id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11922v1 | Selective Perception: Optimizing State Descriptions with Reinforcement Learning for Language Model Actors | 2023-07-21T22:02:50 | 2023-07-21T22:02:50 | Kolby Nottingham, Yasaman Razeghi, Kyungmin Kim, JB Lanier, Pierre Baldi, Roy Fox, Sameer Singh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are being applied as actors for sequential
decision making tasks in domains such as robotics and games, utilizing their
general world knowledge and planning abilities. However, previous work does
little to explore what environment state information is provided to LLM actors
via language. Exhaustively describing high-dimensional states can impair
performance and raise inference costs for LLM actors. Previous LLM actors avoid
the issue by relying on hand-engineered, task-specific protocols to determine
which features to communicate about a state and which to leave out. In this
work, we propose Brief Language INputs for DEcision-making Responses (BLINDER),
a method for automatically selecting concise state descriptions by learning a
value function for task-conditioned state descriptions. We evaluate BLINDER on
the challenging video game NetHack and a robotic manipulation task. Our method
improves task success rate, reduces input size and compute costs, and
generalizes between LLM actors. | [
0.0237701852,
0.0422915854,
-0.0170398019,
0.0259321649,
-0.0329654403,
-0.0129977688,
-0.0046907798,
0.0192105509,
-0.009594853,
-0.0372751281,
-0.0272615477,
-0.0257970262,
-0.0036805698,
0.0557453074,
0.0082144579,
-0.065386802,
0.0533926338,
-0.0853173509,
0.0277731158,
-0.0058922311,
-0.043600928,
-0.0173950586,
-0.0334445275,
0.0632071421,
0.0196310543,
-0.0159432478,
-0.0393385477,
-0.0146542778,
0.0187194552,
-0.0354875177,
-0.0225877147,
-0.0053197504,
0.0366407,
-0.0267741643,
0.0000022868,
-0.0411575064,
0.0030282009,
-0.0561003089,
0.0121228788,
-0.0289131366,
-0.0018686033,
-0.0171575993,
0.0069596735,
0.0101122409,
-0.024627341,
-0.0595302582,
0.0913614407,
0.0363224447,
0.0249072928,
0.0607647561,
-0.0055691455,
0.0384545252,
-0.0382204317,
-0.0117762471,
0.0101629561,
-0.0388040841,
0.0144665102,
-0.0046598264,
0.0645241961,
-0.0092858477,
-0.0555811338,
-0.0148854265,
0.0167476367,
-0.0251189452,
-0.0418327563,
0.0672823489,
0.0209544469,
0.0009426626,
0.0053255269,
0.043228928,
-0.0079496251,
-0.0049627004,
0.0432675332,
-0.013538857,
0.0243837293,
0.0028886953,
0.0072252969,
0.04433202,
-0.0097481422,
0.0091926428,
-0.0529033132,
0.036992047,
0.0260454006,
0.0103994515,
-0.0404802635,
0.1171705797,
-0.0221284907,
-0.0307912752,
-0.0045386525,
-0.029774446,
0.0185765997,
-0.0903044045,
-0.0264964085,
0.0381347872,
-0.0864012167,
-0.0067174402,
-0.028535597,
0.0187884886,
-0.0427938439,
-0.0307931062,
0.0315086916,
0.0560330041,
-0.005000615,
0.0495540537,
-0.010982641,
0.0750277415,
-0.0098934704,
0.0245776363,
-0.0278847609,
0.0142608909,
-0.0149370031,
0.0111018,
-0.0360047519,
0.0248962101,
-0.0301281922,
-0.0268183667,
-0.0109908096,
0.0379175059,
-0.0535192937,
0.0463488959,
-0.0409916453,
0.0148303621,
-0.0042973785,
-0.0066492152,
-0.0910097882,
0.0090859458,
-0.0258866344,
0.0104462737,
0.007529736,
-0.0142979855,
-0.0137125636,
0.0111935632,
0.0141409291,
-0.0348823294,
0.0100851404,
0.1050066352,
0.0164168477,
-0.0179621968,
0.0418702886,
0.0064692604,
-0.0007523286,
-0.0720951259,
0.0194531437,
-0.0468597859,
-0.0027560191,
-0.0058575966,
0.0246349517,
-0.0467005,
0.0070007662,
0.0143109541,
0.0370600075,
0.0956267938,
0.028767379,
0.0027478312,
-0.0081552723,
-0.0108290808,
-0.009704995,
0.0790574029,
0.0462816469,
0.0675995424,
-0.0119107682,
0.001068647,
0.0226057917,
0.0305725783,
-0.043732889,
0.0089311404,
-0.0616862774,
-0.0051363115,
0.0224690679,
0.0332029276,
0.0490341783,
0.0188629236,
-0.0323220082,
0.0007729446,
0.0558262803,
0.0560965799,
-0.0227763392,
-0.0335875079,
0.0542296916,
0.055028718,
-0.0126960594,
-0.0274506621,
-0.0278714783,
0.0672464445,
0.0190331452,
-0.008741064,
-0.0115253087,
0.0196159612,
-0.0086952727,
-0.0579055138,
0.0158213396,
-0.0277526248,
0.0700392053,
0.0826121718,
0.0586965866,
0.0081444671,
-0.0532423109,
-0.0042388854,
0.0236906465,
-0.0054202774,
0.0059794392,
-0.0568992049,
0.0355557092,
0.0623314381,
0.0283227526,
-0.0557881184,
-0.0232775472,
-0.0270106979,
-0.0069684857,
0.0391291231,
0.0217633005,
-0.0031992209,
0.0535216071,
-0.0059559499,
-0.0563781299,
-0.0018122534,
0.0233017951,
0.0427652113,
-0.0018024556,
-0.0060403696,
-0.0048745708,
-0.0072125052,
0.0126381712,
0.0129892128,
0.0240069684,
-0.071813494,
0.0421268791,
0.0011569288,
0.0573815182,
-0.0421494618,
0.0034989368,
0.0105150416,
-0.0099103246,
-0.0143311871,
-0.0018847294,
0.0082774758,
-0.0179534573,
-0.0169405732,
0.0117670214,
-0.0150598288,
0.0077088126,
0.0578073598,
-0.0176230893,
-0.0401964635,
0.0154295648,
-0.0209774356,
0.0313810073,
0.0219353773,
-0.0019040877,
-0.0017194204,
-0.0161387865,
-0.0187854767,
0.03100417,
-0.0105885481,
-0.0185395554,
-0.0019281885,
-0.001650915,
0.0017704478,
-0.0648782402,
-0.0111369304,
0.0362815,
-0.0056677642,
-0.0323459469,
0.0536110625,
0.0167939942,
-0.0089301625,
-0.0004254293,
-0.0554997511,
-0.0406552553,
-0.0230240356,
-0.0132020805,
-0.0145472372,
-0.0068777697,
-0.0048510646,
-0.0234538615,
-0.0017094403,
0.0097523946,
0.0108083403,
0.0159748122,
0.0063891313,
0.033850532,
-0.0343110561,
-0.0377012938,
-0.0089884773,
-0.0094020376,
0.013220204,
-0.0186846815,
-0.02375599,
-0.0573389605,
0.0390785076,
-0.0157739688,
0.0521881878,
-0.0550396517,
-0.0475563779,
0.0306748543,
-0.0399163701,
-0.0032731695,
0.0532867908,
-0.0248574317,
0.0293407887,
0.1178035885,
-0.0119202761,
-0.030951336,
0.0603371598,
-0.030079728,
-0.0019053298,
-0.0788469166,
-0.0093712518,
0.0505426452,
0.0689397007,
-0.0124661131,
0.0132416775,
-0.0874634683,
0.0050714277,
-0.0284874942,
-0.0519346036,
-0.0388241485,
-0.0088513922,
-0.053175807,
0.0518889204,
-0.0209377669,
-0.0226632282,
0.0686364844,
-0.0201303959,
-0.0044546244,
0.013509525,
-0.0098277917,
-0.0003517258,
0.0859062523,
0.0366751701,
0.0061594811,
0.0038650723,
-0.0174803454,
-0.0369364098,
-0.0284510534,
0.0174819753,
0.0055431514,
0.0201224871,
-0.0693326592,
0.0139509914,
0.0029708853,
-0.0560918637,
-0.0296117738,
0.0243755206,
-0.0391786285,
-0.0010631584,
-0.0056234268,
-0.0482957214,
-0.0418652557,
0.0082991309,
0.0659549236,
0.0628905147,
-0.0121821975,
-0.0072137094,
-0.0412692167,
-0.0535846874,
0.0859649703,
0.0376494527,
-0.0280903,
-0.0389819145,
0.0237877462,
0.0357365645,
0.0303906333,
-0.0083140898,
-0.0103718378,
0.0082837921,
0.0529498644,
-0.0307028573,
0.0094462875,
0.0843610689,
0.0344596133,
-0.0732243508,
-0.0423876345,
0.0670694858,
0.0086751292,
-0.0690551102,
0.0120780533,
-0.0221026,
0.0111074476,
0.0350607038,
0.0406223238,
-0.0414052792,
-0.0234015323,
-0.0182232708,
-0.0167842004,
-0.0000350722,
-0.0244085882,
0.0125542916,
-0.1129341274,
0.0217732247,
-0.007496173,
-0.0615177304,
-0.0456092544,
-0.0245979372,
0.0207475517,
-0.0138201183,
-0.0193802211,
-0.0031358616,
-0.0032238294,
-0.0169622842,
0.0063731871,
-0.0114915753,
-0.0188411884,
0.0327253155,
0.0041026971,
0.0316407345,
0.0677001774,
0.0368725955,
-0.0486990772,
-0.0158995446,
0.0170390159,
0.0197136365,
0.0036090815,
0.0057375231,
0.0032411979,
0.0154670011,
-0.0155363549,
0.0216915496,
-0.0097953463,
0.0284346156,
-0.0565472879,
-0.0040990207,
0.0797966123,
-0.064739652,
-0.0031120891,
0.0217125379,
-0.0187685955,
0.0480898954,
0.0531968698,
0.0057397247,
-0.0598987639,
-0.0495412201,
-0.023573162,
-0.0641194284,
-0.0468336828,
-0.062332809,
-0.0442636125,
0.0302304849,
-0.0138588669,
-0.0470493846,
-0.0299239643,
0.0704802349,
0.0136828413,
-0.002348827,
0.0125766788,
0.047991965,
0.039907366,
-0.0205129031,
0.0237517171,
-0.0331130177,
0.0008829334,
-0.0253495742,
-0.0183533542,
-0.0027402821,
-0.0574682318,
-0.0077548157,
0.0149950981,
-0.0125201605,
-0.039804887,
0.0098326048,
0.0802827179,
0.018203225,
0.0142812487,
-0.0168057494,
-0.0470618755,
0.0238935333,
-0.0150192128,
-0.0042092106,
0.0259639118,
0.0345941931,
0.0278714839,
0.0098208319,
0.0369029231,
-0.0688545853,
-0.0015226644,
0.0051514246,
0.0405878425,
-0.0245506372,
-0.0247606765,
0.0059490455,
-0.0361308381,
0.0532361753,
-0.0440742373,
0.0141098499,
-0.0058727679,
-0.0063850707,
-0.0452561118,
0.0044605872,
-0.0481185392,
0.0191995669,
0.0073551,
0.0261739586,
0.0473206267,
-0.0116216103,
0.0033863862,
-0.0060423426,
0.0160353929,
0.0217330344,
0.0472040884,
-0.0106471684,
0.0572781339,
0.013336963,
0.0220952984,
0.0309876185,
0.0038448048,
0.0218895562,
0.0246256199,
0.0423327498,
0.0455019623,
-0.0373218358,
-0.0851546079,
-0.0031441096,
-0.0231574904,
-0.090368472,
0.044490613,
0.0110370424,
0.0548721775,
-0.0250874776,
0.0145434868,
-0.0667689219,
0.0077193431,
-0.010951329,
0.0181932226,
0.0439316407,
-0.0569877289,
0.0328694023,
0.0496050119,
-0.021751428,
-0.0155327739,
0.0526418164,
0.0459234901,
0.0606331304,
-0.0106815975,
0.0041173217,
-0.027336875,
-0.0383007079,
-0.0152750323,
0.0401110575,
-0.0382600315,
0.01708024,
-0.0701050162,
-0.0519971736,
-0.0336066633,
0.0348267555,
-0.014878042,
-0.0587036796,
0.0517781042,
-0.0049143098,
0.0249149669,
-0.0393326618,
-0.0535110198,
-0.0430471674,
0.0189688578,
-0.0123041049,
-0.0405480377,
-6.231006088e-33,
0.0013335345,
-0.0590898693,
0.0428748764,
-0.0359694511,
-0.0005553394,
-0.0106403856,
-0.0609102249,
-0.0198029075,
0.0242375433,
0.0139837405,
-0.0115456367,
0.0011100749,
0.0051412401,
0.0202945322,
0.0326827727,
-0.0468619093,
0.0501311794,
0.0212203451,
-0.0650509372,
0.009162439,
0.0369342975,
-0.0199853405,
0.0552535467,
-0.05620116,
0.0092408787,
0.0404727533,
-0.0361033306,
0.0157330781,
-0.0086926408,
0.0428633615,
-0.0093033444,
0.0120763425,
0.0106476313,
-0.0607594736,
-0.0107348999,
0.0102707352,
-0.0334337912,
-0.033576306,
-0.0101582697,
-0.005308819,
-0.0453156382,
-0.0241671335,
-0.0061833644,
0.0250916611,
-0.0156835821,
0.0333818309,
0.0465333313,
-0.0277263969,
-0.0325754061,
-0.0013000802,
-0.0481266826,
0.00399767,
-0.0024869258,
-0.0197992269,
0.0731530786,
0.0562615916,
-0.0236927122,
-0.0303600859,
-0.0205801018,
0.025948599,
0.0138743399,
0.0190550368,
0.0397659279,
0.063434191,
0.0603880323,
0.0569139123,
0.0087816501,
-0.0048304363,
-0.020608332,
-0.0114898747,
0.0241004433,
0.028624177,
-0.0202572402,
0.0420815311,
0.0135412263,
-0.017228391,
-0.0438126586,
-0.0055869576,
-0.0152466083,
0.096887365,
0.0243527368,
0.0081014782,
-0.0563043356,
-0.0235463474,
-0.0239298772,
0.0274501666,
0.0071183611,
-0.0226107948,
0.0467563085,
0.0081238374,
0.0065647815,
-0.033356376,
0.0610219352,
-0.0021751579,
-0.0128255505,
0.0101735955,
-0.0230666269,
0.0332637429,
0.0025608488,
-0.0346319973,
-0.0245480873,
-0.0295075234,
0.0143357022,
-0.0277294964,
0.0226129275,
0.019769581,
-0.0384144858,
0.0714773163,
-0.0423429124,
0.0104840882,
-0.0410761759,
0.0068928036,
0.0284113158,
0.0369584598,
0.0574351177,
-0.0309673473,
-0.0085570551,
0.021231642,
-0.0302452911,
-0.0927826315,
0.0088275829,
0.0023835122,
-0.0458327681,
0.0276091322,
-0.043363709,
-0.0242112391,
-0.0561627559,
0.0569179468,
0.0106833261,
-0.0451306403,
0.0095030628,
0.0119013246,
3.182e-7,
-0.0337567218,
0.0359816253,
-0.0345483907,
0.0399182588,
-0.0146204941,
0.0707243532,
0.0071614916,
0.0121595617,
-0.0122240465,
-0.0104206633,
0.0332198888,
0.0589170903,
0.044663623,
-0.0110660959,
-0.1134184375,
0.0082611162,
0.0025554833,
-0.0081160674,
-0.0259831455,
0.0000331541,
0.0503516383,
0.0628435835,
0.0215430334,
0.0186410993,
0.0518390313,
-0.0268514175,
0.021554485,
-0.0858351812,
0.0308405776,
0.010509084,
0.034191858,
-0.0275439881,
-0.0089185154,
-0.0130666541,
-0.0102721844,
0.0184288435,
-0.0465051457,
0.0935952514,
0.0096486239,
-0.0282003544,
-0.042514801,
0.0384796336,
0.0186354239,
-0.0309672877,
0.064766705,
-0.0429033265,
-0.0029316607,
-0.0054389173,
0.0266170762,
-0.0136594428,
-0.0342922583,
0.0075880089,
-0.0282944329,
-0.0085793138,
-0.0162783898,
-0.0036963637,
0.0045812926,
-0.0705464929,
-0.0301784202,
0.02462749,
-0.0468364283,
-0.0189979207,
-0.0381460413,
0.0043314896,
0.0294548217,
-0.0597692244,
-0.0025851806,
3.018327176e-34,
-0.0019124475,
0.0008916068,
-0.0071017989,
0.0178734791,
0.0174651444,
0.0209968407,
-0.0061823367,
0.0450397953,
0.075748831,
-0.0187823195,
-0.0294529721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11865v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11865v3 | CARTIER: Cartographic lAnguage Reasoning Targeted at Instruction Execution for Robots | 2023-07-21T19:09:37 | 2024-02-01T16:32:38 | Dmitriy Rivkin, Nikhil Kakodkar, Francois Hogan, Bobak H. Baghi, Gregory Dudek | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL | This work explores the capacity of large language models (LLMs) to address
problems at the intersection of spatial planning and natural language
interfaces for navigation. We focus on following complex instructions that are
more akin to natural conversation than traditional explicit procedural
directives typically seen in robotics. Unlike most prior work where navigation
directives are provided as simple imperative commands (e.g., "go to the
fridge"), we examine implicit directives obtained through conversational
interactions.We leverage the 3D simulator AI2Thor to create household query
scenarios at scale, and augment it by adding complex language queries for 40
object types. We demonstrate that a robot using our method CARTIER
(Cartographic lAnguage Reasoning Targeted at Instruction Execution for Robots)
can parse descriptive language queries up to 42% more reliably than existing
LLM-enabled methods by exploiting the ability of LLMs to interpret the user
interaction in the context of the objects in the scenario. | [
0.0340393111,
0.0713485032,
-0.004528021,
0.0187519863,
-0.0215970632,
0.0237940326,
0.0125258472,
-0.0228965953,
0.0395551249,
-0.0364953429,
-0.0152366385,
0.0076696523,
0.0071636452,
-0.0003778593,
0.0010440821,
-0.0381237566,
0.0199197233,
-0.0621274486,
-0.0244277567,
0.0018269767,
-0.0245176498,
0.0335666128,
-0.0470178202,
0.0565958284,
0.000815114,
0.0024050779,
-0.0503995977,
0.0009878431,
-0.0169879422,
-0.0728081688,
-0.0181834605,
0.0173716433,
0.0658244491,
0.0176730752,
0.0000019653,
-0.0283400137,
0.0031549323,
0.0134624429,
-0.0231809895,
-0.0337386653,
0.0180980321,
-0.0232024416,
0.0397256389,
-0.0052147233,
-0.0353627391,
-0.000767031,
0.059094023,
0.0322284512,
0.0270533524,
0.0365937911,
-0.0055002063,
-0.0594549291,
-0.0322316736,
0.0230252836,
0.0335767232,
-0.0340554118,
0.0076842406,
0.0316177867,
0.0736304373,
0.0485001542,
-0.0144740036,
0.0142898113,
0.0292671546,
-0.0101144891,
-0.0329169407,
0.0499378182,
-0.0172054563,
-0.0204186216,
-0.02537244,
0.0538986176,
0.0471246429,
0.0024116626,
0.0449906625,
0.0327653214,
-0.0259147715,
-0.0185411405,
-0.0573960245,
0.0138032474,
0.0060925824,
-0.0206207968,
-0.0459325835,
-0.0162321925,
-0.0043204902,
0.016197551,
-0.0636107251,
0.1174976081,
-0.0053315018,
0.0022130883,
-0.0112139834,
-0.0260764267,
0.0203718599,
-0.0723543838,
-0.0020366372,
0.076934427,
-0.0742378831,
0.0212294776,
0.0008935875,
0.0873291939,
-0.0024335743,
-0.0370826162,
0.0140373912,
0.0511182696,
-0.016767662,
0.0297242329,
0.0306662749,
0.0845488459,
-0.020673994,
0.0576006137,
-0.0445542634,
-0.0107078888,
-0.0410459936,
0.001603007,
-0.0469783582,
0.0251931977,
-0.0661309808,
-0.0360007919,
0.0324699096,
0.0441742316,
0.0035250406,
0.0224650726,
-0.0327019878,
0.0219422765,
-0.0200386532,
-0.0016258686,
-0.0385953709,
-0.027268732,
-0.0448029339,
0.0106419763,
-0.0280628204,
-0.0276246853,
0.0060126772,
0.0241521914,
0.0051169558,
-0.0268498454,
-0.0059707677,
0.0835051164,
-0.0064774407,
-0.0207567364,
0.0277819466,
-0.0474892706,
-0.0308716483,
-0.0709161609,
0.0137591921,
-0.0711158961,
0.0107204486,
0.0057267291,
-0.0230861437,
-0.0250446703,
0.0103826672,
0.0078399424,
-0.0263906624,
0.0847197622,
0.0329760909,
0.0229272023,
0.0206694156,
0.0135478973,
0.031238256,
0.0443963557,
0.0543623492,
0.0330188237,
-0.0081769805,
0.0495174751,
0.0152396979,
0.0279142819,
-0.0263123699,
-0.0059405994,
-0.0194327477,
0.0263822451,
-0.0203691348,
0.0576286726,
-0.0209947862,
0.0431736,
-0.0125961406,
0.0103148073,
0.0161039345,
0.0527802743,
-0.0707667023,
-0.025348451,
0.0807568431,
0.0406398959,
-0.0279377289,
-0.0173578765,
-0.06459333,
0.0148817832,
-0.0325532854,
-0.0327106193,
-0.0362006575,
-0.0193112083,
-0.0101559944,
-0.0343163162,
0.0144562861,
0.0211942252,
0.0857907087,
0.0138961216,
0.0339545757,
0.0090604126,
-0.0158494711,
0.0085869376,
-0.0266230721,
-0.0311924536,
-0.0473169424,
-0.006831862,
0.0394948758,
0.0719435886,
0.007254825,
0.0079163853,
-0.0605583005,
0.0376791134,
0.0374660455,
0.013980763,
0.0136767365,
-0.0210424252,
0.0290873181,
-0.0181648545,
-0.0323600583,
0.0141163692,
0.0256480873,
0.0331225097,
0.0547835231,
-0.0193299465,
0.007566534,
-0.0314297304,
0.0092519531,
0.0349325947,
0.0121789705,
-0.0015900197,
-0.035198316,
0.0255057234,
-0.0077290633,
-0.0218101107,
0.0027881074,
0.0008411102,
0.0314224362,
-0.0170337781,
-0.0102301734,
0.0408934169,
-0.0396423265,
-0.0153212762,
0.012007596,
0.0001346339,
-0.0464237668,
0.0119969938,
-0.0293181203,
0.0035785139,
-0.0361213572,
-0.0340515897,
0.0255065653,
0.0205166377,
-0.0086369989,
0.0342828706,
-0.0484664664,
-0.033099331,
0.0233954303,
-0.028138509,
-0.0120212976,
0.0541266762,
0.0464190394,
0.0088774646,
-0.0114207417,
0.0258028153,
0.0277130567,
0.0154835125,
-0.0106253494,
0.0132112289,
0.0573293529,
-0.0002316716,
-0.0313738734,
-0.0914811715,
-0.0301268492,
-0.023321528,
-0.0237049069,
-0.0130158756,
-0.0252680089,
0.0082537578,
-0.0187869575,
0.0133553734,
0.0180953927,
-0.0194892026,
0.018137794,
0.0308660455,
0.0111826258,
-0.064059943,
0.0026837299,
0.0109400237,
-0.0236491933,
0.0029384706,
0.0402694307,
0.0103500392,
-0.0392518342,
-0.0032648519,
-0.0448964313,
0.0357252583,
-0.0210910998,
-0.0139930099,
0.0418768115,
-0.0602135137,
0.0110448189,
0.0568962172,
-0.0419968031,
0.0011460079,
0.0731150433,
-0.0636962056,
-0.0625224337,
0.0268694852,
-0.0173451733,
-0.0384163298,
-0.0572947487,
-0.0441326648,
0.0159787126,
0.0266535506,
-0.024396766,
0.0258346628,
-0.0304417852,
-0.016539963,
-0.0159408823,
-0.0467851721,
-0.0253520124,
0.0226750206,
-0.0126903141,
0.0886775553,
-0.0127978008,
-0.0244300831,
0.039516896,
-0.0614818633,
-0.0131748021,
-0.0115136662,
0.0069507072,
-0.0246118382,
0.107488215,
0.0257415213,
0.0235851817,
0.0084696114,
-0.0363722853,
-0.0018820048,
-0.0265747998,
-0.0292065982,
0.0104430886,
0.0504540019,
-0.1365561485,
0.0296100676,
0.0388777331,
-0.0678457394,
-0.0162807386,
0.0017838213,
-0.0376017652,
0.0171946008,
0.0033145982,
-0.0919616818,
0.0032330614,
0.0032997297,
0.0129571706,
0.0635170937,
-0.0057378672,
-0.0325754806,
-0.0410037264,
-0.0254348405,
0.0410820208,
0.0834553093,
-0.0735206977,
0.0145301111,
-0.0281714965,
0.0347164497,
0.0226994157,
-0.006922937,
-0.0588529482,
0.0509629287,
0.0307052862,
0.047604546,
-0.0050683147,
0.0604465753,
0.0452131741,
-0.0508078076,
-0.0735922679,
0.0916959569,
0.0255674403,
0.0128353098,
-0.0053740786,
-0.0170817319,
0.0268822573,
0.0333008319,
0.0270575453,
-0.0539759398,
-0.0323526189,
0.0285573211,
-0.0217389967,
0.009276065,
-0.0498584732,
-0.0100815715,
-0.1084225327,
0.056262929,
-0.0075747552,
-0.0667616129,
-0.0687858909,
0.0030692497,
-0.0079477178,
-0.0052732904,
-0.0326536112,
-0.0020340781,
0.0021008442,
-0.0155613134,
0.0000631537,
-0.0309923626,
0.0161001533,
0.0326406173,
-0.0185086206,
0.0268708132,
0.0474262312,
0.0643538237,
0.0245610178,
-0.0122991363,
-0.0008704343,
0.0658023506,
0.0142106656,
-0.0411335267,
-0.0280006975,
0.0113249188,
0.0030805019,
0.0173825435,
0.0283847358,
-0.0186837669,
-0.0196756348,
0.0055867406,
0.0402902588,
-0.0553800613,
0.0172078256,
-0.037349239,
0.044254031,
0.0255777054,
0.0520024337,
-0.0083266636,
0.023196049,
-0.0598945431,
-0.0673285797,
-0.0812374651,
0.0052338876,
-0.0511616617,
0.0052302233,
-0.0059403684,
-0.0135884797,
-0.0441832095,
-0.0217739828,
0.0564530902,
0.0385184251,
0.0077547641,
-0.0538491234,
0.0377842113,
0.0197165422,
-0.0250448771,
-0.0128199635,
-0.0593125895,
0.0292076916,
0.0076789744,
0.0242376383,
0.0162494015,
-0.0363586545,
-0.0262546446,
0.0503331386,
-0.033162605,
-0.0471402146,
0.0131840855,
0.0657209754,
0.0198828168,
0.0391639322,
-0.0305629726,
0.0019574899,
-0.0192531887,
0.02620239,
-0.0241083689,
0.0252027269,
0.0186785273,
0.0487180911,
0.0374118239,
0.0343429446,
-0.0417022631,
0.0275381133,
-0.0340110995,
0.0338586941,
-0.0802431405,
-0.0038198519,
0.0421628989,
-0.0033784586,
0.035390567,
0.0256172437,
0.0105060162,
0.0032474909,
0.0165248681,
-0.0327737518,
-0.0220578499,
-0.0412754528,
0.0202128347,
-0.0059304736,
0.0011796029,
0.020580003,
0.011679031,
0.0023945924,
0.0387162045,
0.0181625132,
-0.0150447376,
0.0285742283,
0.0008940581,
0.0580712892,
0.0154402498,
-0.0152335363,
0.0456527285,
-0.0151813664,
0.0701931566,
-0.0043776971,
0.0451247804,
0.0371536687,
-0.0243540015,
-0.0537834577,
-0.0075332844,
-0.0536077209,
-0.1140342578,
0.0543550216,
0.0224943999,
0.0258532055,
-0.0072363913,
0.0202013012,
-0.0791537017,
0.0099972785,
-0.0017749765,
0.0295586381,
0.062727958,
-0.0479829423,
0.0428617932,
0.0166980419,
-0.010697037,
-0.0158714373,
0.0111927306,
-0.0052256281,
0.0624402314,
0.0326844268,
-0.0440523177,
-0.0429059006,
-0.0550174713,
0.0345374309,
0.0108756246,
-0.0008079683,
-0.0200049113,
-0.0235920381,
-0.016267037,
-0.0399845801,
0.0285756886,
-0.0110408934,
-0.025366364,
0.0647969916,
0.0381241329,
-0.01130006,
-0.0534593686,
-0.0214254018,
-0.0026061588,
-0.0367935337,
-0.018356951,
-0.044345323,
-5.699097466e-33,
-0.0413186029,
-0.0990190953,
0.0686320066,
-0.0227153134,
0.0091002975,
-0.035052076,
-0.0651297346,
-0.0150987925,
-0.0148731256,
-0.0034329046,
0.0070360126,
0.0104324147,
0.007684696,
0.0333065726,
0.0348971412,
-0.0237003472,
0.0355272666,
0.0296182204,
-0.0250348095,
-0.0052081277,
0.0177710652,
-0.0161207896,
-0.0185582656,
-0.0600573495,
0.0114464248,
-0.0058723451,
-0.0114295771,
0.0611946546,
-0.0313958786,
0.027439801,
-0.0203516483,
-0.0123735322,
0.0046548261,
0.0115211038,
-0.0255016927,
0.0304682422,
-0.0697145537,
-0.0258984175,
0.0049147271,
0.0264988672,
-0.0601993538,
-0.0200867392,
0.0215162765,
0.0013303921,
-0.0167747177,
0.0021681881,
0.0211532619,
-0.0068415338,
-0.0183186363,
0.0514314994,
-0.0426680632,
0.0121303154,
-0.017171884,
-0.0583589002,
0.0443131365,
0.0661611333,
0.0307471622,
0.0109279333,
-0.0034239925,
0.023877224,
-0.0201222636,
-0.0124752494,
0.0313317813,
-0.0220941119,
0.0155313648,
0.0381609164,
0.0445294492,
-0.0193403158,
-0.043120373,
0.0012365864,
0.0044636619,
0.0931411013,
-0.0334883742,
0.0252907854,
0.0043586977,
0.0543645248,
-0.0368288867,
0.0112708155,
-0.0614993162,
0.0604071021,
0.0152641125,
0.0102079408,
-0.0496028513,
-0.0069343401,
-0.0294337794,
0.0112808244,
-0.008932597,
0.0017359756,
0.0176127534,
0.0136872791,
0.0086871497,
-0.0111602973,
0.0164725445,
-0.0001978968,
-0.0371456556,
0.0210955553,
-0.0095160976,
-0.0100491215,
-0.0288035516,
0.0587079749,
-0.0095645264,
-0.0312928744,
0.0113030905,
-0.0181550048,
0.0200983975,
0.0504249483,
-0.0211028755,
0.0715653971,
-0.0158079881,
-0.0379920378,
-0.0542391948,
-0.0361780524,
-0.0264768377,
0.0136531098,
0.0514145382,
0.0155862868,
-0.0198241938,
0.0610998422,
-0.0516152941,
-0.0304752514,
-0.0287063699,
-0.0133254053,
-0.019157771,
-0.0102743162,
-0.0342130661,
-0.0019327112,
-0.0441733599,
-0.0090707401,
0.0187122263,
-0.0335589126,
-0.005203329,
0.0114879655,
2.746e-7,
0.0018461625,
0.0684594139,
0.0167702865,
0.0645961016,
-0.0275101569,
0.0270157661,
0.0035392421,
0.0338257216,
-0.0447109044,
0.0008534435,
0.0329970904,
0.0504302494,
0.0160213169,
0.0071425466,
-0.0909992531,
0.0363892727,
0.0135366274,
-0.0570695698,
-0.0820990652,
0.0101644034,
0.0664977282,
0.0366377123,
-0.0090261763,
0.0243366323,
0.0149906836,
-0.0280276146,
-0.0088316975,
-0.0463241786,
0.0392047875,
-0.0006217147,
-0.0110089062,
0.021517843,
0.0166663844,
-0.0223363824,
0.0073535531,
-0.0347803719,
-0.0108762551,
0.0951824188,
-0.0093310773,
-0.0271714702,
-0.0128260795,
-0.040622551,
-0.0269488562,
-0.0428976901,
0.0455798209,
-0.0520417467,
0.0346477665,
0.0331740752,
0.0546856783,
-0.0181022789,
-0.0352921784,
0.0206662118,
0.0080293426,
-0.0202500075,
0.0202750769,
-0.015780326,
0.0132854627,
-0.0641406253,
0.0045702825,
-0.0087431874,
-0.0473764911,
-0.0188051034,
-0.0172171425,
0.0025991923,
-0.0393281281,
0.0020448931,
-0.0337302387,
2.307904079e-34,
-0.0043830527,
0.03884672,
-0.0064454963,
0.0357527696,
0.0664016977,
0.0192705654,
0.0235364959,
0.025974622,
0.0342613049,
-0.0773689821,
-0.0209852755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11864v1 | The Looming Threat of Fake and LLM-generated LinkedIn Profiles: Challenges and Opportunities for Detection and Prevention | 2023-07-21T19:09:24 | 2023-07-21T19:09:24 | Navid Ayoobi, Sadat Shahriar, Arjun Mukherjee | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | In this paper, we present a novel method for detecting fake and Large
Language Model (LLM)-generated profiles in the LinkedIn Online Social Network
immediately upon registration and before establishing connections. Early fake
profile identification is crucial to maintaining the platform's integrity since
it prevents imposters from acquiring the private and sensitive information of
legitimate users and from gaining an opportunity to increase their credibility
for future phishing and scamming activities. This work uses textual information
provided in LinkedIn profiles and introduces the Section and Subsection Tag
Embedding (SSTE) method to enhance the discriminative characteristics of these
data for distinguishing between legitimate profiles and those created by
imposters manually or by using an LLM. Additionally, the dearth of a large
publicly available LinkedIn dataset motivated us to collect 3600 LinkedIn
profiles for our research. We will release our dataset publicly for research
purposes. This is, to the best of our knowledge, the first large publicly
available LinkedIn dataset for fake LinkedIn account detection. Within our
paradigm, we assess static and contextualized word embeddings, including GloVe,
Flair, BERT, and RoBERTa. We show that the suggested method can distinguish
between legitimate and fake profiles with an accuracy of about 95% across all
word embeddings. In addition, we show that SSTE has a promising accuracy for
identifying LLM-generated profiles, despite the fact that no LLM-generated
profiles were employed during the training phase, and can achieve an accuracy
of approximately 90% when only 20 LLM-generated profiles are added to the
training set. It is a significant finding since the proliferation of several
LLMs in the near future makes it extremely challenging to design a single
system that can identify profiles created with various LLMs. | [
0.0741266683,
0.0223712809,
-0.0114835948,
0.0589758456,
-0.0206353329,
0.0029692177,
0.0477584675,
0.0433325022,
0.0568661764,
-0.0074915132,
-0.0100293048,
-0.0246694349,
0.0131193567,
0.0513524972,
0.0314882062,
0.0060559115,
0.0164073054,
0.0048247818,
-0.01705743,
0.0012256281,
0.0109060174,
0.0265679285,
0.022934882,
0.0579058193,
-0.0052663563,
0.0034411873,
0.0529070199,
0.0152542265,
0.0163903646,
-0.0225355495,
0.0318391323,
0.0629199296,
-0.0360020921,
0.0825126916,
0.0000017753,
-0.0461303778,
0.0251864586,
-0.0028719108,
-0.0286583789,
0.0544414707,
0.0882717445,
0.0084282635,
0.0010069987,
0.034121383,
-0.0596724972,
-0.0045926906,
-0.0052998639,
0.0382471569,
0.0531043634,
0.0549566858,
-0.0250021629,
-0.0500708744,
-0.0018607975,
-0.032073658,
-0.027285926,
0.0004729783,
0.0670177713,
-0.0099247368,
-0.0018583062,
0.047260683,
-0.0041427203,
0.0185057893,
-0.0307922699,
-0.0270025786,
0.0411477573,
0.0288741663,
-0.0522241741,
-0.0156375393,
0.0188021995,
0.0473864973,
-0.0594901145,
-0.0345822386,
0.0291554946,
-0.0239408128,
-0.0044558179,
0.0485279039,
0.0278764963,
0.0273023061,
-0.0013568553,
-0.0080284989,
0.0059281257,
0.0214373525,
0.0625330731,
0.0100838784,
-0.0175740179,
0.0109234862,
-0.0041432893,
-0.0447968729,
-0.0160419438,
-0.0404778793,
0.0110183824,
-0.0568963513,
0.0268760044,
-0.0143487286,
0.0105280476,
-0.0037973945,
-0.0790784582,
-0.0201484561,
0.0169242937,
-0.0535392389,
-0.0075648841,
-0.0044647842,
0.0143103739,
0.0172933377,
-0.0168270227,
0.0134901861,
0.0040847659,
0.0023899223,
-0.0108796256,
0.0022196891,
-0.0507016331,
-0.0084865,
0.0048561632,
0.0021732224,
0.0055406028,
0.003801249,
-0.1004936174,
0.0322530419,
-0.0246833395,
0.0443281308,
-0.019471975,
-0.0136959003,
0.0270861406,
0.004301941,
0.0005867363,
-0.0375145972,
0.0045079421,
-0.0513346158,
-0.0319799967,
-0.0372991562,
0.0310670305,
0.0542878956,
0.0273255538,
-0.0277931746,
0.0029487326,
-0.0017551506,
0.0514155328,
-0.071625717,
-0.0321284533,
-0.0382599905,
-0.0114083663,
0.0065040644,
-0.0154423974,
-0.0488900729,
0.0133811235,
-0.0035821742,
-0.0087092994,
-0.0279172678,
-0.0110387681,
0.0260134265,
-0.0641016588,
0.0465759635,
-0.0319975689,
0.0284572449,
0.0067410753,
0.0120397974,
-0.0149627933,
-0.0018447922,
-0.0090403184,
0.0757869184,
0.064789772,
-0.0166757219,
0.0138740735,
0.0608487278,
0.022438284,
-0.0159057751,
0.0080421623,
0.0115931816,
0.027793536,
-0.0090429829,
0.0218808763,
0.0365600549,
-0.0392884314,
-0.0352293216,
0.0629258603,
0.0986586437,
0.0122315632,
-0.0034366101,
0.0720074251,
0.0321306661,
-0.000719618,
-0.0070281071,
-0.0619237795,
-0.070217751,
-0.0551074035,
-0.0371471867,
0.0039336421,
0.0272722188,
0.0171307027,
0.0152609302,
-0.0204892047,
-0.0329715945,
0.01378919,
-0.000888571,
-0.0002643234,
0.0141858738,
0.0012665896,
0.007740966,
0.0114679355,
0.0017805159,
-0.0002431282,
-0.0277019106,
0.0238977931,
0.077418156,
0.04934562,
0.0275780018,
0.0129673788,
-0.058133129,
0.0056416965,
0.0462106615,
0.0347560458,
-0.0040286649,
-0.0233525727,
-0.0573275834,
-0.036154218,
-0.0110550057,
-0.0188815072,
-0.0158147514,
0.0490135215,
0.0192649364,
0.0430913568,
-0.0296995565,
-0.0254448187,
0.02270131,
-0.091589734,
0.00221316,
0.0199023727,
0.0262270253,
0.0005547244,
0.0370638967,
0.0256856233,
-0.0205513593,
0.02518267,
-0.0157685038,
-0.0073825014,
-0.0580093041,
0.0256896447,
0.028654905,
0.0247854386,
-0.0276030619,
-0.0713056624,
0.025664689,
-0.027712578,
0.0200556014,
0.0339789614,
-0.0089258086,
0.0302381162,
-0.045776058,
-0.029959945,
-0.0582195148,
0.0682874322,
0.0308878832,
0.0730031803,
-0.0598727278,
0.0473906994,
0.0010274419,
-0.0434315801,
0.0100600719,
-0.0565607212,
-0.0335459709,
-0.0210988577,
0.0229607075,
-0.0028479893,
0.0060552489,
-0.0019546868,
-0.0140045863,
-0.0026859355,
-0.0435309261,
-0.0219399929,
-0.0298959818,
0.0177921206,
0.001780694,
0.0087892562,
-0.000186154,
0.0263372026,
-0.048194509,
-0.0247414,
0.007317496,
0.0152820982,
0.0421350487,
-0.0353052765,
-0.0459440723,
-0.0109483162,
-0.0059480071,
-0.0007126806,
0.0571895987,
0.0010893415,
-0.0654477999,
-0.0499668159,
-0.0037897879,
-0.0283028372,
-0.0070350454,
-0.0149986576,
-0.0014095883,
-0.0130796544,
0.0025130284,
0.0257095732,
-0.0261132084,
0.039192751,
0.0410307571,
-0.0034870016,
0.0601073913,
-0.0040856991,
-0.0617618151,
0.0046478347,
0.0509292856,
-0.0521149747,
-0.0717644915,
0.0328549184,
-0.0070212744,
0.0370639376,
-0.0020511968,
-0.0118206991,
0.0257130545,
0.0006773815,
-0.0167889707,
-0.0060776146,
-0.014687092,
0.0174952894,
-0.0153294643,
-0.0000219138,
-0.0408071578,
0.0570487007,
-0.0308137052,
0.0392908566,
0.0298050698,
-0.1045843661,
-0.0019357387,
0.0035850096,
0.0267956555,
0.0399896279,
0.0254737977,
-0.0369712375,
0.0315501355,
-0.0027033931,
0.0394569151,
-0.0449426062,
-0.0389586277,
0.0679854751,
0.0241862554,
0.0408773758,
0.0266292188,
-0.0628250092,
-0.0747786313,
-0.0609477684,
-0.0139850564,
-0.0101486528,
-0.0606652722,
0.0026380622,
-0.0109232655,
-0.0298233349,
-0.0163523536,
-0.0151028819,
-0.0122606298,
-0.0173465274,
0.0397998802,
0.0064026299,
-0.0369775221,
0.0243978929,
-0.018896345,
-0.011520464,
0.0224182084,
0.0019795634,
0.0013160373,
-0.037565086,
-0.0289071146,
0.0215787701,
-0.0408888608,
-0.029556388,
-0.0014692385,
-0.0372959338,
-0.0101181269,
-0.0032025359,
0.0925001353,
0.0459300093,
-0.0154078286,
0.0291386396,
0.0069736158,
-0.0355359763,
0.0001108391,
0.0229123551,
-0.0610341094,
-0.0241180006,
-0.0030631959,
0.0259400923,
-0.0021628689,
-0.0492495857,
0.0048556691,
-0.1061392874,
0.0198236946,
0.0193562768,
-0.0122060645,
-0.0534038879,
-0.0366519056,
-0.0541586168,
0.0301403217,
0.0444361493,
-0.040196348,
-0.0414266773,
0.0014458728,
-0.0215465762,
-0.0505409949,
-0.0630308986,
0.0037993381,
-0.069744423,
0.0714053735,
0.023688212,
0.0391350202,
-0.0089740111,
-0.0790850595,
0.0359224826,
0.0162197929,
-0.0090534547,
-0.0013660626,
0.0533008985,
-0.0350309424,
0.011916602,
-0.0408244617,
0.0272117537,
-0.0067415358,
-0.0083285114,
-0.0269838646,
0.0483819246,
-0.0234607887,
-0.0293543953,
-0.0163932648,
0.0066187503,
0.0343653746,
0.0741815642,
0.0198425129,
-0.0368125811,
0.0051621632,
-0.0308328196,
0.0006724995,
0.0192586295,
-0.030136833,
0.0593234003,
-0.0234992802,
0.0021881051,
-0.0435616001,
-0.0074460614,
-0.0099835927,
-0.0022216067,
0.0267080218,
0.0161012802,
0.0008621172,
-0.0362285078,
-0.0765520409,
0.0002119336,
-0.0729653239,
0.0882124305,
-0.0292213503,
0.0356463194,
-0.0215058364,
-0.0375098325,
0.0038255665,
0.0010695442,
-0.0518460013,
-0.0326428376,
-0.036599379,
-0.0198622532,
0.0135695664,
0.0322054066,
-0.0680557117,
-0.0907491222,
0.091598168,
0.0217214637,
-0.0032494029,
0.0073896567,
0.0124229807,
0.0143403839,
0.0171698742,
0.0204331297,
-0.0196147859,
-0.0323227458,
0.0210520737,
-0.0368722342,
-0.0267414134,
-0.0084657986,
-0.0337665826,
0.0419419408,
0.0275388677,
0.0114211095,
0.0222575776,
-0.0283257905,
-0.0715874583,
-0.0328860991,
-0.0145444991,
0.0284006875,
-0.0157093499,
0.0629257113,
0.0194769595,
0.0149103776,
0.0114754206,
-0.0614072047,
0.0483144596,
-0.0484202616,
0.0040102629,
-0.0210946873,
0.0255717784,
0.0164660309,
0.0110391947,
-0.0069089355,
0.0378974043,
0.0113412514,
0.0592116937,
0.0008074455,
0.0018564378,
-0.0139937336,
0.0060452586,
0.0110703595,
0.026338568,
-0.0351289064,
0.0059339157,
0.0111167002,
0.028607998,
0.0220883992,
-0.0125267729,
0.0431198552,
-0.0013169849,
-0.0010774905,
-0.0000423863,
-0.0045817937,
-0.0362257957,
-0.0642393529,
-0.0073670074,
-0.0085316123,
-0.0460691564,
0.0510863401,
0.0668688044,
0.0504438356,
0.0074753957,
-0.0139144128,
-0.0818296224,
-0.0157875419,
0.0255148672,
0.0585992001,
0.0684898272,
-0.0564787611,
-0.0168566443,
-0.075660266,
-0.0744426027,
0.0303950384,
-0.0153183741,
-0.0141655449,
0.0579591244,
-0.0285962448,
0.0205935817,
0.0075484016,
0.0154538769,
-0.065475218,
0.010485284,
0.0215341616,
-0.059845794,
0.024243705,
-5.361599813e-33,
0.0581068024,
-0.0983369723,
-0.0114344377,
-0.0016209938,
-0.0120842075,
0.0648839101,
0.0206993669,
-0.0523109138,
-0.0053053889,
0.0168084633,
-0.0105577288,
0.0307077318,
-0.0029434289,
0.0340280011,
-0.039075546,
0.0078034587,
0.0477333367,
0.0262883287,
0.0007168656,
0.0061870529,
0.0561488122,
0.0169777256,
0.0100469571,
-0.0346454941,
0.0575865768,
-0.0421548635,
-0.0088022929,
0.0110615678,
0.0316459164,
0.0432661511,
-0.0433389992,
0.0484806858,
0.0184558015,
0.0262749624,
0.0142707229,
0.0237413794,
-0.0285092574,
-0.0088124126,
0.0028513093,
0.0348372981,
0.0493858308,
-0.0154122422,
0.0411578529,
-0.0391148143,
-0.0219586529,
0.0259468947,
0.0363797359,
0.0098744128,
-0.0294536036,
-0.0515911914,
-0.0131218443,
0.034961883,
0.0068564001,
0.0444412306,
0.0427532271,
0.0384807363,
0.0333769806,
0.0300789084,
-0.1146353781,
0.0348753966,
-0.0478629954,
-0.0499956571,
-0.002116082,
0.0047788261,
-0.0037820337,
0.0661793053,
0.0456593446,
0.0007653521,
-0.0102812313,
0.0325695239,
-0.0042353403,
0.0044151195,
0.0106535377,
0.0568125248,
-0.0116220256,
-0.0488689691,
-0.0478685796,
0.0176116284,
0.0755587444,
-0.0509406403,
0.0443886183,
0.0012003076,
-0.0670441315,
-0.0119640501,
0.001045463,
-0.0405548885,
-0.0502635203,
-0.0316407904,
0.014474323,
0.0115483468,
-0.0724881068,
0.0350774787,
-0.012026188,
-0.0937267914,
-0.0220237058,
0.0234273691,
-0.0001322106,
0.0069135842,
0.0179522429,
0.0404870659,
-0.0116527118,
-0.0330041796,
0.0353948846,
-0.0722378194,
0.0038446742,
-0.0201190598,
0.0517006703,
-0.0101680905,
-0.0484561548,
-0.0364378542,
0.0071432823,
-0.0038856692,
-0.0298372321,
0.0018644584,
0.0403725356,
0.0427595936,
-0.0133541767,
0.0260439795,
0.0510408431,
0.0518108457,
0.0090800347,
-0.0141659575,
0.0018404259,
0.0293917656,
-0.0177245159,
-0.0021521468,
-0.0480990335,
0.0628807694,
0.0463603884,
-0.0672203228,
0.0000234205,
-0.0172564834,
2.589e-7,
0.018943157,
0.0435027294,
-0.0390623473,
-0.0055140471,
0.0141380476,
0.0560179912,
0.0623167604,
0.008264374,
-0.0206476022,
-0.0482069515,
-0.0153043699,
0.0209963247,
0.0135729806,
0.0001578946,
-0.0607870892,
0.0130625702,
-0.0001714144,
-0.0263733901,
-0.0512025766,
0.0230664182,
0.0383876152,
0.0606244877,
0.0730526,
-0.0376948118,
-0.0055108117,
-0.0342570506,
0.0088029178,
0.0069572628,
-0.0828947946,
-0.0109127434,
0.0425998755,
0.0199526493,
0.0278505553,
0.009606625,
-0.0517972969,
0.0429267026,
0.0221050587,
0.0068416446,
-0.0028421739,
0.0580022968,
-0.0608003326,
-0.076461412,
0.0086684916,
-0.0397407301,
0.0595931187,
-0.00570584,
-0.0277638268,
-0.0458854623,
-0.0492146686,
-0.0256279688,
0.0300017372,
-0.0298228506,
-0.0369532742,
0.0872559696,
0.0357248336,
-0.0080577256,
-0.0223643221,
-0.0574059971,
0.0592577979,
0.00032734,
-0.0234074108,
-0.0087051447,
-0.0066147237,
0.0240581408,
0.0831622332,
-0.0271143299,
0.0115274275,
2.472105716e-34,
0.0195887554,
-0.0032370093,
0.015344834,
-0.0256188232,
0.032355573,
0.0251943097,
-0.0236429088,
0.0288207959,
0.0117947226,
-0.0245426632,
0.0219734609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11848v1 | MythQA: Query-Based Large-Scale Check-Worthy Claim Detection through Multi-Answer Open-Domain Question Answering | 2023-07-21T18:35:24 | 2023-07-21T18:35:24 | Yang Bai, Anthony Colas, Daisy Zhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Check-worthy claim detection aims at providing plausible misinformation to
downstream fact-checking systems or human experts to check. This is a crucial
step toward accelerating the fact-checking process. Many efforts have been put
into how to identify check-worthy claims from a small scale of pre-collected
claims, but how to efficiently detect check-worthy claims directly from a
large-scale information source, such as Twitter, remains underexplored. To fill
this gap, we introduce MythQA, a new multi-answer open-domain question
answering(QA) task that involves contradictory stance mining for query-based
large-scale check-worthy claim detection. The idea behind this is that
contradictory claims are a strong indicator of misinformation that merits
scrutiny by the appropriate authorities. To study this task, we construct
TweetMythQA, an evaluation dataset containing 522 factoid multi-answer
questions based on controversial topics. Each question is annotated with
multiple answers. Moreover, we collect relevant tweets for each distinct
answer, then classify them into three categories: "Supporting", "Refuting", and
"Neutral". In total, we annotated 5.3K tweets. Contradictory evidence is
collected for all answers in the dataset. Finally, we present a baseline system
for MythQA and evaluate existing NLP models for each system component using the
TweetMythQA dataset. We provide initial benchmarks and identify key challenges
for future models to improve upon. Code and data are available at:
https://github.com/TonyBY/Myth-QA | [
0.0507075265,
0.0253879782,
0.0299475044,
0.0394554436,
-0.0301813334,
0.0211027544,
-0.0182482488,
-0.0151533755,
0.0145050408,
-0.0504048839,
0.0069641592,
-0.0171480943,
-0.0144362282,
0.022349976,
-0.0075025805,
0.0236170124,
0.0583297759,
0.0248307064,
0.0693001449,
-0.0263314098,
0.0387783162,
0.0602191724,
-0.0572392829,
0.0368933007,
-0.0485946648,
-0.0390744843,
0.0496133715,
0.0026482653,
0.0486543775,
-0.0254151728,
0.0266494807,
0.0326629244,
0.0183453429,
0.0664662868,
0.0000014286,
-0.0494399481,
-0.0206263978,
0.0036974298,
-0.0233608931,
0.0177529808,
-0.0005301208,
-0.0005730117,
0.0427900031,
0.0391771495,
-0.0105084712,
0.0281924624,
0.0321421586,
0.0657765046,
0.1023347005,
0.0612348765,
0.0057034004,
-0.0075381175,
-0.0331152007,
0.007101852,
-0.0338908024,
-0.0388566814,
0.0433406718,
0.0173229538,
-0.0171460491,
0.0351346433,
0.0248959698,
0.0134844407,
0.0234139524,
0.0040530222,
-0.05840794,
-0.0036469337,
-0.0461397022,
-0.01827644,
0.0076155802,
0.0542602353,
0.0241179522,
-0.0594241507,
0.0047978028,
0.0008385836,
0.0176884439,
0.0198181123,
-0.0178855471,
0.0479018465,
-0.0381063446,
0.0120660281,
0.0189909711,
0.0020249006,
0.0189271048,
0.0470230579,
0.026276812,
0.0375085026,
-0.0341401547,
-0.0507280976,
0.0180857666,
0.0153363543,
-0.0584949814,
-0.0528978817,
0.0302399993,
0.0224749763,
-0.0346303545,
0.0202388652,
-0.0295786932,
-0.045517236,
0.0768914968,
-0.0872659385,
-0.033822991,
-0.0044203741,
-0.0207505729,
0.0614677593,
-0.0244748853,
-0.0001438247,
-0.0247405954,
-0.0314159989,
0.0165284127,
-0.0665605217,
-0.0261491612,
-0.0120361205,
-0.036470186,
0.0417197049,
-0.0664510503,
0.0283038206,
-0.0158982445,
-0.0359031036,
-0.0441114679,
-0.0113264145,
0.0237228572,
0.0316475816,
0.0166934729,
-0.0062036752,
-0.0376840867,
0.0315075591,
-0.0486470051,
0.0233735479,
-0.0249493476,
-0.0365036465,
-0.0171565711,
0.0113041308,
-0.0042730677,
0.0099442108,
-0.0004360743,
-0.0089343861,
0.0063287779,
0.0138019649,
-0.021017557,
-0.0380199738,
-0.0001979891,
-0.0331185535,
0.006825326,
-0.0695355162,
0.023322165,
-0.0088506807,
-0.0062277638,
-0.004035369,
0.0159639213,
0.0691296533,
-0.0100577455,
0.0117350658,
-0.0004730622,
-0.0282656476,
0.0527717546,
0.0118469046,
0.0254867896,
0.0828309432,
0.0160092264,
0.0152902966,
0.0717395246,
0.0749192536,
-0.00304743,
-0.0120810522,
0.0794400424,
0.0346492082,
0.0803086609,
0.0421778336,
-0.021144392,
-0.0195831433,
-0.0285604354,
0.0211310629,
0.0023764814,
-0.085208863,
0.0207612012,
-0.0107245231,
-0.0323333517,
-0.0338328257,
0.017317621,
0.0210061781,
0.025435403,
-0.0428520292,
-0.0092828628,
0.0305151884,
-0.0644878671,
-0.0467138402,
0.0273638461,
0.0672536492,
-0.0015528713,
-0.0367887318,
-0.0155753559,
0.0259149615,
-0.0262162033,
-0.0146712344,
-0.0158091132,
0.0141134532,
-0.0484589599,
0.0375949107,
0.029899938,
-0.0220426675,
-0.0247381572,
-0.0279535223,
0.0312563851,
-0.0360610187,
0.0154268714,
-0.0405384861,
0.0008110127,
-0.0224310886,
0.0384961963,
0.0663248226,
0.0364633389,
-0.0302748084,
0.0006803964,
0.0135954693,
0.0056685251,
-0.0255563781,
0.0196431484,
-0.0145916762,
0.0599077865,
0.0357721858,
-0.0073282137,
-0.0315615796,
-0.0228744484,
0.0111309104,
0.0059772753,
0.0085317921,
0.0285984054,
0.0139384717,
0.0146389678,
0.0539385937,
-0.0090433992,
-0.0076741292,
0.0430360287,
-0.0051930109,
-0.0701670423,
-0.0132860551,
0.0338639468,
-0.0393225364,
0.035166502,
-0.026221741,
-0.0667183772,
0.0437952392,
-0.0417728797,
0.0021856127,
-0.0162128787,
-0.0224389192,
-0.0503317155,
-0.0265143942,
-0.050220795,
-0.0076009268,
-0.0048811049,
-0.0113617582,
0.0689947754,
-0.0238822009,
0.0164380074,
-0.0120189572,
-0.0097343456,
0.0410171747,
-0.0059477333,
0.0022784595,
0.011875337,
0.0053686649,
0.0109237619,
0.0357063562,
-0.0406096466,
-0.0451911502,
0.0347899646,
-0.0764951482,
0.0191323142,
-0.0372539088,
0.0174048562,
0.0416219011,
-0.0342997387,
0.0020833293,
0.00213845,
-0.0109703308,
-0.0215872135,
0.0399566963,
0.0111348396,
0.0276085008,
-0.0080573373,
0.034791261,
-0.0114552416,
0.0101260208,
-0.0506526232,
0.0314822942,
0.0055081355,
-0.0239089895,
-0.0194760226,
-0.0319443978,
-0.0558043346,
0.0041495566,
0.001055156,
0.0151704829,
0.0347409658,
0.0345664881,
-0.0008646602,
0.0076559,
0.0300103426,
0.0066221855,
0.0029161111,
0.0189686678,
-0.0150114624,
0.0114035672,
-0.0205551162,
0.0216059983,
0.011109083,
-0.0345223509,
0.0501114428,
0.0408548042,
0.0022846172,
-0.0139926746,
-0.0597408228,
0.0217218157,
-0.0501565114,
-0.0285700578,
0.0095000779,
0.0246772114,
0.0032461816,
0.0300836824,
-0.0290376395,
-0.0080440417,
0.0777455941,
-0.0103919795,
0.0383124277,
-0.0735163465,
-0.0293549877,
-0.0425805189,
0.0402861796,
-0.019571647,
0.017810056,
0.0385571979,
0.0381725989,
0.0345765688,
-0.0428618789,
0.0151160806,
-0.0212846976,
-0.0116456021,
-0.0294733439,
0.0250307322,
-0.012069731,
-0.0464378707,
-0.0241390262,
-0.086832121,
-0.0307785738,
-0.0104547553,
-0.0553926006,
-0.0209565684,
-0.0507256053,
-0.0340634026,
0.008705765,
0.0006374363,
-0.0018118628,
-0.0050705355,
0.0251808371,
0.0216516741,
0.0479663871,
0.0422958322,
0.0606192574,
0.0082193073,
-0.0291230064,
0.0673067719,
-0.0258423872,
0.0149024986,
0.0190722477,
-0.0685314462,
-0.0330122039,
-0.0383289345,
0.0426072404,
-0.042326387,
0.0637223274,
-0.0228555929,
0.0327289104,
0.0554703251,
0.0549609847,
0.0649108067,
0.0080706812,
0.0250426568,
-0.0101655768,
0.0162343327,
-0.0100973649,
-0.1233085021,
-0.0216761772,
-0.054369662,
-0.0000658551,
-0.0432322584,
-0.0269979741,
-0.0255733281,
-0.0998412296,
0.017593503,
-0.0362347774,
0.0092009744,
-0.0680757314,
-0.0639064908,
0.0210194346,
-0.0166766755,
-0.011292736,
0.0097242966,
0.0159918461,
0.0189409871,
0.0243383963,
-0.010927313,
0.0212829225,
0.052395191,
0.0029156196,
-0.0061626546,
-0.0111840451,
0.0400854237,
0.0136895357,
-0.0185084995,
-0.017789619,
-0.0277131274,
-0.0431531407,
-0.0291746818,
0.0348737426,
-0.013430384,
-0.0158125497,
-0.0306380074,
0.0136142839,
-0.0534063801,
-0.0268187188,
-0.000260707,
0.0597163029,
0.0045699449,
0.0013926399,
-0.0526869856,
0.0431889221,
0.0175161958,
0.0580683351,
-0.016551394,
0.0112905111,
-0.0460142754,
-0.032684993,
-0.0447158143,
-0.0545474552,
-0.0272922125,
0.0161016248,
0.0407602228,
0.0326751545,
-0.0710120499,
-0.0239877105,
-0.0042036618,
0.0260428581,
-0.068844825,
-0.0326101109,
0.0246405192,
0.0432087332,
-0.0359673612,
0.0032977108,
-0.0408653654,
0.0597681701,
-0.0110686067,
0.0133651039,
0.0472579077,
0.0097358441,
-0.0358143151,
0.0414183661,
-0.0608006977,
-0.0343447812,
-0.0300529301,
-0.0071229809,
0.0104423016,
0.0031347396,
-0.0383821726,
-0.0100867394,
-0.0007228475,
0.0677669421,
-0.0232298151,
0.0289296675,
0.0477280915,
0.0121527407,
0.0113406153,
0.0229840931,
-0.0159155019,
-0.002977134,
-0.0034673421,
0.0280692633,
-0.0225194246,
0.0048069884,
0.0120969024,
0.0109512685,
0.0449236222,
0.0556918643,
-0.0179079324,
-0.036708191,
-0.016352741,
-0.003819559,
-0.0502531715,
-0.0025062661,
0.061049141,
-0.0123179452,
-0.0498412624,
-0.0335062332,
0.0187657252,
-0.0225440431,
0.0429403298,
-0.0263384618,
0.0026439072,
0.0308363698,
0.0253371075,
-0.0387957655,
-0.0527285002,
-0.0439983085,
-0.0331275351,
0.0005900503,
0.0410237201,
0.0139713529,
0.0163446926,
0.0269208346,
-0.0123521518,
0.0226960126,
-0.0370210782,
-0.0680420101,
-0.015365894,
-0.0373912342,
-0.0031604494,
0.0072612618,
0.0055518332,
0.0226595681,
-0.0091503328,
-0.0303849559,
0.0001083955,
-0.0357633419,
-0.0052657276,
0.0098959329,
0.0426970534,
0.0090542641,
-0.0340787433,
0.0306351762,
0.0364316888,
0.0062999749,
0.0461274721,
0.0272031352,
-0.0567948818,
-0.0068116253,
-0.0721965879,
-0.066063486,
0.0336741209,
0.0139947049,
0.0269056931,
-0.0773997828,
-0.0125110708,
0.0323089585,
0.0014868572,
0.0243922547,
0.039255742,
-0.020236291,
0.0568586998,
0.0335958265,
-0.0229353625,
-0.043273475,
0.0080151549,
-0.019320786,
-0.0124470498,
-0.0044284705,
-5.738103307e-33,
0.0173691809,
-0.0658016354,
-0.0179376695,
-0.022703344,
0.0230587833,
0.0124890665,
-0.0019027537,
-0.0246908441,
-0.0597842932,
0.0640491694,
0.03514532,
0.0648945346,
0.0031331254,
0.0118469661,
-0.0391401425,
-0.0059174141,
0.0381766371,
-0.026996782,
-0.0472234152,
0.0202400759,
0.0764887258,
-0.0325147063,
0.0394772738,
-0.0962385312,
0.0431333445,
-0.0373858623,
-0.0181744117,
0.0521343611,
-0.0430027172,
0.0541249961,
-0.00849206,
0.0686360747,
0.0518133901,
-0.0516986959,
0.0403854251,
0.0053332639,
-0.065676026,
-0.0236417763,
0.0332845114,
-0.0319922678,
-0.0196879599,
0.0187653862,
0.0038580911,
0.0266087949,
0.0107870828,
-0.0034242049,
-0.00281022,
-0.0132523514,
0.0593408905,
-0.068330586,
-0.0502702668,
0.0406777598,
-0.0162528679,
-0.0110353008,
-0.0768701062,
0.0431567281,
0.0075642942,
0.0506322384,
-0.0492836572,
0.0011862303,
-0.0495714284,
-0.029173648,
0.0018903485,
-0.0541250184,
-0.0472982824,
0.0446093418,
-0.0247792266,
0.0159858093,
-0.0301379692,
0.0074357484,
-0.0648664683,
0.0240249597,
0.0797467157,
0.1117383912,
0.0319128782,
-0.0061511472,
-0.1191100404,
0.0013092664,
0.0410718545,
0.0037848067,
0.0161440726,
-0.0451437607,
0.0102442233,
0.0083152745,
-0.0372744799,
-0.0039599533,
-0.0285902731,
0.0450511314,
-0.0072891633,
0.0362495221,
-0.0355221778,
0.0624767467,
0.0123719191,
-0.0281468444,
0.0245502871,
0.0508070365,
-0.0119401431,
-0.0113054384,
0.0468598083,
0.0750751868,
-0.0660933182,
0.0582546666,
0.0328786746,
0.0046461532,
-0.0038695326,
-0.0189842489,
0.0439788178,
-0.0311952587,
-0.0536098704,
0.0331059024,
-0.0010527039,
0.0529869944,
-0.0664036721,
0.000100195,
0.0332870707,
0.0321543068,
-0.0008830617,
0.0322917961,
-0.0058091208,
0.0203242935,
-0.0366017669,
0.0208904315,
-0.0332222879,
-0.0006772584,
-0.0124443052,
-0.0182945114,
0.0031707445,
0.0260422099,
-0.0487776957,
-0.0758354217,
0.0267371461,
0.0239000749,
2.212e-7,
0.0352528691,
0.0214296822,
0.0149395932,
0.000604247,
0.0427293703,
0.0370575041,
0.0373936668,
0.0250673853,
-0.0101829097,
-0.0907072797,
-0.0719495937,
0.0566921681,
0.0068364311,
0.0669343546,
-0.0263543595,
-0.0090711359,
-0.0356381945,
-0.0451647229,
-0.069379814,
0.0089563811,
0.0466640256,
0.0522042811,
0.0223110635,
-0.0049959207,
-0.0137443896,
-0.0076536336,
0.0676483884,
0.0535640493,
-0.023549201,
-0.0028808394,
0.0463703126,
-0.046704974,
0.0402485356,
0.0160316899,
-0.0125035085,
0.0324642248,
0.0061917705,
0.049857121,
0.0261497591,
-0.0328976773,
-0.0417619832,
-0.0329070874,
0.0238473974,
-0.0408652462,
0.0438822582,
-0.0314651355,
-0.0321364328,
-0.0503193289,
0.0054260171,
0.0409976356,
0.054301329,
-0.0016269113,
-0.034991052,
0.0037165822,
-0.0184005722,
0.0321687013,
0.013851515,
-0.0608826168,
0.0125698708,
0.0043287366,
-0.036412295,
-0.0360116139,
0.0448399857,
-0.0217811912,
0.049514249,
-0.033534281,
0.0337158553,
1.803429199e-34,
0.0348974802,
-0.0239064563,
0.0095559042,
-0.0420434549,
0.0543792062,
0.0203322992,
-0.0227369871,
-0.0249769352,
0.0278636813,
-0.0131869055,
0.0187385585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11845v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11845v2 | Multimodal Document Analytics for Banking Process Automation | 2023-07-21T18:29:04 | 2023-11-26T08:57:44 | Christopher Gerling, Stefan Lessmann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, q-fin.CP | Traditional banks face increasing competition from FinTechs in the rapidly
evolving financial ecosystem. Raising operational efficiency is vital to
address this challenge. Our study aims to improve the efficiency of
document-intensive business processes in banking. To that end, we first review
the landscape of business documents in the retail segment. Banking documents
often contain text, layout, and visuals, suggesting that document analytics and
process automation require more than plain natural language processing (NLP).
To verify this and assess the incremental value of visual cues when processing
business documents, we compare a recently proposed multimodal model called
LayoutXLM to powerful text classifiers (e.g., BERT) and large language models
(e.g., GPT) in a case study related to processing company register extracts.
The results confirm that incorporating layout information in a model
substantially increases its performance. Interestingly, we also observed that
more than 75% of the best model performance (in terms of the F1 score) can be
achieved with as little as 30% of the training data. This shows that the demand
for data labeled data to set up a multi-modal model can be moderate, which
simplifies real-world applications of multimodal document analytics. Our study
also sheds light on more specific practices in the scope of calibrating a
multimodal banking document classifier, including the need for fine-tuning. In
sum, the paper contributes original empirical evidence on the effectiveness and
efficiency of multi-model models for document processing in the banking
business and offers practical guidance on how to unlock this potential in
day-to-day operations. | [
0.0313322134,
0.0466813445,
-0.0117886644,
0.0159568042,
-0.0293486901,
0.0385586731,
0.0436727516,
0.0713595301,
-0.0054884246,
-0.0994513631,
-0.0451528504,
-0.0339517072,
0.0243698079,
0.0567603782,
0.0168543886,
-0.031372983,
-0.0175392516,
0.0045681098,
0.0468463339,
0.0369817279,
0.0351413675,
0.0117358007,
-0.0127950199,
0.0125793824,
-0.0636880696,
-0.0260378122,
-0.0327017792,
0.0106472122,
-0.034626618,
0.0093702804,
-0.0088521894,
0.0286509264,
0.0365205556,
0.0412397571,
0.0000022286,
-0.0648977235,
-0.0276104845,
0.0076312548,
0.0103342095,
0.0110967001,
0.0937643647,
-0.0522518642,
0.0289769769,
-0.0253508985,
-0.0053335712,
-0.0056894482,
0.0419161431,
0.0962433293,
0.0065828362,
0.0477171019,
-0.0474869087,
-0.0681700036,
0.0051459335,
-0.0023650029,
0.0093091484,
-0.0372906253,
-0.0106376177,
0.0185189471,
-0.0106812548,
-0.0148122236,
-0.0530243069,
0.0302163232,
-0.0126215853,
-0.030443009,
-0.0054234844,
0.037039075,
0.0322687104,
0.0087717045,
-0.0560456403,
0.0352229439,
-0.0284039583,
0.0667122751,
0.0166135747,
-0.037908189,
-0.0024997455,
0.0178925022,
-0.0513562188,
0.0148148444,
-0.0467834733,
-0.0478392169,
-0.0846929923,
-0.01564469,
0.0151282968,
-0.0063254791,
-0.0056757964,
-0.0069805235,
0.0031999147,
-0.036535427,
0.0150871305,
0.004428844,
-0.0048291613,
-0.0060252952,
0.001631734,
-0.0137002626,
0.0278105922,
-0.0007901738,
0.0043901205,
-0.0397521742,
0.0274419226,
-0.0435450561,
0.0671338439,
0.0118106036,
-0.0517500713,
0.0604921095,
-0.0169794429,
0.0404990204,
-0.0205836315,
-0.0018140364,
-0.0318071283,
0.0456693359,
-0.0647541434,
-0.0116801159,
-0.0083521716,
0.0048141368,
-0.0471366048,
-0.0693275779,
-0.0392833874,
0.0267567318,
0.045600336,
0.0156550817,
0.0012037322,
-0.0080433153,
0.017767759,
-0.0102838427,
-0.0221456941,
0.0068355869,
-0.0208755173,
0.0031621431,
-0.0471560508,
-0.0004122416,
0.056836348,
0.0518845655,
0.0054607098,
-0.0131244464,
-0.0054803635,
0.0565863252,
0.0120548252,
-0.0454345495,
-0.0564712845,
-0.0282692555,
-0.0473380089,
-0.0424262322,
0.0199177433,
-0.0144274784,
0.0476212576,
0.0041728555,
-0.0210872293,
0.0517279394,
-0.0299697239,
-0.0081649795,
-0.0172990579,
0.0739184022,
0.0328613743,
0.0013710139,
0.0691105798,
-0.0438115597,
0.0103867231,
0.0434010401,
0.0262995139,
0.0347655639,
0.0549812689,
-0.0529834963,
0.0273371805,
0.0691297278,
-0.0584019385,
-0.07628382,
0.0226507764,
0.0009216654,
0.0136520471,
-0.0257635135,
0.0450459458,
-0.0099162478,
-0.026104128,
0.018614674,
0.058632791,
0.0611006729,
0.0462920927,
-0.0041636792,
0.0003562094,
0.0215156954,
-0.0067121959,
0.0008537379,
0.013125171,
0.0061166817,
-0.0326541364,
0.0364244133,
-0.0307043735,
-0.0059275827,
-0.033477515,
-0.0223822072,
-0.0392784104,
-0.0224241912,
-0.0025206869,
-0.0382787064,
0.0829786137,
-0.0299128089,
-0.0550655797,
0.0174062997,
-0.0027477078,
-0.0456375033,
-0.0344201885,
-0.0277034435,
0.0217249803,
0.0683966503,
0.061395064,
-0.0295714922,
0.0431120843,
-0.0215689149,
-0.0216852035,
0.0392763726,
0.0917873159,
-0.0034425885,
0.0262882728,
-0.0811094642,
-0.0529016331,
0.0075441469,
0.0076957522,
0.025456626,
-0.0247715395,
0.010824088,
0.0049609556,
-0.0336415544,
0.0032264267,
0.0560808778,
0.0217190757,
-0.0213402025,
0.000791145,
0.031205235,
0.0035233581,
0.009235532,
-0.0322630219,
-0.0214876756,
0.0234700944,
-0.0063607143,
0.0200538058,
0.0127281649,
0.0049138214,
0.0373086557,
0.004408746,
0.0250798743,
0.0100497119,
0.0016939709,
-0.063866131,
-0.0165149886,
-0.0094821723,
-0.0368546806,
0.020439487,
-0.044074893,
0.0184234567,
0.0213316269,
0.0022075067,
-0.0461122952,
0.0642427653,
0.0041477298,
0.0232544206,
-0.0229790919,
-0.0344207399,
0.0339647979,
0.0104336226,
0.0171931852,
0.0177148301,
-0.0122531289,
0.0267011467,
0.0546701923,
0.011844621,
-0.0102851028,
-0.0233683567,
-0.1275829822,
-0.0464774705,
-0.0021391301,
0.005778668,
0.0009847559,
0.02566332,
-0.0218207743,
-0.0521119423,
-0.0153850699,
0.0221959036,
0.0178459864,
0.0073407697,
0.0461357608,
-0.0023292552,
-0.0190707315,
0.0083157765,
-0.0175341908,
0.0007982015,
0.0434808657,
0.0541068912,
-0.0506630987,
-0.0538900755,
-0.0483790301,
0.0222102944,
-0.0040597701,
-0.0046066665,
0.0405596681,
0.0012800279,
-0.0297240186,
0.0087856203,
0.0582456179,
-0.0271797329,
0.0383927785,
-0.0269435681,
-0.0136321271,
-0.0557268076,
0.0062715625,
0.0062006302,
0.0376411006,
-0.0063367491,
-0.0178971104,
0.0280708224,
0.0272072069,
-0.0063800924,
0.0380726568,
-0.0260002892,
-0.0170467179,
0.0194763076,
-0.0138285393,
-0.0846396387,
0.0037123943,
-0.0009493707,
0.0568042994,
-0.00652475,
-0.0391943641,
0.0055726464,
-0.0264260843,
-0.0170099735,
-0.0132867852,
0.0132902684,
-0.0266691819,
0.09976013,
0.0070203226,
0.0169919189,
-0.0107925003,
-0.039289806,
-0.0158673096,
-0.0220183674,
0.0428308547,
0.0238963366,
0.0310236253,
-0.0397828408,
0.0215807669,
-0.031139018,
-0.0237105396,
-0.0169311166,
-0.0610765144,
0.0021479512,
-0.0204636827,
0.0144962352,
-0.0120831141,
-0.0975362957,
0.0695953071,
-0.0110174986,
0.062817432,
0.0164528843,
-0.0470943041,
0.0019630697,
0.062281698,
0.0093412288,
-0.0180184618,
-0.0195976943,
-0.0656518266,
-0.0143942153,
0.023359362,
-0.0282160696,
0.0272158738,
-0.032224372,
0.0129321069,
-0.025416879,
-0.0230689403,
-0.0329834372,
-0.0078128045,
-0.0100136315,
-0.0463618599,
0.0438605212,
0.0922499299,
0.0158457607,
-0.0069364398,
-0.0382598229,
0.0032905652,
-0.0278749689,
-0.0221817084,
0.0265327655,
-0.0464554243,
-0.0252492614,
-0.0098936995,
0.030117128,
0.0573148578,
-0.0186150391,
0.0049338825,
-0.0643635094,
0.0609281585,
-0.0121671977,
-0.0093136933,
-0.0187282041,
-0.0291473549,
0.0034349735,
-0.0444658622,
-0.0228516385,
-0.0027332492,
-0.0278181713,
-0.0516567454,
0.0012479607,
-0.0585713945,
-0.0121797267,
-0.0231751837,
-0.0144363344,
-0.1038538292,
0.0614533164,
0.0172442198,
-0.0092917765,
-0.0486235917,
0.0527699627,
0.0286208503,
0.0331948884,
-0.0152336229,
0.0676209033,
-0.0132940356,
0.0168922916,
0.0037717125,
0.0170076042,
-0.0098063182,
0.0073397914,
-0.0029628873,
-0.0000265706,
-0.0056198239,
-0.0033542311,
-0.0356260985,
-0.0205435995,
-0.0331520922,
0.0516987443,
-0.0176400822,
-0.0757749304,
-0.0641660467,
-0.0108582163,
0.0119827809,
0.0161764175,
0.0422461852,
-0.0004921825,
-0.0376655571,
-0.0469926521,
-0.0842639431,
-0.0605301373,
0.0034229509,
0.0386595279,
0.0006651398,
-0.0346163325,
-0.0019060592,
0.0082255322,
-0.0374981649,
0.0170923192,
-0.0101782624,
0.0414946266,
-0.0354583301,
0.0509774238,
0.0002108189,
-0.021484755,
-0.0405875631,
0.022459954,
-0.0598698705,
-0.0070718667,
-0.0142396046,
0.0280776192,
0.0200274903,
0.0042629531,
0.0207832195,
-0.0167814475,
0.0022845629,
0.0139965974,
-0.0529999696,
-0.0412892736,
0.024586428,
-0.012607336,
-0.0553673804,
-0.0193421096,
-0.0321754031,
0.03323818,
-0.0023798444,
-0.0242897738,
-0.0218018256,
-0.0135412356,
-0.0430978052,
0.0149722174,
0.0133040966,
-0.0276749842,
-0.0043818657,
-0.0257268716,
-0.0099766674,
0.0006480765,
-0.0033002475,
-0.0366020426,
-0.0405295305,
0.0142649552,
0.0144492928,
0.010427407,
0.0359698273,
-0.012929651,
-0.0061688866,
-0.0319780372,
0.0045273788,
0.0345306657,
0.0186139308,
-0.0227542836,
-0.0346788689,
-0.0062506651,
0.0474571697,
0.0030798404,
0.0256651342,
-0.0053286403,
0.0936662704,
-0.0035401336,
0.0205771048,
-0.0219152737,
0.0212020054,
-0.0164204594,
0.0248916112,
-0.0261782259,
0.0422976427,
0.0386446789,
-0.0679196566,
-0.0033046112,
-0.0765336379,
0.0034216214,
-0.0346654132,
0.0240535177,
0.0865700319,
0.0025760373,
0.0128583051,
0.013169148,
-0.0129707493,
-0.0387821198,
0.0688133016,
-0.0101652816,
0.0112946099,
-0.0524400324,
-0.0469914936,
-0.0864088163,
-0.0027392202,
0.1387145072,
0.0634133592,
-0.0162779614,
-0.0039947988,
-0.077813305,
0.0226789862,
0.0410988666,
-0.0107047521,
0.0067281513,
-0.0089199059,
0.0402423404,
0.0787460282,
0.0192472897,
0.0102175707,
-0.0243456569,
0.0027191688,
-0.0084546888,
0.0115221515,
-0.0346379764,
-5.716968653e-33,
0.0102955196,
-0.0342456289,
0.0075030532,
0.0228946973,
0.0190670714,
0.0057337163,
0.0310038161,
-0.006476691,
0.053698808,
-0.0217110906,
-0.00769861,
-0.0208196007,
0.0264464822,
0.0187550522,
0.0334313363,
0.0296219848,
0.0364245884,
-0.0516794734,
-0.0454625562,
-0.0266527459,
0.0056114118,
0.0354595967,
0.0501341484,
-0.0772727728,
0.0383621603,
0.0040359921,
-0.0265610069,
-0.0119878603,
0.0366040468,
0.0358089395,
-0.0348330289,
0.0019541348,
0.0331629328,
-0.0485400632,
-0.000002155,
0.0853682458,
-0.0368451104,
0.0028608791,
0.0104446057,
0.0781863034,
0.0047399127,
0.0143635515,
0.0373462066,
-0.0485079139,
-0.0357231237,
0.0018249748,
0.0489054658,
-0.0340448022,
-0.0119032925,
-0.013353481,
-0.0704059526,
0.0527879521,
0.0075096278,
0.0145962732,
0.0802860633,
0.0456277281,
0.0318253711,
-0.0241324753,
-0.0724499524,
0.0170697905,
0.0123960478,
-0.0555663295,
0.0743099228,
0.0178305153,
-0.0318410322,
0.0398446172,
0.0179971624,
-0.009706961,
0.0261820611,
-0.0147937769,
0.0295092687,
0.0642300695,
0.015205266,
0.0199008696,
0.0210522935,
-0.0011138323,
-0.0091900676,
0.0774404109,
0.0268872585,
0.0326225758,
0.0468546487,
-0.0090453969,
-0.0489636287,
-0.0106405737,
0.0243429821,
-0.0205493048,
-0.0236816444,
0.0085671227,
0.0547080599,
0.03450137,
0.0162273273,
0.0031449527,
0.0545060262,
-0.0195454042,
-0.0676906928,
0.0083124209,
-0.0000585235,
0.0624064729,
0.0052469522,
-0.0451292135,
-0.0169281662,
-0.040481858,
0.0067150476,
0.0345491841,
0.0016972534,
-0.0179783013,
0.0377284214,
0.0064870534,
-0.0672204792,
0.0294594672,
0.0353203453,
-0.0005791019,
-0.010525791,
0.0841450617,
0.0322979763,
-0.0253505595,
-0.0180344135,
0.0164399203,
-0.0049558845,
0.0054940362,
-0.0051963432,
-0.0463397019,
0.0111130131,
0.0335561521,
0.0261141397,
0.0103639485,
-0.0068255402,
-0.046550747,
0.0568821803,
0.0097088451,
-0.0049071792,
0.045109123,
2.664e-7,
0.0617746003,
0.0513040051,
-0.0072934465,
-0.0303002633,
0.0299711321,
0.0659037754,
-0.0142257959,
-0.0048470506,
-0.0199418664,
-0.025822673,
0.0179113951,
-0.0215952899,
0.0774533525,
-0.0084628575,
-0.0411172286,
-0.0483294018,
-0.0324590765,
0.01034432,
-0.0884842649,
0.0597999915,
0.0370175987,
0.0538390204,
-0.0352461673,
-0.0809169784,
0.0097599551,
-0.0565831549,
0.0446650758,
-0.0432015583,
-0.0028714514,
-0.0248026121,
0.0651540011,
0.0099987471,
-0.0176376477,
0.0142921312,
0.0053360048,
0.0033101188,
0.0207942445,
0.043979384,
-0.0161534976,
0.0729991049,
0.0257441103,
0.0200809762,
-0.0416382588,
-0.042038098,
0.0192026477,
-0.0131387608,
0.006202193,
-0.0534158908,
-0.0144850984,
0.003969003,
0.0263041351,
0.0038259614,
-0.0113356318,
0.0422082506,
0.0426448956,
-0.0609985478,
-0.0030677647,
-0.0240369681,
0.0242804307,
0.0080533614,
-0.0139507307,
0.0315994024,
-0.0286703091,
-0.0104786139,
0.056265533,
-0.0811155811,
-0.0220698602,
2.504330562e-34,
0.046824608,
-0.0018759264,
0.0048447479,
0.0190122258,
0.028061796,
-0.0015743473,
-0.0035921384,
-0.0006453395,
-0.0075135883,
-0.0910538658,
0.0462541021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11729v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11729v3 | OUTFOX: LLM-Generated Essay Detection Through In-Context Learning with Adversarially Generated Examples | 2023-07-21T17:40:47 | 2024-02-18T12:25:13 | Ryuto Koike, Masahiro Kaneko, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved human-level fluency in text
generation, making it difficult to distinguish between human-written and
LLM-generated texts. This poses a growing risk of misuse of LLMs and demands
the development of detectors to identify LLM-generated texts. However, existing
detectors lack robustness against attacks: they degrade detection accuracy by
simply paraphrasing LLM-generated texts. Furthermore, a malicious user might
attempt to deliberately evade the detectors based on detection results, but
this has not been assumed in previous studies. In this paper, we propose
OUTFOX, a framework that improves the robustness of LLM-generated-text
detectors by allowing both the detector and the attacker to consider each
other's output. In this framework, the attacker uses the detector's prediction
labels as examples for in-context learning and adversarially generates essays
that are harder to detect, while the detector uses the adversarially generated
essays as examples for in-context learning to learn to detect essays from a
strong attacker. Experiments in the domain of student essays show that the
proposed detector improves the detection performance on the attacker-generated
texts by up to +41.3 points F1-score. Furthermore, the proposed detector shows
a state-of-the-art detection performance: up to 96.9 points F1-score, beating
existing detectors on non-attacked texts. Finally, the proposed attacker
drastically degrades the performance of detectors by up to -57.0 points
F1-score, massively outperforming the baseline paraphrasing method for evading
detection. | [
0.0426671021,
0.0313512422,
0.0036616791,
0.0755448192,
-0.0400406905,
-0.0125798387,
0.0031653589,
0.029179126,
0.0269408021,
-0.081773594,
0.0038574978,
-0.0087723956,
-0.0326156318,
0.020755576,
0.060643781,
0.0372975096,
0.0054064519,
-0.0178779643,
-0.0256201643,
0.0169648379,
0.0267742928,
0.0046415655,
0.0212169327,
0.0202537347,
0.0274391398,
-0.0216246918,
-0.0125534087,
0.0172839332,
0.017474575,
-0.0027488791,
0.0415599644,
0.0432502702,
-0.0264109094,
0.0717970058,
0.0000019423,
-0.0437930152,
-0.0307361688,
-0.0211669207,
-0.0116704106,
0.0424674079,
0.0587427132,
-0.0190690178,
-0.0357988328,
0.0235088356,
-0.0501314923,
0.0349151529,
-0.0191464368,
0.0676187575,
0.0610310882,
0.1138123199,
-0.0155523568,
-0.014750923,
0.0560980961,
-0.0065223104,
-0.0070988,
-0.0242159385,
0.0261232276,
-0.0673418716,
-0.0135388039,
0.0313277021,
0.0065217596,
0.021184219,
0.0105997948,
-0.0342257954,
-0.0283492133,
-0.0068102647,
-0.0138288643,
0.0159938689,
0.0016903243,
0.0514288172,
-0.0635858998,
-0.0464580469,
0.0270831808,
-0.0181861222,
0.0267757848,
0.0184453074,
-0.0262300931,
0.0285958014,
-0.0439080149,
0.00732035,
0.0229661372,
-0.0250050575,
0.0414250717,
0.0440524332,
0.0133868642,
0.0021085204,
0.0163459536,
-0.0454978347,
-0.0333852023,
-0.0232347175,
-0.0255242679,
-0.05251633,
0.0538401045,
0.041282177,
0.0099505968,
0.0055924277,
-0.1081086993,
-0.0800503939,
0.0462477021,
-0.0529760793,
0.0504879318,
-0.001858469,
-0.0093448954,
-0.0019119522,
-0.0739672035,
0.0704878494,
-0.0502192751,
0.0403580666,
-0.0067089703,
0.0208704453,
-0.0126897115,
-0.0203261375,
-0.0186295006,
0.0403856263,
0.0123391338,
-0.0049116961,
-0.0473093577,
0.0373967066,
0.0095285056,
0.0398472212,
-0.0582700558,
-0.0161644705,
-0.0184699297,
0.0102501893,
0.0355912074,
-0.0107314214,
0.0154133746,
-0.0012557007,
0.0030714991,
-0.0696539655,
-0.0135990037,
0.0655238479,
-0.0022451831,
-0.0095538376,
0.0044058007,
0.0672906265,
0.0102446051,
-0.0305497758,
-0.0406491533,
-0.0984774455,
-0.0128721884,
-0.0148688154,
0.0026107817,
-0.0734708682,
-0.0516201742,
-0.0012483636,
0.0022799622,
-0.0580518208,
0.0183495972,
0.055242613,
0.0099695651,
0.0183574539,
0.0296117906,
-0.0325020365,
0.0261643138,
0.0210723411,
0.0091696456,
0.0412942879,
0.0186712332,
0.0684342384,
0.0561805293,
0.0143786417,
0.0635634065,
0.0613825694,
0.022365151,
0.0177853908,
0.0121847652,
-0.0232542176,
0.0113339862,
0.0148593904,
0.0009012739,
0.0383815952,
0.0091765914,
-0.0428440087,
0.0997141004,
0.0272614807,
-0.0103784911,
0.0105182901,
0.0088991402,
0.0282565597,
0.0127671799,
0.0545830317,
-0.0050120107,
-0.0177489147,
-0.0645778626,
-0.0261915475,
0.002949924,
-0.0017575528,
0.0300869122,
-0.0243806709,
-0.0252108686,
-0.0323163606,
-0.039666824,
-0.0174588989,
0.0145384213,
0.0507366844,
-0.0466293246,
0.0104368208,
-0.0222440176,
-0.0533748791,
0.0197870173,
-0.0856219828,
0.017859485,
0.0437280126,
0.0604101494,
-0.0244772136,
0.0455758013,
-0.0483274162,
0.0257351846,
0.0483096242,
0.0264786649,
-0.0036519936,
-0.0135610141,
-0.0342254415,
-0.0209173169,
-0.0467792042,
0.0043419986,
-0.0242089517,
0.0414508358,
0.0056557488,
0.0258542988,
-0.0101268869,
-0.0555220954,
0.0623677187,
0.0009467779,
-0.0337078124,
0.0143575519,
0.0269956216,
0.0120440852,
0.0085144117,
-0.008332205,
0.0514817238,
0.0219228733,
-0.0565524437,
-0.0176354926,
-0.0502274483,
-0.0051061767,
-0.0211884733,
0.0378449038,
-0.0418523774,
-0.0074106348,
0.0336767994,
-0.0337496772,
0.0052528447,
0.0066926801,
-0.0547058582,
-0.0040031676,
-0.0448658913,
0.0251198895,
-0.0137714045,
0.0257251579,
-0.0408896767,
0.0540045425,
-0.0164940599,
0.0217942111,
-0.0101370141,
0.006699021,
0.0339581333,
-0.0230181757,
-0.0159393717,
-0.0195285585,
-0.0116479388,
0.0007866538,
0.0078947376,
-0.0028752889,
-0.024247149,
-0.0465204827,
-0.0351960845,
0.0303564705,
-0.0257007722,
0.0175845642,
0.0621844344,
-0.0227669664,
-0.007516867,
0.0001574782,
-0.0210973341,
-0.0223690905,
0.0107531538,
0.003535626,
0.0486552678,
-0.0248813629,
0.0135824578,
-0.0110568348,
0.0165607873,
-0.0257929377,
0.0439734869,
0.0340720005,
-0.0558705181,
-0.0607608147,
0.0659861639,
0.0257148482,
0.000761466,
-0.018274568,
-0.0366039388,
0.0014376655,
-0.0115047349,
0.0138503173,
0.0953327268,
0.0429418609,
0.0231497604,
0.0449853167,
0.0399178751,
-0.0188409891,
-0.0364276022,
0.0059243278,
0.0034753415,
-0.0534587912,
-0.0187922083,
0.0539902821,
0.0166389886,
0.0484342463,
-0.0142134307,
0.0181381796,
0.0330342539,
-0.0110594602,
-0.0231258664,
-0.0063206614,
-0.0247823279,
-0.0409020558,
-0.0141128814,
-0.027298877,
-0.0416728109,
0.0570127219,
-0.0320939124,
0.0310311895,
-0.0139377294,
-0.030722009,
-0.0141364718,
0.002182964,
-0.0058372775,
0.0161516834,
-0.0007330193,
-0.0076054102,
-0.0531179942,
0.0011655401,
0.0441470519,
-0.0333289132,
0.0278372671,
-0.006497697,
-0.0126050869,
-0.0131986337,
0.002345728,
-0.0743365884,
-0.0779489949,
0.0027870361,
0.0051008528,
-0.0310141575,
-0.0270284284,
-0.0216459893,
-0.051736027,
0.0022939807,
0.0420118235,
-0.0554191582,
-0.0036799333,
-0.0315797441,
0.0679104477,
0.0533334091,
-0.0778943226,
0.0195570812,
-0.0692082569,
0.0357647389,
0.114941977,
-0.0244732834,
0.0368298329,
0.0263706427,
-0.032915242,
0.0147369485,
-0.0228258763,
-0.0288068559,
0.0119577292,
0.0282308124,
-0.0726424754,
-0.0029840893,
0.079903625,
-0.0009606503,
-0.0020925801,
-0.0067015532,
0.0015006713,
0.0046773739,
0.0001254699,
-0.0313312747,
-0.0450421609,
-0.0239610057,
0.0223616622,
0.0426661782,
-0.0474135354,
-0.0048804474,
-0.0013008971,
-0.0869108662,
0.0002963854,
0.021315176,
-0.0036361199,
-0.0112676099,
-0.0040942794,
-0.0196609516,
0.0427429378,
-0.0140275015,
-0.0243359432,
-0.0075195655,
0.0010792037,
-0.0088320905,
-0.0099195326,
-0.0283564981,
-0.0361519903,
-0.0611755028,
-0.0119233886,
0.0537374206,
0.0376501717,
-0.0174106825,
-0.031684421,
0.0590708666,
-0.0363143645,
-0.0149460537,
0.0033474369,
0.0640347376,
-0.0206705015,
-0.0080391504,
-0.0210883897,
0.0699468106,
-0.0155030945,
-0.0139865698,
0.0580163598,
0.0467604361,
-0.0173107535,
-0.0248464942,
-0.0221087374,
0.0015734072,
0.0226438344,
0.0769625604,
0.0335211568,
-0.0547877587,
-0.0634378344,
-0.0600292683,
0.0113750771,
-0.087235719,
-0.0322358757,
0.0231496971,
0.0042672656,
-0.0086777089,
-0.0701811388,
-0.0216138586,
-0.0397627577,
-0.0137351602,
0.0088550299,
0.0412960798,
-0.0448357388,
-0.0201909412,
-0.0560398102,
-0.0370384194,
-0.0215870664,
0.0322747603,
-0.0410392955,
0.0066639665,
0.0069123837,
-0.0342642628,
-0.012476759,
0.0401037373,
-0.0848371238,
-0.0534289218,
0.0201328769,
0.0156227062,
0.0059401621,
0.0108455857,
-0.0136696557,
-0.0584357493,
0.1056836843,
0.0434858873,
-0.0109839654,
0.0174233913,
0.0365506485,
-0.0319114216,
0.0024144829,
0.0397005081,
-0.0215270743,
-0.019546058,
0.061645586,
-0.029988993,
-0.0311957747,
-0.0239611249,
0.0029325646,
0.0261535253,
0.0272849146,
-0.0284643117,
-0.0105170421,
-0.0000738543,
0.0204768497,
-0.0049392241,
-0.0355296582,
-0.0135123888,
0.0332258865,
0.0364876874,
0.0012204071,
0.0204321556,
0.0473416187,
0.007434682,
0.036817804,
-0.0004866981,
0.0442701355,
0.0024356397,
0.0594052933,
0.0265705418,
0.0054537477,
-0.015228685,
0.0371556021,
0.0062267813,
0.0202802215,
0.0092319744,
0.0404464006,
0.0009416079,
-0.0119723063,
0.0203649867,
0.0251935963,
-0.0827793106,
0.0186694786,
-0.0552765802,
0.0338550545,
0.029986186,
0.0158976782,
0.045292329,
-0.0420011617,
-0.0161892902,
-0.0394455716,
0.0339642465,
-0.0000184447,
-0.0460454226,
-0.0056416811,
-0.0082972357,
0.0115040774,
0.0258350391,
0.0775362253,
0.0248505641,
0.0634308755,
0.0148891388,
-0.0236835685,
-0.0454377718,
-0.0096352911,
0.0368158221,
0.0053913458,
0.0053133368,
0.0063172863,
-0.0080715697,
-0.0304995943,
0.0398691148,
0.0261369031,
0.0024031627,
-0.0084637869,
-0.0237960182,
0.0543743037,
-0.0159027074,
0.0201917142,
-0.0706914142,
0.0598407239,
0.02048539,
-0.0479789153,
-0.0120070912,
-5.084108944e-33,
-0.0131416842,
-0.0869452953,
-0.0476856567,
0.0316956565,
0.0189938173,
-0.0055008628,
-0.0301100407,
-0.0284582041,
0.0070143286,
-0.0027025368,
0.0069348095,
0.0229661483,
-0.0165491626,
0.0470980778,
-0.0267743524,
-0.0338062979,
0.0597493201,
-0.0288107023,
-0.0341475606,
0.0057927333,
0.0641585588,
0.0280153528,
0.0380618498,
-0.0696149245,
0.0284933876,
-0.0583486483,
-0.0402652696,
-0.0135714198,
-0.0664575174,
0.057538256,
-0.0068988772,
0.0340374634,
0.0309659708,
0.0168230608,
-0.0143750487,
0.0527681708,
-0.0212720465,
0.0060032317,
-0.0152311511,
0.0175291244,
0.0122773061,
-0.1001188383,
0.0717527047,
-0.0304204803,
-0.005654756,
-0.0153776379,
0.034918271,
-0.0265336744,
0.0017231269,
-0.0552120879,
-0.0458393432,
0.0193536337,
0.012188429,
0.0082835732,
0.0124844993,
0.0384906791,
0.0281381384,
0.0115275504,
-0.0454945303,
0.0231520087,
-0.0101327859,
0.0394780226,
0.018949911,
0.0140639767,
-0.0361146703,
0.0634715483,
0.0109698679,
-0.0021115893,
-0.0054741432,
-0.0098465905,
0.0125849219,
-0.0021275769,
0.0959722549,
0.1145685911,
0.0426127762,
-0.0244227741,
-0.0647130758,
0.0279203635,
0.0265086889,
-0.0142688798,
0.0398080908,
-0.0294403639,
-0.0430459641,
0.0068457741,
-0.0044861031,
-0.0655714497,
-0.0295056012,
-0.0101951426,
0.0408378579,
0.0106696784,
-0.0362289101,
-0.019884618,
-0.0029466425,
-0.0629439428,
-0.0221191403,
0.0225492995,
-0.0377456993,
-0.0192589872,
-0.0012503107,
0.0044537005,
0.0142409969,
-0.00382779,
0.0187950991,
-0.0385291651,
0.0332446359,
-0.0095916269,
0.0777967423,
0.0197962262,
-0.0690841898,
0.0022463093,
-0.0198583864,
0.0254480895,
0.0263266042,
0.0192790553,
0.0280203056,
-0.0408919603,
-0.0031457166,
0.0004337971,
0.0046339813,
-0.003495205,
-0.051198598,
-0.0193824973,
-0.009951097,
0.0243177749,
-0.0283793081,
-0.018817408,
-0.0082893921,
0.0486250035,
0.0288111996,
-0.0686044246,
0.031593658,
-0.0376938395,
2.49e-7,
0.0305001009,
0.0051339096,
0.0193245877,
-0.0146866348,
0.0286811348,
0.0533939376,
-0.0248899609,
0.033308208,
-0.009551473,
-0.0042958967,
-0.0233331453,
-0.0121488841,
0.065028891,
0.0181111638,
-0.1065224335,
0.0323451385,
-0.0503279455,
0.0144352838,
-0.0487011261,
-0.0014062866,
0.0829465389,
0.0662625879,
0.0111128604,
-0.0353442542,
-0.0129033346,
-0.0926719606,
0.0420950092,
0.0019939477,
0.0045843585,
0.0032482501,
0.0602308027,
0.0035681517,
0.0334311239,
0.0052396948,
-0.0253743585,
-0.0231489837,
0.0160143618,
0.0722013488,
0.0588655546,
-0.0071423058,
-0.0141578671,
-0.030640956,
0.0215672962,
-0.0478023887,
0.0782892779,
0.0091876164,
0.0067110392,
-0.0390144065,
-0.0108650615,
-0.0595335364,
0.0057338243,
-0.0383138768,
-0.0009330834,
0.0061617633,
0.0214364491,
-0.0021496054,
0.0163657106,
-0.0560572147,
-0.0548628382,
-0.0439612269,
-0.0297458023,
-0.0140588619,
-0.0476605967,
0.0400558896,
0.0365171954,
-0.0364421122,
-0.0003638266,
2.548912563e-34,
0.0173124038,
-0.0178415254,
0.0082753198,
0.0181355923,
0.0036363564,
0.0207808353,
0.0162761994,
0.0041283984,
0.002762673,
-0.0104493061,
-0.0066883708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03762v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03762v2 | GPT-4 Can't Reason | 2023-07-21T17:04:25 | 2023-08-10T14:24:37 | Konstantine Arkoudas | cs.CL | cs.CL | GPT-4 was released in March 2023 to wide acclaim, marking a very substantial
improvement across the board over GPT-3.5 (OpenAI's previously best model,
which had powered the initial release of ChatGPT). However, despite the
genuinely impressive improvement, there are good reasons to be highly skeptical
of GPT-4's ability to reason. This position paper discusses the nature of
reasoning; criticizes the current formulation of reasoning problems in the NLP
community, as well as the way in which LLM reasoning performance is currently
evaluated; introduces a small collection of 21 diverse reasoning problems; and
performs a detailed qualitative evaluation of GPT-4's performance on those
problems. Based on this analysis, the paper concludes that, despite its
occasional flashes of analytical brilliance, GPT-4 at present is utterly
incapable of reasoning. | [
0.0281317998,
0.0523254648,
0.0118553862,
0.0537544265,
-0.0688617751,
0.0403748862,
0.0080360882,
0.022648802,
0.0213158112,
-0.0352372937,
0.0022511869,
0.0139140543,
-0.0149999857,
-0.0281472504,
0.0021419013,
-0.0746583417,
0.0402876027,
-0.0104583567,
0.0253155921,
-0.011356947,
-0.0173307247,
0.0136226183,
-0.0404214859,
0.0253709592,
-0.0161852986,
-0.0406963117,
-0.0189533252,
-0.0333751552,
0.0245031212,
-0.0213705786,
-0.0309918057,
0.0177397337,
-0.000086172,
0.0178916138,
0.0000018845,
-0.041070167,
-0.0062332982,
0.0003918657,
-0.0274515506,
-0.0107338866,
-0.0422755256,
0.0102947857,
0.013322439,
0.0330120064,
-0.0395663455,
0.015888717,
0.0044452217,
0.1062273756,
0.0434856713,
0.0760026276,
-0.003683178,
-0.0760700554,
0.0191904958,
0.0004759896,
0.0369388685,
-0.0697772354,
-0.0123299193,
0.0126162805,
0.0376862027,
0.0208762288,
0.009057126,
0.0177711695,
0.0557521991,
0.0235192161,
-0.0356691442,
0.0434256569,
-0.0325305201,
-0.0080747921,
0.001476008,
0.0294670351,
0.0345576741,
-0.0066520073,
-0.02256261,
-0.0016854939,
-0.0187426638,
-0.004433034,
-0.0418178812,
0.0571272708,
-0.0351135656,
0.0425274149,
0.0379117914,
0.002226322,
0.029725574,
0.019638814,
-0.02584875,
0.1214848533,
-0.0025013445,
-0.0376652181,
0.050790064,
0.0247949753,
-0.0541135594,
-0.0358709954,
-0.0136346165,
0.078217864,
-0.0000326678,
0.0370511897,
0.0167919993,
0.0996514857,
0.0207296032,
-0.0052792844,
-0.0337659419,
0.0590104274,
0.002640709,
0.034915559,
-0.0347758457,
0.046423886,
-0.0342199467,
0.0465857014,
-0.0122334072,
-0.0370649397,
-0.1084652543,
-0.0422640853,
-0.0289629214,
0.0759148076,
-0.0215600599,
-0.0018788194,
-0.0316567644,
0.0054891407,
-0.0154824806,
0.0056749629,
0.0338932872,
-0.0024867679,
-0.0018307995,
-0.0327029787,
-0.0937938765,
0.0082128737,
-0.0312329438,
0.0149834659,
-0.0040046601,
-0.0507431366,
-0.0077267233,
-0.0012867751,
-0.0332684889,
-0.0421494432,
-0.0008038093,
0.0672013015,
0.0211560279,
-0.0143543119,
-0.0822307393,
-0.052910611,
-0.0204851851,
-0.0939276889,
0.0079666181,
-0.026057167,
-0.0000975286,
-0.0014135794,
-0.0162727609,
-0.0284334086,
0.0110755516,
0.024616817,
-0.0229329467,
0.0960596204,
-0.0103232469,
-0.0060121529,
0.0042329705,
0.0483598039,
-0.0150459828,
0.0484499969,
0.0138968294,
0.0080907252,
-0.0060785245,
0.009038738,
0.0146830799,
-0.0101502035,
-0.0007910035,
-0.0057286825,
0.0257764962,
0.006008537,
-0.0357272662,
0.0291860644,
-0.0326709971,
0.0612964109,
-0.0163789503,
-0.0078257788,
0.0363019779,
0.0686405972,
-0.0105449203,
0.0192385092,
0.0148530938,
-0.0366577059,
-0.0116533712,
0.0274270549,
-0.0470324643,
0.0318880789,
-0.0340805091,
0.00221648,
-0.0076603577,
-0.0201971028,
-0.0139314067,
-0.0597439408,
-0.0430605076,
0.0343030244,
-0.0046507325,
-0.0097861942,
0.019014949,
-0.0307205319,
-0.0183901694,
0.0329822823,
0.0058338521,
-0.053657189,
-0.0221013445,
-0.0593301803,
0.0490646586,
0.0059449775,
0.0419939123,
-0.001582891,
-0.0735445693,
0.0051677232,
0.001003827,
0.0376408733,
0.0572992302,
0.0070264903,
-0.0029067986,
-0.0429006033,
-0.0092485659,
-0.0342228599,
0.00253817,
0.0042500217,
0.0135047836,
0.0313980505,
0.0090060141,
-0.0269165691,
0.033068791,
0.0129319206,
0.0039348067,
-0.0153919877,
-0.039828904,
0.0180720892,
0.0476289056,
0.0114336284,
0.0372017026,
0.0172902923,
0.0106563875,
-0.0010504831,
-0.0355119444,
0.0320962965,
-0.0234535839,
-0.0308671463,
0.0491172038,
-0.0297260936,
-0.0505001768,
-0.0038090681,
-0.0616579019,
-0.0431262031,
0.0312570706,
0.011753263,
0.0301990025,
-0.061834529,
-0.0149357691,
0.0199053306,
-0.025492439,
-0.0168728177,
0.1085167378,
0.0360546075,
-0.0019384802,
0.0034712425,
0.0463410877,
0.0647824556,
-0.0691298023,
0.0051928018,
0.050499402,
0.0239558574,
-0.0205539335,
-0.0207118206,
0.0312590152,
-0.0776756406,
-0.0028725148,
-0.0627745539,
0.047111392,
-0.0010468399,
0.0299527999,
0.0186764225,
-0.0200583432,
0.0105716344,
0.023149319,
-0.028164573,
-0.0096882237,
0.039515093,
0.0182418749,
0.0555079319,
-0.0036442033,
0.010213675,
0.0318676084,
0.0122881215,
-0.0441965684,
-0.0158250667,
0.0122745624,
-0.0148345521,
-0.0228639245,
0.0429729261,
-0.0746459141,
-0.002288687,
0.0083336188,
0.003495041,
0.0562315211,
-0.0059625944,
-0.0052599665,
0.0358951762,
-0.0283188988,
0.048111219,
0.0071608517,
-0.0237617102,
-0.0352983512,
0.0607167594,
-0.0212450679,
-0.0339127854,
0.0053910292,
0.0006779397,
0.0016849699,
0.0183391646,
0.0034874422,
-0.0184083637,
-0.0943385735,
0.0353767276,
-0.0189780798,
0.0259527266,
-0.027100943,
-0.0145920496,
-0.007007062,
0.057843484,
-0.0238787849,
-0.0179507304,
0.0720632449,
-0.0141244484,
0.0130418912,
-0.0816104487,
-0.0019542226,
-0.0456465073,
0.0958487391,
-0.0489816256,
-0.0033469005,
-0.0062176911,
-0.032436084,
-0.0017634494,
-0.0323503949,
0.0107038952,
0.0035424056,
0.0626303032,
-0.0716410428,
0.0343259797,
-0.0125238737,
-0.0459663905,
-0.0140930228,
0.0140156243,
-0.0483644828,
0.0154403113,
-0.0203367863,
-0.0057095792,
0.0037515326,
0.0291218981,
-0.0050545549,
-0.0317027718,
-0.0050199386,
-0.0245356299,
-0.0220659599,
-0.0063791452,
0.0083292481,
0.0276466664,
0.0265891962,
0.0017923313,
0.0171178691,
0.0560522452,
0.0360111184,
-0.0153507832,
-0.0211110096,
0.0394655839,
-0.0233092662,
-0.0266597215,
-0.0496880747,
-0.0072043086,
0.0491183065,
-0.0596672781,
-0.010289602,
0.1080298871,
0.0334313735,
-0.0233348925,
-0.0102353049,
-0.008246961,
0.0050501917,
-0.0115290163,
0.0154343965,
-0.0695403814,
-0.0480941758,
0.0255747847,
0.0107053015,
-0.0160912275,
-0.0191187188,
-0.0328011215,
-0.088583529,
0.0660619065,
-0.013826034,
-0.0145868678,
-0.0231374037,
-0.0313536003,
0.0074436334,
-0.0106026977,
0.0111201303,
0.0112771438,
0.0172037371,
0.0371017382,
0.0385647789,
-0.0209721792,
-0.0074354531,
0.0354529619,
-0.0026246023,
0.0287833083,
0.0273433197,
0.0662182346,
0.0035090158,
-0.0824554041,
0.0399248451,
-0.0235215873,
0.0209560134,
-0.0480703302,
0.0132169835,
0.0071374057,
-0.0025356724,
-0.0443442799,
0.0272498447,
-0.0381038301,
-0.0374963917,
0.0150623536,
0.1120720133,
-0.0529357642,
-0.0365881287,
-0.0004360713,
0.0346820168,
-0.0555913597,
0.0884321481,
0.0061102263,
0.0748863742,
-0.0830430239,
-0.0390164629,
-0.0148986839,
-0.0285750479,
-0.015290224,
0.0157042202,
0.0306749754,
0.0020320383,
-0.0242980141,
-0.0654657334,
0.0337662324,
0.046249114,
-0.0146512445,
0.0207912736,
-0.031745445,
0.0331252851,
0.0002721844,
0.0258833282,
-0.0288872588,
-0.012788631,
-0.0294845235,
0.0324359611,
0.0253307074,
-0.0221209433,
-0.0019749387,
0.001780736,
-0.0462950543,
-0.0462582186,
-0.0292186718,
0.0103084166,
0.0387705527,
-0.0084146094,
-0.0180692952,
-0.013669827,
-0.0295762233,
0.0066666584,
0.0171351787,
0.0041255797,
0.015723493,
0.0525097884,
0.0355506837,
0.0295496266,
0.0080622919,
0.0046404162,
0.0061998125,
0.0350270756,
-0.0170672499,
-0.0099385679,
0.037724182,
0.0458147787,
0.0219818894,
0.0271966793,
-0.0061236005,
-0.0328525938,
0.0125765661,
-0.0134698432,
-0.0051985942,
-0.0373534597,
0.0302446783,
0.0226978716,
0.0036153411,
-0.0508324094,
-0.0503338836,
-0.030769363,
0.00485826,
-0.0018257382,
-0.0010884944,
0.0353234261,
-0.0249796323,
-0.0218391139,
-0.0207173657,
-0.0233755354,
-0.0163935032,
-0.0067856433,
0.0722305328,
-0.017875446,
0.0766559094,
0.0629356578,
0.0028636344,
0.0206366722,
-0.0117592812,
-0.0815980807,
-0.1025724709,
0.0569819249,
0.0339076668,
0.0363313071,
0.0079913363,
0.0228139721,
-0.064125441,
0.0147010479,
0.0433181375,
0.0186352748,
0.0317710005,
-0.0293069091,
0.0436792746,
0.0149162589,
-0.018293377,
-0.0369904153,
0.0293635596,
-0.051753439,
0.0488878749,
0.0134643288,
-0.0512837432,
-0.0212259926,
-0.0685996488,
-0.0170561466,
0.0166459009,
0.010608566,
0.0098213814,
-0.063195996,
-0.0500937961,
-0.0282105785,
0.0068232939,
0.0046165586,
0.006734692,
0.0051536406,
0.0610917099,
0.0117551135,
-0.0575469658,
-0.0041006776,
-0.0201903153,
-0.0537987575,
0.0185665078,
-0.0005762415,
-5.866270762e-33,
-0.0352489166,
-0.0455142744,
0.0661189556,
0.0016701493,
-0.0290623866,
-0.0372577347,
-0.0299257655,
-0.0005192374,
-0.0428667814,
0.0334620662,
-0.0158319362,
0.0266938973,
0.0129429931,
0.0019061628,
-0.0005236859,
-0.0451495238,
-0.0103045357,
0.0296497047,
-0.030942481,
0.0184131246,
0.0381050669,
-0.0214720517,
0.0592587329,
-0.020108534,
0.0336488187,
0.0269346461,
-0.0254567396,
0.0399315581,
-0.1064997837,
0.0342116021,
-0.007323565,
-0.0029183158,
0.0432715788,
-0.0268734563,
0.036463622,
-0.0275216922,
-0.0116669564,
-0.0762384236,
0.0523317792,
-0.0176094696,
-0.0471170209,
-0.0479693376,
0.000017534,
0.0160167962,
-0.0188146699,
-0.0213866327,
0.0122138588,
-0.0212304033,
0.0213395543,
0.0292010233,
-0.0171369277,
0.00875118,
-0.0221085455,
0.0245125666,
0.0077578491,
-0.021070702,
-0.03081185,
0.0228053443,
-0.0421447158,
0.0030153885,
0.0069983914,
-0.019691078,
0.0652863532,
-0.0554553047,
-0.0103827063,
0.0338701345,
0.0045485375,
-0.0135538094,
-0.0656182691,
0.0059149512,
-0.036055129,
0.077510111,
0.0484642759,
-0.0088936323,
0.0353820175,
0.0202420559,
-0.0526603721,
0.0282042213,
0.0169100706,
0.0592123121,
0.0163333826,
0.012307832,
-0.0514752269,
-0.0111886291,
0.0008530309,
0.016513573,
-0.0400305428,
-0.0486941114,
0.0405889526,
-0.034299355,
0.0082170488,
0.0177377649,
0.0021361497,
-0.0138305519,
0.0138399564,
0.0074836407,
0.0020073198,
-0.0198941696,
-0.0110239731,
0.0456183106,
-0.0262835678,
-0.0043713264,
-0.0141333258,
0.018498648,
0.0174662992,
-0.0243094824,
0.018147476,
0.0111233015,
-0.012726062,
-0.025329994,
-0.0853258967,
0.0326740555,
-0.0139202904,
0.0025346933,
0.0220257062,
0.0334234461,
0.0157679431,
0.0138274999,
0.0065299082,
0.0037022051,
-0.0255055819,
0.017022714,
-0.0249825623,
-0.0249626674,
0.0108402018,
0.0082786884,
0.0113925198,
0.0310193393,
-0.0290217903,
-0.0490156859,
-0.0011127397,
0.0566839948,
2.531e-7,
0.0490014851,
0.021184016,
0.0145456102,
0.0113476329,
0.0133202709,
0.0069716731,
-0.0271991156,
-0.0515183583,
0.0091963774,
0.0073553985,
0.004606755,
0.0614045151,
0.0397472084,
0.0594576374,
-0.0300403666,
0.0070031127,
-0.0110789733,
-0.0821551383,
-0.0703770816,
0.0335888788,
0.1167923957,
0.0465213247,
0.0334435143,
-0.0320635661,
0.0155359944,
-0.0188828576,
0.0410555378,
-0.0252654199,
0.0045799841,
0.0020276518,
0.0684404969,
0.0062187822,
0.0028344337,
0.0425212532,
0.0325502604,
-0.006229219,
-0.0092441551,
0.0378591828,
0.0075808228,
-0.0712605193,
-0.0324462727,
-0.0331206471,
0.0223586746,
-0.0667527914,
0.1040729061,
-0.0125554139,
-0.070258379,
0.0476608723,
0.0090937689,
-0.040453542,
-0.0075665154,
0.0201131366,
-0.0154528012,
-0.0053392514,
-0.0128768394,
-0.0342535749,
-0.0240972266,
-0.1053488255,
0.0284148138,
-0.005959461,
-0.0283558685,
-0.0195674952,
-0.013840748,
0.0164648518,
0.0721382648,
-0.0548712537,
-0.0649487898,
2.13733893e-34,
-0.00290046,
-0.012023272,
0.038815096,
0.01192596,
0.0552124642,
0.0556106642,
0.0335925035,
-0.0077360389,
-0.0086071491,
-0.0539625548,
-0.0209547654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11661v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11661v2 | Enhancing CLIP with GPT-4: Harnessing Visual Descriptions as Prompts | 2023-07-21T15:49:59 | 2023-08-08T13:44:12 | Mayug Maniparambil, Chris Vorster, Derek Molloy, Noel Murphy, Kevin McGuinness, Noel E. O'Connor | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive pretrained large Vision-Language Models (VLMs) like CLIP have
revolutionized visual representation learning by providing good performance on
downstream datasets. VLMs are 0-shot adapted to a downstream dataset by
designing prompts that are relevant to the dataset. Such prompt engineering
makes use of domain expertise and a validation dataset. Meanwhile, recent
developments in generative pretrained models like GPT-4 mean they can be used
as advanced internet search tools. They can also be manipulated to provide
visual information in any structure. In this work, we show that GPT-4 can be
used to generate text that is visually descriptive and how this can be used to
adapt CLIP to downstream tasks. We show considerable improvements in 0-shot
transfer accuracy on specialized fine-grained datasets like EuroSAT (~7%), DTD
(~7%), SUN397 (~4.6%), and CUB (~3.3%) when compared to CLIP's default prompt.
We also design a simple few-shot adapter that learns to choose the best
possible sentences to construct generalizable classifiers that outperform the
recently proposed CoCoOP by ~2% on average and by over 4% on 4 specialized
fine-grained datasets. The code, prompts, and auxiliary text dataset is
available at https://github.com/mayug/VDT-Adapter. | [
0.030998135,
0.0349456482,
0.0151131721,
0.0227888599,
-0.0364652947,
-0.0071441354,
0.0092935655,
-0.0082400441,
-0.0102455048,
-0.0695539266,
-0.0530703105,
-0.0181836691,
-0.0129774185,
0.0674447417,
0.0026187981,
-0.1006186977,
0.0106186448,
-0.0242126845,
0.0040786634,
0.0327997357,
0.0185687933,
0.0241796821,
0.0202835687,
0.0366808511,
0.0024426291,
-0.0181502663,
-0.006095272,
0.023685202,
0.0437645093,
-0.0283662137,
-0.0016572382,
0.0446066521,
0.0513692535,
-0.0137537792,
0.0000019905,
-0.0076821777,
0.0186216347,
0.0111969151,
0.014093671,
0.0031412458,
0.0381431133,
-0.0498613641,
0.0193980597,
-0.0104397414,
-0.0317484848,
-0.0403904952,
0.0600192323,
0.043393679,
0.058778666,
0.0660758168,
-0.0332254618,
-0.0120375995,
0.0192199647,
-0.0445071906,
0.0426136106,
-0.0182862729,
0.0124614807,
-0.0004057741,
0.0050432286,
0.0500723459,
-0.0362622589,
0.0260511301,
0.0192879438,
-0.0109480731,
0.0295455307,
0.0478074364,
-0.0556548238,
-0.0177610405,
-0.0219898503,
0.0965567529,
-0.023809826,
-0.0136892404,
-0.0315123722,
-0.0302898865,
0.0040902216,
-0.0204792116,
-0.050203599,
0.0329547487,
0.006139671,
0.0277714115,
-0.0320819728,
0.0446715429,
0.0019254041,
-0.0119457589,
0.0015492052,
-0.024860695,
0.0221883208,
0.015120401,
-0.0121747963,
0.0309862122,
-0.0198463183,
-0.0408390313,
-0.0315997861,
0.0170657951,
-0.0019059635,
-0.0077025909,
-0.0919867009,
-0.0073198923,
-0.0139786871,
0.0036303191,
0.0623528361,
0.0238776691,
-0.0860118344,
0.0722110271,
-0.0384859703,
0.0469008274,
0.0032877175,
0.0372134857,
-0.0253599398,
-0.0292289648,
-0.0474294685,
-0.0074273855,
-0.0588446446,
0.0043181824,
-0.0448788069,
-0.0578956902,
-0.023206098,
0.018713003,
-0.0136454366,
-0.0163189918,
0.0122591415,
-0.0058028749,
-0.0409208238,
-0.0231440645,
-0.0367260501,
0.0236569587,
-0.0212487578,
0.0082547572,
0.0194593836,
-0.0620586425,
-0.0194961876,
0.0532635152,
0.0332705453,
-0.0450956225,
-0.0074760001,
0.0758665949,
-0.0327858888,
-0.062001802,
-0.0323820077,
-0.0003332816,
-0.041940257,
-0.0381279178,
0.0110576255,
-0.058721859,
0.020354135,
-0.0131646842,
0.0074199848,
-0.0479911193,
0.0011233275,
0.0147881061,
-0.0149965677,
0.108219862,
-0.0305914562,
-0.0177931692,
-0.0295189805,
0.001243712,
-0.0078373151,
0.0461164489,
-0.012431616,
0.074896425,
0.0118141482,
0.0005381949,
0.0406084843,
0.0324887112,
0.0018404922,
0.0084879333,
-0.0408595577,
0.0058611403,
-0.0015121027,
0.0062101781,
0.0481229313,
0.0505621918,
-0.0296361409,
0.0123554049,
0.084812738,
0.0343925655,
0.004313156,
-0.0114423651,
0.0797100961,
0.0357835405,
-0.0203094129,
-0.003135354,
-0.0563111976,
0.0493795127,
-0.0080037285,
0.0047587883,
-0.0020656949,
0.0135155283,
-0.0551290736,
-0.0241448004,
0.0276038591,
-0.0041454742,
0.0055585159,
0.0073754317,
0.0545389578,
0.0276845302,
-0.0318609662,
0.0006291489,
0.0165747721,
-0.0278637893,
0.0225215293,
-0.0480840169,
0.0193818845,
0.0682802349,
0.0136711765,
0.0206744596,
-0.0201370493,
0.004534611,
0.0378459096,
0.0426102206,
0.0324540026,
0.0105722575,
0.0210988298,
-0.0478169434,
-0.0742960572,
-0.048176378,
-0.0055819778,
0.0247912388,
0.0075786831,
0.0293959752,
0.0486706197,
-0.0181789584,
-0.0164018627,
0.0452936552,
0.0379772112,
-0.0492964573,
0.0144010941,
0.0121583398,
-0.0249070041,
-0.0244453382,
-0.0239378158,
0.001885231,
-0.0000060238,
-0.0159536675,
0.0109576248,
0.015835382,
-0.023943482,
-0.02593912,
-0.0045981719,
-0.0830212384,
0.0005835647,
0.0114327157,
-0.0571869686,
-0.0460929424,
-0.0122756194,
-0.0152804945,
0.0072750216,
-0.0511199012,
-0.0004896345,
0.0275603198,
0.0388449617,
-0.0199161377,
0.0661975071,
0.0249560792,
-0.0355767123,
0.0177461393,
0.0073949923,
-0.0008850379,
-0.0328834839,
-0.004528746,
-0.0277880654,
-0.0006581096,
0.0091819633,
0.0260341465,
0.037019711,
-0.0436112806,
0.0333140306,
-0.0701643229,
-0.0098331822,
-0.0291888174,
-0.0080083041,
0.0014153662,
0.003104104,
-0.0155811701,
-0.0416022539,
-0.0527315177,
0.0090075675,
-0.0043239165,
0.0015488795,
0.0330609009,
0.0278687049,
0.047828842,
0.0022131791,
-0.0043189265,
0.0467848517,
0.0391975082,
0.0151516106,
-0.0430524386,
-0.0328499191,
0.0392527245,
-0.0081089269,
0.0218284,
-0.0145488847,
0.0064867609,
-0.0002211881,
-0.0294970162,
0.0291686822,
0.0415079035,
0.0199699961,
0.0174165424,
0.0046775565,
0.0091415318,
-0.0252835434,
0.0084069213,
-0.0248379204,
-0.0311489813,
-0.0023613896,
-0.0032387036,
0.0150791081,
0.0031433178,
-0.017567018,
-0.0013217278,
-0.1064384952,
0.0367210358,
0.009660135,
-0.0159744769,
-0.0603418835,
0.0257331543,
0.0008915751,
0.0266787298,
-0.0287183523,
-0.0809149072,
0.0344706103,
-0.0320334546,
0.0044823466,
0.0185684822,
-0.0215576701,
-0.0326950327,
0.099492088,
0.0250259787,
0.011724514,
0.0339543149,
-0.007503137,
-0.054317154,
0.0072147115,
0.0042526978,
0.008395955,
0.0525542051,
-0.0464345627,
0.0239921082,
-0.0370515734,
-0.0467012227,
-0.0317495242,
-0.0349392779,
-0.0228981152,
0.0165723432,
0.0158062913,
-0.0196749717,
-0.0295610912,
0.0348664299,
0.014148552,
0.0631493703,
-0.0187923033,
-0.0115497103,
-0.0151873613,
0.0355093293,
0.0849243626,
-0.0006165564,
-0.031298399,
-0.0242480822,
-0.023467714,
0.0465103462,
-0.0278141964,
0.0003938394,
-0.0507120676,
0.018995326,
0.0214028489,
0.0108977472,
-0.0117307315,
0.0216885433,
0.0582775734,
-0.0578142852,
-0.0066980948,
0.0727550834,
0.0156533048,
-0.0644229874,
-0.0371546932,
0.0379006378,
0.0016177336,
0.0137305586,
0.0375267044,
-0.0965309814,
-0.0524773225,
-0.0330554508,
-0.0065027699,
0.0332752354,
0.0256322175,
-0.0607232116,
-0.116026774,
0.0831806883,
0.0124190301,
-0.0293161012,
-0.0389987119,
0.0247498564,
0.0141500495,
-0.0267468095,
-0.0310764927,
-0.0135812936,
-0.0362384841,
0.0087500699,
-0.0031570455,
0.0141020026,
-0.0566315874,
0.0208946299,
-0.0268888194,
-0.0116189811,
0.0845436975,
0.012201814,
-0.0090318648,
-0.0399640203,
0.018100325,
-0.0299174041,
0.0074015418,
0.0091657676,
0.0918804333,
-0.0468648151,
-0.0432824157,
0.0085149389,
0.0479997732,
0.0056862943,
-0.0256566051,
-0.002470332,
0.038281627,
-0.0153250052,
-0.0370856859,
-0.0463157706,
-0.0120686796,
0.007540036,
0.0558891073,
0.0222574491,
-0.0390873142,
-0.0290528163,
-0.0123349251,
-0.0063941483,
-0.0649250969,
-0.0410337597,
-0.0170517862,
0.0124398563,
0.0104131624,
-0.0665223598,
-0.0326859504,
0.0550684743,
0.0462610386,
-0.0046613808,
-0.0256323162,
-0.0436761379,
0.0191922225,
-0.0618089698,
0.0727578625,
-0.0477639884,
-0.0012191379,
-0.067361176,
-0.0223657992,
0.0460309573,
-0.0729067922,
-0.0208177678,
0.0249228459,
-0.0462607294,
-0.0195303801,
-0.068166472,
0.0924005285,
0.0120577747,
0.047132697,
-0.0159393046,
-0.0344679356,
0.0602841601,
0.0734289438,
0.0112345926,
-0.0280988812,
0.0140736327,
-0.0342282616,
-0.0204216484,
0.0148038259,
-0.0434877984,
0.0465342104,
0.0129663674,
0.0085969726,
0.0286562182,
-0.0049228813,
0.0436685011,
-0.0122632915,
0.0776308551,
-0.0288183503,
0.0348329395,
-0.0168049447,
-0.0045245858,
0.0001604262,
-0.0162353907,
-0.078480348,
0.0220071655,
0.0156022077,
0.0175073519,
0.0053807679,
0.0123680644,
-0.0166502669,
0.0175213479,
-0.0821494162,
-0.0398757793,
0.007976681,
-0.0175897367,
0.013411466,
0.0243099816,
-0.0017591832,
0.0060873758,
-0.0117048807,
0.0322379619,
-0.0223455131,
0.0420334749,
0.0385549366,
0.0163030364,
-0.0098382821,
0.0553791299,
-0.0478807166,
-0.0563755669,
-0.069750987,
0.031956058,
0.0375599675,
-0.0183054935,
0.0126026943,
-0.0414732844,
-0.0259411689,
-0.0317260474,
0.0529216193,
0.0242054425,
-0.0422493145,
0.0337250046,
0.0229364652,
-0.0217766762,
-0.0358190723,
0.0799948722,
0.0074223215,
0.0193301663,
0.0325329453,
-0.0082339793,
-0.0346738845,
-0.0169964302,
0.0319884904,
0.0036888034,
-0.00062978,
0.0278712753,
-0.0145986481,
-0.0585161895,
-0.0069322409,
-0.014107367,
-0.0102940928,
0.0428113863,
0.0724477768,
0.0330654345,
-0.0076818531,
-0.0227674972,
-0.0215484239,
-0.0279082023,
-0.0106139136,
0.0110608032,
0.0057017235,
-5.962227101e-33,
-0.0307024606,
-0.0108224954,
0.0506555438,
0.007476449,
-0.0114069367,
0.0113271102,
-0.0285438411,
-0.0031647647,
-0.0095776049,
0.0220997836,
0.012353464,
-0.0125946756,
0.0275719259,
0.0728473589,
-0.0225766096,
-0.000470342,
0.053810671,
0.0229504649,
-0.0191923752,
0.0401049517,
0.0115751131,
0.0176909547,
0.0561941452,
-0.0224926155,
-0.0092926826,
0.0137790442,
-0.0394813791,
-0.0064308322,
0.0266068429,
0.0547230616,
-0.00992171,
0.0253168717,
0.0016372243,
-0.0023147156,
-0.0385750607,
0.028936252,
-0.0593823232,
-0.0160864629,
0.0145573672,
0.0046216762,
-0.0737692714,
-0.0164482947,
0.0060544251,
-0.0407994054,
0.0227957238,
-0.0345232412,
0.0615360737,
-0.0289679971,
-0.0146395182,
-0.0240795836,
-0.0535007119,
0.0135479281,
0.0182112679,
-0.0476832353,
0.0542391688,
0.0768194869,
0.0182668902,
0.0441618711,
-0.0171132647,
0.0491082221,
0.0268199686,
0.0188421011,
0.0689634606,
0.0371755436,
0.0185130555,
0.053412322,
0.0029501931,
-0.0627957806,
-0.0192778371,
-0.0341272391,
0.0202793758,
0.0569579042,
0.0366731808,
0.0392152332,
0.0247333813,
0.0176994149,
-0.0224779043,
0.0239978991,
-0.0618135221,
0.0296300203,
0.024209002,
0.0024456698,
-0.0038996318,
0.0006335951,
-0.01742566,
-0.0288731549,
-0.0431876592,
-0.0320489369,
0.0631989241,
0.0349226631,
-0.0088161584,
0.0365410484,
0.0587349311,
-0.0206066072,
0.0101579307,
0.0233112928,
-0.0512964465,
0.0268881004,
0.0033413735,
-0.0002529212,
-0.032981541,
-0.0216421783,
0.0634718463,
-0.0022220209,
-0.0330962241,
0.0204824209,
0.0697891936,
0.0475191511,
-0.04695566,
0.0146363508,
-0.0307190828,
0.0173511952,
-0.0287555084,
0.0444525294,
0.0206069183,
0.0155331567,
-0.06423188,
0.0327253044,
0.0064880233,
-0.0261283051,
-0.0016716293,
-0.0252074115,
0.0041339626,
0.023016762,
-0.0093055954,
0.0251986943,
-0.04101694,
0.0026731684,
0.024444228,
-0.0460741334,
-0.0290089548,
0.0244003478,
2.613e-7,
0.0291856788,
0.0037710709,
0.0091871796,
0.0391516238,
-0.0202034973,
0.0302567147,
-0.0009054822,
0.0508731045,
-0.0098119611,
0.0041490826,
0.0481295548,
0.0372730829,
0.0332013071,
-0.0269354973,
-0.0582535081,
0.0473119803,
-0.0259875059,
-0.0385357551,
-0.0461840518,
-0.023569474,
0.0869568512,
0.0965325385,
-0.0141861215,
-0.0107449023,
0.0761978999,
-0.0541326106,
0.111904338,
-0.0423236936,
0.0126766022,
-0.004651655,
-0.0321986899,
0.059577994,
-0.0621730462,
0.037054643,
-0.0123945512,
-0.0150760096,
0.0525659323,
0.0489431731,
-0.0022602933,
-0.0058492981,
-0.0238835309,
0.0410740748,
0.0096087893,
-0.0369813964,
0.0898115784,
-0.086571604,
-0.0075607183,
-0.0394289382,
-0.0555706695,
0.004094311,
0.004206724,
-0.042362269,
-0.0280662514,
0.0176452305,
0.0393254384,
0.0173299238,
-0.0587738454,
-0.090159297,
0.0032747784,
-0.0107492935,
-0.0144854579,
-0.0055465512,
-0.0734192804,
0.0024839537,
0.0204566177,
-0.0292888097,
-0.0263020936,
2.12026189e-34,
0.031967774,
0.0164034739,
-0.0083565349,
-0.0316777043,
-0.0007321569,
0.0298520401,
0.0028144692,
-0.0062428783,
0.0075758006,
-0.0585999787,
-0.0364936963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11636v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11636v1 | OxfordTVG-HIC: Can Machine Make Humorous Captions from Images? | 2023-07-21T14:58:44 | 2023-07-21T14:58:44 | Runjia Li, Shuyang Sun, Mohamed Elhoseiny, Philip Torr | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | This paper presents OxfordTVG-HIC (Humorous Image Captions), a large-scale
dataset for humour generation and understanding. Humour is an abstract,
subjective, and context-dependent cognitive construct involving several
cognitive factors, making it a challenging task to generate and interpret.
Hence, humour generation and understanding can serve as a new task for
evaluating the ability of deep-learning methods to process abstract and
subjective information. Due to the scarcity of data, humour-related generation
tasks such as captioning remain under-explored. To address this gap,
OxfordTVG-HIC offers approximately 2.9M image-text pairs with humour scores to
train a generalizable humour captioning model. Contrary to existing captioning
datasets, OxfordTVG-HIC features a wide range of emotional and semantic
diversity resulting in out-of-context examples that are particularly conducive
to generating humour. Moreover, OxfordTVG-HIC is curated devoid of offensive
content. We also show how OxfordTVG-HIC can be leveraged for evaluating the
humour of a generated text. Through explainability analysis of the trained
models, we identify the visual and linguistic cues influential for evoking
humour prediction (and generation). We observe qualitatively that these cues
are aligned with the benign violation theory of humour in cognitive psychology. | [
0.071665369,
0.086061351,
-0.0141725354,
0.0184031762,
0.0148218572,
0.0494079292,
0.0129882107,
0.0232729558,
0.0551215522,
-0.0205262806,
-0.0068992809,
-0.0201099049,
-0.0164061524,
0.0630610436,
0.0082153175,
-0.0788549557,
-0.0247680694,
0.0302878655,
0.0114376191,
-0.0231028348,
0.0121378461,
0.0150527274,
-0.0052022282,
0.0458565876,
-0.0110659357,
0.0000028782,
0.0023465748,
0.0793587789,
0.0012877458,
-0.0036469502,
0.0049778866,
0.0245622508,
0.0155457584,
-0.0067724935,
0.0000017882,
-0.0131395692,
0.0250274334,
-0.0225374792,
0.0159712266,
0.0139860837,
0.0617103018,
-0.0369761772,
-0.0376795568,
-0.0063896845,
-0.0143089686,
0.0556871928,
0.0797398984,
0.0554660037,
0.0845114291,
0.0620304048,
-0.0189670473,
-0.0142780161,
-0.0241087005,
-0.0294813849,
0.0377153493,
-0.0443849228,
0.0073406803,
0.0569523536,
-0.0383073017,
-0.0208729971,
-0.0611477941,
0.0093958862,
-0.0029900647,
-0.0204973985,
-0.0134905735,
0.0040810662,
-0.0204278547,
-0.0432868265,
0.0009413773,
0.0729616731,
0.0050345198,
0.0165681802,
0.0089359879,
0.0264496747,
-0.0066482304,
-0.0240950268,
-0.0560375117,
0.0364933386,
0.0302972868,
0.0125187254,
-0.0157138854,
0.052324377,
-0.0036758143,
0.0534094647,
0.0227487497,
-0.0314411074,
-0.0019024585,
0.0189419053,
-0.0338487439,
-0.0068392875,
-0.078313075,
-0.0369072594,
0.0474169403,
0.045012515,
0.0294385161,
0.0251769163,
-0.0197164677,
-0.0208943374,
0.031150043,
-0.0545931458,
0.0084684109,
0.0131582916,
-0.0455512851,
0.0775717348,
-0.0127940224,
0.0492688082,
-0.0398836285,
-0.0104767615,
-0.0366097726,
-0.0096733468,
-0.0286232196,
-0.0110560609,
0.0040789484,
0.005579425,
-0.0310228802,
-0.0338455215,
-0.064290151,
0.0134807751,
-0.0225786269,
-0.0127935624,
0.0167170428,
0.0787460208,
-0.054020483,
-0.0286474843,
-0.0179797634,
0.0083124526,
-0.0411722139,
-0.0009704774,
-0.0233873669,
-0.0493466221,
-0.0082759596,
0.0392548554,
0.030684676,
-0.0213230122,
0.0315274522,
0.0692247525,
0.0079239812,
-0.0263227988,
-0.0217079557,
-0.0659970939,
-0.0693870932,
-0.0338037647,
0.0396089777,
-0.021898251,
0.0085314149,
-0.0359785445,
-0.005887452,
-0.0410182066,
0.0192894675,
0.0051386598,
-0.0167142618,
0.0537905954,
-0.0129643707,
-0.0245710928,
0.0100869145,
0.0367081016,
-0.0107592996,
0.0456648432,
0.0292156544,
0.0549401492,
0.0426581092,
-0.0280206725,
0.0198240764,
0.0029476371,
0.0264694523,
-0.0047736736,
-0.0132123232,
-0.0115823057,
-0.0569918305,
0.0442798622,
0.0525384471,
0.0301350448,
-0.0008295264,
0.0094402721,
0.0328563899,
0.0003324288,
0.0161004309,
0.0603442788,
0.0656072274,
-0.0035649878,
-0.0424331278,
0.02289664,
-0.0182451084,
0.0482169464,
-0.0302364491,
-0.0051025278,
0.0048525478,
0.0431636125,
-0.0291526057,
-0.039049387,
0.0161294211,
-0.0390528925,
0.0430549346,
-0.044216536,
0.0330384076,
0.0468094014,
-0.0646796376,
0.0392412543,
0.0080579417,
-0.0699630901,
-0.0254492331,
0.0013976248,
0.0103335371,
0.0527818464,
0.0324001908,
-0.0052842316,
-0.0045512533,
-0.0146021741,
0.0275371633,
0.0309052132,
-0.0010253096,
0.0410986356,
0.0422422066,
-0.0519545414,
0.0245884415,
-0.0302016195,
0.017994443,
0.0117256492,
0.0249065552,
0.0253503844,
0.0110280188,
0.0205055308,
-0.0193958152,
0.0352902673,
-0.0486084521,
-0.0361574292,
-0.0028762273,
0.0276011471,
0.0404984951,
0.0058789169,
-0.0043166107,
-0.0288271885,
0.0146303894,
-0.035322912,
-0.0262483731,
0.0743741021,
-0.0596209541,
-0.0524106547,
0.0074510933,
-0.0988741666,
0.0013943432,
0.0478717647,
-0.0416712612,
-0.0178960189,
0.047877159,
-0.0566687658,
-0.0238064546,
-0.0846528783,
-0.0315326974,
-0.0062453048,
0.036798656,
0.0240512379,
0.0600785986,
-0.0196584277,
-0.0098883705,
0.0054100039,
-0.0089742262,
-0.004850361,
0.0064982153,
-0.0409537107,
-0.0018216348,
-0.0213313978,
0.0030455003,
-0.0229949038,
0.0428891405,
-0.0486047119,
-0.0198128279,
-0.0915689692,
-0.0059179314,
-0.0052390718,
-0.0462105535,
0.0226847082,
-0.0189630128,
0.006509135,
-0.0201198924,
-0.0191165954,
0.0238918122,
0.002016111,
0.005174689,
0.0267553981,
-0.0192519464,
-0.0138581246,
-0.0369207636,
-0.0107599823,
-0.0085119717,
0.0708699822,
0.0238906518,
0.0411002636,
0.0013341513,
0.0379597843,
-0.0726256967,
-0.0134810479,
-0.0079392381,
-0.0742242783,
0.0013465628,
0.0174967907,
-0.0413190983,
0.0536862016,
0.0570846088,
0.0533604659,
-0.0226949248,
0.0089424504,
0.0082272161,
-0.016381599,
-0.0067644198,
0.0283363834,
0.0191691536,
-0.0719871745,
-0.0264653582,
0.0168768298,
0.0092567438,
0.0495759882,
-0.0970842615,
0.0505968221,
0.0214971192,
-0.0326451585,
-0.0167716015,
-0.0169560649,
-0.0087108407,
0.0162253324,
-0.0278639812,
-0.0460479222,
0.0629080459,
-0.0055538942,
-0.0539063513,
0.0067339297,
-0.0011751363,
-0.0194428694,
0.1036305279,
0.0075978423,
0.0577934571,
-0.008645786,
-0.0118289273,
-0.0030870216,
-0.0183455348,
-0.0061530783,
-0.0280089676,
0.0390543491,
-0.0111279013,
-0.0461318381,
0.0129421903,
-0.031133011,
-0.0315258875,
-0.0337028019,
-0.0275395475,
-0.0076594041,
-0.014102187,
-0.0135264639,
0.0027524694,
-0.0023710809,
0.0054566897,
-0.0495363921,
-0.0180191901,
-0.0066924896,
0.0031245505,
0.0220262613,
0.0645469725,
0.0367860347,
0.0012121154,
0.0171081014,
-0.0109068099,
0.0100702541,
-0.0582878552,
0.0208871216,
-0.0301757883,
0.0382689983,
-0.029257521,
0.0247062482,
-0.0041608838,
-0.0205876157,
0.0825777948,
-0.012984952,
-0.0321514867,
0.057066977,
-0.0075286673,
0.01303716,
0.0270590745,
0.0212350469,
-0.0135165062,
0.0197868571,
-0.005113116,
-0.0333178043,
-0.0276179779,
-0.0121116405,
0.0041569294,
-0.0155282533,
-0.0076364647,
-0.0431406051,
-0.0771207809,
0.032895606,
0.0085636284,
-0.0139517263,
-0.0103503615,
0.0226451475,
-0.0351046212,
-0.019331567,
-0.0126311108,
-0.0069370549,
0.0294727162,
0.0112745501,
0.0212217588,
0.0252725147,
-0.0358963646,
0.0484589785,
0.0018444732,
0.0538912863,
0.0417482518,
0.0721103251,
-0.0105442936,
-0.0636315271,
-0.0241214633,
-0.0370995738,
0.0131780962,
-0.0096256593,
0.077904433,
0.0002771595,
-0.0247837901,
-0.0305681285,
0.0525006875,
-0.0255592745,
0.0114831124,
-0.0286663678,
0.0199748836,
-0.0081631187,
-0.0273901466,
-0.0693951249,
0.072996676,
-0.0098802662,
0.1014101356,
0.0557823181,
-0.0626493022,
-0.0051819873,
-0.0521586053,
-0.003134025,
-0.1068558469,
-0.0100014955,
-0.0048214216,
0.0081649572,
-0.0132615184,
-0.0878219381,
-0.0070251161,
0.0130801834,
0.007111907,
-0.0142530045,
-0.0582003258,
-0.0927949846,
0.0106005967,
-0.0283430181,
0.0102702621,
0.0018832291,
-0.0420607403,
-0.0029223883,
0.0115878116,
0.0469189696,
-0.0869825631,
-0.0502070189,
0.0086327996,
-0.0218496434,
-0.0231026281,
0.0323575884,
0.0719007999,
0.0169455037,
-0.0045345929,
0.0275713541,
-0.0451128967,
0.0153991692,
0.0852743164,
0.0059747109,
0.01194245,
0.0425977632,
0.052372247,
0.0025234681,
0.0432775542,
-0.0413284414,
0.0637712032,
0.0059692264,
-0.0137090487,
-0.0132161006,
-0.0375446565,
-0.0264422689,
0.0029171831,
-0.0159857161,
-0.0368843339,
-0.0718115121,
0.0161264502,
-0.0188870449,
0.0186235532,
0.0028539989,
-0.0511745736,
0.0075254473,
0.0160434172,
0.0199813042,
-0.035211239,
-0.0584996119,
-0.0422284231,
0.0208211821,
-0.0131817255,
-0.0127163259,
0.0317037813,
-0.020304393,
-0.0279138442,
0.0341676064,
-0.0258314777,
0.0121935215,
-0.0394275039,
-0.0054790778,
0.0123607935,
0.0655899197,
0.0145227406,
-0.0045530545,
0.0031291621,
0.032448791,
0.0119002573,
0.0261098705,
-0.0138297547,
-0.0068285237,
0.0665388927,
-0.0224389192,
0.0592678823,
-0.0219796468,
0.014535198,
0.0137357004,
0.0257231612,
0.0086803548,
-0.0949789435,
0.0188870113,
-0.0167786982,
0.0223457292,
-0.0195998326,
0.0551374331,
-0.0658081174,
0.0425129235,
0.0466441251,
-0.0062604509,
-0.0443835221,
-0.00201759,
0.0270066839,
0.0310639851,
0.0328549668,
0.0435152762,
-0.0012178819,
-0.0517299771,
0.0405998975,
-0.021812534,
0.0288743861,
-0.0052887215,
0.0568031594,
0.046425011,
-0.0131577179,
0.0315478854,
-0.0144535955,
0.0255321898,
-0.0805204809,
0.0377293639,
-0.0347004235,
-5.949435518e-33,
-0.0215997417,
-0.0352508835,
-0.0540380441,
0.015156338,
0.0048208768,
-0.0011877659,
-0.0877135023,
0.0074816123,
-0.0018894651,
0.0247589499,
0.0264855213,
0.0005293032,
-0.0122953421,
0.0396361947,
0.008435498,
-0.0220927559,
0.0312552825,
0.0207293686,
-0.0182167385,
0.0358321704,
0.0497688837,
0.0236845333,
0.0450068973,
-0.0883494988,
-0.0036843212,
-0.0168826338,
-0.051987797,
0.0076764547,
0.04945888,
0.0681442842,
-0.0206291024,
0.0406494513,
0.0348358601,
0.0234462656,
0.000427382,
0.0201214179,
-0.0242898017,
-0.0199507382,
0.0170332417,
-0.0148249697,
-0.058269944,
-0.0459842272,
0.0567195863,
-0.029773498,
-0.0190211628,
-0.0317072272,
0.0616308153,
-0.026792407,
0.0465661325,
-0.0573527254,
-0.0237015728,
-0.0120529691,
-0.0339760855,
-0.0454961397,
0.0051348144,
0.030356532,
0.0335040949,
0.0381886736,
-0.0251018535,
0.0283434726,
-0.0602714568,
-0.0306649804,
0.0244615674,
-0.044862099,
0.0065802452,
0.0741468295,
-0.0085299863,
0.0310625061,
-0.0509484597,
0.0002543794,
0.0013534157,
0.0630483776,
0.0889391154,
0.0557206795,
0.042352926,
-0.0191132091,
-0.0469403863,
0.0258156098,
-0.0309764948,
-0.0031579987,
0.0434608236,
0.0063751787,
-0.0253602955,
0.0387495905,
0.0081578521,
-0.0156988185,
-0.0106075918,
-0.0730691925,
-0.0071470323,
0.016546132,
-0.0643300638,
-0.0060035246,
0.0267458018,
-0.0319215059,
0.0271791164,
-0.0020910997,
-0.0188721847,
0.0326014459,
-0.0027057086,
-0.005039115,
-0.0096576205,
-0.0181374457,
0.0512080602,
0.0390272997,
0.0318223722,
0.0110682752,
0.0801426843,
0.0128543517,
0.0010327045,
0.0105570732,
-0.0374931172,
0.0297604036,
-0.0498930998,
0.0138390884,
-0.0131590106,
0.051091522,
-0.0644228458,
-0.0749261826,
0.0449754037,
0.0305797197,
-0.0236236174,
-0.0178401396,
0.0067664571,
0.0274055563,
-0.0763789192,
-0.030962076,
-0.0165758356,
-0.0775231123,
-0.0009020924,
-0.0700928941,
-0.0110321036,
0.0035900662,
2.552e-7,
0.0224543344,
0.0400314331,
0.0433623902,
0.0219061691,
0.0619285405,
0.0330142975,
0.0163996406,
0.0208032336,
0.0077643357,
-0.0339324661,
0.0270106737,
0.0208013747,
0.0036107288,
-0.0207666866,
-0.0256843511,
0.0059320838,
-0.057988964,
0.0327427313,
-0.0149939014,
-0.0015185855,
0.0638166294,
0.040351849,
0.0075200251,
-0.025101969,
0.0428738929,
-0.0517292805,
0.0492776372,
-0.0510580502,
0.0465749577,
-0.0374907441,
0.0041572517,
0.0215353835,
-0.0155295553,
-0.0158062726,
0.0129359486,
-0.0629981533,
0.0184197687,
0.0348061547,
-0.031127857,
-0.023468338,
0.0056221597,
0.0381514095,
-0.0058389036,
-0.0565667637,
0.0498758219,
-0.0123015847,
-0.0396686122,
-0.0204824395,
-0.0204854142,
-0.0183468815,
0.0704805776,
-0.0090698777,
-0.0095763709,
-0.003693531,
0.0405185819,
0.0005815844,
0.0003052335,
-0.0674390718,
-0.0370705873,
-0.0018890034,
-0.0547127761,
0.0185287595,
-0.0393058658,
-0.0306629259,
0.0252666436,
-0.0709402561,
-0.0121686235,
1.997748746e-34,
0.0346521996,
0.0065837544,
0.0118998457,
-0.034044005,
0.0164138675,
0.0269300677,
0.0022415787,
-0.0257933885,
0.0320661068,
-0.0183280371,
-0.0203430559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11610v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11610v2 | CausE: Towards Causal Knowledge Graph Embedding | 2023-07-21T14:25:39 | 2023-07-24T01:35:47 | Yichi Zhang, Wen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge graph embedding (KGE) focuses on representing the entities and
relations of a knowledge graph (KG) into the continuous vector spaces, which
can be employed to predict the missing triples to achieve knowledge graph
completion (KGC). However, KGE models often only briefly learn structural
correlations of triple data and embeddings would be misled by the trivial
patterns and noisy links in real-world KGs. To address this issue, we build the
new paradigm of KGE in the context of causality and embedding disentanglement.
We further propose a Causality-enhanced knowledge graph Embedding (CausE)
framework. CausE employs causal intervention to estimate the causal effect of
the confounder embeddings and design new training objectives to make stable
predictions. Experimental results demonstrate that CausE could outperform the
baseline models and achieve state-of-the-art KGC performance. We release our
code in https://github.com/zjukg/CausE. | [
-0.0004783673,
0.0429537408,
-0.01431832,
0.0383257866,
0.0249690562,
0.00856023,
-0.022487564,
-0.0049235839,
0.0795212686,
-0.0072436654,
0.0626530498,
0.064129509,
-0.0360858515,
0.041447971,
0.0520435646,
-0.0140102357,
0.0444798917,
0.0399350934,
-0.0084257163,
-0.0384207517,
-0.0301634353,
0.0065540671,
-0.0025105141,
0.0047365944,
-0.0429099202,
-0.0088063739,
0.0103788814,
-0.0234241039,
0.0076377583,
-0.0001430645,
-0.0052461172,
0.0048707556,
0.0432267971,
-0.0382472873,
0.0000021005,
-0.0129508581,
0.0023471159,
-0.0087813651,
-0.013448705,
-0.0329856239,
-0.0995899066,
-0.0160388052,
0.0743084997,
-0.0065636542,
-0.035362646,
-0.004369041,
0.0063696527,
0.0740616545,
-0.0150641324,
0.0486563481,
-0.033735849,
-0.0397025123,
0.0338519625,
-0.0363446996,
0.0351998359,
0.0165951829,
0.0424704403,
0.0357823037,
-0.0363626555,
-0.01893121,
-0.0677441955,
0.0149383694,
0.0446411148,
0.0212733168,
0.0868623257,
0.0179656371,
0.0074571492,
0.0035881065,
0.0411778241,
0.1087903082,
0.0117829302,
0.0164578538,
0.0227081999,
-0.0108400332,
0.0195504893,
0.0371563956,
-0.0422187671,
-0.0814546496,
0.0060946112,
0.0002814224,
-0.0126138125,
-0.0183858313,
0.0763021037,
0.0006351654,
-0.021825036,
0.054557845,
0.0110659543,
-0.0316320732,
-0.0206989665,
0.0098708067,
-0.0072079054,
0.0025454189,
-0.0171530861,
-0.0179938767,
-0.0043162042,
0.0116975103,
0.0199253596,
0.0114064682,
-0.0144958952,
-0.0074810577,
-0.0510421693,
0.0064120432,
0.0054678186,
0.0616667792,
-0.0700040609,
0.0231302083,
-0.0409910344,
0.0623272993,
-0.0123975854,
0.0092107039,
-0.0400067493,
-0.0035323428,
0.0154568292,
0.0390989706,
0.0013166373,
-0.0235645548,
-0.0246474575,
0.0459004007,
-0.0615550056,
0.0616657101,
-0.0050393166,
0.0706035495,
0.0290805753,
-0.0035282765,
-0.0187161695,
0.0310984906,
-0.0553481691,
0.0592574626,
-0.0502697192,
0.0407249741,
-0.010241841,
-0.0018654305,
0.0195808057,
-0.0403273366,
-0.0045944927,
0.0580032654,
0.0286638252,
-0.0138374027,
-0.0294840299,
-0.0560889691,
0.0164260287,
-0.0413496457,
0.0492227152,
-0.0291825198,
0.0487702005,
0.0103027839,
-0.0015761933,
-0.0404044688,
-0.0025107567,
-0.0695203245,
-0.103721559,
0.0563327707,
-0.0217862856,
-0.023612773,
-0.0249958578,
0.0134158852,
-0.0192831494,
0.039429795,
0.0173142664,
-0.0051921587,
0.0214503184,
-0.0204555821,
-0.0313864686,
-0.0091093155,
0.0794423148,
-0.0153452875,
0.0076089832,
0.0149399014,
-0.0084152045,
0.0440070406,
0.0292868726,
-0.0129521629,
-0.039053157,
0.0122280959,
0.0070503182,
-0.0105336895,
0.0383969806,
0.0166303609,
0.0175427627,
-0.0467649847,
-0.0349096321,
0.0370989479,
-0.0547353961,
0.0358616859,
-0.0264372565,
0.0138616357,
0.0331127867,
-0.0018962747,
-0.035266798,
-0.0253084656,
0.0349094234,
-0.0235506147,
0.0252522677,
0.0180544108,
0.0707192943,
0.0050825905,
-0.0433770381,
-0.0175355021,
0.0141683035,
-0.0191338509,
0.0395133495,
0.0272468701,
0.0304317717,
0.0625175163,
0.0745157674,
-0.0292927679,
-0.0167108085,
-0.0212512221,
-0.0092197433,
-0.0451904908,
0.0091712093,
-0.0386974476,
0.0299018044,
-0.0473775491,
-0.083563149,
-0.0044080843,
0.0027088812,
-0.0178053938,
0.0306637269,
0.0008325455,
0.0214021318,
-0.0586479455,
0.0452175997,
0.0065723434,
-0.0543969832,
0.0058330782,
-0.0103271045,
0.0487015583,
0.0474518202,
0.035945341,
0.0127947163,
-0.0126690483,
0.0347130038,
-0.0339341387,
-0.0754175633,
0.0179504566,
0.0098077925,
-0.0562740304,
0.0154702961,
-0.0498024598,
-0.0002296777,
0.006890852,
-0.0336458944,
-0.0678308457,
0.0820215717,
0.0202436969,
0.0612076819,
-0.0002081767,
-0.0490761064,
0.019227026,
-0.0077875159,
0.0120442724,
0.0547938682,
-0.0181037057,
0.0068977848,
-0.0167597216,
-0.0237371121,
0.0237172823,
0.0368597806,
-0.0136402128,
-0.0153889284,
0.003494801,
0.008139723,
0.0287904199,
-0.0597510822,
-0.0520980135,
0.0039265878,
-0.0630440339,
0.0031136558,
0.0217554811,
-0.0430324636,
-0.037334092,
0.0067499396,
0.0464457572,
-0.0414050557,
0.0018962142,
0.0212593712,
-0.0134640057,
0.0226456039,
0.0258183312,
-0.019632332,
-0.0156865809,
0.0082883611,
-0.0121868737,
-0.0494855307,
0.0600255355,
0.0102041196,
-0.035126742,
0.0365866423,
0.0094717778,
-0.0523081273,
0.0015749852,
-0.0474220254,
0.0173571538,
-0.0264015254,
-0.0101714032,
0.0160708297,
0.0330140106,
-0.0632988214,
0.0319257192,
0.0223819762,
0.0062064989,
-0.0317971557,
0.0167992879,
-0.0806513503,
0.0350038074,
-0.0386402607,
0.0131005542,
-0.0614223294,
0.0129776821,
0.0138588035,
-0.0267112441,
-0.0916973948,
-0.0117279794,
0.0346164331,
-0.0048496583,
-0.0423766486,
-0.0038489287,
0.0224913899,
0.003230192,
-0.0360422507,
-0.0248570126,
0.054400377,
0.0364809409,
0.0290769525,
0.0367918164,
0.0421000011,
-0.0078391405,
0.0404023528,
0.0116004162,
-0.0104230652,
0.0259050578,
-0.0049528917,
-0.0544080399,
-0.0097138127,
0.0305406731,
0.0104033835,
-0.0143696247,
0.0023671598,
-0.000336039,
0.054876551,
-0.025168987,
-0.0337197259,
-0.0142492708,
-0.0051971236,
0.0152805923,
-0.0131476093,
-0.0234630052,
0.0045426786,
-0.0589664243,
-0.0000582939,
-0.0160561744,
0.0043988014,
-0.0160127785,
-0.0316854082,
0.0342556126,
0.0401817076,
-0.0236233808,
0.0181928203,
-0.0200250819,
-0.0042539183,
-0.0071004503,
0.000510784,
-0.01003101,
-0.0079081412,
0.0319993794,
-0.0348770954,
0.0133007094,
-0.0276675653,
-0.0157458354,
-0.0164047796,
-0.0105699422,
0.0487343818,
0.066742979,
-0.0079187015,
0.0013294598,
0.0122693963,
0.0463383161,
-0.0141583886,
0.0578600839,
0.0017945287,
-0.1139447466,
-0.0098538371,
-0.0143091585,
-0.006987209,
0.0328078903,
-0.0486552455,
0.0122107239,
-0.0501272082,
0.0157830361,
0.0261342414,
0.0379126072,
-0.0643412545,
-0.0454537533,
0.0139376037,
-0.0281828698,
-0.0644599795,
-0.0503937081,
0.0249169357,
0.0023415976,
-0.0107731503,
-0.0293297134,
-0.0678693429,
-0.00722832,
-0.0264274906,
0.0655078068,
0.0064575863,
0.0220662057,
-0.0184754711,
-0.0022580554,
-0.0341321975,
0.0411744155,
-0.0347581841,
0.0029499019,
0.0783017427,
-0.010219859,
-0.0186869018,
-0.0169693101,
0.0400237329,
-0.0590841882,
-0.0009271044,
-0.0072850971,
0.1355232298,
-0.0124684535,
-0.0351081006,
-0.0184335019,
-0.0270016398,
-0.0150048286,
0.0391284749,
-0.0102129523,
0.0045073158,
-0.0136583131,
0.0022008845,
0.0163562745,
0.0051816832,
0.0311346669,
-0.0095514869,
0.0075779818,
0.0179257821,
-0.0258474667,
-0.0422643013,
0.0731034279,
-0.0132485423,
0.0204920527,
0.0211961865,
-0.0015666343,
-0.0427476503,
-0.0677571818,
0.0235198848,
-0.0023344748,
0.0317468047,
0.0245615393,
0.0237631258,
-0.0240061507,
-0.0193463825,
-0.0257667359,
-0.0251728743,
-0.0543444306,
-0.0534973182,
-0.0487064235,
0.0442811102,
0.0028797903,
0.0998290926,
-0.0295130815,
-0.0192920864,
0.0350466296,
0.0169779379,
-0.0396464206,
0.010460454,
0.0330569781,
-0.0397580266,
0.002617016,
0.0420247801,
-0.0591886267,
-0.0320196114,
-0.0075416956,
0.0288002212,
-0.0570772476,
0.0238740332,
-0.0313715823,
-0.002022431,
0.0518321171,
0.0107976031,
0.027320452,
-0.0828182921,
0.0050990079,
-0.0184034072,
-0.0159088392,
-0.0505044684,
-0.0086367158,
0.0596011467,
0.018135393,
0.0147720603,
-0.0479770005,
0.0232362151,
0.0221691541,
-0.0304853804,
-0.0170026924,
0.0199794248,
-0.0137667647,
0.0551981963,
0.0148669081,
-0.0093678515,
0.0473520607,
0.0254049078,
-0.0245761499,
-0.0303508844,
0.0131261991,
0.0161650106,
0.0195828322,
-0.0204165187,
-0.0493748225,
-0.0504112244,
0.0055337357,
0.0003159837,
0.0150140012,
0.063634865,
-0.0081886286,
0.0457100645,
-0.0153564336,
-0.0078021702,
-0.0013746101,
0.0743260235,
-0.0081155282,
-0.0076815928,
0.0372203477,
0.0071296836,
-0.0333120674,
0.0260504894,
0.060138803,
0.0266925301,
0.0742323101,
-0.0531469285,
-0.0223484486,
-0.0327917412,
-0.0350063853,
0.0514434576,
0.0752972215,
-0.0342743471,
0.0701775849,
-0.0418514758,
-0.0675917193,
0.0067836791,
-0.0392385349,
-0.0641380772,
0.0268195849,
0.0062816339,
-0.0037506756,
0.0119410595,
-0.0302919243,
-0.0153124491,
-0.0100909844,
-0.0404236689,
-0.0505846702,
0.0161046479,
-6.261783469e-33,
-0.0179480519,
-0.0340546444,
0.0188910831,
0.0153136384,
-0.030809816,
0.0323445909,
-0.0226515699,
-0.0215961393,
-0.0237943605,
0.041230429,
-0.0001194643,
0.0457235835,
-0.0116137341,
0.0004242941,
0.0063814842,
-0.0065163709,
0.0487756468,
0.0178507529,
0.0345402509,
0.0260469634,
0.0443760455,
0.0332596153,
0.046915248,
-0.1227130666,
0.0264303815,
-0.0127244405,
-0.0015454721,
-0.0039546723,
-0.0015830033,
0.0149514955,
-0.0259540509,
0.0503201373,
0.024650529,
0.0142017324,
-0.0066963551,
-0.0202076621,
-0.1196877211,
-0.0675769374,
0.026785817,
0.0130101172,
-0.0534689166,
-0.0233238414,
0.0036094724,
-0.0024244997,
0.0792745724,
-0.0678888857,
0.0551763698,
-0.0146944104,
-0.0732014105,
-0.0368401073,
-0.0318946131,
0.0121543128,
-0.0348116904,
0.0066754501,
0.0250445623,
0.0171426386,
0.056070853,
-0.0375805385,
-0.044856593,
-0.0048647262,
-0.0294186771,
-0.0407156795,
-0.0065853605,
-0.0133862365,
0.0311427582,
0.0453335345,
-0.0246053766,
-0.0028721946,
-0.0253423974,
-0.0005074323,
-0.0057044956,
0.0533872806,
-0.0048674392,
0.0323937163,
-0.0100927567,
-0.0477901213,
-0.0793165043,
-0.0182983913,
0.0018554046,
0.0053456156,
-0.0186836813,
-0.0197059978,
-0.0183675885,
-0.0427358523,
-0.0584482253,
-0.0091148559,
-0.0111420909,
-0.0289938319,
0.0058279326,
0.0340992771,
0.0158903468,
-0.0091643687,
-0.0091693942,
-0.0769907907,
0.0151774734,
0.0951772928,
0.006286996,
0.0235935152,
0.0239786506,
-0.0041894387,
-0.0225035567,
-0.0254219156,
0.0253101718,
-0.0140806017,
0.0375492573,
0.0302981194,
0.0680119917,
-0.0039292122,
-0.0130477268,
-0.0268270001,
-0.036393363,
-0.0585455298,
0.0096303485,
-0.0385015495,
0.0379961692,
0.0761208236,
-0.003800137,
0.0130407661,
0.0550017916,
0.0679281503,
0.0011911131,
0.0055732769,
0.0072541586,
0.0250529908,
-0.0213426352,
-0.0503465943,
-0.0261905603,
-0.0142372642,
0.0343736298,
-0.0523416325,
-0.0157882106,
-0.0358363874,
2.742e-7,
0.036315795,
0.0104389777,
0.0181225222,
0.024256397,
0.008062995,
0.0243832488,
0.0220782291,
0.0341183655,
-0.0295698494,
0.0256527103,
0.060412772,
-0.0145485196,
0.0121660456,
0.0061934399,
-0.0571580939,
0.0177212935,
-0.0268362891,
-0.0334625244,
-0.0245458726,
-0.0157260615,
0.0393682197,
0.0299056247,
0.0955309644,
0.0221372861,
0.0048492136,
-0.0225546993,
0.065211691,
-0.00012831,
0.0202227607,
-0.0200807657,
-0.0159809701,
0.0325737894,
0.0024521202,
0.0775837153,
-0.0190421175,
0.0464153513,
0.0093541825,
0.0183586255,
0.0167451203,
0.00691499,
-0.0337466002,
-0.0151813701,
0.0235177726,
-0.0307885874,
0.0889254436,
-0.0589052923,
-0.0067504337,
0.067787759,
-0.0527928025,
0.0217561424,
0.0353308246,
0.0350578241,
0.014469956,
-0.0355490036,
0.0109260362,
0.0175986309,
0.0221305396,
-0.0713132992,
0.0019828121,
0.0227302071,
-0.0179075934,
-0.0507936627,
0.0306835845,
-0.0470360219,
0.0490358509,
-0.0009566295,
0.009284649,
2.709440092e-34,
0.0216480233,
0.0195448007,
0.0327435881,
-0.0429436788,
0.0259270556,
-0.0741497949,
-0.0169307925,
-0.0365947187,
0.0533959605,
-0.0640807301,
0.0163856111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11584v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11584v1 | A Change of Heart: Improving Speech Emotion Recognition through Speech-to-Text Modality Conversion | 2023-07-21T13:48:11 | 2023-07-21T13:48:11 | Zeinab Sadat Taghavi, Ali Satvaty, Hossein Sameti | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Speech Emotion Recognition (SER) is a challenging task. In this paper, we
introduce a modality conversion concept aimed at enhancing emotion recognition
performance on the MELD dataset. We assess our approach through two
experiments: first, a method named Modality-Conversion that employs automatic
speech recognition (ASR) systems, followed by a text classifier; second, we
assume perfect ASR output and investigate the impact of modality conversion on
SER, this method is called Modality-Conversion++. Our findings indicate that
the first method yields substantial results, while the second method
outperforms state-of-the-art (SOTA) speech-based approaches in terms of SER
weighted-F1 (WF1) score on the MELD dataset. This research highlights the
potential of modality conversion for tasks that can be conducted in alternative
modalities. | [
-0.0189221445,
0.0950429589,
-0.0096218036,
0.005580279,
0.0041733081,
-0.0101576988,
0.0376131609,
-0.0086622704,
-0.019503979,
-0.0826140866,
-0.0651396364,
0.0198612791,
0.003948723,
0.0189685673,
-0.0525560118,
-0.0742486119,
0.0072894823,
-0.0074391766,
0.012163817,
0.0111558978,
0.0302018002,
0.0519162081,
-0.0278411135,
0.0277927928,
-0.0392304249,
0.037924733,
-0.0043026661,
0.0130720241,
0.0392089821,
-0.0373132527,
-0.0098793348,
0.0329024084,
0.0279397164,
0.0180335026,
0.0000019616,
-0.0278931353,
-0.0069989809,
0.0308540519,
-0.0343092494,
-0.0214694608,
0.107707426,
-0.0083298665,
-0.0167626366,
0.0357367359,
0.0029057628,
0.0110581601,
0.0552265011,
0.0506401919,
0.0380588099,
0.0609813221,
-0.0307138339,
0.0205538943,
0.0338491052,
0.0281453971,
-0.025438441,
-0.0063275425,
-0.0018021486,
0.0272102002,
0.0083737122,
-0.0617769808,
-0.0263260286,
0.0392613709,
-0.0487703644,
0.0018538089,
0.0110959914,
-0.0014552425,
-0.0005950272,
-0.0346815176,
-0.0523464717,
0.041456975,
0.0020199998,
-0.0072533269,
0.0069579869,
-0.0102047976,
-0.012585707,
-0.0087651154,
-0.000502661,
0.006288406,
0.001424362,
0.0183194112,
-0.0142536759,
0.0506506823,
-0.0029409397,
0.0089764539,
-0.0007238596,
-0.0226104334,
-0.0245546233,
-0.0174611919,
0.0434086286,
-0.0473805852,
0.0112780593,
0.0155307269,
0.0536615476,
-0.0236492846,
0.0267653111,
-0.0003776737,
-0.0475824326,
-0.0629831105,
-0.0264663436,
-0.0293128956,
-0.0292685181,
0.0272024106,
-0.057674896,
-0.0151949096,
0.0043851058,
0.0055018244,
0.0325873643,
-0.0295917839,
-0.0382329673,
-0.0083354041,
-0.0620660298,
0.0389834717,
-0.0117258541,
0.0229270961,
-0.051910989,
-0.0333720669,
-0.0507411771,
-0.0219565984,
-0.0082431408,
-0.0085358657,
0.0244115666,
-0.0088051585,
-0.0299356263,
0.0038730209,
0.00694315,
0.0673965439,
0.041822724,
0.0844592303,
-0.0177475102,
-0.0155539224,
0.055662293,
0.0090841884,
0.0261895917,
0.02012036,
0.0258699059,
0.0559907332,
-0.0465420932,
-0.0288774818,
-0.0261548739,
0.0233369526,
-0.0475289524,
-0.0288620126,
-0.0109796207,
-0.0199386925,
0.0512781292,
0.0118195303,
0.0043101334,
0.0097539676,
0.0265397932,
-0.0498851836,
0.0005064547,
0.0854769796,
-0.0137147242,
0.004452534,
0.0360736698,
0.0009276717,
0.0162135623,
0.0215416625,
0.0395164937,
0.0342469029,
0.0340099335,
-0.0494247116,
0.0233973023,
0.0523191281,
-0.0175880287,
0.0083460864,
-0.0002165052,
-0.0259724073,
-0.035820175,
0.0168006718,
0.0496113971,
0.0388870649,
0.002992799,
-0.0018075996,
0.0279653259,
0.0423679799,
0.033524096,
0.0549823791,
-0.0327984132,
0.052566167,
0.0377310105,
-0.0610529631,
-0.0214270055,
-0.0170395207,
-0.0789916888,
-0.0123907924,
0.0074384832,
0.0265260078,
-0.0134839108,
-0.0168533865,
-0.0282917321,
-0.0236487947,
0.0082219038,
0.0320498943,
0.0284211691,
-0.0196835957,
-0.0241391826,
0.0136245079,
-0.0051393481,
-0.1171182618,
0.0299408231,
-0.0616882145,
-0.0066496916,
0.0408543795,
-0.0206832308,
-0.0664075166,
0.0022185289,
-0.043899633,
-0.0393396951,
0.028724866,
-0.0068688206,
-0.0042100092,
0.047393363,
-0.0762994811,
0.0404381305,
0.0655171275,
0.0014432106,
0.0226105023,
-0.0738991052,
0.0381378904,
0.0020004301,
-0.011732975,
0.0136708682,
-0.0044106604,
0.020953849,
-0.0436462797,
0.0271451641,
-0.0168154072,
0.0293029789,
0.0170981884,
-0.021428518,
-0.0270283129,
0.0243776273,
0.009320166,
-0.0006567628,
0.0686684549,
-0.0121393735,
-0.0029126056,
0.029905878,
-0.0123664141,
0.0383388549,
0.0290947054,
-0.0193369631,
-0.0532420911,
0.0609973706,
-0.0033496157,
0.0328837596,
-0.0008325193,
0.0394760035,
-0.0078892764,
0.0254329853,
0.0266691707,
-0.0070801973,
0.0293961335,
-0.0358904898,
0.0100183394,
-0.0256500915,
0.0176641885,
-0.0144023988,
-0.0002683357,
0.0309278388,
-0.0350263342,
0.0615834184,
-0.0099108089,
-0.0177396201,
-0.0477123931,
-0.0637767389,
-0.1446958333,
-0.0158966742,
0.0040048263,
0.0135818254,
0.0249359105,
0.0110906651,
-0.0301201306,
0.005510191,
-0.0109874159,
0.0001691173,
0.0072270092,
-0.0201443713,
-0.0519821048,
-0.0150158526,
0.0049002157,
-0.0501392819,
0.0275624171,
-0.0179338977,
-0.017870333,
-0.0224229135,
-0.013905786,
-0.0435407124,
0.0326206237,
-0.0078038601,
0.0182642769,
-0.0247100666,
-0.0338483937,
0.0072692707,
-0.0084733842,
0.0319665447,
0.046294,
0.0294534005,
0.0639623031,
0.0198831204,
0.0007761566,
-0.0644850805,
0.0215758849,
0.043544922,
0.0362784825,
-0.0272647832,
-0.0418645255,
-0.0095398519,
0.0073083574,
0.0451809317,
0.0431557447,
-0.0009631368,
-0.0337158069,
0.02092788,
-0.0641816705,
0.000313215,
-0.0180152487,
-0.0212218724,
-0.016427787,
0.0697040558,
-0.0448072851,
-0.0250121988,
-0.0399439707,
-0.0480878428,
-0.0902038291,
-0.0289429463,
-0.0116540529,
0.0493601635,
-0.0735043809,
-0.0102120657,
-0.014659185,
-0.023888262,
0.00753114,
-0.0613745227,
-0.0340557508,
-0.0783088282,
0.0581793971,
-0.0157550909,
-0.0178184323,
-0.0048561706,
-0.0202448554,
-0.0078081898,
-0.0389592126,
-0.0629638508,
0.0188152306,
0.0063297562,
-0.058076296,
-0.0117575293,
0.0014751506,
0.0375887863,
-0.0174656417,
0.0136693856,
0.0035287752,
0.0169676375,
0.0707398802,
-0.0000632188,
0.0451234877,
-0.0084745092,
0.0299996063,
0.0132990396,
0.031872008,
0.0522486754,
0.0003367807,
-0.040428184,
-0.0236919932,
0.0093861055,
0.022962518,
-0.007211443,
-0.0159938447,
0.027471073,
-0.0231893677,
0.077592738,
0.0883048624,
0.0465600118,
-0.028577663,
-0.0134938527,
-0.0280362777,
-0.0143994382,
-0.0124804005,
0.0068642441,
-0.0372008197,
-0.0467150621,
0.0378017761,
0.0430302583,
-0.0275097582,
0.0241233408,
0.0151287131,
-0.0119035235,
0.0444474407,
0.0062075276,
-0.0158666074,
-0.0390893333,
-0.034442354,
0.0276674796,
-0.0216901414,
0.0140193561,
-0.0688791424,
-0.0236887969,
-0.0342984088,
0.051112432,
-0.0277166571,
-0.0496039316,
0.0071888966,
0.0300117303,
0.1037161648,
0.0058710901,
0.0857196152,
-0.0504913665,
-0.0338578783,
0.0132463565,
0.0445289798,
0.0123188877,
-0.0287282225,
0.0368142873,
0.005820075,
0.0107964408,
-0.0113566555,
0.0204755701,
-0.0024737024,
0.0060532223,
0.015694933,
0.073155567,
-0.0119372616,
-0.0296392143,
-0.0296695922,
0.0167995449,
0.0538734682,
0.0417605303,
-0.012253331,
-0.0336404741,
0.0046917018,
-0.0135356216,
0.0423072614,
0.0238654781,
-0.0677727908,
0.007509083,
-0.0199018773,
-0.0010382768,
-0.0499836355,
-0.0188957192,
0.0028682773,
0.034961205,
-0.0146033168,
-0.0340068713,
-0.0118081225,
0.0474181771,
-0.0433673486,
0.0383813456,
0.0153136272,
0.0303882621,
-0.0363630317,
0.0059366208,
0.0372099802,
-0.061084874,
0.005415766,
-0.0075671659,
-0.011987132,
-0.0326398388,
0.0356150456,
-0.0182573441,
0.014504631,
-0.0090546757,
0.0224977024,
-0.0041374634,
0.0579597205,
0.0492443256,
-0.0359828025,
-0.0010691436,
0.0957446992,
0.021869719,
-0.0303656366,
-0.0059322943,
-0.0023721997,
0.0428578332,
-0.0063297106,
0.0123038599,
0.0059815804,
-0.050603129,
-0.0172088239,
0.0597527064,
0.0154322544,
-0.0018887593,
-0.0635156408,
-0.0078672674,
0.0095815081,
0.0000171725,
0.0341744721,
-0.0489652865,
-0.0020058881,
0.000541613,
0.0465624817,
-0.0405976065,
-0.0066757137,
-0.0313838795,
-0.0534799062,
0.0157866366,
0.1193791255,
0.0517693684,
0.0383051299,
0.0154889822,
0.0332176089,
-0.0217717942,
-0.0116369706,
0.0483718328,
0.0018130159,
-0.0232870262,
0.0410504937,
-0.0381002836,
-0.0611563437,
-0.0275898762,
0.0350959823,
-0.0199153926,
0.033367537,
-0.0600036643,
0.04176981,
-0.0278581157,
-0.029392587,
0.0552024804,
-0.0259979647,
0.0436923914,
-0.0045750937,
-0.0015150135,
-0.049156934,
0.0162730534,
0.0265690871,
-0.0240748711,
-0.0148078138,
0.0269076489,
-0.0037495238,
-0.0701008961,
0.0242040828,
-0.0032949978,
-0.0129020363,
-0.0386609398,
-0.0074185524,
0.0833462849,
-0.0381392576,
-0.020269841,
-0.0056738677,
-0.0340942927,
-0.0467962027,
0.0503455736,
-0.0621413328,
0.0063676215,
-0.0595075712,
-0.0152466185,
0.0225312617,
-0.0270302016,
0.0473616011,
-0.0127893286,
0.0118153561,
-0.0294506364,
-0.0084387446,
-0.0364086218,
-5.55169525e-33,
0.0195900034,
0.0049789236,
-0.0490624905,
0.0016506524,
-0.0567727089,
0.0286374129,
0.019665705,
0.0215213038,
0.0360018164,
0.0201224852,
-0.0360765085,
-0.0034796484,
0.0193808414,
0.0126688713,
-0.0096528456,
-0.0125541091,
0.0360608362,
-0.0344883911,
-0.0158445593,
-0.0093933363,
0.0387146659,
0.0039003806,
0.0426820107,
-0.1402449906,
-0.0164002534,
0.0493140183,
-0.0513011739,
-0.0336809978,
0.0604357794,
0.0368601121,
0.0076302816,
0.0704528242,
-0.0012150171,
0.0279162042,
0.0100321621,
0.0215775017,
-0.0385094061,
0.0426569059,
-0.0000173873,
0.0205614772,
0.0011639521,
-0.0053833183,
0.0087769125,
0.0183704253,
-0.0195836555,
-0.0422624014,
0.0088615939,
-0.0477110744,
0.0151727907,
-0.0683285147,
-0.0814619064,
0.036919646,
-0.010284191,
-0.030461425,
0.0736038834,
0.0525950491,
-0.0155066187,
-0.0318297073,
-0.019698495,
0.0077423835,
0.0393116437,
0.0011409951,
0.0060617737,
0.0183742754,
-0.0442175493,
0.0210216381,
0.0304611158,
-0.0722227693,
0.0057143718,
0.0203026645,
0.0443502069,
0.0395970233,
0.0321611091,
0.0725334734,
0.0059803571,
-0.0251434799,
0.0219387859,
0.0131326634,
0.0400635079,
-0.0474666171,
0.0365282521,
0.0430475064,
-0.0514512062,
0.0361914597,
-0.0537596121,
-0.0118835792,
-0.0018589495,
-0.0162889957,
0.035271313,
-0.0066857468,
0.0142780086,
-0.0021507281,
0.0237777792,
0.0040070065,
0.017729383,
0.005936827,
-0.0075677196,
0.0767860338,
-0.0185627304,
-0.0077798348,
-0.0216019563,
-0.0120631233,
0.1036513299,
0.0293982159,
0.0500770174,
-0.0502487421,
-0.0400805064,
0.0706921071,
-0.0616362169,
-0.025597157,
0.0295990165,
0.0226941518,
-0.0012260546,
0.026031673,
-0.0282662772,
-0.0106116952,
-0.0021947175,
-0.0324155167,
-0.0123053752,
0.0661547557,
-0.0127303964,
-0.010450013,
-0.0099038891,
0.0188031457,
-0.0699060261,
0.0190388169,
0.0055431393,
-0.0629386082,
0.0257616267,
-0.0122705363,
0.0050164121,
-0.006037679,
2.737e-7,
-0.0177503098,
0.0345258713,
0.0147999534,
-0.1176664233,
0.0109511111,
0.055218406,
-0.0089639919,
0.0161087085,
0.0741345435,
0.0400715172,
0.067910105,
-0.0465233289,
0.0600675158,
0.0601552911,
-0.0362297222,
-0.0470752493,
0.0018837143,
0.0038231388,
0.0239697304,
0.0443225689,
0.0777346492,
0.083698675,
-0.0025964042,
-0.0190506373,
0.007255055,
0.0158963427,
0.0115897981,
-0.0498384982,
0.0011027409,
-0.0001735956,
-0.022207424,
-0.0739773959,
-0.018138146,
0.0065325131,
-0.0049349223,
0.0048764069,
0.0341822617,
0.0260291323,
-0.0092998417,
-0.045936048,
-0.0337141752,
0.0405460857,
-0.0203950554,
0.0205540601,
0.0216621533,
-0.0151844565,
0.0015243076,
-0.0785843581,
-0.0462093353,
0.0506618097,
-0.007814697,
-0.0259542279,
-0.0143480087,
0.0444054641,
-0.0092338473,
-0.0080745397,
-0.0469354354,
-0.0388075858,
0.0029965003,
-0.0054761064,
-0.0468881987,
-0.030808324,
-0.0266933143,
0.0268690363,
0.025090009,
-0.0782772526,
-0.0079773096,
1.99263856e-34,
-0.0040353378,
-0.0117659122,
-0.011597462,
-0.0047060223,
0.031169286,
-0.0056037982,
-0.0271937046,
-0.0012196499,
0.0264220536,
-0.0691725388,
-0.0058379755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11558v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11558v1 | Advancing Visual Grounding with Scene Knowledge: Benchmark and Method | 2023-07-21T13:06:02 | 2023-07-21T13:06:02 | Zhihong Chen, Ruifei Zhang, Yibing Song, Xiang Wan, Guanbin Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Visual grounding (VG) aims to establish fine-grained alignment between vision
and language. Ideally, it can be a testbed for vision-and-language models to
evaluate their understanding of the images and texts and their reasoning
abilities over their joint space. However, most existing VG datasets are
constructed using simple description texts, which do not require sufficient
reasoning over the images and texts. This has been demonstrated in a recent
study~\cite{luo2022goes}, where a simple LSTM-based text encoder without
pretraining can achieve state-of-the-art performance on mainstream VG datasets.
Therefore, in this paper, we propose a novel benchmark of \underline{S}cene
\underline{K}nowledge-guided \underline{V}isual \underline{G}rounding (SK-VG),
where the image content and referring expressions are not sufficient to ground
the target objects, forcing the models to have a reasoning ability on the
long-form scene knowledge. To perform this task, we propose two approaches to
accept the triple-type input, where the former embeds knowledge into the image
features before the image-query interaction; the latter leverages linguistic
structure to assist in computing the image-text matching. We conduct extensive
experiments to analyze the above methods and show that the proposed approaches
achieve promising results but still leave room for improvement, including
performance and interpretability. The dataset and code are available at
\url{https://github.com/zhjohnchan/SK-VG}. | [
0.0243362114,
0.0212041121,
0.0388088711,
0.0737445652,
-0.0243269484,
0.0072411988,
-0.0112390472,
0.0153834168,
-0.0198594164,
-0.0736668557,
-0.0418385305,
0.0071509383,
0.0382201448,
0.0433826819,
0.0194878299,
-0.0418373123,
0.0045875302,
-0.0143659441,
-0.0459178835,
0.0088849217,
0.0575103797,
0.0179363657,
0.0125791011,
0.0189437084,
-0.0404078774,
-0.0073544616,
-0.0047477516,
0.0311373509,
0.0149231842,
-0.0099775149,
-0.0409204178,
0.0103824884,
0.0802066326,
0.0210651308,
0.0000019971,
-0.0024377985,
0.0073275329,
-0.0081465524,
-0.011153318,
-0.0182434749,
0.0122276293,
-0.0886024162,
0.0129171582,
-0.0201315451,
-0.0332899578,
0.0011638065,
0.0667997599,
0.0903785005,
0.0507907309,
0.0354680754,
-0.033199396,
-0.033204224,
0.018167207,
-0.0281160641,
0.0426692218,
-0.0186568126,
0.014189438,
0.0498153381,
-0.0172489155,
0.0001455824,
-0.0364994369,
0.028301537,
0.0304586161,
-0.0321519971,
0.0062522949,
0.0476173759,
-0.0491194837,
0.0116098747,
-0.0077975844,
0.1015948802,
-0.0209356211,
-0.0350689217,
-0.0402566642,
0.0010933736,
-0.0273224004,
-0.0176679771,
-0.0232985187,
0.0427345,
-0.0111374017,
0.0479780957,
-0.0426009893,
0.0254120771,
-0.0022943974,
0.0113454973,
-0.0089378962,
0.0468580462,
0.0156488456,
0.0098187784,
0.0028016057,
0.0413531698,
-0.0572953746,
-0.0687516481,
-0.005963326,
0.0211767312,
0.0436194614,
-0.0146549353,
-0.0449030027,
-0.0095314365,
-0.0334367305,
-0.0397473574,
0.0085863518,
0.0466946065,
-0.0783325508,
0.0723286793,
-0.0442165099,
0.0719410628,
-0.0211558565,
0.0478947721,
-0.0186416935,
-0.0057022651,
-0.0070530535,
-0.0109944204,
-0.0558113493,
-0.01146321,
-0.0648427308,
-0.036899548,
0.0128231039,
-0.0132690463,
-0.0038742786,
0.0211504772,
-0.0049844375,
0.0247987229,
-0.0365898088,
-0.0028366779,
-0.0260097757,
0.0329430476,
-0.0101584857,
0.020943163,
-0.0388603993,
-0.0372240618,
-0.0004788217,
0.0569572896,
0.034601748,
-0.0342334956,
0.0144256996,
0.0433421023,
-0.0477496125,
-0.0059367134,
-0.047727026,
-0.0408907346,
-0.0137236482,
-0.0477695912,
0.0071752374,
-0.0490522459,
0.0069585294,
-0.0022634184,
-0.02009991,
-0.0485314913,
0.0153298089,
0.0225552153,
-0.0311241616,
0.1310348064,
-0.0093093421,
-0.0443740934,
-0.0065742438,
0.0232639946,
0.0183446649,
0.0586764999,
0.0391673334,
0.0700703785,
0.0053281048,
0.0303780213,
0.0143202748,
0.0245050527,
0.0206889603,
0.0116289156,
-0.0750579163,
-0.0082372818,
0.0000082693,
0.0146024246,
0.0477086529,
0.0518580191,
-0.0133867553,
-0.0361168534,
0.074820064,
0.0450623333,
-0.0378570706,
0.0160491727,
0.0419200696,
0.0067770146,
-0.0079250187,
0.0045577134,
-0.076537922,
0.0554102175,
-0.0043225153,
0.0195797589,
-0.0432232097,
-0.0066705756,
-0.0485479385,
-0.035910897,
-0.0149029512,
-0.0145835895,
0.0396031477,
-0.0122095104,
0.0571531393,
0.0312248766,
-0.0556815453,
0.043671634,
-0.003588092,
-0.0253356062,
-0.0017194025,
-0.0032561347,
0.0373691767,
0.043883346,
0.0440316759,
0.0062553147,
-0.0006812682,
0.0155849354,
0.0557509363,
0.0784375742,
-0.040763177,
0.0250051506,
0.015843017,
-0.0642191917,
-0.0652864799,
-0.0288776383,
-0.0190948155,
0.0294822063,
-0.00353365,
0.0241688024,
0.0228475202,
-0.0699521974,
0.0183757544,
0.0535955168,
0.0572909154,
0.0076339203,
-0.0539294221,
0.0406558737,
-0.0415577777,
-0.0170174409,
-0.025477834,
-0.0105199628,
0.0119893625,
-0.0415437892,
-0.0058392868,
0.0190191995,
-0.0414307863,
-0.0552517846,
0.0223355796,
-0.0692001656,
-0.0110576749,
-0.0064679934,
-0.0391625576,
-0.0179519188,
0.0128668593,
0.0150820659,
0.0277401637,
-0.0462740958,
-0.0090249227,
0.0151405428,
0.012601437,
-0.0242441781,
0.0515002571,
-0.0065266066,
-0.0364853814,
-0.0229340009,
0.0045511574,
0.0396546796,
-0.0379219465,
-0.0198004022,
-0.0187798422,
0.015427039,
0.0136205545,
0.0102000013,
0.0386800654,
-0.0209920425,
0.0025148001,
-0.0841831714,
-0.0476848073,
-0.0321019962,
-0.023626104,
-0.000035428,
-0.0152171655,
0.0212386809,
-0.0494125485,
-0.0447368659,
0.0249676462,
-0.0000138519,
-0.0196779203,
0.0675030723,
0.0293351524,
0.0040958789,
-0.0267205238,
0.019572163,
0.0178689361,
0.0602564514,
0.0272296239,
-0.0512631945,
-0.042405732,
0.0578176118,
-0.0408486985,
0.0441793874,
-0.0274792966,
-0.0291954037,
-0.000340647,
-0.0070103137,
0.0110451197,
0.0616763793,
-0.0063841906,
-0.0186251607,
0.0059952834,
0.0255893879,
-0.039929118,
-0.019809518,
0.0195154008,
-0.0389102995,
0.0128633482,
0.0291434545,
-0.0398265235,
0.0189142842,
-0.0135659166,
0.0269958377,
-0.0795793459,
0.0031165292,
0.0196321905,
0.0078690778,
-0.083158344,
0.0177724417,
0.0374707021,
0.0492029972,
-0.0905102789,
-0.0631980449,
0.0540379174,
-0.061782226,
-0.0346775278,
0.0137668392,
0.0085778963,
-0.0309993606,
0.0793962553,
0.0270273909,
0.0286645405,
-0.0085140383,
0.0021835731,
-0.0453146733,
-0.0535750203,
-0.0065127765,
0.0268745087,
0.1114056408,
-0.0385978557,
0.0607478917,
-0.0315656401,
-0.0402015448,
-0.0243800282,
-0.0180563107,
-0.0406054594,
-0.0051224912,
-0.0711877346,
-0.0135705341,
-0.0271762852,
0.0571058318,
0.0079682423,
0.0580335259,
-0.0093961889,
-0.008856182,
-0.0276797786,
0.0197097249,
0.0614581667,
0.0019292739,
-0.0369172208,
0.0043388121,
0.0166052356,
0.066700615,
0.0283834878,
0.0030630985,
-0.0452487879,
0.0414164364,
0.005726025,
0.0456774645,
0.0273220725,
0.0043528886,
0.0309267826,
-0.0627893135,
-0.0293507986,
0.0705097616,
0.0084705055,
-0.0458799489,
-0.0177695807,
-0.0239771698,
0.0168782715,
0.0444967076,
-0.0063890861,
-0.0811771378,
-0.0601289496,
-0.0162503012,
-0.0156891979,
0.0638483986,
-0.0140492897,
-0.0373725593,
-0.0667108968,
0.0243905503,
0.0171183534,
-0.0033465482,
-0.0749361962,
0.0254442636,
0.0015217813,
-0.0178662818,
0.0066983821,
-0.0288413223,
0.0036422985,
-0.003394007,
-0.0141796535,
0.0249334369,
-0.011535936,
0.0206039492,
-0.0808444545,
-0.0225677788,
0.046346426,
0.0185388755,
-0.0002154581,
-0.0656640306,
0.000655687,
0.0187984537,
0.0165722501,
-0.0088785347,
0.0403228179,
-0.0505682789,
-0.027027607,
0.0546818934,
0.0192008708,
-0.0515331663,
-0.0063451598,
-0.0360350162,
0.0258496813,
-0.0300418027,
0.020043835,
-0.0102707539,
0.0221266225,
0.0186901931,
0.0663967803,
0.0476783216,
-0.0061894604,
-0.025442116,
-0.0345539562,
0.0010345432,
-0.0318289176,
-0.0406433865,
0.0071594585,
0.0010228829,
0.013908824,
-0.0595881864,
-0.0064285356,
0.040005587,
0.0623427816,
-0.0098961396,
-0.0318736173,
0.0085395863,
-0.0058651883,
-0.0799689442,
0.069461152,
-0.0454081185,
0.0357763097,
-0.0203415938,
0.0320288762,
0.0431843139,
-0.048324313,
-0.0348589383,
-0.006675214,
-0.0582022741,
-0.0290028863,
-0.0266543794,
0.0315039195,
0.0176038835,
0.0508944392,
0.0057775243,
0.0086394893,
0.0198573843,
0.0199723877,
0.0235110223,
0.0295670126,
-0.0111344801,
-0.0213893894,
0.0030383416,
0.0327372253,
-0.0375101306,
0.0360951498,
0.0355842225,
-0.0050074733,
-0.0222224146,
-0.0097047593,
0.0081588244,
-0.0017339186,
0.0520929359,
0.0058941334,
0.0441279747,
-0.027770184,
0.000795204,
0.009409056,
-0.0156738497,
-0.0876521915,
-0.0058721611,
-0.020213861,
0.0023016878,
-0.0106647452,
-0.0000738241,
-0.0058323578,
0.0536442697,
-0.0089785941,
-0.0256027225,
-0.0056142593,
0.0098105483,
-0.0072084996,
0.0116359806,
-0.0048468313,
0.0059940149,
-0.0234600771,
0.0424364358,
-0.0235975534,
0.0371073708,
0.0595805123,
-0.0128790215,
-0.0498360172,
0.0562061518,
-0.0007645427,
-0.027889289,
-0.0436699502,
-0.0007645561,
0.0583952256,
-0.0167605933,
-0.0233164355,
-0.0218819957,
-0.0070193526,
0.0145871108,
0.0485918447,
0.0117810257,
-0.0505172648,
0.0697240084,
0.0122346785,
-0.0176406913,
0.0098115243,
0.039609082,
0.0198829006,
0.0535843112,
0.0166587327,
-0.0264026728,
-0.0194331966,
-0.0128140952,
-0.0089891991,
-0.0111900959,
0.0227948446,
0.0366340615,
-0.0123570887,
-0.0751894563,
0.0027810514,
0.0287112836,
-0.0251796246,
0.0381664746,
0.0679480657,
0.0326893404,
0.0449432507,
0.0042292583,
0.0375357904,
-0.0353802741,
-0.015856903,
-0.0160119869,
-0.0418777429,
-5.695702491e-33,
-0.0410018452,
-0.0426095128,
0.0334117226,
-0.0127282348,
-0.0277020074,
0.0361655727,
-0.0274781343,
-0.0123182423,
-0.0315457545,
0.0280674882,
0.0163862258,
0.0194250122,
0.0140833603,
0.030246472,
-0.0277116783,
-0.0198744722,
0.0260601453,
-0.0172988921,
-0.0239124093,
-0.0162641257,
0.0167193785,
0.0062630586,
0.0746161565,
-0.0630154461,
-0.0310324691,
0.0233562253,
-0.0273683295,
0.0292891189,
0.0184910148,
0.0592172854,
-0.010575505,
0.0230948925,
0.002703316,
0.0000955135,
-0.0159098562,
0.0250262599,
-0.0718341544,
-0.0134091973,
0.0257155299,
0.0499270782,
-0.0283889193,
0.026158629,
0.0444494672,
-0.0420259163,
-0.0014359613,
-0.0122759296,
0.0369943306,
-0.0204768516,
0.0223909952,
0.0184082333,
-0.0431096256,
-0.0058956775,
0.0027368797,
-0.0361648649,
0.0561357327,
-0.0229330007,
0.0379665978,
0.0322131962,
-0.0781441256,
0.0000650241,
-0.0497902036,
0.0225998126,
0.0738702342,
0.030582333,
-0.0001482462,
0.0733157098,
-0.020322945,
-0.0367886126,
-0.0764660239,
-0.0309484527,
0.0358913094,
0.0316590145,
0.0543503501,
0.0410737582,
0.0383461155,
0.0231457446,
-0.0619773604,
0.0191640295,
-0.0378641859,
0.0657856911,
-0.0266330671,
0.0234479494,
-0.0231861789,
-0.0332542807,
-0.039555341,
-0.0188879911,
-0.0481578559,
-0.0053666215,
0.0438600741,
0.0290699303,
-0.0007339374,
0.0416360646,
0.0454493091,
-0.0161382128,
0.0245309826,
0.0467639863,
-0.00236435,
0.0379341468,
0.023407435,
0.0169925429,
-0.0546306968,
-0.0165160708,
0.0625660568,
0.0066919993,
0.0029726904,
0.0142652169,
0.0668434724,
0.0205748677,
-0.0290028695,
-0.0094290478,
-0.0363387316,
-0.0015674137,
-0.0070874682,
0.0173178911,
0.02743949,
0.0274907909,
-0.0362425596,
0.0242602024,
-0.0164569672,
-0.0380930379,
-0.0016163604,
-0.0457536466,
0.0176817831,
0.0412389636,
-0.0143819582,
0.0039429208,
-0.025002392,
-0.0537792221,
0.048678156,
-0.046605356,
-0.0124207307,
0.0399248339,
2.607e-7,
0.0325463712,
-0.0012093084,
0.0658948198,
0.0167455617,
-0.0058258083,
0.0546760671,
-0.0046919822,
0.0111785885,
-0.0335173011,
-0.0617462471,
0.008108018,
0.0591430441,
0.036556825,
-0.0358246788,
-0.015320342,
0.0593200289,
-0.0403527394,
-0.0351562575,
-0.0457858332,
-0.0247681495,
0.0272389352,
0.0753518045,
-0.017062258,
-0.0110569466,
0.033758454,
-0.0847757533,
0.0821909159,
-0.0209444743,
0.0347064435,
-0.0214679148,
0.0050927005,
-0.0007450616,
-0.0271666665,
0.0526573136,
0.0286233332,
-0.006237519,
0.0548024513,
0.0025906009,
-0.0654259697,
-0.0005219239,
-0.0592511445,
0.0087564075,
-0.0194761623,
-0.0513167568,
0.0587482899,
-0.0286859237,
-0.0101956846,
-0.0157011803,
-0.0008634931,
-0.0040805936,
0.0006452899,
-0.0009654071,
-0.0555870049,
-0.0010178776,
0.0759487227,
-0.0109625356,
-0.0342241339,
-0.0919998363,
-0.0172187742,
-0.0031156014,
-0.016749911,
0.0010584301,
-0.0601964779,
-0.0069175819,
0.0396080613,
-0.0405486114,
-0.0611728393,
2.409775358e-34,
0.0193371847,
-0.0049258382,
-0.0052081859,
0.0069318591,
0.0399241634,
0.0007109623,
0.0071895341,
-0.0311585609,
-0.0215996429,
-0.0368432701,
-0.0181299262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11545v1 | Bridging Vision and Language Encoders: Parameter-Efficient Tuning for Referring Image Segmentation | 2023-07-21T12:46:15 | 2023-07-21T12:46:15 | Zunnan Xu, Zhihong Chen, Yong Zhang, Yibing Song, Xiang Wan, Guanbin Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Parameter Efficient Tuning (PET) has gained attention for reducing the number
of parameters while maintaining performance and providing better hardware
resource savings, but few studies investigate dense prediction tasks and
interaction between modalities. In this paper, we do an investigation of
efficient tuning problems on referring image segmentation. We propose a novel
adapter called Bridger to facilitate cross-modal information exchange and
inject task-specific information into the pre-trained model. We also design a
lightweight decoder for image segmentation. Our approach achieves comparable or
superior performance with only 1.61\% to 3.38\% backbone parameter updates,
evaluated on challenging benchmarks. The code is available at
\url{https://github.com/kkakkkka/ETRIS}. | [
-0.0090750838,
0.045111239,
0.0228777677,
0.0490994416,
0.0036230136,
-0.0096200602,
-0.0119864456,
0.0112595875,
-0.0686815158,
-0.0372552648,
-0.0551292636,
0.0364664458,
0.0400120318,
0.0478245318,
0.0067787319,
-0.123095341,
0.0121984854,
-0.0368110314,
0.0029411404,
-0.0056011504,
0.0079728486,
-0.0092743468,
-0.0121315261,
0.0260682888,
-0.0022808283,
0.016320562,
-0.0212774891,
0.0433657207,
0.0193206128,
-0.012455008,
0.0054955021,
0.0454818048,
0.0276766252,
-0.0247215666,
0.0000021389,
0.0087856026,
-0.0289255306,
-0.0031423608,
-0.0098688286,
-0.0156698953,
0.0354451686,
-0.0361494943,
-0.0259231701,
-0.0012245676,
0.0126864994,
-0.0429953858,
0.101630114,
0.081687592,
0.0613144562,
0.0683256164,
-0.0265225284,
0.0080069238,
0.0221783556,
-0.0260746442,
0.0142498985,
-0.0296814963,
0.0159031246,
0.0006386822,
-0.081652984,
-0.0073153647,
-0.0692627579,
0.0304281898,
0.0310696587,
-0.0004378585,
-0.0012222215,
0.0163094178,
-0.0204890613,
-0.0406945273,
-0.0299397539,
0.0489632003,
-0.0836171508,
-0.0005657348,
-0.0175742935,
0.0088610435,
-0.0253547132,
-0.0187971853,
-0.0258002859,
-0.0129946489,
-0.0056054848,
0.0243633892,
-0.0289227795,
0.0150769986,
-0.0035208738,
-0.0110235754,
0.0110060181,
-0.0048479079,
0.0383799784,
0.0314547047,
0.0107886214,
0.0384222008,
-0.0321138576,
-0.0689189434,
0.0256312564,
-0.0081853652,
-0.0058933673,
-0.0151194232,
-0.060226351,
0.0026498761,
-0.0467330515,
-0.0248741861,
0.026549533,
0.0327324606,
-0.018096393,
0.0451109596,
-0.0239810385,
0.0264906529,
-0.023862239,
0.0768424347,
-0.0448863767,
-0.0359994955,
-0.0042833076,
0.0122262547,
-0.0950118974,
-0.0380425304,
-0.0287659392,
-0.0157836284,
-0.0106130075,
0.0064042085,
0.0015028879,
-0.0175398644,
0.0537534058,
0.0114085246,
-0.070334807,
-0.0269084908,
-0.0111698443,
0.0484586246,
-0.0309678223,
0.0062684282,
-0.0077334265,
-0.0475254394,
-0.0143537242,
0.0291207936,
-0.0005163805,
-0.0347203836,
-0.0092455838,
0.0422020145,
-0.0762300342,
-0.0215064343,
-0.0131544182,
-0.0340071879,
0.0067637558,
-0.0567544326,
0.0459382609,
-0.0311957728,
0.0178917032,
0.0146801537,
0.019046979,
-0.0423153006,
-0.0182454269,
0.0045704241,
-0.0127293589,
0.0709627494,
0.0024713795,
-0.0234196931,
0.0150119606,
0.0255966969,
0.0231417883,
0.1218708977,
0.0509301983,
0.0375591703,
0.0141135016,
0.0218010377,
-0.0277185682,
0.0350140817,
-0.0018278542,
0.010580413,
-0.0415196009,
-0.0232214518,
0.0704743415,
-0.0125329513,
0.0641506985,
0.0179287288,
-0.0403883047,
-0.0374621376,
0.0398783349,
-0.0183774661,
0.0286464486,
0.0388601758,
0.0197040662,
0.0003598346,
-0.009054089,
-0.0113094356,
-0.0417345688,
0.0354240872,
0.0121986773,
-0.0070582414,
-0.0055547105,
0.0452097394,
-0.0404298753,
-0.0296474062,
0.0216526315,
-0.0175225772,
0.0158536602,
-0.0048594014,
0.0639189482,
0.0237271283,
-0.0520766042,
0.0785522908,
0.000659143,
-0.0489114076,
-0.0060895756,
-0.0225936621,
-0.0297027938,
0.0329531953,
0.0152341491,
0.0143413628,
-0.0041770255,
0.0225678105,
0.0646571219,
0.0136332819,
0.0193120427,
0.0001623279,
0.0520551242,
-0.0743944049,
-0.0668768883,
-0.0182288792,
-0.0163606051,
0.0360389277,
0.0131224822,
0.0109199109,
0.0292917006,
-0.06931521,
0.0516331904,
0.0161050968,
0.0380236693,
0.0196763854,
-0.0317570381,
0.0165147595,
-0.0181820281,
-0.0372637883,
-0.0139629934,
-0.0265454371,
0.0178964455,
-0.0260961186,
0.0812030509,
0.0501489453,
-0.0735568926,
-0.0299028493,
-0.0107916528,
-0.0635757148,
0.0214823876,
-0.0105651943,
-0.041604504,
-0.0420149826,
0.0270769969,
-0.0139981294,
0.0358989052,
-0.0042897691,
0.006725159,
-0.0071288366,
0.0178453028,
0.0183720607,
0.0278256498,
-0.0107231559,
-0.0320106074,
0.0206714086,
0.0164781194,
-0.0059347744,
-0.0288106874,
-0.010764733,
0.0195196271,
0.0311783664,
-0.0179050975,
0.0152586317,
0.0085006952,
-0.001060026,
-0.0237222798,
-0.074319452,
-0.0190992672,
-0.0460303687,
-0.0196278766,
0.0161308479,
0.031341292,
0.014624998,
-0.0413564555,
-0.0124148205,
0.0597530566,
-0.0164537374,
0.0077791302,
-0.0189937353,
0.0120172258,
-0.0178925451,
-0.0087659732,
-0.0117634255,
0.0552424751,
0.0216384828,
-0.0006840564,
-0.0608717315,
-0.0774062648,
0.0118508777,
0.0173080433,
0.0503740869,
-0.0196353011,
-0.0229227673,
-0.0281057358,
-0.0050441627,
0.0319665223,
0.081625104,
-0.0108279036,
0.0253573377,
0.0135267042,
-0.0129413996,
-0.0095379138,
-0.0061173113,
-0.0033826479,
-0.0398721248,
-0.0332953408,
-0.009251792,
-0.0361341126,
0.0792387053,
-0.0397728793,
0.0395710692,
-0.0570197441,
-0.0239459872,
0.0056716576,
-0.0538736358,
-0.0333597809,
0.0199525207,
0.0181868095,
0.0316267647,
-0.0491218381,
-0.0531935282,
0.0489842519,
-0.0468861572,
-0.0463950075,
-0.0021964533,
0.0099707069,
-0.0005573052,
0.0142482026,
0.064195618,
0.0140320268,
0.0129497964,
-0.0170061029,
-0.062941052,
-0.0067833201,
0.0328784548,
0.012631177,
0.0390188508,
-0.0240660831,
0.0055723856,
-0.043382749,
-0.0283363946,
-0.0093967877,
0.0635041222,
-0.0282297786,
0.0337068513,
-0.0161737371,
-0.0142088896,
-0.0133472905,
0.052694533,
0.0095883459,
0.0413353853,
-0.0198522974,
0.0053517972,
-0.0333279334,
0.0251360592,
0.0404111706,
0.0262223762,
-0.0587875545,
-0.0214871261,
0.0084566539,
0.062467631,
0.0575584285,
-0.028367348,
-0.0674171597,
0.048554454,
0.0273063984,
0.0199156068,
-0.0098488024,
0.0184490401,
0.0790856183,
-0.064535588,
-0.0461345874,
0.0531662889,
0.0059708785,
-0.053724803,
-0.0451818518,
0.0069021233,
0.0497360639,
0.0397688448,
-0.0005821033,
-0.0267067626,
-0.0663931444,
-0.0021397544,
0.0044876277,
0.0347878002,
-0.0001856736,
-0.0184649192,
-0.0572513416,
0.0381794907,
0.0097221918,
0.0352790132,
-0.0369791277,
-0.0409294292,
0.0250126533,
-0.0279663894,
-0.0063162684,
-0.0083333813,
-0.0101511246,
-0.0165875293,
0.0239690244,
0.0346228406,
0.0105803199,
-0.015757313,
-0.030950034,
-0.03653704,
0.0290676225,
-0.0034486935,
0.0036863682,
-0.0408664979,
0.0420875549,
-0.0519171432,
-0.0082422709,
-0.0196682177,
0.054720033,
-0.0282234494,
0.002951331,
0.0386263467,
0.0114578111,
-0.0193300787,
-0.0151685514,
-0.0190021284,
0.052601587,
-0.0128966169,
0.0374850631,
-0.0011168445,
-0.006530365,
-0.0005296791,
0.034528695,
0.0020207476,
-0.0061569135,
-0.0144031337,
-0.0239663236,
0.0100678401,
-0.0407799743,
0.0017032286,
-0.0319966003,
-0.0512136407,
-0.0613875911,
-0.0435878858,
0.0194156542,
0.0561198816,
0.0389823318,
-0.0217568055,
-0.0261036716,
0.0023846875,
0.0173234269,
-0.0810479671,
0.0296478216,
-0.0332734175,
-0.0107097179,
-0.0629371628,
-0.0267336797,
0.051711455,
-0.0112408167,
-0.0107082427,
0.0381551944,
-0.0607224926,
-0.0238064751,
-0.0062124506,
0.0495518148,
0.0100696944,
0.0955907181,
-0.0209590979,
-0.0212547053,
0.0109622451,
-0.0179826673,
0.0297307782,
0.0410299301,
0.0372897573,
-0.0027938762,
-0.0154553279,
0.0191412438,
-0.0652753264,
-0.0120868757,
0.0108361905,
-0.0299198106,
-0.0431843176,
-0.0829555914,
-0.0069670081,
-0.0127159161,
0.0678989366,
-0.0028636288,
0.0322492458,
-0.0325017907,
0.0419344455,
-0.0048136027,
0.0191424526,
-0.0774479583,
0.0150711294,
-0.0124637233,
0.0209680405,
0.025266828,
0.0491607077,
0.0278194714,
0.0097444188,
-0.0109611591,
0.0407745428,
0.0149356397,
0.0274094325,
-0.0044446494,
0.0152880559,
0.0306985304,
-0.0026215443,
0.0426983573,
0.0479147546,
-0.0445141904,
0.0579800569,
0.0258710701,
-0.0023948988,
-0.0603787638,
0.0686149746,
0.0136180054,
-0.0376593135,
-0.0939125642,
0.0622690618,
0.0019103645,
0.0065924735,
0.0310067758,
0.0054435479,
-0.0165922996,
-0.0160253812,
0.055394236,
0.0188016742,
-0.038798783,
0.0768805742,
-0.0011700068,
0.0099917408,
0.0123064471,
0.0439094491,
0.0034209874,
0.0403542928,
-0.0047898036,
-0.0074399738,
-0.0218582246,
0.0044258474,
-0.0144501133,
-0.0317342579,
-0.0048488309,
0.0170357358,
0.0443092547,
-0.035867162,
0.0049833697,
-0.0311385505,
0.0292838681,
0.0235015061,
0.0666496158,
0.0403040461,
-0.0121047208,
-0.0391164497,
0.0091538653,
-0.0414643474,
0.0061493139,
0.0123829916,
0.0242669377,
-6.327052793e-33,
-0.0718027651,
0.0324924216,
0.0182340667,
-0.0245808158,
-0.0028020225,
0.0012362503,
-0.0391231328,
0.0023525907,
-0.0028168506,
0.0000778156,
0.0247465726,
-0.0213424843,
0.0411055796,
0.0404773243,
-0.0194313359,
-0.0319945551,
0.0786521286,
-0.0158159435,
-0.0369732343,
0.0051758112,
0.0064468272,
0.0026874125,
0.0825419575,
-0.0286029112,
-0.0644056872,
0.0404019691,
-0.0185264163,
0.0262189563,
0.0594916008,
0.0368664451,
0.0093831066,
0.0285470486,
0.0173465591,
-0.0282484461,
-0.035210941,
0.0160159916,
-0.1200821847,
-0.0128092086,
-0.0028488529,
0.093878001,
-0.0743036717,
-0.0059969798,
0.0403780639,
0.0117520522,
0.0205767769,
-0.0456457622,
0.0199857578,
-0.0523647405,
-0.0274387263,
-0.0094731897,
-0.0286640022,
0.0099302093,
-0.0049295654,
-0.0468916111,
0.0968604386,
0.0164650045,
0.0193396509,
-0.0376729593,
-0.0587845147,
-0.0131769292,
0.0276016202,
0.0560066625,
0.0561454333,
0.0641829297,
-0.0126985079,
0.0246935394,
0.0317544192,
-0.084088102,
0.0517660305,
0.0296246391,
0.0197021998,
0.0599891543,
0.0213180371,
-0.000138468,
0.0026143903,
-0.0102607729,
-0.0336676091,
0.0134440558,
0.0053764633,
0.0742697492,
-0.0187047813,
0.0537858605,
0.0203789175,
-0.0145844957,
-0.031934496,
-0.0997271612,
-0.0198905859,
-0.0371863134,
0.0209834464,
0.0515750945,
-0.0345889553,
0.0139726549,
0.0942268223,
-0.0029918861,
0.0383658484,
0.0141116986,
-0.032997407,
0.0624075644,
0.008093738,
0.0251125153,
-0.0384378135,
-0.0313225873,
0.0728317499,
-0.0007404521,
0.0147843529,
-0.0097345207,
0.0211117435,
-0.0042220261,
-0.040133208,
0.0011864606,
-0.0471921749,
0.0129068997,
0.0164325349,
0.1038514972,
0.0222612005,
-0.005331106,
-0.047942955,
0.0394433215,
-0.0241688378,
-0.0148698175,
-0.0270444155,
0.0055616088,
0.0284788497,
0.0491234735,
-0.0413623825,
0.0167810544,
-0.0227378588,
-0.0622889586,
0.0453066379,
-0.0606645197,
-0.0394837186,
0.056466911,
2.851e-7,
0.0213453565,
0.0192078743,
0.0354589708,
-0.0266480669,
0.0127495406,
0.0308804233,
0.0065446137,
0.0233366415,
0.0327684842,
-0.0635912716,
-0.009614693,
0.0441325605,
0.0350278877,
-0.0040361034,
-0.0406146832,
0.0169708692,
-0.0024795788,
-0.0028291354,
-0.0037758411,
-0.0222608261,
-0.0111286603,
0.0762120336,
-0.0267750435,
0.0066205859,
0.0227771644,
-0.0190007165,
0.0304417405,
-0.0511954464,
0.0001941973,
-0.0087923026,
-0.0068502566,
0.0595157109,
-0.0333803594,
0.0392350629,
-0.0204962529,
-0.0171244815,
0.0238612406,
0.0580947362,
-0.0258970968,
-0.0373180583,
0.0012329816,
0.0093783038,
-0.027666064,
-0.0251171291,
0.0682493225,
-0.0332255401,
-0.0094631668,
-0.0186898317,
0.003413172,
0.0199369565,
-0.0189869534,
-0.0096074659,
-0.0412632674,
0.0291279703,
0.0556215085,
0.001211704,
-0.0638660938,
-0.0505057871,
-0.0012313719,
-0.0235925093,
-0.0190098546,
-0.0623415187,
-0.0449109636,
-0.043112427,
0.0398673005,
-0.0421163402,
-0.031040052,
2.604925787e-34,
0.0332021676,
-0.0135889342,
0.0101381037,
0.0141888801,
0.036989551,
-0.020117959,
-0.0278566089,
0.0000685549,
-0.039318338,
-0.0561945699,
-0.0420911722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11516v1 | IndigoVX: Where Human Intelligence Meets AI for Optimal Decision Making | 2023-07-21T11:54:53 | 2023-07-21T11:54:53 | Kais Dukes | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper defines a new approach for augmenting human intelligence with AI
for optimal goal solving. Our proposed AI, Indigo, is an acronym for Informed
Numerical Decision-making through Iterative Goal-Oriented optimization. When
combined with a human collaborator, we term the joint system IndigoVX, for
Virtual eXpert. The system is conceptually simple. We envisage this method
being applied to games or business strategies, with the human providing
strategic context and the AI offering optimal, data-driven moves. Indigo
operates through an iterative feedback loop, harnessing the human expert's
contextual knowledge and the AI's data-driven insights to craft and refine
strategies towards a well-defined goal. Using a quantified three-score schema,
this hybridization allows the combined team to evaluate strategies and refine
their plan, while adapting to challenges and changes in real-time. | [
0.0328058451,
0.0285638273,
-0.0259834547,
-0.0171090215,
0.001319738,
-0.0254672766,
-0.0300945044,
0.0230118986,
-0.0476131104,
0.0044596433,
-0.0510358624,
0.0362709723,
-0.0125501128,
0.0806501731,
0.0327243619,
-0.0086909449,
0.0041383645,
-0.0153235635,
0.0271813832,
0.0124286469,
0.0035434572,
-0.0385591537,
-0.0312245954,
0.0066272193,
-0.0424749777,
0.0170757547,
-0.0255697649,
-0.0042041829,
0.0501136594,
-0.066082418,
0.0078198705,
-0.0275546685,
0.011570408,
-0.0418149158,
0.0000022865,
-0.0237531457,
-0.0182910152,
-0.0616108216,
-0.0183062218,
-0.0520898923,
0.0269612484,
0.0187935289,
0.0246800892,
0.010457579,
-0.1051450968,
0.0433321483,
0.0028403902,
0.0211271346,
0.0563983805,
0.0148109803,
0.0006618166,
0.0224923249,
0.0172251984,
-0.0070448332,
-0.0593074113,
-0.0795860663,
-0.0149302734,
0.0625672862,
0.0159710869,
-0.0152483722,
0.0364374667,
0.0080722608,
0.0202748422,
-0.0060115759,
0.0226901807,
0.016246153,
0.0330796912,
-0.0099227503,
-0.0216305237,
0.025220925,
-0.0033508225,
0.0161232743,
0.0140087754,
0.0304252077,
0.033902742,
-0.0321654044,
0.0092221154,
-0.0273444783,
-0.0187904574,
0.010754968,
0.0007270209,
0.0352436677,
-0.0092467861,
-0.0040240763,
-0.015659159,
0.0786511824,
-0.0440889001,
-0.0010082324,
0.0263998695,
-0.0008484838,
-0.0203170925,
-0.0578475408,
-0.0222487766,
0.0424996987,
-0.1340277493,
-0.0117611997,
0.0271334313,
-0.0144923013,
-0.06330093,
-0.0031753057,
0.070639573,
0.0231938902,
0.0726659894,
0.0334689394,
0.0347356796,
0.026067961,
0.0005408446,
-0.0131313987,
-0.039632991,
0.0182865523,
-0.0481517836,
-0.0150618516,
-0.0238715187,
0.0756830648,
-0.0265864655,
-0.0169837605,
-0.0336911306,
0.0301771741,
-0.1029852405,
0.039842505,
0.0012558171,
0.0667988658,
0.0192967802,
0.0034686856,
-0.0827779546,
-0.0400660038,
-0.0790881366,
0.0170333628,
-0.0024355501,
0.0384452604,
0.0366012752,
0.0288236383,
-0.0488400906,
0.0064863563,
0.0299393665,
0.0884619653,
-0.02185224,
0.02201543,
-0.0132100284,
-0.0520992316,
0.0621004067,
-0.0769806951,
-0.0229946859,
-0.0063130171,
0.0208526477,
-0.0516032949,
-0.0362085998,
-0.024743313,
0.0128953923,
-0.0165502075,
0.0249863174,
0.0697744414,
-0.0063765072,
0.0212191138,
0.008162926,
-0.0046945699,
-0.0129862614,
0.060840074,
0.0530797467,
0.0434010029,
0.0111393416,
0.0302458126,
0.0310073867,
0.0174445715,
0.0069598886,
-0.0386855565,
-0.0150182648,
0.0105506526,
-0.0373056941,
0.0680404305,
-0.052101288,
-0.0174325444,
-0.0422164164,
0.0101126395,
0.0476846844,
-0.0105245654,
0.0296245571,
0.03300317,
0.0525185727,
0.0197110996,
-0.022371063,
-0.0535980426,
0.0018247897,
0.0758370683,
-0.0294712894,
-0.0205792747,
-0.0498980395,
-0.0098160347,
-0.0115419161,
-0.0703413486,
0.065615125,
0.0185126755,
-0.014320517,
0.0254941527,
0.0019856284,
-0.0366208963,
-0.0252227038,
-0.0418417677,
-0.0142185921,
0.0518088788,
-0.009431731,
-0.0621839836,
0.0081370948,
0.0727235004,
0.0486029126,
-0.0819721818,
-0.0438697264,
-0.0135770207,
-0.0625540316,
-0.0179626364,
0.01953342,
-0.0424703471,
-0.0323214941,
0.0144349234,
-0.0349988975,
0.0147883743,
0.0081144357,
0.0360633954,
0.0133574428,
-0.0183694381,
-0.0588922948,
0.0354837701,
0.0114210313,
0.0073551228,
-0.0013547087,
-0.0310191866,
0.0104937619,
-0.0067952173,
0.0362123027,
0.0361892171,
0.0068036439,
0.0029654568,
0.0091567244,
0.0033009755,
-0.0751755685,
0.0235089399,
0.0508120097,
0.0858602598,
0.0326771215,
-0.0506629646,
0.0174897537,
0.0336532444,
0.0070190029,
-0.0193641223,
0.0389723219,
-0.0161280911,
-0.0409677923,
0.0038193234,
-0.0152145717,
-0.0067640026,
-0.0021628193,
-0.0176052097,
0.0191710237,
0.014946782,
-0.0640639439,
-0.0124787809,
-0.0534685999,
0.0191345401,
-0.0362980179,
0.1001447663,
0.0273867641,
0.0222086087,
0.0034191697,
0.0551654957,
0.022643635,
0.0029195789,
0.0015750473,
-0.1029571444,
0.0301191825,
0.0001059616,
0.0048764888,
-0.0150767444,
-0.0511083864,
-0.0043528951,
-0.0085083814,
-0.0074113263,
0.047241658,
-0.0079485197,
-0.051149372,
0.037741717,
0.0566172525,
0.0074197054,
-0.0336018428,
0.0068234331,
-0.0461709239,
0.001799166,
0.0625020042,
-0.0147839077,
-0.0448205546,
-0.0058709485,
-0.0452337414,
0.0419573523,
0.0034286845,
0.0019501527,
0.0100889895,
-0.0317148082,
-0.0243341606,
0.0178731419,
-0.0055276356,
0.0558923446,
0.0493432134,
-0.0391322523,
-0.0461972915,
0.057543017,
-0.0181713346,
0.003620605,
-0.0465011634,
-0.0068313112,
0.0388138257,
0.0194849651,
-0.0248753317,
0.0068637896,
-0.0296268295,
0.0833585337,
0.0107512325,
-0.0390549935,
-0.0449579805,
-0.0130874375,
0.0035485192,
0.0625171587,
0.0025078149,
0.0219811164,
0.0784349665,
0.0495255888,
0.0254335273,
-0.0092437286,
-0.0040561068,
-0.0481464751,
-0.0061134659,
-0.0319865234,
0.0054492443,
-0.0694260299,
0.01095594,
-0.0303821918,
0.008396673,
0.0104848742,
-0.0236851666,
-0.0095857223,
-0.049980469,
-0.0286787022,
0.0386386327,
-0.0438697636,
-0.012995719,
0.0243488643,
-0.0363222882,
0.0270836968,
0.0558881499,
-0.0387061574,
-0.0682255104,
-0.0312424246,
0.0557689033,
0.0194438994,
-0.033717189,
-0.054994233,
-0.0155422892,
-0.0351407081,
0.0282023009,
0.0130855571,
0.0273605976,
0.0296552218,
0.0345941223,
0.0229050908,
0.0219716113,
-0.0304904468,
-0.0262005571,
0.0250294618,
0.0084572742,
-0.0266744718,
0.0137185678,
0.0318364762,
-0.0217168983,
-0.0158109758,
-0.0076619461,
0.0450132675,
0.0241300967,
-0.0114015834,
0.0256647654,
-0.0380012132,
-0.0088813296,
0.0035716887,
0.078990221,
-0.0602635331,
-0.0153194591,
-0.0175966676,
0.0584341399,
-0.005845028,
-0.0639550835,
-0.014644281,
-0.0573124439,
0.0245112199,
-0.0190054476,
-0.009045016,
-0.0132999066,
-0.0067512202,
0.0019490565,
-0.0325520001,
-0.0382132046,
0.0027866033,
0.0416783579,
0.0058421236,
-0.0201780628,
0.015164474,
0.0304177776,
0.0105243893,
-0.0050112996,
-0.0181845035,
0.0755970106,
0.0635375753,
0.0062452378,
-0.0189899672,
-0.0177053064,
0.0661887601,
0.0398685895,
-0.0019617993,
0.0245450307,
-0.0332217515,
0.0060175234,
0.0126329418,
0.0265564974,
0.0019600599,
0.0379699655,
0.0581852309,
0.0249443874,
-0.0426021479,
0.0329784453,
0.0125131598,
-0.0042697745,
0.0266088899,
0.020096302,
-0.0409231335,
-0.0493878126,
-0.0119197266,
-0.0046397992,
0.0357627273,
-0.0736487433,
-0.0345130339,
-0.0051429975,
0.0218333881,
-0.0164240263,
-0.0750757903,
-0.0900276154,
-0.0156647656,
0.0718394667,
0.0035205793,
-0.0368011259,
-0.0146837644,
0.0203424133,
-0.013609739,
-0.0527471602,
0.0179768428,
0.0102738729,
-0.021543948,
0.0032205067,
-0.0338916481,
-0.0684316084,
-0.0246072952,
0.023455333,
0.0222269148,
0.0160938222,
-0.0162021853,
0.109124504,
0.0242864341,
-0.0018439163,
-0.0015210825,
-0.0255981795,
0.0272079278,
-0.0115419514,
-0.0162259024,
-0.0193728879,
0.0115486765,
0.0080602281,
0.0033971635,
0.0117246155,
-0.0299444478,
0.0310516953,
0.0521195009,
0.0173591264,
-0.0557265878,
0.0025536621,
0.007181671,
0.00966396,
0.0179994199,
-0.0348218083,
-0.0143074403,
0.0239044726,
0.0128419269,
-0.0397388227,
-0.0200351384,
-0.0270493608,
-0.0290617049,
0.0104827546,
-0.008546208,
0.0378999636,
0.0347287282,
0.0403049663,
-0.096504055,
-0.0250499025,
0.0240926482,
0.0183477011,
0.0589580275,
0.000038547,
0.0016602481,
0.0418980382,
0.0247998051,
0.0028490066,
0.0324907266,
0.0211804677,
0.0240277555,
0.0323261023,
-0.060531076,
-0.0341893435,
0.0127552608,
-0.0124033317,
-0.0749260113,
0.037541829,
0.0208987296,
0.0419164449,
0.0834346935,
-0.0513859205,
-0.042733565,
0.0161170457,
0.0346816033,
-0.0531936213,
-0.0220812205,
-0.0057852892,
-0.0274496544,
0.0395477675,
-0.0062167402,
0.0265803058,
0.0153193166,
-0.041754894,
0.0365598798,
-0.1023927405,
-0.0463121571,
-0.0574963763,
-0.0025281894,
-0.0024268816,
0.0651671812,
-0.0090439087,
0.0198473819,
-0.0712797493,
0.0220999848,
0.0107731624,
0.0925936624,
0.0074680741,
-0.0129677933,
0.0033820013,
-0.0131116966,
-0.0165528562,
-0.0170028824,
-0.0261402633,
-0.0021340272,
-0.0722714961,
0.0074070762,
-0.0376271792,
-6.174957048e-33,
0.0036156755,
-0.0486626104,
0.0696356371,
0.0073416424,
-0.0153710786,
-0.0125369094,
-0.0152490726,
0.014622326,
0.0054240162,
0.0165921617,
-0.0263279248,
-0.0127840545,
0.0002402713,
-0.0330577157,
0.0320749283,
0.0071557863,
0.002550958,
-0.0318077728,
-0.0414859019,
-0.0118768914,
-0.0019371969,
0.0014925495,
0.007516304,
-0.0942314416,
-0.0156759508,
0.040420305,
-0.0458535254,
0.0794353783,
0.022660058,
0.0002534359,
0.0096062077,
-0.0155497901,
0.017668644,
-0.0966805965,
0.0224568099,
-0.0134218503,
-0.0330663659,
-0.0460681394,
-0.029217096,
-0.011039393,
-0.0244518314,
0.0130706299,
0.0176690184,
0.0194716938,
-0.032278575,
0.0217081569,
0.0305039026,
-0.0059347921,
0.0485662185,
-0.0471781865,
-0.037291564,
-0.0002131719,
-0.0317143351,
0.0189303327,
0.0668909103,
0.03764515,
-0.0124149583,
-0.0705797225,
-0.0410328433,
0.0191679969,
-0.0420689061,
-0.0499177091,
0.0104559232,
0.0175368898,
0.0061233034,
0.0181676,
0.059569668,
-0.007700142,
-0.0474590957,
-0.0192433801,
-0.0195756704,
0.0700415373,
0.0408533625,
0.0103735868,
-0.0510174744,
0.011646539,
-0.0340510048,
0.0523363054,
0.0086455764,
0.0646312088,
-0.0148230996,
0.024489671,
-0.0658835471,
0.0119001837,
0.0318271667,
-0.0409309417,
-0.0186639484,
-0.0288126171,
0.0032739262,
0.0002909502,
0.0103844618,
0.0713658109,
-0.0054120137,
-0.0053228606,
0.0308410693,
0.0339414403,
0.0343636274,
0.0336489379,
-0.0121560236,
-0.0142154852,
-0.0075671757,
-0.0381502025,
-0.0064930469,
0.0090748193,
0.0409212112,
0.0036298989,
-0.0040369676,
0.0078967018,
0.0145343766,
-0.0033447011,
-0.008559607,
0.0294134971,
0.0571488291,
-0.084743388,
0.0431239791,
-0.0040208865,
-0.0103894901,
-0.0297003239,
0.0164900105,
-0.024172904,
-0.0242934134,
0.0089263255,
-0.038174063,
0.0078329006,
0.0081599392,
0.013592938,
0.0004906147,
-0.0056337928,
-0.0717615932,
-0.0191632975,
-0.0265564024,
0.004799509,
3.032e-7,
-0.0301187374,
0.0832746476,
-0.0221918151,
-0.0189153906,
-0.0190280359,
0.0676802173,
0.0019731054,
-0.0353305787,
-0.0147750871,
0.0001047161,
0.1019935459,
0.0640704855,
-0.0023679943,
0.0200101472,
-0.0049080532,
-0.0641538873,
0.0660792887,
0.0157057494,
-0.0273564178,
0.0277149081,
0.0405090898,
0.0016769803,
0.0646915883,
-0.0151738729,
0.0431930013,
-0.0261364225,
-0.008508455,
-0.0148865823,
0.0249456726,
0.0468352437,
0.0291640926,
0.002217219,
-0.0276790429,
0.0254937131,
-0.0086735869,
0.0310662799,
0.0091839172,
0.0200652927,
-0.0285451096,
0.0179879479,
-0.0431214496,
0.006440137,
0.009315989,
-0.0058777235,
0.0254235417,
-0.0283289347,
-0.0240917951,
-0.0063571692,
-0.0303955078,
0.0048705037,
-0.0721767172,
-0.0022798185,
0.0047123376,
0.0163241215,
-0.0137555134,
0.0238882806,
0.0320832804,
-0.0409087539,
0.0095159328,
0.0747606903,
-0.0557782836,
0.0389888324,
-0.007767302,
0.0450568087,
-0.0013399913,
-0.0211846549,
0.0286866874,
2.471241085e-34,
-0.0281796772,
-0.0053965696,
-0.0097103231,
-0.0055353288,
0.0668002442,
0.0355767421,
-0.0550720058,
0.013091105,
0.0573132113,
0.0049545458,
-0.0353897326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11457v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11457v1 | Incorporating Human Translator Style into English-Turkish Literary Machine Translation | 2023-07-21T09:39:50 | 2023-07-21T09:39:50 | Zeynep Yirmibeşoğlu, Olgun Dursun, Harun Dallı, Mehmet Şahin, Ena Hodzik, Sabri Gürses, Tunga Güngör | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although machine translation systems are mostly designed to serve in the
general domain, there is a growing tendency to adapt these systems to other
domains like literary translation. In this paper, we focus on English-Turkish
literary translation and develop machine translation models that take into
account the stylistic features of translators. We fine-tune a pre-trained
machine translation model by the manually-aligned works of a particular
translator. We make a detailed analysis of the effects of manual and automatic
alignments, data augmentation methods, and corpus size on the translations. We
propose an approach based on stylistic features to evaluate the style of a
translator in the output translations. We show that the human translator style
can be highly recreated in the target machine translations by adapting the
models to the style of the translator. | [
0.0381908938,
0.0154434303,
-0.0262740012,
0.026443297,
-0.0205734018,
0.0381389223,
0.0180244464,
-0.0103556132,
-0.0287369322,
-0.0192136858,
-0.0394983888,
-0.0296636801,
0.0412201583,
-0.0340826772,
0.0404937081,
-0.0523997173,
0.0051293238,
-0.0113811744,
0.0051461332,
0.0042555355,
0.0534271002,
0.0530916564,
0.0131601552,
0.0185370371,
0.0186780449,
-0.022501722,
-0.0264787413,
0.0572061054,
0.047774259,
0.0396942049,
-0.0037600407,
0.0075356201,
-0.0155805424,
0.055369202,
0.0000015299,
-0.0035165888,
-0.0012330245,
-0.0262911934,
0.0630519167,
-0.0122636128,
0.0803498626,
-0.0577240139,
-0.0368127897,
-0.0145111522,
-0.0116703808,
-0.0011053125,
0.062701866,
0.0219054129,
0.0649887621,
0.0977447852,
-0.0238761995,
-0.1105805859,
0.0090758791,
0.0034380509,
-0.005284545,
-0.058935333,
-0.0265109576,
-0.0533770025,
-0.0649689808,
0.0548390634,
0.021617366,
0.0456100255,
-0.0452162959,
-0.015592901,
-0.0169877391,
-0.0502656437,
-0.0679904148,
-0.0109493202,
0.0285265334,
0.0168412942,
0.0361601822,
-0.0442253947,
0.001561393,
0.0165109318,
0.0033256768,
0.0326215401,
-0.0174859706,
0.0020257893,
-0.0301301051,
-0.0187018886,
0.0272461474,
0.0555564612,
-0.0027329659,
-0.0088680144,
-0.0281342268,
-0.0117569054,
0.0339272581,
-0.0147236446,
-0.0126212724,
0.0012929535,
-0.0082007693,
0.0080509512,
0.0198420491,
0.0360453725,
0.0072159502,
-0.0098663401,
-0.0485334583,
-0.0875128359,
-0.0130011495,
-0.0481282324,
0.0499316007,
0.037796963,
0.0147712622,
0.0063797971,
-0.0162282567,
0.0311032701,
-0.0276010837,
0.0013810381,
-0.0716972798,
-0.0223643705,
-0.008581033,
0.0134506263,
-0.063389942,
-0.0642788336,
0.0088266917,
0.0359236896,
-0.0477208421,
0.0106059685,
0.0397707298,
0.0234320275,
-0.0093058133,
-0.0205659494,
-0.0751716644,
-0.0333857797,
-0.0166266169,
0.0219476111,
-0.0028440005,
-0.0415990613,
-0.0462866239,
0.0005403915,
-0.0088968007,
0.0338155404,
0.0087790135,
-0.0450196452,
-0.0291069318,
0.0338409916,
-0.0123131573,
-0.0397392772,
-0.0110336021,
0.0310149286,
-0.0185821578,
-0.0470298678,
-0.0303161461,
-0.0128983296,
0.0389287882,
-0.0189032275,
0.0053471364,
-0.0327017494,
-0.0190567728,
0.03213007,
-0.0121139046,
0.0375887081,
0.0314994752,
0.0354079641,
0.01738948,
-0.0731127337,
0.0123564107,
0.0444564298,
0.0640525594,
0.065915294,
0.0285101905,
-0.0034155722,
0.0036994792,
0.0685458928,
-0.0165081453,
0.0055964803,
-0.0423519425,
-0.0018634595,
0.0214698426,
0.0766412914,
0.023798503,
0.0375871323,
0.0148524269,
0.0428321324,
0.0767325908,
0.0122657977,
0.0394062698,
0.0542485453,
0.0578888245,
0.0257749893,
0.0524098687,
0.0290079806,
-0.0111654708,
-0.0002779305,
0.0307135209,
0.0529340394,
-0.0226880573,
0.0695562661,
0.0096901683,
-0.0177906901,
0.0013469044,
-0.0030461338,
0.0154909398,
-0.0394016057,
0.0416530035,
0.0076253316,
-0.0529696271,
-0.0312003978,
-0.0198509973,
-0.0300122797,
-0.0021628675,
-0.0223542266,
-0.0454384759,
0.0920233354,
0.0634764507,
-0.034292195,
0.041948799,
-0.0055326149,
-0.0005721344,
0.0032933953,
0.050007008,
-0.0148645025,
0.0256901085,
-0.0367060453,
0.0189701207,
0.0018902532,
0.0198432915,
0.0156172356,
-0.0537202917,
0.0616703928,
0.0376357771,
-0.0142704817,
-0.0677066445,
0.0499506705,
-0.0218156427,
-0.0492239483,
-0.0143565927,
0.0219782814,
-0.0209836215,
0.0059296759,
-0.0364674963,
0.0017069922,
-0.0017917026,
-0.0513591431,
0.0469462611,
0.0855301917,
-0.0149544394,
-0.0126972217,
0.0181874055,
-0.0371025689,
-0.0189494099,
0.0048277271,
-0.0399938077,
-0.0578286275,
0.0081767133,
-0.0443924889,
0.0039830436,
-0.0085455533,
0.0562348478,
-0.0167166144,
-0.0071396357,
-0.0601537153,
0.011181958,
0.0649826452,
-0.0392200239,
-0.0268294085,
-0.0512305126,
0.0183812268,
0.0355468281,
-0.0043655573,
-0.0048699002,
0.0402207412,
0.0205505732,
0.0263628736,
-0.0300858095,
0.0013611331,
-0.0569162704,
-0.0667214543,
0.0097021628,
-0.0239641219,
0.0349892378,
0.0539814346,
0.0403636396,
-0.0073389658,
0.0146524468,
-0.0177194793,
-0.0042081303,
-0.0137240496,
-0.0240867361,
0.0646746382,
-0.0213914067,
0.0269919895,
-0.0256918296,
0.0014148209,
0.0063137095,
0.0245202091,
0.0449545644,
-0.0253074076,
-0.0381272212,
-0.0056083184,
0.0129776644,
-0.0316889659,
-0.0022529142,
-0.0811275989,
-0.0067504337,
-0.0138604539,
0.0052747647,
0.0606789552,
0.0241733771,
-0.0159663539,
0.0230444539,
0.0011920276,
0.0055348044,
-0.0278119538,
0.020220818,
-0.0520697422,
-0.0151194427,
-0.0372262374,
0.0268238336,
-0.0068618073,
-0.0333010927,
-0.0206386112,
-0.051642783,
-0.0009270325,
0.0245855283,
0.0057061519,
0.0449119955,
0.0243436974,
-0.0350745544,
0.0756189749,
-0.0062642586,
0.0076736719,
0.0286657307,
-0.0181756821,
0.0054021985,
-0.0451667346,
0.0163292736,
-0.0559923574,
0.0357557945,
0.0042036064,
0.0193530321,
-0.0182867479,
-0.0161925312,
-0.0357630663,
0.0495402552,
0.0944761038,
-0.0309634767,
0.0382471606,
-0.0290736929,
-0.0136383791,
-0.0121142576,
0.0258815028,
-0.0294942614,
-0.0498310439,
-0.0112464512,
-0.0487762429,
0.0403935872,
-0.0301474538,
-0.0285926331,
-0.0154434117,
-0.0173250996,
0.0549097806,
-0.0266634915,
0.0170152839,
-0.0318980478,
0.0078604817,
0.0180505235,
-0.0202495139,
-0.0491323695,
-0.0343450978,
0.0433896072,
-0.0087864455,
-0.0709054545,
-0.0103559075,
-0.0498883352,
-0.0244053304,
0.0470412597,
-0.0464916416,
-0.0256519914,
-0.029703876,
0.0619609021,
-0.0415768921,
0.0082504917,
0.0980656818,
-0.0050779027,
-0.0240711104,
-0.0326686725,
-0.0314204469,
0.0205030181,
0.0116215581,
0.044526048,
-0.0430190004,
-0.0001101833,
0.0092706485,
0.0315442719,
0.0077811633,
0.0114970598,
0.0156283733,
-0.0613917038,
-0.0192942489,
0.0512893237,
-0.0704186037,
-0.0255861692,
0.0063631115,
-0.0061785304,
-0.0456185639,
-0.0224184394,
-0.0143266823,
-0.0109628364,
0.0374761298,
-0.0166856945,
0.0093856063,
-0.0537987798,
-0.079077512,
-0.0645322874,
-0.0082716178,
0.0612155013,
0.0676682591,
-0.0176497698,
-0.0087410398,
-0.0260039046,
-0.0111902356,
0.0094194002,
0.0407205671,
0.0429940708,
-0.020246258,
-0.0074867532,
-0.0243955124,
0.0068250708,
0.0129905557,
0.0115199266,
0.0531194918,
-0.0313270167,
-0.0130966241,
0.0484904759,
-0.0053078467,
0.0224648733,
-0.0017755457,
-0.0049257758,
0.0027875337,
-0.030082019,
-0.0116636232,
-0.00930769,
0.0047969199,
-0.0564291477,
-0.060653951,
0.0291771609,
-0.0593731329,
-0.0475131758,
-0.1039323136,
-0.0450531766,
-0.0323150493,
0.0466517806,
0.0711237416,
0.0154713076,
-0.0326740146,
-0.0026880272,
-0.0092068138,
0.007994676,
0.0000789832,
0.0140087148,
0.008869228,
-0.0036328873,
0.0129896617,
-0.0620351993,
0.0664248988,
0.021362694,
-0.0607325546,
-0.0622180514,
0.01696763,
0.0393621586,
0.0194572285,
0.0490770824,
-0.0399429202,
-0.0454534739,
0.0003722792,
-0.0000620667,
-0.0061667198,
0.033718694,
0.0053883758,
0.0086166309,
-0.0368470922,
0.044771295,
0.0186542179,
0.0074149566,
-0.0075451001,
-0.0169964377,
0.0091924267,
-0.0577290989,
0.02746314,
0.0136458548,
0.0027309635,
-0.0638941601,
0.0299564451,
-0.0005114712,
-0.0144293699,
-0.0187461767,
-0.0378971323,
-0.0048004738,
-0.0131067615,
0.0480019338,
-0.0165316537,
-0.0056399805,
-0.0385097265,
-0.0171997044,
-0.0355109759,
-0.0576497354,
-0.0268482473,
-0.0091536017,
0.0593535639,
-0.0128856804,
0.0492009073,
-0.0120655717,
0.0611650646,
-0.0226840209,
0.0360354111,
0.0134470761,
0.0164504647,
0.0037154728,
0.0378137417,
0.0014642262,
0.0562800132,
-0.0356616452,
-0.0048862216,
-0.0187116824,
-0.0155653739,
0.0793581754,
-0.0501871929,
0.1155815795,
0.0020075447,
-0.0184449106,
0.0124267824,
0.057757549,
0.0231355019,
0.0408242345,
-0.0827272013,
-0.0184246358,
0.0042982353,
0.0040694233,
0.0147700924,
-0.0181977823,
-0.029286975,
0.0038895151,
-0.0412029885,
0.010950515,
-0.0049577127,
0.0003871211,
-0.0192445479,
0.021317251,
-0.0383306257,
-0.03129787,
-0.049664475,
0.0099937487,
0.0302469209,
0.0253001377,
-0.0407752544,
0.0141406199,
0.0527036265,
-0.0398384146,
0.0525928065,
-0.0751695409,
0.0421797,
0.0187479425,
-0.0041485694,
-0.0646482706,
-4.629302465e-33,
-0.0198508669,
0.0327372551,
-0.0117449472,
-0.0114196045,
-0.0573282987,
-0.0658444911,
0.0012989809,
-0.0286584031,
0.0104517154,
0.0146914758,
-0.0568926893,
-0.0078630373,
0.0137778632,
-0.0283565298,
0.0403450914,
0.0301827285,
0.05852874,
-0.009536244,
-0.0431244113,
-0.0019756246,
0.0477865823,
-0.0042652986,
0.085936673,
-0.0461317785,
0.0315656178,
-0.0982048064,
-0.0321876071,
0.0018719648,
0.0501654111,
-0.0096271671,
0.0489970744,
0.0011875248,
-0.0054690759,
-0.0074985032,
-0.0098602939,
-0.0200585388,
-0.0442648306,
0.0136622516,
0.0134356637,
0.0838983357,
0.0376646779,
-0.0659213364,
0.0189987291,
-0.0609481968,
-0.0103625227,
0.0066505563,
0.0580800287,
-0.0495243408,
-0.0080399141,
-0.0309691019,
-0.0995668471,
0.0191211328,
-0.0473676845,
-0.0152531285,
0.0713870227,
0.055212345,
-0.0024007941,
0.0058242367,
-0.0240574069,
-0.0086137122,
-0.053099066,
0.0157544538,
0.0241468884,
0.0055393549,
-0.0281908512,
0.0032450587,
-0.0283205565,
0.0506596006,
-0.0274780821,
0.0458495282,
0.0179600678,
-0.0066219312,
0.0046339585,
0.0830432698,
0.0225063935,
-0.0261432994,
0.0091135791,
0.050320372,
-0.0064810314,
0.0188231822,
-0.0204553138,
0.0082958257,
-0.0102056637,
-0.0189505629,
-0.0036173731,
-0.0563256182,
0.0190267432,
-0.0108234817,
-0.0421886072,
-0.012501657,
-0.0295547545,
-0.0179954804,
0.0148387346,
-0.0435946807,
0.0433998294,
-0.0345018096,
-0.0641807541,
0.0441373922,
-0.0408514291,
0.0391597226,
0.0621065646,
-0.0570035949,
0.0166546442,
0.0243948568,
0.035429094,
-0.0095147379,
0.0473605245,
0.0167841967,
-0.0348134451,
0.0034778325,
-0.0008041328,
-0.0066910107,
-0.0222680401,
0.0283617359,
0.0204568151,
-0.0020938623,
0.0037976995,
0.0341023579,
0.0461564176,
-0.0149696674,
-0.0278953295,
-0.0308461208,
0.0505360775,
-0.0236661211,
-0.0276165865,
0.0457289517,
-0.0006769317,
-0.0188486278,
0.0160788521,
-0.0418853536,
-0.0222746972,
-0.0408794396,
2.344e-7,
0.0472359061,
0.0113895042,
0.0381244533,
0.0151387909,
0.0164247993,
0.0312202424,
-0.0121304067,
0.0513404571,
0.0037181433,
0.0334127843,
0.0792100728,
0.0038461923,
0.0777728185,
-0.0079738516,
-0.0779913738,
-0.0408441685,
-0.0317028761,
0.0376493484,
-0.0619531944,
0.025799796,
0.0507200584,
0.0542079844,
0.0110123502,
-0.0044222474,
0.0193630662,
0.0008503121,
0.0579690225,
-0.0275205653,
-0.0283596274,
0.0250670239,
0.0687319115,
-0.0247469209,
-0.0526500233,
0.0285389964,
-0.0203447342,
0.0208605155,
0.0575864241,
0.075532198,
-0.0088465931,
0.0495442934,
0.0186819788,
-0.0192481112,
0.0049432553,
-0.0369424149,
0.0562178679,
0.0305484906,
-0.0327703878,
-0.0266051628,
-0.0293873902,
0.0181845147,
0.0258520637,
-0.0003478167,
-0.0365449265,
0.0593214333,
0.058396358,
-0.0046318402,
-0.0117943948,
-0.0453873649,
-0.0297357403,
-0.006925059,
0.0087627778,
-0.0138287861,
0.0051759146,
0.0032975599,
0.0255855881,
-0.0095762387,
0.0014334973,
1.637610108e-34,
0.0464519821,
-0.0338054597,
0.0306378137,
0.0065728822,
0.0220824424,
-0.014910413,
0.0092545412,
0.0512767322,
0.0163876526,
-0.016350273,
-0.0185175706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11450v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11450v1 | Topic Identification For Spontaneous Speech: Enriching Audio Features With Embedded Linguistic Information | 2023-07-21T09:30:46 | 2023-07-21T09:30:46 | Dejan Porjazovski, Tamás Grósz, Mikko Kurimo | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Traditional topic identification solutions from audio rely on an automatic
speech recognition system (ASR) to produce transcripts used as input to a
text-based model. These approaches work well in high-resource scenarios, where
there are sufficient data to train both components of the pipeline. However, in
low-resource situations, the ASR system, even if available, produces
low-quality transcripts, leading to a bad text-based classifier. Moreover,
spontaneous speech containing hesitations can further degrade the performance
of the ASR model. In this paper, we investigate alternatives to the standard
text-only solutions by comparing audio-only and hybrid techniques of jointly
utilising text and audio features. The models evaluated on spontaneous Finnish
speech demonstrate that purely audio-based solutions are a viable option when
ASR components are not available, while the hybrid multi-modal solutions
achieve the best results. | [
0.0099209342,
0.0457956456,
0.0060581919,
0.0100438446,
-0.0557464473,
-0.0141038178,
0.0336231813,
-0.0477381051,
-0.0619490109,
-0.062365368,
0.0171543341,
-0.0072051631,
0.0252390057,
0.0527739935,
-0.0445383936,
-0.0503862761,
0.0318419226,
-0.0715010166,
0.0407516174,
-0.0216188747,
-0.0004379051,
0.0057132435,
-0.0800991654,
-0.009436598,
-0.0413467251,
0.0215814412,
-0.0334335491,
-0.007602809,
-0.0049655526,
-0.002076247,
-0.0247158706,
0.0600296147,
-0.0132350791,
0.0217495374,
0.0000014646,
-0.0287320968,
-0.0246299729,
-0.0130625805,
-0.0027518419,
-0.0248533543,
0.0506534725,
0.0240006894,
0.0053459052,
0.0316443965,
0.0336676724,
0.0009493368,
0.009325482,
0.0845514908,
-0.0025776413,
0.0411314107,
-0.0210148208,
-0.0354888327,
0.0127616338,
0.005173373,
0.0024742167,
-0.0114995986,
-0.0083754621,
-0.0537775494,
0.0343421288,
0.0048173284,
-0.0018053673,
0.0779949576,
-0.0417862795,
-0.0167709254,
0.039970763,
0.0171931535,
-0.0930978507,
-0.0676314905,
-0.0253310446,
0.0661679506,
0.033513505,
-0.0138717163,
0.0670735613,
-0.0196161084,
-0.0468880162,
-0.0053390423,
-0.0017435262,
0.0410590135,
-0.0105752004,
-0.0090281842,
0.03609097,
0.0422067642,
0.0002410412,
-0.0178386066,
0.0170762744,
0.0204304382,
0.0191054363,
-0.0132443821,
0.0215116404,
-0.0155198276,
0.044179216,
-0.0201001856,
0.0213722158,
-0.0154809644,
0.0131021552,
-0.0137042701,
-0.008441289,
-0.0461884402,
-0.0178902447,
-0.0234274343,
-0.0480027683,
-0.0153893726,
-0.0856593177,
0.0324677974,
0.0122526586,
0.0064867297,
0.0207050256,
-0.0396825448,
-0.0399804711,
-0.0047377073,
-0.0003573151,
0.019672744,
-0.0164772607,
0.0139783099,
-0.0174557976,
-0.0514639542,
-0.0107513005,
0.0061274548,
0.0012237027,
0.0038123743,
-0.0247978363,
-0.0317727588,
-0.012361018,
0.0407874808,
0.0225396622,
0.0342721194,
0.0258374847,
0.0896715969,
-0.0728403106,
-0.0455670655,
0.0259084348,
0.0470632464,
0.0931140408,
0.029625304,
0.0340410732,
0.0261530932,
-0.0457427576,
-0.0719273686,
-0.0183540732,
0.0019688569,
-0.0160967205,
-0.0269346349,
-0.0133630484,
-0.0574676804,
0.027210841,
0.0142713403,
-0.0390147045,
0.0277527068,
0.0202994887,
-0.0357724167,
0.0202115737,
0.0446469337,
0.0056826724,
0.0596080311,
0.0650789291,
-0.0094796605,
0.0415506959,
0.0453408733,
0.0136109218,
-0.0020770992,
0.0493260361,
-0.0009938502,
0.0180497766,
0.0309629496,
-0.0307084341,
-0.0065246946,
-0.0157591216,
-0.0207948387,
-0.0044336277,
-0.0030196069,
0.0347688682,
0.0345439091,
0.0231182203,
0.0299547929,
0.0672442317,
0.0572725646,
-0.0019000741,
0.0120644262,
0.0219405442,
0.0505743697,
0.0233919807,
0.0074100913,
0.0219942126,
-0.0275819264,
-0.0007409967,
0.0262296014,
0.0524562001,
-0.010578067,
-0.0297723636,
-0.0248758402,
0.0041688592,
-0.0431983359,
-0.0361912921,
0.0434038751,
0.0679780394,
-0.0238753259,
0.0081924368,
0.01931745,
-0.0075855362,
-0.0166070294,
0.0065544173,
-0.00633222,
0.0439131856,
0.0170773119,
-0.0000033834,
-0.0485041663,
-0.0159368552,
-0.0687223002,
-0.0166291799,
0.0507868789,
-0.0165542141,
-0.0066103954,
0.0541892238,
-0.0235997606,
0.0165824965,
0.0090787597,
0.0157505851,
0.0182560533,
-0.0372522734,
0.026628118,
0.0168340988,
0.0206734911,
0.082742922,
-0.0060176812,
0.0195599087,
-0.0086631253,
0.0214736853,
-0.0012830269,
0.0698653683,
0.0626491234,
-0.0335277468,
-0.0044855671,
0.0363602303,
-0.0450414643,
0.0099688517,
0.0264920853,
-0.0178507864,
-0.0363016352,
0.0314635448,
0.0132758496,
-0.0101770526,
0.0266785845,
0.035218358,
-0.0785414428,
0.0425777547,
-0.0010123393,
0.0090061808,
-0.0378904194,
0.0058534415,
0.0168090686,
0.0427132696,
0.0243299566,
-0.0148831354,
0.0355980732,
0.014599626,
0.007146121,
-0.02907384,
0.0330537409,
-0.1041112542,
-0.0317938104,
0.0180980209,
-0.0548698232,
0.0380269252,
-0.0033849122,
-0.0273921899,
0.0059707388,
-0.0085441824,
-0.0982977077,
-0.0030833804,
-0.0490957722,
0.0017514125,
-0.0253585801,
0.0110782832,
-0.0319837183,
-0.0400351807,
-0.0272598658,
-0.0439941026,
0.0346650556,
-0.0179743413,
-0.059793558,
0.0040205549,
-0.031847015,
-0.0222177058,
0.0256677177,
-0.0077380394,
0.0172881521,
-0.0048799347,
-0.0637636483,
-0.0192434639,
0.0317642279,
-0.0166761912,
0.0292701442,
-0.0157014672,
0.0041091302,
-0.0342039093,
-0.0106304521,
0.0767122284,
0.0185619239,
-0.0118375029,
-0.0175789353,
0.0271512717,
-0.0340719521,
-0.0019985868,
-0.0038832019,
-0.0050795511,
0.0444959067,
0.0120965037,
0.0218077786,
-0.0211097524,
0.0041860584,
0.0556686781,
0.0398407876,
0.0240143258,
-0.0350510515,
-0.0340553895,
-0.0028853868,
-0.0228952076,
-0.0050682365,
-0.0388659649,
0.0384458117,
0.0243724491,
-0.0142061627,
0.0222119857,
-0.0571074523,
-0.0284608435,
-0.07440494,
-0.0832652152,
-0.0250123702,
0.0198375992,
-0.0147514129,
0.0099055059,
-0.0131776249,
-0.0155953988,
0.009963179,
0.0000823335,
0.0227331072,
-0.0536439978,
0.0412562452,
-0.0150008537,
0.0298077799,
0.001696069,
-0.0199315101,
-0.0340508148,
-0.1080185771,
-0.012222087,
0.0076709716,
-0.0318664908,
-0.0168087631,
-0.0202614889,
0.0181442518,
0.0506689921,
0.05904283,
0.0062419581,
0.0544640534,
-0.0071216887,
0.112034902,
0.0116945878,
-0.0107616205,
-0.02970149,
0.0251388233,
0.0437274687,
-0.027426336,
0.0691920072,
-0.0026214216,
-0.0190390591,
-0.0080227284,
0.0041981493,
-0.0044223028,
-0.055153314,
0.0312766768,
0.0209956486,
-0.0078328559,
0.039163623,
0.0675916374,
-0.0154052088,
0.0144436816,
-0.026358882,
0.00947606,
-0.0139662717,
0.0065703443,
0.0131620914,
-0.0309053473,
-0.0215497781,
0.0542373285,
0.045622196,
-0.0253359843,
0.0565012172,
-0.0239589252,
-0.0121145928,
0.0266408697,
0.0242999215,
-0.0422645658,
0.0049807276,
-0.065749146,
-0.0066001071,
-0.0445596352,
-0.027900517,
-0.0456459969,
-0.0267028715,
0.0189457685,
-0.0071621267,
-0.0684638619,
-0.084765926,
-0.0032203733,
0.0017218813,
0.0750838518,
-0.0297333393,
-0.0119342916,
-0.0455196723,
0.0002340881,
0.006282968,
-0.0178940687,
-0.0175857246,
0.0080511468,
-0.0118567152,
0.0093003996,
0.0185465701,
-0.0005293438,
0.0067569278,
0.0236718878,
-0.0305892453,
-0.0076418468,
0.0529907122,
-0.022135254,
0.0061576399,
0.0165214241,
0.0228169747,
0.0348002501,
0.0410610028,
-0.0003995706,
-0.0152881173,
-0.0139810285,
0.0415846445,
0.0180294812,
0.0146569461,
0.0024804275,
0.0117684342,
0.0360440388,
-0.0825270861,
-0.0223251507,
-0.0259998851,
-0.0198203214,
0.0077880793,
0.0066642938,
0.0422282144,
-0.0331083648,
0.0374210067,
-0.0661455765,
0.0591767356,
0.0316502899,
0.0084475838,
-0.0646451488,
-0.0294461362,
0.0591006093,
-0.0720599219,
-0.0290927682,
-0.0024735117,
-0.0549812913,
-0.0569156148,
0.0436645783,
-0.0548741743,
0.0118905054,
0.0400751084,
-0.0006780287,
-0.0431095958,
0.0643593669,
0.0004935925,
-0.0594272539,
0.0362603106,
0.0092220325,
0.0200105328,
-0.0472220033,
0.0007142108,
-0.0457552746,
0.0682680309,
-0.0074259718,
-0.0210204497,
-0.0356874987,
-0.0432521664,
-0.0405051187,
0.0132183954,
0.0863334239,
-0.0117515689,
0.0087055238,
-0.0675445795,
0.0160238966,
0.0539981388,
0.0333323441,
-0.0176536646,
0.0062192222,
0.0142780412,
0.0400260352,
-0.0500998721,
-0.0005799211,
-0.0748026893,
0.0064098001,
0.0090696057,
0.0689267516,
0.0481118448,
-0.0140914526,
-0.0120464135,
-0.0076851593,
0.0167798437,
0.0671521053,
0.0364458486,
0.011179883,
0.0118322428,
0.0630088821,
-0.0285300203,
-0.0387218408,
0.0003761225,
-0.00332706,
-0.0449599177,
0.0085803876,
-0.0000397171,
0.0200704392,
0.0419609137,
-0.0382192843,
0.0014382447,
0.0287716407,
0.0282988232,
-0.0467300303,
0.0752915218,
-0.0143558001,
-0.0356971808,
0.0146658216,
-0.0120456051,
-0.0487663075,
0.075136818,
0.0244435724,
-0.0029747486,
-0.004764969,
-0.0099643962,
0.0335234813,
-0.0494117402,
0.0015285662,
0.0273534823,
0.0117217302,
-0.0526449718,
-0.0074394853,
-0.0238895137,
-0.0278406236,
0.0582373552,
-0.0518823117,
0.0106919138,
-0.0205250885,
0.000620312,
0.0192001015,
-0.0303848945,
0.0276938248,
-0.0236645993,
-0.0365537591,
-0.0247389134,
0.0096397353,
-0.0513558984,
-5.362742614e-33,
-0.0127745392,
-0.0023184563,
-0.0585562438,
0.0276667029,
0.0040531042,
0.026743114,
0.0087153772,
0.0444598347,
0.0618231893,
-0.0215788856,
-0.0119648129,
0.0024258418,
0.0295961071,
-0.0246049911,
-0.0060879812,
-0.0278644022,
0.0733771697,
-0.0277495831,
-0.0057013487,
0.023207739,
0.0505284965,
0.0495860167,
0.0037117798,
-0.0894411802,
-0.0337466151,
-0.0274927597,
0.0200882144,
-0.0137603935,
0.0950563699,
0.0233136155,
-0.0191044956,
0.0527922884,
-0.003346242,
-0.0408078097,
0.0018879328,
0.0503680296,
-0.0516201779,
-0.0062345294,
-0.0440491214,
0.0635164604,
0.0187262036,
-0.0411205478,
0.0062169805,
-0.0170876868,
-0.0178321432,
0.0048008268,
0.0542277992,
-0.0014896567,
-0.0103478897,
-0.0656774417,
-0.0232795682,
0.050646659,
-0.0187182426,
-0.0098084565,
0.0660017505,
0.0280877501,
0.026441548,
-0.0758614987,
0.0018762121,
0.0536147654,
-0.0188781507,
-0.0062208907,
0.0232301354,
0.0056580626,
-0.0318358429,
0.02533965,
0.0542359203,
-0.0672392175,
-0.0045576622,
-0.0418363959,
0.0174378268,
0.0037385758,
0.0375452116,
-0.0067322352,
0.0030520479,
0.0070341476,
-0.0425950177,
-0.0170767996,
0.0370304398,
-0.0202323198,
-0.0142379133,
-0.0056646275,
-0.0700843558,
-0.0038141359,
-0.075872615,
-0.0291998144,
-0.0154455416,
0.0019629323,
0.0663203672,
0.0177082941,
0.0230537113,
0.0079506338,
0.0802360252,
0.0155709796,
0.0367321074,
0.0296926536,
-0.0140868155,
0.0406873189,
-0.0091047743,
-0.0014657601,
-0.0579602644,
-0.0177192781,
0.0685252473,
0.0111223394,
0.0431625284,
-0.0340109393,
-0.0489340015,
0.0723618791,
-0.0526141226,
0.0134498887,
0.0499700122,
0.0126016242,
-0.0007901996,
0.0508651435,
0.0580675453,
0.0075175022,
-0.0226677172,
0.0511380658,
-0.0129099172,
0.0680891946,
-0.0241549034,
-0.0567028411,
-0.0426301546,
0.0283552296,
-0.0434072688,
0.0267973281,
0.0013795054,
-0.0021055522,
-0.0110674072,
0.0063072862,
0.0252336487,
0.0026640904,
2.336e-7,
-0.0524488986,
0.0030521816,
0.0057830946,
-0.0940278545,
0.0042566904,
0.0146900304,
-0.0207129158,
-0.0241345502,
-0.0339629129,
0.0424440689,
0.0315162279,
-0.0368201211,
0.0781165361,
0.0269984752,
-0.1117963716,
-0.0005737047,
-0.0442657769,
0.0440199487,
-0.0604363978,
-0.0003077888,
0.0157542992,
0.0869302377,
-0.0063573113,
-0.0115876505,
-0.0030799194,
-0.0437278934,
0.0358589403,
0.0142764598,
-0.0383084267,
-0.012623678,
0.0428400636,
-0.0056348071,
-0.0441428721,
-0.0191104598,
-0.0277364738,
0.0645029172,
0.0294774082,
0.0696210116,
0.0001178208,
-0.0446859002,
0.0101440763,
0.0620996356,
-0.0380079895,
0.04535098,
0.070357725,
0.0042255479,
-0.0253616292,
-0.0507378541,
-0.0365489684,
0.0303374119,
0.0190811362,
0.0228100158,
0.0071102185,
0.0135842599,
-0.0170169864,
-0.0435718745,
-0.0006347052,
-0.0393881463,
-0.0219964311,
0.0206395779,
-0.0406585336,
0.0157170128,
-0.0321646221,
0.0075396448,
0.0469314456,
-0.0308805723,
0.0144178122,
1.439312936e-34,
0.0196074322,
-0.0360426418,
-0.0953663662,
-0.0193537008,
-0.023925446,
-0.0358361341,
0.0058888071,
0.0285347514,
0.0152758928,
0.0099218553,
0.0175567158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11795v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11795v1 | Prompting Large Language Models with Speech Recognition Abilities | 2023-07-21T08:39:15 | 2023-07-21T08:39:15 | Yassir Fathullah, Chunyang Wu, Egor Lakomkin, Junteng Jia, Yuan Shangguan, Ke Li, Jinxi Guo, Wenhan Xiong, Jay Mahadeokar, Ozlem Kalinli, Christian Fuegen, Mike Seltzer | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models have proven themselves highly flexible, able to solve a
wide range of generative tasks, such as abstractive summarization and
open-ended question answering. In this paper we extend the capabilities of LLMs
by directly attaching a small audio encoder allowing it to perform speech
recognition. By directly prepending a sequence of audial embeddings to the text
token embeddings, the LLM can be converted to an automatic speech recognition
(ASR) system, and be used in the exact same manner as its textual counterpart.
Experiments on Multilingual LibriSpeech (MLS) show that incorporating a
conformer encoder into the open sourced LLaMA-7B allows it to outperform
monolingual baselines by 18% and perform multilingual speech recognition
despite LLaMA being trained overwhelmingly on English text. Furthermore, we
perform ablation studies to investigate whether the LLM can be completely
frozen during training to maintain its original capabilities, scaling up the
audio encoder, and increasing the audio encoder striding to generate fewer
embeddings. The results from these studies show that multilingual ASR is
possible even when the LLM is frozen or when strides of almost 1 second are
used in the audio encoder opening up the possibility for LLMs to operate on
long-form audio. | [
-0.0182870049,
0.031444218,
0.0080361152,
0.0707081258,
-0.0045932974,
-0.0055863899,
0.0248077083,
-0.030462591,
-0.0044971667,
-0.0365571156,
-0.0448573641,
-0.0251746383,
0.0119913742,
0.0245959833,
0.0451693572,
-0.029995665,
0.0215287786,
-0.0956531689,
-0.0195558593,
-0.0349006392,
-0.0025038479,
0.0159624256,
-0.0088027772,
0.0345863998,
0.0143156908,
0.0242224876,
-0.0174054671,
0.002588344,
0.0168125741,
-0.0012663582,
-0.0534318089,
-0.009885394,
0.0666809306,
0.0156301521,
0.0000019114,
-0.0536049604,
0.012697421,
-0.0035905009,
-0.0213223603,
0.0204781275,
0.012745766,
-0.0160886031,
-0.0236241929,
0.0414849073,
0.0019819837,
0.0036408918,
0.0234975945,
0.0064682267,
0.0405964106,
0.0565991774,
-0.005383302,
-0.0743261725,
0.0513719879,
-0.0043910723,
-0.0332039259,
-0.0211304184,
-0.0179001074,
-0.0256570727,
0.042251315,
-0.0014901416,
-0.0287253782,
0.0807223618,
0.0411133245,
-0.0120336451,
-0.0144359702,
0.0327685289,
-0.026002951,
-0.0307090078,
-0.0319902115,
0.0596674532,
0.0038891106,
-0.0301680807,
0.0005052178,
0.0207478777,
-0.0142261861,
-0.0402488448,
-0.034866441,
0.0510954596,
0.0304756034,
0.0369453207,
0.0216770228,
-0.0009737661,
0.0404118374,
-0.0117307119,
-0.0203398447,
0.0164224636,
0.0152665637,
-0.0291742925,
0.0156972203,
-0.013318141,
0.0130231725,
-0.0509795025,
0.0123527367,
0.0623203665,
-0.0024198298,
0.0169308968,
-0.0406621024,
0.0010294113,
0.0081487745,
-0.0396469645,
0.0049070991,
0.0564128123,
-0.0593433045,
0.0629324242,
-0.056582965,
0.0686485916,
-0.0046159374,
0.0198908374,
-0.0593876913,
-0.0327582136,
0.0163989551,
-0.0177270342,
-0.0335681066,
0.0234902278,
-0.0400603153,
-0.0418651551,
-0.0246558804,
0.0283944588,
0.0325505547,
0.0194021929,
-0.0149612613,
-0.0160659254,
0.0169594083,
-0.0263993889,
-0.0015596269,
0.0240806788,
-0.0123055354,
0.0355959795,
-0.00439189,
-0.0550248697,
-0.0089590391,
0.0286853313,
0.013291223,
-0.0000148431,
0.0318729542,
0.0827250332,
-0.0155754918,
-0.0464334041,
-0.0337498114,
0.0342612304,
-0.003297542,
-0.0509203002,
0.0179540161,
-0.0757454857,
0.0407150462,
0.0033912654,
0.0038541858,
-0.0150547456,
0.0249162279,
-0.005712715,
0.0243525878,
0.0914211348,
-0.0066242996,
0.0242984071,
0.0487634093,
-0.0137802381,
0.0285729747,
0.0853135586,
0.0809440762,
-0.0116553167,
0.0408329703,
-0.0328463949,
-0.0283413548,
0.0830487385,
-0.0151740862,
0.0041571744,
-0.0173751377,
-0.0088463919,
-0.0126950471,
0.0255043767,
0.0428068303,
0.0814804733,
-0.0214117877,
-0.0044010566,
0.0569288656,
0.0983281881,
-0.0283425394,
0.0047018882,
0.0116190454,
-0.0399110205,
0.0154255629,
0.0171547532,
-0.0179292262,
0.0387111939,
-0.012105125,
0.033380311,
0.0657734126,
0.0479816981,
-0.0454198532,
-0.0391472466,
-0.034262564,
-0.0341998264,
0.0010550069,
0.029383475,
0.032673046,
0.0082362387,
-0.0533366874,
0.063833341,
-0.0124554634,
-0.067668885,
0.026187513,
-0.0657571852,
0.0340314656,
0.0588370003,
0.0442437232,
-0.0338030122,
-0.006281876,
-0.0303341504,
-0.0005916092,
0.082815282,
0.0442129411,
-0.0196639728,
0.0182565711,
-0.0728053153,
-0.0108987037,
0.0183716062,
-0.0315811001,
0.0500508808,
-0.0040300181,
0.0414807647,
0.0019113313,
-0.0195030738,
0.024573084,
0.0026737836,
-0.0520756766,
-0.0293149892,
0.0339130647,
0.0051793014,
0.0505730174,
0.0373879299,
-0.0165502559,
-0.0073010726,
0.0638284832,
-0.0974170417,
-0.0112975566,
0.0281964615,
-0.0559465215,
-0.0050832038,
0.0438638479,
0.0001174916,
0.0160022192,
0.0110507291,
0.0016617853,
-0.0853222013,
0.0219885521,
-0.0419632308,
0.0789445266,
-0.0578624234,
0.0275873933,
0.014680637,
0.0228876993,
-0.0098272655,
-0.0014482808,
0.002617649,
-0.0095680058,
0.0137176523,
-0.0004843492,
0.0026001283,
-0.0463817529,
-0.067670539,
0.0691098124,
0.0089887623,
0.0160442479,
-0.0185614601,
-0.001278457,
0.0028416831,
-0.0561413914,
-0.0795230642,
-0.0163655337,
-0.025238324,
0.0306879804,
0.004058612,
0.030285053,
-0.0002313326,
-0.0135388048,
-0.0468782932,
-0.0245212503,
0.0339429602,
0.0006393922,
-0.0014769459,
-0.0157014746,
-0.0401231982,
-0.0327166133,
-0.0194067173,
0.0505729839,
0.0152217504,
-0.0231534913,
-0.0242053401,
-0.0750379786,
-0.0204660278,
-0.0139996745,
0.0333328359,
-0.0118939225,
-0.0294435844,
0.0038193041,
0.002384207,
0.0709297135,
0.0577251799,
-0.0095502837,
-0.0059695025,
0.0693420842,
0.0169249736,
-0.0415941924,
0.0163406078,
0.0188743044,
-0.0010140799,
-0.0557883531,
0.0179378595,
-0.0231631007,
0.0143919699,
0.0138952984,
0.0232715607,
-0.0183110107,
-0.0411598794,
-0.013758081,
-0.038381692,
-0.0401314832,
-0.0541317537,
-0.0504715629,
0.0478247404,
0.0030041579,
-0.0431022719,
0.0363766663,
-0.082444407,
-0.0314138234,
-0.0158268809,
-0.035895396,
-0.0541606918,
0.0442948677,
-0.0056195846,
0.0225402527,
-0.0167738125,
-0.03146201,
-0.0059720119,
-0.0022058436,
-0.0200049784,
-0.059532553,
0.0606979467,
-0.0247781817,
0.0204945039,
-0.0151151232,
-0.0501626991,
-0.0356987379,
0.0169005357,
-0.0490839332,
0.0310966913,
-0.0071699773,
0.005846533,
-0.0352663212,
0.0444845408,
0.0541281328,
0.0514858626,
-0.0044354824,
0.0326657444,
-0.0502883717,
0.0576332919,
0.0221724585,
0.0547903813,
0.0064814771,
-0.0384550057,
0.0608150922,
0.0026434409,
0.025606703,
-0.0369584635,
-0.0384837613,
0.0095768729,
0.0642937794,
-0.0057046656,
-0.013478457,
0.010396135,
0.056760896,
-0.0326220579,
-0.0101848301,
0.1088245735,
0.0195558444,
-0.0152033335,
-0.0218859948,
-0.0221974347,
0.0429915525,
0.0094167273,
0.017779354,
-0.0686395094,
-0.0279360935,
0.0545041785,
0.0320576876,
0.029065704,
0.0682218522,
-0.0101481006,
-0.1148424819,
0.0395973064,
0.0150153702,
-0.0489606373,
-0.0458194166,
-0.0351202562,
-0.0372304879,
0.000579041,
0.056609083,
0.0271023139,
-0.0121049006,
-0.0427320637,
0.002837562,
-0.044603318,
-0.0161234196,
-0.0014345144,
0.0005253818,
0.0677841157,
0.077029258,
0.027181318,
-0.0348188914,
-0.0446863733,
0.0606793873,
-0.0174023919,
0.0037681628,
-0.0006698283,
0.0101077789,
0.0270762667,
-0.0161722023,
0.034368407,
0.0256494321,
-0.0204592235,
0.0010256664,
0.0078085084,
0.0663259253,
-0.0174412839,
0.0060716756,
0.0091858096,
0.0082423138,
-0.0564879663,
0.0636731535,
0.0253976956,
-0.0327254049,
-0.0309284162,
-0.0329561569,
-0.0277323313,
-0.0310697295,
-0.0081914756,
-0.0245658886,
-0.0049558398,
0.0056040715,
-0.0464746654,
-0.0035717681,
0.004837363,
0.0238364227,
0.0417534821,
0.0144959865,
0.0090203667,
0.0189733375,
-0.0285042357,
-0.0137113752,
-0.0193414986,
0.0390885137,
-0.0852688774,
0.0112707634,
0.0587648079,
-0.0633185655,
-0.0110966265,
0.041185271,
-0.0429711342,
-0.0803039148,
-0.0325813964,
0.0120032039,
0.0242397897,
0.0596770868,
-0.0196304079,
-0.0460993424,
0.0804232135,
-0.0043402822,
-0.0176170208,
0.0569898933,
0.0359148122,
0.0223472863,
-0.0122085921,
0.0288003087,
-0.0558961965,
0.0052376776,
-0.020747697,
0.0196590256,
-0.0059185978,
-0.0806366801,
-0.0308276229,
0.0516099706,
-0.017113924,
-0.0326379836,
0.0265636444,
-0.0345845558,
0.0520272367,
-0.0028463292,
0.0367496237,
-0.038768895,
0.0093250405,
0.004689659,
-0.0090650413,
0.0152025679,
0.0104527846,
-0.0019578272,
-0.0016304789,
0.0027686707,
0.0789379105,
0.0169797,
-0.0162624121,
0.0022448592,
0.0016338209,
-0.019313518,
0.0290313996,
0.0127531355,
0.0338486061,
-0.0318268687,
0.0057131061,
-0.0187725779,
-0.0020142146,
-0.0123797124,
0.0480498262,
-0.0671654269,
-0.0087874457,
-0.0175116751,
0.0688343793,
0.0573228896,
0.018358754,
0.0684443489,
0.0082964031,
-0.0033808015,
-0.0150681725,
0.0326367095,
-0.0175191835,
-0.0133278733,
0.032009244,
0.0122380657,
-0.0168381743,
0.0198645648,
0.0364861898,
-0.022697283,
0.035931278,
-0.0007742341,
0.0587549917,
-0.0502256565,
-0.0556075759,
0.0002129848,
0.0120137688,
-0.0265192464,
-0.008327961,
0.0062886057,
-0.0731740966,
0.0310927965,
-0.0034418975,
-0.0199681409,
-0.0504753105,
0.0109027671,
0.0023431778,
0.0181840062,
0.0106968582,
-0.0082813557,
-0.0338461921,
-0.0040597352,
-0.0354913399,
0.01743697,
-6.144228524e-33,
-0.0385148674,
0.0000357712,
0.0248954501,
-0.0086226538,
-0.0335998833,
0.0175848976,
-0.0385027751,
-0.0078498162,
-0.0004511165,
-0.0539779328,
-0.0308764298,
-0.0306170676,
0.0221729092,
0.031855654,
0.0049624573,
-0.0051704817,
0.0472723097,
-0.0331578664,
0.0145426802,
0.0060014194,
0.0377581231,
0.0196504015,
0.0148130339,
0.0046737618,
-0.0107600689,
-0.0103747416,
-0.0161585789,
-0.0199921764,
0.0018713042,
0.0617442727,
-0.0351396054,
0.0425051861,
-0.0080247829,
-0.0160553865,
-0.0212342609,
0.0312147439,
-0.0973050743,
0.016924344,
0.0330148973,
0.0221425071,
-0.0037955255,
-0.0365438312,
0.052120965,
0.0192168858,
-0.036412593,
0.0029291434,
0.0108579434,
-0.0366923362,
-0.0251326934,
-0.0397131853,
-0.0389567241,
0.0125755137,
0.0015178213,
-0.027374953,
0.0625389293,
0.0543794557,
-0.0239229333,
0.0093063945,
-0.0408911444,
0.0489017442,
0.0154979089,
0.0129995598,
0.0633656234,
0.0342716575,
-0.0191130973,
0.0378728546,
-0.0039122673,
-0.0888352618,
-0.0135519868,
-0.0026398511,
0.0200441815,
0.0059545939,
0.0273509398,
0.0205185451,
0.0105793197,
-0.0070161279,
-0.0341885164,
0.0116639407,
0.0198242255,
0.0040909424,
0.060409829,
0.0206964798,
-0.0260457471,
-0.0072644046,
-0.0553160049,
0.0021769095,
-0.0249711126,
-0.0167576931,
0.0558204614,
0.0189481117,
0.0230914764,
-0.05618947,
0.0537392311,
-0.0193872526,
0.0289281532,
0.0055998764,
0.0060984772,
0.018855555,
-0.0018513119,
0.0315148905,
-0.0407513268,
-0.0108182188,
0.0415775068,
-0.0254654624,
-0.0096561778,
-0.0021687811,
0.0067122183,
0.0509286709,
-0.0892407224,
0.0232235491,
-0.0015394245,
0.0093330676,
0.0277229473,
0.0402936116,
0.0058655115,
-0.0254068878,
-0.0024125632,
0.0370186828,
-0.0391062647,
-0.0004509238,
-0.0267066546,
-0.0097499704,
-0.0351476334,
0.0466262028,
-0.0711857751,
0.0300013814,
0.0025627622,
0.0380296521,
0.011281726,
-0.05379875,
-0.0066201161,
0.0025000426,
2.728e-7,
0.0019860675,
0.0089710504,
0.0341456495,
0.0052003725,
0.0272593852,
-0.0001353703,
-0.0430610329,
0.0161331445,
0.0198628101,
0.0002340856,
0.0048583797,
0.0273430608,
0.0704480186,
0.0422643535,
-0.1314070523,
0.0062999837,
-0.061405655,
0.0237195604,
-0.0283954665,
-0.0213350896,
0.0339196585,
0.1227321774,
-0.0249775648,
-0.035832677,
-0.0277186502,
-0.0496484824,
0.0494000241,
-0.0253389627,
-0.0258044824,
-0.0485310331,
0.0122388294,
0.0051900852,
-0.0343789905,
-0.0192377344,
-0.0230742749,
0.0291463733,
0.0326633304,
0.0609231107,
0.0105814226,
-0.0956452787,
0.0158260632,
0.0344347768,
-0.0344911925,
-0.0157748777,
0.0826866627,
0.0164097417,
-0.0247270372,
-0.0372391082,
-0.0234755781,
-0.021455463,
0.0053420197,
-0.0272822231,
0.0053511839,
0.0101939309,
0.0119335372,
-0.0431557,
-0.013714225,
-0.062026035,
-0.0106476303,
-0.0239184033,
-0.0484456941,
-0.0312876068,
-0.0352697447,
0.0056379857,
-0.0136205349,
-0.0489699915,
-0.0145754488,
2.371766023e-34,
0.0511376373,
-0.0393567383,
0.0113570588,
0.0583714508,
-0.0098264283,
-0.02586863,
0.0026620044,
-0.0071313321,
0.0078828242,
-0.1015787572,
-0.0322107449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11394v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11394v3 | MeetEval: A Toolkit for Computation of Word Error Rates for Meeting Transcription Systems | 2023-07-21T07:22:18 | 2024-01-25T19:48:36 | Thilo von Neumann, Christoph Boeddeker, Marc Delcroix, Reinhold Haeb-Umbach | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | MeetEval is an open-source toolkit to evaluate all kinds of meeting
transcription systems. It provides a unified interface for the computation of
commonly used Word Error Rates (WERs), specifically cpWER, ORC-WER and MIMO-WER
along other WER definitions. We extend the cpWER computation by a temporal
constraint to ensure that only words are identified as correct when the
temporal alignment is plausible. This leads to a better quality of the matching
of the hypothesis string to the reference string that more closely resembles
the actual transcription quality, and a system is penalized if it provides poor
time annotations. Since word-level timing information is often not available,
we present a way to approximate exact word-level timings from segment-level
timings (e.g., a sentence) and show that the approximation leads to a similar
WER as a matching with exact word-level annotations. At the same time, the time
constraint leads to a speedup of the matching algorithm, which outweighs the
additional overhead caused by processing the time stamps. | [
0.0084671555,
0.0488081053,
0.0263114721,
-0.0082980208,
-0.0576025695,
-0.004926614,
0.0020243002,
0.0022010389,
-0.034221746,
0.017988326,
-0.0219638366,
-0.0511612967,
0.0989781916,
0.0250959396,
0.0007478935,
-0.015431121,
0.0572181381,
0.0116821034,
0.0082467142,
0.0329331458,
0.0382590666,
0.0288107153,
-0.0769589022,
0.0457020923,
-0.0531220064,
-0.0194590501,
-0.0240618754,
0.0069743353,
0.019956043,
-0.0187112913,
-0.0076403716,
0.0287888702,
-0.0210079066,
0.0915316939,
0.0000019053,
-0.0437200107,
-0.0414695814,
0.0317819342,
-0.0389239639,
0.0349401198,
0.0304359291,
0.0443772674,
-0.0688382313,
0.0622555055,
-0.0028437676,
-0.0137990499,
0.0701100156,
-0.0421185866,
-0.0114565315,
0.0669542626,
-0.0235171355,
0.0466566123,
0.0025210506,
-0.0208886135,
-0.0014234975,
-0.0372592695,
-0.0132751623,
0.0034281216,
0.0268128682,
-0.0938858762,
0.0298733991,
0.025178792,
-0.0463257059,
-0.0534218177,
-0.0025774771,
-0.0033275117,
-0.0619409382,
-0.0400986411,
-0.0439357869,
0.0302544329,
0.0577442721,
-0.0165986344,
0.0124827111,
0.036431592,
-0.0191090554,
-0.0318263434,
-0.00200882,
-0.0530048609,
-0.0397060066,
-0.0168191101,
0.0016695688,
0.0450212993,
0.0082887458,
-0.0260631312,
0.0128466068,
0.0231559463,
0.0439968891,
-0.0498401411,
-0.0349147953,
-0.0012590085,
0.054616414,
-0.0286232494,
0.0661374703,
-0.0155525655,
-0.0053777886,
-0.0181073453,
-0.0395653918,
-0.0204096586,
0.0063361581,
-0.0346333906,
0.0051440885,
0.0662057623,
0.0184857193,
-0.0069204262,
0.0436014719,
0.0223804004,
0.0099761691,
-0.0424417704,
-0.0239827279,
0.0063526165,
0.0196038317,
0.0252821464,
-0.0093700504,
-0.0505118147,
-0.0336577743,
-0.013160293,
-0.0731531382,
0.0211889185,
-0.0002866704,
0.0474090725,
0.0129067581,
-0.0377944969,
-0.02076279,
-0.0052543702,
-0.0009047925,
0.0218200497,
0.0090102283,
0.0195433553,
-0.0293486062,
-0.0809006244,
-0.015632296,
0.0250104312,
0.0712802112,
0.0016422225,
-0.0105308304,
0.0359759443,
-0.0356218927,
-0.0135699417,
0.0396193154,
-0.0286536962,
-0.0584579967,
-0.0148085123,
-0.0619236156,
-0.0564672872,
0.0505925156,
-0.0037587304,
-0.0259619355,
0.0010610387,
-0.002571349,
-0.0037249448,
0.0253387745,
0.0601854213,
-0.0184248332,
0.0579753816,
0.0142169893,
-0.0147059737,
0.0009845787,
-0.019751817,
0.0524478368,
-0.0154797537,
0.0317959264,
-0.0272220671,
-0.000556461,
0.1081133932,
-0.0092978524,
-0.0121887578,
0.0228537843,
-0.000751006,
0.0555933267,
0.0467448756,
0.0248864386,
0.0516231768,
0.0234888606,
0.0279683359,
0.0260019619,
0.0600686707,
0.0627328008,
-0.0280811377,
-0.0015964152,
0.0214320049,
-0.0198348537,
-0.0042508841,
-0.0103286803,
-0.005374135,
-0.0093117133,
0.0063740253,
0.0936420262,
0.0235147346,
0.0101966197,
0.0142056309,
-0.0320910513,
0.0078542614,
-0.0422533192,
-0.0070834816,
0.0245898981,
-0.0398890078,
-0.0489141122,
0.0667605922,
0.0034393026,
-0.0529557653,
-0.0110379765,
-0.0233909693,
-0.0060787797,
0.057972528,
0.0716419518,
-0.0273563359,
0.0152967423,
-0.0160438269,
-0.045380827,
0.0741813481,
0.0836963132,
-0.022240866,
0.0135926967,
-0.0219493266,
0.0185536407,
0.1173439845,
0.0015712312,
0.0078310091,
0.0094593354,
0.0494041443,
0.0070186979,
-0.0260363575,
-0.0053395573,
0.0019328971,
0.0216271076,
-0.035166841,
-0.0604723655,
0.0107952012,
0.0824354514,
0.051786039,
-0.037382748,
0.0432045646,
0.007636243,
0.0071947514,
0.0446546488,
0.0707184598,
-0.0253088567,
-0.0469183438,
0.0523989908,
-0.0223479252,
-0.0483164527,
0.0291188322,
0.0195469521,
-0.0461272299,
-0.006590738,
-0.0331377685,
0.0316926874,
-0.0423822366,
0.0989574492,
0.0038510819,
-0.021754127,
0.0219010133,
-0.0081979353,
-0.0079692043,
0.0075840964,
-0.0038614648,
-0.036766652,
0.0194920804,
-0.0619534403,
-0.0021509663,
0.0270025432,
-0.0348672085,
-0.0047564423,
-0.0001709006,
-0.0053651384,
-0.0376058631,
-0.0536356419,
-0.093956396,
0.0116873067,
-0.001365858,
0.0530182794,
-0.0083684977,
0.0270521436,
-0.0034732549,
-0.0093896454,
-0.0189826284,
-0.0552129708,
0.022929512,
-0.0075036348,
-0.0294571444,
-0.0191388968,
-0.0698961988,
-0.0738045797,
0.0056313695,
-0.0364519022,
-0.0018409749,
0.021401817,
-0.0839892477,
-0.0521150678,
-0.0035524287,
-0.0180089548,
-0.0018826462,
0.0266864412,
-0.0216085706,
0.0243065041,
0.0136070941,
0.0381163657,
-0.0136478627,
-0.0027384723,
-0.015345877,
0.0057382258,
-0.0196035467,
-0.0381232798,
-0.008131193,
0.02998445,
0.036365021,
0.0068950453,
-0.056001991,
-0.0039399453,
0.0377456248,
0.0245476682,
0.0465466902,
-0.0535721108,
0.004222787,
0.0052675796,
-0.0466708019,
-0.0083466293,
-0.0296028964,
-0.0428274572,
0.0086658299,
-0.0322664417,
-0.0454355367,
0.0143151851,
-0.0693599805,
-0.0333257988,
-0.0212092306,
-0.0348787643,
-0.0090856506,
-0.0019743745,
-0.0721157491,
-0.0122412862,
-0.0164237358,
-0.0714179501,
-0.0028473164,
0.0185452569,
0.0268972646,
-0.0766312405,
-0.0067336494,
-0.0324425884,
0.0166593567,
-0.0169172622,
-0.0276855957,
-0.0125419414,
-0.009890765,
-0.0194643326,
-0.0118365772,
0.0116574587,
-0.0417540409,
-0.056703914,
0.0576017983,
-0.0236723404,
0.0373651795,
-0.0006432557,
0.0290216245,
-0.0251626894,
0.0362728126,
0.015996933,
0.0293108299,
0.0036473793,
-0.0282962117,
-0.0002686872,
-0.0115411347,
0.0617381595,
0.0194873642,
0.0108376052,
-0.0241137166,
0.0205840766,
-0.0001626006,
0.0007169301,
0.0215746481,
0.040259432,
-0.0047266232,
0.031052269,
0.1135185584,
0.0074081374,
-0.0288151875,
-0.0323293991,
-0.0518468842,
0.0370402373,
-0.017847985,
0.0209589843,
-0.0622896403,
-0.0066351779,
0.0525435023,
0.0696915463,
0.023528818,
0.031728413,
-0.0336843058,
-0.0528033562,
0.0146377804,
0.0485942028,
-0.0476063639,
-0.0302227065,
-0.0282589197,
-0.0212680865,
-0.0224019978,
0.0435110703,
0.0487262309,
-0.0080433944,
-0.0143489111,
0.014310292,
-0.0811246186,
-0.0230671316,
0.0452586561,
-0.0272511803,
0.0847854987,
0.0554335229,
0.0585780032,
0.0193634331,
-0.0484862216,
-0.0145597756,
0.0085081235,
-0.0146047715,
-0.0141069815,
0.0116392998,
-0.0024531265,
-0.0003836529,
-0.0134131229,
0.0286814161,
0.0136129046,
0.0101227462,
0.0058074975,
0.0450132005,
-0.0190971121,
0.0499862619,
0.0113621429,
0.0420943387,
0.0242671985,
0.0457019731,
0.013563565,
-0.0273119882,
-0.0242498629,
0.0388726816,
0.0435755476,
-0.0693832934,
-0.0016639407,
-0.0091370987,
-0.0149032157,
-0.0388831086,
-0.0453905463,
-0.0289192181,
-0.0112789553,
0.0413901061,
0.0161235295,
-0.0066087251,
-0.0157918092,
0.0401097424,
-0.0514698364,
0.0233707801,
0.0032602886,
0.0498358645,
-0.1047305763,
-0.0066653877,
-0.0386336595,
0.0253820568,
-0.0050289151,
0.0540014245,
-0.0324987136,
-0.0603817813,
0.0375899896,
-0.0359634422,
0.0287508648,
0.0397845134,
-0.0138774198,
0.0103840157,
-0.0380462743,
-0.0175249912,
0.0267249793,
0.0368005224,
-0.0113172419,
-0.0291150901,
-0.0213441458,
0.0186457857,
-0.0398576483,
-0.0118762441,
-0.0713940933,
0.0303485096,
-0.0005790194,
-0.0989486575,
0.0072209784,
0.0383469798,
0.0327407941,
-0.0154040875,
0.0000818769,
-0.0294233914,
0.0071322881,
0.0015069663,
0.0256496202,
-0.015493229,
-0.0439345203,
-0.0395200811,
0.000447334,
-0.0174692068,
0.0329368412,
-0.0822713822,
-0.0286462363,
-0.0366594531,
0.0324145928,
-0.0180564113,
-0.0146593843,
0.0216585845,
-0.012927467,
-0.0006766198,
0.0479559153,
-0.0079789301,
0.018436119,
-0.0158165935,
-0.0059578773,
-0.0210443735,
0.0259595104,
0.0331849456,
0.0087637082,
-0.0077057215,
0.0326476544,
-0.0226795562,
-0.0023104756,
0.0731405914,
-0.0128640058,
0.0689425245,
-0.0073303194,
0.0169435721,
-0.0392234139,
0.0492637008,
-0.0156722497,
0.0223330185,
-0.0301858671,
-0.0019930936,
-0.0146154603,
0.0216105692,
0.0241309498,
-0.0147260251,
0.0183752812,
-0.0331065953,
-0.0472852997,
-0.0302283093,
-0.0281039011,
-0.0202481877,
-0.0491175577,
-0.0426033288,
-0.0531321391,
-0.0474907942,
-0.0301116314,
0.0741105825,
0.0358162001,
-0.0104883816,
0.0011374579,
-0.0096038831,
0.0195888914,
-0.0120942211,
0.0045586894,
0.0130603928,
-0.0113528008,
0.0026240549,
-0.0362694673,
0.0038340036,
-6.371692926e-33,
-0.0397042073,
-0.0361607783,
0.0030872305,
0.012160955,
-0.0569279157,
0.0292715169,
-0.0311485194,
0.0145619325,
0.0106889307,
-0.0161898285,
-0.0084692826,
0.0200234428,
0.0470463261,
-0.0454410873,
-0.002299706,
0.0598672144,
0.0754109919,
0.0015040593,
-0.0384427235,
-0.0335080549,
0.0691667572,
0.0182314944,
0.0166277457,
-0.0610113852,
0.0296990722,
0.0132900691,
-0.023969762,
0.0035734223,
0.0490513705,
0.0201382004,
0.0294634886,
-0.0105561214,
-0.037642885,
0.0343400091,
-0.0100882333,
0.0454205833,
-0.0994796604,
0.0169952549,
0.0181420743,
0.0552414171,
0.0531672798,
-0.0020129338,
-0.0140099861,
-0.0031799695,
-0.078784436,
0.0038749636,
0.0049343682,
0.0045009842,
-0.0441943556,
-0.0090033272,
-0.0314064212,
0.0530907921,
0.0023099112,
-0.0390172713,
0.0487466156,
0.0266784634,
0.0228832029,
-0.0666726977,
-0.0390806198,
0.038809903,
0.0059632543,
0.0410625152,
0.0383887477,
-0.0040435484,
-0.0309455171,
0.0418231152,
0.019879194,
-0.0334849767,
0.0304396935,
-0.0340799242,
0.0042359098,
-0.0129194027,
0.0247445833,
0.0133361639,
0.0325569324,
-0.0179070756,
-0.0175031703,
0.0598916411,
0.0116533879,
-0.0208756775,
0.0178793259,
0.0477162786,
-0.0649086088,
0.0236847699,
-0.0330898054,
0.0609211214,
-0.023601681,
0.0017259524,
0.0279886462,
0.0030310557,
0.0204811413,
0.0085331984,
0.0488442853,
0.0165855102,
0.0420698114,
-0.0199836213,
-0.001722189,
-0.0255150404,
-0.0611909814,
0.0126261842,
-0.0402187854,
-0.0024177742,
0.0596663579,
0.0229150802,
0.063523829,
-0.0314379036,
-0.0314675383,
0.0484121256,
-0.0684835911,
0.011535041,
0.0089832461,
0.013929802,
-0.0431004651,
-0.0654114783,
0.0552538224,
-0.0335473828,
0.0077276202,
0.011927383,
0.0049737077,
0.0416143239,
0.0043296339,
-0.0095726624,
-0.0011511998,
0.033162903,
-0.0646115988,
0.0452420935,
-0.0072325356,
0.0129880728,
0.0144703528,
0.0220991205,
-0.0052375095,
-0.0204278417,
2.664e-7,
0.0182004105,
0.0555023588,
0.0702509955,
0.0264347754,
0.0143176122,
-0.0224183165,
-0.0264433045,
0.0391828008,
-0.0329145454,
0.0582696013,
0.0513998196,
-0.0513186939,
0.1345302761,
0.0235418864,
-0.0263405256,
-0.0233637672,
-0.1223274246,
0.0171678122,
-0.0422523059,
0.0009036057,
0.0089067379,
0.036712084,
-0.0249966066,
-0.0203445181,
-0.0021570374,
-0.03491484,
0.015240523,
0.0053850389,
-0.0359812491,
-0.0053304955,
0.0215671565,
-0.0420366414,
-0.0095005799,
0.0076623182,
-0.0493508875,
0.0183961429,
0.0279438961,
0.0390848853,
-0.0343890265,
-0.0285305772,
0.0119898319,
0.0012507151,
-0.0369400531,
0.0338039957,
0.0121495957,
0.0621789172,
-0.024310885,
-0.0149828587,
-0.0060691088,
0.004886019,
-0.0064598913,
0.0251810998,
0.0064740907,
0.0080445092,
0.0144529585,
0.0055035097,
-0.0307884496,
-0.0047511072,
-0.0253369305,
0.0262727439,
-0.0198704507,
-0.0712879822,
0.0018660538,
-0.0009481274,
0.0024737772,
-0.0239131693,
-0.0179697908,
2.258481199e-34,
0.0470424965,
-0.0005743422,
-0.0279110018,
0.0172513891,
0.0520084798,
-0.0322852209,
0.0694059581,
0.0142411804,
0.0221978705,
-0.0292816795,
-0.0347155072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11380v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11380v2 | Is ChatGPT Involved in Texts? Measure the Polish Ratio to Detect ChatGPT-Generated Text | 2023-07-21T06:38:37 | 2023-12-30T13:17:52 | Lingyi Yang, Feng Jiang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The remarkable capabilities of large-scale language models, such as ChatGPT,
in text generation have impressed readers and spurred researchers to devise
detectors to mitigate potential risks, including misinformation, phishing, and
academic dishonesty. Despite this, most previous studies have been
predominantly geared towards creating detectors that differentiate between
purely ChatGPT-generated texts and human-authored texts. This approach,
however, fails to work on discerning texts generated through human-machine
collaboration, such as ChatGPT-polished texts. Addressing this gap, we
introduce a novel dataset termed HPPT (ChatGPT-polished academic abstracts),
facilitating the construction of more robust detectors. It diverges from extant
corpora by comprising pairs of human-written and ChatGPT-polished abstracts
instead of purely ChatGPT-generated texts. Additionally, we propose the "Polish
Ratio" method, an innovative measure of the degree of modification made by
ChatGPT compared to the original human-written text. It provides a mechanism to
measure the degree of ChatGPT influence in the resulting text. Our experimental
results show our proposed model has better robustness on the HPPT dataset and
two existing datasets (HC3 and CDB). Furthermore, the "Polish Ratio" we
proposed offers a more comprehensive explanation by quantifying the degree of
ChatGPT involvement. | [
0.0703270361,
0.0353555009,
-0.0264138486,
0.0465133227,
-0.0830950886,
0.0067770062,
0.0170242675,
0.0345133282,
0.0263120942,
-0.0292381644,
-0.0023824412,
-0.0433434471,
0.0121394731,
0.0464207679,
0.0459517203,
-0.02638603,
0.0290893707,
0.0237758067,
0.0186559223,
0.0156523716,
0.0512569062,
0.0222805701,
0.0431342348,
0.0458002351,
0.0099234525,
-0.0388199165,
-0.0004640917,
0.0127085978,
0.0239062607,
0.0320214257,
0.0300537497,
0.0814796835,
-0.0281665735,
0.0933976322,
0.0000018407,
-0.0493028797,
-0.0297334362,
0.0077062063,
0.0193426311,
0.0321536884,
0.0889673904,
-0.003133706,
-0.0327407084,
0.0243391991,
-0.0458035581,
0.0424519479,
0.0331846364,
0.0400368758,
0.0295907464,
0.0882240683,
-0.0227349531,
0.0208955221,
0.0541624464,
0.0157560203,
0.0165152401,
0.0340561904,
0.0287395045,
-0.0093602585,
-0.0256735347,
0.0718573406,
0.0304357987,
0.0131340129,
-0.0162986759,
-0.0604227595,
-0.0021950027,
0.0064857202,
-0.0463771597,
-0.0278771166,
0.0033063511,
-0.0012044484,
-0.0203135535,
-0.0621219613,
0.0579432361,
-0.0059139649,
0.0115599325,
0.0470318161,
-0.0152776558,
0.0384335332,
-0.056511946,
-0.0022337823,
0.0180932209,
-0.0012684311,
0.0059384285,
0.0468471348,
0.0487265401,
0.0356432311,
0.0187225547,
-0.027761668,
-0.0139429076,
0.0038559593,
0.0082627339,
-0.0706067011,
0.047106605,
0.0146825146,
0.0130110038,
-0.0082169361,
-0.0570364296,
-0.054861296,
0.0373539142,
-0.0640652031,
-0.0459002517,
0.0392634757,
-0.0115544517,
0.0161092058,
-0.0277379546,
0.0236093067,
0.0073127928,
0.0180944148,
-0.0268883631,
0.0225279536,
-0.0190917887,
-0.0100495983,
-0.0282326341,
-0.0180779863,
-0.008108045,
-0.0075216652,
-0.0735795721,
0.0270310715,
0.0276904684,
0.0065026581,
-0.0020908683,
-0.0065822299,
-0.0470218323,
0.0008246939,
0.0431649834,
0.0069409851,
0.0010373313,
-0.0091196438,
0.0041415403,
-0.0533975884,
0.0023637109,
0.0508201048,
0.0047984347,
-0.0241251085,
-0.0107077686,
0.0584154911,
-0.013838714,
-0.0145328604,
0.0138906846,
-0.0881461129,
-0.0378519818,
-0.0448306091,
-0.0000969404,
-0.0563222989,
0.0039699129,
0.0073217754,
-0.0184775442,
-0.0342161432,
-0.0046627861,
0.054440815,
-0.0574036874,
0.0251618046,
-0.0516867824,
0.0095352549,
0.0455968827,
0.0032905531,
-0.0606728271,
0.0174948238,
0.0137126278,
0.0608970672,
0.0712496266,
-0.0063760504,
0.0157924313,
0.0523058586,
0.0139492517,
0.024084283,
0.0581995808,
-0.0414408185,
0.0003849491,
-0.0113660013,
0.0188243631,
0.0789902881,
-0.0307305306,
-0.0368838012,
0.0873144343,
0.0459067747,
-0.0032770669,
0.0331385769,
0.0223920159,
0.0502335019,
0.0321765468,
0.0690021291,
-0.0031411266,
-0.0313166939,
-0.0691913366,
0.0000216899,
0.0307148788,
0.0251369942,
0.0229275618,
0.0036079849,
-0.0092152087,
0.0044337166,
0.0156299174,
-0.0628671348,
0.0148042841,
0.003377208,
-0.0385990664,
-0.0241397303,
0.027739184,
-0.064697586,
0.0321266018,
-0.0519934334,
0.0309764724,
0.0623491332,
0.0759394318,
-0.0023311444,
0.0422663055,
-0.034748096,
0.0066403397,
0.0558084287,
-0.0048096906,
-0.0039232504,
-0.0395531654,
-0.0270464867,
-0.0087826354,
-0.0011809982,
0.0109059233,
0.0230415165,
0.0354510918,
0.0187492333,
0.0240206122,
-0.0017684236,
-0.0370965078,
0.0209986996,
-0.0195995718,
0.0285603963,
-0.0163036827,
-0.0225826632,
0.0195349921,
0.0200400129,
-0.0235551056,
0.0230404027,
0.0035009205,
-0.0075601996,
-0.0182449594,
0.030776158,
0.0209904499,
-0.023742985,
0.0345240273,
-0.0496239327,
-0.0167965777,
-0.0113399895,
0.0005345483,
-0.0099657346,
0.0142182624,
-0.052267924,
0.0114455661,
-0.0615322441,
-0.0022764883,
-0.0088217659,
0.0243137963,
-0.0281794611,
0.0615725182,
-0.0055366964,
0.0179053545,
0.0350340195,
-0.0165977683,
0.0380138718,
-0.0156456474,
0.002993589,
-0.018767843,
-0.0070608179,
0.0074909688,
0.0612877533,
0.0188017208,
-0.0338328183,
-0.0340039767,
-0.0670137852,
-0.0103194686,
-0.0209974833,
0.0340289064,
0.0615242012,
-0.0258721784,
-0.0068202545,
0.0325129516,
-0.042787496,
-0.0157559253,
0.025807688,
0.0169156305,
0.0560848415,
-0.037126869,
0.0366652906,
-0.0191692337,
0.018045187,
-0.0155918226,
0.0160416756,
0.0744261965,
-0.0687040836,
-0.0627739131,
0.0489028357,
-0.0020460275,
-0.0451780967,
0.0018227164,
-0.0648248717,
-0.011655461,
-0.0078355903,
0.037631534,
0.0290324185,
0.0367709622,
-0.0048816861,
-0.0006242098,
0.0022922882,
-0.0101669068,
-0.0560899004,
-0.0492134728,
0.0293267872,
0.016420858,
-0.0861466303,
0.0403059348,
0.0308573823,
0.0088692158,
-0.0187495369,
-0.043847926,
0.0276099797,
-0.0377624817,
-0.017903747,
-0.0064448337,
-0.053009335,
-0.0445632078,
0.0282270536,
-0.0149417408,
-0.0655397177,
0.0341159441,
-0.0589556769,
0.0119564943,
-0.0356550775,
-0.012415533,
-0.0120180938,
0.0218607709,
0.0094616665,
0.039528247,
0.0212287512,
-0.0199155249,
-0.0442201085,
0.0187388025,
0.082054913,
-0.0159740467,
-0.0265906248,
-0.0158869755,
0.0105392989,
-0.0099353939,
0.00327734,
-0.0279714558,
-0.0679020733,
0.0317282826,
-0.0003906431,
0.0720345676,
-0.0589228719,
0.0079154512,
-0.0038931181,
0.0203423649,
0.0251013245,
-0.0453852192,
-0.0075870804,
-0.0181563627,
0.0545448065,
0.0440351292,
-0.0437969379,
0.030382609,
-0.0585282445,
-0.0275501553,
0.0977326781,
-0.0116314059,
-0.0129903154,
0.0103175547,
-0.0423375443,
-0.0064379149,
-0.0062732566,
-0.0246773716,
-0.0118140206,
0.018429039,
-0.0302121714,
-0.0075810072,
0.098948881,
0.0104688639,
-0.0439189412,
-0.0200674608,
-0.0169924572,
0.0371248052,
-0.0235420335,
0.0049046096,
-0.082487449,
0.0056791017,
0.0188553985,
0.0133077987,
-0.063352637,
-0.0394537039,
-0.0330733918,
-0.0710254908,
0.0497488901,
0.0233486891,
-0.0362920575,
0.0017199626,
-0.0234004688,
-0.0355615392,
0.0125089651,
-0.0021997818,
-0.0194349792,
-0.0065541468,
0.0291524306,
0.013674181,
-0.0709887221,
-0.0435091555,
-0.0341558941,
-0.0278032385,
0.024778286,
0.0346426554,
0.0509147309,
-0.0117471516,
-0.0138739608,
0.0410491452,
0.0179732963,
-0.0208876543,
-0.026777707,
0.0952453837,
-0.0183305033,
0.0057686004,
-0.0376082771,
0.0553222895,
-0.0068543581,
-0.0134934839,
0.0180904921,
0.0439750962,
-0.0041337884,
-0.0127288392,
-0.0010680022,
0.0252635125,
0.038021598,
0.0668871477,
0.0200657211,
-0.0178388301,
-0.0339405723,
-0.0457647108,
0.0396613777,
-0.0330289192,
-0.033534959,
-0.0353415087,
-0.0247190855,
-0.0501926951,
-0.1185487807,
-0.0534969978,
-0.0165279508,
-0.0007927837,
0.0238454156,
0.016599834,
0.0003834959,
-0.010101283,
-0.0482041873,
-0.0132154329,
-0.0381911322,
0.0163380634,
-0.0429946035,
-0.0120136729,
-0.013907304,
-0.0491037555,
-0.009434632,
0.0064106607,
-0.0609464273,
-0.0713447481,
0.0255969279,
0.011085364,
0.0295358188,
0.0251249336,
-0.0174632892,
-0.0433617681,
0.0178493503,
0.0396075249,
-0.0448098853,
0.014225807,
0.0137347523,
-0.0043056076,
-0.0125085609,
0.0047371206,
-0.0077161756,
-0.0022638002,
0.0162990205,
-0.0347070098,
-0.0155142797,
-0.0265325326,
0.0249525104,
0.0542725585,
0.022349989,
-0.042359259,
0.0264626984,
-0.057251703,
-0.0296844132,
-0.0536794029,
-0.0032909333,
-0.0480711833,
-0.0137769347,
0.0214155633,
-0.0006130199,
-0.0051092189,
0.0277665406,
-0.0624767169,
0.012773877,
-0.0297666341,
-0.0023425415,
-0.0291904435,
0.0794981197,
0.0158084817,
-0.0096730562,
0.013265321,
0.0209337156,
-0.0125482967,
0.0371820927,
0.001300543,
0.0330464244,
0.0220679156,
-0.0233135801,
0.0506679565,
0.0384249762,
-0.098827742,
0.0058060875,
-0.027755579,
0.0177739114,
0.0395229273,
0.0112753361,
0.1025511771,
-0.0576798022,
-0.0193649046,
-0.0422376692,
0.0542875081,
0.0130520426,
-0.0216068644,
-0.0587351657,
-0.0351093635,
-0.0472814441,
0.0297813583,
0.0973801166,
-0.0050844275,
0.0080700051,
-0.0077981181,
-0.0840120837,
-0.0138589842,
-0.0150293205,
-0.0033556381,
-0.0100808926,
-0.003379012,
0.0026850398,
-0.0715370253,
-0.0456017517,
-0.010383172,
0.0107474737,
0.0283402242,
0.006207739,
0.0033540204,
0.0481204949,
-0.0410288461,
0.0242499411,
-0.0759914219,
0.0642585978,
-0.0062746559,
-0.0180229526,
-0.0086619267,
-5.645090113e-33,
0.0218689218,
-0.0847362801,
-0.0253857374,
0.0541016646,
-0.0044523198,
0.0098554632,
-0.0425377302,
-0.0116963349,
0.0174657796,
0.0256017745,
-0.0249648616,
0.003696467,
0.0109999534,
0.009636445,
0.005448462,
0.0073084626,
0.0448947661,
-0.0054518748,
-0.0292961672,
0.0439274013,
0.071631074,
0.0200902782,
0.0481534414,
-0.0531365946,
0.0467645898,
-0.0477077477,
-0.0577044338,
-0.0319374315,
-0.0109579042,
0.03189018,
-0.012422611,
0.0210788194,
0.0235394314,
0.0156753045,
-0.0193988234,
0.0261063352,
-0.0142642744,
-0.0245216191,
0.0066138622,
0.032577984,
-0.0034578461,
-0.0501897968,
0.0404829346,
-0.0446624756,
-0.0342951789,
-0.0032012032,
0.0467251129,
-0.0141149927,
-0.0097376928,
-0.0300762393,
-0.0603867508,
0.0522131883,
-0.0106684575,
0.0083243819,
0.013922425,
0.0660774186,
0.0178530477,
-0.0022463819,
-0.0399421751,
0.034382008,
0.035775803,
0.0274296794,
0.0056404597,
-0.0186921768,
-0.0012791702,
0.0609235913,
0.0424299091,
0.0204225369,
0.0166516695,
0.0270011909,
-0.0090046702,
-0.0014640754,
0.0824237242,
0.1058465466,
-0.0034969153,
-0.0221998766,
-0.0518916845,
0.0541914962,
0.045861356,
-0.0141841108,
0.0083012544,
-0.0377962254,
-0.0261704288,
-0.0357209407,
0.0207954701,
-0.0258311592,
-0.0098217623,
-0.0356321856,
0.0272826683,
-0.0217411313,
-0.0418250374,
-0.0246736351,
0.0163154006,
-0.0478296578,
0.001022998,
0.0106063588,
-0.0696728751,
0.0138707431,
-0.0056222896,
0.0274110138,
-0.0559624583,
-0.0284227803,
0.0289755743,
-0.0095360745,
0.0120469211,
0.0066883564,
0.0512542538,
0.0059308228,
-0.0470205322,
0.0138441604,
-0.0139339007,
0.0364236012,
0.0200016629,
0.0077046044,
0.0057683815,
-0.0356328636,
0.0002966799,
-0.0138934217,
0.0570935495,
0.0436815023,
-0.0508195609,
-0.019103365,
-0.0175621212,
0.0090057719,
-0.0277013592,
0.0193917993,
0.0122247618,
0.0085216938,
0.0325695872,
-0.0296959039,
0.0096175801,
-0.0552914701,
2.591e-7,
0.0369278677,
0.0609708503,
0.0188488998,
-0.0255807284,
0.0253908727,
0.025164824,
-0.0179039035,
0.0363509655,
0.011163203,
-0.0048337057,
-0.0037177687,
-0.0385048874,
0.0692448169,
0.0264608841,
-0.084925957,
0.0106729837,
-0.080692701,
-0.0351799838,
-0.0410117991,
0.0244868211,
0.053564202,
0.0270339064,
0.0219780765,
-0.0300184824,
-0.0049916902,
-0.0511204042,
0.064635776,
-0.0036223633,
-0.0564979315,
0.0340089761,
0.0559851378,
-0.018814275,
0.0077275261,
0.0371979475,
-0.0359900743,
-0.022992773,
0.0325122103,
0.0388398841,
0.0251773223,
0.0432555154,
0.0035061985,
-0.0455217026,
0.00617305,
-0.0692918375,
0.048513595,
0.0143241016,
-0.002059991,
-0.0326002873,
-0.0239174012,
-0.0497074351,
0.0393911973,
-0.0369107276,
-0.0400099792,
0.0271458682,
-0.0057384269,
0.0392699651,
-0.0005427816,
-0.0210203193,
-0.0096237883,
-0.0494961403,
-0.0389504768,
-0.0687642172,
-0.0308947358,
0.0098923324,
-0.0046840203,
-0.0577442273,
0.0152027216,
2.742441637e-34,
0.0514321253,
-0.0279301144,
0.004462264,
-0.0100468164,
0.0387361571,
0.0121886488,
0.0703436509,
0.0331782587,
0.0100022964,
-0.0288673136,
-0.0064301812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11346v1 | CohortGPT: An Enhanced GPT for Participant Recruitment in Clinical Study | 2023-07-21T04:43:00 | 2023-07-21T04:43:00 | Zihan Guan, Zihao Wu, Zhengliang Liu, Dufan Wu, Hui Ren, Quanzheng Li, Xiang Li, Ninghao Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Participant recruitment based on unstructured medical texts such as clinical
notes and radiology reports has been a challenging yet important task for the
cohort establishment in clinical research. Recently, Large Language Models
(LLMs) such as ChatGPT have achieved tremendous success in various downstream
tasks thanks to their promising performance in language understanding,
inference, and generation. It is then natural to test their feasibility in
solving the cohort recruitment task, which involves the classification of a
given paragraph of medical text into disease label(s). However, when applied to
knowledge-intensive problem settings such as medical text classification, where
the LLMs are expected to understand the decision made by human experts and
accurately identify the implied disease labels, the LLMs show a mediocre
performance. A possible explanation is that, by only using the medical text,
the LLMs neglect to use the rich context of additional information that
languages afford. To this end, we propose to use a knowledge graph as auxiliary
information to guide the LLMs in making predictions. Moreover, to further boost
the LLMs adapt to the problem setting, we apply a chain-of-thought (CoT) sample
selection strategy enhanced by reinforcement learning, which selects a set of
CoT samples given each individual medical report. Experimental results and
various ablation studies show that our few-shot learning method achieves
satisfactory performance compared with fine-tuning strategies and gains superb
advantages when the available data is limited. The code and sample dataset of
the proposed CohortGPT model is available at:
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/CohortGPT-4872/ | [
0.0740479007,
0.0419668257,
0.0000514894,
-0.0409639031,
-0.0660099462,
0.0284703728,
0.0129008805,
0.0248084515,
0.0566976964,
-0.0267957635,
-0.0014644777,
-0.0560513623,
0.0094726598,
-0.01111292,
-0.0179210734,
-0.0472379215,
0.0437053517,
0.0020831171,
0.0646495894,
-0.0024706468,
-0.034372773,
0.0297287591,
-0.0280105826,
0.0400671922,
0.0286043584,
0.0043674512,
0.0242904611,
-0.0131204771,
0.0244288146,
-0.0678562,
0.0095869405,
0.0550575629,
0.0020652949,
0.011331982,
0.0000021746,
-0.0474579073,
-0.0471290126,
0.0294892434,
-0.0386306942,
-0.0588010773,
0.0217854548,
-0.0198277533,
0.0103477053,
0.0216910634,
-0.0494873412,
-0.0257744677,
0.0466648489,
0.0398951136,
0.0299920086,
0.0783884153,
-0.0176811349,
0.006124855,
0.0069025923,
-0.0436108597,
0.0550147258,
-0.0435455404,
0.0610787421,
-0.0017256998,
0.0574287772,
0.002500474,
-0.0028954751,
0.0301338844,
-0.0298416,
0.0225025453,
0.0241307672,
0.069785364,
-0.0517049842,
-0.0178853031,
0.0009560498,
0.0251758229,
-0.0046121003,
-0.0038185124,
0.0405943207,
-0.011424995,
-0.0191189349,
0.0431960225,
-0.0169305503,
-0.0362327062,
-0.0527453311,
0.0162461028,
0.0049211862,
0.0108550219,
0.0288851038,
-0.0109434603,
-0.0190517139,
0.0110492315,
-0.0157628171,
-0.0181076135,
0.0528726093,
0.0358878523,
-0.0422249138,
-0.0315975621,
0.0235994421,
0.02238876,
-0.0666651726,
0.0355476812,
-0.000524225,
-0.0452618338,
0.0718334392,
-0.0522499532,
-0.0254375804,
-0.0083592925,
0.0294543318,
0.0661041737,
0.0005222645,
-0.000685192,
0.0126313502,
0.0333716907,
-0.0342156328,
0.0019875346,
-0.0967371091,
-0.0216773301,
-0.0482845306,
0.0614622273,
0.0529823005,
0.0022599776,
-0.1022206545,
-0.0099397944,
0.0159276351,
-0.023825733,
0.0422241017,
0.006850291,
-0.0256008245,
0.0202324297,
-0.0354010724,
0.0086604757,
0.0137323989,
-0.0008005653,
-0.0256070532,
-0.0164879635,
0.0270035248,
-0.0121669658,
0.0051183556,
-0.0480263755,
0.0223496482,
0.0547654629,
0.0070485049,
-0.0483139157,
-0.0335752964,
-0.0039580171,
-0.0326466933,
-0.0413069464,
-0.0093296636,
-0.0725610852,
0.0634169802,
0.0164330117,
0.0149902087,
-0.0180047229,
0.0084187733,
0.0050534112,
-0.0759936497,
0.088223353,
-0.054841768,
-0.0067478432,
0.0328989327,
0.0150211845,
-0.0209496506,
0.0410468169,
0.0626250431,
-0.0228441004,
-0.0060786973,
-0.0111358175,
0.0208695717,
0.0083254818,
0.0153084565,
-0.0281810332,
0.032717742,
0.0092334365,
-0.0115767615,
0.0781650543,
-0.0364342742,
0.0480560958,
-0.0195782259,
0.0124117034,
0.0247118995,
0.0851143524,
0.0230133142,
0.0114415707,
-0.0020827167,
-0.0016685225,
-0.0247013718,
-0.017476717,
0.0128311962,
0.0193775985,
0.0082240487,
-0.0177133251,
0.0073115383,
0.0097209932,
-0.0202882979,
-0.021548748,
-0.0172867235,
0.0121020647,
0.0175035484,
0.0106966067,
0.0583189391,
-0.026869785,
-0.0404052772,
-0.0063709868,
0.0697393417,
0.0071145087,
-0.025639765,
-0.0709562004,
0.0023981205,
0.0297587197,
0.0658793747,
-0.0452254154,
-0.0389136225,
-0.0375913382,
-0.0051155458,
0.001747769,
0.0412618071,
0.0000502743,
-0.0245481506,
-0.0410072543,
-0.048093345,
0.0571038947,
-0.0039803358,
0.0068272967,
-0.0076457001,
0.0355541185,
-0.0168508049,
-0.0082212612,
-0.0169047769,
0.0426968038,
-0.0355338827,
-0.0215514619,
0.0293028336,
-0.0013702018,
0.0674869642,
-0.0040179426,
-0.0050504645,
0.0001169361,
-0.0198643189,
-0.0229376741,
-0.0179831069,
-0.0177537892,
-0.0293373745,
-0.0922882259,
-0.0106027657,
-0.0495703742,
-0.019107271,
-0.0498525053,
-0.0427793972,
-0.0348484516,
-0.0093660615,
-0.0384165086,
0.0265204925,
-0.0090966076,
-0.0091116317,
0.0194394719,
-0.0387144089,
-0.0592951737,
0.0687318519,
0.0145288073,
-0.0125649814,
0.0310093351,
-0.0945449769,
0.0011114355,
-0.0429371707,
-0.0162723642,
0.0295847338,
0.0234325472,
0.0010018927,
0.0407347195,
0.0350763761,
-0.0273090061,
-0.0475615859,
-0.1026389822,
0.0253671166,
0.0229148865,
0.0144688506,
-0.0191460531,
0.0172031093,
-0.0289791133,
-0.0324937068,
-0.057641156,
0.0045323493,
0.0191750117,
0.0130083729,
0.0241964962,
0.0301340241,
0.0495300554,
-0.0132885342,
0.0066643395,
-0.035424687,
0.0338124484,
0.0507209562,
-0.0697992891,
0.0248812083,
0.0233417582,
-0.0463542342,
-0.0241881032,
0.0028251442,
-0.0074315057,
0.0151358526,
-0.0111610396,
0.0231504515,
0.0166359562,
0.0003302846,
0.0213949643,
0.0325276777,
0.0050698658,
-0.0266392846,
0.0399494953,
-0.0617422312,
-0.0307688955,
-0.009075759,
-0.050090909,
0.0290398188,
0.0545947254,
0.0445979014,
-0.0153833004,
-0.097375676,
-0.0016403825,
-0.021311935,
0.0436436199,
-0.0743895397,
0.017561812,
-0.0213284753,
0.000670479,
-0.0266608652,
-0.0222242419,
0.0956020728,
0.0310252625,
0.0377700515,
-0.0864475146,
-0.0137277367,
-0.0471359901,
-0.0104577485,
0.0426770598,
0.0131665086,
0.0318056457,
-0.000853552,
-0.0237416402,
0.0066490313,
0.0060471455,
-0.0701185539,
0.016357664,
-0.0113661848,
0.0402876996,
0.0128630102,
-0.0483244136,
-0.0210172646,
-0.0080699781,
-0.0141865266,
-0.0068397033,
-0.014809533,
0.0366906784,
-0.0622620098,
0.029831307,
0.0171241313,
0.0684123859,
0.0004350175,
-0.0322758704,
0.0014343698,
0.01868237,
0.0297157392,
-0.0192864928,
-0.0162293725,
-0.0358640477,
0.0263138637,
0.0563559234,
0.0031821693,
0.0267775469,
0.0107847648,
-0.0008779269,
-0.0122892251,
-0.046615798,
-0.026156472,
0.0185737889,
0.0121026468,
-0.0345361084,
0.0189564563,
0.1060858667,
0.0229282416,
-0.1026336253,
-0.0171524566,
0.0073389583,
0.0265973769,
-0.0130929835,
0.0298839509,
-0.0459572636,
-0.0203910656,
-0.0004336902,
0.0432402007,
-0.0479065403,
-0.0558089092,
0.0016389323,
-0.0384649001,
0.0429860279,
0.0070283711,
-0.0586037524,
-0.0027080309,
-0.0782525316,
0.031107083,
-0.0246880297,
-0.0476335287,
-0.0229154117,
0.0001563909,
0.0117649585,
0.0147778383,
-0.0733978376,
-0.0591534488,
0.0240851548,
-0.0077331113,
0.0549131334,
0.0571942106,
0.0480612628,
-0.0042192652,
0.0041957339,
-0.0109188221,
-0.0024117294,
-0.0104608405,
-0.0228560679,
0.0787236765,
0.0122156022,
0.0083485227,
-0.0487857983,
0.0340051167,
-0.0268271733,
-0.0243845768,
0.0222329572,
0.1067622527,
-0.0315920189,
-0.054141216,
-0.0316270366,
0.0230530538,
0.023844786,
0.042805817,
-0.0132805724,
-0.0395769551,
-0.0248092115,
-0.0068118731,
0.0398172103,
-0.0205291975,
-0.0344854444,
0.041483786,
-0.0458259471,
0.0250661578,
-0.035993699,
-0.0044734324,
0.0622217394,
0.0006135276,
0.0102784624,
0.0796657279,
0.0210154094,
0.0015992395,
-0.0075914399,
0.0429674461,
-0.0070986114,
0.003403066,
-0.0664967895,
-0.062410064,
0.035164427,
-0.0487824418,
-0.0144599127,
-0.0043868516,
-0.0316922702,
-0.0093850186,
-0.0238424987,
0.0445160419,
0.0214932244,
0.0261102635,
0.0134068141,
-0.0137815652,
0.1131909713,
0.0375261866,
-0.022388896,
-0.0263540763,
-0.0346731693,
0.0138184512,
-0.0351618081,
0.0054053124,
-0.0083855223,
0.0225865562,
0.0008245147,
0.0129833668,
-0.0529833809,
0.026822038,
0.0249633249,
0.0227727331,
0.0626919046,
-0.0519833453,
-0.0141636115,
-0.0386348665,
0.0148705589,
0.041055724,
0.011448171,
-0.0259166248,
-0.0347790718,
0.0152727561,
-0.0241951626,
-0.0193925146,
-0.0690928772,
-0.0443410315,
-0.0000383886,
-0.0366803221,
0.022322977,
0.0476078428,
0.0035552601,
0.0711834803,
-0.0034787366,
0.0144236227,
0.0130533883,
0.0184656028,
0.0077217882,
-0.0170198679,
0.0682691038,
0.0147467926,
0.0247589368,
0.0252965614,
0.0104384748,
-0.0610853694,
-0.0115401912,
-0.0211824495,
0.0292662159,
0.0206218157,
0.0129726408,
0.0142230187,
-0.0403858684,
0.0035869796,
-0.0226314627,
0.0366847776,
-0.0223937873,
0.0159154236,
0.0388989523,
0.0151207782,
-0.0063464516,
-0.0094806626,
0.0996407717,
0.0275263172,
0.0198317822,
0.02151189,
-0.0525777563,
-0.0575988814,
-0.0093339868,
0.0433183163,
0.0107816104,
-0.0298380703,
0.0389572568,
-0.0524029024,
-0.0248570107,
-0.0015263078,
-0.0402125753,
-0.0068325833,
-0.0178229287,
0.0739385858,
0.0226490032,
-0.0180835202,
0.0002833243,
-0.0518514588,
0.002457134,
-0.0214452837,
-0.0223954264,
0.0107894111,
-6.158782613e-33,
-0.0049590939,
-0.0222883914,
0.0300196614,
0.0202070791,
-0.0152152833,
0.011070353,
-0.0365824439,
-0.0182361547,
0.032105986,
0.0233590472,
-0.0267871935,
-0.0239540637,
0.0010530804,
0.0416040421,
-0.0101811392,
-0.0159665905,
0.025453791,
0.0034641898,
-0.0094434284,
0.0340160467,
-0.0317597948,
0.036748983,
0.0487035215,
-0.0696430504,
0.0097835204,
0.017840907,
0.0217156038,
0.0090304455,
0.0005890803,
0.0637342408,
-0.0199683122,
0.0317258127,
0.0427792929,
-0.0078838142,
0.0270348843,
0.0163807794,
-0.0606899709,
-0.0623337813,
-0.0106349746,
-0.017048033,
-0.0299921352,
-0.0219944622,
0.0152646527,
-0.0169575028,
0.0152802439,
-0.0393013619,
0.0430456325,
-0.0274293516,
-0.0498220436,
-0.0443495922,
-0.0138762277,
0.0556130633,
-0.0014774617,
0.0040814606,
-0.0108991005,
0.034063261,
-0.0661364496,
0.0485519581,
-0.0154477861,
0.0205650274,
0.0424329452,
0.0123171397,
-0.03934085,
-0.0014075061,
-0.006100771,
0.069237262,
-0.0101423664,
-0.0116928881,
-0.0204296615,
-0.010024081,
-0.0388889238,
0.0142831123,
0.0269803461,
0.0065909605,
0.0444101281,
0.0080433367,
-0.100874275,
0.0148194712,
-0.0008254453,
0.0136525538,
0.0411886163,
-0.0239402484,
-0.0274261888,
-0.0264693741,
-0.0214685109,
-0.0194661338,
-0.0133861434,
-0.0504461862,
0.0026981209,
0.0052800938,
-0.0123891812,
-0.0352389216,
0.0258977711,
0.0064532184,
-0.0049542785,
-0.0205169469,
0.0171975344,
0.0119802598,
-0.0227921586,
0.0197963733,
-0.0747826174,
-0.0247530434,
0.0275205299,
-0.0208293218,
0.0293611083,
0.0291724559,
0.0190980341,
-0.0068904269,
-0.0512127057,
-0.0037312931,
0.033068005,
0.0266689025,
-0.0186855868,
0.015521355,
0.0217642933,
0.0302865505,
0.027754508,
0.0427836664,
0.0298695359,
-0.0346665196,
0.0124987159,
-0.0069698803,
-0.036868412,
-0.0132766962,
-0.0226998776,
0.0126762325,
-0.016525764,
0.0268933233,
0.0444853008,
-0.0642909855,
-0.0082328087,
0.0054979152,
3.01e-7,
0.0653896779,
0.076905705,
-0.043914035,
-0.0422788747,
0.0316565745,
0.0075876527,
-0.0152028045,
0.0207247064,
0.0272682793,
-0.0026175235,
0.0880382732,
0.0172754042,
0.0285468493,
0.057514865,
-0.1108390018,
0.0057468866,
-0.0829314068,
-0.0187339466,
-0.037105009,
-0.0039319862,
0.0550214089,
0.0654755756,
0.0029398547,
-0.0303365272,
-0.0053803432,
-0.0270148739,
0.0550604947,
-0.0362009332,
-0.0171688143,
0.0567413643,
0.0206150729,
-0.0121747497,
-0.006851736,
0.0878719911,
-0.0115578836,
-0.0055328184,
0.0064819832,
0.052581422,
-0.0219945498,
0.0128611643,
0.0359531231,
0.0400145315,
0.0314847194,
-0.0220439658,
0.0742321163,
-0.0972932354,
-0.0461822674,
0.0060817678,
-0.0006768665,
-0.0483900234,
0.071981959,
-0.0183164179,
-0.0396715142,
0.0291092135,
0.0380733721,
0.0224452429,
-0.0299875904,
-0.0684900656,
0.0288972426,
0.0343722664,
-0.0587558746,
-0.0284895431,
0.0363517925,
0.0203866605,
-0.0056288159,
-0.0656428188,
0.0373640731,
2.764701183e-34,
0.034089487,
-0.0145074222,
-0.0215178076,
-0.0173362363,
0.003713296,
-0.0047713919,
0.0116795562,
0.015786998,
0.0397442207,
-0.0595896617,
0.0025241517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11344v1 | DEFTri: A Few-Shot Label Fused Contextual Representation Learning For Product Defect Triage in e-Commerce | 2023-07-21T04:22:43 | 2023-07-21T04:22:43 | Ipsita Mohanty | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Defect Triage is a time-sensitive and critical process in a large-scale agile
software development lifecycle for e-commerce. Inefficiencies arising from
human and process dependencies in this domain have motivated research in
automated approaches using machine learning to accurately assign defects to
qualified teams. This work proposes a novel framework for automated defect
triage (DEFTri) using fine-tuned state-of-the-art pre-trained BERT on labels
fused text embeddings to improve contextual representations from
human-generated product defects. For our multi-label text classification defect
triage task, we also introduce a Walmart proprietary dataset of product defects
using weak supervision and adversarial learning, in a few-shot setting. | [
0.0569469295,
0.0018074797,
-0.0285649076,
-0.0173981972,
0.0021810464,
-0.007105825,
0.0199150201,
0.0150813377,
0.0223883074,
-0.1098189875,
-0.0104562407,
0.0023242503,
-0.0503493585,
0.0383189656,
0.0118573084,
-0.0013237227,
0.0283195004,
0.046319399,
0.0107531548,
0.0165913366,
0.0151916211,
0.0255333334,
-0.030302899,
0.0339925848,
-0.0357157663,
-0.0306559447,
0.0148984082,
-0.0000802255,
0.0557840019,
-0.0316717885,
0.0520453081,
0.0371654443,
0.0002430777,
0.0089684958,
0.0000021721,
-0.0344978273,
-0.0150559833,
-0.0112541392,
-0.0168281049,
0.0448836461,
-0.0258901305,
-0.0322092772,
-0.0150938109,
0.026163673,
-0.0065091588,
0.0026776495,
0.0371976085,
0.0759557709,
0.0646340251,
0.0525060371,
-0.015119005,
0.0073235007,
0.0078862691,
-0.0002844393,
0.0225480031,
-0.0874277651,
0.0044924887,
-0.0160622336,
0.015537112,
0.0094298143,
0.0252996963,
0.0043049809,
0.0417926162,
0.0011224129,
0.0142308911,
0.0581827834,
-0.0146501865,
0.0240525082,
-0.0191194136,
0.0881895274,
-0.0312672444,
0.0026075977,
-0.0450022817,
-0.0321430303,
0.0132980272,
-0.0353806131,
0.0418913923,
-0.0275880061,
-0.0061316839,
0.0009754928,
-0.0302799344,
-0.0259472188,
-0.0058738678,
-0.0386880636,
0.0217695739,
-0.000061078,
-0.00863316,
-0.0336622484,
-0.0247973986,
0.0040652938,
-0.0572028086,
-0.0217982382,
0.0229578987,
0.0147670116,
-0.0364012234,
-0.0241196062,
-0.0608782768,
-0.0508606583,
0.0320703909,
-0.0358989164,
-0.0197180603,
-0.0244940203,
-0.0445008725,
0.0215648152,
-0.0426871888,
0.0338136107,
0.0368288681,
0.0517639443,
-0.0472353213,
0.0154993152,
-0.0469162464,
-0.0119620506,
-0.0286956802,
0.0102085313,
0.0212583318,
0.0012152917,
-0.011982684,
-0.0009793466,
-0.032617636,
0.0248342883,
0.0319487005,
0.0328504667,
-0.058212541,
-0.0041239331,
-0.0449467115,
-0.0100417333,
-0.056698028,
0.0249096993,
-0.0660180524,
0.0276341513,
0.0028209072,
0.0196897108,
-0.0354648232,
-0.0149839092,
0.0041240784,
0.028458491,
-0.0019189281,
-0.0119723557,
-0.0713215843,
0.0052110669,
-0.0515829213,
-0.0006180847,
-0.0405747034,
-0.0029446566,
-0.031235544,
-0.0235845745,
-0.0166798662,
-0.0147625059,
-0.0097085917,
-0.0026438443,
-0.0198864043,
0.075939022,
-0.0335843526,
-0.0305817872,
0.0136468317,
0.021068424,
0.0308706388,
0.0191285759,
-0.0121161891,
0.0584769771,
-0.0004033946,
0.0270802006,
0.0518725812,
0.0149977868,
-0.0135407327,
0.0146111837,
0.0057677133,
-0.0054123723,
-0.0114284493,
0.0273458883,
0.0351238213,
0.0017231149,
-0.011418947,
0.0011737433,
0.0264774784,
-0.0206640288,
0.0218792614,
-0.0198489111,
0.0280138347,
0.044979047,
-0.0621098205,
-0.0547307767,
-0.0014779568,
0.0632937476,
-0.0160940196,
-0.0509086885,
0.00903566,
0.0010921522,
-0.0533069447,
-0.0417775139,
-0.0216101278,
-0.0041864216,
-0.0391181111,
-0.005942787,
0.0506039634,
0.0085481759,
-0.0369242057,
0.0291744005,
0.0284828413,
0.0155995842,
-0.0582157187,
-0.029088527,
0.0232085399,
0.0938157663,
0.0513228998,
-0.0845532492,
-0.1036228538,
0.0052184002,
0.0063149491,
-0.0191997737,
0.0598310605,
-0.0452562533,
-0.0299515575,
-0.0336810499,
-0.0444778539,
-0.055564139,
-0.0004058697,
0.0450813137,
-0.0341060683,
0.0014317847,
-0.0012678652,
-0.0449380092,
0.0068338648,
0.051282946,
0.0338738486,
-0.0330323093,
0.031598188,
0.0254399646,
-0.0035522203,
0.0041876594,
-0.0026461664,
-0.0157284308,
0.0521788187,
-0.0403952636,
-0.0532983691,
0.0135574741,
0.0319318548,
-0.0713471472,
0.0179656204,
-0.0415105037,
-0.0469478555,
0.0020884688,
-0.0575806573,
-0.0027617861,
-0.002737181,
-0.0004567055,
-0.0339222848,
-0.004858125,
-0.0056570452,
-0.0243769996,
-0.03027438,
-0.0499341562,
0.0830615163,
0.0379894227,
0.0106790485,
-0.0501513258,
0.0055703567,
0.0216401424,
0.0152119221,
-0.0149152949,
0.018988695,
-0.0095727723,
0.0508605465,
-0.0060203834,
0.0368966907,
-0.0009624346,
-0.0039990898,
-0.0578020848,
-0.0112215886,
-0.0019854412,
-0.00222885,
-0.0190483797,
-0.0586912222,
0.0350075588,
-0.0285283905,
-0.0450735874,
-0.0066072266,
-0.0259450674,
-0.0074679782,
0.0574759133,
0.0235736966,
-0.002676476,
0.0089214351,
0.0003437494,
-0.0448526889,
0.0335089155,
0.0493220873,
-0.0136797633,
-0.0878048167,
0.0292728972,
0.0116336448,
0.0020577891,
-0.0017224286,
-0.0147616016,
-0.0072856289,
0.0159276333,
0.0110241203,
0.0139939925,
-0.0382009633,
0.0626667067,
0.0137590095,
0.0268586148,
-0.0244579352,
0.0128666414,
0.0191088393,
-0.0169062037,
-0.0012803862,
-0.008537028,
0.0145300459,
0.0295973159,
0.0060329116,
-0.02200941,
-0.0663589537,
0.000760804,
-0.0006724589,
-0.0293410551,
0.0137698324,
-0.0324355438,
0.0057164109,
0.0142175108,
-0.0375542641,
-0.0250010043,
0.0935594812,
0.026064124,
0.0306795258,
-0.0994770899,
-0.0103051933,
-0.0249611791,
0.038475614,
-0.018985182,
0.0233674236,
0.0367921665,
-0.0380576886,
-0.0236433875,
0.0511892326,
0.0131879775,
0.015879795,
-0.0061764475,
-0.0376534797,
0.0513054356,
-0.0042562722,
-0.0415878855,
-0.0300191659,
-0.0398017317,
0.0218445379,
0.0072522596,
0.0147117106,
0.0207547992,
-0.1193513423,
0.0163936503,
-0.0098495018,
0.0505397543,
0.0641850829,
-0.0432605147,
-0.0035857235,
0.0020147976,
-0.0277087986,
-0.0515898168,
-0.0000514458,
-0.0542195477,
0.011276531,
0.022515988,
0.0867740065,
0.0238944478,
-0.036227975,
-0.0065924632,
-0.0118518304,
-0.0267726742,
0.0318892896,
0.0151210409,
0.0045308014,
-0.0268431064,
0.0115811555,
0.0586573705,
0.0504269227,
-0.0327880345,
0.0334119238,
0.0826230347,
-0.0138424868,
0.0564041398,
0.0144360131,
-0.0812262744,
-0.0478313044,
0.0018316916,
0.0324666724,
0.0176879223,
-0.0066391174,
0.0216401573,
-0.075653024,
-0.0030151054,
-0.0216171723,
0.0260515809,
-0.0696219131,
-0.0062330356,
0.005559437,
-0.0196927004,
0.0565729551,
-0.0158795062,
0.0093374932,
0.0134160491,
0.0320894383,
-0.0424087644,
-0.074435927,
0.0603645779,
-0.035137862,
0.0115869241,
0.0681853145,
0.022117259,
0.0033565243,
0.0241888594,
0.043070592,
-0.0100679761,
0.0084046712,
0.0175421294,
0.0949992687,
-0.0296564661,
-0.0187063999,
0.052689556,
-0.0095096864,
-0.0620591342,
-0.0190621559,
-0.009749243,
0.0415656529,
0.0088640098,
0.0020962078,
-0.0128073534,
-0.0238666758,
0.0067984965,
0.0335389338,
0.0157831069,
-0.0755031109,
-0.0014959282,
0.0019273676,
0.0269190036,
-0.0406849384,
-0.0152352527,
0.0484620035,
-0.042267248,
-0.075035505,
-0.0818993151,
-0.0634253249,
0.0496217832,
0.0341073014,
0.0192804616,
-0.0908290371,
-0.0746727884,
0.0170204733,
-0.0222740825,
0.0282281209,
0.0545794889,
0.0747597367,
-0.0300300084,
0.0318289585,
0.002476369,
0.0130676758,
-0.0521586649,
0.0124167847,
-0.02062116,
-0.0335973911,
-0.0198091175,
0.0403008834,
0.0035409895,
-0.0144127412,
-0.0608051606,
-0.0959032476,
0.0057430146,
0.0952811241,
-0.0162854288,
0.0165079311,
0.0162689313,
-0.0157586802,
-0.0246122386,
0.0029181321,
-0.0513187051,
0.0489273183,
0.0200050678,
0.0126317181,
0.0092824986,
-0.00556381,
0.0294269584,
-0.0551013462,
0.0529694706,
0.0257400405,
0.000455181,
-0.0438081548,
0.040506348,
0.0233663395,
-0.0342330039,
-0.0325005502,
0.0375018343,
0.007508954,
-0.074278757,
-0.0102510601,
0.0348148122,
-0.0058849994,
0.05113649,
-0.0353078097,
0.0098839626,
0.059627153,
0.0318176001,
-0.0007410392,
0.0132974396,
0.0150834508,
-0.0052016028,
0.0108572952,
0.0321531147,
-0.0161772668,
0.0094039207,
0.016128419,
0.0371256284,
0.0081410455,
-0.0001417332,
-0.0293517578,
-0.0201986488,
-0.0652232096,
-0.0179005954,
0.0348315723,
0.0421192832,
0.016814176,
0.0000478853,
-0.0165736228,
-0.020510504,
0.0134155275,
-0.0292305425,
0.020020118,
0.0024855288,
0.0345783159,
-0.019197287,
-0.0118405428,
0.0634800196,
0.0332843736,
0.0497960672,
-0.0572711565,
-0.0255709682,
-0.0420408696,
0.0319822207,
0.0479511693,
-0.0094042607,
-0.0077023855,
0.0004857287,
-0.0674492419,
-0.0161534641,
0.0326669924,
-0.0006294133,
0.0148085654,
0.0444511548,
-0.0058199004,
0.1000377685,
0.0070422585,
0.0226307102,
0.0125733456,
-0.0416086428,
0.0176522825,
-0.0020163748,
-0.0384113081,
-6.116491265e-33,
-0.022624556,
-0.0787199363,
-0.0325290971,
-0.0662223995,
0.0467019342,
0.0268317554,
0.0031408514,
-0.0132055711,
0.0492297448,
0.03791482,
0.0138632124,
0.0445049927,
-0.0099628773,
0.0128163863,
0.0267685354,
-0.0201431643,
0.0682401434,
0.0198981743,
0.0157953966,
0.0672624111,
0.0089628752,
0.051368963,
0.0509874448,
-0.0374740213,
0.0367682613,
0.0312551968,
-0.0138322152,
0.030157119,
0.0453437828,
0.0663619712,
0.0003652514,
0.0352546908,
0.023604136,
-0.0244221669,
0.0096058864,
-0.0327238403,
-0.0371983759,
-0.0080009298,
-0.072218664,
-0.0067664469,
0.0283503328,
0.0072904732,
0.0351196602,
-0.0204373337,
0.0265786722,
0.0342176333,
0.0827833861,
0.0073952232,
-0.0179797746,
-0.1016808227,
-0.0665331334,
0.0314375497,
-0.0461557768,
-0.027024623,
0.0116337948,
0.0683873594,
0.0437799096,
-0.0014160884,
-0.0220402684,
-0.0388080925,
-0.0282756966,
-0.0405424908,
0.0223056562,
-0.0083189951,
-0.0584246889,
0.0397844389,
0.0050358912,
0.0405129977,
0.0098518888,
-0.0562155508,
-0.0055614761,
0.0528185405,
0.0560879968,
0.0311409347,
0.0300082993,
0.003655022,
-0.0574381836,
0.0554638878,
-0.0060364702,
0.0124557409,
-0.0044618212,
0.0444793813,
-0.0813091919,
-0.0192831829,
-0.0089392085,
-0.0209507793,
-0.044771865,
0.0297486167,
0.0225606952,
0.0111651057,
-0.0320328102,
0.0392564945,
0.0037376559,
-0.024294164,
-0.0095302202,
-0.0303069931,
-0.007477704,
0.0124700516,
-0.03260912,
0.0106918169,
-0.0430977419,
-0.0160965696,
0.0465166867,
0.0409056917,
0.0275947563,
-0.0443996564,
0.0710217431,
-0.005695276,
-0.0475850329,
0.0340807438,
-0.006307804,
-0.0080178231,
-0.0217495244,
0.0509519503,
0.0063738762,
0.0157957003,
0.016975468,
0.0162659381,
0.0254644584,
-0.0198555384,
-0.0371062271,
0.0404238589,
-0.0326186866,
-0.0188474562,
0.0005636124,
-0.0145663144,
-0.0021298863,
0.0196914095,
0.0408046171,
-0.0994351357,
-0.0222885869,
0.0075870086,
2.773e-7,
0.048488874,
0.0588965677,
-0.008738013,
-0.0519284606,
0.0359869376,
0.0641716495,
0.0033496672,
0.0392948687,
-0.0224526171,
-0.0166680999,
0.067736119,
0.0013812223,
0.0205165166,
0.053791482,
-0.009944668,
0.0069322987,
-0.0319141895,
0.0145830167,
-0.0525388494,
0.0078127505,
0.0661350414,
0.0564494357,
0.0273961201,
-0.0272538457,
0.026937101,
-0.0291492566,
0.0324735306,
-0.0068863127,
0.0232632197,
0.0320391953,
0.0380203053,
0.0105004357,
-0.0222392976,
0.0089935232,
-0.0361352973,
-0.0221339688,
0.0416710749,
-0.0017904867,
-0.0372381769,
-0.0435327888,
-0.0176755879,
-0.0193808638,
0.0007139412,
0.0329576507,
0.0490873158,
-0.1011961997,
-0.0010301931,
0.0315596201,
0.0002892286,
-0.0133586209,
0.0070511904,
0.0065682409,
-0.0133126965,
0.0299352054,
-0.008522517,
-0.0265514553,
-0.0146015454,
-0.100854136,
0.0144596221,
0.0510959402,
-0.0541439541,
-0.0144759333,
0.0378437936,
0.0030530856,
0.0524584092,
-0.0293473899,
0.0395598412,
2.818324848e-34,
0.0675143972,
-0.0238380525,
-0.0102099078,
0.0023782109,
0.0040001282,
0.0070922822,
0.0232360847,
-0.0430976599,
0.0256650168,
-0.0318164974,
-0.0183286406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11316v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11316v1 | Making Pre-trained Language Models both Task-solvers and Self-calibrators | 2023-07-21T02:51:41 | 2023-07-21T02:51:41 | Yangyi Chen, Xingyao Wang, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) serve as backbones for various real-world
systems. For high-stake applications, it's equally essential to have reasonable
confidence estimations in predictions. While the vanilla confidence scores of
PLMs can already be effectively utilized, PLMs consistently become
overconfident in their wrong predictions, which is not desirable in practice.
Previous work shows that introducing an extra calibration task can mitigate
this issue. The basic idea involves acquiring additional data to train models
in predicting the confidence of their initial predictions. However, it only
demonstrates the feasibility of this kind of method, assuming that there are
abundant extra available samples for the introduced calibration task. In this
work, we consider the practical scenario that we need to effectively utilize
training samples to make PLMs both task-solvers and self-calibrators. Three
challenges are presented, including limited training samples, data imbalance,
and distribution shifts. We first conduct pilot experiments to quantify various
decisive factors in the calibration task. Based on the empirical analysis
results, we propose a training algorithm LM-TOAST to tackle the challenges.
Experimental results show that LM-TOAST can effectively utilize the training
data to make PLMs have reasonable confidence estimations while maintaining the
original task performance. Further, we consider three downstream applications,
namely selective classification, adversarial defense, and model cascading, to
show the practical usefulness of LM-TOAST. The code will be made public at
\url{https://github.com/Yangyi-Chen/LM-TOAST}. | [
0.0316129327,
0.0562209487,
-0.011518809,
0.0393517949,
-0.0275499616,
-0.0010020823,
0.0012972786,
-0.0267356075,
0.0039013634,
-0.0508051962,
-0.0619610362,
-0.0364720821,
0.0034744127,
0.0291011296,
0.0307069495,
-0.0110626211,
0.0097406423,
-0.0439030826,
0.0098814918,
-0.0164594688,
0.0069533326,
-0.002591969,
-0.0065204478,
0.0111349579,
-0.0007004181,
-0.0150481975,
-0.0048266002,
0.0175582841,
0.0078652846,
-0.0179896671,
0.0553550348,
0.0750956759,
0.0099375937,
0.0478344858,
0.0000021339,
-0.0407874472,
-0.0219080038,
-0.0126733789,
-0.0516879559,
0.0139068477,
0.0219061524,
-0.0257082377,
-0.0050743488,
0.0534315109,
-0.0549192578,
0.0012016473,
0.0350736938,
0.00109414,
0.0302848965,
0.0936710835,
0.010360348,
-0.0102908118,
-0.00755555,
-0.0222266093,
-0.0230109803,
-0.0672194585,
0.019151127,
0.0078872079,
-0.0539040081,
-0.0167915188,
-0.0060122865,
0.0330242291,
0.0125252791,
-0.0033689626,
-0.0199597813,
0.0242687706,
-0.032382559,
-0.0079619521,
-0.0324590765,
0.0332260318,
-0.0467178263,
-0.0752211511,
-0.0109113585,
-0.0390030518,
-0.00761165,
-0.0190778878,
-0.015177411,
-0.002291251,
0.0268299393,
0.0404580235,
-0.0140054962,
0.0062448839,
0.0551024638,
0.001912743,
0.000173893,
0.0771069825,
0.002725316,
-0.021738112,
-0.0130368564,
0.0098861828,
-0.0041536232,
-0.0685602278,
0.0090182694,
0.046703957,
-0.0315821916,
0.0282643288,
-0.0805816501,
-0.0549640916,
0.0131078791,
-0.0566804335,
0.0530271083,
0.0272477306,
-0.0293580145,
0.0374708883,
-0.0307239536,
0.0561008453,
0.008587392,
0.0433863401,
-0.0437172316,
0.0059127705,
-0.0290109087,
0.0001378361,
-0.0388067365,
0.0005926806,
0.0163527895,
0.0147847785,
-0.05892919,
0.0308966748,
0.0186894909,
0.0163463149,
0.0078646801,
-0.0023985384,
-0.0492816865,
-0.048044432,
-0.0100019909,
0.0148686906,
0.0143325496,
0.0326855332,
-0.0203115288,
-0.0584429577,
-0.0260318387,
0.0243276022,
-0.0228949804,
-0.0149431061,
0.024033213,
0.0444978587,
0.0108686229,
-0.0487004742,
-0.028959522,
-0.001633424,
-0.0452796817,
-0.0923524797,
-0.0024581966,
-0.0568006597,
-0.01625406,
0.0178083647,
0.0092632072,
-0.0377954058,
0.0022073176,
-0.0134560298,
-0.0250818543,
0.0881160945,
0.0179138221,
0.0100059723,
0.000811119,
-0.0126828877,
-0.003026481,
0.0925755724,
0.0599904843,
0.0222063735,
0.0405008011,
-0.0210823845,
0.0456025563,
0.0536354929,
0.0338000208,
-0.0057823788,
-0.0079276292,
0.0228260551,
0.0140564181,
-0.0162075851,
-0.0077372999,
0.0393003635,
0.0217675623,
0.02343316,
0.0991915986,
-0.0062030521,
0.0004893392,
0.0025242651,
0.0054980791,
-0.0268336721,
0.017346831,
0.0150931505,
-0.0764198974,
0.0021143267,
-0.0940653235,
-0.0008227479,
0.027534876,
0.0301357545,
-0.0458936356,
-0.0547131002,
-0.0111997966,
-0.0301279593,
-0.0049134158,
0.0382209904,
0.0737229884,
0.003613655,
-0.0510491244,
0.0423626602,
-0.0043422966,
-0.0330997184,
0.0201156642,
-0.0518533848,
-0.0091608027,
0.0027634357,
0.0371964127,
-0.0543914326,
-0.011536736,
-0.0005820628,
0.0375161022,
0.0016932279,
0.0655770823,
-0.0016149889,
0.0091712102,
-0.0364275798,
-0.0351208001,
-0.0145551013,
0.029483797,
0.0117264502,
0.0329245515,
0.004426857,
0.0287703313,
-0.0672138855,
-0.0448631495,
0.0402334966,
-0.0255538393,
-0.0390529335,
0.0066528097,
0.0050945799,
0.0126424618,
0.0007683604,
-0.0211609621,
0.0229428466,
0.0503188483,
-0.0123702576,
0.0063680452,
0.0093785441,
-0.0213620923,
-0.0134335812,
0.0614795573,
0.0052158604,
-0.0093384823,
0.053403385,
-0.0618836693,
-0.0501708053,
0.005302255,
-0.0023294964,
0.0188687574,
-0.0351438187,
0.0481635295,
-0.0503175184,
0.0107132988,
-0.0317015946,
0.0358445346,
0.008708206,
-0.011026199,
-0.0291156583,
-0.0031047107,
0.017719822,
-0.0189104974,
-0.0601210222,
-0.023048928,
-0.0164982937,
0.0331717022,
0.0328064971,
-0.0074730786,
-0.0234656837,
-0.0191134848,
-0.0746870413,
0.0290420484,
-0.0464259274,
0.0180683527,
0.0363673307,
-0.0082652317,
-0.0211685374,
-0.0391393863,
-0.0356336869,
-0.0042354371,
0.0251677874,
-0.0019033018,
0.019291997,
-0.0005008767,
-0.0012558844,
-0.0527102053,
-0.0008284422,
-0.0210141689,
0.0301713143,
-0.001987926,
-0.0106025692,
-0.0627053976,
0.0600621589,
0.0012460187,
0.055687502,
-0.0155750774,
-0.0512032881,
-0.010722328,
0.0003632131,
0.0013491322,
0.0700884834,
0.0114826309,
-0.0107207512,
0.07472343,
0.0120844012,
-0.0265969019,
0.0051873792,
-0.0284199119,
-0.0508834459,
-0.0574460588,
0.0010771474,
0.0098812059,
0.0818055049,
-0.0009076407,
-0.0244141892,
-0.0378091522,
0.0184501782,
0.0011329929,
-0.0269982331,
0.005924568,
-0.0057873172,
-0.0259614978,
0.0155663621,
-0.0197372586,
-0.0925018862,
0.0897141844,
-0.076035887,
0.0137206763,
-0.0187860318,
-0.0209058113,
-0.0045954338,
0.051355917,
0.018885823,
-0.0043007103,
0.0499404408,
0.0101695405,
-0.0772045404,
-0.021311745,
0.0288084541,
-0.0511067994,
0.0144610265,
-0.0339438133,
0.0042550308,
-0.0120892236,
-0.04018059,
-0.0687145069,
-0.0655247942,
-0.0644833744,
0.0048507177,
-0.0036950293,
0.0103911785,
-0.0339487009,
0.0148328673,
-0.0272018146,
0.0418704376,
-0.0140703656,
0.021884663,
-0.0203704201,
-0.009262532,
0.062499173,
-0.0251703486,
0.0379526168,
-0.0383787975,
0.0189853869,
0.0236653201,
0.040068727,
0.0138554182,
-0.0399446227,
-0.0133607425,
0.038598381,
-0.0086540366,
-0.0100700455,
0.0242179148,
0.0729735345,
-0.0182085503,
-0.0114181191,
0.1478557885,
0.0224081129,
-0.0363686532,
-0.0146655366,
0.0052207545,
0.0155751156,
0.0291630998,
0.0368398726,
-0.0678486675,
-0.0248648021,
0.0159147009,
0.0228659883,
-0.0088528022,
-0.0058786296,
-0.0265626926,
-0.1119341478,
-0.0040432392,
0.0197591837,
-0.0172379594,
-0.0305866096,
-0.0192426816,
0.0045519969,
-0.0268541016,
0.038739454,
-0.0094495863,
0.0114455074,
0.0036191237,
0.0433595292,
-0.0435930863,
-0.0730757415,
0.0220124479,
-0.0607337095,
0.0667720288,
0.0815873146,
0.0209107455,
-0.0072725085,
0.011019229,
0.0362094641,
0.012348162,
-0.0134737669,
0.0330321193,
0.0376612209,
-0.0203353781,
-0.0057522827,
0.043855533,
0.0362444706,
-0.0395342261,
0.0004366009,
0.0098204212,
0.0309158638,
-0.0083428621,
-0.0129359961,
-0.0079242839,
-0.0069835898,
0.0388913788,
0.0780631527,
0.0146597149,
-0.0427261926,
-0.0287059043,
-0.0329714194,
-0.015532393,
-0.0442746095,
-0.0088221543,
0.0404531136,
0.0007066865,
0.0052161044,
-0.0291846953,
-0.0138487285,
0.0300858207,
0.0294253323,
0.0220656469,
0.0028170608,
-0.0139607722,
0.0100646494,
-0.0319582187,
-0.0028617834,
-0.0631497279,
0.0251471531,
-0.0689387694,
0.0066456045,
0.0150317671,
-0.0431197472,
0.0031204547,
0.0003162812,
-0.1332875043,
-0.1007188857,
-0.0103656799,
0.1044497713,
0.0264543202,
0.0490045957,
-0.0395452604,
-0.0745458379,
0.0975676253,
0.0343650877,
0.001809039,
0.00818663,
0.0460493565,
-0.0685654283,
0.0025267545,
0.0350133553,
-0.0380719379,
0.0161333252,
0.078951776,
0.0090539884,
-0.0155070405,
-0.0686347783,
0.0272653215,
-0.0041316962,
0.1068857387,
-0.0302744489,
-0.0182144959,
-0.003785816,
0.0248508286,
-0.0185056292,
-0.0375333577,
-0.0193389487,
-0.0116785271,
0.0218629576,
0.0046599996,
0.0118897576,
-0.0112530626,
-0.0229857862,
0.0244024768,
-0.0254092366,
-0.0118934,
0.0458430126,
0.0295523051,
0.0530601628,
-0.0013365069,
-0.0009965668,
0.0113312267,
0.0189088881,
0.0196211319,
0.0246298779,
0.020157434,
0.0139800822,
0.0041160686,
-0.0254731812,
0.0132020339,
-0.0922539756,
-0.0285747498,
-0.0584119745,
0.0234369654,
0.0798112676,
-0.0290615149,
0.0203332081,
-0.0150494752,
-0.0007285443,
-0.0424656235,
0.0247170199,
0.0081487717,
-0.0067449845,
0.0308377929,
-0.0067620571,
-0.0242746156,
0.0403906778,
0.0905039981,
0.0226105414,
0.0703033954,
0.0236551724,
-0.0316522606,
-0.0177210178,
-0.008763779,
-0.0022848817,
0.0021305715,
-0.0564798117,
-0.011045034,
-0.0217570756,
-0.0922725871,
0.0503155291,
0.0450347513,
0.0195951164,
-0.0061833654,
-0.00463783,
0.0645861328,
-0.0189058259,
0.0207430981,
-0.0425466895,
0.0146345561,
-0.0011544399,
-0.0079503674,
-0.0007230655,
-6.4725643e-33,
-0.0332810096,
-0.0067338925,
0.0100694457,
0.007870703,
0.0267939251,
0.0282046143,
-0.0299155694,
0.0183052998,
-0.0168405659,
-0.0002555556,
-0.0290832575,
0.0183786396,
0.0261162203,
0.0211618114,
-0.0084410496,
-0.0222733617,
0.047807999,
-0.0450100899,
-0.0499061868,
-0.0213546921,
-0.0073440378,
0.0443308763,
0.0705287382,
-0.0456372425,
0.0255802684,
-0.0139151188,
-0.0397892371,
0.0210013855,
-0.008741972,
0.0582298674,
-0.0042979876,
0.0341832153,
0.0086792503,
0.0164983571,
-0.0305951387,
0.0247496329,
-0.0315152518,
0.0026660257,
0.0055884961,
0.05000218,
-0.0046314965,
0.0094963061,
0.0271107182,
-0.0245497469,
-0.0274846833,
0.0077136522,
0.0195480511,
-0.0425458215,
-0.0052233776,
-0.0003414842,
-0.020362664,
-0.0019245831,
-0.0025515531,
-0.0481234938,
0.0419319533,
0.0410381705,
0.0282433163,
-0.0008184726,
-0.0713749304,
0.0185284615,
0.0215646569,
0.0394566134,
0.0884916931,
0.0614328645,
-0.0054281438,
0.0506605431,
-0.0032492925,
0.0269071441,
-0.0112153133,
-0.0047509242,
0.0409111828,
0.0139587494,
0.0521570258,
0.0658063069,
0.0476066992,
-0.0334656388,
-0.0762875453,
0.0377809703,
0.021141801,
-0.0108444896,
0.0549116842,
0.0232758261,
-0.0301880278,
-0.0244961381,
-0.0480747819,
-0.0543238521,
-0.0180512331,
-0.0193438642,
0.0000488669,
0.0458428897,
-0.0289070718,
-0.010938189,
0.0343231857,
-0.0690422803,
-0.0140835904,
-0.0079311933,
0.0026175582,
-0.007377964,
-0.0346871205,
0.0587053709,
-0.0334262103,
-0.0291453395,
0.0012809663,
-0.0056896773,
0.0246919207,
0.0114156613,
0.0530664884,
0.0429906435,
-0.0379222147,
0.0098893605,
-0.0287196357,
0.0100497277,
0.056917198,
0.0404824987,
0.0366675816,
0.007116762,
-0.0073822928,
0.0222332515,
0.0046442831,
-0.0523441695,
-0.017181186,
0.008008264,
0.0048041753,
0.0146674486,
-0.0304211639,
-0.027914511,
-0.0163635537,
-0.0146065122,
0.0196131542,
-0.0435118191,
-0.004068098,
-0.0333891585,
2.775e-7,
0.0599399842,
0.017765278,
0.001097656,
0.0013753683,
0.0115172751,
0.0539788045,
-0.037292067,
0.0451189391,
0.0289815739,
-0.0313802324,
0.0115995035,
0.0147704845,
0.057500165,
0.0296933446,
-0.0674633831,
-0.0289094839,
-0.043657966,
0.0356048793,
-0.0089281201,
-0.0136211496,
0.0207085088,
0.101448223,
0.0354232863,
-0.0087153781,
-0.0325816199,
-0.0437043272,
0.0573364645,
-0.0270680282,
0.0021899883,
0.0379591733,
0.0290849824,
0.0326216668,
-0.0214134194,
0.0470586754,
-0.039900057,
0.0264910404,
-0.0100439359,
0.0462914556,
0.0231878273,
-0.0050507537,
-0.0307183769,
0.0187150761,
0.0080341632,
-0.0386494622,
0.0764288604,
-0.0718476251,
-0.0170117915,
-0.0684227049,
0.0068023507,
-0.0340806395,
0.0324060395,
-0.0150650898,
0.0020058537,
0.0158120394,
0.02660105,
0.0115488702,
-0.0177107006,
-0.0916109607,
-0.063842088,
0.0143526644,
-0.0223380718,
-0.0008859896,
-0.0079338998,
-0.0266244784,
0.024766406,
-0.0820465013,
0.0453463197,
2.604290056e-34,
0.0328502432,
-0.0255823266,
0.006547004,
0.0068429043,
0.0288863368,
-0.0036645574,
-0.0140024517,
-0.0053388663,
0.0206829067,
-0.0532631613,
-0.0172083005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11315v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11315v2 | GIST: Generating Image-Specific Text for Fine-grained Object Classification | 2023-07-21T02:47:18 | 2023-08-04T19:36:31 | Kathleen M. Lewis, Emily Mu, Adrian V. Dalca, John Guttag | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent vision-language models outperform vision-only models on many image
classification tasks. However, because of the absence of paired text/image
descriptions, it remains difficult to fine-tune these models for fine-grained
image classification. In this work, we propose a method, GIST, for generating
image-specific fine-grained text descriptions from image-only datasets, and
show that these text descriptions can be used to improve classification. Key
parts of our method include 1. prompting a pretrained large language model with
domain-specific prompts to generate diverse fine-grained text descriptions for
each class and 2. using a pretrained vision-language model to match each image
to label-preserving text descriptions that capture relevant visual features in
the image. We demonstrate the utility of GIST by fine-tuning vision-language
models on the image-and-generated-text pairs to learn an aligned
vision-language representation space for improved classification. We evaluate
our learned representation space in full-shot and few-shot scenarios across
four diverse fine-grained classification datasets, each from a different
domain. Our method achieves an average improvement of $4.1\%$ in accuracy over
CLIP linear probes and an average of $1.1\%$ improvement in accuracy over the
previous state-of-the-art image-text classification method on the full-shot
datasets. Our method achieves similar improvements across few-shot regimes.
Code is available at https://github.com/emu1729/GIST. | [
0.055775471,
0.0347346254,
0.0287385043,
0.0502796471,
-0.0198240466,
0.026523089,
0.0368321911,
0.0159903858,
-0.0208444446,
-0.1196568757,
-0.0342250764,
0.018351743,
0.0241639335,
0.025700083,
0.0267442092,
-0.0639441013,
-0.0222463533,
-0.0185014941,
0.0285199434,
0.0087602399,
0.0459660478,
0.04580158,
0.0192791875,
0.0215554032,
0.0071488786,
0.0097483918,
0.0180854201,
0.0270846598,
0.0412692502,
-0.0155041963,
0.023377968,
0.0599936061,
0.0356868878,
-0.0095998561,
0.0000018703,
-0.0217907596,
0.0390152782,
0.0229162294,
-0.0018380847,
-0.0131218154,
0.049700439,
-0.0482100286,
0.0367307886,
-0.0256755259,
0.0099195112,
-0.0263263509,
0.0669768304,
0.0588861518,
0.0272004828,
0.04193772,
-0.047943607,
-0.0663408339,
-0.0274696946,
-0.0466026403,
0.0360685512,
-0.0415379703,
0.0108252261,
0.0088506825,
-0.0023386071,
0.0690135881,
-0.0179794207,
0.0111349616,
0.0040340475,
-0.0084847864,
0.0173635278,
0.046232406,
-0.0398417041,
-0.0220952109,
0.0012150961,
0.0722169802,
-0.0118371546,
-0.0431811213,
-0.0199668538,
-0.0396888219,
-0.0061518503,
-0.0401229151,
-0.0112155415,
0.0344540626,
-0.0145076131,
0.0143195139,
-0.0399667025,
0.0267771129,
0.002384,
0.0286433287,
-0.002503668,
-0.0492567345,
0.0127746789,
0.0173875,
-0.0529323816,
0.0287178848,
-0.004432179,
-0.0765284449,
-0.0402924828,
0.0266196001,
0.0090641584,
-0.0439634472,
-0.0676557645,
-0.0261945818,
0.0128205419,
0.0035371881,
0.0262786597,
-0.0260476004,
-0.0800250992,
0.0713936016,
-0.0357631668,
0.0228591263,
0.0134523092,
0.0284596272,
-0.0417195968,
-0.004452656,
-0.043224562,
0.0080993315,
-0.0279938411,
0.0196412914,
-0.0115617709,
-0.0374520048,
-0.0293921512,
0.0007528255,
-0.0116085391,
0.0334383696,
-0.028492989,
0.0129526034,
-0.0303197168,
-0.0191358924,
0.0017760718,
0.0076216878,
-0.0423834361,
0.0337911695,
0.0092904093,
-0.0090235509,
-0.0013573045,
0.0645908639,
0.0411649682,
-0.0168099497,
0.0064411685,
0.0269399434,
-0.0316185281,
-0.0652976856,
-0.0142868496,
-0.0296615157,
-0.0550482236,
-0.0598541945,
-0.0212952793,
-0.0544018596,
0.043658141,
0.0090609342,
0.0079124849,
-0.0344428979,
0.0096978797,
0.0049936259,
-0.0244135819,
0.1028226018,
-0.0475267209,
-0.024356056,
0.0160769224,
0.0056142313,
0.0317728184,
0.0470339432,
-0.0106117325,
0.0865764916,
0.0099788327,
-0.0144637516,
0.0310903229,
0.0302615929,
-0.0138473241,
0.0201364104,
-0.0531604961,
0.0002263108,
-0.0179233402,
0.0316600092,
0.0101887891,
0.0389670916,
-0.0087033799,
0.0172419883,
0.0723507255,
0.0217842944,
0.0073599806,
0.020475205,
0.0599106066,
0.0312523432,
-0.0018292095,
-0.0068779495,
-0.0601632968,
0.0379268713,
-0.0173300821,
0.0263001248,
-0.0037608505,
-0.0066153454,
-0.0587060861,
-0.0362220556,
-0.0023828738,
-0.0498359911,
0.0179724284,
0.0201705117,
0.0780586824,
0.0264943875,
-0.0103690131,
0.0025883154,
0.0572227016,
-0.0206223782,
0.0118859066,
-0.0495948605,
0.0317370817,
0.0723173395,
0.0005004547,
0.0054864376,
-0.0106665529,
-0.0027421294,
0.0863488466,
0.0549123585,
0.0373188406,
0.0050173672,
0.0049264263,
-0.058836367,
-0.079274781,
-0.0406432301,
-0.0149492295,
-0.0216673668,
-0.0047536776,
0.0242251176,
0.0562086925,
-0.0165574122,
-0.0555331223,
0.0608562902,
0.0529612042,
-0.0471266732,
0.0162685588,
0.0250768438,
-0.0383682214,
-0.015504363,
-0.0216912031,
-0.0055668969,
0.0062518595,
-0.0264594909,
0.006172345,
-0.0243261717,
0.0107851988,
-0.0172105506,
-0.0176870916,
0.0056550521,
-0.0002808976,
-0.0286426395,
-0.0508606285,
-0.0224331263,
-0.02366044,
0.0008651003,
-0.0265425369,
-0.0426555946,
-0.0196777694,
-0.0092045721,
0.0131539442,
-0.0390831642,
0.0358251035,
0.0458577015,
-0.0196972527,
-0.0208777096,
-0.0007896355,
0.0335665606,
-0.005257092,
-0.0409006551,
-0.038599167,
-0.0157618653,
0.0194565877,
0.043148879,
0.0541130304,
-0.0239544492,
-0.0070201172,
-0.0568853766,
-0.0502349995,
-0.0159087237,
-0.0151213501,
-0.0224247761,
-0.0207881872,
0.0225521643,
-0.0329433903,
-0.0511707217,
0.0301333498,
-0.0117199682,
-0.0084273098,
0.0310596749,
0.0207372606,
0.022519704,
-0.0057254415,
0.0192004628,
0.0387371741,
0.0604317784,
0.0472589731,
-0.037161909,
-0.0803486258,
0.0155697912,
-0.0308406539,
0.020530181,
0.0022681728,
-0.0313503407,
0.0161254462,
-0.00664098,
-0.0212704726,
0.0492691025,
0.0082347048,
0.0130291283,
0.010901534,
0.0460482314,
-0.0264399294,
-0.0210427381,
-0.0092090266,
-0.0427279957,
-0.0159894265,
-0.0169054344,
-0.0157089178,
0.0276021771,
-0.0184739511,
0.0175737888,
-0.0888958126,
0.0230421126,
0.0136678992,
-0.0026254181,
-0.0563833341,
0.0081900246,
0.0095631192,
0.0106846113,
-0.0341055021,
-0.0723239779,
0.039680779,
-0.0570857972,
-0.0028100607,
0.0173453335,
-0.0261788405,
-0.0170638692,
0.086712122,
-0.0027387852,
0.0393140092,
0.039573431,
0.0091324551,
-0.0340649784,
-0.053430967,
0.015304693,
0.0105175367,
0.0410196446,
-0.0181299392,
0.0274395905,
-0.0460227355,
-0.0420712084,
-0.0067602941,
-0.0395462215,
-0.0480970405,
0.0102971215,
-0.0682594925,
-0.0166276563,
-0.0265009459,
0.0302966032,
0.0137854042,
0.0410228297,
-0.0281090662,
-0.0007829195,
-0.0069715185,
0.0215037577,
0.0792520568,
-0.0123039614,
-0.0626116917,
-0.0264968965,
-0.0066559161,
0.0358896852,
-0.0319585763,
0.0532534383,
-0.0412753783,
-0.0182459559,
0.023730142,
0.050755769,
0.0220289081,
0.0387560762,
0.0627194196,
-0.0458139107,
-0.0292573106,
0.090803504,
0.0056104069,
-0.0599823482,
-0.0298875049,
0.0470218845,
0.0447388589,
0.0302381217,
0.0078501096,
-0.0871944278,
-0.0770190209,
-0.0182863716,
0.0045771627,
0.0242194403,
0.0519644246,
-0.0505912751,
-0.0556452051,
0.023201853,
0.0245555844,
-0.0199035928,
-0.0556528307,
0.0453879088,
0.0078431834,
0.0117517607,
-0.0446879826,
-0.0454603173,
0.0038080649,
-0.0096936291,
0.0114090964,
-0.0026072212,
-0.0669270828,
0.0274278931,
-0.0351561047,
-0.0069730855,
0.0489557758,
0.0007239033,
-0.0279139541,
-0.0410273038,
0.0381740034,
0.0094897356,
0.0246055163,
-0.0059416918,
0.0713707581,
-0.042052839,
-0.0568996668,
0.0286559779,
0.0386540145,
0.007605582,
-0.0281793103,
0.0054440326,
-0.0012612045,
-0.0163858291,
-0.0321077034,
-0.02929339,
-0.0082898643,
0.0329286605,
0.0478393808,
0.0350288413,
-0.0749980882,
-0.0133336149,
-0.002025475,
-0.0294167381,
-0.022627227,
-0.0246537887,
-0.0070878137,
-0.0138007235,
-0.0037285378,
-0.0538430028,
-0.0311550908,
0.0742857605,
-0.0047061667,
0.0057616713,
-0.0100236032,
-0.0285032373,
-0.0197838899,
-0.0704482421,
0.0595303625,
-0.0444154479,
0.0306379944,
-0.0401623696,
-0.0329177044,
0.0534244142,
-0.0644566566,
-0.0205830466,
0.0404742695,
-0.0914425105,
-0.0325553976,
-0.0270654,
0.0671937093,
0.0014427456,
0.0232248511,
0.0076256013,
-0.0748049915,
0.0476252809,
0.0599433072,
0.0098039312,
0.0033039467,
-0.0054574367,
-0.0483814403,
-0.0284584481,
0.0331087969,
-0.0627508909,
0.0605387203,
0.051086098,
-0.0252656974,
0.0019959677,
-0.0334586613,
0.0030879788,
-0.0201696288,
0.0681797639,
-0.0524258912,
-0.0010353709,
-0.0139212497,
0.0026286733,
0.0243467521,
-0.0445215628,
-0.0530555882,
-0.0137472339,
0.0104476018,
-0.0077192076,
0.0091188392,
-0.0017533717,
-0.0003118361,
0.0530618057,
-0.0567924194,
-0.0127572296,
-0.0263570827,
0.0117508508,
0.0254055485,
0.0210263226,
-0.0168451462,
0.0429184064,
-0.0339992754,
0.0148621993,
-0.0220533665,
0.0574835539,
0.0522103086,
0.0149606382,
-0.0451599471,
0.0326795243,
0.0329559967,
-0.0149122579,
-0.0661423132,
0.0133743519,
0.0127677629,
-0.0096821878,
-0.0123505285,
-0.0118537722,
-0.0381551497,
-0.017939711,
0.0751015469,
-0.0186678991,
-0.0359599926,
0.0388032123,
0.0106853023,
-0.0245488621,
-0.013900795,
0.0579177476,
0.0391399637,
0.0136852516,
0.0266164932,
0.0120142801,
-0.0354093984,
-0.006356542,
0.0253903978,
0.0024258413,
0.0103136385,
0.0556217246,
-0.0130318282,
-0.0277816579,
-0.0183871929,
-0.0189666357,
-0.0174650121,
0.0298025776,
0.0716729313,
0.0322021246,
0.0076036598,
0.0061588422,
-0.0029654885,
-0.0298588481,
0.0115224114,
0.0205950867,
-0.0083134361,
-5.860938793e-33,
-0.0108836526,
-0.042722784,
0.0192553289,
0.0197109431,
-0.0149937877,
0.0138573339,
-0.0205602255,
0.0071394369,
-0.008581032,
0.0340974852,
0.047579933,
-0.0242616292,
0.0114706783,
0.0704080462,
-0.0001893473,
0.0193780791,
0.0309431348,
0.0158213302,
-0.0043391702,
0.043602474,
0.0091720661,
-0.0023000785,
0.0604622774,
-0.0474641211,
0.0180045925,
-0.0178621542,
-0.0461812727,
-0.00974367,
0.0196070969,
0.039148137,
-0.0110514257,
0.0181405563,
0.0174989793,
0.0082970727,
-0.0189405344,
0.0276706573,
-0.0525862761,
-0.0083942991,
-0.0053813029,
0.003783406,
-0.04027877,
0.0043133134,
0.0339362249,
-0.0482261926,
0.0196554549,
-0.0388342366,
0.070687823,
-0.0289393477,
0.0093767196,
-0.0330555588,
-0.0629801154,
0.021483371,
-0.0043872781,
-0.0494734272,
0.0555362552,
-0.0102840988,
0.0229093041,
0.061438825,
-0.0281702336,
0.0140055018,
0.0138792731,
0.0191263352,
0.0301902164,
0.0404413417,
-0.0235575736,
0.0478214584,
0.0062984121,
0.0109803118,
-0.017990116,
-0.0104324659,
0.019953806,
0.0436377786,
0.0567901805,
0.0705375597,
0.0198884029,
-0.0121148843,
-0.0469354279,
0.0179937705,
-0.0822527856,
0.025855124,
0.018550979,
-0.0148046864,
0.0060101193,
-0.0047921739,
-0.0604248121,
-0.0039416589,
-0.0502864495,
0.0147006502,
0.0284023508,
0.0466107093,
-0.0222377218,
0.0276207961,
0.0380832665,
-0.0203779899,
-0.0019448028,
-0.0045337738,
-0.0283777416,
0.0256288163,
-0.00744985,
-0.0332656801,
-0.0359478332,
-0.0787623674,
0.0663136691,
0.0166241061,
0.0097986273,
0.0216461997,
0.109172374,
0.0166656934,
-0.0525878705,
0.0304076783,
-0.0176606681,
0.0070672776,
-0.0062585906,
0.0354456604,
0.0101184584,
0.0260057412,
-0.0472907871,
0.0394030549,
0.0043950072,
-0.046163965,
0.0179637186,
0.0048194756,
0.0061191726,
0.0353162587,
-0.015918646,
0.0315280855,
-0.0332426913,
-0.0191934332,
0.0555023476,
0.0051250183,
0.0098394817,
0.0276706014,
2.462e-7,
0.0266744886,
0.0201183464,
0.0036751179,
0.0189810973,
-0.015705524,
0.0810252205,
0.0136883445,
0.0387892947,
-0.0018465022,
0.0053640646,
0.0162127372,
0.0207430385,
0.0434885919,
-0.0549561046,
-0.0367779583,
0.0911328867,
-0.0369947627,
0.0028415972,
-0.0458258055,
0.0114697143,
0.0686929747,
0.0960938707,
0.0052988227,
-0.0079557961,
0.0700592324,
-0.0770847276,
0.0876156539,
-0.0333602354,
0.0316740684,
0.0079065962,
-0.0344210044,
0.0434603505,
-0.052312322,
0.0284389015,
-0.0166407079,
-0.0371567383,
0.0309110265,
0.0373083092,
-0.0408221632,
0.0370547362,
-0.0178273935,
0.031006014,
-0.0042668041,
-0.0620887466,
0.0664932653,
-0.1095064133,
-0.0122798989,
-0.0659620166,
0.0092858188,
0.0100302463,
0.0095024845,
-0.0377668105,
-0.0116222389,
0.0100770602,
0.0481480882,
0.0047875373,
-0.0347037837,
-0.1162578091,
-0.0264277048,
0.0138376104,
-0.0003582501,
0.0201401524,
-0.0491540842,
-0.03349372,
0.0248989072,
-0.0567947887,
-0.0190661717,
1.780105393e-34,
0.0072526918,
0.0059431917,
-0.0293193366,
-0.0421033092,
0.0177960787,
0.0144351535,
-0.008969265,
0.0088472273,
-0.0120686358,
-0.0476431362,
-0.0123557169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04524v1 | Who should I Collaborate with? A Comparative Study of Academia and Industry Research Collaboration in NLP | 2023-07-21T01:26:29 | 2023-07-21T01:26:29 | Hussain Sadiq Abuwala, Bohan Zhang, Mushi Wang | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | The goal of our research was to investigate the effects of collaboration
between academia and industry on Natural Language Processing (NLP). To do this,
we created a pipeline to extract affiliations and citations from NLP papers and
divided them into three categories: academia, industry, and hybrid
(collaborations between academia and industry). Our empirical analysis found
that there is a trend towards an increase in industry and academia-industry
collaboration publications and that these types of publications tend to have a
higher impact compared to those produced solely within academia. | [
0.0991837084,
0.0274783298,
-0.016115997,
-0.0356982909,
-0.0642427877,
-0.0326106586,
0.0907247886,
-0.0146269714,
0.0219364781,
-0.0814230964,
-0.0048534651,
0.0870046765,
0.0211419575,
0.0224119145,
-0.0070978971,
0.0125035113,
-0.0020029868,
0.0619791336,
0.0555276796,
0.0013976938,
0.0141331609,
0.0312548876,
-0.0224248935,
0.0687054843,
0.0271436684,
-0.0073884572,
0.0558740869,
-0.0184736773,
0.0292331539,
0.0186264943,
0.0215998571,
0.0266681481,
-0.0002935415,
0.054996755,
0.0000013409,
-0.0785349011,
-0.0605328791,
0.0349462926,
0.0241704304,
0.0346090794,
0.0146323089,
-0.007038163,
-0.0183270387,
0.012371893,
-0.0488173477,
0.0085309111,
0.0418510102,
0.0106228534,
-0.0156444963,
0.0411377102,
0.0073707858,
-0.0950975269,
0.0206428021,
-0.0106947189,
-0.074866116,
0.0023692066,
0.0376547351,
-0.01374692,
-0.0165653732,
0.0149373543,
0.0145213399,
0.0266219452,
-0.0177414287,
-0.0502606183,
0.0670385659,
0.0788973868,
-0.0299422145,
0.0225156229,
-0.0050622197,
0.0170247443,
0.032960929,
0.0094768405,
0.0363198668,
-0.0005138217,
0.0125352526,
0.0545644052,
-0.0007463283,
0.0195867829,
0.0024684672,
0.0059092273,
-0.0182723068,
0.026579896,
-0.003650612,
0.0401431918,
0.0075373827,
0.0327729508,
-0.032340467,
-0.0387347415,
0.0439042412,
0.0103973756,
0.0338370614,
-0.0330171436,
0.0281329546,
-0.0168550666,
0.0323166922,
0.0201165527,
0.034892194,
-0.0205871891,
0.0259185527,
0.0159015767,
-0.054489322,
-0.0315369926,
0.0192834623,
0.0283179358,
-0.0460431501,
-0.0508219078,
-0.007719249,
0.0159235224,
0.040372733,
0.0330765583,
-0.1256423295,
-0.0237763133,
-0.0145077975,
0.0089747915,
-0.0115730818,
-0.0379027389,
-0.020518871,
-0.0326744318,
-0.0214493219,
0.038077835,
0.0027917172,
0.06600447,
0.017240515,
0.0087221507,
-0.0340365246,
0.0452954881,
-0.0034637635,
0.0401922017,
-0.0438741855,
-0.0097081559,
0.0553637594,
-0.0235617291,
0.0234157145,
-0.0395058356,
0.0296325888,
0.0394147299,
0.0230704714,
-0.0467468128,
0.014487138,
-0.0280536264,
0.0308630392,
-0.0357507281,
0.0213026553,
-0.0254975185,
0.0409534164,
0.0404889882,
-0.0013492381,
-0.0917090848,
0.0100386776,
-0.012566478,
-0.0369018055,
0.0197945517,
-0.0582361408,
0.0049294611,
0.0267456565,
-0.0132158613,
0.0221824218,
0.0187939573,
0.0184711143,
-0.0080093462,
0.0584870689,
-0.0123845134,
-0.0299932286,
-0.011622468,
-0.0351585373,
-0.0541395135,
0.0687995255,
0.0094379494,
-0.0301727019,
0.029550584,
0.0000397572,
0.0431337394,
-0.0288270973,
0.0086494079,
0.0143326046,
0.0559386201,
0.045233909,
0.0014897109,
-0.0210704114,
0.0516538247,
-0.002279836,
-0.0439492203,
-0.0144213019,
-0.0035669573,
0.0152693521,
0.0134254778,
0.036715515,
0.0389211737,
0.0214412306,
-0.0236992873,
-0.0028233146,
0.0481570512,
-0.011709922,
-0.0219437126,
0.0328843854,
-0.0232730173,
-0.0417483747,
0.0432301909,
-0.011906581,
0.0107796602,
-0.0055950265,
0.031637989,
-0.0235156249,
0.0330248624,
0.0406287089,
-0.0168070067,
0.0443132669,
-0.0576621443,
-0.0488697886,
0.0490736067,
-0.010886685,
0.0166675467,
-0.0136096431,
0.0045083733,
-0.0143153239,
-0.0193177722,
-0.0250803567,
0.0001406952,
0.0350740254,
0.0461731032,
-0.019656729,
0.0213215481,
-0.0444141775,
0.0441146567,
-0.0266639274,
0.0242385808,
-0.0084246621,
-0.0083080586,
0.0090174368,
0.0883297697,
-0.031012252,
0.0348616876,
0.0404904559,
-0.0368476212,
-0.0090993792,
0.0203376804,
0.0663766712,
0.0454795584,
0.0073910845,
-0.0633573607,
-0.0268306639,
-0.0410757437,
-0.0333353616,
0.0204840638,
0.0659608915,
0.001894614,
0.0536694676,
0.0327787846,
-0.0533734411,
-0.0500597395,
-0.0065448103,
-0.0475908853,
0.0288810041,
-0.0059238155,
0.0515181385,
-0.0225455333,
-0.0359707437,
0.0011129841,
0.0034949502,
-0.0040265424,
0.0388038605,
-0.0140176155,
-0.0108379219,
0.0574679337,
-0.054979112,
-0.0537633859,
-0.0096411202,
0.0006566597,
-0.0098743439,
0.0166359562,
0.0117823854,
-0.0063125365,
-0.0464558974,
0.0002126495,
0.0080168853,
0.0262791235,
-0.0325056054,
-0.0290338285,
-0.0133759109,
0.0379199609,
0.0481001362,
-0.0193922352,
-0.0216773693,
-0.0039684828,
-0.000040443,
0.0096867234,
0.0888120532,
-0.0473447479,
-0.0601064377,
-0.0223282054,
-0.0194913112,
-0.013414287,
0.0005905195,
0.0140535822,
0.0149885984,
0.0626779199,
-0.0321433246,
0.014621445,
-0.0309823323,
0.0101338197,
0.0253959447,
-2.141e-7,
-0.035550952,
-0.001611157,
-0.0320908353,
0.0203440655,
-0.0266431496,
-0.0274601914,
0.0462953374,
-0.0041691605,
-0.0145903071,
-0.0210141335,
0.0292682257,
0.003617645,
-0.0023627791,
-0.0028978833,
-0.0047607864,
-0.0364747569,
0.0145472866,
0.0707543641,
0.0249887556,
-0.0047369148,
0.0220511667,
-0.0116225006,
0.0051994729,
-0.0717777759,
-0.0089083882,
-0.0520119369,
0.0554082058,
-0.0100409575,
-0.016451098,
0.0383464471,
-0.0389341041,
0.0095625613,
0.0392838232,
0.0139650563,
-0.0158150736,
-0.0146968402,
-0.0061902222,
0.0235134792,
-0.030158814,
0.0506933592,
-0.008278219,
0.0037835271,
-0.048092667,
0.0523306504,
0.0772182718,
-0.0100044105,
-0.0333905332,
-0.0120670106,
0.0385440774,
-0.0062980456,
0.03825102,
-0.0256417599,
-0.0289287549,
0.0247661658,
0.031299267,
0.0123299854,
0.049081929,
0.0525691807,
-0.0646067932,
-0.0032035762,
0.0142739033,
0.0064217709,
-0.0464726947,
-0.0648082942,
0.0090423562,
-0.0990633965,
-0.0141044715,
-0.023688456,
-0.0110441446,
-0.010433482,
0.0404543243,
0.0463079251,
0.0110468389,
-0.0420182757,
-0.0065598423,
-0.0061537218,
-0.0318268426,
0.0268395133,
0.0222377703,
-0.0636612177,
-0.0011831204,
-0.010189753,
-0.0375838876,
-0.0504462756,
-0.0617613494,
-0.0405636914,
-0.0903830975,
0.0310618021,
-0.0670360997,
-0.0144446818,
0.0103951553,
-0.0830309391,
-0.0000765237,
-0.0485083573,
0.0163899213,
-0.0301969759,
-0.0443601646,
-0.0008730494,
0.051342655,
-0.0669603348,
-0.0798106715,
-0.0151833268,
-0.0493768193,
0.0442376658,
0.0396657102,
0.0218483265,
-0.0690224022,
0.0065522003,
-0.027657466,
0.0207260214,
0.0281655081,
0.0116991112,
0.0661555156,
-0.0414707363,
0.0242589694,
0.0231101979,
-0.0001230866,
-0.0775692612,
0.0379259884,
0.0279338341,
0.027563747,
0.0210640002,
0.0163466204,
-0.0111121796,
0.0113507137,
-0.0102605093,
0.0574538372,
-0.0432199836,
-0.0226941947,
-0.0267095994,
0.0162234847,
0.0287186429,
0.0009648537,
-0.022580646,
-0.0596051626,
-0.0591051318,
-0.0443182178,
-0.056657847,
-0.0509320758,
0.0704239234,
-0.0248139985,
0.0105921831,
0.0637837499,
0.0213408079,
-0.0114357136,
-0.0042456398,
-0.0051990245,
0.0171845593,
0.0644718483,
-0.0125010423,
-0.0093673123,
0.0167275835,
0.0576829426,
-0.0459212773,
0.0006689119,
-0.0037561136,
-0.0666110888,
0.0011048744,
0.0020663375,
0.0195097439,
0.0447526313,
-0.0044351756,
-0.0369403847,
-0.0157108493,
0.0959805101,
-0.026829619,
-0.0336165242,
-0.0177151635,
-0.0584499128,
-0.0056367829,
-0.031785842,
-0.0250011384,
-0.0190100987,
0.0235215724,
0.0011741999,
-0.0165684409,
-0.0526455007,
0.0181961749,
-0.0119342469,
0.0484557599,
-0.0563318543,
0.0581800826,
-0.0277459901,
-0.0131533686,
-0.0049910708,
0.0162268076,
-0.012640493,
-0.0361293592,
0.0214047302,
-0.0030641202,
0.0098126382,
0.0737336874,
-0.027830014,
0.0496719703,
-0.0077950987,
0.0599348806,
0.0233102702,
0.0596147478,
0.0001972868,
-0.0287892912,
-0.0199871063,
-0.0290011819,
-0.0081005068,
0.0363016091,
0.0127211427,
-0.0030834381,
0.0161847025,
-0.019702537,
0.0243461058,
0.0033816993,
-0.0783892199,
-0.0427911319,
0.016378548,
-0.006920178,
0.0346383005,
-0.0074289055,
0.0362200327,
-0.0405784622,
0.0116703343,
0.0077426932,
0.0312866196,
0.0137007236,
-0.007287364,
0.0127322674,
-0.0114586102,
-0.0462514199,
-0.0022540786,
0.0718015805,
0.0314595588,
-0.0018942676,
-0.0339602567,
-0.0202751551,
0.0174599066,
-0.0385658517,
0.0027771264,
0.0589548536,
0.0151948733,
0.0171186272,
-0.0209811274,
0.0201596003,
-0.0190720279,
-0.0500664748,
0.0182745997,
-0.0225432292,
-0.0149051063,
0.026885679,
0.0735313669,
-0.0316656567,
-0.0192978699,
0.0361635983,
-0.0427897163,
-0.0601897314,
-0.028705338,
-5.414657955e-33,
0.0348441936,
-0.0586007833,
0.0123865288,
-0.0004511737,
-0.030267287,
0.0451460555,
0.013400645,
0.0201010928,
-0.0700303614,
-0.0088607054,
-0.0561756603,
-0.0104481773,
0.0195678938,
-0.0269120485,
0.0729217604,
0.0209286064,
0.0136991348,
-0.0156506822,
0.014431145,
-0.0055567096,
0.0153048066,
0.0061950213,
0.0710322484,
-0.0961458907,
0.0725396276,
-0.011315559,
-0.0270204376,
-0.0066086901,
0.0352503285,
0.0309306402,
-0.0102087008,
0.0234333407,
0.0273348782,
-0.0957440883,
0.0151408315,
-0.0097552203,
-0.0565004684,
0.0024737087,
0.0437844023,
-0.0131632099,
-0.0197324175,
0.0053605931,
0.0621782355,
-0.0198709127,
-0.027992595,
-0.0099216383,
0.082263656,
-0.0247798581,
-0.0252693631,
-0.0285543595,
-0.054482542,
-0.0039526671,
-0.0417282768,
0.0904325396,
0.0240476225,
-0.0157890636,
0.0064804507,
0.0175337456,
-0.0579065233,
-0.019513499,
-0.0309285726,
0.0126742767,
0.054069519,
-0.0314650498,
0.0054623671,
0.0189308897,
-0.0237613395,
0.0023160405,
0.0210724212,
-0.0470355265,
0.0182943176,
0.0635398924,
-0.0021539473,
0.0469992757,
0.0263746884,
-0.0486978963,
0.0020976344,
-0.0045770667,
0.055730477,
0.0070689754,
0.0267452244,
0.0148886843,
0.0042963987,
-0.0314911641,
0.0206800718,
-0.0112899914,
0.0111896088,
-0.0535925776,
-0.0265636686,
0.0120753301,
-0.0220590439,
0.0753178746,
0.0112532983,
-0.0526997969,
-0.0389273129,
0.0361625627,
-0.0023539774,
0.0339340158,
0.0060630124,
-0.0530035421,
-0.1410437375,
0.0093287053,
-0.0254689585,
-0.0033988741,
0.0344384685,
-0.0306928847,
0.0385454893,
-0.0358426534,
-0.0057581286,
-0.002043261,
-0.0017122683,
0.0514817238,
0.0010967335,
-0.0250144619,
0.0043361364,
0.0616143122,
0.0110940114,
-0.0137512488,
0.0604109168,
0.0604127012,
-0.000580321,
0.0429083146,
-0.0343063846,
0.000214415,
-0.0611526221,
-0.0072385771,
0.0329226181,
0.0122029837,
0.0124444831,
0.0096492572,
-0.026305262,
-0.071725525,
2.259e-7,
0.0677810237,
0.0432947688,
0.0111237448,
-0.0067389072,
0.0179245826,
-0.0244144984,
0.0317324325,
0.0405436046,
0.0151307527,
0.0046644001,
-0.0109015536,
-0.0519391261,
-0.0255922489,
0.0067918925,
-0.0549637303,
-0.0503315181,
-0.0482594781,
-0.0121265631,
-0.0702954754,
0.0018258189,
0.0136802588,
-0.0285435319,
0.0447071604,
0.0086896736,
-0.0714876503,
-0.0189977828,
0.0010151652,
-0.0488355234,
0.0859490931,
0.0680110678,
0.0175206065,
-0.0026926408,
0.0008983783,
0.015417398,
-0.0095133269,
0.0226014294,
-0.0058344346,
-0.0112956306,
-0.003633914,
0.0273673125,
0.0433961153,
-0.0387818292,
0.0113693448,
-0.0338391326,
0.0334621146,
-0.0407556035,
-0.0512028672,
-0.0104682883,
-0.0550857522,
-0.0498161875,
-0.0021180676,
0.0373941101,
0.0154549628,
0.0375170857,
-0.0171601586,
-0.0404570661,
-0.0195522308,
-0.0637636408,
0.0119709913,
0.0127819264,
0.0077169975,
-0.0204903129,
0.0256442092,
-0.0185861979,
0.0291911867,
-0.0051226518,
0.0108708125,
1.421212619e-34,
0.0151037863,
-0.0312020294,
0.0137001369,
0.0802590251,
0.0344038904,
0.0108118793,
-0.0583995841,
0.0106672999,
-0.0452805907,
-0.0072410554,
0.0227627177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11278v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11278v3 | Generator-Retriever-Generator Approach for Open-Domain Question Answering | 2023-07-21T00:34:38 | 2024-03-26T16:40:50 | Abdelrahman Abdallah, Adam Jatowt | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-domain question answering (QA) tasks usually require the retrieval of
relevant information from a large corpus to generate accurate answers. We
propose a novel approach called Generator-Retriever-Generator (GRG) that
combines document retrieval techniques with a large language model (LLM), by
first prompting the model to generate contextual documents based on a given
question. In parallel, a dual-encoder network retrieves documents that are
relevant to the question from an external corpus. The generated and retrieved
documents are then passed to the second LLM, which generates the final answer.
By combining document retrieval and LLM generation, our approach addresses the
challenges of open-domain QA, such as generating informative and contextually
relevant answers. GRG outperforms the state-of-the-art generate-then-read and
retrieve-then-read pipelines (GENREAD and RFiD) improving their performance by
at least by +5.2, +4.2, and +1.6 on TriviaQA, NQ, and WebQ datasets,
respectively. We provide code, datasets, and checkpoints at
https://github.com/abdoelsayed2016/GRG. | [
0.0227078684,
0.045460593,
0.0076807635,
0.0481509455,
-0.0133538647,
-0.0051246118,
-0.0059822537,
-0.0103862379,
-0.0074996906,
-0.0214497931,
-0.0058799167,
-0.0152886789,
-0.0562685914,
0.0215366445,
0.0029898463,
0.0216654632,
0.0182160847,
-0.0379210487,
0.0036162683,
-0.0123371091,
-0.0086389296,
0.0492829047,
-0.0016330973,
0.0292388201,
0.0135826916,
-0.0259847473,
-0.0241678245,
0.0004640801,
0.0002566916,
-0.003591931,
0.0499321111,
0.0034418881,
0.0673174337,
0.0263297278,
0.0000018357,
-0.0392259434,
-0.0239701793,
0.0077038906,
-0.0251440443,
-0.0323902555,
0.0054204883,
0.0090154884,
0.0302957594,
0.0419408269,
-0.0555824041,
-0.0358542874,
0.0257832725,
0.020461306,
0.0571814887,
0.0508342348,
0.0111867599,
-0.0467288196,
0.0253772158,
-0.0208119079,
0.0242531076,
-0.0417495035,
0.0161857586,
0.0219049957,
0.0298135057,
0.044715181,
-0.013214835,
0.0430175848,
0.0485444479,
-0.0046390584,
-0.0014943857,
0.0319959596,
-0.0203356892,
0.0299584642,
0.0232314169,
0.1061213389,
0.0139196161,
0.0058227736,
0.0134377684,
0.0316271037,
-0.0102418903,
0.0165771246,
-0.0537274666,
0.0343074575,
-0.0232149903,
-0.0040726089,
-0.0118457582,
0.0148647968,
-0.0001763424,
0.0141218435,
-0.0148390234,
0.0557488315,
0.039624542,
-0.0216011684,
-0.0128083546,
0.0082466099,
-0.0096361898,
-0.0593627878,
0.0234359428,
0.0805430114,
-0.0173277557,
0.0146294208,
-0.0104464283,
-0.0439322442,
0.0314920545,
-0.0311236084,
-0.0074928086,
0.0012957917,
-0.0301170908,
0.0555506721,
-0.0310903657,
0.0309849922,
-0.052673392,
-0.0004723882,
-0.0779777616,
-0.0754738003,
-0.0249654334,
-0.037029013,
-0.0597131215,
0.0333023593,
-0.0600438118,
-0.0258414708,
-0.0150384419,
0.0341245756,
0.0259555932,
-0.0194450729,
0.0096835066,
0.0558304489,
-0.0356553979,
-0.015438946,
-0.0219685864,
0.0503937528,
-0.0646954402,
0.0091471104,
0.0186896157,
-0.0373525582,
-0.0230236556,
0.004883396,
0.0303341877,
-0.0429631881,
0.0069718692,
0.0399489626,
-0.0131763658,
-0.0059950054,
-0.0395597816,
-0.0349330753,
0.0164462142,
-0.0697677657,
0.0233384073,
-0.0741712376,
0.0425404683,
0.0188421402,
-0.0366843268,
-0.0400990397,
0.0115286428,
0.0581594408,
0.014270355,
0.022103237,
-0.011154633,
-0.0220058337,
0.0757456124,
0.0291626528,
0.0339097865,
0.0589685924,
0.0316548757,
0.0009701463,
0.0611104704,
0.0071033649,
0.0185993165,
0.0190098658,
0.0320870616,
0.006653999,
0.0330747925,
0.0626158863,
0.0383305214,
0.0389621668,
0.0443301089,
0.0514442399,
-0.028223861,
-0.0298324581,
0.010496079,
0.0226474255,
0.0318009444,
0.0088724224,
0.0505165979,
0.0220336318,
-0.0127881179,
-0.0093516111,
0.0194650386,
0.0660874695,
-0.018257916,
0.0103878668,
0.038993448,
0.0285995454,
-0.0628210679,
-0.0115376124,
0.0093804123,
-0.0062869564,
-0.012048793,
0.0435025357,
0.0587269925,
0.027981868,
-0.0567971617,
0.0383836105,
0.0118926661,
-0.0425644666,
0.0359592289,
-0.0240251347,
0.0656184107,
0.030711066,
0.0637449324,
-0.0112170978,
-0.0237043109,
-0.0169955418,
0.0077583278,
0.043970909,
0.0151747018,
-0.0365378894,
0.0016221401,
-0.0660986677,
-0.0090905204,
-0.0538349599,
-0.0238927808,
0.0257522631,
0.044019293,
0.0336931981,
0.0438143238,
-0.0498686545,
0.0293591823,
0.0186403617,
-0.0786099359,
-0.0519554541,
0.0370777585,
-0.0044963872,
-0.0053706672,
0.0286855511,
-0.0162076037,
0.0179238562,
0.0411542542,
-0.0518454053,
-0.0422061272,
-0.0212016553,
-0.0395328626,
-0.032928247,
0.0312436149,
-0.0068235844,
-0.0040348107,
0.0479177386,
-0.0413663723,
-0.0377352126,
0.0128033319,
-0.0347203985,
0.019038517,
-0.0809418783,
-0.0625763834,
0.0444219932,
0.0221895184,
-0.0420351848,
0.044999335,
0.0294630174,
0.0325310975,
0.0061979517,
0.0230989624,
0.0291934516,
-0.0600421429,
0.0125573054,
0.0061736414,
-0.0035695161,
0.0193429496,
0.0212420356,
-0.0009921663,
-0.0583654195,
-0.0462545604,
-0.0697274059,
0.0386097059,
-0.0197324976,
0.0209747795,
0.0229248572,
0.0371330194,
0.0042421035,
-0.0088591659,
-0.0741060153,
0.0042066649,
0.04853829,
0.0277589541,
0.0193940699,
0.0485508107,
-0.0081521766,
-0.0105459597,
-0.0134729445,
0.017487023,
0.0713538677,
-0.0092289736,
0.0468471497,
-0.0655104667,
-0.0181748644,
-0.0391444601,
0.03637667,
0.0014555875,
0.0087891957,
-0.0099582933,
-0.0386505872,
0.0098011652,
0.0281940978,
0.0137267308,
-0.0067684483,
0.0146369692,
-0.0316523872,
-0.0725207329,
0.0137138776,
-0.0410741828,
-0.0578169227,
0.0024839812,
0.0073654945,
0.0156929623,
0.0306370314,
0.0002768491,
-0.0279753339,
-0.0150301177,
0.009267509,
0.022987593,
-0.0136776557,
-0.0673820525,
-0.0038285165,
-0.0032967373,
0.0349550396,
-0.0108474903,
-0.0031002953,
0.0606183335,
-0.0164829474,
-0.0123012755,
-0.0674720109,
-0.0007386309,
-0.0759962946,
0.0405981578,
-0.0275848676,
0.0293930378,
0.0166649744,
-0.0299138259,
-0.0194848608,
-0.0030407568,
-0.0277363285,
-0.0612075068,
0.0196814872,
-0.0242002308,
0.0244290438,
-0.0162056684,
-0.0514918342,
-0.0574915111,
-0.0162612181,
0.0080731492,
0.0390547402,
-0.0275086574,
-0.007360348,
-0.0124598863,
-0.0109208189,
0.0096066538,
0.0183138121,
-0.0274591204,
-0.0153924078,
-0.0070528495,
0.1074831784,
0.0847711265,
0.0153371217,
0.005699819,
-0.0111405887,
-0.0006069711,
0.0768269971,
0.0210220832,
-0.0040312116,
-0.0108516142,
-0.0069133025,
0.0210299343,
-0.0290437508,
0.0223106649,
0.0006611292,
0.0313221253,
-0.0345183723,
-0.0775361732,
0.0992307439,
0.0433199517,
-0.0161813553,
-0.0296606887,
-0.0264864303,
0.0116349505,
0.0091834767,
0.0613323972,
-0.0918004066,
-0.0213712584,
-0.0081851706,
0.0529406704,
0.0360887945,
-0.0207339823,
-0.0129268533,
-0.1286934912,
0.044434838,
-0.017375635,
-0.0296120793,
-0.0409540124,
-0.0361506157,
-0.0075102318,
0.0216800328,
-0.004642325,
0.0327902772,
-0.0096894661,
0.0221785083,
0.0113696894,
0.0665384009,
-0.004670003,
0.0437765382,
-0.0515734479,
-0.0019262031,
0.0498039015,
0.0012076363,
0.0210032444,
-0.0491881147,
0.0008988978,
-0.0637919903,
-0.0138101522,
0.0164797492,
0.0209727455,
-0.0045863348,
-0.0017678819,
-0.0454076491,
0.0470806248,
-0.0599272698,
-0.0039277161,
0.0310029797,
0.0591890812,
-0.0148197692,
-0.0108080506,
-0.0482806303,
0.0124682831,
0.0269752238,
0.0710977018,
0.0121741351,
-0.0359571204,
-0.0193846729,
-0.0253216457,
-0.0131918443,
-0.0759664699,
-0.0304494146,
-0.0025887052,
0.0294913407,
0.0192721989,
-0.070203349,
-0.0249656253,
0.0285088532,
0.0257755034,
-0.0171513632,
-0.0020059068,
0.0012542659,
0.0048832432,
-0.0663963109,
0.0192057714,
-0.0516447872,
-0.0053727166,
-0.0418964401,
-0.0075617451,
0.0632431731,
-0.0395599939,
-0.043942906,
0.0576389469,
-0.0815405473,
-0.0245875362,
-0.022783095,
0.0297369752,
0.0165283307,
0.0176115464,
-0.018865779,
-0.0279978476,
0.0224791802,
0.0471841916,
-0.0759138763,
0.0112048509,
-0.0155206854,
0.0023958543,
-0.0086811781,
0.0326906331,
-0.089335829,
0.0072752154,
-0.0015638011,
0.057117939,
0.0163305253,
-0.0520278513,
0.0156802945,
0.0020232068,
-0.0025101874,
0.0330846012,
0.0221381523,
-0.0476069711,
0.0247715842,
-0.005208537,
-0.0056067323,
-0.0394279361,
0.0065634232,
0.0078967661,
-0.0513816513,
-0.0019978059,
0.0146028791,
0.0082598077,
0.0618333332,
-0.0436903946,
-0.0154414866,
0.0394962281,
0.0186988562,
0.0183002427,
-0.011812754,
-0.0371174216,
0.0089198239,
-0.0048150215,
0.0811370388,
-0.0276094656,
0.0622123554,
0.0152124129,
0.0056791049,
-0.0029129598,
0.007644007,
-0.0647353232,
-0.0351004042,
-0.0217992328,
0.0252565909,
0.0457641408,
0.0080650523,
-0.0142288143,
-0.0025079243,
-0.0200461429,
-0.0209570937,
0.0043204795,
0.0068330364,
-0.0331098028,
0.0466326512,
0.0156269725,
-0.0185767412,
-0.0027148579,
0.0826909542,
0.0091269668,
0.0451470912,
0.0158762019,
0.0091536483,
-0.0258213971,
-0.0310326666,
-0.0141641693,
0.0099864723,
-0.0132713607,
0.01798537,
-0.0205488112,
-0.0394903421,
0.0206318498,
0.0029278318,
-0.0277115181,
0.0199146885,
0.0553419329,
0.067894645,
0.0062635331,
-0.0564480387,
-0.0435461886,
0.0754642859,
-0.0831350088,
-0.0409859009,
0.0063179038,
-6.203874209e-33,
-0.0370897539,
-0.0244254917,
0.0344121121,
-0.0144058494,
-0.0107648894,
0.0004924213,
-0.0332808904,
-0.0204939488,
-0.0194246322,
-0.0252185147,
-0.0073559196,
0.0017432353,
-0.0065088635,
0.05948928,
-0.0172054563,
-0.0342535675,
0.0143280746,
-0.0176474173,
-0.0084614037,
0.0403112844,
0.0712086707,
0.0413821228,
0.0312293954,
-0.0581108332,
-0.0015244378,
-0.057316795,
0.0114111388,
0.0324660726,
-0.0074890922,
0.0756582692,
-0.0249884371,
0.0638885945,
0.0120012742,
-0.0609398745,
0.0126676736,
0.047589533,
-0.1130423769,
-0.0204786006,
-0.0148673654,
-0.0155442264,
-0.0506029278,
-0.0602673292,
0.0059008002,
-0.019317165,
0.0347811282,
-0.0236551985,
0.0199388992,
0.0025436794,
0.0089169247,
-0.0721052587,
-0.0084459707,
-0.0149640162,
-0.0129636871,
-0.0273310654,
-0.0233152509,
0.0269914903,
0.0130790286,
0.0326550119,
-0.057019908,
0.0014927321,
-0.0134664439,
0.0217870511,
0.0141622787,
0.0122748381,
-0.0095962295,
0.0388221629,
-0.0244772993,
-0.0373524353,
-0.0517913811,
-0.0212681331,
-0.0367576033,
0.0118237138,
0.046392981,
0.0613951162,
0.0223527737,
0.0125810253,
-0.0906447023,
0.0642771795,
-0.0281889439,
0.028304169,
0.0234932266,
-0.0094229411,
0.0155111384,
-0.0064965538,
-0.0435928293,
0.0428724922,
-0.039944645,
-0.0193185098,
0.0591714084,
0.0159583762,
-0.0038771192,
-0.0217051096,
0.056703724,
-0.0592641458,
0.0163908675,
0.0900148451,
-0.0174612328,
-0.0060628396,
-0.0153181963,
0.0435260087,
-0.0368619524,
0.0167018753,
0.0518731251,
-0.0151521722,
-0.0317809917,
0.0337386429,
-0.0084780371,
0.0052966485,
-0.0638570413,
0.0103922337,
-0.0436583348,
0.0625526905,
-0.0240358561,
0.007089199,
-0.0176388901,
0.0446894169,
-0.009519198,
0.0558904037,
-0.0042394367,
0.0171610937,
-0.0151867596,
-0.0182577781,
0.0251109656,
0.0115458397,
-0.0324889198,
0.0552127436,
-0.0396901295,
0.0247630551,
-0.0013172274,
-0.0471999161,
-0.0000813404,
0.0397601053,
2.538e-7,
0.0649860352,
-0.0118673323,
0.0303858817,
0.0591777973,
0.0036650519,
0.0140685067,
0.0120023107,
0.0392756648,
0.0508501865,
-0.0015536363,
-0.0319540985,
0.0435401574,
0.0226657819,
0.045434013,
-0.1103842333,
0.0154297724,
-0.0295306463,
-0.000940157,
-0.0360146053,
-0.0229498707,
0.0414012708,
0.063626945,
-0.00639555,
-0.0166061409,
-0.0046192631,
-0.0620286651,
0.0836768001,
0.0218033381,
-0.0130131301,
0.0132832984,
0.0045898384,
0.0107648,
0.013912485,
-0.0183147509,
-0.0099893929,
0.0082779005,
0.028828118,
0.0580632947,
0.0285806786,
-0.0684423745,
-0.00927159,
-0.0363608375,
0.0105277058,
-0.0558966771,
0.0742643625,
-0.0540928133,
-0.027333796,
0.0011405353,
-0.0391717106,
-0.0180514585,
-0.0059039216,
-0.0425999612,
0.0068509104,
0.0090850042,
0.0244491529,
0.0010870893,
0.0190173537,
-0.0743149444,
0.0022559541,
-0.0064314315,
-0.0572649315,
-0.0172849689,
-0.0150331156,
0.0024526478,
-0.0021670037,
-0.0575553216,
0.027764,
2.158212909e-34,
0.0212860275,
0.0283205174,
-0.0221085884,
0.0244159792,
0.0278269406,
-0.0076811505,
-0.0022780166,
-0.0110245263,
0.015540259,
-0.1105740964,
-0.014835014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11254v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11254v2 | An In-Depth Evaluation of Federated Learning on Biomedical Natural Language Processing | 2023-07-20T22:10:04 | 2023-11-11T23:50:59 | Le Peng, Gaoxiang Luo, sicheng zhou, jiandong chen, Rui Zhang, Ziyue Xu, Ju Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) such as BERT and GPT have revolutionized natural
language processing (NLP). However, the medical field faces challenges in
training LMs due to limited data access and privacy constraints imposed by
regulations like the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
(HIPPA) and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Federated learning
(FL) offers a decentralized solution that enables collaborative learning while
ensuring data privacy. In this study, we evaluated FL on 2 biomedical NLP tasks
encompassing 8 corpora using 6 LMs. Our results show that: 1) FL models
consistently outperformed models trained on individual clients' data and
sometimes performed comparably with models trained with polled data; 2) with
the fixed number of total data, FL models training with more clients produced
inferior performance but pre-trained transformer-based models exhibited great
resilience. 3) FL models significantly outperformed large language models using
zero-/one-shot learning and offered lightning inference speed. | [
0.0384014882,
0.105613932,
-0.0090578198,
-0.0174472854,
-0.0350301899,
0.015882168,
0.0838864595,
0.011014319,
0.0323225111,
-0.0187758151,
-0.0479284264,
-0.0355820246,
0.0254743043,
0.0280606318,
-0.0081651341,
-0.030995883,
0.0281233992,
0.0328454636,
-0.0133785326,
-0.0263065491,
-0.0393800214,
0.0138132172,
-0.0133509347,
0.0555271953,
0.0471117161,
-0.0371947698,
0.014807892,
-0.0372427739,
0.0048894719,
-0.0107404385,
0.0366213694,
0.0483842976,
-0.0072276969,
0.0851120278,
0.0000018746,
-0.024957262,
-0.0549725778,
0.0548709333,
-0.0250540935,
0.0350918025,
-0.0055813156,
-0.0210113842,
0.0041416348,
0.0286549106,
-0.0496874824,
-0.0485655367,
0.0316557139,
0.0396333151,
0.0393807963,
0.0616489835,
-0.0066530267,
-0.0552535728,
0.0340922996,
-0.0369358025,
-0.0848672539,
-0.0055797072,
0.0157540441,
-0.0283425488,
0.0027478293,
-0.0268060993,
0.0089166462,
0.051707834,
-0.0079345331,
0.0694751665,
-0.0128509933,
0.0329504535,
-0.0759489164,
-0.044850219,
-0.0418490507,
0.0447861515,
-0.0027422828,
0.0201198887,
0.0002627398,
-0.0298749451,
-0.0127242915,
0.0477510989,
-0.0197703242,
0.0297021624,
-0.0325182825,
0.0192682445,
-0.0154723395,
-0.0195770953,
0.0341107808,
0.0023913234,
0.0024064134,
0.0524814539,
-0.0056662229,
-0.0067423591,
-0.0091455374,
-0.0108694537,
-0.0184601881,
-0.0148406513,
0.0607103631,
0.0128701432,
-0.0156650767,
0.0035005463,
-0.0377951711,
-0.0819013193,
0.0753360987,
-0.0425262898,
0.0098847561,
-0.0292690173,
0.0080609042,
0.0268849358,
-0.0196281131,
-0.0181873795,
-0.0382589251,
0.079462558,
-0.0035637782,
0.0208381973,
-0.0883667171,
-0.009046182,
0.011791124,
0.0697583854,
-0.0404786319,
-0.0121060228,
-0.0420231894,
0.0053851823,
0.0129721118,
0.0132388957,
0.0161592048,
0.0316707939,
-0.0124086095,
-0.0121423351,
0.0038111755,
0.0341452807,
0.028566163,
0.0116320886,
-0.0178346764,
-0.0653873309,
0.009633394,
-0.018015746,
-0.0024304602,
-0.0182839669,
0.011707712,
0.066775538,
0.0275305733,
-0.0351601839,
-0.0067854845,
-0.0318373926,
0.019718023,
-0.040884681,
0.0141613102,
-0.0481108055,
0.0112644471,
0.0077524977,
0.028753113,
-0.0260075349,
0.0122770313,
0.0053132898,
-0.0654256791,
0.0914818123,
-0.033639241,
-0.0239475016,
0.0112649798,
0.0305566434,
-0.0035139311,
0.0660270825,
0.0214730855,
-0.0305024814,
0.045861844,
-0.0041105393,
-0.0060406788,
-0.01264791,
0.0335723422,
-0.0236120205,
0.0146506149,
0.008051076,
-0.0327145271,
0.0607029796,
-0.0476458445,
0.0502329543,
0.0054701264,
-0.0081046205,
0.0424859785,
0.1061574742,
0.0872721151,
-0.0027434658,
-0.0605902523,
0.0263703521,
0.0185558498,
-0.018606035,
-0.0223398395,
-0.0182927996,
0.0007597037,
-0.0272254776,
-0.0475134514,
0.054977335,
-0.0117294183,
-0.0262676496,
-0.0269405581,
-0.0475314073,
-0.0227007978,
-0.0101931132,
0.0241314005,
-0.0025606081,
-0.0211457573,
0.0766998902,
0.0297960229,
-0.0293700267,
-0.0180131011,
-0.0463076383,
-0.0435204655,
0.0417633802,
0.0701555014,
-0.0394597016,
-0.055223614,
-0.0590357818,
-0.0162935667,
0.0271951519,
-0.0212664604,
0.0076801204,
0.0813775286,
-0.0257070772,
-0.0408274755,
0.0542311817,
0.0174485818,
-0.0269958172,
-0.0234598443,
0.0245545413,
-0.0376947448,
-0.0136669073,
-0.0134201748,
0.0529585853,
-0.0203651637,
-0.0161627401,
0.0182041936,
0.014048988,
0.0573099256,
0.009785654,
-0.0218363125,
0.023517061,
0.0179128423,
-0.0157232732,
-0.0646015033,
-0.0194015298,
0.0226879455,
-0.0282321051,
-0.0068152142,
-0.0314183533,
0.0010226138,
0.0270900913,
-0.04812086,
-0.0088097341,
-0.0400208831,
-0.0109302234,
0.0363959037,
-0.0045822086,
0.0141047705,
-0.0160371456,
0.0207497068,
-0.0444143154,
-0.0069528655,
-0.0523070581,
0.0038404153,
-0.0348389037,
-0.0536310524,
0.0526887774,
0.008810332,
0.0338689163,
0.0322019085,
0.010111928,
0.0006600258,
-0.0023863609,
0.012767666,
-0.0125714922,
0.0196640398,
-0.0241957717,
0.0135451583,
-0.0017835274,
0.042356234,
0.0085962387,
0.0401235819,
-0.0083764475,
-0.0513168536,
-0.0264559947,
-0.0212055463,
-0.0256002434,
0.0201464277,
0.0132863028,
0.011735104,
-0.0284849349,
-0.0060823611,
-0.0091994749,
-0.0248124115,
0.0313460827,
0.0094628688,
-0.0449468642,
-0.0183884017,
-0.0471691713,
-0.0212992765,
0.0193776079,
0.0175673366,
-0.0203995127,
0.0172251966,
0.0406329855,
-0.0300549585,
0.0341037363,
0.0073498995,
0.020705035,
0.0296829715,
0.0254365578,
-0.0148313185,
0.0036088114,
-0.0329089835,
-0.0128657389,
-0.0135804117,
0.0145731242,
0.0592241064,
0.0413133539,
0.0220670123,
-0.0228549689,
-0.0279985908,
0.0308018439,
-0.0241054855,
-0.0039102952,
-0.0595027916,
0.0150977597,
-0.0249775723,
0.0142834373,
0.0305919461,
-0.0648798794,
0.1007434353,
-0.000339618,
0.0406075418,
-0.0803007782,
-0.0366955698,
-0.038217511,
0.0199435521,
-0.0187339503,
0.0362258591,
0.0037833394,
-0.0765261054,
0.0301049724,
0.0532003082,
0.0196553748,
-0.0631505102,
-0.0080416212,
-0.0131386891,
-0.0074496241,
0.0026202924,
-0.0343741886,
-0.0175272468,
-0.0402894206,
-0.0486961417,
0.0272381604,
-0.0035805493,
-0.0091302013,
-0.0437793992,
0.0110710477,
-0.0065446417,
0.0446609259,
0.0110129965,
-0.0131304823,
0.0000126515,
0.0104976203,
-0.0167793185,
-0.0608339868,
-0.001669256,
-0.0176772419,
0.0128747169,
0.0692966953,
0.0648960844,
0.0147716403,
0.0323313251,
-0.0331051797,
0.0164908059,
-0.0649031326,
-0.007754636,
-0.0264070015,
0.0413903892,
-0.0252881534,
0.0319601446,
0.0835458115,
0.0134833166,
-0.0530325174,
0.0097409338,
-0.0134574473,
-0.0016445997,
-0.0234673675,
-0.0078674508,
-0.0916784853,
-0.0346194394,
0.0066827233,
0.064959228,
-0.0087015182,
-0.0459592342,
-0.0064594294,
-0.0431819782,
0.0152446274,
-0.0013213403,
-0.0182589572,
-0.038632419,
-0.0700856745,
0.0089023123,
-0.0229587201,
0.0221847221,
-0.0453585424,
-0.0033872633,
-0.0094460137,
0.0331524536,
-0.0672407374,
-0.0835748315,
-0.0272076409,
-0.0402313769,
0.0553842038,
0.0397172794,
-0.0036573745,
-0.0200743563,
-0.0594081916,
-0.0125629781,
0.0533117428,
-0.0214364696,
-0.0221624821,
0.068184793,
-0.0303026773,
-0.0137695549,
-0.0240907315,
0.0273012277,
-0.0130820451,
-0.020439256,
-0.0062680128,
0.0625652969,
-0.0376733094,
-0.0014098202,
-0.025833521,
-0.005079966,
0.0236612204,
0.0403625816,
-0.0065044276,
-0.0232723821,
-0.0380003676,
0.0449497737,
0.0664586276,
0.0083853649,
-0.0034488535,
0.0688834637,
-0.033790648,
-0.0377313308,
-0.0400941595,
0.0167004373,
0.0241210349,
0.0078029502,
0.0208899882,
0.0500927158,
0.0757664666,
-0.0003774815,
-0.0457269028,
0.0481782965,
0.0187804382,
0.0268352237,
-0.0876624584,
-0.06133404,
0.0083147343,
0.0618521981,
-0.0256946534,
0.0416876376,
-0.0231446568,
-0.0374035351,
0.0267331954,
0.0254345499,
0.0206989795,
-0.006801147,
-0.0159391202,
-0.0451931246,
0.0657991096,
0.072507672,
-0.0748031288,
-0.0334058329,
0.0289227292,
-0.0574657843,
-0.0114303995,
0.0263274908,
0.0100078555,
-0.0019617619,
0.0166274216,
-0.0087340996,
0.0300999675,
-0.0379002243,
0.0066864514,
0.0564820841,
0.1037843749,
-0.0261795856,
0.0209150892,
-0.0289794896,
0.0265208445,
-0.0242503881,
0.0331802405,
-0.0246201307,
-0.0110472105,
0.0449440591,
-0.0193993505,
-0.0145908035,
0.0005416271,
-0.0285136849,
-0.0332343839,
-0.0474520996,
0.0620234497,
0.0334720947,
-0.0441299826,
0.0540697202,
-0.0125728212,
-0.0053761769,
0.0140342703,
0.0218713582,
0.0427644029,
0.0013900261,
0.0487555265,
-0.0099769356,
0.0385005511,
-0.0180962794,
0.0616292842,
-0.0696955323,
-0.1151117012,
-0.0025544316,
0.0106563736,
-0.0226946753,
0.0310066007,
0.0219752006,
-0.0157707613,
0.0047714789,
-0.0030164176,
0.0180773623,
-0.0639987364,
0.0193520002,
0.0358829424,
-0.0074461512,
-0.0085017374,
0.0345075391,
0.1275099814,
0.0267925765,
0.0475803055,
-0.0479841344,
-0.0428717732,
-0.057156764,
-0.0208480842,
0.034959808,
0.0249697696,
-0.0650100112,
0.0018953613,
-0.0101136994,
-0.0462784469,
0.0069910339,
-0.0210036058,
0.0042208708,
-0.0224814229,
0.0372412391,
0.0158634912,
0.0283002518,
-0.0550220795,
-0.0439548902,
0.0647084787,
0.0251060799,
-0.0231588148,
0.0301299561,
-6.103959026e-33,
0.0068672686,
-0.0082120467,
-0.0171433762,
0.019707609,
-0.0095381821,
0.0621729866,
0.0095525179,
0.002777687,
0.0249409415,
0.0100923209,
-0.0289676022,
0.0286322888,
0.0159518775,
0.0420862995,
0.008833738,
-0.0207401216,
0.0246441849,
-0.0207227468,
-0.0136304172,
0.0132516036,
0.0252373405,
0.0863762796,
0.0680971071,
-0.0612835288,
0.0198547374,
0.0272795595,
-0.0067005954,
0.0125999739,
-0.0477276444,
0.0288689546,
-0.0320111476,
0.0244337022,
0.0245870519,
-0.0445113331,
0.0039094011,
0.0196618866,
-0.066246435,
0.0109803146,
-0.0053975326,
0.0311331544,
-0.0336428732,
-0.0127947507,
0.0787690729,
-0.0171933118,
-0.0168868639,
-0.027131239,
0.0066020093,
0.0047629019,
-0.0435768254,
-0.0445758775,
-0.0021570718,
0.0326246843,
-0.0021973201,
0.0190475304,
0.0139914816,
0.0292636305,
-0.0285804234,
0.0087011624,
-0.0281598084,
-0.031414818,
0.0422540046,
-0.0068729711,
0.0195110552,
-0.0044086021,
0.0027306122,
0.052481968,
0.0380497724,
-0.0355005711,
-0.0487027913,
0.0225134119,
-0.0186169334,
0.0489253923,
0.0273582246,
0.0035097972,
-0.0101119233,
-0.0322303474,
-0.0642457753,
0.0210301988,
0.0039161365,
-0.011389575,
0.019914737,
0.032481581,
-0.0258856192,
-0.0084607545,
-0.0090487199,
-0.0074454532,
0.0080370735,
0.0053154393,
-0.0261913147,
-0.0041696676,
-0.031546995,
0.0148913646,
-0.0013821973,
-0.054445833,
-0.0195536725,
-0.0130205983,
0.0841204077,
-0.0050039585,
-0.0129308356,
0.018487243,
-0.073014535,
0.008863356,
-0.0002538764,
0.0112492982,
0.0525763147,
-0.0155969011,
0.0557824858,
-0.0129163889,
-0.0675526485,
-0.0181880407,
-0.0073971851,
-0.0108446367,
0.0115084993,
0.068746455,
0.0661836341,
0.0006975649,
0.00942811,
0.0131108426,
0.0012061014,
0.0223292354,
-0.0346758366,
0.0020675606,
-0.0111262687,
0.0095743146,
-0.0119681191,
-0.0295911487,
-0.0459718741,
0.0473989137,
0.052569408,
-0.048230134,
0.0019583993,
-0.0506626889,
2.762e-7,
0.096564956,
0.0365547575,
-0.0053722565,
-0.0815124661,
0.0173853766,
0.0238645487,
-0.0032241021,
0.0556838885,
0.0083565488,
0.0198964663,
0.0031881931,
-0.0408979207,
0.0263967719,
0.0172635857,
-0.0370136872,
-0.0722164884,
-0.0698645115,
0.0294842515,
-0.0450301021,
-0.0295425989,
0.0044142264,
0.0422962382,
0.014223827,
-0.0601301305,
0.0125906356,
0.0152485091,
0.0223011859,
-0.0339023247,
-0.0200972483,
0.0023620389,
0.0191692971,
0.0858641937,
0.0231669191,
0.0086105186,
-0.0194247235,
0.0020466908,
-0.0233516209,
0.0694435611,
-0.0379448123,
0.026833633,
0.0153324539,
-0.0287786257,
-0.0065741926,
0.0074199042,
0.0532810315,
-0.067612879,
-0.0735226423,
0.0007219492,
0.0209484231,
-0.0452103578,
0.0917853937,
-0.000687983,
-0.0374590643,
0.0256440323,
0.0202271789,
-0.0113448082,
-0.0287768859,
-0.0731231943,
0.0030928676,
-0.0021849982,
-0.0303647555,
-0.0237814467,
0.0227895267,
0.0116866864,
-0.0032234632,
-0.0573227219,
0.0033158979,
2.354096185e-34,
0.0011926022,
-0.0164745823,
0.010350504,
0.036266733,
0.0145848291,
-0.0288373772,
0.0525082462,
-0.0125607289,
-0.01763466,
-0.0384295098,
0.0068343799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11224v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11224v3 | Jina Embeddings: A Novel Set of High-Performance Sentence Embedding Models | 2023-07-20T20:37:24 | 2023-10-20T14:09:36 | Michael Günther, Louis Milliken, Jonathan Geuter, Georgios Mastrapas, Bo Wang, Han Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, 68T50, H.3.1; H.3.3; I.2.7; I.5.4 | Jina Embeddings constitutes a set of high-performance sentence embedding
models adept at translating textual inputs into numerical representations,
capturing the semantics of the text. These models excel in applications like
dense retrieval and semantic textual similarity. This paper details the
development of Jina Embeddings, starting with the creation of high-quality
pairwise and triplet datasets. It underlines the crucial role of data cleaning
in dataset preparation, offers in-depth insights into the model training
process, and concludes with a comprehensive performance evaluation using the
Massive Text Embedding Benchmark (MTEB). Furthermore, to increase the model's
awareness of grammatical negation, we construct a novel training and evaluation
dataset of negated and non-negated statements, which we make publicly available
to the community. | [
0.0245458633,
0.0423516892,
0.0044930601,
0.0685656592,
-0.0464146957,
0.01587037,
-0.0194448791,
-0.0352303125,
0.0038764058,
-0.0456262827,
-0.0459953137,
-0.0253433771,
-0.0217258539,
0.0000799986,
0.0205638371,
-0.0272603966,
0.0480844565,
0.0665851086,
0.0265933964,
-0.0080723446,
0.035353329,
0.0117617808,
0.0098094232,
0.0319679976,
-0.0450416766,
-0.0447753593,
-0.0008026864,
0.0183488298,
0.0261213761,
-0.0529258326,
0.0477207936,
-0.0002727656,
0.0111860894,
0.0361502767,
0.0000017252,
-0.0041146562,
0.0041859783,
-0.0213350523,
-0.0037097388,
0.0554653518,
0.0424042642,
-0.0562681295,
0.0190660618,
0.0220459383,
-0.0427397154,
-0.0067215608,
0.0307092499,
0.0652181953,
0.0985229388,
0.0862740353,
-0.0144435558,
-0.025432324,
0.0074395924,
-0.0350155272,
-0.0159821175,
-0.0124021163,
0.0314889923,
0.0016930775,
-0.0338836797,
0.0188056715,
-0.0030544205,
0.0357337445,
0.0218685362,
-0.0050096433,
0.0065715322,
0.0141401179,
-0.0586032346,
0.0025181083,
0.0061888122,
0.0798666701,
0.0026435738,
-0.0163029879,
0.0022804497,
0.0167448595,
-0.026540244,
-0.0233578905,
-0.0294324812,
-0.0056055165,
0.0225173961,
0.0813176185,
0.012089883,
-0.0026357018,
0.0400833786,
-0.0083332974,
0.0005971968,
0.0299749188,
0.0244339164,
-0.0787629485,
-0.021045953,
0.0172542669,
-0.0726890862,
0.0188456494,
0.0206286833,
-0.0110838171,
0.0158057697,
-0.002920937,
-0.0211946815,
-0.0420017391,
0.0398442633,
-0.0527503937,
0.0250021275,
0.0106378337,
0.0037552158,
0.0405039862,
-0.0448085554,
0.0049035088,
0.011327886,
0.0206110608,
-0.0333863795,
-0.0295119528,
-0.0380452573,
-0.0188758783,
-0.0195351988,
0.0668929145,
-0.0374063402,
-0.0351903364,
-0.030959934,
-0.0131083094,
-0.0435860939,
0.0365492664,
0.0139751015,
0.0432182588,
0.0044159982,
0.0033718231,
-0.0149402404,
0.0069428664,
-0.0508912653,
0.0208024941,
-0.0563147664,
-0.0236136634,
-0.0433395766,
0.0162741113,
0.0422625281,
0.0010377043,
0.013477955,
0.0164669305,
-0.0068782796,
-0.0508749299,
0.0018092876,
0.0060589937,
0.0019106589,
-0.0509822071,
-0.0405729413,
-0.0300929789,
0.020022342,
-0.011202367,
-0.0046998472,
-0.0497901477,
0.0069746072,
0.0599846616,
-0.0008896574,
0.0490522012,
0.0060215429,
-0.0308090262,
-0.0221049841,
0.0098318607,
0.0612376891,
0.0627490133,
0.0066402759,
0.0210041068,
0.0325599946,
0.0508316606,
-0.0160270855,
-0.0139061091,
0.0375307389,
0.0271287896,
-0.0373955481,
0.0488895327,
0.0207067821,
0.054962188,
0.0141871423,
0.0570736639,
-0.0436179079,
-0.0359176695,
0.0344710127,
0.0036614523,
0.0095487898,
-0.0028877689,
0.0268717371,
0.024631802,
-0.0210058074,
-0.0255589839,
-0.0304808319,
0.0025808832,
-0.0193756633,
-0.0178493056,
0.0360920392,
0.0146944476,
-0.050294783,
-0.0247432161,
0.0064489706,
-0.0129850898,
-0.0094884513,
-0.0225356575,
-0.0106229791,
-0.0096455002,
-0.0362054408,
0.041552864,
0.0060478947,
-0.0775047541,
-0.0490561277,
0.0368000418,
0.0306350198,
0.0358134732,
0.0409161523,
-0.0302669946,
-0.0383693054,
-0.0078141456,
-0.0264392123,
0.0328575261,
0.0273228846,
-0.0284004174,
0.0231103096,
-0.0807235092,
-0.009157775,
-0.0209427495,
0.0349107869,
0.0100624776,
-0.011392409,
0.0485999621,
0.0658156872,
-0.0294283256,
-0.0069366097,
0.049131088,
-0.0158126429,
-0.0251045749,
0.0396357924,
0.041103255,
0.0287964772,
0.0332758203,
0.0063898815,
0.0089281611,
0.0499144979,
-0.0577753745,
-0.0472449176,
-0.0253063925,
-0.0350306667,
-0.1005410329,
0.053584516,
-0.0347586349,
-0.0092052929,
0.1023311764,
-0.0667702183,
-0.0318514518,
-0.0089869695,
-0.0014769845,
-0.0032205626,
-0.0455551781,
-0.014031643,
0.0057801721,
0.0401606262,
-0.0022886151,
0.052754458,
-0.0260817222,
0.0222610813,
0.0082330033,
-0.0127229644,
0.0853438228,
-0.0443722531,
-0.0759675354,
-0.0356283225,
0.0296780374,
0.0387759022,
0.0022051088,
-0.0046134642,
-0.0180471893,
-0.0065096254,
-0.1167352572,
0.0130538121,
-0.0268788263,
0.0217890292,
0.0372378938,
-0.0160549376,
0.0104202162,
-0.0319443494,
-0.040462181,
-0.0010737331,
0.0130144004,
0.0128411306,
0.0566864274,
-0.0225293264,
-0.0132336617,
-0.0545468368,
-0.0066050501,
-0.0233657081,
0.0337520875,
-0.0414060466,
-0.0019415679,
0.0007096677,
0.0164366942,
-0.0301064476,
-0.0097382301,
0.0050601573,
-0.0351369195,
-0.0009842719,
-0.0036571007,
0.0064948471,
0.0566579327,
-0.0260273404,
0.0171253756,
0.0427608192,
0.0345219858,
-0.0165727176,
0.0135289263,
-0.0114006344,
0.0668192282,
0.0058794944,
-0.0274687801,
0.0064325761,
0.0280629508,
0.029476732,
-0.0139771523,
-0.0545140095,
0.0271123517,
-0.0090944003,
-0.0065002353,
-0.0407303572,
0.0220645219,
-0.0140106641,
0.0011145147,
-0.0411917791,
-0.0179080814,
0.0308178067,
-0.0049936869,
-0.0123091182,
-0.0515031368,
-0.0078844875,
-0.0441392474,
0.0396591425,
-0.0054140477,
0.0010595419,
0.0072742528,
0.0129588451,
0.0007442198,
-0.0188018586,
0.0426380821,
-0.0052611306,
-0.0028155209,
0.0136775421,
-0.0063799364,
-0.0289289486,
-0.0472371764,
-0.0256381109,
-0.1034241095,
-0.0336861014,
0.0090823621,
-0.0251445938,
0.0268713627,
-0.0421396568,
-0.0393094905,
-0.02182886,
0.0041374527,
-0.0137411077,
-0.0022289921,
-0.0351683423,
0.0614496022,
0.0565996841,
0.0105580352,
-0.0089163752,
0.0260593407,
0.0219864156,
0.0365851931,
-0.0159746204,
0.0146722477,
-0.0337879695,
-0.0228265561,
0.0039095893,
-0.003731333,
-0.0287669357,
-0.0064897686,
0.0267031249,
0.0071334071,
-0.0090762638,
0.1052121595,
0.0500415973,
-0.0144238919,
0.0073713935,
0.007427833,
0.0553374514,
0.0268938504,
-0.0227169264,
-0.1124837771,
-0.0490125418,
-0.0139861908,
0.0022421787,
0.0208551753,
-0.011178975,
-0.0047478746,
-0.1042838395,
0.0097131906,
0.0008380772,
0.0452030413,
-0.044960238,
-0.0360909551,
0.006673831,
-0.0361450948,
0.0135641787,
-0.0175135694,
-0.0094361054,
0.0051927608,
0.0067029721,
0.0004799989,
-0.0591191836,
0.005731429,
-0.0130375139,
0.0500033908,
-0.0272779018,
0.0793658122,
0.0011202589,
-0.0147728715,
-0.0003055625,
-0.0494741611,
-0.034412194,
-0.0017253316,
0.069279477,
-0.0394237749,
-0.0147397975,
-0.0311882105,
0.0086417105,
-0.0595157407,
-0.0039916486,
0.0179673284,
0.0832739174,
-0.0097075487,
0.0019997763,
-0.0488581546,
0.0057526366,
-0.0056020366,
0.0818838477,
0.0343750156,
0.0020246056,
-0.0478836149,
-0.0058260304,
0.0059160786,
-0.0187860262,
-0.0170415789,
-0.0158852078,
0.019909326,
0.0065544802,
-0.075163424,
-0.1004402563,
0.0165854078,
0.0038988537,
-0.0035786254,
0.0212239232,
-0.0077296845,
-0.0129431821,
-0.0261087213,
-0.0088108843,
-0.0309558492,
0.0050609526,
-0.0060330243,
0.037809547,
0.0185007844,
0.0392064005,
-0.0261236634,
-0.0618078411,
-0.0630847961,
-0.0469199978,
-0.0245628785,
0.0131559195,
0.0007453662,
0.0186274182,
-0.0198534001,
0.0023526005,
0.0467693843,
0.0595565289,
-0.0571357682,
0.0139576122,
0.0865749642,
0.0053452733,
0.0085583599,
0.0749601424,
0.0022181533,
0.0420215279,
-0.0073841969,
0.0508101359,
-0.0203664843,
-0.01975419,
0.0211982448,
0.0088910349,
0.0424347222,
0.0378022157,
-0.0084494976,
-0.028491715,
0.0036813635,
-0.0655643493,
-0.0364601687,
-0.0228389241,
0.0204708539,
0.0488296486,
0.0052350224,
-0.0597400218,
0.0297445767,
-0.0331521593,
0.0571549796,
-0.0530839674,
0.0306752529,
0.0511601977,
0.0165766124,
-0.0305389725,
-0.0052531022,
-0.0374827683,
-0.0519768931,
-0.0118366322,
-0.009765991,
-0.0217780974,
-0.0213292241,
0.010342828,
0.0083270511,
-0.0523685515,
0.0366561301,
-0.0376100354,
0.0450500287,
-0.0030513499,
-0.0149294296,
0.0709330216,
-0.014408242,
0.0499252044,
-0.0201754626,
-0.0081143416,
0.0072335112,
0.0239873473,
-0.0001949711,
-0.0133558828,
0.0245061666,
0.0025557852,
-0.0481784306,
0.0023147068,
0.081813246,
-0.0258854367,
0.0588458106,
0.0267040636,
-0.0115470327,
-0.0520065092,
-0.0100668641,
0.0705179125,
0.0394932218,
0.0131031079,
0.0172947422,
-0.025600899,
-0.0400521867,
0.0436881892,
-0.0077113477,
-0.0510566346,
0.0016009936,
0.0215867087,
0.0299996622,
0.0403903648,
0.0080538159,
-0.0363828987,
0.0192978419,
-0.0320376679,
-0.0373415016,
-0.0713938698,
-5.872803572e-33,
0.0285077058,
0.0192660913,
-0.0161732715,
-0.0119655663,
-0.0179122537,
0.009598433,
-0.0106345247,
-0.0263178907,
-0.0324631855,
0.0579324961,
-0.0139694745,
0.0402554795,
0.0017238421,
0.0371125527,
-0.0226439033,
0.0011282447,
0.0804288909,
-0.0126044629,
-0.0162912086,
0.0030242857,
0.0349593535,
0.0380234793,
0.0375848338,
-0.0582129546,
0.000642465,
-0.0220993366,
-0.0112007931,
0.0198539328,
0.0220686141,
0.0216971766,
-0.0579650663,
0.0773101375,
0.0315118432,
-0.016432371,
0.0117538786,
0.0216290578,
-0.0624902844,
-0.0598867871,
-0.001604636,
-0.0140947541,
-0.0252156965,
-0.0425754897,
-0.0014001209,
-0.0128752934,
0.0024613619,
0.0347031578,
0.0289513245,
-0.008628197,
-0.0389356278,
0.0032122035,
-0.0702755377,
0.0364739262,
-0.0208617691,
0.007329375,
0.0298738852,
0.0352020413,
0.0120495614,
-0.0059723253,
-0.0647104755,
-0.0126813203,
-0.0589647442,
0.024361141,
-0.0272040125,
-0.0257676803,
0.0050499593,
0.0741737187,
0.0037591215,
-0.0164686777,
-0.0030244433,
0.0198197719,
-0.0034318292,
0.0162220299,
0.0280386452,
0.0787525177,
0.0203302838,
-0.0318490341,
-0.0798709765,
0.0265582092,
0.024706237,
0.0403463319,
0.0386842452,
-0.0084377406,
-0.0497696996,
-0.0170313753,
-0.0128309717,
-0.0128395539,
-0.0242204349,
-0.0062465686,
0.0525392517,
0.0169246085,
-0.0238892455,
-0.0031551379,
-0.0264769271,
-0.0366285779,
-0.0243284646,
0.0878634304,
-0.0296883397,
-0.0009955709,
0.0494558923,
0.0074509503,
-0.0728694648,
-0.0138840582,
-0.0009741988,
0.0400121063,
0.01941159,
-0.0412658118,
0.0743064508,
0.0056157215,
-0.0815702826,
0.010301874,
0.0032717555,
-0.0116471499,
-0.0498957708,
0.0086783944,
0.0081700161,
0.0292093251,
0.0170492996,
0.0211810637,
0.0315934904,
0.0319985971,
-0.0333517343,
-0.0231714565,
0.0286231209,
0.0185257569,
-0.008294791,
0.0043154079,
-0.0576643795,
0.025486419,
0.0067185783,
-0.0846807212,
0.003360658,
-0.0061982009,
2.386e-7,
0.0292730499,
0.0322490148,
0.0335177742,
-0.0061328458,
0.0086206608,
0.0516746864,
-0.0161206182,
0.0530109219,
-0.0341566168,
0.0249913577,
0.0317723304,
0.0096550146,
0.0039686612,
0.0025104759,
-0.0781725571,
0.06897448,
-0.0848259926,
-0.0533934906,
-0.0357464403,
-0.0014685361,
0.0921575055,
0.1384016275,
0.0028516364,
0.0044098068,
-0.0191103406,
-0.0294850711,
0.0743852407,
0.0064071263,
-0.0316503942,
0.0025625916,
0.04072069,
0.018211063,
0.0250732992,
-0.0373379067,
-0.0026740343,
0.045247443,
0.0154620484,
0.0776534155,
-0.0148412604,
-0.0330663249,
-0.0102387331,
-0.0102982037,
-0.0177230034,
-0.022699222,
0.1283186823,
-0.0220047962,
-0.0350858234,
-0.0093886405,
-0.053561464,
0.0428819358,
0.089094907,
0.0208757222,
-0.0482424796,
-0.0191605762,
0.0469787158,
-0.0128501384,
-0.0363017991,
-0.0724276528,
-0.0184051357,
-0.0048429477,
-0.0295642558,
0.0060826652,
-0.0331441276,
0.0139394142,
0.0534904003,
-0.036296539,
0.0410929061,
2.294055056e-34,
0.042457357,
-0.024092108,
0.0383810848,
-0.0228060465,
-0.0015943251,
-0.0204146728,
-0.0318227895,
-0.0183004532,
0.0370710529,
-0.0674283952,
0.0316516533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11788v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11788v3 | Applying QNLP to sentiment analysis in finance | 2023-07-20T18:30:35 | 2023-09-11T07:21:10 | Jonas Stein, Ivo Christ, Nicolas Kraus, Maximilian Balthasar Mansky, Robert Müller, Claudia Linnhoff-Popien | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, quant-ph | As an application domain where the slightest qualitative improvements can
yield immense value, finance is a promising candidate for early quantum
advantage. Focusing on the rapidly advancing field of Quantum Natural Language
Processing (QNLP), we explore the practical applicability of the two central
approaches DisCoCat and Quantum-Enhanced Long Short-Term Memory (QLSTM) to the
problem of sentiment analysis in finance. Utilizing a novel ChatGPT-based data
generation approach, we conduct a case study with more than 1000 realistic
sentences and find that QLSTMs can be trained substantially faster than
DisCoCat while also achieving close to classical results for their available
software implementations. | [
0.0023325966,
0.0860001743,
-0.0202534031,
0.0340710059,
-0.036197491,
-0.0068533788,
-0.0396905094,
0.0395878814,
0.0415150709,
-0.0348199829,
-0.0266901311,
-0.0654313117,
-0.0246043187,
0.0390411466,
0.0161715336,
-0.0121673141,
0.0450072661,
0.0324585736,
-0.0128915077,
-0.05863747,
0.0034943942,
-0.0457552895,
0.022298187,
-0.010363223,
0.0426946394,
-0.018767003,
-0.0070768595,
0.0017609079,
0.0135094505,
-0.0318815373,
-0.0101338038,
0.0359755121,
-0.0151053378,
0.0056630131,
0.0000017808,
-0.0164639857,
-0.0027814384,
-0.0124573652,
0.0343346409,
0.0201840028,
-0.0156819504,
-0.0452297926,
0.0004848508,
0.024169473,
-0.0717773065,
0.0447750986,
0.0699572936,
0.0358706266,
0.0599004366,
0.0892056599,
0.0017295511,
-0.0359781086,
0.0109689087,
-0.0161098,
0.0126773585,
-0.0559380427,
0.0121779284,
-0.0077401064,
0.0027431834,
-0.0084408475,
-0.0341874324,
0.0228193402,
0.0378061906,
0.013367285,
0.0274966322,
0.0156247197,
0.0022481845,
0.0536096506,
-0.064770855,
0.0650287718,
-0.0064096716,
0.0031807872,
-0.0028123464,
0.0157116186,
-0.0471338332,
-0.0428575762,
0.003244821,
0.0322045423,
-0.0184770133,
0.0385629311,
0.0155867776,
-0.0012744091,
0.016236838,
-0.0087291477,
0.0165503342,
0.012117763,
0.0195810869,
-0.0446256176,
0.0356461592,
0.0034177986,
-0.0393322594,
0.00124621,
-0.0169163067,
-0.0319595821,
0.0330457613,
0.0007674792,
0.0042531043,
0.0358489193,
-0.0166471507,
-0.0647754073,
0.0013250781,
0.0725551546,
0.0190887675,
0.0103978738,
-0.00890591,
0.0343169942,
0.0091403676,
-0.0468967296,
-0.0127354041,
0.029648615,
-0.0958861113,
0.0039317394,
0.0108487289,
0.069952853,
-0.0179516915,
-0.053595148,
-0.1342184544,
-0.0178437028,
0.0221156199,
0.0067140297,
0.007603894,
0.0301684756,
0.0049261083,
0.0130116884,
-0.0284083728,
0.0444323085,
-0.0359215215,
-0.016351549,
-0.0470299721,
-0.0543424599,
-0.0180265401,
0.0378751531,
-0.0287171323,
-0.0273378268,
-0.0120416973,
0.0954293236,
0.0230063461,
-0.0612880699,
0.0002037113,
-0.0091370996,
-0.0214687344,
-0.0340400487,
0.041540511,
-0.0113477213,
0.0010191284,
-0.0207486078,
0.000850361,
-0.0046640346,
0.0124290045,
-0.0198519006,
-0.0165780038,
0.0694865584,
-0.0277363695,
-0.0787060261,
-0.0372280516,
-0.0027070791,
0.0861885101,
0.0436461605,
-0.0183748547,
0.0120454337,
0.0172746889,
-0.0265473537,
0.0121539105,
-0.0167228766,
0.0269993115,
-0.0494226925,
-0.0621521547,
0.0176797118,
-0.0680265874,
0.0090784524,
0.0199494995,
0.0647078529,
-0.0393368602,
-0.0154218506,
0.0162223335,
0.0275787208,
0.0525044724,
0.0612806156,
-0.0490424447,
0.024869103,
-0.0121854991,
-0.0137144309,
-0.0187917296,
0.0682890639,
-0.0480481461,
0.0206940956,
0.0211295523,
-0.0397807248,
-0.0261033289,
-0.0623065904,
-0.0159654059,
-0.0242303498,
0.0408290625,
-0.0410565101,
0.0106428107,
0.0109655559,
-0.0626582652,
-0.0090797376,
0.0333012156,
-0.0176124573,
-0.0072072116,
-0.0636142194,
0.0246892832,
0.09186095,
0.0042470573,
-0.0182865318,
0.0506940037,
0.0096003106,
-0.0936983079,
0.065710105,
0.0327751413,
0.0252091866,
-0.0130254049,
-0.0296450276,
0.0108923791,
-0.0392427593,
-0.012561257,
0.0183630791,
0.0070666326,
0.0374241956,
0.00216145,
0.0308302455,
0.0074511147,
-0.0108327698,
0.0624202639,
-0.0920682475,
0.0274469107,
-0.0259525813,
0.0463310592,
0.0423338003,
-0.0185542423,
0.0358821973,
-0.0030670171,
-0.0060956036,
-0.1008132026,
-0.0375925079,
-0.0056597777,
-0.0556310378,
0.0058709513,
-0.0474979095,
0.0353547297,
0.0059006354,
-0.0189410653,
-0.0382151343,
0.0752396137,
-0.0231454503,
0.0335826129,
-0.0523096956,
-0.0633836612,
0.0315721706,
0.0630884841,
-0.0217830054,
0.0812855735,
0.0017797659,
0.0127381356,
-0.0160531197,
-0.0132424254,
-0.0200978648,
-0.0375342816,
-0.0196081176,
0.0047428221,
0.033416111,
0.0477830358,
0.0346916057,
0.0093073742,
0.0107323024,
-0.0089344643,
-0.0652683899,
0.0196045116,
-0.0077024018,
0.0349170603,
0.0059439051,
-0.0032533931,
0.0106960721,
-0.0072155748,
-0.0321774743,
-0.0299569387,
-0.0116254911,
0.002074165,
0.0411191657,
-0.0243401397,
-0.0063042701,
-0.0352638364,
0.0020408533,
-0.0297468565,
-0.0067598834,
-0.0085972659,
-0.0115803592,
-0.0260628592,
-0.0091663636,
-0.0414394774,
-0.0213743579,
0.0096507259,
-0.0299362075,
0.0117692249,
-0.0174126234,
0.0255202278,
0.0429186821,
0.0329071172,
0.0468032807,
-0.0017307466,
0.0001623268,
0.0058388719,
0.0513564311,
-0.0679046586,
0.0452984199,
-0.0348043554,
0.0123798875,
0.0199256781,
0.0587307848,
0.0355514735,
0.012340554,
-0.0740172192,
0.0455478579,
0.005548391,
0.0135648251,
-0.0376629755,
0.0274756979,
-0.0075977687,
0.0096730106,
0.0344746709,
0.0005375786,
0.0621487983,
0.0159895029,
-0.0084806392,
-0.0657920539,
-0.0273697823,
-0.0444475375,
0.0597121306,
-0.0377188697,
0.0098512322,
-0.0500443354,
0.0184443481,
0.0243868642,
-0.0575620346,
0.0023853369,
0.0030176293,
-0.0284852609,
0.0047191237,
0.0192695707,
-0.001893698,
0.0112114372,
0.0128904078,
-0.0155571392,
-0.0562376082,
-0.0035786643,
0.0111943204,
-0.0301628355,
0.0452589206,
0.0363627039,
0.000472459,
-0.049201142,
-0.051786527,
-0.0086154947,
0.002716481,
0.0157830901,
0.0457431264,
-0.0357814655,
0.0781804547,
0.0075703152,
0.0399869569,
0.0415161364,
0.0240723714,
0.0466884449,
-0.0180318002,
-0.0165340863,
-0.0187277906,
-0.0039116847,
-0.0220522005,
0.0164586995,
-0.0154190883,
-0.0329891741,
0.0034490936,
0.0735373273,
0.0269175135,
0.039236147,
0.0066784099,
0.0603279583,
-0.0558281951,
-0.0346225351,
0.0130652552,
-0.1158706471,
-0.05261131,
-0.0425700732,
0.0396453738,
0.0280410554,
-0.0293505993,
-0.0403709151,
-0.053145431,
0.0112276692,
0.0304608066,
0.0195699688,
-0.0707666203,
-0.0262581315,
-0.0226354711,
-0.0173343718,
0.0440264568,
0.0364319012,
-0.0091256741,
0.0155448578,
-0.0108405538,
-0.0504135601,
0.0091621745,
0.0094839083,
0.0257405099,
-0.0114131169,
0.0493264124,
0.0530067943,
-0.0200425386,
-0.0464260131,
-0.0496934019,
-0.0679973736,
0.0216813162,
-0.0189645607,
0.0073392377,
-0.0100964606,
-0.035425283,
-0.0191753246,
0.0376809463,
-0.0351194292,
0.0308737028,
0.0053250282,
-0.0448119268,
-0.0527283549,
-0.0651264712,
0.004064105,
0.054567907,
-0.0060552554,
0.0731546432,
-0.0361295417,
-0.0407247357,
-0.0932974219,
-0.0192037057,
-0.0118788946,
-0.0539925843,
-0.046728313,
-0.0679385513,
0.0102518955,
-0.0202723108,
-0.1104756072,
-0.0589464568,
-0.0299231466,
0.0068291677,
-0.0362285674,
0.005311355,
0.0746397153,
-0.0092426892,
-0.0028973715,
-0.003239918,
-0.0159081165,
-0.0215951018,
-0.0258605313,
0.0034443815,
0.0300269388,
-0.0330062397,
-0.0044069346,
-0.0270543694,
-0.0485436171,
-0.0388139673,
-0.0238237008,
-0.008834864,
0.0138087366,
-0.0132665858,
0.029327387,
0.013589927,
-0.0041686837,
0.074165754,
0.0080361674,
0.0114687122,
0.0505891927,
0.0805809498,
-0.0103676114,
0.0278948043,
0.0295965988,
0.0250534024,
-0.0189178791,
0.0379142947,
-0.0624212287,
-0.0306557901,
-0.0143987751,
-0.0116699794,
0.0653657317,
0.0146064451,
0.007804804,
0.0223306678,
-0.0094393613,
-0.0150650814,
0.0411538966,
-0.0597723834,
-0.0427895188,
0.0338607095,
0.026408108,
-0.021684004,
0.0106334444,
0.0098971073,
-0.0329654515,
-0.0105190389,
0.0235688817,
0.0076572672,
0.0152719943,
-0.0124279587,
-0.0224885978,
-0.0147205666,
0.0325873308,
0.0332905054,
0.050134629,
-0.0068557146,
0.0153212035,
0.038388934,
0.0113046458,
-0.0038689196,
-0.0129512046,
-0.070319064,
-0.0447046049,
0.0081087546,
0.0638129413,
0.035272453,
0.0383805633,
-0.0033195408,
-0.0759631544,
0.007205396,
0.0363035463,
0.080706954,
0.0102549838,
-0.0011592564,
0.0138205849,
0.0097133424,
-0.0777497292,
-0.0414345749,
0.0476522706,
0.0194815174,
0.0087323412,
0.0155294696,
-0.0083823455,
-0.0738740638,
-0.0497378148,
0.0148703381,
0.0197000951,
0.0264020357,
0.0397873223,
-0.0608366877,
-0.0160824116,
0.0518068671,
0.0102333669,
-0.0043809144,
-0.044004973,
0.0866845995,
0.0337037034,
0.0037267436,
-0.0076153302,
-0.0111731235,
-0.0299194939,
0.0267707258,
-0.0072226455,
-0.0407054275,
-5.712992176e-33,
-0.0170998946,
0.0136018982,
0.0224957112,
0.0318399109,
0.0071137603,
0.0144035639,
-0.0169309527,
-0.0149995741,
0.0322815701,
-0.0195120722,
0.0203694683,
0.0501595065,
0.0061938772,
-0.0017170929,
0.0025295222,
-0.0173037834,
0.0684230775,
0.0179377012,
0.0308549069,
-0.0067392346,
0.0004974024,
0.0531869903,
0.0857719257,
-0.0077069001,
0.0173270386,
0.0204843413,
-0.011414784,
-0.006279421,
0.0241589043,
-0.0220683031,
-0.0598525107,
0.0248941462,
-0.031613078,
-0.0414901301,
0.0328975953,
-0.0024622341,
0.000618907,
-0.0276843794,
0.0246401057,
-0.0049209218,
-0.0022017614,
0.0085511049,
0.0229046363,
0.0169347785,
-0.0225883704,
0.0003116333,
-0.0131213013,
0.0139464391,
-0.0034390842,
-0.0636431575,
-0.0320228264,
0.0230580475,
0.014459908,
0.0263203084,
0.0041223494,
-0.0055846311,
-0.0235986393,
-0.0126530444,
-0.0632836074,
0.0122659989,
0.0097874505,
0.023727268,
-0.006530399,
-0.0201142915,
0.0193479005,
0.0505466498,
0.0657246262,
-0.0259947255,
-0.0013122809,
0.0391490571,
0.0226839073,
-0.0007527203,
0.0450352244,
0.04160491,
0.0747675598,
-0.0416971557,
-0.0570908673,
-0.0369961374,
0.1050225496,
0.0066930302,
0.0387546979,
0.0155698964,
-0.028129451,
-0.0508053452,
0.0513230413,
0.0547070615,
-0.0132175321,
-0.0282796789,
-0.0053440011,
0.0130955717,
-0.0338936187,
0.0043555927,
0.0144553408,
-0.0279651657,
-0.0176544767,
0.0145000275,
0.0111862458,
-0.0227514878,
0.0015397237,
-0.0336278491,
-0.0303846188,
-0.0315866619,
0.0069208662,
-0.006937291,
-0.0192898326,
-0.0026122434,
-0.0092280321,
0.0209554695,
-0.0601048507,
-0.008149636,
-0.0124723297,
0.0379139148,
0.0275406279,
0.0222250633,
-0.0139987506,
0.0379666388,
0.0040570893,
0.0326804854,
-0.006451481,
0.0753105655,
-0.0345795751,
-0.009303337,
0.0259853043,
0.0560657755,
-0.0093761617,
-0.0219280813,
-0.0135881957,
0.0534194931,
-0.0394965447,
-0.0952386111,
-0.0254293401,
0.0336668976,
2.632e-7,
0.0210102815,
0.0477653667,
0.0077087767,
-0.0015518472,
0.0291007906,
0.0198061522,
0.0053097834,
0.0227095485,
-0.0087518524,
0.0274862833,
0.0475918129,
0.0433834195,
-0.0111282701,
0.016785197,
-0.0925644338,
-0.01395314,
-0.0810469016,
-0.0403201878,
-0.0350070894,
0.0370057523,
0.0653836951,
0.0850111917,
0.0244264882,
0.0023282904,
0.0397263542,
-0.0191719159,
0.0657408983,
0.0300124735,
-0.0310740992,
0.0014136689,
-0.0243886132,
0.0367162749,
-0.018574981,
-0.0126880677,
0.0285732597,
0.0288593192,
-0.019848492,
0.0038984609,
0.0223025344,
-0.0649416372,
-0.0041327183,
0.0107164392,
-0.0051583904,
0.0393802226,
0.0655605718,
-0.0687523633,
-0.0312079396,
-0.0416161157,
-0.0397242531,
0.0244724527,
0.0749092698,
0.0113032339,
-0.0193052012,
-0.0004339323,
-0.0123040276,
-0.0114627481,
0.0049608275,
-0.0477358848,
-0.022496894,
0.0249458868,
-0.0119864698,
-0.0246062744,
-0.0294730589,
-0.0161064491,
0.0106993206,
-0.0468534604,
-0.031364426,
2.191063614e-34,
0.0881503373,
-0.0100852363,
-0.003371146,
0.010705472,
0.0442994274,
0.0183145404,
-0.031375479,
-0.0023384728,
0.0354522094,
-0.0118635222,
-0.0342673622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11170v1 | UMLS-KGI-BERT: Data-Centric Knowledge Integration in Transformers for Biomedical Entity Recognition | 2023-07-20T18:08:34 | 2023-07-20T18:08:34 | Aidan Mannion, Thierry Chevalier, Didier Schwab, Lorraine Geouriot | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained transformer language models (LMs) have in recent years become the
dominant paradigm in applied NLP. These models have achieved state-of-the-art
performance on tasks such as information extraction, question answering,
sentiment analysis, document classification and many others. In the biomedical
domain, significant progress has been made in adapting this paradigm to NLP
tasks that require the integration of domain-specific knowledge as well as
statistical modelling of language. In particular, research in this area has
focused on the question of how best to construct LMs that take into account not
only the patterns of token distribution in medical text, but also the wealth of
structured information contained in terminology resources such as the UMLS.
This work contributes a data-centric paradigm for enriching the language
representations of biomedical transformer-encoder LMs by extracting text
sequences from the UMLS. This allows for graph-based learning objectives to be
combined with masked-language pre-training. Preliminary results from
experiments in the extension of pre-trained LMs as well as training from
scratch show that this framework improves downstream performance on multiple
biomedical and clinical Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks. | [
0.023650052,
0.0462101996,
0.0403633043,
-0.0364765786,
-0.0094323605,
0.0450722761,
-0.0147856195,
0.0062118187,
-0.0074158753,
-0.0743350685,
-0.0222533513,
-0.0399770848,
-0.0117936907,
0.0309007578,
0.0303986762,
-0.0230279844,
0.0126750544,
0.0207898561,
-0.0090690581,
0.0016052129,
-0.0244318172,
-0.0046382463,
0.0091783488,
0.0232503358,
-0.0050746053,
0.0266471282,
0.021476578,
0.0062872134,
0.0083914781,
-0.0563483611,
-0.012062409,
0.0361671373,
0.0077183852,
0.0153802028,
0.0000019353,
-0.0700342953,
-0.0549552105,
0.0394733101,
-0.048906751,
-0.0583187975,
0.0500267595,
-0.0810834467,
0.0170457438,
0.0090183336,
-0.0185204819,
-0.0666232631,
0.0420654155,
0.0634029061,
0.0239545908,
0.0715055093,
-0.0166047141,
-0.0121485302,
0.0578071252,
0.009301519,
-0.0166124925,
-0.0034399079,
0.0631118715,
-0.0463713892,
0.0214297567,
-0.016907122,
-0.0217951965,
0.0364900157,
-0.0232912786,
0.0398874432,
0.0305218603,
0.0387959182,
-0.0372193754,
0.0032154471,
0.0006861099,
0.0583081618,
-0.021903852,
-0.0404603891,
0.0234586671,
0.002319291,
-0.0282406583,
0.043108657,
-0.0372274965,
-0.0066198958,
-0.0145632913,
0.0009512687,
0.0019106802,
-0.014794834,
0.0385109931,
-0.0039576804,
-0.0699250028,
0.0279483795,
0.0276723336,
-0.051625222,
0.0389308706,
0.0089943036,
-0.0075382474,
-0.039401114,
0.0433418714,
0.0529687107,
0.0011743521,
0.0300040618,
-0.0204861406,
-0.0484610796,
0.0370617807,
-0.0432744771,
0.0014930655,
-0.0044002621,
-0.020880593,
0.0208547115,
-0.036143776,
0.0226036124,
-0.0131892012,
0.0724718943,
-0.0174479429,
-0.0298631713,
-0.0426319018,
-0.0227175783,
-0.0263249334,
0.0479042046,
0.0126856454,
-0.0158972908,
-0.0600148663,
0.0227227341,
0.0110785076,
0.0012989194,
0.0464693047,
0.0221855603,
0.0032111425,
-0.0094368029,
-0.0040036505,
0.02008898,
0.049923297,
-0.0160077959,
-0.040219333,
-0.0562055334,
-0.0149625773,
0.0007976094,
0.0376237333,
-0.0567776151,
0.0444857813,
0.0876858532,
0.053102456,
-0.0866023004,
0.0176235959,
0.0152691873,
-0.0165207926,
0.0133323791,
0.031970229,
-0.0518414453,
0.0351716429,
0.0388592444,
0.0139499828,
-0.0378991067,
0.0233174488,
-0.0094267186,
-0.0560785644,
0.0868858099,
-0.0497731157,
-0.013874677,
-0.0072465162,
0.0062394519,
0.019697994,
0.0102255438,
0.024152549,
-0.0490510203,
0.0053763879,
-0.0267645456,
0.0059171487,
0.0259851571,
0.0323476009,
-0.0646832064,
0.0018199838,
0.0131841395,
-0.0157951396,
0.0303245801,
0.0144284759,
0.0624869019,
-0.000873178,
-0.0182062723,
0.0130774165,
0.03552882,
0.029516872,
-0.0171087291,
0.0132795107,
-0.0159621015,
0.0095413858,
-0.0076717194,
-0.0119649731,
-0.0373938531,
0.0234135799,
0.0431120023,
-0.0295391865,
0.0338280424,
-0.0257461723,
-0.0023684844,
-0.0240222178,
-0.0409145504,
0.0016449442,
0.0087814434,
0.0718020201,
0.0232985485,
-0.0774525106,
0.1009325609,
0.0686593205,
-0.0046041859,
0.0412126519,
-0.04571018,
-0.0753569081,
0.0400000699,
0.0689485297,
-0.0382700041,
-0.0569015481,
-0.0331124179,
-0.0449603088,
0.022080807,
-0.0216358583,
-0.0126166595,
0.0155007411,
-0.0260650441,
-0.0000972755,
0.0244105048,
0.0134994732,
0.0093347616,
-0.0049617612,
0.0234817583,
-0.0090274243,
-0.0620984882,
-0.0075152125,
0.0470383279,
-0.053692054,
-0.0426395945,
-0.0169365294,
0.0047563077,
0.0141916182,
0.0292534083,
-0.0218420904,
0.0332902446,
0.0358327851,
-0.0383912884,
-0.0392710157,
-0.0192700382,
-0.0250184834,
-0.046799615,
0.0296074487,
-0.0130816717,
-0.0124989375,
0.0074035181,
-0.0066860071,
-0.0160584711,
-0.0561350249,
-0.0167357028,
0.0715857744,
-0.008977416,
0.0340968743,
0.0319101922,
0.0021667997,
-0.0513822213,
0.0157570541,
-0.0234090723,
0.0214540884,
-0.000817006,
-0.0461053886,
-0.0084987441,
-0.0005973166,
-0.0196567811,
0.0115208495,
-0.0016309764,
-0.0088355076,
-0.0066285674,
-0.0149768023,
-0.022355549,
-0.0268193148,
-0.1048429012,
-0.0209215712,
-0.0035137197,
0.0363084637,
0.026897205,
0.0472772233,
-0.00674906,
-0.0207824409,
-0.0230467934,
-0.0646934211,
0.0383526348,
0.0095394701,
0.0409807414,
0.0069958479,
0.018902665,
-0.0086860433,
-0.0047607659,
-0.0468104817,
0.0606945455,
-0.0056751836,
-0.04541732,
0.0052208225,
0.0127459802,
-0.018203022,
0.01921192,
-0.0089026503,
0.0058233701,
-0.0016141015,
0.0268973392,
0.0465853103,
0.0433555394,
0.0114253834,
0.0566952042,
0.0115535911,
-0.0220370051,
-0.0140843382,
-0.0027931402,
-0.078570731,
0.0016747073,
-0.0354305208,
-0.0154184112,
0.0682587326,
0.0725345686,
-0.0190091114,
-0.0221342556,
-0.0104089892,
-0.0333015099,
-0.0047152471,
0.0005412205,
-0.0231431648,
0.0155790858,
-0.0581855886,
-0.0010347134,
0.0119414181,
-0.0222667009,
0.0930943191,
-0.0522076301,
0.0154581601,
-0.0440919399,
0.0012202614,
-0.0527058914,
-0.0032671206,
0.0415651649,
0.0185167622,
-0.0026050329,
-0.0444126427,
0.0163836796,
0.0482579768,
-0.0419639945,
-0.0640675947,
0.0184212346,
0.0181992594,
0.0157056171,
0.0273758378,
-0.004706813,
-0.0446828008,
0.0078238091,
-0.0175755732,
0.0501300916,
0.0280545726,
-0.0142712882,
-0.0549964793,
0.0458591171,
-0.0118305869,
0.0471352525,
0.0227817781,
-0.0087920353,
-0.0279012714,
0.0439946651,
0.0579584166,
-0.0150914527,
0.0211265516,
-0.0054603736,
-0.0206904784,
0.0400153659,
0.0065233433,
-0.020806415,
0.0286862869,
-0.0159227978,
0.0282684173,
-0.08863388,
0.0300260372,
-0.0064494614,
0.0235438664,
0.0037910468,
-0.013171006,
0.1465926319,
0.0210692286,
-0.0272267144,
0.0028642134,
0.0264269076,
0.0016129499,
-0.0188240297,
0.0149344439,
-0.0710351095,
-0.0136868758,
-0.0076213237,
0.0195589904,
-0.0094406968,
-0.0553564057,
0.0270107407,
-0.0596349612,
-0.0070778932,
-0.0105067072,
-0.0277624503,
-0.0254780687,
-0.0720089972,
-0.0175020006,
-0.0182871558,
0.0135074565,
-0.0432408415,
-0.0463677719,
0.003629121,
0.0399744511,
-0.0283884015,
-0.0965277255,
0.012312524,
-0.0482147895,
0.0025011143,
0.0391197838,
0.0152790025,
-0.0302971452,
-0.0063947528,
0.0078958757,
0.0033419391,
-0.0128963208,
-0.0000126472,
0.0468363911,
-0.0561132133,
-0.0100343786,
-0.0382618196,
-0.0103969369,
-0.0474578291,
-0.0438002087,
-0.0607087351,
0.0691665113,
-0.0170569755,
-0.0144627858,
-0.0278205648,
-0.0379029475,
-0.0088063348,
0.044742763,
-0.0067298873,
-0.0148424031,
-0.019853808,
0.0287015643,
0.0642697737,
0.0201889966,
-0.0206549056,
0.0325791873,
-0.0669296831,
-0.0275239795,
-0.0412995555,
-0.0297605265,
0.0574921109,
0.0225147195,
0.0149738956,
0.0122581664,
0.0450754613,
-0.0289030783,
-0.0981038585,
0.0545825027,
0.0061691729,
0.0008028828,
-0.0651254728,
-0.0759864524,
0.0327987634,
0.0235052686,
-0.0442231521,
-0.0048897634,
-0.0114888446,
-0.0449751727,
0.0243173912,
0.0446324199,
0.013800174,
0.0073932582,
0.0064652124,
-0.0066747242,
0.0723057464,
0.0566567443,
-0.0470932387,
-0.0384413488,
-0.00203804,
-0.016944522,
-0.0216879062,
-0.0015079321,
-0.0174596179,
0.0330252871,
0.0238923859,
0.0383748561,
-0.0204523746,
-0.0484117977,
0.0359164886,
0.0221522506,
0.0887858942,
-0.0139643066,
0.0104787061,
-0.0345153511,
0.0172787663,
-0.0029954528,
0.0345579386,
-0.0184063837,
-0.0303626191,
0.031903781,
0.03378978,
-0.042176988,
0.0486183986,
-0.0522380322,
-0.0136990668,
-0.0294236727,
0.0332592167,
0.015679609,
-0.0077550663,
0.0539881885,
-0.0252605341,
0.021403566,
0.0108573632,
0.0365784727,
-0.0085339155,
-0.0138910813,
0.0165352393,
0.0004857166,
0.0424124338,
-0.0007518193,
0.0625622123,
-0.0555971824,
0.0077023185,
-0.0305557977,
-0.0128351534,
0.0084540499,
-0.0193204451,
0.0192126725,
-0.0117751984,
-0.0011281552,
-0.0175668616,
0.0054600504,
-0.0274006929,
0.020993622,
0.0811497942,
0.0185040999,
-0.0261787176,
-0.0246995948,
0.0731201023,
0.0501184873,
0.05946026,
-0.0051786914,
-0.0390546359,
-0.0170113016,
-0.015329998,
0.0514492504,
0.0124651669,
-0.0521711558,
0.020055376,
-0.0527471267,
-0.0735837966,
0.0534917526,
-0.0330407582,
-0.0015690242,
0.0014501932,
0.0561310053,
0.0162241794,
0.0243252106,
-0.010643119,
-0.0160414223,
0.0376825333,
0.0105448859,
-0.0282412358,
0.0291230939,
-6.312773475e-33,
-0.0067777545,
-0.0578641482,
0.0143621145,
0.0017297342,
-0.004231785,
0.020586608,
0.0033281015,
-0.0202739965,
0.0002180124,
0.0069481037,
-0.0196239818,
-0.0091749523,
0.0087147737,
0.0498952083,
-0.0550353527,
-0.0393722318,
0.0383097641,
0.0358489864,
-0.0028218101,
-0.0249833968,
0.0039069243,
0.0981218293,
0.0859226882,
-0.0645378307,
0.0211943332,
-0.014264863,
0.0568957776,
0.0001204634,
0.0551161468,
0.0540394112,
-0.0493996553,
0.0295538865,
0.0294172894,
-0.0198978968,
0.001770076,
0.013292037,
-0.1231263727,
0.0000259619,
0.0042076781,
0.0169891044,
-0.0051144352,
-0.0250835121,
0.0582500659,
-0.0199220441,
-0.0195985828,
-0.0037429342,
0.0352401771,
0.018700894,
-0.0267384555,
-0.073636435,
-0.0483986251,
0.0507185943,
0.0253064074,
0.0175300781,
0.028044045,
-0.0309565403,
-0.0032096482,
0.0487311631,
-0.0462221541,
-0.0078067579,
0.0360324383,
0.0026271536,
0.0205032378,
0.0026142509,
0.0061541353,
0.0474476181,
-0.0159906335,
-0.0338491164,
-0.0287534408,
0.0245224051,
-0.0073986403,
0.0318198279,
-0.0084582381,
-0.0220361259,
0.0212081857,
-0.0238849167,
-0.0654620901,
0.0469905436,
-0.068239972,
0.0266468376,
-0.0018179518,
-0.0226723421,
-0.0227763746,
-0.0059558763,
-0.0188049972,
0.0179550145,
-0.014765365,
-0.0243669022,
0.0102622015,
-0.0121913785,
-0.024639871,
0.04883077,
-0.0021661718,
-0.0309202429,
-0.0394315086,
-0.009008117,
0.0608096756,
0.0109877456,
-0.0503998846,
0.0160895586,
-0.0555800125,
-0.0357432365,
0.0378742851,
-0.0238508657,
0.0263568759,
0.0025758608,
0.0286107995,
0.0025569312,
-0.0672639236,
-0.0058163796,
0.0053460514,
-0.0132282758,
-0.0148720527,
0.0265911017,
0.0442659743,
0.0540963709,
-0.0007246111,
0.0278664827,
0.0271655247,
-0.0279058237,
-0.0255948342,
0.0446084328,
0.0203208067,
0.0259303171,
-0.0193294995,
-0.0227181073,
-0.0155361537,
0.063808471,
0.0235635079,
-0.0644185543,
0.0023204763,
-0.0377462879,
2.806e-7,
0.1185748056,
0.0737325624,
0.0325832479,
-0.0254921336,
0.0113575449,
-0.0234939419,
0.0061194082,
0.0400110222,
-0.0055142916,
-0.0093613071,
0.0169360843,
0.0040082666,
-0.0259675346,
0.0120290155,
-0.0771939829,
-0.0406999066,
-0.0570233203,
-0.007889851,
-0.025138218,
0.0203252528,
0.0549962707,
0.0884121209,
-0.0310371481,
-0.0226594582,
-0.0177119244,
-0.0191493407,
0.0676083043,
-0.0221940577,
0.0076569142,
0.058264181,
-0.0011979482,
0.0016974643,
0.024640033,
0.0444619916,
-0.0249174386,
0.013384752,
0.024066519,
0.0553726479,
-0.0446656086,
-0.0261552408,
0.0411832184,
-0.0069426922,
-0.0020093373,
-0.0327873826,
0.0575287603,
-0.0797227249,
-0.0620925166,
-0.0237750206,
-0.0306331031,
0.0026420373,
0.0180185381,
-0.0004366096,
-0.0158329252,
0.0612605587,
0.0455973446,
0.0150965694,
-0.0169301704,
-0.0958083123,
0.0155062219,
0.0452993065,
-0.0022655963,
-0.0262599606,
0.0046186158,
-0.0327258371,
0.032725703,
-0.0502879098,
0.0178043265,
2.862595526e-34,
0.0129792653,
0.0266140271,
-0.0182389449,
0.0648990422,
0.0106181009,
-0.0506377444,
0.0234700777,
0.0154877026,
-0.0015992129,
-0.0824074969,
0.0086141294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11088v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11088v3 | L-Eval: Instituting Standardized Evaluation for Long Context Language Models | 2023-07-20T17:59:41 | 2023-10-04T10:04:25 | Chenxin An, Shansan Gong, Ming Zhong, Xingjian Zhao, Mukai Li, Jun Zhang, Lingpeng Kong, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been growing interest in extending the context length of
large language models (LLMs), aiming to effectively process long inputs of one
turn or conversations with more extensive histories. While proprietary models
such as GPT-4 and Claude can largely preserve the reasoning ability in an
extended context, open-source models are still progressing through the early
stages of development. To bridge this gap, we propose L-Eval to institute a
more standardized evaluation for long context language models (LCLMs)
addressing two key aspects: dataset construction and evaluation metrics. On the
one hand, we build a new evaluation suite containing 20 sub-tasks, 508 long
documents, and over 2,000 human-labeled query-response pairs encompassing
diverse question styles, domains, and input length (3k$\sim$200k tokens). On
the other hand, we investigate the effectiveness in evalution metrics for
LCLMs. Results show that popular n-gram matching metrics generally can not
correlate well with human judgment, and thus we strongly advocate for
length-instruction-enhanced (LIE) evaluation and employing LLM judges. We
conducted a comprehensive study of 4 popular commercial LLMs and 12 open-source
counterparts using the L-Eval benchmark. Our empirical findings offer useful
insights into the study of LCLMs and lay the groundwork for the development of
more principled evaluation of these models. | [
0.0296005625,
0.0458135866,
-0.003573247,
0.0506240353,
-0.0804682672,
0.0059441631,
0.0226574931,
-0.0170794874,
-0.0118858106,
-0.0561881103,
-0.0306908153,
-0.0561127663,
0.0054453812,
0.0206608325,
0.0157193225,
-0.0295044314,
0.0403580964,
-0.0364840925,
-0.0022532498,
0.0105127338,
0.0093201948,
-0.000212881,
0.003538843,
0.052049078,
0.0166000556,
-0.0267248638,
-0.0246488266,
-0.0031689615,
-0.0071962327,
-0.0126108136,
-0.0106378868,
0.0608932264,
0.0009538251,
0.0385976061,
0.0000018295,
-0.0842461288,
0.0037177852,
0.0012749482,
-0.0406198725,
0.0220339503,
0.0426774286,
0.0214600693,
0.0187516473,
0.0229363889,
-0.0290817209,
-0.0214858875,
0.0161155518,
0.0502715856,
0.0255567096,
0.0707863718,
0.002714518,
-0.0480652861,
0.0431663468,
-0.0451636575,
0.0340563431,
-0.0747720748,
0.0304716099,
-0.0022698254,
0.0389258377,
0.0119093563,
-0.0197858196,
0.0351429321,
0.0542914197,
-0.0208663065,
-0.0090152109,
0.0138094984,
-0.0500555821,
0.0189754106,
0.0168986432,
0.0865346566,
0.0326508172,
-0.0076302285,
-0.0117505444,
0.0133677255,
0.020504456,
-0.0145520885,
-0.0508347712,
0.0109326802,
0.0044457503,
-0.0192002747,
0.0216205139,
0.006605247,
0.0316891149,
0.00846765,
-0.0426958427,
0.0837474912,
0.022275785,
-0.0549341738,
0.0013645091,
-0.0167005025,
-0.0275538042,
-0.0634200424,
-0.0069750571,
0.005928332,
-0.0420545302,
0.0219866671,
-0.0349302553,
0.0003572619,
0.0503179915,
-0.0124192741,
-0.0136694405,
0.0250991397,
-0.0116511667,
0.0703064874,
-0.0309149977,
0.0819065645,
0.0027771445,
0.0096215978,
-0.0496708564,
-0.0358873084,
-0.0446301363,
0.0079262871,
-0.0278717279,
-0.0043310826,
-0.0518333353,
-0.0377571061,
-0.0347844139,
0.0222436152,
-0.0019657311,
0.006999129,
0.0292378217,
-0.0079907794,
0.008694659,
-0.0113659212,
-0.0420396253,
0.0140706934,
-0.0406030007,
0.0273718797,
0.0261435807,
-0.0507191382,
0.0043918709,
0.0148692681,
0.0021325029,
-0.0604073405,
-0.0045665386,
0.0477893502,
0.0177244917,
-0.0392560139,
-0.0062714787,
-0.0287579913,
-0.0315742269,
-0.064174585,
-0.0255536214,
-0.0814727545,
0.0235552043,
0.0092810383,
-0.0098962691,
-0.0195050128,
-0.0282215253,
0.0322564691,
-0.0209336169,
0.0694706962,
0.054849714,
0.0180239249,
0.0039989664,
0.0248923525,
0.0046821968,
0.0518522412,
-0.0007541913,
0.0067145913,
0.0649488345,
-0.016387729,
0.0125219524,
0.0395187959,
-0.0002333247,
-0.0014117802,
-0.001498871,
0.059569288,
0.0218041092,
0.050649859,
0.0282327309,
0.0678506196,
-0.0262060855,
-0.0572972149,
0.0347571783,
0.0598721281,
0.065348424,
-0.0246010832,
0.0638967231,
0.0089487182,
-0.003181824,
0.0070278784,
-0.0607987382,
-0.0039712884,
-0.0297608133,
0.0318385474,
0.0304711815,
0.0043156999,
-0.0393198542,
-0.0270154942,
-0.018810356,
0.0050642849,
0.0205998011,
0.030815972,
0.0226232633,
-0.013017497,
-0.0304549672,
0.0262682252,
0.0009277452,
-0.0566783324,
-0.0023740635,
-0.0575600304,
0.0277399793,
0.0630522817,
0.0614450797,
0.0015581353,
-0.0156448465,
-0.0143833831,
0.0338448882,
0.0370716602,
0.0600808412,
-0.0135727059,
0.0238933414,
-0.030994419,
-0.0257285107,
-0.0089799445,
0.0014449396,
-0.0086172782,
0.0437778458,
0.0139615126,
0.0396671779,
-0.0863138512,
0.004701559,
0.0392544754,
-0.0428437777,
-0.0521267429,
-0.0391235575,
0.0119626867,
0.0207765475,
0.0141974455,
0.0090123769,
0.0415428393,
0.0360611267,
-0.0157933012,
-0.0044910926,
-0.0166456345,
-0.0756953061,
-0.0251468718,
0.0493964441,
-0.0256037116,
-0.0014352922,
0.0093694162,
-0.0122069158,
-0.0507032387,
-0.0070261736,
-0.0056805685,
0.0440865755,
-0.039466694,
0.027461946,
-0.0079924632,
-0.0044944109,
-0.0559485368,
0.0572288819,
0.0003721416,
0.0293531474,
0.016575234,
0.0319724865,
0.0131660225,
-0.0444100127,
-0.0500371009,
0.0156290624,
-0.0078602126,
-0.0074037104,
0.0278375074,
0.0197670925,
-0.0729408637,
-0.0280710794,
-0.1167560592,
0.0071842354,
-0.0401959829,
0.0185945127,
0.0107937502,
0.0137596754,
-0.0227933545,
0.0212969389,
-0.0637631789,
-0.0324501991,
0.0075080437,
0.0235357713,
0.0012074079,
0.019543184,
-0.038475126,
-0.0528890267,
-0.0328808799,
-0.0059365844,
0.0564066395,
-0.0172972847,
0.0276814606,
-0.0322092213,
0.0491213165,
-0.0153465578,
0.0033685921,
-0.038703233,
-0.0040142601,
0.0137370061,
-0.0194678176,
0.0489102229,
0.0578641519,
0.014063552,
-0.0189697407,
0.016803002,
0.0019780975,
-0.049182456,
0.0083606141,
-0.0155609753,
-0.033061713,
-0.0405483209,
-0.0018085373,
-0.0039194394,
0.0440548211,
-0.0251326337,
0.0022769887,
-0.0311937407,
-0.0182904284,
-0.0021834094,
-0.0344194062,
-0.0269136466,
-0.0231742449,
-0.0294982567,
0.0289161522,
-0.0369733684,
-0.0396453589,
0.0641846731,
-0.0613602884,
0.0025111397,
-0.0390973352,
-0.0055135875,
-0.0602553599,
0.1058098301,
-0.0088634007,
-0.006627386,
-0.0218312126,
-0.0173558276,
-0.0276574269,
0.0047931517,
-0.0063018529,
-0.0337307788,
0.0823401809,
-0.0438040458,
0.0229543038,
0.000161047,
-0.0376300402,
-0.044137001,
-0.0305440724,
-0.0276254267,
0.0172034688,
0.0232325904,
0.0006104204,
-0.0117183309,
0.0228048712,
0.0170910656,
0.0517577752,
-0.0196650643,
0.0098670227,
-0.0166880861,
0.0345314555,
0.0485056192,
0.0071776714,
0.013481196,
-0.0117385518,
0.0463320091,
0.0388610363,
0.0669972524,
-0.0151820527,
-0.015701361,
-0.0101339333,
0.0091675445,
-0.0298902597,
-0.0292991921,
0.0318848453,
0.0620669648,
-0.0611588135,
-0.0211637076,
0.1317769289,
0.0228057429,
-0.0554128885,
0.0025753807,
-0.0458126143,
0.0515540317,
0.0240641013,
0.0034853402,
-0.0728246272,
-0.0578487888,
0.0291621108,
0.0094814114,
0.006852577,
-0.0363396071,
0.0067902859,
-0.1272214204,
0.0036412713,
-0.0065392689,
-0.0495081879,
-0.0148310391,
-0.0381448492,
0.0149348127,
-0.0037861592,
0.0396349318,
0.0458996408,
-0.0291357245,
-0.005445559,
0.0011534569,
-0.0129218055,
-0.0510635115,
0.0900631472,
-0.0454303659,
0.0538185164,
0.0511162616,
0.0058346377,
0.025090497,
-0.0473386906,
0.0707983822,
-0.0485232286,
0.0144947506,
0.0151358275,
0.0298393574,
-0.0289668217,
0.018854361,
-0.0192355029,
0.0361729264,
-0.0392562486,
0.0119201774,
0.0415064767,
0.0631968156,
-0.0089575592,
0.0075500524,
-0.0294571314,
-0.0237974133,
-0.0039901482,
0.1084448174,
0.0590473041,
-0.0200166199,
-0.0642710999,
-0.0022520716,
-0.0297395159,
-0.0386744998,
-0.0160135273,
-0.0005579126,
0.0021519435,
0.0157059394,
-0.0422824509,
-0.062632896,
0.0337249003,
0.0265005585,
-0.0221528709,
0.0344355851,
-0.0242372938,
0.0007230036,
-0.0396632589,
0.0462457724,
-0.0414409339,
0.0579300895,
-0.0842334554,
0.0451818444,
0.0006653803,
-0.0089020869,
-0.0115163038,
0.0425508805,
-0.0828322247,
-0.0457684994,
0.010122532,
-0.0021311424,
0.027792206,
0.0317021906,
-0.0312671438,
-0.0401565842,
-0.0005493037,
0.0017041531,
-0.0463612154,
0.0246026088,
0.0131566068,
-0.0003193012,
0.0044184504,
0.0505004451,
-0.0419909321,
0.0012475542,
-0.0014296694,
0.0678523928,
-0.0139257321,
-0.0463621169,
0.0122788809,
0.0199895408,
0.032844238,
0.0097589372,
0.014931812,
-0.0034166344,
0.0144077195,
-0.0545592085,
-0.0080726193,
-0.0114215882,
0.0023268999,
0.0253147837,
-0.005858663,
0.0140713723,
0.0129308933,
-0.0279980507,
0.0326397866,
-0.0473990515,
0.0261335634,
0.0216563176,
-0.0021620453,
0.0246703941,
0.0045327158,
-0.0327868797,
-0.0300356708,
-0.0092718182,
0.0361672156,
-0.0152980415,
0.0596495792,
0.0131557779,
0.0148216207,
-0.0065077567,
0.0394691564,
-0.0936575457,
-0.0039341161,
0.009956887,
0.0127890483,
0.0437700264,
-0.0188579541,
0.0410274789,
0.0081932368,
-0.0027295151,
-0.0497751385,
0.0341707356,
0.0042513805,
-0.0266903564,
0.0298799854,
0.0622606426,
-0.0215894356,
0.0174674634,
0.0849239305,
0.0214892458,
0.0260566957,
0.0027452353,
0.0008376014,
-0.0273168813,
-0.0375189148,
-0.0141727012,
0.0282633919,
-0.0293502025,
-0.0204766784,
-0.0711381882,
-0.0754986778,
-0.0193312187,
0.014067959,
0.0064876666,
0.0016291846,
0.0503669567,
0.1005003825,
0.0039625997,
-0.0275637582,
-0.0263517164,
0.0242049713,
-0.0225669146,
-0.0193037968,
-0.0309958067,
-6.023971411e-33,
0.0001189331,
-0.0182507169,
0.0440655686,
-0.0334805027,
-0.0525731593,
0.0136926277,
-0.0165589713,
0.0169766061,
-0.0276916809,
0.0011941558,
-0.0337249748,
0.0135899903,
0.0019096044,
0.0274196155,
-0.0085803438,
-0.0329024047,
0.0240988601,
0.0142127667,
-0.0158400424,
0.020978421,
0.0219139066,
0.0079134433,
0.0073577394,
-0.0547270887,
0.0494056568,
-0.0068200319,
0.0284919627,
0.0149528133,
-0.0214112289,
0.0984515622,
-0.0050597806,
0.0261148494,
0.0347509794,
-0.0641894042,
-0.0162310693,
0.0382703207,
-0.0939063206,
-0.0000249345,
0.0467223115,
-0.0193438455,
-0.0441853628,
-0.0295177735,
0.0411118232,
0.0052434625,
-0.0350196175,
-0.0108079575,
0.0209933799,
-0.0217486341,
-0.0355458185,
-0.0082405927,
-0.0340461098,
0.0367238112,
0.0032010372,
-0.0107606994,
0.0008128054,
0.0536142439,
-0.0048440988,
0.0461935066,
-0.0392500907,
-0.0038678229,
-0.0362933539,
0.0336722471,
0.0847966,
0.0016882853,
0.0121176364,
0.0490349047,
-0.0116788382,
-0.0126329148,
-0.0252504237,
-0.0310493112,
0.0192038734,
0.0485248379,
0.0326988399,
0.04981298,
0.0300593637,
-0.0076753004,
-0.0494866669,
0.0139576653,
0.0062155663,
0.0604185686,
0.0152418315,
0.0017227341,
-0.0543486439,
-0.0211195834,
-0.0711766705,
0.0173676647,
-0.0447200648,
-0.0009451341,
0.0711958706,
0.0026782248,
0.0187572371,
-0.0384866446,
0.0459907092,
-0.029968217,
-0.0080465935,
0.0271068476,
-0.0195401311,
0.010103723,
0.0087493313,
0.0486242883,
-0.046131067,
0.0094264867,
0.0239033718,
0.0236318167,
0.0059191114,
-0.0198840443,
0.0284193382,
0.0013829628,
-0.0519539304,
-0.0141727608,
-0.0429849327,
0.0015815276,
-0.0384256542,
0.0088610603,
0.0526785739,
0.0228416435,
0.0007849463,
0.0606333278,
-0.0068332488,
0.0007883761,
-0.0348832272,
-0.0710988194,
0.0081150914,
-0.0008904367,
-0.0243820362,
0.0030715154,
-0.0280274637,
0.0115382606,
0.0434866361,
-0.0255356506,
0.0038730674,
0.0335047692,
2.481e-7,
0.0420932546,
0.0347330458,
0.0426045135,
0.0170433354,
0.0182088595,
0.021855114,
-0.0012913531,
0.0270856135,
0.0050183372,
-0.010533602,
-0.0132924421,
0.0139102209,
0.0503291376,
-0.0072455695,
-0.0760076046,
-0.0111915441,
-0.0662589669,
-0.0001588142,
-0.0443190522,
0.0086087864,
0.0659867749,
0.0877663866,
0.0027193506,
0.0006248294,
-0.0150012979,
-0.0642230362,
0.0298821833,
-0.0517365858,
-0.0172444023,
0.009461835,
0.0375998914,
0.0165297315,
0.0482560359,
0.0142391361,
0.0130427266,
0.0316600911,
0.0203128587,
0.077358149,
0.0240976438,
-0.0537138209,
-0.0041930005,
-0.0474498495,
-0.0143615259,
-0.0778418034,
0.1086396649,
-0.0150739839,
-0.0108887628,
-0.0249451082,
-0.0293962844,
-0.011981138,
0.0163082313,
0.0254356544,
-0.014807269,
0.0146698235,
0.0356291384,
-0.026324451,
-0.008549449,
-0.0943649858,
-0.0353949405,
-0.0115322284,
-0.0420182347,
-0.0355087928,
-0.0546877012,
0.0039857584,
0.0269483328,
-0.0589837767,
-0.0072658421,
2.508494843e-34,
0.0530994087,
-0.0051588821,
0.0265189987,
-0.0320414715,
0.0339104533,
-0.016738439,
-0.0178976599,
0.0051015457,
0.0165887456,
-0.1266862601,
-0.0156619865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11031v1 | Embroid: Unsupervised Prediction Smoothing Can Improve Few-Shot Classification | 2023-07-20T17:07:28 | 2023-07-20T17:07:28 | Neel Guha, Mayee F. Chen, Kush Bhatia, Azalia Mirhoseini, Frederic Sala, Christopher Ré | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Recent work has shown that language models' (LMs) prompt-based learning
capabilities make them well suited for automating data labeling in domains
where manual annotation is expensive. The challenge is that while writing an
initial prompt is cheap, improving a prompt is costly -- practitioners often
require significant labeled data in order to evaluate the impact of prompt
modifications. Our work asks whether it is possible to improve prompt-based
learning without additional labeled data. We approach this problem by
attempting to modify the predictions of a prompt, rather than the prompt
itself. Our intuition is that accurate predictions should also be consistent:
samples which are similar under some feature representation should receive the
same prompt prediction. We propose Embroid, a method which computes multiple
representations of a dataset under different embedding functions, and uses the
consistency between the LM predictions for neighboring samples to identify
mispredictions. Embroid then uses these neighborhoods to create additional
predictions for each sample, and combines these predictions with a simple
latent variable graphical model in order to generate a final corrected
prediction. In addition to providing a theoretical analysis of Embroid, we
conduct a rigorous empirical evaluation across six different LMs and up to 95
different tasks. We find that (1) Embroid substantially improves performance
over original prompts (e.g., by an average of 7.3 points on GPT-JT), (2) also
realizes improvements for more sophisticated prompting strategies (e.g.,
chain-of-thought), and (3) can be specialized to domains like law through the
embedding functions. | [
0.0396125317,
0.0397093892,
-0.0068032267,
0.0162877105,
-0.0629699305,
0.0517206974,
0.063515231,
-0.0200038999,
0.0363838598,
-0.0973078907,
-0.009495711,
-0.0200453326,
-0.0016254614,
-0.0151801743,
0.0207793377,
-0.0584075525,
0.0534048341,
-0.0209955368,
0.0682680383,
-0.0129811876,
0.0059244977,
0.0067849834,
-0.0152499666,
0.0295331627,
-0.0289096572,
-0.0189363081,
-0.0172040835,
-0.0118765011,
0.0071910084,
0.0054326495,
0.010662836,
0.1087630242,
0.0012196422,
0.0367294811,
0.000002198,
-0.0636538565,
0.0089820521,
-0.0094251074,
-0.0525142029,
0.0018030663,
0.0354774334,
-0.0395033248,
0.0298599359,
0.0078760087,
-0.0059473622,
-0.0821801871,
0.0432760753,
0.0131228995,
0.0245569814,
0.0489165187,
-0.0023853877,
-0.0406465717,
-0.0136622908,
-0.0460823961,
0.056502562,
-0.0493743382,
0.0271238722,
-0.0327556953,
-0.0248839371,
0.0303598456,
-0.036770314,
0.0335954614,
-0.0011985414,
-0.0031094218,
0.0391963795,
0.0497727208,
-0.0032016516,
-0.0071756067,
-0.0067272182,
0.0699716657,
-0.0059848176,
-0.0176174827,
-0.0238794796,
-0.0395335741,
0.0229307339,
0.0356735066,
-0.0199218225,
0.0068255346,
-0.0092467824,
0.0035080167,
0.0004564001,
-0.0115725044,
0.0341139622,
0.0117801586,
0.0070880596,
0.045970384,
-0.0016682739,
-0.0291362479,
0.021477541,
0.0226470735,
-0.0188721102,
-0.065643169,
-0.0219027363,
0.0200996473,
-0.0223430693,
0.0146401981,
-0.0342493467,
-0.0329227857,
0.0339348651,
0.030379761,
0.0582820661,
0.0260782279,
-0.0431916676,
0.0764527246,
-0.0168217383,
0.0216506645,
0.0445326492,
0.0328770801,
-0.0380949341,
0.0052704518,
-0.0631014034,
-0.0094314432,
-0.045368243,
0.038925074,
-0.0012401406,
0.0085841687,
-0.0458902679,
0.0082874438,
-0.0252603143,
0.0269122627,
-0.0080172103,
-0.0068883216,
-0.0082268696,
-0.0077429065,
-0.0263501015,
-0.0046155495,
-0.0439595506,
0.0298200976,
0.0064960509,
-0.0445298478,
-0.0230430681,
-0.0079623731,
0.0146030169,
0.0023623698,
-0.0020978821,
0.0546426103,
-0.0013012001,
-0.0441572927,
-0.0266909171,
-0.0346100666,
-0.0394857042,
-0.0372904688,
-0.0013595177,
-0.0714176372,
0.0301817395,
0.0137825329,
-0.009842854,
-0.0138687557,
-0.0111292824,
0.0050080931,
-0.0437493958,
0.1153786182,
-0.024653187,
0.003280214,
0.019219676,
-0.0062388158,
-0.0169767682,
0.0414364077,
-0.0159217734,
-0.010572644,
0.0375145376,
0.0110446205,
0.0363574661,
0.0310651939,
0.0261957292,
0.0097700516,
-0.0203224979,
-0.0218111016,
0.0406206734,
0.0209565964,
0.0194058996,
-0.0025907357,
-0.0253463741,
-0.0338930413,
0.0378440917,
0.0529369079,
-0.0234234519,
-0.0368261635,
0.0482910126,
-0.0037316992,
0.0026377975,
0.019078739,
-0.0750145391,
0.0064919423,
-0.0451698042,
-0.0034248419,
0.0161963589,
-0.0283127949,
-0.0404928625,
-0.0303064659,
-0.0133065553,
-0.0093818894,
-0.0020647759,
0.0224489644,
0.0317564011,
0.0162325203,
-0.0115150996,
0.0130794235,
0.0317557715,
0.0022599287,
-0.0242472999,
-0.0429915227,
0.0409105159,
0.0683395416,
0.0174156558,
-0.0252135843,
-0.0258323513,
-0.0274445508,
0.056079004,
0.0332579799,
0.0644475743,
-0.0334490538,
0.0107140793,
-0.0364357084,
-0.058616288,
0.0036948498,
0.041586224,
0.0488864332,
-0.0075075361,
-0.0172781218,
0.0234244298,
-0.0392482355,
0.0253820848,
0.0392468311,
0.0028058218,
-0.078359589,
0.0387428589,
0.0242579654,
0.0152318226,
-0.0102095949,
-0.0082453284,
0.0024473306,
-0.0133932643,
-0.0143331708,
0.0066490024,
-0.0207838118,
-0.0275242887,
-0.0919659734,
0.02132014,
0.0134229362,
-0.0316074938,
-0.0143961366,
-0.0909107849,
-0.0339423865,
-0.0399937294,
-0.0165655054,
-0.0163595732,
-0.0493414588,
-0.0091163013,
0.0082739005,
-0.0333233811,
-0.0484443605,
0.0555586107,
-0.0137379132,
0.0312506892,
0.0351288877,
0.0116028944,
0.0287754871,
-0.0243522767,
-0.0495558418,
-0.0196254104,
0.0260012411,
0.0058542094,
0.0340716131,
0.0029352207,
-0.0379812643,
0.0003579333,
-0.0890065581,
-0.0047654477,
-0.0133429011,
-0.0161993019,
0.0028398971,
-0.0129565541,
-0.0116439005,
-0.0589207001,
-0.0344775468,
-0.001235576,
0.0052099866,
0.0426521897,
0.0271973629,
0.0014836643,
-0.0155273294,
-0.0212218966,
-0.0072481423,
-0.0261910371,
0.0513066165,
-0.0003151164,
-0.0605548173,
-0.0558282249,
0.0110847438,
-0.0375176221,
0.017100146,
-0.0068630632,
0.0186593477,
-0.0247239321,
-0.0056634629,
0.0242925547,
0.0407925099,
-0.0051955874,
-0.0007977257,
0.0442273021,
0.0016630021,
-0.0690322146,
-0.004455375,
-0.0432132035,
-0.0283597019,
0.0107539287,
-0.0216277484,
-0.028699765,
0.0634510517,
0.0297790859,
-0.0093928175,
-0.060473498,
0.0382547826,
0.0087711243,
-0.0180940852,
-0.0924311206,
0.0232105833,
0.0031674914,
0.0204007011,
-0.0296366047,
-0.093413651,
0.1067811996,
0.0135462387,
0.0168372095,
0.0031089496,
-0.0040703896,
0.0011860543,
0.0499112271,
0.0352255628,
0.0017814272,
0.0134807108,
-0.0289656986,
-0.0642934591,
-0.0144696552,
0.0510211326,
-0.0235564858,
0.0112711061,
-0.0444691777,
0.0133014107,
-0.0079990486,
-0.0481277741,
-0.0416158251,
-0.0768569037,
-0.0267415587,
0.0168769099,
-0.02689505,
0.0283059981,
-0.0123789124,
-0.0120579349,
-0.0196419265,
0.056925837,
-0.0172045827,
-0.0146200489,
-0.0138258087,
0.0186391771,
0.0237469599,
-0.0118661169,
-0.0229097456,
-0.0190779995,
0.0458970554,
0.0078242365,
-0.006527775,
0.0281654987,
-0.0014171547,
0.0286121611,
0.0192391686,
-0.0393488221,
-0.0473169498,
0.0537776984,
0.0245151296,
-0.0113366134,
0.009505121,
0.1228552908,
0.0419669747,
-0.0420499705,
-0.0318080597,
-0.0001604448,
0.0401876792,
0.041760806,
0.0213950835,
-0.0996169299,
-0.0429070853,
0.0041404055,
0.0307387058,
-0.0030879995,
-0.0499621369,
0.0034367645,
-0.1342624575,
0.0673135817,
0.0098246774,
-0.0183272623,
-0.0055526625,
-0.0442856215,
0.0084217573,
0.0005162504,
-0.0188705157,
0.0025310453,
0.0017027853,
0.0104076667,
0.0352847688,
-0.0481299087,
-0.0632427409,
0.0325537622,
-0.0378125608,
0.0655622557,
0.0377672575,
-0.0197785534,
0.0038132633,
-0.0327253044,
0.0047296588,
0.0039868872,
0.0052066362,
-0.0128637739,
0.0900906846,
-0.0227481071,
-0.0072937636,
-0.0227377098,
0.0370515995,
0.0144341411,
-0.049675405,
0.0096167559,
0.0815542191,
-0.0375209749,
-0.0063736513,
-0.0223179776,
0.0069813123,
0.0259278715,
0.0899918973,
0.0312332455,
-0.0420430675,
-0.0273720101,
-0.0340148993,
0.00607582,
0.0005984229,
-0.018143259,
0.0346558765,
-0.0095351562,
-0.0334588699,
-0.0357780047,
-0.06331525,
0.0563353747,
-0.0052126464,
0.0239454098,
0.0131291589,
-0.0330036432,
0.014929926,
-0.0413849279,
0.0020017142,
-0.0416799262,
0.0100467065,
-0.001438035,
-0.0112438519,
0.0272674523,
-0.0042198072,
-0.0257255565,
-0.0134051321,
-0.0658684969,
-0.039363265,
0.0028259081,
0.0557855181,
0.0162182972,
0.0592672043,
-0.028890729,
-0.0519235916,
0.0882010609,
0.0845841095,
0.0239037629,
0.0129642338,
0.0273131374,
0.0071563213,
-0.0014850692,
0.0330015384,
-0.048081629,
0.0320024975,
0.0342052989,
0.006171443,
-0.0361872539,
-0.0369369797,
0.0356417075,
0.0252535064,
0.1101370156,
-0.0227988232,
-0.0168926623,
-0.0355108492,
-0.0113835428,
0.0119294459,
-0.0516000278,
-0.0251125749,
0.0057067857,
0.0271900278,
-0.0152546484,
-0.0340798832,
0.0194010939,
-0.0216102898,
0.0513164327,
-0.0295480508,
-0.030089194,
-0.0074877841,
0.0088457251,
0.0013503967,
0.0059212241,
-0.0367080718,
0.0146570615,
0.0025687907,
0.0018662005,
-0.0097877709,
0.065863736,
0.0270755682,
0.0124709886,
-0.0438984483,
-0.0071158931,
-0.0702385232,
-0.0304010864,
-0.036444325,
0.0691586062,
0.0407862961,
-0.0139501141,
-0.0283966139,
-0.0224146172,
-0.0283637177,
-0.03134536,
0.035552673,
0.0357371457,
-0.0415721387,
0.0878172368,
0.023447521,
-0.0349667259,
-0.0079630585,
0.0708409175,
0.0088648442,
0.0428171866,
0.0194375776,
0.0031842235,
-0.0527319871,
-0.0064687473,
0.0307848621,
0.0298637673,
-0.0128645934,
0.0187143162,
-0.0800277442,
-0.0551544838,
0.0064753341,
0.0053096768,
-0.0094023701,
0.0253196023,
0.0367172919,
0.0471305363,
-0.0021958884,
-0.022631539,
-0.0541566946,
0.0096993186,
0.0143122934,
-0.0269217268,
0.0018659586,
-6.536219523e-33,
-0.023453163,
-0.0223568585,
0.0020966122,
0.0026311316,
0.0388177745,
-0.0144314962,
-0.0050932327,
0.0233086478,
0.006961674,
0.0587334111,
-0.0038216941,
-0.0088028936,
0.019713074,
-0.0007654738,
0.0429369509,
-0.0500074588,
0.0573734194,
-0.0235782973,
-0.0277430899,
-0.0039659087,
0.0104769431,
0.034867093,
0.0405683853,
-0.0578070022,
0.0527732223,
-0.0007826939,
-0.0157122631,
0.0329843275,
-0.0074039251,
0.0396594442,
-0.0131220482,
0.0424887203,
0.0226175953,
-0.027872622,
-0.0331026018,
0.0300676282,
-0.0913400352,
-0.0503291823,
0.0048922081,
0.0052078282,
-0.0276512336,
-0.0270492304,
-0.0070146639,
-0.0119706709,
-0.0107372878,
-0.0296555292,
0.049931366,
-0.0395414308,
-0.0428073108,
-0.0204962641,
-0.0194917172,
0.0320895426,
0.001945463,
-0.0290764775,
0.0462218896,
0.0624981523,
0.0174962524,
0.0458525643,
-0.0802919939,
0.0044880463,
-0.0095096501,
-0.0014542575,
0.021818446,
0.0118024871,
-0.0104767038,
0.0757019743,
0.0353827626,
-0.0092344321,
-0.0381636657,
-0.0149049507,
0.0161772296,
0.011279841,
0.0261209458,
0.0548707619,
0.0691067576,
-0.0204700176,
-0.0609071776,
0.0173904411,
0.0152160283,
-0.0091332579,
0.0124203833,
-0.024789501,
-0.026863616,
-0.0635696873,
-0.0622080751,
-0.0421327166,
-0.0393399708,
0.001806137,
0.031442143,
0.0209537558,
0.0023405289,
-0.0107714739,
0.0199459456,
-0.0319383368,
-0.0270985272,
0.000763431,
-0.007185115,
0.0283243116,
0.0073316884,
0.0103686554,
-0.0545120612,
-0.0282589626,
0.0254276004,
0.0075843749,
0.0219776463,
0.0184213091,
0.0942845717,
0.0102779726,
-0.1009886339,
-0.0059208232,
-0.0029878621,
-0.0090438826,
0.0050244112,
-0.0126993349,
0.0326506011,
0.0187051892,
0.0042089508,
0.0467013419,
0.0240266994,
-0.0158327352,
0.0158262793,
0.0095014563,
-0.0220565647,
-0.0018401764,
0.0006630148,
-0.0151286572,
0.0289804339,
-0.0018344703,
0.0388701111,
-0.020559499,
0.0088968342,
0.037788488,
2.893e-7,
0.0485367551,
0.0455056615,
-0.0146572804,
0.0169408116,
0.0137428185,
0.0573136024,
-0.012775749,
0.0252884757,
0.0446031541,
-0.049509421,
0.0311485659,
0.0071438774,
0.053906884,
0.0250484217,
-0.1056846008,
0.0018956722,
-0.0541446209,
0.0000675385,
-0.0282616783,
0.0116319293,
0.0912091434,
0.0994634852,
0.0413006172,
-0.0006994822,
0.0046687941,
-0.012064199,
0.0716215521,
-0.0432405584,
-0.003770652,
-0.0216963794,
0.0600084923,
0.0013984242,
0.0269473828,
0.0704082474,
-0.0155956103,
0.0118330894,
-0.0132787079,
0.0672188401,
-0.0076734223,
0.0279293917,
-0.046046,
0.0010923623,
0.0218698885,
-0.023561826,
0.0758868232,
-0.0939163566,
-0.0025699888,
-0.0226321109,
-0.015506587,
-0.01253061,
0.0721743405,
0.0066594486,
-0.0325930715,
0.0115629816,
0.0390043184,
0.0184436664,
-0.0171329658,
-0.0863177702,
-0.0095293308,
0.0584442317,
-0.0191740021,
-0.0276888907,
0.017414866,
0.0005414012,
0.0512833893,
-0.1022026911,
0.0186858568,
2.759233987e-34,
0.0427744947,
-0.0078262184,
0.023278201,
0.0115979956,
0.0095248781,
-0.0197914075,
0.0052703652,
0.0185539145,
0.0511706062,
-0.0606872737,
-0.0066055832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10811v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10811v3 | "It Felt Like Having a Second Mind": Investigating Human-AI Co-creativity in Prewriting with Large Language Models | 2023-07-20T16:55:25 | 2024-02-29T15:53:12 | Qian Wan, Siying Hu, Yu Zhang, Piaohong Wang, Bo Wen, Zhicong Lu | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.m; K.4.0 | Prewriting is the process of discovering and developing ideas before a first
draft, which requires divergent thinking and often implies unstructured
strategies such as diagramming, outlining, free-writing, etc. Although large
language models (LLMs) have been demonstrated to be useful for a variety of
tasks including creative writing, little is known about how users would
collaborate with LLMs to support prewriting. The preferred collaborative role
and initiative of LLMs during such a creativity process is also unclear. To
investigate human-LLM collaboration patterns and dynamics during prewriting, we
conducted a three-session qualitative study with 15 participants in two
creative tasks: story writing and slogan writing. The findings indicated that
during collaborative prewriting, there appears to be a three-stage iterative
Human-AI Co-creativity process that includes Ideation, Illumination, and
Implementation stages. This collaborative process champions the human in a
dominant role, in addition to mixed and shifting levels of initiative that
exist between humans and LLMs. This research also reports on collaboration
breakdowns that occur during this process, user perceptions of using existing
LLMs during Human-AI Co-creativity, and discusses design implications to
support this co-creativity process. | [
0.0713450015,
-0.0073615885,
-0.0388319492,
-0.0292980932,
-0.0560576096,
0.0021709492,
0.0156103289,
-0.0363398716,
-0.0004154656,
-0.0370111838,
-0.042184744,
-0.0586488321,
0.0005999191,
0.0300529562,
-0.0274136923,
-0.0055693216,
-0.031602554,
-0.0326835662,
0.0520826578,
0.018699266,
-0.0030310291,
0.04170084,
-0.0163395498,
0.0830027014,
-0.0416853428,
-0.041932594,
-0.0315281972,
0.0062680775,
-0.0177171789,
-0.0250485186,
-0.0289128628,
0.0699641854,
0.0295118168,
0.0103951795,
0.000001903,
-0.0489636213,
0.0304283015,
-0.0127510307,
0.0251480993,
-0.0360269845,
-0.0092860591,
0.0463008657,
-0.0266897809,
-0.0088712787,
-0.036556568,
0.0494678281,
0.0305807814,
0.0586230867,
0.0328189209,
-0.0028691536,
-0.0023309458,
-0.0368016697,
-0.0063375165,
-0.0121301403,
-0.0211842153,
0.0198682714,
-0.0336726047,
-0.0161709227,
0.0258074179,
-0.0561171547,
0.0035734966,
0.0190109387,
0.0283015538,
-0.0555919074,
-0.0044707945,
0.0507665165,
-0.0068228506,
-0.0406474173,
0.028159786,
0.0324218348,
0.0204284824,
0.0002321897,
-0.0170453433,
-0.001789104,
0.0129654938,
0.0412588045,
-0.0367341898,
0.042641554,
-0.0143844159,
0.0049045598,
-0.0069846213,
-0.0455968082,
-0.0315415487,
0.0128600253,
0.0137154572,
0.0467299633,
-0.000672121,
-0.0010961598,
0.0031066136,
0.0276919622,
-0.0132961674,
-0.0812615007,
-0.0011171059,
0.0311749317,
-0.0240266211,
0.0025552739,
-0.041815795,
-0.0430703387,
-0.0200183392,
-0.0519658588,
0.140048489,
-0.0016721463,
0.0442902111,
0.0251571368,
0.0117183691,
0.0383220352,
0.0003950265,
0.0391902626,
-0.0377046056,
0.0399390161,
-0.0602822937,
-0.054858394,
-0.0593899861,
0.0434426442,
0.0067911358,
-0.0334496237,
-0.0180558767,
0.0494084321,
0.0201380271,
-0.0118227042,
-0.0060220421,
0.0109759178,
0.0069069718,
-0.0183555223,
-0.0104234628,
-0.0148392329,
0.018809868,
0.0317072049,
0.0017727542,
-0.0035588858,
0.0221344996,
0.0272501018,
-0.0273836162,
-0.0501929969,
-0.0071321181,
0.0242122747,
-0.0286699049,
-0.018521484,
-0.0313877389,
-0.0510209166,
0.0314942636,
-0.0271698106,
-0.0151634598,
-0.0318193138,
0.0197146311,
0.0454243645,
-0.0292586926,
-0.0571383536,
-0.0074615274,
0.0237745903,
-0.012993671,
-0.0078140926,
-0.0430054814,
0.0607011579,
0.0383326933,
0.0008680212,
-0.0001760999,
0.0133067742,
0.111361444,
0.0636694655,
-0.001406371,
0.0213865992,
0.0304541159,
0.0033927499,
-0.0527250208,
-0.0159087479,
-0.0330819637,
-0.0163703058,
-0.0387958325,
0.0424069725,
-0.0139449537,
0.0551977642,
-0.0118118646,
0.0753709823,
0.1141244918,
0.0888805315,
0.0802063793,
0.0495334528,
0.0542677119,
0.0167470872,
0.0072294534,
0.0166388247,
0.0031287915,
0.0415808,
0.0210222118,
0.0100941174,
-0.0272969808,
0.0386645384,
-0.0214777943,
-0.0315834358,
-0.0088039218,
-0.0017032018,
-0.0108682131,
-0.027808262,
-0.0245952196,
0.0110804699,
-0.0118398312,
-0.0169840604,
-0.0681313947,
-0.0866591856,
0.0221363381,
-0.0202435609,
0.0585173704,
0.1329881996,
0.0448525697,
-0.0087889321,
-0.0024086218,
0.0000783483,
0.0289641675,
0.0134952124,
0.0062283906,
0.006729858,
-0.0532334186,
0.0299869403,
0.0154623175,
-0.0580508336,
-0.021515863,
-0.0207952596,
-0.0463700406,
0.0154677583,
-0.002703151,
0.0132252192,
-0.0312689953,
0.0313811861,
-0.0682951435,
0.0209243465,
-0.0235605482,
0.016917821,
-0.0238074102,
0.0388502702,
-0.0772654191,
0.0513392203,
0.0232696272,
-0.0405493192,
-0.0777145475,
0.0918923616,
-0.0057645747,
0.0354032293,
0.014936531,
-0.0425529927,
0.0089415368,
-0.021312546,
0.0466362461,
-0.0256057512,
0.0513398387,
-0.0184746832,
0.0178835839,
-0.0287229028,
-0.0106007792,
-0.005688387,
-0.0219811276,
-0.0105495593,
0.000371996,
0.0002470537,
-0.0178631376,
0.0087432852,
0.0003733866,
0.0138818286,
0.0352973379,
-0.00014653,
0.06725315,
0.0308581255,
0.0162408669,
0.0005031933,
-0.0026471028,
-0.0477176346,
-0.0463680811,
-0.0928663239,
-0.0209858045,
-0.0175374933,
0.0002130714,
0.012170122,
-0.0151843019,
-0.0359890088,
0.0173729043,
-0.0145692099,
-0.0172154661,
-0.0130102523,
0.0191543084,
0.0272532627,
0.022357814,
0.0227061305,
0.0008107151,
0.0272181332,
0.0012587018,
0.0309716277,
0.0838270634,
-0.046860341,
-0.0438138135,
0.0440829471,
-0.0347269103,
-0.0318513624,
0.0124683697,
-0.0139771607,
0.0348520465,
-0.0250852387,
0.0752255097,
0.0218110662,
0.0191709585,
0.0287088826,
0.092250973,
-0.0155211557,
-0.0013222084,
0.0082651554,
0.0440643728,
0.0241005253,
0.0122233219,
0.0168916434,
0.0385963917,
0.0505066328,
0.0182215553,
-0.0002009819,
-0.020457292,
0.0754604489,
-0.0100611094,
-0.0317475721,
0.0018660751,
-0.0778893903,
-0.0348103754,
0.0618320704,
-0.0029859238,
-0.0349734239,
0.0399051569,
-0.0045010052,
-0.006350134,
0.0296486169,
-0.0079957619,
-0.0458401293,
0.0701896921,
-0.0511745065,
0.0232276749,
-0.0209886152,
0.0277275164,
-0.0616718195,
0.0283424594,
0.0012957581,
-0.0029328496,
0.0077517871,
-0.0402969941,
-0.0087523079,
-0.0341815203,
-0.0069282958,
-0.008991587,
-0.0117501309,
-0.0345555209,
0.0224147476,
0.0643901825,
0.0002500682,
0.0179796945,
0.0172317419,
0.0370447449,
0.0354245231,
0.022377545,
-0.0012874325,
-0.0275637396,
-0.0046817362,
0.0210400429,
-0.0064073717,
-0.0312820189,
-0.0234810244,
0.0465468504,
0.023290677,
0.0076237,
0.0031728405,
-0.0063333539,
-0.0130487178,
0.0271673352,
-0.000262141,
-0.0482942499,
0.0139732258,
0.0715175793,
0.0016543143,
-0.0047753225,
0.0920248628,
0.0287079103,
-0.0269979108,
0.0132339085,
-0.0429677255,
-0.0256263763,
0.0149846692,
0.0227992237,
-0.0127607519,
0.0112495665,
0.0060537462,
-0.0142598096,
-0.0126427505,
-0.0509792492,
-0.0255727787,
-0.0431065708,
0.0453109443,
-0.010809713,
0.0227748733,
0.0374149084,
0.0125753712,
-0.0094540957,
0.0730348974,
-0.0339528508,
0.0077149551,
-0.018661771,
0.0394048803,
-0.0054893219,
-0.036761567,
-0.0040364703,
-0.0275233071,
-0.0511093773,
-0.0043635909,
0.0818377733,
0.0754714385,
0.0119544948,
-0.011962682,
-0.0126024811,
0.0042760568,
0.0707029626,
-0.0159673393,
-0.0136828534,
-0.0043115746,
0.0422803834,
-0.0288984925,
0.0234223567,
-0.0534902252,
-0.0371436067,
0.0139889885,
0.0351897329,
-0.0646961704,
-0.027618194,
-0.0107106464,
0.0256750453,
0.0152048944,
0.0251489524,
0.0561069958,
-0.0924432129,
-0.0220244005,
0.0120607382,
0.0220953804,
-0.085256204,
-0.0324183479,
-0.041934941,
0.0156331845,
0.0470797792,
-0.0523128472,
-0.0476360582,
0.0192995872,
0.0469402373,
0.0421341956,
0.0386879854,
-0.0030549553,
-0.0296038911,
-0.0330266841,
-0.0197595023,
0.0233889129,
0.0561492406,
-0.0152710415,
-0.0352792628,
-0.0367820524,
-0.0538502969,
0.0274806228,
0.0174488723,
-0.053781759,
-0.0484653264,
0.0219355579,
0.011056602,
0.0154817766,
-0.0234866999,
0.0335866995,
-0.0931914002,
0.0054469523,
0.0076196468,
0.0002753029,
0.0471688695,
-0.0319030546,
0.0550804175,
0.0123389177,
0.0201148037,
0.0043362468,
-0.0063847071,
0.0696284026,
0.0363765508,
-0.0154502802,
-0.0754071772,
0.0168690179,
0.0225597192,
-0.0121549806,
-0.0597150587,
0.0540590361,
-0.0732391402,
-0.0099719074,
-0.0280050691,
-0.033418946,
-0.0736824647,
-0.0130734667,
0.0072762975,
-0.0301000178,
0.0234560817,
0.028593909,
-0.03100162,
0.0176639836,
-0.0343229771,
0.0271635652,
-0.0166124869,
0.0621845722,
0.0245344285,
-0.0091033857,
0.0151414955,
0.0426207893,
-0.0494089685,
0.0143533498,
0.0272845794,
0.0569268987,
0.0022853133,
-0.0051110424,
0.0160486102,
0.0705161542,
-0.0427846462,
-0.1194595471,
0.0127219371,
0.0038439361,
0.0497132242,
0.0173696186,
0.0302749705,
-0.0440158956,
0.041278284,
0.0051153065,
0.0664387792,
-0.0056430595,
-0.0279453043,
-0.0476445183,
-0.0093263425,
-0.0282392688,
-0.0429025367,
0.0865494385,
-0.0484129228,
-0.0053292643,
-0.0263776667,
-0.0323561206,
-0.0157895535,
-0.0129483165,
0.0365749113,
-0.0005783782,
-0.0077651446,
0.0289160423,
-0.0935342833,
-0.014434509,
0.0570617467,
-0.0237959549,
0.0153638618,
-0.0397784896,
-0.0009069537,
0.0584872551,
0.0042938874,
-0.0066832313,
-0.0470737033,
-0.0239741933,
-0.03870878,
-0.0061926777,
-0.0387124829,
-5.367873647e-33,
-0.0314098448,
-0.0768361092,
0.0452674553,
-0.0113805654,
-0.0360955633,
-0.025808882,
-0.0345963165,
0.0757285878,
0.0539965928,
-0.0049246708,
-0.0248389803,
-0.028738467,
-0.0122354096,
-0.0292212218,
0.0331955515,
0.0349231288,
0.0506608859,
-0.0243490804,
-0.0266160145,
-0.0196058657,
-0.0021507966,
0.0244580321,
-0.0306873657,
-0.0442330875,
-0.0287979096,
-0.0402464531,
-0.0078935567,
-0.0154290702,
0.0020005836,
0.0041510509,
0.0182998255,
-0.0072403499,
0.0564028434,
0.0176055096,
-0.0132483086,
0.0457223877,
0.0438092612,
-0.0398537405,
0.0112335766,
-0.0070862751,
-0.0099260919,
-0.040704485,
0.016167758,
-0.0039283889,
-0.0320084356,
0.0179826114,
0.0306859482,
0.0107035991,
0.0074184495,
-0.0193578843,
-0.0789451972,
-0.0160828605,
-0.0133387605,
-0.0469232947,
0.0007402234,
-0.00176243,
0.003628908,
-0.0459435806,
-0.0719369054,
0.0379131772,
-0.0569802634,
-0.0122511405,
0.0460783876,
-0.000824985,
-0.0214626268,
0.0517261513,
-0.0120916385,
0.0945518315,
-0.0856066868,
0.017323615,
-0.0220762398,
0.0615813099,
-0.0048901951,
0.023599036,
-0.0212372262,
-0.0148052182,
0.0294204094,
0.0344366878,
-0.0309963562,
-0.0187001787,
0.0278046932,
0.0348867178,
-0.0081427703,
-0.0353436507,
-0.0074111484,
-0.0296417344,
-0.0277547687,
-0.042527575,
-0.0032609783,
-0.0081137484,
0.0154105052,
-0.0109320469,
-0.0013853466,
-0.0028865724,
0.0177961215,
-0.0382191837,
-0.0666830838,
0.0497224033,
-0.0216242895,
-0.0074809273,
-0.0413129702,
-0.0166795328,
0.0169979353,
0.049214568,
0.045132786,
0.0368603058,
0.02000916,
0.0177538861,
-0.0169446375,
-0.0265196078,
-0.0243148878,
0.0223076269,
0.0529559441,
-0.0437528342,
0.0178668872,
-0.0069865622,
-0.01255727,
-0.0213574972,
0.0237099975,
-0.0379026867,
-0.043580994,
-0.0442881584,
-0.0275218152,
-0.0275947843,
-0.0015810456,
-0.0089674452,
-0.0354836471,
-0.0035076749,
0.065183185,
-0.0314844102,
-0.0329559855,
-0.023638187,
2.866e-7,
0.0142094716,
0.0247096457,
-0.0220600404,
0.0070442935,
0.0278801713,
0.0185312983,
-0.0267088544,
0.0139083145,
-0.0066501359,
0.0628991276,
0.0400815308,
0.0352876633,
0.0108414292,
0.0079001132,
-0.0586601533,
0.0097809387,
-0.0495832153,
0.0269360133,
-0.0568798482,
-0.0048817345,
0.0735223144,
-0.0772207007,
0.009505216,
-0.0312083289,
-0.0440661423,
-0.0477992892,
0.0446136296,
-0.025738528,
0.0115131335,
0.0254582632,
0.0242837127,
-0.0060397149,
-0.001216767,
0.0207912698,
-0.0100211538,
-0.0286493301,
0.0429759063,
0.0165461637,
0.0011322368,
0.0336298272,
0.0375569761,
0.0173381325,
-0.0151803186,
-0.0212392583,
0.0329446383,
-0.0442694165,
-0.0309467744,
-0.0043980074,
0.0461563841,
-0.0583215244,
-0.0071077142,
-0.0286366437,
0.0643757209,
0.0306211933,
0.0098004099,
0.007204758,
0.0333849378,
0.0188536681,
-0.0212263148,
0.0065185218,
-0.0425271653,
0.0067830314,
-0.0671955943,
0.0025568251,
-0.0073891841,
-0.0495434888,
0.030645825,
2.098389889e-34,
-0.0043699774,
-0.0009424415,
0.0110137099,
0.0579318963,
0.0653089285,
0.0264171734,
0.0307925418,
0.0088878861,
-0.0151594756,
-0.0295865983,
-0.0320074707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11019v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11019v2 | Investigating the Factual Knowledge Boundary of Large Language Models with Retrieval Augmentation | 2023-07-20T16:46:10 | 2023-07-23T16:52:59 | Ruiyang Ren, Yuhao Wang, Yingqi Qu, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jing Liu, Hao Tian, Hua Wu, Ji-Rong Wen, Haifeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Knowledge-intensive tasks (e.g., open-domain question answering (QA)) require
a substantial amount of factual knowledge and often rely on external
information for assistance. Recently, large language models (LLMs) (e.g.,
ChatGPT), have demonstrated impressive prowess in solving a wide range of tasks
with world knowledge, including knowledge-intensive tasks. However, it remains
unclear how well LLMs are able to perceive their factual knowledge boundaries,
particularly how they behave when incorporating retrieval augmentation. In this
study, we present an initial analysis of the factual knowledge boundaries of
LLMs and how retrieval augmentation affects LLMs on open-domain QA. Specially,
we focus on three primary research questions and analyze them by examining QA
performance, priori judgement and posteriori judgement of LLMs. We show
evidence that LLMs possess unwavering confidence in their capabilities to
respond to questions and the accuracy of their responses. Furthermore,
retrieval augmentation proves to be an effective approach in enhancing LLMs'
awareness of knowledge boundaries, thereby improving their judgemental
abilities. Additionally, we also find that LLMs have a propensity to rely on
the provided retrieval results when formulating answers, while the quality of
these results significantly impacts their reliance. The code to reproduce this
work is available at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/LLM-Knowledge-Boundary. | [
0.0564613827,
0.0092740506,
-0.0215794388,
0.0494839363,
-0.0216466933,
-0.016050715,
-0.0334969126,
-0.0001622426,
0.0399817415,
-0.0516246408,
-0.0439002179,
-0.0262126401,
-0.0607872717,
0.0095228106,
0.0119747007,
-0.0082808677,
0.0569980592,
-0.0263461322,
0.0309683792,
-0.0362371504,
-0.0195495281,
-0.0155684985,
-0.00452543,
0.0203096457,
0.0008603925,
-0.0186852887,
0.0206853244,
-0.0488346033,
-0.0083215898,
-0.0195533372,
0.0335862376,
0.036471609,
0.0514086224,
0.0376170017,
0.0000018974,
-0.0624789707,
-0.0027505087,
-0.0214707851,
-0.0657547489,
0.0323542245,
-0.0117758419,
0.0375551656,
0.0367524624,
0.0098527325,
-0.070171155,
-0.0216312036,
0.0070329504,
0.0460603982,
0.0492498837,
0.0382899232,
0.0241613295,
0.0294326562,
0.0111892121,
0.0131921712,
0.0270235743,
-0.0610356703,
0.0380298682,
0.0629507825,
0.0090025254,
0.035869088,
-0.0238003619,
0.0251000319,
0.0147236604,
0.014754178,
0.0069244402,
0.0399263017,
-0.0409464948,
0.0124769509,
0.0112812389,
0.0281706117,
0.0865768939,
-0.0117687983,
-0.0440661944,
0.0361274444,
0.0224853046,
0.0386339352,
-0.0905795172,
0.0433191583,
-0.0292278957,
-0.0120351231,
-0.0640050471,
0.0197422579,
0.0193144158,
0.0212057531,
-0.0110387029,
0.105228059,
-0.0190683883,
-0.0649094135,
0.0068372702,
0.0190337431,
-0.014562563,
-0.0488246679,
-0.0044838325,
0.0717871562,
0.0077122152,
0.0419478454,
0.0329296961,
0.0204565655,
0.0444918461,
-0.0294662304,
-0.0018606412,
0.0367595926,
-0.0535400473,
0.0442458019,
-0.0342795216,
0.0398337245,
-0.0218169,
0.0109639755,
-0.0395716205,
-0.0183097683,
-0.0392234996,
-0.0608745664,
-0.0106725255,
0.0242572576,
0.0013822997,
0.0131708225,
-0.0159935001,
0.0105775734,
-0.0094952043,
-0.0110053848,
-0.0033191065,
0.0502255484,
-0.0079625128,
-0.0098877354,
-0.1121452376,
0.0544508174,
-0.0438913256,
0.0179903489,
0.0065805838,
-0.0831136107,
-0.0074121961,
-0.0145912766,
-0.0073193708,
-0.0160835534,
0.0248739664,
0.0469635315,
-0.0328394324,
-0.0347252786,
-0.019259613,
-0.024204297,
0.0174829848,
-0.0777910948,
0.0250364132,
-0.0420204476,
-0.0040961984,
0.0264692903,
-0.0220668893,
-0.0123611409,
0.02790769,
0.0293152314,
0.0008943976,
0.0251099244,
0.0036475065,
0.0182675794,
0.0425516851,
0.0383946709,
-0.0380989239,
0.0534499474,
-0.009704072,
-0.0039490359,
0.0449564457,
0.003252706,
0.0141269499,
-0.0106794629,
0.0154712563,
-0.0013715228,
0.0039656078,
0.0687631965,
0.0198192038,
0.0195196457,
0.0434939936,
0.0401086323,
-0.0473285057,
-0.0136336014,
0.0636176169,
0.0450250283,
-0.0010638905,
0.007608843,
0.0247309078,
-0.0151180066,
0.0695667341,
0.0323078446,
-0.0465499759,
0.0444955379,
-0.0081741055,
0.0194312893,
0.0151419081,
0.0440148301,
-0.0268449783,
-0.0421696156,
-0.0052882396,
0.0197273586,
0.0094286501,
0.0492561646,
0.0486101992,
0.0024470068,
0.0112594841,
0.0477067716,
0.0012315576,
-0.0367270224,
-0.0033953802,
-0.0977984592,
0.0544514582,
0.0140599636,
0.0496891439,
-0.0506882071,
-0.0524287894,
0.0123179248,
0.0030209192,
0.0115523618,
0.0617607236,
0.0080029443,
-0.0380463377,
-0.0189107507,
-0.0032304127,
-0.0492521077,
0.0110632889,
0.0031498137,
0.0548794679,
0.0198834185,
0.014413788,
-0.071921289,
0.0235186536,
0.0244106464,
-0.0202698186,
-0.0278835949,
-0.0471936539,
-0.0121703111,
-0.0114855701,
-0.0017095655,
-0.0022285094,
0.0368516669,
0.0409606099,
0.0066154315,
-0.0586730428,
0.0002626501,
-0.0180133078,
0.0077598663,
0.0352868177,
0.0008884676,
-0.0197910946,
-0.010990506,
0.0007431468,
-0.0380718149,
0.0215097647,
-0.021785751,
0.0571917892,
-0.0668429956,
-0.0195607301,
-0.0103100287,
-0.0015896425,
-0.0266350862,
0.0877034515,
0.0071641183,
0.0400503576,
0.0100142481,
-0.0121222511,
0.0077800425,
-0.0395238996,
-0.0030036217,
-0.034800142,
-0.0235013049,
0.0348239355,
0.0214169938,
-0.0413594022,
-0.0665969104,
0.0000186786,
-0.1014749408,
0.0004214571,
-0.0036309692,
0.0107921753,
-0.0071046818,
-0.0221725181,
-0.0260574576,
-0.018729968,
-0.0496627465,
0.0026792195,
0.0368578844,
0.0554624684,
0.011754524,
0.0354501531,
0.0095506422,
-0.0265336595,
0.0190949179,
0.0137231695,
0.0082152402,
0.0016417985,
0.0101692891,
-0.0403532572,
0.0480426066,
-0.0955262929,
0.0511470474,
-0.0377118513,
-0.0094438149,
0.0252428371,
-0.0026926433,
0.0150395259,
0.0838234052,
0.0165034458,
0.0053306082,
0.0853473172,
-0.0137413349,
-0.0615549535,
0.0319218487,
-0.0167988408,
-0.0739906281,
-0.0080844695,
0.0002401047,
0.018826969,
0.0254353639,
0.0042062839,
-0.0151741505,
-0.0084496364,
0.0095579792,
-0.0171345547,
-0.0286262576,
-0.0421814583,
-0.0065255091,
-0.0249261595,
0.0939350352,
-0.0007461935,
-0.0474512205,
0.0640891343,
-0.0059128124,
-0.0248597283,
-0.0200681351,
0.0080057634,
-0.04672952,
0.0693680197,
-0.0138696833,
0.0039033804,
-0.0078547243,
-0.0116226114,
-0.0486492515,
0.0027926341,
0.0171735473,
-0.0757027045,
0.0443621799,
-0.0141583383,
0.0019339076,
-0.0083245188,
-0.0445470214,
-0.070457004,
-0.0097546456,
-0.0190108623,
-0.0056467257,
-0.0414143614,
-0.0082188128,
-0.0242046453,
-0.0212126952,
0.0659213737,
-0.0160125587,
-0.0261067487,
-0.0028412272,
-0.0089966087,
0.0009529016,
0.0526500419,
0.0717207491,
0.0378168002,
-0.0280871447,
0.004115684,
0.0745135769,
0.0253456049,
-0.0342834555,
0.0076114344,
-0.0400109254,
0.0412098877,
-0.0037494183,
-0.0240848977,
0.0183103886,
0.0605056956,
-0.0570785813,
-0.0141036231,
0.0944631696,
0.0253718831,
0.0066927313,
-0.0298877042,
-0.082964696,
-0.0146167167,
0.0491266698,
0.0402242318,
-0.0629731342,
-0.0024405185,
0.0050125802,
0.0143031031,
-0.0466731451,
-0.0293812323,
-0.0262214281,
-0.1354261786,
0.0367478356,
-0.0368122384,
-0.0073171202,
-0.0358297601,
-0.0084787169,
0.0118625648,
0.0316303596,
0.0256206542,
0.0393088199,
-0.0283895284,
-0.007273946,
0.0212379545,
-0.0128657399,
-0.0278626774,
0.0741847903,
-0.0254228637,
0.0362368897,
0.0268773623,
-0.0050031296,
-0.0065602446,
-0.0567512847,
0.0024476652,
-0.0137363682,
0.0402188711,
0.0144669227,
0.0253956243,
-0.012006104,
0.0128176352,
-0.0112924082,
-0.016699411,
0.0158186033,
0.0068932958,
0.0211133175,
0.0930527672,
-0.0212958734,
-0.0148382084,
-0.0222656447,
0.023541756,
-0.0235717464,
0.0772101581,
0.0185269006,
0.0063791829,
-0.0053232932,
-0.0224312656,
-0.0175595731,
0.0025429763,
-0.0380389132,
0.039655935,
0.0016270548,
0.0397543013,
-0.0621315204,
-0.0180817358,
0.0327840559,
0.0294796303,
-0.0242300667,
0.0235020146,
-0.0088104289,
0.019652931,
-0.0198940728,
0.039015349,
-0.0772612095,
-0.0065801875,
-0.0131674865,
0.0140836127,
0.0237707607,
-0.0577492863,
-0.0114536909,
-0.0177617837,
-0.0325863063,
-0.0377124287,
0.0007783442,
0.0357062183,
0.0362304188,
-0.0080347136,
0.0050415746,
-0.046763394,
0.0129902819,
0.028969394,
-0.0737624466,
0.0422341526,
0.0392081589,
0.0166797023,
-0.0123265879,
0.0266777575,
-0.0486149564,
-0.0046556154,
-0.0012828964,
0.0211320743,
-0.0107843438,
-0.0573469363,
0.0443382263,
0.0278800558,
0.0450735763,
0.0384339429,
0.0291545689,
-0.0265889894,
-0.004667968,
-0.0170442462,
-0.0223688856,
-0.0015667898,
-0.0088381292,
0.0201201662,
-0.0259854235,
0.0305183008,
-0.0079790428,
-0.0063191047,
0.0434023477,
-0.0357397459,
-0.0215531997,
0.0189605001,
-0.0004726706,
0.0258817077,
0.0045229588,
-0.0458233282,
0.0040478599,
-0.0133327981,
0.0530139208,
0.0166973416,
0.0803840682,
0.0078360401,
-0.0080963662,
-0.0223797355,
-0.0113970712,
-0.1044826657,
-0.0625410229,
0.0179091878,
0.0668238476,
0.0221119411,
-0.0047944784,
0.0167307407,
-0.0398370102,
-0.0118848775,
-0.0053850953,
-0.0556197204,
0.0197664946,
-0.0377915204,
0.0747624263,
0.0223255213,
-0.0286291186,
0.0108957477,
0.0854249597,
-0.0167889819,
0.0611710362,
-0.042808231,
-0.0282578934,
-0.0074289027,
-0.0458369404,
0.0173386373,
-0.018815957,
-0.012701272,
0.0226520598,
-0.0885454267,
-0.0754668117,
-0.0132126436,
0.0015509999,
-0.0391140506,
-0.0709731206,
0.0029002926,
0.082425423,
0.0481040515,
-0.0414341763,
-0.0295467284,
0.0466537029,
-0.0347695984,
0.0515439212,
-0.0289992448,
-6.415682863e-33,
-0.0228953324,
-0.0184262823,
0.0391184799,
-0.0226417203,
-0.0247500297,
0.0267814025,
-0.0039830566,
0.0243547317,
-0.059277527,
-0.0077356715,
-0.0414525978,
0.0070842076,
0.0096998531,
-0.0082670907,
0.011776193,
-0.0449242257,
0.0002467291,
-0.0233558994,
-0.0412468426,
-0.0018947308,
0.063870497,
0.0110824918,
0.0323947705,
-0.038473852,
0.0577872358,
-0.0335369743,
0.0272455849,
0.0618210398,
-0.0414954871,
0.0619460493,
-0.0219630245,
0.0623319112,
0.0432760306,
-0.0571923479,
-0.0077698482,
0.010313578,
-0.0378353,
-0.042076923,
0.0487339459,
-0.0160210207,
-0.0280522034,
-0.0095293634,
0.0126733519,
-0.0001248155,
-0.0069239107,
-0.0214147568,
0.0046412796,
-0.0337190777,
-0.0151252318,
-0.0161760785,
-0.0359011367,
-0.0081231156,
0.0229531284,
-0.0335250497,
-0.0283037908,
0.0425914973,
0.0004786922,
-0.0162808746,
-0.0507626534,
0.0123425405,
0.0024921631,
0.0309067275,
0.0666833669,
0.0090253912,
0.0057393154,
0.0532514043,
-0.0300971735,
0.02678659,
-0.0753965229,
-0.0331646763,
0.0105314348,
0.026945699,
0.0289940443,
0.0448170379,
0.0099815279,
-0.0068900525,
-0.0141836209,
0.0129082203,
0.0362623259,
0.044145029,
0.0348003209,
0.0099112643,
-0.0179673955,
-0.0148956142,
-0.048378095,
0.0625604242,
-0.0447037555,
-0.0126647828,
0.0415762775,
0.0212200638,
-0.0134719629,
-0.0358327068,
0.0164719857,
-0.0264637284,
0.0432003811,
0.0014396182,
-0.0352239273,
0.0189877767,
-0.0114168609,
0.0449583754,
-0.0541337766,
0.0004883446,
0.0228165016,
-0.0239946153,
-0.0514544584,
0.0208955146,
0.0037627376,
-0.0110821733,
-0.0243673977,
0.0066210171,
-0.0366030447,
0.0274841078,
0.0019189249,
-0.0136695588,
0.0314117968,
0.0456042551,
-0.0166427996,
0.0188412499,
0.0080077676,
0.0000797052,
-0.0554191545,
-0.0309302732,
0.0058674589,
-0.0114964517,
-0.0319939405,
0.0233898908,
-0.0334854871,
0.0177751388,
-0.0370460376,
-0.0310070328,
-0.0103119407,
0.0387767367,
2.68e-7,
0.0547214299,
0.0125390366,
-0.004506296,
0.0527087301,
0.0172330234,
0.0293254573,
-0.0181091186,
-0.0068901102,
0.0771744624,
-0.0655466765,
-0.0286174659,
0.0570395291,
0.0211787354,
0.043056272,
-0.054473985,
-0.0324258432,
-0.0538564995,
-0.0477959812,
-0.0202487074,
-0.028355239,
0.0519106425,
0.0409369469,
-0.0125183696,
-0.0010145169,
-0.0164554287,
-0.0743998364,
0.0843052268,
0.00602336,
-0.0155854104,
0.0075078094,
0.0739319175,
0.0458336361,
0.0199744534,
0.0476753674,
0.0398281515,
0.0083534252,
0.0022688129,
0.0355841108,
0.0484296083,
-0.0167053007,
-0.0138314515,
-0.0261522643,
0.0147427153,
-0.076433748,
0.0959287658,
-0.0606110394,
-0.0249978602,
-0.0215942934,
0.0207399093,
-0.0123219229,
0.0085563865,
-0.0344429463,
-0.0167886913,
0.0032636551,
-0.0087568555,
0.012079074,
0.006802171,
-0.0648885816,
-0.0146893105,
-0.0068207975,
-0.0631897077,
-0.0828652382,
-0.0298224427,
0.0045555336,
0.000169269,
-0.0539248735,
0.0083987387,
2.225544399e-34,
0.0243481807,
-0.014190115,
0.0274456944,
0.0044394713,
0.0366801135,
-0.0006803377,
-0.0036145195,
0.008651495,
0.0023623679,
-0.0659307167,
0.0059385984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11005v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11005v1 | Integrating Pretrained ASR and LM to Perform Sequence Generation for Spoken Language Understanding | 2023-07-20T16:34:40 | 2023-07-20T16:34:40 | Siddhant Arora, Hayato Futami, Yosuke Kashiwagi, Emiru Tsunoo, Brian Yan, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | There has been an increased interest in the integration of pretrained speech
recognition (ASR) and language models (LM) into the SLU framework. However,
prior methods often struggle with a vocabulary mismatch between pretrained
models, and LM cannot be directly utilized as they diverge from its NLU
formulation. In this study, we propose a three-pass end-to-end (E2E) SLU system
that effectively integrates ASR and LM subnetworks into the SLU formulation for
sequence generation tasks. In the first pass, our architecture predicts ASR
transcripts using the ASR subnetwork. This is followed by the LM subnetwork,
which makes an initial SLU prediction. Finally, in the third pass, the
deliberation subnetwork conditions on representations from the ASR and LM
subnetworks to make the final prediction. Our proposed three-pass SLU system
shows improved performance over cascaded and E2E SLU models on two benchmark
SLU datasets, SLURP and SLUE, especially on acoustically challenging
utterances. | [
0.0061515691,
0.0560990758,
0.0164181404,
-0.0004539243,
0.0060137273,
0.0049270783,
0.0871444196,
-0.0563561432,
0.0037315902,
-0.0691936985,
-0.0219494198,
-0.0604575276,
0.0166624263,
0.0569469333,
0.0347599909,
-0.0060125985,
0.0440354086,
-0.0720495954,
-0.0182401147,
-0.0135619137,
0.0010940608,
0.0194792747,
0.0046927007,
0.0261422005,
0.0253080707,
0.0209463052,
-0.0229868405,
0.0186252408,
-0.0100905765,
-0.057488665,
-0.007545413,
0.0485201254,
0.0594819747,
0.0327564739,
0.000002168,
-0.0227497909,
-0.0058754715,
-0.0358125418,
-0.0734123141,
0.0071036126,
0.0066097453,
0.0262614954,
0.0129704569,
0.0640016273,
-0.043944452,
0.0046370523,
-0.0092819948,
0.0206150338,
0.0307823848,
0.0344966948,
-0.0036347997,
-0.0488708131,
-0.017589936,
-0.0486140214,
-0.0123865269,
-0.0227346234,
-0.0086354697,
-0.028228024,
0.0023285558,
-0.0335261486,
0.0073260423,
0.0419001654,
0.0277073942,
-0.015831938,
0.0109857349,
0.0034985456,
-0.0028467418,
-0.0749474093,
-0.0671943501,
0.0616220869,
-0.0326787829,
-0.0164823662,
0.0004950988,
-0.0069755362,
-0.0245326143,
-0.0298524126,
-0.0206288081,
0.0299378019,
0.0060535166,
-0.008936028,
-0.0026948538,
0.0035226655,
0.0183768328,
-0.0176435113,
-0.0499633737,
0.0227676611,
0.0240545627,
-0.0062333695,
-0.013860058,
-0.0326296128,
0.0376100987,
-0.0873681083,
0.0382285751,
0.0592482612,
-0.0455084108,
0.0149221048,
-0.0410695076,
-0.0282765757,
0.0119103035,
-0.0111993076,
0.0685820431,
0.0424402989,
-0.0288038775,
-0.0281189661,
-0.0361709483,
0.0592954829,
0.0289568342,
-0.0198821258,
-0.0581040569,
0.0209928863,
0.0094764447,
0.0245321244,
-0.0170265958,
0.0476170443,
-0.0609973222,
-0.041459322,
-0.0424407311,
0.0174344964,
0.036484424,
0.0097888904,
0.0220063925,
-0.0034840007,
-0.0330044925,
0.0195864215,
0.009070511,
0.0124159902,
0.0278441533,
0.0377306789,
0.0007382217,
-0.0515079238,
-0.0280579776,
0.0429050103,
0.0209075511,
0.0013970028,
0.0172585994,
0.0499890111,
-0.000445097,
-0.0547155887,
-0.0643766448,
-0.02540127,
-0.0359083153,
-0.0687964559,
0.0101893609,
-0.042350024,
0.025491789,
-0.0242911857,
-0.0224429574,
-0.0374883004,
0.025521595,
-0.0185111221,
0.0096823499,
0.0457300395,
-0.0239490122,
-0.0270798486,
0.0107990056,
-0.0070949076,
0.0567792207,
0.0219202694,
0.0180077758,
0.0304752402,
-0.027286442,
-0.0386756435,
-0.0162067208,
0.0285674166,
0.0416512378,
-0.0295167156,
-0.0167275183,
0.0029629227,
0.0037132821,
0.0144592905,
0.055763416,
0.0569666997,
-0.0351191349,
-0.0180092081,
0.0328882672,
0.0574489012,
0.0483177193,
0.0249762498,
0.0846371129,
0.0193228815,
-0.0480867065,
0.0123144072,
0.0028001072,
0.0000648393,
-0.0328851752,
0.0339367464,
0.0425265394,
0.0693255439,
-0.0452300273,
-0.0525403246,
-0.0213227905,
-0.0330620445,
-0.0000273749,
0.0448742025,
0.0242688432,
0.0395598188,
-0.0598024353,
0.0790890008,
-0.0042279246,
-0.0804934204,
0.0479069054,
-0.0200832896,
0.0311985593,
0.0721026063,
0.0343655981,
0.0107498486,
-0.0524188355,
-0.0378834642,
-0.0089620315,
0.0602089912,
-0.005023011,
-0.0034429196,
0.0307422653,
-0.0794389024,
-0.0173371658,
0.023717843,
-0.0271251015,
0.0807630047,
-0.0503947996,
-0.0278524645,
0.053239096,
-0.0020406886,
-0.0303774215,
0.0239446182,
-0.0582350381,
-0.0015299472,
-0.0030138108,
-0.0040324111,
0.0656012595,
0.0429434776,
-0.0239365827,
0.0136171011,
0.0530235358,
-0.0091136573,
-0.0136416201,
0.0048758979,
-0.0822653696,
-0.0716383085,
0.0611447915,
0.0328337848,
0.0198955946,
0.0198211614,
0.0060073058,
-0.0896075442,
0.017833652,
-0.0223203618,
0.0233752131,
-0.0734847337,
0.0292092562,
0.0725847334,
0.041891735,
-0.0267609637,
0.0101967789,
-0.0359764844,
-0.0193144679,
0.0208284929,
0.0113246283,
-0.0021692778,
-0.066790998,
-0.0043607904,
0.0220880453,
0.0033324817,
-0.0191623624,
-0.0067279884,
0.0169691276,
-0.0131301573,
0.010924303,
-0.0571709462,
-0.0395512544,
-0.0429504141,
0.0437554233,
0.0151771447,
0.0172138046,
-0.0048744357,
-0.0377796888,
-0.0124837775,
0.0052435254,
0.0207635071,
-0.0425638109,
-0.0227094963,
0.0161369592,
-0.0547906756,
-0.0451715738,
0.0163470693,
0.0084542595,
0.0490288958,
-0.022676399,
-0.0273336601,
-0.0400094539,
0.0162997935,
-0.0439716056,
0.0360521004,
-0.0129133929,
-0.0346284285,
-0.0027366339,
-0.0112804361,
0.0012194481,
-0.0188068785,
0.0133541105,
0.0003170113,
0.0231453162,
-0.0288714785,
0.0012281854,
-0.006184685,
-0.0317565836,
0.0192098916,
-0.0252307858,
0.0282425135,
-0.0230234042,
0.0778252035,
0.0322731473,
0.0233960152,
-0.0182939526,
-0.0171725694,
0.0476202406,
-0.0510789417,
0.0050935335,
-0.0527394898,
-0.0447747298,
0.0462749787,
-0.0143909911,
-0.0275094472,
0.0127735529,
-0.1188198179,
-0.0298393816,
-0.0644703805,
-0.0132884094,
-0.0287439954,
0.0256426316,
0.0144914966,
0.0106492266,
-0.0321049541,
-0.0360510498,
0.0204596054,
0.0340451822,
-0.0293642953,
-0.0381235853,
0.0439216234,
-0.0551851615,
0.03222619,
-0.012140275,
-0.009434849,
-0.0335155502,
0.0033444026,
-0.0355570465,
0.0372102037,
0.035875801,
-0.0155436005,
-0.0096076885,
0.0556849092,
-0.0057238583,
0.0975108892,
0.0045897025,
0.0377061851,
-0.0331691839,
0.0252636801,
0.0410561115,
0.0206081644,
0.0031015007,
0.0230276212,
0.065860495,
0.0170167629,
0.0732924417,
0.0037668471,
-0.0424297787,
0.0390969254,
0.047004573,
-0.0273419991,
0.0094761895,
0.0472745672,
0.0189108513,
-0.0414006896,
-0.013641852,
0.1474241465,
0.0130200703,
-0.0197228193,
0.000212784,
0.0013403465,
0.0310146809,
0.0434607044,
-0.009699977,
-0.0659598932,
-0.0388245583,
0.0248957388,
-0.0059877052,
0.000799523,
0.0064394809,
-0.0323779397,
-0.0661328509,
0.0382221229,
0.05271006,
-0.0683156922,
0.0145753892,
-0.036191497,
-0.0419398919,
0.027475154,
0.0483978391,
0.0218080375,
-0.0192470271,
-0.0216003545,
0.0449840203,
-0.0586009473,
-0.0532471314,
0.0157647561,
0.0063033602,
0.0492346659,
0.0552766286,
0.0125596989,
0.0284908134,
0.0044866041,
0.0602969266,
-0.0194634162,
0.0516532138,
-0.041841805,
0.0021192271,
-0.0336452462,
0.0130686099,
0.0117271123,
0.0510051772,
-0.0567431934,
0.0000467414,
-0.0183688328,
0.0400806591,
-0.0629941821,
0.0099743567,
0.0270544738,
0.0147282863,
0.0172112547,
0.0239166077,
0.050725013,
-0.006082559,
-0.0042095887,
0.0165296067,
-0.0069698547,
-0.0210697744,
-0.0024718912,
0.0372904986,
0.0046665664,
-0.0355272405,
-0.0163413212,
-0.0602013916,
0.0161453001,
0.0347597003,
0.0130136637,
0.0303778555,
0.0124512725,
-0.0101745743,
-0.0319226757,
-0.0021660225,
0.0109818121,
-0.0023524205,
-0.0503017567,
-0.0222445242,
0.0053829555,
-0.0788242742,
-0.0289036799,
0.0388754457,
-0.0513929129,
-0.0665450618,
0.0182939265,
0.0291339774,
0.0250807386,
0.0388314649,
0.0201404579,
-0.0190241225,
0.0824488178,
-0.0112791331,
0.0047952435,
0.0115584284,
0.0270378646,
-0.0014329748,
-0.0068717063,
0.0165120512,
-0.0210837554,
0.048146937,
-0.0041093975,
0.0134879565,
0.0012512393,
-0.0528926812,
-0.0182504132,
0.0384140871,
0.0753246993,
-0.0472831428,
-0.0019754488,
-0.0370627195,
0.0789909735,
-0.0018088253,
0.0455988199,
-0.0312596001,
-0.0113938544,
0.0404469781,
0.0180618912,
-0.0116372472,
0.0074323174,
-0.0510919802,
-0.0008365125,
-0.009714148,
0.0689819157,
0.0294462033,
0.00229499,
-0.0000529032,
-0.0224523414,
-0.0174814537,
0.032837294,
0.0010142205,
0.0124828927,
-0.0015105966,
0.0568764582,
-0.0180521477,
0.0638727471,
0.0113114873,
0.0566573925,
-0.0365589485,
-0.0481411703,
-0.0549371578,
-0.014442442,
0.0335007608,
-0.004302009,
0.0518877245,
0.0301719438,
0.0315760747,
-0.0360808782,
0.0659929067,
-0.0313248076,
-0.0431983657,
0.0421295278,
-0.014253743,
-0.0389974564,
0.0261103325,
0.0576989688,
0.0160215888,
0.0441509746,
0.0200015362,
0.026819028,
-0.0618584007,
-0.0873690099,
0.008077547,
-0.00530846,
-0.0484299324,
-0.0277089756,
-0.0068642013,
-0.070428066,
0.0283516105,
0.0068196026,
0.0313667133,
0.0132473279,
0.051624082,
0.0336088613,
-0.0258110333,
0.0266481135,
0.0016632132,
-0.039155025,
-0.0172258355,
-0.0179931279,
0.0338624604,
-7.205537925e-33,
-0.0498396941,
0.0000652101,
0.0362582356,
0.0029114853,
-0.0191715937,
-0.004613854,
-0.031319242,
-0.0076374323,
0.0136294393,
-0.0621335544,
-0.0201489553,
-0.0172717795,
0.0270213727,
0.0283153523,
0.0083256653,
-0.0078956652,
0.0869794562,
-0.0138995107,
-0.0061800121,
0.0032644088,
0.0263417885,
0.0737297833,
0.0515017472,
0.0192771237,
-0.0333961844,
-0.0003892232,
0.0283063799,
-0.0266673118,
-0.015171879,
0.0058639995,
-0.0185456127,
0.0109665226,
-0.0012641825,
-0.0227837879,
-0.0624771006,
0.0178678315,
-0.0615429804,
-0.0084756687,
-0.0011972078,
0.028503906,
-0.0219164602,
0.017273264,
0.0398083925,
-0.0065935412,
-0.0334386081,
-0.0062575671,
0.0013748439,
0.0235882308,
-0.0423607305,
-0.049092643,
-0.030639438,
0.0119839972,
0.0037397991,
-0.0317988768,
0.0904844478,
0.0416210368,
-0.0193973929,
-0.0142621109,
-0.0555353574,
0.0179714374,
0.0028359208,
0.0405656025,
0.07943964,
0.016500799,
-0.0207621511,
0.0173461288,
0.0534268618,
-0.0537963547,
-0.0189558715,
0.0207687188,
0.0048540393,
0.0061580106,
-0.0217123404,
-0.0154146021,
0.0236495677,
-0.0520514995,
-0.0515512489,
-0.006731113,
0.0004826253,
0.0530014373,
0.0097694183,
0.0206671488,
0.0163928084,
-0.0072575524,
-0.0683039129,
-0.0346400775,
-0.0181341358,
-0.0348843522,
0.0514577217,
0.0173639134,
-0.0030028913,
-0.0134640178,
0.0428185686,
0.0322457962,
0.0061108815,
0.0185651258,
0.0324895643,
-0.0520300232,
-0.0091281021,
0.0422347449,
-0.1040029451,
-0.047986377,
0.049559392,
0.0063573602,
-0.0119926389,
-0.050170362,
0.00176406,
0.0618023053,
-0.0295265652,
-0.0041849879,
-0.043888662,
0.0256838705,
0.0275790319,
0.0264819749,
0.0825728551,
-0.0096924948,
-0.0178613439,
0.0479077734,
-0.0613988489,
-0.0225813724,
-0.0195191577,
-0.004581382,
0.0444792248,
0.0305420477,
-0.0494659133,
-0.0002802565,
-0.0187385883,
-0.0114079202,
0.0327848569,
-0.0323108323,
-0.0146085471,
0.0334930122,
3.08e-7,
-0.0007616468,
0.0189166814,
0.0533505045,
-0.0011911608,
0.0162573531,
-0.0151922386,
0.0048607374,
0.0072090374,
-0.005503275,
-0.000714823,
0.0267507471,
-0.0086573828,
0.0501536615,
-0.0038655121,
-0.0759547055,
-0.0214092005,
-0.0413437821,
0.041697599,
-0.0304817762,
-0.0171568226,
0.0334413722,
0.0491296016,
-0.0424120724,
-0.040511325,
0.038056422,
-0.0252798125,
0.0160056986,
0.0093504451,
-0.0056806416,
-0.0230186712,
0.0109230625,
0.0033033681,
-0.0261674169,
0.0573263466,
-0.0079656038,
0.0381634757,
-0.0099789277,
0.0247648787,
-0.0441789664,
-0.0666637942,
0.0215534959,
0.0497233048,
-0.021744689,
-0.0145134507,
0.0409382135,
0.0093616992,
-0.0173975024,
-0.0140255261,
-0.042064447,
0.0002303371,
0.0028555626,
-0.0129403882,
0.0694643855,
0.0377873816,
0.0060175094,
-0.0133960368,
-0.0119336247,
-0.0793023929,
0.0127270268,
0.0056400802,
-0.0748240948,
0.0138047142,
-0.0775076598,
-0.0018361786,
0.0145328902,
-0.0151764676,
-0.0421080329,
2.541920438e-34,
0.0298909694,
-0.0251962692,
0.0000183856,
0.0215823445,
0.0266734287,
-0.0515525341,
-0.0339731462,
0.021504242,
-0.0083040614,
-0.0811171085,
-0.0573422983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11787v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11787v2 | LLM Cognitive Judgements Differ From Human | 2023-07-20T16:22:36 | 2023-08-16T14:03:03 | Sotiris Lamprinidis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have lately been on the spotlight of
researchers, businesses, and consumers alike. While the linguistic capabilities
of such models have been studied extensively, there is growing interest in
investigating them as cognitive subjects. In the present work I examine GPT-3
and ChatGPT capabilities on an limited-data inductive reasoning task from the
cognitive science literature. The results suggest that these models' cognitive
judgements are not human-like. | [
0.0516279228,
0.0235103369,
-0.0201188643,
0.0217922609,
-0.0752416253,
0.0288841985,
-0.0112084998,
0.0259981304,
0.0429354683,
-0.0428856313,
-0.0422305204,
-0.0295866653,
0.0034416059,
-0.0247706138,
0.0569249988,
-0.0067458395,
0.04922124,
-0.0547822639,
0.0674176365,
-0.0275382958,
-0.0222256407,
0.0060903407,
-0.0024519027,
0.0127141364,
0.036637444,
-0.0154014574,
0.0211429317,
-0.0588355362,
-0.0255147405,
-0.0421081297,
-0.0185830835,
0.0537922829,
0.0275095999,
0.0435569398,
0.0000017928,
-0.062572062,
0.044169426,
-0.0263033397,
-0.0585846715,
0.0220496003,
0.0284861568,
0.022696944,
-0.0177294444,
0.0073890756,
-0.0320290886,
0.0168859325,
0.0355043449,
0.062193796,
0.0017632256,
0.045802217,
-0.0109237544,
-0.0285569634,
0.0231028404,
-0.0004600263,
0.0471097566,
-0.0169567484,
0.0320444591,
0.0578718558,
0.0215475187,
-0.0145381326,
0.0076964269,
0.0055457954,
0.0333108976,
0.0561469607,
-0.0605834834,
0.0400736481,
-0.0680104494,
-0.0429468416,
-0.0139090111,
0.0236740652,
0.0292530358,
-0.0269489363,
-0.043207664,
0.0180936102,
0.0242081732,
0.0050430349,
-0.0471553802,
0.0605673119,
-0.0361844562,
0.0290728658,
0.0251864456,
0.0050946758,
0.025016306,
-0.0035308592,
-0.047287561,
0.1366006881,
0.0108574796,
-0.0476009808,
0.0319430046,
0.0016779224,
-0.0733269081,
-0.019326048,
-0.0313647874,
0.0173156802,
-0.0084388191,
0.0231344625,
0.0366118066,
0.0603884906,
0.0328455977,
-0.0611405633,
0.0159794372,
0.0568851009,
0.0189258475,
0.0431257859,
-0.0341649726,
0.0509959124,
-0.0347712971,
0.0574602634,
0.0003240842,
0.0147179998,
-0.05752692,
-0.039382603,
-0.0091489488,
0.0158627536,
0.0300066303,
-0.0124598695,
-0.0693214536,
0.0106771793,
0.0114830239,
-0.011712838,
0.0027240652,
-0.0218506195,
-0.0046930942,
-0.0290878713,
-0.0856540501,
-0.0031402791,
-0.0103090135,
0.0352763347,
0.0051338165,
-0.078802444,
0.0034040746,
-0.0063270219,
-0.0372130312,
-0.0201047454,
0.0014307017,
0.0633899122,
-0.0106069297,
-0.031500306,
-0.0556229912,
-0.0056506419,
-0.014152375,
-0.1039701775,
0.0181937069,
-0.0505357981,
-0.0126886899,
0.0467012264,
-0.0101594673,
-0.0364215076,
0.0059201741,
0.0245507434,
-0.0575568713,
0.0625998378,
0.0175214354,
0.0141800242,
0.0085666087,
0.0103677362,
-0.0266677886,
0.0664958581,
0.0206469707,
0.0079483027,
-0.0113146855,
-0.0084142042,
-0.0021930095,
0.0376153737,
-0.014309369,
-0.0164476298,
-0.0445841998,
0.0005085417,
-0.0077924035,
0.0262186229,
0.0183668397,
0.0652422383,
-0.0274057519,
-0.0126329679,
0.0699004754,
0.0848262459,
-0.0001372393,
0.0299887545,
0.0394390225,
0.0032567035,
0.0197903644,
0.052778177,
-0.0602874756,
-0.0007890577,
-0.0575340912,
0.0130580487,
0.0110712182,
0.0169615708,
-0.0142895067,
-0.0202773921,
-0.0395118557,
0.0150396479,
0.0508094095,
-0.0072543183,
0.0473503061,
-0.004645694,
-0.0391673744,
0.0393690355,
0.0153945973,
-0.0320985503,
-0.0500345267,
-0.0643312037,
0.0423576832,
0.0387320705,
0.0132950479,
0.0146554327,
0.0081318868,
0.0205923468,
-0.0090065077,
0.0626909211,
0.0730237216,
0.0336036533,
-0.0513613708,
-0.0313398354,
0.0077713276,
-0.0093266293,
0.0073446152,
0.0153812291,
0.003881088,
0.0009582011,
-0.0050366982,
-0.0143868364,
0.0208791774,
-0.0036439151,
-0.0471031815,
-0.0104853576,
-0.0866238698,
-0.0172758009,
0.0124713322,
-0.0250172913,
0.0237429515,
0.0383045301,
0.0004387553,
-0.0047734338,
-0.0245847553,
0.0324447043,
-0.0323338695,
-0.0020554499,
0.0281173438,
0.0074608144,
-0.0127262445,
-0.0203571301,
0.0206995942,
-0.0162601918,
0.0435717404,
-0.0299456995,
0.0798110068,
-0.0348551571,
0.0382491909,
-0.0074713882,
0.0153471772,
-0.018661391,
0.1084800661,
-0.0094280327,
0.0473247841,
0.0119649414,
0.0087916348,
0.0075211376,
-0.0626223013,
-0.0026809631,
0.0333342738,
0.0219450258,
-0.0126614552,
0.0107587343,
-0.0206079129,
-0.0528690405,
-0.0146092735,
-0.0760118961,
-0.0196293648,
0.0079224762,
0.0111501096,
-0.0071505075,
-0.0309024118,
-0.0247135963,
0.0263472274,
-0.0412409306,
-0.0066992138,
0.0329340287,
0.0697282255,
0.0152063686,
-0.0468464233,
-0.0395590663,
-0.0000521458,
-0.0096839657,
-0.0408359803,
0.0389895402,
0.0327671245,
-0.0241528284,
-0.0437348224,
0.0338377208,
-0.0433438048,
0.007764881,
-0.0083697345,
-0.0370120555,
0.0334741324,
0.0021492117,
0.0689475685,
0.0516112633,
-0.0223164782,
0.0337298475,
0.0248939395,
-0.0135021377,
-0.0209910553,
-0.0031931871,
-0.0225457549,
-0.0344150253,
-0.0414089374,
-0.0417778119,
-0.0348792374,
0.0795142949,
0.026231939,
0.0093762726,
-0.0551429987,
0.0512326434,
-0.0160027761,
-0.0187898502,
-0.0276688971,
0.0080382172,
-0.0166933723,
0.0740015209,
-0.0129486006,
-0.0470709316,
0.0662928671,
-0.0028386677,
-0.0107080666,
-0.0189573281,
0.0088907722,
-0.0288896747,
0.0484659374,
0.0292354506,
-0.0033813061,
-0.0029061865,
-0.0250229295,
-0.0418433398,
0.0008740969,
0.0036507989,
-0.0140452618,
0.0407401174,
-0.0393519662,
0.0159323309,
0.0101045948,
-0.0224708412,
-0.0222013332,
0.0102457674,
-0.0705034509,
0.0359088257,
0.0404753909,
-0.0165373702,
-0.0216251463,
0.0280697476,
0.0195352305,
-0.0025914162,
-0.0033421873,
-0.0229379814,
-0.0115271024,
-0.0288688894,
-0.0063860365,
0.0504569411,
0.0338760875,
-0.0332035087,
0.0254161078,
0.0470524393,
0.0279001128,
0.0120025268,
-0.0155043211,
0.0484217554,
0.0287185311,
-0.0098088477,
-0.048733741,
0.0226668827,
0.0268744249,
-0.0430878736,
0.0216868464,
0.1152879894,
0.0300715342,
-0.0296009779,
0.0169322118,
-0.0330755487,
0.0332234502,
0.0457079187,
-0.0013713312,
-0.0784110129,
-0.0316168517,
0.0069886749,
-0.0448820479,
-0.0497155748,
-0.0341455378,
-0.0439305566,
-0.0989894345,
0.0418824293,
0.0066590505,
-0.0006510985,
0.0094615528,
-0.0269475318,
-0.0002261516,
-0.0034740116,
0.0126593662,
0.0373410508,
-0.030133022,
-0.0076726307,
-0.0035558483,
-0.0159600694,
-0.0392319374,
0.0571386777,
0.0062863305,
0.0499062203,
0.0139165483,
0.0138925277,
-0.0446698852,
-0.096656099,
0.0630124956,
0.0100243818,
0.0070698489,
0.0033163412,
0.0046279072,
0.0340977386,
0.018625427,
-0.0452584513,
-0.0027901672,
-0.0268826857,
-0.0338167511,
0.0076186345,
0.0922111645,
-0.0407698639,
-0.0513520762,
0.0291114096,
0.0368448384,
-0.0525945164,
0.0996484384,
0.0154589852,
-0.0218594037,
-0.0311049968,
-0.0258967467,
-0.0311324373,
0.0335743353,
-0.0802158341,
0.0470060036,
0.0328080319,
-0.014731504,
-0.0399437621,
-0.0257624108,
0.0367949456,
-0.0037436518,
0.0069810236,
0.0201136041,
0.0065262779,
-0.007927333,
-0.0091148643,
0.0288398657,
-0.011334599,
-0.0155459102,
-0.0815701559,
0.0274523981,
0.0167906694,
-0.0305249915,
-0.0184758287,
-0.0137423882,
-0.0491344146,
-0.0717849359,
0.0009838335,
-0.0095665567,
0.0392392911,
-0.0193850901,
0.0017159972,
-0.0213093068,
-0.0151842944,
0.012575618,
-0.0377735049,
0.0207068063,
0.0129092084,
0.0469846837,
0.0139895864,
0.0406209081,
0.0105532957,
0.0455869399,
-0.0026385598,
0.020877013,
-0.0094271014,
0.0002366093,
0.066686146,
0.0381171294,
0.0435054898,
-0.005567045,
0.0214968752,
-0.0158790778,
-0.0168851521,
-0.0184653848,
-0.0052234042,
-0.027853962,
-0.0252864547,
0.0061113047,
0.0112309773,
-0.0221486948,
-0.0644283369,
-0.0294401553,
0.0240770876,
-0.0156964436,
0.0055496898,
-0.0097727329,
0.0006036893,
0.0119745582,
-0.0268079564,
-0.0117868036,
0.0295769237,
-0.0523424931,
0.0305833761,
0.0053988253,
0.1139028296,
0.0185398031,
-0.0109391632,
-0.035513036,
-0.0070342207,
-0.0569462329,
-0.0773330256,
0.0339888744,
0.0534156673,
0.0129410308,
-0.0176251531,
0.0115305232,
-0.0713387132,
0.0020272441,
-0.0169029236,
-0.004055765,
-0.0014323072,
-0.0116862375,
0.0415701047,
0.0325458758,
-0.0403476954,
-0.0172766708,
0.0696485639,
0.0256749187,
0.0127632432,
-0.0271190852,
-0.0342428982,
-0.0324709415,
-0.0527665988,
-0.0088048335,
-0.0270388145,
0.0156401824,
0.0331198573,
-0.0877108723,
-0.0755091906,
-0.0526468568,
0.0257558096,
0.0225398317,
-0.0299296565,
0.0009711875,
0.0911994427,
-0.0303304084,
-0.0497538149,
-0.0006933451,
0.0011374825,
-0.0259681549,
0.0258375537,
-0.0304712746,
-6.433561397e-33,
-0.0212650392,
-0.025605185,
0.0371703394,
0.0172715671,
0.0007084677,
-0.0441702381,
-0.0114146145,
0.0329234302,
-0.0108661307,
0.0226801243,
-0.0229073782,
0.0119962804,
0.0117612844,
-0.0179935638,
0.0204256009,
-0.0062622107,
0.0033451871,
0.00687386,
-0.0234121233,
-0.0154760517,
0.0164354499,
-0.0088058095,
0.0678303093,
-0.0400846861,
0.0589522459,
-0.0087412829,
0.0150517887,
0.0021640302,
-0.0727542341,
0.0448310561,
-0.0256890841,
0.0234128237,
0.0448189899,
-0.0474199727,
0.0066980338,
0.0140633397,
-0.0156047223,
-0.0134889297,
0.0809997097,
-0.0265905932,
-0.0025560157,
-0.0349135846,
0.0305100642,
-0.0412549786,
-0.0462048687,
0.0104841385,
0.0154399406,
-0.046615757,
0.0020648472,
0.0406049639,
-0.0697144642,
0.0200717188,
0.0063968091,
0.0427143611,
0.0076952586,
0.0266996268,
-0.0669525787,
0.0172229391,
-0.0352869406,
0.0383420996,
0.0076859146,
0.0147220008,
0.0555358902,
-0.0122070974,
0.0173400473,
0.0565703176,
0.0039290418,
0.0250670742,
-0.0415730625,
-0.0252884962,
0.0047818646,
0.0682977811,
0.0295064896,
0.0023210205,
0.0199717898,
-0.0112749217,
-0.0238477364,
-0.036761608,
0.0572429337,
0.0192327108,
0.0494876355,
0.011722642,
-0.049833104,
-0.0403752923,
-0.0128041282,
0.0045643565,
-0.0483041555,
-0.0398291573,
0.0279525984,
-0.0464070253,
0.0221855249,
-0.0333800539,
0.0186198168,
-0.0091165053,
-0.033749532,
-0.0219017621,
-0.0168825351,
-0.0022089833,
-0.0066114501,
0.0490614176,
-0.0602389388,
-0.0105444007,
-0.0314760022,
0.044978898,
0.0137300026,
0.0093613658,
-0.0044031828,
0.0141646219,
-0.0416987836,
-0.0366704799,
-0.0548437387,
-0.0222964939,
0.018851446,
-0.027274603,
0.0580096282,
-0.0042216782,
-0.0065683802,
-0.0223415941,
0.000659336,
-0.018519612,
-0.0271651391,
0.0146599868,
-0.0414995365,
0.0336657129,
-0.0123066893,
-0.0205187369,
-0.0272110533,
0.0275067464,
0.0156725291,
-0.0399432778,
-0.0109713264,
0.0293524917,
2.671e-7,
0.0296598319,
0.0729227215,
-0.0222031735,
0.0240320228,
0.0285577625,
0.0167642608,
-0.0376094803,
-0.0227460619,
0.0512796231,
-0.0285603087,
-0.0062986575,
0.037754342,
0.0366013087,
0.0165126901,
-0.0444136932,
-0.0094684921,
-0.0474540517,
-0.0141167715,
-0.0336723775,
0.022232946,
0.0523419417,
0.0600312911,
0.0275034327,
-0.0061138403,
-0.0090384334,
-0.0654573068,
0.0542331375,
-0.0528531969,
-0.0067237313,
0.0060948557,
0.059560582,
0.0271613561,
0.0114574172,
0.0736554638,
0.0512226559,
0.008951664,
0.0188007355,
0.0428070873,
0.0183459856,
0.0108865937,
0.0042469795,
-0.0247846823,
-0.0174278822,
-0.0542055853,
0.0658000633,
-0.1021674648,
-0.0767809674,
0.0294404645,
0.0187246818,
-0.0535017215,
0.0236878637,
0.006639231,
-0.0115341265,
0.0079673249,
0.0268612094,
-0.0200398173,
0.0014642231,
-0.0468853377,
0.0048232209,
0.0193705969,
-0.0643408969,
-0.0755628347,
-0.0374615639,
-0.0042718654,
0.0245150719,
-0.0343375728,
-0.0005413131,
2.261410522e-34,
0.0540848859,
-0.008870746,
0.0425389186,
0.0067300498,
0.0536366776,
-0.0014711616,
0.0779663548,
0.0304769594,
0.0322888903,
-0.0893961042,
-0.0029209796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10982v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10982v2 | MASR: Multi-label Aware Speech Representation | 2023-07-20T16:09:57 | 2023-09-25T12:49:00 | Anjali Raj, Shikhar Bharadwaj, Sriram Ganapathy, Min Ma, Shikhar Vashishth | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | In the recent years, speech representation learning is constructed primarily
as a self-supervised learning (SSL) task, using the raw audio signal alone,
while ignoring the side-information that is often available for a given speech
recording. In this paper, we propose MASR, a Multi-label Aware Speech
Representation learning framework, which addresses the aforementioned
limitations. MASR enables the inclusion of multiple external knowledge sources
to enhance the utilization of meta-data information. The external knowledge
sources are incorporated in the form of sample-level pair-wise similarity
matrices that are useful in a hard-mining loss. A key advantage of the MASR
framework is that it can be combined with any choice of SSL method. Using MASR
representations, we perform evaluations on several downstream tasks such as
language identification, speech recognition and other non-semantic tasks such
as speaker and emotion recognition. In these experiments, we illustrate
significant performance improvements for the MASR over other established
benchmarks. We perform a detailed analysis on the language identification task
to provide insights on how the proposed loss function enables the
representations to separate closely related languages. | [
-0.0462318584,
0.012116679,
0.0169512611,
0.0405020602,
0.0088725276,
0.012353085,
0.0606027581,
-0.0284264609,
0.0003353185,
-0.0225934871,
-0.0930271894,
0.0494790003,
-0.0085947877,
-0.0161486007,
0.0126862209,
-0.0127842426,
0.0193631854,
-0.0351568162,
0.0244041104,
-0.0038165797,
0.0224165563,
0.0345237963,
-0.0344835594,
0.0243822485,
-0.0520818271,
0.0013295555,
-0.0061912318,
0.0226165522,
0.0481172651,
-0.0258566048,
-0.0118970955,
0.0218911208,
0.048728954,
0.0480874181,
0.0000020952,
-0.0092087695,
-0.0506852306,
0.0039507137,
-0.0358209871,
-0.038764324,
0.0037167601,
-0.0062939436,
-0.0004532945,
0.0182293076,
0.0098302774,
-0.0542663634,
0.0375254937,
0.0323982723,
0.0624078102,
0.0186102167,
-0.0319850557,
-0.0431182981,
-0.024576176,
-0.0035811027,
0.0051454441,
-0.0087959142,
-0.0391866639,
-0.0184951518,
-0.0282793809,
-0.0224543605,
0.0094485013,
0.067018196,
-0.0164973866,
0.0145899747,
-0.0108075663,
0.0105615426,
-0.0079504689,
-0.0099831922,
0.0089900279,
0.0535544194,
-0.0149762966,
-0.0053978371,
0.0210170243,
-0.0137440469,
-0.0038589193,
-0.0457261689,
-0.0054614479,
0.0188823696,
-0.0030112003,
0.0130908117,
-0.045611579,
0.0902593583,
0.0249114018,
-0.0217633042,
-0.0154477712,
0.0365101919,
-0.0136349574,
-0.0255624801,
0.0384200402,
-0.0314641073,
0.0282975845,
0.0696918592,
0.0341760814,
-0.035667371,
0.0174442958,
-0.0035245616,
-0.0187300257,
-0.0455225967,
-0.0133281471,
-0.0542563386,
0.0124928858,
0.0212536082,
-0.0567026958,
0.0322856121,
-0.0177065581,
-0.0012720645,
0.0126847988,
0.0610810742,
-0.0092969211,
-0.0316779539,
-0.0484306552,
-0.0041152402,
-0.0312894508,
0.062081974,
0.0107878586,
0.0155308973,
-0.0248620454,
0.0067962692,
-0.0655892715,
0.0243010335,
-0.0061982069,
-0.012426422,
-0.0021641115,
-0.0147161987,
0.0156222852,
0.0420502014,
-0.0109612141,
0.0335757583,
0.0194813926,
-0.0329437703,
-0.0082626548,
0.0327141061,
0.0395449102,
-0.0104559893,
0.0034596857,
0.0771002769,
-0.0037603523,
-0.0367148817,
-0.0394783691,
-0.0225796942,
-0.0098824166,
-0.0334277973,
-0.0214997288,
-0.033649724,
0.0778122023,
-0.0295487903,
0.004932723,
-0.0371014848,
-0.0393130705,
-0.0357997343,
0.0547127277,
0.0919935405,
-0.0034141375,
-0.0051055211,
0.0530341677,
0.0226173606,
0.0090168323,
0.0329382606,
0.0053294618,
-0.0112644685,
0.0067481552,
-0.0598921105,
0.0064278711,
0.0153489644,
0.002367036,
-0.01934289,
-0.0184583422,
-0.0249928813,
0.0375988372,
0.0232831426,
0.036684826,
0.0059685977,
-0.0131188352,
-0.0190318301,
0.027551543,
0.0191266742,
0.0168979689,
0.0437301733,
0.0372394547,
-0.0071700574,
0.0190927871,
-0.0122022107,
0.0306126103,
0.0395926312,
0.0087864352,
-0.0060151923,
0.0655538291,
0.0205205213,
-0.0511855483,
0.0091676023,
0.022881534,
-0.0579856336,
-0.0342096575,
0.0260513127,
0.0544437766,
-0.0050748722,
0.0066129928,
0.0762559772,
0.014979721,
-0.0477086641,
0.0153728239,
-0.0148155298,
-0.0257953759,
0.0183722209,
-0.0394378826,
-0.0835926011,
-0.0111522628,
-0.0594581887,
-0.0272150561,
0.0213280264,
0.011259838,
0.0001240285,
0.0955063999,
-0.0563676767,
-0.0355350189,
-0.0124590201,
0.0121591929,
0.0653139651,
-0.0937923491,
0.0252339747,
0.0282142516,
-0.0340696536,
0.047455579,
-0.0122902356,
-0.006206118,
-0.0353245512,
0.0382625051,
0.023847511,
0.0450249352,
0.0403745361,
-0.0297389701,
-0.0086512538,
0.0434509963,
-0.0173164513,
0.0023511893,
-0.0000359991,
-0.097165361,
-0.0624844991,
0.0588342175,
-0.0263866019,
-0.0000737959,
0.0579926893,
-0.0362663567,
-0.0831096917,
0.0773921907,
0.0025778727,
0.0346922316,
-0.039688278,
-0.0274431538,
0.0232838616,
0.0342787132,
0.0131891929,
0.0150632262,
0.021459898,
-0.0142552266,
0.0097364644,
-0.0249041468,
0.0227917507,
-0.0366286561,
-0.0348794721,
0.0045274524,
-0.0193140134,
0.0728196278,
0.0079796324,
-0.0310339611,
-0.0310033597,
0.0141571201,
-0.0447804406,
0.0017090179,
-0.0407807641,
0.0098555526,
-0.0128732556,
0.0279814061,
0.0214877166,
-0.0521592833,
-0.0246556364,
-0.05176479,
-0.056119062,
-0.0063968515,
-0.0378352739,
0.0444120318,
0.0054333885,
0.0113784373,
-0.0003796211,
0.0016762147,
0.0193403084,
-0.045543015,
-0.0104025444,
-0.0127804065,
-0.036545679,
-0.0401442721,
-0.0061542662,
0.0065867789,
0.0453933962,
-0.0249189455,
-0.0284393113,
0.019779617,
-0.0170432981,
-0.0005232897,
-0.0049606287,
0.0526476465,
0.000660588,
-0.0662159622,
-0.0039734244,
0.0130884564,
0.0244526584,
-0.0179757494,
0.0157718342,
-0.0453498475,
0.025385458,
0.0471970849,
0.0503322259,
-0.0213414282,
-0.0546824746,
0.0291135143,
-0.0590093546,
-0.0499964356,
0.0311691333,
-0.0352164619,
-0.0102561526,
0.0055974941,
-0.0126249818,
0.046807304,
-0.0379690453,
-0.0643309429,
-0.0196431819,
-0.1019962281,
-0.0163312051,
0.0151550733,
-0.0604428463,
0.0305848643,
-0.0100687118,
-0.0221683756,
-0.040818885,
-0.0273083523,
0.0534019656,
-0.0366692953,
0.0058659255,
0.0060916347,
-0.0056151869,
-0.020365309,
-0.0040672328,
-0.0020694924,
-0.0287791528,
0.0134521304,
0.0095071467,
-0.0594107658,
0.0142435245,
-0.0329010934,
-0.0120772375,
0.0491931364,
0.0512750708,
0.0258978698,
0.0138823129,
0.0057761427,
0.0851046368,
0.0184798241,
0.0044455375,
0.0026242144,
-0.0127404155,
0.041517213,
0.0046736235,
0.0435769111,
-0.0151668862,
-0.0476283841,
0.0089887716,
0.0035302979,
0.0499910451,
0.0248673763,
0.0169357471,
0.003861007,
-0.012192932,
0.030787373,
0.0996197611,
0.0154420482,
-0.0677632689,
-0.0421268344,
-0.0282462481,
-0.0090438351,
0.0357133262,
0.0001070994,
0.0041520954,
-0.0305027105,
0.019767005,
0.0404284708,
0.0101485178,
-0.007558384,
0.0013413416,
-0.059527155,
0.013291873,
-0.0057434002,
-0.0301892292,
-0.0506177656,
-0.0573793165,
-0.0309190862,
-0.021725582,
0.0293580629,
-0.0711832345,
0.0027377689,
-0.0356067345,
0.0386646762,
-0.0427320525,
-0.0263006929,
0.0277165808,
-0.0217068009,
0.0765464529,
-0.0113146594,
0.0314779431,
-0.026788814,
-0.0250777379,
0.0323031731,
-0.0112567581,
-0.0427608006,
-0.0307253171,
0.0441505648,
0.0062227645,
-0.0155669544,
0.034659043,
-0.0057832208,
-0.0342162251,
-0.0158031229,
-0.0048140404,
0.1063888893,
-0.014452884,
-0.0016376559,
0.015707057,
0.0061914269,
0.0255952645,
0.051653821,
0.0447726399,
-0.0276289042,
0.0288102403,
0.0176202916,
0.0648289397,
0.0403571315,
-0.0131423017,
0.046160914,
0.0048689204,
-0.0516934581,
0.0283388365,
-0.0287405513,
0.0258045495,
0.0246963985,
-0.0337014906,
0.0017398795,
-0.0393752195,
-0.008035141,
-0.0613278113,
0.0266303737,
-0.0340292268,
0.0099656451,
-0.0227546766,
-0.0270451158,
0.0543508679,
-0.031870164,
-0.0234383214,
0.015795989,
-0.0289386138,
-0.0207928959,
-0.0242285449,
0.0266403221,
0.0030895649,
0.0577544309,
-0.010135157,
-0.0150392978,
0.0478535183,
0.0586953238,
-0.0591390245,
0.0053654923,
0.0844998509,
-0.0094414558,
-0.0457751229,
0.0190344863,
-0.0600057729,
0.0626416057,
0.0003516724,
-0.0193641242,
-0.0072751772,
-0.0301261693,
0.0334603488,
0.022406511,
0.076800257,
0.0005371709,
0.0177006628,
-0.0355089679,
-0.0130200787,
-0.0016152426,
-0.0047747819,
-0.031002583,
-0.0065902146,
0.0599182434,
-0.0109252641,
0.0016721174,
0.0162269901,
0.0123262778,
-0.0304194391,
0.0205650553,
0.0621680915,
0.0056938347,
0.0480130538,
-0.0274524633,
0.0619155727,
-0.0171206761,
0.0182847586,
0.0674978942,
0.0002944996,
-0.0033440429,
0.0011067917,
-0.0031064746,
0.0029678082,
0.0194960628,
0.0277859792,
-0.0328738354,
-0.0034433068,
-0.0051855207,
-0.0384303965,
-0.0071108337,
-0.0090295551,
0.0392654315,
0.0219623893,
0.0165369399,
-0.0453706868,
0.038822636,
-0.0075363596,
-0.00347487,
0.0135408919,
-0.0238938052,
-0.0282843541,
0.0129074808,
0.0493323952,
-0.0135312714,
0.0168726686,
-0.0340788178,
0.0149315204,
-0.0518076606,
-0.0099515682,
-0.033053603,
0.01396624,
-0.0156566817,
-0.0180264078,
-0.0131684756,
-0.0861055627,
0.0445987247,
-0.0679528117,
-0.0025163891,
0.0287053213,
0.0130813625,
0.0023152067,
-0.0306906141,
0.0415369757,
0.016263891,
-0.0454773977,
0.0310676917,
-0.0028708426,
0.0449157618,
-6.165680928e-33,
-0.0353368782,
0.0119368834,
-0.0190002397,
-0.0188931711,
0.0312170479,
0.0141940108,
-0.0448214486,
0.0267812386,
0.0183591414,
-0.0227749012,
0.0190960784,
-0.0035711324,
0.0224193968,
0.0065208124,
0.0025237007,
-0.0314631648,
0.0785533711,
-0.012241506,
0.0201432239,
0.0195376966,
0.0725867897,
0.0571525879,
0.0676323101,
-0.1041122004,
-0.0522511415,
-0.0090220738,
-0.0400019065,
-0.0219173785,
0.0166921187,
0.0594327524,
-0.0214655735,
0.0688418001,
-0.003004821,
-0.0367464274,
-0.0497971699,
-0.0041413046,
-0.0935514867,
-0.0192558337,
-0.059285067,
0.019698726,
0.0056568072,
-0.0331775695,
0.0136794634,
0.0108130137,
0.0264638755,
-0.0401120372,
0.0626064688,
-0.0098636681,
-0.0211932361,
-0.0167612359,
0.0254117623,
0.0302870274,
-0.0456130728,
-0.0048669707,
0.1239691749,
0.0682265162,
0.0055754702,
0.0133852093,
-0.056824699,
-0.0048110797,
-0.0768654644,
-0.0150283137,
0.0412171073,
0.0387246907,
-0.0076079699,
0.0478767864,
0.0684851184,
-0.0397332758,
0.0578216538,
-0.0284483675,
0.0418513641,
0.0374494791,
0.0047076629,
0.0492927358,
0.0065307459,
-0.0369509831,
-0.0408258177,
-0.0058524394,
0.0056112586,
-0.0428302735,
0.0160751604,
0.0337829664,
-0.0308658499,
0.0010546653,
-0.0444854945,
-0.0357688665,
-0.0391167253,
0.0019774113,
0.052621983,
0.0302165244,
0.0219349079,
0.0498918071,
0.0477011241,
-0.0193253048,
0.0194329917,
-0.0005061268,
-0.037468154,
0.0110620866,
0.0252022501,
0.0096661095,
-0.021059256,
-0.0611080304,
0.0404827073,
-0.0016686785,
0.0304157715,
-0.0429191217,
0.041828014,
0.0365129299,
-0.0747487098,
-0.0042650127,
-0.0024024295,
-0.0086787194,
-0.0131928716,
-0.0536821447,
-0.0071454463,
0.0137219261,
-0.0225791372,
0.049003195,
0.0287018884,
0.0095246043,
0.0297611281,
-0.0163991582,
-0.007099261,
0.0269861612,
-0.0151225235,
-0.0118827187,
-0.0090335729,
-0.0811231583,
0.1017162129,
-0.0157986879,
0.0094335293,
-0.0412615128,
2.9e-7,
-0.0319370553,
-0.0166077763,
-0.0020549749,
-0.070823893,
0.000013608,
0.0605168752,
-0.0510576479,
0.0323964134,
-0.0127846478,
-0.0029882765,
0.0284418166,
0.0016969081,
0.0600402318,
0.0284477994,
-0.077316545,
0.0351999737,
-0.0805025846,
0.0082135228,
-0.0274774823,
0.0423937924,
0.0252246074,
0.0988885388,
0.0246336721,
-0.0334001333,
0.0082749613,
0.0082434695,
0.076191619,
-0.036144916,
0.0371919423,
-0.0299488027,
-0.0235493407,
-0.0003763471,
-0.0255217012,
0.0001314363,
-0.0152366022,
0.0053920429,
0.0651193708,
0.0517927334,
0.0114608333,
-0.0881765857,
0.033779487,
0.0643196106,
-0.0238576848,
0.0506855361,
0.0462077744,
-0.0087215472,
-0.0347422287,
-0.0359856784,
-0.0518795848,
0.043298956,
0.0255443063,
0.0105287759,
0.0040772543,
0.0033025586,
-0.0318368785,
-0.0190676562,
-0.0086205807,
-0.094603084,
0.0009963729,
0.046383854,
-0.05864124,
0.0179245584,
-0.030502582,
-0.0180679187,
0.0709731132,
-0.0658659786,
0.0329149887,
1.881411769e-34,
-0.0126041947,
-0.0164612904,
-0.0083408048,
-0.0374888256,
-0.0208936464,
-0.0671098009,
-0.0670279488,
0.0093628122,
0.0256732497,
-0.0142584853,
-0.0026819592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10932v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10932v2 | Identical and Fraternal Twins: Fine-Grained Semantic Contrastive Learning of Sentence Representations | 2023-07-20T15:02:42 | 2023-09-14T06:09:34 | Qingfa Xiao, Shuangyin Li, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The enhancement of unsupervised learning of sentence representations has been
significantly achieved by the utility of contrastive learning. This approach
clusters the augmented positive instance with the anchor instance to create a
desired embedding space. However, relying solely on the contrastive objective
can result in sub-optimal outcomes due to its inability to differentiate subtle
semantic variations between positive pairs. Specifically, common data
augmentation techniques frequently introduce semantic distortion, leading to a
semantic margin between the positive pair. While the InfoNCE loss function
overlooks the semantic margin and prioritizes similarity maximization between
positive pairs during training, leading to the insensitive semantic
comprehension ability of the trained model. In this paper, we introduce a novel
Identical and Fraternal Twins of Contrastive Learning (named IFTCL) framework,
capable of simultaneously adapting to various positive pairs generated by
different augmentation techniques. We propose a \textit{Twins Loss} to preserve
the innate margin during training and promote the potential of data enhancement
in order to overcome the sub-optimal issue. We also present proof-of-concept
experiments combined with the contrastive objective to prove the validity of
the proposed Twins Loss. Furthermore, we propose a hippocampus queue mechanism
to restore and reuse the negative instances without additional calculation,
which further enhances the efficiency and performance of the IFCL. We verify
the IFCL framework on nine semantic textual similarity tasks with both English
and Chinese datasets, and the experimental results show that IFCL outperforms
state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0290482268,
0.0454916507,
-0.0297543351,
0.069382064,
-0.0740918368,
0.0330455601,
-0.0338245742,
-0.0393775105,
-0.0088149002,
-0.038319964,
-0.0636605322,
-0.0278783794,
-0.0056307507,
-0.0242789704,
0.0368069224,
-0.060683161,
0.0673198029,
0.0466310345,
-0.0185961835,
-0.0082028927,
0.034867838,
-0.0022075444,
-0.0184117127,
-0.0121339774,
0.0109188762,
-0.0082437629,
0.0158158354,
0.0060746991,
0.0628367886,
-0.0630170554,
0.0274326783,
0.019364614,
0.0055464557,
0.024868289,
0.0000019853,
-0.0393612497,
-0.002007409,
-0.0134889288,
0.001885016,
0.0007067649,
0.0558138601,
-0.0282324553,
0.0244120043,
-0.0208138358,
-0.0374681614,
-0.0236943178,
0.037460383,
0.0732661709,
0.0626926795,
0.0568995476,
-0.0182838421,
-0.0425663926,
0.0304621514,
-0.0177199654,
0.0126358932,
0.0009931284,
0.0097531034,
0.0000419321,
-0.0243737344,
0.0381718874,
-0.005911578,
0.0241286959,
0.054746408,
0.0593750291,
0.0308934078,
0.0554506741,
-0.0372710899,
0.020428529,
-0.0239248555,
0.0698288232,
0.0182136949,
-0.0499327965,
-0.0271027293,
-0.020668067,
0.0086774928,
-0.0403884985,
-0.0318163224,
0.0019627577,
0.0124896821,
0.0654019564,
0.0517966822,
0.0334394984,
0.0231817551,
0.0103598544,
-0.0120953368,
-0.0009502816,
0.0216923282,
-0.0661629885,
0.0063542137,
0.0425157174,
-0.0663693622,
0.043808192,
0.0301087163,
-0.0022621907,
0.022429429,
0.0049501238,
-0.0203582644,
-0.0710979253,
0.0360450782,
-0.0628156587,
0.0334322304,
0.0453260764,
-0.0409555286,
0.0426460505,
-0.0717522576,
0.0015341522,
-0.0214191414,
0.0381776541,
-0.0589738153,
-0.0097593619,
-0.0515081249,
-0.0191556904,
-0.0452432148,
0.0482275002,
-0.0156630818,
-0.0418299697,
-0.0099570332,
0.0061474112,
-0.0415589176,
-0.0040781936,
-0.0227739289,
0.0016915038,
-0.0128733963,
0.0024682586,
-0.0234779362,
-0.0006244054,
-0.0668761283,
0.0345019735,
-0.0091788312,
-0.0205959603,
-0.0267560966,
0.0379559025,
0.0118450634,
-0.0172206927,
0.0025009238,
0.0698465258,
-0.0431903452,
-0.0461730659,
-0.0674131066,
0.0253938641,
0.0232643895,
-0.0188230593,
-0.0349143632,
-0.0501447767,
0.0255538914,
-0.0187912714,
-0.0097789988,
-0.0380719043,
0.0086888168,
0.0137040941,
-0.0122866007,
0.0744058266,
-0.0352803543,
-0.0527221709,
-0.006719836,
-0.0030313714,
0.0011578144,
0.0427809507,
0.0019343691,
-0.0362436026,
0.0217409749,
0.0573658682,
-0.0170303099,
-0.0255829431,
0.0259493161,
0.0113447178,
-0.0406068936,
0.0029202898,
0.0109376861,
0.0233413707,
0.0464499742,
0.0321050361,
-0.0521041937,
-0.0447902344,
0.0596585535,
0.0094418004,
-0.0292763934,
0.0289856382,
0.0377712026,
0.0295746028,
-0.0501747392,
0.0382057875,
-0.0546612702,
0.048484914,
-0.0088965595,
0.0092237908,
0.0217662994,
-0.0147111109,
-0.0542369075,
-0.015323868,
0.033424709,
-0.0336848833,
0.0438051336,
-0.0424796268,
0.0369882956,
0.0319370925,
-0.0212565027,
0.0365281552,
0.0474531613,
-0.0236553662,
-0.0192433801,
-0.00425755,
0.0112206852,
0.0410248488,
-0.0052935244,
-0.043915309,
-0.0512993224,
0.0204403996,
-0.0599671975,
0.0426004119,
0.0346550755,
0.030820109,
0.0219492372,
-0.0592173412,
-0.0135318441,
-0.0513577424,
-0.0002960661,
-0.0029508537,
0.0059614601,
0.018674938,
0.0323824175,
-0.019666139,
-0.0206264574,
0.0526270829,
-0.0235469788,
-0.0055598179,
0.0082464423,
0.0248651728,
0.0110793924,
-0.0068188193,
0.0181360338,
0.0184916239,
0.0355266556,
-0.0480159521,
-0.0416063294,
0.0055240225,
-0.0670985356,
-0.0899674818,
0.0350372344,
-0.0446122289,
-0.0144619215,
0.0643052161,
-0.055548612,
-0.0169679541,
0.0275525507,
-0.0124011412,
0.0518938079,
-0.0683807507,
0.0079401238,
0.00293087,
0.033797849,
-0.03552901,
0.073961027,
-0.0270810761,
0.019203838,
-0.049719736,
0.0217155702,
0.0142178247,
-0.0421608835,
-0.029046895,
-0.0781939253,
0.0109824361,
0.0130679617,
-0.008205764,
-0.0077931369,
-0.0749817789,
-0.0071074036,
-0.0509810783,
0.0415829308,
-0.0032155097,
0.0258760545,
0.0629478917,
-0.0048802719,
-0.0010664209,
-0.0387462676,
-0.0331631862,
0.0159052908,
-0.0352175757,
0.0247159991,
0.0600878224,
0.0050181439,
-0.0028976446,
-0.0096387155,
-0.0066395346,
-0.0042049955,
0.0075950925,
-0.0406200811,
-0.0326020941,
-0.0397925861,
0.0562291667,
-0.0219828207,
-0.0060646283,
-0.0020720912,
-0.0279486645,
-0.0137919486,
-0.01276288,
0.0195645541,
0.0807781965,
-0.0029525829,
-0.0270696282,
0.0301141944,
0.0467070453,
-0.0360833518,
0.0065988298,
-0.0241869912,
0.058001481,
-0.0013247568,
0.0030855741,
-0.0338506959,
0.0570462011,
-0.0068642548,
-0.0150596108,
-0.0200130697,
-0.0124131702,
0.0060533569,
-0.0082403282,
-0.0064352807,
0.0170645937,
-0.0302673429,
0.0135946218,
-0.0564961769,
-0.020054087,
0.0804555118,
-0.0041770204,
-0.0230881423,
-0.0704194158,
-0.0327081606,
-0.0235163383,
0.0375188589,
0.0204770193,
0.0187896304,
-0.0328202844,
-0.0017188436,
-0.0443517864,
-0.0079906275,
0.0035589491,
0.0075197145,
0.0168790277,
0.0320151187,
-0.0375671647,
-0.0041425126,
-0.0569657087,
-0.0187582653,
-0.0545726642,
-0.0077023562,
0.0168922972,
0.0024694304,
0.0266591851,
-0.0265497193,
-0.0280305631,
0.0023109454,
0.0558405332,
-0.0213347524,
-0.0005146573,
-0.043261271,
0.0645584986,
0.0218091197,
0.0107066063,
0.059659075,
-0.022421889,
0.0372031219,
0.0484030172,
0.0153955687,
0.0086698886,
-0.0227760077,
0.0103173414,
-0.0052078632,
-0.0061014448,
-0.0330936871,
-0.0003823955,
0.0446162038,
-0.042191647,
-0.0330417976,
0.0770927593,
0.0229439773,
-0.0472087711,
0.0081382943,
-0.0191466957,
0.0217326507,
0.0331989266,
-0.0357309543,
-0.0615360215,
-0.0400686711,
0.0030387766,
0.018013062,
0.0081349779,
-0.0001253731,
0.0067191962,
-0.1104269773,
-0.0102108046,
0.0072958712,
-0.0476258695,
0.0173042472,
-0.017962547,
0.0152032143,
-0.0028865486,
0.0345499702,
0.0124960216,
0.0110507775,
0.0007421148,
-0.0139623862,
0.0239272937,
-0.006097299,
-0.0185569599,
-0.0581013523,
0.0409171544,
0.0184667446,
0.0149450749,
0.0196195375,
-0.0470433719,
0.033883445,
-0.0786400065,
-0.0034069871,
-0.0216190405,
0.0497344509,
-0.0007246102,
-0.0072702602,
-0.0654154196,
0.0413436964,
-0.0087793237,
-0.0321095176,
-0.0106156031,
0.0495881289,
0.0038867577,
0.0142397201,
-0.011892572,
0.0363265611,
-0.0198558047,
0.0879752114,
0.0445213206,
-0.0240692347,
-0.0065897675,
0.0622003712,
0.0132622793,
-0.0725348741,
0.0293289423,
0.0286920499,
0.0125226537,
0.0439875908,
-0.0517983362,
-0.0688770637,
-0.0328969881,
0.0166263264,
-0.0168912727,
0.0206525791,
-0.0600960553,
-0.0434703194,
-0.0448291823,
0.0097015286,
-0.0244817305,
-0.0161223784,
-0.0025510625,
-0.0273327008,
0.0213536639,
-0.0178850479,
-0.0391264223,
-0.0243007522,
-0.0374219269,
-0.0461122356,
-0.0260993205,
0.0584133565,
0.0009674774,
0.0752900466,
-0.0029882537,
0.0112879341,
0.0301523041,
0.0815048814,
-0.0446092859,
0.0263523497,
0.0367383547,
0.0084284898,
0.0261816178,
0.038503997,
0.002008389,
0.0256721489,
0.06571199,
0.0443037935,
-0.0272221435,
0.0085249152,
0.0306241885,
0.0084029073,
0.0810563266,
-0.0002144591,
0.0476801656,
-0.0139752803,
0.0336953178,
0.0041969325,
-0.0166374184,
-0.0282753613,
-0.0084283557,
0.0276561752,
0.0197484512,
-0.0184642803,
0.0201358479,
0.0266801082,
0.0210409425,
-0.0278870892,
-0.014907497,
0.0218049102,
0.0471362583,
-0.0571878888,
0.0480405055,
-0.034392532,
-0.0095215701,
-0.0059500602,
0.0173963811,
-0.0245129876,
0.0460523143,
0.0427889824,
-0.0064382032,
-0.0564968325,
0.0602350309,
-0.0601649731,
0.0352005325,
-0.0078106499,
-0.0072475504,
0.0331916362,
-0.0229383726,
0.0275403857,
-0.0115146367,
-0.0145595903,
0.005657475,
-0.0033178611,
-0.0360587612,
-0.0205397476,
-0.0069621555,
0.0098168878,
0.004141713,
-0.0226828922,
0.0422748961,
-0.1014710367,
0.041058816,
0.0047753584,
0.0048246472,
-0.0388604887,
0.0009126619,
0.0699940622,
0.0538011044,
0.0069518541,
0.0258081034,
-0.0056822291,
-0.0614577122,
-0.0055767563,
0.0217601061,
0.0035917496,
0.0170872118,
0.0325659327,
0.0216433275,
-0.0098957755,
-0.0473799184,
0.0096057234,
-0.009056556,
0.0215242505,
-0.0041291923,
-0.0337226428,
-6.690593523e-33,
-0.038676247,
0.0374004394,
-0.0125034815,
0.0096775172,
-0.0225570276,
0.0125932042,
-0.0314689651,
-0.0227807947,
-0.009203936,
0.0409093574,
0.0382824279,
0.0241872836,
-0.005729964,
0.0391968302,
-0.0193570834,
-0.0122906212,
0.0389721133,
0.0256174076,
0.0015404187,
0.0058488837,
0.0491164885,
0.0344599709,
0.0618912615,
-0.064127706,
-0.0220754836,
-0.0350341164,
0.0036589396,
0.054398004,
0.0234923717,
0.0480847508,
-0.0120823542,
0.0453839004,
0.0438643843,
-0.0315412097,
-0.0331823155,
-0.0136908125,
-0.1165381074,
-0.0686489567,
0.0230237041,
-0.0128751751,
-0.0364031009,
-0.0221843645,
0.0616364665,
-0.0027000874,
0.0091195609,
-0.0074371537,
0.0184591208,
-0.0261675697,
0.0107631795,
0.0504779667,
-0.0721562654,
-0.0037874205,
0.0182478894,
0.0031885591,
0.0085562048,
0.0118209738,
-0.0123356376,
0.0313969478,
-0.0823937878,
-0.0237669069,
-0.0202808399,
0.0339979678,
-0.0074595246,
-0.0008378533,
0.0094967904,
0.0648403317,
0.0520668961,
-0.0333774202,
0.0288922414,
-0.0237770434,
0.0387234762,
-0.004779316,
0.0405475684,
0.0693542585,
0.0475237295,
0.0031438926,
-0.0559950434,
0.0295832995,
0.0070414268,
0.000997445,
0.0129025644,
0.0279246923,
-0.0289849639,
-0.0014204261,
-0.0064703836,
-0.0366981551,
-0.0443982817,
-0.026374612,
0.0329989642,
0.0186869539,
-0.0184774958,
0.0474148691,
-0.0101549253,
-0.0258664321,
0.0128356814,
0.0050596911,
-0.0177041218,
-0.0051770504,
0.0194017515,
-0.007430695,
-0.0466185398,
-0.0605765544,
0.0078931721,
0.0118884984,
-0.0024875777,
0.0073409039,
0.1247725934,
-0.0272521582,
-0.0747234747,
0.013135653,
-0.0160074402,
-0.0370364562,
-0.0108968467,
-0.0436999835,
0.0044627255,
0.0359580331,
-0.0170232579,
0.072420314,
0.0893243328,
-0.0088290703,
-0.0554355681,
-0.0316015296,
-0.0305538662,
0.0471494757,
-0.0005538871,
0.0153081873,
-0.0254978351,
-0.012750647,
-0.0086253667,
-0.0879341215,
-0.0150592318,
0.0073526534,
2.792e-7,
0.0302087422,
-0.008257797,
0.0213033911,
-0.0399554372,
0.0275970101,
0.0467203483,
-0.0275609586,
0.0467495732,
0.0052418113,
0.0134492032,
0.0377515703,
0.0659743398,
-0.0060457266,
-0.0167822074,
-0.0563883111,
0.0996633172,
-0.0973370224,
-0.0303451885,
-0.0260989349,
0.0230116639,
0.102481015,
0.0863087326,
0.0341872685,
-0.0117308004,
0.0369730145,
-0.036231041,
0.0676005706,
-0.0102747222,
0.0082613127,
-0.0295047499,
-0.0524104834,
0.0126652988,
-0.0014012774,
0.0273679439,
0.0087319268,
0.0215564258,
-0.0101617919,
-0.0114742769,
-0.0042917659,
-0.0288529098,
0.0144711202,
0.0026407209,
0.0011900457,
-0.0574735366,
0.0814018175,
-0.0775120929,
-0.0434221849,
-0.0126023693,
-0.0708492249,
0.0211051255,
0.0407336317,
0.0231943987,
-0.0586352237,
0.0040251496,
0.0085759293,
0.0524833575,
-0.0474906377,
-0.0791530907,
-0.0274733342,
0.043042466,
-0.0141052268,
-0.0090571027,
-0.0535806082,
0.02772923,
0.0271641072,
-0.0641088486,
-0.0018327337,
2.319979528e-34,
0.0061788666,
-0.000274785,
0.0161950029,
0.0156695843,
-0.0050301058,
-0.0178608168,
-0.0327157602,
-0.0139999045,
0.0306933858,
-0.0210937411,
0.0246836226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10930v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10930v2 | MediaGPT : A Large Language Model For Chinese Media | 2023-07-20T14:59:02 | 2023-07-26T14:21:47 | Zhonghao Wang, Zijia Lu, Bo Jin, Haiying Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in generating
high-quality text and making predictions based on large amounts of data,
including the media domain. However, in practical applications, the differences
between the media's use cases and the general-purpose applications of LLMs have
become increasingly apparent, especially Chinese. This paper examines the
unique characteristics of media-domain-specific LLMs compared to general LLMs,
designed a diverse set of task instruction types to cater the specific
requirements of the domain and constructed unique datasets that are tailored to
the media domain. Based on these, we proposed MediaGPT, a domain-specific LLM
for the Chinese media domain, training by domain-specific data and experts SFT
data. By performing human experts evaluation and strong model evaluation on a
validation set, this paper demonstrated that MediaGPT outperforms mainstream
models on various Chinese media domain tasks and verifies the importance of
domain data and domain-defined prompt types for building an effective
domain-specific LLM. | [
0.042316366,
-0.0039296309,
-0.0027823106,
0.0003085006,
0.0087234834,
0.0142978085,
0.0584735647,
-0.0021295042,
-0.005797049,
-0.0583210401,
-0.0638205931,
-0.0792555511,
-0.0141256833,
0.007492064,
0.0305317603,
-0.0695680231,
0.0175230261,
-0.00752756,
0.0200324189,
0.0017155252,
0.0287135467,
0.0364892706,
0.0223163161,
0.0174458623,
-0.0137615502,
-0.0491775796,
0.0156538654,
0.0337864235,
0.008963502,
-0.0315878578,
0.0347744003,
0.0623710975,
0.0703380778,
0.0204231199,
0.0000019897,
-0.0428868905,
-0.0051487861,
-0.0316317342,
0.0089453571,
0.060950011,
0.0650736466,
-0.0054826615,
-0.0424117111,
0.0354432315,
-0.0065721041,
-0.0150593417,
0.0391115882,
0.0612188019,
0.0543715283,
0.093669191,
-0.029800145,
-0.0057112845,
0.0023344744,
-0.0343062878,
0.006120549,
-0.0302601922,
0.0114761805,
0.0450380482,
0.0240141694,
0.0266149472,
-0.0058984552,
0.0119895106,
0.0155657781,
-0.0073729297,
-0.0432370119,
0.0302128531,
0.0067897253,
0.000524133,
-0.0267381761,
0.0669500008,
0.0032244287,
-0.0055884901,
-0.0245170426,
0.0067134337,
-0.0057881218,
0.0048245252,
-0.0431140549,
0.0516498685,
0.0027288825,
0.0050890911,
-0.0057190997,
-0.0133824218,
0.0242740661,
0.0203038473,
0.0313898996,
0.017959971,
0.0351060703,
-0.0326177478,
-0.0029328496,
-0.0137345977,
-0.0181834362,
-0.0537200421,
0.0276679732,
0.0191386715,
-0.0216921121,
0.0144716762,
-0.0355096124,
-0.0193486642,
-0.0175189599,
-0.0415662676,
0.0204459317,
0.0137062874,
-0.0350672752,
0.0360448025,
-0.0175839979,
0.0479270741,
-0.0263649579,
0.0056531173,
-0.0289157331,
0.0249533448,
-0.0676078647,
-0.0284058414,
-0.03763064,
0.0257727895,
-0.0324188955,
-0.0423359461,
-0.0419784486,
0.0170275997,
-0.0145360595,
-0.0101803625,
0.0451040603,
0.0043435134,
-0.0387766883,
-0.0330060758,
-0.0304106586,
0.0702010468,
-0.0221545137,
0.0493409745,
0.001820547,
-0.0086426875,
0.0275645722,
0.0399614535,
-0.0032994759,
-0.0089827888,
0.0153254597,
0.0548447743,
-0.0516835786,
0.0034201846,
-0.0761525184,
0.0046750135,
-0.015745895,
-0.054616604,
0.0166612417,
-0.0634391159,
-0.0061386721,
0.0013543691,
0.027026685,
-0.0160990153,
-0.0057482263,
0.0159999244,
0.0263705794,
0.0322356001,
0.0042949035,
0.0305753704,
0.0598876998,
0.0302081108,
-0.0067070439,
0.0979357511,
0.0253494084,
0.0521070547,
0.0523250848,
-0.0076492787,
-0.0048291376,
0.0625294745,
-0.0356159173,
0.0199153982,
-0.037606135,
-0.0047580074,
0.0089310398,
0.0053546233,
0.0380307436,
0.0389161743,
-0.0101247942,
0.0480943955,
0.0914470032,
-0.0023614916,
0.0114707351,
0.0165738277,
0.0730836689,
0.0326552764,
-0.0013326886,
0.0310960971,
-0.0331000648,
0.030054681,
0.0224655047,
0.0474988706,
0.0114342375,
0.0220362172,
-0.0750222728,
-0.0316318348,
-0.0131934742,
-0.0269225612,
0.0135612935,
0.0056242603,
0.0418805964,
-0.0047195395,
-0.0509591438,
0.0436339304,
0.0242252592,
-0.0304708313,
0.027318811,
-0.0320940949,
0.0288903806,
0.0703253597,
0.0089855781,
-0.0397333167,
-0.016327884,
-0.0233631823,
0.0687448382,
0.067397669,
0.0512231141,
-0.0240528509,
-0.0496592931,
-0.0753244162,
-0.0230891742,
0.0048882538,
0.003073696,
0.0362823233,
0.0022044964,
0.0361202583,
0.0215630811,
-0.0170554575,
-0.0639649555,
0.0179950837,
-0.0525910817,
-0.0484278537,
-0.007822847,
0.0091119939,
0.0076964875,
0.0493631922,
-0.0356041119,
-0.0124677727,
-0.0080153048,
-0.0080404263,
-0.0228497256,
-0.0246633627,
-0.0707512647,
-0.0097913779,
0.0265576243,
-0.0240298603,
0.0113901403,
0.0346259139,
-0.0268359259,
-0.0454905331,
-0.0286597442,
0.0077925497,
0.0006230181,
-0.081547685,
0.0430052876,
-0.0071201781,
0.0007636174,
-0.0116512878,
0.0582825877,
0.0393560156,
-0.0107514272,
0.0360690281,
0.0381825417,
0.0066708978,
-0.0252205394,
-0.0314724632,
0.0122629795,
0.0003476892,
0.019672785,
0.0428764299,
0.0508779399,
-0.0322176442,
-0.0200736038,
-0.0696980059,
0.0269713476,
-0.0508153997,
0.0067503056,
0.0187366623,
-0.0006786199,
-0.0400043279,
-0.013359,
-0.0519755781,
-0.0108688669,
0.0012417553,
0.0136978868,
-0.0144311031,
0.0034210682,
0.0141205518,
0.0025924491,
-0.0092501771,
-0.0078208754,
-0.0081041092,
-0.0193433054,
-0.027175976,
-0.0529136397,
0.0721240342,
-0.0065289238,
0.0057230559,
-0.0142970216,
-0.0447899215,
0.0030676092,
0.0166121442,
0.0496721379,
0.0294466093,
0.0106396414,
0.020980088,
0.026438145,
0.0090310182,
-0.0237975419,
0.0246436317,
0.0015662101,
-0.049570363,
-0.0474248864,
-0.0235065091,
-0.0017760388,
0.046834033,
0.0170093887,
0.019856371,
-0.0675456598,
-0.0253035557,
-0.0330508277,
-0.0072000623,
0.0042720488,
-0.0169510469,
-0.041892916,
0.0070824912,
-0.0277778078,
-0.0225054473,
0.0619635433,
-0.0358691178,
-0.010449416,
-0.0641100481,
-0.0061408137,
-0.0265068188,
0.0309659801,
-0.0154793747,
0.0244882759,
0.0274830628,
-0.0674376562,
-0.0769203827,
0.0196338594,
0.0387618393,
-0.0107299071,
0.0318603739,
-0.0149504943,
-0.0156401712,
-0.0268436056,
-0.0069237044,
-0.0193718225,
-0.0118957218,
-0.0046230126,
0.0178333148,
0.0008316966,
0.0189496912,
-0.023480976,
0.062206883,
0.0076898215,
0.0335100219,
-0.0508251972,
0.0206732415,
-0.0180446096,
0.0275686774,
0.0738279745,
-0.0059813652,
-0.0555313751,
-0.0591371655,
0.0701491237,
0.0082429582,
0.0071859527,
-0.0146551561,
-0.002503287,
0.0237262342,
0.0371115282,
-0.025367463,
-0.0276590977,
0.0398301631,
0.094637841,
-0.0683171377,
0.0233445168,
0.1557910293,
0.0228046011,
-0.0639385059,
-0.035557922,
0.0393725485,
-0.0071234368,
0.0223278366,
0.0139535954,
-0.1006961539,
-0.022711616,
-0.0066425521,
0.007289601,
0.0248573031,
0.034953393,
-0.0044938959,
-0.1227686256,
0.0505099297,
0.0236533452,
-0.0166531429,
-0.0344511531,
-0.0416835248,
-0.0155940829,
-0.0024485756,
0.0446301028,
-0.0252206586,
-0.0455591306,
-0.023053959,
0.0259994566,
-0.0127546722,
-0.0981182382,
0.0388095826,
-0.0415802151,
0.0743642151,
0.0867735818,
0.0031270669,
-0.0236354209,
-0.0139301773,
0.003984666,
0.0345073938,
-0.0045833476,
-0.0017316493,
0.0453991555,
-0.0244959835,
0.0077234814,
-0.0084899375,
0.0288979225,
-0.0017284976,
-0.001262915,
0.0351803191,
0.0549661107,
-0.0059519773,
-0.0225639846,
0.0051844167,
0.0093806498,
0.0163911954,
0.08629518,
-0.0005415999,
-0.0817814395,
-0.0199768934,
-0.0093194982,
-0.0468079112,
-0.0453611724,
-0.0136115681,
0.0394500457,
-0.0729227439,
-0.0161957201,
-0.0628017709,
-0.0283323936,
0.0298776738,
0.0088693732,
0.0212298501,
0.0091275573,
0.012813231,
0.0343394876,
-0.0369830504,
0.0057487949,
0.0001992161,
0.0240008608,
-0.0919374228,
-0.0355492011,
0.0290439464,
-0.0602891184,
0.0213834848,
-0.0153848156,
-0.0692169368,
-0.0453472473,
-0.0357997641,
0.022105189,
0.0105839539,
0.0280626975,
0.0104658362,
-0.0397315398,
0.0395238996,
0.0102307145,
-0.0679777116,
-0.027795339,
0.0126093142,
-0.0438424237,
-0.0252299495,
0.0196160898,
-0.0384855382,
0.0509125814,
0.010473622,
0.042071607,
0.0211871136,
-0.0139324926,
-0.0012376739,
-0.0227060039,
0.0155370161,
-0.0364155881,
-0.0358543582,
-0.083005622,
0.0072024944,
-0.0298985206,
-0.0026861969,
-0.0199049022,
-0.0021664798,
0.0363313444,
0.0075473585,
-0.0139557831,
0.007205518,
-0.0153073315,
-0.0021200755,
-0.0594702065,
0.0323658586,
-0.0375506952,
0.0165724102,
0.0006414311,
0.0179360565,
-0.007837032,
0.0087783886,
0.0187607873,
0.0073434282,
-0.0113445409,
0.1148593724,
-0.0008713583,
0.0279429536,
0.0335030183,
0.0409102403,
-0.0160394479,
-0.0031558233,
-0.0408495143,
0.0261467304,
0.0773824975,
-0.0492556058,
0.0185440797,
-0.0345239118,
-0.0099593773,
-0.0481494702,
0.0199640319,
0.0060884333,
-0.0241250694,
0.0200904254,
0.0201448444,
-0.0276659131,
0.0015275707,
0.1094208136,
0.0403287373,
-0.0163811408,
0.0366964675,
-0.0358388908,
-0.026909614,
-0.0024881985,
0.0500327721,
0.0083317999,
-0.040408887,
0.0231319796,
-0.0357935801,
-0.0725035369,
-0.0325124674,
-0.0381480791,
-0.0206793994,
0.0141206449,
0.0369392894,
0.0728459358,
-0.035293743,
0.0141548207,
-0.0441794619,
-0.0320135392,
-0.0354530104,
-0.01128757,
-0.0239833556,
-6.00610904e-33,
-0.0263751801,
-0.0054554692,
0.0328386426,
0.0015432494,
-0.0164041333,
0.0087246653,
-0.0158811156,
-0.0088162581,
0.0168498829,
-0.0024277461,
-0.0097927479,
-0.0026880428,
0.0204605982,
0.0546274148,
-0.02051902,
-0.0013500829,
0.0653032809,
-0.0400165208,
-0.0149406409,
0.0068138996,
0.010129068,
0.032026425,
0.0682142526,
-0.0626095384,
-0.0084954193,
-0.0084985876,
-0.0149618639,
-0.0231425371,
0.0585240759,
0.0943303928,
0.0117234588,
0.0442887172,
0.0231192335,
-0.0864759758,
-0.025893027,
0.0577503629,
-0.0834285319,
-0.006461842,
0.0154708503,
0.0267998241,
0.0031699236,
-0.0306553319,
-0.0223807953,
-0.0356124751,
-0.0033362184,
-0.0067727799,
0.0536892265,
-0.0379978903,
0.0274066217,
-0.0159214549,
-0.0536280461,
0.0027314411,
0.0085423701,
-0.0150863128,
0.0076098167,
0.0031653589,
-0.0158703718,
0.0052340617,
-0.0595021322,
0.0269366261,
0.0272839721,
0.0805897862,
0.0786768124,
0.0308238734,
0.0103642158,
0.0148878237,
0.0079276897,
-0.0013581795,
0.0056668841,
-0.0134224845,
0.038255278,
0.033371523,
-0.0091116,
0.0386981629,
0.0075515825,
-0.0281332247,
-0.0462641194,
0.0438205674,
0.0129680634,
0.0033130278,
0.0352532342,
-0.0005277165,
-0.0110458685,
-0.02143801,
0.0006259364,
0.0180520322,
-0.0040486408,
-0.0804619789,
0.0418568589,
0.0110348472,
0.0060635954,
-0.0116857495,
0.0735447258,
-0.0403591283,
-0.0146039026,
0.0120637072,
-0.0393963568,
0.0194009319,
-0.0085109994,
0.0220611915,
-0.056459073,
-0.0312417168,
0.0320383385,
0.0020601403,
-0.023120271,
0.0048566437,
0.0177232791,
0.0603341833,
-0.0688989237,
0.0070121633,
0.0007915028,
-0.0038436542,
0.0223091524,
0.073584944,
-0.0021865226,
-0.0022790921,
-0.0275513344,
0.063229762,
-0.006997582,
-0.0542932265,
-0.027015578,
-0.050526198,
-0.0387369394,
0.0106407236,
-0.0479455441,
0.0277792402,
-0.0429317132,
0.0167376045,
0.033214733,
-0.0407548994,
-0.0245075263,
0.0195299461,
2.543e-7,
0.0056354282,
0.0289060287,
-0.0033626775,
0.0730763897,
0.0268168375,
0.022646239,
-0.0101806773,
0.0368612595,
0.0211214963,
-0.0163447578,
0.0492788069,
0.0300108101,
0.0560623258,
0.0060238908,
-0.1277127564,
0.0067673987,
-0.0287584774,
0.0171063077,
-0.0548743531,
0.0066276784,
0.0289682709,
0.0973703116,
-0.0244553164,
-0.0057457453,
0.0059290584,
-0.0534198433,
0.0540506542,
-0.0082407854,
-0.0208538808,
0.0479034036,
0.0200722478,
0.0062364065,
-0.0470974967,
0.020007154,
-0.0363161974,
0.0053923712,
0.0500695407,
0.0879146829,
0.0017353313,
-0.0293289442,
-0.0057346891,
0.0319931805,
-0.0159646813,
-0.0438425615,
0.057125587,
-0.0116122877,
-0.0261789188,
0.0057775341,
-0.0284199286,
-0.0247078612,
-0.023798082,
-0.050039053,
-0.0114984093,
0.0224727914,
0.0148169352,
-0.0025678491,
-0.0282410849,
-0.0420675687,
-0.0024568541,
0.0112220719,
-0.021840727,
-0.0468921624,
-0.0311565716,
-0.0305067748,
0.0043591103,
-0.0568787083,
0.028676264,
2.483005671e-34,
0.0275579095,
-0.0237051323,
-0.0069069867,
-0.0091885254,
-0.0025131817,
0.0172763709,
-0.0258115381,
0.0027095997,
-0.0005804804,
-0.059263885,
-0.0264407825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10928v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10928v4 | FLASK: Fine-grained Language Model Evaluation based on Alignment Skill Sets | 2023-07-20T14:56:35 | 2024-04-14T04:29:51 | Seonghyeon Ye, Doyoung Kim, Sungdong Kim, Hyeonbin Hwang, Seungone Kim, Yongrae Jo, James Thorne, Juho Kim, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) is challenging because
instruction-following necessitates alignment with human values and the required
set of skills varies depending on the instruction. However, previous studies
have mainly focused on coarse-grained evaluation (i.e. overall preference-based
evaluation), which limits interpretability since it does not consider the
nature of user instructions that require instance-wise skill composition. In
this paper, we introduce FLASK (Fine-grained Language Model Evaluation based on
Alignment Skill Sets), a fine-grained evaluation protocol for both human-based
and model-based evaluation which decomposes coarse-level scoring to a skill
set-level scoring for each instruction. We experimentally observe that the
fine-graininess of evaluation is crucial for attaining a holistic view of model
performance and increasing the reliability of the evaluation. Using FLASK, we
compare multiple open-source and proprietary LLMs and observe a high
correlation between model-based and human-based evaluations. We publicly
release the evaluation data and code implementation at
https://github.com/kaistAI/FLASK. | [
0.0144659607,
0.0406286418,
-0.0105146347,
0.035114456,
-0.0315231681,
0.0239120312,
-0.0239961017,
-0.0186711848,
-0.0032985143,
-0.0118583022,
-0.0789851919,
-0.014517176,
0.036862053,
0.0022549576,
0.0191363525,
-0.0549293831,
0.0540746041,
-0.0508898087,
-0.0054083411,
0.0312054399,
0.0249805748,
0.017733803,
-0.0152950669,
0.0567307808,
0.0454361849,
-0.0237934999,
0.0018499815,
0.0036829696,
0.0117340125,
-0.0065337815,
0.0211946014,
0.0439032279,
-0.0071932585,
0.0260071754,
0.0000020558,
-0.0372030735,
0.0136606311,
0.0039046027,
-0.0133429551,
0.0690406933,
0.0666703135,
0.0208345,
-0.0275668893,
0.0332377106,
-0.0277567077,
-0.0040281513,
0.0508998409,
-0.0314474627,
0.0658120736,
0.0453271791,
0.012997861,
0.0074047022,
-0.0098656975,
0.0048058298,
-0.0198016409,
-0.0380614921,
-0.0208595581,
0.0178498495,
0.0248295758,
0.0044880053,
0.0221337304,
0.0109704919,
0.0243480168,
-0.021665398,
0.0087267449,
0.0088994084,
-0.0424261838,
-0.0283438209,
-0.0155907646,
0.0423973426,
-0.0234232806,
-0.0403518751,
-0.0343577527,
-0.0120187141,
0.0091841659,
0.0280738715,
-0.0475365594,
0.0030030897,
0.0147923985,
0.0076918472,
0.0279085264,
-0.0076890085,
0.010369421,
0.0053181015,
0.0212063491,
0.0676754937,
0.025413746,
-0.0192034077,
-0.0198090076,
0.0080765001,
0.0182871334,
-0.0617023818,
0.0123507585,
0.0424965955,
-0.0610496849,
0.0038353857,
-0.0440267287,
0.0390253961,
0.0328002125,
-0.04010842,
0.0780215263,
0.0634163022,
-0.0077655595,
0.0523336343,
0.0004239173,
0.0647184849,
0.0337786414,
0.0338143744,
-0.0372997038,
0.0287130903,
-0.0651663989,
-0.0061353077,
-0.0114315981,
-0.0108248629,
0.0132042719,
0.0054766466,
-0.0396386459,
0.0373341776,
-0.0176697802,
0.0518818349,
0.0239472017,
-0.0312365331,
-0.0075432328,
0.0191228427,
-0.0225186925,
0.0687496364,
-0.0258103553,
0.0103429565,
0.0051817531,
-0.02709103,
0.0034688311,
0.0174930245,
-0.0505902246,
-0.0304687172,
0.0212535765,
0.075818643,
0.0056260158,
0.0248221587,
0.0038411606,
-0.0264519677,
0.0261708032,
-0.0808403045,
-0.025739288,
-0.1084518656,
0.0017336445,
0.0448918715,
-0.0056033353,
-0.0498551801,
-0.0093948934,
0.0370598733,
-0.0140072489,
0.0207088981,
0.0055145957,
0.0447408706,
0.0058753784,
0.0192404035,
-0.0102443649,
0.0586303547,
0.0362159573,
0.0269495603,
0.0269599874,
-0.0681160614,
0.0173779428,
0.0546546988,
-0.0237760544,
0.0059652212,
-0.017329704,
0.0334639512,
0.0196147785,
0.0232938565,
0.0286311619,
0.0351354033,
0.0007313206,
0.0114929415,
0.0510499366,
0.0406211317,
0.0295036826,
-0.0358077101,
0.0724832788,
0.0341239348,
0.0453598127,
0.0037105943,
-0.0460661091,
0.0321482122,
-0.0474149659,
0.0218124166,
-0.0010222277,
0.0535272211,
-0.0139185591,
-0.0544874556,
-0.014775781,
0.0049618804,
0.0180479959,
0.0097350953,
0.0368165895,
-0.0275548324,
-0.0284995064,
0.0341971256,
0.0397753119,
-0.061691355,
-0.0089234244,
-0.0416180715,
-0.0142159341,
0.1046757922,
0.0713445842,
-0.0090735573,
-0.0372964926,
0.0129980249,
-0.0174939819,
0.0006744452,
0.0504178032,
-0.0223399438,
-0.0027654709,
-0.0547067896,
-0.0520088114,
-0.0093821557,
-0.0027428861,
0.0052181482,
0.0194740705,
-0.029247988,
0.0098939296,
-0.0566637814,
-0.0885832906,
0.0299337357,
-0.0101003945,
-0.0132588586,
-0.0623524226,
0.017211657,
0.0048230477,
0.015206214,
-0.0033947653,
0.0274216365,
0.0254402217,
0.0215220284,
0.0567329638,
0.00073994,
-0.0337696187,
0.0147660468,
0.0440651663,
0.0015205959,
-0.0458294973,
0.0490726158,
-0.0158066489,
-0.0202109423,
0.0106444834,
-0.0151829636,
-0.0031203399,
0.0148885362,
0.0451344959,
-0.033449728,
-0.0130661828,
-0.0347295329,
0.0341858752,
0.0025070659,
0.0398495607,
0.0073909364,
0.0323511064,
0.013317191,
-0.0155566363,
-0.0555340834,
-0.0005541782,
-0.0017917807,
0.0577207804,
0.0274122506,
0.0554304421,
-0.0426235683,
-0.0217542201,
-0.0844414234,
0.0167047419,
-0.0197354555,
0.0454331636,
0.0453584418,
-0.0086081801,
-0.0138665661,
0.0069182129,
-0.026213415,
-0.0421530828,
-0.0186915696,
-0.000797436,
0.0115770036,
-0.0124232136,
-0.0552253835,
-0.0398614891,
-0.010644746,
-0.0140417023,
0.0171118304,
0.003792014,
0.0650154799,
-0.0729110241,
0.0329217017,
-0.0047513121,
-0.0039927727,
0.0193753894,
-0.0707762241,
0.0254948083,
0.0313867889,
0.0192104895,
0.0577108301,
-0.0155272158,
0.0192400273,
0.0593079068,
0.0059294514,
-0.0515930839,
-0.0184264109,
0.0154477991,
-0.0375058465,
-0.030250214,
-0.0519445911,
-0.0488234945,
0.0814056993,
0.0052242517,
0.0193376336,
-0.0551058874,
-0.0013275094,
-0.0293434486,
0.0111352867,
-0.0076072323,
-0.004812499,
-0.0254598409,
0.0159543008,
-0.0418851227,
-0.0779840648,
0.0637148246,
-0.0580671728,
-0.0154930893,
-0.0497454777,
-0.0309919342,
-0.0223663449,
0.068369329,
0.0055162157,
0.0120522585,
-0.0268754829,
-0.0263693389,
-0.0570226237,
0.0272387564,
0.0225736499,
-0.0471936315,
0.0302810725,
-0.062026903,
-0.0109136226,
-0.0164878108,
0.0156575684,
-0.0192694291,
0.0024159688,
-0.0231347475,
0.0228734519,
0.0380406864,
-0.0303894188,
0.0043145875,
0.0264922176,
0.043207705,
0.0104422551,
-0.0129659548,
0.0129037555,
-0.0098611796,
-0.0091117378,
0.0183948856,
-0.012012871,
-0.0239833333,
-0.0370199122,
0.0032964889,
0.0318634361,
0.0509217866,
0.0029635206,
-0.0275345985,
0.0085180495,
0.057260517,
-0.0527689531,
-0.0249321051,
0.0527440347,
0.0884286463,
-0.0735009685,
-0.0100932131,
0.1000744998,
0.040534988,
-0.0414480381,
0.0160738174,
-0.0247499049,
0.046385441,
0.0431322567,
0.0545437299,
-0.0502765402,
-0.0270574596,
-0.0204948783,
0.0442638844,
0.0059716422,
0.0103794709,
0.0089637479,
-0.1056313217,
0.0226455294,
0.0225089584,
-0.057913702,
-0.0203261059,
-0.0533907339,
0.0264829248,
-0.012017508,
0.0309718642,
0.0289387237,
-0.0200770665,
0.0008099426,
0.0298085772,
-0.0623011701,
-0.0962575823,
0.0804446116,
-0.0349715017,
0.0982030854,
0.0752399564,
0.0005166125,
0.0036982498,
-0.0673817769,
0.0394887291,
-0.0014297703,
0.0038879912,
0.0043860334,
0.0257788617,
-0.012384397,
-0.0195375383,
-0.007839771,
-0.0154886013,
-0.0232471712,
-0.0011791941,
-0.0093746241,
0.0589366518,
-0.0074134427,
0.0395767763,
-0.0033741947,
-0.0264495201,
0.0103883138,
0.0585187748,
0.04602075,
-0.0538088232,
-0.0429503396,
-0.0521178506,
-0.0646560714,
-0.045458287,
-0.0524921194,
0.0414029881,
-0.00292152,
-0.039886035,
-0.0302027091,
-0.065788649,
0.029554924,
0.0088858856,
-0.0057527707,
0.0238934606,
0.0044134422,
-0.0079236915,
-0.0550527908,
0.0337504335,
-0.0169470031,
0.069739677,
-0.1106366068,
-0.0679976121,
-0.0147485379,
-0.0184750296,
-0.0076404791,
0.0024559884,
-0.0819309428,
-0.0631352812,
-0.0079533802,
0.0624584518,
0.0230119973,
0.0284027606,
-0.0282974485,
-0.0633816421,
-0.0136934984,
0.0095313266,
-0.0809324235,
0.002587653,
0.0177057572,
-0.0272592884,
0.0005172333,
0.000508296,
-0.0262287445,
0.0062107178,
0.0249891225,
0.035324052,
-0.0217813905,
-0.0254770108,
0.0157156009,
0.0266650319,
0.0027873011,
-0.0127869118,
-0.0071582478,
-0.0047733122,
-0.012545526,
-0.022443423,
-0.0368114151,
-0.040023189,
-0.0417794101,
0.0248731673,
-0.0224004854,
0.0543393828,
-0.0100067686,
-0.0441942178,
0.0196918268,
-0.0510550402,
0.0638688281,
-0.0087145781,
0.0532758124,
0.0288484357,
0.0091407085,
-0.035117656,
-0.0234693754,
-0.0237956569,
0.0445748605,
-0.0137059018,
0.0560197979,
-0.0089565245,
0.0231962185,
0.0123772845,
0.0640800074,
-0.0122507503,
-0.0442342274,
-0.0267935731,
-0.0000460159,
0.0400221758,
-0.0271440558,
0.0705366433,
-0.0217673164,
0.0157744121,
-0.0310823936,
0.0401273854,
-0.0146939158,
-0.0331111476,
-0.0064398977,
0.0480372794,
-0.0032004914,
-0.017797906,
0.0802039281,
-0.0098348074,
0.0209590811,
-0.0160513185,
-0.0223642271,
-0.0420786999,
-0.0031904152,
0.0409190208,
-0.0010246575,
-0.0588351339,
-0.0212202016,
-0.0678115487,
-0.0622907355,
-0.0592059083,
0.0766950548,
0.0143102566,
-0.0165878534,
0.0357116014,
0.0757267922,
-0.0345300101,
0.0309334826,
-0.0397636592,
-0.0392594635,
0.0005951832,
-0.0046230839,
-0.0267961603,
-6.228392817e-33,
-0.0555458665,
-0.0273642037,
0.0356654376,
-0.0221551303,
-0.001292038,
-0.0066255741,
-0.0369823165,
0.0265529584,
-0.024988547,
-0.0185450446,
0.0195553862,
-0.0237369239,
0.0035704107,
-0.0161434952,
0.0555341393,
0.0200270228,
0.0086733457,
0.0045152926,
-0.0623958074,
0.0083301449,
0.0024267461,
-0.0277535282,
0.0809857026,
-0.0647038743,
0.0385476984,
-0.0074028992,
-0.0186492,
-0.0189393889,
-0.0216261949,
0.0917452052,
0.0176380705,
0.0177415274,
0.021772122,
-0.0497253984,
-0.0196781121,
-0.0255937241,
-0.0033474814,
-0.0345590748,
0.0481975675,
0.0304449834,
-0.0299191233,
-0.0071861497,
0.0533665717,
-0.0100704739,
-0.0473779365,
0.0054021031,
0.033161208,
-0.0191682149,
-0.0017057367,
0.0551983789,
-0.0629178435,
0.0327340327,
-0.0247285254,
-0.0692720935,
-0.0225279536,
-0.0027766482,
-0.0181804746,
-0.0281013306,
-0.051238738,
0.0175369661,
0.0206242148,
0.0568402931,
0.117452845,
0.0158295818,
-0.018458372,
0.026646873,
0.0021540015,
0.0032774366,
0.0133235203,
0.0132891526,
0.0411286019,
0.0353836976,
0.0217238478,
-0.0164316166,
-0.0075600678,
-0.001492181,
-0.0277524199,
0.0477212667,
0.0085284291,
0.0724389851,
0.0082419841,
0.0310775898,
-0.0798749253,
-0.0120798899,
-0.0268623959,
-0.002030866,
-0.0375163741,
-0.0320531949,
0.0293729398,
-0.0314410552,
-0.0309682954,
-0.0247828756,
0.0308426023,
-0.0075490284,
-0.0244065728,
0.0078684725,
-0.0588683784,
0.0568035766,
-0.0151517969,
0.0175244082,
-0.0513651893,
-0.0369285829,
-0.0010697552,
-0.0052744308,
0.0550647974,
0.0227270219,
0.0084322132,
0.0259237047,
-0.0565539487,
0.0142311528,
-0.0551032238,
-0.0035269104,
-0.0102860117,
0.0057493621,
0.0538258366,
-0.0361692235,
-0.0235337187,
0.0540443249,
-0.0193849578,
-0.049191568,
-0.056106519,
-0.0027293002,
0.0148418928,
-0.016069157,
-0.0366100743,
0.0260753259,
-0.0449518301,
-0.007136445,
0.0031331158,
0.034575548,
-0.0140589224,
-0.0004506026,
2.729e-7,
0.06165291,
0.0518299416,
0.0087855123,
0.0394477509,
-0.0237785112,
0.028831793,
-0.0487472638,
0.0091731092,
0.019409867,
0.0207058992,
0.0066654654,
0.0307222735,
0.059321221,
0.0211289153,
-0.0343127921,
0.0144171258,
-0.0351129398,
0.0372418873,
-0.0358908027,
0.0332558602,
0.0456938259,
0.0414289646,
0.0104290312,
0.0160234105,
-0.0119328443,
-0.0270932615,
0.0012904241,
-0.0151583189,
0.0061681741,
0.0309805796,
-0.0065297531,
0.0231211353,
-0.0061632222,
0.0224416461,
-0.0026092327,
0.0000630944,
0.0188332591,
0.0721209347,
-0.0494019091,
0.0230551995,
-0.00180194,
-0.0386749506,
-0.0052058487,
-0.0961925834,
0.0243109129,
-0.0053088674,
-0.023654053,
-0.0327008143,
-0.0245570671,
-0.0020525882,
-0.0003756344,
0.0144994101,
-0.0365534239,
0.0226240698,
0.0247223563,
-0.0342239141,
-0.0598721988,
-0.03766324,
-0.0503133871,
0.0234664902,
-0.0005711758,
-0.057763271,
-0.0349739194,
-0.0196075477,
-0.0071726777,
-0.0572000109,
-0.0212510899,
2.73165395e-34,
0.0221796967,
-0.0127196321,
0.0550586432,
0.0092594614,
0.0502297506,
0.0135189435,
-0.0114493379,
0.0286298823,
0.018318262,
-0.030195592,
-0.0138365617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02035v1 | What Twitter Data Tell Us about the Future? | 2023-07-20T14:02:47 | 2023-07-20T14:02:47 | Alina Landowska, Marek Robak, Maciej Skorski | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | Anticipation is a fundamental human cognitive ability that involves thinking
about and living towards the future. While language markers reflect
anticipatory thinking, research on anticipation from the perspective of natural
language processing is limited. This study aims to investigate the futures
projected by futurists on Twitter and explore the impact of language cues on
anticipatory thinking among social media users. We address the research
questions of what futures Twitter's futurists anticipate and share, and how
these anticipated futures can be modeled from social data. To investigate this,
we review related works on anticipation, discuss the influence of language
markers and prestigious individuals on anticipatory thinking, and present a
taxonomy system categorizing futures into "present futures" and "future
present". This research presents a compiled dataset of over 1 million publicly
shared tweets by future influencers and develops a scalable NLP pipeline using
SOTA models. The study identifies 15 topics from the LDA approach and 100
distinct topics from the BERTopic approach within the futurists' tweets. These
findings contribute to the research on topic modelling and provide insights
into the futures anticipated by Twitter's futurists. The research demonstrates
the futurists' language cues signals futures-in-the-making that enhance social
media users to anticipate their own scenarios and respond to them in present.
The fully open-sourced dataset, interactive analysis, and reproducible source
code are available for further exploration. | [
0.0739943832,
0.0765973032,
-0.0247279294,
-0.0233227871,
-0.0216588173,
-0.0443500429,
-0.0119156856,
0.0144308945,
0.0316976979,
-0.014794413,
0.0612068027,
-0.02282965,
-0.0512128174,
0.0576107241,
-0.0017577059,
-0.0434909724,
0.0284091961,
0.0227582417,
0.0414889865,
-0.0223096367,
-0.0033753349,
0.0484918393,
-0.0105545688,
0.0398300588,
-0.0368556604,
-0.0326194465,
0.0152465552,
0.001471572,
-0.0038756798,
-0.0525712147,
0.0489625633,
0.0739112124,
0.0129651735,
0.0265382752,
0.0000021886,
-0.0326849148,
-0.033856947,
-0.0497040115,
0.0349516384,
-0.0431958549,
0.0615146533,
-0.0112641631,
-0.0008947189,
0.022146266,
-0.0801773667,
0.0413026251,
0.0135078859,
0.0445184968,
-0.0048897816,
0.0153575065,
-0.0280485637,
-0.0114862313,
0.0226379484,
0.0089874994,
0.0025682671,
0.0052965721,
0.0249702316,
-0.0410778709,
-0.0405604281,
0.0570966303,
0.0250505637,
0.0427900814,
-0.0281141531,
0.0268892199,
0.0323166326,
0.0438353978,
-0.0139772873,
-0.0423983335,
-0.0348681435,
-0.0168672558,
0.0943690985,
-0.0467495732,
0.0203819051,
0.0154758729,
-0.0246156361,
0.0297273863,
-0.0518371053,
-0.006060265,
-0.0012403352,
0.036388088,
0.039367266,
0.0342338458,
-0.0062450478,
0.0414711311,
0.0519821495,
0.1158861667,
0.0004964006,
-0.0404015966,
-0.0062808744,
0.0212779511,
0.0184915904,
-0.062802121,
0.0129059982,
-0.0084236674,
-0.0227658991,
0.0119638843,
-0.0138598848,
-0.0240905508,
-0.0186644364,
-0.0560422279,
-0.0154700615,
0.0103097064,
0.0337236747,
0.0241084117,
0.0457562618,
-0.034817148,
-0.0232597068,
-0.0414419062,
-0.0021461607,
0.0324925967,
-0.0191661529,
0.0080361022,
-0.0160985608,
-0.0134325977,
-0.0123452852,
-0.028066434,
0.0097384918,
-0.0106113562,
-0.0064605381,
-0.0208434593,
-0.0338954777,
0.0308779106,
-0.014019547,
-0.0483596958,
-0.0658681691,
0.0153838303,
-0.0335454494,
0.0122295842,
-0.072821036,
-0.0215510353,
0.0062227203,
-0.0070164856,
0.0377451405,
0.0014293665,
-0.0232265182,
0.0507504866,
0.0200582072,
0.0040971045,
-0.0519151166,
-0.0550625809,
0.0271792002,
-0.0018589955,
0.0289744847,
-0.0161409844,
-0.0101087773,
0.0503188781,
0.0247648582,
-0.0122229103,
0.0139797451,
0.030066058,
0.0203611404,
0.0136891156,
-0.0574847944,
0.0551234074,
0.0282563418,
0.0149698192,
0.0173645541,
0.0684221759,
-0.0002340894,
0.0594785213,
0.0513875447,
0.0064116814,
-0.0097547499,
0.0361237302,
0.0010331746,
0.0095726317,
0.0078245429,
-0.008793192,
-0.0399704166,
-0.0117795607,
-0.0224254522,
0.0281798355,
0.0384168997,
0.0354793854,
0.038684193,
0.0562031977,
-0.0185134616,
0.046147339,
0.0038368327,
0.0299063884,
-0.0140764462,
-0.0281320401,
0.0427077673,
0.0541285053,
-0.0009818085,
-0.0334722586,
-0.0093143024,
-0.0131581211,
-0.028192576,
-0.0013989742,
-0.0190136731,
0.0240751319,
0.0025032302,
-0.0476069488,
-0.00703872,
-0.0430040024,
-0.0563018247,
0.0303200148,
-0.0194578581,
-0.0164818112,
-0.0100705475,
0.011014428,
0.001777065,
0.0738929883,
0.0164897516,
-0.0201496445,
-0.0420641676,
-0.0013765943,
0.0231033228,
0.0459442586,
0.0248718206,
0.0134232026,
-0.0766108632,
0.0202513244,
0.0081715444,
0.0094086882,
0.0039276374,
-0.0070523014,
0.0455770493,
0.05503916,
-0.0188359004,
-0.0079977335,
-0.0015334907,
0.0145944925,
-0.0371569544,
-0.0114169102,
-0.0404222533,
0.0113308122,
0.0257634073,
0.0362624377,
0.0389225148,
0.01218466,
0.0287514292,
0.0010138624,
-0.0429708809,
0.0612996295,
0.0002650473,
0.089709796,
0.027563313,
-0.0331060477,
-0.0396244526,
0.0280750208,
0.0045836382,
-0.0056921537,
0.0715470612,
0.0259697344,
0.0475991927,
-0.0132635208,
-0.0286880285,
-0.0345773697,
0.0081704976,
0.0219228212,
0.0565368533,
-0.0191327352,
-0.0126721319,
-0.0209931638,
-0.0519898497,
0.0471322872,
0.0240121335,
-0.0374444537,
-0.0272850692,
0.0004833367,
0.0097626224,
0.048677668,
-0.0327741876,
-0.0975637659,
-0.0012033591,
-0.0839035586,
-0.034352053,
-0.040193852,
-0.0006678797,
0.0231871549,
-0.0167367849,
-0.0263859257,
0.0089188144,
0.0049474002,
0.0195942074,
-0.0018951978,
0.0012931543,
0.0038055878,
-0.0057168128,
0.049257502,
-0.0367139541,
0.0019191757,
-0.0658039749,
0.0035606672,
0.0380317569,
-0.0728446618,
0.0161327478,
-0.0058869235,
-0.0451025777,
0.0025370689,
-0.024636846,
0.0097492803,
-0.0029777905,
-0.0372457877,
0.0331511386,
-0.0505892746,
0.0462589003,
0.0309510119,
-0.0009068861,
-0.0149820251,
-0.0007994889,
0.0121457335,
-0.0494602323,
-0.0265170708,
-0.0201326888,
-0.0092477277,
0.038064748,
0.0139064128,
0.0147883277,
0.0090932017,
-0.0793174878,
0.0400013588,
-0.0429073758,
-0.0067635216,
-0.0134477802,
-0.0056521539,
0.0018719691,
0.095287852,
0.010804778,
-0.035452161,
0.0490773581,
0.044229649,
0.0146101015,
0.0227452628,
-0.040767815,
-0.0072750375,
0.0321607329,
-0.0141141005,
0.0021916477,
0.0438995957,
-0.0093688238,
-0.022637615,
0.0125962179,
-0.0745511204,
-0.0058436221,
0.011866699,
-0.0173449703,
-0.0060277604,
0.0332209207,
-0.0063322629,
-0.0015407702,
-0.0946541503,
-0.0826034695,
-0.0125553412,
-0.0167795848,
-0.0172769837,
-0.0196697656,
-0.0181427822,
-0.0515998416,
-0.0347840749,
-0.0078902282,
-0.0245986469,
0.0116961543,
-0.0185179021,
0.0575753078,
-0.035891626,
-0.0191981234,
0.0417094491,
-0.0026589297,
0.0005358633,
0.0191254113,
-0.0238846168,
-0.0476195887,
-0.0012850089,
0.0368291773,
-0.0118104452,
-0.0254837852,
0.0133856889,
0.0374946594,
0.0266898163,
0.0313439183,
0.0957546309,
0.0417955853,
0.0432128161,
0.0200337991,
-0.0324021541,
0.0493712723,
0.0140354186,
0.0256600045,
-0.0933077931,
0.0167158861,
-0.0400299281,
-0.0322970338,
-0.0235268008,
-0.0918351337,
-0.0619459189,
-0.0509870164,
0.0101305665,
-0.0069539626,
0.0705566183,
0.0338841751,
0.0028229791,
-0.0044915504,
0.018001873,
-0.0327122211,
-0.0167812854,
-0.0105926879,
0.0424453989,
0.0302089434,
-0.0761021525,
0.0100371065,
0.0310493689,
0.0162999984,
-0.0182647109,
0.0119454712,
0.0787076652,
0.0047805887,
-0.0011227453,
-0.0256915446,
-0.0340229273,
0.0407986529,
-0.0316559859,
0.0352023691,
-0.036370147,
0.0034365777,
-0.0374579206,
0.0275143702,
-0.0380586945,
-0.0377665982,
0.0014665469,
0.0752419233,
-0.0388564058,
-0.0449091308,
-0.0413817316,
0.0547856726,
0.0337404236,
0.0231573749,
-0.0159955099,
-0.0296861939,
0.0082602473,
-0.0194127131,
0.062537618,
0.0033236966,
-0.0323372371,
-0.065313518,
0.003269525,
-0.0125621837,
-0.0332750864,
-0.0681114718,
-0.0141926948,
-0.0481263064,
-0.0056977011,
-0.0073548732,
0.0203500558,
-0.0085877329,
-0.0424945205,
0.0056373063,
-0.0148820821,
0.011083167,
0.0092465309,
-0.0365861058,
0.0440279171,
0.0253251027,
0.0020101997,
0.0143988123,
-0.0921750143,
-0.0495248958,
0.009702337,
-0.0133437524,
0.0201395135,
-0.0559471846,
0.0047034174,
-0.0516124628,
0.0375288501,
0.0500055663,
-0.0047954028,
0.035220094,
0.0034893206,
0.0486893766,
0.0193111822,
0.0379249789,
0.0286355037,
0.0379134938,
-0.0314901955,
-0.0207397044,
-0.0652330816,
-0.0042687887,
-0.0215875544,
-0.0071080322,
0.1034367383,
-0.0169302821,
-0.0417920388,
0.000778224,
-0.0657048225,
0.0096120816,
-0.0242167544,
0.0093243169,
-0.017454762,
0.0145727452,
0.0040547145,
-0.0624204129,
0.0297717769,
-0.0322286002,
-0.0120312935,
-0.0383131318,
0.0068522287,
0.0054256395,
0.0066300393,
0.0004856243,
0.0015756787,
0.0194822941,
-0.0449262075,
0.0002996271,
0.0029482539,
0.0317241848,
0.0113970833,
-0.0383760184,
0.0148242982,
0.0296908971,
0.0040782019,
-0.0666437373,
-0.113766849,
0.0255860686,
0.0460727736,
-0.0096152229,
-0.0225739963,
0.0298616365,
-0.0675527453,
0.0122099221,
0.0143558364,
-0.000366841,
-0.0445628501,
-0.0409200303,
0.0567018948,
-0.0306724198,
-0.0355179384,
0.0066535142,
0.0382732339,
-0.0428796038,
0.0438905917,
0.0597781464,
-0.0493312404,
-0.0197117236,
-0.0240363721,
-0.0222219452,
0.0158075392,
0.0464063548,
0.051165387,
-0.0516011231,
-0.0042475313,
0.0947124511,
-0.0380838141,
-0.0244832728,
-0.0233802609,
-0.0037121435,
0.0297543723,
-0.0288510956,
-0.0070683425,
-0.0199887864,
-0.0141877988,
-0.0451376066,
-0.0295881927,
-0.0627609342,
-6.974451164e-33,
0.0015064013,
-0.0617588684,
0.0574704558,
0.0216864701,
-0.0536777899,
0.001827392,
-0.0152471876,
0.0347290002,
-0.0413322411,
0.0182486866,
-0.0474755429,
0.0269259941,
0.0057428074,
-0.0234688558,
0.0637210533,
-0.0440176874,
0.0291003175,
-0.015504675,
0.0136760166,
0.0075974781,
0.0550936013,
0.0189251229,
0.0450540781,
-0.0987976268,
0.0303383358,
0.0002880301,
-0.0301723927,
0.0029079276,
0.0937189832,
-0.0497696921,
-0.0254442599,
0.0539700761,
0.0440086909,
-0.0152771417,
-0.0118349791,
0.069762744,
0.0283833109,
-0.0863516554,
0.0177515261,
-0.000748707,
0.0460701548,
0.0126965819,
-0.0402405635,
-0.0041772616,
-0.0890524164,
0.0506858453,
0.0386294946,
0.0270889327,
0.0453932434,
0.0185968131,
-0.0509332344,
0.0285689551,
-0.0289232247,
0.0623613372,
0.0371069349,
0.0689760372,
0.0467510186,
0.0072465083,
-0.0624589622,
0.0824114382,
-0.0364801846,
0.0274189711,
0.0211371575,
-0.0467681661,
0.0188431181,
0.0685957968,
-0.0110409483,
0.0336308144,
-0.0319691636,
0.0083238231,
0.0025883494,
0.0552671365,
-0.0290461686,
0.0340287685,
0.0204908699,
-0.0631517768,
0.0295068081,
0.0323121734,
0.0175107364,
0.013091418,
0.0400130376,
-0.0015725096,
0.0094856126,
-0.0181723014,
-0.004809984,
-0.0305339191,
-0.0145553788,
-0.011926489,
-0.0558384135,
-0.0225229263,
0.0153244752,
0.0530906953,
0.0199110508,
-0.0169315338,
-0.0202753842,
0.0531963632,
-0.0579790436,
0.0137648834,
0.0047032544,
0.0631961897,
-0.0694929957,
0.0087968223,
-0.0212929193,
0.0183721948,
-0.0080527365,
0.0001588694,
-0.0452076234,
0.0279631745,
-0.0510906056,
-0.02345323,
0.0075284666,
0.0042400872,
0.0005351011,
-0.0842632875,
0.0419342592,
0.0195878521,
0.0094981361,
-0.0176303573,
0.0720514804,
0.0471039936,
0.0161439218,
0.0158156957,
-0.0011945595,
-0.007107887,
-0.0209002569,
-0.0113811847,
-0.0513933524,
0.014118148,
0.0294885114,
-0.0618907735,
-0.0306063853,
-0.0277345423,
2.858e-7,
0.0385186262,
0.0748701245,
-0.0290364865,
0.0159831587,
0.0416793339,
0.0440475568,
0.0371514335,
0.0017180435,
0.0096207885,
-0.011079777,
0.0168525539,
-0.0048895171,
0.0167112276,
0.0182586629,
-0.0386357345,
-0.0473103076,
-0.0853179023,
0.0012769935,
-0.0803903639,
0.0082937293,
0.0407245643,
0.0192810707,
0.0487757698,
0.001399097,
-0.0366260782,
-0.0064773457,
0.0494809411,
-0.0577140786,
0.0099834166,
0.0347715542,
-0.0062681278,
-0.007058667,
0.0060013691,
-0.0102517074,
-0.0418444686,
-0.0344895683,
-0.0274900198,
-0.01295406,
0.0220797826,
0.0089000249,
0.0394969508,
0.0142355161,
-0.0291691553,
-0.0235155709,
0.0463379584,
0.0006552644,
-0.0727567077,
-0.0443203822,
-0.0022445361,
0.0287055168,
0.0090907821,
-0.0014560134,
-0.0321340002,
0.0056401449,
-0.0059816418,
0.0059860731,
-0.0229539182,
-0.0673727393,
0.010143375,
0.0062909522,
-0.0271858685,
-0.0144644454,
-0.0335086882,
0.0098289205,
0.0246958099,
-0.0321633667,
0.0709465742,
2.151539223e-34,
0.0041388255,
0.0494087227,
-0.0171287209,
-0.0272541009,
0.0228761025,
0.0124839153,
0.0274959952,
0.0270659178,
0.02305663,
-0.03286843,
-0.0064952201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10867v1 | FigCaps-HF: A Figure-to-Caption Generative Framework and Benchmark with Human Feedback | 2023-07-20T13:40:22 | 2023-07-20T13:40:22 | Ashish Singh, Prateek Agarwal, Zixuan Huang, Arpita Singh, Tong Yu, Sungchul Kim, Victor Bursztyn, Nikos Vlassis, Ryan A. Rossi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Captions are crucial for understanding scientific visualizations and
documents. Existing captioning methods for scientific figures rely on
figure-caption pairs extracted from documents for training, many of which fall
short with respect to metrics like helpfulness, explainability, and
visual-descriptiveness [15] leading to generated captions being misaligned with
reader preferences. To enable the generation of high-quality figure captions,
we introduce FigCaps-HF a new framework for figure-caption generation that can
incorporate domain expert feedback in generating captions optimized for reader
preferences. Our framework comprises of 1) an automatic method for evaluating
quality of figure-caption pairs, 2) a novel reinforcement learning with human
feedback (RLHF) method to optimize a generative figure-to-caption model for
reader preferences. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our simple learning
framework by improving performance over standard fine-tuning across different
types of models. In particular, when using BLIP as the base model, our RLHF
framework achieves a mean gain of 35.7%, 16.9%, and 9% in ROUGE, BLEU, and
Meteor, respectively. Finally, we release a large-scale benchmark dataset with
human feedback on figure-caption pairs to enable further evaluation and
development of RLHF techniques for this problem. | [
0.0406115912,
0.0727511793,
0.0126084425,
0.0086550992,
0.0050989604,
0.0098342039,
0.008114689,
0.001085858,
0.0111535788,
-0.0098594865,
-0.0568177812,
0.0211955234,
0.0049452586,
0.0669480637,
0.0144701265,
-0.110785,
0.0042109913,
-0.0347829945,
-0.0025061846,
-0.0055995868,
0.0077492883,
-0.0043149688,
-0.0159566049,
0.0378799513,
-0.023013249,
-0.0111885527,
0.0135712009,
0.0121567501,
0.0298750196,
-0.0581301115,
0.0003136843,
0.089160867,
0.0375315808,
0.0152379302,
0.0000018527,
-0.0162485503,
0.0069233384,
0.0207126904,
0.0419390351,
0.0143572232,
0.0756718442,
-0.0544109121,
0.0033882135,
-0.0442935452,
-0.0259941705,
-0.0046138242,
0.0780181661,
0.065519385,
0.0767555535,
0.0181709751,
-0.003054504,
-0.042166844,
-0.0349393114,
-0.0537055694,
0.0339856595,
-0.0079292729,
-0.019157527,
0.0676879287,
-0.0008303653,
0.0039830278,
-0.0404021032,
0.0326668955,
-0.0039038942,
-0.0256891716,
0.0278301593,
0.0785158426,
0.0098083019,
-0.0500990264,
-0.0293522179,
0.1111159474,
0.0417826995,
0.0197391454,
-0.0263093971,
-0.0193339474,
-0.0035843218,
0.0462466329,
-0.0533806793,
-0.0149598578,
0.0151713546,
-0.0167380199,
-0.0401943624,
0.0221733693,
-0.0030582547,
-0.0178654585,
-0.0011411184,
-0.0185516477,
0.0066143218,
0.0182900894,
-0.0362195224,
0.0268592034,
-0.0741418749,
-0.0399287492,
0.0269135442,
-0.0105443411,
-0.0118890898,
-0.0059503024,
-0.0450352579,
-0.0321080871,
0.0215127394,
0.0132942135,
-0.0063581644,
-0.0291141309,
-0.026194226,
0.0595966242,
0.0103279566,
0.0182791408,
-0.0108734798,
0.0437049456,
0.0032164124,
0.0342901982,
-0.0249010231,
0.005983043,
0.0273779333,
-0.0049109305,
-0.0439479984,
-0.0404706523,
-0.0587443188,
-0.0248349253,
-0.0234547872,
0.0429073013,
-0.0042835288,
0.0532022603,
-0.0691725463,
0.019884821,
-0.0845829472,
0.0357650258,
-0.0345005281,
-0.022010684,
0.0196992066,
0.0125869466,
0.000206411,
0.0252718199,
0.0255352333,
-0.0043225451,
0.0007844254,
0.094186902,
-0.0180921182,
-0.0046885428,
0.018834604,
-0.0330928117,
-0.0268092062,
-0.0417755432,
0.0093038902,
-0.0210892037,
0.0311844721,
-0.0211386234,
0.0086560007,
-0.082609728,
0.0132968985,
0.0069763297,
0.0059715603,
0.1131187603,
-0.0197246391,
-0.032569997,
0.0459371023,
0.010026875,
-0.0703702047,
0.0516997613,
0.0496466123,
0.0455154181,
0.0167831238,
-0.033271376,
0.0513093546,
0.0065757795,
0.0387077145,
0.0164976623,
0.0060877083,
0.0048865173,
-0.0220418889,
0.0649748072,
0.0635055527,
0.0215251092,
-0.0357786305,
0.0180613641,
0.0563424751,
0.0357347019,
-0.0164818559,
0.0212371945,
0.0229014419,
-0.0103727151,
-0.0160104595,
0.0154672172,
-0.0352029614,
0.0801050812,
0.0451321565,
0.026123045,
-0.0090617938,
0.0009198037,
0.0124271186,
-0.0374673195,
0.0396464132,
0.0038523476,
-0.0230864026,
-0.0365119614,
0.0413256809,
0.0167166311,
-0.0523061305,
0.0194965824,
-0.0008228094,
-0.0546853691,
0.0038496831,
-0.0081181647,
0.0295887776,
0.0665102974,
0.0570577867,
-0.0070563732,
-0.0351424664,
-0.0215127338,
0.0004526166,
0.0736402273,
0.0337533765,
0.0047904775,
-0.0292840991,
-0.0404183008,
-0.0422761329,
-0.0196931697,
0.0011574348,
0.0516618602,
-0.0139309438,
0.0007417544,
0.0325734206,
0.0006279978,
-0.101096496,
0.0382713415,
0.0113548376,
-0.0276596453,
-0.0089400411,
0.0216959063,
0.0175739415,
0.0005597268,
-0.0240305737,
0.0189678967,
0.0060326322,
0.0035395741,
-0.0029697567,
0.0585636422,
-0.0371516868,
-0.0552421734,
0.0150714405,
-0.1046560928,
-0.0330205783,
-0.0024708249,
-0.0114717027,
-0.0329618528,
0.0043840031,
-0.0403505862,
-0.0122419903,
-0.043416135,
0.0006588939,
0.0005295929,
0.0036621147,
-0.0277586933,
0.040918719,
-0.0128857056,
-0.015541235,
0.0320909023,
-0.0064498917,
-0.005979511,
-0.0450633466,
-0.0073583559,
-0.0187725332,
0.0417601168,
0.0041824761,
0.0320904292,
0.0568474904,
-0.06369932,
-0.0012751166,
-0.0290690772,
-0.0352091156,
0.0161841195,
-0.0234466996,
-0.0075326171,
-0.0221231543,
0.0011227843,
-0.019877078,
-0.0274347886,
-0.0401877798,
-0.0103134429,
-0.0172351096,
0.0838202983,
0.0077401567,
-0.0120376647,
-0.0471248068,
0.0019807084,
0.0037023616,
0.0415316261,
0.081752412,
0.0554764494,
-0.0414281636,
0.0020973508,
-0.0056477371,
-0.018726211,
0.0078140479,
-0.0073440382,
0.0469551757,
0.0002676349,
-0.009808314,
0.061133042,
0.0176315866,
0.04634583,
0.0036941757,
0.0143097807,
-0.0589274615,
0.0188888721,
-0.0444159321,
-0.0514207445,
0.0430464894,
-0.0227153823,
0.0325674489,
0.0249153189,
-0.0485690795,
0.0409426615,
-0.0745301619,
0.0551891886,
0.0004649454,
-0.0653729215,
-0.0474846959,
0.0481868796,
0.0016375333,
0.0473855399,
-0.0191453397,
-0.0568540543,
0.075877443,
-0.0381969027,
-0.0142067904,
-0.0270803533,
0.0390845314,
-0.0337389223,
0.0148994075,
0.0142231071,
0.035769958,
0.0307242721,
-0.0135051105,
-0.0113100372,
0.0147073912,
0.0438640974,
-0.0134198517,
0.0053031174,
-0.0473082438,
-0.0123633863,
-0.018269429,
-0.0445670895,
-0.0092907893,
-0.0014683235,
-0.0187349785,
-0.04872749,
-0.0015186488,
-0.0499528944,
-0.0429735072,
0.0265436489,
0.0115750497,
0.0134727722,
-0.0283612479,
-0.0323826633,
0.0066652894,
0.0278570671,
0.0514999889,
0.0371479839,
-0.0348691568,
-0.0474195853,
-0.0256920327,
0.0124907596,
-0.0005546073,
-0.0097920392,
-0.0295176301,
0.0239477474,
-0.0111057023,
0.0231827609,
0.0412773751,
0.0096179824,
0.0537826531,
-0.0503670275,
0.0022525496,
0.0674008653,
0.02386689,
-0.0512535125,
-0.0228556227,
0.0256272275,
0.076197356,
0.0067762863,
-0.0013321678,
-0.0522326492,
-0.0404482335,
-0.0342663899,
0.0552405715,
0.0237759203,
0.009669764,
-0.0123424251,
-0.0722170025,
0.0704519078,
0.0316971205,
-0.0573904701,
-0.0598836206,
-0.0269441362,
-0.0059741098,
-0.0155995777,
-0.0224252976,
0.0035231076,
0.0080383848,
0.0231666397,
0.0208100341,
0.0170969106,
-0.0507974885,
-0.0194309801,
-0.0316514261,
0.0272660628,
0.0711633638,
0.024701843,
-0.0026825471,
-0.021666158,
-0.0590720885,
0.0479426272,
0.0018118561,
-0.0246239007,
0.0802803561,
-0.0032026009,
-0.0352602452,
-0.0076659848,
0.0718417019,
-0.0181904417,
-0.000425822,
0.0247962084,
0.0129909506,
0.0100364722,
-0.0197643843,
-0.0904048011,
0.0333287604,
0.0217862874,
0.0415027365,
0.0496143922,
-0.0158979464,
-0.0413316078,
-0.0347693488,
0.0262933671,
-0.1173493192,
-0.0320509039,
-0.0112887602,
-0.0094293598,
-0.0401851647,
-0.0767150372,
-0.0046113781,
0.0431528017,
0.0303753298,
0.0261377487,
-0.0191105604,
-0.0242862199,
0.0325978063,
-0.0492766984,
0.0452781506,
-0.0204041414,
-0.0156399962,
-0.0624628961,
-0.0363915898,
0.0615730621,
-0.0116140312,
-0.0506883673,
0.0407513157,
-0.0226307884,
-0.0156039242,
-0.055970151,
0.0739987493,
0.0131230019,
0.0248111486,
0.0284421258,
-0.0230477136,
0.0352181159,
0.0685011297,
0.0059636412,
-0.0287938118,
-0.0007586959,
0.0352572128,
-0.0258939378,
-0.0160790831,
-0.0224371981,
0.0057137785,
-0.0221783072,
0.0262094494,
0.010971575,
-0.0263521131,
0.0000962015,
0.0367723964,
-0.0038703009,
-0.0853858665,
0.0071782991,
-0.0101651568,
-0.0175351519,
-0.0120578036,
-0.0021629059,
-0.0389443338,
0.013954509,
0.0202637725,
0.0238386709,
-0.0117550278,
-0.0059866444,
-0.0047714533,
0.0149959661,
-0.0166479032,
0.0241643079,
0.0692947432,
-0.0216784105,
0.0142413126,
0.0064028832,
0.0004455029,
-0.0252117924,
-0.018900238,
0.0536304191,
0.0046652621,
0.0461964384,
0.0271482412,
-0.0064600427,
-0.0063097696,
0.0453437492,
-0.024616925,
-0.002006121,
-0.0527263768,
0.0542272776,
0.0350424163,
0.0239775181,
0.0257079788,
-0.0413932353,
-0.0159898475,
0.0094743222,
0.0386052467,
-0.0150710009,
0.0082937637,
0.0500062928,
0.0081067411,
0.0160553642,
-0.0397672392,
0.0716879293,
0.0286999829,
0.0249435883,
-0.0343875214,
-0.0341012441,
-0.0526843779,
0.0134989787,
-0.059352681,
-0.0387056135,
0.0213728901,
0.0294998754,
-0.0483123809,
-0.0487662181,
0.027951641,
0.0191128552,
-0.0131637128,
0.0332355984,
0.0567144342,
0.0159969833,
-0.0251774807,
-0.0069315326,
-0.0147952074,
0.0148560833,
-0.0432119854,
-0.0223188829,
-0.0354030244,
-5.185124316e-33,
-0.0339655578,
-0.0638026819,
0.0106571959,
-0.0127771264,
-0.0237593986,
-0.0276197009,
-0.0547721311,
0.0025924104,
0.0409047268,
0.0232869275,
0.0102183344,
-0.0802541152,
0.00101975,
0.0359830223,
0.0056307879,
0.0121660428,
0.0528882407,
0.0040345374,
-0.0506140888,
0.0371999778,
0.0120007964,
-0.0007996471,
-0.0030799827,
-0.085696958,
0.0054881792,
0.0083824089,
-0.0187566616,
-0.0111121228,
0.0261579361,
0.0531201139,
-0.0222787168,
0.0036893059,
-0.0086915856,
-0.0372132882,
-0.0279949699,
0.0115558393,
-0.0904556438,
-0.0171419438,
0.0003547161,
0.0082625952,
-0.0458879545,
-0.0282597821,
0.0266418923,
-0.0268654525,
-0.0031645121,
-0.0254909471,
0.0628855899,
-0.0126567269,
0.0031840312,
0.0076492382,
-0.0264556464,
0.0118175587,
-0.0574862584,
-0.0075143725,
0.0412158221,
0.0310891401,
0.0269570798,
0.053105779,
-0.0058699227,
0.0587543286,
0.0626476929,
-0.0114838537,
0.0824403465,
0.0516310558,
0.0332787335,
0.0466342494,
0.0186585486,
-0.0028601969,
-0.01220157,
-0.0024015615,
0.020879399,
0.0796548799,
0.0504456908,
0.086997658,
0.031620089,
0.0014559292,
-0.0177944824,
0.0879316702,
-0.0857790932,
0.0089984573,
0.0199667215,
0.0093744909,
-0.0326054581,
0.0216095932,
-0.0409753434,
-0.006176176,
-0.0363577008,
-0.0279479194,
0.0251477081,
-0.0008288107,
-0.072505556,
0.0135012427,
0.0169262011,
-0.007762826,
-0.0054661268,
-0.04198955,
-0.0258688014,
0.0452942289,
-0.0281808581,
-0.0727373511,
-0.0078286817,
-0.0180101153,
0.044225499,
0.0168380644,
0.0217741001,
-0.0033980331,
0.0471931361,
0.0021841978,
-0.0073681227,
-0.0131645938,
-0.0190659668,
-0.0177516043,
-0.0237475727,
-0.0285816155,
0.0032482015,
-0.0014076147,
-0.0893735886,
-0.0029593606,
-0.0195450839,
0.0463075675,
-0.0370180011,
-0.0148941027,
0.0114933727,
0.0405507088,
-0.0402998626,
-0.0165869053,
-0.0013019713,
-0.0287431367,
0.0210709348,
-0.076986894,
-0.0302320737,
-0.0084245838,
2.389e-7,
0.0325550027,
0.0391793251,
0.0560964867,
0.0053465888,
0.0124152396,
0.0605937541,
-0.033502616,
-0.0249647181,
-0.0015393447,
-0.0209086724,
0.0341957137,
0.0085966131,
0.0220634192,
0.0102093918,
-0.0421338305,
-0.0380976461,
-0.0241904631,
0.0140652452,
-0.0085547976,
-0.0348151773,
0.0414778665,
0.0018292423,
-0.0168287307,
-0.0356940441,
0.0573160946,
-0.0169133265,
0.081577152,
-0.048095718,
0.0271305591,
0.0035771606,
0.0002281956,
0.0508585498,
-0.0253385603,
0.0180813372,
-0.0168138687,
-0.0189951565,
0.057622429,
0.0401342809,
-0.0139047075,
-0.0289026666,
-0.0122736599,
0.0737109929,
0.0289797094,
-0.0122526428,
0.0190716013,
-0.0869361013,
-0.0392620042,
-0.0082547879,
-0.0379999056,
-0.0040179677,
0.0387902595,
-0.0608278885,
-0.0603038184,
0.0381059758,
0.0215666499,
0.0318696685,
-0.0273945183,
-0.0274074581,
-0.0192426722,
-0.0038597486,
-0.016022712,
-0.0116236061,
-0.0563511662,
-0.0140385358,
-0.0094262902,
0.0131357014,
-0.0318577699,
1.812148749e-34,
0.0544057041,
-0.011243728,
0.006699827,
0.0136743886,
0.0472013913,
-0.0060093538,
0.0133036273,
-0.0050080954,
0.0398729742,
-0.0452738293,
-0.0142721888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10864v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10864v2 | Divide & Bind Your Attention for Improved Generative Semantic Nursing | 2023-07-20T13:33:28 | 2023-10-09T07:20:00 | Yumeng Li, Margret Keuper, Dan Zhang, Anna Khoreva | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Emerging large-scale text-to-image generative models, e.g., Stable Diffusion
(SD), have exhibited overwhelming results with high fidelity. Despite the
magnificent progress, current state-of-the-art models still struggle to
generate images fully adhering to the input prompt. Prior work, Attend &
Excite, has introduced the concept of Generative Semantic Nursing (GSN), aiming
to optimize cross-attention during inference time to better incorporate the
semantics. It demonstrates promising results in generating simple prompts,
e.g., ``a cat and a dog''. However, its efficacy declines when dealing with
more complex prompts, and it does not explicitly address the problem of
improper attribute binding. To address the challenges posed by complex prompts
or scenarios involving multiple entities and to achieve improved attribute
binding, we propose Divide & Bind. We introduce two novel loss objectives for
GSN: a novel attendance loss and a binding loss. Our approach stands out in its
ability to faithfully synthesize desired objects with improved attribute
alignment from complex prompts and exhibits superior performance across
multiple evaluation benchmarks. | [
0.0247312188,
0.0532008894,
0.0119911674,
0.0194472503,
-0.0212328415,
-0.0103085935,
0.0355096981,
0.0003557626,
0.0062320386,
0.0266143233,
-0.0066183018,
-0.0673696846,
0.0107606258,
0.0065401895,
0.0355216227,
-0.0927219987,
0.0323020518,
0.0141419778,
-0.05358449,
-0.0110164899,
-0.0012958163,
0.0226355754,
-0.0078817159,
0.0319114588,
-0.0769169927,
-0.0307309385,
-0.0005463862,
0.0191214327,
0.0480648614,
-0.0251271911,
-0.0319657102,
0.0550459921,
-0.0006967721,
0.004423582,
0.0000021439,
-0.0166256838,
-0.000621215,
0.0289861467,
0.0018496264,
-0.0374468677,
0.0693712607,
-0.0205697231,
-0.014302982,
-0.003466143,
0.0056175878,
-0.0186579917,
0.0713876262,
0.052777797,
0.0618583933,
0.0397966094,
-0.0209462438,
-0.0048540002,
0.0154433744,
-0.0717909634,
0.0613617525,
-0.0590204038,
0.0170194507,
-0.0131626055,
-0.003684182,
-0.025385052,
-0.054242745,
0.0704709217,
0.0393385962,
0.0041871467,
0.053960938,
0.0989456624,
0.021071801,
-0.0231114924,
-0.0059028929,
0.0663812086,
-0.0284836199,
0.0433078259,
0.0150744049,
-0.0283806212,
0.0068714097,
0.0324865542,
-0.0284683295,
0.0070327879,
0.001047191,
0.0272517875,
-0.0326483399,
0.0509383269,
0.0040231096,
-0.0184659567,
0.0142855216,
-0.0650112033,
0.0305275787,
-0.0014530788,
-0.0124732144,
0.0443295278,
-0.0535667017,
-0.0760617405,
0.0463106334,
0.0155355781,
-0.0088679418,
0.0253167953,
-0.0709673166,
-0.0410084911,
0.0136125814,
-0.0059444397,
0.0259543657,
0.0038784512,
-0.048686821,
0.0515796542,
-0.0334393978,
0.0036855594,
-0.0461880937,
0.0235208515,
-0.0463581271,
0.0118727135,
-0.0057028225,
-0.0009046865,
-0.0617808178,
-0.0063973344,
-0.0528967604,
-0.049838759,
-0.0474927798,
-0.0136950426,
-0.0057813264,
-0.0243761465,
0.0576392077,
0.0630361885,
-0.0694309548,
0.0004641912,
-0.0379286408,
0.0193932708,
-0.0416692346,
0.0024842152,
0.0325872898,
-0.0242855847,
-0.020964846,
0.0180890467,
0.0279197022,
-0.0152275423,
-0.0190622993,
0.0839651227,
-0.0516598299,
-0.0158204529,
-0.0392499119,
-0.0396792479,
-0.0607265793,
-0.0688737854,
0.0380620845,
-0.049318172,
0.0572306365,
-0.0350612216,
-0.0037082091,
-0.1024319157,
0.0160385221,
0.0144542782,
-0.0189796723,
0.0469447635,
-0.0161604472,
-0.0001724908,
0.0172414221,
0.0152177997,
0.0216791574,
0.0357308686,
0.0520406738,
0.0448156223,
-0.0357388817,
-0.0029891811,
-0.0099883443,
0.0029599147,
0.0534703918,
-0.004728592,
0.0074955304,
-0.0162462872,
0.0085319988,
0.0723007545,
0.0346396342,
0.084768258,
-0.0267897956,
-0.0228333157,
0.0563669764,
0.0456793904,
-0.0003308975,
0.0055367039,
0.0579146929,
-0.0227461271,
-0.0594976805,
-0.0040077358,
-0.0325628296,
0.058403302,
0.0462132357,
-0.0065787695,
0.0492218435,
0.0428697765,
-0.0339620747,
-0.0639714673,
0.0120290574,
-0.0067930301,
-0.0119665898,
-0.015177208,
0.0267924536,
0.0497774035,
-0.0675113797,
0.0196646601,
0.0237829089,
-0.0475595035,
0.019826794,
-0.0473201983,
0.0128923515,
0.0863691643,
0.0255553294,
0.0148335258,
-0.0459841341,
0.0024264904,
0.0589663982,
0.080676049,
-0.0109369066,
0.0369855016,
0.0094010672,
-0.0379859172,
-0.0186185595,
0.0240022,
-0.01911496,
0.036659345,
-0.0066010701,
0.041834984,
0.0070659486,
-0.0049271598,
-0.0077446415,
0.0456680693,
-0.0173440836,
-0.0058414373,
-0.0030700637,
0.0176974665,
-0.0137745552,
-0.0028618907,
-0.002062246,
0.0226496551,
0.0003290448,
-0.0460898802,
0.0107308663,
-0.0114132334,
-0.0679066181,
-0.0382547304,
-0.0394803919,
-0.0552855134,
-0.0651461706,
-0.0504245386,
-0.0359332412,
-0.0237136967,
0.0073786974,
-0.0387063324,
-0.0040603839,
-0.0350779332,
-0.0144345099,
0.0596214309,
0.0044577988,
-0.0246614031,
0.0794138908,
-0.0505149662,
-0.0085860668,
-0.0294287149,
0.0500387996,
-0.0341328457,
-0.0533929616,
0.0121858176,
-0.0274402853,
0.0118659306,
0.0159706213,
-0.0259275865,
0.0260150507,
-0.057188049,
-0.0559775159,
-0.0323564596,
0.0100959633,
0.0104447436,
-0.0041702217,
-0.0104117068,
0.0220496412,
-0.0053783227,
-0.0042281738,
-0.0575190373,
0.0261269044,
-0.0096389838,
0.0088094715,
0.0344665423,
-0.0129636368,
0.0100071756,
-0.0164624751,
-0.0075710802,
0.0049471501,
0.0254988391,
0.0260706078,
0.0008687861,
-0.0471063666,
0.0287275333,
-0.0328682698,
0.0035998535,
0.0049110311,
0.0081959581,
0.0276591331,
-0.0021943692,
0.0687808916,
0.0672160983,
0.0038258503,
0.0159719586,
0.0126155103,
-0.0126807969,
-0.0310349353,
0.0289210174,
-0.0441930927,
0.012818303,
0.0333717428,
-0.0343800485,
-0.0205309391,
0.0781534985,
0.0213746987,
-0.0037616207,
-0.0832258463,
0.022021303,
0.0079915803,
-0.0301330406,
-0.0340720788,
0.040723674,
-0.0083357692,
-0.0026214393,
-0.0442065783,
-0.0305504855,
0.0626877919,
-0.0247942023,
0.0012119077,
-0.0288221315,
0.0203412343,
0.0170854032,
0.0316871889,
-0.0012564547,
0.0423492528,
0.0383632854,
-0.0123860613,
-0.0567796491,
0.012351471,
-0.0110915117,
-0.0267043989,
0.0362697281,
0.010505639,
0.014020144,
-0.0113166757,
-0.0233592261,
-0.0505495183,
-0.0155860567,
0.0197686311,
-0.0261890795,
-0.0269300863,
0.0275314506,
-0.0196976401,
0.0062904083,
-0.0134521164,
0.0114263585,
0.0167505611,
-0.0375056975,
-0.030200595,
0.0561752543,
0.0413565077,
0.0021634556,
-0.02981182,
-0.0541154295,
-0.0598305613,
0.081496194,
-0.008405068,
0.0048172879,
-0.0139411474,
0.0022531059,
-0.0215510689,
0.0310213342,
0.0030774802,
0.0099036908,
0.0815046132,
-0.0608515367,
-0.0182620734,
0.0470376611,
0.0134868529,
-0.0041784449,
0.0005859932,
0.0075381459,
0.0651611015,
-0.0243912637,
0.0151322633,
-0.0587154292,
-0.0399651974,
-0.0184619911,
0.0101767089,
0.0282193795,
-0.0180238541,
0.0067864666,
-0.0621804297,
0.0649487302,
-0.0089966189,
-0.056169115,
-0.0154655343,
-0.0046509551,
0.0184267703,
-0.0068675792,
0.0104004238,
-0.0194195267,
0.017258333,
0.0108973272,
0.0149738751,
0.0732136443,
-0.0265698731,
0.0083203698,
-0.0392610356,
0.0244499873,
0.0811042711,
0.0313548744,
0.0401006266,
-0.0994293541,
0.0118002938,
0.0002006575,
0.0095314886,
0.016490709,
0.0557896197,
-0.0047452198,
-0.0118873306,
-0.015177656,
0.0376838744,
-0.008282912,
-0.0340006538,
-0.0040214746,
0.0646474659,
0.0048048608,
-0.029915452,
-0.0667895898,
0.0346345454,
0.049982775,
0.0722579733,
0.0310457405,
-0.0632186607,
-0.0398546271,
-0.010267023,
0.0618037507,
-0.0526138321,
-0.0624225065,
0.0117124813,
-0.0466368645,
-0.0845324397,
-0.0805728957,
-0.0339770801,
0.0359180272,
0.0528863333,
-0.0222698785,
-0.0373672023,
0.0195672736,
0.0010792715,
-0.0203555897,
0.059746474,
-0.0269779693,
-0.0048780716,
-0.0347973965,
-0.0500533059,
0.0068257414,
-0.0120333694,
-0.0395405665,
0.0375739895,
-0.0804064721,
-0.0210762396,
-0.0039445069,
0.0496394038,
0.0137022948,
0.0194438603,
-0.0185148753,
0.0037872503,
0.0318132825,
0.0659030303,
0.0201169644,
0.0122715244,
-0.032512743,
0.0033967998,
0.0006280259,
0.0230933409,
-0.0258260034,
0.0640128329,
0.0136279054,
0.045760531,
0.0035446174,
0.0222248565,
-0.0159377009,
-0.0196021497,
0.0214897506,
-0.060221456,
0.0013709971,
-0.0609532483,
0.011444699,
0.0100589199,
-0.0018783115,
-0.0624044389,
-0.0316758789,
0.0351660922,
0.0078993924,
0.008868142,
-0.001115751,
0.0059366226,
0.0101061789,
-0.0515587144,
-0.0302025042,
0.0225450043,
0.0253265705,
0.0245355088,
0.0116125522,
-0.0123531288,
-0.0000469727,
-0.0199136753,
0.0354319699,
-0.0198832247,
0.025623275,
0.0242057033,
-0.0079979254,
-0.0373376906,
0.0272798799,
0.0053000874,
-0.0087510077,
-0.0475245938,
0.0620504692,
0.0117388284,
0.0176425911,
0.0310376137,
-0.0114414748,
-0.0073665422,
0.009909614,
0.0166898798,
0.0256464146,
-0.0228616577,
0.0328783467,
-0.0039835242,
0.03335502,
-0.0523821227,
0.060354203,
-0.042619396,
0.0562469848,
-0.021090243,
0.0000162615,
-0.030115597,
-0.0296453871,
-0.0242670979,
-0.0428778641,
0.0152135147,
0.032519538,
-0.0628232956,
-0.056892775,
0.0153761012,
0.0239830129,
-0.0208328478,
0.0231480207,
0.0759890452,
0.0034989733,
0.0083676102,
-0.025462063,
0.009765205,
0.0269554146,
0.0158452932,
-0.039492216,
0.0140894027,
-6.302390921e-33,
-0.0716176257,
-0.0198299661,
0.0333255008,
-0.0255391002,
-0.0395305902,
0.0022764413,
-0.0577140264,
-0.0130555546,
0.0048330245,
0.0429874212,
0.0093436474,
-0.0131459944,
0.0226458609,
0.0661193505,
-0.0159887187,
-0.0033221999,
0.0402005613,
0.0048171729,
-0.0215623062,
0.0584617667,
0.0193898939,
0.0077492693,
0.0350192152,
-0.0569460317,
-0.0077227773,
0.0115754884,
-0.0002464566,
-0.0139738293,
0.0230598394,
0.0353239737,
-0.02561602,
0.0321858153,
0.0024097443,
-0.0270739589,
-0.044428084,
0.0331171826,
-0.0904361308,
-0.0379667878,
-0.0116230072,
-0.0395031013,
-0.142832309,
-0.0474033132,
0.0432808138,
0.0044049388,
0.0123244748,
-0.0443366952,
0.0452849865,
-0.0174843613,
-0.0062751207,
0.0037712371,
-0.0681142509,
0.0077714138,
-0.016481014,
-0.0421898253,
-0.0032857612,
-0.0229867399,
0.01260693,
0.0198652633,
-0.0645815209,
0.0117886607,
0.019283535,
0.0278129093,
0.0312834792,
0.0325808041,
-0.0166958664,
0.0412782803,
0.0291702673,
0.0091141602,
-0.0398156494,
0.0224469099,
0.0019280385,
0.062682651,
0.0465835221,
0.0402471013,
0.0388072021,
0.0035114426,
-0.0683614761,
0.0365005806,
-0.0774473473,
0.0265765488,
0.030594537,
0.0000511764,
0.011777861,
-0.0038324804,
-0.0046458892,
-0.0163316708,
-0.0290179085,
-0.0256825462,
0.0267668534,
0.0360705778,
-0.032683786,
0.0346562713,
0.0256143603,
0.0217460673,
-0.0036359585,
-0.0356961936,
0.0308295954,
0.0381217524,
-0.0209336933,
0.0025310423,
-0.0188411921,
-0.0348133259,
0.0574777424,
0.0185445361,
0.0161652602,
0.0378591605,
0.0547393188,
-0.0433902033,
-0.0440919735,
-0.0052655032,
-0.0400380008,
0.0450301357,
-0.0087106088,
-0.0363618247,
0.0330272131,
-0.0230949484,
-0.0321509056,
0.0205524098,
0.0178892184,
0.0151434606,
-0.016379457,
0.0222090948,
0.0226651281,
0.015174997,
-0.0447892174,
0.0228705183,
-0.0411192067,
0.0074843471,
0.0521594286,
-0.0723253638,
-0.025937669,
0.030000573,
2.814e-7,
0.0691845715,
0.0000326653,
0.0306006819,
0.0210435409,
-0.0078714592,
-0.0087788953,
0.0002611216,
0.0622584857,
-0.0080507407,
-0.0458545275,
0.0042042029,
0.0513528362,
0.0462478958,
0.0121315969,
-0.0735304803,
0.0180010144,
-0.0098688388,
0.0536061712,
-0.0218537506,
-0.005642225,
0.0481612422,
0.0616392381,
-0.0170306824,
-0.018618308,
0.0474269018,
0.0101226764,
0.0707433671,
0.003106297,
0.0422924086,
0.0069283145,
-0.0278996844,
-0.0145270359,
0.0010875037,
0.0076143113,
-0.015673941,
-0.0369852893,
0.0826313123,
0.0487559587,
-0.0339104086,
-0.0137526654,
0.0100996438,
0.0223303121,
-0.0003669373,
-0.0056959544,
0.0721567944,
-0.0979864001,
-0.0122086005,
0.0125582051,
-0.0318514146,
0.0148209687,
0.0526065156,
-0.0040366603,
-0.0539252274,
0.0064947032,
0.0324720442,
0.0176638514,
-0.0382912308,
-0.0664895996,
-0.0251398794,
0.0004744436,
-0.0432343669,
-0.0548699796,
-0.0270189941,
-0.0177292302,
0.0014730321,
-0.041638732,
-0.0823320448,
2.287881645e-34,
0.0156545155,
0.01858682,
0.0226015057,
0.01439327,
0.0087694079,
0.0043686298,
-0.0067077116,
0.00143031,
0.0010108044,
-0.0534471683,
-0.0332980901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11785v1 | Adversarial Conversational Shaping for Intelligent Agents | 2023-07-20T12:44:47 | 2023-07-20T12:44:47 | Piotr Tarasiewicz, Sultan Kenjeyev, Ilana Sebag, Shehab Alshehabi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The recent emergence of deep learning methods has enabled the research
community to achieve state-of-the art results in several domains including
natural language processing. However, the current robocall system remains
unstable and inaccurate: text generator and chat-bots can be tedious and
misunderstand human-like dialogue. In this work, we study the performance of
two models able to enhance an intelligent conversational agent through
adversarial conversational shaping: a generative adversarial network with
policy gradient (GANPG) and a generative adversarial network with reward for
every generation step (REGS) based on the REGS model presented in Li et al.
[18] . This model is able to assign rewards to both partially and fully
generated text sequences. We discuss performance with different training
details : seq2seq [ 36] and transformers [37 ] in a reinforcement learning
framework. | [
0.0659373254,
0.0772003755,
-0.0078082155,
-0.0257812254,
-0.0341574997,
-0.0142243616,
0.0211610179,
-0.0140933208,
-0.0217180569,
-0.0215096809,
-0.0146836657,
-0.0371586196,
-0.0188095663,
0.0500116013,
0.0244155359,
-0.0753822997,
0.0381118394,
-0.0082935225,
0.0281575564,
0.0053367261,
0.0078254323,
-0.0027584017,
-0.0320643298,
0.0571754538,
-0.0471040085,
-0.0053472505,
-0.0274544172,
0.0035385936,
0.0145563604,
-0.0106744412,
0.036642883,
0.0092400601,
-0.0018335254,
0.0668545365,
0.0000021301,
-0.0133306626,
0.002556596,
-0.0125392824,
-0.0235201009,
-0.0111338319,
0.0311153773,
0.0158245359,
-0.0584120937,
0.0325320289,
-0.0466521308,
0.0024458384,
0.0326395147,
0.0751211941,
0.0489089042,
0.1235703602,
-0.004791359,
-0.0549890436,
0.0448193066,
-0.0544517152,
0.0351276509,
-0.0525575839,
-0.0196515154,
0.0002718164,
-0.0099505568,
-0.0052335667,
-0.0031798722,
0.0121781742,
0.0362740941,
-0.0607452206,
0.0031691433,
0.0307179224,
-0.0069257226,
-0.0365453064,
-0.0030118311,
0.0604981668,
-0.0511018783,
0.0165175442,
0.0062017078,
-0.0015542894,
0.0319455117,
-0.0402246416,
-0.0232050773,
0.0248505697,
0.0159444306,
-0.0067487881,
-0.0384424739,
0.0172364023,
0.0113828285,
-0.0122208577,
-0.0223627985,
-0.0111774793,
0.0217835251,
-0.0196651276,
-0.0092729982,
-0.010572779,
-0.0089578768,
-0.0864516869,
0.0057779886,
0.0182474088,
-0.0736752152,
0.0116363782,
-0.0493052863,
-0.0193483457,
-0.0005554107,
0.0357552245,
-0.006939258,
0.0122969504,
0.0128774745,
0.0112722609,
-0.0250341743,
0.0497936718,
-0.0068745902,
0.0308916196,
-0.0200260226,
0.0012768296,
-0.0369086638,
-0.0218095835,
-0.0475855656,
0.0144472355,
-0.0474064574,
-0.0311823022,
-0.0697908774,
0.0360335819,
-0.0046179956,
0.0378183089,
-0.014040634,
0.0586954281,
-0.0705325454,
0.0041392031,
-0.0495281033,
-0.0179072395,
-0.0586818308,
0.020156702,
0.0753629357,
-0.0741116852,
-0.0064507606,
0.0281209368,
-0.0155313248,
0.0080273971,
0.0026798756,
0.1229149103,
-0.0209746379,
-0.0251769125,
-0.0080261575,
-0.0353679471,
-0.0281790178,
-0.0603908226,
0.0420373119,
-0.0129504725,
-0.01157811,
-0.0502654016,
-0.0341965705,
-0.0143093765,
-0.0027532966,
-0.0151489647,
0.0250535775,
0.0382456705,
0.059900362,
-0.0429695472,
0.0341838859,
0.0275586043,
-0.0080012893,
0.0394287147,
0.0344200768,
0.0704411641,
0.0141693549,
-0.002769843,
0.0450705513,
0.0049055666,
0.0303918235,
0.0062499419,
0.0428097732,
-0.0276587792,
-0.0147812841,
0.0476225391,
0.0290951114,
0.0367009342,
-0.0585419647,
0.0021056791,
0.0654652417,
0.0304176584,
-0.0142788952,
0.0499806181,
0.0291242171,
0.0540138707,
-0.0184576008,
0.0022075989,
-0.0408496261,
0.022173902,
0.0051178755,
0.0137655642,
0.0044713491,
0.0120456042,
-0.0356877297,
-0.0526212268,
0.0717022941,
-0.0194073841,
0.0374360383,
-0.0037529527,
0.0190572608,
0.0449525192,
-0.0875992253,
-0.0629832447,
-0.013786803,
-0.0288636275,
-0.0326562785,
-0.0356852747,
0.0179081727,
0.0131782861,
0.045449473,
-0.0237972736,
-0.0214779433,
-0.0438257381,
-0.043987643,
0.0671177879,
0.0096252961,
-0.0081867417,
0.0339044146,
-0.0346443765,
-0.0064540468,
-0.0405438319,
-0.0040858989,
0.0765402466,
0.0160034429,
0.0020200906,
0.0128869219,
0.0347404703,
0.0099227,
0.0192398932,
0.0047584539,
-0.041614756,
0.0403825007,
-0.0053972155,
0.0351621211,
0.014031752,
-0.020001458,
0.0136906104,
0.0148692122,
-0.0260352697,
-0.0519604944,
0.0189672653,
-0.0867249295,
-0.0512153432,
0.0097226026,
-0.0564790554,
-0.0194907896,
0.0481671095,
-0.0379119329,
-0.0450805314,
0.0466467217,
-0.0694230124,
0.0412832908,
-0.0033834097,
0.0133630345,
0.0490644686,
0.02352315,
-0.0245127454,
0.0275443755,
0.0154486764,
-0.0324653573,
0.0286150277,
0.0627841577,
-0.010042958,
-0.0504680201,
0.0285569821,
0.0169298723,
-0.0321389511,
-0.0130522894,
0.0366536453,
0.0183217544,
-0.0322238356,
-0.0346975438,
-0.0346351117,
-0.0048313276,
-0.0220114775,
-0.0141211348,
0.0151476664,
0.0185187645,
0.0009605941,
-0.0131459581,
-0.0851966515,
-0.0071208514,
0.0419530571,
-0.0323668458,
0.028309634,
0.012775817,
-0.0277131647,
-0.0585522614,
0.0241434034,
0.0421330705,
0.0137014566,
0.0222588181,
0.0033136951,
-0.0197509211,
-0.0328152776,
-0.0188088212,
0.0618187748,
-0.0262516066,
-0.0781561136,
0.0268193632,
0.0289872997,
0.050863497,
0.0853968039,
0.05367174,
0.0469713882,
-0.0224417038,
0.0264170412,
-0.0323948525,
0.0250184666,
-0.0419532545,
-0.0197645295,
-0.0477927811,
0.0017621811,
0.0378118902,
0.0421227142,
0.0425816625,
0.0384156369,
-0.038200371,
0.0355216488,
0.0419244207,
-0.0965375677,
0.0126099456,
0.0101479562,
-0.0262886323,
-0.0089572873,
-0.0284825489,
-0.0450463593,
0.0649857,
-0.0041976138,
-0.032175377,
-0.0481484197,
-0.0295306928,
0.0287116803,
0.0191823617,
0.0204784647,
0.0276817828,
0.0121253068,
-0.0201205369,
-0.0411073081,
-0.0141852582,
0.0289047472,
-0.0166680515,
-0.0136257801,
-0.0322283767,
-0.0084699206,
-0.0000010129,
-0.0442142524,
-0.0909123421,
-0.0145361004,
0.0190053843,
0.022970343,
0.0755878612,
-0.0569745451,
-0.0502092242,
-0.0270723104,
0.0083422242,
0.0342666246,
-0.0106550734,
-0.0085363388,
-0.0409828722,
0.0221146215,
0.0722718537,
0.0143030472,
0.0060799597,
0.0166852772,
0.0770709589,
0.0237443596,
-0.0101302788,
0.012872031,
-0.0174607486,
-0.0210918579,
-0.0183059089,
-0.040684782,
0.0055704811,
0.0298532266,
0.0521237403,
-0.0262193829,
-0.0192596987,
0.0830338001,
0.0097066872,
-0.0073996554,
0.0158530027,
0.0044950671,
0.0474995822,
-0.0062399884,
0.0211381223,
-0.0730927661,
-0.0286196377,
0.0066534705,
0.0302220006,
-0.0220350064,
0.0095832665,
-0.0024285752,
-0.1065997183,
0.0275285672,
-0.0133647518,
-0.0510018505,
-0.0421557762,
-0.0032422843,
-0.0210352335,
0.0116009349,
0.0344807208,
-0.0115155596,
0.0169733483,
-0.0032685951,
0.0244526248,
-0.0262217671,
-0.0033815899,
-0.0376928262,
-0.039556995,
0.0593510233,
0.1452814937,
0.0434666201,
0.0259437319,
0.0154776135,
0.0184386317,
0.0475309975,
0.0056894757,
0.0113872495,
0.0579936169,
-0.0222268496,
-0.0073404312,
-0.0212493483,
0.0542069413,
0.0058300286,
0.018814411,
0.0070775007,
-0.0145647051,
-0.0108519224,
-0.0038700881,
-0.0169404484,
0.043641787,
0.0593040884,
0.0577092357,
0.0131573947,
-0.0296790488,
-0.0748632029,
-0.0505516827,
0.0147640724,
-0.0838830173,
-0.0335426256,
-0.0002338673,
-0.0037201291,
-0.0176423248,
-0.0917533562,
-0.0824473724,
0.0074378666,
0.0016294444,
-0.015884703,
-0.0293052439,
-0.0129293483,
0.0046767211,
0.0041486565,
-0.04075481,
-0.0070508602,
0.0148181599,
-0.0441977531,
-0.0458881743,
-0.0032860634,
-0.0723928362,
-0.0103405118,
0.0342142656,
-0.0479484163,
-0.0558563508,
0.0010142599,
0.0400574654,
0.0135243973,
0.0593204498,
-0.0219690409,
-0.0224894173,
0.0455607697,
0.0415268168,
-0.0248685256,
-0.0046774405,
0.0724451691,
0.0677967966,
-0.0078284554,
0.0267271567,
-0.0417889729,
0.0683811679,
0.0079042651,
0.0147163998,
-0.0343828239,
0.0046115927,
0.0089032659,
-0.017218912,
0.00855429,
-0.0185485259,
0.0085789394,
0.0080414684,
0.029038569,
-0.0137750795,
0.0033800539,
-0.0503503159,
-0.0010201517,
0.0237087421,
-0.0046481714,
0.0242549274,
0.0207181796,
-0.0149396332,
0.0315163322,
-0.0084263124,
-0.011683926,
-0.0045127887,
0.0139003024,
-0.016911719,
0.009378395,
0.0225323066,
0.0273900088,
0.0009951891,
0.0245252438,
0.0098179234,
0.0513553582,
0.0386557952,
0.0091601508,
0.034526933,
0.0171229728,
-0.0831597,
-0.0521443263,
-0.0097521385,
0.0276297927,
0.0467979498,
0.0165675301,
0.044807639,
-0.0286714826,
0.0379517265,
0.0052594952,
0.0430115312,
-0.0060150442,
-0.0282601602,
0.0071478202,
-0.0094736535,
-0.0221822672,
-0.0146788564,
0.0567509867,
0.0230906438,
0.0559021942,
-0.0137165803,
0.006559927,
-0.0630259141,
-0.0495954789,
0.0371127352,
-0.0084001282,
0.0214360636,
-0.0105338013,
0.0024241905,
-0.0431428142,
-0.0569277592,
0.0275430623,
0.0443796068,
-0.0091777323,
0.0774371177,
0.0051596863,
-0.0461845659,
-0.015466243,
-0.0336031318,
0.0351124369,
-0.0151611669,
-0.0281774644,
-0.0214402173,
-6.13799069e-33,
-0.0231157709,
-0.003338506,
0.0059945607,
-0.024475554,
-0.0496669002,
-0.0325131081,
-0.0283302721,
-0.0290127583,
-0.0017639878,
0.0152384816,
-0.0248631723,
0.0221242402,
0.0161525887,
0.0605778657,
-0.0560921617,
-0.0358272418,
0.0921967775,
-0.0100386236,
-0.0372106023,
0.0547512434,
0.0238184519,
0.0296437666,
0.0175790992,
-0.0526428148,
0.0035728591,
-0.0207269564,
-0.0351973772,
-0.0056191008,
0.016315911,
0.0197645947,
-0.0022226288,
0.0047777682,
-0.0171347577,
-0.0586153679,
-0.0048788125,
0.0298285466,
-0.0661385357,
-0.0212142803,
-0.0150940409,
0.0278850794,
-0.0772933811,
-0.0451751612,
0.0165396165,
-0.0034192258,
0.0034190079,
0.0208318196,
0.0181827061,
0.017693866,
-0.02761597,
-0.0317374766,
-0.0779526904,
-0.0039181467,
-0.0391927883,
-0.0448927507,
-0.007898734,
0.0426615737,
0.0111891422,
-0.0213163216,
-0.0099024158,
0.0153226042,
-0.0069633625,
0.052973479,
0.0265645999,
0.047215648,
0.0159465,
0.0421835296,
0.0199971534,
0.0006903519,
-0.0472259,
-0.010900801,
-0.0148197738,
0.0278776232,
0.0365721248,
0.035212718,
0.0332213454,
-0.0290026665,
-0.0692211092,
0.0355041325,
0.0341555029,
0.04019868,
-0.0037668627,
0.0184434,
-0.0163687337,
0.0087038958,
-0.0472604297,
-0.0247653518,
0.0135427406,
-0.032831084,
0.0490301736,
0.0650099814,
0.0039291275,
-0.0375345573,
0.0092862435,
-0.0409863293,
0.0235330705,
0.016456252,
-0.0430401154,
-0.0126558132,
-0.0183103066,
-0.024964219,
-0.0409157798,
-0.007067258,
0.0943624154,
0.0369118713,
0.0118384426,
0.0009696768,
0.0154375657,
0.0186827313,
-0.0178707801,
0.0211603008,
-0.0351699591,
0.0981727168,
0.0100692157,
0.0201975796,
0.0040164702,
-0.0222147368,
-0.0470295697,
0.0162722711,
-0.0356695764,
0.0226254445,
-0.022580551,
-0.0270714127,
0.0029911301,
0.0013483071,
-0.0782903358,
0.0159651432,
-0.041218508,
0.0022506015,
0.0420493595,
-0.0871036053,
-0.026433751,
-0.0484360158,
2.869e-7,
-0.0511496253,
0.0370414294,
0.0645070598,
0.0462036096,
0.0285104327,
0.047777839,
0.0331800804,
0.0400532596,
-0.0219036415,
-0.0011502001,
-0.0066821021,
0.0017374944,
0.0348353572,
-0.0201945081,
-0.0736067072,
-0.022332659,
-0.0890203491,
0.0014171065,
-0.016474992,
-0.003353569,
0.0238304418,
0.0899269357,
0.0041678678,
-0.014107964,
0.0445836224,
0.0132638607,
0.0288923588,
-0.0225532111,
0.0064066085,
0.0052764979,
0.0726397038,
0.0084875608,
-0.0064662145,
-0.0179419294,
-0.0208062641,
0.0034919991,
-0.0065873689,
0.0503062233,
-0.0024447278,
-0.0560991056,
-0.0195666943,
0.0038924597,
0.0154549731,
0.0001277973,
0.036463961,
-0.0334861092,
-0.0145595968,
-0.0152423326,
-0.0401124544,
0.0052338848,
0.0083977859,
-0.0322112776,
-0.0305797681,
0.0003320375,
0.0246820208,
0.0308189541,
0.0415511765,
-0.0777638108,
0.009164921,
-0.0196237378,
-0.0399396047,
-0.0312685817,
-0.050392516,
0.0295883007,
0.0153632648,
-0.0150573337,
-0.0150750335,
2.223035912e-34,
0.0294450112,
0.0221377295,
-0.0066640256,
-0.0088139661,
0.0230490994,
0.0229898281,
0.0454982296,
0.0125525082,
0.0494278967,
-0.042181436,
-0.0474840477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10826v1 | Yelp Reviews and Food Types: A Comparative Analysis of Ratings, Sentiments, and Topics | 2023-07-20T12:41:35 | 2023-07-20T12:41:35 | Wenyu Liao, Yiqing Shi, Yujia Hu, Wei Quan | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study examines the relationship between Yelp reviews and food types,
investigating how ratings, sentiments, and topics vary across different types
of food. Specifically, we analyze how ratings and sentiments of reviews vary
across food types, cluster food types based on ratings and sentiments, infer
review topics using machine learning models, and compare topic distributions
among different food types. Our analyses reveal that some food types have
similar ratings, sentiments, and topics distributions, while others have
distinct patterns. We identify four clusters of food types based on ratings and
sentiments and find that reviewers tend to focus on different topics when
reviewing certain food types. These findings have important implications for
understanding user behavior and cultural influence on digital media platforms
and promoting cross-cultural understanding and appreciation. | [
0.0542173125,
0.052672673,
-0.0130505795,
-0.0326004736,
0.0121715963,
0.0112051209,
-0.0026706739,
0.0335145406,
-0.0006249031,
-0.0649177656,
-0.0472156815,
-0.0048326841,
0.0177734699,
0.0619601384,
-0.0082063992,
-0.0423885323,
-0.0064553106,
0.0489742234,
0.0467778593,
0.0360125601,
0.024719188,
0.0131981801,
0.0409865975,
0.0087032644,
-0.007940379,
0.0083911847,
0.0261361692,
0.0216728523,
0.0064058648,
-0.0444333926,
0.0513470396,
0.0311666112,
-0.0294653568,
-0.006891923,
0.0000017378,
0.0182991512,
0.0053240163,
-0.0270261839,
0.0583836697,
0.0291659366,
0.0664780438,
0.0024243863,
0.0189750828,
0.0059959171,
-0.0290410575,
-0.0436542965,
0.0107383616,
0.0735742003,
-0.0022005821,
0.015237689,
-0.0145472139,
-0.0825592205,
-0.1261375397,
0.0377545618,
0.0211299546,
0.0342929959,
0.011100078,
-0.0245752968,
-0.0169447642,
-0.0196718797,
0.0081038345,
-0.0386495925,
0.0001215523,
0.0292671993,
0.0101800412,
0.0379595906,
0.0283906069,
-0.0428813323,
0.0296290927,
0.0577371679,
0.0249524005,
-0.019485103,
-0.0030365991,
0.0032520983,
-0.0282354634,
0.0119907763,
-0.0317211486,
0.0304774772,
-0.0085359924,
0.0390594117,
-0.0296537075,
0.0119559821,
0.048683878,
0.0288629625,
0.0312213991,
0.1123273745,
0.0016419316,
-0.0206114091,
-0.024325652,
0.030671712,
0.0443645082,
-0.0203178134,
0.0417075641,
-0.0254054144,
0.0092560276,
0.0051826634,
0.0470490195,
0.0308191348,
0.0261786878,
-0.0429082364,
0.0307548903,
0.0010206146,
-0.0348145477,
0.0035388714,
0.0701757148,
-0.0445965305,
0.0100314887,
0.0091679022,
-0.0398866348,
0.0771338269,
-0.0723741055,
0.036417298,
0.064984709,
0.0230324566,
0.0141385132,
-0.0045767161,
-0.0094729625,
0.0210043658,
-0.0071629467,
-0.0158051625,
-0.0055278293,
0.0556239262,
0.0390346311,
0.0400120541,
-0.0641188174,
0.064886339,
-0.0886592418,
0.0489414595,
-0.0139114922,
0.0617912225,
0.0448940992,
0.0052569732,
0.0373923704,
0.0229700021,
0.0194989257,
0.0017255617,
0.04980921,
-0.0273730066,
-0.0658124313,
-0.0208219271,
-0.0182311814,
-0.0326915607,
-0.0327972285,
-0.0602513514,
0.0048050326,
0.0261123665,
0.020728603,
0.0310133137,
-0.0022070464,
0.0418519937,
-0.0489280336,
0.0294570494,
0.0248561315,
0.0104296366,
0.0485540554,
0.0214078166,
0.0113414191,
0.0108870883,
-0.0516661368,
0.0613071881,
0.0663539171,
0.006189995,
-0.0056667398,
-0.0258326828,
-0.0570694841,
-0.0050242818,
-0.0285899658,
-0.0045058304,
-0.0353251994,
-0.0376640297,
-0.0098126102,
0.0645665154,
-0.0241982937,
0.0322527587,
0.0984732509,
0.0651133358,
-0.0353373252,
0.0843074843,
0.0087679857,
0.019993322,
0.0000297962,
-0.0015560106,
-0.0152606089,
0.0307193585,
-0.0190589949,
-0.0226286016,
0.01374951,
0.0107719824,
-0.0580010526,
-0.0614928938,
-0.031959597,
-0.0203360915,
0.0764785185,
-0.0201019738,
0.0347450674,
-0.0164412633,
-0.0083114645,
-0.0265725963,
0.0124142049,
-0.0425136536,
-0.0074155158,
0.0037171817,
0.1155738607,
0.1007550806,
-0.0216935705,
0.0274924841,
0.0369873643,
-0.0274553839,
-0.0379838422,
-0.0270431638,
0.0425372049,
-0.0066377069,
-0.0372510441,
0.007522657,
-0.0221216734,
-0.0443012454,
0.0542919599,
-0.0148306526,
0.0072754337,
0.0739163235,
-0.0234415065,
-0.0113316439,
-0.0174756758,
-0.0322185755,
0.0889269784,
0.0132022928,
0.0152944531,
0.0176919587,
0.0316471942,
0.0628518462,
0.0192454159,
-0.0058074994,
-0.0010555135,
-0.0039213728,
-0.0751480311,
0.054743316,
0.0401631407,
0.0473405309,
-0.0064358842,
-0.0581603982,
-0.0151711041,
0.0046686446,
0.0045030951,
-0.0023725098,
0.0289412625,
-0.0000256782,
0.0357242152,
0.0259079672,
-0.032701727,
-0.0128090568,
0.0064490903,
0.007339871,
0.0560622253,
-0.0410443917,
0.0072448342,
-0.0605321899,
-0.052647762,
0.0038195234,
0.0265881047,
-0.0159350876,
-0.0253089797,
0.006210275,
0.0332905129,
0.0486509129,
0.0189433377,
-0.0509361587,
0.0117443306,
-0.092302531,
-0.0112240827,
-0.0472560115,
0.0154265612,
0.0534697622,
-0.0148111675,
0.0257411189,
0.0020188892,
-0.0350359306,
-0.0276960433,
-0.0483777598,
0.0530641824,
-0.0038567092,
0.0083120326,
0.0406695455,
-0.0374178849,
-0.0120767979,
-0.0117656244,
0.0291988421,
-0.0084319981,
-0.0106910812,
-0.0298317894,
-0.0581061281,
-0.0343369544,
-0.0611155182,
0.0053533274,
-0.0160969794,
-0.0160351116,
0.0098076966,
0.013183265,
0.0002489669,
0.0198665448,
0.0173309445,
0.0470977463,
-0.0060707466,
-0.0147145847,
-0.0297911186,
-0.0255103763,
0.0458008721,
0.0042558606,
-0.0869798809,
0.0177059583,
0.0159073565,
0.0086705284,
0.0412917845,
-0.0174711794,
0.0392918028,
-0.0315272361,
-0.0021821053,
-0.0192653965,
0.026098147,
0.009704343,
0.0677321181,
0.011308373,
-0.0200610217,
0.0425718576,
0.0296279788,
0.0472611971,
-0.0635413751,
-0.0396455936,
-0.0074561816,
0.0073149432,
-0.024960639,
0.0473097339,
-0.036969848,
-0.0016353657,
0.0252164006,
-0.0125287762,
0.0120176785,
-0.0393118225,
0.074452959,
0.0301931426,
-0.0585516058,
0.0387322865,
0.0118105114,
0.003830824,
-0.0194635335,
-0.0239651781,
-0.0237151384,
0.0488319248,
-0.0088068126,
-0.0278310757,
0.0252899528,
-0.033569511,
-0.0253094491,
0.0055921259,
-0.0335120186,
0.0392764546,
0.0270250719,
0.0384663194,
-0.046677392,
-0.0193617903,
-0.0208076872,
0.0025295357,
0.0335427597,
-0.0128354924,
-0.0497230329,
0.0051133712,
0.0115374904,
0.0253517944,
-0.0163313858,
-0.0193448551,
0.0107644331,
-0.0148690343,
0.0168646052,
0.0258186497,
0.0660176203,
0.040449243,
-0.114249751,
-0.0238525551,
0.0092945546,
-0.041980356,
0.0258012302,
0.0219912101,
-0.0565929413,
0.0230918936,
-0.0266844463,
0.0160638113,
-0.0424718447,
0.031110229,
-0.0399111807,
-0.0535879098,
-0.0337622948,
-0.0137040028,
-0.0606948733,
-0.0592775159,
-0.0534141213,
-0.0250429008,
-0.0163918082,
0.0266307779,
-0.0389336944,
-0.0487978645,
0.0115417177,
-0.0169438459,
-0.0281156879,
-0.0067761005,
0.0391711071,
-0.0659963191,
0.0267487857,
0.0495457202,
0.0451530479,
-0.0124240005,
-0.0381419845,
-0.0162719842,
0.0286903139,
-0.0089429058,
-0.026597593,
0.0477623828,
-0.0366038047,
0.0333357789,
-0.0272649787,
0.0144817084,
-0.0374646001,
-0.0054815738,
0.0051664449,
0.0292359386,
0.0257724356,
-0.0789851695,
-0.0413191281,
0.0161998887,
0.0284123961,
0.0235673822,
0.0133996168,
-0.0476778001,
-0.0032830581,
-0.0469560027,
-0.0621016324,
0.0245616157,
0.0108736614,
0.0226293094,
-0.0491389483,
-0.0802299231,
-0.0400885642,
-0.008960872,
-0.0456084795,
0.0105929291,
0.0333334841,
0.0165562052,
0.0280928146,
0.0010843732,
-0.0052266316,
0.0453704484,
0.0363921374,
-0.0186259169,
-0.0399938226,
-0.0712578297,
0.0638120398,
-0.0246968959,
0.0084884642,
-0.0147849228,
-0.0448868535,
-0.0025127186,
-0.0307734143,
0.0712100565,
0.0160746444,
0.023080688,
-0.0119061144,
-0.042517364,
0.0120208664,
0.004710868,
-0.040834669,
-0.0688235238,
-0.0025563459,
0.0594089963,
0.0236727055,
-0.0034532461,
-0.041265741,
0.0133971591,
0.0013710546,
-0.0488144867,
-0.0736438185,
-0.0275941845,
0.0178550109,
-0.0315019935,
0.0078374865,
0.0213845894,
-0.0140940975,
-0.0013191132,
-0.030409025,
-0.0107671171,
-0.0246519614,
-0.0260777734,
-0.0331132635,
0.0338622481,
0.0281339809,
-0.0758528039,
0.0114294197,
-0.0047553238,
0.0611248463,
-0.0602991506,
0.0258011557,
0.0043984554,
0.014130801,
-0.0205423776,
0.0019477471,
-0.0035519537,
0.023811426,
0.0133210095,
-0.0270286333,
-0.0262696277,
0.0549137034,
-0.0230577905,
0.0132511957,
-0.0352474526,
0.0304368697,
-0.0031329712,
-0.0433816314,
0.0470619984,
-0.0358714424,
-0.0089597777,
-0.0856776536,
0.0394199193,
-0.0077270716,
-0.0078373775,
-0.0078188786,
0.045605246,
-0.009365784,
0.002908109,
0.051875405,
0.0066430233,
-0.0143856555,
0.0358027406,
0.0504081026,
-0.0444419235,
-0.0278951284,
0.0224421956,
-0.0492592044,
0.0021829407,
0.0494048819,
0.0311298333,
0.0385473669,
-0.0345983356,
-0.0098086474,
-0.0511660911,
-0.0439385958,
0.0270050205,
-0.0289995726,
0.0656128526,
-0.0108174626,
0.0214324687,
0.0662191585,
0.0092419777,
0.0075859004,
-0.0340827443,
-0.0242941063,
-0.015166739,
-0.0237480439,
-0.0096946107,
-6.374944637e-33,
0.0217259806,
-0.0700403228,
-0.0266911425,
0.0471655242,
0.0296734292,
-0.0160896834,
-0.0135759087,
0.0375522897,
0.0398488007,
0.0166389178,
-0.0014623617,
0.0194791649,
0.0061857603,
-0.0233950596,
0.0430905223,
-0.0562108085,
0.0614019632,
0.0101548443,
0.0071735312,
0.0280060805,
0.0190271046,
0.0265411399,
-0.0062734862,
-0.0389635414,
0.0273166616,
-0.0054277,
-0.0175667014,
-0.038744688,
0.0236506518,
0.0210160017,
-0.0384066701,
0.0653584152,
0.0333150886,
-0.0024255847,
0.0123569369,
0.0181736555,
-0.0455576852,
0.0373365879,
0.0131737096,
-0.0049236892,
0.0078062047,
-0.0279428195,
0.0419110693,
0.010778496,
-0.0175259728,
0.050485827,
0.0917013586,
0.015559529,
0.0258034151,
-0.0305519775,
-0.0108933803,
0.0090200519,
-0.0223419853,
0.0361457802,
0.011334586,
0.0244726203,
0.0131639028,
0.0525173694,
-0.0501014143,
0.0587765984,
-0.0539030693,
-0.005299055,
0.0145431412,
-0.0243715141,
-0.0270900428,
0.0318567492,
-0.0387617759,
0.0309464317,
-0.0105708987,
-0.0260202084,
0.0057168012,
0.0389632583,
-0.0389283188,
0.0317970663,
0.0092942342,
-0.0989737362,
-0.0010281873,
0.0291515999,
0.0669891387,
-0.06255126,
0.0225795973,
-0.0123774866,
-0.0009489617,
-0.0033778944,
0.0316411667,
-0.046542488,
-0.0588673055,
-0.0352840833,
-0.0107043982,
0.0195280928,
-0.0359308459,
-0.035822425,
-0.005574706,
-0.0231547654,
-0.0363339968,
0.0288369879,
-0.0365744643,
-0.0175550617,
0.0089493692,
-0.0282361656,
-0.0835571513,
-0.0073262472,
-0.0800423026,
0.0017819823,
-0.0004309485,
-0.0037126665,
0.0251216441,
0.036615897,
-0.0566961169,
-0.0255041979,
0.0119967712,
-0.0509051904,
0.0209713522,
-0.0113128964,
-0.0062340521,
0.0153879803,
-0.0003836597,
0.0591101162,
0.0343154222,
0.0933945775,
-0.0140287708,
-0.0362467803,
-0.0032519621,
-0.0057451036,
-0.0050272616,
-0.049964834,
-0.0146983443,
-0.0143340779,
-0.0111199683,
-0.0579192787,
-0.0116019351,
-0.0311856326,
2.536e-7,
0.0455004834,
0.068041794,
-0.0587903522,
-0.0668168515,
0.0151091348,
0.0335416757,
0.0142165972,
0.0354314968,
-0.0079405215,
0.0099881934,
0.0237694681,
0.0060637095,
-0.0361392908,
0.0894815177,
-0.0587674603,
0.0373744629,
-0.0749346614,
0.0299793798,
-0.0334263705,
0.0242462065,
-0.0313693509,
0.0283341929,
0.047026895,
0.0002631961,
-0.035475757,
0.0157521963,
0.0381846912,
-0.0553025454,
-0.0195460077,
-0.0081965523,
0.0258945897,
-0.0026375921,
0.0050764619,
-0.054990869,
-0.0339201726,
-0.0333283618,
0.0558448434,
-0.0114231398,
0.0276029836,
-0.0392280482,
0.0007349811,
0.006622972,
0.0055441102,
-0.0946334004,
0.0356301628,
-0.0245976243,
-0.0376156606,
-0.0255431775,
0.0153443255,
0.0051553338,
0.0554955117,
-0.0318541043,
0.0057101101,
0.014244169,
-0.0093010981,
-0.0193031859,
0.0059448066,
-0.0428070985,
0.0213197786,
0.0001396697,
0.0166981537,
-0.045596417,
-0.0072934991,
-0.0066371378,
-0.0320753939,
0.0185576826,
0.0124559589,
1.830552927e-34,
0.0464726128,
-0.0094731906,
-0.0111649856,
-0.0449618138,
-0.001383584,
-0.0035860678,
-0.0756480694,
-0.0321889147,
0.0158395804,
-0.0151439654,
0.0084558865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10814v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10814v1 | Cross-Corpus Multilingual Speech Emotion Recognition: Amharic vs. Other Languages | 2023-07-20T12:24:23 | 2023-07-20T12:24:23 | Ephrem Afele Retta, Richard Sutcliffe, Jabar Mahmood, Michael Abebe Berwo, Eiad Almekhlafi, Sajjad Ahmed Khan, Shehzad Ashraf Chaudhry, Mustafa Mhamed, Jun Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.NE, cs.SD, eess.AS | In a conventional Speech emotion recognition (SER) task, a classifier for a
given language is trained on a pre-existing dataset for that same language.
However, where training data for a language does not exist, data from other
languages can be used instead. We experiment with cross-lingual and
multilingual SER, working with Amharic, English, German and URDU. For Amharic,
we use our own publicly-available Amharic Speech Emotion Dataset (ASED). For
English, German and Urdu we use the existing RAVDESS, EMO-DB and URDU datasets.
We followed previous research in mapping labels for all datasets to just two
classes, positive and negative. Thus we can compare performance on different
languages directly, and combine languages for training and testing. In
Experiment 1, monolingual SER trials were carried out using three classifiers,
AlexNet, VGGE (a proposed variant of VGG), and ResNet50. Results averaged for
the three models were very similar for ASED and RAVDESS, suggesting that
Amharic and English SER are equally difficult. Similarly, German SER is more
difficult, and Urdu SER is easier. In Experiment 2, we trained on one language
and tested on another, in both directions for each pair: Amharic<->German,
Amharic<->English, and Amharic<->Urdu. Results with Amharic as target suggested
that using English or German as source will give the best result. In Experiment
3, we trained on several non-Amharic languages and then tested on Amharic. The
best accuracy obtained was several percent greater than the best accuracy in
Experiment 2, suggesting that a better result can be obtained when using two or
three non-Amharic languages for training than when using just one non-Amharic
language. Overall, the results suggest that cross-lingual and multilingual
training can be an effective strategy for training a SER classifier when
resources for a language are scarce. | [
0.0062017534,
0.0321251042,
-0.0161075965,
0.0350677893,
-0.0246941298,
0.0461070277,
0.022032667,
-0.0619628653,
0.026168298,
-0.0136238234,
-0.0907869339,
-0.0522993244,
0.0174494516,
-0.040547736,
-0.0381702296,
-0.0582741238,
0.0249014404,
0.0186654367,
0.0357180908,
-0.0065432126,
0.0275471099,
0.0665335953,
-0.037985187,
0.0158191696,
-0.0518727377,
0.0368253924,
-0.0518239811,
-0.0138677405,
0.0351881459,
-0.016997138,
0.0168940462,
0.0205169506,
-0.000022319,
0.0232775267,
0.0000019923,
-0.0481682569,
-0.0231462084,
0.0015680274,
-0.014288025,
-0.0289181098,
0.0804474205,
0.00541793,
-0.0563528128,
0.0098795779,
-0.0212227628,
-0.0073079164,
0.0894689858,
0.051766973,
0.0261871703,
0.0535422042,
-0.0319031626,
-0.0453855582,
0.0012968722,
0.0026268105,
-0.0050276034,
0.0005713135,
0.0060573258,
0.0417592116,
0.0173954945,
-0.080652535,
-0.068003796,
-0.0092340345,
-0.0107117388,
-0.0021821081,
-0.0346323885,
-0.0252919309,
-0.0562606081,
-0.0819848627,
0.0257750265,
0.0140909534,
-0.0240505878,
0.0141930655,
-0.0048153359,
0.0107677197,
-0.0061930446,
0.0213404372,
0.0061283386,
0.0178377014,
-0.0254864134,
0.0140283341,
0.051137235,
0.0450008139,
-0.0147697693,
0.0208219737,
0.0070166565,
0.027032353,
-0.0206468701,
-0.0240844525,
0.0788562968,
-0.0022389295,
-0.0115352785,
0.0136747276,
0.0219498202,
-0.0300178248,
-0.0051163747,
0.0112954099,
-0.019230051,
-0.0704352334,
-0.0297221504,
-0.0650012046,
-0.0263060536,
0.0599350967,
-0.0694518164,
-0.0062389174,
-0.034621466,
0.0390155055,
0.0326161943,
-0.016424492,
-0.0508605316,
-0.033929266,
-0.0392798297,
0.0336765684,
0.0013752172,
0.0051016873,
-0.022119632,
0.0138566829,
-0.1269783378,
-0.0242996141,
-0.0436823443,
0.0060364413,
-0.0066910484,
-0.0619012862,
0.0114346789,
0.0274988562,
0.0152548281,
0.0319222286,
-0.0272529423,
0.0435927175,
-0.0432416387,
-0.1191212088,
0.057196565,
0.0013209527,
-0.0208854284,
0.0222845357,
0.0388456024,
0.0743633732,
-0.0228457674,
-0.0033149035,
-0.0823470354,
0.0376668833,
-0.0126514342,
-0.0621415228,
-0.0149262119,
-0.0290760733,
0.0763480812,
0.0472362004,
0.0034723382,
0.0190548319,
0.0017453049,
-0.0519590676,
0.0188146401,
0.0631069914,
0.0330540165,
-0.0123258363,
0.0729458705,
0.0117637385,
0.0198868513,
0.046093028,
0.0043002032,
0.0096695013,
0.0354274921,
-0.022771731,
0.0092315422,
0.0149109028,
-0.010104958,
-0.0244376659,
0.0131592713,
-0.0314368308,
0.021234585,
-0.0006345523,
0.0092657832,
0.0021204981,
-0.0217013061,
-0.005168193,
-0.0167651083,
0.0395764932,
-0.0127627701,
0.0132362926,
-0.0211264119,
0.0171166789,
0.0348131321,
-0.0039314162,
0.0259772781,
0.0211074892,
-0.0034046264,
-0.0059983707,
0.0337534472,
0.0191265885,
-0.036487449,
-0.0335977599,
-0.0283113234,
-0.0319235101,
0.0067267241,
0.0278171469,
0.0775503218,
-0.0263429768,
-0.0077993348,
-0.0033407446,
0.0660566911,
-0.0874575153,
0.0028935913,
-0.03329584,
-0.027115874,
-0.0147710862,
-0.0595096014,
-0.0247307606,
-0.0139024155,
-0.0291942004,
-0.0298992787,
0.0145170949,
0.0333686322,
-0.0135947987,
0.0430666916,
-0.0836176053,
0.0192255192,
0.0390851796,
-0.0250619221,
0.0551161692,
-0.0382971764,
0.0841265991,
-0.0242337566,
0.0227740612,
0.0031321081,
-0.0171198882,
-0.0536496341,
0.0165693983,
-0.0083567603,
0.0025816138,
0.0750508383,
0.0162644275,
-0.0401292108,
-0.0311922953,
0.0100979256,
0.0048791263,
0.0099486941,
0.0443717502,
-0.0084140655,
-0.0247747228,
0.0216703992,
-0.040088661,
0.0353123918,
0.0124096684,
-0.0261958819,
-0.0524318554,
0.0965053737,
0.0126043223,
0.0596335419,
-0.0303498507,
0.0508056581,
-0.0312725045,
0.0193398986,
0.0335254967,
0.0177962314,
0.0281036571,
0.0185389481,
-0.015954379,
-0.0371286422,
0.0667859167,
0.0084297284,
-0.0249709692,
0.0689840317,
-0.0156166377,
-0.0144874891,
0.0080117872,
-0.0263863914,
-0.0283678249,
-0.0336231515,
-0.0523402914,
-0.0226492789,
0.0153452968,
0.0199232344,
-0.0573328435,
0.0268547926,
-0.0410258733,
0.0010519129,
-0.0403036214,
-0.0165672842,
0.022847008,
-0.0153176384,
-0.0245729536,
-0.0140526975,
0.0123444488,
-0.03126375,
-0.0009806787,
0.0124163497,
0.0374377742,
-0.0074621062,
-0.0646541342,
0.0212902464,
-0.0149028739,
-0.0247399341,
0.0252822209,
-0.0256166663,
-0.0784811378,
-0.009605784,
0.0102495681,
-0.0197658967,
0.0065647466,
-0.0348928571,
0.0323236585,
0.0299018752,
0.0004132943,
-0.0265478957,
0.0345317721,
0.0118050938,
0.0133532202,
0.0027760419,
-0.0446616076,
-0.0829299763,
0.0306841098,
0.0118979504,
-0.0019981023,
-0.0128942681,
-0.0341983698,
-0.0270267222,
-0.0534333289,
0.0005016473,
-0.0252205059,
0.0162209384,
0.0272057299,
0.0212169476,
-0.0199440476,
0.015883131,
0.0132071357,
-0.0505819209,
-0.064237304,
0.0107489359,
-0.0217985865,
0.0124052996,
-0.0558863245,
0.0160539709,
-0.015595967,
-0.0034165415,
-0.0159865022,
-0.0346627012,
0.0161945131,
-0.0506019071,
-0.0156506412,
-0.0244520437,
-0.0384581126,
-0.0255919397,
-0.0294735841,
-0.004422389,
0.0134575423,
-0.0293625016,
0.0007389738,
0.0121804466,
-0.0021594511,
0.007554308,
0.0221995842,
0.0429470874,
-0.0442139693,
-0.0063999379,
0.0089176064,
0.0641876906,
0.0104452204,
0.0107710687,
0.0002256692,
0.0170520637,
0.0100474479,
0.0144390194,
-0.0001690528,
0.015505489,
-0.0012917928,
-0.0244673844,
0.023856068,
0.0306358747,
0.0185239073,
-0.0291935354,
-0.0576278903,
-0.0152845597,
0.0307111964,
0.0886548832,
0.0671313033,
0.0336116664,
-0.012147354,
0.0022009939,
-0.0782871097,
-0.0197902396,
-0.0029470972,
0.014730528,
-0.0770932809,
0.0055193827,
0.0302441474,
0.004138933,
-0.018850565,
0.0040035755,
-0.001866271,
-0.0970003754,
0.01151763,
0.0049073109,
-0.024573328,
-0.0286858026,
-0.0400073007,
-0.0011597034,
-0.0270027574,
-0.0076073119,
-0.0640529022,
0.0097373333,
-0.0363530777,
0.082464762,
0.0087828357,
-0.0930268988,
-0.0065110871,
-0.0098720388,
0.049013935,
-0.0133844819,
0.0548589192,
-0.0400653817,
-0.0270785596,
-0.009400961,
-0.0191301685,
-0.0227766428,
-0.0459774099,
0.0088975895,
0.0319972895,
-0.0333799832,
-0.0181579664,
-0.0104270866,
-0.0177501924,
0.0267893802,
-0.0276895333,
0.042136047,
-0.0267476644,
0.0066800052,
-0.0053618499,
0.023109328,
0.0131841637,
0.0253909826,
-0.0163148418,
-0.0444885008,
-0.0119100166,
0.0322765671,
0.0306794588,
-0.0138227269,
-0.0185088888,
0.0492037013,
-0.0412520878,
-0.0661403537,
-0.0163347386,
-0.0497630909,
-0.0182016175,
-0.0034946913,
0.0265930258,
0.0013006306,
-0.005237347,
0.0340504162,
-0.0227948911,
-0.0016779202,
0.0680580661,
0.0150944423,
-0.0201193411,
-0.0192154814,
0.0314892158,
-0.0661506429,
0.0055412343,
-0.0375422873,
0.0088675357,
-0.0633951575,
0.058726564,
-0.0252934638,
0.0081295772,
0.0059333905,
0.0232376643,
-0.0354033448,
0.0506804809,
0.0002892641,
-0.0123919873,
-0.0103090201,
0.0829319283,
0.041797962,
-0.0418171398,
0.0011415383,
-0.0231121238,
0.0510994121,
0.0213522203,
-0.0521318279,
-0.0198878869,
0.0053872452,
-0.0393727496,
0.0210008491,
0.0255578421,
-0.0445943475,
-0.058983881,
-0.0402540602,
0.000895736,
0.0225673001,
0.0189671665,
-0.0189971011,
-0.0426368117,
0.0232049152,
0.0369429775,
-0.0440367796,
-0.0180212744,
0.0027761613,
-0.0626453832,
0.0366973616,
0.097070016,
0.0655349866,
0.0668893084,
-0.005820856,
0.0578963086,
-0.0055668494,
-0.0211195759,
0.034010347,
0.0014336287,
-0.045449391,
0.0334511362,
-0.0135824746,
0.0036054184,
0.0843118951,
0.0512242205,
0.0571427532,
0.0451394692,
-0.0109967757,
-0.003015555,
0.0459582955,
-0.0422521979,
0.0547159053,
-0.0226416178,
0.0350411236,
-0.031050276,
0.0176006593,
-0.0391400345,
-0.0102592651,
0.0219101906,
-0.0442668609,
-0.0181340799,
0.0245220587,
0.0181552749,
-0.0645956323,
0.0283813141,
-0.0134792915,
0.0222055521,
-0.026521109,
-0.0228580926,
0.0651966706,
-0.0762645751,
-0.011504801,
0.0195123106,
-0.0416354798,
-0.0409967639,
0.0049554179,
-0.05190292,
-0.0048924284,
-0.0066150599,
0.0329663604,
0.0333094783,
-0.0030755592,
0.0413690396,
-0.0399109609,
-0.0078279004,
-0.0604828335,
-0.031851016,
0.0552413203,
-5.363648112e-33,
0.0258141365,
0.0339169912,
-0.0587641634,
-0.0110975048,
-0.0147831347,
0.0147625757,
0.0040722569,
0.0317213535,
-0.0248315632,
0.0438283719,
-0.0101824189,
-0.0011971749,
0.0314947851,
-0.016648896,
0.0585735738,
-0.0147101562,
0.01572139,
0.0102033988,
0.0291440878,
0.0074091675,
0.0495986268,
0.0200154725,
0.0863220543,
-0.098622255,
0.0414101072,
-0.003853627,
-0.0103400219,
-0.0517044216,
0.0404052362,
0.0723555908,
-0.0140667344,
0.0466624908,
-0.0211409442,
0.0046264352,
0.0351155028,
-0.0174475126,
-0.0294463038,
-0.0022499629,
-0.0020985329,
0.0949372724,
-0.0224699676,
-0.0469881743,
-0.0127875945,
0.0171581712,
-0.0672899336,
0.0431896895,
0.0031006082,
-0.0215235148,
0.0346566103,
-0.0405093282,
-0.0380654074,
0.0357245207,
0.003993303,
-0.0191558786,
0.0734637231,
0.1178913414,
-0.0088038621,
-0.0206177458,
-0.0116505362,
0.0109498752,
0.0130203143,
0.0253728013,
0.0642434433,
0.0190475341,
-0.0313041881,
0.0335205197,
0.0532723255,
-0.0721039027,
0.0915631279,
0.0222655367,
0.0215758309,
-0.0213898271,
0.0060509071,
0.0735091195,
0.0115193082,
-0.0512745082,
-0.0329711623,
0.0452882759,
0.0608319826,
0.0060759573,
0.0142013403,
0.0191801544,
-0.0044166073,
-0.0158432648,
0.0363778397,
-0.0214749333,
-0.0002330011,
-0.0005862034,
0.0367437452,
-0.0447379611,
0.0350798257,
0.0337712243,
0.034541674,
0.011534214,
0.0013817779,
0.0153151238,
-0.0337791517,
0.0491486527,
0.009960358,
0.0118363416,
-0.0397399925,
-0.0251916461,
0.0098556625,
0.0236151405,
0.0643439591,
-0.0057130912,
0.0179417003,
0.061270345,
-0.0483547896,
0.0191715714,
0.0040390943,
0.0539536476,
0.0236618109,
0.0565959625,
-0.0354863331,
-0.0065140119,
-0.020123668,
-0.0074122916,
0.023726536,
0.0588503815,
0.0153149487,
-0.0115890801,
-0.0252704043,
-0.0084800571,
-0.0495027564,
0.0272839684,
-0.0163940415,
-0.030025607,
0.0114439651,
-0.018993238,
-0.0022291206,
0.0079366518,
2.811e-7,
-0.0409877226,
0.004600626,
0.0210970826,
-0.0327649526,
0.003183193,
0.0285758246,
-0.0368889906,
0.0120756822,
0.0133494856,
0.0465074591,
-0.0045569725,
-0.0544620119,
0.0899554566,
0.0676648095,
-0.0884137303,
-0.0472088158,
0.0057909354,
0.0190720297,
-0.0132982666,
0.047538504,
0.0184141994,
0.1071255505,
-0.0005552245,
0.0017460062,
-0.0430776477,
0.0192807075,
0.0139634721,
-0.0402346216,
-0.0074414588,
0.0192232877,
-0.0319724828,
-0.0159945432,
-0.021881368,
0.0267625246,
-0.0209789593,
-0.0158430059,
0.0277870391,
0.0218969658,
-0.0104396781,
-0.0479032956,
0.0324608833,
0.0594476834,
-0.041986946,
0.0069160722,
0.0156389587,
0.0238719508,
-0.0436342433,
-0.0002038267,
-0.0160033237,
0.0089676902,
0.0882277712,
-0.0329675637,
0.0022651267,
0.0270129349,
0.0201432556,
-0.0506188981,
-0.0413456894,
-0.010036313,
0.0004183505,
0.0218148567,
0.0002254589,
-0.0411926061,
0.0378825925,
0.0201559477,
0.0366584696,
-0.0183441322,
0.0004620225,
1.699063093e-34,
0.0187017079,
-0.0248726085,
-0.0039349827,
0.0172834024,
0.0250174608,
-0.0149723692,
-0.0411520936,
0.0203942154,
0.0204583965,
-0.0026764472,
-0.0111101484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10802v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10802v1 | Meta-Transformer: A Unified Framework for Multimodal Learning | 2023-07-20T12:10:29 | 2023-07-20T12:10:29 | Yiyuan Zhang, Kaixiong Gong, Kaipeng Zhang, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao, Wanli Ouyang, Xiangyu Yue | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | Multimodal learning aims to build models that can process and relate
information from multiple modalities. Despite years of development in this
field, it still remains challenging to design a unified network for processing
various modalities ($\textit{e.g.}$ natural language, 2D images, 3D point
clouds, audio, video, time series, tabular data) due to the inherent gaps among
them. In this work, we propose a framework, named Meta-Transformer, that
leverages a $\textbf{frozen}$ encoder to perform multimodal perception without
any paired multimodal training data. In Meta-Transformer, the raw input data
from various modalities are mapped into a shared token space, allowing a
subsequent encoder with frozen parameters to extract high-level semantic
features of the input data. Composed of three main components: a unified data
tokenizer, a modality-shared encoder, and task-specific heads for downstream
tasks, Meta-Transformer is the first framework to perform unified learning
across 12 modalities with unpaired data. Experiments on different benchmarks
reveal that Meta-Transformer can handle a wide range of tasks including
fundamental perception (text, image, point cloud, audio, video), practical
application (X-Ray, infrared, hyperspectral, and IMU), and data mining (graph,
tabular, and time-series). Meta-Transformer indicates a promising future for
developing unified multimodal intelligence with transformers. Code will be
available at https://github.com/invictus717/MetaTransformer | [
-0.0079863956,
0.0602898709,
0.021783907,
0.0552600287,
-0.0087795444,
0.0058198879,
0.0282132253,
-0.0357796848,
-0.0504345372,
-0.0495695397,
-0.0892187729,
0.0251741856,
0.0150186205,
0.0669685155,
0.0072991787,
-0.0664537176,
0.0189479254,
0.005457025,
-0.0447505862,
0.0161380637,
0.0044851834,
0.0085193152,
-0.0475030988,
0.0359047838,
-0.0477473475,
0.0199992899,
-0.0403761454,
0.0131301126,
0.0254935548,
-0.0440155938,
-0.0102558276,
0.0216538329,
0.0327992402,
0.026933305,
0.0000021764,
-0.014786006,
0.0008281364,
-0.0431128368,
0.0429286398,
-0.0881073102,
0.039424058,
-0.059994638,
0.0251037627,
-0.0231681522,
-0.0436497144,
-0.0278473105,
0.0927070603,
0.0361217931,
0.0350769721,
0.0196455456,
-0.0383382812,
-0.0456637144,
0.0250637773,
0.0097497748,
0.0182247199,
-0.0065380596,
-0.0198300928,
-0.0200166609,
-0.012275124,
0.0014899482,
-0.0648449659,
0.0177691504,
0.0199569315,
0.0272720587,
0.0267524179,
0.0541130863,
0.0054628947,
-0.0494270474,
-0.0513975248,
0.1024711207,
-0.0502310321,
-0.00226085,
-0.0084290598,
0.003658928,
-0.0043490021,
-0.0028108892,
-0.0220778286,
0.0082107093,
-0.0184347034,
0.0078483457,
-0.0843609869,
0.010332929,
0.0276864525,
-0.0150636714,
-0.0197290741,
0.035466373,
-0.0085471487,
0.0255316719,
0.0287507586,
-0.0224890821,
-0.0215197075,
0.0010253991,
0.0055253911,
0.0118496185,
-0.0374703892,
-0.0423015878,
-0.0481345095,
-0.0401293486,
-0.0372703671,
0.0182202384,
0.0544512495,
0.0107825371,
-0.06453491,
0.0555882528,
-0.0399207361,
0.0023948157,
-0.0309131145,
0.0761382207,
-0.0280888639,
-0.0576367788,
-0.0505187288,
0.0154890474,
0.000584117,
-0.0153723639,
-0.0079547567,
-0.0265950561,
-0.0029193563,
0.0238014292,
-0.00719791,
0.0281690173,
-0.0234631933,
0.0197361521,
-0.0257096905,
-0.0228447653,
-0.0048638005,
0.0707668811,
0.002532603,
0.0572708175,
-0.0201373789,
-0.0275315084,
0.0196048338,
0.0446830653,
0.0276702009,
-0.0116344467,
0.0241508354,
0.0966605097,
-0.032590542,
-0.0356405191,
-0.0056130663,
-0.0244058371,
-0.0001861196,
-0.0159687288,
0.084689945,
-0.0435318202,
0.0393634886,
-0.0124679552,
0.0255893469,
-0.0212215167,
-0.0135537442,
-0.0251060631,
0.0015148704,
0.1166250706,
-0.0234063715,
-0.0298515037,
0.015997434,
-0.0053068493,
-0.0350289829,
0.0362472087,
0.0587047748,
0.0470778719,
-0.0050090309,
-0.0186583214,
0.0134653328,
0.0093978019,
-0.0111571988,
0.0077048293,
-0.0211335514,
-0.0382192209,
0.0025420948,
0.0137574626,
0.0294062663,
0.0015920684,
-0.0157046933,
-0.0415393896,
0.0404566191,
0.0109618371,
-0.00351246,
0.008628251,
0.0210020691,
-0.0421419255,
-0.0158167165,
-0.0425998457,
-0.0383156016,
0.0978379175,
-0.0015748774,
-0.0254015252,
-0.0109858233,
0.0493592508,
-0.0383170359,
-0.0365664586,
0.0296612997,
-0.0382595398,
0.0068661259,
-0.0115737161,
0.0524955504,
0.0073383292,
-0.0480552576,
0.0089027714,
-0.0066102124,
-0.0179122537,
0.0164207257,
-0.0088044712,
0.0059915492,
0.0144158602,
0.0098107886,
-0.0327622518,
-0.0083521204,
-0.0285168327,
0.0201528426,
0.0310125221,
-0.0359560698,
-0.0159940775,
0.0676263124,
-0.0594844669,
-0.0781320632,
-0.0016537543,
-0.007466963,
0.0057055084,
-0.0356952101,
-0.0248993635,
0.0148841329,
-0.0554655567,
0.1001155451,
0.0372196771,
0.04312215,
0.0293563027,
-0.0092356512,
0.0095435837,
0.047965426,
-0.02223121,
0.0225704163,
-0.025818374,
0.0148104383,
-0.0379056782,
-0.0106484899,
0.0698330328,
-0.0517460927,
-0.0296594352,
0.0078638457,
-0.0824537054,
0.0229130648,
0.0562761091,
-0.0786580741,
-0.0447571687,
0.0359553732,
0.0207938068,
0.0024085697,
-0.0032197442,
-0.036303807,
0.0259430408,
0.0348067582,
0.0220044814,
0.0017907354,
-0.0729792789,
0.0022455584,
-0.0265029818,
-0.0009940928,
0.0255306419,
0.0210574698,
-0.0103450995,
0.0372768901,
0.0040315907,
0.0073195612,
0.0114080301,
-0.0103539396,
-0.0349175893,
-0.0121171474,
-0.0803430304,
-0.0080436375,
-0.0191628058,
-0.0178321712,
0.0152816428,
0.0381661318,
0.0265284907,
-0.0580864586,
-0.0102327364,
0.0555803925,
0.0043975837,
0.0036326903,
0.0330164358,
0.0125032114,
0.0055467268,
0.0111811971,
-0.0240714625,
0.0044933362,
0.0552634224,
0.0014381662,
-0.0214580093,
0.0133304475,
-0.0540632419,
-0.0097220931,
0.0156787839,
-0.0071956618,
-0.0258568432,
0.0140922917,
-0.0382535569,
0.0168189928,
0.0501653552,
0.0141924042,
0.0009587726,
0.0144367823,
-0.0026494395,
-0.0154930884,
0.0144600635,
-0.0359954722,
0.0431689657,
-0.0340275243,
0.041503612,
0.000168659,
0.0368047766,
0.0195304267,
0.0059654838,
-0.021459382,
0.005600926,
0.0180555545,
-0.0686291233,
-0.0536576994,
0.0348682255,
0.0062507512,
-0.014580409,
-0.0536312796,
-0.0281201396,
0.0125957979,
-0.0393946394,
-0.029815428,
0.01504023,
0.0150371687,
-0.0048958575,
0.0375078619,
0.0304576065,
0.0413834453,
-0.0371463038,
-0.0187389627,
-0.0329449438,
0.0114338277,
-0.0021458915,
0.0125480564,
-0.0114138154,
-0.039870441,
-0.0134692425,
-0.0081695495,
-0.0230650511,
-0.0177783202,
0.0253690425,
-0.0377406925,
0.0301386751,
-0.0312655419,
-0.0090891132,
-0.0608443096,
-0.028170228,
0.0116050281,
0.055931896,
0.0209556669,
-0.0353132561,
-0.0464501008,
0.0532289036,
0.0018458957,
0.0699000135,
-0.0442553535,
-0.0338893272,
-0.0095861889,
0.0479561836,
0.0329745114,
-0.0268436,
-0.0639129803,
0.0639794394,
0.0209380127,
0.0444236472,
0.0076701809,
0.0217448846,
0.0210087653,
-0.0320057012,
0.0078512244,
0.0275155008,
0.0015701905,
-0.046342276,
-0.0178504493,
0.0418580584,
-0.0124884201,
0.0354089886,
-0.0409153737,
-0.0481155924,
-0.1031323671,
-0.0047167251,
-0.0104070297,
0.0519777238,
-0.0181242079,
0.0028048623,
-0.0294003468,
0.0160419475,
-0.0012986935,
-0.0599251129,
-0.0422660857,
-0.0261054747,
0.0200580135,
-0.01744969,
-0.0077310451,
-0.0093905851,
0.0114831403,
-0.0206963141,
0.0201208461,
0.0043463609,
-0.0410611071,
-0.0117685227,
-0.0121986354,
-0.0246284194,
0.0476398431,
0.0310134944,
-0.0388729386,
-0.0799485743,
0.0269624311,
0.0367808118,
-0.0144959856,
-0.0343359411,
0.0536579862,
-0.0441123098,
-0.0087770224,
0.0348849408,
0.0411812402,
-0.0345869996,
-0.0250640493,
-0.0349859744,
0.0658495426,
-0.0447568931,
0.0042452402,
-0.0262381602,
-0.0227969103,
0.030390976,
0.0275505017,
-0.0301352888,
-0.0179357119,
-0.0201354567,
0.0006926665,
0.0057414095,
-0.0349484943,
-0.0058055818,
0.019914696,
0.0143026114,
-0.0112813441,
-0.0225676764,
0.0257044099,
0.0315134041,
0.0361840762,
0.0062512052,
-0.0245728735,
0.005058046,
0.0295382738,
-0.0869924948,
0.0240674447,
-0.0082137501,
-0.0049382215,
-0.0539185368,
0.0115001854,
0.0736077204,
-0.0503557436,
-0.0028057822,
0.0471674614,
-0.0659833476,
0.003510471,
-0.0185322426,
0.0299812518,
0.0084326705,
0.0492728427,
0.0193815921,
0.0116117839,
0.0718718469,
0.0399565324,
-0.0410294496,
0.013844789,
0.055281166,
-0.0138236973,
-0.0201391485,
-0.0145115023,
-0.0461495705,
0.0554742403,
-0.0048212712,
-0.0283619501,
0.0026219643,
-0.0350768119,
0.0178246964,
-0.0303267315,
0.0712732151,
0.0001894884,
0.0463681892,
-0.0672158077,
-0.0237691496,
0.0534121618,
0.0200758316,
-0.0591799654,
0.0210936666,
0.0244761519,
0.0305130649,
0.015982287,
0.0529805943,
0.0655859485,
0.0181159396,
0.0019123196,
0.041228801,
0.0444868132,
-0.0050364872,
-0.0243050978,
0.004013665,
0.0317533091,
0.0206348579,
-0.0046656406,
0.0163586736,
-0.008076787,
0.0460512042,
0.0463441536,
-0.0274552535,
-0.0664909333,
0.0728142038,
-0.0414735451,
0.0299520474,
-0.0457488447,
0.0263163671,
0.0099350968,
0.0359377749,
-0.0051905611,
-0.0285648387,
0.0108226817,
-0.0146235777,
0.078677468,
0.026461428,
-0.0256788451,
0.0786508173,
-0.0158945005,
0.0069555817,
-0.0195872374,
0.0349599086,
-0.0394370034,
0.0482501872,
-0.0227282904,
0.0069173304,
-0.0665133074,
-0.0009979371,
0.0054069688,
0.0155575201,
0.0069838469,
0.0127085336,
0.0244449936,
0.0006410067,
0.010564168,
0.0145049188,
0.0080722896,
0.0261192024,
0.0390597619,
0.0326663814,
0.0191024095,
-0.0628630519,
-0.0193360671,
-0.0232046656,
0.0484024361,
-0.004862994,
0.0280529708,
-6.23180322e-33,
0.0048360927,
-0.0068876776,
0.0117064007,
0.0001820892,
-0.0042468216,
-0.0205290206,
-0.002858608,
0.0024182948,
-0.0068188622,
-0.0148098292,
0.0154521009,
0.0000032452,
0.0068686712,
0.0203062762,
0.0272250418,
-0.0106704636,
0.0627001673,
-0.0314743109,
-0.0045952634,
0.0133793037,
0.0600841083,
0.0134424847,
0.0858467147,
-0.0570464954,
-0.0271778218,
0.0228033531,
-0.0464561246,
0.0181892049,
0.0054123332,
0.0055082021,
-0.0361827426,
0.0118077332,
0.019817261,
-0.0388301015,
-0.0528748296,
0.0349227414,
-0.1025265604,
0.0000934982,
-0.0507125854,
0.0658783764,
-0.1006319225,
-0.021274196,
0.0822369009,
-0.0243557915,
0.0259112641,
-0.0213803053,
0.0414500721,
-0.0201654676,
0.0320667364,
-0.0150928749,
0.014078008,
0.0182386711,
-0.023282392,
-0.0316741765,
0.0573861487,
0.0486169457,
0.0332909226,
0.0156883392,
-0.0690115243,
0.0550498478,
-0.0791564584,
0.0193602461,
0.0589369349,
0.0563746355,
0.0069990815,
0.0689215586,
0.041089654,
-0.0644821003,
0.0036757167,
0.0322683267,
0.044071354,
0.0639690533,
-0.0078492267,
0.0877532214,
0.0549197495,
-0.0403139777,
-0.0118188215,
0.03910264,
-0.0258222185,
0.0325966328,
-0.0087195514,
0.0203655474,
0.0149066076,
0.0049056229,
-0.0106314458,
-0.0073136645,
-0.0126578659,
0.0153361568,
0.0437432863,
0.017126767,
0.0179789905,
0.0259161834,
0.074731417,
-0.0251668002,
0.0242954735,
0.0343437716,
-0.0050526364,
0.0611103959,
0.0237905513,
-0.0426898301,
-0.0270296242,
-0.058724992,
0.0885031745,
-0.0268355757,
0.0238628294,
-0.0150051657,
0.0348725878,
0.0721732825,
-0.0104826037,
-0.0269409921,
-0.0067435508,
-0.0019022503,
0.0469063297,
-0.0086790696,
0.0191515945,
0.0018961146,
-0.0616129972,
-0.0283127427,
-0.0278445259,
0.010160069,
-0.0435331948,
-0.0456114858,
-0.0365690812,
0.048269473,
-0.0218104739,
-0.0179909114,
-0.0541413166,
-0.1110612005,
0.0371087305,
-0.0622666553,
-0.0066605075,
0.0418131202,
2.949e-7,
0.0008132559,
0.0059181885,
-0.0014960847,
-0.0992957354,
0.0328578204,
0.0605272688,
-0.0341534168,
0.0597332306,
-0.0236241166,
-0.0503279269,
0.0101049831,
0.0223680455,
0.0175814293,
0.0343943015,
-0.0438679568,
-0.0129245911,
0.0082924617,
0.012655762,
-0.0462732464,
0.0328052379,
0.0501531586,
0.0700056702,
-0.0007403619,
-0.012078925,
0.0209389795,
0.0067589069,
0.0613254756,
-0.0262286048,
0.0382639952,
-0.0360982306,
0.025342172,
-0.0096782772,
-0.0191842932,
0.0111467615,
-0.0048260037,
-0.0063941437,
0.053468015,
0.0076917498,
-0.010323083,
-0.0546405278,
0.004485358,
0.042309422,
-0.0062665786,
-0.0002126669,
0.0702678189,
-0.0556925647,
-0.0425172523,
-0.0428360514,
-0.0313512012,
0.0485142283,
-0.001133077,
0.0188506264,
-0.0380624123,
-0.0071890447,
0.0095696412,
-0.0134128733,
-0.0475641489,
-0.0677638948,
-0.0256419145,
0.0088172248,
-0.0465116613,
-0.0189430621,
-0.0202680714,
-0.0491055883,
0.048658397,
-0.047216408,
-0.0571435057,
1.921767271e-34,
-0.0175281987,
-0.0065623126,
0.003035892,
-0.0440934896,
-0.0171338003,
-0.037992198,
-0.0150218057,
-0.0004966592,
-0.0022450837,
-0.027982492,
-0.0066172983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10799v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10799v2 | Layer-wise Representation Fusion for Compositional Generalization | 2023-07-20T12:01:40 | 2023-12-21T07:38:56 | Yafang Zheng, Lei Lin, Shuangtao Li, Yuxuan Yuan, Zhaohong Lai, Shan Liu, Biao Fu, Yidong Chen, Xiaodong Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing neural models are demonstrated to struggle with compositional
generalization (CG), i.e., the ability to systematically generalize to unseen
compositions of seen components. A key reason for failure on CG is that the
syntactic and semantic representations of sequences in both the uppermost layer
of the encoder and decoder are entangled. However, previous work concentrates
on separating the learning of syntax and semantics instead of exploring the
reasons behind the representation entanglement (RE) problem to solve it. We
explain why it exists by analyzing the representation evolving mechanism from
the bottom to the top of the Transformer layers. We find that the ``shallow''
residual connections within each layer fail to fuse previous layers'
information effectively, leading to information forgetting between layers and
further the RE problems. Inspired by this, we propose LRF, a novel
\textbf{L}ayer-wise \textbf{R}epresentation \textbf{F}usion framework for CG,
which learns to fuse previous layers' information back into the encoding and
decoding process effectively through introducing a \emph{fuse-attention module}
at each encoder and decoder layer. LRF achieves promising results on two
realistic benchmarks, empirically demonstrating the effectiveness of our
proposal. | [
0.0074080466,
0.0905911848,
-0.0031704498,
0.0304410048,
-0.0027217644,
0.0487126336,
-0.0320197456,
-0.0377075225,
-0.0355428755,
0.00647608,
0.0068781753,
-0.0448606797,
0.0426475629,
0.0382277407,
0.0082219159,
-0.0574482828,
0.032828249,
0.012293186,
-0.0553272404,
0.0144974021,
0.0032260921,
-0.0123681482,
0.0341606848,
0.0440755114,
-0.0185824912,
0.009634194,
-0.0311783608,
-0.0103764152,
0.0235874709,
0.02855503,
-0.0120301154,
0.0301482566,
0.0228042752,
0.0306207929,
0.0000020674,
-0.0155585455,
-0.0144425472,
-0.0292856302,
0.0204192698,
-0.0328760147,
-0.0013142945,
-0.0453244522,
-0.0091893198,
-0.007758325,
-0.0259285979,
-0.0186786205,
0.0678149164,
0.0427309498,
0.0851899907,
0.0808784291,
-0.0154156089,
-0.0809763744,
0.0412020944,
-0.0505686812,
0.0209221002,
0.0190738626,
0.0085540703,
-0.0396566503,
-0.0581717752,
-0.0622207522,
-0.0561757945,
0.0043065553,
0.0807961747,
0.0177224651,
0.0220385324,
0.0487321056,
-0.0177085083,
-0.0292144846,
0.0004009699,
0.0577158593,
-0.0574883074,
-0.0080736754,
-0.0167494714,
0.0064151422,
0.021915786,
-0.0513896644,
-0.0219437983,
0.0202494506,
-0.020845376,
0.0354322642,
-0.0192851331,
-0.0153770931,
0.0317150094,
-0.0176072344,
-0.050167378,
0.0243570078,
0.0224718414,
-0.0144088222,
-0.0305265021,
0.0037684436,
0.0150627401,
-0.0191847682,
0.0059075993,
0.0263928398,
0.0169401467,
-0.0132648833,
-0.0438723341,
-0.019682223,
-0.0332587659,
-0.0378954783,
0.0312748253,
0.056627918,
0.0237409994,
0.0376505889,
-0.0650833175,
0.0594996288,
-0.0460334122,
0.0480738245,
-0.0503820628,
-0.0160627216,
-0.0601268336,
-0.0265005138,
-0.0142812328,
0.0707399845,
-0.044639647,
-0.0468383804,
-0.0351539515,
0.0298853591,
-0.0321367681,
0.0269878972,
-0.0271480344,
0.0294633191,
-0.0368695222,
-0.0121306181,
-0.0154977795,
0.0208014734,
0.0143024856,
-0.0180609655,
0.0234879889,
-0.0035765585,
-0.0432865061,
0.009071121,
-0.0046303272,
-0.0055721314,
-0.0054729809,
0.0607471243,
-0.0568751618,
-0.0313855112,
-0.0064518908,
0.0025184415,
-0.0271208473,
-0.009649069,
0.0590019152,
-0.0399270989,
0.0564480014,
-0.0243083406,
-0.0153715275,
-0.0659118369,
0.0007403052,
0.0227266438,
-0.003296193,
0.0601217076,
-0.0009476186,
-0.0632329062,
-0.0041225003,
0.0305725373,
0.021721622,
0.0660699159,
0.0197729282,
0.0419626907,
-0.079802379,
-0.0167139228,
0.0134082418,
0.0074461708,
0.0039757974,
0.004744587,
-0.0558469109,
-0.0280196667,
0.0226406436,
-0.0028977199,
0.0426337533,
0.0473846272,
-0.0429667719,
-0.0474716313,
0.0147368042,
-0.0034679286,
0.0300915223,
0.0655446127,
0.02796207,
-0.0047482448,
-0.027510725,
0.0620307289,
-0.0307634082,
0.0764216408,
-0.023163721,
-0.0045515602,
-0.0170411468,
0.0342338681,
-0.0448751748,
-0.0336668715,
0.0275302641,
-0.032198485,
0.0539047793,
-0.0286222734,
0.0243129581,
0.0495700724,
-0.0519568846,
0.0592381507,
0.0296297278,
-0.0645705387,
0.030862866,
-0.0141836116,
0.0000334404,
0.0358798727,
0.0077317441,
-0.0135916192,
-0.0355388597,
-0.0092628896,
-0.0335386433,
0.0437840112,
-0.0246666223,
0.0039263889,
0.0686621591,
-0.0451362059,
-0.0416111536,
-0.0267218426,
-0.004700657,
0.0339662917,
-0.0103800548,
-0.0580428988,
0.0333056115,
0.0271529686,
0.038314037,
0.0254933275,
0.0119750993,
0.0020091883,
-0.0185667519,
0.0143260304,
0.0446549356,
-0.0052581988,
0.0078020142,
0.0336746722,
0.0289075878,
-0.0589518584,
-0.0822839737,
0.0078004324,
-0.1076632068,
-0.053877905,
0.0138555029,
-0.0638937205,
0.0005770677,
-0.0064181313,
-0.0385028943,
-0.0494157933,
0.0549749695,
-0.068217665,
0.088085711,
-0.0208437238,
0.0089866314,
0.0084426366,
0.011916751,
-0.0087432638,
0.0458911955,
-0.042184636,
-0.0102016339,
0.0059785126,
-0.015993759,
0.0008867044,
-0.0178092867,
-0.0050233551,
0.004117385,
-0.0085995123,
0.0206678342,
-0.0019529333,
-0.0306839366,
-0.0309094451,
-0.0616082326,
-0.0323868357,
-0.0313547663,
-0.0187983066,
-0.0082694525,
0.0190003924,
0.0229301602,
0.0366792008,
-0.017375635,
-0.0110564604,
0.0169782788,
-0.0195993539,
0.0228615738,
0.0278650504,
0.001239536,
-0.0310011618,
-0.0167984683,
-0.029294461,
-0.0147656882,
0.0730864406,
-0.049961213,
-0.0232006609,
-0.0507357121,
-0.0801701695,
-0.0166031402,
-0.0047314535,
-0.0270043425,
-0.0461217351,
0.0011300948,
-0.0337151624,
0.0180033408,
0.0708006322,
-0.0036988629,
0.0514125563,
0.0534716658,
0.013210387,
-0.0342127569,
0.0337962545,
-0.045014184,
0.0180392861,
-0.0393466391,
0.0430398658,
0.0187280905,
0.0903293937,
-0.0264432114,
0.0229069814,
-0.0762572363,
0.0076380055,
0.0115131037,
-0.0413039438,
-0.0137654543,
-0.0571873114,
-0.0286512356,
0.0004771437,
-0.060098391,
-0.0110374531,
0.0725257546,
-0.011722303,
-0.016307164,
-0.0286118351,
-0.0029098315,
-0.0416603126,
0.0688082799,
0.0433641523,
0.0203269105,
-0.0019040213,
-0.0558293238,
-0.0655137524,
0.019949289,
-0.0032309797,
0.0090085072,
0.0251542665,
-0.0075743026,
-0.0141370874,
-0.0193774011,
-0.0230858214,
-0.0209396407,
0.0109276902,
0.0080247689,
0.0216220524,
0.005474769,
-0.0081697665,
-0.0466015041,
-0.0252216365,
0.0147862136,
0.0277230665,
0.0231286511,
0.0011329598,
-0.0487639345,
0.0253735762,
0.0002562621,
0.0180613976,
0.0181891266,
-0.046013087,
0.0364123732,
0.0505725369,
-0.0420900807,
0.0038100008,
-0.0468286127,
0.0348650329,
0.0246975347,
0.0261249077,
-0.0008335535,
0.0080238888,
0.0238932278,
-0.0670107827,
-0.0065770592,
0.073959142,
0.012438274,
-0.0767888054,
-0.0076349718,
0.0339531414,
0.0200049747,
0.037230242,
0.02042358,
-0.0669668615,
-0.0245916396,
0.0148822563,
-0.0338632539,
0.0672010183,
0.0001196099,
0.0281137321,
-0.0926987007,
-0.0066433526,
0.0284110755,
-0.0232839417,
-0.0748806596,
-0.0249430425,
-0.0223395433,
0.0226759799,
0.009005201,
0.0048297723,
0.0005092982,
-0.0344041251,
0.003976739,
-0.012646704,
-0.0410497189,
-0.0250052754,
-0.0238564983,
-0.0212950911,
0.0700083524,
0.0072652558,
0.0002157276,
-0.0647273213,
0.0323990844,
-0.006075534,
-0.0089937234,
0.0116671836,
0.0387485623,
0.003821461,
-0.0254204031,
0.0097797429,
0.0222370327,
-0.0323247053,
-0.0186311994,
-0.0410157181,
0.0457221121,
-0.0089194644,
-0.0219810791,
-0.0192037597,
-0.0060498365,
-0.0514031015,
0.0406979695,
0.0522643626,
-0.046781335,
-0.0131741129,
-0.0346365646,
0.0121422904,
-0.0495358072,
0.0188042298,
0.0423287638,
0.0592873879,
-0.0238944329,
-0.0559512712,
-0.004218291,
0.0068950024,
0.0364371687,
-0.0034997433,
-0.0515337847,
0.0269603506,
-0.0274211485,
-0.0529427454,
0.0099923816,
0.0191352665,
-0.0011621004,
-0.0284985621,
0.0189480875,
-0.0083523514,
-0.0286108255,
-0.0336025916,
-0.0365893878,
-0.107297495,
-0.0596283898,
0.0175232515,
0.0462691523,
0.0084385322,
0.0604709089,
0.0143620512,
-0.0131430449,
0.047583703,
0.0350060314,
0.0080751255,
0.0223560072,
0.0343034565,
-0.0353026949,
-0.0082281334,
0.0213334057,
-0.0475358777,
0.0011761338,
0.0432935953,
0.011505207,
-0.0099848956,
0.0204730276,
0.0539815873,
-0.0666963905,
0.0345572829,
0.0090589197,
0.0564631857,
0.0108077535,
0.0164144337,
0.0150681054,
0.0014276664,
-0.051324904,
-0.0327787846,
0.0510630943,
0.0290834568,
0.0431044064,
0.0279533304,
0.080914706,
0.0423286892,
-0.0128073944,
-0.0043460047,
0.0197073296,
-0.028199615,
0.0210099537,
0.0369054675,
-0.0045943996,
0.0184877478,
-0.0187639482,
-0.0076754065,
-0.0126521662,
0.0089432187,
0.0240764804,
0.0293146074,
-0.0694256797,
0.0229530614,
-0.0531744137,
-0.0230271313,
-0.0309405848,
-0.0028679511,
0.0583776347,
0.0007445181,
0.0188406687,
0.03113731,
-0.004327931,
0.0032215596,
0.030021375,
-0.0315047055,
-0.0537034459,
0.0472887419,
0.0153430756,
-0.0041561103,
-0.0268167406,
0.0796336159,
-0.0245940927,
0.0383088104,
-0.0172148347,
0.032149516,
-0.0330665335,
-0.0392753519,
0.0201563016,
0.0475363247,
-0.0206016246,
0.0231565945,
-0.0065953,
-0.0321862921,
0.0046934937,
0.0046649268,
0.0196114928,
0.0141531527,
0.0741899014,
0.0300410986,
0.0112173809,
-0.0198225584,
0.0299328268,
-0.0432165377,
0.0469857268,
-0.0028924008,
0.0113606621,
-6.528045429e-33,
-0.0223936997,
0.0470026024,
-0.0243210867,
0.0182854757,
-0.0410137437,
0.0147052351,
-0.0311124548,
-0.0029933245,
0.0067899423,
-0.0170529168,
0.0083944844,
0.0372225828,
-0.0174886696,
0.0514718071,
0.0316058211,
-0.0103373788,
0.0747662187,
0.0303841494,
-0.0091994107,
0.008594688,
0.0331022404,
0.0237280615,
0.0647066161,
-0.0008608837,
-0.0402379259,
0.0456016771,
-0.00156316,
0.023175614,
-0.0209589824,
0.0315323584,
-0.0210453384,
0.0153955473,
0.0172300898,
-0.0340696312,
-0.0495509095,
0.0061142272,
-0.0756899193,
-0.0227653515,
-0.0222626459,
-0.0009667189,
-0.0536644273,
-0.0368746817,
0.0853782818,
0.0187400207,
0.0059191808,
-0.0629433468,
0.0173742194,
-0.0019532014,
-0.0307032056,
-0.0471975617,
-0.039851658,
-0.0116032846,
-0.0133162141,
0.001481607,
0.0108806025,
0.0202467106,
0.0050512003,
0.0288985707,
-0.0975879803,
-0.022059571,
-0.0266149454,
0.0529410839,
0.0243481006,
0.0430066325,
0.007283113,
0.0512157902,
0.0122479983,
0.0080899494,
-0.0653622821,
0.0146517968,
0.0099880258,
0.0276548807,
0.0353219695,
-0.0044754492,
0.0546741933,
-0.0022683935,
-0.0424193144,
-0.0066461009,
0.0000817268,
0.0894176736,
0.013855922,
0.0559287146,
0.0325555801,
-0.035100922,
-0.0539141707,
0.0360324569,
-0.0163664222,
-0.0186409932,
0.0091857752,
0.0504905693,
0.0157474708,
-0.0173620004,
0.0136866206,
-0.0281353425,
0.0515526496,
0.0403476283,
-0.0179031212,
0.0204515457,
0.0429723114,
0.0056612082,
-0.0468687341,
-0.0193268508,
0.0248318091,
-0.0020378388,
0.016675489,
0.0107859578,
0.0636902601,
0.0346082523,
-0.0364837199,
-0.0266337264,
-0.0566902719,
-0.0109194843,
0.0086535076,
0.0389531925,
0.0513195656,
0.0446496159,
-0.0319923572,
0.0490551367,
-0.044944834,
0.0516716801,
-0.0398808084,
0.0072081657,
0.0240828935,
0.0643572211,
0.0045499126,
-0.0287950356,
-0.0518338047,
-0.0014981868,
0.0630027279,
-0.0563416108,
-0.0270235706,
0.0235395301,
2.823e-7,
0.0254640654,
0.0002444026,
0.0513522066,
0.0069964966,
0.0167277083,
0.0236324985,
-0.0328047834,
0.0451009683,
-0.0146260792,
0.0110166464,
-0.0000919386,
0.0226653144,
0.0364295729,
0.0158084035,
-0.0861226469,
0.014588397,
-0.1136629581,
-0.0057252799,
-0.0140512241,
0.010160259,
0.0591315515,
0.1086021885,
0.003363064,
-0.011692551,
0.0208009034,
0.0171336941,
0.0846174806,
0.0068058204,
0.0217118338,
-0.0237197131,
-0.0343582816,
0.0295893978,
0.0019820691,
-0.0033937665,
-0.015357309,
0.0288713668,
0.0202547926,
0.0031083468,
-0.0054165637,
-0.013855245,
0.0197560024,
0.0452317856,
-0.004932798,
-0.0357281975,
0.0600453541,
-0.1198776364,
-0.0176731609,
0.0159321129,
-0.0661813468,
0.0290334802,
0.0150858704,
0.0231651161,
-0.002289841,
-0.0108454498,
0.0121891163,
0.0115113361,
-0.0038789758,
-0.0870679393,
-0.0180191975,
0.0261573251,
-0.0383718982,
0.0249511357,
-0.0538419336,
-0.0127311461,
0.0493872389,
-0.0049156449,
-0.0281529408,
2.524034786e-34,
-0.0070864931,
-0.0126804514,
0.0382315591,
0.0019564803,
0.0442587696,
-0.0449831337,
-0.0396873429,
0.0062143099,
-0.0017153082,
-0.0512130372,
-0.0194939654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10778v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10778v1 | Extreme Multi-Label Skill Extraction Training using Large Language Models | 2023-07-20T11:29:15 | 2023-07-20T11:29:15 | Jens-Joris Decorte, Severine Verlinden, Jeroen Van Hautte, Johannes Deleu, Chris Develder, Thomas Demeester | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online job ads serve as a valuable source of information for skill
requirements, playing a crucial role in labor market analysis and e-recruitment
processes. Since such ads are typically formatted in free text, natural
language processing (NLP) technologies are required to automatically process
them. We specifically focus on the task of detecting skills (mentioned
literally, or implicitly described) and linking them to a large skill ontology,
making it a challenging case of extreme multi-label classification (XMLC).
Given that there is no sizable labeled (training) dataset are available for
this specific XMLC task, we propose techniques to leverage general Large
Language Models (LLMs). We describe a cost-effective approach to generate an
accurate, fully synthetic labeled dataset for skill extraction, and present a
contrastive learning strategy that proves effective in the task. Our results
across three skill extraction benchmarks show a consistent increase of between
15 to 25 percentage points in \textit{R-Precision@5} compared to previously
published results that relied solely on distant supervision through literal
matches. | [
0.0483570136,
0.0264964923,
0.0111348117,
-0.0124671096,
-0.0120139709,
-0.0033966869,
0.0032571363,
0.0017544043,
0.0514267981,
-0.0641073734,
-0.041842591,
-0.0084114755,
-0.0427432358,
0.0026175927,
0.0146355936,
-0.0007056047,
-0.0248135533,
-0.0078109377,
0.0163591951,
0.0201529711,
-0.0025685234,
0.0613359362,
-0.0041549569,
0.0418111272,
-0.0214147102,
-0.0300975274,
0.0427464843,
-0.0263217166,
0.0336616449,
-0.0035320621,
0.0463627204,
0.0076084542,
0.0170441438,
-0.0401337706,
0.00000173,
-0.0312559009,
-0.0231068861,
0.0147499302,
-0.0143760741,
-0.0431068726,
0.0366060697,
-0.0298159234,
0.0332294218,
0.0362076573,
-0.0270165075,
-0.023998687,
0.0302354619,
0.0435152538,
0.0629067197,
0.0520937555,
-0.0065361471,
-0.0473259427,
0.0277189706,
-0.0049808095,
0.0261551514,
-0.0370807424,
0.0596974269,
-0.0222973414,
0.0173702296,
0.0427749753,
0.0288153738,
-0.0055639562,
-0.0089242095,
-0.0172318686,
-0.0038305018,
0.0194536075,
0.0124241225,
0.0199952219,
0.0382052623,
0.0402635187,
-0.0261881873,
0.0096482281,
-0.0098007005,
-0.0127356676,
0.0216579232,
0.0311964974,
-0.0183990821,
0.0416023321,
-0.0496202633,
0.008696503,
0.0173592232,
-0.0106682954,
-0.0237555224,
0.0207544006,
0.019970851,
0.0672682077,
-0.0119657833,
-0.0477903411,
0.0481129549,
0.0150983911,
-0.0141236577,
-0.0007785236,
0.0381496847,
-0.0072016516,
-0.0353719667,
0.0062031518,
-0.0280209165,
-0.0234643798,
0.0180818476,
-0.0647179708,
0.016465364,
-0.0203226302,
-0.0334470123,
0.0415650755,
-0.0165766049,
0.0030245993,
0.0138020702,
-0.0072723343,
-0.0304034296,
-0.0314088203,
-0.1081610322,
-0.0268091746,
-0.0321841836,
0.0148340426,
-0.0162708629,
0.0236804653,
-0.0456027612,
-0.013276781,
-0.0366192944,
-0.0047324193,
0.0373472162,
-0.0070358794,
-0.017285414,
0.0148163587,
-0.0197788421,
-0.0105016865,
0.027097797,
0.0127935205,
-0.0372641273,
-0.0010889138,
0.0336787552,
0.0452237837,
0.0159553289,
-0.0580257662,
0.0394778475,
0.0636026561,
0.0101793874,
-0.0091749709,
-0.0407951698,
-0.016069416,
-0.0234911181,
-0.0240853112,
-0.0383780748,
-0.023639746,
0.0266694035,
-0.0271134116,
-0.00610284,
-0.0587192662,
0.034043584,
0.0097891698,
-0.0471240878,
0.0475664549,
-0.0138738696,
0.0147293927,
0.0442227311,
-0.0258315485,
-0.0333099179,
0.0271973386,
0.0026440234,
0.0331814662,
0.0322091468,
-0.0251628626,
0.0584023781,
0.0641910583,
-0.0494531505,
-0.0448173843,
-0.0150099825,
0.0376367532,
0.065197818,
0.0244303495,
0.0807242244,
-0.0313914195,
-0.0180674866,
0.0164251216,
0.0796961486,
0.0092618298,
0.0195138473,
-0.0306336377,
0.0946386606,
0.0712540299,
-0.0127526643,
-0.0436628945,
-0.0206399616,
-0.010826732,
0.023559222,
0.0054785493,
0.006290928,
0.0219815373,
-0.0361705832,
-0.0127388611,
-0.0093284911,
-0.0084446268,
-0.060343612,
0.0385781191,
0.0746177658,
-0.0019152442,
-0.0227109008,
0.0676934868,
0.076727733,
0.0175824091,
0.0334549025,
-0.0272820164,
-0.0545129515,
0.0554442778,
-0.0051851696,
-0.0440285243,
-0.0065402812,
-0.0237841625,
0.0182488691,
0.0329271443,
0.0393227264,
-0.0402694084,
0.000730823,
-0.0274926778,
-0.018162379,
0.0012406583,
0.0175924748,
0.0035811772,
0.0075937505,
0.0167822335,
0.0036745796,
-0.0201468151,
-0.0598354489,
0.0469192117,
-0.0125267198,
-0.0437659547,
0.0247078538,
0.0059918817,
-0.01892717,
0.0067260535,
-0.0259419475,
-0.0148557462,
0.0042237393,
-0.0446118787,
-0.03144769,
-0.0306146648,
-0.0027337088,
-0.0055928715,
0.0419073068,
-0.0364649482,
-0.0329073481,
0.0276441611,
-0.0423937514,
0.0062806071,
-0.0427245311,
0.0028490103,
0.0000513929,
-0.0173579361,
0.005154958,
0.009327203,
0.0020288341,
-0.0325744487,
0.0849122405,
0.0630013794,
0.033882197,
-0.0414896645,
-0.0641535893,
-0.0332919955,
-0.064340733,
0.0062538073,
-0.0221631136,
-0.0000993118,
0.0549670272,
-0.0009161699,
0.0474393219,
-0.0533416569,
-0.0375069603,
-0.0408598781,
0.0559408776,
0.0103470227,
0.0219204333,
0.0213541761,
-0.0535980612,
0.0073081311,
0.0030695808,
-0.0523574688,
-0.0614269562,
-0.0195390768,
0.0038644464,
0.0310040042,
0.0155407181,
-0.0381767489,
0.02240422,
-0.0042113722,
-0.0169074237,
0.041069027,
0.0330340229,
0.0383310094,
-0.0602065846,
0.0276189875,
-0.0041041025,
0.0271104071,
0.021551393,
-0.006762933,
-0.0255256575,
-0.0129263289,
-0.0569160394,
0.022629017,
0.013151695,
-0.00711251,
0.0212235041,
0.0170059558,
-0.0065631759,
-0.0028548092,
-0.0412115715,
-0.019412173,
-0.0579924658,
-0.0229689889,
-0.01808591,
0.0580761954,
0.0203868598,
-0.0091450661,
-0.0058516036,
-0.0100964988,
-0.021621732,
-0.0107625658,
-0.0492684282,
0.0532022305,
-0.0107129756,
0.0057317726,
-0.0112699196,
-0.013471907,
0.0275449753,
0.0013765675,
0.0009427366,
-0.0014844205,
-0.0878484398,
-0.0404852703,
0.027478734,
-0.01386334,
0.0339293517,
0.020079691,
-0.0468637347,
-0.0190014858,
0.0107481414,
0.0178536251,
-0.0192500278,
-0.0206674822,
-0.017047422,
0.0171991009,
0.0159460939,
-0.0559409149,
-0.0430039763,
-0.045891095,
0.0174725801,
0.047740031,
0.0214120168,
0.0078247292,
-0.08425989,
-0.0017266207,
0.0004905889,
0.0531113632,
0.0049690022,
-0.0221828148,
-0.0069552278,
0.0620236099,
0.0771596059,
-0.0154447118,
-0.0561860129,
-0.0476499349,
-0.0287488326,
0.0270262696,
-0.0177801456,
0.0196014475,
0.009451584,
-0.0123094535,
0.0246155672,
-0.0783575624,
0.0335933641,
0.0103785936,
-0.0100923246,
-0.0371540524,
0.0060145115,
0.0837897137,
0.0146929892,
-0.0263445247,
0.0124380561,
0.0459300019,
-0.0574767627,
0.0241223369,
0.0327206925,
-0.0464662686,
-0.010890116,
-0.015581795,
0.0368086956,
-0.0083857803,
-0.0557348318,
0.0075010611,
-0.1162056997,
0.0501124449,
-0.0320588648,
-0.049089931,
-0.016067896,
-0.0345116779,
0.0070840539,
-0.0496034175,
-0.0138148917,
-0.0330542587,
-0.0360373966,
-0.0065381643,
0.0473073497,
-0.0014399538,
-0.0551934168,
0.0806419775,
-0.054781042,
0.0260486715,
-0.0320041031,
0.0329444967,
-0.0321916044,
-0.028836688,
0.0448504426,
-0.004433421,
-0.0097540412,
0.0142801888,
0.0685503557,
-0.0591492504,
-0.020635765,
0.0097871004,
0.0271179378,
-0.0575765036,
0.0166273918,
0.0334614404,
0.0838559419,
0.0200170279,
-0.0025614889,
0.0203256644,
-0.0290591419,
0.0176938139,
0.0774347186,
-0.0411365144,
-0.1273726374,
0.0129016507,
-0.0061327484,
-0.02382751,
0.0118685542,
-0.0708001852,
0.0593319312,
-0.0569305047,
-0.0113270748,
-0.0125399353,
-0.038152419,
0.0616997629,
0.0154802985,
-0.0050236075,
0.0039891177,
-0.0336390398,
0.0088265147,
-0.0393343344,
0.0647894964,
-0.0467240699,
0.0272969957,
-0.0401715152,
-0.0157665424,
0.0425185263,
-0.0695342124,
-0.0735112429,
-0.0143256355,
-0.0158336405,
-0.0164651945,
-0.0343991481,
-0.0013879744,
0.0116493301,
0.0507983379,
0.0034798663,
-0.0407241471,
-0.0032587002,
0.0793183595,
-0.0642131791,
-0.0231761839,
0.0085954582,
0.0106009357,
0.005194671,
0.0163560156,
-0.0440123528,
0.042605605,
0.0622251257,
-0.0080537125,
-0.0010387935,
-0.0317470469,
0.0299507696,
0.0184459984,
0.0354465879,
0.0072984183,
0.0029694845,
-0.0694534481,
-0.0108640566,
0.0163679477,
-0.0543805584,
-0.0305909123,
0.0167889483,
0.0637738183,
0.0273528174,
0.0129802739,
0.0332875289,
0.0109887552,
0.036930602,
-0.0328219235,
0.0189027898,
-0.0142325424,
0.027972592,
0.0208145808,
-0.0167237241,
-0.0408960506,
-0.0333609954,
0.0141368108,
0.051884491,
0.0115578249,
0.0212713201,
0.0105535667,
0.0223488249,
0.0069692032,
-0.0110694515,
-0.0128396973,
-0.0503392033,
-0.0452072062,
0.0045043868,
0.073849082,
-0.0393193066,
0.0333305709,
-0.0120787574,
-0.0206086393,
-0.0186694823,
0.0239444207,
0.0149731478,
-0.0090596722,
0.0028038693,
0.0194019414,
-0.0321589708,
-0.001821944,
0.0445428453,
0.0229878686,
0.0467357747,
-0.0130565558,
-0.0576798432,
-0.0509897843,
0.008475597,
0.0717739537,
0.0029115474,
-0.0131823421,
0.0108764032,
-0.0328633748,
-0.0464231521,
0.0231569763,
-0.0296880323,
-0.0313896947,
0.0319452472,
0.024960883,
0.0478880964,
-0.0033822025,
-0.01514888,
-0.0528008044,
-0.0533661917,
0.0434748754,
0.0164958555,
-0.0517006814,
-5.664067367e-33,
0.0191542972,
-0.0406691693,
0.0212485082,
0.0112013984,
0.0144269224,
0.0265774298,
0.0746510178,
-0.0323249474,
0.007443679,
0.0084424876,
0.013365848,
-0.0234345812,
0.0093253665,
0.0399868116,
0.043519754,
0.0231229551,
0.0367428884,
-0.0026747184,
0.033463195,
0.0212847944,
0.0489283316,
0.0285964236,
0.0953539312,
-0.0898857713,
0.0357780494,
-0.0066426406,
-0.0361659452,
0.0386178493,
0.0482740737,
0.0664873645,
-0.0134972297,
0.0433579087,
0.0488023199,
-0.0628996417,
0.0419497527,
-0.0103938216,
-0.0524883196,
0.0128400996,
0.0054134713,
0.0110700112,
0.0382619575,
-0.0304478202,
0.0064579737,
-0.0030634054,
0.023355078,
-0.0357471034,
0.093741402,
-0.0462431088,
0.0210652296,
-0.0381482095,
-0.0288873706,
0.0319672972,
-0.0166866239,
0.0182007384,
0.0052479631,
0.0102978563,
-0.0040922612,
0.0158784967,
-0.0975783691,
-0.0086981058,
-0.0144690443,
0.0147713553,
0.0035375454,
0.0167307537,
-0.0012467562,
0.0342160799,
0.0484545566,
0.0161005016,
0.0903011933,
-0.0231961925,
-0.0119734406,
0.046078559,
-0.037093848,
0.0282407943,
0.0539083369,
0.0026467843,
-0.0392605029,
0.0166329928,
-0.0044038733,
-0.0174668208,
0.0184587371,
0.0005363884,
-0.0425954349,
-0.0072638551,
-0.0200897511,
0.0068169576,
-0.031304881,
0.0044554188,
0.0415278785,
0.0230608601,
0.0391425826,
0.0323988013,
-0.0181370769,
-0.0231052972,
-0.0266652498,
-0.0144321369,
-0.0433581807,
0.0128047811,
-0.0197008327,
-0.037150614,
-0.0449932329,
-0.0664872378,
-0.0222504586,
-0.0371309146,
0.0280112363,
0.0297218952,
0.0526948944,
0.0192807652,
-0.0840707421,
0.0081678927,
0.0038382988,
-0.0011483069,
0.0010101235,
0.0341597274,
0.0484584086,
-0.0207381863,
-0.0089819366,
0.0570337623,
0.0408556983,
-0.017104229,
0.0172221828,
0.0034402937,
0.0270634703,
0.0091083478,
0.0050057294,
0.0087501965,
-0.0085449675,
-0.0654585361,
0.0195228234,
-0.0516918935,
-0.000843642,
-0.0161140691,
2.371e-7,
0.0370150283,
0.0174203012,
-0.0805149451,
0.0176908318,
0.0037084157,
0.0309727322,
-0.004204941,
0.0258511808,
0.0097608678,
0.0159542393,
-0.0121717881,
0.0187658407,
0.0348111019,
0.005899494,
-0.0980808884,
-0.0165535603,
-0.0131340744,
-0.0406071283,
-0.0670617744,
0.020496672,
0.0953160599,
0.0838744864,
0.0494523197,
-0.0158540886,
-0.0202199332,
-0.0922643691,
0.0551328585,
-0.0032992796,
-0.0012959263,
0.0397613086,
-0.0146492263,
0.0067303451,
-0.03264625,
0.0517401285,
-0.0063898955,
0.0237028413,
0.0666873381,
0.1003803834,
-0.027509287,
0.0572175458,
0.0242133271,
-0.0036630614,
-0.0462762453,
-0.0000767478,
0.0432145782,
-0.1029006094,
-0.034029834,
-0.0423958786,
-0.0544430614,
-0.0236483291,
-0.0235077795,
-0.0127259186,
0.0262971967,
0.0071262531,
0.0112772705,
-0.0088441456,
-0.068560712,
-0.0312820487,
0.0152495215,
0.0675995126,
-0.0429344065,
-0.0622197613,
0.048811093,
0.0395936146,
0.0310550388,
-0.0636174828,
0.0219836663,
2.089054581e-34,
0.0223818347,
0.0402907804,
-0.0025129931,
0.0080215754,
0.016534077,
0.0144029772,
-0.0179337021,
-0.0037901395,
-0.0232362766,
-0.0492193922,
0.0059655686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10757v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10757v2 | Vesper: A Compact and Effective Pretrained Model for Speech Emotion Recognition | 2023-07-20T10:42:16 | 2024-04-18T13:08:07 | Weidong Chen, Xiaofen Xing, Peihao Chen, Xiangmin Xu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper presents a paradigm that adapts general large-scale pretrained
models (PTMs) to speech emotion recognition task. Although PTMs shed new light
on artificial general intelligence, they are constructed with general tasks in
mind, and thus, their efficacy for specific tasks can be further improved.
Additionally, employing PTMs in practical applications can be challenging due
to their considerable size. Above limitations spawn another research direction,
namely, optimizing large-scale PTMs for specific tasks to generate
task-specific PTMs that are both compact and effective. In this paper, we focus
on the speech emotion recognition task and propose an improved emotion-specific
pretrained encoder called Vesper. Vesper is pretrained on a speech dataset
based on WavLM and takes into account emotional characteristics. To enhance
sensitivity to emotional information, Vesper employs an emotion-guided masking
strategy to identify the regions that need masking. Subsequently, Vesper
employs hierarchical and cross-layer self-supervision to improve its ability to
capture acoustic and semantic representations, both of which are crucial for
emotion recognition. Experimental results on the IEMOCAP, MELD, and CREMA-D
datasets demonstrate that Vesper with 4 layers outperforms WavLM Base with 12
layers, and the performance of Vesper with 12 layers surpasses that of WavLM
Large with 24 layers. | [
-0.0372115076,
0.0073444038,
-0.0159775838,
0.0269501079,
0.0469783135,
0.0070108785,
0.0308892131,
-0.0460125469,
0.0085378923,
-0.0261485633,
-0.0757327825,
-0.0330192149,
-0.0622814968,
0.0063226856,
-0.0512351319,
-0.069300212,
0.0150220012,
0.0189937167,
0.0269740075,
-0.0351930596,
0.0232500844,
0.0231303629,
-0.0182784516,
-0.0011830761,
-0.0497932583,
0.0152235348,
-0.0516229421,
0.0182434469,
0.0494894199,
-0.0261648968,
0.0311067272,
0.0272510815,
0.0674512684,
-0.0256028436,
0.0000023148,
-0.0154486783,
-0.0011699104,
-0.0353768021,
-0.0467657447,
0.0214317106,
0.0188252348,
-0.0024467346,
-0.0405295342,
0.0129404897,
0.0022543333,
-0.0378344022,
0.0516035557,
0.0467072465,
0.0909690559,
0.0722820237,
-0.0306981131,
-0.0212078746,
-0.0124262217,
0.0037524472,
-0.0115304627,
-0.043006178,
0.0203414857,
-0.0057935398,
-0.0074425782,
-0.0838034749,
-0.0460040458,
0.0006727967,
0.0112801511,
0.0257828385,
0.0343932956,
-0.0277988613,
-0.0006365176,
-0.0359352306,
-0.0468312055,
0.0607005209,
-0.0548533686,
-0.000482371,
-0.0261746664,
-0.0185421351,
-0.0154629247,
-0.03623401,
-0.001235666,
-0.0117574511,
0.019407697,
0.0060078781,
-0.0046389154,
0.0861758515,
-0.0073986109,
-0.0113493027,
-0.0440072343,
0.0072215497,
-0.033499781,
-0.0252814032,
0.0468431562,
-0.0106069837,
-0.0058664395,
0.0220239889,
0.0009806617,
-0.0049830289,
-0.0162864067,
-0.018595146,
-0.0694716722,
-0.0203810949,
-0.0770291388,
-0.0542807654,
0.0202702638,
0.0161767509,
-0.0398612656,
0.0355940126,
0.0104798218,
0.03406284,
0.0031813572,
-0.0155143095,
-0.0294031352,
-0.0258365329,
-0.0055965642,
0.0493230894,
-0.0434040055,
0.0303539038,
-0.0354738645,
-0.0381568447,
-0.0837614611,
-0.0088534532,
-0.0490399413,
0.0035868487,
-0.0075853379,
0.0027742595,
0.0173643511,
-0.0145401824,
0.0349416621,
0.0188677292,
0.0119850878,
0.0565243214,
-0.0240156073,
-0.0497507825,
0.0058469819,
0.0044918014,
0.0649170652,
-0.0055252453,
0.0673772767,
0.0629877895,
0.005710288,
-0.0375609957,
-0.0545205623,
0.0127628734,
0.0046857698,
-0.0351452827,
0.0382017307,
0.0080741886,
0.0662265345,
-0.0395328775,
0.0174541641,
-0.0312458575,
-0.0122365523,
-0.062807925,
0.0138769122,
0.0611367635,
-0.0072012017,
-0.0089167189,
0.0155018363,
0.0045487485,
0.0177049749,
0.0166317783,
0.0262294281,
0.0666249767,
0.0497009046,
-0.0977296904,
0.0237455927,
0.0251461919,
0.0100142397,
-0.0386494026,
-0.006127859,
-0.0179170985,
-0.0013127669,
0.0026437507,
0.070311211,
0.009341415,
-0.0368403159,
-0.0171879828,
0.0509299934,
0.0318478011,
-0.006976644,
0.0366461128,
-0.0197153203,
0.0189623218,
0.0683605745,
-0.0778254494,
-0.0047449679,
0.0493121557,
-0.0565340966,
-0.0288955588,
-0.0117432456,
0.0249577966,
-0.0468394347,
-0.0430517755,
-0.0115267746,
-0.0344419591,
-0.0245606974,
0.0417196788,
0.0493462607,
-0.0334452502,
-0.0658698156,
-0.0079362812,
0.0009497062,
-0.0712178126,
0.0135495784,
-0.032547351,
0.0283088181,
0.0631719381,
-0.0089178644,
-0.0471104831,
-0.0173098501,
-0.0369422473,
-0.0156700257,
-0.0251518134,
0.0175123978,
-0.0094934497,
0.0736167356,
-0.0822049603,
-0.0267454349,
-0.0250533875,
-0.0130472044,
0.0525983274,
-0.0120023228,
0.0228629671,
0.0006987633,
0.02633035,
0.0544495247,
-0.0108593162,
-0.0008468109,
-0.0641438067,
0.0075752069,
0.0027120926,
0.0919260681,
0.016446732,
-0.0364842303,
-0.0416814201,
0.0349367447,
-0.010582394,
-0.0180182122,
-0.0037281138,
-0.0520523451,
-0.0369331501,
0.0168212131,
-0.0260200091,
0.0301514454,
0.066963926,
-0.0452714562,
-0.0523208342,
0.0282326695,
0.0053628148,
0.0406831019,
-0.0374625251,
0.0182632376,
-0.0144437365,
0.06035823,
0.0395239964,
-0.0027138267,
0.034211114,
-0.0603183061,
-0.0199128259,
0.0180692561,
0.0002134957,
-0.0193041768,
-0.0881271362,
-0.00359405,
-0.0025769519,
0.0292584673,
-0.0072022751,
-0.0123690534,
-0.0285658296,
-0.0243605804,
-0.0972225815,
-0.0020985773,
-0.001329484,
-0.0256387126,
-0.0043071196,
0.0155980662,
-0.0480142646,
-0.0207408741,
-0.0032730154,
0.0063861613,
0.0195121989,
-0.0164853148,
-0.0327221267,
-0.0285631102,
0.0058331555,
-0.0583732352,
0.0057831258,
0.0282354411,
-0.020579569,
-0.0463710576,
-0.0155500043,
0.0059484835,
0.0013943047,
0.0175137576,
0.0386002064,
-0.005551666,
-0.0664937422,
-0.0315423235,
-0.0050357133,
0.0016384737,
0.0485529676,
-0.0048096366,
0.1005121917,
0.0139792264,
-0.0164116342,
-0.0284283403,
0.0565741174,
-0.0376325622,
0.0226764195,
-0.0219027847,
0.0553290248,
-0.0338456631,
0.067052342,
0.0269035157,
0.0258279555,
-0.0402622037,
-0.0111060049,
0.0266322959,
-0.0413040817,
-0.0099198017,
-0.0641012639,
0.0086169988,
0.0024813826,
0.0202712025,
-0.0370455049,
-0.0215899851,
-0.0096074566,
-0.0548082925,
-0.0538134016,
-0.0381791517,
-0.0108620115,
0.0614305921,
-0.045942571,
0.0026233923,
0.0074173147,
0.007790586,
-0.0005147309,
-0.0166685712,
-0.052525498,
-0.0586635992,
-0.0483389199,
-0.0017254768,
-0.0475577489,
0.0287700444,
-0.0063089156,
-0.0283380654,
-0.032018315,
-0.0400431603,
-0.0095688803,
0.0194433872,
0.0159118287,
-0.017995242,
0.0010476591,
0.0215087682,
-0.0132720964,
0.0214045905,
0.022205729,
-0.0131060183,
0.048505187,
0.0081801778,
0.0119907232,
0.0263625458,
-0.0076793348,
0.0362087339,
0.0191088077,
0.0441763438,
-0.0019573492,
-0.0087522976,
0.0523504838,
0.0248317178,
0.0013261796,
0.0149853071,
-0.0279050041,
0.045147907,
-0.0627019554,
0.0577669553,
0.1326873302,
0.0440492555,
-0.0242740195,
0.0045427429,
-0.0006005003,
-0.0410666466,
-0.006584269,
0.0152384397,
0.0031520638,
-0.0369513892,
0.0037419507,
-0.0010120171,
0.025243761,
0.0179376472,
0.0306391995,
-0.0695171058,
0.0532917045,
0.0361217856,
0.0318567455,
-0.0270958655,
-0.0335722342,
0.0139505109,
-0.0475481115,
0.0063847783,
-0.054191865,
0.0195192136,
-0.0283629708,
0.0530227087,
-0.0358847678,
-0.0737560913,
0.0410949364,
-0.0115170619,
0.0390352644,
0.0283838715,
0.0420754887,
-0.0336184353,
-0.0416343324,
0.0206248946,
-0.0112132179,
-0.0157659091,
-0.0099369111,
0.0548972152,
-0.0155880852,
-0.0124762366,
0.0078257425,
0.0318115987,
-0.056841474,
0.0222455021,
0.0260699857,
0.0514696911,
-0.0304875225,
-0.02888662,
-0.0058386107,
0.0099324686,
-0.0000223346,
0.0446224101,
0.0170670487,
-0.0365033075,
-0.0127886599,
-0.0042163786,
0.0181053784,
-0.0082267048,
-0.0436391942,
0.0209861808,
-0.0156995673,
-0.0161334928,
-0.0134437,
-0.063198857,
0.0358003564,
0.038025368,
-0.010582556,
-0.0671302453,
0.0188740045,
0.0163421147,
-0.0493762456,
0.0172445234,
0.0344105996,
-0.0048141838,
-0.0008259852,
-0.0010177044,
0.0568402968,
-0.016335085,
-0.0049055321,
-0.0167008173,
-0.0006036289,
-0.0340161622,
0.0409614705,
0.0506579913,
0.0123971086,
0.0290370993,
0.0290243141,
-0.0052294801,
0.1141679883,
-0.0304464921,
-0.0249216594,
0.0250083711,
0.0952089503,
-0.0158124045,
-0.0310518686,
0.0102084102,
-0.0212149248,
0.105526723,
0.000287251,
-0.0093284044,
0.0067744353,
-0.0248498097,
-0.018274853,
-0.0123436013,
0.0578350984,
0.0273909252,
-0.0179683063,
-0.0434644967,
0.0203368962,
-0.0278730318,
0.044683665,
-0.0759210363,
-0.0357227363,
-0.0107733188,
0.0348196514,
-0.0464680903,
-0.0214705598,
0.0054973965,
-0.0769893527,
0.0025975714,
0.0721882209,
0.0045783948,
0.0114435274,
-0.0125750871,
0.0511740632,
0.0258638039,
0.0053732521,
0.0413099751,
-0.0326136462,
0.0010013976,
0.0074807191,
-0.0094700437,
-0.0023831534,
-0.0142967645,
0.044768732,
-0.00490257,
-0.0229917653,
-0.0381540917,
0.0047679367,
0.0462607816,
-0.0462550856,
0.0243267678,
0.0043963674,
0.0185000133,
0.0066261482,
-0.0024117904,
-0.0354301184,
0.0054384926,
0.0265052523,
-0.0318913385,
-0.0335076936,
-0.0112213697,
0.006370293,
-0.0054814634,
0.0743422136,
-0.00173892,
0.0239501521,
-0.0559262522,
-0.0195571613,
0.0814286321,
-0.0012516403,
0.0198163651,
0.0249998216,
-0.0080920607,
-0.0413418822,
0.0417833701,
-0.0492357016,
-0.0133024463,
-0.022159813,
0.0608070083,
0.0081564104,
-0.0510284714,
0.0495953299,
0.0280426312,
-0.0435006283,
-0.0565793999,
-0.0067164251,
0.0668974146,
-6.317017745e-33,
-0.0107338084,
0.054654941,
-0.036958456,
-0.0075901896,
-0.0375457816,
0.0409689099,
0.000836858,
-0.0138780139,
0.0149451373,
0.0123358052,
-0.006220506,
0.0189280901,
0.022651555,
0.0258590672,
0.0087371171,
0.0041430923,
0.0622520782,
-0.0505798198,
0.0286284667,
0.0173478797,
-0.0116941938,
0.0458650999,
0.0387825482,
-0.0912850276,
-0.0442552306,
0.0143877435,
-0.0266705938,
-0.0367974006,
0.0718506575,
0.0358456969,
0.0098467693,
0.0382382497,
-0.0215613116,
0.0066623124,
-0.0236759279,
0.029818207,
-0.0154081788,
-0.0170299411,
-0.0303224344,
0.0179002434,
-0.0362362638,
-0.0369188935,
0.019561192,
0.0582049228,
-0.0147394603,
-0.0393974483,
0.0387659334,
0.0051491535,
0.0129965125,
-0.0852640569,
-0.0055949967,
0.0035469651,
-0.0266839378,
-0.0364456326,
0.0574941151,
0.0273843613,
-0.0163589716,
0.0015367654,
-0.053584028,
-0.0011674502,
0.0159800835,
-0.028019337,
0.0153792268,
0.0036575638,
0.0021756627,
0.0354874805,
0.0793219656,
-0.0441808552,
0.0165845845,
0.0621929429,
0.020704465,
0.0600742511,
0.0288584754,
0.0062099607,
0.0287207179,
-0.0004446503,
-0.0355940126,
0.0259598158,
-0.0000755264,
-0.0089376979,
0.0419784859,
0.0304389261,
0.0054365965,
0.0141978264,
-0.0071401913,
-0.0131313391,
0.0215256754,
-0.0237339623,
0.0509170555,
-0.0065284739,
0.0287974626,
0.0085221697,
0.0321590677,
-0.0255105644,
0.052849263,
0.0092287837,
-0.0163398758,
0.0427625887,
-0.0011349523,
0.0156988222,
-0.0139402011,
-0.0409812406,
0.0681078956,
0.0039122072,
0.0373410061,
-0.0010058171,
-0.0159328692,
0.0833095983,
-0.0271920469,
-0.0327500962,
-0.0047422731,
0.0432253517,
0.0003571922,
0.0284748729,
-0.0352393128,
0.0320219137,
-0.0022726338,
0.0017458076,
-0.009722528,
0.0436311625,
-0.0124662304,
-0.0359692276,
0.0257518813,
0.048254557,
-0.0100211482,
0.0115931435,
-0.0374749452,
-0.0223236531,
0.0074970578,
-0.0297683068,
0.0160819702,
-0.0232589934,
3.043e-7,
-0.0702948123,
0.0124815255,
0.0160763916,
-0.0658533722,
0.0453120396,
0.0352953337,
0.0008176132,
0.0340525284,
0.0194490906,
0.0114496825,
0.0981023759,
0.0351231135,
0.0561673045,
0.0091644777,
-0.0797346607,
-0.0436879173,
0.0096223764,
0.013624859,
-0.0116241351,
0.0423990153,
0.0707115978,
0.0925787613,
0.0574872345,
-0.0030215725,
0.0280443728,
0.0544861108,
0.0336819179,
-0.0405028537,
0.0149215795,
0.0128554758,
-0.0324088559,
-0.0125989392,
-0.0383766964,
0.0078189149,
-0.0192995947,
0.0544916242,
0.0136156548,
0.0524686091,
-0.0010298574,
-0.0791398287,
0.0299812499,
0.0683497414,
-0.0236709248,
0.0038372399,
0.0389842279,
-0.0517874733,
-0.0490746759,
0.0184282083,
-0.0637238175,
0.0072860988,
0.0239708871,
-0.0223496556,
-0.0052333232,
0.0012924704,
-0.0035778461,
-0.0228900984,
-0.06259574,
-0.111954242,
0.0314551331,
0.0108849537,
-0.0503294989,
-0.0285300966,
-0.0200906545,
0.0088020479,
0.0673808828,
-0.0045390883,
0.0057580117,
2.318185981e-34,
-0.0038412423,
-0.0323220827,
-0.00819383,
0.0214575846,
0.0078432159,
0.0065960372,
-0.0404082276,
-0.0254009832,
0.0244070403,
-0.0398976915,
-0.014243762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10751v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10751v1 | Exploring Perspectives on the Impact of Artificial Intelligence on the Creativity of Knowledge Work: Beyond Mechanised Plagiarism and Stochastic Parrots | 2023-07-20T10:26:57 | 2023-07-20T10:26:57 | Advait Sarkar | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Artificial Intelligence (AI), and in particular generative models, are
transformative tools for knowledge work. They problematise notions of
creativity, originality, plagiarism, the attribution of credit, and copyright
ownership. Critics of generative models emphasise the reliance on large amounts
of training data, and view the output of these models as no more than
randomised plagiarism, remix, or collage of the source data. On these grounds,
many have argued for stronger regulations on the deployment, use, and
attribution of the output of these models. However, these issues are not new or
unique to artificial intelligence. In this position paper, using examples from
literary criticism, the history of art, and copyright law, I show how
creativity and originality resist definition as a notatable or
information-theoretic property of an object, and instead can be seen as the
property of a process, an author, or a viewer. Further alternative views hold
that all creative work is essentially reuse (mostly without attribution), or
that randomness itself can be creative. I suggest that creativity is ultimately
defined by communities of creators and receivers, and the deemed sources of
creativity in a workflow often depend on which parts of the workflow can be
automated. Using examples from recent studies of AI in creative knowledge work,
I suggest that AI shifts knowledge work from material production to critical
integration. This position paper aims to begin a conversation around a more
nuanced approach to the problems of creativity and credit assignment for
generative models, one which more fully recognises the importance of the
creative and curatorial voice of the users of these models and moves away from
simpler notational or information-theoretic views. | [
0.0407477319,
0.0316506252,
-0.051190339,
-0.0169276632,
-0.0826545805,
0.025382204,
0.0321231894,
-0.0032150955,
-0.0280564055,
-0.0146499826,
-0.0034736225,
0.0488262661,
-0.0069563612,
-0.0033790371,
0.0072219758,
0.0231698528,
-0.0662717,
0.0107193589,
0.0206522066,
0.0026677432,
-0.0377793834,
0.0088206064,
0.0235947743,
0.0696802735,
-0.0396570191,
-0.0253961403,
0.0154775251,
0.0068558105,
0.0036707493,
0.0416554958,
-0.0259866957,
0.0669109374,
-0.0118701681,
0.080424428,
0.0000017064,
-0.0358361788,
0.0509451665,
-0.0149762798,
0.0001662872,
-0.041121766,
0.0309637673,
0.0477397926,
-0.0146262143,
-0.0411441512,
-0.0545029156,
0.0834638178,
0.0255986042,
0.0252595805,
0.0104759196,
0.0342339389,
-0.0121395728,
-0.0402699299,
0.0708799511,
-0.0027095294,
0.0442785323,
0.0187214166,
0.0000385205,
0.0566334017,
0.0288624559,
-0.0114417179,
0.0056735696,
0.0613003932,
0.0219183322,
-0.0298958849,
0.0492642857,
0.0117304875,
0.0474649556,
-0.0450893454,
0.0266783014,
0.0107245399,
0.0231591165,
-0.0180932712,
0.0156350676,
0.02243804,
0.0288503617,
0.0147169093,
-0.0500116982,
0.064181976,
-0.013951919,
-0.0094809737,
-0.008705277,
-0.0208066795,
-0.0040037255,
-0.0042785686,
0.0453453176,
-0.041500967,
0.0056580198,
0.0128582055,
0.0005266101,
0.0072709844,
0.0092612561,
-0.0521429889,
-0.004150365,
0.0334523618,
0.0514636897,
-0.0070314286,
-0.0441418216,
-0.0267897937,
-0.0249309484,
-0.0192572996,
0.0566715188,
-0.0098657375,
0.0074836742,
0.0620467328,
0.0147693092,
-0.0013327076,
-0.0521090142,
0.0729705766,
-0.0269638114,
0.0111115444,
-0.0930200517,
-0.0382368602,
-0.0119148456,
-0.0011917185,
0.0243259314,
-0.0492964163,
0.0152419126,
0.0308445748,
-0.0457091443,
0.0216329489,
-0.0093061086,
0.0408905149,
0.0004226707,
0.0151687842,
-0.008742786,
-0.0255236439,
0.006187092,
0.0476674549,
-0.0126029607,
0.016558297,
-0.0045946077,
0.0095072938,
0.0250841081,
0.0011387008,
0.0230755936,
0.0456289761,
0.0470402278,
0.0219071414,
-0.0029608207,
-0.0695869997,
0.0270658545,
-0.0203356612,
0.0392314307,
-0.0249601863,
0.0315231346,
0.0121857803,
-0.0355462469,
-0.0739785731,
-0.0516643301,
0.0127234533,
-0.0596210696,
-0.004541459,
-0.0026305371,
0.0560293756,
0.0061026379,
0.0025741162,
-0.0305808038,
-0.0541483276,
0.1123040542,
0.0144975744,
0.0022206572,
0.0338165201,
0.0948610604,
-0.0053269686,
-0.0227002241,
0.0037402117,
0.0002097912,
-0.0253888108,
-0.0393208675,
0.0122306924,
0.0159315038,
0.0293049235,
-0.0317332074,
0.0688500255,
0.0738132894,
0.0039130128,
0.0068206834,
0.037741065,
0.0517119542,
-0.025758395,
0.0086705377,
-0.025787944,
0.0194554031,
0.0313420556,
0.0192588866,
0.0030862691,
-0.0547360219,
0.0081713311,
-0.0116286222,
-0.0033021267,
0.0365713574,
-0.0110777551,
0.009466337,
0.0143273398,
-0.0260159597,
0.0344045833,
0.0129033606,
-0.0541360565,
-0.0600666329,
-0.0138879549,
-0.0016179279,
-0.058373481,
0.0923952013,
0.0820306465,
0.0523404852,
0.0200635754,
0.084413752,
-0.0193561148,
-0.0310769379,
0.0340755321,
-0.0322911702,
-0.0187097602,
-0.0426763073,
0.0321226642,
-0.0093325451,
-0.0643953681,
0.0013391018,
-0.0124309743,
-0.0767642483,
0.0104904948,
-0.0009475125,
0.0057882019,
-0.0614597201,
0.0097397137,
-0.0219576415,
-0.0286420342,
-0.0414512306,
0.0081944047,
0.005909049,
0.0464632921,
-0.0488412566,
0.0434774421,
0.022199966,
-0.022065863,
-0.0462758876,
0.0634282902,
0.0293496195,
0.0475882031,
-0.0027510691,
-0.0645120889,
0.0485958047,
-0.0044703796,
0.0141210314,
0.0097412737,
0.0477309972,
-0.0200943202,
0.0170789585,
-0.0215766318,
-0.0032092903,
-0.0263592638,
-0.0005733285,
-0.015209876,
0.035662245,
-0.0013854847,
0.0076670637,
-0.0259118807,
-0.0072363107,
0.071366109,
0.0308605116,
-0.0054921121,
0.0218424778,
0.0362550765,
0.0495990217,
-0.0015654053,
-0.0356887579,
0.0031533758,
-0.0057958919,
-0.0099045997,
-0.0342686735,
-0.0167586859,
-0.0102983983,
-0.000540236,
-0.0387540385,
-0.0273681488,
0.0159266908,
-0.0099657215,
-0.0359893329,
-0.015712237,
-0.0071170297,
0.0112090651,
0.0271923933,
-0.0112020792,
0.0300213788,
0.017211901,
0.0115444446,
0.0304610897,
0.074695006,
0.0292527005,
-0.0242653508,
-0.0012430121,
-0.0503991023,
-0.0305960625,
-0.0026527026,
0.0527974218,
-0.0067186151,
-0.0288350265,
-0.0026446311,
0.0265028868,
-0.0212026685,
0.0049502444,
0.0162677467,
0.005173062,
0.0033953884,
0.0132687092,
0.0098640593,
0.0070085693,
0.007533106,
-0.0275674723,
0.0297021996,
-0.0153056681,
0.0187538564,
-0.0046128198,
-0.0117103504,
0.111616239,
0.0105359172,
-0.0406007133,
0.0238848086,
-0.0797793418,
-0.0207830649,
0.058495298,
-0.0269905105,
-0.0389650278,
-0.000405978,
-0.0161677692,
0.0296833944,
0.0248720925,
0.0068059745,
0.0032638081,
0.0898180604,
0.0048747566,
0.0302038323,
0.0212875213,
0.0318836831,
-0.0634557158,
0.0463178717,
0.0719644949,
-0.038612213,
-0.0547403321,
0.0240064692,
-0.0001496193,
0.0071116062,
-0.0097969538,
-0.0069293748,
0.0438957028,
-0.0189261455,
0.0218388047,
0.0499586239,
-0.0180537477,
0.0322600231,
-0.0268610623,
0.0680248439,
0.0363024287,
0.0276479032,
0.0017026528,
-0.0235375743,
0.0363301113,
0.0282124784,
-0.0005024643,
-0.0287811812,
0.0285312776,
-0.0518901199,
-0.0320670158,
-0.0223386176,
0.037196286,
-0.022623349,
0.0046728416,
-0.0140731633,
0.024307223,
-0.0213785321,
-0.0076099127,
0.026676992,
-0.0111462213,
-0.0021252586,
0.0440347828,
0.0083086761,
-0.0143337911,
-0.0104398727,
-0.0029327776,
-0.0954080597,
0.012729479,
0.0358224288,
-0.0518172495,
0.0498228744,
-0.0285953712,
0.017152667,
-0.0668124706,
-0.0408380926,
0.0083334865,
-0.0234849807,
0.094111532,
-0.0191896483,
-0.0263715461,
-0.0374574065,
0.0169241577,
-0.0590137281,
0.0237210914,
-0.0750172436,
-0.0147440461,
0.0315600894,
0.0298607536,
0.034523014,
0.035423696,
0.0097472984,
-0.0061564571,
-0.0394897498,
0.0253476501,
0.0958696976,
0.0553611144,
-0.0107980492,
-0.0511696152,
-0.0702098012,
0.0219267197,
0.0006638041,
0.0162315108,
0.0133041292,
0.0205319598,
0.0088074254,
-0.0446497388,
0.0126913702,
-0.0058414987,
-0.0341183357,
-0.0074264831,
0.0405752324,
-0.0221697055,
-0.0399572104,
-0.0593566,
-0.0424269661,
0.0340829119,
0.0203164872,
0.0614697337,
-0.0065839523,
-0.0078655165,
-0.0284609962,
0.003756304,
-0.0850728974,
-0.0358531438,
-0.0196707137,
0.0146381743,
-0.0379011333,
-0.0841239616,
-0.0407314003,
-0.071621336,
0.0736510828,
0.0496306866,
-0.0468717255,
-0.0399769917,
-0.0441842675,
-0.0793844536,
-0.0383069851,
-0.0129179303,
-0.0115836784,
0.0425000004,
-0.0515858121,
-0.0583608598,
-0.0356918983,
-0.0333771743,
-0.0052676112,
-0.0799046084,
0.0091086524,
0.0016303854,
0.0763560385,
0.0315083526,
-0.0241461713,
0.0046278466,
-0.030905189,
0.065881677,
0.0355246179,
0.0010124138,
0.0357705019,
-0.0230170544,
-0.0095607853,
-0.0123286871,
-0.0097513041,
-0.0295156203,
0.0229702499,
0.0504869707,
-0.0181935448,
-0.003710374,
0.0091325939,
-0.0006332573,
0.0000505383,
-0.0596303903,
-0.0358055867,
0.0150066419,
-0.0070393523,
-0.0360809676,
0.0389042459,
-0.0235220417,
-0.0439762287,
-0.0169717483,
0.0247699115,
-0.0137618082,
-0.0154586751,
0.0432119183,
0.0088060405,
0.0226363279,
-0.0555157848,
-0.0340571851,
0.0506770946,
0.0138011435,
-0.0199961793,
0.0071659782,
0.0182034597,
0.0665233061,
-0.0192697011,
0.0514069609,
0.0446009859,
0.0360350907,
0.0252419356,
0.0181982312,
0.0112380926,
0.0409302302,
-0.0928517655,
-0.1015261635,
-0.0050763604,
0.0147920251,
0.0441694148,
-0.0215732977,
-0.00298886,
-0.0024959364,
0.0155122941,
-0.030325124,
0.0364804529,
-0.0141028734,
-0.0410420969,
-0.0902701467,
0.0107705425,
-0.0138707636,
-0.038425643,
0.0655203685,
-0.0561091565,
0.0483435206,
-0.0651539192,
-0.0402979255,
0.0011357958,
-0.0304100607,
-0.0114661632,
-0.0514880009,
0.0435076319,
0.0198607557,
-0.0557534695,
-0.051793661,
0.0276525021,
0.011898458,
0.0691489279,
-0.0289104618,
-0.0079802359,
0.0545560867,
-0.0129054505,
-0.0295917131,
-0.0251224693,
0.0331847742,
-0.0526601113,
-0.0023304538,
-0.0328560658,
-5.209003749e-33,
-0.0006481039,
-0.0409137644,
0.0396192484,
0.033563491,
-0.0473165438,
-0.0417445526,
-0.0466595031,
-0.0279703308,
-0.016445851,
0.0208369698,
-0.0609419309,
-0.0240408685,
-0.0153081883,
-0.0483984388,
0.0533194281,
-0.0160624254,
0.0416476056,
0.0086411647,
-0.0172336586,
0.0227127913,
-0.0017703567,
-0.0024776899,
-0.0166233499,
-0.0580482446,
0.0334658064,
-0.0618380308,
-0.0217503309,
-0.0406998284,
0.009325318,
0.0233381651,
0.0020899472,
0.0199475922,
0.0407541357,
-0.0326379873,
0.004761057,
-0.0213640463,
-0.0012831367,
-0.0126033584,
-0.0066579757,
-0.0089773294,
0.0127181979,
-0.0675615892,
0.0730329901,
-0.0155209294,
-0.0400954895,
0.0370207168,
0.0526803248,
-0.0127049396,
-0.0265480112,
-0.0985570997,
-0.0816952735,
-0.0340819284,
-0.032824941,
-0.0372224264,
0.018787602,
-0.042008426,
0.0235577375,
-0.0033582749,
-0.0667218119,
0.0475957915,
-0.0313792154,
-0.0290381927,
0.0511237271,
0.0081183128,
0.0567543954,
0.0315543562,
0.0133581674,
0.057392709,
-0.0352396443,
0.0469819233,
-0.0168101564,
0.0864009708,
0.0146686574,
0.0505894348,
-0.0205901265,
-0.0335704423,
0.0315627716,
0.0179037768,
-0.0174694341,
-0.0061555128,
0.0060089957,
-0.0034638178,
-0.0306080468,
-0.03859137,
0.0058992081,
-0.1054020226,
-0.013595257,
0.0118203564,
-0.0135544967,
-0.0063237213,
0.0117200362,
0.0054377788,
-0.000372225,
-0.0672225282,
0.0212015752,
-0.0250440054,
-0.0364410169,
0.0350798965,
0.0000317701,
-0.0385906026,
-0.000687065,
-0.016808128,
0.0292798467,
0.046969194,
0.0596891902,
0.0351614468,
0.0430950932,
0.0462849364,
0.016257558,
-0.045587562,
-0.015415322,
0.0134950913,
0.0310126301,
-0.0331736282,
0.0163019449,
0.0614290796,
0.0003279632,
-0.0789484754,
0.0150724193,
0.0373683386,
0.003955211,
-0.0101058939,
-0.0284654312,
-0.0435849726,
-0.0146014094,
0.0069053043,
-0.0184165984,
0.0250727832,
0.0189199634,
-0.0366659611,
-0.0277614575,
-0.0260856524,
2.706e-7,
0.0247226637,
-0.0203103628,
0.0180137679,
0.0072487472,
0.0155204153,
0.0152881984,
-0.0179779213,
0.0232951436,
-0.022562651,
0.0225880258,
0.0403324515,
-0.0005719992,
0.005098898,
-0.0009144532,
-0.0960471183,
-0.0406013392,
-0.0364937373,
0.0201808754,
-0.0557532795,
0.0106334491,
0.033061292,
-0.0272063389,
0.0510447025,
-0.0586822182,
-0.0143589145,
-0.0371641591,
-0.0016827672,
0.0224083625,
0.0631096214,
-0.0186988581,
0.0800308883,
0.0235001463,
0.0006312027,
0.0153461499,
-0.0030402958,
0.006057295,
0.0168594997,
0.0157618336,
0.0097672837,
0.0340432748,
-0.0193060413,
-0.0345931165,
0.0413140282,
-0.013792743,
0.0194313359,
0.0414510109,
0.019086929,
-0.0152887013,
-0.0284592193,
-0.0254733842,
0.0203313399,
-0.0018474592,
0.032765191,
-0.0103947865,
-0.0036174715,
0.0102560781,
0.0603051707,
-0.0217618961,
0.0325214565,
-0.0205351189,
-0.0458861515,
-0.0130165573,
0.0032951578,
-0.0137453936,
0.053000886,
-0.042195078,
0.0287153795,
1.917728461e-34,
0.0154450154,
-0.0298618414,
0.0095174909,
0.016218001,
0.0046893009,
0.0366192237,
0.0047353674,
-0.012715851,
-0.0057032146,
-0.0010758934,
-0.0515667573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10719v1 | LLM Censorship: A Machine Learning Challenge or a Computer Security Problem? | 2023-07-20T09:25:02 | 2023-07-20T09:25:02 | David Glukhov, Ilia Shumailov, Yarin Gal, Nicolas Papernot, Vardan Papyan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive capabilities in
comprehending complex instructions. However, their blind adherence to provided
instructions has led to concerns regarding risks of malicious use. Existing
defence mechanisms, such as model fine-tuning or output censorship using LLMs,
have proven to be fallible, as LLMs can still generate problematic responses.
Commonly employed censorship approaches treat the issue as a machine learning
problem and rely on another LM to detect undesirable content in LLM outputs. In
this paper, we present the theoretical limitations of such semantic censorship
approaches. Specifically, we demonstrate that semantic censorship can be
perceived as an undecidable problem, highlighting the inherent challenges in
censorship that arise due to LLMs' programmatic and instruction-following
capabilities. Furthermore, we argue that the challenges extend beyond semantic
censorship, as knowledgeable attackers can reconstruct impermissible outputs
from a collection of permissible ones. As a result, we propose that the problem
of censorship needs to be reevaluated; it should be treated as a security
problem which warrants the adaptation of security-based approaches to mitigate
potential risks. | [
0.0464117043,
0.0591940358,
-0.0237274058,
0.0349144414,
-0.0322338045,
-0.0187934954,
0.0191217344,
0.021477567,
0.0387055576,
-0.0579913892,
0.0088107232,
-0.0038574047,
-0.0319388732,
0.0115205394,
0.0489158146,
-0.0053872671,
0.0480010957,
-0.0330770314,
-0.0132758655,
-0.022414986,
-0.0118695293,
0.0088856136,
0.0517629236,
0.0415948443,
0.0122272242,
-0.0131016932,
0.0158049297,
0.0076281414,
-0.028115958,
0.0081697488,
-0.0179132763,
-0.0047541759,
-0.0112784682,
0.0556530505,
0.0000020725,
-0.0647215694,
-0.0482671671,
0.0494769737,
-0.0504965633,
0.0322450921,
0.0254797526,
-0.0380438194,
-0.0299892109,
0.0290444698,
-0.0225674473,
0.0473542511,
0.0352181904,
0.023356203,
0.0774971917,
0.0850638151,
-0.0252422839,
0.0085301073,
0.0320115313,
0.0054126224,
-0.0048879776,
-0.0260375384,
0.052241385,
-0.0335167423,
0.0014467536,
0.0074910587,
-0.0070843189,
0.0384890325,
0.0000522237,
0.0001724869,
-0.0602977909,
-0.030614065,
-0.0204001218,
-0.0420367531,
0.0063219336,
0.0225306768,
-0.0249041263,
-0.0149343852,
0.0254685003,
-0.0051030717,
0.0173783507,
0.0312158763,
-0.0070754061,
0.0526817963,
0.000032535,
0.0127973193,
0.0154663334,
-0.0362484232,
0.0638835654,
0.0226244032,
-0.0044796839,
0.0666373223,
0.0110521214,
-0.0380627699,
-0.0050852592,
-0.0616591871,
0.0120977852,
-0.0528721511,
0.0131851397,
0.0274828542,
-0.0189164747,
0.0275646076,
-0.0787126422,
-0.0057139737,
0.0430762768,
-0.0489308052,
0.0115176197,
0.0282151084,
0.0155677367,
0.0201186258,
-0.0183947794,
0.0416634195,
-0.0498120226,
0.0989284217,
0.0433083661,
0.0156198051,
-0.0093289092,
-0.0272773374,
0.0002743489,
0.0672957152,
-0.0180891491,
0.0378489718,
-0.0335560553,
0.0611926541,
-0.0568424091,
0.0617390126,
-0.0336573422,
-0.0227590967,
0.012840678,
0.0216980558,
0.0118145151,
-0.0552724376,
0.0242114775,
0.0009722323,
-0.0455999188,
-0.0659936294,
-0.0000240994,
0.0260552689,
-0.0562654436,
0.0035609393,
0.0034704646,
0.1367270499,
0.0421733521,
-0.0144926114,
-0.0272450596,
-0.1179404184,
-0.0238430649,
-0.0179645251,
0.0303939562,
-0.0249247085,
-0.0527165756,
-0.0203117616,
-0.0099804457,
-0.1003277898,
-0.0122866854,
0.0129257496,
-0.0422922149,
0.0596001856,
0.0101058036,
-0.0386842191,
-0.0002230811,
0.0602442808,
-0.0117800524,
0.0288571641,
0.0139761548,
0.0347486809,
0.0457539558,
-0.0123067163,
0.0239612814,
0.0164047051,
0.0261788927,
0.0105494745,
-0.0893788934,
0.0096698329,
0.0261116643,
-0.0616544522,
-0.0483010411,
0.0866652206,
-0.0021672493,
-0.0663679242,
0.0701848418,
0.027246628,
-0.0537118465,
0.0419922955,
0.0305358097,
0.0089112986,
-0.026240116,
0.0330463648,
-0.052851513,
-0.0284210555,
-0.0631037205,
-0.0431849696,
-0.0045928909,
0.0079215793,
0.0126450695,
-0.0308534373,
-0.0030680962,
-0.0287474822,
0.0484096073,
0.0144104604,
0.026296746,
0.0143641131,
-0.0216274988,
0.0161422249,
0.0181323569,
0.0074920715,
-0.0019989454,
-0.1090174317,
0.0077863745,
0.0646105632,
0.0872729719,
-0.0366159603,
0.0095474618,
-0.0168495364,
-0.0097246757,
0.0233248137,
-0.004867496,
0.0164357368,
0.00970471,
-0.0233970247,
-0.0219091941,
-0.0199985616,
0.0085866749,
-0.0251566991,
0.0083166109,
-0.0158697516,
0.0120321419,
0.0374679044,
-0.0316683054,
0.0438955538,
0.0300270468,
-0.0602720082,
-0.0022021716,
0.0216173902,
0.0296407435,
-0.0051290081,
-0.0103367409,
0.028357625,
0.0687869936,
0.0019284413,
-0.0174464267,
-0.0695826039,
-0.0281270761,
0.0545940697,
0.0289722532,
-0.0257916357,
0.006738144,
0.0421270505,
-0.0117319264,
0.0040561645,
0.0374446549,
-0.0481283143,
0.0195475444,
-0.0027828347,
0.0195597187,
-0.0194428712,
0.0359749831,
-0.0461669415,
-0.0079894839,
-0.0194474198,
-0.0110595413,
0.0494173951,
-0.0020815725,
0.0110730268,
-0.0053232824,
-0.0550813898,
0.0048022931,
-0.0237566214,
0.0301009957,
0.0118563846,
0.0047588241,
0.0053602643,
-0.0188713335,
-0.0038301914,
-0.0095306039,
0.0087343128,
0.0054064495,
0.0028688302,
-0.0051606088,
-0.0121188248,
-0.0370403901,
0.0087533575,
-0.031732399,
0.0007325872,
0.0294922143,
0.0220878776,
-0.0099551911,
-0.0658505559,
-0.0007322208,
-0.0222890694,
-0.0256300662,
0.0558072142,
-0.0246765185,
-0.0353172198,
-0.0228700321,
0.0567107536,
-0.0446627773,
0.0313218385,
-0.0090295644,
-0.0132863931,
0.0432207547,
0.0066934931,
-0.0518027991,
0.0396856964,
0.0085238917,
0.0418726206,
0.099029474,
0.0214450974,
-0.0350968391,
-0.0152142849,
0.0106535507,
-0.0266732853,
-0.0497704931,
-0.0087137204,
0.0144864852,
0.0185402501,
0.0411283635,
-0.0094906464,
-0.0328889526,
0.061871402,
-0.0200084727,
-0.0322167315,
-0.0035488931,
-0.0779389292,
-0.0379715078,
0.027222788,
0.0005595757,
-0.0936557204,
0.0828285292,
-0.0422657542,
0.0275076646,
0.0131496359,
-0.0377481692,
0.0074869473,
0.0241957884,
-0.0082733864,
0.0298031494,
0.0366916358,
-0.0221106634,
-0.0482544675,
-0.0273107439,
0.0314112753,
-0.0330406055,
0.0041234614,
-0.0314713828,
-0.0148938214,
0.003314913,
-0.0209031384,
-0.0622751154,
-0.0583370887,
-0.0025966086,
0.0076634316,
0.0400273837,
-0.0153540215,
0.007109947,
-0.0124396142,
0.0329699814,
-0.0301039331,
0.0199954491,
-0.0157089233,
-0.0368066579,
-0.0289005395,
0.018241711,
-0.0344258882,
-0.0344835371,
0.0051988568,
0.0263715852,
0.0776720345,
-0.0144230332,
-0.0179656725,
0.0185203683,
0.0212143138,
0.0404208153,
0.0179681815,
-0.0018672841,
0.0577903315,
0.0218391214,
-0.0389430039,
-0.0259171724,
0.052762948,
0.0273542944,
-0.007869157,
0.0016392884,
0.0053999154,
0.0011719267,
-0.0000699364,
0.0179317575,
-0.0796648711,
0.0075107361,
0.049137108,
0.0585530549,
-0.0593137629,
0.0023401743,
-0.027562473,
-0.0662625954,
0.0197347961,
0.0205332302,
-0.0201153606,
-0.0278557409,
-0.0540004037,
-0.0419587344,
0.0172156338,
0.0177792739,
-0.0604949109,
0.0107291937,
-0.0381947123,
0.0200702194,
-0.0362262428,
-0.0021249538,
0.0282701552,
-0.0129865408,
0.0379894786,
0.0789453536,
0.0026985588,
-0.0142879132,
-0.009641544,
0.0626349524,
0.0018227806,
-0.0095314821,
-0.0238901619,
0.01335546,
0.0135274427,
-0.0293593351,
-0.0111581618,
0.0274004638,
0.0387991071,
-0.036179807,
0.0194534902,
0.0783170685,
-0.0493164212,
-0.0064755026,
-0.0362195186,
0.0065879701,
0.019773338,
0.0624536984,
0.0252656136,
-0.0494545437,
-0.0255724061,
-0.0899460167,
-0.0074839406,
-0.0265576467,
-0.0458251946,
0.0052097579,
-0.0202624444,
-0.0328522958,
-0.0360426642,
0.0075213369,
-0.042172417,
-0.0191402007,
0.0542441644,
-0.0164569803,
0.0400054678,
0.0072019063,
-0.0045477487,
-0.0554883629,
-0.0559297688,
0.0245618504,
-0.0577748828,
0.0199582037,
-0.0122954287,
-0.0042669675,
-0.013434343,
0.0301303212,
-0.0190550312,
-0.0918816701,
0.0158491731,
0.0710174143,
0.0262601934,
0.0092390785,
-0.0284674801,
-0.0705999956,
0.0927592888,
0.0481032878,
-0.0183875971,
0.0181803778,
0.0812834501,
-0.0328014307,
0.0071689836,
0.0226430744,
-0.0357328989,
-0.0020773867,
0.0742117688,
-0.048411198,
-0.0727929249,
-0.0362446234,
0.0059665432,
0.0602885708,
0.0030860305,
-0.0128906211,
-0.0286051761,
0.0259829052,
0.0135320593,
-0.0085778832,
-0.0316182151,
-0.0022319958,
0.0107101258,
0.0240601748,
-0.02736203,
0.0249130987,
-0.0163181126,
-0.0119167035,
0.0188382808,
-0.000735293,
0.0610501841,
-0.009383156,
0.0354389735,
0.0322218947,
0.0239442997,
-0.0226641856,
0.089690268,
0.0066789244,
0.0002038675,
-0.001346275,
0.0294584837,
-0.0010158081,
0.0576007701,
-0.0374643691,
0.0304716602,
-0.0349433646,
-0.0284423605,
0.0107585099,
0.0428872332,
-0.0114414385,
0.0150652286,
-0.0084309131,
-0.0023310685,
-0.0064943563,
-0.0480949953,
-0.006458269,
0.0110993935,
-0.03758277,
0.0351955928,
-0.0095780576,
-0.0158390123,
0.0116152503,
0.0496029295,
0.0214879885,
0.064337045,
0.0294811707,
-0.0655901134,
-0.0487688482,
-0.0517799146,
0.0262570865,
0.0069695991,
-0.028041929,
-0.004732993,
-0.0691704452,
-0.0856198967,
-0.0132895745,
0.0001222782,
0.0460630842,
-0.032768622,
-0.0419850424,
0.0358101092,
0.0394379795,
-0.003808629,
-0.0902376249,
0.0129677961,
0.0239714887,
-0.0373335779,
0.0022644496,
-5.182949284e-33,
-0.0120353522,
-0.0418839715,
-0.0266581029,
0.0290262904,
0.0503507629,
-0.0017063502,
-0.0078051151,
-0.0239214115,
-0.0299642682,
-0.0297276005,
-0.0097031957,
-0.0104305129,
-0.0097846212,
0.0074670934,
-0.0354273543,
-0.019069355,
0.0159969851,
-0.0211758371,
-0.0213681068,
0.0211827438,
0.0713321716,
-0.0041742232,
-0.0262432173,
-0.092390053,
0.0482306853,
0.0034739159,
-0.0284871925,
-0.0084045287,
-0.0721612275,
0.0736297145,
-0.0204039253,
0.0347959921,
0.0186863318,
-0.0322004519,
-0.0273621138,
0.0543825664,
0.0218201578,
-0.0129388375,
0.0173329338,
-0.0132244341,
0.0285956375,
-0.0812829509,
0.0701248199,
-0.0135193877,
-0.0154297203,
0.0010785525,
-0.0092145186,
-0.02885326,
-0.0347811021,
-0.0321334787,
-0.0539090373,
0.0075219683,
-0.0212055519,
-0.016459221,
0.0576399714,
0.0050694868,
0.040503893,
0.0066192765,
-0.0402307138,
0.0520113818,
0.0229076743,
0.0244626813,
0.0542083383,
-0.0054079359,
-0.014091081,
0.0273673125,
-0.0322540328,
0.0014157285,
0.0137137854,
-0.0117795942,
0.0235109907,
0.040777415,
0.0481167585,
0.0255007856,
0.026938092,
-0.0528900884,
-0.0535700247,
0.0156008871,
-0.0501287729,
0.0496141613,
0.0375879258,
0.0173534043,
-0.0445331,
-0.0044603925,
-0.015483181,
-0.0046770517,
-0.0371905901,
-0.0011000516,
0.0096370829,
0.0006302407,
-0.0455751382,
0.0079507604,
0.0049550617,
-0.0859562308,
0.02176027,
0.0127481716,
0.0053639677,
-0.0473864265,
0.0043518874,
-0.0070704529,
-0.005967719,
-0.0280846208,
0.0315265395,
-0.0673109666,
0.0439103656,
-0.0064209322,
0.0479523949,
0.0591858216,
-0.0694834068,
-0.0111351898,
-0.033275798,
0.0448569767,
0.0231786445,
0.0364508443,
0.0304500479,
-0.0082848174,
0.01694398,
-0.0174164232,
-0.0020332197,
-0.0254083835,
-0.0175523367,
0.023029156,
0.0052601076,
0.0094185947,
-0.0219674241,
0.0008246176,
0.0055158273,
0.0728082061,
0.0487329885,
-0.0451017506,
-0.0062318533,
-0.0325552821,
2.859e-7,
0.0132467402,
-0.0001094928,
0.0358799994,
0.0346131548,
0.0233935229,
0.0590997189,
0.0091424743,
0.0484329425,
-0.0356518552,
-0.018631557,
0.0102577396,
0.0082994653,
0.0496323258,
-0.0023495543,
-0.0202909615,
0.0271423776,
-0.0460451618,
0.0087254392,
-0.039827019,
0.029379636,
0.0817731395,
0.0974531323,
0.0177448746,
-0.0224357489,
-0.0229024328,
-0.0671426877,
0.0078329435,
-0.0269548614,
0.0136496592,
-0.0259899572,
0.0503015108,
0.0424229801,
0.0221838132,
0.02652313,
-0.0375127047,
-0.0112021016,
-0.0438731425,
0.0931177363,
0.0326008648,
0.0042440421,
-0.0197283588,
-0.0297535136,
-0.0140177784,
-0.0239981469,
0.0595275611,
0.0234138686,
-0.026407253,
-0.0160873495,
0.0191228725,
-0.0535159968,
0.0460661091,
-0.0303794816,
-0.0123487832,
-0.0042549125,
-0.006814471,
-0.0039903233,
0.037633203,
-0.0658491924,
-0.0251088273,
-0.0434375256,
-0.0285182074,
-0.0179094207,
-0.0018382994,
0.030444419,
0.0071432865,
-0.0241619796,
0.0247821491,
3.032452394e-34,
0.004814642,
-0.062471468,
0.0041859443,
0.0066470974,
0.0134130428,
0.018100353,
-0.0184813067,
0.0181905571,
0.0164442379,
-0.0259751584,
-0.0050426833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10700v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10700v4 | Topics, Authors, and Institutions in Large Language Model Research: Trends from 17K arXiv Papers | 2023-07-20T08:45:00 | 2024-04-28T23:13:16 | Rajiv Movva, Sidhika Balachandar, Kenny Peng, Gabriel Agostini, Nikhil Garg, Emma Pierson | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.CY | Large language models (LLMs) are dramatically influencing AI research,
spurring discussions on what has changed so far and how to shape the field's
future. To clarify such questions, we analyze a new dataset of 16,979
LLM-related arXiv papers, focusing on recent trends in 2023 vs. 2018-2022.
First, we study disciplinary shifts: LLM research increasingly considers
societal impacts, evidenced by 20x growth in LLM submissions to the Computers
and Society sub-arXiv. An influx of new authors -- half of all first authors in
2023 -- are entering from non-NLP fields of CS, driving disciplinary expansion.
Second, we study industry and academic publishing trends. Surprisingly,
industry accounts for a smaller publication share in 2023, largely due to
reduced output from Google and other Big Tech companies; universities in Asia
are publishing more. Third, we study institutional collaboration: while
industry-academic collaborations are common, they tend to focus on the same
topics that industry focuses on rather than bridging differences. The most
prolific institutions are all US- or China-based, but there is very little
cross-country collaboration. We discuss implications around (1) how to support
the influx of new authors, (2) how industry trends may affect academics, and
(3) possible effects of (the lack of) collaboration. | [
0.0564034581,
0.1138810068,
-0.017532248,
0.0198737532,
-0.0372195132,
-0.0335858911,
0.061121542,
0.0053528966,
0.0260511972,
-0.0420369245,
-0.0078253606,
-0.0118756304,
0.0098813893,
0.0644657388,
0.0165546071,
-0.0158249829,
0.0127451401,
-0.0349637195,
0.0239148438,
-0.054102663,
-0.001854252,
-0.0063100467,
0.0132048139,
0.0583027452,
0.0526935048,
-0.0279362742,
0.0135194268,
-0.0323692411,
-0.0138455499,
-0.00504047,
0.0147229424,
0.045747485,
0.0173177402,
0.0969712883,
0.0000019084,
-0.0702157095,
-0.0097658662,
0.0448703617,
0.035493426,
0.0576269254,
0.0156449527,
-0.024542328,
-0.049821265,
0.0057184128,
-0.0515037663,
0.011128149,
0.0441549756,
-0.0043439935,
-0.0318712592,
0.0391550027,
-0.0055419551,
-0.0403357185,
0.0767289102,
-0.0226025507,
-0.0519362912,
-0.0325690396,
0.0298646484,
-0.0210347492,
0.0323379412,
0.0418905318,
-0.0123716211,
0.0523125082,
0.009868294,
-0.036471922,
0.0236961879,
0.1024126187,
-0.044676736,
0.001361134,
0.0075509925,
0.0402569175,
0.0561446026,
-0.0365157314,
0.0510469563,
-0.0040391865,
-0.028866034,
0.0367855653,
-0.0187053103,
0.0594373159,
0.0247069001,
0.008208503,
0.0615949892,
-0.0008466445,
0.0426434241,
0.0784711987,
-0.0084087318,
0.0405742452,
0.0116591919,
-0.0419160537,
0.0000248558,
-0.0027799227,
-0.0070963344,
-0.056196183,
0.006157151,
-0.0011152787,
0.0215290822,
-0.0024985974,
0.0123272482,
-0.0103934128,
0.0053389026,
-0.0360819995,
-0.0197880529,
0.0105888899,
0.016059529,
0.0584532917,
-0.0108696865,
0.0148980366,
-0.0383974798,
0.004668477,
0.0229423307,
0.014265934,
-0.0367282294,
-0.0119417589,
-0.0189528447,
-0.0049161152,
0.0181541815,
-0.0286261421,
-0.0238525905,
0.0215195995,
-0.0323775746,
0.0150510194,
-0.007894027,
-0.0005821744,
-0.0224814918,
-0.0127935568,
-0.0056200661,
0.0621686131,
-0.0036291073,
0.0280056037,
-0.0083968919,
-0.0132243279,
0.0140793016,
0.0127685154,
-0.0046718018,
-0.0370326452,
0.0318379812,
0.0303362906,
0.0277964994,
-0.0145419408,
0.0226132851,
-0.0105893165,
-0.0214332491,
-0.0554821528,
0.0124435984,
-0.0680709183,
0.0144611765,
0.0302168913,
0.0191271119,
-0.0914351717,
-0.0288662985,
-0.0235882849,
-0.0208052434,
-0.0124354847,
-0.0290407818,
0.0166722946,
0.0284361579,
-0.0161995012,
0.0048786053,
0.0258204564,
0.0275283922,
-0.0026188041,
0.0649324581,
-0.0161549579,
0.0217611454,
0.0302155856,
-0.0032876923,
0.0318900086,
0.004472889,
-0.0023389512,
0.0077148876,
0.0203011539,
0.0037105819,
0.0738524348,
0.001877024,
-0.0058531011,
0.0476268008,
0.0634264126,
-0.0225434359,
0.047781121,
-0.0106051629,
-0.004186613,
0.0105567547,
-0.0502010994,
-0.0221535005,
0.0053435354,
-0.0170043334,
0.0141512891,
0.0465278141,
0.0238950904,
-0.0250255018,
-0.0228890963,
0.0046392349,
0.0154108694,
0.0066165528,
0.0038012499,
0.0843526796,
-0.0536276326,
-0.0091342283,
-0.006052461,
-0.0067591751,
-0.0335845873,
0.0031429275,
-0.0375831425,
0.0412977189,
0.0201806482,
0.0647275522,
-0.0178665929,
0.0191849284,
0.0036867426,
0.0176900625,
0.0621742718,
0.0065110461,
0.0228126775,
-0.0299043972,
0.0075296587,
0.0125947222,
-0.0016853333,
-0.0107201329,
-0.0121503817,
0.0241119135,
0.0296301842,
-0.0299205314,
0.0041188863,
-0.0712414384,
0.0003264994,
-0.081015572,
0.0330744386,
-0.0197667088,
-0.0142595395,
0.0261911061,
0.031641528,
-0.0516181663,
0.0107078636,
0.0480574816,
-0.0370418429,
-0.0148289995,
0.012095347,
0.0482704043,
0.071868524,
0.0571031161,
-0.036854133,
0.0322586969,
-0.0256851539,
-0.0163032413,
-0.0121423621,
0.0968877003,
0.0390594229,
0.052977249,
0.0045521483,
0.0018763574,
-0.0536955446,
0.0255518574,
-0.0242495965,
0.0350271948,
-0.0179937016,
0.0379840247,
0.0113899466,
-0.0175731331,
0.0126149328,
0.0032876516,
-0.0487739556,
0.0484234355,
0.0035096884,
0.030711947,
0.0818059295,
-0.0397951789,
0.0193461888,
-0.0399359539,
-0.0223184694,
-0.0273258369,
-0.0022607946,
-0.0135611454,
0.0036647895,
-0.0104276538,
-0.0157272853,
0.0502437092,
-0.0042337626,
-0.0441715419,
0.002240319,
-0.0107108951,
0.0190529302,
-0.0021361203,
-0.0357579403,
-0.0390551537,
-0.0246334132,
-0.0214562546,
0.0137735177,
0.0320942067,
-0.0193202402,
-0.0624126568,
0.0643436611,
-0.0402888618,
0.0335521661,
-0.0573016517,
0.001537279,
0.0034563625,
-0.0041282712,
0.0000160283,
0.0413248353,
-0.0431244187,
0.0385372192,
0.0608956702,
0.0174461249,
-0.0287602041,
-0.0001380572,
-0.0109541714,
-0.0192741826,
-0.0168349724,
-0.0346128009,
0.0138628092,
0.0482890867,
-0.0286834892,
-0.037099883,
-0.0065818494,
-0.0001697206,
-0.0359318703,
-0.0111534027,
-0.0111912694,
-0.0237898733,
0.0111694625,
0.064366512,
-0.0089675933,
-0.0414137989,
0.0295027364,
-0.0471942835,
0.0154425865,
-0.0459294058,
-0.0536409691,
-0.0535168685,
0.0831246376,
-0.0074041742,
0.0072738463,
0.027101133,
0.0174895748,
-0.0296136346,
0.0153928054,
-0.0362922847,
-0.0116902031,
0.0314410925,
-0.0308664609,
0.0488580354,
-0.0339584462,
-0.0123825353,
0.0121223163,
-0.0429943129,
-0.0412150212,
0.0295795538,
0.068116121,
-0.0850331485,
0.0004861132,
0.0042447625,
0.0474339984,
0.0184348989,
-0.0066746944,
-0.0079731196,
-0.0281879585,
0.0009061727,
0.055368267,
0.0138352411,
0.0265706647,
-0.0106249331,
-0.0011317089,
0.0307212155,
0.0545238219,
0.0174062531,
-0.0306650568,
-0.0340147838,
0.0434941389,
-0.038284786,
-0.0337227955,
0.0007164642,
0.0325730629,
-0.0368704386,
0.0187952481,
0.0842505395,
0.0070673274,
-0.0549230166,
0.0150300264,
-0.0073058554,
0.0498492718,
0.0174777955,
0.0525526814,
-0.090353772,
0.0433271118,
0.0109865693,
-0.0453977734,
-0.0425770357,
-0.042685464,
-0.0179864578,
-0.0860174224,
0.0533278063,
-0.0113946646,
-0.0234555155,
-0.0017631248,
-0.0346176773,
-0.0040827603,
-0.0001317474,
0.0230740812,
-0.0084810099,
-0.0169710219,
-0.0034757664,
0.0317261629,
-0.0516548194,
-0.0479061976,
0.0143450769,
-0.0467596501,
0.0444025323,
0.0399980918,
0.0551500283,
-0.0632894561,
-0.0194097329,
-0.0075266599,
0.0383924469,
-0.0051666545,
0.0000095486,
0.0046241512,
0.0124903945,
-0.0159003008,
-0.0120822731,
0.0191394109,
-0.0579583123,
-0.0064821364,
0.0129362242,
0.0637375563,
-0.0231990684,
-0.0287446287,
-0.011495973,
-0.0254034102,
-0.0410177186,
0.051430434,
-0.0315477662,
-0.0810336769,
-0.0390725359,
-0.0420255996,
0.0397128202,
0.0212738924,
-0.0308120716,
-0.0416118689,
-0.0089918394,
-0.0432342701,
-0.0232563987,
-0.0299160443,
0.0178079773,
-0.0067925905,
0.049559623,
0.0320680924,
0.0687799305,
-0.0219003223,
-0.0044987081,
-0.0009216194,
-0.0460024253,
0.0499074645,
-0.0553808957,
-0.0024860161,
0.0247570314,
-0.0024130847,
-0.0465461165,
0.0109715993,
-0.0413789935,
-0.064814806,
0.0013766305,
0.0085498448,
0.0220403001,
-0.0050318092,
-0.0235817805,
-0.053435415,
0.0193646979,
0.0346568637,
-0.0101101631,
0.0194995068,
-0.0005201518,
-0.0333184078,
-0.0090202829,
0.0099815903,
-0.0357062332,
-0.0329732075,
0.010327843,
0.0055293036,
-0.0319115184,
-0.0413826853,
0.0034705421,
0.0141498689,
0.034566123,
-0.04311141,
0.0272774864,
-0.0217970144,
-0.0260636732,
-0.0037946086,
0.0032090254,
-0.0373583734,
-0.042012427,
0.0267766267,
-0.005680108,
0.0021889552,
0.0634540021,
0.0220785774,
0.023389155,
-0.0529567301,
0.0536638051,
-0.0388179459,
0.0770665035,
0.0606523976,
0.0042519704,
-0.0049757631,
0.0491873883,
-0.0492370948,
0.0585144125,
-0.0052666101,
0.0151527058,
0.0080959415,
-0.0353718549,
0.0096240407,
0.0209367294,
-0.1075861827,
-0.0972251669,
0.0311928056,
0.0327013619,
0.0642887726,
0.0241119768,
0.0415364541,
-0.0480288602,
0.0072984835,
-0.0361598432,
0.0380645767,
0.0326995775,
-0.0293167252,
-0.0071073449,
-0.0095972307,
-0.0447907411,
0.0228537805,
0.0830156803,
0.0446808599,
0.0035389524,
0.0359165072,
0.0067539513,
0.0394010134,
-0.0487940162,
-0.0015223114,
0.0282812323,
-0.0152644813,
0.019389404,
-0.0538626425,
-0.0313986503,
-0.0200746488,
-0.0228807013,
-0.0286915917,
-0.0661096424,
-0.0208539665,
0.0385276191,
-0.0172895957,
-0.0192940924,
-0.0470984206,
0.0046694032,
-0.0397816487,
-0.0556162558,
0.0150923971,
-6.375790258e-33,
0.0364904962,
-0.0184269473,
0.0182695333,
-0.0046270574,
-0.0284569506,
0.0209407043,
-0.0317218117,
0.0197780542,
-0.0672885254,
-0.0010957021,
-0.0652022809,
-0.0079419855,
-0.0012266011,
0.021465376,
0.056623254,
0.0162137412,
0.0341871716,
-0.0018962199,
0.0271240268,
0.0309764594,
-0.0048411959,
-0.0252597108,
0.0345726535,
-0.0726873502,
0.0637227818,
-0.0076836501,
-0.0143044693,
-0.0047841589,
0.0150120845,
0.0322186388,
-0.0374903865,
0.0387912989,
0.0017909686,
-0.0818913504,
-0.0121013988,
-0.0401004702,
-0.0589304119,
0.0218566116,
0.0244940873,
-0.0018629057,
0.0242041573,
-0.0448952839,
0.042469278,
-0.003575224,
-0.0379169062,
-0.0007156249,
0.0500756577,
-0.0058616037,
-0.0387803391,
-0.0101879695,
-0.0333199799,
0.0065466925,
-0.0084800115,
0.0587983951,
0.0065954877,
-0.0018949563,
-0.0170744453,
0.0837851316,
-0.091599457,
0.0370488763,
-0.0086460384,
0.0430246145,
0.0554080121,
-0.0163460672,
0.0268914253,
0.0544054508,
0.0145482272,
0.0252600517,
-0.0043109958,
-0.0419557281,
0.02619607,
0.06621214,
-0.0128046134,
0.0258659758,
0.0172577668,
-0.0435074791,
-0.0530560724,
-0.0206368919,
0.0580732822,
-0.0039308588,
0.0467860028,
0.0004463343,
-0.0456645936,
-0.0526275672,
0.0098546501,
-0.0421159975,
0.0170317013,
-0.0219776239,
-0.0144299762,
-0.0088619022,
-0.0004827605,
0.0223400332,
0.0575959496,
-0.1017519757,
-0.1018726677,
0.0408183523,
-0.0060745319,
0.0625628456,
0.0142134307,
0.0186003074,
-0.1287974268,
-0.0379727893,
-0.0557158403,
0.02748264,
0.0060878373,
0.0133783836,
-0.0184564367,
0.0263511948,
-0.0258592311,
-0.0037729621,
-0.0295919739,
0.0044186292,
0.0379816741,
0.02623225,
-0.0086956425,
0.0438099504,
0.0357832313,
-0.0037088613,
0.0314321257,
0.0373815782,
-0.0045836698,
0.0304500554,
-0.0356132984,
0.0198280048,
-0.0324903317,
-0.0300182346,
-0.0455084033,
0.0455828011,
0.0762735158,
-0.0533207692,
-0.0196601823,
-0.0594609044,
2.751e-7,
0.0340015516,
0.033227589,
-0.0039448445,
0.0255610812,
0.0375367142,
0.0252834614,
-0.0109912464,
0.0293701589,
-0.0070544751,
0.0446332581,
-0.006096249,
0.0299086962,
0.0167088043,
-0.0029309853,
-0.0786071792,
-0.0141829299,
-0.1048869342,
0.0137698306,
-0.0791740865,
0.0124941198,
-0.0486682691,
0.0538897924,
0.029011663,
0.0146585023,
-0.0275044609,
-0.0444081351,
0.0418560691,
-0.049028933,
0.0303567648,
0.0570621826,
-0.01817392,
-0.004618017,
-0.0099471183,
-0.0128536876,
0.0097283926,
0.0403109007,
-0.0085043926,
0.021698555,
0.0180075504,
0.0458382517,
0.0272904932,
-0.0295752529,
-0.0078480495,
-0.0817465112,
0.0560561866,
-0.007952068,
-0.0566343814,
-0.0603531003,
-0.0111837955,
-0.0200342182,
0.0113616716,
-0.0015754518,
-0.000807408,
0.0052914908,
-0.0011266114,
-0.0295872949,
-0.0073365322,
-0.0513566397,
-0.0263314825,
-0.0052741566,
-0.0049283532,
-0.0667551905,
-0.0291845668,
-0.0214714669,
0.0488630719,
-0.0161474328,
0.038512677,
2.593811167e-34,
0.0482792445,
-0.0121242264,
-0.0198111478,
0.0733537152,
0.0236085709,
-0.0054821852,
-0.0235638879,
0.0050570448,
-0.00283766,
-0.0517832637,
-0.016303461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10666v1 | A Dataset and Strong Baselines for Classification of Czech News Texts | 2023-07-20T07:47:08 | 2023-07-20T07:47:08 | Hynek Kydlíček, Jindřich Libovický | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained models for Czech Natural Language Processing are often evaluated
on purely linguistic tasks (POS tagging, parsing, NER) and relatively simple
classification tasks such as sentiment classification or article classification
from a single news source. As an alternative, we present
CZEch~NEws~Classification~dataset (CZE-NEC), one of the largest Czech
classification datasets, composed of news articles from various sources
spanning over twenty years, which allows a more rigorous evaluation of such
models. We define four classification tasks: news source, news category,
inferred author's gender, and day of the week. To verify the task difficulty,
we conducted a human evaluation, which revealed that human performance lags
behind strong machine-learning baselines built upon pre-trained transformer
models. Furthermore, we show that language-specific pre-trained encoder
analysis outperforms selected commercially available large-scale generative
language models. | [
0.0363751054,
0.119757548,
0.0179322399,
0.0276045185,
0.0058642388,
0.0643504336,
0.0184579641,
-0.0313923582,
-0.0351681374,
-0.0447938517,
-0.0033455568,
-0.0039707837,
-0.0283285938,
0.0214571059,
0.0064206151,
-0.0320838466,
0.0289663505,
0.0085350405,
0.0084764753,
-0.0180379357,
0.0129484748,
0.0145272752,
0.0095392866,
0.0212417413,
0.0065733916,
0.0093773054,
0.0043424545,
-0.0138521343,
0.0049338625,
-0.00833683,
0.0021572975,
0.03657059,
0.0247912537,
0.0124961985,
0.0000017292,
-0.0555623546,
-0.007356354,
-0.0324754976,
0.0125122694,
-0.0455789305,
0.0755183995,
-0.1201210767,
-0.0281119607,
0.0131901074,
-0.0421276987,
-0.1142667979,
0.0159543287,
0.0295303036,
0.0340207107,
0.1110343561,
-0.0274894796,
-0.0154519323,
0.0050197756,
-0.0076997411,
-0.0188943911,
-0.0067284484,
0.0445231758,
-0.0332524031,
-0.0665988997,
0.0124175623,
-0.0086015919,
0.0034056131,
0.0353446677,
-0.0189821385,
0.01377887,
0.0346924625,
-0.0327909999,
-0.0459155329,
0.009140837,
0.0095715784,
-0.0382297337,
-0.0484943949,
0.0052598868,
0.0070356419,
-0.0233953558,
0.0122073796,
-0.0242309757,
0.0364590436,
-0.0016506847,
0.0225117728,
0.0427661203,
0.0239305235,
0.0105148051,
0.0229193345,
-0.0175076723,
0.0769994557,
0.010432777,
-0.0093135834,
0.0689628273,
0.0569796972,
0.0290084295,
-0.0464152098,
0.0245289411,
0.0070693125,
0.0048897308,
-0.0170913804,
-0.0245442279,
-0.0091138193,
-0.0048333565,
-0.110298261,
-0.0277117603,
0.0225140434,
0.0161644537,
0.0175387301,
-0.027074907,
0.0111848889,
0.0004192821,
0.0310980491,
-0.0314534195,
-0.0486847609,
-0.0384584554,
0.0199961793,
-0.0282472316,
-0.0063848067,
-0.0239107087,
-0.0016169571,
-0.0621212199,
0.0182926133,
0.0241396949,
-0.0010534375,
0.0003453502,
0.0409451649,
-0.0089878691,
0.0214756541,
-0.0234748833,
0.0495425686,
-0.0331510268,
0.0347672328,
-0.0327360742,
-0.0290016737,
0.0076118372,
0.0132831754,
0.009526033,
-0.0421418957,
0.0456287526,
-0.0208861344,
-0.0219442043,
-0.0007668213,
-0.0201108921,
0.0136560509,
-0.0092407977,
-0.0501702763,
0.0123808812,
-0.0634106621,
0.0141633395,
0.0372759216,
-0.0009930636,
-0.035361208,
-0.0163869653,
0.0235082731,
-0.01594772,
0.0941313133,
0.0278104208,
-0.0100506246,
0.0543777645,
-0.0041916696,
0.0454129726,
0.0595609844,
-0.0017557245,
0.0457791276,
0.0172069184,
-0.0079009105,
0.0392828211,
0.0284198038,
-0.0080331471,
-0.0481449217,
0.0021182157,
0.0360041521,
-0.0268118717,
0.011577745,
0.0812556371,
0.0216678865,
-0.0077234213,
-0.0212063137,
0.049007982,
0.0174012035,
0.0232550297,
0.0611108206,
0.0288146548,
-0.0225291084,
0.0080417935,
-0.0354921483,
-0.0161766652,
-0.0108324625,
-0.0393563062,
-0.0007819714,
-0.0525664985,
0.0334256776,
-0.04925666,
-0.0368360095,
0.0105495509,
-0.0288997702,
0.0574475229,
-0.0217596833,
0.0985372141,
0.0093454476,
-0.0183617398,
0.0235521961,
0.0224979185,
-0.0629325584,
0.0186277498,
-0.0269178245,
0.0216799546,
0.0372373834,
0.0153804785,
-0.0027562431,
0.034914162,
-0.0290462617,
0.0139604537,
0.0039677811,
0.0212751217,
-0.0392629243,
0.0027977149,
-0.0354956537,
-0.0144014014,
-0.0079843523,
0.0213430319,
0.0238918234,
0.0001383435,
0.058227174,
0.0270524956,
0.0142674297,
-0.0092050061,
0.0161772538,
-0.0018198831,
-0.0199416187,
0.0089267567,
0.0257576685,
0.0156879183,
0.019050803,
-0.0022888239,
-0.0119689731,
0.0480738096,
-0.0381846279,
-0.0381302573,
0.0124337925,
-0.0305247344,
-0.0867729038,
-0.0180106461,
-0.0611809082,
0.0077277203,
0.052031979,
-0.0434061661,
-0.0235952102,
0.0421162583,
-0.0141046904,
0.0049238214,
-0.0383965261,
0.0078106858,
-0.0164727028,
0.0335752591,
0.0108792223,
0.0442553498,
-0.012758119,
0.0392646492,
-0.015651891,
-0.0113464119,
0.018225519,
-0.0217884313,
-0.048726812,
0.0496111177,
-0.0071810703,
-0.0002679749,
0.0420342423,
0.0069060479,
-0.0051406706,
-0.0141588617,
-0.1034025624,
0.0092538772,
-0.0239217579,
0.0495014265,
0.019363815,
-0.004808587,
0.0035649533,
-0.0079982113,
-0.0413856581,
-0.0430533327,
0.0136080757,
0.0157386828,
0.0352314599,
-0.020115668,
0.0216645803,
-0.002994827,
-0.0136019327,
-0.0264233015,
0.030845223,
0.0218890272,
-0.0304416548,
-0.0405037589,
0.0583366714,
-0.0021314046,
0.0148870684,
-0.0277203992,
-0.0643392429,
-0.0012132727,
0.0121751325,
0.0413132086,
0.0894830152,
0.0004356568,
0.0419729464,
-0.0029047285,
0.0260541495,
-0.0221372843,
-0.0281286053,
-0.0661770552,
0.0092229405,
-0.0406077281,
-0.0202985499,
-0.0061967755,
0.0434527136,
-0.0124615105,
-0.0025123057,
-0.0117771141,
0.0192717686,
-0.0397405252,
-0.0000613713,
-0.0331300646,
-0.0301912799,
0.0192920696,
0.0337567516,
-0.0118194353,
0.0045588082,
0.0451854914,
-0.01290897,
-0.0127156861,
-0.0413440019,
-0.0364000462,
-0.0394213311,
0.0465226062,
0.0161375813,
0.0002211474,
-0.0012830851,
-0.0517792441,
-0.0234131925,
-0.0252891127,
0.0038003675,
-0.0171262193,
0.0396071188,
-0.0036146566,
-0.0019850137,
-0.0076186527,
-0.0549158975,
-0.038614098,
-0.0836542696,
-0.0019312545,
-0.0079219434,
0.035632614,
-0.0107616391,
-0.0073751956,
0.009019604,
-0.0162070412,
0.0648848638,
-0.0154295601,
-0.018211564,
0.0164981652,
0.0381389819,
0.0053774966,
-0.0268898122,
0.0061176168,
-0.019700706,
-0.0301801302,
0.0550918728,
-0.0153161353,
0.0144040808,
-0.0337939784,
0.0059381789,
0.0364954174,
-0.009763727,
0.0213881098,
-0.0480415411,
0.0078028049,
-0.0529741496,
-0.0350416899,
0.1531126201,
0.011588281,
-0.0577760525,
-0.0147314444,
0.022071125,
-0.042759195,
0.0308363214,
0.0226229336,
-0.0716790706,
-0.0052695074,
0.0106522571,
0.000748532,
-0.0396355055,
-0.0045379647,
0.019626569,
-0.1143089682,
-0.0193676837,
-0.0177275799,
-0.0446792766,
-0.0081715146,
-0.0854088515,
-0.033327505,
-0.0811195746,
-0.0223052111,
-0.0325745307,
-0.0026482351,
0.0031117154,
0.0221313145,
-0.0475683883,
-0.0706407651,
0.0127505651,
-0.0005679628,
0.0133609781,
0.0261076428,
0.0324467756,
-0.0308931749,
-0.022424696,
0.0221367218,
-0.032737568,
-0.0090566967,
-0.0281519443,
0.0818698034,
-0.0036858984,
-0.0023813283,
-0.0249311272,
0.0252628364,
-0.0239668675,
0.0041826954,
-0.0327977538,
0.018536089,
-0.0002577175,
-0.0327691436,
0.0173064284,
-0.0064937612,
0.0402299985,
0.0576898977,
0.0041307611,
-0.0121011045,
-0.0345488451,
-0.0132782906,
0.0182762519,
-0.0390694924,
-0.0470849611,
0.0137003167,
0.0121938838,
-0.1062971577,
-0.0440897867,
-0.0520119816,
0.032361947,
0.0210961811,
-0.0323683023,
-0.0354155749,
0.0348298326,
-0.0054047834,
-0.0718101636,
0.0562862009,
0.0215814672,
-0.0290949121,
-0.0464286394,
-0.0368401445,
0.0513057522,
-0.006174441,
-0.0372583196,
-0.0092737768,
-0.0466569997,
-0.0283008106,
0.0150904683,
0.0355980583,
0.0164125822,
0.0405335948,
-0.0086199008,
-0.0315318443,
0.0792315379,
0.0466009378,
-0.0509123914,
-0.0146264639,
0.0253308993,
-0.006926225,
0.0158797223,
0.0001450341,
0.0171083603,
0.0817217082,
-0.0119848372,
-0.0621286817,
-0.016785061,
-0.0345635824,
-0.0207968857,
-0.0002441133,
0.060524527,
0.0012664988,
0.0018899778,
-0.0504975952,
-0.0068497253,
-0.0205116067,
0.0038228978,
-0.0149720777,
-0.0409606919,
0.0678076446,
0.0138592198,
-0.0720727444,
0.0665521324,
-0.0305473153,
-0.001235571,
-0.0655356497,
0.0078882361,
0.0499937534,
0.0778384805,
-0.0071323914,
0.0280584265,
-0.0188195352,
0.0179583579,
0.0231298245,
0.004528888,
-0.0362493992,
0.0082279118,
-0.0149903446,
0.0350000449,
0.0113643073,
0.0087788077,
-0.0642709285,
0.0197912622,
-0.0393882804,
0.0029149037,
0.0282953996,
-0.0452507287,
0.0791295767,
0.0060449168,
-0.0236373451,
0.0191323031,
0.0280358214,
-0.0044108918,
-0.0089607025,
0.0102287624,
-0.0115966033,
-0.0440178476,
-0.0340740308,
0.0175079629,
-0.0027460207,
0.0345014967,
0.0194290485,
-0.0586422682,
-0.0358637683,
0.0319180787,
0.0203051288,
-0.0564865097,
-0.0095824935,
-0.0038286506,
-0.0271317437,
-0.02333376,
0.029786868,
0.0006769153,
-0.0167768132,
0.0166960582,
0.0272635091,
0.0551414192,
0.0111044394,
0.0080001783,
-0.0389192216,
0.0355565995,
-0.0173384789,
-0.0420587249,
-0.0090080248,
-6.266000555e-33,
-0.0137974247,
0.014836872,
-0.0190430619,
-0.0102526182,
0.0028483532,
-0.0036475095,
-0.0149864517,
-0.021819273,
0.0047348593,
0.0318386853,
0.0081857778,
0.0186918713,
0.0190371685,
0.0493628271,
0.0223932471,
-0.0099349217,
0.0711707696,
-0.0022313728,
-0.0280910172,
0.0149296233,
0.0624477789,
0.0422651842,
0.0964633673,
-0.0605241619,
0.0017569187,
-0.02776655,
-0.0364053808,
-0.0004434806,
0.065659143,
0.0447267555,
-0.00055233,
0.0612530522,
0.0189766437,
-0.0918967128,
0.0103029087,
0.0668126717,
-0.0890255049,
-0.0426980555,
-0.0204810351,
0.0736022443,
0.0271025207,
-0.0023511124,
0.0634344891,
0.0096802134,
-0.0358606614,
0.0194267277,
0.0706087202,
-0.0222659763,
0.0378417745,
-0.0769436434,
-0.0480432063,
-0.0014697803,
-0.0129394373,
-0.0048569064,
0.0391746312,
0.0546712428,
0.0017100858,
0.0272112172,
-0.0870763808,
0.0160517301,
-0.0037511738,
0.0381244011,
0.0168357808,
-0.0250034146,
0.0169262011,
0.0328099392,
0.0180461481,
-0.0207762681,
-0.0482332706,
0.0480936207,
0.0402097777,
0.0173995141,
0.0202762205,
0.0707371235,
0.0525713861,
-0.0435357466,
-0.1059241295,
0.0511967316,
0.0357398875,
0.0015820983,
-0.0027208985,
-0.0255632848,
-0.034518145,
-0.0368291475,
0.0168301798,
-0.0370605774,
-0.0145403193,
-0.0191126075,
0.0177960955,
0.0015942294,
-0.0086773019,
0.0159018915,
0.0118348775,
-0.0490846299,
-0.0278957542,
0.041022338,
-0.0367117301,
0.0141149415,
-0.0152888615,
0.0278498642,
-0.0728263929,
-0.0541704856,
0.0172916558,
0.0508489683,
0.0426877216,
-0.0057003065,
0.0569197237,
0.0399976633,
-0.0751134604,
0.0000199333,
-0.0262427684,
0.0338574536,
0.0037659477,
0.0991396382,
0.0115120104,
0.0025530199,
-0.0186852291,
0.0294969007,
0.0013861776,
0.0344903655,
-0.0059281504,
-0.0490501113,
0.0554570034,
0.0339417979,
-0.0064064125,
0.0056393771,
0.0056288885,
0.0081004137,
0.0190456342,
-0.0451851152,
0.0089463657,
-0.0098648295,
2.616e-7,
0.0590411127,
0.0465440638,
-0.023543803,
-0.003692681,
0.0136484532,
0.0197105743,
-0.0165582374,
0.0378881581,
0.0105851833,
0.0077054729,
0.0104238931,
0.0096178064,
0.02142369,
0.043328248,
-0.0788240284,
0.0049872058,
-0.0569908246,
0.0327890068,
-0.0187134035,
0.0264707059,
0.0557051301,
0.1051619425,
0.0199459009,
-0.0135819986,
-0.0249587409,
-0.0270648822,
0.0712095425,
0.0076320535,
-0.0325117521,
0.0208984315,
0.0209100768,
0.0476960652,
-0.0072742389,
0.0048796879,
-0.0113628889,
0.0153436493,
0.0330309048,
0.0575418882,
-0.0235903133,
-0.0170700457,
0.033123605,
-0.0072370917,
-0.0174527504,
-0.036875397,
0.0991485193,
-0.084525913,
-0.0384870358,
-0.0142660346,
-0.0190169476,
0.0053665387,
0.0784824044,
-0.0110073984,
0.018362226,
0.0190203693,
0.0343894102,
-0.0013831725,
-0.0209443383,
-0.0879015625,
-0.0091740517,
0.0118855387,
-0.0178008284,
-0.0241262503,
0.007154834,
-0.0125176096,
0.015044895,
-0.0093667917,
0.0193840936,
1.952982156e-34,
-0.0072465856,
0.0614457615,
-0.0413534939,
-0.0269415472,
-0.0007180853,
-0.0051234425,
0.018890487,
-0.020749243,
-0.0122282123,
-0.0371911637,
-0.0042079259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10652v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10652v5 | Exploring the Landscape of Natural Language Processing Research | 2023-07-20T07:33:30 | 2023-09-24T20:18:07 | Tim Schopf, Karim Arabi, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | As an efficient approach to understand, generate, and process natural
language texts, research in natural language processing (NLP) has exhibited a
rapid spread and wide adoption in recent years. Given the increasing research
work in this area, several NLP-related approaches have been surveyed in the
research community. However, a comprehensive study that categorizes established
topics, identifies trends, and outlines areas for future research remains
absent. Contributing to closing this gap, we have systematically classified and
analyzed research papers in the ACL Anthology. As a result, we present a
structured overview of the research landscape, provide a taxonomy of fields of
study in NLP, analyze recent developments in NLP, summarize our findings, and
highlight directions for future work. | [
0.0983050689,
-0.0049822703,
-0.0368433371,
0.0301852673,
-0.0877827927,
-0.008989485,
-0.037146911,
0.0296724495,
0.0134392921,
-0.1176531911,
0.0547073856,
0.009077928,
0.001260133,
0.0278511532,
-0.0371804163,
-0.0650585666,
0.0363951586,
0.0203438979,
0.0370238051,
0.0968927741,
0.02044487,
0.0432003103,
-0.0273721665,
0.0384682342,
-0.0294141211,
-0.0004890812,
0.0208127964,
-0.022949541,
0.0178225711,
-0.0539985448,
-0.0215668194,
0.0002491044,
-0.0140039716,
-0.0353937112,
0.000001752,
-0.0573361591,
-0.0786498412,
-0.0024259095,
0.0128496755,
-0.0375616029,
0.0700095296,
-0.0520849116,
0.0035309768,
0.0184255224,
-0.0190151986,
0.0023116847,
0.0509440675,
0.0274292268,
0.0475275218,
0.0543385595,
-0.0195194259,
-0.0304080378,
-0.0183188729,
0.0517810248,
-0.0419510975,
-0.0087370016,
0.0342250727,
-0.0271063056,
0.0029690685,
0.0016377713,
-0.0034097098,
0.0129222143,
-0.0473079346,
0.0031619838,
0.0316432156,
-0.0132042943,
-0.0357994176,
-0.0072399764,
-0.0499283224,
0.0254348144,
-0.0105004692,
-0.0122366603,
0.0316648483,
-0.0410874486,
-0.0336134583,
0.0046371752,
-0.0174780712,
0.0423610285,
-0.0380741768,
0.0243313834,
0.0294125956,
0.0428656712,
-0.0402452685,
0.0348835774,
0.0048910468,
0.0576181561,
-0.020641515,
-0.0507703833,
-0.016947262,
0.0079998486,
0.0152172931,
-0.0351481512,
0.0627579466,
0.0393515266,
0.0062105036,
0.0553527474,
0.0032163463,
-0.0319759436,
0.0665677488,
-0.0582061857,
0.0022026673,
-0.0161195751,
0.0040214201,
0.0209657717,
0.0173023604,
0.0118527785,
0.0228507686,
-0.0401451476,
-0.0013516708,
0.0258433372,
-0.0893920362,
-0.0021715034,
-0.0530598238,
0.0457584858,
-0.0525750332,
-0.0269598234,
-0.0297047552,
-0.0092498194,
0.0016255296,
0.0097142393,
-0.0088754045,
0.0402386487,
0.002307401,
0.0245625637,
-0.0476518199,
-0.0046767811,
-0.0149212619,
-0.0066663157,
-0.0429381914,
-0.0077851559,
0.0413191617,
0.015758479,
0.0756838918,
-0.0048237909,
-0.0016579946,
0.0835631564,
0.062080726,
-0.0520498231,
-0.0553774573,
-0.0774830729,
-0.0198027156,
-0.0067875679,
-0.0473254211,
-0.047977183,
0.0121781416,
0.009419471,
0.0249835644,
0.0034900208,
0.0135701522,
0.0298712477,
-0.0207881518,
0.0618596002,
-0.0356432199,
-0.0092044463,
0.0100002009,
-0.0224342328,
0.0260779504,
0.0261653494,
0.0068937684,
0.0330553316,
0.0798346624,
-0.0038018927,
0.0232577045,
0.0063336981,
-0.0286328197,
-0.1068746969,
0.0126417382,
-0.0064635416,
-0.0386835076,
-0.0281775463,
-0.0547988154,
0.0307317153,
-0.0111495266,
0.0135036903,
-0.0275777671,
0.0892100707,
-0.0173935983,
0.0093615325,
0.0650829747,
0.0291203372,
0.0221874993,
0.0027039445,
0.0086942818,
-0.0303701311,
-0.0069904686,
-0.001461938,
-0.0172150228,
0.0440627113,
0.0143492082,
-0.0625700355,
-0.0584640205,
-0.0124877365,
0.0235039499,
-0.0544864014,
0.0669232905,
0.0121048577,
-0.0165496375,
-0.0199924912,
0.0080682617,
-0.0048511457,
-0.0057950933,
-0.0193024185,
-0.052788794,
0.0620195158,
0.0593070276,
-0.0337383263,
0.0155647714,
-0.0143385604,
-0.0385017172,
0.0435979851,
-0.005724885,
-0.0307446159,
0.0224080384,
-0.0191953983,
0.0062300018,
0.0397727527,
-0.0131367398,
0.0023891728,
0.01759376,
0.0031706649,
0.0103915539,
0.0137426639,
-0.0534000657,
0.0647880957,
0.0353775024,
-0.0365389474,
0.0178472605,
0.0096726837,
0.0409797095,
0.0517824739,
0.0158074256,
0.0217406601,
0.0348335318,
-0.0326802395,
-0.0413709171,
0.0432977043,
0.0163757559,
-0.0478765182,
0.0138040623,
-0.0448156111,
-0.0187643468,
-0.038597241,
-0.031998571,
-0.0213728361,
-0.001219412,
-0.0570650622,
0.0434032977,
-0.0359880924,
0.0220524482,
0.0368572138,
-0.033397451,
-0.0737686902,
0.1050249487,
0.0392962582,
0.023553919,
-0.0042896243,
-0.0467678607,
0.035905011,
-0.0101627586,
-0.0066642798,
-0.0081907278,
-0.0468183607,
-0.0047492003,
0.0638791993,
-0.0067144702,
-0.0488893762,
-0.0020957282,
-0.0394769162,
0.0191436056,
0.0126811415,
0.0263052825,
0.0234609973,
-0.008578849,
-0.0274936557,
-0.0415923223,
-0.0004149085,
-0.0154907126,
0.0786428526,
-0.0224028807,
0.0644243136,
0.02130845,
-0.0456931517,
-0.0042224121,
0.0046186624,
-0.0199311394,
0.0250528883,
0.0388351642,
-0.082114026,
-0.0531787574,
-0.0089412332,
-0.0038860813,
0.0295874365,
0.0174712297,
0.0122216707,
-0.0118285306,
0.0039772405,
-0.0082219262,
0.0271461643,
0.0242871456,
0.0336844772,
0.0112353386,
-0.0510659926,
-0.0071479892,
0.0062475856,
-0.0731204376,
0.0332190506,
0.0000708122,
-0.0573703311,
0.0823669061,
0.0561021529,
0.0048989337,
-0.0251527075,
-0.0234494731,
-0.0214706622,
-0.0289573856,
-0.0061345766,
-0.0162841436,
-0.0268776231,
-0.006400953,
0.0799914151,
-0.0012493492,
-0.0353092924,
0.0629799515,
-0.029686138,
0.037586648,
-0.1248705834,
-0.0285771769,
-0.0627771392,
0.0659505874,
0.0098411106,
0.0601534881,
0.0540833697,
-0.0515407994,
0.049763523,
-0.0069205891,
0.0144742755,
-0.0120952912,
0.0229514446,
-0.0513615832,
0.0245356616,
-0.0131163672,
0.0026852405,
-0.0452218875,
-0.0157224089,
-0.0130569553,
-0.0303909555,
0.0351468623,
0.0035699371,
-0.0244701859,
0.0130501008,
-0.0246610753,
-0.0127896192,
0.0248080585,
-0.0269726291,
-0.0163638983,
0.0401251279,
0.0094346981,
-0.0246895533,
0.0090454696,
0.0711200982,
-0.0007329828,
0.0649747476,
0.0425498076,
0.0222056266,
-0.0013568595,
0.0106193004,
0.0203408245,
-0.1103581712,
0.0265561566,
0.0289020371,
0.0054236101,
-0.0243107863,
-0.0015841837,
0.0873901993,
0.068874985,
0.0151449079,
-0.0166191459,
0.032924924,
-0.0472812355,
-0.0119158337,
0.0283553731,
-0.0320427455,
-0.0013921363,
-0.0302337892,
-0.0068657193,
-0.0737245604,
-0.050943058,
-0.0131065091,
-0.0962723345,
0.0215744786,
-0.0353755802,
0.0084649483,
-0.0405027084,
-0.0878817812,
-0.0195909813,
-0.0384143963,
-0.0497208424,
-0.0523097143,
-0.0530819967,
-0.0228942353,
0.0372723043,
-0.0735136643,
-0.0433068536,
0.0058965646,
-0.0121152513,
0.0127722695,
0.0319576152,
0.06109602,
0.0083273165,
0.0029081523,
-0.0158251673,
-0.052617278,
0.0275389981,
-0.0328961797,
0.0343609601,
-0.0335076861,
0.0025822076,
-0.0259806197,
-0.0043618064,
-0.0210926123,
-0.0019260749,
0.0332649015,
0.0613670312,
-0.0213462394,
0.0240990724,
-0.0464294851,
0.0093046036,
0.0184803735,
0.0376613624,
-0.0230063498,
-0.0098675024,
-0.0220401511,
-0.0212106369,
0.0343868844,
-0.049826473,
-0.0246837642,
-0.0076659475,
-0.0309296809,
0.0017229908,
-0.0701854527,
-0.0576519854,
0.0446142405,
0.0078430278,
0.0089973081,
0.0425288528,
0.0525623485,
-0.0058435425,
-0.0418969058,
-0.0161626972,
-0.0085977027,
0.0056756469,
0.0138957342,
-0.0321666747,
0.0170249902,
0.0177148134,
-0.0326988995,
0.0349666812,
-0.0440852009,
-0.0542769581,
-0.0160424504,
0.0100394879,
0.0196078084,
0.0111401994,
-0.0216607787,
0.026219245,
-0.0127822133,
0.0484824069,
-0.041582644,
-0.0496959835,
-0.0364789478,
0.0309880357,
-0.0171043891,
-0.0077242628,
0.0152581679,
0.0457066149,
-0.0258779228,
0.0405542925,
-0.0206489302,
-0.0217829943,
0.0582522415,
0.0107463589,
0.0422906429,
-0.0336816013,
-0.0494945683,
-0.0099852756,
-0.0346403494,
-0.0256083608,
-0.0301561765,
-0.0148917157,
-0.0095573124,
-0.0249116942,
0.0049277446,
-0.0289738551,
0.017376231,
-0.0602466837,
0.0329509526,
0.0121973474,
0.0471993536,
0.0480306596,
0.0143920574,
-0.0268238634,
-0.0179415029,
0.0138012255,
0.0223280508,
0.0008780282,
0.0341268815,
0.0105222668,
0.0309333261,
0.0337565839,
-0.0069197477,
-0.049337171,
0.0282902364,
-0.0376021788,
0.0239263363,
-0.0232295785,
0.0635846332,
0.0235833004,
-0.0543693453,
0.0308864284,
-0.0515904315,
0.0100276209,
0.0351576135,
0.0198506229,
0.0565361567,
-0.0084449323,
-0.0333246402,
0.005679057,
-0.0363992751,
-0.0207973327,
0.025747139,
-0.002321562,
0.0023228165,
0.0207323879,
-0.0810420141,
-0.03549641,
0.007482836,
-0.006098154,
0.0129124839,
0.0091831814,
0.0345721096,
-0.0612283088,
-0.0005064912,
0.0400253385,
0.005198169,
0.0575396121,
-0.014301708,
0.0275280811,
0.060560558,
0.0830986723,
0.0031200913,
-0.0656396449,
-0.0049605817,
-0.0302243922,
-0.006368727,
0.0119393319,
-5.919706899e-33,
-0.0472024307,
-0.0902975202,
0.0022994089,
0.0027964837,
0.0313580707,
0.0113607207,
0.0146137802,
-0.0103365295,
0.0157723445,
-0.0331261009,
0.0002147448,
-0.0246598646,
0.0280904938,
-0.0020301491,
0.0378341712,
0.0335443728,
0.0098106563,
0.001274324,
-0.0058016763,
-0.0394392572,
0.0585500598,
0.006702736,
0.046429947,
-0.0867641866,
0.0655468628,
0.0146520808,
0.0024215251,
0.0191236138,
0.0505899489,
0.0599303767,
-0.0349085294,
0.0484718531,
0.0652758032,
-0.042874597,
-0.0062593506,
0.0327235125,
-0.0769001842,
-0.0426236354,
-0.000937751,
-0.0073312423,
0.013974363,
0.0235525165,
0.0325900018,
-0.0210397914,
0.0016430798,
0.0498064756,
0.0720143169,
-0.0295097716,
0.0312213618,
0.0053649405,
-0.0685904399,
0.0559962243,
-0.0191421621,
0.0301194396,
0.0646360815,
0.0347180814,
0.0158183351,
0.0132575324,
-0.0392396003,
0.0120506352,
0.0308284611,
0.0206473768,
-0.0057258778,
-0.0272414312,
-0.0108545907,
0.0409964286,
-0.020246787,
-0.017620625,
-0.0252559315,
0.0009072176,
-0.0168951806,
0.0328007042,
-0.0013146122,
0.0281532761,
0.059418235,
0.0135205258,
-0.0389979742,
0.0476390161,
0.0485444255,
0.0503843054,
-0.0033993807,
-0.0164537933,
-0.0547617674,
-0.0143499831,
-0.0023567691,
-0.0113201011,
-0.0014361084,
-0.0304320827,
0.0191450361,
0.025694171,
-0.0546324179,
0.0695490018,
-0.005403351,
-0.0078873225,
-0.036229454,
-0.0145729985,
0.0620951541,
0.039586138,
-0.0174562708,
0.0175982602,
-0.0697517321,
-0.0368484668,
0.0027179653,
0.0032614178,
-0.0081270281,
-0.0484801494,
-0.0002423653,
0.00260315,
-0.0362015069,
0.0246872567,
0.0264171269,
0.0303193387,
-0.0371422134,
0.0351610519,
0.0091765085,
0.0249892082,
-0.0172407702,
0.0171108153,
0.0249465834,
0.00567067,
0.0095769437,
0.0053229122,
-0.0031020378,
0.005121693,
-0.0054233721,
-0.016272258,
-0.0239735041,
-0.0121173067,
0.0105300341,
-0.0091643948,
0.0122031644,
-0.0353363045,
2.463e-7,
0.0459659062,
0.0453569256,
0.0619647875,
-0.0039656288,
0.0124247875,
0.003598047,
0.007300918,
-0.004977372,
0.0047688764,
-0.0085304277,
0.0010446234,
-0.0060225679,
-0.0317317434,
0.0391650461,
-0.0833839178,
-0.0143399322,
0.000040141,
-0.0297475867,
-0.074298583,
0.0314933881,
0.087580882,
0.0361742787,
-0.0210723076,
-0.0039395797,
-0.0528472997,
-0.0111352121,
-0.0106214872,
0.0026303392,
0.0108571779,
0.0307592284,
0.0269702356,
0.0095871305,
0.0125943823,
0.0242685284,
-0.0291629452,
0.0269763414,
0.0117836064,
0.0368561447,
-0.0259463675,
0.0363094769,
0.0437902398,
0.0068346467,
-0.003773557,
-0.0069812238,
0.0501452945,
-0.0163706206,
0.0092136739,
-0.0360378772,
0.0139902132,
0.0028988386,
-0.0335091278,
0.0078403447,
-0.0459187292,
0.0331102423,
0.015996201,
-0.0142456368,
-0.0302443951,
-0.1068075821,
0.0142122163,
-0.0155408196,
0.0133795012,
0.0284112971,
-0.010104822,
0.0247669313,
0.0396745428,
-0.0519975685,
-0.010910904,
2.358803673e-34,
-0.0158228204,
0.0161888767,
-0.0036759353,
0.0663134083,
0.0331117995,
0.0243525263,
-0.0428058617,
0.0427402779,
-0.0187770221,
-0.0569090843,
0.0081574526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10635v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10635v3 | SciBench: Evaluating College-Level Scientific Problem-Solving Abilities of Large Language Models | 2023-07-20T07:01:57 | 2024-06-28T08:24:13 | Xiaoxuan Wang, Ziniu Hu, Pan Lu, Yanqiao Zhu, Jieyu Zhang, Satyen Subramaniam, Arjun R. Loomba, Shichang Zhang, Yizhou Sun, Wei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Most of the existing Large Language Model (LLM) benchmarks on scientific
problem reasoning focus on problems grounded in high-school subjects and are
confined to elementary algebraic operations. To systematically examine the
reasoning capabilities required for solving complex scientific problems, we
introduce an expansive benchmark suite SciBench for LLMs. SciBench contains a
carefully curated dataset featuring a range of collegiate-level scientific
problems from mathematics, chemistry, and physics domains. Based on the
dataset, we conduct an in-depth benchmarking study of representative
open-source and proprietary LLMs with various prompting strategies. The results
reveal that the current LLMs fall short of delivering satisfactory performance,
with the best overall score of merely 43.22%. Furthermore, through a detailed
user study, we categorize the errors made by LLMs into ten problem-solving
abilities. Our analysis indicates that no single prompting strategy
significantly outperforms the others and some strategies that demonstrate
improvements in certain problem-solving skills could result in declines in
other skills. We envision that SciBench will catalyze further developments in
the reasoning abilities of LLMs, thereby ultimately contributing to scientific
research and discovery. | [
-0.0000679773,
0.0489205122,
0.003790339,
0.0355390869,
-0.0730862617,
0.0144135635,
0.0341627076,
0.0098368078,
0.020534303,
-0.031994503,
0.011780587,
-0.021834271,
-0.0329215601,
0.032710474,
0.0067873006,
-0.0081684841,
0.051568713,
-0.0835809857,
0.0336763449,
-0.0235420223,
-0.0308984872,
-0.0216672737,
-0.0534089729,
-0.0062282896,
0.0152671132,
-0.0687130615,
0.0309484452,
-0.0340965167,
0.0025048899,
-0.0420102887,
-0.0167692509,
0.0728312582,
0.0061941794,
0.040667057,
0.0000022852,
-0.0877666771,
-0.0059819394,
0.0357254967,
-0.0527128801,
0.0618509427,
0.0215319078,
0.0250784922,
-0.0079778871,
0.021134546,
-0.0272849221,
0.030802615,
0.0181652401,
-0.015539933,
0.03800736,
0.0005822554,
0.0140272826,
-0.020862462,
0.0318453796,
0.0055674901,
0.0523715019,
-0.0391199291,
0.0404989161,
0.0752996877,
0.0695165768,
0.0145063829,
-0.0329362601,
0.0615293309,
0.0398126692,
-0.0294117611,
0.0057930853,
0.021417018,
-0.0461166315,
0.0113956984,
0.0007388578,
0.0500480719,
0.0172435753,
-0.0161907505,
-0.0197565164,
0.0065402919,
-0.0372698158,
0.0398083515,
-0.0905303508,
0.0401454233,
-0.0009236403,
-0.0334498025,
0.0037887942,
-0.0181395561,
0.0165366158,
0.0377587862,
-0.0289560985,
0.1268694401,
0.0225312114,
-0.0317395478,
0.0226176735,
-0.0092666484,
-0.0283279214,
-0.0549704023,
0.0569595136,
0.0426751003,
-0.0172541048,
0.0075646504,
0.0104488479,
-0.0113854287,
0.0271333531,
-0.0179806221,
0.0299597122,
0.055447191,
0.0434620827,
0.0647984669,
-0.0161186513,
0.0717041939,
-0.0295216087,
0.0052236859,
0.0093703074,
0.020870015,
-0.055165261,
-0.038215369,
-0.015584602,
0.006924896,
0.0056872293,
-0.0006664756,
-0.0241778046,
-0.0202404205,
0.0109563628,
0.0029623287,
-0.0382897146,
-0.0063341954,
0.0216276571,
-0.0266992394,
-0.0347667634,
0.0429055244,
-0.0215153303,
0.0091140121,
0.0082368832,
-0.0488043763,
-0.0291128047,
0.0006623048,
-0.0405029431,
-0.0189323407,
0.0351792313,
0.0321920253,
0.0204328895,
-0.008494854,
-0.0008156708,
-0.0340903774,
0.0135100577,
-0.0963771865,
0.0150516117,
-0.0791118965,
0.021210596,
0.0492729433,
-0.0213194247,
-0.0274120867,
0.021821985,
-0.0115416227,
0.0206830502,
0.0453976989,
-0.0045504137,
0.0074540959,
0.0549608581,
0.0437394157,
-0.0114075216,
0.0368460678,
0.0136732487,
-0.0253538247,
-0.0061579654,
-0.0381508917,
0.011922379,
0.0076055322,
-0.0010552853,
0.0018012691,
-0.0263087284,
0.0273180641,
0.0053663389,
0.0728862658,
-0.0417065844,
0.0590862297,
-0.0133082625,
0.0203097146,
0.0261934884,
0.0824556202,
-0.0132760527,
0.0195940956,
-0.0198665857,
-0.0118112182,
0.0467044003,
-0.0346178263,
-0.0304911528,
0.0612234548,
-0.0428779908,
-0.0117719565,
0.0134706991,
0.0490813404,
-0.0056930478,
-0.0457980819,
-0.0481784269,
0.0342761464,
-0.0380719565,
0.009228033,
0.0692944974,
-0.0430561826,
0.0065699155,
0.0454702005,
-0.0054694745,
-0.0578448586,
0.0063949232,
-0.0164207797,
0.041255597,
0.0457657799,
0.0581032634,
-0.0485619977,
-0.0641551316,
-0.0044183279,
0.0432730503,
0.0349616483,
0.0558088608,
0.0085393153,
-0.0295952838,
-0.0410052016,
-0.0083469218,
-0.0314919502,
0.0024278844,
-0.0329249687,
0.0284309778,
0.0096718529,
0.0092774974,
-0.0178781431,
-0.0061182375,
0.0102650747,
-0.0942495614,
-0.0321424156,
-0.0375067107,
-0.0234963857,
0.000534083,
-0.0021585512,
0.0132117914,
0.0506895296,
0.0381826907,
-0.0371049792,
-0.0129771605,
-0.0058199177,
-0.0192849413,
0.0141473301,
0.0689047873,
-0.0448089615,
-0.0290080383,
0.0125594102,
-0.0004767719,
-0.0105502391,
0.0596864372,
-0.0207614098,
-0.0068289777,
-0.0046422505,
0.0064956443,
-0.0519573987,
-0.0212295819,
-0.009881014,
0.0508440956,
0.0095523363,
0.0566146448,
0.0330081284,
0.011691805,
0.0035290651,
-0.0317179523,
-0.0192619897,
-0.0075024618,
0.003317886,
-0.0267948285,
-0.0144635076,
-0.032337673,
-0.0627320856,
-0.0112025077,
0.0027827604,
0.0077138729,
0.0118374284,
0.0496559404,
0.0164068826,
-0.0405520312,
-0.0243538283,
0.0293296166,
-0.0011584157,
-0.0265645683,
0.0162047669,
-0.0136491219,
0.0171527695,
0.0019457418,
-0.0424425937,
-0.0397484228,
-0.0224961843,
-0.0768778175,
0.0372719429,
0.0367513448,
0.0283454098,
-0.0364769734,
0.0467333496,
-0.0323088877,
0.0023031116,
-0.0153222941,
0.0058104219,
0.0432158262,
-0.0309549849,
0.0422188602,
0.0721545443,
-0.0091441693,
0.0083088418,
0.0585981347,
-0.0487005673,
-0.0500414073,
0.0112760281,
-0.0053876541,
0.0091107609,
-0.0090882396,
-0.0290044844,
-0.021634439,
0.0530266203,
-0.0442976728,
-0.0117901415,
0.0239422061,
0.0598360896,
-0.0445217006,
-0.000783733,
-0.0210974477,
-0.0010774548,
0.0048366454,
0.0364023373,
0.0061659045,
-0.0194179844,
0.0779672116,
-0.0267587341,
-0.0091001168,
-0.0680142418,
0.0051420936,
-0.0318896435,
0.0562058873,
-0.0522716977,
-0.0056090709,
-0.0013826141,
0.0109270439,
-0.0109494328,
0.0005934665,
-0.0052896431,
-0.0278531685,
0.0286687445,
-0.0600631796,
0.0055282461,
0.0210857205,
-0.0315713473,
-0.0167956557,
0.0094934367,
-0.0353841297,
0.0285485629,
0.0200953521,
-0.0584243052,
-0.0382218957,
0.0087083131,
0.0735467896,
0.0047981562,
-0.04570131,
-0.0084744673,
-0.0068304678,
-0.0097762225,
0.0202642027,
0.0146741392,
0.0831245333,
-0.0666418448,
0.047906138,
0.0471283942,
0.0508748144,
0.0078638718,
-0.0099931918,
0.0208539013,
0.0329392999,
-0.0013720386,
0.0031278951,
0.0201027319,
0.0276755113,
-0.0612224825,
-0.0088831382,
0.0916004404,
0.0413979925,
-0.0022692748,
0.0014010501,
-0.0702985004,
0.0084539969,
0.0432761684,
0.05192215,
-0.0768644884,
-0.0204819329,
0.0148148797,
-0.0085552186,
0.003364363,
-0.0520957336,
-0.0283366106,
-0.1006610543,
0.0316464677,
0.0319688916,
-0.0381459221,
-0.0039800135,
-0.0702343136,
-0.0084898872,
-0.0044759214,
-0.0135784186,
0.0475245304,
-0.0037359647,
-0.003787529,
0.022597326,
-0.0033023402,
-0.0600465722,
0.0591718331,
-0.0150758764,
0.0073460382,
0.0003800188,
0.0009681404,
-0.0272805933,
-0.0551063381,
0.0594879128,
0.0378973447,
-0.0088314861,
-0.016363427,
-0.0209109783,
0.026607044,
0.0101295309,
-0.0425760858,
0.0489377119,
-0.0629899129,
-0.0378478505,
0.0232730135,
0.1327236146,
0.0072102691,
-0.00553262,
-0.0408864208,
0.0001861455,
-0.0187747534,
0.0878304765,
0.0051261131,
-0.0057617961,
-0.0575606674,
-0.056195531,
-0.0205565859,
-0.0015827712,
-0.0268955883,
0.0060601351,
0.0390793979,
0.0088790301,
0.0099162702,
0.0284956899,
0.0814895257,
0.0104867946,
0.0110050002,
-0.0064767222,
0.0080996826,
0.01156619,
-0.0238930974,
0.0576853566,
-0.0288776066,
0.0535658114,
-0.0813983008,
0.0215227585,
0.0277123731,
0.0022792132,
-0.0336464457,
0.0310985185,
-0.0578610674,
-0.0744156614,
-0.0307843313,
0.0268046409,
0.0333102867,
-0.0462669954,
0.0051343529,
-0.0648733974,
-0.0263197962,
0.0186726581,
-0.0327184536,
0.0213447455,
-0.0289703105,
-0.0192266386,
0.0193217006,
-0.0280693527,
0.0019150353,
0.0023001295,
-0.0184380691,
0.0639559776,
-0.0364027098,
-0.0352465995,
0.0125421658,
0.0843667239,
0.0192504749,
0.0157224108,
-0.0102320742,
-0.0139893033,
0.0291475821,
-0.031745974,
-0.0236720126,
-0.0171681698,
0.0145778423,
0.0255207457,
-0.0205837451,
0.0382004008,
-0.0189193841,
-0.0125215221,
0.0334553272,
-0.0240032263,
0.0806991458,
-0.0061945929,
-0.0048583015,
0.0862447545,
-0.0324759781,
-0.0018894084,
-0.0277716946,
-0.0286558885,
0.0632859394,
-0.0083763152,
0.0576599091,
0.0236145519,
0.008246989,
-0.0175868701,
-0.027552532,
-0.0696391836,
-0.100001961,
0.0093289278,
0.028292086,
0.0068718567,
0.0403150581,
-0.0033049139,
-0.0737403631,
-0.0176213365,
-0.024936093,
-0.0007696323,
0.0136502916,
-0.0236756466,
0.0773154348,
0.0541498475,
0.0155053632,
-0.0105704144,
0.0279773362,
-0.0004263018,
0.030984953,
0.0075278813,
0.0150481043,
-0.0221223105,
-0.0229034722,
-0.0382678583,
0.0114856279,
-0.0038198144,
0.0027090027,
-0.1000499949,
-0.0421395041,
0.0078713736,
0.0285847224,
-0.0135457143,
-0.0192684717,
0.0370400995,
0.0603788197,
-0.0334895514,
-0.0565609373,
0.0301296264,
0.0503333695,
-0.0491285175,
-0.0444217585,
-0.0017553141,
-6.245489648e-33,
-0.0146744875,
-0.0283310115,
0.0425119139,
0.0016257523,
0.00853041,
-0.0154045019,
-0.05292942,
0.0203681812,
-0.0199597757,
0.0178545099,
0.0025017424,
0.0148632172,
-0.0015137335,
-0.0362980627,
0.0086627519,
0.0191079024,
0.0010687707,
0.0184379835,
-0.0344292037,
-0.0155015662,
0.0300534032,
0.0149603263,
0.0279850066,
-0.0514997952,
-0.0209165011,
-0.0245299097,
0.0064011943,
0.0343890153,
-0.0821053535,
0.0452480353,
-0.0219573453,
0.0069253128,
-0.0131521914,
-0.0525538363,
-0.0152912773,
0.0011287008,
-0.0213905256,
-0.0134936189,
0.0280620735,
-0.0284356195,
-0.0131400255,
-0.0362312458,
0.0201756023,
0.0538046435,
-0.0555351749,
-0.0350443088,
0.0105557181,
-0.0337885432,
-0.0182775334,
0.0082647782,
-0.0182939339,
0.0201123618,
-0.0410643481,
-0.0047671776,
0.0027181443,
0.0228384454,
-0.0323528424,
0.0289447755,
0.018961221,
0.0639648363,
0.0486455038,
0.0131829027,
0.0715715885,
-0.0206809267,
0.0231522471,
0.0542908125,
0.0304493941,
-0.0152101014,
-0.0063517173,
-0.0259307325,
0.0271404032,
0.0621591471,
0.0694328994,
0.018260764,
0.0460107736,
0.0101214405,
-0.0827640519,
-0.0100999838,
0.0246468112,
0.0166239887,
0.026333943,
0.0037855057,
-0.0171975438,
-0.0308319591,
-0.0508644953,
0.0488881059,
-0.0452925824,
-0.0094734235,
0.0116505949,
-0.0723373666,
-0.0376868621,
-0.0098610558,
0.0287810136,
-0.0266025532,
-0.0375682153,
0.0429430269,
0.0025609478,
0.0587659515,
-0.0122988522,
0.0502233319,
-0.0985618234,
-0.0166517813,
-0.0342732556,
-0.0220625326,
0.0437183939,
0.0119051468,
-0.019542506,
0.0139614642,
-0.0203031413,
-0.023313649,
-0.0496953912,
-0.0265297368,
0.0677729845,
0.0234079193,
0.0238260329,
0.0198716614,
0.0147423325,
0.0475978963,
-0.0125551755,
-0.0164216217,
0.0042013237,
0.0242924374,
-0.0289021097,
0.0064564166,
0.0023833124,
-0.037408825,
-0.0279796552,
0.0143856332,
0.0274827965,
-0.0612316057,
-0.0046146475,
0.0087453704,
2.966e-7,
0.0424417071,
0.1021683887,
0.0162899736,
-0.0131360702,
-0.0032615133,
0.0046429671,
-0.064644374,
-0.0559020899,
0.0467047207,
-0.0101990495,
-0.0379052646,
0.0422407761,
0.0403910615,
0.0486530289,
-0.043214526,
-0.0060163154,
-0.0302942209,
-0.0210034307,
-0.0803742334,
0.0047435942,
0.0506700799,
0.0078125959,
0.0254143775,
-0.0108854314,
0.0012203801,
-0.0461714379,
0.0372025296,
-0.034617994,
0.0159201939,
0.044551421,
-0.0363721512,
-0.0129309548,
0.0226797014,
0.0506336242,
0.0000892808,
-0.0251915306,
-0.0068554753,
0.0672924966,
0.0340639651,
0.0080966847,
0.0141750015,
-0.0140750743,
-0.0175916832,
-0.0481368676,
0.0396160185,
-0.0400051214,
-0.0324449874,
-0.0020101855,
0.0000601852,
-0.0680772886,
0.0086017875,
-0.0217391141,
0.0424896553,
-0.0017617675,
-0.0183982234,
-0.0217129029,
-0.0087996796,
-0.0288795773,
-0.0396076404,
0.0180990566,
-0.0442525186,
-0.0541439168,
-0.0545966215,
-0.0105964402,
0.0312788375,
-0.0255422127,
-0.0180926528,
2.985601827e-34,
0.0490661561,
-0.0035678814,
0.0476027839,
0.0309269596,
0.0243968219,
0.0139769111,
-0.0075915302,
0.0090057999,
-0.0154062677,
-0.0735864565,
-0.0123825483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10634v1 | Generative Language Models on Nucleotide Sequences of Human Genes | 2023-07-20T06:59:02 | 2023-07-20T06:59:02 | Musa Nuri Ihtiyar, Arzucan Ozgur | q-bio.GN | q-bio.GN, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models, primarily transformer-based ones, obtained colossal success
in NLP. To be more precise, studies like BERT in NLU and works such as GPT-3
for NLG are very crucial. DNA sequences are very close to natural language in
terms of structure, so if the DNA-related bioinformatics domain is concerned,
discriminative models, like DNABert, exist. Yet, the generative side of the
coin is mainly unexplored to the best of our knowledge. Consequently, we
focused on developing an autoregressive generative language model like GPT-3
for DNA sequences. Because working with whole DNA sequences is challenging
without substantial computational resources, we decided to carry out our study
on a smaller scale, focusing on nucleotide sequences of human genes, unique
parts in DNA with specific functionalities, instead of the whole DNA. This
decision did not change the problem structure a lot due to the fact that both
DNA and genes can be seen as 1D sequences consisting of four different
nucleotides without losing much information and making too much simplification.
First of all, we systematically examined an almost entirely unexplored problem
and observed that RNNs performed the best while simple techniques like N-grams
were also promising. Another beneficial point was learning how to work with
generative models on languages we do not understand, unlike natural language.
How essential using real-life tasks beyond the classical metrics such as
perplexity is observed. Furthermore, checking whether the data-hungry nature of
these models can be changed through selecting a language with minimal
vocabulary size, four owing to four different types of nucleotides, is
examined. The reason for reviewing this was that choosing such a language might
make the problem easier. However, what we observed in this study was it did not
provide that much of a change in the amount of data needed. | [
0.058500044,
0.0844542012,
-0.0185078811,
-0.0045414455,
-0.0534884073,
0.0235168971,
0.0075021009,
-0.0002412949,
-0.0240336843,
-0.034295328,
0.0335457958,
-0.0585303158,
0.0172303673,
0.017334098,
0.05595994,
-0.0148504898,
0.0240722168,
-0.0254310109,
0.0127116311,
0.0051674894,
0.0211702213,
0.0001842213,
0.0205131285,
0.0426922962,
-0.0302047022,
0.0033665169,
0.0043911855,
-0.0200762302,
0.0021782392,
0.0032595652,
-0.0304407347,
0.074942477,
-0.0084602693,
0.0360514186,
0.0000017959,
-0.0016822552,
0.0029018533,
0.006346941,
0.0187720191,
-0.0081433915,
0.0285508186,
0.0181820448,
-0.0299672317,
-0.0081955623,
-0.0288723558,
0.0002807939,
0.0937627554,
0.0207747258,
0.0139683131,
0.0765542239,
-0.0181115773,
-0.09768489,
0.0605912916,
-0.0273266844,
0.0602707379,
0.0098140342,
0.0445293002,
0.032976266,
0.0514433943,
0.0007339657,
-0.0307775512,
0.0556427017,
-0.0026972725,
0.0101104844,
-0.0080263996,
0.0224598031,
-0.0181937832,
-0.0225684103,
0.031611301,
0.0419011116,
-0.0609008111,
-0.076079689,
0.0266383905,
0.01688339,
0.0023212093,
0.0176452976,
-0.0346851349,
0.0376775153,
-0.0365912393,
0.0607270971,
0.0227182489,
-0.039928399,
0.0340819322,
-0.0402063914,
-0.0051602363,
0.0345978849,
0.0410211124,
-0.0132520963,
-0.0726266876,
-0.0217167269,
-0.003983669,
-0.0265417956,
0.0100607164,
0.0025780399,
0.0389841609,
-0.0038062315,
-0.0038207525,
-0.0274729449,
0.0418029986,
-0.0435755849,
0.0417063832,
0.0129492041,
-0.007058213,
-0.0080486657,
-0.024054084,
0.0682492778,
-0.0239555333,
-0.010588442,
-0.0334437788,
-0.0145951323,
-0.094740957,
-0.0004456393,
-0.04182202,
0.0382196009,
-0.0070103193,
-0.0019421389,
-0.0614474937,
-0.0209396351,
0.0555966832,
-0.0185193997,
0.0153109822,
-0.0087645883,
-0.0342818461,
0.0486465245,
0.0087527568,
0.0069298563,
0.0025056624,
-0.0514592193,
-0.0241167825,
-0.1047894359,
0.0037107829,
0.0133385872,
-0.00406479,
-0.0219545066,
-0.0357121676,
0.0737381205,
0.0211872812,
-0.0245838538,
0.0197187085,
-0.0055247466,
-0.0575157404,
-0.0339826196,
-0.0042110933,
-0.0491682068,
0.0062571177,
0.0103876973,
-0.0175336003,
-0.0470142998,
0.0405018181,
-0.005016556,
-0.0023845665,
0.0696368814,
0.0152979903,
-0.0072160903,
0.0089031653,
0.0008689223,
0.0661042556,
-0.0068302471,
0.0419786349,
-0.0173804779,
0.0059013688,
-0.056720838,
0.0512366556,
0.0106105879,
-0.0141379647,
-0.091190055,
0.0065250467,
-0.0303606428,
0.0225632377,
0.0386460684,
0.0312019307,
0.0526795015,
0.0038668017,
-0.0395620279,
0.0202617962,
0.0694956854,
0.0699921697,
0.0808357894,
0.0599533692,
0.0243182816,
-0.0158705749,
0.0057593677,
0.0211814214,
0.0058240653,
-0.0166740827,
0.0427330397,
-0.00167339,
0.0277851913,
-0.0135725467,
-0.0100971339,
-0.0205684248,
0.0051571997,
0.0175221972,
-0.0327213444,
0.0455232896,
-0.0202509426,
-0.0655359402,
0.0132894395,
0.0041961833,
-0.0588583201,
0.0268637333,
-0.0429968052,
0.0218621325,
0.0528264493,
0.0420311727,
0.0159812476,
-0.010356863,
0.0092195151,
-0.081795685,
0.0232050885,
0.0050376412,
-0.013577505,
-0.0325304717,
-0.0492254235,
-0.0109772487,
0.004504133,
0.0010427017,
0.0466581807,
-0.020550387,
-0.0047934302,
0.0363228992,
-0.0011536955,
0.0035925084,
0.0188183524,
-0.0725259483,
-0.0133480364,
0.0001531838,
-0.0131986383,
0.0429455116,
0.0250575542,
-0.0263634715,
0.0646636263,
0.019963488,
-0.0633720458,
-0.0038372353,
-0.0019983267,
-0.0002903546,
-0.0660386756,
0.0400900096,
-0.0437173173,
0.0137077402,
-0.0024307251,
-0.0170697216,
-0.0591507107,
0.0593913719,
-0.0905895978,
0.0373046361,
-0.0736338124,
0.0015904611,
0.0305146147,
0.0211095996,
-0.0416160598,
0.05669057,
0.0137490127,
0.0354286842,
-0.0215292946,
-0.0100587541,
0.0457872674,
-0.0776934326,
0.0186147839,
0.009757081,
0.013291114,
-0.023426339,
0.0196223371,
-0.0176572595,
0.0053722141,
-0.0251850411,
-0.0529373735,
-0.0251317304,
0.0096826795,
0.0582048334,
-0.028266063,
0.0377664529,
0.0154056195,
-0.0016920943,
-0.0812498182,
-0.0031138393,
0.011249491,
-0.0023197855,
0.0255433954,
0.0226910189,
-0.0561815389,
-0.0359452665,
-0.0284350757,
-0.0272185039,
0.0423618853,
0.0197528359,
-0.0533710159,
-0.0275668353,
-0.0261087697,
-0.0313189551,
0.0382435583,
-0.0166823026,
-0.0520623401,
-0.0045656194,
-0.0346087888,
0.0974487588,
-0.0284175538,
0.0010186926,
-0.0007097084,
0.0253554918,
0.0063562528,
0.0003654863,
-0.0056019481,
-0.0691722035,
0.0039331033,
0.0082876636,
-0.0180522092,
0.0175116118,
0.0901533812,
0.0179746877,
-0.0515478812,
-0.0610644929,
0.0046322858,
0.0176878721,
-0.0050595067,
0.0120075876,
-0.0117880153,
-0.0225935094,
0.0254509039,
0.0006975876,
-0.0454980545,
0.0721004084,
-0.0313374847,
0.0078041567,
-0.017632911,
-0.0038657289,
-0.0391847938,
0.0510207526,
0.0211436804,
0.0181523971,
0.015986193,
-0.0296161212,
0.0210451838,
0.0174396262,
-0.0188207161,
-0.0580817275,
0.0324764997,
-0.0622460581,
0.0319064744,
0.0011809052,
-0.0130708264,
-0.026356278,
0.0356804207,
-0.0040918197,
0.0497941114,
0.0688609332,
-0.030040402,
0.0010164515,
0.0732579082,
0.0062961695,
0.0373961292,
0.0126553643,
0.0287807062,
0.0110963918,
0.0422342122,
0.009757,
-0.0473215692,
-0.0059174937,
0.0247792099,
-0.0117265647,
0.0031255018,
-0.025220871,
0.0534084514,
-0.0009316265,
0.0228463933,
0.0084641725,
-0.0218029488,
-0.0339668654,
0.0221888144,
-0.0023637619,
-0.0251622479,
-0.0552158877,
0.1111057475,
0.0201671775,
0.0061869733,
0.0385836959,
0.0150290122,
-0.0266591739,
-0.0207635406,
0.0318065397,
-0.0940363556,
-0.0097967666,
-0.0250367057,
-0.0151034053,
-0.0143737532,
-0.0425053537,
0.0162009783,
-0.0723828375,
0.0402733721,
0.0193078201,
-0.0248548128,
-0.0556862913,
-0.0343295187,
-0.0526680835,
-0.0367734693,
-0.0398051813,
0.0170328673,
-0.0049702772,
0.0339245461,
0.0474757664,
-0.0126152635,
-0.0795001984,
0.0028436047,
-0.0067900079,
-0.001888845,
0.1166660786,
0.0472019129,
0.0240478609,
-0.0733952671,
-0.0024933373,
-0.0047694813,
0.0133205419,
-0.0319398753,
-0.0090819169,
0.0576078817,
-0.0244553667,
-0.0463160947,
0.0050741965,
-0.0282155275,
-0.0014758583,
-0.0373423398,
0.0679090172,
-0.0149080865,
-0.0507444367,
-0.0322464332,
-0.0084808944,
-0.0169457905,
0.0619977564,
0.030351162,
-0.010172192,
-0.0639957115,
-0.0143575091,
0.0813964531,
-0.0642055199,
-0.0771393031,
-0.0195341371,
0.0199541114,
-0.0380521864,
-0.083250232,
-0.0022619576,
0.0094284508,
0.0153641338,
0.0223107245,
0.0273754373,
0.0272935275,
0.0002635006,
-0.0419091508,
-0.0118059227,
0.0187710393,
-0.003031519,
-0.0900666341,
-0.0617525838,
0.074900113,
-0.0038083601,
-0.0173653625,
0.051114466,
-0.0632118136,
-0.0514673144,
-0.0123144099,
0.0443981178,
0.0241989121,
-0.0408330224,
-0.0013785557,
-0.0285447426,
0.0051992792,
0.0329282172,
0.02638603,
-0.0208394509,
-0.0263152849,
0.019420566,
-0.0249846652,
0.0150621999,
-0.0149120977,
0.0269029271,
-0.0099331858,
0.061910972,
-0.0175067037,
-0.0271091703,
0.043667797,
0.0094752377,
0.0576276667,
-0.0152178975,
0.0161594022,
-0.022000419,
-0.0110194487,
-0.0255826842,
0.0320806056,
-0.0413458347,
-0.0037616773,
0.0358286463,
0.0096476143,
-0.0328916274,
-0.0241752174,
-0.0380680375,
0.0067171128,
-0.04474416,
0.0305119883,
0.0324668176,
-0.0004207431,
0.0077442215,
-0.0297723562,
0.0212807935,
0.0496010631,
-0.020817345,
-0.0164914019,
-0.0407261997,
-0.0151983891,
-0.0039509526,
0.0559867583,
0.0021447153,
0.0029785263,
-0.0316710621,
0.0472313575,
-0.0283708367,
0.0044892067,
0.0390307643,
-0.0006276885,
0.0221602712,
-0.0272370093,
0.0034658776,
-0.0461091362,
0.061145369,
0.0003869497,
-0.0161175393,
0.0406160653,
0.0229259022,
-0.0536707342,
-0.0580547601,
0.075795345,
0.0645887479,
0.0525329486,
-0.0210511126,
-0.0438119918,
-0.0396243818,
-0.0177903622,
-0.001093642,
-0.046239242,
-0.0339725278,
0.0233880356,
-0.0576836057,
-0.0479695015,
-0.0114375465,
0.0385910869,
0.0498592779,
0.0088446839,
0.0278309304,
-0.0075661223,
0.0147751402,
-0.0415423103,
-0.0326372758,
0.0469372198,
-0.0105563169,
-0.0807131305,
-0.039570827,
-5.731920207e-33,
-0.0117926318,
-0.0261087641,
-0.0040294859,
-0.0076634479,
-0.0054928907,
-0.0225869957,
-0.0559252836,
0.0128444126,
-0.0000721723,
-0.0071355365,
0.007447937,
-0.0154378908,
0.0032446368,
0.0097620515,
0.0196826309,
0.0202001296,
0.05153412,
-0.0147437099,
0.0391660854,
0.0407467373,
0.0241091829,
0.0452313982,
0.042931091,
-0.0024041233,
-0.0027823956,
-0.0295554604,
0.0189299975,
-0.0231101811,
-0.0096990364,
0.0208447706,
-0.0446126498,
0.0068622497,
-0.009276079,
-0.0632792041,
-0.0240851473,
-0.0227382537,
-0.0770690292,
-0.0031738658,
0.0215119366,
-0.020276241,
0.0017557926,
-0.0583414994,
0.0351109169,
-0.0342352092,
-0.0659177899,
0.0350079685,
0.0344928876,
-0.0219544601,
-0.0460772663,
-0.0788984522,
-0.0352273025,
0.0265140943,
0.0107609704,
0.0221072864,
0.0759475604,
-0.0261835437,
-0.0195969623,
-0.0013526635,
0.0149882687,
0.0291254167,
0.0863833576,
0.078783825,
0.0527620129,
-0.0033282051,
0.0428494774,
-0.0134139517,
0.0163480416,
-0.0632268637,
-0.0244905651,
0.0466212593,
-0.0084027629,
0.0143737942,
0.0288189892,
0.002427265,
0.0543560013,
0.0025686526,
-0.0745608211,
0.0296584386,
0.010023593,
0.0303408969,
-0.0057335696,
0.0265874434,
-0.0412800834,
0.0070796194,
0.0259264279,
-0.0220121704,
0.0086245565,
-0.0400296263,
0.0194795672,
-0.0283520799,
0.0004611238,
0.0474227071,
0.0227152072,
-0.0267577674,
-0.0371616259,
0.039416559,
0.031926427,
-0.0017528054,
-0.0323723964,
0.019233536,
-0.0325300097,
-0.0478151329,
0.0653293803,
0.0166854113,
0.0455876067,
-0.0340546593,
0.0032637587,
0.0229796469,
-0.0502758101,
-0.0105112977,
-0.0238336604,
0.0304515287,
-0.0037538458,
0.0540717207,
-0.0078154579,
0.0021346824,
0.0219469219,
0.0114965066,
0.0162693951,
-0.0326847695,
0.0390905663,
0.0365798958,
0.024130404,
-0.0110542569,
-0.0469910577,
0.0019110935,
-0.018132126,
0.0605976805,
0.0154629247,
-0.011078611,
-0.035910327,
0.0540338233,
2.631e-7,
0.033716049,
0.0368642919,
0.0914671943,
-0.0143950945,
0.0378491171,
-0.0131614516,
-0.010206853,
0.0091035329,
-0.0602016859,
-0.0108857602,
0.0130565753,
-0.0264071301,
0.0291991122,
0.0048440602,
-0.0351409838,
0.0382904969,
-0.0371058956,
0.0280966535,
-0.0168444533,
0.0165530127,
0.0252846852,
0.1106854603,
-0.0297143776,
0.0085100839,
0.0267097671,
0.0075928727,
0.0498215891,
-0.0155675188,
0.0019207869,
0.0115504237,
0.0297156647,
-0.0042421753,
0.0150135905,
-0.0001078467,
-0.0216945242,
0.0003087237,
0.0212060995,
0.0528754257,
-0.0357280597,
-0.0368880369,
0.064015992,
-0.0064159785,
0.0184324086,
-0.0328674763,
0.0057218862,
-0.0117058959,
-0.0397389159,
0.0207719915,
-0.0025316833,
0.0400427878,
-0.0275040623,
-0.0034851406,
-0.0001020466,
0.0291464273,
0.0361064933,
-0.0118392296,
-0.0026857259,
-0.0584860295,
0.0178784635,
0.0105152512,
-0.0470293276,
0.0296683852,
-0.0636809096,
0.0435386188,
0.0229723547,
-0.0087179299,
-0.0050278106,
2.187729985e-34,
0.0032288635,
-0.0278775245,
-0.0278493371,
0.0120534813,
0.0254549161,
-0.0084959073,
-0.0027964639,
0.0374174193,
-0.0160649326,
-0.0893527642,
-0.0562360473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10633v1 | Multi-Method Self-Training: Improving Code Generation With Text, And Vice Versa | 2023-07-20T06:58:55 | 2023-07-20T06:58:55 | Shriyash K. Upadhyay, Etan J. Ginsberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models have many methods for solving the same problem. This
introduces novel strengths (different methods may work well for different
problems) and weaknesses (it may be difficult for users to know which method to
use). In this paper, we introduce Multi-Method Self-Training (MMST), where one
method is trained on the filtered outputs of another, allowing us to augment
the strengths and ameliorate the weaknesses of each method. Using a 176B
parameter model trained on both language and code, we show that MMST can 1)
improve the less performant method (up to 30%) making the model easier to use,
2) improve the more performant method (up to 32.2%) making the model more
performant, and 3) improve the performance of related but distinct tasks (up to
10.3%) by improving the ability of the model to generate rationales. We then
conduct ablation analyses to explore why MMST works. We show that MMST
generates more data than traditional self-training, but the improvement in
performance is driven by the use of multiple methods. We also analyze
prompt-engineering and anti-correlated performance between methods as means of
making MMST more effective. We hope the evidence from our paper motivates
machine learning researchers to explore ways in which advances in language
models allow for new forms of training. | [
0.013808025,
0.0675884411,
-0.0212469995,
0.0102569824,
-0.0112214517,
-0.009194578,
0.0158958342,
0.0037036797,
0.0019011364,
-0.056458734,
-0.0330672488,
0.0186229199,
-0.0192257017,
0.0396757498,
0.0418459475,
-0.0278760474,
0.0253561251,
-0.0515856855,
-0.0155762378,
-0.0044216146,
-0.0158723667,
0.0258614998,
0.0105859572,
0.0503834039,
0.0144869359,
-0.046136938,
-0.0403327942,
0.0053877607,
-0.0330025889,
-0.0373936631,
0.0015763795,
0.0752882063,
0.0184371769,
0.0014167669,
0.0000024369,
-0.0429390892,
-0.0353258476,
-0.0101973657,
-0.0090394933,
0.0593755841,
0.0252095405,
0.0145172756,
0.0124091757,
0.0424352586,
-0.0559667423,
0.0262158941,
0.0475586914,
-0.0059222542,
0.0996690691,
0.0501933135,
0.0099423835,
-0.0212341361,
-0.0096172504,
0.0112076374,
0.0066851922,
-0.0118204728,
-0.0157232489,
0.0411742553,
0.0306403283,
0.0188441873,
0.0047075259,
0.0188222621,
0.0371649116,
0.0009087808,
0.0144614847,
0.0631018355,
-0.0129445717,
0.0043262984,
-0.0024761402,
0.0201279111,
-0.0751155242,
-0.0479044989,
0.0166541003,
-0.0214796383,
-0.008504929,
-0.0078179846,
-0.0158666596,
0.0232852083,
-0.0062055094,
0.0163739678,
0.0242572445,
-0.0094260601,
0.014267968,
0.0074241185,
-0.0252744965,
0.0364893377,
-0.0110709406,
-0.0229886454,
-0.0026616526,
-0.0076303398,
0.0115816863,
-0.0814175159,
-0.0159506556,
0.0557208471,
0.0016557579,
0.0066692578,
-0.058287397,
-0.0355684161,
0.0254618134,
-0.0477623194,
0.0283241197,
0.0492803827,
-0.0034211641,
-0.0071054855,
-0.0609050058,
0.0404682569,
-0.0005586543,
-0.0040233703,
-0.0194362532,
0.0557101928,
-0.0998000875,
-0.0330740474,
-0.0681558996,
0.0760881528,
-0.0004134737,
0.008615749,
-0.0646960586,
0.0385097861,
0.0036574034,
-0.0096086068,
0.0141709,
0.0043302733,
-0.0363265648,
-0.0010702935,
0.0109440144,
-0.0150485644,
-0.0438969284,
-0.0386796445,
0.0072634546,
-0.04768629,
-0.0059023672,
0.0002039331,
-0.0121793477,
-0.0161127187,
0.0243673921,
0.0398140214,
-0.0350111946,
0.0106253186,
-0.0631921962,
-0.0631226227,
-0.0078609651,
-0.0585281178,
-0.0250758734,
-0.1088582277,
-0.0278823469,
0.0093405433,
-0.0230783019,
-0.0718078464,
0.0178608801,
-0.0079904944,
0.0163711049,
0.0610526092,
-0.0439924225,
0.0198866129,
0.0460891724,
0.0128131527,
-0.0098758088,
0.0800975859,
0.0392440483,
0.0195046794,
0.0008358848,
-0.0476011038,
0.0542800501,
0.0201054886,
0.0074721323,
-0.0062786294,
-0.0241924785,
-0.0007434167,
0.0162276924,
0.0083379857,
0.0351641662,
0.0239312369,
-0.0275836214,
0.038507551,
0.0116250915,
0.034482073,
0.0439139158,
0.0532579608,
0.0883248523,
-0.0001844249,
0.0243730638,
0.0106366463,
-0.0346403606,
0.0408612713,
-0.0091787381,
0.0332515799,
0.0132309273,
0.0301954653,
-0.0270810146,
-0.0989429578,
-0.0116138682,
-0.0158076994,
-0.0059900736,
0.0015542494,
0.0507776998,
0.0083724055,
-0.0435901396,
-0.0004027049,
0.0068182275,
-0.0803938508,
-0.0178291891,
-0.0762148276,
0.0059138392,
0.0637552142,
0.0349078998,
-0.0377341285,
-0.0200926457,
0.0031733843,
0.0090579866,
-0.0244148932,
0.0335315168,
-0.0142064029,
0.0064301374,
-0.0551611632,
-0.0210864022,
-0.0801049173,
-0.0033709195,
0.0579033829,
0.0124567654,
-0.0365359709,
0.0274780411,
-0.0015537307,
-0.0626376271,
0.0429416969,
-0.03411524,
-0.0374792628,
0.0421586223,
-0.0129925087,
-0.0116039431,
-0.0208234191,
-0.0260949507,
0.0406430401,
0.025312623,
-0.0286702942,
-0.0355269201,
-0.0139571074,
-0.0607384294,
-0.0200648047,
0.0370611884,
0.0193266142,
-0.0211808179,
0.0089713866,
-0.0045884294,
-0.0379127823,
0.0508578271,
-0.0271321721,
0.0133537473,
-0.0095196022,
0.0400558785,
0.0093851984,
-0.0324237123,
-0.0258289352,
0.0597722866,
0.0280270651,
-0.0036779987,
-0.0145918773,
0.0618032776,
0.0491048992,
-0.0281344131,
0.0176980682,
0.0138575481,
-0.0282545425,
0.0467075631,
0.0158199705,
0.0342119895,
-0.0245579425,
-0.0364721194,
-0.0836874843,
0.0035840736,
-0.0205928627,
-0.0108244251,
0.0180552229,
0.0105964523,
-0.0002113389,
-0.033523187,
-0.0365002751,
-0.0348410904,
-0.0138207395,
0.0307746567,
0.0118375681,
0.0148981214,
-0.0211365167,
-0.035638582,
-0.0262441952,
-0.0401844829,
0.0444129668,
-0.0026475477,
0.0083726114,
-0.0747581273,
0.0615935102,
-0.0046323617,
0.019769134,
-0.004138547,
-0.0477046259,
0.0145000629,
-0.0387937613,
0.0550380759,
0.0623344369,
0.003311862,
0.007869455,
0.085851565,
0.0126374187,
-0.077025272,
0.0308354367,
0.0150300292,
-0.0373221748,
0.0198630262,
-0.047820393,
0.0322471559,
0.070076257,
0.0215128604,
-0.0032911634,
-0.0534408614,
0.0607645288,
0.0082069421,
-0.0458350405,
-0.0283108801,
-0.0556780733,
0.0127785811,
0.0649966151,
0.00525067,
-0.0861374959,
0.0699738637,
-0.0414335653,
-0.0188950002,
-0.03880018,
-0.0401630178,
-0.0190773681,
0.0558254682,
-0.0073240935,
0.0383143686,
0.0215524659,
-0.0294360165,
-0.0339985564,
-0.0187804159,
0.0364214741,
-0.0074573727,
0.0458530299,
-0.0564487875,
0.0058705602,
0.0059668845,
-0.0750128478,
-0.0630975887,
-0.0433947034,
0.0183720384,
-0.0072596804,
0.0138102882,
0.0075997696,
0.0376940183,
0.0289358962,
0.0093633197,
0.0700900704,
-0.0146959061,
-0.047854051,
0.0007741292,
-0.0233353823,
-0.0069546881,
-0.0334295295,
-0.0273782182,
-0.0185010638,
0.0539312772,
-0.0105071161,
0.0615512207,
0.0083867116,
-0.0659257695,
0.0334783383,
0.0044384985,
-0.0610482022,
-0.0364420637,
0.0538588315,
0.0565775894,
-0.0594175123,
-0.0318553448,
0.114858292,
0.0544387214,
-0.0158043951,
0.0068091839,
-0.0374181345,
0.0340275317,
0.0477581397,
0.0669703782,
-0.0304076001,
-0.0161457863,
-0.0073958305,
0.0524495095,
-0.0217589047,
-0.0079671126,
-0.0168512426,
-0.1205267981,
0.0377036743,
0.0031379245,
-0.0083460091,
-0.0176585056,
-0.0372764431,
-0.0529477447,
-0.0100861629,
-0.0514611453,
0.0311971232,
-0.0263962559,
0.0303854216,
0.0454871468,
-0.0426926278,
-0.0170826912,
0.0039084889,
-0.0122651961,
0.0008771828,
0.0704903528,
0.0122427745,
0.0164485984,
-0.0103161437,
0.0408636332,
0.0031953841,
0.047832299,
-0.0376842171,
0.0577558912,
0.0056842095,
0.000183435,
0.0388942994,
0.0344001278,
-0.0186121892,
-0.0335131213,
0.033114586,
0.0513734668,
-0.0053684833,
0.0029689246,
-0.0029970116,
0.0105598206,
-0.0040138466,
0.0290655363,
0.0195008628,
-0.0296597127,
-0.0431794822,
-0.0646238327,
-0.011631134,
-0.069123432,
-0.0239300355,
-0.0308070686,
-0.0188743658,
-0.0102817295,
-0.0600312762,
-0.0413246751,
0.0083559696,
0.0794493407,
0.0133214705,
0.0076660695,
0.0019599413,
0.0312624797,
-0.0399032906,
-0.0026273385,
-0.0103443582,
-0.0188503023,
-0.0360504985,
-0.0276617482,
-0.0042056092,
-0.033698272,
-0.0121174501,
0.0013188411,
-0.0589096211,
-0.0555454716,
-0.0355574898,
0.102574721,
0.0244560074,
0.0523532666,
-0.0160640348,
-0.0379030854,
-0.0328832455,
0.0049273069,
-0.0280562695,
-0.0101837814,
0.0294045713,
0.0006735682,
0.0150086721,
-0.0035331962,
-0.0228704531,
0.014742435,
0.0200226549,
0.0211943071,
-0.0431508087,
0.0040089446,
0.0627176017,
0.0223163459,
0.0196495224,
-0.0177712999,
-0.0203747991,
-0.0175736416,
-0.0166286323,
-0.0203245487,
-0.0479302369,
-0.0446902923,
0.0662000626,
0.018869685,
-0.0119065261,
0.0398757868,
-0.0149864396,
-0.028367186,
0.0262824185,
0.005148964,
0.0309093632,
-0.0139882406,
0.0720670894,
0.0412008837,
-0.0036047031,
-0.0344479196,
0.0234558079,
0.0436985306,
0.0158979911,
-0.0304727722,
0.072518073,
0.0014309576,
0.0449999981,
-0.0135578476,
0.0212063156,
-0.0569550544,
-0.072878778,
-0.03203246,
-0.0153360777,
0.0378938951,
0.0171862822,
0.0270898268,
-0.0323960036,
0.0059052324,
-0.022764083,
0.0751884654,
0.0212041158,
-0.008976738,
-0.018438844,
0.025116235,
-0.0296971295,
-0.0591704883,
0.1052599326,
-0.0042703911,
0.0166903734,
0.007151966,
-0.0235454813,
-0.0418818519,
-0.0054871524,
0.0353916623,
0.014848439,
-0.009019943,
-0.0241664704,
-0.033671461,
-0.0524258055,
-0.0094696553,
0.0363355167,
0.0274705067,
-0.0103310188,
0.065658465,
0.1030899882,
-0.0066463007,
0.0299462155,
-0.0511401668,
0.0180429667,
0.0049958513,
-0.0216254834,
-0.036777094,
-5.996252887e-33,
-0.0264125243,
-0.0476443432,
0.0453818142,
-0.0143206045,
0.0295004323,
0.0033427335,
-0.0385332331,
0.0407024436,
0.0280489903,
-0.0245401859,
-0.0055141924,
-0.0104405461,
0.00083488,
-0.0389468223,
0.0574724115,
0.0330337361,
0.0705456361,
-0.0015083752,
-0.0669366866,
0.0168534443,
-0.0040751649,
0.0208035316,
-0.0022192514,
-0.0433739312,
-0.0455404781,
0.0247883033,
0.0069080885,
-0.0088474844,
0.0160162896,
0.0607997403,
-0.0036823899,
-0.0010059156,
0.0071390094,
-0.0385676585,
-0.0445123576,
-0.0148246633,
-0.0183366593,
-0.0476515144,
0.0123620294,
-0.022439681,
-0.0157680307,
-0.0712609515,
0.0555738471,
-0.0177197754,
-0.0311440509,
0.0015919288,
0.0381114595,
0.0109923789,
-0.0031793404,
-0.0225980971,
-0.074357219,
0.0367126204,
-0.0390632562,
-0.0262354836,
0.0149110099,
0.0508025885,
-0.0166544579,
0.0096369181,
-0.0115226787,
0.005762002,
0.0442487448,
0.0712478533,
0.0832641125,
0.0086696558,
-0.0025952014,
0.0116697373,
0.0202838331,
0.0160951316,
-0.0333568268,
0.0078722108,
0.0442187153,
0.0567812622,
0.0625381172,
0.0211735535,
0.0615182407,
0.0124469157,
-0.0541797429,
0.0299942829,
-0.0232787579,
-0.0018828926,
0.0321034789,
0.0166710876,
-0.0260145701,
-0.0209977385,
-0.0494483151,
-0.013696285,
-0.0220214147,
-0.0612079874,
0.0470422544,
0.0081488211,
-0.0186156686,
-0.0012754444,
0.0307118967,
-0.0052251797,
-0.028905822,
0.020485796,
-0.0519314371,
0.0307682976,
-0.0093127079,
0.0173652638,
-0.0114554148,
-0.0041970112,
0.0140853589,
0.0195587538,
0.0703439936,
0.0166356787,
0.0254451986,
0.015393896,
-0.0783852413,
-0.0121160802,
-0.058619678,
-0.0043038386,
0.0125831058,
0.0250110384,
-0.0003277463,
0.0023522417,
0.0026368967,
0.021562146,
-0.0066417404,
-0.0694227219,
-0.0587238781,
-0.0122585706,
0.0257676393,
0.036084462,
0.0037471228,
-0.0155735323,
-0.0550945923,
0.0219061486,
0.0472016372,
-0.0235645622,
-0.0408772901,
0.0283196289,
2.951e-7,
0.0167701412,
0.0266867764,
-0.0095978566,
0.0123412861,
-0.0124655105,
0.0510905795,
-0.0199822206,
-0.025812909,
0.0314428546,
0.0278365593,
-0.0236319937,
0.0488451719,
0.0282305386,
0.0440162458,
-0.0291239694,
-0.0138722993,
-0.0147730615,
0.0145377908,
-0.0739618614,
-0.0089315074,
0.046158839,
0.0485963784,
0.0066387346,
0.0064597777,
0.0214362685,
-0.0171579551,
0.040829476,
0.0129451463,
0.0127234226,
0.0491943732,
-0.041902747,
0.0167918261,
-0.0065451548,
-0.0061035254,
-0.0308317617,
-0.0100060292,
0.000946201,
0.0720972866,
-0.0132376077,
0.0312485322,
0.0648269877,
0.0153803965,
-0.0021268632,
-0.0781033486,
0.0480217151,
-0.0322864391,
-0.0054379702,
0.001470718,
0.0080951173,
0.0027416844,
0.0206128098,
-0.0308217797,
0.0009334559,
0.0294482615,
-0.008837712,
-0.016507661,
-0.0197212677,
-0.0407793038,
-0.0542430878,
0.0339817815,
-0.0085231932,
-0.0276241805,
-0.067925781,
0.0353503674,
0.0482068323,
-0.0628081709,
-0.0000785798,
3.19452804e-34,
-0.0092302123,
-0.0189310536,
0.035080228,
0.0494644046,
0.040567454,
0.0120930336,
-0.0350545645,
0.0384107344,
0.0351895019,
-0.0138830869,
-0.037139982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10587v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10587v1 | A Deep Dive into the Disparity of Word Error Rates Across Thousands of NPTEL MOOC Videos | 2023-07-20T05:03:00 | 2023-07-20T05:03:00 | Anand Kumar Rai, Siddharth D Jaiswal, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems are designed to transcribe spoken
language into written text and find utility in a variety of applications
including voice assistants and transcription services. However, it has been
observed that state-of-the-art ASR systems which deliver impressive benchmark
results, struggle with speakers of certain regions or demographics due to
variation in their speech properties. In this work, we describe the curation of
a massive speech dataset of 8740 hours consisting of $\sim9.8$K technical
lectures in the English language along with their transcripts delivered by
instructors representing various parts of Indian demography. The dataset is
sourced from the very popular NPTEL MOOC platform. We use the curated dataset
to measure the existing disparity in YouTube Automatic Captions and OpenAI
Whisper model performance across the diverse demographic traits of speakers in
India. While there exists disparity due to gender, native region, age and
speech rate of speakers, disparity based on caste is non-existent. We also
observe statistically significant disparity across the disciplines of the
lectures. These results indicate the need of more inclusive and robust ASR
systems and more representational datasets for disparity evaluation in them. | [
0.0110256942,
0.069550544,
-0.0223918185,
0.0291603468,
-0.0043609128,
-0.0005254098,
0.0219692457,
-0.0197882093,
0.0049809502,
-0.0787720457,
-0.0027631877,
-0.0267833807,
0.0448708422,
0.0195264015,
0.0134400008,
-0.0863163173,
0.0196458716,
-0.0211172998,
0.0127580669,
-0.0180378519,
0.0155089777,
0.0252044126,
-0.0705355853,
0.0468543172,
-0.0069258842,
0.0022795738,
0.0174523965,
-0.0102290697,
0.0139680197,
0.0070824847,
0.0184647795,
0.0459740721,
0.0000515917,
0.061233975,
0.0000017663,
-0.0551238991,
0.0211865287,
0.010672654,
-0.0142025454,
0.0630462989,
0.0179070272,
0.0501880534,
-0.0262778364,
0.0635791346,
-0.0185541362,
0.0365291424,
0.0451485887,
-0.0383376516,
0.0103233512,
0.059096586,
-0.0085121784,
-0.01377228,
0.030068649,
0.0177293848,
-0.0203408487,
0.024601724,
-0.0138403457,
-0.003590655,
0.0077412911,
-0.0364953019,
-0.0483117104,
0.0275919735,
-0.0154480245,
-0.0416095071,
0.018778814,
0.0052048969,
-0.0743902773,
-0.0617488138,
-0.0091126189,
0.053547319,
0.0386226177,
0.0587293357,
0.0424121544,
0.0035341019,
-0.0236400515,
-0.0075874776,
-0.0160122495,
0.0604530387,
-0.0174912494,
-0.0041031931,
-0.0163210072,
0.0356858149,
-0.0146830194,
-0.0053084185,
0.06019843,
-0.0252633449,
0.020234596,
-0.0282146148,
-0.0396643281,
0.0004555601,
0.0018034913,
-0.0003299177,
0.0743790343,
0.0029220181,
-0.0080577731,
0.00711584,
-0.0367327444,
-0.0651689991,
-0.0108722765,
-0.0271316357,
0.0344538763,
0.0549184084,
-0.0522389635,
-0.006362326,
0.022471033,
0.0959142968,
0.0262936782,
0.0288377628,
0.0058165174,
0.0090465834,
-0.0334276035,
-0.0033654929,
0.0242632609,
0.0048433924,
-0.0018621302,
-0.0002891085,
-0.0730539411,
-0.0009661851,
-0.0438289382,
0.0012083114,
-0.0090224678,
-0.0236872174,
-0.0057715122,
-0.0147515386,
-0.0028037676,
0.052252505,
-0.0070321853,
0.0724112391,
0.003159822,
-0.1067974567,
0.0213394389,
0.0327531658,
0.0174840894,
0.0120523116,
0.0076399078,
0.0243872609,
-0.0396943204,
-0.0303836502,
-0.0385714173,
-0.0046991943,
-0.0569006875,
-0.0280430652,
-0.0123557299,
-0.05709121,
0.0424560383,
0.0406023152,
-0.001178308,
-0.0178145207,
0.007378954,
0.0098896809,
-0.0153548941,
0.0380729809,
0.0207285304,
0.0187451709,
0.0961512104,
0.0366535671,
0.009076491,
0.0440249629,
0.0730053559,
-0.0412718356,
0.0439258218,
-0.0236361939,
0.0104371281,
0.0388482884,
-0.0087550394,
0.0212759282,
-0.0214121472,
-0.0134065337,
0.025514463,
0.0113102868,
0.0502794124,
0.0429819152,
0.0139905009,
0.0225331932,
0.0404212885,
0.0973806754,
-0.0220296457,
0.0155910561,
-0.0016031059,
0.037397664,
0.0181605406,
0.0070516681,
0.0162239745,
-0.029458344,
-0.0046950616,
0.0054789083,
0.1074434891,
0.0346955098,
-0.0258930344,
-0.0327491611,
-0.0405759923,
-0.0156997368,
-0.0232175663,
-0.0039786841,
0.0343615189,
-0.0141638014,
-0.0258792862,
0.0310311951,
0.0372746475,
-0.0816575065,
0.0448432639,
-0.0738205016,
0.0028674558,
0.0240234844,
-0.0154283168,
-0.030324541,
0.019924812,
-0.0167775899,
0.0003518013,
0.0601247177,
0.0455680266,
-0.0060559665,
0.0017056701,
-0.0746154189,
0.011427436,
0.0209250525,
0.0158741586,
0.0156210596,
0.0104943225,
0.0673345327,
0.0446200892,
0.0039320309,
-0.0515380688,
0.0005691028,
-0.0126411794,
-0.0035496629,
-0.0209754985,
-0.0033348917,
0.0643807426,
0.0177457556,
-0.0452266783,
-0.0513721779,
-0.0235750247,
0.0032601752,
-0.0054362286,
0.0133263478,
-0.0366920494,
0.0025010013,
0.0622011051,
-0.1247584596,
0.0120571451,
0.0652360842,
-0.0098146899,
-0.0769697428,
0.0720578134,
-0.0299582202,
0.0055175475,
-0.0303314868,
0.0303372648,
-0.002081,
0.0135158272,
0.0371948369,
-0.0236647781,
0.0057244487,
-0.0055892081,
0.0345071219,
-0.003539355,
0.0248282515,
-0.0952583551,
-0.0349416994,
0.0031393289,
-0.0421214066,
0.0683687925,
0.004085382,
-0.0047674901,
-0.0486937426,
-0.022798216,
-0.0707843453,
-0.0025541335,
-0.0152453342,
-0.0071973293,
-0.0219827015,
-0.000341616,
-0.0420345552,
-0.0434513763,
0.0169103723,
-0.0226117112,
0.0048237378,
-0.003930748,
-0.0073438105,
-0.0302542355,
-0.0094264615,
-0.0139667913,
-0.0370577052,
-0.0357727744,
-0.0164025705,
0.0252745003,
-0.0201716218,
-0.0184234325,
0.0377993844,
0.009470637,
-0.0050293314,
-0.0064256545,
-0.0409570038,
-0.0154722733,
0.0309890304,
0.0200631339,
0.0348407738,
0.0147082051,
0.0344517194,
0.0014826364,
-0.0166159198,
-0.0114965076,
0.0091286842,
0.0288935918,
-0.0233912896,
0.0078765713,
-0.0431091115,
-0.050612811,
-0.0108197434,
0.0161085725,
0.0284577403,
-0.0482636653,
-0.0511515252,
-0.0826275051,
0.0022478197,
-0.0163199957,
0.0039806329,
-0.0341587849,
0.0196586512,
0.0117762117,
-0.0483058654,
0.0249304511,
-0.0554922596,
0.0034368588,
-0.0343575403,
-0.0340817384,
-0.0278691817,
-0.0050960104,
-0.0113435453,
-0.0007598828,
0.0136055024,
-0.0772128776,
-0.0539448187,
0.0055801794,
0.0078904629,
-0.0702783838,
0.0337662175,
-0.0448335223,
-0.0018225858,
-0.0396989733,
-0.0076918993,
-0.000788639,
-0.0373188443,
-0.0232862476,
-0.0271747056,
0.0106478911,
-0.048637256,
-0.0080214003,
0.0238322876,
-0.0092676347,
0.0235486887,
-0.0113927582,
0.0150724137,
-0.0063029332,
0.0096363444,
0.0394895077,
0.060755562,
-0.031994123,
-0.0248885211,
0.0275362879,
-0.0142256999,
0.0712736249,
-0.0005029957,
-0.0057198331,
-0.0203599315,
0.0339222476,
-0.0169015937,
0.0176907536,
0.0412054919,
0.0709958375,
-0.0198400933,
0.0227808207,
0.1008424908,
-0.0003394372,
-0.0348435044,
-0.047507979,
-0.0173994098,
0.0188388675,
0.0105425948,
0.0040133195,
-0.0895865858,
-0.0054535065,
0.0368639417,
0.0850876123,
0.006235138,
0.0317645147,
-0.0363259166,
-0.0997727215,
0.0199692585,
0.0297500361,
-0.0231701415,
-0.0302147977,
-0.0445897393,
-0.0245583262,
-0.0193557795,
0.0690961927,
-0.0207674112,
-0.0267897118,
-0.0191171207,
0.0622461066,
-0.1110205501,
-0.0432731882,
0.0326374918,
-0.0042948602,
0.0754155517,
0.0163393915,
0.0088378182,
-0.0537917279,
-0.0524424277,
0.0036179603,
-0.0172345061,
-0.0161113124,
0.0048403717,
0.0673422292,
-0.0307594333,
-0.010621625,
0.0033590249,
0.0643130019,
-0.0015896229,
0.0123554859,
0.0288532339,
0.056841325,
0.009880499,
-0.0053833677,
-0.0482949317,
0.0197772812,
0.0013367538,
0.0469780117,
0.026970543,
-0.0416728333,
0.0005819082,
0.004690805,
-0.0063897721,
0.0138950003,
-0.0251435526,
0.0376933925,
0.016592551,
-0.0402632207,
0.0410728976,
-0.0320604257,
0.0116941836,
-0.0022734974,
0.0428339653,
-0.0251370948,
0.0372876674,
0.0480071865,
-0.0296543296,
0.0312418155,
-0.0317328647,
0.0279607251,
-0.0935908705,
-0.0326496251,
0.0182177369,
-0.0097239381,
-0.0398012064,
-0.0104960715,
-0.0293219741,
-0.0574303567,
0.0415245257,
0.0187378991,
0.0251414105,
0.0419215634,
-0.0170306265,
-0.0264903009,
0.0668321401,
0.0520391688,
-0.0317339897,
0.0144783333,
0.0300916489,
0.0009614746,
-0.0242742784,
-0.0001522194,
-0.0479823053,
-0.0003106317,
-0.0533162653,
-0.0114682084,
-0.0132734673,
-0.0446812734,
-0.0275984611,
0.0057267514,
0.0462045409,
-0.0364764221,
-0.0043991446,
-0.05042018,
0.0139866155,
0.0336348489,
0.0316377096,
-0.0149192456,
-0.0400330015,
0.0374837853,
0.0265344139,
-0.0182649065,
-0.0007134619,
-0.0504970253,
-0.0309163574,
-0.0405732803,
0.0731353611,
0.0254221298,
0.0248863101,
0.0288235284,
-0.0092961909,
0.0171466637,
0.0151493931,
0.0282591973,
0.0323385857,
0.0244769901,
0.0622832477,
-0.0111521119,
0.0347681269,
0.0748319253,
0.0081973476,
-0.0346647911,
-0.0076705469,
-0.0121727865,
0.0295134373,
0.0323009826,
-0.025489416,
0.040795844,
0.0069639143,
0.0278738812,
-0.0327671617,
0.0327878483,
-0.0457562581,
-0.0066154446,
0.039410308,
-0.0300588477,
-0.0179104134,
0.0450033918,
0.0643883124,
0.0061405795,
-0.000070547,
0.020803567,
-0.0025970691,
-0.0202632062,
-0.0453126393,
-0.0088889869,
0.0127451783,
-0.0039854147,
-0.034569364,
-0.0519382358,
-0.0559837073,
0.0009778587,
-0.0401273444,
0.0432600379,
-0.0060161878,
0.0162636936,
0.0095757702,
-0.0631700531,
-0.0097731045,
0.0041832407,
-0.0085587287,
-0.0411441065,
-0.0253211912,
0.0561539084,
-5.839065415e-33,
-0.0479788594,
-0.0010392531,
-0.0404955149,
0.0263387132,
-0.0112563856,
0.0342431031,
0.0095997164,
0.0353106968,
0.0019336831,
0.0046559344,
-0.0321100205,
0.0344845653,
0.0420168191,
0.0647754818,
0.0594082996,
-0.0212935135,
0.0600684471,
-0.0061659669,
0.0108932843,
0.0016857926,
0.0225959271,
0.0225071833,
0.0424045064,
-0.0767653883,
0.0264435727,
-0.0326200537,
0.0193871837,
-0.0532546975,
0.0252189096,
0.0466124117,
-0.0138966916,
0.088273026,
-0.0161973871,
-0.0139983352,
-0.0204922799,
0.0153336916,
-0.0493187308,
0.0004894922,
-0.0368560143,
0.1029459015,
0.0159729812,
-0.0250305329,
0.0188130923,
0.0341667607,
-0.0887380913,
-0.0454320349,
0.0685316399,
0.0245269649,
0.0246937051,
-0.003070541,
-0.0096592708,
0.0208438728,
-0.0497611128,
-0.0284409095,
0.0104440013,
0.0042712074,
0.0276450198,
-0.0614779703,
-0.0577469133,
0.0227960255,
0.0368107669,
0.0381538011,
0.0884053558,
0.0072340015,
-0.0504846647,
0.0175866988,
0.0418576933,
-0.0546393059,
0.0114757102,
-0.090023987,
0.0154601568,
-0.0097893067,
0.0047349352,
0.0013841772,
0.0514922701,
-0.0770773813,
-0.0156115685,
-0.0137588754,
0.000073548,
0.0133731617,
0.0042286082,
0.0006613645,
-0.0546582527,
-0.0146859484,
-0.0124354688,
-0.0574133806,
-0.0113348952,
0.0020566443,
0.0458173677,
-0.0135346213,
0.0401542522,
-0.0098616779,
0.0461323299,
-0.0388324484,
0.0034612513,
-0.0316989198,
-0.0324331075,
0.0072426926,
-0.0320899263,
0.0222998466,
-0.0633818731,
-0.0317181572,
0.0051197866,
0.0672076121,
0.0288469177,
-0.0084336204,
-0.0080021322,
0.0538884103,
-0.069137305,
-0.0024253596,
0.0015978721,
-0.0103172762,
-0.0124624148,
-0.0023400804,
0.0514558852,
0.02467582,
-0.0277839527,
0.0261694323,
0.0055298409,
0.0533010028,
0.0089321239,
-0.0318421498,
-0.0215354376,
0.0003299709,
-0.0511320829,
0.0151415057,
-0.0068852245,
-0.0052446355,
0.0204759669,
-0.0272515658,
-0.0046846331,
-0.0172972102,
2.54e-7,
-0.0277340598,
0.0714322627,
0.0241254847,
-0.073302947,
0.0002891033,
0.0181970336,
-0.0077214995,
0.0049175597,
0.0010013269,
0.0243832972,
-0.0035977124,
0.001026903,
0.0836767852,
0.0320385285,
-0.078969501,
-0.0460411645,
-0.1092558503,
0.0252373479,
-0.0452275425,
0.0477207229,
0.0220904741,
0.0484077074,
0.0203229506,
-0.030710008,
-0.0550755076,
-0.0417660475,
0.0243237149,
0.0175170954,
0.0228382796,
0.0131392637,
0.0151749169,
0.0197136421,
-0.0302371606,
0.0324669071,
-0.0263329931,
0.0180825014,
0.0427598841,
0.0399515778,
-0.0145238917,
-0.0123698628,
-0.0385566466,
0.0642876551,
-0.0328173339,
-0.01792253,
0.0262292307,
0.0635381043,
-0.0373753794,
-0.0606543273,
-0.042208869,
-0.0033947648,
0.0578289181,
0.0105718141,
0.0317193754,
0.0008318844,
-0.0036223561,
-0.0443283655,
-0.0327253304,
-0.0515300371,
0.0219882354,
-0.028033819,
-0.0131258452,
-0.0502341352,
-0.0046631214,
0.0173357297,
0.0441644751,
0.0181710143,
-0.0088048754,
1.8214068e-34,
0.0362137258,
0.0071178749,
0.0227301121,
-0.0254279748,
0.0031333314,
0.0074660336,
0.0397935584,
-0.0112386616,
0.0112284301,
0.0115228249,
-0.0170752387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10558v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10558v2 | Instruction-following Evaluation through Verbalizer Manipulation | 2023-07-20T03:54:24 | 2024-04-02T04:38:21 | Shiyang Li, Jun Yan, Hai Wang, Zheng Tang, Xiang Ren, Vijay Srinivasan, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL | While instruction-tuned models have shown remarkable success in various
natural language processing tasks, accurately evaluating their ability to
follow instructions remains challenging. Existing benchmarks primarily focus on
common instructions that align well with what the model learned during
training. However, proficiency in responding to these instructions does not
necessarily imply strong ability in instruction following. In this paper, we
propose a novel instruction-following evaluation protocol called verbalizer
manipulation. It instructs the model to verbalize the task label with words
aligning with model priors to different extents, adopting verbalizers from
highly aligned (e.g., outputting ``postive'' for positive sentiment), to
minimally aligned (e.g., outputting ``negative'' for positive sentiment).
Verbalizer manipulation can be seamlessly integrated with any classification
benchmark to examine the model's reliance on priors and its ability to override
them to accurately follow the instructions. We conduct a comprehensive
evaluation of four major model families across nine datasets, employing twelve
sets of verbalizers for each of them. We observe that the instruction-following
abilities of models, across different families and scales, are significantly
distinguished by their performance on less natural verbalizers. Even the
strongest GPT-4 model struggles to perform better than random guessing on the
most challenging verbalizer, emphasizing the need for continued advancements to
improve their instruction-following abilities. | [
0.0588600338,
0.0806028992,
0.0053061754,
0.0222007558,
-0.0265677609,
0.025582321,
-0.002590769,
-0.0108392257,
-0.000169595,
-0.0524294302,
-0.0673601851,
-0.0255728308,
-0.0172170717,
-0.012420183,
0.0110422922,
-0.0621455684,
0.0452801771,
0.0188646819,
0.0123182824,
0.0349900611,
0.0004764893,
0.0064181457,
-0.019900782,
0.0413186364,
0.01845528,
-0.0011282087,
-0.0054107183,
0.0089747151,
-0.0005806519,
-0.039119795,
0.0373711549,
0.0738414824,
-0.0019185119,
0.0065966616,
0.0000019215,
-0.0153182065,
0.0090557961,
-0.0089070043,
-0.0065760887,
-0.0114661483,
0.0735323057,
-0.046032425,
-0.0020611284,
0.0030408071,
-0.0734838247,
-0.0277307667,
0.046788007,
0.0857550576,
0.0552470647,
0.0854983628,
0.0071937484,
-0.0241025202,
0.0332371742,
-0.0181854106,
0.0019999458,
-0.0559237339,
-0.0107249562,
-0.0315746516,
-0.0094069382,
0.0566903315,
-0.03249586,
0.014914196,
0.0103241438,
0.0351641513,
0.0156388413,
-0.0073965192,
0.0125250816,
-0.0181653872,
-0.0233535152,
0.0562785752,
0.056734629,
0.009764635,
-0.042984277,
-0.0135282073,
0.021354368,
0.0035631675,
-0.0200860593,
-0.0001288593,
0.0283370651,
0.0209144652,
-0.0022607001,
0.0143335732,
-0.0080009038,
0.0151103744,
0.045944389,
0.1012791097,
-0.0115719484,
-0.0623315312,
0.0480780415,
0.0364635214,
-0.0522278883,
-0.031912338,
-0.0094266795,
0.0110187978,
-0.0437838212,
0.0252766591,
-0.0556904376,
0.0096505675,
0.0055623897,
-0.0404621996,
0.0686970428,
0.0550708435,
-0.0157794915,
0.0185279716,
0.0037019381,
0.0557752214,
0.0088968957,
0.039773684,
-0.0276262388,
0.0237125419,
-0.0829178244,
-0.0145804556,
-0.0003589552,
0.0346826762,
-0.0395305716,
-0.0114269881,
-0.0592474155,
-0.0003067248,
-0.043795146,
-0.0279083066,
0.0058018784,
0.0173567738,
-0.0178380441,
0.0192899387,
-0.072215125,
0.0307070818,
-0.0291154832,
0.0373762995,
-0.0102623012,
-0.0186318103,
-0.0155141186,
-0.0022410699,
-0.004669826,
-0.023273252,
0.0174634568,
0.0491161831,
-0.009070199,
-0.0390564874,
-0.0477251336,
-0.0146453651,
-0.0155250384,
-0.0873448253,
-0.0106486296,
0.000244817,
0.0094527667,
-0.0082477545,
-0.0084250877,
-0.0399738327,
0.004580549,
0.0283022225,
-0.0341431536,
0.0802406296,
0.042106878,
-0.0357111916,
-0.0124451127,
0.0071694036,
-0.0039481465,
0.0361907147,
0.0067459154,
0.019218903,
0.0200070981,
-0.0199716799,
0.0039211446,
-0.0016397589,
0.0051518218,
-0.0053980541,
-0.0160917919,
0.0149349198,
-0.0213966072,
-0.000587091,
0.0546577759,
0.0566276871,
-0.0189393498,
-0.0180683881,
0.0524583571,
0.0337300226,
-0.0405985974,
0.0012672505,
0.0666592494,
0.038736213,
0.008859355,
0.0296355747,
-0.0959185138,
-0.0003370665,
-0.047959052,
-0.017397318,
0.017940376,
-0.0249437522,
-0.0258698314,
-0.0656032935,
0.0038909072,
-0.0212601069,
0.0640765503,
-0.0018858711,
0.0244197045,
0.0142986095,
-0.0580031872,
0.0100001609,
0.0348298848,
-0.0549324341,
-0.0203524586,
-0.0568047501,
0.0239315201,
0.0574142374,
0.010232334,
-0.0090637794,
-0.0303183068,
-0.0111140534,
0.0088692661,
0.0484141856,
0.0561789647,
-0.0089507513,
0.0000730027,
-0.0315510891,
-0.0348881073,
-0.02341385,
0.0433762744,
0.0083635459,
0.0111020803,
0.001455863,
0.0087412205,
0.0206398554,
-0.0466187149,
0.0461706035,
0.0189343616,
-0.0931241587,
0.0115157049,
0.0026764167,
0.0475694947,
0.0238737371,
0.0160335302,
0.0044885376,
0.0254518148,
0.0217920151,
-0.0151896132,
-0.0034857597,
-0.0573745854,
-0.0367121994,
-0.0021203209,
0.017827997,
-0.0185076371,
0.042696055,
-0.0857819468,
-0.0318677351,
0.0337559283,
-0.0322720185,
0.0270547736,
-0.0121600479,
0.0285177622,
0.0048905183,
-0.0097667202,
-0.0261193309,
0.0392665602,
-0.0167350676,
0.0388022587,
0.0101732276,
0.0033597453,
-0.0081658941,
-0.0361587033,
-0.0062134089,
-0.0448351875,
0.0007176209,
0.0099500977,
0.0443387702,
0.0244581979,
-0.0537636094,
-0.0204157513,
-0.1216191575,
0.0043324307,
-0.022846695,
0.0277677905,
0.0403781161,
-0.0126329688,
0.0096608605,
-0.0285729226,
-0.0424365215,
-0.0488844514,
-0.0228952952,
0.0248860102,
0.0408598892,
0.0060670739,
-0.0038064767,
-0.04539074,
0.0031637882,
-0.0155655565,
-0.0117068114,
0.0063217953,
0.0215761755,
-0.0758936852,
0.0073745716,
-0.0196604263,
0.0367376283,
0.0056115733,
-0.0657439828,
0.0140098175,
0.0142194396,
-0.0013756687,
0.0833401009,
0.0223621111,
0.036005605,
0.0159573928,
0.0322448574,
-0.031743329,
0.0376119763,
-0.0459116772,
-0.0234797224,
-0.02123872,
-0.0396059267,
-0.0164860599,
0.0921200886,
0.0305766892,
0.0132467141,
-0.0907958001,
-0.0077493861,
-0.0514954925,
-0.0151419118,
-0.0004231605,
0.0004146641,
-0.0088738156,
-0.0111192325,
-0.0257871598,
-0.0510800779,
0.0816222876,
-0.0006020264,
-0.015823558,
-0.0667937398,
-0.0091236448,
-0.0107770385,
0.0401613973,
0.0267435312,
0.0014117038,
0.0203655716,
-0.0080102971,
-0.0534666777,
-0.0395332165,
0.011032938,
-0.0218148343,
0.0149719305,
-0.0665893257,
-0.0179352574,
0.0213648863,
-0.0546833463,
-0.0228888839,
-0.0578923002,
-0.0041973605,
0.0289591569,
0.0666791126,
-0.0542939156,
-0.030272739,
-0.0149375489,
0.0235876366,
0.024180783,
-0.0289805923,
-0.0181974676,
-0.0053319982,
-0.0091863899,
0.0392024107,
0.0086925635,
0.0005002233,
-0.0055368971,
-0.0149403242,
0.0682736188,
0.0498420261,
-0.0244253613,
-0.0332308523,
0.0225580856,
0.0269323345,
-0.0245203208,
-0.0090882434,
0.017359985,
0.1007020026,
-0.0515839048,
0.0055518313,
0.1396705806,
0.0343980342,
-0.0302950032,
0.0106179537,
0.0374668539,
0.0112434002,
0.0318292193,
0.0029685406,
-0.0413582101,
-0.0625588968,
-0.0286141988,
0.0527189821,
-0.0123886643,
-0.0147737199,
-0.0177713521,
-0.1079726741,
0.0297964979,
-0.0001845837,
-0.0169399325,
-0.0163622368,
-0.0428118482,
0.0261529293,
-0.0444687046,
0.0397458896,
-0.0237060245,
-0.0081857117,
0.0135448342,
0.0337003656,
-0.059395995,
-0.0610869825,
0.0541745052,
-0.0247489326,
0.0506083295,
0.0453678742,
0.0165686384,
0.0170769319,
-0.0118784225,
0.0206325892,
0.0133622838,
0.0084446194,
-0.0083034374,
0.0836270303,
-0.0294731036,
0.015469024,
-0.0230662208,
0.0257344246,
-0.0320334062,
0.0153352087,
-0.0205856171,
0.0437128693,
0.0005408394,
0.0037925364,
-0.0059811673,
0.0258995909,
0.0322879218,
0.0949586481,
0.0299955551,
-0.0613129213,
-0.0471144766,
-0.0179763641,
-0.0018777557,
-0.0601070523,
-0.0257501043,
-0.0023564717,
-0.0175309405,
-0.0199589152,
-0.0601129122,
-0.1084254235,
0.0100160139,
-0.0017556223,
-0.0116440495,
-0.0269552171,
0.0170654655,
-0.0245154779,
-0.0284044351,
0.0479596704,
0.0310775395,
0.0090209953,
-0.095617801,
-0.0930138975,
0.0449387319,
0.0001060422,
-0.0377026647,
0.0198533852,
-0.0668805912,
-0.0631731823,
0.0046900166,
0.0644728616,
0.0141498707,
0.0493354984,
-0.0087172128,
-0.0340346694,
0.0009020282,
0.0224818736,
-0.0559239388,
0.0325404517,
0.0566665791,
0.0223988742,
-0.0226523019,
0.0284560453,
-0.0030392818,
0.06579566,
0.0259069316,
0.0053612776,
-0.0350465216,
-0.0020322476,
0.0354926921,
0.0061831293,
0.0842557475,
-0.0013757793,
-0.0136133246,
-0.0079247942,
-0.0027255218,
-0.0139239421,
-0.0257991273,
-0.0501754023,
-0.0087714233,
0.0376269184,
-0.0015930205,
-0.0505374409,
-0.0292591024,
-0.0474460162,
0.0013629133,
-0.048568435,
-0.0051028463,
0.0201196168,
0.015986437,
-0.0093588019,
0.0176151432,
-0.036327038,
-0.0031754519,
0.0000704049,
0.0480999574,
-0.0117074223,
0.0909650251,
0.0056953193,
0.0206906479,
0.0020272476,
0.0336361378,
-0.0717426911,
-0.0142066842,
-0.0426404662,
-0.0224722736,
0.0090746842,
-0.0247316491,
0.0160934348,
-0.0225507244,
-0.006537043,
0.0011615085,
0.029342385,
-0.0091278814,
-0.0146596795,
0.0439969674,
0.0275925547,
-0.0143396473,
-0.0101017542,
0.04030931,
0.0138637777,
0.0438205414,
-0.0093758078,
-0.009176922,
-0.0577787422,
-0.021983793,
0.0484376214,
0.0144538162,
0.0040330542,
0.0587022491,
-0.036027994,
-0.0455964506,
0.0025561713,
-0.0113745565,
-0.0002748354,
-0.035981413,
0.0506745502,
0.0393867344,
-0.0446154289,
-0.039740216,
-0.0381101556,
-0.0422217287,
0.0122418031,
-0.0035071291,
-0.0686402395,
-6.54595629e-33,
-0.0282820463,
0.0010722096,
-0.0017075026,
0.0028486464,
0.0111408681,
-0.0290362891,
-0.0066868151,
0.0095846523,
-0.0108355815,
0.0427921787,
0.014275888,
0.0250292663,
0.0072613102,
0.0444256775,
0.0173698924,
-0.0124322865,
0.0475871526,
-0.0204559192,
-0.0399981365,
0.0199914128,
0.0438826792,
0.0140729444,
0.0861458257,
-0.0814246833,
0.074306041,
0.0203323197,
-0.0329468064,
0.003410087,
-0.0155366948,
0.0648824126,
-0.0120979231,
0.0477920249,
0.0271835346,
-0.0217139851,
0.0065792794,
0.0254550725,
-0.0386534557,
-0.0575198494,
0.0361012109,
0.0236087255,
-0.0597611107,
-0.0153160831,
0.0082284082,
-0.0203714631,
-0.0574375466,
-0.0159387644,
0.0264847782,
0.0040968731,
0.0285983309,
0.0435017161,
-0.0627653301,
0.0078806197,
-0.0108852889,
-0.0311204735,
0.0066426951,
0.0545745939,
-0.0227688514,
0.000043362,
-0.0728320032,
0.003804578,
0.0154678207,
0.0355684012,
0.0312896073,
0.0192749966,
-0.0262271687,
0.056576252,
0.0237787869,
-0.0098347226,
-0.0153414635,
0.0129880952,
-0.0287908949,
0.0336266495,
0.0325055532,
-0.0004085505,
0.0658086538,
0.0204239059,
-0.0289750602,
0.0146949179,
0.0364126712,
0.0133862151,
0.0346465409,
0.0008417441,
-0.0930529833,
-0.0230693631,
-0.0123500209,
-0.021679068,
-0.0327042192,
-0.0260041952,
0.0444734842,
0.0295944158,
-0.015867712,
0.0232009441,
0.0155364275,
-0.0172970518,
0.002733418,
0.0191574376,
-0.0251070578,
0.007931916,
0.0127544412,
-0.0206230823,
-0.0856613889,
-0.0185692552,
0.0202379711,
0.01815027,
0.0001956618,
-0.0063490868,
0.0562231578,
0.0328974053,
-0.0743800178,
-0.0024076754,
-0.0077906321,
0.0572274476,
-0.0286152698,
0.0160259232,
0.0369612984,
0.0387961976,
-0.0298102293,
0.0939681455,
-0.0098604709,
-0.0062061218,
-0.036755912,
-0.0250837915,
0.0156739689,
0.0005517911,
0.0201310217,
-0.0041332357,
0.0293331277,
-0.0047067534,
-0.0149003603,
-0.0376478508,
-0.00424845,
0.0523083657,
2.754e-7,
0.0502946936,
0.0290863737,
-0.0063645747,
0.0191524196,
-0.0167222936,
0.0492029302,
-0.0171336308,
0.0109927794,
0.0155061185,
-0.0060434919,
0.0088952538,
0.0371951871,
0.0484164096,
-0.0031519448,
-0.0571077652,
0.0042924248,
-0.0331497379,
0.0150896711,
-0.0171965845,
0.0136435777,
0.0810813457,
0.0921722054,
0.0078988476,
0.0104888184,
-0.010747279,
-0.0112775797,
0.0567943752,
-0.0248922762,
0.0095284926,
0.0079636266,
-0.0029126301,
0.0005819583,
0.0052756756,
0.0529426113,
-0.0412802324,
0.0047353483,
-0.0256747734,
0.0954639465,
-0.0280726571,
-0.0462683626,
-0.026482746,
0.0198782552,
0.0052465289,
-0.0078738136,
0.0361026376,
-0.0842990726,
-0.0326788761,
0.0102774734,
-0.035923332,
-0.0045667109,
0.0244996753,
-0.0011207996,
-0.024091227,
0.0033045956,
0.0136656798,
-0.0148674175,
-0.0335808657,
-0.0918004736,
0.0141495112,
0.0245913006,
-0.0172696952,
-0.0540931895,
-0.015763266,
0.0167464279,
0.0266598742,
-0.0678282231,
-0.0201219935,
2.299091774e-34,
0.0391186178,
-0.0014415378,
0.0472725816,
-0.0033641406,
0.0467860587,
0.0024579617,
-0.0098066498,
0.0088873897,
0.0485011302,
-0.0791060925,
-0.0080511579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10549v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10549v1 | Dynamic Large Language Models on Blockchains | 2023-07-20T03:26:57 | 2023-07-20T03:26:57 | Yuanhao Gong | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Training and deploying the large language models requires a large mount of
computational resource because the language models contain billions of
parameters and the text has thousands of tokens. Another problem is that the
large language models are static. They are fixed after the training process. To
tackle these issues, in this paper, we propose to train and deploy the dynamic
large language model on blockchains, which have high computation performance
and are distributed across a network of computers. A blockchain is a secure,
decentralized, and transparent system that allows for the creation of a
tamper-proof ledger for transactions without the need for intermediaries. The
dynamic large language models can continuously learn from the user input after
the training process. Our method provides a new way to develop the large
language models and also sheds a light on the next generation artificial
intelligence systems. | [
0.0416941456,
0.0842269808,
-0.0108987419,
0.0280718673,
-0.0123658963,
-0.0056120134,
0.0496764332,
0.0216403715,
0.0239032377,
-0.0233286507,
0.0168690067,
-0.0088928407,
-0.0193028059,
0.0595379248,
0.0425766297,
-0.0704627782,
0.0336631574,
-0.0258267391,
0.0055754744,
-0.0531577058,
0.0265393145,
-0.0202443711,
0.00176078,
-0.0050183455,
-0.0261635222,
-0.0366142914,
-0.0274269879,
-0.0403575115,
-0.0175022911,
0.0107683707,
-0.0105358986,
0.0435982831,
0.0174467526,
0.0800625458,
0.0000021445,
-0.0299509298,
-0.0197372399,
0.0171748083,
-0.0730957538,
0.0074317222,
0.0049567767,
-0.0036658433,
-0.0304364413,
0.0275290105,
-0.0298058186,
-0.0426824577,
0.0770326033,
0.0762607381,
0.0612252913,
0.0499090627,
0.0106829284,
-0.0645893961,
0.0050092512,
-0.0109290918,
-0.0191068444,
-0.0301252697,
0.0406632684,
0.0013537321,
0.0034640972,
0.040750362,
-0.0117324879,
0.0173525065,
0.034126427,
-0.0125267087,
0.0074311825,
0.013166449,
-0.0324563198,
0.0133195324,
-0.0385374278,
0.0278265774,
-0.0206055027,
-0.0242218189,
0.0121359872,
0.0302746147,
-0.0274596419,
0.0078525078,
-0.0540393256,
0.0534078293,
0.0178167094,
-0.0309880506,
0.0020968004,
-0.0314854085,
0.0466849059,
0.0489573553,
0.0146222087,
0.0520674251,
0.0164754055,
-0.0206221994,
-0.0624284782,
-0.0285877213,
-0.0218090694,
-0.0475354046,
0.0248474404,
0.0071440074,
-0.0146458223,
-0.0003377734,
-0.0458580293,
-0.0206464641,
0.0280612577,
-0.0695111454,
0.0208662972,
-0.0197629277,
0.0120306322,
0.0569976121,
-0.0200751182,
0.0369007811,
-0.0454195738,
-0.0007402765,
0.0155629832,
-0.0119408555,
-0.0715237334,
-0.0094024092,
-0.0551541038,
0.0771399662,
-0.0212664809,
-0.0055884901,
-0.0608137548,
0.0447586887,
-0.0230948534,
0.0495261364,
-0.0257032011,
-0.0066702804,
0.0163498465,
-0.022011295,
0.0373472162,
-0.0092991441,
-0.054877758,
0.0405562893,
-0.0044770688,
-0.0040813545,
0.0020283554,
0.0399828739,
0.0010284755,
0.0098662255,
0.0029376075,
0.0982024148,
0.050933376,
0.0224230159,
-0.0572192669,
-0.062348336,
0.0433416069,
-0.0310651772,
-0.0613794923,
-0.0684662536,
-0.0133627867,
-0.0053175213,
-0.0226323884,
-0.0114085283,
-0.0288476478,
0.0230711401,
-0.038138561,
0.0723562762,
-0.0109605426,
-0.005562102,
0.012127459,
-0.0351365656,
0.0248274505,
-0.0036602023,
0.0237986427,
0.0413752571,
0.0674509406,
-0.0123892175,
0.0346407443,
0.0395222679,
-0.0206680596,
0.0032645327,
-0.0312240794,
0.0154731292,
0.1025112793,
0.0360860452,
-0.086405918,
0.0684228987,
-0.0133501207,
0.0098058907,
0.1178617477,
0.0438011363,
0.0062576211,
0.0758538544,
0.0157312285,
0.0102125024,
0.0209320206,
-0.0680851638,
-0.0568435304,
0.0048792162,
-0.0165657904,
0.0021249873,
-0.0228619315,
-0.0165588297,
-0.03535299,
-0.0018446867,
-0.0001091497,
-0.050156422,
0.0092102727,
0.0166439898,
0.0485470109,
0.0109465355,
-0.0361353196,
0.0465027913,
0.0139411017,
-0.0318767317,
-0.0357055999,
-0.0643859878,
0.0616510026,
0.0477011651,
0.0619320199,
-0.0257530287,
0.0790850595,
-0.0626664534,
0.0292716064,
0.0402362086,
0.0180900861,
-0.0288387984,
-0.0213793386,
-0.0448035561,
-0.0037353204,
0.0831208676,
0.0107485363,
-0.0058643548,
0.0143029941,
0.0088672945,
-0.0426099226,
-0.0004211728,
-0.0561954267,
0.0093183834,
-0.0081615653,
-0.0450481139,
0.018569855,
0.0344909579,
0.0306105763,
0.0289999656,
0.0030736993,
0.0060892287,
0.0252370089,
0.0040017553,
-0.0372584723,
-0.0431747027,
-0.0334931128,
0.0400948226,
0.0386210531,
0.0096995905,
0.0281616636,
-0.0038031081,
-0.0248267036,
-0.0260455199,
0.0788892582,
-0.0149085727,
-0.0055756168,
-0.0154728005,
-0.009685101,
-0.0322820283,
0.0314067714,
-0.0159671586,
0.0320645534,
0.0153882662,
-0.0209963564,
-0.0417956673,
0.0168365277,
0.037063811,
-0.018014092,
-0.023788305,
0.0296411049,
-0.0132436389,
0.0647420138,
0.0414330065,
0.012951754,
0.0084664049,
-0.0409455411,
-0.056569092,
-0.0159824677,
-0.0115745412,
0.0336939618,
-0.0070666326,
0.0433454886,
0.0174856074,
-0.0171010345,
-0.0486456826,
0.0213990808,
-0.025783889,
-0.0022765992,
0.0137582067,
0.0191303883,
-0.0403918661,
-0.0235279109,
-0.0311498456,
0.0092660189,
0.0645272136,
0.0042706016,
0.0066902535,
-0.0410586037,
-0.0238244105,
0.0027784717,
0.0242876131,
0.0127215097,
-0.026316287,
0.0080585079,
0.0022963183,
-0.027644543,
0.0454622619,
0.0153259933,
-0.0043256441,
-0.0096921483,
-0.0015655059,
-0.0541931503,
-0.0213131309,
-0.0193419009,
0.0132765537,
-0.0470144413,
0.0229430273,
0.0007528911,
0.0648002997,
0.0131515721,
-0.0353201516,
-0.0548567884,
0.029788442,
-0.0034959558,
0.0065016481,
-0.0401340909,
-0.043020349,
-0.0204227082,
-0.0289069824,
0.0055903746,
-0.0523764975,
0.0385458209,
-0.0130910939,
0.0161468834,
-0.023514038,
-0.0314051546,
-0.0297890268,
0.0515642017,
0.002413996,
0.0517591871,
-0.0114607848,
-0.0035698984,
-0.0347339511,
-0.0250830278,
0.0399871245,
-0.0352410413,
0.0102534229,
-0.0341793522,
0.0312769711,
0.0301867984,
-0.0468766354,
-0.0280662626,
-0.0244277306,
-0.0239814855,
0.0527837463,
-0.0010947587,
-0.034202449,
-0.0167882126,
0.0144082988,
0.0348868184,
0.0402107872,
0.0259005632,
0.0118547156,
-0.0485152565,
-0.0063302484,
-0.0000052707,
-0.0547069162,
0.0086432789,
-0.0298633724,
0.0395007394,
0.0522468351,
0.0348028094,
-0.0024372586,
-0.0499659404,
-0.0026136476,
0.0156159531,
-0.0275469329,
-0.009333591,
0.0116812922,
-0.016444942,
-0.0470474139,
0.0007576587,
0.1071974263,
0.0226847325,
-0.0491737723,
0.0051805759,
0.0069979066,
-0.0014302807,
0.0016279162,
0.0182904471,
-0.1070852652,
-0.0025173384,
0.0025216786,
0.0085442802,
-0.0099345436,
-0.0200282224,
-0.0009444802,
-0.0599870384,
-0.0078508817,
0.0206289347,
-0.013072514,
-0.0159477033,
-0.0175973121,
-0.0397633575,
-0.0032839589,
-0.019120276,
-0.0210156515,
0.0079600858,
-0.0088100657,
0.016555788,
-0.0324014425,
0.0063591185,
0.041249413,
-0.0698755234,
0.0452426374,
0.0890108049,
0.0187595356,
-0.0289229415,
0.0049272804,
0.0418094173,
0.0569745079,
-0.0506148897,
0.0070159589,
-0.015784245,
0.0396815725,
-0.0126729365,
0.0044900803,
0.0386422053,
-0.0278996173,
-0.0120397788,
0.039610073,
0.0653899834,
0.0011465786,
-0.0156375859,
-0.0023684942,
-0.0459883511,
0.0480189137,
0.0349746309,
0.0028524892,
-0.075218372,
-0.0403500088,
-0.0538108051,
-0.0248725191,
-0.0055997097,
-0.0039833551,
-0.0350246169,
0.0057886513,
0.0170828886,
-0.0729030073,
0.0152117191,
-0.0096841175,
0.0077499398,
0.0451693013,
0.0032086791,
0.1096667722,
-0.0376765281,
-0.0126947043,
0.0075095999,
-0.063737303,
0.0472913533,
-0.0948910043,
0.0079678809,
0.0180279128,
-0.0515309907,
-0.0367157422,
0.0336651951,
-0.084414877,
-0.0566602014,
0.0310733858,
0.0241310932,
0.0226909034,
-0.0031576606,
-0.0582809038,
-0.0802664086,
0.0209511518,
-0.0245021004,
-0.0196304116,
-0.0283062328,
0.0428774841,
-0.0328064524,
0.0052270675,
0.0299756881,
-0.0226118322,
0.0181876831,
0.0363234356,
-0.0332876146,
-0.0716907904,
0.0004802002,
0.0037449116,
0.0416975282,
-0.0261425506,
0.0236542094,
-0.0002682506,
-0.014363436,
-0.0034916354,
-0.0036338423,
-0.0206046104,
-0.038263306,
0.0042955158,
0.0297178049,
-0.0211868677,
0.0053781788,
-0.0251095165,
0.0691155717,
-0.0345775932,
0.0180157255,
0.0330614187,
-0.0482267663,
0.0438585877,
0.0567370951,
-0.009985283,
0.0024064018,
0.0162108764,
-0.0016899029,
0.0484894887,
-0.0292894747,
0.033438459,
0.0277775824,
-0.0185378026,
-0.0483002476,
0.0041463464,
-0.0062567038,
-0.0760241151,
0.0218342748,
0.0487765595,
0.0371943377,
0.030026935,
-0.0304774232,
-0.0372281671,
-0.0006087122,
-0.038462285,
0.0234301463,
-0.0072318306,
-0.0793224126,
0.0038299777,
0.0324831866,
-0.0182500649,
0.0304194018,
0.0489038154,
-0.0124345385,
0.0108777117,
-0.0345905982,
-0.0218684394,
-0.0625338703,
0.0211019032,
-0.021451205,
0.003151438,
-0.0785429701,
0.0508504361,
0.004889396,
-0.0382500328,
-0.0038537269,
0.0189371258,
0.0280429795,
-0.0037009139,
0.0227844082,
0.0324159786,
0.0178124812,
0.0206403472,
-0.0630922616,
0.0300922729,
0.0398204587,
-0.0585748106,
-0.0239948835,
-5.94210778e-33,
0.0159275662,
0.0017517167,
0.0210147072,
-0.0179628097,
0.0061216797,
0.0032816052,
-0.0197025985,
0.0046366253,
-0.0052881259,
0.0334836654,
-0.0155141838,
-0.0111784721,
0.0151297422,
0.068772912,
0.0273299031,
0.0042079976,
0.0443864986,
-0.0071549257,
0.0141857173,
0.0116154589,
0.0489080101,
-0.0189408343,
0.0586385354,
-0.0366537683,
0.021014085,
-0.016324481,
-0.0544234812,
0.0162977166,
-0.0444930717,
0.0589100383,
-0.0442293696,
0.0047130287,
-0.0266000442,
-0.0625551715,
-0.0145905465,
0.0411233641,
-0.0259225331,
0.0259159617,
-0.0071786204,
0.0657776296,
-0.0310048163,
-0.0492097624,
0.0368828923,
-0.036912255,
-0.0094503751,
0.0679728463,
0.0126748886,
-0.0415285043,
-0.0335339233,
-0.0100538293,
-0.0212429632,
0.0124144144,
-0.0337967128,
0.0423072539,
0.0086394018,
-0.0315720253,
-0.0010709764,
-0.0137701603,
-0.0837847516,
0.0518407673,
-0.0140483836,
0.0032696216,
-0.0249520596,
-0.0133941509,
0.0219765212,
0.0172500834,
0.0219996944,
-0.0207907688,
-0.0062078158,
0.0403943472,
-0.0227464009,
0.0540623143,
0.0777213424,
0.0284372997,
0.0203300472,
-0.0344892107,
-0.027588781,
-0.0356459059,
0.0148466825,
0.0404002182,
0.0580893829,
-0.0053955386,
-0.0478905328,
-0.0265077017,
-0.0515485108,
-0.0155059714,
-0.0222146213,
0.0062466166,
0.0025269107,
0.0398543105,
0.0024931526,
-0.0372757241,
0.0150753995,
-0.1002927199,
-0.0426204316,
0.0200835243,
0.0531910248,
0.003051226,
-0.0010758428,
0.0318014771,
-0.0162306726,
-0.0304365363,
-0.0770280585,
-0.064104721,
0.018909201,
0.0305900667,
0.0124504287,
0.0325732753,
-0.0585938469,
0.0200994015,
-0.0052697454,
0.024324771,
0.0276055336,
0.0511809476,
0.0007394062,
-0.0005758522,
0.0197354443,
0.0144870244,
-0.0074648322,
-0.015960101,
0.0174878389,
0.0346771702,
-0.007882216,
0.0472150631,
-0.011129003,
-0.0031124426,
-0.0749775022,
0.037592344,
0.0417580418,
-0.0273975078,
0.0075341524,
0.0242448468,
2.871e-7,
-0.0144369984,
0.0556252003,
0.0177748539,
-0.0175707806,
0.0589976162,
0.0901053548,
-0.0123364739,
0.0139271775,
-0.0710209012,
0.0440822355,
-0.0527680591,
0.0119438795,
0.0737209991,
-0.0187935103,
-0.1111179441,
-0.0072625722,
-0.0582326949,
0.017978305,
-0.0545162894,
0.0015058095,
-0.0359329693,
0.112916261,
0.0562267341,
-0.0173360556,
-0.0157428011,
-0.0602813698,
0.0170244146,
0.0114218118,
-0.0100557189,
0.0065612369,
0.0097962171,
0.0070641632,
0.0264845397,
-0.0008658489,
-0.0126612596,
0.0167897269,
-0.0299323462,
0.042316705,
0.0045668818,
0.0656260028,
0.0104150651,
-0.0619444586,
-0.0271062907,
-0.0169720855,
0.0302263871,
0.010208643,
-0.0315033495,
-0.0412185602,
0.0121521736,
-0.0276767556,
0.0268214792,
-0.0011388808,
0.0174850058,
0.0034951833,
0.0135000199,
-0.0182859711,
0.0383004099,
-0.0493559539,
0.0031406572,
-0.0157867353,
-0.0595897473,
0.0396041423,
-0.0072311917,
0.038173005,
0.0372814126,
-0.0136231408,
0.0555315949,
2.34162791e-34,
0.0286245886,
-0.017851973,
0.0210266225,
0.0520881079,
0.0326130241,
-0.0030068227,
0.0030389221,
-0.0130728176,
0.046865806,
-0.0661254451,
-0.0163934957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11779v1 | The Extractive-Abstractive Axis: Measuring Content "Borrowing" in Generative Language Models | 2023-07-20T02:12:00 | 2023-07-20T02:12:00 | Nedelina Teneva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Generative language models produce highly abstractive outputs by design, in
contrast to extractive responses in search engines. Given this characteristic
of LLMs and the resulting implications for content Licensing & Attribution, we
propose the the so-called Extractive-Abstractive axis for benchmarking
generative models and highlight the need for developing corresponding metrics,
datasets and annotation guidelines. We limit our discussion to the text
modality. | [
0.0359551273,
0.07083112,
-0.0438001305,
0.049653545,
-0.0661037937,
0.0079969205,
0.0104035558,
0.0351533256,
-0.0365892462,
-0.0180308726,
-0.0107230246,
-0.0287204832,
-0.0392149389,
0.026045844,
0.0401443206,
-0.0188821349,
0.0017027681,
-0.0000461973,
0.0131132575,
0.0107036484,
0.0242653918,
0.0154389702,
0.0500342064,
0.0136214672,
0.0156934019,
-0.0075652385,
0.0239645429,
-0.0041165561,
0.0339515507,
0.0090590576,
-0.0321764052,
0.039585337,
-0.0114355227,
0.0633046851,
0.0000014469,
-0.0672596693,
-0.0052056815,
0.0284477659,
0.0241286866,
0.0458779074,
0.096043095,
0.0496491343,
-0.0061984351,
0.0038237695,
-0.042630408,
0.0001099289,
0.0217955243,
0.0346677862,
0.0200818516,
0.0504584722,
-0.0275333729,
-0.0217281133,
0.0499418974,
-0.0458983555,
0.0237119943,
0.0005040466,
0.0062886886,
0.0511899926,
0.0014647624,
0.0329572931,
0.0006072976,
0.0769881755,
0.0308928769,
-0.0198634434,
-0.0016879964,
0.0209321789,
0.0113657964,
-0.0005280818,
0.0231519919,
0.0350311436,
0.0511067249,
-0.0296846703,
0.0496779792,
-0.0397973061,
0.0355120897,
0.0552574322,
-0.0613100566,
0.0522646196,
0.0045181415,
0.034606047,
0.0505495295,
-0.0124638919,
0.0357790664,
0.0064439531,
0.0073792809,
0.0088626388,
0.0512229018,
-0.0176120717,
-0.0309102815,
-0.0187082458,
0.0024723117,
-0.0534245744,
-0.0092568286,
-0.0241646506,
0.061802499,
0.0140936878,
-0.0235536005,
-0.0490502603,
0.0415979959,
-0.018672552,
0.0506381765,
-0.0118640624,
-0.0214359667,
0.0266624298,
-0.0193671323,
0.0299501009,
-0.049275063,
0.0161115639,
-0.0156938788,
0.0049636592,
-0.0483286977,
-0.0247088578,
-0.0170257483,
0.0186193828,
-0.0120291132,
-0.028494576,
-0.0324075185,
0.0431814753,
0.0058220867,
-0.0354865491,
0.0202960148,
-0.0101835281,
-0.0166542847,
-0.0038543274,
0.0080643184,
-0.0209603198,
-0.0084901992,
0.0364075303,
0.0472124331,
-0.0647349879,
0.0125124939,
0.0290863086,
0.0180095471,
-0.0365741253,
-0.0160387401,
0.0685581341,
0.0163349919,
-0.0147673655,
-0.0105840741,
-0.029076064,
0.0064623952,
0.000052535,
0.0100651467,
-0.07013046,
0.0300550759,
0.0217911061,
-0.0033912302,
-0.0535334274,
-0.0188638363,
-0.0202084705,
-0.0151548237,
-0.0072585484,
0.0132879876,
0.0211939216,
0.0051238509,
0.0083193993,
0.0170690902,
0.0315950252,
0.0209747478,
0.0197724085,
0.0595140606,
0.0157184415,
0.0280202385,
0.0506558456,
0.0116213104,
0.0338856652,
0.0100891795,
-0.0146822296,
-0.0323957168,
-0.0192833859,
0.0345714428,
0.0838745236,
-0.0343372822,
-0.0132249705,
0.0876794681,
0.0657812208,
0.0376706682,
0.0499340631,
0.0547868945,
0.0152502907,
0.0147999879,
0.0123928674,
-0.0020726442,
-0.00123801,
-0.0000976258,
0.0337528996,
0.0278267767,
0.0212504771,
-0.0003104016,
-0.0280708205,
-0.0178065598,
0.0141538046,
-0.0052198307,
-0.0397110842,
0.0223758593,
0.0277395658,
-0.0020602311,
0.0351111926,
0.0076644551,
-0.0731428266,
0.0382066555,
-0.0478710383,
0.0436586849,
0.017311655,
0.052994132,
-0.0047723581,
0.0297425892,
0.0087066758,
-0.0505215488,
0.0537270531,
0.0110231601,
-0.0300556887,
0.0124073848,
0.0022835969,
-0.0196733531,
-0.0532945432,
0.031427823,
0.023923289,
-0.0145549877,
0.0048136669,
0.022905305,
-0.0669529289,
-0.0250549335,
0.0290241316,
-0.0510675758,
-0.0130956694,
-0.0388658419,
-0.0170840248,
0.0524563454,
0.0286847241,
-0.0432459749,
0.0248005018,
0.0147129083,
-0.0328352451,
-0.0418088175,
0.0573086627,
-0.0016502624,
0.0325605944,
0.035152372,
-0.0519888476,
0.03230156,
-0.003484945,
-0.0040869163,
-0.0200587641,
0.0272267256,
-0.0359508954,
0.0985177457,
-0.0778477564,
0.0142021989,
-0.0185206868,
-0.0164486133,
-0.0289662872,
0.0569620244,
-0.0382245071,
0.0512011051,
0.0547461733,
-0.0053391978,
0.0455291979,
0.0210588779,
-0.0036320605,
-0.0162709802,
-0.0223524719,
0.0156457089,
0.0259684734,
-0.0214853864,
-0.0313686989,
-0.0409736633,
-0.0266243555,
-0.0198542122,
-0.0239587836,
0.0588559881,
0.0563916378,
0.0073227789,
-0.0289348625,
0.0484979786,
-0.0562108308,
-0.0409555435,
0.0003073137,
0.0012513251,
0.0304643679,
0.0023456565,
-0.0033665933,
-0.0360194631,
-0.0115203271,
0.0153069058,
0.029839851,
-0.0021936737,
0.0345870331,
-0.0469530821,
0.0561185926,
-0.0309464801,
-0.0060252789,
-0.0258175693,
-0.019749919,
0.0048558749,
-0.0277807768,
0.0380022638,
-0.0190274138,
0.0219833627,
0.0002922166,
0.0210467577,
-0.0044971677,
-0.0533852801,
-0.0391197391,
-0.0542695522,
-0.0158139691,
-0.0305794831,
-0.0752252936,
0.0540829524,
0.0711335093,
0.0116074048,
-0.003801787,
-0.0149217453,
-0.0124714049,
-0.0332082622,
-0.038886603,
0.0141268121,
0.0101149427,
-0.0488446429,
0.0373112857,
0.0016216347,
-0.0848625749,
0.016477529,
-0.0444052815,
0.0249512997,
0.002033401,
0.0139297545,
-0.032440085,
0.0668221265,
-0.0125930626,
0.0060728248,
0.0518517308,
-0.0320698619,
-0.0464764945,
0.0389770679,
0.0819331706,
-0.0336677656,
0.0245330706,
-0.0027799315,
0.0165528469,
0.0088280207,
-0.0057282099,
-0.0119706029,
-0.0392966941,
0.0648419186,
0.03910698,
0.0892913863,
-0.027123807,
0.0245519243,
-0.0010304339,
0.0081488471,
0.0030005225,
-0.0019283015,
-0.0099864407,
-0.0150441257,
0.1075931638,
0.0643946156,
-0.0050089229,
-0.0147451134,
-0.0234650951,
-0.0493171439,
0.0255692452,
-0.0302747767,
0.0168648083,
0.0067656739,
0.0011259074,
0.0300221182,
-0.0286492221,
-0.0308869835,
0.0310350638,
0.0425384194,
-0.0085448101,
-0.012661607,
0.0934808478,
0.0423216,
-0.0271902699,
-0.0010767477,
-0.0429067798,
0.0376467444,
0.0215202663,
0.0069406498,
-0.0878055915,
0.0405494012,
-0.0180715062,
-0.0016601911,
-0.0192600433,
-0.0125102894,
0.0163507164,
-0.1110655144,
0.0364141837,
-0.0149372313,
-0.052698791,
-0.0027425108,
-0.0242469087,
-0.0023321977,
-0.0133798337,
-0.0563814007,
-0.010049344,
-0.0342114791,
0.0021975073,
0.0374772027,
-0.0065941638,
-0.0434388705,
-0.0337223522,
-0.0524948277,
0.0149972672,
0.0527571924,
0.0318874754,
-0.0235980768,
-0.0486560203,
0.0017482613,
-0.0728330091,
-0.0280796085,
-0.001492315,
0.0106776766,
0.0178377219,
0.0145229921,
-0.0432236381,
0.0211034101,
0.0269041341,
-0.0330479555,
-0.0322198384,
0.0633260086,
0.0281937756,
-0.0300772376,
-0.0544938147,
-0.0431927256,
0.0183400139,
0.0669546723,
0.0809576288,
-0.0199800711,
-0.0404430665,
-0.0581807084,
0.0323291868,
-0.0481967516,
-0.0523710474,
-0.0326986164,
-0.0247246325,
-0.0046623149,
-0.0943049267,
-0.0192699581,
-0.0828024223,
0.0102373082,
0.0211966559,
0.0318760835,
-0.0190271884,
-0.0687430352,
-0.02586204,
-0.0342015848,
-0.0229427908,
-0.0236847214,
-0.0251283199,
-0.0448611453,
0.0380438566,
-0.0255258419,
-0.0383270532,
-0.0013219881,
-0.0792935565,
-0.0715758428,
0.0112916706,
0.0128132915,
0.0282954685,
-0.0021211666,
-0.0108458996,
-0.0521443263,
0.0729587302,
0.0483270325,
-0.0050946265,
0.0224848483,
0.0209339019,
0.0171314888,
0.008664107,
0.0403279513,
-0.057664603,
0.0300331134,
0.0436665379,
0.0244274307,
-0.0155013856,
-0.0016875748,
0.0026216744,
0.0334158204,
-0.0047154156,
-0.0438735858,
-0.0118129989,
-0.0679017007,
-0.0184370577,
-0.0280814897,
-0.0131608956,
-0.0342855826,
0.0047953832,
0.0454766378,
0.0020794775,
-0.0451631807,
0.119368121,
-0.001559325,
0.075040184,
-0.0824498907,
0.0158468541,
0.019882014,
-0.0135696121,
-0.0306613632,
0.0119046737,
0.0042800908,
-0.0220139958,
-0.0280806851,
0.0393373966,
-0.0005397157,
0.0570697524,
0.0068363319,
0.002143993,
0.023047477,
0.0554763414,
-0.0509854406,
0.0071350145,
-0.0256270207,
-0.0060169515,
0.0281222258,
-0.033153668,
0.1247537732,
-0.0279650558,
-0.014374434,
-0.0132330079,
0.0456824973,
-0.0152626261,
-0.0451555811,
0.002730835,
0.0031914485,
-0.0333809443,
0.0058220448,
0.0733305812,
-0.0066811317,
0.014946457,
-0.0369656384,
0.0001758855,
-0.0232274812,
-0.0180252474,
0.034708064,
-0.0339755192,
-0.0101944525,
-0.0211321246,
-0.070138745,
-0.0828604549,
-0.0405190736,
0.0391395055,
0.0489383079,
-0.0156562906,
0.0067800982,
0.0768704787,
-0.0053677433,
-0.019728953,
-0.0665798336,
0.0066442387,
-0.0262307171,
-0.0147159975,
-0.0505808182,
-5.99544951e-33,
-0.0001672659,
0.0252716579,
-0.0207078326,
0.0179172978,
-0.0533503331,
0.0144321891,
-0.051885549,
-0.0073564453,
-0.0028982733,
-0.0049641752,
-0.0236439314,
-0.0011523511,
-0.0034711396,
0.0032313876,
0.0140638771,
0.0142339785,
0.0209180694,
-0.0067770709,
-0.0543147922,
0.0343493149,
0.0364780389,
-0.0061334404,
0.0267496649,
-0.0667594969,
0.054162439,
-0.0451291576,
-0.0123157129,
-0.0318719521,
0.0020131571,
0.0677824914,
-0.0336201414,
0.007949858,
0.0297722835,
-0.0504628569,
-0.0032553489,
-0.0249782614,
-0.0414182134,
-0.0284642782,
0.0597325489,
-0.0434696041,
-0.0234602373,
-0.0452931486,
0.0556989089,
0.0031729725,
-0.0346313752,
-0.0245735664,
0.0565186851,
0.0002416029,
-0.0176069029,
-0.0998971686,
-0.0744542181,
0.0209944714,
-0.0057521216,
0.0428458974,
0.0370149277,
-0.0145045258,
0.008319593,
0.0371212922,
-0.0051763202,
0.0236003362,
0.0134827709,
0.0522345528,
0.0733206123,
0.0066506146,
0.0412572175,
0.068235606,
-0.0074525527,
-0.0149761019,
0.0033730969,
0.0111369388,
0.0198236164,
0.0686736256,
0.0115098627,
0.0656838566,
0.0285566244,
-0.0026411631,
-0.0191416387,
0.0275790375,
-0.0190380011,
-0.0134341931,
0.0309982188,
0.0108640408,
-0.0046391268,
0.005285148,
-0.0441618189,
-0.0809928849,
-0.005725096,
-0.0292609297,
0.0097812712,
-0.024496438,
-0.0298370887,
-0.0187338069,
0.0345402174,
-0.0527728423,
-0.0455365442,
0.0205048155,
-0.0549510606,
0.0627936497,
0.0097679887,
-0.0055184863,
-0.0579701513,
-0.0228572246,
0.0183631387,
-0.0042669778,
0.0176551808,
-0.0259818379,
0.0370484404,
0.0332309194,
-0.0449521095,
-0.0138630318,
-0.046287816,
-0.0070711737,
-0.0229577776,
0.0198660325,
0.021887036,
-0.0046041934,
-0.0115237059,
-0.0289187543,
0.0485669039,
0.034137439,
-0.0341758355,
0.019785095,
0.0050780652,
0.0085575264,
-0.0342975855,
0.0025217205,
-0.0249910876,
0.0462973639,
0.0612447783,
-0.0308143254,
-0.0258982126,
-0.0097569963,
2.346e-7,
0.0688218996,
0.0109937359,
0.0232502986,
0.0176901873,
0.0293294974,
0.0156071,
-0.0044686017,
0.0472161807,
0.0112876194,
-0.0062533915,
-0.0071850941,
-0.0161281861,
0.039829012,
0.0291978996,
-0.0649861023,
0.0412696041,
-0.0680098832,
-0.0044196341,
-0.003645143,
-0.0005094847,
0.0304550249,
0.0545891374,
0.0163755193,
0.0004308226,
-0.0012301406,
-0.026474759,
0.0442102961,
-0.0488768965,
0.0137132332,
0.0538519844,
0.034723103,
0.0079871146,
0.026871739,
-0.0740507841,
-0.0286073387,
0.0277756471,
0.0036040889,
0.0265112408,
0.029568335,
-0.0373904109,
-0.0186409652,
-0.0605860129,
0.015645599,
-0.0516717099,
0.0322740637,
0.0294573326,
-0.0107899774,
-0.0558216386,
-0.0592600517,
0.0081133349,
-0.0042951144,
-0.0368567929,
-0.0059449147,
0.0214315914,
-0.0215130895,
-0.0051648226,
-0.0295572653,
-0.0595874339,
-0.0207306631,
-0.0420724414,
-0.0429732762,
-0.0668393523,
-0.0464939736,
0.0401321538,
0.0108446684,
-0.0547942147,
0.0332378931,
1.922443065e-34,
0.0240968801,
-0.0276392698,
0.0155283101,
0.0292162318,
0.0141707147,
0.0131439343,
0.0196161196,
0.0323545747,
-0.035406962,
-0.0707661957,
-0.0080275591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10522v1 | Gender-tuning: Empowering Fine-tuning for Debiasing Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-07-20T01:48:51 | 2023-07-20T01:48:51 | Somayeh Ghanbarzadeh, Yan Huang, Hamid Palangi, Radames Cruz Moreno, Hamed Khanpour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have revealed that the widely-used Pre-trained Language Models
(PLMs) propagate societal biases from the large unmoderated pre-training
corpora. Existing solutions require debiasing training processes and datasets
for debiasing, which are resource-intensive and costly. Furthermore, these
methods hurt the PLMs' performance on downstream tasks. In this study, we
propose Gender-tuning, which debiases the PLMs through fine-tuning on
downstream tasks' datasets. For this aim, Gender-tuning integrates Masked
Language Modeling (MLM) training objectives into fine-tuning's training
process. Comprehensive experiments show that Gender-tuning outperforms the
state-of-the-art baselines in terms of average gender bias scores in PLMs while
improving PLMs' performance on downstream tasks solely using the downstream
tasks' dataset. Also, Gender-tuning is a deployable debiasing tool for any PLM
that works with original fine-tuning. | [
0.0419680513,
0.0750646442,
-0.0302276071,
0.0181864575,
0.0248463079,
0.0204490777,
0.0725735873,
-0.0206587985,
0.0009088842,
-0.0648587346,
-0.0411411673,
-0.0150762415,
0.0133661451,
0.0194421168,
0.0407894216,
-0.0632018149,
0.0270669069,
0.0002250379,
0.0183744822,
-0.0414499305,
0.0060765902,
0.039268069,
0.0173137654,
0.0358688496,
0.0356256366,
-0.0130724441,
0.0518411063,
0.0220016036,
-0.0108646946,
0.0082545904,
0.0863776654,
0.0644220933,
0.0018495513,
0.0262137223,
0.0000019632,
-0.0779895633,
0.0110933064,
-0.0056833713,
-0.0325020365,
0.0206525866,
0.0469698161,
-0.0270825531,
-0.0018386065,
0.0540311895,
-0.0209348556,
-0.0320468135,
0.0288277064,
0.0204938184,
0.037725769,
0.0453260392,
-0.006617961,
0.0189347193,
-0.0718177706,
-0.0403505303,
-0.0366654061,
0.0017660407,
0.0324300826,
-0.0420574024,
-0.0678125992,
0.0016997048,
-0.0073247165,
0.0073376223,
-0.0093734199,
0.0101107117,
0.0027823576,
0.0198518801,
-0.0385827832,
-0.0489944108,
0.0060297833,
0.0482947603,
-0.0444350541,
-0.0383912437,
0.0176307894,
-0.0249804482,
0.0126793329,
-0.0055498052,
-0.0104305716,
0.0017707964,
0.0115697859,
-0.0012823263,
-0.0176804624,
-0.0265800618,
0.0455356129,
0.0657880902,
-0.0178067423,
0.0705695152,
0.0123204999,
-0.0123495385,
0.0174069386,
0.0081782471,
0.0324403197,
-0.0536289923,
0.0236284677,
-0.044132024,
-0.0132666808,
-0.000384502,
-0.0443262272,
-0.0333666876,
0.0156447608,
-0.0256587937,
-0.0073348708,
0.0281104483,
-0.0077597303,
0.00499039,
-0.0242184885,
-0.0015462807,
0.0362396315,
0.0347066075,
-0.0230000056,
-0.0314353295,
0.0279727783,
0.0041253478,
-0.025790995,
-0.0267682672,
-0.0309036393,
0.0488707498,
-0.0313917659,
-0.0101808505,
-0.0299293865,
-0.0208437406,
0.0088458993,
0.0151674552,
-0.0373283029,
-0.0249737706,
0.0038726234,
0.0061329193,
-0.0466228686,
0.0494711995,
-0.0320333987,
-0.0880378708,
-0.0174168535,
0.0085413652,
0.003060889,
-0.0345452279,
0.0308652576,
0.0127749583,
0.0051839477,
-0.0318682827,
-0.0329536982,
-0.0011142347,
-0.0099483691,
-0.0650179908,
0.0003633375,
-0.0448393263,
0.0047819549,
0.0263909809,
0.0211981181,
-0.0489942916,
-0.0164191406,
0.0031972092,
-0.0268292502,
0.0627983361,
0.0328548588,
-0.004238531,
0.0758373365,
0.0178867038,
-0.0102855954,
0.1180173904,
0.0312097464,
0.0116101876,
0.0482398868,
-0.0121004842,
0.0061564702,
0.0626711175,
0.0590491332,
0.0352482758,
-0.0179688223,
-0.0010356962,
-0.0128526147,
-0.0036127798,
0.0864655897,
-0.0102669187,
0.015059405,
-0.0221556798,
0.0905152708,
0.040519096,
0.0128694763,
0.0378235504,
0.0264648069,
0.0138196116,
-0.004336928,
0.0105060302,
-0.0730119795,
-0.0283167772,
-0.0396106653,
-0.030426899,
-0.0045198365,
0.0614627823,
-0.0311592948,
-0.0250586141,
0.0017447987,
-0.0059725642,
0.0007107258,
0.0279582478,
0.024352679,
0.0329154544,
-0.0091802338,
0.0636067912,
0.0440729931,
-0.0491973236,
0.0161736682,
-0.048775699,
0.0002294008,
0.0299730506,
0.0035685829,
-0.0278078541,
0.0015587652,
-0.0442788489,
0.0088592665,
0.0466538109,
0.0561318547,
0.0080924137,
0.0551880226,
-0.0541690215,
-0.0185083784,
0.0109846359,
0.0392633751,
0.0261577684,
0.0592846237,
0.0219350476,
0.040593408,
-0.045149643,
-0.0640004501,
0.0459763184,
-0.0280598365,
-0.0437994339,
0.0376139916,
-0.0021128103,
0.0157907251,
0.0193386395,
-0.0363429822,
-0.0083808526,
-0.0111771673,
0.00019345,
0.0298298523,
0.0011148439,
-0.0389725752,
0.0044497326,
0.0064936373,
-0.0741188079,
-0.0518926755,
0.0730567276,
-0.0389881283,
-0.0136611424,
0.0546198748,
0.0195517596,
0.006844155,
-0.0321246982,
0.003470358,
-0.024615055,
0.0512472577,
-0.0193420295,
0.0135679916,
-0.017863024,
-0.0313794203,
-0.0052257618,
-0.0259241015,
-0.0180912688,
-0.0454288907,
-0.0297363549,
-0.0048316009,
0.0197631158,
0.0050833267,
0.0377505869,
-0.0035081981,
-0.0292092692,
-0.0192215815,
-0.0565435961,
-0.0205972865,
-0.0344873108,
-0.0192686934,
0.0026592959,
0.0036585231,
-0.0492095873,
-0.0281658955,
-0.0154215004,
-0.0497305691,
-0.0062284092,
0.0071227835,
0.0034475613,
-0.0307634473,
0.0256416965,
-0.0516577065,
-0.0168024916,
-0.0127093121,
0.0493378825,
0.0172944423,
-0.0186782144,
-0.0323951691,
0.0125047201,
-0.0149253411,
0.0245883334,
-0.0203246977,
-0.0337499231,
-0.0186742395,
0.0342495441,
0.0257759225,
0.0924112275,
0.0142676998,
-0.0045001553,
0.0566431545,
0.0308198743,
-0.0607790537,
-0.0157193467,
0.0070105144,
-0.0054299221,
-0.0083390391,
-0.055326324,
0.0017075011,
0.0247966032,
-0.0082747182,
-0.0262849722,
-0.0337189995,
0.0411577858,
-0.0269003734,
-0.0482871309,
-0.0326164402,
-0.0226752702,
-0.0165022071,
0.0340299681,
-0.0460528843,
-0.081200771,
0.0411541946,
-0.0341271013,
-0.0065894746,
-0.0209965017,
-0.0214595366,
-0.0367241651,
0.0278791171,
-0.0181865413,
0.0300059784,
0.0386387222,
0.0026456646,
-0.0746315494,
-0.0289188977,
0.0284544658,
-0.037972305,
0.0149621014,
-0.0326088034,
0.0050196764,
0.0138485301,
-0.0478253849,
-0.0441907234,
-0.0641626418,
-0.0248756334,
-0.0131016849,
0.0366808102,
-0.0080948388,
-0.0174387824,
0.006781999,
-0.0092246374,
0.0559910014,
-0.0144473277,
0.0092515396,
0.005364215,
-0.017374048,
0.0456701182,
0.0003478145,
0.0352300256,
-0.0429265015,
-0.0165044405,
0.003163426,
0.0305958074,
-0.0096891141,
0.0042416938,
0.0229615346,
0.0521004871,
-0.0271471366,
-0.0042596254,
-0.0099566393,
0.0347491279,
-0.0484907702,
0.0090068718,
0.1297551095,
0.000935929,
-0.0827708021,
-0.0081821373,
0.0194019452,
0.0560486317,
0.0376897007,
0.0248240922,
-0.0780146271,
-0.0048592007,
0.0362851284,
0.0421048701,
-0.0327847488,
-0.0365980417,
-0.041923102,
-0.1384408921,
-0.005967062,
0.0176820643,
-0.0103808343,
-0.0163544007,
-0.0318696946,
0.0032814364,
-0.030646015,
0.0464168526,
-0.0303701367,
-0.0023732428,
0.0054047685,
0.0214685034,
-0.0477160402,
-0.0863129422,
0.020094363,
-0.0773133785,
0.0823771432,
0.0274928156,
0.0212852489,
-0.0317117088,
0.0056846309,
0.0420517176,
-0.0042173183,
-0.0037228328,
-0.0332169197,
0.0476965606,
-0.0645692945,
-0.0232564807,
-0.0120763183,
0.0484959818,
0.0374756344,
0.0256090481,
-0.0095781293,
-0.0083744824,
0.0336282961,
-0.0162273832,
-0.021017164,
-0.0202609692,
0.0196885075,
0.0914360955,
0.0350036025,
-0.0495940074,
-0.0081467843,
-0.0648216903,
0.0032976423,
0.0145112677,
-0.0381988734,
0.0079982607,
-0.0088076089,
-0.0228878148,
0.0015411373,
-0.0362323858,
0.0449060909,
0.0126927095,
0.004677569,
-0.0382066853,
0.0159331672,
0.0074947202,
-0.0604434684,
0.0571902953,
-0.0416590348,
0.0250401516,
-0.0125644971,
-0.0409241281,
-0.0070092836,
-0.0331005752,
-0.0109850196,
0.0442750193,
-0.0384126939,
-0.0708120018,
0.0724060386,
0.0676231831,
0.0245271455,
0.0688307285,
-0.0152276149,
-0.1074182317,
0.0917213559,
0.0365414284,
-0.0525915474,
0.03206205,
0.0597933717,
-0.0248149298,
0.0170113761,
0.0486998521,
-0.0433604233,
0.0313057862,
0.0460967459,
-0.0288228188,
-0.00599775,
-0.0298411585,
-0.0209445897,
0.0144569604,
0.0512315035,
-0.0694955811,
0.017097719,
-0.0684670806,
0.0031133057,
-0.0254832581,
-0.0348432064,
-0.0108277006,
-0.0248547178,
0.0327920951,
0.0152046755,
-0.0197717994,
0.0194566809,
-0.0427428707,
0.0098998416,
-0.037374448,
0.0295417346,
-0.0019259983,
0.0498662107,
0.0055304216,
0.0080787884,
0.004689212,
0.0218622312,
-0.0155566689,
0.0279159006,
0.0200946238,
-0.0134854475,
0.0094816191,
0.0290764309,
-0.0439633951,
0.0120377168,
-0.0327265374,
-0.0019808887,
-0.0220604092,
0.010856363,
0.0263102707,
-0.0571279638,
0.0734898522,
0.013460245,
-0.0138180461,
0.0087373406,
-0.0263817031,
0.0172153395,
0.0040354556,
0.0103176069,
-0.0046724905,
-0.0280848034,
0.0244518742,
0.0692222416,
0.0585995093,
0.0708659068,
-0.01214395,
-0.0230575912,
-0.024340583,
-0.0146965785,
0.0148684448,
-0.0003749005,
-0.0259999745,
-0.0007435133,
-0.0676541701,
-0.0667228699,
-0.0327811129,
-0.0166421663,
0.0115513066,
-0.0028737306,
0.0096075321,
0.0477166325,
-0.0405512527,
-0.0248328187,
-0.047213424,
-0.018136831,
0.0275252499,
-0.0112413839,
0.0053516999,
-6.69108723e-33,
-0.0275392924,
-0.016816467,
-0.0281104874,
-0.021064857,
-0.0018789385,
0.0046573929,
-0.0033223771,
0.0134349903,
-0.0142650297,
0.016865667,
-0.0231050346,
0.0289654396,
0.023749372,
0.0070766606,
-0.0164261311,
0.0135152629,
0.081845969,
-0.0063921614,
-0.0450344011,
-0.0309899542,
-0.0233531483,
0.0445928499,
0.0388037674,
-0.057952702,
0.0744816735,
-0.0177288335,
-0.0372059941,
0.0108389715,
-0.016512543,
0.0206731334,
-0.0102252513,
0.0511977375,
0.0021922817,
-0.0278061014,
-0.0060702129,
0.0517284833,
-0.0731448904,
-0.0314250067,
0.0188744292,
0.0293578207,
0.0305902641,
-0.0093805278,
0.043132063,
0.0155638503,
-0.0487546176,
-0.0138858203,
0.0311541297,
-0.0047339015,
0.0394539647,
0.0127469758,
-0.0244442746,
0.0355048329,
-0.0214949902,
0.0100799734,
0.044585336,
0.0056327181,
-0.0046310388,
0.0063272356,
-0.0678272322,
0.0171275865,
0.0454403013,
0.0038026653,
0.0457058996,
0.0495194085,
0.0296245329,
0.0461620055,
0.0758790076,
0.0362082645,
-0.0020812864,
-0.0399555564,
0.0782919452,
-0.0341258496,
0.0267123282,
0.0598757677,
0.0350624211,
-0.0173649229,
-0.0714600459,
-0.0069112787,
0.0061553284,
-0.0039245803,
0.0234766416,
-0.0237970166,
-0.0507103503,
-0.0619787276,
-0.0640149117,
-0.094409883,
-0.0119673098,
0.0001211857,
0.0092218956,
0.024621198,
-0.0748630166,
0.0133571317,
-0.0103986571,
-0.0482512973,
-0.0208330043,
-0.0029044936,
0.0064160633,
-0.0430097133,
0.0427911207,
0.0232436191,
-0.0699537545,
0.0058993348,
0.0201478526,
0.0258135069,
0.0243062228,
-0.0075966031,
0.0190647691,
0.027116375,
-0.0810502321,
0.0157164577,
-0.0278497729,
0.0264724623,
0.0318172015,
0.0370582193,
0.0220732726,
0.0306341257,
-0.0091054495,
-0.0060522258,
0.0510165431,
0.0012857071,
-0.0107926391,
0.0144496365,
0.00884715,
0.0523979552,
-0.0106315389,
-0.0254932158,
0.0101768104,
-0.0098104244,
0.0864785388,
-0.0320976302,
-0.0086893821,
-0.0395447426,
2.513e-7,
0.0113776671,
0.0720617548,
0.0022127777,
0.0256962795,
0.0138064241,
0.0378557779,
0.0356852822,
0.0407893024,
0.0555065349,
-0.0073647485,
-0.0166943334,
0.0371287353,
0.0305827912,
0.016093269,
-0.0648481995,
-0.0015219825,
-0.053106878,
0.0450804345,
-0.0181821901,
-0.0060384325,
-0.0357407928,
0.096800983,
0.0463091135,
-0.0068086563,
-0.0085798306,
-0.0261563342,
0.0289049353,
-0.0467749611,
0.0082246969,
0.0188860279,
0.0244203936,
0.0350414254,
0.0055735474,
0.0220318548,
-0.0169563852,
0.0363256149,
-0.007350754,
0.0480344929,
-0.0052679065,
0.0069080316,
-0.0141639272,
0.0286516882,
-0.0365399159,
-0.0826040134,
0.0809924901,
0.006944099,
-0.0290341079,
-0.0716448128,
-0.0112027125,
-0.0020860103,
0.0728801712,
-0.0453899801,
-0.0247856844,
0.0262554474,
0.0343904123,
-0.0027044658,
-0.0283746589,
-0.0780384615,
-0.0448747464,
-0.0251715817,
-0.0118680485,
-0.0429490022,
0.0121270036,
0.0069983765,
0.0130222877,
-0.0469466522,
0.0705219507,
2.270433589e-34,
0.0264416318,
0.0045888927,
0.0171678755,
-0.0267087631,
0.0196012445,
-0.0010389278,
0.0059439344,
-0.0034465264,
0.0409925282,
-0.0336357467,
0.0071406658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10514v1 | Building Socio-culturally Inclusive Stereotype Resources with Community Engagement | 2023-07-20T01:26:34 | 2023-07-20T01:26:34 | Sunipa Dev, Jaya Goyal, Dinesh Tewari, Shachi Dave, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | With rapid development and deployment of generative language models in global
settings, there is an urgent need to also scale our measurements of harm, not
just in the number and types of harms covered, but also how well they account
for local cultural contexts, including marginalized identities and the social
biases experienced by them. Current evaluation paradigms are limited in their
abilities to address this, as they are not representative of diverse, locally
situated but global, socio-cultural perspectives. It is imperative that our
evaluation resources are enhanced and calibrated by including people and
experiences from different cultures and societies worldwide, in order to
prevent gross underestimations or skews in measurements of harm. In this work,
we demonstrate a socio-culturally aware expansion of evaluation resources in
the Indian societal context, specifically for the harm of stereotyping. We
devise a community engaged effort to build a resource which contains
stereotypes for axes of disparity that are uniquely present in India. The
resultant resource increases the number of stereotypes known for and in the
Indian context by over 1000 stereotypes across many unique identities. We also
demonstrate the utility and effectiveness of such expanded resources for
evaluations of language models. CONTENT WARNING: This paper contains examples
of stereotypes that may be offensive. | [
0.0468325242,
0.0680857673,
-0.0260659456,
0.0030043111,
0.018598523,
0.0597190075,
0.0552408248,
-0.0607713871,
0.0508091673,
-0.0316161513,
0.0071768346,
-0.0418509133,
0.0359720513,
0.0247627366,
0.029496409,
-0.0414862521,
0.0278737228,
0.0571161397,
0.0040978668,
0.0039799004,
0.0156376436,
0.044349689,
-0.0151895015,
0.0914420784,
-0.0776619017,
-0.0217531938,
0.0697968677,
-0.0154570155,
-0.0075949463,
-0.0525349639,
0.0185307246,
0.0435099937,
0.0056258528,
0.0210125092,
0.0000019424,
-0.0614898317,
0.044062566,
0.0310427248,
0.0046843505,
-0.0066501689,
0.0626042187,
-0.01219982,
0.0235140417,
0.0381123237,
0.0010055824,
-0.0100721009,
0.0582830459,
-0.0348235331,
0.018952433,
0.0099983746,
0.0043214322,
-0.0363274328,
-0.0660999194,
-0.0081268949,
-0.0234278291,
0.0447577946,
0.0553428456,
-0.030223513,
-0.0418472104,
-0.047082603,
-0.0305753537,
-0.0095918365,
0.0038531029,
-0.0061564925,
0.0081073903,
-0.0279290229,
-0.0359362103,
-0.0515528582,
0.0553846695,
0.0615816228,
0.0123503823,
0.0073437495,
0.0079947598,
0.0164035205,
-0.0441024825,
0.0043675397,
0.0186126791,
0.0314514972,
-0.0109355338,
-0.016316032,
-0.0142460596,
0.0395114347,
-0.0215147529,
0.0229352359,
0.0979442298,
0.0158442277,
0.0223180018,
0.008853334,
-0.0512869917,
-0.0281464644,
-0.018272521,
-0.0014356613,
-0.0291424599,
-0.0186523944,
-0.026701225,
0.0288216174,
0.017958045,
-0.0588713288,
0.0298644882,
-0.0602039099,
0.0039662225,
0.0659101903,
-0.0213970467,
-0.0408475511,
0.0448826961,
0.0390820689,
0.0282664355,
-0.0010744045,
0.0018453888,
0.0078541311,
-0.0041119643,
-0.0197594445,
0.0501408875,
-0.0159566645,
0.0144251138,
0.0680006668,
-0.0909403861,
-0.0190002937,
-0.079536587,
-0.0059939981,
-0.0027623079,
0.0309347548,
-0.0042491704,
-0.0297526661,
-0.0137815904,
0.0004648435,
-0.06534563,
0.0127712311,
-0.0479385555,
-0.0965023562,
0.0367906764,
0.023215415,
-0.0850264728,
-0.0207400918,
-0.0282447394,
0.0584816635,
-0.0014484415,
-0.0124770226,
-0.0007054044,
0.0113113895,
-0.0858481005,
-0.0203140844,
-0.02997889,
-0.0451189429,
0.0208654813,
0.0114641804,
0.018701775,
-0.0932545438,
0.0179682989,
-0.0123553118,
-0.0439308174,
0.0432516746,
0.0524061546,
0.0140080405,
0.083135426,
0.0758147016,
-0.0139038227,
0.0599920228,
0.0238140523,
-0.0320677906,
0.0150072109,
-0.0288102478,
0.0040149596,
0.0009197493,
0.0262705814,
0.0007994459,
-0.0421428867,
0.037449725,
0.0108807562,
-0.0466986857,
0.0042587398,
0.0214921404,
-0.0158767756,
0.0314356312,
-0.0062177209,
0.0601301566,
-0.0473218113,
0.0657779053,
0.0171528179,
0.0363956429,
-0.0430963039,
-0.0596890226,
-0.0590405613,
-0.0280311145,
0.037449576,
-0.0437648445,
0.012759204,
0.0678530708,
0.0059053046,
0.0270576011,
-0.0128840385,
0.0358497053,
0.0622005425,
-0.0314420052,
-0.0093548289,
0.029388221,
0.0379346684,
0.0133551378,
0.0461833961,
-0.0485339239,
0.0119266361,
-0.0372096971,
0.0013606962,
0.0395742245,
0.0207752623,
0.0021679495,
0.0233877711,
-0.020970298,
-0.0439895764,
0.039879851,
-0.010171352,
0.0137691749,
0.0001468066,
0.0225793123,
0.0077100862,
0.0519516245,
-0.0019508085,
0.0068991194,
0.062938422,
0.044070188,
0.0308633465,
0.0003020049,
-0.0525578856,
0.0011727586,
-0.0063710804,
-0.015855547,
-0.0376599953,
0.000550536,
0.051602643,
0.0023142027,
-0.0478496514,
-0.0233414639,
-0.0313940942,
0.0226374362,
0.0107945884,
0.0750874206,
-0.0661374331,
0.0200746655,
-0.0073937406,
-0.1044736058,
0.0058409702,
0.0268582311,
0.0166738722,
0.0132477386,
0.0731138214,
0.0169212949,
-0.0055516232,
-0.014552692,
-0.0213443208,
-0.04447807,
-0.0162375253,
-0.0051700068,
0.0147566004,
-0.0178206433,
-0.0380462296,
-0.0202028379,
-0.0220771562,
0.0621864311,
0.0093781361,
-0.0586931258,
-0.0129708452,
-0.0142250741,
0.0175939295,
-0.0087350598,
0.010759877,
-0.0336076394,
0.0042307279,
-0.0916739404,
-0.0534342416,
0.0217839591,
-0.0391072482,
-0.0376953781,
0.040517915,
-0.0426220037,
-0.0218180232,
0.0236322861,
-0.0503999963,
0.05494719,
0.0463935174,
-0.0130822174,
-0.0394943468,
-0.0052658683,
0.0060284566,
-0.0033779189,
-0.0373984054,
0.06225425,
-0.0314121172,
-0.0384484939,
0.0152257923,
-0.0417759009,
-0.0471562184,
-0.0209914222,
0.0006696803,
-0.0680817664,
0.0122641157,
0.0804290771,
0.045053862,
-0.0089739747,
0.0198536236,
0.0416875817,
0.0258242302,
-0.0153852561,
0.0072757103,
-0.0527229421,
0.0154482601,
0.0103887012,
0.0334189236,
-0.0920239687,
-0.0492085367,
0.0457094871,
0.0242593605,
-0.0280727092,
-0.0336319692,
0.0086623337,
-0.0774223357,
-0.0499310456,
-0.0304817371,
-0.071644865,
-0.030791631,
0.0010598218,
-0.0422010459,
-0.034555871,
0.0264660083,
0.0109799365,
0.0170511305,
-0.0012467782,
0.0333231911,
-0.0090336921,
0.0401820354,
-0.0096152769,
0.029291492,
-0.001368003,
0.0092676468,
-0.0242654588,
-0.0298918728,
0.0177425239,
-0.0200034771,
-0.0180960763,
-0.0750432238,
0.0184989292,
-0.0354334638,
-0.0243349615,
-0.0396212675,
-0.0293067861,
-0.0095087094,
-0.0027761701,
0.0151231615,
0.0268989783,
0.0366521254,
0.0527630188,
0.0118181901,
-0.0173612069,
0.0047906018,
0.0146487625,
0.0355958268,
-0.0762147158,
0.0213591885,
-0.018139055,
0.0374230593,
0.0492421351,
0.0152332112,
-0.0058310777,
-0.0392588936,
0.0019326431,
0.0092789447,
0.028486684,
-0.008760999,
0.0153323188,
0.0274417978,
0.0187271927,
0.0545814112,
0.044735413,
-0.0193188693,
0.0265188385,
0.006660027,
-0.0107402671,
0.0061341072,
-0.0084711537,
-0.0133122001,
0.0107750027,
-0.0115306377,
-0.1145830899,
0.0364743173,
0.0229007341,
0.0239297207,
-0.0564935654,
-0.0322020128,
0.0015686319,
-0.0572305731,
-0.0075743305,
-0.0013746402,
-0.0238244385,
-0.0421867371,
0.0534023158,
-0.0057735718,
0.0192841701,
0.0124370996,
0.0185025129,
0.0132447705,
0.0019873176,
0.0250758678,
-0.0805843621,
-0.0143885054,
0.0111469263,
0.0153409438,
0.0299038719,
-0.0240976568,
-0.0271272454,
-0.007029077,
-0.0022936335,
-0.0072579184,
-0.0254845172,
-0.0395399369,
0.0190640409,
-0.0103240954,
-0.02863268,
-0.0314760469,
-0.025639737,
0.0085708648,
0.0323367454,
0.0028508923,
0.0104132844,
0.0256375484,
0.0363633968,
-0.0092245527,
-0.027676465,
0.0056453203,
-0.0024408449,
0.0593675859,
0.0505050421,
0.0048232186,
0.0430924334,
-0.0667576194,
-0.0009797374,
0.0267925989,
-0.0876393989,
0.021600036,
-0.0033650096,
-0.0596716516,
0.0336099304,
-0.0498435944,
0.0283058379,
-0.0029237163,
0.0466223992,
-0.0565475561,
-0.0127955144,
0.0008886799,
-0.0359026305,
0.0247013364,
-0.0352806151,
0.0262360666,
0.0186322313,
0.0127137722,
0.0024942309,
0.0202918518,
-0.0297411438,
0.0184641406,
-0.0195485111,
-0.0248957649,
0.0868532509,
0.0565988272,
0.018947443,
-0.0202944446,
-0.0044712205,
-0.0574120358,
0.0556034297,
0.0163189154,
0.0026879392,
-0.0095095569,
-0.0366804861,
0.025410505,
0.0011542169,
0.0098975925,
-0.0252644736,
0.0596979819,
0.0247482378,
-0.0300848074,
-0.0507079251,
-0.0067635067,
0.0011281039,
-0.0156073533,
0.0166333038,
-0.0842918083,
-0.0016801032,
-0.0351317488,
-0.0431533717,
-0.0082037905,
-0.067461744,
-0.0006498765,
-0.0316300802,
0.0474946871,
0.0418701172,
-0.0026383805,
-0.0061267233,
-0.0304583833,
0.0674256533,
-0.0433073491,
0.0557541922,
0.0782680362,
0.0692129359,
0.0064990195,
0.0098519474,
0.0050463951,
-0.0278970841,
-0.0875944048,
-0.0005962023,
-0.0027964122,
0.0375299491,
0.0200301036,
0.0312202666,
0.0366737135,
0.0160114672,
0.0795430169,
-0.0330171399,
-0.038570974,
-0.0090653151,
0.0026591537,
0.0201459732,
0.0110431034,
0.0259054117,
-0.012598685,
-0.0163183548,
0.0093629202,
-0.0349829197,
-0.0484529361,
0.0671610162,
0.0027005968,
-0.0104635675,
-0.0244519375,
0.0285429601,
-0.0123857893,
-0.0000183177,
0.0406714231,
-0.0585723184,
0.0011407952,
-0.0174325164,
0.0075878012,
2.196e-7,
0.0228034016,
0.0029346661,
-0.1042814404,
-0.0715741664,
-0.0266698394,
-0.0295431167,
0.0403985977,
0.0147523656,
0.0081949905,
0.0416856259,
0.037443731,
-0.0448552445,
0.0103033902,
0.0176959448,
-0.0314819887,
-0.0231477059,
0.0227318145,
-5.554548028e-33,
-0.0407785773,
-0.0491654016,
-0.0001958459,
-0.0518607609,
-0.0476353206,
-0.0142778531,
0.004647478,
0.0102119399,
-0.0261523444,
0.0326639935,
0.0377348773,
0.0006911964,
-0.0042645088,
-0.0086561535,
0.0229164772,
0.0069969599,
0.0179179106,
0.0338794701,
-0.0257750507,
-0.0355915315,
0.0267450772,
-0.0383869745,
0.0494100563,
-0.0533350147,
0.0825550556,
-0.0531665757,
-0.0467481799,
-0.0090492424,
0.0282409955,
0.0006609397,
-0.0389233679,
0.0756017864,
0.031780798,
-0.0025035643,
0.0373195559,
0.0551497042,
-0.0406347662,
-0.0043368619,
0.0226790104,
-0.0013502043,
0.0442101955,
-0.0217020828,
0.0140550015,
0.0117948381,
-0.045097433,
0.0446099006,
0.017335631,
0.0056670331,
0.0437749214,
0.0247885864,
-0.0372214355,
0.0025639201,
-0.032389991,
0.0291219335,
-0.0471073501,
0.0414313152,
0.0221129656,
0.0063153706,
-0.0563547909,
-0.0015203283,
0.0067309537,
0.0039702351,
0.0248938147,
0.0342815965,
-0.0088376021,
0.0219759606,
0.0210971832,
0.0016007758,
0.0106336586,
-0.0607244037,
0.0280195251,
-0.0413560234,
-0.0157720372,
0.0851049572,
-0.0030385563,
-0.1091391146,
0.0284084603,
-0.0146123134,
0.0672003701,
0.0261002462,
0.0052761449,
0.0076113669,
-0.0795950145,
-0.075584501,
-0.0012519888,
-0.0500190146,
-0.0172390956,
-0.01430583,
0.0732784346,
-0.0206309631,
-0.0170496609,
0.0656322911,
0.0313470252,
0.0057396647,
0.0288823955,
-0.0083045475,
-0.0036610968,
-0.0281461012,
0.0426183119,
-0.0014915578,
-0.0439817123,
0.0047807945,
0.0066624465,
0.0536181256,
0.0294654593,
-0.0124436077,
0.002561315,
-0.0276191756,
-0.0684967488,
0.0160146113,
0.0169218294,
0.0231715143,
0.0019142816,
0.0197133515,
0.0114049409,
0.0342191719,
-0.0141312964,
-0.0623794086,
0.049533572,
0.0152547574,
-0.0061246329,
0.0233023241,
-0.033693023,
0.0202324819,
-0.0091006644,
0.0084107053,
-0.0061162775,
-0.0152431317,
0.0374547914,
-0.0262216609,
-0.0003938423,
-0.048951786,
2.55e-7,
-0.027770441,
0.0419389233,
-0.0076440759,
0.0065851305,
0.0314676985,
0.0030052275,
0.025587393,
0.0197268147,
0.0398866646,
0.0164645351,
-0.032402616,
0.0425083749,
0.0248743389,
0.0551984198,
-0.0005129313,
0.0362161398,
-0.0837732032,
0.0084619466,
-0.0191576462,
0.0030764919,
-0.0455961674,
0.012579836,
0.0263131559,
-0.0116057023,
-0.0709738731,
-0.019499531,
-0.0027160123,
-0.030764522,
0.0187398735,
-0.00488945,
0.0124402624,
0.0339908004,
0.0315854214,
-0.001504869,
0.0420853943,
-0.0040805154,
0.0341773033,
0.0003270048,
-0.0222311057,
0.0426235013,
-0.021495942,
0.0102132764,
0.0004769232,
-0.0828451514,
0.0289534014,
0.0460352153,
-0.006579251,
-0.0175200813,
-0.0541253574,
-0.0146025317,
0.0538568944,
-0.0204957239,
-0.0316516384,
-0.0183668938,
0.0515558124,
-0.0516895391,
0.02720166,
-0.0156495851,
-0.0146396477,
-0.0202648845,
0.0153214969,
-0.0665018111,
-0.0006370567,
-0.012709735,
-0.0402683243,
-0.0069011254,
0.0481424406,
1.908785061e-34,
0.0535226837,
0.0212363061,
0.0302353762,
-0.05370811,
0.0568536073,
-0.0003721363,
-0.0089045297,
-0.0501386411,
0.0405403934,
-0.0117273452,
-0.0007651701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10512v1 | IvyGPT: InteractiVe Chinese pathwaY language model in medical domain | 2023-07-20T01:11:14 | 2023-07-20T01:11:14 | Rongsheng Wang, Yaofei Duan, ChanTong Lam, Jiexi Chen, Jiangsheng Xu, Haoming Chen, Xiaohong Liu, Patrick Cheong-Iao Pang, Tao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | General large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have shown remarkable
success. However, such LLMs have not been widely adopted for medical purposes,
due to poor accuracy and inability to provide medical advice. We propose
IvyGPT, an LLM based on LLaMA that is trained and fine-tuned with high-quality
medical question-answer (QA) instances and Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF). After supervised fine-tuning, IvyGPT has good multi-turn
conversation capabilities, but it cannot perform like a doctor in other
aspects, such as comprehensive diagnosis. Through RLHF, IvyGPT can output
richer diagnosis and treatment answers that are closer to human. In the
training, we used QLoRA to train 33 billion parameters on a small number of
NVIDIA A100 (80GB) GPUs. Experimental results show that IvyGPT has outperformed
other medical GPT models. | [
0.0621232428,
0.036865361,
-0.0055002752,
0.0029851056,
0.0146094812,
0.0184007492,
-0.0248315763,
0.0586301088,
0.0321126021,
0.0097277975,
-0.0314449072,
-0.0333159864,
-0.0039446633,
0.0309151243,
0.00852961,
-0.0676082149,
0.0341182165,
-0.0120708244,
0.0453219973,
-0.0262597539,
0.0114560854,
0.0055281674,
-0.0306778848,
0.0581751019,
0.0199427847,
-0.042566739,
0.0088613462,
-0.0194598362,
0.0358763933,
-0.0779184699,
-0.0187271964,
0.0160467997,
0.000208791,
0.009825483,
0.0000023136,
-0.0459723771,
-0.005701723,
0.0098701399,
-0.0254967846,
0.0085417572,
0.0285398401,
0.0000942551,
-0.0179197695,
0.0414320827,
-0.0275502056,
-0.0451460108,
0.0258607455,
0.0994951651,
0.0781061053,
0.0601969697,
-0.0041424558,
0.0008623148,
0.0552600659,
-0.0491866954,
0.0303194467,
-0.0692972913,
0.0320986062,
0.0112886727,
0.0550312661,
-0.0186112504,
-0.0119796554,
0.0385724269,
0.0223808289,
-0.0037861187,
-0.015148377,
0.0727416724,
0.0142697264,
0.0000507589,
-0.0119689237,
0.0923906863,
-0.0299213734,
-0.0122440755,
0.0030163857,
0.0108808037,
-0.0091517251,
-0.019005673,
-0.049360238,
-0.0044658273,
-0.0284939874,
-0.0030066499,
0.0196647141,
-0.0402201861,
0.0367073789,
-0.0278884228,
0.0134670185,
0.0154208858,
0.0139942961,
-0.0115557397,
-0.0179055128,
-0.0093321642,
0.0076902364,
-0.0258872993,
0.0295807384,
0.0569139533,
-0.0743055791,
0.011855633,
-0.0001880928,
0.0410547517,
0.0708041415,
-0.0767592713,
0.0220551696,
0.0123659261,
-0.0004055616,
0.0185257923,
-0.0138741611,
-0.008644768,
-0.041670993,
0.0287601873,
-0.0562621169,
0.0234836992,
-0.0347962156,
-0.0208288413,
-0.0249373149,
0.049392499,
-0.0267272703,
-0.0190649144,
-0.0770616382,
0.0155445021,
0.0105692195,
0.008573194,
0.0354617834,
0.0418821014,
-0.0275458768,
0.0162958764,
-0.0637155473,
0.0319616348,
-0.042684257,
0.0149644855,
-0.0350315049,
-0.0580893159,
0.012159694,
-0.0010942882,
-0.0094641224,
-0.0013910052,
0.0270355251,
0.1218422204,
-0.014721334,
-0.0073359897,
-0.0076643201,
-0.0014339046,
-0.01259524,
-0.0491018072,
0.0009644403,
-0.0791543201,
0.058805652,
0.0107084662,
0.0414300859,
-0.0136727905,
0.0271901246,
0.0343371481,
-0.0369279198,
0.0329351723,
-0.0280366037,
0.0141547043,
0.047601223,
0.0303622708,
0.0195270311,
0.0198790673,
0.0535967201,
-0.0110748727,
-0.0039439243,
-0.0175960753,
0.0284041781,
-0.0026813135,
0.0237432942,
-0.0125789503,
0.027410401,
0.0132292164,
-0.0133181019,
0.0926816016,
-0.0140716434,
0.0875684246,
-0.0355266407,
-0.0322006494,
0.0461424254,
0.0425033756,
0.032405626,
0.0326109566,
-0.0046562306,
-0.0151888495,
0.0059939814,
-0.0113572394,
-0.0108418297,
0.0325605273,
0.0064669838,
0.0070848023,
0.0184434652,
-0.0123935984,
-0.0321024507,
-0.0536406972,
-0.0337887891,
-0.0144515643,
-0.0229012854,
0.0079278909,
0.007873904,
-0.0378940031,
-0.035741698,
0.014486759,
0.0527354404,
-0.0161923543,
-0.0360114947,
-0.0715350211,
0.0327675678,
0.0970808938,
0.042531155,
-0.0287601147,
-0.03875852,
-0.0266010445,
-0.0272399336,
0.0272045005,
0.027778808,
-0.0304072183,
0.0100192446,
-0.0414701924,
0.0213007051,
0.024158949,
-0.0090045091,
0.0121124797,
-0.0117742447,
0.0183392633,
-0.0496884771,
-0.0162510369,
-0.0425126329,
0.0382140949,
-0.0434692763,
-0.0276160073,
0.0173575729,
-0.0181703828,
0.0121178981,
0.0067537636,
-0.0273622163,
0.0271778889,
0.0208437145,
-0.0377802998,
-0.049224183,
-0.0033522062,
-0.0543616898,
-0.0624391325,
0.0177777316,
-0.0209827479,
-0.0013974371,
-0.0303215217,
-0.0457214192,
-0.0426276028,
-0.0331885666,
-0.0636396408,
0.0217283014,
-0.0044929218,
0.0012350718,
0.0485838391,
0.0096917888,
-0.0315171815,
0.0296400469,
0.0105687669,
-0.0047826543,
0.0079876669,
0.0068717636,
-0.0076384093,
-0.0694032758,
-0.0065829419,
0.0222972929,
0.0155907562,
0.0097286729,
-0.014600046,
0.0407671295,
-0.0176722202,
-0.0322315432,
-0.0959139541,
0.0005942488,
0.0131317712,
0.0072990358,
0.0418786369,
0.0088820197,
-0.0166567639,
-0.0171612557,
-0.0558252446,
0.0141107738,
0.0198209882,
-0.0048659742,
0.0407798886,
0.0331694856,
0.015552856,
-0.0627101511,
-0.0013065339,
-0.0353474803,
0.0033692818,
0.008205031,
-0.0238712989,
-0.0046391282,
-0.0480802506,
-0.0165408626,
0.0361165516,
-0.0026537087,
-0.0505017564,
0.0172561686,
-0.0044417796,
0.0213826112,
0.0487827137,
-0.0014606031,
0.0144650703,
0.0291767027,
0.0194739755,
-0.0361918807,
0.0331964195,
-0.0469856262,
-0.0523909368,
-0.0185696054,
-0.022966478,
-0.0112749115,
0.0907032937,
0.0214663204,
0.0180896409,
-0.0546972081,
-0.0400164425,
-0.0176117644,
0.0271618012,
-0.0364898257,
0.0159272309,
-0.0368770808,
0.0019019248,
0.0034087161,
-0.0343662649,
0.0905971676,
-0.0279930308,
0.0250292327,
-0.0780698508,
-0.0371891558,
-0.039401371,
0.0138936834,
0.0002209592,
0.0366454087,
-0.0067947884,
-0.0186621044,
0.008388998,
0.0226848386,
-0.0140226558,
-0.0552532934,
0.0346942134,
-0.0320856199,
0.0124792373,
-0.0064236983,
-0.0464648344,
-0.0369652696,
0.0259685721,
-0.0243699774,
-0.0155305015,
0.0043896115,
-0.006191819,
-0.0073766005,
0.0188168343,
-0.000907174,
0.0863760486,
-0.0123679964,
-0.013860005,
-0.0130986366,
0.0068090754,
0.0376883075,
0.0103799719,
0.008622474,
-0.0344108716,
0.1085214317,
0.0756850541,
-0.0045559169,
0.0077167843,
0.0250394419,
-0.0175322127,
-0.0085261092,
-0.0187201183,
-0.0154165672,
0.0515079163,
0.0173135456,
-0.0552567355,
-0.0200944133,
0.1078229547,
0.0332652926,
-0.056667421,
0.0174909309,
-0.0163429379,
0.0015310596,
-0.0067750001,
0.0543264262,
-0.1103584617,
-0.0182127431,
-0.0207784213,
0.0302422624,
-0.0026848465,
0.0122285085,
0.0305555556,
-0.0534111001,
0.03387402,
-0.0063745612,
-0.0490199067,
-0.0067951502,
-0.0352817513,
-0.0095536262,
0.0008804261,
0.0104354508,
-0.0008492358,
-0.0136164697,
-0.0082444241,
0.0019374796,
-0.0320486128,
-0.024501143,
0.0420550667,
-0.0029712694,
0.0436893143,
0.055439692,
0.0514066145,
0.0066965758,
-0.0145329777,
-0.0031497709,
0.0108936056,
0.0282308962,
-0.0185403228,
0.0648969188,
0.0043412745,
0.0095343851,
-0.0538376532,
0.0535368696,
-0.0398422368,
0.0048151109,
0.0191532839,
0.0683150664,
-0.0442079343,
-0.0263087302,
-0.0399799794,
0.0193411652,
-0.0053379149,
0.0328406841,
-0.0046222638,
-0.0194599554,
-0.0718829185,
-0.0291426834,
0.0188058726,
-0.0045427061,
-0.0540315993,
0.0238173362,
-0.0207915641,
-0.0242192987,
-0.0869645253,
-0.02264468,
0.0202811062,
-0.0024855044,
-0.0104537858,
0.0482627749,
0.0355385467,
0.0074891918,
-0.0203750432,
0.0344853848,
0.0077896989,
0.0383043326,
-0.0833560228,
-0.0425158106,
0.0631228015,
-0.022907488,
-0.0076846117,
0.0386804827,
-0.0101783928,
-0.0220480841,
-0.0323874466,
0.044805564,
0.014425193,
0.0188590698,
-0.0342054889,
-0.0186290164,
0.0125112785,
0.031923607,
-0.0279833004,
0.0077702776,
0.0072711799,
0.0163023807,
0.0012211998,
0.0112479078,
-0.0142456591,
0.0391192473,
-0.0052898722,
0.0584147871,
-0.0278447084,
0.0003694847,
0.0342949592,
0.0123348106,
0.0466048121,
0.003584994,
-0.0306820665,
-0.0216129068,
0.0554181449,
-0.0383470207,
0.0307304934,
-0.0170497522,
-0.0086933384,
0.0370008647,
-0.0166128762,
0.0035265456,
-0.0578262471,
-0.0424022786,
-0.0300149564,
-0.0576508641,
0.0353834741,
0.0139902476,
-0.0327816121,
0.0193859879,
-0.0036232213,
0.0103431391,
-0.005893012,
0.0095524788,
0.0242429264,
0.0024186382,
0.0719588622,
-0.0145205259,
0.0057838759,
0.0272007622,
0.0455497392,
-0.0362225138,
-0.0828750208,
-0.0385122821,
0.084997192,
0.0754937232,
0.0477503464,
0.0376940854,
-0.0240127463,
0.0075140996,
-0.0025109844,
-0.0088789733,
-0.0248995814,
0.0068214145,
0.0859365091,
0.0177489873,
0.0020996546,
-0.0317152478,
0.0800216943,
0.0048608966,
0.0576382019,
-0.015229811,
-0.0196962804,
-0.0479913279,
-0.0361073166,
0.0003227364,
0.0292385034,
-0.0532075204,
0.0165947955,
-0.029435657,
-0.046212133,
-0.032466542,
0.0146296555,
-0.0330522582,
-0.0504992642,
0.0504307374,
0.0071262014,
0.0191496871,
-0.0349531844,
-0.0412786901,
0.0456491821,
-0.0264547784,
-0.0088408561,
0.0103241932,
-6.749576156e-33,
-0.007572907,
-0.0106984228,
0.0517121218,
-0.0068623386,
-0.0041912193,
0.023410935,
-0.0550106317,
0.008416336,
-0.035507597,
0.0328329913,
-0.031028593,
0.0058546681,
0.0125247836,
0.0324095413,
-0.0125095686,
-0.0184914079,
0.0299459938,
0.0039802501,
-0.0105655836,
0.0568090267,
-0.0103087015,
0.0340764299,
0.0402144119,
-0.0831929892,
-0.0293797571,
-0.0161777176,
0.015304747,
0.0260257721,
-0.0501109064,
0.0650161952,
-0.0579089783,
0.0520323887,
0.0265154149,
-0.0292504188,
0.0122786043,
-0.004959255,
-0.0931283012,
-0.0257361401,
0.0084055057,
-0.0250794329,
-0.0723823011,
-0.0225500632,
0.0320627429,
-0.0047036656,
-0.0018443074,
0.0056209872,
0.0086333342,
-0.0272036921,
-0.0135285081,
-0.0321039818,
-0.0273069702,
0.0396575257,
0.0177247226,
-0.0130914748,
-0.0467838012,
-0.0121907899,
-0.0401176587,
0.0235290639,
-0.0339285694,
-0.0075466456,
0.0478381179,
0.0490495116,
0.0251785591,
-0.0138222752,
0.0135386325,
0.0299691893,
0.0143463435,
-0.0147582004,
-0.0364979282,
0.0427703708,
-0.0481255241,
0.0181811042,
0.0546281897,
0.0046720998,
-0.0285634603,
-0.0189755354,
-0.0889001116,
0.0240747444,
0.0077360664,
0.0682522953,
0.014171428,
0.0160428565,
-0.0519030914,
-0.0136940489,
-0.031928204,
0.0268189646,
-0.0162801873,
-0.0483626798,
0.0375372358,
0.0044249035,
-0.006608339,
-0.0423552208,
0.0007493403,
-0.0112936348,
-0.0011481192,
-0.0055622859,
0.0098646935,
0.0249929652,
-0.0254631732,
0.0056850915,
-0.0591511279,
-0.0088384831,
0.0108982502,
-0.0510189831,
0.0224841516,
0.0091695078,
-0.007916661,
-0.0216762442,
-0.0787564367,
0.0249458961,
-0.0018422042,
0.005356052,
0.0192711875,
0.0507450625,
-0.0089707999,
0.0125529896,
-0.008449953,
0.0833118707,
-0.0165701769,
0.0254719034,
-0.0514999442,
-0.0395685732,
-0.0300954506,
-0.0043445509,
-0.0743890703,
0.020239871,
-0.0446424708,
0.0627426356,
0.0102507593,
-0.0946379229,
-0.0273654405,
0.021353282,
3.034e-7,
0.0545828603,
0.0637381524,
0.0260936301,
0.0215653982,
0.0459002033,
0.0009312732,
0.0072303773,
0.0264879502,
0.0062775998,
-0.0133605935,
0.0204163752,
0.0211031456,
0.0201889966,
0.0186540149,
-0.0604832806,
-0.0121803023,
-0.1202641577,
-0.0094554229,
-0.0217710827,
-0.0318769477,
0.0531442538,
0.1251936555,
-0.0486832559,
-0.0190838482,
0.060629826,
0.0078741536,
0.0454374962,
-0.0192371868,
-0.010594368,
0.0579621345,
0.0003750553,
0.03904723,
0.003636841,
0.013011069,
-0.010108659,
-0.0244090315,
-0.0236919187,
0.1114017442,
-0.0287639666,
-0.0232691839,
0.0513136052,
0.0115584135,
0.0547691844,
-0.0652128831,
0.0508044921,
-0.0258329343,
-0.041066967,
-0.0217495169,
0.0466210619,
-0.0302739982,
0.0663690045,
-0.0440939665,
-0.0245275293,
0.0209171344,
0.0112927305,
0.0177947301,
-0.0175567567,
-0.0615193471,
-0.0350369141,
0.0157181378,
-0.0333330333,
-0.0412778296,
-0.0088035502,
-0.0330569483,
-0.0346493311,
-0.0576912984,
-0.0102327941,
2.595441935e-34,
0.0182225928,
-0.0241092686,
0.0092002861,
0.0370730683,
0.0358426757,
0.0082849087,
0.0434539765,
0.0243565366,
0.0416858867,
-0.0866799131,
-0.0343105383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11778v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11778v1 | Transsion TSUP's speech recognition system for ASRU 2023 MADASR Challenge | 2023-07-20T00:55:01 | 2023-07-20T00:55:01 | Xiaoxiao Li, Gaosheng Zhang, An Zhu, Weiyong Li, Shuming Fang, Xiaoyue Yang, Jianchao Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper presents a speech recognition system developed by the Transsion
Speech Understanding Processing Team (TSUP) for the ASRU 2023 MADASR Challenge.
The system focuses on adapting ASR models for low-resource Indian languages and
covers all four tracks of the challenge. For tracks 1 and 2, the acoustic model
utilized a squeezeformer encoder and bidirectional transformer decoder with
joint CTC-Attention training loss. Additionally, an external KenLM language
model was used during TLG beam search decoding. For tracks 3 and 4, pretrained
IndicWhisper models were employed and finetuned on both the challenge dataset
and publicly available datasets. The whisper beam search decoding was also
modified to support an external KenLM language model, which enabled better
utilization of the additional text provided by the challenge. The proposed
method achieved word error rates (WER) of 24.17%, 24.43%, 15.97%, and 15.97%
for Bengali language in the four tracks, and WER of 19.61%, 19.54%, 15.48%, and
15.48% for Bhojpuri language in the four tracks. These results demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed method. | [
0.0032128843,
0.0024280841,
0.0442007259,
0.0642706528,
-0.0034738129,
0.008366582,
-0.012780128,
0.0072960812,
-0.0217728857,
0.0219831578,
-0.0443069115,
-0.0236545596,
0.0260147639,
0.049222745,
0.0065964367,
-0.0291827563,
0.013487204,
-0.0639881045,
0.0161699355,
-0.0097121513,
0.0304948948,
-0.0061324975,
-0.0458626412,
0.0234088432,
-0.0138027174,
0.0188781377,
-0.0052869776,
0.0115033602,
-0.0014170556,
-0.044718504,
-0.0236187894,
-0.0266501103,
0.0212369096,
0.0377006494,
0.0000022906,
-0.0327477604,
-0.0316467844,
-0.0108619584,
-0.0825708732,
-0.0334574468,
-0.0140996277,
0.0029005571,
0.0257042758,
0.0345125198,
0.0020619817,
0.0132018188,
0.0616482757,
0.0584740639,
0.0187621154,
0.0788144767,
0.0054714051,
-0.0357148238,
-0.0009741756,
0.0332242474,
0.0134118348,
-0.0625131652,
-0.0307053477,
-0.0316749029,
0.0080756964,
0.0116379475,
-0.0064506014,
0.066990003,
0.0026220437,
-0.0107017066,
0.027212318,
-0.0288043916,
-0.043775782,
-0.0578228422,
-0.0250927433,
0.0128100915,
0.0101762833,
-0.0695544928,
0.0236656796,
0.0055171438,
-0.0489814468,
-0.0329391621,
-0.022156395,
-0.0187401623,
-0.0587375537,
0.0033070142,
0.0267900098,
0.0609696805,
-0.0077047958,
-0.0361135565,
0.0160721466,
0.0196377113,
-0.0157173313,
-0.0712778643,
-0.0093123391,
-0.0481172018,
0.0266697165,
0.0240683816,
0.0853686929,
-0.0113216201,
-0.0223754421,
0.0121625829,
0.0105220387,
-0.0641810596,
-0.0041191368,
-0.081217967,
-0.0128801782,
0.0545984879,
-0.0018940561,
0.0075296834,
0.0118789226,
0.0843754783,
0.0217191,
-0.0030993083,
-0.0335355327,
-0.0092075821,
0.0056381184,
-0.0056241411,
-0.0474525057,
0.0022357353,
-0.0528565943,
-0.0032270609,
-0.0133489091,
-0.004826637,
0.0266302079,
-0.0357071348,
0.0891172141,
-0.0207525548,
-0.0559082367,
-0.0476321988,
0.0517970361,
0.0433455445,
0.0111330794,
0.0037175857,
-0.0172514282,
-0.0878836736,
-0.0420757942,
0.033903148,
0.0331007279,
-0.001556337,
-0.0450732894,
0.0001799363,
-0.0102901915,
-0.0584352389,
-0.0597963966,
0.0555283651,
-0.0081580887,
-0.0324924141,
-0.0079243807,
-0.0092105772,
0.0402798206,
0.0219338816,
0.0054716459,
-0.0198799763,
0.0095965313,
-0.0320849158,
0.0334621258,
0.0570577532,
-0.0042959801,
-0.0097819818,
0.0634467378,
0.0051671723,
0.0410247445,
0.058231812,
0.0143913962,
-0.0152032375,
0.0044962908,
-0.0560230576,
0.0162801258,
0.0552342869,
-0.0277886596,
-0.010781873,
0.0060645882,
0.0182514973,
0.0207282994,
0.0052023148,
0.0251913294,
0.031321533,
0.0068038618,
0.0228110906,
0.0047248509,
0.0119277555,
0.0859548673,
-0.0068804198,
-0.0050113513,
0.0126418639,
0.0148060601,
-0.0274927821,
0.0409089848,
-0.0023048853,
-0.0072203614,
0.0024419609,
0.0370661467,
0.0283359084,
0.0016617121,
0.0122022508,
-0.0249869712,
-0.0198700055,
-0.0239981655,
0.0175319389,
0.0806276426,
0.0023816165,
-0.069056429,
0.0593949929,
0.0330315568,
-0.0453362428,
0.0215239357,
-0.0554398112,
-0.0061725331,
-0.0007208808,
0.0272066798,
-0.0233338326,
-0.0293848049,
-0.0262760185,
-0.0392958075,
0.0342965014,
-0.007583817,
0.0326955169,
-0.0159166697,
-0.1013901755,
-0.0025740755,
0.0984840393,
-0.0274447948,
0.0335175171,
-0.0534506999,
0.0346713886,
-0.0114723342,
-0.0198490322,
0.016434852,
-0.0042572552,
0.0035832338,
-0.0083077364,
0.0108830566,
0.0084197391,
0.084445782,
0.0598111562,
0.0069968798,
-0.0407290608,
0.0289261937,
0.0019324098,
0.0447706766,
0.0360635631,
-0.080174163,
-0.0588886365,
0.028616026,
-0.0157431532,
0.0417710543,
0.0395084061,
0.0451666117,
-0.0867963433,
0.0486894771,
-0.0480113178,
0.0270041581,
-0.0127422018,
0.0760332718,
0.0185530018,
-0.0041456558,
0.0061469716,
0.0074098171,
-0.0036151833,
0.0033370664,
-0.0179505199,
-0.0053617689,
0.0242133085,
-0.0641989112,
-0.018161336,
0.0440025926,
-0.019573085,
0.0150971077,
0.0087415166,
-0.0115272375,
-0.0082172016,
-0.0017072414,
-0.0356102996,
-0.0206528325,
-0.0119486824,
0.0308097471,
-0.0268501099,
0.0415482819,
-0.0263156593,
-0.047117386,
0.0356221236,
0.002620948,
-0.0016458121,
-0.0543556996,
-0.0640920773,
-0.0033144285,
-0.0057999333,
-0.0017050011,
-0.0027807306,
0.0163763165,
0.0153002813,
0.0096200611,
-0.0636143088,
-0.0763090625,
0.0436520316,
0.0376982354,
-0.0061161369,
0.0016582765,
-0.0514082499,
-0.0176086854,
-0.0046081604,
0.0070070634,
0.0170151535,
-0.0012247773,
-0.0107780928,
-0.05052514,
-0.012449584,
-0.0480657555,
-0.0023189199,
0.0457771011,
0.0389929488,
-0.0023523387,
-0.001062314,
0.016032869,
0.0315030031,
0.0221118908,
0.056120526,
-0.0475132205,
-0.0622087047,
-0.0476465002,
-0.013346998,
-0.0060997386,
0.0150379138,
-0.0700881407,
0.0014515285,
0.0006768735,
0.0217409395,
0.0063900915,
-0.0872897878,
-0.0600793958,
-0.1110992655,
-0.0192214027,
-0.0126619488,
-0.0365354307,
-0.016715683,
-0.0063348375,
-0.009534182,
-0.0680994615,
0.0360365659,
0.0222719125,
-0.0234958027,
-0.0454667769,
0.0030111189,
0.0124780471,
0.0104278363,
-0.0317503288,
0.0094678225,
-0.0000281226,
-0.0087842941,
0.0108638983,
0.0087519297,
0.0448303372,
-0.0201965272,
-0.0055765454,
0.0875636488,
0.0229614843,
0.0527400263,
-0.0032244371,
0.0316932909,
-0.0317914076,
0.059146449,
0.0409148671,
0.019324122,
0.0179205239,
0.0278520845,
0.0254529174,
-0.0401294194,
0.0771868452,
-0.0171461292,
-0.0335545987,
-0.0234587193,
0.0261550024,
-0.0017121502,
0.024512032,
0.0159997437,
0.062683478,
-0.0228707269,
-0.0075267265,
0.0568043925,
0.0086494377,
-0.010418403,
-0.0529114157,
-0.0446044058,
-0.0140465759,
-0.0073503456,
-0.0171462111,
-0.0347791277,
-0.0151906526,
0.0795182884,
0.0605947077,
0.0164940115,
0.022757953,
-0.0094978753,
-0.0730752051,
0.016774999,
0.0140198935,
-0.0457923748,
-0.0599654354,
-0.0365749672,
-0.0360127017,
-0.0149922781,
0.0443375148,
0.0658407062,
-0.0260505546,
-0.0424182042,
0.0517738312,
-0.0593509637,
-0.0496715121,
-0.013545231,
-0.0269636698,
0.1161605865,
0.030985726,
-0.0074520526,
-0.009659824,
-0.0214180835,
-0.0082646124,
-0.0259459149,
-0.0058796899,
-0.0222504251,
-0.0241387207,
0.0042295973,
-0.0189887863,
-0.0043740179,
0.0212885458,
-0.0119397892,
0.0303215776,
0.0325235315,
0.0687519014,
-0.0385350399,
-0.0187947135,
0.0412443057,
-0.0077228309,
0.0175981559,
0.0357889198,
0.007037479,
0.0032846692,
0.0062206802,
-0.0252587404,
0.0645141155,
-0.0253063366,
-0.0045599006,
0.0241770409,
-0.0276337359,
-0.0474510975,
0.0168740265,
-0.0370541103,
0.0331992917,
0.0304213054,
0.0454226509,
0.0246863272,
-0.0068842573,
0.0249520633,
-0.0157885402,
-0.0118645579,
-0.0346608758,
-0.0052196742,
-0.0726424307,
0.0087587982,
-0.0014539466,
-0.0392764062,
-0.0307728592,
0.0056629181,
-0.0041717733,
-0.006223754,
0.0439890884,
0.0210449211,
0.0219691452,
0.0012066406,
-0.0261954237,
-0.0306908712,
0.0349428952,
-0.0086524375,
-0.0656650737,
-0.0022858812,
0.0433434397,
-0.0132122329,
-0.0055146562,
-0.0056036911,
-0.0272831395,
-0.0090409163,
-0.0297653638,
0.0218378343,
-0.0177836567,
-0.0107074948,
0.0175592378,
0.0343900584,
0.0388017967,
-0.0310931392,
-0.0566770472,
-0.0218412541,
0.043651592,
0.0333261639,
0.0591915175,
-0.0175860468,
-0.0125867156,
0.0247579683,
0.0403074324,
0.014790657,
-0.015803365,
-0.0328893438,
-0.0219325069,
-0.0048424578,
0.1191845611,
0.0582658611,
0.0405793786,
0.0327578671,
-0.0235276669,
-0.0123778023,
0.0199290793,
0.0390235782,
0.0207259171,
0.004932201,
0.0630741343,
-0.0213219579,
0.0167101882,
0.0546756051,
0.044860635,
0.0255184639,
0.0232942756,
-0.0357235633,
0.0247454438,
0.0323402286,
0.0259061866,
0.0506667346,
0.0243459847,
0.0468406193,
-0.0285957959,
0.0132930279,
-0.0537472218,
0.0539872646,
0.0198927876,
-0.0093226489,
-0.0301584918,
0.0111707374,
0.0183013827,
-0.0266854987,
0.0039057212,
0.0115907956,
0.0480571873,
-0.0531425402,
-0.012235947,
-0.0236421674,
0.0153220445,
-0.0268629938,
-0.0158193242,
0.0164081194,
-0.0364769846,
0.0495431796,
-0.0306539796,
0.0058404645,
-0.0338313207,
0.0030666352,
-0.0315568149,
-0.0243209209,
0.0069006775,
0.0224847868,
-0.0532046854,
0.0176058747,
-0.012248463,
-0.007011083,
-6.919775248e-33,
-0.0114962319,
0.0490735397,
-0.0065810578,
0.0039136093,
-0.0156416222,
0.0095553836,
-0.0320854858,
-0.0250730719,
0.019393215,
-0.0532313064,
-0.0267867446,
-0.0085828118,
0.0322763212,
0.0135544054,
0.0192420483,
-0.0039356817,
0.0576689541,
0.0126450565,
-0.0032030346,
-0.0248928685,
0.030680459,
0.0546949469,
0.0574236885,
0.000353914,
-0.0195814557,
-0.0371874273,
0.013493794,
-0.0100337621,
0.0318749957,
0.0311108548,
-0.0163439251,
0.0357792266,
0.0013023844,
-0.0640301928,
-0.0156985465,
0.0125288917,
-0.0900326744,
0.0506735593,
-0.0188417435,
0.1054425314,
0.0560634919,
-0.0317558385,
0.0216465909,
0.0120547824,
-0.0718223527,
0.0104543874,
-0.0143674472,
0.0043239077,
-0.0194038842,
-0.0060607302,
-0.0031292711,
0.0478653647,
-0.0280198958,
-0.0079553565,
0.0716106072,
0.0411650054,
-0.0202750452,
-0.0651010424,
-0.1074923277,
0.0028497519,
0.0027272115,
0.0520801395,
0.0409569591,
0.0084800553,
-0.0545921847,
-0.026088113,
0.0360747464,
-0.138616249,
0.0250510704,
-0.0547275431,
0.0114669297,
-0.0045343391,
-0.0020431343,
-0.0108029088,
0.03721397,
-0.0450917743,
0.0293836128,
-0.0215649288,
0.0571422651,
0.0686901286,
0.0206384156,
0.0338415466,
-0.085628897,
0.0008717818,
0.0200999137,
-0.023046745,
-0.0548459105,
-0.038135156,
0.0786476135,
-0.0204421934,
-0.0020016429,
0.0367701054,
0.0907712802,
-0.0060633193,
0.0863654688,
-0.0055572288,
0.0428865328,
0.0047386955,
-0.0266763158,
0.0632588938,
-0.0487054139,
-0.0337354876,
0.0483125746,
0.0284509305,
-0.0037671209,
-0.0304317232,
-0.0268336758,
0.0318220928,
-0.0445638336,
0.0070799887,
0.0174449589,
0.0178646278,
-0.0105683319,
0.0414722748,
0.0275981333,
-0.0268474817,
0.0061354646,
-0.0038429601,
0.0124403648,
0.0083835954,
-0.0172189474,
0.0119784754,
0.0162047632,
0.0086021442,
-0.0247901995,
0.0320208259,
-0.0346130766,
-0.0134069771,
-0.0174519271,
-0.0151406806,
0.0176565219,
0.0206568874,
3.14e-7,
-0.0495101027,
0.0504228622,
0.0265454687,
-0.0439386927,
-0.0447538719,
-0.0111302938,
-0.0160284564,
-0.0375527404,
-0.0098975617,
0.0474726595,
-0.0205136817,
-0.0318085738,
0.0702107474,
-0.0013578781,
-0.1126968116,
-0.0238261204,
-0.0518364273,
0.0006064224,
-0.0336710103,
0.0337323025,
0.0092676058,
0.0683952793,
-0.0178542826,
-0.010691477,
-0.022286525,
-0.033933185,
-0.0012104929,
0.0306913834,
-0.0047950638,
0.0074106166,
0.0084981816,
-0.0171550177,
-0.0465800799,
0.0175789222,
-0.0318410024,
0.0245957058,
0.0183961149,
0.0126496088,
-0.0164872035,
-0.0501214564,
0.0417465046,
0.075121671,
-0.0454496592,
-0.036722213,
0.0491797999,
0.0531151444,
-0.0159663297,
0.0051632025,
-0.0487255678,
0.0182000659,
-0.0518155172,
0.0073360358,
0.0488284007,
-0.0195820779,
0.009665723,
-0.0318499506,
-0.0349166431,
-0.0197532419,
0.0118995383,
-0.0102729602,
-0.0469261222,
-0.0225922428,
-0.0331061669,
0.0032872406,
0.0397095196,
-0.0233131628,
0.0015466422,
2.598482838e-34,
0.0661415234,
0.0003202239,
0.0217438657,
0.0223996267,
0.0217115246,
-0.0571457967,
0.0067564002,
0.0292808078,
-0.0137514789,
-0.0704695135,
-0.0172848646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10511v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10511v2 | General Debiasing for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis | 2023-07-20T00:36:41 | 2023-08-07T09:08:23 | Teng Sun, Juntong Ni, Wenjie Wang, Liqiang Jing, Yinwei Wei, Liqiang Nie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing work on Multimodal Sentiment Analysis (MSA) utilizes multimodal
information for prediction yet unavoidably suffers from fitting the spurious
correlations between multimodal features and sentiment labels. For example, if
most videos with a blue background have positive labels in a dataset, the model
will rely on such correlations for prediction, while "blue background" is not a
sentiment-related feature. To address this problem, we define a general
debiasing MSA task, which aims to enhance the Out-Of-Distribution (OOD)
generalization ability of MSA models by reducing their reliance on spurious
correlations. To this end, we propose a general debiasing framework based on
Inverse Probability Weighting (IPW), which adaptively assigns small weights to
the samples with larger bias (i.e., the severer spurious correlations). The key
to this debiasing framework is to estimate the bias of each sample, which is
achieved by two steps: 1) disentangling the robust features and biased features
in each modality, and 2) utilizing the biased features to estimate the bias.
Finally, we employ IPW to reduce the effects of large-biased samples,
facilitating robust feature learning for sentiment prediction. To examine the
model's generalization ability, we keep the original testing sets on two
benchmarks and additionally construct multiple unimodal and multimodal OOD
testing sets. The empirical results demonstrate the superior generalization
ability of our proposed framework. We have released the code and data to
facilitate the reproduction https://github.com/Teng-Sun/GEAR. | [
0.0177851822,
0.0770657808,
-0.0043724268,
0.0136068761,
-0.0177559983,
-0.0064140502,
-0.0045924471,
0.0023788209,
0.0030026676,
-0.0570614636,
-0.0425345041,
-0.0231609773,
-0.0061059804,
0.0202598404,
0.0287424978,
-0.090333797,
-0.0151677812,
0.0329427309,
0.0501120426,
-0.0329703353,
0.0699307919,
0.002410593,
-0.000960033,
0.0081188148,
-0.0612388328,
-0.0191932563,
0.0205935407,
0.0435473099,
0.0229918659,
-0.0099079963,
0.0196782202,
0.0210055653,
0.0184145607,
-0.0511905737,
0.0000021953,
-0.017219279,
0.0102412552,
-0.0188484136,
0.0844519213,
-0.0578919649,
0.0572864525,
-0.0524970852,
0.0407035612,
0.0270838384,
-0.012834629,
0.0092000067,
0.0772841722,
0.0535425022,
0.0186805613,
0.0194450822,
-0.0427218974,
0.0193507262,
-0.0286682416,
-0.0150896665,
0.0345015116,
-0.0210200064,
-0.0260871928,
0.0037809864,
-0.0325807258,
-0.0398786329,
-0.0650932491,
0.0003314506,
-0.0074695866,
0.0399375185,
0.0091907475,
-0.0162901692,
0.0205320176,
-0.0306394361,
-0.0266125929,
0.0865885839,
-0.0237407312,
0.0019319867,
-0.0139960982,
-0.0211425703,
0.0086241271,
0.0397012234,
-0.0467594862,
0.0114199128,
0.0012259277,
0.0311058946,
-0.0505682193,
0.0559597984,
0.0344807766,
0.0008893621,
0.0101574995,
-0.0013678285,
-0.0003294597,
0.0181396045,
0.0118825603,
0.0641900375,
-0.0420718081,
0.019175889,
-0.0059103142,
-0.0518918224,
0.0307948235,
-0.0125149917,
0.0006203285,
-0.0416558944,
-0.0064624413,
-0.0329027325,
0.0223086383,
-0.0124048851,
-0.0855233595,
0.0424061455,
0.045326937,
-0.0062932698,
-0.0111084543,
0.0145391272,
-0.0149343256,
0.0120541072,
-0.0722891167,
0.0114943003,
0.0405543596,
0.021212751,
0.0079787783,
-0.0138520645,
-0.0252271593,
-0.0243223067,
-0.0561289638,
-0.0189416576,
0.0070677223,
0.0519189797,
-0.011108567,
-0.0187948644,
-0.0081558861,
0.0736661851,
-0.0494566001,
0.0445086919,
-0.0375488736,
-0.0472124964,
0.0035088395,
0.0474610776,
-0.0188579187,
-0.0170966629,
0.0310688298,
0.0792380422,
0.0324186496,
-0.0311866626,
-0.0101358993,
-0.0322611183,
-0.0370776094,
-0.0539492927,
0.0548350215,
-0.0377164371,
0.0158384256,
0.0135301379,
0.0280653685,
-0.0200857613,
-0.0171030164,
-0.0293016229,
-0.0240361243,
0.0474911928,
0.0128283622,
-0.0283080377,
-0.0027040129,
-0.0035370095,
-0.0235418361,
0.0893375129,
-0.0142958555,
0.0548551604,
0.0496382266,
0.0140568586,
0.02391674,
0.0276057795,
0.0099200159,
-0.0071352609,
-0.0289109647,
-0.0113189174,
-0.0227894075,
-0.0160254352,
0.0747945234,
0.0221402515,
-0.0078257928,
-0.0307983197,
0.0558526963,
-0.0620167665,
-0.0573763251,
-0.0201443955,
-0.0300321169,
-0.0195878483,
-0.0172916763,
0.016943628,
-0.0388160609,
0.0668935254,
-0.0081267692,
0.004228862,
0.0239199307,
0.0353530385,
-0.0451937877,
-0.023094466,
0.0224701762,
-0.0307035912,
0.0236523673,
0.0157480631,
0.0570468716,
0.0226281192,
-0.0185188614,
-0.0024235034,
0.0625130236,
-0.0059109265,
-0.0021720447,
-0.0058566951,
0.0020793988,
0.0357122682,
0.0024642146,
-0.0402305275,
0.0251861848,
-0.0172085427,
0.0117581133,
-0.0141585777,
-0.0052422578,
0.0021456492,
0.0639077425,
-0.0505449176,
-0.0636800528,
0.0056145596,
0.0325756334,
0.0298023783,
-0.0162823461,
0.0107744075,
0.0016161355,
-0.07274241,
0.0329840668,
-0.0125938812,
0.0433724001,
-0.0031691783,
0.0201722831,
0.020606352,
0.0465607755,
0.0228421297,
-0.0252795666,
-0.0261944085,
-0.0044417395,
-0.0306645613,
-0.024432594,
0.0459531397,
-0.0155588491,
-0.0320007615,
0.007935117,
-0.0921714157,
-0.0024000392,
0.0519207455,
-0.0615617298,
0.0310416296,
0.0633388236,
0.0046278955,
0.0024777178,
-0.0081984149,
-0.0597714037,
0.0084791454,
0.0140408035,
0.0078304764,
0.0278782472,
-0.0449753255,
-0.0347056426,
-0.0429019816,
-0.0353643224,
0.0256842934,
0.0108371507,
-0.0460087322,
-0.0056138397,
0.0096928282,
0.0124557167,
0.0256275274,
-0.0354161039,
-0.0086865909,
0.0027588429,
-0.1146890298,
-0.0285863113,
-0.0232063048,
-0.0182073656,
0.0103594428,
0.0155020813,
0.0144616896,
-0.05195513,
-0.0060639102,
0.0003182418,
-0.018513009,
0.0323311053,
-0.0042610671,
0.0106142685,
0.0408923216,
-0.0273553878,
-0.0156428479,
-0.0097479904,
0.0789059177,
0.0021993525,
-0.0359884463,
-0.0010096147,
-0.0195305012,
-0.0654960275,
0.0254194569,
-0.0241136588,
-0.013861184,
-0.0190777741,
-0.0050673401,
0.0111328764,
0.0276294239,
-0.0022476504,
-0.0195436161,
0.0408120044,
0.0115218069,
0.0016185485,
-0.0045014471,
-0.0067754942,
0.0209621228,
0.0073992559,
-0.0379024856,
-0.028620895,
0.0213336758,
0.0391300544,
0.0100914529,
-0.0426407978,
-0.002450214,
0.0248104669,
-0.0416901261,
-0.0267717987,
0.0277607646,
0.0248824283,
-0.0156788733,
-0.0124374349,
-0.0493164361,
0.0501512997,
0.0352901295,
0.0153004285,
-0.0327667668,
0.0418691114,
0.0057290485,
0.0625230074,
0.0004613069,
0.0353927575,
0.021357581,
0.0393639542,
-0.0503631271,
-0.0484372079,
0.0422897041,
0.0088859666,
0.0030459373,
-0.0145064685,
-0.0005564369,
0.0399169624,
-0.059766233,
0.0140940687,
-0.0620529428,
-0.0451448783,
-0.0369203538,
-0.0425359346,
0.0103997542,
-0.0041834065,
-0.0179348607,
-0.019758679,
-0.0364451446,
0.0038639156,
-0.0055005746,
0.0481436886,
0.0548773259,
0.0510505177,
-0.0151369311,
-0.0260927733,
-0.0518566631,
-0.0491711795,
0.0181395169,
0.0053334432,
-0.0172931999,
-0.0384681746,
-0.0068694996,
-0.0056162509,
0.0795532465,
-0.0132529112,
0.0032694226,
0.0452586077,
0.0112801623,
0.0556114428,
0.0556782447,
-0.0016719734,
-0.0713827536,
0.003536606,
0.044336509,
0.0402161144,
0.0470884815,
-0.0311661959,
-0.0320612565,
-0.0723911747,
-0.0240021143,
0.0096074361,
-0.0010783377,
-0.0133717703,
0.0281470455,
-0.1031547859,
0.0107428385,
-0.0167277344,
0.0173683148,
-0.0685721859,
-0.0341296569,
0.0041709626,
-0.0688202828,
0.0051634223,
-0.0393867046,
0.026670875,
0.0345727429,
-0.0042974842,
-0.0240726992,
-0.0587862246,
0.0182358902,
-0.0387004614,
0.012630403,
0.0607012622,
0.0092720622,
-0.0362923294,
-0.0064332746,
-0.0071629989,
-0.0072914665,
0.0295625832,
-0.0162738971,
0.112221688,
-0.0307149906,
-0.0359383002,
-0.0078515578,
0.0235295705,
0.0041702376,
0.0075550382,
-0.0087523134,
0.0248069353,
-0.0092821252,
-0.0305486154,
-0.051684469,
0.0250389725,
0.0592924394,
0.029250199,
-0.0194296539,
-0.0939517915,
-0.0107788006,
-0.0305794273,
0.0046876008,
0.0287345815,
0.0372606292,
-0.0109996768,
0.0127176782,
-0.020365864,
-0.0879624188,
0.0176066291,
-0.0085397661,
0.0455451496,
-0.0219742898,
0.0040335041,
-0.054458417,
0.0041655763,
-0.0493967719,
0.0366776548,
0.0319513157,
0.0216891207,
0.0255544707,
0.0014865556,
0.0328658521,
-0.0409326628,
-0.0318491831,
0.0245254096,
-0.0532596558,
-0.0381954387,
-0.0039587109,
0.0936496854,
0.0111483261,
0.0249349978,
0.0342305787,
-0.0303374287,
0.0367105231,
0.0797755644,
-0.0212063491,
0.0160999224,
0.056446448,
-0.0072644111,
0.0092410026,
0.0173572339,
-0.0500652902,
0.0261229053,
0.0176767316,
-0.0343809873,
-0.0035293712,
-0.0211213231,
-0.0170909148,
-0.030845711,
0.0745083466,
-0.0499710552,
-0.0153878313,
-0.0199605525,
-0.0360967815,
0.0164609775,
-0.0165466983,
-0.0460875519,
0.0445931517,
0.0300356187,
0.0415260196,
-0.0429376736,
0.024148399,
-0.0019893874,
0.009791893,
-0.003840935,
0.0324335657,
0.0244273376,
0.0113316737,
-0.0179882627,
0.0042699748,
0.0414701141,
0.0094762323,
0.001410972,
-0.0347773731,
0.0244651046,
0.0369753987,
0.0272333976,
0.0153117198,
-0.0461307094,
-0.005933091,
-0.0195907895,
0.0576250888,
-0.0501951613,
0.0603860579,
0.0166808721,
-0.0234673545,
0.0108928438,
-0.0186250824,
-0.0011588228,
-0.0135288583,
0.0289006587,
-0.0225878395,
-0.0093607437,
0.0560715832,
-0.0193423647,
0.0054161814,
0.032110326,
0.0687706918,
-0.0278396327,
0.0367301442,
-0.0106849102,
0.0090422276,
-0.0343997367,
0.0084424429,
0.0842082724,
0.0278670806,
0.0138479667,
0.0265185628,
-0.0258064345,
-0.0733744204,
0.0628007799,
-0.0346820988,
0.0335670821,
0.023900196,
0.0494886376,
0.0576869249,
0.0195629206,
0.0328249373,
-0.0178120434,
-0.044732552,
-0.0238507222,
-0.0198661387,
0.0154865859,
-6.422740972e-33,
0.0268151555,
0.004212332,
-0.0721121654,
-0.015057914,
0.0325657278,
-0.025330523,
-0.0178601667,
0.0123385396,
-0.0050617363,
0.0431809351,
0.0155687397,
-0.0004469136,
-0.0077036195,
0.0177311581,
0.0259963349,
-0.0073185121,
0.0291368384,
-0.012007826,
0.0085409423,
0.0260170754,
0.0194609314,
0.0411717519,
0.0578138642,
-0.1284445375,
0.0114642959,
-0.0071054529,
-0.078718625,
-0.0200585593,
0.0619444549,
0.0106327515,
-0.0239424314,
0.0651146844,
0.0426020212,
0.023073256,
-0.0193063207,
0.0171751827,
-0.0259289108,
-0.0077754478,
0.0052710227,
0.0101669244,
-0.0270161442,
0.0159118418,
0.0201926306,
-0.0096530151,
-0.0352444276,
-0.0468628854,
0.0621759705,
-0.0132136075,
0.0333694294,
-0.016450638,
-0.024700759,
0.0129064256,
-0.0062956824,
0.0028117173,
-0.0106297713,
0.0273134392,
0.0302141607,
0.0199657213,
0.0140898526,
0.0180158466,
-0.0813591555,
-0.0272397641,
0.0077527948,
0.0092570251,
0.0014941402,
0.0841252431,
0.0201948304,
-0.0032712684,
-0.0006645927,
0.0242284145,
0.0126932049,
0.0113093723,
0.0082397489,
0.1443848014,
0.0732440725,
-0.0209566411,
-0.0602084361,
0.0178091638,
0.0046944004,
-0.020772798,
0.0470082536,
0.0092075467,
-0.0253874213,
-0.0111630997,
0.0012317867,
-0.0552665181,
-0.0066410191,
-0.0449541844,
0.0121168513,
0.0054780995,
-0.0032649895,
-0.0012689945,
0.0244257655,
-0.0623362362,
-0.0259984285,
0.06014603,
-0.048138842,
0.0362547636,
0.0291455593,
-0.0126524623,
-0.0327768363,
-0.0095833475,
0.0158131402,
0.0306720063,
0.0095368773,
-0.0114244604,
0.0614614524,
0.0476860106,
-0.0668362528,
-0.0130295893,
-0.0084116766,
0.0308987554,
-0.005822585,
0.0694347546,
0.0056027067,
0.0098981187,
-0.0426966995,
0.0038800638,
-0.0109225484,
0.044359114,
-0.0117484489,
-0.0207287557,
-0.0097771902,
0.0117011257,
-0.039999973,
-0.0503213964,
0.0057304148,
-0.1391995847,
-0.0064293207,
-0.066388756,
-0.0202124212,
-0.0000706456,
2.928e-7,
0.0201138966,
0.0365516432,
-0.0086597167,
-0.0222779345,
0.0180263892,
0.0673146695,
-0.0155642265,
0.0432300195,
0.0170311574,
-0.0873237252,
0.0234187655,
0.0224053208,
-0.0089235762,
0.0208932515,
-0.0550683551,
0.0186716821,
0.0094988123,
-0.0210792832,
0.0103810756,
0.0118378131,
0.0116106654,
0.1111574844,
0.0133269783,
-0.0325118825,
0.0173762944,
-0.0228351001,
0.068696335,
-0.0196306482,
-0.0048648422,
-0.0555134825,
0.0035208964,
-0.0186602362,
0.0014979112,
0.004777207,
-0.0006957129,
-0.0210877843,
0.0171853546,
0.0142051736,
-0.0139420833,
-0.0574990883,
-0.0309714805,
0.0647317544,
-0.0056325556,
0.0150213903,
0.0266656112,
0.0105413608,
-0.0424293429,
-0.1171892658,
-0.035018716,
0.0260165613,
0.044010397,
0.0197107866,
-0.0207862854,
0.0273670871,
0.0163701847,
0.0061023673,
-0.0485119559,
-0.0719804391,
-0.04471571,
0.0182369575,
-0.0484838113,
-0.0455455892,
0.0354354493,
0.0162261147,
0.026433723,
-0.0410647057,
0.0048967134,
2.199725308e-34,
0.0803331658,
-0.0424443781,
-0.0118919564,
-0.0599815659,
0.0028841437,
-0.0309618749,
-0.0957134888,
-0.0418871529,
0.0493256673,
-0.0049401624,
0.0199556593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10490v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10490v4 | Abusing Images and Sounds for Indirect Instruction Injection in Multi-Modal LLMs | 2023-07-19T23:03:20 | 2023-10-03T17:03:10 | Eugene Bagdasaryan, Tsung-Yin Hsieh, Ben Nassi, Vitaly Shmatikov | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We demonstrate how images and sounds can be used for indirect prompt and
instruction injection in multi-modal LLMs. An attacker generates an adversarial
perturbation corresponding to the prompt and blends it into an image or audio
recording. When the user asks the (unmodified, benign) model about the
perturbed image or audio, the perturbation steers the model to output the
attacker-chosen text and/or make the subsequent dialog follow the attacker's
instruction. We illustrate this attack with several proof-of-concept examples
targeting LLaVa and PandaGPT. | [
0.0079622921,
0.039854642,
-0.0135676498,
0.0629204139,
-0.0188668221,
-0.0048290486,
0.0049925051,
0.0030747484,
0.0094619254,
-0.0429744013,
-0.0294782501,
0.030896211,
-0.0099733146,
0.0012262675,
0.0990143567,
-0.0362788998,
0.0616699606,
-0.0293982364,
-0.0583170764,
0.0202980973,
0.0079295281,
-0.0341710225,
-0.0370447673,
0.027898971,
-0.0299972612,
-0.0241382029,
-0.0897344947,
0.0838941708,
-0.0018853862,
0.0024896006,
-0.0418451689,
0.0047537079,
0.0008070571,
0.0315589197,
0.0000019338,
-0.033858858,
-0.0082060173,
0.0315862857,
-0.0323457867,
0.0212546531,
-0.0199021399,
0.0259071738,
-0.0488849804,
0.0330837145,
-0.0347437747,
0.0509303957,
0.0418125354,
0.0596886501,
0.1016638651,
0.0938227251,
-0.0016931593,
-0.0016934364,
0.0323655605,
-0.0158509146,
0.0668660328,
-0.0268643461,
-0.0165042523,
-0.0603130497,
0.0306294281,
0.0436207503,
0.0090306718,
0.0112209115,
0.0194957405,
-0.0086974474,
-0.0554315411,
0.0301884562,
0.0272475053,
-0.0134744775,
-0.0683674365,
0.0430620499,
-0.0144992769,
0.0415448397,
0.0204145443,
0.0208717622,
0.0315762982,
0.0091572003,
-0.0019807864,
-0.0073293908,
-0.0035046893,
-0.0268049277,
-0.0315915383,
-0.0313464552,
0.0258997548,
0.0067415242,
0.0134348338,
0.0053479704,
0.0393077657,
-0.0199868046,
-0.0159157179,
-0.0292313304,
0.0274011604,
-0.0528838746,
-0.0329076461,
0.0737308189,
-0.0264954679,
0.0030044457,
-0.0645738766,
-0.0156537145,
0.0162256341,
-0.0049203918,
0.0624334626,
0.0325163268,
-0.0693914369,
0.0329786725,
-0.0074411202,
0.0079668565,
-0.0582792759,
0.0650234595,
0.0011776346,
0.0464394093,
0.0143628279,
-0.0225950852,
0.0190772135,
0.021515714,
-0.0447200648,
0.001229907,
-0.0300933402,
0.0659876242,
-0.0235918239,
0.0504066944,
-0.0331111178,
0.0189199857,
-0.0202009883,
0.0146259684,
-0.0136876861,
-0.0427905656,
0.0179998726,
-0.0026314438,
0.0017203914,
-0.0668789372,
-0.0297154319,
0.0245152265,
-0.054175742,
0.0116047654,
-0.0146402596,
0.1617519706,
-0.0148647875,
-0.0066166101,
-0.0567950048,
-0.0781655163,
-0.0154300751,
-0.0168677717,
0.0198894646,
-0.0430707969,
-0.0138665391,
-0.0427929275,
-0.0145005435,
-0.0329593495,
0.0300085898,
0.0246336292,
0.0167626031,
0.09702079,
0.0436939374,
-0.0368875787,
0.029345626,
0.0696296394,
-0.0487839021,
0.0405240692,
0.0245133433,
0.0365281217,
0.0386395156,
-0.00954937,
0.0437398143,
0.04319245,
-0.0027903446,
0.0158211384,
0.0004841313,
-0.0255318284,
0.005914019,
-0.004361752,
-0.0371129699,
0.0514800586,
-0.00784727,
-0.0284229573,
0.0913690329,
0.0409927852,
-0.0325888507,
-0.0395174697,
0.0062690312,
-0.0316223167,
-0.0058094147,
0.053563457,
-0.0399093293,
0.0534095727,
-0.0684905201,
-0.0024159614,
0.0187223684,
0.012119785,
-0.0142654637,
-0.0240597352,
0.0165322423,
-0.0407795496,
-0.0105399964,
0.0034484239,
-0.0022476171,
0.0140536064,
-0.0251380783,
0.0250699595,
0.0001310074,
-0.0450086594,
-0.0467840321,
-0.0753092244,
-0.008884606,
0.0346126743,
0.0205954462,
-0.0399583988,
0.0345814899,
-0.0150582911,
-0.0008889067,
0.0230794437,
-0.0033106573,
0.0184821058,
0.0103416592,
-0.0151788788,
-0.0181060564,
-0.0397279412,
-0.0044355164,
0.0500108376,
-0.0284218658,
-0.0008980724,
-0.0075530685,
0.0425672904,
0.0576332211,
0.034050066,
0.0209800098,
-0.0908383504,
0.0158058405,
0.0545459241,
0.0295268688,
0.0181120187,
-0.0031484521,
0.0348310098,
0.0641850233,
-0.0004305436,
0.0253956337,
-0.0058970777,
-0.0305073038,
-0.0074479217,
0.0346092172,
-0.0444194712,
-0.0134931579,
0.0050124191,
-0.0538261272,
-0.0094254809,
0.0312577784,
-0.040233884,
0.0149197904,
-0.0270768944,
0.0147052398,
0.0361759253,
-0.0013136039,
-0.0295223985,
-0.0117901564,
-0.0243565124,
-0.0287923943,
0.0439600497,
0.0555491522,
-0.0061064293,
-0.0507365316,
-0.0387346931,
0.0233549885,
-0.0205590017,
0.0243390631,
-0.0471607707,
-0.0062885117,
-0.0246100686,
-0.0562303625,
-0.0344070531,
-0.0349837579,
-0.0048849094,
0.0129420646,
0.0259802528,
0.0003211525,
0.0057280748,
-0.0167756639,
-0.0343708768,
-0.0035707522,
0.0035666192,
0.002947368,
0.0189236086,
-0.0093815327,
-0.0021773272,
0.0018400057,
0.0055887979,
0.0116859768,
0.021866763,
-0.0564425029,
-0.0411504023,
-0.0541262738,
0.001557215,
-0.0171699096,
0.0168907586,
-0.0277453214,
-0.0316982418,
0.0635901839,
0.0297869481,
0.0274746045,
0.0845924839,
-0.0021465553,
0.0760660172,
0.0440102965,
0.0129081672,
-0.0384786576,
0.008455351,
0.0475585982,
-0.0140169049,
-0.0173253231,
-0.008205561,
0.012107593,
0.031067647,
0.0387214608,
0.0264334213,
-0.0004186457,
0.0491249524,
0.0190790426,
-0.0555944219,
0.0027475932,
-0.0092625273,
-0.0787179172,
0.0090718577,
-0.0085859122,
-0.0835295394,
0.0594173819,
-0.0689372867,
-0.0144808469,
0.054985363,
-0.0472414196,
0.0113061368,
0.0212038979,
-0.0323637985,
-0.0152531462,
0.0508305803,
-0.0171180498,
-0.0577323474,
-0.0239046998,
0.0387275442,
-0.0505809821,
0.0534361787,
-0.035912957,
-0.0416992158,
-0.0189910457,
-0.0250122119,
-0.0458847433,
-0.0392279401,
0.0144292219,
-0.0193016306,
-0.0120044155,
-0.0109651797,
-0.0135795278,
-0.0472500734,
0.0535377711,
-0.0491892137,
-0.0030761096,
-0.0148956878,
-0.0595583282,
0.0196714811,
0.0370299406,
-0.0040672389,
-0.0529395789,
-0.0057696071,
0.046613954,
0.0758650824,
0.0002978386,
-0.0326560289,
-0.0346936956,
0.0071313893,
-0.0048357835,
0.0314518325,
0.0170114655,
0.0461418033,
0.0664504245,
-0.0035793679,
0.0152577143,
0.0127592888,
0.0075311586,
-0.017843958,
0.012799737,
0.0265876241,
0.0187048595,
0.0131485322,
0.005481414,
-0.0944594741,
-0.0343206637,
0.0427067503,
0.0551961623,
-0.0110687297,
0.0235377438,
-0.0359329246,
-0.0789591968,
0.0237201825,
0.003194679,
0.0344802737,
0.006976618,
0.0205798298,
-0.0130134607,
0.0435826294,
0.0434907638,
-0.0157053545,
0.0169119891,
-0.0053054187,
0.0221932251,
0.0401300415,
-0.0035252527,
-0.0246023182,
0.0016101534,
0.0301318802,
0.0733437836,
-0.0130956024,
-0.0190993045,
-0.0386799276,
0.0377678797,
0.0025066307,
0.0254898649,
0.0153443795,
0.0254313163,
0.0142257586,
-0.023036588,
0.0028077716,
0.0310064405,
0.0294723883,
-0.0184918158,
0.0402870849,
0.0335858651,
-0.0330633596,
0.0153563097,
-0.0487894528,
-0.0024094989,
0.0421133526,
0.0134797506,
0.0153652029,
-0.0202680603,
-0.0101181865,
-0.094314076,
-0.0256023165,
0.0109862806,
-0.0686197653,
-0.0019193292,
0.0073328,
-0.0117439507,
-0.0535302646,
-0.0367667042,
-0.0254635382,
0.0425435156,
0.0331907421,
-0.0099889562,
-0.0217508115,
0.0162247568,
-0.0168180261,
-0.018160006,
-0.0007419608,
0.0577287972,
-0.0286830645,
-0.0113569368,
0.0231847968,
-0.0439746529,
0.0218798406,
0.0244522989,
-0.0522164628,
-0.072563991,
-0.0432527922,
0.0582560301,
0.0193671603,
0.0260282066,
-0.0115730045,
-0.0171220209,
0.0502448305,
0.057701271,
-0.0107807927,
0.0339797102,
0.08955504,
0.0229243096,
0.0053466684,
-0.0006205268,
-0.0351457223,
-0.0192362964,
0.0672850907,
-0.0165815651,
-0.0775256008,
-0.0531189889,
0.0057754787,
0.0187851712,
0.0323592946,
-0.0167147387,
0.0180990361,
0.0406445265,
0.0679660514,
-0.0178270247,
0.0155945364,
-0.0364510976,
-0.005546947,
-0.0285780597,
-0.0303784143,
0.0421612412,
-0.0249006227,
-0.004861637,
0.0026752856,
-0.0041217171,
0.0493712947,
0.0450061671,
0.0059575895,
-0.0007187629,
0.0324144103,
0.0015273491,
0.0756173208,
0.0129745314,
0.0213246383,
0.0304928888,
0.0754539296,
-0.0152317062,
0.0121158957,
0.0125952987,
0.0381118059,
-0.0657116473,
-0.008497498,
0.0308960881,
0.0488761887,
0.0373189896,
0.0273184739,
-0.0297217965,
0.0014212267,
0.0059124944,
-0.0065935981,
0.0300822426,
-0.0095329983,
-0.013230524,
0.0344875194,
-0.0072380551,
0.0226987805,
0.0041044033,
0.0312664546,
-0.0409250483,
0.0450289771,
0.0000015051,
0.0118655199,
-0.0592169575,
-0.0331469178,
0.0495299883,
0.0005571051,
-0.0037012859,
-0.0437622517,
-0.0250796434,
-0.0749589726,
-0.0212624203,
0.0081332661,
0.0121986652,
-0.0366877243,
0.0128867282,
-0.0018458371,
0.0399085842,
0.0461773984,
-0.0055064247,
0.0143794585,
0.0066484935,
-0.0663690045,
0.0246978886,
-5.72579882e-33,
-0.0117931217,
-0.0570975468,
-0.0087499758,
-0.0100842118,
0.0265561566,
0.0062932097,
-0.0077308952,
0.0259792786,
-0.0004915626,
-0.037546888,
-0.022686759,
-0.0214580856,
0.0159697905,
-0.0038426246,
-0.0175993703,
-0.0444809832,
-0.0229796302,
-0.0296010021,
-0.0105858948,
0.0081654293,
0.0414806232,
-0.0099319369,
-0.003390756,
-0.0809459463,
0.0525203347,
0.0082654059,
-0.0747831911,
-0.0142969182,
-0.0732022375,
0.0482663289,
-0.0003994599,
0.0116200419,
-0.0243718009,
0.0130254198,
-0.0168805812,
0.0823019817,
-0.0027974974,
-0.0502417907,
0.0083412416,
-0.0003172313,
-0.0329825357,
-0.061716225,
0.0115469387,
-0.0296959244,
-0.0028332355,
-0.004653722,
-0.0067697805,
0.006030811,
-0.0081422077,
-0.025569858,
-0.029184524,
-0.0183614325,
-0.009880905,
-0.0619766153,
0.001801319,
0.0106724873,
0.0084607936,
-0.0256915819,
-0.0468168966,
0.053838592,
0.0172948409,
-0.0088092992,
0.0445324108,
0.0020983305,
-0.023889685,
0.0514118038,
0.0243049134,
-0.032076098,
-0.0487539619,
-0.0156782977,
-0.020452043,
0.0620345771,
0.0824874938,
0.0519881435,
0.0040973178,
-0.0244438276,
-0.0297365543,
0.0372606367,
0.0389041565,
0.0145220868,
0.0038407785,
0.0256167427,
-0.0367494635,
0.021221254,
0.0017471988,
-0.0123587502,
-0.0311381258,
-0.05497602,
0.0325631052,
0.0112730926,
0.0139208771,
-0.0577098206,
0.0130433105,
-0.0243031736,
-0.0022273217,
-0.0455914885,
0.021731358,
-0.0226701684,
-0.0170609634,
-0.0393417962,
0.0222038459,
0.004941171,
0.0766582787,
-0.0558286272,
0.0375977121,
-0.0008164978,
-0.0024743651,
0.0523013882,
-0.0526044294,
-0.0171413496,
-0.0273729153,
0.0323991179,
0.0466972813,
-0.0070801177,
0.0203790851,
-0.0577806421,
-0.0311982725,
-0.0097705601,
-0.0270654727,
-0.0238765143,
-0.04566627,
0.0057073184,
-0.0459700562,
0.042323675,
-0.0428444482,
0.0392182842,
-0.0204481035,
0.017211495,
0.0267748535,
-0.0499452315,
-0.0020769674,
-0.0089713065,
2.768e-7,
-0.0267220438,
-0.0214071665,
0.0372478738,
0.0673773363,
0.0315490365,
0.0647993088,
-0.0535760969,
0.0503232926,
0.005442258,
-0.0722886398,
-0.01090845,
-0.0095552513,
0.0691227168,
-0.001812357,
-0.0577059984,
-0.0154358968,
-0.0105165439,
0.0038978208,
-0.0314048231,
0.0397290923,
0.089901112,
0.0785089284,
0.0022517687,
-0.020788772,
0.019748671,
-0.031734433,
0.0117416391,
-0.0299335402,
-0.0021086619,
-0.103297472,
0.0520153008,
-0.013657405,
-0.0046363818,
0.0235555936,
-0.0427440144,
-0.0712564886,
-0.0343735367,
0.0474129841,
-0.0000533873,
-0.0949144512,
-0.0416192338,
-0.0099856369,
-0.001943044,
0.0159897227,
0.0550882369,
0.0463881493,
-0.0243124701,
-0.0078974077,
0.0100463219,
-0.0418973342,
0.0219333936,
-0.0465892553,
-0.0040296316,
-0.0329156816,
0.0104564186,
0.0137947462,
-0.0035465988,
-0.0140520185,
-0.007188465,
-0.0269279461,
-0.0122180656,
-0.0736651123,
-0.0137192132,
0.0184533056,
0.0328471512,
-0.0236494951,
-0.0463188775,
2.364954126e-34,
-0.0229357723,
-0.0377724469,
0.0382192321,
0.0359773152,
0.0183970425,
0.0469092391,
0.025579771,
0.0105020991,
0.0422373675,
-0.0523280576,
-0.0440752283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10488v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10488v1 | SPRINT: A Unified Toolkit for Evaluating and Demystifying Zero-shot Neural Sparse Retrieval | 2023-07-19T22:48:02 | 2023-07-19T22:48:02 | Nandan Thakur, Kexin Wang, Iryna Gurevych, Jimmy Lin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Traditionally, sparse retrieval systems relied on lexical representations to
retrieve documents, such as BM25, dominated information retrieval tasks. With
the onset of pre-trained transformer models such as BERT, neural sparse
retrieval has led to a new paradigm within retrieval. Despite the success,
there has been limited software supporting different sparse retrievers running
in a unified, common environment. This hinders practitioners from fairly
comparing different sparse models and obtaining realistic evaluation results.
Another missing piece is, that a majority of prior work evaluates sparse
retrieval models on in-domain retrieval, i.e. on a single dataset: MS MARCO.
However, a key requirement in practical retrieval systems requires models that
can generalize well to unseen out-of-domain, i.e. zero-shot retrieval tasks. In
this work, we provide SPRINT, a unified Python toolkit based on Pyserini and
Lucene, supporting a common interface for evaluating neural sparse retrieval.
The toolkit currently includes five built-in models: uniCOIL, DeepImpact,
SPARTA, TILDEv2 and SPLADEv2. Users can also easily add customized models by
defining their term weighting method. Using our toolkit, we establish strong
and reproducible zero-shot sparse retrieval baselines across the
well-acknowledged benchmark, BEIR. Our results demonstrate that SPLADEv2
achieves the best average score of 0.470 nDCG@10 on BEIR amongst all neural
sparse retrievers. In this work, we further uncover the reasons behind its
performance gain. We show that SPLADEv2 produces sparse representations with a
majority of tokens outside of the original query and document which is often
crucial for its performance gains, i.e. a limitation among its other sparse
counterparts. We provide our SPRINT toolkit, models, and data used in our
experiments publicly here at https://github.com/thakur-nandan/sprint. | [
0.0032735518,
-0.0162260085,
0.0347099975,
0.005991383,
-0.0077044098,
-0.0099660158,
0.0265104007,
0.0595048368,
-0.0484938323,
-0.0477944873,
-0.0495443866,
-0.0496033616,
-0.0329069607,
0.0368824191,
0.0059090788,
-0.0110095516,
0.0331554227,
0.0439187512,
-0.0311761238,
0.037726339,
-0.0083020879,
-0.0087900013,
-0.0097530978,
0.0349968299,
-0.0162092876,
0.0213034358,
-0.0150417676,
0.0490943529,
-0.0058382545,
-0.0620419011,
0.0290050618,
0.0333279781,
0.0489029475,
0.0854158401,
0.0000019262,
-0.0423908345,
-0.0217845142,
0.0189829785,
-0.0302758757,
0.0144619625,
0.0457481965,
0.0112320613,
0.0625254288,
-0.0315376408,
-0.0104758814,
-0.05436299,
0.0483468398,
0.0501675531,
0.0265785065,
0.0710268319,
-0.0162716862,
-0.0009952313,
0.0160402767,
-0.0281375125,
0.0325232744,
-0.0524027832,
0.0180807728,
-0.0880248025,
0.0331207551,
0.0513629988,
0.0252442546,
0.029296305,
-0.012972408,
0.0116652464,
0.0546128675,
0.0327458978,
-0.1092865095,
-0.0172279552,
0.0278775096,
0.0327584073,
0.0293466095,
-0.0441491716,
-0.0046081403,
0.062349949,
-0.0072459774,
0.004372573,
-0.0824364051,
-0.0075379647,
0.0228685476,
-0.007724606,
-0.0620316565,
0.0131576732,
0.0282400437,
0.0192443859,
-0.0285087228,
0.0441603623,
0.0168087929,
-0.0243335012,
-0.0182736944,
0.0037558575,
-0.018243365,
0.0000791741,
0.0243280921,
0.0196268018,
0.0006593055,
-0.0295573175,
0.0053799683,
-0.0419693738,
0.0502066538,
-0.0239493847,
0.0503452569,
0.0358559825,
-0.0422653668,
0.0604184009,
-0.0441376083,
0.0252930485,
0.0002674629,
0.0345236771,
-0.0148645444,
-0.0208372213,
-0.0348422825,
-0.0204617102,
-0.0329702236,
0.0903091952,
0.010760719,
-0.0232876707,
0.0116309132,
-0.0101887118,
-0.011523257,
-0.0426061265,
-0.0353432521,
0.0491399541,
-0.0430040546,
0.001000211,
-0.0190963801,
0.0579684675,
-0.0264040604,
0.0039278269,
0.0293292422,
-0.021699043,
-0.0471289977,
0.0036786837,
0.0217879731,
-0.0419703089,
0.029605804,
0.0046567321,
-0.0017275641,
-0.0596982017,
0.0041824086,
-0.011048656,
0.0215308107,
-0.0421321839,
0.0086849928,
-0.0690243542,
-0.013918506,
0.0154627087,
0.0092864092,
-0.0404174291,
-0.0044947513,
0.0469403006,
-0.0312825069,
0.0231554732,
-0.0060092113,
-0.0306088086,
0.0007075274,
0.0261891503,
0.0362338573,
0.0581792332,
-0.0495681837,
0.0739332214,
0.0441643074,
0.0347942486,
-0.0040243501,
-0.0237290282,
0.0498389788,
0.0177273732,
-0.0247100834,
0.0169404428,
-0.0137776649,
0.0011928821,
0.0081922887,
0.0196121931,
-0.0740595162,
-0.0472484827,
0.0104540763,
0.0891381875,
0.0231057126,
-0.0405322947,
0.017178325,
-0.0063523743,
-0.0335029699,
-0.0212587789,
-0.0112148337,
0.0351821817,
-0.0345981233,
-0.0076707979,
0.0389791839,
-0.0095992992,
-0.0445607454,
-0.0045433971,
-0.0036248434,
0.0188123751,
-0.0365999043,
0.004885565,
0.0617214367,
-0.0380909145,
-0.0316437706,
0.095359154,
0.0219970308,
-0.0618382283,
-0.0273497794,
-0.0347357653,
-0.0001867818,
0.0149295824,
0.0655992702,
-0.0609422028,
-0.0393735804,
0.0157334022,
-0.0164703559,
0.0186719093,
-0.0337203741,
-0.00465253,
0.0301486831,
-0.0699375942,
-0.034053579,
-0.0382086933,
0.0398818627,
0.0276612621,
-0.0035635976,
0.0153895365,
0.0617799982,
-0.0514791496,
0.026395414,
0.0252638943,
0.0025303348,
-0.0631469414,
0.006361932,
-0.0087805483,
-0.0102788117,
0.0212602783,
-0.0304706339,
0.0226133335,
0.0700678751,
-0.0048987442,
0.0004665627,
-0.0804401636,
-0.0347842723,
-0.0065330421,
0.0200697538,
-0.0408925526,
0.0509569272,
0.0554294847,
-0.0056896401,
-0.0155073991,
0.0025840094,
0.0241466872,
-0.0075221355,
-0.0549968928,
0.0087575046,
-0.0357525572,
0.0226826798,
-0.0378135219,
0.0330513828,
0.0186273996,
0.0466490649,
-0.0231357999,
-0.0194018055,
0.0513313524,
-0.0772836655,
-0.0792334899,
0.0011589482,
-0.0346542113,
0.0313029736,
0.0383319221,
-0.0023899067,
-0.0129666431,
0.0407217219,
-0.1089236587,
0.0220092759,
-0.0370466672,
-0.027093472,
0.0000765224,
0.0216265414,
0.0082173236,
-0.0226300471,
-0.0093569029,
-0.0160947517,
-0.0114227692,
0.0371036679,
0.0093992669,
0.0184685662,
0.010278957,
-0.0437121093,
-0.0647447333,
0.0079797739,
0.0513005741,
-0.0301612765,
-0.029027082,
0.0246197954,
0.0712933689,
-0.0293447375,
0.0032959108,
-0.0146175204,
-0.0051699537,
0.0375074223,
-0.0752464235,
-0.0297072828,
0.0410464741,
-0.0152628897,
0.0120678768,
0.0083979182,
0.0075679035,
-0.0741103664,
0.0124055631,
-0.0181667581,
0.0099463547,
0.0203654338,
0.015482164,
0.0280757472,
0.018810207,
-0.0339876227,
-0.0087158475,
-0.0154728936,
-0.0209420919,
0.025284078,
-0.0121213095,
-0.0872552246,
0.0403959192,
0.0221140832,
0.0393495597,
-0.0362733416,
-0.0250393581,
0.0342704095,
-0.0145323975,
-0.0061878529,
0.0054135085,
-0.0087883472,
-0.0618189946,
0.0445404835,
-0.0158024691,
-0.0107193431,
-0.0152411051,
-0.0228578057,
-0.0070039933,
-0.0128311198,
-0.0217070635,
-0.0304606892,
0.0425011516,
0.0540628284,
0.0540223084,
-0.0148219559,
-0.0307075679,
-0.0026793431,
-0.0379165523,
0.0054636351,
0.0626793653,
-0.0040699374,
-0.0089576775,
-0.0812455565,
0.0089311516,
0.0045434278,
0.0444608741,
-0.0196758751,
0.0020296655,
0.0243581831,
0.0119007919,
0.0241841152,
-0.0340408981,
-0.0270544868,
0.0019470943,
-0.0263995454,
0.0385448076,
0.0267085973,
-0.0167972706,
-0.0211235825,
-0.0091450932,
0.0528920852,
-0.0245742369,
-0.0181245841,
-0.0081272312,
0.0066872276,
-0.031565398,
-0.0431856066,
0.074815914,
0.021721743,
-0.0763929263,
-0.0314875692,
-0.0700757876,
0.028475197,
0.0610546954,
0.0209585298,
-0.0745546892,
-0.0235372931,
-0.0092574656,
0.0430021025,
0.0103069423,
-0.0283054132,
0.0535075217,
-0.1090255827,
0.0379178971,
-0.0195927955,
0.021313116,
-0.0013120507,
-0.077056177,
0.0184022039,
-0.003448244,
-0.0035319652,
0.0270102397,
-0.0038839916,
-0.0303961188,
0.0177749675,
0.0614670403,
-0.0388316251,
0.0122396648,
-0.0362507701,
-0.0212368742,
0.0329202451,
0.01099905,
-0.0128395548,
-0.0293221939,
0.0104396502,
0.0031547255,
-0.0200499501,
-0.0358732231,
0.0835083127,
-0.0200915653,
-0.0099835293,
-0.0070334687,
-0.0454099961,
-0.0063147196,
0.0137111042,
-0.0520382859,
0.0450066179,
-0.0243827086,
0.0418330468,
-0.0590186007,
-0.0333439484,
-0.0361644477,
0.0500374995,
0.0086354567,
0.0574439541,
-0.0508058332,
-0.0105315149,
-0.00834384,
-0.0420859195,
-0.0172064137,
0.0087152598,
-0.0195040032,
-0.0374595411,
-0.0472218879,
-0.027897425,
0.0252692346,
0.0638368502,
-0.0568869077,
0.0033630142,
-0.0773890838,
-0.0102843884,
-0.0576272644,
0.0427414328,
-0.0036182043,
-0.0043442855,
-0.0686018243,
0.008368439,
0.0404916406,
-0.0224106852,
-0.0164051633,
-0.0394336283,
-0.0273749512,
-0.0185077041,
0.0035755571,
0.0284870844,
0.0143303815,
-0.0085320072,
-0.0188102666,
-0.0519964583,
0.1146763936,
0.1095910072,
-0.0130253825,
-0.0044953777,
0.0054548746,
-0.049706582,
-0.0299487561,
0.008953942,
-0.0567235313,
0.03791219,
-0.0167210307,
0.055314377,
-0.0012265218,
0.0160804931,
0.026023278,
0.0040932857,
0.0671896562,
0.0358354561,
0.0081570502,
-0.0130448304,
-0.004440669,
-0.0399859957,
-0.0084093213,
-0.0066517997,
-0.0038279861,
0.0451972522,
-0.0167221799,
0.0027259986,
0.0419188701,
-0.0245084818,
0.096743986,
-0.0642200038,
0.0198016558,
0.0159273874,
-0.0152868163,
-0.0173139293,
0.0085203676,
-0.0545549542,
0.0055859238,
-0.0078279031,
0.0543363765,
-0.0431687422,
0.013466619,
0.0146218399,
0.0092796618,
-0.0458530001,
0.0325665064,
-0.0797391757,
0.0137661593,
-0.0021328512,
0.0049300995,
0.0484562553,
-0.0371320844,
-0.0032388044,
0.0139895147,
-0.0197420456,
-0.0367939547,
-0.0283665471,
-0.0044574458,
0.0084420033,
-0.0169095956,
0.0531516448,
0.0293627325,
0.0306551382,
0.0747104138,
0.0186591242,
0.032511387,
-0.0088755516,
-0.0358871035,
-0.0082955388,
0.0170637202,
0.082136564,
0.0671626106,
-0.0137853865,
-0.0235809702,
0.0015340635,
-0.0262345113,
0.0550240129,
-0.023731418,
-0.0233002286,
-0.0226896144,
0.0495959446,
0.0777843371,
0.0207147598,
0.0110558895,
-0.0167298578,
-0.0015922423,
0.0004269957,
-0.0118682487,
-0.0431597047,
-6.979660073e-33,
-0.0204118583,
0.0189865492,
0.0229360722,
-0.035092622,
-0.0082936417,
0.0323961712,
-0.0154940095,
-0.0049607065,
-0.0380071551,
0.0243307296,
-0.0244687572,
0.002738992,
0.003507863,
0.0144710504,
0.0025474653,
-0.0249526016,
0.0481437407,
0.0194541682,
-0.0071316301,
-0.0080882777,
0.07723362,
0.0812993199,
0.0346078835,
-0.0260618329,
0.0033881778,
-0.0115874372,
0.0307983216,
0.0062146122,
0.0443656705,
0.0560135283,
0.0045689256,
0.0288441218,
0.0438175797,
-0.0131686674,
0.0230698157,
-0.0015943756,
-0.072055392,
-0.0316787697,
-0.0164827853,
-0.0326724127,
0.0143580353,
-0.0234707817,
0.0426700413,
-0.0204725079,
-0.0335371271,
-0.0274556354,
0.022629153,
0.0180519633,
-0.0725828558,
-0.0556305684,
-0.0492090099,
0.016008677,
0.0167826284,
-0.034855742,
0.0168349948,
0.0257268641,
-0.0131257409,
0.0500639528,
-0.0505653955,
-0.0086505404,
-0.067379348,
0.0676189139,
0.0111487079,
0.0400252715,
-0.0092015136,
0.0583247729,
0.0268516783,
0.0106258076,
-0.0253307354,
-0.0103410669,
0.0856399536,
0.0427167155,
0.0251203477,
0.0246548206,
0.067629911,
-0.0118004568,
-0.0609041564,
0.0366716981,
-0.0008065439,
0.0750564113,
0.04798235,
0.0478141755,
-0.0540868528,
-0.0217576325,
-0.0019748716,
-0.0172621123,
-0.0640425235,
-0.02096726,
0.0126284929,
0.0337432213,
-0.0032630765,
0.0417058282,
0.0754042715,
-0.0192578714,
0.0089785019,
0.0277615134,
0.0185529329,
0.015431677,
-0.0040794606,
-0.0028191716,
-0.0229569767,
-0.0115202013,
0.0326389037,
0.0437014885,
-0.0145019004,
-0.0092241,
0.0348280594,
-0.0165239647,
-0.0180094559,
-0.0513107143,
-0.0157101396,
-0.0321874395,
-0.0167170148,
0.0562586971,
-0.0117874546,
0.0325593464,
0.0084860269,
0.064401634,
0.0055940677,
0.0057428661,
-0.0076901256,
-0.0428110734,
0.0281315986,
-0.0320585258,
-0.0018183924,
0.035681732,
-0.0474799722,
0.0229966827,
0.0249548536,
-0.0288510825,
-0.0018863416,
0.0174155626,
2.812e-7,
0.0354452357,
0.0329635739,
-0.0108932257,
-0.0236432124,
-0.0309875198,
0.0205391925,
-0.0228195991,
0.0274785645,
0.008250149,
-0.0233739242,
-0.0044209864,
0.0284681972,
0.0148448618,
0.0121074896,
-0.0801614746,
-0.0308560636,
-0.0430534109,
-0.0468693003,
-0.0470108092,
-0.0156001011,
0.0341237038,
0.0885919258,
-0.0052664904,
-0.0089529315,
0.0363404639,
-0.0691368133,
0.0549765863,
0.0125942295,
-0.0013167433,
-0.0067370068,
0.0439814813,
0.0324473754,
0.0422863327,
-0.0451514609,
0.0181673989,
0.0534985326,
0.0466496199,
0.019339053,
-0.0673238188,
-0.0484552495,
0.013143735,
-0.0100142667,
0.0129403705,
-0.0350704901,
0.0569434687,
-0.0113735041,
-0.0264291242,
-0.0062976358,
-0.0543540269,
0.0384045504,
0.0255299155,
0.0023124102,
-0.0167152323,
0.0127039403,
0.0126697132,
-0.010998955,
-0.025362229,
-0.0747844204,
0.0272396337,
0.0156727377,
-0.0347977728,
0.0154965203,
-0.0296592824,
-0.0173629336,
-0.0015112062,
-0.03341645,
0.0010466228,
2.550035022e-34,
0.0490897,
0.0200457517,
-0.0017371346,
0.0231006574,
0.0128565533,
-0.0173965041,
-0.0352974087,
0.0195776504,
-0.0066865417,
-0.0857062787,
0.0020450279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10485v2 | FinGPT: Democratizing Internet-scale Data for Financial Large Language Models | 2023-07-19T22:43:57 | 2023-11-14T16:34:00 | Xiao-Yang Liu, Guoxuan Wang, Hongyang Yang, Daochen Zha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.GN | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in
understanding and generating human-like texts, which may potentially
revolutionize the finance industry. However, existing LLMs often fall short in
the financial field, which is mainly attributed to the disparities between
general text data and financial text data. Unfortunately, there is only a
limited number of financial text datasets available, and BloombergGPT, the
first financial LLM (FinLLM), is close-sourced (only the training logs were
released). In light of this, we aim to democratize Internet-scale financial
data for LLMs, which is an open challenge due to diverse data sources, low
signal-to-noise ratio, and high time-validity. To address the challenges, we
introduce an open-sourced and data-centric framework, Financial Generative
Pre-trained Transformer (FinGPT), that automates the collection and curation of
real-time financial data from 34 diverse sources on the Internet, providing
researchers and practitioners with accessible and transparent resources to
develop their FinLLMs. Additionally, we propose a simple yet effective strategy
for fine-tuning FinLLM using the inherent feedback from the market, dubbed
Reinforcement Learning with Stock Prices (RLSP). We also adopt the Low-rank
Adaptation (LoRA, QLoRA) method that enables users to customize their own
FinLLMs from general-purpose LLMs at a low cost. Finally, we showcase several
FinGPT applications, including robo-advisor, sentiment analysis for algorithmic
trading, and low-code development. FinGPT aims to democratize FinLLMs,
stimulate innovation, and unlock new opportunities in open finance. The codes
have been open-sourced. | [
0.0096472939,
0.0892252401,
-0.0150946993,
-0.0130097177,
0.0315812007,
0.0136564402,
0.0247709155,
0.0482087061,
-0.0078943074,
-0.0129334535,
-0.053380657,
-0.008571622,
-0.0474429503,
0.0865685493,
0.0289049391,
-0.0407774746,
-0.0031583915,
-0.0230529644,
0.0382044315,
-0.0279234219,
0.0293942727,
0.0002595101,
0.0350324512,
0.0163581092,
0.0246053059,
0.0024125173,
-0.0310739744,
0.0072732968,
-0.0038278271,
-0.019407453,
-0.0061876089,
0.0111616757,
0.0135741169,
0.0690586641,
0.0000021102,
-0.0290606655,
-0.0429141,
-0.0061201258,
-0.0107394587,
-0.0333549418,
0.0459624082,
-0.0406949446,
0.021557169,
0.032947734,
-0.0870826691,
0.0164695699,
0.0657930598,
0.0722933114,
0.075775139,
0.1090770811,
-0.0136593543,
-0.031457223,
0.0156827588,
-0.0654343218,
0.0165379047,
-0.0456854552,
0.0330995023,
0.0155081414,
-0.0358124785,
0.0027402632,
-0.0304555278,
0.0339813046,
-0.0111287637,
0.0105994577,
0.0216573942,
-0.0143875387,
-0.0403403081,
-0.0137639577,
-0.0627571568,
0.0706560016,
-0.0146466941,
0.0142933726,
0.0485124215,
-0.0192928892,
-0.0264636688,
0.0155720105,
-0.0495560057,
0.0730848536,
0.0102695068,
0.0279973336,
0.0100418404,
-0.0156180961,
0.0142399687,
-0.0094372258,
-0.0343887024,
0.0337419659,
-0.0281529315,
-0.0235911626,
0.0302301254,
0.0156612713,
-0.0002847796,
-0.0425019674,
0.0060327174,
0.0155248381,
-0.0078649186,
-0.003355565,
-0.0199665017,
-0.0559805892,
-0.0068960148,
-0.0530788116,
0.032647498,
0.0191536061,
0.0051510837,
0.0309330262,
-0.044011306,
0.000472728,
-0.0006799141,
0.0113105681,
0.0051195016,
0.0148456087,
-0.048396986,
-0.0070644384,
-0.0396998487,
0.0510569513,
-0.0451717079,
-0.0226913858,
-0.0731534585,
0.0261051431,
-0.0156751759,
0.0353028663,
0.0175532363,
-0.013374988,
-0.0319907703,
-0.0128608877,
-0.0334555544,
-0.0146174282,
-0.0164689068,
0.0388346426,
0.002185575,
-0.0257972442,
0.0186058879,
0.0152857034,
-0.0211906992,
0.0062652929,
0.0366734862,
0.1113651767,
0.0462377518,
-0.0170187932,
-0.0398191996,
-0.0662215501,
0.0235081147,
-0.0044903904,
-0.0218596701,
-0.0376439504,
0.0028118805,
-0.0239304248,
-0.0018578217,
0.0193536989,
0.0075506587,
0.0008043608,
-0.0296907388,
0.0769180804,
-0.0156879555,
-0.0141642122,
-0.0014649275,
-0.063115105,
0.0134619363,
0.066547662,
0.0083840042,
0.0304457135,
0.0681399405,
0.0026073398,
-0.005137647,
0.0518172942,
0.028710762,
-0.0296708904,
0.0109639475,
0.0259386729,
0.0120991515,
-0.0038907381,
0.0641200915,
0.0197871905,
-0.0248810779,
0.0044393856,
0.0785122216,
0.0402862579,
0.0730123296,
0.0280681346,
0.0041778069,
0.053906139,
0.0104132323,
-0.0689181611,
-0.0086859539,
0.0268152729,
-0.0291358698,
0.031797301,
-0.0126147242,
0.0671531931,
-0.0358325988,
-0.0291556735,
0.0218590572,
-0.0312806591,
-0.0208352301,
0.008179253,
0.0272408519,
-0.0277610049,
-0.0432997942,
0.0161472857,
0.0489490703,
-0.0130318739,
-0.0049086711,
-0.0446909927,
0.05642315,
0.0676484257,
0.0087007899,
-0.0284577161,
0.0432698093,
-0.0514569581,
-0.0190161094,
0.0645289868,
0.0200668089,
-0.0007638067,
-0.0500649549,
-0.0472419336,
-0.0314792171,
0.0518753082,
0.0006912215,
0.028824795,
-0.0152542889,
0.0095541319,
-0.0258124694,
0.0094929747,
-0.040094614,
0.0176740754,
-0.0014869104,
-0.0504381359,
0.0187974423,
-0.032889653,
0.0103857145,
0.0277358163,
0.001142944,
-0.0143814487,
0.0058723586,
0.0065703588,
-0.0490097739,
0.0188355763,
-0.0441578664,
0.0184204485,
0.0044787205,
-0.0298902206,
0.005729408,
0.0334308408,
-0.0659951344,
-0.021269748,
-0.0096767675,
-0.014167699,
0.0249730423,
-0.0382097363,
-0.0410580523,
0.0296878107,
0.0295929257,
0.0019462586,
0.0325693339,
0.0094524082,
0.01200369,
-0.0198966805,
0.0186557937,
-0.0035589926,
-0.0491489731,
0.0411078259,
0.0159914885,
-0.021101458,
0.0574222766,
0.0427648351,
0.0417924225,
0.0099097854,
-0.0249038227,
-0.0617715903,
-0.0250419416,
-0.0200172234,
0.0257492438,
0.02714229,
0.0067396159,
-0.0185445473,
-0.0295856148,
-0.0455768704,
0.0315119587,
-0.0033298603,
-0.0156120462,
0.0728785545,
-0.0018774265,
-0.0005961561,
-0.0580416694,
-0.0197506528,
0.0145564675,
0.0250026062,
0.049917981,
0.0177350808,
-0.0321970209,
-0.0370392315,
-0.0134268375,
0.0320842527,
-0.0055870442,
0.0227792617,
0.0028552464,
-0.0323884785,
0.0151050603,
0.0485047959,
0.0437792912,
0.0358867459,
-0.0179966874,
0.0118815443,
-0.0551318675,
0.0140985912,
-0.031887874,
-0.030492818,
-0.0429309495,
0.0178934708,
0.0563703813,
0.0579837859,
-0.0290734712,
-0.0104810363,
-0.0835538208,
0.0517548174,
0.0225872658,
0.0025786129,
-0.0488699041,
0.0660897642,
-0.0294205826,
0.0415921509,
0.028330639,
-0.0434337705,
0.0368835926,
0.0073789717,
-0.0137427188,
-0.0156091033,
-0.0521803126,
-0.0779914781,
0.0246112309,
-0.0199634451,
0.0285237134,
-0.0274392068,
-0.0148785291,
-0.0310060866,
-0.000170834,
0.0433555767,
-0.0463216491,
0.0253543612,
-0.0119006932,
0.0158095863,
-0.0072363457,
-0.0455188863,
-0.0080255074,
-0.0693898126,
-0.0561395697,
-0.0010876051,
0.0496305712,
-0.0800359026,
-0.0378136039,
0.0127732428,
0.0036025424,
0.0105499476,
-0.0031169739,
-0.0515126213,
0.0200790986,
0.0165522806,
0.078508988,
-0.0117595429,
0.0184335429,
-0.0362399481,
0.0451137982,
0.022267716,
0.0524159223,
-0.0240086652,
-0.00788798,
0.0013371311,
-0.0018302741,
-0.0491691306,
0.0330986343,
0.0211026687,
-0.016519906,
-0.0268671792,
0.0146803521,
0.0926256776,
-0.0118509689,
-0.0324505568,
0.0007620662,
0.0000279415,
0.0298743099,
-0.0310370121,
0.0502594151,
-0.1243111864,
-0.0112777622,
-0.0177011415,
0.0630633831,
0.0143868513,
-0.0548287407,
-0.0180295818,
-0.1272856891,
0.0540617891,
-0.014878165,
-0.0211357549,
-0.0243059769,
-0.0690984875,
-0.0224460699,
-0.0645182058,
0.0236243941,
0.0320900045,
-0.0413754247,
0.0466211736,
0.0022240509,
-0.0636794567,
-0.0065056914,
-0.0142028444,
-0.0203939416,
0.0051008621,
0.028620109,
0.0016460276,
-0.0269888863,
-0.0078710821,
-0.071926415,
0.0093200272,
-0.0147621874,
-0.0211798307,
0.0438679829,
-0.0196665134,
-0.0385649092,
-0.0140491221,
0.0602047555,
-0.0063473042,
0.0440771803,
0.0096785827,
-0.0048057381,
-0.0000838003,
-0.0408443175,
-0.0026950259,
0.0180334374,
0.0176285654,
0.0470631421,
0.0000044374,
-0.0746256188,
-0.0388592519,
-0.0534240156,
-0.0075784815,
-0.053672649,
-0.042506367,
-0.0231005922,
-0.0119240517,
0.0048306743,
-0.1065317169,
-0.0335970297,
0.0022860761,
0.0285932496,
0.0058594062,
-0.0055682207,
0.062546052,
-0.0140403435,
-0.0532240942,
0.0162046012,
-0.0542412288,
0.0023033274,
-0.0660500228,
-0.0044558207,
0.0271389838,
-0.0525349565,
-0.0366575606,
0.0485599451,
-0.0565194748,
-0.0321592279,
0.0269980878,
0.0250708424,
0.0245496053,
-0.0071289884,
0.0109761087,
0.0300856978,
0.0532999858,
0.0807743371,
-0.0584839135,
-0.01377708,
0.0608139224,
0.0381778032,
-0.0040573692,
0.0338268802,
-0.0628052354,
0.0311454125,
-0.0350776389,
-0.0015929645,
-0.0335507169,
0.0205372442,
-0.0001320728,
0.0090887612,
0.0532054752,
0.0274128281,
-0.0269156452,
-0.0189457759,
-0.0326052979,
0.0084635569,
0.0084306672,
-0.0451775044,
-0.0218452606,
0.0386127234,
-0.0174802765,
-0.0091867642,
0.0385242961,
0.0159212723,
-0.0424805805,
-0.0301743411,
-0.0027304706,
-0.013202494,
0.0316778682,
0.0395470373,
-0.0200742967,
0.0273438096,
0.0154097173,
0.050960239,
0.0112027805,
0.0041344133,
0.008501038,
0.0203489661,
0.0133241033,
0.0203847662,
-0.0088264225,
-0.0451099165,
-0.0797609016,
-0.0176822711,
0.0214686189,
0.0212627482,
0.0085802572,
0.0457071289,
-0.0525992326,
0.0206170399,
0.0138602629,
0.0101654408,
-0.0247809123,
-0.0096639339,
0.0152846584,
-0.0131769022,
-0.0634132847,
-0.0253302399,
0.1110136509,
0.0156581178,
0.024116002,
-0.0378086194,
0.0099062221,
-0.0386868492,
-0.0177604016,
0.0489417017,
-0.0117593706,
-0.0128528494,
-0.0290392563,
-0.0289917905,
-0.0399866514,
0.0292087812,
0.0097154053,
-0.0064686332,
-0.001878484,
0.0457358807,
0.023185309,
-0.0172208473,
0.0586436279,
-0.0085310824,
0.0209398903,
-0.0197660122,
-0.0307322629,
-0.0447226539,
-6.794127392e-33,
-0.0221801605,
-0.0116174147,
0.0330804251,
0.0403151363,
0.0081382114,
0.0108700739,
-0.0210396741,
-0.0140121058,
0.0357770361,
0.0075822398,
0.001370738,
0.0250583906,
0.014225102,
0.0426689312,
0.033076562,
0.0094545567,
0.0472580567,
-0.0425441749,
-0.0183255933,
0.0226522461,
0.0302918702,
0.0627349615,
0.0323334523,
-0.073867619,
0.0186337903,
-0.0005755255,
-0.0651937351,
-0.013127517,
0.0499993823,
0.0463160053,
-0.0011057135,
0.0562464111,
-0.0063644866,
-0.0734707639,
-0.0310954805,
-0.0062383655,
-0.0386403017,
-0.0401128344,
-0.0135129187,
0.0302184131,
-0.0047275778,
0.0146556217,
0.0620237626,
-0.029501291,
-0.0044678678,
0.0023352313,
0.024956055,
0.0009542003,
0.0312357098,
-0.0666105524,
-0.0525576398,
0.0238071512,
0.0104289725,
0.0525280386,
0.03577834,
0.0706402808,
0.0162967294,
0.0000544298,
-0.0330981165,
0.0502149872,
0.0068646735,
-0.0036075397,
0.0008659209,
0.0371657871,
0.0016097444,
0.0540155508,
-0.0036750264,
0.0096798111,
0.0203329939,
0.0321426354,
0.0142492345,
0.0740505308,
0.0428911336,
0.0581824072,
0.0157154184,
-0.0303206351,
-0.0304866359,
0.0226996746,
0.0091070337,
-0.0032127395,
0.0133660194,
0.019790113,
-0.0142750461,
-0.0187625326,
0.0006471403,
-0.0127174892,
-0.0098075476,
-0.0201008469,
0.0165460855,
0.0394620784,
-0.0031355433,
-0.0059654652,
-0.0089002419,
-0.0668930411,
-0.0778055191,
-0.012309785,
-0.0047690249,
0.006035591,
0.0072442535,
-0.0353369564,
-0.0438415632,
-0.057436917,
-0.001018123,
-0.0197067969,
-0.0238776151,
-0.0075096623,
0.0227200482,
0.0340103023,
-0.0700667202,
-0.0113228196,
0.0184505656,
0.0460526086,
0.048446089,
0.0246773772,
0.0045545907,
0.0094863372,
-0.0140168015,
0.0301890727,
-0.002791998,
0.0179872997,
-0.0124363098,
-0.0292211361,
-0.0103583401,
0.0277303159,
-0.0025959455,
0.0043355175,
-0.0265915021,
0.0652623326,
0.0441007651,
-0.0640215054,
-0.0193259586,
0.0274413396,
2.917e-7,
0.0323096029,
0.092810452,
-0.0006540021,
0.0113308402,
0.0213716403,
0.0507130846,
-0.0242384635,
0.0319428034,
-0.0107638044,
0.0219697673,
0.0244603772,
0.0223336127,
0.0644122586,
0.0077013923,
-0.0848198831,
-0.083527036,
-0.0852835253,
0.0168214496,
-0.0850272924,
0.0178118106,
-0.0042622457,
0.0740968511,
0.004265463,
-0.0199841522,
0.0325382836,
-0.0543700755,
0.0563238263,
-0.0636183098,
-0.019493863,
-0.0045053037,
0.0295604449,
0.0371895246,
-0.0181591511,
-0.0255501978,
-0.019199172,
0.0161440261,
-0.00499633,
0.0341523401,
0.0213262141,
0.0251634438,
0.0146689313,
-0.0081708515,
-0.0154340798,
-0.051348377,
0.0358193703,
-0.0913425833,
-0.0146215977,
-0.0570494793,
-0.053538654,
-0.022408329,
0.03951836,
-0.016561104,
-0.0049950425,
0.013038883,
0.0165747665,
-0.0108851213,
0.0026161415,
-0.0455457903,
-0.0076274886,
0.0148273576,
-0.031783592,
0.015070078,
-0.064340122,
0.0360925123,
0.0207415503,
-0.0362560712,
0.0476568975,
2.670645794e-34,
0.0727301911,
-0.015875021,
-0.0259305332,
0.0076637417,
0.0413568132,
0.0149669237,
0.0107748965,
0.038294822,
0.0123699782,
-0.0968511477,
-0.0094952742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10476v1 | What can we learn from Data Leakage and Unlearning for Law? | 2023-07-19T22:14:58 | 2023-07-19T22:14:58 | Jaydeep Borkar | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have a privacy concern because they memorize
training data (including personally identifiable information (PII) like emails
and phone numbers) and leak it during inference. A company can train an LLM on
its domain-customized data which can potentially also include their users' PII.
In order to comply with privacy laws such as the "right to be forgotten", the
data points of users that are most vulnerable to extraction could be deleted.
We find that once the most vulnerable points are deleted, a new set of points
become vulnerable to extraction. So far, little attention has been given to
understanding memorization for fine-tuned models. In this work, we also show
that not only do fine-tuned models leak their training data but they also leak
the pre-training data (and PII) memorized during the pre-training phase. The
property of new data points becoming vulnerable to extraction after unlearning
and leakage of pre-training data through fine-tuned models can pose significant
privacy and legal concerns for companies that use LLMs to offer services. We
hope this work will start an interdisciplinary discussion within AI and law
communities regarding the need for policies to tackle these issues. | [
0.0457672328,
0.0934886485,
-0.0469626337,
0.0438205302,
-0.0649328083,
0.0155886328,
0.0604269691,
0.0100042811,
0.0239242315,
-0.0373045206,
-0.0224957336,
-0.0082943887,
-0.0150015214,
-0.0013211719,
0.0043323748,
-0.0041968534,
0.0325882435,
-0.0379733108,
0.0244087819,
-0.0290284939,
-0.0140254153,
-0.0057378281,
0.0263767969,
-0.003163934,
-0.0092703095,
-0.0146798296,
0.0001440164,
-0.0384947099,
-0.0010762336,
0.0100155501,
0.0259103477,
0.0632250011,
0.0051139421,
0.0627306551,
0.0000016518,
-0.056940984,
-0.030563008,
0.0242176354,
-0.0672266707,
0.0386340208,
-0.005183279,
-0.0057136621,
0.0055927122,
-0.0005647374,
-0.0492428169,
0.0448874645,
-0.0012476557,
0.0071045905,
0.0411417559,
0.0877223015,
-0.0047805728,
-0.0412067026,
0.0453538373,
-0.0270086862,
0.0151096387,
-0.0636317208,
0.0417822115,
-0.0437035523,
-0.040329162,
-0.0369581729,
0.0403265394,
0.047542043,
0.0356925055,
0.0209723189,
-0.0294248257,
0.0170363504,
-0.0257606991,
-0.0017610257,
-0.0218399949,
0.0374864787,
0.0190758836,
-0.0133068683,
0.025163468,
0.010130249,
0.065537408,
-0.0116080707,
-0.002390431,
0.076278016,
-0.0356723778,
0.0022911436,
0.0008398604,
-0.0297729187,
0.0488204286,
0.0264828056,
-0.0002859378,
0.0531768575,
-0.0039424491,
-0.0355077162,
0.0141801331,
-0.0229779184,
0.0493529625,
-0.0490680188,
0.065925546,
0.0163656734,
0.0342526734,
0.039881397,
-0.0808913261,
-0.0313214362,
0.0370180309,
-0.0510875322,
0.051422324,
-0.017782528,
0.0085223634,
0.0385078304,
-0.0055298987,
0.0147960056,
-0.0015025056,
0.0350273773,
0.0058364039,
-0.0097895963,
-0.0169740878,
-0.0163206756,
-0.0085076019,
0.0856256112,
-0.0250729378,
0.0423738323,
-0.0090413326,
0.021417534,
-0.0415121391,
0.0387757607,
-0.0337941498,
-0.0054447954,
-0.0065252264,
-0.0387258604,
-0.0549734607,
-0.065110296,
-0.0192050207,
0.0407167859,
0.0376268663,
-0.0439959727,
0.0001255263,
-0.0427408777,
-0.0123025309,
-0.0025948952,
0.0042656502,
0.0805604011,
0.007431285,
-0.054832954,
-0.0805145577,
-0.0704730675,
0.0093922913,
-0.0807889476,
0.005000487,
-0.0511697829,
0.0104432004,
-0.0175821129,
-0.0397311822,
-0.0907106027,
-0.0135984141,
0.0321001038,
-0.0615809038,
0.0591181852,
-0.0098474184,
-0.0098407706,
-0.0075323978,
0.0305796824,
0.0171014555,
0.0136483358,
-0.0101801949,
0.032748688,
0.0487525985,
-0.0270074867,
0.0481915064,
0.0285131037,
0.032641001,
0.0123210428,
0.0049797478,
0.0110180331,
-0.0039641447,
-0.0359284058,
-0.0016504583,
0.0424668975,
-0.0203767605,
-0.0294468068,
0.0706344545,
0.075428091,
-0.0288597904,
0.0472042337,
-0.0361347944,
-0.0242572352,
0.0178093985,
0.0284827426,
-0.0869494528,
-0.027249394,
-0.0509164482,
-0.0184661727,
-0.0308064241,
0.0211304929,
-0.028484365,
-0.0344466791,
0.035971038,
-0.0580726862,
0.0184665862,
0.0547866188,
0.0150933675,
0.0334717594,
0.0131690642,
0.0695690438,
0.0086657247,
-0.0586157106,
-0.0071555297,
-0.0510766543,
-0.0095258867,
0.0544653386,
0.0134690013,
-0.0323567837,
-0.0120049268,
-0.0288183149,
-0.0142010292,
-0.0151033755,
0.0123574985,
0.0023136586,
0.0606603213,
-0.0370723084,
-0.0406630151,
0.0065949508,
0.0198919345,
0.0169666987,
0.0118188467,
-0.0313116089,
0.0342300236,
-0.0350729041,
-0.0100802556,
0.0215480141,
-0.047548037,
-0.0396883339,
0.0080450717,
0.0003721967,
0.007384677,
0.0436715446,
0.0057914732,
-0.0149880406,
0.0444979779,
0.0149196321,
0.0373590812,
-0.0430897623,
-0.0004816257,
0.0440159366,
0.0143224839,
-0.0233051311,
0.0027569009,
0.0294073429,
-0.0247969739,
-0.0075412774,
-0.0064744852,
0.0064919745,
0.0573271699,
-0.0279432237,
0.0216160361,
-0.0189252459,
-0.0005743685,
-0.0077422434,
0.0489986725,
-0.0496132672,
-0.0322262794,
-0.0416671336,
-0.0078679956,
0.0102766296,
-0.0513083227,
-0.0440883338,
0.0029687495,
-0.0265762825,
0.0463239886,
0.0144706788,
-0.0324150361,
-0.0427552722,
-0.0113534415,
-0.0350944661,
0.0146571537,
-0.0123798717,
0.0307062455,
-0.0246707983,
0.0089712394,
-0.0287108403,
-0.0532035343,
-0.0158225112,
-0.022784492,
-0.0309271067,
0.0303077903,
0.0072075664,
0.0062331525,
-0.038238544,
-0.0053205318,
-0.0179943871,
0.0140919145,
0.0084381728,
-0.0208670963,
-0.0182542838,
-0.0326898918,
0.0512614585,
-0.0161219798,
0.0345694162,
-0.012745088,
-0.00249153,
-0.0131613063,
0.02489038,
-0.0343494713,
0.0591060221,
0.0182155687,
0.0402209498,
0.0162266027,
0.006987005,
-0.0349265672,
-0.0134743638,
-0.0136653865,
-0.0361548476,
-0.0632863417,
0.0120409857,
0.0289580375,
0.0016011217,
0.0032997015,
-0.0006990248,
-0.0012064847,
0.0355108082,
-0.0065649152,
-0.0390172452,
-0.0171128511,
-0.012571644,
-0.0468291752,
0.0342184305,
0.0033436685,
-0.0884094313,
0.0570201464,
0.0199225806,
0.0696636066,
-0.0145381466,
-0.0333557799,
0.0098976661,
0.0729147941,
0.01571781,
0.0292843562,
0.0470814258,
-0.0687550306,
-0.0217239689,
-0.0043355613,
0.0457056351,
-0.0646619201,
0.0532089956,
-0.0109032728,
-0.0103022344,
0.0013071069,
-0.0735116899,
-0.067046389,
-0.0479402617,
-0.0129533121,
0.0000080048,
-0.0076797139,
-0.0324070156,
-0.0017091742,
-0.0834278092,
0.026986504,
-0.0081478423,
0.0015109135,
0.0091652228,
-0.0225744992,
-0.0116443774,
0.0186296254,
-0.0321029276,
-0.0072494899,
-0.0220796093,
-0.0092519615,
0.0655414686,
0.0469684228,
0.0219633821,
0.0374255851,
0.0096230935,
0.0129840663,
-0.030158069,
-0.0186914969,
0.0477017947,
0.0087925019,
-0.0398518555,
-0.0018890365,
0.0635073781,
0.0112602711,
-0.0521988161,
-0.0042639826,
0.0402758121,
0.0122947963,
0.0163891707,
0.000016199,
-0.095369488,
0.0186673496,
0.0265709013,
0.0455307141,
-0.0441700742,
-0.0403609425,
-0.0066042668,
-0.1016559005,
0.0288229659,
0.021961987,
-0.0010986128,
-0.0303437915,
-0.0252078325,
-0.0179081392,
0.0195138101,
0.0415576696,
-0.0311513003,
-0.0170666408,
-0.0093918508,
0.0365435146,
-0.0277294498,
-0.0451586917,
-0.0096106417,
-0.0415632315,
0.0645204037,
0.052617766,
0.0195373818,
-0.0416060612,
-0.041345235,
0.0263916198,
0.009827855,
0.0012566709,
0.0154688191,
0.0805618241,
0.0156722721,
0.0145795504,
-0.0250843056,
0.0825999826,
-0.0050181784,
-0.0351245925,
0.0429770276,
0.0371250324,
-0.0299619921,
-0.0070729279,
0.0142355282,
-0.0586921759,
0.0063628866,
0.0575064868,
0.0008601922,
-0.0179456975,
-0.0057387026,
-0.0497780964,
0.0330273882,
-0.0010017629,
0.0144419326,
0.0419813842,
-0.0190941896,
-0.0355300456,
-0.0154575612,
-0.0381697007,
-0.0023132467,
0.0292673539,
0.0352903269,
0.017690789,
0.0196804311,
-0.0049232622,
-0.0309702959,
0.011328565,
-0.0722063333,
0.0096962824,
-0.0435796976,
-0.0105964234,
-0.0107220309,
0.0167853218,
0.0047443458,
-0.0129709532,
-0.0689617097,
-0.0562149994,
0.0424426608,
0.0502754673,
0.0283662882,
0.0600963309,
-0.0171939116,
-0.0747128427,
0.0725498125,
0.056473989,
-0.0495154075,
-0.0004696268,
0.0722779334,
-0.0445012264,
-0.0140875978,
0.020093387,
-0.0330963172,
-0.0108873816,
0.071226567,
-0.0479542241,
-0.0377930775,
-0.0055676736,
0.0168092586,
0.0574492179,
0.0288936589,
0.0096675334,
0.0028812692,
-0.0135785975,
0.0204560719,
0.0056098751,
-0.0150939282,
0.0004989257,
-0.0235257335,
0.0426870771,
0.0273656305,
0.0210884009,
-0.0189688131,
0.0276324581,
0.0090587884,
-0.04673272,
-0.003931846,
0.0497637317,
0.0414121114,
0.0358366854,
-0.0095189121,
-0.007356755,
0.0866908878,
-0.0034188251,
0.0541966073,
-0.0174348559,
0.0356750339,
-0.0006172485,
0.005701371,
-0.0342950597,
0.020597063,
-0.0441549085,
-0.0578670613,
0.0030458593,
0.0388691127,
0.0333277173,
-0.0084715299,
-0.029314911,
-0.022974398,
0.0022865757,
-0.0038153764,
-0.0106953941,
-0.0083671892,
-0.0319439806,
-0.0099019194,
-0.0105359126,
-0.0364582986,
0.0556889251,
0.0799836963,
-0.00489025,
0.0689483285,
-0.0461444184,
-0.0013694251,
-0.0390192755,
-0.0298375394,
0.0040581618,
0.0308681782,
-0.0126983905,
-0.0414453,
-0.0429064743,
-0.0833950713,
-0.0211048499,
-0.0140427696,
-0.0012338193,
-0.0005328116,
0.0175805911,
0.0431841612,
-0.0051500476,
-0.0214545932,
-0.0662928,
0.0226934049,
0.0175620131,
-0.021091789,
-0.0019943335,
-5.259137114e-33,
0.0168701243,
-0.00256082,
-0.0016861727,
0.0680560321,
0.0045582131,
0.0140734427,
0.0102844574,
0.0064263688,
-0.0410679691,
-0.0097518275,
-0.0448521078,
0.0190340467,
0.0131887766,
0.0176659524,
-0.0216735173,
-0.0601700693,
0.0221000481,
-0.0255719647,
0.0010084821,
0.0444640182,
0.0377958491,
0.0481445752,
0.0549922772,
-0.0898400843,
0.0574763454,
0.0112032285,
-0.0350580998,
0.0075911479,
-0.0596491098,
0.0585752837,
-0.0122671947,
0.0342994109,
0.0069015543,
-0.0185279232,
0.0014340742,
0.0420349501,
-0.076023221,
-0.0080614062,
-0.002438508,
0.0010872874,
0.0466435924,
-0.070168145,
0.0660942048,
-0.0494338535,
-0.0081396708,
0.0110172192,
0.0030202833,
-0.0171482433,
-0.0494330414,
-0.0461566374,
-0.0154683394,
0.0059451838,
-0.0144633502,
0.0122946352,
0.0620192215,
-0.0105101429,
-0.0048954859,
-0.0329939388,
-0.0659727678,
0.011838275,
0.03756354,
-0.0187465772,
0.0396643989,
0.0054248702,
0.0104277739,
0.0873456672,
0.0678216964,
0.0325792246,
0.0192656908,
-0.0046947184,
0.0301249065,
0.0729042068,
-0.0203050897,
0.0140620312,
0.0175094809,
-0.0691399649,
-0.0299237762,
-0.0064522135,
-0.0209756158,
-0.0025609457,
0.0282064769,
-0.0152772218,
-0.0582818389,
-0.0240152404,
-0.0576339997,
-0.0285661612,
-0.0178023539,
0.0139873642,
0.0094340602,
-0.0057504219,
-0.0230246037,
0.0093121566,
0.0022547652,
-0.0494221002,
-0.0288111698,
0.0289347861,
0.0340415388,
-0.0046973173,
-0.0103548169,
0.010546525,
-0.0629995763,
-0.0500780791,
-0.0434231311,
-0.0388653092,
0.0322209746,
0.0173779074,
0.0693356469,
0.0077836686,
-0.0476860814,
-0.0173262861,
-0.0123228803,
0.0446305871,
0.0738506913,
0.0201288518,
0.0252382047,
0.0291471891,
0.0199323408,
0.0251726303,
0.0576305501,
0.0159593858,
-0.0640775412,
0.0421925485,
-0.0147430878,
0.0006826391,
0.0082987016,
-0.032718949,
-0.006848291,
0.0402863361,
0.080096893,
-0.0222167522,
0.022682596,
0.0138724847,
2.426e-7,
0.0134523278,
-0.0227258131,
-0.0207857378,
-0.0265342109,
0.0054713567,
0.0741297305,
0.0136207193,
0.0544109456,
0.0315574668,
-0.0098555889,
-0.0161902998,
-0.0005413002,
0.0508603901,
0.0349372663,
-0.0639315471,
-0.0013490465,
-0.0174086895,
-0.033537332,
-0.068522945,
0.0488625206,
-0.0088482257,
0.1048065126,
0.0710225701,
-0.0475564897,
-0.012970088,
-0.0401171744,
0.026919134,
-0.0544418842,
-0.0076214904,
-0.0109724989,
0.0640874207,
0.0477105901,
0.0010784428,
0.0338903926,
-0.0235871915,
0.0498374738,
-0.0482135527,
0.0611916855,
0.0180622283,
0.0036830774,
-0.0461085215,
-0.0702780038,
0.0006326659,
0.0007473609,
0.0596446358,
-0.0012705496,
-0.0349204168,
-0.0293373168,
0.0139282132,
-0.0653156862,
0.0108085778,
0.0159430187,
0.0069120014,
0.0136663271,
0.0008949424,
-0.019530734,
0.0036225189,
-0.0766075775,
0.0064854929,
0.0053312513,
-0.0076408167,
-0.0213881638,
0.0066103693,
0.0056466069,
-0.0033894656,
-0.0668159351,
0.0747065842,
1.84830668e-34,
-0.0184727572,
-0.0430349596,
0.0180522129,
0.0460295267,
0.022293672,
0.0254627839,
0.0415106863,
0.031481754,
0.0016205565,
-0.0506656095,
0.0082005169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10475v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10475v2 | Findings of Factify 2: Multimodal Fake News Detection | 2023-07-19T22:14:49 | 2023-09-12T18:51:05 | S Suryavardan, Shreyash Mishra, Megha Chakraborty, Parth Patwa, Anku Rani, Aman Chadha, Aishwarya Reganti, Amitava Das, Amit Sheth, Manoj Chinnakotla, Asif Ekbal, Srijan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | With social media usage growing exponentially in the past few years, fake
news has also become extremely prevalent. The detrimental impact of fake news
emphasizes the need for research focused on automating the detection of false
information and verifying its accuracy. In this work, we present the outcome of
the Factify 2 shared task, which provides a multi-modal fact verification and
satire news dataset, as part of the DeFactify 2 workshop at AAAI'23. The data
calls for a comparison based approach to the task by pairing social media
claims with supporting documents, with both text and image, divided into 5
classes based on multi-modal relations. In the second iteration of this task we
had over 60 participants and 9 final test-set submissions. The best
performances came from the use of DeBERTa for text and Swinv2 and CLIP for
image. The highest F1 score averaged for all five classes was 81.82%. | [
0.041321855,
0.0280044209,
-0.0033219531,
0.0541694164,
-0.045489125,
0.0108847357,
0.0098257428,
0.0102472808,
-0.0049977098,
-0.0584313646,
0.0059236856,
-0.022837976,
0.0075634178,
0.072650224,
0.0104279742,
-0.0385603458,
0.0549218282,
0.0330105163,
0.0454282984,
-0.0069455979,
0.0458578877,
0.0434409082,
-0.0509004183,
0.0313225202,
-0.0728657544,
-0.0156902857,
0.0379212573,
0.0336105712,
0.0387175456,
-0.0414067619,
0.0057483041,
0.074948214,
0.0309177935,
0.0539271757,
0.0000020193,
-0.0210075323,
0.0178531725,
0.0023976066,
-0.0431747362,
-0.0229805242,
0.0665927306,
-0.0361555852,
-0.008932706,
-0.0105395541,
-0.0226693954,
-0.0272887591,
0.0432961136,
0.085043557,
0.0782012418,
0.0817134157,
-0.0299654417,
0.0040049236,
0.0165378097,
0.0181642324,
0.0019496487,
0.0291328356,
0.0109778224,
0.0150591582,
-0.0254799929,
0.0239958633,
0.020063078,
0.0166157074,
-0.0062958612,
-0.0231844503,
-0.0466440432,
0.0338794589,
-0.0406302474,
-0.0619093291,
0.0055321692,
0.0507303141,
-0.0359758921,
-0.0298642404,
0.0076024779,
-0.0112675605,
0.0140968496,
0.0635766089,
-0.0026999346,
0.002510767,
-0.0271392111,
0.0032596125,
-0.0024734212,
0.0157987252,
0.0185897127,
0.0212405678,
0.0690438747,
-0.0167436898,
-0.0072302353,
0.0053842925,
-0.011965611,
0.003946566,
-0.0172754936,
-0.0499864779,
0.0079032648,
-0.0123426495,
0.0148222856,
-0.0344730727,
-0.0625230223,
-0.0602665693,
0.0594673641,
-0.0713637918,
-0.0057597854,
-0.0159679875,
-0.0729282796,
0.0518748201,
-0.0132133178,
0.0144437868,
-0.0063028894,
0.0149703175,
0.0075355144,
-0.0096722059,
0.001411516,
0.0345183052,
0.0315294005,
-0.0111587672,
-0.0230963957,
-0.0070350454,
-0.0223599784,
-0.0171843413,
-0.0317312367,
0.0366457924,
-0.0131656285,
0.008777773,
-0.0288597029,
-0.0139859952,
-0.0223099831,
0.0645485297,
0.0088563021,
0.0228957124,
-0.0395281799,
-0.033965677,
0.0341109559,
0.0493868403,
-0.0012007295,
-0.006256938,
0.0245383345,
-0.0107398042,
-0.0303445309,
-0.0085399291,
-0.0445189588,
-0.0264841802,
-0.0135737434,
-0.0687354729,
0.0225377884,
-0.0790166631,
0.00857946,
-0.0195212644,
-0.0145872347,
0.0218855143,
-0.0087534031,
0.0312379003,
-0.0244167559,
0.0490678661,
-0.0130374227,
-0.0201149434,
0.0455605201,
0.0436948426,
0.0039257286,
0.0791474804,
-0.0146918995,
0.08096122,
0.0591360629,
0.0371604078,
0.0201369375,
0.0130808149,
0.0420062095,
0.0122657428,
0.028212985,
-0.0097919265,
-0.0170886721,
-0.0141453501,
0.0204196982,
0.0022033639,
-0.0136924041,
-0.0284853261,
0.0814996287,
-0.0423278846,
0.031968873,
-0.0235805102,
0.0345432907,
0.0142055489,
0.033255931,
-0.0037803722,
-0.0476653762,
0.0527480878,
-0.056167759,
-0.0011716331,
-0.0473713353,
0.0996511355,
-0.0103423465,
-0.0113600371,
-0.0016370044,
-0.0254310966,
0.0183518138,
-0.0374282748,
0.0064256573,
0.0095927855,
-0.0296674687,
0.0271318052,
0.0162633788,
-0.0041506798,
-0.0204160903,
-0.0268779453,
0.0176852103,
-0.0050113369,
0.0288515799,
0.00024263,
0.0054431255,
-0.0232868418,
0.0427258983,
0.0396127664,
0.0283254832,
-0.0179644097,
-0.038981311,
-0.015265285,
-0.0002978422,
-0.0602450445,
0.0155276125,
-0.0053095166,
0.0291460659,
0.0403874293,
-0.0046247072,
0.0050505721,
0.016561728,
0.0071956557,
0.0356165208,
0.0281578433,
-0.0394531637,
0.0335912555,
-0.0025492313,
0.0269840155,
-0.0267802458,
-0.0438838638,
0.0489255078,
0.0057637058,
-0.0156746656,
0.0197497979,
0.0176160689,
-0.0457606316,
0.0411358848,
-0.0887394845,
-0.0503620543,
0.0709102228,
-0.0220635533,
0.021099804,
0.016634969,
-0.0267831385,
-0.0285862684,
-0.0477632768,
-0.0406949371,
-0.0110199675,
0.0460360572,
0.0464077927,
0.0936857164,
-0.0137033388,
-0.0176834445,
0.0100076199,
-0.0178233571,
0.0244873315,
0.0379025713,
-0.0046232357,
0.012645199,
-0.0023997016,
0.0127098132,
0.0092783915,
-0.0249655172,
-0.0207598563,
0.0097829299,
-0.0948255062,
-0.0208423845,
-0.0076900367,
-0.0246539209,
0.0295139272,
-0.0195966214,
-0.0072239577,
-0.0081585413,
-0.0249161106,
-0.0111852959,
0.0193569325,
0.0082314527,
0.0178074669,
-0.0286836997,
0.0025151405,
-0.0019745256,
0.0188367777,
-0.0120829465,
0.0379780307,
0.038754683,
-0.0427389704,
0.0041569457,
-0.0519945212,
-0.0555786528,
0.013723054,
-0.0248200092,
-0.0225925278,
0.0153397331,
0.0264688283,
0.0385264829,
0.0234516412,
0.0765543804,
0.0434069075,
0.0345368572,
0.0476580709,
0.0001856758,
-0.0139852073,
-0.0054167695,
0.0626391992,
-0.000959999,
-0.073897481,
-0.0091774072,
-0.0187371522,
0.0220201723,
0.0200168937,
0.0045355018,
0.0278814603,
0.005470112,
-0.005590756,
0.0251355041,
-0.0318541005,
-0.0043995194,
-0.0037061614,
-0.023029767,
-0.0295964759,
0.0795942247,
-0.0299788751,
0.010460495,
-0.0158255007,
-0.0248212051,
0.0203363206,
0.0384618565,
-0.0054716445,
0.0343423337,
0.0048540151,
0.0200290717,
0.0215432718,
-0.0102282763,
0.0747276396,
-0.0230758097,
0.0181248393,
-0.02577921,
0.0154405078,
0.009674632,
-0.0242034569,
-0.033028923,
-0.1226277798,
-0.0293937717,
-0.0409517325,
-0.0810899287,
-0.0305315573,
-0.0902670175,
-0.0416048318,
0.0441724882,
0.0220117941,
-0.0047014998,
0.0124023417,
0.0295598507,
0.0590574928,
0.0283659883,
0.0228797887,
0.0136586679,
0.0121023227,
-0.0394556187,
0.0668153018,
-0.0172983743,
0.0155366911,
-0.0344607569,
-0.0221477002,
-0.0246262886,
0.022475265,
0.016693281,
-0.0431448035,
0.0245834775,
-0.0032284835,
0.033205267,
0.0462232977,
-0.0090719461,
0.0184278712,
0.0013381782,
0.0411829352,
-0.0400922187,
0.0234189425,
-0.018275829,
-0.0856583938,
-0.0351678021,
-0.0266740359,
-0.0156002641,
-0.0359905809,
0.0158004817,
-0.024398407,
-0.0717274919,
0.0521436706,
-0.0153099345,
0.0221129414,
-0.0276236199,
-0.0392623283,
0.0176708996,
-0.012303994,
0.0020928215,
-0.0344153941,
0.0432583354,
-0.0310549568,
-0.0189177878,
0.0355734341,
-0.0506516322,
0.0084451167,
-0.021081198,
0.0248441715,
-0.0040449486,
0.0419565737,
-0.0115137091,
-0.0782246143,
-0.0016363661,
-0.0009752984,
-0.0027822873,
-0.0034961547,
0.1040102541,
-0.0297878776,
-0.0013762988,
-0.04179997,
0.0342265666,
0.0339832604,
-0.034495499,
-0.0300272927,
0.0584827401,
0.0159966797,
-0.0513423644,
-0.0749756247,
0.025420567,
0.0239219721,
0.0401776284,
0.0193363093,
0.0033946515,
0.0117764836,
-0.0090574073,
-0.002923276,
-0.0247660074,
-0.0614775941,
0.0123098046,
-0.0119579667,
-0.0306604076,
-0.0665232912,
0.0095721241,
-0.0276515335,
0.0549979545,
-0.069696188,
-0.0445047319,
-0.0213214066,
0.0078850016,
-0.0596489832,
0.0252291597,
0.0207417086,
0.0524247289,
0.0117682749,
0.0163533539,
0.0000089357,
-0.0292952005,
-0.0197685063,
0.0376414917,
-0.0979749113,
-0.0173005406,
0.0188702326,
0.0287383385,
0.0193256922,
0.0418139473,
-0.0194840766,
-0.0112881707,
0.0551839657,
0.092985332,
-0.0498535596,
0.009386613,
0.0152246282,
-0.053999994,
0.0118321609,
-0.0047360412,
0.0013028586,
0.0357801765,
-0.0082917614,
-0.0362280831,
0.0022791745,
0.0237324145,
0.0051813032,
0.0488381237,
0.0288735516,
-0.0253947638,
-0.0041716662,
-0.0302238576,
-0.0433410928,
-0.0119379312,
-0.0357058421,
-0.0085350759,
0.047175087,
-0.0203976724,
-0.0146132428,
-0.0052108229,
-0.019960152,
-0.0360020958,
0.0003232289,
-0.0203417167,
-0.028357761,
0.0468984209,
0.0635292307,
-0.0038743187,
-0.0200606808,
-0.0338617451,
0.0264829639,
0.0067787222,
0.0016696893,
-0.0300957151,
0.0081141526,
0.0134027917,
-0.0418787375,
-0.0057135965,
-0.0019620087,
-0.0245173369,
0.0589934178,
-0.0653464869,
0.0478051752,
0.0449377522,
-0.0125502702,
0.0176417716,
-0.0329921953,
-0.0157089923,
0.0224058125,
-0.0292858183,
-0.0380867943,
-0.0279902201,
0.0044240477,
0.0019762919,
-0.0092678983,
0.0395704992,
0.0747272074,
-0.0520510338,
0.0185418054,
0.0323414765,
-0.0264559705,
-0.0476742387,
-0.0138494223,
-0.0199274868,
0.0398851112,
-0.0042755664,
-0.0207361151,
-0.054849837,
-0.0403728299,
0.0386682637,
0.0050737788,
0.0292535406,
0.0492677763,
-0.0303299502,
0.0815869644,
0.0333702751,
-0.0086976066,
0.0084762173,
0.0129058827,
0.0023896494,
-0.0040160003,
0.0105522648,
-6.783831531e-33,
0.0141644469,
-0.0575100593,
-0.037783362,
-0.0086873407,
0.0048566153,
0.0649047345,
-0.0048429715,
-0.0237711873,
-0.0176428407,
0.0456300825,
0.0424541458,
0.0291656572,
-0.0008660675,
-0.0069294544,
-0.044300992,
-0.0080286879,
0.0251006298,
-0.0146735311,
-0.0610305928,
0.0161832776,
0.0493318178,
-0.024084026,
0.040274065,
-0.1134525463,
0.0496214442,
-0.0157003421,
-0.0606910251,
-0.0094173597,
-0.002272693,
0.0653325692,
-0.0012920068,
0.0388199314,
0.0348808095,
-0.0140053416,
0.0023226801,
0.0181645304,
-0.0429294407,
-0.0555623621,
0.0592515059,
-0.0216890592,
-0.0348956585,
0.0353995934,
0.0385349467,
-0.0150847547,
-0.0145643642,
-0.015452317,
0.0323969238,
-0.0149946166,
0.0195837151,
-0.002942452,
-0.0533197224,
0.0049513667,
0.0189352874,
-0.0069896076,
-0.0185520146,
0.0507128835,
0.0547859408,
-0.0184222981,
-0.0918958262,
0.0539501309,
-0.0744300336,
-0.0349278264,
0.0333505236,
-0.0868414417,
-0.033773534,
0.0689824596,
-0.0177169051,
0.026764283,
-0.0384502858,
0.0163265597,
0.0083067659,
0.0514834262,
0.0563535243,
0.140610069,
0.0427098908,
-0.0524843037,
-0.0660516769,
0.0363864079,
0.0401817262,
-0.0350773782,
-0.0170766488,
-0.0429900363,
-0.0068272189,
0.0295143984,
-0.0049975538,
0.0289252754,
-0.0508050025,
-0.0351505764,
-0.0343464166,
0.0549644567,
-0.0355280042,
0.0680759475,
-0.0083098942,
-0.0163359772,
0.0085238703,
0.0259553716,
-0.0179383941,
0.045793388,
0.022936821,
0.0228758976,
-0.0314011388,
0.0277729593,
0.051083371,
0.0535007305,
0.0077855028,
-0.0045399852,
0.0638276413,
0.0116081582,
-0.0382945463,
0.0137957959,
-0.0072529619,
0.024574561,
-0.0291467942,
-0.027131211,
0.0169484597,
-0.0040105158,
-0.0392900966,
-0.0362875909,
-0.0077848551,
0.0362301953,
-0.0367584489,
0.0059304447,
-0.0054729609,
0.0390316434,
-0.0070458557,
-0.0105894981,
-0.0495822914,
-0.0951982513,
0.0033495612,
-0.1026660353,
0.0244695917,
0.0051874379,
2.835e-7,
-0.0172816496,
0.0333428457,
-0.009229145,
-0.0029049767,
0.006944804,
0.0433074273,
0.0152567569,
-0.0015620433,
-0.0157039445,
-0.0715222955,
-0.0298739057,
0.0147302793,
0.0004533985,
0.0641912967,
-0.0171917118,
-0.0077583357,
-0.0179600101,
-0.0292640813,
-0.0668586195,
0.0059394967,
-0.0173196811,
0.0372486152,
0.0356016494,
-0.0444270559,
0.0165809486,
-0.0132918386,
0.0346467756,
0.0479363278,
-0.0526069105,
-0.0358050577,
0.0837472081,
-0.0246147942,
0.0095892418,
0.0183070321,
-0.0406766012,
-0.0200948734,
0.0040896265,
0.0074012494,
0.0354568474,
0.005666649,
-0.0039626891,
-0.0218993835,
0.0146571258,
-0.0476049632,
0.0435925908,
0.0019096632,
-0.0279765315,
-0.0876294151,
-0.0633530989,
0.0328842998,
0.0491657294,
-0.0068020294,
-0.0510235988,
0.0353136174,
0.0196726155,
0.0001050384,
-0.0292233881,
-0.0482303724,
-0.0076870243,
0.0206213631,
-0.0526835248,
0.0073228455,
0.0160319339,
-0.0507516861,
0.0828226432,
-0.0421357974,
0.008643602,
2.135863363e-34,
0.0229390692,
-0.019608859,
0.0105554331,
-0.0736369342,
0.0127579654,
0.0205429923,
-0.0380047858,
-0.0395366997,
-0.0076298551,
0.0104524465,
0.0087545002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10472v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10472v1 | Can Instruction Fine-Tuned Language Models Identify Social Bias through Prompting? | 2023-07-19T22:03:40 | 2023-07-19T22:03:40 | Omkar Dige, Jacob-Junqi Tian, David Emerson, Faiza Khan Khattak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | As the breadth and depth of language model applications continue to expand
rapidly, it is increasingly important to build efficient frameworks for
measuring and mitigating the learned or inherited social biases of these
models. In this paper, we present our work on evaluating instruction fine-tuned
language models' ability to identify bias through zero-shot prompting,
including Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompts. Across LLaMA and its two instruction
fine-tuned versions, Alpaca 7B performs best on the bias identification task
with an accuracy of 56.7%. We also demonstrate that scaling up LLM size and
data diversity could lead to further performance gain. This is a
work-in-progress presenting the first component of our bias mitigation
framework. We will keep updating this work as we get more results. | [
0.0365856066,
0.0515633188,
-0.0470798463,
0.0526707917,
0.0057975585,
0.0395746045,
0.0386022367,
-0.0058549223,
0.0200878959,
-0.0627243668,
-0.0682101548,
-0.0294627044,
0.0152214598,
0.000411564,
0.0235030614,
-0.03881111,
0.0707425103,
-0.0225972757,
0.0576898158,
-0.0443932451,
0.0028971531,
0.0340383537,
0.0175124686,
0.0343865603,
0.0009426757,
-0.0119584473,
0.0116358753,
0.005448841,
0.0111968555,
-0.0197432656,
0.0554776005,
0.0738460943,
-0.0164212659,
0.0380334519,
0.0000018843,
-0.0575371906,
0.0048873168,
-0.0433994681,
-0.0132767018,
0.0206144247,
0.0675843209,
0.0106648672,
-0.0091076503,
0.0403763838,
-0.0323343277,
0.0111760059,
0.0480883829,
-0.0039706985,
0.0309552103,
0.0403525904,
0.011421009,
-0.0312191769,
-0.0246834457,
-0.0305762123,
0.0173190963,
-0.0182561912,
0.0425712317,
-0.0425313823,
-0.0333232395,
-0.0173562206,
-0.0365859605,
0.0188481789,
0.0067385309,
0.0049185557,
0.0188421644,
0.0147106145,
-0.0234953128,
-0.048184745,
-0.0469188839,
0.0676939562,
0.013103311,
-0.039430771,
0.0070263189,
-0.0150577659,
0.0257424936,
-0.0192334093,
-0.0092874309,
0.0368631482,
0.0096727582,
0.0326893516,
0.0565316156,
0.004046083,
0.0046061585,
0.0153027102,
0.0041909544,
0.0731368437,
0.0174770895,
-0.0088939117,
-0.0065249507,
0.0599594414,
0.0580705702,
-0.0658884421,
0.0008292201,
0.013496724,
-0.0213110168,
0.0118938386,
-0.0478771068,
0.024951309,
0.0249323398,
-0.0157707464,
0.0585320555,
0.0318451077,
-0.0594633855,
0.0153208952,
-0.0129374145,
0.0109792352,
-0.0060852589,
0.0030868845,
-0.0084250513,
0.0255917665,
-0.0006420944,
-0.006277699,
-0.0119952178,
0.0030478181,
-0.0171772894,
0.0280672275,
-0.0190164614,
0.0093755657,
-0.0362300836,
-0.0079587614,
-0.0038883898,
-0.0159530248,
-0.0382841304,
0.0093465559,
-0.0235431232,
0.0601807795,
-0.0679567307,
0.0502815731,
-0.0109682018,
-0.118485786,
-0.0166620314,
0.0061654006,
0.0012886273,
-0.0223812796,
0.0149800275,
0.0535478927,
-0.0101160798,
-0.0539587066,
-0.0528676137,
-0.0313386731,
-0.0144864339,
-0.0856754109,
0.0133833401,
-0.0433227606,
0.0200932492,
0.0067344145,
0.0173129346,
-0.0158407483,
-0.0162139181,
0.0104925251,
-0.0533433892,
0.0257255081,
-0.0128616281,
0.0108059123,
0.0196152516,
0.0102345822,
0.0137294997,
0.1057631969,
-0.0004511621,
-0.0081238337,
0.0331000499,
-0.0098674437,
0.0080192108,
0.034306664,
0.0274724569,
-0.0057544825,
-0.0201545618,
-0.0203195736,
-0.0021079942,
-0.0152900377,
0.0850763172,
0.0656500012,
0.0025388245,
0.0045187934,
0.0816677436,
0.0533085912,
-0.034075357,
-0.0123620834,
0.026495656,
0.0184088144,
-0.0003906495,
0.0440129004,
-0.0906559601,
0.0308751687,
-0.0354423337,
-0.0345524959,
0.0145153198,
0.0652046204,
-0.0395199321,
-0.0209752787,
0.0039309198,
-0.0015065826,
0.003403839,
-0.0046558618,
0.0277952421,
0.0065810257,
-0.0111314915,
0.0252213068,
0.056115333,
-0.0235741306,
0.0033218549,
-0.0754293948,
0.067044802,
0.0386280864,
0.0101187201,
0.000649117,
-0.0008783233,
-0.0155528737,
0.0129384482,
0.0594346188,
0.0703134537,
-0.0283283815,
-0.0015405203,
-0.0438035615,
-0.0060601034,
0.0060884207,
0.0422716551,
0.0183225386,
0.0209718663,
0.021808736,
-0.0020606259,
-0.0027837916,
-0.018894067,
0.0522268862,
0.0101555083,
-0.0236615036,
-0.0394478217,
0.0170755982,
0.0298203398,
0.0237037651,
-0.0172656141,
-0.0239604581,
0.0015049659,
0.0167432297,
0.0255638137,
0.0061001838,
-0.0795352012,
-0.0304369908,
0.0258192196,
-0.0225705598,
-0.050281316,
0.0194556005,
-0.011101976,
-0.0036532823,
0.0461790226,
-0.0234782677,
0.0558706224,
-0.0116074048,
0.0283086728,
-0.0596154444,
0.0330392383,
-0.0394440591,
0.0350774974,
-0.0090478407,
-0.0211874023,
0.0389315523,
-0.0475250706,
0.0124475937,
-0.0380284078,
-0.0387050696,
-0.003689155,
-0.0007177324,
-0.0261297766,
0.0071489778,
0.0258396864,
-0.0459152162,
-0.02821327,
-0.0514741428,
-0.0264682956,
-0.025403291,
0.0205998495,
0.0157717932,
-0.0120250126,
-0.0256884601,
-0.0197216664,
-0.0259424038,
0.0139916502,
-0.0053987452,
0.0442732647,
0.0129050864,
-0.0204225238,
-0.051971104,
-0.0381323136,
-0.0039802822,
-0.0351898633,
0.0181274861,
0.0183729734,
-0.0252046734,
-0.0731017962,
0.0063693817,
-0.0339868218,
0.0358221978,
-0.0030324142,
-0.0522237159,
0.0420146063,
0.0313605554,
0.0280406065,
0.1392608583,
0.0026767228,
0.0058514667,
0.0833645239,
-0.0167320892,
-0.0574285202,
-0.0230560042,
0.003799462,
-0.0197419636,
-0.0225317907,
-0.0290406831,
-0.0480305441,
0.1003487334,
0.0233782902,
-0.0084055355,
-0.0498524755,
0.0185740665,
-0.0051422478,
-0.0600902736,
0.0181812756,
-0.0511036888,
-0.0124175576,
0.0289693419,
-0.0391387008,
-0.0961736217,
0.0773856491,
-0.0227479003,
-0.0222616047,
-0.0194865149,
0.0185606834,
-0.0016574857,
0.0270636901,
-0.0064247889,
0.0142417643,
0.0044979593,
-0.0104493685,
-0.0750344917,
-0.0132180993,
-0.0010501565,
-0.0174329691,
0.0035438405,
-0.0650090799,
-0.0155758783,
-0.0048144534,
-0.0190975405,
-0.0387327261,
0.0066184178,
-0.0653318092,
-0.0254901741,
0.0055099097,
-0.0131251384,
0.0320228077,
-0.0296993181,
0.0066502439,
0.0109284529,
-0.0288206153,
0.0090132868,
-0.0246532392,
-0.0123527814,
0.0587145947,
-0.0364168286,
0.0533387698,
-0.0338902511,
0.0279722046,
0.0277846884,
0.029793594,
0.0107345516,
-0.021749923,
0.0207132548,
0.0538989976,
0.003455834,
-0.0130272675,
0.0380094275,
0.082741186,
-0.0214217547,
-0.0019249259,
0.1073640436,
0.0065315124,
-0.0873918906,
0.0172184203,
-0.0202131998,
0.0403662026,
0.0321413837,
0.0177923441,
-0.0982712731,
-0.0432465747,
0.030480111,
0.0073511889,
-0.0240837652,
-0.028777726,
-0.000352164,
-0.1378841549,
0.0107299667,
-0.0022534602,
-0.0025349639,
-0.0137708392,
-0.0269649941,
0.0124150729,
-0.0008195411,
0.0229545925,
-0.0071507478,
-0.0187373608,
0.0012021904,
0.0240054075,
-0.0043668645,
-0.0407562591,
0.038439665,
-0.0459755808,
0.1205817014,
0.0633719563,
0.0156977642,
0.0053504757,
-0.0369938128,
0.0604103841,
-0.0204347353,
-0.0083475048,
-0.0277261548,
0.0250617433,
-0.0509035438,
-0.0174192693,
0.0017418026,
0.0397041738,
0.0002619601,
0.0487246141,
-0.0068634246,
0.0577421784,
0.0056964322,
-0.0526560061,
-0.0040603201,
-0.0037454891,
0.0117751556,
0.0830077529,
0.0658871457,
-0.0509407446,
-0.0114082312,
-0.0272300933,
-0.0284759551,
0.0068966844,
-0.0434967726,
0.0125960708,
-0.0091218883,
-0.0263739843,
-0.0621860288,
-0.0525274798,
0.0189002119,
0.0309819188,
0.0263695195,
-0.0295771398,
0.0292192455,
-0.007814968,
-0.0027699703,
0.0270981509,
-0.0603257306,
0.0310203303,
-0.0539175868,
-0.0412749127,
0.0050536636,
-0.030671522,
-0.006071439,
0.0155692585,
-0.0725458264,
-0.0871549472,
0.0514138676,
0.0641411021,
0.0314510353,
0.0327652507,
-0.003855522,
-0.0674030855,
0.0431441963,
0.0436272509,
-0.0198238418,
0.0837296769,
0.0120381964,
-0.0077386289,
0.0067426506,
0.0348832905,
-0.0247680526,
0.044427529,
0.0257316753,
-0.0069539202,
-0.0245117974,
-0.0439300314,
-0.0154494457,
-0.0115938028,
0.0726252869,
-0.0488197654,
-0.0132873515,
-0.0569101609,
0.0055806334,
-0.0207086504,
-0.0114983069,
-0.0319584459,
-0.0432880782,
-0.0007437292,
0.0123435082,
-0.0138096074,
-0.0870748311,
-0.0533499457,
0.0411236994,
-0.0317350402,
0.0388174504,
0.0146154771,
0.0619631708,
0.0060912422,
0.0196263958,
-0.0104009137,
0.054709699,
-0.0095868008,
0.057058204,
0.0229924452,
0.0581795499,
0.0085062943,
-0.0099050663,
-0.0182084534,
0.0411952883,
-0.0314033255,
0.0082527539,
-0.0114542814,
0.0219292492,
0.0319580063,
-0.0243152883,
0.046001818,
0.0164891891,
0.0177206341,
-0.0045755049,
0.0236255992,
-0.0019876144,
-0.0558856465,
0.0350030288,
-0.0148799838,
-0.0183366966,
0.023511745,
0.062732093,
-0.0119129727,
0.0898493156,
-0.0155435987,
0.0179644842,
0.008115096,
-0.0130697004,
0.023649808,
-0.0249493569,
-0.0150361648,
-0.0218600482,
-0.0743774846,
-0.0675283745,
-0.0293098073,
0.0097243069,
0.0341904685,
-0.0236787889,
0.0285650901,
0.0508019738,
-0.0343926996,
-0.0413404629,
-0.0038630054,
-0.0259290915,
-0.0121184122,
0.0000780192,
-0.0322157815,
-6.728591378e-33,
-0.0569807664,
-0.0265719537,
-0.0121355001,
-0.0006434273,
0.0091914954,
0.0248432606,
-0.0473293476,
0.0282221995,
-0.0543081835,
0.0009563068,
-0.0072114859,
0.0143915517,
0.022075206,
-0.0323501676,
0.0313940607,
0.0131969405,
0.0441013612,
-0.0397204868,
-0.014455514,
0.0075887116,
0.0024314981,
-0.0022348545,
0.0554009527,
-0.0282011591,
0.0244123079,
-0.0119570475,
-0.0129159428,
-0.004786063,
-0.0319106951,
0.0168388244,
-0.0287937764,
0.0266876873,
0.0314747915,
-0.0000844525,
-0.0110527705,
0.0352508575,
-0.0235384796,
-0.0545310937,
0.0266551878,
0.0037770157,
0.0141561115,
-0.0405892432,
0.0249881372,
-0.0091481097,
-0.0894137025,
0.0161686689,
0.0265125018,
-0.0091290185,
0.0388575271,
0.0499853492,
-0.072243467,
-0.0080331946,
0.0041915514,
-0.0109777283,
-0.0141941784,
0.0195118487,
0.0059220293,
0.01935721,
-0.0106214536,
0.0488330834,
0.0454052128,
0.0226338878,
0.089675203,
0.0139374305,
-0.0024366952,
0.0629158393,
0.055228021,
0.0353000239,
-0.0042344118,
-0.0394288041,
0.070864208,
-0.0166267958,
0.0357107185,
0.0352677479,
-0.0100225024,
-0.0010321201,
-0.0340229198,
-0.0031831914,
0.0939336047,
0.0169144589,
0.0150125083,
-0.0090392586,
-0.0465428531,
-0.0394138396,
-0.0343053155,
-0.0700647384,
-0.01382872,
-0.0103716524,
0.0404579714,
0.0262117404,
-0.0179997943,
0.0027819909,
0.0526816808,
-0.0278634075,
-0.0106830942,
0.0024867989,
-0.0270685311,
0.0180693828,
0.0142049836,
-0.0031844268,
-0.0926604867,
-0.0501848869,
0.0252985545,
0.0285823476,
0.0363036096,
0.0084937112,
0.0093348613,
-0.0156478379,
-0.0617784634,
0.03977165,
-0.0338668264,
0.0093334168,
0.0220472924,
0.0018361072,
0.0308160186,
-0.0173052587,
0.0036464508,
0.0343184136,
0.0165835191,
-0.0050084293,
-0.0537649654,
0.0084288856,
-0.0358228274,
0.0431517251,
-0.0593087226,
-0.0111940168,
-0.0117888004,
0.0049948529,
-0.0006780153,
-0.0284341983,
-0.0199757293,
-0.0528532155,
2.578e-7,
-0.0160712451,
0.0658628345,
0.0157661252,
0.0107697798,
0.0142146237,
0.0392769426,
0.0160477664,
0.0471716374,
0.0141289104,
-0.0090043899,
-0.02824945,
0.0527933091,
0.0293709245,
0.0131482929,
-0.0647978038,
0.0201299451,
-0.063474603,
0.0556560904,
-0.0471757576,
-0.0402330197,
-0.02771019,
0.0586431473,
0.0108345188,
0.0032501803,
-0.0105575267,
-0.0181758497,
0.0057952618,
-0.0081086466,
0.0239672493,
0.0158316549,
0.0060452619,
-0.0017934127,
-0.0088083502,
0.0197608322,
0.0158488713,
0.0121908681,
-0.0681766793,
0.0351436883,
-0.0201016571,
-0.0053359345,
0.0214163456,
0.0162031576,
-0.0373773687,
-0.0704618841,
0.0614892021,
0.0086915866,
-0.0067051603,
-0.0269961581,
0.0071824375,
-0.025784377,
0.0202148482,
-0.0182587653,
0.017544698,
0.0128304772,
0.0118429065,
-0.0059606722,
-0.0320782512,
-0.0848660246,
-0.0267356858,
-0.0352236703,
0.001529695,
-0.0844519734,
-0.0095342463,
0.0261810273,
0.0035714344,
-0.0404921994,
0.0293376166,
2.166157368e-34,
0.007344564,
-0.0430499651,
0.0479093902,
0.007988533,
0.033766184,
-0.0002510144,
-0.0680147111,
0.0035253034,
0.0499133356,
-0.0694994628,
0.0160807706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10457v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10457v3 | Improving the Reusability of Pre-trained Language Models in Real-world Applications | 2023-07-19T21:00:16 | 2023-08-08T04:18:34 | Somayeh Ghanbarzadeh, Hamid Palangi, Yan Huang, Radames Cruz Moreno, Hamed Khanpour | cs.CL | cs.CL | The reusability of state-of-the-art Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) is
often limited by their generalization problem, where their performance
drastically decreases when evaluated on examples that differ from the training
dataset, known as Out-of-Distribution (OOD)/unseen examples. This limitation
arises from PLMs' reliance on spurious correlations, which work well for
frequent example types but not for general examples. To address this issue, we
propose a training approach called Mask-tuning, which integrates Masked
Language Modeling (MLM) training objectives into the fine-tuning process to
enhance PLMs' generalization. Comprehensive experiments demonstrate that
Mask-tuning surpasses current state-of-the-art techniques and enhances PLMs'
generalization on OOD datasets while improving their performance on
in-distribution datasets. The findings suggest that Mask-tuning improves the
reusability of PLMs on unseen data, making them more practical and effective
for real-world applications. | [
0.0342425443,
0.0567032918,
-0.0151826348,
0.0428256691,
-0.0024072246,
0.0187931489,
0.0217813775,
0.0285443887,
-0.0095941527,
-0.0489349887,
-0.0556380898,
-0.0103953425,
0.0155128967,
0.0397686698,
0.028649753,
-0.0503397174,
0.0249637179,
-0.0187221449,
-0.0169080701,
0.008200164,
0.0079862112,
0.022775257,
0.0129620861,
0.0362995937,
-0.0041999896,
-0.0067772036,
0.0190978833,
0.0126912044,
0.0097322017,
-0.0023182346,
0.0514485836,
0.044703491,
0.0353653617,
0.0400333256,
0.0000020313,
-0.0522485822,
-0.0100315195,
-0.0161318444,
-0.0274438933,
0.0415840559,
0.0447325818,
-0.0206645597,
0.0098145204,
0.0576076843,
-0.0455956198,
-0.0339747034,
0.040571671,
0.0022777801,
0.0248073135,
0.0894728974,
-0.0177595206,
-0.012290298,
-0.0167706441,
-0.0218306761,
-0.0359006971,
-0.0121744517,
0.0412520282,
-0.0114571387,
-0.0244177878,
-0.0574178807,
0.0028719255,
0.0157112014,
-0.0164193511,
0.0545656569,
-0.0055450452,
0.0306383893,
-0.0404873975,
0.0036187775,
-0.0027461909,
0.0672528297,
-0.1030863971,
-0.0601074696,
0.0208964981,
-0.0446952619,
-0.0480078943,
0.0121439705,
-0.0093188239,
-0.0282958858,
0.0406387821,
0.0467685014,
-0.0062556914,
0.0291059334,
0.0424252674,
0.0023945631,
-0.0683610216,
0.0230410956,
0.0062198392,
-0.0080269193,
-0.0143414997,
-0.0359205902,
-0.0312541239,
-0.0308675226,
0.0146841984,
0.0144724594,
0.0160181951,
0.0400755741,
-0.0783704221,
-0.0881289393,
0.0117689241,
-0.0431192033,
0.0756572261,
0.0208865013,
-0.0238861889,
0.0331288613,
-0.0324464366,
0.0250982996,
0.0281190593,
0.0638444647,
-0.0307581108,
0.0002192541,
-0.0269246716,
-0.0097167753,
-0.0556483604,
0.0370630175,
-0.0132507738,
-0.0253225397,
0.0042988807,
0.0094362004,
0.0044563357,
-0.0125767468,
0.0060774414,
-0.0197251569,
-0.0143443737,
-0.025841454,
0.0125735486,
-0.0476496927,
0.0216247477,
0.0306527168,
-0.0494937375,
-0.0768816993,
0.0036009201,
0.0138117587,
0.0125103239,
-0.0174841639,
0.040217068,
0.0650272518,
-0.0039262762,
-0.0542063117,
-0.0266854931,
0.0266140103,
0.0168574657,
-0.0345629454,
-0.0135844052,
-0.0448880568,
0.0078434339,
0.0069218986,
0.0127096586,
-0.0551722944,
-0.0052138194,
0.0072804405,
-0.062380638,
0.0745951906,
-0.015780393,
0.0317605883,
0.0233274754,
-0.0119022029,
0.0329475552,
0.0684995577,
0.0353709236,
-0.0142221786,
0.0514954068,
-0.0232803449,
0.0455857888,
0.0844469517,
0.0220856927,
0.004150697,
-0.0220236257,
-0.0087203085,
0.0133654419,
-0.0294167697,
0.0366906002,
0.0305110849,
-0.0141754868,
-0.0114189629,
0.0485394038,
0.0066794329,
0.0382350646,
0.0047868132,
0.0449927449,
0.0301154684,
0.0157702025,
-0.0018423953,
-0.0335278288,
-0.0557097569,
-0.0610597096,
0.0063498318,
-0.0303456709,
0.0549037717,
-0.0419022068,
-0.0360886082,
-0.0303399637,
-0.028126657,
0.0168797206,
0.0157372635,
0.0461943746,
0.0293273777,
-0.0486846268,
0.0379800349,
0.0144701563,
-0.0164223313,
0.0133996615,
-0.0540406741,
0.0064676437,
0.0453515574,
0.0557187088,
-0.0498874448,
-0.002856984,
0.0175735597,
0.000820544,
0.0128924334,
0.0344120301,
0.0075111445,
0.0592012145,
-0.071959883,
-0.0269241612,
0.0014649743,
0.0197011363,
0.0284554791,
0.0210509785,
-0.0098347859,
0.0474172086,
-0.0633105785,
-0.0260677412,
0.0663438737,
-0.0426960923,
-0.0338796079,
0.0098165516,
0.0051279166,
0.0157853831,
-0.0148639902,
-0.0339879133,
0.0113832541,
0.0212846585,
-0.0335281417,
0.0168156717,
0.0003300894,
-0.049511563,
-0.0149863074,
0.0073199384,
-0.0342774577,
0.0236330889,
0.0904467031,
-0.0492558964,
-0.0356910229,
-0.0071049663,
0.014875045,
0.0903935134,
-0.0626786798,
0.0331112221,
-0.025598824,
0.0555023216,
-0.0321392231,
0.0332316048,
-0.0005885037,
0.0060870307,
0.0102164634,
-0.0033658626,
0.0253628679,
0.0005562882,
-0.0166499745,
-0.0122125605,
-0.0099561866,
0.0276201274,
-0.0104643488,
0.0435374007,
-0.0233607274,
-0.0028462391,
-0.0639166236,
-0.0023792102,
-0.0479969829,
-0.0083597815,
0.0402528197,
-0.0065237344,
-0.0552299581,
-0.0301323328,
-0.0112846913,
-0.0304323789,
-0.0106921373,
-0.0055545173,
0.0005634917,
-0.0047361865,
-0.0327655785,
-0.0314772315,
-0.0052899322,
0.0081930468,
0.0606480315,
-0.0621575117,
-0.0476652458,
-0.0447960123,
0.0889106691,
-0.0098786624,
0.051925227,
-0.0095442096,
-0.0096312379,
-0.0363380052,
-0.0066611692,
0.0519527979,
0.0163353402,
-0.0083332062,
-0.0366947912,
0.0634602979,
0.0090112695,
-0.0635895729,
-0.0257017836,
-0.0189788789,
-0.0224014446,
-0.0279869922,
-0.0160057172,
0.0150731672,
0.0497653186,
0.019518083,
-0.0151567673,
-0.0362716429,
-0.0043682861,
-0.0131050125,
-0.0249212906,
-0.0418007486,
-0.0026424266,
-0.0258419011,
0.0329156853,
-0.0106603848,
-0.0649678111,
0.0232195612,
-0.0600508563,
-0.0141034406,
-0.044000335,
-0.0187303703,
-0.0308796726,
0.0418486297,
0.0158006232,
0.0112149129,
0.0208988264,
-0.0384519845,
-0.040645048,
-0.0075955028,
-0.0126081901,
-0.04539546,
0.0335293822,
-0.0548299737,
0.0128437625,
0.0129184937,
-0.0154443486,
-0.0653184205,
-0.0829058066,
-0.0280343797,
0.0015502085,
0.0052638981,
0.0267586671,
-0.0030176404,
0.0306254849,
-0.0224172901,
0.082357496,
0.0231208783,
0.0056604552,
-0.0171727501,
0.0085526891,
0.0427534208,
-0.0098036211,
0.0074271238,
-0.0135948034,
-0.0181937907,
-0.0138280224,
0.0428514332,
-0.0153767457,
-0.0343753658,
0.01114571,
0.0453106724,
-0.0004633479,
-0.0344701447,
0.0438886583,
0.0202516746,
-0.0436930694,
-0.0079567526,
0.1181755811,
0.0366435088,
-0.0274562314,
0.0064567137,
0.0048571811,
0.0548014864,
0.0282517113,
0.0291601941,
-0.0697217137,
-0.0161855724,
0.0172823649,
0.0159136411,
-0.0198808555,
0.0065506045,
-0.0204658937,
-0.1276746988,
-0.0029735977,
0.021908924,
-0.0246431492,
-0.0063540922,
-0.0252825394,
0.0100436471,
-0.0241237581,
0.0305609107,
-0.021491196,
-0.0184174087,
-0.0193255935,
0.0354622193,
-0.0807237849,
-0.1050762087,
0.0171859376,
-0.0133635672,
0.0367546678,
0.058511585,
-0.0069223107,
-0.0138134211,
-0.042489294,
0.0480536707,
-0.0130386082,
0.0229960475,
-0.0281500444,
0.0442178622,
-0.0203532707,
-0.0206681564,
0.0324236564,
0.0221066438,
-0.0387604758,
-0.0204998143,
0.0010806179,
0.0313043743,
-0.0104312599,
-0.0165369455,
-0.0063573685,
-0.0293118525,
0.0111488523,
0.0779963285,
0.0393422395,
-0.0392060578,
-0.0111140059,
-0.0143097434,
0.0109656667,
-0.0360885374,
0.0094211465,
0.0209752489,
-0.0291410498,
-0.0111732269,
-0.0320600644,
0.0036034593,
0.0466520749,
0.0399668701,
0.0206911284,
0.0108496808,
-0.0086719897,
-0.0111184651,
-0.0488808118,
0.0183885526,
-0.059620969,
0.0285688341,
-0.0420454219,
-0.0389684588,
0.0176070705,
-0.0233885553,
-0.0350685418,
0.0185867902,
-0.0745350271,
-0.0682748482,
0.0326955914,
0.0666597486,
0.0257639289,
0.0397933833,
-0.0026445515,
-0.0797941983,
0.0775456578,
0.0113669736,
-0.0196999963,
0.0197243802,
0.0632324442,
-0.0624667965,
0.0115551986,
0.0199110843,
-0.0305308327,
0.0344195999,
0.0753669813,
0.003702519,
-0.033334408,
-0.005829365,
0.0065693618,
-0.0008556574,
0.0748200864,
-0.0275860392,
-0.0004332932,
-0.0537173338,
0.034069255,
-0.0064670816,
-0.0044739242,
-0.0389207229,
-0.0061993808,
0.0221489351,
0.0309951324,
-0.0315781012,
0.0383898169,
-0.0549581386,
0.0369088687,
-0.0147554008,
0.0053929021,
-0.0083881635,
0.0272186529,
0.038814187,
0.0040609287,
-0.017188007,
0.0393885486,
0.0125725335,
-0.0124278702,
-0.0069737947,
0.0138615435,
0.0003136715,
0.0259766076,
-0.0410853736,
0.0436687209,
-0.0313444063,
-0.0250969082,
-0.0478242822,
-0.0033043947,
0.0487114526,
-0.0413002968,
0.0358516239,
-0.0117316507,
-0.0012393146,
-0.0197039098,
0.0218683854,
0.0059757247,
-0.0247848555,
0.0048926459,
-0.0078613013,
-0.0618366674,
0.0198238231,
0.0971329585,
0.029308524,
0.0261221603,
-0.0036978065,
0.0055151335,
-0.0316779986,
0.0343480781,
0.0647441521,
0.0617691092,
-0.0242927764,
-0.0116585474,
-0.0516333506,
-0.0878048688,
0.0106020421,
-0.017313296,
-0.002493524,
0.0051122918,
0.0336821824,
0.0699489564,
-0.0125268297,
0.0320979916,
-0.0326670185,
-0.0232227165,
0.0415438712,
-0.0171350352,
-0.0022622149,
-6.561835014e-33,
-0.0153243784,
0.0065359506,
0.0037824714,
-0.00733223,
0.0024384374,
0.0223216601,
-0.0096198181,
-0.0095343282,
-0.0123739503,
-0.0307752229,
-0.0287915207,
-0.0099309031,
0.0250480343,
0.0253246892,
-0.038800396,
0.0170643684,
0.0471515097,
-0.0016907637,
-0.0250631943,
-0.018158257,
0.0162711404,
0.0716922432,
0.0714224949,
-0.0663362071,
-0.0309208743,
-0.0230753273,
-0.0319997445,
0.005399107,
0.0071430453,
0.0524043925,
-0.0392523408,
0.0373002551,
0.0258804355,
-0.0014450895,
-0.0629925653,
0.0187643748,
-0.0555572584,
-0.0218655709,
0.0374141298,
0.0086029675,
-0.0049612462,
0.0079143345,
0.0547815822,
-0.0190117862,
-0.0356619246,
0.025650965,
0.0469408929,
-0.0518310033,
-0.0256051458,
-0.0055601671,
-0.0305498373,
0.0252233539,
0.0215000752,
-0.0154380947,
0.0322914533,
0.0115198279,
-0.0279735494,
0.0350688733,
-0.0657084361,
0.0157569423,
0.0582364425,
0.0269943513,
0.0694114715,
0.061156828,
0.0373839252,
0.0557751432,
0.0039333929,
-0.003974007,
0.0043435981,
0.0050516087,
0.1084697843,
0.0229832381,
0.0179994367,
0.0443634875,
0.057618767,
-0.0547584891,
-0.0593475588,
0.0148398904,
-0.0390717722,
-0.0514947735,
0.0454966724,
0.027729135,
-0.0219034404,
-0.0301888436,
-0.0630962625,
0.0171667654,
-0.0359291583,
-0.024373604,
0.0465981551,
0.0375715569,
-0.0327679925,
0.0205456205,
0.0238307342,
-0.0370453186,
-0.0323454849,
-0.0077489675,
-0.0043205796,
0.0018126689,
-0.0022663523,
0.0265432298,
-0.0676675141,
-0.0772926062,
0.0251457375,
-0.0020470277,
0.0202781968,
-0.0279565193,
0.058963798,
0.0610672086,
-0.0836678296,
0.0086009223,
-0.0094903298,
0.0019481397,
0.0225636885,
0.0384075269,
0.0205496419,
0.0123106176,
-0.0020635522,
0.0263556503,
0.014899306,
-0.0541270338,
-0.0381041802,
0.011676928,
-0.0056237425,
0.0606345572,
-0.0148429992,
-0.0166080389,
-0.0131338676,
-0.0273220558,
0.0998667851,
-0.0140864933,
-0.0119065596,
-0.0042994581,
2.578e-7,
0.06532529,
0.0158918072,
-0.0217366051,
0.0083513604,
0.0088453442,
0.0149900885,
-0.0216037333,
0.0406510606,
-0.0083238222,
0.0005138438,
0.0379239693,
0.0031758458,
0.056885682,
-0.0230132788,
-0.0627472699,
0.0075364518,
-0.0313953646,
-0.0055640177,
-0.063151449,
-0.0209954567,
0.0015468016,
0.1284194589,
0.0417367704,
-0.0137542933,
-0.0238324162,
-0.0446442515,
0.048093725,
-0.0746839345,
-0.006693243,
0.0156159317,
0.0149745671,
0.0668450892,
0.010206027,
0.0250531342,
-0.0293219071,
0.0439106598,
0.0342723802,
0.0575200021,
-0.0033376887,
-0.0147951311,
-0.007250757,
0.0040811775,
-0.0400978737,
-0.0750221238,
0.0788442791,
-0.0437253453,
-0.0013383041,
-0.0345877521,
-0.0057039354,
0.0010342657,
0.0177037586,
-0.0374587886,
-0.0244133249,
0.035257753,
0.0442298278,
-0.0077771633,
-0.0271309577,
-0.0791438892,
-0.0280044824,
0.0022794963,
-0.03442996,
-0.0112183103,
-0.0201284029,
-0.0338848531,
0.0255316347,
-0.0310653448,
0.0408900753,
2.703461372e-34,
0.032273598,
-0.0154745532,
-0.0101576261,
0.0079506598,
0.0250668339,
-0.0167119838,
0.015227274,
0.036824137,
-0.0083456337,
-0.0858529359,
0.0170820039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10443v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10443v3 | Integrating a Heterogeneous Graph with Entity-aware Self-attention using Relative Position Labels for Reading Comprehension Model | 2023-07-19T20:17:37 | 2024-01-13T15:24:59 | Shima Foolad, Kourosh Kiani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the significant progress made by transformer models in machine
reading comprehension tasks, they still fall short in handling complex
reasoning tasks due to the absence of explicit knowledge in the input sequence.
To address this limitation, many recent works have proposed injecting external
knowledge into the model. However, selecting relevant external knowledge,
ensuring its availability, and requiring additional processing steps remain
challenging. In this paper, we introduce a novel attention pattern that
integrates reasoning knowledge derived from a heterogeneous graph into the
transformer architecture without relying on external knowledge. The proposed
attention pattern comprises three key elements: global-local attention for word
tokens, graph attention for entity tokens that exhibit strong attention towards
tokens connected in the graph as opposed to those unconnected, and the
consideration of the type of relationship between each entity token and word
token. This results in optimized attention between the two if a relationship
exists. The pattern is coupled with special relative position labels, allowing
it to integrate with LUKE's entity-aware self-attention mechanism. The
experimental findings corroborate that our model outperforms both the
cutting-edge LUKE-Graph and the baseline LUKE model across two distinct
datasets: ReCoRD, emphasizing commonsense reasoning, and WikiHop, focusing on
multi-hop reasoning challenges. | [
0.0470853075,
-0.0153384451,
-0.0118487412,
0.0515388958,
-0.0274414085,
0.0194348209,
0.0041697854,
-0.0416933745,
0.0836341828,
-0.0301013775,
-0.0205618571,
0.0157409366,
-0.0157508124,
0.0401419513,
0.0309160817,
-0.033219032,
0.0472860485,
-0.0160235073,
0.0141412718,
0.0196241494,
-0.0279846527,
0.0180232115,
-0.0152992783,
0.0056252782,
-0.0143479146,
-0.0211099852,
-0.0284319799,
0.0197161641,
0.0400039107,
-0.0342076793,
-0.0336701535,
0.0135896802,
0.0057347175,
0.0057203355,
0.0000019836,
-0.0086894268,
-0.0402288325,
0.0041637681,
-0.0201389138,
-0.0286767539,
-0.0343413427,
-0.0392518453,
0.0242981315,
-0.0411529317,
-0.0170181599,
-0.0108163403,
0.0322811715,
0.0547290444,
0.0663181022,
0.0411112569,
0.0003344909,
-0.0233384483,
0.019622324,
-0.0023130151,
0.0578779504,
-0.0788649619,
0.0142321857,
0.0406366698,
0.0304332115,
0.0059260214,
-0.0738047734,
0.0510345399,
0.0396908484,
0.001626706,
0.0386148766,
0.0399690866,
0.0285225958,
0.0135896392,
-0.0192328505,
0.1287304163,
0.0057836357,
-0.0386927202,
-0.0022400848,
-0.0073626316,
0.0361010507,
0.0324815325,
-0.0282795951,
-0.0181282833,
-0.0462064557,
-0.0115927663,
0.0096175717,
-0.0140102915,
0.0353711545,
-0.0025300193,
-0.0294037368,
0.103719376,
-0.003971159,
-0.0227497946,
-0.0125876376,
0.0127469804,
-0.0403382331,
-0.0184010323,
0.0499652401,
0.0768944547,
-0.007649858,
0.0405640863,
-0.0360292979,
-0.0345373601,
-0.0181718916,
-0.0023885786,
-0.0130932834,
0.0579629093,
-0.0014606586,
0.069900535,
-0.035073258,
0.04188025,
-0.0512475967,
0.069591701,
-0.0609154254,
-0.0092085879,
-0.010874236,
-0.0096808923,
-0.0745864362,
0.0472648405,
-0.0481015779,
-0.0789800361,
-0.0139915701,
0.0412840731,
0.030206874,
-0.0229641385,
0.0551465079,
0.0353476033,
-0.0301084835,
-0.0380952246,
0.0086573884,
0.0475808904,
-0.0550486483,
-0.0123629915,
0.0039069518,
0.0273907725,
-0.0241569411,
-0.0000207497,
0.018885918,
-0.0320903324,
-0.0205158349,
0.0737281591,
0.0114124781,
-0.0268618688,
-0.021261666,
-0.0096759619,
-0.023164181,
-0.0312978551,
0.0229616519,
-0.0310049374,
0.0188373961,
0.0319958441,
0.0032174347,
-0.0192286838,
0.0043087974,
0.0010739556,
-0.0629217476,
0.0667165741,
0.0215654708,
0.0052292347,
0.0128938183,
0.0094419383,
-0.0258613154,
0.0512476265,
0.0430936441,
-0.0140368389,
0.0296734311,
-0.0037116911,
-0.0445281714,
0.0026317113,
0.0342899524,
-0.0262813549,
0.0078849252,
0.0140604237,
-0.0614475347,
-0.0022524435,
0.0243140068,
0.0232459009,
-0.0219830144,
-0.0621236749,
0.0340488292,
0.0311030205,
0.0111092748,
0.0070674336,
0.0465400517,
0.040032126,
-0.0235406049,
0.052830141,
-0.0728800446,
0.0646353513,
0.0194331165,
0.038637884,
0.009751563,
-0.010761681,
-0.0036486713,
-0.0173374638,
0.0105708856,
0.0332488939,
0.0193203371,
0.0292813145,
0.0383645482,
0.0488021299,
-0.0709429383,
0.0637660474,
0.0070321653,
-0.0106236776,
-0.0046392833,
-0.0035822731,
0.0175780673,
0.0711911097,
0.0318223536,
-0.0133625893,
-0.063375935,
0.0282107145,
-0.0151241235,
0.009670536,
0.0173711609,
-0.0097966222,
-0.002816695,
-0.041147694,
-0.0258615203,
-0.0118966457,
-0.0172551014,
0.0079475306,
0.0169018209,
-0.0023003381,
0.0033708492,
-0.1015617847,
0.0269749612,
0.017337922,
0.0079523083,
0.0066901962,
-0.0419718027,
0.0277050156,
-0.0175171774,
0.0279229507,
0.0458547547,
0.0238078218,
0.0315994136,
-0.0090408716,
-0.0002559015,
0.010319896,
-0.0516122468,
-0.0637039095,
0.0113361105,
-0.0511739925,
-0.0409173928,
-0.0130004305,
-0.0103055127,
-0.0603389144,
0.0301811099,
-0.0685060024,
0.0316598192,
0.0057447581,
-0.0053402982,
0.0359052047,
-0.0052968329,
-0.0239186678,
0.0686659366,
-0.0227661841,
0.0199127439,
-0.0122098429,
0.0311261676,
-0.0355934277,
-0.0195571389,
0.0115654962,
-0.0150851971,
-0.0026007092,
-0.0192391053,
-0.0113942483,
-0.031596873,
-0.0725952387,
-0.0053526959,
-0.0565919392,
0.0154164899,
0.0013668584,
0.0035592071,
0.0206881873,
0.0214580074,
-0.0096747726,
-0.04165297,
-0.0017164883,
0.0238018204,
-0.018222712,
0.008655536,
0.0254953634,
-0.0208469369,
0.0196168516,
0.0017394339,
-0.0536202081,
-0.0420818552,
0.0585512742,
0.0374225639,
-0.0185817853,
-0.0604335666,
-0.0295774937,
-0.0221878868,
-0.0116620958,
-0.0037113999,
-0.0108010499,
0.0209551472,
0.0000477427,
0.0596375167,
0.0817034543,
-0.0325635262,
0.0167197045,
0.0147347841,
-0.053750027,
-0.0421024114,
0.0456663221,
-0.0126988571,
0.0511045009,
-0.0097323041,
-0.0164976716,
-0.0289353505,
0.0558140725,
0.0063310848,
-0.0217349678,
-0.0645909831,
0.0053038718,
-0.0014085332,
-0.0107948259,
-0.0403980836,
-0.0174573138,
-0.0081048002,
-0.0166952778,
-0.0621227771,
0.0043470785,
0.1104994565,
-0.0007766006,
-0.0054245931,
-0.0170368496,
0.047081247,
-0.0415460765,
0.0601672605,
0.0220871065,
0.0092421118,
-0.0329839513,
-0.0525522307,
-0.0397128761,
0.0457129814,
0.0029757067,
-0.0075971335,
0.0631812438,
0.021523511,
0.0350784399,
0.0077970312,
0.005304887,
-0.0246756542,
0.0402619243,
-0.0217995383,
-0.0147482892,
0.012795412,
-0.0140490076,
-0.0294198301,
0.0191389471,
0.0165346935,
0.0257922169,
-0.0267765,
-0.0065108291,
-0.0241779331,
0.0599594153,
0.0359958597,
0.011708051,
0.0253244247,
-0.0293850154,
0.021499211,
0.0598770604,
0.0253859572,
-0.072286725,
0.0302046891,
0.0250866674,
0.0174736287,
-0.0438829586,
0.0193776265,
-0.0190929156,
0.0732721686,
-0.1065219045,
-0.0290310644,
0.0645907447,
0.0257620346,
-0.0355876647,
-0.0138161005,
-0.0122306524,
0.0173921883,
0.029291667,
0.0242613498,
-0.0852114707,
-0.0395473391,
0.0039670398,
0.0198896509,
0.0435933135,
-0.0716313347,
-0.0059709428,
-0.0486379229,
0.0141416723,
0.0008324723,
-0.0618759245,
-0.0391873047,
-0.0452728942,
0.0246937145,
0.028628828,
-0.0079434253,
0.0144050447,
0.0057609468,
-0.0091866096,
-0.0255459547,
0.0393335074,
0.0201787744,
0.0170573443,
0.0032266437,
-0.0093281977,
-0.0247954838,
0.0219069682,
0.0289812516,
-0.0268133506,
0.0136555769,
-0.0259533152,
0.0111384504,
-0.0119149992,
0.0479319282,
-0.0455204211,
-0.0137041286,
-0.0796170682,
0.0142459767,
-0.0657999218,
-0.0243254751,
-0.038863413,
0.0931928307,
0.0236115083,
-0.0442912206,
-0.0481048003,
0.0131315738,
0.0017133725,
0.0595895648,
0.0581517518,
-0.0072743874,
-0.0757299438,
-0.0325329602,
0.0195943899,
-0.0749818832,
-0.0288268607,
0.0376523025,
0.016453106,
-0.0140282298,
-0.0465233214,
-0.0682120621,
0.0258028284,
0.033409752,
0.0058482741,
0.0058914814,
0.0688935965,
-0.0413138345,
-0.0840619504,
0.0357889161,
-0.0287910607,
0.0006573756,
-0.0313414149,
0.0009825502,
0.0019817932,
-0.0145391794,
-0.0078680981,
0.0369723849,
-0.0600163378,
-0.0458308943,
0.0083729457,
0.017212579,
0.0128625408,
0.0511922799,
-0.0432503596,
-0.0018499846,
0.0214412268,
-0.0170479938,
-0.0565411001,
-0.0178418271,
-0.0032834045,
-0.0173964929,
0.0007578681,
0.0341568887,
-0.0236025304,
0.0310473479,
0.0190873146,
0.0734715313,
-0.0321328454,
-0.0382716767,
0.0131360441,
0.0159899779,
0.0029713437,
0.0328480899,
0.020386463,
-0.0318155512,
0.0180580113,
0.0008896957,
-0.0229160693,
-0.0230454598,
-0.0116122458,
0.0133149447,
-0.0528910384,
-0.0071293358,
0.0116524315,
0.0262605362,
0.0270189606,
-0.0076750144,
0.0342498794,
-0.0095583517,
0.0000789353,
0.0072493595,
-0.023560226,
-0.0246299617,
-0.0093040839,
0.0039626681,
0.0447822101,
0.0149094826,
0.0668406561,
0.0293715987,
-0.0449478589,
-0.0449149646,
0.0051591247,
-0.0804823264,
0.0208426304,
0.0136003457,
0.0223913752,
0.0056632394,
-0.0063076424,
0.0383484401,
0.0081060519,
-0.0214767735,
0.0189126078,
0.0451367795,
0.0140301194,
-0.0253036451,
0.0305545088,
0.0461749919,
0.0385918766,
-0.0001652889,
0.0282317512,
-0.0111585148,
0.0087932246,
0.0206567291,
-0.0404227115,
-0.0419004299,
-0.026962202,
-0.0436961167,
0.0204260815,
-0.0174142439,
0.0385017358,
-0.0610085614,
-0.0975805297,
0.0066798008,
0.0065553184,
-0.0087835202,
-0.0067159687,
-0.0093885064,
0.0298971832,
0.0432750806,
-0.0756659806,
-0.0297032278,
0.0741421804,
-0.0032601708,
-0.0167834982,
0.0228188355,
-6.345167161e-33,
-0.0309178848,
-0.0768037438,
0.0157850198,
-0.0283001065,
-0.0278900228,
0.0283516943,
-0.0600716434,
-0.0256481841,
-0.0362012349,
0.0253062136,
-0.0057804738,
0.041125536,
0.0069025536,
0.0131930793,
-0.0283380244,
-0.0192669984,
0.0147748338,
0.0285175554,
-0.0269325171,
0.0325572081,
0.0518159494,
0.0461894684,
0.0502741486,
-0.0229066815,
0.0466353111,
-0.0208827537,
0.0422988795,
0.0221997257,
-0.0055456809,
0.0546997748,
-0.0230836421,
0.0371231288,
0.0486468598,
-0.0071495213,
-0.0097055305,
0.0504120477,
-0.1481162161,
-0.0373118557,
0.0155645488,
0.0232979227,
-0.0389719233,
-0.0209063832,
0.0512964688,
0.030261239,
0.0782142952,
-0.0763348714,
0.0280863699,
0.0017211227,
-0.0375075452,
0.0388723947,
-0.0401721708,
0.0336896144,
-0.0326156206,
-0.0128348069,
-0.0014224872,
0.0314649306,
0.013682981,
0.0326064453,
-0.1005324647,
-0.0008048124,
-0.0348987058,
-0.0099069169,
0.0227403119,
0.0139072137,
-0.0085011506,
0.0172098223,
-0.0035058814,
-0.0108944252,
-0.0632978007,
-0.016560737,
0.0076509966,
0.0555170253,
-0.0094654877,
-0.0129125873,
0.015649464,
0.0127351703,
-0.0538955927,
0.0041206125,
-0.0233733337,
0.0416491218,
0.0176747758,
0.0026943337,
-0.0598758236,
-0.0105431415,
0.0010459184,
-0.013011571,
-0.0639340878,
0.0042354097,
0.0104135396,
-0.0214610137,
-0.0608289465,
0.0390154086,
0.0129317027,
-0.0348757096,
0.0027866329,
0.0611327551,
0.039609164,
0.0283377618,
-0.0185575951,
0.0585573576,
-0.0271594208,
0.0081879273,
0.0077912887,
0.0061292313,
0.0037634692,
0.0041531096,
0.041610457,
0.000853498,
-0.036406897,
-0.0336596854,
-0.0379304066,
-0.020217713,
-0.0342580453,
-0.0223590732,
0.067291297,
0.0536778197,
-0.0278726406,
0.0683975145,
0.0150363706,
0.0218597427,
-0.0159069989,
0.0518437922,
-0.0021917871,
0.0458407514,
-0.0164641589,
-0.0160537343,
-0.0164520033,
0.0328040496,
-0.0063623991,
-0.0894578323,
-0.0023314168,
0.0767538249,
2.792e-7,
0.0680407509,
0.0214067176,
0.063700214,
0.0255864747,
0.0035602646,
0.0120396698,
0.0095873736,
0.0393749736,
0.0491941869,
-0.0441763736,
0.0072081564,
0.0641233176,
-0.0328551829,
0.0041879686,
-0.0747309923,
-0.0017303366,
-0.0084412526,
0.0188213065,
-0.0319080167,
0.0148521522,
0.0381189808,
0.0356536433,
-0.0012331348,
-0.0089198621,
-0.0046078307,
-0.0187950842,
0.0405782573,
0.0254531968,
0.018023828,
-0.0000672597,
0.0253406838,
-0.017888058,
-0.0090245698,
0.0470781513,
-0.0060220249,
0.0242103804,
0.0339611955,
0.025984833,
0.016190622,
-0.0546007194,
-0.0075543863,
-0.024942752,
0.022538757,
-0.0657054856,
0.0688128918,
-0.076604329,
-0.0483077392,
0.0351820029,
-0.0546195544,
0.0082691899,
-0.0336331092,
0.0093500102,
-0.0167326555,
0.0232345276,
0.0187880192,
-0.0335029811,
0.0335648246,
-0.0779229626,
-0.0334198885,
-0.014214824,
-0.0188697875,
0.0107257403,
-0.0340238176,
-0.0502241999,
0.025580097,
-0.0127447015,
-0.0167830959,
2.269309752e-34,
-0.0118493428,
-0.0058639129,
0.0092420839,
0.00818168,
0.0182075314,
-0.0653030202,
-0.0234513525,
0.009267359,
0.0360904932,
-0.1006727442,
-0.0374832675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10442v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10442v1 | Thrust: Adaptively Propels Large Language Models with External Knowledge | 2023-07-19T20:16:46 | 2023-07-19T20:16:46 | Xinran Zhao, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Wenlin Yao, Dong Yu, Jianshu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although large-scale pre-trained language models (PTLMs) are shown to encode
rich knowledge in their model parameters, the inherent knowledge in PTLMs can
be opaque or static, making external knowledge necessary. However, the existing
information retrieval techniques could be costly and may even introduce noisy
and sometimes misleading knowledge. To address these challenges, we propose the
instance-level adaptive propulsion of external knowledge (IAPEK), where we only
conduct the retrieval when necessary. To achieve this goal, we propose
measuring whether a PTLM contains enough knowledge to solve an instance with a
novel metric, Thrust, which leverages the representation distribution of a
small number of seen instances. Extensive experiments demonstrate that thrust
is a good measurement of PTLM models' instance-level knowledgeability.
Moreover, we can achieve significantly higher cost-efficiency with the Thrust
score as the retrieval indicator than the naive usage of external knowledge on
88% of the evaluated tasks with 26% average performance improvement. Such
findings shed light on the real-world practice of knowledge-enhanced LMs with a
limited knowledge-seeking budget due to computation latency or costs. | [
0.0258875843,
0.0546875894,
-0.0045265788,
0.0589642003,
-0.0060530268,
0.0127471127,
-0.0054542259,
0.0221641492,
0.0059674629,
-0.0397021025,
-0.065770939,
-0.029530054,
-0.0539188273,
0.031679865,
0.0322865956,
-0.0067356736,
0.0529895984,
-0.0492520779,
0.0460217707,
0.0043119462,
-0.0045838943,
-0.0213831365,
0.0011211407,
0.0499457158,
-0.0102373315,
0.0084868874,
-0.0158110224,
-0.0073459232,
0.002260115,
-0.0081787603,
-0.0018772553,
0.0366331674,
0.0341372527,
0.0437231325,
0.0000022829,
-0.0364982858,
-0.007526794,
-0.0077957683,
-0.0759811774,
0.0239275619,
0.0242743734,
0.0251326039,
0.0230088104,
0.0074730976,
-0.0620291643,
-0.0509243049,
0.0451454259,
0.02358355,
0.0460630395,
0.0735005066,
0.0061239847,
0.009418794,
0.0041303085,
-0.027654849,
0.0378543884,
-0.0604116097,
0.0248693787,
-0.0439144745,
-0.0143397078,
0.006846176,
-0.0007446438,
0.0902634934,
0.0377780274,
-0.0270555187,
0.0189490039,
0.0261682272,
-0.0375050306,
0.0316538177,
-0.0095663313,
0.0450160615,
-0.0175342858,
-0.0421576127,
-0.0323414281,
-0.0194563922,
0.0097269043,
0.0100294184,
-0.0384309292,
0.004925828,
0.02069683,
0.0096099619,
-0.0091965487,
0.0267124735,
0.0622571111,
-0.0018625368,
-0.0460895188,
0.0632802397,
0.0005657187,
-0.0243148394,
0.0094504878,
-0.020391386,
-0.0422192737,
-0.0317001492,
0.0122462399,
0.055188708,
0.0061920681,
0.0365868993,
-0.0196727868,
-0.0126914773,
-0.0146958921,
-0.0727106407,
0.0976732448,
0.0315997563,
-0.0164406076,
0.0754106194,
-0.0417369716,
0.053214632,
-0.0140354624,
0.012450275,
-0.0452981927,
-0.0071614883,
-0.0532178879,
-0.0187857896,
-0.0534443446,
0.0544813126,
-0.004663677,
-0.012408331,
0.0051490562,
0.02809125,
-0.0041559921,
-0.0091910101,
-0.0174931083,
-0.0227271356,
-0.0030876843,
-0.0413162299,
-0.0428053401,
0.0248392932,
0.0146893952,
-0.0107446518,
-0.0085546291,
-0.0510036163,
0.0012377283,
-0.0046987631,
-0.0166523606,
-0.0061352868,
0.0154966973,
0.0630208999,
-0.0128821516,
-0.0600686334,
-0.0190252159,
-0.020587042,
0.0143324928,
-0.0435946621,
-0.0273752119,
-0.0430664569,
0.035297554,
0.0047876248,
-0.0183870997,
-0.0673919618,
0.0064963107,
-0.0018926996,
-0.0387120731,
0.064016141,
-0.0047166101,
0.0432425402,
0.0066330545,
0.016142847,
0.0293122921,
0.0654431358,
0.0001803156,
0.0060479129,
0.0292269569,
-0.0004195578,
0.0035886229,
0.043084126,
0.0565480702,
0.0068821581,
-0.0430030413,
0.0279438011,
0.0105043873,
0.000121217,
-0.017305281,
0.0286333151,
-0.0310954526,
0.0069431625,
0.0567819849,
0.0246544145,
0.0561700612,
-0.0090825902,
0.0532023422,
-0.0153442388,
0.0074001323,
-0.0527054109,
-0.0406566225,
0.0253770426,
-0.0928463414,
0.0005756596,
0.0432435721,
0.01229594,
-0.0447180606,
-0.0714195222,
-0.0022250302,
-0.0072454582,
-0.0441839173,
0.0613696538,
0.0621520877,
0.0117167011,
-0.0177305434,
0.0614150912,
0.0320452712,
-0.0412318259,
-0.0058559184,
-0.0660065264,
0.0120567717,
0.0613783039,
0.0649123341,
-0.0572144389,
-0.0314341709,
0.0364264995,
-0.001839449,
0.0178229306,
0.0503326245,
-0.0053603332,
0.029589802,
-0.0260991864,
-0.0477755181,
-0.0009758299,
-0.0024139578,
0.0091601098,
0.0419365466,
0.0179373566,
0.0218704157,
-0.0636931434,
-0.0195393972,
0.0332858711,
-0.0278543141,
-0.0387528129,
0.0034402926,
0.0041518509,
0.0259650461,
0.0008813891,
-0.0172682106,
0.0189197324,
0.0437225439,
-0.0405590795,
-0.0080321655,
-0.001947686,
-0.0503311753,
-0.0299366824,
0.0243169479,
0.0150003647,
0.0069729565,
0.0112454463,
0.0011340977,
-0.0318305492,
0.0031963214,
-0.0098710097,
0.0834918916,
-0.0546172895,
0.0085731465,
-0.0243602023,
-0.0051856684,
-0.0280234348,
0.0576541945,
-0.0153730847,
0.0190091692,
0.0160663594,
0.0036334328,
-0.003091282,
-0.0163087901,
-0.0576505065,
-0.0193021335,
0.0139618488,
0.0262386575,
0.0314373225,
-0.0033732213,
-0.0170621816,
-0.0057915472,
-0.0681193843,
0.004447673,
-0.0216966216,
-0.0191443749,
0.0100123072,
-0.0045566196,
-0.0179538708,
-0.0471363179,
-0.0197845027,
0.0369823985,
-0.0025430552,
0.0203709491,
0.0066264514,
0.0562104098,
-0.0184818991,
-0.0315354243,
-0.012258335,
0.0240008235,
0.0488939323,
0.0067713852,
-0.00526339,
-0.0442857817,
0.0938426033,
-0.0471280739,
0.0425950736,
-0.0098923771,
-0.043978963,
-0.0038752679,
-0.0813601688,
0.0000894577,
0.0459180474,
-0.0100092171,
-0.0000394078,
0.0600098036,
-0.0242964905,
-0.0744126663,
0.0269607212,
-0.0469152518,
-0.0394343697,
-0.0498139933,
0.055376973,
0.037546359,
0.0669586435,
-0.0327857994,
-0.0411178246,
-0.0492283478,
-0.0048344163,
-0.0134903407,
-0.0434744731,
-0.067761369,
0.012695034,
0.0286618173,
0.0438124314,
-0.0251376275,
-0.0660467297,
0.0749964863,
-0.0368295759,
-0.0034414805,
0.0326961316,
-0.0390774161,
-0.0119562102,
0.0727761462,
0.0159496404,
0.0173822772,
-0.0334775038,
-0.0097969733,
-0.0344050266,
0.0032002325,
-0.0072121555,
-0.0316306539,
0.0570114292,
-0.0451676659,
0.0287091918,
0.02436403,
-0.0578957424,
-0.0483833253,
-0.058954373,
0.0038366246,
-0.0060688602,
-0.0150376391,
-0.0057708612,
-0.029291274,
0.0350911543,
0.0622953139,
0.0485370606,
0.0142973624,
-0.0269834828,
-0.0167878866,
-0.0256359316,
0.0112484759,
0.0122444471,
0.0103729405,
-0.0479845405,
0.032539662,
0.0406092592,
0.0415845774,
-0.0580799207,
-0.0226731002,
0.0132380435,
0.0251739193,
-0.0283127185,
-0.0360208265,
0.0313901529,
0.0132003156,
-0.0839829445,
-0.0363458209,
0.1298586875,
0.0170715395,
-0.0507277511,
-0.028343007,
-0.0039140959,
0.0028826506,
0.0380416997,
0.0612164997,
-0.0464797728,
-0.0144365039,
-0.0018614751,
0.0007609458,
0.0102696763,
-0.0430528447,
-0.0059259287,
-0.1247086897,
0.0142010292,
0.0088598467,
-0.0407829285,
-0.0391390137,
-0.0026950662,
-0.0154054938,
0.0054799002,
-0.0058967033,
0.0376640931,
0.0084525617,
-0.000554012,
-0.0029599597,
0.0003406962,
-0.0382175446,
0.0379318707,
-0.0321262963,
0.0269776154,
0.0455514453,
-0.0050861668,
-0.0139181009,
-0.047041595,
-0.0068830564,
-0.0084796278,
0.0175877269,
-0.0036939583,
0.014664717,
-0.0141716069,
-0.0373448953,
0.0120055508,
-0.002048075,
-0.0360351838,
0.0185712017,
0.004012668,
0.0846777335,
-0.0284340959,
0.0122946063,
0.0038986497,
-0.0489349775,
0.0050507896,
0.077416718,
0.0325669162,
-0.0181618333,
-0.006372083,
-0.0183449108,
-0.0191890672,
-0.0044306042,
-0.0672311783,
0.0510980897,
0.0204843897,
0.004514371,
-0.0429551266,
-0.0247236472,
0.0350804888,
0.0778718442,
-0.0072018271,
0.0212679226,
0.005580307,
-0.0125851789,
-0.084040679,
0.003481112,
-0.0721259192,
-0.0243840963,
-0.0489697382,
-0.0259428974,
0.0131086698,
-0.0279099122,
-0.0156284422,
-0.0145365773,
-0.0241159089,
-0.0503901429,
0.014093779,
0.0814809948,
0.0221878868,
0.0324922018,
-0.0163923539,
-0.0546036512,
0.1077690497,
0.0297242403,
-0.0520962179,
0.0201174617,
0.0168612972,
-0.0233400781,
0.0029641823,
0.0534690917,
-0.0641469955,
0.0223267693,
0.0359323174,
0.0323749259,
-0.02003197,
-0.0647625253,
0.0255386867,
0.0529707931,
0.042218361,
0.0227692463,
-0.0393410064,
-0.0294285305,
0.0217895284,
-0.0183298513,
-0.0209562518,
-0.0697695464,
-0.0006052753,
0.0174687002,
-0.0064979242,
0.0191611592,
0.0043772133,
0.0260179676,
0.0189592894,
-0.0310058985,
-0.0251633469,
0.0118597047,
0.009349511,
0.0548230782,
0.0097197676,
0.00502099,
0.0208400916,
0.0038747417,
0.0142849805,
-0.0365683213,
0.0455736108,
0.0304096807,
0.0141691081,
-0.0464013815,
0.0323097073,
-0.0691337287,
-0.0793573856,
-0.0076718531,
0.0328839645,
0.063181147,
-0.0037644422,
0.0292541329,
-0.0390818007,
-0.0023544631,
-0.03740675,
0.0098311082,
0.0264335014,
-0.0476909764,
0.0472331382,
0.0327174999,
-0.0047061224,
0.0300856326,
0.0906888694,
-0.0362756178,
0.0505769476,
0.0000854668,
0.0040690606,
-0.0465182476,
-0.0120309908,
0.0446657613,
0.024057474,
-0.0181897711,
0.0311473701,
-0.025834389,
-0.0721201822,
-0.0217356328,
0.02354444,
-0.0498115718,
-0.0130806435,
0.0437417589,
0.081629999,
0.0151826991,
-0.009778942,
-0.0272332057,
-0.0057482473,
-0.0385383852,
0.0201744717,
0.036163196,
-7.01136536e-33,
-0.0655779019,
-0.0091456622,
0.0488639101,
-0.0150170205,
-0.0072345259,
0.0444268659,
-0.0409420952,
0.0057444097,
-0.0237070471,
0.0067883921,
-0.0104242219,
0.0281548165,
-0.0069772727,
0.0224702768,
0.0250783637,
0.0097440872,
0.021395456,
-0.0220349319,
0.0013719118,
0.0308187492,
0.0517750047,
0.0490612425,
0.0530568548,
-0.00846521,
-0.0193341486,
-0.0056891562,
0.0168720335,
0.0678646415,
0.0078398576,
0.0597006381,
-0.0403862186,
0.0401812382,
0.0039917673,
-0.0473862812,
-0.0497363582,
-0.0386601463,
-0.0357139483,
-0.0391843431,
0.0016824607,
-0.0121329511,
-0.0207948331,
-0.0091196885,
0.0465187877,
0.006389006,
0.0007126159,
0.0061577284,
0.0156797301,
-0.0440657176,
-0.0027888175,
-0.0150445104,
-0.0034072699,
0.014183294,
-0.0147673646,
-0.0217903648,
0.0623254254,
-0.0250264853,
-0.0061342232,
0.0023503944,
-0.0559413806,
0.0119542759,
-0.0028666013,
0.0518725216,
0.0556549877,
0.0195740815,
0.0251052119,
0.0412399322,
0.0291625038,
-0.0059331516,
-0.0138528785,
0.0260400344,
0.0718413666,
0.0444695316,
0.0187323503,
0.0411190763,
0.0329406261,
0.0124921007,
-0.0600780174,
0.0052330969,
0.0111850221,
0.012075291,
0.0359767526,
0.0204360597,
-0.0466774143,
-0.0301409867,
-0.0457980409,
0.0190772116,
-0.0422095843,
-0.034318503,
0.051650539,
0.0228744894,
0.0158327073,
-0.0414943248,
0.0418381058,
-0.0432959013,
0.0137829734,
0.025829535,
-0.0027957801,
0.0120010804,
-0.0084521426,
0.0439385325,
-0.0810764655,
-0.0338016078,
-0.0062000281,
-0.0157355499,
-0.0089727398,
0.0034543939,
0.0076839901,
0.0426201634,
-0.0723270997,
-0.0156320203,
-0.0355371088,
-0.0063213282,
0.0392162837,
-0.0204552859,
0.03672437,
0.0170065816,
0.0089276209,
0.0562188923,
-0.0086010061,
-0.062920019,
-0.0166994575,
-0.0012867393,
0.0043248171,
0.0076565999,
-0.0136545915,
0.0041880202,
-0.0504990965,
0.0003059728,
0.0253567994,
-0.0455975607,
0.0035514901,
0.0332549438,
2.925e-7,
0.0401492193,
0.014658737,
0.012895911,
0.0282495003,
0.0117912348,
0.032853134,
-0.0424273983,
-0.0086912271,
0.0064888224,
0.002621107,
0.0147104003,
0.0833937004,
0.038767729,
0.0255940706,
-0.0848079845,
-0.0286778547,
-0.0386099145,
-0.0271176305,
-0.0434526466,
-0.0257025268,
0.0300001856,
0.079439804,
0.0105663463,
-0.0028867412,
0.0084367823,
-0.0972940549,
0.06650123,
-0.0567949302,
0.002006755,
0.0242243093,
0.0293658543,
0.0583670363,
-0.0100010009,
0.0247057732,
0.0008721963,
0.0361849591,
0.0016539531,
0.0609762594,
0.0251939129,
-0.0245602597,
-0.0044169505,
0.0054462138,
-0.0135302953,
-0.0465586446,
0.0795708746,
-0.055316411,
-0.0050476436,
0.0136318225,
0.0384304114,
-0.0655199513,
-0.0097266017,
0.0018283514,
-0.0043724561,
0.0211195424,
0.0117819393,
-0.0200845655,
-0.0117013324,
-0.1079830229,
-0.031220885,
0.021296449,
-0.0271459464,
-0.0152814053,
-0.0522784777,
-0.0413103104,
0.0061583431,
-0.0437264964,
0.0326542445,
2.872960769e-34,
0.0280023143,
-0.0054009324,
0.016053075,
0.0234053433,
0.0318581872,
-0.0195643418,
-0.0358042531,
0.0178407095,
0.0061404174,
-0.1072755679,
-0.0112033617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10432v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10432v2 | PharmacyGPT: The AI Pharmacist | 2023-07-19T19:40:34 | 2023-07-21T02:22:14 | Zhengliang Liu, Zihao Wu, Mengxuan Hu, Bokai Zhao, Lin Zhao, Tianyi Zhang, Haixing Dai, Xianyan Chen, Ye Shen, Sheng Li, Brian Murray, Tianming Liu, Andrea Sikora | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we introduce PharmacyGPT, a novel framework to assess the
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 in
emulating the role of clinical pharmacists. Our methodology encompasses the
utilization of LLMs to generate comprehensible patient clusters, formulate
medication plans, and forecast patient outcomes. We conduct our investigation
using real data acquired from the intensive care unit (ICU) at the University
of North Carolina Chapel Hill (UNC) Hospital. Our analysis offers valuable
insights into the potential applications and limitations of LLMs in the field
of clinical pharmacy, with implications for both patient care and the
development of future AI-driven healthcare solutions. By evaluating the
performance of PharmacyGPT, we aim to contribute to the ongoing discourse
surrounding the integration of artificial intelligence in healthcare settings,
ultimately promoting the responsible and efficacious use of such technologies. | [
0.0312238541,
0.0481367707,
-0.0361286588,
0.0001066627,
-0.0331055261,
0.0267134029,
0.0315610617,
-0.0004398737,
0.0708820224,
0.008335989,
0.0174799673,
-0.035964027,
-0.0176459551,
0.0372428335,
0.0326863527,
-0.0350621752,
0.0094330236,
-0.0098295426,
0.0367359631,
0.0165266972,
-0.0090362178,
0.0317901671,
-0.036983408,
0.0767813623,
-0.0031489795,
0.0066654375,
0.0138811423,
-0.0333414339,
0.0125756077,
-0.0566179231,
-0.0151198534,
0.0058051301,
0.0055893799,
0.007004743,
0.0000019555,
-0.0568379201,
-0.004938886,
0.0445597433,
-0.0684639141,
-0.080564037,
0.0629325658,
-0.042627167,
0.005861633,
0.0340226851,
-0.048159644,
-0.0202458426,
0.0381944366,
0.0244615041,
0.0025759228,
0.0479217619,
-0.0123656308,
-0.015201292,
0.0162429679,
-0.0213462934,
-0.0015500264,
-0.070820801,
0.0371176563,
0.0293741282,
0.0703019947,
-0.0162456688,
0.006943306,
0.0445835404,
0.0101546012,
0.0167145282,
-0.0069606882,
0.0559534766,
-0.0545342378,
-0.0056984085,
-0.0135891913,
0.0194418188,
-0.0123066176,
-0.0069253989,
0.0274358205,
0.0221003462,
0.0015207768,
-0.0128778173,
-0.037435282,
0.0092990911,
-0.0243486576,
0.0093459627,
0.0057322006,
0.0067115612,
0.0389048569,
-0.0107803363,
-0.016080888,
0.0558079742,
0.0021302993,
-0.0193869025,
0.0240161847,
0.0077670161,
-0.0536027886,
-0.0063326843,
0.0228927713,
0.0417320654,
-0.0754354447,
0.029067792,
0.0093252175,
0.040954221,
0.0459530354,
-0.0563845411,
0.0280379709,
0.0059863026,
0.042855382,
0.0365654007,
-0.0006038386,
0.0221439693,
-0.0239923131,
0.0003724301,
-0.0702881292,
0.014139276,
-0.0969887823,
-0.0078228386,
-0.0366785899,
0.011914365,
0.0127368364,
-0.0199130587,
-0.0610656254,
-0.0111477794,
-0.0444993861,
0.0029733232,
0.0424955226,
0.0424024798,
-0.003238807,
-0.0121087218,
-0.0122219017,
0.0098941829,
-0.0125035895,
0.0220170207,
-0.0325886905,
-0.0429164767,
0.0522253998,
0.0128467102,
-0.0262741111,
-0.0018147394,
-0.0139551433,
0.0993451402,
0.0191761442,
-0.0079376465,
-0.025548961,
-0.0417360403,
-0.003256171,
-0.060981255,
0.0176400356,
-0.0523169897,
0.0596099943,
-0.0122982953,
0.0194373764,
-0.0356390402,
-0.0069284779,
-0.0046031652,
-0.0486740433,
0.0599836707,
-0.0263792649,
0.0190810058,
0.0472621173,
0.000865032,
-0.0100943437,
0.0166867897,
0.0229400359,
-0.0250635091,
-0.0134142768,
-0.0338572673,
0.0389893092,
0.0374679565,
-0.025206361,
-0.0396252163,
-0.0139873074,
-0.0038823716,
-0.0004171787,
0.0655022934,
-0.0604979992,
0.0591238029,
0.0022564437,
0.0022097365,
0.0342357159,
0.0633214787,
0.0225339141,
0.0272540282,
0.0525648333,
-0.0406804942,
-0.0052726348,
-0.0510270111,
-0.0197346564,
-0.0080633266,
-0.0068112118,
-0.0109468019,
-0.0267928634,
-0.0305050351,
-0.0247441288,
-0.0279828832,
-0.0134185953,
-0.0557805859,
-0.0024777325,
-0.0180295967,
0.0351673849,
-0.0564454719,
-0.0443830304,
0.0285232682,
0.0301814377,
-0.0167912263,
-0.0356715806,
-0.0730496645,
-0.0170468893,
0.1328714341,
0.0461172462,
-0.0359086171,
-0.0129473666,
-0.0355788693,
-0.008136861,
0.0012564964,
0.0386719219,
-0.0271271374,
-0.0081761517,
-0.0256439112,
0.0076039848,
0.0377376936,
0.006416149,
0.0202584267,
-0.0244761892,
0.0231469218,
-0.0353785641,
-0.0085168146,
-0.0314471163,
0.0248529911,
-0.0873771757,
-0.0425210446,
-0.0002763506,
-0.0055932226,
0.0291414279,
0.0458044633,
0.0100369435,
0.0085415244,
0.0354319364,
-0.0549390316,
-0.020797072,
0.0105515011,
-0.0027787741,
0.0085701477,
0.0159262829,
0.0029858781,
0.0087915435,
-0.0455165505,
-0.0333732516,
-0.0389594734,
0.0150201162,
-0.0513624139,
0.05495511,
0.0323271118,
0.0124808326,
0.0068484973,
0.0229010507,
-0.0376851112,
-0.0042968229,
-0.0149533702,
0.0037985228,
0.0124108875,
-0.0028822552,
0.0055632642,
0.0104401503,
0.012442275,
0.0134164291,
0.0156173008,
0.0479387492,
0.0049909223,
0.0085342983,
0.0053989491,
-0.0001025449,
-0.1109240726,
-0.0302128717,
0.0261574704,
-0.0160040259,
0.0182621628,
0.0078652045,
-0.0116838049,
-0.0052976659,
-0.0212392081,
0.007343946,
0.0004465729,
-0.0034448972,
0.0167741422,
0.0633618906,
-0.068876721,
-0.0304104723,
0.0035058639,
-0.0587149598,
0.0223183781,
0.0068966295,
-0.0297315679,
-0.0158270132,
-0.0224534664,
-0.0016702858,
0.004398773,
-0.0218612403,
-0.0105242692,
0.0267019924,
-0.034292873,
0.0112707596,
0.0220132787,
-0.0473815165,
0.010309224,
0.0345279798,
-0.0311190877,
0.0089465538,
0.0217260253,
-0.0402645171,
-0.0576754138,
0.0100716734,
-0.0568276942,
-0.0333117396,
0.0828272924,
0.0171814635,
0.0182064977,
-0.031417124,
0.005442766,
-0.0521164201,
-0.0024850096,
-0.0307440571,
0.0252848435,
-0.031808272,
0.0692680478,
0.0266987775,
-0.0482295752,
0.0612044111,
-0.0220630281,
0.0364878401,
-0.0819629356,
-0.047428295,
-0.033987131,
-0.0341839604,
0.0257932208,
0.0065333545,
-0.036216028,
0.0029523992,
0.005497444,
0.0091030169,
-0.0475967117,
-0.0286019482,
0.0914899632,
-0.0554503277,
0.0445243455,
0.0199341383,
-0.0200222284,
-0.0361065567,
0.0116955731,
-0.0487869903,
0.0099311825,
0.0437059328,
-0.0132441176,
-0.0573407672,
0.0463024974,
-0.019160755,
0.0452687778,
0.0156913679,
-0.0358289555,
0.0293526836,
-0.0342186838,
0.0362279117,
-0.0270672683,
0.0160146225,
-0.0148475552,
0.0602935106,
0.0238715578,
0.0262789018,
0.0147072654,
-0.0333334096,
0.0134636676,
-0.0171418879,
-0.0017832918,
-0.0120584937,
0.0524527058,
-0.0047081313,
-0.0295588747,
-0.0138616022,
0.1413250864,
0.0244609453,
-0.0643377826,
0.040797364,
-0.0134310387,
-0.0529505052,
-0.0231389962,
0.0386029072,
-0.0497705489,
-0.0158232227,
-0.0198471546,
0.0462418012,
-0.0336078182,
-0.0514339097,
-0.0099371755,
-0.047675848,
0.0414376855,
0.0298784971,
-0.0729968101,
-0.0093951635,
-0.0491274409,
-0.0129060959,
-0.0493605025,
0.0122910375,
-0.0113099553,
0.0067693614,
-0.0347577929,
-0.0021181714,
-0.0986382812,
-0.0352635719,
0.0379404873,
0.0013297636,
0.0439286381,
0.0897452012,
0.0257608686,
-0.0178402178,
0.0222783387,
-0.005697248,
0.0175920445,
0.0215469673,
0.0054075606,
0.0464168526,
0.0344406925,
0.0128043098,
-0.0316753425,
0.0328746215,
-0.08713644,
-0.0121090626,
0.0129056824,
0.0943396911,
-0.0486001261,
-0.0527463295,
-0.0486593917,
0.0319090225,
0.0205998514,
0.0309908222,
-0.0027511939,
-0.0107579911,
-0.0602271371,
-0.0257178098,
0.0273942277,
0.0080026677,
-0.0066658449,
0.0143892104,
0.0147791672,
-0.0166410767,
-0.0425787792,
-0.0472907573,
0.0386467054,
-0.0197450258,
0.0082083773,
0.0053406302,
0.0499349721,
-0.0002387591,
-0.0030617001,
-0.0219867341,
0.0101496251,
0.0500648953,
-0.0533322319,
-0.0547118969,
0.0246909875,
0.0021976628,
0.0105195828,
0.0349110365,
-0.0296704676,
-0.0384823829,
0.0519847684,
0.0823490843,
0.0284588635,
0.001782484,
-0.0042239232,
-0.0024446386,
0.0416166633,
0.0498865843,
-0.0236090515,
-0.0337767377,
-0.0524694063,
0.0278865732,
0.0076977876,
0.00004163,
-0.0192040056,
0.0768838599,
-0.0305137001,
0.0164598506,
-0.0184394624,
-0.0271184575,
0.0040725367,
0.0190351177,
-0.0208733995,
0.0039741877,
0.0213202853,
-0.0248102564,
0.0063098636,
-0.0481733717,
0.0317231342,
-0.0156217366,
-0.0280724596,
0.0517822094,
-0.0047116606,
0.0106033087,
-0.032152608,
-0.0582293943,
-0.0810254291,
-0.007230815,
0.0175682697,
0.0375243388,
0.024419399,
0.0573223121,
-0.0017083251,
0.007793311,
0.015044719,
-0.0315225348,
0.051553376,
-0.0047737216,
0.0909799561,
-0.0375014134,
0.028297849,
-0.0228212569,
0.0723373666,
-0.030611217,
-0.1028292701,
-0.0189545881,
0.0636186749,
0.0367763452,
-0.0394134484,
0.0266167,
-0.0704481676,
0.022261709,
-0.066036284,
0.0173714478,
0.0120913265,
0.030793054,
0.007749741,
0.0332964808,
-0.0257077161,
-0.0282512922,
0.1136804298,
-0.0122658014,
0.049669154,
0.0003258144,
-0.0300255194,
-0.0490974709,
-0.0278488453,
-0.002731527,
-0.0080537302,
-0.0521801449,
0.0099965585,
-0.0453624949,
-0.045885291,
0.0038615488,
0.0081224302,
-0.0082553159,
-0.0249905474,
0.037918184,
0.0356248952,
-0.0029202185,
0.0052058124,
-0.0299244728,
0.0209968425,
-0.0337281674,
-0.0022227122,
-0.0048061791,
-5.184354e-33,
0.0299134906,
-0.0342532694,
0.0311148055,
0.0166093111,
0.0314373411,
0.0161789563,
-0.0352105834,
0.0147521598,
-0.000899825,
0.057590615,
-0.021796871,
0.007310275,
-0.0019052906,
0.012911167,
0.0376477838,
-0.0290762726,
0.0015353314,
0.0100393631,
0.0196511783,
0.0463069379,
-0.0278883539,
0.0520929061,
0.01802692,
-0.0456180312,
0.0021277533,
-0.0188935995,
0.0377820656,
-0.0092488639,
-0.0095146345,
0.0589154139,
-0.0346929766,
0.0494616069,
0.0445115454,
-0.0119464668,
-0.0175481904,
0.0002686185,
-0.0020292851,
-0.0094938474,
0.0071394593,
-0.0153476177,
-0.0291163474,
-0.0177495871,
0.0354808234,
-0.013645866,
-0.0441381745,
0.017339889,
0.0100476975,
-0.0500293039,
0.0000541404,
0.0023513767,
-0.0614653938,
0.0421791561,
-0.0282421783,
-0.0013710164,
0.0168569218,
0.0165888108,
-0.0507281646,
0.018434329,
-0.0309212394,
-0.0025906421,
-0.0277119409,
-0.0047150417,
0.0259546693,
-0.0241352245,
-0.0129965413,
0.0352198146,
0.0493777208,
0.0363261364,
-0.0199340731,
0.0268848483,
-0.0550773107,
0.0534730814,
0.0472070761,
0.0093277907,
-0.027881505,
-0.0139708295,
-0.0524368882,
0.0313508138,
-0.0523130521,
0.0269531403,
0.0193420481,
-0.0076799318,
-0.06707865,
-0.0460601002,
0.0060065561,
0.0138723878,
-0.0148013849,
-0.0220208392,
0.0160142332,
-0.0409437008,
0.020121064,
0.02803245,
0.026658522,
-0.0508793779,
0.0144587867,
-0.0177362487,
0.0546004958,
0.0328255743,
-0.0104791252,
0.0114495382,
-0.0613797829,
-0.0222611912,
0.0012465618,
0.0079727108,
0.0426035412,
0.0099957911,
0.0009391722,
-0.0204093978,
-0.0068128924,
-0.0122436136,
0.0028875717,
0.0020633996,
0.0101709822,
0.0134851253,
0.0474512316,
0.0292300694,
0.0247773882,
0.069473058,
0.0124984905,
-0.057521075,
-0.0114516327,
-0.0056495201,
0.0029687816,
-0.0327082053,
-0.0688359439,
0.004175439,
-0.0663532466,
0.0500798076,
0.0362997092,
-0.0677238256,
-0.0134571847,
-0.0197618138,
2.745e-7,
0.1078558713,
0.0632648095,
0.0164149515,
-0.018579999,
0.0354711264,
-0.0017346656,
-0.0038437087,
-0.0016986051,
-0.0277237017,
-0.0128642507,
0.0833162814,
-0.0083730258,
0.0585205853,
0.0436402895,
-0.0374789499,
-0.0147702629,
-0.0720721632,
-0.0464789793,
-0.065691486,
-0.0327826627,
0.0446027666,
0.0523831733,
-0.006463862,
-0.0358296521,
0.0253796875,
-0.0329757631,
0.0078409873,
-0.0556964837,
0.0084858537,
0.0596234947,
-0.0021736561,
0.017636545,
0.0037717526,
0.0581391826,
-0.0003164681,
-0.0186639801,
-0.0145526063,
0.1036323979,
-0.0644925758,
0.0370329618,
0.0573933795,
-0.0231453329,
0.0227028932,
-0.0623466074,
0.0323759466,
-0.0506612882,
-0.0530494042,
-0.0306162238,
-0.0023353798,
-0.0190348942,
0.0787363872,
-0.0215510484,
-0.0033224714,
0.0676256046,
0.0153478095,
0.0162451509,
-0.0008530167,
-0.0308276787,
0.003241556,
0.0424112529,
-0.0567126572,
-0.0182391088,
0.0345161557,
-0.0257974248,
0.0181497559,
-0.0367167257,
0.0437345505,
2.089494932e-34,
0.0458403379,
0.0051417863,
0.0380137712,
0.0213664137,
0.0722928271,
0.0064177243,
0.003939854,
0.025616277,
-0.0061433492,
-0.0719244331,
-0.0369842537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10172v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10172v3 | DialogStudio: Towards Richest and Most Diverse Unified Dataset Collection for Conversational AI | 2023-07-19T17:57:53 | 2024-02-05T08:10:52 | Jianguo Zhang, Kun Qian, Zhiwei Liu, Shelby Heinecke, Rui Meng, Ye Liu, Zhou Yu, Huan Wang, Silvio Savarese, Caiming Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite advancements in conversational AI, language models encounter
challenges to handle diverse conversational tasks, and existing dialogue
dataset collections often lack diversity and comprehensiveness. To tackle these
issues, we introduce DialogStudio: the largest and most diverse collection of
dialogue datasets, unified under a consistent format while preserving their
original information. Our collection encompasses data from open-domain
dialogues, task-oriented dialogues, natural language understanding,
conversational recommendation, dialogue summarization, and knowledge-grounded
dialogues, making it an incredibly rich and diverse resource for dialogue
research and model training. To further enhance the utility of DialogStudio, we
identify the licenses for each dataset, design external knowledge and
domain-aware prompts for selected dialogues to facilitate instruction-aware
fine-tuning. Furthermore, we develop conversational AI models using the dataset
collection, and our experiments in both zero-shot and few-shot learning
scenarios demonstrate the superiority of DialogStudio. To improve transparency
and support dataset and task-based research, as well as language model
pre-training, all datasets, licenses, codes, and models associated with
DialogStudio are made publicly
accessible\footnote{\url{https://github.com/salesforce/DialogStudio}}. | [
0.0477291085,
0.0772480667,
0.0003821227,
0.0440201163,
-0.0024274427,
0.0253496431,
0.0176554713,
-0.0466141887,
0.0305443574,
-0.0307326764,
-0.0562846921,
-0.0090796212,
-0.0101370895,
0.0655646324,
-0.0021394349,
-0.0566478595,
0.0366018116,
-0.0384241007,
0.0414585918,
0.0143036563,
0.020955367,
0.0295901317,
-0.0460261479,
0.0614220314,
0.0061657433,
-0.0273626056,
-0.0314235911,
0.0038803783,
0.0159854665,
-0.0092036119,
0.0371858478,
0.0485624224,
0.0429141261,
0.0376911387,
0.000001768,
-0.0323383212,
0.0237144306,
-0.043165151,
-0.0626619011,
-0.0295458883,
0.0032288134,
0.004685374,
0.0130015854,
0.0245871078,
-0.0450158864,
-0.0051471414,
0.0324165411,
0.0553587601,
0.06657058,
0.0900707841,
-0.0009940033,
-0.0218583569,
0.0104605388,
-0.0448501334,
-0.0116996076,
-0.0427894183,
-0.0257964768,
0.0322364084,
0.0040418664,
0.0196166132,
0.0097757,
0.0048804805,
0.0188249312,
-0.0457998589,
-0.0097155329,
0.0172122959,
-0.059922155,
-0.0339880735,
-0.0190973766,
0.1381195039,
0.0269143507,
0.0228648931,
0.0061573633,
0.003520987,
0.0062238961,
-0.0552668497,
-0.0827348456,
0.0210184082,
0.0138927503,
-0.0053215199,
-0.0405726433,
0.013893716,
-0.0048462818,
0.0147134503,
0.0001085012,
0.0062721726,
-0.0105016781,
0.0143832462,
-0.0035303845,
-0.0216444563,
-0.0164718293,
-0.085115701,
-0.0313225947,
0.0140698142,
-0.0693293288,
0.0248964038,
-0.0505686961,
0.0078835431,
0.0336329639,
0.0143071087,
0.0132723544,
0.0226820037,
-0.0143009583,
0.0758199841,
0.0309285186,
0.0320727006,
0.0201769676,
0.0083064903,
-0.0178482309,
-0.0269570854,
-0.0422701575,
0.0045487038,
-0.0437978841,
0.0163596999,
-0.0587597825,
-0.0431028344,
0.0033588898,
0.0500313565,
-0.0188482627,
0.0248348117,
0.008751695,
0.0332536511,
-0.0356015265,
-0.0071296003,
-0.0178188384,
0.0302483104,
-0.0518581197,
0.026903132,
0.0589319132,
-0.0656609833,
-0.0421731807,
0.0200138465,
0.0138393454,
-0.0114076454,
-0.0242468342,
0.0485122688,
-0.0167297833,
-0.0437788852,
0.0251832921,
-0.0055835685,
-0.0232267082,
-0.0556887314,
-0.0171847567,
-0.0126903905,
0.0556969903,
-0.031799484,
-0.0159301814,
-0.0426629595,
0.0312500708,
0.0112120099,
-0.0026870528,
0.0736550391,
-0.0263742618,
-0.0227978118,
0.039666038,
0.0248209555,
-0.02975237,
0.0900991485,
0.0245340131,
0.0180617291,
0.049122829,
0.0117083658,
0.0069281245,
0.005303862,
0.027274657,
0.0120188901,
0.0064259609,
0.0657241717,
-0.0291317087,
0.0251780152,
0.0204281881,
0.0315324366,
-0.0561610386,
-0.0068869768,
0.0402188264,
0.0403264947,
-0.0129981562,
0.0107330279,
-0.005339934,
0.0676862299,
0.0176135711,
-0.0369393714,
-0.0560574122,
0.0472723842,
0.0179344136,
0.0087322695,
0.0388437249,
0.018471159,
-0.0305082854,
-0.0450564362,
0.0114665711,
-0.021942718,
0.0026983768,
0.0196084902,
-0.0048999321,
0.0256339181,
-0.0586472265,
0.0423278064,
0.0138674956,
-0.0697673187,
-0.0632121339,
-0.010298158,
0.0361661874,
0.0527355932,
0.0534637943,
-0.0503296331,
-0.0841705203,
-0.0358621143,
0.0535601974,
0.0356076583,
0.0512361787,
-0.0390760973,
0.0633787438,
-0.0752418041,
-0.0291442648,
-0.0431826673,
0.0037835988,
0.0312002227,
0.0039784918,
-0.0110025909,
0.0133575387,
0.0017391298,
-0.0197257027,
-0.0050511719,
-0.0168861467,
-0.0137078371,
0.035489738,
-0.0097477026,
0.0405803137,
0.0356326066,
-0.0135266203,
-0.0192917474,
0.0321464986,
0.0067225955,
-0.001202493,
0.0450144187,
-0.0654287785,
-0.0705096051,
0.0370958224,
-0.0227855463,
-0.0245344061,
0.016375633,
-0.0618179515,
-0.0489954762,
0.0442890041,
-0.0237744953,
0.005287834,
-0.0282371305,
0.0023328932,
0.0210431032,
0.0219008513,
0.0164785441,
0.036846973,
0.0081901401,
-0.0330777243,
0.0551843345,
0.0495918877,
0.0279016234,
-0.0467190519,
0.027847534,
0.0152370725,
-0.0202634539,
0.0101236012,
0.0276266877,
0.0144749759,
-0.0642784387,
-0.0287991557,
-0.1150032282,
0.0115581062,
-0.0090290643,
-0.0218725931,
0.0081286756,
0.0230876189,
-0.0025233282,
-0.0355680548,
-0.0221677199,
-0.0016986827,
0.0362525359,
-0.0270847436,
0.0180256832,
0.0130125461,
0.010805387,
-0.071117416,
0.0173436813,
0.0315620005,
0.0298161339,
-0.0299502127,
0.038005773,
0.0002942098,
0.0011190693,
-0.0567868128,
0.0497534722,
-0.042670805,
-0.0338726565,
0.0275278296,
0.0157822892,
0.0281114802,
0.0596947409,
0.0293102469,
0.0201845206,
0.0140711758,
-0.0118849203,
-0.0472853631,
0.0525466278,
0.0132576274,
0.0069931853,
-0.0178394224,
0.0133755375,
0.0116819805,
0.0405540243,
-0.0036230709,
0.0190231521,
-0.0466539524,
0.0480956249,
0.0421178043,
-0.0375676863,
-0.0009312872,
-0.0070573604,
-0.0258638877,
0.0271713715,
-0.046784915,
-0.0227657259,
0.0668245405,
-0.0325448699,
-0.0343509167,
-0.0614344403,
-0.0090520587,
-0.0520118661,
0.0478411168,
-0.0245312322,
-0.0081813494,
-0.00626546,
-0.0161449108,
-0.0196250845,
-0.0173753686,
0.0249961633,
-0.0212625507,
0.0516860858,
-0.0501203351,
-0.0017538294,
-0.0000620333,
-0.0508117191,
-0.0495765917,
-0.0080268169,
-0.0467449501,
-0.0013374878,
0.0195022821,
-0.0146303633,
-0.0377044491,
-0.0414809547,
0.0118038664,
0.0543789938,
-0.0123277074,
0.0158772264,
-0.0210575499,
0.0326482579,
0.0772005916,
0.0235124417,
0.0085651809,
0.0076398607,
0.0846933126,
0.030237522,
0.0351993926,
-0.0160349663,
-0.0281022806,
-0.0131855151,
-0.0064429748,
0.009638275,
0.0196687207,
-0.0107468693,
0.0761209279,
-0.0143627459,
-0.0234453604,
0.1305246353,
0.0097550377,
-0.0438258275,
-0.0114574097,
-0.0194669385,
0.0398352258,
0.0322764441,
0.0023982963,
-0.1079100072,
-0.0567426085,
0.0050372449,
0.018779695,
0.0100359535,
-0.0341516212,
-0.0210345499,
-0.0881444588,
0.0271745436,
-0.0083143553,
-0.022890145,
-0.0193492956,
-0.0021910451,
-0.0017468007,
-0.034636803,
0.0370832048,
-0.0120369289,
0.0124961184,
-0.0041722972,
-0.0097658643,
0.0067322343,
-0.0129942819,
0.0387042835,
-0.0087471064,
0.0730923936,
0.0590585843,
0.0515917093,
0.0475609079,
0.0331129171,
0.0273599606,
0.0038501227,
-0.0201744456,
0.0070549706,
0.0737223923,
-0.0157256648,
-0.0250240155,
-0.004811164,
0.0486730337,
-0.0235584248,
-0.0335124359,
0.0322974473,
-0.0025736424,
-0.0435317308,
0.0172152277,
-0.0166621432,
0.0452868678,
0.037114311,
0.066852428,
0.0614279471,
-0.016336903,
-0.015781818,
-0.0335609093,
0.0012425403,
-0.0634403676,
0.024372546,
-0.0203809291,
0.0355426297,
0.0109163253,
-0.0683927611,
-0.0574177615,
0.026213171,
-0.0128530478,
-0.0018073067,
-0.0291448906,
-0.0167690925,
0.0244960971,
-0.0075461576,
0.0466129035,
-0.0165821929,
-0.0070609609,
-0.0544530749,
-0.0296431631,
0.0396046266,
-0.0216251034,
-0.0239175316,
0.0405297503,
-0.0848075598,
-0.0551674217,
-0.0436836854,
0.0762913227,
0.0190392938,
0.0772258639,
-0.0093804561,
-0.0332863107,
-0.001137638,
0.0053241206,
-0.0429056287,
-0.0311782081,
0.0530615374,
0.0442212187,
-0.0022843624,
0.0530256853,
-0.0497159958,
0.0198344905,
-0.0364620835,
0.0050671473,
-0.037555676,
-0.0702438951,
-0.0210886337,
-0.0144410077,
0.0131954132,
0.0348373912,
0.0042859339,
-0.0477854013,
0.0362227894,
-0.022695858,
-0.0178998355,
-0.0687752292,
0.0213592909,
-0.0092942389,
-0.0448470712,
0.0129011888,
0.0021232311,
-0.0390271805,
0.0446325019,
-0.0234015137,
0.0116774058,
0.0307340026,
-0.0190832373,
-0.0086836955,
-0.0242210403,
-0.0382236354,
0.0433695465,
-0.0181749277,
0.0295246504,
-0.0092021469,
0.0759754255,
0.0205561146,
-0.0489224754,
0.0452475436,
0.0428510085,
-0.0644060597,
-0.0588794686,
-0.0096949721,
0.026542848,
0.0169024393,
0.0000969647,
0.0512336195,
-0.009600549,
0.0229401328,
-0.0114258314,
0.0458670594,
-0.0139717013,
-0.0497264415,
0.0202088263,
0.0325344168,
-0.0165822376,
0.024587309,
0.0834909379,
-0.0020941577,
0.0279746279,
0.0111407125,
0.056863822,
-0.056840498,
-0.0321270972,
0.0122894328,
0.0364019983,
0.0005447502,
0.0279291142,
-0.0064479662,
-0.0395837165,
-0.0051938002,
-0.0124617089,
-0.0261017475,
0.0020382495,
0.0573683381,
0.0248503909,
-0.0084776254,
-0.0071452474,
-0.0201103706,
-0.0028732345,
-0.0243873876,
-0.0276595559,
-0.0377049446,
-5.280949881e-33,
-0.026997894,
0.0065019508,
0.0091692088,
-0.0275890548,
-0.0180608686,
-0.012335021,
-0.0537250377,
-0.0140336212,
-0.0367126763,
-0.004542768,
-0.0165948961,
0.0619687587,
-0.0032133495,
0.0713614747,
-0.0122340294,
-0.0273401067,
0.0456791073,
-0.0219627526,
-0.0104489075,
0.0729209632,
0.0171993058,
0.0029335713,
0.0360485576,
-0.0563375577,
0.0120476354,
-0.0046396828,
-0.0084856562,
0.0424485654,
0.0227092393,
0.0562475994,
-0.0048976042,
0.0313560627,
-0.00338073,
-0.0433616526,
-0.0257130433,
-0.0038230072,
-0.0539938435,
-0.0321460925,
0.0207116865,
-0.0032250418,
-0.0311633721,
-0.0342851877,
-0.0071833963,
-0.0328964181,
0.036824923,
-0.0320894681,
0.0091990428,
-0.0341810733,
-0.0000789031,
0.0116568869,
-0.0408232622,
0.0036338079,
-0.0719361603,
-0.0826453045,
0.0066264784,
0.0629275814,
0.0329994261,
-0.013100191,
-0.0272522531,
0.0320885256,
0.0130464332,
-0.0068178736,
0.0490990132,
0.0111919837,
0.0024829002,
0.0711927265,
0.0268235188,
0.004210399,
-0.0257851034,
-0.0140289459,
-0.0304482337,
0.0771214366,
-0.0018014739,
0.0624311417,
-0.0256091133,
-0.0081219804,
-0.0146126021,
0.026665749,
0.0255090483,
0.031925004,
-0.0193620864,
-0.0003949556,
-0.0093297474,
0.007427691,
-0.0442002714,
-0.0096716257,
-0.013845793,
-0.0112224389,
0.0322009698,
0.0209702142,
-0.0113298995,
-0.0209760871,
0.0229207333,
-0.0461968929,
0.0146417161,
0.0714748204,
-0.017562123,
-0.0221187752,
0.0136141637,
0.0144069754,
-0.0475953259,
-0.0057430579,
0.0899460465,
0.0085633043,
0.007480768,
0.0128273414,
0.0200956482,
-0.0113840196,
-0.0357011259,
0.0166274048,
-0.0227078032,
0.0709832758,
-0.0498663746,
0.0503078774,
-0.0107465079,
0.0357528292,
-0.039609924,
0.0749333352,
-0.010106043,
-0.0039647422,
-0.0298425145,
-0.0373906158,
0.0094758961,
0.0146136098,
-0.0564217195,
-0.0219747573,
-0.0231614336,
-0.0442835093,
0.0173500702,
-0.0319203436,
-0.0083827581,
-0.0238908939,
2.315e-7,
-0.0265782122,
0.0240556151,
0.042738989,
0.0298254602,
0.0206537843,
0.0417004526,
-0.0051012752,
0.0310319141,
0.007119942,
-0.0154318009,
0.0103293844,
0.0404244326,
0.0501429252,
0.0057736393,
-0.0999237299,
-0.0259081982,
-0.0811412707,
-0.0349592082,
-0.0596130453,
-0.0255388133,
0.0347203985,
0.1108965799,
-0.0023426241,
0.0047253948,
0.0034992185,
-0.0197283048,
0.0189090949,
-0.0392192267,
-0.0109432768,
0.0205086172,
0.0479830578,
0.0171208046,
-0.0131833954,
-0.0299291629,
-0.0261275005,
0.0254466794,
-0.0011321752,
0.0586607009,
0.0042384272,
-0.0827634335,
-0.0152098862,
0.0120448358,
0.0075118085,
-0.0354735442,
0.0643935874,
-0.0500543602,
-0.0248472989,
-0.0393354371,
-0.0342354663,
-0.0042494438,
0.0109526934,
-0.0285978764,
0.0030949623,
0.0068842452,
0.0046785856,
-0.018165553,
0.0338239595,
-0.085215278,
-0.013423549,
-0.0248984192,
-0.0367921554,
-0.0250855535,
-0.0382125862,
-0.0296201594,
0.005434786,
-0.0219216328,
0.032080695,
1.796008316e-34,
0.0505772568,
-0.007307712,
0.001235717,
0.0401109643,
0.0440777913,
-0.0440756716,
0.016758861,
-0.0285910647,
0.0368733257,
-0.0569134988,
-0.0110516259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10169v1 | Challenges and Applications of Large Language Models | 2023-07-19T17:55:13 | 2023-07-19T17:55:13 | Jean Kaddour, Joshua Harris, Maximilian Mozes, Herbie Bradley, Roberta Raileanu, Robert McHardy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) went from non-existent to ubiquitous in the
machine learning discourse within a few years. Due to the fast pace of the
field, it is difficult to identify the remaining challenges and already
fruitful application areas. In this paper, we aim to establish a systematic set
of open problems and application successes so that ML researchers can
comprehend the field's current state more quickly and become productive. | [
0.0241727345,
0.0874939412,
-0.0149268946,
0.0633608401,
-0.0425168835,
0.0073778047,
0.0350413248,
0.0283118337,
0.0133523429,
-0.0527314954,
-0.0305743981,
-0.057365939,
0.0098253228,
0.018792754,
0.0184192806,
-0.0092401579,
-0.0133205894,
-0.050922472,
-0.0295477584,
-0.0316615626,
-0.0213079844,
0.0131719708,
0.0423483439,
0.0430961065,
-0.0025853396,
-0.0147684515,
0.0346221514,
-0.0138286473,
-0.0191696249,
-0.0037946869,
-0.0132759986,
0.0063070501,
0.0168862343,
0.0826877132,
0.0000016734,
-0.0662819818,
-0.0088268155,
0.0082302103,
-0.0096877664,
0.0323472023,
0.0445697308,
-0.0429053158,
-0.0182140339,
0.0299618226,
-0.0070645511,
-0.0264720879,
0.0609807447,
0.0135808196,
0.020980427,
0.0720623806,
-0.0182501357,
-0.0574751981,
0.0131247696,
-0.0616748631,
-0.0413724817,
-0.0343427584,
0.0742663965,
-0.0056772344,
0.0167720355,
-0.0186632778,
-0.0286623742,
0.0322720148,
-0.0067348252,
-0.0096013201,
-0.0265631452,
0.025336368,
-0.0170467179,
0.0034774484,
0.0181749351,
0.0321456119,
-0.025884863,
-0.0175761152,
0.0146197965,
-0.0121456999,
-0.0268672965,
0.0047613136,
-0.0248373393,
0.0648232698,
0.0101623805,
0.0557648391,
0.021528855,
-0.0193120968,
0.0683887303,
0.0169860907,
-0.0440953225,
0.0655541494,
0.0355248451,
-0.0034938739,
-0.0089513622,
-0.0070185014,
-0.020121038,
-0.0296225045,
0.0003127476,
0.0341972224,
-0.0197399948,
0.0246088374,
-0.0322151668,
-0.0262943469,
0.0216632001,
-0.0734049529,
0.0631924942,
-0.0264281034,
0.0070200339,
0.0857503638,
-0.0228485521,
0.0265185405,
-0.0540124923,
-0.0213743094,
-0.0395539217,
-0.0282643083,
-0.0186953992,
0.0128348973,
-0.0407562107,
0.0135942111,
-0.0056354143,
-0.0056087859,
-0.0302093495,
0.0348476991,
0.0082346769,
0.0374831557,
-0.0085916035,
-0.0437544473,
0.0062737707,
-0.0462473817,
0.0344177373,
0.0423916504,
0.0308794603,
0.0128119886,
-0.0650269985,
-0.0347441062,
0.0205339994,
0.0439764149,
0.0115096811,
-0.013306981,
0.0175881162,
0.0555879287,
0.0379078165,
-0.0303147789,
-0.0305553544,
0.0263448469,
-0.0301155522,
-0.0802728981,
-0.0608937703,
-0.076397337,
0.0063317525,
0.02235955,
0.0294495597,
-0.0532275513,
0.0176330954,
0.0067617851,
-0.0554804727,
0.0617209822,
-0.0131423082,
0.0185140148,
0.0132988514,
-0.0310276169,
0.0382647216,
0.0885939524,
0.0058076656,
-0.0092960857,
0.0440995619,
-0.0360200852,
-0.0004954026,
0.087832056,
-0.0009028799,
0.0229653846,
-0.0410049595,
-0.0148070846,
0.0684047341,
0.0353934839,
-0.0023497294,
0.0773718879,
0.0139711164,
-0.0232373439,
0.050286632,
0.0410356894,
0.0197460484,
0.0137178814,
0.0162256043,
0.0030293958,
-0.0076842979,
-0.0299672261,
0.0040809694,
-0.046767164,
-0.0254019666,
-0.0173915699,
0.0190206058,
0.049126558,
-0.0348449387,
-0.0120994709,
-0.0421463475,
-0.0494759455,
-0.0114171784,
0.0179914776,
0.1014517546,
-0.0360752419,
0.009815569,
0.012687631,
0.0355594158,
0.0038317842,
0.0243787132,
-0.0708625466,
0.0237267781,
0.0348432697,
0.0413552783,
-0.0366142392,
0.0147041529,
-0.0012217874,
0.0144005148,
0.0114755528,
0.0040173628,
-0.0095896507,
0.0053462945,
-0.0236439705,
0.0376477279,
0.0259612799,
0.0094678076,
-0.0078429179,
0.0138905393,
0.0296093281,
0.0106921503,
-0.0078564147,
-0.025690496,
0.0151525736,
-0.0167527422,
0.0142370192,
0.0412964262,
-0.0022131046,
0.0438305587,
-0.0008677673,
-0.0381796025,
-0.0082150679,
0.0310475696,
-0.0693465471,
-0.0191263761,
-0.0256969091,
0.0283421986,
-0.0061145211,
0.056864135,
0.0037213808,
-0.0157728959,
0.0154760461,
-0.0320352614,
-0.0195171572,
0.0034663966,
-0.0270650424,
0.055892121,
-0.0433942676,
0.0319627188,
-0.0314314067,
0.0431333482,
-0.0519176014,
0.0354812965,
0.0123748723,
0.0487629808,
-0.0151622742,
-0.0161840376,
0.0248414297,
0.0026149214,
-0.0665360838,
0.0677075014,
0.0072377701,
0.0346129835,
0.0165487658,
-0.0173550416,
0.0113491043,
-0.0433833115,
-0.0738526583,
-0.0218004696,
-0.0495834984,
-0.0002574984,
-0.010211166,
-0.0125461156,
-0.0119520258,
-0.0083294921,
-0.0244447999,
0.0054392722,
0.0300204139,
0.0280194841,
0.0221451782,
0.0074904859,
-0.0450923704,
-0.0126731209,
-0.0494080819,
0.0151811242,
0.0928795338,
-0.0278972238,
-0.032504186,
-0.0832172483,
0.0337789506,
-0.0077111642,
0.0260342471,
-0.0201357864,
0.0082548792,
-0.0342973284,
-0.0342731029,
0.0406616181,
0.0392399617,
-0.0006027965,
0.031775821,
0.0685920417,
0.0033654238,
0.0046941475,
-0.0211078003,
-0.0210312493,
-0.0440676697,
-0.0605412871,
-0.0094647165,
-0.001246732,
0.0381909274,
-0.0303753428,
-0.0351584405,
-0.0008539043,
0.0102383271,
-0.0438803099,
0.0054530129,
-0.0311666057,
0.0006605588,
-0.0115633085,
0.0375645459,
0.0133576095,
-0.0687672421,
0.0339625999,
-0.0451661795,
0.0023511099,
-0.0244928394,
-0.0533653013,
-0.0749600306,
0.0755014941,
0.014440082,
0.0202762112,
-0.0176273677,
-0.0192488302,
0.0048468607,
-0.0003391898,
-0.0212414805,
-0.0213689171,
0.0748468712,
-0.028481828,
0.0431962907,
-0.0058241067,
-0.0361444801,
-0.019131301,
-0.0707396567,
-0.0665247068,
-0.003536266,
0.027696399,
-0.0364081785,
-0.0441945158,
0.0446564071,
-0.0053094868,
0.0044141789,
0.0236056391,
0.0246763714,
-0.0017348137,
0.0282001495,
0.0612632446,
-0.0005564782,
0.002193637,
-0.0283147041,
0.0103454059,
0.0406010486,
0.0389840715,
0.0273424275,
-0.0319587626,
-0.0184995551,
0.0741773844,
-0.0436610729,
-0.0184544008,
-0.0010110886,
-0.0041803941,
-0.0302135795,
0.0200736523,
0.1147480085,
0.0236514658,
-0.0565756597,
0.0171669405,
0.0067782672,
0.0347982273,
0.0044050273,
0.0308548454,
-0.0548195019,
0.0055410727,
-0.0168436188,
-0.0265617557,
0.0095524071,
-0.0194476116,
-0.0108642047,
-0.119124338,
0.0419051163,
0.0340464376,
-0.0082242088,
-0.0493244305,
-0.0309077892,
0.0062640156,
-0.0281151943,
0.0257795881,
-0.0205368455,
-0.0294644777,
-0.0556704178,
0.0186772496,
-0.0374891981,
-0.0703925788,
0.0214461256,
-0.0540021732,
0.0449114405,
0.0390993804,
0.021676559,
-0.0223275628,
-0.0085915495,
0.0003607507,
0.000058136,
-0.0326939188,
-0.018951185,
-0.0080771297,
-0.0048707877,
-0.0368963443,
0.0088654943,
0.0254185386,
-0.0324084796,
0.0038253684,
0.0264765099,
0.0858093053,
-0.0158465654,
-0.0178363714,
0.0233993754,
-0.033464063,
-0.0239286926,
0.0606766678,
0.0119387945,
-0.0876961052,
0.0005419811,
-0.012069609,
-0.0377549678,
0.0355023369,
-0.0246789102,
0.0119451862,
-0.0071837679,
-0.0119227162,
-0.0280055031,
0.012382227,
0.0505654402,
0.017271515,
-0.0044013467,
0.057529103,
0.035226021,
-0.0152364066,
-0.0340866968,
0.0071418993,
-0.0621617548,
0.0289819911,
-0.065827854,
0.0071731764,
0.0661277696,
-0.0101113776,
-0.0042568343,
0.0145975156,
-0.1239416078,
-0.0798293501,
-0.0090500573,
-0.003708835,
0.0161291398,
0.0210462399,
-0.0182509422,
-0.0789417028,
0.0232246276,
0.0094788717,
-0.0122825736,
0.0385821015,
0.0054976456,
0.0015682142,
0.0029226395,
0.0708798468,
-0.022622481,
0.0012825535,
0.0127666434,
-0.0208061449,
-0.0192844588,
-0.0304249618,
0.0008407526,
0.0223480016,
0.0269429032,
-0.0099121509,
-0.0059470767,
-0.0133018,
0.02044384,
-0.0283961855,
-0.0169250928,
-0.0345152058,
-0.0248812269,
0.0448264889,
0.0027437415,
-0.0496589318,
-0.0151627483,
-0.0078897364,
0.0266959369,
-0.0253018737,
0.0726537928,
-0.0190381017,
-0.0028423702,
0.098199442,
0.0023616974,
-0.0129374592,
0.021322472,
0.0217778832,
0.0129345153,
-0.0030226088,
0.0145975705,
0.0087268697,
-0.0065054959,
-0.0369636528,
0.0072085368,
-0.0056975549,
-0.0692871287,
0.0037124592,
0.0614968427,
0.0744286925,
-0.0122099835,
0.0227421243,
-0.0498996787,
-0.0315459818,
-0.0588710643,
0.0175518375,
-0.002702527,
-0.050733652,
0.0259377416,
0.0039072433,
-0.0588654466,
0.0738107935,
0.0779207423,
0.0382800922,
-0.0058369148,
0.0345332585,
-0.0135003934,
-0.0286184642,
-0.0297091063,
-0.0005156774,
-0.0164682027,
-0.0445957929,
0.0193922948,
-0.0638446063,
-0.0717041865,
0.0114522306,
-0.0205581207,
-0.0117574409,
-0.0139172459,
-0.029382864,
0.0797579736,
0.0245551318,
0.0425632708,
-0.0574475043,
0.017340634,
-0.0134236366,
-0.0474995598,
0.009199528,
-5.822105236e-33,
0.006449875,
-0.0304434989,
-0.0009561929,
-0.0130175753,
-0.0040730438,
0.0168546364,
0.0171305798,
0.0201889332,
-0.0044626929,
-0.0177949369,
-0.0146668833,
-0.0134824114,
-0.0007405574,
0.0489130691,
0.0053167399,
0.0161502697,
0.0473960079,
0.0015548097,
0.0199760869,
0.0184565354,
0.0057642409,
0.0155056631,
0.0065013482,
-0.0420887321,
-0.0018281799,
-0.0066532325,
-0.0043815202,
0.0371862128,
-0.0193786025,
0.0626148432,
-0.0387907661,
0.0802895948,
0.0337780975,
-0.0235698726,
-0.0032632384,
0.0125473794,
-0.049736958,
0.036676567,
0.0107053304,
0.0257747676,
0.0076912986,
-0.0188793745,
0.0388263427,
-0.0149219977,
-0.0052612834,
0.0188628845,
-0.0012028983,
-0.0307141785,
-0.0454216711,
0.0197480861,
-0.0282734632,
0.0356979668,
0.0199397393,
0.0313142538,
0.0282093696,
-0.0239921305,
-0.0091033727,
0.0421175398,
-0.0407229699,
0.0161559377,
0.0242765881,
0.0628389791,
0.0577883497,
0.0361022651,
0.0000502055,
0.0449687615,
0.0068530468,
-0.0015561014,
-0.018721737,
-0.0178932175,
0.0243229344,
0.0195618104,
0.0385060497,
0.036191348,
-0.0031271752,
-0.0195390675,
-0.0886686742,
-0.0308402665,
0.0292605087,
-0.0057706176,
0.0563414432,
0.0057301209,
-0.0097231511,
-0.0524792001,
-0.0488885157,
0.0108960057,
-0.0273174662,
0.0111286733,
-0.0024104908,
-0.0032258965,
-0.0010490752,
0.0061809667,
0.0313894786,
-0.0635388717,
-0.0712884888,
0.0232086703,
0.0170274191,
0.026254395,
-0.0017784792,
0.0369646847,
-0.065575555,
-0.0449328423,
-0.0553668216,
-0.0382475667,
-0.0204158612,
-0.0320468023,
0.0114942901,
0.0081624687,
-0.0789806023,
-0.011018292,
-0.0132522946,
-0.0028210196,
0.0095562413,
0.0554070733,
0.047704272,
-0.0164629705,
0.0253979266,
0.051669579,
0.0200355072,
-0.0071467026,
0.0233239252,
-0.0232053082,
-0.0132119833,
0.0063594431,
-0.0145261306,
0.0278907456,
-0.0220816974,
0.0165169965,
0.0685418397,
-0.0305392779,
0.0061211716,
-0.0334966891,
2.333e-7,
0.0391161777,
0.0607159436,
-0.0154654887,
-0.0021433514,
0.0540099591,
0.0056081079,
-0.0432287827,
0.0324747711,
-0.0188429374,
0.0440470614,
0.017832024,
0.0239746254,
0.0622808635,
-0.0154320775,
-0.0876836628,
0.022689553,
-0.0513938069,
0.0278271232,
-0.0863752067,
-0.008720424,
0.0076811695,
0.1580147594,
0.0258223023,
-0.0193757433,
-0.0005619883,
-0.0571567118,
0.0572216883,
-0.0585162342,
-0.0210978277,
0.0148972031,
0.0235021468,
0.0156545322,
0.0182135478,
0.0174796749,
0.0200266615,
0.0458254032,
0.0155901853,
0.061452195,
0.023028506,
0.0405150354,
0.0203810725,
-0.0036654077,
-0.0423817821,
-0.0485570095,
0.0728896931,
-0.0490635037,
-0.0556235686,
-0.050238654,
0.0378577225,
-0.0311710648,
0.0136478506,
-0.0117295431,
-0.0086881667,
0.0253198724,
0.0254813712,
-0.0386480056,
0.0159317665,
-0.0682353079,
-0.0045225397,
0.003843962,
-0.0598859824,
-0.0336441472,
-0.000919518,
-0.0113951713,
0.0423101559,
-0.0219649523,
0.0404717624,
2.213038241e-34,
0.059700869,
-0.0008826313,
-0.0338175818,
0.0304391161,
0.0235719252,
-0.0168015696,
-0.0256046485,
0.0278131664,
-0.014117863,
-0.1112986803,
0.0226709526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10168v2 | LLMs as Workers in Human-Computational Algorithms? Replicating Crowdsourcing Pipelines with LLMs | 2023-07-19T17:54:43 | 2023-07-20T02:29:25 | Tongshuang Wu, Haiyi Zhu, Maya Albayrak, Alexis Axon, Amanda Bertsch, Wenxing Deng, Ziqi Ding, Bill Guo, Sireesh Gururaja, Tzu-Sheng Kuo, Jenny T. Liang, Ryan Liu, Ihita Mandal, Jeremiah Milbauer, Xiaolin Ni, Namrata Padmanabhan, Subhashini Ramkumar, Alexis Sudjianto, Jordan Taylor, Ying-Jui Tseng, Patricia Vaidos, Zhijin Wu, Wei Wu, Chenyang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | LLMs have shown promise in replicating human-like behavior in crowdsourcing
tasks that were previously thought to be exclusive to human abilities. However,
current efforts focus mainly on simple atomic tasks. We explore whether LLMs
can replicate more complex crowdsourcing pipelines. We find that modern LLMs
can simulate some of crowdworkers' abilities in these "human computation
algorithms," but the level of success is variable and influenced by requesters'
understanding of LLM capabilities, the specific skills required for sub-tasks,
and the optimal interaction modality for performing these sub-tasks. We reflect
on human and LLMs' different sensitivities to instructions, stress the
importance of enabling human-facing safeguards for LLMs, and discuss the
potential of training humans and LLMs with complementary skill sets. Crucially,
we show that replicating crowdsourcing pipelines offers a valuable platform to
investigate (1) the relative strengths of LLMs on different tasks (by
cross-comparing their performances on sub-tasks) and (2) LLMs' potential in
complex tasks, where they can complete part of the tasks while leaving others
to humans. | [
0.0324595496,
0.0589330271,
-0.0277876556,
0.0169850104,
-0.0281400867,
-0.0016710106,
0.0010803968,
0.0287687574,
-0.0082178246,
0.0100337705,
-0.0449576564,
0.0033551939,
-0.0070960312,
-0.0652064532,
0.0261991061,
-0.0458703078,
-0.0136064263,
-0.0411343575,
-0.0386949182,
-0.014408052,
-0.0140355146,
-0.0328123868,
-0.0193889681,
0.0170473829,
-0.0074033509,
0.0394220203,
-0.0258155838,
0.0268400442,
0.0318697616,
-0.0301153678,
-0.0138636045,
0.0291915946,
0.0261817239,
0.0059460946,
0.0000020403,
-0.0568761267,
0.0329594612,
0.0144833121,
-0.0536367744,
-0.0257990006,
0.0119205518,
0.0058658328,
-0.0122703752,
0.0067110187,
-0.033987049,
0.0624434315,
0.0407904983,
-0.0110273389,
0.0527894199,
0.0066379588,
0.0318391733,
0.0718673244,
-0.00894689,
-0.0031929957,
0.0619786382,
-0.0588356741,
0.0132730799,
-0.0520864576,
0.0807586387,
0.0044525275,
0.0333361514,
0.015622694,
0.0275021866,
0.0281856116,
0.0379724875,
0.0123074353,
-0.0328879692,
-0.0333385654,
-0.0439443514,
0.0447637737,
0.0094739068,
-0.0021529032,
0.02373017,
0.0005694705,
0.0149253309,
0.0590996891,
-0.0338966958,
0.0119794402,
-0.0287005119,
0.00821485,
-0.0845558196,
-0.0001307265,
0.0178299788,
0.0202320702,
0.0734536722,
0.0547080375,
-0.0380677842,
-0.017730318,
0.0057062227,
0.0451954119,
0.03331054,
-0.0440110303,
0.0381460451,
0.0198092572,
-0.034916807,
-0.0320156366,
-0.0105574885,
-0.0352396481,
0.0168225877,
-0.0098103164,
0.0716545433,
0.0023583872,
0.0067325695,
0.0501641594,
-0.0210253783,
-0.0142101077,
-0.0364479199,
0.0375220366,
-0.0124621084,
0.0132961003,
-0.0577624068,
0.0205104277,
-0.0072633359,
-0.0120253433,
-0.0205184314,
0.0624425299,
-0.0111579187,
0.0122820372,
-0.0499968827,
0.0121707693,
-0.0144745177,
0.0435099117,
0.0117372405,
-0.0200063866,
-0.0602642596,
-0.0622961484,
-0.0414794162,
0.0222047623,
0.0330167152,
-0.0494060442,
-0.0158029571,
0.0162990447,
0.0005905651,
0.0055093141,
0.030969495,
0.0618316717,
0.0144680226,
0.043256823,
-0.0661518127,
-0.0313612297,
0.0609315559,
-0.0311575141,
0.0327317752,
-0.0542913862,
0.0567901433,
-0.0214199834,
-0.0219310839,
0.0028672162,
0.0254564937,
-0.0003350474,
-0.0250391923,
0.1060536206,
-0.0184463747,
0.0190699007,
0.032634344,
0.0236561503,
-0.0666020736,
0.0119270338,
0.0269097723,
0.041765701,
0.0389183834,
0.0072744517,
0.0680787638,
0.0425767042,
-0.0291553903,
0.0111457082,
0.0274037141,
-0.0078814263,
-0.0174818076,
0.0712064058,
0.0653184876,
0.036161121,
-0.0369391814,
0.0256707724,
0.0476135314,
0.0769191235,
-0.041989632,
0.0112551209,
0.0039258096,
0.0531665757,
0.0275239851,
-0.0257926788,
-0.0550556406,
0.0552612767,
-0.0279715322,
-0.0072613992,
-0.0178253762,
0.0169879962,
-0.0259177051,
-0.0065720049,
-0.0122646233,
-0.0117112659,
-0.0073255035,
-0.0052516828,
0.0249082521,
-0.0070196921,
-0.0210809056,
-0.0113540916,
-0.0182150137,
-0.0521308333,
0.0054395311,
-0.0759088174,
-0.0105291847,
0.0581503995,
0.0256667901,
-0.0334508345,
0.042551212,
-0.0085384548,
-0.0138443811,
0.0123987235,
-0.0010646433,
-0.0074671283,
-0.0471745692,
-0.0103592901,
-0.0466884635,
0.0231819637,
-0.0199753121,
0.0088524492,
0.0606740788,
-0.0367508791,
-0.021988254,
-0.0037861769,
-0.0209116694,
0.0267458074,
-0.0249862485,
-0.016244065,
-0.0087318784,
0.017986875,
0.0232921559,
0.0126229385,
0.0239945799,
0.0088310856,
0.0109171784,
-0.0062666978,
-0.0348020867,
0.0108011952,
0.0123317679,
0.063776508,
0.0177898202,
-0.0523762405,
-0.0621752702,
0.0448623262,
-0.0194682777,
0.0387518555,
0.0058715735,
-0.0118608624,
-0.0118505461,
-0.0205147918,
-0.0170971919,
0.0082827667,
-0.0518535152,
0.0143651292,
0.0358161628,
-0.0082089994,
0.0037594773,
0.0047731586,
-0.0139267985,
-0.0110118324,
-0.0544093028,
0.0041239085,
-0.0439367741,
0.0236678738,
0.0463852435,
-0.0072348532,
0.0131384768,
-0.0470350198,
-0.0155589096,
-0.0619308352,
-0.012867922,
-0.0001949687,
0.0271091685,
-0.0075357482,
-0.0453109741,
-0.0098198215,
-0.0311199594,
0.0033914226,
0.0138055682,
-0.0107174786,
-0.0051383697,
0.0508324541,
-0.0002845577,
-0.0012930306,
-0.0160156861,
0.0194757693,
-0.002846143,
-0.0281864423,
0.060289681,
-0.0020697657,
-0.0486072823,
0.0076413257,
0.004649125,
-0.0024210156,
0.0105034504,
-0.0303769279,
0.0390065499,
0.0308484193,
0.0021397069,
0.0397797301,
0.0002405254,
0.0110235671,
0.0279779993,
0.0319257341,
-0.0052337879,
0.006119357,
0.0191077311,
-0.0476378351,
-0.0090451362,
-0.0277113412,
0.025151927,
0.0368505046,
-0.0279834028,
0.0256222524,
0.0110478317,
0.0524973907,
0.02162816,
-0.0430727266,
-0.0387763903,
-0.0256966744,
-0.0751198307,
0.0373951122,
-0.0267713722,
-0.0391191095,
0.0603326187,
-0.0165321231,
-0.0031682702,
0.0607297458,
-0.0190730561,
-0.0134507585,
0.0341397859,
-0.0262930971,
-0.008665381,
-0.0484992787,
0.0150871435,
-0.0198930539,
0.0533086881,
0.0254043806,
-0.0515801162,
-0.0433818027,
-0.0546363369,
-0.0376103632,
-0.0341336317,
-0.0762210488,
-0.0155274915,
0.0157534126,
-0.0336900279,
0.018583985,
0.0399338603,
-0.04642253,
0.0038359233,
-0.0446249098,
0.0590973087,
-0.0168256517,
0.0114957877,
-0.0218132958,
-0.0296208635,
0.0140631348,
-0.023631813,
0.0971057639,
-0.0093976445,
-0.0494289771,
-0.033078175,
0.0871469006,
0.0979330987,
-0.0494795851,
-0.009917113,
0.0340138525,
0.0428503789,
0.0021269168,
0.0133527238,
0.0395266488,
0.0702517107,
-0.025854433,
0.0228033345,
0.0206317622,
0.0128667168,
-0.0461649485,
0.0101921465,
-0.0360561423,
-0.0317091197,
0.0213481374,
0.0216637794,
-0.0806950331,
-0.0170764159,
0.0447523408,
0.0920215845,
-0.0472584143,
-0.0721315145,
0.0274873786,
-0.0929060504,
0.0956769586,
0.0021414307,
-0.0121731693,
0.0234892014,
-0.0648325905,
0.0243427362,
-0.0122935735,
-0.0084824339,
0.000994056,
0.0072680875,
-0.0044147032,
0.0141642382,
0.0055294069,
-0.0167455357,
0.0181274433,
-0.0504092164,
0.0493698306,
0.0479957797,
0.0065695443,
-0.0291336589,
-0.0851756632,
0.0366136171,
0.0586002208,
0.0604354925,
-0.0037822484,
0.0123593053,
-0.023670312,
-0.0063471468,
-0.0466169454,
0.0450204499,
-0.0666720793,
-0.0190665144,
0.0195071772,
0.0900240391,
-0.0080737825,
-0.0224606488,
-0.0113799255,
-0.0386249013,
0.0417126752,
0.0581226535,
0.0162671153,
-0.073966302,
-0.0403747968,
-0.0515384786,
-0.0201949514,
-0.0498635061,
-0.0728020221,
-0.0124557121,
0.0130734285,
-0.0258960426,
-0.0510857962,
-0.0179894548,
0.0439468361,
0.0254855752,
-0.0168665424,
-0.059856914,
0.027767539,
0.0188682117,
-0.0344139375,
0.0269194562,
-0.0238769967,
0.043437738,
-0.0568705425,
-0.035201475,
-0.0132777384,
-0.0375070907,
-0.0020759795,
0.0286517199,
-0.0927519947,
-0.0352570452,
0.0098197898,
0.0782443136,
0.0289355963,
-0.0071818242,
-0.010247739,
-0.0497406945,
0.0039720014,
0.0835189,
-0.0563005656,
0.0383433737,
-0.0128763616,
0.0372276865,
-0.0173097905,
-0.0164582226,
-0.0184499808,
-0.0035883542,
0.0509034023,
-0.0006528692,
-0.0373488739,
-0.0482106693,
0.0145543907,
0.0647686943,
0.0291384887,
-0.0258488134,
0.0129502416,
0.0022645025,
0.0013210657,
0.0521052331,
-0.0194012839,
-0.0470916592,
-0.0583863594,
-0.0263494141,
-0.011567222,
0.0584018566,
0.0221811756,
0.0159175135,
0.0355987735,
-0.0257938486,
0.0885001943,
0.0091620106,
0.0477837585,
0.0287195425,
0.0302815959,
0.0326124057,
0.0290589612,
-0.001575603,
0.0394508764,
0.0482717864,
-0.0043345322,
-0.0106849661,
0.0280972812,
-0.0066363676,
0.043672476,
-0.0353196189,
-0.1220988855,
-0.0031598578,
0.046411667,
0.0225667693,
0.0438870899,
-0.0455482528,
-0.0320383906,
-0.0094632031,
-0.0090088826,
-0.0222637299,
-0.0298525784,
0.0275958367,
-0.0048670233,
0.0326584205,
-0.0088589909,
0.00108621,
0.0274949819,
-0.0400268286,
0.015696818,
-0.0740505159,
-0.024416104,
-0.0340167098,
-0.0274465829,
-0.0009262039,
-0.0158333313,
0.009443216,
-0.0089393165,
-0.0486365855,
-0.0247794334,
-0.0096244374,
0.0511041544,
0.0037099801,
-0.0381248593,
0.0566389449,
0.0075357538,
-0.0356397182,
-0.0040047816,
-0.0034301989,
-0.0019637763,
0.01314718,
-0.0166365802,
-0.0045476099,
-6.161784532e-33,
0.0135164196,
-0.1014166251,
0.0154616972,
0.024693653,
-0.0085389353,
-0.0437409058,
-0.0153797381,
0.0462222695,
0.0430141389,
0.0082703438,
-0.0313495174,
-0.0298979487,
0.0125325304,
-0.0588966534,
0.0529122613,
-0.0146495216,
0.0511801764,
-0.0565814525,
-0.0169898234,
-0.0339178108,
-0.0361399762,
0.0076669175,
-0.0191624295,
-0.0533545017,
0.0543738827,
-0.0228948146,
-0.0244663749,
0.0219129883,
0.0052574663,
-0.0251199249,
0.0164420884,
0.0216947701,
0.0202729404,
-0.0019731263,
-0.0086522838,
0.0324263722,
-0.0591412447,
0.020021243,
-0.0320641287,
-0.0224765148,
-0.0846893787,
-0.0261027943,
0.0607646033,
0.0164142065,
-0.0812607706,
0.0085534547,
0.0311791711,
-0.0086725075,
0.0427238271,
0.0260261521,
0.0333680548,
0.0125261415,
0.0047611459,
-0.0070212455,
0.0256957561,
-0.0105643729,
-0.0376451351,
0.017102262,
-0.0862365216,
0.0359259099,
-0.0345619544,
-0.0418054536,
0.0377561599,
-0.0147166038,
0.0206545629,
0.0274478439,
0.0350367092,
0.0108907158,
-0.0374317877,
-0.0368223488,
-0.0367489383,
0.0970165059,
0.0382323414,
0.0664838925,
0.0114350151,
-0.0080658859,
0.0353463814,
0.0811958984,
-0.0135320947,
0.0278604571,
-0.0267507434,
0.0203540325,
-0.0253823753,
0.0022473787,
0.0283223297,
-0.0400280468,
-0.0212225113,
0.0044270107,
-0.0267518796,
0.0038158982,
-0.0026618049,
-0.0175644625,
-0.0245050918,
-0.0073576495,
0.0357711837,
-0.0571095832,
0.0579435937,
0.0565970652,
0.0337050855,
-0.0639079362,
-0.0698892027,
0.0058843023,
-0.0502994955,
0.0044088135,
0.0620181598,
0.0119550768,
-0.019435728,
0.021344509,
-0.0445319302,
0.0101544699,
-0.0317716897,
0.0561850369,
0.0334516689,
-0.0393089019,
0.0209926199,
-0.0240262765,
-0.0015292431,
-0.0478527807,
-0.0606773794,
-0.0289491806,
0.002589344,
0.0672031641,
-0.0616891198,
0.0026130565,
-0.0019474296,
-0.0121411495,
-0.0335925482,
0.0092791189,
0.0167275257,
-0.0324735418,
-0.025652241,
-0.0269602928,
2.801e-7,
-0.0438857824,
0.0199202038,
0.0485906973,
0.0098913768,
0.0297673587,
0.0511549413,
-0.0538274162,
0.0164818671,
-0.0095412675,
-0.0612472817,
0.0375623554,
0.0523032807,
0.0632466227,
0.0147734899,
-0.0741366297,
-0.0223094169,
-0.00676054,
0.0564798489,
-0.0022749577,
0.0086133275,
0.0141498419,
-0.0515341386,
0.0169478133,
-0.0240139905,
0.0259849932,
-0.038140174,
0.019781094,
-0.0667927861,
0.0160104558,
-0.0109026041,
-0.0022456269,
0.0014884172,
-0.0140568735,
0.0155583024,
-0.029560985,
-0.035996411,
0.0208465438,
0.0603889078,
0.0142672388,
-0.0164783411,
-0.0077207657,
-0.0363958888,
0.0301355813,
0.005139506,
0.000550048,
0.001927875,
-0.008862352,
0.0013385721,
0.0085718082,
-0.0390777104,
-0.0258815773,
-0.0100078955,
0.0172339939,
-0.0231829751,
-0.0013900499,
0.0059168325,
-0.0248818118,
-0.0229374357,
0.0023079605,
-0.0260989424,
-0.0433069244,
-0.0957185179,
0.0018999091,
0.0402461402,
0.0045715054,
-0.0006080128,
-0.0101364627,
1.781381677e-34,
0.0083986688,
0.0329506509,
0.0376990885,
0.0420512259,
0.0517041869,
0.0406786054,
-0.038851101,
-0.0090088053,
0.0395593978,
0.0270549003,
0.0012759727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10156v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10156v2 | Exploring Transformer Extrapolation | 2023-07-19T17:37:03 | 2023-12-19T08:02:03 | Zhen Qin, Yiran Zhong, Hui Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Length extrapolation has attracted considerable attention recently since it
allows transformers to be tested on longer sequences than those used in
training. Previous research has shown that this property can be attained by
using carefully designed Relative Positional Encodings (RPEs). While these
methods perform well on a variety of corpora, the conditions for length
extrapolation have yet to be investigated. This paper attempts to determine
what types of RPEs allow for length extrapolation through a thorough
mathematical and empirical analysis. We discover that a transformer is certain
to possess this property as long as the series that corresponds to the RPE's
exponential converges. Two practices are derived from the conditions and
examined in language modeling tasks on a variety of corpora. As a bonus from
the conditions, we derive a new Theoretical Receptive Field (TRF) to measure
the receptive field of RPEs without taking any training steps. Extensive
experiments are conducted on the Wikitext-103, Books, Github, and WikiBook
datasets to demonstrate the viability of our discovered conditions. We also
compare TRF to Empirical Receptive Field (ERF) across different models, showing
consistently matched trends on the aforementioned datasets. The code is
available at https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/Rpe. | [
0.0282269362,
0.0725410283,
-0.0258367956,
0.0200808235,
-0.0162987933,
0.0135391392,
-0.0251200609,
0.046852652,
-0.067077145,
-0.0006148739,
0.0030559991,
-0.052749414,
0.0416519344,
-0.001460238,
0.0404050238,
-0.0395298265,
0.0123741338,
-0.0143385446,
-0.0138892028,
0.010628026,
-0.0110658687,
-0.0365607478,
-0.0132625466,
0.0670221671,
0.0110306451,
0.0202836245,
-0.0121803638,
-0.0658389777,
0.0127760014,
-0.0204566903,
0.00787983,
0.0377486013,
0.0261195041,
0.0305725485,
0.0000020422,
-0.0248448532,
-0.0143098254,
-0.0171005223,
0.0056803813,
-0.0332065225,
0.0060627148,
-0.0788229629,
-0.0072716633,
0.0201745778,
-0.0367738679,
-0.048913423,
0.0877677724,
0.0439998955,
0.0007625417,
0.0947512537,
-0.0265276246,
-0.0809933916,
0.0182995815,
-0.0262197461,
0.0195714459,
0.0120980218,
0.0148616042,
-0.0285355356,
0.0129456762,
-0.0024434074,
-0.0652083755,
0.0041896957,
0.0285358652,
0.0340358205,
-0.0293503515,
0.0328270718,
0.0266189091,
-0.0181104448,
-0.0077537652,
0.0439445898,
-0.0708024204,
-0.0619216487,
-0.0328521095,
0.0177551769,
-0.010745707,
0.0077684526,
-0.0253167544,
0.021230964,
0.0065698903,
0.0027878596,
-0.0112735964,
0.0418376476,
0.0039654365,
-0.0336860493,
-0.0550348125,
0.061535053,
0.009456587,
-0.0557009242,
-0.0139339175,
0.0129802721,
-0.0198162347,
-0.0058255265,
0.0171472505,
0.0258835685,
0.022848282,
0.0174625181,
-0.0367354937,
-0.0564354099,
-0.0032989962,
-0.0232087914,
0.0549387932,
0.0603751726,
-0.0052364967,
-0.0347422436,
-0.0512731262,
0.1136129126,
-0.0407191664,
0.0515145622,
-0.0503387004,
0.0235572923,
-0.0311597772,
0.0057163094,
-0.0202146564,
0.0085806604,
-0.026462527,
-0.0282051954,
-0.0569886602,
0.0240101553,
0.0273680985,
-0.016478993,
0.046013847,
0.0165050142,
-0.0358008519,
0.0024232664,
0.0035576273,
0.0658040345,
-0.0084045222,
0.0148135424,
-0.0322473869,
-0.007323816,
-0.0382565595,
0.0147944903,
0.0234648939,
-0.0368841775,
-0.012687224,
0.0596804954,
0.0102000227,
-0.0527654365,
0.0021345529,
0.0427994318,
-0.0383760445,
-0.0239518639,
0.0174158514,
-0.0451338626,
-0.0132292258,
0.0369261354,
0.0142590888,
-0.032321889,
-0.0071339589,
0.0078980364,
-0.0210533645,
0.062826626,
0.0116778631,
0.0160173327,
-0.0031550727,
-0.0055008377,
0.0093991468,
0.050757423,
0.0405452289,
-0.0101739429,
0.0389214121,
-0.0295918044,
0.0307544302,
0.073285684,
0.001030117,
-0.0394498296,
-0.017924903,
-0.0390405841,
-0.0040674214,
-0.0086351223,
0.0355103612,
0.0118664363,
-0.0135086123,
-0.0764390603,
0.0473479182,
0.0837540329,
0.0604204759,
0.0376885645,
0.0242733937,
0.0110005867,
-0.0179515798,
0.0571289174,
-0.0056241723,
0.0230221376,
0.0091178734,
0.0355707221,
-0.0221448746,
0.0268918481,
-0.0042029652,
-0.0135066761,
-0.0347689129,
-0.054677356,
0.0199834555,
-0.0559668131,
0.0449342802,
0.0088500204,
-0.0527287722,
0.0872096941,
0.0154493125,
-0.0766865388,
-0.0096119354,
0.0135361617,
-0.0039618993,
0.0080410996,
0.0130127249,
-0.0223444272,
-0.0100340927,
-0.0060814875,
-0.0569194555,
0.0305120386,
0.0157833379,
0.0144698629,
0.0136058247,
-0.0556209721,
-0.0441545807,
0.0503825247,
0.0107076112,
0.0206693877,
0.0325146802,
0.0177261941,
0.0182130374,
-0.0592167675,
0.0094449176,
0.0370154455,
-0.0283829812,
-0.0176690258,
-0.0307543539,
0.0261950027,
0.024555508,
0.0126240375,
-0.0056597549,
0.0217300914,
0.0536938198,
-0.0402924605,
0.0146206915,
0.034512531,
-0.0364491977,
-0.0230141655,
0.0524493977,
-0.0327299684,
0.0404708497,
0.060956493,
-0.0105944024,
-0.0290492941,
0.0265903436,
-0.0822072625,
0.0552534945,
-0.005090686,
0.0311820842,
-0.0276240278,
0.0547193773,
-0.0107080089,
0.0343497097,
-0.0004130863,
0.0522191152,
0.0189355612,
-0.059612684,
0.0204074979,
-0.0114368312,
-0.0275319312,
0.0293780733,
-0.0195363648,
-0.0180568844,
0.0500142798,
-0.0417928025,
-0.0099813305,
-0.067078501,
-0.0429872572,
-0.0490873866,
-0.0271973033,
0.0525584333,
0.0027878212,
0.001849949,
0.0022720201,
-0.0108551141,
-0.0382249355,
-0.0274977442,
0.0133975307,
-0.0016391631,
0.0348047204,
0.004315035,
-0.064087227,
-0.0208621752,
-0.0255209859,
-0.0064134011,
0.0797964036,
-0.0116840452,
-0.0179396588,
-0.0831310451,
-0.0244390219,
0.0071798186,
0.0211226158,
-0.0041536572,
-0.0700809658,
-0.0110811647,
-0.011041712,
0.0168527197,
-0.0040677153,
0.0386496931,
0.0390780866,
0.0136307981,
0.0182682443,
-0.0304747038,
-0.008013336,
-0.0737133324,
0.0000350111,
-0.0631522238,
-0.0056119706,
-0.0333066136,
0.1157736331,
-0.0294525586,
-0.0165644344,
-0.0733160824,
-0.0056576179,
-0.0194463804,
-0.0238344092,
0.018550666,
-0.0075239455,
-0.0438165888,
0.0298861396,
-0.0193593241,
-0.0406507999,
0.0519260429,
-0.0474395044,
-0.0185237397,
-0.0657752082,
-0.0052293343,
-0.0343812853,
0.0366210826,
0.041756276,
-0.0093133133,
-0.0108290575,
-0.0284804907,
-0.0530785955,
0.0331373848,
-0.0341519415,
-0.0426282212,
0.0531571917,
-0.0096029239,
0.0024877992,
-0.0070042992,
-0.0168728381,
-0.0386679433,
-0.0469416529,
0.0312565155,
-0.0110942312,
0.013804419,
-0.0467792377,
-0.0477917939,
0.0667135268,
0.0285543241,
0.0713018402,
-0.0065011997,
0.0079710726,
-0.01361412,
0.0475764424,
0.0501837805,
0.0325041674,
0.010168164,
-0.0451826043,
-0.0093394807,
0.0303456951,
0.0235308539,
0.0304883085,
-0.0653158352,
0.0047202022,
0.023779612,
-0.0357236378,
-0.0085645672,
0.0301550776,
-0.0184138473,
-0.0251367763,
-0.0294354688,
0.1124833003,
0.0043025129,
-0.0532651469,
0.0348272994,
0.0118070487,
0.0338112116,
0.0187309124,
0.0088917585,
-0.0417763703,
0.0013847721,
-0.0172616541,
0.0045527383,
-0.0134352501,
-0.0257243663,
0.0090089776,
-0.134043172,
-0.0064599398,
0.0048696641,
-0.037241146,
-0.0615397766,
-0.012373928,
0.014334213,
0.0140371062,
-0.0017587601,
0.021569293,
-0.0368852168,
-0.0031329982,
0.0417251401,
-0.0644214451,
-0.0515602492,
-0.0184919164,
0.000172518,
-0.0128211062,
0.0308332015,
0.0142944334,
-0.0065521258,
-0.0543074645,
-0.0626779422,
-0.0257220976,
0.015540272,
0.0297452752,
0.0743322745,
0.015138573,
-0.0299467184,
0.049273327,
0.005257918,
-0.0661121458,
-0.000709802,
-0.0468934663,
0.0595997833,
0.0107358219,
-0.0079420572,
-0.0091789505,
0.0154327471,
-0.0182376038,
0.0313513428,
0.0197841469,
-0.0457040928,
-0.0099670831,
0.0161859542,
0.0501617305,
-0.0134516852,
-0.0413488746,
0.0052315625,
0.0268323645,
-0.0642764568,
-0.0799917132,
-0.0260256436,
0.0017182658,
0.0693122,
0.0310106948,
-0.0220638011,
0.0195094049,
0.005169346,
-0.0627295002,
-0.0145590072,
0.026070755,
0.0162595529,
-0.0277755465,
0.0306162853,
0.0372243486,
-0.0198091548,
-0.0251393374,
-0.0238409191,
-0.078204684,
-0.0618434995,
0.0333140306,
0.0399091356,
0.0319271125,
0.0296617523,
0.007224347,
-0.028014861,
0.060239438,
0.0224886611,
-0.0529470071,
0.0526536629,
0.0465401821,
-0.0154534262,
0.0001265521,
-0.006796415,
-0.0149198724,
0.020400878,
-0.0217759609,
0.0365651771,
-0.0184689201,
-0.0433644243,
0.0380762629,
-0.0193273462,
0.062107835,
-0.0142023787,
0.0482860692,
-0.0092237536,
0.0369332246,
-0.0185454264,
0.0478340648,
-0.0277563799,
-0.0123514682,
0.0560973845,
0.0469700545,
-0.0086055342,
0.0080554364,
-0.0114526171,
0.0001591057,
0.0081636002,
0.0547179244,
0.0017344207,
-0.0019199597,
-0.0041794335,
0.0313578695,
-0.000170373,
-0.032397002,
0.0015619937,
0.0427029468,
-0.0150976432,
0.062921837,
0.0128380451,
0.0346181244,
-0.0413395055,
0.0376953371,
-0.0650708154,
0.0374457017,
-0.0332386717,
0.0156554542,
0.0140623776,
-0.0578639396,
0.0465094447,
-0.0279388055,
0.0377254076,
-0.0147628924,
-0.0145189967,
-0.0306377448,
-0.0047666444,
0.0153734162,
0.020580044,
-0.0290314946,
0.0070005683,
0.072367385,
-0.0266802553,
0.0252830982,
-0.0526151769,
-0.0004428935,
-0.0124012651,
-0.0328602232,
0.0140185719,
-0.0363496244,
-0.0033236318,
-0.0138990423,
-0.0338384025,
-0.0698967129,
0.0638180375,
-0.0115626566,
0.0021581277,
-0.029101152,
0.0298997741,
0.0416058563,
-0.0344301648,
0.0364319161,
-0.0140845021,
-0.041860763,
0.014909572,
-0.0011617531,
-0.0311368853,
-5.75030053e-33,
0.0082422365,
-0.0172240697,
-0.0258595608,
-0.0048506348,
-0.020859899,
0.0240725353,
-0.0349580124,
0.0089616384,
0.0137760816,
-0.016033968,
-0.0093929823,
-0.0259333681,
0.023203399,
0.045750834,
0.0055156355,
-0.0147793218,
0.0289358217,
0.013602552,
-0.0094780754,
-0.0461234413,
0.0565271042,
0.0320614241,
0.082972236,
-0.038867265,
-0.0096096676,
0.0144723849,
-0.00581893,
-0.0034394755,
0.028027799,
0.0941240191,
-0.0093229814,
0.0406955257,
0.0201877579,
-0.0718804598,
-0.0196865704,
0.0156823471,
-0.0628445372,
-0.0095501021,
-0.0084983073,
0.0362984166,
0.006337937,
0.0056734476,
0.0492582396,
-0.0390187725,
-0.0416972749,
-0.0194932166,
0.0374397077,
-0.0423083976,
-0.0110826232,
-0.0033017786,
-0.0417120941,
0.0051429467,
0.00139008,
0.0245544035,
0.0589835159,
0.0795153975,
0.0185623839,
0.0070311152,
-0.0633874834,
0.0202045925,
0.0270985086,
0.0649163276,
0.0324766859,
-0.0056105517,
-0.0033170802,
0.0226804651,
0.0464937352,
-0.0771797746,
-0.0281306114,
-0.0152999805,
0.0319125578,
-0.0301671121,
0.0570328236,
0.0097620459,
0.0668082684,
-0.0249033589,
-0.000241324,
0.0042206994,
0.0069729816,
0.0437861048,
0.0344460085,
0.0073490534,
-0.0529885478,
0.0012174363,
-0.0030881655,
-0.0009622098,
-0.0144031998,
-0.043124821,
0.0302486625,
-0.0049015349,
0.0121598355,
0.0351898782,
0.040285442,
-0.0510747284,
0.0130466614,
0.018616613,
-0.0125166653,
0.0632991716,
-0.0215942524,
-0.0135143725,
-0.0004369433,
-0.0393300802,
0.0103765829,
-0.0033244079,
0.0102668693,
-0.0365469195,
0.0208377,
0.0565651432,
-0.0736473799,
-0.032339599,
-0.0270862933,
0.0032834171,
0.0067459499,
0.0576103143,
0.0548619628,
0.0099867787,
-0.0080324719,
0.0417532474,
-0.0074564512,
0.010705092,
0.0023935083,
-0.009707354,
0.0427647084,
0.0460194424,
-0.0290643647,
-0.0451941155,
-0.0014605876,
0.0372583233,
0.0123746237,
-0.0451928936,
0.0097522596,
0.0398179367,
2.846e-7,
0.0592644028,
0.0283755921,
0.0787536651,
-0.0139643727,
0.0115683582,
-0.0147561915,
-0.0063801212,
0.035219159,
0.0145241292,
-0.0195492674,
0.009102745,
-0.0344242826,
0.0385710075,
-0.0062010144,
-0.0909616053,
-0.0358053483,
-0.0825276449,
0.0148324249,
-0.0166208558,
0.0493106209,
0.0404117703,
0.1151853129,
0.0005502783,
0.0052185501,
-0.0209415331,
-0.0167560931,
0.0452504046,
-0.0334706828,
0.0439002179,
0.0056616324,
0.0174900517,
-0.0287648588,
0.0208537076,
0.0053299824,
-0.0257158317,
0.0723460019,
0.0223884899,
0.016416816,
0.0081356615,
-0.0511479639,
-0.0039312937,
0.0175035428,
-0.0249400828,
-0.0483765192,
0.0082394015,
-0.0911269262,
-0.0051970896,
0.015151443,
-0.0550392941,
0.0199619476,
-0.0065226206,
-0.0105217472,
0.0375406258,
0.0404036492,
0.0360378139,
-0.0005760911,
-0.0129054431,
-0.0692466125,
-0.035657078,
-0.016107861,
-0.034171544,
-0.0011054878,
-0.0532425083,
-0.0114864931,
0.0510082468,
-0.0173028633,
-0.0245428421,
2.65432984e-34,
0.008523819,
-0.0143302744,
0.0108647048,
0.0139560625,
-0.0065305759,
-0.0644418746,
0.0501914248,
0.036927063,
0.0159302019,
-0.0871273205,
-0.0459828302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10098v1 | Gradient Sparsification For Masked Fine-Tuning of Transformers | 2023-07-19T16:13:13 | 2023-07-19T16:13:13 | James O' Neill, Sourav Dutta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning pretrained self-supervised language models is widely adopted for
transfer learning to downstream tasks. Fine-tuning can be achieved by freezing
gradients of the pretrained network and only updating gradients of a newly
added classification layer, or by performing gradient updates on all
parameters. Gradual unfreezing makes a trade-off between the two by gradually
unfreezing gradients of whole layers during training. This has been an
effective strategy to trade-off between storage and training speed with
generalization performance. However, it is not clear whether gradually
unfreezing layers throughout training is optimal, compared to sparse variants
of gradual unfreezing which may improve fine-tuning performance. In this paper,
we propose to stochastically mask gradients to regularize pretrained language
models for improving overall fine-tuned performance. We introduce GradDrop and
variants thereof, a class of gradient sparsification methods that mask
gradients during the backward pass, acting as gradient noise. GradDrop is
sparse and stochastic unlike gradual freezing. Extensive experiments on the
multilingual XGLUE benchmark with XLMR-Large show that GradDrop is competitive
against methods that use additional translated data for intermediate
pretraining and outperforms standard fine-tuning and gradual unfreezing. A
post-analysis shows how GradDrop improves performance with languages it was not
trained on, such as under-resourced languages. | [
0.0073827999,
0.0641381815,
0.0043104156,
0.0533177741,
-0.0089356918,
-0.0023698555,
0.0260475408,
-0.0212366637,
-0.0394460931,
-0.0221448764,
-0.0695214048,
-0.0047249994,
0.018425744,
-0.0162126515,
0.0242836438,
-0.0691545457,
0.0274553075,
-0.0381409489,
-0.0584869646,
-0.0166557096,
0.0029897501,
0.0319301747,
-0.0071332031,
0.0289116912,
0.010883796,
-0.0126166418,
0.0113686305,
0.0224204268,
0.0009071503,
0.0108229453,
0.0340782851,
0.0661394298,
-0.00061639,
0.0038254275,
0.0000024626,
-0.0412512608,
-0.0042439266,
0.00008546,
-0.0063273739,
0.0117106857,
0.00212669,
-0.041253686,
-0.0075384378,
0.0144022666,
-0.0389336348,
-0.0590211153,
0.0686587989,
0.0326515846,
0.038203273,
0.0508915596,
-0.0186837129,
-0.0513802096,
-0.0203288551,
-0.0290024094,
-0.0463335663,
-0.0655474141,
-0.0029139665,
-0.0344259553,
-0.0752534196,
-0.0290026646,
-0.0378753468,
0.0455170609,
0.0038993366,
0.0234120172,
0.0110863512,
0.0437026024,
-0.0403365269,
-0.0192406997,
-0.0175132174,
0.0504704155,
-0.1013890356,
-0.0259035267,
-0.0130812181,
-0.0179395732,
-0.0116054257,
-0.0356497355,
-0.0000494509,
-0.0185539257,
0.039799694,
0.0225989204,
-0.0187297929,
-0.0288017653,
0.0507201329,
0.0104017798,
-0.0478564687,
0.0346516892,
-0.0037610475,
0.0060510528,
0.0232028533,
0.0203079712,
-0.0104339225,
-0.0471598059,
0.0018710291,
0.0393164195,
-0.0138125475,
-0.0228639375,
-0.0919037685,
-0.0659989044,
-0.0319136269,
0.0384449176,
0.092857331,
0.0173685923,
-0.0246053152,
0.039246425,
-0.0448867567,
0.0117684565,
-0.00226218,
0.0324735902,
-0.0494151451,
-0.0168954004,
-0.0001578104,
0.0193821378,
-0.0805138499,
0.0265885219,
-0.0292397887,
-0.0005336558,
-0.0301434901,
-0.0032881743,
-0.0033690769,
-0.0263247881,
0.0318599828,
-0.010659365,
-0.0516962297,
-0.0224888232,
0.0290486775,
0.0197890606,
-0.0210654028,
0.0254387092,
-0.0071062772,
-0.023003092,
-0.0292923041,
0.0025564702,
0.0492301099,
-0.0210400838,
0.0333631746,
0.0539697893,
-0.0321751609,
-0.0095483596,
-0.0479660034,
0.0284108222,
0.0243320409,
-0.0825928822,
-0.0124366451,
-0.0440501869,
0.0022816383,
0.0059463098,
0.0324408375,
-0.0873663425,
-0.0209037829,
-0.0154724875,
-0.0355899222,
0.0551490299,
-0.0100440467,
-0.021197103,
-0.0031525537,
-0.0151724014,
-0.0102004586,
0.0738638863,
0.0257142484,
0.0124136508,
0.0234252103,
-0.0830955282,
0.0011090176,
0.0492953956,
0.0555568375,
0.011715862,
-0.020059241,
-0.0566430576,
-0.0083111646,
-0.0099543752,
0.0798732713,
0.0542038977,
-0.0193455834,
-0.0353955925,
0.0610839985,
0.0795947686,
0.0208830256,
0.0482649691,
0.029644303,
-0.0102575086,
-0.0147767952,
0.0362065546,
-0.023632152,
0.0176816601,
0.0108784065,
-0.0306264423,
-0.023907464,
0.0707256868,
-0.0595125183,
-0.028257031,
0.0213825759,
-0.0054008081,
0.0304085612,
0.0220544785,
0.0531559289,
0.0541896708,
-0.0380888283,
0.0866970792,
0.0236562677,
-0.0130396187,
0.0198492967,
-0.0467499308,
-0.0252311714,
0.0061869943,
-0.0114021758,
0.0065595172,
-0.0532708243,
-0.0210383553,
0.0133853834,
-0.0110601541,
0.0540367477,
0.0300743729,
0.0610215068,
-0.0441281721,
-0.0184561592,
-0.0110103087,
0.0092087071,
0.0284060724,
-0.0253508948,
0.043840535,
0.0294412188,
0.0073172301,
0.0022622126,
0.0420308784,
-0.0397639684,
-0.0247527771,
0.0537403151,
0.0080834012,
0.0175332818,
-0.0260604173,
-0.0107511375,
-0.0283632018,
0.0128818778,
-0.0506060347,
0.018816743,
0.0084589645,
-0.0194410738,
0.0049534491,
0.0128451977,
-0.0002011878,
0.0094902059,
0.0698832795,
-0.0567735918,
-0.0317728966,
0.0350069255,
0.0342481583,
0.0377293453,
-0.0318821967,
0.0091246795,
-0.0145077044,
0.0570019633,
-0.0091945259,
-0.0064759757,
0.0163650531,
-0.0034720055,
-0.0218059551,
0.0262109712,
0.0110099651,
-0.0183243714,
-0.0544325449,
0.0128361499,
-0.017509127,
0.0348500833,
0.004688161,
0.0336696804,
-0.0063159363,
-0.0119139971,
-0.0404423475,
0.0214721039,
-0.0538315587,
0.0232769139,
0.017426502,
0.0315446779,
0.0071353512,
-0.0196460597,
-0.0119815897,
-0.0101363529,
-0.0124750426,
-0.0125610558,
-0.0181316603,
0.0081186714,
0.0112589346,
-0.021230923,
-0.0470024832,
0.0696611479,
0.0482336283,
-0.0309160557,
-0.0064363745,
-0.0615007468,
0.0153706269,
-0.0270117242,
0.0482489504,
0.0022099356,
-0.07772661,
-0.0346450731,
0.0040815333,
0.0260827579,
0.0746861398,
0.0017402308,
0.0088682193,
0.0416324213,
0.0166225508,
-0.0068005794,
0.0178652089,
-0.0519056991,
-0.0421033166,
-0.0681288466,
0.0412831865,
0.0016693011,
0.0701993629,
-0.0038193655,
-0.0159976203,
-0.0471268035,
-0.0144648748,
-0.0493529812,
-0.0254362356,
-0.0404166058,
0.0364205986,
-0.0149102528,
0.0171168633,
-0.0082711345,
-0.0326304175,
0.0321701951,
-0.0159684643,
0.0104927057,
-0.024914369,
-0.0673409253,
-0.0064462372,
-0.0048859725,
-0.0036114908,
0.0360994786,
-0.0073060272,
-0.0183288828,
-0.0503440611,
-0.0150945643,
0.0099926572,
-0.0174019895,
0.0012889637,
0.0004838141,
-0.0007349005,
-0.010601907,
-0.0474519432,
-0.0175398998,
-0.0462494344,
-0.0072923447,
0.0016360899,
0.0993251428,
-0.0460095666,
-0.0313934572,
0.0480576083,
-0.0140310396,
0.1014668271,
-0.0150289629,
0.0018751931,
-0.0227349289,
0.0146109909,
0.0217366442,
0.0334749557,
0.0057812524,
-0.0032037366,
-0.0113534387,
0.0118991788,
0.0436546318,
-0.0120973084,
-0.0546326973,
0.0109789604,
0.0495758541,
0.0065484964,
-0.0232770499,
-0.0011382996,
0.0371104628,
-0.0578866974,
-0.0204862282,
0.0609342642,
-0.0273207948,
-0.0415298305,
-0.0098449877,
0.0278315973,
0.0653059408,
0.0098264515,
0.0403061174,
-0.0560648553,
-0.0240073502,
0.017351307,
0.033633247,
0.0263894666,
-0.0036909115,
-0.0018651102,
-0.0635222569,
0.0293900687,
0.007663765,
-0.0670831129,
0.0082369661,
-0.0563396923,
0.0136996666,
-0.0160298664,
0.0373453349,
-0.0193793625,
-0.0117769223,
-0.0338689536,
0.0479735844,
-0.0342142358,
-0.0825084448,
-0.0070901401,
-0.0134877125,
-0.0074435822,
0.0454888642,
0.0061922097,
-0.0443215482,
-0.0483159088,
0.1023828536,
-0.0193167571,
-0.0038147219,
-0.0248130355,
0.0443275906,
0.0156454481,
-0.0510763451,
0.0253646448,
0.0053528361,
0.0025349301,
0.0052503245,
-0.0277448762,
0.0401231647,
0.000458134,
-0.0399333537,
0.0306035746,
-0.0283863153,
-0.0116307251,
0.0361158289,
0.0024694153,
-0.0441594683,
-0.0341462977,
-0.0047347704,
0.0151011385,
-0.0535214357,
-0.0419764519,
0.0397476405,
-0.0189110264,
-0.0689146668,
-0.0194262825,
-0.0043084957,
-0.0006175671,
0.043447569,
0.0127058411,
0.0185620673,
0.0368509591,
0.0382755361,
-0.0434904806,
0.0541633442,
-0.0177612137,
0.0040511372,
-0.0714998916,
-0.0376511738,
0.046456255,
-0.0096325055,
-0.0179043319,
-0.0001572315,
-0.1037176773,
-0.0548430607,
0.0199012384,
0.0544627495,
0.0112964679,
0.0364240296,
-0.0113262478,
-0.0698497519,
0.067902185,
0.0618806221,
-0.0239173621,
0.0668358505,
0.0506010801,
-0.0916427746,
-0.013988479,
0.0264030453,
-0.0272687152,
0.0629403517,
0.0227045603,
0.000651469,
0.0101950979,
-0.014460261,
-0.0156950187,
-0.0122729959,
0.0557254292,
-0.0087088896,
0.0118275713,
-0.0393846184,
0.0268062484,
0.0366649665,
0.0111157252,
-0.049288068,
-0.0305071417,
0.0293745361,
0.0114355339,
-0.0061412724,
0.0411236063,
0.0349725373,
-0.0098065566,
-0.0426740348,
0.0240467563,
0.0020076239,
0.0075236144,
0.0446512513,
0.0380748436,
-0.0115979752,
-0.0105499635,
0.0352903344,
0.0041372096,
-0.0181324501,
-0.0187453702,
0.0376525372,
0.0509012081,
-0.0707718655,
0.0221968461,
-0.0431765951,
-0.0919465721,
-0.0263704918,
-0.0472948849,
0.077743873,
-0.0168750454,
0.044630859,
-0.000558107,
-0.0212709438,
-0.0105178244,
0.0391296372,
-0.001548888,
0.0147145623,
0.000677876,
-0.026608685,
-0.0096799061,
0.0331484452,
0.0496896505,
0.0032166867,
0.047841195,
0.0047758436,
0.0030798961,
-0.0302617084,
-0.0020626299,
0.0081230225,
0.0172868818,
0.0189107694,
-0.0126721412,
0.0194820762,
-0.0927783176,
-0.0127180731,
-0.0238235798,
0.009670876,
-0.0047415653,
0.0449713469,
0.0301372316,
-0.0035424323,
0.0070836777,
-0.0232492499,
-0.016304696,
0.0524510145,
-0.0149056055,
0.0193607919,
-7.617482573e-33,
0.0098478328,
0.0063535222,
-0.0057987426,
0.0406763144,
-0.0284937304,
0.0034252179,
-0.010991117,
-0.0130315963,
-0.0247925594,
0.0249701981,
-0.0283936188,
-0.0053672236,
0.0190178808,
0.0372815356,
-0.0466021597,
-0.0010962035,
0.0956829935,
-0.0018254815,
0.0098435553,
0.0399368778,
0.0224576797,
0.0634514466,
0.083901763,
-0.066155389,
-0.0481908731,
-0.017282581,
-0.0293480195,
-0.0080060717,
0.0304010995,
0.0154659003,
-0.0203050636,
0.0296520889,
0.0019816514,
-0.0441676453,
-0.0235585831,
-0.0083235446,
-0.1026515737,
-0.029199671,
-0.0129126944,
0.0427496992,
-0.0562847927,
-0.0123177841,
0.0629523396,
0.0193221718,
-0.0380121507,
-0.0006546811,
0.021487968,
0.0111482693,
-0.0437457338,
-0.0668984428,
-0.0452694297,
0.0127699832,
0.002882164,
-0.0314286388,
0.0485082977,
-0.0137366848,
-0.0375393555,
0.0064068562,
-0.0588086508,
-0.043858584,
0.0118725002,
0.0519812107,
0.0463547967,
0.0556428954,
0.0007355376,
0.0087601598,
0.0167724211,
0.0325460695,
0.0448433422,
-0.0101165045,
0.1058617756,
0.0179920476,
-0.006319744,
-0.0217108913,
0.10187231,
-0.0686689019,
-0.0536261275,
-0.0041263583,
-0.0744834021,
0.0514733903,
0.0566718765,
0.0288035609,
0.0327887498,
-0.0180536937,
-0.0705684647,
0.0116692195,
-0.0131355273,
0.0000638827,
0.0293719526,
0.0305604935,
-0.0144892316,
0.0031126274,
0.0501404479,
-0.0143527174,
-0.008578904,
0.0145456577,
-0.0164115671,
-0.005413733,
-0.0194644164,
0.0034284852,
-0.0469524637,
-0.0578733496,
-0.0295380466,
-0.0120763499,
0.0297493581,
-0.0014128917,
0.0514952689,
0.0464065075,
-0.0438272953,
-0.0095885694,
-0.0321765766,
0.0503701605,
0.0244655218,
0.0853867009,
0.0293728244,
0.0028792841,
-0.0131061049,
0.0575098507,
0.0116139771,
-0.0128433248,
-0.0190996788,
0.0166735388,
0.0447488576,
0.0215850994,
-0.0310042053,
-0.0089823455,
-0.0397023745,
0.0184322521,
0.0425340943,
-0.0694540218,
-0.01680048,
0.0189499073,
3.171e-7,
0.0214738566,
0.0292268358,
-0.0437003002,
0.0144349653,
-0.0064480575,
-0.0043797372,
-0.0130469222,
0.0085944431,
0.0122984136,
0.0111349709,
-0.0006752225,
0.0384781994,
0.0435370393,
0.0276613813,
-0.0607281178,
-0.020304177,
-0.045355536,
0.0291497577,
-0.0266071577,
-0.0258274768,
-0.0374534726,
0.107956171,
0.0370507985,
-0.015505882,
0.0225890055,
0.0118559906,
0.0430349857,
-0.0391565412,
0.0615998544,
0.0255394876,
0.0634912476,
0.0511072576,
-0.0025443446,
0.0005319393,
-0.0305660851,
0.0109773176,
0.0030581616,
0.0338336341,
-0.0329872929,
-0.0111704236,
0.0369247645,
0.0444069356,
-0.0040676966,
-0.041310817,
0.0244559534,
-0.0664218217,
-0.0007935813,
-0.033852227,
-0.0017539368,
0.0007836813,
0.0427551977,
-0.0292754453,
-0.0001674671,
0.0529481359,
0.0558736771,
0.0039803991,
-0.0572151877,
-0.0971347466,
0.0000718525,
0.0518887453,
-0.0193136539,
-0.0167236514,
-0.0260223169,
-0.0316413753,
0.0335060991,
-0.0024890131,
0.0256646108,
2.766017875e-34,
0.0093629155,
-0.0301613696,
0.0069793221,
0.0307884105,
-0.0011308012,
-0.0065434915,
0.008525691,
0.0239139572,
-0.0005292633,
-0.0463882089,
-0.0157690886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10088v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10088v2 | Android in the Wild: A Large-Scale Dataset for Android Device Control | 2023-07-19T15:57:24 | 2023-10-27T14:24:31 | Christopher Rawles, Alice Li, Daniel Rodriguez, Oriana Riva, Timothy Lillicrap | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.HC | There is a growing interest in device-control systems that can interpret
human natural language instructions and execute them on a digital device by
directly controlling its user interface. We present a dataset for
device-control research, Android in the Wild (AITW), which is orders of
magnitude larger than current datasets. The dataset contains human
demonstrations of device interactions, including the screens and actions, and
corresponding natural language instructions. It consists of 715k episodes
spanning 30k unique instructions, four versions of Android (v10-13),and eight
device types (Pixel 2 XL to Pixel 6) with varying screen resolutions. It
contains multi-step tasks that require semantic understanding of language and
visual context. This dataset poses a new challenge: actions available through
the user interface must be inferred from their visual appearance. And, instead
of simple UI element-based actions, the action space consists of precise
gestures (e.g., horizontal scrolls to operate carousel widgets). We organize
our dataset to encourage robustness analysis of device-control systems, i.e.,
how well a system performs in the presence of new task descriptions, new
applications, or new platform versions. We develop two agents and report
performance across the dataset. The dataset is available at
https://github.com/google-research/google-research/tree/master/android_in_the_wild. | [
0.0147989588,
0.0290570371,
-0.0221350342,
0.027627727,
-0.018090751,
0.0156297646,
0.042605672,
0.007367033,
0.029165661,
-0.0691361427,
-0.0159290452,
-0.015462379,
0.015319082,
0.0068715778,
0.011315506,
-0.0496577434,
0.0192339346,
0.0090846,
-0.0117458645,
0.0497042313,
0.0347803794,
0.0000389324,
0.0071946084,
0.045612786,
-0.0225831959,
-0.017148966,
-0.0285673831,
0.0500930324,
0.0350436457,
-0.0223707296,
-0.0031354257,
0.0237739161,
0.0325088054,
0.0533313304,
0.0000016811,
-0.016704442,
0.0573500395,
-0.0130811948,
-0.0131031182,
-0.0222437549,
0.0699876621,
-0.0069262935,
0.0038145601,
0.0149803227,
-0.0519370995,
-0.0173821989,
0.010567287,
0.0342720784,
0.0486230552,
0.0587296896,
-0.006359525,
0.02783636,
-0.0180117842,
0.008107285,
0.0360950604,
-0.0288141649,
0.0015717433,
-0.0174848866,
0.0546100251,
-0.0190816708,
0.015751468,
-0.0403032154,
0.0385976471,
0.0203253347,
-0.0491808988,
0.0292501729,
-0.0178755727,
-0.030957289,
-0.0186971091,
0.0597093292,
-0.0280828942,
-0.0189526808,
0.046568878,
0.0101453634,
-0.0059984657,
-0.0289568584,
0.0102691501,
-0.0232409202,
-0.0361441523,
-0.0249347426,
-0.0513907634,
-0.023329122,
0.0193758477,
-0.027978139,
-0.0118665295,
0.0736345723,
0.0090504671,
-0.0052021584,
-0.030639274,
0.0022345223,
0.0412348136,
-0.0624427907,
0.0471824221,
0.013774598,
-0.0729522333,
-0.005670574,
-0.0714906976,
-0.0327607542,
-0.0447768047,
-0.0418049619,
0.0299238749,
0.0165817291,
-0.0108207716,
0.0172142349,
0.0249761492,
0.0371404774,
-0.0273279846,
0.0505844839,
-0.0250756051,
0.0609573796,
-0.0450766534,
0.0056906035,
-0.0246296544,
-0.0240489189,
-0.047747653,
-0.024609562,
-0.0043245461,
0.0056160493,
-0.0344454199,
0.0207698438,
-0.040841911,
0.03014623,
-0.0263552461,
-0.0117046926,
0.0098957745,
-0.0217065364,
-0.055420436,
0.0781835467,
0.0216718763,
-0.0514586382,
0.0230630673,
0.0061023133,
0.0095380405,
-0.0117664244,
-0.0104994671,
0.0474188067,
-0.0128471097,
-0.0355613567,
-0.0250698254,
-0.005090327,
0.0192971863,
-0.0280621089,
0.0036328477,
-0.0411647484,
0.0724133179,
-0.019673001,
-0.0165296961,
-0.0389052257,
0.0235905107,
0.0442884415,
0.0058755782,
0.0841217637,
-0.004784097,
0.0029779945,
0.0151375756,
0.0436675064,
-0.0534147024,
0.0197695922,
0.0644386783,
0.070720695,
0.0286963228,
0.0167329293,
0.0202030577,
0.0364755243,
-0.0261199195,
-0.0252983477,
-0.0032925766,
0.0042340718,
0.0033686964,
0.0302606188,
-0.0070509482,
0.0209126286,
-0.004001454,
-0.0026928575,
0.0613222718,
0.0736180693,
-0.055430647,
-0.0222246051,
0.0126517573,
0.0019538214,
-0.0022359327,
-0.05061315,
-0.0796257481,
0.00209569,
0.0103101153,
-0.0271203686,
-0.0161263067,
-0.012897755,
-0.0412882417,
-0.0302219931,
-0.0329504274,
-0.0103268456,
0.0378717259,
0.0099571142,
0.018408021,
0.0175118577,
0.0277047139,
-0.0205493644,
-0.0131192906,
-0.0267150346,
-0.0343552828,
-0.0525218137,
0.0595675707,
0.0596376173,
0.0070477435,
-0.0462391376,
-0.0270601492,
0.0101546682,
0.0558931828,
-0.0191110708,
-0.0048044305,
-0.0273407642,
0.0530638359,
-0.0049239188,
-0.0221097041,
-0.0046302266,
0.0381511115,
0.0226558242,
-0.0048976629,
0.001425424,
0.0068829656,
-0.0262102094,
-0.0118670864,
0.038468454,
0.0009646406,
-0.050859876,
0.0296815243,
0.026234543,
0.0127183888,
0.0130880782,
-0.0075418693,
-0.043954879,
0.0373587795,
-0.0437535308,
0.0076715224,
0.0246076733,
0.0027997924,
-0.0014176311,
0.0255754516,
-0.0551531538,
-0.0246973112,
0.0517545417,
-0.0270630065,
-0.0266350787,
0.0250001922,
0.040800903,
0.0349998511,
0.0337471776,
0.0160848293,
0.0264651105,
-0.0234329607,
0.0496647805,
0.0477692857,
0.0366796553,
0.0139355287,
0.0345292874,
0.0158163849,
-0.0141434055,
-0.0179439541,
0.0183019359,
-0.0033815966,
-0.0547167696,
0.0138689466,
0.0207505077,
0.0247541983,
-0.0501112565,
0.0079199467,
-0.0522424988,
0.0180987436,
-0.0645562634,
-0.0013651234,
0.0320370942,
0.0597786941,
-0.0008401453,
-0.065685384,
0.0320596844,
0.0143800275,
-0.0029424848,
0.0127988476,
-0.0020493194,
0.0233462919,
-0.0044059139,
-0.0365358368,
0.0260011461,
-0.0240712687,
0.0082090152,
0.0196064953,
0.0495885126,
-0.0531346276,
-0.0089815045,
0.0021699232,
0.0180135854,
-0.0383984372,
-0.0257983711,
0.0729129687,
-0.0061036386,
-0.027542606,
0.117657125,
-0.0169907417,
0.0474826768,
0.0093081249,
-0.0343975611,
-0.0262380615,
0.0013452551,
0.0524918102,
-0.0070598298,
-0.09817826,
0.0014835782,
0.0215597562,
0.0733348429,
-0.0077330582,
0.0233016275,
-0.0423009656,
-0.0280062519,
-0.0377502516,
-0.0590900257,
-0.0094248075,
0.0421085544,
-0.048022531,
0.0434933566,
-0.066241011,
-0.055340454,
0.0330795459,
-0.0066872123,
-0.0081844302,
0.0291857123,
-0.0096997246,
0.0185893718,
0.0892017633,
0.0268461965,
0.0089469431,
0.0167430528,
-0.0333742201,
0.008039617,
0.0168811232,
-0.001304752,
-0.0144275865,
0.0251496471,
-0.1086769179,
-0.0129874554,
-0.0212667733,
-0.049046807,
-0.0226317905,
-0.0135086328,
-0.0163828284,
-0.0465556495,
-0.0076769069,
-0.0257946625,
-0.0382498689,
-0.0023756716,
0.0172352418,
0.043550685,
0.032396201,
-0.0303499512,
-0.0337901413,
-0.0293379445,
0.0414087623,
0.0114102373,
-0.0975604802,
0.0138075855,
0.0008635488,
0.0363501683,
0.0823746249,
-0.0179603174,
-0.06625586,
0.0235115532,
0.0208581183,
0.0093436697,
0.0195441972,
0.0812254846,
0.0862624645,
-0.055420652,
-0.0309995115,
0.066821292,
0.0185413584,
-0.0205695964,
0.022578707,
0.0269772373,
-0.0001876491,
0.0302469414,
0.0254744925,
-0.0851034224,
-0.0660309494,
-0.0112868529,
0.0021189973,
0.0577406548,
0.0050300094,
0.0027103804,
-0.0676870719,
-0.0307511017,
0.0026007574,
-0.0243282281,
-0.0371438004,
-0.0234283768,
0.0151299015,
-0.0570137873,
-0.0082286168,
0.0030122262,
-0.0021481642,
-0.0209410563,
-0.0211168509,
-0.0214772951,
-0.0354076959,
0.0672801509,
-0.0311573427,
-0.0112956176,
0.0759697109,
0.0119205816,
0.0069229985,
-0.0231259111,
-0.0503481254,
0.0068205772,
-0.0040641571,
0.0064115855,
0.0182492509,
0.0027717049,
0.0074896305,
0.0043189204,
0.1007180214,
-0.0769856721,
-0.0263275839,
0.0338719636,
0.0603203401,
-0.0021322344,
-0.0377618149,
-0.0258262269,
-0.0629621893,
0.0612133779,
0.0104468782,
-0.0065329522,
-0.0440907329,
-0.0631550997,
-0.0373099037,
-0.0416941345,
-0.0163907502,
-0.0225690398,
-0.0029880046,
0.0184409209,
-0.0345794968,
-0.0268889014,
-0.0304390639,
0.0484806858,
0.0630616918,
0.0284137074,
-0.0318001844,
0.0217746682,
0.0535134412,
-0.0300857238,
0.0177386757,
0.0272448417,
0.0525441207,
0.0051475549,
-0.0270071235,
0.0091951927,
-0.0020459716,
0.0062807002,
0.027636962,
-0.0420310125,
-0.0805673525,
-0.0094741005,
0.0589328296,
0.0272724628,
0.0429429375,
-0.0546405986,
-0.017369438,
-0.0055826348,
0.0274225678,
-0.0273505282,
0.019010881,
0.0203590672,
0.0082902759,
-0.0247658081,
0.0339676365,
-0.0617846958,
0.0026299537,
-0.0107303755,
0.0099978922,
-0.0528177842,
-0.0353899077,
0.0279575847,
-0.0375524648,
0.0438481271,
-0.0059303036,
0.017801838,
0.0072353301,
0.0095171351,
0.0106353443,
0.0007311704,
-0.050025817,
0.0036067772,
-0.0630885214,
-0.0045309304,
-0.0074310517,
0.0032389339,
-0.0015019283,
0.0023172321,
-0.0695752129,
0.0270935744,
0.0025875471,
0.0464944802,
0.0041293027,
-0.0034372774,
0.0154005513,
0.0130835995,
-0.0088100592,
0.0643780529,
-0.0145723308,
0.0215995237,
0.0073246537,
-0.0018030507,
-0.0181062743,
0.0540544353,
-0.0272180568,
-0.0395780019,
0.0177526623,
0.0075260778,
0.0345400311,
-0.0370200463,
0.0100784004,
-0.0440403111,
0.0147563918,
-0.0444730893,
0.0498226061,
-0.0149493609,
-0.0488682464,
0.0157687943,
0.0310841724,
-0.0094478792,
-0.0152186239,
0.0421172082,
-0.0001245825,
0.016748976,
0.0330308415,
-0.0150136324,
-0.055330053,
-0.0291217044,
0.0314169191,
0.0090906788,
-0.0123699857,
-0.0092695802,
-0.0379287973,
-0.0477007292,
-0.023826478,
0.0395645052,
0.0409768373,
-0.0175457951,
0.010436397,
0.0404257551,
-0.0068451795,
-0.0268894099,
-0.0031931214,
-0.0591524355,
-0.0655694082,
0.0019594387,
-0.0728475899,
-4.482906031e-33,
-0.008487056,
0.0267450251,
0.0042993813,
-0.0287896413,
0.0152374031,
-0.0417455323,
-0.0136548737,
-0.001346641,
0.018550938,
0.0201209709,
-0.0583254173,
0.0293605495,
0.0068405066,
0.0155238723,
0.0243453663,
-0.0302582365,
0.0490399413,
-0.0507503822,
-0.0688241869,
0.0439838506,
0.0459445119,
0.0228359401,
0.0293453764,
-0.0511666425,
0.023890689,
0.0060977256,
0.0067048492,
-0.0359504595,
-0.0164345894,
0.0023714583,
0.0014015046,
-0.0045505776,
0.0221037287,
-0.0029585976,
-0.0234616939,
0.0543576963,
-0.0346607342,
-0.0337148905,
-0.0452419072,
0.0721533,
-0.0696329623,
-0.0111538945,
0.0241121538,
0.0055480464,
-0.0547536649,
0.0173440035,
0.0517736003,
-0.0071501075,
0.0134869069,
-0.0169525519,
0.0093361363,
0.0068507711,
0.0474025384,
-0.0769444779,
-0.0229475517,
0.0253736172,
-0.0550508872,
-0.0143446261,
-0.065729931,
-0.0025019872,
-0.0393435173,
0.030939417,
0.0529724844,
0.0153481895,
0.071586743,
0.0421950594,
0.0197761562,
-0.0072683464,
-0.0039315149,
0.0237827301,
-0.0191959124,
0.1181905121,
-0.0371302441,
0.025843529,
0.0730763748,
-0.0487002321,
-0.0156970937,
0.0446399935,
0.0088052768,
0.0556442589,
-0.0289438721,
0.0318507105,
-0.061540544,
0.0150341485,
0.0100742085,
0.0286415573,
-0.0014061357,
-0.0189021155,
0.0715932027,
0.0460936427,
-0.0358788855,
-0.0288167316,
0.0389198586,
-0.0382282175,
-0.0056205988,
-0.0216125604,
0.0077596889,
0.0208930001,
0.0194023829,
-0.0147583708,
-0.0243944936,
-0.0467194654,
0.0039456114,
0.0350720584,
0.0672115833,
-0.0281012412,
0.0064978707,
0.0813699514,
-0.0237060487,
0.0008276833,
-0.0228079893,
0.0364303477,
-0.0107162921,
0.0069743395,
0.0524016581,
0.0021292684,
-0.0071804011,
0.0769377127,
-0.0590101406,
-0.0756162331,
-0.0216182228,
-0.0232108142,
0.0114000095,
-0.0508778356,
-0.0461818017,
-0.0463230684,
-0.1101746187,
0.0153862434,
0.0129149398,
-0.0134014003,
-0.009439623,
0.0461973585,
2.558e-7,
-0.0621018335,
-0.0335357301,
-0.0056911786,
0.0414502844,
0.0367765948,
0.0631993786,
-0.0098667657,
0.0845293254,
-0.0429958254,
-0.0480275154,
-0.0261346046,
0.0005090695,
0.0580988303,
-0.0062777577,
-0.0392823964,
-0.0046864771,
0.0263174586,
0.0474727079,
-0.02566614,
-0.0207342729,
0.0603237152,
0.0762634352,
0.0152850337,
0.0304276291,
0.0836414322,
-0.0249624979,
0.007476896,
-0.0270664748,
0.0836821944,
-0.0242777467,
0.028929254,
-0.0080427919,
-0.0371407941,
-0.0117191318,
-0.031064488,
-0.0250287764,
-0.055914972,
0.0662586614,
-0.0253878888,
-0.017999474,
-0.0719084218,
-0.0384954661,
0.0012515427,
-0.0145412358,
0.0584193841,
-0.0388282202,
-0.0195199773,
0.0145727489,
0.0171179157,
-0.0091433907,
-0.0337548889,
0.0256180149,
0.0176622625,
-0.003788485,
0.0074934792,
-0.0170145053,
-0.0255534407,
-0.0912550688,
-0.0212821495,
0.0204469394,
-0.0204833988,
-0.0239069071,
-0.0670979843,
0.0541034415,
-0.0051391716,
-0.0364346392,
-0.015567081,
1.408432217e-34,
-0.0343454219,
-0.0183452703,
-0.0144419968,
0.0264562238,
0.0361507609,
-0.0003603157,
0.0226979479,
0.033961527,
0.0492312163,
-0.0314029753,
0.0010668441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10025v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10025v2 | An Empirical Study on Fertility Proposals Using Multi-Grained Topic Analysis Methods | 2023-07-19T15:09:50 | 2023-07-22T15:07:57 | Yulin Zhou | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI | Fertility issues are closely related to population security, in 60 years
China's population for the first time in a negative growth trend, the change of
fertility policy is of great concern to the community. 2023 "two sessions"
proposal "suggests that the country in the form of legislation, the birth of
the registration of the cancellation of the marriage restriction" This topic
was once a hot topic on the Internet, and "unbundling" the relationship between
birth registration and marriage has become the focus of social debate. In this
paper, we adopt co-occurrence semantic analysis, topic analysis and sentiment
analysis to conduct multi-granularity semantic analysis of microblog comments.
It is found that the discussion on the proposal of "removing marriage
restrictions from birth registration" involves the individual, society and the
state at three dimensions, and is detailed into social issues such as personal
behaviour, social ethics and law, and national policy, with people's sentiment
inclined to be negative in most of the topics. Based on this, eight proposals
were made to provide a reference for governmental decision making and to form a
reference method for researching public opinion on political issues. | [
0.0577115491,
0.0473652594,
-0.0052901255,
-0.0038615656,
-0.0421747267,
-0.008809818,
0.0004509066,
-0.0173133016,
-0.0395973288,
-0.0379789919,
0.0876966789,
-0.0257979445,
-0.0132403988,
0.0198252685,
-0.0405513421,
-0.0298629235,
0.0166632719,
0.0470957384,
0.0107087893,
0.0090125808,
0.0390299857,
-0.0138373813,
0.0041286992,
0.0348205231,
-0.008127653,
0.0197072942,
-0.0027801571,
0.0134188142,
0.0124971699,
-0.0777603984,
0.019525772,
0.0329662189,
-0.0250496678,
-0.0004364008,
0.0000018224,
-0.0583282001,
-0.0400859974,
0.0007517465,
0.0671055466,
0.0097526954,
0.077446945,
-0.0454003066,
-0.0198051054,
0.0292933267,
-0.0263265986,
0.0408380032,
0.0351816416,
0.0928373411,
0.0414723754,
0.0266202334,
-0.0235172901,
-0.0425766818,
-0.0154742496,
-0.0105034979,
0.0060186363,
-0.0013757014,
0.0398952886,
0.0252228174,
-0.0289833285,
0.0371838063,
0.0324000791,
-0.0062276833,
-0.0543189831,
-0.0257012863,
-0.0416853838,
0.0120262383,
-0.0015758425,
-0.0552969649,
0.027863523,
0.0183880012,
0.0615436994,
-0.0171326976,
0.0576651283,
-0.0191300549,
-0.0391954407,
0.0712373853,
-0.0519870184,
0.004697293,
-0.0419370867,
0.0277744178,
0.0322682671,
-0.0221344568,
-0.0108952718,
0.0484914444,
0.0370314904,
0.0806841552,
-0.0154120075,
-0.0368471444,
-0.0192921571,
-0.0113216704,
0.0436270125,
-0.0125435665,
0.0345510766,
-0.0136867128,
0.0223111361,
0.0321146436,
0.0343880504,
-0.0488609597,
0.0527972206,
-0.0807789341,
-0.0457145199,
0.0321669877,
0.0232619252,
0.0122247525,
0.0504655652,
-0.094216302,
0.0137883155,
-0.0635908693,
0.0159159806,
-0.0000825697,
-0.069064863,
0.047676973,
-0.045611199,
0.008186684,
-0.0221627858,
0.011052751,
-0.0301902257,
0.029829463,
-0.0175103638,
-0.0458711013,
-0.061950542,
0.0182366874,
0.0339871719,
0.0154005317,
-0.0369655825,
0.0288496446,
-0.051529251,
0.0478385687,
-0.0726507753,
0.0601811111,
0.0354163833,
0.0382622369,
0.0667232648,
0.0477316603,
-0.0308075454,
-0.0171159357,
0.0236833543,
0.0102813533,
-0.0338116512,
-0.0060491995,
-0.043217089,
0.0230428912,
-0.0152157508,
-0.0724285021,
-0.0339914933,
-0.0165210553,
0.0117235305,
0.0264208689,
0.0321234539,
0.0201760232,
-0.0179458596,
-0.000264926,
-0.0440585315,
-0.0101715215,
0.0186762735,
0.0525032915,
0.053414911,
0.0656636581,
0.0137620606,
0.0298084747,
0.0559134074,
-0.0068700267,
-0.0110812057,
-0.0356768146,
-0.0086563583,
0.0182004794,
-0.0020606525,
0.0177906901,
-0.0289554056,
-0.0642868653,
-0.0336637944,
0.0273171701,
-0.0023154779,
0.0185406003,
-0.0048245052,
0.0924414694,
-0.0460433252,
0.0304800589,
-0.000574609,
0.0483664311,
-0.030669041,
0.0099345129,
0.0502578244,
-0.0169257075,
-0.0101595409,
-0.0366756395,
0.0312188733,
-0.0264613852,
-0.0102037108,
-0.0542999022,
-0.0118992543,
0.0167355556,
0.034073364,
-0.0732126683,
0.0187420473,
-0.0453574806,
0.0193244778,
0.0318140686,
0.0426716655,
-0.0244889557,
-0.0071408004,
-0.0120385168,
0.0320403539,
0.0362759568,
-0.0291449446,
-0.0261924248,
-0.0287868101,
-0.0013265776,
0.0227891039,
0.0261213072,
0.0251463391,
-0.0139899887,
-0.0804671645,
0.0065073315,
-0.0306829195,
0.0350611545,
0.0171058159,
-0.0122348489,
0.0040724603,
0.0337110348,
0.0274970271,
0.0513414219,
0.0329662189,
0.0156272128,
0.0505590029,
0.0654779822,
-0.0070110341,
-0.0043475092,
0.0313819237,
0.049693536,
0.0029514625,
-0.0032402754,
0.0616597086,
0.0042091464,
-0.0497219637,
-0.0109569374,
0.0468443669,
0.0375313088,
0.0078393491,
-0.0538383387,
-0.0106829898,
-0.0246621557,
-0.0198347494,
-0.0110670635,
0.0736962259,
0.0150597421,
0.0066074417,
-0.0390917249,
-0.0027691906,
-0.0581324287,
-0.0119095072,
-0.021031525,
0.0319431908,
-0.0397608206,
0.0184228476,
-0.0404414386,
-0.0561414286,
0.0498286784,
-0.0138015673,
-0.0266507193,
0.0011547133,
0.0081509724,
0.0441498533,
0.0538005307,
-0.0050108884,
-0.0516117103,
-0.0556344762,
-0.0630066469,
0.0015696296,
-0.0070058717,
0.033736866,
0.0228286665,
-0.0046130344,
0.0117596965,
0.0213025343,
0.0162915755,
0.0531327464,
-0.065405488,
0.007177915,
0.0333535336,
-0.0125406375,
0.065296486,
0.0128084477,
0.0039646234,
-0.0536642745,
-0.0246370696,
0.0489732064,
-0.0193485338,
0.0296115857,
0.0025102939,
-0.0622486919,
-0.0212049894,
-0.0078700939,
-0.0009203229,
0.000723941,
0.0020341487,
0.0202234983,
-0.0563021377,
0.034460403,
0.0798128098,
0.0327779837,
0.0285153743,
0.0000436989,
-0.0113509204,
-0.0255306717,
0.0754552335,
0.0104455976,
0.00467163,
0.0275026746,
0.0026003437,
0.0033881231,
0.0186471958,
-0.0219851993,
0.0360010825,
-0.0415025018,
0.0368658565,
-0.0368366465,
0.0168669503,
0.0136288442,
0.0331337415,
0.0010033483,
0.0124646621,
-0.0166924559,
0.0344680287,
0.0528247803,
-0.0490472615,
-0.0557025,
-0.021379441,
0.0110575473,
-0.0094171008,
0.0258453041,
0.0216615684,
0.0035102866,
0.0125432769,
-0.029293919,
-0.0125130471,
-0.0108556952,
0.0565952696,
-0.011558909,
0.0123980073,
-0.0230524559,
-0.0232814923,
0.0137257641,
-0.1112756953,
-0.0153922299,
0.0065226718,
0.0199578684,
0.0128612043,
0.0110905617,
0.0666147396,
-0.0118636489,
-0.0475787483,
0.0175079759,
-0.0284913741,
-0.0000264197,
0.0389069766,
0.017524831,
-0.0423476361,
-0.0069390046,
0.0558426604,
-0.0337611623,
0.0682286844,
-0.0010063939,
-0.0036166902,
-0.0422014259,
-0.0198331177,
-0.0284105279,
-0.0362887308,
-0.018972503,
-0.0286107901,
0.0257871356,
-0.0668715239,
0.0873806104,
0.0761029422,
0.0288125686,
0.042839732,
-0.0023436004,
-0.0209368877,
-0.0317732506,
0.0253263488,
-0.0010332522,
-0.0759118125,
0.0320086926,
-0.0365874693,
-0.020159319,
-0.0448964387,
-0.0293574035,
-0.016234668,
-0.0356877334,
0.002697469,
-0.0311943199,
0.0145233274,
0.0142797129,
-0.060814172,
0.041645471,
-0.0103617795,
-0.0154407788,
-0.0352589861,
0.0019497807,
0.0072156033,
-0.0044968659,
-0.0653350726,
-0.0126296738,
0.0094627049,
-0.0293246694,
0.0163083337,
-0.0255973805,
0.1078702733,
-0.0455085486,
0.0191043615,
0.0432287231,
-0.0166963004,
-0.0278992504,
-0.012940974,
0.0148957232,
-0.0009026953,
-0.0195483454,
-0.0549478382,
-0.0039451113,
0.006665844,
-0.0186241418,
0.0159021989,
0.0370385572,
-0.0352581255,
-0.0638538823,
-0.0138768377,
0.0454388112,
0.0134868119,
0.040690124,
0.0050760061,
-0.0175923221,
0.0064460686,
-0.0399220325,
-0.004241447,
0.0309262183,
0.0079400297,
-0.0561241731,
-0.0122401007,
-0.0880373344,
-0.0431192145,
-0.0050382176,
-0.0099312244,
0.0501695201,
-0.0043983022,
0.0507471934,
0.1212872714,
0.0000095749,
-0.0203143917,
-0.0069504543,
0.0018378451,
-0.0389598534,
0.0095256204,
-0.0542611443,
0.0444493815,
0.0701660737,
-0.0073265289,
-0.0357107222,
-0.0280377865,
-0.033076413,
-0.0339693092,
-0.0551475286,
0.0116483318,
0.0008811548,
-0.023177674,
-0.0049736015,
0.0325203799,
0.0558232516,
-0.0024231367,
-0.0243104007,
0.0073973988,
0.0657762662,
0.004659689,
0.015673954,
0.040241845,
0.0244325716,
-0.0233006179,
-0.0239512771,
-0.0790578425,
0.0053804568,
-0.0473754406,
-0.0005538871,
0.0438178591,
0.0282302573,
-0.0067088706,
-0.0277199,
-0.0350221023,
-0.0285625197,
-0.0373666361,
-0.0031416612,
-0.0462731756,
-0.0238279421,
0.0038978744,
-0.0697551966,
-0.0016553142,
-0.0456247739,
0.0181616805,
-0.0323993787,
0.0532964878,
-0.0280095525,
0.0417131297,
-0.0063774101,
-0.007251122,
0.010337458,
-0.0092688184,
-0.016010832,
0.0003429858,
-0.0182313025,
-0.0017125667,
-0.025628889,
-0.0174936689,
0.0573485717,
0.0099543389,
-0.0145321013,
-0.0197117534,
-0.0192081388,
0.0115816789,
-0.0118365381,
-0.0097060548,
0.0253967997,
0.0043769823,
-0.0089496421,
-0.0001057739,
0.0400622226,
-0.0130728129,
-0.0457594134,
0.0345141478,
-0.0097613698,
-0.0472796112,
-0.0040008193,
0.0226411652,
-0.0393985808,
0.0036515561,
0.0701815113,
-0.0455015562,
-0.010635064,
-0.0145843849,
0.0220799372,
0.0347259268,
-0.0019938864,
0.031518016,
-0.0593095534,
0.0241212081,
0.0075940997,
-0.0276788417,
-0.0100939209,
-0.0045773671,
0.0015698751,
0.0102695553,
0.0074957293,
0.0554903932,
-0.0758872777,
-0.0409163348,
-0.0551073477,
-0.0090510203,
0.0078295469,
-6.313334039e-33,
-0.0144210057,
-0.0548804589,
-0.0002535092,
0.0351445414,
-0.0005559964,
-0.0267680697,
-0.0318830758,
0.031156918,
-0.0128060458,
0.0097882198,
0.0256604701,
0.0248817354,
0.0123024452,
-0.0071440176,
0.0291448738,
-0.0008316279,
0.0206502136,
-0.0024810601,
0.0191147849,
0.0294833723,
0.0325473621,
-0.015788909,
-0.0023546275,
-0.095501326,
0.0637909696,
0.018656835,
-0.0221146587,
-0.0168020632,
0.0767567903,
-0.0099630905,
-0.0178626478,
0.0324236862,
0.065421544,
-0.0394769199,
0.0157877356,
0.0901432037,
-0.0319229662,
-0.0807428882,
-0.0139551675,
-0.0361722484,
0.0113091925,
-0.0191916283,
0.0188160501,
0.0295158233,
-0.0074555115,
0.0560207404,
0.0551344715,
0.0056939814,
0.021147253,
-0.0451673158,
-0.0519140027,
0.0574426353,
-0.0484002158,
0.0664174706,
-0.0329656489,
-0.0155886598,
0.0062284376,
0.041296728,
-0.0358277522,
0.0307694133,
-0.0286534913,
0.0134140616,
-0.0456094071,
-0.0723722801,
0.0359277166,
0.0456860512,
-0.0250053946,
0.0233750623,
-0.0002334616,
-0.0334728472,
0.0272374526,
0.0105498927,
-0.0084317261,
0.0459995233,
0.0650358051,
-0.0559160933,
-0.0815992728,
0.017210409,
0.0329751521,
-0.0010497149,
0.0386678055,
-0.002787157,
-0.0160656124,
-0.0161514208,
-0.0058055939,
-0.040194422,
-0.0379739404,
-0.0268730167,
-0.0541280024,
-0.0145539772,
-0.0307355057,
0.0531746931,
0.0004118984,
-0.0346744992,
-0.0424004346,
0.0245593283,
-0.0494864322,
-0.0162513349,
0.0180227533,
0.040781714,
-0.0591772608,
-0.0617105924,
-0.0127915367,
0.0373453163,
0.0287532117,
0.0000111953,
0.0027223965,
-0.0369662791,
-0.0860316902,
-0.041994039,
0.0138357943,
-0.0342699401,
0.0022192195,
-0.0283887144,
-0.0186727941,
0.0301367864,
0.0320856497,
0.0166458786,
0.0736905634,
0.0404815264,
0.0196820702,
-0.0426607914,
-0.0338046066,
-0.0266329516,
0.0019934105,
0.0046150875,
-0.0060182055,
0.0014511792,
0.0606690347,
0.006701658,
-0.030000193,
-0.0114354463,
2.699e-7,
0.079645671,
0.053058479,
-0.0605452843,
-0.0406742282,
0.0401128009,
0.0372136384,
0.0058695767,
0.023503108,
-0.0120818261,
-0.0011703238,
0.0195184443,
-0.0137305781,
0.0110027278,
0.0225431956,
-0.0560834333,
0.0121311285,
0.0064328681,
-0.0122151468,
-0.027371591,
0.1010520384,
0.0073734252,
0.0254429728,
0.0239456575,
0.0486510806,
-0.0599032156,
0.0329720378,
0.0428779796,
-0.0306594241,
-0.0401120894,
0.0500664264,
0.0026632198,
0.0234267004,
-0.0065069152,
0.0008902993,
-0.029612761,
-0.0092573138,
0.0089505743,
0.0409316085,
0.0148435952,
0.0115721552,
0.0222774651,
-0.0581332892,
0.0277906284,
0.0000895511,
0.0643098205,
-0.0266941525,
-0.0674372762,
-0.0862598494,
0.0205155928,
-0.005106803,
0.0282882061,
-0.0092735635,
-0.0339624025,
0.0151305189,
-0.0320547372,
-0.0310728159,
-0.0057781655,
-0.0288661532,
-0.0016953417,
0.0267126076,
0.00647307,
-0.0675974712,
0.0531931035,
-0.0072726398,
0.0591691844,
-0.0130861932,
0.0768876895,
1.666645393e-34,
0.0421831906,
-0.0032565715,
-0.0358644687,
-0.0557488315,
0.0153410453,
0.034260992,
-0.0622254722,
-0.009160337,
-0.0199995413,
-0.0096921856,
0.037157502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10016v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10016v1 | When Dialects Collide: How Socioeconomic Mixing Affects Language Use | 2023-07-19T14:55:50 | 2023-07-19T14:55:50 | Thomas Louf, José J. Ramasco, David Sánchez, Márton Karsai | physics.soc-ph | physics.soc-ph, cs.CL, cs.SI | The socioeconomic background of people and how they use standard forms of
language are not independent, as demonstrated in various sociolinguistic
studies. However, the extent to which these correlations may be influenced by
the mixing of people from different socioeconomic classes remains relatively
unexplored from a quantitative perspective. In this work we leverage geotagged
tweets and transferable computational methods to map deviations from standard
English on a large scale, in seven thousand administrative areas of England and
Wales. We combine these data with high-resolution income maps to assign a proxy
socioeconomic indicator to home-located users. Strikingly, across eight
metropolitan areas we find a consistent pattern suggesting that the more
different socioeconomic classes mix, the less interdependent the frequency of
their departures from standard grammar and their income become. Further, we
propose an agent-based model of linguistic variety adoption that sheds light on
the mechanisms that produce the observations seen in the data. | [
-0.0216348302,
0.0781905353,
-0.0196342319,
-0.0177355651,
-0.0052340431,
0.0113874236,
0.0104515776,
0.0099333134,
0.0209456701,
-0.0162994005,
0.0269634072,
0.0154638756,
0.0478453152,
0.0068024467,
0.0337116458,
-0.0512441024,
-0.0036933124,
-0.0008529649,
-0.0091364151,
-0.0654883161,
0.036120113,
0.0252340864,
0.0464208499,
0.0452113412,
0.002351647,
0.0478424877,
0.0148137864,
-0.0334961563,
0.0188159607,
0.070003584,
0.0382698998,
0.0824384689,
-0.0167748556,
0.054224629,
0.0000018852,
-0.0078828987,
-0.0014294551,
-0.0427204221,
0.0071844859,
0.0415763743,
0.0490410849,
0.0482100658,
-0.0329130888,
0.0084613021,
-0.0407009199,
0.0164318811,
0.0193628743,
-0.086096935,
0.0207001735,
-0.0254878737,
-0.0178144127,
-0.0423556529,
-0.0090344436,
-0.0038556703,
-0.0239207838,
-0.0002726143,
0.0255945511,
-0.0509615541,
0.013435211,
-0.018486347,
-0.0465141907,
0.023640262,
-0.00609991,
-0.0439280458,
-0.007546735,
0.0505066402,
-0.0280124564,
0.0180729758,
-0.0006097957,
0.0180244818,
0.0285806414,
-0.030857306,
0.0489987172,
0.0248179398,
-0.0116757583,
0.0311513226,
-0.0322112814,
-0.0215594955,
-0.0058421427,
0.0212017596,
0.0105638206,
-0.0534547381,
-0.0036638961,
0.037587814,
-0.0479925834,
0.0797217712,
0.0180107672,
-0.0080941524,
-0.0486359634,
0.0582354106,
0.0183381028,
-0.067482233,
0.0134305656,
-0.0401030481,
-0.0157773793,
-0.0082224635,
0.0282759443,
-0.0419249237,
-0.0202917289,
-0.0200456623,
0.028697947,
-0.0037332692,
0.0091482317,
0.0226832479,
0.0437955521,
-0.0336089879,
-0.0251705162,
0.0253727678,
0.0128896795,
0.0068398998,
-0.072812885,
0.0066474057,
0.0053810868,
-0.0394557863,
-0.0125107551,
0.045863688,
-0.0193903577,
-0.0016351268,
-0.005090483,
-0.0092751794,
-0.0206674486,
-0.0265525337,
-0.0208895337,
-0.0426653512,
0.0056411182,
0.0382143743,
-0.0325846002,
0.0392029323,
0.0170431957,
-0.0191315915,
0.0508580953,
-0.0201975666,
0.0446469896,
0.0075301295,
-0.0307153426,
-0.0105758738,
-0.000212765,
0.015751591,
-0.0333242454,
-0.0015929061,
-0.0567069761,
0.0209346265,
-0.0308086649,
-0.0817002282,
-0.0317914449,
0.0124326181,
0.0024125669,
-0.0499090776,
-0.0662752688,
-0.0072871302,
-0.047657989,
-0.0407437272,
-0.0448325053,
0.0352573842,
0.0531153306,
-0.0437728204,
0.0013405291,
0.0505341068,
0.0522183366,
-0.055419106,
0.0486587435,
-0.0518188551,
0.0037598663,
0.0320359878,
-0.0093830861,
0.0459112301,
0.0087962393,
-0.0416701958,
-0.0381810516,
-0.0304716639,
0.067167908,
0.0545710213,
-0.014810794,
-0.0117186951,
0.0494251549,
0.0621075183,
0.0359273814,
-0.0189830773,
-0.0021644603,
0.0771961808,
-0.0535215028,
0.0004577235,
0.0323230699,
-0.0559513271,
-0.0130941682,
-0.03725788,
0.0385427028,
0.0703575835,
-0.0449082032,
-0.0138699077,
0.0183657557,
0.0132561885,
0.1026566997,
-0.0045784009,
0.0232773814,
-0.0149210561,
0.0567118488,
0.0357380919,
0.0522713363,
-0.0316729583,
0.0022462909,
-0.0234265886,
0.0237604361,
0.0485103875,
-0.0498382859,
0.0473087281,
0.0823553056,
0.0136895487,
0.0667852536,
0.0503208414,
-0.0044565424,
0.0000703109,
0.0080126291,
-0.0496832058,
0.0240573715,
0.0792156979,
0.0069634132,
-0.0121578053,
0.0272900108,
0.0116439629,
-0.021472767,
-0.0503351055,
-0.0055083879,
-0.0713366792,
-0.0058456371,
0.0111735584,
0.0136627667,
-0.0002460805,
0.0015467874,
0.0092641069,
-0.0186577644,
-0.0140499324,
-0.0654423833,
0.000339076,
0.0029626256,
0.0552531332,
0.0089377631,
0.0257823355,
-0.0239186194,
-0.0174428597,
0.0005326486,
-0.0061736279,
0.0066988938,
-0.0157170165,
0.0852892399,
-0.0553274825,
0.1078375876,
0.0369313248,
-0.0076077464,
-0.0234989449,
0.0327915922,
-0.0088636298,
0.0102946805,
-0.0222677756,
-0.0418475568,
-0.0265432391,
0.0078012799,
0.0095130736,
-0.0341147445,
0.0391223133,
-0.0304119959,
0.0113516748,
0.0691799894,
0.0039900295,
0.0002022959,
-0.0244775843,
-0.0327804722,
-0.0648196042,
-0.0465250276,
0.0060769031,
0.0258720592,
0.0204880424,
-0.0252044704,
-0.0312781408,
0.022885941,
-0.0366521478,
0.0533010401,
0.0019658818,
0.0418346822,
0.0106572667,
-0.042143818,
0.004515836,
-0.0370904058,
-0.0345229134,
-0.0309909992,
0.0302240606,
-0.0421843417,
-0.0094608488,
0.0007301376,
-0.0553549081,
-0.0202428345,
0.0010265259,
0.0039144591,
-0.0243801326,
0.0112220002,
-0.0169506334,
0.0321820006,
0.0039461637,
-0.0058587408,
-0.0119630974,
-0.0131806787,
-0.0675707385,
-0.0490750074,
-0.0256377291,
-0.0222712215,
0.0284859091,
-0.0516826361,
-0.0765542015,
-0.0207851324,
0.114307113,
0.0001949479,
-0.0301888548,
-0.0459105074,
0.0291092228,
-0.0405046828,
-0.000880341,
-0.0171312112,
0.0333451778,
-0.0148081882,
0.0753780678,
-0.028509669,
-0.0728411451,
-0.0316995122,
0.0153561654,
0.0133326137,
-0.0122662727,
-0.042340517,
-0.0116278138,
0.0173762739,
0.013593127,
0.0393819325,
0.0193711985,
-0.0443933867,
-0.01377255,
-0.037905544,
0.0597316623,
0.0090509271,
0.0424450077,
-0.0464214124,
0.025314359,
0.0472049303,
-0.032500077,
0.0626657158,
-0.1034369692,
-0.0675363317,
-0.0221575852,
0.0395898148,
-0.0841245204,
0.0765736699,
-0.0113451658,
0.028146442,
0.0272768438,
-0.0067212512,
0.004636711,
-0.0102625536,
0.0077503417,
0.017001152,
0.0843795016,
-0.035774149,
-0.0306881201,
-0.0156391542,
-0.0027045235,
0.0173799228,
0.051789552,
-0.0050942344,
0.0133730071,
0.0247934535,
-0.0237181764,
-0.0398070887,
0.0379094295,
0.0315777771,
0.008571201,
0.0143126296,
0.0283886716,
0.0285619833,
0.0075652199,
0.0132042123,
-0.044289317,
0.1053929999,
0.001503687,
0.0336039513,
-0.052916605,
0.0226242132,
-0.0049439268,
0.0076770233,
-0.0230583698,
-0.0146775218,
-0.0040205084,
-0.0429462157,
0.0316188112,
0.0244785082,
-0.002388915,
0.0563697219,
0.0123561108,
0.013003055,
0.0073396047,
-0.0046476191,
-0.0318591334,
-0.0040751453,
0.0056493487,
0.0481634885,
-0.0823380277,
-0.0345206112,
0.020078769,
-0.035041824,
0.0368250795,
-0.023243269,
0.0200267676,
-0.054350242,
-0.042968858,
0.0234037302,
0.0213041436,
-0.013743476,
-0.0116842184,
0.0369034186,
0.0295389611,
0.016365286,
-0.0524839424,
0.0030799771,
-0.0341347978,
0.0005138998,
0.0083411438,
0.0192044675,
0.0419424027,
-0.0633553788,
0.0099413423,
0.0316853747,
-0.0105035938,
-0.000339433,
0.0407302827,
-0.0576945953,
0.0189966355,
-0.0579955094,
-0.026801683,
0.0338230133,
-0.0819804072,
0.045009084,
-0.0057220301,
-0.0912245661,
-0.0225159414,
-0.0236222614,
0.0325850919,
0.022761533,
0.0200857967,
-0.0432312749,
0.0760513619,
-0.0814717188,
0.0240848139,
-0.0057619042,
-0.0491373278,
0.0303182006,
-0.012465233,
-0.0248279907,
0.0242275111,
0.0022382662,
-0.0202822033,
-0.0650208369,
-0.0439167358,
-0.0862981081,
0.0775706172,
-0.0273843966,
0.0247805957,
0.0176103022,
-0.0097995084,
-0.0433836654,
0.0354901999,
-0.010272922,
0.0365753956,
0.0652935207,
0.0282707941,
-0.0303835291,
0.0091192331,
0.0069928346,
-0.0135344276,
0.0410242788,
-0.019115163,
-0.0033637849,
-0.1254096329,
0.0333817713,
-0.0227838922,
-0.051781971,
-0.0013621182,
-0.0173869841,
-0.0490602851,
-0.0324921981,
-0.0341670066,
0.0014260934,
0.013092869,
-0.0008390163,
-0.0693000033,
0.0149224801,
0.0062627587,
-0.0238549076,
0.0283932649,
-0.0141650112,
0.0187586714,
0.0012693547,
0.0393031351,
-0.0355047099,
0.0306424536,
0.0108864419,
0.0069401064,
0.0421154313,
0.0346170627,
-0.0264834184,
0.0799259022,
0.0561382473,
0.0027511264,
-0.0004235896,
-0.0375880226,
0.0089526521,
0.0024158631,
-0.0506769083,
-0.0486175492,
0.0148521606,
-0.0051432559,
0.0060466691,
-0.0407984145,
0.0630558655,
0.0100377742,
0.0087892385,
-0.0381289572,
0.0108547239,
0.0041072513,
-0.032020174,
-0.0029516735,
-0.0436166897,
-0.0306388456,
0.0245712176,
0.0527849682,
0.0083007561,
-0.0184078328,
0.0073969099,
-0.0141520929,
-0.0057377275,
-0.0226014778,
-0.0107403882,
0.0031022027,
0.0168560892,
-0.0212367605,
-0.0631810278,
-0.0429099835,
-0.0169144627,
-0.0135590648,
0.0143249966,
-0.0314161219,
0.0037893199,
0.0281768441,
-0.0323406346,
0.0260514487,
-0.0463433601,
-0.0052334815,
-0.0582813323,
-0.0218708813,
0.039738331,
-6.352812282e-33,
-0.0139429746,
-0.0436561406,
-0.0015576215,
-0.0230821669,
0.0110586798,
0.0200331882,
-0.0261208098,
0.0406774469,
-0.0075896145,
0.0142052639,
-0.0352945104,
-0.0053735441,
0.0253110137,
0.0325562097,
0.0812399015,
0.031551782,
-0.0197454728,
0.0069900001,
0.0296798944,
-0.0033850882,
0.0223665629,
-0.0361762978,
0.0259915385,
-0.0172179826,
0.0027074923,
0.0279058572,
-0.0216456577,
-0.0023483485,
0.0098790936,
0.0115858847,
0.0024620609,
0.0607616492,
0.0098585701,
0.0087149581,
-0.0379295498,
0.0651358217,
0.0016120914,
-0.038582705,
-0.0082781753,
-0.0098825274,
-0.0020472868,
-0.0525412522,
0.0133239096,
0.0318713337,
-0.0574225709,
-0.0012265041,
0.0295587387,
0.0459296145,
0.0623578802,
0.0623544641,
-0.0279196277,
0.0520414002,
-0.0322711393,
0.0210994035,
-0.0230193865,
-0.0184306577,
0.0171878021,
-0.0367375575,
-0.0178506542,
0.0607357472,
0.0547371022,
0.0388549864,
0.0629955456,
-0.0192673542,
0.0230581369,
0.0141754467,
0.0189830381,
0.0318731964,
-0.0101599852,
-0.0144149875,
0.0401749723,
-0.0012887617,
-0.03142526,
0.0536812283,
0.0087688798,
-0.0471616052,
0.0357953049,
-0.0152048515,
0.0855944678,
-0.0365905277,
-0.0482269451,
0.0327885039,
-0.051260069,
-0.0793010816,
-0.0156157352,
-0.0336764716,
0.0154453684,
-0.0354323909,
0.0140538635,
-0.0392337888,
0.0518039092,
-0.0203678664,
0.0434773304,
-0.0099628847,
-0.0997122228,
-0.0867276639,
-0.0593233183,
0.0246158615,
0.0007642959,
0.046274513,
-0.0620601401,
-0.0213715769,
-0.0009909773,
0.0528302938,
0.0062641264,
0.0700170323,
-0.0257059727,
0.0325386859,
-0.0517627932,
0.0138280187,
0.0147216171,
0.0156679768,
-0.0007557226,
-0.0244068112,
0.0565061085,
0.0093586408,
0.0084617902,
0.0000977504,
0.0307311229,
0.0412965417,
0.0098650921,
0.0097802989,
-0.0404776931,
0.024838116,
-0.0008830302,
0.0015996533,
-0.0120023303,
0.0096463896,
0.0630059466,
-0.0103996377,
-0.0051538632,
-0.0518624708,
2.545e-7,
0.0354116224,
0.103166908,
-0.0127415992,
-0.0456042811,
0.0485889725,
0.0147153661,
0.0255797599,
0.0022964051,
0.0231892783,
0.0153274862,
-0.0286005996,
0.0158385318,
0.0606002249,
0.0436023325,
-0.0509083606,
-0.0042650653,
-0.0713555962,
0.0171106681,
-0.0446508005,
0.0113855759,
0.0200699326,
0.0319605097,
0.01528122,
-0.0078405663,
-0.0144652491,
-0.0143930996,
0.0130808866,
-0.0591546483,
0.0084002335,
0.0032456259,
-0.0307771489,
-0.0521662645,
-0.0000119727,
0.0005755172,
-0.0090987217,
0.0254096203,
-0.0201863684,
0.0051181102,
-0.0148195997,
0.0632192492,
0.0093387794,
-0.0472198613,
-0.020049911,
-0.0367493518,
0.0071262186,
0.0121230409,
-0.0162739437,
-0.0041239657,
-0.0160192456,
-0.00866389,
0.0095358808,
-0.0236503351,
-0.0260345824,
-0.0336609967,
0.0226124357,
-0.0094934423,
-0.0034223099,
-0.0285795089,
-0.0324808881,
0.0194905121,
-0.0218310114,
-0.0598668568,
0.0088858977,
0.0616888963,
-0.009756445,
-0.0108465208,
0.0098299338,
2.011513739e-34,
0.0181839317,
0.067817919,
0.0461512916,
-0.0147855487,
0.0430675074,
0.0222910549,
0.0184288584,
0.0131051876,
0.0603202656,
-0.0494269282,
0.004945504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09998v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09998v3 | Generating Mathematical Derivations with Large Language Models | 2023-07-19T14:13:02 | 2023-08-08T12:23:49 | Jordan Meadows, Marco Valentino, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.HO | The derivation of mathematical results in specialised fields, using Large
Language Models (LLMs), is an emerging research direction that can help
identify models' limitations, and potentially support mathematical discovery.
In this paper, we leverage a symbolic engine to generate derivations of
equations at scale, and investigate the capabilities of LLMs when deriving goal
equations from premises. Specifically, we employ in-context learning for GPT
and fine-tune a range of T5 models to compare the robustness and generalisation
of pre-training strategies to specialised models. Empirical results show that
fine-tuned FLAN-T5-large (MathT5) outperforms GPT models on all static and
out-of-distribution test sets in conventional scores. However, an in-depth
analysis reveals that the fine-tuned models are more sensitive to perturbations
involving unseen symbols and (to a lesser extent) changes to equation
structure. In addition, we analyse 1.7K equations, and over 200 derivations, to
highlight common reasoning errors such as the inclusion of incorrect,
irrelevant, and redundant equations. Finally, we explore the suitability of
existing metrics for evaluating mathematical derivations and find evidence
that, while they can capture general properties such as sensitivity to
perturbations, they fail to highlight fine-grained reasoning errors and
essential differences between models. Overall, this work demonstrates that
training models on synthetic data may improve their math capabilities beyond
much larger LLMs, but current metrics are not appropriately assessing the
quality of generated mathematical text. | [
-0.0108278617,
0.0936173275,
-0.0059804432,
0.0721370727,
-0.0174599774,
0.0139437672,
0.034273129,
0.008125673,
-0.0527386107,
-0.0234177858,
-0.0072337002,
-0.0141515033,
-0.0305107348,
0.0269065425,
0.0348626934,
-0.059924446,
0.0080408752,
-0.028729463,
-0.0005203641,
-0.0089548118,
-0.0229451153,
-0.0240871944,
0.0205767564,
-0.0076301717,
-0.0351743661,
-0.0668333247,
0.0390206687,
-0.0518575534,
0.0261705946,
0.0150235333,
-0.0028178757,
0.0272884667,
0.0297872983,
0.0860785693,
0.0000023185,
-0.0612628423,
-0.0158410352,
0.0378096886,
-0.0379731134,
0.0555361249,
0.0259200726,
-0.0122196572,
-0.004924282,
0.0079589328,
-0.0534442589,
-0.012418204,
0.0479322374,
-0.0139723122,
0.058243148,
0.0649546012,
0.0115804803,
-0.0704754964,
0.0136758182,
-0.0194188263,
0.039500013,
-0.0704858452,
0.0330021009,
0.0394462459,
-0.0087500094,
-0.0200955011,
-0.044030793,
0.0161387715,
0.074782677,
0.0082313428,
-0.0154275028,
0.027530916,
-0.0433622301,
0.0439651534,
-0.0045382897,
0.0642985925,
-0.0171640664,
-0.0414216444,
0.0046084654,
-0.0125669967,
-0.0245430954,
0.0386508517,
-0.0582920983,
0.0225636549,
-0.0206625033,
-0.0182212908,
0.0156026268,
-0.0374318361,
0.0432882421,
0.0137812374,
-0.0358250663,
0.0229861997,
0.0322401673,
-0.0360502899,
-0.0160763524,
-0.0085166106,
-0.0824709013,
-0.0147039946,
0.0049587684,
0.0260407198,
0.0221688636,
0.0206818469,
-0.0473035276,
-0.0726280659,
-0.0350145847,
-0.043832887,
0.0537775755,
0.0441762246,
0.0310564488,
0.0122264838,
-0.0337890536,
0.0671902299,
-0.0634240061,
0.0130817406,
-0.0390500836,
0.0394873098,
-0.0702961832,
-0.0320338644,
0.0004906586,
0.0434415713,
-0.0061644842,
0.0119677801,
-0.0548756644,
0.012222616,
-0.0385476798,
-0.0017540838,
-0.000202928,
-0.0452977046,
-0.0385012627,
-0.0449877232,
0.0066075199,
0.0173007976,
-0.0318667367,
0.0045057116,
0.0022619613,
-0.0278042648,
-0.0282668546,
0.0264652316,
-0.0129709449,
-0.0209630094,
0.0244352669,
0.0867519528,
0.0307592489,
0.0251555163,
0.0095876511,
-0.022388909,
0.0242216438,
-0.0976757556,
0.0153321642,
-0.0845458061,
0.0334720463,
0.0139977783,
-0.048917558,
-0.0289700367,
-0.0091015864,
-0.0027938103,
0.0359143615,
0.005546716,
0.0041877846,
0.0052988366,
0.0347371586,
-0.006845016,
-0.0329349786,
0.0284733903,
0.0533849746,
0.005230899,
0.0273819752,
-0.0129706105,
0.0195650086,
0.0537245348,
0.0205735471,
0.0146052269,
-0.016071476,
0.0276123472,
0.0208900813,
0.0343757086,
-0.0039798799,
0.0198795702,
-0.0540352091,
-0.0092547424,
0.0412936248,
0.0453746691,
0.0333206765,
0.020400038,
0.0679884925,
-0.0228963308,
0.069868736,
-0.0109906085,
-0.0598223358,
0.0102755642,
-0.057265494,
0.0220693834,
-0.0067238235,
0.0151816346,
-0.0004455216,
-0.059595678,
0.0138587356,
-0.0026185531,
-0.0583043322,
0.0117928339,
0.0972575247,
-0.041994717,
0.0110307131,
0.0628206357,
0.0066675344,
-0.0322215892,
0.0087964311,
-0.0319256447,
0.0363573506,
-0.0186152682,
0.0601999424,
-0.0507937297,
-0.0084387865,
-0.0198956002,
-0.0112164142,
0.0514870808,
0.021274982,
-0.0118416054,
-0.0307026561,
-0.0198649522,
0.0014083983,
-0.0305427443,
0.0465891287,
0.0133322114,
0.0358684286,
-0.0150392205,
0.0543284714,
-0.0418724194,
-0.0131273214,
0.0356034301,
-0.0550112575,
-0.0490649715,
0.0350250006,
-0.0298383161,
0.0239825752,
0.0126039572,
-0.024698399,
0.0387858674,
0.0016338142,
-0.0094393464,
0.0109880371,
-0.016412748,
-0.0157717969,
-0.0149313184,
0.0607251972,
-0.0393811651,
-0.0238600764,
0.0292339455,
-0.0545790792,
0.0019435084,
0.0788981095,
-0.0357355997,
-0.0064081056,
-0.0214582272,
-0.001037039,
-0.0210268926,
-0.0092570418,
0.0004434986,
0.0804061368,
0.0281304568,
0.0167170465,
0.0060819234,
0.0035861444,
0.0043254681,
0.0275295768,
0.0344421975,
-0.0129961856,
0.0010522029,
0.0314647108,
-0.0042996434,
0.0346673802,
-0.0121633559,
-0.021143863,
-0.0178366099,
0.0251463708,
-0.0330972634,
0.0727953613,
0.0486538447,
-0.0203361213,
-0.0060562394,
0.0373799205,
0.0069061988,
-0.0228638034,
-0.0373526998,
-0.029582018,
0.0155696338,
0.0189717729,
-0.0472474732,
-0.0697564557,
-0.0265654065,
-0.0529718995,
0.0397188738,
0.0287657417,
0.0527474694,
0.0024875212,
0.0538945869,
-0.0273857694,
-0.0148000028,
-0.0240761209,
0.0040960126,
0.0202880297,
-0.0573509559,
0.0367580578,
0.0590079725,
-0.0035718654,
0.0391542912,
-0.0263954978,
-0.0193648767,
-0.0556336939,
-0.0070728809,
-0.0499823056,
-0.0220744275,
-0.013587785,
-0.0019600519,
-0.0028064824,
0.0261802822,
-0.0107169561,
-0.0320653953,
-0.0578776374,
0.0779750794,
-0.0308674611,
0.0093760053,
-0.0330224074,
0.0416536927,
-0.0180515833,
0.0262732264,
0.0242995694,
-0.0566335544,
0.0370703079,
0.0233079307,
0.003139352,
-0.0577075481,
0.0070813699,
-0.0753659531,
0.0242447983,
-0.0079695703,
-0.0253197495,
-0.0001348296,
0.0137095954,
-0.0338067375,
-0.0035802384,
0.0538532697,
-0.0353523493,
0.0597721189,
-0.0759937093,
0.0131672258,
-0.005291726,
-0.0171111971,
0.0012113424,
-0.0369079709,
0.0127220964,
0.0116559472,
-0.0396444313,
-0.0440418832,
0.0018530576,
-0.0349714421,
0.0414369814,
0.0191150233,
-0.0369261429,
-0.0229855012,
-0.017105611,
-0.0146224825,
0.031149853,
-0.0389521085,
0.047655955,
-0.1095430106,
-0.0117973536,
-0.0064989123,
0.0253806114,
0.0080579929,
-0.0228357203,
0.0006042822,
-0.032906495,
-0.0061640185,
-0.015668802,
0.0681192949,
-0.0208452437,
-0.0757904127,
-0.0069052284,
0.0807176381,
0.0106145889,
0.0250762254,
-0.0169927683,
-0.0396187045,
0.0069235256,
-0.0072876392,
0.0088656014,
-0.1005191281,
-0.013689301,
0.0028714461,
-0.0034692537,
0.0068013538,
-0.0363580137,
0.0038978527,
-0.1275043339,
0.0309187714,
0.0498565212,
-0.0450880006,
-0.0103453947,
-0.0453194119,
0.0003731648,
-0.0211089943,
-0.0347750522,
0.0305617005,
-0.0113091078,
0.0247474425,
0.000382528,
-0.0224146023,
-0.0730557069,
0.0314589813,
-0.0223729108,
-0.0350180939,
0.026295213,
0.0234107543,
-0.0540397018,
-0.0413064025,
0.0315478779,
0.0192449689,
-0.0448285341,
0.0061985566,
-0.0079165762,
0.0070241867,
0.0083842315,
-0.0083643096,
0.0585703515,
-0.0505407006,
-0.0060243709,
0.0301693715,
0.0989774689,
0.0360553786,
-0.0281365756,
-0.008411549,
-0.0176890474,
-0.0268958341,
0.0586888492,
0.0134392083,
-0.0327139348,
-0.0552002564,
-0.043992538,
-0.0307535343,
0.012283423,
-0.0365395695,
-0.0255493112,
0.0066625457,
-0.0079896078,
-0.0077010239,
-0.0107031176,
0.0249369591,
0.0344620943,
0.0044198246,
-0.0141285202,
0.0023622089,
-0.0129879368,
-0.0156381074,
0.0463997126,
-0.0279129855,
0.0289948191,
-0.0276254509,
0.0317496173,
0.0082489643,
-0.0115644969,
-0.0255434737,
0.0460782014,
-0.071851939,
-0.0706772953,
-0.015781695,
0.0432015732,
0.0273672901,
0.0024915312,
0.0128432,
-0.0043317149,
0.0134757925,
0.0580451153,
-0.0122957025,
0.0098327724,
0.0442213342,
-0.019394679,
0.0195040293,
-0.0092424918,
-0.0358415991,
0.0163801052,
0.0468065813,
0.0424360745,
-0.0201528762,
0.0193736721,
0.0316353105,
0.0569865406,
0.0012782959,
-0.0076128803,
-0.039426975,
-0.008325086,
-0.0003970645,
-0.0706603378,
-0.0224021934,
-0.0291051399,
0.0072789346,
0.015353838,
0.0094825504,
-0.0180935077,
-0.0050173379,
0.0456379876,
0.0340566896,
0.0009307021,
0.0111902542,
-0.0297035128,
0.0080869757,
0.069168888,
-0.0503945798,
-0.0102728987,
-0.0464943126,
-0.0059154434,
0.0380348973,
-0.0095567368,
0.0455175042,
0.0371871814,
0.0394822843,
-0.0326606445,
-0.0312189665,
-0.0446344502,
-0.0768189579,
-0.0555380285,
0.0229647718,
0.0384828188,
0.0278101936,
0.0098698018,
-0.0793590471,
-0.0211504996,
-0.0347850882,
0.0333376192,
0.0025952309,
-0.0010247432,
0.0379934274,
0.0228724871,
-0.0042979117,
-0.0518117212,
0.0500173271,
-0.0253524724,
0.0480288789,
-0.005261322,
0.0541151427,
-0.0323338583,
-0.0058779074,
0.0089805881,
-0.0228056945,
0.0341591015,
0.005486391,
-0.0885822847,
-0.0770846978,
0.0445050374,
0.0351433195,
-0.0067390446,
0.0158104189,
0.0597434416,
0.0885470062,
-0.0617901273,
-0.0077488422,
-0.0091530336,
0.0299075507,
-0.02635663,
-0.0394792892,
-0.0443984233,
-5.801063887e-33,
-0.0131783448,
0.0031320243,
0.0453735068,
0.055624038,
-0.0191915408,
-0.0039395336,
-0.0413170755,
-0.0104367286,
-0.0257237814,
0.0192118008,
0.0106981946,
0.0168963298,
-0.0106946062,
0.0035157767,
0.0082460046,
-0.0150126349,
-0.0028550276,
-0.0295844004,
-0.0236234982,
-0.0103507945,
0.034470357,
0.0012474653,
0.0678508207,
-0.0747686476,
0.0183338877,
-0.0138458656,
-0.0022029099,
-0.0134716025,
-0.0246046912,
0.0678701699,
-0.0295933522,
0.0279604308,
-0.0161425676,
-0.0144417724,
-0.0093733752,
-0.0198860876,
-0.0001989246,
-0.0124785267,
0.0245646778,
-0.0153211337,
-0.021504933,
-0.0400287434,
0.0512244329,
0.017581163,
-0.0705451965,
-0.0453425236,
0.0435038321,
-0.0169701483,
0.0074784011,
-0.0505763106,
-0.0820821524,
0.0315220468,
-0.0170772523,
0.0286565255,
-0.0022499415,
0.0134489164,
-0.0218466856,
0.0120955482,
-0.020092478,
0.0059307958,
0.0459259152,
0.0150919538,
0.0352116972,
0.0044804895,
0.0563254729,
0.0337972641,
0.0308461115,
-0.0317289196,
0.002865073,
-0.0229099486,
0.0604863465,
0.0433117636,
0.0684949681,
0.0639926791,
0.0629377887,
0.0337839387,
-0.072066471,
-0.0105014974,
-0.0325627252,
0.0444305688,
0.0384126604,
0.0076219924,
-0.0471602306,
0.0073436745,
-0.0402254313,
0.032489527,
-0.0210048016,
-0.0182934087,
0.0213390402,
-0.0074962471,
-0.0006613593,
-0.0034750872,
0.0300297011,
-0.0506551154,
-0.0099154571,
0.0111172665,
-0.0177205969,
0.0378902592,
0.0125136171,
0.0151448706,
-0.0377063118,
-0.0163907893,
-0.023788048,
0.0009021947,
0.060086038,
0.012972231,
0.004647586,
0.0236113295,
-0.0105279749,
-0.0097566918,
-0.0443761237,
-0.0243904833,
0.0415082574,
0.0114207221,
0.0175867714,
0.03084879,
0.0113703776,
0.0238328259,
-0.0020163804,
-0.009574933,
-0.0003629247,
0.0624202415,
0.0146980183,
0.0360470228,
-0.0199700408,
0.0050805807,
0.0084239971,
-0.0002229784,
0.0798449814,
-0.0688513368,
-0.0193593875,
0.0208643712,
2.916e-7,
0.0655721873,
0.0489456132,
0.0168594848,
0.0280763078,
0.0140610281,
0.0516794175,
-0.0211387835,
-0.0143073192,
0.0551520735,
-0.01308023,
0.0112993428,
0.0266772602,
0.0552243032,
0.0054612122,
-0.0375493616,
0.0381238684,
-0.0480086207,
-0.0412004553,
-0.0322188362,
0.0119330976,
0.0405247211,
0.0644150898,
0.0434296466,
0.0205674507,
-0.0166118611,
-0.0295650307,
0.0850402415,
-0.0358666778,
-0.0202124398,
0.05399701,
-0.0521812774,
-0.0274860803,
0.0258383509,
-0.0115961991,
-0.0121882996,
0.0464323834,
0.014617186,
0.0812874585,
0.0209749136,
0.0791241676,
-0.0130730988,
-0.0570979826,
0.0125719607,
-0.0470457375,
0.0118327076,
-0.0760121644,
-0.0376142822,
-0.0212568436,
-0.0587847531,
-0.0224205758,
0.034655761,
-0.0340661593,
0.0383589827,
0.002140882,
-0.0002229092,
0.0256713964,
-0.0011993881,
-0.0202438273,
-0.0326558091,
0.0862244964,
-0.0802320763,
-0.0275454242,
-0.0128953345,
0.0189830586,
0.0213784296,
-0.0382221155,
0.0112854037,
3.140825396e-34,
0.0390032753,
-0.0212861877,
0.0325183086,
0.0461462364,
0.0355237983,
-0.0027321607,
-0.0480499119,
0.0334344283,
0.0248422716,
-0.0438952856,
-0.0192399751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09959v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09959v1 | GUIDO: A Hybrid Approach to Guideline Discovery & Ordering from Natural Language Texts | 2023-07-19T13:01:03 | 2023-07-19T13:01:03 | Nils Freyer, Dustin Thewes, Matthias Meinecke | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extracting workflow nets from textual descriptions can be used to simplify
guidelines or formalize textual descriptions of formal processes like business
processes and algorithms. The task of manually extracting processes, however,
requires domain expertise and effort. While automatic process model extraction
is desirable, annotating texts with formalized process models is expensive.
Therefore, there are only a few machine-learning-based extraction approaches.
Rule-based approaches, in turn, require domain specificity to work well and can
rarely distinguish relevant and irrelevant information in textual descriptions.
In this paper, we present GUIDO, a hybrid approach to the process model
extraction task that first, classifies sentences regarding their relevance to
the process model, using a BERT-based sentence classifier, and second, extracts
a process model from the sentences classified as relevant, using dependency
parsing. The presented approach achieves significantly better results than a
pure rule-based approach. GUIDO achieves an average behavioral similarity score
of $0.93$. Still, in comparison to purely machine-learning-based approaches,
the annotation costs stay low. | [
0.0343911946,
-0.00031129,
-0.0298070535,
0.0039072013,
-0.0529910848,
-0.0014351938,
-0.0228915997,
0.0108383354,
-0.0317394361,
-0.0642356277,
0.0035276911,
0.0485845581,
-0.0052031758,
0.0391292721,
-0.0404913351,
-0.0677287951,
0.0163158104,
0.0083170747,
0.0529615358,
0.0675587878,
0.0126008848,
0.029452119,
-0.0016161619,
0.0705125257,
0.0221517254,
-0.0120074069,
-0.0018853266,
0.0079686316,
0.027124824,
-0.0448660888,
0.0068011708,
0.0425678678,
-0.0021767728,
-0.025088666,
0.0000017626,
-0.0629515722,
-0.021374071,
0.0299138837,
0.0163525287,
0.0029433398,
0.0065078661,
0.0143698612,
0.0079714563,
0.0302223042,
0.0090266941,
-0.0130354455,
0.0408378206,
0.0740266964,
0.0878127813,
0.0518028103,
-0.0416112766,
-0.0326667354,
0.0132612977,
0.0339640342,
-0.0429586843,
-0.0405815765,
0.0399443544,
0.0173941087,
0.0139244581,
0.0115493005,
0.0807464644,
-0.0262723304,
-0.0168120153,
-0.0151097467,
-0.0390520096,
0.0016136135,
0.0369788595,
-0.0006024527,
0.009270574,
0.0394876711,
0.0187913887,
-0.0112171546,
0.0395552255,
-0.0035479369,
-0.0004107161,
-0.0240104739,
-0.045990698,
0.0280563086,
-0.0534945577,
-0.0258224029,
0.0109687177,
0.0092595331,
-0.0190126747,
-0.048400037,
0.0160073861,
0.0511162467,
-0.0143179232,
-0.0355552882,
-0.0067093917,
0.0063357796,
0.0233584419,
-0.0372327939,
0.0693625882,
0.0193314273,
0.0158662107,
0.0021855598,
-0.0057220575,
0.0184988473,
0.0197905824,
-0.0496451296,
0.0320605524,
0.0002388452,
-0.0013686146,
0.0014323839,
0.0142832715,
-0.0071999775,
0.0227682739,
-0.0117505211,
-0.0468925908,
0.0423666909,
-0.1133962274,
0.0029700687,
-0.0512829162,
0.0328909345,
-0.0131771974,
0.0024325619,
-0.0128307994,
0.028078232,
-0.0275613908,
0.0354286619,
0.075931102,
-0.0228224415,
-0.0161898974,
0.0123313544,
-0.0253627207,
-0.0197723098,
-0.021236524,
0.0189953893,
-0.0410266668,
0.0265398994,
0.0070645772,
-0.0027572596,
0.0194882229,
-0.0122251203,
-0.0268818475,
0.0311873257,
0.039454557,
0.0125464639,
-0.063670218,
-0.0383107364,
0.051900208,
0.0067663402,
-0.0065521072,
-0.0301059578,
0.0008670829,
0.0018466355,
-0.0269360263,
0.0440741517,
-0.0053518815,
0.0306477547,
-0.0233342275,
0.019698659,
-0.0037559653,
0.0092136925,
0.0106592672,
-0.0094308788,
0.007812175,
-0.0157897472,
0.0143145956,
-0.0065140044,
0.0224741083,
-0.0117082074,
0.0138445776,
0.0419472083,
-0.0509479828,
-0.042426765,
0.0255528446,
0.0155006247,
-0.0158499461,
-0.0482023992,
0.0274982583,
-0.0021441481,
-0.0206141528,
0.0509028472,
0.0092192767,
0.0397741571,
-0.0189486314,
0.0098103154,
0.0846245065,
0.0755447596,
0.0443102233,
0.0184236951,
-0.0067253895,
-0.0238063503,
-0.0119281113,
0.0175304096,
-0.1106692106,
-0.010378601,
-0.0158727579,
-0.0607135631,
-0.030695105,
-0.0079473769,
-0.0162014198,
-0.0375806764,
0.0346552841,
0.0339579619,
-0.0603624508,
0.0511514805,
0.0081532644,
0.0013580392,
-0.0425758325,
-0.0210472904,
-0.0332069285,
0.0938366801,
0.0493060164,
-0.0915147588,
0.0111252591,
-0.017034607,
0.01874955,
-0.007036787,
0.0117245782,
-0.036605753,
-0.0173406024,
-0.0256391149,
-0.0430559032,
0.0053811977,
0.0269489493,
-0.0362026282,
-0.0071318811,
-0.052405756,
-0.0063742581,
0.0127085634,
-0.0834818333,
0.0779714212,
0.0131337307,
-0.0505481847,
0.0220263675,
0.0057765818,
0.0303301085,
0.0223604385,
-0.0216002166,
0.0387309752,
0.0327303261,
-0.0309551228,
-0.0024321943,
0.0522991829,
0.0051237433,
0.0289827734,
-0.0033000999,
0.0254575107,
-0.0162040126,
-0.0307018757,
-0.0612953119,
-0.0069366978,
-0.0321894363,
-0.0353736058,
0.0267505459,
0.03368425,
0.0258984212,
0.0226090532,
-0.0723090023,
-0.0701998621,
0.0591415353,
0.0198103227,
-0.0057912841,
-0.0095367981,
-0.0614438169,
0.0189736076,
0.0158308744,
0.0369172618,
0.0059077684,
-0.0349974558,
0.0094498666,
0.0476393998,
0.0394268706,
0.0075371922,
-0.0033010626,
-0.0424366072,
-0.0094069131,
-0.0010303218,
0.0541337579,
0.0434547625,
-0.0318059698,
-0.0143542597,
-0.0318189561,
0.0144328233,
-0.0044258675,
-0.0302536245,
-0.0261813346,
0.0595306493,
0.0148699842,
-0.0670156926,
-0.017602127,
0.0035170307,
-0.0515064374,
0.0230769627,
0.0088037821,
-0.009312504,
-0.1000094637,
0.0396337956,
0.0369913206,
0.0159620717,
0.0280660447,
0.0105040492,
0.0114158383,
0.0151472678,
-0.0007063211,
0.027145274,
-0.0204768311,
0.0141862715,
0.0275935195,
-0.0109381443,
-0.0035221053,
-0.0138183562,
-0.0175206438,
0.0312066823,
-0.0202950407,
-0.0721826032,
0.0549353845,
0.0300918538,
0.015699733,
0.0167139061,
-0.0020376968,
-0.0299127549,
-0.0091946265,
0.0166419819,
-0.0045579947,
-0.0640887916,
-0.0097513944,
0.0199613832,
-0.0208575092,
-0.0101020671,
0.0585241653,
-0.0101359822,
0.0124513581,
-0.1043590531,
-0.0185256545,
-0.008763534,
0.0731785074,
0.0149551379,
0.0243732762,
0.0270141382,
-0.0219206531,
0.0000496438,
-0.0013454794,
0.072133176,
0.0214739963,
0.0187753681,
-0.0873147324,
0.0111815892,
-0.0132410126,
-0.0192153268,
-0.044699356,
0.0243939068,
0.004849141,
0.0536504909,
-0.0059670457,
-0.0044094576,
-0.0170458332,
0.0248229206,
0.0017811162,
0.0592860058,
0.0347955339,
-0.0387778655,
-0.0235486031,
0.0222898833,
0.0103010684,
-0.0760026574,
-0.0175958332,
0.0309110265,
0.0246958565,
0.0225862376,
0.0045713424,
-0.0271503758,
-0.0389119461,
-0.0485897511,
-0.0168873649,
-0.117257759,
0.0052996441,
0.0600378662,
0.001734113,
-0.0582784079,
-0.0309516806,
0.0897237584,
0.0583243668,
-0.0035229074,
0.0301241707,
-0.0034871362,
-0.0195830185,
0.0303847045,
0.0390281007,
-0.0066429432,
0.0210617613,
0.0159841701,
0.0103357518,
-0.0139601426,
-0.0024870876,
0.0030171783,
-0.0437737666,
0.0357998647,
-0.0304616373,
0.0053179138,
-0.016220687,
-0.0745461732,
-0.0241731629,
-0.0335239172,
-0.0611968562,
0.0112204887,
-0.0241428595,
-0.0312275756,
0.0129430974,
-0.0689629391,
-0.0472613387,
0.0202796757,
-0.0001693423,
-0.0438015051,
0.0495989211,
0.0072032833,
-0.0144781945,
0.0007111123,
0.0890065283,
-0.0318818726,
-0.0091825174,
-0.0193709247,
0.033592809,
0.030695593,
0.0283997618,
-0.0306512136,
0.0115553001,
-0.0828686133,
-0.0482905321,
0.0629928857,
0.0621459596,
-0.034952011,
-0.0196610689,
-0.0094737001,
0.0002999339,
0.0008879171,
0.058107581,
-0.0049541825,
-0.0031992535,
-0.0228825994,
-0.0471975021,
0.0211035013,
0.0164470077,
-0.0240361709,
-0.0228918102,
-0.0405815057,
-0.0283218995,
-0.083757773,
-0.0356688648,
0.0025392163,
0.0483344421,
0.030985605,
0.0004469776,
0.0809701532,
0.0144615397,
-0.0493090339,
0.0125620635,
0.0167367272,
0.025413435,
-0.0022936782,
-0.0170217063,
0.0038156414,
0.0591464452,
-0.0526639111,
0.0345905088,
-0.0382959917,
0.0031137767,
-0.0403239615,
0.0724937096,
0.0170163587,
0.0102663664,
-0.0158499833,
0.0271341335,
-0.0630190521,
-0.0292376485,
-0.0026362531,
-0.0801206678,
0.0350529812,
-0.0033218742,
-0.0021740331,
-0.0309053529,
-0.0120408488,
0.0438614227,
-0.0560845733,
0.0428455807,
-0.0609577484,
-0.0567074753,
0.0467787199,
0.0219609123,
-0.0056452514,
0.0228401925,
-0.0410226062,
-0.0726040304,
0.0080427425,
-0.0348635316,
-0.0306597929,
-0.0196581893,
0.0560496636,
-0.0170607343,
-0.0201010872,
0.0225180518,
0.0112861749,
-0.04417051,
-0.0107153319,
0.0055169608,
-0.0000149561,
0.0365630239,
0.0609741025,
-0.0461686328,
-0.0598237216,
-0.0173623729,
-0.0312231071,
0.0202810857,
0.0277678091,
-0.0213306174,
0.0356921367,
0.0013496738,
0.0033039853,
-0.0231330302,
0.0158712547,
-0.0171047449,
0.0367380828,
-0.0206317604,
-0.0039942339,
0.0517596528,
-0.0421248749,
0.0638677627,
-0.0493557081,
0.0022599781,
-0.0123089226,
0.0370197073,
0.0213821176,
0.0307948627,
-0.0190619249,
0.0391062014,
-0.0294074751,
-0.0835966095,
0.0346947759,
0.0063918508,
0.0431083106,
-0.0304580741,
-0.0909894705,
-0.0548027009,
-0.0878432915,
0.0111932345,
0.0418538712,
-0.0363231227,
-0.0214859433,
-0.0414297432,
-0.003140528,
-0.0305183101,
-0.0123212375,
0.0396667942,
-0.0498622283,
0.0345965587,
0.0621357001,
0.0148313968,
-0.0561296977,
-0.0279870741,
-0.0335025489,
0.0299876519,
-0.019649297,
-0.0755843967,
-4.764821903e-33,
-0.0167215336,
-0.0450168848,
0.0325966217,
0.0418953598,
0.015825158,
-0.011585813,
-0.0275943074,
-0.0270762816,
0.0267282519,
0.057187397,
0.0203636866,
-0.019217873,
0.0187461451,
-0.0637829006,
0.0226584245,
0.050057333,
0.0697002336,
-0.0293758139,
-0.0178855266,
-0.0088132434,
0.0458920375,
0.0062257014,
0.0551173761,
-0.0676775202,
0.0322594345,
0.0236106738,
-0.0139877452,
0.0465488285,
0.0296909232,
0.0384904146,
0.0018443125,
0.0036113705,
0.0373525321,
0.0124023175,
0.0082640769,
-0.0115800453,
-0.0474500768,
-0.0132253747,
0.0158807244,
-0.0182199255,
0.0070874197,
0.0111425733,
0.0441951677,
-0.0250375848,
-0.0201855134,
0.0612965301,
0.0579820424,
-0.0350007229,
0.0042910529,
0.000926939,
-0.1192574352,
0.0231382642,
-0.0050613494,
-0.0045146835,
0.0259294137,
0.0612274632,
0.0056692041,
-0.0549972467,
-0.0398881845,
-0.0146478526,
-0.0428230204,
0.0354248621,
0.0491584614,
-0.006669512,
0.0045749568,
-0.0076763378,
-0.0415630974,
0.042783998,
0.0265546497,
0.0361613669,
-0.0039330572,
0.0843112171,
-0.0112230591,
-0.0777743682,
-0.0406213254,
0.011716377,
-0.0403232425,
0.0739960074,
-0.0028074409,
0.0748368427,
0.0120371329,
-0.0263977684,
-0.0416448228,
0.0093159899,
0.0043165307,
-0.0253978875,
0.0248792041,
0.0393315554,
0.0193507839,
0.016785495,
-0.0025052803,
0.0061617238,
0.0058337767,
0.0226868037,
-0.0245513264,
-0.0093423557,
-0.0127221085,
0.0092597054,
-0.0151534686,
-0.0116723292,
-0.0428496338,
-0.0694945231,
-0.0052222982,
0.010391498,
0.0398027599,
0.0123229334,
0.0330005363,
-0.0412115715,
-0.0361696817,
0.0218773037,
-0.0417237505,
0.0192680825,
-0.0452622548,
0.0779893473,
0.0043120086,
0.0160948895,
0.0193175059,
0.0316905938,
0.0033694368,
-0.0236666519,
-0.0027769115,
0.0806010067,
0.0212360229,
0.0141323758,
0.0181584917,
-0.0153158549,
0.0043631736,
0.0673077404,
0.0334225222,
0.024911182,
-0.0124236979,
0.0180294421,
2.344e-7,
0.0592457913,
0.0279194135,
0.0247107893,
0.0816196352,
0.0377280973,
0.0215500817,
-0.0035268646,
-0.0176940039,
-0.007959839,
-0.0305642709,
0.0438033491,
-0.0447142385,
0.0229681302,
0.0126645025,
-0.0658126175,
-0.103732504,
-0.0283876564,
-0.042465508,
-0.0629926845,
-0.0011003065,
0.0471586734,
0.0234035719,
0.0200977847,
0.0323646665,
-0.0271957964,
-0.0322878584,
-0.0025368996,
0.018705016,
0.0277447663,
0.069447279,
0.0443929061,
-0.0476806574,
0.0137068378,
0.0191963539,
-0.0228089485,
0.0148811387,
-0.0024004381,
0.0986879542,
-0.0362892747,
0.0398242734,
0.0011135855,
-0.0508803502,
0.0295120757,
-0.0276029482,
-0.0159247369,
-0.0482080691,
-0.0394773111,
-0.0188209601,
-0.0305230059,
-0.0082291598,
-0.0178554058,
0.0285066944,
-0.0088382298,
0.0399301313,
-0.0290778968,
-0.0191198923,
-0.0113494005,
-0.0088214995,
0.0005997781,
0.0178067293,
-0.0005367597,
-0.0218779333,
0.0012322039,
-0.0005724909,
-0.011912711,
-0.0049159066,
0.0412118323,
2.56341201e-34,
0.0230183974,
-0.009052475,
0.0139878811,
0.046917107,
0.0167799257,
0.0339153409,
-0.0061280346,
0.0501969196,
-0.0279974286,
-0.0398136452,
0.016563151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09923v1 | Large Language Models can accomplish Business Process Management Tasks | 2023-07-19T11:54:46 | 2023-07-19T11:54:46 | Michael Grohs, Luka Abb, Nourhan Elsayed, Jana-Rebecca Rehse | cs.CL | cs.CL | Business Process Management (BPM) aims to improve organizational activities
and their outcomes by managing the underlying processes. To achieve this, it is
often necessary to consider information from various sources, including
unstructured textual documents. Therefore, researchers have developed several
BPM-specific solutions that extract information from textual documents using
Natural Language Processing techniques. These solutions are specific to their
respective tasks and cannot accomplish multiple process-related problems as a
general-purpose instrument. However, in light of the recent emergence of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with remarkable reasoning capabilities, such a
general-purpose instrument with multiple applications now appears attainable.
In this paper, we illustrate how LLMs can accomplish text-related BPM tasks by
applying a specific LLM to three exemplary tasks: mining imperative process
models from textual descriptions, mining declarative process models from
textual descriptions, and assessing the suitability of process tasks from
textual descriptions for robotic process automation. We show that, without
extensive configuration or prompt engineering, LLMs perform comparably to or
better than existing solutions and discuss implications for future BPM research
as well as practical usage. | [
0.0462022349,
0.0146525353,
-0.0226533785,
0.0214714427,
-0.0642267093,
-0.0001909733,
-0.0048204334,
0.0061740088,
0.0060957419,
-0.0471615344,
-0.0182305612,
0.0219178312,
-0.0117021846,
0.0580759421,
-0.0466460697,
-0.047911983,
0.0033740692,
-0.0361600369,
0.0849813595,
0.0539309345,
-0.0163670909,
0.0504752025,
-0.0034376087,
0.0319655277,
0.0269732121,
0.0029655653,
0.0029757274,
-0.0298396461,
0.0098818224,
-0.0352138132,
-0.0259730369,
0.0069254306,
0.0244195126,
-0.0405646935,
0.0000020968,
-0.0773769841,
-0.0155407488,
0.0306228008,
-0.0128111113,
-0.0086385794,
0.0492003001,
0.0140181417,
0.0003781895,
0.0461462922,
-0.0036644612,
-0.0179125406,
0.0044452832,
0.0749891102,
0.0531326458,
0.0420194007,
-0.0353621207,
-0.0168137867,
-0.0270972718,
0.0010393001,
-0.0321184248,
-0.0581942238,
0.0484833196,
-0.0073264698,
0.051487986,
0.0498289093,
0.052736003,
-0.009882303,
-0.0211345665,
-0.0093513895,
-0.0532034747,
0.0197703931,
0.0414960049,
0.0027403249,
0.0014541923,
-0.0032190883,
-0.0005123668,
0.0275230352,
0.0448150709,
0.0019329889,
-0.00169782,
-0.0481855609,
-0.0572010465,
0.0724460036,
-0.0442727022,
-0.0012593096,
-0.0149820587,
0.0108835828,
0.003700495,
-0.0125280851,
-0.0225577056,
0.0643559918,
0.0037280559,
-0.0257536843,
-0.001660842,
0.0033193713,
-0.0115697738,
-0.0422593839,
0.0275834538,
0.0459354743,
-0.0230687503,
0.038154792,
-0.003040178,
0.0511944257,
0.0123411994,
-0.0302809477,
0.0243156161,
-0.0117226401,
0.0286451094,
0.0456890315,
-0.0066770352,
0.0180457514,
0.007211044,
-0.0171102267,
-0.0350888595,
-0.0100112073,
-0.1049202383,
-0.0016631495,
-0.0490809679,
0.0128909675,
-0.0190043934,
-0.0299370941,
0.0038644006,
0.0539967231,
-0.0245830044,
0.047977861,
0.0561638623,
-0.0342032053,
-0.0050915312,
-0.0399679653,
-0.0634425655,
-0.0109772403,
0.0146698905,
0.0442186445,
-0.0421645269,
0.0185558517,
0.0329751,
0.0099504115,
0.0251154378,
-0.0178222116,
0.0024434668,
0.0719685555,
0.0323579684,
-0.0030610086,
-0.087633647,
-0.0323833078,
0.0286886133,
-0.0430869944,
-0.0275439024,
-0.0226622019,
0.0061168266,
0.0006297079,
-0.0385102779,
0.039541509,
0.0126184514,
0.0238715429,
-0.0184430927,
0.0458372161,
0.0144393314,
0.0359100401,
0.0232098959,
-0.019717982,
0.0128452815,
0.0198130216,
0.025239354,
0.0028519367,
0.0474201739,
-0.0122243147,
0.0133948904,
0.0494923517,
-0.083960861,
-0.0376439728,
0.0560721643,
0.0169938002,
-0.0099770073,
-0.0421172418,
0.0101934122,
0.0094845556,
0.0227854028,
0.060061913,
0.0474604666,
0.0418831967,
-0.0354591832,
0.0022811259,
0.0338569842,
0.0603391565,
-0.0056730341,
-0.0203101449,
0.0055867112,
-0.0275257621,
-0.0466937684,
0.0083658071,
-0.0597693138,
0.002198603,
-0.0195385646,
-0.0707028583,
-0.0299691427,
0.0080379322,
0.0242178421,
-0.0120237861,
0.0836804435,
0.0081641842,
-0.0672979206,
0.0397914052,
-0.0201833844,
-0.0073903892,
-0.0062874085,
-0.0171098933,
-0.0021679921,
0.0646543503,
0.0634018704,
-0.097567372,
0.0248509701,
-0.0257704705,
0.0119419703,
0.0187215079,
0.0170437116,
-0.0110552134,
-0.0399772711,
-0.0046035149,
-0.0421816446,
0.017565906,
0.0062662777,
-0.0360995419,
-0.0065152873,
-0.0158728026,
-0.0078493897,
-0.0152153326,
-0.0610852018,
0.0664084554,
-0.0169018935,
-0.0346642211,
0.0270737689,
0.0091708172,
0.0376254544,
0.0064884494,
-0.0103991348,
0.0374254286,
0.0494397655,
-0.0529141165,
-0.0406272523,
0.0221321061,
0.0253465362,
0.0386121236,
0.0175188314,
0.0457235053,
0.0053229937,
-0.0297148973,
-0.0447935238,
-0.0343689583,
0.0066851419,
-0.0125534842,
-0.0074332599,
0.0379090607,
0.0507185198,
-0.0061765108,
-0.0614434741,
-0.0712776929,
0.0561900288,
0.035883002,
-0.0079334285,
0.0039605559,
-0.040908169,
0.0114960205,
0.0144245718,
-0.0111020189,
0.0668755919,
-0.0170379505,
0.0107492181,
0.0605130084,
0.0105743287,
0.0126884626,
-0.0260251425,
-0.0675851181,
0.0217619706,
0.0072790748,
0.0219554268,
0.0297855008,
-0.0130689582,
-0.018492274,
-0.011093555,
-0.0043419139,
0.0006974956,
0.0231104046,
-0.009054644,
0.0443897806,
0.0107234214,
-0.0467249975,
-0.0133163659,
0.0093319956,
-0.0148368292,
0.0105065135,
0.0324913971,
0.0002427947,
-0.101312466,
0.0668838769,
0.005539488,
0.0237886719,
0.0104252174,
0.0169522315,
0.0200944934,
-0.0504085943,
0.0147723341,
0.0481434166,
-0.0282017719,
-0.0039512212,
0.0425083861,
-0.0233687926,
0.003954445,
-0.0099621611,
-0.0611003116,
-0.0181234293,
-0.009321807,
-0.0520891808,
0.0665873587,
0.02773441,
0.0185328275,
-0.0006707302,
-0.0020640099,
-0.0197133441,
-0.0286644679,
0.062454842,
-0.0237261374,
-0.0662191957,
0.016991036,
0.0605277941,
-0.0138515029,
-0.0013247487,
0.0240932759,
-0.0069526625,
0.025920637,
-0.0751441121,
-0.0457959399,
-0.0372022688,
0.0954346657,
-0.0188406389,
0.0215669554,
0.0146928038,
-0.0122851059,
-0.0093412921,
0.0086678695,
0.0336033553,
0.0069017471,
0.0154323066,
-0.0930287987,
0.0386313908,
0.0001077704,
-0.0296741202,
-0.0320857503,
0.0022783314,
-0.0147324195,
0.0573543906,
0.0017193554,
0.0002575928,
-0.0306549612,
0.0293512587,
0.0018774287,
0.0437302887,
0.0318177119,
-0.0246805698,
-0.0461274534,
-0.0394583046,
0.0090124849,
-0.0628984272,
-0.0099666892,
0.0251388811,
0.0371907279,
0.0118586626,
0.0035878597,
-0.039323207,
-0.0268149134,
-0.0451025553,
-0.0112937512,
-0.0736929625,
0.0271540713,
0.0351276584,
0.0177925155,
-0.0654741898,
-0.0338064656,
0.0885967836,
0.0256590918,
-0.004267924,
0.004044008,
-0.0017747312,
-0.0578161664,
0.0327819325,
0.0263984278,
0.0076793726,
-0.0014364579,
0.00955413,
-0.007198893,
0.014351014,
-0.0405248925,
0.0020863297,
-0.0840351954,
0.0559944361,
-0.0259669255,
0.0080662156,
-0.0504953898,
-0.0713634342,
0.0055651311,
-0.052977629,
-0.048695419,
0.015371548,
-0.0230087359,
-0.0519150868,
0.0087786531,
-0.0593489632,
-0.0477190651,
0.0555277206,
-0.0144576775,
-0.0809873864,
0.033307299,
0.019339269,
-0.0110919019,
0.018310193,
0.0539790839,
-0.0215024408,
-0.0160698146,
0.0069223843,
-0.011739498,
0.0440726206,
-0.0061180629,
-0.0006949649,
0.0302047431,
-0.0834674984,
-0.0120845167,
0.0579106621,
0.0855757222,
-0.0235067867,
-0.0354524255,
0.0020710712,
-0.0171456598,
0.0113199623,
0.0782166123,
-0.0417147279,
-0.0297757555,
-0.0203969497,
-0.0211784095,
-0.0150675792,
0.0510701537,
-0.0127710458,
-0.0047662565,
-0.04538358,
-0.0162962805,
-0.0527070574,
-0.0119817248,
0.0496303067,
0.0123282699,
0.0175408926,
0.0038172209,
0.1065071598,
0.0018407318,
-0.0379222184,
-0.0115267904,
-0.0267751683,
0.0515092537,
-0.0218490176,
0.0188524295,
0.0012865816,
0.0467140004,
-0.025347501,
0.0198309794,
-0.0771876946,
-0.0173590388,
-0.0511819459,
0.0340851881,
0.0138479425,
-0.0107666878,
-0.0339214094,
0.0030097913,
-0.0129091274,
-0.0695508868,
-0.0229354035,
-0.0452544801,
-0.000093357,
0.0530405343,
0.0021288644,
0.0075217541,
-0.0443799384,
0.042306181,
-0.0437130481,
0.0205417108,
-0.0444600098,
-0.0686283112,
0.0175501388,
0.0326038413,
-0.0094213178,
0.0204635896,
-0.04338466,
-0.0686070248,
-0.0215824675,
-0.0392293371,
-0.0465968922,
-0.0349186882,
0.0431041643,
-0.018579293,
-0.0305062626,
0.0196624082,
0.0101415925,
-0.0452790149,
0.0096204979,
0.0256424956,
0.0049994919,
0.0242920741,
0.0323518738,
-0.0064740428,
-0.02626637,
-0.0083458349,
-0.0234552622,
-0.0121250711,
0.0183628518,
-0.0041117454,
0.0505270846,
0.0076943277,
0.0208610073,
-0.0276511908,
0.0062712268,
-0.0250255708,
-0.0200171657,
0.0315192081,
-0.0013719985,
0.0462418795,
-0.0296944454,
0.0264185835,
-0.077457346,
0.0101662613,
-0.0263056625,
0.0323726274,
0.0433195233,
0.0026909437,
-0.0011592101,
0.0292991083,
-0.0531436019,
-0.0403046571,
0.0486129113,
-0.0288929604,
0.0233325362,
-0.0193568021,
-0.0910944566,
-0.0701205134,
-0.0567148775,
0.0153473578,
0.0257494505,
-0.0018110367,
0.003314001,
-0.0430424847,
-0.0060402583,
-0.0127845686,
-0.0165865179,
0.0015597501,
-0.056395065,
-0.0054338635,
0.0761303082,
0.0147456098,
0.0063019386,
-0.0475000404,
-0.0264584329,
0.0207181815,
0.0071228612,
-0.0682934374,
-5.479716792e-33,
-0.0141727012,
-0.0547122322,
0.0412468761,
0.0051968675,
0.0305259079,
-0.0122130327,
-0.0451824516,
-0.0147956936,
0.0247027203,
0.0405672677,
-0.0026898584,
-0.0251232535,
0.0083383098,
-0.0219954345,
0.041332189,
0.0392921679,
0.0745130703,
-0.0233943611,
-0.0309324171,
-0.0051860507,
0.0978362635,
-0.0339100994,
0.024597967,
-0.0497647114,
0.0420294292,
0.0134695005,
-0.0273857266,
0.0678443685,
0.0341550559,
0.0326459929,
-0.0265100915,
0.0409847684,
0.0332731977,
-0.0053755501,
-0.016290566,
0.014203175,
-0.0236292537,
-0.0032952547,
-0.0026451771,
-0.005653243,
0.0037657153,
0.0150760924,
0.032709267,
-0.0198627114,
-0.0080450037,
0.0471395254,
0.036397174,
-0.0371973254,
0.0147304498,
0.0173830856,
-0.0935731009,
0.0155997565,
-0.0103726257,
-0.0070463023,
0.0436101034,
0.0123256631,
-0.0064140516,
-0.0174472462,
-0.0252844784,
-0.0010578517,
-0.0131046502,
-0.0039491081,
0.0500278026,
-0.0018737982,
0.0291219465,
0.0136714093,
-0.0673524886,
0.05825774,
0.031191811,
0.0414628834,
-0.0171940215,
0.1211958826,
0.0294099096,
-0.0536849387,
-0.0537982583,
0.0377196856,
-0.0388634801,
0.0383889116,
-0.0203254279,
0.08639732,
0.0610303581,
-0.0077637481,
-0.0083725611,
-0.0224419311,
-0.0083525283,
-0.0091360854,
-0.0038586031,
0.0552469008,
0.0223472491,
0.0221670698,
-0.0004194905,
-0.0022021073,
0.028564658,
0.0088714976,
-0.0398206674,
0.0328794457,
-0.0216315184,
0.0108372504,
-0.0140739046,
0.0017535163,
-0.0518963002,
-0.0403187759,
-0.0001139401,
0.0003844659,
0.0090730209,
0.0117378682,
-0.0281109307,
-0.023188239,
-0.0414074399,
0.0219549332,
-0.0549335554,
0.0542710535,
-0.0064339638,
0.0556601025,
0.0147559578,
0.0114996703,
0.0193200242,
0.0303377733,
-0.0048550549,
-0.0413157195,
0.016510291,
0.0633654222,
-0.0038826733,
-0.0129742604,
0.0205483958,
-0.0196652822,
-0.0056576878,
0.0106686857,
0.049584873,
0.0185775142,
-0.0026545941,
0.004035709,
2.657e-7,
0.0252907127,
0.0210983977,
-0.00933435,
0.0792455375,
0.0393326432,
0.0551926643,
-0.0176814329,
-0.0327080414,
-0.0198271777,
-0.030899737,
0.0268360768,
-0.0053188591,
0.037943434,
0.0345146209,
-0.0410849676,
-0.0788000301,
-0.0195375606,
-0.0230229106,
-0.0924892351,
0.0025790527,
0.0885039493,
0.0335669406,
0.0127452398,
0.011874306,
-0.0367250293,
-0.0675159171,
-0.003844738,
-0.0205459073,
0.0160095114,
0.0549904965,
0.0379643813,
-0.0181386992,
0.0144677656,
0.0056623574,
-0.0150991073,
0.0278500561,
0.0037755917,
0.0979686007,
-0.0052003656,
0.0414852165,
-0.0061331689,
-0.0324541628,
0.0145345498,
0.0006483598,
0.0310770199,
-0.0660653934,
-0.0364497826,
-0.0410339274,
-0.0021076794,
-0.0256679412,
-0.0375837795,
0.0299297888,
-0.0207722448,
0.0435735136,
-0.0338406041,
-0.0198658183,
-0.0112685636,
-0.0556506738,
0.036232464,
-0.0085669281,
-0.0361327566,
0.0009680705,
-0.0033738068,
0.0305092167,
0.008215188,
-0.0205344278,
0.0596542023,
2.574523876e-34,
0.0144069334,
0.0007249399,
-0.0092158243,
0.0310106091,
0.037770845,
0.046847932,
-0.0513869189,
0.0419543386,
-0.0077700741,
-0.109103173,
0.0228934605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09885v1 | Test-takers have a say: understanding the implications of the use of AI in language tests | 2023-07-19T10:28:59 | 2023-07-19T10:28:59 | Dawen Zhang, Thong Hoang, Shidong Pan, Yongquan Hu, Zhenchang Xing, Mark Staples, Xiwei Xu, Qinghua Lu, Aaron Quigley | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Language tests measure a person's ability to use a language in terms of
listening, speaking, reading, or writing. Such tests play an integral role in
academic, professional, and immigration domains, with entities such as
educational institutions, professional accreditation bodies, and governments
using them to assess candidate language proficiency. Recent advances in
Artificial Intelligence (AI) and the discipline of Natural Language Processing
have prompted language test providers to explore AI's potential applicability
within language testing, leading to transformative activity patterns
surrounding language instruction and learning. However, with concerns over AI's
trustworthiness, it is imperative to understand the implications of integrating
AI into language testing. This knowledge will enable stakeholders to make
well-informed decisions, thus safeguarding community well-being and testing
integrity. To understand the concerns and effects of AI usage in language
tests, we conducted interviews and surveys with English test-takers. To the
best of our knowledge, this is the first empirical study aimed at identifying
the implications of AI adoption in language tests from a test-taker
perspective. Our study reveals test-taker perceptions and behavioral patterns.
Specifically, we identify that AI integration may enhance perceptions of
fairness, consistency, and availability. Conversely, it might incite mistrust
regarding reliability and interactivity aspects, subsequently influencing the
behaviors and well-being of test-takers. These insights provide a better
understanding of potential societal implications and assist stakeholders in
making informed decisions concerning AI usage in language testing. | [
0.0328615308,
0.041716177,
-0.0719526261,
0.0065959208,
-0.07083413,
-0.0063073537,
0.0154896956,
-0.0049089584,
0.0479685925,
-0.0407191068,
0.0208848752,
0.0186690111,
0.0135022579,
0.0121601652,
0.0116154645,
0.011034281,
-0.0133306198,
0.0255714413,
0.0241926834,
0.0111865019,
0.0311002079,
0.0428077877,
-0.0096905306,
0.0418620072,
-0.0206081551,
-0.0133192968,
-0.0007031934,
-0.0554309115,
-0.0019569537,
-0.0277151633,
0.0279736333,
0.0289408248,
-0.013580828,
0.0337977372,
0.0000018531,
-0.0480400845,
0.019998325,
0.0034239516,
-0.0562769286,
-0.0087800324,
0.0213148408,
0.0772602707,
-0.0032454859,
0.0290084872,
-0.078515254,
0.0557244085,
0.0023611812,
-0.0475964695,
-0.007418653,
0.0428297631,
-0.008141824,
0.0262787305,
0.0329541005,
0.0205404982,
0.0031482012,
-0.0117010046,
0.0059512863,
-0.0389496833,
0.0025420047,
-0.0338538401,
-0.0319731459,
0.0131612979,
0.0214759391,
-0.0228880215,
-0.0333975218,
0.0160865132,
-0.0321666226,
-0.0468322523,
-0.0139615498,
-0.0025325047,
0.0585582033,
-0.017833693,
-0.0326582268,
0.0018290952,
0.0266310144,
0.0558437929,
-0.0180227309,
0.0179915745,
0.0048340983,
-0.0058729695,
0.0186301097,
-0.0528098457,
-0.0190417729,
0.0285492595,
-0.0085249124,
0.0632948428,
-0.0162228495,
-0.0503487661,
0.0217078738,
0.0438800789,
0.0375384577,
-0.0315201953,
0.0135977715,
0.0204324368,
-0.0068669473,
0.0233000908,
0.0013045864,
-0.0430776887,
0.0339756794,
0.0051947883,
-0.0027292944,
0.0200015344,
-0.0222349279,
0.0027118092,
0.0287327264,
0.0775699764,
0.0828415975,
0.0484220125,
-0.022500718,
0.0228206292,
-0.0263661426,
-0.0194987431,
-0.0029689795,
0.0063093486,
0.027237758,
0.0377389863,
0.0000377879,
-0.0167993344,
-0.079500854,
0.0586026683,
-0.0499776714,
-0.005391635,
-0.00044977,
0.0258136354,
-0.0313781649,
0.0155564966,
-0.0351494141,
0.0203022379,
-0.0055433474,
-0.0567076951,
0.0394889191,
0.0262128729,
0.0065807784,
0.0070513138,
0.0163886193,
0.0207852796,
-0.0003663949,
-0.0538169332,
0.0116826072,
-0.0022889376,
0.0036397285,
-0.0239677634,
0.0023171932,
-0.017601354,
-0.0153914494,
0.0186345968,
-0.0419251658,
-0.0774479806,
-0.0085763996,
0.0534054413,
-0.0004881219,
0.0249940958,
0.0114135705,
0.0056738043,
0.025707446,
0.0156139638,
0.0006098484,
0.0013829097,
0.0330475047,
-0.0135640502,
0.0242087599,
-0.0528603718,
0.0596820004,
0.0322073363,
0.0034456935,
0.0198560599,
0.0208969545,
0.0148726851,
-0.0585556701,
-0.010192411,
0.0058947606,
0.0534738228,
0.0098948227,
0.0170490146,
0.0419617482,
0.1078712121,
-0.0371267907,
0.000596954,
0.0108440816,
0.0304806512,
0.0054071648,
0.0102507034,
-0.0314320847,
-0.0333558768,
-0.0273673628,
-0.0125060258,
-0.0353939123,
0.0290927347,
0.0019814016,
-0.072844401,
-0.0077966298,
-0.0143328682,
0.0792462453,
0.0887866691,
0.0091863815,
-0.0302211996,
-0.0177958105,
-0.0401143581,
-0.0124015547,
-0.0375552662,
0.0376952961,
-0.0851692259,
0.0519080125,
0.0831253007,
0.0254969075,
0.002164345,
0.0225787852,
-0.0239979345,
-0.0023422695,
0.0547211356,
0.0293200109,
-0.0247123241,
-0.0580624826,
0.0040139165,
-0.0042288499,
0.0429074429,
-0.0147939492,
0.0124205863,
-0.0170771908,
0.0594771244,
-0.0129820704,
0.0181930996,
-0.0852718651,
0.0498394631,
-0.0256056357,
-0.0649696514,
-0.0588296242,
0.0319334976,
0.0068485728,
0.0282938983,
-0.0218570996,
-0.0092970841,
0.0048320163,
0.0421513952,
-0.0136061432,
0.005412308,
-0.0000723845,
0.0415422991,
0.0168983582,
-0.0558077283,
-0.0538002811,
0.0425149463,
-0.0097429492,
-0.0032691443,
0.0254278034,
-0.0342620872,
-0.0291759707,
0.0109691881,
0.0091118617,
-0.0728044733,
-0.011074353,
-0.0357557274,
-0.0268523544,
-0.0329931267,
-0.0027911519,
-0.0303722043,
-0.00727903,
0.0138946064,
0.006675601,
-0.0533563569,
0.0281767454,
-0.0113831796,
0.0404588841,
0.0521293432,
0.029053187,
-0.0566772744,
0.0307766292,
-0.0582123473,
-0.0205658618,
0.007302654,
0.023622619,
-0.0079933451,
-0.0551854782,
-0.019438263,
0.0275997333,
-0.0501187332,
-0.0448628999,
0.0271766428,
0.0204937179,
0.0040480588,
-0.0028260078,
-0.0226078779,
-0.0250658114,
-0.0067048077,
-0.0590764098,
0.0165676437,
0.0782547891,
0.0226204842,
-0.0381033458,
-0.0174515136,
-0.0246486235,
-0.001775075,
0.0356081016,
-0.0245955735,
0.0363065265,
0.0105244918,
-0.0219613723,
0.0759344921,
0.0160539914,
0.0259193033,
0.0170182027,
0.044088807,
-0.0223101173,
-0.0104137538,
0.072100997,
0.0102635836,
-0.0004943881,
-0.058423534,
0.0043453509,
0.0139132235,
0.0271261577,
-0.025384374,
0.0314524285,
0.059873566,
-0.0946782529,
-0.0293915644,
-0.0103909411,
-0.0779276639,
-0.0541914776,
0.0453774296,
-0.0249815825,
-0.0259949006,
0.0604685433,
0.0017262348,
0.013408754,
-0.0802661255,
-0.0017787607,
0.0062971283,
0.0410864279,
0.0098470068,
0.0196974315,
-0.0147628542,
-0.0302148052,
-0.0530094206,
-0.0307994783,
0.0164863989,
-0.0715040416,
0.0393082239,
-0.0440051332,
0.0150853964,
0.03091833,
-0.0202721264,
-0.0417037942,
0.0169241782,
-0.0121258525,
0.0097356597,
0.0166851524,
-0.0208290834,
0.0215136018,
-0.0805342123,
0.0252339821,
0.0156726744,
0.0159821752,
-0.0296802856,
0.0143385762,
0.0063535692,
0.0310443081,
0.0204002727,
0.0648046806,
-0.0110367434,
-0.0006437213,
0.0266549848,
0.0529833399,
0.0102828359,
0.0065764198,
-0.0303269718,
0.0294076968,
-0.0328600407,
0.006161727,
0.0400093906,
0.0132392123,
-0.0311239734,
0.003546617,
0.0543921441,
0.021437576,
-0.0118897269,
0.0025055297,
-0.0335612223,
-0.009095856,
0.0206420459,
0.0368400998,
-0.1109118834,
0.0150126517,
-0.0050458056,
0.0125717325,
-0.0678905174,
-0.0144133884,
-0.0099381953,
-0.0604105853,
0.0470467024,
-0.0303434413,
-0.0008143215,
-0.0167079158,
-0.0027665359,
-0.0157564227,
0.0063056084,
0.1135546565,
0.0063965949,
0.0165811181,
0.0266352072,
0.0103901336,
-0.0392242037,
-0.0099102305,
0.0872209966,
-0.0208061617,
0.0294513218,
0.0576727912,
0.0377502553,
-0.0729019791,
-0.0473530143,
-0.015166197,
-0.0140497684,
-0.0239348076,
0.0189014636,
0.0047741425,
-0.0113941375,
0.0229018405,
-0.031557139,
0.0047543943,
-0.044292096,
0.0176543873,
0.0628903136,
0.0367842317,
0.0054123681,
-0.0595633686,
-0.0155942999,
-0.0050475714,
-0.0071424097,
0.0413222052,
0.0328710377,
-0.0607882477,
0.0343587846,
-0.0390214808,
0.004165669,
-0.0101812361,
-0.0883652568,
0.0367567949,
0.018969316,
-0.0152753545,
-0.0444832332,
-0.1248627454,
0.0580828786,
0.0243616868,
0.0395389348,
-0.0248937514,
0.0330290012,
-0.0285627916,
-0.0261346959,
0.043621745,
-0.0109683834,
0.0292365961,
0.0037712103,
-0.0172288436,
-0.033038158,
0.007168266,
-0.0110161183,
0.0315590836,
0.0280941147,
-0.0370809808,
0.062773779,
0.0419257507,
0.0272597447,
0.0129153356,
0.0078702876,
-0.0088512599,
-0.0277958605,
-0.045660343,
-0.0304923113,
0.0207688641,
0.0360998362,
-0.017855078,
0.0062524253,
-0.0089613702,
-0.0031896024,
-0.0175246652,
-0.0198844988,
-0.0407401994,
-0.0079095736,
-0.0392072126,
0.0674344227,
0.0711486936,
0.0095457276,
-0.0208189096,
0.0456670336,
-0.0262992699,
-0.0301299784,
-0.0069372598,
-0.0324910805,
0.0157555398,
-0.0449561924,
0.0045830831,
0.0141643193,
-0.027309591,
-0.002976961,
-0.0467169657,
0.0148444567,
-0.0189994443,
0.066020757,
0.0098022176,
0.0974855199,
0.0048348783,
-0.0165952966,
-0.0063996422,
0.0052101831,
-0.0061130994,
0.0655061826,
0.048762504,
0.0537178852,
-0.0189938359,
-0.0111492649,
0.0306546576,
0.0193354115,
-0.0125310831,
-0.0542597696,
0.0166540239,
0.0088220378,
-0.0407209583,
0.0027629528,
-0.0047553601,
0.0084750941,
0.0472324677,
0.0240328684,
-0.039838668,
-0.0156240882,
-0.0464876182,
0.0382122211,
0.0060879984,
-0.0121998014,
-0.0089046424,
0.0147210639,
-0.0394942462,
0.0342089534,
-0.0577162132,
0.0252941046,
0.0084770024,
-0.0343416072,
0.0023661787,
0.0212198459,
-0.0014356186,
-0.0564215258,
-0.0439679399,
-0.0688450187,
-0.0095601212,
0.0198264662,
0.0366621017,
-0.0419680066,
-0.0172537789,
0.0530500636,
-0.0080054738,
-0.0219286382,
-0.0229605567,
-0.0001658603,
-0.0382999927,
-0.0413340554,
0.0087353615,
-5.663419743e-33,
0.0072947168,
-0.080423139,
0.0375950187,
-0.0172036737,
0.012272601,
-0.0067306617,
-0.0033836339,
0.0199778695,
-0.0568528771,
0.0063384566,
-0.0213400237,
0.0179968886,
-0.0071327467,
0.0110300453,
0.0505720079,
0.0003828904,
0.0105314087,
-0.0309677497,
-0.001866255,
0.0047377632,
-0.0739817247,
-0.0252496749,
0.0490999036,
-0.046378091,
0.088508077,
-0.0229341127,
-0.0043097981,
-0.0249255188,
-0.0576265045,
-0.0010623246,
0.0236254949,
0.0658334568,
0.0415428132,
-0.009763455,
0.0216934606,
0.0518480092,
-0.0202948488,
-0.038527526,
0.0275567174,
0.0312004779,
-0.0188497063,
-0.024530923,
0.0484480448,
-0.0382542498,
-0.0366338156,
0.0395303592,
0.0494474173,
-0.0043961089,
0.029400669,
0.0288927425,
-0.0527904965,
-0.0066485945,
-0.0723307803,
0.0223970227,
-0.0170969311,
0.0773353428,
0.0137696741,
-0.0456862114,
-0.0574471392,
0.0210150853,
0.0026541876,
-0.016078962,
0.0600745939,
-0.0353778787,
-0.0418009572,
0.0536540598,
0.0589316003,
0.0094992816,
0.0220168382,
-0.0387527645,
0.0713114515,
-0.0365664847,
0.0509979092,
0.0641482174,
-0.0220697895,
-0.075719133,
-0.0143363811,
0.0356475711,
0.0607525855,
-0.0180714764,
-0.0200149529,
-0.0187082645,
-0.1367246509,
-0.0366785936,
-0.0354578383,
-0.0428225771,
-0.0249444228,
-0.0396941379,
0.0563656501,
-0.0365218706,
-0.0160950646,
0.0010776569,
0.0089181876,
-0.0425378792,
-0.0025897473,
-0.0137779247,
-0.0411200151,
0.0063369046,
-0.0138790207,
0.0300375614,
-0.0183099173,
0.0052308296,
-0.025888117,
0.0103732338,
0.0531435162,
0.025650762,
0.0150193339,
0.0179791916,
-0.0371934026,
-0.0083549106,
-0.0212709364,
0.0176632199,
0.0618843809,
-0.009361418,
0.0262109935,
0.0730658993,
0.0284467675,
0.0055210693,
0.0537172817,
-0.0426573232,
-0.0564701185,
-0.0116250543,
-0.062767908,
-0.0344955176,
-0.0592175126,
-0.0385442078,
-0.0369781144,
0.0556019209,
0.0151111837,
-0.0476448461,
-0.0081135174,
-0.0417853519,
2.559e-7,
0.0312147401,
0.077200599,
-0.0260089412,
-0.006047566,
-0.0308357254,
-0.0004068507,
0.0090453504,
0.0201906152,
0.071237132,
0.032216385,
0.039638944,
0.0033044436,
-0.0166712068,
0.0209128689,
-0.0571541786,
-0.0054820874,
-0.0117739299,
0.0251127258,
-0.0596470051,
0.0739887431,
0.0830397904,
0.0149848768,
-0.0083729085,
-0.0285004731,
-0.0476330705,
-0.0346703827,
-0.0463420413,
0.016277561,
0.0316500552,
-0.0096110478,
0.0059139412,
0.0301143639,
0.032388825,
0.0922104046,
-0.0288081113,
0.0106035927,
-0.0171630289,
0.0406222045,
-0.0201037526,
0.0185994785,
0.0232805908,
-0.0107790688,
0.0108032636,
-0.0373167694,
0.0496406071,
-0.0115579106,
-0.0164905079,
-0.0539442338,
-0.0448618494,
-0.0791052356,
0.0115940934,
-0.0108010415,
-0.007710156,
0.0444355346,
0.0108103119,
-0.0351604857,
0.0350342691,
0.0079327328,
0.0451571681,
0.0029049492,
0.0370501913,
-0.037217062,
0.0068776025,
0.0015308474,
-0.0305788256,
-0.0433378369,
0.0043447204,
1.795363287e-34,
-0.0018389216,
-0.0109008299,
0.0436692424,
0.0248114765,
0.0744308531,
0.037665084,
-0.0115226675,
0.0040735006,
-0.0028179153,
0.0173247531,
-0.0425177775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09813v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09813v1 | DAPrompt: Deterministic Assumption Prompt Learning for Event Causality Identification | 2023-07-19T08:02:20 | 2023-07-19T08:02:20 | Wei Xiang, Chuanhong Zhan, Bang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event Causality Identification (ECI) aims at determining whether there is a
causal relation between two event mentions. Conventional prompt learning
designs a prompt template to first predict an answer word and then maps it to
the final decision. Unlike conventional prompts, we argue that predicting an
answer word may not be a necessary prerequisite for the ECI task. Instead, we
can first make a deterministic assumption on the existence of causal relation
between two events and then evaluate its rationality to either accept or reject
the assumption. The design motivation is to try the most utilization of the
encyclopedia-like knowledge embedded in a pre-trained language model. In light
of such considerations, we propose a deterministic assumption prompt learning
model, called DAPrompt, for the ECI task. In particular, we design a simple
deterministic assumption template concatenating with the input event pair,
which includes two masks as predicted events' tokens. We use the probabilities
of predicted events to evaluate the assumption rationality for the final event
causality decision. Experiments on the EventStoryLine corpus and
Causal-TimeBank corpus validate our design objective in terms of significant
performance improvements over the state-of-the-art algorithms. | [
0.0353406779,
0.0500354655,
-0.0059229056,
0.0270443168,
-0.0526204072,
0.0202445146,
0.0222597271,
-0.0030361393,
0.074806869,
-0.0350897834,
0.0704365671,
0.0036107539,
-0.0305715092,
0.049760364,
-0.0152819725,
-0.017052114,
0.0856034011,
0.0261078961,
0.0256510377,
0.0078515876,
-0.0082092509,
0.005057923,
-0.0549231805,
0.0341970138,
-0.0258114673,
-0.0016103187,
-0.0102170687,
-0.0121282618,
0.009391753,
-0.0302293021,
0.0011539748,
0.0619898513,
0.001079081,
0.0131636085,
0.0000020291,
-0.0745018274,
-0.0346491411,
-0.0527104177,
-0.0212415252,
-0.0284373015,
-0.0826504752,
0.0390099399,
0.0331434645,
-0.0024282977,
-0.0318014286,
-0.0345655829,
0.0268242452,
0.0613715388,
0.0053884005,
0.0744199231,
-0.0209477078,
-0.0528255366,
0.0189366583,
-0.0003240887,
0.0145319365,
-0.0022413912,
0.0301600955,
-0.0498139337,
0.0022778297,
-0.0216291994,
0.0042589637,
0.0056157322,
-0.0092174979,
0.0098049706,
0.0450358093,
0.0283514429,
0.027981732,
-0.0278235674,
-0.0138120828,
0.0686469674,
0.0593953095,
-0.0468294509,
0.0449069105,
-0.0027145545,
-0.0050463225,
0.0896710306,
0.0035180703,
-0.0027289712,
-0.0149829341,
-0.0047077802,
0.0593008697,
0.0315812752,
0.0134883141,
0.0232445728,
-0.0382595174,
0.0965091586,
0.0261729509,
-0.0113916295,
-0.0320870727,
0.0101515856,
-0.0287516303,
-0.0887048841,
0.0098037655,
0.0416113585,
-0.0430772416,
0.0225382391,
-0.0066770925,
0.0027873192,
-0.0182667077,
-0.0058925455,
-0.040997576,
0.0306584947,
-0.0071202852,
0.0555517748,
-0.0212144945,
0.0191463921,
0.0106953932,
-0.0030433864,
-0.0101435175,
0.0291900914,
0.0074446383,
0.0331912041,
-0.0232884511,
0.0112868845,
-0.0123551879,
-0.0128286192,
-0.012911099,
0.0074969302,
0.0184705686,
0.015302985,
-0.0218662657,
-0.0174626652,
-0.0233003311,
-0.0027469608,
-0.0686307624,
-0.025787523,
-0.0821404606,
0.0350552239,
-0.0438194238,
-0.0292159952,
-0.0211184472,
0.006406751,
0.0408180766,
-0.0105647426,
-0.0076735565,
0.03921175,
-0.0089986548,
-0.0197131019,
-0.056197688,
-0.0517498292,
0.0065625748,
-0.0208453406,
-0.0371167399,
-0.02961866,
0.0063422965,
0.0128455795,
-0.0005193143,
-0.0336351506,
0.0043863901,
-0.0033416997,
-0.0544171147,
0.0569877364,
-0.0164612383,
0.0129239094,
0.0291228909,
0.0069698794,
0.0113133732,
0.036987599,
0.040372286,
0.026792787,
0.050632894,
0.0462665744,
-0.0052278466,
-0.0000488534,
0.0509752892,
0.0020726845,
-0.0024118577,
0.0013274529,
0.018239459,
0.0211101305,
0.00333738,
0.0200159736,
-0.0141799795,
-0.0201964099,
0.0187256746,
-0.0014550864,
-0.0489003994,
-0.0396608226,
0.0681027099,
-0.0328526609,
-0.0066951052,
0.0568298548,
-0.000936633,
-0.0169421472,
-0.0225554332,
-0.0173189081,
0.0330720171,
-0.0726681501,
-0.0208921786,
-0.0104451962,
0.0114244753,
-0.0250199363,
-0.0029521801,
0.0136349127,
0.0335474238,
-0.0090019898,
-0.0588330477,
0.043890018,
0.0195792019,
-0.0259370282,
-0.0007794339,
-0.008412688,
0.0875123367,
0.0115052434,
0.0345675647,
-0.0422989763,
-0.0139400279,
-0.029024886,
0.0290205739,
0.0234417189,
0.0296841096,
-0.0440358482,
0.0252683423,
-0.0147727067,
-0.0062305466,
0.0310134199,
0.0053123725,
0.0254377816,
0.0151444683,
0.0174667947,
-0.017565757,
0.0354577936,
0.0246974882,
0.0546848439,
-0.0354527123,
-0.0760447979,
-0.0102325799,
0.0406910181,
0.0359574333,
0.0272622611,
0.0018915662,
0.011503336,
0.0187228173,
-0.0309778713,
-0.0421691686,
0.0331511274,
-0.0460607298,
-0.0477959029,
0.0159098487,
-0.0240804274,
-0.0195843503,
0.0247709956,
-0.016416071,
-0.0976841077,
0.0074638366,
0.0140941711,
0.0240417998,
-0.019792024,
0.0032884292,
0.0026184395,
-0.0274200942,
-0.0424226522,
0.0661831573,
0.0251180977,
0.0478043146,
0.0098891668,
0.0395868272,
0.0517281592,
-0.0282554738,
-0.0299036205,
-0.0029052249,
0.0259038433,
-0.0621040985,
0.069152914,
-0.0557145104,
-0.0453925356,
0.017400885,
-0.0709228665,
0.0275191516,
-0.0118301241,
0.0121084303,
-0.0165357292,
0.0221818741,
-0.0215000473,
-0.0250671953,
-0.0135601284,
-0.0433595069,
-0.0347851589,
0.0293626022,
0.0561735146,
0.0275100041,
0.0155320698,
-0.0437211543,
0.0159980878,
-0.0664995313,
0.0448748358,
0.0412052609,
-0.0543618724,
-0.0177506953,
0.0214736015,
-0.0046398332,
0.0422438271,
-0.0062294514,
-0.0006460418,
-0.0106526585,
-0.0071723256,
0.049266465,
0.0180890057,
0.0257793963,
-0.029134918,
0.0016892104,
-0.0251505096,
-0.0530822352,
0.0275100805,
-0.0656440035,
0.0061237076,
0.0196260884,
-0.0240378827,
-0.0113515062,
0.0738140047,
0.0124212801,
-0.017567195,
-0.0465421528,
-0.0352616869,
-0.0042317016,
0.0081313103,
-0.0550555512,
-0.0786786377,
-0.0315860733,
0.0520901009,
-0.0075195348,
-0.0284587666,
0.0887171775,
-0.0102565521,
0.0182234831,
-0.0314561203,
0.0170696005,
-0.0368101522,
0.064008154,
0.0013559379,
-0.0011758297,
0.0513356999,
-0.0592426583,
-0.0374619663,
-0.006729342,
0.0246652067,
0.0046436125,
0.0113824466,
-0.0570566133,
0.0400556065,
-0.0067154495,
-0.0291684121,
-0.0612861216,
-0.1093708724,
-0.0061124624,
-0.0089486288,
-0.0055296286,
0.0131201418,
-0.000560905,
0.0081474651,
-0.0226359889,
0.0406348892,
-0.0044054114,
0.0114916358,
-0.0036826849,
0.0668267161,
0.0490072854,
-0.030166816,
0.0190723296,
0.0047505251,
0.0052815406,
-0.0205369163,
0.021347085,
0.0050315512,
-0.0137445284,
0.0113175428,
0.0159011371,
-0.0750607252,
-0.0217542183,
0.0233023204,
0.0222097095,
-0.0053859865,
0.0155522507,
0.1332386136,
0.061503347,
-0.0628226846,
0.006523659,
0.0584550053,
-0.0069903922,
0.0125534227,
-0.007451246,
-0.0957393125,
-0.0372895002,
0.004843825,
-0.0118570374,
-0.0597152747,
-0.0923394188,
-0.0193913355,
-0.0664800107,
-0.0314688347,
-0.0191996712,
0.0202449895,
0.0169536099,
-0.071509622,
0.0157903377,
-0.0320206694,
-0.0491007976,
-0.0038367498,
0.0162269864,
0.0322864763,
0.0078557478,
-0.0435217805,
-0.0260122605,
0.0137406895,
-0.0161362458,
0.0507213026,
0.0206714589,
0.0230152495,
-0.0143194795,
0.025876943,
-0.0129470164,
-0.057024844,
-0.0092785815,
-0.0300155394,
0.0409429483,
-0.0258626547,
-0.0139155472,
-0.0030461263,
0.0505946167,
0.0013363607,
-0.0220360402,
0.0346082933,
0.0651866794,
-0.0272536594,
0.0200698432,
-0.0083281109,
0.006257215,
0.0614489317,
0.0936447233,
-0.0131039936,
0.0166142341,
-0.0343799703,
0.0235548634,
0.0193088669,
-0.0308959391,
-0.0068473998,
-0.0516648553,
0.0016040739,
-0.0460447446,
-0.0769558921,
-0.0451655574,
-0.0280521978,
0.0260084886,
0.0027504514,
0.0219051577,
-0.0121239759,
0.0093556223,
-0.0394599549,
0.0425282381,
-0.0154118631,
0.0334274918,
-0.0271762889,
-0.00465417,
0.0122157661,
0.0250596013,
-0.0292798206,
0.0705617517,
-0.01310982,
-0.0443808101,
0.0110911084,
-0.014450564,
0.0206489135,
0.0543710552,
-0.0505719706,
-0.0247653499,
0.0143341534,
-0.0146110402,
-0.0179122183,
-0.0089427559,
0.0046336227,
0.0258105937,
-0.0210098624,
0.0332558863,
-0.021537181,
0.0506259426,
-0.0017365423,
0.0548332147,
-0.0394419245,
-0.0407461822,
0.0095494743,
-0.0004223699,
0.108597748,
-0.0245996844,
0.0013622999,
-0.0541615933,
0.006658942,
-0.0275882147,
-0.0040421318,
0.0091584232,
0.0366784558,
0.0000443058,
0.0082372725,
-0.0521536618,
-0.0240791813,
-0.0418324359,
0.0269840471,
-0.0187688116,
0.0222511198,
0.0561462007,
0.0332418159,
-0.002927056,
-0.0135971541,
-0.0405745618,
0.0153979231,
0.0445579253,
0.0233346354,
-0.0139510045,
0.0668230951,
0.0337675214,
0.01257216,
0.00406917,
-0.0552616976,
-0.0868403465,
0.0326493904,
0.0204909127,
0.0082008075,
0.0681048781,
-0.0404939167,
0.0127420276,
-0.0114320442,
0.0080318972,
0.0055663991,
0.0305996221,
0.0313262157,
0.0052485443,
0.0377890579,
0.0009108156,
-0.0382849798,
0.0733297914,
0.0543370731,
-0.0156371146,
0.0773187056,
0.001883775,
-0.0178572088,
-0.0228778031,
-0.0481054485,
0.0182104073,
0.0227818489,
-0.0315292813,
0.013258921,
-0.0986884683,
0.0033328074,
0.0128481081,
-0.0266279783,
0.0138483029,
0.0100304941,
0.0451743454,
0.0386837684,
0.0295310188,
-0.011816795,
-0.0434520096,
0.0452105254,
-0.0558597259,
-0.0186154172,
-0.0480474979,
-6.29708136e-33,
-0.0336310081,
-0.0118451174,
0.0097976746,
-0.0015095512,
-0.0000262092,
0.0303619318,
-0.0551468357,
-0.0174991153,
-0.0414060317,
0.014109713,
-0.0185575932,
0.0178855564,
0.0259920713,
-0.032077007,
0.0059066643,
-0.0152792558,
0.021603439,
0.0151408343,
-0.020097496,
0.0109474016,
0.0723046884,
0.0446930267,
0.0014255202,
-0.0345124304,
0.0452636518,
-0.0253868029,
-0.0007329359,
0.016737951,
0.0435076617,
0.0117131034,
-0.0193393547,
-0.0033929427,
-0.002870769,
-0.0532759875,
0.0122951763,
0.0622418225,
-0.1004079655,
-0.0936942026,
0.0557457581,
-0.0106430799,
-0.0358076245,
-0.0450460836,
-0.0349065922,
-0.0126921423,
-0.0062154718,
0.0094575724,
0.0433958769,
0.0010867475,
-0.014343461,
-0.052591756,
-0.0379574001,
0.0466227792,
-0.0190309901,
-0.0003594194,
0.0095957415,
0.0426744446,
0.0339310244,
-0.0168503467,
0.0020570075,
0.029265957,
-0.0443143807,
0.0096616885,
-0.0282953475,
-0.0038069482,
-0.01462771,
0.0615953356,
0.0049522389,
-0.02115958,
-0.0093952771,
0.0660293475,
-0.0135408239,
0.0005527399,
0.0367966853,
0.0520193763,
0.0180455856,
-0.0094841765,
-0.0943464339,
0.0384055637,
0.0981988087,
-0.0119538214,
0.0028426372,
-0.0395368859,
-0.0480001643,
-0.0203406867,
-0.0516969934,
0.0166555103,
-0.0286405385,
-0.0138671929,
0.0196237229,
0.0062656305,
0.0115012471,
0.0388298668,
0.0196388233,
-0.0185993332,
-0.0096353712,
0.0454205684,
-0.0038964322,
-0.0161840469,
0.0055090422,
0.046171315,
-0.072894536,
-0.0040315939,
0.0278782751,
0.0001506971,
0.0395984054,
0.0263750292,
0.0026762635,
0.0148538388,
-0.0338920131,
-0.0216342881,
-0.0007024311,
-0.0381527506,
-0.0519853756,
-0.0466000475,
0.0317629203,
0.0380586907,
0.0087190969,
0.0281414092,
0.0006680305,
0.0377267748,
0.0285813827,
-0.0528712012,
-0.0075859874,
0.0473366641,
-0.0288402233,
-0.01623738,
0.0157597885,
0.0672318414,
-0.025164092,
-0.030829614,
-0.0032160755,
0.0061838143,
2.679e-7,
0.0182083044,
0.0265507344,
0.0386123061,
0.0363446511,
-0.0098051932,
-0.009045898,
0.0246472899,
0.0292594619,
-0.0014553329,
0.0223364234,
0.0356874801,
-0.0075569157,
0.0335870497,
0.0024670633,
-0.0973689184,
-0.0533387363,
-0.033993315,
0.0046175448,
-0.0727309138,
0.0118790753,
0.1054432169,
0.0378019176,
0.0584508069,
0.0205381159,
-0.0232687518,
-0.0086333882,
0.0230348874,
-0.0250034053,
-0.0266200397,
0.027884163,
0.0278721824,
-0.005188908,
-0.0263673868,
0.0669620782,
-0.026985772,
0.0221128166,
-0.0303652212,
0.048101861,
0.0065823211,
-0.0160196368,
-0.0199334566,
-0.0385288559,
0.0132282963,
-0.0359744728,
0.1060049161,
-0.0035321077,
-0.0171149541,
0.0245316587,
-0.0640194044,
0.0076584243,
0.0065755094,
0.0165861789,
-0.0486413017,
0.0234985258,
0.0133856032,
0.0132510969,
0.003454071,
-0.1001507342,
-0.0258168802,
0.0402961634,
-0.0117405187,
-0.0568887182,
-0.0014010631,
-0.0415657684,
-0.0036228823,
-0.0943097472,
-0.0110973483,
2.644126687e-34,
0.0110416841,
0.0268476978,
-0.0366385207,
0.0060665184,
0.0343295708,
-0.0377757475,
0.0002704604,
0.0177858751,
0.0641605183,
-0.0680705011,
0.0033841438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10323v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10323v1 | IncDSI: Incrementally Updatable Document Retrieval | 2023-07-19T07:20:30 | 2023-07-19T07:20:30 | Varsha Kishore, Chao Wan, Justin Lovelace, Yoav Artzi, Kilian Q. Weinberger | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Differentiable Search Index is a recently proposed paradigm for document
retrieval, that encodes information about a corpus of documents within the
parameters of a neural network and directly maps queries to corresponding
documents. These models have achieved state-of-the-art performances for
document retrieval across many benchmarks. These kinds of models have a
significant limitation: it is not easy to add new documents after a model is
trained. We propose IncDSI, a method to add documents in real time (about
20-50ms per document), without retraining the model on the entire dataset (or
even parts thereof). Instead we formulate the addition of documents as a
constrained optimization problem that makes minimal changes to the network
parameters. Although orders of magnitude faster, our approach is competitive
with re-training the model on the whole dataset and enables the development of
document retrieval systems that can be updated with new information in
real-time. Our code for IncDSI is available at
https://github.com/varshakishore/IncDSI. | [
-0.0005350048,
0.0696322098,
-0.0052102963,
-0.0048288843,
0.0108348792,
0.0143572493,
-0.008443905,
0.0201879032,
0.0096718827,
0.0067063943,
-0.009467978,
0.0004320619,
-0.0623230264,
0.0615026727,
-0.0078027844,
-0.0050565004,
0.0528258234,
0.0280675068,
-0.0005649967,
-0.0038573085,
-0.0025574293,
-0.0195065383,
-0.0144749023,
-0.0287056454,
-0.0003905385,
0.0013464752,
-0.0923763514,
0.0246626921,
-0.0188515969,
-0.0058378568,
0.0239036866,
-0.0077096284,
0.0784405544,
0.0415597558,
0.0000020504,
-0.0473822728,
-0.0527280197,
-0.0153039498,
-0.0499180555,
-0.0032633129,
0.0477326438,
-0.0208215993,
0.0286988821,
-0.0039198813,
-0.0259276163,
-0.0272335019,
0.0161299016,
0.0346120931,
0.0655578598,
0.0737456903,
-0.0089786891,
-0.0123136183,
0.0609158203,
-0.0458445773,
0.0331946686,
-0.0132201463,
0.0179739948,
0.0159423947,
0.032081034,
0.0203068405,
0.0339712352,
0.0397933722,
0.0268963594,
-0.0438796692,
0.0742647052,
0.0095135663,
-0.0321409255,
0.0069129756,
0.0156928804,
0.0268290844,
-0.0642896369,
-0.0303408653,
-0.0075321989,
-0.0379245579,
-0.0264288075,
-0.0005394496,
-0.0389969535,
-0.013838755,
-0.0036757172,
-0.0046007028,
-0.021968266,
-0.0090756519,
0.0433252268,
0.0227142554,
0.0087792054,
-0.018872954,
0.0015963801,
-0.005164593,
0.001239448,
-0.0305978656,
0.0069152364,
0.0107841641,
0.0335242152,
0.065399684,
-0.0079497863,
-0.0182178412,
-0.0274627879,
-0.0613745786,
0.0133617204,
-0.0940353945,
0.0226046424,
0.021985976,
0.0280743726,
0.0897477418,
0.0059732613,
0.0167240072,
-0.0383612253,
-0.0368133485,
-0.0521126725,
-0.0249884389,
-0.0414612442,
-0.0639033094,
-0.055910483,
0.0535461754,
-0.0352737904,
-0.0528618768,
0.0271392539,
0.0698883086,
0.0247863885,
-0.0142634567,
-0.0060753147,
-0.0144145777,
-0.0703639239,
0.0278480016,
0.0228888411,
-0.0239007641,
-0.0273556542,
0.0112477588,
0.0112572741,
0.0028442405,
-0.0104398066,
-0.0148454364,
0.0288935397,
0.0098110251,
0.0249192473,
-0.0227167811,
-0.0413249433,
-0.0558677055,
-0.030580258,
-0.013815321,
0.0326943994,
0.0107075879,
0.0378408134,
-0.0204305276,
0.0173004568,
-0.0296032671,
-0.0305116568,
-0.0390222408,
-0.0146167921,
0.0397377461,
-0.0042732889,
0.0371444933,
-0.0162016936,
0.0184919238,
0.0869136825,
-0.0054934486,
-0.0103079621,
0.0417946838,
0.0134175587,
0.0224112831,
0.0274238903,
0.0407382995,
0.0025117018,
0.0386152305,
0.0267841071,
0.0343386866,
-0.0304219313,
0.018488206,
-0.023698654,
0.0325712301,
-0.0167924166,
-0.036312595,
-0.0434678383,
-0.018404346,
0.0045297216,
0.0147964722,
0.0197750255,
-0.0117321517,
-0.0570751727,
0.0312322229,
-0.0210384373,
-0.0641915128,
0.0091169542,
0.0598110594,
0.038722463,
-0.0141807441,
0.0140357865,
-0.0392329097,
-0.0510932989,
-0.0198688824,
0.0121080633,
0.0240350235,
0.0104170702,
-0.0067808675,
0.0240825303,
0.00913304,
0.0268440377,
0.0121943625,
-0.0024036833,
-0.047195334,
-0.0209498387,
-0.0249462388,
0.0091369534,
0.0577480011,
0.0561038703,
-0.0575101636,
-0.019678032,
0.0022263986,
0.0174004957,
0.0398574062,
0.0110198688,
-0.0080064489,
0.0080943219,
-0.023599593,
-0.0343385339,
-0.0032908975,
0.0011228131,
0.0088114934,
-0.0009392255,
0.0479188301,
0.0112254173,
-0.016630074,
-0.018834969,
0.0131662088,
-0.0599177703,
-0.0266258214,
0.0472408608,
-0.0062221489,
-0.0018305391,
0.0001234187,
-0.0199950915,
-0.0026580018,
0.0567872189,
-0.0057166656,
-0.0352530628,
-0.037772838,
0.0129942456,
0.0412628502,
0.0213013738,
-0.0104965931,
0.0244768411,
0.0216654483,
-0.0122234421,
-0.0385930166,
0.0018855826,
-0.0318276696,
-0.0097654453,
-0.0492735766,
-0.025201546,
-0.0096798679,
0.0043764892,
-0.0149411475,
0.0233377926,
-0.0055105449,
0.009250938,
-0.0183968488,
0.0289597232,
0.0174995512,
-0.0335990638,
0.0114596272,
0.0430465713,
-0.0246124156,
0.027652001,
0.0408489369,
0.0063671707,
-0.0039713867,
-0.0356272683,
-0.0892689303,
0.0220336299,
-0.0128151346,
-0.0164483897,
-0.0132108796,
0.0535666831,
-0.0057763658,
-0.0535412058,
-0.0420596749,
0.0042633545,
-0.0122513445,
-0.0001765822,
0.0057703503,
0.0416927636,
0.0225569271,
-0.0290520489,
-0.0509643741,
0.042822767,
0.0242945701,
-0.0107991342,
-0.0524540953,
-0.0078924596,
-0.0152508188,
-0.0223908331,
0.058464326,
-0.0122663202,
-0.022958098,
0.0174346343,
-0.0614319295,
-0.0349259898,
0.0608737469,
0.0317848027,
-0.0298558697,
0.0083337333,
-0.0151809128,
-0.087936677,
0.0508400202,
-0.0343196429,
0.0011513829,
0.0447035283,
0.0123683559,
-0.0000219866,
-0.0234884974,
-0.0492162555,
-0.0215099603,
-0.0220930278,
0.0311121475,
0.0142067671,
-0.0407491811,
-0.0724290013,
0.0014852398,
-0.0047463104,
-0.0196098201,
0.0130240023,
-0.0723195523,
0.021390086,
-0.0071873209,
0.0014989779,
-0.0341879874,
-0.0338658616,
-0.0530041941,
0.0479653217,
0.0394686721,
-0.00187226,
-0.048122175,
0.0161111671,
0.0125456816,
0.0555893369,
0.0380483046,
-0.0398758948,
0.0412810631,
0.0043113828,
0.072482422,
0.0061403313,
-0.0810682252,
-0.0314313099,
-0.0715046823,
0.0587595031,
0.0049767084,
-0.0131927738,
-0.0628335476,
-0.0398346819,
-0.0288076922,
0.0046559288,
0.1158327013,
-0.0411646552,
-0.0324266814,
-0.0065170946,
-0.0240447689,
0.0287900772,
0.0000824889,
-0.0195623096,
0.0203344822,
-0.014442849,
0.0454348661,
0.034892343,
-0.0122649614,
-0.0629866272,
0.0527668968,
0.0029620205,
-0.0265341438,
-0.0148368357,
-0.0595804825,
-0.0406155549,
-0.0099741174,
-0.0660509542,
0.0377484709,
0.0197632909,
-0.0987868756,
-0.031396836,
-0.0236873217,
0.0216222759,
0.0213692896,
0.0431515016,
-0.0010115887,
0.0013595429,
0.0134753967,
0.0892067328,
0.0011786262,
-0.0049638781,
-0.0389837995,
-0.0386921018,
0.0311460048,
0.0113498112,
0.0138095776,
0.0172117408,
-0.0804272965,
-0.0275650658,
0.0228733439,
-0.0271744076,
0.0420329757,
0.0250458177,
-0.0188868456,
0.005919443,
0.0405836403,
-0.0011006999,
-0.0659260601,
-0.0022355078,
-0.0469442606,
0.0339037739,
0.0001515038,
0.0268068425,
-0.0124732107,
0.0420911834,
-0.017362548,
-0.0268882308,
-0.013900429,
0.0293288641,
-0.0191517621,
0.0076739145,
-0.0416158736,
0.026514696,
-0.0322588049,
0.0007051832,
-0.0044249599,
0.0386390947,
-0.017876761,
0.0418220535,
-0.0772577971,
-0.0742848963,
0.0114071136,
0.0213463418,
-0.0258475598,
-0.0323873647,
0.0403583907,
0.0136776473,
0.0265198015,
0.0209323373,
0.0690725148,
-0.0123856766,
-0.0622546002,
0.0266343877,
-0.081095539,
-0.0331877954,
-0.0788422674,
0.0445123315,
-0.0282685682,
-0.0135966875,
-0.00752141,
-0.0616132319,
-0.0968795344,
0.0043509253,
0.0244156905,
-0.0160392076,
-0.0009615484,
0.0137599353,
0.0612900928,
-0.0286306404,
-0.0418478213,
-0.0227661114,
-0.0297882613,
-0.0182001237,
0.0074831555,
0.023202667,
0.0202714652,
0.0514233559,
-0.028940713,
-0.0897332653,
0.0330833122,
0.033011619,
-0.0118673239,
0.0267236065,
0.0003080144,
-0.0537612475,
-0.0059242607,
-0.0146756805,
-0.0686032549,
0.027984919,
-0.0183295459,
-0.0457107872,
-0.0131321428,
0.0125731137,
-0.0121289939,
0.0248520486,
0.0628695264,
0.0605295971,
0.0362369604,
-0.022861803,
0.0761249214,
0.0036403048,
-0.0285684168,
-0.0432701446,
0.0432547219,
0.0110693416,
-0.0147129437,
-0.0285788719,
0.0560228787,
0.0703944564,
-0.0106193256,
-0.00270448,
-0.0688203648,
-0.0217702743,
0.0459764041,
-0.0044557373,
0.0174098797,
-0.0535969101,
0.0537253134,
-0.0255665723,
0.0422637537,
-0.0367863514,
0.0174324997,
0.0598173626,
-0.0002015589,
-0.0329024941,
0.01328093,
-0.0802079737,
-0.0370424762,
-0.0081240302,
0.0106003406,
0.0233839341,
0.0005876267,
0.0156163294,
-0.0101624532,
-0.0171147119,
-0.0388135687,
-0.0422050767,
0.0057984125,
-0.0276501942,
-0.0262670442,
0.0369556211,
0.0266316067,
0.0284799617,
0.0281080287,
0.0011989018,
0.0183250457,
-0.0741557404,
0.0136836898,
-0.0221141074,
0.0326993018,
0.0415723212,
0.0781462565,
0.022863593,
-0.0111915311,
0.0584154539,
0.0460813157,
0.0300378632,
0.02810378,
-0.0066783493,
0.012340202,
0.048335772,
0.0443099588,
-0.0266969521,
-0.0337683819,
-0.0221616756,
0.0276930109,
-0.0701410174,
0.0004272693,
0.0261764061,
-6.363702503e-33,
0.0094543919,
-0.0061010784,
-0.0045589139,
0.0081755957,
-0.0382823087,
0.010866479,
-0.0003388398,
-0.0236009639,
0.0087131299,
-0.0191100687,
-0.0399812758,
0.0770166218,
0.0056139217,
0.0304594543,
0.00645932,
-0.0113452962,
0.0417346805,
0.0012091396,
-0.0318663605,
0.0459724963,
0.0886879191,
0.0310113113,
0.009865691,
-0.0148415761,
-0.0243050996,
-0.0276883077,
-0.0043439534,
0.0512464419,
-0.0068914606,
0.0482366867,
-0.0020600364,
0.0140506495,
-0.0034925323,
-0.0011272929,
-0.0148825133,
0.0188287068,
-0.0773513988,
-0.0550743118,
-0.071140565,
0.0369271189,
-0.0217152014,
-0.0022699023,
0.0662588254,
-0.0062863566,
-0.0374901108,
0.0009048877,
0.0125558637,
0.0010855896,
-0.0633929819,
-0.0341673642,
0.018673487,
0.0260244235,
0.0288975853,
0.031865336,
0.0204046648,
0.0161101557,
0.0149527825,
-0.0375650488,
-0.0909477547,
-0.0169739462,
-0.0174363293,
0.0519372188,
-0.0454543568,
0.000783593,
0.0094626984,
0.0739941001,
0.0679440647,
-0.040781945,
0.0240177587,
-0.043134544,
0.0307849627,
-0.0059568528,
0.0652831569,
-0.0021361855,
0.0467189215,
0.0121060396,
-0.0613678247,
0.0178311393,
0.0004070522,
0.0497257486,
0.021820195,
0.0685780346,
-0.0853287801,
-0.0033756057,
-0.0411312059,
0.0112197278,
-0.0306822713,
-0.006135426,
0.0354420803,
0.083269991,
-0.010222923,
-0.048904933,
0.0423883311,
0.0100658694,
0.0156495869,
0.04640387,
0.0079473583,
0.0085947709,
0.0124505078,
0.0040286789,
0.0125161745,
-0.0005900569,
-0.0138147688,
-0.0069962339,
-0.0077121663,
0.0091111735,
0.0127598355,
0.0457485355,
-0.0463883206,
0.0007997659,
0.0321372114,
0.0192816909,
-0.0078662457,
0.0382771268,
0.0296280142,
-0.0165156182,
0.017372705,
0.1149903685,
0.0088265939,
0.0246501192,
-0.0152368201,
-0.0785195082,
0.0382896625,
0.0000814442,
-0.0178893078,
0.0553048067,
-0.0167211406,
0.0221807398,
0.042096477,
-0.132406354,
0.0599345714,
0.0733711123,
2.856e-7,
0.0156658292,
0.0413741991,
0.0108016161,
0.0163916778,
0.0441225842,
0.0095944405,
-0.0276061576,
0.0271854345,
0.0080909021,
0.0499371365,
-0.0012854288,
-0.0140737221,
0.0256719049,
-0.0017124225,
-0.0670092329,
-0.0528764091,
-0.0676268712,
0.0204517283,
-0.0233243443,
-0.0258663502,
-0.0127743175,
0.0825991407,
-0.001977148,
0.0168521032,
0.0044314405,
-0.0886746645,
0.0658638552,
0.0131707219,
-0.0044424031,
-0.0062520164,
0.0849226192,
0.0597403087,
-0.0172223337,
-0.0266622007,
-0.0278285202,
0.0594010688,
0.036914181,
0.0266405158,
-0.016545184,
-0.0013529703,
0.0115651665,
0.0025640642,
0.0006643424,
-0.0128534166,
0.0557411946,
-0.0321662761,
0.0331934504,
-0.0155793168,
-0.0272076745,
-0.0122943316,
0.0336968936,
0.0070632868,
-0.006277476,
0.021486992,
0.0141094346,
0.0225207135,
0.0043247323,
-0.0782543868,
0.0065183686,
0.0013973274,
-0.02918691,
0.0210260209,
-0.0848125815,
0.0495865531,
0.0164998323,
-0.0012343365,
-0.0281702336,
2.124841267e-34,
0.0219654739,
0.0057809763,
0.0036267629,
-0.0053900243,
-0.0196647923,
0.0061345478,
0.0058264821,
0.0330252387,
0.0205599628,
-0.0712729692,
-0.0291812792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09793v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09793v1 | On the Origin of LLMs: An Evolutionary Tree and Graph for 15,821 Large Language Models | 2023-07-19T07:17:43 | 2023-07-19T07:17:43 | Sarah Gao, Andrew Kean Gao | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, I.2.1; H.5.0 | Since late 2022, Large Language Models (LLMs) have become very prominent with
LLMs like ChatGPT and Bard receiving millions of users. Hundreds of new LLMs
are announced each week, many of which are deposited to Hugging Face, a
repository of machine learning models and datasets. To date, nearly 16,000 Text
Generation models have been uploaded to the site. Given the huge influx of
LLMs, it is of interest to know which LLM backbones, settings, training
methods, and families are popular or trending. However, there is no
comprehensive index of LLMs available. We take advantage of the relatively
systematic nomenclature of Hugging Face LLMs to perform hierarchical clustering
and identify communities amongst LLMs using n-grams and term frequency-inverse
document frequency. Our methods successfully identify families of LLMs and
accurately cluster LLMs into meaningful subgroups. We present a public web
application to navigate and explore Constellation, our atlas of 15,821 LLMs.
Constellation rapidly generates a variety of visualizations, namely
dendrograms, graphs, word clouds, and scatter plots. Constellation is available
at the following link: https://constellation.sites.stanford.edu/. | [
0.0283575151,
0.0363730974,
-0.0201345123,
0.0232848749,
-0.0276660789,
0.0006638418,
0.0002633059,
0.0266660769,
-0.0113874217,
-0.0074810362,
-0.0448958464,
-0.0783852264,
0.0173737351,
0.0599617697,
0.0657556951,
-0.0397102982,
0.0228287224,
-0.0240127016,
-0.0302330572,
0.0060053342,
-0.0047959816,
0.0192712881,
0.0388342217,
0.0552312359,
-0.0089977216,
-0.0115291905,
-0.0278717428,
0.0244635623,
0.0249465313,
-0.0249174722,
-0.0109515861,
0.0508965589,
0.0250899903,
0.1043594778,
0.0000020081,
-0.0459051691,
-0.0207213331,
-0.0236629024,
0.0238068886,
0.0462136082,
0.0881413147,
-0.0055210907,
0.0045955698,
0.0271761417,
-0.0327672958,
-0.0186905749,
0.0412575081,
-0.0046053338,
0.0293989815,
0.0637836903,
-0.0007095148,
-0.0220216773,
0.0400641896,
-0.0650602579,
0.0010841844,
-0.0087538175,
0.0302446615,
0.0096547063,
-0.008329019,
0.0281925257,
-0.0205596182,
0.0189975742,
-0.0029316526,
-0.0390015915,
0.029130267,
0.0593335181,
-0.0123375468,
-0.0507769361,
0.0183755159,
0.0598449558,
0.0068781208,
-0.0356183872,
0.0526384041,
0.0122438325,
-0.0172046516,
0.034138985,
-0.0587827824,
0.0463623181,
-0.0023423645,
0.0323239826,
0.0387696102,
-0.0415138714,
0.0353864208,
-0.0102927564,
-0.009211706,
0.0228352174,
0.0438357405,
0.0006820954,
-0.0195451397,
-0.0136768809,
-0.0583384261,
-0.0659191906,
0.0093013262,
0.0195545964,
0.0251043402,
0.0174506046,
-0.0499383509,
-0.0108182896,
0.0370973945,
-0.0120128561,
0.0564137585,
0.0021243491,
0.0359396338,
0.0088737402,
-0.024469763,
0.0268188901,
0.0005108358,
-0.0380554609,
-0.0458261669,
0.0162991732,
-0.0266298596,
-0.0181890856,
-0.0230446011,
0.0040624323,
-0.0201024301,
-0.0199064538,
-0.0659167394,
0.0291377064,
0.0150564406,
-0.0112634609,
0.0179597512,
0.0097252363,
0.0083838981,
0.0024032039,
0.0027781071,
-0.0037279902,
-0.0171671715,
0.011269277,
0.0136237396,
-0.0168092046,
0.0090177516,
0.0386189707,
0.0309802238,
0.0123196179,
-0.0206100307,
0.0380927809,
0.0158778429,
-0.0343372263,
-0.0443820953,
-0.0147959534,
-0.056739632,
-0.0116746426,
-0.0051550851,
-0.090540424,
0.0225198958,
-0.005323695,
-0.0174573679,
-0.0252300296,
-0.0001561204,
0.0207898375,
-0.049704846,
-0.0299170595,
-0.0548973978,
0.0333111249,
0.0689205751,
-0.0077744173,
-0.0115046045,
0.0306218192,
0.0389842466,
0.0259321947,
0.0498230606,
-0.0193188433,
0.0120982481,
0.0633576885,
0.0186929926,
0.0310991611,
-0.0146892238,
-0.0607284717,
0.0069328211,
0.0110309897,
0.0411648154,
0.0729163364,
-0.0383446664,
-0.0478341207,
0.065434508,
0.0628634393,
-0.0011413294,
0.0255080089,
0.0456345901,
0.0074881972,
0.0048576943,
-0.0112576112,
0.0199195016,
-0.004182999,
-0.0574257039,
-0.0082903653,
0.0450657494,
0.0241478793,
-0.0048883869,
-0.0228509344,
-0.0207560062,
0.0018300143,
-0.017927086,
-0.0504486002,
0.0363692492,
-0.0053334269,
-0.0176443998,
0.0220984295,
0.0309584439,
-0.0580529124,
0.0286356881,
-0.0414267704,
0.0492247231,
0.0536714308,
0.0449504741,
0.0111823138,
-0.0377754159,
0.03851505,
0.002217246,
0.0616283789,
0.0152901253,
-0.0207231082,
-0.0336653069,
-0.0497613177,
0.0070632757,
-0.010359874,
0.0206122957,
0.0372976884,
-0.0047408296,
0.0276083611,
0.0203092564,
-0.0355509818,
-0.0404499732,
0.038014926,
-0.0883609876,
0.0270551909,
0.0164886508,
-0.0481302999,
0.0494061038,
0.0033429936,
-0.0314936303,
0.0025921841,
0.0402632058,
-0.0184808206,
-0.0055014407,
0.0216242187,
-0.0252705328,
-0.0286640134,
0.0353398435,
-0.0277995821,
0.0214207023,
-0.0130418669,
-0.0311653502,
-0.0332120433,
0.0472807027,
-0.0480724052,
0.0461370833,
-0.0382327512,
0.0580903329,
-0.0185983554,
0.0200691521,
-0.0338286795,
0.0775993839,
-0.0270733144,
0.0173664466,
0.0089891125,
0.0287927929,
0.0040695127,
-0.0250655729,
-0.0009058834,
-0.012410949,
-0.0022689044,
-0.0220083781,
0.036547143,
0.0288544409,
-0.02614622,
-0.0399094298,
-0.0851881132,
0.0176905952,
-0.0209661759,
0.0378504694,
0.0522888191,
-0.023810491,
-0.0344555713,
0.0366406552,
-0.0323401392,
0.0495314822,
0.0524211265,
-0.0243179686,
0.0462325178,
-0.0369204842,
-0.0351210386,
-0.0561782829,
-0.0044671088,
0.011233883,
0.0513548031,
0.0044675102,
-0.0096161049,
-0.0391852632,
0.078647919,
-0.0568968579,
-0.0244670585,
-0.0230812021,
-0.0174448844,
0.0008896511,
-0.0213578902,
0.0741336793,
0.0003201464,
0.0555524901,
0.0360855758,
0.0343799815,
0.0104981093,
-0.0112512233,
-0.0511319898,
-0.0523885228,
0.0146961138,
0.0011480293,
-0.0817447901,
0.0381709412,
0.0896063149,
0.0133043081,
-0.0296065379,
-0.0318968818,
0.0303996056,
-0.0080809481,
-0.0054162252,
-0.0143623147,
-0.0187335219,
-0.0026800025,
0.0265326519,
-0.0393853746,
-0.0885180905,
0.0072349203,
-0.0572490469,
0.0149125429,
0.0077590789,
-0.0555926822,
-0.0551250502,
0.0788675249,
0.0473374091,
0.0170042068,
0.0172527749,
-0.0100538442,
-0.0409232825,
0.0414064378,
0.0021781465,
-0.010541562,
0.0061474689,
-0.0678279921,
0.0096370578,
-0.0082125729,
0.0182626694,
-0.0101391114,
-0.0276224278,
0.0102938367,
-0.0276589654,
0.0786529928,
-0.0589725785,
-0.0103510069,
0.0260829832,
-0.0030423554,
0.0132730156,
-0.0204798318,
-0.0137365069,
-0.0055889911,
0.0667731836,
0.0812399164,
-0.0270067528,
0.0141862445,
-0.0492447615,
0.0025839098,
0.0728249773,
0.0104270112,
0.0372885503,
-0.0176042505,
-0.002419512,
0.0277627893,
0.005823317,
-0.0519223921,
-0.0085488986,
0.0258029886,
0.0056551429,
0.0035049014,
0.1321053654,
0.046441555,
-0.0353854336,
0.042307023,
-0.0108217262,
0.1021372378,
0.01901423,
-0.0012525427,
-0.0676635802,
0.0334828421,
-0.0106031867,
0.0235583074,
-0.0012311933,
-0.0513015836,
-0.0242279973,
-0.1093775928,
0.0428109132,
0.0418766588,
-0.0361251868,
0.0281951334,
-0.029268818,
-0.0201858748,
0.0062364768,
-0.0250922963,
0.0236780383,
-0.0284668896,
0.0153480032,
0.0323315971,
-0.019917788,
-0.0422997251,
-0.0094345957,
-0.0549026355,
0.0326537602,
0.0011072037,
0.0456340276,
0.0058353287,
-0.0010380062,
0.0357688963,
0.0282031409,
-0.0116094695,
-0.0407301486,
0.0194817986,
0.0179649815,
0.0118438071,
-0.011879229,
0.0468930528,
-0.043237485,
-0.0022068596,
0.0287855938,
0.0506885089,
-0.0072321836,
-0.0647339076,
-0.0171004143,
0.0251277853,
-0.0413363948,
0.0676476359,
0.0325774252,
-0.0348798521,
-0.0178652015,
-0.0293640625,
0.0501184762,
-0.0265408158,
-0.0219346602,
0.0117797507,
-0.0134936227,
-0.0455580354,
-0.0973350406,
0.0289645568,
0.025254542,
0.0318699814,
0.005414546,
0.0054715811,
-0.0072588469,
-0.0663254783,
-0.0182302836,
0.003695088,
-0.0300144497,
-0.0541459993,
-0.0707460716,
-0.0298158675,
0.0416925363,
-0.03733439,
-0.0219362415,
0.0248301085,
-0.0937310606,
-0.0824255422,
-0.0218646377,
0.0147380428,
0.0225473978,
0.0150355874,
0.0257465951,
-0.071960479,
0.0581062771,
0.0439350791,
0.0117390566,
0.0435721241,
-0.063451454,
-0.0308258943,
-0.017206341,
0.0190163776,
-0.0386736654,
0.0229969807,
-0.023329854,
0.0424379297,
-0.0307588261,
-0.0301274396,
-0.0193594079,
0.0137191806,
-0.0022948468,
-0.0639212951,
-0.0353483297,
-0.0735141486,
-0.0320234112,
-0.0353605449,
0.0079733273,
-0.0394895785,
0.006292935,
0.0364077277,
-0.0019300941,
-0.0187040847,
-0.0010745205,
0.0096739903,
0.0699680299,
-0.0263691358,
0.0083049908,
-0.0070429053,
0.0215947125,
0.0175684933,
-0.0118356068,
0.009390587,
-0.013519071,
-0.0598816797,
0.0237108413,
-0.0190754067,
0.0458198674,
-0.0125769684,
-0.0136207677,
0.0046491046,
0.0543311611,
-0.0598486178,
-0.0295293238,
-0.0500771292,
0.0208713803,
0.086144723,
0.0181927383,
0.075002417,
-0.0440503471,
-0.008554494,
-0.045127295,
0.0425150022,
-0.0013544476,
-0.0660088137,
-0.0121428408,
-0.0033106417,
-0.0491536967,
0.02016907,
0.1003998443,
0.063031584,
0.0031889011,
0.0311624743,
-0.0212666951,
-0.0092119528,
-0.0027232517,
0.0204614643,
-0.014509174,
-0.009101117,
0.0119728381,
-0.0484642498,
-0.0506303795,
0.0163793415,
0.0043719714,
0.0175387487,
-0.0143261757,
0.0514099598,
0.0469852686,
-0.0280958191,
0.0532168858,
-0.0686642528,
0.0308238193,
-0.0508106984,
-0.028737653,
-0.0119330604,
-6.713365787e-33,
-0.0168596562,
-0.072400935,
0.0204760879,
-0.0145640336,
-0.0419257507,
-0.0190758929,
-0.031636063,
0.0142506408,
0.0212430358,
-0.0308490824,
0.0118661579,
-0.0075527886,
-0.0208511651,
0.0293028597,
-0.0050261673,
0.0449732281,
0.0209242776,
-0.0152715603,
-0.0207579155,
0.0627805591,
0.0424814448,
0.0218116734,
0.0255900268,
-0.0211237129,
-0.0201083515,
0.0031004038,
0.0084749199,
0.0020428507,
-0.0142615372,
0.0448714085,
-0.0379504412,
0.0078286417,
0.0242889058,
0.0166011713,
0.0005382368,
-0.0179026667,
-0.0122884186,
-0.0107381707,
-0.001898839,
-0.0398863591,
-0.0133628873,
-0.0461512618,
0.0486418679,
0.0048174043,
-0.0244427193,
0.0032388458,
0.0414231494,
-0.0027186032,
-0.0526802428,
-0.0206004661,
-0.0278228913,
0.0449481905,
-0.0179789905,
0.0056040953,
-0.0501236059,
0.0260852426,
0.0054979781,
0.0697918087,
-0.0166767426,
0.0655979887,
0.017753249,
0.0411959328,
0.0663764924,
0.0188261736,
0.035252396,
0.0847436339,
0.0019762658,
0.0130648809,
-0.0071353302,
0.0132051194,
0.0356524177,
0.0695459023,
0.0083802622,
0.0141950632,
-0.0052048974,
-0.0486825146,
-0.0558858924,
0.0483127721,
0.022254426,
-0.0298448578,
0.032210391,
0.0116224224,
0.0094538974,
-0.029090276,
-0.0364926867,
-0.0480532311,
-0.0114169177,
-0.0107842684,
0.0100004692,
0.0144414213,
-0.0310333241,
-0.0833703205,
0.0266250502,
-0.0108406777,
-0.0353212506,
0.0250918474,
-0.0427747704,
0.0206232127,
-0.0043428689,
0.040423099,
-0.0369594283,
-0.0688791424,
0.0057385578,
-0.0006642942,
-0.0175952371,
-0.0011879413,
0.0041428809,
-0.0033686506,
-0.0340417437,
0.0238125268,
-0.0157805383,
0.0060958741,
0.0077720075,
0.0162461344,
0.0243797284,
-0.0281563029,
-0.0064859027,
0.0281872097,
0.0453479886,
0.0303810015,
-0.0175564904,
-0.0287405737,
-0.0301602185,
0.0205280613,
-0.0124297692,
0.0282478817,
-0.0345466547,
-0.0008770466,
0.0712991282,
-0.0460554622,
-0.0214490518,
-0.0122802537,
2.726e-7,
0.0440052114,
0.0736503154,
0.0262110606,
0.012402853,
0.0530176498,
0.00403956,
-0.0257827491,
0.0198740661,
-0.0045701535,
0.0083668698,
0.0107539315,
-0.0068973121,
0.0526103154,
0.0226532351,
-0.0506715812,
0.0291441474,
-0.0980209112,
0.0047642384,
-0.0462720655,
0.0033892011,
0.004342047,
0.079230234,
-0.0232803691,
-0.0087842606,
0.0034029318,
-0.0433169976,
0.087097995,
-0.0400333852,
-0.0100744795,
0.0400222167,
-0.0024175125,
-0.0247511286,
-0.0108327866,
-0.0479484722,
-0.0203746594,
0.014151887,
-0.015864348,
0.046894554,
0.0268759206,
0.0125230057,
0.0529753827,
0.0206832886,
0.0084440969,
-0.0731829256,
0.0562685579,
-0.0061615319,
-0.0329593867,
-0.0357228108,
-0.0042194431,
-0.0055340771,
-0.0091152918,
-0.0594033077,
-0.0026449466,
0.0468849167,
-0.0011359608,
-0.0172446724,
0.0068820086,
-0.0148081677,
-0.0176047683,
-0.0083351238,
-0.0695221648,
-0.0600297078,
-0.0409320183,
0.042750217,
-0.0166551266,
0.0116802352,
0.0034543881,
2.862407264e-34,
0.0323653966,
-0.0357254446,
-0.0108595621,
0.001577392,
0.0452945083,
-0.0241888501,
0.0007692016,
0.0367757156,
-0.0156762097,
-0.0960251093,
-0.0412319303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09782v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09782v2 | ZeroQuant-FP: A Leap Forward in LLMs Post-Training W4A8 Quantization Using Floating-Point Formats | 2023-07-19T06:58:03 | 2023-07-20T18:47:20 | Xiaoxia Wu, Zhewei Yao, Yuxiong He | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In the complex domain of large language models (LLMs), striking a balance
between computational efficiency and maintaining model quality is a formidable
challenge. Navigating the inherent limitations of uniform quantization,
particularly when dealing with outliers, and motivated by the launch of
NVIDIA's H100 hardware, this study delves into the viability of floating-point
(FP) quantization, particularly focusing on FP8 and FP4, as a potential
solution. Our comprehensive investigation reveals that for LLMs, FP8 activation
consistently outshines its integer (INT8) equivalent, with the performance edge
becoming more noticeable in models possessing parameters beyond one billion.
For weight quantization, our findings indicate that FP4 exhibits comparable, if
not superior, performance to INT4, simplifying deployment on FP-supported
hardware like H100. To mitigate the overhead from precision alignment caused by
the disparity between weights and activations, we propose two scaling
constraints for weight quantization that negligibly impact the performance
compared to the standard W4A8 model. We additionally enhance our quantization
methods by integrating the Low Rank Compensation (LoRC) strategy, yielding
improvements especially in smaller models. The results of our investigation
emphasize the immense potential of FP quantization for LLMs, paving the way for
high-efficiency deployment in resource-limited settings. | [
-0.0641791672,
0.0693394467,
0.0113683874,
0.0414988063,
0.0047828858,
-0.0014666584,
0.0313350298,
0.0227189679,
-0.0200880971,
-0.0450090356,
-0.0141703626,
-0.0738576427,
0.0047972105,
-0.0074524898,
0.0361308753,
-0.0008952022,
0.0548224039,
-0.0324300006,
-0.0048218747,
-0.0257782955,
-0.0123804351,
-0.0212548226,
0.0011948455,
0.0188082699,
-0.0108113717,
-0.0161881633,
-0.007242084,
0.0202758871,
0.0087615317,
-0.033412274,
-0.0093468828,
0.0588139184,
0.0522686541,
0.0572848916,
0.0000020709,
-0.0215731934,
-0.0179850757,
0.017541999,
-0.0366472974,
0.0508353561,
0.0269385409,
-0.0135844462,
-0.0452159867,
0.0095490739,
-0.0014404769,
-0.0158979036,
0.0710678846,
-0.0083250934,
0.0450899638,
0.0534388348,
-0.0090694642,
-0.0479306765,
0.0521196648,
-0.0067841061,
-0.012502376,
-0.0338711664,
0.0213497821,
0.0330268443,
-0.0319181867,
-0.0160136595,
-0.0211245567,
0.0041503916,
0.0075119147,
0.0084341317,
-0.0156818926,
0.0340842456,
-0.0667015761,
-0.0068173623,
-0.0285694227,
0.0502334498,
-0.0819597915,
-0.0337634012,
-0.0137725351,
0.0093883779,
-0.0438188016,
-0.117377013,
-0.0422446206,
0.053654328,
0.0604259931,
0.0460138544,
0.0047591054,
-0.01135715,
0.0540269986,
0.0043164957,
-0.042163875,
0.0628736243,
0.0342751369,
-0.0085253948,
-0.0195438284,
-0.0097176181,
-0.1309512705,
-0.050669495,
-0.0001523658,
0.0102098761,
0.0102780629,
-0.0085834293,
-0.0748379454,
-0.0026906945,
0.0098633571,
-0.0540141463,
0.028198,
0.085685052,
-0.0032807174,
0.0057050004,
-0.0323663577,
0.0672154725,
-0.0304358881,
0.0233547501,
-0.0318461955,
0.0390818976,
-0.0032356449,
0.0041730003,
-0.0077924929,
0.053454604,
-0.0601241663,
-0.0256303921,
-0.0502830744,
-0.0175899398,
-0.0120573537,
-0.0234986749,
0.0039048854,
0.0042225569,
-0.0147515927,
-0.0005149873,
0.0252892785,
0.0600517169,
0.0209959708,
-0.0047981152,
-0.0057368279,
-0.0529311597,
-0.0070471284,
0.0257040095,
-0.0148238381,
-0.0344224572,
0.0497839116,
0.0015073937,
0.0060974774,
-0.0422913544,
0.0055552809,
0.0188145749,
-0.0218969993,
-0.0458173715,
-0.0240100436,
-0.0588059425,
-0.0139190247,
0.0079868361,
0.0066147572,
-0.0143526299,
0.0364275575,
0.0142481104,
0.0217252225,
0.0564490259,
-0.0544010401,
-0.0006858804,
-0.0166788772,
-0.0115709919,
0.0645425171,
0.080270566,
0.0321652889,
0.0167389866,
0.0109471567,
0.0133417081,
-0.005515541,
0.0495830514,
0.0156787038,
0.0102557205,
-0.0444815941,
-0.0299443007,
-0.0039398447,
0.0577016361,
0.1013940424,
0.0651008114,
-0.0587696061,
-0.0532860085,
0.0425260365,
0.0329266079,
0.0326087698,
0.0185177829,
-0.0111634945,
-0.0224235449,
0.0067225634,
-0.0331398435,
-0.0408465527,
0.0067875413,
-0.0071875625,
0.0091574416,
0.0673047155,
0.0581295267,
-0.0294688325,
-0.0186729133,
-0.043977689,
-0.0179028641,
-0.0058213207,
0.0079183821,
0.0185226742,
-0.0420822203,
-0.0158362407,
0.1065389439,
0.0187495351,
-0.0681767464,
-0.0268737748,
-0.0933318958,
0.001050933,
0.0428135656,
0.0313894451,
-0.0171128139,
-0.0300906226,
-0.0026295467,
0.0026133161,
0.0194198936,
-0.0145465201,
0.0207517408,
0.0432578698,
-0.0629198849,
-0.0279673692,
0.0012173268,
0.0035557849,
-0.0044309399,
0.0273593068,
-0.0062418818,
-0.0286199674,
-0.0488504581,
-0.0341368541,
0.0154141877,
0.0580560379,
-0.0579277202,
0.0272296984,
-0.0121099558,
0.0085364431,
0.0551235676,
-0.0050274045,
-0.0101610031,
0.0499207973,
-0.0365072936,
0.0358913578,
-0.0578965396,
-0.0007965242,
0.0212192982,
0.1221290454,
0.0316767208,
0.0350483879,
0.0550239533,
-0.0295406803,
-0.0453093015,
0.0148635898,
0.000428819,
0.0195359327,
-0.0459704064,
0.0348070376,
-0.0171511248,
0.0479629412,
-0.0427036211,
0.0287938248,
-0.0134162204,
0.0082258619,
0.009646574,
0.0137966052,
0.0248443764,
-0.0393005572,
-0.0507439896,
0.0039602979,
0.0194993205,
0.0503203049,
-0.0076639131,
-0.0009183019,
0.0084126685,
0.0137814041,
-0.1243498921,
0.0274492204,
-0.0445352085,
0.0184058622,
0.0486205891,
0.0218388755,
0.0140934065,
0.006774921,
-0.0446031243,
-0.0410271734,
-0.0063644424,
0.0073816325,
0.0191276465,
-0.0092984801,
-0.0096190087,
-0.0389930643,
-0.0562437959,
-0.0018299414,
0.0277448166,
-0.0399723388,
-0.0165614579,
-0.0695355758,
0.0119086551,
-0.0230841562,
0.0474746041,
0.0055599795,
-0.0276395287,
0.0190753024,
-0.0143444389,
-0.0065394393,
0.0411932059,
-0.0240925625,
0.0086624511,
0.0700916573,
0.0446846075,
-0.0330500193,
0.0264588483,
-0.0037922598,
-0.0403031074,
0.0050787493,
-0.0068848273,
-0.0439326577,
0.0687907264,
-0.0387341492,
-0.015356713,
-0.0148493135,
-0.0057125282,
0.0087451059,
-0.0204097647,
-0.023151055,
0.0297656283,
-0.0207931027,
0.0543333851,
-0.0059025725,
-0.0626229271,
-0.0074136192,
-0.0334711485,
-0.0211464018,
-0.024845399,
0.0067211781,
-0.0187139362,
0.0282468982,
0.0203474127,
0.0299671274,
-0.0480765775,
-0.016416261,
-0.0057569547,
-0.0118275303,
-0.0265995171,
-0.0405121371,
0.0499425083,
-0.0118823806,
0.0396779366,
-0.0575019307,
-0.026202146,
0.0286698975,
0.0114353066,
-0.0071928496,
0.0336156487,
-0.0145390555,
-0.0524161495,
0.0435381494,
0.0696283653,
0.0038262513,
0.0438189358,
-0.0373255424,
0.0030023179,
-0.031614203,
0.0501515344,
0.0088885045,
0.0090638408,
0.049379617,
-0.0127623668,
-0.0216890797,
0.0088321706,
0.0393579602,
0.0570612103,
-0.0866900682,
0.0022089144,
0.0646024421,
0.0123181837,
-0.0374382697,
0.0197873637,
0.0703760535,
-0.0205494836,
0.033621747,
0.0727683008,
0.0272625443,
-0.0440739356,
0.0138253635,
0.0050449111,
0.0436966419,
0.0266854148,
0.0055577289,
-0.1095587984,
-0.0207754672,
0.0212193131,
-0.0018518651,
0.0212920904,
-0.0089076525,
0.006986483,
-0.0658488423,
0.0339767225,
0.0422577634,
0.0265734475,
-0.0494997017,
-0.0164943784,
0.000860789,
-0.0381084718,
0.0745493695,
0.0424202047,
0.0019954343,
0.0005072668,
0.02332245,
-0.0158880763,
-0.0272091348,
0.0266977921,
-0.0216361266,
0.0494641028,
0.0561066903,
0.0215579551,
-0.0059954384,
-0.0254344493,
0.0054188888,
0.0065950234,
-0.0154239088,
-0.0169642661,
0.0076725478,
0.0357987396,
-0.001985498,
0.0009221415,
-0.0026969272,
-0.0042201267,
-0.0132202087,
-0.047626581,
0.0608603582,
-0.0106405234,
0.0019499697,
0.0002044764,
-0.0341263115,
-0.0188997239,
0.0245765597,
0.0093027372,
0.0000655784,
-0.072076112,
-0.0394432023,
0.026324993,
-0.0093974471,
-0.031441655,
-0.0266557839,
-0.0066934181,
-0.0280514471,
-0.0273319427,
0.0250887182,
0.012063277,
0.0303450115,
-0.0119605409,
-0.0334533714,
-0.0349426381,
-0.004044977,
-0.0773651525,
0.0069913375,
-0.04062289,
0.0468693823,
-0.0558370687,
-0.000323594,
0.0126544982,
-0.0151096461,
-0.0053943908,
0.0139598744,
-0.0907334015,
-0.0632278249,
0.0065777036,
0.0143397953,
0.026169654,
0.0332694724,
0.0024977981,
-0.0697226748,
0.0326827653,
0.0691807345,
-0.0364316441,
0.0647913516,
0.0156192631,
-0.0123749925,
-0.0062455041,
0.0281078517,
-0.0094448328,
0.0350635201,
0.0081497775,
0.0544497333,
-0.0419909991,
-0.0441836417,
0.0017334985,
0.0272139292,
0.0654086173,
-0.0089990292,
-0.0187361613,
0.0194207281,
0.0015907913,
-0.0271355808,
0.0293882284,
-0.0281257313,
0.0085887741,
0.0287982039,
0.0125119928,
-0.0189705603,
-0.0038408849,
0.024861753,
-0.0108923372,
0.0290959943,
0.01350231,
-0.0492421836,
0.0154891079,
0.0176384002,
-0.0120045058,
-0.0222390052,
0.00136483,
-0.0029581734,
0.0413204096,
-0.0173432492,
-0.0026231904,
-0.0229972992,
0.0049817744,
-0.0549721196,
0.0514002778,
-0.0233807061,
-0.0488494374,
-0.0651678294,
-0.029275611,
0.0834592357,
0.0492270663,
0.0604350902,
0.0074872728,
-0.0324361026,
-0.0086892247,
0.0101396358,
0.0157455262,
0.009878072,
0.0513139255,
0.03352613,
-0.0319165289,
0.0101059973,
0.0237419549,
-0.0108713554,
0.0145716453,
0.0230497736,
0.0047542765,
0.0028668116,
-0.0568294339,
-0.0429594181,
0.011455887,
-0.0136515219,
-0.0306328703,
-0.0221181475,
-0.0305328202,
0.0245501697,
0.0356306694,
-0.0245377328,
-0.0416895673,
0.0037627704,
0.0325166285,
-0.02052976,
-0.0532065332,
-0.0165622067,
-0.0540108904,
0.0184571389,
-0.0028985385,
-0.0048492127,
-6.18768104e-33,
-0.0169608146,
0.0464616269,
0.0173676498,
-0.0166112874,
-0.0274057221,
0.0098708263,
0.0126129212,
0.0142416451,
-0.0088564046,
-0.0350615233,
-0.0225562174,
0.0078450404,
0.0236573257,
-0.0002775479,
-0.0200610813,
0.0202734917,
0.0748135448,
-0.0345918648,
-0.0188520141,
0.0216177143,
-0.0085091954,
0.0127208605,
0.0610790811,
0.0179476961,
-0.0386383533,
0.0292250346,
-0.0157512948,
0.0035679231,
0.0149891227,
0.0179008357,
-0.0444977395,
0.0598594137,
0.0055248309,
-0.0066086468,
-0.0174192581,
-0.0324076153,
-0.0364528447,
0.0135526406,
0.0287961755,
0.0196571648,
0.0258158185,
-0.0485950261,
0.0493633784,
0.0204417259,
-0.0579052605,
-0.0481522754,
-0.0298959464,
-0.0204233173,
-0.0369952209,
-0.0404498205,
-0.0180800539,
0.0349524356,
0.0275738798,
0.0581133813,
0.0736194625,
-0.0126791811,
-0.0444104113,
-0.0228627529,
-0.0893064216,
0.0048096003,
0.0390856154,
0.0825816616,
0.0408644713,
0.0483919978,
0.0224757995,
0.0383304916,
0.0767895505,
-0.0445509516,
-0.0047444399,
0.0757239461,
0.0596770234,
0.0128071494,
0.0468806103,
0.0410342999,
0.1247793362,
-0.0071258806,
-0.0719182938,
-0.0087506939,
-0.0068636956,
-0.0296424255,
0.0133265536,
0.0483832061,
-0.0272570774,
-0.0265310518,
-0.0009739436,
-0.0089166109,
-0.0563015901,
-0.0576207601,
-0.002391868,
-0.0090059517,
-0.0176233239,
0.0275220629,
0.0264340583,
-0.0322177038,
-0.0200975593,
-0.012049458,
0.010241746,
0.0577879809,
0.0109001091,
0.0169229787,
-0.021258615,
-0.0179877281,
0.0052851546,
0.0137903793,
0.0227358881,
-0.0105346665,
0.0080240574,
0.0858542845,
-0.0637932494,
-0.0211525988,
-0.0248622112,
-0.0000715342,
0.0160716362,
0.061858777,
0.0076528937,
-0.0033757882,
0.0274282005,
0.0185964424,
-0.0405609682,
0.0124233896,
-0.0290698111,
0.0159475114,
0.0166599937,
0.0424232557,
-0.0314120203,
0.0071085664,
-0.0388003364,
0.0710665956,
0.0295208655,
-0.0714368299,
-0.0595479012,
0.0134517225,
2.777e-7,
0.0562447608,
0.0216607079,
0.0223824792,
-0.0212955773,
-0.0063595506,
-0.0112320036,
-0.0045722751,
0.0083449092,
0.0077075083,
-0.0152369039,
0.010548491,
0.0101712318,
0.0149326595,
0.0036531349,
-0.0287547298,
0.0176306441,
0.0012399835,
0.0158921573,
-0.046244774,
-0.0313337594,
0.0069058719,
0.115693368,
-0.0202781986,
-0.0182785653,
0.0553208813,
0.0125880586,
0.0394922346,
-0.0168265682,
0.0354384929,
0.008368033,
0.0082593868,
-0.0046923533,
-0.00916145,
-0.0266764704,
0.0305176377,
0.0059763482,
-0.0246317312,
0.0960557386,
-0.0516396016,
-0.0257391743,
-0.0063204058,
-0.0080941385,
-0.0193767175,
-0.0628999919,
0.0594979711,
0.0001804167,
-0.0191427488,
-0.0850447789,
-0.0343429297,
-0.0275575221,
-0.0084280223,
-0.0175197758,
0.0282383822,
0.0339627936,
0.0123418346,
-0.0240585618,
-0.0005324106,
-0.0677181631,
-0.0565072484,
0.0061545935,
-0.0413237177,
-0.0423514843,
-0.0479676574,
0.0059885038,
0.006646066,
-0.0484252572,
0.0075432318,
2.956543928e-34,
0.0353578143,
-0.0263284277,
0.0601145439,
0.019636251,
-0.0151576465,
-0.0262408163,
-0.0265902933,
0.0004887664,
-0.036169,
-0.0533840396,
-0.0250160247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09744v1 | Enhancing conversational quality in language learning chatbots: An evaluation of GPT4 for ASR error correction | 2023-07-19T04:25:21 | 2023-07-19T04:25:21 | Long Mai, Julie Carson-Berndsen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The integration of natural language processing (NLP) technologies into
educational applications has shown promising results, particularly in the
language learning domain. Recently, many spoken open-domain chatbots have been
used as speaking partners, helping language learners improve their language
skills. However, one of the significant challenges is the high word-error-rate
(WER) when recognizing non-native/non-fluent speech, which interrupts
conversation flow and leads to disappointment for learners. This paper explores
the use of GPT4 for ASR error correction in conversational settings. In
addition to WER, we propose to use semantic textual similarity (STS) and next
response sensibility (NRS) metrics to evaluate the impact of error correction
models on the quality of the conversation. We find that transcriptions
corrected by GPT4 lead to higher conversation quality, despite an increase in
WER. GPT4 also outperforms standard error correction methods without the need
for in-domain training data. | [
0.048361972,
0.0110601103,
-0.0194554701,
0.007616933,
-0.0353838988,
-0.0004743978,
-0.0058000972,
-0.0144786341,
0.0414690375,
-0.0484700538,
-0.0464422442,
-0.0314729474,
0.0416571349,
0.0081151007,
-0.0026690532,
-0.0690605566,
0.0459249727,
-0.0169997085,
0.0222957265,
-0.0011699202,
0.0310192239,
0.0176151786,
-0.0467581861,
0.0741783753,
-0.0250318758,
-0.0293979868,
-0.0144394478,
0.0138314422,
0.0181320999,
-0.0101714786,
0.0381568633,
0.036294587,
-0.0008923803,
0.066695109,
0.0000017519,
-0.0396850854,
-0.0254745334,
-0.0114250975,
-0.009636187,
-0.0272525419,
0.0512835756,
0.0408161432,
-0.0301151033,
0.0793321878,
-0.047080446,
-0.0286009014,
0.0669759065,
0.0403289162,
0.0011145178,
0.0606654324,
-0.0136527121,
0.014766816,
0.031895332,
0.0258452222,
-0.0211043116,
-0.0468199141,
-0.0349321216,
0.008109156,
-0.0055791475,
0.0044346009,
-0.0327647552,
0.0274755731,
-0.0086044744,
-0.044199314,
-0.0003896876,
0.0088537261,
-0.0238605347,
-0.0356648229,
-0.0396529213,
0.0329318382,
0.0474480204,
-0.0304956883,
-0.0238285344,
0.0138378302,
0.0179449432,
0.0111598847,
-0.0229661018,
0.0012426099,
-0.0207832512,
0.0232381541,
-0.0274993498,
-0.0263682567,
-0.0274937768,
-0.0006380839,
0.0381462649,
0.0097670965,
0.0150575144,
-0.0561326705,
-0.0104437945,
0.0088684745,
0.0131522464,
-0.0200600009,
0.0541888215,
0.0051118005,
-0.0545480512,
0.0269886367,
-0.0548060499,
0.0048427125,
0.0109146936,
-0.0130655598,
-0.0295483321,
0.0710737035,
-0.0042838124,
0.0030319525,
0.0036226339,
0.0808728635,
0.0670187697,
0.0031045075,
-0.0063494942,
-0.0179104712,
-0.0676640719,
-0.0047776699,
-0.0340625346,
0.0470200591,
-0.022144774,
-0.0242041722,
-0.0647623092,
0.0298858285,
-0.0014473158,
0.0112163844,
0.0068937559,
-0.0182408001,
-0.0340735987,
0.0100066317,
-0.0339081809,
0.0550994389,
0.032994315,
0.0022232281,
-0.0067453329,
-0.1192653179,
0.0061815307,
0.0164995231,
0.0398769043,
-0.0162895247,
-0.0224358421,
0.0370822102,
-0.0119784521,
-0.0636463314,
-0.0020541076,
0.0196438599,
-0.0277586412,
-0.0394591466,
-0.0374255478,
-0.0303702895,
-0.0175174158,
0.002689102,
-0.0050000818,
-0.0311947484,
0.009644432,
0.0236297548,
0.001366946,
0.0470674671,
-0.0489846095,
0.0313750468,
0.0086968029,
-0.0077780848,
0.0107867727,
0.0331125744,
0.0371636264,
-0.0716266483,
0.0454285368,
-0.0492137447,
0.0017706156,
0.0147707192,
-0.0416169837,
-0.0394797213,
0.0090316525,
-0.0385265015,
0.0105343768,
0.0222057197,
0.0477469712,
0.0626783818,
-0.029882811,
0.0268327873,
0.0575217158,
0.0801595971,
-0.0113793407,
0.0263012834,
0.0158094652,
0.0422805622,
-0.0109356176,
0.058582738,
-0.0504792407,
-0.0051188464,
-0.0248628575,
-0.009246883,
0.0737609938,
0.0283526853,
-0.0041137263,
-0.0494852886,
-0.011041468,
-0.0225856677,
0.0354495049,
-0.0072742822,
0.0142744444,
-0.0077403923,
-0.0462540053,
-0.0034325419,
-0.0037555776,
-0.0906748176,
-0.0091238264,
-0.0521994494,
-0.0160513781,
0.0847433209,
0.0517951921,
-0.018445408,
-0.0656212196,
-0.0154849337,
-0.0507523678,
0.081239678,
0.0593132079,
0.014002583,
0.0248012003,
-0.0622599013,
-0.0124402884,
0.0325671211,
-0.0061321021,
0.0076848925,
0.0014817696,
0.0546888448,
0.022906363,
0.0043043741,
-0.0174150169,
0.0036808627,
0.001148659,
-0.014898886,
-0.0215499662,
-0.0087102512,
0.0494652651,
0.0542457215,
-0.0087889526,
-0.0175509043,
-0.0014513927,
0.0327189192,
-0.0279018674,
0.0636519939,
-0.0661552325,
-0.0479821488,
0.0752450302,
-0.0594012812,
-0.0408320427,
0.0881278813,
-0.0210515317,
-0.0435539745,
0.0514741801,
-0.0607812554,
0.0460320003,
-0.0521711223,
0.0486998931,
-0.0169755556,
0.0180809237,
-0.0009489103,
-0.0111973016,
0.0548020452,
0.0378954597,
-0.0203297716,
0.011254794,
0.0058734524,
-0.060343802,
-0.0001133519,
0.024859719,
-0.0264678728,
0.0354122892,
0.0619097836,
0.0160002373,
-0.0793203339,
0.0202953797,
-0.1076228395,
-0.0012703824,
0.0052070362,
0.0250029862,
0.015977269,
0.0190863051,
-0.0178022254,
-0.0609326549,
-0.0459005274,
0.0032630069,
0.0491898395,
-0.0010320683,
0.0129245538,
-0.0432091542,
-0.0512825102,
-0.062730521,
0.029118957,
-0.0006616766,
-0.0196607243,
0.0527220666,
-0.016890211,
-0.0708724856,
0.0511894338,
-0.0249894354,
0.0466088578,
0.0340331309,
-0.0606059693,
0.0199447963,
0.0145493923,
0.0301959887,
0.0278985258,
0.0347614102,
0.0089574996,
-0.0002229761,
-0.0135444906,
-0.0590677224,
0.0155534549,
-0.0075000706,
-0.0309780687,
-0.0090607433,
-0.0150165102,
0.003516142,
0.0137060853,
0.041712936,
-0.0013618708,
-0.0544800907,
-0.0025629797,
-0.0033345702,
-0.0149997752,
-0.0011299361,
-0.0255309343,
-0.0304523818,
0.011040912,
0.0117134303,
-0.0633766726,
0.0681457445,
-0.0377865098,
-0.028879527,
-0.0866565183,
-0.0242208671,
-0.0094990702,
-0.0093698213,
-0.0113663366,
0.024369644,
-0.0176635534,
-0.0823541135,
-0.0119882422,
0.0049922373,
0.0198815204,
-0.0564652979,
0.0527208522,
-0.054847762,
-0.0013483498,
0.0164656527,
-0.0105935223,
-0.0380385779,
0.0193428341,
-0.0163268521,
0.0065693711,
0.0378268324,
-0.0350236632,
-0.0325534903,
-0.0008023779,
0.0023050988,
0.0630863532,
-0.0050528296,
-0.0125908358,
-0.0090047019,
0.0127817895,
0.0179136489,
0.0299201682,
0.0012542972,
0.0068677408,
0.0832037032,
0.0467664264,
0.0396816544,
-0.0062819417,
-0.0335964113,
-0.0293656494,
0.0300125107,
-0.0133399405,
-0.013533663,
0.0204664133,
0.0720610395,
-0.0375995375,
-0.0218390096,
0.1415403932,
0.0278307404,
-0.030989714,
-0.0295706037,
-0.062946707,
0.0244350713,
0.0126208933,
-0.0055921329,
-0.0367452167,
-0.0311202649,
0.0236972906,
0.0395678282,
-0.0245844871,
-0.0173753873,
0.0055579259,
-0.1054259166,
0.0369776115,
0.014100112,
-0.1066998541,
-0.0646070912,
-0.0339586735,
0.0354335867,
0.0119409487,
0.0874491557,
-0.0094473595,
-0.0240109209,
-0.0015927693,
0.0262577999,
-0.0655138716,
-0.0626046136,
0.0103843249,
-0.0182615872,
0.0916121677,
0.0723124817,
0.057841897,
0.0074668792,
-0.0145316385,
0.0460891873,
-0.0080047827,
-0.0044693309,
-0.0254679285,
0.0466679558,
0.0058722328,
0.0196720418,
-0.0505771711,
0.0170976035,
0.0070132366,
0.0099967793,
0.0272354763,
0.035706915,
-0.041510433,
0.0034512826,
0.0176888555,
0.0400848128,
0.0166132748,
0.0534815863,
0.0406236574,
-0.0191348754,
-0.0361735225,
-0.0224517863,
0.0656628907,
-0.0136672398,
-0.0022697668,
0.0099836402,
-0.0138212042,
-0.0206863955,
-0.0535625257,
-0.0770715103,
0.0340372398,
-0.0380568281,
-0.0049440349,
0.0123355761,
-0.0113739222,
0.0266277883,
0.0136085795,
-0.0051819202,
-0.0266697239,
0.0153236864,
-0.1002791077,
0.0011729242,
-0.0124489674,
-0.0345603861,
-0.0007226123,
-0.000373106,
-0.0162456334,
-0.062814489,
-0.0070586302,
-0.0037667805,
0.0174708646,
0.0275629479,
-0.0059513692,
-0.037035089,
-0.0118160155,
0.0481885821,
-0.0428187959,
0.0208435301,
0.0317234322,
0.0475359224,
-0.0023041216,
0.0214211959,
-0.0020795506,
0.0012366225,
-0.0398274846,
0.0341267474,
0.0331018567,
-0.0867209211,
0.0333103202,
0.0564122461,
0.0612549409,
0.0140292747,
0.0170119274,
-0.0306951404,
0.0021619983,
-0.0152491732,
0.0416702218,
-0.0424348488,
-0.0162405539,
-0.0062414319,
0.008397772,
-0.0097808829,
-0.0154999401,
-0.1105356216,
0.0031820396,
-0.0095344782,
0.0363976955,
0.0194252878,
0.0105115855,
0.0076812375,
0.0024114158,
-0.0218607802,
-0.0199280195,
0.0409158245,
0.0203302428,
0.0241138805,
0.0801444277,
-0.0046007065,
-0.0113826692,
0.080441229,
0.0165751372,
-0.0440187305,
-0.0570201688,
-0.006362977,
0.0160740707,
0.0349982604,
0.0080595445,
0.0662354529,
-0.023914054,
0.0507364124,
-0.0409802534,
0.0525468737,
-0.0096377227,
-0.0183296315,
0.0293724574,
-0.0190694667,
0.0010165564,
0.0132695818,
0.0593426898,
-0.0450096689,
0.0251127761,
-0.0195132457,
-0.0098409299,
-0.030626772,
-0.0414332487,
0.0002632967,
0.0100983214,
-0.0089243595,
-0.0022414636,
-0.0049084327,
-0.0882152319,
-0.0244232826,
0.0154626584,
-0.0019957081,
-0.0329801254,
0.0281838141,
0.0214117672,
-0.0603041127,
-0.0129630789,
-0.035195224,
-0.0332885385,
-0.0108302962,
-0.0098863188,
-0.0271252003,
-5.795465962e-33,
-0.0449637063,
-0.0448045507,
0.0037706031,
0.0396196544,
-0.0363494828,
-0.0310995579,
-0.032349471,
-0.0003577601,
-0.0021480569,
-0.0010334847,
-0.0024896683,
0.0468190163,
0.0127544533,
0.0169836078,
0.0017094847,
0.0069403136,
0.0797421932,
0.0133968955,
0.0056346473,
0.0195705518,
0.0300049782,
0.0146853598,
0.0720321238,
-0.0526190251,
0.0297292378,
0.0153704183,
-0.0032163011,
-0.0016573126,
0.0317164958,
0.0345336609,
0.0233877152,
0.0556189902,
0.016295081,
-0.0175504982,
-0.0190228987,
0.0435508341,
-0.0297892168,
-0.064215377,
0.0100241024,
0.0454931408,
0.010131768,
-0.008955529,
0.0276213288,
-0.0424790159,
-0.0500564203,
-0.0153787239,
0.0459537432,
-0.0193557292,
0.0048966282,
0.0294679664,
-0.0514057949,
0.0280358233,
-0.0403532982,
-0.0191738009,
0.0241391324,
0.0915856957,
-0.0056591933,
-0.0431712382,
-0.0496712998,
0.0571058989,
-0.0026361728,
0.0056984397,
0.0373152196,
-0.0190780554,
-0.0062324698,
0.0180991348,
0.0440576971,
-0.0502669401,
0.0341149159,
-0.0489256196,
0.0385141931,
-0.0346111767,
0.0106899235,
0.0512075014,
0.0221150909,
-0.0258458853,
-0.0138615761,
0.0222505722,
0.005989566,
0.0448428951,
-0.0107216528,
0.0130725708,
-0.0662348494,
-0.0094518475,
-0.0376258008,
0.0451457016,
-0.0216487814,
-0.0456317402,
0.0526315495,
-0.0168726593,
0.0379506685,
-0.038104441,
0.0205921959,
-0.0182948168,
0.0033912179,
0.009853051,
-0.0076486389,
0.006542997,
-0.0333383121,
0.0267672911,
-0.0127093876,
-0.0275730081,
0.0357969962,
0.024288401,
0.0041058604,
-0.0276718028,
-0.0141741894,
0.0653614327,
-0.0864926726,
0.0166437477,
-0.0195482802,
0.0471503325,
-0.0243687723,
-0.0334690958,
0.0164787974,
-0.0258235969,
-0.0226769224,
0.056530308,
0.0028673136,
0.0012377808,
-0.0577896722,
-0.0222489107,
-0.0252103657,
-0.0281668883,
-0.0400914215,
-0.0111077372,
-0.0060984516,
-0.0258896984,
-0.0184823219,
-0.0321776941,
-0.0228850469,
-0.0296820216,
2.59e-7,
-0.0182601716,
0.06022726,
0.0121279368,
-0.010359617,
0.0079895221,
0.0241916012,
0.0078294175,
0.0117830895,
0.0409106798,
0.0725497454,
0.0165994894,
-0.0187678821,
0.065807119,
0.0251828562,
-0.0776258409,
-0.0180601217,
-0.0543886088,
-0.0095051071,
0.0113213286,
0.0415728465,
0.0796551853,
0.0279312767,
0.0010324026,
-0.0359206088,
-0.0314356647,
-0.0144513315,
0.0196028687,
-0.0336231887,
0.0097393291,
0.0168763157,
0.0354261883,
0.0057880878,
0.0254680216,
0.0468867421,
0.0024412342,
0.0143734952,
0.0078998301,
0.0171519481,
-0.0164026469,
-0.0148434853,
0.0271644667,
0.0531691127,
-0.0207124371,
-0.0508744046,
0.0206693038,
-0.0124081085,
-0.0094942078,
0.0105417212,
-0.0304945372,
-0.0385267437,
0.0202100091,
-0.0219769273,
-0.0583362691,
0.0419930443,
-0.0023993698,
0.0098303603,
-0.0110781332,
-0.0192501582,
0.0395393893,
-0.005489355,
-0.036220964,
-0.0394875556,
-0.0034611423,
0.0160162523,
0.0053765927,
-0.0158969518,
0.0281255618,
1.697027674e-34,
0.0362509042,
-0.0050782016,
0.040610604,
0.0070932796,
0.0528241917,
0.0071282992,
0.0712090507,
0.0427909717,
0.0235963613,
-0.0379814617,
-0.0180493798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10314v1 | Mood Classification of Bangla Songs Based on Lyrics | 2023-07-19T03:31:41 | 2023-07-19T03:31:41 | Maliha Mahajebin, Mohammad Rifat Ahmmad Rashid, Nafees Mansoor | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Music can evoke various emotions, and with the advancement of technology, it
has become more accessible to people. Bangla music, which portrays different
human emotions, lacks sufficient research. The authors of this article aim to
analyze Bangla songs and classify their moods based on the lyrics. To achieve
this, this research has compiled a dataset of 4000 Bangla song lyrics, genres,
and used Natural Language Processing and the Bert Algorithm to analyze the
data. Among the 4000 songs, 1513 songs are represented for the sad mood, 1362
for the romantic mood, 886 for happiness, and the rest 239 are classified as
relaxation. By embedding the lyrics of the songs, the authors have classified
the songs into four moods: Happy, Sad, Romantic, and Relaxed. This research is
crucial as it enables a multi-class classification of songs' moods, making the
music more relatable to people's emotions. The article presents the automated
result of the four moods accurately derived from the song lyrics. | [
0.0424839444,
-0.0199603755,
-0.0295722559,
0.0260854606,
-0.0307544898,
-0.0024942199,
-0.0137192355,
-0.0342007205,
0.0214899033,
-0.0053665815,
-0.0210947115,
0.0212919284,
0.0139153283,
-0.0065551787,
-0.0377894156,
-0.09243083,
-0.0175269172,
0.0673652813,
0.1102321222,
0.0490733497,
-0.0260292906,
0.0262149666,
-0.0305746775,
0.0145209525,
-0.0228246693,
0.0214220099,
-0.011342058,
0.0370320156,
-0.0225482844,
-0.0170437284,
-0.0209426489,
0.0455424488,
0.0185058285,
-0.0429894924,
0.0000016742,
-0.0387075469,
0.0012775394,
-0.014619967,
0.0488511324,
-0.0530577712,
0.0155330291,
0.0285033081,
0.0042475234,
0.0272898711,
0.0078670047,
0.0098337159,
0.0207902137,
0.0395137183,
0.0685673356,
0.1028462797,
-0.0018238608,
-0.0746084973,
-0.0309665427,
0.0187704917,
0.0454283655,
0.0182815176,
0.0249583572,
-0.0046405778,
0.0608404316,
-0.0470001921,
-0.0327138379,
-0.0123914024,
-0.0322813429,
0.0299308393,
0.0245407745,
0.0055971257,
-0.1073287278,
-0.0462109707,
0.0269807968,
-0.0185051188,
-0.0195082501,
-0.0193858426,
0.0172503982,
0.0126617495,
0.0354792289,
-0.0440691262,
-0.0001038434,
-0.0168591384,
-0.0032517321,
0.0191486515,
-0.0239654798,
0.0723141655,
-0.00625131,
-0.0060769091,
0.0347992182,
0.0082231322,
-0.0124359522,
-0.0754314214,
0.0303773507,
-0.0600406453,
0.0112596024,
0.0000562501,
0.0144909052,
-0.0126999486,
0.028358534,
0.0219775029,
-0.0326682553,
-0.0746769235,
0.0101987747,
-0.05902135,
-0.01317049,
0.0080114137,
-0.0142531544,
0.0186945889,
0.0102858478,
-0.0414696448,
0.0631284639,
-0.0421451442,
-0.0325107612,
0.0009928438,
-0.01748918,
-0.0093339887,
-0.0305123329,
0.0006536494,
0.0332417451,
-0.0280619878,
-0.0997721255,
-0.0053249281,
-0.0159244761,
-0.0085785305,
-0.0083091687,
-0.006095048,
0.03418855,
0.009908095,
0.049425669,
-0.0078596426,
-0.0511149652,
0.0206932034,
-0.0158358831,
-0.019836463,
0.0786846951,
0.0110094883,
0.018840719,
-0.0030490498,
0.0659050345,
0.0451118127,
0.0747000352,
-0.0491379313,
-0.1115930304,
-0.013490878,
-0.020850135,
-0.042975761,
-0.0390845202,
-0.0509815924,
0.0285287295,
0.0121244555,
-0.0281429496,
0.0212809369,
0.0241653137,
0.0051397127,
-0.011175219,
0.0354698226,
-0.0035792871,
0.0091124168,
0.0238484219,
0.0000608152,
0.022240987,
-0.0062820236,
0.0278924275,
0.0364147127,
0.0415650569,
-0.0429649651,
0.0522637144,
-0.0095825531,
-0.0203040577,
-0.0561423227,
-0.0221669115,
-0.0401698127,
-0.0467317291,
0.0677241087,
-0.0415971912,
0.0012868714,
0.0347802043,
0.035578113,
0.0115849823,
0.0437887907,
0.0254319031,
0.1124124154,
-0.0541317686,
0.027538782,
0.0648658648,
0.0147894695,
0.0053596748,
0.0462473482,
-0.0062436559,
-0.0029854425,
0.0408214517,
0.0260150786,
0.0104362136,
0.0039467677,
-0.0636517256,
-0.0093370434,
0.0211048201,
-0.0360537469,
0.0203555375,
-0.0110939173,
-0.0057404642,
0.0317381322,
0.0378727838,
-0.0627353042,
-0.0537892133,
0.0164429136,
0.0584473349,
0.0352311879,
-0.0006301333,
-0.0468897261,
0.0159585234,
-0.0356306806,
-0.0224698875,
0.0015623202,
-0.0417059958,
0.0039683869,
-0.0425456949,
-0.0164492726,
0.0424691364,
0.0188195761,
-0.0038741557,
0.0011796819,
-0.065388307,
0.0418337621,
-0.0133683635,
0.0186464284,
0.0052561709,
-0.013011096,
0.0486727767,
-0.0157983173,
0.0568433776,
0.0399786234,
0.0161316339,
0.0676269531,
-0.0433729626,
-0.0106943352,
0.0157044902,
0.0167450737,
0.0152187888,
0.0509974509,
0.0229349658,
-0.0470619425,
-0.0045864321,
-0.0273206979,
0.0416954197,
0.0073515428,
0.0016002312,
-0.055017557,
0.0682252944,
0.0031569104,
0.0207355097,
0.0156078879,
0.0513351746,
-0.0566480197,
0.0172643326,
0.0417589843,
-0.0114556216,
0.0251125284,
0.01071053,
-0.036241211,
0.0019078213,
0.0700188279,
-0.0050630928,
-0.0403198376,
0.0667377934,
0.0196410492,
0.0361291207,
-0.0129957078,
-0.0171361826,
-0.0515046343,
-0.0478405729,
-0.100902535,
-0.0155854588,
-0.0116830999,
-0.0482017137,
-0.0034307004,
0.0174365491,
-0.0308655165,
-0.0545817055,
-0.0035027794,
0.0234084092,
0.0177228693,
0.0012814809,
0.0026648748,
-0.0107107768,
-0.0343036056,
-0.0224325415,
-0.0073766783,
-0.0291171391,
-0.0190528762,
0.018579198,
-0.0097083515,
0.0217557102,
-0.032523185,
-0.040279001,
-0.032723695,
0.0457576737,
-0.0495024659,
-0.0245003514,
-0.0341058187,
0.0235315561,
0.0549241379,
0.0084943976,
-0.0058354936,
0.0161967222,
-0.0056478283,
0.0269909631,
0.0136252372,
0.0241100155,
0.0688975975,
0.0088539151,
-0.0475545414,
0.0035199095,
0.0001388734,
0.0486395583,
-0.0203004442,
0.0187264252,
-0.0125761293,
-0.0024878324,
0.0641550347,
-0.0362049751,
0.0591685697,
-0.0066652955,
0.0174066536,
0.0555210188,
-0.0237386432,
0.0391040072,
0.0231348611,
0.0096806213,
-0.103526853,
-0.0307599138,
-0.015065602,
0.0133513194,
-0.0764961839,
0.0040916521,
0.0138116544,
-0.0129030272,
-0.0023002822,
-0.0383754149,
-0.0088657318,
-0.0375005715,
-0.0446006507,
-0.0130375512,
-0.0266722217,
0.0194555223,
0.0113723362,
0.0153381359,
-0.0465763882,
-0.0124914832,
0.0068599083,
0.0081573986,
0.0113720866,
0.0382390171,
-0.0377157591,
-0.0118137654,
-0.0619461536,
0.0062676538,
-0.0013490937,
0.0468211286,
0.0192771386,
0.0188841876,
-0.0413929708,
0.0137765482,
0.0406340882,
-0.0066166148,
-0.0507572554,
-0.0006403488,
0.0153538585,
-0.0249549113,
-0.0126714129,
-0.0114311501,
-0.0213603675,
0.0007113824,
0.016379429,
-0.0618150048,
-0.0267004371,
0.0272065494,
0.09295775,
0.0178484675,
-0.0024136645,
-0.0178959258,
-0.0315694734,
-0.0584948808,
0.0135021014,
0.0339233764,
0.0410671569,
-0.0072991061,
0.0227940623,
0.0248597059,
0.0222678147,
0.0325444266,
-0.0030637907,
-0.0264600925,
-0.0082512954,
0.0115916785,
0.0128440633,
-0.0224809032,
-0.013378894,
-0.0281437766,
0.0116841709,
-0.0194531288,
-0.0237222668,
-0.0179362781,
0.0064295181,
0.0164509453,
-0.0196524821,
-0.0306541547,
0.0366739072,
-0.0489872508,
0.0493702739,
0.0336268879,
0.0975471064,
-0.07702443,
-0.0314367414,
-0.0619255565,
0.0203309935,
-0.013691185,
0.0300663058,
0.0133039271,
0.0423501134,
-0.0122564388,
-0.0271632858,
0.0037935865,
-0.02464059,
0.044770591,
0.0411796048,
0.03478368,
-0.0202592369,
-0.0551703833,
-0.0451003723,
0.0269372854,
0.030715216,
0.0023721501,
0.0339970104,
-0.0256887916,
0.0211402439,
0.0021422911,
-0.0127873821,
0.0025081227,
-0.0137624554,
-0.0130606387,
-0.0509163253,
-0.0404502377,
-0.0145123573,
-0.0596293323,
0.0013184932,
0.0199980959,
0.030999627,
0.0204005446,
0.0140574416,
0.0081460308,
-0.0420532152,
-0.0380322188,
0.0683350787,
0.0679045022,
-0.003443694,
-0.0448892266,
0.0237233415,
-0.009203298,
0.0142670609,
-0.108539626,
-0.0146186091,
-0.0164367612,
0.0458608195,
0.0042253309,
0.007373834,
-0.0058313189,
-0.0111762919,
-0.0323825777,
0.0255662277,
0.0113789747,
-0.0026899164,
-0.0039032584,
0.0614499487,
0.0588781275,
-0.0121857021,
0.0010494346,
-0.0259855036,
0.0148311369,
-0.0100134583,
-0.0290360861,
0.0247724596,
-0.0134093091,
-0.0048182639,
0.0052517992,
0.0052987994,
-0.0181608535,
-0.0938123688,
0.0035301743,
-0.0334342197,
0.0099648051,
-0.0449285209,
0.0106547428,
-0.0178709663,
0.0438873321,
0.0504585616,
-0.0378254093,
-0.0414155312,
0.0077005401,
-0.0888784155,
0.0130983442,
0.0594518967,
0.0832820386,
-0.0225145519,
-0.001513249,
0.0004019022,
-0.0018540984,
-0.0276826639,
0.0423152857,
-0.000286592,
0.0114492849,
0.0033827692,
0.000045744,
-0.0261761677,
-0.0227010325,
0.0633047074,
0.0413704626,
0.0446095765,
-0.0054776939,
0.0217148475,
0.0584027395,
-0.028550256,
0.0212283488,
-0.0285521783,
0.0043630064,
-0.0172980297,
0.0411790386,
-0.0490437597,
-0.0224816203,
0.0180303454,
-0.0302689616,
-0.0269456487,
-0.0265126396,
0.0051465472,
-0.0529203787,
-0.0157153066,
0.0454478636,
-0.0346990377,
-0.0174876228,
0.0650990233,
0.0491658673,
-0.0069200536,
0.0431571789,
0.0482365638,
-0.046126835,
-0.0371409692,
0.069424808,
-0.0480268523,
0.0655377284,
-0.0138237383,
0.0029431742,
0.0165035836,
0.0294965915,
0.0357747264,
-0.0518223792,
-0.0028794615,
-0.0634046495,
0.0235614125,
-0.0143204583,
-4.911942e-33,
-0.0119587984,
-0.0201809444,
-0.0614476427,
0.0077103153,
-0.01468255,
-0.0338963233,
-0.012638499,
0.0201066583,
-0.0048667765,
0.0300255734,
-0.0283416808,
0.0368233249,
-0.012870796,
0.0006894516,
0.0931280181,
-0.018783085,
-0.0075511029,
-0.0212676562,
-0.033151824,
-0.0044381674,
0.0653406382,
0.0833516866,
0.0446547642,
-0.1071509048,
0.0101183048,
-0.0057506268,
-0.018997822,
-0.0070512146,
0.0371362083,
0.0161990672,
0.0023573616,
0.0498729423,
0.0125408294,
0.0561080426,
-0.0236759298,
0.0049668057,
0.0091757281,
-0.0379562676,
-0.0273317788,
0.0818441957,
0.0025679721,
0.0141347768,
0.006309533,
-0.0002444776,
-0.0183451734,
0.0310214385,
0.0253862664,
-0.0278876778,
-0.0115107149,
-0.0748967826,
-0.0227499176,
-0.0006844502,
-0.0173532125,
-0.0335798562,
0.0354160257,
-0.0053188419,
-0.0014641799,
0.0104501238,
0.0077099903,
-0.0169217773,
0.0036886169,
-0.0171401743,
-0.006390098,
-0.017493654,
0.0000383763,
0.0225671958,
0.0257253591,
-0.0703992099,
0.010582014,
0.06349428,
0.020561289,
0.0380706564,
0.0042175124,
-0.0054346113,
0.0487855263,
-0.0524461456,
0.0323741697,
0.0422037728,
0.0835647061,
-0.0148403328,
0.0263879914,
0.0424111411,
-0.0613417365,
-0.0170487072,
0.088103734,
-0.0245289262,
-0.0137612801,
-0.0530835167,
0.0057795313,
-0.0302931555,
-0.0201241113,
-0.0246945545,
-0.0282781702,
-0.0489360988,
-0.0014357578,
0.0112274652,
-0.0620321967,
0.0364449807,
0.0262425821,
0.0101014124,
-0.022809783,
-0.0033398711,
0.0390049182,
0.0366980098,
0.0316055827,
-0.0048122271,
0.0119928364,
0.061897926,
-0.0573669039,
-0.0189307462,
0.0050525903,
-0.0244284365,
0.0197638981,
0.0155065991,
-0.0241628736,
0.0002726039,
0.0030376513,
-0.0014597501,
0.0261336509,
0.08920338,
-0.0108506167,
-0.0383248404,
-0.0168123804,
-0.0004415728,
0.0141922766,
-0.0075051426,
-0.0210187901,
-0.0668624267,
-0.0315273032,
0.0060228575,
0.0105902208,
-0.0351657122,
2.644e-7,
-0.0302898865,
0.0372221991,
-0.000521748,
-0.0096205352,
0.0107862735,
0.0668527633,
-0.0912760273,
-0.0031641524,
0.0048170998,
0.0225350559,
0.0441342443,
-0.0880418196,
0.0264326669,
0.0413234867,
-0.1196309105,
0.0068635778,
-0.0207967609,
-0.0338172354,
-0.0591954999,
-0.0095278956,
0.0748782381,
0.0717823654,
0.0407705531,
0.0007295925,
-0.0082750656,
0.0382848382,
-0.0180369224,
-0.021442337,
0.0308555886,
-0.0417500734,
0.0208410211,
-0.0050773094,
-0.0015961597,
-0.0334916599,
-0.0214346685,
0.0308812559,
0.0419513732,
0.0124173556,
0.0085871462,
0.0210452341,
0.0161326714,
0.0347651131,
-0.0112759275,
0.0324977599,
0.0164288934,
-0.0137326485,
-0.1013738587,
-0.0113552017,
-0.0102670761,
-0.0411839709,
0.043082945,
-0.0065675275,
-0.0291157309,
-0.0438909233,
-0.0351169296,
-0.0720142201,
0.0133722955,
-0.0625441745,
0.0358300805,
0.0368070789,
-0.0221841261,
-0.0011813104,
0.0221265201,
0.044402197,
0.0500337034,
-0.0623104759,
0.0370508544,
1.900589776e-34,
0.060554307,
-0.0257814359,
-0.007602497,
-0.0008290006,
0.0201082937,
-0.0066998373,
-0.0175965857,
-0.0196270123,
-0.0016611392,
-0.0415540487,
-0.0083225975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09706v1 | RaTE: a Reproducible automatic Taxonomy Evaluation by Filling the Gap | 2023-07-19T01:37:31 | 2023-07-19T01:37:31 | Tianjian Gao, Phillipe Langlais | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Taxonomies are an essential knowledge representation, yet most studies on
automatic taxonomy construction (ATC) resort to manual evaluation to score
proposed algorithms. We argue that automatic taxonomy evaluation (ATE) is just
as important as taxonomy construction. We propose RaTE, an automatic label-free
taxonomy scoring procedure, which relies on a large pre-trained language model.
We apply our evaluation procedure to three state-of-the-art ATC algorithms with
which we built seven taxonomies from the Yelp domain, and show that 1) RaTE
correlates well with human judgments and 2) artificially degrading a taxonomy
leads to decreasing RaTE score. | [
0.0333827436,
0.0535218455,
-0.0169383176,
0.0021741525,
-0.0152620971,
0.0136214476,
0.003803577,
0.032185778,
0.0014294393,
-0.1119501889,
-0.0821911618,
-0.0096338,
0.0082763368,
0.0623094514,
-0.0100740138,
0.0058186003,
0.0232525803,
-0.0058862893,
0.0168539286,
0.0074794102,
-0.003273333,
0.0155970082,
-0.0014244789,
0.0275063999,
-0.025308257,
-0.01159102,
0.0128838634,
-0.0136571862,
-0.0124639412,
-0.0430074669,
0.0062976633,
0.0665633678,
-0.02970374,
0.0764788836,
0.000001705,
-0.0489874706,
-0.0047266115,
-0.0130136022,
0.0296091121,
0.006987269,
0.0604222454,
0.0222520307,
0.0524836816,
-0.0130313858,
-0.039679423,
-0.0594160631,
0.0062298691,
-0.0111972457,
0.0453674421,
0.0214637686,
-0.0064272531,
-0.0983109251,
-0.0515196174,
0.0001568421,
0.0018537367,
-0.0334911719,
0.0002825811,
0.0368858874,
-0.0038641067,
0.0125889946,
-0.0161745194,
-0.0019220978,
0.0002752504,
-0.0225290935,
0.0506593846,
0.0413207114,
-0.0200524163,
-0.0412501097,
0.008379125,
0.0929382145,
-0.0075627668,
-0.0240047462,
-0.0143962437,
-0.0066723586,
0.0144497938,
-0.0017333686,
0.0012719315,
0.0051373043,
0.0072992723,
-0.0108435666,
0.0138183916,
0.0347029753,
0.0424662344,
0.0244356934,
0.0328586958,
0.1136877984,
0.0238720309,
-0.0219600815,
0.0286635626,
0.0276492424,
-0.0436108671,
-0.0529514104,
-0.0028382984,
0.0149319796,
-0.0200873688,
0.0403192677,
0.0007963467,
0.0648972169,
0.0675232783,
-0.0451565869,
-0.0145910177,
-0.0010448688,
0.0398039296,
0.052968815,
-0.0061970926,
0.0032376782,
0.0366638005,
0.0175640248,
-0.0407052301,
0.0120186927,
-0.1104051098,
0.030920295,
0.0095965154,
0.0441884287,
0.0285319053,
-0.0012959298,
-0.0584284142,
-0.0038236305,
-0.0404300727,
-0.011773658,
0.0145882722,
0.0324217491,
0.0089912843,
0.0237194281,
-0.0647933185,
-0.0496295802,
-0.050166633,
0.0310169272,
-0.0161888376,
0.0315872692,
0.0347564109,
0.0208617039,
0.0053589428,
0.0265761409,
0.0284686256,
0.0053558713,
0.0536081642,
-0.0517075025,
-0.0162808485,
-0.0222481415,
-0.0416234359,
-0.0355403721,
-0.0265306085,
-0.0780464783,
0.031304609,
0.0110773332,
0.0023540601,
-0.0214884486,
0.0054058996,
0.0248656403,
-0.0620618165,
0.0826304033,
-0.0508731492,
-0.0002769015,
0.0336731933,
0.0137446551,
-0.0105810845,
0.0544298179,
-0.0031598588,
0.0617448911,
0.0546131693,
-0.0042742235,
0.0417664275,
0.0025622239,
-0.0074447338,
-0.0157711804,
-0.0056510069,
0.0109680658,
-0.0513275117,
0.0405610539,
0.0145425703,
0.0531657115,
-0.0168729778,
0.0018161458,
0.0325000323,
0.0640191287,
0.0391563326,
0.068335861,
0.0425223596,
-0.0101154437,
-0.0286050607,
-0.0231831875,
-0.0151396384,
0.0020022241,
-0.0500361659,
-0.0035591084,
0.0146296704,
0.0087800296,
-0.0315344557,
-0.0568973012,
-0.0239039566,
-0.0075416598,
0.0137654236,
-0.0193796139,
0.0413950756,
0.0105463741,
-0.017163869,
0.0234735236,
0.0395059884,
-0.0327476896,
0.0416245162,
-0.0512589291,
0.0319533646,
0.1124306247,
0.0530862398,
-0.0140199037,
-0.0057898266,
0.0168999489,
-0.0525810532,
0.0141624352,
0.0474654846,
-0.0431225896,
-0.0412722901,
-0.0164276939,
-0.0150597254,
-0.01858408,
0.0414316431,
0.00991969,
0.034000922,
0.0440205336,
0.0393125005,
-0.0754129514,
-0.0622139387,
0.0250085611,
0.0398791507,
-0.0385995656,
0.0077036344,
-0.0088137779,
0.003747128,
0.0430826172,
-0.0078674816,
0.0070644924,
0.0428041816,
-0.0070390757,
-0.0499563999,
-0.0133875217,
-0.0135432435,
-0.0196238458,
0.0414628945,
0.0168476328,
-0.008951975,
0.0114215575,
-0.0253520217,
0.0038394507,
-0.0126800556,
0.0101348152,
0.0490596481,
-0.0451876409,
0.0404708534,
-0.0422574989,
-0.0184599031,
-0.0428861342,
0.084853068,
0.0049409093,
0.066136755,
-0.0543544032,
-0.0172807053,
0.0059875334,
0.037580587,
-0.0702628642,
-0.0355446227,
-0.018680105,
0.0536766686,
0.042756889,
0.0479640886,
-0.0832730606,
0.0092362761,
-0.1009885371,
0.0098679829,
0.0008222764,
0.0211720522,
0.0150396563,
-0.0370670408,
0.0153104058,
0.0245583002,
-0.0138790915,
0.0216974616,
-0.0153643237,
0.0217060354,
0.0113430666,
0.0152436066,
-0.048483707,
-0.0190719403,
-0.0267940369,
0.011032139,
0.0450222567,
0.0443617925,
0.040071927,
-0.0348813944,
0.0014090823,
-0.0468291529,
-0.021787433,
0.0517846458,
-0.0334455743,
-0.0148470467,
0.0055223219,
-0.0315251872,
-0.0334884524,
-0.0030274966,
0.0018879947,
0.0828678459,
0.0098217279,
-0.0486960784,
-0.0363425985,
-0.0463055186,
-0.024733901,
0.0192161929,
-0.0421403423,
0.0153363422,
0.0567442514,
-0.0207750723,
-0.0157551989,
-0.0291099846,
0.0413026698,
-0.0651666,
0.0051889075,
-0.0691791177,
0.0125343101,
-0.0116333775,
0.0461790264,
0.0104435766,
-0.0231660269,
0.0658310056,
-0.0282877032,
0.0397251137,
-0.0327670239,
0.0133634368,
-0.0115381591,
0.0606849752,
-0.0315458253,
0.0265447348,
0.0273736734,
-0.0154049462,
0.002562505,
0.0341539718,
0.0137101766,
-0.038066376,
0.0221013278,
-0.0321456008,
0.0019845511,
0.0514274612,
0.0284979213,
-0.0268652122,
-0.004274697,
-0.00915376,
0.0478573032,
0.0474604778,
0.0266414694,
0.0125691006,
0.0158269797,
-0.0356972516,
0.007726281,
0.0113211498,
-0.0349889547,
0.036071524,
0.0430375151,
0.0313318297,
-0.0015892192,
0.0019023343,
0.03807915,
-0.0080641126,
0.0223010108,
-0.0122832404,
0.0178165771,
-0.0170371961,
-0.0176715814,
0.0334768929,
-0.0733745918,
-0.000510536,
-0.0041310517,
-0.066287674,
0.0110096782,
-0.0206657089,
0.121962525,
0.0922787711,
-0.0775582492,
-0.001751755,
0.0175525267,
-0.0076888008,
0.045382686,
-0.010377015,
-0.0560083315,
0.0003971166,
-0.0212811735,
0.0182391107,
0.0142030232,
-0.0253044777,
0.0121101253,
-0.0739449188,
0.0022547378,
-0.0217628404,
-0.0207277536,
-0.0045401189,
-0.0701089576,
-0.0066344631,
-0.0235799905,
-0.0311451089,
0.0036991378,
0.0047859806,
0.0372805968,
0.0032841242,
-0.039765723,
-0.0227214713,
0.1087026596,
-0.0294240359,
0.0459395573,
0.049038481,
0.0623215996,
-0.0380487032,
-0.059332937,
0.0336935259,
-0.030539969,
-0.0292179883,
-0.0111285048,
0.0385658443,
-0.0056939898,
0.0133810453,
0.0041491049,
-0.0671513528,
-0.0633049533,
0.0246968903,
0.0111559518,
0.0489428937,
0.0235980842,
-0.0100920266,
-0.010524082,
-0.0030431224,
-0.010191245,
0.075659126,
0.0084971674,
-0.0240544472,
0.0130036054,
-0.0148513187,
-0.0346534699,
-0.0260231178,
-0.0550171696,
0.0382926911,
-0.0402177908,
-0.1019157469,
-0.0804338306,
-0.062810421,
0.028657034,
0.009824777,
0.0074769487,
-0.0176751912,
-0.0136609171,
0.024754256,
-0.0562375933,
0.0334867872,
0.0049996502,
-0.024558451,
-0.0434393585,
-0.0391546041,
0.0333352461,
-0.001793367,
-0.0306152664,
0.015928207,
0.0233651716,
-0.0148113156,
0.0341638848,
0.0378106646,
0.0144883804,
-0.0166528486,
-0.0513347685,
-0.028309999,
0.0654968992,
0.0153591353,
-0.0701806098,
-0.0103527885,
0.0104862293,
0.0336581059,
0.0121860318,
0.0462763645,
-0.0668968931,
0.0317529403,
-0.0178639777,
0.0580255613,
-0.0155093102,
-0.0104872379,
0.0350770652,
0.0302885715,
0.0398961268,
-0.0779193714,
-0.014482799,
0.0086159538,
-0.0365563184,
-0.0097446153,
-0.0444794707,
0.0010261635,
-0.001851102,
0.0652773604,
0.004500499,
-0.0281556994,
0.0402500704,
-0.0428549312,
0.0299354549,
-0.0157651044,
-0.0531813763,
0.0338434875,
-0.0063283043,
-0.0185876582,
-0.0087443003,
-0.0397784412,
-0.0625544414,
-0.0262450762,
-0.0170062818,
-0.0422270037,
0.0163636766,
-0.0149848796,
-0.0096699297,
-0.0460492484,
0.0571665652,
0.0264840145,
-0.0447640084,
-0.0270663034,
0.034164533,
0.0303166136,
0.0197879225,
0.0210811123,
-0.0207133722,
-0.0331139751,
0.0000505439,
0.0173607096,
-0.013910763,
-0.0280862432,
0.004339837,
0.0095287068,
-0.0115899025,
-0.0276304223,
0.0689024478,
0.0194023252,
-0.0050582136,
-0.0041666734,
-0.0807078183,
-0.0080775712,
0.0094201453,
-0.0605089106,
0.0287347231,
-0.0309537128,
0.0077857482,
-0.076120235,
-0.0710915849,
-0.002238814,
0.0126214689,
0.033683423,
0.0624027736,
0.0664529577,
0.0844808668,
-0.0049257036,
0.0196035579,
-0.0469027944,
-0.0059154155,
-0.0287810899,
-0.0023550889,
-0.0019563374,
-6.298060694e-33,
-0.006831618,
-0.1050093696,
0.0069243265,
0.016120242,
0.0318786465,
0.0130147878,
0.0087586166,
0.0471755229,
0.0320346132,
0.0399091691,
0.032219924,
0.0218469314,
-0.0093643675,
-0.028375743,
0.0491157174,
-0.0227411427,
-0.0064066676,
-0.0157914422,
-0.0291118603,
0.0124124549,
0.0154557703,
0.0333139002,
0.0332562439,
-0.0444641858,
0.0584184527,
0.0159549434,
-0.0308699366,
-0.0278042499,
0.0026883008,
0.0366588421,
-0.0297211166,
0.1007726267,
0.0292665567,
-0.008988779,
0.0498594157,
-0.0232579391,
-0.042185314,
-0.0056516514,
0.0106380647,
-0.005423028,
0.0102238581,
0.0069553265,
-0.0009623828,
0.0283206273,
-0.0245724935,
0.0217827465,
0.0529260002,
-0.0137852458,
-0.0077879806,
-0.0772240758,
-0.0430103354,
0.0244707298,
0.0326990224,
-0.061975576,
0.0507168844,
-0.0126045095,
-0.0013638585,
0.0308281053,
-0.0275990404,
0.0197171643,
-0.0285509024,
0.0176356938,
0.0894704759,
-0.0122967483,
-0.0174984131,
0.054355152,
-0.0301117133,
0.0387396961,
0.0244806949,
-0.0168095995,
0.0186220203,
0.0095220786,
0.0136297401,
0.0069834176,
0.0278791245,
-0.0488579012,
-0.0006247486,
0.0461098962,
-0.0175977554,
-0.0337733291,
-0.0094623398,
0.0103955911,
-0.0377386287,
-0.0115946876,
-0.0107468646,
0.0141535355,
-0.0823054463,
-0.0277623311,
0.0052601136,
0.0179830249,
-0.0133150816,
-0.001434811,
-0.0472563691,
-0.0165387634,
-0.0478294343,
-0.0192796513,
0.0047180578,
-0.0048850947,
-0.021577863,
-0.003421078,
-0.0474839248,
-0.0309015382,
-0.005751628,
-0.0020963419,
0.003044703,
-0.0114219086,
0.039870318,
0.007785955,
-0.0257024057,
-0.0009557901,
-0.0071106819,
-0.0294312593,
0.0061486396,
-0.0477422029,
-0.0131436232,
0.0369517691,
-0.0217008572,
0.0429271683,
0.0715956166,
0.0342590101,
-0.0207435843,
0.0051028347,
0.0122806327,
0.0097920615,
-0.0407193266,
-0.0301753096,
0.0251953118,
-0.0280934125,
-0.0259617809,
-0.0180328768,
-0.0395707451,
-0.0472652167,
2.513e-7,
0.0838090554,
0.0596988238,
-0.0678326264,
-0.0156059787,
0.0013786573,
0.0300998576,
0.0342862718,
0.0329339169,
-0.0328448229,
-0.0301978942,
-0.0218972638,
-0.0088871671,
-0.009918225,
0.0597886667,
-0.0421531014,
-0.0046937503,
-0.0132286195,
-0.0263997614,
-0.0257814713,
-0.0163278691,
0.0367614664,
0.0153660085,
0.0228602141,
-0.0115069589,
-0.0478132181,
-0.0269119907,
0.0220089778,
-0.0228173099,
-0.0329401009,
0.0635956898,
0.0498648733,
0.0420905612,
-0.006812131,
0.0113125518,
-0.0358096622,
-0.0066085211,
0.0340858437,
0.0000842029,
-0.0305123534,
-0.0474601276,
-0.0114693735,
-0.0347176716,
0.0380549617,
-0.0922801197,
0.0339631215,
-0.0213744417,
0.0151100513,
0.0014308491,
-0.0419764891,
0.0515351072,
0.0324718766,
-0.0456191525,
-0.0184991378,
0.0224298108,
-0.0035651899,
0.0087204697,
-0.0286459327,
-0.0840386227,
0.0027976506,
0.0478646867,
-0.0173917413,
-0.0589941293,
0.0035949801,
-0.0176295433,
-0.0164116565,
-0.0409244075,
0.0203976519,
1.719966345e-34,
0.037661992,
0.0345345698,
0.0147519978,
0.0256564785,
0.0280724261,
-0.0131699471,
0.0129959928,
0.0012652627,
-0.0104362452,
-0.0167523883,
0.0263275746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09705v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09705v1 | CValues: Measuring the Values of Chinese Large Language Models from Safety to Responsibility | 2023-07-19T01:22:40 | 2023-07-19T01:22:40 | Guohai Xu, Jiayi Liu, Ming Yan, Haotian Xu, Jinghui Si, Zhuoran Zhou, Peng Yi, Xing Gao, Jitao Sang, Rong Zhang, Ji Zhang, Chao Peng, Fei Huang, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rapid evolution of large language models (LLMs), there is a growing
concern that they may pose risks or have negative social impacts. Therefore,
evaluation of human values alignment is becoming increasingly important.
Previous work mainly focuses on assessing the performance of LLMs on certain
knowledge and reasoning abilities, while neglecting the alignment to human
values, especially in a Chinese context. In this paper, we present CValues, the
first Chinese human values evaluation benchmark to measure the alignment
ability of LLMs in terms of both safety and responsibility criteria. As a
result, we have manually collected adversarial safety prompts across 10
scenarios and induced responsibility prompts from 8 domains by professional
experts. To provide a comprehensive values evaluation of Chinese LLMs, we not
only conduct human evaluation for reliable comparison, but also construct
multi-choice prompts for automatic evaluation. Our findings suggest that while
most Chinese LLMs perform well in terms of safety, there is considerable room
for improvement in terms of responsibility. Moreover, both the automatic and
human evaluation are important for assessing the human values alignment in
different aspects. The benchmark and code is available on ModelScope and
Github. | [
0.0161698349,
0.0449985899,
-0.0113540804,
0.0311223492,
-0.03663674,
0.0120595638,
0.0076219076,
-0.0206699986,
0.0109980451,
-0.0109240692,
-0.0300303306,
-0.0471993759,
-0.0092865201,
0.0009680729,
0.0221979171,
-0.0499557592,
0.0655939206,
-0.0217953753,
0.0192670524,
-0.0149449147,
0.0229610801,
-0.0104159983,
0.003708241,
0.0364041999,
0.012624546,
-0.013921598,
-0.0022930412,
0.0070687234,
0.1004008576,
-0.0275999382,
0.0137659153,
0.0456977487,
-0.0036509172,
0.0496805422,
0.0000020243,
-0.0724636018,
-0.0050845374,
0.0086058471,
0.0096575748,
0.0253217872,
0.0667074472,
-0.0042524673,
-0.059495233,
0.0219477378,
-0.0558540486,
0.0039074002,
0.0320211761,
0.053938821,
0.0674419552,
0.0823036283,
0.0020823909,
0.0018854284,
0.0199901722,
-0.0069246152,
-0.0301978998,
-0.0873462483,
0.0225620233,
0.056775637,
-0.029384939,
0.0084575675,
0.0036455754,
0.0243600048,
0.0328030139,
-0.0174773838,
-0.0453494005,
-0.0048432294,
-0.0132091865,
-0.0232460164,
-0.0135379387,
0.0898795426,
-0.0168857574,
-0.0119792828,
-0.0046846657,
-0.0203572549,
0.007704685,
-0.0066852099,
0.0031715648,
0.0312609859,
-0.0021292379,
-0.00406919,
0.0050771316,
0.0205689911,
0.0328681879,
0.0440915003,
0.0252275951,
0.0451636277,
0.0130530791,
-0.0274257381,
0.0253136531,
-0.0199271105,
-0.0182828829,
-0.0508238077,
0.0027917158,
0.0184771772,
-0.0651928633,
0.023342004,
-0.0419542007,
-0.0197213776,
0.0583178736,
-0.0876530111,
0.0292241499,
0.0347342379,
-0.0129920673,
0.0348369852,
-0.0010706383,
0.0721814185,
-0.0187346078,
0.0534288995,
-0.0469547063,
0.0115097705,
-0.0012910158,
-0.0026838952,
-0.0046123364,
-0.0223985501,
0.0081089009,
0.0255411137,
-0.0666136891,
0.0091154091,
-0.0557859838,
0.0422734208,
-0.0137154423,
0.0005717152,
-0.0029924675,
-0.0123702493,
-0.0232323799,
0.0181410499,
-0.052694194,
-0.0037350385,
-0.0053306483,
-0.0399533883,
0.0258094519,
0.0256468505,
-0.0278787781,
-0.0386124924,
-0.0149367303,
0.1031883135,
0.0037239885,
0.0062989509,
-0.0226314925,
-0.0038402518,
-0.0257194564,
-0.0692161247,
-0.0118738357,
-0.0430975668,
0.0029098908,
-0.0304205976,
-0.0212141182,
-0.0634647384,
0.0212187581,
0.0257007759,
0.0059873452,
0.0357565954,
0.0036364102,
0.0057397303,
-0.0008597927,
0.0335240662,
-0.0303844474,
0.0662331134,
0.0301309377,
0.0498881228,
0.0438744053,
-0.0358517729,
-0.0124913091,
0.0416009612,
-0.0012036711,
0.0178874116,
-0.0672372878,
0.0302618332,
0.0217972919,
0.0291334726,
0.0107260235,
0.075410679,
-0.0170202795,
-0.0060534277,
0.0628688484,
0.0053462661,
-0.0437101834,
-0.0043363138,
0.0249564406,
-0.0036093548,
0.0131099606,
-0.0003747103,
-0.0623556376,
0.0278028678,
-0.0819392577,
-0.008780594,
-0.0073117316,
0.043796774,
-0.0143847931,
-0.0482273288,
-0.0264327843,
-0.0048497999,
0.0658932999,
0.0223909337,
0.0146509279,
-0.0209238231,
-0.0193881374,
-0.0280865598,
0.0167020336,
-0.0653714836,
-0.0242552496,
-0.0265649129,
0.0148224384,
0.097656928,
0.0252054743,
-0.0013247161,
-0.0245042685,
-0.0196525492,
-0.0115396101,
0.0189294256,
0.0781396031,
-0.0164830927,
-0.0182132293,
-0.0480315685,
-0.0439691544,
0.0196717605,
-0.0039498252,
0.0163996778,
0.0323738419,
0.0278852582,
0.0118074417,
-0.0303984229,
-0.0890782923,
0.0382501557,
-0.0382759161,
-0.0003586613,
-0.0405801982,
0.0329025239,
0.0302934572,
0.0169379823,
-0.0177697502,
0.01100343,
0.01666997,
-0.0091120293,
-0.0241315532,
-0.0013386133,
-0.0494778156,
0.0036468254,
0.0528396219,
-0.0628659278,
-0.0653647929,
0.0511400215,
-0.0518254004,
0.0022863799,
-0.028936686,
0.0019343462,
-0.0588139258,
-0.0639258251,
0.0125378603,
-0.0430596732,
0.0188270584,
-0.0479507037,
0.0928082764,
-0.0001690011,
0.0097427648,
-0.0072992682,
0.0192322694,
0.0244793203,
-0.0411104858,
-0.0721375793,
0.0047354284,
-0.0320857018,
0.080915533,
0.0332607292,
0.0302542057,
-0.0346282087,
0.0032293235,
-0.0675869733,
-0.0042518815,
-0.0304087847,
0.0059592547,
0.0351420976,
-0.0405500568,
-0.0108495811,
0.0118203126,
-0.0413243733,
-0.0058468822,
-0.0070815538,
0.0183399897,
0.0327468179,
-0.0361512974,
-0.0053265318,
-0.0278525632,
0.0055299723,
-0.0192422085,
0.003903582,
0.0162130222,
0.0101544568,
-0.0439845324,
0.0415552892,
-0.0309980661,
0.0073808469,
-0.003313706,
-0.0843783394,
0.0250604339,
0.0490694344,
0.0173339639,
0.078278847,
0.0532418638,
0.0461835153,
0.0553993545,
0.0477084406,
-0.0496790074,
-0.0004027305,
0.0010481545,
-0.0240100734,
-0.0203425046,
-0.0394258685,
-0.017930124,
0.0458081551,
0.0130985091,
0.0008058898,
-0.0541142449,
0.0002625818,
-0.0560100526,
-0.0597502626,
-0.0232031718,
-0.0210738443,
-0.0442725159,
0.0396965332,
-0.0084983762,
-0.0281649008,
0.0842253417,
-0.0030674706,
0.0172945261,
-0.0173393488,
-0.0169852972,
-0.0068299435,
0.065622665,
-0.0126109011,
0.0418032929,
0.0228385441,
-0.0109518655,
-0.0776730925,
-0.006730984,
0.0370254889,
-0.0550361611,
0.022782851,
-0.0182302967,
-0.0051813489,
-0.0188085828,
-0.0250994172,
-0.0580860004,
-0.0457398593,
-0.029351538,
0.0334076248,
-0.0083945859,
-0.0054314239,
-0.0121661276,
0.0087676281,
0.0471772067,
-0.0120334821,
-0.0163670555,
0.0305956472,
-0.016046457,
-0.034263093,
0.065657258,
0.0093992297,
0.0390272029,
-0.0323251039,
0.0605046302,
0.0788951367,
0.0188170262,
0.0399704091,
-0.0284619331,
-0.0018926868,
0.0182408225,
-0.0141826468,
0.0129490877,
0.0372557156,
0.0550143942,
-0.0336512588,
0.0331009589,
0.0850210562,
-0.0040953122,
-0.0027343985,
0.0161146987,
-0.0268091764,
0.01186141,
0.0092060305,
0.0007287131,
-0.0732787549,
-0.0138926366,
0.0019971924,
0.0212176666,
-0.0113704475,
-0.0280300472,
0.0354102626,
-0.1068960577,
0.0369456559,
0.017545687,
-0.0559776425,
-0.0064123338,
0.0068592741,
0.0123020224,
-0.0280694347,
0.0854472443,
0.0060154968,
0.0129480595,
-0.0606401823,
0.014334687,
0.0018274296,
-0.0782916546,
0.0630428717,
-0.054780364,
0.0548309125,
0.1069897637,
0.0409833379,
-0.0161865931,
-0.0594065264,
-0.0110167786,
0.0242244005,
-0.0142865079,
0.0451146886,
0.0273593292,
-0.0230953041,
-0.0182071999,
-0.0224981979,
0.0139703741,
0.0069333813,
-0.0149572864,
0.0198939461,
0.0509376861,
-0.0099266516,
-0.0390333422,
-0.0243629254,
0.0237293523,
0.0163958091,
0.0908538774,
0.001887653,
-0.0630666241,
-0.0014813112,
-0.0255982801,
-0.0298899189,
-0.0388880596,
-0.0685758665,
0.0629981458,
-0.021076886,
-0.0498508178,
-0.0827433094,
-0.0465410836,
-0.0038979279,
0.0123949125,
0.0172399096,
-0.0390702486,
-0.0040221675,
0.0280791298,
-0.0285888202,
0.0101164179,
-0.0146795595,
0.0646961331,
-0.046771232,
0.0424039215,
0.0001678467,
-0.0236941651,
-0.0126886275,
0.0096288798,
-0.0276252627,
-0.0784882084,
0.0213493425,
0.0523027889,
0.0168579668,
0.0005744601,
-0.0372337326,
-0.0396398902,
0.0492900088,
0.031372413,
-0.0127689894,
0.000134038,
0.0327519514,
-0.0172544941,
-0.0068300567,
0.0173145737,
-0.0394576341,
0.0022153915,
0.0206364486,
0.0458650924,
-0.0320688523,
-0.0523121804,
0.014574497,
0.0501596108,
0.0278216079,
-0.0272038989,
-0.0096702054,
-0.0110285841,
-0.0056392821,
-0.0083362479,
-0.0648546964,
-0.0206359066,
0.0128502371,
0.0388719551,
-0.0088489456,
0.0243752021,
0.0112403054,
0.0128038218,
0.0061054081,
0.0064315288,
0.0187378451,
0.0013065233,
0.0921207219,
0.0232933164,
0.0105013549,
-0.0412658639,
0.0024975461,
0.0052259332,
0.0320597701,
0.0098693203,
0.073371537,
0.032781072,
0.0280010924,
0.0248757973,
0.0426004902,
-0.0553211421,
-0.0640500188,
-0.0283223875,
0.0017087925,
0.0444448516,
0.0326925367,
0.0488724485,
-0.0325997025,
0.0038979154,
-0.0410700329,
0.0026865171,
-0.0020866692,
-0.0601330325,
0.0310590621,
0.0217789952,
-0.0180926919,
-0.0222597569,
0.0515119694,
0.0028487679,
0.0211055093,
-0.0051647709,
0.0012063637,
-0.0272661056,
-0.0426002219,
0.0432006493,
-0.0322987586,
-0.0477172025,
-0.0342262909,
-0.0959830359,
-0.0837576613,
-0.0257907063,
0.0558948703,
-0.0278823674,
0.0026327821,
0.0065669362,
0.0461053029,
-0.0145584913,
0.0215259083,
-0.0374204703,
-0.0136521831,
-0.0224304497,
0.0067541986,
-0.031108994,
-6.481643524e-33,
-0.0267124027,
-0.0480777808,
-0.0037174439,
-0.0710551515,
-0.0269175097,
-0.0261197146,
-0.0256687608,
0.0214758534,
-0.0607946962,
0.0215231199,
0.0003480233,
-0.0118415561,
0.0061104274,
-0.0053967633,
-0.0012342738,
-0.0491267964,
-0.0055953767,
-0.0098277954,
-0.0166742951,
-0.0021892255,
0.0286272075,
-0.0141041419,
0.0635986552,
-0.0756543502,
0.0640995204,
0.0162430126,
-0.0414829403,
0.0218142848,
-0.0233386476,
0.0637430996,
0.0197907351,
0.0428423211,
0.0088206725,
-0.032731317,
0.0065584509,
0.0283741243,
-0.0415520966,
-0.0260576792,
0.0358446315,
0.0097457459,
-0.0375899412,
-0.0348407067,
0.0178416856,
-0.0453307442,
-0.0071904003,
-0.011485653,
0.0367699377,
-0.0201004874,
-0.0134466309,
-0.0134922247,
-0.0587517507,
0.0217391234,
-0.0249100756,
-0.0064999713,
-0.0232723989,
0.0454443544,
0.0049864384,
-0.0029175458,
-0.0512877032,
-0.0119421193,
-0.0183370207,
-0.0192420147,
0.0819379911,
0.0080615934,
0.0079313442,
0.0804039091,
-0.0135146808,
0.0191925354,
-0.0233745407,
-0.0352799185,
0.0340420417,
0.067353867,
0.0434621088,
0.0853903964,
-0.0197794419,
-0.0300377756,
-0.0744583756,
0.0511308797,
0.0143059287,
0.0508846454,
0.0149590662,
0.0023073284,
-0.0703938007,
-0.0085187946,
-0.0213748049,
-0.0162151139,
-0.0272257868,
-0.0523926392,
0.0343844816,
-0.0372491218,
-0.0623301938,
-0.0363679156,
0.0154788699,
-0.0525216982,
0.0132955629,
0.0441073701,
-0.0004525195,
-0.0056279176,
-0.0033285909,
0.0596197024,
-0.0374198258,
-0.0154618835,
-0.0147413276,
-0.0174743216,
0.0273227002,
0.0117163975,
0.0464424714,
0.0077657695,
-0.0259365346,
0.0165746491,
-0.018342413,
-0.0082980189,
0.0154238539,
0.0147012295,
0.0389659964,
-0.0076974509,
-0.0063911001,
-0.0001127236,
0.0315522254,
-0.0092198411,
-0.0423648469,
0.011424019,
-0.010402061,
0.0246526599,
-0.0241909884,
0.0054106093,
-0.0384051353,
0.0117228664,
0.0595210306,
-0.032522656,
-0.0015265904,
0.0133212544,
2.73e-7,
0.0141826095,
0.0151699753,
0.0187001787,
0.0487001687,
-0.0133316508,
0.084247604,
-0.0260648802,
0.0537386388,
0.0124389259,
-0.0010953892,
0.0470578298,
0.0203403737,
0.0886365101,
0.0553517751,
-0.0571477935,
0.0071971393,
-0.0621920936,
-0.0142630758,
-0.0075385366,
0.0381008573,
0.0546847656,
0.0519136079,
-0.0010322991,
-0.0004350775,
0.0224592295,
-0.019639194,
0.0344376937,
-0.0237277467,
0.0183444526,
0.0275933985,
0.0177111384,
0.0178868622,
0.0039300513,
0.0125109274,
0.0217593033,
-0.0075686388,
0.0445817001,
0.0969270542,
-0.0012839737,
-0.0433008447,
-0.0326816402,
-0.0521639362,
0.0185074452,
-0.0614737794,
0.0556335449,
-0.0287383609,
-0.0247408673,
-0.0260474756,
-0.0168919377,
-0.0114330119,
0.0333029367,
-0.0054955017,
-0.0162919126,
0.0217259713,
0.0191116352,
0.0040648202,
-0.0223990176,
-0.0190476775,
-0.0309738368,
-0.0205409415,
-0.0010841473,
-0.0938079804,
0.0080512334,
0.0321158618,
-0.0080691474,
-0.0408053845,
0.0024092675,
1.978258499e-34,
0.0049688886,
-0.0317197852,
0.0063831299,
-0.0196337737,
0.0451398641,
0.0414084904,
-0.0170662906,
0.0029375998,
0.0008734618,
-0.0263555963,
-0.0244223252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09702v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09702v4 | Efficient Guided Generation for Large Language Models | 2023-07-19T01:14:49 | 2023-08-19T21:27:51 | Brandon T. Willard, Rémi Louf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this article we show how the problem of neural text generation can be
constructively reformulated in terms of transitions between the states of a
finite-state machine. This framework leads to an efficient approach to guiding
text generation with regular expressions and context-free grammars by allowing
the construction of an index over a language model's vocabulary. The approach
is model agnostic, allows one to enforce domain-specific knowledge and
constraints, and enables the construction of reliable interfaces by
guaranteeing the structure of the generated text. It adds little overhead to
the token sequence generation process and significantly outperforms existing
solutions. An implementation is provided in the open source Python library
Outlines | [
0.0059049884,
0.0784723684,
-0.009998587,
0.0046430025,
-0.0473089069,
-0.0033503745,
0.0179068409,
-0.0040248525,
0.0055338312,
-0.0798329189,
0.0346393622,
-0.0745131075,
-0.0092029199,
0.0985733494,
0.0553765669,
-0.0489952005,
0.0340848379,
-0.034943521,
-0.0013152562,
0.0213963855,
-0.0148183769,
0.0073269689,
0.0014476782,
0.055868499,
-0.0490195118,
0.0038802719,
-0.049346149,
-0.0038499436,
-0.0211914703,
-0.0530356094,
-0.0032378193,
0.0144117782,
0.0097333435,
0.0508759767,
0.0000019007,
-0.0298850387,
-0.0222280975,
0.006597077,
0.0268526133,
-0.009481186,
0.0510538071,
-0.0294609442,
-0.0165132377,
0.0466668531,
-0.0241233036,
0.0053826771,
0.0651238039,
0.0196035951,
0.0739351884,
0.0937379822,
-0.020086281,
-0.0043255123,
0.0032250541,
-0.0134768486,
-0.0426976457,
-0.0245086662,
0.0385613106,
-0.0102165993,
0.0173677057,
-0.0265021287,
0.0092169186,
0.0241416786,
0.0275558867,
-0.0412871093,
0.0063950159,
0.0330583155,
0.02513046,
-0.0450350344,
-0.0521908663,
0.0412334353,
-0.0230202843,
-0.0434467755,
0.047142908,
-0.0044218395,
-0.0033068759,
-0.0289057903,
-0.0318047814,
0.0806656927,
0.0221072938,
0.0248753112,
0.0543439463,
-0.0201805197,
0.0324882567,
0.0207023546,
-0.0346897691,
0.0346691199,
0.0686661601,
-0.0298016388,
-0.0336024053,
-0.0014505095,
0.006839802,
-0.096981898,
0.0425402969,
0.0893353373,
-0.047987923,
0.0267164279,
-0.0964751095,
-0.0509760007,
0.0096191773,
-0.0391948856,
0.0401360318,
0.0418659523,
0.0289233997,
-0.0043475796,
-0.0277799107,
0.0369780548,
-0.0142284567,
-0.0030232565,
-0.0235635825,
0.0148430914,
-0.0290335976,
-0.0372564904,
-0.0564601831,
0.0280149356,
-0.0407881364,
-0.0399607196,
-0.0512799174,
0.0524041764,
0.0322325714,
-0.0000197218,
0.001100932,
0.0033093286,
-0.0348596759,
0.0208129995,
-0.0132892374,
-0.0097909635,
0.0028479639,
-0.0128053352,
0.0362974219,
-0.0135382656,
-0.0173536874,
0.0309158005,
0.0141146574,
0.0021590064,
-0.0300671849,
0.0880388692,
-0.0193334147,
-0.0236573238,
-0.0305401627,
-0.0479006357,
0.0099439686,
-0.0499383509,
0.0223953668,
-0.0454376303,
0.0127536952,
0.0087118205,
-0.0242080409,
-0.0683164448,
0.0368313007,
0.0213280842,
0.0246815048,
-0.0170305055,
-0.0549784414,
0.0031281642,
0.0147322351,
-0.0098459832,
0.0404217802,
0.0279392842,
0.0598851368,
0.0396829136,
0.0067375782,
0.0000060063,
0.0140119791,
0.0420813374,
0.003105917,
-0.0233859066,
-0.078557238,
-0.0534605235,
0.0172146671,
0.0432111062,
0.003509531,
0.0950253531,
-0.0266537368,
0.023047436,
0.0090112081,
0.0285383537,
0.0122919017,
0.0327128619,
0.115209803,
-0.0118071688,
-0.0093155615,
0.0017107386,
0.0075818156,
0.0227713492,
-0.0074455542,
0.008211541,
0.0099194786,
0.0460457169,
-0.0057560797,
-0.0306973271,
0.0076186229,
-0.0115487399,
0.024525987,
-0.0497564934,
0.031478744,
0.0141094523,
-0.0718788356,
0.0362018496,
0.0161071979,
-0.0571926944,
0.0282359663,
-0.0554060936,
0.0387241989,
0.0724245533,
0.0534132831,
-0.0064449538,
-0.0272143614,
0.0203157049,
-0.0135877309,
0.1046427041,
0.0249409825,
-0.0114213536,
0.0104153696,
-0.0521310642,
-0.0129876602,
-0.0003165724,
0.0132473595,
0.0285088699,
-0.0080095865,
0.0071036969,
0.0583746284,
-0.0052905204,
-0.0499109253,
0.0810598955,
-0.032333035,
-0.0346073732,
0.0184024144,
-0.0129791191,
0.0194193833,
0.0017346453,
-0.0144010717,
0.0578248277,
0.0302340575,
-0.0214793906,
-0.0105401585,
-0.0094867283,
-0.0496786423,
0.0040846053,
0.0490729846,
0.0145208891,
0.0093260556,
0.0002603197,
-0.0222537648,
-0.0794271454,
0.0315266773,
-0.0462501608,
0.0566610284,
-0.0256786831,
0.0236068927,
0.0444125347,
-0.0119410139,
-0.0390161052,
0.0523708798,
0.0234800205,
-0.014826457,
0.0242634658,
0.0025465614,
0.0018227091,
-0.038374722,
0.0041494155,
-0.001965404,
-0.0153246131,
0.0064427871,
0.0298094321,
0.0450277403,
-0.0224956051,
-0.0328857452,
-0.0531762578,
-0.0100219799,
-0.0239862464,
-0.0051622489,
0.0339763425,
0.0251179896,
-0.0003571818,
0.0010982529,
-0.0381452404,
0.0103224656,
0.0527229272,
-0.0128969466,
0.0380204804,
0.0336422883,
-0.074789159,
-0.0599753335,
-0.0219422542,
-0.0158636197,
0.0385617502,
0.0539477989,
-0.0420152284,
-0.0846325383,
0.0279289968,
-0.0389765762,
0.0355620682,
0.0124300933,
-0.0231026243,
0.0252608191,
-0.033097256,
0.0534960665,
-0.0096703731,
0.0373486131,
0.0336876288,
0.0790067986,
-0.0189821534,
-0.0208461434,
0.0035848191,
-0.0501811132,
0.0304789227,
-0.0077772862,
-0.0185805745,
0.066241622,
0.0748758763,
0.0134603428,
-0.0016013866,
-0.0599362776,
0.0420063511,
-0.002177625,
-0.0287577901,
-0.0220996086,
-0.0376337692,
-0.0226898696,
0.0265730396,
-0.0128007671,
-0.0417120792,
0.0386007167,
-0.066638805,
0.0235934649,
-0.0307648033,
0.0007799764,
-0.0349062756,
0.0525073819,
0.0225553103,
0.0363296904,
0.0467630327,
-0.0168144926,
-0.0175925121,
0.0199430455,
-0.0324615128,
0.0084177377,
0.0255378447,
-0.0662519038,
0.0374862701,
-0.0049650096,
-0.0103766713,
-0.070980221,
-0.0059267301,
-0.011871228,
0.0170912426,
0.0509189926,
-0.0210398305,
0.0006412954,
0.0118840802,
0.0202825218,
0.0302803349,
-0.0249645356,
-0.002291892,
-0.0128272679,
0.0241798256,
0.0383443497,
-0.0152981644,
-0.0154974908,
-0.0391599685,
0.0190247744,
0.0246657785,
0.01726106,
0.0484485887,
-0.0316415094,
-0.0072727893,
0.011770511,
-0.0473472886,
-0.018358022,
0.0477039739,
-0.0033408257,
-0.0672104508,
-0.0542898513,
0.1312209964,
0.0355794989,
-0.0382263213,
0.043341279,
-0.020360183,
0.0236845724,
0.018912049,
0.041123651,
-0.0498747788,
-0.002839111,
0.0124525456,
0.0253553409,
-0.0213080235,
-0.0086736986,
-0.0318139344,
-0.0757757276,
0.0243885424,
0.0265089944,
-0.0369617455,
-0.0289101712,
-0.0144393994,
-0.0339785852,
0.0563551448,
-0.0192106795,
0.057524465,
-0.012161267,
0.0182343964,
0.0516197905,
0.0317151286,
-0.043050494,
-0.048591353,
-0.0127331289,
0.0466369875,
0.0847813934,
0.0369161107,
-0.0043559684,
-0.0139787262,
0.0392659195,
0.0188926049,
0.0049464335,
-0.025916487,
-0.0060692583,
0.0055056941,
-0.0388463549,
-0.0115784649,
0.0094050951,
-0.0104010403,
-0.0095641408,
-0.0046367547,
0.0428029038,
-0.0252844896,
-0.0064193583,
-0.0123639004,
-0.0296809115,
0.0415384509,
0.0282549001,
0.0489688516,
-0.0213695485,
-0.0636628345,
-0.0386498496,
-0.0243955031,
-0.0911628455,
-0.0066481247,
-0.0282289498,
0.0018970567,
-0.0032531878,
-0.1020588577,
-0.0131799281,
0.0428254046,
0.0636971816,
0.0255299751,
-0.0255939998,
0.0389387086,
-0.0388193093,
-0.0448628478,
-0.0112506105,
-0.0338536799,
0.0104860421,
-0.0839725956,
-0.0646160468,
0.0307688117,
-0.0299025923,
-0.0094395261,
0.0451605245,
-0.0261655804,
-0.0653390661,
0.0075941207,
0.0703442544,
0.0194962155,
-0.0287417341,
-0.0049981023,
-0.0168617833,
0.0403364189,
0.0393737294,
-0.0118945874,
-0.0012625862,
0.0060639651,
-0.016338421,
-0.0211107768,
0.0114846453,
-0.0399623588,
0.0127155352,
-0.0004672374,
0.0833876133,
0.0242768098,
-0.0177254044,
0.0233662575,
0.0280029289,
-0.0076051769,
-0.0522127673,
0.0176594649,
-0.032733649,
-0.0394783653,
-0.062390998,
-0.0038904233,
-0.0554068387,
0.0489293113,
-0.0070275394,
0.0227712039,
0.0053744623,
-0.0475590378,
-0.0095263487,
0.0307475142,
0.0247800648,
0.00382836,
-0.0361947902,
0.0391490906,
0.0365911648,
-0.0279112663,
-0.0192910638,
0.0167509075,
-0.0317559801,
0.016783528,
-0.0546603017,
0.0252069701,
0.0240625627,
0.029378565,
-0.0607089475,
0.0344555415,
-0.0123374341,
-0.0408856981,
-0.0370865986,
0.0042469017,
0.0769452825,
0.0264282748,
0.0483774059,
-0.0760165602,
0.0078189168,
-0.0101707084,
0.0549105667,
0.0317328833,
-0.079267852,
0.0124507109,
0.0182642415,
-0.0260738991,
-0.0344610661,
0.0946902037,
0.0421661548,
0.0199173372,
0.0320081785,
0.0010493163,
-0.0587160885,
-0.0238312036,
0.0066096568,
-0.0061266348,
-0.0274622981,
0.0006329416,
-0.0389843471,
-0.0689248964,
0.0295503065,
0.0363605134,
0.0265846774,
0.0077566695,
0.0559856705,
0.004127169,
-0.0103613073,
0.0281697325,
-0.0484925844,
0.0129125593,
-0.0121774161,
-0.0675935745,
-0.0413330272,
-5.899207012e-33,
-0.0485564247,
-0.0631700605,
0.0291760881,
-0.0245752223,
-0.0417845063,
-0.0084263217,
-0.0915510952,
0.0095828492,
0.0817146599,
-0.0170452595,
-0.0103960522,
-0.0300840456,
0.0047765095,
0.0436737426,
0.0033934233,
-0.0034800905,
0.0530747958,
-0.0085493512,
-0.0318567716,
0.0447642095,
0.0366679914,
0.0357639529,
0.0139722023,
-0.0118362447,
-0.0217246022,
0.008931892,
-0.0151523892,
-0.0149447136,
-0.0102830045,
0.0282464288,
-0.0458193347,
0.017067356,
0.0158569738,
-0.0072276276,
-0.0306797642,
0.0139289144,
0.0201738793,
-0.024567537,
-0.0050149718,
-0.0371184498,
-0.0392241962,
-0.0556194894,
0.0350014232,
-0.0256015081,
-0.0185361858,
0.078196384,
0.0120642846,
-0.0140526677,
-0.0272568036,
-0.0473462306,
-0.1050688103,
0.0046431636,
0.018102007,
-0.0220824536,
-0.011838791,
0.0058816108,
-0.0194011778,
-0.0475087091,
0.0159829147,
0.0136324223,
0.0356936753,
0.0462985933,
0.0309531372,
0.0461208783,
0.0271450281,
0.0517640412,
0.0168042351,
0.0042450875,
-0.0286302306,
0.0527921207,
0.0192569196,
0.0076147192,
0.0143812671,
-0.0041920454,
-0.0007184229,
-0.0272125956,
-0.0649164841,
0.0095073301,
-0.0068678502,
0.0194394756,
0.0419432931,
-0.0020409683,
-0.0002378284,
-0.0128595093,
-0.02586958,
-0.0022074571,
-0.0059744064,
-0.0086719068,
0.039244011,
0.0361769274,
-0.051769007,
-0.0416820273,
0.0300904177,
0.0079994267,
-0.0094556753,
0.0233609118,
-0.0115836961,
0.0148240896,
-0.0242237877,
-0.0084094107,
-0.0415362008,
-0.0669034049,
0.0306938943,
-0.0215160921,
0.020184461,
0.0061386963,
-0.0485854857,
0.0541893877,
-0.0340764038,
0.0095665734,
-0.0533317104,
0.0495032407,
0.0096357716,
0.0242853295,
0.006061669,
-0.0133522246,
-0.0066823736,
0.0125149814,
-0.0084355818,
-0.0266140811,
-0.0116016716,
-0.001516599,
0.0317507274,
0.0437329486,
-0.0655857548,
0.0028548671,
-0.0588587709,
0.0622903816,
0.0449787714,
-0.0481340885,
-0.0049245455,
0.009596996,
2.674e-7,
0.0157277435,
0.0455667637,
0.0645862371,
0.0524736568,
0.0234284122,
0.002541376,
0.0022322566,
0.017558014,
-0.0065824152,
0.0307586845,
-0.0139988707,
-0.0100163622,
0.0241735447,
0.0056572952,
-0.0714373589,
0.0371962264,
-0.0240185801,
0.0049167117,
-0.0484569967,
-0.0117604509,
0.0336189643,
0.0467836708,
-0.000739642,
-0.0033473482,
0.0016397205,
-0.0174944699,
0.0429603159,
0.0281005595,
0.0298536457,
0.0070443782,
0.034115795,
0.0235978924,
-0.0054371972,
-0.0191718806,
-0.0029398042,
0.0038407904,
-0.0284136273,
0.054607369,
-0.0045158458,
0.0025473842,
0.0357314423,
0.002852265,
0.0110351238,
-0.0195023306,
0.000119664,
-0.0316410474,
-0.0078107305,
-0.0301159658,
0.0047215861,
0.0261208285,
-0.0650306568,
-0.0361093916,
-0.0460607745,
0.0357220173,
0.0043509658,
-0.0022159144,
0.0196449235,
-0.0328577235,
-0.0180539824,
-0.0439730957,
-0.0519530363,
-0.0115693733,
-0.0595262609,
0.0298961662,
0.0159486644,
-0.0188104287,
-0.0114253312,
2.733163496e-34,
0.0152227171,
-0.0533983707,
0.007798037,
0.0383083969,
0.013397933,
0.0194491949,
-0.0000018048,
0.02649327,
0.0081026778,
-0.0791794881,
-0.0535043702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09701v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09701v1 | Efficiency Pentathlon: A Standardized Arena for Efficiency Evaluation | 2023-07-19T01:05:33 | 2023-07-19T01:05:33 | Hao Peng, Qingqing Cao, Jesse Dodge, Matthew E. Peters, Jared Fernandez, Tom Sherborne, Kyle Lo, Sam Skjonsberg, Emma Strubell, Darrell Plessas, Iz Beltagy, Evan Pete Walsh, Noah A. Smith, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Rising computational demands of modern natural language processing (NLP)
systems have increased the barrier to entry for cutting-edge research while
posing serious environmental concerns. Yet, progress on model efficiency has
been impeded by practical challenges in model evaluation and comparison. For
example, hardware is challenging to control due to disparate levels of
accessibility across different institutions. Moreover, improvements in metrics
such as FLOPs often fail to translate to progress in real-world applications.
In response, we introduce Pentathlon, a benchmark for holistic and realistic
evaluation of model efficiency. Pentathlon focuses on inference, which accounts
for a majority of the compute in a model's lifecycle. It offers a
strictly-controlled hardware platform, and is designed to mirror real-world
applications scenarios. It incorporates a suite of metrics that target
different aspects of efficiency, including latency, throughput, memory
overhead, and energy consumption. Pentathlon also comes with a software library
that can be seamlessly integrated into any codebase and enable evaluation. As a
standardized and centralized evaluation platform, Pentathlon can drastically
reduce the workload to make fair and reproducible efficiency comparisons. While
initially focused on natural language processing (NLP) models, Pentathlon is
designed to allow flexible extension to other fields. We envision Pentathlon
will stimulate algorithmic innovations in building efficient models, and foster
an increased awareness of the social and environmental implications in the
development of future-generation NLP models. | [
0.0421947874,
0.0734745935,
0.0102320667,
0.0514820516,
-0.0896562487,
0.0056371116,
-0.0027862366,
-0.0173332021,
0.0098321773,
-0.0657734498,
0.0135389715,
-0.0092177577,
0.0196299478,
0.0388336442,
0.0112972381,
-0.0618774705,
0.0758623034,
0.0051849214,
0.0011117257,
0.0321360715,
0.0038789697,
-0.0187918749,
-0.0110006155,
0.0463785604,
0.0110819582,
0.0075095226,
-0.000493924,
0.0233018845,
-0.0074035241,
-0.0255944151,
-0.0002865499,
0.050191801,
-0.0304081645,
0.0504851341,
0.0000024465,
-0.0322391018,
-0.0237644985,
0.0410959125,
-0.0353664756,
0.0553308651,
0.1107114851,
-0.0316860341,
-0.018651573,
0.0291257128,
0.010630562,
-0.0314851068,
0.0866200104,
-0.0214168131,
0.0183564909,
0.044121176,
-0.0116475578,
0.0136096179,
0.0184553452,
-0.0234619137,
-0.0587791987,
-0.0153028863,
0.0101433098,
-0.0271686129,
-0.0354311243,
-0.0176665653,
-0.0101360725,
0.0652982071,
0.0282764174,
0.0352042876,
0.010445171,
0.0109575689,
-0.0436402522,
-0.0333036371,
-0.0303127095,
0.0218143072,
-0.0118102375,
-0.0177910905,
0.0106824469,
-0.0185368992,
-0.044006303,
-0.0220235996,
-0.0363823958,
0.0191846136,
-0.0033822481,
0.0108512836,
0.0123457061,
0.0570987016,
0.0340781361,
0.0469162352,
0.0091053545,
0.0677938312,
0.0174502656,
-0.0042033084,
0.0157081001,
0.0289432909,
-0.0236447286,
-0.0573455617,
0.0273842942,
-0.011159624,
-0.0109319957,
-0.0100038946,
-0.0282858852,
-0.034468092,
0.0145890191,
-0.060815718,
0.066950947,
0.0419649705,
0.044663962,
0.0573958792,
-0.0034600613,
0.0054651801,
-0.0223331284,
-0.0354855582,
0.0082250126,
-0.0075759096,
-0.022872325,
0.0147216078,
-0.0121965939,
0.0160841849,
-0.05465886,
-0.0648058727,
-0.0450108983,
0.0157880094,
-0.024092786,
-0.0144879259,
0.0198078305,
0.0090298085,
0.0002473888,
0.0187187009,
-0.0414650775,
0.0343052074,
-0.0427075848,
-0.0077308202,
-0.0057922266,
-0.0711064115,
0.0043522161,
-0.0011591362,
-0.0008319702,
-0.0369523279,
0.0310760494,
0.092893742,
0.037859194,
-0.0335338488,
-0.0331104547,
-0.023809718,
0.023983527,
-0.0550645106,
-0.0242356397,
-0.0449474566,
0.0465970077,
0.0042494959,
0.008302724,
-0.0241295919,
0.0121866232,
0.0211729724,
-0.0396639034,
0.0555058308,
-0.0136717344,
-0.0039145127,
-0.032297913,
0.0063813189,
-0.0298855416,
0.096512787,
0.0332514457,
0.0269121621,
0.0759544298,
-0.0128013827,
-0.0309077427,
0.0577361993,
0.0191978104,
-0.0435258299,
-0.0295060407,
-0.0110798953,
-0.0173852462,
0.0189244784,
0.0238295272,
0.068327494,
-0.0115116313,
-0.0014090593,
0.0421451032,
0.0568630919,
0.0064691175,
-0.0178314373,
0.0036496196,
0.0165230837,
-0.0044276388,
-0.0538499579,
-0.0418674164,
0.0280236416,
-0.0425112657,
-0.0035559272,
0.054959286,
0.0212838594,
0.0320681334,
-0.0374956541,
-0.0388629735,
0.001905725,
0.0307463333,
-0.0160784908,
0.0231892802,
-0.0285285264,
-0.0341717713,
0.0482948832,
0.018476909,
-0.0424431488,
-0.0721106008,
-0.0676386878,
-0.0156789329,
0.0445061401,
0.0510414429,
-0.001640343,
0.0350310132,
0.0106863454,
-0.0144584747,
0.0082239881,
0.0333302841,
-0.0114078596,
0.0518451743,
-0.0249956027,
-0.0120984111,
0.0354028679,
0.0250133891,
-0.0021423497,
0.0903380662,
0.000802613,
0.0232062675,
-0.0289373957,
-0.0249552224,
0.0388056077,
0.0259777512,
-0.0126604103,
-0.0021542099,
-0.0093626305,
0.0446367711,
0.0040084301,
-0.0170022137,
0.0326322727,
0.0468296967,
-0.0312383696,
-0.0032256173,
-0.0112216203,
0.0026229389,
-0.0121933734,
0.0136166131,
-0.0111438539,
0.0099329473,
0.0713914707,
-0.0309703536,
-0.0264957622,
0.0216530673,
-0.0599438474,
0.0773454159,
-0.02535934,
-0.007066133,
-0.0232602544,
0.0056440351,
-0.0160721596,
0.0653139949,
-0.0195732191,
0.0348348133,
0.0172610991,
-0.0176478643,
0.0122371176,
-0.0040947003,
-0.0173996482,
-0.0069703795,
-0.0056776451,
-0.0256547984,
0.0407164246,
-0.0101373475,
-0.029716339,
0.0191012509,
-0.1102965176,
0.0549371429,
-0.0209860243,
0.0438040011,
0.0185798388,
0.0080288546,
0.0131322881,
0.011980732,
0.0262054224,
-0.001167596,
-0.0152279902,
0.0533637814,
0.0253862813,
-0.0251519158,
-0.049413994,
-0.0587081984,
-0.0536148846,
-0.0006986512,
0.073279202,
-0.0077572269,
-0.0228799935,
0.0005619653,
0.0038290771,
0.0134733682,
0.0154307364,
-0.0112844594,
0.0065534981,
-0.0036130631,
0.003812535,
0.030468097,
0.0412272736,
-0.014619682,
0.0133975763,
-0.0066580274,
-0.0168112479,
-0.0539362505,
0.0136735504,
0.017820064,
0.0132384524,
0.0118274232,
-0.0341484472,
-0.0113540469,
0.0666856542,
-0.0278823376,
-0.0334707461,
-0.0042151487,
0.0105879204,
-0.0335554071,
-0.047405351,
-0.0533072315,
0.000109261,
0.0129272835,
0.0136212241,
-0.0253026299,
-0.0660896897,
0.0256567486,
-0.0384465866,
-0.0159475245,
-0.0238879751,
-0.0205462929,
-0.007879761,
0.1013301834,
0.0318892822,
0.0331605077,
-0.021807041,
0.0166373327,
0.0180632528,
0.0291100983,
0.0230110139,
-0.0396702699,
0.0236152429,
-0.0536624417,
0.0284373425,
-0.041573599,
-0.0344064422,
-0.002170379,
-0.0110349357,
-0.0468283929,
0.0020042139,
0.0425090939,
-0.0377069749,
-0.0201320983,
0.0383275487,
0.018592447,
0.0451291539,
0.0109661361,
-0.0274431687,
-0.0064501162,
0.0132681029,
0.0311654601,
-0.0367667787,
0.0523180217,
0.0106267193,
-0.0251682177,
0.0868955925,
0.0429504998,
0.0311976355,
-0.0567092821,
0.0056238361,
0.0261711199,
-0.0380647518,
-0.0265402142,
0.039084699,
0.0396121182,
-0.0974063724,
0.0183125138,
0.100374721,
0.0193000194,
-0.0098152282,
0.0194533262,
0.0359980017,
0.0473901257,
0.0217953939,
-0.0025232558,
-0.0413314812,
-0.0683303997,
0.0472204573,
0.0312086139,
-0.0550122894,
-0.0504589789,
-0.0066709016,
-0.1000497639,
0.0201851167,
-0.0236587413,
-0.0229165014,
0.0062833168,
-0.1088852957,
-0.0234829802,
-0.0814662054,
-0.0243211836,
-0.010577336,
-0.0038460046,
0.0083279004,
-0.0046401792,
-0.0786988661,
-0.0202684794,
0.0280975457,
-0.0347676277,
0.0577700473,
0.034464974,
0.0145462323,
-0.0138880974,
-0.0483683161,
0.042151995,
0.0014655851,
-0.0054500061,
-0.0339660794,
0.0270497669,
-0.0147095099,
-0.0133879762,
-0.0414538421,
0.0116463751,
-0.0359988771,
0.0106881605,
-0.0321824849,
0.0746212006,
0.0309061073,
0.0147287147,
-0.0511340089,
-0.0354738347,
0.0212327186,
0.0937524661,
0.0196202621,
-0.0117909098,
-0.0850449875,
-0.0398514159,
-0.0294488221,
-0.0626248196,
-0.0406603105,
-0.0412489623,
0.0075637284,
-0.0837147012,
-0.0140974279,
0.0022935246,
0.0048353216,
0.0229666177,
-0.0107739605,
-0.0165859945,
0.017960228,
-0.000146481,
-0.1112004891,
0.028542269,
-0.0064639612,
0.0562049598,
-0.0434426777,
-0.0168210585,
0.0474074073,
0.0941064805,
-0.0463756733,
0.0842953846,
-0.1124050617,
-0.070179835,
0.0067742686,
0.0483808033,
0.0261374041,
-0.0095054572,
0.0118291164,
0.0043554297,
-0.0375800617,
0.0318121277,
-0.0239586607,
0.0167653151,
0.0330209956,
-0.0338335298,
-0.0006342274,
0.0051051071,
0.013228138,
0.0308743007,
-0.0290451739,
0.0460940748,
0.0160790365,
-0.035043925,
-0.0082323859,
0.0450661853,
0.03743295,
-0.0390614718,
-0.0746372715,
0.0036777572,
-0.0188168939,
0.004127373,
-0.0127475066,
-0.0659880638,
-0.0051245582,
0.0311101917,
0.0126993041,
-0.06596715,
0.0398900248,
0.0279566124,
-0.0129086142,
-0.0272813607,
0.0088525964,
0.0114762979,
0.0019800838,
0.0029561005,
-0.0346041135,
-0.0382109284,
0.0260313675,
-0.006202287,
0.0432154946,
-0.0458930619,
0.0028248441,
0.0103564365,
0.0182739664,
-0.0169192757,
0.0544225574,
-0.027799448,
-0.0079277754,
-0.0201416854,
0.0337230042,
0.0374313742,
0.0081838919,
0.0685963333,
-0.0305974409,
-0.0271722116,
-0.0218110848,
0.01328592,
-0.0011673919,
-0.0217189584,
-0.0003324725,
0.0251830462,
-0.0307216682,
0.0029027408,
0.0667948723,
0.0120678358,
0.0491609834,
-0.0077151353,
-0.0265682042,
-0.0244735684,
-0.0295479447,
-0.0376922488,
0.0017635835,
-0.0019723512,
0.0060213744,
-0.0705074072,
-0.0633899346,
-0.0100810733,
0.0411147214,
0.0552425645,
-0.0127896499,
0.0485557728,
0.0611456186,
0.0319088213,
-0.0429893881,
-0.0169877931,
0.0166012589,
-0.0234572049,
-0.0031733471,
-0.01335169,
-7.485133664e-33,
-0.0154850474,
-0.0014028932,
0.0093023879,
-0.0188803561,
-0.0345574208,
0.0221662857,
-0.024300592,
0.002227756,
0.0002008915,
-0.0170831997,
-0.0004820259,
0.0120187635,
0.0133773517,
0.009710459,
0.0187911671,
0.0096963011,
0.0483488813,
-0.0088841831,
-0.0364528596,
-0.0141205555,
0.0220704284,
0.0212791301,
0.0200860482,
-0.0457487553,
-0.0019280637,
0.0470444374,
0.0030231483,
-0.0082779275,
-0.0083727995,
0.0341472887,
-0.0463747531,
0.0194953028,
0.0173203107,
-0.0819008574,
-0.0038771559,
0.0094118649,
-0.0561977364,
-0.0151886875,
0.0182871819,
0.0149179129,
-0.0451043621,
0.0030523909,
0.0159210656,
0.0492044501,
-0.0433993414,
-0.0152542647,
-0.0242336635,
-0.0167882666,
-0.035575375,
0.0062313369,
-0.0421140268,
0.0363590717,
0.0015655051,
0.0348514654,
0.040081583,
-0.0012766875,
-0.0154641699,
0.0002434575,
-0.0679549649,
-0.0233604088,
0.0315052383,
0.0582165569,
0.061563883,
-0.0165470187,
0.018865224,
0.0501385853,
0.039932441,
-0.0195088144,
-0.0416087992,
0.0252366494,
0.0450744927,
0.0308317225,
0.0391040072,
0.0289113205,
0.0806519315,
0.0026620533,
-0.0857352987,
0.0190725718,
0.031783402,
0.0193302613,
0.0074214665,
0.0110447584,
-0.0537153482,
-0.0356811173,
-0.0595420189,
0.0086662685,
-0.0186117515,
0.0039587901,
0.0476290584,
0.0227563828,
-0.0387742855,
0.0228236336,
0.01696066,
-0.0632436052,
-0.0058496189,
0.0148969088,
0.0469634384,
0.0112149734,
0.0151374498,
0.0312267691,
-0.0586001687,
-0.0179980118,
-0.0304697752,
0.0281494148,
0.0635596812,
-0.0411352962,
-0.0117146997,
0.0384321436,
-0.0790565014,
-0.0068672136,
-0.0411102585,
0.0199843142,
-0.0094307819,
0.0137402248,
0.0272113625,
-0.0121560283,
0.007879517,
0.0343596153,
-0.0120993266,
0.0224891212,
-0.0588726252,
-0.0105552208,
0.0136320526,
0.0106495097,
0.0146354912,
-0.0210631341,
-0.0458109006,
-0.0092460131,
0.014003301,
-0.045369789,
-0.0433595181,
0.0134166637,
3.172e-7,
0.0486363657,
0.0491214395,
0.0207217988,
0.0494619794,
0.0289440546,
0.0333719738,
0.0145097533,
0.0038917281,
-0.031210335,
-0.0185310803,
-0.0230219979,
-0.0039988928,
0.0645942017,
0.0261609163,
-0.0302861221,
-0.0490207486,
-0.071593523,
0.0142178377,
-0.0424013063,
-0.0047041485,
0.0158836152,
0.0756584406,
0.0223777983,
-0.0114372978,
0.011710152,
-0.0070100152,
0.027379591,
-0.0438416228,
0.0168020576,
-0.0029438613,
0.0450610481,
0.0225811638,
0.0152119463,
0.0094721997,
-0.0119726323,
-0.0128645897,
0.0106431097,
0.0946370363,
-0.0177625902,
-0.0090153227,
0.0142838778,
-0.0651412159,
-0.0166105013,
-0.0335369557,
0.0907548517,
0.0342277959,
0.0002470682,
-0.0467145368,
0.0242103599,
0.0123751136,
0.0146366749,
0.0177567303,
-0.0142538473,
-0.0073489505,
0.0197630748,
-0.0285622235,
-0.0218238328,
-0.0619099177,
-0.0310793109,
-0.0339214876,
-0.007908117,
-0.0500392169,
-0.0711164996,
0.0139922798,
0.023931155,
-0.0629005805,
-0.0420074202,
3.528832204e-34,
0.0351071171,
-0.0018682505,
0.0301487595,
0.0277704839,
0.050259389,
0.0081552202,
0.0313629471,
-0.0532118157,
-0.0677818134,
-0.0678436682,
-0.0236609131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10303v1 | Analyzing sports commentary in order to automatically recognize events and extract insights | 2023-07-18T18:51:06 | 2023-07-18T18:51:06 | Yanis Miraoui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | In this paper, we carefully investigate how we can use multiple different
Natural Language Processing techniques and methods in order to automatically
recognize the main actions in sports events. We aim to extract insights by
analyzing live sport commentaries from different sources and by classifying
these major actions into different categories. We also study if sentiment
analysis could help detect these main actions. | [
0.0442535356,
0.0082648862,
0.0111748679,
0.0648688972,
-0.0487034842,
0.0126358392,
-0.0615562722,
0.0361262523,
-0.0006131917,
-0.1132111177,
0.0512141474,
0.0060731587,
-0.0169729423,
0.0416299328,
-0.0194607992,
-0.0744436607,
0.0098913629,
-0.0169714075,
0.0575546138,
0.0336768925,
0.0553154871,
0.040591117,
-0.0429898798,
-0.0062284395,
-0.0245601609,
0.0500385091,
-0.0150206285,
-0.0645276308,
-0.0174744539,
-0.0119673004,
-0.0268132519,
0.0181439146,
0.0141871432,
-0.0906705558,
0.0000012555,
-0.0600669123,
0.0171430558,
-0.0528442897,
0.0334925354,
-0.007069868,
0.0437738895,
-0.035913866,
0.0397690684,
0.0028354232,
-0.0254049227,
0.0102850478,
0.0038612278,
0.0422549061,
0.0673693046,
0.0708652139,
-0.0288933553,
-0.0359963328,
-0.0363197066,
0.0345085748,
-0.0361129753,
-0.0480678789,
0.0351627357,
0.0031740749,
-0.01166928,
0.0295921285,
0.0233094841,
-0.0174538512,
-0.0565965958,
0.0257448945,
-0.0138918879,
-0.0073795598,
-0.0311019439,
-0.0058751265,
-0.00998531,
-0.0060211909,
-0.0460438393,
-0.0007407718,
0.0229341816,
-0.0212504212,
-0.0142822368,
-0.0388087034,
-0.001565142,
0.0516246222,
-0.0281112678,
0.0173315424,
0.01586942,
0.0396660939,
-0.0306310561,
0.0239847619,
0.0059984345,
0.0025707232,
-0.007647315,
-0.0088966312,
-0.0254851375,
0.049067609,
0.0179227702,
-0.0553296991,
0.0360759459,
0.0319207013,
-0.0010132504,
0.0180727355,
0.0039495663,
0.0012589124,
-0.0298397597,
-0.0925229341,
-0.0057392363,
0.0146590415,
0.0193329398,
0.0425873362,
0.0036454971,
-0.045371525,
0.0351106226,
-0.0540499948,
-0.0275640357,
-0.0194354448,
-0.0469438769,
0.0233297199,
0.0118986657,
0.0625335798,
-0.0816842616,
0.0040058671,
-0.0316377953,
0.0005848855,
0.0406983756,
-0.0036790245,
0.0035239921,
0.0101931868,
0.0449633747,
0.0137296431,
-0.0314314924,
-0.0107271047,
-0.0870965049,
0.0176467784,
-0.0315035805,
-0.0313124843,
0.0273456499,
0.0407831818,
0.05725215,
0.0261529107,
0.0088168876,
0.009396866,
0.0092571732,
0.0063467571,
-0.0457239635,
-0.0340048522,
-0.0107904691,
-0.0269107297,
-0.0274768267,
-0.0480476022,
0.0204963684,
-0.0297082532,
-0.0392560884,
-0.0137469126,
0.0293563437,
0.0140553378,
-0.0255889632,
0.0534829497,
-0.0328278095,
0.0214643758,
0.004306755,
-0.0024887063,
0.0636468083,
0.021286428,
-0.0375335738,
-0.0270906147,
0.0372093953,
0.0119664324,
0.0322585888,
0.020496184,
-0.0459331907,
-0.042810455,
-0.0380460657,
0.0063202577,
-0.0646867231,
0.015110326,
-0.0345956162,
0.0140770786,
-0.0003581124,
-0.0050011696,
0.0117322262,
0.0631798282,
-0.0017646732,
0.0059657902,
0.0335721076,
0.0425024666,
0.0265980456,
0.0292073637,
-0.0035343883,
0.0079567144,
0.0206185523,
0.0173628256,
-0.0070321751,
-0.0011083283,
-0.0230346657,
-0.0932587981,
-0.029838305,
-0.022662444,
-0.0149337221,
0.0049178721,
0.0540285371,
-0.0483630374,
0.0025828921,
0.023062434,
0.011484798,
-0.0189916715,
0.0274327304,
-0.0337297618,
0.0002967726,
0.0467401631,
-0.0328397565,
-0.0570704378,
0.00740895,
-0.0116701517,
0.0075726407,
0.0383416004,
0.0365063697,
-0.0020930113,
0.0075806845,
-0.0371570066,
-0.0110870581,
-0.0055699712,
0.0438178852,
-0.0044162231,
-0.0502413437,
0.0318346359,
-0.0229588449,
0.0955854282,
-0.0518021472,
0.0524427742,
0.0639150739,
-0.0591963604,
-0.0091100819,
-0.0285156798,
-0.0010804936,
0.0650541037,
0.0005839471,
-0.0115277348,
0.0358068831,
0.0041123764,
-0.0192869641,
0.0774759874,
0.0291624386,
-0.0377758257,
-0.0026678951,
-0.0316613987,
-0.0430788063,
0.0134917405,
-0.0283242185,
-0.0156727768,
0.0312982723,
0.0276538115,
-0.0047294209,
-0.0133260218,
-0.0041783792,
-0.0093926359,
-0.0009835112,
-0.0089215459,
0.0503493622,
0.0381423682,
0.0106630689,
-0.0129644973,
-0.0677441731,
0.0142861456,
-0.0269998927,
-0.0060625211,
0.0360070951,
-0.0090536615,
0.037083637,
0.0873992071,
-0.0200433731,
-0.0421199575,
0.0066224653,
-0.078336373,
0.0202255175,
-0.0437786132,
0.0353225619,
0.055746641,
0.024134554,
-0.0255046394,
0.0080384975,
-0.0082175471,
-0.0629169121,
0.0200953521,
-0.016087627,
0.0475151688,
0.0285762846,
0.0594544336,
-0.0310580228,
0.0329434611,
-0.0137997437,
0.0300599448,
0.0339740179,
-0.0598823428,
-0.0883384049,
-0.010815748,
0.0066107255,
0.0424323827,
0.0232667159,
-0.015846746,
0.0040436834,
-0.0148272021,
-0.0443143733,
0.0721433684,
0.0296720751,
0.0590209365,
-0.0180150159,
-0.0489769839,
0.0128535265,
0.0055054394,
-0.0660026148,
0.0186332893,
-0.0342891924,
0.0008320372,
0.0847172588,
0.0218598042,
0.009949252,
0.0218186472,
-0.008890273,
0.0090028131,
-0.0319402292,
0.0406652242,
-0.0210792534,
-0.0581050329,
-0.0092364885,
0.023954941,
0.0602060668,
0.0280142576,
0.0284972526,
0.0099098124,
0.012801066,
-0.1071978286,
-0.0711327493,
-0.0453279205,
0.0723876581,
-0.0013925231,
0.0538487323,
0.0018884437,
-0.0355383381,
0.0389791764,
-0.058236517,
0.0591092296,
0.0252275094,
0.0143384002,
-0.0016480571,
0.01211215,
0.0163286924,
-0.000957183,
0.0025657294,
-0.0465032719,
-0.0484822653,
-0.0233581662,
0.0426302627,
-0.00792835,
-0.0248926841,
0.0063648876,
-0.0207245778,
-0.0368249491,
-0.0002845859,
0.0018075953,
0.0514829904,
0.0514415242,
-0.0078278305,
0.0152119705,
-0.0326449536,
0.013108342,
0.0015216762,
0.0480685346,
-0.0313775688,
0.0321646668,
-0.0081357462,
0.0003372684,
-0.0136907091,
-0.0539744832,
0.0044528982,
0.0191810615,
0.0436209701,
-0.0597828925,
0.0628980771,
0.1294438541,
0.054123424,
-0.0016054732,
-0.0131844459,
0.0208905376,
-0.0935771465,
0.0068813055,
0.023015881,
-0.0490794554,
-0.02774073,
-0.0358639993,
0.0033643031,
-0.0319813974,
-0.0053274478,
-0.0127558876,
-0.0613082051,
0.003133649,
-0.0105265491,
-0.0136940135,
-0.0762072951,
-0.0163247492,
0.010033207,
-0.0528871343,
-0.0655947626,
-0.0147521291,
0.0155004077,
0.0240137186,
0.0268825851,
-0.0857178718,
-0.0423996933,
0.0309854578,
-0.0228347369,
0.0010569789,
-0.0234467536,
0.0443245582,
-0.0321695879,
0.0141060436,
0.0538468584,
-0.030456489,
0.0203503594,
-0.0070615271,
0.0525212139,
-0.0246631764,
-0.0085427575,
-0.0373077653,
0.0102990624,
0.0067165364,
0.0216361992,
0.0337298065,
0.0409312472,
0.0096499054,
-0.0254618432,
-0.0068502184,
0.0358756967,
0.0336802825,
0.0210390612,
-0.016720837,
-0.0292347129,
-0.0289558861,
-0.0050826692,
0.0158799551,
-0.0741012096,
-0.0870163217,
-0.0205436684,
0.0131918425,
-0.0640802309,
-0.0329877585,
-0.045662649,
0.0049191527,
0.0046879249,
-0.0118320743,
0.0731991082,
0.010404394,
-0.0015832669,
-0.0370297469,
0.0423218794,
0.0458542965,
-0.0310462117,
0.043501623,
-0.00777133,
0.0970738456,
0.0103021488,
-0.0277359374,
0.0185277946,
0.0157965627,
-0.0485902764,
-0.0053295875,
-0.0141451731,
0.0172314905,
0.0222783554,
0.0196567122,
-0.0223197676,
-0.0775057748,
0.0012033739,
-0.0013543328,
-0.0000525316,
0.0008686644,
0.0268461015,
-0.0163715575,
-0.0188720319,
0.0271252282,
0.0324197896,
-0.0470670201,
-0.0130653949,
-0.089445889,
-0.0135736726,
0.0267468803,
-0.0251214635,
0.0795182884,
0.0169240143,
-0.0279952772,
-0.0025149535,
-0.0493020639,
-0.0183855928,
-0.0046764161,
-0.0095440168,
0.0376513675,
-0.0327090807,
0.0499768481,
-0.0403594375,
0.0424901433,
-0.0813737884,
-0.0161307324,
-0.011527773,
0.0858093426,
0.0696868226,
-0.0031125783,
-0.0508855395,
0.0162416305,
-0.0111042922,
0.023662338,
0.0083707282,
0.0046597002,
-0.0059859445,
-0.0499755628,
0.0063190395,
-0.0282711014,
0.0449200422,
-0.0097327642,
0.0040784883,
0.0492104478,
-0.0150538487,
0.024045255,
0.0833093375,
-0.0576374456,
-0.0346990004,
-0.0021173258,
0.0074840677,
0.0401908606,
0.0399232693,
-0.0214012396,
-0.0286304969,
-0.0075246645,
-0.000206017,
-0.020570986,
-0.006304455,
0.0132240299,
-0.0265523158,
-0.0000767889,
0.0679216981,
-0.0627728999,
-0.0417080671,
-0.0086032003,
0.0257160906,
0.0228331238,
-0.0065534245,
0.0211277474,
-0.0498212241,
0.0369282328,
0.0313457549,
-0.0566334724,
0.038420137,
-0.0011090878,
0.0340166576,
0.0350095071,
0.029490713,
0.0419054143,
-0.051673457,
0.0165456161,
-0.0672061443,
-0.0119448267,
-0.0104708029,
-5.181008616e-33,
0.0054697362,
-0.0749359876,
0.0049526202,
0.0426556766,
-0.0231571011,
-0.0093545411,
-0.004594896,
0.0188893471,
-0.021363087,
0.0097326702,
0.0351233333,
0.0042495131,
0.0027549323,
-0.0286521949,
0.0528860316,
-0.0502357259,
0.0139048565,
-0.0487358272,
-0.0174472183,
-0.0179785229,
0.0347170867,
0.0196790155,
0.0560188852,
-0.0868013203,
0.0374619327,
-0.0207124371,
-0.0235567782,
0.0058482965,
0.0801831931,
0.0219189208,
0.0201043263,
0.0156411529,
0.0357301049,
-0.0442765169,
-0.0115539115,
0.0615410842,
0.0221686326,
-0.0460374989,
0.030111596,
0.0385074541,
0.0052250233,
0.0264882687,
0.0388865247,
-0.0012267156,
-0.0278447736,
0.0143649448,
0.0503495075,
-0.0208862759,
0.0450126603,
-0.0650146231,
-0.0594631732,
0.0642087832,
-0.0281407759,
0.0239624102,
0.0628753453,
-0.0004212373,
0.0092219971,
0.0040743798,
-0.0189789515,
0.0227851681,
-0.0171363465,
0.0537107326,
-0.0354963429,
-0.0058948174,
-0.0291428324,
0.0204524733,
-0.0235172678,
-0.0208477788,
-0.0546475537,
0.0330840908,
-0.0333183967,
0.0326209888,
0.0570225567,
0.008539347,
0.0256079417,
0.0296080206,
-0.0585295297,
-0.0220698435,
0.0844278336,
0.0424356088,
-0.0190622266,
0.0107862204,
-0.0535649285,
0.0350257158,
-0.0008299063,
-0.0153450426,
-0.0030794789,
-0.024086887,
-0.0081268167,
-0.0107746543,
-0.0075974194,
0.0509673357,
-0.0091520566,
0.041411072,
-0.0089153368,
0.0132291131,
-0.0161604527,
0.0584246032,
-0.0398398526,
0.03012155,
-0.039823316,
-0.0121403886,
-0.041426722,
0.0272766072,
0.0083725201,
-0.0247156229,
-0.0262277946,
0.0343190767,
-0.0175340865,
-0.0115084844,
0.0394153297,
0.0064008799,
-0.0073113334,
0.0450582579,
-0.0329706743,
0.0335734114,
-0.0220840368,
0.0520749763,
-0.0135012111,
0.0047807088,
0.0312479753,
0.0137026161,
0.0055714068,
-0.0015164,
-0.0060635265,
-0.0147254663,
0.0235256217,
0.0528053455,
-0.0130167808,
0.0148691069,
-0.0071486146,
0.0047717686,
2.081e-7,
0.0342776738,
0.0589651428,
-0.0392786115,
-0.0275147445,
-0.0112457564,
0.0306861922,
-0.0006683274,
0.0289697498,
0.0109823467,
0.0261751562,
0.0244300291,
0.0056543387,
-0.0136711039,
0.0242395699,
-0.1116928086,
-0.0857372731,
0.0060340315,
-0.0556563139,
-0.029950019,
0.0247615483,
0.0993366167,
0.0472073257,
0.0465187989,
0.0398883447,
-0.0491893217,
-0.0397322737,
0.012276669,
-0.0034245644,
-0.0254732221,
0.0132743046,
-0.0199427996,
0.0199462697,
-0.0671137944,
-0.0042841136,
-0.0494065247,
0.0227763094,
0.036122188,
0.0288181938,
-0.0285112038,
0.0121614719,
-0.0171258338,
0.001795858,
-0.0231205653,
0.043445915,
0.0184564497,
-0.056624487,
-0.0257125702,
-0.0763127878,
-0.0076709674,
-0.0253524967,
0.0023849565,
-0.0283392891,
-0.0087576834,
0.0397384986,
-0.0104744378,
-0.019105874,
0.0028696018,
-0.0676974729,
0.0064392835,
0.0277852882,
-0.008678155,
0.0080513116,
0.0266861804,
0.0289076082,
0.014510775,
-0.0231738724,
0.0179908331,
1.027819314e-34,
0.019092666,
0.0252081864,
-0.0322464071,
0.0179500133,
-0.0057158195,
0.0185462032,
-0.0487837419,
0.031770248,
0.0455306545,
0.0045810165,
0.0059172614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09532v1 | Can Model Fusing Help Transformers in Long Document Classification? An Empirical Study | 2023-07-18T18:21:26 | 2023-07-18T18:21:26 | Damith Premasiri, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Ruslan Mitkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text classification is an area of research which has been studied over the
years in Natural Language Processing (NLP). Adapting NLP to multiple domains
has introduced many new challenges for text classification and one of them is
long document classification. While state-of-the-art transformer models provide
excellent results in text classification, most of them have limitations in the
maximum sequence length of the input sequence. The majority of the transformer
models are limited to 512 tokens, and therefore, they struggle with long
document classification problems. In this research, we explore on employing
Model Fusing for long document classification while comparing the results with
well-known BERT and Longformer architectures. | [
0.0301356968,
0.0375679173,
0.0141391438,
0.0108438451,
-0.0189154837,
0.0284868348,
0.0122170569,
0.0043735476,
-0.0004006624,
-0.1246927753,
-0.0041804449,
-0.0490455516,
0.0288217347,
0.0280079897,
-0.0038528878,
-0.058319319,
0.0305399522,
-0.0129933776,
0.0013805378,
0.0131674195,
-0.0169174094,
-0.0175607707,
0.0204916149,
0.031641189,
-0.0153702619,
0.0091435295,
-0.0172193702,
-0.0201235693,
-0.0137444995,
0.0106649902,
0.0094229495,
0.0297257956,
0.0032830553,
0.0688266456,
0.0000013761,
-0.0551790893,
-0.040796645,
0.03290255,
-0.016951466,
0.0132019222,
0.0266203936,
-0.0011015699,
-0.021996228,
0.0416244566,
0.0028742864,
-0.0119094029,
0.032529451,
0.116109632,
0.0509719104,
0.0995645002,
-0.0188234076,
-0.0594701655,
0.0960961804,
-0.0309890602,
-0.0144537715,
0.0015943216,
0.0574709661,
-0.0436039194,
0.0344765112,
-0.0158337262,
-0.0153880827,
-0.0040693628,
0.0079573337,
-0.0021572376,
-0.01265758,
0.0325202346,
-0.0416077599,
-0.00269096,
0.0041808262,
0.0066527314,
-0.0501362085,
-0.0095303999,
0.0093417261,
0.0266647767,
0.011804969,
0.0158028975,
-0.0249098111,
0.0073792571,
-0.0132422298,
-0.0165705644,
0.0215059239,
-0.008936462,
-0.0002226592,
0.0002607302,
-0.1031432152,
0.0219692532,
0.0173637643,
-0.0239957832,
-0.0153438561,
-0.0105084926,
-0.0219857655,
-0.0772641152,
-0.0002775141,
0.0406858362,
0.0059804441,
-0.0123758307,
-0.0424912348,
-0.0549188629,
0.0293950289,
-0.0576884523,
0.0070623029,
0.0240301285,
0.0019408669,
0.038161099,
-0.0454282016,
0.0316271186,
-0.0268288385,
0.0172942523,
-0.0268537551,
0.0066088797,
-0.0824772194,
-0.021983942,
-0.0678748563,
0.0413951874,
-0.0251154713,
-0.0475541502,
-0.0587966405,
0.0345683508,
0.0363194197,
-0.0055830991,
0.0149355587,
-0.0121449698,
-0.0081200721,
0.0099080373,
0.0048413854,
0.0564798377,
-0.015299812,
-0.003616272,
-0.0019466742,
-0.0127655324,
0.0240071137,
0.0153684476,
0.0062791412,
-0.0434380323,
0.0068881307,
0.0453933254,
-0.0101255421,
-0.0848758742,
0.0005934021,
0.0159184393,
-0.0308415759,
-0.0447598211,
0.0331832916,
-0.0380641818,
-0.0027515122,
0.0369833857,
0.0261988752,
0.0080628572,
-0.0003511553,
0.0051847794,
0.0135014895,
0.0699316263,
0.0344881527,
-0.0283312891,
0.0510359481,
0.0016204917,
-0.0077103754,
0.048847083,
0.0094974851,
0.0316939913,
0.0205997378,
-0.0389099866,
0.0203047357,
0.0433883443,
-0.0124407606,
-0.0239647124,
-0.0179624427,
0.0075407927,
0.0306997187,
-0.0082587758,
-0.0251481254,
0.0534480773,
-0.0043586013,
0.0026818109,
0.0264100544,
0.026421098,
0.0400385074,
0.0399117358,
0.0169033017,
0.0132052628,
-0.0113190627,
0.0348787457,
-0.0166336708,
-0.0331602097,
-0.0158537272,
0.0246402174,
0.0050377129,
0.0661795214,
-0.0324959643,
-0.0225190986,
-0.0435307845,
-0.0278651752,
0.0160348117,
-0.0161835533,
0.0642543808,
0.0152554037,
-0.0322518609,
0.0904681981,
-0.0048933337,
-0.0508734621,
-0.0154789137,
-0.0602503158,
-0.0139883989,
0.0253649876,
0.0079364553,
-0.0581897721,
-0.0449348651,
-0.0078557283,
-0.0305334162,
0.0012908876,
0.0398443118,
-0.0179494657,
-0.0172355007,
-0.031998042,
-0.0138891889,
0.0419316888,
0.0098930895,
0.0100490106,
0.0039725979,
-0.0098162023,
0.0281383414,
-0.0365797915,
-0.010353297,
0.0293601993,
-0.0419669338,
-0.0241659544,
0.0011810125,
0.0304568652,
0.020496672,
0.0019788388,
-0.0146029908,
0.0249274895,
0.065367423,
-0.0315383635,
-0.0770056248,
-0.0353689939,
-0.0085759657,
-0.0008969963,
0.047306601,
0.0192118324,
-0.008051279,
0.0356724337,
-0.0157848205,
-0.0331798978,
-0.0400027335,
-0.0880149975,
0.0657545403,
-0.0079147089,
0.0679283589,
0.0021834488,
0.030498011,
-0.0398674347,
0.0552632548,
0.0238701366,
0.0184295662,
-0.0210518371,
-0.0582915284,
0.013622365,
-0.0051094578,
-0.0459812395,
0.0370482467,
-0.0228605177,
0.0031679214,
0.0369785614,
-0.0555187911,
-0.0224116631,
-0.0872687474,
-0.1133881882,
-0.0028450461,
-0.0182694178,
0.0433229692,
-0.0361298211,
0.0323551185,
0.006637034,
0.0039760373,
-0.0332376063,
-0.0748671815,
-0.0095310854,
0.0341389775,
0.0090758651,
0.0258800276,
-0.0627513453,
0.0229800306,
-0.0256237164,
-0.0304031428,
0.0912103578,
-0.0200303532,
-0.0413781628,
-0.0597503819,
-0.0282218903,
-0.000809623,
0.0492106192,
-0.0159506854,
-0.022462897,
-0.0297448058,
-0.0053207963,
0.0769334882,
0.0570733137,
0.066294089,
0.0373917669,
0.0006378014,
0.0064812819,
-0.0068932441,
0.0103380857,
-0.0427026451,
0.0262300931,
-0.0449403636,
0.0334141552,
0.0050574047,
0.0502883941,
-0.0590524673,
-0.0167824682,
-0.0147691527,
-0.0119735161,
0.0048263357,
0.017023338,
0.0290645361,
-0.0378295928,
-0.0178655237,
-0.0100987842,
0.0116417548,
0.0040377611,
0.0460647754,
-0.0489498302,
0.0052127568,
-0.056359563,
0.0080119027,
-0.0753543675,
0.0508154146,
0.0229516085,
0.0063206982,
0.0229223259,
-0.0364809483,
0.0108379237,
-0.0071574459,
-0.0218716227,
-0.0315814242,
0.0613858961,
0.027785657,
0.0418242291,
-0.0404219329,
-0.0222004261,
-0.0158715006,
-0.0453744642,
-0.0063524987,
0.0470594205,
0.0111012207,
-0.0312571935,
-0.0989861563,
0.05170127,
0.0038541621,
0.0500933863,
-0.0290116053,
-0.0003657246,
-0.0012268276,
0.0653741732,
0.0150356665,
-0.0095518632,
-0.0138692083,
-0.0397169515,
0.005290892,
0.0255935248,
0.0158438273,
-0.0010513976,
-0.0461537018,
-0.0357333347,
0.0514428094,
-0.1093362942,
-0.0399993956,
0.0129377712,
0.0073386859,
-0.0610491671,
0.0099554947,
0.1121306643,
0.0145830773,
-0.0187995732,
-0.0117035732,
0.0116921682,
0.033912275,
0.0083214501,
0.0259751268,
-0.0170247853,
-0.0223731436,
0.0376201756,
-0.0223870873,
-0.0125295734,
0.0179810468,
0.0056103063,
-0.1014702842,
0.0167699978,
-0.0008984596,
-0.0123651158,
-0.0114625003,
-0.0466290303,
-0.0262124855,
-0.0012012139,
-0.016836023,
-0.0163384434,
-0.0541498214,
-0.0438909307,
0.0421638377,
-0.0272023696,
-0.0339304991,
-0.0079613235,
-0.0024263654,
-0.0239162501,
0.0577629916,
0.0218887404,
-0.0137966257,
-0.0369354598,
0.0721041486,
-0.0002086399,
-0.0001201531,
0.0015877307,
0.0465286411,
-0.0434263125,
0.0280800965,
0.0226967018,
-0.0006109662,
-0.0129393749,
-0.0089197671,
-0.0264765061,
0.0783433691,
-0.0035771024,
-0.0028215589,
-0.0446046665,
-0.0457816087,
-0.0280416366,
0.042323336,
0.0028275081,
-0.0445946492,
-0.0375640243,
0.0074314331,
-0.0248631462,
0.0223952699,
0.0136359232,
0.0079391431,
-0.0438736118,
-0.0698116645,
-0.0618787743,
-0.0044566449,
0.0267907269,
0.0454450548,
0.0244486667,
0.0130486265,
0.0178959109,
0.0073775551,
-0.0534316599,
0.0255069025,
0.0040304204,
0.0378129631,
-0.1025585309,
0.0349991396,
0.0515249781,
-0.0099768667,
-0.0313688219,
-0.0358730406,
-0.0854980499,
-0.0558819361,
0.0143861407,
0.0026205454,
0.0249742568,
0.0189744513,
0.0122850034,
-0.0355720967,
0.0388682075,
0.0796081424,
-0.0360527411,
-0.0361079052,
0.0463199951,
-0.0334504023,
-0.0390176028,
-0.0150644444,
-0.0333654806,
0.013493197,
-0.005391669,
-0.0233532134,
-0.0189210847,
-0.0149344755,
-0.0091517074,
0.027065184,
0.0438872166,
-0.0117588202,
0.0091001894,
0.0112839565,
0.0649371073,
-0.0091666561,
-0.0238064788,
-0.0055265971,
-0.0016788562,
0.0247159749,
0.0133437179,
-0.002809928,
0.052746214,
0.0107755782,
0.0114846574,
-0.0245025624,
0.057805948,
-0.0153195802,
-0.0075179092,
0.0226482004,
-0.0144451419,
-0.0063098045,
-0.0497225262,
0.0471443459,
0.0175526757,
-0.0377404131,
0.028736094,
0.0292194188,
0.0715079084,
-0.0340424068,
0.0320033915,
-0.0630217865,
-0.0108637027,
-0.0338461325,
0.0170305856,
0.0214767046,
-0.0446164086,
0.0108309481,
-0.0041078147,
-0.0283141993,
-0.0191260446,
0.0167999994,
0.0276848972,
-0.0126874512,
-0.005957298,
0.0338928588,
-0.0214013364,
-0.0086528491,
0.0668194517,
0.0196701046,
0.0261509083,
0.0519095995,
-0.0473717228,
-0.0363612585,
-0.0165544134,
0.0485468134,
-0.0425455123,
0.0053335573,
-0.0016323038,
-0.0320160799,
-0.0293677915,
0.0757703856,
-0.0454159677,
0.030896917,
-0.0196667034,
0.0301739313,
0.0630870163,
0.0234558228,
-0.0047032177,
-0.0390599817,
0.0156353563,
0.0322151594,
0.0066853864,
-0.0033752068,
-4.750858867e-33,
-0.0024026819,
-0.0306041818,
0.0069125099,
0.0100590372,
-0.0516297221,
0.0228403788,
0.0200244095,
-0.0210726596,
0.0412057936,
-0.0087402621,
-0.0286410004,
-0.0125553124,
0.0170929525,
0.0470182411,
-0.0198482182,
0.0013048504,
0.065078631,
0.0382861085,
-0.035459727,
-0.0063754604,
0.0354320966,
0.0227009095,
-0.0012205649,
-0.020151915,
-0.0162579771,
0.005654647,
0.0271970164,
-0.0063476381,
0.0041230549,
0.0870415196,
0.0037895541,
-0.003295464,
0.0385624692,
-0.0515080914,
-0.0048641399,
0.0759655535,
-0.0783094242,
0.0183725059,
-0.0158033594,
0.0145854708,
0.0258921012,
-0.0304274689,
0.0331033505,
0.0169463307,
-0.0014526716,
-0.0282645002,
0.0437506437,
-0.0268495418,
-0.0536583625,
-0.0668179393,
-0.061193306,
0.0433884673,
0.0164488833,
-0.024209775,
0.0257230662,
0.0265980139,
0.0332408547,
0.0140039772,
-0.0137762083,
-0.0213983897,
0.0440188199,
0.0851064175,
0.0086522354,
0.0272187367,
-0.0357090309,
0.023710778,
-0.0221156012,
0.0165357534,
-0.0290275589,
-0.0264916234,
0.0012455061,
0.034873493,
0.0346720852,
-0.0192838833,
0.0598297194,
-0.024961032,
-0.0261331722,
0.0338527486,
-0.0083688311,
0.031612616,
0.0567896143,
0.0240142774,
-0.0198270399,
-0.0025445926,
-0.0326232873,
0.0232299548,
-0.0245909076,
0.0218873955,
0.0005311314,
0.0293659233,
0.0019063103,
0.0004571223,
0.0378913619,
-0.0326115526,
-0.0238814503,
0.0361317657,
0.0042240475,
0.0304380711,
-0.0251695588,
-0.0157745406,
0.0014983753,
-0.0644904375,
0.0353974327,
0.0180058349,
-0.0079641771,
-0.0377219655,
0.0676160082,
0.0281165503,
-0.0792422891,
0.0027877288,
-0.0061920993,
0.0059796111,
-0.015325156,
0.0810579211,
0.0447209142,
0.0351538435,
0.0015257377,
0.0660018995,
-0.0292602517,
0.016942149,
-0.0103465132,
0.0069994591,
0.0273536872,
0.0188697632,
0.00307392,
0.0026842754,
-0.0212773569,
0.0509031489,
0.0167473592,
-0.0567707084,
-0.0117094647,
0.0113500115,
2.139e-7,
0.0494031683,
0.0538980737,
0.0608228073,
-0.0013452428,
0.0027510761,
0.034680564,
0.0056759412,
0.0422434658,
0.0167456269,
0.0696517229,
-0.0176560376,
-0.0302652568,
0.0260612313,
0.0056777424,
-0.0723038316,
-0.0525608994,
-0.0704592913,
0.0399015807,
-0.0496068187,
0.0271439329,
0.0691213906,
0.1074277461,
-0.010496241,
-0.0242750142,
-0.0066669406,
-0.0464048572,
0.0587625317,
0.0050814515,
-0.0009713452,
0.046840623,
0.0202795994,
-0.0179540236,
0.0406319909,
0.0119195748,
-0.0131645966,
0.0468942896,
0.0074712299,
0.0353480726,
-0.029346671,
-0.006957673,
0.0366425142,
0.0030806661,
-0.0211918522,
-0.0040158327,
0.0575828329,
-0.0747509822,
-0.0403331369,
-0.0115009099,
-0.059607856,
-0.0159004889,
-0.0129653933,
0.0085458811,
0.0135890627,
0.0489696264,
0.0346274525,
-0.0398745239,
0.0141170332,
-0.1064598784,
0.0018733003,
-0.002835257,
-0.0462596156,
-0.0048293252,
-0.0297442153,
-0.0124797691,
0.0530128479,
-0.0862294361,
-0.0352064855,
2.383062937e-34,
0.0403372534,
-0.0127771879,
-0.0256458055,
0.0248497482,
0.0175610315,
-0.0370793901,
0.0242344979,
0.0173721705,
0.0113114789,
-0.0975020602,
-0.0068960264
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.