0.1051279306,
0.0355952084,
-0.0506025217,
0.0116028208,
-0.0458843485,
-0.0006359186,
0.0226883572,
0.0423471853,
-0.0573952943,
-0.0277360305,
0.0157679152,
0.001246736,
0.0199605841,
-0.040299084,
0.0179346316,
-0.1258572787,
0.057452783,
-0.0076907184,
-0.0271797571,
-0.0020058313,
-0.0173977707,
0.0078164339,
-0.0150119867,
0.0175209995,
0.030551048,
0.0082392292,
-0.0140726026,
0.0024299193,
0.0095776673,
-0.0304271765,
0.0285212658,
-0.0313990414,
0.0405611321,
0.0582230799,
0.0343171954,
0.0061862092,
-0.0383549444,
0.0398726091,
0.0535706654,
0.0153569402,
-0.0171850473,
-0.0060026459,
-0.007159601,
-0.007511761,
-0.0207030345,
0.0580806024,
-0.0444657318,
-0.0313750766,
0.0145475343,
0.0810724348,
-0.048404973,
-0.0000128454,
0.0086406078,
-0.0220857468,
0.0440888442,
0.0560621992,
0.012310735,
-0.0759762675,
-0.0646274835,
-0.0391098484,
-0.042243585,
-0.0158601254,
-0.0540035293,
0.005080841,
0.020300746,
0.0125762485,
-0.053497754,
-0.0430679098,
0.1025736183,
0.0767238587,
0.0142450677,
-0.0298239794,
-0.0054772324,
0.0285533834,
0.0245558973,
0.0150990468,
-0.0352419466,
0.0390035696,
-0.0653299689,
0.0028442608,
0.0353293568,
-0.0468094125,
-0.0015947551,
0.0229641665,
-0.0086002946,
-0.0653790385,
0.0179596543,
0.0560207218,
0.0328825936,
0.0293567088,
-0.026619792,
-0.0255246051,
0.0695579872,
0.0111086573,
-0.0249954667,
0.0118340338,
0.0265728477,
0.029873563,
-0.0007309669,
0.0430058874,
-0.0336189233,
-0.0033347313,
-0.0058110603,
0.0376383215,
-0.0236158073,
-0.0547409616,
0.0127063999,
-0.0136473197,
0.0090568718,
-0.0314094126,
-0.0564391948,
-0.0390027016,
0.0325963944,
-0.0081556905,
-0.0196300652,
-0.0564852245,
0.0130929863,
0.0004853896,
0.0015546115,
0.0579282381,
0.0101366406,
0.0058983229,
0.0109622646,
0.0070419335,
0.0291931015,
0.0177804232,
-0.0104302475,
0.0663511083,
0.022492554,
0.0081814481,
0.0109680193,
0.0057354304,
0.0245236047,
0.0223781522,
0.0643420294,
0.0442831703,
-0.0451658852,
-0.0488283671,
0.0056657768,
-0.014424474,
-0.0672947392,
0.0092036938,
0.0751047358,
0.0456421971,
0.0234191809,
-0.0005961579,
-0.0904295295,
0.008562278,
0.0000232175,
-0.0062652687,
-0.0010621924,
-0.0364341289,
0.0498486683,
0.0383771658,
-0.0226773899,
0.006740679,
0.0658996701,
0.014409868,
0.0561477467,
0.0139022749,
0.019893216,
-0.0433854274,
-0.0394359156,
0.0177705754,
0.0039283535,
-0.0455446169,
0.0061970153,
-0.0385103151,
-0.050188344,
-0.0499555022,
0.0510551855,
-0.0711515322,
-0.0578487739,
0.0622839816,
0.0247273408,
0.0151292318,
-0.0026021264,
-0.0309498981,
0.0087025901,
0.0064846226,
-0.037439201,
-0.013886502,
-5.955686944e-33,
-0.0258016102,
-0.0373968855,
0.0553249381,
-0.0192105584,
-0.0147685297,
-0.0164671913,
-0.0414807163,
0.0240610167,
0.0033221208,
0.0400198214,
-0.030705601,
-0.0004789201,
0.0162947401,
0.0073354817,
0.0079625538,
-0.0075074024,
0.0229584631,
-0.0155650405,
-0.050256107,
0.0156981796,
-0.0006055128,
0.0135261323,
-0.0066933511,
-0.0357567817,
-0.0038561106,
0.0138101829,
-0.0314035974,
0.0495668575,
-0.047330033,
0.0626076236,
-0.0261714458,
0.0128930034,
-0.0027040872,
-0.0454948023,
-0.0233267769,
0.0503522828,
-0.0533559546,
-0.0301018301,
-0.0007462531,
0.0278357752,
-0.0759368092,
-0.0008956084,
-0.0044324771,
0.0227386653,
-0.0320361108,
0.042931132,
0.0059705861,
-0.0269605648,
-0.0199851561,
0.0233422685,
-0.0375130475,
0.0067544691,
0.0088553205,
-0.0506697297,
0.0418385491,
-0.009504294,
-0.0013515075,
-0.0230564252,
-0.035807997,
0.0163894333,
0.0255389772,
-0.0015487063,
0.0501288027,
0.0012606425,
0.0246354174,
0.0474077687,
0.0022754013,
-0.0152469724,
-0.0426420011,
-0.0194242038,
0.0109005887,
0.0679947212,
-0.0043065855,
0.0288063586,
-0.0219761916,
0.0108066974,
-0.0228387173,
0.0336885042,
0.0436338,
0.0563388653,
0.0299172103,
0.0156025216,
-0.0302589387,
-0.0113902325,
-0.0439326316,
0.0332277641,
-0.0110392421,
-0.0424326472,
0.0325611234,
0.0390876532,
0.0055633369,
-0.0340941288,
0.0289225485,
-0.0136733884,
-0.039202787,
0.025430169,
-0.0169252958,
0.0386094674,
0.0038195136,
0.0278997123,
-0.0440950058,
-0.0366122015,
-0.0013707061,
-0.0172942579,
0.0040199757,
0.03128599,
-0.0000253889,
0.0659570098,
-0.0482444502,
0.0113991071,
-0.0369762182,
0.0331417657,
0.0478013046,
0.0074160993,
0.026983751,
-0.0369034559,
-0.023740368,
0.0273682531,
-0.0180598665,
-0.0459424183,
-0.0093989456,
-0.0317838602,
-0.0169512276,
-0.0000704747,
-0.0360319093,
-0.007464081,
-0.0495322347,
0.0296420697,
0.0259521492,
-0.0348385163,
0.0027531306,
0.0336703844,
2.813e-7,
-0.0347544178,
0.0530183055,
0.0076280488,
0.0067947526,
0.0161936563,
0.0456114933,
-0.0335242152,
0.0023764353,
-0.0419549346,
-0.0150437048,
0.0255299676,
0.0516678505,
0.0434137844,
0.0265625659,
-0.1053792164,
-0.0239151046,
-0.0429525934,
-0.0269596484,
-0.0837301835,
-0.0164410789,
0.0071193054,
0.0957253873,
0.0154616218,
0.0046050991,
0.0379431322,
-0.0177209489,
0.0294513013,
-0.0415212549,
0.0139858145,
0.0043178387,
0.0015918544,
0.0016761065,
-0.0216258448,
0.0028945121,
-0.0007550461,
0.0163428932,
-0.0226845238,
0.0714963749,
0.0243126694,
-0.0016035623,
0.0094248476,
-0.0259709191,
0.0233349297,
-0.0502389856,
0.055055365,
-0.0539490916,
-0.0097383531,
-0.0151185608,
0.0514199287,
-0.0653985217,
-0.027383402,
-0.0244372059,
0.0161406379,
-0.0143551528,
-0.0017201613,
-0.0016393864,
0.0096994424,
-0.0926670507,
-0.0036211056,
0.0053419992,
-0.057264246,
-0.0306862444,
-0.057606183,
0.0181208588,
0.0042228354,
-0.0636285841,
-0.0069190529,
2.477834644e-34,
0.0046994095,
0.0184635893,
-0.008293815,
0.0580507815,
0.0316070542,
0.0267266612,
-0.0067912848,
0.0189838465,
0.0571294799,
-0.0626683235,
-0.0330488607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15062v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15062v2 | Lawyer LLaMA Technical Report | 2023-05-24T11:52:07 | 2023-10-14T02:14:51 | Quzhe Huang, Mingxu Tao, Chen Zhang, Zhenwei An, Cong Jiang, Zhibin Chen, Zirui Wu, Yansong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), like LLaMA, have exhibited remarkable
performance across various tasks. Nevertheless, when deployed to specific
domains such as law or medicine, the models still confront the challenge of a
deficiency in domain-specific knowledge and an inadequate capability to
leverage that knowledge to resolve domain-related problems. In this paper, we
propose a new framework to adapt LLMs to specific domains and build Lawyer
LLaMA, a legal domain LLM, based on this framework. Specifically, we inject
domain knowledge during the continual training stage and teach the model to
learn professional skills using properly designed supervised fine-tuning tasks.
Moreover, to alleviate the hallucination problem during the model's generation,
we add a retrieval module and extract relevant legal articles before the model
answers any queries. When learning domain-specific skills, we find that
experts' experience is much more useful than experiences distilled from
ChatGPT, where hundreds of expert-written data outperform tens of thousands of
ChatGPT-generated ones. We will release our model and data. | [
0.0754768401,
0.0325630829,
-0.0174754187,
-0.0012236829,
-0.0382057466,
0.0153316734,
0.0199127924,
0.0254337844,
0.0255922079,
-0.0693522021,
-0.0562811904,
-0.0143154226,
-0.0579775237,
0.0060050692,
0.02584517,
-0.0471240431,
0.0477668159,
-0.0071867979,
0.0582923144,
-0.0150074344,
0.0178403128,
0.0115911234,
-0.0060583958,
0.0258397255,
-0.0109391967,
-0.0081415661,
0.0227761324,
-0.0215388071,
-0.0041658403,
0.0175247882,
0.0471260212,
0.0638219491,
0.026877908,
-0.010325456,
0.0000019089,
-0.0437510535,
0.0185643081,
-0.0115181943,
-0.0114093386,
-0.0067314254,
0.0491139553,
-0.0158065818,
-0.009460656,
0.0330351442,
-0.0475012325,
0.0153087927,
-0.0331494696,
0.0268848967,
0.0533916876,
0.1059007794,
0.0088971481,
-0.036869619,
0.050998766,
-0.0625384673,
-0.0012202259,
-0.0696656033,
0.0286859572,
0.0290127862,
0.0375532992,
0.0022507017,
0.0042516342,
0.0195683483,
0.036691118,
-0.0053412314,
0.0002413054,
0.0252574477,
-0.0245470367,
0.0278379135,
0.0054977136,
0.0308959745,
0.0003395134,
-0.0294657946,
-0.0010020648,
-0.00073284,
0.0629194006,
0.0002484162,
-0.0316314884,
0.0548877865,
0.0090139769,
-0.0055515245,
0.0227675326,
-0.0165746585,
0.0076561756,
0.0268593188,
-0.0015354514,
0.0276292432,
0.0007224189,
-0.0309380293,
0.0285583083,
0.0065259798,
0.0335738175,
-0.0487602539,
0.0290709268,
0.0615303181,
-0.035694886,
0.0266076829,
-0.0417660996,
0.0078474227,
0.0595172904,
-0.0501970574,
0.010494818,
0.0049786977,
-0.0188652296,
0.0684532747,
-0.0452375039,
-0.0054744822,
-0.0039987098,
0.0378803462,
-0.0323228389,
-0.0401022956,
-0.0818348378,
-0.019908417,
-0.0525802523,
0.0367064476,
-0.0656247586,
0.0183954164,
-0.0168415718,
0.0064013628,
-0.0176493302,
0.0092779854,
0.0149536589,
0.0154014956,
-0.0332625173,
-0.0418325588,
-0.0530779287,
-0.0248737596,
-0.0282275714,
0.0565067716,
0.0027374031,
-0.0229893513,
0.00758459,
0.0094634844,
-0.0270671602,
0.0078333896,
0.0269823503,
0.0973241925,
-0.0322568491,
-0.0340935253,
-0.039100457,
-0.057587713,
-0.0114980638,
-0.0788728669,
0.0080464901,
-0.0635713339,
0.017324511,
-0.0333948173,
-0.0062101898,
-0.0812065154,
0.0173327159,
0.0267954953,
-0.0254935976,
0.0643268153,
-0.0190158747,
-0.0028863193,
0.0253203139,
0.0434559695,
0.0010406455,
0.0530159734,
0.0023259472,
0.0046853339,
-0.0112475818,
0.0054627,
0.0335653611,
0.0315407701,
0.0028662847,
-0.007235969,
-0.0013504127,
0.0196489245,
-0.0010674066,
0.0560518578,
0.0300319381,
0.0190585256,
-0.0294584762,
0.0018070549,
0.0160983503,
0.0521547906,
0.0405766256,
0.0476055741,
0.0286145825,
-0.019113468,
0.0299169552,
-0.0047106715,
-0.0905924886,
0.0294210501,
-0.0052809818,
0.0035496494,
-0.0717700645,
0.0204918478,
-0.0478341803,
-0.0436372943,
0.0337062851,
0.0002280266,
-0.0510461442,
0.0188705549,
0.0350196771,
0.0308939703,
-0.0192003902,
0.052208703,
0.0324802287,
-0.0126765734,
-0.0064686709,
-0.0485742055,
-0.0208540931,
0.0754475892,
0.0410566516,
-0.0448538065,
-0.0670139715,
-0.0223989021,
0.0204808135,
0.0701510161,
0.0360565744,
-0.0176880937,
-0.0350188613,
-0.0571676977,
-0.0338236727,
-0.0030648131,
0.0381973237,
0.0131790871,
0.0249837302,
0.023044344,
0.0526660532,
-0.0511520356,
-0.0215037428,
0.0415893421,
-0.0846774206,
-0.0448616482,
-0.008660119,
-0.0206383262,
0.0218195952,
0.0100372238,
0.0006265562,
0.0044035208,
0.0210974142,
-0.0378292762,
0.0037392995,
0.008117035,
-0.0055269776,
-0.004886461,
0.0489945225,
-0.0287564937,
-0.0194623303,
-0.0053355922,
-0.041456338,
-0.0135013461,
-0.0382343829,
0.0051663225,
0.0255099051,
-0.0612577647,
-0.0207932461,
0.0115892878,
-0.0320411772,
-0.0238758791,
0.0628794879,
0.0100845685,
-0.041127868,
0.0037579313,
0.013346374,
0.0097533697,
-0.0316863805,
-0.0146429176,
-0.0449983105,
-0.0086678583,
0.052407179,
-0.0139990048,
0.040343903,
-0.0589732379,
-0.0669181421,
-0.0776938796,
0.0067728045,
-0.0222032554,
-0.0017300515,
-0.002789278,
-0.0502492674,
-0.0371588059,
-0.0313248597,
-0.0541043989,
0.0038712942,
0.0070321928,
-0.0156302135,
-0.0016573177,
-0.0046114451,
-0.0240736473,
-0.0380119793,
-0.003423437,
-0.0067896685,
-0.0221423227,
-0.000223475,
0.0019212917,
-0.0288661681,
0.082679607,
-0.0251902863,
0.0272493716,
-0.0224337839,
-0.0167159531,
-0.0079730405,
0.0000290463,
-0.0264788531,
0.0462416857,
0.0031719313,
0.0215202682,
0.0307482053,
-0.0040655946,
-0.0578386933,
0.0214503929,
0.0018161398,
-0.0156365801,
-0.0589928664,
0.0185606144,
0.0040979031,
0.0301928036,
-0.026406901,
0.0062645553,
-0.0280463845,
0.0153925233,
-0.0030381058,
-0.0205206163,
0.0103873964,
0.0419000983,
-0.0198400766,
0.0257641207,
-0.0102952076,
-0.0573280789,
0.0540225692,
0.022087086,
0.0513152182,
-0.0445484929,
-0.0150172068,
-0.0392607041,
0.0487002172,
-0.0228225607,
0.010049114,
-0.0149151869,
-0.0500534214,
-0.0402804539,
-0.0043208916,
0.0327776708,
-0.064402163,
0.0660028309,
-0.0326053947,
0.023134999,
0.0031200147,
-0.0561189726,
-0.0594633073,
-0.0132644009,
-0.0397413634,
0.0546311066,
-0.0182743631,
0.0283347685,
-0.0622382909,
-0.0427177548,
-0.0309649687,
0.0102082202,
0.0123306001,
-0.023597585,
-0.0325128324,
0.0270126052,
0.0369033664,
0.0212042928,
-0.0341666825,
-0.033471439,
-0.0128565505,
0.0284700915,
-0.0093473475,
-0.0178350843,
0.0047444869,
-0.0009025845,
0.008506923,
-0.0764562041,
-0.011881086,
0.0381560847,
-0.0084270034,
-0.065429531,
-0.0139648318,
0.1037576795,
0.0296032652,
-0.0515755117,
-0.0146732051,
-0.0089272456,
0.0108965691,
0.0529360808,
0.0603396706,
-0.085015662,
-0.0171599295,
-0.0037903117,
0.0106929643,
0.0009427867,
0.0006107312,
-0.0062822201,
-0.124461554,
0.0874637067,
0.022479834,
-0.011376624,
-0.0434156805,
0.0190772098,
-0.0133374389,
0.0024391252,
0.0239728373,
0.018771505,
-0.0360966623,
-0.0137731265,
0.0482052863,
-0.0065805377,
-0.0521416254,
0.0489201918,
-0.0316872783,
0.1046562418,
0.0530463271,
0.0005933327,
-0.0270051397,
-0.0364611894,
-0.0027967442,
0.0223019272,
0.0365910344,
0.0046086428,
0.0456299037,
-0.024681624,
0.0032896721,
-0.0269694943,
0.0482135303,
-0.0230775662,
-0.02055718,
0.0614748746,
0.0752909407,
-0.0362056755,
-0.0147964945,
-0.0279976893,
0.0049911104,
-0.0257310439,
0.0434123725,
0.010557944,
-0.0108834142,
-0.0295759011,
-0.0140560623,
-0.0342526957,
-0.0230379384,
-0.0362685658,
0.0180117916,
-0.0078666555,
0.0269593839,
-0.0264355484,
-0.0401575118,
0.0447481237,
0.0500026383,
0.0244899187,
0.0241626315,
0.0029653129,
-0.0148182176,
-0.0437057838,
0.0272658113,
-0.074872382,
0.0020962255,
-0.0426337644,
0.0010578505,
0.0722369999,
-0.0234122518,
-0.0301837064,
-0.0146374209,
-0.0215483662,
-0.0336015895,
-0.0072707571,
0.0577236563,
0.0220463444,
0.0359367542,
-0.0477822982,
-0.072438471,
0.0404495373,
0.0506854653,
-0.0687515736,
0.0024362009,
0.0482304879,
-0.0362089798,
-0.0031709657,
0.012151951,
-0.0400272347,
0.0365729369,
0.0385720544,
0.0075487057,
-0.0132552227,
-0.0099896621,
0.0368159004,
0.0127342027,
0.0124408128,
0.022675531,
0.0006657455,
-0.0509547293,
0.0184851009,
-0.0043493612,
-0.012785933,
-0.0296661891,
-0.0086633116,
0.0343298651,
-0.0182280783,
0.0111061139,
0.0198863503,
-0.026757136,
0.0162213519,
-0.047319565,
0.0076163528,
0.0127292015,
-0.0130122928,
0.0009447553,
-0.0341548659,
-0.0012136039,
0.0041353153,
0.0028898206,
0.055135753,
-0.0098851891,
0.064406164,
0.0051616621,
0.0189228281,
-0.0313575156,
0.0130452877,
-0.0259625651,
-0.0579119213,
-0.0150676556,
0.0945403501,
0.0988632515,
-0.013447498,
-0.0149721308,
-0.0378365405,
0.0085489908,
0.0023762295,
0.025938388,
-0.0041383798,
-0.015225552,
0.0629978701,
0.0297501702,
0.0052696923,
-0.010049222,
0.0790495798,
0.0259116367,
0.0466914922,
-0.0130845839,
0.0074624158,
-0.0362282656,
-0.0431080945,
0.0328532942,
0.0204255916,
-0.0360485166,
-0.002176644,
-0.0790882781,
-0.0594243743,
-0.0218450632,
0.0020290753,
-0.0420954153,
0.0028542392,
0.03784867,
0.0716297403,
0.000959035,
-0.0231325161,
-0.0251540449,
0.0191773903,
0.024962889,
-0.0153501984,
0.0090599312,
-5.779214385e-33,
-0.0440738574,
-0.0400953963,
0.0704098195,
0.0351909623,
-0.0106364228,
-0.0283653531,
0.0045138276,
-0.0065899035,
-0.023620842,
0.0209560897,
-0.0164827555,
0.0318261124,
0.0149164526,
-0.0098604914,
0.0347292051,
-0.022918392,
0.0291817542,
-0.0080550127,
0.0260336511,
0.0290584676,
-0.0354628563,
0.0361363739,
0.0403803475,
-0.09463045,
0.002855632,
0.0231315866,
-0.0007612762,
-0.0060964925,
-0.0603743121,
0.0746917501,
0.0047024349,
0.0399466902,
0.0249346085,
-0.054101333,
-0.0107253036,
-0.0084835161,
-0.0909181908,
-0.000346789,
0.0227251127,
-0.0123526258,
-0.0006360842,
-0.055392947,
0.050198745,
-0.0132171474,
-0.0049038497,
-0.0232623462,
0.0510821268,
-0.0458593667,
-0.0490474626,
-0.0449204333,
-0.0776364654,
0.0284765288,
-0.0004650346,
-0.0150447302,
0.0132042924,
-0.0324719697,
0.0028095958,
-0.0033630822,
-0.0489930399,
-0.0031742027,
0.0166874751,
0.0197506882,
0.0387244597,
-0.0403304212,
-0.0386897065,
0.0476685576,
0.0080559272,
0.0273975264,
-0.0074675232,
-0.0270710681,
0.0495110899,
0.1047791541,
0.0104042124,
0.0276545603,
0.0036806753,
-0.0290206037,
-0.0668005124,
-0.0047199745,
0.0148325861,
0.0631576777,
-0.0023661905,
-0.0167742148,
-0.0200403333,
-0.002685206,
-0.0260149967,
-0.0081923241,
0.0022483896,
-0.0177316144,
0.050359223,
0.0176680125,
0.0486077145,
-0.0434681401,
-0.0238810703,
-0.0498059839,
0.0265434515,
0.0270662606,
-0.0178157836,
0.0209658984,
-0.0304030422,
0.0416177511,
-0.0901667625,
-0.0596647747,
-0.0087352572,
-0.0273486339,
0.0049534333,
0.0078722751,
0.0532389395,
-0.0082529783,
-0.0671639144,
-0.008946158,
-0.0067558927,
0.0342106111,
0.0559885241,
0.0497217812,
0.0106349187,
0.0284080319,
0.0049601495,
0.0279898494,
0.0067514349,
-0.0471142977,
-0.0218398534,
0.004588515,
0.0101075154,
-0.0103878537,
-0.0321572907,
0.0263444223,
-0.0105301337,
0.0270935912,
0.0224669874,
-0.0106192818,
0.0150269167,
0.02401039,
2.55e-7,
0.0666068792,
0.0455587134,
-0.0240366366,
0.0359227136,
-0.000380893,
0.0266068317,
-0.0080073653,
0.0444023907,
0.0322404094,
-0.0136535158,
0.0139367487,
0.0347263776,
0.0582126006,
0.0209854487,
-0.1005023718,
-0.0186400935,
-0.0129156336,
-0.0271241181,
-0.0453303047,
-0.0320804752,
0.0381865688,
0.0972684175,
0.017208131,
-0.0330579579,
0.0098495865,
-0.0473580621,
0.0828084052,
-0.0058088154,
-0.0230649654,
0.026315501,
0.0617836937,
0.033894632,
-0.0189690534,
0.0547802076,
-0.0202557221,
0.0553582646,
-0.0255177058,
0.1077061146,
-0.0202400126,
0.0288955867,
0.0117495749,
-0.024101261,
0.0031251067,
-0.015512825,
0.0462389924,
-0.0503362752,
-0.004900475,
-0.0107029323,
-0.0314104706,
-0.0277348403,
0.0083755339,
0.002674191,
-0.0208434798,
-0.0180601589,
0.0354960784,
-0.0189192481,
-0.0225626249,
-0.0795176402,
0.0025412417,
0.0392628312,
-0.0236105379,
-0.0013450807,
0.007481128,
-0.0161203053,
0.0349889919,
-0.076507546,
0.0404665805,
1.982926956e-34,
0.0338802971,
0.0067792651,
0.0279018153,
0.078831695,
-0.0070020687,
0.0443293527,
0.0033151675,
0.0219556801,
0.0107528483,
-0.0544524454,
0.0094550215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15060v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15060v4 | Who Wrote this Code? Watermarking for Code Generation | 2023-05-24T11:49:52 | 2024-07-03T15:09:52 | Taehyun Lee, Seokhee Hong, Jaewoo Ahn, Ilgee Hong, Hwaran Lee, Sangdoo Yun, Jamin Shin, Gunhee Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Since the remarkable generation performance of large language models raised
ethical and legal concerns, approaches to detect machine-generated text by
embedding watermarks are being developed. However, we discover that the
existing works fail to function appropriately in code generation tasks due to
the task's nature of having low entropy. Extending a logit-modifying watermark
method, we propose Selective WatErmarking via Entropy Thresholding (SWEET),
which enhances detection ability and mitigates code quality degeneration by
removing low-entropy segments at generating and detecting watermarks. Our
experiments show that SWEET significantly improves code quality preservation
while outperforming all baselines, including post-hoc detection methods, in
detecting machine-generated code text. Our code is available in
https://github.com/hongcheki/sweet-watermark. | [
0.0345217399,
0.0770650506,
-0.026349131,
0.0282084253,
-0.0060607083,
-0.0121392328,
0.0187802222,
0.0687109381,
0.0139097935,
-0.0033858407,
0.0165155232,
0.0362756886,
0.0212370064,
0.0150420545,
0.0484991185,
0.0029479642,
0.0158970393,
0.0405582562,
-0.0255592447,
0.0180123504,
-0.0011377003,
0.0029928167,
0.0739032477,
0.014407739,
0.0068389121,
-0.0185324848,
0.0234002359,
0.0586587451,
-0.0147395497,
-0.0310813412,
-0.0219538659,
0.0746167228,
-0.0255836118,
0.0437184684,
0.0000023644,
-0.0030154332,
-0.0363090783,
0.0089957677,
0.0089984294,
0.0456910841,
0.0138352579,
0.0048187086,
-0.0378543288,
0.0251493733,
-0.0338876843,
0.0111720404,
0.0574569888,
-0.0007785159,
0.0680693388,
0.0324853919,
-0.0085819196,
0.0251581669,
0.0242762994,
0.0279333442,
0.0689498186,
0.0208775718,
0.0013157784,
0.0279711187,
-0.0359540917,
-0.0228043701,
0.0281746387,
0.0565122664,
0.0310256351,
-0.0382797271,
0.0038054688,
0.0398712195,
0.0063258903,
-0.0035271551,
0.0210837778,
-0.0136367949,
-0.085767597,
-0.0441118143,
0.0467789024,
-0.0062676985,
-0.0194036979,
-0.058690045,
0.0081675295,
0.0330357477,
0.00094265,
0.0186282154,
-0.0209291819,
-0.0047682263,
-0.0001020929,
0.0032754752,
0.0234239884,
0.01444933,
-0.0044409921,
-0.0323352069,
-0.0602419972,
0.0030216719,
-0.0024487232,
-0.0956569538,
0.0172642637,
0.0209030025,
0.0840030238,
-0.028298445,
-0.0756130144,
-0.0648563355,
0.0111043667,
-0.0165331382,
0.0164999757,
0.0159505699,
0.0336011164,
-0.0012876524,
-0.0514694154,
0.0421335585,
-0.0082062203,
0.0432224609,
0.0180216525,
0.0423611626,
0.0167416167,
-0.0090689249,
-0.0324641131,
0.0122458106,
0.0151234232,
0.0269666929,
-0.0162796043,
0.0537923165,
0.014081317,
0.0594540127,
-0.0480143726,
-0.0174876228,
-0.0010504741,
0.014439716,
0.0799017251,
-0.0714666024,
0.0228909105,
-0.0221005213,
-0.0014255681,
-0.0275981724,
0.0106212879,
0.0623563901,
0.0134834005,
0.0092243738,
-0.0023784654,
0.0337834843,
0.0224286132,
-0.0168815665,
-0.0396790504,
-0.0401095413,
0.001482405,
0.0286144,
0.0113086104,
-0.0516205393,
-0.0681169704,
-0.037216153,
0.0030768355,
-0.0675170347,
0.0015813505,
0.017492326,
-0.007231331,
0.0358371735,
-0.1111295372,
-0.0207688883,
-0.0068567279,
0.0179102533,
-0.0147033194,
0.0232669394,
0.067297183,
0.0439985134,
0.0490378812,
-0.0587495863,
0.0239068568,
0.0213459898,
-0.010768936,
0.0446358919,
-0.0030131442,
-0.0228856672,
0.0219569057,
-0.0365679227,
0.0511237569,
0.0186901093,
0.0045234547,
-0.007320384,
0.0253669582,
0.0347593985,
-0.0142889163,
0.0271154549,
0.007540524,
0.0403910317,
0.0004319865,
0.0236129835,
0.0062555042,
-0.0067220628,
-0.0142408432,
-0.0357829109,
0.0150007056,
-0.0050002201,
0.0232203957,
-0.0155280679,
-0.0094555104,
-0.0214339159,
-0.0119676106,
-0.0388061777,
-0.02656883,
0.0288140345,
-0.0150260814,
-0.0096458858,
-0.0027836764,
-0.0419793762,
0.0206643865,
-0.0416252278,
0.0324904844,
0.0656500757,
0.0635065064,
0.0011994513,
0.1310249418,
-0.0122952433,
-0.0549630038,
-0.01222739,
-0.0523284711,
0.0212230682,
0.0172899067,
-0.0522811078,
-0.0315168537,
-0.0350765064,
-0.023754986,
0.0343417227,
-0.0025916079,
0.0092313979,
0.0440650806,
0.0152373165,
-0.0143910488,
0.0188156497,
0.0153512433,
-0.0048930701,
0.0200926345,
-0.0147372112,
0.0061528319,
-0.023640858,
-0.0700284913,
0.0410713702,
0.0213268083,
-0.0247615166,
-0.0157992616,
-0.0329590775,
0.0149623388,
-0.0160835031,
-0.0018883602,
-0.0534554571,
-0.0043098731,
0.0374483317,
-0.0058395038,
-0.001776206,
0.0498659089,
-0.0465198755,
0.013618188,
-0.0630717054,
-0.002959467,
-0.0390088819,
0.0080816317,
-0.0343102738,
0.01445561,
0.0036982386,
0.0536326356,
-0.0058852695,
0.037657667,
-0.0006321808,
-0.000857811,
-0.0050922888,
0.0027201714,
-0.0690487847,
0.0195021499,
-0.0006502445,
0.0707206279,
0.023260057,
-0.0418029092,
-0.0184019264,
0.0187514164,
-0.0009480111,
-0.0119279735,
0.0300105456,
0.0022184118,
0.016366154,
0.0077304468,
-0.0025324444,
-0.0223623496,
0.0032939082,
-0.014266381,
0.0333183371,
-0.026444843,
-0.0166113339,
0.0051752659,
-0.0045822663,
-0.0006829976,
0.0647235215,
0.0262900442,
-0.0102819027,
-0.1009229124,
0.1001607031,
-0.0290325489,
-0.0256740134,
0.038507387,
-0.0404206924,
-0.0327362567,
-0.0394178182,
0.0246444251,
0.0613527335,
0.0218012501,
-0.0142790014,
0.0411814488,
0.053137958,
0.0027881998,
-0.0121585121,
0.0154269459,
0.0248397291,
0.0219992343,
-0.0616166554,
0.0697378814,
0.0227312651,
0.0202233959,
0.0179330688,
-0.0287997071,
0.0347554237,
0.012442667,
0.018046312,
0.0084389299,
-0.0068121199,
-0.0404345319,
0.0545234308,
-0.0452174805,
-0.0785785466,
0.0053438237,
-0.0325431935,
-0.0139341401,
0.0140673975,
0.0082544936,
0.0212695524,
-0.0110685015,
0.0001533276,
0.029560715,
0.0377588049,
-0.0347040333,
-0.0057398868,
0.0085865147,
0.037243817,
-0.0496052168,
-0.0417497791,
-0.0092477771,
-0.016243441,
-0.002778681,
0.00196912,
-0.0064702351,
-0.0291516986,
0.020035807,
-0.0341850668,
0.056974519,
-0.0012434064,
0.0289238617,
-0.009433087,
0.0222861469,
0.0353715084,
0.011512599,
-0.0388407521,
-0.0332869217,
0.0486036204,
-0.0323980749,
-0.0956691578,
0.0206382647,
0.0151501242,
-0.0137336599,
0.0668264031,
0.0322248898,
0.0595533922,
-0.0001311403,
-0.0058170334,
0.0535372458,
0.0399373285,
-0.0201359112,
0.0549558774,
0.0276487879,
0.0035623314,
-0.006244462,
0.044221133,
0.0201149583,
-0.0130640799,
0.0314928591,
-0.0113272322,
0.0686142892,
0.0360049792,
-0.015486531,
-0.0889824703,
-0.0113773188,
0.0244220905,
0.0472360104,
-0.0487411842,
-0.0150724454,
-0.0406023487,
-0.0279088207,
0.0335273184,
0.0245756991,
0.0035510114,
-0.0117980558,
-0.0497546755,
-0.0310896244,
0.0586047396,
-0.0545490086,
-0.0256200694,
0.0219313987,
0.0132205226,
0.0159525685,
-0.0235783216,
0.009629922,
-0.0005031396,
-0.0215934068,
0.0202624314,
0.1234188452,
0.0439969972,
0.0119424909,
-0.0100657092,
-0.0000816297,
-0.0756547898,
-0.0126365162,
-0.0214578807,
0.0531623028,
-0.0125189964,
-0.0306122433,
0.0133592738,
-0.0114311995,
-0.0181989539,
-0.0147271538,
-0.0019748341,
0.0143293897,
0.0000840193,
-0.0546729043,
0.0071447273,
0.0010345611,
0.0086208694,
0.0327917077,
0.0518956892,
-0.0004487944,
-0.0626166835,
-0.0822098404,
0.0665508956,
-0.0456336997,
-0.0223135184,
-0.0436568446,
-0.0338077657,
-0.0701301917,
-0.0508474708,
0.0159198549,
-0.0498446561,
0.0073485998,
0.0224105641,
-0.0227148533,
0.0277917571,
-0.0321946703,
-0.0752760321,
-0.051156152,
-0.0837746933,
0.0009134542,
-0.0360039361,
-0.0113739138,
-0.0137677146,
-0.0063141463,
-0.005398416,
0.0413253494,
-0.0464574769,
-0.0436068252,
-0.0156492461,
0.0299911685,
0.0200130306,
-0.0145639833,
-0.0259714853,
-0.0306317098,
-0.0121207545,
0.0047263955,
-0.0179072153,
0.0222996119,
0.0440954119,
-0.0307278335,
0.0221613552,
0.0076595787,
-0.0429367386,
-0.0051496392,
0.0782390907,
-0.0540682338,
-0.0433864854,
0.0090076216,
0.025203025,
0.0272020716,
-0.0076248217,
-0.0242993198,
-0.0154298898,
0.0441986769,
-0.0236040112,
0.0062005082,
-0.0279942993,
-0.0523217134,
0.0173753202,
0.0342985578,
-0.0196391121,
0.0152640631,
0.054679174,
-0.0282243993,
0.0121436259,
0.0013010703,
0.0195068307,
-0.0578386188,
0.0785414726,
0.0333141387,
-0.0037988054,
-0.0057528643,
0.055712074,
0.0181169324,
0.0201795287,
-0.0127252946,
-0.0031304108,
0.024790328,
-0.0111305211,
0.0105616143,
0.0503544994,
-0.0912829265,
-0.0110542998,
-0.0136984158,
-0.0125275329,
0.061792504,
0.0638291538,
0.0373025313,
-0.0261219256,
0.0206036605,
-0.033558663,
0.0508332364,
-0.0015917266,
-0.093284294,
-0.0559165888,
-0.0290468298,
-0.0527866632,
-0.0375285,
0.0597125255,
0.0281484425,
0.0271612201,
-0.013434777,
-0.0266191624,
-0.0484557487,
-0.0048875003,
0.0568294786,
-0.0028618702,
-0.0102163358,
-0.0022076506,
-0.0016658198,
-0.0327920094,
-0.0063905101,
-0.0067496751,
0.0377193987,
0.011917905,
-0.02737456,
0.0427156538,
-0.0311104897,
-0.0233877022,
-0.0344915576,
0.01410113,
0.0160815883,
-0.0411066785,
-0.0022400871,
-6.072535491e-33,
-0.0060309339,
-0.0403363332,
-0.078439422,
0.0368825346,
0.0395509303,
0.0205881409,
-0.0489186756,
-0.0186485704,
0.0027263099,
-0.04435651,
0.0377328284,
0.0145970536,
-0.0006108927,
-0.0455488041,
-0.0152270375,
0.0203345977,
0.0328587592,
0.0096281087,
-0.055715017,
0.035489466,
-0.0143534429,
-0.0162782315,
-0.0150268124,
-0.0210717879,
-0.0244928263,
-0.03270524,
-0.0530755781,
-0.0412909575,
0.0074890894,
0.0034686401,
0.0149396295,
-0.0170249399,
-0.0105677797,
-0.0075182277,
-0.0529929288,
-0.0011400473,
-0.0244299769,
-0.0244322401,
-0.0428823158,
0.010698678,
0.0143677425,
-0.1068552658,
0.057934463,
-0.0438461937,
-0.0358777866,
-0.003001563,
0.0052789119,
0.0037677533,
-0.0264382083,
-0.0844848752,
-0.0156828575,
0.021275267,
-0.042762991,
0.0039044323,
0.017925581,
-0.0047862628,
0.0330019034,
0.0117388144,
-0.0492891558,
0.0461022705,
0.0097605251,
0.0074741989,
-0.0002866705,
-0.0185122248,
0.007753476,
0.0074588419,
0.0469755642,
0.0214696042,
0.0321149416,
0.0114008049,
0.0382026993,
-0.0167812277,
0.064920418,
0.0029476313,
0.0968106091,
-0.0612132587,
0.0321065672,
0.0639058799,
-0.060419403,
-0.0079186466,
0.0232559461,
0.0263339002,
-0.0415156931,
-0.0194404367,
-0.0223104451,
-0.0796514153,
0.005758665,
-0.0189915113,
0.0414293185,
0.0138653796,
-0.055424083,
-0.005757879,
-0.0008056668,
-0.0796644464,
0.0022886393,
0.0143275065,
-0.0401761308,
0.0278328229,
-0.0105253672,
0.0067701656,
0.0322053172,
0.0136228045,
0.082584925,
-0.0280691441,
0.0598375909,
0.0193261281,
0.0352984928,
-0.0108270245,
-0.07406459,
-0.000656589,
-0.0194938388,
0.0259353649,
0.019218076,
-0.0212001,
-0.0195555743,
-0.0475569852,
0.0389043055,
-0.0462597236,
0.0246838313,
-0.0002038944,
-0.0544969365,
0.0351698399,
-0.0219543073,
0.0560074858,
-0.0237127151,
0.0031625256,
-0.0418119915,
0.0203800648,
0.064857021,
0.0047222241,
-0.058334928,
-0.0124758901,
2.978e-7,
0.0138764223,
0.0263957717,
0.0195382126,
-0.0271504596,
0.019995911,
0.0489342213,
-0.0194832738,
-0.0119526805,
-0.0401922725,
0.0031183986,
-0.0446277335,
-0.0221445393,
0.0662122071,
-0.0317085311,
-0.0164225362,
0.0076444815,
-0.0031193625,
-0.0079301987,
-0.0383492671,
0.0326158106,
0.0587710552,
0.0524856038,
-0.0140295941,
-0.0394653529,
0.0528199114,
-0.0867602602,
0.0142928436,
-0.0326817706,
0.0805059746,
-0.0017174114,
-0.0372981094,
-0.0063438765,
0.012317583,
-0.0398177765,
-0.0531416051,
-0.0784427971,
-0.0126540866,
0.0729542822,
-0.0023412593,
0.0805604383,
-0.0042244676,
-0.0300234426,
0.0038730407,
-0.0763767809,
0.0404429697,
0.0812096894,
-0.0183929522,
-0.0300849769,
-0.0269930959,
-0.0452600606,
0.0467431992,
-0.0169622265,
-0.0102805234,
-0.0240051597,
-0.0084812269,
0.0251988918,
-0.0143707255,
0.0078905821,
-0.0435086749,
-0.0640659407,
-0.0241404828,
-0.020123424,
-0.0374708548,
0.0240890589,
0.0809624642,
-0.0533967689,
0.0465279445,
2.993132567e-34,
0.0103769805,
-0.064254798,
0.015447625,
0.0369135328,
0.0522540174,
0.0104703829,
0.01253621,
0.0048607015,
-0.0079337638,
0.0122953448,
0.0115654701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15057v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15057v2 | Linear-Time Modeling of Linguistic Structure: An Order-Theoretic Perspective | 2023-05-24T11:47:35 | 2023-12-12T08:46:11 | Tianyu Liu, Afra Amini, Mrinmaya Sachan, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tasks that model the relation between pairs of tokens in a string are a vital
part of understanding natural language. Such tasks, in general, require
exhaustive pair-wise comparisons of tokens, thus having a quadratic runtime
complexity in the length of the string. We show that these exhaustive
comparisons can be avoided, and, moreover, the complexity of such tasks can be
reduced to linear by casting the relation between tokens as a partial order
over the string. Our method predicts real numbers for each token in a string in
parallel and sorts the tokens accordingly, resulting in total orders of the
tokens in the string. Each total order implies a set of arcs oriented from
smaller to greater tokens, sorted by their predicted numbers. The intersection
of total orders results in a partial order over the set of tokens in the
string, which is then decoded into a directed graph representing the desired
linguistic structure. Our experiments on dependency parsing and coreference
resolution show that our method achieves state-of-the-art or comparable
performance. Moreover, the linear complexity and parallelism of our method
double the speed of graph-based coreference resolution models, and bring a
10-times speed-up over graph-based dependency parsers. | [
0.0329009406,
0.0202205107,
-0.0138680451,
0.0594917834,
-0.0526136272,
0.0078232791,
-0.0584476441,
-0.0031090486,
0.0293125566,
-0.0553861298,
0.0448799916,
0.0191660728,
0.012416441,
-0.0050545894,
-0.0371889658,
-0.055781737,
0.0494958013,
-0.0447508693,
0.0432390645,
-0.0091050649,
-0.0033235711,
0.0272782482,
-0.0323830508,
-0.0083769308,
-0.0743702427,
-0.0136088543,
-0.0084736515,
0.0176658705,
-0.0000137225,
-0.014903673,
-0.0293728951,
0.0257941857,
0.0084970612,
0.0192989018,
0.0000021846,
-0.0305167418,
-0.0473947264,
0.0230497923,
-0.0099120066,
0.0199300349,
0.0194074195,
-0.0408986211,
-0.0063062138,
-0.0094795208,
-0.0157464296,
-0.0178605858,
0.0229618046,
0.0189815201,
0.0485792831,
0.0416602045,
-0.0262816567,
-0.0505849868,
0.0075272643,
0.0181650277,
-0.0840819702,
-0.0622306094,
-0.0034198815,
0.0294650774,
0.0297627728,
0.017562123,
-0.0410565548,
-0.0063560749,
0.0179787166,
0.029544076,
0.0112121729,
0.044456441,
-0.0463673808,
0.0181838609,
0.0039724358,
0.0865938887,
0.0063943798,
-0.0061983718,
0.0287738685,
0.000278097,
-0.0068458342,
0.0020977617,
-0.0247027166,
-0.0118299676,
-0.0245176814,
0.0322586447,
0.0370532311,
0.0011725641,
-0.0210953522,
0.0011526239,
-0.0602514558,
0.1270075291,
-0.0057500647,
-0.0117049152,
0.0167646259,
-0.0033429984,
-0.0443963259,
-0.0344669074,
0.0641243756,
-0.0227377452,
-0.0260673948,
0.0255175699,
-0.0315341465,
0.0104782982,
-0.0338024944,
-0.0524313711,
-0.0282549933,
0.0095025282,
-0.0174502339,
0.0261933152,
-0.0254619457,
0.0796387643,
-0.0220968276,
0.0270380545,
-0.049702853,
-0.0064246706,
-0.0499385633,
0.0238963477,
-0.0746894032,
0.0768417791,
-0.0827407688,
-0.0348512977,
-0.0436162055,
-0.0023187199,
0.0141541706,
-0.0139876474,
0.0276981629,
0.0056775743,
-0.0002027399,
0.0180430021,
-0.0168857332,
0.0165323857,
-0.0215923619,
-0.0234793052,
-0.0666090697,
-0.033555802,
0.0093280589,
0.00187395,
0.0385124683,
-0.0563395657,
-0.0143871475,
0.061441008,
0.0164338816,
-0.0146773951,
0.0331704542,
-0.0546221696,
-0.0270124264,
0.0139366584,
-0.0353171863,
-0.0803114623,
0.0271360502,
0.0304968618,
0.0224916525,
-0.0258517303,
0.028211236,
0.0122915916,
-0.0649732426,
0.0526679754,
0.0161516909,
0.008709847,
-0.0092066536,
-0.0362589657,
0.0195370596,
0.0203804728,
0.0160440467,
0.011969245,
0.0181084387,
-0.006813908,
-0.0612786114,
0.0374108069,
0.0023720062,
-0.016364228,
-0.0090402029,
-0.0173421782,
-0.0576531664,
0.0051631066,
0.008043021,
0.1048567295,
-0.0119586,
-0.051748123,
-0.0111669693,
0.0547285676,
-0.0270442311,
-0.0352326855,
-0.0034647123,
0.0132342195,
-0.0062080054,
0.0625221431,
-0.0549011491,
-0.0154923685,
0.0357008055,
-0.0131026106,
0.0190007258,
-0.0179890245,
0.0147582134,
-0.0179755036,
-0.0204075091,
-0.0015199139,
0.0147055844,
-0.0458858982,
0.0460630432,
-0.0047896225,
-0.0627971292,
0.0471182279,
0.0319393352,
-0.0268718526,
-0.0412134305,
0.0149842603,
-0.0772854313,
0.0700259358,
0.0324596055,
0.0157796051,
-0.0306928586,
0.0402439646,
0.0336698666,
0.0183537882,
0.0106919678,
-0.0164189618,
0.0157724656,
-0.016776653,
0.0091674356,
0.0481363945,
-0.0256578214,
0.0524446368,
0.0067222873,
-0.0118506309,
0.0016732141,
0.0020613363,
-0.0488849729,
0.0019375067,
0.0369293652,
0.0153753925,
0.0245071277,
0.0208032932,
0.0555045269,
0.0451905951,
0.0011709851,
0.0439254232,
0.0412882753,
-0.0425787717,
-0.0089653842,
0.0461132154,
-0.0499505885,
-0.0302438848,
0.0247407742,
-0.0486620218,
-0.0261158533,
-0.0180686433,
-0.030596137,
-0.0440774448,
0.0423400812,
-0.0732796788,
0.06626793,
0.0275056157,
0.0046071806,
0.0395696573,
-0.0276463255,
-0.0171097666,
0.0791181251,
-0.0145140858,
0.0236439202,
0.0046507958,
0.023923818,
-0.0047851573,
-0.0357943811,
0.0044502057,
-0.0027739517,
-0.0069318525,
-0.0345458388,
0.0306099206,
-0.0289386865,
-0.0317863934,
-0.0183054917,
-0.0866017118,
-0.0338440202,
0.020452857,
0.0244704969,
0.0120759597,
0.0071555553,
0.0231110863,
-0.021299364,
0.0159939192,
0.0134441108,
0.0391084775,
0.0197691768,
0.0279125758,
0.0079226969,
-0.068962276,
-0.0326713435,
-0.0213534385,
-0.0674592108,
0.0258493219,
0.0325424597,
-0.0344243944,
0.0007044268,
0.032903146,
-0.0300956201,
0.048509486,
0.015617908,
-0.0179491788,
0.0190567505,
-0.0280701406,
0.0298939776,
0.0397320986,
-0.0254803076,
0.0193933547,
0.0117826378,
-0.0972259343,
-0.0471965633,
0.0105176549,
-0.0016198361,
0.009105769,
-0.0235245749,
-0.0550092421,
-0.0157242436,
0.0850327611,
0.0422551297,
0.0078528048,
-0.0418442897,
-0.0029269874,
-0.0404330269,
0.0082728826,
0.0226590484,
-0.026369093,
-0.0267926063,
0.0214052945,
-0.0516286641,
0.0125326607,
0.0484736525,
-0.0204766784,
0.0128694903,
-0.0156465657,
0.0143644381,
-0.0640207604,
0.0826049373,
0.0499316491,
0.0234428681,
0.0262663178,
-0.0775615275,
-0.0121282153,
0.0232593808,
0.0204768404,
-0.014274531,
0.0404092595,
-0.0674201399,
0.0674919933,
0.0042459546,
-0.0208446439,
-0.0309546851,
0.0197048262,
-0.0351945683,
0.0133163398,
0.0398357362,
0.0060664946,
0.0115405945,
0.0052580163,
-0.0232381355,
0.0194990318,
0.0014199244,
0.0060629835,
-0.0430406071,
0.0638381988,
-0.0161046237,
-0.0223456621,
-0.0076901796,
0.0001006379,
0.0046296692,
0.0553552173,
0.0423326567,
-0.0019693386,
-0.0580786429,
-0.0193899255,
0.0011721515,
-0.0474017337,
-0.045904085,
-0.014848046,
-0.0050698994,
-0.0145697128,
-0.026199095,
0.1342462748,
0.0672028884,
-0.007957262,
0.0089226589,
0.0164417177,
0.0115877045,
0.0478668511,
0.0085716816,
-0.065037936,
-0.0223106723,
0.0120866122,
-0.0264628716,
-0.0012764058,
-0.0718900114,
-0.0072777229,
-0.1027023047,
-0.0079033431,
0.0039217635,
-0.0325233191,
-0.0174910352,
-0.0288943462,
-0.0107312743,
0.0048215808,
-0.0442291126,
0.034264382,
-0.0006555122,
0.0277938545,
0.0223917123,
-0.0257445127,
0.0556507297,
0.0281951874,
-0.0003467134,
-0.0263378713,
0.019197613,
0.0600245111,
0.0031338229,
0.0460687429,
0.0372998826,
-0.0048848465,
0.0229363628,
-0.0481669642,
-0.0138845444,
0.0263742134,
-0.0120229227,
-0.018495068,
0.0070560407,
-0.0361773148,
0.0144717274,
-0.005503505,
0.0552027225,
0.030361658,
0.0327006057,
-0.0023839718,
-0.0063743661,
-0.03761461,
0.0235879067,
0.0181011353,
0.0162544344,
-0.0281545632,
-0.0619737171,
0.0337552018,
-0.070358865,
-0.0417817347,
-0.0252297521,
0.0185828637,
0.0163156502,
-0.0877567679,
0.0031619717,
0.0126256784,
0.0182400458,
-0.036220029,
-0.0132658919,
0.0527542233,
-0.0192236733,
-0.0460441969,
-0.02031116,
-0.0190487914,
0.020100316,
-0.1099596247,
0.0072925147,
0.0729703978,
0.0675150156,
-0.0393135063,
0.0814060196,
-0.0373879485,
-0.0526342653,
0.0126702692,
0.0264585018,
0.0067015528,
0.0213730428,
-0.0400699154,
0.0113675883,
-0.0372885354,
0.0451313816,
-0.0674302801,
0.0264517479,
-0.0051883338,
0.0116258794,
0.014016646,
0.0395639464,
-0.0165865291,
0.0424238928,
-0.0394067131,
0.0366187878,
-0.0718791932,
-0.0660223439,
0.0677972287,
0.0776712075,
0.0433487929,
0.041583363,
-0.0013299339,
0.0110651702,
0.0291198939,
-0.0769039392,
-0.0426109098,
-0.0136065846,
0.0001649179,
-0.0213225614,
0.0131883901,
0.0006693259,
-0.052033674,
0.0153260631,
0.0342336334,
0.0526269637,
-0.0009098856,
0.0258291028,
-0.0009193626,
0.0331372209,
-0.0181770418,
0.0052725221,
0.0000225325,
0.0122785168,
0.0544476025,
-0.0533171631,
0.0008215338,
-0.0005222414,
-0.0130866999,
-0.0411804803,
-0.0141504202,
-0.0162962452,
0.0150167309,
0.0275161136,
-0.0144495284,
0.0401212387,
-0.0175595693,
0.0945395306,
-0.009070931,
0.0075916871,
-0.006673024,
0.0398209542,
0.0112627419,
-0.0184804052,
0.0101722404,
0.0365312286,
0.0384392552,
0.0201878566,
0.0661196411,
0.021341987,
-0.0153094111,
0.0324872807,
-0.0312438197,
-0.0297586992,
-0.0366739966,
-0.0710621774,
0.0041624098,
-0.0166176725,
0.0724237487,
-0.0383982025,
-0.0310617313,
0.0399989486,
-0.009314876,
0.0415747687,
-0.0145903276,
0.0609932207,
0.0177588016,
0.042953968,
-0.0260413438,
-0.0181583222,
0.025907075,
-0.0018146468,
-0.0863032714,
-0.026216194,
-6.112708745e-33,
-0.0823938027,
-0.0785451382,
-0.0214291643,
0.0110487686,
0.0176699404,
0.043430537,
-0.0188471712,
0.0212964304,
0.0066519314,
-0.0227325745,
-0.0032708857,
-0.0066367565,
0.0120199881,
0.0047903373,
0.0187338777,
0.0219335202,
0.0227952469,
-0.0263423901,
0.0155241936,
-0.0067192502,
0.0880962163,
0.0322211906,
0.032933075,
-0.0447845459,
0.0038238601,
0.0064552291,
0.017807655,
0.0298107266,
0.0155135663,
0.027429726,
0.0266284235,
0.0251144636,
0.0188873429,
-0.027393572,
0.0010262247,
0.0096201282,
-0.1053401902,
-0.0389130935,
0.0631796047,
0.0363021865,
-0.0206643939,
-0.0150326993,
0.0342914425,
-0.0092677176,
-0.009627278,
-0.0162438322,
0.0156696253,
-0.0045377105,
-0.0256974995,
0.042288024,
-0.0374666825,
0.028271744,
-0.0410976149,
0.0006283706,
0.0748833492,
0.0348783471,
-0.0021592006,
-0.0178245548,
-0.0075767748,
0.044333674,
-0.0446711406,
0.0482105315,
-0.0036981343,
-0.0125128375,
-0.0088026151,
0.0223054569,
0.045446232,
-0.064264603,
-0.008042424,
0.0466457382,
-0.0184102952,
0.0456725359,
-0.0385353714,
0.008326171,
0.0014887553,
0.0273802076,
-0.0665383935,
-0.0191557892,
0.0629175156,
0.034334898,
-0.0183433741,
0.0226512179,
-0.0615723953,
-0.0488655418,
-0.0125768501,
-0.0253373552,
-0.032636404,
-0.0347376578,
0.0070175054,
-0.0363547169,
-0.0153833516,
0.0077686636,
0.0238775332,
-0.0272966418,
-0.0612615421,
0.0189897623,
0.0088067716,
0.0439547114,
-0.0296470895,
0.0414194204,
-0.0416101553,
-0.0146922506,
-0.0101929577,
-0.0048015863,
0.0558549128,
0.0014725579,
0.0036813787,
-0.0335893296,
-0.044309821,
-0.0078084902,
-0.0398534313,
-0.0128484378,
-0.0759606883,
0.0034227527,
0.0323285945,
0.0152502395,
0.0085410606,
0.0544720031,
0.0048720012,
-0.0099368244,
-0.0502807498,
0.0018547699,
0.0221225973,
0.0422491319,
-0.044724118,
-0.0345426127,
0.0137367602,
0.0042620352,
0.0198547635,
-0.0122077232,
-0.0503497869,
0.0217354316,
2.926e-7,
0.0192996096,
0.0785674825,
0.0943682194,
0.0344726034,
0.031084571,
-0.0060663028,
-0.0140278982,
0.0270178933,
-0.0108201783,
-0.0294203442,
0.0052077738,
0.0189732611,
-0.0285222735,
0.0424767397,
-0.0947804675,
0.0295406133,
-0.0517582297,
-0.0266484078,
-0.0337095931,
0.012764209,
0.0232698079,
0.0498571061,
0.0012265374,
0.007558546,
-0.0711026415,
-0.0018161002,
0.019752536,
0.0130585097,
-0.0037892144,
-0.0214841031,
-0.0557632558,
-0.0088684224,
-0.0226390008,
0.0491810404,
0.0264114402,
0.0169189628,
0.0533986762,
0.0408133157,
-0.0165042821,
0.0109072095,
0.0198542234,
-0.0371643566,
-0.0182758402,
0.0269293804,
0.0542096049,
-0.0395242944,
-0.02868375,
-0.0027032185,
-0.0363141,
0.0277079474,
-0.072819151,
0.061983373,
-0.0114290798,
0.0295304116,
0.0223239511,
-0.036141403,
0.0121111581,
-0.0190548673,
-0.013734703,
0.0061713615,
-0.0139845703,
0.0011506943,
0.0118556898,
0.0322947688,
-0.0362401158,
0.0355487689,
-0.0364479944,
2.5311114e-34,
0.0156429131,
0.0316278525,
0.0233432893,
0.0299843047,
0.0383729525,
-0.0395089947,
-0.0750036389,
0.0370339379,
0.0353732817,
-0.0417000465,
-0.0242458414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15056v1 | Reasoning over Hierarchical Question Decomposition Tree for Explainable Question Answering | 2023-05-24T11:45:59 | 2023-05-24T11:45:59 | Jiajie Zhang, Shulin Cao, Tingjia Zhang, Xin Lv, Jiaxin Shi, Qi Tian, Juanzi Li, Lei Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Explainable question answering (XQA) aims to answer a given question and
provide an explanation why the answer is selected. Existing XQA methods focus
on reasoning on a single knowledge source, e.g., structured knowledge bases,
unstructured corpora, etc. However, integrating information from heterogeneous
knowledge sources is essential to answer complex questions. In this paper, we
propose to leverage question decomposing for heterogeneous knowledge
integration, by breaking down a complex question into simpler ones, and
selecting the appropriate knowledge source for each sub-question. To facilitate
reasoning, we propose a novel two-stage XQA framework, Reasoning over
Hierarchical Question Decomposition Tree (RoHT). First, we build the
Hierarchical Question Decomposition Tree (HQDT) to understand the semantics of
a complex question; then, we conduct probabilistic reasoning over HQDT from
root to leaves recursively, to aggregate heterogeneous knowledge at different
tree levels and search for a best solution considering the decomposing and
answering probabilities. The experiments on complex QA datasets KQA Pro and
Musique show that our framework outperforms SOTA methods significantly,
demonstrating the effectiveness of leveraging question decomposing for
knowledge integration and our RoHT framework. | [
-0.007355358,
0.0370732136,
0.0032645639,
0.0372387618,
-0.0075029363,
0.0299999192,
-0.03656023,
-0.0432556197,
-0.0230694134,
-0.0193853676,
-0.009372077,
0.0227884352,
0.0128843924,
0.0129913362,
-0.0016876662,
-0.0785656422,
0.0408899635,
-0.0226670597,
0.0016576162,
-0.0164164845,
-0.0011189046,
0.0339800753,
-0.0222369991,
0.0202170853,
0.0093475897,
-0.0696651787,
-0.0547658652,
0.0221317802,
0.0159788188,
0.0322089419,
-0.017306475,
0.0125365201,
0.0333874784,
0.0064582145,
0.0000018675,
-0.0059505184,
-0.0444623977,
0.0152964396,
-0.0463179611,
-0.0231259409,
-0.0621182658,
0.0260404777,
0.0159170683,
0.0349829756,
-0.0353007354,
-0.0051768278,
0.0200844761,
0.0386438444,
0.0665602237,
0.0209776442,
-0.0022987097,
-0.0587503947,
0.0336500071,
0.0262134969,
0.0185198281,
-0.0374085866,
-0.0093376795,
0.0310308021,
0.0173074529,
0.023880627,
0.0010445415,
-0.0063034385,
0.0468350463,
-0.020778032,
0.0194057636,
0.0036933608,
-0.0103589278,
0.0167456977,
-0.0003548774,
0.092964761,
0.0099859554,
-0.0046555116,
0.0030141866,
0.0138441678,
-0.0073179319,
0.0132509759,
-0.0626542345,
0.0098557556,
-0.0203970838,
-0.0026475457,
-0.0101897875,
0.0161895603,
0.022938367,
-0.0125230849,
-0.0370915085,
0.0924099311,
0.0226113107,
-0.0135571631,
0.0250793137,
-0.0107655525,
-0.017467292,
-0.0691884682,
-0.0288816188,
0.0844412893,
-0.0603870824,
0.0366489217,
-0.0014714678,
0.0277571268,
-0.0000648979,
0.0001938318,
-0.0381643735,
0.0261311121,
-0.0070731328,
0.0719634295,
-0.0017117413,
0.0092236931,
-0.0339229107,
-0.040121492,
-0.0381448865,
-0.0657183975,
-0.0841494128,
-0.0386366844,
-0.0001268299,
0.0440307036,
-0.0755884126,
-0.0249129888,
0.0000279688,
0.0281807315,
-0.0159694459,
-0.0047485754,
0.0346397869,
0.0303546283,
-0.0188170932,
-0.0021615706,
-0.0239646863,
0.0667229146,
-0.1082011089,
0.0359737352,
-0.0078172022,
-0.0003545676,
-0.0158949047,
0.018588569,
0.0238497108,
-0.0091857128,
-0.018807793,
0.0222337991,
-0.0231032521,
0.0172796268,
-0.0400665142,
-0.0732197389,
0.0097379629,
-0.0322097763,
0.0030221196,
-0.0589331239,
0.0250422824,
-0.0302012302,
-0.0275505614,
0.0127320001,
-0.0027385601,
0.0260638073,
-0.0322430395,
0.0795731544,
-0.0421723165,
0.0047956831,
0.0287872702,
0.0155385742,
-0.0154738724,
0.0637104958,
0.0224364456,
0.0144303469,
0.029274445,
-0.0016057896,
0.0036352163,
-0.0052958326,
0.0238363966,
-0.009465985,
0.0391235612,
0.0665506497,
-0.0908572972,
-0.0150857493,
0.0477539822,
0.0167783536,
-0.0146733215,
0.0275615212,
-0.0213407837,
0.0397295579,
-0.0254818536,
-0.0170897339,
0.001359175,
0.0179608837,
0.0069181384,
0.042734012,
-0.0188854877,
0.045538377,
-0.0111478064,
0.0007736122,
-0.0078258524,
0.0375699326,
-0.0524851903,
-0.0535381474,
0.0067400979,
-0.0035767525,
-0.0319858268,
0.0347092673,
0.0397306196,
0.0277808234,
0.0019081446,
0.0402520485,
0.0369889103,
-0.0185114592,
0.0048860237,
-0.0213843472,
0.06836541,
0.0382857881,
0.0233679302,
-0.0643186867,
0.0195296314,
0.0060015828,
0.0033843087,
0.0080559328,
-0.0337234661,
-0.0475209728,
0.0250608344,
-0.0219343994,
-0.048647508,
-0.0074562118,
0.0185484514,
0.0129965171,
0.0165253449,
-0.011174676,
0.0028957783,
-0.0553622469,
0.0439417213,
0.0133807454,
-0.0069426317,
-0.006508512,
0.016858032,
0.0083756587,
0.0147523405,
0.0681369528,
0.0088933529,
0.0298690833,
0.0116096046,
-0.0189956725,
-0.0603587925,
0.027428316,
-0.0011253111,
-0.1008713767,
0.0132849235,
-0.0461002812,
-0.0260161478,
0.0212445818,
-0.0572903529,
-0.0675221458,
0.0002277426,
-0.0454281829,
0.0214552525,
-0.0486293435,
-0.0440936945,
0.0175302625,
-0.0363521092,
-0.0399687886,
0.1063929349,
0.0165836252,
-0.0389879942,
-0.0072086952,
-0.0395808034,
0.0466029644,
-0.0146742603,
0.0348143987,
0.0177749526,
-0.0372574702,
-0.0200884622,
0.0106482273,
-0.0245645326,
-0.0662718937,
0.0337398462,
-0.0349166356,
0.0164401084,
-0.0062283841,
0.0341621712,
0.0442329384,
0.0282222219,
0.0252582766,
-0.0210522786,
-0.0746398494,
0.0113605661,
0.0050417744,
0.0257216245,
0.0414575152,
-0.0097960187,
0.0019524143,
-0.0322413966,
-0.0128768915,
-0.026512729,
0.0692234784,
-0.0199504811,
0.0120289158,
-0.0119696492,
-0.0367545784,
-0.065016441,
0.0026532309,
0.0047441982,
-0.0130829429,
-0.0028677487,
-0.0032680114,
0.0054260809,
0.0674236491,
-0.0553852618,
-0.0280809365,
0.0297680199,
0.0010179926,
-0.0287702847,
0.0246202759,
-0.002853031,
0.0077965246,
0.0060690506,
-0.0583261289,
0.0207606852,
0.045392029,
0.0053603654,
-0.0156047503,
-0.0311960168,
0.0295479298,
-0.0097357724,
0.0185899138,
-0.0541448593,
-0.0434459783,
0.0215334035,
0.0688516051,
-0.0228310954,
-0.0299560539,
0.0859873295,
-0.006086038,
-0.0069395653,
-0.0498358011,
-0.0009958212,
-0.0640248284,
0.0663798973,
-0.0418759584,
0.0160063673,
0.0068334597,
-0.0289735254,
-0.0300705805,
-0.020286344,
0.0184651334,
-0.0086141257,
0.0293724295,
-0.0329879671,
0.0158988591,
0.0025716249,
-0.0223958679,
-0.0177695174,
-0.0122450246,
-0.0180646814,
0.0215380862,
0.0116322879,
-0.0178542063,
-0.0001682281,
-0.0058003226,
0.0551161431,
-0.0211791694,
-0.0232576355,
-0.0057558725,
-0.0114315376,
0.1090914086,
0.0699286163,
0.0418940149,
0.0510427393,
0.0162270796,
0.0679485127,
0.0464643463,
0.0537069552,
-0.0307623651,
0.007847867,
-0.005198414,
-0.0034559108,
-0.0255089998,
-0.0017454509,
-0.0215383675,
0.0614275299,
-0.0485488512,
0.0232380927,
0.0838479102,
0.053457059,
-0.0145126311,
-0.0104066795,
-0.0347272493,
0.0446995571,
0.0105678467,
0.0486366935,
-0.0834769979,
-0.0433687419,
0.002995111,
0.0500979498,
0.0395368896,
-0.021375455,
0.0204162132,
-0.0857621208,
0.028199546,
-0.0104725352,
-0.056939669,
-0.0572980978,
-0.0338081792,
0.0073634763,
-0.0048218179,
-0.0197702777,
0.0084203118,
-0.0087283188,
0.0315968171,
0.0239287317,
-0.0612039119,
-0.0076870802,
0.037537504,
-0.0118928924,
-0.0035250669,
0.0539455488,
0.0316540562,
0.028753506,
0.0017077453,
-0.0563649237,
-0.0617712513,
-0.0097507928,
-0.0083746156,
0.0131310401,
0.0276326276,
-0.0056241835,
-0.0391462334,
0.0604827777,
-0.0661190972,
0.009687487,
0.0313327238,
0.1163706481,
0.0065260208,
-0.0213653781,
-0.0167928822,
-0.0275545139,
-0.0070803994,
0.09959995,
0.0360743999,
0.0327710584,
-0.0417942144,
-0.0235950854,
-0.0269903075,
-0.0169361494,
0.0243923236,
0.0477680042,
0.0092209103,
-0.005173217,
-0.0831672028,
-0.0371537209,
0.0332176574,
0.0322990268,
-0.0447297394,
0.0180170611,
0.0117839165,
0.0166395716,
-0.0431326516,
0.0148925129,
-0.0156431794,
0.0254445598,
0.0314698741,
-0.0083513148,
0.0206527431,
-0.0070476243,
-0.0266665611,
-0.0392329618,
-0.0007059947,
-0.0300900955,
-0.0447486602,
-0.0005653222,
0.0232294109,
0.034238033,
-0.0295881126,
-0.0274320021,
-0.0009405214,
-0.0391724296,
-0.0551261976,
-0.0097895507,
0.045425687,
0.0227910616,
0.0056000366,
0.0568767413,
-0.0664079338,
-0.0012828676,
-0.0320779495,
0.044350639,
-0.0436456688,
-0.0017724579,
0.0264726467,
-0.0013984625,
-0.0488544405,
0.0137820486,
-0.0063996254,
0.0002747193,
0.0185140576,
-0.0342685506,
-0.0244687814,
-0.0479235873,
0.0314805806,
0.0013907258,
-0.0233425926,
0.0074075954,
0.0006535871,
-0.0089090606,
-0.0091308234,
-0.0148290917,
-0.0058950707,
0.0667345896,
-0.0196405854,
-0.0195646714,
-0.0184542388,
0.0108123394,
-0.0319154561,
-0.0072040316,
0.0359464735,
0.0056438744,
0.0326902196,
0.0130771874,
-0.0197231136,
-0.0232617185,
-0.0165376756,
-0.0791050494,
-0.0854822174,
0.0563080683,
-0.0404970795,
0.0439754128,
0.022597203,
0.0061317519,
0.038580887,
-0.0300064404,
0.0516150929,
0.0143114328,
0.0565532632,
0.0011900457,
0.0498672016,
0.0351611562,
-0.0377739891,
-0.0153527865,
0.1038221866,
0.0056647123,
0.0004879366,
-0.0368937962,
-0.0043836222,
-0.0159508027,
-0.0327965058,
0.0101424968,
0.0582806766,
-0.0314187668,
-0.0090260506,
-0.037905816,
-0.0584910214,
-0.0300000198,
-0.008940137,
-0.0360505059,
0.0148823541,
0.040250171,
0.0316811055,
0.0462623425,
-0.052603215,
-0.005609639,
0.0145351738,
-0.0746896267,
-0.00482166,
0.0235254057,
-6.021351161e-33,
-0.0238672867,
-0.0281864703,
0.0084125157,
-0.0566354804,
-0.0229134411,
0.017775109,
-0.059786316,
-0.0164122153,
-0.0393767767,
0.0278305281,
0.0083652837,
0.0400043949,
-0.0077960868,
0.0458989739,
-0.0046977908,
-0.0319362655,
-0.0069178822,
0.027693389,
-0.022695791,
0.0234202351,
0.0400660262,
-0.0035695038,
0.0211498197,
0.0000688859,
0.0190998539,
0.0002978219,
-0.0014321163,
0.0846917033,
-0.0054168375,
0.0391872413,
-0.0021467351,
0.0222426448,
0.0233984757,
-0.0362355486,
0.0212028474,
0.0860231072,
-0.0935543999,
-0.026466703,
0.045495268,
-0.0038304592,
-0.0921152979,
-0.0106697977,
0.019111596,
0.0044727568,
0.0905360654,
-0.0687611997,
0.0312447641,
-0.0290508457,
-0.0158598796,
-0.0597332865,
-0.0089439536,
0.0329786763,
-0.0615255572,
-0.0152798947,
-0.0192444548,
0.0481406748,
0.0252316557,
0.0422643386,
-0.0220561922,
-0.0010642194,
-0.0063515552,
-0.0045248889,
0.0546398908,
-0.0224098489,
0.0033441852,
0.0308908802,
0.0308499597,
-0.0357324332,
-0.0567776114,
0.0193288922,
-0.0590438135,
0.0425354429,
0.0511321872,
0.0152817713,
0.0198391192,
0.0587067381,
-0.108348757,
0.0574882589,
0.0064920844,
0.029165823,
-0.0344194993,
0.0134252496,
-0.0186917428,
-0.0149326306,
-0.0422883593,
0.0358204842,
-0.0271840822,
-0.0186189115,
-0.0090518212,
-0.0459280089,
-0.0286913272,
-0.0029610305,
-0.002186917,
-0.0440902598,
0.0210948996,
0.0531126857,
0.0037500197,
0.010083911,
0.0206214432,
0.0644175485,
-0.0122689959,
0.0460961238,
0.0145372553,
-0.0586961694,
-0.017668236,
0.0298028179,
0.0126673616,
-0.0071950215,
-0.029481886,
0.0111479359,
-0.0261263829,
-0.012107051,
-0.0519196652,
0.0344143957,
0.0430036187,
0.0731294081,
0.0151567366,
0.0069080829,
0.016439287,
0.0633528531,
-0.0158116966,
0.0135563985,
-0.0224907398,
-0.0024172387,
0.0262792222,
-0.0234506708,
-0.0304168426,
-0.0116094258,
-0.030681191,
-0.0578388758,
-0.0168843977,
0.039244771,
2.533e-7,
0.0485100821,
-0.0098470878,
0.0024351918,
0.0333107747,
0.041274976,
0.0126993461,
0.0068327254,
-0.0209411085,
-0.009491818,
-0.0767576322,
0.0035619761,
0.0141257262,
0.0604213439,
0.0633464381,
-0.0773198754,
-0.0383965932,
-0.0319168158,
-0.052640155,
-0.064676255,
-0.0062885075,
0.0754378065,
0.0614985377,
0.0042573055,
-0.0150381774,
0.0079098418,
0.0235353205,
0.0345185287,
0.0351558924,
0.0122290663,
0.0100899702,
0.008061734,
-0.0386237614,
0.0210470427,
0.0336225927,
-0.0246455278,
0.0268547237,
0.0080299992,
0.0598971844,
-0.0169048011,
-0.0494712815,
-0.0257039182,
-0.051959347,
0.0639578253,
-0.0415258706,
0.1018420085,
-0.0017008897,
-0.0319940373,
0.0371242277,
-0.0506072678,
-0.0165490024,
-0.0011621274,
0.005126202,
-0.0021786087,
0.0170465056,
0.0002504379,
-0.033324793,
0.0241182204,
-0.0733087882,
-0.0115437107,
0.0174882114,
-0.0178293157,
-0.003667925,
0.0004059419,
-0.0115830014,
0.0340395719,
-0.0325760134,
-0.0050130207,
2.12823367e-34,
0.0163906068,
0.0094342101,
-0.00405529,
0.031133689,
0.0323590897,
-0.018643735,
0.0032366957,
-0.0323519781,
0.0535617024,
-0.0734580532,
0.0174280349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15054v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15054v2 | A Mechanistic Interpretation of Arithmetic Reasoning in Language Models using Causal Mediation Analysis | 2023-05-24T11:43:47 | 2023-10-20T12:13:27 | Alessandro Stolfo, Yonatan Belinkov, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Mathematical reasoning in large language models (LMs) has garnered
significant attention in recent work, but there is a limited understanding of
how these models process and store information related to arithmetic tasks
within their architecture. In order to improve our understanding of this aspect
of language models, we present a mechanistic interpretation of
Transformer-based LMs on arithmetic questions using a causal mediation analysis
framework. By intervening on the activations of specific model components and
measuring the resulting changes in predicted probabilities, we identify the
subset of parameters responsible for specific predictions. This provides
insights into how information related to arithmetic is processed by LMs. Our
experimental results indicate that LMs process the input by transmitting the
information relevant to the query from mid-sequence early layers to the final
token using the attention mechanism. Then, this information is processed by a
set of MLP modules, which generate result-related information that is
incorporated into the residual stream. To assess the specificity of the
observed activation dynamics, we compare the effects of different model
components on arithmetic queries with other tasks, including number retrieval
from prompts and factual knowledge questions. | [
-0.0179542638,
0.0616129525,
-0.0287063736,
0.0274374615,
-0.0263821948,
0.0173534043,
0.0011325665,
-0.0109977676,
-0.0555000678,
-0.0324438848,
-0.0245485008,
-0.034225516,
0.0084299007,
-0.0037557411,
0.052803725,
0.0053658374,
0.0384992361,
-0.0559283346,
0.0148328179,
-0.0005891847,
-0.0510084741,
-0.0231263284,
-0.0257441234,
0.0254100822,
-0.005432853,
-0.0251168814,
0.0052784136,
-0.0480707623,
-0.0180876311,
-0.0098702516,
-0.0366597213,
0.0272726323,
0.0166101456,
0.0261134636,
0.0000019736,
-0.0514286831,
-0.0042136628,
0.0063092201,
-0.0608504526,
0.0059017297,
-0.009387088,
0.0011365777,
0.0181153137,
0.0188227408,
-0.0182006825,
0.0219664685,
0.0556971245,
0.0331051275,
0.0078948922,
0.0586485974,
-0.0004312306,
-0.0380319953,
0.0270862859,
-0.0100047402,
0.0635950193,
-0.0239540786,
0.0281120148,
0.0082105659,
-0.0116770286,
0.0162895657,
-0.0308185164,
0.00319472,
0.0642472059,
0.0123971589,
-0.0090579977,
0.0220170226,
0.0325409323,
-0.0230372474,
0.0155911157,
0.031511616,
0.0329992026,
-0.0408455096,
-0.0043750713,
-0.0093315467,
0.033958409,
0.02484571,
-0.0836711749,
0.0434922352,
0.0368866064,
0.0157652982,
0.0324091464,
0.0088589378,
0.0200514849,
-0.0063700378,
-0.0515299514,
0.0780835226,
0.0092586717,
-0.0141666122,
-0.0448101461,
-0.0022461761,
-0.0211692527,
-0.0339281596,
-0.007541371,
0.0635408387,
-0.0009362606,
0.0249676127,
0.0190262087,
-0.0387358107,
-0.0416598991,
-0.0646713153,
0.0246401206,
0.1076019332,
-0.0017771181,
0.0091725858,
-0.0443480723,
0.0715688169,
-0.0449699387,
0.0450009741,
-0.0172973797,
0.0467474274,
0.0237094928,
-0.0692673847,
0.0145486575,
0.0404425636,
-0.0051080096,
0.0126347765,
-0.0326863192,
0.0391743295,
-0.0026892642,
-0.0323386788,
-0.0028182012,
-0.0093932627,
0.0248875581,
-0.0051360675,
-0.082209453,
0.0722294524,
-0.0263436157,
0.0125844739,
-0.0071617556,
-0.0611313917,
-0.0368013941,
-0.009130395,
-0.0132987024,
-0.0284031183,
0.0052125808,
0.0786421224,
-0.0151852835,
-0.017177308,
-0.03550696,
-0.0399410576,
0.0389025025,
-0.0293927938,
0.0540017113,
-0.0478330888,
0.0004069267,
0.0706753954,
-0.0161559489,
-0.0112170763,
0.0300266221,
0.0157713518,
-0.0163537208,
0.045915857,
0.0833578333,
0.0219582263,
-0.002078075,
-0.0216458254,
-0.0124765234,
0.0605998486,
0.0452308506,
-0.0153879849,
0.0000466852,
-0.0178963691,
0.0287068207,
0.0425938591,
0.0161484201,
-0.0295438375,
-0.0511327796,
-0.00528818,
-0.015271836,
0.0156931896,
0.0428545885,
-0.0020125308,
-0.0360877365,
-0.0197431874,
0.0592120625,
0.0231270064,
0.0127344755,
0.0354841836,
0.0166915432,
-0.0511536337,
0.0118518313,
0.0313327089,
-0.1146733686,
0.0682785138,
-0.0232512467,
0.0127547523,
0.0103798481,
-0.0034233292,
-0.0197358951,
-0.0671281219,
-0.0131854685,
0.0297879893,
-0.002827914,
0.0168852713,
0.0669009238,
-0.0049050627,
-0.013817721,
0.0911411569,
-0.0164315049,
-0.0301257446,
0.0099691069,
-0.0705402792,
0.0074389437,
0.0030759226,
0.0521037951,
-0.0464201383,
-0.0091166692,
0.0048524505,
-0.0260400791,
-0.0012914093,
0.0199542623,
0.0245210305,
-0.022444319,
-0.0120632797,
0.005891887,
-0.0354918726,
0.0263009612,
-0.0178772788,
-0.0032538685,
-0.0470109135,
0.0087587861,
-0.037434049,
0.0138126519,
0.0285430308,
-0.0359913521,
-0.0483657569,
-0.0336492397,
0.0131752957,
-0.0178120323,
-0.0249729883,
0.0221317336,
0.0724333152,
0.0336137153,
-0.0051965644,
-0.0140082538,
0.0227236301,
-0.0668624416,
0.0084536299,
0.048703637,
0.0105909556,
0.0079492638,
0.0289523508,
0.0185972024,
-0.0355139934,
0.0786827728,
-0.0722968206,
0.0548484772,
0.0111583965,
0.0329549462,
0.0014367,
-0.0083000772,
-0.0254794247,
0.0710788891,
-0.0153334588,
0.0289056748,
0.0104820933,
-0.0091117658,
-0.0008682302,
0.0298508126,
0.0278812777,
-0.029954683,
-0.0219568666,
-0.0103779454,
0.0098591642,
-0.0628292114,
-0.0320520736,
-0.0216290429,
-0.0007449435,
-0.0300468095,
-0.008322902,
0.0565688461,
0.0380677916,
0.0007708344,
0.0084488541,
-0.0067690564,
-0.0039053599,
0.0084649036,
0.0132369688,
0.034700904,
0.0384174809,
-0.0409099609,
0.0182128847,
-0.0239404961,
-0.0291249026,
-0.0656615049,
0.0708391368,
0.0271370616,
0.0118954787,
-0.0420481712,
-0.0024957876,
-0.0128209079,
0.0167159457,
-0.0272167567,
0.0030864617,
0.0298588183,
-0.027521994,
0.0635124594,
0.0689242259,
-0.0353057459,
0.065018028,
0.0410889871,
-0.0159382913,
-0.0566191114,
0.0034590187,
-0.0547323003,
0.0040033357,
-0.0266925301,
-0.0215628631,
-0.0533750243,
0.115113318,
-0.022537848,
-0.022852771,
-0.0260030814,
0.0102983704,
-0.002016037,
-0.0186703969,
0.0111310091,
-0.0073713167,
-0.0402287357,
0.0668663234,
-0.0053734872,
-0.0329280719,
0.053637296,
0.0082877623,
-0.0344908498,
-0.0374297686,
0.0847699344,
-0.0291472226,
0.0689138696,
0.0321868137,
-0.0283495281,
0.0228868667,
-0.0312278401,
-0.0572459251,
0.0065567913,
0.0083460594,
-0.0269155707,
0.0691919029,
-0.0334145464,
-0.0031245472,
0.006593788,
-0.0114114406,
-0.0564491525,
0.0314093083,
-0.0219384972,
0.038905479,
-0.0092400238,
-0.0355648845,
-0.0580329672,
-0.0076951948,
0.0923627988,
0.0244626254,
-0.0488296598,
-0.0257467479,
-0.0396467894,
0.0047915513,
0.027069753,
0.0372072533,
0.0829826146,
-0.0587995648,
0.0135708302,
0.0144018764,
0.032839518,
-0.0039720242,
-0.0120627321,
-0.0039489106,
0.0455643721,
-0.0278560314,
0.0000190513,
0.0524074994,
0.0283970293,
-0.0845039561,
-0.0242939536,
0.0811545402,
0.0400585011,
-0.0251555257,
0.0150171444,
-0.07336054,
-0.0014057391,
0.056352783,
0.0147711765,
-0.0527355038,
-0.0035836585,
0.025546113,
-0.0333958082,
-0.0135465981,
-0.0384922698,
0.0232417248,
-0.0863198936,
0.0079623824,
-0.0213694721,
-0.0214660205,
-0.0194506403,
-0.0313459262,
0.0214173272,
0.0142023303,
-0.005777074,
0.0290608443,
-0.0073954291,
0.0229402538,
-0.002440928,
0.0098645268,
-0.0137654543,
-0.0031878981,
0.0189694669,
0.0068422919,
0.0509945825,
-0.023091089,
-0.0620366186,
-0.0707411095,
0.0566553064,
0.0266994685,
0.0125630777,
0.0051941574,
0.0108368006,
0.0356219858,
-0.0129030738,
-0.0334054753,
0.0115263658,
-0.0421052948,
-0.0281277727,
-0.0462565869,
0.0935725942,
-0.0469311513,
-0.0002039026,
0.0214095786,
0.0156053007,
-0.0607405156,
0.0357347913,
0.0543002114,
-0.0147101153,
-0.019954592,
-0.0432538912,
-0.0176582951,
-0.0148363672,
-0.0390241407,
-0.0340688266,
0.0872629955,
-0.0328598432,
-0.023810925,
-0.011634252,
0.0309223738,
-0.0008099211,
0.0034635232,
-0.0300379954,
0.0636026934,
-0.0361457244,
-0.0226270985,
0.0425873436,
-0.0298248604,
0.0394362956,
-0.0282316506,
0.0267733335,
0.0035541882,
-0.0656710342,
-0.0203770753,
-0.0223300252,
-0.0862582251,
-0.0589308552,
-0.0011421966,
0.0495815314,
0.0233111549,
-0.0291239135,
-0.0062579177,
-0.0498142727,
-0.0251780599,
-0.0115898587,
-0.0724985749,
0.0301881935,
0.0047962237,
0.0046595577,
0.0071946685,
0.0129860342,
-0.0007559116,
-0.0089080185,
0.0546533763,
0.045301836,
-0.0204295311,
-0.0091768261,
0.0550900549,
0.0115633244,
0.0423764698,
0.0329274312,
0.0128531959,
-0.006232678,
0.0288788304,
-0.0233479608,
0.0059387917,
-0.0204209331,
-0.0152346408,
0.0161543321,
0.0517480969,
-0.0013387033,
-0.0573758818,
0.0274964813,
0.0330002159,
0.0255877152,
0.0361633375,
-0.0207702108,
0.0277143866,
0.0121934079,
-0.0012562311,
0.0267359931,
0.0150664225,
-0.010649397,
0.0524458885,
0.0034033915,
0.0709458292,
0.0128796343,
0.0303769261,
-0.0692848042,
-0.0317202732,
-0.0583849922,
-0.070079349,
0.0526729934,
-0.0183627084,
0.0208996404,
-0.0180562958,
0.0143321017,
-0.0415331088,
0.0117876679,
-0.0066602598,
-0.0127132768,
0.0053298995,
0.0107580507,
0.0215639584,
0.0314062387,
0.0174562596,
-0.0636549219,
0.0355307162,
-0.0370164923,
0.0293259155,
-0.013160876,
-0.0186661575,
0.0179104023,
-0.0512985624,
-0.0038941295,
0.0195679758,
-0.0255147535,
0.0076460973,
-0.0751674995,
-0.0527093075,
-0.0279273819,
-0.0160652176,
-0.0127355931,
-0.0680923536,
0.032771349,
0.0642708242,
-0.022832986,
-0.0174260531,
-0.0218145996,
0.0418362916,
-0.0117058214,
0.0042021493,
-0.0465127267,
-5.963778386e-33,
-0.0160888862,
-0.0481584258,
0.0430473089,
0.0364761539,
-0.0163902491,
-0.0253894888,
-0.039691858,
0.039501369,
-0.0195704792,
0.0023834233,
-0.027697295,
0.0169269219,
0.0055042142,
0.0161901228,
0.0313699134,
-0.0403335504,
-0.0041632014,
-0.0199187081,
-0.0465462767,
-0.0281560309,
0.0097390637,
0.0087217204,
0.0806078985,
-0.0364537612,
0.0455046594,
0.019443864,
0.0494118854,
0.0136962244,
-0.0644750595,
0.0557049103,
-0.0073801335,
0.034961395,
0.04407271,
-0.0948986486,
-0.0329912975,
0.0250525568,
-0.0419666916,
-0.0400143601,
0.0477464162,
0.0396344438,
-0.0182605591,
-0.020388253,
0.0651070327,
-0.0103379497,
-0.0143298926,
-0.0382857807,
0.026807582,
-0.0226625521,
0.0034822198,
0.003691795,
-0.0703523979,
0.0007295778,
-0.00133667,
0.0026521175,
0.0354403704,
0.0387565047,
-0.0441829488,
0.0296467487,
-0.0363346785,
0.0191784427,
0.0163496211,
0.0560207255,
0.0245938841,
0.0617275238,
0.0194344297,
0.0016469579,
0.0333659686,
-0.0058511985,
-0.0576534867,
-0.0146745797,
0.0375698321,
0.0125533007,
0.0814006552,
-0.0254515782,
0.0560243092,
0.0306972619,
-0.0290400479,
-0.0325967297,
0.0196658652,
0.0630373135,
0.0262283981,
-0.0019188874,
0.0111291986,
-0.0041414802,
-0.0685128719,
0.0288272724,
-0.0681675673,
-0.0144506721,
-0.0066516609,
-0.0196283292,
0.0408659801,
0.0028396791,
0.021590082,
-0.0232217088,
0.0037492786,
0.0003779423,
0.0302809458,
0.0346672609,
0.0003028611,
0.0118969064,
-0.0536659062,
0.0060497518,
-0.0241448749,
-0.0246807076,
0.0109819733,
0.0391993895,
-0.0199392065,
0.0238406584,
-0.0273681078,
-0.0316151828,
-0.0666045025,
-0.0493749939,
0.033912316,
0.0372378081,
0.0360018946,
0.022730343,
-0.0092696613,
-0.0332693234,
-0.0168143082,
0.0175624266,
-0.0339158587,
0.0103207128,
-0.0251547862,
0.0391644053,
-0.0322195292,
-0.0452369638,
-0.0775923282,
0.0657469928,
0.0133837154,
-0.052518025,
-0.0328502022,
0.0010126866,
2.824e-7,
0.0893727541,
0.0414031781,
0.0025534672,
0.0662410408,
0.0239537917,
0.0161047,
0.014691866,
-0.0187408756,
0.0700384229,
-0.0432334319,
0.0100123538,
0.0039854385,
0.0109292967,
-0.0032350088,
-0.0295301806,
-0.0136799831,
-0.0156541411,
0.0199795235,
0.016243875,
0.0196446534,
0.0128773972,
0.0505215786,
0.0137604671,
0.0205146484,
0.0025579662,
-0.0039854585,
0.0315694101,
-0.0139055699,
0.011810028,
-0.005643941,
0.0052285064,
-0.0368411094,
0.0036477628,
0.0358655676,
0.0003590509,
0.0275132004,
-0.0188722499,
0.0367226228,
0.0091805859,
-0.012893728,
-0.0236900095,
-0.0292622112,
-0.0190579575,
-0.0682617351,
0.038513612,
-0.0716229603,
-0.0368136205,
0.0142177474,
0.0088929255,
0.0056662485,
-0.0119088199,
0.0203916319,
-0.0023412229,
-0.0152450278,
0.0197938904,
0.0039633429,
-0.0029052983,
-0.0560523123,
-0.0465362407,
-0.0145557253,
-0.0541371889,
-0.0570319407,
-0.086694099,
-0.0436119251,
0.0008143499,
-0.0114700822,
-0.0612461045,
2.923044175e-34,
0.0168605689,
-0.0065923496,
0.0273948628,
0.0549030788,
0.0296412595,
-0.0313403234,
-0.0226759035,
0.066188626,
0.0469332635,
-0.1029424071,
-0.0170206279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15053v1 | Decomposing Complex Queries for Tip-of-the-tongue Retrieval | 2023-05-24T11:43:40 | 2023-05-24T11:43:40 | Kevin Lin, Kyle Lo, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | When re-finding items, users who forget or are uncertain about identifying
details often rely on creative strategies for expressing their information
needs -- complex queries that describe content elements (e.g., book characters
or events), information beyond the document text (e.g., descriptions of book
covers), or personal context (e.g., when they read a book). This retrieval
setting, called tip of the tongue (TOT), is especially challenging for models
heavily reliant on lexical and semantic overlap between query and document
text. In this work, we introduce a simple yet effective framework for handling
such complex queries by decomposing the query into individual clues, routing
those as sub-queries to specialized retrievers, and ensembling the results.
This approach allows us to take advantage of off-the-shelf retrievers (e.g.,
CLIP for retrieving images of book covers) or incorporate retriever-specific
logic (e.g., date constraints). We show that our framework incorportating query
decompositions into retrievers can improve gold book recall up to 7% relative
again for Recall@5 on a new collection of 14,441 real-world query-book pairs
from an online community for resolving TOT inquiries. | [
0.0804459006,
0.0282597225,
-0.0158170424,
0.0265761334,
-0.0426168106,
0.0074875345,
-0.020281788,
0.0479047373,
0.041339498,
-0.0460412875,
-0.0195419267,
0.0150283063,
-0.013868765,
0.0131034683,
-0.0023135392,
-0.0791475698,
0.0168246925,
-0.01766867,
0.021375712,
0.0087196482,
0.018391341,
0.0151896179,
0.0068442943,
0.0093746912,
0.0077665467,
-0.0080341613,
-0.0146100139,
0.0218248311,
-0.0213771109,
-0.0177674405,
0.0366385095,
0.0298733693,
-0.0097463354,
0.016206691,
0.0000019098,
-0.0112501709,
-0.057794176,
0.0077978009,
-0.0140136704,
-0.0189694706,
0.0593641251,
0.0448667631,
0.0474206768,
-0.0230685472,
-0.0302892085,
0.0416349992,
0.0145992031,
0.0646673143,
-0.0026559886,
0.0387025289,
0.0007456307,
0.0058366838,
-0.0022015085,
0.0224117991,
0.1180710867,
-0.0456074663,
0.0091008851,
-0.066480726,
0.0579210781,
0.0301736426,
0.0220093187,
0.0598346405,
-0.0282388609,
0.0186256655,
-0.0123574827,
0.036498107,
-0.0350524038,
0.022873316,
-0.0007887745,
0.0316375345,
0.0152654909,
-0.0105064297,
0.024397241,
0.0280112568,
0.0051555047,
0.0645048022,
-0.0922708213,
-0.0330679603,
-0.0492882766,
-0.0384363234,
-0.0372928567,
0.0078045204,
0.01227949,
0.0196930692,
-0.0035790962,
0.0412659943,
-0.0036435013,
-0.0173270572,
0.0026144988,
-0.0352756269,
0.0010874803,
-0.0028850401,
0.0411298983,
0.0357932895,
0.0080734612,
0.0151843214,
-0.0089274999,
-0.0117598865,
0.0514892824,
-0.0159872267,
0.0760141015,
0.0232738499,
-0.0515059158,
0.0718830898,
-0.0195722934,
0.0054880623,
-0.0073949387,
0.0262952987,
-0.036066886,
0.0068812817,
-0.0452702343,
-0.0240996256,
-0.0381235369,
0.0730792657,
-0.0439527668,
-0.03257557,
0.025955908,
0.0117500369,
0.0229764432,
0.0108139049,
-0.0190810207,
0.0612964481,
-0.013698847,
-0.0091515072,
-0.0501808934,
0.0026072052,
-0.0279902052,
-0.0204622969,
0.0445354842,
-0.0130682727,
-0.0086475806,
-0.0318144113,
0.0363704637,
-0.043543499,
0.0208759196,
0.0125351073,
-0.0335160084,
-0.0482915416,
-0.0683474615,
-0.0825582296,
-0.0085683763,
0.0055883876,
0.006104256,
-0.048003532,
0.0509611927,
0.0163526833,
-0.001652672,
-0.0056163105,
0.008379803,
0.0768182278,
-0.0565804914,
0.0726620778,
0.0312181003,
-0.013860113,
0.0381763354,
0.0357213356,
-0.0159482434,
0.0430595614,
-0.0042825644,
0.0636223257,
0.0552799366,
0.0325767398,
0.0131425662,
-0.0227065571,
0.0049277931,
-0.0156490281,
-0.0265259277,
0.0311318897,
0.0090605188,
-0.0022659681,
-0.0267486554,
0.064509578,
-0.0316133425,
-0.0199038144,
0.0486853905,
0.0998911187,
-0.0264632069,
0.0070437295,
-0.0289796535,
0.0134516284,
0.0033592654,
0.0153311696,
-0.0094154282,
0.042428188,
-0.067418322,
-0.0141470488,
-0.0068816659,
0.0150631107,
-0.0325412564,
-0.0199523531,
0.0084840944,
0.0302089341,
-0.0014454104,
0.0504904352,
0.0291437432,
-0.0180816147,
-0.0316952281,
0.0195453577,
-0.0075421133,
-0.0656055585,
0.0308666695,
-0.0340323336,
-0.015189345,
0.070097968,
0.0694261864,
-0.0509026758,
-0.0042190216,
0.0150727546,
0.0094705774,
-0.0275231134,
-0.0086558321,
-0.0054354249,
-0.0030756274,
-0.0391759016,
-0.0153090218,
0.012920198,
-0.0030997836,
-0.0050933906,
0.0297366828,
-0.0060770125,
0.0206008796,
-0.0452187657,
0.0016386348,
0.0031735853,
-0.0012328844,
-0.0259945616,
-0.0110652605,
0.0312227979,
-0.030934168,
0.0064813555,
0.0457916036,
0.0168098863,
0.0493787862,
-0.0216764975,
-0.0126418676,
-0.0555700697,
0.0165783763,
0.009980076,
0.0121936072,
-0.0273931492,
0.0257582646,
-0.0115950797,
0.0118539389,
-0.0261368155,
-0.0356164165,
-0.0087274257,
0.0867288187,
-0.030590659,
-0.0010010893,
-0.0060877432,
-0.0344228297,
-0.0637073368,
0.081514962,
-0.011523569,
0.0118131638,
-0.0501349308,
-0.0429997034,
-0.0146372188,
-0.075515531,
-0.0243682321,
-0.0185094383,
0.0137733547,
0.0326565988,
0.0371571854,
-0.0219715647,
-0.0553525053,
-0.0523521118,
-0.1118675098,
-0.0200098734,
0.0001662713,
-0.0007228731,
-0.0227837935,
0.0171032008,
-0.0129829263,
-0.0245623663,
-0.0478005782,
-0.0666541755,
-0.0471318066,
0.0428198576,
0.0034672394,
0.0490696542,
0.0245557074,
-0.0303904396,
-0.0187658332,
-0.0084355623,
0.039587751,
0.013149363,
-0.0513347276,
0.0087047853,
0.0298481286,
-0.0060823741,
0.0113314269,
-0.0104270503,
0.031058507,
0.0018296512,
-0.0467058606,
0.0126231955,
0.0973038822,
0.0204129517,
-0.0016825143,
-0.005399297,
-0.0558000095,
-0.0744064525,
0.0233988073,
-0.031752333,
-0.0111798877,
0.026982611,
-0.0218429286,
0.0505625531,
-0.0501539297,
-0.0053819441,
0.0201119985,
-0.0261141174,
0.0171022695,
0.0113096517,
-0.0056887064,
-0.1033526361,
-0.016803503,
-0.0046674479,
0.0608262718,
-0.0314790532,
0.0078239134,
0.0545837805,
0.0085839517,
0.0096553424,
-0.0032370903,
0.0229587238,
-0.0369796082,
0.0992495343,
-0.0153527716,
0.0354969352,
-0.007941098,
-0.0524951443,
-0.0365523919,
0.0188305005,
0.046372544,
-0.0773718208,
0.046141699,
0.0031720514,
-0.0046230187,
0.0170177948,
-0.049223084,
-0.03383011,
-0.0033689949,
-0.0119728046,
-0.0380712897,
0.0187181551,
-0.0284927934,
-0.0546472743,
0.0237522777,
0.0407901108,
-0.0051359143,
-0.0219841655,
-0.0400611758,
0.0157057922,
0.0219682194,
0.0646618083,
-0.0278002787,
-0.0149291875,
-0.0349268466,
-0.0415346287,
0.0586825162,
0.0579855852,
-0.0610566922,
0.0388664529,
-0.0021597773,
0.0625272244,
-0.055757381,
0.0052501247,
0.0106801754,
-0.0467278324,
-0.0644197688,
-0.0175490547,
0.0568137392,
0.0528791025,
-0.0922688097,
-0.0601597391,
0.0045464947,
0.0043790285,
0.0053537595,
0.0477245525,
-0.0516358428,
-0.0063805659,
0.0283825416,
0.0462895967,
-0.019061517,
-0.0276472401,
-0.0097309267,
-0.1090751961,
0.0252813753,
-0.0092537589,
-0.0041352073,
-0.0188646205,
-0.0366165899,
0.0012570695,
0.0141889872,
0.0187545083,
0.0536279418,
-0.0687397346,
0.0081999665,
0.0039728167,
0.0177301951,
-0.0052414355,
0.0188989937,
-0.0000795954,
-0.0438983813,
0.0448770821,
0.0217614584,
0.0450535007,
-0.0215712786,
-0.0127655417,
-0.0144190844,
0.0066025113,
-0.0137717603,
0.0781051293,
-0.0296459664,
0.0299566779,
-0.0264343228,
0.0244335383,
-0.0183325429,
0.0026862277,
-0.0054006912,
0.0353597105,
-0.0137998788,
0.0372946821,
-0.0461864434,
-0.0414481796,
-0.0278954711,
0.0708203837,
0.0026763203,
0.0016523299,
-0.0113272825,
-0.0165123902,
0.0212872755,
-0.0311964639,
-0.0028872718,
0.0076960237,
-0.0310334451,
0.0252574589,
-0.0644945651,
-0.0009046129,
0.0238854382,
0.0485063419,
0.030806236,
0.0524832979,
0.0103717064,
0.0181858111,
-0.0620301589,
0.0076666824,
-0.044494234,
-0.0268100835,
-0.0686199442,
-0.0040244176,
0.0405538231,
-0.0358810388,
0.0029660244,
0.0200333614,
-0.0467464738,
-0.0279246904,
0.0087895775,
0.0209774207,
0.0255554002,
-0.0002703611,
-0.0120368013,
-0.0863281935,
0.0070397751,
0.084415704,
-0.0509863049,
-0.0270912312,
-0.0125339022,
0.0441449136,
-0.0246929675,
0.0287676472,
-0.07629738,
-0.0225178376,
-0.0247904081,
0.0132161593,
-0.0839063749,
-0.0404224843,
0.0388696268,
0.0287607014,
0.0355653614,
0.0199237149,
0.0444671698,
-0.0106961131,
0.0251344685,
0.0049074879,
-0.0436178297,
-0.0105624218,
0.0072437543,
-0.0119559001,
-0.0149486531,
-0.0268946178,
0.0007797915,
0.0392639749,
0.0579337217,
-0.0944641083,
-0.0542338453,
0.0031532655,
-0.0062197689,
0.0183054972,
0.0193241071,
0.0051112603,
0.0454009473,
0.0082057696,
0.0655350015,
-0.0014838844,
0.0486748517,
0.0433258861,
-0.0125116734,
-0.0610540546,
0.0120269135,
-0.0797346085,
-0.0326922052,
0.0165841561,
-0.0252095163,
-0.0150829079,
-0.0498232879,
-0.0222064462,
-0.0025503756,
-0.0380956084,
-0.0008793654,
0.0018962122,
0.021572154,
-0.0048726257,
-0.0067554186,
0.0532602444,
0.0229468755,
0.0141095128,
0.0519378223,
-0.0641430765,
-0.0044376138,
0.0218116678,
-0.0678991005,
-0.0183052309,
-0.0212768018,
0.0362994634,
0.0574058481,
-0.0012491371,
-0.0353337005,
-0.0762890428,
-0.0027301356,
0.0619024783,
-0.0146838315,
0.0329575539,
0.0258868523,
0.0750917345,
0.0787161365,
0.0205506794,
-0.0293264948,
-0.0123833111,
0.0306170173,
-0.0315413065,
-0.0399067178,
0.0048949192,
-6.372919113e-33,
-0.0126757715,
-0.022963725,
0.0007620542,
0.0718932748,
-0.008788202,
-0.0173164196,
-0.004437529,
-0.0024383073,
0.0035725283,
-0.0177874342,
-0.0348241478,
-0.0014734571,
0.0201262701,
0.0080837915,
0.0111556388,
-0.0300302487,
0.0300149247,
0.0469029769,
-0.0342001505,
0.0276672021,
0.1087375209,
0.0718329623,
-0.0240891818,
-0.048536066,
0.0086733745,
-0.0244109146,
0.0107634952,
0.012142593,
0.0276549403,
0.0429767072,
-0.0233917646,
0.0193427801,
0.0170436185,
0.0478120148,
0.0218374599,
0.0025607764,
-0.1178305969,
-0.0213748328,
0.0038782738,
-0.0150744971,
0.0325346999,
-0.0303414557,
0.0399633721,
-0.0237980355,
0.0224622451,
0.0092493026,
0.0507778674,
0.0041212607,
-0.0452923886,
-0.0613658205,
-0.0045159934,
-0.0071833255,
0.0270439778,
-0.0164533444,
0.0584831573,
0.0269177128,
0.0306259245,
0.0324894115,
-0.0431414433,
0.023365112,
0.0021836159,
0.0643117875,
0.0126614748,
0.033788532,
-0.032611534,
0.0816696361,
0.0377912559,
-0.0005000564,
0.0028582641,
0.0062487205,
0.0306337047,
0.0060007605,
0.0025808294,
0.0198062286,
0.048076719,
-0.0034038753,
0.00247144,
0.0402513184,
0.0251461919,
-0.000489615,
0.0253826883,
0.0273839552,
-0.0693269968,
-0.0249313414,
0.0001229866,
0.0230039004,
-0.0763419345,
0.0025351909,
0.0386452228,
0.0395858884,
-0.0410609506,
-0.0185742676,
-0.0001042287,
0.0167687852,
-0.0227606408,
-0.0302568562,
0.0262145605,
0.0086497506,
-0.0125315739,
-0.0025350964,
0.0000491328,
-0.0043341233,
-0.0022318913,
-0.024945328,
-0.0359821096,
0.0023091608,
0.014082253,
0.0312653966,
-0.0694641843,
-0.0148854712,
0.0044802646,
-0.0020155667,
-0.0205620229,
-0.0475057289,
0.0274702348,
0.0220639184,
-0.0131752407,
0.0461431257,
0.0099683739,
0.024312811,
-0.0648381338,
-0.0425895788,
-0.0292293932,
-0.0359132066,
0.0216628574,
0.0114430059,
0.0182646979,
0.0218202621,
0.0056154113,
-0.0311535206,
0.0111692622,
0.0537931658,
2.801e-7,
0.0381370485,
0.0219997671,
0.0323505923,
0.0107526416,
-0.0502120592,
0.010044775,
0.0310758557,
0.0010132295,
0.0376362726,
-0.0322695449,
-0.005454394,
0.0096713919,
0.0199679099,
0.0175089911,
-0.1222412139,
-0.0235717148,
0.0009729876,
-0.0394060425,
-0.0342608877,
-0.0324239768,
0.0062563405,
0.0094311284,
0.0583922341,
-0.0268499441,
-0.0177383404,
-0.0410745889,
0.0605486445,
-0.0514141545,
-0.0325739644,
0.0054141898,
0.0443355963,
0.0312783457,
0.0039526359,
0.0060845814,
-0.0173271652,
0.0034305453,
0.0443763919,
-0.0009704518,
-0.0002016953,
-0.0624567121,
-0.0237167664,
0.0014552006,
-0.0130775999,
-0.0480840243,
0.0483163893,
-0.0057921419,
0.0351219922,
0.0558285341,
-0.022006914,
-0.016613815,
0.0018090341,
-0.0102611743,
-0.0318635255,
0.0196240004,
-0.0110395271,
0.0249647666,
0.0181845911,
-0.1110616326,
0.018944893,
0.0252800565,
0.0026667151,
-0.0166397206,
-0.0435491391,
0.0085636955,
-0.064814955,
-0.0663645491,
-0.0334730484,
2.526407586e-34,
0.0175544973,
0.0083520794,
-0.0254112128,
0.0238318965,
0.0208324585,
0.0193118621,
0.0217645913,
0.0112303067,
0.0377634279,
-0.0664876923,
-0.0215251036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15051v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15051v2 | A Monte Carlo Language Model Pipeline for Zero-Shot Sociopolitical Event Extraction | 2023-05-24T11:41:33 | 2024-06-02T19:17:34 | Erica Cai, Brendan O'Connor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current social science efforts automatically populate event databases of "who
did what to whom?" tuples, by applying event extraction (EE) to text such as
news. The event databases are used to analyze sociopolitical dynamics between
actor pairs (dyads) in, e.g., international relations. While most EE methods
heavily rely on rules or supervised learning, \emph{zero-shot} event extraction
could potentially allow researchers to flexibly specify arbitrary event classes
for new research questions. Unfortunately, we find that current zero-shot EE
methods, as well as a naive zero-shot approach of simple generative language
model (LM) prompting, perform poorly for dyadic event extraction; most suffer
from word sense ambiguity, modality sensitivity, and computational
inefficiency. We address these challenges with a new fine-grained, multi-stage
instruction-following generative LM pipeline, proposing a Monte Carlo approach
to deal with, and even take advantage of, nondeterminism of generative outputs.
Our pipeline includes explicit stages of linguistic analysis (synonym
generation, contextual disambiguation, argument realization, event modality),
\textit{improving control and interpretability} compared to purely neural
methods. This method outperforms other zero-shot EE approaches, and outperforms
naive applications of generative LMs by at least 17 F1 percent points. The
pipeline's filtering mechanism greatly improves computational efficiency,
allowing it to perform as few as 12% of queries that a previous zero-shot
method uses. Finally, we demonstrate our pipeline's application to dyadic
international relations analysis. | [
0.0197578128,
0.0870908946,
-0.0068169809,
0.0376944095,
-0.0402663387,
-0.0001370932,
0.0343916677,
0.0046199309,
0.0239465646,
-0.0482434519,
0.0430744886,
-0.0507276841,
-0.0355399698,
0.0535164773,
0.0178542472,
-0.0542203411,
0.0525651239,
0.022828836,
0.0403227434,
-0.0000158302,
-0.0209019836,
0.0286981352,
-0.0187222175,
0.0201510675,
-0.0094371606,
-0.00332842,
-0.0434956662,
0.0225747786,
0.0444700345,
-0.0199965667,
-0.0266408846,
0.0524154678,
0.0328822695,
0.0275797229,
0.000002153,
-0.0492707416,
-0.0243649613,
-0.0272614155,
0.0196747817,
-0.015288542,
0.0486560762,
-0.0228896104,
-0.0068294797,
-0.0167868622,
-0.0399175547,
-0.0403100587,
0.0020799055,
0.0072300467,
0.0265831947,
0.0997865796,
-0.0163467135,
0.0113098416,
-0.0053883963,
-0.0428382829,
0.001739102,
-0.0090760579,
0.0442765877,
-0.0425125957,
-0.0259909853,
0.017912535,
-0.0003681651,
0.0220634937,
-0.0011815539,
-0.0072721266,
-0.0124864886,
0.0483308025,
-0.0186910722,
0.0071158237,
-0.0016325559,
0.0418995842,
0.0047163852,
-0.0007369724,
0.0461368859,
-0.0158216842,
-0.0145389168,
0.0126270643,
-0.027375428,
0.0371270366,
-0.0004407903,
0.0385950431,
0.0584618114,
0.0088470764,
0.021411499,
0.021157274,
-0.0178338196,
0.0583961271,
0.0094623743,
-0.0031253546,
-0.0361917131,
-0.0094110528,
0.011422893,
-0.0786694288,
-0.008125959,
0.0201123897,
0.0058274898,
0.0327708311,
-0.037827421,
0.0316476077,
-0.0021067094,
-0.0853971317,
-0.008276619,
0.0252473392,
0.0279949326,
0.0707621202,
0.0335972533,
-0.030984886,
0.0199937392,
0.0125826793,
0.0005847029,
-0.0059752241,
-0.0515041202,
0.0251627602,
-0.0070069106,
0.0016196114,
-0.0690972134,
-0.0168800727,
-0.0114473719,
-0.0118232807,
-0.0041389139,
0.0281276945,
-0.0276741181,
0.0058756345,
-0.081378758,
-0.0042027025,
-0.047295291,
0.025877364,
-0.0565815046,
0.011854778,
-0.01164818,
-0.0551006086,
-0.0353690982,
-0.0003757898,
0.0216546208,
-0.0137093151,
-0.0166352913,
0.0464726388,
-0.0232393499,
-0.0067609772,
-0.038676735,
-0.037342485,
-0.003894299,
-0.0235140547,
0.0254189391,
-0.0659687296,
0.0725304857,
-0.0154770901,
-0.0072763613,
-0.0500684045,
0.0403813496,
-0.0141029544,
-0.0662218556,
0.0611661114,
0.0372747965,
0.0124930898,
0.0170771908,
0.0206540581,
0.0349387974,
0.1027350947,
0.0534992218,
0.0262393337,
0.047518529,
0.0436736308,
0.0120873936,
0.0263901632,
0.0196608566,
0.040490903,
-0.0545524321,
-0.0377602614,
-0.0377808176,
-0.0008768539,
0.0525656082,
0.028626509,
-0.0352637358,
-0.0351979174,
0.0328598469,
0.0170682501,
-0.0147366831,
0.026853241,
0.0666715503,
0.0126183033,
-0.0317709632,
0.0280964989,
-0.0043210699,
0.0102163507,
-0.002556992,
-0.0236981865,
0.0150689436,
0.017031543,
-0.0139051182,
-0.0087393112,
0.0177086424,
-0.0002877827,
0.0204304289,
0.0002000883,
0.0627371073,
-0.004624824,
-0.0392800607,
0.0238865223,
0.0486939773,
-0.0482860133,
0.0392739102,
-0.044450637,
0.0027947633,
0.0463452972,
0.0674737096,
-0.033638645,
-0.034671057,
-0.0471277386,
0.0029802823,
0.0464265943,
0.0158101786,
-0.0170823205,
0.036002636,
-0.0296929721,
-0.0297386069,
-0.0223289914,
0.0245909169,
0.0378758721,
0.0286474507,
0.0198902376,
-0.0076524606,
-0.004007881,
0.0167123452,
0.0296561439,
-0.0355612859,
-0.0591343902,
0.0060568126,
-0.0149767725,
0.0218924582,
0.0160447005,
-0.0213856306,
-0.0072245952,
0.038731128,
-0.0439775847,
-0.008579636,
-0.0067605721,
-0.0011979747,
-0.0197832994,
0.0133541767,
-0.0117915133,
-0.0260344278,
-0.0254233386,
-0.0345762931,
-0.0216126014,
0.0624338388,
0.0487059131,
-0.0098607959,
-0.0292251222,
-0.0035387452,
0.0014960807,
-0.0003331968,
-0.0501857847,
0.0765028372,
0.0004172207,
0.0018600518,
0.0017436513,
0.0108615467,
0.0119576957,
-0.0118021592,
-0.0255611725,
0.0370512977,
0.0126237553,
-0.0183390193,
0.0234983508,
-0.0498717129,
-0.0302736275,
-0.0535553023,
-0.0643548295,
0.0367277563,
-0.0153486114,
0.0176262334,
0.0452431068,
0.0046919719,
-0.0300555695,
0.0403333381,
-0.0026084981,
-0.0620893016,
-0.0333498716,
-0.0296839047,
0.0367861129,
0.0094794966,
-0.0086135911,
-0.0436808206,
0.00174008,
-0.0709987208,
0.0628942102,
0.0119883753,
-0.0139353843,
0.0110149011,
0.0046322364,
-0.0380731523,
0.0412407182,
-0.0557371527,
-0.0366835818,
0.0160751212,
-0.0156930778,
0.053972587,
0.0671091676,
0.0184338726,
0.0950303003,
0.0424576774,
-0.0468584411,
-0.0577766672,
0.0208505634,
-0.0534715429,
-0.0052399896,
-0.0147452932,
-0.0612400509,
-0.0148523403,
0.051612936,
0.0279602073,
0.011671653,
-0.0216744207,
0.0272590257,
-0.005759188,
-0.0315074436,
0.0080237659,
-0.0092735384,
-0.0022586642,
0.0369514599,
-0.027940724,
0.0076937918,
0.0523477383,
0.003655311,
0.0284355059,
-0.0294474624,
-0.0186823681,
-0.019818902,
0.1100210026,
-0.0192839541,
-0.0010915566,
-0.0082721971,
-0.0166599005,
-0.0488528647,
-0.0727069005,
0.034349028,
-0.0226007495,
0.0264242645,
-0.0714897588,
-0.0030104318,
-0.0389014855,
0.0220297966,
-0.0415376127,
-0.0544808246,
-0.0006014658,
0.0306919198,
0.0334451757,
-0.0041139219,
0.0243596118,
0.0254868418,
0.043399062,
0.0218454711,
-0.0023700178,
-0.0053917351,
-0.0226873383,
0.0634624064,
0.0311919712,
-0.0681980252,
-0.0465034842,
-0.0052161193,
-0.0076765013,
0.0275552906,
0.0308600012,
0.0149108525,
-0.0250028577,
-0.014745729,
0.0270691141,
-0.0281447303,
-0.0057863458,
-0.016030388,
0.0331763104,
-0.074032791,
0.0122120352,
0.1165754795,
0.0412191898,
-0.0278145876,
0.0114929127,
0.0121386796,
-0.0217092969,
0.0005432394,
0.018763341,
-0.1107076779,
0.0262490977,
0.0027485776,
-0.0443201736,
-0.0539725423,
-0.0759441257,
-0.0285980254,
-0.0951260775,
0.0159041882,
-0.0042485846,
0.005351427,
-0.0016717933,
-0.0383279771,
0.0158375613,
-0.0158179421,
-0.0687042102,
0.0010145709,
0.0159335937,
0.007060416,
-0.0036021806,
0.003217604,
-0.0707713068,
0.0149901491,
-0.0596613064,
0.0652839467,
0.012571509,
0.0608001724,
0.0041453452,
0.0268236455,
0.0255269166,
-0.023049565,
-0.018275084,
-0.0150726158,
0.0487320907,
-0.0320123844,
-0.026022546,
0.0011607585,
0.0492076725,
0.0402582511,
-0.0434616171,
-0.0150861219,
0.0557124726,
-0.0380668379,
-0.0123445513,
-0.0055291695,
0.0160672031,
0.0476480238,
0.0723935738,
0.0180729106,
0.0068674404,
-0.0464986525,
-0.0224726349,
0.0325780921,
-0.0816593096,
-0.0183697306,
-0.0042269244,
-0.0298103672,
-0.0761591643,
-0.0232349839,
-0.0787387788,
0.0331137963,
0.0289854947,
-0.0154862283,
0.0010480772,
0.0428028293,
-0.0069798869,
-0.030571619,
0.01236015,
-0.0239165034,
0.0068688602,
0.0392090678,
-0.0529553853,
-0.0032931545,
0.0511707887,
-0.0272075459,
0.051742509,
-0.0547234192,
-0.0544972122,
-0.0041736369,
-0.0098172287,
0.0190085806,
0.0228403099,
-0.0186434966,
0.0003331351,
0.014159997,
0.0815346465,
0.0162773058,
0.0002370159,
0.013980194,
0.0426233001,
0.0228168517,
0.0391619094,
0.0167637393,
0.0383701883,
0.0133290375,
0.0345837362,
-0.1043020487,
-0.0380349495,
-0.0058999872,
-0.0590274744,
0.0743101761,
-0.0290771276,
-0.0370737426,
-0.0806603506,
-0.0535171144,
-0.0816816539,
0.0024265174,
-0.0162686557,
-0.0021605717,
-0.0027670348,
-0.0061952639,
-0.0462373644,
0.0132592637,
-0.0959710479,
0.0498881601,
-0.0158754215,
0.0206351317,
0.0193387903,
0.0036980209,
0.0067926976,
-0.0096032396,
-0.0175257977,
0.0009936548,
-0.004009821,
0.0066186138,
-0.0258497205,
0.0108586634,
0.0348497778,
0.0025728596,
-0.0147685874,
-0.023609234,
-0.0384739451,
0.0255424585,
0.0011031755,
0.032169465,
0.0719306171,
-0.0207100101,
0.0245943666,
0.0009455039,
-0.0177463256,
0.0213749912,
0.0387622863,
-0.0118878568,
-0.0485186167,
0.0169605836,
0.0389699303,
-0.0362315103,
0.0295728762,
0.0614605509,
-0.0239085387,
0.0381596684,
0.0482439213,
-0.0185465328,
-0.0075329691,
-0.0492618121,
0.0597567409,
0.0183267761,
-0.0069503742,
-0.0052624163,
-0.1076664329,
-0.0314476937,
0.0131502897,
0.021208521,
0.0013568008,
-0.0201242082,
0.0056669554,
0.0469986647,
-0.0028784864,
0.028347116,
-0.0829427093,
0.0503644012,
-0.0054850285,
-0.0623265766,
-0.0004539828,
-7.097061102e-33,
-0.037546806,
-0.0127189932,
0.0260988753,
-0.0089282729,
-0.0498710722,
0.0212035682,
-0.0697737932,
-0.0269156154,
-0.0234143455,
0.0217488986,
0.0054010469,
0.0057389517,
0.0198399127,
-0.0118057439,
-0.0018606386,
-0.0110781621,
0.0403492749,
0.0017164027,
-0.0062832627,
0.0172628164,
0.0576452017,
0.0198156219,
0.0212778077,
-0.0735608712,
0.0316905119,
-0.0049065193,
-0.0018358923,
-0.0168322884,
0.0710017756,
0.0045453184,
-0.0231099334,
0.0035015596,
0.0167279467,
-0.063327089,
0.0306375455,
0.003696739,
-0.0554492325,
-0.0279143434,
0.0143671716,
-0.0556253605,
-0.0059367651,
-0.0294941962,
0.003873568,
0.0294618923,
0.0073374198,
-0.0107917385,
0.0455093719,
-0.0148070101,
-0.0293794945,
-0.0401085615,
-0.0695435405,
0.0532480665,
-0.0039431872,
0.007465947,
-0.0362126231,
0.0032078354,
0.0412931442,
0.046891015,
-0.0603100285,
0.0079659196,
-0.0070369844,
0.0265563577,
0.0391896777,
0.0067213508,
0.0158275571,
0.0739321634,
0.0175220352,
0.0247018337,
-0.042072963,
0.0346259847,
0.032720197,
0.0339441523,
-0.0189746749,
0.0903354436,
0.0197719261,
-0.0319447406,
-0.1162879169,
0.0203070678,
0.0627222881,
-0.0124010723,
-0.0045438153,
0.0063208714,
0.0056141443,
-0.035766907,
-0.0226551108,
-0.0734542534,
-0.0239711795,
-0.0299022626,
-0.0109379757,
0.0084703239,
-0.0287688915,
0.0504539125,
0.0401212014,
-0.0113292318,
0.0009374824,
0.005553741,
-0.0171610434,
0.0277629383,
0.017340865,
0.0158101413,
-0.0403765216,
-0.0281574465,
0.0291827954,
0.0095789004,
0.0282868892,
0.0240379497,
-0.0158139393,
-0.0069974973,
-0.0296712928,
-0.0121434676,
-0.0551931523,
0.0201283619,
-0.0433661006,
0.0058882441,
-0.0082986141,
0.0283485614,
0.0076420251,
0.0063505769,
0.0524762087,
0.0113224592,
0.0539756045,
0.0088943299,
-0.0525483973,
0.0225181114,
-0.0018914177,
0.0120003885,
-0.0156557597,
0.051884491,
0.0340300947,
-0.0337856226,
-0.0207937285,
-0.0295651257,
2.923e-7,
0.0319583602,
0.0378585793,
0.0396852866,
0.0645129308,
0.0020933391,
0.0265507996,
0.0067743445,
0.0537364483,
-0.0063697007,
-0.0211947151,
0.0060057109,
0.0347095095,
0.0250988696,
0.0707281306,
-0.0612456165,
-0.0141039006,
-0.0234096423,
-0.0084804129,
-0.0878664553,
-0.0079083359,
0.0621877387,
0.037372835,
0.0784824565,
0.0331370831,
-0.017231524,
-0.0378059484,
0.0502323844,
-0.0170680266,
-0.0788381398,
0.0651303753,
0.0198395289,
-0.0272480864,
-0.0101036076,
0.0437373035,
-0.0300803725,
0.0248733051,
-0.0219778493,
0.0820424035,
0.0090580992,
-0.0202392936,
0.0047047213,
-0.055469621,
0.0045933407,
-0.0666465461,
0.0908462107,
-0.0671558529,
-0.0121436538,
0.0045890226,
-0.0356367975,
0.0410762727,
0.0243495535,
0.0000118201,
-0.0375030152,
0.0351679176,
0.0016729329,
0.0153666874,
-0.0043734796,
-0.0314635113,
-0.0130138174,
-0.0082448497,
-0.0317797028,
-0.0319401436,
0.0322674699,
-0.0196555164,
0.0070752539,
-0.0001038843,
0.0107535943,
2.875256886e-34,
0.0207221676,
0.03585409,
-0.0359264538,
-0.0237147491,
0.0489599481,
0.0085261846,
-0.0639649853,
0.0100717265,
0.0292061828,
-0.0276728403,
-0.020288514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15048v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15048v1 | Ranger: A Toolkit for Effect-Size Based Multi-Task Evaluation | 2023-05-24T11:38:39 | 2023-05-24T11:38:39 | Mete Sertkan, Sophia Althammer, Sebastian Hofstätter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | In this paper, we introduce Ranger - a toolkit to facilitate the easy use of
effect-size-based meta-analysis for multi-task evaluation in NLP and IR. We
observed that our communities often face the challenge of aggregating results
over incomparable metrics and scenarios, which makes conclusions and take-away
messages less reliable. With Ranger, we aim to address this issue by providing
a task-agnostic toolkit that combines the effect of a treatment on multiple
tasks into one statistical evaluation, allowing for comparison of metrics and
computation of an overall summary effect. Our toolkit produces
publication-ready forest plots that enable clear communication of evaluation
results over multiple tasks. Our goal with the ready-to-use Ranger toolkit is
to promote robust, effect-size-based evaluation and improve evaluation
standards in the community. We provide two case studies for common IR and NLP
settings to highlight Ranger's benefits. | [
0.0227805153,
0.0125008989,
-0.0304680895,
-0.048566673,
-0.0250909366,
-0.0016807879,
0.0371240564,
-0.0020835742,
-0.0509438626,
-0.0361675471,
-0.0300249495,
0.0391852185,
0.0217564292,
0.0336648077,
0.015961716,
-0.0647016093,
0.0508998558,
0.0218536649,
0.0118485978,
0.029321149,
0.0265590716,
-0.0003567882,
-0.0244199745,
0.077238366,
0.0141937165,
-0.0609369241,
0.0285080466,
0.0179699678,
0.043433506,
-0.0936716497,
-0.0244937502,
0.0612537302,
0.0187998656,
0.0229612328,
0.0000023157,
-0.0495936088,
-0.0226805042,
0.0498792827,
0.010691761,
0.0035474582,
0.0679570735,
0.0154549154,
0.0477471687,
0.0166249275,
0.0060881842,
-0.0441113785,
0.0573924109,
0.0350569822,
-0.0043292958,
-0.0019903125,
-0.0312305987,
0.0293501969,
-0.0208950154,
-0.0076937322,
0.042738907,
0.049388364,
0.0013187071,
-0.0191123243,
0.0079701459,
-0.018979894,
-0.0070000747,
0.0308913365,
0.0128682684,
0.0005643487,
0.0185255762,
0.0169462003,
-0.0131087722,
-0.0546030812,
-0.0316916294,
0.0353382938,
0.0029465263,
0.0262279175,
-0.0096993428,
-0.0221151896,
0.0319022089,
0.0707076192,
-0.0984677821,
0.0036481011,
0.0210077669,
-0.0461378954,
-0.0413787141,
0.0241663922,
0.0228647869,
-0.0355205946,
0.0390294418,
0.0185102951,
0.0050654933,
-0.0135478666,
0.0549203269,
0.0156657156,
-0.0228033233,
-0.0421210527,
-0.0149055477,
-0.0329814106,
-0.0400290638,
-0.0232530124,
0.0408938266,
-0.0397483595,
0.0845244378,
0.000252754,
0.0837443098,
-0.0094904583,
-0.0458385646,
-0.0024174661,
0.0135416146,
0.0085970722,
0.0315138325,
0.0210277699,
0.0222796649,
0.0501191728,
-0.0673145428,
0.0019814519,
0.0145392437,
0.0021721621,
-0.0141601283,
-0.0028213444,
-0.0604063459,
-0.0286512673,
-0.0515207611,
-0.0126190307,
0.063406989,
0.0354539678,
-0.05079275,
0.0532352701,
-0.0159018394,
0.0620740876,
-0.0353002474,
0.0639369339,
0.0153893474,
-0.0254978966,
0.0074786171,
0.0013565922,
0.0004035199,
-0.0331786796,
0.0073009855,
0.0360903777,
0.029788183,
-0.0221299343,
0.0247256309,
-0.0285131782,
-0.0487335771,
-0.0361278653,
0.0354544446,
-0.0716670305,
0.0406286009,
-0.0010198073,
0.0449709743,
0.0030965649,
-0.0062494869,
0.0102054337,
-0.0107093574,
0.0407400765,
-0.0288240518,
0.0268983115,
-0.0096954061,
0.0027380928,
-0.0609213188,
0.0646970496,
0.0228872653,
0.0095122028,
0.0451307967,
-0.025219446,
-0.0161039215,
-0.0246730801,
-0.0119372951,
-0.0216384381,
0.0339689776,
-0.0107328286,
-0.0097834812,
-0.0075008683,
-0.0449135751,
0.0084765805,
-0.0212242454,
0.0573181026,
0.0535012931,
0.0598818511,
0.0520250238,
-0.02613681,
0.0061092707,
-0.0134513257,
0.0105471928,
-0.0353958346,
-0.0488435403,
0.0317605324,
-0.0098084612,
0.0124798948,
-0.0024626784,
0.0663858056,
-0.0043158997,
-0.047654368,
-0.0431506373,
0.0212093256,
0.0025753193,
-0.0174250845,
0.0337103531,
0.0028781833,
0.0269520171,
-0.0155997965,
0.0242173839,
-0.0399473757,
0.0015079451,
-0.0057447162,
-0.0653784722,
0.0289750919,
0.0404586457,
-0.0608865619,
0.0035206114,
-0.0399954729,
0.0140455319,
0.0169908348,
0.0297142062,
0.0181114972,
0.0264203679,
-0.0011341864,
-0.0367400423,
-0.0404267646,
0.0173711367,
0.0046815374,
0.0295506828,
0.0164949335,
-0.0406701416,
-0.040398024,
-0.050664641,
0.0364707187,
0.0324763469,
0.0039667147,
0.0154358465,
-0.017733885,
0.0105377408,
0.0183731094,
-0.0480017327,
0.0151300076,
0.0268757716,
0.0127830086,
-0.0185543876,
0.0445789583,
0.0509670191,
-0.0149345323,
-0.0021188874,
-0.0558553562,
-0.0418304279,
0.0264780838,
-0.0282268506,
-0.0100248605,
-0.0264724679,
-0.0233391672,
0.0314688645,
0.0507535189,
-0.0141834505,
-0.0215438921,
-0.0153557258,
-0.0518945791,
0.0121467076,
0.029366551,
-0.0241410304,
0.0013841511,
-0.090623498,
-0.0028767884,
-0.0028081464,
-0.0334283337,
0.0174395181,
-0.041343078,
-0.0291605815,
0.022275053,
0.0107286619,
-0.095352158,
-0.0084979348,
-0.0986084193,
0.0095451539,
0.0287026353,
0.0234632362,
0.0245982818,
0.011376881,
0.0021849433,
0.0101261772,
0.0069539114,
-0.0235866513,
0.0061342558,
0.0721884444,
0.0100979796,
-0.0058817845,
0.0097370977,
-0.0662420243,
-0.0295412261,
-0.0422704481,
0.0632252768,
0.0767854303,
-0.0396356732,
0.0274842847,
0.0256314687,
-0.0110745011,
-0.0560777783,
0.020802794,
0.0141331954,
0.0286852978,
0.0172446799,
0.072233595,
0.0389460362,
-0.0204040352,
0.0261412188,
0.0895299688,
-0.0270648897,
-0.0486805029,
-0.0091541735,
-0.0139040276,
-0.0151155852,
0.0187032279,
-0.0709168613,
0.0264337156,
0.0306410845,
0.0024330101,
0.0164490715,
-0.0024019196,
-0.0292228293,
-0.0447394364,
-0.0378588066,
-0.0441219173,
-0.0353975929,
-0.0273482446,
0.0079964111,
-0.0214351974,
-0.0539730676,
0.0478996634,
0.0351223126,
-0.0053522522,
-0.0638113618,
0.021022873,
-0.0073948563,
0.0693755373,
-0.0292190108,
-0.0081008263,
0.0256431606,
0.0098704584,
-0.0159257874,
-0.0546241514,
0.0421205908,
-0.007976721,
0.0255246032,
-0.0665844008,
0.0001050747,
-0.0149134919,
-0.0215330403,
-0.0052763298,
0.0086852601,
-0.0030853094,
-0.0240644328,
0.0289678089,
-0.030067673,
-0.0385711677,
-0.0214220453,
0.0854204968,
-0.0291540921,
-0.0374508984,
-0.0395044014,
0.0415485017,
-0.0269895382,
0.0322788768,
-0.003901937,
0.0227945577,
-0.0202275105,
0.0181532409,
0.0541325994,
0.0338374078,
0.0138593344,
-0.0096732667,
-0.0032334789,
-0.0131969796,
-0.0492762178,
-0.0041231317,
0.0094753793,
0.0673113763,
-0.0291378349,
0.0303349942,
0.0619761646,
0.0257718712,
-0.0750899091,
0.014369539,
-0.0644471645,
0.0121220546,
0.0110563673,
-0.008148524,
-0.046266973,
-0.0373139121,
-0.0147955548,
0.0061890287,
-0.0204106495,
0.0107267108,
0.025627045,
-0.0331701636,
0.0086651118,
-0.0166884046,
-0.0471442565,
0.0073904241,
-0.0564190075,
0.0326740928,
-0.011357978,
-0.0248481743,
-0.0236473754,
-0.0498213917,
0.0264013149,
0.0036468147,
-0.049314294,
-0.0310287662,
0.0222031251,
-0.0289009027,
0.0294785518,
0.0393850841,
0.0169208925,
-0.0192301478,
-0.008180514,
0.038852524,
0.0357745774,
0.0133675132,
-0.023075847,
0.103177391,
0.028438922,
0.0354272425,
-0.0345458873,
-0.0156362057,
0.006541077,
-0.0689405948,
0.0369749703,
0.0586954542,
0.0154455928,
-0.0233099498,
-0.0340493172,
0.0092709325,
-0.0050219302,
0.042343732,
0.0563447997,
-0.0074271718,
-0.0154679306,
-0.0338450931,
-0.0155348126,
-0.0626559928,
-0.0450036637,
0.0018283855,
-0.0240886137,
-0.0157114826,
-0.0299752969,
-0.0588812977,
0.0923879296,
-0.0413776748,
-0.0112883262,
0.0165236797,
-0.0012684434,
0.0299688224,
-0.0600353144,
0.0663077608,
0.0491782315,
0.0277718958,
0.0081874589,
0.0045738863,
0.0289241672,
0.059036918,
0.0064160959,
0.0484663434,
-0.0280230902,
-0.0102546224,
0.0195911992,
0.0387815088,
0.0187574774,
-0.0559253544,
0.0331919342,
-0.0079406658,
0.0316941515,
0.0584750064,
-0.0371655673,
-0.0232723542,
0.0307818837,
0.0054114559,
0.0231203623,
-0.0413091555,
-0.0392272659,
0.0041557876,
0.0007972197,
0.02460742,
0.036695227,
0.017430298,
0.0068970071,
0.0211010687,
0.0558522642,
-0.0300578121,
-0.0112545202,
-0.0135729145,
-0.05037947,
-0.0523361713,
0.0033709691,
0.0068216408,
0.0045640455,
-0.0181094073,
0.0010642996,
-0.0109972795,
0.101605393,
-0.0575013272,
-0.0187535826,
-0.0728039667,
0.0489044301,
-0.0305611156,
0.0025651716,
0.0023272072,
0.0274438746,
-0.0443734191,
-0.0541724414,
-0.012154323,
0.0091832392,
0.0266056992,
0.004973372,
0.0021200324,
-0.0074182441,
-0.0095956232,
0.0679706782,
-0.0615871176,
0.0035790144,
0.0232092384,
-0.0101666851,
-0.0019651337,
0.0210281331,
0.0981068984,
-0.000215324,
-0.0047680615,
-0.0492626391,
-0.0070508635,
0.0007315853,
0.0426709019,
0.0191516522,
-0.0104335286,
-0.0231207851,
-0.074392572,
0.06482324,
-0.0438021757,
0.0157700647,
-0.0421406291,
-0.0359971896,
-0.0202532373,
-0.0634815618,
-0.0075597838,
0.0245897826,
-0.0383344628,
-0.0617146865,
-0.0813526958,
-0.0472011082,
0.0011684342,
-0.0066267061,
0.035544835,
0.016212767,
-0.0109237656,
0.0024063501,
0.0124894585,
-0.0776024088,
0.0101290951,
0.0153936548,
-0.0091024311,
-0.0251476839,
-0.0223163515,
-5.998172983e-33,
-0.007861712,
-0.0238275062,
-0.005098742,
0.0063378075,
0.0209577568,
0.0261344612,
-0.0164247286,
0.026337022,
0.0140234809,
0.0570226498,
-0.0072222208,
-0.0027133997,
0.0100943763,
-0.0067272512,
0.0642327592,
0.0261212587,
0.0460327156,
-0.0058034062,
-0.0382520631,
0.0162443854,
-0.0051863152,
-0.0212494209,
0.0553661473,
-0.064615503,
0.0423827283,
0.0862657428,
-0.0106722927,
-0.0517872013,
-0.0592829771,
0.0703720972,
0.0167649481,
0.0732027516,
0.0322409347,
-0.0229310635,
-0.0529076867,
0.0227509867,
-0.0413896516,
-0.0632835403,
0.0415363945,
-0.0438982211,
-0.0589307621,
0.0144366995,
0.0425340049,
0.031726934,
0.0096921958,
-0.0604105406,
0.0456324071,
-0.0222031958,
-0.0095470082,
-0.0177885387,
-0.0428658538,
0.0013532493,
-0.0167308412,
0.0139271589,
-0.0100805564,
0.092487067,
-0.0181096662,
0.007291134,
-0.043687284,
0.0350733213,
-0.0130911134,
0.000387878,
0.0236003548,
0.021426525,
0.0117422454,
0.0371295735,
-0.0332999155,
0.0292277876,
0.0269531645,
-0.0194120593,
0.0232058335,
0.0286990479,
0.0545300841,
0.0507519171,
0.043979805,
0.0199814551,
-0.0577378795,
0.0575644039,
-0.0235480256,
0.0488872007,
0.0117672263,
0.0009272223,
-0.0009204809,
-0.0190186724,
-0.0295395218,
0.0431888439,
-0.0365445763,
-0.0316917114,
0.0571605712,
-0.0351830125,
0.0072184368,
0.0437683873,
0.0143504972,
-0.0134804165,
-0.0049981344,
-0.0167931598,
0.0036691383,
0.0518893301,
0.0125114024,
-0.053613916,
-0.0312877856,
0.0328938887,
0.0138704879,
0.0743096322,
0.0681027621,
-0.0340114236,
0.0540735945,
-0.0472561233,
-0.0532987826,
-0.0041099153,
-0.0012871969,
0.005116188,
0.0287639443,
-0.0350928977,
0.0048547653,
0.0315801688,
-0.0117229261,
0.0115820961,
0.0411797874,
-0.0221754722,
-0.0557872914,
-0.0226593688,
-0.0180290993,
-0.0048560156,
-0.0071564796,
-0.0095925117,
-0.0559309609,
-0.0186767094,
0.0443965569,
-0.0155274374,
-0.0253026001,
-0.0732706934,
2.931e-7,
0.0800582767,
0.0570845865,
-0.0094189495,
0.0250350051,
0.0166782085,
-0.0123006329,
0.0018705504,
0.0192972589,
0.0469382294,
0.0245609581,
0.0015748129,
0.0225791037,
0.0253082849,
0.0447645336,
0.0222152919,
-0.0662545636,
-0.0382287949,
-0.0222197883,
-0.04467123,
0.0247684773,
0.0665932074,
-0.0058782944,
0.0080557317,
0.020291619,
-0.0256861895,
-0.006958066,
0.0017351134,
-0.053043697,
0.00801099,
0.006702689,
-0.0231389068,
-0.0429016165,
0.0285856426,
0.0400628038,
-0.0388676897,
-0.0610080436,
-0.0105502894,
0.0269476119,
-0.0493718274,
0.0141271511,
0.0114283562,
0.012733005,
0.0137295518,
-0.0275602154,
0.0315878913,
-0.1036366001,
-0.0224080421,
0.0065852762,
-0.0032738298,
0.0171120614,
0.089509517,
-0.0140293911,
-0.015606218,
0.0156256109,
-0.019917937,
0.0467378832,
-0.0632244796,
-0.0178195424,
-0.021308424,
0.0407010838,
-0.0052564284,
-0.0815813616,
-0.0279401969,
-0.0498115569,
-0.0512058362,
-0.0940952376,
-0.0212319195,
2.921201955e-34,
0.0144578367,
0.0324826762,
0.0452725068,
-0.0166722797,
0.0345850177,
-0.0078233667,
-0.0329438746,
0.0100227706,
0.0041388599,
-0.0671612695,
-0.0214094501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15047v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15047v3 | Ghostbuster: Detecting Text Ghostwritten by Large Language Models | 2023-05-24T11:37:10 | 2024-04-05T23:57:35 | Vivek Verma, Eve Fleisig, Nicholas Tomlin, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce Ghostbuster, a state-of-the-art system for detecting
AI-generated text. Our method works by passing documents through a series of
weaker language models, running a structured search over possible combinations
of their features, and then training a classifier on the selected features to
predict whether documents are AI-generated. Crucially, Ghostbuster does not
require access to token probabilities from the target model, making it useful
for detecting text generated by black-box models or unknown model versions. In
conjunction with our model, we release three new datasets of human- and
AI-generated text as detection benchmarks in the domains of student essays,
creative writing, and news articles. We compare Ghostbuster to a variety of
existing detectors, including DetectGPT and GPTZero, as well as a new RoBERTa
baseline. Ghostbuster achieves 99.0 F1 when evaluated across domains, which is
5.9 F1 higher than the best preexisting model. It also outperforms all previous
approaches in generalization across writing domains (+7.5 F1), prompting
strategies (+2.1 F1), and language models (+4.4 F1). We also analyze the
robustness of our system to a variety of perturbations and paraphrasing attacks
and evaluate its performance on documents written by non-native English
speakers. | [
0.0710239187,
0.0870761126,
-0.0083635217,
0.0327922776,
-0.0650388822,
-0.0065919682,
0.0392091647,
0.0486682579,
0.0376226306,
-0.0710740462,
0.0085814595,
-0.0009580819,
-0.0073562134,
0.0444598645,
0.0197796561,
0.0300671067,
0.0237204973,
-0.0130513227,
0.0137878768,
0.0082549192,
0.0257971324,
0.0253359172,
0.0194897763,
0.0658122301,
-0.0327400006,
-0.0338678956,
-0.0130391875,
0.0268089045,
-0.0105763758,
0.00296783,
0.0122858975,
0.0598925501,
-0.0170874931,
0.1148503944,
0.0000018853,
-0.0313575342,
-0.0346754938,
-0.0146647356,
-0.0158665199,
0.0179094709,
0.0443465933,
0.0118122222,
-0.0373833552,
0.0317558199,
-0.0419301204,
0.0201661438,
0.0205149539,
0.0530241989,
0.0328862779,
0.0864726454,
-0.039066039,
0.0147253657,
0.0621110015,
0.0056928764,
0.0064510098,
0.0168547332,
0.0341677219,
-0.0268710721,
-0.0052303094,
0.0157948788,
0.0237414856,
0.0376991034,
0.0127311768,
-0.0717388988,
-0.0579173416,
0.0097908154,
-0.0348300897,
0.0096545098,
0.0149593223,
0.008728222,
-0.0499577299,
-0.0607276373,
0.0393572338,
-0.0012220487,
0.0109585878,
0.0406115092,
0.0074038291,
0.0310117491,
-0.0342906602,
-0.0236710571,
0.042636808,
-0.0420418791,
0.0177919865,
0.0352190137,
0.0408235677,
0.0429727584,
0.0254740845,
-0.039590992,
-0.0044550872,
-0.0066584502,
0.0044634887,
-0.05656863,
0.0464726724,
0.0051315152,
-0.0077836947,
-0.0109353885,
-0.0956145972,
-0.0729117692,
0.0310750809,
-0.0382160582,
0.0541527122,
0.0023155254,
-0.0151745873,
0.0373872556,
-0.0389524363,
0.0573937409,
-0.0196842179,
0.0374907292,
-0.0088123586,
0.0414783508,
-0.0271668416,
-0.044644285,
-0.0435068458,
0.0387151465,
0.0098792072,
-0.0222664997,
-0.0031722088,
0.0259167533,
0.0245722439,
0.0173161719,
-0.0221142359,
-0.0128301568,
-0.0215047449,
-0.0094247079,
0.0426062271,
-0.0360371061,
0.0111680226,
0.015963763,
-0.0043772119,
-0.0626990646,
-0.0231202357,
0.0656248704,
0.0186635014,
-0.0192743279,
0.0041492633,
0.0306150857,
-0.0100907469,
-0.0497538336,
-0.0386460423,
-0.0380413532,
-0.0191349704,
-0.0305255782,
-0.0278021265,
-0.0465974063,
-0.03581471,
-0.0268218592,
-0.0097808652,
-0.0367271043,
0.0053913635,
0.0305831209,
-0.0013519874,
0.0303474255,
-0.0002512117,
-0.0126519855,
0.0450333916,
-0.0163576528,
-0.0257385317,
0.02739558,
0.0131146284,
0.069961153,
0.0580282323,
0.0256877281,
0.049625393,
0.0527213216,
0.0095807258,
0.0275114812,
-0.0019901202,
-0.032604754,
-0.0097611211,
0.0033515773,
0.0066430001,
0.0398712866,
-0.0012511539,
-0.0191369765,
0.0636939779,
0.0680762231,
-0.0690457672,
0.0439674668,
0.0666617975,
0.0094971685,
0.0146559812,
0.0384939909,
-0.0233591907,
-0.042262245,
-0.0518595465,
-0.0280483086,
-0.0100333272,
-0.0288950168,
0.0220633019,
-0.03156491,
-0.0097585917,
-0.0235617068,
-0.0000454146,
-0.0406324789,
0.0191887543,
0.0206583422,
-0.0627576187,
-0.035575185,
-0.0302150268,
-0.0502139218,
-0.0179945119,
-0.0756296441,
0.0396188498,
0.0727792159,
0.0960781798,
-0.0268414933,
0.0264597107,
-0.0479035676,
-0.002875041,
0.0510354191,
-0.0146274753,
0.0055508362,
0.0117439646,
-0.0248179901,
-0.0218176506,
-0.025034545,
0.0407317057,
0.0309139118,
0.029896928,
0.0362724811,
0.0290906895,
-0.0248627681,
-0.0798993856,
0.0558444224,
-0.0542318858,
-0.0325385071,
0.0196164213,
-0.006204003,
0.0035121946,
0.0010087863,
-0.0286880787,
0.0366226174,
0.0123213958,
-0.0635169744,
-0.0359061137,
-0.0027255365,
0.0135523733,
0.0051636319,
0.0265903901,
-0.007233486,
-0.0074417344,
0.0668214187,
-0.0034177841,
-0.0133748017,
0.0127960257,
-0.054307688,
0.0272430852,
-0.0615883842,
0.0215733107,
-0.0423644073,
0.0210954901,
-0.0125075448,
0.0488536842,
0.0071495827,
-0.0113022756,
0.0165235363,
-0.0273651406,
0.063639611,
-0.0081446916,
-0.0207616128,
-0.0074798069,
-0.0155663909,
0.0200764947,
0.0422732681,
0.0106266858,
-0.0144737391,
-0.0308128912,
-0.0844096988,
0.0199583452,
-0.026824167,
0.0146570588,
0.0333257616,
-0.0308471415,
-0.0032889952,
0.0083728116,
-0.0033515899,
-0.0462366156,
0.0021814364,
0.00206432,
0.0241048355,
-0.0272557642,
0.0251909513,
-0.0364995375,
0.0053112004,
-0.0263526142,
0.0420340411,
0.0369221382,
-0.040192388,
-0.0498690829,
0.0893639326,
0.0208895802,
-0.0032261861,
-0.0033146485,
-0.0426077917,
-0.0138582084,
-0.0422929972,
0.0297469515,
0.101367712,
0.0117222974,
0.004407967,
0.0147018321,
0.0244342647,
-0.0337028466,
-0.0149915135,
0.0120562697,
0.0115523264,
-0.0057159914,
-0.0402126983,
0.0438334234,
0.0052931053,
0.0372613333,
-0.0125992848,
-0.0302357618,
0.025210673,
-0.0125070857,
-0.0206818189,
0.0196764488,
-0.0494565256,
-0.0329791494,
0.010412395,
-0.0379124284,
-0.0527206995,
0.0302583482,
-0.0272648204,
0.0249995124,
-0.0117355539,
-0.013669135,
-0.0059715975,
0.0320360325,
-0.0042277998,
0.02331255,
0.0153329009,
-0.0296606552,
-0.0464782566,
-0.0030095177,
0.0530310944,
-0.0134403268,
-0.0112251984,
-0.0167845078,
0.0306007192,
0.0263548698,
-0.000632151,
-0.0468278527,
-0.0666323528,
-0.0095645143,
-0.0018967624,
-0.0152553003,
-0.0485653505,
-0.0374008939,
-0.0201524049,
0.0127788605,
0.0962838084,
-0.064386785,
-0.0216663927,
-0.0233684145,
0.0558658987,
0.0515591651,
-0.0900684744,
-0.0004553912,
-0.0429312699,
0.0116986167,
0.0558597222,
0.0101679983,
0.0442529023,
-0.0021600565,
-0.0512751564,
-0.0169731025,
0.0066502606,
-0.0266839601,
-0.0147800604,
-0.0038750714,
-0.0500064678,
-0.0184606761,
0.1179764718,
0.0229641777,
-0.0465989411,
-0.025343379,
-0.0457276516,
0.018623855,
0.0031511267,
-0.0016193248,
-0.033387851,
-0.0304609127,
0.0274978802,
0.0296657421,
-0.0231355857,
-0.0202985108,
-0.0043072277,
-0.0903339684,
0.0108523564,
-0.0019568843,
-0.0014662393,
0.0135860685,
-0.0080705294,
-0.0193054751,
0.0102486406,
-0.0354563259,
-0.0458307527,
0.0085875215,
0.0127905039,
-0.0154209686,
-0.0185854137,
-0.0239919312,
-0.029087564,
-0.0419039391,
0.003460583,
0.07405781,
0.0579089113,
-0.0058849538,
-0.0355430655,
0.032712847,
-0.0137064224,
-0.0023509183,
-0.0068929428,
0.0700623915,
-0.0075406493,
0.0278359186,
-0.0061903833,
0.0396954641,
-0.0287272539,
-0.0026077183,
0.0496425144,
0.033330787,
-0.0343428776,
-0.0402611531,
-0.0166535471,
-0.0178010445,
0.018733928,
0.0668152571,
0.0080813253,
-0.0437900946,
-0.0540863425,
-0.0329947248,
0.0584819168,
-0.057315927,
-0.0474582016,
-0.0137945563,
-0.0140508292,
-0.023287829,
-0.0908061415,
-0.0082219448,
-0.0250847656,
0.031652987,
0.0382661521,
0.0443203337,
-0.0229336452,
-0.0389302522,
-0.0759767741,
-0.0390012637,
-0.0107000479,
0.0385454036,
-0.0375669524,
0.0053525944,
0.001065325,
-0.0027878692,
-0.0031521597,
0.0286160875,
-0.0836751834,
-0.0325847566,
0.0306832902,
0.0134916678,
0.0113605745,
0.0158916768,
-0.0311062839,
-0.0576223955,
0.0676655248,
0.0455472209,
0.009056014,
0.0137732867,
0.0345721021,
-0.0453911871,
-0.0097300922,
0.0382290408,
-0.0230007805,
-0.0091350973,
0.0492647812,
-0.0376399048,
-0.0540086776,
0.0176207051,
0.025933424,
0.0313098133,
0.0247741938,
-0.0302949715,
0.0356963314,
-0.0290346425,
-0.0131208962,
-0.0239049047,
-0.021841865,
-0.0428885296,
0.0285392981,
0.0464869738,
-0.0102921026,
0.0010234512,
0.0133333877,
-0.0231716391,
0.0302988701,
0.0056431065,
-0.0071199839,
-0.0117415516,
0.083387129,
0.0147244846,
0.0102392687,
0.0286604948,
0.0752390102,
-0.0031719364,
0.0471873209,
-0.0076322146,
0.0414340794,
0.0203049351,
-0.0342575833,
0.0314012989,
0.0417231433,
-0.0918960795,
-0.0230503287,
-0.0256769806,
0.0378426425,
0.0368581153,
-0.0114122396,
0.0523933917,
-0.0387869403,
-0.0032199305,
-0.0096815396,
0.030392183,
0.0400599837,
-0.0045537921,
-0.0665752813,
-0.0052532507,
-0.0195034798,
0.0479467586,
0.0886702314,
0.0089590633,
0.0507897846,
0.0098547162,
-0.0301793106,
-0.0308614038,
-0.0008049619,
0.0411548875,
0.0156666543,
0.0114691546,
0.0127841746,
-0.0335736535,
-0.0353165753,
0.0279197339,
0.0016262216,
-0.0099546202,
0.011645685,
-0.0158994161,
0.0679332241,
-0.0352171548,
0.009148147,
-0.0457456075,
0.0380432904,
-0.0012346739,
-0.0475866273,
-0.0181016792,
-4.985588925e-33,
0.0029420247,
-0.0944256261,
-0.0552040637,
0.0239693858,
0.0057688868,
0.030520089,
-0.0247005373,
-0.0094340611,
0.0046409927,
0.0228479039,
-0.0292589627,
0.0460265949,
-0.0065005287,
-0.0016565081,
0.0152621483,
-0.0122372685,
0.0458074808,
-0.0087847505,
-0.0366708599,
0.0047005909,
0.0527773537,
0.0148081305,
0.0431215987,
-0.0824164227,
0.0275759492,
-0.0424710214,
-0.0677435026,
0.0025449232,
-0.0422021933,
0.0307080317,
-0.0167049728,
0.0112752002,
0.0009250587,
0.0024862713,
-0.0055076736,
0.0103244092,
-0.0022454411,
-0.0321854837,
-0.021838218,
0.0063962969,
-0.0204018634,
-0.0809225217,
0.0246763937,
-0.0328962691,
-0.0227055158,
0.0249937326,
0.0457308218,
-0.0137750283,
0.01404119,
-0.0205497332,
-0.0441153757,
0.0240266491,
-0.0200954825,
0.0121242693,
0.0138760842,
0.048254732,
0.0305375401,
-0.0204246324,
-0.0478992499,
0.0108756283,
-0.0174623113,
0.0208422225,
0.0049985261,
-0.018777933,
-0.0131063079,
0.0502791815,
0.0404236764,
0.0294123087,
0.0051406035,
-0.0264211893,
0.0146571994,
-0.0043368028,
0.0609187745,
0.1034111008,
0.0250847023,
-0.0292664841,
0.0122024557,
0.0453868844,
0.0003884612,
-0.0132459551,
0.031674061,
-0.020359287,
-0.0695838705,
-0.0107771093,
0.0050621689,
-0.0826904401,
-0.0276682097,
-0.0339923203,
0.0350344814,
0.0248599369,
-0.0387073457,
-0.0328828879,
0.0037405991,
-0.0568473302,
0.0027527234,
0.0415276475,
-0.0642477348,
-0.0008164083,
0.0120790787,
0.0231094286,
0.025825711,
0.0098144319,
0.0374250934,
0.0232304987,
0.0409352817,
0.0095327888,
0.053385146,
0.042354811,
-0.0918073431,
0.0178533122,
-0.0006605514,
0.0280142762,
0.0146301212,
-0.0153587833,
0.0032093849,
-0.0183671918,
0.0090639014,
0.0158464145,
0.0500187874,
0.0213940274,
-0.0497422218,
0.0097496528,
-0.0107427994,
0.0050720097,
-0.0260958783,
-0.0314449407,
-0.019565247,
-0.0032816343,
0.0351419263,
-0.0738590807,
0.0195118934,
-0.0414896719,
2.502e-7,
0.0288916472,
0.0524370223,
0.0185677484,
-0.0192508362,
0.012171587,
0.0810064077,
0.0199675951,
0.0116589889,
-0.0172131322,
0.0523160547,
-0.0068346839,
-0.0373460278,
0.0711593553,
-0.0006008568,
-0.1144462824,
0.0143348649,
-0.0692505017,
0.0097301686,
-0.0932736993,
-0.0014932866,
0.0536780208,
0.0621772744,
0.0319578312,
-0.0576338209,
-0.0239804275,
-0.0965318978,
0.0205221493,
0.017911166,
-0.0328714848,
-0.0072935261,
0.0295187663,
0.0015839703,
0.0230106544,
0.0100213354,
-0.0326139443,
-0.0068769883,
0.0110282497,
0.0485347956,
0.0040629669,
0.0032450415,
0.0071838261,
-0.0105834603,
0.0113764293,
-0.0599571541,
0.0665000081,
0.0769412667,
0.0065395338,
-0.0540886894,
-0.016513871,
-0.0331534483,
0.0333305858,
-0.0396215841,
-0.0067792647,
0.017269874,
-0.0052389679,
0.0133313779,
0.0173271466,
-0.0148722092,
-0.0189959202,
-0.0623371489,
-0.0097600045,
0.0188852139,
-0.0626719519,
0.0014539405,
0.0280015692,
-0.0677388161,
0.0471088663,
2.614629355e-34,
0.0408115834,
-0.0004437668,
0.0076924553,
0.0280504301,
0.0255544446,
0.0251183528,
0.0417023674,
0.0096510993,
-0.0050402866,
-0.0237764362,
-0.0001965929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15045v1 | SETI: Systematicity Evaluation of Textual Inference | 2023-05-24T11:35:31 | 2023-05-24T11:35:31 | Xiyan Fu, Anette Frank | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose SETI (Systematicity Evaluation of Textual Inference), a novel and
comprehensive benchmark designed for evaluating pre-trained language models
(PLMs) for their systematicity capabilities in the domain of textual inference.
Specifically, SETI offers three different NLI tasks and corresponding datasets
to evaluate various types of systematicity in reasoning processes. In order to
solve these tasks, models are required to perform compositional inference based
on known primitive constituents. We conduct experiments of SETI on six widely
used PLMs. Results show that various PLMs are able to solve unseen
compositional inferences when having encountered the knowledge of how to
combine primitives, with good performance. However, they are considerably
limited when this knowledge is unknown to the model (40-100% points decrease).
Furthermore, we find that PLMs can improve drastically once exposed to crucial
compositional knowledge in minimalistic shots. These findings position SETI as
the first benchmark for measuring the future progress of PLMs in achieving
systematicity generalization in the textual inference. | [
0.0483871996,
0.0864335075,
-0.0190555137,
0.0400480404,
-0.0286525171,
0.0543885864,
-0.0001119263,
-0.0277421921,
-0.0792744979,
-0.0385129862,
-0.0062315371,
-0.0354743749,
0.0211558416,
0.0219627302,
0.0389570519,
-0.0176189542,
0.0460440665,
-0.0171807837,
-0.0020765432,
0.0149235623,
0.001773331,
0.0130060418,
0.0055789151,
0.0138095384,
-0.0042225677,
0.009148133,
-0.0152654573,
-0.0016581183,
0.0062404023,
-0.014482093,
-0.0126938717,
0.0408328325,
0.0247134175,
0.0106282216,
0.0000020112,
-0.0653910935,
0.0012989768,
-0.0114759486,
-0.0077126659,
-0.0000259567,
0.0552934445,
-0.0229669437,
0.0360312946,
-0.0103468746,
-0.028604215,
-0.0134826247,
0.0425656736,
0.0369266942,
0.0142018246,
0.0602600984,
-0.0217475444,
-0.0200198498,
-0.0309131257,
-0.0215981919,
-0.0090641491,
-0.0133986324,
0.0289324708,
0.0048873965,
-0.0235150214,
-0.0038370162,
0.0159832984,
0.0328585766,
0.0400124975,
0.0389172994,
-0.0365018807,
0.0225553047,
-0.0600934215,
-0.041835092,
0.0323885828,
0.0728501156,
0.0165751334,
-0.0522174314,
-0.0307067782,
-0.0506758541,
-0.0117748538,
-0.0103370696,
0.0005169004,
0.045143906,
-0.034005519,
0.0082469638,
0.052537363,
0.0235635173,
0.052145768,
0.0355038047,
-0.0515919924,
0.0890468657,
0.0261646863,
-0.0221515074,
0.0190390423,
0.0073982757,
-0.0168938227,
-0.0296823699,
-0.0453818999,
0.0167359281,
0.0054277889,
0.0131973373,
-0.0253297146,
-0.0107360352,
0.0074318456,
-0.036530368,
0.0653261393,
0.0305984393,
0.0023154302,
0.0667620078,
-0.0211996827,
0.0303421654,
-0.0195667967,
0.017664481,
-0.035208825,
-0.0440205224,
0.0031899964,
0.0216077287,
-0.0206288639,
0.0285318661,
0.014600141,
-0.048313465,
-0.0308790337,
0.0146171385,
0.0123469383,
0.0128096687,
-0.0292927288,
-0.02251729,
-0.0346367583,
-0.0224150047,
-0.035281159,
-0.0277232174,
-0.0670773312,
0.0628626198,
-0.0328557193,
-0.0355932824,
-0.0101672541,
0.0180435497,
0.0074148108,
-0.0220371932,
0.0292181503,
0.024968598,
0.0346936993,
-0.0367936753,
-0.0256552603,
-0.0136088906,
0.0038146621,
-0.0851411521,
-0.0275766384,
-0.0476586781,
0.0675540194,
-0.0030361351,
-0.0278722197,
-0.0145698907,
-0.0064835418,
0.0087115653,
-0.0367405303,
0.070281066,
0.0058219042,
-0.0019895879,
-0.0237457529,
-0.009107668,
-0.0314782746,
0.0772329345,
0.010093526,
0.0162011702,
0.0142376479,
0.025182331,
-0.021989191,
0.0109902229,
0.0049793506,
-0.0345967487,
0.0090509355,
0.026848074,
-0.031617526,
-0.0011737129,
-0.0127354385,
0.0541264005,
-0.035354048,
-0.0101249609,
0.0418409556,
0.0132098803,
0.0375165753,
0.0202784743,
0.1072829515,
-0.0268577989,
0.0247123726,
0.0119210593,
-0.077790685,
-0.0089309514,
-0.0734759718,
0.0028333087,
0.0231214762,
0.0114447307,
-0.0311482213,
-0.0619149208,
-0.0259510167,
-0.0343165323,
-0.0315949954,
0.0003626056,
0.0765214115,
0.0384345204,
-0.0056024594,
0.0140824001,
0.045996841,
-0.0623882748,
-0.0133544821,
0.0039491407,
0.05184187,
0.0240426641,
0.0360901542,
-0.0315052606,
-0.0133453347,
0.0398058519,
0.0081784166,
0.0257250089,
0.0169157479,
0.0044958536,
0.0582077913,
-0.0265247617,
0.0202644616,
-0.0446622856,
0.0386992693,
0.0145560401,
0.0424464792,
0.0002451316,
0.0330650695,
-0.0754349083,
0.0181624107,
0.0547434539,
-0.0280974656,
-0.0167598035,
-0.0068020686,
0.0175306592,
0.0129998727,
-0.0333347172,
-0.0139173325,
0.0280881282,
0.0001414976,
-0.0250475742,
-0.011824212,
0.0340290144,
-0.0455919988,
-0.0692405999,
0.0092271324,
-0.0497602224,
-0.0274314731,
0.0157574564,
-0.0532776527,
-0.01484989,
0.0269662756,
0.011554691,
0.0078299018,
-0.0713050961,
0.0134524284,
0.007285485,
-0.0025560495,
0.0017296467,
0.0926212296,
0.004771241,
0.0342869088,
0.0248274505,
0.0271197408,
0.0224428251,
0.0000610303,
-0.0680121183,
-0.0181713551,
-0.0301826615,
-0.0358571336,
0.0005206173,
-0.014226079,
-0.0326980092,
-0.0073375474,
-0.0586220473,
0.0182650443,
-0.0267718192,
0.0228403751,
0.0270426795,
0.0326237604,
-0.0018267663,
0.0096373139,
0.0059591262,
0.0066794488,
-0.0048383977,
0.0314461626,
0.0581333078,
0.0096560549,
0.0239756666,
-0.0668608472,
-0.0091594663,
-0.042096559,
0.088311851,
-0.00136645,
0.0364982449,
-0.0122906836,
0.0009524835,
-0.0604799874,
0.0276878551,
-0.0380213298,
-0.0434700027,
0.0037122543,
-0.0320548862,
0.019101968,
0.0690463856,
-0.0094570247,
-0.0132727316,
0.0515943803,
-0.004521715,
-0.0214273352,
0.0303437654,
-0.0348367877,
0.0040930505,
0.0001657127,
-0.0258445852,
0.0086632855,
0.0447168648,
-0.0178547297,
-0.0196200591,
-0.0442374274,
0.0253658835,
-0.0289808679,
0.0001814083,
-0.0027384104,
-0.0193523392,
0.0122878402,
0.0338919088,
-0.0188018531,
-0.0276324749,
0.0706260577,
-0.0648883358,
0.0038886359,
-0.0194551591,
-0.0264574178,
-0.0656367242,
0.0933301225,
0.0183538739,
-0.0110089667,
0.0117943622,
0.018763857,
-0.0440475643,
0.0107753575,
0.0732989684,
0.0035438568,
0.0166783426,
-0.0533570014,
0.0293825828,
-0.018826196,
-0.028627092,
-0.0423016138,
-0.0585036241,
-0.033471562,
-0.0140566444,
0.0314310342,
0.0042163571,
-0.0085385768,
0.0097710574,
-0.0194847193,
0.0284214281,
0.0083435597,
0.0043996084,
-0.0235966556,
-0.0169164538,
0.0300125834,
-0.0145343076,
0.0297564231,
-0.0293351989,
0.041475717,
0.0372416601,
-0.0284904689,
0.0126956869,
-0.0488461033,
0.0192629937,
-0.0034782558,
-0.0000363021,
-0.0197768044,
0.0265296251,
0.0379768386,
-0.0470139086,
-0.0199134909,
0.1180283278,
0.0275399275,
-0.0404624119,
0.0052875225,
0.0115363961,
0.0026970075,
-0.011383309,
-0.0105583798,
-0.1000104845,
-0.030102659,
0.0205061026,
-0.0444779471,
-0.0157179516,
-0.0337719172,
-0.0248577017,
-0.1153920442,
0.0009280263,
-0.0216569342,
-0.0481743366,
-0.018510988,
-0.0350399353,
0.0287432428,
-0.0045247641,
-0.0295255985,
0.0176518746,
-0.0172289424,
0.012372829,
-0.0303208567,
-0.0738133341,
-0.0399518125,
0.0258645695,
-0.0322320759,
-0.0053304825,
0.0158936549,
0.0094039273,
0.0136243394,
-0.0195400398,
0.0483866706,
-0.0873583406,
-0.0160762258,
0.0130027067,
0.0446943641,
-0.0502451919,
0.0145365624,
0.0007702323,
0.0308174826,
-0.033679381,
-0.0203041974,
0.0023124602,
0.0127398465,
-0.0063480604,
-0.049741853,
-0.022893412,
0.0451448783,
-0.0204415955,
0.1019252464,
0.0613770969,
-0.0032183968,
-0.0280844048,
-0.0193679314,
-0.0446506292,
-0.0243690368,
0.0005565664,
0.03696182,
0.0577095486,
-0.0405360796,
-0.0633638576,
-0.0481186919,
0.0503340028,
0.0373767167,
-0.0393044613,
0.000032913,
-0.0035755525,
-0.0420484804,
-0.0360021926,
0.0434188731,
-0.0231340975,
0.0102942185,
-0.0125219719,
0.0170829426,
0.0233859308,
0.0051026498,
-0.0229252651,
-0.0024739874,
-0.0947161391,
-0.0692585111,
-0.0226171575,
0.0769940466,
0.0179216601,
0.0370828323,
-0.0490896925,
-0.013692609,
0.0068638325,
-0.0015722391,
0.0103631346,
0.0247897599,
0.0481778234,
-0.0116426898,
0.0426138267,
0.0559223555,
-0.0576700941,
0.0290277041,
0.0412312113,
0.0301326141,
0.0402422696,
-0.0072844536,
0.0329409577,
-0.0024178093,
0.0378741063,
0.0035790016,
-0.0261006542,
-0.0148258153,
0.0301939044,
-0.0495354421,
-0.0558999777,
-0.0422791503,
0.0545270219,
0.0229837243,
0.0603802353,
-0.0376981422,
-0.0187709294,
-0.0013005207,
0.0424020924,
-0.0128856059,
0.0003350539,
0.0630020052,
0.0134250764,
0.0117792459,
-0.0335818455,
-0.0579071939,
0.0157845709,
-0.064406395,
0.0277721863,
-0.0265685488,
0.0180984885,
0.0578554869,
0.0067972769,
-0.0415873006,
0.0064251083,
-0.068964012,
-0.0382620655,
-0.017354425,
-0.0232588314,
0.0420955047,
-0.0345428064,
0.01734378,
-0.0146571472,
0.0028429579,
0.0083634891,
0.0407538675,
0.0169922709,
-0.0194950402,
0.0310510844,
0.0169404708,
-0.0130786747,
0.0269117579,
0.0535726249,
-0.0034895651,
0.0448276214,
0.0225329697,
0.0331599079,
-0.0208445154,
-0.0181681346,
-0.0295451526,
0.0660775527,
-0.0209377445,
0.0348659195,
-0.0434978865,
-0.0627557933,
-0.0127845202,
0.0373729393,
-0.0172253437,
0.0216231719,
0.0162960868,
0.0809264183,
0.0356692262,
-0.0004817156,
0.0002128593,
-0.0340379104,
0.0091233002,
0.0196508802,
-0.0438795947,
-6.665796469e-33,
-0.0156525057,
-0.0018382465,
0.0129672932,
-0.0225283541,
-0.0021532422,
0.0024474168,
-0.0374167562,
-0.0123349847,
-0.0435846075,
0.0105908802,
0.0139115248,
0.0319465324,
-0.0104295667,
0.0141087687,
-0.030018935,
0.002007606,
-0.002495779,
0.0550300963,
-0.0640503168,
-0.0180794764,
-0.0018219532,
0.0080353171,
0.055188939,
0.0069441968,
-0.0089850053,
-0.0049224431,
-0.0060418248,
0.0201819148,
-0.0572067238,
0.0474868678,
-0.0035580299,
0.008930333,
0.0347079299,
0.0554206744,
0.0188875441,
0.0290935822,
-0.0693188086,
-0.0446981229,
0.0558569096,
-0.0285286587,
-0.0810302049,
-0.0004455685,
0.0193048622,
-0.0031199991,
0.0237980504,
-0.0443868302,
0.0316878445,
-0.0181481913,
0.0296241902,
-0.0569479167,
-0.0562242679,
0.0511260852,
-0.0028136056,
0.0057646488,
-0.0070634536,
0.0333663151,
0.0067081368,
0.0305931084,
-0.0216571782,
0.0019817059,
0.0049652327,
0.002890253,
0.0088355141,
-0.0230650809,
0.0071168961,
0.0489444286,
-0.0318397544,
0.0174342785,
-0.0672504529,
0.0078809531,
0.0339283794,
0.0704390705,
0.0217322391,
0.0567986146,
0.0475182347,
0.0605627522,
-0.0702327341,
0.0019675873,
-0.0014422802,
0.0523781143,
0.0240281969,
-0.0124147218,
-0.0545461439,
-0.0113518527,
-0.0763370916,
-0.0190627109,
-0.0443656035,
-0.0193970166,
0.0372069515,
-0.0028058114,
-0.0240181293,
-0.0352049023,
0.0196926892,
-0.0502121374,
0.0069244914,
0.0290561169,
-0.0316525735,
-0.0120803965,
0.0013764822,
0.061112307,
-0.0372389406,
-0.0533061139,
0.027391078,
0.008937438,
0.0120489849,
-0.0072335494,
0.0503397696,
0.0131236967,
-0.0278900843,
-0.0278288685,
-0.0376898907,
-0.0505311973,
-0.027521288,
0.0222384129,
0.0584550351,
0.0651537701,
-0.0076133083,
0.0363267437,
-0.020169476,
0.0127913654,
-0.0486497544,
0.0133639462,
0.0351877399,
0.0232474543,
-0.0190962553,
-0.0217401609,
-0.0209691525,
-0.011078177,
0.0538308769,
-0.0324585438,
-0.0130060939,
0.0488865077,
2.783e-7,
0.0890254453,
0.0175550524,
0.0117940027,
0.063960366,
-0.0094137732,
-0.0023478433,
-0.0168253109,
-0.0010345788,
0.0122501096,
-0.0031890785,
0.0550154671,
0.0564079471,
0.0384968147,
0.0291000493,
-0.0611646101,
0.0273797363,
-0.07522811,
-0.0496307127,
-0.0582067408,
-0.0266341325,
0.061437849,
0.1100033596,
0.035282556,
0.0235994458,
-0.0092514036,
-0.0647342801,
0.0597531982,
-0.0302786883,
-0.0015383607,
0.0190717429,
-0.0046319542,
0.0271530077,
0.0068360576,
0.0173737034,
0.0136704948,
0.0464434288,
0.0001576465,
0.0452694446,
-0.0019343264,
-0.0044626938,
-0.0170080047,
-0.0365682282,
0.014155278,
-0.0627642125,
0.117734164,
-0.0701773018,
-0.0281350017,
-0.0086927665,
-0.0469586179,
-0.0032831458,
0.0489751026,
0.0183722191,
-0.0151346773,
0.0413329005,
0.0409728736,
-0.0168104786,
-0.0305384118,
-0.107108824,
-0.0355683826,
0.0119730262,
-0.0288989525,
-0.024586156,
-0.0215029251,
-0.0522199497,
0.043963775,
-0.0463853814,
0.0276826676,
2.556319555e-34,
0.0471497141,
-0.0257136058,
0.0115884496,
0.005094952,
0.0836194903,
-0.0079042278,
-0.0076124882,
0.0032041771,
-0.003583492,
-0.0974100158,
-0.003874022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15044v1 | Is Summary Useful or Not? An Extrinsic Human Evaluation of Text Summaries on Downstream Tasks | 2023-05-24T11:34:39 | 2023-05-24T11:34:39 | Xiao Pu, Mingqi Gao, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Research on automated text summarization relies heavily on human and
automatic evaluation. While recent work on human evaluation mainly adopted
intrinsic evaluation methods, judging the generic quality of text summaries,
e.g. informativeness and coherence, our work focuses on evaluating the
usefulness of text summaries with extrinsic methods. We carefully design three
different downstream tasks for extrinsic human evaluation of summaries, i.e.,
question answering, text classification and text similarity assessment. We
carry out experiments using system rankings and user behavior data to evaluate
the performance of different summarization models. We find summaries are
particularly useful in tasks that rely on an overall judgment of the text,
while being less effective for question answering tasks. The results show that
summaries generated by fine-tuned models lead to higher consistency in
usefulness across all three tasks, as rankings of fine-tuned summarization
systems are close across downstream tasks according to the proposed extrinsic
metrics. Summaries generated by models in the zero-shot setting, however, are
found to be biased towards the text classification and similarity assessment
tasks, due to its general and less detailed summary style. We further evaluate
the correlation of 14 intrinsic automatic metrics with human criteria and show
that intrinsic automatic metrics perform well in evaluating the usefulness of
summaries in the question-answering task, but are less effective in the other
two tasks. This highlights the limitations of relying solely on intrinsic
automatic metrics in evaluating the performance and usefulness of summaries. | [
0.0530139133,
-0.0459636822,
0.0081473384,
-0.0209161025,
-0.006082234,
0.0334628895,
-0.0370921567,
-0.0050611123,
-0.0249414761,
-0.0352737196,
-0.0193847902,
-0.0077874861,
0.0367636979,
-0.0316470377,
0.0070525324,
-0.1000592187,
0.0154798515,
0.001808501,
0.0109411487,
0.0179474894,
0.0407521576,
-0.0174143631,
0.0159844812,
0.0287299082,
0.0451355167,
0.0242718402,
0.0170365609,
0.0003985298,
0.0644906238,
-0.0066635134,
0.0093798004,
0.0287748091,
-0.0005162543,
-0.0306350645,
0.0000017381,
-0.0539132245,
0.0245544091,
-0.0147225624,
0.0047161421,
0.0244682766,
0.0329891555,
0.0151887992,
0.053709656,
0.0109523376,
-0.0123394923,
0.0364272483,
-0.0042257058,
0.0188309234,
0.0859252885,
0.0246584248,
-0.0038349447,
-0.031173436,
-0.0043139323,
-0.0002436014,
-0.0029546057,
-0.0147329336,
-0.0166102573,
0.0347026624,
0.0230351258,
0.0065471758,
0.0238564536,
0.0232217647,
0.0041739526,
0.0085757691,
0.0368438885,
0.0292586312,
-0.037832167,
-0.0012195174,
0.0222214703,
0.0610845946,
0.0171590541,
-0.0145314075,
0.0145003265,
0.007826725,
0.0275289863,
0.0122138811,
-0.0750750825,
0.0144424429,
-0.0236413628,
-0.0062275715,
-0.0183757078,
0.0818619728,
-0.031994544,
0.025907563,
0.0182865504,
0.0224831682,
-0.006658169,
-0.0358872488,
-0.022001503,
0.0184392594,
-0.032347329,
-0.0659604371,
0.014908649,
0.0688534528,
-0.0062101441,
-0.0212557111,
-0.0192920044,
-0.0569780208,
0.0413385294,
-0.0613020919,
0.0207814481,
0.0174506381,
0.0384966582,
0.0605248809,
-0.0357340612,
0.0592199154,
0.0524069555,
0.026114326,
-0.0747042298,
-0.0019870296,
-0.0406128652,
0.0002791439,
-0.0224818476,
0.0721249431,
-0.0009713252,
-0.0303833522,
-0.0478488915,
0.0224398952,
0.0103540914,
-0.0192849673,
0.0040148636,
0.031555824,
0.0198162515,
0.0166044049,
-0.0365419537,
-0.0198570713,
-0.0982494727,
-0.0158859193,
0.0238831602,
0.0333527699,
0.0108957049,
0.0207279213,
0.0016017486,
0.0113696363,
0.0214527212,
0.0248490199,
-0.0093094762,
-0.0328440666,
0.0071921325,
-0.0237646345,
0.0085562011,
-0.0353421308,
-0.046713423,
-0.058649987,
-0.0094486773,
0.0465331674,
-0.0302052274,
0.0355530716,
-0.0125157451,
0.0526672751,
-0.043144498,
-0.0056834472,
0.006918068,
0.0383956321,
0.0530622266,
0.0050317049,
-0.0046959007,
0.030572854,
0.0284313485,
0.0551914237,
0.0451861396,
0.0233222917,
0.0334793627,
0.0124896895,
-0.0133863268,
0.0028417581,
0.0124418512,
0.0341447741,
-0.0693788677,
0.0008731093,
0.0059783198,
0.0645586923,
-0.041588679,
0.0178814009,
0.0619017705,
0.0856372863,
0.0233881604,
0.0116342111,
0.0229413304,
0.0356250107,
0.0490172505,
0.0767844394,
0.0044928859,
0.0565556772,
-0.0412662588,
0.0478277206,
0.0897797644,
0.0242681913,
-0.0392238498,
-0.0781965032,
-0.0068995925,
0.0176836681,
0.0232633129,
0.020026844,
0.0184739511,
0.016559219,
-0.0116718998,
0.0175482538,
-0.0027087708,
-0.0724965334,
0.0051196986,
-0.0331850238,
0.034956459,
0.0619420633,
0.0279523432,
-0.0311680883,
-0.0066876276,
0.0073766457,
-0.0009985627,
-0.0002898304,
0.0368160717,
-0.0140844826,
-0.020373445,
-0.0456057861,
-0.0262431186,
-0.0009880856,
-0.0072238808,
-0.0194185935,
0.0106736049,
-0.0074021672,
0.0472420715,
-0.0563778803,
-0.0638842136,
0.0295451954,
0.0135953147,
0.0029877839,
-0.008136671,
-0.01470125,
-0.0174262561,
0.037268661,
-0.0028503072,
0.0364316218,
0.007423515,
-0.0200118143,
-0.0285458714,
0.0020082947,
-0.0257085096,
-0.0061664726,
0.0044976841,
-0.0693085492,
0.0128628369,
0.0394060463,
-0.000292253,
-0.0460460484,
0.0106180003,
-0.0879364386,
-0.0297444128,
-0.0431634709,
0.0148509415,
-0.0214239918,
-0.0279978961,
-0.0448307618,
0.078893654,
0.0123163899,
0.0227012113,
0.0352030471,
-0.0657670274,
0.0214665923,
-0.0249402281,
-0.0272231102,
-0.0369362123,
0.0034342958,
0.0192981008,
0.0749530941,
-0.0118130716,
-0.0457395501,
-0.0034045703,
-0.1225707531,
0.0105721019,
-0.0417213067,
0.0225360505,
0.0673399493,
0.0147386286,
-0.0181852765,
-0.0155045418,
-0.0508246608,
-0.0346731991,
0.0152741801,
0.0256697014,
0.0476910807,
0.0288982559,
0.0447356775,
-0.0617822222,
-0.0380230322,
0.0014081413,
0.0494745858,
0.038036298,
0.0107331909,
-0.0429571532,
0.0167982001,
-0.0361085273,
-0.0576583594,
0.0138124758,
-0.0093328543,
-0.0045845988,
0.0295869634,
0.0394993946,
0.053260494,
0.0685375854,
-0.0158849657,
0.0310623795,
0.0350678116,
-0.0306193959,
-0.0257845055,
-0.041562669,
0.0228569843,
0.0413296074,
-0.0295907129,
0.0514112599,
0.0205141157,
0.0122859459,
0.0018963697,
-0.0382670164,
0.0449885987,
-0.0402401239,
-0.0149050318,
-0.0921443179,
-0.0259456336,
-0.0107408157,
0.0250450149,
-0.0292026568,
-0.0004747723,
0.07157363,
-0.0100052683,
0.0215927996,
-0.0585159734,
-0.0236458778,
-0.0606225654,
0.0215153378,
0.0066242306,
0.0271400176,
-0.0089127952,
-0.0028723015,
-0.0182241071,
-0.0269994717,
0.0553054921,
-0.0296528246,
0.061046835,
-0.0158990305,
-0.0088820392,
-0.0142198345,
-0.0341218933,
-0.0109938458,
-0.0538774058,
-0.0042043808,
0.0284407195,
0.0121541396,
0.0195080675,
-0.0175610352,
0.0411330797,
0.0827782899,
0.0235163122,
-0.0502589308,
-0.0300354809,
0.0075011146,
0.0637467578,
0.0799384341,
-0.004357019,
0.0373033993,
-0.0407253876,
0.034155231,
0.03447951,
0.0167223793,
-0.030604437,
0.0248339027,
-0.0380324423,
-0.0014083894,
-0.0697716996,
-0.0035045245,
0.0211550631,
0.0596653819,
-0.0272444375,
0.0123626236,
0.098255977,
0.020070076,
-0.0336161368,
-0.0321983807,
-0.0077770329,
0.0176721066,
0.0163321123,
0.0034785846,
-0.0246612635,
-0.0195194297,
-0.0053201104,
0.0358437672,
0.0010510203,
-0.0179017931,
0.0162304137,
-0.0783534348,
-0.0099158036,
-0.0245788526,
-0.0589878559,
-0.0040607741,
-0.0458924808,
0.0343747623,
-0.0105511453,
-0.033123605,
0.021153897,
-0.0430674218,
0.0220387969,
0.0195255298,
-0.0572144464,
0.037288066,
-0.0056712194,
-0.0444021113,
-0.0512349792,
0.0718881264,
0.0374873504,
-0.0115247481,
-0.0077375281,
0.0171350986,
-0.059439335,
0.0274107903,
0.0397855416,
0.0735301003,
-0.0042272508,
0.0426930338,
-0.0785571262,
0.009466188,
0.0333632231,
0.0190197714,
0.016490709,
0.0057863523,
0.0174848679,
-0.0273212343,
-0.0825640708,
0.041851934,
-0.0445467047,
0.0816725269,
0.0581829287,
-0.0333310179,
-0.043863263,
-0.0105964169,
0.0015690856,
-0.0819833055,
-0.0301708933,
-0.0089776954,
0.0059560006,
-0.0147563173,
-0.0987085178,
-0.0731335059,
0.0112869972,
-0.0278338287,
-0.0170710813,
0.0053620934,
-0.0212690383,
0.0159856305,
-0.0206954908,
-0.020019535,
0.0107320165,
0.0135961724,
-0.0176102165,
0.0135194631,
0.0484632365,
-0.0348648764,
-0.0249619856,
0.0195549298,
-0.0415268391,
-0.0289808791,
-0.0384140536,
0.0444419459,
0.0204998236,
0.0196368415,
-0.0016083603,
-0.027727969,
0.0610693954,
0.0028296604,
-0.0037108914,
0.0323539823,
-0.0138963079,
0.0278313756,
-0.0141586065,
0.00062475,
-0.0701349378,
0.0349261574,
-0.032573346,
0.0245477837,
-0.0166628361,
-0.0588229261,
0.0103581008,
0.0392927229,
0.0124252299,
-0.0012337653,
-0.0163970478,
0.014053395,
-0.035634093,
-0.0111692874,
-0.022145398,
-0.0074891727,
0.0339894444,
-0.0213043522,
0.0295818951,
-0.0150049431,
0.0763763338,
0.0073667639,
0.0101510081,
-0.0445353575,
-0.0139903184,
-0.0363864228,
0.0012187071,
-0.0629111826,
-0.0038612746,
-0.0672128648,
-0.0552417338,
-0.0122944405,
0.019211404,
-0.0061630881,
0.0186621081,
0.0247947928,
0.0110288849,
0.0108529776,
0.0860632211,
-0.0936719254,
-0.0019929048,
-0.0516869836,
-0.0270778611,
0.0219961852,
-0.0298864711,
0.0514804237,
0.0299231932,
-0.0187909026,
-0.0111379633,
0.01065253,
-0.0006610921,
-0.0013581181,
-0.0535293892,
0.0521212816,
0.0106675113,
-0.0200924072,
0.0632508099,
-0.0703807771,
-0.0275265295,
0.0059751403,
-0.0468103141,
-0.0189385116,
-0.012580554,
-0.0330340341,
0.0302542467,
0.0079523595,
-0.0406827517,
-0.0780078471,
-0.0045700315,
0.0264497902,
0.0224557314,
0.0333639905,
-0.0206486136,
0.0604977868,
0.0351097174,
-0.0029336608,
0.0012689501,
-0.06271559,
-0.0271780565,
-0.0638019294,
0.0501301885,
-0.0372535512,
-5.801704898e-33,
-0.0248537511,
-0.0202633515,
-0.0240978859,
0.0262949783,
-0.0255619027,
-0.0116459168,
-0.0442164317,
0.005467881,
-0.0067688855,
0.0151797086,
-0.0060270485,
-0.0005569084,
-0.0021688035,
-0.0022083886,
0.008348465,
-0.0127572529,
0.0230307095,
0.0001175656,
-0.0743440762,
0.032530304,
0.0343308672,
-0.0178930759,
0.0083713252,
-0.0124972127,
0.0243729707,
-0.0355951115,
0.0008469108,
-0.0119332839,
0.0410519652,
0.049993787,
0.0175805185,
0.0274538379,
0.0527998172,
-0.045301944,
-0.041043818,
0.0477696471,
-0.0653985813,
-0.0452540964,
0.0402593315,
-0.0707121491,
-0.0681894794,
-0.0207025129,
0.0487655587,
-0.0140765393,
-0.0176395532,
-0.0431630351,
0.0870808437,
-0.0220647976,
0.0006320901,
-0.0786300153,
-0.0064661847,
0.0263931248,
-0.0351539366,
-0.0366305038,
-0.011649359,
0.0798662826,
-0.0092600966,
0.0259214137,
-0.0143122636,
0.0471472368,
-0.0016113421,
0.012439277,
0.0358415246,
0.0240216628,
-0.0058580502,
0.0450099558,
-0.0014463261,
0.002719529,
-0.0494676493,
-0.0123827262,
-0.0080156131,
-0.0042113592,
0.0721252784,
0.0282204691,
0.0560119189,
0.0228246097,
-0.0253790636,
0.1071367413,
-0.0273200274,
0.0121191442,
0.0273255315,
-0.0046412605,
-0.0510487184,
-0.0081705973,
-0.0471195281,
0.0308774728,
-0.0415216163,
-0.0320912339,
-0.0126245059,
-0.0027474831,
-0.0138477748,
-0.0353164934,
-0.016301658,
-0.0074950317,
0.0552417822,
0.0093376823,
-0.0222918782,
0.0335935131,
0.0253103953,
-0.0272644181,
-0.0202493239,
0.0585826226,
-0.0010062075,
0.0425753705,
-0.0013313125,
-0.0010866233,
0.0420293249,
-0.0194654744,
-0.0049822358,
0.0007310117,
0.0154795256,
0.0122918729,
-0.0485124812,
-0.0335165784,
-0.0186611079,
0.0351212658,
-0.0116357142,
0.0531609692,
-0.0281935781,
-0.0081090098,
-0.0396568254,
-0.0157418698,
0.0478630774,
0.0049701403,
0.0049868836,
0.0284336973,
-0.0280613787,
0.0249075796,
0.0055009504,
-0.018093951,
-0.0156334359,
0.024387382,
2.409e-7,
0.0463236272,
0.0227086712,
0.0506295189,
-0.0045896601,
-0.026772948,
0.0300831627,
0.0156973917,
0.0152689535,
0.0432979763,
-0.0076544047,
0.0355548263,
0.0321531631,
0.0328167155,
0.0244171359,
-0.0833659619,
-0.0196336098,
-0.0875591636,
-0.0535833128,
-0.0008386484,
0.00746023,
0.072950311,
-0.0090859216,
-0.0155319404,
0.0156230703,
-0.039400734,
-0.0472309552,
0.0280367695,
-0.0184761081,
-0.0076024365,
0.0119345281,
0.0459174179,
0.0082336143,
0.0011626357,
0.005829812,
0.0037545657,
-0.009569264,
0.1065291837,
0.0087811826,
0.0105250366,
-0.0374078341,
-0.0123606529,
-0.0142426053,
0.0490338616,
-0.0325737447,
0.059086863,
-0.0568879135,
0.0012878111,
-0.0178841371,
-0.0348705873,
0.0167330299,
0.0099189747,
-0.001418599,
-0.0314348638,
0.034224093,
-0.0084667271,
0.0108363414,
0.0133273406,
-0.0668541268,
-0.0571871921,
0.0414717235,
-0.0126717202,
-0.0371414311,
-0.0576956943,
-0.0014325508,
-0.0096934233,
-0.0812777057,
-0.0093274573,
1.772490394e-34,
0.0621414222,
0.0039096023,
-0.0112940241,
-0.043267943,
0.0212982222,
-0.0107083516,
-0.0455927327,
-0.0147784604,
0.0352990925,
-0.0600275211,
0.0003619597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15041v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15041v1 | Generating Faithful Synthetic Data with Large Language Models: A Case Study in Computational Social Science | 2023-05-24T11:27:59 | 2023-05-24T11:27:59 | Veniamin Veselovsky, Manoel Horta Ribeiro, Akhil Arora, Martin Josifoski, Ashton Anderson, Robert West | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have democratized synthetic data generation,
which in turn has the potential to simplify and broaden a wide gamut of NLP
tasks. Here, we tackle a pervasive problem in synthetic data generation: its
generative distribution often differs from the distribution of real-world data
researchers care about (in other words, it is unfaithful). In a case study on
sarcasm detection, we study three strategies to increase the faithfulness of
synthetic data: grounding, filtering, and taxonomy-based generation. We
evaluate these strategies using the performance of classifiers trained with
generated synthetic data on real-world data. While all three strategies improve
the performance of classifiers, we find that grounding works best for the task
at hand. As synthetic data generation plays an ever-increasing role in NLP
research, we expect this work to be a stepping stone in improving its utility.
We conclude this paper with some recommendations on how to generate
high(er)-fidelity synthetic data for specific tasks. | [
0.0749833286,
0.0674778372,
-0.0486636199,
0.0562507361,
-0.0362901688,
0.0080562569,
-0.002674242,
0.0319229923,
0.0317487977,
-0.0858556256,
0.0229307339,
-0.0123780584,
-0.0364071243,
0.0511072427,
0.0109622991,
-0.0108409952,
0.0259286296,
0.0282705184,
-0.026596928,
-0.036871288,
0.0069936486,
0.036823459,
0.0228216555,
0.0307863038,
-0.0347937942,
0.0229245964,
0.0400030017,
0.021873286,
0.0022378571,
-0.0185649842,
0.0352030285,
0.0479036383,
-0.0040191114,
0.030364586,
0.0000017586,
-0.0486577675,
0.0038485578,
-0.0264417324,
-0.0321990028,
-0.0176834185,
0.0894814581,
-0.0313278325,
-0.027555123,
0.0365854539,
-0.081051439,
-0.0061258059,
0.0422194637,
0.0016911563,
0.0471775196,
0.0839952826,
-0.0169720277,
-0.0465603806,
-0.0028950784,
0.0228517316,
0.01515128,
0.0157697834,
0.0505897999,
0.0239380486,
-0.0254129544,
0.0301783364,
-0.0371061265,
-0.0176507253,
-0.0206016339,
0.0177341104,
0.0222510099,
0.0325221308,
-0.03726485,
-0.0165339969,
0.003288551,
0.0577311367,
-0.0011622661,
-0.0738439709,
-0.0058219461,
0.0088099595,
-0.0071120844,
-0.007376628,
-0.0036360775,
0.0330017544,
-0.0237987395,
0.0522278808,
0.0456411503,
0.0077902982,
0.0175286606,
0.0460049175,
0.0140192257,
0.0202082116,
0.0112737715,
-0.0329096019,
-0.0094005028,
0.0235760137,
-0.0499466434,
-0.040164765,
0.0048608766,
0.0051238569,
0.0089578312,
0.0325981565,
-0.0678547695,
-0.03499946,
0.0295706037,
-0.0760674253,
-0.0089562563,
0.0271131843,
0.0159831233,
0.0294285361,
-0.027772015,
-0.0182701722,
-0.0201653056,
0.0307921413,
-0.0194695555,
-0.0502485149,
-0.0672507212,
0.0169826634,
-0.0334589966,
0.0111816945,
-0.055992119,
0.0059298445,
-0.043844182,
0.0332685038,
-0.0304890145,
-0.0005267062,
0.0098025771,
0.0354133397,
-0.038865421,
0.0183136631,
-0.0315260552,
-0.0508471951,
-0.0330512039,
0.0333699696,
-0.0423703529,
-0.0703050494,
0.0124798892,
0.0200759489,
0.0222311392,
-0.0111834658,
0.0531661734,
0.0175988823,
0.0598921403,
-0.0352430083,
-0.0725957155,
-0.0120734107,
-0.0566047877,
-0.0381003916,
0.0164146498,
-0.0567173772,
0.028002955,
0.0112965554,
-0.013866446,
-0.0272390619,
0.0131110083,
0.0024487632,
-0.0511308424,
0.0847942084,
-0.0781006217,
-0.0118923271,
-0.000685091,
-0.0094200289,
-0.0118516358,
0.0585685857,
0.0360491946,
-0.0089724381,
0.0683289394,
-0.0018972658,
0.008182588,
0.0181755088,
0.0305297803,
-0.0010840505,
-0.0490797944,
-0.0000382811,
-0.038900815,
-0.0133575248,
0.0303915348,
0.0518893413,
-0.0267310292,
0.0071590063,
0.0453982837,
0.0116811758,
-0.0244147722,
0.0678941086,
0.0992888361,
0.0104104057,
-0.0218609683,
-0.0051343748,
-0.0120547116,
-0.0352698974,
-0.053342849,
-0.0172345135,
-0.0511013903,
0.0368663035,
-0.0204641204,
-0.0335835703,
-0.0397838615,
-0.007878988,
0.0099537335,
-0.0176098309,
0.0256694835,
0.0516270511,
-0.0344234668,
0.0222421456,
0.0609491952,
-0.0482565016,
-0.0078058876,
-0.0101569425,
0.010302945,
0.0865939409,
0.0347960815,
0.0098388577,
-0.0210150015,
-0.0111152185,
-0.0239580348,
0.0663457215,
0.015862396,
-0.0280974172,
-0.02277641,
-0.0255954415,
0.0169955809,
-0.0136582106,
0.0299005918,
-0.0020316809,
0.0526685342,
0.0328727588,
0.0054436699,
-0.0397033356,
0.0045243604,
0.0492140651,
-0.0494894907,
-0.0371699221,
0.0243764985,
-0.0138375349,
0.0506052226,
0.0192005709,
-0.0224635694,
-0.024694683,
0.0211574174,
-0.0413234271,
-0.0408165902,
0.0169393457,
-0.0078603579,
-0.0737100318,
0.0273303669,
-0.0472776033,
-0.0195023585,
0.0536842979,
-0.0304915477,
-0.0012069363,
0.0204951614,
-0.0313703492,
0.0482827909,
-0.079979293,
-0.0023320559,
-0.0321374871,
0.060691569,
-0.012906584,
0.0893208161,
0.0030865627,
0.0153933037,
-0.0177865624,
0.0226237457,
0.0084426822,
0.0141665367,
0.0103622554,
0.0291890241,
0.0103841303,
0.0089762686,
-0.0045001805,
0.0252647046,
-0.0511020795,
-0.0371390209,
-0.1010892913,
0.0134132486,
-0.0192573592,
-0.0123247756,
0.0304822009,
-0.0144738182,
-0.0243953988,
0.0283983182,
-0.0170577653,
-0.010684276,
0.0149715692,
0.00071252,
0.0236137398,
-0.0381931104,
-0.042348329,
-0.0210375842,
0.0207717959,
-0.0254377089,
0.0635528043,
-0.0084555512,
0.0053200047,
-0.0475540087,
0.0201588999,
-0.0453272015,
0.0430631787,
0.0106888711,
-0.04679133,
-0.0005638623,
0.0138671193,
0.0292945206,
0.017885847,
0.0519336276,
0.0403741375,
0.0350905657,
0.0139721325,
-0.0379149914,
-0.0006300961,
-0.048835367,
0.0270557534,
-0.0385366045,
-0.0304896627,
-0.0056098108,
0.0471521467,
0.0145992003,
-0.0255337339,
-0.0482125096,
0.0720719844,
-0.0068477932,
-0.0170253031,
0.0227103774,
-0.0323457681,
-0.0319565497,
0.0099567147,
-0.016056966,
-0.0143020917,
0.0376614779,
-0.0163878668,
0.0002434844,
-0.047582712,
-0.0299747884,
-0.0063603846,
0.0523345843,
-0.0221367907,
0.0250833463,
0.0072739115,
0.0239615999,
0.0005618226,
-0.0025530362,
0.0272282958,
-0.0219336487,
0.0148492604,
-0.0304775238,
0.0185849983,
0.0294927303,
-0.033473298,
-0.0952415168,
-0.0719978511,
-0.0496495292,
-0.0135135716,
0.0208787713,
0.0011382262,
0.0191729665,
-0.0061087171,
-0.0212366618,
0.012534433,
-0.0025833722,
-0.0267202016,
-0.0069852881,
0.0141485361,
0.0305171125,
-0.046646297,
0.022498006,
0.0299543869,
0.0029528646,
0.0393619277,
-0.0030723372,
0.0408562049,
-0.0377866514,
0.0096531659,
0.0075486046,
-0.0062200748,
0.0070201773,
-0.0087340306,
-0.0084419372,
0.0026985414,
-0.0287858024,
0.1154037938,
0.0403626449,
-0.0150186568,
0.0469165258,
0.0204445422,
-0.0048854942,
0.0308106765,
-0.0016528426,
-0.0749868006,
-0.0152786365,
0.0053323517,
-0.0031319102,
-0.0462140106,
-0.0497841835,
-0.0266601313,
-0.1573407054,
0.0473620333,
0.0008065183,
-0.0293806139,
-0.0188255664,
-0.0194852687,
-0.0066740974,
0.0116876028,
0.0114659453,
-0.0301076118,
0.0142403152,
-0.0000327857,
0.0239071473,
-0.0192087591,
-0.0885387808,
0.0260145869,
-0.017117165,
0.0658954233,
0.0068893805,
0.0799149945,
0.0150040146,
-0.0306192674,
-0.0031463527,
-0.0445554741,
-0.0154393343,
-0.0428892002,
0.0740449652,
-0.0073899874,
-0.0163120031,
-0.0029843622,
0.0250351299,
-0.0536122099,
0.010877043,
-0.0150793782,
0.0516270995,
-0.0207571834,
-0.0329505466,
-0.0390021354,
0.0099579291,
0.033987049,
0.088120833,
0.0174954683,
-0.053570088,
0.0080440287,
-0.0087461378,
-0.0086027132,
-0.0546880402,
-0.0635883361,
0.0283971503,
-0.0259201359,
-0.0133163314,
-0.0913688391,
-0.0343654342,
0.0335517712,
0.0413974747,
-0.0094237057,
-0.0197574534,
-0.0064627789,
-0.0190814249,
-0.051891461,
0.0145970145,
-0.0486424826,
0.0067790463,
0.0300627593,
-0.0431196764,
0.0181097873,
-0.0344468281,
-0.019607937,
0.0137877706,
-0.0227643549,
-0.056197755,
0.0442210734,
0.0218666792,
0.0233862046,
0.0332857631,
-0.014254407,
-0.0056125429,
0.0289775487,
0.0635174066,
-0.0262787268,
0.0214908663,
0.0226118583,
0.0173843782,
0.0284244157,
0.0426462255,
-0.0224714726,
0.0701710954,
0.0562028326,
0.0243797805,
-0.0160249956,
-0.0209213644,
0.0315376185,
0.0158895329,
0.0532736704,
-0.0345216803,
-0.0507375523,
-0.0055534402,
-0.0229575653,
-0.0541216023,
-0.0468602329,
-0.0383285955,
-0.0047382414,
0.0082451198,
0.0154072344,
-0.0535692275,
-0.0023427592,
-0.0788912177,
0.0669296458,
-0.0198977292,
-0.0296513028,
0.0240890048,
0.0208183657,
0.0218078122,
0.0095319636,
-0.0532195121,
-0.0163581036,
0.0250354894,
0.0041916138,
-0.0139435958,
-0.0019079235,
0.0212925375,
-0.0081289569,
-0.0334187672,
-0.0040720692,
-0.0307835862,
0.0157565922,
-0.0414771549,
0.0470578894,
0.048630368,
-0.0248806942,
0.0377354287,
-0.0489051975,
-0.0142025817,
0.0061927359,
0.0286184214,
0.0033013024,
-0.0362530909,
-0.0100105824,
0.0035600001,
-0.0625124276,
-0.0064937831,
0.0455542766,
-0.0015912708,
0.0690134689,
-0.0050351801,
-0.0243449751,
-0.0321450308,
-0.003845725,
0.0072925775,
-0.0354499593,
0.0094917463,
0.0233891625,
-0.1068584099,
-0.0635336116,
0.0468962565,
-0.0053552543,
0.0089841224,
0.0117449667,
0.0400597602,
0.0787551999,
0.0033551727,
0.0302751679,
-0.0269339047,
0.0263105035,
-0.0191734992,
-0.0051662098,
-0.0156344082,
-6.040235477e-33,
-0.0039921119,
-0.0557225198,
-0.0092273643,
0.0126538603,
-0.0256139487,
0.0186750349,
-0.0205308218,
-0.0157889146,
0.0071257856,
0.0273006614,
-0.0144767174,
0.0137030846,
0.0086376062,
-0.0089890491,
-0.0113451304,
-0.0046173623,
0.0498515964,
-0.0106016397,
-0.0116625186,
-0.0081137735,
0.0548072867,
0.0242569931,
0.0732398033,
-0.0873388723,
0.0291177183,
-0.0045176749,
-0.0147180771,
0.0172934439,
0.0177725442,
0.0626430064,
-0.0231093746,
0.1160757691,
0.0270521045,
-0.0011513681,
0.0142144356,
0.0009899636,
-0.018878784,
-0.0310161803,
0.012793689,
-0.0123462733,
0.004993876,
-0.0089832554,
0.0572394542,
0.010103236,
-0.0448688939,
0.0299416073,
0.0404028408,
-0.0527909212,
0.0277168974,
-0.0585240349,
-0.0927186161,
0.0135663766,
0.0337907299,
-0.0003787403,
0.0003884587,
0.0068186196,
0.0199891701,
0.0376593657,
-0.0113695022,
0.0416148752,
-0.0278391019,
-0.0190999042,
-0.0020589211,
-0.020318415,
0.0408828296,
0.0885919258,
0.0122060934,
0.0585953034,
-0.0289385449,
-0.0031618269,
0.0387145132,
0.0424032919,
0.0480610207,
0.1469534636,
0.0500115976,
-0.0446902961,
-0.0558235534,
0.0004903136,
0.0273342114,
-0.026872823,
-0.0007978215,
-0.0358339176,
-0.0687784106,
-0.0151196951,
0.0006060328,
0.0195529498,
-0.0109594055,
-0.0093032932,
0.0064404095,
0.0238041058,
-0.0614796579,
0.0325793847,
-0.011085798,
-0.0599954873,
-0.0069684088,
0.016118804,
-0.0250623543,
-0.003160886,
0.0191231072,
-0.0118333502,
0.0048788679,
-0.0554377139,
0.0237965677,
-0.0020036346,
0.0080050323,
0.0149624329,
0.0503428951,
0.0069521181,
-0.0388454273,
0.0244552065,
-0.0100831557,
0.0347296894,
-0.0236329585,
0.019142095,
0.0003573032,
0.0364774242,
0.0009110785,
-0.0107591618,
0.064681001,
0.0356774516,
-0.0163453463,
0.0247458629,
-0.005783258,
0.0410840847,
-0.0405582823,
-0.0268286094,
-0.014247233,
-0.0389241613,
0.0152168842,
-0.0801821873,
-0.0115569467,
-0.0602159463,
2.588e-7,
0.0269569196,
0.0633298308,
-0.00764364,
0.023408493,
0.0229669455,
0.0397622772,
0.037045721,
0.0336406976,
-0.0172549505,
-0.0558123328,
-0.0209852066,
0.0242317189,
0.0098729599,
0.0521830767,
-0.0897221342,
0.0296755154,
-0.049081888,
0.0064342092,
-0.0302046817,
-0.0190137234,
0.036384251,
0.0812860504,
0.057391081,
-0.0498162992,
0.0118322307,
-0.0250159912,
0.0389615819,
-0.0140992394,
-0.0217838362,
0.0107161198,
0.0257907491,
-0.0082950173,
0.0151960412,
0.0358480699,
-0.0244804993,
0.0167385023,
-0.016656572,
0.027900774,
-0.0174820963,
0.0099293077,
-0.0038404705,
-0.0432876498,
-0.00577603,
-0.0533458181,
0.0497042015,
-0.0201069266,
0.0092433831,
-0.037795186,
-0.0245284606,
0.0038704271,
0.0173463393,
-0.0374042913,
-0.0071106241,
0.0040790541,
0.0339962058,
0.004285018,
-0.0165391527,
-0.0602476075,
-0.0029531689,
-0.003570663,
-0.0409255698,
-0.0670608729,
0.0459058769,
0.0114470813,
0.0827009529,
-0.0535559841,
0.0540880598,
2.382772049e-34,
0.008078292,
0.0627392456,
0.0249513369,
-0.0127423052,
0.01782641,
0.0121666547,
0.021321483,
0.0058123204,
0.0181539673,
-0.025130529,
-0.0168358181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15040v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15040v2 | Active Learning for Natural Language Generation | 2023-05-24T11:27:53 | 2023-10-17T14:37:10 | Yotam Perlitz, Ariel Gera, Michal Shmueli-Scheuer, Dafna Sheinwald, Noam Slonim, Liat Ein-Dor | cs.CL | cs.CL | The field of Natural Language Generation (NLG) suffers from a severe shortage
of labeled data due to the extremely expensive and time-consuming process
involved in manual annotation. A natural approach for coping with this problem
is active learning (AL), a well-known machine learning technique for improving
annotation efficiency by selectively choosing the most informative examples to
label. However, while AL has been well-researched in the context of text
classification, its application to NLG remains largely unexplored. In this
paper, we present a first systematic study of active learning for NLG,
considering a diverse set of tasks and multiple leading selection strategies,
and harnessing a strong instruction-tuned model. Our results indicate that the
performance of existing AL strategies is inconsistent, surpassing the baseline
of random example selection in some cases but not in others. We highlight some
notable differences between the classification and generation scenarios, and
analyze the selection behaviors of existing AL strategies. Our findings
motivate exploring novel approaches for applying AL to generation tasks. | [
0.0451020859,
-0.0064906208,
-0.0030057204,
-0.0208039004,
0.0007882533,
0.0436148308,
0.0251650903,
-0.0103014978,
0.028828226,
-0.0874952078,
0.0249751043,
-0.0327559263,
-0.0219548903,
0.0209300313,
0.0338340923,
-0.0331647843,
0.0271600578,
-0.0210826229,
0.0421058759,
0.0112089654,
-0.0145124113,
0.055406034,
-0.0215412453,
0.0451740362,
-0.0307355896,
0.0496267229,
0.0127752246,
-0.0116679939,
-0.003068642,
-0.0518198125,
0.0356494151,
0.0523645766,
0.0043344437,
-0.0217695944,
0.0000019152,
-0.0419557691,
-0.01263214,
-0.0209924951,
0.0083585884,
0.0245425589,
-0.0037927649,
0.023214642,
0.0217156895,
-0.0013249862,
-0.0406899713,
-0.0215230547,
0.0711962953,
0.0112142945,
0.0479905009,
0.0455259234,
-0.0071240044,
0.0279870331,
-0.0503481962,
-0.0280572902,
0.0403234102,
-0.0299411882,
0.0101527721,
0.0131693715,
-0.022689756,
0.012150391,
0.0309026781,
0.0120965047,
-0.0147384275,
-0.0426453725,
0.0356681794,
0.0423020348,
-0.0361999981,
-0.0264542773,
0.0212415885,
0.0734073222,
0.0021832315,
-0.0051404336,
0.0311978068,
-0.0590884946,
0.0065662372,
-0.0025754988,
-0.0163535643,
0.0371607915,
-0.0393371731,
0.0449421182,
0.0350698084,
-0.0066679586,
-0.0058127064,
0.0276736654,
0.0183046237,
-0.0127137527,
0.0023641875,
-0.0115338778,
0.0471596159,
0.0526308417,
-0.069547981,
-0.0467316285,
0.0273236278,
0.0433162302,
-0.0864835978,
0.0117428154,
-0.0443576388,
-0.0147515535,
0.0351666771,
-0.0353316665,
0.0506867431,
-0.0015740417,
0.038863346,
0.0199388005,
0.0170403998,
-0.0124363964,
0.0373009332,
0.0012649985,
-0.0334678069,
0.0383462682,
-0.0729822144,
-0.022609368,
-0.0532058887,
0.0494649857,
-0.005694252,
-0.0308504682,
-0.0677435324,
0.0024623498,
-0.0016723478,
-0.0028460997,
0.0226484481,
0.0470445417,
-0.1018846259,
0.0492905453,
-0.0081397621,
-0.0439497381,
-0.0008808672,
-0.0022623017,
0.0098967711,
-0.0391812399,
0.0098509258,
0.0298142172,
0.0046487716,
-0.0334381387,
-0.0211479701,
0.0522382781,
-0.0347359739,
-0.0290517639,
-0.0235593785,
-0.0343807004,
0.0135645922,
-0.0192991812,
0.01520635,
-0.0264014564,
-0.0060727149,
-0.0207750984,
-0.000754657,
-0.0439062566,
0.038265679,
0.0406677909,
-0.0154765155,
-0.0065709422,
-0.0324019827,
-0.0311030131,
0.0337031446,
-0.0147207854,
0.0206684601,
0.0502895936,
0.0248463918,
0.0534699373,
0.0500056706,
0.0045660315,
0.0054015843,
0.0005536746,
0.0131474202,
-0.0127126034,
0.0135705406,
-0.0143871047,
-0.0510784611,
-0.0041655372,
-0.0427647643,
0.0324162245,
-0.0103508821,
0.0368899703,
0.0490316898,
-0.0282757822,
-0.0461063087,
0.0029251419,
0.1065724045,
0.0511523969,
0.0162188597,
0.0044014934,
0.0144746667,
0.0394356251,
-0.0006409682,
0.0175595749,
0.0080992421,
0.0369356573,
-0.0187414791,
-0.0541452467,
-0.022490127,
-0.0324875861,
-0.0020627559,
0.006082918,
0.0186942481,
0.0552316383,
-0.067306973,
0.0480795577,
0.0343452469,
-0.0272215512,
-0.0017703694,
-0.0303077307,
0.0136880195,
0.0025742615,
0.0393571965,
-0.0079397298,
-0.0601621121,
-0.013144901,
0.0418160073,
0.0495706499,
0.0803996995,
-0.0487037376,
-0.0143916011,
-0.0808215663,
-0.0341542661,
-0.015348644,
0.0331182852,
-0.0065163388,
0.018296117,
-0.0076597659,
0.0269755498,
-0.0002934923,
-0.0998755991,
0.0619150624,
0.0000849951,
-0.0598518923,
0.0592196509,
-0.0146685848,
0.0346472412,
-0.0243563205,
-0.0313176289,
0.0146186668,
0.0011356092,
-0.0259460676,
-0.0276815984,
0.0421193875,
0.0045551094,
-0.0179280601,
-0.0302504301,
-0.0430359989,
-0.0352389812,
-0.0149621665,
-0.0576410927,
-0.0179106463,
-0.0589311868,
-0.085886687,
-0.0530970208,
-0.0585869215,
0.0260705147,
0.0136950994,
0.0183410086,
-0.0796924978,
0.081392929,
0.0000767318,
0.003818413,
0.0619157106,
-0.0253919531,
0.0087950518,
-0.0476359054,
0.0102907466,
0.0094275037,
0.0075854384,
-0.031467177,
0.0413196832,
0.0604568981,
-0.034101475,
-0.0220710374,
-0.0345376618,
0.0121717071,
-0.0100091649,
0.0049640047,
0.0269138142,
-0.0015738808,
-0.001009049,
-0.0002000128,
-0.0210088398,
0.0009857024,
-0.001664093,
-0.0026750644,
0.0364789031,
0.002282053,
0.0273880009,
-0.0423684344,
0.0108912671,
0.0220420323,
0.0293322504,
0.0681532845,
-0.0015688444,
-0.0463018492,
0.0319720544,
-0.0253189113,
-0.0394964293,
0.0522123575,
0.0009653734,
0.0090976181,
-0.0172396656,
-0.0359638631,
0.013406259,
0.0494053401,
0.0777219236,
0.0046912786,
-0.022280857,
-0.0321812518,
0.0248421356,
-0.0597452857,
0.0240609702,
0.0109160691,
-0.0655820966,
0.0400089659,
0.0574598722,
0.0169625357,
-0.0111274319,
-0.0354092531,
0.0313628986,
-0.0335814692,
-0.0301928706,
-0.0238887686,
0.0092763267,
0.0018359796,
0.022150347,
-0.0137838991,
-0.0590411797,
0.0644733161,
-0.000840362,
0.0059744292,
-0.0879376233,
-0.0001138878,
-0.0147378752,
-0.0013192958,
0.0283508915,
0.0215942599,
0.0099426657,
-0.0127824126,
-0.0195197146,
-0.0321474895,
0.0196685065,
-0.0169783123,
0.0113376807,
-0.0716109052,
-0.0138825579,
0.0094418824,
-0.0271259528,
-0.0519661419,
-0.0177716278,
0.0205632783,
0.0136840893,
0.062460281,
0.0087715443,
-0.0148229422,
0.0013499883,
-0.0033501601,
0.0248932745,
0.0091960663,
-0.0329038128,
-0.0419428907,
0.0273696724,
0.0682218224,
-0.0281576701,
-0.0180846453,
-0.0371479616,
-0.0059420182,
0.0131639382,
-0.0125031145,
0.033269044,
0.0088786846,
0.0105577419,
0.0194688663,
-0.0632045269,
-0.0268838499,
0.0406565331,
0.0345686972,
-0.0288901813,
-0.0490950309,
0.111173749,
0.0481856912,
-0.0303832293,
0.0196291357,
0.0508548655,
0.0216362327,
0.0079958523,
0.050684385,
-0.0128348209,
-0.0147435041,
-0.0282311738,
0.0645572841,
-0.0244943332,
-0.0241180565,
-0.0417947583,
-0.0869884789,
0.0544929877,
-0.0002419915,
-0.0347816125,
0.0147159006,
-0.0276895966,
-0.0227587894,
-0.0237791464,
-0.0118302088,
-0.0267877858,
-0.0350819193,
0.0675244778,
0.0614046566,
-0.0410655513,
-0.0418558717,
-0.0171369072,
0.0200186186,
0.0161846429,
0.0299252346,
0.0512187257,
0.0273582879,
0.0186753627,
0.0456781685,
-0.0416551605,
0.0188340172,
-0.047980722,
0.0631662384,
0.0374478921,
-0.0177581031,
-0.0046283649,
0.0112632234,
-0.0111595616,
-0.0008060652,
0.0178368241,
-0.0015951777,
-0.0283179544,
0.01797444,
0.0056933141,
0.03136025,
0.0777943656,
0.0161369871,
0.0217405297,
-0.0429864787,
-0.0435143523,
-0.0284723528,
0.0182262845,
-0.1146893874,
-0.0248621348,
0.0347867906,
-0.0551968068,
-0.021414049,
-0.1084186658,
-0.0443738773,
0.0459624454,
0.0766290575,
0.0383952707,
0.0243387613,
0.0062403665,
-0.0104239061,
0.0034985957,
-0.0085089011,
0.0019457791,
-0.0034080266,
0.005105752,
-0.1208264306,
-0.0022613429,
-0.0594879501,
-0.0166575182,
0.0485939421,
-0.0358663611,
-0.044749856,
0.0197832789,
0.0668788105,
0.0211486463,
0.0284173731,
-0.0008040814,
-0.0383679867,
0.0183549765,
0.0626230389,
0.0297500081,
0.0005743775,
0.01053527,
-0.0126034105,
-0.00852089,
0.0155412145,
-0.0520078093,
0.0363257602,
0.0380443521,
0.0576767027,
-0.0191279817,
-0.0259580202,
0.025733294,
0.015136471,
-0.0023608045,
-0.0808010623,
-0.0340931676,
-0.031695962,
-0.0011357524,
0.0351787396,
-0.0221518353,
-0.0484957434,
0.0384482667,
-0.0190498699,
0.0064306082,
-0.0136561431,
0.0293465238,
-0.0080362847,
0.0913331583,
-0.0230524801,
-0.0208845064,
-0.0078718439,
0.023169037,
-0.0006968352,
-0.0062925359,
-0.0419264473,
0.042804271,
0.0096929958,
0.0611438267,
0.0092312051,
0.0748355314,
-0.0050588171,
0.0556186587,
-0.0194036402,
0.0026964156,
-0.0334072113,
-0.0127512291,
-0.0693416223,
0.0168115385,
0.0790123716,
-0.0592114627,
0.0957518071,
-0.0312329121,
-0.0152729955,
-0.0047062007,
0.0577833578,
0.0318482369,
-0.0576251,
-0.0362994447,
0.0009138129,
-0.0058501437,
-0.0015382009,
0.0847470984,
0.0178691112,
0.0302628316,
0.0040325131,
-0.008426494,
-0.0641772673,
-0.0203855019,
0.0296749081,
-0.0122669768,
0.0291838553,
0.0189582091,
-0.0164659843,
-0.04425871,
0.0055235815,
-0.0351706371,
0.0361550562,
0.0012778727,
0.09484265,
0.0357241705,
-0.0096899988,
0.0155428834,
-0.0748472884,
-0.0016346052,
-0.0164612401,
0.0255961902,
-0.0222262032,
-5.844286447e-33,
-0.0323400758,
-0.0557527915,
0.0040591848,
0.0289145168,
0.0066466862,
0.0175578129,
-0.0427035056,
-0.0367316231,
0.0523350984,
0.0223553553,
0.0217314232,
-0.0490971506,
0.0231926888,
0.0366095155,
-0.000638792,
-0.0130419312,
0.026413314,
0.0025319022,
-0.0343311206,
0.0597613417,
0.0405277424,
0.0139082856,
-0.0055255955,
-0.0832785442,
0.0146114165,
0.0144036897,
-0.0344879739,
-0.0136066945,
0.0129376985,
0.0459588245,
-0.0010279691,
0.019073464,
0.0032881065,
-0.0277409554,
-0.0148956776,
-0.0420401618,
0.0024456782,
-0.0195976254,
-0.0354614817,
-0.007214969,
-0.0126210414,
-0.0137409912,
-0.0345934182,
-0.0364050046,
0.0237697363,
0.0151183214,
0.0720281079,
-0.0071576866,
-0.0552699715,
-0.0797406733,
-0.0735079795,
0.01226898,
-0.0621241592,
0.0014951255,
-0.0206372403,
0.032296028,
-0.0163324941,
-0.0393390507,
-0.0185919553,
0.0291640479,
0.0128101157,
0.0183084588,
0.0148414215,
-0.0082004964,
-0.0097433496,
0.0626907796,
0.0109637603,
0.0142377922,
-0.0196249913,
0.0635591596,
-0.057838127,
0.0518750697,
-0.0225784332,
0.0104080457,
0.031106513,
-0.0026889909,
-0.0469894074,
0.0473994277,
0.0652570799,
-0.033968851,
0.0459995568,
-0.0340113565,
-0.0134044653,
-0.0202915203,
-0.007488199,
0.024666043,
-0.0011050281,
-0.0471122712,
0.0341833793,
0.022830816,
-0.0911527649,
0.0055689388,
0.015941523,
0.0309178755,
-0.025640592,
-0.0001333393,
-0.0275718663,
-0.0124761714,
-0.031783957,
-0.0556257516,
-0.0363872051,
-0.103698574,
0.0536877811,
0.0053435313,
0.0226987787,
0.0287020393,
0.0359652787,
0.0337599926,
-0.0345750712,
0.0384669788,
-0.033206977,
0.0313194878,
-0.0010367403,
0.0155468704,
-0.00329229,
-0.0325007699,
-0.0245009083,
0.0343115889,
0.0219667368,
-0.0282506123,
-0.0025223647,
-0.0274665784,
-0.0054050405,
0.0266278908,
-0.040633712,
0.0189215336,
-0.0055935807,
-0.0138284219,
-0.011305673,
-0.0629602373,
-0.0132007487,
0.0044847322,
2.568e-7,
0.0264943261,
0.0515736453,
-0.03699743,
0.0038643291,
0.0149646178,
0.0231151693,
0.0064766174,
0.0094561158,
0.04386485,
0.0388666615,
0.0112095671,
0.0002106562,
0.0321905129,
0.0485778973,
-0.0931780934,
-0.0116871605,
-0.0377147831,
0.0373200588,
-0.0446710475,
-0.0081729824,
0.0307654534,
0.0258318149,
-0.0074719205,
-0.0283921026,
-0.0010415844,
-0.0602010489,
0.0462670662,
0.0149230026,
0.0032952875,
0.0412466861,
0.0411115661,
0.0087591494,
-0.0271087885,
0.0349794328,
-0.0677974299,
-0.0453474335,
0.0181807633,
0.0480639897,
0.0227234513,
-0.0092400219,
0.0316694453,
0.0294657331,
0.051788561,
0.0164800975,
0.0541714542,
-0.0741145089,
-0.0238404069,
0.0357302651,
-0.0100687686,
-0.0102293575,
-0.0131173804,
-0.0147942258,
-0.0017282531,
0.0313897245,
-0.0076412428,
0.0223970115,
-0.0435158424,
-0.0397955589,
-0.0218483359,
-0.0499830656,
-0.0337625146,
-0.0222872496,
-0.0192859527,
0.0712249875,
-0.0057921195,
-0.0174676534,
0.0101366835,
2.385386375e-34,
0.0339912213,
-0.0062610311,
0.0003008097,
0.0309139267,
0.023180183,
0.0249215886,
0.0306474492,
0.0190574229,
-0.0090926895,
-0.0155654345,
-0.0168613587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15038v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15038v2 | Is GPT-4 a Good Data Analyst? | 2023-05-24T11:26:59 | 2023-10-23T02:10:58 | Liying Cheng, Xingxuan Li, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated their powerful capabilities
in plenty of domains and tasks, including context understanding, code
generation, language generation, data storytelling, etc., many data analysts
may raise concerns if their jobs will be replaced by artificial intelligence
(AI). This controversial topic has drawn great attention in public. However, we
are still at a stage of divergent opinions without any definitive conclusion.
Motivated by this, we raise the research question of "is GPT-4 a good data
analyst?" in this work and aim to answer it by conducting head-to-head
comparative studies. In detail, we regard GPT-4 as a data analyst to perform
end-to-end data analysis with databases from a wide range of domains. We
propose a framework to tackle the problems by carefully designing the prompts
for GPT-4 to conduct experiments. We also design several task-specific
evaluation metrics to systematically compare the performance between several
professional human data analysts and GPT-4. Experimental results show that
GPT-4 can achieve comparable performance to humans. We also provide in-depth
discussions about our results to shed light on further studies before reaching
the conclusion that GPT-4 can replace data analysts. | [
0.0243234728,
0.09593454,
-0.0411363356,
0.0376326367,
-0.0598605871,
0.0063410616,
0.0268317852,
-0.0272173919,
-0.0063061821,
-0.0167576335,
-0.0030176712,
-0.0638506413,
-0.0080054477,
0.0679970533,
0.0052486146,
-0.065469034,
0.0288309883,
-0.0270317551,
0.0176748876,
0.0291758049,
-0.0101426104,
0.0175697859,
-0.0035754999,
0.0418083221,
-0.0176174678,
-0.0054223114,
-0.0334907062,
-0.0281829815,
0.0194565002,
-0.0223532319,
0.0188818965,
0.0446185507,
0.0167541206,
0.082747519,
0.0000021553,
-0.0536114462,
-0.0105293458,
0.0222121812,
-0.0089080622,
0.0239905827,
0.0383293964,
-0.0157939717,
-0.0003088642,
0.0296385307,
-0.0580037534,
-0.029873183,
0.0507174656,
-0.03036597,
0.0664021522,
0.0592959486,
-0.0225459095,
-0.0544909462,
0.0205885433,
-0.0153930085,
0.0227779616,
-0.0538489036,
0.0071807168,
0.0206091031,
0.0533362105,
0.003155401,
0.0172716193,
0.0261176452,
0.0366370678,
0.0018793823,
-0.0354944952,
0.0401269384,
-0.0609926209,
0.0068701874,
-0.0228874832,
0.0147852385,
0.0211288091,
-0.0130429221,
-0.0144092571,
-0.0064491588,
0.0018464664,
-0.0168493204,
-0.0238245502,
0.0395906568,
-0.0345588811,
0.0049142912,
0.0073982626,
-0.0034820589,
0.012231674,
-0.0128214424,
-0.0379553549,
0.0899345428,
-0.005377993,
-0.0416221656,
0.0325574949,
0.027753979,
0.0104637519,
-0.0536513999,
-0.0036045301,
0.0357157663,
-0.0231679622,
0.0307557452,
-0.0293253735,
0.0012713103,
-0.001810596,
-0.0269654114,
0.011802542,
0.0602366887,
-0.010278848,
-0.0039097592,
0.0098063061,
0.0599551648,
0.0177695509,
-0.0034017696,
0.0074680904,
-0.0353496149,
-0.074022904,
-0.0106536401,
-0.0437989831,
0.0168667771,
-0.0196332205,
0.0087421583,
-0.0247133523,
0.0588273183,
-0.0148902461,
0.0237706974,
-0.0058029019,
-0.0118524814,
-0.015974788,
0.0305507462,
-0.0594246313,
-0.0099707842,
-0.0319167003,
-0.0140426019,
-0.0077610766,
-0.0921063647,
0.0226091854,
0.0032159539,
-0.0039344542,
-0.0345100462,
0.0295012556,
0.0701707378,
0.0251087341,
-0.0048480546,
-0.0682552457,
-0.031072814,
0.0098935124,
-0.0976409316,
-0.0196458586,
-0.0582449697,
0.0119837495,
0.0432970785,
-0.0423778594,
-0.0473106392,
-0.0127121415,
0.019164212,
0.002467013,
0.0619905479,
-0.0488048606,
0.0340384059,
0.0269658379,
0.007374608,
-0.0184552316,
0.0643338412,
0.0274307057,
0.0332715139,
-0.0106964363,
-0.0333611444,
0.0600295067,
0.0421426781,
-0.0344939344,
0.0087800594,
-0.0365113989,
0.0573871098,
-0.0372304581,
0.0165612623,
0.0083823036,
0.0780468956,
-0.0067514996,
0.0416802578,
0.0510636866,
0.0512203649,
0.0193041302,
0.0885962397,
0.064998962,
0.0152570819,
0.018873753,
-0.0090469476,
-0.0338002667,
0.0152371721,
0.0067318035,
0.0167745706,
-0.0113770543,
0.0036416091,
0.0049441387,
-0.0506740063,
-0.0006196764,
0.0148014817,
0.0061738361,
0.0053660199,
0.0415545478,
-0.0602927618,
-0.036600668,
-0.0013902566,
-0.0324686654,
-0.0709677562,
-0.0533325113,
-0.06528835,
-0.0021401197,
0.0718768612,
0.0452955291,
-0.0525798798,
-0.0390889272,
-0.0292133372,
0.0057585281,
0.0165797044,
0.0681275353,
-0.0079573607,
-0.0139773563,
-0.0365635939,
-0.0124487802,
-0.0114134261,
0.0119139273,
0.0307401158,
0.0187171567,
0.0190015063,
0.0292085093,
-0.015545073,
-0.0570182055,
0.004675773,
-0.0079561314,
-0.0097651444,
-0.0026949206,
0.0002797926,
0.0215352513,
0.0395210087,
-0.0370243266,
0.0037255478,
0.0090489183,
0.0213476401,
0.0049067014,
0.0074460409,
0.0060207825,
0.0330688953,
0.0321311578,
-0.0438479371,
-0.0230792742,
0.0127883498,
-0.0336511359,
-0.0376509912,
0.0233149081,
-0.0433796197,
0.0395885706,
-0.0453457609,
0.0097015295,
-0.0593142845,
-0.0020306942,
-0.0117479274,
0.0630843118,
0.0343738757,
0.0061949431,
-0.0033660349,
0.0353924818,
0.0482791699,
-0.0467514992,
-0.0176887363,
0.0139022805,
0.0283522792,
0.0536424182,
0.0222284459,
0.0016731748,
-0.0421357751,
0.0083103636,
-0.0996177644,
0.0219624545,
-0.0163586102,
0.0544841215,
0.0390652679,
0.0163757186,
-0.0424678549,
-0.0020806228,
-0.0546920411,
-0.0285913143,
0.0022501582,
0.0162295308,
0.049186714,
0.0222458057,
-0.0274139177,
-0.0326997489,
0.0094524147,
-0.0533099733,
-0.0039549884,
0.0532409512,
-0.0372622907,
-0.0390047692,
0.0251768939,
-0.0220187157,
0.0250086356,
0.0017577163,
-0.0142874578,
0.0446975678,
-0.022730045,
0.0476911142,
0.0200904533,
-0.0287331175,
0.0206898134,
0.044062756,
-0.0269211177,
-0.0112792905,
0.0279290453,
0.0371744484,
-0.0196194369,
0.0083703259,
-0.0333053768,
0.0006443731,
0.0153306974,
0.0196568854,
-0.0126875807,
-0.0404641107,
0.0537054092,
0.0010824393,
0.0157154668,
-0.0205645468,
-0.0129932994,
-0.0178775359,
0.0731363147,
-0.0068094786,
-0.0599265657,
0.0495998785,
-0.0278970692,
-0.013222307,
-0.0418401174,
-0.0385057926,
-0.0506543741,
0.092407316,
-0.0013930708,
0.0068026199,
-0.0511935763,
-0.0117031122,
-0.0148371272,
0.0086587323,
-0.017389724,
-0.0441534817,
0.0977242067,
-0.0852306783,
0.0151833957,
-0.0160129275,
-0.0115136625,
-0.0356767699,
0.0072019873,
-0.0610146597,
0.0118148373,
0.0621473491,
-0.0306891073,
-0.0029309825,
0.0188879836,
0.0333646685,
0.0689881742,
-0.0053812792,
-0.0279090237,
0.0189899188,
-0.0299400818,
0.0174670238,
-0.0195185915,
-0.010968646,
-0.0222751833,
0.0113388672,
-0.0030860982,
0.0223164316,
0.0002443448,
-0.0748382881,
-0.0056255423,
-0.0159494318,
-0.0242912918,
-0.028546555,
0.0269191545,
0.0140540265,
-0.0910521001,
-0.0049845683,
0.1198401377,
0.0139281834,
-0.0636062771,
-0.0156957489,
-0.0051081078,
-0.0113048749,
0.023877088,
0.0501566231,
-0.1017887369,
-0.0123677086,
-0.0061529186,
0.0485697351,
-0.0271720216,
-0.0528412536,
-0.0243018847,
-0.1159139276,
0.0786938667,
-0.0214790162,
-0.0460094288,
-0.037870042,
-0.0501347594,
0.0148588857,
-0.0366380438,
0.0137739247,
0.0285091475,
0.0056006606,
0.0293789469,
-0.0000849698,
-0.0242739916,
-0.0511804707,
0.0543411709,
-0.0250703674,
0.0297734439,
0.0934539363,
0.0331461802,
-0.0408627205,
-0.0069644032,
0.001286583,
0.0129592754,
0.0006974305,
0.0159635358,
0.0736305043,
0.0045909407,
-0.0178990196,
-0.0270399731,
0.0091158375,
-0.0484916903,
0.0513717309,
0.0511717312,
0.091908291,
-0.0384237021,
-0.0216860753,
-0.0202967115,
-0.0375615321,
0.0040449263,
0.0680441186,
0.0306486338,
-0.0257732291,
-0.0644795075,
-0.0454375297,
0.0083370525,
-0.0568938591,
-0.0032815742,
0.0084640812,
0.0100860046,
-0.0309861954,
-0.0068201432,
-0.0775775164,
0.0699523538,
0.0215082448,
0.0177270118,
0.0060605179,
-0.0142042199,
0.0047313953,
-0.054229632,
-0.0067033265,
-0.0067683258,
0.0521407649,
-0.0501836278,
-0.0433307961,
0.0175407305,
-0.0164618585,
-0.0053263418,
0.02988079,
-0.0602765493,
-0.0497828498,
0.0069771581,
0.0250848085,
0.0434765927,
0.0031297666,
-0.0080324747,
-0.0123022953,
-0.0280787516,
0.0554112345,
-0.0616447628,
-0.0289481543,
-0.0072142589,
0.0137907891,
0.007067922,
-0.0095475633,
-0.0293447878,
0.0118752196,
-0.0395645872,
-0.0199819915,
-0.0137910126,
-0.0273402762,
0.0414547287,
0.0610843189,
0.0165356006,
-0.0023795543,
-0.0195206702,
-0.0148299355,
-0.0116863046,
-0.0507538505,
-0.0280537643,
-0.0431347974,
0.0012194687,
0.0199629627,
0.0049147736,
-0.0087866671,
-0.0209178403,
-0.0318952948,
-0.0303563792,
-0.0380171537,
0.0308383461,
0.0276540406,
0.0336774439,
0.0440857857,
-0.0290029403,
-0.0255931206,
-0.0431862138,
0.0345717072,
0.0550909638,
0.0035485304,
0.0661424845,
0.012076647,
0.0112330774,
0.0509020723,
0.0298647601,
-0.0716189966,
-0.0476370901,
-0.0077827638,
0.0140420403,
0.0309534464,
0.0062640803,
0.0154757546,
-0.0620926991,
0.0180380456,
-0.0222840291,
0.0121406792,
0.0145255094,
0.0031751939,
-0.0083061242,
0.0323655568,
-0.0384640843,
-0.0423510708,
0.0704869032,
0.0006004131,
0.0528268851,
-0.0176972467,
-0.0608522631,
-0.0414035656,
-0.031138245,
0.0070747202,
-0.0227811392,
-0.0065658772,
-0.0388387181,
-0.0613555796,
-0.066076912,
-0.0475720726,
0.0314894244,
0.0172229651,
-0.0516678877,
0.0236396398,
0.0704878941,
-0.0058857631,
0.0218299739,
-0.0331361964,
0.0213516001,
-0.0280879214,
-0.0086886585,
-0.0311806593,
-6.064419804e-33,
-0.013869985,
-0.0350391902,
0.0529346727,
0.0034520081,
-0.0145964772,
-0.0155325485,
-0.069308795,
-0.0082867173,
-0.0135209886,
-0.0081585813,
-0.0131851649,
0.030758461,
0.0149397422,
-0.0239514131,
0.0538890213,
-0.0037650622,
0.037779294,
0.0005902451,
-0.0122424047,
0.0212081727,
-0.0147972414,
0.0165787116,
0.0412552059,
-0.0401028991,
0.0278299097,
-0.0202371012,
-0.0172745064,
-0.0086386725,
-0.0187454522,
0.0206884723,
0.004646353,
0.0435348041,
0.0322707184,
-0.0218852498,
-0.0117947655,
0.0064699817,
-0.0272983368,
-0.0175494757,
0.0102452245,
-0.0010570603,
0.0133698089,
-0.0110540874,
0.0512923412,
-0.028974833,
-0.0285774022,
0.0166812111,
0.0200176556,
-0.034843307,
0.013302343,
-0.0096005397,
-0.0318342261,
0.0531694293,
-0.0223656278,
0.0246107634,
0.0405456051,
0.0448184721,
-0.0147454562,
0.0074682948,
-0.02558209,
0.0206026454,
0.066350393,
-0.0039784131,
0.0672738403,
0.0113464249,
0.0143098906,
0.0237858128,
0.0740002692,
-0.0154044181,
-0.0278512724,
0.0025500958,
-0.0055225873,
0.04120031,
0.0024831053,
0.0265299287,
0.0233174004,
-0.0086551365,
-0.0262554977,
0.0607444122,
0.0125653371,
-0.0184352361,
0.0076116119,
0.0036188222,
-0.0760530308,
-0.0391831733,
0.0129624121,
-0.0088098226,
-0.0245291479,
-0.0522016399,
0.0450062454,
-0.0616658404,
-0.0032683329,
0.063545391,
0.0176768359,
-0.0375331454,
0.008947514,
0.0202127714,
-0.0622550771,
0.0142718563,
0.0032477453,
0.042569302,
-0.0301088151,
0.0033611997,
-0.0168228932,
0.0815732628,
0.0602523796,
0.0075525339,
0.0004325803,
0.0596383736,
-0.0733067468,
0.0005818075,
-0.0754867196,
0.0572893396,
-0.0268973317,
0.0027277293,
0.0078557609,
-0.0141574135,
0.0255616084,
0.0302158091,
0.0336845703,
-0.0126899984,
-0.0514295027,
0.0049495273,
-0.0172857791,
-0.0433822088,
-0.0086651184,
-0.0277381726,
0.0094678653,
0.017943481,
0.0467873812,
-0.0216729734,
-0.0132047059,
0.0063818106,
2.855e-7,
0.063152574,
0.0238547828,
0.0381294973,
0.0446566306,
-0.0014003118,
0.0130101312,
-0.0290004406,
-0.0122022731,
0.019187374,
0.0276296288,
0.0409699976,
0.001326142,
0.0484346636,
0.0793805346,
-0.0478570797,
0.005105895,
-0.0403559394,
-0.0382230282,
-0.0938133299,
0.0395848565,
0.0715254098,
0.0612633973,
0.0185261313,
-0.0158637632,
0.0074407565,
-0.046396967,
0.0037877716,
-0.0129236188,
0.0265725367,
0.0426306017,
0.011434325,
0.0648413748,
-0.0153176431,
0.0461470485,
0.0198896006,
0.0071310722,
0.0035859514,
0.0758655444,
-0.0131184906,
0.0253244918,
0.0466515608,
-0.047309868,
0.0085672271,
-0.0926197022,
0.0834583491,
-0.023657741,
-0.0176420081,
0.0147286579,
-0.016622141,
-0.0338732675,
-0.0121054277,
-0.0188425723,
-0.0055639683,
0.0020604851,
-0.0175521839,
-0.0441771038,
-0.0048847417,
-0.006572478,
-0.0145158675,
0.0329685174,
-0.0382462144,
-0.0497594289,
-0.041606199,
0.0268274248,
0.0116692251,
-0.0319661871,
0.0420873947,
2.482973758e-34,
0.0495179892,
-0.0032249582,
0.0104059288,
-0.0055579981,
0.0822142884,
0.0290015638,
0.0007605462,
0.0124303447,
-0.0129189538,
-0.0203358326,
-0.0460019447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15035v2 | Self-ICL: Zero-Shot In-Context Learning with Self-Generated Demonstrations | 2023-05-24T11:22:34 | 2023-10-23T14:50:57 | Wei-Lin Chen, Cheng-Kuang Wu, Yun-Nung Chen, Hsin-Hsi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited striking in-context learning
(ICL) ability to adapt to target tasks with a few input-output demonstrations.
For better ICL, different methods are proposed to select representative
demonstrations from existing training corpora. However, such settings are not
aligned with real-world practices, as end-users usually query LMs without
access to demonstration pools. In this work, we introduce Self-ICL -- a simple
framework which bootstraps LMs' intrinsic capabilities to perform zero-shot
ICL. Given a test input, Self-ICL first prompts the model to generate
pseudo-inputs. Next, the model predicts pseudo-labels for the pseudo-inputs via
zero-shot prompting. Finally, we perform ICL for the test input with the
pseudo-input-label pairs as demonstrations. Evaluation on 23 BIG-Bench Hard
tasks shows Self-ICL outperforms zero-shot baselines on both average accuracy
and head-to-head comparison. Moreover, with zero-shot chain-of-thought,
Self-ICL achieves results comparable to using real demonstrations.
Additionally, we conduct a range of analyses to validate Self-ICL's
effectiveness and provide insights for its behaviors under different settings. | [
-0.0185517408,
0.0209889207,
0.0130046709,
0.0569415912,
-0.0334790945,
0.0094319871,
0.0508881472,
0.0048169168,
0.0018557278,
-0.0431929529,
-0.0695579499,
-0.022945812,
-0.0296788234,
0.0038059198,
0.0516159013,
-0.0180141013,
0.0223992988,
-0.0456420369,
-0.0420207046,
0.0079895332,
-0.0097748172,
0.0046688621,
-0.0335285403,
0.0139048574,
-0.0126554668,
-0.0291214213,
-0.0245796312,
0.026624307,
-0.0375551023,
-0.0490031019,
-0.0015417556,
0.046741277,
0.0452519953,
0.0436131172,
0.0000020688,
-0.0653270185,
0.0005182071,
-0.0070713935,
-0.0706444681,
0.0123878643,
0.0422087274,
0.0029724841,
-0.0187269337,
0.0212668441,
-0.0451746322,
-0.0213615447,
0.0105484007,
0.0212703291,
0.0455421656,
0.0822323635,
0.0067618871,
0.0070518889,
-0.0174655654,
-0.033490371,
0.0193541385,
-0.0217379369,
0.0085395994,
-0.0466101207,
0.0252925344,
0.0072060372,
-0.0121361921,
0.0359695517,
0.0501856245,
0.0005567258,
-0.0129011776,
0.0601816736,
-0.0537602007,
-0.0135553339,
-0.0151224528,
0.0731512085,
-0.0348329619,
-0.0445896499,
0.0052102474,
-0.0288415439,
0.0004984127,
-0.0324371234,
-0.0521253571,
0.0212289114,
0.0360540934,
0.0283308364,
0.0063376105,
0.0310490169,
0.0380272307,
0.0034113333,
-0.0244827066,
0.0405342467,
-0.0186166931,
-0.0471039452,
0.0189789683,
-0.00773881,
-0.005271412,
-0.0487786829,
-0.0573367067,
0.0332992636,
-0.0640820265,
0.0312395003,
-0.0430003516,
-0.0287899096,
0.0140271131,
-0.0215606932,
0.0719084963,
0.0198265351,
-0.0023662841,
0.0538229905,
-0.0298124366,
0.0381841287,
0.0174261965,
0.0611858107,
-0.0338530503,
0.0064484323,
-0.0613405742,
0.0217203442,
-0.0538218766,
0.03345754,
-0.0141809341,
-0.0131677631,
-0.0096788602,
0.050541833,
-0.0263123214,
0.0224410351,
0.0048352242,
-0.0126349181,
-0.0367512628,
-0.0282251667,
-0.0002471269,
0.0261806808,
-0.0118270535,
-0.0077652703,
0.0033087221,
-0.0753283203,
-0.027478341,
0.0175135117,
-0.0035378342,
-0.0179344639,
0.0096229156,
0.0681616291,
-0.0281711351,
-0.0797344893,
-0.0234036446,
-0.0054951664,
0.0158944633,
-0.0674816072,
-0.0110906325,
-0.0776173845,
0.0091226604,
-0.0081450613,
0.0138659375,
-0.0577355847,
0.0060600755,
0.0362156965,
0.0064860708,
0.0771157295,
0.0043644221,
0.008272619,
0.015041302,
0.0007714536,
-0.0094025051,
0.1018063501,
0.0175764933,
-0.0027353885,
0.0242679771,
0.0154856769,
0.0460582711,
0.0591672808,
0.0619792305,
0.040318612,
-0.0623636879,
0.0129253026,
0.0226088595,
0.0568814464,
0.0171138775,
0.0301754363,
-0.0143969338,
0.0154449204,
0.0573452674,
0.0524062179,
0.029271096,
-0.0257268753,
0.0450997576,
0.0151672373,
0.004417635,
-0.0245640781,
-0.0696267933,
0.008259384,
-0.0007507712,
0.0261964221,
0.0324638374,
-0.0301067363,
-0.0487476178,
-0.0260041095,
-0.0163119659,
-0.0210103523,
-0.0128966561,
0.0176523663,
0.0548858829,
0.0480958708,
-0.0565029047,
0.0079701077,
0.0293771643,
-0.0083317766,
0.0017518576,
-0.0491128005,
0.0168401562,
0.0355548561,
0.0469844118,
-0.0244339723,
-0.0172213111,
-0.0344191752,
0.0595889799,
0.081666097,
0.0035134186,
-0.0269998796,
0.000480708,
-0.0313508436,
-0.0069324556,
-0.0140462415,
0.0216515288,
-0.0133433174,
0.0125937406,
0.005851442,
-0.0027058243,
-0.052968286,
-0.0141056236,
0.0370175391,
-0.0647559986,
-0.0763419718,
0.042796921,
0.004712665,
0.0232107583,
-0.0054448154,
-0.0205509178,
0.0070218658,
0.0498794317,
-0.0223423131,
0.0018412253,
-0.0316725224,
-0.0774360597,
-0.0724150985,
0.0364374071,
0.0035948101,
-0.0041101864,
-0.0163711533,
-0.0488416627,
-0.0275950804,
-0.0176579542,
0.011211453,
0.0473999381,
-0.0422688574,
-0.0011327539,
0.0048307464,
-0.0073839216,
-0.0328086317,
0.0317853354,
0.0022275557,
0.0060834228,
0.0259383302,
0.0529514998,
-0.0152107216,
-0.0365106538,
-0.0421071872,
-0.0009072384,
-0.010853542,
0.0330933854,
-0.0261953175,
0.0527942032,
-0.0519390889,
0.0146596069,
-0.0925149918,
0.0087230336,
-0.052869793,
0.0010899361,
0.0281579662,
-0.0113388216,
-0.0313587487,
-0.0425781123,
-0.0059756963,
-0.0323170461,
-0.0019271517,
0.0157780107,
0.0234870519,
0.0382270962,
0.0224477444,
-0.0034941924,
-0.0010183472,
-0.0063446783,
0.0534850359,
-0.0334076509,
0.0250572301,
-0.0101219928,
0.0183991808,
0.0095195007,
0.0236835368,
-0.0059464453,
0.0079081226,
0.0237923488,
-0.0224827919,
0.0007620886,
0.0377592854,
0.0001167592,
0.0220067445,
0.0243818313,
0.0015676966,
-0.0765315294,
0.0101299807,
0.0069445921,
-0.0196027793,
-0.0417768918,
0.0253470168,
0.0056929607,
0.0658370852,
0.0016354657,
0.0109109413,
-0.0424543433,
0.0263274051,
-0.019494433,
-0.0366646945,
-0.0557161719,
0.0208676942,
-0.0489960238,
0.0075568678,
-0.006109626,
-0.053241808,
0.0534785651,
-0.043836832,
-0.021895498,
-0.0242127124,
-0.015264702,
-0.0152120385,
0.0462805517,
-0.0192555375,
-0.0180754811,
0.0319533199,
-0.01252985,
-0.0269896444,
0.0069875433,
-0.0076794387,
-0.0255541541,
0.0397042334,
-0.0411534421,
0.0283844583,
0.0090429951,
-0.0393965803,
-0.0653374121,
-0.0489986055,
-0.0173508879,
0.0190141443,
-0.0686143413,
0.0038130567,
0.0207097996,
-0.0147712724,
0.0296440274,
0.0784227848,
-0.001210689,
-0.0158435572,
-0.0199672971,
-0.0027139778,
0.0242494754,
0.0071469247,
-0.0308363475,
-0.0238865037,
0.0291812513,
0.0262413751,
0.0984757468,
-0.0109857414,
-0.0341258422,
-0.0063516288,
0.0037608687,
-0.0202088524,
0.0137281632,
0.069039315,
0.021357147,
-0.0628474429,
-0.018832447,
0.1179693937,
0.0190561563,
-0.0941349119,
0.0046523553,
0.0195719395,
0.0185813289,
0.0449888222,
0.0451959893,
-0.0908264443,
-0.0380847678,
0.0115213199,
0.0272155646,
0.0028129457,
-0.0292616338,
-0.0326874256,
-0.1685204506,
0.0331252143,
0.0116850855,
-0.0479602702,
0.0105176903,
-0.0384410545,
0.0091893412,
-0.0023358869,
0.0175061319,
0.0262462217,
-0.0262183752,
-0.0091185458,
0.0290249269,
0.0055071712,
-0.1085938662,
0.0347179621,
-0.0284432378,
0.0643269122,
0.0562571362,
-0.006927981,
0.0103241587,
-0.0242041685,
0.0605856366,
-0.050028123,
0.0003362333,
-0.0390613414,
0.0443682671,
-0.0152095445,
-0.0146682747,
0.0278053954,
0.0517094582,
-0.0456226096,
-0.0114945658,
0.0042463276,
0.0904934704,
-0.0086461483,
0.0106641622,
0.0083923414,
-0.0634760559,
0.0445631482,
0.0629382581,
0.0287577268,
-0.0521661751,
-0.0139167253,
-0.0119885551,
-0.0302648079,
-0.0274636019,
-0.0289409123,
0.0020561211,
-0.0134894829,
-0.0191338025,
-0.052179452,
-0.0561542623,
0.0425115041,
0.1063144132,
-0.0122787543,
-0.0001406256,
-0.0241238717,
-0.005081947,
-0.0304805338,
0.0208630748,
-0.0576604232,
0.0379505008,
-0.0761533678,
0.0020503814,
0.0550789088,
-0.0200795494,
-0.0082464581,
0.0252112523,
-0.0626051202,
-0.0654146746,
-0.0055913036,
0.0625554919,
0.0142179513,
0.0870155022,
-0.0244613551,
-0.0367734097,
0.111572884,
0.065723002,
-0.0149345053,
0.0225524027,
0.0316544399,
-0.0092617031,
-0.004044014,
0.047610011,
-0.024007326,
0.0080732619,
0.0299482085,
0.0349537991,
-0.0468590409,
0.0127159543,
0.0441944525,
-0.0254207142,
0.070309788,
-0.0276916493,
-0.0075784908,
-0.008637974,
0.0210784692,
-0.0073007871,
-0.0200924408,
-0.0273078475,
-0.0025824774,
0.0053974567,
-0.0150976945,
0.0056154653,
0.0115381703,
-0.0337007269,
0.0500254557,
-0.0012254823,
-0.0158444624,
0.0164219774,
0.0036700228,
0.0261297263,
0.0306592919,
-0.0012804177,
0.0016137493,
0.0114811873,
0.0426786877,
-0.021827748,
0.0570638031,
0.0352871865,
0.0069150766,
-0.0187946111,
0.0215729773,
-0.0347091071,
0.0100256577,
-0.0549374893,
0.0300828815,
0.0543488413,
0.0011309566,
0.0384402685,
-0.0271069948,
0.0043782308,
-0.0323767923,
0.0030738474,
-0.0537882261,
-0.0382516459,
0.010318798,
0.0403043181,
0.0050581708,
0.0251713376,
0.0788451582,
0.0057804063,
0.0237380005,
0.0241741017,
0.0545368232,
-0.0503735095,
0.0087478515,
0.0230882131,
0.0266135372,
0.0030395214,
-0.0073647005,
-0.0328166373,
-0.0727891997,
0.0091946349,
0.0223093946,
-0.0333179832,
-0.0220156834,
0.0519329421,
0.0462011062,
-0.0069719539,
0.0337348022,
-0.026585117,
-0.0038709999,
0.0467351377,
-0.0530924611,
-0.0308956224,
-6.471012647e-33,
-0.0255168937,
-0.0369007401,
0.0448078364,
-0.0209962912,
0.0042618252,
0.0136830863,
-0.0335336663,
0.019748738,
0.0049021924,
0.0063864626,
-0.0479855314,
-0.0251342971,
0.0159614272,
0.0398676507,
0.0290481728,
-0.0223629642,
0.0345020704,
-0.0469485298,
-0.0305492617,
0.0276800338,
-0.0019445487,
0.0361696407,
0.0501489751,
-0.0378903858,
0.0262658074,
-0.0214009471,
-0.010582733,
0.0328882784,
-0.0074630775,
0.0415687636,
-0.0101294294,
0.05225382,
0.028074082,
-0.0510681905,
-0.0373971388,
-0.0025971581,
-0.0568926819,
-0.0244684014,
-0.0187584385,
0.0139378756,
-0.036941804,
0.0130232079,
0.0411340632,
-0.0200213194,
-0.0354340449,
0.0093061859,
0.0074452157,
0.0107012782,
-0.0323715732,
-0.0015040743,
-0.0218118187,
0.0126952706,
0.0184165742,
-0.049792368,
0.0324451774,
0.0323600061,
-0.0085370904,
0.0032543307,
-0.0732284114,
0.0125284018,
-0.0155947823,
0.0245822221,
0.0884560868,
0.0193459988,
0.0176927932,
0.0555842482,
0.0002367263,
0.0057437774,
0.0126806991,
-0.0229825377,
0.0777904168,
0.0293348823,
0.0082459236,
0.0794325843,
0.0664594695,
0.0249855686,
-0.0161246769,
-0.0011261574,
0.0360069722,
-0.0106016379,
0.016058065,
0.0194999035,
-0.0431613214,
-0.0246329065,
-0.029071603,
-0.008549707,
-0.0316996872,
-0.0532697812,
0.0654928684,
0.0359477662,
-0.0167666059,
0.0254621599,
0.0598651804,
-0.0314196572,
-0.0488729738,
0.0082995705,
-0.0119395144,
0.0401313156,
0.0119481497,
-0.0004232736,
-0.0643458664,
-0.0365815572,
-0.011925621,
0.0316059664,
0.0124678034,
0.0058807312,
0.0438525081,
0.0440215878,
-0.0710182711,
-0.0099491496,
-0.0418971889,
0.0209895261,
0.010822623,
-0.0053764586,
0.0307582524,
0.0212207064,
-0.0264658425,
0.0642326176,
-0.0071567455,
-0.0875509903,
-0.0062011476,
0.0053252424,
-0.0395603999,
0.0003326254,
-0.0236291736,
-0.0035890345,
-0.0296185818,
0.0374885984,
0.0423857756,
-0.0342105255,
0.0023203227,
0.0147044118,
2.756e-7,
0.0036777302,
0.0490523838,
0.0010859559,
0.0175233837,
0.0256105531,
0.0410276093,
-0.058873564,
0.0254384875,
0.0161007922,
-0.0348436162,
0.0108053805,
0.0282108206,
0.0428502075,
0.0269971918,
-0.1076116264,
-0.0111666005,
-0.0513933711,
0.037894845,
-0.0600489303,
-0.0006506802,
-0.003966732,
0.0858941451,
0.0414444767,
-0.018650284,
0.0194466636,
-0.0390842296,
0.0486999415,
-0.0089998608,
-0.0046713664,
-0.0044424082,
-0.0412534028,
0.0268971492,
0.0048168031,
0.0207408164,
-0.0233305655,
0.0157575905,
-0.0235835034,
0.0421661139,
0.0000254786,
-0.0346867368,
0.0092244353,
0.0062308777,
-0.0080576716,
-0.0354377069,
0.0743334815,
-0.0820325837,
0.0157431159,
-0.019615287,
0.0079206433,
-0.0199020524,
0.0139116216,
-0.0214095861,
-0.0247810762,
0.0271336716,
0.0321617238,
-0.0112006329,
-0.031697195,
-0.0507287718,
-0.0394011475,
0.0066584926,
-0.0515118949,
-0.0017006957,
-0.0576529801,
0.0111255934,
-0.0041661453,
-0.0575423427,
0.0065060705,
2.458485823e-34,
0.0115096383,
0.00455742,
0.0212807599,
0.0398784801,
-0.0255800597,
-0.0021567664,
-0.0224681608,
0.0285590701,
0.0392298289,
-0.0470895581,
-0.0151991565
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.