id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14031v1 | Multi3WOZ: A Multilingual, Multi-Domain, Multi-Parallel Dataset for Training and Evaluating Culturally Adapted Task-Oriented Dialog Systems | 2023-07-26T08:29:42 | 2023-07-26T08:29:42 | Songbo Hu, Han Zhou, Mete Hergul, Milan Gritta, Guchun Zhang, Ignacio Iacobacci, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating high-quality annotated data for task-oriented dialog (ToD) is known
to be notoriously difficult, and the challenges are amplified when the goal is
to create equitable, culturally adapted, and large-scale ToD datasets for
multiple languages. Therefore, the current datasets are still very scarce and
suffer from limitations such as translation-based non-native dialogs with
translation artefacts, small scale, or lack of cultural adaptation, among
others. In this work, we first take stock of the current landscape of
multilingual ToD datasets, offering a systematic overview of their properties
and limitations. Aiming to reduce all the detected limitations, we then
introduce Multi3WOZ, a novel multilingual, multi-domain, multi-parallel ToD
dataset. It is large-scale and offers culturally adapted dialogs in 4 languages
to enable training and evaluation of multilingual and cross-lingual ToD
systems. We describe a complex bottom-up data collection process that yielded
the final dataset, and offer the first sets of baseline scores across different
ToD-related tasks for future reference, also highlighting its challenging
nature. | [
0.0418678671,
0.0218258612,
-0.016073795,
0.0459661335,
-0.0057025068,
0.0426262729,
0.0678232014,
-0.0449816622,
0.0179348905,
-0.0139677348,
-0.091138579,
-0.0611874983,
-0.0136421919,
0.020679893,
0.0280126017,
-0.0649339557,
0.0458803475,
-0.0302426387,
0.01706196,
0.0024627985,
0.0223886091,
0.0218133945,
-0.0553580821,
0.0562982112,
-0.0062806616,
-0.0352160707,
-0.0151152434,
-0.0160855055,
0.0204921905,
-0.0324951895,
0.0048838188,
0.0580888577,
0.0077815088,
0.0238189287,
0.0000018338,
-0.0372272879,
0.0230665933,
-0.04505134,
-0.0191744026,
-0.0360597111,
0.0476662554,
-0.0087398039,
-0.010354083,
0.008345278,
-0.0289042816,
-0.0429097414,
0.0351451263,
0.0773722678,
0.0595717728,
0.0711086169,
-0.0021636961,
0.0351410769,
-0.0233908836,
-0.0284749325,
-0.0165801495,
-0.0197644364,
-0.0276840217,
0.0490003005,
-0.0086851642,
0.018347092,
0.0129885664,
0.0001852492,
0.0237794407,
-0.0622090138,
-0.0539877117,
-0.0279479567,
-0.0315163285,
-0.0386070907,
-0.0193588212,
0.0944638401,
0.0346396044,
0.0410823338,
-0.0087913452,
0.0103259077,
0.0084232632,
-0.0497569218,
-0.0568517931,
0.0140661271,
-0.0124214618,
-0.0131266266,
-0.0048992438,
0.0395734645,
-0.0180373844,
0.0049821385,
0.0187380742,
0.0307063982,
-0.0244388208,
-0.0185517501,
0.0321793407,
-0.0125095947,
0.002807932,
-0.0441598035,
0.012810179,
-0.0280868225,
-0.0819081366,
0.0065030293,
-0.0308253933,
-0.0327977985,
0.0273243431,
-0.0492611229,
0.0460798554,
0.0434700437,
-0.0614353716,
0.0337460712,
0.0332374945,
0.059254989,
-0.006712588,
-0.0027585621,
-0.0268691592,
-0.0445411541,
-0.02992942,
0.0206913091,
-0.0125876553,
0.0026699831,
-0.0603253916,
0.0133679425,
-0.0312545337,
0.0409307033,
-0.0443068184,
0.0010595338,
0.0116986064,
0.00361776,
-0.0440594628,
0.0073037776,
-0.028660709,
0.0468224771,
-0.0366848335,
0.0400944874,
0.0198033992,
-0.0473932698,
-0.0020674833,
0.0375180356,
-0.0091270031,
-0.0410193689,
-0.0112100262,
0.0631997883,
-0.0151996529,
0.0042830715,
-0.0029588232,
0.0168809369,
-0.0315515511,
-0.0642356649,
0.0127437636,
-0.0433239602,
0.051233232,
-0.0223331247,
0.015988823,
-0.0263119508,
0.016114587,
0.0129334657,
0.0213558543,
0.0438356623,
0.0098480787,
-0.0199132729,
0.0427481309,
0.0069981366,
-0.0411447287,
0.0850725472,
0.0324861407,
-0.0114690252,
0.0718272328,
-0.0032627918,
-0.0473070517,
0.031948179,
0.0064051878,
0.0111311981,
0.0620396584,
0.051784873,
0.0040515265,
0.0216684993,
0.0336108692,
0.0293153096,
-0.0319484957,
-0.0001405645,
0.0368184298,
0.0422863103,
-0.0269033946,
0.0040512974,
0.0349803083,
0.0164281484,
0.0078430055,
-0.0003582364,
-0.0353377089,
0.0307186991,
0.0342301279,
-0.0163721032,
0.0211290289,
0.0317553878,
-0.0604141802,
-0.0522715859,
0.0070566908,
0.0108338511,
0.0019596945,
-0.0103688659,
0.0340133905,
0.0275078081,
-0.010076385,
0.0188859142,
0.0215101968,
-0.0762892812,
-0.0272022672,
-0.0103266547,
-0.0050879498,
0.019502027,
-0.0029730196,
-0.0368170105,
-0.0589077212,
-0.0344684757,
0.0705689862,
0.0593659207,
0.0602010824,
-0.032013163,
0.0456517786,
-0.0587525964,
-0.0234738123,
-0.0082444893,
-0.0100512663,
0.0126317721,
-0.0129023138,
0.0021285405,
-0.0125719048,
-0.0104869306,
-0.027254492,
-0.0071899309,
-0.0122240297,
0.0091016339,
0.0485419184,
0.0115638422,
0.0439526215,
0.0623486564,
-0.0058929869,
-0.0310217794,
0.0280298926,
-0.0381239168,
0.0136628002,
0.0474693961,
-0.049616456,
-0.0466587245,
0.0208045766,
-0.0272964053,
-0.0367483571,
0.0304329488,
-0.0327401794,
-0.063714847,
0.0301681552,
-0.0364401117,
-0.0288938247,
-0.0374569595,
0.0003479611,
0.007515335,
0.0178078972,
-0.0182938874,
0.0135511048,
-0.0091800317,
0.0066978019,
0.0312460251,
0.0128071764,
0.0391512848,
-0.0395033993,
-0.0102133006,
0.0333224088,
-0.0189108793,
-0.0187425576,
0.0153984204,
0.0325372741,
-0.0413945019,
-0.0081388131,
-0.1285955906,
0.0102498438,
-0.0158114843,
0.0331531651,
0.0005187691,
0.0086794766,
-0.0139502911,
-0.0387229286,
-0.0641402751,
-0.0095031168,
0.0594399534,
-0.0147924917,
0.0449734218,
0.0089022769,
0.0127910813,
-0.0224635322,
-0.0066766148,
0.0161463507,
0.015800653,
-0.0158619732,
-0.0193534307,
-0.0511361137,
0.0049969102,
-0.0517680049,
0.0184141733,
-0.020587422,
-0.0260514803,
0.0327603258,
0.0581561439,
0.0924947634,
0.0324502327,
0.0002194324,
0.0135720838,
0.0007151511,
-0.0169781074,
-0.0505005606,
0.0381456688,
0.0147867166,
0.0079572303,
-0.0245618764,
-0.0410650969,
0.0027982576,
0.0470003784,
0.0006699761,
0.0150333298,
-0.024964856,
0.0060948324,
-0.0151651576,
-0.0312254708,
-0.0055741672,
0.0088823987,
-0.0240538493,
0.0342477746,
-0.0339096263,
-0.0274912473,
0.0749688298,
-0.0135796834,
-0.0442905091,
-0.0714497194,
-0.0002802289,
-0.0397326425,
0.082827203,
-0.0646162704,
0.0195142422,
0.0223120637,
-0.0465797894,
-0.0326438472,
0.0288205091,
0.027574541,
-0.0163926017,
0.0473013222,
-0.0373191498,
-0.0323934108,
-0.0506873913,
-0.0772613436,
-0.0311935805,
0.0209502913,
0.0016449931,
0.0010403746,
0.020056976,
-0.013343174,
-0.0309200715,
-0.0192962531,
0.0260832962,
0.0309379939,
-0.0030917542,
0.0088009378,
-0.0047381166,
0.0090217702,
0.0408365242,
0.0410622023,
0.0190477073,
-0.02024756,
0.0665324554,
0.0144033041,
0.0840050057,
-0.0724423528,
0.0186385289,
-0.0146946246,
0.0371654034,
0.009736863,
-0.0067556789,
-0.0419620872,
0.0669805333,
-0.0331176408,
0.0143545037,
0.0730945021,
-0.0030512454,
-0.0412519537,
-0.0207659565,
-0.0602437481,
-0.007808418,
0.0263419952,
-0.0017655723,
-0.1321700364,
-0.0420480259,
-0.0138607761,
-0.0162973758,
-0.023950547,
-0.0358093269,
0.0049711857,
-0.0941533074,
0.0417338088,
-0.0207546763,
-0.0286133941,
-0.0213312563,
-0.0020328455,
-0.0120520955,
-0.0136707928,
0.051436346,
-0.0281622205,
0.0316451751,
-0.0344201736,
0.0365074612,
0.0093620671,
-0.0150121888,
0.0547525957,
-0.0375920199,
0.0510622598,
0.0260000303,
0.055135902,
0.029309582,
-0.003338045,
0.0240791477,
0.0165955611,
-0.0278991591,
0.0117668072,
0.0109135089,
0.0126160355,
-0.0469883122,
-0.0460176431,
0.0296857748,
-0.020804191,
-0.0120215816,
0.0496789925,
0.0527106151,
-0.0472004041,
0.0463322215,
0.0135470619,
0.0145098083,
0.0455042198,
0.0613709353,
0.0145399533,
-0.0728814229,
0.0045886799,
-0.0130082984,
-0.0340704545,
-0.0686777607,
-0.0011260618,
0.0003368351,
-0.0255048871,
0.0077185216,
-0.0603351668,
-0.0694725513,
0.0297626499,
0.0109192599,
0.0281949881,
-0.0168403704,
0.0024854424,
0.0166551787,
-0.0307920538,
0.0595611483,
-0.008058683,
0.0291046761,
-0.0512334108,
-0.0157756787,
0.0078291791,
-0.0088517247,
0.0086234501,
0.0439302027,
-0.0716535524,
-0.034493655,
-0.0418308377,
0.0717946365,
0.0086365268,
0.0089232661,
0.035993427,
-0.0117984572,
-0.0435075797,
-0.0376189575,
-0.0532891303,
-0.0395940207,
0.0672018602,
0.0357809588,
-0.0073390012,
0.0598979145,
-0.0172365736,
0.0241904743,
-0.0199545436,
0.0149925686,
-0.0042597014,
-0.0428073965,
-0.022973597,
-0.01817807,
0.0388344862,
0.0100903269,
-0.0422805361,
-0.0863419622,
0.0575097501,
-0.0234469697,
-0.0337934792,
-0.0599071123,
0.0267356392,
-0.0168712307,
-0.0355233029,
0.0236029439,
0.0274392646,
-0.0266554523,
0.0047649504,
-0.0401637219,
0.0496458821,
0.0385098495,
0.0175636094,
-0.0360757969,
0.003311631,
-0.0401877388,
0.012644114,
0.0173258912,
0.0374277979,
0.002182326,
0.0913512185,
0.0128055401,
-0.0292215068,
0.0772062466,
0.0457366705,
-0.0105975885,
-0.006888411,
0.0150766326,
-0.0246995185,
0.0493989848,
0.0402739719,
0.0851965472,
0.0043626456,
0.0149878124,
-0.0006149152,
0.0537208319,
-0.0112105599,
-0.0245389063,
0.0053233043,
0.0129195247,
-0.0123929027,
-0.0084038833,
0.0757575929,
-0.0429851972,
0.0106173996,
0.0100428993,
0.020705156,
-0.0416897535,
-0.0507335365,
0.0083688051,
0.0180795398,
-0.0262707882,
-0.00388816,
-0.036602471,
-0.0403881073,
-0.0349348672,
0.0198728293,
-0.0162498131,
0.0025860961,
0.0150908735,
0.0385001414,
-0.018698398,
-0.0131581668,
-0.0474971719,
-0.0103171906,
-0.0402730368,
-0.0142065194,
0.0064555411,
-5.006067506e-33,
-0.0275104064,
-0.0118568549,
0.0094023105,
0.0160525162,
-0.0049885013,
-0.0259826556,
-0.0144955842,
0.0205021016,
-0.0381759852,
0.0203099027,
0.011876327,
0.0091048414,
0.0191746447,
0.0457570106,
0.0170407165,
0.0070950422,
0.0291153863,
-0.0051197107,
-0.0148535501,
0.0482945666,
0.0538967624,
-0.013980641,
0.0890939906,
-0.0647579134,
0.094116129,
-0.0027189208,
-0.0035788983,
0.0399512351,
0.0280155223,
0.0864192396,
-0.0042082747,
0.070809193,
0.0132240569,
-0.0414206088,
-0.0280724,
0.0344039164,
-0.0801395476,
-0.0272932164,
0.0456200428,
0.0339169912,
-0.0105384765,
-0.0159473233,
-0.0574807413,
-0.0194695387,
0.0102109378,
0.0171001442,
-0.0006102697,
-0.0413496643,
0.0166034047,
0.0248591378,
-0.0644726008,
0.0278908573,
-0.0272779763,
-0.0436342359,
-0.0108034099,
0.1207882464,
-0.0087937023,
-0.082080625,
-0.0323822796,
0.0152885756,
-0.045623716,
-0.0159297213,
0.0501269624,
0.0239062347,
-0.0067467378,
0.0644786283,
0.0327214934,
0.0435005501,
0.037873935,
-0.0364651494,
-0.0224487688,
0.0264470261,
0.0263541173,
0.0732937008,
-0.0347714089,
0.0256880242,
-0.0604866482,
0.0358378403,
0.0556067936,
0.0096037937,
0.0013108058,
-0.0218503959,
0.0026927833,
-0.0022170779,
-0.0239246525,
0.0059870789,
-0.0078251846,
-0.0336841159,
0.0381520167,
0.0041495608,
0.020331189,
0.0273532011,
0.0504229479,
-0.0083596399,
0.008615585,
0.0157673508,
0.001646906,
-0.0056498135,
-0.0000463199,
-0.0158435386,
-0.0464570075,
-0.0399388038,
0.0072484128,
0.0295623261,
0.0309720132,
0.0014466277,
0.0651085302,
-0.0232075248,
-0.0624241419,
0.0149162496,
-0.0478071943,
0.0840213075,
-0.056780953,
0.0621663891,
0.0109537719,
-0.027931774,
-0.0437588394,
0.0810442343,
0.009925927,
-0.0369426347,
-0.0391132496,
-0.0417421423,
0.0073397588,
0.0101298308,
-0.0260527786,
-0.0082814218,
-0.0178390332,
0.0038746817,
-0.0027641486,
0.0012677301,
0.0027333919,
-0.0211133342,
2.343e-7,
-0.0107524022,
0.019696651,
0.0240856651,
0.0296766479,
0.0019131991,
0.0366262831,
-0.0084438967,
0.021415418,
0.0055100136,
0.0113217691,
-0.0230803359,
-0.0008405175,
0.0825161785,
0.0483764522,
-0.1163589358,
-0.0652175397,
-0.0301745348,
-0.025474906,
-0.0444391295,
0.0230912007,
0.0316135362,
0.0861719027,
-0.0119376164,
-0.0038824913,
-0.0220977347,
-0.0162738953,
0.0559688695,
-0.0407590382,
-0.0068741934,
0.0212525502,
0.0383964591,
-0.039876245,
-0.005463216,
0.0186103936,
-0.0159980338,
0.0274233464,
0.0121890688,
0.0680376142,
0.0236356091,
-0.0440160222,
0.0138990479,
-0.0034837273,
-0.0181037299,
-0.0424862616,
0.0315525196,
-0.0245723575,
-0.0519265421,
-0.0257649142,
0.0422326773,
-0.0129980352,
0.0540158339,
-0.0410971381,
0.0081326617,
0.0172779132,
0.0268704016,
-0.0294832755,
0.0137688117,
-0.036346782,
-0.0179569442,
0.0202604719,
-0.0160754751,
-0.0589877293,
-0.0192630775,
-0.0429399237,
-0.0229661576,
-0.0161670092,
0.0072844676,
1.496456196e-34,
0.0242798682,
-0.0078438511,
0.0216527414,
0.0276563503,
0.0217314325,
-0.0374275893,
-0.0019081439,
-0.0232326761,
0.0348638184,
-0.0131220315,
-0.0148717575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14005v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14005v2 | Unsupervised extraction of local and global keywords from a single text | 2023-07-26T07:36:25 | 2024-06-14T06:40:31 | Lida Aleksanyan, Armen E. Allahverdyan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | We propose an unsupervised, corpus-independent method to extract keywords
from a single text. It is based on the spatial distribution of words and the
response of this distribution to a random permutation of words. As compared to
existing methods (such as e.g. YAKE) our method has three advantages. First, it
is significantly more effective at extracting keywords from long texts. Second,
it allows inference of two types of keywords: local and global. Third, it
uncovers basic themes in texts. Additionally, our method is
language-independent and applies to short texts. The results are obtained via
human annotators with previous knowledge of texts from our database of
classical literary works (the agreement between annotators is from moderate to
substantial). Our results are supported via human-independent arguments based
on the average length of extracted content words and on the average number of
nouns in extracted words. We discuss relations of keywords with higher-order
textual features and reveal a connection between keywords and chapter
divisions. | [
0.0460998788,
0.0122573925,
-0.0093436977,
0.0329732895,
-0.0468510948,
0.0061204233,
0.008305978,
0.0214717276,
0.0296477266,
-0.0584063604,
0.0175148658,
0.0217352416,
0.0122534409,
0.0101362206,
0.0328376256,
-0.0896186829,
0.0095343878,
-0.0252948385,
-0.0098050181,
0.0272402409,
0.0046371291,
0.0008802652,
0.0063265478,
0.0097026555,
0.0258229282,
-0.0087667983,
-0.0261712633,
-0.0488375276,
0.0374776796,
0.0245450549,
-0.0098419515,
0.0185420401,
0.005870203,
-0.0059048873,
0.0000018614,
-0.050181061,
-0.0497244187,
-0.0130517501,
0.0887502506,
0.0021479304,
0.0543131717,
0.0371905789,
-0.0068446905,
-0.0588663034,
-0.0250387453,
0.0522659011,
0.0086329859,
0.0559358299,
-0.0411589146,
0.0294998698,
-0.0203271843,
-0.0829643235,
-0.0199922714,
-0.0014881219,
-0.0065405564,
0.0061876364,
0.0164548736,
-0.0464400165,
0.003711476,
0.0171713494,
-0.0495479256,
-0.0025058212,
-0.0471595526,
0.0449251607,
0.0483904257,
0.0075401533,
-0.0494368747,
-0.0023525669,
-0.0109268557,
0.0323283859,
-0.0114746643,
-0.0141643593,
0.0649179891,
-0.0026724457,
-0.008637174,
0.0807504952,
-0.0372234657,
0.0419570245,
-0.0474339575,
-0.0038065687,
0.023558341,
-0.0094437115,
-0.0026329202,
-0.0113976886,
-0.051795911,
0.0503615737,
0.0305294655,
-0.0172893796,
0.001264053,
-0.0346332304,
-0.0561398752,
-0.0369889997,
0.0181471668,
0.0096984515,
0.0603399687,
0.0026111072,
0.0131341219,
-0.0159340985,
0.0013338458,
-0.1122315973,
-0.0391212702,
-0.0540055446,
-0.0113393711,
0.0240798108,
0.0387566462,
0.0075472798,
0.0129744001,
-0.0079985671,
-0.0151091581,
0.0476644263,
-0.0061777984,
0.011181931,
0.0054305289,
0.013534395,
-0.0342275351,
-0.0329777896,
-0.0331809074,
-0.059965305,
0.0637061745,
-0.0212677196,
-0.0414102338,
0.0393888876,
-0.0242414288,
-0.0415365025,
0.0161884744,
-0.0021737467,
-0.0715939403,
-0.0221569594,
-0.0453290492,
0.0229983497,
0.0124947093,
0.0301477779,
0.0888275206,
-0.0279705357,
0.0186686683,
0.0208813399,
0.0190432724,
-0.0510163344,
-0.021497203,
-0.0302553363,
-0.0243244413,
0.0265864749,
0.006384023,
-0.0534942448,
-0.0529311411,
-0.0295579862,
0.0154748987,
-0.0056892033,
0.016258996,
0.039513357,
-0.0597425438,
0.0438633636,
-0.0394684412,
0.0043035997,
0.0266043637,
0.0138653228,
0.0545530431,
0.0009834945,
0.0553751774,
0.1073782369,
0.084494099,
-0.0214922167,
0.0490247086,
0.0337716416,
-0.0322479494,
-0.009061764,
-0.0271898042,
-0.0580302253,
-0.0082673347,
-0.0303367544,
-0.0341901928,
0.0117775351,
-0.0109161558,
0.0390478298,
0.0618411154,
0.1283443719,
-0.0222148858,
0.0359638892,
-0.0099924123,
0.0407850258,
0.034886919,
0.0321778618,
-0.0012806946,
-0.054284364,
0.0107943853,
0.0046380446,
0.0306444634,
0.0241484474,
0.0577931888,
-0.0053030145,
-0.0234914683,
0.0261629503,
-0.0068899277,
-0.0360242426,
0.1057768986,
0.0240460858,
0.0107582109,
-0.0171723422,
0.0247567613,
-0.0548380837,
-0.003695054,
0.0377462171,
-0.0008794736,
0.0285324771,
0.0744121224,
-0.0304507073,
0.0444906615,
0.0213159751,
0.0139438417,
0.051291015,
-0.0493353531,
-0.0079372544,
0.0044191172,
-0.0486147776,
0.0032988319,
0.0147758489,
0.0039908108,
-0.0212036874,
0.012963132,
0.0256399401,
-0.0138281528,
-0.0401645787,
-0.0399195924,
0.0372076519,
-0.0023697347,
-0.0795338973,
-0.0197937153,
-0.0162076894,
-0.0102157146,
0.0018121992,
-0.0341480598,
0.0268600546,
0.0260821525,
-0.0490462855,
0.0040235976,
0.0319219567,
0.0386114232,
0.058435116,
0.0279171653,
-0.0715579838,
0.0285060145,
-0.0312417503,
0.0381369069,
-0.0261298437,
0.0332030691,
-0.0160177853,
0.0437636636,
0.0114658419,
-0.0075230375,
0.0222736616,
0.016787447,
-0.0470416248,
0.0965820849,
0.0368073173,
0.0396894701,
-0.0577771254,
-0.0820277482,
-0.0056944573,
-0.0026363691,
-0.0100008501,
-0.0210103709,
0.0231530257,
-0.03045577,
0.0550938547,
-0.016282374,
-0.0125715211,
-0.0115565946,
-0.093005985,
0.02415419,
-0.0113190264,
0.0071045361,
-0.0151815126,
-0.0057973242,
-0.0330878459,
0.0044047725,
0.0189036224,
-0.0312091298,
-0.033100795,
-0.0137616815,
0.0409706496,
-0.0383202434,
-0.0039070561,
-0.0373273157,
0.0131316651,
-0.0113658179,
0.0151654212,
0.0447466448,
-0.0813758075,
0.0268459395,
0.0105079189,
0.0287435856,
0.0272626672,
-0.020929968,
-0.0535352007,
-0.0023532296,
-0.0595239177,
0.0464967377,
0.0383036323,
0.0328935198,
-0.0190715697,
-0.0038718777,
-0.0870178565,
-0.0100934589,
-0.0332269594,
-0.0032327578,
0.0053968057,
-0.0012327433,
-0.0171905365,
0.0282969344,
0.0512457564,
0.0361877009,
-0.0316192843,
0.0132060144,
0.0102390852,
-0.0413134769,
0.0004735551,
-0.0462062508,
0.0334870517,
-0.0392195992,
0.0774530172,
0.0061710807,
-0.0329741426,
-0.0161923636,
-0.0049160882,
0.0228257328,
-0.0621294491,
0.0068691424,
-0.0370838083,
0.0743258521,
-0.0172700062,
-0.0054726796,
-0.0229523424,
-0.0428282656,
-0.0098761627,
-0.0191862639,
0.0638145879,
-0.028899692,
0.0362191685,
-0.045550447,
-0.033287935,
0.0179817993,
0.0065252492,
-0.0032989008,
-0.0705201998,
-0.0213970449,
-0.0707994401,
0.0574732944,
-0.045300521,
0.0064284285,
0.0084642526,
-0.0013962658,
0.0138965733,
-0.0262188818,
0.0049533318,
0.0015227975,
0.0505574979,
0.0699243098,
-0.0258846395,
-0.0405263416,
-0.0209358279,
-0.0098902844,
0.0283829141,
-0.0068027773,
0.001330758,
0.0193663258,
0.0180404633,
0.0009727885,
-0.0663055703,
-0.0480942279,
-0.0113275889,
-0.0079353331,
-0.0303303003,
-0.0234716143,
0.0539903082,
0.0421552919,
-0.0601794384,
-0.0095061446,
-0.0177322123,
-0.0481092744,
-0.0020190033,
0.0052240365,
0.007836502,
0.0077045006,
0.0113348961,
-0.0086265514,
0.0235357005,
-0.0235568825,
0.0146451574,
-0.0611254498,
0.0177925453,
-0.0036497985,
-0.0479637161,
-0.0188363194,
-0.0223606229,
-0.0317176953,
-0.0138933538,
-0.1004049852,
0.0000076717,
-0.0308784395,
0.0201311503,
-0.0232283659,
-0.0304198284,
0.0267292671,
-0.0331160016,
-0.0816662461,
-0.0370161198,
0.0521374047,
0.0650444552,
-0.0709371418,
0.0037399242,
-0.0096382741,
0.0472524166,
0.001811732,
0.0238119625,
0.0296519026,
-0.0153919728,
0.0043598069,
-0.0280903205,
0.0334044062,
-0.0242384225,
-0.0383843035,
0.098825708,
-0.0218656417,
0.0302589238,
-0.0173465405,
-0.0242348928,
0.053998176,
-0.026292244,
0.0069395262,
0.0050579505,
0.0281811301,
-0.0214410555,
-0.0229220521,
0.0325269178,
-0.0069711967,
-0.0940783769,
-0.0050007887,
-0.0504557192,
-0.0191889629,
-0.0793192014,
-0.0272534378,
-0.0144890472,
0.088987343,
0.0757581592,
0.0576822534,
-0.0080330372,
0.009792869,
-0.0544495992,
0.0390267521,
-0.0273950472,
-0.0556694269,
0.0010667039,
-0.029483296,
-0.0003644546,
-0.0546177439,
-0.0120048607,
0.0339775607,
0.0035299065,
-0.0215401333,
0.0213590413,
0.0000090695,
0.0172450487,
-0.00097584,
-0.0289118718,
-0.0246979017,
0.0630026236,
0.0077333604,
-0.0092269303,
0.0140536595,
0.0007446638,
0.0071018683,
-0.0033901241,
-0.0066897613,
-0.0102224899,
0.0303214826,
0.020254191,
0.0058775372,
-0.0432552285,
-0.0198022705,
-0.0135691967,
0.0167941917,
0.0783892423,
-0.0542345382,
-0.0318091661,
-0.0452670194,
-0.0425432436,
-0.0030486025,
-0.0419234522,
0.0121665895,
0.0764413252,
-0.001801415,
-0.0235660262,
-0.0164421983,
0.054556746,
0.0029578069,
-0.017550746,
-0.006404385,
-0.0227103215,
0.0511136539,
-0.0267264321,
-0.043836087,
0.0405433849,
0.0094533563,
0.0355702899,
-0.039331235,
0.0925633982,
0.0113081643,
-0.0042847502,
0.0208916161,
-0.0107880421,
-0.0279115476,
0.0363107882,
-0.0954808518,
0.0267504491,
-0.022682542,
0.0184381437,
0.0676483735,
-0.0344963111,
0.0580582097,
-0.0175668169,
-0.0106382519,
0.0217466466,
0.0302569754,
0.021995306,
0.052606862,
-0.0924742073,
0.0081056356,
-0.0235918816,
0.0289983191,
0.0568541549,
-0.0124571333,
-0.0286467504,
0.0446761772,
-0.0497436486,
-0.0233269241,
0.0355050191,
0.0672589764,
0.0391804464,
0.0324673317,
-0.0112074316,
-0.0287468489,
0.0055055134,
0.0499760248,
0.0411744751,
0.0152598228,
-0.001809204,
0.0166641343,
0.043656446,
-0.0282479692,
0.0224955566,
-0.08328484,
0.0725667849,
-0.0135334218,
-0.0354068652,
0.003462086,
-6.206241361e-33,
-0.0451526344,
-0.0479859002,
-0.0043644337,
0.0553694516,
-0.0068771243,
-0.0021776352,
0.0095307594,
0.0049436525,
0.0517493002,
0.0366711915,
-0.0341053382,
0.0211700778,
0.0155574298,
-0.0382659622,
0.0652531981,
0.0029464902,
-0.0369328745,
0.0316563547,
-0.0157698411,
-0.0091363778,
0.0625745952,
0.0351654552,
0.049318321,
-0.021054415,
0.0726127028,
-0.0536910929,
-0.0056459978,
-0.018038651,
0.010100726,
0.0187394246,
-0.0118172914,
-0.0084248185,
0.0216763522,
-0.0124762896,
0.0207007267,
0.0021270667,
-0.0184613988,
-0.0455765463,
0.0199643485,
-0.0027888939,
0.0335021801,
-0.0312774293,
0.0082607446,
0.0184459314,
0.005139072,
0.0259045456,
0.0978677422,
0.0108212242,
-0.071467571,
-0.0491044112,
-0.0441725999,
0.0287153777,
0.0034756311,
0.0045916531,
0.0412827954,
-0.0396695696,
-0.0009858665,
0.0052555637,
0.0448146425,
0.0292287599,
0.0703616366,
0.0408557802,
-0.029603906,
0.0286412854,
-0.0062544891,
0.0588038974,
0.0146615198,
-0.0264782645,
-0.0351789892,
0.0278679207,
0.0363328829,
0.0255660377,
-0.0009487467,
0.0718633533,
0.0143230539,
0.0459908843,
0.0189398862,
0.0446166135,
0.0198371373,
-0.0255534463,
-0.0027562839,
-0.0324847735,
-0.049382627,
-0.0224122945,
0.0020570194,
-0.0184552893,
-0.0013974217,
0.0278244056,
-0.0169307273,
-0.0088512329,
-0.0553498305,
0.028840147,
-0.0335067213,
-0.0096901068,
0.0193861984,
0.003765373,
0.0483198166,
0.0223009922,
-0.0327720009,
-0.010139727,
0.0116950944,
-0.0009764871,
-0.0270790141,
0.0008284475,
0.01314543,
0.0092813047,
-0.0660175085,
-0.0154406205,
-0.0264321454,
-0.0471059866,
0.022550879,
-0.0668221936,
-0.0251049716,
0.0248355214,
0.0066809668,
-0.0067601944,
0.0227272119,
0.0708452761,
0.0525247157,
0.0409201756,
0.0413270891,
0.0132085662,
0.0311558321,
-0.003539979,
0.0197232999,
0.0202626679,
-0.0174884796,
-0.0080223326,
0.026819434,
-0.0088389814,
0.0090461634,
0.0110727008,
2.806e-7,
0.0386257656,
0.0538853481,
0.0538933054,
-0.0099150604,
-0.0127768163,
0.0288413502,
0.025403766,
0.0219140295,
-0.0191693809,
-0.0052879271,
0.0473409221,
0.0122573348,
0.0183099564,
0.0421590619,
-0.1198175624,
-0.0338763744,
-0.0209777113,
-0.0463232324,
-0.0568885542,
-0.0129919648,
0.0379481651,
0.0305455998,
0.0471187718,
-0.0132594556,
-0.0257316362,
-0.0363998599,
-0.0236156061,
-0.0271710996,
-0.0516476147,
0.0228935517,
-0.0000850487,
-0.0207910761,
-0.0389372632,
0.0162918065,
-0.0025023057,
-0.0042423815,
0.0686660483,
0.0132658333,
-0.0161874145,
0.0013103863,
-0.0144937634,
-0.0270237122,
0.0011213806,
-0.0026539094,
0.0414732583,
0.0316741802,
-0.0087454449,
-0.0410116762,
0.000385533,
0.0165252332,
-0.0259120073,
-0.0056402949,
-0.040352419,
-0.0086422376,
0.0267556775,
0.0283887126,
-0.0065898136,
-0.0746287405,
0.0388557017,
0.009472141,
-0.0203469731,
-0.0106024705,
0.0169378426,
0.0085936487,
-0.0344908722,
-0.0287890192,
-0.0201229751,
2.025058097e-34,
0.0164264943,
-0.0105323633,
-0.0558813587,
0.0110249259,
0.0315700918,
-0.0128347948,
-0.0189942904,
-0.0181165487,
-0.0073523833,
-0.0437105112,
-0.0244451519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14004v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14004v1 | Affective Natural Language Generation of Event Descriptions through Fine-grained Appraisal Conditions | 2023-07-26T07:34:19 | 2023-07-26T07:34:19 | Yarik Menchaca Resendiz, Roman Klinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Models for affective text generation have shown a remarkable progress, but
they commonly rely only on basic emotion theories or valance/arousal values as
conditions. This is appropriate when the goal is to create explicit emotion
statements ("The kid is happy."). Emotions are, however, commonly communicated
implicitly. For instance, the emotional interpretation of an event ("Their dog
died.") does often not require an explicit emotion statement. In psychology,
appraisal theories explain the link between a cognitive evaluation of an event
and the potentially developed emotion. They put the assessment of the situation
on the spot, for instance regarding the own control or the responsibility for
what happens. We hypothesize and subsequently show that including appraisal
variables as conditions in a generation framework comes with two advantages.
(1) The generation model is informed in greater detail about what makes a
specific emotion and what properties it has. This leads to text generation that
better fulfills the condition. (2) The variables of appraisal allow a user to
perform a more fine-grained control of the generated text, by stating
properties of a situation instead of only providing the emotion category. Our
Bart and T5-based experiments with 7 emotions (Anger, Disgust, Fear, Guilt,
Joy, Sadness, Shame), and 7 appraisals (Attention, Responsibility, Control,
Circumstance, Pleasantness, Effort, Certainty) show that (1) adding appraisals
during training improves the accurateness of the generated texts by 10 pp in
F1. Further, (2) the texts with appraisal variables are longer and contain more
details. This exemplifies the greater control for users. | [
0.0327285603,
0.0165234692,
-0.0173896551,
0.02452025,
-0.0353996642,
0.0033456383,
0.0139431208,
-0.0336098,
0.0447765067,
-0.0498478748,
-0.0052360101,
-0.0032379481,
-0.0139605049,
0.0249979589,
-0.0235387236,
-0.1102587208,
0.0069907783,
0.0642997101,
0.0696633235,
0.0312817916,
0.0498998463,
0.0494779162,
0.0001515375,
0.0127619859,
-0.0533933789,
0.0144850342,
-0.0240636766,
0.0199759118,
0.0348313898,
-0.0684026107,
0.0003038327,
0.0349727422,
0.0151546095,
-0.0637166277,
0.0000021433,
-0.0270057656,
0.0084889596,
-0.0189378224,
0.0510002449,
-0.0105506694,
0.1163625568,
0.0032593785,
0.0014601911,
-0.0154772419,
-0.0292479564,
-0.002817346,
0.0489522815,
0.073465161,
0.0333184898,
0.0652531832,
-0.044173196,
-0.0322891064,
-0.0515037328,
0.0242004953,
0.0486108661,
0.0141390897,
-0.0394827537,
0.0103649469,
0.0386218168,
-0.0406270958,
-0.0085460832,
-0.023602182,
0.0048358613,
0.0125266323,
0.0140018566,
0.0367122851,
0.0197654627,
-0.0306208488,
-0.012187521,
0.0374706797,
0.0116086146,
0.0073882383,
0.0064432858,
-0.0353166088,
0.0288106892,
-0.0247950573,
0.0041711004,
0.0470166169,
-0.0447855033,
0.0177173931,
0.0154823083,
0.0633872002,
-0.0251590498,
0.0576038212,
0.0566192642,
0.0139657706,
-0.0174716879,
-0.0271660555,
-0.0188732035,
0.029612625,
-0.0193801597,
-0.0529745184,
0.0281081107,
0.0246603154,
0.0094890911,
0.0078253634,
-0.0751759261,
-0.0042109136,
-0.0094932299,
-0.0827822089,
-0.0372221842,
0.0288393367,
-0.0441306829,
-0.0110582504,
0.016957609,
0.0423310101,
0.0442508385,
-0.0362294577,
-0.0545679145,
0.0639911443,
-0.0187195353,
0.0207289476,
-0.0307488013,
0.0487153642,
-0.043336954,
-0.0124841835,
-0.0734320655,
-0.0250524879,
-0.0024175965,
-0.0297787506,
-0.0238665659,
0.0386428721,
-0.0219783317,
0.0491136163,
-0.0442821048,
-0.0078888489,
-0.077351816,
0.0307742245,
0.0221388526,
-0.0100697055,
0.0218245015,
0.0332915112,
0.0296287332,
-0.0037099747,
0.008935431,
0.0296471789,
-0.0098186247,
0.0017172914,
-0.0651554987,
-0.0609814748,
-0.032787703,
-0.0369033851,
-0.0425687842,
-0.0223981515,
0.0068551372,
0.0009241424,
-0.0094677238,
-0.0134478835,
0.0296132956,
0.0206091292,
-0.0014211742,
0.0294595156,
-0.0174991209,
-0.0116178291,
-0.0295933206,
0.0004139071,
0.0195621494,
0.020838188,
0.0571673699,
0.1041852459,
0.0212179553,
0.0142980907,
0.0314236283,
-0.0411118716,
-0.0135667091,
-0.0400129594,
-0.0226807017,
-0.0443585515,
-0.05748602,
0.0343685187,
0.0306874663,
0.0524807647,
-0.0318010487,
0.0412952825,
0.0540431179,
0.0131121222,
-0.0199783035,
0.0549500026,
0.0463517755,
0.0210860651,
-0.0076732007,
0.044775255,
-0.0020216904,
0.0574384704,
-0.0188097674,
0.0114040915,
-0.0128042186,
0.0062017352,
-0.0194746256,
-0.0716086626,
-0.0272079222,
-0.0028404193,
0.0533661395,
-0.0058416883,
-0.0097580925,
0.0157325789,
-0.0740380287,
-0.0438883379,
0.0164995566,
-0.1128065065,
0.048547335,
-0.0234559886,
0.0230212174,
0.1452300251,
0.0254004747,
0.0152824055,
0.0010620619,
0.0144778704,
-0.0258269981,
0.051277779,
0.0642600954,
0.0051137279,
-0.023180997,
-0.0571261607,
0.0135409525,
-0.050918851,
0.0044594128,
0.003203962,
-0.0455470458,
0.0308409072,
0.0161345862,
0.0360134095,
-0.0468275547,
0.0187563151,
0.0212148037,
-0.0472413599,
-0.0063230074,
0.0107638109,
-0.0000370707,
0.021153558,
-0.0017125922,
0.0075505264,
0.0158081409,
0.0236295294,
-0.0330118872,
0.0615385994,
-0.02438231,
-0.057641916,
-0.0231228359,
-0.0299972165,
0.0308131948,
-0.0339035839,
-0.0161707886,
-0.0166399218,
0.0257327128,
-0.027324589,
0.0046664276,
-0.0221162867,
0.0092597669,
-0.004538476,
-0.0130323693,
-0.0074062608,
0.0741048306,
0.0109644216,
-0.0137738753,
-0.0114600332,
0.0072410209,
-0.0082314862,
-0.0353383534,
-0.0479647927,
-0.0200126264,
0.0235935319,
0.021806119,
0.0318735763,
-0.0000418687,
-0.067348592,
-0.0460022166,
-0.0951461568,
0.000411259,
0.0101981498,
0.0118741496,
0.0222123358,
-0.0214351024,
-0.0080486583,
0.0381887481,
-0.0401331522,
-0.0066998368,
0.0048865471,
0.005602398,
0.0195603725,
0.0117963133,
0.0072381934,
-0.0718769729,
0.023280615,
-0.0283903349,
0.0105310744,
0.0817643702,
-0.0307696518,
-0.0276718736,
0.0757544413,
-0.0647838488,
-0.0089194654,
0.0177341476,
-0.0856036618,
0.0247447267,
0.0276726279,
0.0350525714,
0.047432743,
0.0241974015,
0.1050076112,
0.0284589771,
-0.0293616802,
-0.0367050469,
0.0151970331,
-0.0506042913,
0.017476676,
0.0183130782,
-0.0521643758,
-0.0082373777,
0.0398563072,
0.0668741465,
0.0275886171,
-0.068224445,
0.0138497632,
-0.0249017514,
-0.036719501,
0.0202389751,
-0.0679133832,
0.0019378733,
0.0208014715,
-0.0008177743,
-0.0512318052,
0.0595742948,
0.0484249517,
-0.008306467,
-0.0653098151,
0.0322486237,
-0.0093112104,
0.0745177492,
-0.0353731401,
0.0401763394,
0.0422596484,
0.0052364171,
-0.0015172072,
-0.0507586598,
0.0089578349,
-0.045454789,
-0.0223343708,
-0.0444278196,
-0.032141611,
0.0279814061,
-0.0228998661,
-0.0134835662,
-0.0518357567,
-0.0088305781,
-0.0274151079,
0.0137358429,
0.0116753159,
-0.0012602374,
0.0106940316,
0.0564577356,
-0.0269094612,
-0.0387828238,
-0.0285319071,
0.0230156071,
-0.0091791758,
0.0456500091,
-0.0348643623,
0.0216016024,
-0.0252438448,
-0.0099313268,
0.0360847078,
0.0291191824,
0.023505833,
-0.0132973688,
0.0239135195,
-0.0079249805,
-0.0001582301,
-0.0245695915,
0.019780999,
0.0232445542,
-0.0302589256,
0.0101909293,
0.1036446467,
0.0256816614,
-0.0039107497,
0.0282035656,
-0.0064081023,
-0.0089223636,
-0.0013689519,
0.0157220997,
-0.0559776798,
-0.0063152988,
-0.023729302,
0.0318703018,
-0.0428256579,
-0.0109538408,
-0.0036804022,
-0.061890278,
0.0333981924,
0.0125636663,
-0.0019666171,
-0.0263541341,
0.0038230293,
-0.0116272802,
0.0148012638,
-0.0167128481,
-0.0048823324,
0.0076161721,
0.0108928178,
0.0334075056,
0.001797023,
-0.0504371636,
0.0114530046,
-0.0103549082,
0.0165763423,
0.0479145981,
0.0805112198,
-0.0048636482,
-0.016806541,
-0.003016636,
0.0342928693,
0.0409011804,
-0.0273663905,
0.0433512107,
-0.0145171359,
-0.0062230839,
-0.0857515261,
0.0221444909,
0.039219629,
-0.0216706991,
-0.0114817815,
0.0441198386,
-0.0271089915,
-0.0530699119,
-0.0321611091,
0.0396579094,
0.0615976565,
0.065885596,
0.0156733096,
-0.0562960096,
-0.0019964846,
0.0167591237,
0.0478610545,
-0.0489788689,
-0.038488023,
-0.0211049151,
-0.0300205629,
-0.0248237886,
-0.098326087,
-0.0736303329,
0.0124449395,
0.0391629376,
0.0005883463,
-0.0621113554,
0.0129416035,
-0.0169055276,
-0.0283086728,
0.0254808888,
0.0357533097,
-0.0165671576,
0.0380658954,
-0.0299149901,
0.0391589701,
-0.0415422544,
0.0156657007,
0.0114298705,
0.0001294135,
-0.0192881152,
0.0246290565,
0.0520178266,
0.0122092916,
-0.0233789477,
0.0281086192,
-0.042753689,
-0.0106313089,
0.0246729199,
-0.0357960276,
0.0092821475,
-0.0138757136,
0.0540059172,
0.0164076071,
-0.0134832719,
-0.0112495022,
0.0389607549,
-0.0074020624,
0.0117910933,
0.0278033782,
-0.0585373193,
0.0182655118,
0.0187265053,
-0.0165946167,
-0.0619249754,
-0.0374986306,
-0.0382179841,
-0.0463196598,
-0.0533159934,
-0.0425647907,
-0.0468697138,
-0.0068716565,
-0.0241757762,
0.0441399813,
-0.0471859016,
-0.0470507108,
-0.0465406328,
0.0080579389,
-0.0353917778,
0.0263812002,
0.0281063244,
0.0004045852,
-0.0022963935,
0.0219327509,
-0.0644678101,
-0.0167855993,
-0.0269018989,
0.0088454941,
-0.0255412217,
0.066779919,
0.0049541122,
-0.0049343617,
-0.0063415882,
0.0040665967,
0.0096041551,
0.0621253438,
-0.0430374853,
-0.007236768,
0.004133828,
-0.0119102336,
0.0584273078,
-0.0712579712,
0.0449361317,
0.0036907969,
0.0334280469,
-0.0074537783,
-0.0764864534,
0.0141165741,
-0.0130248992,
-0.0143762687,
-0.0566345043,
0.0189864896,
-0.0824914351,
0.0595259666,
-0.0068913396,
-0.0161002371,
-0.0342974886,
0.0174221992,
0.04693643,
-0.0290700365,
-0.0003481018,
0.011212728,
-0.0970895588,
0.0085090445,
0.038479317,
-0.0164261144,
0.0335069448,
-0.0525611155,
0.0600583293,
0.0388629958,
-0.03133104,
-0.0054510538,
-0.0109206149,
0.0309391767,
-0.054897707,
0.0062033026,
-0.0670405254,
-5.766878307e-33,
-0.0260972995,
-0.0473559052,
-0.0059537808,
0.012857452,
-0.0520332828,
-0.006042066,
-0.0342622958,
0.0155322561,
0.0372258984,
0.0568828844,
0.0107572703,
-0.0240389761,
0.0046526068,
0.0053770994,
0.0078309905,
-0.0377875939,
0.0380512252,
-0.0142636914,
-0.0393680334,
0.0320042185,
0.041168578,
-0.0262518711,
0.0562918857,
-0.0887328535,
0.0429669619,
-0.0032501752,
-0.0731224194,
-0.0182672199,
0.0498507805,
0.0317016803,
-0.0084053157,
0.0411808304,
0.0191523544,
0.0178025737,
-0.0091533354,
0.0232763588,
0.0180177744,
-0.0233935174,
0.0454198383,
-0.0108383195,
-0.0347621515,
-0.0277828816,
0.0222161114,
0.0177203249,
-0.0412773676,
0.0170458555,
0.0316855423,
-0.0043782615,
0.0404586568,
-0.1012744382,
-0.0756433383,
0.0101249479,
0.0124830026,
-0.0534227043,
0.0044418676,
0.0425891168,
-0.0272625387,
-0.0113693429,
-0.0065999948,
0.0207413211,
-0.0066863624,
0.0060421186,
0.0025379662,
-0.033967793,
-0.0024013387,
0.0612434931,
0.0136156902,
0.0639730096,
-0.0476634651,
0.0644750595,
0.0105549907,
0.0114945564,
0.04786852,
0.0544776879,
0.0017036904,
-0.0283646975,
-0.0166024417,
0.0431457423,
0.0127266375,
0.0050092433,
0.0563514046,
0.0056170304,
-0.0399357975,
0.0015398972,
-0.0084881363,
0.0049663144,
-0.0309247002,
-0.0335867479,
0.0059091253,
0.0053628068,
-0.0041884906,
-0.0244857818,
-0.0387292057,
0.0273778737,
-0.0026954669,
0.0253744591,
-0.0474022664,
0.0663858801,
-0.040400967,
-0.0224620812,
-0.0214369074,
-0.0127860019,
0.0286944099,
0.0401512794,
0.0350951962,
0.0377812125,
-0.0185926277,
0.0535810739,
-0.022449296,
0.0165691264,
-0.0023838349,
0.0362597629,
0.0123624336,
-0.046621304,
-0.0156031428,
-0.0053054551,
-0.0263829231,
-0.0097807404,
0.0108981244,
0.0198792666,
-0.0002632877,
-0.0319058858,
0.0174898859,
0.0481618084,
-0.0397373289,
0.025108058,
0.0042035608,
-0.0199436583,
-0.0198066421,
-0.0056594326,
-0.0183857605,
0.0180902183,
2.876e-7,
-0.0182318836,
0.0454345271,
0.0322954319,
0.0136728976,
-0.0060994038,
0.0477743037,
0.0396877825,
0.0369515568,
0.0452004112,
-0.0055049872,
0.0219297968,
-0.0032640258,
0.0336450934,
0.0333911926,
-0.0407225713,
0.0238804594,
0.0008613235,
0.0244418029,
0.0025729381,
0.0092213871,
0.1465512514,
0.0043548718,
0.033159174,
0.0188029371,
0.0181853026,
0.0357617773,
0.0465779938,
-0.0159245208,
-0.0270216651,
0.0020210885,
-0.006865731,
-0.0171749797,
-0.0241819359,
-0.0008660923,
-0.0098890653,
-0.0460458696,
0.0115826707,
0.0496252999,
0.0010817975,
-0.0293179564,
0.0471338034,
0.0084895203,
-0.0274914913,
-0.0292118713,
0.0228105355,
-0.0514444932,
-0.0155440299,
-0.002432432,
-0.0201647021,
-0.0003294432,
-0.019438114,
-0.04064833,
-0.0638175085,
0.032085754,
0.0111533124,
0.016276639,
-0.0473095104,
-0.0355555788,
-0.0401838757,
0.0258694161,
-0.0060195313,
-0.0425302163,
-0.0446810126,
0.0443445817,
-0.0062815039,
-0.0596713983,
0.0018729018,
2.206440779e-34,
0.0142857516,
0.0054071783,
0.0000875641,
-0.0297588836,
0.0443519093,
0.061973758,
-0.0347900949,
0.0036209584,
0.0636546314,
-0.0072052181,
-0.0188674647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00108v1 | DPBERT: Efficient Inference for BERT based on Dynamic Planning | 2023-07-26T07:18:50 | 2023-07-26T07:18:50 | Weixin Wu, Hankz Hankui Zhuo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large-scale pre-trained language models such as BERT have contributed
significantly to the development of NLP. However, those models require large
computational resources, making it difficult to be applied to mobile devices
where computing power is limited. In this paper we aim to address the weakness
of existing input-adaptive inference methods which fail to take full advantage
of the structure of BERT. We propose Dynamic Planning in BERT, a novel
fine-tuning strategy that can accelerate the inference process of BERT through
selecting a subsequence of transformer layers list of backbone as a
computational path for an input sample. To do this, our approach adds a
planning module to the original BERT model to determine whether a layer is
included or bypassed during inference. Experimental results on the GLUE
benchmark exhibit that our method reduces latency to 75\% while maintaining
98\% accuracy, yielding a better accuracy-speed trade-off compared to
state-of-the-art input-adaptive methods. | [
0.0642213747,
0.0343171842,
-0.0124200489,
-0.0012702602,
-0.0146673145,
-0.0010437694,
0.0108263437,
0.0001537709,
0.0024751523,
-0.0337828621,
-0.0121803218,
0.0044121007,
-0.0126447445,
-0.0393552706,
0.0154615715,
-0.0692931861,
0.0298844371,
-0.0085296882,
-0.0181287359,
-0.0102403117,
0.0030173962,
0.005415339,
-0.0024199993,
0.0503937602,
0.0096525159,
0.0170957688,
-0.0298103783,
0.0567717217,
-0.0099011799,
-0.0375693813,
0.0195829198,
0.0591117479,
-0.0173027422,
0.0273752417,
0.000001822,
-0.0213999152,
-0.0406327955,
-0.0080547677,
-0.0101558575,
0.0281605851,
-0.0618275627,
0.0309446827,
-0.0149303721,
0.0490422845,
-0.0122395251,
0.0031337228,
0.0317737088,
0.0249615889,
0.0346235335,
0.0843544826,
-0.0269313622,
0.0140514169,
0.0005436446,
-0.0126088299,
-0.0276950095,
-0.0239128135,
0.0000509022,
-0.0707829073,
0.0107723391,
-0.0463385694,
0.0194126647,
0.0248575769,
0.0339383036,
0.0318962485,
-0.0324203148,
0.0237732232,
-0.0685117021,
-0.0539226606,
-0.0477744788,
0.0657097101,
-0.0647002682,
-0.046428889,
0.0331234001,
-0.0021845826,
-0.0170597956,
0.0212003831,
-0.0148739461,
-0.0091609163,
-0.0207263436,
-0.0041907467,
-0.0008873475,
-0.0330546014,
0.0335801318,
-0.014792501,
-0.0695400238,
0.050712537,
0.0466972701,
-0.0353633389,
-0.027128147,
-0.0029737693,
-0.0496303104,
-0.0506689474,
0.0615998991,
0.0277615283,
-0.0306038428,
0.0090685543,
-0.0452627726,
-0.0288880784,
-0.0136031946,
-0.0615808852,
0.0670938864,
0.0497077554,
-0.0192235149,
0.0248263534,
-0.0361428708,
0.0275045503,
-0.0476737358,
0.0213258658,
-0.0216293242,
-0.0021719532,
-0.0093915481,
0.0207858477,
-0.0598448776,
0.0518528819,
-0.0449365452,
-0.0427827798,
-0.0098415222,
0.0364876762,
0.0430715047,
-0.0397672392,
0.028771583,
-0.0015126353,
-0.0238475744,
-0.0140425907,
0.0147179067,
0.0259648375,
-0.0669169202,
0.0181131344,
-0.0342333429,
-0.07326217,
-0.0031381682,
0.0082511902,
0.0282282233,
-0.0303098839,
0.0062398645,
0.0586938001,
-0.0042250161,
-0.0496550314,
-0.055514358,
0.0133643281,
0.0036134517,
-0.0130773261,
0.0419799984,
-0.0444771796,
0.0051278314,
0.0047191372,
-0.0038820503,
0.0030784989,
0.0043055625,
0.0260078572,
-0.021810282,
0.0269292761,
-0.0132047683,
0.0123485457,
-0.0013894243,
-0.0155824339,
-0.0035410763,
0.0516240969,
0.0421273671,
0.0227420256,
0.0264392868,
0.027858641,
-0.0075293924,
0.0811357349,
0.0259503014,
-0.0127018383,
-0.0280373711,
-0.029046895,
-0.0355100669,
-0.0083370358,
-0.0332529768,
0.0490905643,
-0.0286966637,
0.0100820502,
0.0319853164,
0.0674855858,
0.0629900768,
0.05925598,
0.0013940462,
-0.0064198258,
0.0333286114,
-0.0015411966,
-0.0411135033,
-0.0119154975,
-0.0309118871,
-0.0020947936,
0.0325293317,
0.0537931807,
-0.0172339678,
0.0006450195,
-0.0561281256,
-0.0112562096,
-0.0140644349,
-0.0084322384,
0.0237580761,
0.0389382988,
-0.0470547937,
0.0953130424,
0.0175759755,
-0.0340424366,
-0.0430406928,
-0.0519640669,
0.005383275,
0.0385396704,
0.0571499541,
-0.0282403696,
-0.0925232619,
0.0471933484,
0.0018152507,
0.0427337512,
0.0101734726,
-0.021350408,
0.043609675,
-0.03821088,
-0.0398893133,
0.0541327223,
0.0097690476,
0.0149859488,
0.0797206461,
-0.0166953672,
-0.0060918084,
-0.0508492403,
0.0289446916,
0.0487915389,
-0.007400339,
-0.0238145757,
0.0234160088,
0.0364386775,
0.0136450212,
-0.0031761955,
-0.0311188884,
-0.0208919365,
0.0249367692,
-0.0269501153,
0.0219190661,
0.0306464843,
-0.0302953236,
-0.0668697134,
0.0257884096,
-0.0099320784,
-0.0089586778,
0.022426866,
-0.0116597805,
-0.0174985342,
-0.0010882365,
-0.040207006,
0.0953349546,
-0.0091346651,
0.051556088,
0.0041389656,
0.0044359872,
0.0168320201,
0.04025748,
-0.0123652956,
0.0086170416,
0.056210693,
0.0247187689,
0.018622471,
-0.0055592577,
-0.0245926511,
0.0224077255,
-0.01802928,
-0.0138780996,
0.0361897461,
0.0015795978,
-0.0071627125,
-0.0491971113,
-0.0763736665,
0.0138076758,
-0.0324342772,
0.0417714119,
0.0378921963,
0.0754279569,
-0.0058231046,
-0.0476760082,
0.0218434632,
-0.0111149838,
-0.0441075824,
0.0462849215,
-0.0094122849,
-0.0139019629,
-0.0186789278,
-0.0302554052,
-0.0143612381,
-0.0233348515,
0.0517231077,
-0.0099416114,
-0.0436803512,
0.0093652802,
-0.1066840738,
-0.0140381763,
0.0530550703,
0.0224771593,
-0.067733191,
0.001194858,
-0.0343497321,
0.0525035225,
0.0213921051,
0.0066965269,
0.0055712769,
-0.0215439778,
-0.0062439716,
-0.0518613346,
0.0382329635,
-0.0391504057,
0.0198750533,
-0.0465939976,
-0.0100957127,
0.0101456251,
0.1203420386,
-0.0480133258,
0.0250560343,
-0.0600417219,
-0.0572691113,
0.0216015074,
-0.0154581061,
0.0502502061,
0.0175063293,
-0.0315856226,
0.0050883088,
-0.0218028389,
-0.0214074422,
0.0942705795,
-0.0354028679,
-0.0148847895,
-0.0397359282,
0.0370628163,
0.0017671966,
0.0427486598,
0.0033071025,
0.0172718409,
-0.0012604459,
-0.0513690002,
-0.025349563,
0.0199409164,
0.0071927942,
-0.0201851316,
0.0106177554,
-0.0558617525,
0.0139688235,
0.0003641173,
-0.0741692483,
-0.0425101221,
-0.0250457581,
-0.0259207785,
0.0019049161,
0.0141630825,
-0.0710401833,
-0.0660280138,
0.0065848362,
-0.0071740244,
0.0907317922,
-0.0033606486,
0.0231666211,
-0.0178599879,
0.0673901886,
0.0046036155,
0.0286839548,
0.0035296613,
-0.0191619582,
0.0244721957,
0.0170104727,
0.0658701062,
-0.0056666355,
-0.0393176153,
0.0372848026,
0.0507261753,
-0.0327189378,
-0.0227510426,
0.0545628257,
0.0333807543,
-0.0369294994,
-0.0055475207,
0.1235364974,
0.0251356177,
0.0005815424,
0.0022620047,
0.0249921381,
0.0565275885,
-0.0100164674,
0.05297672,
-0.0551652014,
-0.0691107437,
0.0315414779,
0.0238769092,
0.01596912,
-0.010476389,
0.0160768479,
-0.0857939348,
-0.013746392,
-0.0311179832,
0.0535831749,
0.0293211266,
-0.0550159551,
-0.0033874458,
0.0172981713,
-0.0008338884,
0.0015620856,
-0.0032967774,
-0.0112826349,
0.022387987,
-0.0656263828,
-0.0294551514,
-0.0121929692,
-0.0310004447,
0.0046688598,
0.0901646912,
0.0290559549,
0.0172898807,
-0.035089165,
0.0544124469,
-0.030149037,
-0.0070181172,
-0.0433574431,
-0.0007472467,
-0.0035224771,
0.0149454288,
-0.0143228248,
0.0193676576,
-0.0029722056,
-0.0223939344,
-0.0314402655,
0.0819367468,
0.0091651753,
0.0077017345,
-0.0271711517,
-0.0167541951,
-0.0217325408,
0.0342008434,
0.0200422332,
-0.0539267547,
-0.0493194051,
-0.0128315585,
-0.0375747345,
-0.0652755648,
0.0087363571,
0.0116671408,
-0.0293765683,
-0.0407200493,
-0.0615170412,
0.0173863489,
0.0381016023,
0.0712163299,
0.0203765444,
-0.0377063528,
0.0402363613,
0.0253006034,
-0.0525787361,
0.0172771718,
0.0492471755,
0.000417884,
-0.0616745166,
-0.0165545866,
0.0354963467,
-0.0127245616,
-0.0172396731,
0.0051699462,
-0.0355785526,
-0.0740971044,
0.0344974436,
0.0345268697,
0.0209508613,
0.0540407598,
-0.0620867051,
-0.0503340848,
0.0684242845,
0.0717835873,
-0.0215947796,
-0.0125519186,
0.0276363622,
-0.0142982192,
0.0000388525,
0.0430584438,
-0.0552241951,
0.0068830498,
0.0142803453,
0.0799355134,
-0.0254140832,
-0.0207720585,
0.0215733238,
0.0130052567,
0.0818983987,
-0.0153438738,
-0.0209512655,
-0.0098246122,
0.0500235409,
0.0275969114,
0.004862024,
-0.0419626199,
0.0287273042,
-0.0237959083,
0.0180083141,
-0.020367112,
0.0510762632,
0.0020830671,
-0.0088399379,
-0.0270218924,
0.0357424542,
0.0360765383,
-0.0031272538,
0.006015229,
-0.0353428647,
0.009569901,
0.0145862401,
0.0216056127,
0.0168261267,
-0.0566690303,
0.0211653188,
0.0238394625,
-0.0075576352,
-0.050929863,
0.0067211716,
-0.0626498312,
-0.0176341385,
-0.0522408187,
0.076443851,
0.02180757,
-0.0053405319,
0.0473910868,
-0.0039504608,
-0.0117099602,
0.003163439,
0.0008305418,
-0.0168010257,
-0.0241060145,
0.0349695645,
0.0072758445,
0.0045082006,
-0.0116768666,
0.0546504706,
0.0117139909,
0.0560069904,
0.0040304004,
-0.0222878009,
-0.034707468,
-0.0639235228,
0.0387266167,
0.0099107809,
-0.0436053537,
0.0334503576,
-0.0166035574,
-0.0468839817,
0.0110854236,
0.009549357,
0.0304541923,
-0.0295973923,
0.0185304098,
0.0501032323,
0.020362569,
-0.0634997189,
-0.0046704616,
-0.0160800591,
-0.0020594606,
-0.0151165808,
0.016554147,
-6.412539885e-33,
-0.0224376898,
0.0095162848,
-0.0001691223,
-0.0572460555,
-0.0067465538,
0.0147655541,
-0.0362084806,
-0.0185614452,
-0.020621663,
-0.0071126171,
-0.0681928098,
0.0232058167,
0.0228151344,
0.0382701829,
-0.0255241301,
0.0122901537,
0.0634219795,
0.003767278,
-0.0548496395,
-0.0181622133,
-0.0141964033,
0.0672011748,
0.0490294136,
0.0448714867,
-0.0608163029,
0.0035094703,
0.0074115018,
0.0042259563,
0.026969865,
0.0508157685,
-0.0019118392,
-0.0230829902,
-0.0017416867,
0.0071897027,
-0.007593486,
0.0306239836,
-0.1065401062,
-0.0357271209,
0.0029830681,
0.0599363819,
-0.0533237718,
0.0247166157,
0.04531743,
-0.0015137201,
-0.0125454431,
0.0241263211,
0.0169314314,
-0.0016665608,
-0.0471980125,
-0.0343647972,
-0.0356096178,
0.0375996903,
0.0114538958,
-0.0442944616,
0.047703173,
0.0358253904,
-0.0262568519,
-0.0178307835,
-0.021554118,
-0.0117656477,
0.0102769574,
0.0492040068,
0.0346332416,
0.0318339914,
0.0175218657,
0.0361857563,
0.0055265129,
-0.0286438484,
-0.0106664803,
-0.007106333,
0.0385118797,
0.0490352102,
0.0098837633,
-0.0281634722,
0.0535586923,
0.0150096128,
-0.0471395329,
0.0189255532,
0.0612523071,
0.0276354011,
0.0252897814,
-0.0010970158,
0.0005227056,
-0.006902393,
-0.0215426274,
-0.0034810361,
-0.0223641098,
-0.0159001015,
0.0132434284,
0.0246759523,
-0.036898002,
0.0341925919,
0.0511245914,
-0.0157941561,
0.0030530714,
-0.0103337131,
-0.004395776,
0.0118173789,
-0.0134489872,
0.053922005,
-0.0398816578,
-0.0515212007,
0.0055537918,
0.0067948424,
0.0169559401,
-0.0021728133,
0.0023075014,
0.0380776525,
-0.0630569458,
-0.020281665,
-0.0463398695,
-0.0103452653,
-0.020863628,
0.0395172276,
0.0786395967,
-0.0011158119,
0.0026357167,
0.0131568471,
-0.0181721188,
0.0006070528,
-0.0101034511,
0.0076001696,
0.0431519784,
0.0346895903,
-0.0361815244,
-0.0218791123,
-0.0632528439,
0.0401606523,
-0.0415068455,
-0.0935024098,
-0.026671499,
0.0469303541,
2.663e-7,
0.0144297732,
0.0317585096,
0.0534790568,
-0.0028895328,
0.0054170899,
-0.0087778484,
0.0170455854,
0.0189297777,
-0.0061817137,
0.0330721512,
0.0112500712,
-0.0048047882,
0.048729986,
0.0044786739,
-0.084461987,
-0.0270766914,
-0.0882986113,
0.0462495387,
-0.0484740846,
-0.0159854386,
-0.002724909,
0.0881440416,
-0.0081631038,
-0.0095323985,
0.009917534,
-0.0203808472,
0.0337322466,
0.0066097924,
0.0315174423,
0.0162031222,
0.0461233184,
0.0199217387,
-0.0140806688,
-0.0141642569,
-0.0330322683,
0.039281413,
-0.0192725249,
0.0570821911,
-0.0155414371,
-0.0239067581,
0.0215675384,
-0.0611684136,
-0.0154715637,
-0.0151738776,
0.0513958596,
-0.0292538069,
-0.0045032571,
0.0397814102,
-0.0142298797,
-0.0109486552,
-0.0509054326,
-0.0239572432,
-0.0136277545,
0.0308397003,
0.0346883684,
-0.0285061933,
-0.0149808507,
-0.1040985584,
-0.0341924988,
-0.0175428372,
-0.0329645611,
-0.0202362463,
-0.0648062751,
-0.0106032658,
0.033130385,
-0.0753820613,
0.0093871923,
2.585031004e-34,
0.011890769,
-0.0225070957,
-0.0095288269,
0.0744283125,
0.0191802923,
-0.0186984763,
0.0689097866,
0.0016877305,
0.0228329413,
-0.072963573,
-0.0484049767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14389v1 | Diff-E: Diffusion-based Learning for Decoding Imagined Speech EEG | 2023-07-26T07:12:39 | 2023-07-26T07:12:39 | Soowon Kim, Young-Eun Lee, Seo-Hyun Lee, Seong-Whan Lee | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, 68T10 | Decoding EEG signals for imagined speech is a challenging task due to the
high-dimensional nature of the data and low signal-to-noise ratio. In recent
years, denoising diffusion probabilistic models (DDPMs) have emerged as
promising approaches for representation learning in various domains. Our study
proposes a novel method for decoding EEG signals for imagined speech using
DDPMs and a conditional autoencoder named Diff-E. Results indicate that Diff-E
significantly improves the accuracy of decoding EEG signals for imagined speech
compared to traditional machine learning techniques and baseline models. Our
findings suggest that DDPMs can be an effective tool for EEG signal decoding,
with potential implications for the development of brain-computer interfaces
that enable communication through imagined speech. | [
-0.0400244631,
0.0320435911,
-0.0151638743,
0.0054357243,
0.0036103958,
0.0002567341,
0.027309265,
0.0199958254,
0.0086795567,
0.0242537092,
-0.0117912171,
-0.0422091633,
0.0337969214,
0.0733767301,
0.0357659422,
-0.0117743323,
0.0259147566,
0.0013177771,
-0.0264699627,
-0.0635701045,
-0.0022411412,
-0.0111173419,
-0.0815029815,
0.0258058272,
0.007322005,
0.0256709252,
-0.0271534957,
-0.0073621436,
-0.0026571387,
-0.0306526721,
-0.0287936702,
0.0237737726,
0.0507871471,
-0.0595677309,
0.0000018445,
0.0117625389,
0.0324984901,
-0.0380953923,
-0.0475803353,
-0.0588506423,
-0.0239543431,
0.0323866718,
0.0251039378,
-0.0251807887,
-0.0094399825,
-0.0503881425,
0.0604731925,
0.0335939974,
0.0595583878,
0.0376490988,
-0.0162293687,
-0.0334934592,
0.0560786463,
-0.0265229903,
0.032273192,
0.026051186,
0.0238118321,
0.0106685683,
-0.0085178744,
-0.0430641584,
-0.0367983803,
0.0107413437,
0.0253194515,
0.0387756154,
0.0759155303,
0.0550550744,
0.0688593984,
-0.0808740929,
-0.0241670571,
0.0548517294,
0.0088426517,
-0.0038345014,
0.0140948296,
0.0041537541,
-0.0205696635,
0.0618120432,
0.006771985,
-0.0479150787,
0.0272126421,
0.0542382896,
0.0037434024,
0.0060171774,
0.028660588,
-0.0473065563,
-0.0375696421,
0.036947161,
0.017388247,
-0.0119275292,
0.027272379,
-0.0016076039,
0.0081136404,
-0.0184484944,
0.0623144768,
-0.0201377813,
-0.0115458444,
-0.0588899255,
-0.0372199602,
-0.05747623,
-0.0558561385,
0.0319367349,
-0.0160044786,
0.039830707,
0.0736326799,
-0.016849542,
-0.0323062465,
-0.026557127,
-0.0310630258,
-0.0160597488,
-0.0050416645,
0.0130445678,
-0.0185721815,
0.0230016094,
0.0016057717,
0.0163540915,
-0.0122923423,
-0.044356402,
-0.0480713435,
-0.0299785584,
-0.0450805053,
-0.0180974212,
0.0435516536,
0.0125010386,
-0.0075635738,
-0.0036292484,
-0.0210421216,
0.0035293361,
-0.014089915,
0.0288613494,
0.0418137796,
-0.0000556763,
-0.0290949792,
-0.0035777974,
0.0439415686,
-0.026527958,
-0.0222231708,
0.0224031694,
0.0224797595,
0.0349351689,
-0.0115630412,
0.0309923533,
0.0317377634,
0.0198819712,
0.0457248129,
-0.0862315595,
0.0019694672,
-0.0267113335,
0.0150645897,
-0.079155162,
0.0152934575,
-0.0729000494,
0.0210452974,
0.0386517085,
-0.023329718,
-0.0068551148,
0.0997142568,
0.0172303636,
-0.0170217566,
0.0008022079,
0.0215714294,
-0.0467767604,
-0.028749764,
-0.0312832445,
0.0007750579,
0.0239026807,
0.0403641164,
-0.0208006911,
-0.045386821,
-0.0773316547,
-0.0187947024,
0.0116260126,
0.0682123974,
0.0106023643,
-0.0372148007,
-0.03821183,
0.053748291,
0.0597048439,
0.0122703314,
-0.0170973279,
0.0188859161,
0.0627233237,
-0.0530647263,
-0.0321939476,
0.0579437762,
0.0175692663,
0.0303256772,
-0.0048795701,
0.0214653797,
-0.0412858501,
-0.0084490441,
-0.0293465964,
0.0548005961,
-0.0617097951,
0.0528672151,
0.0240653083,
0.0492872261,
-0.0286509283,
-0.0269054789,
0.0234760046,
0.0314331129,
-0.0129333092,
0.0270549878,
-0.0283244383,
0.0346367136,
0.0114449011,
0.0044012866,
-0.0184956305,
0.0389466695,
-0.0408568718,
-0.0296204351,
0.0074131335,
-0.0177088138,
0.0254905727,
0.0209725499,
-0.0224485602,
-0.0612736754,
0.0230992269,
0.0248529501,
0.0088555021,
-0.0573168322,
0.0425283872,
0.012744843,
0.0030011027,
-0.0040203449,
0.0048266337,
-0.0346921384,
0.0193208288,
0.0418688767,
-0.0096303616,
0.0439944118,
0.001528751,
-0.0638829172,
0.0159833655,
-0.0111903371,
-0.0590035506,
-0.0390037596,
-0.019501444,
-0.0466059744,
-0.0452197753,
-0.0107329637,
-0.0330175534,
-0.0015725766,
0.0354067087,
0.0234336313,
-0.0283166971,
0.0039381743,
-0.0230497494,
0.0331903957,
-0.0043373681,
0.0100635011,
0.0050158184,
0.0328739882,
0.0196242295,
-0.0019369539,
-0.0159094501,
-0.0317036286,
0.0099473307,
0.0414291173,
0.0173587576,
-0.04315155,
-0.0289799273,
-0.0180046223,
-0.005885331,
-0.0288404897,
-0.0097701158,
-0.0152067961,
-0.0475345403,
0.0317134298,
-0.0553886555,
-0.0089985151,
-0.0280816983,
0.0080423104,
0.0308595691,
0.0311742593,
-0.0174581409,
0.0151509792,
-0.023070775,
0.0187640935,
0.011719266,
-0.0263962578,
-0.0224387031,
-0.0268691368,
-0.0108720781,
-0.0128764324,
-0.0232062452,
-0.0260866769,
0.0652469769,
-0.047450304,
-0.0413230136,
0.0041614855,
0.0695785433,
0.0209227223,
0.0427051783,
0.0016429995,
-0.001213635,
0.0112225385,
-0.0253284089,
0.0427585952,
0.017606793,
0.0194836985,
-0.0175765753,
0.0199350975,
-0.038973663,
-0.0096514197,
-0.0232056379,
-0.0181105491,
0.0801133662,
-0.0210539903,
-0.0284594446,
-0.0179417953,
0.0441939756,
0.0796526521,
0.0230971295,
-0.0424559787,
-0.005365517,
0.0169858597,
-0.0429207161,
0.0045529795,
-0.0040482511,
-0.0240284707,
0.0292821191,
-0.0360088609,
0.0161384623,
0.09244854,
-0.0027861574,
0.0136247193,
-0.017829204,
-0.0328752436,
0.0513669848,
-0.0552516542,
0.0009940175,
0.0131081594,
-0.0305590071,
0.0044708694,
0.0176397096,
0.0562726147,
-0.0188307781,
-0.0042881058,
0.0032307359,
-0.0120425504,
-0.0247588549,
0.046955198,
0.0223828331,
-0.0663905516,
-0.0399515219,
0.0169183835,
-0.0054189777,
-0.0412241668,
0.0385158546,
-0.0398346819,
-0.0199922845,
-0.0029440264,
0.0401864126,
0.0212759525,
-0.0173341464,
0.0086240321,
0.0786300525,
0.0604584105,
0.0423075296,
-0.0428874567,
-0.0184530523,
0.0211984869,
-0.0089888759,
0.0195401069,
0.0157618281,
-0.0387948118,
0.025091717,
-0.0451720804,
0.0149326622,
0.0311333016,
0.0425815247,
0.039892979,
-0.0043435344,
-0.0113242455,
0.0890197158,
-0.0138777513,
-0.0943457559,
0.0122597869,
-0.0306666363,
0.0785419941,
-0.0021261992,
-0.0274611562,
-0.0546576194,
-0.0272378922,
-0.0344307087,
0.0112742791,
0.0010144208,
-0.0016481451,
0.0196867101,
-0.0262852646,
0.0016472472,
0.0288570989,
0.0486033373,
-0.0172876008,
-0.0682747215,
0.0000110516,
-0.0054878313,
0.0177624505,
-0.0443744473,
0.0254558902,
0.0167587958,
0.0326917805,
-0.0089894328,
-0.0831026807,
-0.0251527391,
-0.0124666411,
0.0729357675,
0.052567251,
-0.0316443704,
-0.0414902009,
-0.0543544888,
-0.0044668135,
-0.0277216565,
-0.0254479852,
-0.0051233764,
0.0145081542,
0.0163875129,
-0.0051399656,
0.0245459415,
0.0554769561,
-0.0692105442,
-0.035792619,
0.0113526927,
0.0666319877,
-0.0507634729,
-0.0479150005,
-0.000755067,
-0.0170309395,
0.0610414334,
0.0084847827,
0.0717757046,
-0.0510643311,
-0.015167173,
-0.0123051098,
0.0896780565,
0.0469360687,
-0.0624083616,
-0.0254532322,
0.0168241952,
-0.0477060899,
-0.029155897,
-0.0223560557,
-0.0111985561,
0.0249865949,
0.0516132563,
0.0272748042,
0.0967957005,
-0.062803179,
-0.0513603948,
0.0092419758,
0.0449587293,
0.0090192342,
0.0230198074,
-0.0220982675,
0.0207914691,
-0.0235894434,
-0.0103300922,
0.0024402353,
-0.0757635906,
-0.038832549,
0.0279565286,
0.0028392221,
0.0146620944,
0.0383790322,
-0.0207519624,
-0.0093765752,
0.107418865,
0.0049818559,
-0.0093706353,
0.0531762801,
0.0178419892,
0.003629114,
-0.0152375475,
-0.0137096178,
-0.0059190183,
0.0446263477,
-0.0392733403,
0.0215947628,
-0.0257694051,
0.0530356281,
-0.0073030242,
-0.0038133154,
0.0454328731,
-0.0155055951,
0.0656627193,
-0.051959686,
0.0174298994,
0.0119303837,
0.0469248928,
-0.0327682011,
-0.0442042388,
0.0495271571,
0.0086851148,
0.0048759747,
0.0157926288,
-0.0198283736,
-0.061576128,
-0.0275853258,
0.0147999367,
0.0048829289,
0.0083070435,
0.0030247257,
0.0008183229,
-0.011386334,
0.0117864879,
0.0197303277,
0.0411080457,
-0.0076647019,
0.0652663037,
0.0045080911,
-0.0387956575,
-0.0199176203,
0.0072233789,
0.0013350822,
-0.0559898764,
0.0377636738,
0.0017075546,
0.0082872706,
0.0105907954,
0.0395481437,
0.0266677793,
0.0390809663,
-0.0410677865,
0.0385806076,
-0.0515647307,
0.0252765901,
0.0329822823,
-0.0038244263,
0.0195709839,
0.0123075284,
0.0344265252,
-0.033154577,
0.0268191379,
-0.0561125651,
0.0120565826,
-0.0282766856,
-0.0409753807,
-0.0338191651,
0.0330666006,
-0.0359627418,
0.0112251183,
0.0076537938,
-0.0381352305,
-0.0215644278,
-0.0195310749,
0.0168558005,
-0.0274741221,
0.0374551117,
-0.0254335534,
-0.030848505,
0.0141941914,
0.0289303698,
-0.0225221459,
0.0136909978,
-0.0353917368,
-0.0371813662,
-6.014072647e-33,
0.0279086567,
0.0047298865,
-0.0329596698,
-0.0278368723,
-0.0571572483,
-0.0056281528,
-0.0851440877,
0.0428438596,
0.0383521542,
0.0015311906,
0.0025914235,
0.0510891601,
0.0154863587,
0.0231761374,
0.012593694,
0.0000697061,
0.0195361152,
-0.0442568548,
0.0099518765,
0.0006801903,
0.0027337526,
0.0516728051,
0.0369465984,
-0.0618827045,
0.0071596983,
0.0241870582,
0.0413206667,
-0.0555204041,
0.020436652,
-0.0082817925,
-0.0902972519,
0.0324627012,
0.0013153913,
0.0418121889,
-0.019317707,
-0.0153947668,
0.0061435993,
-0.0044922209,
-0.0629958585,
-0.0116692539,
-0.0694574118,
-0.018976178,
0.1228675619,
0.0497048274,
-0.0173764043,
0.0388688892,
0.045424249,
-0.0177757293,
-0.0085189519,
0.0085413158,
-0.0003415971,
-0.0047062994,
-0.0158680454,
0.0231062043,
0.0442163683,
-0.0143538583,
-0.0643129498,
0.000578256,
-0.0794035792,
0.0095863156,
-0.0200261921,
0.0047991662,
0.0407158546,
-0.0350625515,
0.0797984079,
0.0699758157,
0.1084416062,
0.0248593055,
-0.0421481431,
0.0113731772,
0.0358409174,
0.047042083,
-0.014978,
-0.0102866543,
0.0514835343,
-0.0508390479,
-0.052725032,
0.0281101651,
-0.0354350358,
0.0110006565,
0.0227848124,
-0.0018633916,
-0.0028319932,
-0.0463414267,
-0.0250776373,
-0.0267521627,
-0.0013083281,
0.0090024294,
0.0140257468,
-0.0596557148,
-0.0189639647,
-0.0410738736,
0.0387894325,
-0.0333581381,
0.0408808291,
-0.0470304862,
-0.0003296202,
-0.0029787451,
0.052940648,
-0.05740311,
-0.0398906246,
0.0017689812,
0.0277583562,
0.0308403485,
0.0454678163,
-0.0056718234,
-0.1109789684,
0.011541944,
0.0129946424,
-0.0286316257,
-0.0232057963,
-0.017338356,
0.0308891647,
0.0349817052,
0.0404971056,
-0.0365176015,
-0.0151230618,
-0.0116614588,
-0.0416942015,
0.0113840271,
-0.0174231734,
-0.0058127502,
0.0351836495,
0.0703852847,
-0.0216801278,
-0.0114827231,
-0.053216327,
0.0438152775,
0.0438427068,
-0.0363815799,
-0.0313095301,
0.0308560021,
2.716e-7,
-0.0338095017,
0.0093096197,
-0.0006151472,
-0.0057308683,
0.0205894019,
0.0345015451,
-0.0237141214,
0.0040892763,
-0.0086476421,
-0.1027134508,
0.0358310044,
0.068694219,
0.0405240208,
-0.0432983041,
0.0065975343,
-0.0568874702,
-0.0109505327,
0.0342398435,
-0.0030058832,
-0.0220062137,
0.0028613303,
0.0139997704,
0.0008828571,
-0.012674965,
0.0893280953,
0.0710278898,
0.0871054232,
-0.0217331164,
0.0235029925,
-0.0046937373,
0.0015157579,
-0.0472754948,
0.0166680906,
0.0552548468,
0.0073524159,
0.0163161941,
0.0086793099,
-0.016553022,
-0.0576476343,
-0.0293473173,
-0.0169223864,
0.009379182,
0.0039259503,
0.0225994643,
0.0292520989,
-0.0345706232,
-0.0409853086,
0.023870362,
-0.0721933991,
0.0133833233,
0.0985396951,
-0.010783297,
-0.0389285982,
-0.0614428185,
-0.0307773352,
0.0285117403,
0.0227337088,
0.0024562043,
0.0282375906,
0.0303555671,
-0.0992985666,
-0.0012862195,
-0.0086930608,
-0.0061826529,
-0.0053171371,
0.0297592804,
0.0143035203,
1.679804271e-34,
-0.0324020386,
0.0280338544,
-0.0041430281,
0.0304802749,
-0.0137541033,
-0.0364789777,
0.0288051255,
-0.0280429572,
-0.0087132398,
-0.0374625511,
-0.0570200682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00072v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00072v1 | How User Language Affects Conflict Fatality Estimates in ChatGPT | 2023-07-26T07:07:44 | 2023-07-26T07:07:44 | Daniel Kazenwadel, Christoph V. Steinert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | OpenAI's ChatGPT language model has gained popularity as a powerful tool for
complex problem-solving and information retrieval. However, concerns arise
about the reproduction of biases present in the language-specific training
data. In this study, we address this issue in the context of the
Israeli-Palestinian and Turkish-Kurdish conflicts. Using GPT-3.5, we employed
an automated query procedure to inquire about casualties in specific
airstrikes, in both Hebrew and Arabic for the former conflict and Turkish and
Kurdish for the latter. Our analysis reveals that GPT-3.5 provides 27$\pm$11
percent lower fatality estimates when queried in the language of the attacker
than in the language of the targeted group. Evasive answers denying the
existence of such attacks further increase the discrepancy, creating a novel
bias mechanism not present in regular search engines. This language bias has
the potential to amplify existing media biases and contribute to information
bubbles, ultimately reinforcing conflicts. | [
0.0286106151,
0.0556036942,
-0.0303774588,
0.0084428443,
-0.0419308022,
0.0100539569,
0.0684320554,
0.0067519019,
0.0110412259,
-0.0193087421,
0.0167031214,
-0.0130674802,
-0.0015366682,
-0.0067513641,
0.0104109282,
-0.0198469367,
0.0437145382,
-0.0096365428,
0.0744668096,
-0.0179026499,
0.0151101435,
0.0339455567,
-0.0179549735,
0.0451664925,
-0.0094057275,
0.0192865767,
-0.0091914106,
-0.0263462793,
0.0309020374,
-0.0309988745,
-0.0183070321,
0.0223140791,
0.0103266584,
0.0415809974,
0.0000016048,
-0.0289658774,
-0.0031097562,
-0.0008745136,
-0.0172997881,
-0.017329704,
0.0560085364,
-0.0318948179,
-0.0098842103,
0.0055861012,
-0.0400807075,
-0.0378489159,
0.0262968522,
0.0306694936,
0.044567965,
0.0873646587,
-0.0042451522,
-0.0140990987,
0.012569542,
0.0049404018,
0.0069497735,
-0.0143196257,
0.0110291475,
-0.0239614882,
-0.0546477996,
0.0110738873,
0.0121482629,
0.0322226807,
0.0073995348,
0.0375483222,
-0.0952438042,
0.0297829602,
-0.059566386,
0.0242496561,
0.0360272974,
0.0209888853,
0.0200731736,
-0.0015521462,
0.0035174836,
0.0123376977,
0.0077283084,
0.0335888974,
-0.0163185876,
0.0095783435,
-0.0408277027,
0.0008985625,
0.0351495482,
0.0276202243,
-0.0042997939,
0.014560964,
-0.0421688184,
0.0518621728,
-0.0157339834,
-0.0060153627,
0.000661863,
-0.0082801459,
-0.0215761121,
-0.0272955075,
-0.0065862564,
0.0171922613,
-0.0512676872,
-0.014863939,
-0.0007460918,
-0.0505056567,
0.0276347324,
-0.1215421781,
-0.0052666846,
0.046483852,
-0.038706813,
0.0329221487,
0.0035356295,
0.0025813961,
0.0303732622,
0.0262954254,
-0.0133336009,
-0.0074799885,
-0.0347116031,
0.0042443676,
-0.0034816305,
0.0135840112,
0.0438343994,
0.0314874277,
-0.0625300482,
-0.0126020759,
-0.0516001396,
0.004974456,
-0.035651356,
-0.0481078811,
-0.0555615276,
0.0059276191,
-0.0362954922,
0.0060926038,
-0.0602222234,
0.0292036831,
-0.044250045,
-0.1068560332,
0.0133245625,
0.0240035225,
-0.0296630207,
-0.0112914126,
-0.0263359975,
0.0529543124,
-0.0158355739,
0.0158096142,
-0.0332077444,
-0.0292408932,
0.0344170593,
-0.0112113813,
0.013865904,
-0.0464875363,
0.0395445228,
0.0100508323,
-0.0208899323,
-0.0401606672,
-0.0214826521,
0.020938877,
-0.0385634489,
0.0750064328,
0.0110797035,
0.0433433652,
0.0799623728,
0.0367202684,
0.0103609832,
0.1064020619,
0.0243128501,
-0.0198855046,
0.039664939,
0.0064028036,
0.0482507199,
0.0073822639,
0.0021654412,
0.0562999621,
-0.0394646488,
0.0299073141,
-0.0028472021,
-0.0022163403,
-0.0016021401,
0.0099176196,
-0.0405649394,
-0.054034315,
0.0424972028,
0.0566614345,
-0.052127853,
0.0408149213,
0.0074627833,
0.0243803654,
-0.0037651707,
0.0303102192,
-0.009038223,
-0.0001743414,
-0.0315609984,
-0.0219057556,
0.0372547172,
0.0516413152,
-0.0413499624,
0.0050131823,
-0.0010794102,
0.0062547419,
0.0430334695,
0.0151091181,
0.0330917425,
-0.0257383976,
0.0042443657,
0.0222215205,
0.0371300466,
-0.0400236696,
-0.0062974109,
-0.0874452069,
-0.0563535877,
-0.0094697848,
0.0125588663,
-0.0190832615,
-0.0463442989,
-0.0264650807,
0.0131947873,
0.029091116,
0.0258663204,
0.0239790622,
-0.0006070875,
-0.0288753174,
-0.0298348069,
0.0129437307,
0.0181319993,
-0.001453473,
0.0389109738,
0.0461773798,
-0.0035055673,
-0.0221471637,
-0.016641289,
0.0108134719,
0.0055277329,
-0.0193899721,
-0.0348418579,
0.0174339972,
0.0516709983,
0.0164262448,
-0.0151664829,
-0.001117925,
0.0096663702,
0.0101445802,
0.0008942853,
0.0208510701,
0.0223783907,
0.0713307112,
-0.0017252254,
-0.0500457734,
0.0054577519,
-0.0023240151,
-0.0181381851,
0.0138495332,
0.0476087146,
-0.0076672225,
0.0255991984,
0.0081309555,
-0.0119047649,
-0.0334929749,
-0.011116921,
-0.0431783386,
0.0612701625,
0.0074367151,
-0.006601627,
-0.0185740143,
-0.0292587914,
0.0735615268,
-0.0181175154,
-0.0477745831,
0.0498908162,
-0.0048192809,
0.0029591031,
0.0396033339,
-0.047650259,
-0.0019999112,
-0.0028676169,
-0.0963392481,
-0.0108060641,
-0.0106328102,
0.0030442132,
0.0191571433,
-0.0093860785,
-0.0474405102,
0.0137807364,
-0.0495135747,
-0.017865086,
0.0146263177,
0.0468406267,
-0.011552088,
-0.0095058084,
0.025286451,
-0.0298393685,
-0.0075646271,
-0.0397491381,
0.0460329279,
0.0395308509,
-0.0527851731,
-0.0051433453,
0.0094154859,
-0.07997711,
0.0191843957,
-0.0459024385,
-0.0839317963,
0.0777470991,
0.0101360157,
-0.0170400776,
0.0374890417,
0.0361980088,
0.0792058036,
0.0721855685,
-0.008495789,
-0.0459065996,
0.0001621471,
-0.068347089,
-0.082460545,
-0.0032178373,
-0.0761019886,
-0.0488081276,
0.0409278683,
0.0340279192,
0.0183367748,
-0.0284519233,
0.0128297545,
-0.0680604428,
0.0073865741,
-0.0190539453,
-0.0282046907,
0.0192006864,
0.0688032731,
-0.002889662,
-0.0159861743,
0.0599316582,
0.0348323956,
0.0587363131,
-0.0506756008,
0.0134507548,
-0.0225835126,
0.0248801503,
-0.0176118799,
0.0256248508,
0.017990768,
-0.0180616956,
-0.088764362,
-0.0565321408,
0.0600948259,
-0.0516829304,
0.0057264203,
-0.0136040207,
-0.0089779859,
-0.0065001077,
-0.0012927899,
-0.0085183652,
-0.0355306268,
-0.0030742583,
-0.0129042119,
0.0181114711,
-0.0176366288,
-0.0164446868,
0.0073213559,
0.0701436549,
-0.0106982486,
0.000346092,
-0.0193587318,
-0.0137505075,
-0.0303352289,
0.0338610671,
-0.0481952056,
0.0241063386,
0.0034655584,
0.0060732886,
0.074811995,
0.0285678692,
-0.023881739,
-0.0007264503,
-0.000584343,
0.0644080266,
-0.0003111067,
-0.0120735308,
0.0302185509,
-0.0010044198,
-0.0081523256,
0.038685821,
0.0733999982,
0.0429470837,
-0.0812960118,
-0.0113784028,
-0.0241754223,
-0.0041893376,
0.0168481469,
0.0039998475,
-0.1036414132,
0.0454135649,
0.0018128831,
0.0287258979,
-0.0725816563,
-0.045123525,
0.0287817586,
-0.0991605595,
0.0127556017,
0.0041274526,
-0.0434771702,
-0.0095160156,
-0.0593062788,
0.0016270641,
-0.0058732224,
0.0271674525,
-0.0135512101,
0.0170417503,
0.0023265514,
-0.0001440918,
-0.0557624809,
-0.0672360882,
-0.0196172781,
-0.0634607077,
0.0488903746,
0.0319016352,
0.0338196792,
-0.0547311418,
0.0274632182,
0.0319102407,
0.016867714,
-0.0350940041,
-0.0009610932,
0.0627224743,
0.0085587772,
-0.0174760353,
-0.0319798961,
-0.0055486793,
0.0320292003,
0.0052296091,
0.0226538572,
0.0251571033,
-0.0252737589,
0.0182743538,
-0.0145332916,
0.015959153,
0.0228830948,
0.0436358377,
0.0037459077,
0.0131267961,
-0.0022986133,
-0.0616369322,
0.0266765207,
0.0065782242,
-0.0811863616,
0.0285644401,
0.0006947287,
-0.0737064183,
-0.0199757759,
-0.0618029311,
0.01253937,
0.0018461569,
0.019567905,
0.0059166891,
-0.0041665216,
0.0060385838,
-0.019621104,
0.0032276625,
0.0056758984,
-0.0055739367,
0.0038710947,
0.0093912948,
-0.0267700925,
-0.008402477,
-0.0050413627,
0.0486070402,
-0.0419729874,
-0.0404631682,
0.0539251007,
0.0151471552,
0.0394288152,
-0.0140996063,
-0.0050127064,
-0.0233127624,
0.0153447175,
0.0186128803,
-0.0163888354,
-0.0080068428,
0.0087367138,
0.0011019782,
0.0522110499,
0.0211930424,
0.0166177191,
0.0167898741,
0.0413170159,
-0.0560577139,
-0.0892925262,
-0.025833521,
0.0254355222,
-0.0286586434,
0.0759244785,
-0.0081871301,
-0.0318362862,
-0.019368859,
-0.0138949491,
-0.0462819375,
0.0041959817,
0.0359539054,
-0.0285603646,
-0.0072338586,
0.034433376,
-0.0136699239,
0.0066566896,
-0.0285845958,
0.0036084345,
-0.0241782144,
0.0093612382,
0.0055200383,
0.009879034,
0.0226030294,
0.0053248298,
-0.0077939159,
0.0158669446,
-0.0070500281,
0.0139129069,
-0.0026726224,
0.0366824679,
0.0177306943,
0.009015061,
0.0647384897,
-0.0057079215,
-0.0755056888,
-0.0919847265,
0.0134098884,
-0.0085196076,
0.0323276818,
-0.0205134004,
0.0033633809,
-0.0028178603,
0.0077747507,
0.0093678664,
0.0023643228,
-0.0231599342,
-0.018267896,
0.0054164114,
0.0064972765,
-0.0089113861,
0.0255381465,
0.1090422422,
0.0046205157,
0.0515254959,
0.0107487403,
-0.0674245358,
0.0415687934,
-0.0420635417,
0.0275393911,
0.0496551953,
-0.0447412804,
-0.0164363217,
-0.0852389932,
-0.071870029,
-0.0446051396,
0.0028229053,
0.0158717223,
-0.0082432507,
-0.0047045886,
0.0765721202,
0.0102886902,
0.025286844,
-0.0565146767,
0.0384978652,
-0.0604309328,
-0.0416513272,
0.0532869101,
-5.704426129e-33,
-0.0044007674,
-0.0266579688,
0.0027475441,
-0.0294096973,
-0.0114737358,
-0.0010255044,
-0.0178532116,
0.0295255482,
-0.1028853655,
0.0163685456,
-0.001518183,
0.0417690985,
0.0125746317,
-0.0274967831,
0.0213495586,
-0.0659124628,
-0.0302436836,
-0.0024412666,
-0.0078193238,
-0.0104904007,
0.0503358245,
-0.0326630846,
0.0408849604,
-0.0985258445,
0.0388956256,
0.0058223531,
-0.0165686142,
-0.0101001393,
0.0048532463,
0.0512338392,
-0.0126759103,
0.0428746529,
0.0252990816,
-0.0214643516,
0.0288531557,
-0.0343254022,
0.033039134,
-0.014389351,
0.0458270125,
-0.0056831646,
0.0365052931,
-0.0115376944,
-0.012882635,
-0.0093417233,
-0.0682975277,
-0.0065948935,
0.0387707651,
-0.0244870707,
0.0234009381,
0.0041301069,
-0.0550602302,
0.028311586,
-0.0114533613,
0.0399742201,
-0.0265215877,
0.0276628044,
0.0417552702,
0.042359326,
-0.0821710154,
0.0198632088,
-0.0159311797,
0.035092961,
0.0212461557,
-0.0029064461,
-0.037072584,
0.0571776852,
0.0149208754,
0.033004608,
-0.0340290107,
-0.0599095263,
0.0144666191,
-0.0209608786,
0.0667097718,
0.0961210951,
0.033167731,
-0.0468371436,
-0.0898781195,
0.009154438,
0.024939863,
0.0403364785,
0.0206443761,
-0.0096359188,
-0.0682040676,
-0.043875061,
0.0122183533,
-0.0495524667,
-0.0569009744,
-0.0326548927,
-0.0003021649,
-0.0331473909,
0.025914114,
0.0280712806,
0.0273190644,
0.0126040876,
0.069263421,
0.0041158595,
-0.0203884803,
0.0251122415,
-0.0219807122,
0.041076716,
-0.01144672,
0.0197524782,
-0.0242721159,
-0.0138382707,
0.0365075916,
0.0343772024,
0.0093740877,
0.011114914,
-0.0223805346,
-0.0170971528,
-0.016781155,
0.0027945507,
0.0088702086,
-0.017178677,
0.04327498,
0.0234655775,
0.0232061055,
-0.0541832261,
0.0822757334,
-0.0589675568,
-0.0251006596,
-0.0437992103,
-0.0788601786,
-0.0054792338,
0.0100219287,
0.0105038183,
-0.0066327546,
0.04532874,
-0.0171444975,
-0.0654604807,
-0.0459613502,
-0.040510498,
2.5e-7,
0.0333984569,
0.0245992709,
-0.0178477429,
0.0522394627,
-0.0121214036,
0.0435145609,
0.02760965,
0.04523357,
0.0659795105,
-0.0283349175,
0.0054470925,
0.0399759263,
0.0383213237,
0.0708191767,
-0.0546666719,
-0.0032447921,
-0.0220592413,
0.002848835,
-0.0806641951,
0.016255172,
0.0697748289,
0.0189624317,
0.0223775841,
0.0143190175,
-0.0695158541,
-0.0041257576,
0.034177497,
-0.0497422181,
-0.0437351726,
0.0407935195,
0.0556991771,
0.0092530968,
-0.0009025997,
0.0544351339,
-0.0271036383,
-0.0422757231,
0.0462558344,
0.0138943568,
0.0224206615,
0.011182975,
-0.0200517867,
-0.0565553978,
-0.0038073899,
-0.1113044396,
0.0590456985,
0.0076542501,
-0.0249100011,
-0.000593355,
-0.0214601737,
-0.026540203,
0.0466019511,
-0.0283915661,
-0.0225484222,
0.0103876619,
0.0267663561,
0.0497806594,
0.0407689959,
-0.0219311882,
-0.0211855471,
-0.0006465357,
-0.0122112958,
-0.0530297272,
0.0091131609,
0.0330182388,
0.014426291,
0.0528751686,
0.0482901707,
2.115710523e-34,
0.0057190768,
0.0468669273,
0.0065327347,
-0.020018518,
0.0640493631,
0.0384276845,
-0.0090060178,
0.0158021841,
0.0222295523,
-0.0001951828,
-0.0155987265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13989v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13989v1 | This is not correct! Negation-aware Evaluation of Language Generation Systems | 2023-07-26T06:54:31 | 2023-07-26T06:54:31 | Miriam Anschütz, Diego Miguel Lozano, Georg Groh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models underestimate the impact of negations on how much they
change the meaning of a sentence. Therefore, learned evaluation metrics based
on these models are insensitive to negations. In this paper, we propose
NegBLEURT, a negation-aware version of the BLEURT evaluation metric. For that,
we designed a rule-based sentence negation tool and used it to create the
CANNOT negation evaluation dataset. Based on this dataset, we fine-tuned a
sentence transformer and an evaluation metric to improve their negation
sensitivity. Evaluating these models on existing benchmarks shows that our
fine-tuned models outperform existing metrics on the negated sentences by far
while preserving their base models' performances on other perturbations. | [
0.0078552747,
0.0267390199,
0.0121503621,
0.0151589466,
-0.0548083968,
0.0085301846,
0.0486599207,
-0.0305146594,
-0.0470800288,
-0.0304893237,
-0.061357554,
-0.0546879843,
-0.0083642034,
0.0629639849,
0.0366409272,
-0.0324478038,
0.0216194298,
0.0502441004,
0.0299869273,
0.0365378857,
-0.0045675142,
0.0166474637,
-0.032712616,
0.0499772243,
-0.0366174467,
0.0055494239,
-0.0053198528,
0.028861871,
0.0292751025,
-0.0378434025,
0.0116805444,
0.0348912477,
-0.0554422028,
0.0440428108,
0.0000018318,
-0.050100971,
-0.0042172782,
-0.0160983447,
0.0018789211,
-0.009614056,
0.0890227333,
-0.0360570066,
-0.0138270231,
0.0274986029,
-0.0663143024,
0.0133120492,
0.0759964883,
0.0414581969,
0.0606681257,
0.0917967707,
-0.0013956671,
0.0016251827,
-0.0116047673,
-0.0375964269,
0.0119401347,
0.0008508376,
-0.0239642728,
-0.0136352023,
-0.0355395377,
-0.0346189253,
-0.0272288751,
0.0204864182,
0.0301728938,
-0.0289504807,
0.0418208279,
0.0432974324,
-0.0451197326,
-0.0394482203,
-0.0093111107,
0.066159904,
-0.0231088195,
-0.032265652,
0.0017945927,
-0.0172814913,
-0.0127285654,
-0.0438118652,
-0.0288327001,
0.0301172286,
0.0324817598,
0.0175563712,
0.0035854271,
0.0163925979,
0.0113673108,
0.0189938471,
0.0051323576,
0.0778363198,
0.0296901166,
-0.0296711307,
-0.0493602753,
0.0103432629,
-0.009837986,
-0.0249399021,
-0.0025973879,
0.0174138229,
-0.0165183805,
0.0044456185,
-0.0479961745,
-0.0112886364,
0.012079576,
-0.033889778,
0.0403160527,
0.010918784,
0.0241167825,
0.0100631006,
-0.0700884238,
0.024647031,
0.0370177366,
0.0006219299,
-0.0391275659,
0.004227702,
-0.0321610011,
0.0004053834,
-0.0172084514,
0.0347586125,
-0.0640423223,
-0.0373886712,
-0.0460273847,
-0.0120793721,
-0.0405735597,
-0.005567187,
0.0153219197,
0.0513876751,
-0.034024395,
-0.0136354882,
-0.0194481909,
0.0409350693,
-0.0139319524,
0.0342034362,
0.0253940057,
-0.0211648792,
-0.0248122904,
0.0299187694,
0.0151988203,
0.0129994582,
-0.0005463578,
0.0587031618,
-0.0366311967,
0.0037123745,
-0.0113015426,
-0.0436991528,
-0.0266196355,
-0.0924167037,
-0.0405906625,
-0.0592594482,
-0.0205959398,
0.00392133,
-0.0281303171,
-0.0628425255,
0.014556163,
0.0071768127,
0.0244330969,
0.0316042304,
-0.001146357,
-0.0277991556,
0.0033600465,
0.0117262639,
-0.0061099813,
0.0481697805,
0.0405207761,
0.0364608839,
0.0158729199,
0.0269332621,
0.0124348728,
0.0045926622,
0.0548678935,
0.0360066742,
-0.0264913831,
-0.0261947718,
-0.0486076064,
0.0134212943,
0.028308956,
0.0688710734,
-0.0414123908,
-0.0109495064,
0.0517201535,
-0.0527752489,
0.0272636488,
0.0456412621,
0.05873226,
0.0174219105,
-0.0296122301,
-0.0081775961,
-0.0291636251,
0.0326123163,
-0.0634832084,
0.0305792056,
0.0327371247,
-0.012484327,
-0.0288536344,
-0.0391998775,
0.0170604065,
-0.029535424,
0.0307455789,
-0.051098343,
0.0226403587,
0.0441032574,
-0.0553208627,
0.0419803821,
-0.0191352013,
-0.1155583262,
0.0340979248,
-0.0076385196,
0.0446748324,
0.019465344,
0.0517942421,
0.0133411558,
-0.0502356701,
-0.0124093844,
-0.0554463007,
0.0917491019,
0.0481872633,
-0.0206842367,
0.0368568376,
-0.0722477883,
-0.0068773143,
-0.0298387818,
0.0292048752,
0.0054504708,
-0.0177806839,
0.0533126257,
0.0855975449,
-0.0106847268,
-0.0392144546,
0.0231418554,
-0.0033049828,
-0.0284785889,
0.0491538793,
-0.0056693079,
0.0419040062,
0.0129844658,
-0.0201750323,
0.0388861522,
0.0121263135,
-0.0492552221,
-0.0496365316,
-0.0135979559,
-0.0545000471,
-0.086357601,
0.0292753913,
-0.0423195474,
0.052365534,
0.0608604364,
-0.0384219103,
-0.0644595623,
0.0787682608,
-0.0280767772,
0.0227368642,
-0.0362111852,
0.0290959142,
0.0268609133,
0.0297925659,
-0.0288334936,
0.0235160533,
-0.0154182678,
0.0138255414,
0.0046345158,
0.0352171697,
0.045723442,
-0.0080607664,
-0.0354806222,
-0.0199647304,
-0.0069557345,
0.0115745505,
0.0522837974,
0.0286289155,
-0.0340528451,
-0.0474058948,
-0.0578264371,
0.0281353015,
-0.0249113645,
0.0411537811,
0.0849785954,
-0.0040538507,
0.0248621125,
0.0075191464,
-0.0447211042,
0.0236784648,
0.0469739996,
-0.017907029,
0.0398153104,
0.0141597027,
-0.0293429345,
-0.0370634161,
0.0007421873,
0.008293638,
0.0197193306,
-0.009412366,
0.0433482043,
-0.0059632035,
0.0385843962,
-0.0768830627,
-0.0252593849,
0.0409154892,
-0.0563733466,
0.0206917748,
0.0148217184,
0.026599247,
0.0299808774,
0.0226622466,
-0.001797285,
0.0254327115,
0.0162198748,
-0.0320008285,
-0.0038937025,
-0.0256764423,
0.0165258981,
-0.0057071354,
-0.0693696737,
-0.0175387096,
0.0184562765,
0.0282554291,
-0.0214829259,
-0.0694070086,
0.0624160469,
-0.0156231616,
-0.0418089665,
0.0181936454,
-0.0033099854,
-0.0173609238,
0.018261712,
-0.0394529365,
-0.0473880954,
0.0397329554,
-0.0296142846,
-0.0331526585,
-0.0485973433,
0.0184096433,
-0.0242439732,
0.0429150537,
-0.000068671,
0.0347233079,
0.0081252232,
0.0178666413,
-0.0315605104,
-0.0153067103,
0.0326742306,
-0.0149895111,
0.0186304357,
-0.0356893018,
-0.0098409513,
-0.0285634659,
-0.0193588603,
-0.0568420924,
-0.0088086771,
0.0132145546,
0.0065553351,
0.0588418879,
-0.0092394538,
-0.0310403332,
0.0065920516,
-0.014430969,
0.00924177,
-0.0466152728,
-0.0148586836,
0.0067431624,
0.0354283378,
0.0587437153,
0.011814273,
0.0576012507,
0.0155850351,
0.0106126675,
0.0325556621,
-0.0216284823,
0.0151212458,
-0.0231324416,
-0.0000518952,
0.0000115279,
0.0096969819,
-0.0092433104,
0.0291695036,
0.0328465626,
-0.0083258087,
-0.0473867729,
0.1113843918,
0.0369186886,
0.0129092261,
0.0404143482,
-0.0073463973,
0.0856065527,
0.0096313134,
-0.0181454364,
-0.0637099743,
-0.0259390939,
-0.0252152681,
0.050538417,
-0.0219052285,
-0.0338304229,
-0.0216063317,
-0.1071996763,
0.0235151257,
0.0374102406,
-0.0100044487,
-0.0198763758,
0.0014917848,
-0.0168620721,
-0.0324409008,
-0.0316168964,
0.0257153213,
-0.0068733855,
0.0188804436,
-0.0095982095,
-0.0057996684,
-0.0572670214,
-0.0345690213,
-0.0003163982,
0.073945269,
0.0036120694,
0.0415414423,
0.0060611428,
-0.0211395733,
0.0350724049,
-0.0174863804,
-0.0159253292,
-0.0384400599,
0.0660860837,
0.0199666545,
0.0029835177,
-0.0105092945,
0.0084691411,
-0.016618764,
0.0085739242,
-0.0069645923,
0.0058726016,
-0.0193123072,
-0.0391839594,
-0.0298486929,
0.0344345607,
0.0314809196,
0.0579008013,
0.0197751131,
-0.0159515887,
-0.0728092119,
-0.0067725307,
-0.0182390511,
-0.0639670268,
0.0175829288,
-0.031954065,
0.01383832,
-0.0389830135,
-0.1187624186,
-0.0536616668,
-0.0321265981,
0.0501244664,
-0.0188967306,
-0.0509655103,
0.0062516383,
-0.0142660793,
-0.0117763774,
-0.01806858,
0.0229984578,
0.0045000301,
-0.0427660868,
-0.0112437764,
0.0154019585,
-0.0030077365,
-0.0040080864,
0.0116769038,
-0.048593875,
-0.0592718981,
-0.0251981039,
0.0439710803,
0.0199827086,
0.0178370606,
-0.0181388184,
-0.0187456124,
0.0528564304,
0.0598843768,
-0.034915179,
0.0047024009,
0.070478417,
-0.0380179286,
-0.0067668762,
0.0408386067,
-0.0071488926,
0.0519004427,
0.0239502192,
0.0762801021,
0.0057251356,
-0.0212316588,
0.011508734,
0.0259136278,
0.0026286545,
-0.0396287665,
0.012333978,
-0.0083259018,
-0.0300860126,
-0.0563554056,
-0.0054785004,
-0.046530243,
-0.0063174227,
0.0528176427,
0.0051229475,
-0.0191085786,
0.0171827115,
-0.06097956,
0.0518793985,
0.0038112134,
0.0093231304,
0.0428615659,
0.0023797923,
-0.015352116,
-0.0259922817,
-0.0365924127,
-0.041575484,
0.0044544013,
0.0023760735,
-0.0137405368,
0.0296884142,
0.0109569756,
0.0275247153,
-0.0157762598,
0.0548173226,
-0.0315423645,
0.0802290738,
-0.0445023999,
0.0040223724,
0.049075339,
0.0312287286,
0.1110153943,
-0.0322779007,
0.0056953696,
-0.0309595279,
0.0393197164,
-0.0094137974,
-0.0320404842,
-0.0039057082,
-0.0141884377,
-0.0125333155,
-0.003012582,
0.0594969466,
-0.0060016811,
0.0283189416,
-0.0120834848,
0.0150133185,
-0.0592692271,
-0.028544629,
0.0135432305,
0.0011210542,
0.0050359485,
0.0393816382,
-0.038329225,
-0.0579327121,
0.0247565396,
0.042053733,
0.0447028913,
-0.0102996845,
0.0461422801,
0.0137392981,
-0.0518483929,
-0.0240440294,
-0.0531351157,
-0.0018605933,
-0.0076642539,
0.0156416111,
-0.0757188052,
-6.18594939e-33,
-0.0152398879,
-0.0121207908,
0.016467005,
0.0013154217,
-0.0313546695,
-0.0186286177,
-0.0273110345,
0.031683106,
0.0084365476,
0.0220991839,
0.0107766688,
-0.0203352682,
-0.0030398841,
0.0543122254,
-0.0110644344,
-0.0141952746,
0.094120875,
0.0128085054,
-0.0665233582,
0.0533791818,
0.0167840179,
0.0132910581,
0.0143298497,
-0.0859385654,
-0.0113470852,
-0.0110716438,
-0.0659379438,
-0.0192367844,
0.0293328594,
0.0221420638,
-0.0053995196,
0.0662089959,
0.017442029,
-0.0346970223,
-0.02471116,
-0.0479904711,
-0.0219451785,
-0.0347867459,
0.0075986404,
-0.0282445028,
-0.023552591,
-0.026662413,
0.0331530534,
0.0198201481,
-0.0432825051,
0.0424398892,
-0.0091023594,
-0.0271394495,
-0.0035832771,
-0.0298775919,
-0.0971798524,
0.0276521556,
-0.0127107259,
-0.0716152787,
-0.0306687988,
0.0609744154,
-0.0523700006,
-0.0525196828,
-0.0460200123,
0.0312502235,
0.0174039938,
0.0416616276,
0.0652442127,
0.009470351,
-0.0366004445,
0.0210964885,
-0.0092967236,
-0.0082094399,
0.0006238626,
-0.0034682436,
0.0275705978,
0.0432222039,
0.0595172979,
0.0556509234,
-0.0004548354,
-0.0350562781,
-0.0508629456,
0.0532694906,
-0.0067372378,
0.0473994799,
0.0355084799,
-0.0306001864,
0.0041786563,
-0.0113082724,
-0.0083811386,
-0.0404488631,
-0.0097138127,
-0.019545719,
0.047260996,
0.0379012413,
-0.027365081,
-0.0464638472,
0.003107988,
-0.0156799126,
0.0057943286,
0.0609007627,
-0.0453893282,
-0.0113678761,
0.0105974562,
0.0028770724,
-0.0754305795,
-0.0018008156,
0.0611567274,
0.0734660476,
-0.0145467902,
-0.0229998082,
0.0474926159,
0.0451005511,
-0.059891846,
0.0301452242,
-0.0227213148,
0.0708179474,
-0.0257013254,
0.0081597129,
-0.0047711497,
-0.0325045846,
-0.0284095742,
0.0034147662,
-0.0085867671,
0.0128560392,
-0.0097739976,
0.0251127798,
0.0491882041,
0.0277746152,
-0.0695097223,
0.0324655138,
-0.0204399563,
0.0187830608,
0.014848073,
-0.0551603846,
-0.0247337315,
0.0199232623,
2.55e-7,
0.0131968893,
0.0250536017,
0.0174736828,
0.0252797846,
0.0221858397,
0.0498683341,
-0.0116620753,
0.0397308283,
0.0187762063,
0.0607181489,
0.008610785,
-0.0268990323,
0.0157363471,
-0.000706314,
-0.0255417284,
0.0466768257,
-0.0714559257,
0.0156348888,
-0.0243534148,
-0.0069159982,
0.0910651684,
0.076460667,
-0.035463918,
0.0045414749,
0.006986646,
-0.026815936,
0.0468272418,
0.0324272923,
0.0101931626,
0.0052905916,
0.0781976655,
-0.0011743895,
0.0087192394,
-0.0024653927,
-0.0231498517,
0.0078396313,
-0.0232820008,
0.0664991587,
-0.0317706689,
-0.057648927,
0.0131684057,
-0.0068916921,
0.0065118549,
-0.0525200516,
0.0552406684,
-0.0289740842,
-0.0072082807,
-0.0030443538,
-0.0515514277,
0.0632950813,
0.0363434628,
-0.0571109988,
-0.0593684204,
-0.0012441312,
0.046738416,
-0.0069424002,
-0.0131371813,
-0.0261183381,
-0.0423907228,
0.0126073789,
-0.0019631966,
-0.0416077077,
-0.0073783891,
0.0440417156,
-0.006249337,
-0.0124280015,
0.0104845436,
2.013978833e-34,
0.0545847826,
-0.0110366838,
0.0321329609,
-0.037709821,
0.0194177981,
0.003031553,
-0.0442227609,
-0.0115368674,
0.0135949906,
-0.0436203629,
-0.0192082804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14385v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14385v4 | Mental-LLM: Leveraging Large Language Models for Mental Health Prediction via Online Text Data | 2023-07-26T06:00:50 | 2024-01-28T16:54:03 | Xuhai Xu, Bingsheng Yao, Yuanzhe Dong, Saadia Gabriel, Hong Yu, James Hendler, Marzyeh Ghassemi, Anind K. Dey, Dakuo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68U35, H.5.2; I.2.m | Advances in large language models (LLMs) have empowered a variety of
applications. However, there is still a significant gap in research when it
comes to understanding and enhancing the capabilities of LLMs in the field of
mental health. In this work, we present a comprehensive evaluation of multiple
LLMs on various mental health prediction tasks via online text data, including
Alpaca, Alpaca-LoRA, FLAN-T5, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4. We conduct a broad range of
experiments, covering zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting, and instruction
fine-tuning. The results indicate a promising yet limited performance of LLMs
with zero-shot and few-shot prompt designs for mental health tasks. More
importantly, our experiments show that instruction finetuning can significantly
boost the performance of LLMs for all tasks simultaneously. Our best-finetuned
models, Mental-Alpaca and Mental-FLAN-T5, outperform the best prompt design of
GPT-3.5 (25 and 15 times bigger) by 10.9% on balanced accuracy and the best of
GPT-4 (250 and 150 times bigger) by 4.8%. They further perform on par with the
state-of-the-art task-specific language model. We also conduct an exploratory
case study on LLMs' capability on mental health reasoning tasks, illustrating
the promising capability of certain models such as GPT-4. We summarize our
findings into a set of action guidelines for potential methods to enhance LLMs'
capability for mental health tasks. Meanwhile, we also emphasize the important
limitations before achieving deployability in real-world mental health
settings, such as known racial and gender bias. We highlight the important
ethical risks accompanying this line of research. | [
0.0462814942,
0.0648408905,
-0.0359302089,
-0.0007606578,
-0.0198234525,
0.0309221223,
0.0635716468,
0.0187958628,
0.0771044418,
-0.0325883254,
-0.0058790338,
-0.0550965108,
-0.0062325262,
0.0047130021,
0.0021571869,
-0.0707901865,
-0.0005199126,
-0.0145211192,
0.0698531941,
-0.0139570925,
0.0036106326,
0.009937766,
-0.0221491735,
0.0464641899,
0.0211183261,
-0.035680417,
0.0102386214,
0.0103560938,
0.0171568152,
-0.0796797425,
0.0147608425,
0.076018393,
-0.0137176057,
-0.0046008825,
0.0000024602,
-0.0426740684,
-0.0166916791,
-0.0070672934,
0.0037126979,
-0.0302732158,
0.0298076216,
-0.0579313263,
0.0268472861,
0.035349194,
-0.0275332313,
-0.0008082142,
0.0225942377,
0.0785301924,
0.0446072258,
0.0459656343,
-0.0226985961,
0.0014637805,
0.0062211794,
-0.0246033557,
0.015567895,
-0.0084265359,
0.0489036404,
-0.0247307029,
0.0416151062,
-0.0191494823,
-0.0140779084,
0.0266893785,
-0.0188656934,
0.0541405268,
-0.0453763194,
0.0089255413,
-0.024822956,
-0.0422221012,
-0.0073059103,
0.0903321356,
0.0066860835,
0.0511348285,
0.029598292,
-0.0179033745,
0.0026553113,
0.0021652298,
-0.0511944704,
0.019137077,
-0.011638145,
0.0036805957,
0.0281349998,
-0.0020868452,
0.0263323691,
0.0195585433,
0.025401853,
0.0987499431,
-0.0032297345,
-0.0557102375,
0.0216272324,
-0.0086778663,
-0.0390189514,
-0.060362801,
0.0186051112,
0.0364419855,
-0.0682460442,
0.0129531762,
-0.0191452056,
-0.0410391837,
0.0511442758,
0.0102647273,
0.0459981784,
0.0782194957,
-0.039071504,
-0.0090935249,
0.0265660845,
0.0454185754,
0.0084730871,
0.0304024462,
-0.0175508019,
0.017370699,
-0.0525819696,
0.0139088361,
-0.0188553445,
-0.0048779324,
0.0002924197,
0.0030783419,
-0.0910088569,
-0.0014493489,
-0.0295084417,
-0.013801923,
0.0017670525,
-0.0262873527,
-0.0053304103,
-0.0002960872,
-0.0240850784,
-0.0026236654,
-0.046891477,
0.0276044887,
0.0122881485,
-0.0648649931,
0.0079066958,
-0.0172548741,
-0.0186405051,
-0.0539595447,
0.037654791,
0.0615900978,
0.0305023268,
-0.0411182381,
-0.0488789678,
-0.0444814004,
-0.0571525209,
-0.0669779629,
-0.00088874,
-0.0456038713,
0.0268284064,
0.0159973074,
0.0092103761,
-0.0188333634,
0.0287335534,
0.0290537756,
-0.0681348145,
0.0712242797,
-0.0265692305,
0.0136066545,
0.0123335589,
0.0403870568,
-0.0264678784,
0.0701762512,
0.0138390986,
0.0269648097,
0.0283032078,
-0.0309017096,
-0.003980685,
0.030808432,
0.0055907401,
-0.0115632163,
0.0127836708,
-0.0017129444,
-0.0136612104,
0.0504814833,
-0.0193197075,
0.0449972041,
0.0001722444,
0.0438597314,
0.0885817185,
0.0900091529,
0.0020140458,
0.0059456564,
-0.0053591589,
0.0317434743,
-0.0098149711,
-0.0137375463,
-0.0764384419,
0.012006538,
-0.0452357754,
-0.0169106293,
0.0241859127,
0.0429883339,
-0.0279815923,
-0.0363409072,
-0.0494551137,
-0.0216343701,
0.0077291946,
0.0366343781,
-0.0038175485,
-0.0453847535,
-0.0009390906,
0.0219101813,
0.0613799207,
0.0025948531,
-0.0320730805,
-0.0603580326,
0.0379334725,
0.0974866897,
0.0302779675,
-0.035061866,
-0.0406708159,
-0.0222175047,
0.0279979501,
0.0187123045,
0.0046989289,
0.0158662964,
0.0113025308,
-0.0422349907,
-0.0099651376,
0.0342646986,
0.014108629,
-0.0250143893,
0.0305849873,
0.0435168147,
-0.0029883906,
-0.000661281,
-0.0127129033,
0.0422599167,
-0.026704181,
-0.0422974378,
0.0083831893,
0.0110928081,
0.0481185913,
0.0034004536,
0.0162866637,
0.0002911255,
-0.0003061277,
-0.0207144823,
-0.0422772281,
-0.0144522674,
-0.0485186428,
-0.0167025831,
0.0233663004,
0.0217356496,
-0.0008472487,
0.0349153392,
-0.0370906256,
-0.0215888396,
0.0025137227,
-0.0288113728,
-0.0097461268,
-0.0060897963,
-0.0145314364,
-0.0015490432,
0.0238736067,
-0.0351575613,
0.0368675739,
-0.0276649464,
0.0375377052,
0.0362592824,
-0.0435446016,
-0.0331142955,
-0.0540801212,
-0.0533315875,
-0.005801158,
-0.0013185415,
0.0074496437,
-0.038466014,
0.0332527757,
-0.0442600027,
-0.0288891159,
-0.1290694475,
0.0254619233,
-0.0155833345,
-0.0193586983,
0.0136620244,
-0.0194611829,
-0.0505691953,
-0.0087072514,
-0.026575936,
0.018714292,
0.0427484438,
0.0702506453,
0.0048061595,
-0.0019144632,
-0.0071823429,
-0.0230448637,
-0.0208859313,
-0.0405927151,
-0.0017782919,
-0.0002639445,
0.0005354786,
-0.0324134417,
-0.0160983745,
-0.0534044467,
0.0012921237,
-0.0096595036,
-0.0248869881,
0.0009422231,
0.0024515162,
0.0636289939,
0.0452799872,
0.0049022487,
0.0144832237,
0.0547636449,
-0.0000886365,
-0.0204138681,
0.0106640579,
-0.0069162818,
-0.0095126824,
-0.0008101167,
-0.052245751,
-0.0371840373,
0.056751892,
0.0432267599,
0.0112554776,
-0.0571688451,
0.0274674501,
-0.037296731,
0.0054104426,
-0.0324504822,
0.0153940059,
-0.023738103,
0.0295308307,
-0.0179817285,
-0.0727113783,
0.0766698346,
0.0104222205,
0.0160683971,
-0.0318681113,
-0.014562441,
-0.0324322097,
0.0456721149,
0.0043102778,
0.0123002818,
0.0405088887,
0.0081427097,
-0.0166096464,
-0.024166625,
-0.0250403266,
-0.0516135022,
0.0452285931,
-0.0517375357,
-0.0135747194,
0.0069522061,
-0.0459597856,
-0.0327396542,
-0.0634598956,
-0.0744709149,
-0.0120359082,
-0.0132710449,
0.0118337348,
-0.023005506,
-0.038649518,
0.0395247303,
0.0199342519,
-0.0274197515,
-0.0183576737,
0.00396886,
-0.000696466,
0.0639258772,
-0.0207462385,
0.027287744,
-0.0325906165,
0.0419861488,
0.031479951,
0.0027916762,
0.0164314304,
0.0361437127,
0.0231220815,
0.0093235364,
0.0050172289,
0.0024364921,
0.0579096489,
0.0691455752,
-0.039686922,
0.0089108385,
0.1390631199,
0.0149543453,
-0.0326422267,
0.0145170614,
-0.0275484622,
0.0061358404,
0.0004411543,
-0.0078369575,
-0.0611460283,
-0.0659620836,
0.0017574953,
0.0708894208,
-0.0519266762,
-0.0479070321,
0.0170960911,
-0.0700573921,
0.0218229294,
-0.0097099636,
0.0124006355,
0.0104799671,
-0.0371772088,
0.0302788131,
-0.0166620705,
0.0017547824,
-0.0283425152,
-0.0052763168,
0.0039466294,
-0.0157990158,
-0.0682277605,
-0.0533115007,
0.0945233405,
-0.0090811001,
0.0867912099,
0.0474271514,
0.0476647951,
-0.020295592,
-0.0653781146,
0.007215993,
0.0099573173,
0.0082366187,
-0.0075331517,
0.0886074007,
0.0160168353,
0.0108848084,
-0.075863868,
0.0683415756,
-0.0199095812,
-0.0198438596,
0.025977958,
0.1017684191,
0.0074450527,
-0.0296104606,
-0.0266719405,
0.0206823424,
0.0469866842,
0.0783511624,
0.002336933,
-0.0847834051,
-0.0199550632,
-0.0144568393,
-0.0127839148,
-0.007577973,
-0.0435168706,
0.0000316807,
-0.0098325396,
0.0075445562,
-0.0461138561,
-0.0593306571,
0.0694907904,
-0.0241308212,
-0.0016051148,
-0.0199721884,
0.02125201,
0.0175771751,
-0.0319132507,
0.0560697913,
-0.0104868487,
0.0329828002,
-0.047705695,
0.0010963466,
0.0135896793,
-0.031123139,
0.0099474741,
0.0338325649,
-0.0821579024,
-0.0256363433,
0.0558174998,
0.0351146273,
0.0177926999,
-0.0057248427,
0.0064403643,
-0.034671519,
0.036232803,
0.020814836,
-0.0428470373,
0.0059139114,
-0.0061429455,
0.0637934208,
0.0081016012,
0.0455923118,
0.0039610369,
0.0542379357,
0.0423483923,
0.005844167,
-0.0091377934,
0.0073772534,
0.0020313181,
0.0417084508,
0.0590044111,
-0.023629304,
-0.0552937649,
-0.0047832504,
-0.0245597102,
-0.0105084842,
-0.0238361154,
0.0016277494,
-0.0220646188,
0.0338053703,
-0.0146986423,
-0.0306261294,
-0.0397670269,
-0.0306234453,
-0.0133502362,
-0.0677122176,
0.0265644137,
-0.0390429236,
0.0226563942,
0.0375727825,
-0.0031896525,
-0.0080925394,
0.0503408164,
-0.0327968858,
0.0313425995,
-0.0028289624,
0.1156126037,
-0.0165145043,
-0.0047548576,
0.0164336488,
0.0280253571,
-0.0391625762,
-0.0881723613,
-0.0055395253,
-0.0013290117,
-0.0014258972,
0.0148426974,
0.0382820182,
-0.0024998249,
-0.0041592908,
-0.0262673609,
0.0106104864,
-0.0118598938,
-0.0246682074,
0.0379079841,
0.0059514893,
-0.0311042834,
-0.0264080279,
0.0657690316,
-0.0334671736,
0.0211560596,
0.0357536338,
-0.0343471318,
-0.0199407171,
0.0026669852,
-0.0127829276,
0.0070952293,
-0.0439283028,
0.0026282372,
-0.075542219,
-0.0446064919,
0.041441489,
-0.0308857094,
-0.0208979473,
-0.0267556254,
0.0149993636,
0.0224046316,
-0.0063842521,
-0.0146423168,
-0.0344066583,
0.0345993228,
-0.0262654293,
-0.0394369699,
-0.0415783338,
-6.847884952e-33,
-0.0107949944,
-0.027571464,
0.0077271578,
-0.0076037589,
-0.0024408614,
-0.0000719441,
-0.0158539843,
0.0406217277,
-0.0141580533,
-0.0009149281,
0.0147698969,
0.033920791,
0.0094073946,
0.0329413302,
0.0383773297,
-0.0361736827,
0.0040116641,
-0.0169561226,
-0.0231669024,
0.0049477699,
-0.0041770404,
0.037943203,
0.0307771657,
-0.0728425309,
0.042957738,
-0.0170582514,
0.0007252641,
0.0088607371,
-0.0257362239,
0.0350216888,
-0.0479878113,
0.0796184689,
0.0621442348,
-0.0084174573,
-0.0024950677,
0.0594517142,
-0.0255169887,
-0.0305867121,
0.0099064847,
-0.0430116467,
-0.046187479,
-0.0333450697,
-0.0021980174,
0.0005474919,
-0.0193302128,
-0.0430949926,
0.020808043,
-0.0614618137,
0.0295790881,
0.008409149,
-0.0135152303,
0.0132104531,
-0.0022358892,
-0.0035374395,
-0.033047311,
0.0720659569,
-0.0275389738,
0.0453720316,
-0.0642405897,
0.0159371663,
0.040491242,
-0.0044914205,
0.0258774646,
-0.0219507497,
-0.0011155528,
0.0639604405,
0.0052204095,
0.0082321819,
-0.0598814599,
-0.0220993552,
0.0106827905,
0.0256521776,
0.0690744817,
0.022308765,
0.0365627855,
-0.0404676534,
-0.0530310981,
-0.0012436055,
0.0230724644,
0.0019932943,
0.0546144918,
-0.0246255416,
-0.0458313711,
-0.0450587049,
-0.0349275507,
0.0024690737,
-0.0538330823,
-0.0244948771,
0.0508595817,
-0.0017029458,
0.0150275892,
-0.0022531732,
-0.0040583387,
-0.0146487439,
-0.0059471149,
0.0034311763,
-0.0058033569,
0.0128116291,
0.0023134013,
0.0106332004,
-0.061288584,
-0.0005270412,
-0.0007815009,
0.0162698571,
0.0609529689,
0.0005654569,
0.0576819219,
0.0061936136,
-0.0646869391,
-0.0140888793,
-0.0003225688,
0.0580308586,
0.0280361529,
-0.010452291,
0.0065281768,
0.0213629846,
-0.0006409211,
0.0419590399,
0.0310082305,
-0.0208568927,
-0.0621214472,
-0.0352559686,
-0.0040593147,
-0.0112998448,
-0.0003957522,
-0.00758996,
-0.0095465984,
0.0011136254,
0.0252877474,
-0.0307808127,
0.0058639375,
-0.0131386099,
3.045e-7,
0.0203508362,
0.0743781179,
-0.0381718166,
0.0048985062,
0.0019871641,
0.0341118984,
-0.0113398321,
0.0347656943,
0.0520593971,
-0.0334582552,
-0.0140811121,
0.0491202325,
0.0587069727,
0.065102011,
-0.0195909943,
-0.030567674,
-0.0279333256,
-0.0088179065,
-0.081098929,
0.0241753608,
0.083498098,
0.0634916201,
0.016503321,
-0.0167664699,
-0.0036376503,
0.0045057838,
0.0424170345,
-0.0383221954,
-0.0098832734,
0.015890101,
0.0294502545,
-0.0008164688,
0.0122496495,
0.0214400385,
0.0120789083,
-0.0101376669,
-0.0345652178,
0.0784868822,
-0.0024597591,
0.0067660981,
0.0016323013,
-0.0025620256,
-0.0064600268,
-0.0443837419,
0.085851185,
-0.0728528127,
-0.0482957959,
-0.0035713636,
-0.0195558332,
-0.0435888544,
0.0485402457,
-0.0190278124,
-0.0080834385,
0.0247192532,
0.0203014463,
-0.0061268699,
0.0176284257,
-0.069966726,
-0.0399475545,
0.0301709063,
-0.0497671738,
-0.0401807353,
-0.0453477353,
-0.0149121517,
0.0011319447,
-0.1179060191,
0.0348351523,
3.035095879e-34,
-0.0058589149,
0.0350635648,
0.0330182053,
-0.0179981105,
0.0091959611,
0.0195456222,
-0.0139325205,
0.0252429862,
0.0048554605,
-0.1026738212,
-0.0089632692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13949v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13949v1 | How Does Diffusion Influence Pretrained Language Models on Out-of-Distribution Data? | 2023-07-26T04:03:25 | 2023-07-26T04:03:25 | Huazheng Wang, Daixuan Cheng, Haifeng Sun, Jingyu Wang, Qi Qi, Jianxin Liao, Jing Wang, Cong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformer-based pretrained language models (PLMs) have achieved great
success in modern NLP. An important advantage of PLMs is good
out-of-distribution (OOD) robustness. Recently, diffusion models have attracted
a lot of work to apply diffusion to PLMs. It remains under-explored how
diffusion influences PLMs on OOD data. The core of diffusion models is a
forward diffusion process which gradually applies Gaussian noise to inputs, and
a reverse denoising process which removes noise. The noised input
reconstruction is a fundamental ability of diffusion models. We directly
analyze OOD robustness by measuring the reconstruction loss, including testing
the abilities to reconstruct OOD data, and to detect OOD samples. Experiments
are conducted by analyzing different training parameters and data statistical
features on eight datasets. It shows that finetuning PLMs with diffusion
degrades the reconstruction ability on OOD data. The comparison also shows that
diffusion models can effectively detect OOD samples, achieving state-of-the-art
performance in most of the datasets with an absolute accuracy improvement up to
18%. These results indicate that diffusion reduces OOD robustness of PLMs. | [
-0.0168894976,
0.050943315,
0.0082056168,
0.0335322805,
0.0066129733,
-0.0117715318,
-0.0412653871,
0.0413177013,
-0.0551272854,
-0.004126905,
-0.0212684833,
-0.044858858,
0.0507507138,
-0.0263846796,
0.0053962823,
-0.0139285186,
0.0169163458,
-0.0454503633,
-0.0627603456,
-0.011748394,
-0.0036168175,
-0.0301712248,
0.0124885626,
0.0127286939,
0.0184447411,
0.0014748104,
0.0012358276,
0.0082283299,
-0.0245649219,
0.0015581478,
-0.0039747097,
0.0285963751,
0.0376024768,
-0.0205815714,
0.0000021278,
-0.0191791505,
-0.011962546,
0.0087246941,
-0.0192704313,
0.0137292268,
0.0711878389,
-0.0189634599,
-0.0217312649,
0.0382381417,
0.0093280729,
-0.0461985357,
0.061596185,
0.0677320063,
0.0412247516,
0.0854459554,
-0.023606278,
-0.0396436863,
0.051045537,
-0.0327723883,
-0.025434237,
0.0113421371,
0.0263360608,
0.0223311819,
0.0095830262,
-0.0027362581,
-0.0449559875,
0.0498566553,
-0.0260356627,
0.0272143241,
-0.0075632837,
0.0181903113,
0.0475105383,
-0.0415544398,
-0.0426894836,
0.0822208598,
-0.072108306,
-0.0146894017,
-0.0080739129,
-0.0214428753,
-0.0202378016,
0.0552712791,
-0.0301263425,
0.0148729654,
0.0506770238,
0.0521061122,
-0.043722745,
-0.0132794185,
0.039493449,
-0.00968148,
-0.0478820652,
0.0483584329,
0.0151485102,
-0.0372191966,
-0.0107157053,
0.0088166418,
-0.0224217083,
-0.0189523827,
0.0239064619,
0.0324674249,
0.0233145114,
0.0263528489,
-0.0552519038,
-0.0478398129,
0.0062870774,
-0.041502919,
0.0517458767,
0.018046964,
-0.0056277784,
-0.0125029609,
-0.01026625,
-0.0013039161,
-0.061111372,
0.0333461128,
-0.0450139381,
0.0102076717,
-0.0353062823,
0.0185301173,
-0.0291745421,
0.0790939927,
-0.017830966,
-0.0022327113,
-0.0143808341,
0.0177280065,
0.0130089512,
-0.0422260053,
0.0373026542,
-0.0009065427,
-0.0231117439,
-0.0087796701,
-0.0187735297,
0.0575260781,
0.0404887423,
0.0171077885,
-0.0013000902,
-0.0339376293,
-0.0444956422,
0.0239734165,
0.0210686345,
-0.005229678,
0.0056658122,
0.0524472743,
0.0067563606,
-0.0626039207,
-0.0415927805,
0.0151089523,
-0.0142579535,
-0.0536458828,
0.0229464732,
-0.0757111013,
-0.0121445134,
0.0161657333,
0.0253699888,
-0.0680758804,
0.0300649945,
0.0218365062,
-0.0576483384,
0.0566217601,
-0.0194734968,
0.0439510308,
0.0232465193,
-0.0219656415,
0.0361097418,
0.0648079365,
0.0221154075,
-0.0426041558,
0.0235528424,
-0.0046288138,
0.0272083133,
0.0551949292,
0.0403515473,
0.0420320109,
-0.0084340284,
-0.0446987115,
0.0037534838,
-0.01056711,
0.0645585656,
0.0700588673,
-0.0445889495,
-0.0048541757,
0.0933256522,
0.0450154357,
0.0331779197,
-0.046849139,
-0.0067759482,
0.011471346,
-0.0216561109,
0.0307655092,
0.0012790848,
-0.0449922569,
-0.0053856773,
0.025747953,
0.0144591276,
0.0301875062,
-0.0455702096,
-0.0480075926,
-0.02372442,
-0.0455831811,
0.0500092469,
-0.0025399232,
0.0855742544,
0.0405808724,
-0.0467760339,
0.0876152739,
0.0177073553,
-0.0534891449,
-0.0059539629,
-0.0644645467,
-0.0076821432,
-0.0265320819,
0.0616337731,
-0.0161056314,
0.0356068872,
-0.0276249554,
0.0046220114,
0.00509946,
0.0164206401,
0.0501206443,
0.0304667838,
-0.0420313701,
-0.02509363,
0.0505878143,
0.0277348291,
-0.0021324968,
0.0028536653,
-0.0007182747,
0.0230471957,
-0.0677023903,
-0.0579568036,
0.0490461215,
-0.0303584579,
0.000201098,
0.0219920501,
-0.0179102402,
0.0112127168,
0.0130489469,
-0.0384559333,
0.0198077746,
0.0415125825,
-0.0098498901,
-0.0074476171,
-0.0088205906,
-0.0407617502,
-0.0363723598,
0.0380803607,
-0.0076171304,
-0.0059038177,
0.0307557322,
-0.0025181281,
-0.0137424078,
0.0227280017,
-0.0313006081,
0.0371698029,
-0.0720398128,
0.038429331,
-0.0060370276,
0.042681478,
-0.0197154582,
0.063182883,
-0.0424650311,
0.0222388674,
-0.0125494888,
0.0358912647,
0.0288360789,
-0.0133556863,
-0.0514937863,
-0.0114020361,
-0.0398694091,
0.0204984136,
-0.0076581659,
-0.0256368406,
-0.0083995266,
-0.012819658,
-0.0347456969,
0.0061830385,
-0.0523078181,
0.0024609,
0.0258341674,
0.0278039388,
-0.0072437064,
-0.0098261498,
0.0134944944,
0.0087553328,
0.039647501,
-0.0070891869,
0.0430674292,
-0.026636349,
-0.0011792515,
-0.0127460184,
-0.0236498043,
-0.0089548482,
0.0692910179,
-0.0662927404,
-0.0372042693,
-0.0631537363,
0.0873758197,
0.0103628002,
0.0528058708,
0.0010910725,
-0.0546355806,
-0.0033028303,
-0.0097095715,
0.088024579,
0.0077097476,
0.0152719952,
0.0276115015,
0.0307431743,
-0.0378160663,
0.007584691,
-0.0253665373,
-0.0610531271,
-0.0152378455,
-0.0413185395,
-0.0021216357,
0.0070355274,
0.0724643469,
-0.0098434146,
-0.0311272275,
-0.0142919943,
-0.0558524206,
-0.0150275063,
0.0162884258,
0.0075579579,
-0.0145103177,
-0.0496620052,
0.0268323049,
-0.0160021596,
-0.0259384401,
0.0371384211,
-0.0672262087,
0.0039589759,
-0.0714002028,
-0.033440765,
0.004889756,
-0.0166293308,
-0.005271154,
-0.0064107301,
0.0206487179,
-0.0433536358,
-0.0412916802,
-0.0101132486,
0.010331437,
-0.0513259508,
0.0387684181,
-0.0382802039,
0.0215836167,
0.012367242,
0.0161180999,
-0.0188392848,
-0.1018232033,
0.0496632643,
-0.0003444833,
-0.0392627418,
-0.0144218151,
-0.0081837997,
0.0110704508,
-0.0150783332,
0.0557160787,
0.0044861552,
0.0040235114,
-0.0239155218,
0.0702102035,
0.030522272,
0.0225467347,
0.0048360536,
-0.0535311773,
-0.005627464,
0.004305792,
0.0327928774,
-0.0384713747,
-0.0272653308,
0.0082721515,
0.0012857252,
-0.0018957662,
-0.0223083999,
0.0470370576,
0.0649330318,
-0.0212121624,
-0.0398057997,
0.0646348,
-0.0138341272,
-0.035613399,
-0.0011378542,
0.0372832641,
0.057129629,
0.0093538649,
-0.0281547848,
-0.0440280177,
-0.0173080061,
-0.0017759328,
0.008622529,
0.0014951311,
0.0139519898,
0.0084605375,
-0.1124695092,
0.0267915186,
0.0078370813,
-0.0012990648,
-0.0473459587,
-0.0658522397,
-0.0078370022,
0.0226290002,
0.0485168695,
-0.0211559273,
-0.0221741609,
-0.0266016405,
0.0414552502,
-0.0178526435,
-0.1136118621,
-0.0211021956,
-0.0254447591,
0.0276387837,
0.0790984109,
-0.0197536796,
-0.0212484468,
-0.0736635253,
0.0760616958,
-0.0119986413,
-0.0115465764,
0.0295553561,
0.0447119325,
0.0344981365,
-0.0074183461,
0.009018613,
0.0227440558,
-0.0510407686,
-0.0174083281,
-0.0793878213,
0.064811185,
-0.0173129328,
-0.0283705872,
0.0000368308,
-0.0061408724,
0.0386880934,
0.0385621078,
0.0166218765,
-0.0310555212,
-0.0684368834,
-0.0070817168,
0.0525200516,
0.0556002185,
-0.0369578637,
0.0562784821,
-0.0146943908,
-0.1155010015,
-0.0762860402,
-0.0234365109,
-0.0226715505,
0.0662753806,
0.0177950859,
0.0240041632,
0.0418666638,
-0.0094473045,
-0.0404879488,
0.0234204903,
-0.0161147211,
0.0007629996,
-0.046573326,
0.0125461807,
0.0241787378,
0.0041642003,
-0.0166696012,
0.0007283852,
-0.123595044,
-0.0766026899,
0.0362391174,
0.0184003673,
0.0285696313,
0.0227401014,
-0.0155893946,
-0.0531011336,
0.1200715899,
0.0125648212,
-0.0020215344,
0.0185192805,
0.0412012599,
-0.0776620358,
0.0178296454,
0.0039321096,
0.0033544584,
0.0057206461,
0.0072136251,
0.0123603372,
-0.015975697,
-0.0004343004,
0.0059340871,
-0.0143963257,
0.0855117217,
0.0239638854,
-0.0004683784,
-0.0232079495,
0.0274778027,
-0.0184390191,
0.0226508994,
-0.0250608232,
-0.0290573351,
0.0849746615,
0.0172858108,
-0.01324997,
0.0014071958,
-0.0221752934,
0.048093643,
0.0233200956,
0.016580727,
0.0270550363,
-0.0205289871,
0.0405683964,
0.0215118546,
0.0043713711,
0.0128499977,
0.0048988876,
0.0202706996,
0.0144183487,
0.0376594886,
-0.0083949063,
0.0076427883,
-0.0263048448,
0.007681224,
-0.0786289349,
-0.0310105272,
-0.0500905327,
-0.0092438078,
0.0177761316,
-0.0205538422,
0.0558772273,
-0.0167051964,
0.0163008235,
-0.037701726,
0.0287556443,
-0.0241848789,
0.0382449664,
0.0323502235,
-0.019461954,
-0.0063040247,
0.037873961,
0.086020872,
0.0101364423,
0.0101617407,
-0.0202964786,
0.0126013393,
-0.0082903774,
0.0009033443,
-0.0127138132,
0.0189548135,
-0.0245336685,
0.0093688229,
-0.0039874567,
-0.0740755349,
-0.0330989473,
-0.0055680168,
-0.0003418233,
-0.0322774313,
0.02049735,
0.061788056,
-0.010966274,
0.0298888069,
-0.0459741503,
-0.0000595199,
0.0364144854,
-0.0187998973,
-0.0074467063,
-6.721219559e-33,
-0.0040739719,
-0.0270395018,
-0.0232481714,
-0.0380053408,
-0.0167769324,
-0.0190377999,
-0.0300609749,
0.0359011404,
-0.0436395817,
0.0137570556,
-0.0416945592,
0.0437883139,
0.0224282704,
0.0439838432,
-0.0412015989,
0.004313597,
0.0501423813,
-0.0263609812,
-0.0056956178,
-0.0357705019,
0.0043588472,
0.0490067452,
0.0554186106,
-0.011459168,
0.0079719108,
-0.0093323244,
-0.0056094606,
-0.0135340886,
0.0503322072,
0.0253604222,
-0.0281129535,
0.0601096638,
0.0138653079,
-0.0199414808,
-0.0512042306,
0.0018471514,
-0.0704536736,
-0.0005177158,
-0.0059474334,
0.0137953404,
-0.0097444002,
0.0236941576,
0.0745509341,
-0.0029883578,
-0.0306253582,
0.0043752543,
0.0191301275,
-0.0037653537,
-0.024432024,
0.0309326891,
-0.0220414586,
0.0369421206,
0.0180531293,
-0.0199051127,
0.0393616445,
-0.031589929,
-0.0365386903,
0.0240522083,
-0.0591890141,
-0.0027323274,
0.0394883007,
0.0588276833,
0.0092163188,
-0.0075403801,
0.0153888678,
0.011656628,
-0.0210791249,
0.0289680399,
0.0038504307,
-0.031559512,
0.0861155242,
0.026081169,
-0.0093677239,
0.0157842916,
0.0442951508,
-0.0366206057,
-0.0605803952,
0.0286278371,
-0.0444405265,
0.006524228,
0.042519033,
0.0074828346,
-0.0031420074,
-0.0410132036,
-0.0315283723,
-0.0396059714,
0.0159155857,
-0.0298409872,
-0.0010474736,
0.0204452369,
-0.0103032002,
-0.0139625343,
0.0509002246,
-0.066357553,
-0.0301533584,
-0.0191312954,
-0.0166390706,
0.0262068715,
-0.0148948766,
0.0078758728,
-0.051735647,
-0.0597177669,
-0.0121345222,
0.0561419539,
-0.0137399351,
-0.0049736598,
-0.0117852846,
0.0224475395,
-0.0640102103,
0.0101832524,
-0.0281156208,
0.001849013,
-0.0054257391,
0.0898354203,
0.0401924886,
-0.0102591738,
-0.0044788448,
0.0430484861,
0.0069120419,
0.0226282254,
-0.0055428059,
0.0239832681,
0.0220170226,
0.019825615,
-0.0298880711,
-0.006665214,
-0.0274585355,
0.0711553767,
0.0678985044,
-0.0206087083,
-0.0125550767,
0.0173048601,
2.819e-7,
0.0679798946,
0.0376081504,
0.0290086288,
0.0214448217,
-0.0012997849,
0.0175600909,
-0.0314128883,
-0.0009702982,
-0.0027991293,
-0.0693349317,
0.0207219105,
-0.0084148655,
0.03855085,
-0.0085967984,
-0.0752566755,
-0.0756087229,
-0.0294321477,
0.0334027447,
-0.0177897047,
-0.0373048075,
0.0136000011,
0.1034851596,
-0.0090052774,
-0.0072673517,
-0.0108812209,
0.0066963029,
0.0754944831,
-0.0249180514,
0.005723645,
0.0155060384,
0.018734647,
-0.0302148014,
0.0223119687,
0.0199943017,
-0.0391074792,
0.0452746525,
0.0104783913,
0.0039171008,
-0.0339033678,
-0.0875785723,
0.0275164545,
0.029074695,
-0.0140867205,
-0.0542424656,
0.0485973991,
-0.0204508118,
-0.0218805615,
-0.0177627578,
-0.0575870499,
-0.0046519209,
0.0457154065,
-0.022854859,
-0.0221984573,
0.0084773256,
0.023868205,
0.0415049531,
-0.0178479198,
-0.058210142,
-0.0069220564,
0.003812908,
-0.0213369206,
-0.0638146847,
-0.0078024031,
-0.0359915346,
0.060589619,
-0.0032016772,
-0.0109479679,
2.624310194e-34,
0.0522697344,
0.0028195409,
0.0049873302,
0.0436595082,
0.0138750039,
-0.0226413477,
0.0122941565,
0.0175263714,
-0.0409280993,
-0.0814899653,
0.004744295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13923v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13923v2 | GrammarGPT: Exploring Open-Source LLMs for Native Chinese Grammatical Error Correction with Supervised Fine-Tuning | 2023-07-26T02:45:38 | 2023-08-17T19:58:42 | Yaxin Fan, Feng Jiang, Peifeng Li, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction aims to correct ungrammatical sentences
automatically. Recently, some work has demonstrated the excellent capabilities
of closed-source Large Language Models (LLMs, e.g., ChatGPT) in grammatical
error correction. However, the potential of open-source LLMs remains
unexplored. In this paper, we introduced GrammarGPT, an open-source LLM, to
preliminary explore its potential for native Chinese grammatical error
correction. The core recipe of GrammarGPT is to leverage the hybrid dataset of
ChatGPT-generated and human-annotated. For grammatical errors with clues, we
proposed a heuristic method to guide ChatGPT to generate ungrammatical
sentences by providing those clues. For grammatical errors without clues, we
collected ungrammatical sentences from publicly available websites and manually
corrected them. In addition, we employed an error-invariant augmentation method
to enhance the ability of the model to correct native Chinese grammatical
errors. We ultimately constructed about 1k parallel data and utilized these
data to fine-tune open-source LLMs (e.g., Phoenix, released by The Chinese
University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen) with instruction tuning. The experimental
results show that GrammarGPT outperforms the existing SOTA system
significantly. Although model parameters are 20x larger than the SOTA baseline,
the required amount of data for instruction tuning is 1200x smaller,
illustrating the potential of open-source LLMs on native CGEC. Our GrammarGPT
ranks $3^{rd}$ on NLPCC2023 SharedTask1, demonstrating our approach's
effectiveness. The code and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/FreedomIntelligence/GrammarGPT}. | [
0.0753004104,
0.0609247051,
0.007265144,
0.0383631289,
-0.0202661306,
0.0388972051,
-0.0202860329,
-0.0355178751,
0.0159029085,
-0.0539622307,
-0.0648596585,
-0.0222013723,
0.0040579871,
-0.0257831607,
0.0318575986,
-0.0005320334,
0.0626168922,
0.0043935557,
-0.0234044343,
0.0100238714,
0.0217849799,
0.0169253089,
-0.0094476324,
0.0370591246,
-0.0280339476,
-0.0640565604,
-0.0027062478,
0.065095678,
0.0256917831,
-0.0181777235,
0.0725270361,
0.0474708416,
-0.0309988912,
0.0661610588,
0.0000019825,
-0.0303923637,
-0.0289398246,
-0.0122301374,
-0.0016961843,
0.0697400719,
0.0113934586,
-0.0147439428,
-0.07511051,
0.0320561044,
-0.0002524589,
-0.0226015672,
0.0397591926,
0.0438493378,
0.0662417635,
0.1210329682,
0.0127227651,
0.0331194848,
0.0459543802,
-0.0164435785,
-0.0276605189,
0.0070334985,
0.0205701627,
0.0141653493,
-0.0445312522,
-0.0207733642,
-0.0308415238,
0.0120687885,
-0.0014352211,
-0.0473510474,
-0.0118194902,
-0.0060659954,
-0.0492355376,
0.0079741413,
-0.0429699086,
0.0419384614,
-0.0065328958,
-0.0432111435,
-0.0106749162,
0.0028694889,
0.0062960084,
-0.0067172144,
-0.0261727571,
0.0237880982,
-0.0057010734,
0.0383186527,
0.0643067136,
-0.1073311344,
0.0193939973,
0.0250462126,
0.0575668029,
0.050452318,
0.0233346205,
-0.0599908046,
-0.0470025428,
0.0247675013,
-0.018719133,
-0.0419841409,
0.0325963572,
-0.0023111645,
-0.0691716,
0.0015480012,
-0.0420509018,
-0.0316232815,
-0.0029222025,
-0.0508492067,
0.0513594151,
0.0269421339,
-0.0554588735,
0.017894635,
-0.0199932605,
0.0356410183,
0.0195191856,
0.0554107912,
-0.0249441061,
-0.0005746313,
-0.0329370834,
-0.0058429628,
-0.0564193949,
0.0127106542,
-0.0409365147,
0.0206821747,
-0.0452709757,
0.0118024247,
-0.0095207803,
0.0397497937,
0.0408769809,
-0.0167505611,
-0.0640630797,
-0.0366617702,
0.0117807388,
0.024096217,
0.0096868789,
0.0321021788,
0.0018127114,
-0.0677947775,
-0.0325556248,
0.02710093,
0.0319518745,
-0.0096090967,
0.008743315,
0.0235724859,
-0.0150202122,
-0.0286400933,
-0.0530645177,
0.015912272,
-0.0191017147,
-0.0228870902,
-0.0504255667,
-0.0488468558,
-0.0340223275,
-0.0240318142,
0.0274817534,
-0.0063223923,
0.0099654747,
0.005140176,
-0.0168449897,
0.0373829417,
-0.0693471283,
0.0158893112,
-0.0104674688,
-0.0336812176,
0.0215670951,
0.041231744,
0.0353712365,
-0.0235198885,
0.0662768483,
0.0054286649,
0.0210547391,
0.0133401044,
-0.0418030992,
0.0018147354,
0.0226450935,
-0.0198345426,
0.0018141834,
0.0369130485,
0.0501765944,
0.0656045973,
-0.010495753,
0.0542124994,
0.0543707125,
0.0106530301,
-0.0096491771,
0.0261145849,
0.0265843067,
-0.0101495953,
0.0123887593,
0.0212101117,
-0.068674542,
0.001072348,
-0.0654378459,
0.0019929723,
0.0246053003,
0.0269483645,
-0.025490649,
-0.0535340458,
-0.0296431053,
-0.0014395665,
-0.0153904157,
-0.0249783229,
0.0380275995,
0.0319413207,
-0.0130840279,
0.0420651659,
0.0326652005,
-0.064551577,
0.0004589536,
-0.0288121141,
0.0252519157,
0.0814215541,
0.0612660982,
-0.0091373604,
-0.0549246743,
-0.0257266257,
-0.0026679675,
0.0560204349,
0.0614453219,
-0.0160396062,
-0.0295629613,
-0.0592834875,
0.0103348093,
0.0029469293,
0.0319995694,
-0.0199135393,
0.0335583203,
-0.0080564488,
0.0156599935,
-0.00379062,
-0.0640488043,
0.0258375928,
-0.0018934788,
-0.0069753076,
-0.0065163965,
-0.011826898,
0.0306399539,
0.011613165,
-0.0368150622,
-0.002868766,
-0.0321420766,
-0.004218407,
-0.0504983254,
0.0075520291,
-0.0219126828,
-0.0616606288,
0.0440101437,
-0.0337814987,
-0.042296242,
0.0395930856,
-0.0827777162,
-0.0585046746,
0.0054772124,
-0.0218569878,
0.0142259654,
-0.0862269253,
0.0516634621,
0.0097201709,
0.0071773082,
-0.0141347218,
0.0042003766,
0.0149663249,
0.0154964365,
-0.0131107243,
0.0127587039,
-0.0045642247,
-0.0379750542,
-0.0303522702,
-0.0215507131,
-0.0108888028,
0.0438342206,
0.0047362898,
0.0680149421,
-0.039627485,
-0.0452769957,
-0.0971523225,
0.0309855565,
-0.0562976114,
0.0341765881,
0.0647897348,
0.0015498614,
-0.0428634249,
-0.0243923087,
0.0132923769,
0.0331244655,
0.0018717037,
-0.0071040825,
0.0524141975,
-0.0352565646,
-0.0224494822,
-0.0690174326,
0.0076833861,
-0.0174738877,
-0.063650839,
0.0073311622,
-0.0302963369,
-0.0866529718,
0.0370290838,
-0.0110620977,
0.0292319134,
0.0406625606,
-0.1037676111,
-0.0195868239,
-0.0080403527,
0.0478095412,
0.0392300226,
-0.0223895535,
0.0084427604,
-0.0071131438,
-0.0292774998,
-0.005042688,
0.0294211674,
0.0093011102,
-0.0601459779,
-0.0279154144,
-0.0003242267,
-0.0115614142,
0.0832211897,
0.0070262249,
-0.0300830193,
-0.0310240109,
-0.015666388,
-0.0265072286,
0.0204455387,
0.0025358205,
0.0270705484,
-0.0213362556,
-0.01928984,
-0.0451632105,
-0.0336547829,
0.068442978,
-0.0119915297,
-0.0218776949,
-0.0466812551,
0.0021444019,
-0.0461330563,
-0.000084613,
-0.0014104927,
0.0105624925,
-0.0047460743,
-0.0560792945,
-0.0422315709,
0.0446745083,
0.0430836976,
-0.0067715533,
0.0373664796,
-0.0679819882,
0.0109634222,
-0.000861169,
-0.0535825305,
-0.005771454,
-0.0339647308,
-0.0408018604,
-0.0322797596,
0.0222314894,
-0.0168262739,
0.0027289044,
-0.0164590217,
-0.0166793633,
0.0531225391,
-0.0204896983,
-0.0055965148,
-0.0358474366,
-0.0058657355,
0.0200870521,
0.0510217361,
0.0093832836,
0.0101995636,
0.0321244001,
0.0519035757,
-0.0060916469,
0.023924036,
0.0003702354,
0.0145642487,
0.0287480131,
-0.0253008083,
-0.0476271063,
-0.0010063865,
0.1072842926,
-0.0548567474,
-0.0449501164,
0.1168821529,
0.0351676717,
-0.0205198172,
-0.0032026295,
-0.0086535644,
-0.0036181994,
0.0082572279,
0.0105321333,
-0.0638463423,
-0.042518191,
0.0420394242,
0.0285633467,
-0.0057762535,
0.012272764,
0.0183502939,
-0.1334776878,
0.0684494451,
0.0466857143,
-0.0129398163,
-0.0113862855,
-0.008398233,
0.0167084988,
-0.0276812464,
0.0499218851,
0.0389238633,
-0.0218338445,
-0.0013605483,
0.0019999815,
-0.0563132688,
-0.0748140737,
-0.0085968692,
-0.0436845981,
0.0822925642,
0.0497700199,
0.0043767737,
0.0249714851,
-0.0108381519,
0.0865998417,
0.0069563258,
-0.0081287893,
-0.0145356832,
0.0287189689,
0.014213453,
-0.0291192792,
-0.0372736752,
0.0763592273,
-0.0557504594,
0.0053891153,
0.0016450584,
0.0588822924,
-0.0054010106,
0.0256504472,
0.0249656923,
-0.0139735136,
-0.0109591065,
0.0554625466,
0.0315559655,
-0.0340799317,
-0.0378710665,
-0.0729911774,
-0.0166703332,
-0.0530362353,
0.0380257629,
0.0592767335,
-0.0267787836,
-0.0063854246,
-0.0693637356,
-0.0601790845,
0.0091572637,
-0.0476978533,
0.0216907077,
-0.0348483175,
0.0032315042,
0.010067028,
0.0128352456,
0.008099095,
-0.0309187789,
0.0097478097,
-0.0858791322,
-0.0280524604,
0.012910312,
0.0251838844,
0.0202699043,
0.0064969393,
-0.064286083,
-0.0543685034,
0.0117787151,
0.0388142094,
-0.0028810266,
0.0289714113,
-0.0535633564,
-0.0467814803,
-0.0246480536,
0.0606191792,
-0.0152297718,
0.0266831014,
0.033051271,
-0.0201587789,
-0.0003981321,
0.0504176393,
-0.0228543598,
0.0114121642,
0.0155267091,
0.0748056918,
-0.0040579895,
0.007663419,
0.0579101965,
0.0552348085,
0.0632458851,
-0.0120265102,
0.0318565592,
-0.0718920305,
0.0442984365,
-0.032085117,
-0.0166830998,
-0.0337911882,
0.0063389274,
0.0340397656,
-0.0535975359,
-0.0257113334,
0.009131832,
-0.0413850173,
0.0096756816,
-0.0443130322,
-0.017556157,
0.0039716419,
0.0333052948,
0.001499386,
0.0062594661,
-0.0113360137,
0.0277980771,
0.0293650981,
0.0214428846,
-0.0012647714,
0.0497908071,
0.011640125,
0.0323764049,
-0.0002776782,
0.0219513215,
-0.0272675361,
0.0042563439,
-0.0420176126,
0.0571559556,
0.1442791671,
0.0115939416,
0.08660274,
-0.0415929705,
-0.0270044394,
-0.0307793953,
0.0517683439,
0.0142635088,
-0.0148489112,
0.0117186802,
-0.0059638303,
-0.0275076032,
-0.0445729084,
0.0657341555,
-0.0146187302,
0.0623205528,
0.0178318433,
-0.0068854997,
-0.0259669628,
-0.0137959626,
-0.0009475549,
-0.0227442496,
-0.0078190574,
0.0048656659,
-0.0013015012,
-0.0687396303,
-0.0361784846,
0.057463672,
0.0018419598,
-0.0148043651,
-0.0287409015,
0.0159617811,
-0.0175988805,
-0.0157264341,
-0.0508757308,
-0.025886314,
-0.0061380742,
-0.0308531895,
-0.0178454313,
-6.463356506e-33,
-0.0455554202,
0.025501525,
-0.0104319789,
0.0244362317,
-0.0082903337,
-0.0194983203,
-0.0347402766,
0.0103367725,
0.0282195434,
0.027360348,
-0.0293637048,
0.0381001011,
0.0097898198,
0.0463409424,
0.048654113,
0.0117376018,
0.0717242286,
0.0074629113,
-0.0054481053,
-0.0196304414,
0.0359230675,
0.0331591517,
0.0877035558,
-0.0324949473,
0.0149549618,
0.0011060059,
-0.0436588526,
0.0411369652,
-0.011654187,
0.033822231,
0.0355840065,
0.0565168895,
0.0120459013,
0.028013844,
-0.0414656848,
-0.0305220373,
-0.0851675346,
-0.029156208,
-0.0041372022,
0.0443350598,
0.0006042222,
-0.0423247181,
0.0144304894,
-0.0306032561,
-0.006762872,
0.0167976748,
0.0083382661,
-0.0536890998,
0.0427308939,
0.0313546993,
-0.0212237071,
0.017244542,
-0.0051839179,
-0.0083473762,
-0.0345473588,
0.0030002375,
-0.021381082,
-0.0192792583,
-0.0325397551,
-0.0142747993,
0.0431688018,
0.060521692,
0.0428396091,
-0.0180601776,
-0.0183764547,
0.0070874924,
0.0121235,
-0.0008652934,
0.0091103949,
0.030248588,
-0.0046753846,
0.0172778256,
0.0139563996,
0.0554904789,
0.0328137279,
-0.0329211764,
-0.0329092219,
0.0120656304,
-0.0049510654,
0.0240407791,
-0.0239237919,
0.0241234768,
-0.0308224782,
-0.0300122462,
0.0017126193,
0.0017368391,
-0.0174464416,
-0.0176159739,
0.0474820696,
0.0199837089,
-0.0252565313,
-0.0263968073,
-0.0269823726,
-0.0314775594,
-0.007698298,
-0.0257463306,
-0.0014170461,
0.016001394,
-0.0280030835,
0.0183357727,
-0.0624549575,
-0.0527150519,
-0.0027035489,
0.0060899486,
0.0077792718,
0.0165837798,
0.058248587,
0.0439715683,
-0.0628371462,
0.0416737162,
-0.0096322,
0.0153901689,
-0.006337293,
-0.0280338228,
-0.0013567428,
-0.0118359104,
0.0072272331,
0.0229051523,
0.0279804561,
0.0255724043,
-0.0373349674,
-0.0431109481,
-0.0348698981,
-0.003101029,
-0.001052634,
0.0260737073,
-0.0201783609,
-0.0343563035,
0.0046675997,
-0.0548435114,
0.0040804264,
0.0023310552,
2.682e-7,
0.0110649532,
0.0574892722,
0.037321046,
0.0261106137,
0.0206097253,
0.0040498553,
-0.0319800638,
0.0288289245,
0.008578578,
0.0406596586,
0.0376855582,
0.0106177814,
0.0877997652,
0.0084236246,
-0.0620000735,
0.0178721864,
-0.0535145178,
0.0312259272,
-0.0310924444,
-0.0112328604,
0.0029189966,
0.0732726455,
0.0196450688,
0.0125864707,
0.0031843979,
-0.0503705442,
0.0328877941,
-0.0075732027,
-0.0532422885,
0.0588494316,
0.0339431725,
0.0589880869,
0.0027085843,
-0.0081403721,
-0.0134225292,
-0.0238589067,
0.0106225302,
0.0516628772,
0.0124707473,
0.0304290801,
-0.0110799447,
-0.0029945888,
0.0037481845,
-0.0260321796,
0.0453166887,
-0.0056862938,
0.0227482039,
0.0027805201,
0.0052070143,
-0.0120565016,
0.0007239044,
-0.0478722155,
-0.033439301,
0.0257353093,
0.0451132171,
0.0195874255,
-0.03096883,
-0.013666071,
-0.0303242169,
0.0135871703,
0.0178560615,
-0.0428302065,
0.0171177164,
0.0105174324,
-0.0018809197,
-0.044115115,
0.00113565,
2.286431792e-34,
0.0626977906,
-0.0168809816,
0.0361872241,
0.011168615,
0.0477773286,
-0.0031151171,
0.0048256661,
0.0016198597,
-0.0294649694,
-0.0437551923,
-0.0392015651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16833v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.16833v2 | Data Augmentation for Neural Machine Translation using Generative Language Model | 2023-07-26T02:12:58 | 2023-11-13T13:17:03 | Seokjin Oh, Su Ah Lee, Woohwan Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the rapid growth in model architecture, the scarcity of large
parallel corpora remains the main bottleneck in Neural Machine Translation.
Data augmentation is a technique that enhances the performance of data-hungry
models by generating synthetic data instead of collecting new ones. We explore
prompt-based data augmentation approaches that leverage large-scale language
models such as ChatGPT. To create a synthetic parallel corpus, we compare 3
methods using different prompts. We employ two assessment metrics to measure
the diversity of the generated synthetic data. This approach requires no
further model training cost, which is mandatory in other augmentation methods
like back-translation. The proposed method improves the unaugmented baseline by
0.68 BLEU score. | [
0.0230574794,
0.0589468479,
0.000430985,
0.022830585,
-0.0170215163,
0.0059161521,
0.0532165729,
-0.0176832881,
-0.018134851,
-0.0235178042,
-0.0280835126,
-0.0622578934,
0.0050587403,
0.0283399802,
0.0530454218,
-0.0345656835,
0.0358559005,
-0.0053183506,
-0.0249024015,
-0.0023559192,
-0.0287370589,
0.0125369364,
0.0087451972,
0.0201304313,
-0.0147216711,
-0.0183070581,
0.0002379973,
0.0443050005,
0.042136915,
-0.029974198,
-0.0193265267,
0.0565411374,
0.0075814766,
0.0989858434,
0.0000019619,
-0.0481663942,
-0.0179373212,
0.03510895,
-0.0307595395,
0.0326752625,
0.0480958298,
-0.0085282382,
-0.0128655806,
0.0303651448,
-0.0328499861,
-0.0378298573,
0.0623530932,
-0.0058618127,
0.0585416034,
0.0992036015,
-0.0162351169,
-0.0081842747,
0.0340559669,
-0.0708457679,
0.0045006978,
0.0071545732,
-0.0359715447,
0.0212359671,
-0.0117732808,
0.0608586781,
-0.0020700183,
0.057413917,
0.0452136211,
-0.009497012,
0.0267061368,
0.0327486023,
-0.0003630056,
-0.0361149497,
-0.017053362,
0.0656418353,
-0.0194348767,
-0.0057048225,
-0.0515842885,
-0.0234793667,
0.0260667317,
-0.0252693556,
-0.0596086532,
0.014382761,
0.0078321677,
0.0032721807,
0.0087217297,
0.0306239463,
0.0586907491,
-0.0168237425,
-0.015501691,
-0.0172556024,
0.0457367636,
-0.0240973439,
-0.0192392934,
0.0192231294,
-0.0232261568,
-0.021613311,
0.0043779761,
-0.0054410803,
-0.0311555155,
0.0151757663,
-0.0340058021,
-0.0716510043,
0.0345278159,
-0.0402299128,
0.0513624735,
0.0616779476,
-0.0281057898,
0.0283496697,
-0.0220074095,
0.050624758,
-0.0196236167,
0.0162298158,
-0.0628595129,
-0.0027136798,
-0.0306490157,
0.0300525166,
-0.0374442711,
-0.0325171091,
-0.0599760339,
-0.0244462136,
-0.0282476898,
0.036674425,
-0.0033835655,
-0.0218766034,
0.0729228333,
-0.0239624307,
-0.0728494748,
0.0158657413,
-0.0002906798,
0.0073231505,
-0.0299667194,
-0.0013008225,
0.0373935141,
-0.1101056188,
-0.0427214056,
-0.0060584676,
-0.0053511676,
-0.0489611626,
-0.0041833892,
0.0545950048,
-0.0231342055,
-0.0441621356,
-0.0090693133,
0.0192170087,
-0.0191810355,
-0.0472539216,
-0.0059913378,
-0.0623331629,
0.0749708414,
-0.0233600345,
0.0186112169,
-0.0025953699,
-0.0175412036,
0.0017645224,
0.011865682,
0.0420428067,
-0.0637612119,
-0.0153755993,
0.0499949493,
-0.011173089,
-0.0065197037,
0.0647371337,
0.0382587723,
0.0135305254,
-0.0015390693,
0.0020428326,
-0.0044309692,
0.045185674,
0.0120625179,
0.0266518313,
-0.0222828016,
-0.0015045879,
0.0343604535,
0.0467039831,
0.0260242783,
0.0546562821,
-0.0494333878,
0.0138658425,
0.0595878772,
0.0112951426,
0.0273347721,
0.0260756798,
0.0470244884,
-0.0104675163,
-0.0027348052,
-0.0223780051,
0.0037759244,
0.0293113943,
0.0133476434,
0.0277126767,
0.067274034,
0.0680475459,
-0.0169409048,
-0.0439423956,
-0.0109758619,
0.001906366,
0.0094656209,
-0.0138548007,
0.0157574471,
0.0304165166,
-0.0219327584,
-0.0126711437,
0.0184361264,
-0.0714468136,
0.020843368,
-0.0146661801,
-0.0253749173,
0.078720279,
0.0564813055,
0.0291989557,
-0.0644840226,
-0.0382364988,
-0.0160201751,
0.0836023241,
0.075100787,
0.0282888617,
0.0271139666,
-0.0556501038,
-0.0220174231,
-0.0204689968,
0.0089494521,
0.0384826362,
0.0212832652,
0.0060665733,
0.0382077172,
-0.022680046,
-0.0774795637,
0.0408643894,
-0.0499164611,
-0.0310092736,
0.0400361195,
-0.0124947093,
0.0370867439,
0.033672452,
-0.0242638011,
-0.0003002471,
0.0150094433,
-0.0320327468,
-0.0120952949,
0.0200647563,
-0.0425182134,
-0.0632290989,
0.0330500677,
-0.0323169827,
-0.0060568815,
0.0138734737,
-0.0494811125,
-0.0748044923,
-0.0294590108,
-0.0437802933,
-0.0263198502,
-0.0752015486,
0.0286254995,
0.0082557062,
0.0314802863,
-0.0383471698,
0.0326764286,
-0.0039094454,
-0.0035168573,
-0.0008842182,
0.0540736243,
0.0406301096,
-0.0612161607,
-0.0422753952,
0.0136999404,
0.0261702836,
0.0452285334,
0.0253796168,
0.0340008251,
-0.0341116004,
-0.0188764147,
-0.0959941894,
0.0196707267,
-0.0107753519,
0.0163927358,
0.0529224724,
0.0656295568,
-0.0139124095,
0.0025474878,
-0.0409138575,
0.0093572121,
0.0120402398,
0.0183596704,
0.0057760342,
0.0088075995,
-0.0065185148,
-0.0199745912,
-0.0087057836,
0.0252261199,
0.039153412,
0.0297820438,
-0.0004918727,
-0.0495687053,
-0.0023010096,
-0.0148332212,
0.0326987058,
0.004652679,
-0.059494406,
0.0235428549,
-0.0269656591,
0.0343747064,
0.0051623378,
0.0188043993,
-0.0206515715,
0.0204142537,
0.0268375147,
-0.0578313693,
0.0192034617,
-0.041222129,
-0.0247897413,
0.0072210869,
-0.0506568998,
0.0190543775,
0.034328457,
-0.0134018501,
-0.0251867305,
-0.0643181503,
0.0037361262,
0.0125068612,
-0.0370979086,
-0.0343172215,
0.0182330236,
-0.0292728171,
0.0112449378,
-0.0306597929,
-0.0625728741,
0.054516945,
-0.0899943933,
-0.002844512,
-0.0484957919,
-0.0113773625,
-0.0234617647,
0.0267344024,
-0.0050952495,
0.0141961426,
-0.0412099622,
-0.0045788614,
-0.0223904345,
0.0653540194,
0.0044680876,
-0.0171741955,
-0.0035985636,
-0.0412299186,
-0.0028206867,
-0.0080821645,
0.0079328101,
-0.0503086299,
-0.0142901791,
0.0276448149,
0.0107035274,
0.058440201,
-0.0224780943,
0.0000129077,
0.0041672369,
-0.0000013878,
0.110807687,
-0.0237099733,
0.0051723011,
-0.0140928868,
0.0046723392,
0.017803533,
0.0129938684,
0.0110308137,
-0.0398203246,
0.0061761597,
0.0019566473,
0.0007238241,
-0.0013604119,
-0.0654791817,
-0.0129027013,
0.0206524264,
0.0030517743,
-0.0133464038,
-0.0041919802,
0.0347331986,
-0.0243570339,
-0.0315551311,
0.1030621901,
0.0164547488,
-0.0531387702,
-0.0070560956,
0.0057462286,
0.0487887412,
0.0216061324,
0.0262075216,
-0.0738896057,
-0.0109087545,
-0.0149545157,
0.0296998788,
0.0052021225,
0.0256616957,
-0.0434055924,
-0.1184750944,
0.0279751923,
0.0361706167,
-0.0763796121,
-0.0163326263,
0.0047167595,
-0.0223401152,
-0.0214827452,
0.0540244356,
-0.0094953692,
0.0318478718,
0.0205381401,
0.0319409147,
0.0430115014,
-0.0776206702,
-0.0300668199,
-0.04907557,
0.0573225841,
0.0583754517,
-0.0032189966,
0.0031059436,
-0.0308792293,
0.0439027548,
-0.0031710009,
0.0105484184,
0.0195377599,
0.0332265049,
0.0031506664,
-0.0150012309,
0.0429120325,
-0.0017240683,
-0.0088354629,
0.0286977459,
0.0313802846,
0.0470681153,
-0.017412534,
0.0336942039,
0.0162214935,
-0.0283001363,
0.0233265217,
0.0374923237,
0.0379044786,
-0.0446225703,
0.0373001806,
-0.0095272521,
-0.0182152819,
-0.0965659618,
0.0360506177,
0.0277607962,
-0.04228938,
-0.080392614,
-0.0860631168,
-0.0755186751,
0.0048237867,
0.0478073098,
0.0152433636,
0.0016199842,
-0.016359685,
-0.0065811174,
-0.002902169,
0.0794402212,
-0.0337384157,
-0.0093378127,
-0.0539274886,
-0.0369823501,
-0.0156196058,
-0.0422457531,
-0.018763788,
0.0486555248,
-0.0872940123,
-0.0695608705,
0.0097663803,
0.0753315836,
0.0237171352,
0.0494079329,
-0.0514243655,
-0.0179430824,
0.0164414048,
0.0610155538,
-0.0430180766,
-0.0090817222,
-0.0139124366,
-0.0156908315,
-0.0125137316,
-0.001563795,
-0.0041980278,
0.0116610015,
0.0206249021,
0.0640610382,
0.0096112201,
-0.0376186259,
0.0163781121,
0.0398518555,
0.0562856458,
-0.0689967871,
-0.0162521303,
-0.0556337014,
0.0147161083,
-0.0073382137,
0.0071387663,
-0.0626896173,
-0.0288382731,
0.061677333,
-0.0027978003,
0.0155240307,
0.0036485547,
-0.0136185214,
-0.0039767618,
-0.0521832295,
-0.05666098,
-0.0308039971,
0.0279254541,
0.0153119238,
0.0154610155,
-0.0211848672,
0.016019417,
-0.0257547945,
-0.0061879759,
-0.0328600332,
0.0460525863,
0.0169727486,
0.0183678474,
0.0066485535,
0.0622006804,
-0.0731950477,
-0.0098936884,
-0.0603922196,
0.0651258975,
0.0487429909,
0.023179533,
0.1026305482,
-0.003795027,
-0.0110448441,
-0.0258455798,
0.0313811079,
0.0069276346,
-0.0354661532,
0.013222822,
-0.0043017818,
-0.0083254836,
-0.0169204138,
0.0763009042,
-0.0285595581,
-0.0002600167,
-0.0266259443,
0.0117520001,
-0.0302086156,
-0.0263172854,
-0.0105342958,
-0.0083942339,
-0.0136599215,
0.0041212081,
-0.0116665,
-0.0611763969,
-0.0233228356,
0.0469406471,
0.0012821235,
0.0228910558,
0.0285002626,
0.0437760167,
-0.0695718899,
0.0157105047,
-0.025934808,
0.0289303269,
-0.0022142485,
-0.0224621259,
-0.0198199712,
-6.414390554e-33,
-0.0382483155,
0.0256994963,
0.0361698605,
-0.0568403862,
-0.0471233875,
-0.0078937877,
-0.0214479119,
-0.025300784,
0.0003759167,
0.0052228733,
-0.0138391461,
0.0148460418,
0.0248838812,
0.0487007387,
-0.0016295852,
0.0140833333,
0.0674810708,
0.0074188542,
-0.0366027914,
0.0269340631,
0.0270971674,
0.0091425944,
0.0768773779,
-0.0283758044,
0.0539833121,
-0.0359544978,
-0.0185107458,
-0.0029438185,
-0.0070775826,
0.0129370205,
-0.0051055294,
0.0245418847,
0.0113840951,
-0.0635003597,
-0.0270042047,
-0.0130121866,
-0.055792544,
-0.0170107279,
0.0331940241,
0.0363081247,
-0.049526576,
-0.0335795544,
0.0154933166,
-0.0363502875,
0.0003580653,
-0.0067851599,
-0.0140399858,
-0.0577023923,
-0.035187006,
0.0003497275,
-0.0355441049,
0.0123606175,
-0.0038354523,
-0.0010301351,
-0.0034823366,
0.0495667979,
-0.0249610934,
-0.0065590465,
-0.0530451834,
0.0078772651,
0.0318284966,
0.0316013135,
0.0830804035,
0.0369925424,
0.0025927729,
0.027287269,
0.0162757505,
-0.0063008489,
0.0036113772,
0.0305827577,
0.0172464568,
-0.013234036,
0.0710099936,
0.0563799702,
0.0572295487,
-0.0046302122,
-0.0436127931,
0.0568992198,
0.0057988106,
-0.0386083536,
0.0229623262,
0.0119948639,
-0.003236135,
-0.0161868408,
-0.0419877581,
-0.0280417688,
-0.0267806277,
-0.0239475444,
0.0288587436,
0.0222201981,
-0.0317128934,
-0.0258466192,
0.0604410432,
-0.0085669803,
0.0514917485,
0.0039221621,
-0.0198062491,
-0.0034730947,
-0.0142673906,
0.0214103721,
0.0122744571,
-0.0320218317,
0.0723216683,
0.0512777381,
0.0034787692,
-0.0112727899,
0.0542155132,
0.0052259653,
-0.0437356755,
0.0195809212,
-0.0665508583,
0.0267052501,
-0.0154031832,
0.0225163884,
0.0276535619,
-0.0053193034,
-0.0156999044,
0.0484240651,
0.0315042287,
0.029391706,
-0.0092761237,
-0.0083276117,
0.0091039827,
0.0105435206,
-0.0478975624,
0.0306899343,
-0.0046368716,
-0.0070503745,
0.0417773016,
-0.0532278307,
-0.0162719786,
0.0103290603,
2.666e-7,
0.0379964225,
0.0268951301,
0.0115747945,
0.0169305447,
-0.0011905637,
0.001455254,
-0.0265959036,
0.0291782077,
0.0499968156,
0.0136102429,
0.0217285659,
0.0227952208,
0.0752315372,
0.0217828359,
-0.0721931532,
-0.0566219762,
-0.069147408,
0.0516251288,
-0.0430148318,
-0.000797795,
0.0286190175,
0.0938416123,
0.0024854285,
-0.0037298941,
0.0223042965,
-0.0082510961,
0.0343655571,
-0.0247420277,
-0.0463910401,
0.0256839693,
0.0648978502,
0.0429203585,
-0.0162237938,
0.0021737535,
-0.0352731906,
0.0210959949,
0.0249341708,
0.0499606282,
0.0019499752,
0.0183285251,
0.0224735122,
-0.0025867808,
-0.0138009908,
-0.0494023487,
0.0346837156,
-0.0222540945,
0.011232391,
-0.0185774378,
-0.0399069265,
0.0053022378,
0.0520357192,
-0.0717189014,
-0.0267906468,
0.0195237808,
0.0490875877,
-0.0085751088,
-0.0243790969,
-0.0332012512,
-0.046749223,
-0.0305471178,
-0.0375743769,
-0.0610580519,
-0.0199885014,
0.0006057399,
0.0060166186,
-0.0220403206,
-0.0002960592,
2.340308004e-34,
0.057502728,
0.0104621658,
0.0366697572,
-0.0382703394,
0.0189436637,
-0.0312618874,
0.0350559019,
-0.009095842,
-0.0202106722,
-0.0730133131,
-0.0558005497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13900v1 | FinTree: Financial Dataset Pretrain Transformer Encoder for Relation Extraction | 2023-07-26T01:48:52 | 2023-07-26T01:48:52 | Hyunjong Ok | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present FinTree, Financial Dataset Pretrain Transformer Encoder for
Relation Extraction. Utilizing an encoder language model, we further pretrain
FinTree on the financial dataset, adapting the model in financial domain tasks.
FinTree stands out with its novel structure that predicts a masked token
instead of the conventional [CLS] token, inspired by the Pattern Exploiting
Training methodology. This structure allows for more accurate relation
predictions between two given entities. The model is trained with a unique
input pattern to provide contextual and positional information about the
entities of interest, and a post-processing step ensures accurate predictions
in line with the entity types. Our experiments demonstrate that FinTree
outperforms on the REFinD, a large-scale financial relation extraction dataset.
The code and pretrained models are available at
https://github.com/HJ-Ok/FinTree. | [
0.0262622517,
0.0802922472,
0.0093218451,
0.074852109,
0.0296868235,
0.0186767187,
0.0001099619,
0.0632413179,
-0.0171155017,
-0.0133094601,
-0.0643535107,
-0.013595067,
-0.033913821,
0.0492803641,
0.0093881125,
-0.0307841431,
0.0272033587,
0.0104994206,
0.0220752154,
0.0230094399,
0.0124121262,
0.0102310358,
0.0110031422,
-0.0088980263,
-0.0515347198,
-0.0033103256,
0.0053648115,
-0.0045337891,
0.0141424574,
-0.0257901605,
0.0292606577,
0.0054016551,
0.0131285479,
-0.0147243068,
0.000001886,
-0.0290188137,
-0.0376676172,
-0.0013456505,
-0.0401251391,
-0.0498934798,
-0.0494252034,
-0.0731707513,
0.046256423,
0.0038031936,
-0.0764662623,
-0.0474288091,
0.0379960947,
0.0828159228,
0.0456564799,
0.0937504992,
-0.0319167711,
-0.094624944,
0.0310909636,
-0.06010703,
-0.020058265,
-0.0323880017,
0.0500336625,
-0.0194054693,
-0.059143804,
0.001014374,
-0.0274001081,
-0.0149115548,
0.0375358276,
0.0040060212,
0.0400362313,
0.0228294861,
-0.0546960384,
-0.0194765683,
-0.0409837961,
0.0864444971,
-0.0062521133,
0.0456785373,
0.0180540141,
0.0036100787,
-0.0156691689,
0.0272428878,
0.0008086552,
0.0146227377,
-0.0173344091,
-0.0078942152,
0.0127815958,
0.0339800715,
0.018790029,
-0.0041801147,
-0.0443668477,
-0.0012155882,
-0.0239691697,
-0.0444724783,
0.0267493036,
0.0058590649,
-0.0002686202,
-0.0484679453,
0.0237084981,
0.0373094976,
0.0207138248,
0.0091670537,
-0.0400219858,
-0.0235548913,
-0.0439657159,
-0.0536713712,
-0.0312812403,
0.0178585015,
-0.0191983599,
0.0450016744,
-0.0673122182,
0.0194421131,
0.0065536527,
-0.0009225745,
0.0023071803,
-0.0119938217,
-0.0300859585,
0.0041745263,
-0.0828884244,
0.1019450948,
-0.0889058709,
-0.0311813354,
-0.0445012301,
-0.0099942246,
-0.0193930995,
0.0548200272,
0.0113883493,
-0.0212780647,
0.0046076174,
-0.0121821156,
-0.0212496947,
-0.0031927137,
-0.0399090759,
-0.0109903058,
-0.0057961252,
-0.0153341452,
-0.0174147934,
-0.0043011825,
0.0102490755,
-0.0735458359,
0.0231862273,
0.1118145585,
0.0386898667,
-0.0477777384,
-0.0178161748,
-0.0455010012,
0.0513226539,
-0.0081326719,
0.016662864,
-0.0062227626,
0.0524112061,
0.0153777339,
-0.0185794979,
-0.0068388418,
0.0174195711,
-0.0353267156,
-0.0350087583,
0.0768456981,
-0.02029288,
-0.0274779499,
-0.0201748498,
-0.0180137679,
0.0160283912,
0.0413636155,
0.0047581294,
0.016388895,
0.0492966995,
0.0008433986,
-0.0008975825,
0.0618043132,
0.0090491753,
-0.0765935928,
0.0183125082,
0.0496731289,
0.0292495526,
-0.0103934584,
0.0722910017,
0.0119125992,
-0.0292523727,
-0.0386163965,
0.0171579327,
0.0093906326,
0.0733304918,
0.0348391607,
0.0346253663,
-0.0011884888,
0.0600939132,
-0.0248355772,
-0.0364666246,
-0.0152298743,
-0.0123528559,
0.0325822644,
-0.089087449,
0.0481586792,
-0.016619226,
0.0177403018,
0.0318650119,
-0.0301818084,
-0.0478592366,
-0.0054732016,
0.0502519123,
0.0275892224,
-0.0628707409,
0.080012545,
0.0282113403,
-0.0098507022,
-0.0037408422,
0.0204151925,
0.0239681564,
0.0352045037,
0.0521099642,
-0.0454930626,
-0.0016003383,
-0.0166870076,
-0.0507561266,
0.0356986262,
0.0112221884,
-0.0208973028,
0.0257836226,
-0.0384019464,
-0.0312083587,
0.0420659445,
-0.0051559145,
0.0006914245,
0.0284161028,
0.0060591577,
0.0201531034,
-0.0028090179,
0.0324472189,
0.0368564129,
0.0073751374,
-0.0175327621,
-0.0007022871,
0.0146455569,
-0.006388511,
0.0403963514,
-0.0225981176,
-0.0108487858,
0.0442099869,
-0.0121701425,
0.019462226,
0.0098081911,
-0.0595653392,
-0.04130264,
0.0057881414,
0.0022869469,
-0.0476235114,
0.0025760317,
-0.0387246758,
-0.0021627259,
-0.0617176369,
0.0436708927,
0.0932536498,
-0.0132377325,
-0.0000741211,
0.0425825827,
0.0314560011,
0.0154442051,
0.0803190842,
-0.0008058006,
-0.0028705858,
-0.0224326532,
-0.0255801622,
-0.0196203049,
0.0036207878,
0.0375745408,
0.0157939773,
-0.0283826515,
-0.0175764933,
0.0174946208,
0.0208884031,
-0.0335947424,
-0.0111858528,
-0.036297258,
-0.0404038578,
0.0051821619,
0.0479374751,
-0.0003534765,
0.0297282375,
-0.0231920369,
-0.0271202642,
-0.0116280476,
-0.0037967619,
-0.0429403149,
-0.0251618456,
0.0636017621,
-0.0045504686,
-0.0266133193,
-0.0242744219,
-0.0169117805,
-0.0050848057,
0.0552144721,
0.0109971194,
-0.0399870053,
0.0032194837,
-0.0092493147,
-0.0101008648,
0.0272979941,
-0.0095486408,
0.0259763058,
-0.0347566493,
0.0046273619,
0.0117252059,
0.0025194783,
0.0066843578,
0.1094946042,
-0.0843486711,
0.0002477851,
-0.0176133718,
0.0162186269,
-0.0160170775,
0.0460149422,
-0.0258275196,
0.0424112864,
0.0187912695,
0.0547630638,
-0.0509067886,
0.0208964329,
-0.0281854793,
0.0101800375,
0.0455580838,
0.0120814024,
-0.0279451013,
0.0107908519,
-0.0020651245,
0.0208535641,
-0.0430684835,
0.0061773071,
0.0520340875,
-0.0169170164,
-0.0398148932,
0.0176671408,
-0.0111436266,
-0.0696737021,
0.0675282255,
-0.0022730019,
-0.0010902922,
0.0236794837,
-0.0620597191,
-0.0219301283,
-0.0087641058,
0.0143753914,
-0.0142979193,
0.0440025255,
0.0064361515,
0.027402604,
0.0081384927,
-0.0153478375,
-0.0430266075,
-0.0596526824,
-0.0030202151,
0.0287685003,
0.0098519195,
-0.0367872119,
-0.0170258917,
0.0241541173,
-0.0323675647,
0.0236354936,
0.012735174,
-0.0198168606,
-0.0120930094,
0.0811238885,
0.0751993582,
-0.0143012907,
0.0277169272,
-0.0285876654,
0.045747336,
0.0191108044,
-0.0232672747,
-0.0337882489,
0.0043553412,
0.0009357075,
-0.03108567,
-0.0522719473,
0.0227452964,
-0.0193577167,
0.001805741,
-0.0567455515,
-0.0302173588,
0.1033048928,
0.0078259176,
-0.0013947386,
0.0129214935,
0.0569720231,
0.0019038401,
0.0044895913,
0.0379864238,
-0.1084792167,
-0.0287121944,
-0.0088335322,
-0.0148592992,
0.0553093441,
-0.0625266135,
0.0003473444,
-0.1056857854,
0.0052046692,
-0.0192721058,
-0.0451285839,
-0.0509769656,
-0.0561610796,
-0.0344652757,
-0.0311994106,
-0.0027186323,
0.0296859816,
-0.0412721187,
-0.0007335602,
-0.0003656358,
-0.0233345442,
-0.0067655002,
-0.0046870704,
-0.0365581773,
-0.0217536688,
0.0310251601,
-0.0053622131,
-0.0287444964,
0.0122332759,
-0.0348316878,
-0.0226587262,
-0.0285207722,
-0.0184482075,
0.0698631257,
-0.0438284613,
-0.0412915498,
0.0076823691,
-0.0106259696,
-0.0558298267,
0.01781388,
0.0085663982,
0.0004449952,
0.015944846,
-0.0211888254,
-0.0024488694,
-0.0170859769,
-0.0259385351,
0.0494828112,
0.0059977709,
-0.0033743551,
-0.0129421689,
-0.0170377921,
0.0051410999,
-0.0245892294,
0.0304401256,
-0.0332605541,
-0.0449533276,
0.0191584397,
-0.0792406127,
-0.0850531384,
0.0470573679,
0.0497404151,
-0.0105792694,
-0.0410627164,
0.0374663994,
-0.007954699,
-0.0659527034,
0.0062231338,
-0.0233929325,
0.0230048653,
-0.0191201791,
0.0048426944,
0.0026270214,
-0.006895022,
-0.060701929,
-0.0056534987,
-0.0064895423,
-0.0016428963,
-0.0040035895,
0.0253240392,
0.0201643072,
0.0327619091,
-0.0154934423,
0.0686024427,
0.0184924994,
0.0678368807,
-0.1072338149,
-0.0403597914,
0.0402853899,
-0.0488265194,
0.0107217776,
0.0071136518,
-0.0419054069,
0.0234466083,
-0.0050697676,
0.0309776273,
-0.0456531793,
-0.0035070272,
0.0192701966,
-0.0106095392,
0.0634543076,
0.050482329,
-0.0030025956,
-0.0355945341,
0.0174996536,
-0.0394035131,
0.0016769668,
-0.0345666111,
0.0002412983,
0.0346803479,
0.0287020449,
-0.0087887999,
-0.0083702197,
0.0076323268,
-0.0140693029,
0.0024474203,
-0.0001199354,
0.008961549,
0.0390607491,
0.0184587054,
-0.0501434207,
0.0257031657,
-0.0126906112,
0.0563128553,
0.0033859876,
-0.0216776337,
0.0056963693,
0.0268853884,
0.0067494577,
-0.0067824232,
-0.0179677382,
-0.0189688765,
0.0225225762,
-0.0443557166,
0.0287922807,
0.0227692444,
-0.0529594608,
-0.0177829899,
-0.0189683679,
0.0312167536,
0.0319053531,
0.0274956524,
-0.0218939763,
-0.0195455644,
0.0399926975,
-0.0001032852,
-0.0577216521,
-0.0253865663,
0.0803431645,
-0.0009851648,
0.0473328084,
0.0039109481,
-0.0163657591,
-0.0293290988,
-0.0111418599,
0.0535963923,
0.0144854151,
-0.0031499253,
0.0136827817,
-0.0444242842,
-0.063373059,
0.0109540112,
-0.0197350159,
-0.0001710844,
0.036395371,
0.0462938212,
0.0305864364,
0.0286539104,
-0.0279036928,
-0.0096153747,
0.0224491619,
-0.0032303839,
-0.0418186933,
-0.0629911721,
-5.887025584e-33,
-0.0471601412,
-0.016940698,
0.0383054838,
0.0372579135,
-0.0345538929,
0.0443795435,
-0.0242755078,
-0.0498781763,
-0.0097626485,
0.0240097363,
-0.0007937205,
0.017431343,
0.004496851,
0.0322841741,
-0.0125660496,
-0.0223833118,
0.0191981923,
-0.0044087204,
0.0194660444,
-0.0287119113,
0.0040631783,
0.084201023,
0.0784958303,
-0.0825942531,
-0.0002965048,
-0.003473016,
-0.0114370547,
0.0186582822,
0.0834544599,
0.0432413332,
0.0062029138,
0.0142100323,
0.0031212114,
-0.0751292184,
0.0024544897,
-0.0147585599,
-0.1385439336,
-0.0371822119,
-0.0183225255,
0.036410749,
0.000528688,
0.0241606105,
0.0543777831,
-0.021548301,
0.0204625633,
-0.0230467338,
0.0095814532,
-0.012521401,
0.0076418328,
-0.0598567165,
-0.0659033284,
0.0294681676,
0.0495435558,
0.0266837161,
0.0444932543,
0.0436564051,
0.0266098101,
-0.0243822355,
-0.0222544651,
-0.0103422198,
0.0077211238,
-0.0035664646,
-0.0104680471,
0.0232341792,
0.0040642237,
0.0366499722,
0.021392107,
-0.0393837728,
-0.0018777542,
0.0456891172,
-0.0121593904,
0.0653546378,
0.0011688173,
0.0100244125,
0.0402874127,
-0.0477331467,
-0.070655033,
0.0246606972,
0.0188724734,
0.0241062772,
-0.0450949371,
0.0130135128,
0.0022953304,
-0.0123323184,
0.0336971469,
0.0290218759,
0.0007107043,
-0.0233765859,
0.0001296166,
0.0238973666,
0.0187824816,
0.0775521621,
-0.0047703357,
-0.0519937798,
-0.0601642728,
0.02746059,
0.0163185317,
-0.0067088455,
0.0087076863,
-0.0194858033,
-0.0254177526,
-0.0621619262,
0.0173270926,
-0.0275351424,
0.0159479082,
0.0008109828,
0.0675830096,
-0.0284194481,
-0.0527600758,
-0.0174497105,
-0.0104918228,
0.0273054969,
0.0101239644,
0.0199932028,
-0.0041359514,
0.0596331991,
-0.0299041066,
-0.0012940507,
0.0196611378,
0.0180081744,
-0.0377422608,
0.0353886634,
0.0309048612,
0.0849238262,
0.0409836955,
-0.0280237217,
-0.0265485123,
0.0417553037,
0.0296966117,
-0.0376478098,
-0.02918268,
0.0279930141,
2.507e-7,
0.0409120955,
0.0346861556,
0.0682826862,
0.006452241,
0.0104740197,
0.0169392768,
0.0282992702,
0.0293740779,
-0.0240983441,
-0.0041223932,
0.0315083787,
-0.0033099172,
0.0229094084,
0.0008423977,
-0.0789495781,
-0.0638037622,
-0.0795987993,
-0.0642227903,
-0.0665344447,
0.0251340978,
0.0316399187,
0.0699749067,
0.0197554156,
-0.0098598124,
-0.0233172607,
-0.0205280725,
0.048290126,
-0.0211763103,
0.0079107881,
0.0098180538,
-0.0359749086,
0.0141862649,
-0.0121118985,
0.0463582277,
-0.0244166981,
0.0494470745,
0.0430302657,
0.0176646858,
-0.0142414365,
0.0248167589,
0.0196211487,
0.0153341377,
-0.0169111993,
-0.0113976719,
0.0423188433,
-0.0525087416,
-0.0020914262,
-0.0145819876,
-0.0672582313,
0.0312994048,
-0.029155815,
0.0363094248,
-0.0077557173,
0.0389754809,
0.072962366,
0.0041433563,
-0.0074351868,
-0.0618676543,
0.0145077128,
0.0503131002,
-0.0032916116,
0.0346738994,
-0.0226493385,
-0.045531489,
0.0101161022,
-0.0260211714,
-0.0101131778,
2.405989899e-34,
0.0145070814,
-0.0097869746,
-0.0141868321,
0.0944147557,
0.0730509013,
-0.0304901656,
-0.0222270619,
0.0384705625,
-0.0272317585,
-0.0460538119,
0.0123983026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13854v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13854v4 | WebArena: A Realistic Web Environment for Building Autonomous Agents | 2023-07-25T22:59:32 | 2024-04-16T15:13:18 | Shuyan Zhou, Frank F. Xu, Hao Zhu, Xuhui Zhou, Robert Lo, Abishek Sridhar, Xianyi Cheng, Tianyue Ou, Yonatan Bisk, Daniel Fried, Uri Alon, Graham Neubig | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | With advances in generative AI, there is now potential for autonomous agents
to manage daily tasks via natural language commands. However, current agents
are primarily created and tested in simplified synthetic environments, leading
to a disconnect with real-world scenarios. In this paper, we build an
environment for language-guided agents that is highly realistic and
reproducible. Specifically, we focus on agents that perform tasks on the web,
and create an environment with fully functional websites from four common
domains: e-commerce, social forum discussions, collaborative software
development, and content management. Our environment is enriched with tools
(e.g., a map) and external knowledge bases (e.g., user manuals) to encourage
human-like task-solving. Building upon our environment, we release a set of
benchmark tasks focusing on evaluating the functional correctness of task
completions. The tasks in our benchmark are diverse, long-horizon, and designed
to emulate tasks that humans routinely perform on the internet. We experiment
with several baseline agents, integrating recent techniques such as reasoning
before acting. The results demonstrate that solving complex tasks is
challenging: our best GPT-4-based agent only achieves an end-to-end task
success rate of 14.41%, significantly lower than the human performance of
78.24%. These results highlight the need for further development of robust
agents, that current state-of-the-art large language models are far from
perfect performance in these real-life tasks, and that WebArena can be used to
measure such progress. | [
0.0584299974,
0.0326291136,
-0.0318887234,
-0.0103385737,
-0.0252664723,
0.0045815716,
0.0223436784,
0.0026472316,
0.0699698031,
-0.0252062529,
-0.0169568192,
-0.0251777619,
-0.0283541959,
0.0516336039,
-0.0021418389,
-0.0588165969,
-0.0046805199,
-0.0175728947,
0.012632302,
0.0013424215,
-0.0052798358,
0.0117688654,
-0.0285341758,
0.0548655316,
-0.0088199945,
-0.0267896429,
-0.0159018245,
-0.0106237186,
0.0180951208,
-0.0194378532,
0.0240379423,
0.036083784,
0.0287673324,
0.0126513988,
0.0000022882,
-0.0448766164,
0.0479736924,
-0.0213271808,
-0.015125622,
-0.0108331274,
0.0017424626,
0.0416377112,
-0.0301449262,
0.0464989506,
-0.0549806431,
0.0120754521,
0.0253892764,
0.052091755,
0.0297360923,
0.0562707894,
-0.0108344788,
0.0048187072,
0.0120193446,
0.0023694059,
0.0058332817,
-0.0676221773,
0.013655996,
0.0181409549,
0.0465911292,
-0.0217689984,
0.0180488192,
-0.0006405853,
0.0153576257,
-0.0068792286,
-0.0195548404,
0.0547820032,
-0.0190782677,
-0.0521982126,
0.0019884265,
0.0738063157,
0.0054267063,
-0.0051991544,
0.0241035614,
0.0154742748,
0.0046894085,
0.0174018629,
-0.0497254059,
0.0498173907,
-0.025872102,
-0.0166854374,
-0.0103525082,
-0.0027540724,
0.0001063305,
0.006426286,
-0.0029196038,
0.0583427921,
0.0143110743,
-0.0202622283,
-0.0257695895,
0.012073637,
-0.0190856233,
-0.0595785938,
0.0190135892,
0.0533798076,
-0.0600700378,
0.0315758213,
-0.0316701233,
0.0251499955,
0.0176848769,
-0.0534110181,
0.0189712625,
0.0520634241,
0.0004260199,
0.0592234991,
-0.0195091683,
0.0725106001,
-0.0058373837,
-0.0061345641,
-0.0057401489,
0.0108509706,
-0.0749869868,
0.0207395926,
-0.0264609922,
0.0193274263,
-0.027789196,
-0.0322536752,
-0.007663562,
0.0654753521,
-0.0187538173,
0.0496507958,
0.0019965388,
0.0123779019,
-0.0516683608,
-0.0121924058,
-0.0620827973,
-0.0367613733,
-0.0737662986,
0.0263031889,
0.0054156096,
-0.0699826553,
0.0143795973,
0.0075608557,
0.0268006176,
-0.0098414188,
0.0019207423,
0.1085297987,
-0.0019764667,
-0.0215670709,
-0.0552138351,
-0.0391802974,
0.0113810021,
-0.057076592,
-0.0133470902,
-0.0565958433,
0.0420513377,
0.0168611463,
-0.0371661596,
-0.0354503319,
-0.0028599354,
0.0256325044,
0.0129671935,
0.0597947873,
-0.0127722956,
0.0095112957,
0.0321440361,
0.0147539619,
-0.0330416001,
0.0342299752,
0.026228141,
0.0982483104,
0.0351844914,
0.0442989469,
0.0779625997,
0.0244277511,
-0.0394596457,
0.0080492627,
0.0602294095,
0.0079344278,
-0.0108255092,
0.0417766459,
-0.0000333045,
0.0471848361,
-0.0215305928,
0.0383840539,
0.0889280066,
0.065873988,
-0.049756173,
0.0330397002,
0.0491464175,
0.055572141,
0.0040776418,
-0.0246413443,
-0.0586127229,
0.0549873151,
-0.0383362956,
-0.0026475093,
-0.037966799,
0.0433463044,
-0.0338764414,
-0.0520133339,
0.0059465528,
-0.0167333689,
0.0437715016,
0.0114022931,
0.0452007689,
-0.0087659983,
-0.054820843,
-0.0640558451,
-0.0004868137,
-0.0452443026,
0.010707343,
-0.0757008493,
0.0308315326,
0.1034933105,
0.0585260466,
-0.0314793177,
-0.064695105,
0.0030663116,
0.0284428094,
0.0460930243,
0.0401997678,
-0.0162902363,
-0.0514429882,
-0.0179519523,
-0.0452725738,
-0.0116140572,
0.0061343112,
0.0357144885,
0.0363509022,
0.0163553432,
-0.0004286958,
-0.0284138806,
0.0050473944,
0.0249827914,
-0.0213348884,
-0.0173236206,
-0.0506335944,
0.0181125011,
0.0226606168,
0.0020653685,
-0.0118325353,
-0.0102453111,
0.0059270933,
0.0106732035,
-0.0763422996,
0.0263863988,
0.0107044196,
0.0269642714,
0.0485391803,
-0.0442139022,
-0.02987542,
0.0528101884,
-0.0183784924,
-0.0442199111,
0.0439846292,
-0.0444331095,
0.0163647868,
-0.0024697657,
0.0287376195,
0.0127282124,
-0.0099253356,
0.0096718641,
0.082870394,
0.0381442457,
-0.0325758383,
0.002654118,
0.0088919178,
0.0051512932,
-0.0239695031,
0.0000091519,
0.0058984621,
-0.001923913,
0.0298088342,
0.0515847392,
0.0158743039,
-0.0522984602,
-0.0132606849,
-0.1112171263,
-0.0132079497,
-0.0182467103,
0.0084612751,
0.0322601497,
-0.0027382826,
-0.0136141861,
-0.0114250639,
-0.0414222963,
0.0385585614,
-0.0055128559,
0.0133558232,
0.0472450629,
0.001776455,
-0.0463894792,
-0.0708552301,
0.0083549535,
-0.0177625157,
-0.0387675278,
0.0271869805,
-0.0192842856,
-0.0209354125,
0.0397877134,
-0.0354276299,
0.044658117,
-0.0199295711,
-0.0670645013,
0.0365335047,
-0.0350852348,
0.0329070725,
0.0671030656,
0.0344608054,
0.0355800353,
0.047082644,
-0.0007653903,
-0.0676925555,
0.0275055934,
-0.0133985346,
-0.0212008767,
-0.0519971922,
-0.0181166902,
0.0165164787,
0.0575488955,
0.019534139,
0.0239791367,
-0.080916658,
0.0275385827,
-0.0159865562,
-0.0156256426,
-0.0058862539,
0.0034799511,
-0.0205875095,
0.057951007,
-0.0278717596,
-0.0151350219,
0.0748232082,
0.0061680144,
-0.0021908246,
-0.0104619889,
0.004618403,
-0.0097425049,
0.0744343176,
0.0189174637,
0.0326226912,
0.0001083003,
-0.0168354977,
-0.0408529565,
0.0250741709,
0.0364073329,
-0.0221973062,
0.0270607062,
-0.0670211688,
0.0120365992,
-0.0000138392,
-0.0666233227,
-0.0516170114,
0.0032722994,
-0.0305870343,
-0.0014549316,
0.0242625009,
-0.0346914679,
-0.0261517931,
-0.0263287257,
0.0491266437,
0.0662586913,
-0.0014676814,
-0.0442934074,
-0.037757311,
-0.0282870103,
0.0681141466,
0.0331099853,
-0.0244616382,
-0.0002308563,
-0.0053450554,
0.0511066318,
0.044053629,
-0.0252310392,
-0.0172029119,
-0.0059070629,
0.0156045863,
-0.0424907021,
-0.001009582,
0.0541065075,
0.0246596616,
-0.0408923812,
-0.0153254624,
0.1238649487,
0.0422262773,
-0.0193128455,
-0.000360028,
-0.0318916962,
-0.024767369,
0.0415894166,
0.0398525894,
-0.0468621515,
-0.0182610136,
0.0173369758,
0.0185301155,
0.0070984219,
-0.0375581905,
0.0362776481,
-0.1062419862,
0.0487711206,
-0.0308335368,
0.0147951869,
-0.0006521323,
-0.0603348166,
0.0308484938,
-0.0049002101,
-0.0134208044,
0.0103210295,
0.0142974947,
-0.0240126476,
-0.0006732391,
-0.0275251102,
-0.0599160045,
0.0596393533,
-0.0641603544,
0.0762946904,
0.0693785399,
0.062121436,
-0.0024044889,
-0.0257336758,
0.0093159694,
0.0417838059,
-0.0014851693,
0.0226403456,
0.0480878055,
0.0026174602,
-0.0037087798,
-0.0164644811,
0.0176879,
-0.0763427168,
0.0071234959,
0.022610547,
0.0782954022,
-0.0032454929,
-0.0225936379,
-0.0346434601,
-0.0005837927,
0.0036693318,
0.0622927584,
0.001364283,
-0.0395696387,
-0.0699777529,
-0.04341387,
-0.0156839062,
-0.0457291193,
-0.0380806215,
-0.01809166,
-0.0016321789,
-0.0008307072,
-0.1084184647,
-0.0830548182,
0.0662352368,
0.0274148844,
0.0216821954,
-0.0690836832,
0.0483294502,
0.0251551196,
-0.0185777545,
-0.0273354966,
-0.0341520384,
0.0175851751,
-0.0335992761,
-0.0140619269,
0.0355077498,
-0.0836850256,
0.0046335645,
0.0263954364,
-0.0207380671,
-0.0351115875,
0.0034798852,
0.0440666713,
0.0226572957,
-0.0048170453,
-0.0499472469,
-0.0210148562,
-0.0116222491,
-0.0141839208,
-0.0606793761,
-0.0249646623,
0.0289607961,
0.0445504375,
0.0123414025,
0.0171379857,
-0.0915099904,
0.0341726579,
-0.0358982049,
0.0317527689,
-0.0125745181,
0.006566029,
0.0605031401,
0.0235688146,
-0.0100440793,
-0.0080658281,
-0.0153065333,
-0.0115819462,
-0.0051371888,
-0.0301534291,
-0.0258049238,
-0.0357084088,
0.0014924891,
0.0035764105,
0.0296234563,
0.0355832838,
0.0437615588,
-0.0275189374,
-0.0066448026,
-0.0133128399,
-0.0356518403,
0.0146311186,
0.0091590406,
0.0119249802,
-0.0133907115,
-0.0307850502,
-0.0085214563,
0.0173033532,
0.0380682535,
-0.0067549706,
0.050776083,
0.000907008,
-0.0194378421,
-0.0218600072,
0.0220202077,
-0.0639599413,
-0.0667639002,
0.0003449419,
0.0314575993,
0.0545161217,
0.0218928345,
0.0578037538,
-0.0783854723,
0.0116246548,
-0.0149939852,
-0.0043641026,
0.0020257526,
-0.0384915844,
-0.0113068065,
0.0420006588,
0.0055820197,
-0.025211988,
0.0625052452,
-0.0327844284,
0.0509164929,
-0.0158373956,
-0.0312224347,
-0.0422487557,
-0.0432723239,
-0.0261856392,
0.0084989695,
-0.0201386064,
-0.0559848212,
-0.0323466845,
-0.0636728555,
-0.0356426165,
0.0534025431,
0.0103627881,
-0.0118049867,
0.0351296887,
0.0526479892,
-0.0014751339,
-0.0099333022,
-0.043735873,
-0.0322393477,
-0.0332811475,
0.0159940328,
-0.0567016304,
-6.326963896e-33,
-0.0183072034,
-0.023259839,
0.0493928343,
0.0153596252,
0.0262073725,
-0.0447039828,
-0.0820994154,
0.0131154153,
-0.0076140366,
0.0198626891,
-0.0236927383,
0.0199318808,
0.0164414607,
0.0051932121,
0.018564282,
-0.000149614,
0.0560517311,
-0.0060129003,
-0.0362309106,
0.0347625948,
0.0248660576,
-0.0158721488,
0.0009253183,
-0.0540363789,
0.0053119268,
-0.0171343293,
-0.0406766199,
0.006968352,
0.0138253542,
0.0466501191,
-0.0237677339,
0.0339308791,
0.0396386869,
0.0142323617,
-0.0016405376,
-0.0109098991,
-0.0569672771,
-0.0268188603,
-0.0218549632,
-0.0031191488,
-0.0498559996,
0.000461382,
0.0103186183,
-0.0206622984,
-0.0352820158,
0.031475082,
0.0620058551,
-0.011316915,
0.0232551638,
-0.0140858013,
-0.1140128151,
-0.0128968908,
-0.0108074937,
-0.0367244296,
-0.0148580307,
0.0435417779,
0.0213629249,
-0.0448067151,
-0.0285128374,
0.0298782047,
-0.0179938246,
-0.0124501586,
0.0594187379,
-0.0066644377,
-0.0036734801,
0.0587545261,
0.0145374238,
0.055732742,
-0.0442709289,
0.0123068448,
0.0093281055,
0.0452329107,
0.0196639597,
0.0524452962,
-0.0183675978,
-0.0173220169,
0.0052356934,
0.0602337681,
0.0398965254,
0.0394107997,
0.0208504312,
0.030157404,
-0.0709886029,
0.0103745311,
-0.0108397752,
0.0254168417,
-0.0448674932,
-0.0454045273,
0.0462305583,
0.0150083508,
-0.0128453393,
-0.0718683079,
-0.0099298824,
-0.0294133704,
-0.0088161966,
0.0223278794,
-0.0449366383,
0.0445391573,
-0.0033260558,
-0.0062108608,
-0.0061025,
-0.0441484489,
-0.00096488,
0.0242010765,
-0.0042755986,
0.0310862251,
-0.031515196,
0.0384629592,
-0.029128246,
0.0025026535,
-0.0583758391,
0.0266306046,
0.0350398533,
-0.0130151529,
0.0206204038,
-0.0192262921,
-0.0123986974,
0.0238221027,
0.0024092167,
-0.021388948,
-0.0390629321,
0.0002853898,
-0.0037993372,
-0.0351206325,
-0.0366743095,
-0.0214562174,
-0.0697214827,
0.0794839486,
0.0162163191,
-0.068059735,
-0.0109800287,
-0.0089964867,
3.013e-7,
-0.0318564437,
0.0635177568,
0.0096340645,
0.0636825711,
0.0113926074,
0.0381675214,
-0.0056904,
0.0290275533,
-0.0281118769,
-0.0176795553,
0.0152547751,
0.0436646864,
0.0217307601,
0.0380036719,
-0.0514691845,
-0.0162594765,
0.0040393802,
-0.0201887898,
-0.0552647784,
0.0058976803,
0.0570099801,
0.0370411426,
0.0185525268,
-0.0041683381,
0.0308359656,
-0.0396482125,
0.0251001958,
-0.0195004009,
-0.0008425603,
0.0191545617,
-0.0012441177,
0.0352669246,
-0.0154824043,
0.0062566116,
-0.0111460947,
-0.0215325393,
-0.0133445645,
0.0679980144,
0.0134600615,
-0.0005717331,
-0.0076167099,
-0.0414940603,
0.0427701361,
-0.0288309958,
0.0388091654,
-0.0407096483,
-0.0083634406,
0.0374321267,
-0.0254317038,
-0.0323236808,
-0.0507510416,
-0.0287079308,
-0.0172512494,
-0.0221399069,
-0.0147655234,
-0.0151580414,
-0.0142235532,
-0.0689520165,
0.0282439962,
0.0075073764,
-0.0636214614,
-0.0346812606,
-0.033253558,
0.0248417482,
0.0348629504,
-0.0159612056,
0.0179759469,
2.485487755e-34,
0.002602383,
0.0320791043,
0.0103232162,
-0.0135291498,
0.0508616567,
0.0443063937,
-0.0270358678,
0.0091221211,
0.0448424891,
-0.0382389128,
-0.0463752039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00073v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00073v1 | Trustworthiness of Children Stories Generated by Large Language Models | 2023-07-25T22:55:51 | 2023-07-25T22:55:51 | Prabin Bhandari, Hannah Marie Brennan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown a tremendous capacity for generating
literary text. However, their effectiveness in generating children's stories
has yet to be thoroughly examined. In this study, we evaluate the
trustworthiness of children's stories generated by LLMs using various measures,
and we compare and contrast our results with both old and new children's
stories to better assess their significance. Our findings suggest that LLMs
still struggle to generate children's stories at the level of quality and
nuance found in actual stories | [
0.046662312,
0.0527799726,
-0.0404965393,
0.0536458157,
-0.0494052954,
-0.0066729058,
0.0335000008,
-0.0152944056,
0.0157900974,
-0.0090427548,
-0.0129844602,
-0.0471069813,
0.0538363792,
0.0539016612,
-0.0013734373,
-0.0172229148,
0.0082423827,
-0.0227812305,
0.0489054509,
-0.0029220786,
-0.0119623309,
0.042603381,
0.0111130439,
0.03853257,
-0.0041370387,
-0.0205402393,
0.0217083432,
0.0085969027,
0.0312468261,
-0.0421757698,
-0.0257544629,
0.0053148177,
-0.0029755183,
0.0335184224,
0.0000017852,
-0.0342964828,
-0.0005777626,
-0.0206800364,
0.0014825052,
0.0214065835,
0.050391458,
0.0052580037,
-0.0332506299,
-0.007017435,
-0.0092439484,
0.0272019394,
0.0441306904,
0.0379277728,
0.0374437049,
0.0527152494,
-0.0015841415,
0.0188276451,
0.016189225,
0.0245182775,
0.0393907912,
0.0118214162,
-0.0077925003,
0.0369870029,
0.008488426,
-0.0141752819,
-0.0052336697,
0.0154920546,
0.0155632459,
-0.0602091774,
-0.0124647394,
0.0443763174,
0.0133038331,
-0.0287590623,
-0.035316404,
0.0129515389,
0.0100023346,
-0.0256443042,
-0.0338401571,
-0.0118101193,
-0.0139753465,
0.0676553175,
-0.0431923792,
0.0631712675,
0.0120878899,
0.023264464,
0.0069967243,
0.0172540601,
0.0201395135,
0.0153824743,
0.055222366,
0.0249070413,
0.0056612622,
0.0118389037,
-0.0113055073,
0.0207243543,
0.007567015,
-0.0789063126,
-0.0036909564,
0.0237109866,
0.0654153898,
0.0217600726,
-0.0570799112,
0.0452309027,
0.0239225328,
-0.0190287735,
0.0134215318,
0.0022287739,
-0.0007338415,
0.0184499733,
-0.0000566122,
0.0455716066,
0.0026899134,
-0.0129181035,
-0.003901202,
0.0386816673,
0.0091748536,
0.0089106122,
-0.0096803689,
-0.0049181646,
-0.0119636189,
-0.0387609415,
-0.0340744406,
0.005758469,
0.0293006785,
0.0194967091,
0.0165903196,
0.0092169587,
0.0068543758,
-0.0182397887,
-0.0377987735,
0.0068053715,
-0.0426073112,
0.0244865306,
-0.0126937665,
-0.0342049748,
0.0032897179,
0.0123399021,
0.0403544717,
-0.0281941015,
-0.0066401162,
0.0334433541,
0.002700469,
-0.0341453664,
-0.0674587563,
-0.0388242006,
-0.0183182321,
-0.075945735,
-0.0089915404,
-0.0605916642,
-0.021347899,
-0.0201049503,
0.0561014526,
-0.0471518971,
0.0094180778,
0.004403844,
-0.0444203913,
-0.035355702,
-0.0326010622,
0.0114502618,
-0.0405798033,
0.0149278948,
-0.0132710449,
-0.0024577004,
0.0921605378,
0.0395671949,
0.0521987937,
0.0040811524,
-0.0047487873,
-0.0039210957,
-0.0283543412,
0.0286467951,
-0.007132445,
-0.0302797128,
-0.0269985609,
-0.0037550246,
-0.0185381044,
0.0932716653,
-0.0326565914,
0.0176722892,
0.1488501281,
0.0739116743,
0.0106871249,
0.0458147861,
0.0284428168,
0.0019995598,
0.0625377893,
0.0524698645,
-0.0435615145,
0.024325313,
-0.0103297923,
-0.0071496652,
-0.0229906291,
0.0334420018,
0.018403586,
0.0201734342,
-0.0369509421,
-0.0217420515,
0.0376618803,
-0.0415417589,
-0.0133901117,
0.0052133994,
-0.0244923178,
-0.0568373427,
0.0067819366,
-0.0842833072,
0.0369516909,
-0.0186181627,
0.1045542806,
0.0806507096,
0.0269476324,
0.0491263457,
0.0337596983,
-0.0208333209,
-0.0273624472,
0.0177725498,
-0.0295349173,
0.0017616692,
0.0083869863,
-0.0070185894,
0.0299184807,
-0.0360509306,
0.0253131445,
0.0123937922,
-0.0009248993,
0.0473677218,
-0.0078247553,
-0.0307242051,
-0.0342166536,
0.0340759903,
-0.0577293597,
0.0276808552,
-0.0290111881,
0.0068475683,
-0.0285148937,
0.0220438559,
-0.0386325903,
-0.0002056489,
0.0294494964,
0.0114893718,
-0.0106818993,
0.0439180434,
-0.0717121959,
-0.0020038905,
0.0209912211,
-0.0845459327,
0.0062084072,
-0.0099282758,
0.048377011,
0.0082770223,
0.0234636702,
-0.0420197099,
0.0589594468,
-0.0043683248,
0.0396073945,
-0.0550369509,
-0.0412995555,
-0.0098101646,
0.04155045,
-0.0064488994,
0.0165359173,
-0.0513396226,
0.0360408276,
-0.008306385,
0.0139871417,
0.022510346,
0.0364610367,
0.022083506,
0.0306693278,
0.0211462565,
-0.0031901028,
-0.0421665423,
-0.0770790204,
-0.0462729931,
-0.0107891066,
0.0279182307,
0.0015095196,
0.0382811464,
-0.0456907973,
-0.0121331494,
0.0638112724,
-0.0731001869,
0.0104981391,
0.0025629043,
0.0080163013,
-0.0064037177,
-0.0203202218,
-0.0154884709,
-0.0348240398,
0.0187689457,
0.0036426911,
0.0972029492,
0.0749339759,
-0.0081134411,
-0.059187822,
0.03040535,
-0.065051198,
-0.0180426408,
-0.012045267,
-0.0508516766,
0.0205587447,
-0.0013558854,
0.040564727,
0.0250450894,
0.0093717994,
-0.0189278927,
0.063971512,
-0.0540194921,
-0.0089230342,
-0.0389134213,
0.0199407563,
-0.0136548989,
-0.0136025324,
-0.0701345131,
0.0003965969,
0.0632645413,
0.0312070325,
-0.0037693693,
-0.0220592897,
0.0849938616,
0.0126479352,
-0.0108153485,
0.0313135907,
-0.1006541774,
0.0014766572,
0.0901351497,
-0.0178462975,
-0.0900900364,
0.0675551295,
-0.0509746969,
0.0095366957,
-0.0038077135,
-0.0010690433,
0.0065901591,
0.0715350211,
-0.0156567208,
0.0536631458,
0.0367489457,
0.0149775948,
-0.0144975223,
0.0022534784,
0.0472656004,
-0.0191489179,
0.0320034474,
-0.0342245102,
-0.0272712167,
0.0367948785,
0.0155822765,
-0.0506135896,
-0.0462180749,
-0.0337456837,
-0.0399389192,
0.0197086036,
-0.0857062861,
-0.0364280678,
-0.0150531139,
0.0430665947,
-0.0076706167,
-0.0304378942,
-0.0171772894,
0.011860407,
0.026520649,
0.0578624085,
-0.0482136905,
0.0623595677,
-0.0670423061,
0.0194363836,
0.0608528815,
-0.0387103744,
0.0129573094,
0.0073909913,
0.0133749349,
0.0244520772,
0.0301329214,
-0.0438537151,
0.0145713417,
0.0490849316,
-0.0495265275,
0.0099237589,
0.051902622,
0.0214700717,
0.0008521116,
0.0091516292,
-0.0129479766,
0.0123326369,
-0.022227332,
-0.0458543897,
-0.0412241556,
0.0217088927,
0.0254280902,
-0.0252790451,
-0.0282998625,
-0.0540375561,
-0.0399001427,
-0.0602822304,
0.0261702444,
0.01931227,
-0.0234575402,
-0.0190327261,
-0.0304432269,
-0.0458192416,
0.0658975244,
0.0113229314,
0.0264378674,
-0.0420211777,
-0.0227974709,
-0.0624948479,
0.0256867912,
0.0010992528,
0.0322672799,
-0.0318942294,
0.0509016812,
0.0477667712,
0.0557723194,
-0.013998311,
-0.0509426333,
-0.0760811642,
0.0412667505,
-0.0477835685,
0.0395663232,
0.024762895,
-0.0128028523,
0.0102451788,
-0.0311713256,
0.0390444249,
0.0179202333,
-0.0439698696,
0.0027143895,
0.03642001,
0.0198065136,
-0.0817352235,
0.0091260169,
0.0206140708,
0.0237534214,
0.0867430866,
0.0209237467,
-0.0301692951,
0.0379524007,
-0.0332426801,
-0.040222358,
0.0158435795,
-0.0594658293,
0.0565087162,
-0.0003829743,
0.0043058586,
-0.1070296243,
-0.0150800897,
-0.0122904275,
0.0200945791,
0.0327171758,
-0.0126723666,
0.0515022278,
-0.026340533,
-0.0294511784,
0.0164207239,
-0.0307108946,
0.0060089841,
-0.0231593866,
0.0522509404,
-0.0064358548,
-0.0714824274,
0.0346684121,
0.0147029404,
-0.081517294,
-0.0411199592,
-0.0130373761,
-0.015082974,
0.0290618446,
-0.0237554852,
0.0294546951,
-0.0419793166,
0.0283624195,
-0.037910074,
-0.0730235949,
0.0207804888,
-0.0167637262,
0.0105399676,
0.0303470306,
-0.0074687139,
-0.0116218505,
0.0111713791,
0.0257277675,
-0.0045569153,
0.0307117775,
-0.0538358763,
0.0098178005,
0.0279363301,
0.005641914,
-0.0387703031,
0.0302664954,
-0.0695475116,
-0.0200096779,
-0.0602025762,
-0.0061838212,
-0.0187118351,
0.0229399838,
0.0359075703,
-0.0032428652,
-0.0125121716,
-0.0402887277,
-0.0598154925,
0.0506833084,
-0.0352749005,
0.0202762261,
-0.0126837995,
0.0043549114,
0.0428172089,
0.0125376862,
-0.0317155905,
-0.0061819563,
-0.0649043322,
0.0570757352,
0.0329171047,
0.0035483718,
-0.0037989467,
-0.0516304113,
-0.0181561559,
0.0016499191,
-0.0398902707,
-0.0379346199,
-0.0401407033,
-0.0123755429,
0.0197344907,
-0.0101151327,
0.1033201516,
-0.0527182035,
0.0171208363,
-0.0295702498,
0.0107596526,
0.0442843139,
-0.0293773711,
-0.0175043624,
-0.0024436109,
-0.0100902906,
0.0566420034,
0.04427379,
-0.0309527982,
0.0190328155,
-0.0087558758,
-0.0214252807,
-0.0016995213,
-0.0288630594,
0.007914748,
0.0363964364,
0.0106124366,
-0.0231642406,
-0.0574318357,
-0.0220707431,
-0.0085481154,
0.0043543996,
0.0076127779,
-0.0303894896,
-0.0106089534,
0.0321890712,
0.006582607,
0.0446148291,
-0.0470187776,
-0.0104685742,
0.0133213419,
-0.000341243,
-0.0127570191,
-5.684135259e-33,
0.0375635847,
-0.0582223311,
-0.0236758478,
0.004369779,
-0.0169880372,
0.0215850379,
-0.0366241708,
0.0359536931,
0.000188095,
0.0391204655,
0.0157063957,
-0.0376704,
0.0030389032,
-0.0205528699,
-0.0212415736,
0.0548309274,
0.0162253082,
0.011082517,
-0.0500622541,
-0.018043695,
0.0318612084,
-0.033623226,
0.043773748,
-0.067443043,
0.0566751324,
-0.0764342397,
-0.0474009477,
-0.0232115015,
0.0162887182,
0.0623048842,
-0.0197976436,
0.0331754014,
0.006953985,
0.0091824243,
-0.0096007744,
0.0179151949,
-0.0222009886,
-0.0023757785,
0.0386042781,
-0.0435326211,
-0.0508086868,
-0.0160979982,
0.0032309669,
-0.0048151542,
0.0060348338,
-0.0269742999,
0.0209594686,
-0.0340478048,
-0.0013636183,
-0.008416241,
-0.0747437552,
-0.0011339899,
0.0047446904,
-0.0187454782,
0.0100823482,
0.0690273866,
0.0158108547,
0.0074049737,
-0.0201462377,
0.0609979816,
0.0025945595,
0.0207525305,
-0.008246243,
-0.0352745391,
-0.0064212242,
0.1001627073,
0.0148506826,
0.0250431448,
-0.0323923752,
0.0520662218,
0.0168378744,
-0.0045716502,
0.0639842525,
0.1015579775,
-0.0166174993,
0.0009669064,
-0.0540020391,
0.0171276145,
0.0265346989,
0.0093276296,
0.0409937948,
0.0048415051,
-0.021981841,
-0.0151413986,
-0.0323748961,
-0.0039297813,
-0.0153403133,
-0.0393588915,
-0.0159280002,
-0.0116218319,
-0.0390873849,
-0.0049668895,
-0.0096532824,
-0.0184955616,
-0.0246565752,
0.0209015124,
-0.0524171703,
0.0059217936,
-0.012053743,
0.0373186357,
-0.007999233,
0.0051884409,
0.0257899743,
0.0128637692,
0.0380625241,
0.0370658934,
0.0248552654,
0.0060835844,
-0.0682929456,
0.0263757706,
-0.0195961203,
0.014231124,
0.0627100021,
-0.0115629761,
0.0258697793,
-0.0696566775,
-0.0143128121,
0.0069124326,
0.002789815,
-0.0117670521,
-0.0469617508,
0.0123897046,
-0.0235883128,
-0.0096502872,
-0.032627292,
-0.0098125171,
-0.03402384,
0.0086426856,
0.0685920343,
-0.0296899211,
0.0057947612,
-0.0561554506,
2.507e-7,
-0.0616804659,
0.0549730547,
0.0101282159,
0.0159291439,
0.0355200581,
0.0454721488,
-0.0198824164,
-0.0175653975,
0.0269329865,
-0.0282671489,
-0.0418234915,
-0.0191939585,
0.0615471601,
0.0932860076,
-0.0485048182,
0.0399300754,
-0.0820821151,
-0.0060774102,
-0.0215397347,
-0.0392437093,
0.0545389131,
0.0142690651,
0.0456606485,
-0.0420536511,
0.0178299844,
-0.0382981487,
0.0075310804,
-0.0367651246,
-0.0256429277,
0.0057338439,
-0.0294234492,
0.0065965019,
-0.014187051,
-0.0204761494,
-0.0132981641,
0.0257173833,
-0.0237776842,
0.0563859977,
-0.0058123395,
0.0294935144,
0.0495585129,
-0.0473583005,
-0.0243812632,
-0.0759029835,
0.0248995405,
0.0181804225,
-0.0142340753,
0.0257611182,
0.0169473086,
-0.0086726137,
0.0175653789,
-0.0768840164,
0.0064617633,
0.0363101549,
-0.0033020787,
0.0095101278,
0.0201835651,
-0.0019701177,
-0.0175356157,
-0.0287847128,
-0.0177288894,
-0.0834424198,
0.0030205308,
0.0094466731,
-0.0554773659,
-0.0792408809,
0.0654227287,
1.929973232e-34,
0.0151068196,
-0.04769722,
0.0065348912,
-0.003060841,
0.0797382742,
0.0203740541,
0.0387999192,
-0.0147055872,
0.0286547001,
-0.0116564296,
-0.0253268108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13829v1 | ARC-NLP at Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection 2023: Multimodal Methods Boosted by Ensemble Learning, Syntactical and Entity Features | 2023-07-25T21:56:14 | 2023-07-25T21:56:14 | Umitcan Sahin, Izzet Emre Kucukkaya, Oguzhan Ozcelik, Cagri Toraman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Text-embedded images can serve as a means of spreading hate speech,
propaganda, and extremist beliefs. Throughout the Russia-Ukraine war, both
opposing factions heavily relied on text-embedded images as a vehicle for
spreading propaganda and hate speech. Ensuring the effective detection of hate
speech and propaganda is of utmost importance to mitigate the negative effect
of hate speech dissemination. In this paper, we outline our methodologies for
two subtasks of Multimodal Hate Speech Event Detection 2023. For the first
subtask, hate speech detection, we utilize multimodal deep learning models
boosted by ensemble learning and syntactical text attributes. For the second
subtask, target detection, we employ multimodal deep learning models boosted by
named entity features. Through experimentation, we demonstrate the superior
performance of our models compared to all textual, visual, and text-visual
baselines employed in multimodal hate speech detection. Furthermore, our models
achieve the first place in both subtasks on the final leaderboard of the shared
task. | [
0.0328714624,
0.062450625,
0.0116347559,
0.0387048088,
-0.0088233948,
0.0294204727,
0.0319086462,
0.0025527764,
0.0010764101,
-0.0895784199,
-0.0072056181,
-0.0432158969,
-0.0112466766,
0.020395942,
-0.000923143,
-0.0701073483,
0.0285168644,
0.0317956731,
0.0230131354,
-0.0067421147,
0.0782319233,
0.0306174196,
-0.0347274691,
0.0502258278,
-0.0992939249,
0.0078515215,
0.03101076,
-0.0023327412,
0.0605686009,
-0.0150344633,
0.0283765178,
0.0175083894,
0.043273896,
0.0501480773,
0.0000017423,
-0.015388824,
0.0029980591,
-0.0150916884,
0.0053304452,
-0.0728766322,
0.0599850006,
-0.0413626879,
-0.0088198287,
-0.0051600733,
-0.0125234518,
0.0116965529,
0.0612278469,
0.1094975099,
0.0713108629,
0.0763577297,
-0.0209504683,
-0.0312306788,
0.0157984775,
0.0272567999,
-0.0122679891,
0.0337365344,
0.0063503953,
-0.0708571747,
-0.0434255823,
0.0389626138,
-0.0082509471,
0.0291731637,
0.0037173261,
0.0307608619,
0.0047246963,
-0.010353934,
-0.0464419648,
-0.0207238384,
-0.0201385338,
0.0648128837,
-0.0477951616,
0.0075052544,
-0.0064414721,
-0.0051094093,
-0.0350588821,
-0.0275020935,
-0.0088619152,
0.008843245,
-0.0200395044,
0.0292765852,
-0.0265816227,
0.0160957016,
0.0367765799,
0.0579253733,
0.0151447449,
0.0150520168,
-0.0196236614,
-0.0061579109,
0.0138108553,
-0.0032654284,
-0.0346870571,
0.0020465485,
0.0169912353,
-0.0016145982,
0.0007725701,
-0.0193039589,
-0.0639488623,
-0.065155074,
-0.0138262035,
-0.0707894489,
0.0344156809,
0.0230306238,
-0.0354666896,
0.0359679647,
-0.01445923,
0.0173138008,
-0.0224674419,
-0.0168530624,
0.0041636005,
-0.005437267,
-0.0334647223,
0.0117875934,
-0.0089558037,
0.009793207,
-0.0302359443,
-0.0323877111,
-0.0270701461,
-0.043660596,
-0.0245140791,
0.0001260042,
-0.0202790294,
0.0536485389,
-0.0238065924,
-0.019953819,
-0.0006827351,
0.0421013087,
-0.0273983832,
0.0144098457,
-0.0453455336,
-0.0517451391,
0.0230626091,
0.0710066855,
-0.0099081816,
-0.0162331313,
0.0228358675,
0.0685458928,
0.0028536294,
-0.0234036092,
-0.0165765248,
-0.0491327234,
-0.0389348604,
-0.0334612802,
0.0540564619,
-0.0494984314,
0.0207859185,
-0.03099324,
-0.0044636717,
-0.0525525399,
0.018709287,
0.0237002764,
-0.0181823373,
0.1016554236,
0.0515194051,
-0.0260669161,
0.0322739705,
0.0009198369,
0.0156582948,
0.0638382584,
0.028684739,
0.0589440465,
0.0565017462,
0.0185832735,
0.0059007513,
0.0412395634,
0.0290497039,
0.0018683621,
-0.0371163227,
-0.0071418993,
-0.0647505149,
0.0004352657,
0.0021635252,
0.0136853196,
0.0065441276,
-0.0821332484,
0.0676481128,
0.037969321,
-0.0601887591,
-0.0276779141,
0.0344084911,
0.0126037681,
-0.0526103452,
-0.0042030551,
-0.0364758149,
0.0216695089,
-0.021756202,
-0.0562743582,
0.0282813646,
0.0808595866,
-0.0298665855,
-0.0099064987,
-0.0059092105,
-0.0162741374,
0.0138002243,
-0.0377137065,
0.0178802144,
-0.0041210041,
-0.0433582217,
0.023561595,
0.035509333,
-0.0079745986,
-0.006665187,
-0.0134464102,
-0.0103998082,
0.0685008094,
0.0054310309,
-0.0118518462,
-0.0059218062,
-0.078156136,
0.0335806087,
0.0439981446,
-0.0259106029,
0.0042305156,
0.0413464159,
-0.0460535511,
-0.0385577269,
0.0022888598,
0.0081892228,
0.0276682004,
0.0462863892,
0.0204851348,
-0.0101951407,
0.033320751,
-0.0246417262,
0.0211476944,
0.0545367673,
-0.0148859313,
-0.0234091766,
0.0561673827,
0.0244128462,
0.0367825776,
-0.0324320942,
-0.0421681888,
0.0256200265,
-0.0458104126,
-0.060932409,
0.02848728,
-0.0460829921,
-0.0321321487,
-0.0089462791,
-0.0661726892,
-0.0027400514,
0.0537081696,
-0.0070976457,
0.0375170745,
0.0555276498,
-0.0308646411,
-0.0513688922,
-0.0316497646,
-0.0353071094,
-0.0091147237,
0.0525909625,
-0.0185162276,
0.0569753647,
-0.0144220972,
-0.0279863682,
-0.0035706556,
-0.0365112685,
0.0542956665,
0.0278872494,
-0.0683443919,
-0.0104412185,
-0.0042131222,
0.0236739404,
0.0119952355,
-0.0294704493,
-0.0195899475,
0.036727827,
-0.072191827,
-0.006398764,
-0.039101731,
-0.0287087988,
-0.0105727334,
0.0062895422,
0.0195484031,
-0.0027968318,
-0.0025486844,
-0.0385813303,
0.0451842397,
0.02743835,
-0.0056419349,
-0.0257703457,
-0.0076477062,
-0.017778622,
-0.002093741,
-0.0151350424,
0.060597159,
0.005822822,
-0.0909627676,
0.0414537676,
-0.044149749,
-0.0255350266,
0.0395711325,
-0.017143175,
-0.0340452939,
0.0548759103,
0.0166047942,
0.0101023214,
0.0574331619,
0.024880236,
0.0955481008,
-0.0075277179,
0.0153402016,
-0.0281210486,
-0.0032817733,
-0.020633053,
0.0671489611,
-0.0064853039,
-0.0159623679,
-0.0155878607,
0.0597747937,
0.0421053991,
0.0059939674,
-0.0506723039,
-0.0016481404,
-0.0393848307,
-0.0711688697,
-0.0551048405,
-0.0501218326,
0.0127975978,
-0.0536145158,
-0.0339901336,
-0.0561832041,
0.0555773117,
0.0070618065,
0.0171915926,
-0.0026122492,
-0.0212380886,
-0.018844435,
0.0662655309,
0.0209460817,
0.0529243574,
-0.0060704211,
-0.0184755009,
-0.0070018675,
-0.0247321278,
0.0177788865,
0.0072391252,
-0.001480079,
-0.0091781896,
0.0108702648,
0.0082526244,
-0.0164246447,
-0.0617108867,
-0.0798966661,
-0.0060557164,
-0.0245649181,
-0.0263467561,
-0.0221939534,
-0.0450422056,
0.0035614199,
0.0543995537,
-0.0241157338,
0.0104809757,
0.0190546531,
0.0132865394,
0.0347841047,
0.00280025,
-0.0251989607,
-0.0133988587,
-0.0242164414,
-0.030459702,
0.0654688925,
0.0040944396,
0.0288718455,
-0.0610751063,
0.0109039145,
0.0094711212,
0.0295993984,
-0.0228127129,
-0.0433453172,
0.0289828051,
-0.0133516099,
0.0561505929,
0.0714486092,
-0.0044300822,
-0.0211112946,
-0.0016974716,
0.0442610197,
-0.0008838692,
0.0053971815,
-0.0319002159,
-0.078711994,
-0.0335082114,
-0.0298852921,
-0.0312061645,
-0.0437740833,
-0.0383718275,
0.0034796693,
-0.0372574404,
-0.013956462,
-0.0251413472,
-0.0559489727,
-0.0256304778,
0.0045402474,
0.0292012636,
-0.003511653,
0.0097538214,
-0.0443050079,
0.0386999585,
-0.015868932,
0.0109892031,
-0.0474583022,
-0.0535428263,
-0.0005668247,
-0.0475425087,
0.02311977,
0.056259688,
0.0485508069,
-0.0313080847,
0.0127395708,
-0.00082333,
0.0035140417,
0.008918752,
-0.0495485254,
0.0753927827,
-0.0443970002,
-0.0624518543,
0.005781082,
0.0339167155,
0.0319772065,
0.0053615267,
-0.0203915909,
0.046746511,
-0.0052877436,
-0.0076352051,
-0.0713122487,
0.0336096138,
0.0511757284,
0.0570428446,
-0.0095641781,
-0.0429161936,
0.0230483729,
-0.0406786166,
0.0001461278,
-0.0692254975,
-0.0387514569,
0.0136693185,
-0.022131497,
-0.0215433035,
-0.0457888171,
-0.0491863154,
0.047215227,
0.0289324205,
-0.0032239663,
0.0098997001,
-0.053752847,
0.0118311513,
-0.0566569567,
0.026202308,
0.0291541982,
0.0841347128,
0.0011789611,
0.000724379,
-0.0133547904,
-0.0032795339,
-0.0283228066,
0.0413879864,
-0.0533343814,
-0.0299815424,
0.0170843005,
0.0281727854,
0.0053659217,
0.019007517,
0.0254146457,
-0.0466033146,
0.061975535,
0.0504486226,
0.018331293,
0.0047388491,
0.0252894703,
-0.0082891071,
-0.0074486299,
0.0250135139,
0.0231801961,
0.0619270243,
0.0131259253,
-0.0430016778,
-0.0602387935,
-0.0169487651,
-0.0400820337,
-0.0319067612,
0.0319673419,
-0.0320461653,
-0.0514692962,
-0.0476236418,
-0.0123594059,
0.0129205547,
-0.0345690399,
-0.0321427584,
0.0370850749,
0.0004085194,
0.0089741573,
-0.0257105343,
0.016262237,
0.0019897444,
0.0201433487,
-0.0234891903,
0.0281187259,
0.0362334438,
0.0347123966,
0.0067502349,
0.0506687909,
-0.0097198691,
0.0655902699,
0.0081578083,
-0.0273725949,
-0.0181214362,
0.0216163099,
0.0333419815,
-0.0097587742,
0.0255948063,
0.0047266586,
0.0502635278,
0.0346988291,
-0.0654529035,
-0.0028268483,
0.008786276,
-0.0073872595,
0.0291340817,
-0.0042619514,
-0.0110651953,
-0.0049272026,
0.023535125,
-0.014054372,
-0.0452691503,
0.0379215889,
0.0250252448,
-0.0071347095,
0.0184262954,
0.0208061785,
-0.0083552618,
0.0434256122,
0.0856165364,
-0.0200864784,
-0.0442404673,
0.0038657179,
0.0605334006,
0.0093939109,
0.0104166279,
0.0584813729,
-0.0035841195,
-0.0145716695,
0.0266473945,
-0.0451151356,
-0.0164003614,
0.0147063378,
0.0247714911,
0.0443380214,
0.0160413329,
0.0517257676,
-0.0037136045,
-0.0112041123,
-0.0078463517,
-0.0292289089,
0.0153782051,
-5.612309983e-33,
-0.0282287076,
-0.0240977257,
0.0015777923,
-0.0450246632,
-0.0040261946,
0.0160625335,
0.0278035942,
0.0045046681,
-0.0111096064,
0.0298293605,
0.0427446999,
0.0032148273,
-0.0029552593,
0.0055106669,
-0.0332891941,
-0.0317793861,
0.0326081291,
-0.0228110794,
0.0088801943,
-0.0050149783,
0.1061332971,
0.0171353463,
0.0674974769,
-0.0641833395,
0.0251526255,
0.0281971339,
-0.0579426028,
-0.0147667537,
0.0504211113,
0.0624637902,
-0.0427171849,
0.0522903018,
0.0565870181,
-0.033323139,
-0.0058405176,
0.0504719429,
-0.0236951262,
-0.0003878867,
0.0266318452,
0.0282943454,
-0.0367437229,
0.0028867244,
0.0312761776,
-0.0061700894,
-0.0080981851,
-0.0256421324,
0.0576368608,
-0.0234657861,
0.0414113998,
-0.0183700565,
-0.0847298279,
0.0275360569,
-0.0249322131,
0.0035551516,
-0.020876497,
0.0160986576,
0.0736134648,
0.0255446658,
-0.0513119549,
0.0129145905,
-0.0648095384,
-0.0065278779,
0.0091564832,
-0.0205261204,
-0.0111486902,
0.0917219371,
0.0062947222,
-0.0161401108,
-0.0578939356,
0.0372470617,
0.0466260202,
0.0640838966,
0.0643212944,
0.0875994042,
-0.0104049006,
-0.0142631596,
-0.0721367374,
0.0220337994,
0.0293006599,
0.0101511255,
-0.0006696954,
-0.0172711071,
-0.0533060655,
-0.0017212731,
-0.0091204597,
-0.0242069364,
-0.0301489346,
-0.0444563217,
0.025884198,
-0.0007936141,
-0.0348137692,
0.0796417966,
0.0639671758,
-0.0076342076,
-0.0225395001,
0.0496284813,
-0.0015943227,
0.0315778442,
0.0205189269,
0.0466757268,
-0.0472028293,
-0.0033858751,
0.0421067178,
-0.0258062165,
0.0323065743,
-0.0132364146,
0.0637509823,
0.0487553254,
-0.0583897531,
-0.0009067369,
0.0008202886,
0.0306544248,
-0.0305590257,
0.0698496103,
-0.0029403514,
0.0348782428,
-0.0376162082,
-0.0012513376,
-0.0184085555,
-0.0372288227,
0.0155760935,
-0.0372055173,
-0.017682299,
0.0143468063,
-0.0052081486,
0.0023949926,
-0.0344260186,
-0.0636991039,
0.0089371577,
-0.1025631428,
0.0105040707,
-0.0330362692,
2.437e-7,
-0.0105283558,
0.0146288211,
0.0147990296,
0.0161857307,
0.0019949442,
0.0557151884,
0.0318643488,
0.0471075997,
-0.0521076918,
-0.0420643501,
-0.0213312786,
0.0588623546,
0.0059043225,
0.036607068,
0.0005091794,
-0.0062072342,
-0.01060123,
-0.0147092231,
-0.0748445541,
0.0214459058,
0.0095320167,
0.0816541016,
0.0502352864,
-0.0504673384,
-0.0140938172,
-0.0040737758,
0.0345902629,
-0.0067707375,
-0.0423211381,
-0.0375533216,
0.0378033072,
0.01185505,
-0.034922231,
0.0237945355,
0.0079791285,
0.008701629,
0.0502940007,
0.007627639,
-0.0146865966,
-0.0131070577,
-0.0123693421,
-0.0196635667,
-0.0372957848,
0.0003868903,
0.0629507676,
-0.0023233383,
-0.0186971966,
-0.0476322807,
-0.0226337705,
0.0010440359,
0.0333928354,
-0.0011839177,
-0.0237241872,
-0.0053278692,
0.0520036519,
-0.0296948552,
-0.0205694176,
-0.113534838,
0.0043507009,
-0.0073908847,
-0.0444447659,
-0.0074025574,
-0.0255740266,
-0.0094131334,
0.0478520244,
0.0014525882,
-0.0290512815,
1.898431757e-34,
0.0369375348,
-0.0270465855,
-0.0172677711,
-0.0293422136,
0.0070664757,
0.0000495344,
-0.0654615089,
-0.0485029183,
0.0291120615,
-0.0251338482,
-0.0189823341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00129v1 | Speech representation learning: Learning bidirectional encoders with single-view, multi-view, and multi-task methods | 2023-07-25T20:38:55 | 2023-07-25T20:38:55 | Qingming Tang | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | This thesis focuses on representation learning for sequence data over time or
space, aiming to improve downstream sequence prediction tasks by using the
learned representations. Supervised learning has been the most dominant
approach for training deep neural networks for learning good sequential
representations. However, one limiting factor to scale supervised learning is
the lack of enough annotated data. Motivated by this challenge, it is natural
to explore representation learning methods that can utilize large amounts of
unlabeled and weakly labeled data, as well as an additional data modality. I
describe my broad study of representation learning for speech data. Unlike most
other works that focus on a single learning setting, this thesis studies
multiple settings: supervised learning with auxiliary losses, unsupervised
learning, semi-supervised learning, and multi-view learning. Besides different
learning problems, I also explore multiple approaches for representation
learning. Though I focus on speech data, the methods described in this thesis
can also be applied to other domains. Overall, the field of representation
learning is developing rapidly. State-of-the-art results on speech related
tasks are typically based on Transformers pre-trained with large-scale
self-supervised learning, which aims to learn generic representations that can
benefit multiple downstream tasks. Since 2020, large-scale pre-training has
been the de facto choice to achieve good performance. This delayed thesis does
not attempt to summarize and compare with the latest results on speech
representation learning; instead, it presents a unique study on speech
representation learning before the Transformer era, that covers multiple
learning settings. Some of the findings in this thesis can still be useful
today. | [
-0.0417666547,
0.0746372566,
0.0169285219,
0.0110478625,
-0.0066325204,
0.0143370768,
0.0318985395,
-0.0284623932,
0.0022042303,
-0.0266925413,
-0.0717972443,
-0.0511097312,
0.0002630839,
0.0242079385,
0.0319471285,
-0.0907733887,
0.0278642848,
-0.007484097,
0.0005774149,
0.0007848925,
-0.0030984941,
-0.0238105003,
-0.0417405665,
0.0479900688,
-0.0326325931,
-0.017820552,
-0.0186537579,
-0.0222530272,
-0.0025678233,
-0.0417731926,
0.0121822953,
0.0269476697,
0.0779621154,
0.0296906978,
0.0000020974,
0.0121717984,
-0.0131011736,
-0.0215522498,
-0.0204009078,
0.0008282827,
-0.0085981442,
-0.0033034696,
-0.0009440382,
0.0052763112,
-0.0429639295,
-0.0622456335,
0.0361238159,
0.0766890123,
0.0639628544,
0.0683942288,
-0.0188815724,
-0.060371682,
-0.0123865781,
-0.0466435514,
-0.0048240139,
0.0157983676,
-0.0249557514,
-0.031716425,
-0.0222927686,
0.0170108732,
-0.0448930785,
0.0521719158,
0.0291929115,
0.0009329761,
0.0027395824,
0.0325698182,
-0.0224383865,
-0.012176401,
-0.0079200109,
0.0749075934,
-0.0381629691,
-0.0132701173,
-0.0358293988,
-0.0096154958,
-0.0094123539,
-0.0275643691,
-0.0250205006,
-0.0022641798,
0.0400178805,
0.025991505,
-0.047996968,
0.061200425,
0.0340065695,
-0.0422103517,
-0.0307145678,
-0.0072583281,
-0.0070238519,
-0.0181336626,
-0.0082587879,
-0.0136699444,
0.0064434186,
0.0149341719,
0.0370327085,
-0.0068536806,
0.0124872606,
-0.0201394409,
-0.0041902033,
-0.0279598236,
-0.0032398622,
-0.0578192063,
0.0436545573,
0.0388971195,
-0.0640972257,
0.0122281732,
-0.0255291462,
0.0345011391,
-0.0242921785,
0.0098729413,
-0.0478452034,
0.0117928488,
-0.0503290966,
0.0031494403,
-0.0501225889,
0.0506707355,
0.0048157386,
0.0064321281,
-0.0551123545,
-0.0044721654,
-0.0394198932,
0.0080245072,
0.0236811433,
0.0360277295,
-0.0507849641,
-0.0027181562,
0.0296161771,
0.06332279,
-0.0069839363,
0.0378689542,
-0.0259427484,
-0.0172377191,
-0.0393333137,
0.0354587138,
0.0348810628,
-0.0171426125,
0.0053577032,
0.0733035952,
0.0057283025,
-0.0411400385,
-0.0287055876,
-0.023190381,
-0.0336909704,
-0.0412778631,
-0.0081620496,
-0.0340129435,
0.0142261591,
-0.008539292,
0.0180076808,
-0.0354796946,
-0.0166143719,
-0.0238183308,
0.0406238325,
0.0861983299,
0.0519631431,
-0.0344658419,
0.0203151219,
0.0218718201,
0.0307460651,
0.0326651298,
0.0448223501,
0.0048928647,
-0.0182050243,
-0.0573528558,
-0.0080716936,
0.042121917,
0.0475228876,
-0.0172933135,
0.0133310789,
-0.0116358651,
0.0349291116,
0.0302360151,
0.0207804497,
0.0092203375,
-0.024749158,
-0.0321982875,
0.0394091569,
0.0286136102,
0.0423524752,
0.0291077942,
0.0788627937,
-0.003039065,
-0.0098017659,
0.0036160334,
0.0107213873,
0.0367897116,
0.0495860241,
-0.0078583462,
0.0114869699,
-0.0157635938,
-0.058670301,
-0.0085473871,
0.0529128499,
-0.046127528,
-0.0188546535,
-0.0276877638,
0.0361149162,
0.0059010703,
-0.0660493746,
0.0889289007,
-0.0126395067,
-0.041432444,
0.0137279406,
0.0037154488,
-0.0257198047,
-0.0043119104,
-0.0102667697,
-0.0600328073,
-0.0507705249,
-0.0471436903,
0.0004607816,
-0.0088042673,
0.0049035004,
-0.0216190852,
0.0339281671,
-0.0417294949,
-0.0469218791,
0.0064741485,
-0.0176116228,
0.0400489867,
-0.0750835538,
-0.0047018817,
0.0565843619,
-0.0043939743,
0.0005217828,
0.0046094772,
-0.0227389559,
-0.0342139266,
0.0320580862,
0.0362078883,
0.0777566731,
0.0289157834,
-0.0115808388,
0.0206942782,
0.0686395317,
-0.0466098376,
0.0064528016,
0.0323900133,
-0.1212340742,
-0.0629783794,
0.0244638138,
-0.0440576747,
0.033348728,
0.0799837187,
-0.0121668484,
-0.0770110339,
0.0470779203,
-0.0197626073,
0.0452043898,
-0.0274401847,
0.0176236127,
0.0356575027,
0.0280682817,
0.0055057523,
-0.0012332902,
0.0107802665,
0.0068330518,
0.0155015187,
-0.0105259623,
0.0399478003,
-0.0287017114,
-0.0234388225,
0.040828988,
-0.0151060047,
-0.0040200045,
0.0095372591,
-0.0470931344,
-0.012711741,
0.0310511235,
-0.0806151628,
-0.0131016476,
-0.0314059444,
0.0112315724,
-0.0205839127,
-0.0176015869,
0.0331935212,
-0.0562250242,
-0.0441570953,
-0.0160295628,
0.0036308514,
-0.0149902413,
-0.0131963519,
0.0017344434,
-0.0149711072,
-0.0090361452,
-0.0037726457,
-0.0050077303,
0.0422518328,
-0.0219217911,
-0.0387310646,
-0.0170247946,
-0.0111589869,
0.0322393663,
0.0262034908,
-0.0098014753,
-0.021890441,
-0.007982769,
0.0043178159,
0.0436460935,
-0.0022612768,
0.0402485542,
0.0120295072,
0.0305184033,
0.0121123008,
-0.0424843095,
0.0044454648,
-0.0279398356,
0.0550937243,
-0.0463963561,
0.0401538499,
-0.0204486437,
0.0623878203,
0.0039381501,
0.0004259183,
-0.050845705,
-0.0222866964,
-0.0057793581,
-0.0186458193,
0.0008165842,
-0.0367821865,
-0.0227113478,
-0.0216488056,
-0.0011273877,
-0.0322276726,
0.0290711783,
-0.0375385061,
-0.0348914862,
-0.0160905514,
-0.0330436602,
-0.0165727958,
0.0810137093,
0.034038797,
0.013253632,
-0.0001690052,
-0.0394593216,
-0.0556083396,
0.0107853562,
0.0122759445,
-0.0340710916,
0.0197256804,
0.0033675232,
0.0028511682,
-0.0303172078,
-0.0249380469,
-0.0495578349,
-0.0646807626,
0.0166951772,
0.0152193801,
-0.010871036,
0.0146541949,
-0.0580362268,
0.0140237566,
-0.0006130628,
0.0551914535,
0.0168621577,
0.0120380064,
-0.0133342426,
0.0564844608,
-0.0026410199,
0.0353308395,
-0.0042509874,
-0.0076056113,
0.0217407327,
0.0273201037,
0.057480704,
0.0019122561,
-0.0817376077,
0.0147202779,
0.0074478858,
-0.0273943841,
-0.0206323359,
0.0143619068,
0.0315610357,
-0.052730754,
0.0033652449,
0.1053924114,
-0.0080272639,
-0.0649760291,
0.0096410643,
0.0504197255,
-0.0310674887,
0.0227027405,
-0.0171317235,
-0.0141157918,
-0.0274667479,
-0.0317182913,
0.0195521694,
0.0354428701,
0.0050263782,
-0.0007202447,
-0.0771399811,
0.0130835446,
0.0257317182,
-0.0099752871,
-0.046284873,
-0.0468547605,
-0.0467583202,
-0.0343768783,
0.0163522977,
-0.0226569809,
-0.0280572735,
-0.0217109155,
0.0591070428,
-0.0623159893,
-0.032547351,
0.0219021235,
-0.0436909869,
0.0328028053,
0.044581797,
0.0210983232,
-0.0185342729,
0.0017902754,
0.0030947402,
-0.0109803006,
-0.0101611689,
0.0186615977,
0.083120726,
-0.0141783776,
-0.0239636656,
0.0271689277,
0.028978169,
-0.0563931614,
0.0039642416,
-0.0279070754,
0.0920514464,
-0.0527144931,
0.0062336791,
-0.0136591475,
0.0050271582,
0.0267317314,
0.0544968098,
0.0084973024,
-0.0185092706,
-0.0057801702,
0.0186070837,
0.0829295665,
-0.017809324,
-0.0465242937,
0.0131682726,
0.0007885611,
-0.0415779054,
-0.0469937027,
-0.017695073,
0.0003007213,
0.0479932725,
0.0072542643,
-0.0005218179,
0.0408160798,
-0.0230721086,
-0.0720778555,
0.0192404371,
0.0002928239,
0.0289560296,
-0.0244753901,
-0.0325914919,
0.0828266889,
-0.0227369275,
-0.0143251689,
-0.0153187215,
-0.0913045704,
-0.0211150069,
-0.001309583,
0.0361583233,
0.0067789401,
0.0495690778,
0.0064038048,
0.0096824057,
0.099405691,
0.0411559753,
-0.0452706814,
-0.0295470171,
0.0994387716,
-0.0192181822,
-0.041267205,
0.0282630529,
-0.049224861,
0.0504229777,
-0.0163774546,
-0.0036628556,
-0.0205334425,
-0.0040070089,
0.0363606103,
-0.0009844966,
0.0797190592,
0.0159493741,
0.0325550996,
-0.0275858026,
-0.0038197751,
-0.0165426191,
0.0234691314,
-0.0331638306,
0.0157858413,
0.0476528667,
-0.0020322499,
-0.0004182165,
0.0438823737,
-0.0148918983,
-0.030985577,
-0.0289974455,
0.0757161081,
0.0130639924,
-0.0476861298,
-0.0357071571,
0.0554634519,
0.0204523467,
0.0247871038,
0.0343209319,
0.0032098342,
0.0065338723,
0.0034497345,
0.0065603657,
0.1029034331,
-0.0275321323,
0.0091964733,
-0.0809783489,
-0.0010687383,
-0.026157435,
-0.0089931553,
0.06211178,
-0.0775482953,
0.0141642252,
-0.0082535325,
0.0400629342,
-0.0207355917,
0.0500661545,
-0.0242837258,
-0.0164768398,
0.0158666056,
-0.0152465496,
-0.0243117064,
0.0042932406,
0.0883268341,
-0.0137162544,
0.0625560209,
0.0027640436,
0.0089705251,
-0.0520620644,
-0.0503806174,
0.0316349305,
-0.0121535901,
-0.0311472062,
-0.013737333,
0.019439498,
-0.0713139996,
0.044808872,
-0.0631438866,
-0.0028653725,
-0.0250223763,
0.0579881705,
-0.0128930844,
-0.0024306914,
0.0485771298,
-0.0007728444,
-0.0221507121,
0.0147412177,
-0.0035712479,
-0.0008852576,
-5.885128998e-33,
-0.0189854708,
0.0095671806,
-0.0107999388,
-0.0171545539,
-0.031011058,
0.010217336,
-0.0237592943,
0.0177930929,
-0.0055936589,
-0.0016302125,
0.014469781,
0.0236211829,
0.0126618678,
0.0399269462,
0.0448773727,
-0.0340202972,
0.1029233858,
-0.0269451421,
0.0187106896,
0.015122599,
0.0623694099,
0.0277365576,
0.0430837609,
-0.0693802238,
-0.0237695072,
-0.0188399069,
0.0040234607,
-0.0192836449,
0.0139999222,
0.024588054,
-0.0124486936,
0.0373564363,
0.0032137379,
-0.0568037927,
-0.0565374568,
0.0082786307,
-0.0749772117,
-0.0253982004,
-0.0696477816,
0.0582687967,
-0.0425244793,
-0.0129498448,
0.0516410954,
0.0053523798,
-0.0129229277,
-0.0137035716,
0.0322250091,
-0.0056739803,
-0.0090457899,
-0.0265271347,
-0.0225197487,
0.0045879157,
-0.0530925207,
-0.0469789207,
0.0776485652,
0.0765753239,
0.0228539146,
0.0164431315,
-0.0662597641,
0.0173819698,
-0.0317615196,
0.0388324037,
0.0388050452,
0.0122868251,
0.0230584927,
0.0631906092,
0.0619769394,
-0.0348350964,
-0.0029305443,
-0.0075287353,
-0.0059953793,
0.0136952996,
0.0153807346,
0.0055240132,
0.060329359,
-0.042240072,
-0.0368059501,
0.0171947461,
0.0058412752,
0.0153288636,
0.012835335,
0.0285572615,
0.0116557796,
0.0008267861,
-0.0161191728,
-0.0386997461,
0.0324981548,
-0.0068698926,
0.0080692191,
0.006954785,
0.0112496037,
0.0552128702,
0.0563098229,
-0.0312301628,
0.0015360352,
0.0021812613,
-0.014699257,
-0.0090308376,
0.0242148433,
0.0466322303,
-0.0360242426,
-0.0372812524,
0.0449355394,
0.0196997728,
0.0058101225,
-0.0242574755,
0.042281419,
0.0461379588,
-0.0285617542,
-0.0212755911,
0.001535664,
-0.0322754756,
-0.0078163398,
0.0323054753,
0.0593957379,
0.0243995413,
-0.0071578557,
0.0533497296,
-0.0180717483,
-0.0096197678,
0.0201201811,
-0.0111072706,
0.0125646824,
0.0240242537,
0.0019888177,
-0.0276320353,
-0.0671826378,
-0.0074748495,
0.0309893433,
-0.0528468192,
-0.0103722261,
-0.0037458905,
2.772e-7,
0.0009233198,
-0.0127638821,
0.0457970388,
0.006845674,
0.044024691,
0.0298445206,
-0.0475617126,
0.0272360183,
-0.0292087216,
-0.0019250406,
0.0476887859,
-0.0095619056,
0.051592797,
0.0085759824,
-0.0881716087,
-0.0227568801,
-0.0875845477,
0.0203309394,
-0.0286531989,
0.0163812898,
0.0538378954,
0.1170859858,
-0.0368530191,
-0.0173124131,
0.0291832797,
0.0260902997,
0.0734990761,
0.0065266457,
0.0101723392,
-0.0197972655,
-0.0160615593,
0.0028111355,
-0.0399728939,
0.0236360133,
-0.0513607748,
0.0235920437,
0.0413688235,
0.0179243013,
0.0206412598,
-0.0723797977,
-0.0014995901,
0.0659964457,
-0.0028494499,
0.0628341809,
0.0525230132,
-0.0704551414,
-0.0432327613,
0.0047713495,
-0.0797339156,
0.0378295965,
0.0097008329,
0.0206657592,
0.014371491,
-0.0023403117,
0.0043816287,
-0.0105335712,
-0.0107357688,
-0.0595534965,
0.0208286624,
0.0040086443,
-0.0593091138,
0.0160344429,
-0.0453077108,
-0.0145357726,
0.0836799741,
-0.0254341029,
-0.013713019,
1.934553757e-34,
0.0299141277,
-0.0252774712,
0.0195277613,
-0.0310335848,
-0.0532743596,
-0.0717901662,
-0.0161381792,
-0.0252217948,
0.05064255,
-0.0234001596,
-0.0485238433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13808v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13808v2 | Watermarking Conditional Text Generation for AI Detection: Unveiling Challenges and a Semantic-Aware Watermark Remedy | 2023-07-25T20:24:22 | 2024-02-13T05:27:44 | Yu Fu, Deyi Xiong, Yue Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | To mitigate potential risks associated with language models, recent AI
detection research proposes incorporating watermarks into machine-generated
text through random vocabulary restrictions and utilizing this information for
detection. While these watermarks only induce a slight deterioration in
perplexity, our empirical investigation reveals a significant detriment to the
performance of conditional text generation. To address this issue, we introduce
a simple yet effective semantic-aware watermarking algorithm that considers the
characteristics of conditional text generation and the input context.
Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed method yields substantial
improvements across various text generation models, including BART and Flan-T5,
in tasks such as summarization and data-to-text generation while maintaining
detection ability. | [
0.040807046,
0.0449174009,
-0.0264932755,
0.0034328252,
-0.0101294648,
-0.0029029609,
0.0280987583,
0.060081739,
0.0139138196,
-0.046271164,
0.0105640786,
0.001049788,
-0.0042134742,
0.0486658737,
0.0340411775,
-0.0446043909,
0.0319035277,
-0.0084143085,
0.0179973599,
0.0159766339,
0.0253890995,
0.0260526966,
0.0404453091,
0.0185683724,
-0.0473562777,
-0.0211830102,
0.0010471352,
0.0272284374,
0.0219440125,
-0.0291662887,
-0.0493611619,
0.0547868349,
0.0096974857,
0.0703418255,
0.000002047,
-0.0234584007,
-0.0311417934,
0.0080055315,
0.0031544541,
0.018867163,
0.0540878884,
-0.008639426,
0.0069334744,
0.0137158679,
-0.0391024984,
0.0707924441,
0.0523796417,
0.0380558297,
0.0774383843,
0.0597474016,
-0.0270045716,
0.0093138311,
0.0400386937,
-0.00919249,
0.0628362745,
-0.0349820592,
-0.0059567969,
0.0022553545,
-0.0182599016,
-0.0166778043,
0.0185674876,
0.0619882494,
0.0065119639,
-0.0191195719,
-0.0185477994,
0.0328901559,
0.0159398299,
-0.0327685811,
0.014596439,
0.0345610566,
-0.0352571718,
-0.0201793313,
0.0144450208,
-0.022744162,
0.0148344636,
0.0321937129,
-0.0158519167,
0.0618624054,
-0.016189184,
-0.0010975882,
0.0299909115,
0.02905971,
0.0187835544,
0.0346444808,
-0.0212480146,
0.007056477,
0.0264316164,
-0.0234467089,
-0.0804567933,
-0.0158889741,
-0.0352263115,
-0.0873496756,
0.0304552633,
0.022447668,
-0.0009126824,
-0.0048826286,
-0.140468955,
-0.0867149457,
0.0009964608,
-0.0116128093,
0.0525762439,
0.0012588329,
0.0214452744,
0.004129177,
-0.0428825617,
0.067993626,
-0.0182536356,
0.0223738644,
-0.0042605218,
0.0048425798,
0.0107599366,
-0.0528868847,
-0.0398759283,
0.0273688827,
-0.029200146,
-0.0453635901,
-0.0294709019,
0.0458633415,
-0.0060766251,
0.0007045486,
-0.0551465824,
-0.0146814901,
-0.0335362963,
0.0161353815,
0.0160662122,
-0.0692023039,
0.0106696999,
0.0269484948,
0.0389242657,
-0.0182079282,
-0.0298338253,
0.0428255945,
0.0364022627,
0.0165291671,
0.0057205488,
0.0915885642,
0.0164459236,
-0.031304419,
-0.0076377168,
-0.0709484145,
0.003888373,
-0.0065019978,
0.0158959422,
-0.0346009172,
-0.0192189906,
-0.0272126477,
-0.0088269319,
-0.0462249704,
0.0201832019,
0.0441227742,
-0.0015975254,
0.0468823127,
-0.0567331165,
-0.0181843117,
0.0167992096,
0.0111077307,
0.007690615,
0.0534130223,
0.0496769361,
0.0809945092,
0.0520661473,
0.0251412075,
0.0267291833,
0.0219496582,
0.0377158523,
0.0183846708,
-0.0146161495,
-0.0420879796,
-0.002619294,
-0.0208615456,
0.0205285903,
0.044661779,
-0.0125062186,
-0.0049721897,
0.0553410091,
0.0550819673,
-0.054355178,
-0.0012743032,
0.0529594198,
0.0417122059,
0.0042945887,
0.0385002531,
-0.0033066249,
0.0100115053,
-0.0434007384,
0.0013464955,
0.0020029808,
0.0045780097,
-0.0139160315,
-0.0301439241,
-0.0092234956,
-0.0265072044,
0.0209887642,
-0.0220363364,
-0.0052822605,
0.0873643383,
-0.0448181815,
-0.0119659072,
-0.0088979304,
-0.0458859541,
0.0246746652,
-0.0691988617,
0.0345218219,
0.0727229416,
0.0791656524,
-0.008156037,
0.0589977205,
0.0073654312,
-0.0245537627,
0.0778831318,
-0.0228641015,
0.0107186902,
-0.0185398161,
-0.0165913235,
-0.0098190671,
-0.0423686802,
0.01514553,
0.0388183221,
0.0159806795,
0.0315562114,
0.076285705,
-0.0265466589,
-0.0186193511,
0.0535860583,
0.0352424309,
-0.0203784667,
0.0225213058,
-0.0268905088,
0.0257513467,
0.0033701779,
-0.0355183259,
0.0493895262,
0.0061106067,
-0.0443195514,
-0.0398912206,
-0.0251470339,
-0.0256185848,
-0.0271989573,
-0.0072733159,
-0.0299045239,
0.0034693985,
0.0548384748,
-0.0047185984,
-0.0421607941,
0.0081073437,
-0.0931954011,
0.0079634301,
-0.0465966538,
0.0281794854,
0.0263681151,
0.0452148132,
-0.0204649288,
0.0694603249,
-0.0013862936,
-0.0298212506,
0.0224305876,
0.0630291626,
-0.0047847871,
-0.0265539344,
-0.0062258202,
-0.0369606242,
-0.0191060491,
-0.0068420982,
0.0230050012,
0.035706643,
-0.0020234811,
-0.013043724,
-0.051145751,
-0.0085070534,
-0.0176246222,
-0.0149356835,
0.0248811152,
0.0221648607,
0.0159727931,
0.005167373,
-0.0540142953,
-0.0300609302,
0.0473565534,
0.0111929141,
0.0362951383,
-0.0141318608,
-0.0412826464,
-0.0194420014,
-0.004866329,
0.0114395525,
0.0568147339,
0.0620429851,
-0.0639476776,
-0.036014542,
0.0639755875,
-0.0498236045,
-0.016302431,
-0.0060364655,
0.0166305993,
-0.0004006081,
0.0059608077,
-0.0007296518,
0.0363710374,
0.0434226468,
0.0247119591,
0.0273848251,
0.0450727604,
-0.0097660385,
-0.0115109077,
0.00605238,
0.0284746066,
0.0354226306,
-0.0591902062,
0.0548378043,
0.0088667357,
0.0307723824,
0.0354067273,
-0.0364889354,
0.068251878,
-0.003784749,
-0.0442045704,
-0.0300640166,
-0.0325884148,
-0.02810096,
0.0373029485,
-0.0198621023,
-0.0633980036,
0.0335632637,
-0.0424614921,
0.0356415845,
-0.0146622779,
-0.0050782417,
0.008005294,
0.0220718887,
0.0348158926,
0.0533393919,
0.0065576341,
-0.0023580501,
-0.0246887375,
0.0044236211,
0.0197467506,
-0.040508844,
-0.0159116946,
-0.0226692744,
-0.0054551307,
0.0034416071,
-0.003276953,
-0.062332835,
-0.0512188748,
0.0136431074,
0.0106872749,
0.0632364154,
-0.0556943789,
0.0010337579,
-0.0056006219,
0.0398756005,
0.0294737332,
-0.0351484269,
-0.0132480823,
-0.0387965105,
0.0997324362,
0.0486325324,
-0.0740740374,
-0.0036006367,
-0.0268443562,
0.0004084256,
0.0626419485,
0.0263624433,
0.000081609,
0.0243768487,
-0.0057703923,
-0.0019394335,
0.0255000908,
-0.0384546965,
0.0439660884,
0.0060335877,
-0.0438575149,
-0.0147939045,
0.0706753433,
0.0426024534,
0.0084357718,
0.0109303081,
0.0168529395,
0.068748869,
0.013367556,
-0.0059690811,
-0.0783538595,
-0.0311372187,
0.0166455843,
0.0394321233,
-0.0566638224,
-0.0065565142,
-0.0560716987,
-0.0582127981,
0.0318127684,
0.00473681,
-0.0405838601,
-0.0117628593,
-0.0505808331,
-0.0303620063,
0.0534499697,
-0.0147045227,
-0.0399381183,
0.0059990892,
-0.0024362493,
0.0102022151,
-0.0237160958,
-0.0218680743,
-0.0172619633,
-0.005843671,
0.00616764,
0.0885002092,
0.0330998749,
-0.0374879204,
-0.0387544334,
-0.0041754963,
0.0054210634,
0.0253811348,
-0.0132925268,
0.0690253526,
-0.0389888547,
-0.0143909808,
-0.0180145036,
0.0067186831,
0.0082857795,
-0.0314704031,
0.0313531682,
0.0175967403,
-0.0111383582,
-0.0131919645,
-0.0298772734,
0.0059706327,
0.0258418098,
0.062451914,
0.058283288,
-0.0442613661,
-0.035483934,
-0.0281838756,
0.0498319119,
-0.0873492062,
-0.0167101566,
-0.0267995838,
-0.0452396013,
-0.0760319382,
-0.0943735763,
-0.0236572996,
-0.0259164087,
0.0243001115,
0.017783884,
0.0364430882,
-0.0032188734,
-0.0308063384,
-0.0521902815,
-0.0205903873,
-0.0520770438,
0.0271723662,
-0.0012814977,
-0.0300535876,
-0.0061304444,
-0.0530434102,
-0.0150232697,
0.0868791044,
-0.0668930188,
-0.0448554344,
0.0146628516,
0.0273046978,
0.0204092693,
0.0027073701,
-0.0156671368,
-0.0211365707,
0.0590290166,
0.0448741429,
-0.0049989768,
0.0348918289,
0.0585797578,
-0.0128347259,
-0.0036733032,
0.0077782623,
-0.0609085113,
0.011115157,
0.0286592469,
-0.0108883101,
-0.049152609,
0.0095593445,
0.0390920341,
0.0758395121,
-0.0333411172,
-0.0582257472,
0.0070966715,
0.0008024455,
-0.0229710098,
-0.0506521016,
-0.0363728553,
-0.0517231226,
0.0207133889,
-0.0080573792,
-0.0003102982,
0.0205464624,
0.0212557558,
-0.0357253775,
-0.0039649839,
-0.0047116042,
-0.0285722781,
-0.0411177576,
0.0458001755,
-0.0061452724,
-0.0074817138,
-0.014612807,
0.0352976285,
-0.0145706991,
0.0077419863,
-0.0072779963,
0.0237741582,
0.0204413123,
-0.0270430576,
-0.0440455675,
0.0582639314,
-0.0661885813,
0.0021987131,
-0.0361816399,
0.0367722586,
0.0079154233,
0.0184682403,
0.0304017942,
-0.0581066012,
0.0151057057,
-0.000278488,
0.0519513749,
0.0115491124,
-0.0842768103,
-0.0220301263,
-0.0178101454,
-0.0321508385,
-0.0108143743,
0.0707494617,
0.0081849527,
0.021696249,
-0.0060838754,
-0.0330727249,
-0.0363430679,
-0.0158453435,
0.0469469391,
0.0386465304,
-0.0043321452,
-0.0209141672,
-0.0547952354,
-0.0699991286,
0.0225088056,
-0.011705555,
0.0326776095,
0.0188599098,
-0.0005372728,
0.0594867654,
-0.0068332953,
-0.0051238616,
-0.0374732874,
0.0014786453,
-0.02686969,
-0.0233444814,
-0.0172828138,
-5.544954892e-33,
-0.0564782023,
-0.0688365325,
-0.024996249,
-0.0141025484,
0.0261084381,
0.0558591411,
-0.0369385183,
0.0015842988,
0.0268611815,
-0.0142642325,
-0.0188819561,
0.0083596604,
0.0042193029,
0.0203536712,
-0.0709966794,
0.0158894714,
0.0596713647,
-0.0008058466,
-0.0459904149,
0.0482126549,
0.0486085638,
-0.0357817411,
-0.0315598249,
-0.0839360356,
0.0053540817,
-0.0431037545,
-0.0654995292,
-0.0544036478,
-0.0534570888,
0.0149286035,
-0.0220762137,
0.0247181561,
0.001777383,
0.0370181687,
-0.0528834499,
0.0347664617,
-0.0039531076,
-0.0284642,
-0.0146754701,
-0.0038448377,
-0.0259919073,
-0.0949779749,
0.0073513621,
-0.0308241155,
-0.0079598958,
0.0247979946,
0.0332041495,
-0.0124662844,
-0.0026352829,
-0.0457288362,
-0.0333238803,
0.021407349,
-0.0186182559,
-0.0054188729,
0.0004101996,
0.0234432537,
0.0368445478,
-0.0202937834,
-0.0437113121,
0.0483736619,
0.0351492092,
-0.0277841818,
0.0528182425,
0.016664369,
0.0035999583,
0.0541651398,
0.0221807975,
0.0046954532,
0.0087377289,
-0.0042498563,
-0.0056307763,
0.0210208222,
0.0694289953,
0.033673618,
0.0530386716,
-0.0334989354,
-0.023480542,
0.0461808778,
-0.0802357271,
-0.0323277563,
0.0461845063,
-0.013807578,
-0.076142475,
0.0062568728,
-0.0274327137,
-0.0439777598,
-0.00744351,
0.0020384805,
0.0341706052,
0.0278063864,
-0.0543056428,
-0.0467553325,
0.0030009593,
-0.0388778411,
0.0303638857,
0.0178442206,
-0.0432212614,
0.0173195954,
-0.0129239885,
0.0166232046,
0.0278646201,
-0.00400523,
0.101737909,
-0.0183200259,
0.0257610604,
0.0069764336,
0.0600994453,
0.0160006247,
-0.0446189381,
-0.0089500034,
-0.0123097328,
0.033359848,
0.0229664668,
-0.0137982806,
0.0061421972,
-0.0369829722,
-0.0120151052,
-0.035628859,
0.0240420774,
-0.0196960028,
-0.0420942865,
-0.028936604,
-0.0395211764,
0.0213445779,
-0.0367957167,
0.0153620047,
-0.0252213553,
0.0531748571,
0.0685310438,
-0.0457421467,
-0.0225252621,
-0.0146784689,
2.648e-7,
0.025032334,
0.0121683925,
0.026536515,
0.0359565169,
-0.0105483532,
0.0518785678,
0.040202789,
0.027874222,
-0.0200260393,
0.0373261273,
-0.0157920867,
0.0033970037,
0.0487177484,
0.0069039026,
-0.0248885732,
0.0175153054,
-0.0381512605,
0.0311602522,
-0.0494162254,
0.0062924805,
0.0625932887,
0.0730427727,
0.0169487968,
-0.0487244204,
0.0216191355,
-0.0777925998,
0.0443074591,
-0.0062812739,
0.0081290193,
-0.0035173586,
0.012426815,
0.0110849254,
0.0278016645,
0.046716731,
-0.0510181524,
-0.0152033148,
0.03759709,
0.0338730216,
-0.0093861073,
0.0170989055,
-0.0172613561,
-0.0012943045,
-0.0098254168,
-0.0366511792,
0.0624013282,
0.0576333925,
-0.0271004513,
-0.0403150395,
-0.0437106006,
-0.0255452339,
0.0104704816,
-0.0320700482,
-0.0476963855,
0.0068104258,
-0.0042329328,
0.0144374389,
-0.0231145434,
-0.0226796269,
-0.0175862107,
-0.086162515,
-0.0270706154,
-0.0173481908,
-0.0826693848,
0.0250434931,
0.0634016395,
-0.053325437,
0.0210102443,
2.845475324e-34,
-0.0011607177,
-0.040965762,
-0.0152538819,
0.014484101,
0.043819584,
0.0196042042,
0.0074755177,
0.0234593209,
0.0119802319,
-0.0491101295,
-0.0107262069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13779v1 | Is GPT a Computational Model of Emotion? Detailed Analysis | 2023-07-25T19:34:44 | 2023-07-25T19:34:44 | Ala N. Tak, Jonathan Gratch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC | This paper investigates the emotional reasoning abilities of the GPT family
of large language models via a component perspective. The paper first examines
how the model reasons about autobiographical memories. Second, it
systematically varies aspects of situations to impact emotion intensity and
coping tendencies. Even without the use of prompt engineering, it is shown that
GPT's predictions align significantly with human-provided appraisals and
emotional labels. However, GPT faces difficulties predicting emotion intensity
and coping responses. GPT-4 showed the highest performance in the initial study
but fell short in the second, despite providing superior results after minor
prompt engineering. This assessment brings up questions on how to effectively
employ the strong points and address the weak areas of these models,
particularly concerning response variability. These studies underscore the
merits of evaluating models from a componential perspective. | [
0.0406377465,
0.0616159774,
-0.0219569728,
0.0130261071,
-0.0534317307,
0.0318930261,
0.0428191908,
-0.021210121,
0.0373903178,
-0.0229572132,
-0.0036698172,
-0.065199472,
-0.0440011285,
0.0404116139,
-0.0170300007,
-0.077172108,
0.0056887451,
0.0371612944,
0.0693927333,
-0.022184914,
0.0028321948,
0.0337522179,
-0.0081794616,
0.0210433323,
-0.0408225283,
-0.0228957441,
-0.0090143019,
0.0162086468,
0.0325694978,
-0.0311863925,
-0.0053592795,
0.0513573885,
0.0025045674,
-0.0322582386,
0.0000022656,
-0.0407647565,
-0.0077406499,
-0.0189568549,
0.012191318,
0.0265195668,
0.0727572665,
0.0284065604,
-0.0194695313,
0.0066839312,
-0.0208457876,
-0.0349398218,
0.0481121391,
0.0645100251,
0.0605163425,
0.0579344705,
-0.0389324054,
-0.0332461409,
0.0193680041,
-0.0053440747,
0.0122150825,
0.0195982512,
0.0236879867,
-0.0154532334,
0.0283067655,
-0.06066975,
-0.0219161361,
-0.0017907344,
0.0092082946,
0.0414050929,
-0.0117951185,
0.0148412306,
-0.0049978928,
-0.0236498211,
-0.014683404,
0.0126350773,
0.0569655783,
0.0136023583,
0.0042497558,
-0.0272314735,
-0.0008038108,
0.0149545679,
-0.0123888496,
0.014310576,
-0.020552747,
0.0012865849,
0.0112723596,
0.0062173214,
-0.0117703136,
0.0130153634,
0.003811758,
0.081812419,
-0.0170464423,
-0.0348810926,
0.0386217758,
0.0142433187,
-0.0445523001,
0.0309041496,
-0.005896986,
-0.0152768511,
-0.0020917542,
0.0246538445,
0.0044694827,
0.0349299274,
-0.0500355996,
-0.0474496111,
-0.0012350185,
0.0706738234,
-0.0216803085,
-0.0147561822,
0.0265972838,
0.070541881,
0.0045023644,
-0.0290397815,
-0.0101579828,
0.0212579798,
-0.0814902708,
-0.0090259984,
-0.0056483522,
0.0565578341,
-0.0074601527,
-0.0183894746,
-0.0885864645,
-0.0067789233,
-0.0266920757,
-0.0495449044,
0.0140909692,
-0.0091722105,
0.0151761593,
0.0098158047,
-0.05153431,
0.0125561906,
-0.0762438029,
0.0094536729,
-0.0042795097,
-0.060441535,
0.0323186144,
-0.0221088491,
-0.0184193216,
-0.0415709801,
0.0101064323,
0.0104223732,
0.0106779477,
-0.0076813134,
-0.0546814688,
-0.014246556,
-0.0375759713,
-0.0922571942,
-0.0014860989,
-0.0056496998,
0.0286337938,
0.0140206395,
0.0160286687,
-0.0603396371,
0.0159061793,
-0.0197142139,
-0.0438456796,
0.042816449,
0.0173485819,
0.005624509,
-0.0086077703,
0.0217992738,
0.0204196759,
0.0114942789,
0.0057352898,
0.0434080996,
-0.0084889345,
-0.0348471142,
0.0334541649,
-0.0161632933,
-0.0559333749,
-0.0351792648,
-0.0497870259,
-0.0257696174,
-0.019130351,
0.0216932017,
-0.00229541,
0.0480524339,
-0.0153524932,
0.0182746612,
0.041125875,
0.0329833478,
-0.0226113629,
0.0798634365,
0.0030380941,
0.0152100073,
0.0346222408,
-0.0037557399,
-0.0524234362,
0.0247844364,
-0.0245653484,
-0.0066727581,
-0.0087543176,
0.0079793613,
-0.0363456197,
-0.0282962658,
-0.0229776464,
0.0006180454,
-0.0164644662,
0.0059055435,
0.0063488353,
-0.0880568475,
-0.0375372134,
-0.020704329,
-0.0031687836,
-0.0740840062,
-0.0309454072,
-0.0640340298,
0.0393634737,
0.0835821107,
0.0252116639,
-0.0158673488,
-0.0101979878,
-0.0138748772,
-0.0477507636,
-0.0001475295,
0.0254338942,
0.0272857025,
-0.0066658547,
-0.0391736403,
0.0204700511,
-0.0067634257,
0.0359871238,
0.0364315026,
-0.0317413695,
0.0109368302,
0.0079703648,
0.0484296456,
0.0399494991,
-0.008731924,
-0.0344426334,
-0.0593235753,
-0.0352557562,
-0.0093106879,
0.0446736515,
0.0037010808,
-0.0046953573,
-0.001555856,
0.0224923566,
0.0276626926,
-0.0116810109,
0.045159094,
-0.0443284139,
-0.0019963363,
0.0015760133,
0.0075578005,
0.012183818,
-0.0057294508,
-0.0265463125,
-0.0276055187,
0.0365554877,
-0.0124785826,
0.0119012753,
-0.0488000289,
0.0450672545,
-0.0422196537,
0.0192572959,
0.0123726418,
0.0600443147,
0.0006826046,
0.0129948743,
-0.0093133785,
0.0040354375,
0.0093319528,
-0.0479497239,
-0.0682250783,
0.0037861187,
0.0396142788,
0.0177440923,
0.0056846873,
-0.0357246734,
-0.0760295242,
-0.0555255972,
-0.1071053594,
0.0063119889,
0.0289868396,
0.0080844881,
-0.0075262515,
-0.0279473774,
-0.0546107702,
0.0348965451,
-0.0119811203,
0.0011641991,
0.0179066435,
0.0466246381,
-0.0192275662,
-0.0081433691,
0.0228667874,
-0.0678494573,
-0.0030386148,
-0.051503364,
0.0067516691,
0.0198314972,
-0.007100991,
-0.0097309379,
0.0302443318,
-0.0747423396,
0.0323460288,
-0.0212283023,
-0.0674282238,
0.0188515764,
-0.0144263618,
0.0750956312,
0.0525812097,
-0.008293475,
0.0628062934,
0.0135981739,
-0.0338406228,
-0.0334925093,
0.0480737276,
-0.0262933876,
-0.0176241174,
-0.0133588361,
-0.0501646288,
-0.0609500073,
0.0546700582,
0.0408918448,
0.0117512122,
-0.0680812076,
0.0265775938,
-0.0097152647,
-0.0078542,
-0.0176641569,
-0.0486144684,
-0.02417152,
0.0200204048,
0.0430430062,
-0.0511550382,
0.0561332889,
0.051420141,
-0.0006884121,
-0.021831207,
0.0063752322,
-0.0019270689,
0.0958409682,
-0.0174556263,
-0.0159102455,
0.0257505886,
0.031618122,
-0.0260159839,
-0.045657441,
-0.0191654917,
-0.0455554351,
-0.0049841036,
-0.045323126,
-0.0348023698,
0.0382025018,
-0.0280799847,
-0.0163335986,
-0.0433506705,
-0.0463302583,
-0.0013086846,
-0.0071996809,
0.0183354579,
-0.0338862874,
-0.0016503225,
0.0609190278,
-0.0479295217,
-0.0443628356,
-0.0248146616,
0.0224211495,
-0.0047369581,
0.0333051458,
-0.0334480926,
0.0411292315,
-0.0275018346,
0.0446946137,
0.0049893321,
0.0499071814,
0.0039540655,
0.0113970349,
0.0407380499,
-0.0208137389,
0.0296001602,
-0.0576417409,
0.0373983607,
-0.0050207763,
-0.0260226317,
0.0127702104,
0.1433029622,
0.0329132155,
-0.0344491787,
-0.0255962573,
-0.0325273015,
0.042215053,
0.027001908,
0.0109518701,
-0.0150521277,
0.005459073,
0.0040828967,
0.0285741147,
-0.053909719,
-0.0279794764,
0.0120378807,
-0.0916961059,
0.0584428571,
0.0042798202,
-0.0043410142,
-0.0041014981,
-0.0040649706,
0.007920187,
-0.0105338506,
-0.0263830498,
-0.0010252343,
0.0098279575,
0.0035498796,
0.0211031847,
-0.0406468324,
-0.0135235945,
0.0762307569,
0.017402418,
0.0500224344,
0.0020495893,
0.0771955177,
-0.0136746196,
-0.0423723608,
0.0370238908,
-0.0314662643,
0.0127113853,
0.0085588302,
0.0286376737,
-0.0040622163,
0.0259779301,
-0.0432471745,
0.0258923937,
-0.0149053568,
0.0206192639,
0.0120481886,
0.0977663249,
-0.0232212935,
-0.0248941891,
-0.0178938229,
-0.0022627271,
-0.017210776,
0.0730616078,
-0.0041953684,
-0.0402613319,
-0.066660203,
-0.0009728234,
0.0087841339,
0.056501992,
-0.0451654866,
-0.0328895152,
0.0020651992,
0.0022503899,
-0.0343053564,
-0.0804716796,
0.0028155944,
0.0123658879,
-0.0184319746,
-0.044669047,
-0.0377098359,
0.0017066166,
-0.0430109054,
0.0470485352,
0.0171097983,
0.0019655251,
-0.0315396488,
0.0496800132,
0.0576618873,
-0.0405884758,
-0.0091436487,
-0.0161472801,
0.0247546416,
-0.0181510244,
0.0712247044,
0.0314370878,
0.030878868,
-0.0282526165,
0.0155913644,
-0.0230290834,
-0.0148602584,
0.0105826119,
-0.0110330898,
0.0200501382,
0.0243096817,
0.0478473678,
-0.0074291797,
0.0063142967,
0.0074972482,
0.0672163516,
0.0262334943,
-0.007589797,
0.0384565592,
-0.0447718278,
0.0236274879,
0.0488939136,
0.069215104,
0.0064010457,
-0.0503286757,
-0.0385040119,
-0.0362661295,
-0.0218099263,
-0.0012804201,
-0.0290351491,
-0.0190855935,
0.0288837813,
0.0319397636,
-0.0767241269,
-0.1165292859,
-0.0134710167,
0.0004585863,
-0.0161710344,
-0.0099488935,
0.0270919744,
-0.0088212341,
-0.0256862156,
0.0166429561,
-0.0226417892,
-0.0226802956,
0.0017419696,
0.0263732411,
-0.0242855288,
0.1168265492,
-0.0071808593,
-0.0280063897,
0.0431681201,
0.0211958252,
-0.0555145517,
-0.015188653,
-0.0335451476,
0.0008463601,
-0.0035302662,
-0.0214787219,
0.0104572251,
-0.0804980695,
0.031353794,
-0.0371285118,
0.0147170797,
0.0334405564,
-0.0023911991,
0.0323745534,
0.008545192,
-0.0246265698,
-0.0173514355,
-0.0096899197,
-0.0253691357,
0.0522116795,
-0.0172631033,
-0.0453894772,
-0.0376680382,
-0.0137225725,
0.0218616948,
-0.0208688825,
-0.0111506479,
0.0148224523,
-0.1184652969,
-0.0341940336,
0.0141488723,
-0.0148458648,
0.0144365178,
-0.0706669241,
0.0488623679,
0.0556079783,
-0.0583620705,
0.0268098284,
-0.0327712148,
0.0325219519,
-0.0463801324,
0.015117011,
-0.0227475725,
-6.184929648e-33,
-0.0218220633,
0.0339033678,
-0.0093458975,
0.0022795517,
-0.0607846268,
0.0081052799,
-0.0169129856,
0.04203045,
-0.0013847938,
0.0315407068,
-0.0147410315,
0.0240210723,
0.017002508,
-0.015200044,
0.0160873625,
-0.0051294719,
0.0013850714,
0.0041565718,
-0.001817859,
0.0010701602,
0.0132374186,
0.0243110638,
0.0481336005,
-0.0935724974,
0.0491416231,
0.0115530211,
-0.0429198407,
-0.0085752849,
-0.0035223314,
0.0376791321,
-0.0299632549,
0.0415774435,
0.0390421003,
-0.0261691846,
0.0210213903,
0.0012092144,
0.0032750503,
-0.0268272143,
0.0427105054,
-0.051893793,
0.0028030253,
-0.0252532754,
-0.0146673182,
0.0045000114,
-0.0522111617,
-0.0270230006,
0.0234223362,
-0.0346031897,
0.0286120642,
-0.0309897866,
-0.0105627002,
-0.0016814319,
-0.0075075114,
0.0289362576,
0.0179017205,
0.083032757,
-0.0570976995,
0.0512924269,
-0.0160081536,
-0.0069043911,
0.0043081883,
-0.0033731153,
0.0021247182,
-0.0355414152,
0.0348456763,
0.0806720629,
0.0734249651,
0.0076927259,
-0.0606040806,
0.0115070166,
0.0085327839,
0.0195088312,
0.089177452,
0.0574547611,
-0.0037259436,
-0.0282718353,
-0.0069700554,
0.0153600834,
0.0346315466,
0.0035761576,
0.0913350582,
0.0211520419,
-0.0213796496,
-0.0120817451,
-0.0422018431,
-0.0056248032,
-0.0312954858,
-0.0391620807,
0.0499120243,
-0.0460904352,
-0.0014045472,
-0.0238732006,
0.0149918338,
-0.0021166711,
0.0230221786,
0.0248929542,
-0.0437552221,
0.0680067465,
0.0001303413,
0.0551659763,
-0.0187018178,
-0.0114348168,
-0.0045122234,
0.0260604247,
0.0537154749,
0.0135632576,
-0.0349173062,
0.0526380055,
-0.0650833324,
-0.0159716308,
-0.0436399989,
0.0223259702,
-0.0242685582,
-0.0358190611,
-0.033625938,
0.02442858,
0.0038154721,
-0.0305020306,
0.0281121023,
0.014813845,
-0.0227875225,
0.0057958327,
0.0065606837,
0.0176213831,
0.0097920587,
0.0156784952,
0.0275699217,
0.0077005168,
0.0024408358,
0.0136534562,
-0.0082137743,
0.0256885327,
2.931e-7,
-0.0205141492,
0.061437659,
0.0067140376,
-0.0461356677,
0.0287010819,
0.0418601893,
-0.0272309296,
0.0003057982,
0.110408932,
-0.012368096,
0.0515285283,
0.0174319036,
0.0606001168,
-0.0053355265,
-0.0413190201,
0.0364560299,
-0.0205261391,
-0.0215846635,
-0.0467017777,
0.0773145854,
0.1146149337,
0.0631277487,
0.0709882751,
0.0075984462,
0.0015153342,
0.0533662029,
0.0476195551,
-0.0636247173,
-0.0185741074,
0.0206890497,
-0.0259140935,
0.0038829329,
-0.0069474084,
0.0266435444,
0.0363747515,
-0.0045525017,
0.0248840395,
0.0744400099,
0.0088022947,
-0.0274648201,
0.0566477925,
0.0117935585,
-0.0197326653,
-0.0798906237,
0.0443562046,
-0.0194560308,
-0.0162734017,
0.0146906786,
-0.0501510724,
-0.0190854836,
0.0606174693,
-0.0013518104,
-0.0339707918,
0.0186184365,
-0.0124870986,
-0.0111509813,
-0.0214486644,
-0.0510352366,
-0.0016994784,
0.0351448059,
-0.060864076,
-0.0486584529,
-0.033811599,
0.0318876058,
0.047265172,
-0.0678778067,
-0.0063587911,
2.411037637e-34,
0.0300703999,
0.0339732021,
0.0027657759,
0.0106825233,
0.0612784922,
0.0350640491,
-0.0018789764,
0.0117388684,
0.0140534695,
-0.0597680546,
-0.0049306285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13776v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13776v1 | Combating the Curse of Multilinguality in Cross-Lingual WSD by Aligning Sparse Contextualized Word Representations | 2023-07-25T19:20:50 | 2023-07-25T19:20:50 | Gábor Berend | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we advocate for using large pre-trained monolingual language
models in cross lingual zero-shot word sense disambiguation (WSD) coupled with
a contextualized mapping mechanism. We also report rigorous experiments that
illustrate the effectiveness of employing sparse contextualized word
representations obtained via a dictionary learning procedure. Our experimental
results demonstrate that the above modifications yield a significant
improvement of nearly 6.5 points of increase in the average F-score (from 62.0
to 68.5) over a collection of 17 typologically diverse set of target languages.
We release our source code for replicating our experiments at
https://github.com/begab/sparsity_makes_sense. | [
-0.0542918295,
-0.0218111929,
0.0229543764,
0.0447390936,
-0.0273970179,
0.0202407464,
-0.0057364414,
-0.0199968182,
-0.0092526004,
-0.0506466553,
-0.0603330545,
0.0054420177,
0.0294003468,
-0.0258862935,
-0.001068325,
0.0031920925,
0.0903086066,
0.0042210282,
-0.0773263797,
-0.0126506956,
-0.0136114061,
0.0211900957,
-0.0156389046,
-0.0243677422,
-0.0317136794,
-0.0384156331,
0.0221451838,
0.0052463827,
0.0248057321,
-0.0247728173,
-0.0089595355,
0.0434927344,
0.0480899438,
0.1027274802,
0.000001991,
-0.056612175,
-0.0239752326,
0.0084338123,
-0.0089314263,
-0.017769767,
0.0225852411,
-0.0725227445,
0.0178336892,
-0.0243569128,
-0.0241721123,
-0.0278295055,
0.0571043491,
-0.0250109602,
0.029094059,
0.0273295455,
-0.0211110562,
-0.0697125345,
-0.0253410339,
-0.011997371,
0.0235426538,
-0.0574274696,
0.0068367729,
0.0209977049,
-0.0490510538,
-0.0453843102,
-0.0679129958,
0.0500768237,
-0.0109919114,
0.0369441472,
-0.0045551327,
-0.0101612676,
-0.0294742025,
-0.0058410848,
0.0084664589,
0.0639268383,
-0.0064512929,
-0.0548124164,
-0.0278465301,
0.015656054,
-0.0628051609,
-0.0095786275,
-0.0033126618,
-0.0145307723,
0.0242123678,
0.0136996452,
0.0441737399,
0.0244450793,
0.0515825078,
0.044816263,
-0.023654379,
0.0485914089,
0.0279305391,
-0.0199790858,
0.0064155031,
0.0076240166,
0.0038666502,
-0.0027662327,
-0.0088145258,
-0.0052975817,
-0.0322907381,
0.0340651423,
-0.0663284659,
-0.0809944272,
0.0301669389,
-0.0644860789,
-0.0124578588,
0.041283071,
0.003629169,
0.0629396439,
-0.0250229388,
0.0093511743,
0.0100379949,
0.031419035,
-0.0458872579,
-0.054070767,
-0.0621780306,
0.0347129889,
-0.0126897795,
0.0203942675,
-0.0349878184,
-0.0042203604,
-0.0582791902,
-0.0023735513,
-0.0069722827,
-0.0135285817,
-0.0243669618,
-0.0231167749,
-0.0434747525,
-0.0194120407,
-0.000035353,
0.0897616819,
-0.0128988074,
-0.0104083121,
-0.0480709858,
0.020542806,
-0.0145562645,
0.0371107198,
-0.0138982926,
-0.0454420932,
0.0231768396,
0.0362747312,
-0.0157970339,
-0.0320429876,
-0.0340669304,
-0.0167139918,
-0.0146306297,
-0.0247282367,
-0.0433179699,
-0.0797895044,
0.0101917088,
0.0357075408,
0.025568435,
-0.0698628947,
-0.0118419053,
-0.0259865336,
-0.0358896554,
0.1094616726,
-0.0591305271,
-0.0214364249,
-0.0136095965,
0.0066344258,
0.0431517363,
0.1002615988,
0.0052820682,
0.0059825396,
0.0473459661,
0.0319546871,
-0.1009746566,
0.0212146081,
-0.0029850942,
0.0425975397,
-0.0245490018,
0.0021739735,
0.005861023,
0.0198175739,
0.0677460209,
0.0309308488,
-0.0477235168,
-0.0053468393,
-0.0132393632,
0.0360989608,
0.0092916973,
-0.0383181609,
0.0400898233,
-0.0013083172,
-0.0394364335,
0.0014410432,
-0.0078898119,
-0.0119775804,
-0.0278836396,
0.0116972616,
0.0085525429,
0.0294764191,
-0.0284594204,
0.0077506984,
-0.0023439261,
-0.055600103,
0.0512003228,
0.0545060486,
0.0470450819,
0.0143081406,
-0.0357512534,
0.0691004544,
0.0729597062,
-0.0425377116,
0.0336248502,
-0.0178714581,
-0.0088735586,
0.0786690935,
0.0150276348,
-0.0163680334,
-0.0565896071,
0.0052441801,
0.0296808593,
0.0464045666,
0.0209243465,
-0.0336187519,
0.0575987436,
-0.0642556325,
-0.0340525359,
-0.0123096788,
-0.0061171111,
0.0309150741,
0.0015166556,
0.041031722,
0.0273299832,
-0.0752066225,
0.0027234321,
0.0172689259,
-0.0553066693,
-0.0445044562,
-0.0115276491,
0.0209661145,
-0.0285096746,
0.019856507,
-0.0235232953,
0.0047315541,
0.0042561614,
-0.0577010401,
0.040916618,
-0.0168320816,
-0.0467441082,
-0.0534379631,
0.045663096,
-0.0109760128,
-0.0338689461,
0.0177415088,
-0.0249149147,
-0.041657012,
0.0058393553,
0.0302236602,
-0.001791237,
-0.0449569598,
0.0222774651,
-0.0134010557,
0.0226374287,
-0.0445644073,
0.0321285725,
0.0231600422,
0.0164625142,
-0.0322602838,
0.0260176808,
0.0586999208,
0.0159776788,
-0.0527676679,
0.017523095,
0.0006065344,
0.0217776522,
0.0278645083,
0.0111919101,
-0.0140236663,
0.0160956047,
-0.0659128949,
0.0168021172,
-0.035939265,
0.0038541767,
0.012937149,
0.0623763502,
0.0142969796,
-0.0180142839,
0.0050570513,
0.0432154872,
0.0176920611,
0.0190845709,
0.0130563173,
-0.0166028999,
0.0263905954,
-0.0297807381,
0.0014998971,
0.0112935724,
0.0178707503,
-0.0317660496,
-0.028298026,
-0.0009017951,
0.0725201964,
-0.0492713749,
0.0050251703,
0.0180671569,
-0.0064611081,
0.0050694938,
-0.0110238874,
0.0095690684,
0.010042862,
-0.0339234211,
0.0226237886,
0.0740768164,
-0.0111187734,
-0.0044550523,
-0.0081689153,
0.0276829787,
-0.0013222307,
-0.0530106723,
-0.0024832096,
-0.0085426625,
0.0434459895,
0.0016627732,
-0.0163765438,
-0.0378642902,
-0.0016814426,
-0.0195480306,
-0.0473200604,
-0.0144460555,
0.057889048,
0.0159240067,
0.0108901747,
-0.047674302,
-0.033093214,
0.0302418973,
0.0076868022,
0.0244207922,
-0.0618991666,
0.0032281119,
-0.0201934949,
0.033624649,
-0.0445255488,
0.0405334048,
-0.0130070569,
0.0107515268,
-0.0719372407,
-0.0615781881,
0.0453476161,
-0.0083773006,
0.0390016325,
-0.0447442494,
0.0445878878,
-0.0175000243,
0.0148427403,
-0.0207809899,
-0.0456802249,
-0.0228353087,
0.0274599921,
0.0353371426,
0.0231589582,
-0.0039843619,
0.0065082605,
0.0320686512,
0.0285588726,
0.0266004652,
-0.0068232417,
-0.0073683267,
0.0059593739,
0.0523355491,
-0.0047594011,
0.0108307777,
-0.0179373156,
0.0161519293,
-0.0070587457,
0.0187975019,
-0.0327786356,
-0.0106899235,
-0.0058791847,
0.0668260753,
-0.0349613801,
-0.0449725576,
-0.0273760185,
0.0510669164,
0.0004028748,
-0.0044733146,
0.1309804022,
0.0475971401,
-0.0530430377,
-0.0008198205,
-0.0285321772,
-0.0029677844,
0.0231772494,
-0.0227505956,
-0.0922396705,
-0.0630040392,
-0.0234646276,
-0.0181494858,
0.0476517566,
-0.0183146354,
-0.0083207292,
-0.0901713744,
-0.023903735,
0.0305590313,
-0.0431955196,
-0.0165411774,
-0.0103082331,
-0.0142384255,
-0.0339218006,
0.0208721254,
-0.0452241935,
-0.0052478379,
-0.0190737378,
-0.0019169356,
0.0262317937,
-0.0587039106,
0.0088757118,
-0.0534429923,
0.026855845,
0.0535740927,
0.0352539495,
0.0178377777,
-0.0060828933,
-0.0418364592,
-0.0487848371,
-0.0321848541,
-0.0421394743,
0.0039775921,
-0.0188073236,
-0.0168656297,
0.0285515431,
-0.0175537076,
-0.0507434383,
-0.0289677605,
-0.0248082802,
0.0325079001,
-0.0022403211,
0.0293367747,
0.0008609326,
-0.0331584997,
0.0288534164,
0.0576119274,
-0.0482514761,
-0.0044673476,
-0.0230085552,
0.0104874857,
0.0004083628,
-0.018462155,
-0.0249396302,
0.0008220791,
-0.0700501204,
-0.0015594283,
-0.0341652036,
-0.0684417635,
0.0294082649,
0.0310286917,
-0.0217456426,
0.0622922331,
-0.0533836894,
-0.0003529022,
-0.0422848538,
-0.0132971266,
-0.037182156,
0.0386539027,
-0.015605987,
0.0010342181,
0.0119277369,
-0.000432423,
0.0080834115,
0.0450223163,
-0.0462630838,
-0.0348066352,
0.0048307003,
0.0101566482,
0.0049776617,
0.0317228809,
-0.0241318867,
-0.0222874675,
0.0662022829,
0.0376031399,
0.0352417715,
0.0281963218,
0.0248509068,
0.0373734273,
-0.0010622015,
0.0761576295,
-0.029663112,
0.0143524017,
0.0243723374,
0.0573268272,
-0.0369242169,
0.0116943242,
0.0044085407,
0.0121353064,
0.0489949957,
-0.065551132,
-0.0020406367,
-0.0174360778,
-0.0364975221,
-0.0697659403,
-0.0176119395,
0.0254769381,
-0.0224353839,
0.0399862751,
-0.046953287,
0.0068000113,
0.0872117952,
-0.0263339877,
0.0131305614,
-0.006626233,
0.0274975002,
0.0464814156,
-0.0081190746,
-0.0182195343,
0.0236980114,
0.0053701899,
-0.0309196804,
0.0208164677,
-0.0092646033,
-0.0532622486,
-0.0096808206,
-0.0218215548,
0.0223009121,
-0.0596076585,
0.0200250708,
-0.0021057141,
0.0242746901,
0.0356219672,
0.0085869571,
0.0996029973,
-0.0327135064,
0.1082586423,
0.0197651107,
-0.013448556,
-0.0122075332,
0.0459124371,
0.0161336828,
0.0408011675,
-0.0021119649,
0.0157328472,
0.0008237165,
0.0229949802,
0.0746592358,
-0.0010187294,
0.0182754491,
0.0278204456,
-0.0141224042,
-0.0088421497,
-0.016267281,
-0.0055121356,
0.0465441607,
-0.0143399164,
0.0151192192,
-0.0674633458,
-0.0828934535,
0.0612029657,
-0.001432366,
-0.0327635221,
0.0181426574,
0.0297895856,
0.0319731683,
-0.0027544242,
0.0222089905,
-0.0208098125,
-0.0194414593,
-0.0142828953,
-0.0563113801,
-0.007115664,
-5.633712429e-33,
-0.0004170883,
0.0331043713,
0.0048824851,
-0.0701644793,
-0.0250544697,
0.0015548766,
-0.0263806209,
-0.0072011524,
-0.0512330867,
0.0286825784,
0.0130150681,
0.0004352214,
0.027295677,
0.0238760561,
-0.0495297015,
0.0156255551,
0.0561255403,
0.0213024653,
-0.0018287944,
-0.0032722703,
0.0807082951,
0.0193028115,
0.0854920223,
-0.0373012386,
0.038367793,
-0.0072223651,
0.0146133443,
-0.0032915161,
0.107144013,
0.0337136164,
0.0050276979,
0.0844772533,
0.0100059733,
0.0255147424,
-0.0134206749,
-0.0474435687,
-0.0760744736,
-0.0384589136,
0.0558582619,
-0.0002210142,
0.0007688301,
-0.0171337388,
0.0154252341,
-0.0123077901,
-0.008404457,
-0.0060900827,
0.0172712803,
-0.0153048141,
-0.0708153993,
-0.004431488,
-0.1087858975,
0.0208534561,
-0.010759159,
-0.0231210459,
0.0334757827,
-0.0232984629,
-0.0042381319,
-0.0033744578,
-0.0607425645,
0.0109537765,
-0.0734646544,
0.0363142677,
0.0812470838,
0.0466933697,
0.0024592953,
0.0293228328,
0.0243208054,
-0.0141448779,
0.0564668365,
0.0038287132,
0.0501891524,
-0.0358392671,
0.0064311954,
0.1247936711,
0.0545862392,
-0.0308522359,
-0.0921176299,
0.0105929151,
-0.0202674475,
0.0371224061,
0.0144998096,
0.0222177636,
-0.0139408754,
-0.046450641,
-0.0720655471,
-0.0008134642,
-0.0133388136,
-0.0244298726,
-0.0105108321,
-0.0278861281,
-0.0204441473,
0.031500414,
0.0584064014,
-0.0336952358,
0.0045665242,
0.0372254588,
0.0211611893,
0.0125120757,
0.0143245049,
0.0361677669,
-0.0263865516,
-0.0199028719,
-0.0289293583,
0.0329759084,
0.0047514047,
-0.0015917636,
0.0122542409,
-0.0094413413,
-0.0097698541,
0.0119142104,
0.0016398042,
-0.0335905924,
-0.0264830403,
0.0075085028,
0.0078808274,
0.0090894299,
0.0180166792,
0.0074243722,
0.0437781028,
-0.0332255848,
0.0475607403,
-0.0578133315,
0.0094075259,
0.0363637395,
-0.0118929297,
0.042882096,
-0.0247090627,
-0.0082966601,
0.0351354964,
-0.043779701,
0.0059574042,
-0.0215753466,
2.589e-7,
0.0422597751,
0.0258851703,
-0.0347443633,
0.0409802198,
-0.0162595809,
-0.0009688628,
0.0168602578,
0.0205537993,
-0.0731786415,
-0.0337176956,
-0.0215355959,
0.042216707,
0.0298353955,
0.0547358543,
-0.0241593327,
0.021480646,
0.0345558934,
0.0336341374,
-0.0069417483,
0.0238230266,
0.0305988695,
0.0975381583,
-0.0135708153,
-0.0021981206,
-0.0250119641,
-0.0396971293,
0.0593972206,
0.0112856571,
-0.0050954917,
0.0116482889,
-0.0276592001,
-0.0143223312,
0.0127009312,
0.0103889024,
-0.0457970761,
0.002956673,
0.0380328223,
0.025435647,
-0.039784506,
-0.0435964018,
-0.0275291,
-0.0223704632,
0.0075187562,
-0.0027186181,
0.0791160017,
-0.0471313186,
-0.0198637284,
0.0090789227,
-0.0134604657,
0.0767805278,
0.0323059857,
-0.0080877319,
-0.0694487095,
0.0119063221,
0.0368243568,
0.0041002957,
-0.0642201453,
-0.0069559077,
-0.021807231,
0.0363798141,
0.0150158182,
-0.0196548346,
0.051565215,
-0.0572873987,
0.0334070101,
-0.0210806932,
0.0215858202,
2.137298752e-34,
0.0500255711,
0.0010484579,
0.0086618112,
-0.0259462278,
-0.0049947985,
-0.0221662428,
-0.0254855435,
0.0065736473,
0.0250403974,
-0.0400161147,
0.0247345399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13693v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13693v2 | Evaluating Large Language Models for Radiology Natural Language Processing | 2023-07-25T17:57:18 | 2023-07-27T12:58:59 | Zhengliang Liu, Tianyang Zhong, Yiwei Li, Yutong Zhang, Yi Pan, Zihao Zhao, Peixin Dong, Chao Cao, Yuxiao Liu, Peng Shu, Yaonai Wei, Zihao Wu, Chong Ma, Jiaqi Wang, Sheng Wang, Mengyue Zhou, Zuowei Jiang, Chunlin Li, Jason Holmes, Shaochen Xu, Lu Zhang, Haixing Dai, Kai Zhang, Lin Zhao, Yuanhao Chen, Xu Liu, Peilong Wang, Pingkun Yan, Jun Liu, Bao Ge, Lichao Sun, Dajiang Zhu, Xiang Li, Wei Liu, Xiaoyan Cai, Xintao Hu, Xi Jiang, Shu Zhang, Xin Zhang, Tuo Zhang, Shijie Zhao, Quanzheng Li, Hongtu Zhu, Dinggang Shen, Tianming Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of large language models (LLMs) has marked a pivotal shift in the
field of natural language processing (NLP). LLMs have revolutionized a
multitude of domains, and they have made a significant impact in the medical
field. Large language models are now more abundant than ever, and many of these
models exhibit bilingual capabilities, proficient in both English and Chinese.
However, a comprehensive evaluation of these models remains to be conducted.
This lack of assessment is especially apparent within the context of radiology
NLP. This study seeks to bridge this gap by critically evaluating thirty two
LLMs in interpreting radiology reports, a crucial component of radiology NLP.
Specifically, the ability to derive impressions from radiologic findings is
assessed. The outcomes of this evaluation provide key insights into the
performance, strengths, and weaknesses of these LLMs, informing their practical
applications within the medical domain. | [
0.0564515218,
0.0628064498,
0.0215518195,
0.0127694393,
-0.0258496385,
0.0406702869,
-0.0029570209,
0.04164901,
0.0058183586,
-0.0266641248,
-0.0328450315,
-0.0755467415,
0.0268452335,
0.005526843,
-0.0052957172,
-0.0685859025,
0.0009835955,
-0.0193351097,
0.0108514559,
0.0157026108,
0.0028190201,
0.0136131179,
-0.0164670441,
0.0370313041,
0.0176827535,
-0.0063352208,
0.0662685931,
0.0010958301,
-0.0008762276,
-0.0486460142,
-0.0671214387,
0.0362377688,
-0.021134112,
0.0275746174,
0.000001831,
-0.0509878807,
-0.0212070029,
0.0371658094,
-0.004968842,
0.01554415,
0.1085460111,
-0.0685331151,
-0.0420972221,
-0.0151787717,
-0.0101172589,
-0.0679871142,
0.0419637971,
0.0437085479,
0.0461948924,
0.0559243187,
-0.0168032665,
-0.0298128091,
0.0191826709,
-0.0056277174,
-0.0224784985,
-0.0348285437,
0.0270013008,
0.0494179837,
0.0253681634,
-0.0042793048,
-0.005492921,
0.0381125882,
-0.0207482595,
0.0171712358,
-0.030572908,
0.0460319705,
-0.0153909028,
-0.0241716839,
0.0156144677,
0.0216334071,
0.0005108926,
0.0163254477,
-0.0176926889,
0.0046586893,
-0.032548815,
0.0088866344,
-0.0246403422,
0.0378798805,
-0.0189155042,
-0.0048921518,
0.0115537783,
0.0038955244,
0.0025165223,
0.0323149674,
-0.0515268408,
0.0008702731,
0.0150750922,
-0.0159189086,
0.0392040834,
0.0385157168,
-0.0209403262,
-0.0199249554,
0.0394637324,
0.0194490682,
-0.0343606547,
0.0375642888,
0.0037973865,
0.0051101651,
0.0775563046,
-0.0749826953,
-0.0216717888,
-0.0040082769,
-0.0494890511,
0.0761384666,
-0.043841321,
0.0511492752,
-0.0476875305,
0.0248058345,
-0.05009811,
-0.0003567507,
-0.0389559269,
-0.0228280593,
-0.0171651617,
0.0054183099,
-0.004765695,
-0.0330725946,
-0.0842049867,
-0.032706704,
0.016443098,
0.0134138437,
0.028338844,
0.0328122266,
-0.0274206493,
0.0126910666,
-0.0573289692,
0.0712257773,
0.0227051526,
-0.0167531297,
-0.0504063219,
-0.0472128503,
0.0378605314,
0.049924653,
-0.026013406,
-0.0162867941,
0.0071466477,
0.0374021195,
0.022049835,
-0.0024848823,
0.0354585052,
-0.0509254523,
-0.0423383452,
-0.0532638505,
0.0101838354,
-0.0708126873,
0.0108601479,
0.0396113992,
0.0384877287,
-0.0121439574,
0.0176097043,
0.0080199679,
-0.0416300222,
0.0498946831,
-0.0371037163,
-0.0022581962,
-0.0078628901,
0.0263784193,
0.0454622135,
0.0191162415,
0.0118017504,
-0.0262363814,
-0.0109702116,
-0.0069740294,
-0.0194881111,
0.0108727403,
-0.0581086352,
-0.0400397889,
-0.0317937322,
0.0167557541,
-0.0080686733,
0.0716915429,
0.007409221,
0.082348831,
-0.0090156896,
0.0126052322,
0.0058533647,
0.0706558079,
0.0318036228,
0.0051633622,
0.0418477617,
-0.0170309562,
0.015731778,
0.0018657154,
0.000070825,
-0.0041131871,
0.0328418501,
0.0094445059,
-0.0446339324,
0.0203501806,
-0.007813978,
-0.0363987349,
-0.0656410232,
0.0107065663,
-0.0000227538,
-0.0107990811,
0.0544947051,
-0.0172583666,
-0.0305510908,
0.0362465717,
0.0382863432,
-0.0175532401,
0.0079704998,
-0.0606033839,
-0.0540959015,
0.0980145335,
0.0482821763,
-0.000762234,
-0.0087808548,
0.0190360341,
0.0217734668,
0.0342455469,
0.032919053,
0.0230703969,
-0.01140662,
-0.0325881541,
-0.0124988947,
0.0485103205,
0.0288528055,
-0.0209511947,
-0.0017846654,
0.0436050668,
-0.0307186954,
-0.0229912922,
-0.0657355413,
0.0244467109,
-0.0330343358,
-0.0093748905,
-0.035344243,
0.0082170907,
-0.0081276884,
0.0237637628,
-0.0366027579,
0.0325566866,
0.0105407694,
0.0003759527,
-0.0214224886,
0.041002173,
-0.0460370034,
-0.0240853205,
0.0337079987,
-0.0715688914,
-0.0210938752,
-0.0218719877,
-0.0178232044,
0.0059994343,
-0.0375347622,
-0.0521879494,
0.0124642858,
-0.0067165801,
0.0451181382,
0.0152176088,
-0.0050490233,
-0.0428226888,
0.0536723658,
-0.0246903207,
0.0411813706,
0.0420999341,
-0.0313794576,
0.0160825271,
-0.0523034446,
-0.0680357739,
0.0297029149,
0.0289493836,
0.0013865022,
-0.0158704314,
0.0397402123,
-0.0337072946,
-0.0472450107,
-0.0464760065,
-0.0196891464,
0.0112346867,
0.0044493307,
0.0553867035,
-0.0170096494,
0.0099321436,
-0.0173054039,
-0.006962148,
-0.0540330522,
0.0640249699,
0.0271288827,
0.0530473851,
0.0192768015,
-0.0049118954,
-0.0241198242,
-0.0182209425,
-0.0352923647,
0.0187178254,
0.0490126573,
-0.0648261532,
-0.0320664793,
0.0353334881,
-0.0314921215,
-0.0132458126,
0.0178373605,
-0.0613925271,
0.0228717346,
-0.0432840474,
-0.0366170183,
0.0485465489,
-0.0234752707,
0.0631955341,
0.0425250605,
-0.0238265879,
0.0107879359,
-0.0288681146,
-0.0104658976,
-0.02628286,
-0.0077254609,
-0.0763875768,
-0.0289957654,
0.0586517043,
-0.006590521,
0.0125983469,
0.0012238808,
-0.024658747,
-0.0773314238,
-0.0140206339,
-0.0275840256,
0.0007737519,
-0.0073964214,
0.0506370142,
0.0039265184,
-0.0110447397,
0.0989526734,
-0.0261872765,
0.0179999713,
-0.1021424532,
-0.0171400644,
-0.0529983267,
0.0416026786,
-0.0175543968,
0.0385543518,
0.0187507905,
-0.0591743439,
0.0096558109,
0.0225633476,
0.0177036338,
-0.0764967427,
0.0318387076,
-0.0070714117,
0.0076646088,
-0.0173587296,
0.0007451198,
-0.0114082983,
-0.0095356684,
-0.0214237794,
0.0107581569,
0.0345874429,
0.0016319667,
-0.0633874238,
0.0861252323,
0.0357186757,
0.0105796745,
0.0023670946,
-0.0067517338,
-0.0034494558,
0.0322650447,
0.0091932137,
0.0319632776,
0.0144370953,
-0.028994821,
0.0276995841,
0.0803181082,
-0.0233286545,
0.0494623482,
-0.0306019615,
-0.0056996006,
0.0205608495,
-0.0062764147,
-0.0179567207,
-0.015213252,
0.0365975834,
-0.0646528155,
-0.0082946867,
0.1000955775,
0.0300111342,
-0.0228572562,
-0.0205486026,
0.0201328453,
-0.0430898517,
-0.006856998,
-0.0171815045,
-0.0280587096,
-0.0083918441,
-0.0171305332,
-0.0021624945,
-0.0021743346,
-0.02410312,
0.0257035494,
-0.0546273291,
0.0462748781,
0.0025840525,
-0.0511032082,
-0.0332228467,
-0.0535474271,
-0.0254961383,
0.001679345,
-0.0034928531,
-0.0158640426,
-0.0321462899,
-0.0069809118,
0.0134031931,
-0.0624077581,
-0.09400592,
0.0456536785,
-0.0527616665,
-0.007717188,
0.0404944159,
0.0454017892,
-0.0428854637,
-0.0098322881,
-0.0231446959,
0.0182885174,
0.0273784306,
0.0103531191,
0.0696852356,
0.0328164436,
-0.0118090659,
-0.0679384768,
-0.0253006443,
-0.019747423,
0.0277229603,
-0.0495894402,
0.0535011813,
-0.015057005,
0.0050682751,
-0.027048571,
0.0629959255,
0.0057089189,
0.0370169468,
-0.0139978137,
0.0080201821,
-0.0352960229,
0.0196617022,
0.0358137302,
-0.0116768377,
-0.0768403709,
0.0799151361,
-0.0475163013,
-0.0454490371,
-0.0388476066,
-0.0402700268,
0.036189463,
0.0038512426,
0.0091769733,
0.0503383577,
0.0141686993,
-0.0097384676,
-0.0198597554,
0.0764599666,
0.0362644121,
0.032092724,
-0.045878958,
-0.0104213143,
0.0758294985,
0.0198234897,
-0.0139201758,
0.0207981039,
-0.0407221727,
0.0225372761,
0.0067667672,
0.0113444384,
0.0260679461,
-0.0368044898,
-0.0178738162,
-0.0357518159,
0.0080851205,
0.0377800688,
-0.0234494749,
-0.0066856868,
-0.0282109194,
0.0078988485,
-0.0092335008,
0.0014426654,
0.0017923964,
0.0009642787,
0.0159990545,
0.0239846092,
-0.034308292,
-0.0429343544,
0.0365670659,
0.0675713718,
0.0312759615,
-0.017331088,
-0.0029431144,
0.0208436847,
-0.0156951919,
-0.0435450859,
0.0012879911,
-0.0117630232,
-0.0071032848,
0.0647044107,
-0.0055667502,
-0.0300853457,
0.0107227238,
-0.0407629944,
-0.0238603875,
-0.0426102355,
0.084012188,
0.0391292088,
-0.035548389,
0.0487104394,
-0.0059788413,
-0.0328142308,
-0.0425160229,
-0.0091842832,
0.0078036999,
0.0036351557,
0.054756254,
0.0005865492,
0.0252798609,
-0.0149311656,
0.0379774831,
-0.0250454284,
-0.0526998192,
-0.0084847696,
0.0070180907,
0.0592773259,
0.0045807478,
0.0400635265,
-0.0419047475,
0.0143328812,
-0.0321020596,
0.0185170807,
0.0027092958,
0.0095665371,
0.0672212467,
0.0078118546,
0.024917176,
-0.0323385075,
0.0738249123,
0.0074433205,
-0.0051196613,
-0.0085859708,
-0.0630744919,
-0.0243208688,
-0.0347428694,
-0.0356363319,
-0.0175301358,
-0.0648624524,
0.0100546889,
-0.0752591044,
-0.0458435863,
-0.0227773059,
-0.0123281842,
-0.0047990484,
-0.0339443311,
0.0126079964,
0.063534379,
0.030218821,
-0.0112445131,
-0.0222087074,
0.0408601053,
-0.0114521924,
0.0138935037,
0.0367263481,
-5.602312771e-33,
0.0122907469,
-0.043063812,
0.0361181721,
-0.0690533444,
0.0103503689,
0.0410080999,
-0.0186857488,
0.0022065202,
-0.0183056276,
0.0078062192,
-0.0248028021,
-0.0224071629,
0.0323388055,
0.0168392528,
0.0023791734,
0.0070166881,
0.0202746987,
0.0179281123,
-0.0103802979,
-0.0376064815,
-0.0166036971,
0.0250932034,
0.0676030964,
-0.1130741984,
0.008680745,
0.0229945742,
0.0105558215,
-0.0147126252,
0.0018109137,
0.0805278122,
-0.0370683074,
0.0188040137,
0.0327759273,
-0.0560389347,
0.0054777865,
0.0058698119,
-0.0785919353,
0.0085146558,
0.0468294397,
0.047163602,
-0.0336539261,
0.0153676011,
0.0498336107,
-0.0176063571,
0.0000180238,
0.0008087332,
0.029821787,
-0.030122444,
-0.0009413515,
0.0198019333,
-0.065987736,
0.0706277564,
0.0347072668,
0.0182835106,
0.0197595451,
-0.0285972208,
-0.0565990992,
0.0592698716,
-0.0442036763,
-0.0019315139,
0.0625389293,
0.025426615,
0.031252142,
-0.0374629609,
-0.0247129779,
0.0511640869,
0.0528936945,
-0.0224928241,
0.0042980709,
-0.0042641237,
-0.0194955729,
0.0349348821,
0.0216683075,
0.038786307,
0.03560118,
-0.0061742743,
-0.0688934252,
0.0188638363,
-0.0176481251,
0.0981905758,
0.0280290134,
-0.0209329184,
-0.0624669828,
0.0057962248,
-0.0084626041,
-0.035283614,
-0.0275823548,
-0.0462124608,
0.0226771105,
0.0043436205,
-0.0185715836,
0.0549208745,
0.0443940051,
-0.010322731,
-0.027510412,
-0.0398318991,
0.0213874467,
0.0571447201,
-0.0664997026,
0.0168074742,
-0.0500264242,
-0.0161256492,
0.001759526,
0.0054428997,
0.0267424546,
-0.0099535771,
0.0089483364,
-0.0148239788,
-0.0593975894,
0.0216903258,
0.0053732703,
-0.0434985347,
-0.0131992931,
0.0470111966,
0.0462271981,
0.0040264498,
-0.0054547535,
0.0465190187,
-0.0070871664,
0.0052075917,
-0.0225850958,
-0.0704568103,
0.0070301807,
-0.0083814198,
-0.0449586734,
-0.0154437926,
-0.0195898861,
0.0073226038,
0.0479031503,
-0.0183127597,
-0.0203366373,
0.0050087734,
2.523e-7,
0.0978443176,
0.0485065579,
0.0113523062,
0.0207623858,
0.0191467535,
-0.0224980079,
-0.0411067642,
0.0044996305,
0.0243285112,
-0.0015773297,
-0.0192178078,
-0.0006562094,
0.0006146487,
0.0525236502,
-0.0698671043,
-0.0066940044,
-0.0439896733,
-0.0133723915,
-0.0156311672,
-0.0033391006,
0.0864745304,
0.0815154314,
-0.0788267478,
-0.0367396921,
-0.0306739733,
-0.0471613333,
0.0261497982,
-0.0281087719,
0.0017731825,
0.0298286378,
0.0440221019,
0.021750534,
0.0271351933,
0.0726605952,
0.0193753652,
-0.0231609214,
0.0528133847,
0.0794311836,
-0.043781653,
0.0352628455,
0.020757772,
-0.0112789813,
0.0084515149,
-0.0479470454,
0.0480967537,
-0.0535423644,
-0.0351565592,
-0.0099735614,
-0.0177335609,
-0.027224822,
0.0652548373,
-0.0250203572,
-0.0441562198,
0.0341906399,
0.0211601593,
0.0029778625,
-0.0713652372,
-0.0575196594,
-0.0032158894,
0.013581478,
0.0040852106,
-0.0569567718,
0.0428555869,
-0.0205222517,
0.0054087089,
-0.0582961664,
-0.0213552862,
2.135266203e-34,
0.0408619791,
0.0119965812,
0.0189281125,
0.0206877794,
0.0239787605,
-0.0020926369,
-0.0162538346,
0.0174238626,
-0.0180950705,
-0.0593170412,
0.0051448862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13692v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13692v2 | ARB: Advanced Reasoning Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2023-07-25T17:55:19 | 2023-07-28T03:31:08 | Tomohiro Sawada, Daniel Paleka, Alexander Havrilla, Pranav Tadepalli, Paula Vidas, Alexander Kranias, John J. Nay, Kshitij Gupta, Aran Komatsuzaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance on
various quantitative reasoning and knowledge benchmarks. However, many of these
benchmarks are losing utility as LLMs get increasingly high scores, despite not
yet reaching expert performance in these domains. We introduce ARB, a novel
benchmark composed of advanced reasoning problems in multiple fields. ARB
presents a more challenging test than prior benchmarks, featuring problems in
mathematics, physics, biology, chemistry, and law. As a subset of ARB, we
introduce a challenging set of math and physics problems which require advanced
symbolic reasoning and domain knowledge. We evaluate recent models such as
GPT-4 and Claude on ARB and demonstrate that current models score well below
50% on more demanding tasks. In order to improve both automatic and assisted
evaluation capabilities, we introduce a rubric-based evaluation approach,
allowing GPT-4 to score its own intermediate reasoning steps. Further, we
conduct a human evaluation of the symbolic subset of ARB, finding promising
agreement between annotators and GPT-4 rubric evaluation scores. | [
-0.012409132,
0.0540847555,
-0.0097252615,
0.050015159,
-0.0655748472,
0.0342359431,
0.0302581619,
0.0071767163,
-0.0120322956,
-0.0296051148,
0.0058974903,
-0.0127281137,
-0.0428689048,
-0.0078331698,
0.0345712975,
-0.0208052825,
0.0303021315,
-0.0630028546,
0.0440253839,
-0.012183235,
-0.0214226581,
-0.0064272061,
-0.0168150831,
-0.0006874348,
-0.0206825212,
-0.0260653235,
0.0282749124,
-0.0266074799,
0.0367834792,
-0.0267717503,
-0.0272146445,
0.0743927509,
0.0178121105,
0.0554796346,
0.0000022309,
-0.0416748822,
-0.0060020951,
0.0476341508,
-0.0406089798,
0.0317311622,
-0.0082153566,
0.0219532009,
0.0249896403,
0.0252618864,
-0.0351737142,
0.0008257989,
0.0096794609,
0.0215746369,
0.0631307214,
0.0544971228,
0.0029315569,
-0.0421976969,
0.0284724031,
-0.0158601608,
0.0136649134,
-0.076597631,
0.0083982134,
0.0835101828,
0.0272535589,
-0.0207930859,
-0.0147822769,
0.0410873704,
0.0751558617,
0.0112740071,
-0.0418525897,
0.0177658703,
-0.0696811453,
0.0153218824,
0.0334350839,
0.0590580851,
-0.0017476911,
-0.0204347298,
-0.0359159634,
0.0062227785,
-0.0198252276,
0.0147318868,
-0.0412929617,
0.03828362,
-0.0093396185,
-0.009558728,
0.0066830567,
0.0265007913,
0.0433994308,
0.014777666,
-0.0513856411,
0.1182357222,
0.0346140824,
-0.0225013848,
0.0370445065,
-0.0109547107,
-0.0834350511,
-0.0523423329,
0.0189912412,
0.0367407948,
-0.0013778107,
0.0258115828,
0.0019881269,
-0.0019105428,
0.0097725559,
-0.0161171965,
0.0548321605,
0.0739255473,
0.0357929394,
0.0789058581,
-0.0381188281,
0.0996767879,
-0.0200571567,
0.0257497635,
-0.0210233461,
-0.0107120527,
-0.0675584972,
-0.0083247153,
-0.0219584722,
0.04091857,
-0.0111420974,
-0.0029940819,
-0.050909806,
-0.0191516671,
-0.0237640832,
0.0174224731,
0.0261265058,
-0.0233498793,
0.0268457048,
-0.0399075672,
-0.0392918251,
0.0046699727,
-0.0446991995,
0.0083242925,
0.002173749,
-0.0437208861,
-0.001983674,
-0.011409522,
-0.0329421461,
-0.0533655733,
0.0291082188,
0.0588807575,
0.0132002067,
-0.0146052958,
0.0275022015,
-0.0240911096,
-0.0031645612,
-0.1273898929,
0.0113635715,
-0.0636571348,
0.0442451611,
0.0311628226,
-0.0240329728,
-0.0206083916,
0.0353795886,
0.0017495041,
0.0344765559,
0.0667051747,
0.0195707623,
-0.0227497239,
0.0103562213,
0.0247622728,
-0.0438040905,
0.0396698862,
0.0172332712,
0.0106039289,
-0.0023297565,
0.0026127154,
0.0066710385,
0.0368345343,
0.0060571819,
-0.0092606666,
-0.0157145821,
0.0424322635,
-0.0055881822,
0.0443164557,
-0.0496306084,
0.0618609972,
-0.0225705486,
-0.0418144464,
0.0112138661,
0.0559493639,
-0.0210340563,
0.0186083056,
0.0270701908,
-0.0440756194,
0.0501695313,
-0.0281715691,
-0.0612103418,
0.0359223634,
-0.0734531954,
-0.008201912,
0.0066401772,
0.0171592329,
0.0062138457,
-0.0571942069,
-0.0323847383,
0.0273561906,
-0.0024204296,
0.0132878302,
0.0689468831,
-0.0382145196,
-0.0063431649,
0.0349724852,
-0.0049383854,
-0.0434256345,
-0.0191543698,
-0.0238446016,
0.0226534624,
-0.0055771745,
0.0511779077,
-0.0514147729,
-0.0531781539,
0.0040624333,
0.0305732079,
0.0155241871,
0.0524190441,
0.0108580636,
-0.0274020899,
-0.0373899117,
-0.0092340028,
-0.0275332816,
0.0225149617,
0.0159940068,
0.0258293431,
0.0166930892,
0.0259475764,
-0.0739239752,
-0.0143172285,
0.0019252489,
-0.0643394515,
-0.0446253233,
-0.0403028429,
-0.0108626997,
0.0302744564,
0.0019495372,
-0.0137881525,
0.0498276167,
0.0135002881,
-0.0345797129,
-0.0140719162,
0.0042565828,
-0.0302207395,
-0.0205664672,
0.057751324,
-0.0444759503,
-0.049152296,
0.054013025,
-0.0385583714,
-0.0249057095,
0.0512498878,
0.0039218026,
0.0104784267,
-0.0322916433,
0.03019787,
-0.0179996639,
-0.014552868,
-0.0068339664,
0.0909898579,
0.0154512841,
0.0438883752,
0.0063047153,
0.0083695054,
0.0452464111,
-0.0181606784,
-0.0298883263,
-0.002961746,
0.0007287786,
0.0024926667,
0.0125934556,
-0.0141114946,
-0.0548562147,
0.0007655231,
-0.0317428038,
0.0131421583,
-0.0148124164,
0.0283958409,
-0.001027424,
-0.0415759273,
0.0109380418,
0.0110171232,
-0.0349949263,
-0.0080182208,
-0.0029092678,
0.0031141546,
0.0052817473,
0.0116533134,
-0.0200772043,
-0.033729054,
-0.0211342387,
-0.0555102974,
0.0410626829,
0.0272342321,
0.0790942907,
0.009261868,
0.0085485429,
-0.0401890427,
0.0181479119,
-0.0138884615,
-0.0001944662,
0.0258881263,
-0.0413895175,
-0.0195435956,
0.0580670983,
-0.0194707233,
0.0298799295,
0.0335928202,
-0.0170560088,
-0.0438671596,
0.0195583198,
-0.0174851771,
-0.0003174809,
-0.0095140962,
-0.026983602,
-0.0222849343,
0.068390362,
-0.022560766,
-0.0204457417,
-0.0389392562,
0.0469181463,
-0.0627747327,
-0.0102307936,
-0.0425418057,
0.008147493,
0.0138899228,
0.0572062805,
-0.0329358689,
-0.0124162761,
0.0807991028,
-0.0258628726,
-0.0020725648,
-0.0515143164,
0.0243259836,
-0.036257565,
0.095350638,
0.010439151,
0.010371862,
-0.0095427586,
0.0108996574,
-0.0180667397,
-0.0218832083,
0.0119431233,
-0.0265549738,
0.0372591019,
-0.0641469955,
0.0348857827,
0.0038818307,
-0.0638291538,
-0.0106034139,
0.0117073394,
-0.0427846573,
0.044962097,
-0.0206887648,
-0.0397554003,
-0.0116476957,
0.0308745597,
0.0107585555,
0.017501168,
-0.0303137284,
-0.0119395703,
-0.0103097884,
0.0104686897,
0.021563733,
-0.0076944116,
0.0547388569,
-0.0446591265,
0.0240636934,
0.0434852503,
0.0319671184,
0.0017452925,
-0.0469528027,
0.0289482921,
-0.0021292958,
-0.0250967406,
-0.0024814196,
-0.0036278607,
0.0152347628,
-0.0667086169,
-0.0110990228,
0.1364782453,
0.0462469682,
0.0073794401,
0.0070099654,
-0.0339658372,
-0.001012887,
0.0326886177,
0.0242251139,
-0.0979972854,
-0.0354158506,
0.002535705,
-0.0304345489,
0.0214662123,
-0.0574388392,
0.0032835291,
-0.0977314934,
0.0345426127,
0.0156789441,
-0.0704246536,
-0.0216161981,
-0.0120888837,
0.0221060999,
-0.0244533885,
0.0046534701,
0.0300072338,
0.0200221129,
0.0036620214,
0.0219294969,
-0.0085448157,
-0.038011048,
0.0836679488,
-0.0337561294,
0.0112534715,
-0.0030865583,
0.0376639701,
-0.0122773107,
-0.0465106554,
0.0285531152,
0.0132597843,
-0.0048072077,
-0.0032035059,
-0.0235288572,
0.0277089607,
-0.0147221759,
-0.0232931394,
0.0230175219,
-0.0505721197,
-0.0208372418,
0.0141423913,
0.1249949783,
-0.0046965699,
-0.028284844,
-0.0072603151,
-0.0134916669,
-0.0587512515,
0.0715684071,
0.0053868401,
0.0297685731,
-0.0700066462,
-0.042148184,
-0.0245403182,
-0.0411224291,
-0.0392769352,
0.0040484518,
0.0403664969,
-0.0224517267,
-0.0176949333,
-0.0225340836,
0.0688754842,
0.0257819947,
-0.0126586417,
-0.0087488377,
0.0086350255,
0.0132455472,
-0.0314914472,
0.0423575193,
-0.0530180037,
0.0304365605,
-0.0145070488,
0.0319448747,
0.0063018622,
-0.0281360354,
-0.05919962,
0.0203764979,
-0.0563139729,
-0.0572830625,
-0.0087128654,
0.0268088486,
0.0293039568,
0.0134079922,
-0.0366540775,
-0.0343455411,
0.0131805809,
-0.0380158536,
-0.0013225612,
0.0008398195,
0.0209303107,
-0.0133934338,
0.0035774682,
0.0181570835,
-0.0162018128,
0.0154631864,
0.0158488061,
0.056161508,
-0.0190742332,
-0.0078446828,
0.0400762782,
0.0684086159,
-0.011652045,
0.0187789183,
-0.0291320477,
0.0143901287,
0.0318370014,
-0.0470786877,
-0.0271712188,
-0.0399335362,
0.0217204764,
0.0498553626,
-0.0183176845,
-0.0173485931,
-0.0232396219,
0.0324530974,
0.0315951854,
-0.0038787329,
0.021430824,
0.0461627804,
0.0264922194,
0.0496074259,
-0.0428491645,
-0.0113359392,
-0.0396648198,
-0.0250674859,
0.0667188317,
-0.055166427,
0.0584894754,
0.0467168801,
0.0033100815,
-0.0309764184,
0.0039045499,
-0.0577176921,
-0.0731883794,
0.0155265741,
0.0442933179,
0.0459804833,
0.0060012764,
0.0061078714,
-0.0789208636,
-0.0225744899,
-0.007165317,
-0.0105095841,
0.0347951315,
-0.0205821581,
0.0487550758,
0.0474983901,
0.0120531274,
-0.0027783702,
0.0286497492,
-0.0083065368,
0.0396128073,
0.0197970308,
-0.0124656633,
-0.032110285,
-0.0397594124,
-0.0095983064,
-0.008386177,
0.0060232463,
0.0180886835,
-0.0922427848,
-0.1063408926,
-0.0102964705,
0.0400785878,
-0.0265634488,
0.0197889768,
0.0210901611,
0.0698114261,
-0.0291889012,
-0.0490062125,
-0.0087309135,
-0.0042565176,
-0.0596467964,
-0.00856198,
-0.0058940626,
-6.642233685e-33,
-0.0254397504,
4.778e-7,
0.0415634587,
-0.0342643149,
0.010222421,
-0.018222332,
-0.0480262339,
-0.0005386661,
-0.0181195587,
0.0386693962,
-0.0085659735,
0.0202174652,
-0.0040944316,
-0.0027420428,
0.00109302,
-0.0238012541,
-0.008403101,
0.0247953273,
-0.0480038971,
0.0180092491,
0.0048878537,
-0.0127787748,
0.0344911255,
-0.0364197008,
0.0097923959,
0.0126231844,
-0.0168423969,
0.0283388309,
-0.089534536,
0.0511150919,
-0.0244837329,
0.0037222756,
0.0045012082,
-0.0414126776,
0.015164189,
-0.0264615882,
-0.0555881821,
-0.0366711058,
0.0361299478,
-0.0166446194,
-0.0521186069,
-0.025920026,
0.014376983,
0.0137661854,
-0.0379461013,
-0.0344483182,
0.0071266033,
-0.038508676,
0.0287600681,
-0.0222926829,
-0.0385020226,
0.0217860397,
-0.0416034162,
0.008628577,
0.020730162,
0.0090361713,
-0.0192060545,
0.0210218374,
-0.030596165,
-0.0060304375,
0.0104090478,
0.0010566732,
0.0624873005,
-0.0244231746,
-0.000802057,
0.0307143871,
0.0017523892,
-0.0274110194,
-0.0042410675,
0.0452687591,
0.0161587428,
0.0828443244,
0.0926459357,
0.0236202292,
0.0432661101,
0.04570641,
-0.0719483718,
0.0060608163,
0.0317624509,
0.0542800725,
0.0477861762,
-0.0013856682,
-0.0568139851,
0.0000049225,
-0.0779938251,
0.026648229,
-0.0592925251,
-0.0230334625,
0.0384057835,
-0.0290273894,
-0.0203322824,
0.0055136038,
0.0288759749,
-0.0439648032,
-0.0271530561,
0.0222507529,
0.0293390006,
0.0175808966,
0.0020256974,
0.069525525,
-0.0186258592,
0.0143325813,
-0.0116187818,
-0.0009820212,
0.0406822041,
-0.0096119912,
0.0134523436,
0.0324159861,
-0.0163934529,
-0.0270811934,
-0.0769892856,
-0.0200036131,
0.0417538062,
0.0316464938,
0.0188389085,
0.0525293723,
0.0143424869,
0.0420318693,
-0.0162958559,
0.0026090844,
0.0092000859,
0.0444358513,
0.0084828213,
0.0097527523,
-0.0045871469,
-0.0081449281,
-0.0216829609,
-0.001177443,
0.0289243683,
-0.0545118265,
0.0067657153,
0.0437670946,
2.888e-7,
0.0771364793,
0.0611571036,
0.0074605728,
0.0121280877,
-0.0002830885,
0.024487095,
-0.0411063693,
-0.0419130176,
0.0421862863,
-0.000110923,
-0.0064948248,
0.0553523749,
0.0405612625,
0.0432804786,
-0.0476734266,
-0.0153890569,
-0.0517489836,
-0.0455063432,
-0.0549369343,
0.0084489807,
0.0739557669,
0.0782210678,
0.0391315073,
-0.007229168,
0.0001877629,
-0.0612782389,
0.0353591517,
-0.0226732455,
0.014274694,
0.0188347567,
-0.0139477216,
0.0068158805,
0.0231716782,
0.0486970767,
0.0086104563,
0.0061352407,
0.0272862911,
0.0623831823,
0.003296525,
-0.0005987807,
-0.0402436368,
-0.0350830778,
0.003337756,
-0.064011462,
0.0930495113,
-0.0417370684,
-0.050540939,
0.0129096005,
-0.0358686671,
-0.0299918409,
0.0200603642,
0.023878254,
0.0198890157,
0.0087698316,
-0.0096837757,
-0.0108156689,
-0.0038599921,
-0.0693689138,
-0.016335601,
0.0153768845,
-0.0451127626,
-0.0368793681,
-0.0287030581,
0.0072842077,
0.0128226103,
-0.0736640096,
-0.0208312571,
2.998675757e-34,
0.0434728786,
-0.0060624513,
0.0438413434,
0.0205122549,
0.0652951598,
0.0081278617,
-0.0548738837,
0.0036573492,
-0.0121190809,
-0.0911937654,
-0.0189738404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14377v1 | How Can Large Language Models Help Humans in Design and Manufacturing? | 2023-07-25T17:30:38 | 2023-07-25T17:30:38 | Liane Makatura, Michael Foshey, Bohan Wang, Felix HähnLein, Pingchuan Ma, Bolei Deng, Megan Tjandrasuwita, Andrew Spielberg, Crystal Elaine Owens, Peter Yichen Chen, Allan Zhao, Amy Zhu, Wil J Norton, Edward Gu, Joshua Jacob, Yifei Li, Adriana Schulz, Wojciech Matusik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs), including GPT-4, provides
exciting new opportunities for generative design. We investigate the
application of this tool across the entire design and manufacturing workflow.
Specifically, we scrutinize the utility of LLMs in tasks such as: converting a
text-based prompt into a design specification, transforming a design into
manufacturing instructions, producing a design space and design variations,
computing the performance of a design, and searching for designs predicated on
performance. Through a series of examples, we highlight both the benefits and
the limitations of the current LLMs. By exposing these limitations, we aspire
to catalyze the continued improvement and progression of these models. | [
-0.0067259041,
0.0616635531,
-0.0642991662,
0.0278009064,
-0.0584333502,
-0.020661138,
0.0362456553,
0.0003672231,
-0.0228730068,
0.0328940526,
-0.0397639014,
-0.0274053663,
-0.0013533985,
0.0372771025,
0.0377921462,
-0.0175402034,
-0.0132482033,
-0.0527342446,
-0.0158892851,
0.0082990974,
-0.0304721985,
0.0013221075,
-0.0096789431,
0.0609636642,
-0.0156238908,
-0.0009242531,
-0.0322610475,
0.0182400439,
0.00835736,
0.0130356858,
-0.0124708796,
0.0964309275,
0.0232033432,
0.0589558408,
0.0000021379,
-0.000955254,
0.0550567731,
0.0059474031,
-0.0038084013,
0.0299058482,
0.0495960861,
-0.021507822,
-0.0685160682,
-0.0010770123,
0.0173390433,
-0.0325582661,
0.0429084152,
0.0263974592,
0.0161147509,
0.0052447552,
-0.0106891366,
-0.031602934,
0.0285125468,
-0.0182273034,
-0.0019428654,
0.016839169,
-0.022385478,
0.0125958025,
0.1090885624,
0.0286463834,
0.0051773204,
0.0505553447,
0.0497993007,
-0.0295765009,
0.0009486534,
0.0331492275,
0.0124020502,
0.0048659113,
-0.0020377263,
0.0584121831,
-0.0189074259,
0.0014595513,
0.0024057874,
-0.0412894189,
-0.0088452203,
0.0102542499,
-0.0440765135,
0.0062225377,
-0.0179313533,
-0.0113374004,
-0.0429983363,
-0.0334268287,
0.0007556283,
-0.0367428064,
0.0249122344,
0.0525247343,
0.043978028,
0.0042238222,
-0.0313734673,
-0.0173218697,
-0.0198218469,
-0.045323547,
-0.009224805,
0.0121641131,
-0.0331547149,
-0.0147578744,
0.0056189168,
0.0052542808,
0.0132234944,
-0.0486562662,
0.0534840822,
0.0224060044,
0.0124783982,
0.0015202742,
-0.0739873797,
0.048945155,
-0.0540702753,
-0.0246335305,
-0.0985553861,
0.0263758283,
-0.0276966579,
-0.0532654896,
-0.0810276642,
-0.0292044692,
-0.102740027,
-0.028666636,
-0.0281675253,
0.070324026,
-0.0213034023,
-0.000879122,
0.0305779707,
0.0013885222,
0.0008322943,
-0.0565800332,
-0.0250966605,
-0.014326632,
-0.001552775,
0.0360744558,
-0.0181982424,
-0.0511309281,
0.0233630985,
0.0243923496,
-0.0267390944,
-0.0078311004,
-0.0265162103,
0.1166097075,
-0.0351323299,
0.049754519,
-0.0104544815,
-0.0209889896,
0.0126597127,
-0.0481702536,
-0.0055066198,
-0.0408418812,
0.0034406886,
-0.007920865,
-0.0050118039,
-0.0268969946,
-0.0042750114,
0.0058667245,
0.0241758619,
0.0404987298,
0.0053432491,
0.0582030602,
0.0068427799,
-0.0245157667,
0.0161342565,
0.0530827492,
0.0427110381,
0.0721174628,
-0.0114703206,
-0.0356551893,
0.0243578181,
0.0580315143,
-0.0328363553,
-0.0126145352,
-0.0237494931,
-0.0092099756,
0.0284765735,
0.0069804825,
0.012922938,
0.0040802835,
-0.0060779839,
0.0522998534,
0.0835505798,
0.0327940024,
0.0416189469,
0.0491757393,
0.0345472209,
0.0229045972,
-0.021625977,
-0.0457049459,
0.0061223689,
0.0114859603,
-0.0179900248,
0.0070684105,
-0.0286241993,
0.0200900361,
-0.0200489201,
-0.0160406232,
0.0187917892,
-0.0080228662,
-0.0018193164,
-0.0110724447,
0.0338378176,
-0.0214710142,
-0.058864288,
0.0085247224,
-0.0116467644,
-0.0482022837,
-0.071840629,
-0.0505104437,
0.00957873,
0.110914059,
0.0256272573,
0.0012525914,
-0.0184288695,
0.0299740192,
-0.0109817497,
0.0418146662,
0.0445522703,
-0.0145761678,
-0.0309090428,
0.0061117923,
-0.0195489302,
-0.000781442,
0.0071876422,
0.0327497646,
-0.0115953842,
-0.030872751,
0.0152476113,
0.0188115407,
-0.0515459254,
-0.0010949327,
-0.0265972,
-0.0093828849,
0.0246073846,
0.0039958311,
0.0120671876,
0.0204731859,
-0.0259005986,
0.0014461696,
0.0308722444,
-0.072526373,
-0.0058090766,
0.0296991393,
-0.0109642018,
0.0458933488,
-0.0110527929,
-0.0225309581,
0.0024018185,
-0.0295461416,
-0.0179593861,
-0.0425056592,
0.0299786478,
-0.0407790281,
0.0342909172,
-0.0015745675,
-0.0018408535,
-0.0246412549,
-0.0335537791,
-0.0534614697,
0.0492003709,
0.0228327978,
-0.0065967329,
-0.0162580069,
0.0611708462,
0.0311839879,
-0.0302187279,
-0.0111778593,
0.0864904895,
0.0250546262,
0.0381984189,
0.0567009933,
0.0243624877,
-0.0157941096,
-0.0268203709,
-0.0789570361,
-0.0134060076,
0.0256990269,
0.034107279,
0.0120943831,
-0.0165087469,
-0.0172954686,
0.0454806201,
-0.0086628394,
0.0337951183,
0.0085961353,
-0.0035267156,
0.0163212027,
0.0194938853,
-0.0604680963,
0.0204627737,
-0.0147828646,
-0.0017302053,
0.005545509,
0.044706028,
0.0090029556,
-0.1081880629,
0.0686223954,
0.034669131,
-0.0031152421,
0.0241262019,
-0.0428718701,
0.0193157587,
-0.0278906897,
0.08332178,
0.0221631527,
-0.0320412964,
0.0298022442,
0.0300007146,
-0.0367372632,
-0.0471723005,
0.025134597,
-0.0063502607,
-0.0272137858,
0.0364099406,
-0.0230872296,
-0.0012335596,
0.024672199,
-0.0085671423,
-0.0047665788,
-0.063729994,
0.0400086381,
0.0123587921,
-0.0211844929,
-0.0165522471,
0.0020200275,
0.0049140267,
0.0834333301,
-0.0388339795,
-0.0636933818,
0.0325241946,
-0.0138479024,
0.0151889138,
0.015179106,
-0.0003706383,
-0.0103285508,
0.0773421824,
0.0147116315,
-0.0079268487,
-0.0119375614,
0.0045597982,
-0.0226577893,
0.0616480224,
-0.0010354872,
0.0083402898,
0.0263513196,
-0.0849737525,
0.0238245949,
-0.0322663337,
-0.0677710623,
-0.0312790759,
0.0586389415,
-0.0374364518,
0.0233075656,
0.0302219372,
-0.0105841309,
-0.0089116991,
0.0655866116,
0.0283854157,
0.0231047142,
0.0045733475,
0.000587681,
-0.039541468,
0.0048616147,
0.001943947,
0.0189399291,
-0.0212968998,
-0.008555254,
-0.0380041189,
0.0304869842,
-0.0118621159,
0.0349062383,
-0.06176975,
-0.0058056857,
0.0563534498,
0.0455985963,
-0.0218450055,
0.0016989305,
0.0297687948,
-0.0398273356,
-0.0106058177,
0.0367456786,
-0.0026834921,
-0.0168759394,
0.0321409367,
0.0217537358,
0.0765089542,
-0.0062406054,
0.0403744131,
-0.0548062138,
-0.0088745421,
-0.0143090161,
0.0032730943,
-0.034398444,
-0.0044298535,
0.0082410602,
-0.112712197,
0.0805456936,
0.0091846818,
-0.0632149279,
-0.0371629335,
0.0034581274,
-0.0037236591,
0.0278152842,
-0.0061067548,
0.0381585807,
-0.0017310246,
-0.0013388325,
0.0238638707,
-0.0280320551,
-0.089889206,
0.0182609316,
0.0371111967,
-0.006304421,
0.0813075975,
0.0024793283,
0.011907178,
-0.05666475,
0.0587672703,
0.0174880344,
0.0172911324,
-0.0321338475,
-0.0315308943,
0.0808793157,
-0.0405898355,
-0.0536103211,
0.0014779605,
-0.0492928438,
-0.0187955946,
0.0037973563,
0.0656105801,
0.0038878568,
-0.0170308575,
-0.0321441405,
-0.0619399026,
0.0133761689,
0.0072475262,
0.0004570972,
-0.0609949008,
-0.068719767,
-0.0835593939,
-0.0099669741,
-0.0696541071,
-0.0509226769,
-0.0259064641,
0.0004290298,
-0.0483984388,
-0.0128202569,
0.0363276713,
0.0039111902,
0.028627554,
0.0150419539,
-0.0612502843,
0.0079397717,
0.0102005685,
-0.0396901481,
-0.0117185442,
-0.0131509192,
0.0411943682,
-0.0591044538,
-0.0296892449,
0.0149447601,
-0.0415513553,
-0.0093918974,
0.060365919,
-0.0505677052,
-0.0636010394,
-0.0119674876,
0.066468969,
0.0257028323,
-0.0427440517,
-0.0065459032,
-0.0456460714,
-0.0003891218,
0.0541124642,
-0.00105541,
0.004331138,
-0.007964747,
0.0137402751,
0.0023831499,
-0.0277913753,
0.0032491104,
0.0431641713,
0.0395295583,
0.0092607792,
0.0341667049,
-0.0331535004,
0.0155348219,
0.0596136674,
-0.0444827676,
-0.0291332733,
0.0415269956,
-0.0378185436,
0.0378985927,
-0.0237369705,
-0.0188944358,
-0.0381117277,
0.0050266557,
-0.0069254581,
-0.0622571856,
0.0276662409,
-0.024950888,
-0.0071403384,
0.0686678961,
-0.0477288067,
0.0638591126,
0.0052533308,
0.0569701828,
0.0527474992,
-0.0076576644,
0.0078643933,
0.0310096908,
-0.0559193753,
0.0539009161,
0.0062222276,
0.0003915773,
0.0282285269,
0.0011862032,
-0.0172674973,
0.071212396,
-0.0163770616,
-0.0992228612,
-0.070551537,
0.0126830162,
0.0478175022,
0.0368657447,
0.0207511727,
-0.0633043498,
-0.0256424602,
-0.0306602921,
0.0493611246,
0.0121518765,
-0.0024215246,
-0.0412602983,
0.0342059992,
0.0163921211,
-0.1265493929,
0.040016219,
-0.0063051744,
-0.0043599652,
-0.0251754187,
-0.0498706587,
-0.0472175628,
-0.0126020666,
0.0288677216,
-0.0103761237,
-0.0060055903,
0.0104360618,
-0.084103778,
-0.0398055576,
-0.0267878175,
0.0602427758,
0.0373595543,
-0.0021923927,
0.0378232561,
0.0673562139,
-0.0174258463,
-0.039002724,
0.0056560594,
0.0047353939,
-0.020837089,
0.0085647535,
-0.03719908,
-5.882910987e-33,
-0.0280502681,
-0.031587664,
0.0411900952,
0.0204608906,
0.0004402535,
-0.0278828871,
-0.037657477,
0.019105237,
0.05835611,
0.0087043587,
-0.003521271,
-0.0590854734,
-0.0242076535,
-0.0069933697,
0.0679275542,
0.016855672,
0.0675348639,
0.0318935141,
-0.0557923801,
0.0389871784,
-0.0147433076,
-0.0072014639,
0.0129584651,
-0.0332045332,
-0.014316516,
-0.0079012401,
-0.0190682001,
-0.01610424,
-0.0064870957,
0.020437533,
-0.0304549392,
0.0506329089,
-0.0043452247,
-0.0143585624,
-0.0238845479,
0.0288221203,
-0.0421071276,
-0.0293298587,
0.0219270103,
-0.0043117474,
0.0124195972,
-0.0649116263,
0.0090244999,
0.0121004879,
-0.0874180421,
0.0232142117,
-0.0072612385,
-0.0400453992,
-0.0019993247,
0.0166024808,
-0.1039971411,
0.002979097,
0.0284696631,
-0.0027313156,
0.0302078929,
-0.012706425,
-0.0250887126,
0.0074399454,
-0.0121190706,
0.052467566,
0.0719076619,
0.0040587531,
0.0836687312,
0.0172974076,
0.0290392134,
-0.0193678718,
0.0157366097,
0.0333235785,
-0.0195498802,
-0.006089964,
-0.0124597028,
0.0721202269,
0.0107974783,
0.0201659482,
0.0116155911,
-0.0082535325,
-0.0352835804,
0.0351432189,
-0.0444151014,
0.0537479371,
0.0575921051,
0.051453989,
0.0280362926,
-0.0253918394,
0.0007352325,
0.0115941484,
-0.0123100756,
-0.001931011,
-0.0115112271,
0.0174057558,
-0.0102266259,
-0.0213076063,
0.0221231319,
-0.0139352391,
0.0013005966,
-0.0333799832,
-0.033406429,
0.0092636906,
0.0009009678,
0.0004045581,
-0.0271676611,
-0.04489474,
-0.0348788947,
0.0440814272,
0.0186508466,
-0.020714635,
-0.0442525744,
0.0282372739,
-0.0423417315,
0.0295582544,
-0.058722958,
0.0140273087,
0.0169203095,
-0.0223622993,
0.0166266374,
-0.0099817589,
0.0070536295,
-0.0345762335,
-0.0176164228,
-0.0586004928,
-0.0143509591,
0.0474462621,
-0.0349972919,
0.0031325619,
-0.0125642689,
0.0169761237,
-0.0246733595,
0.0593741275,
0.0577395558,
-0.0513440557,
-0.0349958837,
0.0190647412,
2.938e-7,
0.0192090441,
0.025465183,
-0.004852959,
0.0683849603,
0.0490175039,
0.0214949884,
0.000317744,
0.0163325276,
0.0022585355,
0.0110196453,
0.0184264816,
0.0385934785,
0.0427737646,
-0.0277123675,
-0.0553122163,
0.0235979035,
0.0044295122,
0.0453738384,
-0.0458369255,
0.0221633203,
0.0599790514,
0.0415185094,
-0.0163538139,
-0.0237414483,
0.0041472656,
0.0244760569,
0.0071225469,
-0.0555056222,
0.045408234,
0.0050426158,
0.0117069818,
-0.0200864449,
-0.0336074643,
0.0211531334,
0.0225350484,
-0.0418869033,
0.0013505479,
0.0634869784,
0.008663361,
0.0277764481,
0.0237198845,
-0.0109320125,
-0.0224379469,
-0.0483658202,
-0.0008926861,
-0.0620693713,
0.0054583685,
-0.0252057053,
0.0139887724,
-0.0094030323,
-0.0285118632,
-0.0122944443,
0.018432349,
0.0058783325,
-0.0031718728,
-0.0140336286,
0.0290296413,
-0.0077743195,
0.0075417743,
0.0259806123,
-0.0826231018,
-0.0734903663,
-0.0429628938,
0.0154704871,
0.0069099236,
0.0213623326,
0.0252170973,
2.243685812e-34,
0.0305038169,
0.0254443604,
0.0344722494,
0.0890375003,
0.0393108353,
0.0252985563,
0.0120489318,
0.0195075367,
0.0156334341,
-0.0694803447,
-0.028392097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13655v1 | A Comprehensive Evaluation and Analysis Study for Chinese Spelling Check | 2023-07-25T17:02:38 | 2023-07-25T17:02:38 | Xunjian Yin, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the development of pre-trained models and the incorporation of phonetic
and graphic information, neural models have achieved high scores in Chinese
Spelling Check (CSC). However, it does not provide a comprehensive reflection
of the models' capability due to the limited test sets. In this study, we
abstract the representative model paradigm, implement it with nine structures
and experiment them on comprehensive test sets we constructed with different
purposes. We perform a detailed analysis of the results and find that: 1)
Fusing phonetic and graphic information reasonably is effective for CSC. 2)
Models are sensitive to the error distribution of the test set, which reflects
the shortcomings of models and reveals the direction we should work on. 3)
Whether or not the errors and contexts have been seen has a significant impact
on models. 4) The commonly used benchmark, SIGHAN, can not reliably evaluate
models' performance. | [
0.018944012,
0.0118628563,
0.0167757701,
0.0169905368,
-0.0152395759,
0.0112615656,
0.0037277285,
0.0091930097,
0.0299968179,
-0.025610622,
-0.0565109886,
-0.0752034783,
0.0612432696,
-0.0067910641,
0.0530352965,
-0.042035725,
0.0386448465,
-0.0099302176,
0.0004979675,
0.0046715401,
0.0215604417,
-0.0210530609,
-0.0186343212,
0.0531351268,
-0.0449666046,
-0.0010999993,
-0.0008814923,
0.0350531451,
0.0092629669,
-0.0218770467,
0.0020442221,
0.0628456548,
-0.0526188873,
0.0368454941,
0.0000018707,
-0.0428816304,
0.0152466074,
0.0026281364,
-0.0084904414,
0.0385720432,
0.0289346129,
0.0043820865,
-0.0768905506,
0.0344130434,
0.0110033778,
-0.0233427435,
0.0813418329,
0.0544229485,
0.0565055273,
0.0570751242,
-0.0225733928,
-0.0171736982,
0.0568137541,
-0.0143863196,
-0.0130584473,
-0.0094877994,
0.042051293,
-0.0100717293,
0.0011128094,
-0.076438345,
-0.0446523391,
0.0382880084,
-0.0237474274,
-0.0077434406,
-0.0282373484,
0.0058829891,
0.0213436186,
-0.0143403001,
-0.0133355558,
0.0602957644,
-0.0560479984,
-0.0110464776,
-0.0334090739,
-0.0131316073,
-0.0060283286,
0.0077805286,
0.0133420853,
0.0144760944,
-0.0239633434,
0.0032641971,
0.038136363,
0.0015106201,
0.0378404111,
0.0260359943,
-0.0128763635,
-0.0006140505,
0.0319156423,
-0.0868849307,
-0.0009844904,
0.0175945982,
0.0454878099,
-0.040713612,
0.0255988035,
0.0359236114,
-0.0065492201,
0.0092367046,
0.0057710223,
-0.0480047688,
-0.0120639009,
-0.0344943181,
0.0482196435,
0.0121474219,
-0.0621987581,
0.0035473262,
-0.0538498424,
0.0901272893,
0.0196246561,
0.0286276881,
-0.0129122529,
0.0090477485,
-0.0292308144,
0.0001085686,
-0.0468356237,
0.0553380921,
0.0160841532,
-0.0085825166,
-0.0742238835,
-0.0268132724,
-0.0226152372,
0.0025304607,
0.0569592379,
-0.0197456107,
-0.0024865633,
0.0132893967,
-0.0204005092,
-0.008834294,
0.0104963602,
0.0053018262,
-0.0189719722,
-0.0233794618,
0.0372865051,
0.0091672624,
0.0152742956,
-0.0077616815,
0.0428803265,
0.0434719659,
-0.0049964916,
-0.0409822091,
-0.0208242107,
0.0332825966,
-0.0333268084,
-0.0386814252,
-0.017899543,
-0.0392240584,
-0.0047566509,
-0.0606595799,
0.0730873495,
-0.0248701666,
-0.0085171545,
0.0007629402,
-0.0027211013,
0.0942933261,
-0.0111255897,
0.0082907025,
-0.0015761635,
-0.0019407908,
0.0607587136,
0.0228543039,
0.0195452832,
-0.010874236,
0.0344381705,
-0.0221078787,
0.0455675945,
0.0484911352,
-0.0447643958,
-0.0389297009,
-0.0127512226,
-0.0548188016,
-0.0114683853,
0.0247230772,
-0.0187328309,
0.1064158902,
-0.0200850535,
0.0089221131,
0.0660904869,
0.0402144417,
0.0899233744,
-0.0088806171,
0.0210867207,
-0.0600591563,
0.0538263582,
0.0266918559,
-0.0367717035,
-0.0076349201,
-0.0551502667,
0.0567278415,
0.0064633866,
0.0107951453,
-0.0671242699,
-0.0798678696,
-0.0422358476,
-0.0246484242,
0.0085158143,
-0.0054338994,
0.036403276,
0.0225342698,
-0.0509096533,
-0.0198216364,
-0.0223028921,
-0.0440698043,
0.0097078215,
-0.0402781479,
0.0341437832,
0.0965564772,
0.0849010199,
0.0070322319,
-0.0204356238,
0.0154690733,
-0.0720282048,
0.0517555475,
0.0363181569,
-0.0125862975,
0.0022019118,
-0.0575329177,
-0.0184401423,
0.0615654737,
0.0116784917,
0.0117709367,
0.0361901261,
0.0234533679,
-0.0114536602,
0.00002591,
-0.0724233091,
0.0369947031,
-0.0073374026,
-0.0301551875,
-0.0255559124,
0.0110633057,
0.0128673268,
0.0178866144,
-0.0542664006,
0.0209063068,
-0.0178097114,
-0.0322158672,
-0.0055575846,
-0.0197716746,
-0.0467305966,
-0.0298511405,
0.0687864125,
-0.0464154519,
-0.0101222778,
0.0485295877,
-0.0072670048,
-0.0486210883,
-0.0548445955,
-0.0300130267,
-0.0025633697,
-0.0948615596,
0.0518919379,
0.010365081,
0.0023973915,
-0.0084704449,
0.0317946114,
-0.0193872955,
0.0139344893,
-0.0067359991,
0.064742133,
0.000756996,
-0.0668630973,
-0.1115173474,
0.0031427362,
0.0005727701,
0.0506450608,
-0.0009872115,
0.0517580919,
-0.0054974449,
-0.0100809354,
-0.0426300801,
-0.0285109766,
-0.0250202864,
-0.0214309059,
0.0101264603,
-0.0228378568,
-0.0088982349,
-0.0189830568,
-0.0414435603,
0.0434322245,
0.0128781404,
-0.0088902684,
0.0617358275,
-0.0255494155,
-0.0093438011,
-0.0668079257,
-0.0392902642,
-0.0270748064,
0.0043474818,
0.0200821385,
-0.0829612687,
-0.0573585257,
0.0570523106,
-0.0177156031,
0.0481092073,
0.0428953543,
-0.0789586604,
0.028186759,
-0.0464328639,
0.0384232588,
0.0038015305,
-0.0047383225,
-0.0164263695,
0.0223070048,
-0.012183358,
0.0279261041,
-0.001401191,
0.0079206852,
0.0057321806,
0.0208459627,
-0.0221423283,
-0.0167070795,
0.0730564371,
-0.0045749983,
-0.0221958831,
-0.0434631556,
-0.0251947809,
-0.0416633599,
0.0085797217,
-0.0463300943,
-0.0118808299,
-0.0178326443,
0.0089315549,
-0.0209873971,
-0.031768851,
0.065283902,
-0.0563071594,
0.0186293516,
-0.015787974,
0.0098286746,
-0.0120552862,
-0.0113590518,
-0.0150578516,
0.0006853247,
-0.011917457,
-0.041137509,
-0.0463520549,
-0.0034544892,
0.014565859,
-0.0596070252,
0.0184509363,
-0.0161423888,
0.0291871894,
0.0032878406,
-0.0017495791,
-0.0337803289,
0.0116124405,
-0.0377146788,
0.0136799328,
0.041866336,
-0.0051224981,
0.0624100678,
0.089546673,
-0.0156340189,
0.0654490665,
0.0090236748,
-0.0003325675,
0.0121587729,
0.010617407,
0.0029935543,
0.0152542731,
0.0248879753,
-0.0144731076,
0.0433367528,
0.008510326,
0.0153087312,
0.0035993659,
-0.0351770222,
-0.0036421523,
0.0135103613,
-0.0221150815,
0.0026152106,
0.0240918379,
-0.0030001223,
-0.0428581163,
-0.0240131672,
0.0880323425,
0.0221076217,
-0.0233583301,
-0.0412698574,
0.0625812858,
-0.0440633297,
-0.002769571,
0.0157439709,
-0.0513147973,
-0.0088357832,
0.0115650706,
-0.0232228134,
0.010658768,
-0.0060852533,
0.0242211372,
-0.1415296048,
0.0291987751,
0.0201161876,
-0.0119735198,
-0.059016481,
0.0258379094,
-0.0101875123,
-0.0272113066,
0.0254666824,
0.0053757518,
0.0002533126,
-0.0697260052,
0.0182399973,
-0.0654897019,
-0.0847680196,
0.0249381624,
-0.0666966364,
0.0048801564,
0.0627624169,
0.0115634929,
-0.0193604957,
-0.0573411956,
0.020608101,
0.0024646672,
0.0038999035,
0.0051676207,
0.0422638394,
0.0146344556,
-0.0413986705,
-0.0311947986,
-0.0282635037,
0.0080147777,
0.012994119,
-0.036238566,
0.0300251879,
-0.0145161236,
-0.0050417879,
0.0159481205,
0.0462353826,
-0.0156536531,
0.0567349568,
0.0277131852,
-0.0762146115,
-0.042749539,
0.0024824636,
0.0055134469,
-0.0726379529,
-0.0132529307,
0.0863091797,
-0.0425152332,
-0.0299328398,
-0.1160621867,
-0.0542302355,
-0.0162331332,
0.0406478047,
0.0359210595,
0.0255478937,
0.0233919136,
0.0097956723,
-0.008873417,
-0.0000654185,
0.0061034486,
0.0292537119,
-0.0799106434,
0.0108250752,
-0.0177177656,
-0.0344525911,
0.0173849799,
-0.0049836873,
-0.0329607464,
-0.0104878079,
0.0417599231,
0.0602691434,
0.0123744365,
0.0020411767,
-0.0747660771,
-0.0695235729,
0.0495357625,
-0.0033168748,
0.0407103188,
-0.0117776813,
0.0184778385,
-0.0691404343,
-0.0164286233,
-0.0242193863,
-0.0113892937,
0.026466867,
0.003490054,
0.0367209278,
-0.0133025246,
-0.0088008959,
0.0407982357,
0.037730854,
0.0447696224,
-0.0381564796,
-0.000729572,
-0.0742620975,
0.0161501858,
0.0245990995,
-0.0012884273,
0.0100956606,
-0.0373210795,
0.0225499608,
0.0151173957,
-0.0196168423,
-0.0250677504,
-0.0268417392,
-0.0234935563,
-0.0048230663,
0.0013096004,
0.0229789726,
0.0432337038,
-0.0011923951,
0.0192556549,
-0.0059404536,
0.0486890674,
0.0150916222,
0.0044258172,
0.0207712241,
0.0095070181,
-0.0080704298,
0.0270334631,
0.017939005,
0.0475366451,
0.0001906617,
0.041488599,
-0.0390035659,
-0.0175043382,
0.1081033796,
-0.0120185213,
-0.0013652877,
-0.0343936495,
0.0110871801,
-0.0505959392,
-0.0147825498,
-0.0125122797,
0.0116408812,
0.0246120337,
0.0143668419,
0.0321639255,
-0.0626707673,
0.0401447043,
0.014394002,
0.021239778,
-0.011114385,
-0.0298364703,
-0.0294555984,
0.0001562136,
-0.0114284251,
-0.0081861475,
-0.0657821819,
-0.0328541473,
-0.0459840149,
-0.0949837491,
0.0250318442,
0.0577914417,
0.0349136554,
0.0612535849,
-0.0008910691,
0.0015173953,
0.0375147238,
0.0628283992,
-0.0195155479,
-0.0504516885,
-0.001613659,
0.0040854756,
0.0298776738,
-5.710021482e-33,
-0.0365333408,
-0.0060983403,
0.0427844599,
-0.0391579121,
0.0076605785,
0.0085342964,
-0.0204222035,
-0.0196304843,
-0.0369493254,
0.0040038158,
-0.0312702768,
0.0145462519,
0.0286483411,
0.0085545247,
-0.0053700586,
0.0159868337,
0.0305419676,
0.0137316165,
0.0231189728,
-0.0650712252,
0.0217702612,
0.0528272986,
0.0736619905,
-0.0290857442,
0.0158718526,
0.0239385739,
-0.0108928513,
-0.0135403173,
-0.0171745475,
0.0678657666,
-0.0114099551,
0.0277799405,
0.0211483594,
0.0227969103,
0.0016972428,
0.0016985852,
-0.0999054462,
-0.0240360294,
-0.0052794274,
0.0685976222,
-0.0142791718,
0.0176921505,
0.0406442694,
-0.0244827271,
-0.0325821042,
0.0174522307,
0.0294770114,
-0.0293043368,
0.0182184931,
-0.0143006155,
-0.042261038,
0.0256741606,
0.0652727261,
-0.0104520181,
0.0010587189,
0.0102990912,
-0.0592241213,
-0.0072891079,
-0.0856304765,
0.0265894216,
0.0682183504,
0.0341288708,
0.0225047711,
0.0339642242,
-0.0257864818,
-0.003799502,
0.0192876179,
-0.0196972601,
-0.0089150025,
0.0072000842,
0.0803026482,
-0.0195848718,
0.1171824634,
0.0404920168,
0.0348942503,
-0.0307358429,
-0.0414741598,
0.0329196826,
0.013889512,
0.0056078034,
0.0026697125,
-0.0277759843,
-0.0568706021,
-0.0326368138,
0.0126442006,
0.0082778959,
-0.0326370038,
-0.0052814637,
0.0555387884,
0.0352417417,
0.0210283231,
0.0087978775,
0.0112484964,
-0.0343571603,
0.0172314737,
-0.0082397684,
0.0370698646,
0.0127452975,
-0.0333980098,
0.0060577411,
-0.03700215,
-0.0526704751,
0.0119659556,
0.0277014971,
-0.0056856014,
0.0046723075,
0.0442695133,
0.0564797856,
-0.067964606,
0.0084403846,
0.0011067296,
0.0124279996,
0.062942706,
-0.0157441795,
0.0251852758,
-0.0213448405,
-0.0013207089,
0.0109486459,
0.0174776744,
-0.0058053988,
0.0069787605,
-0.0339276195,
-0.0042788037,
0.0195492562,
0.0028638362,
0.0174917262,
-0.0236976631,
0.0289600734,
0.0186198391,
-0.0392967053,
0.0039481092,
0.0517941229,
2.528e-7,
0.0430150405,
0.013447945,
0.0528951474,
0.0268497691,
-0.0092293015,
-0.0274705086,
-0.080885835,
-0.0238976423,
-0.0299647003,
0.0482481271,
0.0553448498,
-0.013663929,
0.0658403412,
0.0153401103,
-0.0339218155,
-0.0480415262,
-0.0361696817,
0.0359052271,
0.0059005967,
0.0387777761,
0.0172308385,
0.0574783944,
-0.0217085183,
-0.0426753163,
-0.0157241803,
-0.0479222052,
0.0293380935,
0.0210116841,
0.004134242,
-0.0092024822,
0.0535305291,
0.0550707914,
0.0176934805,
0.0462661311,
-0.0354568809,
0.0192574356,
0.0651189759,
-0.0190424751,
-0.0283468235,
0.0084907915,
0.0218865387,
0.0333010703,
-0.0317389406,
-0.0338600278,
0.0424898975,
0.0089181084,
0.0400451012,
-0.004607664,
-0.01325271,
-0.0058129039,
0.0267591588,
-0.05519633,
-0.0146882283,
0.0210900009,
0.036988005,
-0.0002378761,
-0.0277243089,
-0.0357265286,
-0.0186781138,
0.0494376794,
0.035208866,
-0.0204558969,
-0.0105820661,
-0.043806728,
0.0238824263,
-0.0341181271,
-0.028420249,
2.0405147e-34,
0.0049001519,
-0.031601347,
0.0233938396,
-0.0086573428,
0.0132058486,
-0.003920143,
-0.0058478923,
-0.0184138119,
-0.0075796237,
-0.0446394347,
-0.0408218689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13631v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13631v1 | Contributions to the Improvement of Question Answering Systems in the Biomedical Domain | 2023-07-25T16:31:20 | 2023-07-25T16:31:20 | Mourad Sarrouti | cs.CL | cs.CL | This thesis work falls within the framework of question answering (QA) in the
biomedical domain where several specific challenges are addressed, such as
specialized lexicons and terminologies, the types of treated questions, and the
characteristics of targeted documents. We are particularly interested in
studying and improving methods that aim at finding accurate and short answers
to biomedical natural language questions from a large scale of biomedical
textual documents in English. QA aims at providing inquirers with direct, short
and precise answers to their natural language questions. In this Ph.D. thesis,
we propose four contributions to improve the performance of QA in the
biomedical domain. In our first contribution, we propose a machine
learning-based method for question type classification to determine the types
of given questions which enable to a biomedical QA system to use the
appropriate answer extraction method. We also propose an another machine
learning-based method to assign one or more topics (e.g., pharmacological,
test, treatment, etc.) to given questions in order to determine the semantic
types of the expected answers which are very useful in generating specific
answer retrieval strategies. In the second contribution, we first propose a
document retrieval method to retrieve a set of relevant documents that are
likely to contain the answers to biomedical questions from the MEDLINE
database. We then present a passage retrieval method to retrieve a set of
relevant passages to questions. In the third contribution, we propose specific
answer extraction methods to generate both exact and ideal answers. Finally, in
the fourth contribution, we develop a fully automated semantic biomedical QA
system called SemBioNLQA which is able to deal with a variety of natural
language questions and to generate appropriate answers by providing both exact
and ideal answers. | [
0.0765371844,
-0.0295311064,
0.0014623917,
-0.0012840027,
-0.0465865247,
0.0037895206,
-0.0064112134,
0.0492460169,
0.0108230272,
-0.0396338031,
0.0184743982,
-0.0165217407,
-0.0221737493,
0.0260354485,
0.0099153649,
-0.0396407619,
0.0194209684,
0.0423369445,
0.0056120227,
0.007092298,
0.0126659246,
0.0137448236,
-0.0231672283,
0.0357875153,
0.0416582227,
-0.0229679327,
0.0156260431,
-0.0430264361,
0.0014080106,
-0.0506477877,
0.0247067604,
0.005000934,
-0.0312961638,
-0.0585590601,
0.0000015864,
-0.0805489644,
-0.0391038246,
0.036217209,
-0.0250305366,
-0.0403165407,
0.0082615847,
-0.0074827652,
0.0430323333,
0.0419447981,
-0.0444543473,
0.0029511726,
0.025162803,
0.0297120828,
0.0394943953,
0.0372729413,
-0.0041347081,
-0.0253025293,
0.0401128493,
0.0391520299,
0.0590063855,
-0.0339655094,
0.0544168651,
-0.0043289228,
0.0797609091,
0.023386173,
0.0309556816,
0.0429478362,
-0.0359293036,
0.0192930028,
0.0554795973,
0.0151290521,
-0.02551434,
-0.0158354826,
-0.0000193515,
0.0400900356,
0.0412546173,
-0.0238560718,
0.0231984966,
0.024597805,
-0.0224312991,
0.0334437713,
-0.0228663441,
-0.0259876698,
-0.0637181252,
-0.0412428156,
0.0190440342,
-0.0030667195,
-0.0242393389,
-0.0025834478,
-0.0282474905,
0.009729065,
0.0190704707,
-0.0279688276,
0.0039963443,
-0.0351799317,
0.0187303182,
-0.0501180142,
0.0677178651,
0.0886538997,
-0.0046445113,
0.0145010166,
0.0172916353,
-0.0207609311,
0.0875888243,
-0.0789447278,
-0.0233600494,
-0.0118846847,
-0.010825227,
0.025946131,
-0.0118811745,
-0.0119998269,
-0.0261784494,
0.0251084082,
-0.0680364147,
-0.0164023414,
-0.0555799343,
-0.0331781544,
-0.0587785654,
0.059689533,
0.0033900333,
0.0155904731,
-0.0593338534,
-0.0011759865,
0.0311475806,
-0.0277160443,
-0.0116395298,
0.0773255676,
-0.0355347693,
0.0101724742,
-0.0553145148,
-0.0000643163,
-0.0340343006,
-0.0061884322,
-0.0388745144,
-0.0418653563,
0.0244494844,
-0.0186390821,
0.0493020043,
-0.0061650211,
0.0415638499,
0.0600253306,
0.003277937,
-0.0187333245,
-0.026228426,
-0.0403992236,
-0.0089525823,
-0.0062336279,
-0.0395057052,
-0.0485142581,
0.0117233489,
0.047412876,
-0.0457831137,
0.0086295176,
0.014431959,
0.0321401842,
-0.0475895926,
0.0607355759,
-0.02335383,
0.0099318018,
0.0856988281,
0.0129680894,
0.011736976,
-0.0381800458,
0.002294237,
-0.0349558294,
0.0431319177,
-0.0213548839,
0.0373013616,
-0.0208827648,
0.030718293,
-0.0675677508,
0.0252412856,
0.0817732289,
0.0015014323,
0.0487871058,
-0.0697972625,
0.0875966102,
0.0230218638,
-0.0302028321,
-0.0285835564,
0.0916048437,
0.0156634897,
0.0050804289,
-0.0050483807,
-0.023799656,
0.0375259593,
0.0131893605,
0.0118110813,
-0.002903244,
0.0073403791,
0.0153849423,
-0.0082247527,
-0.0244131852,
-0.0234787054,
-0.0451781973,
-0.0433078632,
0.0153832119,
-0.0206124056,
0.013711852,
0.0339463875,
-0.0233117212,
-0.027059162,
0.0374779254,
0.0208340138,
-0.0010127295,
0.012711932,
-0.049156595,
0.0146026323,
0.013104938,
0.0257858876,
-0.0500884652,
-0.0123116039,
-0.0035649729,
-0.0260240398,
-0.0044186837,
-0.0023798821,
-0.0511189923,
0.0007765233,
-0.0133522376,
0.0374747738,
0.0280215051,
-0.0188094936,
-0.0302112736,
-0.005701412,
0.036210835,
-0.0241003856,
-0.0276790243,
-0.0151397446,
0.0562720895,
-0.0156942103,
-0.0645087361,
0.0111234188,
-0.0033272572,
0.0166556928,
0.0378018431,
0.006407666,
0.0553274602,
0.0409681313,
-0.0345478095,
-0.0435054712,
-0.0454754867,
0.0197562501,
-0.0188949313,
0.004609148,
-0.0232804324,
0.0031346509,
-0.0219447669,
-0.0201668348,
-0.0343245454,
-0.0387771688,
-0.0749413073,
-0.0074547278,
-0.0154318903,
-0.0167653635,
0.0236514434,
-0.0284349844,
-0.09901499,
0.0029379872,
0.0270181783,
0.0370925739,
0.0103029087,
-0.0608186759,
0.0306848511,
-0.0300170667,
0.0070239357,
0.0295586102,
-0.0188304596,
0.012233003,
0.0246922392,
-0.020731274,
-0.0405169539,
0.0053823795,
-0.0590796471,
0.0014975332,
0.01606071,
0.043170549,
0.0405027382,
0.0398876667,
0.0166076981,
-0.042558305,
-0.0716892481,
-0.002692586,
0.0466447659,
0.0151772872,
0.0637838095,
0.0623800866,
0.0240886919,
-0.0614266582,
-0.0068152486,
-0.034087263,
0.0164652597,
0.0172871966,
-0.016623294,
-0.0091100382,
-0.0215019006,
-0.0347007588,
0.0161191877,
0.031377811,
-0.0168829039,
0.0112446034,
0.0041741412,
-0.0380413793,
0.0664274693,
0.0442689024,
-0.0052838116,
0.0043963422,
0.0615777522,
-0.0263581276,
0.026960006,
-0.0655438751,
-0.0207140539,
0.0177719109,
-0.0576608032,
0.0472705215,
0.0363335535,
0.0469887033,
-0.0217449795,
-0.0005208435,
0.0271950606,
-0.0033744716,
0.0400817022,
-0.0713453591,
0.0099770091,
-0.0284585208,
0.0467127971,
0.0425540842,
-0.0129977688,
0.0939724147,
0.0278359335,
0.0089428816,
-0.1137563065,
-0.0485882163,
-0.0462674648,
0.0094105629,
-0.0232055355,
0.0378376618,
-0.0052145701,
-0.0111974496,
-0.0143220639,
-0.0272764917,
0.020786263,
-0.044808466,
0.0368951224,
-0.0125022288,
0.0433683954,
-0.0123798475,
-0.0409126729,
-0.0644912496,
-0.0026500244,
-0.0042436128,
-0.0047204588,
0.0041879276,
0.0354452543,
-0.0117736338,
0.0402391665,
-0.0034172712,
0.0123533681,
-0.0229728725,
-0.0272065867,
-0.0014692029,
0.05689767,
0.0548971072,
-0.0118777743,
0.0143389702,
0.0524402335,
0.0226199534,
0.0830961242,
-0.0313244164,
0.0275807865,
0.0341305621,
-0.0101942485,
0.0123313824,
-0.0858235508,
0.0061601303,
0.0340945199,
-0.002483631,
-0.0513715371,
-0.0072330511,
0.0817572773,
0.0840944052,
-0.0139022851,
-0.0022119859,
-0.0416648164,
-0.0774721652,
-0.0143496208,
0.0832602829,
-0.0492550433,
-0.002874244,
-0.061495401,
0.044456359,
-0.0375096202,
0.005061883,
-0.00651237,
-0.0215625688,
0.0138892885,
-0.0352724083,
-0.0652095228,
-0.0279863458,
-0.0584779494,
-0.0266108606,
0.0068604583,
-0.0346153043,
0.0232668929,
-0.0243976042,
0.0034855809,
0.0268153325,
-0.0502502397,
-0.0141806034,
0.0287561752,
-0.0187407266,
-0.0133948186,
0.0426199473,
0.0354217365,
-0.0128401043,
-0.0116763823,
-0.0035833586,
-0.0731812865,
-0.012372314,
-0.0159147698,
0.0715390518,
0.0133227147,
0.0160854477,
-0.0571110174,
0.0571488105,
-0.0359746218,
0.0276751015,
0.0267631691,
0.0587591566,
-0.0455956087,
0.0013504494,
-0.0909429938,
0.0129098296,
-0.0175454672,
0.0466938391,
-0.0195563398,
-0.0039543747,
-0.0618113354,
-0.0016468995,
0.0388261564,
-0.0130255539,
-0.0186323412,
0.0057896725,
-0.0674513131,
0.0195418391,
-0.0725123435,
-0.0188930407,
0.0499493293,
0.0091981823,
0.0001833762,
0.0413665622,
0.0267424416,
0.0063992306,
-0.0646947548,
-0.0017465975,
0.0478953272,
-0.0121954568,
-0.0362365022,
-0.0467984341,
0.0723703429,
-0.0054773409,
-0.0296143834,
-0.0310665984,
0.0196958911,
-0.0236127544,
-0.0210508574,
0.0415887982,
0.0182658341,
-0.0258445106,
-0.0054617086,
-0.0308857765,
0.0455985218,
0.0195627511,
-0.0169137213,
-0.0402912199,
-0.0161548425,
0.0135270851,
-0.0320501477,
-0.0048448024,
-0.0533316657,
0.0229442194,
-0.0189892706,
0.0093672741,
0.0032129821,
-0.0408828184,
0.0806079805,
0.0574565642,
-0.0086946515,
0.0098676132,
-0.0144151961,
0.0087065864,
0.0211229678,
-0.0076698037,
-0.005108295,
0.001286268,
-0.0113913538,
0.0149819916,
-0.005801436,
-0.0110151721,
-0.0223921295,
-0.0942945853,
0.0146726361,
0.0095039681,
0.0326206535,
0.044616174,
0.0163150653,
0.025839163,
-0.0192295611,
-0.0230019707,
-0.0261586308,
0.013293298,
0.0546018332,
-0.0073421109,
0.0178831331,
-0.0029815603,
0.0189254079,
-0.0380262248,
0.0229272321,
-0.0693873242,
-0.04283382,
-0.0081888018,
0.0366503149,
-0.0008595726,
0.0079552345,
-0.0302521121,
0.0150027871,
-0.029103199,
-0.0157982316,
-0.011386021,
0.0041472055,
0.0457461774,
0.0853892639,
0.0192951541,
-0.0073628747,
-0.0305299331,
0.0495102853,
-0.0043911221,
0.0170311071,
0.0023519495,
-0.0753035322,
-0.0200840458,
-0.0123440009,
0.0114473598,
0.0109392479,
-0.0231504906,
0.0043778168,
-0.0485080704,
-0.0043099588,
0.0426673926,
0.009695136,
-0.0048387968,
-0.0308738314,
0.064557083,
0.051584132,
0.0738842413,
-0.0506615974,
-0.0557599179,
0.0872891322,
-0.0744488984,
-0.0207437873,
-0.0085542584,
-5.429713099e-33,
0.0203745812,
-0.0452289209,
0.0325432122,
0.0033110066,
0.0263584685,
0.0087047685,
-0.0155081628,
-0.0159152504,
-0.0246483739,
0.0311403759,
-0.037708573,
-0.0024238036,
0.0044069071,
0.0213399548,
-0.0141068045,
-0.0504751876,
-0.0089192484,
-0.0124873994,
-0.0059965737,
0.0096349092,
0.0005257096,
0.0445467606,
0.0230356827,
-0.0308121331,
0.0147248944,
-0.0201543774,
0.0493985601,
0.0209035836,
0.0007266828,
0.0645652562,
-0.0260520093,
0.0336071737,
0.0531683043,
-0.0070665912,
0.0317612216,
0.045844622,
-0.0851146206,
-0.0359273963,
0.0052034911,
-0.031628143,
-0.0622320622,
-0.0031117795,
0.0456822701,
-0.0169122182,
-0.0097178202,
0.0010864506,
0.0519512109,
-0.0134918476,
-0.0126265781,
-0.0498819239,
-0.0320434496,
0.0150000984,
-0.0046508363,
-0.0071585597,
-0.0356522314,
0.0441068709,
-0.0429792143,
0.0330583975,
0.0350257382,
-0.0158016346,
0.0196337085,
0.0399994776,
-0.0181828085,
-0.0039798329,
-0.0239737835,
-0.0095703369,
0.0311190411,
-0.0287587214,
-0.0012569032,
0.0210464746,
-0.077911146,
0.0142017938,
0.0661420226,
0.0449600443,
0.0256432854,
0.037224859,
-0.0819278881,
0.0791795328,
-0.0275226403,
0.044251591,
-0.009680382,
-0.0348909833,
-0.0147818755,
-0.0051099909,
-0.015934296,
0.0509705506,
-0.0305687953,
-0.0225395523,
0.0294611156,
-0.060238529,
-0.0197367761,
0.0054545095,
0.0104872808,
-0.0219944436,
-0.0080954088,
-0.0205163136,
0.0190683305,
0.0052895537,
-0.009516377,
0.025838105,
-0.040603064,
0.0264595933,
0.001715589,
-0.0438095853,
0.0078173177,
0.0214749966,
-0.0434905402,
-0.0512194596,
-0.0312470738,
0.0056370017,
0.0230649877,
0.0077531999,
-0.0325717553,
0.0456017144,
-0.0163136497,
0.0598334,
0.0335846283,
0.0633723661,
-0.0047151777,
-0.0060502356,
-0.0386409201,
-0.055553101,
0.0259289201,
0.0218627956,
-0.0490699485,
0.0445702001,
-0.0379714817,
0.0868764594,
-0.0266812053,
-0.0503754914,
0.012326817,
0.0032442533,
2.412e-7,
0.1113857552,
0.0226425063,
0.0392762013,
0.0197890699,
0.028321594,
0.0035570804,
0.0594745539,
0.0107509373,
0.0087931454,
-0.0122944312,
0.0324420147,
-0.0194649026,
-0.0269749463,
0.0223305486,
-0.0599307083,
-0.0302918646,
-0.0672075674,
-0.0432833396,
-0.0269877836,
-0.0000690548,
0.0873563215,
0.0244743079,
-0.0450749323,
-0.0220733043,
-0.0249724798,
-0.0155713446,
0.0031552704,
0.0229314584,
-0.0025341266,
0.073387295,
0.0362822227,
-0.0052246875,
0.048416689,
0.0479013771,
-0.0137930391,
-0.0180747844,
0.0077167763,
0.0442217663,
-0.0627861619,
-0.0139932726,
0.0119855441,
-0.013460299,
0.0635921061,
-0.0296909641,
0.0527277961,
-0.0305608511,
-0.0457895771,
-0.0140804192,
-0.0015277007,
-0.0146376602,
0.0389260538,
-0.0195406452,
-0.0302745383,
0.0411121845,
0.0348741077,
0.0133142024,
0.0059214467,
-0.0629135892,
0.0223087668,
0.0624545477,
-0.0107106054,
-0.0197125543,
0.0451924428,
0.016586341,
-0.0014063693,
-0.0654977411,
-0.0146329636,
1.762071772e-34,
0.0011538705,
0.0159749351,
-0.0021862094,
0.0517050698,
0.0037378662,
-0.0086346231,
0.0038156754,
0.0003948202,
0.0248138532,
-0.0614947006,
-0.0038465592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13617v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13617v2 | GPT-3 Models are Few-Shot Financial Reasoners | 2023-07-25T16:21:07 | 2023-07-26T16:14:24 | Raul Salles de Padua, Imran Qureshi, Mustafa U. Karakaplan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Financial analysis is an important tool for evaluating company performance.
Practitioners work to answer financial questions to make profitable investment
decisions, and use advanced quantitative analyses to do so. As a result,
Financial Question Answering (QA) is a question answering task that requires
deep reasoning about numbers. Furthermore, it is unknown how well pre-trained
language models can reason in the financial domain. The current
state-of-the-art requires a retriever to collect relevant facts about the
financial question from the text and a generator to produce a valid financial
program and a final answer. However, recently large language models like GPT-3
have achieved state-of-the-art performance on wide variety of tasks with just a
few shot examples. We run several experiments with GPT-3 and find that a
separate retrieval model and logic engine continue to be essential components
to achieving SOTA performance in this task, particularly due to the precise
nature of financial questions and the complex information stored in financial
documents. With this understanding, our refined prompt-engineering approach on
GPT-3 achieves near SOTA accuracy without any fine-tuning. | [
0.0047235689,
0.0914815441,
0.0195710622,
0.0298694614,
-0.0007118253,
0.0127552412,
0.0202472638,
0.0205311012,
-0.0217397995,
-0.0149176726,
-0.0487445667,
-0.0262535494,
-0.0334090255,
0.0453580916,
0.0246124081,
-0.02941419,
0.048667483,
-0.0136380242,
0.0787307769,
-0.0032493887,
0.0117592374,
0.0271221865,
0.0032989823,
-0.0027043603,
0.0072376626,
-0.0438336767,
-0.0102406638,
-0.0249958914,
-0.0037404429,
-0.0114144152,
-0.01049022,
0.020491289,
0.0396203212,
0.0439794473,
0.0000021242,
-0.0360523164,
-0.0604011156,
0.0295011047,
-0.0674099326,
0.0204284564,
-0.0186560508,
-0.0060519823,
0.0301765334,
0.0316059813,
-0.0572178997,
0.0164548084,
0.0264350288,
0.0687051713,
0.0917606279,
0.0845312253,
-0.0116378265,
-0.0839763209,
0.0257322527,
-0.0619679019,
0.0339803584,
-0.1007160544,
-0.0162626486,
0.0274062194,
0.015026425,
0.0198439118,
0.0013541997,
0.0189919379,
0.0402242877,
0.0047470811,
-0.0061282669,
0.0117262155,
-0.0526905321,
0.0110544441,
-0.0298138577,
0.0639286861,
-0.0103590824,
0.0304984767,
-0.0045370818,
-0.0359261036,
0.0003525385,
-0.0041253669,
-0.0289113671,
0.0326853842,
-0.0085841175,
0.0016672378,
-0.0049144691,
0.0115339104,
0.0107389921,
-0.0108833471,
-0.0540494733,
0.0609499365,
-0.0036258474,
-0.0274792966,
0.0480253249,
0.0202210676,
-0.0470125973,
-0.0225067586,
0.0083352858,
0.0508499257,
0.0071010068,
0.0092927553,
0.0001388356,
-0.0124478946,
-0.0222467743,
-0.00872018,
0.0119714355,
0.0773710385,
-0.02894881,
0.0575048774,
-0.0397603586,
0.0546122827,
-0.0409872867,
-0.0044495533,
-0.0182747636,
0.0101697417,
-0.0279468857,
-0.0304890908,
-0.08126048,
0.0800119415,
-0.0444064699,
-0.0177236181,
-0.0376731604,
0.025595786,
0.0014943406,
0.0183931794,
0.0137796141,
0.0101119634,
-0.0188605599,
-0.0597724617,
-0.0581595674,
0.0222210009,
-0.0565520898,
0.0013915898,
0.019831378,
-0.0419134721,
-0.0107912337,
-0.0093483152,
-0.000699396,
-0.0430966988,
0.0286599174,
0.0497310385,
-0.0038208603,
-0.0301472731,
-0.0630180314,
-0.0540606566,
0.0221502036,
-0.0645485073,
-0.0369842686,
-0.0102216043,
0.0206209812,
0.0007360487,
-0.0379979163,
-0.0097327149,
0.0074393433,
0.0069763544,
0.0118352445,
0.0753074065,
0.0134170037,
-0.0268484075,
0.0031536585,
-0.0111247497,
-0.0005639735,
0.0462640151,
-0.0032470922,
0.0217202194,
0.0162890833,
-0.0107347816,
0.0061036292,
0.0198827479,
0.0298581608,
-0.0734935626,
0.0139654744,
0.0742007941,
-0.0167683959,
0.0120842671,
0.0438283309,
0.0370499417,
-0.0371671729,
-0.001097606,
0.0418450423,
0.0416835882,
0.0637285486,
0.0246000979,
0.0315592811,
0.0201001372,
0.0179262608,
-0.0104487259,
-0.0267774966,
0.0125355385,
-0.0331888199,
0.048638735,
0.0073600765,
-0.0043186601,
-0.0543272533,
-0.0462846644,
0.0146928113,
0.0168447047,
-0.0714753717,
0.0315778963,
0.0277690012,
-0.0334204212,
-0.0664473101,
0.0683231875,
-0.0157777686,
-0.0294130836,
-0.0261135958,
-0.050496757,
0.090458706,
0.0582802594,
0.039960511,
-0.0525763296,
0.003393535,
-0.0083939731,
-0.0137962662,
0.0051284875,
0.0700405985,
0.0030362681,
0.0022454837,
-0.0451965891,
0.0043704198,
-0.0169513654,
0.0129069062,
0.0566599295,
0.0182858575,
0.0184708275,
0.0426947698,
-0.0208834168,
0.0577307492,
-0.0036703309,
-0.0013942455,
-0.0825456008,
0.011761968,
-0.0116740707,
-0.0041140979,
0.0344829932,
-0.0084045576,
0.0377344787,
-0.020631073,
0.0014070575,
-0.0133545529,
-0.0217055045,
-0.0507606454,
-0.005943378,
-0.0026689509,
0.0186525546,
-0.0152196847,
-0.0025956077,
-0.0595779754,
-0.0420424379,
-0.011771597,
-0.0408277288,
0.0069889659,
-0.0780663341,
-0.0331136025,
0.0272225644,
0.0153577346,
-0.0186052937,
0.0948510095,
0.0312419478,
0.0082469219,
-0.0088304328,
0.038359791,
0.0232148003,
-0.0742805526,
0.0349649079,
0.0046715736,
-0.0346080363,
0.0385157466,
0.0368679911,
0.0039676558,
-0.0163482986,
-0.0140146185,
-0.0462025143,
0.002697726,
-0.0264379103,
0.0453004688,
-0.0029418922,
0.0048562391,
-0.0094293952,
-0.0177279189,
-0.05240326,
0.0109118856,
0.0291082896,
0.0235016234,
0.0523401052,
0.001786674,
0.0122585697,
-0.052450344,
-0.025459785,
-0.0033507561,
0.0078936331,
0.0416325033,
0.0282222331,
-0.0295864623,
-0.0000735294,
-0.0372450091,
0.0330019556,
0.0018685297,
0.0328052342,
0.0287988763,
-0.0532639585,
0.031315729,
0.0659424216,
-0.0089551369,
0.0458624475,
-0.0651319996,
-0.0056036604,
-0.0472975224,
0.0479576886,
-0.0309449863,
-0.0121686421,
0.0168362893,
0.0381246358,
0.0169848017,
0.042768456,
-0.0305050295,
-0.0081375632,
-0.0808935016,
0.0593061075,
0.0314164497,
0.0162391365,
-0.0597470887,
0.0108842449,
0.0139530674,
0.083956264,
-0.0033427288,
-0.0228089839,
0.0546385087,
0.0015353918,
-0.0494816117,
-0.0165839866,
0.0070839603,
-0.0638465956,
0.0744603202,
-0.0267173816,
-0.0089023402,
-0.0044817501,
-0.0502076708,
-0.0384071916,
-0.0481335707,
0.0451962128,
-0.0372852385,
0.05208892,
-0.0423198417,
0.0388214476,
-0.0087227346,
-0.0446869805,
-0.029722292,
-0.0600863285,
-0.0348921455,
0.0343009308,
-0.0229257978,
-0.0067626415,
-0.0431142487,
0.0053536901,
0.0249582306,
0.0382917039,
-0.0235338379,
-0.0340019204,
-0.0231436007,
0.0425769091,
0.0540208258,
0.020247031,
0.0311096963,
-0.0236125179,
0.0610720143,
0.0163471922,
0.0317527056,
-0.0204343423,
-0.0157478154,
0.0086044464,
-0.0059011327,
-0.0563443899,
-0.0234317016,
0.0381138325,
-0.0078806896,
-0.0825354829,
-0.0276346505,
0.1047612354,
0.0095804129,
0.016873356,
-0.0291156657,
-0.0064322436,
0.0121503286,
-0.0160618834,
0.0807015002,
-0.0964795798,
-0.04075839,
-0.0053588795,
0.0200975798,
0.0154360468,
-0.0222130623,
-0.0347215757,
-0.1395661682,
0.0606628582,
-0.0381541364,
-0.0164194927,
-0.0277012438,
-0.0325651355,
-0.0413206667,
-0.038469024,
0.019695675,
0.0589969605,
-0.0097699286,
0.0248482004,
0.0034422621,
-0.0153085152,
0.0051034396,
0.04381302,
0.0087360051,
-0.061007902,
0.071133703,
0.0077386857,
-0.017569162,
-0.0457541235,
-0.0161471628,
-0.0089552458,
-0.0012598393,
0.0123794498,
0.0432822406,
-0.0110857664,
-0.0227291305,
0.0060637477,
0.049137108,
-0.0560481697,
0.0314887017,
-0.021887321,
0.032960806,
-0.0221294574,
-0.0058608796,
-0.0064989808,
0.0067145997,
-0.0392475016,
0.0534757785,
-0.0059304982,
0.0022958675,
-0.0660497695,
-0.0412410721,
0.0145619232,
-0.0697765723,
0.0075776558,
-0.0345829055,
0.035257142,
-0.0094910413,
-0.0570060425,
-0.0795357004,
0.0202612802,
0.0489687212,
-0.0492435656,
-0.0534720011,
0.0329063684,
0.0160639305,
-0.0199470576,
0.0345707573,
-0.0552426018,
0.0234532729,
-0.0482348874,
0.0477140248,
0.0253315698,
-0.0207935739,
-0.0606454723,
-0.0205637068,
-0.0551323593,
-0.0117589971,
-0.0234698746,
0.0355307348,
0.0263911374,
-0.026949646,
-0.0353389829,
0.0263387393,
0.0094884289,
0.0379577614,
-0.0674562454,
-0.0205839425,
0.0513234138,
0.0096581178,
-0.008579501,
0.0212718733,
-0.0554909483,
0.0239323303,
0.0038413506,
0.0302117765,
-0.0284603909,
-0.0007011396,
0.0296078771,
0.0284192748,
0.0313065946,
0.0640670508,
0.0004096692,
-0.0194998309,
0.0047291196,
-0.0264035854,
0.0180498697,
-0.0511927679,
-0.0136914961,
0.0355477706,
-0.0286232326,
-0.0206103139,
-0.0384401567,
-0.0208901875,
0.0260144174,
-0.0205641184,
-0.0111507392,
0.0050472133,
0.0120246215,
-0.0176346973,
-0.051219523,
-0.0004433707,
0.0008780468,
0.0236256067,
0.0432772562,
-0.0066169635,
0.0807633102,
0.017755745,
0.0050285961,
0.0105784098,
0.0028607473,
-0.0689056069,
-0.0666061789,
-0.0022922375,
0.0211290903,
0.0029108715,
-0.015753923,
-0.0318627805,
-0.0286886543,
0.0096715055,
0.0158102699,
0.0107043926,
0.0503102168,
-0.031406913,
0.0173125342,
0.0281860437,
-0.0034645728,
-0.0742517784,
0.0732979327,
0.0042812764,
0.0145683838,
-0.029608978,
-0.0073754285,
-0.0335079134,
-0.0525803715,
0.0171131007,
0.0114394287,
0.001153659,
0.012783763,
-0.0782915428,
-0.0311474018,
-0.0178227089,
0.0277056433,
-0.0316149034,
0.0093728481,
0.0510500968,
0.0947226658,
-0.0126474705,
-0.0101214917,
-0.0026423719,
0.037502367,
-0.0661946982,
-0.0111733004,
-0.0611374155,
-6.035803864e-33,
-0.0253816433,
0.0003315868,
0.0653774962,
-0.0247625113,
0.0009891621,
0.0058051678,
-0.0266444255,
-0.0170220267,
-0.0333076157,
0.0030143636,
-0.0348782726,
0.0467549786,
0.0159676038,
0.0263386443,
-0.0248772334,
-0.0318327062,
0.0248464365,
-0.0221284963,
-0.0233269073,
-0.0157303214,
0.0098033529,
0.0640205145,
0.0517254621,
-0.0051328056,
0.027756881,
0.0211406555,
-0.0382285863,
0.0129008377,
0.0065642325,
0.0258102287,
-0.0077945343,
0.0276519638,
0.0011658239,
-0.1115984842,
-0.0001377892,
0.0387546867,
-0.0595834665,
-0.0770720765,
0.0104464106,
0.015368497,
0.0066478085,
0.0077085863,
0.0086013982,
-0.0351218842,
0.0120179728,
-0.0250377227,
-0.0090989163,
0.0055119088,
0.0320183374,
-0.0295032486,
-0.0515931323,
0.0355090275,
0.000960156,
0.0225196145,
0.0367039479,
0.0619775839,
-0.0107279867,
0.0495656505,
0.0134945037,
-0.0178478938,
0.027762359,
0.0247008987,
0.0097450484,
-0.0147439605,
-0.0068138256,
0.0207612105,
0.0010290778,
-0.0217297114,
-0.0533684939,
0.0011772349,
0.0106832385,
0.0534023866,
0.0643290877,
0.0364149064,
0.0614290461,
0.0167697538,
-0.0609237552,
0.0261418987,
-0.0022478602,
0.0432731509,
0.0090437941,
0.0195139237,
-0.0396761261,
-0.0227640253,
-0.0177105684,
0.0256720185,
-0.057692159,
-0.0120714037,
0.0369521379,
0.0130903404,
0.005945506,
0.0426524691,
0.0241677966,
-0.0292281769,
-0.0020211269,
0.0325985141,
-0.0023665812,
-0.0021722019,
-0.0125279045,
0.0444013849,
-0.0429495387,
-0.0136117898,
-0.0078482376,
0.0162275229,
-0.0150474887,
-0.0106829889,
-0.0029081532,
0.0223593134,
-0.065883331,
-0.0113935443,
-0.0363327861,
0.0359271914,
-0.0254944693,
0.0307840779,
-0.0061813961,
0.0458189249,
0.0041224952,
0.0213259812,
-0.0183601789,
-0.0105361231,
-0.0238184258,
-0.005536132,
0.0089399666,
0.0408503525,
0.0186626576,
0.0148217594,
-0.0058302172,
0.0403315648,
-0.0054478426,
-0.018852653,
-0.0144302091,
0.0524200015,
2.814e-7,
0.0489931852,
0.0129830167,
0.0384575874,
0.0409688093,
-0.0025677735,
0.0370910391,
0.0341175608,
-0.0008957839,
0.005372948,
-0.0245273523,
0.0590695329,
0.0299971495,
0.028428603,
0.0114124771,
-0.0434801914,
-0.0181397665,
-0.0743552074,
-0.0185767934,
-0.0439423919,
0.006709055,
0.0581680313,
0.0910054073,
0.0020452733,
-0.0373907275,
0.0204319786,
-0.079581365,
0.0645588189,
0.0024657175,
-0.0090284357,
0.007848544,
0.0453474522,
0.0175387431,
-0.0025136948,
0.0120798349,
0.0035227616,
0.0247172918,
0.0102652954,
0.0630355179,
0.0030133037,
-0.0148283178,
-0.0213562679,
-0.0261040125,
-0.0068097189,
-0.061379645,
0.0840318799,
-0.04886939,
-0.0230907369,
-0.0082106339,
-0.0702052712,
-0.0143689625,
0.0063112043,
-0.0101244943,
0.0100556482,
0.003989737,
0.0218081009,
-0.0232645012,
0.0344046317,
-0.0470791683,
0.0082207089,
0.0363880582,
-0.0286967382,
0.0066173933,
-0.0524264127,
-0.0110694114,
0.0399604701,
-0.0524358414,
-0.0232404228,
2.347931268e-34,
0.0599132366,
-0.0219511762,
0.0011005339,
0.0322599374,
0.0702635944,
0.0347129479,
-0.0121878861,
0.0353328623,
0.0369386226,
-0.0645360127,
-0.016715046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13714v1 | Diversity and Language Technology: How Techno-Linguistic Bias Can Cause Epistemic Injustice | 2023-07-25T16:08:27 | 2023-07-25T16:08:27 | Paula Helm, Gábor Bella, Gertraud Koch, Fausto Giunchiglia | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | It is well known that AI-based language technology -- large language models,
machine translation systems, multilingual dictionaries, and corpora -- is
currently limited to 2 to 3 percent of the world's most widely spoken and/or
financially and politically best supported languages. In response, recent
research efforts have sought to extend the reach of AI technology to
``underserved languages.'' In this paper, we show that many of these attempts
produce flawed solutions that adhere to a hard-wired representational
preference for certain languages, which we call techno-linguistic bias.
Techno-linguistic bias is distinct from the well-established phenomenon of
linguistic bias as it does not concern the languages represented but rather the
design of the technologies. As we show through the paper, techno-linguistic
bias can result in systems that can only express concepts that are part of the
language and culture of dominant powers, unable to correctly represent concepts
from other communities. We argue that at the root of this problem lies a
systematic tendency of technology developer communities to apply a simplistic
understanding of diversity which does not do justice to the more profound
differences that languages, and ultimately the communities that speak them,
embody. Drawing on the concept of epistemic injustice, we point to the broader
sociopolitical consequences of the bias we identify and show how it can lead
not only to a disregard for valuable aspects of diversity but also to an
under-representation of the needs and diverse worldviews of marginalized
language communities. | [
0.0319449902,
0.0660760254,
-0.0664487779,
0.0269685462,
-0.0365437977,
0.0058685564,
0.0398743227,
-0.0227869786,
0.000774283,
-0.0319373347,
0.010620106,
-0.0130089913,
0.0617755055,
0.0164092202,
0.0071827103,
-0.0414624959,
-0.0211765729,
0.0167508051,
0.013207294,
-0.0367638916,
0.0182756037,
0.0623606108,
0.0288536455,
0.0790264308,
-0.0140707642,
0.004948894,
0.0418563224,
-0.0285349004,
-0.0087799244,
0.0068075191,
-0.0133449454,
0.0128452675,
-0.0093594566,
0.0746860281,
0.000001971,
-0.0583029576,
0.0120439678,
0.0165694524,
-0.0080936663,
-0.0287259892,
0.0201505665,
-0.009486232,
-0.021628648,
0.0095625147,
-0.0609853789,
0.0161118265,
0.0428962521,
-0.0381893776,
-0.0206944402,
0.0129034827,
-0.0084192464,
-0.0114666568,
0.0040724468,
0.0130327521,
-0.0243421029,
0.0393147133,
-0.0008403128,
-0.0343679003,
0.024931144,
0.0080406275,
-0.026571475,
0.0619245395,
0.0512351617,
0.0010247449,
-0.0132992435,
0.0027829572,
-0.019555429,
-0.0637980849,
0.0288046412,
0.0483944453,
0.0258527268,
0.0107866824,
-0.0056163459,
0.0264110249,
-0.0132626649,
-0.0234142281,
-0.0057952655,
0.0648425445,
-0.0226500444,
-0.0088878553,
0.0469176099,
0.0023118297,
0.0034197925,
0.0067973938,
-0.0218313355,
0.0799186155,
-0.0065177036,
0.0165876895,
-0.0129323369,
0.0200405288,
0.0490867309,
-0.0262684599,
0.0153955584,
0.0088235214,
-0.0286913384,
0.0251312852,
0.0022148693,
-0.032884147,
0.0096635912,
-0.0316021964,
0.0092839152,
0.0257849544,
-0.0166632086,
0.0036063176,
0.0434246734,
-0.0215348694,
-0.0245763306,
0.0214875042,
-0.0242980551,
-0.0252587963,
-0.0201781783,
-0.0296735931,
0.0053766374,
-0.0132467775,
-0.0323440507,
0.0506480671,
0.0324595831,
0.0237897374,
-0.0595372766,
0.0308898501,
-0.0558618978,
-0.0113046514,
-0.0208394639,
-0.0189140104,
-0.0172798559,
0.0515290238,
-0.052958563,
-0.0057824552,
-0.0539421253,
-0.1027294472,
0.033184845,
-0.001721425,
-0.0672925115,
-0.0355748497,
0.003062461,
0.0271140058,
0.0201614257,
-0.012175383,
-0.0098214624,
-0.0207202192,
-0.0047546974,
-0.0359246768,
-0.0139179081,
-0.0522749536,
0.0000788819,
0.0882000551,
0.0108323544,
-0.098191753,
-0.019289488,
0.0002819446,
-0.032169193,
0.0378798768,
-0.0161787998,
0.0129085239,
0.1013568789,
0.0221751928,
-0.0322270542,
0.064431563,
0.0303986371,
-0.0136216041,
0.0347766504,
0.0122587141,
0.0272418186,
0.0108804284,
-0.039448835,
0.0109779537,
-0.0522036217,
0.0217584074,
-0.0257904921,
-0.0271501355,
0.0154895205,
0.0597364567,
0.0296931099,
0.0101768738,
0.0313672572,
0.0590605214,
-0.017779626,
0.0460542701,
-0.0368146151,
-0.0296913441,
-0.0435341932,
0.0075745811,
-0.0024250734,
0.0082262531,
0.00290518,
-0.0421125256,
0.0038572394,
0.0613110773,
-0.0186923724,
-0.0306974966,
0.0077367048,
0.010071177,
0.0746272057,
0.0127003752,
0.0343545824,
-0.0397420526,
0.0422462784,
0.0237717219,
0.033193741,
-0.0019243219,
-0.0110400561,
-0.0600370355,
0.0138916327,
0.0273198057,
-0.0304933265,
-0.0311396476,
0.0463213399,
-0.0199384764,
-0.0192004759,
0.0845960155,
0.0470450073,
-0.0092574861,
-0.034579955,
-0.0042502736,
-0.0065551121,
0.0126252556,
0.0004926627,
0.0618183352,
-0.0232036188,
0.0765496045,
-0.002096561,
-0.0150919147,
-0.0667162985,
-0.0076479069,
-0.0104137082,
0.0047122184,
-0.0471706465,
0.0220880006,
-0.0159460288,
0.0444613062,
-0.058949057,
-0.0032023732,
-0.0138702923,
-0.0294592418,
-0.010608959,
0.043880187,
-0.0316430666,
0.0638164356,
0.0287621524,
-0.1285051405,
-0.0143129667,
0.0303329714,
0.0178200118,
-0.0046514492,
0.1053827628,
-0.0121313613,
0.0071683489,
0.0186646543,
0.0300473962,
-0.0689810663,
0.0079239951,
-0.0470822752,
-0.0046908334,
-0.0091076689,
-0.0072998293,
-0.0104828244,
-0.0298271049,
0.0738065317,
0.0016753582,
-0.0540068932,
0.1197195798,
0.0344717503,
0.0293359403,
0.05021796,
-0.0194954425,
-0.0033113507,
0.0201736167,
-0.0751058608,
-0.0627526194,
-0.0237916149,
-0.0411360897,
-0.0293523762,
0.0269554183,
-0.0090162558,
-0.0090692714,
-0.0143115725,
-0.0386816934,
0.0019388014,
0.01493257,
-0.0076860664,
-0.0025238926,
-0.0040365052,
0.012724652,
-0.0170640759,
0.010857204,
0.0277781431,
0.0283872802,
-0.0231651273,
-0.0400851369,
-0.0681313649,
-0.063653484,
-0.0008651817,
-0.0169489309,
0.0040856414,
0.0532561354,
0.0393004753,
-0.0387782715,
0.0057019335,
-0.0133529641,
0.0487707593,
0.0562564656,
0.0290620159,
-0.0332163014,
-0.0145688662,
0.0395070203,
0.03697972,
0.0326275341,
-0.0488017499,
-0.0333998688,
0.0267637782,
0.0418534875,
0.0017690196,
-0.0492483154,
0.0647480562,
-0.110816367,
-0.0556614175,
-0.0069054645,
-0.0431009531,
0.001784162,
0.036258053,
-0.0114498828,
-0.029291274,
0.0429005772,
0.0267173536,
0.0074116858,
-0.0501795299,
-0.0284711234,
-0.0304327961,
0.0639224574,
-0.0430602171,
0.0520104989,
0.0407496765,
-0.0251842458,
-0.0606835298,
-0.0065000756,
0.0164346043,
-0.0312453844,
0.0554533452,
-0.053266257,
0.009058143,
-0.0292685889,
-0.0282160472,
-0.0181129426,
0.0347599648,
-0.0303398781,
-0.0093375277,
0.0701238662,
0.0011580528,
-0.0090570822,
-0.0212308392,
0.0682206824,
0.0349955298,
0.0432838351,
0.0011297673,
0.0119012371,
-0.0542984232,
-0.0188315343,
0.0239617489,
0.0878226981,
0.0077732983,
0.0072937068,
-0.0100977691,
0.0119397538,
-0.0332615748,
0.0358139426,
-0.0018609411,
0.045533333,
-0.0104058832,
-0.0544591025,
0.0032899335,
0.0475734212,
-0.020749215,
0.0344594903,
0.0466696583,
-0.008102444,
-0.0345178768,
0.0219522677,
-0.0466466397,
-0.0131643433,
0.0311384555,
0.0294601284,
-0.1113657951,
0.0603982247,
0.0088898679,
0.0092879711,
-0.0669938624,
-0.0237047113,
-0.0322561339,
-0.0606964082,
0.019675307,
0.0350314789,
-0.0464247242,
-0.0310093481,
0.0117476117,
-0.044883538,
0.0315487608,
0.0530220717,
-0.0167935994,
0.0464435294,
0.0203108415,
0.0058203973,
-0.050747484,
-0.0110226972,
0.0053289002,
0.004098794,
0.0154908141,
0.0280916356,
0.0409128331,
-0.0359678306,
-0.0102758296,
0.0002500908,
-0.0018412613,
-0.0141207939,
-0.02733781,
-0.0437288247,
0.0285221953,
-0.0348697715,
0.0006052338,
-0.0237739626,
-0.023493804,
0.0042898804,
0.0328744873,
0.0518923216,
-0.0236086715,
-0.0216072518,
-0.0284165181,
-0.0661806837,
0.014262558,
0.0173297282,
-0.013276536,
-0.0315088518,
0.0028081725,
-0.06997554,
-0.0248141941,
0.0295860525,
-0.0406449325,
0.0537595265,
0.0435442142,
-0.0727514029,
-0.0248647705,
-0.093872942,
-0.0229087658,
0.0216042604,
0.055312939,
-0.0219940655,
0.0052503943,
-0.0177856386,
-0.011977056,
0.0215333384,
-0.0092765577,
0.022852594,
-0.000709839,
-0.0176523216,
-0.0793620795,
-0.0489195399,
0.0166890416,
-0.0146260494,
0.0331121087,
-0.0658844635,
0.0346829481,
0.0255432222,
0.0306746904,
-0.0018178793,
0.005196108,
-0.0571995564,
0.0536795706,
0.0402980819,
0.007824936,
0.0143182827,
0.0296955034,
-0.0546231344,
-0.0030940541,
0.0276333485,
-0.0226163343,
0.0036898723,
0.0089352643,
-0.0008136831,
-0.0503384024,
-0.0211054217,
0.0306416247,
-0.0041784449,
-0.0003314729,
-0.060543064,
0.0012972964,
-0.0329785421,
-0.0510464348,
0.0118882488,
-0.0351613313,
-0.0048585492,
-0.0407139361,
0.013915319,
0.0161068961,
0.0031799458,
0.0129873455,
-0.013072649,
0.0031373648,
-0.0174805149,
0.0702867433,
-0.0112290019,
0.0676806346,
0.0141693344,
0.039308399,
0.0232030526,
0.0764341131,
-0.0409310274,
0.0418907814,
0.0120296059,
0.0312332474,
0.0189680941,
-0.0166992601,
0.0263783466,
0.0129731121,
-0.0134326704,
-0.1034109443,
0.0435194634,
0.0097397091,
0.0686482042,
-0.0121710822,
0.0351825655,
0.0270557497,
0.0104523459,
-0.0086919395,
-0.0054827831,
0.0282335188,
-0.0245265793,
-0.0208095443,
-0.0185078848,
-0.0267508458,
0.0105420295,
0.0465069339,
-0.0756377801,
0.0265849326,
0.0123451529,
-0.0018999623,
0.0031678558,
-0.056508258,
0.0049013873,
-0.0173051227,
-0.0262317155,
-0.0048633306,
-0.0995338634,
-0.0442186929,
0.021703301,
-0.007566127,
0.0240136553,
-0.0291479025,
-0.0051293396,
0.0510760732,
0.0076035573,
-0.0128180506,
-0.0477859415,
0.0244707949,
-0.0417602323,
0.0198994502,
0.0501661897,
-5.712588835e-33,
0.0192060675,
-0.0356063582,
-0.0042409757,
-0.0452374853,
0.0037742876,
0.0090088751,
0.0010140607,
0.0487702526,
-0.067859523,
0.0281714648,
-0.0248613916,
-0.0139512885,
0.0064775371,
-0.0073510702,
0.0189744756,
0.015729744,
0.010458312,
0.0427491367,
-0.0087219225,
-0.0063655656,
0.0294223279,
-0.0440723374,
0.0406937115,
-0.0810208544,
0.1063383371,
0.0092136199,
-0.0011963907,
-0.0133929374,
0.0265356097,
-0.009417288,
-0.002456513,
0.1009766608,
0.0115673589,
-0.065967299,
-0.0069856453,
0.0268869847,
0.0083610443,
-0.023096459,
0.0282594841,
0.0438949838,
0.0492941998,
-0.0331972204,
0.0015901393,
-0.007029539,
-0.0796301216,
0.0413797982,
0.0458216779,
-0.0053225737,
0.0220250692,
0.0141102048,
-0.0509589911,
0.0070389998,
-0.0526438132,
0.0420134999,
-0.0372799449,
0.0180664547,
0.0097081251,
-0.0247804932,
-0.0941391289,
0.0103936521,
0.0097161485,
-0.0290467627,
0.0775048137,
0.0026595925,
-0.000702211,
0.0213426594,
0.0463532098,
0.0358603112,
-0.0170228723,
-0.0373336934,
0.0263113193,
-0.0373195373,
0.0181561541,
0.041778028,
-0.0138368001,
-0.0472053215,
-0.0158305131,
-0.0343254283,
0.0011984557,
0.022170702,
0.0262499712,
0.0094316732,
-0.0632346421,
-0.0456947125,
-0.0041226447,
-0.0739275366,
-0.0085135959,
-0.0215668548,
0.0034207851,
-0.0381099209,
0.0093038557,
0.0098931082,
0.0279626288,
-0.0601533838,
-0.0403380133,
-0.0150899859,
-0.0112305908,
-0.0455868542,
0.0410830081,
0.041602198,
-0.0162166171,
-0.0073146964,
-0.0549766198,
0.0594845898,
0.00065769,
0.0218464304,
-0.0240173116,
-0.000557029,
-0.0155289955,
-0.0047646742,
-0.0191821195,
0.0290240049,
0.0251697134,
-0.0029382443,
0.0339464247,
0.0229007769,
-0.0108958203,
-0.0236145947,
0.0473096892,
-0.0118943425,
-0.0301276334,
0.0069694128,
-0.0547958836,
0.0188840423,
-0.0771192759,
-0.0328313857,
-0.0346368663,
0.056852337,
0.080111444,
-0.001928393,
-0.030509891,
-0.0482546613,
2.699e-7,
0.0039106496,
0.0269229822,
-0.0113941887,
-0.0138727529,
0.0096163535,
0.0282827877,
0.0127022844,
0.0655540526,
-0.0360039212,
0.0021646302,
-0.0208037924,
0.0386555828,
0.0433487929,
0.0323703587,
-0.0197544228,
0.0071078148,
-0.0451580994,
0.0599231869,
-0.0636669248,
0.0679636076,
0.0017857854,
0.041819185,
0.0163835585,
-0.0193298738,
-0.0724470615,
-0.0200740714,
-0.0011309905,
-0.029816635,
0.0434016511,
-0.0071429405,
0.0370150916,
0.0411983244,
0.0258671287,
0.0020394025,
0.0310130958,
0.0131356716,
-0.0024314648,
0.0092160022,
-0.0160781443,
0.0352229811,
0.0117229922,
-0.0108802626,
-0.014963001,
-0.0760986283,
0.0328709148,
0.0588758737,
-0.0297120828,
-0.037613336,
0.0293008517,
-0.0179562774,
0.0722010508,
-0.0128235845,
-0.0422895774,
-0.0054398947,
0.0331882052,
-0.0384538099,
0.0211180896,
-0.0380919278,
-0.0328367054,
0.0174078178,
-0.0078787748,
-0.0247229245,
0.0074292212,
0.0280857477,
0.0010944722,
0.0342901386,
0.0522323325,
2.0293886e-34,
0.0086129261,
-0.0040027578,
0.0150433183,
-0.0089908848,
0.0316953734,
0.0259582661,
0.0021946204,
-0.0236136653,
0.0235717427,
0.0353904478,
-0.0185667649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13560v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13560v2 | XDLM: Cross-lingual Diffusion Language Model for Machine Translation | 2023-07-25T15:08:34 | 2023-07-31T01:29:31 | Linyao Chen, Aosong Feng, Boming Yang, Zihui Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, diffusion models have excelled in image generation tasks and have
also been applied to neural language processing (NLP) for controllable text
generation. However, the application of diffusion models in a cross-lingual
setting is less unexplored. Additionally, while pretraining with diffusion
models has been studied within a single language, the potential of
cross-lingual pretraining remains understudied. To address these gaps, we
propose XDLM, a novel Cross-lingual diffusion model for machine translation,
consisting of pretraining and fine-tuning stages. In the pretraining stage, we
propose TLDM, a new training objective for mastering the mapping between
different languages; in the fine-tuning stage, we build up the translation
system based on the pretrained model. We evaluate the result on several machine
translation benchmarks and outperformed both diffusion and Transformer
baselines. | [
0.0080941236,
-0.0056496602,
0.0082856575,
0.0414979123,
-0.0100143552,
0.0117711788,
0.0167535823,
-0.0184915774,
-0.013713913,
0.0060957237,
-0.0588290431,
-0.0733759776,
0.0197157171,
-0.0047819391,
0.031413272,
-0.0501139536,
0.01283859,
-0.0169217195,
-0.0846649706,
-0.0016328943,
-0.0095564965,
0.0166989844,
0.0353988521,
0.0086826654,
-0.0156797729,
-0.0131550338,
0.0036548856,
0.0372917727,
0.0353389941,
-0.0309451073,
-0.0070480802,
0.0277638007,
0.0576770604,
0.0312085487,
0.0000020955,
-0.0057987515,
-0.0106889848,
-0.0058804583,
0.0634300634,
-0.0059305085,
0.0551084839,
-0.0765941069,
-0.0155727286,
0.0331856981,
-0.0148847867,
-0.0237674098,
0.0774997771,
0.0450965799,
0.0667430833,
0.0931658298,
-0.0292703379,
-0.0868466571,
0.006786929,
-0.0693776757,
0.0235684998,
-0.0319679305,
-0.0024951827,
0.0446190163,
-0.0395801291,
0.0019327349,
-0.0479356833,
0.0577128194,
0.0203168616,
-0.0014980222,
0.0065952977,
0.0422126874,
0.0432265811,
-0.051873114,
-0.0258296449,
0.0826806724,
-0.050980743,
-0.0123230396,
0.0096430741,
-0.0141887274,
-0.0283398572,
-0.0038185243,
-0.0164768882,
0.0193936545,
0.0340619422,
0.0453218073,
0.0039238604,
-0.0160029698,
0.0398027822,
-0.0007246822,
-0.0312958732,
0.0236597974,
0.0312434193,
-0.0143286986,
-0.0062033446,
0.0231222212,
0.0357251391,
-0.0544353202,
0.0415506549,
0.0371263586,
-0.0037176677,
0.0066061681,
-0.0588168055,
-0.0484239869,
0.0140548786,
-0.0551037788,
0.0438293256,
0.0386332273,
0.0081015239,
0.0337090977,
-0.0551226363,
0.0398756079,
-0.0602912381,
0.0163594875,
-0.0641886741,
-0.0073366943,
-0.0202585384,
0.0202392042,
-0.0489207655,
-0.0228654929,
-0.0398318917,
-0.0195280947,
-0.0685804561,
0.024983326,
0.0399439707,
-0.031094268,
0.0577700585,
-0.0246868506,
-0.0704067945,
-0.0074752602,
-0.0095515186,
0.0542112216,
-0.0029497584,
-0.0152225522,
0.0234942697,
0.0083094435,
-0.0353412591,
0.0278356913,
0.0200300403,
-0.0295311213,
0.0190308895,
0.0643525571,
-0.0561021641,
-0.0166311078,
-0.0343945846,
-0.0050943457,
-0.0124831963,
-0.0694443509,
0.0380937532,
-0.0808140561,
0.0627439246,
0.0034242212,
0.0100723729,
-0.0056131864,
0.0112466319,
0.0107292905,
-0.0263435654,
0.0314769112,
0.0082852421,
0.0093174325,
0.0421725139,
-0.0225119386,
0.0130042648,
0.0616695434,
0.0447500646,
0.0430847406,
-0.0075308522,
0.0020428384,
-0.0130527057,
0.0735044032,
0.0324303322,
0.0278229881,
-0.0188742969,
-0.0231704246,
0.0039961608,
0.0308428314,
0.0478045046,
0.0445482954,
-0.0565966479,
0.0315733589,
0.0712760836,
0.0280942172,
0.0102820816,
0.0187775344,
0.0761442333,
-0.0026349633,
-0.0579554476,
0.0152554056,
0.0208882336,
0.0405506678,
0.0599421337,
0.0156891905,
0.0134347277,
0.0617762767,
-0.057032641,
-0.0207035318,
0.0244006179,
-0.0341660976,
0.0545217171,
-0.0458496474,
0.0281124115,
0.0472410098,
-0.0745674521,
0.0941644907,
0.0076359678,
-0.053910166,
0.0173355807,
-0.0252503958,
-0.0123778088,
0.0467468537,
0.0335400663,
0.0392144136,
-0.0104128905,
-0.0235516112,
0.0493585579,
0.0685527623,
0.0799981654,
0.0441006087,
0.0186272599,
-0.0606279708,
-0.0131222541,
-0.0095173148,
-0.0020993971,
0.0598899275,
-0.0392719582,
0.0511859693,
0.0437458977,
-0.0303392857,
-0.0654002205,
0.0403385162,
-0.0591790229,
-0.0297825299,
0.0332989655,
0.0034428798,
-0.003100947,
-0.01226654,
-0.0287219621,
0.0025470972,
-0.0083013372,
-0.0459010452,
-0.0307472106,
0.013969006,
-0.0405600332,
-0.0245431233,
0.0094368411,
-0.0522265024,
-0.0148819108,
-0.0019086374,
-0.0335425884,
-0.0416991822,
0.0169037208,
-0.0144653171,
0.0178034361,
-0.0483947024,
0.0268374421,
0.0301391948,
0.0382314771,
0.0011999023,
0.0546255372,
-0.0086200368,
-0.0133987004,
-0.0091071725,
0.0284842588,
0.0143653946,
0.0066393157,
-0.02357357,
0.0044347798,
0.0129981497,
0.0412981994,
0.0320785828,
0.0629717484,
-0.0230389312,
-0.0392553657,
-0.0502781309,
0.031089792,
-0.0345262736,
0.0086582433,
0.0318117999,
0.0410988629,
0.0122098075,
-0.0148614617,
-0.063690193,
0.0257088356,
0.0343718752,
-0.0070638824,
0.0462135375,
-0.0028474303,
0.0176716801,
-0.0371274576,
0.0005682812,
0.0430782065,
0.0257811472,
-0.0058205435,
-0.0136817116,
-0.0486971736,
0.0659858733,
-0.0325800106,
0.0050076973,
-0.009808585,
-0.071790196,
0.0055539734,
0.0021069578,
0.0644039661,
0.0364698023,
0.0130578699,
-0.0095486771,
0.0170675013,
-0.0247757435,
-0.0378270522,
0.0137282247,
-0.045605801,
-0.0165429283,
-0.0372889265,
-0.0513600782,
0.0025681963,
0.0786736906,
-0.0097825732,
-0.0062827454,
-0.0644551665,
-0.0252323169,
0.0002619954,
-0.0376707166,
-0.0011257064,
0.025227109,
0.0036721213,
0.0134355742,
-0.0529046804,
-0.0531042255,
0.0317586213,
-0.0629753172,
0.0077221673,
-0.0525472201,
-0.0106922444,
-0.019880563,
0.0024260317,
-0.0028229328,
0.0588414259,
-0.0132958256,
0.0042796587,
-0.0322915763,
-0.0168831516,
0.0100990767,
-0.0115528703,
-0.0002536383,
-0.0275374781,
-0.005202218,
-0.039843075,
0.0030819664,
-0.0211111531,
-0.0254671462,
0.0302660242,
-0.0019770183,
0.0130013945,
-0.0160657391,
-0.0179121252,
0.0208426286,
0.0187118892,
0.0369672589,
-0.0057239048,
-0.0012286572,
-0.0345944092,
0.0313898735,
0.0285099428,
-0.019194169,
-0.0095665045,
-0.0745029524,
0.0052851159,
0.0093889842,
0.0220802333,
-0.0074999705,
-0.0456633009,
-0.0034752269,
0.0089432942,
0.0113443974,
-0.0179266445,
-0.0211328305,
0.0885535181,
-0.0465294644,
-0.0190825108,
0.0734398365,
-0.0012874174,
-0.0386225581,
-0.0210309215,
0.0255211722,
0.0626049414,
0.001103881,
0.0231554508,
-0.0840272382,
-0.0131832482,
-0.0286943242,
-0.0130480081,
0.0187059436,
0.0240986962,
-0.024683509,
-0.0766076222,
0.0141611695,
0.0495506003,
-0.0443839505,
-0.029851621,
-0.0287326351,
-0.0481771082,
0.0062628202,
0.0249344762,
-0.0466739275,
0.0203618612,
-0.0226662327,
0.0134721231,
0.0656150877,
-0.0923602656,
-0.0119894948,
-0.0769359022,
-0.014655428,
0.0755429044,
0.0465053767,
-0.009464127,
-0.0642852634,
0.0551474802,
-0.0071639395,
0.0020449234,
-0.0033202111,
0.0153301163,
0.0049517974,
-0.051224336,
0.0479496941,
-0.0002846621,
-0.0317422524,
0.0272889715,
-0.0103781419,
0.0538718216,
0.0153411534,
-0.0161193702,
0.0235767271,
0.0014879842,
0.0243575256,
0.0408880077,
0.0157315433,
-0.0542050563,
-0.0496843085,
-0.0014518389,
0.0157276429,
-0.049675364,
-0.0469088368,
-0.0135659417,
-0.0489070006,
-0.0605001636,
-0.0832882822,
-0.0536635742,
-0.0186927989,
0.0466023646,
0.0240656454,
-0.0086962804,
0.0077604791,
-0.0289591681,
-0.0288083944,
0.0505451076,
-0.015317739,
0.0231989007,
-0.0447933562,
-0.0234337524,
0.0196614861,
-0.0306011681,
0.012535587,
0.0324040502,
-0.1037073135,
-0.0859156251,
-0.0419769958,
0.0591990501,
0.0112474374,
0.0485337935,
-0.0177647881,
-0.0214817505,
0.0643961132,
0.0000905233,
0.0388705991,
0.01138396,
0.0169124044,
-0.0228689797,
-0.0119843148,
0.0291757435,
-0.0151426587,
0.0216730814,
0.0112647125,
0.0495872498,
-0.0234692935,
0.002301153,
-0.0008210632,
-0.0422796458,
0.0009892834,
-0.037148688,
0.0254191905,
-0.0485705882,
0.0048762476,
-0.0286574923,
-0.001829193,
-0.0523538888,
-0.0448388495,
0.0555130802,
0.00623819,
-0.0028011966,
-0.0123077547,
-0.0007713686,
-0.0092575951,
-0.0045771743,
-0.0001142574,
-0.01567173,
0.0339345634,
0.0131698288,
0.011595686,
-0.0075823669,
-0.016354328,
-0.0141419014,
0.0141654052,
-0.0299371332,
0.0542155318,
-0.0059256479,
0.0187680814,
-0.0195149314,
0.0332270898,
-0.0150165353,
-0.0368840769,
-0.0142974276,
-0.0058166627,
0.0911775604,
-0.013738242,
0.1127907708,
-0.0133123351,
-0.0123817939,
0.0072266245,
0.0340294912,
-0.0267407279,
-0.0054241144,
0.0094926916,
-0.0267035495,
0.0029465824,
-0.001278552,
0.0654680803,
-0.0130673852,
0.0083924886,
-0.0065177814,
-0.0257760882,
-0.007659026,
-0.0054627601,
0.0016220347,
-0.0481172875,
0.0071395948,
-0.0144962361,
-0.0173104331,
-0.0708502829,
0.002014782,
0.0289023779,
-0.0061164191,
0.0268726554,
0.0415494852,
0.0835244432,
-0.007912444,
0.0396645516,
-0.0602738895,
-0.0046917228,
0.0258924719,
-0.0117178336,
-0.0167781021,
-6.307118613e-33,
-0.0325038508,
0.0117879631,
0.0366376862,
-0.0454730727,
-0.0619203746,
-0.0179455355,
-0.0547345839,
-0.0110335657,
-0.0159616321,
0.014728345,
0.0147487903,
-0.0005830849,
0.0138585856,
0.0429514386,
-0.0261607245,
0.0284357704,
0.0714443773,
-0.0219271258,
-0.0146218902,
0.0249173846,
0.0098374328,
0.0425949655,
0.0663786903,
-0.013614458,
-0.0116358967,
-0.0034586047,
-0.0025055485,
0.0048260028,
0.0405001529,
0.0184693281,
-0.0290467665,
-0.0182449576,
0.0106246099,
-0.0230557192,
-0.0435126126,
0.0072845547,
-0.0617516711,
-0.0049612974,
-0.0011687836,
0.0343330204,
-0.0261068251,
-0.030822413,
0.0586965606,
-0.0390002392,
-0.0094054816,
0.0009748496,
0.0120449942,
-0.007435434,
-0.0167614743,
0.0068132533,
-0.0543646216,
0.0208254457,
0.0059167617,
-0.0264173672,
0.0263852216,
0.0409029238,
-0.0266560055,
0.0210135449,
-0.0846511126,
0.0010223738,
-0.0204258729,
0.0487490855,
0.0697313622,
0.0249658283,
0.0028544276,
0.034250889,
0.0401660688,
0.0263972618,
0.0455152877,
0.0256464742,
0.0413792059,
0.0236128792,
0.0200834572,
0.0197068006,
0.0190671124,
-0.0297219809,
-0.0838360637,
0.0381538682,
-0.0530293435,
0.008548297,
0.0476562046,
0.001477862,
0.0360291637,
0.0061390665,
-0.0482479595,
-0.0523602404,
-0.0113652786,
-0.0365807004,
0.0145078152,
0.0444644317,
-0.0201207846,
-0.0278766081,
0.0744397789,
-0.0040441379,
-0.0223245509,
-0.0167905409,
-0.0361919925,
0.0171080381,
-0.0148013765,
0.0267642066,
-0.0507103875,
-0.0702361241,
-0.0029823699,
0.0319462791,
-0.0076696007,
0.0067484835,
0.0195912551,
0.0102557922,
-0.0403237715,
0.0163375158,
-0.0654858425,
0.0175204091,
-0.0098612951,
0.0710171685,
0.0085840048,
-0.0038630872,
-0.0315875188,
0.0369750597,
0.0077418312,
-0.0221566707,
0.0226414315,
-0.0220476836,
0.0224002209,
0.0656514987,
-0.0394699723,
0.0231212508,
-0.0410598442,
0.0683774054,
0.073315464,
-0.0609630756,
-0.0354932174,
0.0170294605,
2.762e-7,
0.0379066207,
0.0249163155,
0.0019801217,
0.0521295369,
0.011840092,
0.0231064614,
-0.0375950299,
0.0460319221,
0.0128027825,
-0.0282018688,
0.0109159471,
0.031429477,
0.0587432683,
-0.0041236933,
-0.0497678965,
-0.0329676345,
-0.0115885418,
0.0342417955,
-0.0261954851,
-0.0204199925,
-0.0120664714,
0.0715899244,
-0.0301912632,
-0.0062583685,
0.0143644512,
-0.0027067044,
0.1208260208,
-0.0237437896,
-0.0201774985,
0.0099407732,
-0.0173271392,
0.0052557574,
-0.046900481,
-0.014771211,
-0.056321241,
0.0366986357,
0.0226315502,
0.0475269966,
0.0036388172,
-0.0373853035,
0.05906884,
0.020131845,
-0.040982265,
-0.0322072357,
0.0466650911,
-0.0557391793,
-0.0046726982,
0.0028093343,
-0.026095517,
0.0268092118,
0.0697018504,
-0.0665475503,
-0.0714364871,
0.0461258739,
0.0598732606,
0.0191736929,
-0.0343592502,
-0.0170920566,
-0.0218053106,
-0.0057358709,
-0.0245318525,
-0.0214612912,
-0.0439730994,
-0.0026800265,
-0.0095608737,
0.0132269952,
-0.0100529706,
2.220942292e-34,
0.0478798971,
-0.0356243104,
-0.0033147819,
-0.0154095162,
0.0208213422,
-0.015745081,
-0.0100595681,
-0.0019400854,
-0.0172763411,
-0.0462952405,
-0.0272746347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13528v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13528v2 | FacTool: Factuality Detection in Generative AI -- A Tool Augmented Framework for Multi-Task and Multi-Domain Scenarios | 2023-07-25T14:20:51 | 2023-07-26T15:17:49 | I-Chun Chern, Steffi Chern, Shiqi Chen, Weizhe Yuan, Kehua Feng, Chunting Zhou, Junxian He, Graham Neubig, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The emergence of generative pre-trained models has facilitated the synthesis
of high-quality text, but it has also posed challenges in identifying factual
errors in the generated text. In particular: (1) A wider range of tasks now
face an increasing risk of containing factual errors when handled by generative
models. (2) Generated texts tend to be lengthy and lack a clearly defined
granularity for individual facts. (3) There is a scarcity of explicit evidence
available during the process of fact checking. With the above challenges in
mind, in this paper, we propose FacTool, a task and domain agnostic framework
for detecting factual errors of texts generated by large language models (e.g.,
ChatGPT). Experiments on four different tasks (knowledge-based QA, code
generation, mathematical reasoning, and scientific literature review) show the
efficacy of the proposed method. We release the code of FacTool associated with
ChatGPT plugin interface at https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/factool . | [
0.0219860487,
0.0224714372,
0.0009913001,
0.0258358978,
-0.0193015095,
0.0147820711,
0.0173540004,
-0.0313899107,
0.0117394347,
-0.0356027968,
0.028961109,
-0.034748368,
0.0135823842,
0.0602134131,
0.0371349603,
0.0056107361,
0.0557954125,
-0.0065230587,
0.0431546941,
-0.0088254241,
0.0010472967,
0.0428991765,
-0.0408696234,
0.0311951693,
-0.057036031,
-0.0533153452,
0.005267092,
-0.0192720369,
0.0305077881,
-0.0058243466,
0.0126793869,
0.0537852123,
-0.0275213588,
0.0723390356,
0.0000020877,
-0.039743647,
-0.0239426978,
0.0202245489,
-0.0215223152,
0.0207754094,
0.037320815,
0.0390099734,
-0.0448628627,
0.0144171603,
-0.051787626,
-0.0265304707,
0.0550599881,
0.0470671169,
0.0605148599,
0.085700199,
-0.0070629166,
0.0140317986,
0.0388999172,
0.0060110888,
0.0266229175,
-0.0040228278,
0.0223943982,
0.0619168729,
-0.011619241,
0.0346061848,
0.0097671552,
0.0398824997,
0.0325165652,
-0.0498764105,
-0.014592668,
0.0435281396,
0.0076539051,
-0.0286991224,
0.0083263954,
0.018397186,
-0.0023135978,
-0.0630924329,
0.0192723144,
-0.0104520647,
-0.0070382161,
-0.0094917072,
0.0156576056,
0.0543398522,
-0.0503826477,
0.0011787579,
0.026884988,
-0.0438802093,
0.0113542024,
-0.0156513583,
0.020440504,
0.029890364,
0.009963545,
-0.0417493172,
-0.0594675541,
0.0291321613,
-0.0292740855,
-0.1052928492,
-0.0142641468,
0.0060629556,
-0.0143690789,
-0.0006132607,
-0.0622263066,
-0.0358598009,
0.0323625617,
-0.0333309285,
-0.0151430108,
-0.0056920536,
-0.024408577,
0.0152558694,
-0.0014824908,
0.0384982564,
0.0338678621,
-0.0008654881,
0.0215071328,
0.005399405,
-0.0180981755,
-0.0022484241,
-0.0099191219,
-0.007882121,
-0.0150237512,
0.0342982374,
-0.0243142284,
0.0169257224,
-0.0339840539,
0.0604629628,
0.0157435238,
-0.011595971,
-0.0337934494,
-0.0167430099,
-0.0419607386,
-0.0096941758,
-0.0076519884,
0.023300061,
0.0098321717,
-0.0637045428,
-0.0134049589,
0.0200789794,
-0.0024607738,
-0.0010142289,
-0.0091303224,
0.0167280529,
0.0027616441,
0.0044893036,
-0.0421604402,
-0.0466826819,
-0.0124874534,
-0.0696597919,
-0.0280050356,
-0.0898352563,
0.0050570611,
-0.0142265763,
-0.0112801297,
-0.0360096656,
-0.0142724877,
0.0434447341,
0.0004460446,
0.0459189601,
-0.0735114887,
-0.0019661433,
0.0104580764,
-0.0025495584,
-0.000905545,
0.0359526686,
0.0345973596,
0.0014141732,
0.0327369124,
0.0433857776,
0.0421284437,
-0.0305147935,
0.0114006987,
-0.0084443251,
0.0531388149,
-0.0098339403,
-0.0137225166,
0.0026806297,
0.0349925049,
0.0546769835,
-0.0309637953,
0.0155235473,
0.0483410135,
-0.0104334466,
0.0221736468,
0.0522782318,
0.0945480764,
-0.0155386813,
0.0307320133,
0.0328922942,
-0.0346853025,
0.0151896691,
-0.0299966205,
0.0175661817,
-0.0079470407,
0.07015457,
0.0177831929,
-0.0792242885,
-0.0254305322,
-0.0018815637,
-0.0302960295,
-0.0527826138,
0.0349527225,
0.0366588235,
-0.0394722633,
-0.0221386719,
0.0228510946,
-0.0642308369,
-0.0162401106,
-0.0525127351,
0.0473454259,
0.0159204789,
0.0716786757,
-0.0332844816,
-0.0487211943,
-0.0226019733,
-0.0308773462,
0.0671140999,
0.0428727306,
-0.0230867192,
-0.039341379,
-0.0039477111,
0.0041205646,
-0.0275582597,
0.0403990559,
-0.0027772274,
0.0305540189,
0.0266435891,
0.0202446785,
-0.024750283,
-0.024677109,
0.0275504403,
-0.043826744,
-0.0112480726,
-0.0135786394,
-0.0120903002,
0.0037135396,
0.0062461155,
-0.0618170127,
0.0239278395,
-0.0144360466,
0.0282455161,
-0.0344246887,
0.0187889375,
0.0052794237,
-0.0585152209,
0.0388052799,
-0.0425577685,
-0.0475563854,
-0.0225250497,
-0.0343674943,
-0.0091319317,
-0.0193581712,
-0.0236178208,
-0.0057250923,
-0.0552723669,
0.0010358121,
0.0252883509,
0.0066074454,
0.0192769896,
0.0857463107,
0.007908457,
-0.0207242854,
0.013249944,
0.0101239635,
0.0180801768,
-0.0165211298,
0.0146147134,
0.0132509945,
-0.0035003186,
0.0313631929,
0.0398390815,
0.0369621329,
-0.0222178157,
0.0014433847,
-0.0807153657,
0.0094040213,
-0.0113295875,
0.0229520611,
0.0324980468,
-0.0248765536,
-0.0289691444,
0.015589498,
-0.0074735233,
-0.0158576295,
0.0259238649,
-0.0207177382,
0.0641343668,
-0.0242094975,
0.0248179939,
-0.0359243788,
0.0322630443,
-0.0584320799,
0.0270298645,
0.0578433685,
-0.0000577373,
-0.0737469867,
0.0708829388,
-0.074111715,
0.0317168124,
0.0216606036,
-0.0245920829,
0.0153827863,
0.0032579622,
0.1059920266,
0.0467270017,
0.0118399821,
0.0213455595,
0.0364034064,
-0.0163452961,
-0.0055712718,
0.0296996087,
-0.0229733232,
0.0149577325,
0.0325873792,
-0.0295481645,
0.0410952903,
0.0436822586,
0.0196994636,
-0.0403190665,
-0.017325459,
0.0653339252,
-0.0284341592,
-0.0185113605,
0.0361234173,
0.0127778128,
0.0048382725,
0.0382341892,
-0.0224733315,
-0.0285482313,
0.0681862682,
-0.0433882065,
0.0120305978,
-0.0617639981,
0.0120879412,
-0.0051941578,
0.0065761642,
0.0156430565,
0.0339065492,
0.0504249297,
0.0264462754,
-0.0242518857,
0.0289913341,
0.0524392016,
0.0014860425,
0.024446357,
-0.0676117614,
0.0149475588,
0.0172599163,
-0.0400097407,
-0.0468774028,
-0.0135231977,
0.0172361061,
-0.024192214,
0.0209680386,
-0.0282392036,
-0.0270581599,
-0.0482487082,
0.022022957,
0.0461595133,
0.0056680604,
-0.0376781933,
-0.021222543,
0.0164074749,
0.0352309905,
0.0017467055,
0.0600595288,
-0.0073761172,
-0.0077260393,
0.0678555593,
-0.0383776017,
0.0186292157,
-0.0075183255,
-0.0579209365,
-0.0241810717,
-0.024992073,
-0.034014672,
0.0052412627,
0.0582130589,
-0.0403386801,
-0.0373932011,
0.0995154306,
0.0337579623,
0.0187674277,
-0.0065585156,
0.0013153972,
0.0254898556,
-0.0124207484,
0.0297373217,
-0.1074303016,
0.0160036478,
0.0039081536,
-0.0027294017,
-0.0477702022,
-0.016222015,
-0.0278395638,
-0.1120729223,
0.0786855146,
0.0015897049,
0.0210574865,
-0.0443629846,
-0.0345795117,
-0.0050383294,
-0.005822564,
-0.0136191705,
0.0166924652,
-0.0119225821,
0.0470169522,
0.030231256,
-0.0224025119,
-0.061450392,
0.0121158054,
-0.0355088934,
0.0651641637,
0.0422430895,
0.0418388657,
0.0206368584,
-0.010132187,
-0.0126150232,
0.040947251,
-0.0447261594,
0.0086565213,
0.0455416553,
-0.0145577267,
-0.0023750938,
-0.0278598089,
0.0202001743,
-0.0129577192,
-0.0387552157,
-0.0023794468,
0.0706864223,
-0.0172268879,
-0.0418457165,
-0.0174280088,
0.0235536192,
0.0084719779,
0.0557510033,
0.0149306767,
0.0403829031,
-0.0578298233,
-0.0682701916,
-0.0100821424,
-0.0478016548,
-0.045021832,
0.0026098094,
0.0009893734,
-0.0526620969,
-0.0974146649,
-0.0447152182,
0.0129625062,
0.0226555374,
-0.0209317394,
-0.0617057718,
0.0374232382,
-0.010861068,
-0.0056016282,
-0.032684356,
-0.0442988314,
0.0049870014,
-0.011941121,
-0.0208979025,
0.0232378803,
-0.019213587,
-0.0207991395,
0.025390666,
-0.0835551023,
-0.0426025577,
0.0139292888,
0.0429844558,
0.0163279306,
0.0147025343,
-0.074250944,
0.01148206,
0.040123079,
0.0994223654,
-0.0419845171,
0.0376155525,
0.0293315127,
-0.0185914151,
0.0026946568,
-0.0006370167,
-0.0174389761,
0.033838544,
-0.0532477088,
0.0248995591,
-0.0130020464,
-0.0166962445,
0.0437572114,
0.0259573963,
0.02906565,
-0.0168483965,
0.0290786847,
-0.0753809214,
-0.0378819704,
-0.0461659357,
-0.0308881551,
-0.0273263752,
0.0526509061,
-0.0373125076,
0.0193352308,
-0.010748649,
0.0277357232,
-0.0536476597,
0.0294590648,
-0.0064273607,
0.0009853686,
0.0319645256,
0.0494953617,
0.0123433452,
-0.0411291607,
-0.0172602199,
-0.0066802311,
-0.0238067098,
0.0253910869,
-0.0064788284,
0.0340103284,
0.0380449072,
-0.0178372152,
0.0078276889,
-0.0138903894,
-0.0628836378,
-0.0112691848,
-0.0645638704,
0.0500165671,
0.0866689831,
0.0394834056,
0.073286742,
-0.0835893676,
-0.0075526647,
-0.02057245,
0.0333311036,
0.0427154377,
-0.0204955246,
-0.0382999331,
-0.0007972551,
-0.0356621668,
-0.0495354347,
0.0874863416,
-0.002676538,
0.0592129864,
0.0141499108,
-0.0501964167,
-0.0418618768,
-0.0762593821,
-0.0560484752,
-0.0678717345,
0.0149017647,
-0.0139323194,
-0.0653669387,
-0.079793781,
0.0017104783,
0.0872252733,
0.0304834545,
0.0263368469,
0.0035334078,
0.0704990849,
0.0099792723,
-0.0083416561,
-0.0391089506,
0.0342014991,
-0.017807547,
0.0016685582,
-0.0048679342,
-6.028319271e-33,
-0.0493452176,
-0.070608303,
0.0287208166,
0.0101053705,
-0.0062500956,
0.0093005076,
-0.0522701815,
-0.0154131707,
0.015103342,
0.0693243518,
0.029153578,
0.0423930958,
-0.0006942128,
-0.0186102428,
-0.0168092009,
-0.0057262238,
0.0742243379,
0.0123068681,
-0.0379381068,
0.0200471431,
0.0485126488,
-0.0218984466,
0.0545924306,
-0.0721089318,
0.0580091812,
-0.0260700285,
-0.0500933006,
0.0129728243,
-0.0309703778,
0.0449505858,
-0.0060921782,
0.0386539064,
0.0004915453,
-0.0151662836,
-0.0240866654,
-0.0507097319,
-0.0611433573,
-0.0405175462,
0.0103081558,
-0.0229711123,
-0.022291176,
-0.0190846175,
0.0135699287,
-0.0146617405,
-0.0180711951,
-0.0111344131,
0.0570561029,
-0.0032254432,
0.0342357978,
-0.060764458,
-0.0864143819,
0.0296052955,
0.0077277715,
-0.0043087746,
-0.0444440022,
0.0211085919,
0.0357107334,
-0.0333003663,
-0.0489850156,
0.0113102375,
0.0238629971,
0.0044960724,
0.0522668399,
-0.0496189483,
-0.0117827207,
0.0431544334,
-0.0190031473,
0.0246719681,
-0.0634048283,
0.025739627,
-0.0058300118,
0.0171449315,
0.0159028061,
0.1047977209,
0.0133370264,
-0.0189913437,
-0.0540324897,
0.0377133973,
-0.0053856634,
0.0111079989,
-0.0063394783,
-0.0431527868,
-0.0448345803,
0.0031314227,
-0.0104377195,
0.027384948,
-0.0124763874,
-0.0282422546,
0.008421856,
-0.0059097358,
0.0029913071,
-0.0075325458,
-0.0299456902,
-0.0279034637,
0.0214532558,
0.0035655128,
-0.0632300004,
-0.0092820758,
-0.0262047704,
0.0296642594,
-0.0134836221,
0.006112949,
0.0283452906,
0.0486448593,
0.0136453677,
0.0312300734,
0.0322612114,
0.0311871395,
-0.0553518571,
0.0299630184,
-0.0319034979,
0.0261418298,
0.0177127067,
-0.008138827,
0.0006111641,
-0.0062904241,
-0.0170054212,
0.0077105793,
0.0233806521,
0.0628893301,
-0.0453476012,
0.0269479677,
-0.0190783627,
0.0220218431,
-0.0311360527,
-0.0050042849,
-0.0473880246,
-0.0134999417,
0.0176607557,
-0.0658312961,
0.002254572,
-0.0090534203,
2.75e-7,
0.0096069081,
0.0630945563,
0.0463854671,
0.0143092638,
0.0180874951,
0.0318918265,
-0.0048935255,
0.0152865527,
-0.008064975,
0.014787145,
-0.0044036862,
0.0232132822,
0.0128783965,
0.065600872,
-0.0511042476,
0.023665607,
-0.0490789153,
-0.0393741839,
-0.0422233604,
-0.0093138013,
0.0626932234,
0.0307138935,
0.0322799794,
0.0201172046,
0.0332594141,
-0.0147548346,
0.0401997864,
0.0498003587,
-0.0520635769,
0.0551713519,
0.0778349712,
0.0007272087,
0.0328475051,
-0.0210115779,
-0.0233913977,
-0.0282057803,
-0.0189025234,
0.0361779332,
0.0211890247,
0.0276365168,
0.004360145,
-0.0240522772,
0.0289457124,
-0.051458925,
0.0463348776,
-0.0190358311,
-0.0066176294,
-0.0572097674,
-0.0190610886,
0.0201233216,
0.0013833973,
-0.0164704863,
-0.0470178165,
-0.0116705708,
-0.0053113755,
0.0174066797,
-0.0116236359,
-0.0145239811,
-0.0169436596,
0.026734272,
-0.0389940068,
-0.0694168136,
0.0320500955,
-0.0183089525,
0.0507746488,
-0.0521191694,
0.0414054841,
2.850499414e-34,
0.0646535605,
-0.0054125576,
-0.00841258,
-0.0464452393,
0.0666899607,
0.0240462106,
-0.0030939307,
-0.0167161357,
0.0110222632,
-0.0044069458,
-0.0215018038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13497v1 | Zshot: An Open-source Framework for Zero-Shot Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction | 2023-07-25T13:46:36 | 2023-07-25T13:46:36 | Gabriele Picco, Marcos Martínez Galindo, Alberto Purpura, Leopold Fuchs, Vanessa López, Hoang Thanh Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The Zero-Shot Learning (ZSL) task pertains to the identification of entities
or relations in texts that were not seen during training. ZSL has emerged as a
critical research area due to the scarcity of labeled data in specific domains,
and its applications have grown significantly in recent years. With the advent
of large pretrained language models, several novel methods have been proposed,
resulting in substantial improvements in ZSL performance. There is a growing
demand, both in the research community and industry, for a comprehensive ZSL
framework that facilitates the development and accessibility of the latest
methods and pretrained models.In this study, we propose a novel ZSL framework
called Zshot that aims to address the aforementioned challenges. Our primary
objective is to provide a platform that allows researchers to compare different
state-of-the-art ZSL methods with standard benchmark datasets. Additionally, we
have designed our framework to support the industry with readily available APIs
for production under the standard SpaCy NLP pipeline. Our API is extendible and
evaluable, moreover, we include numerous enhancements such as boosting the
accuracy with pipeline ensembling and visualization utilities available as a
SpaCy extension. | [
-0.0035178973,
0.0372605585,
0.0409823023,
0.024412768,
-0.0057411725,
0.0333968364,
0.0210622288,
0.0183905941,
-0.0014945546,
-0.0758740008,
-0.0282267835,
0.0020741303,
-0.0111975223,
0.0040028198,
0.0032022244,
-0.0257216301,
0.0186836682,
0.0306841098,
0.0437497683,
0.0590116195,
0.0053389715,
0.0121352859,
-0.043181058,
0.0056088381,
-0.0007385396,
0.0008408031,
-0.0031365941,
0.000679785,
0.0439633429,
-0.0817301348,
0.012275259,
0.0583883673,
-0.00586189,
0.0781285837,
0.0000020499,
-0.0653141588,
-0.0341194049,
-0.0084853694,
-0.0361979604,
-0.0491576456,
0.0092420885,
-0.0533845872,
-0.018502444,
-0.0122252805,
-0.0210998226,
-0.1002800465,
0.0434763059,
0.0444979854,
0.017821148,
0.0817086324,
-0.0348173119,
-0.0293832626,
0.0158813391,
-0.0095025795,
-0.0123422109,
-0.0194709674,
0.025669476,
-0.0742621273,
-0.0116601977,
0.0264184568,
0.0033447943,
0.0063663209,
-0.0095735388,
-0.0038657745,
0.0290806983,
0.0633565709,
-0.0711512268,
-0.0227176696,
-0.0137428837,
0.110833019,
-0.0000588297,
-0.0038476454,
0.0279987324,
-0.0170617253,
-0.0319109298,
-0.0199848786,
-0.026970217,
0.0161951575,
0.0085114613,
0.0117805731,
-0.0103248656,
0.0006046834,
0.0143029727,
-0.0147478627,
-0.0047457675,
0.0213796329,
0.01013886,
-0.0117941638,
0.012741616,
0.023512464,
0.0234018005,
-0.0738794208,
-0.0147844655,
0.0447467007,
0.0253330562,
0.0236049462,
-0.009729675,
-0.0255381782,
-0.0077071665,
-0.0214097388,
0.0155407144,
0.0026276854,
0.0016957663,
0.0527197458,
-0.0642425567,
-0.0111543369,
0.0412061028,
-0.014435959,
0.0068060718,
0.0089307623,
-0.0640709028,
0.0150010018,
-0.0378702693,
0.0401556827,
-0.0232622661,
-0.0067657446,
-0.0307525843,
-0.025123721,
0.0005153145,
0.0426369868,
-0.029022919,
-0.0104151703,
0.0096625034,
0.0002571881,
-0.005560833,
0.063305743,
-0.0213673692,
-0.0058023948,
-0.0303300973,
-0.0452668853,
-0.033845827,
-0.014584464,
0.0380338915,
-0.0325652957,
0.0297560412,
0.0733791441,
0.0266738702,
-0.1083553359,
-0.0373152941,
-0.0211394001,
0.0242386144,
-0.058099024,
0.0077792699,
-0.0397975333,
0.0512230769,
0.0145909069,
0.0085537732,
-0.0188434012,
0.0203505885,
0.0146545535,
-0.0624807328,
0.058683984,
-0.0574528202,
-0.0232413113,
-0.0434204191,
0.0153901353,
0.0652708262,
0.0763408691,
0.0091433423,
-0.0220657848,
0.0410811156,
0.0050147381,
-0.012947469,
0.0171718709,
0.0343022011,
-0.0136673683,
0.0100902058,
0.010656761,
0.010372146,
-0.0064979247,
0.0233709812,
-0.0489650182,
-0.0302100144,
-0.0202909466,
0.0203617606,
0.0495576933,
0.0028280795,
-0.032337673,
0.0308865681,
-0.0023015037,
0.0357391126,
-0.0433147028,
-0.0331970043,
0.0195385609,
-0.0285749137,
0.0091093443,
-0.0562943183,
0.0217023902,
-0.0297531486,
0.0203335471,
-0.0228142235,
-0.0370327644,
-0.0352437124,
-0.0179146715,
0.0830691755,
0.0367411412,
-0.0684948415,
0.0637174621,
0.0448153168,
-0.0244465638,
-0.0262342151,
0.0259433035,
0.0080178818,
0.055934947,
0.0670564622,
-0.0515950434,
-0.0629649535,
-0.0489152782,
0.0097824428,
0.0445426814,
-0.0088026803,
-0.0189258475,
0.0772613958,
-0.0138629833,
-0.0276663732,
-0.0015494036,
0.0255749393,
-0.0001047938,
0.0468694009,
0.0405258201,
0.0198076684,
0.0018707216,
0.027518671,
0.0463133045,
-0.0310157556,
-0.0572543964,
0.018043587,
0.0091135539,
-0.0165151618,
0.0618588887,
-0.0369879715,
-0.0273762345,
0.0387627371,
-0.0174899604,
0.0030103447,
-0.0014138762,
0.001492566,
-0.0390677378,
0.0062555745,
-0.0111255236,
-0.0222588331,
-0.0122213801,
-0.0419662744,
-0.0259207375,
-0.012498091,
0.0687946081,
0.0523225516,
-0.0084035555,
0.014769935,
0.0323561355,
0.0449732766,
-0.0262336135,
0.0507356189,
0.0349964835,
0.0209278855,
0.005039189,
-0.0344158858,
0.0109509779,
0.0012002133,
-0.0286572613,
0.023313297,
-0.0220804457,
-0.0386684127,
-0.0082016811,
0.0294857807,
-0.0719603002,
0.0481582806,
-0.0757603869,
0.0279367901,
0.0062459707,
0.0491811968,
0.0151808811,
0.0214876719,
-0.0366746187,
-0.0296362527,
0.0351211317,
0.0080879694,
-0.0237368848,
-0.0149244657,
0.0481463298,
0.0121861836,
-0.0238462333,
-0.0117336093,
-0.0029137642,
-0.0427967794,
0.0444733426,
0.0099534923,
-0.0149298888,
0.0121050123,
0.0629275888,
-0.0330649838,
0.0215098374,
0.0272664782,
0.0061574052,
-0.0147894341,
0.0134075293,
-0.0092055313,
0.0458537117,
-0.0522483252,
0.0479927845,
-0.0318623632,
-0.0328106582,
-0.0137850195,
0.013365699,
-0.0398217849,
0.0146083264,
0.0151785845,
0.0066192783,
0.0090203015,
0.0897871107,
-0.0386877581,
0.0175436363,
-0.0214096587,
0.0117156925,
0.0057331333,
0.0024196187,
0.0071279346,
0.0600086711,
0.0390949734,
-0.0040197154,
-0.0261758137,
-0.0161984824,
0.0246489681,
-0.0410215296,
-0.0406289026,
-0.0061272387,
0.0118223904,
-0.0409734435,
0.0565477982,
0.0212985668,
-0.0053834813,
0.062849693,
-0.0309287068,
0.0089252442,
0.0087464638,
0.0003947085,
0.0101474458,
-0.016662797,
-0.0143520152,
0.034378089,
-0.0377316475,
0.0206390731,
-0.010281845,
-0.0224574301,
-0.0578375831,
0.0098303705,
-0.0514854081,
-0.0193727799,
0.0188219622,
0.0215022545,
-0.0041549853,
0.0461814627,
0.0174221341,
-0.0225690361,
-0.0137594519,
0.0483673923,
0.0345309228,
-0.0447569937,
0.025598364,
0.0128278034,
0.0276502464,
0.0469827466,
0.0216124523,
0.0274172816,
0.0143793207,
-0.0096606975,
0.0022409877,
-0.0815541297,
0.0033071314,
-0.0282151401,
0.0159427039,
-0.0508834384,
-0.0072336104,
0.1268569827,
0.0301860925,
-0.02808824,
-0.000599008,
0.03405305,
-0.0041749049,
0.0436395593,
0.009244265,
-0.1076324359,
-0.0617971309,
-0.0087486999,
-0.0105449054,
-0.0146626038,
-0.0887591988,
-0.0153922085,
-0.1338529736,
0.0027335486,
-0.0263149142,
-0.0604835823,
0.036951866,
-0.0784125477,
0.0239990968,
-0.0451954268,
-0.0503296927,
-0.0285501461,
-0.0375446491,
0.0037373658,
-0.0282944217,
0.0234921109,
-0.0729686469,
0.0162964519,
-0.042007491,
0.0590375438,
0.0285263788,
0.0218742788,
-0.0110379886,
0.0392616875,
-0.0143196816,
-0.044125326,
-0.0435326137,
-0.0417212583,
0.0767379105,
-0.0509768873,
-0.0223056842,
-0.0357535407,
0.0111181056,
-0.0510101505,
-0.0194129441,
-0.0087122638,
0.0414631218,
0.0186269637,
-0.0015147764,
-0.0113735972,
-0.0267145038,
0.0133176185,
0.0774424821,
0.0017920748,
-0.0019754483,
-0.0624419674,
0.0107660312,
-0.013295114,
-0.0456669182,
-0.0045841876,
0.0037245569,
-0.0582156405,
-0.0620838255,
-0.0171072297,
-0.0462775305,
0.0836308524,
0.0499236919,
-0.0019829727,
0.0000791891,
-0.0058579715,
0.0147740003,
-0.0832035094,
0.0345381312,
-0.0240529347,
0.0365063064,
-0.0321002267,
-0.0195985921,
0.0282444227,
0.0136429779,
-0.014922603,
-0.0114784352,
-0.0783238187,
-0.0409699902,
-0.0159901287,
0.0255963001,
0.0131821027,
0.0277199335,
-0.0122458469,
-0.011833963,
0.0632825121,
0.0809309036,
-0.0571366139,
-0.0053894846,
0.023943821,
-0.0014488784,
-0.0032068877,
0.0307682771,
0.0022229056,
0.024653472,
0.0276004709,
0.0429176055,
-0.02043158,
0.0003740789,
-0.0167181846,
-0.0109651964,
0.0673225522,
0.0141904503,
-0.0122322179,
-0.0402499847,
0.0097044446,
-0.0461267941,
0.0107828239,
-0.0205625203,
-0.0161845013,
-0.0025659639,
0.0051756962,
-0.0152186649,
0.0620366111,
-0.0409478173,
0.0442426763,
-0.0269605573,
0.021252213,
0.0392383114,
0.0149560571,
0.0097154872,
-0.0356223136,
0.0270284489,
0.0337822698,
-0.0066060969,
0.0408117585,
-0.0199070834,
0.0379108042,
0.0019350643,
-0.0087145511,
-0.0156038469,
0.0226581395,
-0.0169130713,
0.0300288536,
-0.0320242159,
0.0643917248,
0.0567835607,
-0.0534210354,
0.0633200705,
-0.0048195007,
-0.0129748555,
0.026627833,
0.0363424122,
-0.0362054259,
-0.0079395548,
-0.0052787173,
0.0213802587,
-0.0201183967,
0.0018796994,
0.0649810657,
0.0427319966,
0.0330167077,
0.0485280044,
0.006356752,
-0.0311698783,
-0.0045146267,
0.0425700955,
0.0196448322,
0.0050170138,
0.0229057372,
-0.0781066716,
-0.0618963912,
0.0182673074,
-0.0574882627,
-0.031278111,
0.0445438288,
0.0166759361,
-0.018015366,
0.0264510289,
-0.0112476032,
-0.0444194973,
0.0143884635,
-0.0060583428,
-0.0356492661,
0.0088651162,
-6.509215479e-33,
-0.052036494,
-0.0455621742,
0.0016651509,
-0.0206788853,
-0.0135129681,
0.0505164266,
-0.0181652289,
-0.0106744021,
-0.0089818081,
-0.0029868172,
0.0111905271,
-0.0074947858,
0.0167317428,
0.0068415469,
-0.0145782186,
-0.0272976924,
0.0133302873,
0.0078217471,
-0.0134241991,
0.0064873383,
0.0302653406,
0.0626089498,
0.122350134,
-0.0499481596,
0.0193662103,
-0.0155313285,
-0.0035227693,
0.0134908957,
0.0719596222,
0.0406159125,
-0.017211603,
0.0138167767,
0.0235623959,
-0.0569880381,
0.0223664492,
0.0068548047,
-0.1462907046,
-0.0210500117,
-0.0259419549,
0.0244818293,
-0.015398561,
0.0105532343,
0.001828164,
-0.0073550534,
0.0299942382,
-0.0333151184,
0.0331871063,
-0.003734939,
0.00479506,
-0.0105034346,
-0.0902455822,
0.0278558321,
0.0053509059,
0.0027738535,
0.0549415164,
0.0349373072,
0.0249607265,
0.0368198939,
-0.0756143704,
-0.0327094123,
-0.0060712844,
-0.0141962022,
0.0411333703,
0.0215538796,
0.0055133337,
0.0473758914,
0.0198340025,
-0.0365440287,
-0.0350308977,
0.0332259573,
0.0332479104,
0.0193988085,
-0.0177655313,
0.0287019406,
0.0428313464,
-0.0014023217,
-0.0799785033,
0.0052904142,
-0.0065378775,
0.0285970774,
-0.0430802591,
-0.0183624569,
-0.0261210501,
0.0001043679,
0.0171139352,
-0.0526134521,
-0.0301341154,
-0.0219350792,
0.0105849439,
0.0260583647,
-0.0544748753,
0.0468964875,
0.0293028634,
-0.0233560316,
-0.041375272,
0.0197339207,
0.0300530568,
0.0252687335,
0.0089550493,
-0.001310427,
-0.1080584526,
-0.0374690704,
0.0210951269,
0.0112639982,
0.0395193435,
-0.0082423454,
0.0738108978,
-0.0063105053,
-0.0464936532,
-0.017635297,
-0.0197826512,
0.0418042541,
0.0018015648,
0.0627164468,
-0.0159913953,
0.0109089967,
-0.0157677382,
0.0517992862,
0.078402102,
-0.0045884461,
0.0022447451,
0.0363157131,
0.0174811501,
-0.0200034827,
-0.00056057,
-0.0143597163,
0.0092744213,
-0.0093625691,
0.0128703834,
-0.0774709061,
-0.0165440459,
-0.0233290866,
2.718e-7,
0.0362493992,
0.0203275084,
0.0292123873,
0.013454238,
0.0024234122,
0.0411603339,
0.0137563078,
0.0617084168,
-0.0388937742,
0.0092464583,
-0.0098238839,
-0.0032572753,
0.0028559654,
0.0110633811,
-0.0893575847,
-0.0194079634,
-0.0064950697,
-0.0274904929,
-0.0838052854,
0.021130519,
0.0480280928,
0.0480702892,
0.0357272103,
0.0010591743,
0.0029579359,
-0.0111893266,
0.04755532,
0.007993076,
0.0251722708,
0.0312122013,
-0.0045048124,
0.0542560704,
-0.021155294,
0.0094743939,
-0.0233489927,
0.036656376,
-0.0075772475,
0.0436854661,
-0.0406656116,
-0.0184256732,
0.018972287,
-0.0393812805,
0.0256496817,
-0.0156449657,
0.1032941043,
-0.0574894287,
-0.033374805,
-0.0014622555,
-0.0503030233,
0.0151292635,
0.003134338,
0.0224739928,
-0.0158903878,
0.0391489193,
0.0270068608,
-0.0294427108,
-0.0498833433,
-0.0557558462,
-0.0091386531,
0.0095907897,
0.0503609329,
0.0086251609,
0.0035108665,
-0.0607192107,
-0.0090311943,
-0.0337441713,
-0.0092500243,
2.843647108e-34,
-0.0233662371,
0.0129424892,
-0.016592877,
0.0541676022,
-0.0064802221,
-0.0273042899,
-0.0620181076,
-0.0246822592,
-0.0165936556,
-0.0378003195,
0.031241117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13424v1 | Holistic Exploration on Universal Decompositional Semantic Parsing: Architecture, Data Augmentation, and LLM Paradigm | 2023-07-25T11:44:28 | 2023-07-25T11:44:28 | Hexuan Deng, Xin Zhang, Meishan Zhang, Xuebo Liu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we conduct a holistic exploration of the Universal
Decompositional Semantic (UDS) Parsing. We first introduce a cascade model for
UDS parsing that decomposes the complex parsing task into semantically
appropriate subtasks. Our approach outperforms the prior models, while
significantly reducing inference time. We also incorporate syntactic
information and further optimized the architecture. Besides, different ways for
data augmentation are explored, which further improve the UDS Parsing. Lastly,
we conduct experiments to investigate the efficacy of ChatGPT in handling the
UDS task, revealing that it excels in attribute parsing but struggles in
relation parsing, and using ChatGPT for data augmentation yields suboptimal
results. Our code is available at https://github.com/hexuandeng/HExp4UDS. | [
0.0162079167,
0.0307226572,
-0.0070714196,
0.0512725189,
0.0098213917,
0.040499296,
-0.0225284472,
-0.0152696539,
-0.0204299223,
-0.0515036024,
-0.0080824476,
0.0587502308,
-0.0511689223,
-0.0172847454,
-0.0125336247,
-0.0367738493,
0.0678691417,
0.0263610724,
-0.0056769694,
0.0370256975,
0.0128394449,
0.0157653112,
0.0085872374,
0.0017132025,
-0.0632900447,
-0.0214716159,
-0.0210964438,
-0.0004035746,
-0.0058233249,
-0.0571876019,
-0.0000584093,
-0.0030206356,
0.0195238963,
0.0207227618,
0.000002006,
-0.0428156406,
-0.0538458936,
0.0408595838,
-0.0482583568,
-0.0240587443,
0.0821612775,
-0.0165946186,
0.0034669936,
-0.0029707081,
-0.0555440746,
-0.0853308439,
0.0091461372,
0.0600211695,
0.0333760343,
0.0939394385,
-0.0238193441,
-0.063319847,
0.0337456018,
0.0010953047,
-0.0077284402,
-0.0235944763,
0.00257354,
0.0117566222,
0.0304761697,
0.0168186482,
-0.0188812502,
0.0240583885,
0.0220439062,
0.0306334533,
0.0275605042,
0.0121638654,
-0.0541686155,
0.0018108964,
0.0076922635,
0.0359606184,
0.0071139787,
0.0094869155,
0.0159053169,
0.0285085402,
0.0124569852,
-0.0322744586,
-0.0342229605,
0.0038373824,
-0.0222584065,
0.0481025465,
0.0522859618,
-0.0066242502,
0.0132771861,
0.0079042837,
-0.0156778935,
0.0983824804,
-0.0153639819,
-0.0299852081,
0.0033780588,
0.0320097171,
-0.0059542744,
-0.0455848128,
0.0018380865,
-0.0009650459,
-0.0369772315,
0.0117614679,
-0.0145382779,
-0.0269365702,
-0.0132741192,
-0.0071313581,
-0.0185508598,
0.0445981734,
-0.0288133658,
0.0391844064,
-0.0143873226,
0.0102564013,
-0.0092805922,
-0.0053761839,
-0.0368446447,
-0.0079503441,
-0.0711507574,
-0.0103477649,
-0.0567491129,
0.0690315589,
-0.053019587,
-0.0092778252,
-0.0405333973,
0.024011394,
0.0110664768,
0.0196705051,
0.0620132089,
-0.0203380808,
-0.0211774316,
0.0500811897,
-0.0198986083,
0.0440107994,
-0.0290337577,
-0.0166317523,
0.004591879,
-0.0410463735,
-0.0054336484,
0.0014166449,
0.014212165,
-0.0548574738,
-0.0136459218,
0.1170872152,
0.0160983223,
-0.0070379134,
-0.0356266163,
-0.0410005786,
0.0183718242,
-0.0120617198,
0.0202456042,
-0.0588871874,
0.0336068943,
0.0330863036,
0.0089491792,
-0.0032110144,
-0.0064794305,
0.0025692515,
-0.0039272909,
0.0574155115,
-0.0497534461,
-0.0070334813,
-0.0298516527,
-0.011141751,
-0.0210526902,
0.070690386,
0.0053429464,
0.0191149879,
0.014957644,
0.0240240153,
-0.043274194,
0.0414893292,
-0.0108048758,
-0.0357237384,
0.0079078423,
-0.0043974076,
-0.0306151956,
0.0098927747,
0.0260753445,
0.0106739486,
-0.0367050655,
-0.0009213714,
-0.0268225074,
-0.0158875007,
-0.0042351317,
0.0407003872,
0.0504197627,
0.04409023,
-0.0103660189,
-0.0120428316,
-0.10676606,
-0.0202529449,
-0.0057119452,
0.0174404737,
-0.0683945641,
0.0238527767,
0.0131119164,
-0.0295493789,
-0.0058574439,
-0.0096972901,
0.016307544,
-0.0163806137,
0.0286272131,
0.0100549962,
-0.0073752599,
0.0475074314,
0.0420462042,
-0.0395633094,
0.0085776029,
-0.0031976791,
0.0055501619,
0.0638129041,
0.0570265464,
-0.0605611764,
-0.0475177169,
-0.0028263011,
0.0163589101,
0.0247305613,
-0.0074880267,
-0.0095891878,
0.0082075484,
-0.039962776,
-0.0425856262,
-0.03193032,
0.018795345,
-0.0193059836,
-0.0082275709,
-0.0364090279,
-0.0146782948,
-0.0201326963,
0.0212572049,
0.0426344909,
0.0239671748,
0.0285094902,
-0.0159571804,
0.0054933489,
-0.0058046943,
0.0357236601,
0.0049550068,
0.0043770387,
-0.009553127,
-0.0422436818,
-0.0074581942,
0.0396707542,
-0.0164155588,
-0.1006876528,
0.0471350998,
-0.0217054673,
-0.0526284315,
-0.0238489341,
-0.0642606467,
-0.0288070105,
-0.0088780439,
-0.012863555,
0.0595291369,
-0.0034048609,
0.0113354186,
0.0369042084,
-0.0169130173,
-0.0400617756,
0.1059326902,
0.0098881964,
0.0020129937,
-0.0153543111,
-0.0138380677,
0.024970958,
-0.0129888263,
-0.0176327545,
-0.026165653,
-0.0230825432,
-0.0442668423,
-0.007365007,
0.015185453,
-0.044054538,
0.0042071082,
-0.0469167344,
0.0024642737,
0.0004737421,
0.0783536434,
0.0411759503,
0.0421473086,
0.0090793138,
-0.0198367126,
-0.0301912334,
0.0275579337,
-0.0055318386,
-0.0146015827,
0.0567040406,
0.0042506726,
-0.0542455614,
-0.0030098949,
-0.004864681,
-0.0435890667,
0.0127385817,
0.0095348544,
-0.0362958536,
0.0093228705,
0.0103195729,
0.0120637845,
0.0365550444,
0.0318652354,
-0.0186511762,
-0.0133102089,
-0.0295261499,
-0.0031480594,
0.0278456658,
-0.0527820885,
0.0277669802,
-0.0273635015,
-0.0422425605,
-0.032486327,
0.0377977714,
0.0168400481,
0.0469868146,
-0.0555703864,
0.0195953995,
0.0094245728,
0.066345647,
-0.0326262116,
0.0092749186,
0.0018098541,
0.0022242703,
-0.0282961931,
-0.0337121263,
0.0032626647,
0.0176941268,
0.0212486126,
0.0210866649,
-0.0339601673,
0.0281378813,
0.0780772716,
-0.0104814516,
-0.0538230687,
-0.0408202671,
0.0062142592,
-0.0703105107,
0.0489576124,
0.015845295,
-0.0117142489,
-0.0381552279,
-0.0838847607,
-0.0101961391,
0.0115102818,
0.0297693089,
0.0102692507,
0.0300741307,
-0.0143099446,
0.01461796,
-0.0346892662,
-0.0244510695,
-0.0349481702,
-0.0171941072,
-0.0372663364,
0.017701786,
-0.0284854546,
0.0096252579,
0.0093742665,
-0.0366539359,
-0.035647627,
-0.0026778902,
-0.0072092521,
-0.0143251223,
-0.0273804553,
0.0101014907,
0.0188871231,
0.0069259312,
-0.0097375549,
0.0517731756,
0.0349225104,
0.0438341871,
-0.0015476164,
-0.0294520371,
-0.0401025563,
0.0265669748,
-0.0075483923,
-0.0371844359,
-0.0485809073,
-0.0460261069,
0.0193754435,
-0.081108667,
-0.016326081,
0.0970556289,
0.0390836671,
-0.0029974952,
0.0246858988,
0.0052402802,
0.0025999025,
0.0237580333,
0.0302112568,
-0.1183212474,
-0.0654079095,
0.0001325945,
-0.0179795343,
0.0416181274,
-0.0426979959,
0.0376425534,
-0.0640110373,
0.0245145168,
0.0016581183,
-0.031700734,
0.0434528701,
0.0005962054,
-0.0174049847,
-0.0790602863,
0.0314909033,
0.015526996,
-0.0466980599,
0.0151075199,
-0.0208094977,
0.0018794127,
-0.0140011497,
0.0179617256,
-0.0330046304,
0.0115297595,
0.0698051229,
-0.0024948379,
-0.0289313309,
-0.0027205255,
0.0606394187,
0.0166814551,
0.0198925044,
-0.0200926233,
0.0229056068,
-0.0413238332,
-0.0064553004,
-0.0337300971,
0.0085604154,
-0.0518266857,
0.0002126936,
0.0003058533,
0.0774598643,
-0.0192100201,
0.0497197546,
-0.0085400091,
-0.0596427657,
-0.0306559857,
0.0660538897,
0.0164095312,
0.0240317155,
-0.0734937638,
-0.0526607372,
-0.0419472903,
-0.0477003679,
0.0343434885,
0.044355806,
-0.0560937561,
-0.0605391711,
-0.0525381528,
-0.0503486432,
0.0409875028,
-0.0285064466,
-0.0360472426,
-0.0030544193,
0.0194044486,
-0.0044410252,
-0.0510236062,
0.0059875669,
-0.0226334147,
0.0330085233,
0.0305519197,
0.0128757786,
0.0360533893,
-0.001021051,
-0.0245671254,
-0.0132148545,
-0.0348356068,
-0.0354123116,
0.0267382618,
0.0187451839,
0.0158841964,
0.0520173125,
-0.0675181448,
-0.0182584915,
-0.0434904508,
0.0664304793,
-0.1025512591,
-0.0012768025,
0.0189338718,
0.049018234,
0.0314893648,
0.0216195583,
-0.0146152033,
0.0369882919,
-0.0306554958,
0.0528472364,
-0.0101356599,
0.0373214893,
0.0667492002,
0.0649730042,
0.0221784636,
0.0074489559,
0.0419997908,
0.003052372,
0.0190615039,
-0.0694158599,
-0.0275663789,
-0.0525186248,
0.0039955629,
-0.0087351678,
-0.0016775465,
0.0163513832,
-0.0130339833,
-0.0027965487,
0.0411689542,
-0.0176808555,
0.022449173,
0.0368037298,
-0.0055133239,
-0.0001430433,
0.0161659438,
0.001766075,
-0.0148651181,
0.0090478053,
-0.0230082609,
-0.0505154617,
0.0071027051,
0.0305311326,
-0.0136971753,
-0.071169652,
0.0136954365,
-0.0202482808,
0.0374935418,
0.0302263629,
0.0480255261,
0.0491440408,
-0.0062598172,
0.0696002543,
-0.0168896932,
0.0102430293,
0.0190161038,
0.0462592356,
0.0102392687,
-0.0307464991,
0.055760622,
0.0103960121,
-0.044631619,
-0.1008103415,
0.0627689585,
-0.0325859077,
0.0454308428,
0.015168922,
-0.0171458609,
-0.0533526428,
-0.0448329709,
0.001533746,
0.0357919671,
-0.0284941904,
0.0176722035,
-0.0230376665,
-0.0356085636,
-0.082533747,
0.0115960538,
-0.0148417586,
-0.0164886676,
0.043043673,
0.0199494548,
0.0433043391,
-0.0707076043,
0.0114649609,
-0.0062586204,
-0.0204872862,
-0.0459706672,
0.001159658,
-5.847862153e-33,
-0.0418260433,
0.0208987705,
0.0479080901,
0.031847354,
-0.0562069118,
-0.0109978803,
-0.0267483853,
-0.0035529621,
-0.0162745975,
0.0288755428,
-0.0236762892,
0.0133733647,
0.0208223742,
0.0421437882,
0.0465652049,
-0.0457398295,
0.0524896868,
-0.0100685842,
0.0089424336,
-0.0318652354,
0.0455992483,
0.0390891582,
0.0834700391,
-0.0515608452,
-0.005536858,
0.0091762338,
-0.0129305366,
0.0556757152,
0.0390462354,
0.0462710224,
-0.0028199435,
0.0004439961,
0.0450575799,
-0.0113735711,
-0.0290756598,
-0.0471446253,
-0.1443760544,
-0.0330423079,
0.0585827753,
0.0472345836,
-0.0759821162,
-0.013465629,
0.031613417,
-0.0119955307,
0.0327855535,
0.0116976285,
0.0072354046,
-0.0338031687,
0.0148119861,
-0.00315361,
-0.0414445288,
0.0414950959,
0.0010634831,
0.035207238,
0.0783781782,
-0.0243753288,
0.0015996238,
-0.0014430737,
-0.0053789755,
-0.0146350767,
-0.0049240184,
0.045646809,
0.0515472963,
-0.0114171337,
0.0203626566,
0.0298097227,
0.023198342,
-0.0488312356,
-0.0276092608,
0.0500875562,
-0.020247912,
0.0998537615,
-0.0187718496,
0.0221742056,
0.0242977887,
0.0192052796,
-0.0244180374,
0.0150714358,
0.0882053524,
0.0680378601,
-0.0620067418,
0.0562254451,
-0.0360850804,
-0.0016593275,
0.0209172443,
0.0431168526,
-0.0129309455,
-0.0634182617,
0.0189849474,
-0.0015011865,
-0.0056100818,
0.0443619639,
0.0211493149,
-0.0385790169,
-0.0000742095,
0.0015567993,
0.0196752064,
0.010491997,
-0.0102732368,
-0.0222888794,
0.0041130274,
-0.0672419965,
0.0129987914,
-0.0044114124,
0.0157908928,
0.0068245921,
0.0411351621,
0.0030339856,
-0.0184912216,
0.0295124445,
-0.0326947011,
0.0094173402,
-0.051161319,
0.0164083615,
0.0170813091,
0.0169557352,
-0.0269191805,
0.0270269755,
0.0394082479,
0.0324997827,
-0.0282853805,
0.0278938878,
0.0263443217,
0.0232624356,
-0.012428036,
-0.0283748079,
-0.0010868799,
-0.0585821196,
0.0105573833,
-0.0289322026,
-0.0123097263,
0.0147235002,
2.725e-7,
0.0533608198,
0.0194717906,
0.0748953149,
0.0378663726,
0.0109316818,
0.0017117877,
0.0169118457,
0.0438622162,
-0.0313983336,
-0.0193001255,
-0.0262209531,
-0.0155772613,
-0.0084826248,
0.0252116211,
-0.0842359364,
-0.0229011755,
0.0030073796,
-0.048520416,
-0.0556359775,
0.0084257582,
0.0930662304,
0.0802117512,
0.0198385101,
0.0149103971,
-0.0304874908,
0.0092453379,
-0.0088385129,
-0.0179574899,
-0.0273877326,
0.0179296006,
-0.0144248055,
0.0055261091,
0.0177143142,
0.0100174099,
0.0111057078,
0.0581772327,
0.0166028012,
0.0641927049,
-0.0198840667,
0.0497746356,
0.034766037,
-0.0712528229,
0.0102034025,
-0.0215566605,
0.0415776707,
-0.0444605872,
-0.0241810214,
-0.00971979,
-0.0328591056,
0.0117235743,
-0.067715548,
0.0102462275,
0.0021714836,
0.0274101403,
0.0533649847,
-0.0186887551,
-0.0535953306,
-0.0509013645,
-0.0499244966,
0.0162134506,
-0.0150976563,
-0.0221971013,
-0.0019093418,
0.0655740798,
0.0335938036,
-0.0637707412,
-0.0574341677,
2.625442296e-34,
0.0321378931,
0.0015953304,
0.0187024176,
0.0764468387,
0.0388097391,
-0.0023860789,
-0.0159094445,
0.0478915423,
-0.0228124,
-0.084571667,
0.0003072525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13417v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13417v1 | Towards Resolving Word Ambiguity with Word Embeddings | 2023-07-25T11:29:55 | 2023-07-25T11:29:55 | Matthias Thurnbauer, Johannes Reisinger, Christoph Goller, Andreas Fischer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ambiguity is ubiquitous in natural language. Resolving ambiguous meanings is
especially important in information retrieval tasks. While word embeddings
carry semantic information, they fail to handle ambiguity well. Transformer
models have been shown to handle word ambiguity for complex queries, but they
cannot be used to identify ambiguous words, e.g. for a 1-word query.
Furthermore, training these models is costly in terms of time, hardware
resources, and training data, prohibiting their use in specialized environments
with sensitive data. Word embeddings can be trained using moderate hardware
resources. This paper shows that applying DBSCAN clustering to the latent space
can identify ambiguous words and evaluate their level of ambiguity. An
automatic DBSCAN parameter selection leads to high-quality clusters, which are
semantically coherent and correspond well to the perceived meanings of a given
word. | [
0.0535416231,
0.0272201337,
-0.0405264534,
0.0627795011,
-0.0039636591,
0.0137786008,
-0.0007651011,
0.03472865,
0.0080173239,
0.00030261,
0.0065568686,
-0.0564700477,
-0.0095041804,
0.028072115,
-0.0116298757,
-0.0512027815,
0.1173761189,
0.0349567309,
0.0038740276,
0.0112839416,
0.009817617,
-0.0001166319,
0.0082037635,
-0.0029095793,
-0.0439627208,
0.0022258684,
-0.0274121594,
0.0019214367,
0.0021297163,
0.0196899306,
-0.0255510993,
0.0238637403,
0.0446257889,
0.0453575477,
0.0000017477,
0.0096223457,
-0.0626582354,
-0.0197287574,
-0.0101065412,
-0.0031408588,
0.0993985236,
-0.0242707543,
0.0313166045,
0.0108016627,
-0.0116819935,
-0.0253810361,
0.0454443321,
0.0563513972,
0.0241832659,
0.0333483443,
0.0088277422,
-0.0179495607,
-0.0224074051,
-0.0182786807,
-0.0236931276,
-0.0339952335,
0.01742821,
-0.0262698978,
-0.0030493741,
0.0631495044,
-0.0367294289,
0.0296689905,
-0.0413923562,
0.0169532783,
0.0018452653,
0.0179773476,
-0.0158955101,
-0.0170714539,
0.0352142751,
0.0467991866,
-0.0456254929,
0.0091511933,
0.011506984,
-0.0062164473,
0.0027531364,
0.0514989085,
0.0292933937,
-0.0149432942,
-0.0038787748,
-0.0109501062,
0.0139456596,
0.0351939388,
0.0442668274,
0.0263554957,
-0.0616529658,
0.0779886097,
0.0112274056,
-0.0210115518,
-0.0430112779,
-0.0242584478,
-0.0283594728,
0.003314446,
0.0673687384,
0.0268121306,
-0.040168073,
0.0641902089,
-0.0416977853,
-0.0391241759,
0.0344397835,
-0.0666702911,
-0.0760009661,
0.0162833985,
-0.0195225254,
0.0380997732,
-0.0151381427,
0.0161520019,
0.0017443473,
-0.0008975199,
-0.0829182491,
-0.0297411736,
0.0022145489,
-0.0260962453,
-0.08024019,
0.0224108715,
-0.0544709228,
-0.0428894795,
-0.0147638125,
0.0455699526,
-0.0149574354,
-0.025212368,
0.0067344713,
0.0457576364,
-0.0405935496,
0.0019406182,
0.022329988,
-0.0278051905,
-0.0716000572,
0.0335297249,
-0.0364289209,
-0.0417041183,
-0.0150950234,
0.0091770366,
0.0226621237,
-0.0237332433,
-0.0314234905,
0.0310217924,
-0.0179924946,
-0.0234312173,
-0.0643383041,
-0.0393355973,
-0.0220493171,
0.0031835174,
-0.0224297103,
-0.033760462,
0.0736161023,
0.0232646726,
0.0086679999,
0.0040251394,
-0.0064195269,
0.0268062688,
-0.059279535,
0.1355093271,
-0.034728907,
-0.0056671049,
0.0699810162,
0.0243376791,
-0.0243875682,
0.0350657478,
0.032475993,
0.0583842918,
0.0624799542,
-0.0067562247,
-0.0198069513,
-0.0303065758,
0.0204576161,
0.0029065376,
0.0158239305,
0.0316393115,
-0.05078125,
0.0410456322,
-0.0127590653,
0.0817302167,
-0.036444407,
-0.0273687076,
-0.0114679337,
0.0555020235,
0.0368346199,
-0.0095897801,
-0.0105001824,
0.032252457,
-0.049289383,
-0.0124322688,
-0.0017556141,
-0.0163537785,
-0.0370238423,
-0.0058162855,
0.0089080064,
-0.0090146326,
-0.0224403813,
-0.0256918035,
-0.0417666174,
0.0129479831,
0.0593783371,
-0.0165842511,
0.0409855321,
0.0041431682,
-0.0325332619,
0.0601207539,
0.0028554494,
-0.0106036672,
0.0430898182,
-0.007155607,
-0.0028404328,
0.0540447757,
0.044547163,
-0.0472156778,
-0.0278927814,
-0.0171444993,
-0.0131297382,
-0.0028659576,
-0.0183767211,
-0.0400083587,
-0.0167117584,
-0.0692897812,
-0.0131065622,
0.0473238118,
0.0390147604,
-0.0168626383,
0.0128121488,
0.0372750014,
0.0257047359,
-0.0684093609,
0.0287520476,
0.0594103485,
0.051642742,
0.003407815,
-0.0074227834,
0.0379700288,
0.0423238799,
-0.0025059888,
-0.0006382198,
0.0003431037,
0.0620300323,
-0.0002660176,
-0.0489933677,
-0.0504243858,
-0.0301560219,
0.0129732499,
-0.0111093046,
-0.0026730695,
0.0121665411,
-0.0376338586,
-0.0647950992,
-0.0394475609,
0.0142393531,
-0.0504959449,
0.0366638079,
-0.0203781854,
0.0231963005,
-0.0270555429,
0.0162830371,
-0.0744581968,
0.075982511,
-0.0299559701,
0.0485819988,
-0.0197943579,
0.0216826182,
0.0255822875,
-0.026276771,
-0.0387200564,
0.0257897303,
0.016682785,
0.0065564942,
-0.01116098,
-0.0277526285,
-0.0138535919,
-0.0429123193,
-0.0391320139,
-0.0178759806,
-0.039991416,
-0.0173126962,
0.0278833155,
0.0249960814,
0.0248224009,
-0.0051753256,
-0.0064648171,
0.0011989747,
0.0102504175,
0.0240103193,
0.0405844823,
-0.0184997227,
-0.0287577324,
-0.002431338,
-0.0309287123,
-0.0160909723,
0.0068972101,
-0.0276081171,
-0.071476534,
-0.0513545573,
0.0643442944,
-0.0137343584,
0.0019569392,
-0.0160100218,
0.0023741822,
-0.0088522667,
-0.0035541547,
0.0238006823,
0.0304636881,
0.0479568355,
0.0264753122,
0.0143693173,
-0.0422560982,
-0.0482158363,
-0.0052360403,
-0.0272121821,
0.0446594581,
-0.0010996542,
-0.0428852141,
0.020245675,
-0.0258027967,
0.0506353527,
-0.0283988267,
-0.0543305017,
-0.0383179188,
-0.0712688193,
0.0095719816,
-0.0505352914,
-0.0112818638,
0.0059312847,
0.0416512452,
-0.0149827683,
0.0099223098,
0.0746437535,
0.0050219223,
0.0259909872,
-0.0428435132,
-0.01213603,
-0.0284215976,
-0.0026115158,
-0.0334623754,
0.0474990569,
-0.0589185767,
-0.0463760905,
-0.0569922775,
-0.0019581816,
0.0214974787,
-0.069470495,
0.0590371639,
0.0157263912,
0.0075320285,
0.0000262541,
-0.0152599476,
-0.040264111,
-0.0046498259,
0.0156840906,
0.0076050987,
0.0920841098,
0.0053156237,
-0.0543515161,
0.054267332,
-0.012887923,
-0.0090871053,
0.0104437694,
-0.0369058736,
-0.0186848529,
0.020747995,
0.0203305949,
-0.0216404498,
0.0559581853,
-0.0023367961,
-0.052489832,
0.0285732504,
-0.0052313795,
-0.0818504691,
-0.0096618533,
-0.013371964,
0.0425315313,
-0.0564436167,
-0.0052500949,
-0.0164173823,
-0.0032305729,
0.0156779028,
-0.0327460468,
0.084253639,
0.0311080292,
-0.0164616629,
-0.0056985435,
-0.0124510592,
-0.0144204888,
0.0110513559,
0.0208674036,
-0.0298397541,
0.0004150521,
0.0022395337,
0.016470572,
0.0248980075,
-0.0035767897,
0.0189803019,
-0.05397214,
0.0243340619,
-0.0011369684,
-0.0001723638,
-0.0359326862,
-0.04701747,
-0.0077567752,
-0.0438203514,
0.0556047112,
0.0183314793,
-0.0023133338,
-0.005822646,
-0.0115266871,
0.0276075546,
-0.0147612588,
-0.0247504581,
-0.0240898337,
0.0203249622,
0.0196734238,
0.0287448354,
-0.008553464,
-0.0240848511,
-0.0375595689,
-0.0285681076,
-0.054685574,
-0.0308646727,
0.0339040942,
-0.015687244,
0.0012795579,
-0.0081481785,
-0.015945809,
-0.0458487831,
-0.02082121,
-0.0347435661,
0.0333689749,
-0.0443377048,
0.0225550253,
-0.0226411372,
-0.0188565105,
-0.0122305034,
0.0581179969,
-0.0432390794,
0.0069125309,
0.0027767927,
0.0000740146,
0.0511360392,
0.0513855927,
0.0444560833,
-0.0141131142,
-0.0206387695,
0.0124474857,
-0.0495318174,
-0.0417894982,
0.0245096385,
0.0495794639,
0.0204570033,
0.0349714905,
0.0490118563,
-0.0141964648,
-0.0830571651,
0.0102948649,
0.0009091576,
0.0259974543,
-0.0419524312,
0.0378309414,
0.0446764566,
-0.0012843985,
-0.0221873634,
0.0359669477,
-0.0397513285,
-0.0283614658,
0.0565583408,
-0.0472247787,
0.0165599547,
0.0206099488,
-0.094490312,
-0.0537547059,
0.0355787948,
0.0143731283,
-0.030930331,
-0.0232442822,
0.0214382708,
0.0430675223,
-0.0288742874,
0.0440721773,
-0.0596089363,
0.0088334149,
-0.0326248445,
-0.003378717,
-0.110333547,
-0.0492299646,
0.0146552511,
0.0213222653,
0.0670150369,
0.0005024421,
0.009799337,
-0.0787890628,
-0.0122567462,
-0.0022982035,
-0.0321247466,
0.0288695637,
-0.0118811289,
0.0476865433,
-0.0457963198,
-0.0311528817,
0.0253260322,
0.0006967292,
-0.0004436114,
0.0265486091,
-0.0278313104,
0.0253829155,
0.0055321427,
0.0071145212,
0.0105408188,
-0.0042423769,
0.0556117073,
-0.0249023754,
0.0477563478,
-0.0431701243,
0.0213164892,
0.03813418,
0.0069666333,
-0.081825614,
0.0552773811,
-0.0479599573,
-0.0125601487,
-0.041567646,
0.0121215023,
-0.019123001,
-0.0225540567,
-0.0060417261,
-0.0208869018,
-0.0330848098,
-0.0010707678,
-0.007394183,
0.0341659896,
-0.0008913971,
0.0528111793,
0.0431994051,
-0.0077266288,
0.0314592645,
0.0451965742,
-0.0564512424,
0.0282010976,
-0.0297791604,
-0.0754159018,
-0.0396324657,
0.0151416836,
0.0153093273,
0.079162322,
-0.0205664542,
0.0177392494,
-0.0263271276,
-0.0136313541,
0.0540349074,
-0.0017644453,
0.0159369353,
0.0021213032,
0.0390093699,
0.0679809526,
0.0464533046,
-0.0011544182,
-0.0548653975,
0.0017275357,
0.0306567494,
-0.0376864523,
-0.0476353914,
-6.509399885e-33,
-0.0361676998,
-0.0422947779,
-0.03305085,
-0.0366870724,
-0.0114328461,
0.0227084327,
0.044430878,
-0.0179345198,
-0.0585859045,
0.0083203595,
-0.0245342012,
0.0527704656,
0.0287479647,
-0.0133323204,
0.0262862463,
-0.0151562309,
0.0431275219,
0.0313603729,
0.0178181063,
0.0091855982,
0.0941055641,
0.0205855779,
-0.0042763986,
-0.0592524894,
0.0089542959,
-0.0183860939,
-0.0415269546,
0.0550489165,
-0.0121023459,
0.0314383917,
-0.0479699001,
0.0186317768,
0.0273227021,
0.02169168,
-0.0155601995,
-0.024330724,
-0.1089352295,
-0.0383012071,
0.0147843482,
0.0567385405,
-0.0125910295,
-0.0135456538,
0.0530832633,
-0.036664743,
0.0136035737,
0.0456773713,
0.0196716357,
0.0021974763,
-0.0654722676,
-0.0199322812,
-0.0161980074,
0.0402394198,
0.026625108,
0.0170111284,
0.0478237756,
-0.010249109,
0.0163811799,
0.0443707295,
-0.0888159424,
0.0103922626,
-0.0245265514,
0.024607379,
0.0301741753,
0.0636906698,
-0.0275268536,
0.0224230178,
0.0252043493,
-0.0735978559,
0.0161324628,
-0.027660409,
-0.001701041,
0.0553838015,
0.042092789,
0.0342631117,
0.0233982913,
-0.0354330242,
0.0226907078,
-0.0026984829,
0.0142209083,
0.0282135438,
0.0292025581,
0.0617100075,
-0.098976329,
-0.0339251608,
-0.0413573757,
-0.0415346995,
-0.0448765941,
-0.0104342252,
0.0212258939,
0.049315352,
-0.0363267101,
-0.0147073148,
-0.0025930672,
-0.0276413877,
0.0029357821,
-0.0496065542,
0.022040531,
-0.0047056936,
0.0198054221,
0.0461365581,
0.0107260393,
-0.0608769767,
0.037250787,
-0.0096748713,
-0.0398823358,
0.0017172648,
0.0045688567,
-0.0381532721,
-0.0193316843,
0.0088735605,
0.0257264338,
-0.0273628179,
-0.0382370278,
-0.0172089934,
0.0386324152,
0.011540263,
-0.0022469491,
0.0463230014,
0.0613374114,
0.0281716157,
0.0200132281,
-0.0129310889,
-0.0192769002,
0.0151459761,
-0.0295276344,
0.0057534943,
0.0190547016,
-0.0004865013,
0.0340760499,
-0.0564763881,
-0.0026292959,
0.0511954948,
2.686e-7,
0.0813183859,
0.0665325001,
0.0235005841,
0.0362682454,
-0.0161826164,
0.0086553004,
-0.0083076321,
0.0138633233,
-0.0383030474,
0.0036938237,
0.0144127868,
-0.0071505862,
-0.0065221493,
0.0526844375,
0.0050530764,
-0.0201102905,
-0.0037514353,
0.0167453736,
-0.0250571463,
0.0012176381,
0.0758815333,
0.1220556125,
0.018848652,
0.0362290256,
-0.0269851647,
-0.0387320779,
-0.0071908459,
-0.0046528364,
0.0033148697,
0.0274914708,
0.0642782003,
0.0309082828,
0.0208604019,
0.0173837394,
-0.008940367,
0.02637266,
0.0309484936,
0.0446477458,
-0.0020192857,
-0.0024681487,
-0.0249533243,
-0.0818197057,
-0.0030611814,
-0.0424207933,
0.0738176033,
-0.0485014804,
-0.0124987438,
0.0226571392,
-0.0164285731,
0.0380432233,
0.0784407109,
-0.004649912,
-0.0267374273,
0.0004920631,
0.0186224021,
0.0189647116,
-0.0186265893,
-0.1152217239,
0.0725205019,
0.0075462558,
-0.0479261652,
0.0096262796,
0.0010835981,
0.0236074291,
0.0590306148,
0.0105665112,
-0.0105408486,
2.336030306e-34,
0.0573684834,
0.0001024372,
-0.0283071268,
-0.0106890826,
0.0287377276,
-0.0223489683,
-0.0202750545,
0.0066799498,
-0.0026604098,
-0.0660680383,
0.0103035653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13405v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13405v1 | Towards Bridging the Digital Language Divide | 2023-07-25T10:53:20 | 2023-07-25T10:53:20 | Gábor Bella, Paula Helm, Gertraud Koch, Fausto Giunchiglia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; K.4.2 | It is a well-known fact that current AI-based language technology -- language
models, machine translation systems, multilingual dictionaries and corpora --
focuses on the world's 2-3% most widely spoken languages. Recent research
efforts have attempted to expand the coverage of AI technology to
`under-resourced languages.' The goal of our paper is to bring attention to a
phenomenon that we call linguistic bias: multilingual language processing
systems often exhibit a hardwired, yet usually involuntary and hidden
representational preference towards certain languages. Linguistic bias is
manifested in uneven per-language performance even in the case of similar test
conditions. We show that biased technology is often the result of research and
development methodologies that do not do justice to the complexity of the
languages being represented, and that can even become ethically problematic as
they disregard valuable aspects of diversity as well as the needs of the
language communities themselves. As our attempt at building diversity-aware
language resources, we present a new initiative that aims at reducing
linguistic bias through both technological design and methodology, based on an
eye-level collaboration with local communities. | [
0.0358416103,
0.0784666538,
-0.0793494806,
0.0628736541,
-0.0576315336,
0.0203789677,
0.0585741401,
-0.0113477381,
0.0268732943,
-0.0297369268,
-0.007492783,
-0.0186874475,
0.0439635888,
0.0323630348,
-0.003859702,
-0.0561660044,
0.0189143363,
0.0121097406,
0.024002593,
-0.0407244824,
0.0314389281,
0.0651942343,
0.0282293782,
0.0507633425,
-0.0268984269,
-0.0007876186,
0.0586653128,
-0.0191429239,
-0.0001487372,
0.0157273374,
0.0086442307,
0.0341557525,
-0.029207347,
0.0905467123,
0.0000020359,
-0.072751686,
-0.0082838833,
-0.0035806538,
0.0006205087,
-0.0354330912,
0.0451863445,
-0.0278889015,
-0.0238086004,
0.0122835636,
-0.0598483086,
0.0172662009,
0.0655207634,
-0.0329972319,
-0.0137443356,
0.0202875026,
-0.0173469633,
-0.0159710627,
-0.0080151744,
0.0191640686,
-0.0399647169,
0.0347524695,
-0.0175463948,
-0.0339786038,
0.0173669867,
-0.0353436805,
-0.0422233529,
0.0480034612,
0.0274798349,
0.0134467538,
-0.0229720641,
0.0121091828,
-0.0324645527,
-0.0649556294,
0.0072935103,
0.0528711267,
-0.0428875312,
-0.0154663455,
0.0072025526,
-0.0100066094,
-0.003984292,
-0.0126926126,
-0.014168554,
0.0513293371,
-0.0094923116,
0.0048101302,
0.0288122036,
0.0018250337,
0.0149090104,
0.0345726274,
-0.0283577126,
0.0731566027,
0.0152809881,
-0.0074587227,
0.0000154804,
0.0478434674,
0.0537368953,
-0.0295903105,
0.0404648222,
-0.010650197,
-0.0340722278,
0.022907367,
-0.006633292,
-0.0692583695,
0.0298920162,
-0.0304106027,
0.0168369394,
0.043388918,
-0.0386029817,
0.0109004788,
0.00069827,
0.0021389993,
-0.0029528409,
0.0283215437,
-0.0312517583,
-0.0310138203,
0.0070512821,
-0.0032414619,
0.0014223327,
-0.0069671771,
-0.0355293304,
0.0400577672,
0.0104955407,
-0.0017478667,
-0.0613847561,
0.0158341043,
-0.0261480864,
0.0143179558,
-0.0157504641,
-0.015606638,
-0.0130913984,
0.0692697838,
-0.0612573512,
-0.0059973681,
-0.0443442278,
-0.1038467661,
0.0315736718,
0.0044505042,
-0.026566172,
-0.049386654,
0.0174516905,
0.0425409898,
0.004558376,
-0.0264350995,
-0.0061465879,
-0.0050614001,
0.0104456823,
-0.0600985847,
-0.0081532123,
-0.0634931847,
0.0372019187,
0.070716776,
0.0274415314,
-0.0693326443,
-0.0289401915,
0.0129893329,
-0.0294872541,
0.0595575199,
-0.0116086369,
-0.0026490255,
0.0813700482,
0.0010826716,
-0.0093929237,
0.1083103791,
0.040417891,
0.0008401085,
0.0524122417,
-0.0059626787,
-0.0076442873,
0.0397459529,
-0.0181846581,
-0.0094140284,
-0.0426505171,
-0.0059935902,
-0.0500126295,
-0.0159559455,
0.0501640141,
0.0575429983,
0.0190969277,
-0.0120363785,
0.0505199209,
0.075831756,
-0.0050306991,
0.0316529647,
-0.0224300735,
0.0042814319,
-0.0330814868,
0.0095821461,
-0.0231704824,
0.0178720634,
0.0118283862,
-0.0252323914,
-0.0004905944,
0.0988885984,
-0.0094469134,
-0.0229477435,
0.0051267799,
-0.0196138211,
0.0898243412,
0.0215340015,
0.0379132144,
-0.0120667657,
0.014941805,
0.0212035868,
0.0552612022,
-0.0269561186,
0.0245007966,
-0.0619698577,
0.009403049,
0.0553409643,
-0.0006119665,
-0.0256814901,
0.038408462,
-0.0186765231,
-0.0209440459,
0.0980928019,
0.0509348959,
-0.0109223574,
0.0030870277,
-0.0483546406,
-0.0215703007,
0.0368677527,
-0.0064658853,
0.0807457566,
-0.0017811377,
0.0662178248,
-0.0045946385,
-0.0145737454,
-0.0656255782,
0.0076798708,
-0.0155056976,
-0.0001031268,
-0.0215093214,
0.0275314152,
0.0028299524,
0.0408160537,
-0.0375585146,
-0.0179162342,
-0.0345771052,
-0.0094093494,
0.0063043213,
0.0379092619,
-0.0256977174,
0.0240689013,
0.0277004708,
-0.1047376171,
-0.0334067568,
0.0515051819,
0.0113319429,
-0.0138592953,
0.0827074349,
-0.0279975981,
0.0091631766,
0.0008580765,
0.0013204722,
-0.064840287,
0.0179932769,
-0.0382908918,
0.0411038361,
-0.008901868,
0.0010054731,
-0.0062727677,
-0.0246987585,
0.0434277132,
-0.0235585105,
-0.040180333,
0.0670697093,
0.012320376,
0.0382266939,
0.0597978644,
0.0023295116,
-0.0213107076,
0.0018577063,
-0.081377551,
-0.0439719819,
-0.03864206,
-0.0178374536,
-0.0357637294,
0.0180068277,
-0.0206608269,
-0.0231990367,
-0.0192308202,
-0.0060386583,
0.0307418238,
0.0467474423,
-0.0139684649,
-0.0299476292,
0.0140891615,
-0.0095493523,
-0.0250821915,
0.0069051259,
0.0338704363,
0.0404794887,
-0.0267537758,
-0.0520055369,
-0.0297229663,
-0.0455147475,
-0.0004720613,
0.0162966717,
-0.0077007646,
0.0520229638,
0.0109753618,
-0.0057679266,
0.0434789807,
-0.0152786411,
0.000388647,
0.0717361867,
0.0203330945,
-0.0745301545,
-0.0019121111,
0.0140985092,
0.0470401719,
-0.0077678002,
-0.0383962952,
-0.0297328029,
0.0286862142,
0.0286034066,
-0.0070955898,
-0.0635486916,
0.0243525933,
-0.0765043199,
-0.0564383678,
-0.0017717597,
-0.0287443232,
-0.0039768773,
0.0490994304,
-0.0202570315,
-0.0565035455,
0.0746669546,
0.0390459225,
-0.0025248895,
-0.0592742637,
0.0124039706,
-0.0311994962,
0.0424082913,
-0.0057689715,
0.0514104515,
-0.0192268882,
-0.0365911014,
-0.0608173497,
-0.0029699383,
0.0308731757,
-0.0388589278,
0.0586266033,
-0.0348540395,
-0.0032300169,
-0.0152015947,
-0.0525216274,
-0.0423106775,
0.0298903901,
-0.0374504365,
-0.0113465609,
0.0522420369,
-0.0062039234,
-0.010847629,
-0.0151066082,
0.0472770222,
0.0425188169,
0.0180585608,
0.004621265,
0.0065959524,
-0.0267988462,
0.0130159818,
0.0237447191,
0.0741410106,
-0.0002084196,
0.0027887397,
-0.006053776,
0.0407343768,
-0.0329981111,
0.0059569972,
0.0138579588,
0.0586923175,
-0.0182386879,
-0.0347147509,
0.0066073849,
0.0318083949,
-0.0121082431,
0.0241608396,
0.0687715337,
0.0158265028,
-0.0953965262,
0.0058315606,
-0.0528758541,
0.0156402905,
0.0381484218,
0.0190170743,
-0.1115809008,
0.0166856516,
-0.0014858675,
0.0064919237,
-0.0338278562,
-0.0188924391,
-0.0181365814,
-0.0957698226,
0.0173632894,
0.0135125425,
-0.0296625402,
-0.0366572775,
-0.0192545895,
-0.0235196538,
-0.0097842449,
0.0623073392,
-0.0435918793,
0.0229235888,
-0.0081102392,
0.0105137154,
-0.0326529928,
-0.0388911031,
0.0053909118,
-0.0299166087,
0.0509035923,
0.0620005205,
0.040166948,
-0.0497063175,
0.0038223488,
-0.0060703848,
-0.0077422098,
0.0004905181,
-0.0348848216,
0.0034978949,
0.0210138578,
-0.030371055,
-0.0027580871,
-0.0226315111,
-0.0164046306,
0.0121104466,
0.0257708617,
0.0488223806,
0.0068469346,
-0.0143720964,
-0.0079782763,
-0.0452213511,
0.0234667435,
0.0289445743,
0.0141812256,
-0.0569576584,
-0.0185532011,
-0.0574388728,
-0.0072192526,
-0.0322920494,
-0.0400264859,
0.0396467634,
0.0071291439,
-0.0489756502,
-0.0403053798,
-0.0900683925,
-0.0109150996,
-0.0011631401,
0.0513859093,
-0.0068894206,
0.0208063032,
-0.0081736026,
-0.0138884094,
0.0437170081,
-0.0015249194,
0.0338906348,
-0.0264781881,
-0.0267748069,
-0.0658011809,
-0.0689095184,
0.0191324521,
0.0167961773,
-0.0264038965,
-0.0678321496,
0.0581980906,
0.0356029868,
0.0265174955,
0.0161928311,
-0.0146729434,
-0.0924532861,
0.0357401744,
0.0118455598,
-0.0136399725,
-0.0008386571,
0.0412782878,
-0.0373279974,
-0.0031136421,
0.0255672093,
-0.0257270653,
0.0270181,
0.024586482,
0.0040652202,
-0.0484491847,
-0.0221667625,
0.0016737345,
0.0073158466,
0.0163653586,
-0.0844838023,
0.0074555911,
-0.0525589138,
-0.039208252,
-0.0058605131,
-0.0212330818,
0.0042520906,
-0.0490389094,
0.0196274649,
0.0171926655,
-0.0052375742,
0.0114278253,
-0.0239279345,
-0.0114649143,
-0.0179981943,
0.0685434639,
0.0097847143,
0.0508662537,
0.0124188624,
0.042905014,
0.0067297746,
0.0771820918,
-0.0275802929,
0.053487625,
-0.0053879176,
0.0375071093,
0.0065508019,
-0.0283500887,
-0.0017098251,
0.0241048336,
-0.0096674683,
-0.0416534096,
0.0449641123,
0.0026267094,
0.0698654726,
-0.024706332,
0.077583544,
0.0071980921,
0.0150902318,
-0.0172905941,
-0.0143579841,
0.0270029865,
-0.0374245383,
-0.0334390253,
-0.0161626302,
-0.0194844101,
0.0071948534,
0.0481724031,
-0.0569257848,
0.0092387339,
-0.02471596,
0.004268548,
-0.0014666853,
-0.0441099778,
-0.0141756935,
-0.0076731183,
-0.0517980978,
-0.0183543377,
-0.0922516957,
-0.0729636177,
0.0132877361,
-0.0184610523,
0.0237975102,
-0.0335929394,
0.0202542357,
0.0430977941,
-0.0192295928,
0.0059357444,
-0.0351974815,
0.000077466,
-0.028827399,
-0.0237995051,
0.00951917,
-6.227267282e-33,
0.0221122988,
-0.030312622,
-0.0070729931,
-0.0800473243,
0.0563647784,
0.0133590773,
-0.0018871187,
0.0257424228,
-0.0608438142,
0.0185414534,
-0.0375003517,
-0.0023039421,
0.0276971925,
-0.0115975942,
0.0404998809,
0.00777002,
0.0155349681,
0.0077843005,
-0.0142517565,
-0.0078967046,
0.0197982211,
-0.0195775758,
0.0461443253,
-0.0571567826,
0.0655755997,
0.0092335455,
0.0007368111,
-0.027731847,
-0.0112986853,
0.0440234803,
-0.0084652789,
0.0971617401,
0.0351232179,
-0.0229221042,
-0.0207993872,
0.0208857078,
-0.032634858,
-0.0295777973,
0.0177775193,
0.0670956001,
0.0108437436,
-0.0143875657,
0.0288268793,
-0.0169608332,
-0.0665729046,
0.0296089686,
0.0503673404,
-0.0012815616,
0.0085671619,
0.0189715717,
-0.0773899332,
0.0185269658,
-0.0305315219,
0.0292061251,
0.0196175762,
0.0159487333,
0.011750225,
-0.0146553311,
-0.0805661455,
0.0278255977,
-0.0100280521,
-0.0266284253,
0.0999648646,
0.007144562,
-0.0254867114,
0.0397918858,
0.0582893528,
0.031262219,
0.0191498902,
-0.0247861799,
0.0472819991,
-0.035937801,
0.0446710177,
0.0606821664,
0.0100389495,
-0.0609579384,
-0.02374731,
0.0017857184,
0.059703026,
0.0057937601,
0.0218999404,
-0.0044381698,
-0.0786107183,
-0.0298049655,
-0.0069968794,
-0.0675692186,
-0.025139438,
-0.0376919657,
0.0208494868,
-0.0357441977,
-0.0078413533,
0.010360281,
0.0391823053,
-0.0477224551,
-0.0383842811,
0.0115383668,
-0.0014619312,
-0.0149780065,
0.0380571634,
0.0593736246,
-0.0277303178,
-0.0152150746,
-0.0352086313,
0.0316691846,
0.0106937727,
0.0107211256,
-0.0018415978,
0.0073316623,
-0.0407494716,
0.0182998981,
-0.0311996993,
0.0097116102,
0.0380355231,
0.0318722129,
0.0350111648,
0.0113059646,
0.0001810123,
-0.0025378971,
0.0628900528,
-0.0179699995,
-0.0405400544,
-0.0019583625,
-0.0542058833,
0.0260731168,
-0.0740005895,
-0.0278369337,
-0.0509007983,
0.0307737757,
0.0430976264,
-0.0153673328,
-0.0117610786,
-0.0350783467,
2.74e-7,
0.0207273401,
0.0563433133,
-0.0125269964,
-0.0029070927,
0.0145009086,
0.0059164595,
0.012908862,
0.0595841296,
-0.0214207321,
0.023394607,
-0.0305188671,
0.0382450446,
0.0571152493,
0.0623480864,
-0.0580145456,
0.0125052705,
-0.0176664907,
0.073474437,
-0.060856171,
0.0468756445,
0.0041291895,
0.0701923743,
0.0092139738,
-0.025822375,
-0.051950857,
-0.0154477237,
-0.003919207,
-0.0243358128,
0.0280406475,
-0.0164428353,
0.0142196398,
0.0180099905,
0.0014763597,
0.0122811999,
0.0014949472,
0.0135014141,
0.003974386,
0.0249355193,
-0.0302581117,
0.0057504741,
0.0065659117,
-0.0280841291,
-0.0295485202,
-0.0653886348,
0.0469301865,
0.0571906976,
-0.0133374864,
-0.0306091253,
0.0250043273,
-0.0175850447,
0.0623401739,
-0.0408193544,
-0.0456911139,
0.0173562672,
0.0327495597,
-0.0424075574,
-0.0044001136,
-0.0515070558,
-0.0244791172,
-0.026458066,
-0.0049891546,
-0.0447875634,
-0.0022614563,
0.0272511337,
0.0194822215,
0.0055313893,
0.0341484807,
2.02243849e-34,
0.0009998027,
-0.0043678312,
0.0342127718,
-0.0147788869,
0.0279971976,
-0.0052773729,
-0.0286689606,
0.0061396416,
0.0298780911,
0.0123705287,
-0.0159514211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13377v1 | Embedding Models for Supervised Automatic Extraction and Classification of Named Entities in Scientific Acknowledgements | 2023-07-25T09:51:17 | 2023-07-25T09:51:17 | Nina Smirnova, Philipp Mayr | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.IR, J.4; J.5; I.5.1; H.3.3; I.2.7 | Acknowledgments in scientific papers may give an insight into aspects of the
scientific community, such as reward systems, collaboration patterns, and
hidden research trends. The aim of the paper is to evaluate the performance of
different embedding models for the task of automatic extraction and
classification of acknowledged entities from the acknowledgment text in
scientific papers. We trained and implemented a named entity recognition (NER)
task using the Flair NLP framework. The training was conducted using three
default Flair NER models with four differently-sized corpora and different
versions of the Flair NLP framework. The Flair Embeddings model trained on the
medium corpus with the latest FLAIR version showed the best accuracy of 0.79.
Expanding the size of a training corpus from very small to medium size
massively increased the accuracy of all training algorithms, but further
expansion of the training corpus did not bring further improvement. Moreover,
the performance of the model slightly deteriorated. Our model is able to
recognize six entity types: funding agency, grant number, individuals,
university, corporation, and miscellaneous. The model works more precisely for
some entity types than for others; thus, individuals and grant numbers showed a
very good F1-Score over 0.9. Most of the previous works on acknowledgment
analysis were limited by the manual evaluation of data and therefore by the
amount of processed data. This model can be applied for the comprehensive
analysis of acknowledgment texts and may potentially make a great contribution
to the field of automated acknowledgment analysis. | [
0.0707938001,
-0.0179095659,
0.0076106084,
0.0192422103,
0.0093709026,
0.0364519283,
0.0134217544,
-0.0139824934,
0.058449585,
-0.0431969799,
-0.0102032088,
0.06524349,
-0.0144096129,
0.0198995937,
0.0258842763,
-0.015622844,
0.0447067358,
0.0130143631,
0.0437197126,
0.0049039149,
-0.0065238443,
-0.0062168282,
0.0053597805,
0.0286545455,
0.02872869,
-0.0214639474,
0.0398775898,
-0.0404193886,
0.0463131145,
-0.0469120517,
-0.01769186,
0.0407455303,
-0.0250433516,
0.0499659292,
0.0000019628,
-0.0441772565,
-0.0224752724,
0.029429419,
-0.022655759,
0.0253384747,
0.0243758187,
-0.0240745377,
-0.0043809963,
-0.0126994392,
0.0003934275,
-0.0377963856,
-0.0012655781,
0.0541503914,
-0.0084388508,
0.0418989323,
0.0010149294,
-0.0520527549,
0.0627279803,
-0.0100394068,
-0.0337182954,
-0.0012325632,
0.0343725868,
-0.0329200327,
0.0124044595,
0.0625027046,
0.0197474398,
0.0555750541,
-0.0233757906,
-0.0355509706,
0.1024112478,
0.0612881072,
-0.0126795489,
0.0256890468,
-0.0136062736,
0.0152025269,
0.046398662,
0.0202254001,
0.0613212734,
-0.0163171887,
-0.0142564215,
0.023273794,
-0.018377183,
-0.0205783732,
-0.0283537805,
-0.0525620766,
0.064201571,
0.0184130501,
0.0227478407,
0.0402701162,
0.0019924438,
0.0084579047,
-0.0016080678,
-0.0533351824,
-0.0065468992,
0.0174358264,
-0.0208426639,
-0.048719652,
0.0341139548,
0.0441969521,
0.069106549,
0.0171524435,
0.0042803534,
-0.0427882522,
0.032641001,
-0.0125476439,
-0.0015010055,
-0.0236348324,
-0.01753846,
0.0703529492,
-0.0702338293,
0.0166213159,
-0.0179248545,
0.0261403825,
0.0417380631,
0.0179587528,
-0.058012303,
-0.0281097461,
-0.0085557019,
0.0745940432,
-0.0165773407,
-0.0473443642,
-0.0359000526,
-0.0100914985,
-0.0102810487,
0.0488505289,
0.0137781855,
-0.0107762683,
0.0186672024,
0.0424722582,
-0.0049721971,
-0.0090231169,
-0.0454275757,
-0.0004872632,
-0.0045689335,
0.03804354,
-0.0020669613,
0.0003965185,
0.0358582251,
-0.0297291502,
0.0062898304,
-0.0032311748,
0.0578693561,
-0.0924970731,
0.0401143022,
-0.0026478949,
0.0175710022,
-0.0293205436,
0.0137554407,
-0.0066617108,
0.0510678552,
0.0158207268,
-0.0083007254,
0.018845696,
0.0167585723,
-0.0194598567,
-0.043936789,
0.0300662071,
-0.0761538222,
-0.006590656,
0.0700700358,
-0.0151569583,
-0.0042032427,
-0.0067267381,
0.0518646725,
0.0246838909,
0.0393477865,
-0.0133311758,
0.0001424473,
0.0003297245,
0.0063088061,
-0.037985798,
0.057812579,
0.0213145912,
-0.0451474935,
0.0213557631,
0.0031960066,
0.0362473242,
-0.0250955056,
-0.000158506,
-0.015083923,
0.0613855161,
0.017778784,
0.0132692037,
-0.0185314342,
-0.0065230122,
0.0534987897,
-0.0216915254,
-0.0171838328,
0.0371556506,
-0.0126700308,
0.0251545291,
-0.0029357518,
0.0300254934,
0.0032652498,
-0.0205189381,
-0.0099196704,
0.0008762511,
-0.0351863615,
-0.0314375721,
0.0804538205,
-0.0288602505,
-0.0501975566,
-0.055098094,
0.0289295465,
-0.0043648733,
0.026761001,
-0.0199419744,
0.0549126081,
0.0320065431,
0.0645665973,
-0.0490006395,
0.0002501016,
-0.0746260881,
-0.0560247786,
0.0383110754,
-0.0058186222,
-0.0422070138,
-0.0505198576,
-0.0033818523,
-0.0117227957,
0.0160065349,
0.0209751911,
0.0409140438,
0.0250354186,
0.0479180925,
-0.0155172599,
0.0483611561,
-0.0333073549,
0.0596380644,
-0.0232428797,
-0.0313690156,
0.0175641123,
0.0113863591,
0.0272726994,
0.0803970918,
-0.0105335815,
0.0053254059,
0.0523550361,
-0.0466745943,
-0.0227839295,
0.0239387434,
0.0474838689,
-0.0276697446,
0.0059300074,
-0.0185852926,
0.009546156,
-0.0060168589,
-0.0038555684,
-0.028478656,
0.0261008069,
0.0142257176,
0.0175735988,
-0.0347180255,
-0.0060664248,
-0.0094205989,
-0.0082742162,
-0.0377056338,
0.0319861323,
-0.0070254016,
0.0420310162,
0.0267700218,
-0.052260261,
-0.0073195575,
-0.008763303,
-0.0521279275,
-0.0026291432,
0.0032298721,
-0.0244524069,
0.0122893313,
-0.0502964333,
0.0050212368,
-0.0464037992,
-0.0750966892,
0.0079508023,
0.0101505974,
0.0423015989,
-0.0159081277,
-0.026351193,
0.0033917935,
0.0163605884,
0.037434794,
-0.0076147052,
-0.0173270609,
-0.0352575928,
0.0612021238,
0.0189840924,
-0.0088777421,
-0.0402486138,
0.0109070195,
-0.057617154,
0.0186284687,
0.0674688295,
-0.1073822379,
-0.0410008393,
0.0242903866,
0.0023641894,
-0.028982861,
-0.0061492748,
-0.0036428387,
-0.008418926,
0.0309679024,
-0.0439229645,
0.0831464306,
0.0204414725,
0.0604149885,
-0.009845023,
0.0223932415,
-0.0443790406,
0.0089110052,
-0.0277834274,
0.0557552055,
0.0205502976,
0.0118393749,
0.0584159978,
0.0296116918,
-0.0059376657,
0.0089389775,
-0.0116481725,
-0.0230922792,
-0.0211816635,
-0.0270841308,
0.0092965513,
0.0148462672,
-0.0071785441,
-0.0033417195,
0.0340568982,
-0.0237047095,
0.0506570898,
-0.0291889664,
-0.0306819621,
-0.0363581665,
-0.0065638004,
-0.0409867875,
-0.0006723712,
-0.0169514846,
0.0074844388,
0.0278970227,
-0.0590472668,
0.0352918282,
0.0206718035,
-0.00767365,
-0.021311786,
-0.0062314575,
0.0477719568,
0.0126799932,
-0.0339905657,
0.0288594961,
-0.0213576406,
-0.033361081,
-0.0194017291,
0.0544499047,
-0.0033978587,
-0.0363477133,
-0.0218431819,
0.0523537248,
0.0277532302,
0.021004919,
-0.0238307789,
0.0130164353,
-0.0320677236,
0.0228887536,
0.0548338145,
-0.0221988764,
0.0082021132,
0.0126885101,
-0.0213386081,
-0.0159796067,
-0.0303697977,
0.0431192107,
-0.0042212792,
-0.0615308508,
-0.0020989652,
-0.113309361,
0.0010226346,
-0.0344793648,
0.0436188318,
-0.0123670818,
0.0178883076,
0.0977451652,
0.0336891152,
-0.0392314456,
-0.0263886172,
0.0391600579,
-0.0291217286,
0.0091448613,
0.0266720634,
-0.1215135455,
0.0152293928,
-0.0230266023,
-0.0331000797,
-0.0009152266,
-0.0397143289,
0.0154060051,
-0.062736474,
0.0267976187,
-0.0194814708,
-0.0322599337,
0.0006906315,
-0.0784223974,
-0.0071395757,
-0.0072036684,
-0.0720896274,
-0.0192032065,
-0.0225819461,
-0.0022035276,
0.0269162338,
-0.0280394088,
-0.0888545066,
-0.0065919766,
-0.050474301,
0.0754339397,
0.0442944095,
0.0555367544,
-0.0550327674,
0.0139742466,
-0.0467529856,
-0.0267376434,
-0.0213349257,
-0.0076553002,
0.0373916104,
-0.0775305107,
0.0241709407,
0.0189274922,
-0.0060387342,
-0.0249196235,
0.0130533902,
0.0812037066,
0.0697864592,
0.0285216197,
0.0120966015,
-0.075248763,
-0.0188253727,
-0.0174466912,
0.058732532,
0.0045636157,
0.0037214127,
-0.0300963894,
0.0064620092,
0.0377206542,
0.0178513303,
0.0374845117,
-0.0359462313,
-0.0536469109,
-0.0447638594,
-0.0760816559,
-0.0282503907,
0.0449967682,
0.0180522744,
0.0423895791,
0.0369264409,
0.0059386245,
0.0097756619,
-0.0528650284,
-0.0025135325,
0.0027935908,
0.0215440579,
-0.0619756393,
-0.0326818787,
0.0243998952,
0.0446952581,
-0.0511358641,
-0.0208308008,
0.0419310443,
-0.0620434508,
-0.0209540762,
0.0244063754,
0.013472232,
-0.0046463315,
-0.0531244315,
-0.030408835,
0.0548942797,
0.0488225743,
0.0175300613,
-0.028134279,
0.000673064,
0.0079248743,
-0.0488561317,
-0.0124441348,
-0.0039180336,
0.0307747852,
-0.0149334772,
-0.000085492,
-0.0336824954,
-0.0259929206,
-0.0205933023,
0.0222100336,
0.0101351747,
-0.0341344625,
-0.0091442363,
-0.0365347043,
-0.00882072,
0.0130295958,
0.0317695811,
-0.0035909321,
-0.0240725819,
-0.0039432561,
-0.0152752427,
-0.0141808372,
-0.0192554202,
-0.0414811447,
0.0331767611,
-0.0524650961,
0.0782935619,
0.0130650867,
0.0435276665,
-0.0317877345,
0.0019412659,
-0.0371439382,
-0.0457147062,
0.0263953879,
0.0039798515,
-0.0238613021,
-0.0016370476,
0.0157384891,
-0.0003081043,
-0.0027510969,
0.0456787273,
-0.0929843187,
0.0471974202,
-0.0333702601,
0.0382907838,
0.0529478639,
0.0191296209,
0.0220318623,
-0.0222921986,
-0.0233732853,
-0.0137003744,
0.0446984544,
-0.0061103245,
0.0040213736,
0.048826389,
0.0249664132,
-0.0374577641,
-0.0561992973,
0.0121189859,
-0.0010443876,
0.0124111027,
0.007857535,
0.0096777705,
-0.0426908433,
0.002416933,
0.0088187214,
0.007095363,
-0.0276095737,
0.0333806351,
-0.0539288707,
0.0090579698,
0.0710338578,
-0.0406068079,
0.0004569438,
-0.0191235207,
-0.0336567461,
0.015704114,
0.0390391611,
-0.0412097462,
-0.0550892949,
0.0075891386,
-0.0614715554,
-0.0565389879,
-0.0136113157,
-5.852359889e-33,
-0.039032191,
-0.0121254465,
-0.0151232453,
0.0239438191,
-0.0113684554,
0.0748563558,
-0.0471590757,
-0.053386163,
-0.0016698452,
-0.0056329123,
-0.066704832,
-0.0311666131,
0.0076007582,
-0.0202862956,
0.0235532578,
0.003386429,
0.0263517182,
0.0090512382,
-0.0210346319,
0.0148723451,
0.0386693403,
0.0402602889,
0.0729431659,
-0.0860607103,
0.0652557984,
0.0139048966,
0.0038305635,
-0.0198725332,
0.0571357645,
0.0430570804,
-0.0568673126,
-0.0365614146,
0.0132201351,
-0.0361951254,
0.0402714312,
0.0355251431,
-0.1051249355,
0.0150678391,
0.0097007807,
-0.0076434254,
0.0378637239,
-0.0318701193,
0.0044606593,
-0.0093804244,
-0.0337874405,
0.0069072205,
0.0826337412,
-0.0037348496,
-0.0191131737,
-0.040638987,
-0.0672281384,
0.0276258625,
0.0049077254,
0.0735550895,
0.0776519477,
-0.038772013,
0.0076800748,
0.0573876388,
-0.0467526615,
0.001521862,
0.0298207346,
-0.0050991215,
-0.0017978379,
-0.0196269583,
0.022584483,
0.0161387138,
0.0198199525,
0.0232851915,
0.0012922358,
0.0212263316,
0.0303142313,
0.0164881963,
0.0503420196,
0.0313039795,
0.0610134713,
-0.0405869484,
-0.031812124,
0.0254778508,
0.0725216344,
0.0186067522,
0.0223532859,
-0.0372378379,
-0.0486696512,
0.0239493176,
0.009269245,
-0.0748435855,
-0.0150454054,
-0.0451128185,
0.0079292143,
0.013329627,
-0.0674384683,
0.0327718891,
-0.0083628045,
-0.0468191132,
-0.080144003,
0.0259451736,
0.061186336,
0.0660313144,
0.0052766055,
-0.004805658,
-0.1275935173,
-0.0395921022,
-0.0053861309,
0.0147904716,
0.0314103924,
-0.0148812737,
0.0337603614,
-0.0337575227,
-0.0468566306,
-0.0114337467,
0.0066779512,
-0.0138189737,
-0.0338376537,
0.0198826641,
-0.0075067561,
0.0050885109,
0.0240575057,
-0.0090045929,
0.0309337992,
0.021034725,
-0.0063594542,
0.0541737936,
0.0249013714,
0.0393885486,
-0.0051896297,
-0.0097847991,
0.0287617836,
0.0116466777,
-0.0089466209,
-0.0127442954,
0.0254338011,
-0.0560295321,
2.707e-7,
0.0129427128,
0.0558793619,
0.0117432363,
-0.0201970413,
0.0090066213,
0.0035218261,
0.0153666232,
0.045093447,
0.0096660433,
0.0430988707,
-0.0035192382,
-0.0525847934,
0.0103002395,
-0.0041440967,
-0.1300649196,
-0.0525561348,
-0.0287702046,
-0.0180278979,
-0.0404166542,
0.0165776312,
-0.008243409,
-0.013170775,
0.0106002726,
0.0315730795,
-0.0621026605,
-0.0158478916,
0.013311482,
-0.0368416049,
0.0229627211,
0.019803619,
0.002049509,
0.0350372083,
-0.0049460893,
0.0234823488,
-0.0204566773,
0.045988176,
0.0092648324,
0.0575017184,
-0.0193680897,
0.0394533053,
-0.0017503381,
-0.0245587528,
0.0340109132,
-0.0299942326,
0.0301353075,
-0.0325223655,
-0.0201281514,
-0.0521691702,
-0.0449636914,
-0.0429431163,
0.0268810671,
-0.0050141118,
-0.0098234285,
0.039287366,
-0.0066724713,
-0.0470387451,
0.0441247933,
-0.0920549333,
0.0612382963,
0.0140980361,
0.0232899394,
-0.0231011901,
0.0036356957,
-0.0015022316,
0.0132148946,
-0.0584687106,
0.0118542248,
2.6726687e-34,
0.0287381634,
-0.0025454564,
-0.0159281995,
0.1070394963,
0.0064999019,
-0.0195300896,
-0.0000924085,
0.0084613822,
0.0144959176,
-0.0436026901,
0.0174173992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14367v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14367v3 | Prot2Text: Multimodal Protein's Function Generation with GNNs and Transformers | 2023-07-25T09:35:43 | 2024-04-20T09:10:47 | Hadi Abdine, Michail Chatzianastasis, Costas Bouyioukos, Michalis Vazirgiannis | q-bio.QM | q-bio.QM, cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent years, significant progress has been made in the field of protein
function prediction with the development of various machine-learning
approaches. However, most existing methods formulate the task as a
multi-classification problem, i.e. assigning predefined labels to proteins. In
this work, we propose a novel approach, Prot2Text, which predicts a protein's
function in a free text style, moving beyond the conventional binary or
categorical classifications. By combining Graph Neural Networks(GNNs) and Large
Language Models(LLMs), in an encoder-decoder framework, our model effectively
integrates diverse data types including protein sequence, structure, and
textual annotation and description. This multimodal approach allows for a
holistic representation of proteins' functions, enabling the generation of
detailed and accurate functional descriptions. To evaluate our model, we
extracted a multimodal protein dataset from SwissProt, and demonstrate
empirically the effectiveness of Prot2Text. These results highlight the
transformative impact of multimodal models, specifically the fusion of GNNs and
LLMs, empowering researchers with powerful tools for more accurate function
prediction of existing as well as first-to-see proteins. | [
0.0170344431,
0.0608715713,
0.0250037946,
0.0153140295,
-0.0109373275,
-0.010457335,
0.0228116345,
0.0085122762,
0.0337780602,
-0.0332234912,
-0.0072307531,
-0.0332029983,
0.0186025463,
0.0954174772,
0.0483124554,
-0.0001550234,
-0.0039262176,
0.0407997519,
-0.0089461263,
-0.0132429833,
0.0000144076,
0.0360991061,
0.0588795282,
0.0524111092,
0.0110278865,
-0.0083540678,
-0.0154429926,
0.0157094002,
0.009181343,
-0.0238318369,
-0.0116065778,
0.0011439723,
0.046290338,
0.0271244925,
0.000001979,
-0.012771016,
-0.0107293855,
0.0182935018,
0.010786226,
0.0245183501,
0.0266477112,
-0.0399398915,
0.0365798734,
-0.0148675973,
-0.0131493956,
-0.0243112706,
0.0916883722,
0.0462454259,
0.0207940228,
0.0463870876,
-0.0210470743,
-0.066459775,
0.0405091122,
-0.0170162618,
0.0251786876,
-0.0148313148,
0.0351051129,
0.0006906145,
-0.0111340946,
0.0015052647,
-0.0382568799,
0.0364041068,
0.0099145165,
-0.0030150604,
0.0531359948,
0.0338132754,
0.0173769295,
-0.0451506414,
0.0064055701,
0.0924155787,
-0.045590654,
-0.0424547568,
-0.0463727191,
-0.0080281515,
-0.0163999144,
0.0381409526,
-0.0174354892,
-0.001764587,
-0.0245460328,
0.0623668507,
-0.0379340835,
-0.0170366224,
0.0764643997,
-0.0320251808,
0.0080466252,
0.0317052342,
-0.0146282474,
-0.0077083171,
-0.0086158607,
-0.0032531556,
-0.0529669933,
0.0084209777,
0.0171550214,
0.030761255,
0.0419413783,
-0.0120321577,
0.0148490928,
-0.0609704256,
0.0191145074,
-0.0256158952,
0.0229444932,
0.0231121853,
-0.0142068099,
0.0056362376,
-0.0273359064,
0.009731343,
-0.0449980572,
0.0403654613,
-0.0265171658,
0.0101101417,
-0.0838529095,
0.0003752854,
-0.0177083071,
0.0107774427,
-0.0095040239,
-0.052248802,
-0.0446398295,
0.012021509,
-0.0027439813,
-0.0172578339,
0.0528956279,
0.0821136907,
-0.0203278214,
0.0132688992,
-0.0226288494,
0.0675968826,
0.0331040025,
-0.0107682701,
-0.0274909604,
-0.0201391838,
0.0066792285,
0.0133123025,
0.0388658419,
-0.002435304,
-0.0022576044,
0.1287240833,
-0.0399437957,
-0.0079179481,
-0.005064901,
-0.0338338912,
-0.0397607721,
-0.0190861449,
0.0208682287,
-0.0427447855,
0.076161027,
0.031522233,
0.0092860088,
-0.0239840131,
0.0297440849,
-0.0176759902,
-0.0438265167,
0.0844677016,
-0.0686883181,
-0.0251043756,
0.0333101749,
-0.0086323619,
-0.0068552517,
-0.0178879555,
0.0298213325,
0.0192952212,
-0.0088746268,
-0.0020241381,
-0.0131059932,
0.020106148,
0.0049741822,
-0.0554650053,
-0.0049241432,
-0.0301157124,
0.0287897419,
0.0084714405,
-0.0070948759,
0.0277875308,
-0.0026530619,
-0.0357956477,
0.0668171644,
0.0286230016,
0.0354897641,
0.0273696966,
0.0561498329,
0.0681416839,
-0.0073773172,
-0.0262030065,
-0.0237561744,
0.0222673137,
-0.0302360989,
0.0448906124,
0.0167043842,
-0.0158862043,
0.0121186813,
-0.0368942283,
-0.015990464,
-0.0445239618,
0.0786832273,
-0.0440186225,
0.053096164,
0.009345971,
-0.0729607791,
0.0115896119,
0.0264292601,
-0.0150687639,
0.0280994046,
-0.0305320807,
-0.0050294134,
0.0885590911,
0.0365752466,
-0.0333029553,
0.0001028984,
0.0052245138,
-0.024675278,
0.0272030607,
0.009203827,
0.0099646058,
0.0195218697,
-0.0416536629,
-0.0165934283,
-0.0498425104,
0.0231569223,
0.0029969155,
-0.0440316312,
0.0075503141,
0.009948534,
-0.0453058183,
-0.0401381925,
-0.0045654578,
0.0148901837,
-0.0307475813,
0.0228452366,
-0.0065887617,
0.0023985989,
0.0023879225,
0.0123823853,
0.0500576161,
0.030959269,
-0.0541396067,
-0.0337457694,
-0.0207778309,
-0.0095246239,
-0.0231689736,
0.0277267992,
-0.0198452175,
0.008944544,
0.0140157742,
-0.0620591454,
-0.0387991518,
0.0430420861,
-0.0504084602,
0.0543758459,
-0.0054201935,
-0.0496504642,
0.0084205735,
0.0277810041,
-0.0201784261,
0.0281719975,
0.0145563092,
-0.0334923975,
0.0010026717,
-0.0004312765,
0.0171983875,
-0.0133365262,
-0.0206785053,
0.0289613698,
0.0202456117,
0.0169195272,
0.0302260462,
0.0153833013,
0.0097865341,
0.0378956571,
-0.0786870942,
-0.0108920019,
0.0136829596,
0.0205619056,
-0.0074165231,
-0.0184931345,
0.0340788625,
-0.0110000484,
-0.0778143555,
0.0321740918,
-0.0421244688,
-0.0103717679,
0.0411666334,
0.0011296236,
-0.0258841608,
-0.0287171621,
-0.051489193,
-0.0605874099,
0.110693194,
0.0381188989,
-0.057886079,
0.0077153612,
0.0175913889,
-0.0031183907,
0.0198892411,
-0.0040391628,
-0.017712079,
0.0131236417,
-0.0038868152,
0.0191634856,
-0.0048915395,
-0.010150414,
0.0050468063,
0.0836804137,
0.0269378517,
-0.0090514114,
-0.0170423109,
-0.0733950734,
-0.0210599452,
-0.0217400528,
-0.0559101589,
-0.0183593966,
0.0520389788,
0.0474478975,
0.0154972924,
-0.0624297969,
-0.0273888707,
0.0218603592,
0.001424636,
-0.0378360189,
-0.018091049,
-0.0059886123,
-0.0091391299,
-0.0016041057,
-0.0225229543,
0.0834226906,
-0.0236544665,
-0.006004645,
0.0233886763,
0.0011377943,
-0.0425571725,
0.0601675026,
0.0586590134,
0.0373477414,
0.0199889969,
-0.0104156248,
0.0043802727,
0.017631093,
0.0225640479,
-0.0472731218,
-0.0045610871,
0.0052488288,
-0.015426714,
-0.0028059597,
-0.0156053817,
0.0335845016,
0.0415824205,
-0.0348570608,
0.0459497645,
0.0007496508,
-0.027364606,
-0.0369426608,
0.0144048017,
-0.0309817735,
0.0167099368,
-0.0432073176,
0.0140371919,
-0.0467024855,
0.0337083675,
0.0151947113,
-0.0196927544,
-0.0613760538,
-0.0583628118,
0.00231006,
0.0326959006,
-0.0670303106,
0.0138510745,
-0.0363609418,
0.0144593632,
-0.0078428062,
0.0399432257,
-0.0017347845,
-0.0003197823,
0.0201901775,
-0.0518450439,
0.012701299,
0.0673737451,
0.0159831624,
-0.1067105308,
-0.0084075397,
0.0242270865,
-0.0247548334,
-0.0106388927,
0.0022262933,
-0.1027512625,
-0.0774981305,
-0.0434892885,
0.0261546578,
0.0119711803,
-0.0133235715,
0.0056966268,
-0.0353148915,
0.034019243,
0.0389704853,
-0.0274190567,
-0.0444281735,
-0.0722397715,
-0.0466570482,
-0.0318937898,
-0.0074115344,
-0.0109327836,
0.0069017699,
0.0114949252,
0.0184712391,
-0.0251945183,
-0.0602742061,
-0.0008322442,
-0.0069644307,
-0.0280236006,
0.0405947939,
0.0419397727,
0.0092655746,
-0.0126275141,
0.0148562221,
0.0292308815,
0.018308429,
-0.0115986764,
0.0809787214,
0.0018937001,
0.0014599419,
-0.0406288765,
0.0243452173,
-0.0368202105,
-0.059186615,
-0.0630539358,
0.0745147914,
0.0044417102,
-0.0653117076,
-0.0487898029,
-0.0194268599,
-0.0045577213,
0.0243978649,
0.0486424193,
-0.0445159897,
-0.0673100874,
-0.0502570346,
0.0482574888,
-0.0566433333,
-0.0270080399,
0.0112481508,
-0.0089099668,
-0.0277077481,
-0.0077903285,
-0.0090200538,
0.0175050516,
-0.0611299388,
0.0161035452,
-0.0028212559,
0.055619441,
-0.0265618768,
-0.1080477983,
0.026197996,
0.0392454863,
0.01531599,
-0.0085414164,
-0.0459328108,
0.0588698462,
-0.025454076,
-0.0196865555,
0.0604372099,
-0.0506829619,
-0.0653926879,
-0.0625749156,
0.0194537193,
0.0167828165,
0.0082157319,
0.0156639796,
-0.0374567695,
0.066330187,
0.0866694823,
0.0006230637,
-0.0607053116,
0.0029663076,
-0.0167096667,
-0.0237354152,
-0.0013623303,
-0.0459296703,
0.011962791,
-0.016887838,
0.009081468,
0.0241932888,
-0.0366902985,
0.0433757156,
0.0312482752,
0.0519183166,
-0.0021516164,
-0.0131466631,
-0.0434364118,
-0.0303299222,
0.0119698578,
-0.0217896439,
-0.0296084378,
0.0226720292,
0.0431439169,
0.0041332035,
-0.0070030871,
-0.0241068043,
0.0435480103,
0.0106582809,
-0.0212009195,
-0.0007125975,
0.0389379598,
-0.0511291288,
0.048712112,
-0.0231563579,
-0.0284008551,
0.0264887791,
-0.0234503653,
-0.0221162345,
0.0098818978,
-0.0068732379,
0.0154416338,
0.0345122665,
-0.0430980884,
0.0225585848,
-0.0065483195,
-0.0075527583,
-0.0757834613,
-0.0259314962,
0.0541449748,
0.0253225826,
0.0495083109,
-0.0072036576,
-0.0114301546,
-0.045155976,
0.0737924725,
-0.0037635232,
-0.0201860238,
0.0572733916,
-0.0117792245,
-0.0398088284,
-0.0447015651,
0.0584145449,
0.0800182447,
0.013208203,
-0.0171498749,
-0.0626946911,
-0.0131535297,
-0.0026096716,
-0.0062373006,
0.0522030964,
-0.0197951328,
-0.0247470569,
-0.0227291528,
-0.0594992228,
0.0318724029,
0.0214530677,
0.0011438599,
0.0172862615,
0.0256659109,
0.0195508301,
0.0271346811,
-0.0696502328,
-0.0246219188,
0.0420324393,
0.0047676424,
-0.0061279987,
-0.0344597399,
-6.156869864e-33,
0.0297302101,
-0.0938383564,
-0.0159944426,
0.0280021895,
-0.0087300399,
0.0319020115,
-0.0580099486,
-0.0195066072,
0.034161415,
0.0523005389,
0.0402679965,
-0.0391613133,
-0.0089566465,
0.004203591,
-0.0095274439,
-0.0204066206,
0.0192123875,
0.0064155529,
0.0282769669,
0.0398533083,
0.0318680704,
0.0372264758,
0.0495052971,
-0.0319896638,
0.0204568356,
0.0175010916,
-0.0278591886,
-0.0243628211,
0.0179721285,
0.031148728,
-0.0402041264,
0.094560273,
0.0166547634,
0.0202734526,
-0.004007583,
0.0414406918,
-0.0331129543,
0.0225458052,
-0.0177072752,
0.012180089,
-0.0667480975,
-0.0060908808,
0.0716382787,
-0.0007159971,
-0.0105889412,
-0.0230011959,
0.0772361085,
-0.002896579,
-0.024110904,
-0.027830543,
-0.0534237325,
0.0256384201,
0.0189195368,
0.0076320837,
0.029434232,
0.04139008,
0.0249607638,
0.014199215,
-0.0383248962,
0.0269445032,
-0.0280813947,
-0.0343323424,
0.0476432815,
0.044724524,
0.0235501584,
0.0518147461,
-0.0034618601,
-0.0159881804,
-0.0457652733,
0.0050231763,
0.0169988666,
0.0673030987,
0.0533489138,
-0.0089956485,
0.0149165969,
-0.0276461802,
-0.0949020013,
0.019241184,
-0.0388873406,
-0.0273863915,
-0.0001579353,
0.0282167997,
0.0532394983,
-0.0415173247,
-0.0081673395,
-0.0096694669,
-0.0244965721,
-0.036570996,
-0.0299865883,
-0.0372838639,
-0.018587932,
0.062169347,
0.0099231424,
-0.0542557202,
-0.0296998359,
0.0783241242,
-0.0386233553,
0.0422956161,
-0.0318476707,
-0.0113013238,
-0.0220479593,
-0.0328029506,
0.0152598172,
-0.0349391662,
0.0210196339,
-0.0080050677,
0.0238164552,
0.0244290736,
-0.007226917,
0.0029529887,
-0.0617612675,
-0.0304466002,
0.0116393957,
0.0498279184,
0.0432018302,
0.0186966322,
-0.0394981615,
0.0590107553,
-0.0113512473,
0.0584854074,
-0.0008353079,
0.0271627754,
0.030882135,
0.0429161862,
-0.0876261517,
-0.0075043305,
-0.0349939317,
0.0016953758,
0.0304864328,
-0.0746092349,
-0.0345507264,
0.0159111172,
2.801e-7,
0.0991106704,
0.051242359,
0.0117271431,
0.019521635,
0.0110602994,
0.0504003093,
0.0056137028,
0.0553691983,
-0.0197890382,
-0.0301990863,
0.0293313973,
0.0225535035,
-0.0001676041,
0.0267454013,
-0.0475408398,
0.0004415252,
-0.0796452016,
-0.0083468398,
-0.0375695787,
0.0547541864,
0.0311335884,
0.0813004673,
0.0205824077,
-0.020806754,
0.0519292429,
-0.0508599207,
0.0715560094,
-0.0112895491,
-0.0005327351,
0.0083294129,
-0.0145186037,
0.0139469747,
-0.0290583745,
0.0046164524,
-0.0096820761,
-0.0557151251,
0.0362483971,
0.0418101363,
-0.0380075946,
-0.0149831297,
0.0361733176,
0.0143613759,
-0.0120076099,
-0.0127097089,
0.0390322693,
-0.0651351959,
-0.0668856129,
0.0135064404,
-0.0073083439,
-0.0107214041,
0.0279389471,
-0.027972322,
0.0121639362,
0.0405290686,
-0.006675384,
-0.0076417346,
0.0094478577,
-0.0338230208,
-0.0371457972,
0.0093840696,
-0.0429288708,
0.0214065965,
-0.0450806916,
-0.0103165135,
0.0334810019,
-0.0477133431,
-0.0003807186,
2.411569364e-34,
0.0664013475,
0.0020899989,
-0.0005016536,
0.0023797825,
0.0098227635,
-0.0208228733,
-0.0082892198,
0.0005086102,
-0.0338480584,
-0.0623208284,
-0.046410732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13365v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13365v2 | Empower Your Model with Longer and Better Context Comprehension | 2023-07-25T09:34:42 | 2023-07-27T10:17:18 | Yifei Gao, Lei Wang, Jun Fang, Longhua Hu, Jun Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T07, 68T50 | Recently, with the emergence of numerous Large Language Models (LLMs), the
implementation of AI has entered a new era. Irrespective of these models' own
capacity and structure, there is a growing demand for LLMs to possess enhanced
comprehension of longer and more complex contexts with relatively smaller
sizes. Models often encounter an upper limit when processing sequences of
sentences that extend beyond their comprehension capacity and result in
off-topic or even chaotic responses. While several recent works attempt to
address this issue in various ways, they rarely focus on "why models are unable
to compensate or strengthen their capabilities on their own". In this paper, we
thoroughly investigate the nature of information transfer within LLMs and
propose a novel technique called Attention Transition. This technique empowers
models to achieve longer and better context comprehension with minimal
additional training or impact on generation fluency. Our experiments are
conducted on the challenging XSum dataset using LLaMa-7b model with context
token length ranging from 800 to 1900. Results demonstrate that we achieve
substantial improvements compared with the original generation results
evaluated by GPT4. | [
0.0087391017,
0.0455614813,
-0.0243959595,
0.0453061797,
-0.0319670737,
-0.0056457091,
-0.0028905252,
-0.0487487093,
-0.0412584245,
-0.0232104678,
-0.0165675152,
-0.0478369817,
0.0017143565,
0.0422076881,
0.0065684672,
-0.0607405379,
0.042850785,
-0.0550221764,
-0.0075884913,
0.0241109934,
-0.0307170711,
0.0040383455,
0.00517277,
0.03568298,
0.0092724916,
-0.0003846921,
-0.026720209,
0.0057577495,
0.0245749801,
-0.0371479616,
-0.0269818287,
0.0209571552,
0.0116815837,
0.0182715617,
0.0000018706,
-0.0558904111,
-0.0107124289,
-0.0215859339,
-0.0318087935,
0.0242118966,
0.0446865633,
-0.0300293434,
-0.0035869437,
0.0299396906,
-0.0177075192,
0.028277874,
0.0339170508,
0.0452124141,
0.0554957725,
0.0654564872,
0.0024338607,
-0.0387452208,
0.0300897658,
-0.0489759333,
0.0091969352,
-0.0960695297,
0.0302635375,
0.0055536814,
0.0295434464,
0.008180297,
-0.0487292372,
0.0385685973,
0.0594443791,
0.0121246288,
0.0094233872,
0.0582806431,
-0.0043281433,
0.0145585202,
-0.0370604843,
0.0851407424,
-0.0270135645,
-0.0200770479,
0.0015441134,
-0.0009884703,
0.0194653887,
-0.0497131236,
-0.0576771237,
0.0254474375,
0.0030296324,
0.0450113416,
0.057846088,
-0.016190974,
0.0288102161,
0.0064940294,
-0.081455417,
0.0585211515,
0.0004909935,
-0.0270744897,
-0.007362525,
-0.0141724907,
-0.0079734465,
-0.0405921489,
0.0212175101,
0.0797979683,
-0.039711304,
0.0416377485,
-0.0716475099,
-0.0293921549,
0.0144487089,
-0.0130105866,
0.0332094952,
0.0569337718,
-0.0426223688,
0.0451800078,
-0.0406222269,
0.043459028,
-0.0295331385,
0.0046329885,
-0.0670933276,
-0.0030359491,
-0.0258620568,
0.0005548651,
-0.0736451522,
-0.0129017569,
-0.0854573622,
-0.0406176671,
-0.0342374071,
0.0479394719,
0.0383917503,
-0.0197446439,
-0.013288104,
-0.0101221986,
-0.042036403,
-0.0166328475,
-0.0152647505,
0.0246420428,
-0.0328877084,
0.0175167285,
0.0554986782,
-0.0469233356,
-0.0511502996,
0.0182518512,
-0.0004171878,
-0.017689351,
-0.0248275381,
0.0717124715,
-0.0405069068,
-0.0366034918,
-0.0716638714,
-0.0125873992,
-0.037123993,
-0.0596567877,
0.0145278759,
-0.0437559225,
0.0459554121,
0.0057466794,
-0.0014670916,
0.0115316696,
0.0165999942,
0.0191502813,
-0.0311069358,
0.0647000819,
-0.0265517496,
0.033456888,
0.0326779075,
0.0133089358,
0.0100835133,
0.0642518327,
0.0362797864,
0.0198416673,
0.0082834428,
0.0061268741,
-0.0069094407,
0.0153808864,
0.0259322282,
0.0036136541,
-0.0329923406,
0.0063621821,
-0.0067374595,
0.0399779119,
0.0895300955,
0.054362651,
-0.0288052019,
-0.0111569855,
0.0413165353,
0.0152232014,
0.0030730562,
0.0173954107,
0.0639957637,
-0.0090582753,
-0.0291555915,
0.0427645147,
-0.0580535047,
0.0268544313,
0.0048996834,
0.0291220583,
0.0536281057,
0.0290585663,
-0.0153643349,
-0.0319096148,
-0.0036490723,
-0.0068863868,
0.0055983164,
-0.0054390323,
0.0022545559,
0.0348309539,
-0.0420850068,
0.0499022603,
0.0314679816,
-0.0174480043,
-0.0012605947,
-0.0648753569,
0.0391063802,
0.0845901147,
0.0183148365,
-0.0186731685,
-0.0251682252,
0.0004392143,
0.0260089617,
0.0527663827,
0.0155909881,
0.0116377119,
0.0221402235,
-0.0487603955,
0.00065574,
-0.0290462691,
0.0292433556,
0.0212517381,
-0.0035167469,
0.025179619,
0.0270607043,
-0.0281937104,
-0.0001416018,
0.053905461,
-0.0550413541,
-0.0267363098,
-0.0150358714,
-0.0013666875,
0.032764174,
-0.0148327239,
0.0154472524,
0.0072448053,
0.0085829105,
-0.0521841981,
-0.0062404615,
0.0332655907,
-0.0925028399,
-0.0419413112,
0.0254527498,
-0.0076686414,
0.0084649371,
0.0041793562,
-0.022984622,
-0.0624730103,
0.0338187329,
-0.0335216001,
0.0732401907,
-0.0076230364,
0.0416713245,
0.0364648625,
0.0742807239,
-0.0234833639,
0.0781973749,
-0.0379495881,
-0.021317441,
0.043533016,
0.0356123932,
-0.0164166372,
-0.0229528919,
0.0478867628,
0.0199299082,
0.0041842288,
-0.0205062404,
-0.0356035084,
0.004320622,
-0.056285847,
-0.0250149947,
-0.0578410774,
0.005919145,
-0.0303937644,
0.0337491073,
0.0438034311,
-0.0055100461,
-0.0172455441,
-0.0002478903,
-0.0160009414,
0.0404588208,
0.0017083365,
-0.004089748,
0.0305403452,
0.0194598567,
-0.0491076149,
-0.0559681691,
0.0075993156,
0.0130717074,
0.0259763356,
-0.0077804346,
-0.0187231116,
-0.0757504478,
0.0422167666,
0.0132425381,
-0.002922158,
-0.0342653021,
-0.0126059689,
-0.0099782627,
-0.0282963645,
0.0589744002,
0.0585840568,
0.0070129656,
0.045427233,
0.0615691207,
-0.0398570411,
-0.0146311894,
0.0336530246,
0.0114283515,
-0.0165450647,
-0.0428400375,
-0.0198511314,
0.0176183563,
0.0748933852,
-0.0046759476,
0.0194377303,
-0.031962011,
-0.0364077538,
-0.0122654513,
-0.0218485873,
0.0108843548,
-0.000312388,
-0.0336080864,
0.0434502959,
-0.0464006439,
-0.0281940605,
0.0509425066,
-0.039222125,
0.0026644035,
-0.0456119031,
-0.0032329741,
-0.0520127192,
0.0587296821,
0.0025668819,
0.0227039903,
-0.0252076052,
-0.018025877,
-0.0365329236,
-0.0015084676,
-0.0505132489,
0.0003444517,
0.0567430072,
-0.0459055118,
-0.0037809729,
-0.0258573312,
-0.0139939301,
-0.0527726263,
0.0083559528,
-0.0289003905,
0.0274419058,
0.0320653468,
-0.0191327035,
-0.0269275848,
-0.0054341299,
0.0090664793,
0.0589348227,
-0.0052603777,
-0.0043504629,
-0.0285690539,
0.0634619817,
0.0548628159,
0.0374787673,
0.035844624,
-0.0674341246,
0.0420994051,
0.0403082222,
0.0390474349,
-0.0008930112,
-0.0279690959,
-0.0086959787,
0.0104425037,
-0.0269663893,
-0.0167530365,
0.0390451774,
0.0647572502,
-0.0862395093,
-0.0420773849,
0.0903508961,
0.0179310236,
-0.0278198794,
0.0275508277,
-0.0344372466,
0.0254132003,
0.020904446,
0.0168074947,
-0.0790575817,
-0.0453348607,
0.0268213581,
0.0204922389,
-0.0060836156,
-0.0066722343,
-0.0299957637,
-0.1106851101,
0.0455775633,
0.0201067906,
-0.1256501377,
-0.0457261652,
-0.0167988911,
0.0294595789,
0.0469038039,
0.0820349455,
0.0253944155,
-0.0165989734,
-0.0063925032,
0.0079178642,
0.0363282561,
-0.0478627793,
0.0051537561,
-0.0101679303,
0.0947606489,
0.0469789207,
0.0088518048,
0.0109483004,
0.0007400655,
0.0498596989,
-0.0314767845,
0.0340862423,
0.0044467137,
0.0233147815,
-0.0036984913,
-0.010477894,
0.0361449085,
0.0273920167,
-0.0444802418,
-0.0227080863,
0.026164243,
0.0783015788,
0.0083568031,
-0.0487471707,
-0.0196093619,
0.0008125245,
0.0196467899,
0.0755975246,
0.0799206793,
-0.0343097001,
-0.062194664,
-0.0210602265,
-0.0180933904,
-0.0849485025,
0.0390201472,
0.0292960368,
0.0075240289,
-0.025024686,
-0.0866320878,
-0.0455475971,
0.0255750939,
0.0363578424,
0.0067167734,
-0.0065294881,
-0.0051943548,
-0.0226799604,
-0.0266961306,
0.0142839467,
-0.042974595,
0.0111893537,
-0.0755637065,
-0.0000645936,
-0.0002143736,
-0.0461922511,
0.0051065614,
0.0585959814,
-0.0818577558,
-0.0546943918,
0.0066856747,
0.0131703485,
0.0188528318,
0.0334656127,
-0.0207894873,
-0.0669418573,
0.0395416617,
0.0197132006,
-0.0432018973,
0.039226979,
0.0108426865,
0.0206768084,
0.0059949188,
0.0418891571,
-0.0262003019,
0.0272598881,
0.015418455,
0.0420989431,
-0.0346730761,
-0.0194479935,
0.030293433,
-0.0179611985,
-0.0143017862,
-0.0041912929,
0.0031250389,
-0.0171535276,
0.0350101925,
-0.0115462644,
0.0162012689,
-0.0392334685,
-0.0076035755,
0.0276427753,
-0.00936729,
0.0366456695,
-0.0479996428,
0.0033267264,
0.0014557593,
-0.0027888143,
0.0185267068,
-0.02672562,
0.0327175036,
0.0188251715,
-0.0153513439,
-0.0270840451,
-0.0203765724,
-0.0064052031,
0.0424073152,
-0.002075661,
0.0529315136,
0.0300300121,
-0.0204226356,
-0.0139296642,
0.0323059559,
-0.069820933,
-0.0088185631,
-0.0052950727,
0.0351701677,
0.0578080602,
0.0081807617,
0.0743035749,
-0.0082023526,
-0.0138621647,
-0.0117571121,
0.0339240842,
-0.0015111689,
-0.0407956503,
0.0225975011,
0.0268840902,
-0.0075695566,
0.0047692237,
0.0682994202,
0.0144312363,
0.0340380557,
0.0168510415,
0.0290320702,
-0.030556066,
-0.0302157365,
-0.0258226562,
0.0102942623,
-0.006312192,
0.0304683428,
-0.0213330425,
-0.0945224687,
0.013865836,
-0.0006196068,
-0.0035251069,
-0.027390331,
0.0264140517,
0.0550436713,
-0.0014059853,
-0.055555813,
-0.019497009,
0.0117634553,
0.0138422009,
-0.0167929437,
-0.0293652024,
-6.269967848e-33,
-0.0391599499,
-0.0187427811,
0.0364369638,
-0.0417620316,
-0.05164399,
-0.0104882689,
-0.0749710277,
0.0011968613,
-0.0127299614,
0.0091643091,
-0.0173949134,
0.0194904655,
0.009049233,
0.0293005686,
-0.0136137372,
-0.0248085074,
0.0482330844,
-0.0017775951,
-0.013820027,
0.0543705039,
0.0289689843,
0.0358141325,
0.0274593513,
-0.0228046123,
-0.0448029749,
0.0230594222,
0.0033891383,
0.0132656582,
-0.028658703,
0.0549924411,
-0.0215762164,
0.0317422301,
0.0433295965,
-0.0513277538,
-0.0356156416,
0.0490842313,
-0.0738098696,
-0.0053327396,
0.0158933848,
0.0025038046,
-0.0472150184,
-0.0827837065,
0.0706479251,
-0.0019888408,
0.0249887295,
0.0007921158,
0.0185382385,
-0.0707563087,
-0.0288142879,
0.0070025735,
-0.0738330483,
0.0191496648,
-0.0140661262,
-0.0215617139,
-0.0147023676,
0.0440217592,
-0.0207403172,
0.0084515428,
-0.0149424858,
-0.008042179,
0.034635514,
0.0403525159,
0.0403346755,
0.0464229807,
-0.008367789,
0.007800776,
0.0094735809,
-0.0196843874,
-0.0435168408,
-0.0197135303,
-0.0003102165,
0.0470058918,
-0.002426299,
0.0039447392,
0.0239549186,
-0.0240931772,
-0.0665254891,
-0.0233193468,
0.0062964298,
0.0534791499,
0.0439074002,
0.0036685911,
-0.0408653058,
-0.002435907,
-0.0191381164,
-0.0312856138,
-0.019272808,
0.0033900894,
0.0592366941,
0.0250054989,
0.0030950925,
-0.0413735472,
0.0373550095,
-0.0233967509,
-0.0006359068,
0.0163303446,
-0.0169642121,
0.0181521755,
-0.005956653,
0.0368603468,
-0.0598349907,
-0.0256509017,
0.0236917287,
0.0118977018,
0.0057882769,
-0.0144777186,
0.0200031251,
0.0053131585,
-0.0622882769,
0.0031483229,
-0.0633704364,
0.0468063951,
-0.012699238,
0.0192930084,
0.0484685004,
-0.0205106121,
-0.0095370272,
0.0473876074,
-0.0060665854,
0.007174653,
-0.0157011766,
-0.0195624921,
-0.009969186,
0.0325933807,
-0.0448455065,
-0.0099606691,
-0.036254786,
0.0134446835,
0.0159131512,
-0.06340345,
-0.0213545747,
0.0375184752,
2.638e-7,
0.0269424804,
0.035455171,
0.028535841,
0.0040592095,
0.0200456064,
-0.009193358,
-0.0092625804,
0.0400084816,
0.0068755383,
-0.0007035875,
0.0077301855,
0.0446173735,
0.0541179776,
-0.0103413183,
-0.0848667771,
-0.0110094603,
-0.0467066579,
0.0225827172,
-0.0594889931,
-0.0340723656,
0.0422087386,
0.1046755835,
-0.0207324754,
-0.0173717514,
0.0278914198,
-0.0415176451,
0.0412448533,
-0.0083412435,
0.0177059453,
0.0114510208,
0.0119285723,
0.025492439,
-0.0355979688,
0.0049470756,
0.0142934164,
0.0404452533,
-0.0440558456,
0.0839695856,
0.0259416588,
-0.0600125715,
0.0205612015,
0.0018134679,
0.0137131512,
-0.063409254,
0.0833331794,
-0.0683000386,
-0.0132520208,
-0.0300030727,
-0.0238859169,
0.0082435766,
-0.0112988027,
-0.0007973518,
-0.0195104592,
-0.0048569283,
0.0203916952,
-0.0114537142,
-0.0219835751,
-0.0935788676,
-0.0107267806,
0.006460425,
-0.0647134259,
-0.004886501,
-0.070806317,
-0.0027821332,
0.0271474235,
-0.0411380269,
0.0159301814,
2.313648848e-34,
0.0317538939,
-0.0515451171,
0.0274823979,
0.014326253,
0.0077625159,
-0.0168639999,
-0.0069310423,
0.0116827246,
0.0300581995,
-0.0839048475,
-0.0031545113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13339v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13339v1 | Analyzing Chain-of-Thought Prompting in Large Language Models via Gradient-based Feature Attributions | 2023-07-25T08:51:30 | 2023-07-25T08:51:30 | Skyler Wu, Eric Meng Shen, Charumathi Badrinath, Jiaqi Ma, Himabindu Lakkaraju | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting has been shown to empirically improve the
accuracy of large language models (LLMs) on various question answering tasks.
While understanding why CoT prompting is effective is crucial to ensuring that
this phenomenon is a consequence of desired model behavior, little work has
addressed this; nonetheless, such an understanding is a critical prerequisite
for responsible model deployment. We address this question by leveraging
gradient-based feature attribution methods which produce saliency scores that
capture the influence of input tokens on model output. Specifically, we probe
several open-source LLMs to investigate whether CoT prompting affects the
relative importances they assign to particular input tokens. Our results
indicate that while CoT prompting does not increase the magnitude of saliency
scores attributed to semantically relevant tokens in the prompt compared to
standard few-shot prompting, it increases the robustness of saliency scores to
question perturbations and variations in model output. | [
0.0421814881,
0.0178546775,
0.0010684765,
0.0407458469,
-0.0160224363,
0.0087237749,
0.0487702899,
-0.0374054313,
0.0115944967,
-0.050464388,
-0.0217326619,
-0.0397039466,
-0.0049143499,
0.0189899001,
0.0390913635,
-0.0400271453,
0.0408219174,
-0.0589340217,
-0.0012811506,
-0.0220737532,
-0.0042848266,
0.0095149809,
-0.0107005592,
0.0571955405,
-0.0053004287,
-0.0393486321,
-0.0155301522,
0.0245130956,
0.0274953973,
-0.003962494,
-0.004713756,
0.0693698227,
-0.0246131308,
0.0262860004,
0.0000019455,
-0.0689713582,
0.0268577598,
-0.0011151292,
-0.0315155797,
0.0063368878,
-0.0141888466,
0.0313036293,
0.0132903308,
0.0039901524,
-0.0153960194,
0.0377781093,
0.0294923391,
0.0309235454,
0.0447022542,
0.0341291577,
0.0061546513,
-0.0132078575,
0.0111327488,
-0.0021835826,
0.0105188945,
-0.0481567383,
-0.0036825261,
-0.0311741773,
-0.0352620371,
0.0434825905,
-0.0345792882,
0.0524431467,
0.0189097859,
-0.0000033367,
0.0650652424,
0.0409993529,
-0.0311000682,
-0.0179053247,
-0.0251658801,
0.086965844,
0.0023482223,
-0.0124714123,
-0.0198365543,
-0.0089675533,
0.0352905728,
0.0015615458,
-0.0584052615,
-0.0056906827,
0.0078108655,
-0.0015608607,
0.012445759,
-0.0222722664,
0.0252609421,
0.022234289,
-0.026345728,
0.0503195114,
-0.0042178291,
-0.035375908,
0.0079417517,
0.0217027608,
-0.0427165292,
-0.0908096358,
0.0079888366,
0.0332665592,
-0.0287892111,
0.0173284896,
-0.0171237681,
-0.030474931,
0.0122681949,
0.0092196027,
0.0423505269,
0.0260095261,
-0.0700407252,
0.0577355139,
-0.0352178551,
0.0891509131,
-0.0301862713,
0.0151941963,
-0.035707362,
-0.0194323044,
-0.0386756882,
-0.037517149,
-0.0243495405,
0.0450175256,
0.0023115035,
-0.0330272838,
0.0041447566,
0.0255246535,
0.000575176,
-0.0301859621,
0.0184042845,
0.0379056968,
0.0001567986,
0.0029171808,
-0.0366739184,
0.0396902747,
-0.071326755,
0.0218662303,
0.0463374034,
-0.039937444,
-0.0305362623,
0.0265481453,
-0.0065643876,
-0.0266589765,
0.0148664955,
0.0363945924,
-0.0074136001,
-0.0373338424,
-0.0081511261,
-0.0450376086,
-0.022058757,
-0.0575813279,
0.0056160279,
-0.0711531937,
0.004912483,
0.02254094,
-0.0112497844,
-0.0008796261,
-0.0088030081,
0.0336337127,
-0.0475203432,
0.046634376,
0.0024168484,
0.0218578316,
-0.0051281806,
-0.0053983247,
-0.0337108672,
0.0495550074,
0.0241427571,
0.0483199991,
0.0264720563,
-0.0059125558,
0.0075317193,
0.0144939274,
0.011579439,
0.013944366,
0.0033143903,
0.0313950479,
-0.0041678706,
0.0413726941,
0.0627827495,
0.0403998494,
-0.0047072927,
-0.0057956032,
0.0719775409,
0.1051009223,
-0.0119160302,
0.020222567,
0.0376214646,
-0.0087737739,
-0.0030038254,
0.0304988362,
-0.0815167278,
0.0540068485,
-0.0254522115,
0.0081986822,
0.0376123674,
0.0384909026,
-0.0411501788,
-0.0374991074,
-0.0080334954,
0.0439426117,
-0.021237459,
0.0642147735,
0.0292831101,
-0.0024134025,
-0.0237429943,
0.0437428281,
-0.0101702437,
-0.0260225683,
-0.0005040558,
-0.0775480196,
0.0373281837,
0.077581577,
0.0237010233,
0.0009370808,
-0.0344943628,
-0.0056598447,
0.0657309443,
0.0290354323,
0.0160745867,
-0.007425027,
0.0116154421,
-0.0222897027,
-0.0250785835,
-0.021446811,
0.0096499184,
0.0152472751,
-0.0111069698,
0.0142329121,
0.0044606924,
-0.0122418711,
-0.00325495,
0.023792373,
0.0130580319,
-0.0190148968,
0.0101905484,
0.0158341788,
0.0064118179,
0.0194836054,
0.015051092,
0.0206264313,
0.0050436561,
-0.008952193,
0.0121058542,
-0.0074467161,
-0.0526905656,
-0.015863454,
0.0158403423,
-0.0016686179,
-0.0296166372,
0.0136429416,
-0.0266745817,
-0.0428107828,
0.0027513064,
-0.0376846083,
0.0186427739,
-0.0275029875,
0.0144158769,
-0.0126561401,
0.0073466757,
-0.0412491038,
0.050688386,
-0.0300985612,
0.0171195362,
0.0419544429,
0.000910371,
0.0152531192,
-0.0337853916,
0.0044730399,
-0.000875208,
0.0102091543,
-0.000836195,
0.0050531672,
0.0181982424,
-0.0786968023,
-0.0286245272,
-0.1235487536,
-0.0002718036,
-0.0340679698,
0.0306389928,
0.0173612628,
0.0208387356,
-0.0135995988,
-0.0295680705,
-0.0649210736,
-0.0399210677,
-0.0179945715,
0.0476106592,
0.0167060383,
-0.0058691679,
-0.0059413994,
-0.0382137522,
-0.0113910502,
-0.0163167678,
0.0349476747,
0.0125156166,
-0.0097969454,
-0.0557848699,
0.0105322264,
-0.0358334407,
0.0187465865,
-0.0084258644,
-0.0255244449,
0.0230728835,
0.0175033323,
0.0735938102,
0.1109823808,
-0.0009832652,
-0.0128846895,
0.0694685951,
0.0044467775,
-0.0633002222,
0.0181893893,
-0.0156812407,
-0.0307770316,
-0.0179584306,
-0.0223486852,
0.0050537144,
0.0670441166,
0.0032389653,
-0.0069366847,
-0.0572166033,
0.0113176182,
-0.0223823339,
-0.0528764129,
-0.0576147996,
0.0038996639,
-0.0323798768,
0.0594025217,
-0.0178557634,
-0.0551434942,
0.0928667635,
-0.0305181723,
-0.009046807,
-0.0380129069,
0.0227483138,
-0.0336853825,
0.0500417314,
-0.0146066202,
-0.0026552358,
0.0291506182,
-0.0352906398,
-0.0632519498,
0.0154030286,
0.0016238785,
-0.0282110739,
0.0600579455,
-0.0321047157,
0.0031423529,
0.0336126462,
-0.0269797202,
-0.046982944,
-0.0644275919,
-0.0465418287,
0.0186021738,
-0.0134413522,
-0.0152561702,
-0.0023016012,
-0.0089718336,
0.0670425668,
0.0078456495,
-0.0302043557,
-0.0106153749,
-0.007613474,
0.0355259292,
0.0821467042,
0.0287835505,
0.0364410542,
-0.012444634,
0.0258114859,
0.0300933309,
0.045719564,
0.0043121302,
-0.0004587657,
-0.0096189138,
0.0416554473,
-0.0141927795,
-0.0311160963,
0.0226885844,
0.0824915096,
-0.061563205,
-0.0284881853,
0.1166015267,
0.0206667539,
-0.0881016776,
0.0020903065,
-0.0414934084,
0.0661850125,
0.0405892432,
0.0120382849,
-0.0569469444,
-0.0523118898,
0.021051351,
0.0238281414,
-0.0098447902,
-0.0042721722,
0.0017094719,
-0.10563685,
0.0248049963,
-0.0331859067,
-0.0231266227,
-0.0125519251,
-0.0574521273,
0.0164741576,
0.0083190827,
0.0081522614,
0.0057182326,
-0.0151886018,
-0.0020628467,
0.033969827,
-0.0054947431,
-0.0205560941,
0.0524914041,
-0.0348746963,
0.0049861316,
0.107488364,
-0.01171121,
0.0063180407,
-0.0428634323,
0.0219788849,
-0.0137547851,
0.0423070341,
-0.0056615635,
0.0307099577,
-0.025723068,
-0.0054728463,
-0.0512378365,
0.0439007543,
-0.0237750262,
0.0047274497,
0.0268071406,
0.0921346918,
-0.0093702814,
-0.0294469092,
-0.0452030636,
-0.0259213019,
-0.0036908893,
0.0803202614,
0.0611855648,
-0.0732250512,
-0.0221731905,
-0.0154290479,
-0.0336757824,
0.0062622353,
-0.0714247599,
0.0212418269,
0.0300011728,
0.0072321356,
-0.0665085837,
-0.0650287345,
0.0271806195,
0.0138224317,
-0.0146883996,
0.0175672267,
-0.0456482843,
0.0217293203,
0.0022585751,
0.0804963261,
-0.0293679517,
0.0240080208,
-0.0772260129,
0.0072023789,
0.0236063115,
-0.0289984532,
-0.0230177622,
0.0194884576,
-0.0935985073,
-0.0300664958,
-0.0132010886,
0.0487575568,
0.0198213831,
0.0514855348,
-0.0198314674,
-0.067632854,
0.0366935842,
0.0183893386,
-0.0255385228,
0.0270529091,
0.0060798833,
-0.0115698623,
-0.0073607345,
0.0602933764,
-0.0569910631,
-0.0166748799,
0.0214751661,
0.0433498248,
0.0224851388,
-0.0245770346,
0.0112353498,
-0.0061939117,
0.0547452718,
-0.0216667522,
-0.0085759638,
-0.0164383128,
0.0355099514,
0.0151249953,
-0.0185625255,
-0.0415915363,
0.0248661339,
0.0069114803,
-0.021153966,
0.0096506467,
-0.0310174096,
-0.0060718153,
0.0082114358,
-0.0519462489,
0.005711549,
0.0016279633,
0.0264495835,
0.0451997854,
0.0107359868,
-0.0431248359,
-0.0025531349,
0.0063992199,
0.0212423224,
0.0165195763,
0.0763489157,
0.0282816309,
-0.023734251,
-0.0206008088,
0.0344024003,
-0.0923209563,
-0.0607902482,
-0.0017402089,
0.0278377626,
0.0519110821,
-0.012162596,
0.0343035795,
0.0050811567,
-0.006110114,
-0.0172060207,
0.0055633676,
0.0229426138,
-0.0185104124,
0.0310018081,
0.0292474721,
-0.0062526646,
-0.008109808,
0.0733733922,
0.0114345662,
0.0100510651,
0.0125676049,
-0.0138352374,
0.0000415092,
-0.0279458705,
-0.0061793448,
0.0164470915,
-0.0295297857,
0.0381484404,
-0.0839388147,
-0.0708736107,
-0.0180827621,
-0.0231882017,
-0.0038576631,
-0.0222673938,
0.0643872097,
0.0815616697,
-0.0071885176,
-0.03257953,
-0.0260944068,
0.0152400509,
-0.0329066068,
-0.0273701921,
-0.0114812572,
-6.573963177e-33,
0.0048538572,
-0.026730787,
-0.0077267285,
0.0087044705,
-0.0185203683,
0.004909372,
-0.0375160798,
0.0193875544,
-0.0444752537,
0.0174058601,
-0.0398166515,
0.0147323115,
0.015256824,
0.0288497526,
0.0352165699,
-0.0438259691,
0.0251750108,
0.0069983345,
-0.0359368883,
0.0228327569,
0.0251760222,
0.0078858957,
0.0442837961,
-0.0241439976,
0.0602944568,
-0.0233646873,
0.0181210432,
0.0260974541,
-0.0206880011,
0.0809831023,
-0.0209323559,
0.0471465848,
0.0350982063,
-0.0614811443,
-0.0245652255,
0.0238766819,
-0.04961982,
-0.0326388478,
0.0371107645,
-0.0026358368,
-0.0780604854,
-0.0490113348,
0.0225025564,
0.0122293672,
0.0008465332,
-0.0584903024,
0.0467081144,
-0.0124343392,
-0.0312921032,
-0.0358506478,
-0.0561845489,
0.0094455089,
-0.0092962012,
-0.0503528006,
0.0199675933,
0.0571599007,
-0.001301985,
0.0231355131,
0.0208338089,
-0.0070993244,
0.0149312001,
0.0309475958,
0.0890840217,
0.0431590714,
0.0061403736,
0.0488529131,
0.0152234435,
0.0117159374,
-0.0511657,
-0.0238269623,
0.0133939236,
0.0060091717,
0.0676347017,
0.0122701479,
0.0317021273,
0.0498929173,
-0.0704454631,
-0.0198281128,
-0.0214899071,
0.0451982059,
0.0331221297,
-0.0065050321,
-0.0259158928,
-0.0198910646,
-0.077562198,
-0.003689534,
-0.0696048662,
-0.0342632979,
0.0520069227,
0.0005905015,
-0.0061810152,
-0.0189281218,
0.0466396771,
-0.0217403136,
0.0065125423,
0.0416925363,
-0.0079608317,
0.0356582068,
0.0149548883,
0.0310760457,
-0.0306024738,
0.0443516262,
-0.0126184579,
0.0021803866,
0.0252714418,
0.0348479487,
0.0202704333,
-0.0189261567,
-0.0342050679,
-0.0201109983,
-0.0543205477,
0.0089645237,
-0.0396284126,
0.0059004477,
0.0358889364,
0.0044087083,
-0.0222438276,
0.0709393844,
-0.0122147333,
0.0155875999,
-0.0385908186,
0.0311399382,
-0.0302949939,
0.0091597885,
-0.0559946112,
0.0011849331,
-0.0203320272,
0.0040737372,
0.0018092034,
-0.0400306061,
-0.0346982665,
0.0443019234,
2.593e-7,
0.0032623396,
0.037398506,
0.004548281,
0.0034841085,
-0.0021989637,
0.0392447747,
0.0135511281,
0.010483305,
0.051311288,
-0.0720348954,
-0.0120454412,
0.0435462929,
0.0450558364,
0.002320389,
-0.1302550137,
0.0048080478,
-0.0543187596,
0.0172107257,
-0.0337727405,
-0.0386766568,
0.0290407073,
0.0878646374,
0.0003987033,
-0.017458817,
-0.0054810201,
-0.0105779916,
0.022559762,
-0.0207099579,
0.0161978304,
-0.0093311891,
0.0418814197,
-0.0036020393,
0.0222195629,
0.0340486281,
0.0071613188,
0.0011204383,
0.0317755193,
0.0489217676,
0.0097390767,
-0.0435561985,
-0.0446423441,
-0.015530562,
0.0420611352,
-0.0970374718,
0.0732978508,
-0.025641799,
-0.010537765,
-0.0452592075,
-0.001308523,
-0.0286688041,
0.020362936,
-0.0244306363,
0.0008569063,
0.0187426768,
0.0028280972,
-0.0056905854,
0.0152138108,
-0.0859264955,
-0.0417355783,
-0.0078371987,
-0.0266756751,
-0.0533179864,
-0.0405332111,
0.0147571098,
0.035178002,
-0.0520384759,
-0.0159512125,
2.180649009e-34,
0.0323252343,
-0.0112654557,
0.0633006096,
0.0458257087,
0.0103559578,
0.0062453421,
-0.0245830975,
-0.0308294985,
0.0557480305,
-0.1192183048,
-0.022582015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02506v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02506v1 | Improving the Generalization Ability in Essay Coherence Evaluation through Monotonic Constraints | 2023-07-25T08:26:46 | 2023-07-25T08:26:46 | Chen Zheng, Huan Zhang, Yan Zhao, Yuxuan Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coherence is a crucial aspect of evaluating text readability and can be
assessed through two primary factors when evaluating an essay in a scoring
scenario. The first factor is logical coherence, characterized by the
appropriate use of discourse connectives and the establishment of logical
relationships between sentences. The second factor is the appropriateness of
punctuation, as inappropriate punctuation can lead to confused sentence
structure. To address these concerns, we propose a coherence scoring model
consisting of a regression model with two feature extractors: a local coherence
discriminative model and a punctuation correction model. We employ
gradient-boosting regression trees as the regression model and impose
monotonicity constraints on the input features. The results show that our
proposed model better generalizes unseen data. The model achieved third place
in track 1 of NLPCC 2023 shared task 7. Additionally, we briefly introduce our
solution for the remaining tracks, which achieves second place for track 2 and
first place for both track 3 and track 4. | [
0.0176635385,
0.0517483503,
0.0177010279,
0.0197351258,
-0.0441449322,
-0.0015206885,
0.0090934103,
-0.0342628583,
0.015030059,
-0.0287629627,
0.0299539939,
0.0081313774,
0.0174151622,
0.0341523252,
-0.0041811261,
-0.0591689683,
0.0395369902,
-0.0199103393,
0.0159874763,
0.0003556748,
0.0147842681,
-0.0178811606,
0.0041878405,
0.0323259011,
-0.0359894149,
-0.0927201733,
0.0125469714,
0.0497000515,
-0.0083020637,
-0.0208405219,
0.0139884045,
0.0330026448,
-0.0724019259,
-0.0328138024,
0.0000021241,
-0.0480389632,
-0.0603721887,
-0.0136706047,
-0.0043543028,
-0.0162451155,
-0.0056299921,
0.0038803334,
0.0138186784,
-0.0044159731,
-0.0001495061,
0.0514895432,
0.024364233,
0.0708647594,
0.0456613973,
0.0783621594,
-0.0301818196,
-0.0466752201,
0.052156765,
0.0376871601,
-0.0214073583,
0.0284885075,
-0.0229566153,
0.0336270146,
-0.0211357828,
0.0089198686,
-0.0344486833,
0.0322646983,
0.0117666796,
-0.0358425975,
0.0252023544,
0.009702594,
-0.0535865352,
-0.0261420067,
-0.0265073255,
0.0119654723,
0.0224385038,
-0.0226559881,
0.0238571912,
0.0002834862,
0.0262433309,
-0.0062195281,
-0.0134852221,
-0.0304169152,
-0.0519260615,
0.0349648111,
0.0368614085,
-0.004159858,
-0.0027396607,
0.0112780584,
0.0404202715,
0.0593214259,
-0.0074732904,
-0.0684423074,
0.0204804949,
0.0372455418,
-0.0381132998,
0.0140614584,
0.0647752285,
0.0117840022,
-0.0343257263,
-0.0137788104,
-0.0422641896,
-0.0047753104,
0.0068204878,
-0.0581875592,
0.0327639319,
-0.0037190241,
-0.0255852342,
0.0332302004,
-0.0134462863,
0.0763341114,
0.0490377769,
-0.0006312795,
-0.0255454052,
-0.0051068328,
-0.0562789366,
-0.0354848355,
-0.0384685323,
0.0804911256,
0.0081818113,
-0.0203705858,
-0.044001244,
-0.038605921,
-0.0064964416,
0.0042911172,
0.0000784581,
0.0034690241,
-0.0217417888,
0.0033865692,
0.0610152557,
0.0254717916,
-0.0415937304,
-0.0190462209,
-0.0116987126,
0.0029680063,
0.0089482022,
0.0453038178,
0.0059034699,
0.0009709366,
-0.0081047304,
0.0089605646,
-0.0185772479,
0.0034193655,
-0.0176831298,
-0.0367860161,
-0.0555390753,
-0.0240558293,
-0.043244265,
-0.0333077759,
-0.0637997389,
0.0006535923,
0.0452423654,
-0.055242002,
-0.024033444,
-0.0081201959,
-0.0015690093,
0.0009309303,
-0.0021835247,
0.0223127194,
0.0200389512,
-0.0164261293,
0.0099797249,
0.0335761905,
0.0746895894,
0.026441453,
0.0785772949,
0.0041718786,
0.020135276,
0.003813721,
-0.0564439967,
-0.0603885502,
0.02021675,
-0.0164177381,
-0.0399353355,
0.0279973727,
0.0040717111,
0.0362536125,
0.0078379111,
0.0013059676,
0.0734470487,
0.0529956929,
0.0763244629,
0.001464104,
0.0064076474,
0.0256757233,
0.0273457337,
0.0716837868,
0.0107918885,
-0.0457627065,
-0.0395310819,
0.0462192483,
0.0091482336,
0.0198052004,
0.0109680602,
-0.0895107239,
-0.0176685657,
0.0232203696,
-0.0330864564,
-0.0226882678,
0.0225867759,
-0.0246464442,
-0.0525752418,
-0.0192282517,
-0.0148841115,
-0.0910269991,
-0.0105925696,
0.0225582235,
0.0399084128,
0.0655693561,
0.0188541878,
-0.0560015477,
0.0167879462,
0.0049188994,
0.0391460396,
0.0218095258,
-0.0260276757,
-0.0297900215,
0.0653551668,
-0.0337867811,
0.0079411967,
0.0238148123,
0.0360493027,
-0.0395788066,
-0.062973313,
0.0189856533,
0.0209758542,
0.02506979,
-0.0620796159,
0.057364732,
0.0176126882,
0.018537445,
0.024572337,
0.0031864154,
-0.0057515344,
0.0685646832,
-0.0116391499,
-0.0065482473,
-0.004617936,
-0.0498538688,
0.0253881309,
0.0203098729,
-0.0523902774,
-0.0150527675,
0.0171329826,
-0.0716783255,
-0.0372995399,
0.0221320186,
0.0187972244,
-0.0544854291,
-0.0125041017,
-0.0381889902,
-0.0215844531,
-0.0267707035,
0.0552200973,
-0.0405821875,
-0.0379120149,
-0.0379366428,
0.0155034522,
0.0241487902,
0.0130782705,
-0.0346968882,
-0.0558057949,
0.016133057,
-0.0444116481,
0.0065310565,
0.0062364936,
-0.0056335256,
0.0176178962,
0.025910005,
0.0163482968,
-0.0610772334,
-0.0606766604,
-0.0840290263,
0.0258706156,
-0.0340495966,
0.0335165337,
0.009478529,
-0.0446063206,
-0.0296516195,
-0.0225577261,
0.0235640947,
-0.0298515409,
-0.00658039,
-0.0286945216,
0.0530548133,
-0.0525930412,
0.0233377833,
-0.0597961321,
-0.0139469523,
-0.0157282427,
0.049614381,
0.0625469536,
-0.0696368143,
-0.0407107137,
0.0212925933,
0.0408331826,
-0.0741460994,
0.0544586442,
-0.0333651975,
0.0213630851,
0.0420397371,
0.0721288025,
0.0765325874,
0.0086181676,
0.0044035795,
0.0132656386,
-0.0308255069,
0.0063466448,
0.0040893583,
0.0110273035,
0.0740414336,
-0.0243505649,
-0.0198241789,
0.0495347902,
0.0555840731,
-0.0108133778,
-0.0095315669,
-0.0180065297,
0.0078616356,
-0.0776053444,
-0.0345290005,
-0.0672034174,
-0.0248173196,
-0.0109672332,
-0.0131839765,
-0.0338482633,
-0.0412878357,
0.0600834787,
-0.0291522238,
-0.0007826161,
-0.0407961868,
-0.0166679993,
-0.048085738,
0.029860219,
0.0093184058,
-0.0094126398,
0.0228322558,
-0.0631422848,
-0.0121211912,
0.0230506416,
0.0482171141,
-0.0065265088,
0.0553313904,
-0.0297107548,
-0.0152376862,
0.0232686345,
-0.0385378897,
-0.0105367396,
-0.0517731868,
0.0032747297,
-0.0045336066,
-0.0177467763,
0.004099099,
-0.0161662251,
0.0102143325,
-0.0050891638,
0.0437426716,
-0.0484668203,
-0.0102292737,
0.0133440113,
0.0289789028,
0.0335830301,
0.0273184851,
-0.024516996,
-0.0482141934,
0.0348727554,
0.0162808541,
-0.0648421049,
0.0107623711,
0.0007213982,
0.0153766014,
-0.0060057826,
-0.052418299,
-0.0311589092,
-0.0228541326,
0.0703149438,
-0.0593337826,
-0.0168500375,
0.1030739695,
0.0127461627,
0.0171831213,
-0.0215678513,
-0.0387766361,
0.0494042635,
-0.0152939651,
-0.0058670682,
0.0179640986,
-0.0520434231,
0.0209642481,
0.0386267453,
-0.0030974338,
-0.0082564186,
0.0239242781,
-0.0237636268,
0.0019057789,
0.0162437614,
-0.0154036945,
-0.0386360101,
-0.0206473172,
-0.0048754294,
-0.0290108174,
-0.020937847,
0.0043781875,
-0.0312826969,
0.0395627469,
0.0338076912,
-0.0932968631,
-0.0012981821,
-0.1016105041,
-0.0186587628,
-0.0046297624,
0.0671517476,
0.043172583,
-0.0117264418,
0.0210254695,
0.0053008082,
0.0057298336,
-0.0010696145,
-0.0154979872,
0.0738740042,
-0.0088838674,
0.0108562848,
-0.0614203997,
0.043020457,
0.008303104,
-0.0221665185,
0.0674970374,
0.0167559125,
0.0046707941,
-0.0363088585,
-0.0074513499,
0.0245896634,
0.0104528284,
0.0687095448,
0.0347987525,
-0.0465474166,
-0.0764307156,
-0.0633175746,
0.0387517139,
-0.0541924238,
-0.0065109446,
0.0213055145,
0.0000275314,
-0.0022897096,
-0.0863240361,
-0.0592335016,
-0.0136525519,
-0.0097948369,
0.0151271969,
0.0309757348,
-0.0071872664,
-0.0135474857,
-0.0308382679,
-0.0017491756,
0.0259822197,
-0.0251336042,
-0.0707516819,
0.0379653759,
-0.009171105,
-0.0028516022,
-0.0263467599,
-0.0009444957,
-0.0126021951,
-0.0383687131,
0.0274301879,
0.0060262913,
0.0069122217,
-0.0000341827,
0.0027724146,
-0.0397079363,
0.0124882767,
0.0576164089,
-0.0165875535,
0.0358982533,
0.0330624692,
-0.0448324643,
-0.0031603728,
0.0302854404,
0.0047212429,
0.0190378111,
-0.0044188779,
0.0550789274,
-0.0021655441,
-0.0053740945,
0.010811355,
0.0208717491,
0.0390914343,
0.0219920184,
0.0076848678,
-0.0558098964,
0.0294126142,
-0.0195505712,
-0.0131535651,
-0.0223139431,
0.0325073265,
-0.0129414424,
-0.0251564365,
-0.0356915668,
-0.0065001659,
-0.0378765017,
0.0365127102,
-0.0756830797,
0.0527950078,
0.0289539527,
0.0159672275,
-0.0495483726,
-0.0331492871,
-0.027560655,
0.016205091,
-0.0025456529,
0.0235032886,
0.0514088757,
0.0075196922,
-0.0099525657,
0.0216875039,
0.0117548555,
0.0098312339,
-0.0572668463,
0.0575928837,
-0.0165074524,
0.0321538746,
0.0365194231,
-0.0068639992,
0.0984228253,
-0.0094846422,
0.0117736235,
-0.0402729064,
0.0630675554,
0.0659068972,
-0.0154099688,
-0.0372903235,
0.0137938615,
-0.0256980788,
-0.0019763431,
0.0663770288,
-0.0382626355,
-0.0539252236,
0.0166367702,
-0.0522244051,
-0.0275876876,
-0.0093588196,
0.0210397411,
0.0157777872,
-0.0138077689,
0.0146584483,
-0.0297133494,
0.0201524068,
0.0371950865,
0.0188347176,
0.0632176995,
0.0031182501,
-0.0198322833,
0.0367975049,
-0.032385122,
-0.0214163139,
-0.0631688461,
-0.0041680485,
-0.0114269927,
0.0129474849,
-0.0300762355,
-6.121977885e-33,
-0.0229740981,
-0.0234282613,
-0.0525309369,
0.0506911986,
-0.0353467092,
0.0449163839,
-0.0420072414,
0.013135829,
0.0265543982,
0.052440919,
-0.0021272032,
0.033589188,
0.0236031841,
0.0257209036,
0.0227983966,
0.008296784,
0.068971619,
0.0567855574,
-0.0173371229,
-0.0078413868,
0.038308233,
0.030327769,
0.0610976443,
-0.0449163541,
0.0431185253,
-0.0323595516,
-0.024767803,
-0.0185459536,
0.0382937565,
0.0376858078,
0.0275279153,
0.0591021962,
0.0527362265,
-0.0175493043,
-0.0046344372,
0.0155555699,
-0.0587831326,
-0.0538352989,
0.0169337969,
-0.0071660993,
-0.0371680446,
-0.058131516,
0.0633576289,
-0.0075852089,
0.0136458175,
-0.0529256351,
0.0632563084,
-0.0150043983,
-0.0063222814,
-0.0178269483,
-0.0905259252,
0.0478287339,
-0.0548703112,
0.0185338967,
0.0222123861,
0.0731394961,
-0.0079807602,
-0.0005669052,
0.0094217891,
0.0211262703,
0.0239865985,
0.068456009,
0.0016474329,
-0.0069114827,
-0.0341469832,
0.0763290375,
-0.0114306575,
-0.0138085661,
-0.0383608043,
0.0255366378,
0.0072060134,
-0.0269613434,
0.0742787346,
0.0304395463,
0.0859868079,
-0.0194160175,
-0.0635951906,
0.0162359122,
-0.0197538435,
0.0162726995,
0.0164179932,
-0.0089815091,
-0.0471356958,
-0.0111491513,
-0.0106928237,
-0.0103394371,
-0.0012738793,
-0.028651936,
0.013371597,
-0.0521509089,
-0.0358874537,
0.0356005654,
0.0001587589,
-0.0152179161,
-0.0123411641,
0.0231559705,
-0.021409452,
0.0430299938,
-0.0177732501,
0.0139679173,
0.0004823526,
-0.002153619,
-0.0222485047,
0.0305879246,
0.0631755367,
-0.0188319683,
0.041343797,
-0.0221776217,
-0.0204905327,
-0.0173631161,
0.0456786267,
-0.007808791,
-0.0501717478,
0.0490508787,
0.017334111,
0.0138109457,
-0.0130038634,
0.0675348118,
-0.0198610146,
0.0222089887,
-0.0350178182,
-0.0857743099,
0.0124562113,
0.0060885106,
-0.0087338611,
-0.0061610653,
0.0150557663,
-0.0122036757,
-0.0198300667,
-0.0294024255,
0.0076956544,
0.0102691194,
2.67e-7,
0.0235865712,
0.053215798,
0.0191055275,
-0.0379026644,
-0.0310360696,
-0.0074961702,
-0.0240963306,
0.0292330347,
0.0094987238,
-0.0243196432,
0.004628662,
-0.0243016537,
0.084781751,
0.0351705439,
-0.1166424975,
-0.0110135935,
-0.0475820862,
-0.0117045883,
-0.0513096936,
0.0439041406,
0.1046607494,
0.0037247178,
-0.0299625527,
-0.0005037879,
0.0083226562,
-0.0024351547,
-0.0161688812,
-0.0235772673,
-0.0027298012,
0.0320846885,
0.1078357622,
-0.0502667762,
0.0375908054,
0.0362634957,
-0.0202610809,
-0.0055745388,
0.0686403885,
0.0609242246,
0.0073387255,
0.0347616896,
0.002433785,
0.0312364455,
-0.0037672839,
-0.0171707235,
0.0694057047,
-0.0041327532,
-0.0320455767,
-0.0405904539,
-0.0088409744,
-0.0146293137,
0.030329328,
0.001864031,
-0.0236608014,
0.0194176529,
0.0217503123,
-0.0477933511,
0.0173637699,
-0.0115293227,
-0.0609525591,
-0.0020406961,
0.0184458997,
0.0274326857,
-0.0039610118,
0.0284755342,
0.0103198057,
-0.0816699117,
0.0089118443,
2.365120807e-34,
0.0511198789,
-0.049921155,
0.04535494,
0.0206538849,
0.0009657926,
0.0108261118,
-0.026285518,
-0.0006109868,
-0.0091596907,
-0.0334096961,
0.0328420512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13304v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13304v2 | QuIP: 2-Bit Quantization of Large Language Models With Guarantees | 2023-07-25T07:44:06 | 2024-01-15T21:54:28 | Jerry Chee, Yaohui Cai, Volodymyr Kuleshov, Christopher De Sa | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This work studies post-training parameter quantization in large language
models (LLMs). We introduce quantization with incoherence processing (QuIP), a
new method based on the insight that quantization benefits from
$\textit{incoherent}$ weight and Hessian matrices, i.e., from the weights being
even in magnitude and the directions in which it is important to round them
accurately being unaligned with the coordinate axes. QuIP consists of two
steps: (1) an adaptive rounding procedure minimizing a quadratic proxy
objective; (2) efficient pre- and post-processing that ensures weight and
Hessian incoherence via multiplication by random orthogonal matrices. We
complement QuIP with the first theoretical analysis for an LLM-scale
quantization algorithm, and show that our theory also applies to an existing
method, OPTQ. Empirically, we find that our incoherence preprocessing improves
several existing quantization algorithms and yields the first LLM quantization
methods that produce viable results using only two bits per weight. Our code
can be found at https://github.com/Cornell-RelaxML/QuIP. | [
-0.0479815826,
0.1098855659,
0.0192195661,
0.0394156761,
0.0027873046,
0.0167477839,
-0.0087517751,
0.0376777239,
-0.034958709,
-0.0731909797,
0.0028317182,
-0.0322986618,
0.0093735578,
-0.028580375,
0.032971859,
-0.031868279,
0.035494931,
-0.0599969774,
-0.0302572157,
-0.028423531,
-0.0210435782,
0.0079860063,
0.0266244784,
0.0140822176,
-0.0043522902,
-0.0228135772,
0.0070127062,
0.0264348798,
-0.0168944392,
0.0064693252,
-0.0065098121,
0.0517955162,
0.0350392312,
0.0270869285,
0.0000021989,
-0.0147458632,
-0.0387462787,
-0.01055016,
-0.025624847,
0.0812472776,
0.036482852,
-0.0100556435,
-0.0539311171,
0.0126315393,
-0.0150932278,
-0.020784704,
0.061077103,
0.0016434374,
0.0425749868,
0.0439327843,
-0.018316742,
-0.0312320404,
0.0176090747,
-0.0027200028,
-0.0272492785,
-0.024314858,
0.0221580863,
0.0386014618,
-0.035238333,
0.0092740962,
-0.0272250511,
0.0356964692,
-0.006824736,
0.0187048391,
-0.0036546877,
0.0134715438,
-0.0496884547,
0.0137415575,
-0.0359710157,
0.052315291,
-0.0976219326,
-0.0384438783,
0.0038311994,
0.0252127443,
-0.0084882928,
-0.0791232884,
-0.0383255444,
0.0474397875,
0.0289570093,
0.0594434887,
-0.0001425669,
-0.0301870238,
0.0451840535,
-0.0162799731,
-0.0551567674,
0.0966974795,
0.0252148639,
-0.0177482385,
-0.0394855589,
-0.0114888996,
-0.1133695543,
-0.0489591099,
-0.0223122425,
0.0036658484,
0.0192261301,
-0.0207544081,
-0.0822266191,
-0.0171346385,
-0.0053192475,
-0.0277133249,
0.0474795178,
0.0341234729,
0.0140316021,
0.0322861075,
-0.0036672335,
0.030945668,
0.0021256893,
0.039565254,
-0.0615561493,
0.0209750403,
0.0152008478,
0.0136246784,
-0.0544998907,
0.0251808017,
-0.0317303464,
0.0026848882,
-0.023670895,
-0.0049212743,
-0.019851407,
-0.0088959336,
0.011729341,
-0.0003055253,
-0.0072399587,
-0.0299727488,
0.0480647162,
0.0350010321,
0.0114279194,
0.0012226782,
-0.0362131,
-0.0291787274,
-0.012497359,
0.0471934564,
0.0036225945,
-0.0272392705,
0.0102716284,
0.0246876907,
0.0063863839,
-0.0313112214,
0.0041508614,
-0.0014448562,
-0.0034232249,
-0.0401968025,
-0.0512512922,
-0.0710701048,
-0.0161750261,
-0.000414515,
0.0206935182,
-0.0560465232,
0.0119629363,
-0.0081470339,
-0.022933647,
0.0624471121,
-0.0405902565,
0.0238036495,
0.0017305071,
0.0021180781,
0.0390105434,
0.0911209807,
0.0467675105,
0.0196503531,
0.0306258705,
0.0187072791,
-0.0013979797,
0.0673669353,
0.024336338,
0.0078096585,
-0.0533078089,
-0.0318064205,
0.0405857079,
0.0253043771,
0.0973219872,
0.0911593065,
-0.0623544008,
-0.0289783645,
0.0182965398,
0.0322743542,
0.0395793878,
-0.0084293606,
-0.0082609951,
0.0283415522,
-0.0067670685,
0.0177624337,
-0.0297976695,
-0.0023328983,
0.005154097,
-0.000034547,
0.0686148778,
0.0580308288,
-0.0419906303,
-0.0290177912,
-0.0395890251,
-0.0095679397,
0.0060456465,
-0.0076627154,
0.029373236,
0.0033147321,
-0.0302669797,
0.0898727253,
0.0377958417,
-0.0747423097,
0.0162684936,
-0.0610397235,
-0.045516964,
0.0216848943,
0.0435484014,
-0.009293803,
0.0458426997,
-0.0052792002,
-0.0039616148,
-0.0177708101,
-0.0252549611,
-0.0108510163,
0.0389032103,
-0.0656340048,
-0.0469766743,
0.0273999199,
0.0125985015,
0.0023073426,
0.0061378251,
0.0118250279,
-0.0124235861,
-0.0159612093,
0.0015492165,
0.021181915,
0.0290742777,
-0.0671452358,
0.048594974,
-0.0147836981,
0.0276077408,
0.0301752798,
-0.0185765903,
-0.0046442654,
0.0374520384,
-0.0345385596,
0.0285355952,
-0.0597073324,
0.0378673784,
-0.051823847,
0.0722567812,
-0.0023140716,
0.0027779632,
0.0223168507,
-0.0239264946,
-0.0441218205,
0.0399370864,
0.008458294,
0.0311907269,
-0.0506999642,
0.0382184945,
-0.035004504,
0.0351171903,
-0.0555741861,
-0.0062688226,
-0.0341410488,
0.0062420517,
0.0013750843,
-0.0185250081,
-0.0078019868,
-0.0464929342,
-0.0629620403,
0.0190243386,
-0.0079898536,
0.069169946,
-0.0163688231,
-0.003569989,
0.0435351916,
-0.0249126181,
-0.1191362292,
0.0077692023,
-0.0497650839,
0.0048083663,
0.0304870997,
0.0296123493,
0.0123928543,
-0.0173511617,
-0.0338702202,
-0.0261656307,
-0.0305665713,
-0.0075632134,
0.0028089408,
-0.0010408318,
-0.0293299817,
-0.023882471,
-0.0454441123,
0.0108724032,
0.0430776812,
-0.0368938446,
-0.0194320213,
-0.1050012037,
0.0371277295,
-0.0178816039,
0.0374851301,
-0.0001887671,
-0.0364784412,
-0.0062690969,
-0.0327358544,
0.0185435638,
0.0514154658,
-0.0048839203,
0.0018282556,
0.1118576303,
0.0152807403,
-0.0137947742,
0.024624804,
-0.0095523251,
-0.0493550487,
-0.0052732006,
-0.0486186855,
0.0161741991,
0.0707976222,
-0.0171468053,
-0.0189141855,
-0.0148040131,
0.0148185184,
-0.0249991007,
-0.0062086475,
-0.0831714272,
0.0130239232,
-0.020154411,
0.0643116087,
0.0085413055,
-0.0499903075,
0.0095026093,
-0.0463899374,
0.0042226207,
-0.0248081423,
-0.0055882232,
-0.0239945017,
0.0021969201,
0.0099336663,
0.0451513901,
-0.0354270004,
-0.0190123525,
-0.0499708168,
-0.0103641935,
0.0107725291,
-0.0395233333,
-0.0156229753,
-0.0080898441,
0.0443154424,
-0.0249093976,
-0.0232255142,
0.0176620726,
-0.040716406,
0.0035646702,
0.0091673685,
0.0316801034,
-0.0430767201,
0.0503837094,
0.0635872558,
-0.0296592321,
0.0254932251,
-0.0226218104,
0.004967398,
-0.0124020167,
0.0354810655,
0.0486950055,
0.0104381926,
0.0359239727,
-0.0077007324,
-0.0293555614,
0.0271626282,
0.0526031852,
0.0853715837,
-0.0228972901,
-0.0006826688,
0.0534320921,
0.0047394615,
-0.0163481198,
0.0129234958,
0.0597731397,
0.0142201055,
0.0365679376,
0.0883253291,
0.0289450474,
-0.059677165,
0.018982444,
-0.0028577866,
0.031659849,
0.0119785909,
0.003094303,
-0.1064876989,
-0.0208324324,
0.005587039,
0.0188340936,
0.0333766043,
0.0031625584,
0.0017835665,
-0.047688514,
0.0224825554,
0.0593394153,
0.0345039852,
-0.0439397469,
-0.002810203,
-0.0156638063,
-0.047277838,
0.0673548803,
0.0488478877,
-0.0414571166,
0.0123995803,
0.0186270736,
0.0089337463,
-0.039785888,
-0.0018925128,
-0.0256929342,
0.0706354678,
0.0246236846,
0.0276765451,
-0.0076280977,
0.0229706466,
0.0079552606,
-0.0038099634,
-0.0561336689,
-0.0029687847,
0.00441476,
0.02449416,
-0.0121182539,
0.0261021927,
0.0149838543,
-0.0050277202,
0.0155738071,
-0.0164627563,
0.0425989069,
-0.0018287972,
-0.0087523879,
0.0085736243,
-0.0313133188,
0.0028238893,
0.0495940819,
0.0149768507,
-0.003189205,
-0.0341434292,
-0.0215659365,
0.0085975267,
-0.000943027,
-0.0138896946,
0.0003678231,
-0.0106295813,
-0.0202385448,
-0.0537667833,
0.0293566193,
0.0098326346,
0.0143069699,
-0.0297880713,
-0.0030376166,
0.0182979964,
-0.0002448682,
-0.0929136574,
-0.0049427142,
-0.0378404222,
0.0181325804,
-0.021177832,
-0.0055323066,
-0.0115890168,
0.0113040935,
-0.0163337886,
-0.0193122532,
-0.110730119,
-0.0728786364,
0.0142207704,
0.004393016,
0.0182345957,
0.0573807061,
-0.0159961693,
-0.0843017623,
0.0517521948,
0.0550505631,
-0.0104671707,
0.0648944974,
0.0285374951,
0.0021249889,
-0.0066207484,
0.0491039939,
-0.0203914475,
0.0158439223,
-0.0033109647,
0.0200909413,
-0.0825884789,
-0.0675460622,
-0.0261620861,
0.0314124525,
0.0486189015,
-0.0071979049,
0.0113316318,
0.0077200634,
0.003969342,
-0.0044219168,
0.0105717005,
-0.0526393093,
0.0261565112,
0.0275177341,
-0.0157952551,
-0.0179647133,
0.0272255577,
0.0038210559,
-0.0055441088,
0.0484064408,
-0.0046966397,
-0.0740394667,
-0.0028394801,
0.0499462895,
0.0021279433,
0.0082728211,
0.0430912003,
0.0242512561,
0.0280825403,
-0.0063797059,
0.001134342,
-0.0246051233,
0.0176282991,
-0.051265642,
0.0330424048,
-0.0156892352,
-0.0604713559,
-0.0656753927,
-0.0093904631,
0.0637682527,
0.0379229821,
0.0617066324,
0.0070845895,
-0.0222418271,
-0.029432524,
0.0319490172,
0.0002246808,
-0.0044256099,
0.0254479237,
0.0090812547,
-0.0475408733,
0.0365423262,
0.0640238598,
0.0273679979,
0.0065283719,
0.0022170155,
-0.0040776348,
-0.0135634523,
-0.0248195622,
-0.0546141937,
0.0342300162,
-0.0181396287,
0.0207872,
0.0005580235,
-0.0418651216,
-0.0328425653,
0.0299132876,
-0.0243785866,
-0.0152171962,
0.0134927491,
0.0229523629,
-0.0192108154,
-0.0021448589,
-0.0487316288,
-0.0540112257,
0.0180732943,
-0.0391150452,
-0.0244309604,
-6.460856376e-33,
-0.0239703879,
0.0190406758,
-0.0193022806,
-0.0314210728,
0.0165059604,
-0.007215878,
0.0302261468,
0.0319832377,
-0.0114353057,
-0.0194625631,
-0.0067302254,
0.0224580485,
0.0131840836,
-0.0078517683,
-0.0334034935,
0.0278459955,
0.074590981,
-0.0200426839,
-0.022256529,
0.0393027812,
0.0071791415,
0.0115279062,
0.0499508344,
0.0178883057,
-0.0249644816,
0.0005484736,
-0.0154989455,
0.0171457306,
0.0267426558,
0.0273753125,
-0.0450923517,
0.0309491772,
0.0077375416,
0.0381491594,
-0.0318046063,
-0.0483764149,
-0.0402259938,
0.0028176943,
0.0118475324,
0.040787328,
0.0160100963,
-0.0399047993,
0.0532742515,
0.0011686168,
-0.084958382,
-0.0425558425,
-0.0164889488,
0.0024415227,
-0.0464694761,
-0.0390135273,
0.0133646214,
0.0362553075,
0.0162344184,
-0.0061520832,
0.0853280649,
-0.024992656,
-0.0216022711,
-0.0295930952,
-0.0473486595,
-0.0008046571,
0.028952973,
0.0961480439,
0.0398111716,
0.0060919388,
0.0175414085,
0.0342644677,
0.0547573119,
-0.0166863482,
-0.0293836817,
0.0550793596,
0.0440395959,
-0.0076568834,
0.0335810781,
0.0203835592,
0.115178518,
-0.0097991955,
-0.0595740825,
0.0179381687,
-0.0226335526,
0.0067191254,
0.0203391723,
0.0549133793,
-0.0108491192,
-0.0660532191,
-0.0549622141,
-0.0718431249,
-0.0461916327,
-0.0254231114,
-0.0271974336,
0.0022403616,
-0.0597178079,
-0.0038662311,
0.0352727175,
-0.0513758622,
-0.0430983715,
-0.0035452223,
-0.0248777755,
0.0375770852,
0.0119250985,
0.0325256325,
-0.0030587793,
-0.0087975962,
0.0204560123,
-0.0028455909,
0.0109261181,
-0.005104431,
0.0086618243,
0.0392847843,
-0.0577185676,
-0.0260771569,
-0.0130685307,
0.0036123232,
-0.0005846454,
0.0275651775,
0.0227075256,
0.0228739418,
0.0359105729,
0.0401686169,
-0.0042739669,
0.0141084101,
-0.0258818641,
-0.0028959645,
-0.0034825676,
0.0561160557,
-0.0485033505,
0.0094591891,
-0.0354910865,
0.0175346918,
0.0722635463,
-0.0525586195,
-0.0594734922,
0.00908574,
2.803e-7,
0.0548639745,
0.0384885855,
0.0139005156,
-0.0250173286,
-0.0002985066,
-0.0053026993,
-0.0068461834,
0.033871077,
-0.0163910463,
-0.0185597278,
-0.0115884067,
0.0288832188,
0.0133947833,
0.0159897767,
-0.0732844248,
0.017677065,
-0.0417424887,
0.0216902234,
-0.0516987704,
-0.0229536667,
0.0255717374,
0.111593388,
-0.0115736779,
-0.0153439399,
0.0232752878,
0.0079875877,
0.0403881818,
-0.0170405041,
0.0091141583,
0.0446862578,
0.0319365636,
0.002138359,
0.0040358817,
-0.0472431406,
0.0196513198,
-0.0044427905,
-0.0146272117,
0.1053181589,
-0.0170811787,
0.0134375151,
0.0030900096,
0.0010359439,
-0.041560594,
-0.0315878429,
0.0724664778,
-0.0114379674,
-0.011925552,
-0.1191233099,
-0.0023153424,
0.0008266803,
0.0226136222,
-0.0121611496,
-0.0002555449,
0.0425158516,
0.0323094428,
0.0048960051,
0.0238215551,
-0.0712888092,
-0.0290024728,
0.0524802543,
-0.0225229096,
-0.0613914095,
-0.0189193971,
-0.0033101956,
0.0316750035,
-0.0496002659,
0.0336405747,
2.745390934e-34,
0.0505321994,
-0.0241368283,
0.0392457582,
0.0322362855,
-0.0065654116,
-0.0483574942,
-0.0097753769,
0.0061116721,
-0.0235791337,
-0.0620047599,
-0.0029140858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13298v1 | An Intent Taxonomy of Legal Case Retrieval | 2023-07-25T07:27:32 | 2023-07-25T07:27:32 | Yunqiu Shao, Haitao Li, Yueyue Wu, Yiqun Liu, Qingyao Ai, Jiaxin Mao, Yixiao Ma, Shaoping Ma | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Legal case retrieval is a special Information Retrieval~(IR) task focusing on
legal case documents. Depending on the downstream tasks of the retrieved case
documents, users' information needs in legal case retrieval could be
significantly different from those in Web search and traditional ad-hoc
retrieval tasks. While there are several studies that retrieve legal cases
based on text similarity, the underlying search intents of legal retrieval
users, as shown in this paper, are more complicated than that yet mostly
unexplored. To this end, we present a novel hierarchical intent taxonomy of
legal case retrieval. It consists of five intent types categorized by three
criteria, i.e., search for Particular Case(s), Characterization, Penalty,
Procedure, and Interest. The taxonomy was constructed transparently and
evaluated extensively through interviews, editorial user studies, and query log
analysis. Through a laboratory user study, we reveal significant differences in
user behavior and satisfaction under different search intents in legal case
retrieval. Furthermore, we apply the proposed taxonomy to various downstream
legal retrieval tasks, e.g., result ranking and satisfaction prediction, and
demonstrate its effectiveness. Our work provides important insights into the
understanding of user intents in legal case retrieval and potentially leads to
better retrieval techniques in the legal domain, such as intent-aware ranking
strategies and evaluation methodologies. | [
0.0789661184,
0.0132343872,
-0.026447352,
-0.0248142462,
-0.0519636236,
-0.0040793493,
0.0172349643,
0.0536840372,
0.0293941516,
-0.0519680269,
-0.0584630966,
-0.0037356247,
-0.038629964,
-0.0232396051,
-0.0404712334,
-0.040995229,
0.028708173,
0.0350264087,
0.0846992433,
0.0411923863,
0.0443508103,
0.019342402,
0.0232443027,
0.0298326667,
0.001970415,
0.005029175,
-0.014706946,
0.0286620688,
-0.0219348818,
-0.0584523939,
0.0037462851,
0.0457596071,
0.0449114628,
0.0104588075,
0.0000018364,
-0.0515147634,
-0.0221814811,
-0.0374265313,
-0.0248152763,
0.0157613195,
0.0465780087,
0.046590142,
0.0059475373,
-0.0021330414,
-0.0266975313,
0.0596062355,
-0.0175823886,
0.0053159129,
-0.0035248504,
0.0342140235,
-0.0063331025,
-0.0476262197,
-0.0092040785,
-0.0230386648,
0.0690988079,
-0.032473661,
-0.0023852596,
0.0148240924,
0.0367618911,
0.0044460408,
0.0603492111,
-0.0049998253,
-0.0417574719,
-0.0121385716,
-0.0048441798,
-0.0076528569,
0.0099837137,
-0.0066256016,
0.0520031936,
0.0016093121,
0.0985741541,
-0.0129368799,
-0.0016520176,
0.0076983585,
0.0446853004,
0.0519583486,
-0.0338348337,
0.0588888302,
-0.0528998896,
-0.0017419875,
0.0233790055,
0.0528673008,
-0.0013037975,
0.0188824516,
-0.0089773675,
0.0379251391,
-0.0188098848,
-0.0408027433,
-0.0059146448,
-0.0322799236,
0.072150521,
-0.0501462109,
0.0478460714,
0.0136912176,
-0.0052869753,
0.0202031415,
0.0073041897,
-0.0239378624,
0.1121351495,
-0.0739527494,
-0.024933625,
0.0126937786,
0.018675562,
0.0536306798,
0.0221467782,
-0.0156967025,
0.0202200897,
0.0036169074,
-0.0193277244,
-0.0024307896,
-0.0174233839,
-0.0128358193,
-0.0025006833,
0.0383116677,
-0.0675005913,
-0.0103700971,
0.0111599201,
0.0296091922,
-0.0166560896,
-0.0047649592,
0.0083594313,
0.0127472878,
-0.0543535762,
-0.0376171321,
-0.0683449581,
-0.0749769956,
-0.0521986373,
0.0425764583,
0.0062578279,
0.0246822424,
0.0204275642,
-0.0021975671,
0.0254232567,
-0.0030831078,
0.0255362559,
0.0244721565,
0.0159777626,
-0.0489611514,
-0.054738827,
-0.0954978764,
0.0336210206,
0.0108185867,
-0.0611469261,
-0.0213065837,
-0.0014403841,
-0.005824307,
-0.0369858555,
-0.0309212562,
0.0056482647,
0.071333088,
-0.0073687672,
0.0181778427,
0.0159706846,
-0.0090379659,
0.0161403865,
0.0435373373,
0.0241426285,
-0.0033425665,
-0.0446952395,
0.071162492,
0.0561521463,
0.0348839164,
0.0005780988,
-0.0237201639,
-0.0166909713,
-0.0000186165,
0.039177645,
0.0529140569,
-0.0538404621,
0.0387925543,
0.0200349204,
0.0390333794,
-0.0406926461,
0.0180909205,
0.008087052,
0.0897518322,
0.0527272336,
0.0103493407,
-0.0410121866,
0.0282141585,
-0.0212459024,
-0.0085728467,
-0.0106237084,
0.0278078951,
-0.0253470149,
0.0005727516,
-0.0357016437,
-0.0033184146,
-0.0248836465,
-0.0593614802,
-0.0191208553,
0.0376036391,
0.0096499017,
-0.010249123,
0.0257951785,
0.0314679556,
-0.0132276397,
-0.0060892175,
-0.025026815,
-0.0294972043,
-0.0092401523,
-0.0430026986,
0.013135069,
0.0725098923,
0.0464148708,
-0.0380510017,
-0.0410046205,
0.0016522978,
-0.0585659929,
-0.0012951803,
0.0046096807,
0.0060710129,
-0.059682183,
-0.0385763273,
-0.0546908341,
0.0140446192,
0.0018543563,
-0.0099414578,
-0.0064648557,
0.0326755978,
0.0280380677,
-0.0767758638,
0.0187659115,
0.0131616937,
0.0142809115,
-0.0157076623,
-0.0008637068,
0.0160214826,
0.03641681,
0.0346107483,
0.0478205681,
-0.0035509514,
0.0295816995,
0.0403208286,
-0.0005846713,
0.0187040307,
0.0664942563,
0.0684609711,
-0.0189049318,
-0.0497495942,
0.0362413004,
-0.0033321204,
0.0355130546,
0.0095409704,
-0.064586848,
-0.0235476065,
0.0194879789,
-0.059671741,
-0.0192495603,
-0.0236164741,
-0.064035356,
-0.0465709046,
0.0788941234,
0.0219693705,
-0.0218157042,
0.0234493632,
-0.0447159782,
0.0200932901,
-0.0132613797,
-0.0148648228,
-0.0389897376,
-0.0270053577,
0.0151983229,
0.0487425737,
-0.0209112652,
-0.0634736419,
0.023185702,
-0.0883061588,
0.0100517403,
-0.0323613845,
0.0170504935,
-0.0044914512,
0.0085817408,
-0.0004272663,
-0.0257255603,
-0.017279068,
-0.0452429205,
-0.014503127,
-0.0134511786,
0.0057025994,
0.0155278267,
0.0042948243,
-0.0230495725,
-0.0263239611,
0.00296796,
-0.0021031103,
0.0258590132,
-0.0016111382,
-0.0517909266,
0.0906118825,
-0.0388046615,
-0.0158487596,
-0.0331439488,
0.0351700075,
-0.0059007723,
-0.0059339767,
-0.0567584932,
0.0341131389,
0.0967308432,
0.0326275155,
0.0197935738,
0.0205621757,
-0.0864297226,
0.0016722813,
-0.003411009,
0.0095763672,
0.0136721758,
-0.0351018868,
0.1002216712,
-0.0645110235,
-0.0180243813,
0.0297116097,
-0.0102392239,
-0.030463798,
-0.0085602878,
-0.015609026,
-0.068840757,
-0.0245589018,
0.0141773159,
0.0616306551,
0.0335442498,
-0.0640825033,
0.047575701,
0.0530195534,
0.0716553628,
-0.0519225299,
0.0085636806,
-0.0128284553,
0.1134196892,
-0.0223840084,
0.0126525192,
-0.0277702119,
-0.0418315008,
0.0556922331,
0.0002822221,
0.0993595198,
-0.0589597784,
0.067181997,
0.0004854341,
0.0323526077,
0.0067465222,
-0.0567250624,
-0.0011456697,
-0.0794737861,
0.0182794053,
-0.00505237,
0.0318963863,
0.0173056126,
-0.0368661024,
0.004524447,
0.0172877684,
-0.0132868672,
0.0132002933,
-0.0408471376,
0.0176884886,
0.0245100465,
0.0083058998,
-0.0167700239,
-0.0218102299,
0.0135154761,
-0.0342995748,
0.0096227229,
-0.0003545915,
-0.0454452299,
0.0570513681,
-0.0384095088,
0.0546738133,
-0.0665510148,
-0.0400155671,
0.0250281729,
-0.0312124975,
-0.0147752687,
0.024774218,
0.062475998,
0.0698720068,
-0.0563824847,
-0.0471115075,
-0.0445770808,
-0.004268819,
0.022445159,
0.0216698702,
-0.0562758632,
0.025960736,
0.0203576684,
0.0281729158,
-0.0656359792,
0.0012098004,
-0.0235113297,
-0.0350562744,
0.0552321784,
-0.0127960462,
0.0313362293,
-0.0330982283,
-0.0500102118,
0.0207586735,
-0.0060117436,
-0.0152371014,
0.0376419201,
-0.0531935208,
-0.0239736289,
0.0247173607,
-0.0147592621,
-0.0109899594,
0.0130711626,
-0.0354749896,
0.0139245642,
0.0176189039,
0.0103107691,
-0.014497607,
-0.0494195074,
-0.0382805318,
-0.0228758659,
0.0241243485,
-0.0020070416,
0.028370522,
-0.0269309618,
0.071845457,
-0.0931143835,
0.0159716494,
0.014041136,
-0.0036249561,
0.0140676806,
-0.0022552791,
-0.0625356287,
0.004596964,
-0.0481044985,
-0.0605988204,
-0.0033644778,
0.0355649218,
-0.025193328,
0.0269959625,
0.0211571939,
-0.0158594772,
0.0311413128,
0.0076610283,
0.0005080319,
-0.0092962496,
-0.0457506254,
0.0260004103,
-0.0175760817,
-0.0377157554,
-0.0255522542,
0.027630873,
0.011261669,
0.0185383838,
0.0121048559,
-0.0069572995,
-0.0538841821,
0.0296257436,
0.0097964117,
0.0038131599,
0.0085102972,
0.0183320045,
0.0265804864,
-0.0237571429,
-0.0152174635,
-0.0116860783,
0.0423148461,
0.0404882841,
-0.0253834073,
-0.0299340747,
0.0174060427,
-0.0015347522,
-0.0352864936,
-0.0447813123,
-0.0246335752,
0.0400921106,
0.0060461238,
-0.0292075109,
0.0584860407,
-0.0104164211,
-0.0255507752,
-0.0118730413,
-0.0450620502,
0.0170977693,
-0.0211273823,
-0.00270632,
-0.0248363279,
-0.0224567316,
0.0523154214,
0.0426031537,
0.0270835198,
-0.0013011676,
-0.0222149864,
-0.0273902062,
-0.0150687965,
-0.0042992109,
-0.0236097705,
0.0182848014,
-0.0104048857,
0.0011066885,
0.0036954877,
-0.044260405,
0.0972600058,
-0.0227579772,
0.0006361477,
-0.1013513207,
0.0117421197,
-0.0238323752,
-0.0135584027,
-0.0275657047,
-0.0327484794,
-0.0339482427,
-0.0065066325,
-0.0187739208,
0.0659872368,
-0.0413537063,
0.0385411642,
0.0230171438,
-0.0034968103,
-0.0057414807,
0.03857648,
-0.0421744101,
-0.0293739457,
-0.0022578007,
-0.0193222594,
0.017487742,
-0.026072409,
-0.0246570241,
-0.0292129051,
0.0140968524,
0.0196470078,
-0.0004249319,
-0.0044270847,
-0.0133549236,
0.0123061026,
0.0466762446,
-0.0007512642,
0.0136368088,
0.0136424648,
-0.0699510202,
-0.0209110845,
-0.07372953,
-0.0428930037,
0.0033517287,
-0.0139515996,
0.0154938791,
0.0656441972,
-0.0209746081,
-0.115571633,
-0.0615310706,
0.0277996454,
-0.0295490492,
0.016281208,
0.0184471346,
-0.0001143615,
0.0580292828,
0.1016977504,
0.0055724578,
-0.0355110951,
-0.0219361298,
0.0077851838,
-0.0693219304,
0.0120133813,
-0.0538067259,
-5.73102279e-33,
0.0070927972,
-0.0460258871,
0.0128362859,
0.0256464873,
-0.0035844175,
-0.02170638,
0.0116235521,
-0.0243601687,
-0.0197602045,
-0.0038580948,
-0.0279242229,
0.0418436117,
0.0133847333,
-0.0475633666,
0.0440551117,
0.005127735,
0.030638054,
-0.001761901,
-0.0160395186,
0.0143546909,
0.0119718043,
-0.0002040166,
-0.0286810957,
-0.0895458385,
0.0403534248,
0.0319064334,
-0.0192794204,
-0.0214126576,
-0.0369447172,
0.0506435558,
0.0119232154,
0.0215401743,
0.0569347851,
-0.0407332182,
0.0403108001,
0.0255526435,
-0.0535410456,
0.0116822999,
0.0294027403,
-0.0345379114,
-0.0009223596,
0.0029465728,
0.0436443686,
-0.0039043783,
-0.0524635427,
0.0278296303,
0.0447533354,
0.0102613447,
-0.0479466803,
-0.0675321892,
-0.0434381515,
0.0265976544,
0.0105621666,
0.025309043,
0.0383759737,
0.0481759831,
0.0080291657,
0.0857705399,
-0.0558504052,
0.0302490592,
-0.0953003317,
0.0015596111,
0.0150115378,
-0.0269407239,
-0.0146765905,
0.0566779859,
-0.0266064033,
0.01269018,
-0.0157544017,
-0.0474514998,
0.0125034889,
0.0670018718,
0.0040725777,
0.0256714951,
0.0432938747,
-0.0672446489,
-0.0145398118,
0.042830687,
0.0233968534,
0.0058108284,
0.039064616,
-0.0082794726,
-0.0789590254,
0.0089390101,
-0.0040753661,
-0.0114586437,
-0.0348214768,
0.0138883889,
0.0053776419,
0.0210810751,
0.0402513295,
-0.0539157614,
-0.0350038894,
0.0244214479,
0.0184895955,
0.0333560556,
0.020701753,
0.0022378364,
-0.0133327683,
0.0121817645,
-0.0217959713,
-0.0083902488,
-0.0132706827,
0.0176988412,
-0.032577537,
-0.031774912,
-0.0049073338,
-0.0449988917,
-0.014191973,
-0.0086828088,
0.023665024,
-0.0102483034,
-0.0216118786,
-0.0450946316,
0.0418496169,
0.0429510474,
0.0246768966,
0.0190308653,
0.0497694351,
-0.0051264828,
-0.0638402328,
-0.0597031452,
-0.0177955944,
-0.0334516913,
0.0485019684,
0.0103597799,
0.0211469233,
0.0342896804,
0.0011137535,
-0.0055332296,
0.0008449297,
0.0431002267,
2.722e-7,
0.057637427,
0.0416129418,
-0.0508716516,
0.0630076826,
-0.0187917463,
0.0323819555,
0.0370321386,
0.0203802455,
0.0444453731,
-0.0046873572,
0.0563132577,
-0.0171492156,
-0.0029049527,
0.039355088,
-0.0602642037,
-0.0457909554,
-0.0041629295,
-0.0451393686,
-0.0393015482,
0.0191507991,
0.0767098144,
0.0225893203,
-0.0063905255,
0.0040713339,
-0.0009469324,
-0.0176974051,
0.0030628406,
-0.0265272819,
0.0010296201,
-0.0217797514,
0.0877665356,
-0.0130017037,
-0.0030366404,
0.0227834396,
-0.0046964101,
0.0140625788,
-0.0139703769,
0.0014150462,
0.0091645122,
-0.0079524051,
-0.0294494797,
-0.04084979,
0.0351644866,
-0.0561428517,
0.0131699014,
0.0324439555,
0.0126196956,
0.0250610095,
-0.0314580053,
-0.0092945946,
-0.0020799157,
0.0212420821,
-0.0597986244,
-0.0315914825,
-0.0011133829,
0.0174671374,
0.028624028,
-0.0806277841,
0.0617779754,
0.0180592202,
-0.0329896696,
0.0068870378,
-0.0067603248,
0.0240031574,
0.029670503,
-0.0324093886,
0.0367343463,
1.824679932e-34,
0.0178962275,
0.0144460341,
0.0039433623,
-0.0002749373,
0.0085749859,
0.0584423393,
-0.0381886773,
0.01220123,
0.0067954296,
-0.0598713011,
0.0319720097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.16663v1 | Word Sense Disambiguation as a Game of Neurosymbolic Darts | 2023-07-25T07:22:57 | 2023-07-25T07:22:57 | Tiansi Dong, Rafet Sifa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) is one of the hardest tasks in natural
language understanding and knowledge engineering. The glass ceiling of 80% F1
score is recently achieved through supervised deep-learning, enriched by a
variety of knowledge graphs. Here, we propose a novel neurosymbolic methodology
that is able to push the F1 score above 90%. The core of our methodology is a
neurosymbolic sense embedding, in terms of a configuration of nested balls in
n-dimensional space. The centre point of a ball well-preserves word embedding,
which partially fix the locations of balls. Inclusion relations among balls
precisely encode symbolic hypernym relations among senses, and enable simple
logic deduction among sense embeddings, which cannot be realised before. We
trained a Transformer to learn the mapping from a contextualized word embedding
to its sense ball embedding, just like playing the game of darts (a game of
shooting darts into a dartboard). A series of experiments are conducted by
utilizing pre-training n-ball embeddings, which have the coverage of around 70%
training data and 75% testing data in the benchmark WSD corpus. The F1 scores
in experiments range from 90.1% to 100.0% in all six groups of test data-sets
(each group has 4 testing data with different sizes of n-ball embeddings). Our
novel neurosymbolic methodology has the potential to break the ceiling of
deep-learning approaches for WSD. Limitations and extensions of our current
works are listed. | [
-0.0102079315,
-0.0096072154,
-0.0212932639,
0.0699334741,
-0.0143165654,
0.0312637389,
-0.0490410589,
-0.0222045146,
0.0150762796,
0.0025472406,
-0.0216595195,
0.0021507153,
0.0015335829,
0.0293325055,
0.0323173814,
0.008462945,
0.0797952861,
0.034898892,
-0.0449661948,
-0.0069275191,
-0.0579130575,
0.0068748137,
-0.0396776497,
-0.0192435216,
-0.0486639179,
-0.0094192894,
0.0012186914,
-0.0079156589,
0.0225540977,
-0.0263928007,
-0.005759127,
0.0171620417,
0.0453291759,
0.0685982108,
0.0000018622,
-0.0516123995,
-0.0044158609,
-0.0096993381,
-0.0069186557,
-0.0499242768,
0.0309252217,
-0.0923189297,
0.0432783887,
-0.0300463159,
-0.0202655531,
-0.0203592032,
0.0302252118,
0.0188638829,
0.0552084148,
0.0047713965,
-0.00723704,
-0.0710492507,
0.0237538908,
-0.0005584355,
0.018047411,
-0.0200530402,
0.0151865212,
0.0080760354,
-0.0256468784,
-0.01818843,
-0.0746396929,
0.0455657803,
0.0264874659,
0.0231049247,
-0.0008970844,
0.013705615,
-0.0168468598,
0.0249188505,
0.0022348866,
0.0717763156,
-0.0312092528,
0.0020944874,
0.0024496,
0.0131376106,
-0.0165229701,
0.0097842282,
-0.0096997982,
-0.0035078397,
0.0178122614,
-0.000877047,
0.0018018776,
-0.0157519281,
0.0627409071,
0.0312089548,
-0.0042485534,
0.0794883668,
0.0294386167,
-0.0154753793,
0.0168388486,
-0.0118457275,
-0.0066341679,
0.0099460222,
0.0416873991,
-0.0018492416,
-0.0071574948,
0.0550174192,
-0.0177955423,
-0.0424220636,
-0.0037988576,
-0.0761061385,
-0.0121773016,
0.0401921347,
0.0395077802,
0.0678496733,
-0.0635668635,
0.0089847231,
-0.0401333384,
0.0594658144,
-0.0442142263,
-0.0390234664,
-0.0552405193,
0.0177746918,
-0.0305033159,
0.052607391,
-0.0371828787,
-0.0359810404,
-0.0587667711,
0.0217801854,
-0.0111216241,
0.0015845941,
-0.0199319255,
0.0420877188,
-0.0230638031,
0.0095354458,
-0.0275074523,
0.0283520296,
-0.0773809105,
0.0096731978,
-0.0344523787,
0.0230433326,
-0.020256022,
0.0089100646,
-0.0076621631,
-0.0041183727,
0.0270993747,
0.0537818521,
0.0197177231,
-0.0197259132,
-0.0304733645,
-0.0470227078,
-0.0229858216,
0.011693636,
0.025655169,
-0.0806910619,
0.0288481954,
-0.0014515477,
0.0029151735,
-0.0765997022,
-0.0012943639,
-0.0039483318,
-0.022107318,
0.1255782098,
-0.0695171729,
-0.0600175634,
0.0266837254,
0.0192215405,
-0.0182371624,
0.0676179081,
0.0492622145,
0.007247325,
0.0429939851,
0.0305192657,
-0.0557200573,
-0.0273633134,
0.0062177354,
-0.0123823239,
-0.0149718635,
-0.0563555956,
-0.0332641266,
0.1009839177,
0.0407377444,
0.0295305736,
-0.0619387105,
-0.0632356629,
0.0031239234,
0.0420291089,
0.0200158488,
-0.0066288775,
0.0427194536,
-0.0249436945,
-0.0350593738,
-0.0142220771,
-0.0457701422,
0.0202781316,
-0.0072919093,
-0.0025963178,
0.0127865737,
0.0271118358,
-0.0059951837,
-0.0181380305,
0.0361804031,
-0.0346111134,
0.0406754948,
0.0207452476,
0.0415410586,
0.0100584459,
-0.0089042932,
0.092421867,
0.0480828807,
-0.007960856,
0.0476451218,
-0.0038797592,
-0.0211027544,
0.0378341265,
0.0265552681,
-0.0575550757,
-0.0601283498,
0.0032678191,
-0.0389296822,
0.0626904517,
-0.0115799531,
-0.0213514566,
0.0502819121,
-0.063364543,
-0.0018739324,
-0.0172757171,
0.0130169485,
0.0259740595,
0.0035049855,
0.0132003902,
0.0199897289,
-0.077582784,
0.0325626731,
0.0462708175,
-0.024596082,
-0.0375980213,
-0.020010395,
0.0115905832,
0.0149121899,
0.0218572766,
0.0056751957,
0.0129701952,
0.0256870277,
-0.0620062053,
-0.0325167626,
-0.0357845537,
-0.0282660667,
-0.0799470693,
0.0575312339,
-0.0334785953,
-0.0184607916,
0.0496205837,
-0.0563290678,
-0.0246530976,
0.0273823421,
0.0021696086,
0.023834046,
-0.0331061818,
0.0009392601,
0.0056718611,
-0.0005514412,
-0.0288453046,
0.0416551568,
-0.0119002843,
0.0243220236,
-0.041742254,
0.0213554557,
0.0355697051,
-0.0015747537,
-0.0662258416,
0.032969173,
-0.0093532801,
0.0082528219,
-0.0041980706,
-0.0296872184,
-0.0811475143,
-0.0173202995,
-0.0534498282,
0.0374963209,
0.017236894,
-0.0081302188,
0.0029456837,
0.0046675396,
0.014824071,
-0.0081012938,
0.0069960966,
0.0458887033,
-0.0111972159,
0.0205131713,
0.0382540114,
-0.0303428452,
0.0039032917,
0.0030047689,
-0.0340203159,
-0.0585903488,
0.0540104434,
-0.0067681302,
0.0135578969,
-0.0166423861,
0.0010411114,
-0.0773351714,
0.0230424646,
0.0106300963,
-0.0179928802,
0.0266457554,
0.0221351031,
-0.0087435925,
0.0570723861,
-0.0257597901,
0.0081502339,
0.0632321686,
-0.0137771387,
-0.0065819714,
-0.0018453563,
-0.0214366596,
0.0411685631,
-0.038841866,
0.0135699688,
-0.009629963,
0.0510106385,
0.0269789547,
-0.0235990006,
-0.0250757243,
0.069754228,
-0.0271616708,
-0.0248840339,
-0.0304152332,
0.023239661,
-0.0154848322,
0.0047900057,
-0.0501547977,
0.0037539746,
0.0645451844,
0.0102882767,
0.0405382775,
-0.0534153543,
0.0030117561,
-0.0071681128,
0.0720907897,
-0.0174115207,
0.0425763726,
-0.0054623946,
-0.0195670966,
-0.0664134175,
-0.0288175121,
0.0204218831,
-0.0308626145,
0.0362553895,
-0.0365964025,
0.0110387336,
0.0139238471,
0.0176474396,
-0.0397219248,
-0.0327408537,
-0.02540938,
0.0474016145,
0.0320404693,
-0.000399342,
-0.0395576023,
-0.0339128152,
0.0181572046,
0.0082433075,
0.0379006565,
-0.0246733911,
-0.0448289178,
0.0306709968,
0.04953596,
-0.0045313132,
0.0613027066,
0.0062637185,
-0.0332769677,
0.0261667073,
-0.0244979151,
-0.034239471,
-0.0359545387,
0.0289302524,
0.0105161155,
-0.0641177595,
-0.0241753664,
-0.0050994256,
0.0081208525,
-0.0280035716,
-0.0075308275,
0.1112298667,
0.0437827408,
-0.0403038971,
0.0073911552,
0.0340452529,
-0.030181732,
0.0149209136,
-0.0108372876,
-0.0746033043,
-0.0319222547,
-0.0006402106,
-0.0112886,
0.0765913278,
-0.0730796829,
0.001263044,
-0.0926749259,
-0.0254235007,
0.0008496339,
-0.0196808912,
-0.0580059849,
0.0155353146,
-0.0026623413,
-0.0070458627,
-0.0070589059,
-0.0113487635,
0.0239471942,
-0.0131295919,
-0.0153995007,
0.0263148434,
-0.0222762357,
0.0278972518,
-0.0962939635,
0.0552349836,
-0.0100099454,
0.0511717647,
0.0033870658,
-0.027154332,
-0.063426353,
-0.0388566889,
-0.0435796678,
-0.0153128142,
0.02570072,
-0.0077862469,
-0.0032078724,
0.012068918,
-0.0127673037,
-0.0832974985,
-0.0126453005,
-0.026678184,
0.059754353,
-0.0082325265,
-0.0119658234,
-0.0226169955,
0.0060093822,
-0.0166367535,
0.0543585941,
-0.0349877253,
0.0111363661,
0.0120193725,
-0.002325563,
0.0184589084,
0.0087053347,
0.0132854516,
-0.0203857552,
-0.0164676402,
0.0075183962,
-0.0765847862,
-0.0372225977,
0.0229162052,
0.041620478,
0.0110501871,
0.0276371576,
0.0064706863,
-0.0247463752,
-0.0638926774,
0.0147369904,
-0.0281901844,
0.0048209503,
0.0249621347,
0.0252852943,
0.0389371701,
0.0191700403,
-0.0466353409,
0.0392921753,
-0.0153784994,
-0.0252131931,
0.0180748068,
0.0059087295,
0.0166263804,
0.0357591398,
-0.0225003138,
0.004984004,
0.0380916931,
0.0211835131,
0.0283351373,
0.033450827,
0.0061429879,
0.0446820445,
0.0101828966,
0.0460517444,
-0.0386418328,
0.0123810237,
-0.0008466048,
0.0598551072,
-0.0215424355,
-0.0112355454,
0.0028326593,
-0.0154322861,
0.061065577,
-0.0136873228,
0.0002372215,
-0.0217049252,
-0.0469100252,
-0.043583259,
0.000014156,
0.0065258825,
-0.0303375721,
0.0392205417,
-0.0219729859,
-0.0190059841,
0.0366299786,
0.0456597619,
0.0242087431,
0.0305913929,
-0.024696229,
0.0409649834,
-0.0331133828,
-0.0367287323,
0.0212299228,
-0.012235079,
-0.0177623443,
-0.0225746725,
0.0196776297,
-0.0334901586,
-0.0091062179,
0.0181219839,
-0.007541094,
-0.1065302789,
0.0304528456,
-0.028541619,
0.0182575788,
0.0349100977,
0.0226776749,
0.0860953331,
-0.0241056867,
0.0249797497,
-0.0102481609,
-0.0113139311,
0.0328002945,
0.0160213746,
-0.0119390506,
0.0136499237,
0.049765341,
0.0340117849,
0.0232940782,
-0.0325003974,
0.0371404178,
-0.0271294098,
0.0456781052,
0.0129495393,
-0.0244904328,
-0.0345970057,
-0.0099971034,
-0.0095533049,
0.0694679022,
-0.0310762096,
0.0272360761,
-0.0512525998,
-0.0713071525,
0.084339276,
0.0218650755,
-0.0116092954,
0.0164153744,
0.0619335361,
0.0317090899,
0.0335609801,
-0.0470325463,
0.012165783,
-0.0023390495,
-0.0371621251,
-0.0730542466,
-0.0272778049,
-5.804361148e-33,
-0.0219777338,
-0.0095895519,
0.0128353434,
-0.0540844537,
-0.0508661605,
-0.0038630778,
-0.0262131356,
-0.0242715105,
-0.0671468824,
0.0445659086,
0.0082466444,
0.0402337946,
-0.0015842449,
0.0072398325,
-0.0077685895,
-0.0195025615,
0.0288052596,
0.0195990112,
0.0107413977,
-0.0170988142,
0.0513529181,
0.0511790067,
0.0459365994,
-0.0521108918,
0.0222617444,
0.0179711692,
0.0346181206,
0.0534783639,
0.0407606959,
0.0213663857,
-0.0146763846,
0.0620866492,
0.0295952652,
0.0106877955,
-0.0058588078,
-0.0000091786,
-0.0997503176,
-0.0744427145,
0.0054333471,
-0.0161329228,
-0.0341118202,
-0.0212314799,
0.0806829184,
-0.0128469151,
0.0183738489,
-0.0279371887,
0.0241037663,
-0.02385501,
-0.0785814449,
-0.0450057946,
-0.064919658,
0.0016759306,
0.0160133913,
-0.0339830033,
-0.0011484607,
-0.0683914647,
0.023891991,
-0.0208274759,
-0.0873808563,
0.0064504263,
-0.0574438274,
0.0281101037,
0.0121124582,
0.0306834225,
0.0244984776,
0.0470007844,
0.0406891145,
-0.0191747118,
0.0151980007,
-0.0228081476,
0.0778177604,
0.0118595371,
0.0443299152,
0.075353153,
0.0780276358,
-0.0250385795,
-0.0526202768,
-0.0102193626,
0.0063652243,
0.0707197189,
-0.0118129915,
0.0165693741,
-0.0399511084,
-0.0230236575,
-0.0817887411,
0.0177314207,
-0.00363525,
-0.0279345922,
-0.0032063569,
-0.0372398719,
-0.0257599745,
-0.0005086541,
-0.0033256242,
-0.0553616434,
0.034429092,
0.0432201624,
0.0597734787,
0.0286892634,
0.021832576,
0.019099541,
0.0333799645,
-0.0247400273,
-0.0305326935,
0.0165882241,
0.01456651,
-0.0089386925,
-0.0029979467,
0.010933972,
-0.004415425,
0.0051583699,
0.0027906557,
-0.0606441721,
0.0043357452,
-0.0155302593,
0.0210061762,
0.0307425354,
-0.0021886774,
-0.0143252807,
0.0491736941,
0.0025990568,
0.0298742354,
0.0336998329,
0.0238854457,
0.061453376,
-0.041102387,
0.0067228037,
-0.0346940532,
0.0120324446,
0.0418586731,
-0.0904912055,
-0.0008132358,
-0.018216541,
2.783e-7,
0.0584310107,
0.0555896387,
-0.0138237597,
0.0308970269,
-0.0085401079,
-0.0004712357,
0.0222512297,
0.0198095366,
-0.0415449627,
-0.0346669853,
-0.0072435844,
0.0475185961,
-0.0010872304,
0.040998891,
-0.0606192276,
0.0041827029,
0.0125408368,
0.0407727174,
-0.0117171239,
0.0189063195,
0.0609961823,
0.0874562338,
0.0306364018,
-0.0156755522,
-0.032681305,
-0.0691355541,
0.0288766269,
0.0182862952,
0.0434419923,
-0.0324663818,
0.007006492,
0.0234099869,
0.0244997051,
0.0439398065,
-0.020515345,
0.0103119183,
-0.0014937504,
-0.0010781842,
-0.0273401979,
-0.0044081295,
-0.0326117128,
-0.0513626523,
0.0099910498,
-0.0144761857,
0.0461802781,
-0.1047295406,
-0.0261254311,
-0.0063291676,
-0.0491435975,
0.0139623834,
0.0388253666,
-0.0017944983,
-0.0492265448,
-0.0305853467,
0.0101852911,
0.0157489739,
-0.0013849847,
-0.0555747263,
0.0239948761,
0.0652671456,
-0.0291706584,
0.0173348114,
0.0306450427,
-0.0732062235,
0.0564420149,
-0.0530462563,
0.0014601519,
2.064382746e-34,
0.0294343438,
0.010103941,
0.0123767899,
-0.0395755619,
0.0367326811,
-0.0229630843,
-0.0000858764,
-0.0031552566,
0.0517588407,
-0.0342883021,
0.0177878086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13269v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13269v2 | LoraHub: Efficient Cross-Task Generalization via Dynamic LoRA Composition | 2023-07-25T05:39:21 | 2024-01-18T06:53:39 | Chengsong Huang, Qian Liu, Bill Yuchen Lin, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Min Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Low-rank adaptations (LoRA) are often employed to fine-tune large language
models (LLMs) for new tasks. This paper investigates LoRA composability for
cross-task generalization and introduces LoraHub, a simple framework devised
for the purposive assembly of LoRA modules trained on diverse given tasks, with
the objective of achieving adaptable performance on unseen tasks. With just a
few examples from a new task, LoraHub can fluidly combine multiple LoRA
modules, eliminating the need for human expertise and assumptions. Notably, the
composition requires neither additional model parameters nor gradients.
Empirical results on the Big-Bench Hard benchmark suggest that LoraHub, while
not surpassing the performance of in-context learning, offers a notable
performance-efficiency trade-off in few-shot scenarios by employing a
significantly reduced number of tokens per example during inference. Notably,
LoraHub establishes a better upper bound compared to in-context learning when
paired with different demonstration examples, demonstrating its potential for
future development. Our vision is to establish a platform for LoRA modules,
empowering users to share their trained LoRA modules. This collaborative
approach facilitates the seamless application of LoRA modules to novel tasks,
contributing to an adaptive ecosystem. Our code is available at
https://github.com/sail-sg/lorahub, and all the pre-trained LoRA modules are
released at https://huggingface.co/lorahub. | [
0.0324893668,
0.0356176086,
-0.0003577868,
0.02718376,
0.011654269,
0.0375884026,
0.0013931865,
-0.0270946063,
0.0016945335,
-0.0266213845,
-0.0691735372,
-0.0187699553,
0.0133529995,
0.0243188199,
0.0736494809,
-0.0595276617,
0.0347045511,
-0.0579899102,
-0.0276272018,
0.0026862994,
0.0088916756,
0.0436775684,
0.0136190262,
0.0462455638,
0.054178413,
-0.006153984,
-0.0215204954,
0.0138430269,
0.0411007851,
0.020192638,
0.0275247432,
0.0344363265,
0.0493679158,
0.0374121442,
0.0000021633,
-0.0277965628,
-0.041962143,
-0.0049987081,
-0.0103045339,
-0.0192351975,
0.0345115922,
0.0081472285,
-0.0148248393,
0.0467840917,
-0.0455109812,
-0.0542169586,
0.0413456783,
0.0049386714,
0.0345055386,
0.0797440484,
-0.0102574369,
0.0072365259,
0.0134225693,
-0.0667879656,
0.0025405067,
-0.0523369946,
0.0048922412,
-0.0200369563,
-0.0050937803,
-0.0257329885,
-0.0289755389,
0.0097717009,
0.0240359772,
-0.0022400254,
-0.0101646753,
0.0193713102,
-0.0485924669,
-0.0299038403,
-0.0329109803,
0.0906094983,
-0.0643042475,
-0.0055385861,
0.0307911932,
-0.0177639797,
0.0022619169,
-0.034586966,
-0.0445534885,
-0.0081528649,
-0.0015391127,
0.0206905827,
-0.0041831434,
-0.0380380303,
0.0214176383,
-0.0054178447,
-0.0526465923,
0.0403369442,
0.0344644859,
-0.0045776851,
-0.0022182052,
-0.0276153833,
-0.0295335501,
-0.0501568504,
-0.0114227869,
0.0470882766,
-0.026846882,
-0.0014870389,
-0.0932611823,
-0.0423186421,
0.023221042,
-0.0009068613,
0.1011123657,
0.0545492582,
-0.0197251234,
0.0587451719,
-0.0449300893,
0.0414263047,
-0.0374803022,
0.020302454,
-0.0480376072,
-0.0147560872,
-0.0526436269,
0.0053917612,
-0.0150460089,
0.0300736502,
-0.0725980252,
-0.0340714492,
-0.029892901,
0.0456753261,
0.0021293834,
0.0099747786,
0.0363196768,
-0.002810695,
-0.0370049402,
-0.0270786807,
0.0209564716,
0.0326153003,
0.0087028174,
0.0463221259,
0.019422574,
-0.0384710282,
-0.009766751,
0.0017459909,
0.0358855203,
-0.0304104034,
0.03070754,
0.0798114762,
-0.0284711048,
-0.0259878524,
-0.0002503236,
0.0026778153,
-0.006198233,
-0.0895928591,
-0.0134175606,
-0.036198888,
0.0375551805,
-0.0130164418,
0.0135970246,
0.0039988123,
-0.020993676,
0.0279970299,
-0.0255583562,
0.0740386546,
-0.0006479225,
-0.0026993519,
0.0171402711,
0.0149667915,
-0.0142365759,
0.0767682418,
0.0321050957,
0.0334058478,
-0.0005156745,
0.0042889547,
-0.0160396453,
0.0438022017,
-0.0076219165,
0.0033033579,
0.0166843161,
0.0092681022,
0.0448177569,
-0.0259013958,
0.0440758951,
0.011116812,
-0.0241720974,
0.0200433359,
0.0685054809,
0.0308228377,
0.0559419468,
0.0203040335,
0.0460443757,
-0.0132583883,
-0.0205121282,
-0.0037095633,
-0.0492617376,
0.0399654247,
-0.0232987776,
0.0032953646,
0.0230945162,
0.0800414607,
-0.0363839231,
-0.0305340867,
-0.0308906399,
-0.019583974,
0.0021042605,
0.0309393704,
0.0414117314,
0.024956679,
-0.0527919903,
0.0218321849,
0.0401505567,
-0.0658771619,
0.0131810503,
-0.0561599471,
0.0666566864,
0.0661236867,
0.0096168378,
-0.0509381182,
-0.0426228456,
-0.0041003986,
0.041955743,
0.0017143911,
0.0259227846,
-0.0124937026,
0.0522449501,
-0.0697923899,
-0.0350367986,
-0.0290235616,
0.009847668,
0.0147758769,
0.0296966564,
0.0269513037,
0.0226144325,
-0.0344700739,
0.0059712986,
0.0294351615,
-0.0384530015,
0.0024019824,
0.0139763588,
0.0243097749,
0.0278375186,
-0.0114564467,
0.0150607061,
-0.0135618495,
0.0294824522,
-0.0480019003,
-0.0022005767,
0.0220790133,
-0.0356568843,
-0.0250710174,
0.0246043876,
-0.0023523753,
0.0017747075,
0.042744197,
-0.0586507469,
-0.0414175987,
0.0157981981,
-0.0253896806,
0.037217617,
-0.0209088866,
0.0126144625,
0.0095027685,
0.0442374162,
0.0024885365,
0.0278576426,
0.0158764888,
-0.0274273194,
0.0261709373,
-0.0062918435,
0.0014353747,
-0.0326483957,
-0.033106748,
0.0051408452,
-0.0111146579,
0.0131156212,
0.0081202723,
0.0112536922,
-0.0247895885,
-0.0360402428,
-0.082779184,
0.0199474357,
-0.0295172445,
0.041548837,
0.0307271928,
0.0420890488,
-0.0018383334,
-0.0351327397,
-0.0080577526,
0.0192704499,
-0.0167498384,
0.029345436,
0.0042053931,
0.0154383341,
-0.0152207026,
-0.0605491139,
-0.0107458057,
-0.0055588661,
0.041768048,
-0.0527853519,
-0.0057883491,
-0.0758153051,
0.0020369072,
-0.0225470681,
0.0325018317,
-0.0438471064,
-0.0297230519,
-0.0038286517,
-0.0324220508,
0.0823744908,
0.0717012957,
-0.015428666,
-0.0274904501,
0.0585267916,
0.0013336543,
-0.0424743406,
0.0338915996,
0.0063630245,
-0.0395644829,
-0.0530350916,
0.0079660714,
-0.0204907991,
0.054556746,
-0.0326981582,
-0.0104801357,
-0.0729880482,
-0.0137753375,
-0.0256252848,
-0.0418498144,
-0.0180154275,
-0.003329484,
-0.0004498236,
-0.0114952046,
-0.0453589894,
-0.0278321207,
0.0522144884,
-0.0213725232,
-0.04303791,
-0.0173287876,
-0.0566579998,
-0.0938648507,
0.0747895986,
-0.0020176235,
0.0053359624,
0.0027920045,
-0.033367116,
-0.0590663701,
-0.0039934539,
0.0018763441,
-0.0094769318,
0.0377349518,
-0.0576479547,
-0.0006616989,
-0.0620384291,
-0.0753743351,
0.0231314525,
-0.0352354683,
-0.0070359912,
0.0212494768,
-0.0207175389,
-0.0253061745,
-0.02495615,
0.0038858429,
0.026306048,
0.0714588612,
-0.0163950063,
0.0042994842,
-0.0432494134,
0.0199515969,
0.0630327463,
0.06518884,
-0.0245464053,
-0.0346183367,
0.0019718679,
0.0257184412,
0.0680922195,
-0.000692311,
-0.0284644105,
0.0330600739,
0.0523496196,
0.0040975707,
-0.0113455905,
0.0139018474,
0.0583148338,
-0.0631762892,
-0.0001480609,
0.0654560253,
-0.0160099585,
-0.0596262179,
-0.0261552613,
-0.0147798937,
0.0617128164,
0.0443315804,
0.0366148837,
-0.0688916072,
-0.0347415693,
0.0220622327,
0.0005102329,
0.017677946,
-0.0021897287,
-0.0312283281,
-0.1159771234,
-0.0009115539,
-0.0015967988,
-0.052920308,
-0.0046527009,
-0.0369267352,
0.0211453512,
-0.0231281184,
0.0295475014,
-0.013260629,
-0.0345243253,
-0.021075109,
0.0260665081,
-0.0280336924,
-0.0442149751,
-0.0123126274,
-0.0244898684,
0.0362857059,
0.0500515662,
0.011252379,
0.0366925746,
-0.0159888137,
0.0357564837,
-0.0088966349,
0.0014948352,
0.0059386254,
0.0313497595,
-0.0003276506,
-0.023730522,
0.0156099917,
0.0427641384,
-0.0274576694,
-0.0125970198,
-0.0081776669,
0.0658709779,
0.0417247899,
0.0050418116,
-0.0011075551,
-0.0318700336,
0.0125347879,
0.0393301509,
0.0469262637,
-0.04067339,
-0.0151783004,
0.0091929361,
-0.0439269952,
-0.0366347842,
-0.0148871625,
0.0083536003,
-0.0252724122,
0.0169738103,
-0.0200565699,
-0.0132598281,
0.0789852142,
0.0472741164,
0.0010240583,
0.0177143365,
-0.0213604476,
0.0101675969,
-0.0518024489,
0.0294822324,
-0.0411251411,
0.0155855333,
-0.0459359437,
-0.0185188036,
0.041743543,
-0.0096737361,
-0.0167393796,
0.022099752,
-0.0932485983,
-0.0726117343,
-0.0137619339,
0.0564558804,
0.0223324932,
0.0172242094,
-0.0022607453,
-0.078812018,
0.0789027512,
0.015910469,
-0.0093012853,
0.0545609519,
0.033117041,
-0.0151506159,
-0.0010493952,
0.0485044681,
-0.0902942941,
-0.0130146062,
0.0283228438,
0.009585714,
0.0067235371,
0.0087682446,
-0.0119223772,
-0.0245439131,
-0.0130046764,
-0.0185953341,
-0.0333693214,
-0.0309719667,
0.0679313615,
0.0041169622,
-0.0012654749,
-0.0564025454,
-0.013239692,
0.028066976,
-0.0228535347,
0.0018524232,
0.0653064847,
0.048877757,
0.0224772356,
-0.0937194899,
0.0148606915,
0.0236440413,
0.0018872548,
0.0481705293,
0.0201153867,
-0.0303125419,
-0.0009760542,
-0.0206873305,
-0.0068443278,
-0.0383719057,
-0.0162614807,
-0.0058588977,
-0.0126604894,
-0.0263387337,
0.0809176117,
-0.0533380918,
-0.0761567801,
-0.0184817892,
0.0426561683,
0.0634438694,
0.0304328706,
0.0978264511,
0.0399740562,
-0.0260293204,
-0.0151407244,
-0.0137324221,
-0.0288538728,
0.0030052329,
0.0013485873,
0.0161298588,
-0.007572595,
0.0155301038,
0.0982977077,
0.030049596,
0.0593155585,
-0.021537818,
0.0340245254,
-0.0293539539,
-0.0135197854,
0.046810586,
-0.0002748976,
-0.0175999962,
-0.0299794506,
0.0144033059,
-0.075592801,
0.000660933,
-0.000347996,
-0.0183934476,
0.0099610239,
0.0180771891,
0.045978494,
-0.0086022643,
-0.0161638409,
0.001752631,
-0.0433778726,
0.0326090232,
0.0084468424,
0.007194303,
-6.889404882e-33,
-0.0390244536,
0.026606774,
0.023231497,
-0.0032371748,
-0.0031211986,
0.0107786376,
-0.0289668385,
-0.0235138573,
0.0125446906,
-0.0263027903,
0.0005834551,
0.0059616868,
0.0194638409,
0.0069476813,
0.0158739556,
0.0043066097,
0.0736895651,
0.030667888,
-0.0158368461,
0.0174517557,
0.0027033812,
0.050165154,
0.056424994,
-0.0229649413,
-0.0157933496,
0.0153719801,
-0.0342474096,
0.009375643,
-0.0260656774,
0.0684982464,
-0.013888103,
0.0305883642,
0.0214945246,
-0.015155782,
-0.0513264723,
0.0482389815,
-0.0969423875,
-0.0038934441,
0.0349834375,
-0.0088291587,
-0.0391045995,
-0.0281806719,
0.0614525005,
-0.006703475,
0.0239993352,
-0.0268847961,
0.0366874412,
0.000656329,
-0.0111071896,
-0.0216578413,
-0.0692860186,
-0.0018070544,
0.0189952962,
-0.0159872919,
0.0312551707,
0.0373567827,
0.0180978831,
0.0222673193,
-0.0594694391,
0.0177059434,
-0.0515285246,
0.0557506122,
0.0463745445,
0.0125872111,
-0.0246940982,
0.0221041348,
0.0279648285,
0.0023079279,
0.0330624357,
-0.0333202966,
0.0053111203,
0.0579885542,
0.0110713495,
0.0523804016,
0.0303425696,
0.005027479,
-0.0708138049,
-0.0002479338,
0.0290339086,
0.0150047066,
0.0158728678,
0.0610009916,
0.0039230553,
-0.0034411694,
-0.0310519505,
0.0127568562,
-0.0563618243,
-0.0035763185,
0.0398706421,
0.0712716728,
-0.0167032592,
0.0057865139,
0.0319645479,
-0.0329051912,
0.0086480575,
-0.0111360457,
0.0014813424,
0.0117988773,
0.0095912749,
0.0412726365,
-0.0424887948,
-0.0639563128,
0.035207469,
-0.0121940589,
0.0201846026,
-0.0174217243,
0.0506790765,
0.0712910667,
-0.0888105184,
0.0018398457,
-0.0351631343,
0.0373813249,
0.0100326659,
0.0706751123,
0.0360452943,
0.0033848358,
-0.0211547185,
0.0209140982,
0.0020976244,
0.0068846326,
-0.0264491625,
-0.0181108527,
0.0102708405,
0.0118789393,
-0.0128918719,
-0.0145466831,
-0.0245281663,
0.0033934475,
0.0327910073,
-0.0422611758,
-0.0155497212,
0.0307553988,
2.995e-7,
-0.0145833651,
0.0185377765,
-0.0205908623,
-0.0341482684,
0.0177637152,
0.0040385826,
-0.0392179824,
0.0639969856,
0.0011975052,
0.0123943035,
-0.0199402552,
0.0120689087,
0.0520653762,
0.0038080397,
-0.0871306732,
0.0010264715,
-0.0696505159,
0.0062216474,
-0.0481591076,
-0.019027425,
-0.0203388594,
0.1058400199,
0.0260275174,
-0.0176881198,
-0.0021992037,
-0.0334380791,
0.0588624664,
-0.0177249014,
-0.0208837315,
0.00657801,
0.0221199375,
0.0366554745,
-0.0431566648,
-0.0218311101,
-0.0192968212,
0.0532544293,
-0.0165471658,
0.05866763,
-0.0190840978,
-0.0285219215,
0.0268081836,
0.0108562876,
-0.0079265339,
-0.0433803312,
0.0749353915,
-0.0673559234,
-0.0094934786,
-0.0270432644,
0.0044653038,
-0.0211213026,
0.0176485144,
-0.0070344931,
0.0147714373,
0.0198430624,
0.0277548321,
-0.0230935663,
-0.0325293429,
-0.1389732957,
-0.0043831258,
0.005482011,
-0.0606104918,
-0.0414096303,
-0.0517443344,
-0.0238459874,
0.03078866,
-0.0783454254,
0.0210222304,
2.791818369e-34,
0.0115907341,
0.0238660574,
0.0155798476,
0.0293893106,
0.023270499,
-0.0161418281,
-0.0518489219,
-0.0108526815,
0.0176279731,
-0.0888449848,
-0.0361882746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13176v1 | Schema-Driven Actionable Insight Generation and Smart Recommendation | 2023-07-24T23:53:13 | 2023-07-24T23:53:13 | Allmin Susaiyah, Aki Härmä, Milan Petković | cs.CL | cs.CL | In natural language generation (NLG), insight mining is seen as a
data-to-text task, where data is mined for interesting patterns and verbalised
into 'insight' statements. An 'over-generate and rank' paradigm is intuitively
used to generate such insights. The multidimensionality and subjectivity of
this process make it challenging. This paper introduces a schema-driven method
to generate actionable insights from data to drive growth and change. It also
introduces a technique to rank the insights to align with user interests based
on their feedback. We show preliminary qualitative results of the insights
generated using our technique and demonstrate its ability to adapt to feedback. | [
0.0425576009,
-0.0090092467,
-0.0296108425,
0.0267580859,
0.0240085833,
-0.0256926306,
-0.0431731939,
-0.0519716926,
0.0497904047,
-0.0457433201,
0.0130144199,
0.0661495179,
-0.0052211727,
0.0995488763,
-0.0000918755,
-0.0394844711,
0.0396797657,
-0.0161479693,
0.0036954742,
0.0386954285,
0.0246075597,
0.0351993404,
0.0079713296,
0.0302321874,
0.0125820041,
0.029416047,
-0.0067413701,
-0.029769443,
0.0259126797,
-0.0382378586,
-0.0157343876,
0.0189473815,
-0.0142306304,
0.0354445986,
0.0000021517,
-0.0632745773,
-0.0534805283,
-0.0177319814,
0.0481393524,
-0.031175822,
-0.0012701229,
0.0012881763,
0.0273056943,
0.0020541148,
-0.0720335618,
0.0370834805,
-0.0087602511,
0.0270962846,
0.0463370085,
0.0210268106,
-0.0362105928,
-0.0227398034,
-0.0232195742,
0.0131475944,
0.0000621906,
-0.0166059621,
-0.0525867529,
-0.0030020026,
-0.0121956607,
0.0406802632,
0.0136336712,
0.0027283896,
-0.0410137326,
-0.0589829758,
0.0991590917,
0.0194152854,
0.0175722409,
-0.0312711857,
-0.0256646834,
0.0710970163,
-0.0299822912,
0.0378029086,
-0.0074802032,
-0.0471684709,
0.0209751818,
0.004245162,
0.0134532442,
0.0094418759,
-0.0237822421,
0.0269262604,
0.0235057082,
0.023186544,
-0.0045265774,
-0.0182023812,
-0.0048667253,
0.0376163907,
-0.0225332174,
-0.0089362916,
-0.0014809762,
-0.0141643118,
-0.0180964824,
-0.0373462588,
0.0113808615,
0.0303922724,
-0.0680491999,
0.0181008931,
-0.0039916416,
0.0159196947,
0.0220995583,
-0.0778324232,
0.0841973722,
0.0211904123,
0.0299845394,
-0.0205324665,
-0.0086868005,
-0.0157569125,
0.014125526,
-0.0467047915,
-0.0336781219,
0.0230260082,
-0.055761911,
-0.0208648331,
-0.0271645654,
0.0528300442,
-0.0239233933,
-0.0122918095,
-0.075686574,
0.0399649069,
0.0000213457,
0.0147309368,
0.0012287248,
0.0668461472,
-0.0020310259,
0.0206429064,
-0.0766236559,
0.002142038,
-0.0268938243,
0.0062910146,
-0.0050560599,
-0.0024330802,
0.0595762357,
0.0341899432,
0.0163325183,
0.0163082555,
-0.0101399478,
0.0135117527,
-0.0241046529,
0.0132451514,
-0.0839184001,
-0.1146445647,
0.0134356059,
0.0061650854,
-0.0421071276,
-0.0406071767,
-0.0054863398,
0.0127138561,
-0.0139972847,
-0.033874575,
0.012927006,
0.0417326763,
-0.0100521995,
0.0307955313,
-0.0754413977,
-0.0009171264,
0.0107101863,
-0.0093995146,
0.0043100175,
0.0513980836,
0.0476529337,
0.0717816874,
0.0398367159,
-0.0003301777,
0.0105678579,
-0.0178999826,
0.0139235547,
-0.0134824887,
0.0064322916,
0.0065427213,
-0.0734609589,
0.029693041,
-0.0166323427,
0.0181542579,
0.0131477527,
0.0926080868,
0.0425556898,
0.0098034944,
0.0233811215,
0.0671637729,
0.0439520516,
0.0301483888,
-0.0490580499,
-0.0193701256,
0.0607004352,
0.0492930748,
-0.0335473344,
0.0000628216,
0.0113858078,
0.0536129661,
0.0300268922,
-0.0733110532,
0.0024324195,
0.0306291562,
0.0069262763,
-0.0147523759,
-0.0022451722,
0.0138562554,
-0.0289136581,
0.0306358039,
0.0181610901,
-0.0906888545,
0.0086030476,
-0.0113243423,
0.0533495061,
0.1330221146,
0.0506668948,
-0.0431454107,
0.0006310265,
0.0231672917,
-0.0513184033,
0.035793785,
0.0162381139,
-0.055676192,
-0.0280057527,
-0.0366328619,
-0.0425948501,
0.0012791372,
-0.0091052866,
-0.0025223694,
-0.0254947152,
-0.0143515607,
0.0163396597,
0.012640913,
-0.0627812445,
0.0133355763,
-0.011996828,
0.0132168047,
0.0487465113,
0.005953792,
0.0170565881,
0.0502985567,
0.0292355698,
0.032238692,
0.0316746011,
-0.0194043852,
-0.0514880605,
0.0677123293,
0.0129697863,
0.0026315348,
-0.0052655367,
-0.0637445375,
0.0422943458,
-0.0605973043,
0.0023727922,
-0.0190546084,
0.0180064254,
-0.0446465313,
0.0144097544,
-0.0389843844,
-0.0195920486,
0.0087918285,
0.0079904534,
-0.0454860106,
0.1128182188,
0.0074511738,
-0.0177043788,
0.0457897224,
-0.1043276414,
0.0244323257,
0.025255844,
0.0390769653,
0.0135250315,
0.0201079603,
0.0206840485,
0.0605978444,
0.0133510968,
-0.0459870547,
-0.0084374808,
-0.0351540186,
-0.018093938,
0.0261139181,
0.0160757843,
0.0082399538,
0.0082775103,
0.010344618,
-0.0252779517,
-0.0369530097,
-0.0035571374,
0.0225402229,
-0.0279485695,
0.0444589704,
0.0340055637,
0.0239610784,
-0.0079949731,
0.0379771814,
0.0005711358,
0.02621652,
0.0580153428,
-0.0068148286,
-0.0528240204,
0.024801027,
-0.0331227109,
-0.0238711722,
0.0213872697,
0.0101422388,
0.0201753266,
-0.0123734772,
0.01207582,
-0.0379437283,
0.0329147279,
0.0643584579,
0.0399214476,
-0.0375527889,
-0.0266682114,
0.0067270771,
-0.0494922325,
0.0688092262,
0.0023987081,
-0.0374165699,
0.0700106025,
-0.0043032914,
0.0251549948,
-0.0330833793,
-0.0648525953,
0.0318372697,
-0.0337015688,
0.005678908,
-0.0416763946,
-0.0017060013,
0.0241787322,
0.0624936484,
0.0391599685,
-0.0449483767,
0.0377970152,
-0.0177027099,
0.0461304709,
-0.0732129216,
-0.0067196521,
-0.0612605512,
0.0456071086,
-0.0418535024,
0.0469271541,
0.0071219546,
-0.0084255189,
0.0204697289,
-0.0233089626,
0.0006888628,
-0.0117336595,
0.0384779461,
-0.0525665618,
-0.0056368392,
0.0287032165,
-0.0096270349,
-0.0494814739,
-0.0239243992,
0.0051724636,
-0.0057514617,
0.0874974206,
-0.0309846085,
0.0063273087,
-0.0218423642,
0.0037713526,
0.0242498089,
0.0094631221,
-0.0595035255,
-0.0001579112,
0.0282470118,
0.0282097142,
-0.0162656941,
0.0118332664,
0.038308464,
0.0496380925,
0.0335207433,
-0.04787663,
-0.0272758715,
-0.025726432,
0.0031456058,
0.0131651275,
-0.0275291968,
-0.0079401666,
0.0328379981,
-0.0057036425,
-0.0021610027,
-0.0302794036,
0.0691117421,
0.0615852587,
-0.0097233402,
0.0417950824,
-0.0065474706,
0.0094410665,
0.023771856,
0.0535684489,
-0.0398893021,
-0.0228376668,
-0.0465347841,
0.0409864001,
-0.048362162,
-0.0351393037,
-0.0520279743,
-0.1018749699,
0.0528071001,
-0.0087149413,
-0.0003102373,
-0.0352187753,
-0.0114147663,
-0.0341779776,
0.0187902004,
-0.0227321144,
0.007981291,
-0.0313300565,
0.0363951474,
0.0240616146,
-0.0361079834,
-0.0368558504,
-0.0195618775,
0.0113878073,
-0.0095117856,
0.0448884889,
0.0627465099,
0.0466986559,
0.0254335068,
-0.0778116286,
-0.0000582844,
0.0516163483,
-0.0316939466,
0.0271592941,
0.0062692878,
0.0006228284,
-0.0286497921,
0.0529537909,
-0.020163672,
-0.006656135,
0.0387190171,
0.0640951023,
-0.041301582,
0.002241072,
-0.0481941961,
0.029555792,
0.0321718007,
0.0204854216,
0.0055819256,
-0.0256763212,
0.0398164392,
-0.0120898532,
0.0135040144,
-0.0599351078,
-0.0455693565,
0.0339435227,
0.0106686149,
0.0347291231,
-0.0759132281,
-0.0457448885,
0.0188181642,
0.0512941442,
0.0274086408,
0.0397840925,
0.0097598787,
-0.000608028,
-0.0227984581,
-0.007815022,
0.0339437537,
-0.0069262674,
-0.0035466102,
-0.0581907146,
0.0350706279,
-0.0867952928,
0.0036661201,
0.0190064367,
-0.0154556995,
-0.0383661091,
-0.0138048651,
0.0251959059,
0.0205688607,
0.0189628769,
0.016713148,
-0.0442201011,
0.0663413405,
0.0778291002,
-0.0613961555,
-0.0393455662,
-0.006263115,
0.0573102683,
0.0167159401,
0.0422766805,
-0.0087808501,
0.0029822581,
-0.0539840795,
0.0358644798,
-0.024356693,
-0.0344728455,
0.0340615585,
0.0019263445,
-0.0460907482,
-0.0757152438,
0.0041165464,
-0.0412359312,
-0.0256554559,
-0.0437212922,
-0.0544001609,
-0.0346523188,
0.0229156483,
-0.0310130585,
-0.0352473222,
-0.021921223,
0.0109276567,
-0.0635811687,
0.0085588777,
-0.0475771464,
0.0180625897,
0.0180318709,
-0.0180566311,
0.0102244196,
0.0075792326,
0.0105464524,
0.0063173515,
-0.0297551379,
0.0371259041,
0.0010688438,
0.0525362045,
-0.011060454,
-0.0047345413,
-0.0564065129,
0.0451402403,
-0.0112165688,
-0.0411182866,
-0.0229855981,
0.0407600142,
0.0241835937,
0.0148704089,
0.0640713423,
-0.0271662176,
0.0102950782,
0.0510863811,
0.0715344921,
0.0063806344,
-0.072366178,
-0.0191733893,
-0.0204356741,
-0.0392506607,
-0.0211823434,
0.102196008,
-0.0524955504,
-0.0106570441,
-0.0092674643,
-0.0644933283,
-0.0633495077,
-0.0117213186,
0.0393278822,
0.0361940823,
-0.0117463917,
0.0272273496,
-0.0684969053,
-0.0117706424,
-0.0052355137,
-0.0166785438,
0.0337449461,
-0.0159882717,
0.0400402918,
0.062069349,
0.0147144813,
-0.0144201769,
-0.0597047359,
-0.0116387149,
-0.0873031318,
0.0053598024,
-0.0032611075,
-6.225611304e-33,
-0.0168636143,
-0.0832935125,
0.0264732894,
-0.0144586787,
0.0161695518,
-0.001176087,
-0.0431999974,
0.0041885194,
0.0328236595,
0.0143889431,
0.0044005206,
-0.029045485,
-0.0028618008,
0.0446877293,
0.0296431463,
-0.0038362783,
0.0311820302,
0.010005137,
-0.0292555392,
0.038103193,
0.1001440957,
-0.008427754,
0.0211757831,
0.0088353567,
0.0382226333,
0.0249325335,
-0.0552435294,
0.0357657634,
0.0149343936,
0.0259074625,
-0.0215642713,
0.0760583058,
0.0187650528,
-0.0436364934,
-0.0112588461,
0.0007476031,
-0.0028635301,
-0.0430818535,
0.013415915,
-0.0261631068,
-0.0279147569,
-0.0115927709,
0.0159491803,
-0.0078763505,
-0.029405864,
0.0270854663,
0.0438780785,
-0.0338472724,
-0.0193265937,
-0.09631221,
-0.0771448761,
0.0213785134,
-0.0337216444,
-0.0164134819,
-0.0023696206,
0.0514900647,
-0.0195894334,
-0.0152365025,
-0.0313031264,
0.0656876117,
0.0343355723,
0.0166242886,
0.0305817444,
-0.0254335944,
-0.0486092716,
0.0592452437,
-0.0003315069,
0.0105012329,
0.010834055,
0.0700618103,
-0.0304005537,
0.0448184684,
-0.0130156595,
0.0096733626,
-0.0188159402,
0.0139143616,
-0.0199471004,
0.0626329482,
0.0560570024,
-0.0580202416,
0.0406200923,
-0.0254554302,
-0.0479422174,
-0.0427455679,
0.0033282253,
-0.0180668961,
-0.0189739279,
-0.0343897603,
-0.0055955537,
0.0009080208,
-0.0415698029,
0.0151713127,
-0.026418874,
-0.0051908097,
0.0054958202,
0.0006958477,
-0.061159227,
-0.0004226972,
-0.02046551,
0.0012034252,
-0.0186979659,
-0.0127346301,
0.0259109922,
0.0085258856,
-0.0243399162,
-0.0008780832,
0.002521388,
0.0301962364,
0.0025007415,
0.0288601667,
-0.00278123,
0.0322567113,
-0.0493446775,
-0.0352184288,
-0.011741926,
0.0096332906,
-0.0518143699,
0.03274763,
-0.000866011,
0.0665832385,
0.002928515,
-0.002631309,
0.0097304443,
0.0431933254,
-0.0174608957,
-0.0044068461,
-0.0181030333,
-0.058981102,
0.0400636308,
-0.0269687977,
-0.0283696838,
0.0029685111,
2.867e-7,
0.0049843634,
0.0378731638,
-0.0302744899,
0.0058437721,
0.0154598402,
0.0696475878,
0.0666745305,
0.0353700705,
0.0147792771,
0.0326860547,
0.0389838181,
-0.0243549515,
-0.0123987161,
0.0816036835,
-0.0603898913,
-0.0271456838,
-0.0285767596,
-0.0108656911,
-0.068589136,
0.0008388332,
0.0506775528,
0.0120037505,
-0.012477736,
-0.0232084636,
0.0133831399,
0.0170623455,
-0.0074497033,
-0.0062597445,
0.0012656496,
0.03663297,
0.0336390771,
0.0055930158,
-0.0283477772,
0.0058801677,
-0.0458418429,
-0.0115348855,
-0.0267918464,
-0.0425751507,
-0.0084700398,
-0.0112461224,
0.0049287574,
-0.0174929965,
0.0103930384,
-0.0472840182,
0.0183578264,
-0.0539279915,
-0.0430682413,
-0.0207319576,
-0.0127989706,
-0.0170850977,
-0.0522179529,
-0.0308897458,
-0.0166020431,
0.0260154903,
-0.0183401629,
0.0100474982,
-0.0221606866,
-0.0275823139,
0.0034934392,
-0.0118617965,
-0.0167004745,
0.0022293879,
-0.0210283343,
0.0264350083,
-0.0152808102,
-0.0423585624,
0.0512305051,
2.425437213e-34,
0.0337956101,
0.0428519398,
0.0002315931,
-0.0277170241,
0.0660314858,
0.0092331143,
-0.0209828932,
-0.0184050798,
0.0663665608,
-0.01616312,
-0.0476861447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13173v1 | Opinion Mining Using Population-tuned Generative Language Models | 2023-07-24T23:42:32 | 2023-07-24T23:42:32 | Allmin Susaiyah, Abhinay Pandya, Aki Härmä | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present a novel method for mining opinions from text collections using
generative language models trained on data collected from different
populations. We describe the basic definitions, methodology and a generic
algorithm for opinion insight mining. We demonstrate the performance of our
method in an experiment where a pre-trained generative model is fine-tuned
using specifically tailored content with unnatural and fully annotated
opinions. We show that our approach can learn and transfer the opinions to the
semantic classes while maintaining the proportion of polarisation. Finally, we
demonstrate the usage of an insight mining system to scale up the discovery of
opinion insights from a real text corpus. | [
0.0258379336,
0.0835883096,
0.0166724492,
0.0266294256,
-0.0075268336,
0.0113412607,
-0.0047426065,
-0.0388996676,
-0.0190604106,
-0.032623183,
-0.0196900442,
0.0106419064,
-0.0280853361,
0.0543537103,
-0.0390417539,
-0.0051793335,
0.0297167841,
0.0463846326,
0.0488426499,
0.0037089873,
0.0407741144,
0.0292045567,
-0.0166510642,
0.0290235747,
-0.0007321048,
-0.0105598848,
0.0356429778,
-0.0097707296,
0.0625147074,
-0.0033522523,
0.0100527732,
0.017371159,
-0.0473777615,
-0.0115432404,
0.0000019143,
0.0053429115,
-0.0210367125,
-0.0114833377,
0.066068247,
-0.0002274908,
0.080990918,
0.0234545339,
-0.0222234949,
0.0665761754,
-0.0841504782,
-0.0175152756,
-0.0208949354,
0.0475832261,
0.0773604959,
0.0431051403,
-0.0196386054,
0.00578458,
-0.0543298796,
0.0058704508,
-0.0028298446,
-0.0279222727,
0.0195528381,
0.0051727989,
-0.0619099028,
0.0321100429,
0.0009045662,
-0.0135834748,
-0.0255723689,
-0.0356081948,
0.0023123915,
0.0293076318,
0.0006929055,
-0.0010283561,
0.0084831594,
0.0381287709,
-0.0098400144,
-0.0348463766,
0.0036638996,
-0.0291398857,
-0.0020296157,
-0.0095652984,
0.0070310934,
0.0207949243,
-0.0123055996,
0.0969134346,
0.0363046601,
0.0401404165,
0.0166823752,
-0.0111802109,
-0.0070124283,
0.0621979982,
-0.0144102648,
-0.0072079515,
0.0132471733,
0.0499448143,
-0.0415717661,
0.0024136382,
0.0218318589,
-0.0292004179,
0.049350936,
0.0282508973,
0.0094151599,
-0.0010869377,
0.0192382857,
-0.0698498115,
0.0155990981,
-0.0255608913,
-0.0060776677,
0.0553052537,
0.0126301274,
-0.0597531535,
0.0105643226,
-0.0169439558,
-0.0127516631,
-0.0035421143,
-0.0466275886,
0.0117946975,
0.0240381025,
0.0048322906,
-0.0200527273,
0.0153014194,
-0.0274840593,
-0.0048133456,
-0.0222141594,
-0.0103857443,
0.0254660528,
0.0458247997,
0.044263348,
-0.0093314741,
-0.0754435062,
0.0209975224,
-0.0321665443,
0.0253446568,
-0.0155018726,
-0.015183798,
0.040496964,
0.0096712746,
0.0208724197,
0.040560931,
-0.007197429,
-0.0142268958,
0.0262730904,
-0.0158140901,
-0.0639702082,
0.0173472352,
-0.0080073429,
-0.0107982829,
0.010886386,
-0.0482675396,
0.0321822539,
0.0089698751,
-0.0147215854,
-0.0148841487,
0.0228468087,
0.0256981421,
-0.0071481755,
0.0457905233,
-0.0398648828,
-0.0258401465,
0.0280056819,
0.0030418339,
0.0639722869,
0.0493694693,
0.0090596834,
0.0225509349,
0.0264017191,
0.0074435831,
0.0483658463,
-0.0305250548,
0.0075743794,
-0.0240074899,
0.0229510795,
-0.014445737,
-0.0622368343,
-0.0661926791,
0.0066065919,
0.0799023509,
0.0200203266,
-0.0029010614,
0.0266232956,
-0.003497229,
-0.0603907034,
0.0686929524,
-0.0109862266,
0.0204307884,
-0.0289478786,
-0.0237536095,
0.0214394704,
0.037263602,
-0.0224848203,
-0.0250205696,
0.0438076779,
0.0379579663,
-0.0075913407,
-0.0880332142,
-0.0248099603,
0.0201207846,
0.0245472379,
-0.0001713941,
0.0296256021,
-0.0089245867,
-0.0282527916,
-0.0032593168,
0.0704242438,
-0.0971865505,
-0.0199018177,
-0.0266078562,
0.0506989397,
0.0559612364,
0.017645482,
0.0092854584,
-0.0029920342,
-0.0329140499,
-0.047521431,
0.012491961,
0.0307756588,
-0.0114369942,
-0.0482521281,
-0.0213878881,
-0.0113821039,
0.0245916415,
0.023937691,
-0.0032952386,
-0.0284980908,
0.0244675875,
0.0056641297,
-0.0198030323,
-0.0222130958,
0.0101990439,
-0.0020982148,
0.0155241322,
0.0438743569,
0.0101838605,
0.0051445886,
0.0606416687,
-0.0275792908,
0.0013367285,
0.0608434007,
-0.0305976681,
-0.0642781183,
0.044480022,
-0.0002358172,
-0.0439137891,
-0.0056209117,
-0.0855855346,
0.0043011107,
-0.0312916674,
-0.0057203998,
-0.0130013702,
0.014527997,
-0.0233119484,
0.0488026179,
-0.0597425997,
-0.0197015237,
-0.009021299,
-0.0261567906,
-0.0353201255,
0.0735015348,
-0.0455974415,
-0.0040286276,
-0.0470370613,
-0.05834179,
0.0369453691,
0.0205457211,
-0.0348495841,
-0.0254957397,
0.0507683232,
-0.0018458774,
0.0453651585,
-0.0212672781,
0.0040566297,
-0.0329597108,
-0.0618365109,
0.0021867016,
0.0022657129,
0.0236459263,
0.0321887881,
-0.0273787882,
0.0067124972,
0.0375838168,
-0.0493095852,
-0.0097799795,
0.0038411221,
-0.0224902704,
0.0425237492,
0.0022337963,
0.0431823395,
-0.0520780124,
-0.0068215481,
-0.013153364,
-0.0089496998,
0.0245620534,
0.0110923313,
-0.0223985519,
0.0510966145,
-0.0274193715,
0.0270688944,
-0.0371624455,
-0.0491173379,
0.0048868372,
-0.0226967074,
0.0313008614,
0.0336393863,
0.0455267727,
0.0173059069,
0.0674389154,
0.0359700471,
-0.0171428286,
0.0019397719,
-0.0642573014,
0.065912351,
0.0117839929,
-0.0232190844,
0.0477720089,
0.0469681174,
0.0470282286,
-0.0418457165,
-0.0657970831,
0.0257193316,
-0.0148666166,
-0.0085853301,
0.0092163356,
0.0388615914,
0.0271163564,
0.019846512,
-0.0160459373,
-0.0266889147,
0.0306306239,
0.0137482276,
0.0336963683,
-0.0520008393,
-0.0108007155,
-0.0294398684,
-0.0268925708,
0.007177569,
0.003529876,
-0.0106144557,
0.0714570209,
0.0379645489,
-0.0214636065,
0.003426926,
-0.0236236025,
0.0052207541,
-0.0140024545,
0.0084987814,
0.0314549319,
-0.0422698595,
-0.0208367947,
-0.0219762921,
-0.0096089114,
-0.0231243074,
0.1098896489,
-0.0199944992,
0.0055832006,
-0.0323395692,
-0.0185323004,
-0.0322933942,
0.0263939481,
-0.0352286845,
0.034608189,
0.0225542933,
0.0546525344,
-0.0580535755,
0.0546923876,
0.0049546971,
-0.0245040208,
0.0736917406,
-0.0510399304,
0.0173255522,
-0.030920038,
-0.060104616,
-0.0129793501,
0.0067249611,
0.0008615748,
-0.0499892943,
0.0174602643,
-0.0124607552,
0.0146338353,
0.0907177329,
0.0655757487,
-0.0590354726,
-0.026031211,
0.015597037,
-0.0368664861,
0.032696411,
-0.0073953681,
-0.0544719771,
-0.0012655654,
-0.0408886634,
0.013760535,
-0.0217156168,
-0.0053396802,
0.0044174613,
-0.1112863421,
0.007830645,
-0.0130117433,
0.0344622321,
-0.0497341566,
-0.0287400223,
0.0097512174,
-0.0327235349,
-0.0460762531,
-0.0228889417,
0.0289926939,
0.0744603127,
0.0169273149,
-0.0653501898,
-0.0093481792,
0.0260171816,
-0.0160833783,
0.0399610102,
0.0794485137,
0.0735737085,
0.0097634513,
-0.052997157,
0.0119452626,
-0.01706204,
-0.0138214966,
-0.016046321,
0.0712577924,
-0.0383258723,
-0.0315964036,
-0.0383017808,
0.0343689509,
-0.0219181962,
0.0234510843,
0.007405662,
0.0274011418,
-0.0188872777,
-0.0513602123,
-0.0246222671,
0.0341880992,
0.0255210698,
0.09107925,
0.0092078028,
-0.0511445515,
0.0159322619,
-0.0453937426,
0.0055312198,
-0.1080503762,
-0.033953771,
0.0033313662,
0.0697702095,
-0.0120644365,
-0.0739481896,
-0.0132867964,
-0.0008552679,
0.0030838079,
-0.0069156648,
-0.0205197874,
0.0283513181,
0.0266599264,
-0.0134844501,
-0.0078545455,
0.0416553803,
-0.0331767574,
-0.0323301144,
-0.0821428001,
0.0700061023,
-0.0400647484,
-0.0453592762,
0.0075800279,
-0.0389035158,
-0.0433971211,
0.0163347423,
0.0536250435,
-0.0056892205,
-0.0235361978,
-0.0109062074,
-0.0036740142,
0.0404360108,
0.0775068998,
-0.0438523069,
-0.0191863589,
0.0207146276,
0.0952636451,
0.0486393273,
0.0226016138,
0.0156535245,
0.0483772159,
0.0392198749,
-0.0091574294,
-0.0740128905,
-0.0186371133,
0.001709938,
-0.0321876667,
0.0585550331,
0.0054637888,
-0.0049309679,
-0.0598898791,
-0.0340161324,
-0.0258078575,
-0.0379056297,
-0.0570719354,
-0.0355866775,
-0.0002537617,
-0.0322875194,
-0.0857704505,
0.0375058204,
-0.0234053973,
0.0289592668,
-0.018980559,
0.0709330738,
0.0631841868,
0.0081150867,
-0.0073202914,
-0.0004904299,
0.0069165919,
0.0007683788,
-0.0359632336,
-0.012562695,
0.0243695099,
0.0161870141,
-0.0063367733,
-0.0158909131,
-0.0005835334,
-0.0043051578,
-0.0091591757,
0.0261721555,
-0.0363192409,
0.0714676157,
0.0137655772,
0.0093992576,
0.0393773764,
-0.0114522902,
-0.0297829974,
-0.0028791209,
0.041982051,
0.0137874903,
-0.0329419598,
0.0113909356,
-0.0151433274,
-0.0428824127,
-0.0719738379,
0.0366181023,
-0.0465706252,
0.0209200606,
0.039747104,
-0.037594609,
-0.0389070734,
0.0422396772,
0.0110895298,
-0.0116829183,
0.0211054571,
0.065770641,
-0.0409771018,
-0.0443685725,
-0.0166471377,
0.0377138257,
0.054791417,
0.0198186431,
0.0065189674,
0.0356796719,
-0.0243593976,
0.0342310034,
-0.0885214806,
-0.001016521,
-0.0661758557,
0.0146291927,
-0.0186929479,
-6.69891088e-33,
-0.0162918288,
-0.0336966701,
-0.0409781933,
0.0333017409,
0.0412380658,
-0.0451327935,
-0.0556046553,
0.0396775752,
-0.0059559136,
0.0688291714,
0.0090111988,
0.0311881136,
-0.0144999158,
0.0504012443,
-0.0022549799,
0.0236263312,
0.0430659465,
-0.0130322156,
-0.0012215024,
0.0357849076,
0.0863931477,
0.0037637693,
0.0542532243,
-0.0825471357,
0.0109714558,
-0.0217165742,
-0.039008867,
0.0037161687,
-0.0052722101,
0.0156507082,
-0.0063439496,
0.0672086328,
0.0123267677,
-0.0499152988,
0.0108281989,
0.0177971032,
-0.0596961677,
-0.0236929134,
-0.0193297379,
-0.0214064866,
-0.0241102483,
-0.0105595356,
-0.0089732762,
0.0198358577,
-0.0234577935,
-0.0020035892,
0.0458828285,
-0.009828547,
0.0258709472,
-0.1044916138,
-0.015591911,
0.0151474793,
-0.0232028086,
0.0062884754,
0.0015869782,
-0.0368174016,
-0.0265759192,
0.0128164692,
-0.0372217409,
0.0402577296,
0.0233286396,
0.0147930263,
-0.0273771025,
-0.0216620527,
0.0079219341,
0.0885815248,
-0.0012040649,
0.0146376509,
-0.0514031798,
0.0472115017,
0.0047824862,
-0.0013212133,
0.0052255052,
0.0410028547,
0.0040165321,
-0.045951277,
-0.0329856277,
0.036672242,
0.0545308888,
-0.0468361042,
0.0656549409,
0.0020671259,
-0.0326074511,
0.0017182278,
0.0217807982,
-0.0967109054,
-0.0136035318,
0.0015836814,
-0.0112379761,
0.0078427102,
-0.0589474998,
-0.0209882017,
-0.0219939761,
-0.0443784334,
0.0057853004,
0.0492681377,
-0.0493815057,
-0.0074092508,
-0.0175481979,
-0.0220730342,
-0.0575830713,
0.0367129073,
-0.011871214,
0.0148690762,
-0.0223372038,
-0.0298310723,
0.027201511,
-0.0179138631,
-0.072550483,
0.0020324923,
-0.0185405128,
0.0636947826,
0.002518374,
0.0437146872,
-0.0146681527,
0.0317731127,
-0.0201233625,
-0.0028388342,
-0.0197278392,
0.0837750658,
0.0105043733,
0.0064739501,
-0.0227646977,
0.0007497016,
-0.0238900296,
-0.0276861563,
0.0058815419,
-0.0261302684,
-0.0064073526,
-0.0396954678,
-0.006598115,
0.0088664545,
2.563e-7,
0.0780975968,
0.039674852,
-0.0174071994,
-0.0082396949,
0.0092747519,
0.0398718938,
0.0179879777,
0.0099458313,
0.035426531,
-0.03436739,
-0.0039962381,
0.063083142,
-0.0157420877,
0.0563565567,
-0.0818448961,
0.0136031993,
0.0152903851,
-0.0245916005,
0.0047799116,
-0.0134827001,
0.0438737422,
0.0644198284,
0.0293918401,
-0.0001977522,
0.0118203601,
0.0465033054,
0.0483402461,
-0.0214826353,
-0.0166266449,
0.0314514674,
0.0045145759,
-0.0162712783,
-0.0328959562,
-0.0366353914,
-0.0362936966,
-0.0017739513,
-0.0030673144,
0.0343515165,
0.0370291919,
-0.0662532821,
0.0245329197,
0.0333931446,
0.0083353864,
-0.0135201439,
0.0713983923,
-0.0508176684,
-0.0204453245,
-0.091624476,
-0.0015765049,
0.0260565802,
0.0051595736,
-0.0017301128,
-0.0112215932,
-0.0124596749,
-0.0087037627,
-0.0193871073,
-0.0332861468,
-0.0762899891,
-0.0064576734,
0.0157346632,
-0.0360392779,
-0.031039713,
0.0341380499,
0.0430704057,
-0.018979948,
-0.0137159796,
0.052115459,
2.066142314e-34,
0.053102769,
-0.0027481657,
-0.0232594199,
-0.0329198577,
0.0527342968,
0.0162075069,
-0.0470346622,
-0.038764067,
0.0413328409,
-0.049994763,
0.0044852956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15715v1 | Improving Primary Healthcare Workflow Using Extreme Summarization of Scientific Literature Based on Generative AI | 2023-07-24T21:42:27 | 2023-07-24T21:42:27 | Gregor Stiglic, Leon Kopitar, Lucija Gosak, Primoz Kocbek, Zhe He, Prithwish Chakraborty, Pablo Meyer, Jiang Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Primary care professionals struggle to keep up to date with the latest
scientific literature critical in guiding evidence-based practice related to
their daily work. To help solve the above-mentioned problem, we employed
generative artificial intelligence techniques based on large-scale language
models to summarize abstracts of scientific papers. Our objective is to
investigate the potential of generative artificial intelligence in diminishing
the cognitive load experienced by practitioners, thus exploring its ability to
alleviate mental effort and burden. The study participants were provided with
two use cases related to preventive care and behavior change, simulating a
search for new scientific literature. The study included 113 university
students from Slovenia and the United States randomized into three distinct
study groups. The first group was assigned to the full abstracts. The second
group was assigned to the short abstracts generated by AI. The third group had
the option to select a full abstract in addition to the AI-generated short
summary. Each use case study included ten retrieved abstracts. Our research
demonstrates that the use of generative AI for literature review is efficient
and effective. The time needed to answer questions related to the content of
abstracts was significantly lower in groups two and three compared to the first
group using full abstracts. The results, however, also show significantly lower
accuracy in extracted knowledge in cases where full abstract was not available.
Such a disruptive technology could significantly reduce the time required for
healthcare professionals to keep up with the most recent scientific literature;
nevertheless, further developments are needed to help them comprehend the
knowledge accurately. | [
0.079507865,
0.0181400068,
-0.0189874861,
-0.0608989932,
-0.0256444179,
0.0104730148,
0.0109947501,
0.0195274483,
-0.0043091034,
-0.0031487423,
0.0371399634,
-0.0102368435,
0.006489357,
0.0416120999,
0.0111762853,
-0.0703564659,
-0.0004582184,
0.0353951827,
0.0891005397,
-0.0052765119,
-0.0089165922,
-0.000221296,
-0.0171928182,
0.0481481962,
0.0550415777,
-0.009007345,
0.0129208481,
-0.0230325609,
0.0346330889,
-0.0711976662,
0.0066617928,
0.0157684237,
-0.0171431433,
0.0059165782,
0.0000019874,
-0.0608967543,
0.0055207661,
0.0558690466,
-0.0249893256,
-0.0259241294,
0.076384142,
-0.0389297605,
-0.0002688339,
0.0276845787,
-0.0427874513,
-0.012186042,
0.0174997244,
0.0326552391,
0.0067016231,
0.0307318419,
-0.0197535139,
-0.0249767508,
0.0400302336,
-0.0133979376,
0.0144754322,
-0.0251430068,
0.0335022658,
0.0297740251,
0.063948676,
0.0125552649,
0.0245781466,
0.0525136441,
-0.0270743147,
-0.0248166919,
0.0277653169,
0.0682687014,
-0.0175479278,
-0.0157757271,
0.0208438039,
0.0320672058,
0.0124460589,
-0.0122685665,
0.0487109907,
-0.0147474669,
0.008063443,
0.038503509,
-0.0850913748,
0.0554255806,
-0.0325586684,
-0.0181858726,
0.0333575346,
0.0248359907,
-0.004016906,
-0.0003013538,
-0.0015502934,
-0.0290510505,
0.0029441698,
-0.0432724692,
0.0319801867,
-0.0063171922,
0.0235943161,
-0.0570547916,
0.0059953379,
0.0643460453,
-0.0199049227,
-0.0062642721,
0.0230681989,
-0.1087396815,
0.080217205,
-0.0289021451,
0.0016287704,
0.0065358733,
0.0359968767,
0.027059719,
0.0108065838,
-0.0477573648,
-0.010622181,
0.0057677436,
-0.0373983048,
0.0282408651,
-0.0624035895,
-0.0437053517,
-0.0294899009,
0.0431212634,
-0.0314799137,
-0.0209431481,
-0.0415269881,
-0.0231296439,
-0.0068864496,
0.0020718286,
0.0124891903,
0.0515037216,
-0.0552490428,
0.0069535105,
-0.020624103,
0.0146394642,
-0.0283558443,
0.0274051931,
-0.0136311259,
0.0134172207,
0.0239280742,
0.0112567414,
0.0326063484,
0.041618932,
0.0138503639,
-0.0011826555,
-0.0163273923,
-0.0223703478,
-0.0028819593,
-0.041288808,
-0.0041486816,
-0.0372342765,
0.0233810898,
-0.0566628575,
0.0490865372,
0.020365702,
-0.0320341885,
-0.028766511,
-0.001563946,
0.0277817156,
-0.0374278948,
0.0142748952,
-0.0744029284,
0.0336585082,
0.069759585,
0.0132101253,
0.0304079633,
0.0036519663,
0.0212002043,
-0.0010796842,
-0.0104224822,
-0.0140140001,
0.0460925177,
-0.0267259181,
0.0118500004,
-0.0259410795,
0.0651417002,
0.0010599835,
-0.0486804806,
0.0468401499,
-0.0179679804,
0.0854357332,
-0.026455747,
0.0701207668,
0.0198716149,
0.0755989924,
0.0006343436,
0.060643252,
0.0314102396,
0.0001900268,
0.0382956229,
-0.0038537229,
0.034770254,
0.0272890422,
0.0053303814,
0.0329599194,
0.0012927718,
0.0048898691,
-0.0251650847,
-0.0553893894,
-0.0114793973,
0.0143123539,
-0.0092100929,
-0.0120337848,
0.0465689674,
0.0098923389,
-0.0161498953,
-0.0126672536,
0.0181535445,
-0.0129408361,
-0.0055580661,
-0.0468048081,
0.0027455923,
0.0787932202,
0.0759105235,
-0.0318941101,
-0.0042213062,
-0.0257993508,
-0.0060983258,
0.0460013896,
0.0341576375,
-0.023177268,
-0.0672816932,
-0.0342699066,
-0.0268034823,
-0.003626907,
-0.0106032062,
-0.0072298087,
-0.0071039922,
0.0282247663,
-0.0033561396,
0.0015931575,
-0.0962873697,
0.0187893789,
-0.0947067738,
-0.0295059122,
-0.0049184477,
-0.0250218865,
0.0324858092,
0.0371836387,
-0.0018481711,
0.0565313958,
0.0385423936,
-0.0413901918,
-0.0556640513,
0.0288820919,
-0.0034828356,
0.0391202234,
-0.0088088335,
-0.0813916922,
0.0311278384,
-0.0274998508,
-0.0036330689,
-0.0360767469,
-0.0159868058,
-0.0554385521,
0.0248036534,
0.0170472134,
0.009934295,
0.0212774556,
-0.0067988988,
-0.0301455725,
0.0587488525,
-0.0138984406,
-0.0151043655,
0.035208419,
-0.0434764177,
0.0073704249,
-0.0158049483,
0.0145013249,
0.0110803442,
0.0085498793,
0.0038431617,
0.0372740291,
-0.0050607915,
0.0012649251,
-0.011723089,
-0.0975003913,
-0.0441201031,
0.0244172737,
0.000070553,
0.0401839316,
-0.0078176977,
-0.0026242405,
0.0107437111,
-0.025962837,
0.0073168003,
0.0234830249,
-0.000793091,
0.033103846,
0.057988774,
0.0429907441,
-0.0599838346,
-0.0166629292,
-0.0447383039,
0.0270950124,
0.0871623009,
-0.0116301719,
-0.0397393629,
-0.002359869,
0.0096959211,
-0.0036020724,
0.0026783876,
0.0097347517,
0.0094421413,
-0.0181338303,
0.0674493238,
0.0340072997,
0.0203810893,
-0.0130435843,
0.0675333738,
0.0150919305,
-0.0249348097,
0.024379313,
-0.0403427891,
0.0028055916,
0.0236666296,
-0.0679786727,
0.0377321914,
0.0091155954,
0.0384455547,
0.0152362501,
0.0030723393,
0.024939714,
-0.0258186385,
-0.0183693953,
-0.0338177755,
-0.0368719436,
-0.0272519942,
0.0414543003,
0.011496759,
0.0029289578,
0.0420046188,
0.028257316,
0.0395664498,
-0.1118726358,
0.0030222095,
-0.0198902506,
0.0162535757,
-0.0018358664,
0.0215726923,
0.0206198189,
0.0021171866,
-0.0345891416,
-0.0115414821,
-0.0016890069,
-0.0171593167,
0.0398889706,
-0.0351350643,
0.0266781468,
-0.0098607093,
-0.01213622,
-0.0323725566,
-0.0151327886,
-0.0041599064,
0.0143729821,
0.0834015161,
-0.0104571721,
-0.0719244331,
0.018026147,
0.0787865371,
0.090355441,
-0.0045806421,
-0.045664724,
0.0015989903,
-0.006864957,
0.0745023265,
-0.0365205891,
0.0022709549,
-0.003767339,
0.0224163085,
0.0565017015,
0.0149905756,
0.0058392161,
-0.018264642,
-0.0654960796,
-0.024880752,
-0.0832078233,
-0.0074015902,
0.0048076999,
-0.0136436466,
-0.0231039263,
0.0068930308,
0.0723353475,
0.036991626,
-0.0809238628,
0.012099633,
-0.0476350337,
-0.0648033023,
-0.0049819211,
0.0519611537,
-0.0398589857,
0.021601731,
-0.0252543446,
0.0622851625,
-0.044593703,
-0.0335352346,
0.0185777117,
-0.0509556793,
0.0325786434,
-0.0182567742,
-0.0296568032,
-0.0211711563,
0.0023015221,
-0.0043460196,
0.0162187386,
-0.0386434011,
0.0111259259,
-0.0420144051,
0.0026091959,
0.0188257899,
-0.0749531016,
-0.0375167727,
0.0037671006,
0.0098259598,
0.0191636719,
0.058987353,
0.0403347984,
-0.02856558,
-0.0199145395,
-0.0227869656,
-0.0247378778,
0.0264793448,
-0.0051533082,
0.0816478431,
0.0357445776,
0.0472973771,
-0.0276526753,
0.0489078872,
-0.0063589439,
-0.0211572181,
0.0662786961,
0.060540203,
-0.0297508333,
-0.0527737737,
-0.0769187361,
0.0230877455,
0.0193539448,
0.0331026129,
0.0119437193,
0.0014084796,
-0.009322118,
0.0145765347,
0.0401100144,
-0.0042939722,
-0.0137895662,
-0.0272259451,
-0.0337442346,
-0.0052863853,
-0.0808334574,
-0.0394720398,
0.0473231375,
0.0144890714,
0.0387659147,
0.0017711446,
0.0506237634,
-0.001151192,
-0.0398444161,
-0.0221769549,
0.0182715803,
-0.0193926133,
-0.0098414719,
-0.0845211968,
0.0663443357,
0.0110457744,
-0.0024795132,
0.0164830536,
0.0217570476,
-0.0028508722,
-0.014034206,
0.0542011857,
0.0289973393,
-0.0120205404,
0.0011946236,
-0.0041591884,
0.0285523664,
0.0313139595,
0.0075675915,
-0.0121329492,
-0.0544222854,
0.0102752578,
-0.0007866042,
-0.0529884361,
-0.0523112155,
0.0340040363,
-0.0219891816,
0.0242471863,
-0.0398061946,
-0.007567747,
0.0194409471,
0.0582566038,
-0.0370803326,
-0.0485035554,
0.012363934,
-0.0384055339,
-0.0014380211,
-0.0426430181,
0.0088901371,
-0.0067658843,
0.0006084822,
0.0013692027,
0.0182722379,
0.0168700833,
0.0720280036,
-0.064688541,
-0.0445307046,
-0.0552980937,
0.0130162025,
-0.0302792136,
0.0508835688,
0.0164878443,
-0.0344552323,
-0.0333844982,
-0.0315252542,
-0.0261041373,
0.0246876832,
0.0097093303,
0.0390976779,
0.0042318534,
-0.0157853514,
-0.0257255137,
0.032089144,
-0.0787694603,
-0.0672494695,
-0.0244417153,
0.0338365845,
0.0060482086,
0.0098835658,
0.0159697253,
-0.0545726307,
-0.0028977229,
-0.0336006172,
0.0156539418,
0.0116284434,
0.0207607672,
-0.0089994203,
0.017624421,
0.0039817826,
-0.0604783259,
0.0927610844,
-0.0233543105,
0.0142748328,
-0.0212200843,
-0.0493475385,
-0.0435608551,
-0.04549307,
-0.0401454866,
0.0234994739,
-0.0270240884,
-0.0244028848,
-0.0686278865,
-0.0147139784,
-0.0040542767,
0.0105798533,
0.016260555,
-0.0392279252,
0.0357394964,
0.0246087294,
0.0097663403,
-0.0541906096,
-0.0377734862,
0.091444388,
-0.0524731092,
-0.0068909219,
-0.0379168727,
-5.582087289e-33,
0.0212122928,
-0.0486368723,
0.0333330818,
0.0025294037,
0.0109299766,
0.0049526179,
-0.0760724247,
-0.0245848075,
0.0281666182,
0.0371373519,
-0.0321024954,
-0.0029135575,
-0.0033136297,
0.0053498754,
0.0551534295,
0.0339502431,
0.0516091436,
-0.0184926074,
0.0063707321,
0.0523828603,
-0.0046700174,
0.0031303421,
-0.0112682516,
-0.0497010313,
0.0125503363,
-0.0189988408,
0.0231054518,
-0.0377507694,
0.0101639917,
0.0315576605,
-0.0139371306,
0.0022133919,
0.035914477,
-0.0059845657,
-0.0206564683,
0.0167750474,
-0.0700575039,
-0.021290116,
0.0297579449,
-0.0670421347,
-0.0570126697,
-0.0466144085,
0.0693839565,
-0.0061242655,
-0.0341348648,
0.0145129487,
0.0647690669,
-0.0472201258,
-0.0406335406,
-0.1108638197,
-0.0898944736,
0.0135731688,
-0.0058322842,
0.0305849742,
-0.0548833609,
0.0273902304,
-0.0321194343,
0.0110297743,
-0.0303445421,
0.0022519208,
0.0656620041,
-0.0009609023,
0.0147264535,
-0.0446905904,
0.0224022362,
0.0045442437,
-0.0291029066,
0.0187924225,
-0.0322296619,
0.0082931165,
-0.031618949,
-0.0099649932,
0.0375531614,
0.0211360436,
0.0549624227,
-0.0254223924,
-0.0690494478,
0.0901948735,
-0.055603683,
0.0563124306,
0.0550866574,
-0.037131086,
-0.0277291629,
-0.0192820672,
0.0115991151,
0.0206961073,
0.0094143897,
-0.0218963083,
0.0000290543,
0.0105675794,
-0.0096853664,
-0.0205070321,
-0.0339344218,
-0.0172810294,
0.0415002145,
0.0051925979,
0.0172815938,
0.0218924768,
-0.0178444814,
-0.0328731239,
-0.0849510506,
0.0058131907,
-0.0042778691,
0.0628514588,
0.0353077613,
0.0344800465,
0.0290591139,
-0.0318628661,
-0.0235631783,
-0.0178157724,
0.0181414485,
0.0461687855,
0.0022981456,
-0.0243753716,
0.0124598723,
0.0271065328,
0.0246017817,
0.0070365369,
0.007414009,
-0.0050169295,
-0.0295990873,
-0.0079078656,
0.0273667723,
-0.0096503831,
-0.0340318717,
0.0312203933,
-0.0279594176,
0.0535608977,
0.0422976427,
-0.0368834324,
0.00566854,
0.0044635073,
2.796e-7,
0.0780795962,
0.0560563542,
0.0074938782,
-0.0179830864,
0.0482436903,
-0.0264068376,
0.0196313243,
-0.0316482559,
-0.0035680449,
0.0397299118,
0.0685501024,
0.0228627138,
-0.0147442417,
0.0411925651,
-0.0792056248,
-0.0332297608,
-0.0628691465,
-0.0248415899,
-0.0561756194,
-0.001498101,
0.0510837249,
-0.0219619069,
-0.0455488674,
-0.0063980129,
-0.0158775896,
0.0052896263,
0.0233682655,
0.0186676811,
0.0295790136,
0.0312089659,
0.0584861673,
0.0303099416,
0.0137199564,
0.0131718237,
-0.0215335488,
-0.0281217117,
-0.0152572384,
0.0411548093,
-0.0297069941,
0.0468029156,
0.065839313,
-0.0192945022,
0.0516018756,
-0.0103840865,
0.0168907419,
-0.1019663587,
-0.0358457118,
-0.0133579662,
-0.0470063798,
0.0023047642,
0.0106786238,
-0.0153687848,
-0.0143082887,
0.038852714,
-0.027940819,
0.0040629231,
0.0114322593,
-0.0442910306,
0.0402776711,
0.0487720929,
-0.0037698324,
-0.0500100143,
0.0125115393,
-0.0573522002,
-0.0259718467,
-0.046449136,
0.0251305643,
2.239368396e-34,
0.0466005579,
0.0217818525,
-0.0202500559,
-0.0055869524,
0.0049264296,
0.0054626283,
-0.0209422614,
0.032284189,
0.0175117236,
-0.0524598733,
-0.0365393236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13128v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13128v1 | Explaining Math Word Problem Solvers | 2023-07-24T21:05:47 | 2023-07-24T21:05:47 | Abby Newcomb, Jugal Kalita | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated math word problem solvers based on neural networks have
successfully managed to obtain 70-80\% accuracy in solving arithmetic word
problems. However, it has been shown that these solvers may rely on superficial
patterns to obtain their equations. In order to determine what information math
word problem solvers use to generate solutions, we remove parts of the input
and measure the model's performance on the perturbed dataset. Our results show
that the model is not sensitive to the removal of many words from the input and
can still manage to find a correct answer when given a nonsense question. This
indicates that automatic solvers do not follow the semantic logic of math word
problems, and may be overfitting to the presence of specific words. | [
-0.0152569422,
0.0775797889,
-0.0051449398,
0.0236498658,
-0.0659663752,
0.0000482564,
0.0375890955,
0.0020099655,
-0.0863015652,
-0.0093517397,
0.0326273367,
0.0191237926,
0.0464750193,
0.0323407985,
0.0283875745,
0.0069679571,
0.0062046763,
-0.0150656011,
0.0258074999,
0.0016383654,
-0.040676903,
-0.0229906403,
-0.05116136,
0.0061235405,
-0.0807797238,
-0.0252138134,
0.0027853779,
-0.0932800174,
-0.0111819366,
0.0160583276,
0.0110219168,
0.0101484098,
-0.0162379816,
0.0659189895,
0.0000019653,
-0.0445210189,
0.012891707,
0.0272672083,
-0.0607165992,
0.0071833716,
-0.0134544764,
0.0095140534,
0.0108755836,
0.0121221524,
-0.0709950551,
0.024343444,
0.0221974868,
0.0369400233,
0.0568519756,
0.0367284901,
-0.0090786461,
-0.0236207936,
0.0374048874,
-0.0070936936,
0.0605867319,
-0.0589395054,
0.0208010599,
0.0253729448,
0.0102755865,
-0.0699651018,
-0.0607866794,
0.0569030121,
0.058670707,
0.0131098703,
0.0006874974,
-0.0205868743,
-0.0525309853,
-0.0052788402,
-0.0175391417,
0.0481322668,
-0.0551392175,
0.0207945611,
-0.0111633958,
-0.0360353552,
-0.0205940288,
0.0560874119,
-0.0306356661,
0.0022955984,
-0.0274780858,
-0.0232741348,
-0.030493049,
-0.0076530362,
0.0267190859,
0.0363436341,
-0.027370302,
0.0964715928,
-0.0302180573,
-0.057261683,
-0.0027235553,
-0.0094901128,
-0.0510287508,
-0.0426790938,
0.0710101798,
0.072855033,
0.0197627004,
0.0493843406,
-0.0370429903,
-0.055354204,
-0.0331510901,
-0.0849817917,
0.0363369249,
0.0865653232,
0.0342532098,
0.0236110743,
-0.0417157859,
0.0958934799,
-0.0183394197,
0.0169761498,
-0.0158880409,
0.0433185883,
-0.0229157675,
-0.0278032981,
-0.0275405906,
0.063550204,
0.0086035002,
-0.0209650472,
-0.0446746461,
-0.0052182991,
-0.0110797053,
0.0155735416,
-0.0033417479,
0.0162670184,
0.0189680476,
-0.0294107404,
-0.084276028,
-0.0156016108,
-0.0513817631,
0.019927809,
-0.019920228,
-0.0059238053,
0.0291110706,
-0.0251117591,
0.0092077116,
-0.0211900324,
0.0567928031,
0.0916211009,
0.0008062725,
0.0117097897,
-0.0296230055,
-0.0389393382,
0.0270515382,
-0.0545593873,
-0.0021819575,
-0.0327703133,
0.0694501474,
0.0273836385,
-0.0625542998,
-0.0440210439,
0.0046637496,
0.0262969546,
-0.012015867,
0.081618093,
0.0089127813,
-0.0020404502,
0.0878239051,
-0.0202917401,
-0.0166970249,
0.0126044853,
0.0620480813,
0.0025982135,
-0.0066766273,
-0.0463160016,
0.0348956659,
0.0285308398,
0.0239340346,
-0.0460336134,
-0.0670384839,
-0.0253714155,
-0.0221606474,
0.0577991009,
-0.0106726419,
0.0546381101,
-0.023636004,
-0.0272939131,
0.0186522603,
0.0759908259,
0.0229170099,
0.0542628653,
0.0268430114,
-0.0454407074,
0.0530974753,
0.0497051813,
-0.0850732848,
0.0174734127,
-0.0418383852,
-0.0144157959,
-0.0071476437,
-0.0059837797,
-0.0107583255,
-0.1083951294,
-0.0205226671,
0.0100977588,
0.0252916254,
0.0260666162,
0.0584590621,
0.0004917025,
-0.015032785,
0.0227088016,
0.0101036998,
0.0016589469,
-0.0170585085,
-0.0500125587,
0.0267601144,
-0.0121518644,
0.1020577922,
-0.0353034437,
-0.0236234851,
0.0056034215,
-0.0283496082,
-0.0286081396,
0.0374172255,
0.0167264808,
-0.0118322782,
-0.0545218512,
-0.0088466872,
-0.0209572371,
0.0204858631,
-0.0180560201,
0.02477929,
-0.0058853999,
0.0336812101,
0.0112624438,
-0.0133032789,
0.0413540751,
-0.070292525,
-0.0395449772,
0.0106201712,
0.0042852033,
-0.009178766,
0.0039810874,
0.0307134893,
0.0485787243,
-0.0180972181,
-0.0146640278,
-0.0187828038,
-0.0546164624,
-0.0734804347,
0.0031117273,
0.0650963038,
-0.057556428,
0.0009910981,
0.0044024778,
-0.0124538681,
-0.0159966405,
0.0835018456,
-0.0862408504,
0.0168864354,
-0.0054921485,
0.0358998328,
0.0079483734,
0.0072243665,
0.0136438496,
0.0779946521,
0.0116981277,
0.0713044927,
-0.0357585587,
0.0068930211,
0.013689599,
-0.0069129686,
0.007256126,
-0.0510809012,
-0.0395725705,
0.0091951024,
-0.0278416052,
-0.0237237923,
-0.0114391055,
-0.0041979845,
0.0392348729,
0.0066996962,
0.026384782,
0.0470670313,
0.0079628984,
-0.018568635,
0.0032804308,
-0.0100595523,
-0.0531247929,
0.0342797972,
-0.0175126642,
-0.0311127156,
0.0579303987,
0.0300479326,
-0.0137588969,
-0.0565442629,
-0.0496069379,
-0.0575474054,
0.0418031551,
0.0626927391,
0.0140335849,
-0.0253657941,
0.0435072146,
-0.0536649078,
0.0330628008,
0.0066634654,
-0.0275047086,
-0.0096525932,
-0.0235666707,
-0.0059919148,
0.0570210367,
0.0016575775,
0.0298357066,
0.0039071157,
-0.0308554042,
-0.0508469529,
0.016492255,
-0.0320304595,
0.0312428158,
0.0325577967,
-0.0517990775,
-0.0303735062,
0.086401172,
0.0118659195,
-0.0164855812,
0.0034442157,
0.1039065197,
0.0044451873,
0.0128203128,
-0.054646261,
-0.0097186761,
-0.0002973852,
0.0302050803,
0.006772771,
-0.0253395531,
0.0783595517,
0.0201097205,
-0.0082283719,
-0.0340295546,
-0.0056969328,
-0.0573762357,
-0.006715097,
0.0212614555,
-0.0355180614,
-0.0288175941,
-0.0165184289,
-0.0428772904,
-0.0259760767,
0.0425314233,
-0.0142168636,
0.0513294265,
-0.0410026796,
0.0231789164,
0.002610682,
-0.0293987561,
-0.042415645,
-0.0192262214,
0.005590098,
0.0258079469,
-0.0013622213,
-0.0164004192,
-0.0228046104,
0.0154064083,
0.043715924,
0.0418400504,
-0.0339675434,
-0.0282937121,
-0.0520280041,
0.027790159,
0.0373855084,
0.0254133027,
0.0431516394,
-0.0127578611,
0.0012400885,
-0.0502934381,
0.0261378642,
0.0042374223,
-0.0235351827,
0.0386477299,
-0.0173803195,
-0.0368553437,
-0.008135872,
0.0448730886,
-0.0204675067,
-0.0678747147,
0.0046161516,
0.0618161745,
0.0619932599,
0.0229048226,
-0.0263929088,
-0.0357715972,
-0.082451731,
-0.0017859448,
0.0508379005,
-0.0449211448,
0.0001538376,
0.0273732487,
0.0052435519,
-0.0005850859,
-0.0545989983,
-0.0266921427,
-0.0789675564,
0.0023985025,
0.0161639843,
-0.0468406156,
-0.0217463709,
0.0112701738,
-0.033203505,
-0.0244900919,
0.0080257887,
-0.0024512291,
0.0075982511,
0.0148660345,
0.0091084009,
-0.0331961364,
0.0070775249,
0.0105094882,
-0.0218253117,
-0.0147136003,
0.0556672812,
-0.0185763929,
-0.0613927692,
-0.084594965,
0.0372848436,
0.0327973515,
-0.0042040423,
0.0033339928,
0.0466684997,
0.0227160156,
-0.0077392883,
-0.0082329493,
0.0207368825,
-0.0606230386,
0.0041550566,
0.0210386384,
0.0708194822,
-0.0036066107,
0.0076205377,
-0.011060711,
-0.0014328131,
-0.0175866894,
0.020563351,
0.045194678,
-0.0270454995,
-0.0585445389,
-0.0249888953,
-0.0173713434,
-0.0288791694,
-0.0014566496,
0.0247622915,
0.0377251245,
-0.0072068963,
-0.0266758446,
-0.0553147458,
0.036348775,
0.0311074518,
0.0209555309,
-0.0563979372,
0.0362035334,
0.0013922325,
-0.0344911367,
0.0251883529,
0.0119463904,
0.037646085,
-0.0510129184,
0.0505996756,
-0.0042406884,
-0.0327453837,
-0.0290378798,
0.0058161491,
-0.0343593322,
-0.0187053271,
0.0227233618,
0.0254795309,
0.0314024761,
-0.0173023567,
-0.0082741389,
-0.0354062803,
-0.0121901128,
0.0270547718,
-0.0644111782,
-0.0074279332,
-0.0123304455,
0.0140259508,
0.0023498745,
-0.0095062666,
0.0187400561,
0.0404578522,
0.0088526187,
0.0274171848,
-0.0366375335,
0.0326360315,
0.0380055532,
0.0471753664,
0.0198585819,
0.0462698489,
0.0172132868,
-0.0052666636,
0.0227196384,
-0.0153845577,
-0.0085128061,
-0.0350411944,
-0.0079487655,
-0.0061901785,
0.0213566981,
0.0018337159,
-0.0673828572,
0.0149044823,
0.0120062074,
0.0348562486,
0.0325623453,
0.0028785139,
0.0131668309,
0.0350056849,
-0.0323956311,
0.0344962925,
-0.0012280991,
0.0162973925,
0.0384849757,
0.0154496599,
0.0738024563,
0.0015648545,
0.0493290126,
-0.0754160509,
-0.0435633697,
-0.0127915079,
-0.0778832734,
-0.0215083119,
0.0468291566,
-0.0078781554,
-0.0074950247,
-0.0921392292,
-0.0198570862,
-0.0138449017,
0.0064894771,
-0.0133409426,
0.0066347132,
0.0468492769,
0.037689399,
0.0405601524,
0.0161227994,
-0.0945271105,
0.0306860488,
-0.0058022696,
0.0194336623,
-0.0121551082,
-0.0018881584,
-0.0125842663,
-0.0085605243,
0.0334150568,
0.0055430569,
-0.0035142456,
0.0136272693,
-0.068079479,
-0.0557713136,
-0.0297275074,
0.0318087339,
0.011515093,
0.0000010715,
0.0410101227,
0.0532129407,
-0.0352185555,
0.0241110809,
0.0134064518,
0.0704279318,
-0.0482824668,
-0.0206349362,
-0.0163183212,
-5.554751535e-33,
-0.020550549,
-0.0708110854,
0.0539977551,
0.0279667452,
0.0402256027,
-0.0033400008,
-0.0128783602,
0.0168209039,
-0.0407067202,
-0.0049851425,
-0.0460523143,
0.011618902,
0.0079413913,
-0.0046894425,
0.0208114926,
-0.0319539346,
-0.0170509703,
-0.0304320157,
-0.0180927999,
-0.069707863,
-0.0134739839,
0.0317743048,
0.033329729,
-0.0501504466,
0.0087968828,
0.0300674383,
0.0304965358,
0.0029477004,
0.0002894084,
0.0215367544,
-0.02076458,
0.0086343326,
0.0151634803,
-0.0083831884,
-0.0210476127,
0.0214887988,
-0.0377822109,
-0.0683003813,
-0.0039932081,
0.0434922762,
-0.0498169959,
-0.0234402157,
0.0911320895,
-0.0063022799,
-0.0515233502,
0.0116997808,
0.0322206505,
-0.0228191409,
0.0047054649,
0.018503746,
0.0046036323,
0.0342083611,
-0.0021280202,
-0.0408598855,
0.0226986408,
0.0036944258,
-0.0243071001,
-0.0485250205,
-0.0269980766,
0.0180159137,
0.0484617651,
0.0024843386,
0.0130448379,
-0.006697135,
-0.0251763407,
0.0026610119,
0.066572845,
-0.0529417694,
-0.008573289,
-0.0027805623,
0.0206949376,
0.0218973551,
0.1134759858,
-0.0159384366,
0.1294374913,
-0.0000037727,
-0.0302350745,
-0.0010233626,
-0.0101138242,
0.0097628683,
0.0004433033,
-0.02680289,
-0.076888144,
-0.0132289417,
-0.0123743489,
0.0125776986,
-0.0803171247,
-0.0299948677,
0.0071179178,
-0.0245306883,
0.0344967432,
0.0018396968,
-0.0247763414,
-0.0599067137,
0.0236895308,
0.0229667816,
0.057212092,
0.0078614708,
0.0166951381,
-0.0156710725,
-0.0356736891,
-0.0031228871,
-0.0668587908,
0.0422209501,
0.052486591,
0.0177710671,
-0.0045224321,
0.0209199097,
-0.024011666,
-0.0097365677,
-0.0328414142,
-0.0102233114,
0.0535601005,
0.0076282439,
0.0220891889,
0.0130548002,
-0.0177498385,
-0.0205313787,
-0.0199325625,
-0.0351040065,
0.0068424838,
0.0294668619,
0.0050551882,
0.0473894253,
-0.0213922225,
-0.0364134088,
-0.0360375084,
0.0147334291,
0.0238032918,
-0.0403008014,
0.0101381456,
0.0046405355,
2.774e-7,
0.0453057438,
0.0487567447,
0.0211209059,
0.0124604795,
0.017854929,
0.0112838615,
-0.0214118827,
-0.030589249,
-0.0211567543,
-0.0117151793,
0.0283794142,
0.0162494257,
0.012813583,
0.0415379889,
-0.0085455095,
-0.0220503584,
-0.0094744507,
-0.0040633236,
-0.0299064722,
0.0505466163,
0.0217833538,
0.0374914147,
0.0433054641,
-0.0077079521,
-0.0288433507,
-0.0630305037,
-0.0035433527,
0.0322640426,
0.0122947646,
0.0106649213,
0.004718137,
-0.0046357452,
-0.001382793,
0.0157183353,
-0.0228459798,
0.0813169181,
0.0465979911,
0.0482851751,
0.0156649519,
-0.0077763097,
-0.0051529841,
-0.0342414603,
-0.0161144976,
-0.0186129883,
0.0365395956,
-0.0749722123,
-0.0443582162,
-0.0022762371,
0.0215231106,
-0.0322041251,
0.0490908884,
-0.0067269518,
0.0688234717,
-0.0145111363,
0.0395640433,
-0.0232304502,
-0.0005536565,
-0.0451340862,
-0.0166836493,
0.0388703123,
-0.0543949381,
0.0101747774,
-0.0481716394,
-0.000084939,
0.0591050424,
0.0116221644,
-0.0153246066,
1.98936715e-34,
0.0154226189,
0.0153146982,
0.024588177,
0.0228293762,
0.0258828644,
0.0015575164,
-0.03060125,
0.0529513247,
0.0298003778,
-0.0386317,
-0.0117475679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14361v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14361v3 | A Hybrid Machine Learning Model for Classifying Gene Mutations in Cancer using LSTM, BiLSTM, CNN, GRU, and GloVe | 2023-07-24T21:01:46 | 2024-05-20T16:55:07 | Sanad Aburass, Osama Dorgham, Jamil Al Shaqsi | q-bio.QM | q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In our study, we introduce a novel hybrid ensemble model that synergistically
combines LSTM, BiLSTM, CNN, GRU, and GloVe embeddings for the classification of
gene mutations in cancer. This model was rigorously tested using Kaggle's
Personalized Medicine: Redefining Cancer Treatment dataset, demonstrating
exceptional performance across all evaluation metrics. Notably, our approach
achieved a training accuracy of 80.6%, precision of 81.6%, recall of 80.6%, and
an F1 score of 83.1%, alongside a significantly reduced Mean Squared Error
(MSE) of 2.596. These results surpass those of advanced transformer models and
their ensembles, showcasing our model's superior capability in handling the
complexities of gene mutation classification. The accuracy and efficiency of
gene mutation classification are paramount in the era of precision medicine,
where tailored treatment plans based on individual genetic profiles can
dramatically improve patient outcomes and save lives. Our model's remarkable
performance highlights its potential in enhancing the precision of cancer
diagnoses and treatments, thereby contributing significantly to the advancement
of personalized healthcare. | [
0.0046345531,
0.0223891232,
-0.0175484139,
-0.0386593677,
-0.001633784,
0.0210651942,
0.0403639227,
0.0033304715,
-0.0098399539,
0.0074244821,
0.0321167633,
-0.030255178,
-0.0169577841,
0.0776822865,
-0.0060193134,
0.0015689005,
0.0486425161,
0.0367024578,
-0.0588394143,
-0.029423818,
-0.0146497451,
-0.024918139,
0.032990966,
0.0518212542,
0.018160237,
0.0327276662,
0.0307294726,
-0.0106341485,
0.0261263661,
0.0157227702,
0.0181471948,
0.0123066921,
-0.0293153655,
0.0965487212,
0.0000021842,
-0.0532011688,
-0.0102431597,
-0.0029893287,
0.0040457388,
-0.0154231256,
-0.0104074748,
0.0043732626,
-0.0251707695,
-0.0072329631,
-0.0205623396,
0.0079674255,
0.0113426317,
0.0906227008,
0.0344356038,
0.06077604,
0.0084293457,
0.0043074461,
0.086723648,
-0.0278864112,
0.0376910158,
0.0128754815,
0.0044676722,
-0.051769644,
-0.0194438286,
-0.0349404402,
0.0253457651,
0.0990608484,
0.031690415,
0.0112667913,
0.0201288145,
0.0319185257,
0.0004660999,
0.0356424637,
0.0083508482,
0.020447528,
-0.0621773936,
-0.0091903703,
-0.0394469388,
0.0110678151,
0.0247050095,
0.0256036185,
-0.0172438733,
-0.0056450861,
-0.0355534032,
0.0188805684,
-0.0407287218,
-0.0267330185,
0.0391660221,
-0.0210790187,
-0.0061042272,
0.0345120281,
-0.0099018421,
-0.0292072129,
-0.0462917835,
0.0073180217,
0.0094962139,
0.0339865051,
0.0104166828,
0.0222219229,
-0.0397514217,
-0.0387491062,
-0.0208001509,
-0.0612546094,
0.0563286282,
-0.0205730777,
0.0583498105,
-0.0207035057,
-0.0624710955,
0.0111111915,
-0.0606201962,
-0.0233341176,
-0.0652499199,
0.0731801689,
-0.0059639807,
0.0229300987,
-0.0632684082,
0.0255306866,
0.0578701869,
0.0192034859,
0.0282762181,
0.0039234748,
-0.053750895,
0.0053434074,
-0.0250990987,
0.0143941166,
0.0274848584,
0.0751936585,
-0.0162321161,
0.0385571271,
-0.0116085354,
-0.0073321112,
0.0128083928,
0.0145838335,
-0.0072343964,
-0.0637627095,
0.0149710029,
-0.0053098565,
-0.001126873,
-0.0184753388,
0.0083373133,
0.0038949179,
-0.0004270946,
-0.0486933179,
0.0463483855,
-0.0017973454,
-0.0534051247,
-0.0217603035,
-0.0171148647,
-0.0480967462,
0.0106496755,
0.0013561731,
0.0056380881,
-0.0164739918,
0.016995633,
-0.0754799619,
-0.026440626,
0.0715413243,
0.0094566401,
-0.052673243,
0.0640715733,
0.0170010906,
-0.0263041072,
-0.0053079776,
0.0357645303,
0.0027591686,
-0.0077539203,
-0.0375099815,
0.0527528226,
-0.0382918976,
-0.0047953594,
-0.0093782526,
0.0070658587,
-0.0212487932,
-0.0277180653,
0.0852102712,
-0.0200028718,
-0.0019017153,
-0.0082232747,
-0.071345225,
0.0418565236,
0.0136174485,
0.0822518915,
0.0871791393,
-0.0186426472,
-0.0011438143,
-0.0339437351,
-0.0868724063,
-0.0019830875,
0.0463959873,
-0.0537981316,
0.0042651119,
-0.0011359919,
0.0182107482,
-0.0168151706,
-0.0385600924,
-0.0041748527,
-0.0084983418,
-0.0306654312,
-0.0171843171,
0.0095354505,
-0.0437503085,
-0.0221300274,
0.0379450396,
-0.0033514739,
-0.0132678403,
-0.0372315571,
-0.0747886971,
-0.0240051486,
0.0290473402,
0.0288666412,
-0.0267921574,
-0.0544645637,
-0.0646926239,
-0.083517395,
-0.0300851855,
0.0052877325,
0.0429308824,
-0.0136695858,
-0.008374935,
-0.009966691,
0.0054805414,
0.0141416425,
-0.010958517,
-0.0153627777,
0.0253285151,
-0.0088310111,
-0.0388454571,
0.0193454102,
0.0182072986,
-0.0288957637,
-0.0247453768,
0.0326055698,
0.0023563472,
0.0479992107,
-0.0057440978,
-0.0424756743,
-0.025118202,
0.0327705443,
-0.0350278132,
-0.1022606269,
0.004445889,
-0.0017113921,
-0.0317531675,
0.0363137051,
-0.0157307629,
-0.0025016367,
0.0008254613,
-0.0496550612,
-0.0216489509,
-0.0007145553,
-0.0221602917,
-0.0182310138,
-0.0355247445,
0.0195811596,
0.0067800023,
0.0388831533,
-0.0327084661,
-0.0102879563,
-0.0338211805,
-0.0530718602,
-0.0568764694,
-0.0358554833,
0.0557996519,
-0.0433409214,
-0.0109704956,
-0.0131689068,
0.013909868,
0.0084968954,
-0.0271707624,
-0.0341537595,
0.0224512573,
-0.0314538255,
-0.0647754744,
0.00228072,
-0.0028309128,
-0.0049161604,
-0.0192318354,
0.0032820825,
0.0084885349,
-0.0396439135,
-0.0314745717,
-0.0028247284,
0.006351436,
-0.0294506904,
0.0492719412,
0.0181906261,
-0.0253102258,
-0.0469756052,
-0.0202823002,
-0.051508978,
0.0407083035,
0.0081388429,
-0.0229905192,
-0.0091451304,
-0.0232058261,
-0.0031290879,
0.0601143986,
0.0233939663,
-0.0150236711,
0.002610971,
-0.003381364,
-0.0624022372,
0.0708580315,
0.0288906936,
0.0265267249,
0.0174315292,
0.0405476987,
-0.0136543866,
0.0083805714,
-0.0372586027,
-0.0474189669,
0.0434488915,
0.0233141035,
-0.0326072127,
0.0011204084,
0.0030175922,
-0.0122020021,
-0.0307679027,
-0.0332493298,
0.0415271483,
-0.0068664062,
-0.0006974085,
0.0620017275,
-0.0329742692,
-0.0325665176,
-0.0150976805,
-0.0493614934,
0.1112133861,
0.0223824661,
0.051207196,
-0.0678961203,
-0.0054341485,
-0.032307297,
-0.0108666876,
0.0145502947,
0.0336417295,
-0.0222313181,
0.036488194,
0.0073842034,
0.0128923757,
-0.0150003443,
-0.0571722537,
0.0576634333,
-0.0156039856,
0.0305832531,
0.0156840365,
-0.0244787168,
-0.0353332758,
-0.0028424473,
0.0085809901,
-0.0058054649,
0.0144654531,
-0.0366943292,
-0.086621128,
0.008676487,
-0.0031693066,
0.090426527,
-0.0084434263,
-0.0114069516,
-0.0007705444,
-0.0120728267,
0.0179677512,
-0.0034997778,
-0.0053529963,
0.0178052913,
0.071206294,
0.034771271,
-0.0199822392,
0.0184629522,
-0.0709835514,
0.0422502831,
-0.017031569,
-0.006442172,
-0.0266706422,
-0.0134589206,
0.024615135,
-0.035232354,
0.0076442976,
0.0749716684,
0.0235021897,
-0.0473041721,
0.0013680779,
0.033463303,
-0.0448820442,
-0.0252818,
0.0542684831,
-0.0959538519,
-0.0335950181,
-0.0241984408,
-0.0270828381,
-0.0150944451,
-0.0294616092,
0.0573353432,
0.0057775509,
0.0305358805,
0.0679711327,
-0.0407054313,
-0.0302871242,
-0.0228980873,
-0.0125499582,
-0.0296236724,
-0.0078864023,
-0.0157516431,
0.0353799649,
-0.0222527105,
0.0148669602,
-0.0124864643,
-0.0830227211,
0.0318939835,
-0.0376931243,
-0.0224773362,
0.0763395503,
-0.0179318264,
0.0091651864,
-0.0177116953,
-0.0052222409,
0.075325571,
0.0532076061,
-0.0058875945,
0.0844200402,
0.0089244787,
-0.0049360967,
-0.0118704438,
0.0347419642,
-0.0490308553,
0.0344211459,
-0.0216174666,
0.0859216303,
-0.0586362146,
-0.016757153,
-0.0689411089,
-0.0565684885,
0.0099264486,
0.018859962,
-0.0104335044,
-0.0037864198,
-0.0320461281,
-0.0299043488,
0.0254513621,
-0.0029537303,
0.0223084912,
0.0462292098,
0.0050150394,
-0.0571377464,
-0.0319809467,
-0.0228219554,
-0.0015246063,
-0.0151419686,
0.0108970348,
-0.0034079205,
-0.0212794133,
-0.0094867209,
-0.0522166677,
0.0775202587,
0.0602488853,
0.0368948914,
-0.0715383515,
-0.0497308522,
0.049491372,
-0.0237528645,
-0.0052426863,
0.0204072632,
-0.0547112152,
-0.0184768271,
-0.0316774957,
0.0487806834,
0.0157273766,
-0.0082306331,
-0.0035950812,
-0.0286223982,
0.0948248729,
0.0844561905,
0.0261171982,
0.0089483466,
-0.0256142523,
-0.1085223034,
-0.0435303785,
-0.0095203761,
0.0284903981,
0.0340416282,
-0.012281239,
-0.0302659608,
-0.0344054662,
-0.0052493196,
0.0071881758,
-0.0091929426,
0.0932697803,
0.0162299238,
-0.0213789809,
-0.0105341701,
0.0235249922,
0.0675701872,
0.0328440256,
-0.0090331361,
-0.0531363897,
0.0013374371,
-0.0146262478,
-0.0396738388,
0.0047894157,
0.0078875571,
-0.0302425865,
-0.0552161932,
0.0067314813,
0.0184582882,
0.0059094629,
0.0178424586,
0.0090560121,
-0.0100612585,
0.0162494555,
-0.0003154623,
-0.0090329321,
0.0345708504,
0.0118554635,
0.0002723627,
0.0759916008,
-0.0373663232,
0.0572641231,
-0.0290671289,
-0.0212999545,
-0.0494485535,
0.0100344541,
0.0333126336,
-0.0004631563,
0.0329301283,
-0.004452046,
-0.0183519237,
-0.0576751716,
0.014176012,
-0.0294569526,
0.0681182519,
0.0426206701,
0.0376710333,
-0.0245552119,
-0.0224655345,
0.0368688107,
0.0043973895,
0.0503574163,
-0.0484705605,
-0.0110277282,
-0.0425157137,
0.0643842742,
0.0289782714,
-0.0004289226,
0.0120514007,
-0.0014767429,
-0.0316112898,
-0.0066667004,
0.0894308165,
-0.00659328,
0.0361067168,
-0.0032309347,
-0.00970688,
0.0093043176,
0.0136334384,
-0.0310014375,
-0.0096203219,
-0.0092940377,
0.0473934934,
-0.0301156212,
-0.035064552,
-6.30856594e-33,
0.0053072907,
0.0151875978,
0.0119933421,
-0.014948491,
0.0397870243,
-0.0062660784,
-0.0488620214,
-0.0134504717,
0.0222843643,
0.0138381775,
0.0010331809,
0.012598441,
-0.0267756153,
0.0080633489,
0.0195313077,
-0.0379269868,
0.0581408963,
-0.0131164249,
0.0241798982,
0.0050440799,
0.0411011018,
0.0568266436,
0.0099343043,
-0.0615066476,
-0.0671661273,
0.0511750132,
0.0049528982,
-0.0293857437,
-0.0630859807,
0.0302562695,
0.0245339591,
0.0411227681,
-0.0221843068,
-0.0362354741,
0.0082582254,
-0.0614529438,
-0.0151371136,
0.027199652,
-0.082987152,
0.0247887298,
0.0059173852,
-0.0254379157,
0.0527459085,
0.0006898618,
-0.0374311954,
-0.0326129757,
0.0510619469,
-0.0208293144,
-0.0318579115,
-0.0692907572,
0.0194409844,
0.0301357433,
-0.0050372481,
-0.0175525658,
-0.0146252308,
-0.0518211648,
-0.0254210476,
0.0213298872,
-0.0460582674,
0.001340247,
0.0831343904,
-0.0047164178,
0.0518770777,
-0.031989608,
0.0008222206,
0.0075329128,
0.0089454539,
-0.0271790382,
-0.0286452007,
-0.031937521,
0.0078795739,
0.0187622514,
0.0535152033,
0.0143387774,
0.0499520116,
-0.0132199107,
-0.0886891484,
0.0397081859,
0.0172597282,
0.040610183,
-0.0188960303,
0.0324771442,
-0.0076014777,
0.0141755911,
0.0021347811,
-0.0264970735,
-0.0016053549,
-0.0026218924,
0.0310820993,
-0.022245653,
-0.0079482822,
0.06036672,
-0.0152969891,
-0.0250674281,
0.0032221235,
-0.0107291127,
0.0442365929,
0.013078236,
0.0048134183,
-0.0111628147,
0.033449173,
-0.0346522331,
0.0484022722,
-0.0449371822,
0.021281682,
-0.0052177524,
0.0474713296,
0.013681055,
-0.0263836794,
0.0095327534,
-0.0151499184,
-0.0082715759,
0.0220170002,
0.0294882655,
-0.0031348828,
0.0149300834,
0.0113411229,
0.0999792069,
-0.0370958187,
-0.017354304,
-0.0086217104,
0.0190883763,
0.0138977757,
0.00136231,
-0.0203565154,
0.0122611178,
-0.0057745455,
-0.0096071353,
-0.002584436,
-0.0885048211,
-0.0265035927,
0.0189308506,
3.132e-7,
0.0630290508,
0.0622347929,
0.0110131064,
-0.0890976489,
0.0411254242,
0.0414785556,
0.0046024527,
0.0021196273,
-0.0209496543,
0.0242956281,
0.0689799041,
0.0133269886,
0.0390387103,
-0.0082239015,
0.0016370622,
-0.0438065492,
-0.0386088081,
0.0846841633,
0.0053905621,
0.0289338827,
0.0285533685,
0.0874871165,
0.0361504145,
-0.0414719917,
0.1217070222,
-0.0304577611,
0.0337239839,
-0.0389487371,
0.0611660294,
-0.0053233653,
0.0024581929,
0.0082505187,
0.0282833241,
0.0269671399,
0.0109744314,
-0.019600451,
-0.0155778425,
0.0103323003,
-0.0513715073,
-0.0179872438,
0.0415423065,
0.0419722013,
0.0636451244,
-0.0524097085,
0.0086636357,
-0.0343911648,
-0.0247631036,
-0.0178803839,
-0.0193656012,
-0.0295993648,
0.081872128,
-0.0100957006,
0.0132488515,
0.0455782227,
0.0033665346,
-0.0011227522,
-0.013083335,
-0.0636071339,
-0.0005886666,
0.0223493502,
-0.074704282,
0.0319069549,
-0.0199184585,
0.0175915956,
0.0591841489,
-0.0005527241,
-0.0064555472,
2.933148146e-34,
0.0123335458,
0.0177256148,
0.0453686155,
0.0101449378,
0.0195900798,
0.0024140652,
0.0175947547,
-0.0083199097,
-0.0056803483,
-0.0555281304,
-0.0311703775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00121v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00121v3 | Getting pwn'd by AI: Penetration Testing with Large Language Models | 2023-07-24T19:59:22 | 2023-08-17T12:26:40 | Andreas Happe, Jürgen Cito | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.SE | The field of software security testing, more specifically penetration
testing, is an activity that requires high levels of expertise and involves
many manual testing and analysis steps. This paper explores the potential usage
of large-language models, such as GPT3.5, to augment penetration testers with
AI sparring partners. We explore the feasibility of supplementing penetration
testers with AI models for two distinct use cases: high-level task planning for
security testing assignments and low-level vulnerability hunting within a
vulnerable virtual machine. For the latter, we implemented a closed-feedback
loop between LLM-generated low-level actions with a vulnerable virtual machine
(connected through SSH) and allowed the LLM to analyze the machine state for
vulnerabilities and suggest concrete attack vectors which were automatically
executed within the virtual machine. We discuss promising initial results,
detail avenues for improvement, and close deliberating on the ethics of
providing AI-based sparring partners. | [
-0.0052525317,
0.0469367504,
-0.0111056566,
0.0233839452,
-0.0819408521,
-0.059901882,
0.0120604634,
-0.013557543,
0.0527390279,
-0.0006216804,
0.052607581,
0.0084695043,
-0.0361085795,
0.0456632376,
0.0472567268,
0.0007248971,
0.0870713145,
-0.0593110174,
-0.0457783975,
0.0062560649,
-0.0026265639,
-0.0192986988,
-0.0322090387,
0.0387342684,
0.0219228286,
-0.0135750296,
-0.055067759,
0.0405437946,
0.0491701961,
0.0002793585,
-0.0211884808,
0.0083624413,
0.0104892589,
-0.0113963671,
0.0000018273,
-0.0288779754,
-0.0186539199,
0.0375629179,
-0.0149430772,
0.0269678384,
-0.0434639901,
-0.0051754438,
-0.0258077383,
0.0518368557,
-0.0306284633,
0.0295754913,
0.0320414454,
0.042588912,
0.0709592253,
0.0590367652,
0.0143550569,
0.0260496791,
0.0082562435,
-0.000438704,
0.00762273,
-0.0420464948,
-0.00080937,
-0.0037822193,
0.0456921197,
0.0042034965,
0.0164905358,
-0.0561257713,
0.022864867,
0.0025017597,
-0.0341363885,
0.0732799023,
-0.0205930267,
0.0500493348,
-0.0359225683,
-0.0450876057,
-0.0558849648,
0.0099792238,
0.0152882375,
0.0213656481,
-0.0145209059,
-0.0051882421,
0.0372809991,
0.0271613952,
-0.018087158,
-0.0380190313,
0.0497793704,
-0.0256624501,
-0.0135831079,
0.0060559777,
-0.0083470978,
0.0440174006,
0.0198433585,
-0.0387384109,
-0.0077582379,
-0.0316179059,
0.0193172228,
-0.0218340084,
-0.0145107647,
0.0474870503,
-0.057149414,
0.0123197781,
-0.0372222662,
0.0080185151,
0.0626815185,
0.0090770302,
0.0226591434,
0.0246074144,
-0.0192600749,
0.0001344055,
-0.0064431699,
0.0641080886,
-0.0210538246,
0.0302418899,
0.0142051447,
0.0186169725,
-0.0677777603,
0.0208667666,
-0.0005034489,
0.0472275913,
0.0658541843,
0.0145531539,
-0.0199810825,
0.0319096707,
-0.047726173,
0.049646087,
-0.0492049977,
-0.0107550845,
-0.015709905,
0.031111652,
-0.0057591493,
-0.083746925,
-0.0583123229,
-0.0296371989,
-0.0579587929,
-0.0451283231,
-0.0140524209,
0.0183254443,
-0.0552062653,
-0.0410105437,
0.0182636026,
0.1028468236,
0.0040981518,
0.0018960371,
-0.0403604023,
-0.0516509973,
0.0367032662,
0.0036373229,
0.004353872,
-0.0352819301,
-0.0426399074,
-0.0430971533,
-0.0015882819,
-0.0194537397,
-0.0107806912,
-0.0260762237,
-0.0078844558,
0.0762344748,
0.0490440316,
0.008823364,
0.0149765024,
0.0307310782,
0.0367527381,
0.0076328684,
-0.0235150196,
0.0556989536,
-0.0248135738,
-0.0206963401,
0.0778043568,
0.0238782465,
-0.028935248,
0.0400814936,
0.0062968354,
0.0438020267,
0.0244341623,
0.0126427673,
-0.0295928102,
0.0416448414,
0.0186054371,
-0.0237982739,
0.0608690642,
0.043776162,
-0.0680394769,
0.0558290407,
0.0534414835,
0.0252867788,
-0.0197648425,
-0.0161191802,
-0.0500435829,
0.0209925324,
-0.0660699829,
-0.0378420576,
-0.0300902687,
0.0342616811,
-0.0143998377,
0.0120339561,
0.0243465155,
-0.0117659746,
0.0017985791,
0.0024743432,
0.0172980074,
0.0199850835,
-0.0139824217,
-0.0239511486,
-0.0105023459,
-0.0105034336,
-0.0427684821,
-0.1013340503,
-0.0162573289,
0.0342661813,
0.0717979223,
-0.0588215142,
-0.0676952749,
-0.0069386507,
-0.0348711163,
0.0262491833,
0.0103781885,
0.0191710629,
-0.0584822595,
-0.0003824496,
-0.0081543857,
-0.030775005,
0.0275008734,
0.0324755684,
0.0046124151,
-0.0539248958,
-0.0112727331,
-0.0233489461,
-0.025370935,
0.0225322898,
0.0198094025,
-0.0377886742,
0.0049331398,
0.0394810289,
0.045845136,
-0.0050770901,
-0.023432225,
0.021448696,
0.0552300103,
0.0102584632,
-0.0133569008,
-0.0152243115,
0.091302298,
0.0759479925,
-0.0053147338,
-0.0471318737,
0.0405629091,
0.0621572807,
-0.0736791715,
-0.0123346895,
0.0478275158,
-0.0537688397,
-0.0286473017,
0.0111899115,
-0.0317199379,
-0.0191080775,
-0.0091371555,
-0.0313883796,
0.0331590064,
0.0409505367,
-0.0547692254,
-0.0086092362,
0.0263388921,
0.0118488129,
-0.0548131838,
-0.0168130044,
0.0049328096,
-0.0307374038,
0.0272408351,
0.0189268719,
0.0306448601,
-0.0123173343,
-0.0186576247,
-0.0875879824,
0.0397391841,
-0.0085138651,
0.057155367,
0.0303347502,
-0.0022660457,
-0.0221284274,
-0.0211737808,
-0.0048951614,
-0.0009808302,
-0.0049028336,
-0.0121835647,
0.0161821209,
-0.0211994257,
-0.0241722707,
0.0008689629,
0.0203576256,
-0.0412514992,
0.0320400931,
0.0182609316,
0.0098952679,
-0.006851716,
0.0609787591,
-0.011321188,
-0.0126405293,
0.0188517049,
-0.0873165205,
0.0025310821,
-0.0106635839,
-0.0106533514,
0.0614039898,
0.0164916366,
0.0358957089,
0.0829089805,
0.027387144,
-0.0286473092,
0.0106936162,
0.0406129435,
-0.0692963004,
-0.0482218526,
-0.0130750919,
0.0238534901,
0.0397515371,
0.0149257295,
-0.0122472625,
-0.0235821456,
0.0249073841,
-0.0068146866,
0.0289436281,
0.027279878,
-0.0651608407,
-0.0092991712,
-0.0134128164,
-0.0107244486,
-0.0876302272,
0.0793536156,
-0.0288810749,
-0.0016865716,
-0.0391702354,
-0.0683017299,
-0.0409178585,
0.0524439588,
-0.0134593388,
-0.0070508774,
-0.0279790815,
-0.0122345863,
-0.0343535878,
-0.0502727106,
-0.0056732274,
-0.0321206897,
0.0159347225,
-0.0436419062,
0.016042795,
0.0028602073,
-0.0083546182,
-0.0383796543,
-0.0189465135,
-0.060216397,
0.0082620643,
-0.043028608,
-0.0265375357,
0.0107595501,
0.0001753049,
0.0526568219,
0.0226487722,
0.0186322704,
-0.0352397971,
-0.0031967922,
-0.0523483194,
-0.0000036045,
-0.0500484072,
-0.0694308057,
0.026068639,
0.0225502755,
0.0507905334,
0.0820278227,
0.0068152514,
-0.0577637367,
0.0283138342,
-0.0173558109,
-0.0558625385,
0.041714631,
0.0424608402,
0.0000602475,
-0.0424105413,
-0.0337203965,
0.0579384938,
0.0168260839,
-0.0215129014,
0.038667582,
-0.0403343327,
-0.0256476142,
0.0321675874,
0.1103721559,
-0.0825875551,
0.0048097167,
0.0108450055,
0.0481754728,
-0.056567274,
-0.0319037437,
0.0282694772,
-0.1139637232,
0.0371462665,
-0.0068858974,
0.0155134993,
-0.0049963268,
-0.0485359356,
0.0226893518,
-0.0091429679,
-0.0179705229,
-0.0002992945,
0.0388069414,
0.0059383269,
-0.011468973,
-0.01874437,
-0.0141215306,
0.0606471971,
-0.0155205885,
0.025736833,
0.0832674131,
-0.0080194138,
-0.0584059842,
0.0264690034,
0.0276285093,
-0.0148956468,
0.0359417014,
0.0037736851,
0.0309377797,
0.0326513797,
-0.0185223073,
0.0497994609,
0.023802029,
-0.0252428669,
-0.0042837737,
0.0797893256,
0.0552663803,
-0.0650103092,
0.0009775372,
-0.0188562106,
-0.0214454271,
0.0557555854,
0.0209360179,
0.0087173237,
-0.0513985604,
-0.019205533,
-0.0324321203,
-0.0020346676,
-0.0100263506,
-0.1070684791,
-0.0205305014,
0.0078913961,
0.014669029,
-0.0161012653,
-0.0734411255,
0.0444816463,
0.0346082933,
0.0571112745,
-0.0743726641,
-0.0195001885,
0.071708113,
-0.0251513589,
-0.0081679113,
-0.0237926077,
0.069620885,
0.0046560536,
0.0010403263,
-0.0209757574,
-0.0439521931,
-0.0436182767,
0.0178110413,
-0.0102532152,
-0.0559238344,
0.0060136123,
0.0737559572,
0.0259682722,
-0.0258638393,
-0.0459474735,
-0.0384082273,
0.0630881339,
-0.0436943695,
0.0017073978,
0.0187053271,
0.04265837,
-0.0345567688,
0.0102245044,
-0.0173745323,
-0.0197206717,
0.0146869337,
0.0757403001,
0.008888768,
-0.0222316831,
-0.0205176529,
0.0237912685,
0.0438981727,
0.0245428123,
0.0053628809,
0.016829988,
0.0268567093,
0.0133145545,
0.0023215525,
0.0019199362,
0.0195099358,
-0.005785008,
-0.0040316386,
-0.0309527256,
0.0566396788,
-0.0145799788,
-0.0359268039,
-0.0052556498,
0.010977637,
0.0456328876,
0.0458938368,
0.0232647117,
0.0357601158,
-0.0023841821,
0.0101781795,
-0.0199842136,
0.020660704,
0.0573323108,
0.0046020551,
0.030115623,
-0.0263629034,
0.010724809,
-0.0444439426,
0.0105357412,
-0.0399435349,
-0.0715954825,
0.0690779164,
0.0509266555,
0.0331874564,
0.0605808571,
-0.0458768457,
-0.0380730666,
0.0196179654,
-0.0303111374,
-0.0011954125,
-0.0383601077,
-0.0248743929,
0.0381281041,
0.0134674003,
0.0043966183,
-0.0000874875,
0.0480839387,
0.0038798875,
0.0861663222,
0.0090534259,
-0.0183954313,
-0.0577002056,
-0.0147415623,
-0.000550524,
-0.0220932905,
-0.0291473456,
-0.0443591252,
-0.0167722125,
-0.0500845201,
-0.0090560634,
-0.0015440907,
0.0131642632,
-0.0317408852,
0.0062714429,
0.0531714186,
0.0087308027,
0.0567302108,
-0.0569912642,
0.006791912,
-0.0390181877,
-0.0342068635,
-0.0151666803,
-4.869486083e-33,
0.0428584144,
-0.0555659086,
0.0191102792,
-0.0175439157,
0.0010678964,
0.0209324751,
-0.0484739468,
-0.0015653293,
-0.0046909349,
-0.0082924822,
-0.0055280617,
0.004017218,
0.0382688232,
-0.0273256246,
0.0270195045,
0.0115279639,
0.0087659741,
-0.0112526799,
-0.0189537555,
0.057533294,
-0.0116181364,
-0.0130155412,
-0.0071553919,
-0.0440082327,
0.005500467,
-0.0105131418,
-0.0093650082,
0.0250833742,
-0.0570420474,
0.0103023704,
0.0103360144,
0.0220992174,
-0.010591629,
0.0080137197,
0.0335446708,
-0.0036787884,
0.0315076038,
-0.0085791759,
-0.0301068537,
-0.0498719215,
-0.0104018366,
-0.0213245917,
-0.0280783642,
-0.0142800724,
0.0284865722,
0.0200261977,
0.0071071251,
-0.0064692642,
0.0179863404,
-0.041107405,
-0.0109889423,
0.0029235987,
-0.0568736233,
0.0068676006,
0.0052468413,
-0.009622029,
0.0155442404,
-0.0350418165,
0.0277717095,
0.034796007,
0.0132982302,
-0.0250883903,
0.0309253875,
-0.0109915081,
-0.0311568342,
0.0073289205,
-0.0291551892,
0.0013639741,
-0.024417771,
0.0212622881,
0.0106395986,
0.0342413262,
0.0443652011,
0.025895834,
-0.0110858157,
-0.0060709934,
-0.0041425233,
0.0250793081,
0.0728639439,
0.0467107408,
0.0343616158,
0.0089483671,
-0.0833236948,
0.0060080052,
-0.0028249258,
-0.0502467379,
-0.0321265385,
-0.0504100733,
-0.0044474774,
0.0001200548,
-0.0860799924,
-0.0002963973,
-0.0081102066,
-0.0152981291,
0.0550402515,
0.0298131313,
0.006201501,
-0.0022657095,
-0.0511267185,
-0.0094290208,
0.026905369,
-0.0346989147,
-0.0260166638,
-0.0415675417,
0.0451634414,
-0.0391510688,
-0.0296892878,
0.0336164348,
-0.036398381,
0.003940037,
-0.0524907596,
0.0288714021,
-0.0029739754,
0.0501049682,
0.0167671125,
0.0138246585,
0.0497369133,
-0.0272074901,
0.0423491634,
-0.0775447488,
-0.0577008724,
0.0516993031,
-0.0471065529,
0.0087541454,
-0.0265474152,
0.0117371483,
-0.0143031217,
0.0594428666,
-0.0148029262,
-0.0533256307,
-0.0023768558,
-0.0000403637,
2.806e-7,
-0.0301576499,
0.0412642136,
0.0160066616,
0.0530017167,
-0.0193315446,
0.0535581,
-0.0057665617,
0.0725014359,
-0.0122634387,
-0.0540970154,
0.0078600179,
-0.0008625382,
0.0545152761,
0.0317904949,
0.0229359958,
0.038567137,
-0.0048229466,
-0.005714824,
-0.0978857651,
0.0297539178,
0.0521884449,
0.0291644707,
0.009604645,
-0.0353969336,
0.008848018,
-0.0828743502,
-0.0276510008,
0.031343773,
-0.0199835896,
0.0218123961,
0.0223605633,
0.0573167019,
0.0048335339,
0.1004167423,
-0.0478923693,
-0.0214688666,
-0.0565237701,
0.0284662023,
0.0244617444,
0.0106188497,
-0.049439244,
-0.0286117699,
0.0035153644,
-0.0362166576,
0.0544288866,
0.0071384856,
-0.0152307199,
0.0074828635,
0.0213306136,
-0.0402181596,
-0.0069499812,
-0.0589146875,
0.0139581384,
0.0035586671,
-0.0073884334,
-0.0327276699,
0.0071465056,
-0.0201768018,
-0.0273013376,
0.0057235095,
-0.0757960975,
-0.0042186566,
0.0293374006,
0.0414617322,
-0.0048890659,
0.0169195663,
0.0233550631,
2.440491347e-34,
-0.0029268211,
-0.0189983733,
0.0088235596,
0.0301380698,
0.0081974566,
0.0552567951,
-0.010266914,
0.0405388772,
-0.0086125163,
0.002625485,
-0.0165996924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13106v1 | How to use LLMs for Text Analysis | 2023-07-24T19:54:15 | 2023-07-24T19:54:15 | Petter Törnberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This guide introduces Large Language Models (LLM) as a highly versatile text
analysis method within the social sciences. As LLMs are easy-to-use, cheap,
fast, and applicable on a broad range of text analysis tasks, ranging from text
annotation and classification to sentiment analysis and critical discourse
analysis, many scholars believe that LLMs will transform how we do text
analysis. This how-to guide is aimed at students and researchers with limited
programming experience, and offers a simple introduction to how LLMs can be
used for text analysis in your own research project, as well as advice on best
practices. We will go through each of the steps of analyzing textual data with
LLMs using Python: installing the software, setting up the API, loading the
data, developing an analysis prompt, analyzing the text, and validating the
results. As an illustrative example, we will use the challenging task of
identifying populism in political texts, and show how LLMs move beyond the
existing state-of-the-art. | [
0.0017452046,
0.0446152613,
-0.0115875769,
0.0381954387,
-0.0429763608,
0.0323832743,
0.0006208501,
0.0072309901,
0.0631570369,
-0.0712361559,
0.0334344022,
-0.0388338231,
-0.0158723053,
0.0251571964,
-0.0146145094,
-0.0194892175,
0.0317235105,
-0.0089266347,
0.0402926505,
0.0069240546,
-0.0077846255,
0.0178787056,
0.0221638642,
0.0165538285,
0.0090464298,
-0.0113960803,
-0.0128150666,
0.003253849,
0.0106375869,
-0.028687112,
0.0111396657,
0.0216762871,
0.0230320841,
0.0527463481,
0.0000020338,
-0.0468304828,
-0.0305339824,
-0.0275769122,
0.0514686443,
0.0353030451,
0.1104314774,
0.0120219672,
-0.0305122808,
0.0238756537,
-0.0346618555,
0.0173302256,
0.0072526247,
0.0122090448,
0.062695846,
0.0746364519,
-0.0031125708,
-0.0540098809,
-0.0030541026,
-0.0069555137,
-0.031585943,
0.022197146,
0.0821974352,
-0.0151079828,
0.0145560224,
0.0504892133,
0.0211614184,
0.0343174227,
-0.0280444399,
-0.0301214829,
3.749e-7,
-0.0228216201,
-0.025853062,
-0.0536982752,
-0.0024961173,
-0.0005114719,
0.0698128268,
-0.0261307266,
0.0466277264,
-0.0118556125,
-0.0364401042,
0.0321647078,
-0.0331650861,
0.0377538875,
-0.0266166795,
0.0367167592,
0.0384554602,
-0.0393332727,
0.0216906406,
0.0398812816,
-0.0280425195,
0.0652702004,
-0.0066394932,
-0.0152947111,
0.005326889,
-0.0170260668,
0.004245664,
-0.0354888961,
0.0346125029,
0.0315488875,
0.0210606493,
0.0228354875,
0.0094799949,
-0.050855428,
0.0478828177,
-0.0833678246,
0.0067655528,
-0.0120141441,
-0.0016677257,
0.044921115,
0.0413893387,
-0.0128175905,
-0.0027020727,
0.0052875895,
0.0066525936,
0.0129426345,
-0.0178213455,
0.0007119286,
-0.0029210858,
-0.0053593689,
-0.0018407593,
0.0211766735,
-0.0222874619,
0.0044108499,
-0.000509217,
0.0170659684,
-0.0468892604,
-0.0360116251,
0.0460081585,
0.0277613662,
-0.0407987162,
0.0408444591,
-0.0125335511,
0.0204732753,
-0.0593780912,
-0.007345709,
0.0307271145,
0.0585769117,
0.0026731419,
-0.005437159,
0.0296823326,
0.025876401,
0.0047415816,
0.0018275527,
-0.075258106,
0.0106939245,
-0.0241407752,
-0.0476324297,
0.0157093629,
-0.0869254544,
-0.011677294,
0.0325902402,
0.0014509045,
-0.02282173,
0.0287669171,
0.0191799086,
-0.0403140076,
0.0154233649,
-0.0195405185,
0.0132323178,
0.0730129927,
0.0193225872,
0.0301372111,
0.0544183478,
0.0192787442,
0.0378400199,
0.0488221869,
-0.0056651719,
0.0366464742,
0.0444897451,
-0.0353839584,
0.0300019607,
-0.0696559027,
0.0139105944,
0.0023556326,
-0.0111492835,
-0.0026598689,
0.0607506782,
0.0339704864,
0.0281419046,
0.0394501127,
0.0955176055,
-0.0116404751,
-0.0007002791,
0.0008821333,
0.0445732996,
0.0015325649,
-0.0270185079,
0.0251554176,
-0.0053934501,
0.0175130609,
-0.0309183747,
0.0227185581,
0.0433226861,
0.0044011152,
-0.0292197745,
-0.044603765,
-0.0027159038,
-0.0141240591,
-0.0247878749,
0.0631337315,
-0.054699447,
-0.0118702361,
-0.0065551191,
0.0339399949,
-0.0649883226,
0.0209960751,
-0.0289720949,
0.0524622835,
0.0516504087,
0.0202433374,
-0.0713731498,
0.0346753821,
-0.059905,
0.0548612475,
0.0566781014,
-0.0023278433,
-0.0019846768,
-0.057370469,
-0.0494129136,
0.0023391573,
0.0101491315,
0.0276175849,
0.014138354,
-0.0004356363,
-0.0058205416,
-0.0121486001,
-0.0054621142,
-0.0440725908,
0.0283967536,
-0.0287767928,
-0.0180754736,
-0.0271097571,
-0.0162365753,
0.0175051168,
0.0362351052,
-0.031367138,
-0.0102946097,
0.0424685739,
-0.016115034,
-0.0243293904,
-0.0119133601,
0.050806243,
0.0734927356,
0.0235841107,
-0.0279358439,
-0.0003410063,
0.0367218666,
-0.0033077595,
0.0075158579,
0.0354493782,
0.0005411244,
0.0284342021,
-0.0281602144,
0.028106777,
-0.0714443848,
-0.0061763255,
-0.0494193509,
0.0600146614,
-0.0051354519,
0.0527771972,
0.0116485339,
-0.051414866,
0.0488633327,
0.0293895788,
-0.034353368,
-0.0102371462,
0.0299927648,
0.0405054912,
0.0085678669,
-0.0373651944,
-0.0108318059,
-0.0576453283,
-0.0485600457,
0.0255612805,
-0.0263787191,
0.0264474098,
0.0047163949,
-0.0230902936,
-0.0446302779,
0.0288243983,
0.0168921649,
-0.0125741065,
-0.004550857,
-0.0019572284,
0.0492986329,
-0.0377209559,
-0.0003598474,
-0.0265846923,
0.0330757312,
-0.0335890949,
0.0579592809,
0.0390072018,
-0.0676403418,
0.008402477,
0.0170989018,
-0.0363644809,
0.0086687291,
-0.0566748455,
-0.0468200222,
-0.0052958233,
-0.0076967077,
0.0609416515,
0.0269070994,
0.0312384553,
0.0498432852,
0.0607795008,
-0.0157068595,
-0.0321538746,
-0.0326314494,
-0.0161817838,
-0.006393515,
-0.0208289083,
-0.0621633008,
0.0020874622,
0.043650452,
0.0275502577,
-0.0012298136,
0.008100545,
0.0181118231,
-0.0459828302,
0.0184043739,
-0.005499565,
-0.0122507904,
-0.0099521959,
0.0194331706,
0.01117073,
-0.0537687838,
0.0053284448,
-0.0229160283,
0.0597538538,
-0.0517415963,
-0.0721143112,
-0.0720738098,
0.0584034212,
0.0080433367,
-0.0099149747,
-0.0315128416,
-0.0052545043,
0.0362658016,
-0.0350265019,
0.0029403295,
-0.0447710976,
0.0836066529,
-0.0434956811,
0.0246171989,
-0.0176886469,
0.0300332252,
-0.0009307301,
-0.0776316598,
-0.0575688966,
-0.0172286667,
0.0290878452,
-0.0186775606,
-0.0238498282,
0.0313904099,
0.0630555525,
-0.0071904785,
0.0216085631,
0.0398746803,
-0.0026165915,
0.0067911479,
-0.0219804998,
-0.0560489185,
0.0121722743,
-0.035019055,
0.0096905231,
0.0304721314,
-0.0263079107,
0.0211375728,
-0.0485683307,
-0.0410078578,
0.0034164551,
-0.0538806096,
-0.0228299033,
-0.0345648602,
0.032577686,
-0.0600891002,
0.0464498959,
0.102357313,
0.0314556062,
-0.0532723926,
-0.0116004152,
-0.0522965975,
-0.0080402149,
0.0374655165,
0.018420713,
-0.0799861774,
0.0365688391,
-0.0085967099,
0.0084398938,
-0.034515366,
-0.0389379114,
-0.0161987096,
-0.0665718019,
0.0043109544,
0.0113951825,
0.0218528695,
-0.008359395,
-0.0638208836,
0.0290193669,
-0.0116800843,
-0.0388533659,
0.0037539543,
-0.017402444,
0.0071603945,
0.0130020641,
-0.0815887526,
-0.032365147,
-0.0191569608,
-0.0427158475,
0.0397761315,
0.009918239,
0.0459551252,
-0.0517508276,
0.0114692496,
0.0735197738,
-0.0047661695,
-0.03506938,
-0.0285082441,
0.0394769609,
0.0253318474,
-0.0258958489,
-0.0255023576,
0.0195967555,
-0.0023286098,
-0.0234299153,
0.0570370033,
0.0428126641,
-0.0348609984,
-0.0328670405,
-0.0253849383,
0.0284480583,
0.0171928518,
0.0467675589,
0.000637116,
-0.019452678,
-0.0045074252,
-0.0515652187,
-0.0178561322,
-0.0089562265,
-0.0458690636,
0.011855565,
-0.0334614851,
-0.005621762,
-0.0217992663,
-0.0005618418,
0.0268198475,
-0.0213531815,
0.0321797952,
0.0506148972,
0.0026689135,
-0.0183547884,
-0.0474320091,
0.0094958367,
-0.0243452042,
0.0122519881,
-0.0145212878,
-0.0544450209,
0.0580156446,
0.0146271018,
-0.0094193714,
-0.0338809974,
-0.0907673761,
-0.0749459639,
0.0121275447,
-0.0391687192,
0.0148437023,
-0.0142990425,
0.0328210853,
-0.0483538732,
0.0516592152,
0.0615704954,
-0.0247187093,
0.0393483303,
-0.0168911163,
0.0601994954,
0.0034854372,
0.0030936024,
0.0055599585,
0.0158168972,
-0.0114391418,
-0.0322481208,
-0.0786237344,
-0.0099239042,
-0.0358433798,
0.0104433103,
0.0180445556,
-0.007407303,
-0.0701231584,
-0.044169385,
-0.0110717556,
-0.0265969913,
-0.0283388477,
-0.0015527752,
-0.0100682098,
-0.0156953186,
-0.0249730013,
-0.0754961446,
-0.002825937,
-0.0314686894,
0.0334280096,
-0.0499752723,
0.1257747114,
0.0000117339,
0.0244552772,
0.0344512761,
-0.0272919182,
-0.0077484599,
0.0216116123,
-0.0479754955,
0.0220068004,
0.0244851112,
0.0044522579,
-0.014456952,
-0.0104711875,
0.0571680032,
0.0085768541,
-0.0166269131,
-0.0480156951,
-0.0110193044,
0.0027803842,
0.0281809717,
-0.0234675482,
0.0348446257,
-0.0102284597,
-0.0146829719,
-0.044190187,
0.0402881168,
-0.0028413357,
-0.0153291598,
0.0147009315,
-0.0037168269,
-0.0578037575,
0.0330112651,
0.0265771393,
-0.0050123511,
0.0132400896,
0.0924341455,
-0.0434585735,
-0.0256236177,
-0.0213396866,
0.0362654626,
-0.0087140733,
-0.0149677172,
0.0030412655,
-0.0539796576,
-0.0052288622,
0.042854052,
0.0038121231,
-0.035494905,
-0.0286349412,
-0.0294307433,
0.0440888591,
-0.0093176253,
0.0824753717,
-0.0749726221,
0.0538149737,
-0.0618698299,
-0.0255728234,
0.0414655097,
-6.212796211e-33,
-0.017132232,
-0.0803866759,
0.039579168,
-0.0105894757,
-0.0389555022,
0.0104115792,
-0.0214830805,
0.0038557583,
-0.0088295992,
0.0021007243,
0.0075380206,
0.0055840355,
0.0096260644,
0.0070876391,
0.0173001103,
-0.0039496771,
-0.0008534839,
0.018740911,
0.0081086503,
-0.011406254,
0.0425535738,
0.0179258082,
0.046477329,
-0.0844090134,
0.0335680097,
-0.0060830889,
-0.0266064182,
-0.0089667393,
0.029563034,
0.0089663006,
-0.0279868003,
0.0277831927,
0.0272567011,
-0.0260728337,
0.0230891034,
0.0730726868,
0.0056132856,
-0.0190529097,
-0.011117924,
0.0060733673,
0.0544994771,
-0.0315903611,
0.0373792611,
-0.0041598063,
-0.0245797075,
0.020157801,
0.0675408617,
-0.0368443429,
0.0037687554,
-0.0080444757,
-0.0412542522,
0.0614725351,
-0.0150585603,
0.0522217788,
-0.0115946308,
0.0049443631,
0.0039869905,
0.102905646,
-0.0426266529,
0.0288592987,
0.032921806,
0.0198398624,
0.0183246899,
0.0001570911,
0.0280998759,
0.0843587145,
-0.0255455747,
0.0130251078,
-0.0437674969,
0.0022522109,
0.0340115316,
-0.0058529996,
0.0282203816,
0.0773668513,
-0.0194401015,
-0.0295135137,
-0.0856458768,
-0.0041861767,
0.0632367581,
-0.0074557946,
0.0420162678,
-0.011038851,
0.0003132538,
-0.0256588273,
-0.0513517633,
-0.0357057378,
-0.0107751535,
0.0040243752,
-0.0254004132,
-0.0231600832,
-0.0247937422,
-0.0036242763,
0.0228079334,
-0.0232846625,
-0.0305501856,
-0.0024856254,
-0.0145438341,
0.0279327482,
-0.018716868,
0.0220937412,
-0.0639164746,
-0.0139177106,
-0.0482325926,
0.0021391662,
0.0346192569,
-0.0026669735,
-0.0456224829,
-0.00691874,
-0.0878964588,
-0.00749102,
-0.0020996551,
-0.0007580019,
-0.0077915401,
0.0458245389,
-0.0008992706,
-0.0009420356,
0.0153970011,
0.0287154261,
0.0349690579,
0.0101368753,
0.026939055,
-0.0318858176,
-0.0361922197,
-0.0178522523,
-0.0314160511,
0.0144846225,
0.0088161072,
0.0533921048,
0.0448369719,
-0.0468914546,
0.0152470171,
-0.0213599782,
2.665e-7,
0.0875115469,
0.1066896245,
-0.0234315395,
0.0039867633,
0.0059855334,
0.0247553997,
-0.0215374101,
0.0121915592,
-0.0387275778,
-0.0544786416,
0.0019936531,
0.0123865977,
0.0427247249,
0.0531489141,
-0.0925955772,
0.0092562698,
-0.059703052,
-0.0063656257,
-0.0917448923,
0.0353589505,
-0.0069244285,
0.0596514642,
0.0374283716,
0.0161708351,
-0.0574302636,
-0.0424398482,
0.040506009,
-0.0620664246,
-0.0438857786,
0.0534678064,
0.0199102592,
-0.019219419,
0.0110101793,
0.021494275,
-0.0079635447,
0.0021221556,
-0.0137977665,
0.0617121868,
0.0300348978,
0.0161357746,
0.0316251628,
-0.0369775109,
0.0030498179,
-0.0512928478,
0.0758241713,
0.0182025395,
-0.0259454884,
-0.0837759301,
-0.0172146,
-0.028898567,
0.0561506934,
-0.0107451426,
0.0023145981,
0.0338658877,
-0.0104526272,
-0.0170612559,
-0.0012926999,
-0.0454554856,
-0.0086523937,
0.0090431497,
-0.05139146,
-0.0599201955,
-0.0128736291,
0.0275006369,
0.0083593102,
-0.038365256,
0.0493844599,
2.627456937e-34,
0.059462402,
-0.052561447,
-0.0592655651,
0.0345405564,
0.0445318259,
0.0302503332,
-0.0189618655,
0.0072629857,
-0.0106907655,
-0.0774344131,
0.0464397445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16850v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.16850v1 | Comparative Analysis of Drug-GPT and ChatGPT LLMs for Healthcare Insights: Evaluating Accuracy and Relevance in Patient and HCP Contexts | 2023-07-24T19:27:11 | 2023-07-24T19:27:11 | Giorgos Lysandrou, Roma English Owen, Kirsty Mursec, Grant Le Brun, Elizabeth A. L. Fairley | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study presents a comparative analysis of three Generative Pre-trained
Transformer (GPT) solutions in a question and answer (Q&A) setting: Drug-GPT 3,
Drug-GPT 4, and ChatGPT, in the context of healthcare applications. The
objective is to determine which model delivers the most accurate and relevant
information in response to prompts related to patient experiences with atopic
dermatitis (AD) and healthcare professional (HCP) discussions about diabetes.
The results demonstrate that while all three models are capable of generating
relevant and accurate responses, Drug-GPT 3 and Drug-GPT 4, which are supported
by curated datasets of patient and HCP social media and message board posts,
provide more targeted and in-depth insights. ChatGPT, a more general-purpose
model, generates broader and more general responses, which may be valuable for
readers seeking a high-level understanding of the topics but may lack the depth
and personal insights found in the answers generated by the specialized
Drug-GPT models. This comparative analysis highlights the importance of
considering the language model's perspective, depth of knowledge, and currency
when evaluating the usefulness of generated information in healthcare
applications. | [
0.0847072303,
0.0207979493,
-0.0024258497,
-0.0102815619,
-0.0010921319,
0.0135264331,
-0.0124172932,
0.0262346193,
0.0323063731,
-0.0460247248,
-0.0091417413,
-0.0196503792,
-0.0628937706,
0.0136535438,
0.0126460046,
-0.0572593547,
0.0061624027,
0.0448103547,
0.0106629813,
0.0353171863,
0.0147870928,
0.0296872836,
-0.0118925413,
0.064641118,
0.0020780836,
-0.0124113634,
0.021515267,
0.0063230661,
0.0409257077,
-0.0414346643,
0.0234620348,
0.0471783914,
0.0060733147,
0.013038869,
0.000001892,
-0.0350223631,
-0.0099849924,
0.0170194022,
-0.0147339199,
-0.0691268891,
0.0281137154,
-0.0188944712,
0.0087385094,
0.038669724,
-0.0766871274,
-0.0309972428,
0.0455234647,
0.0879811198,
0.0659564734,
0.0682764798,
-0.0307236258,
-0.0344976857,
0.0185888298,
0.0023999591,
0.0536753498,
-0.0506614633,
0.0209412798,
0.0117183272,
0.0050338982,
0.0149403652,
0.0207251441,
0.0330746472,
-0.0086992513,
-0.0214210935,
0.0386504941,
0.0337553844,
-0.0113427695,
-0.035681311,
-0.0191548411,
0.0768851265,
-0.0131198326,
0.0122063495,
-0.01737988,
-0.0089545446,
0.0163161997,
0.0485469103,
-0.0552812926,
-0.0066254493,
-0.0217825565,
0.0342164412,
-0.0145479124,
0.0385030173,
0.0153320013,
-0.0259752292,
-0.0166995507,
0.0051061846,
0.0109017687,
-0.0102496855,
0.0014860691,
0.0162277445,
0.0108363023,
-0.0587861687,
0.0216689631,
0.0573469773,
-0.0072327428,
0.0244343225,
0.025378149,
-0.0060176495,
0.0385798998,
-0.0528975315,
0.005278815,
0.0307791736,
-0.0034283304,
0.0102250846,
-0.0104358066,
0.0002852521,
-0.0296296142,
0.0260548498,
-0.0507554561,
-0.0061154743,
-0.0662254393,
-0.0329717696,
-0.038213402,
0.0404636413,
-0.0143328523,
-0.0053370441,
-0.0617616624,
0.0149504011,
0.0199295525,
-0.038726192,
0.0278357752,
0.0307939649,
-0.0188780744,
0.0080459975,
-0.0342304856,
0.0451447219,
-0.0180543233,
0.0169335585,
0.0159528404,
-0.0680060983,
0.0403424501,
-0.0015312962,
0.0285861976,
-0.0146161262,
-0.0113368947,
0.0725636184,
-0.0063793501,
-0.0214538462,
-0.031334646,
-0.0197290629,
-0.0122556882,
-0.0306698568,
-0.0018344892,
-0.0416087694,
0.0689148381,
0.0277088452,
0.0105158258,
-0.0375901796,
0.0130938711,
0.0454377756,
-0.0549955703,
0.0698321536,
-0.0167725179,
0.0452203453,
0.049815651,
0.0558768436,
0.0463526547,
0.0485746711,
-0.0050228653,
0.0147548225,
0.0215230174,
-0.0574620776,
0.0366091393,
-0.0031048197,
0.0018331424,
-0.0551488213,
0.051126454,
0.0395650193,
-0.0052065393,
0.0366853587,
-0.0542620979,
0.0746326521,
-0.033356294,
-0.0016314653,
0.0364704244,
0.0762451217,
0.0510481037,
0.0322579108,
0.0401052497,
0.0029607886,
-0.0056500863,
-0.0026965146,
0.0027587723,
0.0236530323,
-0.0246622264,
-0.0150607638,
0.0131706093,
0.0138742672,
-0.03960713,
-0.0319385193,
-0.0304351524,
-0.0142211169,
-0.0222878978,
-0.020434374,
0.0014601005,
0.0185039472,
-0.0600065663,
0.1005505919,
0.0238545872,
-0.0601411723,
-0.0052653896,
-0.0662240162,
-0.0117026102,
0.0640680417,
0.0303906742,
-0.0197540373,
-0.0679384023,
-0.0443016365,
-0.0137500698,
0.0231955238,
0.0494368598,
-0.0116220983,
-0.0079060756,
-0.0316606686,
-0.0036684165,
-0.0029035388,
-0.0215017386,
-0.0217683222,
0.0176946875,
0.0327166729,
-0.0008733452,
0.0096800821,
0.0175372828,
0.0328461304,
-0.0243618954,
-0.0305544324,
0.0132147213,
-0.0139935911,
0.0216111261,
0.0514512509,
0.0335668549,
0.0222631097,
0.0265926048,
-0.031338349,
-0.0414373688,
0.0070793903,
-0.0471591204,
-0.0198350921,
0.0106167067,
-0.0570822768,
0.0063956045,
-0.0082495492,
-0.0421931632,
-0.0195112526,
-0.0331747122,
-0.0330159329,
0.0493911393,
-0.0300813317,
-0.0410618372,
0.0183677152,
0.0009583528,
-0.0689690709,
0.0126306172,
-0.0123827001,
-0.003939128,
-0.0121481856,
-0.0408439003,
-0.0251052994,
0.0021301256,
0.016742738,
0.0216927417,
-0.0008983181,
-0.0029554758,
0.0036997276,
0.0147574553,
-0.0305951778,
-0.0427557305,
-0.09357059,
-0.0184889287,
-0.0188138578,
0.0085530458,
0.0441321321,
0.0440165363,
-0.0043897973,
-0.0197397061,
-0.0847339407,
0.0074661276,
0.0365478955,
0.0230008643,
0.0370653979,
0.041800119,
0.053557761,
-0.0610788949,
-0.0024225535,
-0.017082734,
0.0236063432,
0.0387033783,
-0.016140243,
-0.0315401554,
-0.0252589229,
-0.0594297163,
-0.0123255365,
-0.0027950949,
-0.027873572,
0.0225111581,
-0.013545665,
0.0715985894,
-0.035567645,
0.0441156998,
0.0237430334,
-0.0074985144,
0.0205953345,
-0.0347867683,
0.0105084609,
-0.0893303528,
-0.0630275086,
-0.0123423636,
-0.0618848316,
0.0398714207,
0.0721482709,
0.0392481796,
-0.007844626,
-0.083688885,
0.043047931,
-0.0115559911,
0.012976083,
-0.0472131111,
-0.0148065239,
-0.0039047496,
0.0423353948,
0.0260133184,
-0.02875413,
0.0647901744,
-0.0024485467,
0.0194443259,
-0.0667554364,
-0.0195590016,
-0.0623704456,
-0.0027209977,
-0.0075592366,
0.0337236151,
0.0086642327,
-0.0217122957,
0.002059143,
0.0145298848,
-0.0141997579,
-0.0600243807,
0.0611762665,
0.0048359674,
0.0107389055,
-0.0089836633,
-0.0329932421,
-0.0477798991,
-0.047948949,
-0.0110856257,
-0.015184382,
0.0263009798,
0.0193361174,
-0.0105261095,
0.034912508,
-0.0325736329,
0.0400103927,
0.0138061801,
-0.0504534543,
0.0080924733,
0.0545289442,
0.0536709651,
0.0201249309,
0.0386467576,
0.0078924904,
0.0374710597,
0.0705533102,
-0.0073560551,
-0.0244230796,
0.0026521666,
-0.0276693571,
0.0074380045,
-0.032762751,
0.005261654,
0.0033890142,
0.0406765006,
-0.0232423134,
-0.001005915,
0.1024204642,
0.0186473858,
-0.041747842,
0.0201015584,
-0.0289832819,
-0.0473518521,
-0.0188482646,
0.0356464498,
-0.096315451,
0.0048896591,
-0.0620457307,
0.0082237124,
-0.0138815856,
-0.0142354835,
0.0051648836,
-0.0347275101,
0.0272907633,
-0.0197606683,
-0.0043060551,
-0.0090433974,
-0.0216710865,
-0.0041429335,
0.0063431873,
0.0118154809,
-0.0236935653,
-0.0242371578,
0.0064052492,
0.0080636991,
-0.0501411073,
-0.0369216427,
0.0108834971,
0.0294711515,
0.0144465053,
0.0638229251,
0.0285359006,
0.0047816928,
-0.019772416,
0.0022276992,
-0.0033258589,
0.0303330086,
-0.0020587316,
0.0573724844,
-0.0073048752,
0.0342417918,
-0.0467141494,
0.0352595076,
-0.0564754792,
-0.0284720659,
-0.0238709003,
0.0820998922,
-0.0281450842,
-0.0230460819,
-0.0541408435,
0.0625321493,
0.0405509509,
0.0684553757,
0.0329654068,
-0.0036080033,
-0.0071952045,
0.0055241841,
0.0727991313,
-0.0245286711,
-0.0616825148,
0.0002930268,
0.0145524899,
0.0051483777,
-0.0667509437,
-0.0324955061,
0.0278660338,
-0.030185733,
-0.0325925611,
-0.0184962433,
0.0151759619,
-0.0004889923,
-0.011324212,
0.0321066007,
0.0140781412,
-0.0064156172,
-0.0479216874,
-0.0434444584,
0.0543321408,
-0.0189041365,
-0.0054089609,
-0.0139905103,
-0.0431462452,
-0.0284366477,
0.0221741609,
0.0480674691,
0.0206792187,
-0.0004635832,
0.0019781762,
-0.0211807545,
0.0470562764,
0.0605360158,
-0.0405759439,
-0.0350336283,
-0.0193967447,
0.0474020652,
0.0082716439,
0.0234935768,
-0.0098845884,
0.0460341573,
0.0266367719,
0.0146324895,
-0.0070731291,
-0.0755678639,
0.0100659812,
-0.0193958189,
0.0410777405,
0.0126917474,
-0.0002212244,
-0.0400247574,
0.0032572018,
-0.0246759448,
0.0295066833,
-0.0504536517,
-0.0444612578,
0.0258339681,
-0.0202482399,
-0.0390533842,
-0.0157834236,
-0.0944624543,
0.0124373445,
-0.0857621878,
0.0245935842,
0.0291810036,
-0.0043575414,
0.0300596487,
0.0026536279,
-0.0223698728,
0.0101574464,
0.007829411,
0.0058089937,
-0.0108511867,
0.0934563205,
-0.0221432485,
0.0228555612,
0.0283012092,
0.0507561676,
-0.0637545362,
-0.075929001,
-0.0523376465,
0.0248298738,
0.0162081774,
0.0027949556,
0.0251544528,
0.0017138063,
-0.0061419713,
0.0006005706,
0.0146668795,
-0.0008447388,
-0.0057220352,
0.0643750727,
-0.0066486816,
-0.0024632278,
-0.0289550498,
0.0803896785,
-0.0388749726,
0.0339893959,
-0.002022367,
-0.0333975293,
-0.038804695,
-0.0145810228,
0.0050975932,
0.004227384,
-0.0243909527,
0.0145960478,
-0.0638356656,
-0.0313780122,
-0.0136251552,
-0.0115705822,
-0.0260269791,
-0.0044873892,
0.0471341982,
0.052394215,
0.0253381506,
-0.0390441753,
-0.0408353098,
0.0521480888,
-0.0501328483,
-0.0000694993,
-0.0084468974,
-6.161468251e-33,
-0.0087917391,
-0.0265384298,
0.0195728168,
0.0132730892,
-0.0216440074,
0.0202543959,
-0.0260202102,
0.0029723744,
-0.0063784127,
0.0213603377,
-0.0064646765,
0.0117521221,
-0.0085626272,
0.0421323292,
-0.0205923803,
-0.0384736918,
0.0504290089,
0.0011221331,
-0.0106875794,
0.0804358944,
-0.0006260866,
0.0512157604,
0.0411879979,
-0.0681129694,
0.0031276757,
-0.0311152488,
0.0285809468,
0.015067026,
0.0264844,
0.0490859561,
-0.032969404,
0.0486342944,
0.0532706194,
-0.0328644812,
-0.0000030614,
0.0329382159,
-0.0531392843,
-0.0438968092,
0.0020866126,
-0.031014258,
-0.0598183423,
-0.0317938812,
0.0415021107,
-0.0382717885,
0.0013390864,
-0.0485964976,
0.03591723,
0.0165085811,
0.0452408046,
-0.0720441714,
-0.06790784,
0.0131050926,
0.0050334348,
-0.0006772821,
-0.0445041098,
0.0493053235,
-0.0194348097,
0.0479729287,
-0.0417538546,
-0.0056858403,
0.0494591258,
-0.0072408598,
0.0322586522,
-0.0196433607,
-0.0313368142,
0.0217910651,
-0.0166406278,
0.0094580054,
-0.0585129336,
0.0037827461,
-0.0676716119,
0.0456764325,
0.0417496599,
0.0399109535,
0.011379418,
-0.0047018649,
-0.0764292926,
0.044476334,
-0.0582201853,
0.0147314891,
0.0177075453,
-0.0062649399,
-0.0015076618,
-0.0080664903,
-0.0138388192,
0.0491195917,
-0.0160752572,
-0.074085623,
0.0038686616,
-0.0056123971,
-0.0066185398,
0.0252386946,
0.0124972612,
-0.0361194275,
0.0206362102,
-0.0290248226,
0.0133043509,
-0.0033493571,
-0.0288994256,
0.0080389464,
-0.0523508489,
0.0376863964,
0.0239301212,
-0.0043962356,
0.0127790524,
0.0153200291,
0.0176441763,
-0.0268429108,
-0.0467100888,
-0.0267872177,
-0.0042317058,
0.0421642363,
-0.019231651,
0.0113411183,
-0.0030301767,
0.0415076017,
-0.0153545672,
0.0674442425,
0.0112904878,
0.0091589829,
-0.032687068,
-0.0249131583,
0.0304013602,
0.0133700548,
-0.0479443967,
0.0204128698,
-0.0326804593,
0.0354301855,
0.0395513102,
-0.0599777065,
-0.0172211025,
0.0063967202,
2.658e-7,
0.1247542053,
0.0380712301,
0.0180843826,
-0.0398319326,
0.0263656359,
-0.0193136539,
0.0547421053,
0.0143125337,
0.034578912,
0.017267039,
0.025756903,
0.0247546416,
0.0003029193,
0.0668999702,
-0.029946981,
-0.0403870121,
-0.0901080221,
-0.0326326825,
-0.028601652,
-0.0028290602,
0.0985391065,
0.0404216796,
-0.0413035601,
-0.0288051032,
-0.0103155281,
0.0273707081,
0.0696562082,
-0.0566717647,
-0.0072553148,
0.0826886371,
0.0330570564,
0.0246904865,
0.0336324908,
0.004583295,
-0.029296279,
-0.0340176746,
0.0219835807,
0.0460949838,
-0.0181871485,
-0.0441908129,
0.0173292123,
-0.0062396671,
0.0326228403,
-0.0877706409,
0.0572811589,
-0.1163130328,
-0.0558893792,
-0.0117195891,
-0.0255973507,
-0.027415067,
0.0377476998,
-0.0395095535,
-0.0348165929,
0.0482389629,
0.0344942361,
0.0461158566,
-0.0139128082,
-0.0724509507,
-0.0009204828,
0.0237580761,
-0.0530964211,
-0.02317103,
0.0003973422,
-0.06473279,
-0.024340909,
-0.0306943618,
0.0112519059,
2.076915076e-34,
0.0053917598,
0.0269909147,
0.0166154336,
-0.0154211819,
0.0361237824,
0.0278232209,
0.035739854,
-0.0030674243,
0.0148740206,
-0.093541041,
-0.0143102286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13085v1 | Making Metadata More FAIR Using Large Language Models | 2023-07-24T19:14:38 | 2023-07-24T19:14:38 | Sowmya S. Sundaram, Mark A. Musen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the global increase in experimental data artifacts, harnessing them in a
unified fashion leads to a major stumbling block - bad metadata. To bridge this
gap, this work presents a Natural Language Processing (NLP) informed
application, called FAIRMetaText, that compares metadata. Specifically,
FAIRMetaText analyzes the natural language descriptions of metadata and
provides a mathematical similarity measure between two terms. This measure can
then be utilized for analyzing varied metadata, by suggesting terms for
compliance or grouping similar terms for identification of replaceable terms.
The efficacy of the algorithm is presented qualitatively and quantitatively on
publicly available research artifacts and demonstrates large gains across
metadata related tasks through an in-depth study of a wide variety of Large
Language Models (LLMs). This software can drastically reduce the human effort
in sifting through various natural language metadata while employing several
experimental datasets on the same topic. | [
0.0933906958,
0.0439207219,
-0.0240324866,
0.0471566916,
-0.0489531048,
-0.0084707653,
-0.0066353735,
0.0077873748,
-0.0358276814,
-0.0949668512,
0.0046841553,
0.0404130556,
-0.0070050331,
0.0043933536,
-0.0224581007,
-0.0471610948,
0.029982565,
0.0118097886,
0.0137636177,
0.0136233419,
0.03792537,
0.0130595351,
0.0271846764,
0.038780041,
-0.0237077978,
0.0009277997,
0.0609828234,
-0.0078406297,
-0.0173453931,
-0.0300951377,
0.0115961907,
0.070811294,
-0.0504729524,
0.0651316047,
0.0000018903,
-0.0760847703,
-0.0245946124,
0.0439033769,
-0.0016552621,
0.0533654131,
0.0830249861,
0.0295595229,
-0.0175825935,
0.0063439975,
-0.0082453964,
-0.0032472888,
0.0387460738,
0.0221336205,
0.0498282537,
0.0015545122,
-0.0282833632,
-0.0034359228,
-0.0188563839,
0.0133209936,
0.0530501008,
-0.0037483124,
0.037028484,
0.0335478224,
0.0462392941,
0.0277924631,
0.017028261,
0.032641422,
-0.0431530513,
-0.0183373094,
0.0145381102,
-0.000322548,
-0.050836876,
-0.0078324135,
0.0395132415,
0.0452514812,
0.0581736937,
0.0066887988,
0.024728097,
-0.0337593481,
0.030616859,
0.0419843234,
-0.033210963,
0.0454006493,
-0.0228165854,
-0.000671459,
0.0265701693,
0.0004867462,
0.0326619633,
0.0413804613,
0.0073953513,
0.1094564721,
0.011793959,
-0.0488873012,
-0.0232697409,
-0.0427739434,
-0.0433863886,
-0.0588397644,
0.0208234619,
-0.0094384905,
0.0181125663,
0.0334499739,
-0.0310260933,
-0.0579262711,
0.0922689959,
-0.0612295941,
-0.0564760789,
-0.0056984103,
-0.0514501892,
0.0604796223,
0.0157917105,
-0.0001509757,
0.025822239,
0.0269304421,
0.002511818,
-0.0491980463,
-0.035494417,
-0.0325449593,
0.0178548247,
0.0410883799,
-0.0376515798,
0.0269973483,
-0.0170138795,
0.0139048956,
-0.065472357,
0.0212711748,
0.0171653144,
-0.0236786921,
0.0116244266,
-0.0011855272,
-0.0642981455,
-0.0445838906,
-0.0414526239,
0.0422697999,
-0.0282039642,
-0.0354287326,
0.0465947166,
0.0212618522,
-0.0055850912,
-0.0251849536,
0.0333925039,
0.0411516912,
0.0829187259,
0.0040781498,
-0.070968017,
-0.0635264069,
0.0073641585,
0.0025395693,
-0.037593659,
-0.060222704,
-0.0174137671,
-0.0026600987,
-0.00075814,
-0.0401485227,
-0.0344489217,
0.0284912642,
-0.0919260234,
0.0852173194,
-0.072017774,
0.006569034,
0.0464578681,
0.0057567148,
-0.0185776427,
-0.0092027644,
0.0003157878,
0.0007140582,
0.0899057165,
0.0081475768,
0.0154739348,
0.0024542271,
-0.0552780144,
0.0131127136,
-0.011780276,
0.0122207077,
0.0282497332,
0.0168405343,
0.0019468262,
0.0596088655,
-0.0047144638,
-0.0331336483,
0.0607070774,
0.0739940628,
-0.0076473849,
-0.0064431117,
-0.0089423321,
0.0363810547,
-0.0263652168,
-0.0182237364,
-0.0394368805,
-0.0281197745,
-0.0281812251,
-0.0128721585,
0.009566226,
-0.0014850652,
-0.0160065088,
-0.0365703441,
-0.0390952863,
-0.0151997367,
0.0295865629,
-0.04566155,
-0.0038107082,
0.0085005546,
-0.0044630575,
0.049541235,
0.0268327445,
-0.0152505748,
0.0072081634,
-0.0482846014,
0.0225530118,
0.0666349307,
0.0758881271,
-0.0884602815,
0.009330499,
-0.0110214762,
0.0198147055,
0.0488775261,
0.0211591814,
-0.0085245296,
-0.0337823108,
-0.047912512,
-0.0483641922,
0.0003112951,
0.0274088867,
0.0022550412,
-0.017474195,
-0.0157923102,
0.0243226849,
-0.0545479953,
-0.0449854806,
0.0539946482,
0.0373949185,
-0.033342015,
0.000159322,
-0.013081002,
0.006255433,
0.0249120854,
-0.0164073836,
0.0184528045,
0.01272358,
0.0244969837,
-0.0036435456,
-0.0131077031,
0.0294899624,
0.0892711058,
0.0696859658,
-0.0298352465,
0.0098765129,
0.0150481872,
-0.0192471519,
-0.0045248261,
-0.0246688295,
-0.0074269376,
0.0135106379,
-0.0359994583,
0.0333768502,
-0.027996568,
0.0121723814,
-0.0655139685,
0.0123736458,
0.0198909566,
0.0115624228,
0.0178528577,
-0.0593931116,
0.0389902629,
0.0393169001,
-0.0404443406,
0.0318012759,
-0.0241368394,
0.0506042242,
0.0766167045,
-0.0002176323,
-0.0049131215,
-0.0134190414,
-0.0372951888,
0.0108644357,
0.0204177946,
0.0167191904,
0.0112365065,
0.0254607871,
-0.0146654742,
0.0016151238,
-0.0238323696,
-0.0415315665,
0.0163153019,
0.0227127839,
0.0418044403,
-0.0027080923,
-0.0436885394,
-0.0003860907,
-0.0233389717,
-0.01559301,
0.0671462119,
0.0238222536,
-0.0252606012,
-0.0570397936,
-0.0050739837,
-0.055951789,
0.0066314759,
0.0148169883,
0.0432840921,
-0.0222015548,
0.0126969218,
-0.003141697,
-0.0147598926,
0.0098427488,
-0.0062620193,
0.0607592203,
0.0017929187,
-0.0445521213,
-0.0535398945,
0.0284035746,
0.0074488833,
0.0043959958,
-0.0355671793,
0.0537275337,
-0.003994016,
-0.0228470247,
0.0010066947,
-0.0149946613,
-0.0007312905,
-0.0467746072,
0.0048705856,
-0.0145946285,
-0.0499760322,
-0.0026005148,
0.0242132824,
-0.0031441078,
-0.0427093692,
0.0436718687,
-0.0448928997,
0.0292011537,
-0.0469951965,
0.0074900072,
-0.040356379,
0.0474659838,
-0.0195558034,
0.0312126037,
0.0538693033,
-0.0434927605,
0.0019908242,
-0.0362217277,
0.0803665891,
-0.0325450338,
0.015563407,
-0.0594819635,
0.0238367766,
-0.0008044787,
0.0132206595,
-0.0070132245,
-0.0199804436,
0.0253971834,
0.0411413237,
0.0296734702,
0.0255330931,
-0.0390540697,
-0.0037688129,
0.0062985988,
0.049091436,
0.0205215681,
-0.0091348877,
-0.0103486599,
0.0024561617,
-0.0067235571,
-0.0425814837,
0.007591458,
0.0286197606,
-0.0181156229,
0.0324741229,
-0.0057025165,
-0.0127668083,
-0.0043988377,
0.0026781787,
-0.0142307403,
-0.0843247324,
-0.0071230428,
0.0442272164,
-0.0324634798,
-0.0471824184,
0.0422139727,
0.1002128571,
0.070171684,
-0.0293978639,
-0.0021214527,
-0.0101334881,
-0.0309924129,
0.0468400568,
-0.0096877655,
-0.0780929998,
-0.0224519465,
0.0271987543,
0.0275987461,
-0.0313220099,
-0.0653385594,
0.0146540264,
-0.0500576608,
0.026616605,
-0.0113971215,
0.0003092645,
-0.0322887301,
-0.054526791,
-0.0266431514,
-0.0297432207,
0.0393613279,
-0.0486972407,
0.0034183967,
0.0049692453,
-0.0013765083,
-0.0659239218,
-0.0439395569,
0.0315575264,
-0.0937990695,
0.0902967751,
0.0482305139,
0.0257343743,
-0.0463756137,
-0.0277711246,
0.0565371178,
0.0305039622,
-0.0348775722,
-0.0092571015,
0.0578022487,
-0.0012609477,
0.0168736503,
-0.0300317798,
-0.0070998622,
-0.0068514994,
-0.0222699083,
-0.0234609023,
0.0909083784,
-0.0080164988,
0.0142064411,
-0.0566064008,
-0.041143693,
0.003123194,
0.0752714202,
0.0225506239,
-0.0023756893,
0.0002803008,
-0.0366235338,
-0.0345342383,
0.0121196052,
0.0058958745,
0.0263922345,
-0.0240718331,
-0.030692596,
-0.072207436,
-0.0488026254,
-0.0079332227,
-0.0439123139,
0.0474398658,
0.0509344302,
0.019447865,
-0.0287091099,
-0.0846361294,
0.0253529139,
-0.0245679468,
0.032807529,
-0.0204770751,
-0.0221888367,
0.0340867341,
0.0552587025,
-0.0353579335,
0.0188941527,
-0.020805547,
-0.0344681256,
0.0031579533,
0.013048904,
0.0169846341,
-0.0143068023,
-0.0318058468,
-0.0583884493,
-0.011647854,
0.0597571433,
-0.0667037219,
-0.0258920677,
0.0316297077,
-0.0595783181,
-0.0076008532,
0.0051988983,
-0.0438506305,
0.0041316976,
0.0076857605,
0.0128382891,
0.0141791888,
-0.0058676102,
0.0580371432,
0.0721951053,
0.0037968061,
-0.0130952755,
-0.0176333431,
-0.008328734,
-0.0379434042,
0.0193101186,
-0.0541541651,
0.0162710454,
0.0235631093,
0.003246835,
-0.0078049758,
-0.0089461412,
0.0757965893,
-0.0427017249,
0.0106362775,
0.0216725711,
0.0241714548,
-0.0914865285,
0.0423422493,
-0.0079456987,
-0.0167067312,
-0.0047784331,
-0.013632522,
-0.0095687332,
0.0214296672,
-0.0232228134,
-0.0029907376,
0.0307039097,
0.0261368807,
-0.026425831,
0.0470550098,
-0.0063443868,
-0.0469731688,
-0.011527692,
0.0008890848,
0.0358380638,
-0.0115376245,
0.0030448681,
-0.053434357,
-0.015829891,
-0.0298918542,
0.008948151,
0.013857523,
0.0011459637,
0.0137279527,
0.0068760691,
-0.0455865227,
0.003151763,
0.0525338501,
-0.0107916584,
0.0425337963,
-0.049122598,
-0.0544527359,
-0.0252532326,
-0.0184597857,
0.0108908992,
-0.004734749,
-0.0690546706,
-0.0186093282,
-0.0544075705,
-0.0241940748,
-0.0372124128,
0.0141697023,
0.0088525843,
0.0167924538,
-0.0137807699,
0.0563076697,
0.0227170568,
-0.0246929377,
-0.0383405834,
-0.0407341011,
-0.0160632152,
-0.0407678038,
-0.0234778989,
-5.643322463e-33,
-0.0044798874,
-0.0369436182,
-0.0018678794,
0.0539319329,
0.0286213569,
-0.0274388324,
-0.0244055539,
-0.0310632251,
0.0108144544,
0.0280880406,
0.0055804388,
0.0083964802,
-0.003643885,
-0.0291228946,
0.0346281305,
-0.0030821955,
0.0407382511,
0.0392726809,
-0.0276823845,
-0.0041124295,
0.0050664889,
-0.0159805696,
0.0557448268,
-0.0843723491,
0.0833525658,
0.0161067955,
-0.0173626188,
0.0024806208,
-0.0152925067,
0.08144743,
0.0033831133,
0.0596580356,
0.0387651287,
-0.0486447588,
-0.0364740044,
-0.0001127415,
-0.0333879478,
0.0112544466,
0.0177981649,
0.0164401177,
0.0820188373,
-0.0503465086,
0.0441178493,
0.0212200824,
-0.058394026,
0.041661866,
0.079366006,
-0.0327966437,
-0.0395376272,
-0.0153028462,
-0.0354697891,
0.0381770991,
-0.0409119539,
0.0380907468,
0.0554069169,
-0.0179810282,
0.010970911,
0.0625069961,
-0.0282311663,
0.0366535522,
0.0215868317,
0.0059376592,
0.0450094156,
-0.032066945,
0.0125099821,
0.0642959327,
-0.0033722965,
0.022127917,
0.0705815032,
-0.0372491926,
-0.0058402871,
0.0318904072,
0.0297939181,
0.0458286963,
0.0638664216,
0.0056740651,
-0.0034978942,
0.0820682347,
-0.0803640783,
0.0341415517,
-0.0043267687,
0.0203634426,
-0.0454610288,
-0.0025557321,
-0.0282954331,
0.0025120233,
-0.0395743251,
0.0021087807,
0.0411543772,
-0.0277090035,
-0.0261387397,
0.0588206314,
0.0027522633,
-0.0477706268,
-0.0467212573,
-0.0104789147,
0.010776394,
-0.0014253916,
-0.0141901132,
-0.0087637771,
-0.042234242,
-0.0096932789,
0.023440389,
-0.0317664929,
0.033146061,
0.0145695144,
0.0290152784,
0.0038516801,
-0.0823754743,
0.036926426,
0.0246970393,
-0.0289009288,
-0.0254468601,
-0.0260540042,
-0.0104288226,
0.0195377432,
0.0167435613,
0.0049783904,
0.0392435603,
-0.0252693556,
-0.0651333109,
-0.0318852998,
0.01435667,
-0.0032971788,
0.0129904253,
-0.0226025749,
-0.0283184815,
-0.0239033643,
0.0836695805,
0.0147406319,
-0.0057742083,
-0.0325396359,
2.628e-7,
0.0586565249,
0.0498141199,
0.0098767485,
-0.0223594941,
-0.0211988408,
0.0564257614,
-0.016557876,
0.0311991796,
-0.0381237902,
-0.0104088495,
0.0285223648,
-0.0390491635,
0.0334030017,
0.0243180338,
-0.0291560795,
0.0081467452,
-0.0370586812,
-0.0240333341,
-0.0766972825,
-0.0105616516,
0.0134721883,
0.0501448289,
0.0164317098,
-0.0195177291,
-0.0177030321,
-0.0468735211,
-0.0181403402,
-0.0722872838,
0.0220091995,
0.0249124449,
0.0469451211,
-0.0088829556,
0.0313688703,
0.0182881393,
-0.0133628966,
-0.0069508567,
-0.0220087282,
0.0453344025,
-0.0349975824,
0.0359787419,
-0.0491073094,
-0.0732385516,
0.0264355782,
-0.0264922306,
0.0080174832,
0.0722027943,
-0.0224556401,
-0.0189780518,
-0.0459192879,
-0.0040941094,
0.033637356,
-0.0114422739,
-0.0226636268,
-0.0131354444,
0.0123560661,
0.0240424164,
-0.0351355225,
-0.0716074854,
0.0298285428,
0.00937411,
-0.0261725504,
-0.0319792479,
-0.0159416161,
0.0015974501,
0.0170584507,
-0.0374253765,
0.0596810617,
2.384192973e-34,
0.0176637303,
-0.0086535374,
0.0139728086,
0.0368650556,
0.0349976011,
0.0178974513,
-0.012287613,
0.0192957297,
-0.0364570767,
-0.0296728499,
0.0364369601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15780v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15780v3 | LLM-Rec: Personalized Recommendation via Prompting Large Language Models | 2023-07-24T18:47:38 | 2024-04-02T10:59:51 | Hanjia Lyu, Song Jiang, Hanqing Zeng, Yinglong Xia, Qifan Wang, Si Zhang, Ren Chen, Christopher Leung, Jiajie Tang, Jiebo Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Text-based recommendation holds a wide range of practical applications due to
its versatility, as textual descriptions can represent nearly any type of item.
However, directly employing the original item descriptions may not yield
optimal recommendation performance due to the lack of comprehensive information
to align with user preferences. Recent advances in large language models (LLMs)
have showcased their remarkable ability to harness commonsense knowledge and
reasoning. In this study, we introduce a novel approach, coined LLM-Rec, which
incorporates four distinct prompting strategies of text enrichment for
improving personalized text-based recommendations. Our empirical experiments
reveal that using LLM-augmented text significantly enhances recommendation
quality. Even basic MLP (Multi-Layer Perceptron) models achieve comparable or
even better results than complex content-based methods. Notably, the success of
LLM-Rec lies in its prompting strategies, which effectively tap into the
language model's comprehension of both general and specific item
characteristics. This highlights the importance of employing diverse prompts
and input augmentation techniques to boost the recommendation effectiveness of
LLMs. | [
0.0669751838,
0.007235379,
0.005606438,
0.0320158601,
-0.022008758,
-0.0197997373,
-0.0032332425,
0.0090829395,
0.0632814169,
-0.0363098271,
-0.0264291745,
0.0071764621,
0.0151036968,
0.036297068,
-0.0002590579,
-0.0251331888,
0.0018418971,
-0.0369884931,
-0.0182950106,
-0.0134424185,
0.0168926399,
0.0261628237,
0.0452742241,
0.0112127634,
0.0457855836,
-0.0046345964,
0.003550892,
-0.0015668976,
-0.0014222953,
-0.0325006954,
-0.0102432454,
0.0185215995,
0.0165482145,
-0.0441895351,
0.0000021342,
-0.0342951454,
0.0210895725,
-0.0218834523,
0.000591134,
-0.0041143144,
0.0628134236,
0.0450350642,
0.0406164788,
-0.010889763,
-0.0205022022,
0.0299210642,
0.0163000673,
0.1041962281,
0.0270439219,
0.0480615236,
-0.0137064932,
0.0125088505,
0.0023663847,
-0.0272041932,
0.0750602111,
-0.0009350435,
0.038233541,
-0.0411999747,
0.05416926,
0.0501429699,
0.01948159,
-0.0093945703,
0.0108722858,
-0.0192183312,
0.0720413551,
0.0522910692,
0.0053269439,
0.0027472123,
-0.0156621486,
0.1050884351,
0.0181789808,
-0.0142960344,
-0.0232672375,
0.0022788856,
0.0318160802,
0.0062349788,
-0.0378669873,
-0.0304059312,
0.0083162952,
0.0351222381,
0.0238568522,
0.0128211332,
0.0549152531,
0.037771441,
0.0214249324,
0.0896537602,
0.0075314888,
-0.0538302772,
0.0045294827,
0.024120871,
0.0157764126,
-0.0685031265,
0.0300093852,
0.0197421163,
-0.0225839149,
0.0053473576,
-0.0152214309,
0.0372661985,
0.0186890867,
-0.0430398807,
0.0418250263,
0.0243819896,
-0.0441482402,
0.0644440204,
-0.0181978364,
0.0033730972,
0.0002362825,
-0.0132711381,
-0.0670771822,
0.0145436414,
-0.0249944068,
-0.0012157969,
0.0145545816,
0.0542203374,
-0.0543612242,
-0.0270980857,
-0.0352297947,
0.0499782711,
0.028405942,
0.0565888584,
0.0149121108,
0.0489036813,
-0.0002092695,
-0.0002956533,
-0.0741260573,
-0.0039657899,
-0.0670352727,
0.0241481904,
0.0286689363,
0.0176972486,
0.0016398418,
0.022340931,
0.0200618729,
-0.0511518493,
0.0218410715,
-0.0030275302,
0.0045044213,
-0.0348545909,
-0.0503225364,
-0.0100487145,
-0.0041971011,
-0.0163557436,
-0.0466022417,
-0.0642258599,
0.03868277,
0.0118230311,
-0.0074053071,
0.0060943267,
0.0326362737,
0.0097562661,
-0.0459911227,
0.0615494028,
-0.0130739119,
-0.0196121354,
0.0205766372,
0.011447995,
0.0044988897,
-0.0000530422,
-0.0088692056,
0.0633157864,
0.0642294362,
0.0319987424,
0.0170329288,
0.018029606,
-0.02945536,
0.0320939347,
-0.0134691214,
0.0077228127,
-0.0398582667,
0.0234952196,
0.0351786427,
0.0396580994,
-0.056227468,
-0.0063380143,
0.0996767879,
0.0452369191,
0.0028009689,
0.0602251329,
0.027627239,
0.0345420763,
0.0026338799,
-0.0120160161,
-0.0155878402,
0.0451490693,
-0.0461223051,
-0.0292269066,
0.0471768752,
0.0102602933,
-0.0333288275,
-0.0438194536,
0.0069365571,
-0.0469623841,
0.0649173781,
0.0361302942,
0.0131519763,
-0.0158793759,
-0.0213909578,
-0.0126927467,
0.0550826825,
-0.0295571443,
0.0244334601,
-0.0062094405,
0.0760961622,
0.1425337046,
0.0445312038,
-0.020589903,
0.013782694,
-0.02094578,
-0.0282951407,
0.0129474625,
0.0404007956,
-0.0220054947,
0.0150780464,
-0.0519327484,
-0.0267073717,
-0.0062712971,
-0.0080059785,
0.0384654664,
-0.0060087251,
0.0051343446,
0.0103684869,
-0.015789235,
-0.038436614,
0.0087983273,
-0.0138656935,
-0.0408709608,
0.0603509583,
0.0090081245,
-0.0019586778,
0.0294094905,
0.0475058816,
-0.0078622354,
0.0080921538,
-0.0412149914,
-0.0470193811,
-0.0072974316,
-0.0272682104,
-0.0427300632,
0.0396930613,
0.0091923494,
0.0193467196,
0.0063974657,
0.0190685857,
-0.0355807431,
-0.020259412,
-0.0251585748,
0.0346240774,
-0.0460605249,
-0.0125417002,
0.0147340652,
-0.0005026914,
-0.035464,
0.067597121,
-0.0029363141,
0.0120899538,
0.0235839915,
-0.0203325227,
0.0176648069,
-0.0373822935,
-0.0591925867,
0.0069462308,
0.0385427736,
0.0145921186,
0.0218904316,
0.0185688585,
-0.0345629677,
-0.0126363337,
-0.0826296806,
-0.0229451731,
0.0222513825,
-0.0118619539,
-0.035288211,
0.0216503516,
0.016968349,
-0.0050180387,
-0.0806227699,
-0.0419215225,
-0.0074345064,
0.0289187618,
0.023548251,
0.0160944164,
-0.0047263331,
-0.0293048248,
0.000915396,
0.0074378946,
0.0464855023,
-0.0014574715,
0.0239449199,
-0.057446707,
-0.0389714874,
-0.0563415587,
-0.0268751215,
-0.0036265876,
0.0147439754,
-0.0355139785,
-0.0178325102,
0.0253201388,
0.0493301749,
-0.0108272275,
-0.0063494053,
0.0519234203,
0.0110737532,
-0.0628462583,
0.0067949868,
-0.0364846326,
0.046596542,
-0.0066829971,
-0.0286198072,
0.0070573413,
-0.0063234516,
-0.0263279229,
0.0026210651,
-0.0641768873,
0.0030612103,
0.0192871951,
0.0091433059,
-0.0565222874,
-0.0332369916,
-0.015961783,
0.0728497505,
-0.0168432985,
-0.0323034041,
0.098696515,
-0.0262970831,
-0.00434499,
-0.0376933776,
-0.034528967,
-0.0538381785,
-0.003692199,
-0.0177990552,
0.0244174525,
-0.038527444,
-0.0048402427,
0.0009342878,
0.0062466897,
0.0184835792,
-0.0476802476,
0.0502170809,
0.0149286669,
-0.0061943624,
0.0320664644,
-0.0649124458,
-0.0435243137,
-0.082058385,
0.0145473648,
-0.0134596219,
-0.0125919823,
-0.0082600508,
-0.0431749038,
-0.0173541345,
0.0051275445,
0.0347062573,
-0.018893417,
-0.0255970508,
0.0074650217,
0.0235698223,
0.0407066569,
-0.0303139351,
0.0039436384,
-0.0141744064,
0.0209720749,
0.0310206302,
-0.0199945383,
-0.0504706502,
-0.0087773837,
0.0281249117,
0.0642797649,
-0.031596981,
-0.0334094167,
0.0538225025,
0.0282669831,
-0.0053545684,
-0.0160850547,
0.084903039,
0.0371734276,
-0.1179138273,
0.0109937256,
-0.0251203477,
0.005384733,
0.0231500845,
0.0519076772,
-0.0565522984,
-0.0167501438,
0.0044071483,
0.0171578825,
0.0135051152,
-0.034803614,
-0.008260115,
-0.1034020111,
0.0161542613,
-0.0008653338,
-0.0133461477,
-0.0176914185,
-0.0649667904,
-0.0171041079,
0.0009762622,
-0.0008091728,
-0.0021392512,
0.0029649769,
-0.0120985107,
-0.0177476946,
-0.0003693757,
-0.0467281193,
0.0230525304,
-0.0334954187,
0.0423721448,
0.0743739754,
0.0257374737,
-0.0161175039,
-0.0693219304,
-0.014019249,
-0.0152743813,
-0.0110906279,
-0.0079049673,
0.0160915703,
-0.0311359894,
0.0339000337,
-0.0345579945,
0.0327252932,
-0.0257069059,
-0.0465387441,
0.0022652459,
0.0672939718,
-0.0060529886,
0.0038147403,
-0.0325082839,
0.0128473928,
0.034977071,
0.0879874974,
0.0143701276,
-0.0651321486,
0.0303346869,
-0.0846457258,
-0.0562835261,
-0.0006157894,
-0.0011208639,
0.0094135748,
-0.0012991757,
0.0061854734,
-0.0609609671,
-0.0406659208,
0.0119473403,
-0.0097992131,
0.0299216043,
0.0525157861,
-0.0348247811,
-0.0173237082,
0.0256899819,
0.0469467528,
-0.0156286508,
0.0077180746,
-0.0482218899,
0.0020755681,
0.0055110771,
-0.1208328977,
0.0024822035,
-0.012024628,
-0.0500564165,
-0.0415274948,
-0.0687093064,
0.048711367,
0.0126274433,
0.0620191246,
-0.0476137362,
-0.1075735688,
0.0349770486,
0.0277375001,
-0.0178996734,
0.0009305958,
-0.0097321691,
0.0501775406,
0.0353835113,
0.0351687111,
-0.0567799658,
0.0047001224,
-0.0098769544,
0.0061757634,
-0.000856271,
-0.0535378978,
0.0210764725,
0.026590826,
0.0078745242,
-0.0123435752,
0.0777530372,
-0.0295085497,
0.0071772379,
-0.0010127565,
-0.0564036705,
-0.0335241072,
0.0025545973,
0.0637425855,
-0.017011866,
-0.0255614296,
-0.0150420917,
-0.0222808458,
0.0488914996,
-0.04014384,
-0.0006276068,
-0.0319742635,
-0.0532943718,
0.0279806405,
0.0181636084,
-0.0138435783,
0.006281293,
-0.0048277755,
0.0234097056,
-0.0194439664,
0.0540153049,
0.0170441475,
-0.0458972678,
-0.0372606218,
0.0358958766,
-0.0200849194,
-0.01712122,
0.0153045524,
0.0435974076,
0.0159853399,
-0.0501805581,
0.0237860661,
-0.0297720842,
-0.0170346275,
-0.0185811035,
0.00465122,
0.0009147147,
-0.0358375646,
0.0325453356,
0.0313786641,
-0.0313817263,
0.0324874446,
0.0574606135,
-0.0512660481,
-0.008974174,
0.0187040977,
-0.0344669633,
-0.0420416668,
0.0078798225,
0.0131446477,
0.0861909389,
-0.0642980561,
0.0090038907,
-0.0268347859,
-0.0247489195,
0.0407212228,
-0.0305320527,
0.0082313297,
-0.0207996257,
0.0122886468,
0.0658454895,
0.0026671889,
0.0064010741,
-0.0461368747,
-0.0207411498,
-0.0346808806,
-0.0244718641,
-0.037523251,
-6.556622432e-33,
0.0270428788,
-0.0229698773,
0.0104654105,
0.0219100323,
0.0054200576,
-0.0040372908,
-0.0069663017,
0.0054377182,
0.0385928191,
0.0088719688,
-0.024080649,
-0.0094721122,
-0.0034181497,
0.0244369917,
0.0156834219,
-0.0329018533,
0.045650918,
0.050778605,
-0.0356855318,
0.0077124937,
0.0197372716,
0.0355802588,
0.012485154,
-0.0297087543,
0.0597124323,
-0.039786417,
-0.0216016024,
0.0078774048,
0.0087149926,
0.0913112611,
-0.0284936018,
0.0635601059,
0.0181451887,
-0.0154921077,
0.0242417175,
0.0380741656,
-0.061999552,
-0.0178684089,
0.0652766824,
-0.0245359335,
-0.0427012295,
-0.0401379392,
-0.0018611785,
0.004947606,
-0.0078196097,
0.0412304252,
0.0402263589,
-0.0506292321,
-0.0664852113,
-0.0163576901,
0.0162995085,
0.017373465,
0.0024838829,
0.0006891903,
0.0115720406,
0.060361553,
-0.040824566,
0.0968283415,
-0.0605154671,
0.0517625548,
-0.0077580749,
0.0170290451,
-0.0112339314,
-0.0350154862,
-0.0333674289,
0.029956704,
-0.0084122466,
-0.0010151395,
-0.0354489572,
0.0180161968,
-0.0213120785,
0.0176758636,
0.0230455715,
0.0628387854,
0.0201091412,
-0.0008200741,
-0.0231413934,
0.0687557384,
0.0330895446,
-0.0250075962,
0.0481593162,
0.0205930043,
-0.0416848622,
-0.0403464586,
-0.0330474153,
-0.0293176454,
-0.0709791631,
-0.033589527,
0.0069759348,
0.037996497,
-0.0236431845,
0.0027649014,
-0.0023038846,
-0.0249073915,
-0.0425389931,
0.0049850806,
-0.0343923047,
-0.0230752341,
0.0137666296,
0.0024266446,
-0.0565778911,
0.0033886258,
-0.0019478479,
-0.0876127407,
-0.0410957523,
0.019850567,
0.0613437444,
0.003533904,
-0.0354048982,
0.0094488906,
0.0162094142,
-0.0190389305,
0.008901773,
0.0430631377,
0.0354424864,
0.0187286269,
-0.0241041724,
0.1002384275,
0.0058330074,
0.012297051,
-0.0332760625,
-0.0734779984,
0.0261114035,
-0.0109567074,
-0.0141073884,
-0.0085723465,
-0.030758338,
0.0035759693,
0.049021963,
-0.0551392511,
-0.0117150657,
0.0184486266,
2.821e-7,
-0.0302909166,
0.0547771417,
-0.0289965104,
-0.0202280954,
0.0021207002,
0.0454707779,
0.0073890886,
0.0336718298,
0.0182992667,
0.0142043643,
0.0244084727,
0.0281458069,
0.0313434042,
0.0046856566,
-0.0788378939,
0.000172361,
-0.053813722,
-0.0043129358,
-0.0778869838,
-0.0166402552,
0.0219034888,
0.0755364597,
0.069699198,
-0.0057486575,
0.0091971178,
-0.0317372791,
0.071461156,
-0.0856435969,
-0.042049937,
-0.0212250445,
0.0584580712,
0.0120380521,
-0.0186707415,
-0.0023335109,
-0.0121275,
0.0299688987,
0.0154945105,
0.0640807003,
0.0006080119,
-0.0292799342,
-0.0140315229,
-0.0023958338,
0.0039144778,
-0.0498442687,
0.0826722756,
0.0069649136,
-0.0005610241,
-0.0194450151,
-0.0314217582,
-0.0130626811,
0.0519493334,
-0.059312813,
-0.0220839959,
-0.0059990766,
0.0059662224,
-0.0058752354,
-0.0120177418,
-0.0680593997,
-0.0180945173,
-0.0101208398,
-0.0155442255,
-0.04261465,
-0.053103365,
0.0253105536,
0.0054617552,
-0.0968306959,
0.0226967335,
2.54462132e-34,
0.0254464652,
0.0135731213,
-0.0095208688,
0.0143204099,
0.0249797441,
0.0055087898,
-0.0240517426,
0.0198955089,
0.0309499111,
-0.0863157734,
-0.0091051711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12981v1 | 3D-LLM: Injecting the 3D World into Large Language Models | 2023-07-24T17:59:02 | 2023-07-24T17:59:02 | Yining Hong, Haoyu Zhen, Peihao Chen, Shuhong Zheng, Yilun Du, Zhenfang Chen, Chuang Gan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | Large language models (LLMs) and Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have been
proven to excel at multiple tasks, such as commonsense reasoning. Powerful as
these models can be, they are not grounded in the 3D physical world, which
involves richer concepts such as spatial relationships, affordances, physics,
layout, and so on. In this work, we propose to inject the 3D world into large
language models and introduce a whole new family of 3D-LLMs. Specifically,
3D-LLMs can take 3D point clouds and their features as input and perform a
diverse set of 3D-related tasks, including captioning, dense captioning, 3D
question answering, task decomposition, 3D grounding, 3D-assisted dialog,
navigation, and so on. Using three types of prompting mechanisms that we
design, we are able to collect over 300k 3D-language data covering these tasks.
To efficiently train 3D-LLMs, we first utilize a 3D feature extractor that
obtains 3D features from rendered multi- view images. Then, we use 2D VLMs as
our backbones to train our 3D-LLMs. By introducing a 3D localization mechanism,
3D-LLMs can better capture 3D spatial information. Experiments on ScanQA show
that our model outperforms state-of-the-art baselines by a large margin (e.g.,
the BLEU-1 score surpasses state-of-the-art score by 9%). Furthermore,
experiments on our held-in datasets for 3D captioning, task composition, and
3D-assisted dialogue show that our model outperforms 2D VLMs. Qualitative
examples also show that our model could perform more tasks beyond the scope of
existing LLMs and VLMs. Project Page: : https://vis-www.cs.umass.edu/3dllm/. | [
0.030319944,
0.0542011149,
0.0364925005,
0.0542548262,
-0.0135111809,
0.0204655249,
0.0070283031,
-0.0460374877,
0.0004829556,
-0.0634171292,
-0.037956275,
0.0006561742,
0.0393720791,
0.0626608804,
0.0409436598,
-0.0668916926,
0.0084433006,
-0.0706463084,
-0.0218888614,
-0.005279277,
-0.0093521243,
0.04549798,
-0.025637703,
0.0310503729,
0.014862136,
0.005708592,
-0.0199980121,
-0.0016999728,
0.0119382329,
-0.060995739,
-0.0118706711,
0.0385600962,
0.0944191366,
-0.0400207452,
0.0000018673,
-0.0137112336,
0.0011171617,
-0.0171187948,
0.0172943994,
-0.0066956799,
-0.0184662174,
-0.0273370836,
0.004952034,
0.0022134904,
-0.0365374275,
0.0191131681,
0.038436655,
0.071137473,
0.0570443682,
0.0251293406,
-0.017358413,
-0.0214223042,
-0.005279623,
-0.0028241556,
0.0621261559,
-0.0088794697,
-0.0178203061,
0.0727054477,
0.0449065343,
0.0383831486,
-0.0085648289,
0.0366230682,
0.02251832,
0.0073134494,
0.0030590629,
0.0438225605,
-0.0086803474,
-0.0139154438,
-0.0320825502,
0.1169762611,
0.020972617,
0.0092198979,
0.006558307,
0.017605532,
0.0283215791,
-0.0133094108,
-0.0496750474,
0.0138731208,
0.0062644016,
-0.0128862802,
-0.0263950303,
0.0039493898,
-0.0074438383,
0.0022247233,
-0.01192284,
0.0187665168,
0.0148199191,
0.0153557193,
-0.0198510364,
0.0240975041,
0.0067194402,
-0.0622585639,
-0.0100111905,
0.0167642143,
0.0028600011,
0.0189792272,
-0.0465958789,
0.0403027609,
-0.0258853175,
-0.0398590863,
0.0453906134,
0.0122739132,
-0.0406784192,
0.083322823,
-0.0218741335,
0.0510738231,
-0.0053291135,
0.0391390733,
-0.0231332779,
0.0129370317,
-0.0021181277,
0.005679816,
-0.0290642157,
0.0279048271,
-0.0729942918,
-0.0384884514,
0.0183508731,
0.0265955459,
-0.0084805284,
0.0118058706,
0.0055789668,
0.0779782236,
-0.011257533,
-0.0153892543,
-0.0019256043,
0.032745719,
-0.0218748599,
0.0380040295,
-0.0354922414,
-0.0489565805,
-0.0179165006,
0.0184251219,
0.0523115844,
-0.0041111023,
0.015446079,
0.0767927989,
-0.0326027945,
-0.05411838,
0.0415317677,
-0.0276011042,
-0.0353405736,
-0.0324775763,
0.0384141915,
-0.0671897605,
0.0089615416,
-0.0223977361,
-0.0236093216,
-0.0326849408,
0.0238829572,
0.0048159943,
0.003612878,
0.0856419206,
0.0046698265,
-0.0106551079,
0.046137616,
0.0219506454,
-0.0010038461,
0.0197897572,
0.0446623191,
0.0109805828,
0.0043797945,
0.0126914475,
0.0187726896,
0.0583965629,
0.003957991,
0.0307224672,
-0.0345112011,
-0.0059141172,
-0.0252738539,
0.0449855663,
0.0054009808,
0.0072518163,
-0.0264198538,
0.012392899,
0.0621140786,
0.054275509,
-0.0798903182,
-0.0116470503,
0.0260793474,
0.0012971828,
-0.0020123781,
-0.0300113279,
-0.0579736829,
0.0542253815,
-0.0060235332,
-0.0029603518,
-0.0296128504,
0.0255181883,
-0.034542609,
-0.0476958267,
-0.0127336588,
0.011509032,
0.0268701725,
0.0111253634,
0.0475400984,
0.0198660623,
-0.0327488407,
0.0716664642,
-0.0112627177,
-0.0623157062,
-0.015661357,
0.0097534703,
0.0444232263,
0.0329502895,
-0.0118682301,
-0.0001730684,
-0.0570594817,
-0.0111399097,
0.0429648571,
0.0353609584,
0.0220429022,
-0.017528221,
0.0258802604,
-0.0279315822,
-0.0489075705,
-0.0055029597,
-0.0063478788,
0.0369964615,
0.0570091195,
-0.0020526373,
0.0270320512,
-0.0625591129,
0.0233598743,
0.0115536023,
-0.0293250866,
0.0010168952,
-0.0618842058,
0.0115472553,
0.0085574714,
0.0145398267,
0.0206246153,
-0.0311401002,
0.0221683159,
-0.0472939834,
-0.0101981079,
0.0580451936,
-0.0692904517,
-0.0583115742,
0.0237423908,
-0.0108172409,
-0.031588912,
0.0092470394,
-0.0401940644,
-0.0183491893,
0.0075084926,
-0.0346854664,
-0.0010915634,
-0.0027242866,
-0.0240440425,
0.0443826653,
0.0035765171,
-0.0462545529,
0.0610860996,
-0.0694176033,
-0.0125344228,
0.0076239705,
-0.0237215478,
0.002998767,
0.006714338,
0.0067607244,
-0.0059691942,
-0.0122689782,
0.0209513698,
0.0211056005,
0.047258798,
-0.0425128751,
0.0063522616,
-0.0452579856,
-0.0343179442,
-0.0065586078,
-0.0002564528,
-0.0140401917,
-0.010234612,
-0.02399645,
-0.0359304994,
-0.046288427,
0.0111868232,
0.0268859696,
-0.0158691797,
0.0306848437,
-0.0174122863,
-0.0207410194,
-0.0107278181,
0.0341741554,
0.0049191425,
0.0503309183,
0.0506651625,
-0.0388511047,
-0.0287838299,
0.0054503232,
-0.071536839,
0.0342822745,
-0.0112072844,
-0.0237332806,
0.047395803,
-0.0607637726,
0.011821988,
0.0612088367,
-0.0532527752,
-0.0033504483,
0.0262451749,
-0.0195002034,
-0.0789051801,
0.0276464373,
-0.0129473787,
0.0005289688,
-0.0384339318,
-0.0197502002,
0.0027157783,
0.0363235436,
0.0048899227,
0.048149135,
-0.0385882854,
0.0532312021,
0.0232729521,
-0.0540556535,
-0.0283631869,
0.0372373722,
-0.0126971761,
0.0323838405,
-0.0296077523,
-0.0240311418,
-0.0053211376,
-0.0783804134,
-0.0086284215,
0.0013186444,
0.0289015863,
-0.0137984473,
0.0843311325,
-0.0169987064,
0.0234895777,
-0.023088051,
-0.01950486,
-0.0105466228,
-0.0052632522,
0.0053967508,
0.0014182813,
0.0205941461,
-0.0930929631,
0.0183675513,
-0.0138733191,
-0.0579637326,
0.0120063554,
0.01552926,
-0.0757886171,
-0.0192674957,
-0.079360351,
-0.0383047871,
-0.0098221917,
0.0250753481,
0.0269414429,
0.0566092245,
-0.0232207496,
-0.018670572,
-0.0404113121,
0.0007534087,
0.0403533801,
0.1083143428,
-0.045168452,
-0.0046709836,
-0.0092444047,
0.0545025095,
-0.0092207575,
-0.0081728045,
-0.0462408699,
0.066789411,
0.060191799,
0.0478900485,
-0.0181571878,
-0.0008041945,
0.0739046186,
-0.0548948236,
-0.0226146281,
0.0760767907,
0.0140657136,
0.0078934813,
-0.0287846383,
-0.0156952552,
0.0229024757,
0.0245213155,
-0.0419009626,
-0.0639927015,
-0.0623482578,
-0.0174807105,
-0.0336855501,
0.0654543638,
-0.0253549647,
0.0084475894,
-0.1082040742,
0.0348487571,
-0.0022996778,
-0.0367292501,
-0.0843442008,
0.0133686354,
0.030559849,
0.007484837,
-0.0372848846,
-0.0482798107,
0.0104175191,
0.0136428708,
0.0056369826,
0.0332285948,
-0.0314002931,
0.0346273817,
-0.0230576918,
0.0007778368,
0.0169230327,
0.0384666286,
-0.0194418747,
-0.0707865208,
-0.010026441,
0.04739061,
0.0018839246,
-0.0130551709,
0.0018055318,
-0.0200997144,
-0.026048867,
0.0039591268,
0.049749922,
-0.0492009707,
-0.0355067812,
-0.0138653424,
0.0589252263,
-0.0423297286,
0.041605074,
-0.0135055473,
0.039270591,
0.010250669,
0.0738904402,
0.0057490421,
-0.0129351709,
-0.0190806612,
-0.0361465067,
-0.0415479131,
-0.0143009722,
-0.0268364009,
-0.0034484011,
0.0274559911,
0.020134015,
-0.0945591107,
0.0134904748,
0.0801639259,
0.0529512726,
0.0010107942,
-0.0154818445,
-0.0073546348,
0.0271587111,
-0.0513421781,
0.0288240612,
-0.0502544008,
0.0049741054,
-0.0117051369,
0.0447002687,
0.0349073,
-0.0532106832,
-0.0334320627,
-0.0066143377,
-0.0589687079,
-0.0207153168,
-0.0336675495,
0.0742586181,
0.0066719349,
0.049168855,
0.0002705842,
-0.0060386704,
0.0429672562,
-0.0001531215,
-0.0056726644,
0.0375753306,
0.0406001247,
0.0182024129,
-0.0084687918,
0.0091920421,
-0.0342522152,
0.0114537319,
-0.0052234153,
-0.0066369916,
-0.0397393033,
-0.0710028037,
-0.0314292423,
-0.0087793153,
0.0486621708,
0.0012979083,
0.0101159392,
-0.0486703478,
0.0084657418,
-0.0081088785,
-0.0067917579,
-0.0941108242,
0.0416599959,
0.0204832293,
-0.0000457749,
0.0102528874,
0.028238317,
0.0095377611,
0.0553604625,
-0.0351941362,
0.0065289731,
0.0513051599,
-0.0541782714,
0.0140479608,
0.0061714551,
-0.0062425318,
0.0615071394,
-0.0638117492,
0.045211032,
-0.0275588203,
0.0479153693,
0.0125956032,
-0.0417471863,
-0.0074792365,
0.0764456242,
-0.036304187,
-0.0660648495,
-0.0010773174,
0.0579386428,
0.0534570627,
0.0342405699,
0.0355994776,
-0.0198427811,
-0.0104214028,
0.0258793887,
0.0403916091,
0.0302380305,
-0.0523753427,
0.0695594177,
0.0174861625,
-0.0169759113,
-0.0137314899,
0.0068807579,
0.0178633705,
0.0100014592,
0.0366826504,
-0.0221623834,
-0.0392929129,
-0.0209486783,
0.0055204262,
0.0148355328,
0.0108358497,
0.0586829185,
-0.0030650988,
-0.0382567532,
-0.0123785352,
0.0495184362,
-0.0582875088,
0.0064857588,
0.0560747534,
0.0641209185,
-0.0119814882,
-0.0210903883,
-0.0109215574,
0.0125551354,
-0.0451325737,
-0.015345633,
0.0195069853,
-5.108259475e-33,
-0.0388491638,
-0.0455396175,
0.0254772604,
-0.0118434448,
-0.0028469418,
0.0055385162,
-0.0615947247,
0.0167377386,
-0.0249855202,
-0.0002921345,
0.0286460556,
-0.0115698036,
0.0014244806,
0.037935514,
-0.0190442316,
-0.0232809857,
0.0243251771,
0.0084675038,
-0.0351960845,
0.0127466898,
0.0268169604,
-0.0058604861,
0.0849151388,
-0.0265874937,
0.001240689,
-0.0134267258,
-0.0375723056,
0.0293532498,
-0.0121764727,
0.0511145256,
-0.0361282527,
-0.0010065637,
0.0081071928,
-0.0318093225,
-0.0196792521,
0.0412102453,
-0.0962987468,
-0.0181117095,
0.006654866,
0.0174838565,
-0.0422122516,
0.0139246285,
-0.0141411433,
-0.0118366564,
0.0014478947,
-0.0494416431,
0.0278471317,
-0.0214657187,
-0.035142336,
-0.0137653202,
-0.0179748964,
0.017513575,
-0.0156593043,
-0.0582123287,
0.0105392849,
0.0404875539,
0.0529837422,
0.0010125244,
-0.0159166623,
0.0121743465,
-0.026261393,
0.0000434442,
0.0698401183,
0.0350100771,
-0.0055712713,
0.090753682,
-0.0111358678,
-0.0302514508,
-0.0387321301,
-0.0002505773,
0.0454978421,
0.0755511671,
0.0426082835,
0.0728294253,
-0.0232971907,
0.057960324,
-0.0183067862,
0.0442666747,
-0.1097572893,
0.0575595759,
0.012965044,
-0.0285717603,
-0.0198344178,
0.0037516903,
-0.0405553468,
-0.0125689395,
0.0027997142,
0.0316457227,
0.0451977365,
0.016192548,
-0.0231174622,
-0.0044239131,
0.0615910701,
-0.0132666063,
-0.0023393861,
0.0835387781,
-0.0190355498,
0.0367326364,
-0.0110127218,
0.0110599473,
-0.0376521759,
-0.009061452,
0.000409749,
-0.0059093768,
0.0173084307,
0.0065818564,
0.0070088389,
0.0265132412,
-0.0143709704,
-0.011825935,
-0.0544554703,
0.0140334619,
-0.0233453531,
0.0849124938,
0.062849693,
0.0087100584,
-0.0491629429,
0.0218445789,
-0.0416170135,
-0.0128697874,
-0.0355713814,
-0.0223932806,
-0.0439227223,
0.0300965104,
-0.0459679998,
0.0113924854,
-0.0599096492,
-0.041795861,
0.0340285152,
-0.0647669882,
-0.0129944161,
0.0381276719,
2.453e-7,
0.0013718267,
0.0250059869,
0.0125651453,
0.0113730002,
-0.0228022765,
0.0691347569,
0.0098432116,
0.0554021336,
-0.000873712,
-0.0444247685,
0.0065923445,
0.0616897643,
0.0110359369,
0.0019133637,
-0.1236497983,
0.0377462283,
-0.0401215814,
-0.0022828174,
-0.0436830744,
0.019221114,
0.0595862642,
0.0483758226,
-0.0269423854,
-0.014707203,
-0.0026630023,
-0.0334111936,
0.0163817722,
-0.0477530397,
-0.0035782687,
0.0006248053,
0.0629470199,
0.0301871002,
-0.0142834457,
-0.0279482231,
-0.0175127368,
0.0111400848,
0.0330766775,
0.0602572747,
0.0010293769,
-0.0175444614,
-0.0460705198,
-0.0267836042,
-0.0080806762,
-0.0359236784,
0.0761579946,
-0.0473418608,
0.0059199873,
-0.0279551782,
0.0065739262,
-0.042911876,
0.0082357451,
-0.0115189459,
0.0180696994,
-0.0198498759,
0.0171071477,
-0.042001009,
-0.0161945056,
-0.0813526735,
-0.030809436,
-0.0072052488,
-0.0115139559,
-0.0246537272,
-0.0290222801,
-0.0633257329,
-0.0144625464,
-0.0019460552,
-0.0256501958,
1.812316923e-34,
-0.0159196686,
0.0078309132,
0.0117770694,
0.0031172985,
0.0239303242,
0.0080279037,
0.0470526069,
-0.0139691131,
-0.0113717383,
-0.060364347,
0.0210379884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12976v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12976v2 | Evaluating the Ripple Effects of Knowledge Editing in Language Models | 2023-07-24T17:52:46 | 2023-12-20T11:52:41 | Roi Cohen, Eden Biran, Ori Yoran, Amir Globerson, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modern language models capture a large body of factual knowledge. However,
some facts can be incorrectly induced or become obsolete over time, resulting
in factually incorrect generations. This has led to the development of various
editing methods that allow updating facts encoded by the model. Evaluation of
these methods has primarily focused on testing whether an individual fact has
been successfully injected, and if similar predictions for other subjects have
not changed. Here we argue that such evaluation is limited, since injecting one
fact (e.g. ``Jack Depp is the son of Johnny Depp'') introduces a ``ripple
effect'' in the form of additional facts that the model needs to update
(e.g.``Jack Depp is the sibling of Lily-Rose Depp''). To address this issue, we
propose a novel set of evaluation criteria that consider the implications of an
edit on related facts. Using these criteria, we then construct RippleEdits, a
diagnostic benchmark of 5K factual edits, capturing a variety of types of
ripple effects. We evaluate prominent editing methods on RippleEdits, showing
that current methods fail to introduce consistent changes in the model's
knowledge. In addition, we find that a simple in-context editing baseline
obtains the best scores on our benchmark, suggesting a promising research
direction for model editing. | [
0.0544585139,
0.0384463929,
-0.0401968695,
0.0193049964,
-0.0563363843,
-0.0115353251,
-0.0115334,
0.0177599415,
-0.0260039382,
-0.0507216416,
0.0507468097,
-0.0310426205,
0.0385148227,
0.0396197848,
0.0021921687,
-0.0419325046,
0.0818298534,
-0.0201378372,
0.0092287892,
-0.021294402,
-0.016888937,
-0.0215259213,
0.02325112,
0.025961725,
-0.026604889,
-0.0303418376,
-0.0158719551,
0.0097419061,
0.0274139233,
0.0337895602,
-0.0156023884,
0.0952045321,
-0.0160598215,
0.0601778962,
0.0000021422,
-0.0517641343,
-0.0072091375,
0.0242093429,
-0.0459586941,
0.0594152287,
0.036494296,
0.0399455316,
-0.0261655208,
-0.0013415029,
-0.015479791,
0.0237911977,
0.0495284498,
-0.0186859686,
0.0503474325,
0.04208,
-0.0000987578,
0.0069210171,
0.0093613975,
-0.0165138096,
0.0158152599,
-0.0181560107,
0.0500771664,
0.013612425,
-0.0433942378,
0.0294573717,
-0.0393002629,
0.0607974641,
-0.000960628,
-0.0629743114,
0.0632341579,
0.0110176587,
-0.0181421172,
-0.0034924152,
0.0145019162,
0.0204274226,
0.0476148948,
-0.0380754136,
-0.0247757584,
-0.0122151747,
0.0332839824,
0.045830816,
-0.0062093623,
-0.019327838,
0.0069654356,
-0.0150086153,
0.0034732656,
-0.0743209124,
0.0452707596,
0.0094185872,
0.02254376,
0.0650480837,
0.0296473652,
-0.0465581603,
-0.0642544702,
-0.0085037425,
0.0273193289,
-0.111411266,
-0.014044622,
-0.0057437583,
-0.0065609147,
0.0218697246,
-0.0361032337,
0.0130901765,
0.0231708437,
-0.0697801039,
0.0119198887,
0.0290852245,
-0.0191609617,
0.0592878982,
-0.0018425002,
0.0454105809,
0.0216856916,
-0.016592171,
0.0045004021,
0.043711096,
-0.0689191744,
-0.0205575768,
-0.0147280907,
0.0351762287,
-0.0171011854,
0.032363791,
-0.0438307412,
0.002465314,
-0.0270160288,
0.0057186303,
-0.0318592153,
0.0077746506,
-0.0101035461,
-0.010378818,
-0.0412598476,
0.0549615845,
-0.016126439,
0.004656639,
-0.0033771112,
-0.0298723448,
0.0017987877,
-0.0628264099,
0.0073067192,
0.0052253562,
0.0113027338,
0.017813975,
0.0053819288,
-0.0135636907,
-0.0124300029,
-0.0582663566,
-0.0356593728,
-0.0454233661,
-0.0572627224,
-0.073658064,
0.0011443151,
-0.0128228776,
-0.0317172483,
-0.0626781732,
-0.0064341924,
-0.0043090307,
-0.0633561984,
0.0355250873,
-0.0305052213,
0.0537251011,
0.0196480304,
0.0092473645,
-0.0291088223,
0.0856015757,
0.0476023369,
-0.0340426192,
0.0609532744,
0.005816217,
0.0119531872,
0.0464707576,
-0.0087587889,
0.0248477515,
-0.0105111906,
-0.0097357072,
-0.0081691481,
0.0227020681,
-0.0005002197,
0.0359906107,
-0.013135029,
0.0049792523,
0.0912424102,
-0.0063731577,
-0.0323909111,
0.0631015226,
0.0346920714,
-0.0531844832,
0.0270632971,
0.0384792872,
-0.0447009578,
-0.0147127714,
-0.0084192296,
0.0126950229,
-0.0279052667,
0.0152342413,
0.0057909968,
-0.0257928483,
-0.0122104594,
0.0480635054,
0.0081116371,
-0.0105050141,
0.0072004306,
0.0321452543,
-0.009715816,
0.0541784018,
0.0297562871,
-0.0530627146,
0.0116270417,
-0.0474636778,
-0.0057730102,
0.0949514955,
0.0728166923,
-0.0135288052,
-0.0532264374,
-0.0046846434,
0.0009603717,
0.0112994015,
0.0726542398,
-0.0230264254,
0.0029028875,
0.0142825777,
-0.0080390694,
-0.007821775,
0.0594905093,
0.0237651411,
0.0326523744,
-0.0035427266,
-0.003017422,
-0.0464994945,
-0.0252707694,
0.0039079585,
-0.046524778,
0.0089747533,
-0.0279329009,
-0.0115915518,
-0.0246213917,
0.02126812,
-0.0309967976,
-0.012250673,
-0.0094004413,
0.0252176058,
-0.0309854746,
0.0375194773,
0.0088115921,
0.0117804678,
0.0594498739,
-0.0348094627,
-0.0408706069,
0.0160336848,
-0.0137010347,
-0.0113693411,
0.0150915012,
-0.0258667003,
0.0909991562,
-0.0122416737,
0.0506681986,
-0.0751158521,
-0.0174860284,
0.000856803,
0.0626366064,
-0.0005864819,
0.0083964793,
0.0033771698,
0.0026544235,
-0.036809396,
-0.0264061112,
-0.0205090679,
-0.0051108133,
0.0041367835,
-0.0242022704,
0.021718191,
-0.0149130197,
-0.0445006788,
-0.0052621067,
-0.0763827413,
-0.0151366312,
-0.0056299027,
0.0145888738,
0.0342600681,
0.021980647,
-0.0209006537,
0.0055713402,
0.0047137225,
-0.0042280219,
-0.0206075497,
0.0502921864,
0.0305370167,
0.0102651399,
-0.0350841321,
-0.0489142351,
0.0119833648,
-0.0305824969,
0.0514746793,
0.0414753035,
-0.0068410188,
-0.0397524722,
0.0107729137,
-0.0922191814,
-0.0102706021,
0.004837269,
-0.0252795927,
-0.014054656,
0.0299061053,
0.1214046106,
0.0208073556,
-0.0087127741,
0.0101652239,
0.0434337296,
-0.041081503,
-0.0102979373,
-0.0076592402,
-0.0062618563,
-0.0000443653,
-0.0162176881,
-0.0596239008,
-0.0191351138,
0.0260641612,
-0.0063699922,
-0.0484704301,
-0.0353022292,
0.0489540026,
-0.0335746035,
-0.0535347275,
-0.029531274,
-0.0402865224,
-0.0372957736,
0.0286460351,
-0.0445127711,
-0.0618046299,
0.0548095107,
-0.0133414352,
0.0258755814,
-0.0197932255,
0.0021290639,
0.001749594,
0.064213708,
-0.0096707158,
0.0285556298,
0.0169456862,
0.009202959,
-0.0587944277,
0.005577934,
0.0651023388,
-0.0342646502,
0.0435488708,
-0.0767679513,
0.0125943962,
0.0258221738,
-0.0234801546,
-0.0355680175,
-0.0690064654,
-0.0205598623,
0.0156047968,
0.0340823904,
-0.0515103824,
0.0294233579,
-0.0196382459,
0.0329681523,
0.0424494632,
-0.0208913088,
-0.0078437664,
-0.0137892393,
-0.0092303362,
0.0362028219,
-0.006665092,
0.0519847944,
-0.018296333,
0.0459009558,
0.0325865857,
0.0114077171,
-0.0297547933,
-0.0187272429,
-0.012623609,
-0.0289600492,
-0.0618403219,
-0.0248284359,
0.0107254675,
0.0630539283,
-0.0726526901,
-0.0293672811,
0.0946777463,
0.0429029688,
-0.0133732688,
0.0377163142,
-0.0503938496,
0.0139322178,
0.043293409,
0.0149895474,
-0.0699122176,
-0.0054961713,
0.0502066724,
-0.0261001065,
-0.0295232348,
-0.0565908365,
-0.0284936558,
-0.0851944387,
0.0414160416,
-0.0079754842,
-0.0063630119,
-0.0113070598,
-0.0330147557,
0.0227998085,
0.0063794646,
-0.0015137637,
0.0298638735,
-0.0070828823,
0.0103661139,
-0.0104304673,
-0.0084766457,
-0.0452786461,
0.0348109379,
-0.0286980886,
0.0584592186,
0.0355637334,
0.0229515489,
-0.0173258688,
-0.0411249436,
0.029415641,
0.0483647287,
-0.0010273709,
-0.0018954497,
0.0332884938,
0.0256794356,
0.0150527274,
-0.0304321125,
-0.0164920054,
0.0558838323,
-0.0372258797,
0.0072034956,
0.07230331,
0.0124257104,
-0.0385719128,
0.0101798782,
-0.0117949005,
-0.0135186901,
0.0824307948,
0.0497885011,
-0.0228345376,
0.0042034178,
-0.0536986962,
-0.000673454,
-0.009419716,
-0.0473747812,
-0.0350429788,
-0.0188107789,
-0.0310754292,
-0.0933588445,
-0.0257043727,
0.0063396674,
-0.0070878207,
0.0596018955,
0.0109453751,
0.0248175748,
-0.0198491681,
0.0056022983,
-0.0068082637,
-0.0615251809,
0.0321779288,
-0.0097982632,
-0.0026020159,
0.0091069071,
-0.012988559,
-0.0101166833,
-0.0253490452,
-0.0738244653,
-0.0841400325,
0.0501886941,
0.0207696911,
0.0339395776,
0.0549210086,
-0.0254278276,
-0.0617715679,
0.0429913104,
0.0213534608,
0.0117696496,
0.0587175973,
0.0133876959,
-0.0288452376,
0.005871797,
0.0398642272,
-0.0237460993,
-0.0153367054,
-0.0007513866,
0.0232042857,
-0.037554089,
-0.0370959751,
0.0191286337,
0.0186245497,
0.0220737364,
-0.0255778953,
-0.038844116,
-0.0300497152,
0.0291901696,
-0.0364062972,
-0.0212256238,
0.0012600496,
0.0055586863,
-0.0118537638,
0.0248573814,
-0.0147649311,
0.0188893266,
-0.0429974757,
0.0226148255,
-0.0134768467,
-0.0171943977,
-0.024359148,
0.0161433816,
0.0355233029,
0.0129458746,
0.0017353533,
-0.0005353415,
-0.0231194887,
0.0268127043,
-0.0161314197,
0.0109303668,
0.0199167449,
-0.0338221677,
-0.0351510495,
-0.0027531376,
-0.087992169,
-0.0163434092,
0.0032905643,
0.0435929038,
0.0401726067,
0.0009325988,
0.0491047874,
-0.0348681919,
-0.0350772515,
-0.0154502513,
0.002823788,
0.0216238201,
-0.0508827232,
-0.0131643554,
0.0150120221,
-0.0257104076,
0.0415544361,
0.0392460711,
-0.0339698866,
0.1029402912,
-0.0087990714,
-0.0338018909,
-0.0034866456,
-0.0397094712,
-0.0235367119,
-0.0015538645,
-0.0129479561,
-0.013375517,
-0.1286527067,
-0.0697846264,
-0.012333869,
0.0372961611,
0.0199362561,
-0.0065086158,
-0.0117219733,
0.0595003553,
0.0016409003,
-0.01706402,
-0.0411499217,
0.0090861535,
-0.0183746573,
0.020511318,
-0.0040723071,
-6.356684067e-33,
-0.0045650355,
0.0104715368,
-0.0014891281,
-0.0046609687,
-0.0503369197,
0.0245849919,
-0.0555938222,
0.0340012349,
-0.0188109763,
0.0289997142,
-0.0370199122,
0.0237872843,
0.0085797552,
-0.0264575928,
0.019899752,
-0.006670766,
0.0882093534,
0.0315027162,
-0.0516893826,
-0.002791937,
0.0289160442,
0.0010801172,
0.0966154113,
-0.005050669,
0.0705228075,
-0.0165226944,
-0.0352825224,
0.0318827182,
-0.0522545651,
0.021883009,
0.0216858704,
0.0156029286,
0.009715857,
-0.0575697795,
-0.0399730727,
-0.0559225865,
-0.0101697687,
-0.0115031525,
0.064089112,
0.0235188007,
0.009199677,
-0.0310820304,
0.0537656136,
0.0093409959,
-0.0433137454,
-0.024798682,
0.0358495675,
-0.0244581196,
0.0178261586,
0.0387033112,
-0.0539995544,
0.0152740274,
-0.0080792354,
-0.0064551318,
-0.0189823881,
-0.0064333617,
0.0222141948,
-0.0372201279,
-0.092307426,
0.0249760002,
0.0668833181,
0.058812432,
0.0633569583,
-0.0391847529,
0.0109738233,
0.0512930006,
0.036728777,
0.0374875553,
-0.0056229844,
0.0230474826,
0.036728546,
0.0336452201,
0.025546439,
0.1099086031,
0.0462534279,
-0.0262607932,
-0.0273980424,
-0.0022891539,
-0.0094075482,
0.0102546867,
-0.0100873858,
0.0211476292,
-0.0308950786,
-0.0177181214,
-0.0477383621,
0.0094370833,
-0.0215373859,
-0.0402613953,
-0.0025243335,
-0.0108268866,
-0.0140771754,
-0.0081703253,
0.016406782,
-0.0353107862,
-0.0335803777,
-0.0092391362,
-0.0393931754,
0.0393689089,
0.0196327791,
0.0016390759,
0.0106211705,
0.0268858038,
0.0210132897,
0.0419382825,
0.0252638869,
0.0039667762,
0.0366343744,
0.0390604027,
-0.0731445402,
0.0106836809,
-0.013006689,
0.0130203459,
-0.0030435175,
-0.0238346457,
0.0104655102,
0.0170051605,
-0.0163025521,
-0.0286625139,
0.091860868,
0.0765851662,
-0.0490170941,
0.0382884108,
-0.0146309091,
0.0151089719,
-0.0098084519,
0.0022682336,
-0.0330352932,
0.0384608842,
0.0390933231,
-0.0274237245,
-0.035544835,
0.0075193034,
2.81e-7,
0.0338029414,
0.092394352,
0.0004958716,
-0.0159516949,
0.0539492182,
0.0548689514,
-0.0205180068,
-0.0005482895,
0.0499155931,
-0.0348594561,
0.0045450367,
0.009450716,
0.0120297335,
0.0376228206,
-0.0835788772,
-0.0027340576,
-0.0570768006,
-0.0089743128,
-0.0379962847,
-0.0297331102,
0.0073646517,
0.0265422072,
0.0756142959,
-0.0149268899,
-0.0232916437,
-0.0072619594,
0.042757988,
-0.0199878793,
-0.0306302868,
0.0193748977,
0.0067632697,
-0.0171880629,
0.0400321111,
0.0394180417,
-0.0453644581,
0.0077922731,
-0.0325545631,
0.0128003173,
-0.020732386,
0.0696533173,
-0.0345941819,
0.0061673131,
-0.0026911383,
-0.0514099114,
0.0695584714,
0.0407486781,
-0.0044035423,
-0.0731517747,
-0.0354915038,
0.0360032953,
0.0375347398,
-0.0107953446,
-0.0404689685,
0.0263433959,
-0.0200225692,
0.0429673977,
-0.0306052286,
-0.0076155402,
-0.049762696,
0.0062381993,
-0.0286445096,
-0.0921149477,
-0.0239535104,
-0.0335801244,
0.000606522,
-0.1097924337,
0.0290150959,
2.471578121e-34,
0.0099693127,
0.0262186117,
0.0357858352,
0.0070837485,
0.0317044221,
-0.0065935855,
0.0041559106,
-0.0033720154,
0.0046572401,
-0.0326575488,
-0.0179849863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12973v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12973v2 | Wisdom of Instruction-Tuned Language Model Crowds. Exploring Model Label Variation | 2023-07-24T17:49:31 | 2024-04-15T09:00:26 | Flor Miriam Plaza-del-Arco, Debora Nozza, Dirk Hovy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable text classification
capabilities, excelling in zero- and few-shot learning (ZSL and FSL) scenarios.
However, since they are trained on different datasets, performance varies
widely across tasks between those models. Recent studies emphasize the
importance of considering human label variation in data annotation. However,
how this human label variation also applies to LLMs remains unexplored. Given
this likely model specialization, we ask: Do aggregate LLM labels improve over
individual models (as for human annotators)? We evaluate four recent
instruction-tuned LLMs as annotators on five subjective tasks across four
languages. We use ZSL and FSL setups and label aggregation from human
annotation. Aggregations are indeed substantially better than any individual
model, benefiting from specialization in diverse tasks or languages.
Surprisingly, FSL does not surpass ZSL, as it depends on the quality of the
selected examples. However, there seems to be no good information-theoretical
strategy to select those. We find that no LLM method rivals even simple
supervised models. We also discuss the tradeoffs in accuracy, cost, and
moral/ethical considerations between LLM and human annotation. | [
0.0529294573,
0.060472589,
-0.0002112114,
0.0292368513,
-0.0111968536,
0.0276703648,
0.0332733728,
-0.0140151093,
-0.0112855593,
-0.0918498188,
-0.0717524067,
-0.0364198647,
0.0033902253,
-0.086593233,
0.0326570868,
-0.0423161499,
0.0175123475,
-0.0275684949,
0.0280292705,
-0.0152149396,
0.0003065544,
-0.0045227851,
0.0060405121,
0.0315992013,
0.0187546927,
0.0128896013,
0.0171215255,
0.0205370765,
-0.0022647511,
-0.0116771655,
0.017974833,
0.1023998484,
0.0041238409,
0.0534367561,
0.0000019435,
-0.0532791652,
-0.003601453,
-0.0000797985,
-0.0603481308,
0.0333027691,
0.070849143,
0.0370020121,
-0.0204910338,
0.0125939697,
-0.0073153493,
-0.0245836414,
0.0522080027,
0.015901912,
0.0478664897,
0.0580947325,
0.0138761634,
-0.0041117109,
-0.019618094,
-0.0179885533,
0.0346352048,
-0.0563342832,
0.0249634925,
-0.0295440461,
0.0017676007,
0.0530204736,
0.0102543561,
0.0257688165,
0.0056155459,
-0.0123595297,
0.0405476391,
0.0238179937,
-0.0667160526,
-0.0129503896,
-0.0128984591,
0.0612581857,
0.0143377539,
-0.0299936924,
-0.0117094303,
-0.0162282344,
0.0251400713,
-0.0143435979,
-0.0213529132,
0.0347761698,
0.0024049906,
0.0222238265,
0.0135074984,
0.0331245884,
0.022906892,
0.0190955196,
0.0411874689,
0.0545121059,
-0.013640319,
-0.0241950192,
0.0384945385,
0.0487155579,
-0.0352590755,
-0.0559099391,
-0.0182872992,
-0.0047579906,
-0.0082780467,
0.013451824,
-0.0535082407,
-0.0503149293,
0.0220862087,
-0.0567114986,
0.0699122027,
0.0034927442,
-0.0115100415,
0.0550509021,
0.0142697198,
0.0034936266,
0.027639972,
0.0473949574,
-0.051868584,
-0.0280504804,
-0.0665424243,
0.0188992396,
-0.037263643,
0.0211540535,
-0.0038726029,
0.0395296589,
-0.0436964035,
0.0068208799,
-0.035599798,
-0.0037114017,
-0.000693584,
0.0000882425,
-0.0091399336,
-0.0008107184,
-0.0199604928,
0.0288975369,
-0.0191050526,
0.0162967853,
0.0042990544,
-0.0660657957,
0.0197669528,
0.0223557483,
-0.0123985838,
-0.0218404569,
0.0083905281,
0.0354872681,
-0.0137863262,
-0.0403003655,
-0.0403156579,
-0.0157905146,
-0.0274871141,
-0.0493723117,
-0.0014798119,
-0.0701378584,
0.0175061617,
0.0039121606,
-0.0018199261,
-0.0447239876,
-0.0003710845,
0.021002965,
-0.0208195467,
0.0676150173,
-0.0217353944,
0.0054120594,
0.0493714921,
-0.0054662828,
-0.0136931613,
0.0714781582,
0.0142857041,
0.0260856636,
0.0479349494,
-0.0047688605,
0.0475324765,
0.0344650298,
0.0093652736,
0.0219914224,
0.0047331885,
-0.0254761782,
0.0028876152,
-0.0018940328,
0.0282950513,
0.048805166,
-0.0054637012,
-0.0111995265,
0.0792449489,
0.0450028889,
-0.0406105667,
-0.0258133505,
-0.0000057487,
0.0705719963,
0.0286750719,
-0.0059818099,
-0.0483804382,
0.0230374653,
-0.0429829657,
-0.0169708431,
0.0362902395,
-0.0309033096,
-0.0256827865,
-0.0630868375,
-0.0630181581,
-0.0165969934,
0.0050125089,
0.0335894041,
0.0595791228,
-0.0133075863,
-0.0060223104,
0.0299452655,
0.0682226866,
-0.0477658585,
-0.0140179787,
-0.0417971388,
0.023871446,
0.0432396866,
-0.0040474548,
-0.0171766076,
-0.0149036078,
-0.0193193518,
0.0451475233,
0.0398929529,
0.0679854825,
-0.0244772248,
-0.0170631185,
-0.0386493057,
-0.0635716021,
0.0137367602,
0.0161280967,
0.0388899557,
0.0254707951,
-0.0461509563,
0.0066223461,
-0.0420775749,
-0.0919466987,
0.0359345749,
-0.0019812842,
-0.0332647786,
-0.0012269648,
0.0106892996,
0.020864673,
0.0123427939,
-0.0248387083,
0.010043201,
0.0195316747,
-0.0176419932,
-0.0075010238,
-0.0296102036,
-0.0229653157,
-0.0005981526,
0.0081830714,
-0.0070241406,
-0.0243450254,
-0.0162824411,
-0.0522541478,
-0.0211982392,
-0.0357572399,
-0.0340042487,
-0.0005011382,
-0.028902879,
0.0071557527,
-0.0252768416,
-0.0227932855,
-0.0656022802,
0.0489028767,
-0.0056139431,
0.00570645,
0.0047982144,
-0.0191344563,
0.0067003407,
-0.0466340668,
-0.0453139096,
0.0027611707,
0.0172775257,
0.0342882089,
0.0449156389,
0.0154089229,
-0.0449771322,
-0.0154913561,
-0.1085412949,
-0.0085789189,
-0.0239822324,
0.0167515781,
-0.0082829287,
-0.0405800454,
-0.002493842,
-0.0146155637,
-0.0492837131,
-0.0445831679,
-0.0267204735,
0.0274277758,
0.0237255581,
0.008982419,
0.0093969079,
-0.045218423,
-0.0138476091,
-0.0027036902,
0.0160547122,
0.0368136093,
-0.0240215063,
-0.0550226495,
0.0055104918,
-0.0359026827,
0.0187958498,
0.00016063,
-0.0458317958,
0.0097829886,
0.0197834726,
-0.0089123491,
0.0790136307,
-0.0104888184,
0.0202527102,
0.0545251183,
0.0416296236,
-0.0405216292,
0.001841453,
0.0085638184,
-0.0592398085,
-0.0256121028,
-0.0389448814,
0.0117394645,
0.0834837258,
-0.0192040242,
-0.0097869243,
-0.051549498,
0.0054144999,
-0.0584009811,
-0.0421159267,
-0.0584202446,
0.0022766956,
-0.0169807151,
0.0400103554,
-0.0307920258,
-0.0499179401,
0.0512708873,
-0.0055695977,
-0.0098959357,
-0.0261387452,
-0.0142915975,
-0.0176862665,
0.0274341479,
0.0270225238,
0.0147786122,
0.032872051,
0.0192608591,
-0.0498694777,
0.0171439145,
0.0493923575,
-0.0385903008,
0.0272752997,
-0.0467228293,
0.0072281575,
-0.023118129,
-0.0454047211,
-0.0307806935,
-0.0575053431,
-0.0402933918,
0.0065430603,
0.0341269225,
-0.0054318635,
-0.0255580489,
-0.0305719934,
0.0271523856,
0.0091984635,
0.0077102287,
-0.002796914,
0.0130130295,
-0.0000958295,
0.0038230475,
0.0140248267,
-0.0031802019,
-0.055789087,
-0.0266150348,
0.0470420197,
0.0680784434,
0.0070610554,
0.022011783,
-0.0051098345,
0.0626575872,
-0.0045181611,
-0.0498857982,
0.0315802284,
0.0768760443,
-0.0552780628,
0.0230463035,
0.1117599159,
0.0201554932,
-0.0586076342,
-0.0249397028,
0.0086881751,
0.0439174771,
0.0320584998,
0.00408425,
-0.0646895394,
-0.0447639525,
0.0062211887,
0.0597120039,
-0.0212921891,
-0.0023559483,
-0.0117011648,
-0.140843749,
0.0251677241,
0.0106486883,
-0.0593120456,
0.0663144514,
-0.0446030758,
0.0125699174,
-0.0437800176,
0.0057233856,
-0.0208919086,
0.0110800434,
0.0091720326,
0.0652563423,
-0.0160952862,
-0.0596763082,
0.0353435278,
-0.0285806786,
0.0917537436,
0.0484493896,
0.0132274097,
-0.0213383548,
-0.0804831982,
0.0570357367,
0.0209966227,
-0.0045093875,
-0.0026211126,
0.0893678591,
-0.0243566874,
-0.012366455,
-0.0084589142,
0.0176220573,
-0.0111421542,
0.0155907953,
-0.0249254219,
0.0258155167,
0.0316223763,
-0.0017017509,
0.0074124783,
-0.0439403988,
0.0030816519,
0.0899444893,
0.0287047625,
-0.087441057,
-0.0077160317,
-0.0388213433,
-0.0073199454,
-0.0506012514,
-0.0601409338,
0.0610367954,
-0.0641958192,
-0.0895768031,
-0.0551910438,
-0.059411522,
0.0321718156,
0.0177980885,
0.0083087375,
0.0069025289,
0.0034733098,
0.0089726187,
-0.0143679129,
0.0465276539,
-0.0424287394,
0.0215577763,
-0.096274443,
-0.055336643,
0.0224717129,
-0.0218211245,
-0.0281625912,
0.0118451193,
-0.1108746454,
-0.0713266879,
0.0390362553,
0.0458867811,
0.013247177,
0.0376441032,
0.0051065064,
-0.0856560469,
0.0211456064,
0.0546200201,
0.005088775,
0.0125613827,
0.0347113311,
0.0048109172,
-0.030459879,
0.0299519934,
-0.0421178974,
0.0387099758,
0.0664334223,
-0.0386192612,
-0.037961524,
-0.0281149279,
0.004073963,
0.0290412027,
0.0637595206,
-0.0345348604,
-0.0428949483,
-0.0004262652,
-0.0056868633,
0.0262186043,
-0.049627237,
-0.03579662,
-0.0540439487,
-0.0017690072,
-0.0314487405,
-0.0080378372,
0.0342487246,
0.0156937614,
0.0546621792,
-0.0336732231,
0.0132152447,
0.0184647962,
0.0341696739,
-0.0033252763,
0.0387601517,
-0.0094782133,
0.0314738266,
0.0179332402,
0.0577419288,
0.0156199047,
0.0222549103,
0.0082199844,
0.0097626476,
0.0179810822,
0.0260827411,
-0.03868917,
-0.0422565453,
-0.0278852955,
0.0421630926,
0.0529626198,
-0.0081329001,
0.0547447987,
0.0167996287,
-0.0193339754,
-0.0369330011,
0.0004859849,
-0.0082806535,
-0.0115595926,
0.0038478831,
0.0102660256,
-0.0256470591,
0.0090632914,
0.0694966316,
0.0409672223,
0.0015812422,
-0.0196879767,
-0.0032203817,
-0.0316329114,
0.0445494354,
0.0134286629,
0.011713637,
0.0018902293,
0.0204170905,
-0.0570890307,
-0.042985905,
-0.0016568638,
0.0137599008,
-0.0022434085,
-0.0015934805,
0.0459346846,
0.035933733,
-0.0525167584,
-0.0089692054,
-0.0467992872,
-0.0251240022,
0.0159090925,
0.0063280677,
-0.0168575495,
-6.395470972e-33,
-0.0386838354,
-0.0234448072,
-0.0427839607,
-0.0043146033,
0.0072460934,
0.0063094175,
-0.0111466069,
0.03911338,
-0.0111106196,
0.0220379923,
0.0117615629,
-0.0171359293,
0.0191360023,
0.028062351,
0.0506271385,
-0.0427128449,
0.0514992401,
-0.0142590851,
-0.0308479555,
-0.0004595936,
0.0138653386,
-0.0187391862,
0.0733373463,
-0.085143134,
0.0884929076,
-0.0183305927,
0.0174727384,
0.005971686,
0.0093734283,
0.0585201196,
0.0176107176,
0.0660540238,
0.010502982,
-0.0340490937,
-0.0151389521,
-0.0031562534,
-0.0478757396,
-0.0232232772,
-0.013461818,
0.0354632735,
-0.0228660423,
-0.0463117473,
0.0583258495,
0.0065516261,
-0.0381377153,
0.0103683565,
0.0672788844,
-0.0110771786,
-0.0233487729,
-0.0048486632,
-0.0205429085,
0.0267085563,
0.0034752786,
-0.0173050556,
0.0328185447,
0.0155342054,
0.002360238,
0.0518881269,
-0.0797675923,
0.0121590402,
0.0079405233,
0.0140776308,
0.0527548678,
0.0359026343,
0.0101874704,
0.0455926582,
0.0533809178,
0.053400021,
-0.0044450518,
-0.0464726463,
0.0132650258,
0.0245361049,
0.0615230538,
0.0729041249,
0.0319916643,
0.0123568755,
-0.0250030011,
0.0362394899,
-0.0021227226,
-0.0137564922,
0.0120099094,
0.0398555472,
-0.0694377646,
-0.032734599,
-0.0425226428,
-0.0467731021,
-0.0366684534,
0.0183248799,
0.0210814103,
-0.0084174126,
-0.0430278033,
-0.0249629095,
0.0313318111,
-0.0226421058,
-0.0466606729,
-0.0283886921,
-0.0028464436,
0.0569954477,
-0.0009656794,
-0.0213505216,
-0.090859063,
0.0096014962,
-0.0024841912,
0.0264502801,
0.0211680867,
0.0048784367,
0.0761342868,
0.0108539974,
-0.0595927238,
0.0106828194,
-0.0276856869,
0.0077565438,
0.0071943668,
0.022938855,
0.0474251695,
0.0200566202,
-0.0172490552,
0.0442625768,
0.0150476396,
-0.0056637013,
-0.0058305697,
-0.0173047539,
-0.0374754667,
-0.0282816254,
-0.0070291022,
0.0207840875,
0.0061612143,
0.0061293435,
0.0129805552,
0.010474138,
-0.0058260844,
-0.0229860023,
2.569e-7,
0.0404669456,
0.0579921529,
-0.0120912641,
-0.001892456,
0.0014865282,
0.0752224252,
-0.0268068202,
-0.0041929511,
0.0300879367,
-0.0294704325,
-0.0164850764,
0.0283237938,
0.0732899606,
0.0262844749,
-0.0610241629,
-0.0136198541,
-0.0397873484,
0.065551199,
-0.0169742331,
0.0163381007,
0.0570117198,
0.0863991603,
0.0560439937,
-0.0096941991,
-0.01451053,
-0.0233678706,
0.0645417795,
-0.0581952706,
-0.0140991351,
0.027893804,
0.0545663461,
0.0325539634,
-0.0076088714,
0.0294231679,
-0.0262992643,
-0.018252112,
0.0240171794,
0.0451945327,
-0.0284380428,
-0.0177740529,
0.0000987345,
0.0004860392,
-0.0030936019,
-0.0296997931,
0.061345458,
-0.0437800288,
-0.0110084144,
-0.016973732,
0.0079702949,
-0.0179341175,
0.043979045,
0.012166067,
-0.0170935635,
-0.0001136503,
0.0119507043,
-0.0363440514,
-0.0397930779,
-0.0687915459,
-0.0392937399,
0.0006831121,
-0.0123072406,
-0.0510282815,
-0.0089331698,
0.0121556614,
-0.0209420919,
-0.048415862,
0.0066234549,
1.995797242e-34,
0.0273055397,
0.0050580408,
0.0109761991,
0.026093157,
0.0119917421,
0.0297542252,
-0.0551890992,
-0.0255533736,
0.016736038,
-0.0222470686,
0.0255684257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12966v1 | Aligning Large Language Models with Human: A Survey | 2023-07-24T17:44:58 | 2023-07-24T17:44:58 | Yufei Wang, Wanjun Zhong, Liangyou Li, Fei Mi, Xingshan Zeng, Wenyong Huang, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) trained on extensive textual corpora have
emerged as leading solutions for a broad array of Natural Language Processing
(NLP) tasks. Despite their notable performance, these models are prone to
certain limitations such as misunderstanding human instructions, generating
potentially biased content, or factually incorrect (hallucinated) information.
Hence, aligning LLMs with human expectations has become an active area of
interest within the research community. This survey presents a comprehensive
overview of these alignment technologies, including the following aspects. (1)
Data collection: the methods for effectively collecting high-quality
instructions for LLM alignment, including the use of NLP benchmarks, human
annotations, and leveraging strong LLMs. (2) Training methodologies: a detailed
review of the prevailing training methods employed for LLM alignment. Our
exploration encompasses Supervised Fine-tuning, both Online and Offline human
preference training, along with parameter-efficient training mechanisms. (3)
Model Evaluation: the methods for evaluating the effectiveness of these
human-aligned LLMs, presenting a multifaceted approach towards their
assessment. In conclusion, we collate and distill our findings, shedding light
on several promising future research avenues in the field. This survey,
therefore, serves as a valuable resource for anyone invested in understanding
and advancing the alignment of LLMs to better suit human-oriented tasks and
expectations. An associated GitHub link collecting the latest papers is
available at https://github.com/GaryYufei/AlignLLMHumanSurvey. | [
0.0741498843,
0.067339018,
0.0029687376,
0.039152056,
-0.0496058688,
0.0168509167,
-0.045981437,
-0.0406453088,
0.0146907875,
-0.0466308109,
-0.0428939648,
-0.0366005786,
0.0195475798,
-0.0300251767,
0.0233804416,
-0.0497356541,
0.0458340831,
-0.0004858174,
-0.0127193285,
0.0114524867,
0.0377848707,
0.0438278988,
-0.0036147537,
0.0315461159,
0.0138870133,
-0.0150571121,
0.0187213141,
0.0117320437,
0.0340806879,
-0.0236487761,
0.0141068446,
0.0535007976,
0.032033246,
0.0396766961,
0.0000018047,
-0.0629043579,
0.0058798306,
-0.000625634,
-0.0365953371,
0.0120903524,
0.0513699614,
-0.0211966,
-0.0150987776,
-0.002083163,
-0.0262911655,
0.0237173159,
0.0468848273,
0.0348601043,
0.0635268614,
0.0763171017,
0.009468588,
-0.0192762632,
0.0246027261,
-0.009540895,
-0.029522514,
-0.0392956063,
0.0462786928,
-0.011462545,
0.0032920127,
-0.0027544317,
0.0200981218,
0.0055086352,
-0.0374926478,
0.0209074821,
0.0256757457,
-0.0020085969,
-0.0462171882,
-0.0440984741,
-0.0259055421,
0.0802105963,
-0.0075172679,
-0.0380433872,
-0.0068023102,
-0.0094508734,
-0.0200355686,
0.0160088725,
-0.0162232984,
0.0086899651,
-0.0107035264,
0.0496066622,
-0.00681306,
-0.0203757398,
0.030679604,
0.0708106384,
0.0057941549,
0.0548383407,
0.0201974362,
-0.0352913067,
0.0411577858,
0.0220635459,
-0.0331927687,
-0.0526269265,
0.0102158971,
0.0094893165,
-0.0501124412,
0.040194232,
-0.0443802029,
-0.015688587,
0.0492562465,
-0.0862663016,
0.0215108022,
0.0488838255,
0.0105407508,
0.0516762733,
-0.0001489782,
0.068494603,
-0.0360590406,
-0.0047928244,
-0.0282281097,
-0.0169097576,
-0.0425786227,
0.0048595737,
-0.0021837302,
-0.003408049,
-0.0170095842,
-0.0144997239,
-0.0651481897,
0.0168856252,
-0.0098741781,
0.0343582183,
0.0199423302,
0.0095286155,
-0.0275132768,
-0.0290854052,
-0.0702852309,
0.0447515287,
-0.0156219574,
0.0219568871,
-0.0276250839,
-0.03820033,
0.0088029737,
0.0333812982,
-0.0281528328,
-0.045782689,
0.0103228847,
0.037490841,
0.0051284083,
-0.0204434618,
-0.0270115528,
0.0162639599,
-0.0182771645,
-0.0597549863,
-0.0460220911,
-0.0555839166,
0.0475423634,
-0.0101503171,
0.0026392459,
-0.0416442528,
0.0124364113,
0.0519356541,
-0.0451284535,
0.0867048055,
-0.0108370045,
0.0233247299,
0.0346041918,
-0.0330603048,
-0.0037767612,
0.0724796802,
0.0394734666,
0.0266872998,
0.0366546474,
-0.0144462846,
-0.0089564733,
0.0572315194,
-0.0254885107,
-0.0068156556,
-0.0356796086,
0.035332188,
0.0088384971,
0.0726491213,
0.0627564117,
0.0793924034,
-0.0021136149,
-0.0222222377,
0.078079015,
0.0495841876,
-0.0195264388,
0.0050014821,
0.0348822623,
0.0408927463,
0.0145884929,
0.0071342159,
-0.0568715557,
-0.0214179661,
-0.032165505,
0.0145229194,
0.0252294112,
0.0665116236,
-0.0060954294,
-0.0063301963,
-0.0511105321,
-0.0036395316,
0.0206418987,
0.0042593782,
0.050070677,
-0.0207581203,
-0.0263427421,
0.0273568984,
0.0476270281,
-0.0213724207,
0.0189476851,
-0.0064424993,
0.0212903041,
0.0933084562,
0.0456261151,
-0.0051817778,
-0.0193273854,
-0.0040829992,
-0.0163151901,
0.0654688403,
0.0415834822,
-0.0272353813,
-0.0290175006,
-0.0542514436,
-0.01991239,
0.0275868233,
-0.0063800248,
0.0027079263,
0.0474723168,
-0.0282179248,
0.0112640737,
-0.0482372679,
-0.0690279454,
0.0661174059,
-0.0339872316,
-0.0199327227,
-0.0176575053,
0.017403461,
0.0482384525,
0.0148841562,
-0.0016994114,
0.0013172594,
0.0286446773,
0.0111855008,
0.004380736,
0.0016913593,
-0.0249496922,
-0.0008439865,
0.0477635153,
-0.0311165433,
-0.0529359467,
0.0455080085,
-0.0470732749,
-0.0129323574,
-0.0601428449,
-0.0373187363,
0.0207765196,
-0.0403875709,
0.0396985002,
0.0095041832,
-0.006575868,
-0.0518507771,
0.0789265111,
0.0099630719,
0.0083787711,
0.0246520843,
-0.0263169184,
-0.0047784518,
-0.0301175248,
-0.0258761849,
0.0012455049,
0.0153763564,
0.0211605225,
0.0527633578,
-0.0132212956,
-0.07597664,
-0.0068998458,
-0.0985438079,
0.0256840382,
-0.0038012879,
0.0427359454,
0.0213299673,
-0.00968548,
-0.0307147224,
-0.0172701329,
-0.0308422614,
-0.0270254388,
-0.0009774897,
0.0136955073,
0.043917425,
-0.0165560972,
-0.0084598316,
-0.0618349835,
0.023492936,
-0.0267051924,
0.0153534655,
0.0148427766,
-0.0395848453,
-0.0591709651,
0.0247397516,
-0.0114176515,
0.0281978697,
0.0011133287,
-0.0300892275,
0.0060107447,
0.0391218103,
0.0396651961,
0.0634126514,
0.0439804532,
0.0067624017,
0.0495439954,
0.0283314697,
-0.0625115782,
-0.0082136495,
-0.035208784,
-0.0267520137,
-0.0605970249,
-0.030897405,
0.0163854118,
0.0782306269,
-0.0058490816,
0.0169341918,
-0.0542491339,
-0.0062015736,
-0.019438846,
-0.0065143867,
-0.0168253109,
-0.0353576206,
-0.0441856422,
0.0054432838,
-0.0433831885,
-0.0534249991,
0.0833899975,
-0.0481927022,
0.0293260999,
-0.0712183863,
-0.0052389265,
-0.0361093953,
0.0251051225,
-0.0076653841,
0.0244155228,
0.0036000039,
-0.0113611724,
-0.0506532118,
-0.0050703823,
0.0190639123,
-0.0402392931,
0.0264056791,
-0.0517652184,
0.0402004719,
-0.0017031847,
-0.0340365507,
-0.0641785115,
-0.0850716531,
-0.0466693863,
-0.0077009299,
0.0267226901,
-0.012104162,
-0.0443479195,
-0.0047006216,
0.0155540435,
-0.0076409318,
0.0229278356,
-0.0025247312,
-0.024264209,
0.0118718538,
0.0832641274,
0.0301794726,
0.0206443388,
-0.0005512458,
0.0018700903,
0.0429536775,
0.0310560558,
0.009691637,
-0.029498009,
-0.0236988757,
0.0570992418,
-0.0637592599,
0.0258855037,
0.0245955028,
0.054252632,
-0.0374794602,
0.0143120009,
0.1182046458,
0.0392785855,
-0.0450950637,
0.0076742959,
0.008433247,
0.0267471224,
0.0197306927,
0.0128259724,
-0.0493917316,
-0.0356949903,
0.0066701607,
0.0304824095,
-0.0241209883,
-0.0089974403,
-0.0167257059,
-0.1327915788,
-0.0089289853,
0.0229475982,
-0.0145473974,
-0.0042970078,
-0.0515107103,
0.038602367,
-0.0464256555,
0.0444516018,
-0.0192895513,
-0.0184411574,
-0.008546262,
0.0332136415,
-0.0436368883,
-0.0748183504,
0.0187085327,
-0.0755990818,
0.0822880715,
0.0774094909,
0.0364576168,
0.0209269188,
-0.0280938372,
0.0131732188,
-0.0005546134,
0.0165144075,
0.0028762429,
0.0205431376,
-0.0557378493,
0.0087880688,
-0.0470201522,
0.0469886139,
-0.0217853412,
-0.0052171513,
-0.0114466166,
0.0691294745,
0.0029539021,
0.0375765972,
-0.0175347682,
-0.0004416212,
0.0057333717,
0.0996896625,
-0.0087108444,
-0.0591450408,
-0.0048099598,
0.0040775998,
-0.0104498118,
-0.0013980998,
-0.0333034135,
0.0334142856,
-0.0379937217,
0.0114063462,
-0.0652249604,
-0.0458843112,
0.0224662982,
-0.0025129223,
0.032068409,
0.0041104634,
0.0422421843,
-0.0165709313,
-0.0156336278,
0.0753152892,
-0.0384630449,
0.0314169638,
-0.0560123697,
-0.0119136106,
0.0145733925,
-0.0280635599,
-0.0042751934,
0.0289596748,
-0.0838434771,
-0.0885001943,
-0.0146743786,
0.0104783941,
0.0149149299,
0.0814799666,
-0.0181300212,
-0.0777325556,
0.0081507247,
0.0472623967,
-0.0417058878,
-0.0131727839,
-0.025359191,
0.0278755166,
-0.0162225924,
0.0193255432,
-0.0214477237,
-0.0024513265,
0.0176413003,
0.051593475,
-0.0304237213,
-0.0763764158,
0.0612825789,
0.0069030933,
0.0509259477,
-0.0622887984,
-0.0116092432,
-0.0268431511,
-0.0239282195,
0.0017321993,
-0.0430700555,
-0.0011236185,
-0.0442666225,
0.0544766188,
-0.01205948,
-0.0225338619,
0.0018913754,
-0.0372040942,
0.0264501441,
-0.038838651,
-0.0134983789,
0.0019259548,
-0.0080654435,
0.0078130597,
0.0164769143,
-0.0281369183,
0.0074754083,
-0.0122068198,
0.0603883751,
0.0039507467,
0.056156788,
0.0087368041,
0.0153103368,
0.0131906141,
0.014064475,
-0.0091576176,
-0.0220458228,
-0.0539189167,
-0.0006156942,
0.0628901199,
-0.0396705456,
0.0570984632,
-0.0255712252,
-0.0203357041,
-0.0198533796,
0.0081840958,
-0.0417935848,
0.0007041144,
0.0191398729,
0.0256820824,
-0.053908281,
0.0105025461,
0.0483458936,
0.0067926981,
0.0217477139,
-0.0249086376,
-0.039634645,
-0.0302545708,
-0.0272604432,
0.0071958331,
-0.0127821937,
-0.0487776622,
-0.0063617188,
-0.0531981811,
-0.0558488816,
0.0075515551,
0.0008653924,
-0.0345631577,
-0.0254717059,
0.0460917354,
0.0523503274,
-0.0588709004,
0.0182935707,
-0.040882349,
-0.012540821,
-0.0124790827,
-0.0157194547,
-0.0463663042,
-6.116089026e-33,
-0.0338094532,
-0.0200243853,
0.0223648455,
-0.0499648005,
-0.0394217893,
-0.0256785341,
0.0228595026,
0.0006212596,
-0.0251561757,
0.003421623,
0.0095899915,
-0.0195929483,
0.0158838909,
0.0034428725,
-0.0031020558,
-0.0022911965,
0.034803018,
0.0041554198,
-0.0550578199,
-0.0318419002,
0.0328190103,
0.0043664179,
0.0398737304,
-0.0666313916,
0.046805907,
0.0089252237,
-0.0219031852,
0.0388854332,
0.0246385206,
0.0712763667,
-0.0436956808,
0.0317049436,
0.0265034195,
-0.0129657621,
0.0031838662,
0.0579103008,
-0.0334216356,
0.0239500925,
0.0645748898,
0.0221825037,
-0.0034728907,
-0.0058669806,
0.0618460663,
-0.0344286896,
-0.0289869979,
0.0331360959,
0.0504356734,
-0.0332507491,
-0.0035661662,
0.0087682223,
-0.0777950063,
0.0429963917,
-0.0213619005,
-0.0223820042,
0.0019575183,
0.0350440443,
-0.0055187573,
0.0487360954,
-0.0683066845,
0.0284709092,
-0.0165043846,
0.0136460029,
0.0888475329,
0.0011144399,
0.0117496187,
0.0831931084,
-0.0049224086,
-0.0113125285,
-0.0217455588,
-0.0167043563,
0.003777592,
0.0275177881,
0.0141169243,
0.0569666848,
0.0034258175,
0.02777653,
-0.0449684709,
0.0424689688,
0.0173068047,
0.041371949,
0.0161807016,
0.0252837799,
-0.0750480518,
0.001181735,
-0.0365890414,
0.0053999615,
-0.0242706537,
-0.0155091304,
0.0227015261,
-0.0015486734,
-0.0161221344,
0.0035552685,
0.0044488013,
-0.0413478278,
-0.003290419,
-0.008217372,
-0.0078756921,
-0.0013835956,
0.0032906546,
0.0272055287,
-0.0777732879,
-0.0234194044,
-0.0033239259,
-0.0070387996,
0.0125603434,
-0.0080376137,
0.0191642623,
-0.0056295348,
-0.0482904203,
0.0233808868,
-0.0224691648,
-0.0184397604,
-0.0376646668,
-0.0027212517,
0.0782255083,
0.0199623238,
-0.0194873214,
0.0548950247,
0.0207052771,
-0.0034110793,
-0.0029444455,
-0.0179514922,
0.0096527766,
0.0134648299,
0.0072627608,
0.0271356087,
0.007081226,
0.0019410764,
0.0008844543,
-0.0226257592,
0.0070858975,
0.0216500591,
2.512e-7,
0.0400546528,
0.0584893003,
0.0258171,
-0.0130767766,
-0.007191061,
0.0225131325,
-0.030884115,
0.011987973,
0.0086434716,
-0.0469113663,
0.0254531577,
0.0067711193,
0.0822673067,
-0.0027782773,
-0.0783459172,
-0.0019758896,
-0.061709471,
0.0207731742,
-0.0558847375,
0.0172972195,
0.0412502438,
0.0833690763,
0.0100563923,
-0.005246866,
-0.0203826185,
-0.0217425786,
0.0772637203,
-0.0418094285,
-0.0480323993,
0.025713155,
0.0157471877,
0.015951639,
-0.0128727462,
0.0076812827,
-0.0216674246,
0.0283318423,
0.0182557795,
0.0760285482,
-0.023903342,
-0.0148779517,
-0.0452519991,
-0.0069341906,
-0.0009794574,
-0.0578775369,
0.0389279872,
-0.0516009815,
-0.041503422,
-0.0325756371,
-0.0205289871,
-0.0133423014,
0.0092303688,
-0.0083060889,
-0.010309983,
0.0026070822,
0.0539079979,
0.0068399622,
-0.0610118769,
-0.0630976483,
-0.0162153617,
0.0056916899,
-0.0609489977,
-0.0421372317,
-0.0206234138,
0.0250936933,
0.0202495009,
-0.0588285401,
0.0224474948,
1.972239141e-34,
0.0152254542,
0.0084775537,
0.0160191357,
0.0160236023,
0.0283717029,
0.0303739421,
-0.0189714152,
0.0240302943,
0.0164605007,
-0.0909560099,
0.0319808237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03767v1 | Enhancing image captioning with depth information using a Transformer-based framework | 2023-07-24T17:31:51 | 2023-07-24T17:31:51 | Aya Mahmoud Ahmed, Mohamed Yousef, Khaled F. Hussain, Yousef Bassyouni Mahdy | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.IV | Captioning images is a challenging scene-understanding task that connects
computer vision and natural language processing. While image captioning models
have been successful in producing excellent descriptions, the field has
primarily focused on generating a single sentence for 2D images. This paper
investigates whether integrating depth information with RGB images can enhance
the captioning task and generate better descriptions. For this purpose, we
propose a Transformer-based encoder-decoder framework for generating a
multi-sentence description of a 3D scene. The RGB image and its corresponding
depth map are provided as inputs to our framework, which combines them to
produce a better understanding of the input scene. Depth maps could be ground
truth or estimated, which makes our framework widely applicable to any RGB
captioning dataset. We explored different fusion approaches to fuse RGB and
depth images. The experiments are performed on the NYU-v2 dataset and the
Stanford image paragraph captioning dataset. During our work with the NYU-v2
dataset, we found inconsistent labeling that prevents the benefit of using
depth information to enhance the captioning task. The results were even worse
than using RGB images only. As a result, we propose a cleaned version of the
NYU-v2 dataset that is more consistent and informative. Our results on both
datasets demonstrate that the proposed framework effectively benefits from
depth information, whether it is ground truth or estimated, and generates
better captions. Code, pre-trained models, and the cleaned version of the
NYU-v2 dataset will be made publically available. | [
0.0523767285,
0.0607528239,
0.0445455089,
0.0346240401,
-0.0282003265,
0.0119917458,
-0.0013968094,
-0.0408166759,
-0.0480224304,
-0.0844942927,
0.0039333422,
0.0071338941,
0.0675606132,
0.0468874462,
-0.0168321393,
-0.1060597524,
-0.0235849507,
-0.0242417697,
-0.0601867139,
-0.0137136513,
-0.00090499,
0.0249377917,
-0.0017011208,
0.0151027972,
-0.0243827589,
0.0162941944,
-0.0244967099,
0.0081630712,
0.0247142147,
-0.0304006469,
0.0005876764,
0.0737146437,
0.0843925774,
-0.0247673746,
0.0000019607,
0.0056460253,
-0.0136608668,
0.0080208164,
0.0435522087,
-0.0297866613,
0.017653374,
-0.0731692836,
0.0434464812,
-0.029945815,
-0.0150242085,
0.0041158618,
0.0915694535,
0.0835680887,
0.0611626767,
0.0134551506,
-0.0283274781,
-0.0765926316,
0.0100325486,
-0.0070316056,
-0.015588263,
0.0269157868,
0.007456047,
0.0538383685,
0.0030281895,
0.0042444966,
-0.048671782,
0.0151816802,
0.0098429359,
0.0025186548,
0.0407159775,
0.0467866622,
0.0115209995,
-0.0101841521,
-0.0328930356,
0.0670295358,
-0.028623024,
0.0317810737,
-0.0235133581,
0.0217677969,
-0.0312915072,
-0.0176206306,
-0.0131160794,
0.0467099138,
-0.0128626926,
-0.0015443845,
-0.0734773949,
0.0473510735,
-0.0184990466,
-0.0214261468,
-0.0070360177,
0.0101040937,
0.033119075,
0.0246553011,
-0.0590406768,
0.03256917,
0.0178106315,
-0.0781537145,
0.0146856112,
-0.0272295922,
0.0465862006,
0.0065861912,
-0.0185047667,
-0.0055804299,
-0.0108605074,
-0.0536759906,
0.0083204973,
0.0021341373,
-0.0593605004,
0.0671530142,
-0.0011503737,
0.0547931716,
0.0372929201,
0.0289194249,
-0.0252745952,
0.0062248018,
-0.0122680692,
-0.0254955795,
-0.0694694892,
0.0063237259,
-0.045813702,
-0.0231335256,
-0.0413711555,
-0.0269446317,
-0.0085299183,
-0.0085778944,
0.0034353267,
0.0637947172,
-0.0519298837,
-0.0018376381,
-0.0263209734,
0.0229581166,
0.028916046,
0.0269166213,
-0.0085265869,
-0.0350671187,
-0.0067773885,
0.0212384984,
0.0300371759,
-0.0011290262,
-0.0315022916,
0.0492984764,
-0.055494681,
-0.0417646319,
0.0218762681,
-0.008673843,
-0.0571055859,
0.0139751751,
0.0166033208,
-0.0402663648,
0.0360246301,
-0.0124231847,
0.008535902,
-0.0213406831,
0.0164953768,
0.0075377822,
0.0109522045,
0.1036998183,
-0.0472291671,
-0.0147321653,
0.0333835706,
0.0323977508,
0.0008770031,
0.0468954854,
0.032913927,
0.0585806482,
-0.0040633436,
-0.022058567,
0.0130291404,
0.0091013359,
-0.0346237905,
-0.0263315327,
-0.0303468462,
-0.024449883,
-0.0372268818,
0.020010693,
0.0248314142,
0.0302357096,
-0.0140194958,
0.028692916,
0.0703382194,
0.0307948086,
-0.0332423747,
0.0408133492,
0.0654666498,
0.0128678409,
-0.0156243127,
0.0139919491,
-0.0228795018,
0.053501077,
0.0603795648,
0.012030269,
-0.0123297991,
0.0414355658,
-0.0239453446,
-0.0435863994,
-0.0006748955,
-0.0105775027,
0.0615743697,
-0.0153166056,
0.0427442901,
0.0208425857,
-0.0383910351,
0.089560613,
-0.0054077171,
-0.0492425896,
-0.0021391958,
-0.0005580018,
-0.0387163348,
0.051098451,
0.0310068857,
0.0172909759,
0.009916734,
0.0148072299,
0.043739859,
0.0783597603,
0.0050307442,
0.0154607221,
0.0444708169,
-0.043282181,
-0.0882624984,
-0.0334456861,
-0.0141924536,
0.0485354885,
0.007225255,
-0.0189641882,
0.0394241177,
-0.00566555,
-0.0229129214,
0.0302607529,
0.0198882613,
0.0002344053,
-0.026168583,
0.017979309,
-0.0103514763,
0.028127227,
0.0002166276,
-0.0190669429,
-0.0062866001,
0.0045090248,
-0.0391635299,
0.0527962893,
-0.0597013161,
-0.0510967895,
-0.0271343347,
-0.0848521814,
-0.0122410981,
0.0338012055,
-0.0268567782,
-0.0406503938,
-0.0136988629,
-0.0414988324,
0.0110239768,
-0.0237715095,
0.0014826389,
0.015246924,
0.0543870926,
-0.0159513969,
0.0535108969,
-0.0301515087,
-0.0250045694,
-0.0085951732,
-0.0448026471,
-0.0328099206,
-0.0069552944,
-0.0344428122,
-0.0116623044,
-0.0038967773,
0.0131702283,
0.0169282239,
0.0080555566,
-0.031910155,
0.0437427796,
-0.0287437625,
-0.0620780922,
0.010379063,
-0.0522383787,
-0.0113056088,
0.0106214574,
0.029860191,
-0.0148359435,
-0.0292219352,
0.0157133415,
0.004234896,
-0.0089889355,
0.0374383815,
0.0365244113,
-0.0440156795,
-0.0161499288,
0.0128596611,
0.0275252443,
0.0555845052,
0.0644703582,
-0.0751534551,
-0.0420665853,
-0.0025617715,
-0.0254430044,
0.0156462193,
-0.0131271249,
-0.0299441908,
-0.0146418745,
-0.0014365361,
0.0003143489,
0.0286931917,
0.0246662386,
0.0265455339,
0.0447914749,
-0.01072188,
0.0072941929,
0.0178214107,
-0.0245349351,
-0.008366623,
0.0200041533,
-0.0229835808,
0.0158148576,
0.0330636278,
0.0249087811,
0.0663989112,
-0.0477614217,
-0.0309396032,
-0.0057235365,
-0.0453586653,
-0.0171658322,
-0.0117501188,
0.0077887271,
0.0086319372,
-0.0598114766,
-0.0442644134,
0.035006851,
-0.0547768362,
-0.0436932854,
0.000235788,
0.0142258359,
-0.0178205967,
0.0756601244,
0.002994885,
0.0460051745,
-0.0376600958,
-0.0234386455,
0.0297646374,
-0.0065006195,
0.0266341753,
0.0279272106,
0.0806259513,
-0.0920334682,
0.0073595261,
-0.0341623649,
-0.0396276526,
-0.007442764,
-0.0120509239,
-0.0574162155,
-0.0190292783,
-0.0358907618,
-0.0092005748,
-0.0310763121,
0.0597250201,
-0.0117908027,
0.0459312126,
0.0020471583,
0.0024000877,
-0.0070111351,
-0.0122718746,
0.0116548324,
0.0576168038,
-0.0594381988,
0.0073712617,
0.0420161225,
0.0243575796,
-0.0853223354,
0.0108392173,
-0.068570815,
0.0162498541,
0.0392510109,
0.0453067534,
0.0235115234,
-0.0025154268,
0.0299539417,
-0.0513627455,
-0.042167671,
0.0449198931,
-0.0034911798,
-0.0419695191,
-0.0123691494,
-0.0023267954,
0.011344037,
0.0033201524,
-0.0237636659,
-0.0540388785,
-0.0506676547,
-0.0380581766,
-0.024848666,
0.0517096408,
0.0187911149,
-0.0478299223,
-0.0705453083,
0.0386104658,
0.0075683021,
-0.0152302263,
-0.0697590038,
-0.0064353617,
0.0213452224,
0.0000561749,
-0.0163877755,
-0.0445987657,
0.0095592318,
-0.0149269896,
0.0031758016,
0.0166599937,
-0.0460588001,
-0.0019740819,
0.0039748936,
-0.0359197184,
0.0352586731,
0.0135342786,
-0.0348615386,
-0.0203251597,
0.0072441003,
0.0546782054,
0.0289459676,
0.0104090488,
0.0766951889,
-0.0516722873,
-0.0267517176,
0.0369673707,
-0.002585131,
0.0030019102,
-0.0203462392,
-0.01143381,
-0.0324442126,
-0.0173232388,
0.0202045403,
-0.0172273237,
0.0556215383,
0.004999625,
0.0599732026,
0.0057045594,
0.0005666494,
-0.0094722118,
-0.0262914933,
0.0194097944,
-0.0466765463,
0.0027346122,
0.0315177254,
-0.0372498073,
-0.019670222,
-0.0420046933,
0.0151397046,
0.0682516173,
-0.0218466315,
0.0304160379,
-0.0309088137,
-0.0037084322,
0.041786328,
-0.0694254935,
0.0213074815,
-0.0210331623,
0.0132023189,
-0.0116254687,
0.0270066615,
0.0435669348,
-0.0165211093,
-0.0057007377,
0.0261157192,
-0.0608694963,
0.0159547292,
0.018199414,
0.0531104356,
0.0026676401,
0.0408736169,
0.0248171091,
-0.0197743401,
0.0119706281,
0.0353160873,
0.0450506918,
0.0023790349,
0.0126347458,
0.0071823364,
-0.0400994308,
-0.0057745231,
-0.0696347281,
0.0320259333,
-0.0342400037,
-0.002646581,
0.0029233273,
-0.0593444891,
0.0094344812,
-0.0502271354,
0.0779627189,
-0.0299551934,
0.0545835197,
-0.0150293577,
-0.0025873277,
-0.0495952666,
-0.021097403,
-0.0753301457,
0.0182658006,
-0.0225425698,
0.0280967243,
0.0155340666,
0.0199194569,
0.0061794245,
-0.0063362927,
-0.001303724,
-0.0055871252,
0.0489984192,
-0.083691448,
0.0006240768,
0.00781067,
-0.0290568005,
0.001801835,
-0.0257895272,
-0.006172765,
0.0014168195,
0.0042634909,
0.0223078802,
-0.0492042676,
-0.0319744945,
0.0597791299,
-0.0105427429,
0.0146277938,
-0.0581324995,
0.0122477468,
0.058312241,
-0.0102607673,
0.0180346295,
-0.0064634108,
0.0047045499,
0.012592799,
0.0519068912,
0.0010559419,
-0.0726862475,
0.0759599581,
-0.0207519792,
-0.0067289476,
0.000705316,
0.0296110306,
0.0387750454,
0.0087607848,
0.014086185,
-0.0498514436,
-0.0365465172,
0.0047297101,
-0.008927701,
-0.0054261629,
0.0020995066,
0.0271103382,
0.0016039602,
-0.0269044749,
-0.0002772378,
0.0150012448,
0.0338280536,
0.0285802167,
0.0912064612,
0.0003239506,
0.006877352,
-0.0400774553,
0.0091472603,
-0.0047793342,
-0.0533983372,
0.0207102783,
-0.0046506994,
-5.110104266e-33,
-0.0531176813,
-0.0513048731,
-0.0128762424,
-0.0441208407,
-0.0273579285,
0.0331955366,
-0.046596773,
0.0239601824,
0.0124468561,
0.0539292879,
0.0375570953,
-0.0215250049,
0.0216601212,
0.0570601262,
0.0147482529,
-0.0129400389,
0.062488161,
0.0082473289,
-0.0198001415,
-0.0120669454,
-0.0092722056,
-0.0035705457,
0.0701793209,
0.0073795477,
-0.0381149761,
0.004888128,
-0.0317691416,
0.0041659395,
0.0464050286,
0.0293307826,
-0.0179968122,
-0.0101390285,
0.0143188359,
-0.0504032597,
-0.0187486894,
0.0498658866,
-0.0727578998,
0.0057925987,
0.0273691248,
0.0420845337,
-0.0632002801,
0.0101855863,
0.0100287721,
-0.0361186638,
0.0153940804,
-0.0900281668,
0.0534989461,
-0.0437305719,
-0.0014881619,
-0.0478160791,
-0.007026461,
0.00405352,
-0.0226490907,
-0.0514701307,
0.0335697271,
0.0173825957,
0.0489044674,
0.0268473029,
-0.0038867171,
0.025569655,
0.0001770543,
0.0109353261,
0.0939302742,
0.0580288507,
-0.0105954176,
0.0600663573,
-0.0245526955,
-0.0062434319,
-0.0315606259,
0.0307369139,
-0.026642561,
0.0746106356,
0.0445248671,
0.0687117651,
0.0483206101,
0.0331880338,
-0.0068960553,
0.0452453792,
-0.153069213,
0.0389464535,
0.0068649864,
-0.0208616294,
0.0018291664,
0.0081349593,
-0.0346277133,
-0.0127468416,
-0.0031272708,
0.0020954509,
0.0328786224,
0.0172054209,
-0.041546151,
0.0193452928,
0.0460027382,
-0.0297876075,
0.0370802544,
0.0128808692,
-0.024001563,
0.0549933128,
-0.0147255277,
-0.0346008316,
0.0260000229,
-0.0116414996,
0.0473382734,
0.0615518168,
0.0308281705,
0.0043067955,
0.025640389,
0.0222227592,
0.0006594142,
0.014587081,
-0.0308541097,
0.0088264616,
-0.0345106162,
0.0618986264,
0.0110342391,
0.0183104929,
-0.0692080408,
0.0305604097,
-0.0373276807,
0.0181422438,
-0.0265535563,
-0.0155615881,
0.0008373213,
0.0323274024,
-0.0370471403,
0.0229097717,
-0.0393334329,
-0.0819194093,
0.0576029345,
-0.0381328315,
-0.0490462072,
0.0363212079,
2.423e-7,
-0.0177386012,
0.0283993483,
0.0646761805,
-0.0001590999,
-0.0119971391,
0.0089352597,
0.0208215769,
0.052786205,
-0.0171101224,
-0.0362131111,
0.0555099212,
0.012808173,
0.0367306955,
-0.0207104124,
-0.0614631735,
-0.0199957509,
-0.0571766794,
-0.0237361174,
-0.0330114961,
0.0008514225,
0.1008641273,
0.0465602279,
-0.0178065076,
-0.0073942281,
-0.0282629766,
-0.0496452674,
0.0590683781,
-0.0134878708,
0.0298625398,
-0.0117814783,
0.0583985746,
0.0294317417,
-0.0382622257,
0.0298235882,
-0.0352323614,
0.0004339524,
0.0479216836,
0.0523119867,
-0.0416353382,
0.0132572278,
-0.033036489,
0.0490076318,
-0.0235970169,
-0.0570878908,
0.0364572555,
-0.0655236617,
-0.0152970068,
-0.0402866639,
-0.0337557048,
0.0205894299,
-0.0216091666,
-0.0174852908,
-0.0431078449,
-0.0207696781,
0.0585688502,
-0.0121627022,
-0.0291765612,
-0.074383162,
-0.021203367,
-0.030784525,
-0.012845167,
0.0221998394,
-0.0024604164,
-0.0735962018,
0.0272295251,
-0.0055277003,
-0.02026782,
1.90302686e-34,
0.0021603508,
-0.0015673608,
-0.0133038284,
-0.0424937233,
0.0169967562,
0.014421721,
0.0137981959,
-0.0018100205,
-0.0327435881,
-0.0546643175,
-0.0157698095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12950v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12950v3 | RLCD: Reinforcement Learning from Contrastive Distillation for Language Model Alignment | 2023-07-24T17:23:22 | 2024-03-16T04:22:09 | Kevin Yang, Dan Klein, Asli Celikyilmaz, Nanyun Peng, Yuandong Tian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose Reinforcement Learning from Contrastive Distillation (RLCD), a
method for aligning language models to follow principles expressed in natural
language (e.g., to be more harmless) without using human feedback. RLCD creates
preference pairs from two contrasting model outputs, one using a positive
prompt designed to encourage following the given principles, and one using a
negative prompt designed to encourage violating them. Using two different
prompts causes model outputs to be more differentiated on average, resulting in
cleaner preference labels in the absence of human annotations. We then use the
preference pairs to train a preference model, which is in turn used to improve
a base unaligned language model via reinforcement learning. Empirically, RLCD
outperforms RLAIF (Bai et al., 2022b) and context distillation (Huang et al.,
2022) baselines across three diverse alignment tasks--harmlessness,
helpfulness, and story outline generation--and when using both 7B and 30B model
scales for simulating preference data. | [
0.046795968,
0.0629936233,
-0.0130109694,
-0.0032128599,
-0.0711591989,
0.0171248466,
-0.0399431437,
-0.0438662618,
-0.0454166047,
-0.0133445039,
-0.0198160298,
-0.0428033881,
-0.0105991671,
0.0138637517,
-0.0076850234,
-0.0769173056,
0.0485394113,
-0.01232679,
0.0666270256,
0.002448523,
0.0373764262,
0.0272682682,
-0.0148753719,
0.0200006235,
0.039562799,
-0.032298211,
-0.0093681216,
0.0046952497,
0.0564426221,
-0.0251571015,
0.0585727245,
0.0636367351,
0.03216438,
0.0233785883,
0.0000020239,
-0.0719262511,
0.0004535937,
-0.007119413,
0.0098597063,
-0.0142347571,
0.0720659643,
-0.0089806654,
-0.006500788,
0.0109239416,
-0.0366043746,
0.0234700404,
0.0729473904,
0.0558988005,
0.04608877,
0.0583718419,
0.0100802835,
-0.0348412693,
-0.0100309709,
-0.0208911654,
-0.008425937,
0.0127525609,
-0.0073700738,
-0.0120786624,
0.007152562,
0.0122669861,
-0.009529328,
0.0087955659,
0.0026925839,
-0.0001886269,
-0.0011384666,
0.0419964865,
-0.023674598,
-0.0327114798,
-0.0079869349,
0.0871534795,
0.0046819132,
-0.0289100576,
-0.0258643627,
-0.0339549929,
0.0129723893,
0.0124402372,
-0.0151181947,
0.0058297589,
0.0119052893,
0.0419596732,
0.0577700287,
-0.0093249045,
0.0131567875,
0.0102439858,
0.0212861076,
0.0626540929,
0.0107452357,
-0.0503768362,
0.0065042991,
-0.0016997964,
-0.0396523252,
-0.0616955869,
-0.0033895844,
-0.0139328726,
-0.0532593504,
0.0308360588,
-0.0608265027,
0.0250410698,
0.0349075682,
-0.0132404426,
0.0401455313,
0.0438819528,
-0.0244812332,
0.0181652047,
0.0310639627,
0.0689990073,
0.0054890248,
0.0408063903,
-0.034085501,
0.0505572073,
-0.0090748193,
-0.000614888,
0.0081786225,
0.0153223705,
-0.0264812633,
-0.0250118077,
-0.0308825132,
0.0116603682,
-0.039507661,
0.0218475368,
0.0310213305,
0.0203618556,
-0.0567467064,
0.0138391405,
-0.056392815,
0.0496442094,
-0.043910753,
0.0137283159,
0.0255929828,
-0.0120394742,
-0.009459448,
-0.019429395,
-0.0192041211,
-0.042612914,
-0.0041312673,
0.0444112606,
-0.0063949442,
-0.0244394038,
-0.0165021047,
0.0136451526,
-0.055237148,
-0.0785304084,
-0.0578334294,
-0.080721423,
0.0304288045,
-0.0049299276,
-0.0200093631,
-0.0884129852,
0.0207864791,
0.0120592369,
-0.0312997587,
0.0694582388,
-0.0107026454,
0.0021243573,
-0.0162730776,
-0.0083744563,
-0.0242500994,
0.0500831679,
0.0373261385,
0.0098112402,
0.0063570198,
0.0100804456,
-0.0094644567,
-0.0000153384,
0.0034924673,
0.0211887155,
-0.0453944132,
0.0019857597,
-0.0166469309,
0.0341812037,
0.0582230166,
0.0727543607,
-0.0167970937,
-0.0021143348,
0.1050713435,
0.0336144976,
0.0150076142,
-0.034271501,
0.0133796139,
0.0279403403,
-0.0389363356,
0.0584360324,
-0.0571607761,
0.0268177055,
-0.0067070867,
0.0394784994,
0.0307400655,
0.0174804106,
-0.0030283574,
-0.0379813462,
-0.0153978411,
-0.0059748325,
0.0560826957,
-0.0013027721,
0.0322986878,
0.0192700345,
-0.0356922187,
-0.0100935632,
0.0751296356,
-0.0431025885,
0.0071076062,
-0.0126877977,
0.0736268237,
0.1088877395,
0.0331497379,
-0.0196738243,
-0.0388255715,
-0.0359383784,
-0.0287204329,
0.0530001894,
0.0646782815,
-0.0279985443,
0.0058509652,
-0.0400948673,
-0.0381663293,
-0.0358360186,
-0.0000412181,
-0.0056269569,
0.0103162937,
-0.0104142996,
-0.0253623948,
-0.008550141,
-0.062784262,
0.0349371731,
-0.0233608168,
-0.0285522155,
-0.0104682231,
0.0183738265,
0.0201870967,
-0.0001181184,
-0.0132628381,
-0.0080421716,
0.0113045843,
-0.0030297679,
0.0134822829,
0.0137235466,
-0.0655811578,
-0.0483204462,
0.044875294,
-0.0242660772,
-0.0174654275,
0.0459661186,
-0.0236788914,
-0.0173427612,
-0.0171368364,
-0.0103157042,
0.0239900947,
-0.0155031523,
0.0470535643,
-0.0185345598,
-0.0352278575,
-0.0761645511,
0.03802092,
-0.0199479107,
0.0268232729,
-0.0097580161,
-0.0175673328,
-0.0232055932,
-0.0128293959,
-0.010827438,
-0.001133593,
0.0077021564,
0.0178115591,
0.0667183399,
0.0293172896,
-0.0388610624,
-0.0204834491,
-0.0020186256,
0.0218153875,
-0.0196829326,
0.0078614382,
0.0582423843,
-0.003326491,
0.0014852115,
0.008645229,
-0.0506383143,
-0.0552252531,
-0.0025982617,
0.0121514024,
0.0369291157,
0.0210518222,
-0.0096694119,
-0.0716281161,
0.0079025412,
-0.0133716715,
-0.0091205016,
-0.0087831737,
0.0288682133,
-0.0579301342,
0.04202668,
-0.0442360938,
0.0044629187,
0.0014554339,
-0.0375492945,
0.0227424316,
0.0186079647,
0.0400742739,
0.0530000329,
0.030132452,
0.0259375237,
0.0967397541,
0.0283627957,
-0.0794445202,
0.0079470957,
-0.0421327129,
-0.0014197991,
-0.0207753237,
-0.0669685081,
-0.0064429925,
0.0872728005,
0.0090882089,
0.0179191902,
-0.0761193708,
0.0242301468,
0.0024928034,
-0.0347597748,
0.0315913074,
-0.0222950559,
-0.0406847,
0.0468353741,
-0.0567335971,
-0.0734780654,
0.1251835376,
-0.0001133895,
0.0027407384,
-0.058036752,
-0.0051605017,
-0.0011615223,
-0.0009135967,
0.003689931,
0.043342378,
0.0359231718,
-0.0058297156,
-0.0763668045,
-0.0500801727,
0.0595934652,
-0.0257101636,
0.0737032592,
-0.0555817112,
-0.0035202703,
0.0073933769,
-0.0549904779,
-0.0844748393,
-0.0604871362,
0.0102330362,
0.0122574382,
0.0297206193,
-0.01882709,
-0.0173388645,
0.0044844393,
0.0119155897,
0.0329615399,
-0.0056847208,
-0.0023812733,
-0.0104447203,
0.0123187872,
0.0970941335,
-0.0207045153,
0.0353287198,
-0.0143439528,
0.0260807034,
0.0213752091,
0.0040994613,
0.0068825334,
-0.0047504916,
0.0147676123,
0.0417786576,
-0.0323707499,
-0.0048620612,
0.0318451859,
0.0328225009,
-0.0125719877,
-0.0495981239,
0.1106990576,
0.0522927754,
-0.0187764857,
0.0218484979,
-0.012482713,
0.0872749239,
0.0282377172,
0.0061433907,
-0.0592821576,
-0.0154184839,
0.0056655169,
0.0517044961,
0.0082150996,
-0.0125619229,
-0.018375311,
-0.1035525501,
-0.0056705722,
0.0360792167,
-0.0429252461,
-0.0250964481,
-0.0231938362,
0.0300526991,
-0.0270033982,
0.0400859565,
0.0249138828,
-0.0143004814,
0.0027721175,
0.001450867,
0.0075882911,
-0.040269535,
-0.0046339771,
-0.0523237623,
0.0684418902,
0.0907786638,
0.0190255605,
0.002018282,
-0.0386277325,
-0.0161941871,
-0.0041415594,
-0.0120314024,
0.0037695628,
0.0143635878,
-0.0235665031,
0.0093948487,
-0.0308582261,
0.0599661022,
0.0056131394,
-0.0465416349,
-0.0223273281,
0.0302899517,
0.0151050044,
-0.0222212113,
-0.0242759772,
0.033219263,
0.0528801344,
0.0846967697,
0.0122494949,
-0.0732982084,
-0.0162951853,
-0.0235096309,
-0.0253392346,
-0.0332133882,
-0.006812505,
-0.0243733227,
-0.0332171693,
0.0085856868,
-0.0846480727,
-0.0569108054,
-0.019566603,
-0.00306472,
0.0272242911,
-0.0142383883,
-0.0053223111,
-0.0076879272,
-0.0237481501,
0.0165698472,
-0.002345639,
0.0249527786,
-0.0422256589,
-0.0189038869,
-0.0058641289,
-0.0439463817,
-0.0248203129,
-0.0073000453,
-0.0342858732,
-0.1094352975,
0.0242597032,
0.0605379827,
0.0136879059,
0.0919016451,
0.0014640373,
-0.0244222283,
0.0185202528,
0.0376303233,
-0.0248035714,
0.0177622195,
0.0137723871,
0.002912008,
0.0129069658,
0.0202953964,
-0.025487991,
-0.0024791395,
0.0270658359,
0.0784628317,
-0.0439892113,
-0.0431200191,
0.05576488,
-0.0149591221,
0.0507454164,
-0.0193551462,
0.0168998074,
-0.0634993464,
-0.0168548003,
0.0055665853,
-0.0493855961,
-0.0141566116,
-0.0223738439,
0.0332432091,
-0.0102966614,
-0.020412175,
0.016841054,
-0.0585282259,
0.0267875604,
-0.0184307285,
-0.0203644354,
0.037881542,
0.0523686372,
0.0157623459,
0.019865239,
-0.0240710694,
0.0196894128,
-0.0134369768,
0.0548518002,
-0.0068302443,
0.0760843977,
0.0405089967,
0.0213267282,
0.0050928746,
0.0135870771,
-0.0279758163,
-0.0057779662,
-0.0240504146,
-0.0252408832,
0.0166670475,
-0.005169007,
0.0653624907,
-0.0198466834,
-0.0105000362,
-0.0191930104,
0.0293251164,
-0.029144777,
-0.0022673134,
0.0305131283,
0.0284085777,
-0.0153156137,
-0.0072915703,
0.0384736806,
-0.0239651483,
0.0208121594,
-0.0132510066,
0.0182121191,
-0.0300576817,
-0.0210520774,
0.0123192342,
0.0523616746,
-0.0193717666,
-0.0164522808,
-0.067854315,
-0.0389548503,
-0.0140737221,
0.0499149933,
0.0014534025,
-0.0123773674,
0.0373318419,
0.026107857,
-0.0540088601,
-0.0126532316,
-0.0460458137,
-0.0279490352,
-0.0075018024,
-0.0161136966,
-0.0744322985,
-6.361019437e-33,
-0.0260363966,
0.0007756102,
0.0076595731,
-0.0104494924,
-0.0416281335,
-0.0490241498,
-0.0009759892,
0.0084830932,
-0.0088359714,
0.0358820707,
0.0054954374,
0.0030545506,
-0.0005035075,
-0.0021126245,
0.0098141506,
-0.0139162205,
0.0592008084,
0.031958539,
-0.0654672682,
0.0045305872,
0.0316140689,
-0.0003735065,
0.0384869538,
-0.0854632482,
0.0486799255,
-0.0061070314,
-0.0261386149,
0.0026844209,
-0.0226440486,
0.0638986975,
0.0062940815,
0.0206519477,
-0.0067152227,
-0.0041074138,
-0.0076561966,
0.0296996459,
-0.0509524718,
-0.0393662602,
0.0712476224,
-0.0185798462,
-0.0339297764,
-0.0480842739,
0.0291323662,
-0.0235087536,
-0.0283594169,
0.0024153448,
0.0322284661,
-0.0258540697,
0.0088206036,
0.0253404956,
-0.0845064819,
-0.0159073919,
-0.0315489471,
-0.0492526516,
-0.0186305922,
0.0521904938,
0.0008972984,
0.0559329204,
-0.0476973057,
0.049730204,
0.0238816775,
-0.0005781517,
0.0672675446,
0.0362689868,
-0.0198953226,
0.064114362,
0.0003835524,
-0.0235224068,
0.0428334139,
-0.0324781612,
0.0154568059,
0.0197013617,
0.0095086666,
0.0691728219,
0.045346193,
-0.0120886024,
-0.0141411237,
0.0283598825,
-0.004975697,
0.0027228964,
0.0368396156,
0.0252091363,
-0.0445544869,
-0.031301368,
-0.0708358586,
-0.045620665,
-0.0368498974,
-0.0472089611,
0.0267553274,
0.0068821348,
-0.0369920917,
-0.0363163501,
-0.0055589853,
-0.0289943218,
-0.0163296703,
0.0366678238,
-0.0591212213,
-0.0046587735,
-0.0187458694,
-0.006704554,
-0.0748316124,
0.0063858288,
0.0102272388,
0.0241229497,
0.0056758788,
0.0317434445,
0.0545923784,
0.0192060731,
-0.0592029095,
0.024510799,
-0.0195728801,
0.0322456956,
-0.0085089374,
-0.0171342678,
0.0584536865,
0.0065188133,
-0.0123869656,
0.0479974486,
0.0431536362,
-0.0394369587,
-0.0620847903,
-0.0118350033,
-0.0246684719,
0.038998045,
-0.0096188216,
0.0146619938,
0.0081717195,
0.0328173339,
0.0175606329,
-0.0448230356,
-0.0193708073,
0.0092368675,
2.738e-7,
0.0082707051,
0.0354166776,
0.011867309,
0.0365834087,
-0.0330869965,
0.0445399806,
0.0009980595,
0.0298801716,
0.03861266,
-0.0008688625,
0.0256208368,
0.0161675867,
0.0216579325,
0.0164800324,
-0.0422363617,
0.0116057163,
-0.0789974406,
-0.0012983637,
-0.0177468676,
-0.0320656747,
0.0579924546,
0.0543444715,
0.0525519848,
-0.0038905817,
0.0086067738,
0.0188639574,
0.0427559651,
-0.0567558892,
0.0186004881,
0.0325961448,
-0.0536049046,
-0.0298897251,
-0.0038303928,
-0.0236441921,
0.0153485397,
0.0214170422,
-0.041318845,
0.0755028948,
-0.0251446422,
-0.0458401553,
-0.0253720917,
0.0209052116,
0.0046266578,
-0.0669777244,
0.0259595718,
-0.0482365601,
0.0006881582,
-0.0420881659,
-0.0409076624,
-0.0053884801,
0.018887233,
-0.041066505,
-0.0336546823,
0.0213571489,
0.0099703642,
0.0448517874,
-0.0346281677,
-0.0432073064,
-0.0341045372,
0.0563842654,
0.0095589561,
-0.0485432707,
0.0058039357,
0.047543887,
-0.0385212898,
-0.0816649348,
0.016719358,
2.500051258e-34,
0.0265281796,
-0.0200471841,
0.0268739965,
0.004117792,
0.0044583748,
0.0267752558,
-0.0232480392,
0.0012390066,
0.0548441261,
-0.0370368212,
-0.0287131257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12949v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12949v1 | Boosting Punctuation Restoration with Data Generation and Reinforcement Learning | 2023-07-24T17:22:04 | 2023-07-24T17:22:04 | Viet Dac Lai, Abel Salinas, Hao Tan, Trung Bui, Quan Tran, Seunghyun Yoon, Hanieh Deilamsalehy, Franck Dernoncourt, Thien Huu Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Punctuation restoration is an important task in automatic speech recognition
(ASR) which aim to restore the syntactic structure of generated ASR texts to
improve readability. While punctuated texts are abundant from written
documents, the discrepancy between written punctuated texts and ASR texts
limits the usability of written texts in training punctuation restoration
systems for ASR texts. This paper proposes a reinforcement learning method to
exploit in-topic written texts and recent advances in large pre-trained
generative language models to bridge this gap. The experiments show that our
method achieves state-of-the-art performance on the ASR test set on two
benchmark datasets for punctuation restoration. | [
0.0054254876,
0.0849509463,
-0.0001423068,
-0.0199808255,
-0.0368137285,
-0.01558463,
0.0084065385,
-0.0018545886,
-0.028100688,
-0.0199748464,
-0.003463051,
0.0048866612,
0.007783988,
-0.0113415737,
0.0337644517,
-0.0810797885,
0.036259681,
-0.0388563722,
0.0095424196,
0.0282261688,
0.0534496419,
0.0028878516,
-0.0226970948,
0.0518993065,
-0.0117041888,
-0.0466498211,
0.0034621384,
0.0314328931,
0.0394915678,
-0.0207101814,
0.0275689717,
0.0114395153,
-0.0338635817,
0.0438266657,
0.0000015527,
-0.0478910767,
-0.0635636821,
0.0147771742,
0.0130605195,
0.0314632468,
0.0197158698,
-0.0424350873,
-0.0451262332,
0.0763268247,
-0.0150628854,
-0.0078772493,
0.0221226923,
0.0373860709,
0.0310762804,
0.1046990082,
-0.0325457416,
-0.0182457529,
0.0201741215,
-0.0131801963,
-0.019823974,
0.0398869589,
0.016593257,
-0.0056527648,
-0.0011486051,
-0.0269650687,
-0.0002787565,
0.034621004,
0.0014777391,
-0.0314157344,
-0.0387039669,
0.0014990751,
-0.0378797203,
0.0122957164,
-0.0527554341,
0.0032386906,
-0.0208287686,
-0.0238767713,
0.0389454216,
-0.0206390284,
-0.0198282395,
-0.0285766125,
-0.0217262805,
-0.0163993742,
-0.0227530003,
0.0376636423,
0.0120297438,
-0.0279130079,
0.0066144289,
-0.0328217186,
-0.016761845,
0.0064408085,
0.0146070225,
-0.0500998497,
-0.0044121016,
0.0187981594,
-0.0132901324,
0.0075810337,
0.0534379557,
-0.0384497344,
-0.008659495,
0.0022774595,
-0.0642412677,
-0.0612473376,
0.0158715323,
0.0145037994,
0.0096901013,
0.0148243988,
0.0005428651,
0.0065280423,
-0.0035019652,
0.0235125367,
-0.0083345408,
-0.0103557697,
0.0012093197,
0.0278567579,
-0.0234517641,
-0.0029027013,
-0.0533290207,
0.0294639748,
0.0193538871,
-0.0412174314,
-0.055764582,
-0.0158406924,
0.0054042153,
0.0124729061,
0.0234230775,
-0.0337776244,
-0.0309536494,
-0.0274552591,
0.0137205608,
0.0046139294,
-0.0020309612,
0.0288990792,
0.0300404336,
-0.0257283673,
-0.0159571283,
0.0113656316,
0.040536508,
-0.0116317784,
-0.0076657431,
0.0412259921,
-0.045930218,
-0.0256606042,
-0.0619208887,
-0.0240793899,
-0.0310704019,
-0.0158512946,
-0.0506778993,
-0.0204653442,
-0.0353634469,
0.0051105986,
-0.0142760137,
-0.0034048839,
0.0055185375,
-0.0039257756,
-0.0035851768,
0.0978023782,
-0.0350446515,
-0.0202546846,
0.0226367954,
-0.0452313796,
0.031072583,
0.0111373086,
0.0627446249,
0.0051641306,
0.0205583144,
0.0339078456,
0.0311718229,
0.0618002266,
-0.0239689294,
-0.026134681,
-0.0197870545,
-0.035531871,
-0.0184463449,
0.0357441641,
0.0394566096,
0.0750142708,
-0.0394277088,
0.0478214808,
0.0512987114,
0.0104876151,
0.0448764078,
0.0150439208,
0.0060890596,
0.0098262141,
0.0128377657,
0.0295388568,
0.0107843755,
-0.0577029288,
-0.020168718,
0.05868157,
0.0582755543,
-0.0145057095,
0.0325637385,
-0.060934443,
0.0083261495,
-0.0283199195,
0.0327153914,
-0.0174933989,
0.0427110791,
0.0395197868,
-0.0875132456,
-0.0427707322,
-0.0127477776,
-0.0579224266,
-0.0133125307,
-0.0172141083,
0.0347616337,
0.0855666772,
0.0853626281,
-0.0737363622,
-0.0151758315,
-0.050803259,
-0.041835323,
0.0469713435,
-0.0396185517,
-0.003853817,
0.042631384,
-0.0712563619,
0.0387033932,
0.0298447404,
0.0153578836,
0.0277002323,
-0.0161576904,
0.0203413293,
0.0268877726,
0.0309642702,
-0.0174665861,
0.0462092906,
0.0040682103,
-0.0166141,
0.0163690113,
-0.0057814983,
0.0324984379,
0.0183279179,
-0.048108615,
0.0050468827,
0.0194694754,
-0.0573281422,
0.0388655551,
0.0000492771,
-0.0698179305,
-0.074946329,
-0.0133798178,
-0.0247504544,
0.0395714529,
0.0123650851,
0.0274338331,
-0.0693806708,
-0.0462586135,
-0.0151646715,
0.0412492678,
-0.064090766,
0.0416805372,
0.0380631834,
0.0172499903,
-0.0313336365,
-0.0306676943,
0.0153607931,
-0.0058435919,
-0.0103483265,
-0.0198486093,
0.0294692572,
-0.0520334058,
0.0219847634,
-0.0053244284,
-0.0137713263,
0.0291216355,
0.0444185063,
0.0078988541,
-0.0097381808,
-0.0278921016,
-0.0372739695,
0.0209809113,
-0.0474360287,
0.017212322,
-0.009534535,
0.0223693922,
-0.0473401621,
-0.050524652,
0.0352640301,
-0.0084012439,
0.0173383933,
-0.0237258859,
0.0625886023,
-0.0059918384,
-0.0096987784,
-0.0855267271,
0.0060107764,
0.0028570453,
0.0194601007,
0.0069872015,
-0.0208562762,
-0.0861838832,
0.0597626232,
0.0505872741,
0.043037992,
0.0176210031,
-0.0748924762,
0.0358505733,
-0.0168069489,
0.1067996323,
0.0833714083,
-0.0022490062,
0.0078365235,
-0.0338255465,
-0.0066313106,
-0.0230835024,
0.0149815455,
0.0020091729,
0.0407229438,
-0.032554429,
0.0211370308,
0.062195994,
0.0578759462,
-0.001153971,
0.0260058641,
-0.0142020881,
0.0214704406,
0.0220364742,
-0.0266568046,
0.0101140989,
-0.0246560834,
-0.036511898,
0.0099840984,
-0.0069289086,
-0.0164245032,
0.0375674292,
-0.0263614729,
-0.0140192639,
-0.0452725329,
0.0044474741,
-0.0134742465,
-0.0004508746,
0.0501375049,
-0.0073085176,
0.0453277305,
-0.095542118,
-0.0470864885,
0.0207778364,
0.0397579558,
-0.0140107144,
0.0151664531,
-0.0394900478,
0.0287186075,
0.0189423431,
-0.0579499081,
-0.0187180322,
0.0021349918,
0.02015201,
0.000855151,
0.027730085,
-0.0262436327,
-0.0204377752,
-0.0222034641,
0.0140545955,
0.1015341878,
0.0117168687,
-0.0003828872,
-0.0224954467,
0.0435847938,
0.0053746989,
-0.0130308308,
-0.0146114323,
-0.0573205948,
-0.0105310418,
-0.0014278113,
0.0205337647,
0.0112353619,
-0.009646588,
-0.0269421972,
0.02249543,
-0.0569668114,
-0.0211243797,
-0.0017953857,
0.0367899351,
-0.0539324433,
-0.0259617791,
0.0802355185,
0.0094952015,
-0.0238126013,
-0.0387436859,
0.0234248023,
0.0418535024,
-0.0161025748,
-0.0062488052,
-0.1004392728,
-0.0264311675,
0.0260868128,
0.0482542962,
0.0209513344,
-0.0009400765,
0.0188654866,
-0.088201642,
0.0366717838,
0.0118148215,
-0.0534568876,
-0.0087848594,
-0.0014772208,
-0.0112321619,
-0.0248520914,
0.0366929397,
0.0423556976,
-0.0333207101,
0.0289188325,
0.0287974924,
-0.0666947961,
-0.0614300445,
-0.0883925781,
-0.0383381471,
0.0473427586,
0.1115552187,
0.0393249989,
0.0035348693,
0.0075140144,
-0.0168181788,
-0.0094016241,
-0.0014462536,
-0.0008384354,
0.0528305471,
0.0156768132,
-0.0182839781,
-0.0101191467,
0.0580126233,
-0.0007587259,
-0.0276404284,
0.0455581546,
-0.0372641571,
-0.0002648817,
0.0252269339,
-0.0129874581,
-0.0145748882,
0.031776797,
0.0379164182,
0.0085402234,
-0.0496312007,
-0.0895440951,
-0.067185685,
0.066650264,
-0.1024056971,
0.0194770135,
-0.0232278444,
-0.0423256643,
-0.012806545,
-0.0976589322,
-0.0374252833,
0.0330629386,
0.0105029885,
-0.0035728337,
0.0001647156,
-0.0074784723,
0.0179511365,
-0.0258957651,
-0.0631736293,
0.0042849733,
-0.0129195917,
-0.0886890441,
0.0056614531,
-0.0467231721,
-0.0427078903,
-0.0160793979,
-0.0157337096,
-0.038852714,
-0.0468380377,
0.0483853817,
0.0521954633,
0.0094113434,
0.0504075363,
-0.0070557105,
-0.0248391721,
0.0310004558,
0.0919756517,
-0.0557721369,
0.0086262953,
0.0462521128,
0.0249305144,
-0.0144330142,
0.0041806949,
-0.0052611041,
0.0243393984,
-0.0173210073,
0.0742900446,
-0.0451664515,
-0.013181014,
0.025687851,
0.0055947718,
0.0790430978,
-0.0266368613,
-0.013904484,
-0.0514442883,
0.0197935794,
-0.0416609421,
0.0264826249,
-0.0447394401,
0.0246391315,
0.0241361801,
0.0076423092,
-0.0536652729,
-0.0449543633,
-0.0315773971,
0.0365343243,
-0.0440803133,
0.0219613109,
0.0654307902,
0.0394739918,
0.0264085121,
-0.0232505314,
0.0423991159,
0.0499899276,
0.0295818355,
0.0362839177,
0.0224880856,
0.0165532194,
0.0017507334,
-0.0054017529,
-0.0202894639,
-0.007263822,
-0.0429337509,
0.0445312969,
-0.0247466769,
0.0624830686,
0.0500101931,
0.0317563787,
0.0841626227,
-0.0241958015,
-0.0003555193,
-0.0046365694,
0.0212300792,
0.0052777026,
0.0409455188,
-0.0597364828,
-0.0032313839,
-0.0291341152,
0.0015358716,
0.0669409335,
-0.0009285005,
-0.0159226786,
0.0186058879,
-0.0111761009,
-0.0519861355,
-0.001081274,
0.0049372832,
0.0137158446,
-0.0038078148,
-0.0180045273,
0.0160557162,
-0.026151713,
0.0127503145,
0.0472566262,
0.0306468457,
-0.0172884297,
0.006431005,
-0.0002325348,
-0.0679700077,
-0.004760521,
-0.0386341102,
-0.0141457114,
0.0011485388,
-0.0479842052,
-0.0196243823,
-5.112830679e-33,
-0.0087243235,
0.0319175236,
-0.0044416897,
0.0019079074,
-0.0282153934,
0.000437982,
-0.0202013776,
-0.027050443,
0.0533601567,
0.0079873223,
-0.0441923924,
0.0041591404,
0.026946146,
0.0316710323,
0.0153716141,
0.0199245531,
0.1164187118,
-0.0121849403,
-0.0010302799,
-0.0134173604,
0.0099690333,
0.0738624483,
0.032966353,
-0.0384030305,
-0.007351751,
-0.006458276,
-0.0467090048,
-0.0137178609,
0.0392078757,
0.0375568382,
0.0239391681,
0.0114660859,
-0.0067616892,
-0.0021108843,
-0.0304059125,
0.0322465748,
-0.10221304,
-0.002951791,
0.0074651367,
0.0228865147,
-0.049661696,
-0.0270743612,
0.0548131466,
-0.0491440035,
0.0141407521,
0.0295732673,
0.0323193446,
-0.0354243889,
-0.0003560529,
-0.0271913558,
-0.0550247915,
0.0194032826,
-0.024932228,
0.0035438768,
0.0586935282,
0.0242516305,
-0.0156138334,
0.0044013369,
-0.0137255909,
0.0108694974,
0.0585135743,
0.0616855174,
-0.0117282541,
0.0490903147,
-0.0002606614,
0.0222112723,
0.0302806273,
0.0236712527,
0.0098621622,
-0.0324349999,
0.0344302282,
0.0008418339,
-0.0203679465,
0.0671200976,
0.0472459607,
-0.0086379917,
-0.0491507277,
0.0039683948,
0.0266312733,
-0.0175625365,
-0.0138505986,
0.0710792914,
-0.040623039,
0.0015744587,
-0.0113180736,
-0.0017411722,
0.0186149552,
-0.0356656983,
0.0300437286,
0.0208052676,
-0.0097257691,
0.0078749219,
0.0378049314,
-0.0257659219,
-0.0167761184,
-0.0022342976,
-0.0282289274,
0.0083500808,
-0.0516749807,
-0.0150750177,
-0.0465849936,
-0.0181168914,
0.0307671018,
0.0143242385,
-0.0042535006,
-0.0120355291,
0.0063961716,
0.0126365032,
-0.0846662372,
0.0164112877,
0.0241097175,
0.0604698919,
-0.0017616159,
-0.0008915169,
0.0283674672,
0.0106768534,
0.0448972322,
0.0291361734,
0.0194306839,
-0.0068373405,
0.0074322661,
-0.0614432618,
0.0004245696,
0.0117386961,
-0.0469437391,
-0.0328848138,
0.0127423834,
0.0157293361,
-0.0207838435,
-0.0547388308,
-0.0013711677,
-0.004646569,
2.221e-7,
0.0270006638,
0.0739548951,
0.0600498505,
-0.0079655396,
-0.0039186813,
-0.0089031383,
-0.0110515384,
0.033378683,
0.0163928103,
0.0622467995,
0.0464376509,
-0.0624007545,
0.0696660951,
-0.021237921,
-0.1404173672,
-0.0085220886,
-0.0542304702,
0.0068227821,
-0.0508291349,
-0.0363152102,
0.0149903977,
0.0176690482,
-0.0046633673,
0.022345772,
0.008246283,
-0.0225557107,
0.0211267173,
-0.0224168357,
-0.0317306109,
0.0362709612,
0.0479855612,
0.0174662657,
-0.0206600111,
-0.0109980404,
-0.0143542727,
0.0060144323,
0.0315768048,
0.0349657685,
0.0139228906,
0.0074330964,
0.0149381328,
0.0377330855,
0.0015255922,
-0.0098511353,
0.0284231566,
-0.0017001195,
0.0447087623,
-0.0199208148,
-0.070116818,
-0.0475696027,
0.0494461246,
-0.0332425199,
-0.0185887907,
0.026548449,
0.0259070154,
0.0423382744,
-0.0088732168,
-0.0154277962,
-0.0357068703,
0.0222944673,
0.000129747,
0.0426238142,
-0.014319648,
0.0180197544,
-0.0155658079,
-0.082062155,
-0.0021764154,
1.975056884e-34,
0.0529705584,
-0.0590375215,
0.0310130212,
0.0398042388,
0.0086755427,
-0.0034737871,
0.0112337898,
0.0605173223,
0.0212981831,
-0.0624586605,
-0.0079462174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13018v1 | The potential of LLMs for coding with low-resource and domain-specific programming languages | 2023-07-24T17:17:13 | 2023-07-24T17:17:13 | Artur Tarassow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE, D.2.3; I.2.7 | This paper presents a study on the feasibility of using large language models
(LLM) for coding with low-resource and domain-specific programming languages
that typically lack the amount of data required for effective LLM processing
techniques. This study focuses on the econometric scripting language named
hansl of the open-source software gretl and employs a proprietary LLM based on
GPT-3.5. Our findings suggest that LLMs can be a useful tool for writing,
understanding, improving, and documenting gretl code, which includes generating
descriptive docstrings for functions and providing precise explanations for
abstract and poorly documented econometric code. While the LLM showcased
promoting docstring-to-code translation capability, we also identify some
limitations, such as its inability to improve certain sections of code and to
write accurate unit tests. This study is a step towards leveraging the power of
LLMs to facilitate software development in low-resource programming languages
and ultimately to lower barriers to entry for their adoption. | [
-0.0357368961,
0.0797659457,
-0.0332024917,
0.013443538,
-0.0365412086,
0.0097946534,
0.0049277744,
0.0199625418,
0.0174692553,
-0.017147461,
0.0069360142,
0.0337918699,
0.0454489999,
0.0599366538,
0.0181851201,
-0.0216640178,
0.0496576503,
-0.0247452315,
0.0014769251,
0.0188788157,
-0.007573179,
0.0097304694,
0.0413856432,
0.0252931882,
0.0326665267,
-0.0065945489,
-0.0040842812,
0.0182205103,
-0.0304268952,
-0.0107031614,
-0.0124779632,
0.0206712615,
0.0146627538,
0.0142523088,
0.0000022096,
-0.0905344412,
-0.0337636545,
0.0646695271,
0.0150650032,
0.079178229,
0.052772969,
0.0063566221,
-0.0069510876,
0.0132937189,
0.0015759064,
0.0072241249,
0.0629036799,
-0.0729680955,
0.0115095926,
0.0114626605,
0.0188470967,
-0.0261577424,
-0.0181772262,
-0.0116122253,
0.0030020443,
0.0143126119,
0.0196080375,
0.0649358854,
0.0387637354,
0.0134135922,
-0.0071328771,
0.020175295,
0.017195683,
-0.0195617266,
-0.008395615,
0.0193721149,
-0.0113207372,
0.000320228,
-0.0019022279,
0.0028668058,
0.0747746676,
-0.0184413232,
0.043953158,
-0.0047033262,
0.0069286311,
0.0018988656,
-0.0804003105,
0.0297459736,
0.0243007839,
0.0014335889,
0.0338139609,
-0.0352999829,
0.0020448163,
0.001960617,
-0.0251961295,
0.0676032379,
-0.0174770057,
-0.0365843922,
-0.0086842785,
-0.007034353,
-0.0094597414,
-0.0226707458,
-0.0398441702,
0.0059392848,
0.0475305766,
0.0165946744,
0.0003095343,
-0.0229152311,
0.0668761581,
-0.020827733,
0.0076379059,
0.018755367,
0.0275587328,
0.0094136484,
0.00913068,
0.040597368,
-0.0117394421,
-0.0609666705,
0.0137489839,
0.0447809584,
-0.0269442387,
-0.0219140928,
-0.0450572632,
0.0085666645,
0.0217847489,
0.0633146763,
-0.0356314778,
0.035816595,
-0.0137424264,
0.0445484295,
-0.0171147939,
-0.0606284179,
-0.0081674699,
0.0160407536,
0.0158624798,
0.0134220133,
0.009508403,
-0.0307871606,
-0.0154557629,
-0.0596083403,
0.0140206814,
0.0325856432,
-0.0280167125,
-0.0257834885,
0.0425129309,
0.0928369612,
0.0533965193,
0.0436098389,
-0.0139922965,
-0.0400871709,
0.0150078004,
-0.0215167124,
-0.0282001179,
-0.115474306,
-0.0295275915,
0.0354574621,
0.0112793185,
-0.044940237,
-0.0247912537,
-0.0058806017,
-0.0087509789,
0.0222720429,
-0.0426199101,
0.0164836328,
0.0027040532,
-0.0163106378,
0.0216350071,
0.0437167361,
0.0116555952,
-0.0316001698,
0.0155964224,
-0.0717007443,
0.01606456,
0.0454701744,
-0.0353223644,
0.0274935607,
-0.021020934,
0.0436220132,
0.0197422635,
-0.0133334026,
0.0177452415,
-0.0080300961,
-0.0026287031,
0.0365171619,
0.0332718231,
0.0482285842,
0.0260233711,
0.0195148289,
0.0415111445,
0.0507722534,
0.0013394532,
-0.0553945005,
-0.0093624182,
0.0263066515,
-0.0190465115,
0.0449657552,
-0.0357845686,
0.0446968973,
0.0145630166,
-0.0416016318,
-0.0134731736,
-0.0125314789,
-0.0271164216,
-0.0013640065,
0.0732710585,
-0.0297841094,
-0.0245299824,
0.0486606658,
0.0271654408,
-0.0385740809,
-0.0401226804,
-0.0563196652,
0.0443230197,
0.0167124309,
0.0149678951,
-0.0417385921,
0.0157130454,
-0.0449513532,
0.0179972854,
0.0192298386,
0.0648868084,
0.0263374541,
-0.0235067084,
-0.0376092717,
0.0074657309,
-0.0120992512,
-0.0190949384,
0.0901296884,
-0.0066195573,
-0.014991737,
0.0156222945,
-0.0329858549,
-0.009645056,
0.0025693376,
-0.0141582182,
-0.0343167484,
0.0037093922,
-0.0267069209,
0.0249715894,
-0.019288715,
-0.0361750536,
0.030016521,
0.01059236,
0.0142891342,
0.0044178092,
-0.0261005852,
0.0241246875,
0.0540742688,
0.0142189497,
-0.0229270682,
-0.040773008,
-0.0162504781,
-0.0201197881,
0.0032505444,
0.0689812005,
-0.0040295133,
0.0456933714,
0.0055476641,
0.0025249033,
-0.0541770086,
-0.0299386531,
-0.0206458718,
0.0091067543,
0.0312618464,
0.0266911574,
-0.0115250833,
0.0036998843,
0.0252230242,
-0.0153477462,
-0.005317294,
0.0054613026,
-0.0058448403,
0.0229755864,
0.0325234532,
0.0530932397,
0.0237669535,
-0.0434986763,
-0.046456594,
0.0071901111,
0.0305839423,
0.0385084078,
0.027424708,
0.0073048519,
-0.0278530959,
0.0407296866,
0.0172107331,
-0.0014178065,
0.0016562056,
0.0120452251,
0.028635053,
-0.0383582488,
-0.0797952563,
0.002939973,
-0.0267176758,
-0.0235157441,
0.0412833914,
0.0239425525,
-0.0100207683,
-0.0734236017,
0.0456982553,
0.0188472401,
-0.0266186148,
-0.0236844476,
-0.0143338535,
-0.0141624575,
-0.0422248729,
0.0579749681,
0.0019178799,
-0.0938366503,
0.0119662052,
0.0268510822,
-0.0398146473,
-0.0519634895,
-0.013781243,
0.0178702958,
-0.0243917927,
0.0135978013,
-0.0571146309,
0.0235588718,
0.062913768,
-0.0010404252,
-0.009616985,
0.0046745599,
0.0332862474,
-0.0200729053,
-0.0023977254,
-0.025285542,
0.0037414669,
-0.0115968194,
0.034592893,
0.0388729759,
-0.1201955974,
0.009834893,
-0.0580536909,
-0.0257742908,
-0.0448443182,
-0.0667271167,
-0.0811491087,
0.0071477746,
-0.0164069794,
-0.0163344853,
-0.0269127302,
-0.0155938873,
0.0066355383,
0.0168210212,
0.0010064436,
0.0043558171,
0.0831439719,
-0.0342413113,
0.0174170937,
-0.006988483,
0.0200748462,
0.0505747572,
-0.0073384754,
-0.0193563644,
0.0017107558,
0.0383051373,
-0.018629672,
0.031985078,
0.0142221963,
0.0519997366,
-0.0025671849,
0.0338503383,
-0.0245372467,
0.0138580129,
-0.0641042739,
-0.0578634664,
-0.074883543,
-0.0149120772,
-0.0601091832,
0.0093348231,
-0.0235456023,
-0.0144274589,
0.0408156551,
-0.0641881749,
-0.0190233346,
0.0188467987,
-0.0260669887,
-0.0300447065,
0.0576394126,
-0.0001148391,
-0.0441366695,
0.0114581045,
0.0672578663,
-0.006779837,
-0.0030935369,
0.0029340407,
-0.0505544171,
0.0722615346,
0.0412337072,
0.0511596501,
-0.0563364998,
0.0317676701,
0.0083631529,
0.0533889756,
-0.0397575945,
0.0028889505,
-0.0216606297,
-0.0830699876,
0.0730046406,
0.0086161634,
-0.0068825101,
-0.044992324,
-0.0711629763,
-0.028415136,
-0.0185012687,
-0.0179568026,
0.0449468307,
-0.0185963418,
0.0181380156,
0.0065695173,
-0.1199466214,
-0.0282410048,
0.0074707107,
0.0215044562,
0.0159990042,
0.0716788098,
0.0349549241,
-0.0731979907,
0.0072267884,
0.0530724004,
0.0143785523,
-0.0024235256,
-0.0486845821,
-0.0155185852,
0.043631319,
-0.0259085633,
0.0058297422,
-0.0083141802,
-0.0449856445,
0.0013636469,
0.0418888032,
0.0331504419,
-0.013490594,
-0.0427155904,
-0.0060766675,
-0.0034621477,
-0.0119064394,
0.0367719568,
0.028851239,
-0.0083979247,
-0.0326583534,
-0.0620241314,
-0.084145993,
0.010154088,
0.0101319868,
-0.0465030335,
-0.0348982885,
0.0256113093,
0.0305531807,
-0.001197605,
0.0590932518,
0.0013163793,
0.0245368443,
0.0005955755,
0.0236416813,
-0.0161473677,
-0.0550965481,
-0.0057505453,
-0.0597786456,
0.0448800288,
-0.023987066,
-0.0174923521,
0.0176011641,
0.0173401423,
-0.0217835866,
0.0223164521,
-0.0520381667,
-0.0722307786,
0.0002869658,
0.0749417022,
0.0345565528,
-0.0398860201,
0.0056414399,
-0.0031915237,
-0.0716115609,
0.0414597541,
-0.0038116744,
0.037452925,
-0.0126754986,
0.0431211479,
0.0145083703,
-0.0410918854,
-0.0275784638,
-0.0290589519,
-0.000661623,
-0.0096477447,
-0.0181985255,
-0.0266336557,
-0.0171206091,
0.0590762459,
-0.0058185742,
-0.0004225816,
0.0096529368,
-0.0023309414,
-0.027097201,
-0.010363061,
0.0074610296,
-0.0395031609,
-0.0148641421,
0.0228389464,
-0.0125595462,
0.0185001977,
0.035021089,
-0.0366212241,
-0.0145657286,
-0.0021993301,
0.1364584565,
-0.023963511,
0.0071570007,
0.057524588,
-0.0053360425,
-0.0094475141,
0.0011110845,
-0.0223499183,
0.025020957,
0.0198212136,
0.027196575,
-0.0080410717,
0.0182507876,
0.0646887049,
0.0081690159,
0.032650128,
-0.079430595,
0.011657564,
-0.0040339166,
-0.0239976663,
0.0098778615,
0.0454550646,
-0.0490928963,
0.0142497569,
-0.0502406694,
0.0501532815,
-0.0200994555,
0.0048611788,
0.027295066,
-0.0032204278,
-0.0859439,
-0.0630445629,
0.0686236843,
0.0883593932,
-0.0421370417,
-0.0245261583,
-0.0255993512,
-0.0180873945,
0.0135810645,
0.0739372671,
-0.0330030881,
-0.0154492147,
-0.0219375435,
-0.0805797875,
-0.0529399775,
-0.0722645521,
-0.0008000229,
0.0231633857,
-0.0191315413,
-0.0023936601,
0.0511967167,
-0.0120425345,
0.0347597338,
-0.0108181648,
0.0141843576,
-0.0357263722,
-0.0592280626,
0.0244557709,
-5.960832671e-33,
-0.0274358932,
-0.0268508755,
0.0227749199,
0.0291253645,
0.0251405369,
-0.0187551714,
-0.0101016713,
-0.0019823636,
0.0211558286,
-0.0426698178,
0.0573073067,
-0.0162762906,
-0.0002963211,
-0.0368910842,
0.049657777,
0.0383539051,
0.0007999649,
0.03816057,
0.0073271338,
-0.0375770666,
-0.024824677,
0.0213569123,
0.0763150603,
-0.0626228526,
0.0292740613,
-0.0035036844,
0.036817424,
-0.0192690622,
0.0363207683,
0.0307699256,
0.0292548928,
0.0002314891,
-0.0105103115,
-0.0484764203,
-0.0424179509,
0.0196028408,
-0.0149970334,
-0.0316193216,
0.0387044586,
-0.0175855458,
0.0573993996,
-0.0367640145,
0.047732722,
0.0279367995,
-0.045468431,
-0.0025609809,
0.0216427073,
0.0065063788,
-0.0141484309,
-0.0264749546,
-0.042007897,
0.0425799526,
-0.0243282411,
0.075315088,
-0.0111489818,
0.0184505749,
-0.0492845848,
0.0274480749,
0.0509510972,
-0.007791556,
0.0610229596,
0.0230792463,
0.0681228042,
-0.0178424418,
0.0407190472,
-0.0065457248,
-0.0069562527,
0.0419306718,
-0.0301349387,
-0.0062744501,
0.045536086,
-0.0066547976,
-0.0002490897,
0.0242783073,
0.0035052695,
-0.0035369627,
-0.0520315059,
0.0019107943,
-0.0029708925,
0.0095513258,
0.0156578962,
0.0150635932,
-0.0159015786,
-0.0441459641,
-0.0555465557,
-0.004218624,
-0.0121393697,
-0.058145199,
0.0414447263,
-0.0735312849,
-0.02181991,
0.0074541839,
0.0190589968,
-0.0220696777,
-0.0565828942,
-0.0230923835,
-0.0272444542,
0.0239730012,
-0.0136148594,
0.0140998829,
-0.0384059027,
-0.0253862478,
-0.0486700349,
0.0302895177,
0.0875978172,
0.0093377633,
-0.0240719803,
-0.007099174,
-0.0896285027,
0.0117618376,
-0.020649882,
0.0018726939,
0.0001652225,
0.0227963254,
0.0221753251,
-0.0142698325,
0.0502004027,
-0.0015295583,
0.0226400271,
-0.0672004074,
-0.0188764296,
-0.0079103559,
-0.0141168963,
0.0016426867,
-0.01561666,
-0.0303562563,
-0.0060472963,
0.0436254032,
0.0689846203,
0.0153455622,
-0.0412403792,
-0.0098140175,
2.979e-7,
0.0540858284,
0.0678469092,
-0.0432147272,
0.0605432019,
-0.0099615846,
0.0206934456,
-0.028089596,
0.0121054761,
0.0253242534,
-0.0189161021,
-0.0009980944,
-0.0126471221,
0.0351396278,
0.0016940808,
-0.0504964478,
0.0231211949,
-0.0128204189,
0.0130781466,
-0.07037393,
0.01623399,
0.0095655676,
0.0030097584,
0.0259621888,
0.0065520345,
-0.0375197791,
-0.0569003969,
-0.0041365977,
-0.0913900658,
0.0067724427,
0.0341853723,
-0.0328021981,
0.0390663408,
0.0145280063,
0.0123210931,
0.0035332006,
-0.0558905303,
0.0112622688,
0.0760728046,
0.01921973,
0.0837505832,
0.0896352082,
-0.0456337743,
-0.0275605246,
-0.0801274329,
0.0219343156,
0.0075714444,
-0.0474024788,
-0.0352330282,
-0.0251607057,
-0.0252178982,
-0.0159841441,
-0.0342429951,
0.0526789762,
-0.0026481326,
-0.01610649,
-0.039494738,
-0.0092364307,
0.0616247542,
-0.0247480087,
0.0422597975,
-0.027275078,
-0.0862622112,
-0.0394396707,
0.0762025341,
0.0334360451,
-0.0133451242,
0.0283089876,
3.512454032e-34,
0.0683164522,
-0.0480508804,
0.031159481,
0.0239768215,
0.0383247137,
0.0256130788,
-0.0268600658,
0.0377869196,
-0.0010777377,
-0.0398161337,
0.0011411363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12935v1 | Rule By Example: Harnessing Logical Rules for Explainable Hate Speech Detection | 2023-07-24T16:55:37 | 2023-07-24T16:55:37 | Christopher Clarke, Matthew Hall, Gaurav Mittal, Ye Yu, Sandra Sajeev, Jason Mars, Mei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Classic approaches to content moderation typically apply a rule-based
heuristic approach to flag content. While rules are easily customizable and
intuitive for humans to interpret, they are inherently fragile and lack the
flexibility or robustness needed to moderate the vast amount of undesirable
content found online today. Recent advances in deep learning have demonstrated
the promise of using highly effective deep neural models to overcome these
challenges. However, despite the improved performance, these data-driven models
lack transparency and explainability, often leading to mistrust from everyday
users and a lack of adoption by many platforms. In this paper, we present Rule
By Example (RBE): a novel exemplar-based contrastive learning approach for
learning from logical rules for the task of textual content moderation. RBE is
capable of providing rule-grounded predictions, allowing for more explainable
and customizable predictions compared to typical deep learning-based
approaches. We demonstrate that our approach is capable of learning rich rule
embedding representations using only a few data examples. Experimental results
on 3 popular hate speech classification datasets show that RBE is able to
outperform state-of-the-art deep learning classifiers as well as the use of
rules in both supervised and unsupervised settings while providing explainable
model predictions via rule-grounding. | [
0.0717239976,
0.0734202564,
-0.0039048588,
0.0095843226,
-0.0016356393,
0.0348367542,
0.0537357107,
0.0148414318,
-0.0076978975,
-0.0151620042,
0.0214519463,
-0.017825257,
-0.0232898146,
0.0513226576,
-0.0321613774,
-0.0427378826,
0.0143230818,
0.0421545878,
0.043830201,
0.0065558092,
0.0645333603,
0.0305755455,
0.003844887,
0.044043459,
-0.071061641,
0.0042473944,
0.0223437138,
-0.0069809305,
0.0088540977,
0.0340717286,
0.0531038158,
0.0189759955,
0.0494783893,
0.0839065686,
0.0000018672,
-0.0254867692,
-0.0064398777,
-0.0208153073,
-0.0224596485,
-0.0326772109,
0.0593270138,
-0.0478990413,
-0.0204597581,
0.0379182696,
-0.0222796779,
0.0166549403,
0.0653415024,
0.1050382182,
0.0804319307,
0.0673692152,
-0.0201102458,
-0.0340765901,
0.0146813178,
0.0048486427,
-0.0168321114,
0.0400089771,
0.0260979738,
-0.0316895731,
-0.076159209,
-0.0293009896,
-0.0177246425,
-0.018571157,
0.0779758394,
-0.0277632512,
-0.0265211761,
-0.0278516859,
-0.0090445345,
-0.0210764613,
0.0013370727,
0.0741090775,
-0.0523419753,
-0.0503680818,
0.0044975309,
-0.0158739258,
0.0067115058,
-0.0075086011,
-0.0349424258,
-0.0194668546,
-0.0018887906,
0.0566960573,
0.0287996344,
0.0297981985,
0.0661238804,
0.0655509159,
0.0184202082,
0.0232332926,
-0.0548882149,
-0.0185532328,
-0.0062958486,
-0.0235854723,
0.0229971018,
0.0158240311,
0.0394793823,
0.0107179778,
-0.0166681092,
-0.0074019879,
-0.0357451923,
-0.0279122349,
-0.0036667367,
-0.048962377,
0.0283201206,
0.0533067882,
-0.0242765602,
0.0374062955,
-0.006307845,
0.0147900805,
-0.0206872616,
0.0276125576,
0.0086150952,
-0.0018098298,
-0.0346962027,
0.0045665628,
0.0103137987,
-0.0038343167,
-0.0318218656,
0.0243663173,
-0.0252284948,
-0.0289528742,
-0.0666667596,
-0.0060808877,
0.0011747619,
0.0576566942,
-0.0075569493,
0.0079205856,
-0.034940403,
-0.0051378198,
-0.0414140411,
0.0291021783,
-0.0026201278,
-0.042806793,
0.0013197924,
0.0307132658,
-0.0025930323,
0.006700227,
0.0531859808,
0.059762869,
0.0482358932,
0.0040420284,
-0.0306550711,
-0.029376423,
0.0011845934,
-0.0389119871,
0.0171768814,
-0.048412133,
-0.0006543331,
-0.049215883,
-0.0254353359,
-0.0719567984,
-0.0001467435,
0.0199645218,
-0.0045732167,
0.0944879949,
0.0055879783,
-0.0508940332,
0.0129104564,
0.0365042724,
-0.0119916378,
0.03466231,
0.0174696911,
0.0352721587,
0.0379525349,
-0.018782394,
0.0289746355,
-0.0128446659,
0.0461186953,
-0.0029646589,
-0.0374523997,
0.0034718267,
-0.0737106502,
-0.0131464684,
0.0208668076,
0.0362450518,
-0.0069996454,
-0.0748898834,
0.0431332439,
0.034204185,
0.0098663475,
0.0564484224,
0.0750980601,
0.0239041541,
-0.0438678414,
-0.0300070401,
-0.0623400435,
0.0085156951,
-0.0018756342,
-0.050444454,
-0.022532437,
0.0649076551,
-0.0327867605,
-0.0757054016,
0.0017250283,
-0.0158698391,
0.0633604005,
-0.0162430238,
0.0289747864,
0.0116039943,
-0.0167073552,
0.0014459681,
0.0613438338,
-0.0237955563,
-0.0055647283,
-0.0599947497,
0.0451794565,
0.0790096894,
0.0218610857,
-0.0266383849,
0.0132202134,
-0.0816150233,
0.0608510114,
0.0346417017,
0.0347519405,
-0.0082206763,
0.0287734233,
-0.0676931292,
-0.0363924168,
-0.0182211343,
0.0113721676,
0.0096217766,
0.0285749193,
-0.0210102331,
0.0071085296,
0.043201223,
-0.0504329279,
0.0332243405,
0.0403062962,
-0.0299948286,
0.0217555426,
0.0240571816,
0.0384754278,
0.039938949,
-0.0056004296,
-0.0549422428,
0.0096594803,
-0.0182328615,
-0.0475627854,
-0.0153541844,
-0.0516941845,
-0.002860172,
0.0211783536,
-0.0578409098,
-0.011496271,
0.0541334935,
-0.0284117889,
0.0211765375,
0.0144369192,
-0.0146799712,
-0.0103872316,
-0.0343607329,
-0.0608998649,
-0.0299824961,
0.0275847856,
-0.0100597832,
0.0473578945,
-0.0293673128,
-0.0164083634,
0.0298322234,
-0.0432250015,
0.0300641097,
0.0514938682,
0.0015491772,
-0.0478954427,
-0.0487592518,
0.022775244,
-0.0005541959,
0.0262473244,
-0.016175352,
0.0135885077,
-0.0235783421,
-0.0037456534,
-0.0374256484,
-0.021448575,
0.0055053816,
-0.0210214071,
0.0267913491,
-0.0047123623,
-0.0415881388,
-0.034032125,
0.0096469745,
0.0052752043,
0.035076905,
-0.0631195307,
-0.0592360161,
-0.0212250054,
-0.0198626351,
-0.0377170742,
0.0300327018,
0.0105619328,
-0.0120023778,
0.0274238978,
-0.0275585838,
-0.0173897706,
0.017766688,
-0.0231950693,
-0.0398840643,
0.0309263878,
0.0173952729,
-0.0351546109,
0.017268708,
0.0180181228,
0.0988215804,
0.0296243336,
0.0330859087,
-0.0296789221,
0.0044152234,
-0.0318165794,
0.0781981647,
-0.0299417693,
0.0060787275,
-0.0111253038,
0.0611062534,
0.0261058677,
-0.0069984123,
-0.0734627619,
0.0844082907,
-0.0197230186,
-0.0381972007,
-0.0247244779,
-0.0531317666,
0.0171292927,
-0.0034703203,
-0.0567033291,
-0.0723562688,
0.103526406,
0.0215556119,
0.0189483128,
-0.0192670599,
-0.0554218814,
-0.0258947182,
0.0300863292,
-0.015305833,
0.0151542192,
-0.0092849322,
-0.0006721715,
0.0124376277,
-0.0175499618,
0.0270541552,
-0.0074450672,
0.0014362157,
-0.0406785123,
-0.0235296357,
0.0133744581,
-0.0494594201,
-0.0710704252,
-0.0338445567,
-0.0188189652,
0.0008348688,
0.0055434764,
-0.0076260213,
-0.0164107252,
-0.0017714154,
0.0289344769,
-0.0071883649,
0.022070324,
-0.0190051477,
0.0220581256,
-0.0337359644,
0.0043481216,
0.0228652582,
0.022317227,
0.0030053104,
0.0121188695,
0.0270979144,
-0.0231449418,
-0.002111197,
-0.0355029143,
0.0429615229,
-0.0081388876,
0.0024991082,
0.0067391773,
0.0036727355,
0.0155033432,
-0.0536070503,
0.026356589,
0.0706026107,
0.0212549269,
-0.0135759767,
-0.0009848274,
-0.0031025393,
-0.0167171806,
0.0032901433,
-0.0189910028,
-0.078253828,
-0.0284177568,
0.0104895849,
-0.0003258996,
-0.035596706,
-0.0319784768,
0.0064209234,
-0.0167637002,
0.0169152375,
-0.022141479,
-0.0528345816,
-0.0756060928,
-0.0337296091,
-0.0105528971,
-0.0455622785,
0.0267977733,
-0.0461809486,
0.0480808914,
0.0019975738,
0.0129821906,
-0.0568827242,
-0.0290797744,
0.023730319,
-0.0423984565,
0.0303264819,
0.0379023477,
0.047196351,
-0.0047117523,
-0.0338829458,
-0.0014855962,
0.0125018833,
-0.0231902543,
-0.0420521274,
0.0724231228,
0.0146343615,
-0.032523036,
-0.04401787,
0.0643430725,
-0.0303265881,
-0.0217446182,
-0.03481723,
0.0744606256,
0.0256179441,
-0.0073652137,
-0.0485594608,
0.0105738901,
0.0071852342,
0.0683289021,
0.0453910232,
-0.0542962253,
-0.0032585997,
-0.0974144787,
0.0076800836,
-0.0644629672,
-0.0614999756,
-0.0293016378,
0.019468775,
0.004796362,
0.0018437731,
-0.0319372788,
-0.0034157527,
0.0190090425,
0.0279827323,
-0.0226210915,
-0.0095593696,
-0.0307893828,
-0.0264301542,
0.0118627558,
0.0167068411,
0.0313676782,
-0.006692131,
-0.0038801259,
-0.022076387,
-0.0111630652,
-0.0353707336,
0.0107443556,
0.003817894,
-0.0281700511,
0.052011475,
0.0584591925,
0.0100114401,
0.0292436741,
0.0018257041,
-0.0449211299,
0.0507402383,
0.0482371412,
-0.0129727758,
-0.0753564313,
0.0969113186,
-0.0183534771,
0.0372364558,
0.0277417544,
-0.0092949662,
0.053136982,
0.0244483911,
-0.0407098792,
-0.0725412741,
0.0226740278,
-0.0012938387,
-0.0491257757,
0.013978675,
0.0222082362,
-0.0785276368,
-0.0490584448,
-0.0169942155,
0.0138406195,
-0.0194592532,
-0.0180001054,
0.0301803779,
0.0306974296,
-0.0189119857,
-0.0432488322,
-0.0134266606,
-0.0080820685,
0.0295782313,
-0.0144913942,
0.0240779407,
0.0190582629,
0.0353050046,
-0.0055775042,
0.0228796937,
-0.0242493469,
0.068756938,
0.0056243939,
-0.0166199394,
0.0027771858,
0.0350575261,
0.0131439967,
0.0281648077,
0.0125260642,
-0.0413579419,
0.008027005,
-0.0160919633,
-0.0242815726,
-0.0462938808,
0.0008092369,
-0.0327069722,
0.0133331958,
0.025352044,
-0.0213766992,
0.0121921841,
0.0454848148,
-0.014364345,
-0.0178950578,
0.0129196635,
0.036609184,
-0.0352501534,
-0.0104051419,
0.002803477,
-0.0008554123,
0.0327900723,
0.0308386181,
-0.0469800718,
-0.0203497671,
-0.0058800392,
0.037623316,
0.0618465655,
0.0150782503,
0.0174798574,
-0.0333284885,
-0.0280616563,
-0.0077949921,
-0.0297317188,
0.0260445941,
-0.0087425467,
0.0030897055,
0.0537761115,
0.0102685643,
-0.0053349277,
0.0001045429,
-0.0371283554,
0.0131831039,
-0.0545245111,
-0.0197517648,
-5.550087027e-33,
0.0142549546,
-0.0110830879,
-0.0191073213,
0.0005173947,
0.0271059908,
-0.0072235917,
0.0079209926,
-0.0487920307,
-0.0157360286,
0.0581112653,
0.0132739199,
0.032487154,
-0.0041257953,
0.0260306541,
-0.0350356139,
-0.0297078528,
0.0612363927,
-0.0127983354,
0.0002899017,
0.0226491559,
0.0456362255,
0.0306128524,
0.0075209797,
-0.1006861106,
0.0177994501,
0.048497241,
-0.0110595562,
0.0256516039,
-0.0297559146,
0.0902594179,
-0.014683296,
0.0658130199,
0.0387243219,
-0.0418676808,
0.0022413207,
0.0385387689,
-0.0626150221,
-0.0172764882,
0.0070292586,
-0.0159766208,
-0.0051259822,
-0.0282158982,
0.0575866699,
0.0130133172,
0.0047128396,
-0.0325660035,
0.0359570943,
-0.0327337272,
0.0198076665,
-0.0723958686,
-0.0425260961,
0.0185342077,
-0.0511753671,
-0.0200269688,
0.0028371718,
0.0095326379,
0.0264244191,
0.0177731439,
-0.0987845138,
-0.0173696764,
-0.0140063856,
-0.0014383274,
0.0151499128,
-0.0356356278,
-0.0212432891,
0.0708968937,
0.005593074,
0.0275200028,
-0.0533691049,
0.0235134717,
0.019976072,
0.0638451278,
0.0813420713,
0.0527098477,
0.0397537127,
-0.0612769052,
-0.08777567,
-0.0109934276,
0.0244832486,
0.0142659359,
0.016474735,
-0.0107316244,
-0.0679436028,
-0.0137857571,
-0.0082408627,
-0.0505094081,
-0.0137649616,
-0.0300229453,
0.0042893789,
-0.012063304,
-0.0287383422,
-0.0434117392,
-0.0009893357,
-0.0532980822,
0.0193436649,
0.0724623054,
-0.0000934707,
-0.0361664034,
0.0499953143,
0.0007641275,
-0.0758688822,
-0.0051441635,
0.010489529,
-0.0515716225,
0.03639853,
-0.0148805389,
0.0904202238,
0.0630058274,
-0.0464605205,
0.0143702263,
-0.0128445523,
0.0369967818,
-0.0090470109,
0.0555273741,
-0.0074089128,
0.043286372,
-0.0041940082,
-0.0134503525,
0.0185082518,
-0.0159592424,
-0.0102729732,
-0.007267266,
-0.0309608337,
0.0131408339,
-0.0230590031,
-0.0465947986,
-0.0231693313,
0.0266413502,
0.0412827283,
-0.1098266989,
0.0034839988,
-0.0268621724,
2.427e-7,
0.0164910108,
0.0179512743,
0.0164552554,
-0.0075747943,
0.020129839,
0.0525858551,
0.0597226731,
0.0235572681,
-0.0498928204,
-0.0045626657,
0.0048772846,
0.0768847689,
0.0211321022,
0.0245409198,
-0.0019631649,
-0.0191700086,
-0.0484083965,
-0.0219097789,
-0.0306266416,
0.009797167,
0.0090025961,
0.1016970351,
0.0802736282,
-0.0560164414,
0.0225263275,
-0.0019404433,
0.0031357633,
-0.0486345403,
0.0104670608,
-0.0395861529,
0.0938537866,
-0.0289368015,
0.0012902147,
-0.011117693,
0.0021313033,
0.0376030989,
-0.0374903567,
0.0582827069,
0.0198389608,
0.0124399234,
0.0105218217,
-0.036021322,
0.0104028527,
-0.0143012581,
0.0416920744,
-0.0247464105,
-0.0106372992,
-0.038546063,
-0.0136566395,
-0.036978595,
0.0357741825,
-0.0054620281,
-0.0021654377,
-0.0356478803,
-0.0121814087,
-0.0203338284,
0.0191910714,
-0.0731355399,
0.0005414608,
-0.0030734264,
-0.0122702168,
0.0027665386,
-0.0087250583,
-0.0298436955,
0.0557384193,
0.0329178981,
0.0562254041,
2.342047598e-34,
0.0291856546,
-0.0315740258,
0.0006976724,
-0.0281468052,
0.029410826,
0.0208006632,
-0.0055388925,
-0.0202027094,
0.0702144653,
-0.0187889319,
-0.0141506111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12896v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12896v4 | Corrections of Zipf's and Heaps' Laws Derived from Hapax Rate Models | 2023-07-24T15:44:23 | 2024-01-28T17:49:35 | Łukasz Dębowski | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP, 62P99, I.2.7 | The article introduces corrections to Zipf's and Heaps' laws based on
systematic models of the proportion of hapaxes, i.e., words that occur once.
The derivation rests on two assumptions: The first one is the standard urn
model which predicts that marginal frequency distributions for shorter texts
look as if word tokens were sampled blindly from a given longer text. The
second assumption posits that the hapax rate is a simple function of the text
length. Four such functions are discussed: the constant model, the Davis model,
the linear model, and the logistic model. It is shown that the logistic model
yields the best fit. | [
0.0503471494,
0.021365298,
-0.0308306273,
-0.0044784849,
-0.0586788468,
-0.0067063863,
-0.0126204723,
0.0273953434,
-0.0611015484,
-0.0442915969,
0.038609013,
-0.0482058525,
0.0406663865,
0.0097547276,
0.0236397516,
-0.0641352534,
0.0249150526,
-0.0155101568,
0.0342100784,
-0.0054955278,
0.0452920422,
-0.0264248773,
-0.019465128,
0.0204457473,
0.0315223634,
0.0280649196,
0.0142052099,
-0.0171370339,
-0.0262296833,
0.013658924,
-0.0143698249,
0.0699125826,
-0.0468452349,
0.0291365609,
0.0000018122,
-0.0515146703,
0.0002082584,
0.0139702698,
0.013699417,
0.0259009879,
0.0841354057,
0.0053740051,
-0.0421509407,
0.0094812708,
0.021860376,
0.0434752516,
0.0473621823,
0.011523284,
-0.0300636124,
0.0090341875,
-0.0148363607,
0.0041166078,
0.0424472205,
-0.0224845465,
0.0397251733,
-0.0017127729,
0.0374678895,
0.0421156809,
0.0118924147,
-0.0060553872,
-0.038920138,
0.0439715385,
-0.0055199391,
0.0397917517,
0.0149964001,
0.004905514,
-0.0381321758,
0.0050162473,
-0.0245856587,
0.0042758845,
0.0116838487,
-0.0350653753,
0.0264526196,
-0.0029576279,
-0.0389877781,
0.0064978991,
-0.0740499124,
0.0426081456,
-0.0204447303,
-0.0327839144,
0.0261916462,
0.0441460535,
-0.0024362148,
0.0136187952,
-0.0150748193,
0.0498141274,
0.0435644165,
-0.0548979566,
-0.0048222872,
-0.0166256037,
0.0304285716,
-0.0312342737,
0.0323810503,
0.021975819,
0.0583779179,
0.0108456286,
-0.003961633,
-0.0350887105,
0.0697223097,
-0.0915919617,
0.0023132781,
-0.0104347495,
-0.0140940594,
0.0311154388,
0.0254607517,
-0.0455343127,
0.0195476115,
-0.0328540765,
-0.018112788,
0.0460074544,
0.005839631,
-0.0273841713,
-0.0061952448,
0.0116849318,
-0.0129247196,
-0.0413092189,
-0.0507310107,
-0.0174522344,
0.0682743415,
-0.0799071491,
-0.0064603891,
-0.0142355599,
-0.0317393616,
0.0027757937,
-0.0122631807,
0.0128772883,
-0.0709416047,
0.0160375703,
-0.0136864083,
-0.055689171,
0.0043624775,
0.0129745044,
0.0329638645,
-0.038656164,
0.0066857277,
0.0196329225,
0.0122705558,
0.0090323221,
0.0058558239,
-0.0078563392,
-0.0758253336,
0.018208066,
-0.0497935005,
-0.0991860777,
-0.0079272911,
0.0038844654,
0.0278494395,
0.0323244371,
-0.0185952447,
0.0319188982,
-0.0914456397,
0.0051475475,
0.0032452533,
0.0276817009,
0.0051101921,
-0.026520744,
0.034292154,
0.0606780834,
0.0049391668,
-0.0006871368,
0.079723157,
-0.0271223821,
0.0125357853,
0.0380413495,
-0.0280284509,
0.0351996645,
-0.0452294834,
-0.0548912361,
-0.0091607645,
-0.0171561763,
0.0618922077,
0.0787092894,
-0.0275260527,
-0.0338152088,
0.024622133,
0.1209665611,
0.029326858,
0.0224506967,
0.0035296637,
0.0359182246,
0.0565005317,
0.0407729037,
0.0182192419,
-0.0278506726,
-0.0235414673,
-0.0101572536,
0.0798918605,
0.0035662362,
0.0085913995,
-0.0198682044,
-0.0073092487,
0.0413882323,
-0.0119740786,
-0.0807344913,
0.0513013825,
-0.0069367848,
0.0372747071,
-0.0233465564,
0.0367528349,
-0.0157211144,
-0.0138533236,
-0.0091165788,
-0.001912211,
0.0393356867,
0.0700810477,
0.0310213678,
0.0490560457,
-0.0037991358,
-0.0678367019,
0.0158991944,
-0.020824004,
0.0420723967,
-0.0213771723,
-0.0224075727,
0.046114184,
0.0420499444,
0.0280590709,
-0.0282120742,
-0.0135372765,
0.0239700656,
0.0327961482,
0.008295225,
-0.0057958066,
0.0133596379,
0.003191703,
0.0388697386,
-0.0495624579,
-0.0182423443,
0.0376173779,
-0.0115882345,
-0.0385441482,
0.0525618233,
-0.0224859845,
-0.0024961578,
-0.0000195696,
-0.0051050889,
0.0283349063,
0.0227088016,
0.0587784685,
-0.0257657189,
0.0829861239,
-0.0131650064,
0.0505923703,
-0.0020640676,
0.0102890003,
-0.0728105158,
0.0931421295,
-0.045994848,
0.0290587433,
-0.0317636915,
0.0327886716,
-0.0270942505,
0.0144760543,
-0.0058582993,
0.0666593537,
-0.0507392809,
-0.0349993333,
0.0601918846,
-0.051983431,
-0.0312705226,
-0.037801791,
-0.0221149586,
-0.0020487402,
0.0501672849,
-0.0273897722,
-0.0136414254,
-0.0304325819,
-0.0403819084,
0.0067331777,
0.0056090588,
0.0103680594,
0.0000427299,
0.0032552164,
-0.0508578308,
0.0028550015,
-0.0033545787,
-0.0189503077,
0.0236305594,
0.0403192788,
0.0409283973,
-0.038810771,
-0.0352454409,
-0.065902546,
-0.0542235598,
-0.0169993415,
-0.0058447621,
0.0362651236,
-0.0634023324,
-0.0103680585,
0.0559577569,
-0.0372899994,
-0.0223253295,
-0.0127045438,
-0.0520589352,
0.0034534354,
-0.0375003703,
0.0742363408,
-0.0264711082,
0.0436273478,
0.0380842425,
-0.0256583225,
-0.0151854157,
-0.0237696059,
-0.045595184,
-0.0479786023,
0.0364186242,
-0.0114859845,
-0.0350485332,
0.0377324559,
0.033281181,
0.0335000679,
-0.0203405451,
-0.010198568,
0.0079267574,
-0.0436461493,
-0.0497674793,
-0.0539526418,
-0.0078161461,
-0.0484396331,
0.0091123981,
-0.0147088701,
-0.0607780293,
-0.003682375,
-0.0309593901,
0.0260305032,
-0.0426014997,
-0.0281596147,
-0.0242848378,
-0.0177756473,
0.0438594185,
0.0268053003,
-0.0023035589,
-0.0333237797,
-0.0228798985,
0.001013909,
-0.0067414027,
-0.0556215048,
0.0107626636,
-0.006482644,
-0.003185126,
0.0096908379,
0.0094380993,
0.0275068767,
-0.1035006419,
0.0104021691,
-0.0218912903,
0.0628760979,
-0.0512942895,
0.0132962167,
0.0504182316,
0.0348539017,
-0.0069311494,
-0.0305570178,
-0.0082229702,
-0.0280735362,
0.0459802188,
0.0900588408,
-0.0354524031,
0.0140395863,
-0.0175755825,
-0.0573908053,
0.03660338,
0.0378913842,
0.0814747438,
0.0127026858,
0.0038116549,
0.0208324678,
-0.0267874375,
-0.0221566651,
0.0497055911,
-0.0272462349,
0.0198677089,
0.0536657311,
0.0687408,
0.0284307469,
-0.0281601101,
0.016821634,
-0.002363533,
-0.0041222121,
-0.0179213583,
0.0129415188,
-0.0658149719,
0.0313205346,
-0.0006083367,
-0.018614715,
-0.0393309854,
-0.0147206681,
0.0166242551,
-0.1148695201,
0.0227693561,
0.0131022539,
0.0011397348,
0.01356191,
-0.0563974716,
-0.0018951766,
0.0108430702,
-0.0235658512,
0.0303500034,
-0.0637160316,
0.0360184386,
0.0494850613,
-0.0516124591,
-0.0103992214,
-0.0202532951,
-0.0539526604,
0.0722749606,
0.0010109788,
0.0323094726,
-0.1041113734,
-0.0276666246,
-0.0238515474,
0.0079663461,
-0.0393049009,
0.000694461,
0.0446514674,
0.0015654241,
0.0185635239,
-0.0956632197,
-0.0031443669,
-0.0149008101,
0.0135887191,
-0.0046116277,
0.0093658557,
0.001254581,
-0.02730643,
-0.0573778264,
0.031320218,
-0.0181559492,
0.0705831051,
0.0256707128,
-0.0078237876,
-0.0056078066,
-0.0163081568,
0.0214285571,
-0.0155857466,
-0.0235382598,
-0.032901071,
-0.0201304853,
-0.0706090704,
-0.0636974946,
-0.000446965,
-0.0060722735,
0.0831074044,
0.04447354,
0.0395189859,
0.002190822,
-0.0004694232,
0.0306310225,
-0.0599612668,
-0.0220267884,
0.0093285525,
-0.0533072092,
0.0177563448,
0.0234491676,
-0.0181249082,
-0.0555241928,
0.0290866159,
-0.0933334678,
-0.0308043901,
0.0484842248,
0.0080461381,
0.0460189395,
-0.038803488,
-0.0293835998,
-0.0357656181,
-0.029103918,
0.0299756825,
-0.0131570268,
0.0444590114,
-0.0502770282,
-0.0154519444,
0.0197152384,
-0.0211202819,
-0.019773839,
0.0313128196,
-0.0000804246,
0.0505060144,
-0.0178738292,
-0.0558269992,
-0.001055156,
0.0325917453,
-0.0198086482,
-0.0160834156,
-0.0106885098,
-0.0150875077,
0.0090544447,
0.0098923948,
0.0261323061,
0.0192082077,
0.0048092986,
0.003550949,
0.0029748622,
-0.061772,
-0.0122285411,
-0.0200622994,
0.0312468112,
0.0223670416,
-0.0196632314,
0.0148347132,
0.0148062827,
0.0346811302,
0.0050323694,
0.0275743734,
-0.0114471558,
-0.0036344565,
0.0557933338,
0.0177326705,
0.0001526524,
-0.0155941732,
-0.0445655696,
-0.0345203057,
-0.0110902265,
-0.0491714738,
0.0146327717,
-0.0091518667,
-0.0139118787,
-0.021031823,
-0.0205053892,
0.0010480819,
-0.0469258912,
0.0204410031,
-0.029165253,
0.007372776,
0.024044862,
0.0380574204,
-0.0397069864,
0.0050024008,
-0.0362237878,
0.0110849934,
0.0588968806,
0.0291900244,
-0.0352064036,
-0.0229304917,
-0.06715253,
0.0054555065,
-0.0117573906,
-0.0366983525,
0.0001495335,
0.0204157289,
-0.0165924598,
-0.0779246539,
-0.0468544476,
-0.0117106391,
0.0286268964,
0.0520670563,
0.0080597773,
-0.0217254143,
0.0831619129,
-0.0076882285,
0.0104777338,
-0.0353776291,
0.0581182875,
-0.0478465296,
0.0135698244,
0.0084557813,
-6.070949675e-33,
0.0246455111,
0.0108098304,
-0.0289745312,
0.0160489734,
-0.0319907963,
-0.0251966994,
-0.0121340835,
-0.0036879026,
0.0314199217,
-0.008201791,
-0.007252377,
0.007970864,
0.0326660909,
0.006208885,
0.0337613858,
0.0425372012,
-0.0036412913,
0.0076554893,
0.0060353051,
-0.0291391499,
0.0567599162,
0.0165862199,
0.0169604272,
0.0763519928,
0.0431050658,
-0.0140385516,
0.0082266312,
0.0082639093,
0.0542110316,
0.0302951746,
-0.0298169926,
0.0328344852,
0.0289534032,
-0.0153426696,
-0.0034905435,
0.0524709038,
-0.03784585,
-0.0434437506,
0.0869943053,
-0.0015469053,
0.0504268631,
-0.0173904132,
0.0277435072,
0.0267153364,
-0.045151718,
0.0343334526,
0.0583253391,
-0.0339309946,
-0.0603316724,
-0.0415283889,
-0.0219462309,
0.0343193524,
0.0016178682,
0.0630439892,
-0.0099716075,
-0.030398434,
0.0024012558,
0.0027480491,
-0.0100550791,
0.0273876376,
0.0756172836,
0.066382885,
-0.0012049893,
-0.0204248205,
-0.0007621632,
0.0506418645,
-0.0001790464,
-0.0200560503,
-0.0210920367,
0.0240798723,
0.0373642817,
-0.0518447943,
-0.001904411,
0.0251220372,
0.1168795153,
-0.0339710824,
-0.021851385,
0.0340170972,
0.0569355078,
0.0004999046,
0.0368971825,
-0.0103608426,
-0.1127549931,
0.0088875778,
-0.0093892775,
0.0400102921,
0.0018406881,
-0.0700335205,
0.0168445464,
-0.0121965697,
0.0199442394,
0.0358064361,
0.0220474433,
-0.0203088429,
-0.0597824082,
-0.0144310798,
0.0018058297,
0.0664014742,
-0.0327691883,
0.0184973422,
-0.0601226985,
-0.0043641729,
-0.0013237079,
0.0521882027,
-0.0148996264,
-0.0295474641,
0.0134162195,
0.0101774698,
-0.0796502456,
-0.0026483417,
0.0228876844,
-0.0257657561,
0.0539377742,
-0.023294678,
-0.0010840456,
0.0021696079,
0.0039684353,
-0.0118791293,
0.0086026052,
-0.0265394431,
0.0196701176,
0.0210383497,
-0.0120305363,
0.0024065222,
-0.0196764581,
-0.0174954291,
-0.0317093506,
0.0206233133,
0.0330053978,
-0.0347828642,
0.0119632389,
0.0137020331,
2.639e-7,
0.0547314882,
0.0109631773,
0.0908424631,
-0.0459979512,
0.0156955756,
-0.0413261503,
-0.0431654379,
0.0320025347,
-0.012240706,
0.011517928,
-0.0274387281,
0.0093300221,
0.0296712406,
0.0031891274,
-0.0635630488,
-0.0002239596,
-0.0878328159,
-0.0259451494,
-0.0309468955,
0.0021810671,
0.0008801321,
0.0640643314,
0.0147606898,
-0.0175234489,
-0.0089387549,
-0.0325073153,
0.0087394202,
-0.0069629438,
-0.0398543924,
0.050012961,
-0.0000465895,
-0.0191935655,
0.0281706695,
-0.016053576,
0.0052883276,
0.022893073,
0.0785640851,
0.0188864507,
-0.0050696475,
0.0461718068,
0.0016224927,
-0.0571164116,
0.0099300146,
-0.0313012451,
0.0225699749,
0.0627066195,
-0.0121384561,
0.0071728132,
-0.0370282643,
0.0338260978,
-0.0172297247,
-0.0042966618,
-0.0106976228,
-0.0118303252,
0.0137519585,
0.0323793814,
0.0021261752,
-0.0512955785,
-0.016385287,
-0.0053207101,
-0.0210313983,
-0.096208021,
-0.0409549586,
-0.0154675599,
0.0274214949,
-0.0514040925,
0.0125885261,
2.343653112e-34,
0.0342397094,
0.0164255705,
-0.0022992827,
-0.0134736206,
0.0086452086,
0.0181292985,
0.0854769722,
0.0479247831,
0.0202230476,
-0.0736651644,
-0.0137986513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00071v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00071v2 | Interpretable Stereotype Identification through Reasoning | 2023-07-24T15:12:13 | 2024-03-06T18:49:55 | Jacob-Junqi Tian, Omkar Dige, David Emerson, Faiza Khan Khattak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Given that language models are trained on vast datasets that may contain
inherent biases, there is a potential danger of inadvertently perpetuating
systemic discrimination. Consequently, it becomes essential to examine and
address biases in language models, integrating fairness into their development
to ensure these models are equitable and free from bias. In this work, we
demonstrate the importance of reasoning in zero-shot stereotype identification
based on Vicuna-13B-v1.3. While we do observe improved accuracy by scaling from
13B to 33B, we show that the performance gain from reasoning significantly
exceeds the gain from scaling up. Our findings suggest that reasoning could be
a key factor that enables LLMs to trescend the scaling law on out-of-domain
tasks such as stereotype identification. Additionally, through a qualitative
analysis of select reasoning traces, we highlight how reasoning enhances not
just accuracy but also the interpretability of the decision. | [
0.0061490121,
0.0555794351,
-0.0268624462,
0.0594820678,
0.0456465632,
0.0746912882,
0.0386203825,
0.0231595431,
-0.0220513046,
-0.0746977776,
-0.0185343847,
-0.0390838198,
0.0231414344,
0.0174586102,
0.0193059482,
-0.0346420817,
0.0323660038,
0.0146086086,
0.0142719485,
-0.0328484401,
0.0007168021,
0.0340366848,
0.0220296532,
0.0393079855,
0.0058122398,
-0.0127909686,
0.0587451085,
0.0075997398,
0.0024987995,
0.0109106749,
0.014185058,
0.0412069559,
0.0420161784,
0.0208806228,
0.0000019952,
-0.0710486472,
0.0334111862,
0.011001179,
-0.0335228816,
-0.0145359663,
-0.0014620682,
-0.0404951163,
-0.010695532,
0.0277712326,
0.0009721016,
-0.012845533,
0.0603992157,
0.0151327122,
0.0242776684,
0.0177784953,
0.0055158827,
-0.0801406503,
-0.0554237776,
-0.008549748,
0.0146221034,
0.002386054,
0.036333669,
-0.0370343365,
-0.0746586844,
-0.0336934067,
-0.0278947037,
-0.0249911919,
0.0160257854,
0.0227270797,
0.0021178119,
0.0103055499,
-0.0157411639,
-0.0401465483,
0.0432619937,
0.0752412155,
0.0035197129,
-0.021719601,
-0.0030301204,
0.0001051039,
-0.0029662075,
-0.0328269117,
-0.0038796524,
0.0370031968,
-0.014587828,
0.0146726929,
-0.0378066748,
0.0165960975,
0.0539477021,
0.0266649313,
-0.0312174447,
0.0450413264,
-0.0067534051,
0.016708117,
-0.0250820853,
0.003692179,
0.0026755896,
-0.03139586,
-0.0260051824,
0.0266900863,
0.0025548695,
0.0127765974,
0.0005232121,
0.0311357919,
0.0157893039,
-0.0365027189,
0.0398972407,
0.0738563687,
-0.0082405852,
0.0121684214,
-0.0058158874,
0.0384695716,
0.0018603295,
0.0364249684,
-0.0078621479,
-0.0454243422,
-0.0270299911,
-0.0173860285,
0.0233612061,
-0.0123637915,
0.0021718747,
0.0802526623,
-0.0480995029,
-0.0331033394,
-0.0377210937,
-0.0029165812,
0.0184724331,
0.0242357049,
-0.0309738982,
-0.0154392216,
-0.0805017352,
0.0162206069,
-0.0245180409,
-0.0001944737,
-0.0511956066,
-0.0760183856,
-0.0203912258,
0.0088139595,
-0.0205519814,
-0.0446942933,
0.0094238557,
0.1131255478,
0.0239281356,
-0.0450358205,
-0.0552109815,
-0.0440028757,
-0.0258385502,
-0.0864202306,
0.0201590676,
-0.0256946068,
-0.000495705,
0.0049347039,
0.0100314049,
-0.0692049265,
-0.0127478875,
0.0098693389,
-0.0467188507,
0.1173025593,
0.0156279635,
-0.0072917761,
0.0114183147,
0.03194369,
-0.0251855385,
0.0894419774,
0.0187137742,
-0.0177677032,
0.0214892477,
-0.0101880347,
-0.0014902058,
0.0228389278,
0.0289811399,
0.0025838185,
-0.0505263023,
0.0112015018,
-0.0034015884,
-0.0081993537,
0.0750468224,
0.0121036787,
-0.0135310767,
-0.0576890782,
0.0355179459,
0.0731987059,
0.023933243,
0.0165315326,
0.0612234138,
-0.026913086,
-0.0383894406,
0.0038559344,
-0.1020643935,
0.0162796862,
0.0088285534,
-0.0252238419,
-0.0297077186,
0.066754207,
-0.0539761521,
-0.0390785746,
-0.0303588621,
-0.0178825092,
0.0340852514,
-0.0138552701,
0.0139854075,
0.024489589,
0.0069240183,
0.0789447352,
0.0495559573,
-0.0161349047,
-0.0110984566,
-0.067228362,
0.0280667525,
0.0518068597,
0.009553168,
0.0162728876,
-0.0015434434,
-0.0236247107,
-0.0475736298,
0.0263055582,
0.0327703618,
-0.013083525,
0.0522513464,
-0.0658009723,
-0.0117154373,
0.0290533006,
0.0299569555,
0.0054890988,
0.0351730809,
0.0555216782,
0.043964237,
-0.0506236255,
-0.0053348518,
0.0375599675,
-0.0167146325,
-0.0591874234,
-0.0083735613,
0.0252133813,
0.0135127539,
0.0037141719,
-0.0121812783,
-0.0318142623,
-0.0390772298,
-0.0075535299,
-0.0003956719,
0.064237833,
-0.0817136988,
-0.0484701358,
0.0270428043,
-0.0475585721,
-0.0412803665,
-0.0016998255,
-0.0217336416,
-0.0009529677,
0.0598348193,
0.0013345849,
-0.0075507341,
-0.0386385024,
0.0007545875,
-0.0424888581,
0.0366960466,
-0.0057233316,
0.0750833079,
0.0032720435,
-0.0338745341,
0.0239877868,
-0.035005264,
0.03036974,
-0.0529965609,
-0.0114998594,
0.0420508608,
0.0262787715,
-0.005880516,
-0.0501530915,
-0.0166801587,
-0.013313082,
0.0315808579,
-0.0515370592,
-0.0193031728,
-0.001043356,
-0.0149516081,
-0.0110979825,
0.0234324802,
-0.0084561175,
-0.0209333654,
0.0056172651,
-0.0179615412,
0.0035245968,
0.0214754995,
0.0238792375,
-0.0320276655,
-0.0143277841,
-0.0096902624,
-0.0176121406,
-0.0347216837,
0.0649944991,
-0.0111152316,
0.0372262262,
-0.0643002465,
-0.0139485477,
-0.0723827779,
0.019181475,
0.0105167395,
-0.0425825827,
0.0152541315,
0.0372977033,
-0.0376256816,
0.0644906834,
0.0235270988,
0.0428113043,
0.0495009124,
0.0072249006,
-0.0332368501,
-0.0065996153,
0.0133341923,
0.0389254913,
-0.0006947679,
-0.0677506477,
-0.0477116816,
0.096237421,
0.0017619961,
-0.0168361831,
-0.0905014724,
0.0591145121,
-0.0013890361,
-0.0483244583,
-0.0045090513,
-0.018876316,
0.0045379461,
0.0456675626,
-0.0421624333,
-0.0472449102,
0.0786713213,
-0.0266204067,
-0.0004701447,
0.0053327009,
0.0065137376,
-0.0391923487,
0.076933071,
-0.0011584556,
0.0195288248,
0.0475915857,
0.0056435312,
-0.0286320336,
-0.0752191991,
0.0310534034,
-0.0183323193,
0.0530635454,
-0.0563694052,
0.0084191775,
-0.0211225804,
-0.0468261577,
-0.0481731854,
-0.0080189807,
-0.0574638098,
-0.0128251631,
-0.0513310507,
-0.0316587873,
0.0013746716,
0.0229103845,
-0.0057760631,
0.0082242573,
-0.0152868805,
-0.0002267907,
0.0071363151,
-0.022878252,
0.0009554306,
0.0262712762,
0.0362858288,
-0.007776923,
0.0323596559,
0.0352212451,
-0.0256118868,
0.0322414935,
-0.0345450789,
0.0122435214,
0.0085329022,
-0.0104658902,
-0.0281027332,
-0.0101569565,
0.0574635901,
-0.0431957841,
-0.0014268875,
0.1022365689,
0.0096587418,
-0.0232904349,
0.0208427124,
-0.0016536278,
0.0079029193,
0.0371382721,
-0.0051539573,
-0.0844291076,
-0.0476956442,
0.0267687887,
0.0284564458,
-0.0406134874,
-0.0494219922,
-0.027439883,
-0.0967750773,
0.0639442205,
0.0141573036,
-0.0264458414,
-0.0471547842,
0.0007284701,
0.0188004337,
-0.0216623973,
0.0569599383,
-0.0045791399,
-0.0021000854,
0.0036361546,
0.0140844891,
0.0043046195,
-0.0453995131,
0.0498537943,
-0.0267206524,
0.0358904824,
0.0021583692,
0.0339151584,
0.020752864,
-0.0188176874,
0.0057221921,
-0.0342252925,
0.021982925,
-0.0491109528,
0.0629963279,
0.0059519606,
-0.0446375161,
-0.012444404,
-0.0005375327,
0.001661747,
0.0106223691,
-0.0338562801,
0.04846422,
-0.0169850085,
-0.0437612683,
-0.0378532894,
-0.0181017537,
-0.0315097235,
0.0928925872,
0.0457885452,
0.0013349119,
-0.0425992757,
-0.0850726664,
-0.0302957166,
-0.0135431131,
-0.0817406625,
0.0321356542,
0.0158437137,
-0.0433530733,
-0.0027777101,
-0.0411069356,
-0.0093804859,
0.028894946,
-0.0123906191,
-0.0526307672,
-0.0082769496,
0.0032340141,
-0.0746376067,
0.0309817754,
-0.064550966,
0.0425090641,
0.0425920337,
0.0194302946,
0.0269584712,
-0.0411013849,
-0.0368836895,
-0.0067699081,
-0.013817721,
-0.0476155095,
-0.0049491529,
0.0155299762,
0.0353983007,
0.069649592,
-0.0101236263,
-0.0658091605,
0.057777252,
0.0147638125,
0.0485468172,
0.0379715003,
0.0398519598,
0.0052165887,
0.0243398268,
0.0393423177,
-0.0173413567,
0.0585599542,
0.0108984923,
-0.0252539869,
-0.0377002023,
-0.0207296181,
-0.0277592931,
-0.0092791403,
0.0072950725,
0.0012305931,
-0.0130693587,
-0.0199043881,
0.0058981054,
0.0065854555,
-0.0224141162,
0.0013360215,
-0.024719296,
0.0096386941,
0.0066163773,
-0.0357740372,
-0.0476446822,
-0.0626323447,
0.0407035016,
-0.0044515752,
0.0404460244,
0.040196795,
0.0291138738,
0.0066925124,
0.000597845,
-0.025872957,
0.0376118161,
-0.0259007514,
0.0573287159,
0.0084397597,
0.0382055715,
0.0218026824,
0.0268634148,
-0.0286371261,
-0.0096418895,
-0.0133696552,
-0.0450134911,
-0.0025548826,
-0.0134733068,
0.0246091411,
-0.0303137619,
0.0285609961,
0.0299038906,
-0.0032003957,
0.0161810573,
0.0143484334,
0.0182535406,
-0.008384197,
0.0686493292,
0.0201377906,
-0.0031033738,
-0.005302479,
0.0600389242,
0.0114194341,
0.0602190159,
-0.0231902301,
-0.0328902714,
-0.0105230724,
-0.0350019485,
0.0110031394,
-0.0085886456,
0.0191938803,
-0.0302766263,
-0.0713984445,
-0.1032337621,
-0.0055088,
-0.0193036981,
0.0220187809,
0.0197605398,
0.0102465143,
0.0287316032,
0.0188199393,
-0.0455341972,
0.0048598186,
-0.0196833033,
-0.0038891134,
0.0250706021,
0.0180349257,
-6.162730438e-33,
-0.0300185364,
-0.0170241911,
-0.009789139,
-0.0383973494,
0.0009527358,
-0.032687068,
-0.026513949,
-0.0356658101,
-0.0412399247,
0.0086237844,
0.0194344539,
0.0309723821,
0.0241964459,
-0.0101752402,
-0.0026372229,
-0.0159092881,
0.0649992004,
0.0123354616,
-0.0159991775,
-0.0235684086,
0.0208523627,
0.0140729202,
0.0494313799,
-0.0469765142,
0.0328237265,
0.0166659653,
-0.0051818388,
0.03149933,
-0.0211820845,
0.0645164102,
-0.0164115038,
0.064039737,
0.0475780442,
-0.0127689335,
0.0044260821,
0.0283058789,
-0.0770319626,
-0.0228942726,
0.0171717741,
0.0449725389,
0.0300201792,
-0.0407482609,
0.0374932215,
0.0136046307,
-0.0504354425,
-0.044676479,
0.0351236239,
-0.0457192101,
0.052672293,
0.0250670705,
-0.0559757911,
0.0224160347,
-0.0175735131,
0.0055907038,
0.0346434042,
-0.0192032531,
0.0139293019,
0.0477855392,
-0.0591534078,
0.0101359868,
-0.0249440186,
-0.0548153073,
0.0629117489,
0.0505632013,
-0.0022412548,
0.0532486998,
0.0548764095,
-0.0077023637,
-0.036345914,
-0.0440709516,
0.031366758,
-0.0118153859,
0.021219762,
0.0582865216,
0.0447047912,
-0.0316494331,
-0.0561057962,
-0.0154903177,
0.0250949934,
-0.0023783813,
0.0240701716,
0.0108624175,
-0.0865008757,
-0.0667082816,
-0.0324768424,
-0.0738589317,
-0.0351992995,
-0.0475386232,
0.0173849147,
-0.0249846634,
-0.0272529945,
0.0286055077,
0.0184210669,
-0.0463778451,
-0.0229071844,
0.0287672542,
-0.0132439006,
-0.0294780582,
0.022628909,
-0.0121352775,
-0.0607414991,
-0.0192424208,
0.0215036348,
0.0419682898,
0.0450413153,
0.0292820744,
0.0220638122,
0.0019524659,
-0.0399293564,
0.0002553936,
-0.0448767543,
-0.0007047264,
-0.0030362946,
0.0575541779,
0.0097066462,
0.0410344005,
-0.0051654079,
0.0068248366,
0.0257554092,
-0.0078563662,
-0.0312000606,
0.0285935067,
0.005354072,
0.0562239662,
-0.0470365696,
-0.0361090079,
0.0137225287,
0.0047138683,
0.0450260788,
-0.0651286468,
0.0011604362,
-0.0237347204,
2.57e-7,
0.0117628211,
0.0289238542,
-0.008366432,
0.0333475061,
0.0590185188,
0.074098587,
0.0364054143,
0.0208957884,
0.0180736091,
-0.0202201027,
-0.0357584395,
0.0891993791,
0.0194054991,
0.0579095781,
-0.0343271904,
0.0496379659,
-0.0274331421,
-0.0244979206,
-0.0237264317,
0.0186883695,
0.0367396064,
0.0802052245,
0.0393960439,
-0.0451784916,
0.0256544333,
-0.0229528006,
0.0338042453,
-0.0221416149,
0.0388688259,
-0.0169976279,
0.0187098347,
0.0453609675,
0.02286423,
0.0414846987,
0.0302978922,
0.0140075739,
-0.0377733931,
0.0130941533,
-0.0375678353,
0.0012839804,
-0.047009103,
0.0100228805,
-0.0220108684,
-0.0730774105,
0.0897739455,
0.0005374153,
-0.0460400917,
-0.0169054326,
0.0179148093,
-0.0021350561,
0.0120468847,
0.0055107228,
-0.008127192,
0.0249065813,
0.0125983879,
-0.0360621475,
-0.0205020867,
-0.1041016728,
-0.0181529373,
-0.0249450561,
-0.0386195146,
-0.0503832437,
0.0063755354,
-0.0120073203,
0.0471144281,
-0.0347590558,
0.0158258602,
2.097438703e-34,
-0.0031652625,
0.0244107042,
0.0248675756,
0.0017852967,
0.0244988501,
0.0025457363,
0.0014540111,
-0.0199570414,
0.0424177572,
-0.0305107459,
-0.0157238636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12856v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12856v4 | A Real-World WebAgent with Planning, Long Context Understanding, and Program Synthesis | 2023-07-24T14:56:30 | 2024-02-25T16:17:43 | Izzeddin Gur, Hiroki Furuta, Austin Huang, Mustafa Safdari, Yutaka Matsuo, Douglas Eck, Aleksandra Faust | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Pre-trained large language models (LLMs) have recently achieved better
generalization and sample efficiency in autonomous web automation. However, the
performance on real-world websites has still suffered from (1) open domainness,
(2) limited context length, and (3) lack of inductive bias on HTML. We
introduce WebAgent, an LLM-driven agent that learns from self-experience to
complete tasks on real websites following natural language instructions.
WebAgent plans ahead by decomposing instructions into canonical
sub-instructions, summarizes long HTML documents into task-relevant snippets,
and acts on websites via Python programs generated from those. We design
WebAgent with Flan-U-PaLM, for grounded code generation, and HTML-T5, new
pre-trained LLMs for long HTML documents using local and global attention
mechanisms and a mixture of long-span denoising objectives, for planning and
summarization. We empirically demonstrate that our modular recipe improves the
success on real websites by over 50%, and that HTML-T5 is the best model to
solve various HTML understanding tasks; achieving 18.7% higher success rate
than the prior method on MiniWoB web automation benchmark, and SoTA performance
on Mind2Web, an offline task planning evaluation. | [
0.0422863029,
0.018690981,
0.0074520204,
-0.0143979844,
0.0060248529,
0.0283464771,
0.0179627724,
-0.0224454179,
0.0395116545,
-0.055201713,
-0.021902265,
-0.0237593614,
-0.0186611619,
0.0548140854,
0.0073439353,
-0.0403823107,
-0.0137309162,
-0.0305942353,
-0.005817133,
0.005665285,
-0.0046841982,
-0.0095053921,
0.0076192557,
0.0588396452,
0.0216217842,
-0.0251309648,
-0.0326017551,
0.0032717222,
-0.0096844146,
-0.0352742933,
0.0256427061,
0.0366027579,
0.0585512146,
0.0040003341,
0.0000020941,
-0.053816475,
-0.0049218959,
-0.0298131593,
-0.0212021992,
0.0062214057,
-0.0057529095,
0.0124903498,
-0.0121865235,
0.0461209752,
-0.0357983634,
-0.0015749997,
0.007195293,
0.0488978773,
0.0738098472,
0.0794094801,
0.0085350787,
0.0050404635,
0.0152825061,
-0.0071738982,
0.021328073,
-0.0394507311,
0.0250802282,
0.0036566465,
0.028006522,
-0.0315570682,
0.0028359038,
0.0076395185,
0.0193999112,
-0.0233900286,
0.0118983453,
0.0374546833,
-0.0236089397,
-0.0456743762,
0.011989424,
0.0946738943,
-0.0227822196,
-0.0141248982,
0.0436402932,
0.025760036,
-0.0155900549,
-0.0024072961,
-0.0842300579,
0.0798301846,
0.0049293446,
-0.0108742183,
-0.005016428,
-0.0101285204,
-0.0004101964,
0.0212384146,
-0.0621337332,
0.0341578051,
-0.0028998409,
-0.0472016409,
-0.0219619516,
0.0016701908,
0.0227835551,
-0.0799444541,
0.037186753,
0.0998662338,
-0.0221641734,
0.0108436011,
-0.0244136173,
-0.0181652457,
0.0105600283,
-0.0204643887,
0.0124866916,
0.0325946361,
-0.0159555953,
0.0704255626,
-0.0464754365,
0.048105333,
-0.009371167,
0.0018653671,
-0.0408872217,
0.0417596325,
-0.0676570907,
0.0215876997,
-0.0249839183,
0.0764459744,
-0.0295963343,
-0.0327765904,
0.0149348406,
0.0855135322,
0.0220659878,
0.063367106,
-0.0126051428,
-0.0068223234,
-0.0371133797,
0.0027279307,
-0.0149215162,
0.0182314292,
-0.0322886184,
-0.0043059848,
0.0013923589,
-0.0405702554,
-0.0178440493,
0.0396561734,
0.0296454784,
-0.0064231297,
0.0070526372,
0.1029933095,
-0.006327224,
-0.0164120235,
-0.0405320935,
-0.035451442,
-0.0017217533,
-0.0343017355,
0.0141340606,
-0.0691546872,
0.0056032813,
0.020378096,
-0.0273022223,
-0.0269336682,
0.0184965115,
0.0163721293,
0.0043966491,
0.0373262577,
-0.0066924212,
0.0075560198,
0.0097630396,
-0.0107723214,
0.0057193758,
0.0436907448,
0.014607708,
0.0974842608,
0.0120626763,
0.0105123771,
0.0335676521,
0.0354883559,
-0.0010279221,
0.0255781151,
0.0419592224,
0.0057903663,
0.0351659209,
0.009299756,
0.0362013951,
0.0317395739,
-0.0029565908,
0.0513685271,
0.0700239316,
0.0482850634,
-0.0093993302,
0.017208932,
0.0570493601,
0.0506944321,
0.0005778981,
0.0244615078,
-0.0781354681,
0.0431273617,
-0.0422536135,
0.0380005091,
-0.0010087314,
0.0428356566,
-0.0441513769,
-0.0444179028,
0.0094217276,
-0.0310352128,
0.046858646,
0.0005123359,
0.059913367,
-0.0006504846,
-0.0753498748,
-0.015827205,
0.0139914649,
-0.031684678,
0.019086957,
-0.044720564,
0.0368646458,
0.0830791146,
0.0464184657,
-0.0629087538,
-0.0488872454,
-0.0437129028,
0.0066379239,
0.0320711322,
0.0064688134,
-0.0216982644,
-0.0435582586,
-0.0308592133,
-0.0791630149,
-0.0640748069,
-0.0110840015,
0.0015101497,
0.025234852,
-0.0090277083,
0.0339257978,
-0.0293585099,
-0.0420576669,
0.053714864,
-0.016524775,
-0.0380534455,
-0.0484015979,
0.0077368058,
0.0237794835,
-0.0168005843,
-0.0220878981,
0.0029921061,
0.0213205684,
-0.0292133708,
-0.0361377858,
-0.0444285013,
-0.0306816511,
-0.03425695,
0.0687567964,
-0.0483999029,
0.0022472781,
0.0457450822,
-0.0267067365,
-0.0417864509,
0.0251058396,
-0.0264257323,
0.0143455714,
0.0008444819,
0.0341910459,
0.0170274973,
0.0047533056,
-0.0296871364,
0.0592956282,
0.0277646948,
-0.0546590947,
0.0320359841,
0.0169035494,
-0.0217669457,
0.0020701487,
-0.0087341461,
-0.0030805434,
-0.019712219,
0.033719115,
0.0470619984,
0.0608253665,
-0.0685164407,
-0.0208504423,
-0.1132888794,
0.018963648,
-0.0329742171,
-0.0087522613,
0.0298874974,
0.0370284133,
-0.0043715276,
-0.0297413971,
-0.0289101116,
0.007697308,
-0.0276555382,
0.007736499,
0.0249778517,
0.0220314469,
-0.0433200486,
-0.0534735918,
-0.0192379244,
-0.0033982121,
0.0127885705,
0.0268790051,
-0.0282734446,
-0.0415419079,
0.0759057775,
-0.0133041972,
0.0225732829,
-0.0110069122,
-0.059898816,
-0.0074514383,
-0.0478708893,
0.0232211407,
0.0966950879,
0.0256367493,
0.0329302661,
0.0809827894,
0.0115758153,
-0.038419947,
0.0193827525,
-0.0252206512,
-0.0173674803,
-0.042349495,
0.0220321678,
0.028210748,
0.1012528613,
-0.0105731012,
0.013147288,
-0.0324363671,
0.0011956353,
-0.0013250438,
0.0022989477,
-0.0004835574,
-0.005820076,
-0.0333857089,
0.0494768471,
-0.0058068885,
-0.0456884727,
0.0542345867,
-0.0152628031,
-0.0059968173,
-0.027707912,
-0.0057625226,
-0.0324186124,
0.0486845747,
0.0143694803,
0.0314427428,
-0.0188929569,
-0.0276855864,
-0.0665572062,
0.0362928696,
0.0303451996,
-0.0021142119,
0.0634542406,
-0.039951466,
0.0220637657,
-0.0402168445,
-0.0529371053,
-0.0569531955,
-0.0121080009,
-0.0349557102,
0.0020348052,
-0.010152882,
-0.0021609731,
-0.0273606181,
0.0023926315,
0.0627301931,
0.0848082229,
-0.0101995096,
-0.0144510837,
-0.027231263,
-0.0131282201,
0.0203966461,
-0.0123218158,
-0.0053732158,
-0.016332889,
0.030119136,
0.0255827419,
0.047024332,
-0.0112911602,
-0.0227185916,
-0.00595548,
0.0133551238,
-0.0541539825,
-0.0235160571,
0.0571528859,
0.023949625,
-0.0747034699,
-0.0075049652,
0.1364759803,
0.026923582,
-0.0445397161,
-0.0145284319,
-0.0296406131,
0.0122331092,
0.0346396305,
0.020055782,
-0.035395015,
-0.0293269828,
0.0165471043,
0.0283342078,
0.0321207456,
-0.0176351983,
0.0373542979,
-0.0856420472,
0.0134607758,
0.0077211154,
0.0072860145,
0.0149036935,
-0.0457204096,
0.0177505277,
0.0078459661,
-0.0135051385,
0.0567640252,
-0.0398902446,
-0.0046772608,
0.0076534646,
-0.0484198444,
-0.0494802818,
0.0253324974,
-0.0162079558,
0.0187487714,
0.0826568529,
0.0254057888,
-0.0089571131,
-0.0167645924,
0.064777039,
-0.0154020293,
0.011522037,
-0.0320611075,
0.0449071899,
-0.0194708332,
0.0016637316,
0.0061233761,
0.055253014,
-0.0773762986,
0.0112741264,
0.0186199658,
0.0796012357,
-0.017895868,
-0.0150932819,
-0.023923371,
-0.0241034739,
-0.0392716713,
0.0640617087,
0.04566212,
-0.0615052059,
-0.0885536373,
-0.0311889518,
-0.0471690968,
-0.0188821685,
0.0064897076,
-0.0133900559,
-0.0447205901,
-0.0074809436,
-0.0942004621,
-0.0661619604,
0.0547724441,
0.0361597016,
0.0333455689,
-0.0355828591,
0.0518227406,
0.0314875245,
-0.0569124818,
-0.0032648519,
-0.0481795929,
-0.0119923446,
-0.0399397351,
-0.0162825622,
0.0457367823,
-0.0955129266,
-0.0037481142,
0.0025702592,
-0.0519090854,
-0.0284261089,
-0.0089407992,
0.0330823734,
0.0201493911,
0.0538261868,
-0.0177938659,
-0.0347477421,
0.0360960402,
-0.0412565023,
-0.0709023848,
-0.002576536,
0.0505760871,
0.0355429128,
0.005087628,
0.0089406036,
-0.1076286882,
0.0151749402,
0.0056226263,
0.019454848,
-0.0061620218,
0.0157191902,
0.0511527173,
0.0349243321,
-0.0046683755,
-0.0054165646,
-0.005159257,
-0.0019215035,
0.0255454816,
0.0203111004,
-0.0386044718,
-0.0436962992,
0.0119286235,
0.0040976391,
0.0098699918,
0.0701263994,
0.0380990356,
-0.0040918458,
-0.0088532558,
-0.0095335152,
0.0176170822,
-0.0201814678,
0.0152487112,
0.0451583527,
-0.0093340548,
-0.0384654254,
-0.0059239552,
0.0149583546,
0.0204346161,
0.0030920813,
0.0361634307,
0.0332791731,
-0.0041071158,
-0.031623207,
0.0381828174,
-0.0644087791,
-0.0625234917,
-0.0299232546,
-0.0209283326,
0.0547200702,
0.0006891521,
0.0593972243,
-0.0132831344,
0.0121463109,
-0.0390597917,
0.0237636175,
-0.0130122891,
-0.0208878797,
-0.0098143034,
0.0327646956,
-0.0034337197,
-0.0056216815,
0.0950626433,
-0.0133167282,
0.0308931824,
0.0368892811,
0.001997109,
-0.0594562031,
-0.0224049557,
0.0074456772,
0.0487543605,
-0.0157479066,
-0.0514079407,
-0.0010280586,
-0.0573543906,
-0.0050132372,
0.0080648148,
-0.0174736883,
-0.011141872,
0.0557091013,
0.0597900972,
0.0073190322,
0.0142690334,
-0.0081268428,
-0.0028342053,
0.030563809,
-0.010028447,
-0.019587338,
-5.977737749e-33,
-0.0325378329,
-0.042495463,
0.030903209,
0.0048962948,
-0.0327171497,
-0.0051362198,
-0.0736998022,
0.0020560734,
-0.0005895557,
-0.0132614607,
-0.0148125365,
-0.0056806235,
0.0105085736,
0.0315735042,
0.0176546108,
-0.0321520977,
0.0576438978,
-0.0029064009,
-0.0351975672,
0.049751021,
0.0041730814,
0.0250289794,
-0.0014610117,
-0.0279547125,
-0.0281112846,
-0.0159560721,
-0.0113648167,
-0.0154703092,
0.040544115,
0.0578508712,
-0.0276100151,
0.0291574951,
0.0288685728,
0.0010499646,
-0.0372746475,
0.0142483665,
-0.0695583001,
-0.0279484894,
-0.0085613225,
0.0073223496,
-0.0249474198,
-0.0238506217,
0.0588135868,
-0.0301030148,
0.0001619011,
0.0031965948,
0.0635454655,
-0.0442676619,
-0.0131020714,
-0.0281142294,
-0.0827043578,
-0.0092610735,
-0.0392817371,
-0.0446736105,
0.0294564795,
0.0115411244,
0.0056276377,
0.0151291192,
-0.0177189987,
0.025642965,
-0.0023452744,
0.0375065021,
0.0850591958,
0.006850197,
0.0160788279,
0.061081145,
0.0010185706,
0.0118743451,
-0.036375463,
-0.0085168192,
0.0350419991,
0.0166217145,
-0.0044944878,
0.0006027038,
-0.0232369229,
0.0246637929,
-0.0452780761,
0.0350760259,
0.0147137009,
0.0649110004,
0.0249335989,
0.0309274625,
-0.007393226,
-0.0003859379,
-0.0293811467,
0.0397093482,
-0.0339066423,
-0.0324452035,
0.043114081,
0.043813549,
-0.0236213692,
-0.0634345412,
0.0205530394,
-0.0364340842,
0.0060372446,
0.0426423699,
-0.0580749884,
0.0338504389,
0.002511794,
-0.0278873108,
-0.0216069296,
-0.0236944892,
0.0032562776,
-0.0210231338,
0.0042207632,
0.0334598608,
-0.0099653797,
0.0296576507,
-0.0409767181,
-0.0146310832,
-0.066832833,
-0.0158877485,
0.0319344401,
0.0087287314,
0.0389695764,
-0.0321172513,
-0.0191054903,
0.048993025,
-0.0050127138,
-0.0486311726,
-0.0436984077,
0.0010963051,
0.0086434763,
0.0038122467,
-0.0771936178,
-0.0216782633,
-0.0491605401,
0.0603802949,
0.0150438976,
-0.0726145133,
-0.0204239748,
0.0060323258,
2.821e-7,
-0.0038328664,
0.0565664433,
0.013564934,
0.0205851197,
0.0077075018,
0.0411488712,
-0.0106937941,
0.0087333536,
-0.0342027955,
-0.0291979872,
0.0070960298,
0.0331577435,
0.0034062944,
-0.0113702994,
-0.0604479685,
0.0127543109,
-0.0134952245,
-0.0030190765,
-0.0535507463,
0.0052254419,
0.0293639395,
0.0839311257,
-0.0023788076,
-0.0040949951,
0.0235753227,
-0.0353621989,
0.0177963991,
0.0008243337,
0.0005441275,
0.0334818065,
-0.0487644412,
0.0392782912,
-0.0210984088,
0.0148359938,
-0.0042970683,
-0.0029369728,
0.0174277797,
0.0583420321,
0.0124948276,
0.0284020547,
0.0192559306,
-0.0492242239,
0.0447464362,
-0.070511885,
0.0637457371,
-0.0301160123,
-0.0111206351,
0.0093833003,
-0.0290622935,
-0.0563507862,
-0.0471427143,
-0.0166380852,
0.049547866,
-0.0063781859,
-0.0307287499,
-0.0035357133,
-0.0104349433,
-0.0812923238,
0.0038189993,
-0.0007298207,
-0.0298126806,
-0.0335483737,
-0.0448239148,
-0.0092988387,
0.0577568933,
-0.0477542095,
-0.0048765889,
3.042713633e-34,
0.0171557069,
-0.0134247541,
-0.0129892733,
0.0386663899,
0.0253534243,
0.0067734909,
-0.0231434423,
0.0060620597,
0.0398005769,
-0.0791925266,
-0.0234003402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12835v1 | Joint Dropout: Improving Generalizability in Low-Resource Neural Machine Translation through Phrase Pair Variables | 2023-07-24T14:33:49 | 2023-07-24T14:33:49 | Ali Araabi, Vlad Niculae, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Despite the tremendous success of Neural Machine Translation (NMT), its
performance on low-resource language pairs still remains subpar, partly due to
the limited ability to handle previously unseen inputs, i.e., generalization.
In this paper, we propose a method called Joint Dropout, that addresses the
challenge of low-resource neural machine translation by substituting phrases
with variables, resulting in significant enhancement of compositionality, which
is a key aspect of generalization. We observe a substantial improvement in
translation quality for language pairs with minimal resources, as seen in BLEU
and Direct Assessment scores. Furthermore, we conduct an error analysis, and
find Joint Dropout to also enhance generalizability of low-resource NMT in
terms of robustness and adaptability across different domains | [
0.0122601362,
0.0750670061,
-0.0001912807,
0.0212076791,
-0.0400827788,
0.019837549,
0.0417994596,
-0.0087457309,
-0.0528775752,
-0.0079915253,
-0.019023966,
-0.0295612998,
0.0585640743,
0.0175345037,
0.0357703082,
-0.0502420925,
0.0144968377,
0.0188325439,
-0.0413317569,
-0.0084102787,
-0.016642103,
0.0238505807,
0.0123611474,
0.0139678381,
-0.0124153662,
0.0090058893,
-0.0019983931,
0.055958353,
0.0317506306,
-0.0064123981,
-0.0034077505,
0.0364736095,
-0.0205652751,
0.066674985,
0.0000019879,
-0.0463053808,
-0.0117942542,
0.0090037053,
0.0263035018,
0.0251386799,
0.0417718589,
-0.0246039182,
0.0212215129,
0.0378247872,
0.0115470598,
-0.0211429596,
0.056323342,
0.0091005443,
0.0465465523,
0.0872438252,
-0.0125351455,
0.0188011844,
-0.0166976415,
-0.0714014918,
0.0380733684,
-0.0299120974,
-0.0182238463,
-0.0357593447,
-0.0536772236,
-0.0277772266,
-0.0240341369,
0.0475036912,
0.0466748178,
-0.0060698912,
-0.0159027725,
0.0094451057,
-0.0645908564,
-0.0546022728,
0.0013044282,
0.1037995592,
-0.0309179258,
0.0368179753,
-0.0026319337,
-0.0303377062,
0.012797459,
-0.0232727509,
-0.0578225777,
-0.0024000036,
0.0067468719,
0.0040470404,
0.0003678623,
0.020362081,
0.0581451729,
-0.0127336718,
-0.022670595,
-0.012533905,
0.0586409643,
-0.0285317656,
0.0051964377,
0.035618905,
-0.0143956561,
-0.0122702578,
0.0500304028,
0.0023405892,
0.015333754,
0.0054853666,
-0.0600723661,
-0.0640732497,
-0.0134124467,
-0.022657685,
0.0525504202,
0.0571161471,
0.0008478991,
0.0343760103,
-0.0129506988,
0.0696254298,
0.0024117152,
0.0123849278,
-0.0600204691,
-0.0189711135,
-0.0210699774,
0.0182754751,
-0.0077846129,
0.021584861,
-0.0224334337,
0.0009208664,
-0.0381835401,
0.0123795671,
-0.0325235389,
-0.005910493,
0.0460561365,
-0.003824109,
-0.0995385051,
-0.0198045876,
0.0053953007,
0.0798360184,
-0.0060118721,
-0.0167519562,
0.0294601526,
-0.0581249706,
-0.0372943319,
0.0300680511,
0.0094233565,
-0.0446041487,
-0.0104934527,
0.0669587255,
-0.0012072013,
-0.0233222898,
-0.0141772581,
0.0118453521,
-0.0242470577,
-0.0627398789,
0.027679285,
-0.0495415106,
0.095047012,
-0.0137254745,
0.0316462889,
-0.0468879864,
-0.0062642158,
0.0093909046,
-0.0088199219,
0.0416224673,
0.0095347725,
-0.0472343042,
0.0199501868,
0.0202842541,
0.0134808123,
0.0642388687,
0.0535843186,
-0.0114508793,
-0.0279136561,
0.0101478864,
-0.0288043898,
0.030129252,
0.029280439,
0.0223533362,
-0.0316503644,
-0.0291136298,
0.0081760576,
0.0636080503,
0.0578954928,
0.0644025058,
-0.0234905221,
-0.0042031263,
0.06559816,
0.0209973343,
0.0569875464,
0.0589826331,
0.0746730715,
0.0076552206,
-0.0336495563,
0.020937534,
-0.01540682,
0.0470642559,
-0.0147614628,
-0.0151232835,
0.060125757,
0.0807730481,
-0.0433692038,
-0.0733350068,
0.0023603931,
-0.0276021473,
0.0384918936,
-0.0377320275,
0.02168281,
0.0267073475,
-0.0013411231,
0.0529875569,
0.0146954479,
-0.0715384558,
0.0589209534,
-0.021053018,
-0.0196869727,
0.0329372883,
0.0474645644,
0.0192158446,
-0.0305783805,
-0.0137856249,
0.0059838351,
0.0570406578,
0.05286007,
0.0267829429,
0.0676718131,
-0.0724839568,
-0.0128645916,
-0.0187121872,
0.0032456159,
0.0253050067,
-0.015556884,
0.0308280531,
0.0691206083,
-0.0541756675,
-0.034389168,
0.0267327987,
-0.0051439414,
-0.0404387116,
0.0336350314,
0.0329493992,
0.0300860796,
0.0217198785,
0.010180708,
0.0059206532,
-0.0107936449,
-0.04056013,
-0.0643448457,
-0.0091273738,
-0.0595941767,
-0.080679059,
0.0074959425,
-0.0654394552,
-0.0111368438,
0.0147028342,
-0.0493323505,
-0.0612121113,
0.0175828505,
-0.0276059192,
-0.0000035253,
-0.0241312496,
0.004945585,
0.0239874572,
-0.0034051097,
-0.0241538677,
0.0282622315,
-0.0059182844,
-0.0138586229,
-0.0237741526,
0.0100500127,
0.0075768512,
-0.0397524796,
-0.0533755496,
0.0381360129,
0.0080462983,
0.0445934683,
0.0267018843,
0.0513832681,
-0.0266988743,
-0.03943206,
-0.0386167839,
0.0062268521,
-0.009242937,
0.0071107154,
0.0443776697,
0.0651810914,
0.0220399257,
0.0104276435,
-0.0401722342,
0.0203391407,
-0.0435882807,
0.0201253705,
0.0153400609,
-0.0044442951,
0.0269848425,
0.0193103347,
-0.0221888255,
0.0021025667,
0.0585099533,
0.0005448365,
0.0117937336,
-0.0525139198,
0.0379186384,
-0.0623922162,
-0.0231213849,
0.0238783993,
-0.0552529246,
-0.0104164882,
-0.0184830837,
0.0292024259,
0.0568349957,
-0.0298817139,
-0.009287864,
0.0575923473,
0.0139568578,
-0.0731310025,
0.0244120974,
-0.0281384028,
-0.020756634,
0.0170727149,
-0.0346555263,
-0.0067851678,
0.0411427058,
0.0143831093,
-0.0156872906,
-0.0553547181,
0.0208208021,
-0.02295883,
-0.0238551982,
-0.0001445366,
0.0306874793,
0.0016406848,
-0.0343357101,
-0.0151555631,
-0.0409061685,
0.0821978301,
-0.0225376226,
0.0003942456,
-0.0611834675,
0.0289034639,
-0.0455889963,
0.0183058716,
-0.0329305418,
0.0003306588,
-0.020853214,
-0.0374243632,
-0.056202095,
0.0148003083,
-0.0072475602,
0.007786016,
0.0290265586,
-0.0627242923,
-0.0087013151,
-0.0225028414,
-0.0092040598,
0.0181432217,
0.0323823951,
0.0155703714,
-0.0087283105,
-0.0128184585,
-0.0196193177,
-0.0200180858,
-0.0301497299,
0.0248527713,
0.0719979331,
-0.0319065638,
0.0109154023,
-0.0088739572,
0.0327953696,
-0.0142342094,
0.0229425523,
-0.01059548,
-0.0639171824,
-0.0126713365,
0.0244033933,
-0.0137525937,
-0.0045800637,
-0.03347129,
-0.0021102251,
0.0095231878,
0.0444584042,
-0.0169132501,
0.0175472908,
0.0400177725,
-0.0703755766,
-0.021703463,
0.0907193646,
-0.0057254569,
-0.0503859185,
-0.0154242394,
-0.0190308616,
0.0456781872,
0.0339588411,
0.0202643313,
-0.0421740599,
-0.0260009691,
0.0076898043,
0.0315204524,
0.024057081,
0.0155981863,
-0.0314381197,
-0.0734491721,
-0.0095745707,
0.0719022527,
-0.050437931,
-0.0384389944,
0.0011557728,
-0.0286697187,
-0.0385797136,
0.0621531941,
-0.0375320092,
0.015602191,
-0.0100028971,
0.0022557902,
-0.0009442681,
-0.0605160892,
-0.0092729805,
-0.030082887,
0.0250030123,
0.052867949,
0.0408539958,
-0.0262834616,
-0.0080861347,
0.0526951402,
-0.0289659407,
-0.0142671019,
-0.0244802684,
0.004418639,
0.0006873077,
-0.0239911918,
0.0474846736,
0.0129837738,
-0.0340276882,
0.0400129966,
0.0015624585,
0.0730577558,
-0.0138259986,
-0.0360954031,
0.0050477982,
-0.0222347025,
0.0049391165,
0.0644171387,
0.0817530006,
-0.0745672211,
0.0277836826,
-0.0186015423,
-0.0441641398,
-0.1057703197,
-0.003517312,
0.0284838453,
-0.0040732767,
-0.0196367726,
-0.0651133657,
-0.0732834041,
0.0138955396,
0.0472028293,
-0.0060553364,
0.0000892605,
0.016673658,
-0.0019724008,
-0.0026789906,
0.0477427356,
-0.0288194399,
-0.0146309463,
-0.0296682455,
0.0011834626,
-0.0290434957,
-0.014479083,
-0.0199116673,
0.0065068468,
-0.1006061956,
-0.0709753633,
-0.0115825646,
0.0700879619,
0.0197643209,
0.0216808822,
0.0007042102,
-0.0390747003,
0.036964979,
0.0173360575,
0.0343470387,
0.0100036254,
0.0192030426,
0.0046652406,
0.0163858552,
0.0514387153,
-0.0185136814,
-0.010901236,
0.0317325629,
0.0758030862,
0.0139964009,
-0.0084519489,
0.0117699262,
-0.0017646903,
0.0152426753,
-0.0028127744,
-0.0130013861,
-0.0424332768,
0.0422254242,
-0.0133774756,
-0.0029307862,
-0.0693309903,
-0.0230622832,
0.04284909,
0.0216875877,
0.0085760178,
-0.0072076591,
0.0008213657,
0.0175271276,
-0.0248051528,
-0.0123186484,
-0.0098058488,
0.0043737963,
0.0076475656,
0.0222263709,
-0.0247464273,
0.0132293431,
-0.00876828,
-0.0263924897,
-0.0461269766,
0.0386758968,
0.0087074917,
0.0422998369,
-0.0122597059,
0.0123808747,
-0.00513444,
0.0002590756,
-0.0231733676,
-0.0228660442,
0.0272574164,
0.0256393626,
0.0846647918,
0.0266428832,
-0.0201736521,
-0.0317374542,
0.0537039787,
-0.0182693359,
-0.0338324867,
0.0120882206,
-0.0046921023,
0.0146694304,
0.0148904072,
0.0665823221,
-0.013738309,
-0.0005813194,
-0.0185825098,
0.0490464047,
-0.0196541753,
-0.0084348945,
0.010595941,
0.004202344,
-0.0362106934,
-0.0010094367,
-0.0272278674,
-0.0543689542,
0.0123150907,
-0.00446124,
0.0191151742,
-0.0009846864,
0.018465668,
0.0728446469,
-0.0730232969,
0.0223174356,
-0.0056010359,
-0.0218172893,
-0.0000112131,
-0.0350040458,
-0.0129894475,
-6.878884942e-33,
-0.0343681872,
-0.0112737138,
0.0241153874,
-0.0483813882,
-0.0061700009,
0.0428044125,
-0.0318903849,
-0.0312008429,
-0.0263116937,
-0.0162358116,
0.0181997251,
0.0219247602,
0.0125628868,
0.0323400237,
0.01733955,
0.0307983346,
0.0588494688,
0.0170466881,
-0.0385583825,
0.0301743951,
0.0187797602,
0.0377974771,
0.1083150953,
-0.0477319546,
0.044675,
0.0236080419,
-0.010015144,
0.006861276,
-0.0209779032,
0.0234300047,
0.0049477038,
0.0151679348,
0.0374318957,
0.0046839411,
-0.0310640093,
-0.0235328451,
-0.0861109048,
-0.053544201,
-0.0067383689,
-0.009316775,
-0.0550884679,
-0.0568376444,
0.0792578086,
-0.0155030517,
-0.0071728951,
-0.0748124793,
0.0092486609,
-0.0033651399,
-0.0594971217,
-0.002056086,
-0.0724185482,
-0.0026175084,
0.0079279132,
0.0070308289,
-0.0209915694,
0.0338659845,
-0.0361616947,
0.0093616815,
-0.0940471962,
0.0036089635,
-0.023411762,
0.0627518669,
0.0550544038,
-0.0117708277,
-0.0294214934,
0.0152200116,
0.0335673466,
0.0019030926,
0.042178642,
-0.0015048075,
0.0522922799,
-0.0402808785,
0.0753079802,
0.0282560363,
0.0461153798,
-0.0036111048,
-0.0796619281,
0.0170005597,
-0.0078026596,
0.0243926197,
0.0131426742,
0.001745803,
-0.0282409135,
-0.0060496558,
-0.0435669348,
-0.0349748209,
-0.0676879063,
-0.0340652391,
0.0078155678,
0.027876595,
-0.0248077363,
-0.0257130284,
0.0532159507,
0.0099689933,
0.0390108973,
-0.0032025366,
0.0041558486,
0.0032074098,
-0.0047868588,
0.0229765624,
-0.0018447101,
-0.0466236025,
-0.0071838922,
0.0309953392,
0.0397553146,
-0.0193056073,
0.0692102909,
0.0343533978,
-0.0332735255,
-0.0420237854,
-0.0773005933,
-0.0298896004,
-0.0083011733,
0.0433762446,
0.0365347899,
0.0114725968,
-0.0152189359,
0.0575983189,
0.0119408108,
-0.0036907152,
-0.0255839899,
-0.0034245877,
0.0381271765,
0.0439827703,
-0.0576161034,
-0.0362419225,
-0.0053434777,
-0.0286488943,
0.0570781939,
-0.0382372513,
-0.0351245999,
-0.0025211382,
2.82e-7,
0.0456165336,
0.047456298,
-0.024297135,
-0.0121490741,
-0.0209591258,
0.0079860901,
-0.0532588251,
0.0396904014,
-0.0125701101,
0.0483711138,
0.0494230948,
0.0151640838,
0.0793655291,
0.0080478555,
-0.1008858532,
-0.0090403818,
-0.0406686254,
0.0186711196,
-0.0508553535,
-0.0116610602,
0.0504171588,
0.0736621693,
0.0160331726,
0.0099074859,
0.0114125283,
-0.0374617875,
0.0720106736,
0.0183651689,
-0.0320709497,
-0.0151293958,
0.0380303226,
0.0501797684,
-0.0194618367,
-0.0148429414,
-0.0374619886,
0.0207348429,
0.0651050359,
0.0759734958,
0.0056126607,
-0.0364018157,
0.0186015982,
0.017699996,
-0.0288070738,
-0.0157575328,
0.0427577049,
-0.0725829005,
-0.0237348918,
0.0245826989,
-0.0111678941,
0.0236984473,
0.0701740012,
-0.0337365568,
-0.0289345793,
-0.0195292607,
0.0303545631,
-0.0240953453,
-0.033339493,
-0.0458421223,
-0.0106358184,
-0.0061413208,
-0.0299852472,
-0.0422116965,
-0.0417809822,
-0.0014767632,
0.029234603,
-0.0073035988,
-0.0171529893,
2.659552295e-34,
0.04598983,
-0.0362898856,
0.0470606983,
-0.0334983952,
0.008309802,
-0.0181774199,
-0.0279588532,
-0.0172994938,
-0.0314091854,
-0.0322869942,
-0.0583777353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02432v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02432v1 | Performance of Large Language Models in a Computer Science Degree Program | 2023-07-24T14:17:00 | 2023-07-24T14:17:00 | Tim Krüger, Michael Gref | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models such as ChatGPT-3.5 and GPT-4.0 are ubiquitous and
dominate the current discourse. Their transformative capabilities have led to a
paradigm shift in how we interact with and utilize (text-based) information.
Each day, new possibilities to leverage the capabilities of these models
emerge. This paper presents findings on the performance of different large
language models in a university of applied sciences' undergraduate computer
science degree program. Our primary objective is to assess the effectiveness of
these models within the curriculum by employing them as educational aids. By
prompting the models with lecture material, exercise tasks, and past exams, we
aim to evaluate their proficiency across different computer science domains. We
showcase the strong performance of current large language models while
highlighting limitations and constraints within the context of such a degree
program. We found that ChatGPT-3.5 averaged 79.9% of the total score in 10
tested modules, BingAI achieved 68.4%, and LLaMa, in the 65 billion parameter
variant, 20%. Despite these convincing results, even GPT-4.0 would not pass the
degree program - due to limitations in mathematical calculations. | [
0.0222473573,
0.0232432242,
-0.0351895019,
0.0206817556,
-0.0419604182,
-0.0001017989,
0.0010853255,
-0.0133252973,
0.0361770429,
-0.0416330658,
0.0347283296,
-0.028064115,
-0.0217242371,
0.0340513773,
0.0164732672,
-0.0786186308,
0.053200461,
-0.058579877,
-0.0302643906,
-0.0027172004,
0.0123905418,
0.0036805016,
-0.0290234815,
0.0567080751,
0.0276479535,
-0.0523365065,
-0.0003897786,
-0.0178326797,
-0.0435730517,
-0.0349198841,
-0.0038768591,
0.040201731,
0.0430534966,
0.0450944006,
0.0000022981,
-0.0638260096,
0.0064024953,
0.0613209046,
-0.0406106003,
0.108587265,
0.074140504,
0.0842424929,
-0.0100663006,
0.0159892496,
-0.0055006058,
0.0315608829,
0.0423103236,
-0.0165470578,
0.0387011431,
0.0245675091,
0.0199291594,
-0.0357650593,
0.0285285562,
0.018850686,
-0.008176052,
-0.0071956781,
0.0495395511,
0.0788891613,
0.0823551193,
0.0524818152,
-0.0264564138,
0.0014461568,
0.0148685044,
-0.0132758459,
0.0141987149,
0.0318413638,
-0.0444782749,
0.0154935531,
-0.0063847685,
-0.0076290956,
0.0014216487,
-0.0359706916,
-0.0088687288,
-0.0162503943,
-0.0119101815,
0.0337038301,
-0.092738077,
0.0166567918,
0.0097584827,
-0.0088340798,
-0.0001204432,
-0.0281845666,
-0.0010229849,
0.0367827043,
0.0193846412,
0.0295075886,
0.0494328178,
-0.0233988985,
0.0004646816,
0.0158162527,
-0.0348460153,
0.0039728945,
0.0177405067,
0.0572219789,
0.0095628127,
0.0204918161,
0.0099394666,
0.0166299809,
0.0427526049,
-0.0894863084,
0.0321166664,
0.0481430776,
0.0216554776,
0.0451755337,
-0.0040775202,
0.0774418339,
-0.0052112876,
-0.0332425609,
0.0101143755,
0.0324406922,
-0.0699743181,
-0.0260874741,
-0.0460918993,
0.0390640274,
0.0157682449,
0.0247316752,
-0.066202119,
0.0321506299,
-0.0329626203,
0.0121212434,
-0.0000759113,
-0.0262069143,
0.0007478855,
0.0217245445,
-0.0394743755,
0.0443978198,
0.0195248909,
-0.0061041107,
-0.0187528208,
-0.0490158051,
0.0078921802,
-0.0035269747,
-0.0585394464,
-0.0284871329,
0.024752982,
0.046515204,
-0.01415319,
0.0220401436,
-0.0078448011,
-0.0112936059,
-0.0189655442,
-0.0394111946,
-0.0103574563,
-0.0866785645,
-0.0440503322,
0.0328900516,
0.0119169904,
-0.0111938976,
0.0077488059,
0.0182625242,
-0.0044520958,
0.0365691632,
-0.012937516,
-0.0084778313,
0.0422997698,
0.0307763517,
0.0111260796,
0.0456716232,
0.0290010329,
0.0106633743,
-0.0076987785,
-0.0618797168,
0.0340991542,
0.039812617,
-0.0352424085,
0.0210562777,
-0.0183312893,
0.017336037,
0.0696801245,
0.0234224051,
-0.083580479,
0.0607625023,
0.0019864282,
0.0445163138,
0.025578456,
0.0330449566,
0.0170304906,
0.0682323799,
0.0398539752,
0.0342726856,
0.0519114062,
-0.0209943354,
-0.0062609161,
0.0114229722,
-0.0339708328,
0.01606985,
-0.0067171273,
0.0424453169,
0.0069882744,
-0.0352612436,
-0.0212055575,
-0.0063983905,
-0.0062638391,
-0.0040894644,
0.0739147142,
-0.0482686535,
-0.0069675837,
0.011397602,
0.0292740483,
-0.0681153238,
0.0108835604,
-0.0676646158,
0.0195623823,
0.0756332278,
0.0659773126,
-0.0547492616,
-0.0080462396,
0.0015273617,
0.0362752788,
0.0421260595,
0.0827239975,
0.0014446018,
-0.0491160862,
-0.0389686897,
0.0224696156,
-0.0044883993,
0.0075475974,
0.0077166501,
0.0177371632,
-0.0002273867,
0.0069348393,
0.0005265041,
-0.0655695572,
-0.0169845819,
-0.0825475082,
-0.0196241215,
-0.0622683764,
-0.0350865349,
0.0214956626,
0.0204997342,
-0.0099709444,
0.0199158546,
0.0163068864,
0.0153469378,
-0.013289595,
-0.0591629818,
-0.034968853,
0.0606058054,
0.0703029931,
-0.0314306021,
0.0005527097,
0.0060188561,
0.0026800865,
-0.018492721,
0.0846696794,
-0.0159131065,
0.0420701802,
-0.0120900609,
0.0157738067,
-0.065369755,
0.0144573236,
-0.0172033925,
0.0094221635,
0.0587346144,
0.0715353563,
0.0216293652,
-0.0009959877,
0.038785439,
0.0043653962,
-0.034972012,
0.0095826983,
0.0123302564,
0.0459103324,
0.0241589807,
0.0043778243,
-0.0462863855,
-0.0427119993,
-0.0572274327,
-0.0376790203,
0.0209221654,
0.0316316858,
0.0070289527,
-0.0278218742,
-0.0258393846,
0.0415987074,
-0.0152556086,
-0.0332158543,
-0.0239373706,
-0.0133950366,
-0.0184964202,
-0.020315038,
-0.0745761767,
-0.0574301928,
-0.0320113711,
-0.0715336427,
0.0293843858,
0.0510345474,
-0.014558346,
-0.0222616121,
0.0699405596,
0.0004601612,
0.0100661619,
-0.0078104124,
-0.0294638909,
0.0358570665,
-0.0371763036,
0.0820610449,
0.0111757144,
-0.0152710676,
0.0507241823,
0.0322892778,
-0.0383055694,
-0.0331986286,
0.0123413643,
-0.0159252528,
-0.0340743698,
-0.0279816166,
-0.0501760133,
-0.0332613625,
0.0261057783,
-0.0058044265,
-0.0357056297,
0.0035236357,
0.0172786415,
-0.0686324239,
0.0247347467,
-0.0204987954,
-0.0012644582,
-0.0036430573,
-0.0277574416,
0.0209679324,
-0.0056699975,
0.0564667694,
-0.0562894866,
-0.0092868423,
-0.0286131836,
-0.0387327634,
-0.0389710926,
0.0527008772,
0.0039849803,
-0.0057117487,
-0.0138166277,
0.017275868,
-0.0307311825,
0.0158087853,
0.0036600595,
-0.0462672189,
0.0379835591,
-0.0457304604,
-0.0090802936,
-0.005531616,
0.0274915025,
-0.0109701445,
0.0196757372,
-0.0024536974,
0.034133222,
0.0220815707,
-0.0350144468,
0.0004469921,
0.024979718,
0.0528852828,
-0.0077121989,
-0.0245906878,
-0.0090217469,
0.0094085615,
-0.0233183969,
-0.0093151722,
-0.007143293,
-0.0065154084,
-0.0671803728,
0.0329861604,
0.0230900571,
0.031449005,
-0.0008731445,
-0.0512685217,
-0.0045001903,
0.0458116122,
-0.0463160761,
0.0017574561,
0.0547466315,
0.0157700945,
-0.0597738884,
-0.0234535113,
0.0974658653,
0.0197314247,
-0.0156740472,
0.0061019673,
-0.0332316272,
0.0271840952,
0.041558519,
0.0363341011,
-0.073947005,
0.0154427318,
-0.0316828638,
-0.0074550034,
-0.0305318646,
-0.019955663,
-0.0147248488,
-0.0901137367,
0.0312364008,
0.0406425036,
-0.0043680207,
0.0071754707,
-0.0614875667,
0.000059564,
-0.002317908,
0.0090772044,
0.0273914188,
-0.0168120507,
0.0320905596,
0.0433015972,
-0.0421875827,
-0.0414667279,
0.0506053902,
0.0262553524,
0.0333803222,
-0.0087462626,
0.0027120931,
-0.0621083826,
-0.0209048633,
0.0559271947,
0.0054907301,
0.0043613329,
0.00850082,
-0.0251819436,
0.0166225787,
0.0108827325,
-0.0346815959,
-0.0296971854,
-0.0129741924,
-0.0009931672,
0.0518876053,
0.0899910182,
-0.003946085,
-0.0133001544,
-0.049784068,
-0.0220252238,
-0.0117113004,
0.0476805642,
0.0306550674,
-0.0385660306,
-0.0018672403,
-0.0858191624,
-0.0402457565,
0.0249430146,
-0.0422962531,
-0.0131627712,
-0.0081219245,
-0.0084906453,
0.0540770404,
-0.022231916,
0.0431003012,
-0.0138301039,
0.025854338,
0.0347267315,
0.0476453826,
0.0174326915,
-0.0483695604,
0.0335748866,
-0.0509506911,
0.0400175452,
-0.0518250316,
-0.0172771066,
0.0043034111,
-0.0197743792,
-0.0442525223,
0.0367970951,
-0.0619570725,
-0.0752536803,
0.001960451,
0.0460322201,
0.0316550061,
-0.0646114647,
0.0049568284,
-0.0225694142,
-0.0505876653,
0.0154486392,
-0.0113856765,
0.0177382603,
-0.0084010344,
-0.0012968227,
0.0259362049,
-0.0389622189,
0.0028460133,
0.0113839023,
0.0107137598,
0.0285836589,
-0.0080808876,
-0.0262663476,
0.0245231558,
0.0949297398,
-0.0031702593,
0.0219502691,
-0.0134624299,
-0.0099624284,
0.0175205637,
-0.0535479859,
-0.0099078175,
-0.0204986259,
-0.0410081372,
0.029633306,
0.0194054786,
0.0052517578,
-0.0168232583,
-0.0236885827,
0.0393583961,
-0.0215261225,
0.0545549989,
-0.0193957873,
0.0331230499,
0.0602799244,
-0.0489153266,
-0.0256699976,
-0.032291837,
-0.0333953314,
0.0260297265,
-0.0221654698,
0.0626552403,
-0.0030589292,
-0.0008677716,
0.02708501,
0.0100641921,
0.0009802681,
-0.0516138673,
-0.0297621042,
0.0393741839,
0.0239193123,
0.0727625266,
0.0131813083,
-0.0787472948,
0.0235305317,
-0.0270359199,
0.0236766152,
-0.0135293687,
-0.0557585359,
0.0345464535,
0.0266140625,
0.0097330585,
-0.0046773134,
0.0361932516,
-0.0028166564,
-0.0153040718,
0.0256665349,
-0.0280887485,
-0.0086509325,
-0.0228875931,
0.001642184,
0.0192688331,
0.0086489301,
0.0084705921,
-0.0826739222,
-0.056631919,
-0.0405625775,
0.0163302068,
0.009338852,
-0.0429255888,
0.0584387444,
0.0485312156,
-0.0483889729,
0.0102800559,
0.0010604203,
0.0276771896,
-0.0008173352,
-0.0264753513,
0.0136746569,
-6.16499253e-33,
-0.0274442229,
-0.0102699706,
0.0583791658,
0.012444607,
-0.0014876791,
-0.0259023774,
-0.0270756297,
0.0324786343,
-0.0338989086,
-0.0187808927,
-0.0021071723,
0.0167876892,
-0.001671016,
0.0021864667,
0.0212258548,
0.0297316574,
0.0383704081,
0.0254982766,
-0.0023527984,
0.0159663986,
-0.0099560618,
-0.0126663307,
0.0803150684,
-0.0442259237,
0.0036646274,
-0.0257633068,
-0.0064038644,
-0.0610898994,
-0.027827777,
0.0358123593,
-0.0198032111,
0.0642471686,
-0.0002271929,
-0.0537079982,
-0.0087001016,
-0.0355456844,
0.0211004764,
-0.0292386506,
0.0389977396,
0.0176979247,
0.0476502441,
-0.0499580875,
0.039731551,
0.0151852025,
-0.0724632442,
-0.0074673193,
0.0369268321,
-0.0194160994,
-0.0094787031,
0.0379218571,
-0.0658932477,
0.0104777152,
-0.0214283243,
0.0327346548,
-0.0226570759,
-0.0240912549,
-0.0434915461,
-0.0037802353,
0.0398795605,
0.038232971,
0.0879268646,
0.078550905,
0.0726357549,
-0.0291924328,
-0.0018939609,
0.0078894738,
0.0466106385,
0.0225584041,
-0.0365638658,
-0.0437540524,
0.0310501102,
0.0152194854,
0.0639487877,
0.031553492,
0.0066848281,
-0.0195434671,
-0.0874749422,
-0.0151439477,
0.0313790031,
-0.0038011956,
0.0037594801,
-0.0237875767,
-0.0591329187,
-0.045922555,
-0.0226271786,
0.0250742994,
-0.0117771132,
-0.0430852063,
0.0110225268,
-0.0776539594,
0.0005302613,
0.0178377014,
-0.0020961515,
-0.0422650911,
-0.0675898492,
-0.0039451947,
-0.0134283612,
0.0615623593,
-0.0171026532,
0.0428064354,
-0.0700553209,
-0.0180946067,
-0.031207649,
-0.0084317299,
0.0275699999,
0.0150024211,
-0.0330980942,
0.0368852802,
-0.0320429839,
-0.0121986112,
-0.0601807199,
-0.0469703302,
0.0507517979,
-0.0018555191,
0.029433623,
0.0226639453,
0.0100346031,
0.0248288494,
-0.01217141,
-0.0555810854,
-0.0147224106,
-0.0257350504,
-0.0182799567,
-0.0090502212,
0.0042152838,
-0.0288523063,
-0.05034329,
0.0109970281,
0.0434173122,
-0.0581331663,
-0.0276678018,
0.0073103262,
2.979e-7,
0.0249747857,
0.0948298797,
-0.0036951941,
0.0239601806,
0.0033760089,
-0.0160189252,
-0.0372153781,
-0.022268964,
0.0273948442,
0.0273530632,
-0.0250134654,
0.0285545159,
0.0278480947,
0.0119883958,
-0.0435972624,
-0.0031588622,
-0.0277042389,
-0.0160895623,
-0.0774546713,
0.035987325,
0.0596247688,
0.0292774402,
0.0564781763,
0.0307086539,
-0.0522874296,
-0.060189046,
0.0177893676,
-0.0392036103,
-0.0129676266,
0.0321839042,
-0.0245235935,
0.030954551,
0.0132025518,
0.0206529927,
0.0202534981,
-0.0426802523,
0.0115185473,
0.0721840858,
0.0047025736,
0.0561187267,
0.0391989574,
-0.0304163713,
-0.0360345952,
-0.0695532635,
0.0159588624,
-0.0152100865,
-0.0152249271,
0.0078432141,
-0.0504869744,
-0.0407992639,
-0.0201717801,
-0.0197776631,
0.0255638212,
-0.0137232337,
-0.0268541891,
-0.028551789,
0.0100614466,
0.0354682691,
-0.0194330439,
-0.0024097522,
-0.0361058936,
-0.0942748412,
-0.0435160697,
-0.0187663306,
0.0335054882,
-0.0367792323,
0.0189441275,
2.998472801e-34,
0.067770049,
-0.0424986966,
0.0695514753,
0.0344979241,
-0.0059954552,
0.0177702866,
0.037828438,
0.009835395,
-0.005230641,
-0.0310191792,
-0.0590758696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12803v1 | Guidance in Radiology Report Summarization: An Empirical Evaluation and Error Analysis | 2023-07-24T13:54:37 | 2023-07-24T13:54:37 | Jan Trienes, Paul Youssef, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatically summarizing radiology reports into a concise impression can
reduce the manual burden of clinicians and improve the consistency of
reporting. Previous work aimed to enhance content selection and factuality
through guided abstractive summarization. However, two key issues persist.
First, current methods heavily rely on domain-specific resources to extract the
guidance signal, limiting their transferability to domains and languages where
those resources are unavailable. Second, while automatic metrics like ROUGE
show progress, we lack a good understanding of the errors and failure modes in
this task. To bridge these gaps, we first propose a domain-agnostic guidance
signal in form of variable-length extractive summaries. Our empirical results
on two English benchmarks demonstrate that this guidance signal improves upon
unguided summarization while being competitive with domain-specific methods.
Additionally, we run an expert evaluation of four systems according to a
taxonomy of 11 fine-grained errors. We find that the most pressing differences
between automatic summaries and those of radiologists relate to content
selection including omissions (up to 52%) and additions (up to 57%). We
hypothesize that latent reporting factors and corpus-level inconsistencies may
limit models to reliably learn content selection from the available data,
presenting promising directions for future work. | [
0.0524169728,
0.0361862294,
0.0228085462,
-0.0296335109,
-0.0306819174,
0.027480796,
-0.0202507805,
0.0343821011,
-0.0403906778,
-0.0087638563,
0.0112307789,
-0.0352629498,
0.0478324592,
0.0085536819,
0.0153660821,
-0.1220195219,
0.025977632,
0.0090983696,
0.0054657068,
0.0000125468,
0.0217698384,
0.007206901,
-0.0113206878,
0.0202845596,
-0.0021295901,
0.0091913054,
0.0426357239,
-0.0079184175,
0.0456524007,
-0.0375769101,
-0.0159402583,
0.020857716,
-0.007129408,
-0.0114225978,
0.0000018417,
-0.0318374299,
-0.038848538,
0.0210347585,
0.0209195521,
0.0041163671,
0.0680171102,
-0.1023175716,
0.0064979442,
-0.0045030569,
0.0021977972,
-0.0377966352,
0.0300294515,
0.0281882286,
0.0710136592,
0.0515764207,
-0.0202500839,
-0.0010783809,
-0.0307860486,
-0.0163585506,
-0.0547536425,
-0.0103930505,
0.0045125564,
0.0524010323,
0.0092650196,
-0.0071967458,
-0.0044997563,
0.0475681834,
-0.0198919959,
0.0032910686,
-0.0186141226,
0.0479260422,
-0.0175899621,
-0.0349127129,
0.0353069976,
0.0369687378,
0.0262788739,
0.0000305367,
0.0392689593,
-0.0172704048,
0.0014957483,
0.0055483705,
-0.05424463,
0.040210031,
-0.0325811766,
-0.026677819,
-0.0072926967,
0.0413729399,
-0.0311137065,
0.0334727652,
-0.0228274092,
-0.0240716655,
0.0023970907,
-0.0068888445,
0.017972149,
0.0327575952,
-0.0282762926,
-0.0456131212,
0.0269628372,
0.0191247873,
-0.0385893025,
-0.0019652131,
-0.0258487817,
-0.0517022647,
0.0710727051,
-0.0236089118,
-0.053735774,
-0.0049416944,
-0.0297655072,
0.0490709543,
0.0135984411,
0.0055417768,
0.0189048387,
0.0183902886,
-0.0482123867,
0.0016061445,
0.0047607534,
0.0115307812,
-0.0187363513,
0.0332532339,
0.0099703241,
-0.0051326742,
-0.0752625242,
-0.0408440866,
-0.0035864122,
0.0162832048,
0.0076034814,
0.0267268829,
-0.0604896471,
0.0221971646,
-0.0067678243,
0.0389767513,
-0.0370535068,
-0.0120667508,
0.0043103867,
0.014646776,
-0.0106565664,
0.0629062802,
0.0011551944,
0.0340178795,
-0.0185848735,
0.0023114039,
-0.0347401612,
-0.0000135921,
0.0515593402,
-0.0719458833,
-0.0364338271,
-0.0351305492,
0.0095234849,
-0.0774272978,
0.0034135915,
0.0257978626,
0.0165268071,
-0.0358687751,
-0.004391232,
-0.0014752856,
-0.0335328281,
0.0214916915,
-0.0421519168,
0.0071761478,
0.0406047963,
0.0307791997,
0.0085824598,
0.0197559316,
0.0228276886,
0.0108773122,
0.028461406,
0.0422263034,
0.0084970007,
-0.0037440069,
0.009150126,
-0.0194750484,
0.0400930904,
-0.0149749992,
-0.0421509407,
0.0340854675,
0.025112763,
0.0666234568,
-0.0201411843,
0.0116063999,
0.0175777283,
0.0483060367,
0.0220696758,
0.0070888442,
0.0417752601,
-0.0019986408,
0.0295008682,
0.0767994374,
-0.0032187735,
0.0159261972,
0.025094064,
0.0714967772,
0.0338271596,
0.0097927218,
-0.022792656,
-0.0502998121,
-0.0179511346,
0.0189009719,
-0.0048949653,
-0.0067011686,
0.0332990736,
0.0163240042,
-0.0358542576,
0.0395769589,
0.0467669293,
-0.0200082883,
0.0072376779,
-0.0128255412,
-0.0129351187,
0.0079199811,
0.064730078,
-0.0527825169,
-0.0108681144,
0.0053157257,
0.0616557971,
0.0373782553,
0.0502060205,
-0.0207249839,
0.007272196,
-0.0413131677,
-0.0448950902,
0.0420640521,
0.035469491,
-0.0248994268,
0.0014482131,
-0.0000722575,
0.0110249277,
-0.0240683425,
-0.0822972208,
0.0400251262,
-0.0208982751,
-0.0139380256,
-0.0109806107,
0.0061021503,
-0.0041947803,
0.0213318095,
-0.0110588139,
0.0156282261,
-0.0046232771,
0.016996881,
-0.0171069205,
0.0145303514,
-0.0617592521,
-0.0378393792,
0.0059248055,
-0.089223735,
-0.0005798363,
-0.0062611108,
-0.0323754773,
-0.0228240509,
-0.0240607411,
-0.0894803032,
-0.0175286438,
0.0003605448,
0.0316419788,
0.0744929612,
-0.0271535981,
-0.0053430228,
0.0527870283,
0.0056239655,
-0.0020329247,
0.0623374842,
-0.05618646,
0.0063643381,
-0.0415594205,
0.0073253103,
-0.0046279542,
0.0088700838,
0.0043119364,
0.0518906005,
0.028010441,
-0.0267121885,
-0.0190757923,
-0.0730193779,
-0.0208931919,
-0.0157490093,
-0.0079796128,
0.0489902385,
0.0164156053,
0.0048824209,
0.000625648,
-0.0270848237,
-0.0683761165,
0.035362877,
0.0137563124,
0.0605392382,
0.0556409806,
0.0358097553,
-0.061624866,
-0.019839257,
-0.0225704852,
0.0033462176,
0.0523598939,
-0.0725793019,
-0.0268231146,
0.0491503775,
-0.0497487187,
-0.0308045391,
0.0148885371,
-0.0314671323,
-0.0065045916,
-0.0149851106,
-0.0191902258,
0.0174087174,
0.0269742236,
0.0019990094,
0.055440098,
-0.0092650736,
-0.0323180184,
-0.0122930566,
-0.0698032752,
-0.0035662567,
0.0516791753,
-0.0688443184,
0.0299935192,
0.0202865247,
0.0273385439,
0.0240291469,
-0.0238905754,
-0.0249558501,
-0.0522317067,
0.0121074989,
-0.0256966278,
-0.0072547914,
-0.0038307582,
0.0605562963,
0.0116511863,
-0.0058651976,
0.1110192314,
0.0057583824,
0.0397302918,
-0.0907678455,
-0.007924553,
-0.0552482493,
0.009435351,
-0.0212784857,
0.0335419998,
0.0659608841,
-0.0430568904,
-0.0220842212,
-0.0102360286,
0.0815020129,
-0.032234814,
0.0599408112,
-0.0419885777,
0.0152941821,
-0.018450005,
-0.030584991,
-0.0154953329,
-0.0407716669,
0.0218133517,
0.0129453717,
0.0145887826,
-0.0011564388,
-0.0903820172,
0.0500777252,
0.0530822799,
0.0612978041,
-0.0200875346,
-0.0121708475,
0.0138037074,
0.0365654826,
0.0525499657,
0.0224443059,
0.0151731884,
-0.0598363802,
0.0191872716,
0.0645662099,
-0.0321918204,
0.0003389215,
0.0153789083,
-0.0235128459,
-0.0366045944,
-0.0602974333,
-0.0055092876,
0.0022632706,
0.0500056967,
-0.0311468579,
-0.0091379369,
0.0943409204,
0.028766511,
-0.0339213163,
-0.0319095738,
0.0300092474,
0.0045965882,
-0.0128838783,
0.0014850628,
-0.0154550876,
0.0009253158,
-0.0193926543,
0.0606689416,
0.00075868,
-0.007308309,
0.0035172948,
-0.0291269459,
0.0367848203,
0.0155802751,
-0.0644317344,
-0.0654040948,
-0.037272431,
0.0066759456,
-0.0114466781,
-0.0332891978,
-0.0099366754,
-0.048652377,
0.0015960697,
0.0238521267,
-0.1164004058,
-0.041996263,
-0.020567989,
-0.0449494608,
-0.0526198596,
0.0326178931,
0.0498613901,
-0.0111284675,
0.0241041183,
-0.0188260525,
-0.0159713067,
-0.0173978638,
-0.0011996832,
0.1228417605,
0.0093752285,
0.0103528695,
-0.033443775,
0.0319059566,
0.0452013984,
0.0064241323,
-0.0084328651,
0.0131344544,
0.0019612301,
-0.0093374997,
-0.0525148101,
0.1052168161,
0.0063981358,
0.0457399897,
0.0189627241,
0.0368288606,
-0.0041389428,
0.0035550157,
0.0535758063,
-0.0318737477,
-0.0477911979,
0.0010915536,
-0.0826303959,
-0.0566419996,
-0.0844172835,
-0.0582746454,
0.0352813527,
0.0044074324,
0.0088152438,
-0.0082556996,
-0.0164708644,
-0.0028901147,
-0.0380608626,
0.0346111245,
0.0153541118,
-0.0134539688,
-0.0165857039,
-0.0368752182,
0.0571078435,
0.0015646314,
-0.0201234408,
0.0414437614,
-0.0253395047,
-0.0089994296,
-0.0042729317,
0.0404887795,
0.0271841045,
0.0153134735,
0.0154839987,
-0.0033854065,
0.0657436028,
0.0438722111,
-0.0016289949,
0.0231798925,
0.005230037,
-0.0026265113,
-0.0402513742,
0.0017769485,
-0.0517592989,
0.0295368582,
-0.016642943,
0.042942673,
-0.0531344414,
-0.0451754555,
0.030791916,
0.0432846583,
0.0100641912,
-0.0457994081,
0.0127526792,
-0.0209075585,
-0.0439065024,
-0.0185694881,
-0.0157016683,
0.00075795,
0.0605849996,
-0.0204441007,
0.0077292267,
-0.0205694679,
0.0798256621,
-0.0500511639,
-0.0092684282,
-0.0409211516,
0.010018779,
0.0016000798,
-0.0408112705,
-0.0122004319,
-0.0147546493,
-0.0605055951,
-0.0587398782,
-0.0019764104,
0.0200451389,
0.0074209147,
0.0312637947,
0.0330611356,
0.0643537864,
-0.0225042757,
0.0271109808,
-0.0505405553,
-0.0156361796,
-0.0522975586,
0.006049253,
0.036250066,
-0.0286468305,
0.0455336794,
-0.0462584011,
-0.0024614509,
-0.0247036554,
0.03637328,
0.0166673586,
0.0322136134,
0.0103673059,
0.0099130915,
0.0446743444,
-0.0109010506,
0.0915690213,
-0.0432709046,
-0.0069784089,
-0.0040398054,
-0.0703025237,
-0.0505511127,
-0.0501384288,
-0.0117291519,
-0.0095905988,
-0.0231934935,
-0.0272333119,
-0.0865738094,
-0.0148427766,
0.0025202611,
-0.0126647437,
-0.0032407821,
-0.0405903198,
0.0538128242,
0.0368576907,
0.0141996304,
-0.0150678717,
-0.0340924636,
0.019520184,
-0.0153491562,
0.0145970397,
-0.0138533236,
-5.619695027e-33,
-0.0307044499,
-0.0275383722,
-0.0044527669,
-0.0104187559,
-0.0000495953,
0.048866801,
-0.0658178627,
-0.0185026303,
0.0055001262,
0.0352456719,
-0.0146503383,
-0.0099456226,
0.0326485783,
0.0212014709,
0.0123777315,
0.036590334,
0.0420513749,
0.0175261591,
-0.0492549315,
0.0145797255,
-0.0151495794,
-0.0058422303,
0.0266690291,
-0.0897751302,
0.0319785066,
0.0069993474,
-0.0070341215,
-0.0375466719,
0.0473547019,
0.0431617051,
0.0094779814,
-0.0199532844,
0.0165782832,
-0.0317829251,
-0.0381558873,
-0.0073153465,
-0.0977764204,
-0.0269017182,
0.0445355028,
-0.0309943464,
-0.0575226322,
-0.0097060166,
0.0281840563,
-0.0301587973,
0.0254458468,
-0.0514152274,
0.074515231,
-0.0234565698,
-0.0176210739,
-0.0696618184,
-0.0390543379,
0.0600651763,
-0.014609471,
-0.0048217983,
0.0142105725,
0.0379917584,
-0.0207380503,
0.0282664634,
-0.0107559003,
0.0309746768,
0.0580587834,
0.048315417,
0.0128255254,
-0.0229403768,
-0.038315963,
0.0277058445,
-0.0120355925,
-0.010115033,
-0.0085820518,
0.0325120278,
-0.0549575873,
0.0065088426,
0.0244382229,
0.027288137,
0.0385594927,
0.0185377076,
-0.0503050834,
0.0736156479,
-0.0467941239,
0.0726241618,
0.0052716713,
-0.0350072496,
-0.0697348267,
0.0090188598,
0.0060272887,
-0.0041900119,
0.0126408804,
-0.036480397,
-0.0042092297,
0.0336715318,
-0.0584613867,
0.0188196748,
0.001023615,
0.0202225912,
0.0287949014,
-0.0555301495,
-0.0076358491,
0.0317826048,
-0.0447633937,
-0.0349418037,
-0.0430430435,
0.0149275362,
0.0238030143,
0.0286560748,
0.0310671274,
0.0117788725,
0.036022231,
0.0019212393,
-0.0308788251,
0.0139593687,
0.0389860198,
-0.0118727731,
-0.0678450987,
0.0265047252,
0.0104304291,
0.0348517746,
-0.0098017771,
0.0272162948,
-0.0144967418,
-0.0078776339,
-0.0118912589,
-0.0414626673,
0.0399687774,
0.0160550866,
-0.0460248441,
-0.0106481425,
-0.002174597,
0.0088515207,
0.0763434172,
-0.0060136672,
-0.0317530483,
0.0035496706,
2.569e-7,
0.0823691338,
0.0227825865,
0.0508241244,
0.0318334885,
-0.0112945233,
-0.0003181786,
-0.0047322568,
0.005428981,
0.0117882919,
-0.0144994697,
0.0402263924,
-0.0052192784,
0.0156931523,
0.0418434963,
-0.0938898623,
-0.0487835705,
-0.0447011776,
-0.0457994379,
-0.0101930033,
-0.0384517573,
0.0759990215,
0.043585401,
-0.0502229631,
-0.0197943039,
-0.0304342918,
0.0002256749,
0.0262050685,
-0.0043396414,
-0.0161791202,
0.0378613621,
0.0660875589,
0.0092701428,
-0.0033694541,
0.0387176201,
-0.0305039678,
-0.0377206653,
0.0706890151,
0.061235819,
0.0118129924,
0.0130296033,
0.0046622702,
0.0166433137,
0.0439167507,
0.01344012,
0.020780459,
-0.0548714735,
0.0122548714,
0.0009322155,
-0.0363581814,
0.0225568376,
0.0381561294,
-0.0252366289,
-0.0649799556,
0.0693231151,
0.0037957062,
0.0183022209,
-0.0336604938,
-0.089487277,
-0.0208983365,
0.0239435639,
0.0247849859,
-0.0360121168,
0.0669569895,
-0.0061296495,
-0.0241613965,
-0.0828875303,
-0.0101560373,
2.354703907e-34,
0.0891791955,
0.0113793658,
-0.0331344232,
-0.0122219166,
0.017645359,
-0.032739304,
-0.0154810213,
0.0037536144,
0.0285154711,
-0.0206608735,
-0.0158214942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12798v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12798v3 | RRAML: Reinforced Retrieval Augmented Machine Learning | 2023-07-24T13:51:19 | 2023-07-27T07:20:28 | Andrea Bacciu, Florin Cuconasu, Federico Siciliano, Fabrizio Silvestri, Nicola Tonellotto, Giovanni Trappolini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized machine
learning and related fields, showcasing remarkable abilities in comprehending,
generating, and manipulating human language. However, their conventional usage
through API-based text prompt submissions imposes certain limitations in terms
of context constraints and external source availability. To address these
challenges, we propose a novel framework called Reinforced Retrieval Augmented
Machine Learning (RRAML). RRAML integrates the reasoning capabilities of LLMs
with supporting information retrieved by a purpose-built retriever from a vast
user-provided database. By leveraging recent advancements in reinforcement
learning, our method effectively addresses several critical challenges.
Firstly, it circumvents the need for accessing LLM gradients. Secondly, our
method alleviates the burden of retraining LLMs for specific tasks, as it is
often impractical or impossible due to restricted access to the model and the
computational intensity involved. Additionally we seamlessly link the
retriever's task with the reasoner, mitigating hallucinations and reducing
irrelevant, and potentially damaging retrieved documents. We believe that the
research agenda outlined in this paper has the potential to profoundly impact
the field of AI, democratizing access to and utilization of LLMs for a wide
range of entities. | [
0.0541760027,
0.0969049484,
-0.0090540433,
0.03562814,
-0.0437121317,
-0.0217372514,
-0.0304180477,
0.0150138177,
0.0337284952,
-0.0230771061,
-0.0293518249,
-0.0163600519,
-0.0301661957,
0.0274815112,
-0.0139259472,
-0.0535421222,
0.0129371798,
-0.0190330576,
0.050440602,
0.0066524395,
0.0052600661,
0.0294436458,
0.0088647194,
0.0387524255,
-0.0099478355,
0.0009680641,
0.0109231118,
0.0233194306,
-0.0022786849,
-0.0360065363,
0.0243873,
0.0306025501,
0.0563983843,
0.0584629849,
0.0000023588,
-0.067380555,
-0.0565074012,
0.0239065997,
-0.043850679,
-0.0400505736,
0.0214420334,
-0.00708269,
0.0097636767,
0.008011857,
-0.0733184144,
-0.0173972398,
0.0196614638,
0.0483405069,
0.0533898771,
0.0987169445,
-0.0045922915,
-0.0175943784,
0.0214515105,
-0.0252716467,
0.0320151858,
-0.0261111036,
0.0208417289,
-0.0218440518,
0.026800625,
0.0337824263,
0.016870657,
0.0321361609,
0.0502218679,
0.0111769252,
0.0172056444,
0.0251080189,
-0.0251120143,
-0.0269959643,
-0.0225747917,
0.0524493754,
0.0371937938,
-0.0287378002,
0.0205593426,
0.0068979245,
0.0078066913,
0.0365251563,
-0.0528668202,
0.0482404977,
-0.0132403523,
0.0284665171,
-0.0100237662,
-0.0165085606,
0.0601742305,
0.0508027859,
-0.02819594,
0.0427273177,
-0.0165945292,
-0.0606079213,
0.0113448221,
0.0074402932,
0.0197831113,
-0.0378635004,
0.0098373806,
0.0418910198,
-0.0515049137,
0.02133427,
-0.032070104,
-0.0376001112,
0.0366782732,
-0.0024231509,
0.0315314606,
0.0188481472,
-0.026105836,
0.0540723205,
-0.0130574778,
-0.0103942323,
-0.044852376,
0.0466277748,
0.0059543569,
-0.0121393139,
-0.0534890592,
-0.036940828,
-0.0119130919,
0.039634414,
-0.030759709,
0.0053159674,
-0.0202360414,
0.0235179793,
-0.0437219553,
0.0378238522,
-0.018923305,
0.0442398302,
-0.0300452281,
-0.0436353236,
-0.0710727274,
-0.0063065649,
-0.01418343,
-0.005986297,
0.0580056384,
-0.049897898,
-0.0110729123,
-0.0333436094,
-0.0169262569,
-0.015915839,
0.0341406465,
0.0685162544,
0.0086369552,
-0.0393346548,
-0.0443703718,
-0.0635607615,
0.0259581879,
-0.06102046,
-0.0124138063,
-0.0640752167,
0.0168602075,
-0.019201465,
-0.0369749367,
-0.0328197628,
0.0331032835,
0.0512441508,
-0.0227179416,
0.0706952065,
-0.0227981638,
0.0011354823,
0.0291208643,
0.0316721648,
-0.0518198833,
0.0365815014,
0.0126160011,
0.0469543301,
0.057236176,
0.0416456647,
0.0493277237,
0.001156905,
0.0232688859,
-0.0218881909,
-0.0379369184,
0.0196560211,
-0.0174892731,
0.0097780451,
-0.0191347171,
0.0469474569,
-0.0371164083,
0.0216383655,
0.0658126622,
0.0591937341,
-0.0094707124,
-0.0189563166,
0.0213714875,
0.0034721813,
-0.0077777635,
-0.0305307601,
-0.0407086015,
0.0161792766,
-0.0082256719,
-0.0096234456,
0.0342770293,
0.0370319188,
0.0035744903,
-0.0426876321,
0.019519778,
-0.020450091,
0.020066971,
0.0679519773,
0.0750611275,
0.0224626623,
-0.0270253047,
-0.0172237195,
0.0396822914,
-0.0381313898,
-0.0042350492,
-0.0713267624,
0.0466721319,
0.0726093277,
0.0771685019,
-0.0656810701,
0.0337291956,
-0.0228319969,
-0.0079219779,
0.0463181026,
0.0277504846,
0.00724835,
-0.0072337654,
-0.0536056682,
-0.0242489241,
0.0038767101,
0.016512312,
0.0241874903,
0.0481697209,
0.0174898896,
0.0043034218,
-0.0056019761,
-0.0364157446,
0.0240463037,
-0.0120841945,
-0.0451365337,
0.0248158053,
0.0360338315,
0.0120767765,
0.0335411578,
-0.0179896727,
0.0253281593,
0.0369610526,
-0.0253056567,
-0.0367134623,
-0.0350388475,
-0.0481016338,
0.0533663966,
0.0095431563,
0.0207372736,
-0.0069863582,
0.0183018055,
-0.0092456806,
-0.0087381238,
0.0049217665,
-0.0050313426,
0.0544077493,
-0.0560216568,
-0.0091970162,
0.0027386243,
0.010100238,
-0.0464442596,
0.0740863532,
0.0049960488,
-0.0111782886,
0.0213173367,
-0.0192018971,
0.0018596937,
-0.0573819466,
0.0135145802,
0.0050938325,
-0.0101147555,
0.0516112819,
0.0560917594,
-0.0118167419,
-0.016511308,
-0.0175967105,
-0.0360244215,
0.0012489796,
-0.0303420983,
-0.0089401957,
-0.0182585977,
0.0179703068,
-0.0120969331,
-0.0182061568,
0.0053999396,
-0.031155182,
0.0321530886,
0.0384520851,
0.0101062916,
0.0259326082,
-0.0006120738,
-0.0443552397,
-0.0095073245,
0.0116240736,
0.0283791143,
0.007905649,
-0.0025729293,
-0.029161673,
-0.0458237268,
-0.0243486557,
0.026772324,
-0.0130293826,
0.0096808672,
0.0368005596,
-0.0651324764,
-0.0025146015,
0.0759913623,
0.0130226454,
0.0577945597,
0.0364052095,
-0.0004712616,
-0.0885938033,
0.0263993982,
-0.0259660669,
-0.0391634926,
0.0039852117,
-0.0168059692,
0.0429432504,
0.0168028958,
-0.0074802376,
0.0053565633,
-0.0477582254,
0.05448585,
0.0157716237,
-0.0391311161,
-0.0451856405,
-0.0138542475,
-0.012561094,
0.0579681545,
-0.03685458,
-0.0788114369,
0.093169719,
-0.0005465777,
0.0051916079,
-0.024738187,
-0.0457395129,
-0.0332122743,
0.0646861196,
-0.0051637404,
0.0217593368,
-0.0126279993,
-0.0085137673,
-0.0069825044,
-0.025896145,
0.0126316473,
-0.0704362169,
0.039021045,
-0.0367560461,
0.0012782399,
0.0221835077,
-0.051527001,
-0.0597983524,
-0.0318230204,
-0.0195080936,
-0.0024228876,
-0.0402954742,
-0.0428091213,
-0.0301078763,
-0.045997642,
0.072135672,
0.0309031699,
-0.0084762387,
-0.0391269438,
-0.0038749096,
-0.0245088469,
0.0482020639,
-0.0038305521,
-0.0077493256,
-0.0322827958,
0.0049657444,
0.0475319549,
0.0520681515,
-0.0301846471,
-0.0115553252,
-0.0055262027,
0.0075966092,
-0.0350640714,
0.0237690639,
0.0274041798,
0.0027161639,
-0.0901104808,
-0.0254859794,
0.0678055361,
0.0395823345,
-0.0639859438,
-0.0282399096,
-0.0485850163,
0.0316225514,
0.0212736726,
0.0544712953,
-0.0902372748,
-0.0216176193,
0.033478044,
0.0692142844,
-0.0094586825,
-0.0390364155,
0.0036574528,
-0.1431841999,
0.0578076616,
-0.015943259,
-0.0119742779,
-0.0293038059,
-0.064545989,
-0.0196507797,
0.0207144693,
-0.0060666171,
0.0290421303,
-0.0028171665,
0.0003630993,
-0.0067384364,
0.0419888794,
-0.0220805015,
0.0071060397,
-0.051863648,
0.0074007604,
0.0854587182,
0.006625094,
0.0039422135,
-0.048509866,
-0.0191968512,
0.0124170417,
0.0059781908,
-0.0002436742,
0.0346452482,
-0.0151987644,
-0.0069074458,
-0.0343830474,
0.0506290868,
-0.0038968311,
-0.0397386886,
-0.0081977155,
0.098378405,
-0.0174045209,
0.0087326718,
-0.0423528925,
-0.0384060852,
0.051735539,
0.0608500391,
0.0032795395,
-0.0363616906,
-0.0393293016,
-0.0157968774,
0.0043497467,
-0.0124107497,
-0.0214394461,
0.0065940823,
-0.0148245748,
0.0002542882,
-0.0731789321,
-0.0315508135,
-0.0118307285,
0.0239067357,
0.0113898823,
-0.005939059,
0.0038016746,
0.0029968214,
-0.0525624268,
0.0512573235,
-0.0559884086,
0.0091570746,
-0.0513896123,
-0.02766205,
-0.0097578857,
-0.0582156554,
-0.0249643642,
0.0051119947,
0.0160376914,
-0.0587729104,
-0.0121713569,
0.0716021806,
0.0257880818,
0.0549543761,
-0.009554063,
-0.0506183989,
0.0708689094,
0.0823623985,
-0.0576106049,
-0.0074264859,
0.0164339505,
0.0248587132,
-0.0015416871,
0.0318891928,
-0.0893748775,
0.0025357776,
-0.0070105656,
0.0148784705,
0.0110436426,
0.000812882,
0.0375115164,
0.026149638,
0.0253621526,
0.0185556635,
-0.0143381171,
-0.0387745947,
0.006147922,
-0.0105213448,
-0.0450182222,
-0.0316803232,
0.0138121452,
0.0172043853,
-0.0467730388,
0.0057179346,
0.0062567559,
0.0254380684,
0.0414491333,
-0.0111375293,
-0.007974036,
0.0130748386,
0.023950398,
0.0245500077,
-0.0085802423,
-0.0034113477,
0.0388860218,
-0.0278344043,
0.0613533892,
-0.0325783864,
0.0711027011,
0.0220622718,
-0.020609064,
-0.026108155,
0.0008388717,
-0.0690970495,
-0.1126452833,
0.0351485051,
0.0045653498,
0.0313108526,
-0.0123651866,
0.0179428216,
-0.0520064496,
-0.0114312489,
-0.0084767379,
-0.0101014879,
0.020210173,
-0.0342163183,
-0.0030986711,
0.0268454514,
-0.0267715827,
0.0468908548,
0.036387749,
-0.0706156269,
0.0285024829,
-0.0288674086,
-0.0354787186,
-0.0348897763,
-0.0503169447,
0.0280899201,
0.0350593105,
-0.0264928695,
-0.0163133275,
-0.0232103672,
-0.0499842316,
0.0060153324,
0.0433551073,
-0.0389219336,
-0.0002292244,
0.0124619165,
0.061308492,
-0.0022851168,
-0.0194464494,
-0.0465950221,
0.0350936316,
-0.0573336445,
-0.0305149853,
-0.0129723903,
-6.746547054e-33,
0.0073569571,
-0.0125188855,
0.0218941271,
-0.0384779014,
-0.0060427818,
0.0132521885,
-0.0366381481,
-0.0194605161,
-0.0057335435,
0.0147723081,
-0.032461457,
0.0036962039,
0.0167523492,
0.0423542634,
0.0044303485,
-0.0047569168,
0.0199355613,
0.0047805882,
-0.0195675902,
0.0324568525,
0.0601798706,
0.0258956756,
0.0188549217,
-0.1099626794,
0.0456923135,
0.0091151036,
-0.010101635,
0.0469413437,
-0.0396995582,
0.0578856468,
-0.0082489569,
0.0401914977,
0.0127955722,
-0.0356645882,
0.0108516607,
0.0529003553,
-0.0808959454,
0.002332974,
-0.0094331717,
-0.014990557,
-0.0607809238,
-0.0223111212,
0.0696347803,
-0.0065871594,
0.0273354109,
0.0292215683,
0.0279615577,
-0.0111934226,
-0.0184650794,
-0.0008179623,
-0.0317756198,
0.0010229998,
0.0014735153,
-0.0067519853,
0.0242616888,
0.0367847309,
0.0114153475,
0.0434788689,
-0.0692814514,
0.0035572294,
-0.0320008621,
-0.0028485404,
0.0315456353,
0.030023057,
0.009097714,
0.0667953417,
0.0336614326,
-0.0190403573,
-0.0467058495,
-0.0372638479,
0.0199849829,
0.0441164859,
-0.0125964768,
0.0601234697,
0.0449904688,
-0.008417611,
-0.0389251113,
0.019655956,
0.0067146136,
0.0409825519,
0.0610734262,
0.0082385903,
-0.0510566607,
-0.0070024612,
-0.0344817154,
-0.0176731888,
-0.0509552732,
-0.0238339659,
0.0447972491,
0.0507828258,
-0.0255151466,
-0.0208048206,
-0.000279801,
-0.0372371413,
-0.0153715601,
0.0420792475,
-0.0099419383,
-0.0116086807,
-0.0127441287,
-0.0148335518,
-0.033111155,
0.0083407741,
0.0078908233,
-0.0269014686,
0.0042259437,
0.0442372672,
0.0187423117,
0.0120746801,
-0.0613132752,
0.0099746473,
-0.0335503146,
0.0747955516,
0.0040670619,
0.0116899591,
0.0517171063,
0.0276689883,
-0.0112128034,
0.0600029677,
0.0264337994,
0.033977177,
-0.0367304496,
-0.0124660376,
-0.0078537073,
-0.023752993,
-0.0053975652,
0.0245764684,
-0.0199699849,
0.0333632007,
0.0356070995,
-0.0494835228,
0.0162095688,
-0.0211327691,
3.094e-7,
-0.0000880915,
0.0330746919,
0.0229824316,
0.0267464612,
-0.0068481509,
0.056435369,
0.0016642639,
0.0093084164,
0.0018309013,
-0.0392190516,
-0.0053242119,
0.0474678092,
0.0574587658,
0.0265370831,
-0.0861609429,
-0.020678455,
-0.0765329599,
-0.0076144431,
-0.083654955,
-0.0207334906,
0.0432054438,
0.0574463457,
0.0465857051,
-0.0351015516,
0.0186678842,
-0.0491748005,
0.0545300022,
-0.0422648229,
0.0107531594,
-0.0054944204,
0.0454000421,
0.0541425273,
-0.0035424249,
-0.0258225426,
-0.0273644701,
0.0318704247,
-0.0379876941,
0.0565535054,
-0.0078256167,
-0.0337647907,
-0.0133896349,
-0.0001900656,
0.0083155204,
-0.0305512138,
0.0556815565,
-0.0339735672,
-0.0122691216,
-0.0281373262,
-0.0170496535,
-0.0493858196,
0.0129258437,
-0.0234624594,
-0.0378829576,
0.0180513002,
-0.007369102,
0.0168285109,
-0.009374842,
-0.1225992739,
-0.030120749,
0.006061675,
-0.0291038454,
0.0169578828,
-0.0482910275,
0.0396296009,
-0.0318104364,
-0.0720950514,
0.0369272493,
3.061486186e-34,
0.0081571788,
0.0166566521,
-0.0015357656,
0.0288940016,
0.0514577217,
0.0391519293,
-0.0147170024,
0.0226082783,
0.0137222726,
-0.0852115601,
-0.0041115177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12759v1 | Code-Switched Urdu ASR for Noisy Telephonic Environment using Data Centric Approach with Hybrid HMM and CNN-TDNN | 2023-07-24T13:04:21 | 2023-07-24T13:04:21 | Muhammad Danyal Khan, Raheem Ali, Arshad Aziz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Call Centers have huge amount of audio data which can be used for achieving
valuable business insights and transcription of phone calls is manually tedious
task. An effective Automated Speech Recognition system can accurately
transcribe these calls for easy search through call history for specific
context and content allowing automatic call monitoring, improving QoS through
keyword search and sentiment analysis. ASR for Call Center requires more
robustness as telephonic environment are generally noisy. Moreover, there are
many low-resourced languages that are on verge of extinction which can be
preserved with help of Automatic Speech Recognition Technology. Urdu is the
$10^{th}$ most widely spoken language in the world, with 231,295,440 worldwide
still remains a resource constrained language in ASR. Regional call-center
conversations operate in local language, with a mix of English numbers and
technical terms generally causing a "code-switching" problem. Hence, this paper
describes an implementation framework of a resource efficient Automatic Speech
Recognition/ Speech to Text System in a noisy call-center environment using
Chain Hybrid HMM and CNN-TDNN for Code-Switched Urdu Language. Using Hybrid
HMM-DNN approach allowed us to utilize the advantages of Neural Network with
less labelled data. Adding CNN with TDNN has shown to work better in noisy
environment due to CNN's additional frequency dimension which captures extra
information from noisy speech, thus improving accuracy. We collected data from
various open sources and labelled some of the unlabelled data after analysing
its general context and content from Urdu language as well as from commonly
used words from other languages, primarily English and were able to achieve WER
of 5.2% with noisy as well as clean environment in isolated words or numbers as
well as in continuous spontaneous speech. | [
0.0129552688,
0.0470770448,
0.0065790564,
0.0108957747,
-0.0289631654,
-0.0160989631,
0.0270268917,
-0.0057822908,
-0.0123747131,
-0.0089004021,
-0.0702577829,
0.0066556181,
0.0182573795,
0.044622276,
-0.0043106796,
-0.0030091086,
0.0050856471,
-0.0276681427,
-0.0005960953,
-0.0181923974,
0.0177207924,
0.0196492001,
-0.0431440696,
-0.0007108083,
-0.0355368592,
0.0112766204,
-0.0198657252,
0.0329009555,
-0.0032885659,
0.0132748662,
0.0049781166,
-0.0040080035,
0.0236733928,
0.0645298809,
0.0000019131,
-0.018552633,
-0.0294057354,
0.0007021248,
-0.0485015474,
-0.0272357631,
0.0413212478,
0.0302933026,
-0.0676701814,
0.0051798983,
0.0235850476,
0.0462584868,
0.0783192143,
0.0348209739,
0.0111673502,
0.0613557436,
-0.0047233864,
-0.0483295396,
0.0349725224,
0.0224811155,
-0.0512299798,
-0.0396322347,
-0.0169093199,
0.002372684,
0.004487433,
-0.0622910075,
0.0045098653,
0.0338939987,
0.0169091653,
-0.0310957041,
-0.0331457481,
-0.0432782285,
-0.0750417337,
-0.0331030153,
0.0242541656,
0.0575651564,
-0.0747303516,
-0.0579440296,
0.0395046659,
-0.0114095723,
-0.0453184955,
-0.0503718145,
-0.0026918268,
0.0099028004,
-0.0113454238,
0.0005858045,
-0.0036854013,
0.0661409423,
0.0114180278,
-0.0258246921,
-0.0485839471,
0.0068038302,
0.0018370417,
-0.0498365983,
0.0090537174,
-0.0139579428,
0.0408988297,
0.0351190083,
0.090584524,
-0.0144162672,
-0.0318236649,
0.0239327084,
0.0272353012,
-0.0583932437,
0.0057116877,
-0.0860170349,
-0.0164209083,
0.0670372695,
-0.0887749121,
-0.0550278127,
-0.0127096642,
0.0106942616,
0.0247080941,
-0.0407980569,
-0.0236538127,
-0.001471206,
-0.0244460255,
0.0234197713,
-0.0531934239,
0.0397954732,
-0.0160911158,
-0.0306527894,
-0.0493881367,
0.0208441205,
0.0089141177,
0.0023124446,
0.0364265479,
-0.0410492457,
-0.0257294979,
-0.005294783,
0.0490651838,
0.0154052563,
-0.0124087371,
0.0328196883,
-0.0129924202,
-0.1190218106,
0.0314980708,
0.0194095727,
0.0581044108,
0.0160648189,
-0.0238315202,
0.0650390685,
-0.0046761455,
-0.0217463151,
-0.0988414735,
0.0541663319,
-0.0010824262,
-0.040700227,
-0.0288956072,
-0.0247850846,
0.0540990792,
-0.0070259604,
-0.0043736678,
0.0341017954,
0.0069660093,
0.0310450494,
0.0362451524,
0.0511819683,
-0.0030510128,
0.0101691801,
0.1023788452,
-0.0159692764,
0.0472954027,
0.0637131631,
0.0387530252,
0.0002415129,
0.0316178501,
-0.0518629514,
-0.000015647,
0.0402429923,
0.0186600368,
-0.0018855408,
-0.0116775809,
0.0145586366,
-0.012589029,
0.021703165,
-0.0043601906,
0.0240393262,
-0.0006297658,
0.0463468842,
0.0259989146,
0.0234615672,
0.0313825645,
0.0493270122,
-0.023746755,
0.0358898677,
-0.0238688942,
-0.002437524,
0.0158885214,
0.0042008571,
-0.0128298691,
0.0203513019,
0.0478136986,
-0.0021939371,
-0.0203736629,
-0.0079805236,
0.0118719079,
-0.0399995409,
-0.0249814857,
0.0335454345,
0.0548353456,
0.0190238152,
-0.0357701816,
0.0540047139,
0.00771451,
-0.034569528,
-0.0191877671,
-0.0493825674,
-0.0228748433,
0.0224479679,
-0.0051106531,
-0.040700417,
-0.0265024211,
-0.0480709672,
-0.0335454829,
0.0249822643,
-0.0148472264,
0.0168555416,
0.0180391073,
-0.0794013664,
0.0222659279,
0.0658261478,
-0.022916669,
0.0240725633,
-0.0280891843,
0.0601333156,
-0.0019228264,
0.0102357166,
-0.0075798873,
-0.0338836759,
0.0206182562,
0.0191565529,
0.0204587486,
0.0152347153,
0.0831303224,
0.0227988139,
-0.0260184929,
-0.0142818904,
0.0059861336,
-0.0058897715,
-0.0118454471,
0.0048845876,
-0.0809294358,
-0.0022910601,
0.0156711061,
-0.0526524931,
0.0174934808,
0.0229462124,
0.0082176412,
-0.1068943217,
0.085024409,
-0.0487292111,
0.0494353622,
-0.0292899236,
0.0665704906,
0.0376771875,
0.0248802248,
0.0236410666,
0.0119594689,
0.0241922345,
-0.0067001753,
0.0111037157,
0.0400931388,
0.0203612484,
-0.0596623905,
0.0300422572,
0.0340994969,
-0.0358613841,
0.0098483628,
0.0058950596,
-0.0169046372,
-0.0025301152,
0.0132707953,
-0.0591204911,
-0.0191779528,
-0.0309050139,
-0.0100788195,
-0.015967045,
0.0608931221,
0.0212399065,
-0.0485477112,
-0.0397716314,
0.0018428166,
0.013116627,
-0.0137562202,
-0.0273002647,
0.0124915894,
-0.0436296873,
-0.0365828685,
-0.0205611885,
0.0282325335,
-0.0000816956,
-0.0130430795,
-0.0851677358,
-0.0327442363,
0.0074217552,
0.0435842909,
0.045707494,
-0.0128310714,
-0.0461796224,
-0.0102603771,
0.0040265103,
0.007148942,
-0.00712538,
-0.0185957383,
-0.0394311436,
-0.0106697883,
-0.0114086727,
-0.0205616802,
0.0019179798,
0.0216281004,
-0.0104208393,
0.0240679774,
-0.0261375848,
-0.0129040033,
-0.0259105619,
0.0000623036,
0.0337247998,
-0.004956136,
-0.0924962088,
-0.0403713807,
-0.0191682819,
0.003236339,
0.0155191123,
-0.0343143158,
0.0549449362,
0.0155984918,
-0.0002479929,
-0.003643611,
-0.0064928271,
-0.026168149,
-0.0788475797,
-0.0539577156,
-0.010978017,
-0.0405025408,
-0.0423197113,
0.0240943916,
-0.0418512486,
-0.0901112184,
-0.0298826527,
-0.0006646431,
-0.0327450447,
-0.0335555449,
0.0367518589,
-0.0323266014,
0.0189757161,
-0.0133730303,
-0.0467250198,
-0.0258976165,
0.0260727387,
-0.0409949869,
0.0231984891,
0.0418539681,
-0.0319066904,
0.035720747,
0.063442938,
-0.0141413724,
0.0595142581,
0.0233912915,
0.0379137471,
-0.0084040239,
0.0107194334,
0.036016684,
0.0102252075,
0.009483845,
0.0543242693,
0.0253952239,
-0.0362477116,
-0.0102153271,
-0.0046336753,
-0.0321816765,
-0.0134859988,
0.0120710814,
-0.0071527776,
-0.006478793,
-0.0192954224,
-0.0210956931,
-0.0123210307,
0.0146448677,
0.0581689589,
-0.0100670671,
-0.0374334231,
-0.0271375906,
-0.0569354072,
-0.0353286192,
-0.0107719982,
0.0256883614,
-0.0569367446,
0.0056706681,
0.0558315367,
0.0399264768,
-0.0071062935,
0.0391234979,
0.012687969,
-0.0983654186,
0.00602561,
-0.0073229703,
-0.0057759923,
-0.0681293234,
-0.037478853,
-0.0228101648,
-0.0204171091,
0.0547915734,
-0.016060764,
0.0163573343,
-0.0627811626,
0.027000051,
-0.0532274321,
-0.0307025164,
-0.0093640117,
0.0112405969,
0.0448531918,
0.0933179781,
0.0196424481,
-0.0304706078,
-0.0254148338,
0.036446169,
0.0035395178,
-0.0137259923,
0.0001788935,
0.0069651701,
0.0117278816,
0.0023987801,
0.0135638146,
0.0066570677,
-0.0165891405,
0.0121254446,
-0.0125653241,
0.0025232462,
-0.0150017114,
0.00011306,
0.0432315692,
0.0566128716,
0.0244876184,
0.0208966024,
0.0136666372,
-0.0360065959,
-0.0083384635,
0.0346628875,
0.0547376648,
-0.0359466374,
0.0279603433,
0.0258413237,
-0.0241361316,
-0.0963203236,
0.0018933543,
0.0065066093,
-0.0132647529,
0.0312041752,
0.0523602404,
0.0269763842,
0.0474895462,
0.0563617907,
-0.0016297731,
-0.0704455003,
-0.0286829453,
0.0181132089,
-0.0733308569,
-0.0072583728,
0.0330955349,
-0.0541958734,
0.0301428959,
-0.0360891707,
-0.0370291807,
-0.0028879314,
0.0615717731,
-0.0400851071,
0.0136288386,
0.0052423626,
-0.0408979766,
-0.0485675223,
-0.0048773177,
-0.0015149881,
-0.0863171741,
-0.0388073474,
0.0525996573,
0.0589251369,
-0.0122409584,
0.018402312,
-0.0697245449,
0.03990639,
-0.0174732953,
-0.0222010352,
-0.0680601373,
-0.014231544,
0.0155942328,
0.0054665399,
0.0390014052,
-0.032832142,
-0.0181870088,
-0.0329161286,
0.0691181868,
0.0475646444,
0.0318454914,
-0.0225568675,
0.0111791128,
0.0256984141,
0.0591098703,
0.0035310471,
-0.0316947587,
-0.0153372884,
-0.0569610409,
0.0403197668,
0.0718665421,
0.0255120117,
0.0625657663,
0.0224253405,
0.0087381257,
-0.0435876027,
0.0605014525,
0.0562278777,
0.0410154462,
-0.0219831392,
0.041334711,
0.0089342501,
-0.0115240021,
0.0425508581,
0.0500722416,
0.0148248216,
-0.0229705162,
-0.0094633643,
0.0250802655,
0.0404818095,
-0.0060071452,
0.0089695724,
0.015144242,
0.0359419584,
-0.027785657,
0.0284701288,
0.0010783101,
0.0303590447,
-0.0062607862,
-0.0192752313,
-0.0196549315,
0.0327447988,
-0.0059499736,
-0.0047240034,
0.004210447,
-0.0048104785,
0.0300995,
-0.0363571979,
0.0089981686,
0.0140574416,
0.0319626071,
-0.0138375619,
-0.0310757775,
0.0068335873,
-0.0799757466,
-0.0142615857,
-0.0366079919,
0.0397890769,
-0.0383216776,
0.0283402409,
-0.0087554613,
-0.0013211225,
0.0417527519,
-0.0173992179,
-0.0003309315,
0.0874722376,
-0.0371895358,
0.0113905575,
-6.034497963e-33,
0.0196386185,
0.0444123261,
-0.0232024528,
-0.0156218838,
0.0013760444,
-0.0255551524,
-0.006327685,
-0.0213340316,
0.0030926873,
-0.0282758977,
-0.0312438067,
0.0287962407,
0.0467877761,
0.0107527953,
-0.0087990742,
-0.0168464798,
0.0889633596,
-0.0155167729,
0.063240096,
0.0332699008,
0.0376460366,
0.0556630418,
0.0475731939,
-0.0535587482,
-0.0479894988,
-0.0188782066,
-0.0033650049,
-0.0218918342,
0.0274974722,
0.007248322,
0.0129746227,
0.0286142062,
-0.0149424411,
-0.0383267701,
0.0031327009,
0.0358017609,
-0.1123578474,
0.0118500488,
-0.0279458445,
0.1154277027,
0.0361364149,
-0.0198495016,
0.0240681674,
0.0001288896,
-0.0520587638,
0.0520143695,
-0.0097149229,
0.017410649,
-0.0276771225,
-0.0434893854,
-0.0202333741,
0.0519729406,
-0.0188659057,
-0.0098516969,
0.0604544804,
0.0229353141,
-0.026368361,
-0.0280877464,
-0.0771479532,
-0.0059165768,
0.0050212909,
0.0039256816,
0.0212808941,
0.0483987778,
-0.0449572243,
-0.017748341,
0.0781468749,
-0.0591388978,
0.0464997031,
-0.0344807543,
0.0276795793,
0.0041871066,
-0.0248002056,
-0.0198280942,
0.0322202072,
-0.0718955472,
-0.0461680777,
-0.0364500545,
0.0473503284,
-0.0094770547,
0.0301754642,
0.0438907295,
-0.0474415049,
-0.0281660631,
0.0325411484,
-0.012840868,
-0.0344759338,
0.0059424113,
0.0427420512,
0.005726927,
0.0124450261,
0.0123304622,
0.0483709089,
-0.0250304639,
0.031412214,
-0.041383557,
-0.0061268802,
0.0067203552,
-0.0074192807,
0.0298909005,
-0.0960677415,
-0.0416409522,
0.0121018393,
0.0624116957,
0.0037447773,
-0.0199945327,
0.0237045791,
0.0591126122,
-0.0389913432,
0.0185023397,
0.0194685552,
0.0220356937,
0.0375663005,
0.025668256,
-0.0051944098,
-0.0447681732,
0.0100939032,
0.0160162821,
-0.0108280564,
0.0306918435,
0.0264461786,
-0.0123819793,
0.0009715554,
0.0214386825,
-0.0620839223,
-0.0005242043,
-0.0208602361,
0.0041564452,
0.0257272478,
-0.0339346789,
0.00124077,
0.0160166472,
2.811e-7,
-0.0241403077,
0.0040389351,
0.0184410773,
-0.0115256011,
-0.0014020347,
-0.0202133451,
0.0109248413,
-0.0163055975,
-0.0168224778,
0.0362305753,
0.0261618979,
-0.0574743971,
0.0709154308,
0.0174457207,
-0.1300093085,
-0.0658670515,
-0.0576884449,
0.0202491041,
-0.0202902146,
0.0396149606,
-0.009244943,
0.1154233292,
-0.0181440152,
-0.042269811,
0.0153090637,
-0.0196010508,
-0.0114708813,
-0.0062717325,
0.0396882668,
0.0104963761,
0.0328028128,
-0.0181749277,
-0.0423999205,
-0.0131410593,
-0.0376830325,
0.0259217601,
0.047890529,
0.0533975549,
0.0167514756,
-0.0717485547,
0.0164539255,
0.002399927,
-0.023770066,
-0.0199445691,
0.0408185609,
0.0370745771,
-0.0285274927,
-0.0225650705,
-0.0267893188,
0.0124542778,
-0.0272463169,
0.0049460321,
0.013414179,
0.0060772104,
0.0048580011,
-0.0150538636,
-0.0373590998,
-0.0462593883,
0.0500278138,
-0.0081419526,
-0.0191838201,
-0.0375339612,
-0.0217040926,
-0.0443625078,
0.0324083529,
0.0528900996,
0.0070359199,
1.926848529e-34,
0.0682100207,
-0.0190548878,
-0.0011312745,
0.0162535794,
0.0343686081,
-0.0319640972,
0.0221236721,
0.0397325642,
0.0234844927,
-0.0174380243,
-0.0443476625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12659v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12659v2 | A Model for Every User and Budget: Label-Free and Personalized Mixed-Precision Quantization | 2023-07-24T10:03:28 | 2024-02-11T12:07:55 | Edward Fish, Umberto Michieli, Mete Ozay | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Recent advancement in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) has produced large
AI models, which become impractical for deployment in mobile devices. Model
quantization is effective to produce compressed general-purpose models, however
such models may only be deployed to a restricted sub-domain of interest. We
show that ASR models can be personalized during quantization while relying on
just a small set of unlabelled samples from the target domain. To this end, we
propose myQASR, a mixed-precision quantization method that generates tailored
quantization schemes for diverse users under any memory requirement with no
fine-tuning. myQASR automatically evaluates the quantization sensitivity of
network layers by analysing the full-precision activation values. We are then
able to generate a personalised mixed-precision quantization scheme for any
pre-determined memory budget. Results for large-scale ASR models show how
myQASR improves performance for specific genders, languages, and speakers. | [
-0.0290927645,
0.0696806833,
-0.0111466656,
0.0110799149,
0.0194790214,
-0.0325040296,
0.0824083984,
-0.023375364,
-0.0293728653,
-0.0126009565,
-0.0236787647,
-0.0515322462,
-0.0207298845,
0.0153562771,
0.0000635312,
-0.0277203396,
0.033538729,
-0.0273510888,
0.0161014497,
-0.0187507644,
-0.0110843284,
0.0112871695,
0.0180864315,
0.0516111813,
0.0193508193,
0.0032679166,
-0.0053700698,
0.0327885821,
0.0041810446,
-0.0112635689,
-0.0054438962,
0.0402182043,
0.0388666242,
0.0109311808,
0.0000020247,
0.0070850034,
-0.0248366836,
0.002099134,
-0.0550225265,
0.0351661257,
0.013052945,
0.0385145508,
-0.047651913,
0.0165978894,
-0.0086562168,
-0.0067103328,
0.0269138832,
-0.0067121224,
0.044921536,
0.0158828609,
0.0066763242,
-0.0130142961,
0.0037626349,
-0.0237684343,
-0.0314316042,
-0.0307992864,
-0.0368976779,
-0.0045580976,
-0.0188770611,
-0.0177069027,
-0.0134305228,
0.0453092754,
0.0609587282,
0.0364961028,
0.0340207554,
-0.0044260449,
-0.06640663,
-0.0039537218,
-0.0246452875,
0.0399660394,
-0.0535279475,
-0.0232456997,
0.0269834902,
0.0019390625,
-0.0330606364,
-0.1110730171,
-0.0012327567,
-0.0039548888,
0.0066869487,
0.0087134037,
-0.0640939772,
0.0190126766,
0.0355329439,
-0.00624398,
-0.0309470128,
0.0295037869,
-0.0161511302,
-0.0107554141,
-0.0142383752,
-0.0434296466,
-0.0651543811,
-0.0140793119,
0.0473068282,
-0.0189290829,
0.0083711464,
-0.0533351377,
-0.0689107627,
-0.0540200621,
-0.0303480513,
-0.0389436707,
0.0209604762,
0.0596713796,
-0.0209010243,
-0.0013076147,
0.0109429937,
0.0258340258,
-0.0095441928,
0.0184805859,
-0.0108693847,
0.0177518167,
-0.0027932404,
0.0048990087,
-0.053942766,
0.0603291802,
-0.0247892421,
-0.0309628397,
-0.0666787848,
0.0010835446,
-0.0260975361,
-0.0492471866,
0.0350968316,
0.0388439856,
-0.0502407514,
-0.0244759452,
0.0638718456,
-0.0103842914,
-0.0496416017,
0.0397922061,
0.0194614884,
-0.0697223321,
0.0005322655,
0.0008329481,
0.0275064912,
-0.0020102423,
0.0097033009,
0.0276413485,
-0.0038527243,
-0.0220464561,
-0.0304119308,
-0.012651721,
0.0059218723,
-0.0213321988,
-0.0470649526,
-0.04314344,
0.0008526222,
0.0023176447,
0.020151481,
-0.0393745042,
0.0060011465,
-0.0158666875,
0.0197706185,
0.0569983572,
-0.0065123909,
-0.0287731905,
0.0436666794,
-0.002707077,
0.0491542444,
0.0539744049,
0.0654786229,
0.0253035799,
0.0219202451,
-0.0281435903,
-0.0282075647,
0.0133045018,
0.0377785489,
-0.0281930752,
-0.0044325897,
-0.0204029009,
-0.0309604295,
0.0583613329,
0.0678492114,
0.0525359251,
-0.0508587584,
-0.0471155606,
0.0102034248,
0.083042264,
0.0675847158,
0.0134216938,
-0.0128194643,
0.0012557716,
0.0085582715,
-0.0447207168,
-0.0196345821,
0.0127476454,
0.0354074128,
0.0078721112,
0.076437518,
0.0425806306,
-0.0308428034,
-0.0437693782,
0.002595468,
-0.0270507205,
-0.0107100531,
0.0438587107,
-0.0070998576,
0.0095883822,
0.0479381233,
0.1079646945,
0.0023073861,
-0.0607979409,
0.0053818189,
-0.0649692565,
-0.0394170247,
0.0680795833,
0.0128749162,
-0.0109606003,
0.0179507565,
0.0096246051,
-0.0485771336,
-0.0220214911,
-0.0267891418,
-0.0023690669,
0.0451816171,
-0.0702580214,
-0.0303194784,
-0.0089278417,
-0.0114710191,
0.0389910005,
0.0090071093,
0.0458461419,
0.0248059798,
-0.0340718627,
0.0294486973,
-0.0316816717,
0.0343333036,
-0.0822514519,
0.1043100208,
0.0051164543,
0.0390177257,
0.0500829555,
0.0070156734,
-0.012132735,
0.0084497491,
-0.0430354029,
0.0361607112,
-0.0436316878,
-0.0326599441,
0.0493238941,
0.0393863283,
0.0154705942,
0.0500806719,
0.047529988,
0.0042215488,
-0.0590255335,
0.0452605709,
0.0164450891,
0.0101882052,
-0.027748568,
0.009883089,
0.0280254502,
0.0385266468,
0.0094293123,
-0.0276378263,
-0.0060932063,
-0.0172017105,
0.0182428863,
-0.0108487764,
0.0063446704,
-0.0708926991,
-0.0456289314,
-0.0036199668,
0.0126336319,
0.0714575425,
0.0075213858,
-0.0304707773,
0.0131730065,
0.0113077052,
-0.0948989838,
0.0099177398,
-0.0550469644,
0.0271829013,
0.0001030149,
0.0737254173,
0.0197843201,
-0.046778474,
-0.0240146909,
-0.0505754761,
-0.0279875565,
0.0118645914,
-0.0517464504,
0.0124328798,
-0.0074964245,
-0.0220346991,
-0.0331570432,
0.030580353,
-0.0000789562,
-0.0456042215,
-0.0258814283,
-0.038882073,
-0.0244770534,
0.025989363,
0.0376534648,
0.0010276801,
-0.0115254596,
0.0225629453,
0.0367596969,
-0.0164243523,
0.072139591,
0.0037707058,
-0.0018960097,
0.0508036092,
0.034467984,
-0.0489206538,
0.0285370331,
0.0137035111,
-0.0196577124,
0.0106471824,
0.004037403,
0.0009567569,
0.0735250339,
-0.0144664105,
0.0168365389,
-0.0296834223,
0.024545392,
-0.0126170507,
-0.0314795636,
-0.0399579443,
0.0451954976,
-0.0102480082,
0.0574203171,
0.027076995,
-0.0174280908,
0.007176307,
-0.0120017203,
0.0051240213,
-0.0037006764,
-0.0561493821,
-0.0146617955,
0.0365581252,
-0.0046621417,
0.0228466261,
0.0016911747,
-0.0126255229,
-0.0240225643,
-0.016986236,
-0.0015073158,
-0.0341739058,
0.0092216749,
-0.0104562435,
0.012930722,
-0.0203816388,
-0.0588620417,
-0.0019584955,
-0.0083901798,
-0.0264029913,
0.0251119025,
0.0278203972,
-0.0207205564,
0.0177683793,
0.0887753591,
-0.0055914251,
0.0579997785,
-0.0066346629,
0.0064705736,
-0.0200105906,
0.0237487387,
-0.0030347828,
0.0138838589,
-0.0179470256,
0.0318136103,
-0.0182182807,
-0.0010922964,
0.0552961938,
0.0400948115,
-0.0297907908,
-0.0022228188,
0.0468681119,
0.022858724,
-0.0144110778,
0.0283521991,
0.0672805533,
-0.0541408733,
0.0104907872,
0.0402069837,
0.0070633171,
-0.0445483401,
-0.0023179404,
0.0078570908,
0.0441984423,
-0.001130856,
0.0068403073,
-0.0950194001,
-0.0118363332,
0.0362529159,
0.051024422,
0.013833845,
0.0248805191,
-0.0161415543,
-0.0448325053,
-0.0018784883,
0.0441137813,
-0.0037043686,
0.0008073373,
0.0221408196,
-0.0425450765,
-0.0571874194,
0.0791616216,
-0.0064554592,
0.0140413688,
-0.0053730309,
0.044940602,
-0.0533201285,
-0.0972084478,
0.0236667134,
0.003128638,
0.0787565708,
0.0306411702,
-0.0080473432,
0.0298774615,
-0.009734869,
0.0090534277,
0.0302965231,
0.0074214386,
-0.0188364368,
-0.0006499938,
0.014084924,
-0.0065553878,
0.0277114511,
0.0149386246,
0.0056080413,
-0.0069250907,
0.0181787051,
0.0078858752,
-0.010723942,
0.007791874,
-0.0134746218,
-0.0383124538,
-0.0182453934,
0.0268607941,
0.0155982263,
-0.0342183225,
-0.0509992689,
-0.0173809584,
0.0119040869,
-0.0849911869,
-0.0502089933,
-0.0043703322,
-0.0146804508,
-0.1236475632,
0.001783181,
-0.0164359566,
-0.0039826757,
0.0142819835,
-0.0183956884,
-0.037508782,
0.0125321411,
0.0688307658,
-0.0734604895,
-0.0044145905,
-0.0210058801,
0.0194217451,
-0.0648054555,
-0.0031088956,
-0.0046796217,
-0.039601054,
-0.0203456003,
-0.0012157977,
-0.0892525241,
-0.066088751,
0.0501849949,
0.0031847521,
0.0149080642,
0.0823424757,
-0.0143877091,
-0.0834811702,
0.0761622936,
0.064997524,
-0.051100567,
0.0393413119,
0.0618025884,
-0.0053483499,
-0.0276976544,
0.0265535321,
-0.0397509858,
0.0660485849,
-0.0143485554,
0.0276460778,
-0.1013701484,
-0.0612950623,
-0.0235783849,
-0.000558347,
0.0637056753,
-0.0205103904,
0.009835369,
0.0140218707,
0.0418861769,
0.0205173418,
0.0336316377,
-0.0273977965,
-0.0372230336,
-0.0018850098,
-0.0026431654,
-0.0177408531,
-0.0263622012,
0.0251718033,
-0.0556504317,
0.0524252877,
0.0142340232,
-0.0080677057,
0.0467403196,
5.468e-7,
-0.0205161981,
-0.0264998544,
0.0323771313,
0.0316725522,
0.0505685024,
-0.0179092027,
-0.0402588956,
-0.0361846834,
0.02157842,
-0.0436319374,
0.0603906959,
-0.0064801513,
-0.0487417132,
-0.0221588481,
0.0083239777,
0.0209976546,
0.0432278179,
-0.0059142807,
0.010843182,
0.0021477018,
-0.0307177454,
-0.0017325858,
0.0173163544,
0.0096711516,
-0.01357318,
-0.0063925185,
-0.0295551121,
-0.0133944685,
0.0235892646,
0.0293200389,
-0.008755018,
-0.0423320122,
0.0012098323,
-0.0369112268,
-0.0109433513,
-0.0877286792,
0.0442154817,
-0.0119069731,
-0.0409055129,
-0.0172270592,
-0.0236600284,
0.0397653542,
0.0123234149,
0.0171261448,
-0.0176789239,
0.0173280295,
0.011081703,
-0.0371118896,
-0.0353332683,
-0.0091939997,
-0.0554820187,
-0.0102551263,
-0.0023312655,
0.0093383491,
-6.178998545e-33,
-0.0154743278,
0.0461409204,
0.0155725358,
-0.0391730741,
0.0304162763,
0.0257260855,
0.02807796,
0.0121780392,
0.0171197765,
-0.072642073,
-0.0473406538,
-0.0044050631,
0.0490359925,
0.0012210758,
-0.0042723618,
0.0236098748,
0.123388581,
-0.0177928265,
0.0035689087,
0.02792993,
0.0237265676,
0.0213204455,
0.0113277771,
-0.0271806326,
-0.0383555256,
0.0340871513,
0.0008721999,
-0.0674728304,
0.049833782,
0.0285895765,
-0.0094855102,
0.0126266144,
-0.0329243392,
0.0027495511,
-0.0111541934,
-0.00011406,
-0.0969068483,
0.0006655949,
-0.0091135614,
0.0469076075,
0.004806797,
-0.0833414271,
0.0610016659,
0.0287358128,
-0.0754185542,
-0.0170958396,
0.0009376744,
0.013407304,
-0.023388356,
-0.0999498367,
0.0495222285,
0.0412920155,
0.0227446612,
0.018420076,
0.0744551942,
-0.0101846568,
-0.0902029574,
-0.0276830439,
-0.0898434296,
0.0109394565,
-0.0018383226,
0.0528977513,
0.0414018184,
0.0540974699,
0.0187669862,
0.001265988,
0.0653205216,
-0.0202219319,
-0.0072989804,
0.0293347295,
0.0232439488,
0.0094459895,
0.0144920787,
0.0195281748,
0.1077375114,
-0.0375735909,
-0.0281450152,
-0.0214353167,
0.0042163753,
-0.0051423833,
0.040306285,
0.0649967566,
-0.0406034365,
-0.0181427952,
-0.0356362388,
-0.0263736714,
-0.0415535681,
-0.0319736078,
0.0200782437,
0.0153680472,
-0.0406762809,
-0.0060651768,
0.0329127647,
-0.0281840414,
0.0059422413,
-0.0470808819,
0.0414890423,
0.0249166191,
0.0086935274,
0.0046963762,
-0.012306652,
-0.0075194212,
0.0155570349,
0.0085018231,
0.0222282298,
-0.0220918246,
0.0104967011,
0.0484805293,
-0.0706383288,
-0.0403318033,
0.0018106443,
0.0323236771,
0.0078469031,
0.036313273,
0.0346015766,
0.010878887,
-0.0070138196,
0.0341351219,
-0.059551727,
0.0088735959,
0.0051549068,
0.0151871247,
0.0240413528,
0.0431585312,
-0.0406518728,
0.016579017,
-0.0422953553,
0.0409224816,
0.040479213,
-0.040203698,
-0.0276367366,
0.0059779217,
2.867e-7,
-0.050557889,
-0.0026144516,
-0.0050535602,
-0.0459783748,
-0.0005416389,
0.0095697558,
0.0459646918,
0.0165024884,
-0.0191868115,
0.0020634567,
-0.0045409892,
0.0340082794,
0.0295310803,
0.0408088043,
-0.0538574122,
0.0277816337,
-0.0242534205,
0.0679964349,
-0.0125847803,
0.0075324113,
-0.0457244813,
0.0879051387,
0.0026163212,
-0.0039058118,
0.0847212821,
-0.0187451355,
0.0077568232,
0.0015058389,
0.0211949386,
0.0060528088,
0.0432392769,
0.0549322106,
-0.0150912702,
-0.0308895819,
-0.0065562241,
-0.0109729199,
-0.0118703619,
0.0823370963,
-0.0379278772,
-0.0460731871,
-0.0166068301,
0.0049148849,
-0.0408907197,
0.036470145,
0.0354679078,
0.0018356246,
-0.0328549705,
-0.075882569,
0.0061251693,
-0.0149014341,
0.0258487649,
0.0052983947,
0.0211009476,
0.0012905553,
0.0042708637,
-0.0040523051,
0.0054760915,
-0.0889720023,
-0.0028334702,
0.0115508884,
-0.019236004,
-0.0112198237,
-0.0813863203,
0.0058510266,
0.0462150276,
-0.0213807356,
0.0236848239,
2.010319419e-34,
0.0344837531,
-0.0080333212,
0.0397286043,
-0.0166599937,
-0.0312583521,
-0.0072643608,
0.0113625731,
0.0149421766,
0.0222230777,
-0.0233586673,
-0.0522904284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12639v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12639v1 | Fake News Detection Through Graph-based Neural Networks: A Survey | 2023-07-24T09:30:30 | 2023-07-24T09:30:30 | Shuzhi Gong, Richard O. Sinnott, Jianzhong Qi, Cecile Paris | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG | The popularity of online social networks has enabled rapid dissemination of
information. People now can share and consume information much more rapidly
than ever before. However, low-quality and/or accidentally/deliberately fake
information can also spread rapidly. This can lead to considerable and negative
impacts on society. Identifying, labelling and debunking online misinformation
as early as possible has become an increasingly urgent problem. Many methods
have been proposed to detect fake news including many deep learning and
graph-based approaches. In recent years, graph-based methods have yielded
strong results, as they can closely model the social context and propagation
process of online news. In this paper, we present a systematic review of fake
news detection studies based on graph-based and deep learning-based techniques.
We classify existing graph-based methods into knowledge-driven methods,
propagation-based methods, and heterogeneous social context-based methods,
depending on how a graph structure is constructed to model news related
information flows. We further discuss the challenges and open problems in
graph-based fake news detection and identify future research directions. | [
0.0561052114,
0.003682408,
0.0057327356,
0.0488460511,
-0.0386927277,
0.0211820286,
0.0048626415,
0.0003325324,
0.0374552719,
0.0007784245,
0.0175531916,
-0.0349091701,
0.0253951885,
0.0725586489,
0.0147454487,
0.0093647409,
0.0589812472,
0.0484447144,
0.0660103932,
-0.0325264931,
0.0190360192,
0.0410104878,
0.0001480737,
0.0043075597,
-0.0378140248,
-0.0137136718,
0.0240784269,
0.029125955,
0.0267029405,
-0.0280980021,
0.002650904,
0.0096824644,
0.0185638238,
0.1013617963,
0.0000017373,
-0.0011649145,
0.018900726,
-0.0114791216,
-0.0461658984,
-0.0070928773,
0.03395034,
-0.0687068626,
-0.0094256364,
0.0295001324,
-0.0332034975,
-0.0575108528,
0.0158861913,
0.0416077785,
0.0356029794,
0.1107867658,
-0.0374671593,
-0.0226072799,
0.0150616691,
-0.0122054946,
0.0071063526,
-0.0320011489,
0.074921973,
0.0010204642,
-0.0044697425,
0.0033059593,
-0.001509481,
-0.0028997783,
0.0339321718,
-0.0134308646,
-0.0009663202,
-0.0067608654,
-0.0019051238,
-0.0232165586,
0.0038971154,
0.0562503673,
-0.0473391823,
-0.0496003702,
0.0256701577,
-0.0356232673,
-0.0054134084,
0.0378332064,
-0.0024123192,
0.0055971122,
-0.0178777426,
0.0171506312,
0.0037323991,
-0.0303349588,
0.0819208845,
0.0307180192,
0.0193578992,
0.0434971452,
-0.0307731442,
0.0232428499,
0.018451089,
0.0130892377,
0.002720051,
-0.0207113642,
0.0543754995,
0.0012605226,
-0.0248444211,
-0.0048772902,
-0.0682399571,
-0.0356606878,
-0.0124934511,
-0.0847677812,
-0.0235393494,
-0.0503534898,
0.0388570987,
0.0434592217,
0.0027104223,
-0.0240881275,
-0.058550287,
0.0336364061,
0.0030967551,
-0.0076244725,
-0.0017671235,
0.0168115385,
-0.0036958663,
-0.0017706545,
-0.0030113563,
-0.0266365074,
-0.0715628713,
0.0077004223,
-0.0426482409,
0.0008355416,
-0.0133028245,
0.0489609353,
0.0088175945,
-0.0000633188,
0.0262038782,
0.0282417014,
0.0186403953,
0.0314675421,
-0.0171680935,
-0.0129746264,
0.0020102323,
0.0197269041,
0.0305505898,
0.024140751,
0.0002418572,
0.0075632948,
0.035053093,
0.0042834999,
-0.0364108309,
-0.0436240397,
-0.0041377945,
-0.0134163909,
0.0283896755,
-0.0802008659,
-0.0099457167,
-0.0331340209,
-0.0233348738,
-0.006970033,
-0.0211591348,
0.0139328232,
-0.0706544891,
0.0247549638,
-0.0177381858,
0.0119553152,
0.0395342149,
0.010013626,
0.0016840182,
0.0421993285,
0.0188912973,
0.0954729542,
0.0446047373,
0.033002764,
-0.0089175273,
0.0057129711,
0.0758389607,
0.0100469049,
0.0589959919,
-0.0454419255,
-0.0615790673,
-0.0059046615,
-0.0102310358,
0.0057373689,
-0.0255088992,
-0.0629103258,
0.0516219214,
-0.040487837,
-0.0028716589,
-0.0039815498,
0.0667319596,
0.0251098238,
-0.0331291854,
-0.0021009883,
-0.0419239514,
-0.0061855502,
-0.0443687737,
-0.0171168055,
-0.0420792475,
0.0277816486,
-0.0102662276,
0.0182085931,
0.0291410796,
-0.015081156,
0.0570348203,
-0.0262382384,
0.015903065,
0.0251806807,
-0.0330387726,
-0.015936207,
0.0132938037,
0.039324414,
-0.000844587,
-0.0124265691,
-0.0129910121,
0.0288134813,
0.0261340309,
0.042330794,
-0.0043735132,
-0.0108439075,
0.0102136154,
0.0189932548,
0.0195735749,
-0.0226859674,
-0.0376623087,
0.0121263536,
-0.0168795865,
-0.0285461135,
-0.0083810501,
-0.0034682369,
0.0288539026,
0.0546979234,
0.000690574,
-0.0292838253,
-0.0473642945,
-0.0057690297,
0.0081478842,
0.0223003495,
0.0093550878,
0.047851,
0.008885582,
0.0372552983,
0.0258056913,
-0.0354929082,
0.0360683985,
0.0282311942,
-0.0445840582,
-0.0582556762,
-0.0323585868,
-0.0282423347,
0.015796449,
-0.0553396493,
-0.0497843139,
0.0782413334,
-0.0281244554,
0.0026119805,
0.0623815693,
-0.0551739,
0.0046819579,
-0.0039698775,
-0.0452446155,
-0.0143429069,
0.0340459198,
0.0712100416,
0.0740322024,
-0.0517609566,
-0.0145215876,
0.0077684596,
0.0099546136,
0.0039911559,
-0.0092962645,
0.0062478441,
-0.0204249937,
-0.0124234119,
-0.0052211871,
0.027217783,
-0.0325728692,
0.0004341822,
0.0436534993,
-0.0413938686,
-0.024052782,
-0.0143169947,
-0.0080206152,
0.0277672447,
0.0194313787,
0.0273591448,
0.0212959647,
-0.0366004743,
0.0383719802,
0.0208076499,
0.0082284864,
-0.0153438281,
-0.033523988,
0.0034272363,
0.0117276022,
-0.0148182521,
-0.0322945826,
0.0693884864,
0.0475412495,
-0.0698118359,
0.0007116878,
-0.0204931069,
-0.0626658276,
0.0165550914,
-0.0270832703,
0.0055453805,
0.0005112649,
0.0167336836,
-0.0254345275,
0.0389433652,
0.0210890379,
0.0619954541,
0.0091831656,
0.0554573871,
-0.0037859033,
-0.0436098054,
-0.0694353878,
0.0786331221,
-0.045524098,
-0.0476123765,
-0.0009398607,
-0.0133460872,
0.0443712771,
0.0032851412,
0.0019286196,
0.0307473149,
-0.0020975678,
-0.0192365535,
0.0298024844,
-0.072914958,
0.0275391266,
-0.0472435579,
-0.0472067259,
0.0046635685,
0.0920390859,
0.0109713618,
0.0647123307,
0.0186592806,
-0.0451131687,
-0.0052196961,
-0.0349321701,
0.0124475444,
0.020349361,
-0.0139858797,
-0.0113576353,
0.0140212392,
0.0150155947,
0.0658483282,
-0.0146293072,
-0.0322255231,
0.0022014193,
0.0335635878,
0.0297868121,
0.005614236,
-0.0318388157,
-0.073914215,
-0.0076315259,
-0.0003273429,
0.0029923266,
-0.0537375174,
-0.0222653896,
-0.018698398,
0.0120285228,
0.0309160966,
-0.0098428531,
0.0188091025,
-0.0123654474,
0.0582172759,
0.0112566492,
-0.0425702818,
0.0564730354,
-0.0092432005,
-0.0398163311,
0.0399983898,
0.0043995623,
0.0076260008,
-0.0398485698,
-0.0238572098,
-0.0272827037,
0.0084895575,
0.0110099874,
-0.0367017016,
-0.0108289765,
-0.046031069,
0.009271442,
0.0539632924,
-0.0008470171,
-0.034013655,
0.0032026032,
0.064115487,
-0.0409070253,
0.0030446383,
-0.0426346883,
-0.0883867443,
0.0083200969,
-0.0257238094,
-0.0153812235,
-0.0234765895,
-0.0243181475,
0.0019849474,
-0.0467722267,
-0.0074487794,
-0.0071610063,
-0.0217107963,
-0.0641802996,
-0.0721932203,
0.0010769581,
0.0135340448,
0.0133708697,
-0.0323924012,
0.023536494,
-0.0344317555,
-0.0155050438,
0.0037171298,
-0.0561368652,
-0.0054183602,
-0.023385508,
0.0582131185,
-0.0131694702,
0.0415304191,
-0.0163682364,
-0.0246510804,
0.0153256962,
0.0203729607,
-0.0567026325,
-0.0188962072,
0.0486003943,
-0.0447135568,
-0.0035339212,
-0.0389753878,
0.0242769197,
-0.0203858968,
-0.0060642976,
-0.0699603111,
0.0503021553,
0.0140388692,
-0.1313474923,
-0.0221494902,
0.0079905642,
0.0487903282,
0.0201438591,
0.0305439252,
0.0014907086,
0.0019087092,
-0.003848287,
-0.0148059549,
-0.0271704942,
-0.0493209064,
0.0439463966,
0.0015093928,
-0.0370162688,
-0.0418842807,
-0.0066183778,
-0.0168713238,
0.0058380309,
-0.0392233916,
-0.0132595431,
0.0772228837,
-0.0542144477,
-0.0661617294,
-0.0258588828,
-0.0112767573,
0.0646943897,
0.0265059415,
0.0082415054,
0.0002005259,
0.0142854778,
-0.0236445442,
0.0569617972,
-0.0907416046,
-0.0583107173,
0.0018317222,
-0.0067168348,
0.0080835531,
0.0546562821,
-0.0466342717,
-0.0188525449,
0.0675281137,
0.0002449508,
0.0148604559,
0.0118038869,
-0.0072357538,
-0.0373325385,
0.03968402,
0.020836208,
-0.0232360754,
0.0291378088,
0.0259838961,
-0.0303860828,
-0.0597903207,
0.0092002619,
-0.0146928048,
0.027568562,
0.0338337123,
0.0357056744,
-0.0073020421,
-0.0528961644,
-0.0569361784,
-0.0133859254,
-0.0131452279,
0.0389916264,
0.0070327055,
0.0190696642,
0.0132497726,
0.00360002,
-0.017582139,
0.0166629236,
0.0071199429,
-0.0388250872,
-0.0515586026,
0.0203716364,
0.0374420807,
0.0143654058,
0.0066984436,
-0.032523524,
0.0514670685,
0.0116413999,
0.0208114758,
-0.0128467586,
-0.0253245626,
0.0205422323,
-0.0404310413,
0.0073134131,
-0.0422093011,
-0.0472580232,
0.0091964174,
-0.0479642525,
0.0301073287,
0.0238960534,
0.0047113285,
0.0219705421,
0.0041979705,
-0.0079778386,
-0.0142970541,
-0.0106252544,
-0.0352391601,
-0.0483594425,
-0.0198220294,
0.0137063358,
-0.0190549772,
0.0889781192,
0.0282679014,
0.0508521795,
0.0171000008,
0.0169938952,
-0.0749117583,
-0.0261340868,
0.0023035437,
-0.0224300586,
0.0746380389,
-0.0173584968,
0.0035808762,
-0.0517544039,
-0.0658184215,
0.0155580277,
0.0127950534,
0.0408086441,
0.053820014,
-0.0185147244,
0.0663546771,
0.0166672114,
0.0111783165,
-0.0208520349,
0.0232414436,
-0.0157533046,
-0.0639965162,
0.0383736007,
-6.255966241e-33,
0.0492528416,
-0.0785398185,
-0.0489449203,
0.0130573651,
-0.0246324092,
0.0613302179,
-0.0117135542,
-0.0417214818,
-0.0344145484,
0.055297289,
0.0475431792,
0.0857677907,
-0.0173227433,
0.0100812241,
-0.1004862562,
-0.0266148318,
0.0277557522,
0.0040404322,
0.0124298763,
0.0417276584,
0.0526559353,
-0.0062347301,
0.0259960778,
-0.0690192655,
0.039718952,
-0.0547951534,
0.0049695601,
0.0176249985,
-0.0074204314,
0.0356668532,
-0.0108111864,
0.0566999614,
0.0577996746,
0.0044416622,
0.010129327,
0.0333001912,
-0.0492131934,
-0.0186397545,
-0.0021430987,
-0.0021912858,
-0.0635016635,
0.0238536764,
0.0657105595,
0.0270566735,
0.0007470577,
0.0234911945,
0.0469007306,
0.031887006,
-0.0221734475,
0.0093931062,
-0.0457396917,
0.0012956061,
-0.0056879655,
0.0243430082,
-0.0368112922,
0.0326125659,
0.0349826366,
-0.0069209873,
-0.1133282408,
0.0082289614,
-0.0701475441,
-0.0265231729,
-0.019294329,
-0.0535978302,
-0.0238327868,
0.0362066813,
0.0134140607,
0.0447618514,
-0.0436768942,
0.0241785161,
0.0262537301,
0.0298855696,
0.0398271382,
0.0811897889,
-0.0168359429,
-0.0780501589,
-0.1132587045,
0.0006251584,
0.0384269319,
-0.0155377416,
-0.0151928961,
-0.0160950627,
-0.023511814,
-0.0040257438,
0.0130842542,
-0.0513727069,
-0.0348685607,
-0.0093778325,
-0.047432024,
0.0235320758,
-0.0551803,
0.0706910416,
-0.0139798038,
-0.0769448355,
0.00181523,
0.0799883604,
0.0076881237,
0.0374079533,
0.027111413,
0.0641224384,
-0.0696109757,
-0.0007393469,
0.0089087225,
0.0043147523,
0.0014526354,
-0.0136815542,
0.044333037,
0.0198746473,
0.0081498381,
0.0091119558,
-0.0269061793,
0.0246858113,
-0.045735307,
-0.0256831385,
0.0381644294,
0.0034760132,
-0.0123558473,
0.0059968354,
0.0248056185,
0.0453388728,
0.036610838,
0.0406980105,
-0.0220084302,
0.022563545,
-0.03304464,
-0.0253681634,
-0.0529638492,
0.0450605303,
0.0115994448,
-0.1168767735,
0.0222089179,
-0.0111354236,
2.666e-7,
-0.0153362136,
0.0435423553,
0.0278386939,
0.0326981992,
0.0393448099,
0.0341048576,
0.058006119,
0.0271951146,
-0.0335877016,
-0.0885930583,
0.0012478823,
0.0465384759,
-0.0447810441,
0.0151361823,
-0.0522792637,
0.0491597801,
-0.0672520548,
-0.0048096473,
-0.0212925933,
-0.0023538668,
-0.037696749,
0.0292912796,
0.073607482,
-0.0491285734,
-0.0079604601,
0.0032820969,
0.0317302272,
0.0683968291,
-0.0323360488,
-0.0117153488,
0.0408931822,
-0.025154572,
-0.0094980001,
0.0177143961,
-0.0057336264,
0.0103992019,
-0.0067247869,
-0.0156660657,
-0.0009751928,
0.004565401,
-0.0094225034,
-0.0536527112,
0.0283014532,
-0.0293455515,
0.0455477536,
-0.020661993,
-0.0227081683,
-0.0533667356,
-0.0322554111,
0.0087073073,
0.039799571,
0.0018307056,
0.0077132103,
0.039119944,
0.0024732624,
-0.0231480356,
0.0016575832,
-0.03589103,
0.0607554391,
0.0068293223,
-0.034610711,
-0.0019876414,
0.0212099478,
-0.0348797441,
0.0732180625,
0.0023698029,
0.0199613832,
1.724376285e-34,
0.0354622602,
-0.0136794252,
-0.0065232161,
-0.0585698336,
0.0016517173,
0.0185286179,
-0.0752926767,
-0.0273199305,
0.0387234315,
-0.0047380873,
0.015617474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12573v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12573v1 | Tachikuma: Understading Complex Interactions with Multi-Character and Novel Objects by Large Language Models | 2023-07-24T07:40:59 | 2023-07-24T07:40:59 | Yuanzhi Liang, Linchao Zhu, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in natural language and Large Language Models (LLMs) have
enabled AI agents to simulate human-like interactions within virtual worlds.
However, these interactions still face limitations in complexity and
flexibility, particularly in scenarios involving multiple characters and novel
objects. Pre-defining all interactable objects in the agent's world model
presents challenges, and conveying implicit intentions to multiple characters
through complex interactions remains difficult. To address these issues, we
propose integrating virtual Game Masters (GMs) into the agent's world model,
drawing inspiration from Tabletop Role-Playing Games (TRPGs). GMs play a
crucial role in overseeing information, estimating players' intentions,
providing environment descriptions, and offering feedback, compensating for
current world model deficiencies. To facilitate future explorations for complex
interactions, we introduce a benchmark named Tachikuma, comprising a Multiple
character and novel Object based interaction Estimation (MOE) task and a
supporting dataset. MOE challenges models to understand characters' intentions
and accurately determine their actions within intricate contexts involving
multi-character and novel object interactions. Besides, the dataset captures
log data from real-time communications during gameplay, providing diverse,
grounded, and complex interactions for further explorations. Finally, we
present a simple prompting baseline and evaluate its performance, demonstrating
its effectiveness in enhancing interaction understanding. We hope that our
dataset and task will inspire further research in complex interactions with
natural language, fostering the development of more advanced AI agents. | [
0.0485860892,
0.0224667639,
-0.0276045259,
0.0533813648,
0.0068548513,
0.015885571,
0.0028325843,
0.0020301661,
0.016402388,
-0.0053341822,
-0.0334622301,
-0.0848691612,
0.0108192805,
0.0431043729,
0.0096674785,
-0.0378702581,
0.0343860574,
-0.0363877155,
0.0052237194,
0.035937801,
-0.0042785974,
0.0237113182,
-0.031929981,
0.0704755113,
-0.0002758491,
-0.0453124605,
-0.0538539588,
0.0098146079,
0.0152462982,
-0.057049416,
-0.0160836633,
-0.0064897346,
0.0615461096,
-0.0018611429,
0.0000020202,
-0.0367709547,
0.0250723325,
-0.0486617461,
-0.0295973774,
-0.0097502964,
0.0367160738,
-0.0039511221,
0.0204737261,
0.0001681964,
-0.0572891906,
-0.0294515304,
0.0661112741,
0.0583935715,
0.0654745549,
0.0457484014,
-0.0089878077,
-0.0050066593,
-0.0552357845,
0.0043291789,
0.0350005515,
-0.0516788736,
0.0091769351,
0.025213087,
0.0279934201,
-0.0291263834,
0.0074250489,
0.0064823828,
-0.0000686634,
-0.0167971011,
-0.0104748793,
0.0389725044,
0.0172770191,
-0.0026831371,
-0.016606193,
0.0875167102,
0.0211430192,
0.0064814277,
0.0424464792,
0.0072804573,
0.0030130183,
0.0179329384,
-0.0144287804,
0.0016949393,
-0.032624729,
-0.0177765135,
-0.0120650223,
0.0285850428,
0.0268162955,
0.0111216884,
-0.0148489419,
0.0372330956,
-0.0090605887,
-0.0225342605,
-0.035025917,
-0.0016267636,
-0.0174118765,
-0.071101509,
-0.0231295247,
0.0181918219,
-0.1061641425,
0.0176830906,
-0.0509051383,
0.0429713987,
-0.0208954681,
-0.0223828852,
0.0554013774,
0.0372518934,
-0.0012441658,
0.0666221008,
0.0457868129,
0.0377232432,
-0.015333822,
-0.0501796603,
-0.0053844871,
0.01014423,
-0.0212480091,
-0.0085426336,
-0.0137709798,
0.0331555679,
-0.0552176647,
-0.051902011,
0.0162558258,
0.0390317477,
-0.0307283401,
0.0431248806,
-0.0100091342,
0.0172791928,
-0.0292608459,
0.0085207876,
-0.0311023984,
0.0079431357,
-0.0582642704,
0.038804017,
-0.0008251581,
-0.0772054568,
-0.0068332693,
-0.0210387148,
0.0504160784,
-0.0039948947,
0.0086640213,
0.1053677574,
0.0087406635,
-0.0266747344,
0.0195623711,
-0.0405142121,
0.0056099845,
-0.041757375,
-0.0073946826,
-0.0382133052,
0.0656478181,
-0.0509140007,
0.0393692739,
-0.0039128778,
0.0148925344,
0.0103912354,
0.0350871868,
0.0865504369,
-0.0035472941,
0.034595117,
0.0208319575,
0.0254844502,
0.0003769209,
0.0463782325,
0.0300056208,
0.0216014199,
0.0092514828,
0.0107704494,
0.0290861782,
0.0596863665,
-0.0437469371,
-0.0315943919,
0.0162285957,
-0.0032762028,
-0.0169015285,
0.0797408521,
0.0117821153,
0.0287114382,
-0.0517455153,
-0.0144871874,
0.0789907351,
0.063653782,
-0.0438822843,
0.0080153942,
0.0775425062,
0.0478564017,
0.0097347526,
-0.0004497719,
-0.0035349545,
0.0276180673,
0.0126552926,
-0.0428030752,
-0.0453640558,
0.0102528473,
-0.0069067418,
-0.0505122244,
0.0327875465,
-0.0025077905,
0.0171452779,
0.0014971674,
0.0338423774,
-0.0216788035,
-0.0504561551,
-0.0272363182,
0.0173080508,
-0.0637713745,
0.0144142425,
-0.028020218,
0.0559930131,
0.09910018,
0.0406970643,
-0.0619956814,
-0.0604321957,
-0.020504497,
0.0179513767,
0.0483395196,
-0.0009361614,
-0.0391467512,
0.0819136351,
-0.014990868,
0.0033910868,
-0.019480668,
0.000285531,
0.0814630911,
-0.0133400811,
-0.0082699908,
0.0044974359,
0.0199924558,
0.0182927605,
0.0408536308,
-0.0345607027,
-0.0214843862,
-0.0472331271,
0.0266869515,
0.0049880985,
0.0413019732,
-0.0429353453,
-0.0420182645,
0.0331339389,
-0.0365011953,
-0.010688046,
0.0371947847,
-0.0071084802,
0.0001368179,
0.0581537113,
-0.0148633374,
-0.0236283634,
0.0141513916,
0.0148936985,
0.0051442082,
0.0224519894,
-0.0031096376,
0.0452532843,
0.0096831433,
0.0060940944,
-0.0116685387,
0.018853683,
0.0137755461,
0.024754012,
0.0041774372,
-0.0288317986,
0.0333119892,
-0.0452494025,
-0.0008198256,
-0.0267260708,
0.0008293175,
0.0080051273,
-0.0133605478,
-0.0058264383,
0.0372786485,
0.0023504477,
-0.0629702136,
-0.025527183,
-0.0697081536,
-0.0140367029,
-0.006098283,
-0.0177899227,
0.0161044504,
0.0176868271,
-0.03815341,
0.0095224399,
-0.0163656157,
0.0080239382,
0.0126715461,
-0.0197839178,
0.0308835749,
0.0204323661,
-0.0064412933,
-0.0450767279,
0.0330057107,
-0.0237978641,
0.0331262909,
0.0106090084,
-0.0330385081,
-0.012547452,
0.0099643692,
-0.0583521761,
0.037785776,
-0.0567568727,
-0.0749293938,
0.0449459925,
-0.046496857,
0.0045220586,
0.0612667538,
-0.020957211,
0.033864554,
0.0640529692,
-0.0644193739,
-0.0272045676,
0.0291487724,
0.0169306062,
-0.0105462587,
-0.0619929433,
-0.0217647497,
0.0426179394,
0.0765428916,
-0.0276107192,
0.0284236316,
-0.0842549726,
0.0132976277,
0.0075761881,
-0.0712952539,
0.0179732107,
-0.0290618446,
-0.0325053446,
0.0135453288,
-0.0379406363,
0.035692811,
0.0439398363,
-0.0370856635,
-0.0561119616,
0.0119748432,
0.0136324968,
0.0093261944,
0.0872843564,
-0.0027898683,
0.0253334194,
0.0152770746,
-0.0147641078,
-0.0280665569,
-0.0146777304,
0.0026809899,
-0.0191346947,
0.0243644882,
-0.0862249061,
-0.0142127415,
0.0416410342,
0.0084682573,
0.0176602788,
-0.0335775614,
-0.035586156,
-0.043451637,
-0.0114666084,
-0.039137803,
-0.0364599377,
-0.0094609726,
-0.0019636604,
0.0293883532,
0.0090758633,
-0.0309711285,
-0.0376866572,
-0.0285305772,
0.1064451188,
0.0242023487,
-0.0248729922,
-0.035452757,
0.0903374627,
0.0336207859,
-0.0226421244,
-0.0513504185,
-0.0227334909,
0.0246971194,
0.0171758384,
0.0050836015,
0.0120927189,
0.047767356,
0.0495800972,
-0.058233466,
0.000965936,
0.1188850403,
0.0087119248,
-0.0218591169,
-0.0006405413,
-0.0208132472,
0.0061540273,
0.015929142,
-0.0017344924,
-0.0654794797,
-0.0064880401,
-0.0012954588,
-0.0105831716,
-0.0045751869,
-0.0793930069,
-0.0012472344,
-0.1114858985,
-0.000127522,
-0.0086766565,
-0.0469092093,
-0.0189981367,
0.0019632997,
0.0348086208,
-0.0189759303,
0.0030847676,
-0.0449204147,
0.0264735594,
-0.009000889,
-0.0000379816,
-0.0250637084,
-0.015336684,
0.0279321596,
-0.0859476179,
0.1165136918,
0.0354827121,
0.0931119844,
-0.0172796734,
0.0139301792,
-0.0496701524,
0.0615391992,
0.0143550225,
-0.0051547326,
0.043730177,
-0.0261552054,
-0.0161525477,
-0.0005997702,
-0.0119337076,
-0.0176236704,
-0.0263264123,
0.0325153619,
0.0345836878,
-0.0070540402,
-0.0258643143,
0.0120697953,
0.0350391082,
0.0717757046,
0.0542517491,
-0.0016781673,
-0.065371111,
0.0090814671,
-0.0063999421,
-0.0022216623,
-0.0036424128,
-0.0435210392,
-0.0314469784,
0.0085787205,
-0.0183989163,
-0.0764740258,
-0.0736740083,
0.0446019806,
0.0459188297,
0.0202288143,
0.0183208883,
0.0081250239,
0.0278748926,
0.0246826615,
0.0252337344,
-0.0286729448,
0.0179042164,
0.0103616472,
-0.0054351073,
0.0052271211,
-0.0491853245,
0.0233645998,
0.0401083007,
-0.0373482518,
-0.0519143343,
0.0028059529,
0.0366282016,
0.0201910269,
0.0213608891,
0.0028917307,
-0.0537140816,
-0.0367725901,
-0.040261168,
-0.0532204546,
0.0319131389,
0.0115877511,
0.0341151804,
0.0098087173,
0.0238495599,
-0.0349747799,
-0.0062414287,
-0.0258324537,
0.0344323255,
-0.0502915308,
-0.0603987016,
-0.0034617332,
-0.0183082204,
0.0110926088,
-0.0220606104,
0.0124043673,
-0.0117342211,
-0.020339122,
-0.0406666435,
-0.0073736277,
-0.0624983273,
-0.0050185965,
0.0309859905,
0.0270770341,
-0.0004967406,
0.0007682721,
-0.0186282638,
0.0059015309,
-0.0308082644,
-0.014684693,
0.0313846506,
-0.0191073958,
0.0032462901,
0.0268891789,
0.0101886773,
-0.0236685481,
-0.0300511084,
0.0439534746,
0.0260720234,
0.0370068736,
0.0152792111,
-0.0513932928,
-0.0352572314,
0.0485578366,
-0.0090530459,
-0.0509218872,
0.04638239,
0.0340184905,
0.0452376157,
-0.0013963002,
0.0610139221,
-0.0245139524,
0.026301546,
0.0002368132,
0.0142026916,
0.0100766011,
-0.0502138063,
-0.0018565707,
0.0467902087,
-0.0409820229,
0.0019919858,
0.0309795588,
-0.0122148246,
0.0744185299,
0.0221726522,
-0.0056317328,
-0.0420664921,
0.0164313894,
0.0318159983,
0.0503986664,
-0.0396327004,
0.0174624324,
-0.0638878793,
-0.0201433208,
0.0067224987,
0.0557332635,
-0.0269122329,
-0.0329538956,
0.0070060915,
0.0200674199,
0.0114860237,
-0.0143428147,
-0.0353723168,
-0.0288838092,
-0.0405396335,
0.0065239966,
-0.0277054515,
-5.288819081e-33,
-0.0511814207,
-0.0210005175,
0.0098002898,
0.0014910018,
-0.0676373988,
0.0124229528,
-0.0579321571,
-0.0130453259,
-0.0221764296,
0.0109568974,
-0.0088355597,
0.0320089869,
-0.0052941078,
-0.014998382,
0.0123074558,
-0.0440486595,
0.0335407555,
0.0157731455,
-0.0323174037,
0.0297373589,
0.0063673714,
-0.0034633155,
0.0434533246,
-0.1039610729,
0.0237091351,
0.0127053736,
-0.0317426734,
0.0174963083,
0.0093814293,
0.0411889143,
-0.0310553759,
0.0106727257,
0.0147626568,
0.0024511057,
0.0050416877,
0.0415775552,
-0.0421939492,
-0.0294707604,
0.0169531647,
0.0148295658,
-0.0079330392,
-0.0100889998,
-0.04455138,
0.0232696775,
0.009703882,
-0.0069965925,
0.0512166619,
-0.0094289007,
0.012133847,
0.019853089,
-0.067116268,
-0.0074535641,
-0.0635141581,
-0.0531480722,
0.0504754931,
0.062374562,
0.0126169249,
-0.0073945667,
-0.0588154383,
0.0225708988,
-0.0109693995,
-0.0382580757,
0.0143580763,
0.0537859499,
0.050812941,
0.0928213373,
0.0514908917,
0.0307890978,
-0.0688613355,
-0.0140524488,
0.0182812847,
0.0500203595,
-0.0132106254,
0.076829955,
-0.0016712568,
0.0140591478,
-0.0397690162,
0.0432897098,
0.0152366525,
0.0612896532,
0.0278523881,
0.0026679882,
-0.0551113188,
0.0041934922,
-0.0197620429,
0.0048943572,
0.0001079203,
-0.0371309705,
0.0207804646,
-0.0283476207,
-0.029322803,
-0.0284726731,
0.0338748097,
-0.038541507,
-0.0022393526,
0.0152865555,
-0.0154385362,
0.0298253503,
-0.0145387892,
-0.0083478065,
0.0053663896,
-0.0436296239,
0.0373661332,
-0.0188552924,
0.0526951402,
0.0383601002,
-0.0326678455,
0.0655497015,
-0.0139536131,
-0.0214685816,
-0.0160180889,
0.009444518,
0.01326897,
0.0280671697,
0.0558507629,
-0.0605888218,
-0.0297321733,
0.0189931877,
0.0237927735,
-0.0442002714,
-0.0072941654,
-0.0106012151,
-0.0040444643,
-0.0425379686,
-0.0547040217,
-0.0191352498,
-0.0739485621,
-0.0019783438,
0.0442245901,
-0.0176329874,
-0.0291861277,
-0.0299562644,
2.861e-7,
-0.0356861837,
0.0332670845,
0.0174760241,
0.0437511131,
-0.0153011288,
0.046342358,
-0.0158504061,
0.0234968029,
-0.00336614,
-0.0582805686,
0.0720933601,
0.0328373946,
0.0431602634,
-0.0180006586,
-0.1039712429,
-0.0116512217,
-0.0210723262,
-0.0148984818,
-0.0407453515,
0.0132743865,
0.0536613241,
0.0518979654,
0.0272565,
0.0099089462,
0.0434768535,
-0.0093605658,
0.0050883526,
-0.0925591737,
0.0243228953,
0.0162201934,
0.0205668136,
-0.0077982172,
-0.0440596938,
-0.0128871799,
0.0048296251,
0.0488481708,
0.0126364874,
0.0673237741,
-0.0428640246,
0.0287346654,
-0.0223590154,
-0.0088230819,
-0.0170166213,
-0.0401408747,
0.0532425269,
-0.0223825481,
-0.0302828085,
-0.0077611404,
0.0002411189,
-0.0254710764,
-0.039851848,
-0.0388205834,
0.0005473153,
-0.0115731591,
-0.0141460747,
-0.0186839644,
-0.0216250103,
-0.0627214164,
-0.0080094161,
0.0089324554,
-0.0378346145,
-0.0325021744,
-0.0281369518,
-0.0364132188,
-0.0105746817,
-0.0476212464,
0.0229221899,
2.07503176e-34,
-0.0410945565,
0.0194107462,
0.0051120375,
0.0469455421,
0.0833726525,
-0.0000922537,
0.0040479619,
0.0359402858,
0.0353513286,
-0.0791726187,
0.0170220863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12564v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12564v4 | Towards Generalising Neural Topical Representations | 2023-07-24T07:17:33 | 2024-06-13T02:14:30 | Xiaohao Yang, He Zhao, Dinh Phung, Lan Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Topic models have evolved from conventional Bayesian probabilistic models to
recent Neural Topic Models (NTMs). Although NTMs have shown promising
performance when trained and tested on a specific corpus, their generalisation
ability across corpora has yet to be studied. In practice, we often expect that
an NTM trained on a source corpus can still produce quality topical
representation (i.e., latent distribution over topics) for the document from
different target corpora to a certain degree. In this work, we aim to improve
NTMs further so that their representation power for documents generalises
reliably across corpora and tasks. To do so, we propose to enhance NTMs by
narrowing the semantic distance between similar documents, with the underlying
assumption that documents from different corpora may share similar semantics.
Specifically, we obtain a similar document for each training document by text
data augmentation. Then, we optimise NTMs further by minimising the semantic
distance between each pair, measured by the Topical Optimal Transport
(TopicalOT) distance, which computes the optimal transport distance between
their topical representations. Our framework can be readily applied to most
NTMs as a plug-and-play module. Extensive experiments show that our framework
significantly improves the generalisation ability regarding neural topical
representation across corpora. Our code and datasets are available at:
https://github.com/Xiaohao-Yang/Topic_Model_Generalisation. | [
0.032606937,
0.0236795824,
0.0055656927,
0.0263231788,
-0.0181020349,
-0.001012951,
0.0071999305,
-0.0109838909,
-0.0652326122,
-0.0061431346,
-0.0097781448,
-0.0199342296,
-0.0072589619,
0.025456775,
0.0278755799,
-0.0670614839,
0.0124116568,
0.0172777716,
-0.0087300921,
0.0027009428,
0.0327832475,
0.0053326464,
-0.0065938765,
0.0397926793,
-0.0117432773,
-0.0250652581,
-0.0235392936,
-0.0165387709,
0.0377281904,
0.0100635597,
0.0365139656,
0.0291744787,
0.0526873954,
-0.0173304174,
0.000001694,
0.0070706685,
0.0028567999,
-0.0407745391,
0.0627545044,
-0.0157350488,
0.0877420753,
-0.0436831303,
0.0390448384,
0.0027506675,
0.0038475879,
-0.0317826346,
0.0396799408,
0.0744059682,
0.052407939,
0.0913071632,
-0.0199221745,
0.0166372694,
0.0644417778,
-0.0625448376,
0.0607537329,
-0.0817450061,
0.0028974803,
-0.0014366882,
-0.0326147042,
0.0890847668,
-0.0287600085,
0.0004065803,
-0.0072917663,
-0.0023801129,
0.0580473319,
0.0193277393,
-0.0072368686,
-0.0067328047,
0.0064575006,
0.0955216885,
0.0051585534,
-0.0016440494,
0.0136155887,
0.0081044976,
-0.0123015596,
0.0050493581,
-0.0639230758,
0.0076449951,
-0.0097123012,
0.0106673734,
0.039668791,
-0.0074156178,
0.050663799,
0.031269107,
-0.0071076383,
0.0039896453,
0.0217643194,
-0.0072639547,
-0.0055537643,
0.0156122409,
-0.0032144419,
-0.0281105619,
0.0439763367,
0.0139875999,
0.0186830387,
-0.0028850436,
-0.0168641489,
-0.0388475955,
0.0117515335,
-0.0376872607,
-0.0129147936,
0.0503691882,
-0.0265314598,
0.0603194907,
0.0127950422,
0.0272639729,
-0.0570098087,
0.0070224907,
-0.0469947457,
-0.0516695157,
-0.0522433668,
0.0072754337,
0.0109742582,
0.0201771874,
-0.0173072573,
-0.0330989584,
0.0070323506,
0.0447606556,
-0.0167367961,
-0.0271328241,
-0.005372216,
0.0182712004,
-0.0572493486,
-0.0303864256,
-0.0069843512,
0.0530325472,
-0.086801894,
0.0554241687,
-0.01704829,
0.0515349284,
-0.0035673494,
0.0215115044,
0.0112142032,
-0.016581133,
-0.0034264438,
0.0377626792,
-0.005790845,
-0.0278105009,
-0.0605170019,
0.0399543196,
0.0128937792,
-0.025226051,
0.0426477678,
-0.0842103213,
0.0184569601,
-0.0040284242,
-0.0146060595,
-0.0287634265,
-0.025277907,
0.0343482606,
-0.0400530398,
0.0499667749,
0.0060159313,
-0.010059868,
0.0678653717,
0.0500379652,
-0.0065865684,
0.0565184504,
-0.0029061737,
0.0249011703,
0.0325704962,
0.0303455386,
-0.0532112122,
-0.0289742425,
-0.0038789471,
0.0245651137,
0.0119946338,
-0.0025643734,
0.0058051967,
0.0391955115,
0.0828339159,
0.0113088982,
-0.0580262393,
-0.0652848333,
0.0359760374,
0.0699777976,
0.0055015469,
0.0354708061,
0.0004619761,
0.027560113,
-0.0361139402,
0.0001623029,
0.0069216774,
0.019574767,
0.0187503602,
-0.0322859213,
0.0586094484,
0.02446834,
-0.06994728,
-0.0054588122,
0.0272653699,
-0.0628860444,
-0.0060054711,
-0.0630891398,
0.0637851804,
-0.006162724,
0.021954244,
0.0437942259,
0.0626139343,
-0.028275501,
0.0040062112,
0.0226481967,
0.0473645031,
0.0264669172,
-0.002814133,
-0.0414474048,
-0.0708258376,
-0.0172732938,
0.0022600002,
0.0086822174,
-0.00664218,
-0.0283643678,
0.0353597216,
-0.0396068916,
-0.017527258,
-0.0538809896,
0.011671639,
0.0377025008,
-0.0145778097,
0.0209692083,
0.0429882929,
-0.0551012866,
0.0751935169,
0.0421217084,
-0.0311657172,
0.0039152168,
0.0089620687,
-0.0143441679,
0.0400573425,
0.0026735733,
0.0038493779,
-0.0123376828,
0.0127173914,
-0.059767127,
-0.0170226041,
-0.0156500116,
-0.0389195234,
-0.0080385832,
0.050429713,
-0.0898916572,
0.0155069558,
0.0497424267,
-0.0478519537,
-0.0077698776,
0.0442317948,
0.0248078499,
-0.0465307385,
-0.0379558168,
-0.0181078259,
-0.0239558294,
-0.0082137734,
-0.0222698916,
0.0282780603,
-0.007919061,
0.0268384386,
0.032961119,
0.0182484146,
0.0185949467,
-0.0250679813,
0.0128695071,
0.0033213084,
0.0255990792,
0.0162623283,
0.0298348814,
0.0051732291,
-0.0017553002,
-0.0145856813,
-0.1027395502,
0.0354954489,
-0.0190239325,
0.0067380476,
0.0404419154,
0.0141825248,
0.0055643795,
-0.0150595047,
-0.0714915767,
-0.0070734657,
-0.0581270978,
-0.0069297524,
0.0308380835,
-0.025581602,
0.0556590743,
-0.0623418167,
-0.0201039966,
-0.0123126544,
0.0526498258,
-0.0213055331,
0.0032367285,
-0.0622578599,
0.0074938503,
-0.0412607267,
0.0176835265,
-0.0412738211,
0.0184168592,
-0.004943036,
-0.0451424271,
0.071762152,
0.0299425032,
0.0285894182,
-0.0130131962,
0.0612784401,
0.0161958598,
-0.0705688819,
-0.0067730662,
-0.022252325,
0.0602651872,
-0.0405861996,
-0.0494925082,
0.0117665846,
0.0598687716,
-0.0126304859,
-0.0199821051,
-0.0288116783,
0.0140284216,
-0.0170682725,
0.0185585003,
-0.0614121333,
0.018156454,
-0.0074449093,
-0.008863817,
-0.0342368372,
-0.0231369287,
0.0469478704,
-0.0235111993,
0.0348158292,
-0.075904049,
-0.0206293967,
-0.0503328741,
0.0566705056,
-0.0140881473,
0.0058029685,
-0.0312628299,
-0.0189748462,
-0.0388785563,
0.0337704457,
-0.0119079174,
0.0151076773,
0.0320020169,
0.0012889013,
-0.0077781114,
-0.017057322,
-0.0167862494,
-0.0076585161,
-0.0566986948,
0.0316176452,
0.0202130172,
-0.0161469337,
-0.0019949812,
-0.0102298334,
-0.0215769298,
0.0193526056,
0.0651178062,
-0.0210888535,
-0.0056127696,
-0.0264316984,
0.0468452126,
0.0340684429,
-0.042842973,
-0.0506926589,
0.006407416,
-0.0375674777,
0.0430799983,
0.0234363787,
-0.0110967243,
-0.0676618516,
0.0348442867,
0.0069842399,
-0.0059259934,
-0.0227421671,
-0.0360211022,
0.0509780832,
-0.0022194835,
-0.0078241704,
0.0894608572,
0.0209261905,
-0.0715710893,
-0.0277560186,
-0.0109935571,
0.0043391292,
0.0035112947,
0.0302391984,
-0.0361733176,
-0.0094123622,
0.0094642024,
0.014581725,
0.0658675209,
-0.0037968445,
0.0069082282,
-0.0464153364,
-0.0064772847,
0.0132152084,
-0.0229605325,
-0.05474253,
-0.0752894729,
0.0171863902,
-0.0008443929,
0.0066381297,
-0.006613763,
0.0069202995,
0.0025427167,
0.0279553775,
0.0214209203,
-0.0330848545,
0.0016847407,
-0.0575076789,
0.0278373938,
-0.0024977617,
0.0198785719,
0.0136138583,
-0.0061719851,
-0.0227520894,
-0.0024621903,
-0.0288170986,
0.0022527743,
0.0678472519,
-0.0311072133,
0.0086805085,
0.0123453569,
-0.0060233469,
-0.0431330875,
-0.0130681647,
0.0121236993,
0.0669316649,
-0.0176568851,
-0.0001476885,
-0.045961272,
0.0051812683,
0.0099940971,
0.0520245247,
0.0288565736,
-0.0325370505,
0.0052477974,
-0.0144224623,
0.0146570969,
0.0174280759,
-0.0002629273,
-0.0214727167,
-0.0399853624,
-0.0702229887,
-0.0843345746,
-0.0495056212,
-0.0086841481,
0.0139042344,
-0.0219669323,
-0.0136256833,
-0.0184185822,
-0.0493097119,
-0.0326137841,
0.0765578821,
-0.0009745883,
-0.0385635644,
-0.0014967255,
-0.0083097694,
0.0485238619,
-0.0210962035,
-0.0435460955,
-0.0126408217,
-0.1103840321,
-0.0495685339,
-0.0257080086,
0.0029697013,
0.0107783573,
0.0282614492,
-0.0339398421,
-0.0825262144,
0.0141091328,
0.0031516436,
-0.0553974211,
0.0063942596,
0.026422115,
-0.0062757079,
0.0049839667,
0.0345133319,
-0.0433866978,
0.0574592091,
-0.0093222093,
0.0408593901,
-0.0123268785,
0.0040252763,
-0.0220561456,
-0.0514077395,
0.0619390234,
0.035670843,
-0.0083052125,
-0.0802646205,
-0.0192263089,
-0.0076894835,
-0.0104739154,
-0.0314428248,
0.0196396261,
0.0600063093,
-0.0096284077,
-0.0080336304,
-0.0068365666,
-0.0104272431,
0.0614813603,
-0.0256062858,
-0.0372103192,
0.0312299877,
0.0474235713,
-0.0287973061,
0.0384841375,
-0.0382254049,
-0.0307641942,
-0.0255448241,
-0.0071818014,
-0.0419124216,
0.0401507095,
0.0232718829,
-0.005764992,
-0.0153329754,
-0.0045056236,
-0.0810036212,
-0.0340902992,
0.001672774,
0.0673028529,
0.0293005854,
-0.0174139235,
0.0046272469,
-0.0032994903,
-0.0079732062,
-0.0283334777,
0.0262385216,
-0.0026020894,
0.0229461752,
0.0309314858,
0.025188582,
0.0102858581,
-0.0002556626,
0.0995497406,
-0.0072667506,
0.0079114465,
0.0075790151,
-0.0172961075,
-0.0219160542,
0.0240485333,
0.0245671682,
0.0474823304,
-0.0195770524,
0.0196509436,
0.0158468895,
-0.0136173898,
0.0395462587,
-0.0637835637,
-0.0373412371,
0.0159359686,
0.0527301468,
0.0994805843,
-0.0380567908,
0.030261362,
-0.0455354676,
0.0172968358,
-0.0156065784,
-0.0329847559,
-0.0491997376,
-6.291785024e-33,
-0.0076375478,
0.0382623523,
0.0004004558,
0.0095320772,
-0.007467269,
0.0107563529,
-0.0489808805,
-0.0008980731,
-0.001889079,
0.0295302253,
0.015689997,
0.0558506288,
-0.0012406545,
0.0123527665,
-0.0124201681,
-0.0055228164,
0.0385503098,
0.0107796295,
-0.0071911481,
0.0477020964,
0.0496007018,
0.0365831517,
0.0636954159,
-0.0673644543,
0.0501921363,
-0.0187123399,
0.0252814125,
0.0014290456,
0.1017413586,
0.0534484461,
-0.0197655279,
0.0438866913,
0.060684856,
-0.0222168826,
-0.0087935533,
0.0704312846,
-0.0855837464,
-0.0817471892,
-0.0228631552,
-0.0502082892,
-0.0222020559,
-0.0766720399,
0.0355298333,
0.00424738,
0.0253172591,
-0.0338015631,
0.072424762,
-0.0129780369,
-0.0291167274,
-0.001572917,
-0.0259848014,
0.0280387644,
-0.0229706317,
0.0200085584,
0.0017679054,
0.0115841562,
0.0260936804,
0.043577522,
-0.0319534987,
0.0154158808,
-0.0307363886,
0.045729287,
0.0084986407,
-0.0441762358,
-0.0137189003,
0.064073585,
-0.0222053323,
-0.0053140768,
-0.0152244139,
0.0005163182,
0.029965505,
0.0326395296,
0.0348365009,
0.0176579859,
0.0235105976,
0.0043923561,
-0.0834317282,
0.0546806306,
0.0224796031,
0.0368600264,
0.0225820281,
0.0285182074,
0.0025575322,
0.003936213,
-0.0413791947,
-0.008216585,
-0.0236076452,
-0.0362123884,
0.0086368434,
0.0102383504,
0.0209406782,
0.0097761611,
0.03807595,
0.0017316565,
0.0264116619,
0.0427552722,
-0.0318532474,
0.0003300667,
0.0412919559,
0.0146512622,
-0.0739516616,
-0.0405225307,
-0.0030128174,
-0.0270665716,
0.0062165638,
0.0050955084,
0.0551976003,
-0.0225405414,
-0.0355188027,
-0.0237676017,
-0.0342478752,
-0.0761455148,
-0.0151009699,
0.0848343968,
-0.0101984823,
0.0240066648,
-0.0185509324,
0.0871419236,
0.0452720374,
0.0341019705,
-0.0156665184,
-0.0671711266,
0.006101192,
0.0351678915,
-0.0147528648,
-0.0252058525,
-0.0400417745,
0.0126831615,
0.0529314205,
-0.0543232821,
-0.0257097483,
-0.0108920271,
2.421e-7,
0.0419220552,
0.0252529085,
-0.0113181267,
-0.0191864893,
0.0008734117,
0.0272271838,
-0.0178774912,
0.0659818128,
-0.005659679,
-0.0194491763,
0.0034434835,
0.049634736,
-0.0074588563,
0.025369158,
-0.0781283081,
0.0047624013,
-0.0559059978,
-0.021371739,
-0.0193577837,
0.0140851736,
-0.0224240739,
0.0919349268,
0.0387499891,
-0.0083095981,
0.0344349965,
-0.0486724302,
0.1128452942,
-0.0672861934,
-0.0251641218,
0.0309784058,
0.0241784584,
0.003735987,
-0.0058715474,
-0.030261917,
0.0017082982,
0.0264842715,
0.0568387173,
0.0758096129,
-0.0138552375,
-0.0073055685,
-0.0185657758,
-0.0237078387,
0.0097273309,
-0.0289071202,
0.0385662727,
-0.0221487228,
-0.0218506157,
-0.0500292704,
-0.0345485769,
0.0462724268,
0.0550810844,
0.0014212974,
-0.0142879616,
-0.0177406818,
-0.002094219,
-0.0066240379,
0.0035893002,
-0.0834809467,
-0.0116362609,
0.0313155316,
-0.0492393635,
-0.0172611326,
0.0019904745,
-0.0296519939,
0.0384303182,
-0.0599365309,
0.0255886335,
1.784890482e-34,
0.0139031243,
-0.0063907234,
-0.0320462957,
-0.0309997275,
-0.0074894363,
-0.0261868518,
-0.0770181865,
-0.0120899612,
0.0110339038,
-0.0393893756,
-0.0076995566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12520v1 | Lost In Translation: Generating Adversarial Examples Robust to Round-Trip Translation | 2023-07-24T04:29:43 | 2023-07-24T04:29:43 | Neel Bhandari, Pin-Yu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language Models today provide a high accuracy across a large number of
downstream tasks. However, they remain susceptible to adversarial attacks,
particularly against those where the adversarial examples maintain considerable
similarity to the original text. Given the multilingual nature of text, the
effectiveness of adversarial examples across translations and how machine
translations can improve the robustness of adversarial examples remain largely
unexplored. In this paper, we present a comprehensive study on the robustness
of current text adversarial attacks to round-trip translation. We demonstrate
that 6 state-of-the-art text-based adversarial attacks do not maintain their
efficacy after round-trip translation. Furthermore, we introduce an
intervention-based solution to this problem, by integrating Machine Translation
into the process of adversarial example generation and demonstrating increased
robustness to round-trip translation. Our results indicate that finding
adversarial examples robust to translation can help identify the insufficiency
of language models that is common across languages, and motivate further
research into multilingual adversarial attacks. | [
0.0454224981,
0.0443796664,
-0.0332871042,
0.0752244517,
-0.056091506,
-0.0086186435,
0.0476778261,
0.001920698,
-0.0101689063,
-0.0465506539,
-0.0050429865,
-0.027609976,
0.0403869003,
-0.0048645013,
0.0808358192,
-0.0329714604,
0.0179015491,
0.0037564347,
-0.0714507252,
-0.01480457,
-0.0005892682,
0.019253565,
0.0107677327,
0.0312989727,
0.0261082221,
-0.0160969459,
0.0080201132,
0.0237875246,
0.0290606339,
-0.0035358754,
0.0382880457,
0.0231488869,
-0.004290862,
0.092268765,
0.0000017367,
-0.0012433595,
-0.0380270258,
0.0176668745,
0.0099979173,
0.033235155,
0.0657582805,
-0.070973523,
-0.0297299586,
0.0220295247,
-0.0288953651,
0.0062102792,
0.0231312234,
0.0506674014,
0.0556514114,
0.119789429,
-0.0179168601,
-0.0165048745,
-0.0014499847,
-0.0529405996,
-0.021449022,
-0.0340654291,
0.0014526612,
-0.0289890822,
-0.0618720762,
0.0203008167,
-0.0125228884,
0.0489638522,
0.0233147517,
0.0238088835,
-0.0656098649,
-0.0072409883,
-0.0494338796,
0.0095975073,
0.0247969478,
0.0751076788,
-0.0705542043,
-0.0286718402,
-0.0287953727,
0.004689449,
-0.00576668,
-0.015245961,
-0.0146345571,
-0.0037275506,
0.0271431524,
0.0176637433,
-0.0127510903,
0.0183506086,
0.0566324554,
0.0071275681,
-0.0112221008,
-0.0376441553,
0.0279815178,
-0.0306397732,
-0.0063937064,
-0.0055473479,
-0.012392248,
-0.021041235,
0.0442105159,
-0.004829498,
0.0252259057,
0.0108227953,
-0.0871955305,
-0.0583475046,
0.0391068086,
-0.0737466067,
0.0402554572,
0.0375794545,
-0.0203010589,
0.0260588359,
-0.054140579,
0.0424865521,
-0.042010475,
0.0378565043,
-0.0263733137,
-8.793e-7,
-0.0011366812,
0.0225674771,
-0.0188500527,
-0.041096095,
-0.0200311895,
0.032792341,
-0.0352376252,
0.0357949398,
-0.0066260835,
0.0590414889,
-0.0425298698,
0.0023598503,
-0.0501027592,
-0.0181474909,
0.0385819785,
-0.001733924,
-0.0245135538,
-0.0168530047,
-0.0125971874,
-0.0767006129,
-0.0490385108,
0.0262881089,
-0.044935815,
-0.0479119308,
-0.0060195052,
0.0983495489,
0.0036316775,
-0.0289463121,
-0.0231370479,
-0.0310844798,
-0.0155896069,
-0.0553272106,
0.003801534,
-0.0526952483,
0.0047820439,
-0.0070453007,
-0.0209568292,
-0.0706947595,
0.0207359176,
0.0211621337,
-0.0321644731,
0.0875732303,
0.0524653867,
-0.045461785,
0.0255563445,
0.02042423,
-0.0029331306,
0.0647281632,
0.0101383077,
0.0393213704,
0.0511961728,
0.0162120536,
0.0050407778,
0.0591830462,
0.0554428138,
0.0406729802,
-0.0164264943,
0.0030758458,
0.0374030247,
0.023149034,
-0.0268040653,
0.0401635207,
0.0007041065,
-0.0492672324,
0.0850784034,
-0.0097157527,
-0.049590297,
0.0650473163,
0.0243956242,
-0.0203719046,
-0.0305562355,
0.0313831419,
-0.0687407777,
-0.006679974,
-0.0569163822,
-0.0309060737,
0.0085652936,
0.0544417873,
-0.0244425107,
-0.0307827368,
0.0046198978,
0.0015110665,
0.0345288068,
-0.0247455817,
0.0315014087,
0.0721023381,
-0.0410458297,
-0.003414162,
-0.0091905156,
-0.028475631,
-0.0130205769,
-0.0382268578,
-0.0467241518,
0.0165119078,
0.0805102512,
-0.0244828407,
0.0148351574,
-0.0213714112,
0.0217563976,
0.038702026,
0.0689918846,
0.0134542985,
0.0281631518,
-0.0316502675,
0.0044237864,
-0.0420692191,
0.0106143374,
0.0293717515,
0.0390504897,
0.0625410676,
0.0145570124,
-0.0515323021,
-0.0322764032,
0.0399881974,
-0.0007478379,
-0.0528607145,
0.0469286963,
0.0378798805,
0.0060026543,
-0.0046919198,
-0.020105442,
-0.0003256036,
0.0502058677,
-0.0247464627,
-0.0151217654,
0.0263195485,
0.0108720995,
-0.0821025223,
-0.0142825274,
-0.0359569825,
-0.0298303589,
0.0340963975,
-0.0674246326,
0.0244825836,
0.0406853296,
-0.005286227,
0.0165613443,
-0.007095702,
0.0186241418,
-0.0057195076,
0.0536713041,
-0.0168345794,
0.0360054709,
-0.0161944926,
0.0057918173,
-0.0327354223,
0.0014615675,
0.010706109,
-0.008961645,
-0.0376492254,
0.0587077215,
-0.0272695981,
0.0041906754,
0.0101710651,
0.002437447,
0.0207456332,
-0.0236482024,
-0.0122325616,
-0.012553433,
-0.0484622382,
0.0237754975,
0.0384736247,
0.0086044222,
-0.0000281291,
-0.0070095435,
-0.0280668791,
-0.0046852203,
-0.016926486,
0.028308304,
0.0184375364,
-0.006754973,
-0.0081845196,
-0.0048653525,
0.0014432907,
-0.0068123359,
0.0819257647,
-0.0120990006,
-0.0145784197,
-0.0418985523,
-0.0016716082,
-0.0143262688,
0.033034049,
-0.0350275487,
-0.0644681603,
0.0132745802,
0.0365804918,
0.0362999216,
0.0698595122,
0.0060823984,
0.021851249,
0.0325509943,
0.0358557999,
-0.0291143078,
-0.0068942225,
0.0039247018,
-0.0129580656,
-0.0310339909,
-0.0391158499,
0.0206499733,
0.016880665,
0.0330748484,
0.0042261323,
-0.0159644503,
0.0418341719,
-0.0030625418,
-0.0495329723,
-0.024704773,
0.0180729218,
-0.001753295,
-0.0161707681,
-0.0275960527,
-0.0269071013,
0.0765522271,
-0.0150087969,
0.0079270341,
-0.0305951256,
-0.0271743219,
0.0282049421,
0.0647924617,
-0.0042371578,
0.0387482233,
-0.0162760206,
0.0329484455,
-0.0319576636,
-0.0259035993,
0.0511558354,
-0.0138969785,
0.0260244589,
-0.0401470028,
-0.0383428968,
-0.0124826329,
-0.0276414771,
-0.062632665,
-0.0457722507,
0.0235332493,
-0.0008330054,
0.0050272844,
-0.0213249195,
-0.0737873018,
-0.0272864085,
0.0203383993,
0.0342069156,
-0.0251229201,
0.0006744604,
-0.0060656513,
0.0290437825,
0.0180252306,
-0.0480850451,
0.0343925171,
-0.0410643555,
0.0345460474,
0.0718815997,
-0.0046525844,
-0.0024961606,
-0.0072478475,
-0.021575287,
-0.0041574463,
-0.0060420539,
-0.019761676,
-0.017499527,
0.0359610505,
-0.0579464957,
-0.0142733175,
0.0282622371,
0.0128381923,
-0.0091605643,
0.0253021121,
-0.0097579919,
0.0222053658,
-0.0019166004,
0.0112045733,
-0.0655708387,
-0.0082156211,
0.011624529,
0.0250882767,
-0.0039235204,
0.0314475708,
-0.0464568511,
-0.0794127807,
-0.0013323929,
0.0309463162,
-0.0671110377,
-0.0483380035,
0.0035814226,
-0.02563072,
-0.0160376281,
0.0195934437,
-0.0181719232,
0.0455876254,
-0.0137305567,
-0.0278881136,
0.0079840748,
-0.051877182,
0.0005443949,
-0.0384183526,
0.009881014,
0.0610694326,
0.0418818332,
0.0043627056,
-0.0187016726,
0.030802425,
-0.0206623189,
-0.0297084637,
0.0137554072,
0.0639389604,
0.0090129906,
-0.0156688802,
0.042408932,
0.0403031893,
-0.0135319363,
-0.0090766139,
0.035235934,
0.0453361049,
-0.0044147926,
-0.005604201,
-0.0065035215,
-0.000959553,
0.0312035289,
0.0583785065,
-0.0055019762,
-0.0586001799,
-0.0359557495,
-0.073630549,
0.0078389393,
-0.0873944312,
-0.0544452891,
0.0004610897,
-0.0032731069,
-0.0169677902,
-0.0868137404,
-0.0515199825,
-0.0379507691,
0.0387364961,
0.0078047737,
-0.0082745496,
-0.0497732386,
-0.0196027998,
-0.0034384516,
-0.025006026,
-0.0131535167,
0.0542131364,
0.0042466074,
0.0202084593,
0.0020214084,
-0.044425074,
0.0031962448,
0.0212087035,
-0.0906899795,
-0.0879762098,
0.0045767371,
0.0393404849,
0.0135467593,
0.0527341105,
-0.0514059439,
-0.0378365628,
0.0542533807,
0.035996303,
0.0196668133,
-0.0142242983,
0.0906196758,
-0.005151175,
0.0379024483,
0.0811543614,
-0.030377524,
0.0067455624,
0.0481197238,
-0.0093004284,
-0.043526724,
0.0054964875,
0.0075026085,
-0.0112437597,
0.031300731,
-0.0149288801,
-0.0146815619,
0.0226619411,
0.0631531999,
-0.0263183378,
-0.0394264832,
-0.020099543,
0.0093896519,
0.0158362016,
-0.0090872152,
0.0084775183,
0.0145352203,
-0.0159195606,
0.0072525111,
-0.0083025368,
-0.0116378441,
-0.0084122876,
0.0588863231,
-0.0057043657,
0.0491762869,
-0.0151499221,
0.0421040207,
-0.0126355896,
0.0257921945,
-0.0324461013,
0.0398418866,
0.0181245878,
-0.002650345,
-0.0052577336,
0.002487299,
-0.0506748594,
0.0348790102,
-0.0463295653,
-0.0070417556,
0.0490634777,
-0.0062401481,
0.0424175225,
-0.0111104082,
-0.0303356629,
0.0032654568,
0.0084918691,
0.0043907273,
-0.0239749327,
-0.0185442865,
-0.0167961475,
-0.0029426639,
0.0280583072,
0.0547955073,
-0.0319704786,
0.0488991961,
0.0491500497,
-0.032496877,
-0.0422892869,
-0.0302141979,
0.0208228175,
-0.0573358759,
-0.0031466756,
-0.0200017169,
-0.0388371423,
-0.0712739825,
-0.0255937874,
0.0113905165,
0.0195529591,
0.010095641,
-0.0305130519,
0.076038532,
0.0069510229,
0.0471223593,
-0.060042128,
0.0455420464,
0.0101389699,
-0.059077587,
-0.0172957983,
-5.722947144e-33,
0.015347234,
-0.0110118277,
-0.0250984188,
-0.0405795127,
0.0261493735,
-0.0279448964,
-0.0386231467,
-0.0138209956,
-0.035327822,
0.0184408482,
0.0184713379,
-0.0142069142,
-0.0107688885,
0.0140237128,
-0.0391976833,
-0.0056674634,
0.0645597875,
0.0102000358,
-0.0582990795,
0.0105375443,
0.0483688749,
0.0007339162,
0.0840439126,
-0.0502246432,
0.0609787442,
-0.0203213822,
-0.065501146,
-0.0076417262,
-0.0381475165,
0.0330956317,
0.0068962094,
0.0256353747,
0.0042039724,
0.0109774433,
-0.032659933,
-0.017145576,
-0.017433947,
-0.0047261878,
-0.0029896761,
0.0472936518,
-0.0325615257,
-0.0356976055,
0.0339995846,
-0.0421350002,
-0.0086744064,
0.0002848911,
-0.0010286733,
-0.0206412766,
-0.018678315,
0.0095538571,
-0.0492574684,
0.0162845738,
-0.0064658332,
-0.0242109578,
-0.0094001368,
0.076681979,
0.0497177765,
0.0078345118,
-0.0966742784,
0.0059411977,
-0.0228732359,
0.0168834385,
0.056598831,
-0.0536895208,
0.0016988363,
0.0454928689,
0.0157265253,
0.025693683,
-0.005995126,
-0.0139961587,
0.0371365733,
0.0072779255,
0.0966799483,
0.1233635172,
0.0619672686,
-0.049142547,
-0.0621721558,
0.014700097,
-0.0205608308,
-0.0119093917,
0.0295285229,
0.0022467379,
-0.0523253493,
0.0234100167,
-0.0229975712,
-0.0953537151,
-0.0327862315,
-0.0373407863,
-0.0006657165,
0.0081346277,
-0.0317915417,
0.0181419309,
0.0187415481,
-0.0431823134,
0.0102505833,
0.0247389078,
-0.0646663234,
-0.0396169387,
0.025947554,
0.0415217802,
0.0020388577,
-0.0157210678,
0.0137230605,
-0.0191990249,
0.0133626927,
-0.0185810011,
0.1035473198,
0.0200012997,
-0.0654162467,
0.0096389716,
-0.0305026062,
0.0451937802,
0.0211394541,
0.007507435,
0.0096171284,
-0.0173438694,
-0.0253423527,
0.0121322069,
0.0456597917,
-0.0287428387,
-0.032945279,
0.0273325425,
-0.0292529631,
0.0369135588,
-0.0431486815,
-0.0220623948,
0.0019526178,
0.0398225524,
0.0655504167,
-0.0903485417,
-0.0166372154,
-0.0277391616,
2.413e-7,
0.0360384509,
0.050463751,
-0.0048285103,
0.0103447251,
0.0316852778,
0.039318122,
-0.0266960803,
0.0609605573,
-0.0361709893,
0.0244157054,
-0.0190551113,
0.0125273522,
0.0719316527,
0.0542379953,
-0.0236214716,
0.0232454315,
-0.0734743327,
0.032814268,
-0.0428869836,
-0.0223475304,
0.0340228304,
0.1239459887,
0.0397291631,
-0.0006565567,
-0.0111192288,
-0.0497788191,
0.0604691356,
-0.0104385456,
-0.0252108481,
-0.0335571356,
0.0006045752,
0.0267012436,
0.0111448867,
-0.0128835039,
-0.0428941101,
-0.0086207855,
0.0143407537,
0.0317519382,
0.0107627232,
-0.0105470419,
-0.0206931159,
-0.0334106237,
-0.0147893103,
-0.0447256342,
0.0655969605,
-0.0320186652,
-0.0013629555,
0.0069024297,
-0.0084433137,
0.0158970822,
0.0799539983,
-0.0280796438,
-0.0397504754,
0.0265909322,
0.0341414362,
0.0361987762,
0.0101456428,
-0.0550528429,
-0.0290105715,
-0.0187211893,
-0.0109380651,
0.0052051628,
-0.0048408192,
0.0069776922,
0.0215406921,
0.0026337588,
0.0018771702,
2.057864951e-34,
0.037252035,
-0.0247586481,
-0.0129468516,
-0.0225054454,
0.0300813559,
-0.0258002356,
0.065257147,
-0.0246949419,
0.0047789491,
0.0070628249,
-0.0322936811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12507v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12507v2 | Gradient-Based Word Substitution for Obstinate Adversarial Examples Generation in Language Models | 2023-07-24T03:44:17 | 2023-08-18T03:07:02 | Yimu Wang, Peng Shi, Hongyang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.CY | In this paper, we study the problem of generating obstinate (over-stability)
adversarial examples by word substitution in NLP, where input text is
meaningfully changed but the model's prediction does not, even though it
should. Previous word substitution approaches have predominantly focused on
manually designed antonym-based strategies for generating obstinate adversarial
examples, which hinders its application as these strategies can only find a
subset of obstinate adversarial examples and require human efforts. To address
this issue, in this paper, we introduce a novel word substitution method named
GradObstinate, a gradient-based approach that automatically generates obstinate
adversarial examples without any constraints on the search space or the need
for manual design principles. To empirically evaluate the efficacy of
GradObstinate, we conduct comprehensive experiments on five representative
models (Electra, ALBERT, Roberta, DistillBERT, and CLIP) finetuned on four NLP
benchmarks (SST-2, MRPC, SNLI, and SQuAD) and a language-grounding benchmark
(MSCOCO). Extensive experiments show that our proposed GradObstinate generates
more powerful obstinate adversarial examples, exhibiting a higher attack
success rate compared to antonym-based methods. Furthermore, to show the
transferability of obstinate word substitutions found by GradObstinate, we
replace the words in four representative NLP benchmarks with their obstinate
substitutions. Notably, obstinate substitutions exhibit a high success rate
when transferred to other models in black-box settings, including even GPT-3
and ChatGPT. Examples of obstinate adversarial examples found by GradObstinate
are available at https://huggingface.co/spaces/anonauthors/SecretLanguage. | [
0.0433877073,
0.0918346643,
-0.0197046772,
0.0334664248,
-0.0638035387,
-0.0239544045,
-0.0199036524,
0.0063134241,
-0.0306500141,
-0.0442712866,
0.0024235151,
0.0056769834,
0.0070574321,
-0.0189383533,
0.0412178636,
-0.0339970998,
0.0622297786,
0.0105751036,
-0.0412291847,
-0.0033877776,
-0.0152721023,
-0.0089617865,
0.0219636224,
0.0208076239,
0.0466490202,
-0.0108450036,
-0.0021604951,
0.0057900553,
-0.0019640948,
-0.0217551757,
0.0551291853,
0.0471675582,
-0.0254600849,
0.0734480172,
0.0000021779,
-0.0149560533,
-0.0569473803,
0.0313952044,
-0.0295135248,
0.0252125598,
0.039406307,
-0.0424696915,
-0.0315893851,
0.0178726949,
-0.0536929555,
0.0164635647,
0.0427582003,
0.0524334274,
0.054400418,
0.1033843458,
-0.0211966336,
-0.0137986504,
0.0164883099,
-0.0419178754,
0.0131023284,
-0.0472576171,
0.0323784426,
-0.044586163,
-0.0298310183,
0.0292165652,
-0.0381487943,
0.022047624,
0.0211972427,
0.029928565,
-0.0149571272,
0.0130236279,
-0.0476668924,
-0.0141047696,
-0.0022462616,
0.0746329725,
-0.0751534328,
-0.0280908495,
-0.0026093763,
0.0059869527,
0.0126896081,
0.0076962216,
-0.025049109,
-0.0242527816,
0.0178091377,
0.0243885498,
0.0147989076,
-0.0285086855,
0.0471637063,
0.0146391066,
0.0022363635,
0.0123382295,
0.0479342155,
-0.0387069769,
0.0204953682,
-0.0309056789,
-0.0509819016,
-0.0502884015,
0.0085226595,
-0.007595697,
-0.0133281006,
0.038285628,
-0.1106640026,
-0.057957001,
0.0247397516,
-0.0290083122,
0.0911933556,
0.037701562,
-0.0111623518,
0.0341869593,
-0.0701539367,
0.0195325632,
-0.0318508819,
0.0281060133,
-0.0182577688,
0.0156296343,
-0.014906032,
-0.0018813929,
-0.0491884202,
-0.0094161704,
-0.0189066194,
-0.0307116192,
-0.0231387969,
0.0119781587,
-0.0426634289,
0.0067317071,
-0.0470448658,
0.0301635172,
-0.0162948053,
0.0050106701,
0.0076889587,
-0.0422789603,
-0.0178185254,
-0.0129614808,
-0.0040766061,
-0.0629871711,
-0.0452032425,
0.0281339306,
-0.0607044213,
-0.0360522643,
0.0023658073,
0.1056732684,
-0.0077622337,
-0.048487585,
-0.0444770381,
0.0006700314,
-0.0101268254,
-0.0425230935,
-0.007957832,
-0.0471052714,
-0.0160219371,
-0.0123046692,
-0.0240170676,
-0.1162246168,
0.0251484904,
0.0309537984,
-0.0227321945,
0.1149249598,
-0.01555348,
-0.0315081626,
0.0042823264,
0.0169040151,
-0.0213891678,
0.0666203573,
-0.0154515188,
0.0287925489,
0.0474660061,
0.0144261848,
0.0226304028,
0.0266157687,
0.0710764155,
0.0183546003,
-0.0359041654,
0.0018812281,
0.0118463505,
0.0254411101,
0.0138489082,
0.077686429,
-0.0232943501,
-0.0827991143,
0.0731494352,
-0.0129258735,
-0.0625528097,
0.0590867773,
0.0336808152,
-0.0312184393,
-0.0305125341,
0.0211532712,
-0.04773793,
0.0002941728,
-0.0521282144,
-0.0150374528,
0.0067056539,
0.0287395529,
0.0004356173,
-0.0347543322,
-0.0387106054,
0.0170297772,
0.0397064015,
-0.0177845396,
0.0293240286,
0.0711746514,
-0.0872551426,
0.0426557325,
-0.0057287556,
-0.0305496827,
-0.0271607134,
-0.0791214854,
-0.0331064537,
0.0218885783,
0.0891243666,
-0.0070714913,
-0.0206074584,
-0.009979683,
-0.0017063479,
0.0137657616,
0.0802031308,
0.0042841248,
-0.0104191285,
-0.0597393215,
0.0007277226,
-0.04588129,
0.0406527631,
0.0457608663,
0.0811013803,
0.0275512896,
0.0361725464,
-0.0607918799,
-0.036349453,
0.053321559,
-0.0413868129,
-0.0497511439,
0.0255401898,
0.0010304225,
0.0196151678,
-0.0193821583,
-0.0105699152,
0.0079312865,
0.0242464673,
-0.0015129929,
-0.0327971317,
-0.0033602235,
-0.0147419767,
-0.011112731,
0.0095843626,
-0.0103102811,
-0.0015135059,
0.0581327602,
-0.0201897696,
-0.0087271184,
0.0436889902,
-0.0275952388,
0.0701321587,
-0.0223101862,
0.0323231816,
0.0126800369,
0.0635978281,
-0.037401326,
0.0435135104,
-0.0268625543,
0.0052271849,
0.0213817637,
0.0277303979,
0.0114747677,
-0.0147891724,
-0.0401918478,
0.0145078087,
-0.0318465307,
0.0137128076,
-0.0113229463,
-0.0191112924,
-0.0140609266,
-0.0454975069,
-0.0141616492,
0.0081977202,
-0.0252039339,
-0.0060212472,
0.0424241722,
-0.0013460428,
-0.0003220547,
0.0093639484,
0.0155878132,
0.0197969507,
-0.0297007654,
0.0401015878,
0.0152238933,
0.0023234726,
-0.0325497016,
-0.0169095881,
0.0066093304,
0.0153858811,
0.0512513891,
-0.0618334785,
0.0247138813,
-0.0345966481,
0.0063923933,
0.0017428416,
0.0587826855,
-0.0347840264,
-0.0465753339,
0.0254315361,
0.0353730842,
0.0463985428,
0.0677028373,
0.0076600094,
0.067961745,
0.0431051217,
0.0057934783,
-0.0130794933,
-0.013190303,
0.001610829,
-0.015560885,
-0.004050727,
-0.0189604107,
0.0079504261,
0.0299750995,
0.0268729944,
-0.02997908,
-0.0213288832,
0.0642201528,
-0.018075563,
-0.0343231931,
-0.0053397864,
-0.002389791,
-0.0421841331,
-0.0195147544,
-0.0287764501,
-0.0481841713,
0.0511627421,
-0.0111793922,
0.012255433,
-0.0409169495,
-0.0347285531,
0.0119140325,
0.0394156203,
-0.0214660317,
0.0099420734,
0.0423836149,
0.0330677442,
-0.0390086733,
-0.0411262847,
0.0403438918,
-0.0114231538,
0.0041439529,
-0.0162980743,
-0.0125609105,
0.0224362742,
-0.0171524901,
-0.0788772106,
-0.0722766146,
0.0361499414,
0.0029862034,
0.0609853528,
-0.030779643,
-0.0351085588,
-0.0090471115,
-0.0300629344,
0.0308789946,
-0.0285480693,
-0.0034862857,
-0.0067516118,
-0.0083829444,
0.0656738952,
0.0014315847,
0.0394398086,
-0.0086497534,
0.0279865339,
0.0889233202,
0.0009256451,
-0.0188027043,
-0.0359336101,
-0.0012334007,
-0.004830942,
-0.0138296047,
-0.0036477798,
-0.0063778213,
0.024736844,
-0.0310569238,
-0.0259519964,
0.0497718379,
0.016927924,
0.0291190669,
0.0365264639,
-0.0026751475,
0.0644678771,
0.0204144381,
0.0204778332,
-0.0628510043,
-0.0138792563,
0.039817322,
0.050921414,
-0.0205763653,
-0.021075502,
-0.0543174483,
-0.1078631803,
-0.0007487906,
0.0022238181,
-0.0434195846,
0.0088044219,
0.008672188,
0.0093608312,
-0.0278900582,
0.004906395,
0.0008803154,
0.0124157807,
0.0204911064,
-0.0383931249,
-0.0027434309,
-0.0532517955,
0.0196591783,
-0.0197045486,
0.0387659073,
0.0699023828,
0.0255846642,
0.0072670658,
-0.0241413973,
0.0748897344,
-0.0404955111,
-0.0180031825,
-0.0116185704,
0.0810976028,
0.0068664337,
-0.0308421552,
0.0318838768,
0.0590064824,
-0.0056276214,
-0.0306833386,
-0.0013646012,
0.0325362459,
0.0177794192,
-0.0420998186,
-0.0299915131,
-0.0117242113,
0.0745905489,
0.0908269957,
0.0089781824,
-0.0426460356,
-0.0368346423,
-0.0376803465,
0.0031676225,
-0.0608379804,
-0.0075803995,
-0.0106208324,
0.0151442206,
-0.0148736406,
-0.0686706454,
-0.0168957114,
0.0052301153,
0.0432353057,
0.018267449,
0.0152301211,
-0.0622010455,
-0.0022024091,
-0.0299979001,
-0.0252093803,
0.0217804294,
0.0306178126,
-0.013734322,
-0.0221983064,
0.0148776453,
0.003026254,
-0.018438315,
0.0183115304,
-0.0427685492,
-0.1004554704,
0.0412464887,
0.0404808633,
0.0192546453,
0.0334657915,
-0.0292746034,
-0.0244239587,
0.0399141721,
0.0654136017,
0.0338171497,
0.0224189255,
0.0914669931,
-0.0404339731,
0.0293054096,
0.0562558621,
0.0070116431,
0.0076156752,
0.0450775139,
0.0146555239,
-0.0225224197,
0.0587476268,
0.040125072,
-0.0128188832,
0.0400476009,
-0.0303575918,
-0.0004017143,
0.0142404446,
0.0188741907,
-0.014211583,
-0.0101976022,
-0.0286561772,
0.0148464916,
0.033959873,
-0.0092126122,
-0.014819988,
-0.0052007479,
-0.0182740949,
0.0189651363,
-0.0093593448,
-0.0158535931,
0.0264004208,
0.0080339937,
0.0256905053,
0.0362690538,
-0.0000267165,
0.0321974121,
-0.0146826897,
0.0208041891,
-0.0322266109,
0.0134807313,
0.0419795886,
0.0214479677,
-0.0107890638,
0.0203329045,
-0.0475121588,
0.002948863,
-0.0358776748,
0.0349125825,
0.0327269696,
-0.0128561147,
0.0216814503,
-0.0380513743,
-0.0454790518,
0.0102798035,
-0.0177019406,
-0.026965769,
-0.0232776199,
0.0048798597,
0.0049690865,
-0.0134302042,
0.0329931937,
0.0354081132,
0.0238218978,
0.0777970627,
0.0253946967,
0.00351125,
-0.0487296097,
-0.020844169,
0.0420038365,
0.0032678733,
0.0170751177,
0.002906732,
-0.0343537182,
-0.086534597,
-0.042486418,
0.0042750947,
0.0046552378,
0.0154328346,
-0.0126422355,
0.0819536671,
-0.0257902741,
0.0452113897,
-0.051645413,
0.0151379565,
0.0121028302,
-0.0614666343,
0.0011252457,
-6.609515269e-33,
0.0040162657,
-0.0327936709,
-0.0067553897,
-0.066906549,
-0.0079286098,
-0.0259781964,
-0.0186967012,
-0.0087967673,
-0.0272526518,
0.0091072172,
-0.0227705278,
-0.0032723972,
-0.007780503,
0.0045550363,
-0.0339179859,
-0.0164729487,
0.053078495,
0.0307574701,
-0.0226801708,
-0.0293081198,
0.04382037,
0.0371093005,
0.0460867509,
-0.0845091119,
0.0490842797,
0.0130676059,
-0.0582526736,
-0.0321159735,
-0.0292694904,
0.0411191881,
0.0080630789,
0.0253127441,
-0.0156915355,
-0.0012341941,
-0.0354660265,
-0.0227584187,
-0.0348431878,
-0.0297628902,
0.0212445203,
0.000428714,
-0.0378143005,
-0.0194196794,
0.0692073703,
-0.041115094,
-0.0310949106,
0.0270495079,
-0.0205074809,
-0.0207803044,
-0.0291281752,
0.0329759941,
-0.087272957,
0.0246090163,
0.030667875,
-0.0475888439,
-0.0136086848,
-0.014281624,
0.0274303406,
-0.0311854351,
-0.049047444,
-0.0128875813,
0.0088984529,
0.0108586112,
0.0212590937,
-0.0090330169,
0.0103994701,
0.0530933775,
-0.0039866953,
0.030461723,
0.0494080968,
-0.0344006605,
0.0255329572,
0.0502647534,
0.0860803723,
0.0441117696,
0.0961342007,
-0.0607422143,
-0.0166497473,
-0.0093943644,
-0.0013737923,
-0.0021576397,
0.0573596135,
0.0301605165,
-0.0340229981,
-0.0051911469,
-0.0023275178,
-0.0866148174,
-0.0281411521,
-0.0539954789,
0.0449871235,
0.021231221,
-0.0401466824,
-0.0138300955,
-0.0295655522,
-0.0342341848,
-0.004112598,
0.0536126643,
-0.0533874072,
-0.0347575471,
0.0095829228,
0.0085803326,
-0.0027515297,
-0.0251846388,
0.0039244019,
0.00904248,
0.0140805561,
0.0004494893,
0.0451916978,
0.031971965,
-0.0710515752,
-0.0040802066,
-0.0122446967,
0.0597720668,
0.0080390722,
-0.0164322127,
0.0231975857,
0.001966577,
-0.0242670514,
0.0038822859,
0.0589848608,
-0.0230624359,
-0.054615736,
0.0206831042,
0.0048990073,
0.0279868934,
-0.0081247445,
-0.0115546016,
0.009740917,
-0.0013211007,
0.0129470695,
-0.1082188711,
-0.009719939,
-0.0284297373,
2.953e-7,
0.0180865843,
0.0599461719,
-0.0202033501,
0.0129803196,
0.0124311699,
0.0162878893,
-0.0023263174,
0.0242150873,
-0.0524533316,
-0.0217323396,
-0.0201167315,
0.0049627353,
0.0269696154,
0.0304228477,
-0.050585486,
0.0378846191,
-0.0746738538,
0.0132360775,
-0.0424008667,
-0.0104318596,
0.049379956,
0.0962353423,
0.0576286316,
-0.0096421214,
-0.0190437492,
-0.0403817333,
0.0303062201,
-0.0205420144,
0.0217304546,
-0.0069179768,
0.0398019776,
0.0259599239,
0.0019104888,
-0.0266650021,
-0.0457447432,
-0.0057683466,
0.0222213231,
0.0400535502,
0.0003662059,
-0.0295777712,
-0.0276325345,
-0.0353146009,
-0.0228027068,
-0.061390236,
0.0866310224,
-0.0366556458,
-0.008174195,
-0.0643360391,
-0.0343296528,
-0.0038611349,
0.0545023344,
-0.0388397872,
-0.023358712,
0.0041979314,
0.0032669783,
0.0453934856,
-0.0288558919,
-0.0666630417,
0.0129860528,
0.0023756088,
-0.019262705,
-0.0130137559,
-0.0293004494,
0.0369263999,
0.038858261,
0.0179822743,
-0.0225799307,
2.902602512e-34,
0.0435505621,
-0.0229219031,
0.0148952398,
0.0016615487,
0.016069565,
0.001655031,
0.0382538401,
0.0209858641,
0.0153398123,
-0.0314985067,
-0.0203505624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12498v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12498v1 | Robust Automatic Speech Recognition via WavAugment Guided Phoneme Adversarial Training | 2023-07-24T03:07:40 | 2023-07-24T03:07:40 | Gege Qi, Yuefeng Chen, Xiaofeng Mao, Xiaojun Jia, Ranjie Duan, Rong Zhang, Hui Xue | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Developing a practically-robust automatic speech recognition (ASR) is
challenging since the model should not only maintain the original performance
on clean samples, but also achieve consistent efficacy under small volume
perturbations and large domain shifts. To address this problem, we propose a
novel WavAugment Guided Phoneme Adversarial Training (wapat). wapat use
adversarial examples in phoneme space as augmentation to make the model
invariant to minor fluctuations in phoneme representation and preserve the
performance on clean samples. In addition, wapat utilizes the phoneme
representation of augmented samples to guide the generation of adversaries,
which helps to find more stable and diverse gradient-directions, resulting in
improved generalization. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of
wapat on End-to-end Speech Challenge Benchmark (ESB). Notably, SpeechLM-wapat
outperforms the original model by 6.28% WER reduction on ESB, achieving the new
state-of-the-art. | [
-0.0050787418,
0.1005382463,
0.0001240496,
0.0156529248,
0.0230838414,
-0.0215227399,
0.0392682068,
-0.0140085425,
0.0069261589,
0.0058291396,
-0.0476793163,
-0.062861912,
-0.0004668127,
-0.0038019386,
0.0680650771,
-0.068237029,
0.0247154348,
-0.040712174,
-0.0264155548,
-0.0256068334,
0.0367684625,
-0.0205507185,
-0.0470065475,
0.0185208619,
-0.022571139,
0.0232616533,
-0.0003554395,
0.0302827507,
0.0358434469,
-0.0099508464,
0.030760223,
0.0049642543,
0.0230138227,
0.0374185294,
0.0000021871,
-0.028341271,
-0.0127949519,
0.0235238001,
-0.0375659317,
0.0230475795,
-0.0019418671,
0.0046904543,
-0.044734098,
0.048241239,
-0.0026922564,
-0.0125915976,
0.060777165,
0.0231505577,
0.0500789657,
0.0686705112,
-0.0013749895,
-0.0484571047,
0.0331263058,
-0.0279030073,
-0.0393691175,
-0.0702906176,
-0.0283775982,
-0.0133985868,
-0.0107098203,
-0.0444882587,
-0.0102570374,
0.0359566621,
0.0255365763,
0.008338606,
-0.012845871,
0.0214638058,
-0.0397962369,
-0.0197919104,
0.0045716353,
0.0731730536,
-0.0282496419,
-0.0039746584,
-0.0190298129,
-0.0082571888,
-0.0157852098,
-0.0506291203,
-0.0214854442,
-0.0106664896,
0.0090927519,
0.0062378799,
-0.0526566207,
0.0409096293,
0.0582055673,
-0.0171899907,
-0.0229674783,
-0.0084124021,
0.0123409871,
-0.0234138425,
-0.0038471357,
-0.0298468769,
-0.0703006685,
0.0195476152,
0.0516986363,
-0.0091347201,
-0.0421810858,
0.0052809091,
-0.0295404643,
-0.0527933463,
0.0006379348,
-0.0432626903,
0.0396612398,
0.0423291028,
-0.0822233707,
0.0105236778,
-0.0326420777,
0.0722261444,
-0.0141598415,
0.0017519259,
-0.0094039971,
-0.014026477,
-0.0144085707,
0.0170669071,
-0.0585336275,
0.0034463571,
-0.0440748036,
-0.0006459214,
-0.024306979,
-0.0017008793,
-0.0178678446,
-0.0041961712,
0.0241743643,
0.0394303724,
-0.0403049402,
-0.0101951454,
0.0668272749,
0.0150667056,
-0.0167241246,
0.0267263912,
-0.0135206962,
-0.0755600259,
-0.0336518809,
0.0204824358,
0.0106532685,
-0.0288097188,
0.0169352107,
0.1401975602,
0.0040941471,
-0.0420409665,
-0.081528686,
0.0403626785,
-0.0174495112,
-0.0445989482,
0.0228018072,
-0.000045261,
0.0144258225,
-0.0324050076,
0.0204902906,
-0.0648925751,
0.0041509285,
-0.0332474858,
0.0227051508,
0.0835489184,
-0.000604722,
-0.046427995,
0.0614162013,
0.0024433413,
-0.0243071578,
0.0581020899,
0.0395377502,
0.0004800431,
0.0012943195,
-0.0261385646,
-0.0152335567,
0.0636192262,
0.0510009639,
-0.0030785962,
-0.0100503452,
0.0083226636,
0.0073778667,
0.0308309197,
0.0260332339,
0.0566507429,
-0.0365154669,
-0.054478541,
0.0603700094,
-0.0011087629,
0.007419365,
0.044223737,
-0.0241673421,
-0.0341975167,
0.0189213809,
-0.0076180482,
-0.0450858623,
-0.0010244244,
-0.0490817577,
0.0066005057,
0.0434289612,
0.0460411459,
-0.031494692,
-0.0288639069,
-0.022446746,
-0.0320810266,
0.0215973388,
0.0050702016,
0.0275898371,
0.022230925,
-0.0300126895,
-0.0024199712,
0.0207188111,
-0.0414877087,
0.0035302758,
-0.0208993722,
-0.0002272289,
0.0187913645,
0.016993396,
-0.0425350368,
-0.0092323702,
-0.0486867875,
0.0072695101,
0.0338369198,
0.0280296542,
0.0275054872,
0.1109216511,
-0.0678381175,
-0.020749731,
0.0344806947,
-0.0051341807,
0.0810074508,
0.0248644128,
-0.0032406864,
0.0072259814,
-0.0607367493,
0.0060068942,
-0.0079497192,
-0.0264339279,
-0.0644677579,
0.0490769595,
0.0001498968,
0.0687167421,
0.0080669988,
-0.0384624116,
-0.0108123869,
0.0061346749,
-0.0564142466,
0.0125065101,
0.0179764852,
-0.065034993,
0.019553775,
0.0574722476,
0.0002288533,
0.0181029737,
0.0633796528,
0.0012622888,
-0.0619753785,
0.0661278963,
-0.0093698902,
0.0230090227,
-0.0386461839,
0.0182005446,
0.0525350012,
0.0437263474,
-0.0011031182,
0.004684323,
0.0253782552,
-0.0214558151,
-0.0041962913,
0.0824297741,
0.0076896758,
-0.0055445889,
-0.0383710042,
0.0352625959,
0.0031724891,
0.0526009202,
-0.0002115629,
-0.0482701175,
-0.016410578,
0.0098707471,
-0.0450866632,
-0.0131185744,
-0.0507667735,
0.0231075976,
-0.0164349508,
0.0454735383,
-0.0090908194,
-0.0540944785,
-0.0071965288,
-0.0150056584,
-0.0356491543,
-0.0089603439,
-0.0486339107,
0.0083199963,
0.0233035497,
-0.0375835784,
0.0112466794,
0.0566608422,
-0.0117190629,
-0.0105423676,
-0.0111201163,
-0.0281052757,
-0.0480950922,
0.0398347713,
0.0517673455,
-0.0218968056,
-0.0425594039,
-0.032677941,
0.0528090373,
0.0331736356,
0.0349860974,
0.0140370931,
-0.009545736,
-0.0008115457,
0.0356499366,
-0.0297785643,
0.0059217112,
0.0180377886,
0.0069438149,
-0.0010825144,
0.01883859,
-0.0320894159,
0.0042121746,
0.0129927332,
0.0437216833,
-0.0292207096,
-0.0266661234,
-0.0018111432,
-0.0437052064,
-0.0031227672,
-0.013450264,
-0.0641483143,
-0.0387085564,
-0.0238856599,
-0.0409238301,
0.0343474858,
-0.0812272429,
-0.0466902331,
-0.0761178732,
-0.069519408,
0.035761442,
0.015638493,
-0.0065993275,
0.0021835158,
-0.0132417465,
-0.027574664,
-0.0343424529,
-0.0172636602,
0.0105320252,
-0.0282576159,
-0.0021594667,
-0.0008683522,
0.0048297425,
-0.0185406264,
-0.0429822505,
-0.0646227673,
0.0112332646,
-0.0234654211,
0.0413901508,
0.0023645801,
-0.0430889875,
-0.0276191141,
0.0177394226,
0.0062469286,
0.060518939,
-0.0224463399,
0.0259542186,
-0.0117649408,
0.0513498522,
0.0317117386,
0.0502814949,
-0.0009647824,
-0.0083500994,
-0.0061445581,
0.0068865004,
0.0299988724,
-0.0144307055,
-0.0712155625,
0.0026771573,
0.0038714842,
0.01545671,
-0.0137844868,
-0.0151307499,
0.0358395651,
-0.0306895021,
0.0177075025,
0.0369944051,
0.0139754871,
0.0084126489,
0.0155314477,
0.0291982684,
0.0472338125,
0.0044736764,
-0.003193188,
-0.0221523438,
-0.0393018238,
0.0243285075,
0.0554488897,
0.0186434351,
0.0458158217,
-0.0059036929,
-0.0686910599,
0.0157242268,
0.0398636311,
-0.0220343452,
-0.002396665,
-0.00290914,
0.0003674465,
-0.0785590932,
0.0946470574,
-0.0021683876,
0.0129471393,
-0.0195972789,
0.0580726042,
-0.0261454992,
-0.0699260756,
-0.0524228215,
-0.061834611,
0.0557382032,
0.1111168936,
-0.0244310442,
-0.0082237199,
-0.0296988823,
0.0639264062,
0.0244598705,
0.0321335308,
-0.0000670904,
0.027236199,
0.0089061176,
-0.0109750787,
0.0465506762,
0.0254211873,
-0.0087943468,
-0.0084752198,
0.0465175062,
0.0397424363,
0.0006659009,
0.0451466478,
-0.0037361016,
0.0044013378,
0.0050475942,
0.0395214781,
-0.0034528659,
-0.015332737,
-0.0118893078,
0.0003599043,
0.0614730194,
-0.0346928053,
-0.0145724909,
0.0100810584,
0.0225639455,
-0.0414165407,
-0.0237531159,
-0.0289734658,
-0.0254875105,
0.0574884564,
-0.0134414975,
-0.0100060916,
-0.056965813,
0.0435025319,
-0.0517839827,
0.000153616,
0.0120017519,
0.041812554,
-0.0164190549,
-0.0409132801,
0.0532211326,
-0.0834288076,
-0.0031627528,
0.0316369757,
-0.0488106906,
-0.0695767999,
0.0310828034,
0.0110773193,
0.0168469884,
0.0745132193,
-0.0495410934,
-0.037237186,
0.0550505333,
0.0305525735,
-0.0355522968,
0.0226806104,
0.0747675821,
-0.0362697542,
-0.0039734617,
0.0188268013,
-0.0495480858,
0.0403596349,
0.0275260713,
0.027442893,
0.0013906723,
0.0078465939,
0.0058101551,
0.0079186289,
0.0371172614,
-0.0372714773,
-0.0041652927,
-0.0186866298,
0.0405607671,
0.0273926072,
0.0600138791,
-0.0231162179,
0.0210125055,
-0.0053771017,
0.0155178094,
-0.0048606275,
0.0113810608,
-0.004329768,
-0.0046698013,
-0.0177655648,
0.053778097,
0.0083993813,
0.0458385609,
-0.0298551433,
0.0251012165,
0.0263923816,
0.0496881865,
0.0245768558,
0.0206812043,
0.0024201425,
-0.0188157484,
0.0002876442,
0.0061909426,
-0.0369659178,
0.0186365936,
-0.0759558603,
-0.0200623795,
-0.0527287833,
0.0426359363,
0.0514984392,
-0.0184143204,
0.0233342089,
-0.0118923467,
0.0132461544,
-0.020761149,
-0.0208103862,
-0.0201674327,
0.0355032273,
0.0212814566,
0.0049073803,
-0.0109149553,
0.0306014642,
0.0340262316,
0.0093391873,
0.0559146851,
-0.0190474242,
0.0671541691,
-0.0596833453,
-0.0795395821,
0.0338628069,
0.0193221699,
-0.0309825409,
0.0188778155,
0.0091656325,
-0.0633613467,
0.003675798,
-0.0188637618,
0.0386514775,
-0.0012893005,
0.0136765102,
0.017036343,
-0.0115276836,
0.0482382923,
0.0325100385,
-0.0534291901,
0.0256674122,
-0.0052570105,
0.0218931139,
-6.646396404e-33,
0.0083349217,
0.0541917533,
0.0053402851,
-0.0853618011,
-0.0127302213,
-0.0247241948,
-0.0046982309,
0.0076466398,
-0.0049273097,
-0.0273116529,
-0.0181817338,
0.0002511762,
0.0388218276,
0.0095012216,
-0.043163579,
-0.0093345521,
0.1200402007,
-0.0023799411,
-0.0202045999,
-0.0231464766,
0.0103568565,
0.0685985908,
0.0186467245,
-0.1232455745,
-0.0310817529,
0.0110041164,
-0.0276018418,
-0.0439119935,
-0.0007227911,
0.0362432562,
0.0179377142,
0.0379747637,
-0.0340747535,
0.0054435409,
-0.0249274671,
-0.0431894511,
-0.0975960568,
-0.0021409972,
-0.0112839425,
0.0558410734,
-0.0219891686,
-0.0205970127,
0.0465829894,
-0.0218448546,
-0.0069007841,
-0.008965956,
0.0052288314,
-0.056071423,
-0.0257176403,
-0.0011595079,
-0.0068137068,
0.0452341549,
-0.0131800426,
0.0045566577,
0.022087004,
-0.0078537101,
-0.0264846962,
-0.0190398302,
-0.0641992092,
0.0019594652,
0.0399362482,
0.0219146665,
0.0232487414,
0.0439328104,
-0.0087950556,
0.0396577939,
0.0894201621,
-0.080946058,
0.0523784086,
-0.0605957098,
0.0335956626,
-0.0145133818,
0.0412727669,
0.0527317971,
0.0543484576,
-0.0569167361,
-0.0432173088,
-0.0133012114,
0.0014790588,
-0.032895837,
0.0043907175,
0.0318432152,
-0.0630334243,
0.0084283231,
0.0030282945,
-0.0569039509,
-0.0217406359,
-0.0466644205,
0.0532334261,
0.0069788843,
-0.0143977776,
0.0061223758,
0.0358253941,
-0.0080066295,
0.0412531085,
0.0139580397,
0.0148401028,
-0.0488807447,
0.0168204587,
0.0264890753,
0.0100092376,
-0.0195660535,
0.0671511069,
0.0330635644,
-0.0171469394,
-0.0306789372,
0.0339383185,
0.0670842826,
-0.0545989871,
-0.016608553,
-0.0152037628,
0.0499674231,
0.0133763524,
0.0470853038,
0.0519373082,
-0.0037970501,
0.0118267732,
0.0303298105,
-0.0030993768,
0.0185497683,
-0.0274087358,
0.0101941852,
-0.0045037018,
0.0369564779,
-0.0368291028,
-0.0150146093,
0.0528341234,
0.0017627046,
0.0070588798,
-0.0738997161,
-0.0074291308,
-0.0259737018,
3.026e-7,
-0.0457667746,
-0.0078853853,
0.0311511122,
-0.0279206969,
0.0138287665,
-0.0135822855,
-0.0726970211,
0.0029675381,
-0.0462643206,
0.0090412553,
0.0067348816,
0.0063648354,
0.0592491701,
0.043811962,
-0.0504490994,
-0.0215169862,
-0.0676741451,
0.0237606093,
0.0041996539,
-0.0025742953,
0.0269811507,
0.1288549602,
0.0111766476,
-0.0552801415,
0.0267706439,
-0.0103396596,
0.0195271689,
0.0071964567,
0.0438326895,
-0.0614997856,
-0.0035689531,
-0.0161261149,
0.0161153376,
-0.0188743975,
-0.0485418476,
0.0217320994,
0.0213902388,
0.021546023,
-0.0286316536,
-0.0746153444,
-0.0223986991,
0.0519257635,
-0.0029748646,
-0.0059682373,
0.0331504457,
0.0226320103,
-0.0200077891,
0.0006479131,
-0.0878795236,
0.0046308674,
0.0070313839,
-0.0257552732,
-0.0073770168,
0.0153117105,
-0.011457351,
0.0133321714,
-0.0249722991,
-0.0612018891,
-0.0049982499,
-0.0411272161,
-0.054785233,
-0.0246019457,
-0.0393803604,
0.0063123815,
0.0230747201,
0.0131528191,
0.0107759861,
2.247523617e-34,
0.0467175506,
-0.0317291021,
0.0271580163,
0.0037454658,
-0.0277218278,
-0.0272077937,
0.0363127068,
0.0031165965,
0.0325891785,
0.0034321968,
-0.059438359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12425v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12425v1 | On the Effectiveness of Offline RL for Dialogue Response Generation | 2023-07-23T20:43:21 | 2023-07-23T20:43:21 | Paloma Sodhi, Felix Wu, Ethan R. Elenberg, Kilian Q. Weinberger, Ryan McDonald | cs.CL | cs.CL | A common training technique for language models is teacher forcing (TF). TF
attempts to match human language exactly, even though identical meanings can be
expressed in different ways. This motivates use of sequence-level objectives
for dialogue response generation. In this paper, we study the efficacy of
various offline reinforcement learning (RL) methods to maximize such
objectives. We present a comprehensive evaluation across multiple datasets,
models, and metrics. Offline RL shows a clear performance improvement over
teacher forcing while not inducing training instability or sacrificing
practical training budgets. | [
0.0773099288,
0.0983672291,
-0.0149844829,
-0.0240396578,
-0.0331380665,
-0.0161592662,
0.0269052647,
0.0023155231,
-0.0166023616,
-0.0412568226,
0.0133799277,
-0.0485185049,
-0.0024645564,
0.0254558083,
-0.027412517,
-0.0904826447,
0.0239939988,
-0.0271036439,
0.0192569569,
-0.0030032354,
0.0079425545,
0.0143374307,
-0.0466778055,
0.0711929351,
-0.0243998524,
0.0166580044,
-0.0257816743,
0.0148339085,
0.0192659721,
-0.0007899147,
0.0317714289,
0.0286780484,
0.0317442492,
0.034368366,
0.0000017248,
-0.0456340685,
-0.0278637093,
-0.0363503918,
0.0078919241,
-0.0435839146,
0.0180830844,
-0.0035482692,
0.000572981,
0.0378058851,
-0.0510822088,
0.0022316063,
0.0608638078,
0.0320206285,
0.0616750419,
0.0984699875,
0.0215039458,
-0.0059848498,
0.0323794149,
-0.0234873183,
0.0378774777,
-0.0175604224,
-0.0133877518,
0.0355891138,
0.0165040363,
-0.0248720106,
-0.0477735326,
0.0045809173,
0.023175355,
-0.0112937847,
-0.0196344107,
0.0244876072,
-0.0302826986,
-0.0447291136,
0.00401833,
0.1001484469,
0.0212273262,
-0.0059293858,
0.0290460698,
-0.0314327888,
-0.0060676853,
0.0073419255,
-0.0028916581,
0.0607790388,
-0.0086704865,
0.0148035334,
-0.0393126942,
0.0296774898,
-0.0474872962,
0.0199636649,
-0.0159544908,
0.012175655,
-0.0154680079,
-0.0615287274,
-0.0121304644,
0.0186769664,
-0.0120437285,
-0.0338636674,
-0.0146467648,
0.0315471105,
-0.0727594197,
0.0361825451,
-0.0811584741,
0.0149521139,
0.0166358016,
0.0258733407,
0.0229387991,
0.0490487814,
0.0319813639,
-0.0125526749,
0.0044268668,
0.0871155262,
0.012620966,
0.0214317273,
-0.0178958997,
0.0380827375,
-0.0939690173,
0.0018546298,
-0.0488623343,
0.0271120369,
-0.0495742969,
-0.0551992022,
-0.0531430654,
0.0072801653,
-0.0078669256,
0.032228075,
0.0003356409,
0.012770799,
-0.0860542879,
0.0189497769,
-0.045861993,
0.0047252914,
-0.0069995327,
-0.0054931389,
0.0459200218,
-0.0940797105,
0.0087020118,
-0.0004642298,
0.0304331612,
0.0016854174,
-0.0066946517,
0.0353977457,
-0.0364295915,
-0.0348210447,
0.0071088215,
-0.0734252557,
-0.027392704,
-0.0624750815,
-0.0104918741,
-0.0396936126,
0.0117837768,
-0.0390315466,
-0.0109124575,
0.0064095426,
0.030582862,
0.0031748966,
0.0051167863,
-0.0049482882,
0.0102287065,
0.0105825197,
0.0285290442,
0.017826438,
-0.0058385753,
0.0570364483,
0.0359481461,
-0.009347097,
0.0052461494,
-0.0012675952,
0.0036320388,
-0.0040181698,
0.0646589994,
0.0180339385,
-0.044196289,
0.0257993117,
0.0153984288,
0.0509521142,
0.034828335,
0.0315353796,
-0.0609236509,
0.0553159676,
0.0805843025,
0.0201349016,
0.0311962515,
-0.0132965147,
0.0134262918,
0.0847833976,
-0.0134884017,
0.0050759967,
-0.0104079591,
0.019076949,
0.0429880135,
0.0716624111,
0.0579722859,
0.0219479855,
-0.0116814319,
-0.0509043224,
0.023510484,
0.0039194562,
0.0044643478,
0.0080218902,
0.0052612815,
0.0473990738,
-0.0400842391,
0.0006093177,
0.025108587,
-0.0456248112,
-0.0013576666,
-0.0553598665,
0.0104789492,
0.0632771179,
0.0770957991,
0.0190952178,
-0.0666461438,
-0.0435333252,
-0.0062841848,
0.1169218794,
-0.0100568738,
0.0023573057,
0.0122025795,
-0.0823513046,
-0.0288608745,
0.0090361414,
0.0013129395,
0.0522691123,
0.0471534431,
0.029369114,
0.0099809812,
0.0231400523,
-0.0455614366,
0.0216657706,
-0.0241111927,
-0.0228951387,
0.0230937302,
0.0172210131,
0.0381689258,
-0.0220298357,
-0.0372975878,
-0.0021125365,
-0.013153187,
0.0045626429,
-0.0111719109,
-0.0187883396,
-0.0808108672,
-0.0602507256,
0.0026543625,
-0.0354070738,
0.0187341664,
0.0339822546,
-0.0014382731,
-0.0380025059,
-0.0039472231,
-0.048020687,
0.0509667881,
-0.0373745374,
-0.0063412799,
0.0376965143,
0.0278498512,
-0.0378117152,
0.0256005377,
-0.012740504,
0.0182938259,
0.0529237725,
0.0314273946,
-0.016661983,
-0.0576681048,
0.0114264321,
0.0038770009,
-0.0411365107,
0.0512812771,
0.0341840796,
0.0821932107,
-0.0339836255,
-0.0276190322,
-0.0071634431,
-0.0140507687,
-0.0142471911,
-0.0060958061,
0.029644832,
-0.0001111157,
-0.0255451296,
-0.0434233919,
-0.052304633,
-0.0149372164,
0.0579641461,
-0.0085614985,
0.0335501395,
0.0037310785,
-0.024665691,
-0.0358991772,
0.019609889,
0.0360835902,
0.0024124426,
-0.0132814208,
0.050541725,
-0.0251046401,
0.0008207785,
-0.0760078654,
0.036082752,
0.0112302676,
-0.0555927902,
0.0264122337,
-0.013295697,
0.0331091471,
0.0559733361,
0.0534374304,
0.0137470877,
0.0346386433,
-0.0120326644,
-0.0987129807,
0.0396876112,
-0.0189082753,
-0.041340109,
0.0059093041,
-0.0162921213,
0.0048279329,
0.0241629388,
0.0346216485,
0.0322534032,
-0.0763391927,
0.0222018268,
0.0164220836,
-0.0685132593,
-0.0165021382,
-0.0097394353,
-0.0500876456,
0.0294311009,
-0.0090438882,
-0.0576244667,
0.0729073733,
-0.0004665079,
-0.0392089598,
-0.0547577813,
0.0000913692,
0.0016212668,
0.0259930231,
0.0031871677,
0.0381647609,
0.0125601254,
-0.0221228357,
-0.0317104831,
-0.0332487673,
0.0613065772,
-0.0349515639,
0.0149648646,
-0.0371276774,
0.0135438778,
-0.0202712268,
-0.0084099248,
-0.066338107,
-0.0223599654,
0.0109419255,
-0.0405978002,
-0.0277400054,
-0.0272414219,
-0.008835691,
0.0308212526,
0.0207834989,
0.047875721,
-0.0168423336,
-0.0131753096,
-0.0394289941,
0.0432618745,
0.0743394718,
0.0432975926,
-0.0218743607,
-0.0094033312,
0.0497940369,
0.0153682483,
0.0520494729,
-0.0239110515,
0.0042413897,
0.0035260897,
0.0249978546,
-0.0230717007,
0.0284658112,
0.0671500862,
0.0116177397,
-0.0455296971,
-0.0567239076,
0.0720299482,
0.0242114402,
-0.00190923,
-0.0119766388,
0.0011829197,
0.0853399262,
-0.0203919373,
0.0113036623,
-0.0596019477,
-0.0242503919,
-0.0123209674,
0.057507053,
-0.0281973016,
-0.0059525277,
-0.0308883879,
-0.1198558807,
0.0192098003,
-0.0003095315,
-0.067155607,
0.002791536,
0.0215625092,
-0.0196590833,
0.0106007056,
0.0499637797,
0.0083614876,
-0.0101612043,
0.0124422992,
0.025736548,
0.0021587992,
-0.0316023193,
-0.017937744,
-0.0317558683,
0.0794361308,
0.0968300253,
0.0309921913,
0.0297267847,
-0.0388715193,
0.0104428558,
0.0002710921,
0.0274576694,
0.0060942662,
0.0363281108,
-0.0142505355,
-0.0202561393,
-0.0270091277,
0.0327022821,
0.0146944877,
0.0110227531,
0.0392823741,
0.00869036,
-0.0304808747,
0.006639231,
-0.0032511859,
0.060707517,
0.0654277951,
0.040635746,
0.0079426318,
-0.0707356557,
-0.0460342579,
0.0078644753,
0.0128386524,
-0.0726731345,
-0.0126367444,
-0.0368727781,
-0.0403465182,
0.0273077711,
-0.0944770202,
-0.0760940388,
-0.0217406899,
0.0445314012,
-0.0202765167,
-0.0615088977,
-0.0028395632,
0.0376109593,
0.0169067327,
0.0056757005,
-0.0274171494,
-0.0008618143,
-0.0486496687,
-0.0220886357,
0.0155156869,
-0.0610376187,
0.0090173353,
-0.0060910434,
-0.0538065918,
-0.060239844,
0.0044731991,
0.0357352644,
0.022847902,
0.0936046019,
0.0251208227,
0.008434617,
0.0354908258,
0.0209625121,
-0.0432059467,
-0.0020698679,
0.0580032654,
0.038944222,
-0.0156471767,
0.0297629703,
-0.020940084,
0.0232899617,
-0.0027963764,
0.0660042837,
-0.0117752654,
-0.0388685986,
0.0336261056,
-0.0142074497,
0.012576689,
-0.0068355016,
-0.0695130453,
-0.0090808189,
0.0456899405,
0.0121250581,
-0.0190329384,
-0.0338571668,
0.0130418707,
0.0338874795,
0.0199345201,
0.0195411835,
-0.0274097603,
-0.0154236685,
0.0374495424,
0.0263967942,
-0.012593342,
-0.0073141796,
0.0200560484,
0.0063369591,
-0.0061068512,
-0.0322198421,
0.0423517004,
0.0115279127,
0.041378431,
0.0263324119,
0.091435425,
0.0259225629,
-0.0138352886,
0.0231343359,
-0.0027203558,
-0.0423167013,
-0.000695013,
-0.0270889048,
-0.001898616,
0.0110414913,
0.0388865434,
0.0343450792,
-0.0379460715,
0.0244580619,
-0.0074235941,
0.0223067813,
-0.0195876751,
-0.0236200187,
0.0032266378,
-0.006936356,
-0.0079171425,
0.0120825125,
0.0614473447,
0.0088890987,
0.005088605,
-0.001718812,
0.0645697862,
-0.0668195114,
-0.0184391458,
0.0085420981,
0.0231490675,
0.0024322141,
-0.0016432598,
-0.0274941027,
-0.0184103567,
-0.0228123385,
0.0498029515,
-0.0239677485,
-0.0125172762,
0.0498054288,
0.0049867192,
-0.0181968901,
0.0219678823,
-0.0633734539,
-0.0142250927,
0.0024296865,
-0.0044053714,
-0.0455405861,
-5.46017126e-33,
-0.0231365841,
-0.028483808,
0.0285349395,
-0.0055779563,
-0.0541387759,
0.0034337509,
-0.0142981624,
-0.0105593158,
0.0120343845,
-0.0238039549,
-0.0194288455,
-0.008674386,
0.0101222033,
0.0588617474,
-0.0077590132,
-0.026845362,
0.0179310963,
-0.0051165884,
-0.0580044836,
0.0557667166,
0.0327744037,
0.0103018135,
-0.0054801069,
-0.0096058985,
0.0128947254,
-0.0196340252,
-0.0267288201,
-0.0023021929,
-0.0224949736,
0.0713711306,
-0.0137506984,
-0.0125935273,
0.004520345,
-0.0519697703,
-0.0324736238,
0.0348964036,
-0.040559426,
-0.0287891142,
-0.0033769459,
-0.0133279236,
-0.04241056,
-0.0199432597,
-0.000131199,
-0.0170927774,
-0.011671355,
0.0090649389,
0.0074368925,
-0.0194649827,
-0.0497290045,
-0.0130909253,
-0.0638925284,
0.013963569,
-0.0245770495,
-0.0401057415,
-0.0324934311,
0.0873165727,
-0.0133036627,
-0.0382416919,
-0.01085658,
0.0604943149,
0.0488002598,
0.0029655942,
0.0378637761,
0.0423827916,
-0.0068969917,
0.0463046953,
-0.0051005627,
-0.0406349823,
0.0203511529,
-0.0319462456,
0.025901651,
0.0244206712,
-0.0024126933,
0.0779795051,
0.0222019963,
0.0173043981,
-0.0132820932,
0.0312065668,
0.0244451426,
0.0066649853,
0.0303828958,
-0.0087019093,
-0.0419168435,
-0.0019615274,
-0.0096291434,
0.0150677459,
-0.0130137121,
-0.058705654,
0.0678905994,
0.063497372,
-0.0303990543,
-0.0471739732,
0.0358405039,
-0.0252261721,
-0.006768174,
0.0122869182,
-0.0344440416,
-0.0208779387,
-0.0250982121,
-0.0089527871,
-0.0765239149,
-0.0469940044,
0.0785429329,
-0.013789298,
-0.027705729,
0.0204595402,
0.0023440048,
0.0021419181,
-0.0780107975,
0.0304444749,
-0.0131717883,
0.0610346682,
-0.0347166248,
0.0024941983,
0.0399231724,
-0.0579271279,
-0.0295712762,
0.0688404813,
-0.0034374124,
-0.0707879812,
-0.0461020879,
-0.0175080169,
0.013694861,
0.0149554489,
-0.0412133597,
0.0341097079,
-0.0411583632,
-0.0346650071,
-0.0098288395,
-0.0293847211,
0.0074383849,
0.0167780053,
2.447e-7,
-0.0432391912,
0.0137658119,
0.0521114431,
0.009661763,
0.0066789072,
0.0234993845,
-0.0220345445,
0.0339007154,
0.0187865347,
0.0249786768,
0.0481176898,
-0.0144979339,
0.0559727065,
-0.0029675849,
-0.0496029593,
-0.0037834831,
-0.1180283353,
-0.0190006923,
-0.0440855809,
-0.0369897261,
0.035976164,
0.0491431877,
-0.0248149373,
0.0011351443,
0.0422851369,
0.0181554873,
0.0328520201,
0.0029282018,
-0.0093149161,
-0.0081077237,
0.0315891318,
-0.0368418582,
-0.0050744661,
0.0069876462,
0.0044572325,
0.0248627197,
-0.0321498886,
0.0520577282,
0.0345392935,
-0.0518947169,
-0.0156063605,
0.0166329704,
0.0297804344,
-0.0404586494,
0.0309301335,
-0.0350801162,
0.0260778368,
0.0249144081,
-0.0234665219,
-0.0218612924,
0.0042372718,
-0.0519597232,
-0.0357310958,
0.0132382363,
0.0150352735,
0.0354318134,
0.0238915496,
-0.0254240986,
0.0047717718,
-0.0227990746,
-0.0100313267,
-0.094457753,
-0.0506447144,
0.0476674102,
0.0114162229,
-0.031279549,
-0.0441072434,
1.908341955e-34,
-0.004585335,
-0.002985101,
0.0341924354,
-0.0030464998,
-0.0104503073,
0.0196160953,
0.0155111188,
0.002458974,
0.0571659431,
-0.0624242611,
-0.0486477017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12418v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12418v2 | HateModerate: Testing Hate Speech Detectors against Content Moderation Policies | 2023-07-23T20:08:38 | 2024-03-19T02:17:22 | Jiangrui Zheng, Xueqing Liu, Guanqun Yang, Mirazul Haque, Xing Qian, Ravishka Rathnasuriya, Wei Yang, Girish Budhrani | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | To protect users from massive hateful content, existing works studied
automated hate speech detection. Despite the existing efforts, one question
remains: do automated hate speech detectors conform to social media content
policies? A platform's content policies are a checklist of content moderated by
the social media platform. Because content moderation rules are often uniquely
defined, existing hate speech datasets cannot directly answer this question.
This work seeks to answer this question by creating HateModerate, a dataset
for testing the behaviors of automated content moderators against content
policies. First, we engage 28 annotators and GPT in a six-step annotation
process, resulting in a list of hateful and non-hateful test suites matching
each of Facebook's 41 hate speech policies. Second, we test the performance of
state-of-the-art hate speech detectors against HateModerate, revealing
substantial failures these models have in their conformity to the policies.
Third, using HateModerate, we augment the training data of a top-downloaded
hate detector on HuggingFace. We observe significant improvement in the models'
conformity to content policies while having comparable scores on the original
test data. Our dataset and code can be found in the attachment. | [
0.0807756484,
0.0412594154,
-0.0237681922,
0.0170881171,
0.0054368018,
0.0489062965,
0.0415872298,
0.0266915597,
0.029811278,
-0.0575671382,
0.017482942,
-0.0076060644,
-0.0388764925,
0.0300483219,
-0.0098671196,
-0.0267441403,
0.0256629456,
0.0365207978,
0.0223337673,
0.0034331526,
0.0774593577,
0.0225213356,
0.001496405,
0.0307914522,
-0.0823023915,
0.0079734847,
0.026247682,
0.0028033347,
0.0283805262,
-0.0173499286,
0.0339542441,
0.0458262712,
0.0135424659,
0.0893087909,
0.0000017209,
-0.0350092612,
-0.0127501991,
-0.0036647276,
0.018968692,
-0.0234795809,
0.094165802,
-0.0418031439,
-0.0180904455,
0.0402763821,
-0.0511799194,
0.0378318317,
0.0546554998,
0.0487084612,
0.0847619921,
0.0696929097,
-0.0168383494,
-0.0046225516,
0.0231619757,
0.01301271,
0.0076850103,
0.0352185629,
0.02537282,
-0.038501028,
-0.0614407733,
-0.013547821,
0.0006182303,
0.0139728617,
0.0342103727,
0.0252017695,
0.0034879141,
-0.0458459184,
-0.0344191231,
-0.0359958112,
-0.0122694597,
0.0466366298,
-0.0210632961,
-0.0133283632,
0.0137070278,
-0.0132597499,
-0.0051889964,
0.0107047483,
-0.0171254706,
0.0049169525,
-0.0450262763,
0.0167695452,
-0.0062644854,
-0.0048558195,
0.0496484078,
0.0422736332,
0.0216931496,
0.0318745039,
-0.0279164147,
-0.0510558896,
0.0155573208,
-0.0070223911,
0.0187657997,
0.0019382739,
0.0336901248,
-0.0186958946,
-0.0078325076,
0.0036734568,
-0.0589442514,
-0.0315582342,
0.0388580002,
-0.0628472641,
0.0196755957,
0.0449915715,
-0.0402115844,
0.0283152815,
-0.0031731664,
0.0442280136,
0.0037125903,
0.0308550317,
0.0138167543,
0.0298584588,
-0.0170134064,
0.0179692339,
0.0228089932,
-0.0093972478,
0.02700397,
0.0491265766,
-0.0586167984,
-0.0036728738,
-0.0576243699,
0.0093257567,
-0.0047531547,
-0.02103181,
0.0015029687,
0.0189000405,
-0.0323090255,
0.0027781273,
-0.0432668962,
0.006959422,
-0.0113312844,
-0.0630539879,
0.0041891867,
0.0265815724,
-0.0015110787,
-0.011696347,
0.0439648442,
0.0624690577,
0.0486214235,
-0.0223975554,
-0.0196424667,
-0.0401761308,
-0.0128794862,
-0.0432835706,
0.0196492765,
-0.0511517636,
0.0355547257,
-0.0099088196,
-0.017070666,
-0.0561843514,
0.0011294694,
0.0153724346,
-0.0154363383,
0.0762285292,
0.0102153989,
-0.0364760756,
0.0253382996,
0.0350206792,
-0.0059132897,
0.0566033795,
-0.0073830257,
0.0540469587,
0.0685485899,
-0.0192214232,
-0.0035505756,
0.0699010044,
0.0509431325,
0.0231590383,
-0.0317583904,
0.0150779383,
-0.042523846,
-0.0507876463,
-0.002157961,
0.0388767086,
-0.0083173588,
-0.0681021214,
0.036392834,
0.0718733519,
-0.0625391081,
0.0073793461,
0.0679589286,
0.0008868739,
-0.012946343,
-0.0196063183,
-0.0741900206,
-0.0112911584,
-0.0421328247,
-0.0633275509,
0.021019429,
0.0648113564,
-0.0162717346,
-0.0439395122,
-0.0297766216,
-0.0188061129,
0.0765056163,
-0.0463097543,
0.0047813929,
0.0002805609,
-0.0172058027,
-0.0037621418,
0.026430618,
-0.0242042653,
-0.0035414526,
-0.05529847,
0.0308907796,
0.0825672299,
0.0013518616,
-0.0362705179,
-0.0134944851,
-0.0766573995,
0.0159168504,
0.035865996,
0.0531606153,
-0.0169129372,
-0.0544112548,
-0.0361068323,
-0.0194565374,
0.0206081793,
0.0234979652,
0.029853614,
0.0746943653,
0.0091421613,
0.0068155387,
0.0617150441,
-0.0484102517,
0.0339398719,
0.0341943279,
-0.0308286343,
-0.0296986587,
0.0026131475,
0.0706713796,
0.0292226952,
-0.0172163658,
-0.059738569,
0.0181648787,
0.0197599512,
-0.0402517542,
-0.0102172513,
-0.0264745969,
0.0314537622,
0.0449357256,
-0.0383960381,
-0.0369135253,
0.0785441324,
-0.0113062905,
0.0447176434,
0.0472665392,
0.0004193573,
-0.0335795432,
-0.0273647439,
-0.0595406443,
-0.0602848865,
0.0203239955,
0.0025599357,
0.0466368198,
-0.026286792,
0.0008870278,
0.0177742783,
-0.0719504282,
0.0552871265,
0.0380826704,
-0.048268158,
-0.0452547185,
-0.0539020486,
0.0389944203,
0.0146846576,
0.0055408138,
-0.0334315412,
0.0194024332,
-0.0912335217,
-0.0062160539,
-0.0337503515,
0.003985106,
0.0289364532,
0.0102470508,
-0.0034032844,
0.0168528836,
-0.0233734772,
-0.043621555,
0.0388125107,
0.0349928774,
0.0078548025,
-0.0723537058,
-0.0330686904,
-0.0199850239,
-0.0274251532,
-0.0410268866,
-0.0094632963,
0.0304785501,
-0.0579476319,
0.0676700994,
-0.0065431483,
-0.053554289,
0.0066404692,
-0.0290683024,
-0.0556984767,
0.0471377447,
-0.0049864776,
-0.0473357551,
0.0498074926,
0.0626406148,
0.0929277986,
0.0138694309,
0.0462839268,
-0.0301469974,
0.0024625591,
-0.0067232042,
0.0072511402,
-0.0281826761,
-0.0279920157,
0.0162942577,
0.0553156249,
0.0350221433,
-0.0035789339,
-0.0775946677,
0.0455560833,
-0.0800714716,
-0.0314831622,
-0.0152108809,
-0.0320165753,
-0.0121212443,
-0.0146156382,
-0.0288153347,
-0.0612494573,
0.0743197203,
0.0243457686,
0.0206051618,
-0.0028992794,
-0.0307047516,
-0.011674976,
0.0365000591,
0.015333578,
0.0231307279,
-0.0456592143,
0.0139868781,
0.0286430512,
-0.0234344024,
0.0816420987,
-0.0403284729,
-0.0416725613,
-0.0055657104,
0.0196383204,
0.0005178295,
-0.0556781851,
-0.047107242,
-0.0493678004,
-0.0576702021,
-0.0402819738,
0.0125698363,
-0.0027682192,
-0.0128680011,
0.0143115493,
0.0139569938,
0.0110533293,
0.0049723051,
-0.0038009207,
0.0324155502,
-0.0643627495,
-0.0179425832,
-0.0035309682,
0.0014717181,
-0.0124102766,
-0.0300488342,
0.0605109259,
-0.01059567,
-0.0023900638,
-0.0248516966,
0.039074827,
0.0053685885,
0.0034264261,
0.0189801063,
-0.0015042028,
0.0471290164,
-0.0086153131,
0.0426277407,
0.0674578026,
0.0302780792,
-0.0074784858,
-0.0310943946,
0.0041295099,
0.0272929929,
0.0287683494,
-0.0268396698,
-0.1138204932,
-0.0011652948,
-0.0158278905,
0.0622977428,
-0.0741793215,
-0.034499228,
0.0034314964,
-0.0413596071,
0.025876293,
-0.0122583099,
-0.0542598441,
-0.0162972864,
-0.0191947948,
0.0089626396,
-0.0504606143,
0.029371405,
-0.050720986,
0.0294611081,
0.0006665023,
0.0114816176,
-0.0548545122,
-0.0078340545,
0.0236860793,
-0.0370740294,
0.0370943844,
0.0520262904,
0.0145858927,
-0.019410545,
-0.0099243512,
0.061043106,
0.0288949497,
-0.0321230926,
-0.0489733294,
0.0651925728,
-0.0026017756,
-0.0307208672,
-0.0033817922,
0.0641708449,
-0.0134318899,
0.0094366642,
0.0291337054,
0.0400869735,
0.0541041605,
-0.0042875442,
-0.0469493568,
0.0368724614,
0.0107766967,
0.0531232134,
0.0208899193,
-0.0679006651,
0.015929522,
-0.0900854394,
-0.0027580797,
-0.0504746661,
-0.0994037986,
-0.0249797944,
-0.024258839,
0.0005154865,
-0.0237329863,
-0.0246427096,
0.018563481,
0.0096343132,
0.0243172236,
-0.0311058331,
-0.0020997021,
-0.0127561213,
-0.0267973244,
0.0099910451,
0.006318883,
0.0331371017,
-0.0010280695,
-0.0174367968,
-0.0352315865,
0.0123060616,
-0.0454783924,
0.0315520279,
-0.0263547041,
-0.0433691218,
0.0762006044,
0.0680677965,
0.024751896,
0.0203775708,
-0.0026545553,
-0.0247265343,
0.0480560064,
0.0809750482,
-0.0146857435,
-0.013211037,
0.0745243654,
-0.0201473329,
-0.0021357462,
-0.0045412951,
-0.0004912416,
0.0279592369,
0.0160914995,
-0.0650782287,
-0.0292265154,
0.0164870527,
-0.0148752388,
0.0239684805,
0.0067720069,
-0.0047250492,
-0.0656388253,
-0.0231846832,
-0.0269132704,
0.0158061963,
-0.0533612818,
-5.004e-7,
0.0241472144,
0.0170671325,
-0.0347318389,
-0.0454861782,
-0.017633969,
-0.0368314944,
0.0264301561,
-0.0463216864,
0.008625688,
0.0289527848,
0.0327302776,
0.0306212232,
-0.0200520009,
-0.0202735066,
0.0580831021,
0.0227118954,
-0.0084411604,
-0.0159302093,
0.0234370735,
0.0160268396,
0.0283077303,
0.0403580777,
-0.0118281124,
0.0062951325,
-0.0076641692,
-0.0414007492,
-0.0018964813,
-0.0257920735,
-0.0143682165,
0.0353808254,
-0.0035192918,
-0.0217968263,
0.001827153,
-0.012457015,
-0.016168667,
-0.0206440799,
0.0023707433,
0.0213385057,
-0.0155904349,
0.0021699748,
0.0062794299,
0.0000056556,
0.0438741483,
0.0375650786,
-0.0453915857,
-0.0569405146,
0.0111431833,
0.0100960098,
0.0543057844,
0.0062868074,
-0.0048975768,
-0.0407567807,
-0.0412430465,
-0.0028941552,
-0.0468967818,
0.0217621941,
0.0020927191,
-0.0120178973,
0.0528598279,
-0.0157982148,
0.0307394043,
0.0085975667,
-0.0105045233,
-0.0102841388,
-0.0689662695,
-0.0029863652,
-5.618501165e-33,
-0.0085559161,
0.003073432,
-0.0145181613,
0.0033975842,
0.0038227516,
-0.0422031097,
0.0417950451,
0.0062640929,
0.0026900796,
-0.0003670823,
-0.015418279,
0.0273844451,
0.0052370606,
-0.0071842503,
-0.0022608922,
-0.0360557362,
0.0277888626,
-0.0538875312,
-0.0345889963,
0.0142909987,
0.0283712167,
-0.0071032802,
-0.0201264396,
-0.0653237551,
0.0355858244,
0.0062116687,
-0.0375269055,
-0.0051844474,
-0.025549937,
0.0943751186,
-0.0239639115,
0.0613570288,
0.0436966345,
-0.0070496723,
0.0091358209,
0.0332603641,
-0.0476845056,
-0.0152947912,
0.0217027944,
0.0016690723,
0.0284475274,
-0.0035503563,
0.0365140885,
-0.0108279949,
-0.0320077166,
-0.0271155424,
0.0275315475,
-0.0143508064,
0.0232776999,
-0.0240238737,
-0.0516866259,
0.0326611623,
-0.0488000475,
-0.000297337,
-0.0150023792,
0.0318272449,
0.0481968299,
-0.000961832,
-0.0286450479,
0.016271878,
-0.0173808672,
-0.0320663862,
0.008658139,
-0.0119220605,
-0.0124616278,
0.0618554167,
-0.0139039606,
0.0330607221,
-0.0263606403,
0.0232585482,
0.0327432714,
0.0403594561,
0.0527613759,
0.0770894289,
0.0133944815,
-0.0909271017,
-0.0416685753,
0.0205609631,
0.043170739,
-0.0068776957,
0.0187555589,
-0.0388894826,
-0.05401811,
-0.0129860174,
-0.0197845027,
-0.0626126006,
-0.0245337989,
-0.0374190249,
0.0187976975,
0.0105461711,
-0.0572682992,
-0.0186193697,
0.0120833507,
-0.0548845641,
-0.0058743432,
0.0707327276,
-0.0474551953,
0.0093106823,
0.0339298397,
0.0332070962,
-0.0382060036,
-0.0200265739,
0.0160147958,
-0.0257316437,
0.04829726,
-0.0272287074,
0.0734493434,
0.0522389337,
-0.0713467449,
0.0079720616,
-0.0050601438,
0.0782129541,
-0.0504289195,
0.0519241132,
0.013667495,
0.0488417372,
0.0115928156,
-0.0579997748,
0.0259096865,
-0.0261059254,
-0.0363283306,
0.0116418134,
-0.0225015972,
-0.0064040311,
-0.0017259421,
-0.0154573154,
-0.0107902754,
0.0084525235,
0.0097970422,
-0.0872157663,
0.0281968247,
-0.0521465465,
2.442e-7,
-0.0052352939,
0.0428836644,
0.0001925555,
-0.0143124834,
0.0381156392,
0.0280220862,
0.028688496,
0.0264774468,
0.0000386785,
-0.0153920287,
-0.0088860998,
0.0427071974,
0.0059452304,
0.0533683896,
0.0016844538,
-0.0416654497,
-0.041607935,
-0.0035873286,
-0.0687712133,
0.0386029035,
-0.0184581503,
0.0660987645,
0.0679471493,
-0.0332371667,
0.0123212198,
-0.010217174,
0.0108429343,
-0.02840125,
0.0000929234,
-0.0351242572,
0.0778728127,
0.0383769348,
0.0088516623,
0.0049178791,
-0.0167126991,
0.0267592799,
-0.0183573533,
0.0537778102,
0.0536406152,
0.0179090165,
0.0039143185,
-0.0168610718,
0.0076051219,
-0.0435519181,
0.0588404052,
0.023660101,
-0.0063402364,
-0.0786202848,
-0.0271681119,
-0.0538404174,
0.0371113084,
-0.008455595,
-0.0184869282,
-0.0044617811,
0.0059463368,
-0.0051971748,
0.0089186765,
-0.0498407632,
0.0176369362,
-0.024071876,
-0.0378876328,
-0.0708221868,
-0.0275680926,
0.0099755647,
0.0139802201,
0.0455423333,
0.0421370268,
2.001062171e-34,
0.0258398075,
-0.0363494679,
0.0158990454,
-0.0725885704,
0.0142611032,
0.012659315,
0.0198941808,
-0.0019443553,
0.0346835069,
-0.0250994954,
0.0141642019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00107v1 | Validation of a Zero-Shot Learning Natural Language Processing Tool for Data Abstraction from Unstructured Healthcare Data | 2023-07-23T17:52:28 | 2023-07-23T17:52:28 | Basil Kaufmann, Dallin Busby, Chandan Krushna Das, Neeraja Tillu, Mani Menon, Ashutosh K. Tewari, Michael A. Gorin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Objectives: To describe the development and validation of a zero-shot
learning natural language processing (NLP) tool for abstracting data from
unstructured text contained within PDF documents, such as those found within
electronic health records. Materials and Methods: A data abstraction tool based
on the GPT-3.5 model from OpenAI was developed and compared to three physician
human abstractors in terms of time to task completion and accuracy for
abstracting data on 14 unique variables from a set of 199 de-identified radical
prostatectomy pathology reports. The reports were processed by the software
tool in vectorized and scanned formats to establish the impact of optical
character recognition on data abstraction. The tool was assessed for
superiority for data abstraction speed and non-inferiority for accuracy.
Results: The human abstractors required a mean of 101s per report for data
abstraction, with times varying from 15 to 284 s. In comparison, the software
tool required a mean of 12.8 s to process the vectorized reports and a mean of
15.8 to process the scanned reports (P < 0.001). The overall accuracies of the
three human abstractors were 94.7%, 97.8%, and 96.4% for the combined set of
2786 datapoints. The software tool had an overall accuracy of 94.2% for the
vectorized reports, proving to be non-inferior to the human abstractors at a
margin of -10% ($\alpha$=0.025). The tool had a slightly lower accuracy of
88.7% using the scanned reports, proving to be non-inferiority to 2 out of 3
human abstractors. Conclusion: The developed zero-shot learning NLP tool
affords researchers comparable levels of accuracy to that of human abstractors,
with significant time savings benefits. Because of the lack of need for
task-specific model training, the developed tool is highly generalizable and
can be used for a wide variety of data abstraction tasks, even outside the
field of medicine. | [
-0.0036069378,
0.0373153389,
0.0170647018,
-0.0266550072,
-0.0300957169,
0.0436595343,
0.0584412478,
0.032109756,
-0.0352678858,
-0.0285278838,
0.0395838097,
-0.003226188,
0.0448885188,
0.0634406433,
-0.0227318704,
-0.0786691606,
0.0086602708,
0.0200780574,
0.0410620086,
0.0498010889,
-0.0233832337,
-0.0080079613,
-0.0119797634,
0.0367028639,
0.035699103,
0.018847378,
0.0118524367,
-0.0544708855,
-0.0090606501,
-0.0390632898,
-0.0680076182,
-0.0069037578,
-0.0235846378,
0.0214423835,
0.0000023773,
-0.0830073506,
-0.0230594333,
0.0669361129,
-0.0154317161,
-0.0345265828,
0.0590034612,
-0.0780945569,
-0.0006645212,
-0.0038562368,
0.0129623692,
-0.0497330651,
0.0328941941,
0.0688074902,
0.0081805056,
0.0664394423,
-0.041681435,
-0.0019488302,
0.0273387674,
0.0368763953,
0.0032922665,
0.0094070137,
0.0194848441,
0.0107993651,
0.054752674,
-0.0123820351,
0.0387386903,
0.0225626044,
-0.0298690535,
0.0203885753,
-0.0026390073,
0.0719697401,
-0.0096227443,
0.0053634723,
-0.0201295316,
0.0320352428,
-0.0239112675,
0.0033874202,
0.0285365861,
-0.0418735556,
-0.0165157225,
-0.0075532375,
-0.0302878581,
0.0288612489,
-0.0235585496,
-0.0034816705,
-0.0209593475,
0.0175502058,
-0.0197564848,
-0.0237031654,
-0.0412019044,
-0.0039989003,
-0.0115352012,
-0.0426223241,
0.0617254823,
-0.0107963504,
0.0338232554,
-0.012122415,
0.018543968,
0.0335663669,
0.0309325922,
0.0256528743,
-0.0322785564,
-0.0856597275,
0.0707917288,
-0.0474578477,
0.0205465183,
0.0019112937,
0.0019782973,
0.046230942,
-0.0500598624,
0.0307712555,
-0.0160444286,
0.0589557514,
-0.0300381612,
0.0410738103,
-0.0393501557,
-0.0222735032,
0.0036466215,
0.0638493001,
0.0094778147,
-0.0074909935,
-0.0646999478,
-0.0407641083,
0.0260853395,
0.0168776717,
0.0035505535,
0.0288732722,
-0.0225181524,
-0.0042625037,
-0.0073655839,
0.0357139744,
-0.0250743032,
-0.0044748732,
-0.0393944681,
-0.0208439119,
0.0467244796,
0.0404274538,
0.0476698428,
0.0152278813,
-0.0030962143,
0.0747446045,
-0.018965954,
-0.0261598546,
-0.0145337824,
-0.037583176,
-0.0071592759,
-0.012530935,
0.0146402353,
-0.0388152339,
0.0209665708,
0.0204885807,
-0.0241273791,
-0.0179881528,
-0.0004178329,
0.0243549272,
-0.0469108187,
0.0491532944,
-0.0944050401,
-0.0272916742,
0.0496994071,
-0.0022667092,
0.0114776744,
-0.0179164186,
0.0127917007,
-0.025321722,
-0.0352053083,
-0.0346585326,
0.0290915538,
-0.0221418682,
-0.0177374817,
-0.0925841779,
0.0377592966,
-0.0025702026,
-0.0326158926,
0.0413462929,
0.0125300381,
0.0442007147,
-0.0208168961,
0.0232812315,
-0.0146558164,
0.1062893122,
0.0272680782,
0.043526262,
0.0033023385,
0.012772331,
0.0147465952,
-0.0101245819,
0.0115423985,
-0.0010718217,
0.0300183147,
0.0302552748,
-0.0547549799,
-0.0308832098,
-0.0229042508,
-0.0443422943,
-0.0471228808,
-0.0171185061,
-0.0082912631,
-0.0745663121,
0.0672444478,
-0.0071999189,
-0.0519652329,
-0.0178357046,
0.016335167,
-0.0272319969,
-0.0574554689,
-0.0275711324,
-0.0277411696,
0.0541865714,
0.0314338244,
-0.06332504,
-0.0225410294,
-0.0408970527,
-0.0028050023,
0.0105076889,
-0.0334346369,
0.0214572493,
0.0040928931,
-0.0534723029,
0.0073765675,
0.0337273702,
0.005625743,
0.0018383956,
-0.0217919853,
0.0213702545,
-0.0109705189,
-0.0011130002,
-0.0662620366,
0.0609812103,
-0.040400032,
-0.077411972,
-0.030665217,
0.0093058199,
0.0098717995,
0.0048339241,
-0.0205550268,
0.0134586664,
0.0005743472,
-0.0132254418,
-0.0338260867,
0.0098465886,
0.0279602725,
0.0378596,
-0.0016329725,
-0.0611309297,
-0.0026695554,
-0.0352973938,
-0.0236590467,
0.0060561062,
-0.0521553457,
0.0032372805,
-0.0126603339,
0.0009982736,
0.0252714586,
0.0583188459,
-0.0084969467,
-0.0124092586,
0.0455021523,
-0.0034893276,
-0.0079201059,
0.0222590081,
-0.0783090293,
0.0385389812,
-0.024519654,
-0.0037935725,
0.0175579451,
-0.0138578778,
-0.0089297527,
-0.0267896298,
0.0276240241,
-0.0105739702,
0.0165093374,
-0.0611239411,
-0.0197869781,
0.0411483385,
0.002366933,
0.042414248,
-0.0029554705,
-0.0199698284,
-0.0423994809,
-0.0107357623,
-0.0194211826,
0.0182922725,
-0.0213959105,
0.0665018559,
0.0472520106,
0.0212220605,
-0.0161841977,
-0.0061948644,
-0.0532264411,
0.0302890856,
0.0577472784,
-0.0757903606,
0.0288962778,
0.0760911554,
-0.009658617,
-0.0071521061,
0.0259249732,
-0.0165632516,
0.006380097,
-0.0308674015,
-0.0643261075,
0.0258732922,
-0.0354183055,
0.0036714911,
0.0329793394,
-0.0079035247,
0.0002346496,
-0.0092152422,
-0.0009928,
0.0395758785,
0.0588582382,
-0.0515099242,
0.0654049218,
0.0245260615,
0.0043858052,
0.0316785313,
-0.0274494924,
-0.0092948535,
-0.0405480564,
-0.0113891354,
-0.0715559945,
-0.0066362475,
-0.0208137855,
0.0004524792,
-0.0239250809,
-0.006678978,
0.075974606,
0.0251670536,
0.0358104147,
-0.0850876272,
0.0193894897,
-0.0054912018,
0.0095773507,
-0.0104870545,
0.0156724006,
0.0422808155,
-0.0545511469,
0.0349440463,
-0.018316146,
0.0148441289,
-0.0127285849,
0.0135920299,
-0.0041866018,
0.0592357479,
-0.0115105603,
0.0028087252,
-0.0034268936,
-0.0012215502,
0.0140909404,
0.0164722633,
-0.0306218415,
-0.0022996608,
-0.0384164862,
0.0544831865,
0.0098461686,
0.0852664262,
0.0181442667,
-0.0226093214,
-0.0175024066,
0.0390529931,
0.0149216615,
-0.0311770905,
-0.0387484431,
0.0155484052,
0.0318158939,
0.0345601439,
0.0128847454,
0.021159362,
-0.0279773735,
-0.0306719858,
-0.0651050657,
-0.0686394125,
-0.0042976136,
0.0256953705,
-0.0187159367,
-0.0341400132,
0.010843467,
0.0718256012,
0.0528701171,
-0.036175441,
-0.0184010435,
-0.0035785977,
-0.1109362617,
-0.0409860536,
0.0133751435,
-0.0661082491,
0.0073264991,
-0.012568119,
0.0292854216,
-0.0156127345,
-0.0595790297,
0.010347533,
-0.0461832732,
0.0272589438,
-0.0037048161,
-0.0792110488,
-0.041381821,
-0.0395781547,
0.010001095,
-0.0002234036,
-0.0610845014,
-0.0205980781,
-0.0192476995,
-0.0268685203,
0.0046887673,
-0.0989580154,
-0.078561902,
-0.0151435239,
-0.0193525534,
-0.0134234522,
0.0515392981,
0.0361027941,
-0.0355631746,
0.0235945452,
-0.0138253234,
-0.0126984082,
0.0231092423,
-0.028344091,
0.1224076003,
0.0266908873,
0.0277777947,
-0.0469247699,
0.0398518257,
0.0186415203,
-0.0015730392,
-0.0332021266,
0.0528132357,
-0.041259665,
-0.022861734,
-0.021553129,
-0.0176848415,
-0.000409028,
0.0155187724,
-0.0179104004,
0.0099799111,
-0.0768883228,
-0.0026674205,
0.0487824008,
0.0030315695,
0.001172809,
0.0264227036,
-0.0519562103,
-0.0625197962,
-0.0720234737,
-0.0342947654,
0.0651496202,
0.0285840873,
0.0422232337,
0.0208691731,
0.0271812193,
0.0113726193,
-0.0503599867,
0.0103309536,
0.043223165,
-0.019182995,
-0.0019306315,
-0.0150662037,
0.0266350526,
0.027943885,
-0.0099611366,
-0.0004725205,
0.0454607606,
0.0214159507,
-0.0090088667,
0.0489774272,
0.0256078187,
-0.060789559,
-0.001638836,
-0.0477187186,
0.0622514151,
0.0256519131,
0.0021726969,
-0.0395244174,
-0.0302442461,
0.0198435616,
0.0053375214,
-0.0348339379,
0.0182900243,
-0.0070113642,
-0.0124600278,
-0.0322833583,
-0.0363717079,
0.0362272859,
0.0274492428,
0.0681647211,
0.0343076661,
0.0140096629,
-0.0081987316,
-0.0387832783,
0.0061660511,
-0.0560154244,
0.0128452005,
-0.0008105125,
-0.0146117406,
0.0004201937,
0.0339213498,
-0.019456394,
0.0309743304,
-0.04873484,
-0.0360186622,
-0.054280661,
0.0393606685,
0.0681153759,
0.0086026303,
-0.0048324727,
-0.0253951252,
-0.0042084092,
-0.0510492846,
0.0011542909,
0.0346924625,
0.0028203786,
0.0497310832,
-0.0251829028,
0.0568691157,
-0.0257650651,
0.028315343,
-0.0224840418,
-0.0227349661,
-0.0319937132,
0.0189955775,
0.0164432321,
-0.0083899572,
0.0020337144,
-0.069465667,
0.0093149589,
0.0035800019,
0.0240277611,
-0.0002185265,
0.0508729182,
0.0119389705,
0.0058631864,
0.0075557921,
-0.0700423792,
0.0717842579,
-0.0174157955,
0.0068219425,
-0.0385620631,
-0.0475180484,
-0.0609739237,
0.0443635285,
0.0086650513,
0.0007414214,
-0.0581519194,
-0.0382400304,
-0.0393293649,
0.007058295,
0.0396890156,
-0.0123183038,
0.0137460036,
-0.0284810364,
0.0400747135,
0.0056605856,
0.0101886867,
-0.0393497236,
-0.0347478725,
0.0560319386,
-0.0036782976,
-0.0275348872,
0.0097675379,
-5.645395006e-33,
0.0058693788,
-0.0516873673,
0.0243675373,
-0.0068769841,
0.0275594853,
0.0344068222,
-0.0385305882,
0.014100099,
0.0427282676,
0.0035841551,
-0.0068401918,
-0.0245433711,
0.0299231168,
0.0057470272,
0.0082951402,
-0.0147127993,
0.0225651972,
-0.0215706006,
-0.0054532783,
-0.0456130281,
0.0042232391,
0.044975616,
0.0198010616,
-0.088142626,
0.0062981667,
0.0334181376,
0.0160914846,
-0.0955287591,
0.0431116968,
0.0159883555,
-0.0339289941,
0.005942096,
0.0429564565,
0.0043989294,
0.0019019856,
0.0333502442,
-0.089179866,
-0.0084472382,
0.0219347738,
0.0198966991,
-0.0240223333,
-0.0063465652,
0.0720132217,
-0.0357986987,
-0.0106921885,
-0.0019766765,
0.0323098861,
-0.0137557304,
-0.0212983694,
-0.0439311899,
-0.0789308921,
0.0562104583,
0.014969755,
0.0261672419,
0.0555420481,
0.0235247668,
-0.0695077106,
0.014361497,
-0.036785122,
-0.0154549386,
0.0887786821,
0.0140425209,
0.0172326621,
-0.0371517204,
0.0075061703,
0.0483903028,
0.0536372066,
-0.0419277847,
-0.0576489121,
0.0052298247,
-0.0105245905,
-0.0015211094,
0.0272211172,
-0.0064844596,
0.0655815452,
-0.0001562806,
-0.066327028,
0.0692781582,
-0.0543762445,
0.0334635265,
-0.0020652816,
-0.0073499465,
-0.0529207848,
0.0100839967,
0.0369123332,
-0.0201421864,
-0.0126414793,
-0.0376069807,
0.0214926079,
-0.006342323,
-0.013884427,
0.0273208469,
0.0220090132,
0.0150751239,
0.0083761839,
-0.0439426862,
0.0511813983,
0.0652591512,
-0.0474807471,
-0.061867699,
-0.0871286094,
-0.0382946953,
0.0113251237,
0.0317006558,
0.0719984397,
-0.0055655004,
0.0231999606,
-0.0216204338,
-0.0534035154,
-0.0075292941,
0.0450811349,
0.0072199074,
0.0143636912,
0.0842641816,
0.0318139829,
0.0185391326,
0.0204504803,
0.0349047221,
0.0035336909,
-0.0252049062,
-0.002264393,
-0.0006474474,
-0.0066279941,
-0.0304685161,
-0.0263566505,
0.0151166189,
-0.0231121648,
0.0225645714,
0.0196131561,
-0.0217045974,
0.008802684,
0.0508870333,
2.968e-7,
0.0854358748,
0.0677738488,
0.0591469929,
-0.0159478486,
0.0181425605,
-0.0197282601,
0.0137637667,
-0.0323141068,
-0.0026815357,
0.0065090763,
0.0737737194,
-0.0274956468,
0.0123542054,
0.0353679508,
-0.0720395893,
-0.0111496644,
-0.0016800923,
-0.0385395102,
-0.0687739775,
0.0220224373,
0.0922640115,
0.0105990022,
-0.0507415831,
-0.0073996531,
0.0057403785,
0.0245001353,
-0.0049136719,
-0.0013590851,
0.0449457318,
-0.0143666202,
0.0228795875,
-0.0048223929,
-0.0096081095,
0.0698506162,
0.0104117785,
-0.011860365,
0.0254280288,
0.0642750487,
-0.0621211603,
0.0473472439,
0.0523492359,
-0.0220043249,
0.0217254311,
0.0082775317,
0.0502770878,
-0.0398457348,
-0.0567911528,
0.0316752568,
-0.0120704593,
0.0186622217,
0.0490725674,
-0.0097796582,
-0.0295447186,
0.0176361613,
0.0083038621,
-0.005136108,
-0.0488559753,
-0.03207504,
0.0212939046,
0.0089321425,
0.0272726808,
0.0140853561,
0.0318238214,
-0.0221666805,
0.0421795882,
-0.0857552737,
-0.0009236996,
2.840189732e-34,
0.0191276632,
0.0141194612,
0.0066609364,
0.0262721311,
-0.0111918328,
0.0081183519,
-0.0246086009,
0.0223076977,
-0.0049025803,
-0.0389057957,
0.0221984088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12382v1 | CommonsenseVIS: Visualizing and Understanding Commonsense Reasoning Capabilities of Natural Language Models | 2023-07-23T17:16:13 | 2023-07-23T17:16:13 | Xingbo Wang, Renfei Huang, Zhihua Jin, Tianqing Fang, Huamin Qu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Recently, large pretrained language models have achieved compelling
performance on commonsense benchmarks. Nevertheless, it is unclear what
commonsense knowledge the models learn and whether they solely exploit spurious
patterns. Feature attributions are popular explainability techniques that
identify important input concepts for model outputs. However, commonsense
knowledge tends to be implicit and rarely explicitly presented in inputs. These
methods cannot infer models' implicit reasoning over mentioned concepts. We
present CommonsenseVIS, a visual explanatory system that utilizes external
commonsense knowledge bases to contextualize model behavior for commonsense
question-answering. Specifically, we extract relevant commonsense knowledge in
inputs as references to align model behavior with human knowledge. Our system
features multi-level visualization and interactive model probing and editing
for different concepts and their underlying relations. Through a user study, we
show that CommonsenseVIS helps NLP experts conduct a systematic and scalable
visual analysis of models' relational reasoning over concepts in different
situations. | [
0.0140632223,
0.04050887,
-0.01184553,
0.048761487,
0.0149671473,
0.0079706619,
-0.0175638292,
0.0183047503,
0.0043164012,
-0.0210797731,
-0.0124729099,
0.0795597285,
-0.0015506555,
0.0216688756,
0.0261731427,
-0.0549902394,
0.0215394292,
-0.0070152553,
-0.0225306861,
0.0432830304,
0.0249418654,
0.0387331247,
-0.0149502782,
0.0722644702,
-0.0221576467,
-0.0644220114,
-0.019429097,
-0.009518059,
-0.008408484,
-0.0147394538,
-0.0472260416,
0.0303934887,
0.0437998883,
-0.0122712217,
0.0000021026,
0.0074817487,
0.0275550894,
0.0163545515,
-0.0228817482,
0.0382476337,
-0.0027688679,
-0.0066888668,
0.0345852114,
-0.0051014605,
-0.0393601619,
0.0516915917,
0.0293930136,
0.033952035,
0.078911148,
-0.0377826802,
-0.0172000434,
-0.0193733945,
-0.046428781,
0.0361817852,
0.0078803338,
-0.0386822559,
-0.0181616377,
0.0429789163,
-0.0017133334,
-0.0156088229,
-0.004997748,
0.0400473885,
0.0265787821,
-0.0588769875,
0.0081258779,
0.0176962819,
0.0022976333,
-0.0187354106,
-0.005889927,
0.0916195735,
0.0260010734,
-0.0308390986,
-0.0110846506,
-0.0203536525,
0.0180465821,
0.0773689896,
-0.0385649279,
-0.0106893107,
0.0152903516,
-0.0037430881,
0.0103789316,
-0.0209801905,
0.029496517,
0.0421268754,
0.0080903359,
0.0327394307,
-0.012881998,
0.0320084542,
-0.0177309494,
0.0048180865,
-0.018932607,
-0.0362989381,
0.014628822,
0.0753686503,
-0.0324014463,
0.025199173,
0.0130070839,
-0.0101991082,
0.0035629615,
-0.0480632,
0.04261766,
0.0143838879,
-0.0359112062,
0.0527153797,
0.0057747741,
0.0293066353,
-0.0011197485,
0.0089679128,
0.0023494547,
0.0042716158,
-0.0672452226,
-0.0455821007,
-0.0421634614,
-0.0212855954,
-0.051756613,
-0.0138129313,
0.0245557297,
-0.0209838673,
-0.0226030461,
-0.0035121436,
0.0273859259,
0.0585156046,
-0.0224168133,
-0.021857677,
-0.0763977468,
0.0318661556,
-0.0921915546,
0.0321543552,
0.020224981,
-0.0138486791,
-0.0258466732,
0.0087807206,
0.0167790055,
-0.0145951528,
-0.0233726967,
0.0111101968,
-0.0197598785,
0.0266102459,
-0.0432210192,
-0.0561100878,
0.018986728,
0.009222609,
-0.0305214711,
-0.0315946005,
-0.0207792465,
0.0171429012,
-0.0024619994,
-0.0068064821,
-0.0034251336,
0.015018044,
-0.0340528414,
0.0952723399,
-0.0402004309,
-0.0087929145,
-0.0031406656,
0.020256428,
0.0266895313,
0.0561567172,
-0.010597338,
-0.0231312178,
0.0360834934,
-0.0218389723,
0.0378966294,
-0.0130627379,
0.0191021692,
-0.0003045565,
-0.0361090228,
0.0248050615,
-0.0547515154,
0.0298632793,
0.0473917052,
-0.0294807963,
-0.0121154618,
0.0044082101,
0.0390871428,
0.0977191627,
-0.0006241094,
0.0391149633,
0.0345064737,
0.0040962379,
0.0179127418,
0.0126447203,
-0.0256172884,
0.0398816578,
-0.0358685255,
0.0025380168,
-0.0668414384,
0.0097258389,
-0.006398154,
-0.0146147273,
-0.0176856983,
0.0114473403,
0.0271843132,
-0.0196242817,
0.0251141321,
0.0347002968,
-0.0110625587,
0.074941054,
0.0293657482,
-0.0710135698,
-0.0096168099,
-0.0281681698,
0.0233109985,
0.0760858804,
0.0636662692,
-0.0057906494,
-0.020926429,
0.0137846339,
0.0118709104,
0.0468481965,
0.0195250399,
-0.0284794867,
0.0199683886,
-0.0146915624,
-0.0377703793,
-0.0490227379,
0.0155091798,
-0.0090674888,
0.02895041,
-0.005902335,
-0.0019602438,
-0.0914564282,
-0.0238793828,
0.023062909,
-0.022172071,
0.0029305313,
-0.0498342626,
0.0100592915,
-0.0031644802,
0.0285104737,
0.0282635633,
0.0231673922,
0.0184139088,
0.0083267912,
0.0212012604,
0.0685239509,
-0.0169314034,
-0.0486737378,
0.027338637,
-0.0644881427,
-0.0394235402,
0.0089082792,
-0.013482064,
-0.0424940847,
0.00148332,
-0.0481366739,
0.0270672869,
-0.0482988693,
-0.0461452119,
-0.0116646755,
-0.0290751681,
0.0071335789,
0.0762294754,
0.0075245812,
-0.0130398879,
0.0172830876,
-0.0110416263,
0.0206847694,
0.0087230923,
0.0256047882,
-0.0204845667,
0.0006597874,
-0.0148175228,
-0.0029904537,
0.0184269026,
-0.0535655208,
0.0563624837,
-0.0672553927,
-0.0352868102,
-0.0014488696,
0.0018306836,
0.0078859283,
-0.0135835344,
0.0250062011,
-0.0409675762,
-0.0063411118,
0.0086545255,
0.0014571189,
-0.0008546148,
0.0774693415,
0.0025399737,
0.0072416519,
-0.0285734907,
0.0158667229,
-0.0244867131,
0.0502597466,
0.0396219604,
0.0865184739,
-0.0306572188,
-0.0054742903,
-0.0153288655,
0.0165492464,
0.0182239674,
-0.0601233207,
0.0499496534,
0.0090847434,
-0.0276146065,
0.0526423492,
-0.0145699484,
0.107090652,
0.0273789521,
-0.0043817027,
-0.0372531973,
0.0091439513,
-0.0069188159,
0.0283447467,
-0.0342333838,
-0.017696565,
-0.0149440253,
0.0692188665,
-0.0133360298,
0.0188309513,
-0.0718384087,
0.0414571539,
0.0050127939,
-0.0045639174,
-0.0716814846,
-0.0036446902,
0.0170501433,
0.0662426725,
-0.0203328412,
-0.0468114056,
0.065155521,
-0.0329336673,
0.0131954784,
-0.0184017643,
-0.0159472562,
-0.0292850826,
0.0897056833,
-0.050257884,
-0.0156717822,
-0.0146140857,
0.0033629923,
-0.0149449045,
-0.0304788891,
0.0585354008,
0.0008081157,
0.0346089751,
-0.069620721,
0.0066701402,
0.0130966781,
-0.0131372763,
-0.0103599858,
-0.0508673936,
-0.0368538834,
-0.0055305534,
0.0208985712,
-0.0396301672,
-0.0062174108,
0.0042499565,
0.0464447848,
-0.0011994651,
-0.0002392198,
-0.0118462229,
-0.0144166825,
0.0253287088,
0.0342890732,
0.0757876262,
0.0141973607,
0.0063954033,
0.0080054058,
0.0330931321,
0.0077440087,
-0.0155441044,
-0.0345266573,
0.0364678837,
-0.0134539315,
-0.0132903401,
-0.0003542678,
0.0036905373,
0.0874005631,
-0.0596123189,
-0.024876453,
0.0793169662,
0.0657731444,
-0.0070827827,
0.0194506068,
-0.0252894461,
0.021627862,
0.0308958832,
0.0263669472,
-0.0450136922,
-0.0422584005,
-0.005787068,
0.0060083624,
-0.0099295191,
-0.0266545825,
0.0200679526,
-0.1054979861,
0.0298436023,
-0.0514041819,
-0.0683659464,
-0.0372446999,
-0.0745768473,
0.002284934,
-0.0102303158,
-0.0041204421,
-0.0204761885,
-0.0096933357,
0.0142989103,
-0.0027828056,
-0.0025780948,
-0.0495095178,
0.0352509804,
-0.0285670757,
0.0052570594,
0.0430803373,
0.0846729353,
0.0152328229,
-0.0752915815,
-0.0242252499,
-0.0411246754,
0.076547958,
-0.0241123624,
0.0461719483,
0.0360093787,
-0.0144455461,
-0.0485600531,
0.0337165855,
-0.0379519351,
-0.0476436466,
-0.0064288587,
0.0606933609,
-0.033330135,
-0.0072888019,
-0.0233057421,
0.0053356211,
0.0030625642,
0.0865246207,
0.0942970216,
0.0252154116,
-0.047876846,
-0.0497822687,
-0.0050615384,
-0.038793359,
-0.0674564689,
0.0094516696,
0.0226389114,
-0.0091155367,
-0.0492690243,
-0.0234559737,
0.045968201,
0.034017168,
0.0047931685,
0.0000193703,
-0.0076894006,
0.0164825749,
-0.0386549756,
0.0974913836,
-0.0220517479,
-0.0091377115,
0.0230060276,
-0.0237789564,
0.0059687751,
-0.0017131484,
-0.0320356339,
0.0188773442,
0.0220880378,
-0.0161046702,
-0.0312709436,
0.0221583825,
0.0181045029,
0.0347709022,
-0.0227983389,
-0.0639537796,
0.0400058962,
0.0248925965,
-0.0558491684,
-0.0635741055,
0.0191847142,
-0.0220186114,
0.0151229473,
0.0317643136,
0.0008926943,
-0.0212280285,
-0.0324188024,
0.0186423548,
-0.0557495467,
-0.0048212558,
0.0099854795,
-0.0187599286,
0.0302141476,
0.0077292551,
0.0061543523,
-0.0209062118,
-0.0190726705,
-0.0351795778,
-0.0131064029,
-0.0368473865,
0.0371744856,
0.0165816117,
-0.0508962311,
-0.0034682131,
0.0084870923,
-0.0313691124,
0.0104560303,
-0.0189749375,
0.0443764813,
0.0557446741,
0.0072821206,
-0.0133433761,
-0.0037921551,
-0.0010711321,
-0.0074974042,
-0.0539364517,
0.0278585088,
0.0196250044,
0.09175466,
0.0319814719,
-0.0210099388,
-0.000425188,
0.0017521938,
-0.059594959,
-0.0246391427,
0.0131530734,
0.0496698245,
0.0128344595,
-0.0461472943,
0.0544855706,
-0.0001593018,
-0.0252543483,
0.0548270419,
0.0677713901,
0.0376996398,
-0.0025594584,
0.0629711673,
0.0331836268,
-0.0311549138,
-0.0446952544,
0.0690069422,
-0.0175464991,
0.0349309482,
-0.0030801676,
-0.0501924753,
-0.0174567737,
-0.0106714116,
0.0448623225,
0.0325006358,
0.0260793045,
0.0324155502,
-0.0637008622,
-0.0701591372,
-0.0269527454,
0.0179655273,
-0.0315952413,
-0.0091723911,
0.0240812842,
0.0723826289,
0.037247315,
-0.0574002266,
-0.0175738093,
0.0222024713,
-0.0833896622,
0.0179935712,
-0.0304969884,
-6.533474009e-33,
-0.0415920578,
-0.0958303213,
-0.0003749234,
-0.0500199907,
0.0050388859,
-0.0067738639,
-0.0858266726,
-0.0166850574,
-0.0349327289,
0.0622382611,
-0.0226032194,
0.0583621226,
-0.0016309409,
0.0009276958,
0.0101725692,
-0.0306689143,
0.0236872528,
0.0292938203,
-0.0168537796,
0.0048559289,
0.0257068519,
-0.0193602163,
0.0553845465,
-0.0385315716,
0.0469152518,
0.0236006789,
-0.0131547265,
0.0206979048,
-0.0372982323,
0.068416886,
-0.0316938162,
0.0447860137,
0.0069526872,
-0.0443610251,
0.001421857,
0.0156009709,
-0.0666128993,
-0.0504550375,
0.057371486,
0.0082832072,
-0.0687621236,
-0.0284241047,
0.0229919981,
0.0382611975,
0.0065413127,
-0.0099539086,
0.0761294886,
-0.0225282367,
0.0089399209,
0.0056730811,
-0.0161242224,
0.0207290314,
-0.0607158542,
-0.0247388743,
-0.0051764543,
0.0003481728,
-0.0037858207,
-0.0084043834,
-0.0220243484,
-0.0023243797,
0.0317769907,
-0.0096233999,
0.0802338719,
-0.0291453209,
0.0212007277,
0.0423515327,
-0.0590307675,
-0.0168726612,
-0.0799426958,
0.0302463528,
0.0085270526,
0.0837943628,
0.0853691027,
0.0470586233,
0.0010687781,
0.0261277147,
-0.0383560807,
0.0410263278,
-0.0489189699,
0.0516232103,
0.0001815898,
-0.0007546975,
-0.0150984004,
-0.0058361162,
-0.0468995348,
-0.0491655208,
-0.0326554812,
-0.0083140312,
0.010441619,
-0.0428875126,
-0.0505363531,
0.0265126564,
-0.0362658128,
-0.0145533485,
-0.0102276579,
0.0577407405,
-0.0040021027,
-0.0118298,
0.0114352871,
-0.0026625595,
-0.0064118691,
0.0364146307,
0.0272186007,
0.0123494808,
0.0248321146,
0.0485330857,
0.0197553057,
-0.0339697674,
-0.0022588701,
-0.0177477766,
-0.0410812758,
-0.0421174169,
-0.0505111963,
-0.0298313275,
0.0387123451,
0.0033289725,
-0.0385409668,
0.02340791,
0.0034660203,
0.0212066788,
0.0117801605,
0.0173818413,
-0.0074878796,
-0.0041271606,
-0.0052498025,
-0.030797163,
-0.0514484793,
-0.0515561625,
0.0595522746,
-0.0510986336,
-0.0291323084,
0.0418674946,
2.515e-7,
0.0579844341,
0.0336876363,
0.0368810669,
0.0294861645,
0.0090427278,
0.0569393821,
-0.0037579669,
-0.0345608145,
-0.0103550963,
-0.0606573746,
0.0089174556,
0.0698794797,
0.0530406311,
0.0469096825,
0.0052619493,
-0.0073714573,
-0.0619286261,
-0.0376413316,
-0.0550380759,
0.0012443493,
0.0442250185,
0.0049150568,
-0.0096828546,
-0.0044237869,
0.0074766125,
-0.0687986389,
-0.0032125299,
-0.0410106517,
0.0271209981,
-0.0415901765,
0.0168212205,
-0.001389139,
0.0162528548,
0.0279954877,
-0.0425787196,
-0.0207293499,
-0.0147094121,
0.0361414067,
-0.0342795365,
-0.0265421662,
-0.0365853868,
-0.0546109416,
0.0393163972,
-0.0831928551,
0.0870080888,
-0.0444025062,
-0.0217373632,
-0.0218034126,
0.0094513679,
-0.0233497862,
0.0005910875,
-0.0190804545,
0.0187225528,
0.0111075277,
-0.0143805603,
-0.0242065676,
-0.0059023509,
-0.0458745435,
-0.0354315601,
-0.0092021758,
-0.0012465252,
0.0058245016,
-0.0569666736,
-0.0451999418,
0.0424275696,
-0.0443179309,
-0.0146387639,
2.074408886e-34,
-0.0047147889,
0.0280950647,
0.0310084261,
0.0256060436,
0.0937092975,
-0.0033492425,
-0.0044399947,
-0.0119562745,
0.0366629623,
-0.0436900556,
0.0013390756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12375v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12375v4 | In-Context Learning Learns Label Relationships but Is Not Conventional Learning | 2023-07-23T16:54:41 | 2024-03-13T15:00:20 | Jannik Kossen, Yarin Gal, Tom Rainforth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The predictions of Large Language Models (LLMs) on downstream tasks often
improve significantly when including examples of the input--label relationship
in the context. However, there is currently no consensus about how this
in-context learning (ICL) ability of LLMs works. For example, while Xie et al.
(2021) liken ICL to a general-purpose learning algorithm, Min et al. (2022)
argue ICL does not even learn label relationships from in-context examples. In
this paper, we provide novel insights into how ICL leverages label information,
revealing both capabilities and limitations. To ensure we obtain a
comprehensive picture of ICL behavior, we study probabilistic aspects of ICL
predictions and thoroughly examine the dynamics of ICL as more examples are
provided. Our experiments show that ICL predictions almost always depend on
in-context labels and that ICL can learn truly novel tasks in-context. However,
we also find that ICL struggles to fully overcome prediction preferences
acquired from pre-training data and, further, that ICL does not consider all
in-context information equally. | [
0.0136361299,
0.0437488779,
-0.003271702,
0.0502959341,
-0.0154367117,
0.0270139184,
0.009446987,
-0.0112708909,
-0.0063266358,
-0.0464942306,
-0.0689695477,
-0.0346175991,
0.0217325147,
0.0019004269,
0.0273978878,
-0.0364478081,
0.0129042407,
-0.0464893468,
-0.0010802208,
-0.0017921287,
-0.0131396158,
0.0007169283,
0.011790568,
0.0253038406,
-0.0278343484,
-0.0232312754,
0.0132758543,
0.0095393471,
-0.0343562402,
-0.0267747939,
0.029217707,
0.0463467538,
0.014706661,
0.0134353423,
0.0000020156,
-0.0692409277,
-0.0131530911,
-0.0344006829,
-0.0053798319,
0.0027135534,
0.0144225536,
0.0047618826,
-0.0084409602,
0.0123800244,
-0.0380391479,
-0.0134326434,
0.029179683,
0.0446235836,
-0.0076222029,
0.0581049919,
-0.0084126797,
0.0062241177,
-0.010305264,
-0.0553924628,
0.046730455,
-0.0698494688,
0.0238575228,
-0.037839219,
-0.0264589153,
0.0291935373,
-0.035012804,
0.0477706157,
0.0265325233,
0.0011374734,
0.0125406859,
0.0827559829,
0.0064966446,
-0.0259861797,
0.0129745128,
0.0708939061,
-0.026886778,
-0.0293303356,
-0.0110771684,
-0.0204735119,
0.0051071304,
-0.0190531183,
-0.0447535031,
0.0152715975,
-0.0065792464,
0.0282001588,
0.0293085519,
0.0210993364,
0.0640609935,
-0.0026824288,
-0.0134904236,
0.0826445222,
0.0014425426,
-0.0346331783,
0.0307177007,
0.0093518347,
-0.027998535,
-0.0444648825,
-0.0327870324,
-0.0070478688,
-0.0499423854,
0.054641515,
-0.0399395451,
-0.0117968926,
-0.0121135889,
-0.0294299684,
-0.0000880089,
0.010694962,
-0.0238461569,
0.0442160927,
-0.0076393685,
0.0274558738,
0.0033057332,
0.0252394602,
-0.0509391949,
-0.0247777291,
-0.0375085436,
-0.0010448217,
-0.0300075822,
0.0227135718,
0.017020518,
-0.0057799099,
-0.021967357,
0.0575867556,
-0.0192378219,
0.0197914839,
0.0258801263,
-0.002357234,
-0.0351778828,
-0.0187450219,
-0.0202946626,
0.0203247536,
-0.0015363577,
0.0273852572,
-0.0052659106,
-0.0163337216,
-0.005903983,
-0.0027077713,
0.0075792829,
-0.0339920893,
0.0157265142,
0.0695447028,
-0.0113083059,
-0.0420130678,
-0.0172313005,
-0.0033360387,
-0.0230332464,
-0.0616550259,
0.003146024,
-0.0539650731,
-0.0063059516,
0.0487741902,
0.019709371,
-0.0619905293,
0.0125782071,
0.0240006614,
-0.0547098815,
0.0935802534,
0.0399690159,
0.0118282521,
0.0186671969,
0.0139974933,
0.0214554109,
0.0581871457,
-0.0076369392,
-0.0086586019,
0.0213505942,
0.002661898,
0.014556882,
0.0639555678,
0.0317452513,
0.0170808025,
-0.0410990603,
-0.0006174546,
0.0729517266,
0.0332383066,
0.031487152,
0.0105001666,
0.0030956061,
0.0003296807,
0.1022094041,
0.029605221,
-0.0045108343,
-0.0201194398,
-0.0084347138,
-0.0148042887,
-0.0190097652,
0.0053109201,
-0.0978334844,
0.0188261885,
0.0052568829,
0.0013156963,
0.0321819298,
-0.0225714315,
-0.0340056568,
-0.0341035873,
-0.0172617882,
-0.0333468877,
-0.0243951883,
0.0160299987,
0.0528187156,
0.0590113923,
-0.0420210436,
0.0430880226,
0.0523205884,
0.0062778643,
0.0068085603,
-0.0283541884,
0.0135977874,
0.0219834596,
0.0253142416,
-0.0507057533,
-0.0095105963,
-0.0053724176,
0.0490004979,
0.0360330604,
0.0144971432,
-0.031760931,
0.0279445257,
-0.0261897594,
-0.0302087143,
-0.0020882797,
0.0205654167,
-0.0096006189,
0.0314717405,
-0.0062063895,
0.0032868336,
-0.0617026426,
-0.0029720953,
0.035717234,
-0.0515008271,
-0.0580566414,
0.0437654778,
0.0197034534,
0.0054998314,
-0.0297694672,
0.00571757,
0.0295102689,
0.0423873998,
-0.0275965072,
-0.0139879687,
0.0111440206,
-0.1029173359,
-0.057238698,
0.0331914313,
0.0177774355,
-0.0112842228,
-0.0239520557,
-0.0246255342,
-0.0212110952,
-0.0003698405,
-0.003341753,
0.0696617439,
-0.0128820594,
0.0171097666,
-0.0024745753,
-0.005152226,
-0.0490175821,
0.0621582903,
-0.0099670608,
0.0052353363,
-0.0117420666,
0.0717682242,
-0.0219154563,
0.035711363,
-0.0110816639,
0.0145385154,
0.0079828678,
-0.0043235291,
0.0095726484,
-0.0034270345,
-0.0488157943,
-0.0099353837,
-0.086585708,
-0.0074391467,
-0.0258310512,
-0.0241368096,
0.0294247475,
-0.0002939347,
0.0092270216,
-0.0309798177,
-0.0281081013,
-0.0244954824,
-0.0240906887,
0.0256253593,
0.0286686625,
0.0286142733,
-0.0046976125,
-0.0302324854,
-0.0116778072,
-0.0185509771,
0.0605586544,
-0.0151298223,
-0.0225553364,
-0.0347939283,
0.0365763344,
-0.0027060157,
0.0269752182,
-0.0313571356,
0.0336835012,
-0.0047400384,
-0.0380167328,
0.0375067182,
0.0515762903,
-0.013589046,
0.0153352264,
0.0614546239,
-0.0013927092,
-0.051677756,
-0.0012058528,
-0.0313073024,
-0.0520334505,
-0.0545310862,
-0.0000222068,
-0.0151857762,
0.0895818174,
0.0003408876,
-0.002649684,
-0.030597508,
0.0009873703,
-0.0150790615,
-0.0225331821,
-0.0893462449,
0.0142520582,
-0.0329603292,
0.0405387096,
-0.0132316444,
-0.0739925206,
0.0496294685,
-0.0126209911,
-0.0128375264,
-0.0440324247,
-0.0231750123,
-0.0388373174,
0.0896655396,
0.0212262105,
-0.0086945351,
0.0553220436,
-0.0166421272,
-0.0787145495,
0.0168730412,
0.0070242421,
-0.0089800553,
0.0585959479,
-0.0460520796,
0.0210001599,
0.0250033755,
-0.0434597656,
-0.0615928546,
-0.0289305095,
-0.0194022711,
0.0178390648,
-0.0411311574,
-0.0027234359,
0.0040835151,
-0.0289899595,
0.0287856683,
0.0374633856,
-0.0085234381,
-0.0123784374,
-0.0099168289,
0.0475795344,
0.0395980068,
-0.0443922877,
-0.0078626936,
-0.0432935767,
-0.0014198089,
0.0185895432,
0.0704354197,
-0.0073157973,
-0.0137376124,
-0.0030968096,
0.0210136417,
0.010838083,
-0.0424302518,
0.0620007478,
0.009879482,
-0.0494258665,
-0.0372684598,
0.1122700199,
0.0075255972,
-0.0960177928,
0.00457631,
0.012077013,
0.0154265873,
0.0614032447,
0.0114329681,
-0.0401910469,
-0.0391003639,
0.0195485745,
-0.0065672128,
0.0101956045,
-0.022665171,
-0.0187528543,
-0.124925077,
-0.0044004284,
-0.0016701996,
-0.0676715896,
-0.0121444371,
-0.0569632612,
-0.0017456936,
-0.0141519392,
0.0354506113,
0.0070876102,
-0.0246399362,
-0.0012944224,
0.0177971143,
0.0084376726,
-0.0607863516,
0.0509435125,
-0.0366057605,
0.0396085754,
0.0727993026,
0.0227789376,
-0.0184048712,
-0.0035202301,
0.1104194075,
-0.0064974385,
0.0029080696,
-0.0171203539,
0.0413492024,
-0.0018588366,
-0.0067566917,
0.0201808531,
0.0258042607,
-0.0530757084,
-0.0175403431,
0.0115039423,
0.0829968229,
-0.0030326366,
-0.0188663527,
0.0203679111,
-0.0430531539,
0.0397362933,
0.0797844082,
0.0248338245,
-0.0804133341,
-0.0279619731,
-0.0243592635,
0.0137515478,
0.0141088516,
-0.0052895634,
0.0162844118,
-0.0284385309,
-0.0296487138,
-0.0611337349,
-0.0348880701,
0.0213230681,
0.0159010366,
-0.0008099526,
0.0413191393,
-0.0065569896,
-0.0002495741,
-0.0578062721,
0.0366130061,
-0.0335074887,
0.0294003878,
-0.0362875536,
-0.0101774065,
0.053874366,
-0.0256335046,
-0.0232470855,
0.0244143419,
-0.085702166,
-0.0553833395,
-0.0100142593,
0.0141226212,
0.0151168313,
0.0999838859,
0.0004200061,
-0.0452160798,
0.0435134545,
0.0406919681,
0.0044401982,
0.0414825603,
0.008970446,
-0.0079492209,
0.0065373173,
0.0455691591,
-0.0528663881,
0.0033189838,
0.0506769903,
-0.0044299974,
-0.019916499,
-0.0127469478,
0.0333329812,
-0.0452512093,
0.0630013794,
-0.0250148457,
-0.0104092751,
-0.024365047,
0.0321048237,
0.0255487412,
-0.0449312665,
-0.0071820645,
-0.0192601439,
0.0459216833,
0.0414638519,
0.0052306782,
0.032450065,
0.018612463,
0.0591776818,
0.0047009271,
-0.0439256616,
0.0092093106,
0.022666879,
0.060941074,
0.0189572442,
0.0007480904,
0.0254245382,
0.024302071,
0.0582686886,
-0.0059526809,
0.0249941666,
0.0245026853,
-0.0010157862,
-0.0265227966,
-0.0144892791,
-0.072003819,
-0.0151094627,
-0.0433158949,
0.0092794988,
0.0611758232,
-0.049778793,
0.020863764,
-0.0348954089,
0.0027961996,
-0.0465785302,
0.0076408014,
-0.0155047663,
-0.0409760512,
0.0261531733,
0.0053305984,
-0.0113486098,
0.0253951903,
0.097267203,
0.0413034149,
0.045500733,
-0.0026109139,
0.0152339544,
-0.0125440331,
0.0107844323,
0.0107694808,
0.058026433,
-0.0206826497,
0.0190432165,
-0.0222335141,
-0.0633762404,
-0.0006348712,
-0.0387289487,
-0.0232664607,
-0.0212974194,
0.0407767296,
0.062313389,
-0.0072434307,
-0.0064947521,
-0.0290520303,
-0.0170039497,
0.0143895289,
-0.0294179227,
-0.0367778353,
-6.450515699e-33,
-0.0199295133,
-0.0357336365,
0.0014666957,
0.0221763942,
0.031054737,
0.0160635971,
-0.0456969216,
0.0175519157,
-0.0053604264,
0.0048193745,
-0.021879131,
0.012114835,
0.006767272,
0.0396125913,
0.0407015197,
-0.043102324,
0.0215253476,
-0.0059591276,
0.0005956313,
0.0206340645,
0.0240620039,
0.0430037826,
0.0757481009,
-0.090442501,
0.0210710932,
-0.0276848208,
0.0014447765,
0.0413282886,
-0.0246567372,
0.0359705165,
-0.0102933999,
0.0520396568,
0.0415105894,
-0.0603896305,
-0.0328291059,
0.0336096063,
-0.0935676992,
-0.0071584969,
-0.0072832741,
0.0082971966,
-0.0230593011,
-0.003739475,
0.0431013107,
0.0089020981,
-0.0223151576,
-0.0317682065,
0.0537049808,
-0.0085080592,
-0.0486991927,
-0.0174525734,
-0.0463755131,
0.0023849229,
0.0282490496,
-0.0043149209,
0.0119323544,
0.0101431971,
0.0123228291,
0.0405529849,
-0.0564105473,
0.0154623985,
-0.0383238904,
0.0537426732,
0.0501377694,
0.0562776774,
0.0110721597,
0.0518750995,
0.0279079247,
0.0290800203,
0.0187213346,
-0.066034168,
0.0538748503,
0.0333157517,
-0.0054312935,
0.0281552467,
0.0348066054,
0.0019987181,
-0.0610088855,
-0.000360199,
0.0187097155,
-0.0137979425,
0.0140510043,
0.0172623191,
-0.0215761606,
-0.0640260428,
-0.0784578919,
-0.0114061553,
-0.0452254154,
0.0071816924,
0.0396399386,
0.0336178988,
0.0356781334,
0.0131889274,
0.0076444279,
-0.0393337049,
-0.064911902,
0.0258078445,
-0.0238780938,
0.007470658,
0.0075169145,
0.0189972986,
-0.0776543692,
-0.0233602617,
-0.0234159511,
-0.011722724,
0.0082657728,
0.0090065971,
0.0717679337,
0.0105238538,
-0.0674253553,
-0.0328926928,
-0.064294599,
-0.0064913309,
0.0265052933,
0.0094094146,
0.0403555185,
0.0194462873,
-0.0229059029,
0.061145179,
0.0485146977,
-0.0150666432,
-0.0163978189,
-0.018860247,
-0.0300901867,
-0.0008564271,
-0.0265609715,
-0.0524864979,
-0.0277671237,
0.0029905168,
0.0680577457,
-0.0251786876,
-0.0161316395,
-0.0177002233,
2.655e-7,
0.0430508964,
0.050212115,
-0.0177146513,
0.0013436193,
0.0641453937,
0.0637759417,
-0.0455818996,
0.0305088665,
0.0146386344,
-0.0305748899,
0.0047372095,
0.0007098677,
0.0531388,
0.0214538276,
-0.0815433189,
-0.0225770362,
-0.0631691962,
0.0177389458,
-0.0344365127,
0.0142725324,
-0.0128591573,
0.1035862043,
0.0460266322,
-0.0357456952,
0.0002952568,
-0.0462088846,
0.0848378763,
-0.0612211563,
0.0281904824,
0.014848751,
-0.0636051968,
0.0264809895,
0.0138007719,
0.0392703786,
-0.0325511657,
0.0202620197,
0.0037509245,
0.0606410764,
0.0008537609,
-0.0351078361,
0.0008024495,
0.0472395346,
-0.0071619484,
-0.0695848018,
0.081817627,
-0.0711429343,
0.0013762271,
-0.0363696404,
0.035080757,
-0.0111131882,
0.0009864492,
0.0206479132,
-0.0068747606,
0.0062413099,
0.0037222202,
-0.0042202794,
-0.0271863993,
-0.0863021761,
-0.0814225674,
0.0538417995,
-0.0531717464,
-0.0315278098,
-0.0378835015,
0.0222585686,
0.0422439352,
-0.0503259003,
0.0109428223,
2.408042422e-34,
-0.0019254697,
-0.0001244408,
0.0054223854,
0.0528353415,
-0.0087187979,
-0.0354453623,
-0.0179482549,
0.0245497767,
0.0379536189,
-0.0467935577,
0.0130918259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12371v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12371v2 | PSentScore: Evaluating Sentiment Polarity in Dialogue Summarization | 2023-07-23T16:46:01 | 2024-05-03T16:48:50 | Yongxin Zhou, Fabien Ringeval, François Portet | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic dialogue summarization is a well-established task with the goal of
distilling the most crucial information from human conversations into concise
textual summaries. However, most existing research has predominantly focused on
summarizing factual information, neglecting the affective content, which can
hold valuable insights for analyzing, monitoring, or facilitating human
interactions. In this paper, we introduce and assess a set of measures
PSentScore, aimed at quantifying the preservation of affective content in
dialogue summaries. Our findings indicate that state-of-the-art summarization
models do not preserve well the affective content within their summaries.
Moreover, we demonstrate that a careful selection of the training set for
dialogue samples can lead to improved preservation of affective content in the
generated summaries, albeit with a minor reduction in content-related metrics. | [
0.0147136971,
0.0085726203,
0.0029874751,
0.0026799655,
-0.0362479948,
0.0136122862,
-0.0540331528,
-0.0459155813,
-0.0221455805,
-0.0289955605,
-0.0163515527,
-0.0395022891,
0.0121411439,
0.0209343415,
-0.0388813429,
-0.0956515744,
0.025052838,
0.042136576,
0.0239532851,
0.0085261036,
0.0324557051,
0.0197407324,
-0.0001361127,
0.0179540534,
0.0137915583,
0.0091848085,
-0.00107319,
0.0265146103,
0.0628245175,
-0.0106185181,
0.0228315461,
0.0024678926,
-0.0191299245,
-0.0455220677,
0.0000017538,
-0.035277769,
-0.0240029059,
-0.0255434513,
0.0303185992,
0.0236157924,
0.0867876187,
-0.0091622444,
0.0140976543,
0.0239453278,
-0.0178319085,
0.0105037922,
0.010432235,
0.0868736058,
0.1047068462,
0.0666618198,
-0.0070214011,
-0.0137131857,
-0.0048169126,
-0.0027260759,
-0.0388563089,
0.0019286652,
-0.0095352875,
0.0166746993,
-0.0450882986,
-0.0495362766,
0.0094311647,
0.0047115637,
-0.0191574823,
0.0006638428,
-0.0339428969,
-0.0060472004,
-0.0433573611,
-0.0058297114,
0.011017384,
0.0555394329,
0.0303753018,
0.0264767613,
0.0261312965,
-0.0082471212,
-0.0146355648,
-0.0452637821,
-0.0461303517,
0.0296998676,
-0.0114440983,
0.0327861495,
-0.0365647189,
0.0653906614,
-0.0357360095,
0.0207650345,
0.0141485129,
0.0082190102,
-0.0198611468,
-0.0175936092,
-0.0232376084,
0.0133324414,
-0.0023796028,
-0.0141045013,
0.0334671214,
-0.0120725306,
0.014888077,
-0.0083890464,
-0.0128893796,
-0.0132572334,
0.0083225574,
-0.0452440865,
-0.0227488615,
0.0048945863,
0.0019347388,
0.0445356406,
0.0076526669,
0.0067303479,
0.0595517009,
0.0113034928,
-0.0578297526,
-0.0028982633,
-0.0198990926,
0.0320992619,
-0.0125599951,
0.0547771864,
-0.0197014511,
-0.0297876112,
-0.0617696345,
-0.0171447881,
-0.0121511389,
-0.0168847274,
0.0185116716,
0.03094537,
0.0307798404,
-0.016762821,
-0.0068253847,
0.0649150535,
-0.0386969671,
-0.0065753227,
0.0239187013,
0.0359270014,
0.0018995067,
0.0583597235,
0.0063202363,
0.0266221128,
0.0032153418,
0.0287503358,
-0.0017430419,
-0.0514403321,
-0.0380679481,
-0.0184982009,
-0.044958014,
-0.0358404592,
0.0013076926,
-0.0146727003,
0.016912695,
-0.002844641,
-0.0326540545,
-0.0261877421,
0.0103806295,
-0.0142645976,
-0.0092067681,
0.0094806384,
0.0006848513,
0.0053894753,
0.0227462091,
0.0054289852,
-0.0102338018,
0.0275888126,
0.0395732783,
0.0637392029,
0.0652798712,
0.0104735764,
0.0134639563,
-0.0067347158,
-0.0088302456,
-0.0093185762,
0.0036575797,
-0.0261609796,
-0.047563795,
-0.037780121,
0.0306557585,
0.0557758324,
-0.0166293588,
-0.0137945293,
0.0580097251,
0.0454651117,
-0.0594688505,
0.0212710351,
-0.0136201438,
0.051627323,
0.0380840823,
0.0626270846,
0.0011954628,
0.0400555767,
-0.0450088158,
0.0461952873,
0.0942958146,
0.0319428667,
-0.0101413727,
-0.0787120238,
-0.0072138533,
-0.0333049595,
0.0296816528,
-0.0061505381,
0.0130468626,
0.0012432206,
-0.046089232,
0.0254650619,
0.0197614022,
-0.1040035784,
0.0032616984,
-0.0224408917,
0.0034107626,
0.0760080293,
0.0006193079,
-0.0279732421,
-0.0411092229,
-0.0177267585,
0.0010485643,
0.0128026176,
0.0594065897,
-0.0088424617,
0.015476536,
-0.0453731641,
0.0073690447,
-0.0086458428,
0.013241386,
0.0168534443,
-0.0272105765,
-0.0146359038,
0.0285981745,
0.0264349114,
-0.0372101925,
0.0027041689,
-0.002568919,
0.0066967676,
0.0101051265,
-0.0001691066,
0.0350646228,
0.0612320453,
-0.0313131288,
0.0001449659,
0.0466340519,
-0.0144185554,
-0.048969496,
0.0397389308,
-0.0447942577,
-0.0369278751,
0.0091307396,
-0.0449559875,
-0.0043096161,
0.003910773,
-0.0291586984,
-0.0322474279,
0.0511181355,
-0.074447833,
-0.0221696161,
-0.0362499729,
0.0403445549,
0.0076747956,
0.0019108548,
-0.0182256978,
0.0365345702,
-0.0239890628,
-0.0220330935,
0.0302286502,
-0.0599190146,
0.0179196466,
-0.0368342884,
-0.0229584221,
0.0045659291,
0.0013179835,
0.0076819728,
0.0459515117,
-0.0156315845,
-0.0403611995,
-0.053343527,
-0.1006638259,
0.0207352899,
-0.0162712634,
0.0210519228,
0.0330140255,
0.0092332726,
-0.0256896131,
0.0227491166,
-0.0456605032,
-0.0500672869,
0.0377469324,
0.0022699193,
0.0253344718,
0.0305789616,
0.0338284671,
-0.0921062902,
0.0029271471,
-0.0108038215,
0.0108915558,
-0.0284126345,
-0.0089690201,
0.0040131467,
0.045403596,
-0.0338013805,
-0.0314946957,
0.0024290031,
-0.0612755008,
-0.0095841819,
0.0021858655,
0.0388591029,
0.0804159343,
0.0685273781,
-0.0003116019,
0.0085313367,
-0.0226386227,
0.0008753051,
-0.0008576147,
-0.060449034,
0.0451628678,
0.0498262122,
-0.0623090826,
0.0255554467,
0.0476407297,
0.0308861714,
0.0370746814,
-0.0394277312,
0.0052683218,
-0.0245597716,
-0.0022652985,
0.0164296776,
-0.0240846761,
-0.0235192645,
-0.0032940148,
-0.0310670473,
-0.0129308552,
0.0689531788,
-0.0189510453,
0.0067830831,
-0.0659666434,
-0.0042954343,
-0.0531440601,
0.0396082103,
-0.0099935085,
0.0052529806,
-0.0263097268,
0.0244423188,
-0.0297958944,
-0.0712293833,
0.0325435102,
-0.0470483564,
0.0585281663,
-0.0270607118,
-0.0272188168,
0.0066536744,
-0.0155494269,
-0.0026873681,
-0.0259625781,
-0.0250513311,
0.0084285187,
0.0607337542,
-0.0080191409,
0.0065824254,
0.0188433435,
0.0406534448,
-0.000225086,
-0.0281034168,
-0.0016293152,
0.0167266186,
0.0400202423,
0.0415766798,
0.0070248283,
0.0548548363,
-0.0022308661,
0.0338880271,
0.0230602957,
0.0000461599,
0.0047998563,
0.0121544898,
-0.0250973012,
-0.0284155086,
-0.0305714644,
0.0046937694,
-0.0481948815,
0.0705914572,
-0.0111904498,
0.0398570709,
0.1206547916,
0.0286362208,
-0.0211760309,
-0.0349734165,
-0.011169754,
-0.0183527153,
0.0103627397,
-0.0167586468,
-0.0017997669,
-0.0037253462,
-0.0083615808,
0.049167268,
0.0086150179,
-0.0324137509,
-0.016504392,
-0.0878936797,
-0.0103105009,
0.0024855675,
-0.0363057405,
-0.0429243036,
-0.0234871246,
0.0051394328,
-0.0320006534,
0.0115915807,
-0.0203843173,
-0.0032535228,
0.0145724947,
0.0220551398,
-0.0789142922,
0.0285098534,
-0.0117648989,
-0.0211272724,
0.0248908084,
0.0663716123,
0.0646323189,
0.0198357888,
0.0089961486,
0.0201429073,
-0.0372888148,
-0.0105646765,
0.0185664054,
0.090805091,
-0.0137220221,
-0.0009374552,
-0.0276384894,
0.0372636653,
0.0041096569,
0.0007150622,
0.0174733792,
-0.0334882289,
-0.0030223462,
-0.0290189348,
-0.0434913486,
0.0960290879,
-0.0088927159,
0.0883960724,
0.04382734,
-0.0077632708,
-0.008927145,
-0.0152050396,
0.0382178873,
-0.0699975044,
-0.0130050126,
-0.0379284322,
-0.0117194215,
0.0237640589,
-0.1075901538,
-0.0789227486,
0.0089069093,
-0.0163221434,
-0.0554486625,
-0.0351015218,
-0.0183869451,
0.0404144935,
-0.0181760509,
-0.0042024218,
0.0348060876,
-0.0036050137,
-0.036874976,
-0.0317787565,
0.0682457611,
-0.0259708632,
-0.0281753466,
0.0003913972,
-0.0140012978,
-0.0462127961,
0.0071677258,
0.0833791122,
0.0172549151,
0.0145449536,
0.0394991264,
0.0018384397,
-0.0099409446,
0.0552933812,
-0.0085938144,
0.0262041353,
0.0423243828,
0.1040843278,
-0.0286070239,
0.0088061634,
-0.01822602,
0.045288723,
-0.052994255,
0.0222757105,
-0.0266054738,
-0.1106987447,
-0.0094373086,
0.0297159608,
0.0383519679,
0.0120349601,
-0.030187862,
-0.0090000946,
-0.0156348348,
-0.0415471494,
-0.0065936572,
-0.0304142218,
0.011227306,
-0.0430015512,
0.011049103,
-0.0438175388,
0.0514227003,
-0.0227655899,
0.0187280942,
-0.0107940249,
0.0124722216,
-0.0044633839,
-0.0198936686,
-0.0598788522,
0.0159559324,
-0.0534268357,
-0.0034104094,
-0.0193619654,
0.0101384828,
0.0036198245,
0.0441106781,
-0.0036368899,
-0.0081629362,
0.0231604651,
0.0452394821,
-0.0419735201,
0.0303417351,
-0.0489792228,
0.0317996033,
-0.0051719919,
-0.0371388048,
0.0851568803,
-0.002696255,
0.0085928477,
-0.0193421319,
0.0128492201,
0.0259730946,
0.0048483447,
-0.05387339,
0.0140126254,
0.011372759,
0.0189281423,
0.0608911552,
-0.0958834291,
0.0246110894,
0.0147677111,
-0.0233653318,
-0.0448572449,
-0.011988367,
0.0136796189,
0.0064319107,
0.0183449518,
-0.0036680377,
-0.0839473456,
-0.0111602033,
0.0801827237,
0.0077096047,
0.0359096043,
-0.0235712398,
0.0284444112,
0.0315474011,
-0.0210836567,
0.0234441292,
-0.022911679,
0.007705702,
-0.0744750798,
0.0445228405,
-0.0281321872,
-5.453526778e-33,
-0.0457359105,
-0.0057472801,
-0.0534209833,
0.0839832202,
-0.0549786426,
0.0116089853,
-0.0478730574,
0.036452245,
0.0209497027,
0.028210815,
-0.0041764141,
0.0146265328,
0.0037820439,
0.0280275848,
-0.0121403746,
-0.0065008956,
0.0592571571,
-0.0208668076,
-0.043489065,
0.0551219061,
0.0118729733,
-0.0102916602,
0.0144495238,
-0.094063893,
0.0107621085,
0.0066463989,
-0.0229765773,
0.0026760777,
0.0793858245,
0.0233356133,
0.0052974289,
0.0401752442,
0.0193098523,
-0.015068274,
-0.0094298506,
0.0139094731,
-0.0101483986,
-0.0344811194,
0.0191232394,
-0.0277447533,
-0.0304090474,
-0.0227564014,
0.0214358363,
0.0076927515,
-0.0112516927,
-0.0159990843,
0.0268032327,
-0.0401196443,
0.0097130975,
-0.1143370196,
-0.016773941,
0.0278210938,
-0.0404223874,
-0.0687257126,
0.0056253555,
0.0219380595,
0.0292504784,
0.0156978182,
-0.007493855,
0.0244653262,
-0.0117848851,
0.0194250271,
0.010403119,
-0.0201506242,
0.0030760588,
0.100352414,
0.0152204055,
0.0449774079,
-0.0245489627,
0.00032494,
-0.0016836183,
-0.021145463,
0.0569625236,
0.048257716,
-0.0465588123,
0.0137040857,
-0.0055117132,
0.0881899074,
0.0640031844,
0.0044575557,
0.0322678089,
-0.0073873079,
0.0012459881,
0.015104604,
-0.0055512697,
-0.0475392416,
-0.0005055392,
-0.0227318965,
-0.02549766,
0.016893398,
-0.0669747144,
-0.054566741,
0.0005391365,
-0.0307539273,
0.0467819087,
0.0375346541,
-0.0606520884,
0.0275854878,
-0.00019338,
-0.0277709588,
-0.0258524027,
0.037533775,
0.0243987162,
0.0442301333,
0.0075592976,
-0.0292799175,
0.0273182075,
-0.0114488099,
-0.0461301133,
0.0192868412,
0.0402845256,
0.063191317,
-0.0442447439,
0.0438222662,
-0.0313651226,
0.0237809848,
-0.0055846269,
0.0442510359,
-0.0069899592,
0.0455596708,
-0.0036027443,
-0.0138749406,
0.0331828706,
0.0080614882,
-0.0340281054,
0.0185966268,
0.0396230519,
-0.03275235,
-0.0161645878,
-0.0193249881,
-0.0183048267,
-0.0181954931,
2.365e-7,
0.0307015032,
0.0560721271,
0.0697881654,
-0.0210937932,
-0.0124802664,
0.0371969491,
0.0022899916,
-0.0080377916,
0.0450520106,
-0.035839729,
0.0356939994,
0.0107253399,
0.0405254476,
0.0160094965,
-0.108504355,
-0.0004700551,
-0.0451322012,
-0.051009208,
0.0201898292,
-0.0003913958,
0.1047314182,
0.0373817682,
-0.0031130174,
0.0180920251,
-0.016964959,
0.0154549479,
0.0172627252,
-0.040811725,
-0.0330247059,
0.0184603613,
0.0350315049,
-0.0366332419,
-0.0266753156,
-0.0245385971,
0.0013057325,
-0.005340782,
0.0430122353,
0.0483611636,
0.0452268235,
-0.0884900764,
-0.0109910723,
0.0206127409,
-0.0007034282,
0.0109820953,
0.0521885455,
-0.0986033455,
-0.0024621584,
-0.0741797984,
-0.066156745,
0.0103401653,
0.0207013339,
-0.0171304904,
-0.0353519693,
0.0692956746,
-0.0301487297,
-0.013746297,
0.002103013,
-0.0812761709,
-0.0494650453,
0.0032237596,
-0.0017890338,
-0.0454224795,
-0.0032852071,
0.0339760035,
-0.0201596189,
-0.0406186581,
0.0241174567,
1.764776557e-34,
0.0938066691,
-0.024817938,
-0.0363588631,
-0.0352394097,
0.0450579934,
-0.0202465672,
-0.0389391743,
-0.0277960822,
0.0030178428,
-0.0477656052,
0.0204885453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12369v1 | Early Prediction of Alzheimers Disease Leveraging Symptom Occurrences from Longitudinal Electronic Health Records of US Military Veterans | 2023-07-23T16:38:16 | 2023-07-23T16:38:16 | Rumeng Li, Xun Wang, Dan Berlowitz, Brian Silver, Wen Hu, Heather Keating, Raelene Goodwin, Weisong Liu, Honghuang Lin, Hong Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Early prediction of Alzheimer's disease (AD) is crucial for timely
intervention and treatment. This study aims to use machine learning approaches
to analyze longitudinal electronic health records (EHRs) of patients with AD
and identify signs and symptoms that can predict AD onset earlier. We used a
case-control design with longitudinal EHRs from the U.S. Department of Veterans
Affairs Veterans Health Administration (VHA) from 2004 to 2021. Cases were VHA
patients with AD diagnosed after 1/1/2016 based on ICD-10-CM codes, matched 1:9
with controls by age, sex and clinical utilization with replacement. We used a
panel of AD-related keywords and their occurrences over time in a patient's
longitudinal EHRs as predictors for AD prediction with four machine learning
models. We performed subgroup analyses by age, sex, and race/ethnicity, and
validated the model in a hold-out and "unseen" VHA stations group. Model
discrimination, calibration, and other relevant metrics were reported for
predictions up to ten years before ICD-based diagnosis. The study population
included 16,701 cases and 39,097 matched controls. The average number of
AD-related keywords (e.g., "concentration", "speaking") per year increased
rapidly for cases as diagnosis approached, from around 10 to over 40, while
remaining flat at 10 for controls. The best model achieved high discriminative
accuracy (ROCAUC 0.997) for predictions using data from at least ten years
before ICD-based diagnoses. The model was well-calibrated (Hosmer-Lemeshow
goodness-of-fit p-value = 0.99) and consistent across subgroups of age, sex and
race/ethnicity, except for patients younger than 65 (ROCAUC 0.746). Machine
learning models using AD-related keywords identified from EHR notes can predict
future AD diagnoses, suggesting its potential use for identifying AD risk using
EHR notes, offering an affordable way for early screening on large population. | [
-0.003761135,
0.0758206099,
-0.0118732853,
-0.0614360981,
0.0207244456,
0.0318581089,
0.0417592712,
0.0339435227,
0.0798428878,
-0.0091127418,
0.0664895028,
0.0019393383,
0.0055701346,
0.0449068062,
-0.0264174808,
0.0053256117,
0.0653814897,
0.0167542193,
0.0780147314,
0.0001310419,
-0.0269684531,
-0.0367878638,
-0.026451841,
0.0502419397,
-0.0171628576,
-0.0298541691,
0.0438465849,
-0.0512417443,
-0.0043037562,
-0.0389700308,
0.0222101212,
-0.0100517003,
-0.0082955929,
-0.0345948935,
0.0000023196,
-0.0693556219,
-0.0282386784,
0.0097112618,
-0.0267500076,
-0.0330019109,
-0.0184802208,
-0.0120880427,
0.0435351618,
-0.0108198021,
-0.0474528708,
-0.0236941185,
0.0496390052,
0.0296845827,
0.0101462388,
0.0263658576,
-0.0172700863,
0.0147446208,
-0.0041377717,
-0.0045688725,
0.0234378278,
-0.045233082,
0.0548060313,
-0.0203556642,
-0.0696533695,
-0.1128016487,
0.0178062078,
0.0404009745,
-0.0224566478,
0.0996582583,
0.0178447403,
0.095220685,
0.032672286,
0.0249017868,
-0.0353683718,
0.0173354931,
-0.0128130019,
0.0193477441,
0.0030527059,
0.0113211144,
-0.0022115961,
0.0242110398,
-0.042515561,
-0.0533290505,
-0.0021693185,
0.0152391279,
0.0037161065,
0.0054016015,
0.0389148295,
-0.0347342417,
-0.0123168826,
0.0488074645,
-0.0404701494,
-0.0259357914,
0.0282448977,
-0.0138539579,
-0.0345784314,
-0.0131606217,
0.0167945102,
0.0104318606,
-0.0558548607,
-0.0057727778,
0.0089454837,
-0.0242180843,
0.0834683552,
-0.0159299541,
0.0440967269,
0.001034772,
-0.0455561019,
0.0287223887,
-0.0180385485,
0.0366904587,
0.0131296264,
-0.0007163133,
-0.0042395308,
0.0297381077,
-0.0622563213,
0.0377455987,
-0.0172696952,
0.0259505622,
0.06690301,
-0.026529111,
-0.0971909463,
-0.0240338724,
0.0238948073,
-0.0273473673,
0.0269551761,
0.0444724672,
0.032232333,
0.0684672147,
-0.0192975532,
0.0009126528,
-0.0332324877,
0.0159813371,
0.0041959542,
-0.0494683646,
0.0497053191,
-0.0000612421,
-0.005439254,
-0.063137494,
0.036800202,
0.0351952687,
0.0191270877,
-0.0202291273,
-0.0650907978,
-0.009220805,
-0.0368382037,
0.0123057012,
0.0236221328,
-0.0110195512,
0.0248777643,
0.0409718864,
0.0218414683,
-0.0525674522,
-0.0207778588,
-0.039345447,
-0.0155616077,
0.0414323732,
-0.0269059371,
0.0126400562,
0.0360274911,
-0.021831315,
-0.0302873161,
-0.0223893225,
0.0389573611,
-0.0189022869,
0.02365366,
-0.0201874599,
0.0137152225,
0.0520732477,
0.0262131058,
-0.0300301425,
-0.0097447801,
0.0183688849,
-0.0148540875,
0.0420469008,
-0.0008937325,
0.0297942944,
0.0674190223,
-0.0491627865,
0.0209183805,
0.0374580547,
0.031995438,
0.0144374557,
-0.0067066504,
-0.0216105897,
-0.0159899164,
-0.0641809329,
0.025517717,
-0.0145267397,
-0.0394686498,
-0.0351662524,
0.0001609873,
0.0048852111,
-0.0210199505,
-0.0536449961,
-0.0165150948,
-0.0390654765,
0.0337628648,
0.0041615404,
0.0033332766,
-0.0542214625,
-0.0212030914,
-0.0023955395,
0.0085666254,
0.0446695834,
-0.0680909306,
-0.0761235952,
0.0125008551,
0.0491241142,
-0.0053181285,
-0.0099151125,
-0.0130094402,
-0.0323297456,
0.0219259579,
-0.0867431685,
0.0080986479,
0.0129067637,
0.0499212183,
-0.0173764359,
0.0070142965,
0.0522724912,
0.0268830638,
-0.0264008548,
-0.0078810137,
0.0236792918,
-0.0380857587,
-0.0505739786,
-0.0540378541,
0.0561948456,
-0.0161392726,
-0.0165765584,
0.0372560173,
0.0121438205,
0.0754967928,
-0.019314386,
0.0210762769,
0.017137818,
0.0120263221,
-0.0264102947,
-0.0273329671,
-0.025595028,
-0.043015983,
0.0299313888,
-0.0087872762,
0.0526106134,
0.0395147875,
-0.0575453565,
-0.0207041875,
0.0027158323,
0.0053319568,
-0.0435801074,
0.0145568429,
0.0002870205,
0.0009246447,
0.0014957942,
0.0320934802,
-0.0044620787,
0.0742556527,
-0.0431598537,
-0.0322220214,
-0.0090790913,
-0.0828528628,
0.0511316247,
-0.0011383961,
-0.0297664311,
-0.0557375886,
-0.0453405529,
0.0003812193,
-0.0255191922,
-0.0169060286,
-0.0018196334,
0.0435524732,
-0.0910591558,
-0.0035655068,
0.0130565483,
-0.0138905495,
-0.0303805303,
-0.0233668927,
-0.0227555055,
-0.0216623303,
0.0209563617,
0.0192010719,
0.0274599809,
0.0467175953,
0.0206687506,
0.068149969,
-0.0074065067,
-0.0322908685,
-0.0085308878,
-0.042018842,
0.0538103059,
0.027628582,
-0.0614694282,
0.0151599981,
-0.0103606144,
-0.0259272009,
0.0167711563,
-0.0319968574,
0.0044143656,
-0.0265782569,
-0.0283135995,
-0.0228867531,
0.0655520782,
-0.0200284217,
0.0786078274,
0.0444794968,
0.0238474682,
-0.0095271273,
-0.0038127531,
-0.0318174511,
0.0092270887,
-0.0064401049,
-0.0013929382,
0.0484594963,
0.0253122002,
0.080890283,
0.0402499028,
-0.0035072954,
0.0278115645,
-0.0214943066,
0.0081357406,
-0.0605702512,
0.00252729,
-0.0439329073,
0.0489499867,
-0.0330657065,
-0.0871578306,
0.0518938415,
0.0391104296,
0.0230838899,
-0.0395378023,
-0.0266964789,
-0.0407901667,
-0.0275354702,
0.0004461249,
-0.0090511572,
0.023923561,
-0.0071105906,
0.0180035494,
-0.0048819734,
-0.0117176883,
-0.0477285348,
0.0805465281,
-0.0061862483,
0.0342051238,
0.0474058911,
0.0021757421,
-0.0446747839,
0.018657757,
-0.0031988015,
0.0356388241,
-0.0315455683,
0.0034666245,
-0.1169479564,
0.0117921801,
-0.0116503462,
0.023110956,
-0.0018858264,
-0.0166235585,
0.0267010201,
0.0222224407,
0.0246975347,
-0.0481555834,
-0.0314162262,
-0.0426903293,
0.0120863542,
-0.009452966,
-0.004425135,
0.0325187519,
-0.0425920151,
0.0282673649,
-0.0091092708,
-0.0493060201,
-0.0203213785,
0.0687118173,
-0.0140953558,
0.0170057472,
0.0281838663,
0.1091833785,
0.0453063399,
-0.0969189927,
0.0109365722,
-0.0148101058,
-0.0057938211,
0.0126933549,
-0.0403722078,
-0.0152056906,
-0.025538791,
-0.0219625998,
0.051378537,
-0.0123419818,
-0.0220440943,
0.0398767814,
-0.0043726638,
0.0291381907,
-0.0289242957,
-0.0481869318,
-0.0131994542,
-0.0173610114,
-0.0033054056,
-0.0354883857,
-0.0156914145,
-0.0431173854,
-0.0380875655,
-0.0146382414,
0.0287709273,
-0.1117724478,
-0.0463310368,
0.0761527047,
-0.0350253619,
0.0630889982,
0.0951616019,
0.0464761406,
-0.0000866516,
-0.0577994883,
-0.0157708731,
-0.0185297243,
0.0523524173,
-0.02270744,
0.0837029591,
0.0128508369,
0.0132863643,
-0.0462335013,
0.0125290379,
-0.0211542249,
0.0045568394,
0.0415134169,
0.0832137614,
-0.0692816079,
-0.0263982154,
-0.0213956106,
-0.0195041411,
0.0355618931,
0.0213439893,
-0.0241227429,
-0.0373176597,
-0.0339367911,
0.0699775368,
0.0566229969,
0.0100276843,
0.014245728,
-0.0038029477,
-0.0447205976,
-0.0028101513,
-0.0553726368,
-0.0115800248,
0.0673662946,
-0.015528921,
0.0470436439,
0.0116169313,
-0.0100229103,
0.018454019,
-0.0712642595,
0.0307929888,
0.0544247814,
0.0353318453,
-0.0665420964,
-0.0566010736,
-0.0004449131,
0.003819695,
-0.0242217183,
-0.0011078712,
0.0181044694,
0.0181225426,
0.0761185139,
0.0380749218,
0.0122223739,
0.0195537396,
0.0197933596,
-0.0221323054,
0.0332845524,
0.0197291803,
0.0206774697,
-0.0562589318,
-0.0096768681,
0.0220423695,
-0.0157127623,
-0.0041630049,
-0.0151479943,
0.0288481843,
0.0002913806,
-0.0678237304,
-0.0264651794,
-0.015316776,
0.0126945041,
0.0330114216,
0.0435027406,
-0.0262854751,
-0.0331373028,
-0.0044731321,
-0.0232526585,
0.0543299504,
0.0539831221,
-0.009983751,
-0.0157679636,
0.0308412705,
-0.013432866,
-0.0125439279,
-0.0017627992,
-0.0180917345,
-0.0700767785,
-0.0614279993,
0.0533869043,
-0.0341922008,
0.0580121987,
0.0339433439,
0.0094816918,
0.0230842289,
0.0439493358,
0.0121564167,
0.0045347475,
0.0343579613,
0.0635837018,
-0.0366595872,
0.054794658,
-0.025519779,
-0.0156240445,
0.0050385902,
-0.0462442935,
0.0083478279,
0.0220094156,
0.0383892581,
-0.0049910466,
0.0313206017,
0.0023569043,
0.0420457944,
-0.0358788967,
-0.0287564322,
-0.0078010368,
-0.0090153646,
0.021290509,
0.0027571665,
-0.0508893207,
0.0088685593,
0.078062959,
0.0277957674,
0.0150578748,
-0.0289787296,
-0.0700419694,
-0.0256529208,
-0.0108904168,
0.067620039,
-0.001629703,
-0.0980881304,
-0.0170317702,
-0.0198631193,
-0.0010259189,
0.0540434867,
-0.0447833501,
0.0353797674,
0.0223232806,
0.0036675637,
0.0366945416,
-0.0331595168,
-0.0111774858,
-0.042944856,
-0.0038225341,
-0.0703999251,
-0.0292347204,
-0.0277949572,
-5.830329288e-33,
0.0254254248,
-0.01099071,
0.0165438876,
-0.0293328278,
0.0274956301,
0.0244347714,
-0.0259939246,
-0.0116221737,
0.02690682,
-0.0200892054,
0.0183247756,
-0.0161365457,
0.0148506863,
0.0311422832,
0.0248188898,
-0.0523351878,
0.0198170617,
0.0139625724,
0.0095370375,
-0.0213016756,
-0.0185053814,
0.029524887,
-0.0036521312,
-0.0501026995,
0.0180944055,
0.0498985983,
0.0107200043,
-0.0083833197,
-0.0126309153,
0.0396645889,
-0.0531643294,
0.0535505936,
0.0474484004,
0.0248168837,
0.0072694779,
0.0186522156,
-0.0305928458,
0.0057090749,
0.0272479393,
-0.0200249273,
0.0289702713,
-0.0159488339,
0.0121122422,
0.0294071268,
-0.0446028225,
0.045472376,
0.0667937994,
-0.0234866738,
-0.0262680184,
-0.0444550253,
0.0037045816,
0.0090209972,
-0.0077930419,
0.0400467403,
-0.0207197275,
0.0292725749,
-0.0291804895,
0.0297901854,
-0.0889677107,
0.0107691977,
-0.0332109071,
-0.01216326,
0.0037246251,
-0.0203877613,
-0.0082075866,
0.0673612654,
0.0646305159,
-0.0501133166,
-0.0341582224,
0.0063300175,
-0.0329511948,
0.023560226,
0.0373813026,
-0.0686922446,
0.0600592531,
-0.0735535249,
-0.0416805483,
0.0165640861,
-0.0004544664,
0.0123949293,
0.0519711711,
-0.0290718488,
-0.029581828,
0.0174070634,
-0.0161664244,
0.0366851389,
-0.0309049394,
-0.0298057385,
0.0399526507,
0.0095797684,
0.016234925,
-0.0170894489,
0.0293518584,
-0.0330162011,
0.0278397128,
0.0083432328,
0.0378972143,
-0.0046358029,
-0.0055771461,
-0.0150837824,
-0.0260738861,
-0.0217604954,
0.0346602276,
-0.0353153422,
0.0569225512,
-0.0151577266,
0.0519190617,
-0.0252819732,
-0.0202064943,
-0.0113803493,
0.0448923521,
-0.002129497,
-0.0152196102,
0.0211041775,
-0.0113287568,
0.022249056,
-0.0064017135,
0.027171893,
-0.0013162392,
-0.0104323123,
-0.0163377337,
-0.0447278097,
-0.0112987142,
-0.0137585877,
-0.02345719,
-0.0081027765,
-0.0475937352,
0.0220321678,
-0.008213466,
-0.0468508303,
0.0028192208,
0.0066076005,
3.003e-7,
0.0479226671,
0.0772239491,
-0.0070348298,
-0.0111073162,
0.0133887641,
-0.015158399,
-0.0331694409,
-0.0107060112,
0.0083957147,
0.0138088539,
0.0756030157,
0.0101775741,
0.0184480175,
0.0139467297,
-0.0205865484,
-0.0400641412,
-0.0940518379,
0.0087064961,
-0.0596255139,
0.0261464845,
0.0596677475,
0.0124304667,
-0.0025656556,
-0.0690908954,
0.0206850488,
0.0183707383,
-0.0167960729,
-0.0219663195,
0.0128491726,
-0.0106932726,
0.0496259369,
-0.0010679116,
0.0275922585,
0.081102781,
-0.0494486913,
-0.0186303314,
-0.0187184121,
0.0361954793,
-0.0670873448,
-0.0330771282,
0.0028694763,
0.0412764139,
0.0046361047,
0.009530941,
0.0888826922,
-0.017789796,
-0.0584619045,
-0.0106814718,
-0.044571247,
0.0255568344,
0.0635678247,
-0.0134507399,
-0.000966988,
-0.0256425124,
0.0112766894,
0.0286330879,
-0.0145418132,
-0.0043960288,
-0.0190550834,
0.0400982797,
-0.0472483709,
0.0123603689,
0.0070884977,
-0.0113995066,
0.0027893584,
-0.0696369186,
-0.0162986945,
2.695200998e-34,
0.016638007,
0.0088918544,
0.0153477034,
-0.0195284449,
-0.0230270401,
-0.0260941051,
0.0248452518,
0.0043967585,
-0.0222580377,
-0.0138811888,
-0.0134643642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12332v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12332v1 | X-CapsNet For Fake News Detection | 2023-07-23T13:58:00 | 2023-07-23T13:58:00 | Mohammad Hadi Goldani, Reza Safabakhsh, Saeedeh Momtazi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | News consumption has significantly increased with the growing popularity and
use of web-based forums and social media. This sets the stage for misinforming
and confusing people. To help reduce the impact of misinformation on users'
potential health-related decisions and other intents, it is desired to have
machine learning models to detect and combat fake news automatically. This
paper proposes a novel transformer-based model using Capsule neural
Networks(CapsNet) called X-CapsNet. This model includes a CapsNet with dynamic
routing algorithm paralyzed with a size-based classifier for detecting short
and long fake news statements. We use two size-based classifiers, a Deep
Convolutional Neural Network (DCNN) for detecting long fake news statements and
a Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) for detecting short news statements. To resolve
the problem of representing short news statements, we use indirect features of
news created by concatenating the vector of news speaker profiles and a vector
of polarity, sentiment, and counting words of news statements. For evaluating
the proposed architecture, we use the Covid-19 and the Liar datasets. The
results in terms of the F1-score for the Covid-19 dataset and accuracy for the
Liar dataset show that models perform better than the state-of-the-art
baselines. | [
0.0273167044,
0.0326792784,
-0.0249206945,
0.0413413271,
-0.0391257219,
-0.0024478647,
0.0306204855,
-0.0016303728,
0.0434339084,
-0.0054169088,
0.0011199776,
-0.034371268,
0.0064744027,
0.0748760998,
0.0126564512,
-0.0157151222,
0.050475385,
0.056847658,
0.0256396122,
-0.0196236782,
0.0320775174,
0.0162090007,
-0.0123554198,
0.0435849465,
-0.0496143103,
-0.0037986357,
0.0220271833,
-0.0089641921,
0.0568321161,
-0.0163338818,
0.0383487232,
0.0209560189,
0.0092374459,
0.0914123952,
0.0000020321,
0.0011010403,
-0.0186738353,
-0.002204038,
-0.0296093766,
-0.0330946147,
0.0640942752,
-0.054721158,
-0.0119453389,
0.0500306673,
-0.0435926914,
-0.0287118629,
0.0427398644,
0.1073611602,
0.0608763434,
0.1102864742,
-0.0236931071,
-0.0278004296,
0.0351926982,
-0.0080306716,
-0.0010889338,
-0.0330923423,
0.0394402221,
0.0023532636,
-0.0512309298,
0.0201860871,
0.0094108162,
0.00875099,
0.010417399,
0.0023727727,
-0.0496393256,
0.0133958077,
-0.0304681156,
-0.0476773456,
0.0121620474,
0.0409615673,
-0.0714861602,
-0.0440392867,
0.026212953,
-0.0175222829,
0.0198401809,
0.0078835115,
0.0010455924,
0.0187589265,
-0.0146333044,
0.0173567273,
-0.0079883458,
0.0165825821,
0.0550603606,
0.0250310972,
-0.0088712964,
-0.0123133287,
-0.0238405373,
0.0050754719,
-0.016754657,
-0.0363871902,
-0.0032697846,
-0.0392154902,
0.0486281551,
0.0046754852,
-0.0313421637,
-0.0056871558,
-0.072531037,
-0.0497332439,
0.0261006355,
-0.1227576509,
-0.0349352658,
-0.0118152052,
0.0165070985,
0.0084617231,
-0.0337072648,
0.003883074,
-0.0449748002,
0.0312299524,
-0.0073693981,
-0.0021689981,
-0.00907645,
0.0084841819,
-0.0175142027,
0.0264620129,
-0.0007069449,
-0.0059543638,
-0.0765107423,
-0.0353897959,
-0.0311454684,
0.0199565589,
-0.0247371234,
0.0276612733,
-0.008673978,
-0.0048455838,
0.0219096933,
0.083807379,
0.0025568702,
0.0130945249,
-0.0046685888,
-0.0281287525,
-0.0021786352,
0.0313906409,
-0.0035641999,
0.0298111308,
0.0114815515,
0.004375448,
0.014835841,
-0.0318987444,
-0.0121450024,
-0.0427095294,
-0.048292283,
-0.0367781892,
0.0028805868,
-0.0710207075,
0.0098243318,
-0.0428496264,
-0.0087782517,
-0.0270063393,
-0.0012190789,
0.0247111898,
-0.0386950485,
0.0187525246,
0.029150283,
-0.0127663314,
0.055339478,
0.0200271793,
0.0149799157,
0.0659538507,
0.0297808778,
0.1021300405,
0.0425029472,
0.008291427,
0.016481746,
0.0038223115,
0.0552805364,
-0.0192132071,
0.0030749645,
-0.0359238237,
-0.011689797,
0.0274163503,
-0.0324317738,
0.0262164827,
-0.0155859804,
-0.0628595948,
0.0609371103,
-0.0490120351,
-0.0050391234,
0.0087159276,
0.0399993435,
0.0401916914,
-0.0011161139,
-0.0114714345,
-0.0099422559,
0.0202447623,
-0.0618910342,
-0.0452256724,
-0.0424516499,
0.0581845641,
-0.0104108509,
-0.0381302088,
0.0088939844,
-0.0216955487,
0.0104213366,
-0.0219716914,
0.0101753185,
0.0051614298,
-0.0509888865,
0.0592131354,
0.017933622,
-0.0068217423,
-0.0479163006,
-0.0791111439,
-0.003261134,
0.0136178834,
0.0140700117,
0.0392478928,
-0.0336241387,
-0.0552279055,
-0.0024802135,
0.0210604668,
0.0683624148,
-0.0094842371,
-0.0585559681,
0.0004824204,
0.0157116,
0.0032984996,
0.0190750863,
0.0074038994,
0.0194113962,
0.0660536215,
0.0163119938,
0.0119561469,
-0.0426823199,
0.0240797959,
-0.0017488517,
0.0006069239,
0.0050958302,
0.0342144705,
0.0370503552,
0.0143581554,
0.0147496806,
-0.0239043795,
0.0521206968,
0.0006074449,
-0.0594490021,
-0.0441034697,
-0.0247327536,
-0.0365891792,
0.0077550774,
-0.0757015273,
-0.001612876,
0.090375796,
-0.0184189379,
0.0222256351,
0.0357964002,
-0.0394626483,
0.0047220727,
-0.0284152571,
-0.043639157,
-0.0370970853,
0.0593666285,
0.043859072,
0.0471687764,
-0.0341960676,
-0.0024306062,
-0.0226683915,
-0.021988092,
0.0000056439,
0.0089816088,
-0.0080424184,
-0.0247256812,
-0.0138009209,
-0.0008675205,
0.0269678608,
-0.0160451196,
0.0410000309,
-0.0231786966,
-0.0490649492,
-0.0391000733,
-0.0312958471,
-0.0361468866,
0.0285889097,
0.0166823845,
0.0144901015,
0.020388918,
-0.0441083908,
0.0149239022,
0.018820297,
-0.0167043228,
0.0025007518,
-0.0259268489,
-0.0338811018,
0.0078881895,
-0.0174133126,
-0.0258648954,
0.0459865145,
0.0155204805,
-0.0790470913,
0.011917524,
-0.0482584499,
-0.0088231275,
0.0157420915,
-0.0433084369,
-0.0515180901,
-0.0112412255,
0.0049548345,
-0.0250552446,
0.0467605926,
0.0803122297,
0.0542902537,
0.0224910192,
0.0799092948,
-0.0112568103,
-0.0132095683,
-0.0739023611,
0.0216266233,
-0.0445861183,
-0.0386233702,
0.0146109248,
0.0409155115,
0.028908981,
0.0000529403,
-0.0170418173,
0.0029690708,
0.0037775601,
-0.024144439,
0.0508773141,
-0.0454347804,
-0.0020086966,
-0.0191644877,
0.0057537314,
-0.0067445706,
0.0748583004,
-0.0117274392,
0.0487489142,
-0.0274976492,
-0.0398130193,
-0.0140030282,
-0.0287191067,
0.0292353984,
0.0398651101,
0.0334898084,
0.013217953,
0.0081934286,
-0.0222250428,
0.0282140058,
-0.051467251,
-0.0146488966,
0.0089306496,
0.0168512799,
0.0200198572,
-0.024397159,
-0.0835544765,
-0.0878547654,
-0.0299889259,
-0.0467024036,
0.0046742819,
-0.0417702459,
-0.0879770294,
-0.0036870288,
0.0258431416,
0.0438121073,
-0.0093957335,
0.0134036848,
0.0290622413,
0.0218951572,
0.0199751686,
0.0064760633,
0.0844764933,
0.0093513457,
0.0116435811,
0.0686726421,
-0.0356234871,
0.0348810926,
-0.0258201528,
-0.0481598973,
-0.0222866219,
0.0004795571,
0.0008606332,
0.0038889442,
0.014930591,
-0.0446260311,
0.008033569,
0.068396166,
0.0003730512,
-0.022658065,
0.0215244088,
0.0644014105,
-0.0271866359,
0.0006291551,
0.0097917626,
-0.0472486056,
-0.0173658133,
0.0006764589,
-0.0049591437,
-0.0760921016,
-0.0158038959,
-0.0122156357,
-0.0552339368,
0.0120506464,
0.0054469365,
-0.0426140502,
-0.0344789326,
-0.0416963696,
-0.0369709395,
-0.0021416729,
0.0192224067,
-0.0302798543,
0.0328938477,
-0.0523853935,
-0.0333033241,
-0.0627238378,
-0.0351016484,
-0.0070546218,
-0.0023162502,
0.0526680313,
-0.0007604045,
0.0505818799,
-0.0356145203,
-0.066843383,
-0.0038922839,
0.0300341118,
-0.0234275758,
0.0137723954,
0.0928425938,
-0.0438375585,
-0.0079877414,
-0.0052350457,
0.0436057337,
-0.0227281637,
-0.0143695036,
-0.0294283722,
0.0454209447,
0.0090691252,
-0.0931988731,
-0.0573980398,
0.0533547215,
0.0331339426,
0.0426136218,
-0.0004053728,
-0.0040039821,
0.0035035468,
0.0047337697,
-0.0279928911,
-0.0364701673,
-0.0807845816,
0.0655665323,
0.0330489315,
-0.0569669008,
-0.0313719772,
-0.0031221148,
-0.0150068672,
0.019100897,
-0.0384068489,
-0.0376711041,
0.0456600226,
0.0156710166,
-0.058291655,
-0.0067067095,
0.01872674,
0.0550550558,
-0.0048317323,
0.0163022131,
0.0319660679,
-0.0264391545,
-0.013675075,
0.0339650176,
-0.0809832662,
-0.0073522925,
0.0226560496,
0.0051265485,
0.0129040079,
0.0350363106,
-0.0233817827,
-0.0198412463,
0.0879264325,
0.0537730344,
0.0025228872,
-0.0236570612,
0.0279355664,
-0.0138528999,
0.015630845,
0.0182001796,
0.0105747292,
0.0495195352,
-0.0000183688,
-0.042337209,
-0.0765495598,
0.0177181885,
0.0319197476,
0.0023835374,
0.0206736382,
0.0019113785,
0.0296491832,
-0.0081629213,
-0.0246619117,
-0.0127798663,
0.0039057701,
0.0350474603,
0.023007229,
0.0362750292,
0.0158497151,
-0.0005112878,
-0.0055272542,
-0.0271418225,
-0.0238498468,
-0.0261499509,
-0.0147330808,
-0.0006897133,
-0.0019789448,
0.01596063,
-0.0065174052,
-0.0387106687,
-0.0010952197,
0.0268407054,
0.0226050019,
-0.013816406,
-0.0293971021,
0.0271919165,
-0.0137780225,
-0.014503628,
0.0016568467,
-0.0437632799,
0.0144585511,
-0.0499049202,
0.0620519966,
-0.0113635501,
0.0184129421,
-0.0013169121,
-0.0116176391,
-0.0066581289,
-0.0016990784,
-0.0095754927,
-0.0413066298,
-0.0326460265,
0.0050866744,
0.0200899392,
-0.0296920463,
0.0063733747,
0.0601565912,
0.0074613662,
0.0295139886,
0.0110057909,
-0.0387352407,
-0.0500851944,
0.0161489956,
-0.0068846219,
0.0339590572,
-0.0080185737,
-0.0210058279,
-0.0676329434,
-0.0311391577,
0.0559768118,
0.0047535966,
0.0476706363,
0.0113854213,
-0.0263834633,
0.0648109615,
0.0204053335,
0.0059130178,
-0.0136647057,
0.022211995,
-0.0101322448,
-0.0310933217,
0.0154038901,
-6.508494754e-33,
0.0525100231,
-0.039159134,
-0.0296100359,
0.0150285689,
-0.0270662922,
0.0586874522,
0.0095437998,
-0.0197880641,
-0.0393497087,
0.0521102175,
0.0018133946,
0.0383520201,
-0.0120838974,
0.0352822095,
-0.0518902168,
-0.0121759186,
0.0636068881,
-0.0143894143,
-0.0056183902,
0.037028227,
0.051186379,
0.0103775142,
0.0176664758,
-0.0568004474,
0.0097605465,
-0.0166200902,
-0.034720242,
0.0114762885,
-0.0376025438,
0.0320831351,
-0.0000188647,
0.0420731753,
0.0458821543,
-0.0342625901,
0.0076724696,
0.0769341886,
-0.0269168615,
-0.0052547357,
-0.0330822244,
0.0142801004,
-0.0079130596,
-0.0026471294,
0.0682165995,
-0.0169838574,
-0.0262127891,
0.0051685236,
0.0289414283,
-0.0075277337,
0.0110213151,
-0.0452111885,
-0.0092053516,
0.0024740014,
-0.0053970362,
0.0253302436,
-0.0427966416,
0.0817788318,
-0.0038661398,
0.0406196415,
-0.0930371881,
0.0220638644,
-0.0411874615,
0.0086152824,
-0.0098722689,
-0.0251829457,
-0.0391515605,
0.0518066175,
0.0325256512,
0.018630825,
-0.0687076971,
0.0724964365,
0.0351752937,
0.019422885,
0.1060042381,
0.0959608108,
0.0374723896,
-0.1001561731,
-0.0826262981,
0.0144653693,
0.021956671,
-0.00541618,
0.0225553252,
-0.0330152623,
-0.0361127108,
0.0080762561,
0.0082531683,
-0.0307142716,
-0.0073926626,
-0.0058283322,
-0.0279067606,
0.0330705829,
-0.0642441809,
0.0383861214,
-0.0026413004,
-0.0780128911,
0.0129267732,
-0.003855062,
0.0080022868,
0.0088622924,
0.0282431319,
0.0511372574,
-0.0461478345,
0.0002828131,
0.0276924018,
0.0283556972,
-0.0011278924,
-0.0202647932,
0.0671973303,
0.0278871581,
-0.0151217328,
-0.0176921897,
0.0038616285,
0.0340229496,
-0.0061589587,
0.0184233226,
0.0200422499,
0.0237920694,
-0.0230594259,
-0.0327712074,
-0.0239703562,
0.0217347424,
0.013683944,
-0.0013300817,
-0.0124588162,
0.0479713231,
-0.0498904921,
-0.0194270164,
-0.0566055961,
0.0375290327,
0.0377442688,
-0.1469727755,
0.0044409451,
0.0102541661,
2.991e-7,
-0.0262856372,
0.0504863076,
-0.0080048954,
-0.0120371813,
0.0121576376,
0.0613008514,
0.0692876801,
0.0504080914,
-0.0324181505,
-0.088917613,
-0.0080281431,
0.0380547643,
-0.0068806848,
0.0363640822,
-0.077962935,
-0.025710294,
-0.0228542425,
-0.0027584394,
-0.0223418958,
0.0187642854,
0.0339718573,
0.0768793374,
0.0278604981,
-0.0336309038,
0.0231734011,
0.0256017987,
0.0069938172,
0.060874939,
-0.0349901728,
-0.0174005218,
0.0491879955,
-0.0251696911,
0.0138479648,
0.0262846518,
-0.0280411877,
0.0081879282,
-0.0285932142,
0.0042393822,
0.0004174592,
-0.0203783903,
-0.0114222821,
-0.0374880135,
0.0122343348,
-0.008222837,
0.0683543831,
-0.0687626302,
-0.0415645875,
-0.0688432455,
-0.0262820721,
0.0162722915,
0.0555313826,
-0.0122314487,
-0.005859883,
0.0461742617,
0.0124421427,
0.0018602883,
0.0373036787,
-0.0491792262,
0.0420588627,
0.0039630989,
-0.0593316704,
-0.0023955833,
-0.0008637522,
-0.0316844061,
0.082405746,
0.0202353317,
0.0115892133,
2.399918884e-34,
0.0389301181,
-0.0151645076,
-0.0200686194,
-0.0518374369,
-0.0029916628,
0.0174292345,
0.0095709059,
-0.0155069707,
0.0049021379,
-0.0342235453,
-0.0193087701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12282v1 | Milimili. Collecting Parallel Data via Crowdsourcing | 2023-07-23T10:23:00 | 2023-07-23T10:23:00 | Alexander Antonov | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a methodology for gathering a parallel corpus through
crowdsourcing, which is more cost-effective than hiring professional
translators, albeit at the expense of quality. Additionally, we have made
available experimental parallel data collected for Chechen-Russian and
Fula-English language pairs. | [
0.0125058517,
0.0623145401,
-0.0373494551,
0.0290165655,
-0.0586108975,
0.0433647856,
0.0448766053,
-0.0052022426,
-0.0263769217,
0.0257936567,
-0.0177657716,
-0.0603393689,
0.0420554578,
-0.0815698877,
0.0121141886,
-0.0495184734,
0.0063518728,
-0.0327153131,
-0.0025319273,
-0.0441032946,
0.0417027026,
0.0406955518,
-0.0313467719,
0.0080887182,
0.0047740098,
0.026731424,
0.0089703165,
-0.000969584,
0.0175301824,
0.0128646875,
-0.0132569065,
0.0344846845,
-0.0445306599,
0.0536598638,
0.0000014323,
-0.037929859,
-0.0477282852,
0.0026620405,
0.0102343904,
-0.0063905241,
0.0186075866,
-0.0344145298,
-0.022185564,
0.0470285453,
-0.0261938237,
-0.0168347061,
0.0699085295,
-0.0543268658,
0.0180039927,
0.0415464304,
-0.0003303865,
-0.0029284293,
-0.0219734348,
-0.0142531786,
-0.057770323,
-0.0145850908,
-0.0201395042,
-0.0400679298,
-0.0007613294,
0.0018177569,
0.0301989038,
0.0624462031,
-0.0077349329,
-0.0294683874,
-0.0400658846,
-0.0288079903,
-0.0530448444,
-0.0390877202,
0.0216586534,
0.046573896,
0.0176792629,
-0.0393174812,
0.0317080803,
0.0173019599,
0.0009585127,
0.0415191986,
-0.0371656269,
0.0290297773,
-0.0308813415,
0.0163834225,
0.0226467811,
0.0088328812,
0.0052259206,
-0.0286288187,
0.0130424649,
0.029571142,
0.0251818355,
-0.0255888272,
0.0070940549,
0.0506651066,
0.0092751691,
-0.0035353231,
0.0558283404,
-0.0415511467,
-0.0500076674,
0.0151120713,
-0.0238470677,
-0.1413126141,
0.0304951798,
-0.045211006,
0.020897869,
0.0000260851,
0.0091995336,
0.0486415178,
0.0029433961,
-0.0305501297,
0.0247735698,
0.0130968457,
-0.0580784157,
-0.0675105825,
-0.0459586047,
0.0593644194,
-0.0609841309,
-0.0249259565,
-0.0433224775,
0.0495356508,
-0.0166356191,
-0.0016869148,
0.0015595623,
0.052169323,
0.0280197952,
-0.0310211908,
-0.0401508696,
-0.0110655632,
0.0182870068,
0.0340744853,
-0.0764864087,
-0.0030056329,
-0.0688918233,
-0.0870014429,
0.014587394,
0.0135677764,
0.0128903957,
-0.0320492201,
-0.0221184324,
0.0115186777,
-0.0181743912,
-0.0024435802,
0.0037321926,
-0.006221707,
0.0039965576,
-0.0225114338,
0.0055869478,
-0.050172884,
0.0650322139,
0.0081653604,
0.0273184273,
-0.0083320756,
-0.0339578353,
-0.0165509395,
-0.0272484068,
0.086276941,
0.0003390893,
0.0129585462,
0.058985021,
-0.0203641728,
0.0423307829,
0.1013249904,
0.0119208498,
-0.0109914551,
0.0703092441,
-0.0331988595,
-0.028111428,
0.0454987809,
0.0146155832,
0.0214187354,
-0.0065000774,
0.0405483395,
0.0306086466,
0.0428661518,
0.0131054623,
0.0922087803,
-0.0009809932,
-0.0054524252,
0.0549750701,
0.0639826879,
-0.0133104958,
-0.0182292145,
-0.0052187559,
0.037361268,
0.0028216038,
-0.0193555485,
0.0048592011,
0.0175640546,
0.0514257215,
-0.0031396945,
0.0373232365,
0.0381944925,
-0.0221273657,
0.0095748417,
-0.0288779661,
-0.0182459727,
-0.0003111979,
-0.0034658839,
0.0639813989,
-0.0241517145,
-0.0021792285,
-0.0168689787,
0.0392009839,
-0.0408409648,
0.0348816663,
-0.005030382,
-0.0340187028,
0.0438047051,
0.0176232159,
0.0033377926,
0.0265014954,
-0.0129728448,
0.0010012615,
0.0544005111,
0.0277800169,
-0.0340400413,
0.0020163204,
-0.0268800519,
0.00575996,
0.0673941746,
-0.0167360902,
-0.010489421,
0.0062998408,
0.032685034,
0.015777573,
-0.0050459094,
0.0060175657,
-0.0023548265,
-0.0092241718,
0.022757167,
-0.0051874286,
0.0128323045,
0.0138512449,
0.0225684401,
-0.0135430153,
0.0162220038,
0.0197739117,
-0.0232874788,
0.0149772605,
0.0653668046,
0.0389391147,
-0.0019108336,
0.0380950607,
-0.086734198,
-0.0269921515,
0.0425381288,
-0.0003610798,
-0.0153810391,
0.0460269973,
-0.022891283,
0.0145241767,
-0.0157779176,
0.0251005329,
0.0090298485,
-0.0055009006,
0.0105542373,
-0.0036803163,
0.000551465,
0.0350506231,
-0.0070187133,
-0.0446412675,
0.0398045778,
-0.057227008,
-0.0330062509,
0.041610878,
0.0369966626,
0.0380185954,
0.017328361,
-0.0517271161,
-0.0288074575,
0.0128126703,
-0.0639221892,
-0.0077742352,
-0.0101381578,
0.0599769503,
0.0233892165,
0.0225680079,
0.0083861072,
-0.0128146391,
-0.0297388285,
-0.0059328941,
0.0155125828,
0.0143041806,
0.0050041731,
-0.0241798256,
0.0275657587,
-0.0059300303,
-0.0257715043,
0.0609224401,
-0.0113410158,
0.0357052907,
-0.0083009591,
-0.0402256846,
-0.0261068847,
0.0092270952,
0.0111069223,
0.0283712223,
-0.0925902948,
0.0307779871,
-0.0047219396,
-0.0014746232,
0.0057843155,
-0.0280881282,
-0.0280325972,
0.0151309306,
-0.0087205293,
0.0151491426,
-0.02688138,
-0.0035523467,
-0.0210292097,
-0.037065167,
-0.0416622348,
0.0087512825,
0.0418625884,
-0.0065150331,
-0.023567671,
-0.0548178777,
-0.033248499,
-0.063887015,
-0.0148381954,
-0.0558548756,
0.0134496242,
-0.01530712,
0.0281654969,
-0.0395799764,
0.0041515157,
0.0527755693,
-0.0369620845,
0.0003335084,
-0.0377302207,
-0.0254847351,
-0.0125796981,
0.0613504797,
-0.0213905983,
-0.0122084273,
-0.06633313,
0.0013366702,
-0.0192181971,
0.0439757779,
0.0486084372,
-0.0092011746,
0.014447147,
-0.0699006915,
0.0205909517,
-0.0159147382,
-0.0393798761,
0.0126696285,
-0.0711726174,
-0.0266159102,
-0.0061440519,
0.0980187654,
-0.0271114651,
0.0202763658,
-0.0240282603,
-0.0114700589,
0.0295886062,
0.0173333976,
0.0367860384,
0.0010334316,
0.047243908,
0.0004371673,
0.0345097929,
-0.0182345752,
-0.0341268554,
-0.0241076704,
0.0392843671,
0.0887110159,
-0.0285895262,
0.017324606,
-0.0492117554,
0.049329374,
-0.003340953,
-0.0419330522,
-0.0532535501,
0.0103272106,
0.0023582971,
0.0074318862,
0.0456423201,
0.0008313164,
-0.0348265581,
-0.0109861623,
-0.0118324263,
0.0085652461,
-0.0121532865,
0.0128942821,
-0.0997395739,
0.0204318762,
0.0132245366,
0.0458214283,
-0.0281723607,
-0.029588636,
-0.019308392,
-0.1298901439,
-0.0180577785,
0.0149559416,
-0.0351114236,
0.0394088663,
-0.0317476504,
0.0155758355,
-0.0290936138,
-0.0065002423,
0.0183309205,
-0.0014230488,
0.0363536626,
0.0454500765,
0.0299250446,
-0.0525167845,
-0.0441198982,
-0.0604733042,
0.0811303183,
-0.0210717618,
0.0144226011,
-0.0481778681,
-0.068666473,
-0.0195023064,
-0.0553883947,
-0.0521628484,
0.0012153962,
0.0100643132,
0.0206914693,
-0.0580030344,
-0.0124081234,
-0.0097259786,
-0.0273133889,
0.0203417558,
0.0383253656,
0.0351062976,
0.0050749052,
0.0185642391,
0.0657193139,
-0.0044276016,
0.0532369204,
0.0606392995,
-0.0170301497,
-0.0263203643,
0.0445840918,
0.0093428586,
-0.0307694189,
-0.1080349535,
0.0001453117,
0.0543199666,
-0.0364111923,
-0.0966722816,
-0.1034450829,
-0.0589581728,
0.0646994933,
0.035689678,
0.0024567458,
0.0366504043,
-0.0114599513,
-0.0036499915,
-0.0223551374,
0.0487497672,
-0.0083458358,
0.0173596181,
-0.0822447464,
-0.0526583083,
-0.0155849904,
-0.0224830974,
-0.0049659186,
0.0662494674,
-0.1164393276,
-0.052178815,
0.0493011884,
0.0243301298,
0.018011203,
-0.0073271296,
-0.0133906174,
-0.0695235655,
-0.0340541489,
0.0047255438,
-0.0493373871,
0.0364431702,
0.0017664577,
-0.0144916829,
0.0059921071,
0.025549626,
0.0102918819,
-0.0062928409,
0.0219039395,
-0.0487131663,
-0.0450835265,
-0.0420785956,
-0.0130499676,
0.0561341532,
0.0444953069,
-0.0292658731,
0.006456662,
-0.0337181948,
0.0200553071,
-0.0192577653,
0.0071197012,
-0.0237138383,
-0.0427627675,
0.0128832087,
-0.0130232042,
-0.0301066767,
0.0232791472,
0.004369223,
-0.0279640425,
-0.0070767207,
0.0144538609,
0.0294740163,
0.0447636768,
0.0329391621,
0.0519147702,
0.0186311789,
0.0194318555,
-0.0037911902,
0.0527816117,
-0.0176165532,
-0.0667595118,
0.0197673049,
-0.0036275962,
0.0539419353,
0.0195595361,
-0.0037986648,
-0.0432463065,
0.0459715836,
0.0024500506,
0.0382972099,
-0.0041808258,
0.0920643732,
0.0014184172,
0.0088324994,
-0.0185220782,
0.0144916428,
-0.0098431408,
0.0274063516,
-0.0321065299,
-0.0232936796,
-0.0123461504,
0.0300408397,
0.0518808179,
-0.0607090779,
0.0005552905,
0.0090532163,
0.0188855957,
-0.0189148113,
0.0161947384,
-0.0829696283,
-0.0213070102,
-0.026808342,
-0.0388041362,
-0.0301015861,
-0.0351533368,
-0.0266354717,
0.0733855069,
-0.0194907058,
0.0169647448,
0.0433172882,
0.0126966173,
-0.0127531951,
0.0370340981,
-0.055545304,
0.0406946503,
-0.0343630426,
-0.0235549044,
0.0159761775,
-5.691412672e-33,
-0.0203206316,
-0.0207512099,
-0.0179378744,
-0.0477922931,
0.0085738916,
-0.0318877399,
0.0140721099,
-0.0080860937,
0.0082036788,
-0.0076454715,
-0.0198276099,
0.0120779425,
0.0348567031,
-0.0177207198,
0.0503755324,
0.0001744674,
0.0475406535,
-0.0159421284,
0.0039494266,
-0.0131627759,
0.0789927244,
-0.0066085598,
0.0552641638,
-0.0586021766,
0.0681411028,
-0.0487800352,
-0.0290932078,
0.0319050178,
0.0201343633,
0.0099212173,
0.0206021909,
0.0533103012,
0.0249911454,
0.0075680236,
-0.0024571226,
0.0166612957,
-0.0720710084,
0.0148664266,
0.0526079461,
0.0545694344,
-0.0604171902,
0.0139484638,
0.0222251303,
-0.0209012125,
0.0110074859,
0.0139330141,
-0.0076720444,
-0.0127503118,
0.0179767795,
0.05124259,
-0.0023159585,
0.0138047701,
-0.0139867347,
0.0462521128,
0.0626293123,
0.0106241088,
-0.0026976417,
-0.0093716895,
-0.0509613603,
0.0298406389,
-0.0526170135,
0.0385139361,
0.0451157615,
-0.0201065131,
0.0046007633,
0.007012439,
0.0313682184,
-0.0066687968,
0.0822014883,
-0.0090245875,
-0.0125224842,
-0.0147943869,
0.0369153768,
0.1318044364,
0.0256738495,
-0.0808671042,
-0.0106501989,
0.0204789676,
0.0550761782,
-0.013983503,
-0.0728730485,
-0.0052403766,
-0.0064440533,
-0.0330371857,
0.0072095389,
-0.0234577749,
0.000591217,
0.0048540705,
-0.0179651547,
-0.0269573163,
-0.0083476091,
0.0243720431,
0.0326127112,
0.027125394,
0.0237149764,
-0.01666715,
0.0183591526,
0.0433883108,
-0.0380416624,
0.0226268787,
-0.0332507007,
-0.0077357683,
-0.0232038461,
0.0071413978,
0.018870974,
0.0305745304,
0.0274037998,
-0.0030828512,
-0.0499204583,
0.034920264,
-0.0265909862,
0.0612019971,
-0.0065431148,
-0.0069832425,
0.0369915068,
0.015615074,
0.0037942913,
-0.0078481324,
0.0692905411,
-0.0376297235,
0.0022833438,
0.0046995413,
-0.0197908767,
-0.0273886546,
-0.0139074177,
0.0380142108,
0.003580237,
0.0057265023,
0.0687622279,
-0.0233039372,
-0.0044373088,
-0.0554298535,
2.317e-7,
0.0616070069,
0.0299827345,
0.003793922,
0.0021942502,
0.0120172836,
-0.0167355277,
-0.0480816774,
0.0244977456,
0.0044382098,
0.0603573546,
-0.0008129891,
-0.0236525331,
0.1033317596,
0.0568665825,
-0.0839687139,
-0.0629132763,
-0.0295107197,
0.0459931195,
-0.0127677377,
0.0593832098,
0.0055733216,
0.0374526344,
0.0635521486,
-0.0034392462,
-0.0344174728,
-0.0370649733,
0.0444443598,
-0.0317184217,
-0.0396875888,
-0.0012380645,
-0.00966815,
-0.0233327392,
-0.0411094353,
0.0590003617,
-0.033009056,
-0.0199669059,
0.0383877233,
-0.0094618676,
0.0212101992,
-0.0005114365,
0.0146047352,
-0.0698867142,
-0.0511226356,
-0.0266354363,
0.0556548685,
0.01242596,
-0.0231713075,
0.008454022,
-0.0042536757,
-0.0024828641,
0.0089989612,
0.0029928028,
-0.0291997399,
0.0161617845,
0.027710855,
-0.0337990932,
-0.0177465547,
-0.0195685457,
-0.006951449,
-0.008843855,
-0.0251112208,
-0.1018661857,
0.0246697851,
0.0012645612,
-0.009200599,
-0.0060491664,
0.0113963075,
1.080924338e-34,
0.0158749484,
0.0187118147,
0.0219991896,
-0.0077089085,
0.0170096196,
-0.043952927,
-0.0318619125,
0.0000384785,
0.0189443901,
-0.0104000941,
-0.0191372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12267v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12267v6 | Towards Automatic Boundary Detection for Human-AI Collaborative Hybrid Essay in Education | 2023-07-23T08:47:51 | 2023-12-25T06:36:30 | Zijie Zeng, Lele Sha, Yuheng Li, Kaixun Yang, Dragan Gašević, Guanliang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent large language models (LLMs), e.g., ChatGPT, have been able to
generate human-like and fluent responses when provided with specific
instructions. While admitting the convenience brought by technological
advancement, educators also have concerns that students might leverage LLMs to
complete their writing assignments and pass them off as their original work.
Although many AI content detection studies have been conducted as a result of
such concerns, most of these prior studies modeled AI content detection as a
classification problem, assuming that a text is either entirely human-written
or entirely AI-generated. In this study, we investigated AI content detection
in a rarely explored yet realistic setting where the text to be detected is
collaboratively written by human and generative LLMs (i.e., hybrid text). We
first formalized the detection task as identifying the transition points
between human-written content and AI-generated content from a given hybrid text
(boundary detection). Then we proposed a two-step approach where we (1)
separated AI-generated content from human-written content during the encoder
training process; and (2) calculated the distances between every two adjacent
prototypes and assumed that the boundaries exist between the two adjacent
prototypes that have the furthest distance from each other. Through extensive
experiments, we observed the following main findings: (1) the proposed approach
consistently outperformed the baseline methods across different experiment
settings; (2) the encoder training process can significantly boost the
performance of the proposed approach; (3) when detecting boundaries for
single-boundary hybrid essays, the proposed approach could be enhanced by
adopting a relatively large prototype size, leading to a 22% improvement in the
In-Domain evaluation and an 18% improvement in the Out-of-Domain evaluation. | [
0.0717420653,
0.0001408152,
-0.0262736529,
0.0336256213,
-0.052408617,
-0.0153970839,
0.0383446366,
-0.0012819115,
0.0541809574,
-0.0829263404,
-0.0072982679,
-0.0430027582,
-0.0264187455,
0.0422740243,
-0.0079057729,
-0.0098464349,
0.0129124802,
-0.002587962,
0.0015569262,
0.0181164853,
0.0170779862,
-0.0046765264,
-0.001626609,
0.0556874536,
-0.0314599164,
-0.0383487791,
-0.0435513631,
-0.0101130037,
0.0152593302,
-0.0003840461,
0.0435597375,
0.0691317841,
-0.0060921717,
0.02491365,
0.0000020834,
-0.0404621735,
-0.0201573689,
-0.0340581201,
0.0215975698,
-0.0005533411,
0.0669682771,
-0.0036169267,
-0.0231011286,
0.0220897924,
-0.0378172882,
0.0315953493,
0.0250318702,
0.045811262,
0.0545458458,
0.0704805702,
-0.0146640269,
0.0193451233,
0.0721094906,
0.0239472762,
0.0074981577,
-0.0038847628,
0.0287548862,
-0.0284262504,
0.0158884823,
-0.0355861187,
-0.0233014748,
0.0272804759,
0.0382538885,
-0.0594068281,
0.0070956657,
0.0249740463,
-0.0208021421,
-0.021425616,
-0.0108586363,
0.0264706444,
0.00736207,
-0.0336249135,
0.0322434269,
-0.017308766,
0.0036428133,
0.0272904094,
-0.0268708561,
0.0094902953,
-0.0511426404,
-0.008474702,
0.0104295779,
0.0019049087,
-0.0261898506,
0.026686728,
0.007018595,
0.020910101,
-0.004674701,
-0.0640677512,
-0.0152207632,
0.0432647727,
0.0417419411,
-0.0428526103,
0.0850616768,
0.0487066321,
0.0266657248,
0.0098886676,
-0.0695944801,
-0.0753172189,
0.0076356176,
-0.0110022444,
0.0394843072,
0.0002162308,
0.0133371893,
0.0028374223,
-0.005976628,
0.0692163408,
0.0020630907,
0.0451254547,
-0.0189391207,
0.041076608,
-0.0365496539,
-0.0481239185,
-0.0553343259,
0.0305807926,
0.0254295208,
-0.0489503741,
-0.0197600648,
0.0078495424,
-0.0398560241,
0.0251672473,
-0.007819714,
-0.0159493946,
-0.0097886324,
0.0179257393,
0.0289612487,
0.0103443116,
-0.0081150187,
0.0190848727,
0.0337751657,
-0.0460892357,
0.0040607848,
0.0326796807,
0.0274880864,
-0.0001408703,
-0.0108017521,
0.0225928575,
-0.0393422432,
-0.0508403443,
-0.0094200578,
-0.0560873374,
-0.007088948,
-0.0420350879,
0.0162236635,
-0.0501501225,
0.0209081322,
-0.005296492,
-0.0053882324,
-0.0464372821,
-0.0018210619,
0.0279563218,
0.035668496,
0.0206037518,
-0.0274139009,
0.019355258,
0.0657956749,
0.0175405201,
-0.0018761581,
0.0486030094,
0.068972908,
0.0445866995,
0.0524725281,
0.0138309756,
0.0406809188,
0.0286848284,
-0.009911512,
-0.0245631337,
0.0142613212,
-0.0256927442,
0.0059431819,
0.0488625169,
-0.0080212746,
0.0447727479,
-0.0144679397,
-0.0044940184,
0.060908366,
0.0857413113,
-0.0196731929,
0.0372527689,
0.0348371454,
0.0825839713,
0.0452149063,
0.0928342715,
0.0149416244,
-0.009723831,
0.0147604626,
-0.0111938678,
0.0452385508,
0.0077453963,
0.0061495663,
-0.059365537,
-0.0194584671,
-0.0341167711,
-0.00968369,
-0.0440977663,
0.0351095609,
-0.0105732866,
-0.0382920913,
-0.018730633,
-0.0068329945,
-0.0711746216,
0.0670895875,
-0.0357276425,
0.0645733476,
0.0702226758,
0.0678742751,
-0.041563645,
0.0075572627,
-0.0266759284,
0.0408519506,
0.0544521995,
0.0373842828,
-0.021811232,
-0.0523231626,
-0.0441864729,
-0.0245540347,
-0.0160568003,
0.0119145773,
-0.0056582242,
0.0234346781,
0.0052891187,
0.0046531325,
0.0263596755,
-0.035827361,
0.0622331798,
-0.0208980963,
0.036990352,
-0.0292249117,
0.0275884289,
-0.0125336191,
0.0220190249,
-0.0289592929,
0.005996515,
0.0178466309,
-0.0502108186,
-0.0604534224,
-0.0163407624,
-0.0484386086,
-0.0015035952,
0.0205290299,
-0.0884348974,
-0.0053406865,
0.0270461962,
0.0083018811,
-0.0364479534,
-0.0074481508,
-0.0565896966,
-0.0025470539,
-0.0547009632,
0.003821722,
-0.026840182,
-0.0318444706,
-0.0302097965,
0.008527006,
0.0147850653,
0.0137993451,
-0.0040735211,
-0.0185910277,
0.0326197743,
-0.0104704062,
0.0036770371,
0.0183701776,
-0.0158300567,
0.0151510034,
0.0189521573,
0.0031062756,
-0.0259267893,
-0.0822547674,
-0.0914900452,
-0.0221761782,
-0.0196324196,
0.010062702,
0.0272774994,
-0.0497261807,
-0.0150141018,
0.0311849155,
-0.0254676621,
-0.033755824,
-0.0020854061,
-0.0058805454,
0.0383151434,
-0.0296042096,
0.0248741526,
-0.0322850607,
0.0164048951,
-0.0340348892,
0.0039437087,
0.0885845646,
-0.0575051792,
-0.0528215766,
0.0422454439,
0.0128005706,
-0.0013737775,
0.0007719988,
-0.0503915772,
0.0097153075,
-0.012217382,
0.0457854047,
0.1093231365,
0.02889915,
0.0519960597,
0.0766437352,
0.0315359682,
-0.0481346101,
-0.000035009,
0.0095537128,
0.0345004164,
0.0023891069,
-0.0240892079,
0.037443269,
0.0446448103,
0.0278998148,
-0.0095844576,
-0.054737702,
0.0169128589,
-0.0426987931,
-0.0222405717,
-0.0043492159,
-0.0699054375,
-0.0526988357,
0.0256702192,
-0.0324603468,
-0.0262787621,
0.04456174,
-0.0240543075,
0.0196740683,
-0.0252343304,
0.0212437455,
-0.0419851169,
0.0262018163,
0.0086614648,
0.011360473,
-0.0211868603,
-0.0177702419,
-0.0390564837,
0.0842510089,
0.011656072,
-0.0310289171,
-0.0044038626,
-0.0234325211,
-0.0063207541,
-0.0184903163,
-0.0090096239,
-0.0301773865,
0.0050567137,
0.0164500512,
0.0048895194,
0.0046153329,
-0.0102650318,
0.0268688854,
-0.0079775341,
-0.0187390782,
0.0718458593,
-0.048417192,
0.019670818,
-0.0426473096,
0.0800395384,
0.0369884223,
-0.0381579623,
-0.0462090895,
-0.0569011532,
0.0440188423,
0.0757703707,
-0.0265342481,
0.0161137935,
0.0247452352,
-0.0343841985,
0.0217905119,
-0.0321932286,
-0.014289327,
-0.0037412422,
0.0697099268,
-0.0648038536,
-0.0329791978,
0.1083230153,
0.0416168347,
-0.0705428571,
-0.0224876236,
-0.0322320424,
-0.0309375692,
-0.0029525019,
0.0114923045,
-0.0498427004,
-0.0047791484,
0.0019470237,
-0.0033458972,
-0.0378006622,
-0.0187883899,
0.0114150066,
-0.0871267095,
0.0235453472,
-0.0065020141,
0.0019184956,
-0.0168099403,
-0.0229833834,
0.0058950013,
0.0355235375,
-0.0633333102,
-0.0566551499,
-0.0084205195,
0.003217391,
0.0202289056,
-0.026664177,
-0.0085006868,
-0.0576151088,
-0.0392329209,
0.0172190722,
0.0265010707,
0.0451292992,
-0.0063797878,
-0.0465200134,
0.0644741356,
-0.0084138969,
0.0081626698,
0.0009007411,
0.0428081229,
-0.0186684243,
0.0572760291,
-0.0027163194,
0.0233472753,
-0.0133636873,
-0.0048052138,
0.0607034937,
0.0896141306,
-0.0266268104,
-0.0442995392,
-0.0303748008,
0.0241902042,
0.0156035377,
0.0814804584,
0.066845201,
-0.0552365743,
-0.0756078959,
-0.0181768201,
0.0493074208,
-0.0682279617,
-0.0108312918,
-0.01595008,
0.0018610142,
-0.0028385837,
-0.0891752541,
-0.0683493316,
0.0148968864,
0.0063876747,
0.0300905462,
0.0140990373,
0.0112099657,
-0.0158813931,
-0.0353114717,
-0.0430071205,
-0.0110439667,
0.0110295424,
-0.0664852038,
-0.0018730059,
-0.0424307324,
-0.0486496054,
-0.0063119559,
0.0110297613,
-0.0581165329,
-0.0649993718,
0.0256382115,
-0.0033393065,
0.0137915378,
0.007876372,
-0.0031647196,
-0.0638908222,
0.0474152304,
0.0145294173,
-0.0253943596,
0.0174414944,
0.009306795,
-0.0049230163,
-0.0270894207,
-0.0002235033,
0.0224200152,
0.0024568157,
0.0118209757,
0.0101349074,
-0.0354887955,
-0.055444371,
0.0041203932,
-0.0096587539,
0.0233213082,
-0.0224013422,
0.0085084997,
-0.0744068995,
-0.0069391225,
-0.0171968732,
0.0065871174,
-0.0402663574,
-0.0190463122,
0.0172003284,
-0.0065496825,
0.012249398,
0.0267737508,
-0.0282591097,
0.0635308996,
-0.0301029682,
0.0381735042,
-0.0184320956,
0.0889575705,
-0.0041264929,
0.0094266757,
-0.0180738326,
0.0569844842,
-0.0137444781,
0.0185158513,
0.0126035661,
0.0829997733,
0.0142815206,
-0.0195062831,
0.0669339597,
0.036403399,
-0.0650438219,
0.025148835,
-0.052708555,
0.0563986041,
0.0266525522,
0.0129819317,
0.0422466323,
-0.0125673655,
-0.0206904411,
-0.0198283195,
0.0568943992,
0.0105407424,
-0.0832059905,
-0.0077235959,
0.0135331815,
0.0069163986,
-0.0188907627,
0.0461242981,
-0.0155334277,
0.0309771076,
-0.0157797132,
-0.0090748481,
-0.0213119425,
-0.0058314512,
0.0717394799,
-0.0008133455,
0.0131655978,
0.0213851333,
-0.0412626117,
-0.0287978277,
0.0432200544,
0.02723087,
0.0203975141,
-0.0250899624,
0.0017018643,
0.0435930602,
-0.0283573549,
0.0081439838,
-0.0521521792,
0.0101302462,
-0.0069200071,
-0.0265521221,
-0.0388671383,
-5.496207876e-33,
-0.0197008047,
-0.0806828961,
-0.0103391819,
0.0673250183,
-0.0507322177,
0.0269888807,
-0.031899862,
0.0063222782,
0.0487613864,
0.0190278329,
0.0165870562,
-0.0022265923,
-0.0002348213,
0.005215446,
-0.0064817639,
0.0027848626,
0.0550213754,
-0.0451640114,
-0.0284138657,
0.0101076653,
0.0094788633,
0.0068211914,
-0.0046564261,
-0.0483982451,
0.0344189107,
-0.0601883344,
-0.0036053192,
-0.0168205835,
-0.0230807196,
0.0401602164,
-0.0193872862,
0.0347492062,
0.0456765257,
0.0039054763,
0.0180217046,
0.0693265572,
-0.0436832793,
-0.0354770273,
-0.045008298,
-0.0013612306,
-0.0342469923,
-0.0939233527,
0.028680332,
-0.0093891369,
-0.0358418263,
-0.0148322433,
0.0836836621,
-0.0018644137,
0.0182644539,
-0.0659492314,
-0.0848151967,
0.0193987247,
-0.0204274822,
-0.0157743301,
0.0211549383,
0.0764757767,
0.0212518908,
-0.029096473,
-0.052998364,
0.0321370214,
0.0182791166,
0.0073726415,
0.0269698519,
-0.0341772661,
-0.0123099564,
0.0625649989,
0.0264649708,
0.0372635908,
-0.0293801855,
-0.0261905156,
0.028047502,
-0.037125919,
0.0468519591,
0.0475817174,
-0.0073801312,
-0.0210644305,
0.0003188227,
0.0531938113,
0.017758796,
-0.0143006854,
0.0111755515,
-0.0252085812,
-0.0557335988,
-0.0193582922,
0.0049523306,
-0.0579161644,
-0.0031293521,
-0.0280062351,
0.0541897006,
0.0102297161,
-0.007279804,
-0.0347988196,
0.0037120995,
-0.0337613001,
0.0335771404,
-0.0239071008,
-0.0227494258,
0.0451504067,
0.0086151026,
0.0202383455,
-0.0213417113,
-0.0141211199,
0.0404199101,
-0.0108211031,
0.0261709038,
0.0063752742,
0.0567711629,
0.003877366,
-0.0217167791,
-0.0122096315,
-0.0420044363,
0.0066992673,
0.0219065771,
0.0140356235,
0.0204425082,
-0.0128016556,
-0.0123220952,
0.0556093901,
0.0303447712,
0.0131604401,
-0.0678411499,
-0.0184283834,
-0.0233703926,
-0.0103703169,
-0.0308294259,
0.0095601631,
-0.0364252701,
-0.0064902026,
0.0061179157,
-0.045187369,
0.0085619986,
-0.0339946114,
2.571e-7,
0.0193821304,
0.0288520399,
0.0544613265,
-0.0188421309,
0.0266471133,
0.0017556469,
-0.0252090357,
0.0147615997,
0.0239991527,
0.0387821905,
0.0382011011,
0.0245606024,
0.0759812146,
0.0091558136,
-0.102007553,
0.0255086385,
-0.0372405164,
-0.0312986225,
-0.0521250702,
0.0353644677,
0.1045403928,
-0.0313844718,
0.003254235,
-0.0203828439,
-0.0427838303,
-0.0197891928,
0.051569853,
0.0049629859,
0.0180674866,
0.0375718884,
0.0241671614,
-0.041338753,
0.0099986782,
0.0295646675,
-0.0065446775,
0.0051027336,
0.0289190467,
0.0611613952,
0.0076486007,
0.0376263149,
0.0516946018,
-0.0021404473,
-0.0038941973,
-0.0550654791,
0.0657433197,
-0.0230901595,
0.0169875529,
-0.0303848237,
-0.0124043729,
-0.0471328162,
0.0062147183,
-0.0146229016,
0.0232107043,
0.0138583025,
-0.0077014444,
-0.0268150773,
0.0473280512,
-0.025079025,
-0.0251391139,
-0.0544741936,
-0.0560518801,
0.0360066369,
-0.0619005561,
0.0227979589,
-0.0042240103,
-0.0777012482,
0.0250315908,
2.398596682e-34,
0.010402617,
-0.0432291366,
0.0104555935,
0.0090997033,
0.0400056466,
0.0169167481,
0.0040511694,
0.0071353177,
-0.0071263891,
-0.0359304659,
-0.0048343404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12266v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12266v1 | Transformer-based Joint Source Channel Coding for Textual Semantic Communication | 2023-07-23T08:42:05 | 2023-07-23T08:42:05 | Shicong Liu, Zhen Gao, Gaojie Chen, Yu Su, Lu Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.SP | The Space-Air-Ground-Sea integrated network calls for more robust and secure
transmission techniques against jamming. In this paper, we propose a textual
semantic transmission framework for robust transmission, which utilizes the
advanced natural language processing techniques to model and encode sentences.
Specifically, the textual sentences are firstly split into tokens using
wordpiece algorithm, and are embedded to token vectors for semantic extraction
by Transformer-based encoder. The encoded data are quantized to a fixed length
binary sequence for transmission, where binary erasure, symmetric, and deletion
channels are considered for transmission. The received binary sequences are
further decoded by the transformer decoders into tokens used for sentence
reconstruction. Our proposed approach leverages the power of neural networks
and attention mechanism to provide reliable and efficient communication of
textual data in challenging wireless environments, and simulation results on
semantic similarity and bilingual evaluation understudy prove the superiority
of the proposed model in semantic transmission. | [
0.0110809263,
0.0105200578,
0.0095191067,
0.0133777251,
-0.0400890522,
-0.007099214,
0.0014588635,
-0.002689929,
-0.0728052557,
-0.0628611147,
0.0198981613,
0.0142108779,
0.0069759861,
0.0158429835,
0.0212180167,
-0.002129117,
0.0366483033,
-0.0229752678,
-0.0149812894,
-0.0020307484,
-0.0122528905,
0.0020475246,
0.0071226447,
0.0271471124,
-0.0122531606,
0.0235518105,
-0.0258345939,
-0.0115490183,
0.0183789507,
-0.0331338607,
-0.005550269,
0.0188047886,
0.048848629,
0.0291239601,
0.0000019981,
0.0024236145,
-0.0328143723,
-0.0267144404,
-0.01224308,
-0.0131421238,
0.0357098915,
-0.0523564704,
-0.0171898846,
0.0297358613,
-0.0104117561,
-0.0375917703,
0.0527467728,
0.081164293,
0.0860370174,
0.0786761343,
-0.0118195368,
-0.0615596473,
0.0588027686,
0.0009240075,
-0.0008439056,
-0.0363829955,
0.0000031359,
-0.0138762258,
-0.0354152471,
0.0363439322,
-0.0157774836,
0.0467122272,
0.0493072607,
0.0273551606,
0.0268251002,
0.0312796868,
-0.0756110474,
0.029087808,
-0.0528007858,
-0.004805251,
-0.0209189486,
-0.0456168577,
-0.0239649732,
0.0233706031,
-0.0267377887,
-0.0262086615,
-0.0547040142,
0.0379831977,
-0.0208540428,
0.0465172194,
0.0162869226,
0.0309050754,
-0.0223584082,
-0.033802934,
-0.0481401905,
0.0634435266,
0.0159332119,
-0.027163228,
-0.0332186446,
-0.0098385727,
0.0181433298,
-0.0330409817,
0.04135333,
0.0045991233,
-0.0056720222,
-0.0330891795,
-0.095208168,
-0.0446638465,
-0.0329633392,
-0.0790218934,
-0.0133646,
0.0661961585,
-0.0090715038,
0.0303421412,
-0.0459205471,
0.0337164924,
-0.0025666628,
0.0412740521,
0.0195607617,
-0.051738847,
-0.0459033139,
-0.0431861058,
-0.0471653454,
0.0780785754,
-0.0226782039,
-0.0254901201,
-0.0149533441,
-0.0169656761,
0.0564185381,
0.0052307947,
0.0048082364,
0.0076068416,
-0.0644027591,
0.0004106957,
0.0093070306,
-0.004025829,
0.038797956,
0.0165493302,
-0.0072697266,
-0.1036176234,
0.0071065375,
0.0507574007,
-0.0025303271,
-0.0310078952,
-0.041584298,
0.0884766355,
-0.0293442104,
-0.0692842752,
-0.0299426578,
0.0031669631,
0.0214191023,
0.0108425617,
0.0042010192,
-0.0893653855,
0.0248633809,
0.0102086449,
-0.0220776796,
-0.0117231738,
0.0160654616,
0.0311076194,
0.0008833555,
0.068373628,
-0.0041062273,
-0.0212178305,
0.0325219892,
0.0223750155,
0.0518593937,
0.0655014142,
0.0561339743,
0.0189205594,
0.0441157334,
0.0006411421,
-0.0090000788,
0.022614399,
0.0067341663,
-0.0088194739,
-0.0420082659,
-0.009793533,
0.0288874228,
0.0093004853,
0.0076271659,
0.0529576577,
-0.0409901626,
0.0035656577,
0.0428158343,
0.0576904938,
0.0329928137,
0.0606323741,
0.0300782379,
0.0600926764,
-0.0187395383,
-0.011526214,
0.0013012149,
0.0568933673,
0.0006509125,
-0.0343699567,
0.0345707722,
0.080343172,
-0.0282593686,
-0.0191057231,
0.0101794098,
-0.0728781,
0.0448564738,
-0.0702023432,
0.034813229,
-0.02171918,
-0.0496339425,
0.1005798504,
0.009947408,
-0.0412051491,
-0.0144287487,
0.0301750414,
-0.0425726958,
0.005769745,
0.0238284338,
0.0397934616,
-0.0039614295,
-0.0445308872,
-0.0106317848,
0.0161681045,
-0.0464195944,
0.0576993972,
0.041380696,
-0.0500094146,
-0.0254171751,
0.0344558358,
-0.0235140193,
0.0079271067,
-0.0091913119,
0.0524102822,
0.0305510908,
0.0420833267,
-0.0072208205,
0.0355445929,
0.0406214744,
0.0131454328,
0.0127278119,
0.0066516395,
0.0331193358,
0.0432723947,
-0.0062524169,
-0.0003067318,
0.0181902647,
-0.0714496523,
-0.0537910573,
0.0369564109,
-0.0443267524,
-0.0039451923,
-0.0316331163,
-0.0891126767,
0.0252413228,
0.0691802651,
0.0154974032,
-0.0192553103,
0.0246911924,
-0.0597888641,
0.0310967583,
-0.0087652402,
0.0090156393,
0.0030579856,
0.0581862256,
0.0169350617,
0.0017012239,
-0.0097805858,
-0.0196054466,
-0.0616460107,
-0.0233660955,
0.0547774695,
-0.0247120783,
-0.001985552,
0.0352156609,
-0.0117198378,
0.0126285944,
0.0365591645,
0.0239051394,
0.0222815257,
-0.028614834,
-0.0615060776,
-0.0218475144,
-0.0318063758,
0.0322984867,
0.0202490166,
0.0151906507,
-0.0115016326,
0.004984471,
-0.0389681682,
0.0057523255,
0.0013495228,
-0.0313421674,
0.0250580031,
-0.0186481141,
-0.0112801073,
-0.0009827139,
-0.0401698872,
0.0185828898,
0.0749446899,
0.0228918362,
-0.0511727966,
-0.1015302762,
0.004598646,
-0.011425375,
-0.0009173276,
-0.0100742495,
-0.0680158064,
0.0470913239,
0.0005484514,
0.0063054604,
0.0028071059,
0.0560631752,
0.0069922768,
0.0288815983,
-0.0104283923,
-0.0046635456,
0.0118839117,
-0.0521865785,
0.0223454591,
-0.0342631936,
0.0087530212,
0.0551729687,
0.0101654585,
0.0039565582,
0.0360344909,
-0.0301817842,
-0.0200685449,
0.0170140192,
0.0100395959,
-0.0262916442,
-0.0025736524,
-0.0143849319,
0.0256260764,
0.0189665649,
0.0045458172,
0.045904927,
-0.0234450698,
-0.0241791941,
-0.0943154842,
-0.0136573771,
-0.0160294697,
0.003932904,
-0.056502115,
0.0181057807,
-0.0413966291,
-0.0416013747,
-0.0129132653,
0.0090477932,
-0.0063127168,
0.0103998091,
-0.0079787187,
0.0018357642,
0.0043897564,
-0.0035138133,
-0.0051137102,
-0.0091175018,
-0.0099421209,
-0.0237576291,
0.0178589895,
0.0325417742,
-0.0185623039,
-0.0285780523,
0.0143082868,
0.0750660971,
0.013389227,
-0.0285382569,
-0.0023618669,
-0.0354730859,
0.0462475382,
0.016859984,
-0.0336449146,
-0.0008369672,
0.0325723328,
-0.0212626494,
0.0474236794,
-0.0214087144,
0.0382063985,
-0.0100384522,
-0.0069996906,
0.0443371423,
0.0072894362,
0.0040921257,
0.0300391112,
0.0561119393,
-0.0148581807,
-0.0064493567,
0.0741462931,
0.038584996,
-0.0270282887,
-0.0147668449,
-0.0124629159,
-0.0412740186,
-0.006072931,
-0.0009995949,
-0.0712402835,
-0.0246175472,
-0.0218220316,
-0.0208556075,
0.0147605743,
-0.0073306295,
-0.0007410132,
-0.0805022493,
-0.0101410216,
0.0170058589,
-0.0709092468,
-0.101252988,
-0.0535361655,
-0.0448673964,
0.0109244585,
0.019368602,
0.0155984852,
0.0683606043,
-0.0122788073,
-0.0063872659,
-0.0011916908,
-0.054771401,
-0.0091619072,
-0.0645053387,
0.0472910032,
0.0239861477,
0.0146504454,
-0.0383902565,
-0.0598322749,
0.0088844411,
-0.0131519102,
-0.0137447892,
0.0174153671,
-0.014322727,
-0.0355836712,
0.0023638073,
-0.0105454735,
0.0200331267,
-0.0029500478,
-0.0152434371,
0.0053774524,
0.0425714068,
-0.0213188734,
0.0159111526,
0.0028290087,
0.0005443615,
0.0229194779,
0.0412577949,
-0.0119072525,
-0.0245562717,
-0.0522333235,
-0.0213716179,
0.0138717797,
-0.0513564944,
-0.057601776,
0.0420466587,
0.0527637675,
-0.0786261111,
-0.058247976,
-0.0300923176,
-0.0117488811,
0.0117371893,
-0.0137899937,
0.0298922751,
0.0416902527,
0.0050155558,
-0.0350915752,
-0.0343588293,
-0.0189333763,
0.0117139984,
-0.0352076553,
0.0600204803,
-0.0304951593,
-0.0486574583,
-0.0004164506,
0.0456022769,
-0.1052377149,
-0.0217884444,
0.0575733781,
-0.0135130864,
0.012631394,
0.0119653214,
-0.0596098341,
-0.0624273494,
0.0048009702,
0.0833720341,
-0.0959064215,
0.0181178749,
-0.0031489409,
0.0349244922,
0.0367289893,
0.0079036485,
-0.0342909135,
0.0054412256,
-0.0075978832,
0.0148143452,
0.0030905048,
-0.0274098888,
0.0362440348,
-0.0228483155,
0.0411942489,
0.012753319,
0.0081748134,
0.0312712826,
0.0378647521,
-0.0444366895,
0.0317408964,
-0.0141975116,
0.0490734056,
-0.0356604494,
0.0142245227,
0.0430448093,
-0.001894907,
0.0138797117,
-0.0158903636,
0.0463981256,
0.0119217513,
-0.005098037,
0.0081665544,
0.0227596238,
0.00644685,
-0.000525084,
-0.0600570031,
-0.005401562,
-0.0320698395,
-0.0573442057,
0.0309628248,
0.0638349652,
-0.0155315036,
-0.0073864558,
0.0327012874,
-0.0364520103,
-0.0123904143,
0.0093389414,
0.039628718,
0.0469905362,
0.0629607663,
-0.0519080274,
-0.0359285474,
0.0119414069,
0.0060387272,
0.0297918003,
-0.0153458072,
0.0167365074,
0.0390320644,
0.0149190547,
-0.0314182937,
0.0252912603,
0.0124266753,
-0.0270325411,
-0.0260125361,
0.0187441334,
-0.0142441392,
-0.0414974131,
0.0265541431,
-0.015481554,
0.0380736999,
-0.0208520591,
0.0244397223,
-0.0017363438,
-0.0107464204,
0.0692804977,
0.0034576291,
0.0486377105,
-0.0293633398,
0.0459200032,
0.0736430064,
-0.0138677163,
0.0092510283,
0.0176236071,
-0.0099343155,
-0.002205211,
-0.0286656283,
-0.0337638594,
-6.628890355e-33,
0.0018065028,
0.0103984419,
-0.0073355157,
0.0191636514,
-0.0243243761,
-0.0122237522,
-0.0250548515,
-0.0262723379,
0.0189817976,
-0.0372648612,
-0.0023741124,
0.0532311462,
0.010207817,
0.0465685427,
-0.0093542617,
-0.0186034907,
0.0270015839,
0.0063834651,
-0.0397817306,
0.0194920488,
0.0847148448,
0.0281059667,
0.0509074628,
-0.0332106017,
-0.0105285766,
-0.0062490227,
0.0268586129,
-0.0327518769,
0.0443782881,
0.0503476635,
-0.0354603492,
0.0299239978,
0.0144230882,
-0.0764034316,
-0.0141553637,
0.0411318429,
-0.0148723321,
-0.0343607403,
0.0063761375,
0.0216473751,
-0.0125115607,
-0.0489435643,
0.0061096894,
-0.0119119706,
-0.0091076167,
0.0149221821,
0.0174603555,
0.0131799504,
-0.0078652976,
-0.0432830043,
-0.0420463383,
0.0189071894,
0.0013638148,
0.0207689181,
0.0152402064,
0.0196296368,
-0.0283087809,
0.0100772455,
-0.069966875,
0.0331181176,
-0.0290394444,
0.0502300635,
-0.0217758063,
-0.0369435437,
-0.0150505425,
0.0280053671,
-0.0178913306,
-0.0682122633,
-0.0578717366,
0.0444258526,
0.0153281614,
-0.0292590838,
0.0722652301,
0.0564526953,
0.0489280522,
-0.0330716856,
-0.05994514,
-0.0288086589,
-0.0495105386,
0.0655697361,
0.0490797311,
0.0151878214,
-0.0255628824,
-0.0073176869,
0.0050539142,
-0.0178888775,
-0.0158246849,
-0.0186421424,
0.0057614418,
-0.0033065574,
-0.0366527103,
0.0234751906,
0.0628967211,
-0.0125110121,
0.035912808,
0.0538231321,
0.0087543577,
0.0252587628,
-0.011399813,
-0.0045033968,
-0.0329452008,
0.0080289189,
0.0618490428,
-0.0027120807,
0.0200503804,
0.0050342008,
0.0048427219,
0.0550770052,
-0.0382455252,
-0.0173145775,
-0.0204231441,
0.0122191589,
0.0010268337,
-0.0289754029,
0.0226473622,
0.0033707723,
-0.0154966479,
0.0292413048,
-0.0017406869,
-0.062501885,
0.0130328666,
-0.0141325034,
0.0240347311,
0.0289131422,
-0.037000645,
0.0437604487,
-0.0823840573,
0.0463607199,
0.009019956,
-0.0453593358,
-0.0455346778,
0.0588582382,
2.848e-7,
-0.0008281193,
0.0187747143,
0.0943260938,
-0.0221148375,
0.0109695774,
-0.0081137726,
0.0379887037,
0.0519318022,
-0.0154052489,
0.024476219,
-0.0230969191,
0.0091222376,
0.0391496234,
0.002082384,
-0.1259603202,
0.0231707804,
-0.0698544681,
-0.0442808084,
-0.0611888729,
-0.0001782439,
0.1681114882,
0.0650924593,
0.0162818599,
0.0213862844,
-0.0183388647,
0.012606062,
0.0111956112,
0.0036467451,
0.0219470412,
-0.0497078858,
0.0088910749,
0.0189521629,
-0.0497855172,
0.0104183666,
0.0062602884,
0.0091334553,
0.0101761837,
0.0098760305,
0.0099343127,
0.0040458413,
-0.0010149161,
0.0004398658,
-0.0719347894,
-0.0351743959,
0.0418281779,
-0.1197881028,
-0.0448125005,
0.0352554508,
-0.0086121783,
0.0269986372,
-0.0217976402,
0.0050996933,
-0.0416807123,
-0.0458060168,
0.0210781936,
0.0397728235,
0.0308394264,
-0.0509612598,
0.0265066698,
0.0082799224,
-0.025129592,
0.0049961172,
-0.0600638092,
-0.0022205734,
0.0814300925,
-0.0033083684,
0.0233629942,
2.152169444e-34,
0.0182783827,
0.0155623537,
-0.0086784484,
0.0257897973,
0.0064946581,
-0.0289579351,
-0.0030795399,
0.0276344474,
-0.012063141,
-0.0340125561,
-0.0270370599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12262v1 | A meta learning scheme for fast accent domain expansion in Mandarin speech recognition | 2023-07-23T08:23:26 | 2023-07-23T08:23:26 | Ziwei Zhu, Changhao Shan, Bihong Zhang, Jian Yu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.AS | Spoken languages show significant variation across mandarin and accent.
Despite the high performance of mandarin automatic speech recognition (ASR),
accent ASR is still a challenge task. In this paper, we introduce meta-learning
techniques for fast accent domain expansion in mandarin speech recognition,
which expands the field of accents without deteriorating the performance of
mandarin ASR. Meta-learning or learn-to-learn can learn general relation in
multi domains not only for over-fitting a specific domain. So we select
meta-learning in the domain expansion task. This more essential learning will
cause improved performance on accent domain extension tasks. We combine the
methods of meta learning and freeze of model parameters, which makes the
recognition performance more stable in different cases and the training faster
about 20%. Our approach significantly outperforms other methods about 3%
relatively in the accent domain expansion task. Compared to the baseline model,
it improves relatively 37% under the condition that the mandarin test set
remains unchanged. In addition, it also proved this method to be effective on a
large amount of data with a relative performance improvement of 4% on the
accent test set. | [
0.0183232594,
0.0267644729,
0.0141573502,
-0.0088741137,
-0.0200931747,
0.0066271452,
0.0585491247,
-0.0060545551,
-0.0693364143,
-0.0014274939,
-0.0785276666,
-0.0337406769,
0.0528909527,
0.0134523436,
-0.0050065005,
-0.0646718293,
0.0067782938,
-0.0450484417,
-0.013469113,
-0.0305030048,
0.0163645577,
-0.0143861072,
-0.0071677002,
0.0219722744,
0.01508673,
0.0316285715,
-0.014823352,
0.0087258024,
0.0527821891,
-0.0046095159,
-0.0101730246,
0.0139361294,
-0.0062328712,
0.0155075425,
0.0000021372,
-0.0382104926,
-0.044540178,
-0.0103591001,
-0.0371465497,
-0.0084626293,
0.0536486246,
0.0112434411,
-0.0313738026,
0.0537012443,
-0.033234518,
-0.0646251738,
0.0923633948,
0.0332962275,
-0.0201132074,
0.0255223382,
-0.026847953,
-0.0352369845,
-0.0373756699,
-0.0165961161,
-0.0337553583,
-0.0729085281,
0.0267406572,
-0.0502196066,
-0.0129082175,
-0.0183198974,
0.0051387576,
0.0202930868,
0.001613997,
0.0252730083,
-0.0182933211,
0.0203357302,
-0.0087948646,
0.0264198463,
-0.0063147456,
0.0401656739,
-0.031765867,
-0.0339641199,
-0.0107645066,
0.0049789241,
0.0001594238,
0.0506922975,
-0.0035621545,
-0.0209356304,
-0.0306031592,
-0.0248188321,
-0.0477588885,
0.0273109805,
0.02905857,
0.0137692904,
-0.0492114238,
-0.0020652954,
-0.0092997691,
-0.0295013599,
0.0283410493,
-0.0502319708,
-0.0583954155,
0.0425658226,
0.0194133017,
0.0038614934,
0.0152510069,
-0.0040437095,
-0.0043539149,
-0.0178314392,
-0.0092602232,
-0.0119120609,
0.0443989225,
0.0316178538,
-0.0606767312,
-0.01296834,
-0.0046148123,
0.0121512152,
-0.0064005372,
-0.0112143699,
-0.0509280041,
-0.026716372,
-0.0812045112,
0.001206287,
-0.0681816489,
0.0476599932,
0.022400314,
0.0213566367,
-0.0485201366,
-0.0326334015,
0.014975789,
-0.0213805493,
0.0417927206,
-0.0342523977,
-0.0319994725,
-0.0345309898,
0.0315325111,
0.0397186838,
-0.0438462049,
0.0651334003,
-0.0393206403,
-0.0167697743,
-0.0015246551,
0.0002988185,
0.0346737616,
-0.0052565942,
0.0279893223,
0.0344880708,
0.0347423479,
-0.0395786427,
-0.0414085127,
0.0407510251,
-0.0422455147,
-0.035100773,
-0.0072827297,
-0.0389174744,
-0.013598402,
-0.0341557339,
0.0178755261,
-0.0242978279,
-0.0390776061,
-0.0433844551,
0.0481628515,
0.0596660934,
-0.0524658337,
-0.0121816173,
0.0349891521,
-0.0051577007,
-0.0355894789,
0.0636324361,
0.0202360824,
-0.0067682476,
-0.0199591834,
-0.0096518444,
0.0406852178,
0.0263686068,
0.0210359786,
-0.0108895525,
0.0170256831,
-0.0320517197,
0.0204474553,
-0.0265671536,
-0.0001828806,
0.0093644252,
-0.0196518525,
-0.0191714149,
0.0122380666,
0.0125728967,
0.0081548011,
0.0003822223,
0.0239844378,
-0.0278523862,
0.0058636055,
-0.0007201058,
-0.0027845039,
0.0039372863,
0.0169318039,
0.0180952027,
-0.0530274883,
0.0424670093,
-0.065318957,
-0.0264099799,
0.0280453712,
-0.0521946847,
-0.0502199233,
0.0164562892,
0.0569125004,
0.009935623,
0.0070796134,
-0.0185403675,
0.0196799431,
-0.0158653446,
0.0069987299,
-0.0465445295,
-0.0567789003,
0.0498736948,
-0.0284132026,
-0.0578669608,
-0.0437259711,
-0.0525252111,
0.0323433466,
0.0253081471,
-0.0221584886,
0.0028765588,
0.0495670103,
-0.0690843835,
0.0041989959,
0.0710604638,
-0.002804768,
0.0455760695,
-0.0267565809,
0.0334468894,
0.0114297653,
-0.078602694,
0.0345756151,
-0.0115995659,
-0.035531655,
0.0052755717,
0.0418248773,
0.0571490638,
-0.002513459,
0.0132921012,
-0.0307194125,
-0.0318460204,
0.0031119273,
-0.0508188568,
-0.0054165754,
0.0868700668,
-0.0278092604,
-0.0105235865,
0.0742345452,
-0.0422861092,
0.0092299189,
0.002179736,
-0.002257318,
-0.104591392,
0.0031880529,
0.0425592177,
0.0450763106,
-0.0854908824,
0.0475759692,
-0.0401031896,
0.0269661713,
-0.0267724879,
0.0261617303,
0.0113706011,
-0.024307305,
0.0517769344,
-0.0154670626,
0.0277465861,
-0.0129389595,
-0.0225408282,
0.0620299354,
-0.0231339652,
0.0465525053,
0.0031876483,
-0.0262504052,
0.0098252455,
-0.0114175342,
-0.0395160951,
-0.0313601568,
-0.0407726802,
0.0260480195,
0.0024482911,
0.0558307208,
0.0029448164,
-0.0104909232,
0.0161120314,
-0.0148991095,
-0.0668129399,
-0.0169498567,
-0.0464364514,
0.0083343387,
-0.0014221232,
0.0069992929,
-0.008109089,
0.0218024086,
0.0138879344,
-0.0333877802,
0.0033993658,
-0.0085681491,
-0.0510676987,
0.0204313807,
0.0224489365,
-0.0045102141,
-0.0499436893,
-0.0708145127,
-0.0280533396,
-0.0145398565,
0.0034130362,
0.0024973326,
-0.0338573344,
0.0443267748,
0.0353213064,
-0.0295311231,
-0.0081817377,
0.0104430933,
0.0166891254,
-0.0204881132,
0.0219923183,
-0.063617371,
0.0146593051,
0.004214928,
0.0113299359,
-0.0415054448,
-0.0226779711,
0.0132022249,
-0.0333795771,
-0.0143124238,
0.020653937,
-0.0398157686,
-0.0166441146,
-0.0324762836,
-0.0199894514,
0.047044564,
-0.0236598328,
-0.0098426985,
-0.0472660549,
-0.0355341062,
0.0022448311,
-0.0220099203,
-0.0394918583,
0.0156167429,
0.049290292,
-0.0529403985,
-0.0124987764,
-0.0269011967,
0.0406957231,
-0.0216160305,
0.0552126691,
0.0230375603,
0.0045162546,
-0.0127477804,
-0.0241456069,
-0.0362755917,
0.0195721332,
-0.0464739837,
0.0161365699,
-0.0189502202,
-0.0207488853,
0.0036029371,
0.029192118,
0.0043161325,
0.0519565865,
-0.0087055508,
0.0125303101,
-0.0046905493,
0.0298335515,
0.0272393338,
0.0568357147,
-0.0638999194,
0.0038113478,
0.1143863723,
-0.0424003117,
0.0453734323,
0.0140061826,
-0.0730780438,
-0.021272473,
0.0017877957,
0.0033491235,
0.0089283865,
-0.0024967429,
-0.0341037624,
-0.0058582057,
0.0147749856,
0.0868092477,
0.0278497897,
0.0061577735,
-0.0338309668,
-0.0108739603,
0.0386736169,
0.0187024325,
-0.0194733068,
-0.0081398822,
-0.0387845784,
0.0326672718,
0.0207137596,
-0.0058232369,
0.0283353962,
0.0037081798,
-0.0752640516,
0.007138798,
0.0163456779,
-0.0590319932,
-0.0235343277,
-0.0430128165,
-0.015532434,
-0.0166412741,
0.0178507324,
0.0068403101,
-0.022149276,
-0.0522596315,
0.0601810478,
-0.02685868,
-0.0741295591,
0.0012760472,
-0.0382619314,
0.0420514457,
0.0523036085,
0.0007444902,
-0.0503721461,
0.0074605043,
0.0791291744,
0.0405628085,
0.0249878839,
-0.0480157956,
0.0740909427,
0.0294478126,
0.0036647865,
0.0399389565,
0.0036889096,
-0.0249831993,
0.0061977436,
0.0549904443,
0.0497143865,
-0.0208328646,
0.0351224877,
0.0213538893,
0.0085092112,
-0.00606708,
0.0247223936,
-0.0066167763,
-0.0624189228,
0.0236997139,
0.0302677117,
-0.0427448861,
-0.0352377705,
0.0363547131,
0.0779335201,
0.0250781775,
-0.0285175163,
-0.0406957567,
-0.0097272387,
0.0061637154,
0.0772110149,
0.0384080298,
0.0674612075,
-0.0079802629,
0.0613189079,
-0.046908427,
-0.0454142205,
-0.00980167,
0.0284486562,
-0.0373153873,
0.0216051992,
0.0606013574,
-0.0941462144,
0.0108179525,
-0.0150512122,
-0.0032100335,
-0.0348337106,
0.0219390709,
0.011727402,
0.0150456736,
0.0615136772,
-0.023493804,
-0.0322408974,
0.0445948616,
0.0326887593,
0.0341207646,
-0.0014561127,
0.0947157592,
-0.0459920131,
-0.0339385867,
-0.0094148191,
-0.0046898602,
0.0762785226,
0.0059125228,
-0.043809101,
-0.0368246548,
0.0235747639,
0.032151334,
0.0344592221,
0.0583298616,
-0.0338147059,
-0.0027224028,
-0.0390736982,
0.0292839929,
0.0293360297,
0.0286327563,
-0.0195440594,
-0.0210108366,
0.0371243469,
0.0043318989,
0.0054117613,
0.0139127737,
0.0003947831,
-0.084826462,
0.0541125908,
0.0567904525,
-0.0226475522,
0.1048398614,
-0.0273137297,
0.0355535597,
0.002231074,
0.0335806496,
0.0835795701,
-0.0045816102,
-0.0209860001,
0.0243185367,
0.002771239,
-0.0010983171,
-0.0241384227,
0.0302388538,
-0.0431669354,
0.0193037931,
-0.028254848,
0.0057895631,
0.0604966991,
-0.0003995454,
-0.0006357558,
-0.0108574405,
0.0374140367,
-0.0616121441,
0.0261824932,
0.0004073236,
0.0273850374,
0.0102686761,
-0.0177221913,
-0.0070731598,
0.0203953236,
0.0339488946,
0.0113787493,
0.0225688126,
0.0093823522,
0.0388128832,
-0.0358287729,
0.0032627024,
-0.0656992197,
-0.0071282056,
-0.0339858346,
0.0131751094,
-0.0369925611,
-0.0584270917,
0.0626605749,
-0.0266204569,
0.0532484949,
0.0135977697,
0.0247019399,
-0.0186929721,
-0.036742419,
0.0161580686,
0.0098347552,
-0.0322622247,
0.029438179,
0.0222895332,
0.0561251752,
-5.788616871e-33,
-0.0009013521,
0.0236875229,
0.0225962792,
0.0162346903,
-0.0128050903,
-0.0102993883,
0.0094071552,
0.0359564461,
-0.0565427914,
-0.0402836911,
-0.0136799002,
0.0060403515,
0.0510681346,
-0.0024631566,
-0.0333169065,
-0.0237651858,
0.0900227353,
-0.0188049972,
0.0135431131,
-0.0236017946,
0.0432353541,
0.0752153099,
0.0250085574,
-0.0651933178,
-0.0828841329,
0.0325724445,
-0.0514393486,
-0.0101659428,
0.0405543447,
0.0274537802,
0.0289047547,
0.0698898584,
0.012141048,
-0.0431020707,
-0.0219181795,
-0.0079491911,
-0.1193580776,
-0.011350045,
-0.0082838591,
0.0285785329,
0.0167660955,
-0.0412932038,
0.0051369062,
0.0206282455,
0.0193775967,
-0.0249530673,
0.024363216,
-0.0647180453,
-0.0356027894,
0.0193817317,
-0.0199350417,
0.0621444881,
0.0306181945,
0.0149077652,
0.1157521084,
0.0365262516,
-0.0474701412,
-0.0283274855,
-0.0114808893,
0.0123964604,
0.0328400508,
0.0415103808,
-0.0111406622,
0.0599774495,
-0.0109609421,
0.0054136412,
0.0505585521,
-0.0258528162,
0.0714247376,
-0.0166285764,
0.0822836533,
0.0403129719,
-0.0027769511,
0.0870713219,
0.0562250018,
-0.0972795561,
-0.0467038229,
0.0289761908,
0.0170431528,
0.0085651735,
0.0040014619,
-0.0381692573,
-0.0166441444,
0.0195351373,
-0.0506374501,
0.0085728606,
-0.0483387597,
-0.0069684922,
0.043090418,
0.0287195612,
-0.032972578,
0.0086689284,
0.0581059977,
-0.035268236,
0.0259506144,
0.0208175089,
-0.0310296603,
0.0242766105,
-0.0009290496,
0.0057006869,
-0.0293533448,
-0.0649322495,
-0.0067278109,
0.0794232041,
0.0041152886,
-0.0278265681,
0.0717788041,
0.0256967153,
-0.057758633,
-0.0061955852,
0.0122639379,
-0.0101017319,
0.0368873477,
-0.0198249668,
0.0117965834,
0.015831355,
0.0109709091,
0.0051427237,
0.0099902963,
-0.0643199459,
-0.0070158485,
-0.0232660342,
0.0179671515,
0.0431804992,
-0.0214074589,
0.0237070341,
0.0149582066,
-0.0758768916,
0.0416762158,
-0.0533228926,
-0.0265882108,
-0.0167363174,
2.783e-7,
-0.0090593789,
0.0154121742,
0.0289441198,
-0.0229599588,
0.0046802321,
0.0145092197,
-0.0434167199,
-0.0066191684,
0.0074449144,
0.0150256297,
0.0642765239,
-0.0030316822,
0.0585227869,
0.0215647258,
-0.0690587759,
0.022571519,
0.0018145614,
0.0360375978,
0.0231801253,
0.0264618173,
-0.0087515432,
0.0693608597,
-0.0303737838,
-0.0236188117,
0.0171653647,
-0.004082107,
0.0454786979,
0.0118296072,
0.0805606171,
-0.0040814602,
-0.0334854759,
0.0294929408,
-0.0502306633,
0.0422070175,
-0.0282197483,
0.041034475,
0.021486789,
0.0278155617,
-0.0223023035,
-0.0182445534,
0.0192290395,
0.0311222766,
-0.0018257858,
0.0310866106,
0.0592353269,
-0.0248277523,
0.0037331867,
-0.0594575964,
-0.0334001482,
0.0238728765,
-0.0060728616,
-0.0117100347,
0.0244219266,
0.0390422195,
0.0006670706,
-0.0110793365,
-0.0235780645,
-0.057357382,
-0.0292632785,
0.0319908969,
-0.02590736,
-0.0121829323,
-0.0022499366,
-0.0217652209,
0.028649129,
-0.0315174162,
0.0167254601,
1.680755228e-34,
0.0110617392,
-0.061225865,
0.0193853918,
0.0228956062,
-0.0830481797,
-0.0512149073,
-0.0596655682,
0.0018504099,
0.0117075155,
-0.0257334337,
-0.0349705294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02503v1 | MyVoice: Arabic Speech Resource Collaboration Platform | 2023-07-23T07:13:30 | 2023-07-23T07:13:30 | Yousseif Elshahawy, Yassine El Kheir, Shammur Absar Chowdhury, Ahmed Ali | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We introduce MyVoice, a crowdsourcing platform designed to collect Arabic
speech to enhance dialectal speech technologies. This platform offers an
opportunity to design large dialectal speech datasets; and makes them publicly
available. MyVoice allows contributors to select city/country-level
fine-grained dialect and record the displayed utterances. Users can switch
roles between contributors and annotators. The platform incorporates a quality
assurance system that filters out low-quality and spurious recordings before
sending them for validation. During the validation phase, contributors can
assess the quality of recordings, annotate them, and provide feedback which is
then reviewed by administrators. Furthermore, the platform offers flexibility
to admin roles to add new data or tasks beyond dialectal speech and word
collection, which are displayed to contributors. Thus, enabling collaborative
efforts in gathering diverse and large Arabic speech data. | [
0.0082237078,
0.0689924508,
-0.0072533069,
-0.0222228765,
-0.041496899,
-0.0044006007,
0.0345985331,
-0.0261513982,
-0.0553635582,
0.0027431645,
-0.0469561256,
-0.0645166039,
0.0883699581,
0.0102531239,
0.0283002388,
-0.0638609454,
0.0002222685,
-0.0942940488,
0.0057539963,
-0.0137243802,
0.0625194088,
0.0384096019,
-0.054657571,
0.0221716631,
-0.0178171396,
0.0105116162,
-0.0472136214,
-0.0191023666,
0.0105789592,
0.0297756717,
-0.0077766073,
0.0450949222,
-0.0111079011,
0.0013911361,
0.0000020131,
-0.0485008061,
-0.0394498445,
0.0118495934,
-0.0462782197,
0.0092716068,
0.0352825671,
0.0516393073,
-0.0648483932,
0.0263453163,
-0.0070762602,
0.0071942606,
0.0602655001,
0.0054972824,
0.0326868594,
0.0312086809,
0.0170957651,
-0.0219774954,
-0.0410584547,
-0.0104884887,
-0.0307727028,
0.0355158821,
-0.0268280674,
-0.0458692163,
0.0506878495,
-0.0408653319,
0.0270127729,
0.02030164,
-0.0287976246,
-0.0402800888,
0.0004232383,
-0.0408592448,
-0.086193271,
-0.0778868943,
0.0281907022,
0.0303611625,
0.0689196363,
-0.0173105039,
0.0171903931,
0.0377084091,
0.0082653938,
0.0198106896,
-0.0270875636,
0.0307673458,
-0.0232714564,
0.0103854565,
-0.0061942884,
0.0132887345,
-0.0286801532,
-0.0235715881,
0.0235665292,
0.0157015249,
0.0047839251,
-0.0083744153,
-0.0008639313,
0.0013864079,
0.0309761018,
-0.0144598037,
0.0486333407,
-0.0000903755,
-0.0104786409,
-0.0178423524,
0.004725073,
-0.0683464259,
0.0168150384,
-0.0158827733,
0.025537638,
0.0086674225,
-0.0398123041,
0.0091592763,
0.0224617776,
-0.059771724,
0.0468796641,
0.0263555702,
-0.0381111614,
-0.0271126032,
-0.0199721791,
0.0239077192,
-0.0383120924,
0.0318814814,
-0.0543789268,
0.0317851193,
-0.0549203865,
-0.0331308767,
-0.061480917,
0.0332441702,
0.0577772111,
-0.0003328221,
-0.0190361589,
-0.0443248376,
0.0228583571,
-0.0097708218,
-0.0435288213,
0.0510992706,
-0.0243141204,
-0.1212232932,
0.0373955108,
0.0063142157,
0.0638196766,
0.0437299572,
-0.0083530415,
-0.015441996,
0.016153384,
-0.0146891261,
-0.0449889675,
-0.0040900358,
-0.0285786875,
0.0206587221,
-0.0474315286,
-0.0827400535,
0.0432906523,
-0.0262162816,
-0.0274207145,
0.0319994166,
-0.0151473619,
-0.0099654198,
0.0689047873,
0.0523935109,
-0.023319969,
0.0328876711,
0.1001030952,
0.0058134794,
0.0356515683,
0.0543635786,
0.038379658,
-0.0416149907,
0.0177373067,
-0.0048491247,
-0.0060007968,
0.0333282687,
0.0167225655,
0.0240920316,
-0.0449671261,
-0.0385197438,
-0.0070657674,
0.0488744229,
-0.0007112049,
0.055829633,
0.0059445649,
-0.0059720515,
0.0882275403,
0.0603347942,
0.0142424013,
-0.0391332619,
-0.0114672575,
0.0749428272,
0.0240303632,
-0.0483100303,
0.0391458049,
0.0199499223,
0.0387585945,
-0.0135803791,
0.0326779895,
0.0814878792,
-0.0187954828,
-0.0244371649,
-0.0388636366,
-0.0335763656,
-0.0207169242,
0.0225386061,
0.0545206815,
-0.0045446288,
0.001460715,
0.0099064196,
0.0223188791,
-0.0594690256,
0.0218182262,
-0.050119482,
-0.0028491151,
0.0382517166,
-0.017735729,
-0.0046043191,
0.043380145,
-0.0576827824,
-0.0283597801,
0.0400583334,
0.0035695236,
-0.0330827683,
-0.0078691393,
-0.0542246252,
-0.0047438717,
0.069799684,
0.0016396486,
0.0011723302,
-0.0048122313,
0.0308288094,
-0.0181293581,
-0.0102949031,
0.0367829017,
-0.0230186377,
0.0115845092,
0.019958429,
0.0058001266,
0.0249531344,
0.0394215547,
0.0760418624,
-0.0226610396,
0.0293637365,
0.0062043518,
0.0012701238,
-0.014404784,
0.0560581125,
0.0089119663,
0.0456600785,
0.0527088605,
-0.0338560827,
0.0224539377,
0.0139184138,
0.0565048903,
-0.0605760962,
0.0858169273,
-0.0528638326,
0.0721237138,
-0.0314911269,
0.0263963304,
-0.0018732756,
0.0022447929,
0.0595619418,
-0.0213601924,
0.0037040419,
-0.0475038588,
-0.0075714444,
-0.0389373638,
0.0247860104,
-0.0282866117,
-0.0015148595,
0.0176808611,
-0.0167393647,
0.0658055767,
0.0216688272,
-0.0496853627,
-0.040449068,
-0.0352385268,
-0.0978993177,
-0.0267372858,
-0.0010582057,
0.0196329448,
-0.0430863239,
0.0221073423,
-0.0101314513,
-0.0109154712,
-0.0242128875,
-0.0542675816,
-0.0048549306,
-0.0041458397,
-0.0250143949,
-0.0130444625,
0.0069674314,
-0.061700955,
0.0136413015,
0.0332636312,
-0.0009779261,
0.0150357103,
-0.0384018831,
0.0408906117,
-0.097868003,
0.0172264595,
0.0150228031,
0.0264958143,
-0.040249683,
0.031017134,
-0.0018332239,
0.0320360847,
0.0165853482,
0.0025260004,
-0.0030467445,
0.0057912217,
-0.0264693983,
-0.0237623993,
-0.0111612221,
0.0425123349,
-0.0014644573,
-0.0140074613,
-0.0475083962,
-0.0276686884,
-0.010430472,
0.0538008697,
0.0181294028,
-0.0346091241,
0.0240781344,
-0.0381974988,
0.0239392594,
0.0085852575,
-0.01038149,
-0.0513793379,
0.0744500831,
-0.0016338485,
-0.0142468484,
-0.0155051583,
-0.0402524062,
-0.0148448152,
0.0213999115,
-0.0469790585,
-0.0479996093,
-0.005272896,
-0.0728190541,
0.0172625817,
-0.0194524564,
-0.0117475921,
0.0060133454,
-0.0119944625,
0.0547721609,
-0.047220137,
-0.0160911847,
-0.0546983182,
-0.0144729987,
-0.020196218,
-0.0268137027,
0.0247414503,
0.0329511687,
-0.0855439678,
0.0007354371,
0.0635296106,
-0.0206210725,
0.0306463409,
0.0185810085,
0.0122100133,
0.0401342921,
0.0153593514,
0.0390526131,
0.0305718575,
-0.0288831498,
-0.002982768,
0.0780332834,
-0.009831747,
0.0192924328,
0.0147972694,
0.0048746318,
0.0099140927,
0.0133363511,
-0.0361281782,
-0.0148003753,
0.0420722812,
-0.0046749567,
-0.0413033552,
-0.029483242,
0.0253407545,
-0.0114940051,
0.0518796742,
0.0485649407,
-0.0147042572,
-0.0150496205,
-0.0225690771,
-0.0271870848,
0.0103961751,
-0.0123618115,
-0.0272862185,
-0.0999180824,
0.0056964578,
0.0657912642,
0.077762939,
0.0050620758,
0.0206174217,
0.0252760034,
-0.0771353543,
0.0412398577,
0.0063310922,
-0.005552934,
-0.0022507112,
-0.0506476797,
-0.0047886968,
-0.0329574049,
-0.0240869466,
-0.0319074541,
-0.0029943637,
0.0203434881,
0.0666506439,
-0.0296329502,
-0.049010586,
-0.0132071413,
-0.0508840233,
0.1269026399,
0.0276539735,
0.0319754779,
-0.0272449069,
-0.0747492015,
-0.0474558622,
-0.0289223026,
-0.0394177437,
0.0172844231,
-0.004299582,
0.0294717737,
-0.0185237769,
-0.0412671901,
0.0090764863,
-0.0479922071,
0.0108058238,
-0.0015472068,
0.033478491,
0.0031610087,
0.0691291541,
0.0144961067,
0.0513535291,
0.0153835667,
0.0444546342,
0.0016167355,
-0.0534729287,
0.0034340518,
0.0067395484,
-0.011657875,
-0.0820642039,
-0.0412148908,
0.0231222343,
0.0453987643,
-0.0613439158,
-0.0668115467,
-0.0176072717,
0.0187804662,
0.0179192554,
0.0284516104,
0.0137203326,
0.0264286846,
0.0414399952,
-0.0230308883,
-0.0259785689,
0.0289155263,
0.0248761028,
-0.0737408102,
-0.0709516257,
0.0043643466,
-0.0545850843,
0.0193722732,
-0.0087124463,
-0.0817069411,
-0.028692333,
0.0947215483,
0.0042093731,
0.0184801705,
0.0325330235,
0.0078149633,
-0.0227712914,
-0.0066287769,
-0.0282589812,
-0.0066592027,
0.0404330753,
0.0571471751,
0.0120069599,
-0.0206793174,
0.0281061977,
-0.0083492063,
-0.0171243344,
-0.0200225711,
-0.0597561598,
-0.0316043608,
-0.0601871088,
0.0012739106,
-0.0146628292,
0.015358476,
-0.0292061567,
-0.0398359224,
-0.0431948081,
-0.0102155376,
-0.0148719056,
0.0383927003,
-0.0429254919,
-0.0049636131,
0.0119935777,
0.0118556404,
0.0171537083,
0.0305254068,
-0.0184666738,
-0.0353667401,
0.0290008113,
0.0829920024,
0.0471115336,
-0.0043679844,
-0.0071299924,
0.0497275703,
0.0148756029,
0.0072802496,
-0.0354082473,
0.0562401302,
-0.002929819,
-0.0419536494,
-0.0272473209,
-0.0216324944,
0.0767913833,
0.0404846631,
0.040709585,
-0.0377710648,
0.0166323483,
0.0715862587,
0.0207991805,
-0.0172207914,
0.0489677563,
0.0151512427,
0.0100352308,
0.0014687619,
0.0166796073,
-0.046333611,
0.0044083968,
-0.0356045105,
-0.0138871251,
-0.0171951465,
0.0449493863,
0.0271341875,
-0.0429599471,
-0.0003067046,
0.0029011145,
0.0235452857,
-0.0233887509,
0.0009084506,
-0.0208050683,
-0.0126714241,
-0.0471118875,
0.0098405005,
-0.0505304113,
-0.0492624827,
-0.0147565939,
0.0176549368,
-0.0179087594,
-0.0188729391,
0.0414842963,
0.0102861943,
-0.036322929,
0.0111727361,
-0.0289800465,
-0.0055124727,
-0.0169549584,
-0.0140288556,
0.0613117851,
-6.567708078e-33,
-0.0202386919,
-0.0402424373,
-0.0051055923,
-0.007481874,
0.0116475755,
-0.0116046527,
-0.0077509326,
0.0278703887,
-0.0182883386,
0.0023038851,
-0.0277837645,
0.0084194122,
0.0132649848,
0.0097476756,
0.0510973521,
0.0194201842,
0.0461473353,
-0.0278227609,
-0.001816007,
-0.000260012,
0.0209615473,
0.0082094902,
0.045959644,
-0.0809936151,
0.0251844451,
-0.0018446579,
-0.0610059872,
0.0284701195,
-0.0019977619,
0.0700362325,
0.022124568,
0.0614295527,
-0.0264420044,
-0.0219185576,
0.0063867071,
0.0187778436,
-0.0419368222,
0.0130840642,
0.0037499338,
0.0797136799,
0.000043254,
-0.0030166667,
-0.0244572628,
0.0073239221,
-0.0529811308,
0.0306648128,
-0.0159340296,
-0.0272126533,
-0.0005011127,
0.0077984226,
-0.0224923193,
0.0450075008,
-0.001539803,
-0.0379137248,
0.0641073734,
0.0432588831,
-0.0212597679,
-0.0734679326,
-0.0546912141,
0.026926415,
0.0321097001,
0.006992328,
0.0533652939,
0.0117595755,
-0.06670136,
0.0135870036,
0.0461863354,
-0.0639567748,
0.0698695481,
0.000223003,
-0.0112696346,
-0.0062150895,
0.0404758304,
0.0869565159,
0.0081632258,
-0.0240595788,
0.0238942485,
0.0371713378,
0.0186679885,
-0.0143052833,
-0.0544602424,
0.0330175236,
-0.0227461942,
0.0168314241,
-0.0299045723,
-0.0561353862,
0.0031243102,
0.0275545325,
-0.0079217879,
-0.0010192166,
-0.0201666765,
0.0224691499,
-0.0189821813,
0.0359472595,
0.0375946388,
-0.0198030192,
0.0239063185,
-0.005352194,
-0.0004917604,
-0.0098450165,
-0.0264882427,
0.0415537804,
0.0408119559,
0.0329209194,
0.0273154806,
0.0160504561,
0.0042003044,
0.0480166301,
-0.0790265948,
0.0239953212,
-0.000525817,
0.0575021096,
-0.021467451,
0.0309926532,
0.0136473272,
-0.0110874455,
0.0067262235,
0.0315871015,
0.0087413127,
0.0149512086,
0.0077311159,
-0.002533101,
-0.0491673723,
-0.0384888723,
-0.0082017425,
0.0341951177,
-0.0156139517,
-0.0188810211,
0.0223081838,
0.0016935071,
0.0081175286,
-0.0446016341,
2.877e-7,
-0.0050640153,
0.0121134445,
0.0370415822,
-0.037606705,
0.0215539299,
0.0322568454,
-0.0082834987,
0.0015507048,
-0.0060806014,
0.0119714187,
-0.0059071104,
-0.0403432921,
0.1069424897,
0.0478188209,
-0.1076422632,
-0.0724249631,
-0.0521205403,
0.0216003135,
-0.0230880864,
0.0309522897,
0.0196053721,
0.09119986,
-0.0108730709,
-0.0413398296,
-0.0156606454,
0.0100056604,
0.0173101872,
-0.028948836,
-0.0084489677,
-0.0115503231,
0.0298405495,
-0.063335672,
0.0024940337,
-0.0443351157,
-0.0672055781,
0.0052862628,
0.0037336044,
0.0725687742,
0.0073384005,
-0.0519407839,
0.009134612,
-0.0102223381,
-0.0417633541,
-0.0239707716,
0.0050595347,
0.0613878705,
-0.0190078747,
-0.0186935477,
0.0072950721,
0.007250966,
0.0237814225,
-0.020372672,
0.0086105317,
-0.0253201704,
0.0068148747,
-0.0164795872,
-0.0196886901,
-0.0069633424,
0.028474899,
-0.0266201366,
-0.0378143452,
-0.0350041874,
0.0299609471,
-0.0229417011,
-0.0507246517,
0.0047681024,
0.0187083483,
2.033611426e-34,
0.0128056891,
0.0174247772,
0.0264191926,
0.0184730422,
0.0350097977,
-0.0159392878,
-0.0002459352,
0.0102358051,
0.0271983705,
0.0393821076,
-0.0342301652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12231v1 | Exploring the Integration of Speech Separation and Recognition with Self-Supervised Learning Representation | 2023-07-23T05:39:39 | 2023-07-23T05:39:39 | Yoshiki Masuyama, Xuankai Chang, Wangyou Zhang, Samuele Cornell, Zhong-Qiu Wang, Nobutaka Ono, Yanmin Qian, Shinji Watanabe | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Neural speech separation has made remarkable progress and its integration
with automatic speech recognition (ASR) is an important direction towards
realizing multi-speaker ASR. This work provides an insightful investigation of
speech separation in reverberant and noisy-reverberant scenarios as an ASR
front-end. In detail, we explore multi-channel separation methods, mask-based
beamforming and complex spectral mapping, as well as the best features to use
in the ASR back-end model. We employ the recent self-supervised learning
representation (SSLR) as a feature and improve the recognition performance from
the case with filterbank features. To further improve multi-speaker recognition
performance, we present a carefully designed training strategy for integrating
speech separation and recognition with SSLR. The proposed integration using
TF-GridNet-based complex spectral mapping and WavLM-based SSLR achieves a 2.5%
word error rate in reverberant WHAMR! test set, significantly outperforming an
existing mask-based MVDR beamforming and filterbank integration (28.9%). | [
-0.019397866,
-0.0153612057,
0.0398688875,
0.0487772748,
-0.0055055651,
-0.0156720132,
0.0666822717,
-0.0437396914,
0.0300475918,
0.0091602067,
-0.0799777284,
-0.0242700428,
-0.0155959064,
0.0035544871,
-0.0093647726,
-0.0344857872,
-0.001488517,
-0.0478789434,
-0.0045425082,
-0.0386743285,
0.0015481166,
0.0028458994,
-0.0557615049,
-0.0318320543,
-0.0267162789,
-0.0115607111,
0.0099939266,
0.0005842079,
0.015970435,
-0.0067624482,
-0.0242620707,
-0.0207847916,
0.0528782494,
0.0425413884,
0.0000017254,
-0.0128242504,
-0.0460317768,
0.0107769482,
-0.0474626943,
-0.017782744,
0.0090425275,
0.0804015249,
-0.0290366989,
0.0239118878,
-0.032721933,
-0.0331757069,
0.0175702479,
0.0327381976,
0.0254056863,
0.0220776275,
0.0114036435,
-0.0808148086,
-0.0063620023,
-0.0074164551,
-0.0065635052,
-0.0139826396,
-0.0353134535,
-0.0384528488,
-0.0321034566,
-0.0711426809,
0.0128716324,
0.0724448487,
0.0078739477,
0.0012082265,
0.0777242705,
0.0120359752,
-0.0243842192,
-0.0319744647,
-0.0342176594,
0.0764042959,
0.0269706789,
0.0117486073,
0.0424049646,
0.020425681,
-0.0631222874,
0.0168508105,
-0.0064336229,
0.0015772609,
-0.0048280694,
-0.0253876634,
-0.0722285137,
0.0493495502,
0.0330305919,
-0.0581244305,
-0.0486851484,
0.0631091744,
-0.0281414613,
-0.0243897699,
0.0156821143,
-0.0421615243,
0.0367445834,
0.0222968627,
0.0288853366,
-0.009808301,
-0.0089849839,
-0.0077309776,
-0.0257682186,
-0.0782380402,
-0.0606036782,
-0.0139346085,
-0.0201326646,
0.0078378785,
-0.0379914194,
-0.0049984036,
-0.0486799106,
0.0155042764,
-0.013303495,
0.0140753118,
-0.0231831148,
-0.0056977421,
-0.0165375881,
0.0263486821,
-0.0172388498,
0.0498224683,
-0.011245288,
-0.0264341515,
-0.0323801711,
-0.0168283284,
-0.0690036118,
-0.0007524677,
0.0366593525,
0.0102076139,
-0.047228314,
-0.0359939635,
0.0468640998,
0.0170138665,
0.0380871296,
0.0044866814,
-0.0023242724,
-0.0531582832,
-0.0155920209,
0.0243991446,
0.0522514395,
0.0221958943,
-0.0282181706,
0.0543890335,
-0.0185204223,
-0.0056716492,
-0.0051994734,
0.0166493766,
-0.0011487536,
-0.0118059516,
0.0658453256,
-0.0739149749,
0.0353206806,
0.0287492592,
-0.0071736681,
-0.0269503016,
0.0158246253,
-0.0630126521,
0.062819317,
0.0473383218,
-0.0342369452,
0.0012448138,
0.1050831005,
0.0019882799,
-0.0472940877,
-0.0189521071,
0.0220424384,
-0.0266825762,
0.0011143733,
-0.0497690886,
-0.014636782,
0.0323137976,
-0.0293586459,
-0.0753019154,
-0.0116347671,
-0.0114363367,
0.0280496757,
-0.0176656898,
0.0399881825,
-0.0324553177,
-0.0193947554,
-0.0123919882,
-0.0070912829,
0.0533744767,
0.0625751764,
0.0092099011,
0.0212112404,
0.0254490934,
-0.0000886712,
0.0325518847,
0.0325881653,
0.0134787438,
-0.0089961002,
-0.0260472354,
0.0266178139,
0.0575780161,
-0.0226251949,
-0.0086876079,
0.0500828736,
-0.0361277312,
0.0028434249,
0.0651275739,
0.0418829583,
-0.0105138067,
0.0123326425,
0.016123021,
0.022892097,
-0.0654957741,
-0.0038763336,
-0.0313726962,
-0.0140826879,
0.0210449677,
-0.0211524256,
-0.0506248884,
0.0136961211,
-0.0185163077,
0.0049110912,
0.0185509417,
0.0049983282,
0.0372907743,
0.0698850751,
-0.0303896591,
-0.0512208305,
0.0270152409,
-0.023673119,
0.0575270057,
-0.0348166488,
-0.0307080634,
0.0184891857,
0.064076148,
0.0093731638,
0.0050891871,
-0.0216365252,
-0.0431222841,
0.0133517701,
-0.0016772045,
0.082102254,
0.0307011977,
-0.0454496183,
0.0058301869,
0.008209954,
-0.0326453894,
-0.0152797531,
0.0299718715,
-0.0791100115,
-0.0248657111,
0.0398248099,
-0.0193101969,
-0.0005571311,
0.0762748793,
0.0184319187,
-0.0523545295,
0.0810080767,
0.0127062798,
0.0129536111,
-0.0335599296,
0.0117255375,
0.0465328544,
0.028601028,
0.0163114313,
-0.0096714031,
0.0422202311,
-0.0220424272,
-0.088127099,
-0.0008024463,
-0.0159412157,
-0.0403571799,
-0.0141970972,
0.0063250423,
-0.0148440013,
0.0296473689,
-0.0259135962,
-0.0067521855,
-0.0031331512,
0.0291765165,
-0.004595303,
0.0195213314,
-0.0516723804,
-0.004418761,
-0.0189936403,
-0.0062560462,
0.0294094533,
-0.0622543506,
-0.0156590454,
-0.0155033479,
-0.0154345427,
-0.0440998524,
-0.054061491,
0.0103051644,
-0.0324720666,
0.0005457873,
-0.0230600797,
0.0289129689,
-0.0135567086,
-0.0337648503,
-0.0755324513,
0.0116436044,
0.0095124459,
0.0413777232,
0.0608366951,
-0.0054068468,
0.0253571384,
-0.0023854969,
-0.0259938948,
0.0136315469,
0.0297836438,
0.0056626149,
0.0022731062,
0.0198693257,
-0.0167198535,
-0.0218242351,
0.0286032166,
0.0125468094,
0.058943972,
0.0444431826,
0.0694354177,
0.000717875,
-0.035156969,
0.0351672806,
0.0195842572,
0.0211047772,
-0.0378640257,
-0.009612198,
-0.0848660246,
-0.0444564819,
-0.0461046025,
-0.0405236706,
-0.0194401108,
-0.0060915621,
0.0034709561,
-0.0109118139,
-0.0487309024,
-0.0421346426,
-0.0303567946,
-0.0842855051,
0.0195657164,
-0.0531680621,
-0.0128725236,
0.0116061354,
-0.0793911591,
-0.0312013626,
0.0068354663,
-0.0439267419,
0.0221266057,
-0.0581044443,
0.0408775508,
-0.0001840867,
-0.0095353657,
-0.0165977608,
0.0093387943,
-0.0249512475,
-0.014353157,
0.0273794979,
-0.0118886083,
-0.0078854784,
-0.0228708163,
0.0002393904,
0.0457987674,
0.028366413,
0.0433326773,
-0.0170574971,
0.0255768467,
-0.0368242338,
0.100645639,
-0.0141926138,
0.0656636283,
0.0566835515,
0.0327831097,
0.0248366632,
-0.0205155127,
0.0862284154,
-0.0148321548,
-0.0527752265,
-0.0191283748,
0.0076715276,
-0.0307189152,
-0.0243838765,
0.0332596824,
0.0282749385,
-0.0333494842,
0.0219818242,
0.0790582448,
0.0148787126,
-0.0745355412,
-0.0483665802,
-0.0166919958,
-0.0412431248,
0.0059398394,
-0.0130076073,
0.0375985168,
0.027478246,
0.0336546861,
0.0143264653,
0.0229834411,
0.0179780107,
-0.0242614206,
-0.0584983602,
0.0402354449,
0.0360410064,
-0.0195603892,
-0.030720938,
-0.0081160422,
-0.0176317655,
0.0161118973,
0.0409607664,
0.0069240984,
-0.0329544879,
-0.058551304,
0.0604281276,
-0.0836617649,
-0.0088036796,
-0.0469654724,
-0.0560037643,
0.0811664015,
0.043824479,
0.0071236431,
-0.0102537526,
-0.0263367407,
-0.0113815209,
-0.0237515625,
0.015655607,
-0.0291674733,
0.0288629308,
0.0285865739,
-0.0070287935,
0.0338271819,
-0.006110576,
-0.0242531393,
-0.0001795214,
0.0230171271,
0.0200422592,
-0.0395081453,
0.0273086503,
0.0106543731,
0.0419646576,
0.0231435951,
0.0695393533,
0.0126238819,
0.0361520536,
-0.0166528784,
0.0335437693,
0.0915385038,
0.0324340276,
-0.0193877276,
-0.0057707694,
-0.0114976931,
-0.0608154535,
0.0223353542,
-0.0222133305,
-0.0025651127,
0.0192890894,
0.0017928756,
0.0249061547,
-0.0289988238,
0.0235533733,
-0.0208851304,
-0.0190075766,
-0.0100758318,
-0.0006690031,
0.0013915763,
-0.0049262899,
0.0299076177,
-0.0472191535,
-0.0061677201,
0.0200367346,
-0.0072067431,
-0.0051732999,
0.094515942,
-0.0512686782,
0.0155196553,
0.0408600979,
-0.006628166,
-0.0397237986,
0.0381256118,
0.0148100592,
-0.063108325,
0.0101508899,
0.082879141,
0.020061627,
-0.024426695,
0.0297283716,
-0.0131882727,
0.0537907332,
-0.0220008679,
-0.0144056017,
-0.0256166141,
0.0278751738,
-0.0123947393,
0.0135099804,
0.0814817697,
0.0282053184,
0.0310866889,
-0.0335351676,
0.0423701555,
-0.0636863858,
0.0447581746,
-0.0244378671,
-0.0135951135,
-0.0129736476,
0.0157560762,
-0.0178610384,
0.0534449629,
-0.0008237446,
0.0062742829,
-0.005214605,
0.0462775268,
0.053982012,
-0.0182568915,
-0.0372984968,
0.0345706493,
0.0071090874,
0.0402441397,
0.1138199195,
-0.0370391682,
-0.0055561019,
0.0107706496,
-0.0071689067,
-0.0139010875,
-0.0002413786,
0.033485353,
-0.0506271422,
-0.0348101482,
0.009606923,
0.0239547733,
-0.0250075515,
0.0112397131,
0.0497215874,
0.022545794,
0.0081832558,
-0.0066337064,
-0.0038378094,
-0.0179064069,
0.0613166057,
0.030821437,
-0.0164940506,
-0.0329669639,
-0.005044057,
0.0483881682,
-0.0266836882,
-0.00889205,
-0.0010395782,
0.0408841707,
-0.0646931008,
-0.0401068814,
0.0145666217,
-0.0255024508,
-0.0125840222,
-0.0378675349,
-0.0001640175,
-0.0275565609,
0.0395312421,
-0.0449045561,
-0.0066530625,
-0.0147793619,
0.0112554943,
0.0209604464,
-0.0040282682,
0.0009463681,
0.0375982486,
-0.0306036025,
0.0052986303,
-0.0234036446,
0.0316976048,
-5.842646632e-33,
-0.0663161576,
0.0191673655,
-0.0139621561,
0.0374503322,
0.0057976483,
-0.0239688493,
0.0318047479,
0.0265151206,
0.0088562686,
-0.0117419818,
-0.0312705673,
0.044496879,
0.0498113669,
0.0012582347,
-0.012576161,
0.0105431648,
0.1093425453,
-0.034456443,
0.0402085297,
-0.0003514104,
0.030136168,
0.064777106,
-0.0039769891,
-0.0871862248,
-0.0518336743,
-0.0098387664,
-0.0177879557,
-0.0230122078,
0.0165091529,
-0.0194256566,
-0.0190148707,
0.0448298156,
-0.0249769781,
-0.0365986675,
-0.0222799722,
0.0362897962,
-0.0959581584,
-0.0394168608,
-0.0770606697,
0.0254572351,
-0.0209602937,
-0.0333736129,
0.075060524,
0.0257712062,
-0.0675757974,
-0.0405415781,
0.0299946293,
0.0368648134,
-0.0238147806,
-0.0488048308,
0.0392082036,
0.0242785085,
-0.0011719757,
-0.0194730125,
0.100450106,
-0.0182943977,
-0.0461936258,
-0.0088240476,
-0.1394522041,
0.0101941796,
-0.0167018455,
0.0315830596,
0.0363941677,
0.0690490827,
0.0025732429,
0.0404891558,
0.1245422959,
-0.0754885003,
0.0516855158,
-0.0386579894,
0.037755765,
0.0366261825,
0.0114650829,
-0.0103809508,
0.0505550057,
-0.0063291597,
-0.0561008193,
-0.0101235583,
-0.0224072654,
0.0098488601,
0.0138625763,
0.0247003771,
-0.0056980914,
0.0260078982,
-0.0214920435,
-0.0485017188,
0.0001419696,
-0.0093551008,
0.029468324,
-0.0180121232,
0.0007457891,
-0.0207407903,
0.0484890714,
-0.0412099697,
0.0481808931,
0.009732523,
-0.0002820346,
-0.0236835424,
0.0052516493,
-0.0125738261,
-0.0019129994,
0.000986735,
0.0368995741,
0.0390508547,
-0.0019458522,
-0.0441682003,
-0.0020994609,
0.0914066061,
-0.0385429598,
-0.0299579035,
0.0062022293,
0.0239079483,
0.0270187277,
0.0740400776,
0.0425312631,
-0.0242123492,
-0.0085676694,
-0.0004000742,
-0.0045445366,
0.0294187386,
0.024627801,
0.0124201998,
0.0236707069,
0.008899794,
-0.0160055421,
0.0281939227,
-0.0130056962,
-0.0320256874,
0.0693628117,
-0.0203591846,
0.0027692702,
-0.0112328781,
2.598e-7,
-0.0595791005,
0.0146146482,
0.0379354283,
-0.0409789793,
0.0363498405,
-0.0036483498,
0.0153364139,
0.005469461,
-0.0148716662,
-0.0044257212,
0.0103559345,
0.0246123504,
0.0744168982,
0.0238018427,
-0.0363134146,
-0.0337893702,
-0.0701764524,
0.0131053841,
0.0338102654,
0.035852246,
0.0345492363,
0.026611995,
0.0114998743,
-0.0601820871,
0.0134527739,
0.0100850882,
0.0115389861,
0.0060067275,
0.0150941787,
-0.0131838061,
0.026556436,
-0.030264914,
-0.0138026671,
-0.0127024045,
-0.0044891187,
0.0382450558,
0.0409029461,
0.0079929838,
-0.0152685083,
-0.0684496835,
0.0065653129,
0.1014044061,
0.0031880392,
0.0577579439,
0.052672755,
-0.0131386099,
0.0035489353,
-0.0086412327,
-0.070601128,
0.0016628854,
0.0016557706,
0.0249332134,
0.0269528106,
0.0066798492,
-0.0171970706,
-0.0077573759,
-0.0384498313,
-0.0279520173,
-0.0259359144,
-0.0001625635,
-0.0834496543,
0.0194485411,
0.0070487792,
-0.0007292482,
0.0141500412,
-0.0147187831,
-0.0166142266,
1.774550953e-34,
-0.0099369073,
0.0181603413,
-0.0161081385,
-0.0057475711,
-0.0430967994,
-0.0243634488,
-0.0577771068,
0.0142412558,
-0.0131711317,
-0.0447001494,
-0.003631308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12221v1 | FATRER: Full-Attention Topic Regularizer for Accurate and Robust Conversational Emotion Recognition | 2023-07-23T04:01:24 | 2023-07-23T04:01:24 | Yuzhao Mao, Di Lu, Xiaojie Wang, Yang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper concentrates on the understanding of interlocutors' emotions
evoked in conversational utterances. Previous studies in this literature mainly
focus on more accurate emotional predictions, while ignoring model robustness
when the local context is corrupted by adversarial attacks. To maintain
robustness while ensuring accuracy, we propose an emotion recognizer augmented
by a full-attention topic regularizer, which enables an emotion-related global
view when modeling the local context in a conversation. A joint topic modeling
strategy is introduced to implement regularization from both representation and
loss perspectives. To avoid over-regularization, we drop the constraints on
prior distributions that exist in traditional topic modeling and perform
probabilistic approximations based entirely on attention alignment. Experiments
show that our models obtain more favorable results than state-of-the-art
models, and gain convincing robustness under three types of adversarial
attacks. | [
0.0013866237,
0.0718062371,
-0.0018210858,
0.047787074,
-0.0086137755,
-0.0148157971,
-0.0130874226,
-0.0143573545,
-0.0020326329,
-0.0213687681,
-0.04637089,
-0.0289662667,
-0.0044167074,
0.0152659854,
0.0357446633,
-0.0650305375,
-0.0004245637,
0.056415949,
0.0495733321,
0.0109472871,
0.0815324187,
0.0067721172,
0.0174809042,
0.0546978414,
-0.0316315033,
-0.0022122569,
-0.0504496992,
0.046045959,
0.0507948063,
0.0026400792,
0.0377600603,
0.0343922451,
0.0162293687,
0.0061262674,
0.0000020269,
0.0168692786,
-0.0180350002,
-0.0316764936,
0.0282757767,
-0.033354003,
0.030687632,
-0.0533043966,
0.0064533767,
0.0034618289,
-0.0254136585,
0.0234680213,
0.0588915274,
0.1230233014,
0.0662522912,
0.0893355012,
-0.030031044,
-0.000036372,
0.056175895,
-0.0197291635,
0.0166514628,
-0.0814741477,
-0.0101406397,
0.0042592394,
-0.0072041028,
-0.018050177,
-0.0527190752,
-0.001265096,
-0.0039046388,
0.0075476947,
0.0449110158,
-0.0017082756,
-0.0164953489,
-0.0255500283,
-0.0168393701,
0.0927835181,
-0.0412143394,
-0.002934322,
-0.0135574592,
0.0192663036,
-0.0073855855,
-0.0530931838,
-0.0438444577,
-0.0362015665,
-0.0113668432,
0.0131528741,
-0.022122113,
0.0233091023,
0.0209307391,
0.0005091023,
-0.0197087582,
0.0119245723,
-0.0130225364,
-0.0338157415,
-0.010219085,
-0.0057652052,
-0.0254540499,
-0.0251416583,
0.0287314411,
0.0147338407,
-0.0020022308,
-0.0061356458,
-0.0925250947,
-0.0354606584,
-0.0248928256,
-0.0365821235,
-0.0472612716,
0.0273650046,
-0.0555204861,
0.0586203076,
0.0583723858,
0.0284421109,
-0.0284067281,
0.0028673848,
-0.0093281334,
-0.0247823484,
-0.0128031569,
0.0301116183,
0.0040123272,
0.002609411,
-0.0172000118,
-0.0428495854,
-0.0403687842,
0.0148782311,
-0.0352852605,
0.0108142104,
-0.0346967764,
0.017535584,
-0.0351036228,
-0.0321076103,
0.0497454666,
0.0454333611,
-0.0193578396,
0.0160644241,
0.0246192683,
-0.040970996,
-0.0401879214,
0.0530496351,
0.0431928933,
-0.0213443786,
-0.0176671855,
0.0532575808,
-0.0101266261,
-0.0561146699,
-0.0162890125,
-0.0038111953,
-0.0527584814,
-0.0503914878,
-0.0202422291,
0.0088119218,
0.0351600014,
-0.0365847684,
-0.0129283415,
-0.0379841737,
0.0076224552,
-0.03382916,
-0.0169781521,
0.0713178962,
0.0110163689,
-0.041612532,
0.0330542959,
0.0289162137,
0.0243730713,
0.0502903275,
-0.0016909032,
0.0570568517,
0.0161521435,
-0.0025969639,
0.0082436567,
0.0247161016,
0.0288717039,
-0.013234281,
0.0074798628,
-0.0130400825,
0.0133533673,
0.0335594639,
0.0545633547,
0.0480686761,
-0.0330795012,
-0.0392653421,
0.0703450218,
0.0389016122,
-0.0398214459,
0.04437121,
-0.0456496924,
0.0458549075,
-0.0010722956,
0.0126098748,
-0.0475556962,
0.0348609649,
-0.0240141153,
-0.0188216697,
0.0619918443,
0.0032961066,
-0.0396467894,
-0.0220810175,
0.0023677433,
-0.0395123176,
-0.0057518329,
0.0121284053,
0.0397462249,
-0.0077816769,
-0.04162791,
0.0150642665,
0.0167225916,
-0.0345691554,
-0.0059394562,
-0.0073336936,
0.0182123836,
0.0210421346,
0.0220637694,
-0.0782549828,
-0.0238395557,
-0.0634642467,
0.0160837006,
0.0045645074,
0.0234362651,
0.0498076454,
0.0661769435,
-0.0542429797,
-0.0042310129,
-0.0250775684,
0.0052965777,
0.0310182609,
-0.017444443,
0.0128654791,
0.0060756616,
-0.0324632712,
0.068179585,
0.018433623,
0.0202652048,
-0.0378112048,
-0.0035479921,
0.0220307559,
0.0585013479,
0.020334309,
0.0135311056,
-0.0035804366,
0.0527844056,
-0.0121855242,
-0.0221918505,
0.0095799305,
-0.0318776481,
-0.0763212964,
0.0332138538,
-0.0240087099,
-0.0285587199,
0.0255182683,
-0.0440173186,
-0.0177481603,
0.0648483858,
-0.0363216959,
0.0279871225,
0.0278719477,
0.0223045871,
0.0035179358,
0.0612403378,
0.0005688192,
0.015685698,
-0.0295782611,
-0.0206907094,
0.0092121018,
-0.0361359343,
-0.0091527076,
-0.0844522342,
-0.0377903059,
0.001988837,
-0.0332813039,
0.0011406235,
0.0298757553,
-0.0303309839,
-0.0419026278,
-0.0236058291,
-0.0872645751,
0.0046749604,
-0.0287011471,
-0.0096791349,
0.0090561472,
0.048379641,
0.0043643536,
0.0003301601,
-0.0401091874,
-0.0028676144,
-0.0395223908,
-0.018005468,
-0.008791659,
-0.038355343,
0.0255604777,
-0.0951356813,
0.0207149442,
0.0059278612,
0.0413051099,
-0.0220526587,
-0.0157003757,
-0.0380605534,
-0.0042883172,
-0.0231295247,
0.0497890152,
-0.0534553602,
-0.0321501046,
0.0041234666,
-0.0046334649,
0.0290077869,
0.0957734585,
0.0291664116,
0.0834261701,
-0.0008018315,
0.0250626728,
-0.0524456389,
0.0381342657,
0.0019857746,
0.0055376589,
-0.039180629,
-0.0189392697,
-0.0037995661,
0.0689756647,
0.019577425,
0.0511277057,
-0.0382783338,
0.0001676543,
0.0383195952,
-0.0327794105,
-0.0283564795,
-0.0039814762,
-0.0202199519,
-0.0139278565,
-0.0463996939,
-0.0685802028,
0.0819890276,
0.0069243107,
-0.0091935862,
-0.0039749793,
-0.049900312,
-0.0007244771,
0.0496807285,
-0.0259400606,
0.0117299464,
-0.0360488556,
-0.0220250376,
-0.0439942926,
-0.0359683521,
-0.0262940452,
-0.0145335402,
0.0270897225,
0.0049616932,
-0.0371079817,
0.0285153016,
-0.0199442636,
-0.0386700295,
-0.0639309287,
-0.0217210799,
-0.0076041915,
0.0140676955,
-0.0003439902,
-0.0917636156,
-0.0139390072,
0.0292522311,
-0.0353676416,
-0.0099398214,
0.0097327223,
-0.0022884074,
0.0715449601,
0.0686083883,
-0.0258592535,
-0.0193127766,
-0.0114786001,
0.0500156954,
0.0791195631,
0.0450496711,
-0.0199504606,
-0.0219551064,
-0.0350048468,
0.0096267611,
0.0320904851,
-0.002577526,
-0.0293526072,
0.0629224107,
-0.0326903798,
0.0333848223,
0.092238836,
0.0078472188,
-0.0419815965,
0.0086924201,
-0.0291663203,
0.0195930656,
0.0025148694,
0.0034018478,
-0.051280994,
-0.0549984016,
0.0008417337,
0.0207103286,
0.035571713,
-0.0145694576,
-0.0109998276,
-0.0286204349,
-0.0182492137,
0.0206202678,
-0.0344012603,
-0.0700134262,
-0.0120361447,
0.0378115065,
-0.0259908475,
0.0196170472,
-0.0370173901,
0.0452480577,
-0.0130852908,
0.0111508761,
-0.0101403734,
-0.0198013689,
0.0014714354,
-0.0402929224,
0.0284886453,
0.010079043,
0.0799855441,
0.0199671201,
-0.000755754,
0.015326391,
0.0395377986,
-0.028054269,
0.0366059095,
0.0564642549,
-0.045126576,
-0.0010764897,
0.0176297445,
0.0383796953,
-0.0079007596,
-0.0120072439,
-0.0072717504,
0.0528060608,
-0.0490388311,
0.0010114579,
-0.0148743996,
0.0146972388,
0.0524029955,
0.0497497283,
0.0343588665,
-0.0362264179,
-0.0346083902,
-0.0350126699,
0.0403490178,
0.0195236225,
-0.0157213956,
-0.0124238934,
0.0334776752,
-0.0652607828,
-0.0328700356,
-0.0672778711,
-0.0052338708,
-0.0063290703,
-0.0498122163,
-0.060244821,
-0.0213692691,
-0.0400028527,
-0.0194485672,
0.0505134687,
0.0118946265,
0.0050760829,
-0.0103831636,
-0.0088889664,
0.0106113609,
-0.0349333808,
0.0047721686,
0.0492775775,
-0.0833553523,
-0.0628077611,
0.000619893,
0.0513779521,
0.0055182809,
0.0288315602,
-0.0082935793,
-0.0601825751,
-0.0052792956,
0.009532175,
-0.0259591993,
0.0245998912,
0.0534876883,
0.0042364332,
-0.0188368428,
0.0243948884,
-0.0490163304,
0.0307967477,
0.0223233886,
0.0069755088,
-0.0224548746,
-0.0820817128,
-0.0071184696,
-0.0289929844,
0.1045492813,
0.01340211,
-0.0304771364,
0.0047803563,
-0.0207629707,
0.009590623,
0.0094461767,
-0.0487749316,
-0.0340035781,
0.0151144341,
-0.0069074272,
-0.0215324759,
-0.0479025692,
-0.0237919725,
-0.0299745593,
-0.0199222136,
0.0302673168,
0.0048246919,
-0.0170523878,
0.0101452358,
0.0157570112,
-0.0119013954,
0.0290929228,
0.0258619767,
0.00898086,
-0.0022681986,
0.0364363231,
-0.0102541083,
-0.0152859949,
0.0278331693,
0.000483862,
-0.066992037,
-0.0165771525,
-0.031114541,
0.0355200283,
0.0318390653,
-0.0138673866,
0.0317943208,
0.0152234584,
0.0129217012,
-0.0211182367,
0.0473621748,
-0.0234443061,
-0.0569036379,
0.0195315853,
0.0022306093,
-0.0293355081,
0.0521460064,
0.0584631264,
-0.0129254675,
0.0373060293,
-0.002459598,
-0.011370318,
-0.0596983023,
0.0108994134,
0.0861817971,
0.0127066858,
0.0096776001,
0.0281814802,
-0.0138699804,
-0.0450983457,
0.0318607762,
-0.0649494976,
-0.0249896031,
-0.0094297789,
0.0296126381,
0.0340791829,
-0.0503954254,
0.0396135412,
0.0022903066,
0.0466055349,
-0.0421789289,
-0.041008994,
-0.0339818075,
-6.19634076e-33,
0.0090795616,
-0.0166496988,
-0.05928367,
-0.0215271693,
-0.0164372344,
0.0153167062,
-0.0526593402,
0.0073948409,
0.0088716252,
0.0165293142,
-0.0022679206,
0.0669761747,
-0.0134892743,
0.0222613271,
-0.0524892733,
-0.0596632101,
0.0462044738,
0.0047961692,
0.0021838001,
0.0129620442,
0.0430188514,
0.0440210551,
0.0646168366,
-0.1208284125,
0.0232382417,
0.0051274356,
-0.0303396042,
-0.0199113861,
0.1118426248,
0.0424700305,
-0.0021629231,
0.061295189,
0.0004190815,
-0.0132341385,
0.0018355201,
0.0374254137,
-0.009372524,
0.0098693985,
-0.0450078622,
-0.0084266514,
-0.0420065634,
-0.0544485748,
0.0354039669,
0.0210625809,
0.0339579135,
-0.0545011684,
0.0375973061,
0.0081269471,
-0.0135552399,
-0.0360507295,
-0.0223375056,
0.037468344,
-0.0628377721,
-0.0170903932,
-0.0131216496,
0.0399875939,
0.0433221459,
0.0066087386,
0.0026763109,
0.0032075585,
-0.026151685,
0.0106138047,
0.0408075415,
-0.0188940298,
-0.0071995314,
0.0616789274,
0.0243945289,
0.0202746186,
-0.0246352758,
-0.0265298542,
-0.0160460975,
0.0435476378,
0.0409409516,
0.0481245108,
-0.0239125509,
0.0176088903,
-0.040747717,
0.035515666,
0.0106213111,
0.0554689392,
-0.0032539722,
0.0633434728,
-0.0291872527,
0.0171653088,
0.0221754685,
-0.0267865509,
-0.0163289607,
-0.0122262286,
0.0257177018,
-0.0117617063,
0.026263522,
0.0272446498,
0.016470775,
-0.026938051,
0.0520683639,
0.0858677998,
-0.0008177372,
0.0053964863,
0.0015185922,
0.0386796966,
-0.0180126913,
0.0010763981,
0.0466246903,
-0.0108626178,
0.0275447089,
0.0218670834,
0.0197330657,
-0.0033062659,
-0.0512819737,
-0.0216718223,
-0.0433769524,
0.0203907695,
-0.0174008571,
0.05082912,
0.0160501301,
0.0112889614,
-0.0175644234,
0.0430777669,
0.0032609336,
0.0644576475,
-0.0090900585,
-0.0532970242,
-0.0087816725,
0.0097730448,
-0.0453670099,
-0.0112125035,
-0.0022171703,
-0.0388185121,
0.0135645587,
-0.0674381703,
-0.011017343,
-0.0371989645,
2.858e-7,
-0.0091512315,
0.0322741568,
0.0115362499,
-0.0552120209,
0.0106338318,
0.0573402084,
0.0091945464,
0.0761740133,
-0.0037539992,
-0.0362362228,
0.0343165547,
0.018540388,
0.0555397421,
-0.0013955481,
-0.0980700254,
-0.0082278699,
-0.0660889298,
0.0229340624,
0.0056079449,
0.011981437,
0.047971461,
0.1495733857,
0.0341913477,
0.0353847407,
0.036811009,
-0.0210245065,
0.0466930717,
-0.0338664651,
-0.0235932805,
0.0078989146,
0.0521248542,
-0.0252716374,
-0.0020803153,
-0.0410511009,
-0.0166012365,
0.0171003565,
0.0343236625,
0.078199029,
-0.0229246877,
-0.0640373006,
-0.0198131353,
0.0144892568,
-0.0226148926,
-0.0265038982,
0.0011643185,
-0.0465673134,
-0.0487400554,
-0.0204737689,
-0.0289733913,
0.0084820827,
0.0427625254,
-0.009380647,
-0.024873022,
0.0119675314,
0.0045844391,
-0.0248450991,
-0.0134645952,
-0.1026149988,
-0.0264271088,
0.0048191738,
-0.0458527356,
-0.0031690476,
-0.0260737259,
0.01631313,
0.0688678995,
-0.0101518892,
0.0163377095,
1.984496195e-34,
0.0162030328,
-0.0013613384,
-0.0255903583,
0.0195686743,
0.0386187173,
-0.0297378339,
-0.0189087018,
-0.0091887088,
0.0709495768,
-0.041812744,
-0.0084726047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12166v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12166v2 | The Imitation Game: Detecting Human and AI-Generated Texts in the Era of ChatGPT and BARD | 2023-07-22T21:00:14 | 2023-11-12T01:26:48 | Kadhim Hayawi, Sakib Shahriar, Sujith Samuel Mathew | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The potential of artificial intelligence (AI)-based large language models
(LLMs) holds considerable promise in revolutionizing education, research, and
practice. However, distinguishing between human-written and AI-generated text
has become a significant task. This paper presents a comparative study,
introducing a novel dataset of human-written and LLM-generated texts in
different genres: essays, stories, poetry, and Python code. We employ several
machine learning models to classify the texts. Results demonstrate the efficacy
of these models in discerning between human and AI-generated text, despite the
dataset's limited sample size. However, the task becomes more challenging when
classifying GPT-generated text, particularly in story writing. The results
indicate that the models exhibit superior performance in binary classification
tasks, such as distinguishing human-generated text from a specific LLM,
compared to the more complex multiclass tasks that involve discerning among
human-generated and multiple LLMs. Our findings provide insightful implications
for AI text detection while our dataset paves the way for future research in
this evolving area. | [
0.0617359914,
0.0459951386,
-0.0294508263,
0.0557490773,
-0.0742251277,
0.0166556127,
0.029464798,
0.0209497586,
0.0492417589,
-0.0729989037,
-0.004137035,
-0.0148169259,
0.0058266395,
0.0286890455,
0.0231128037,
0.0362509117,
-0.005912811,
-0.0127369845,
0.0374833643,
0.0332597345,
0.0037657111,
0.0484887734,
0.0261030644,
0.0740770027,
0.0047154045,
-0.044827953,
0.0105835013,
0.0070946054,
-0.0011587215,
-0.0114394575,
0.0256693624,
0.0576376468,
0.0023316678,
0.0848208815,
0.0000017341,
-0.0454977266,
0.0174904447,
-0.0443175472,
-0.0016936595,
-0.0006382492,
0.0550846681,
0.022469895,
-0.0163674373,
0.0158415046,
-0.0377978049,
-0.0101477709,
0.0208596718,
0.0459374711,
0.030387681,
0.0920455828,
-0.0284009334,
-0.0196281299,
0.0443008207,
0.0152440649,
0.0053078192,
-0.002380999,
0.0378115401,
-0.0028473905,
0.0173770748,
-0.0073082908,
0.015605445,
-0.0009933858,
-0.0073251398,
-0.0138144772,
-0.0180315375,
0.0170229599,
-0.0431225151,
-0.0013064807,
-0.0161965303,
0.0036805551,
-0.0361479595,
-0.0907378197,
0.0442759022,
-0.0080495011,
0.0018098361,
0.0056509585,
-0.0011858961,
0.0409413427,
-0.0540234782,
0.0287655517,
0.0345189087,
-0.0245954599,
0.0142066851,
0.0415600389,
0.0058544809,
0.0111997314,
-0.0036666952,
-0.0258432291,
-0.0108327717,
0.0248693135,
-0.0194784477,
-0.0689918846,
0.0317690857,
0.0186709799,
0.0031950043,
-0.0176281072,
-0.08698266,
-0.0452857204,
0.010536259,
-0.0365588665,
0.0582567118,
0.0067009674,
-0.0005067133,
0.0334337503,
-0.0255252551,
0.0639621913,
0.0142324241,
0.034555275,
-0.0021087204,
0.0339452103,
-0.053439822,
-0.0257967617,
-0.0440724604,
0.0162228961,
0.0357641354,
-0.0285267737,
-0.0225204621,
0.0034541993,
-0.0035023107,
0.0444608144,
-0.0182460137,
-0.0250958446,
-0.0035074935,
0.0006937551,
0.0309305228,
-0.0482794866,
0.0182328746,
0.0354135744,
-0.0289749503,
-0.0520825163,
0.0143793747,
0.0473308191,
0.022105569,
-0.0176839624,
0.0328128599,
0.0440510772,
-0.0156870205,
-0.0569819808,
-0.0443936549,
-0.0245035589,
0.0110509386,
-0.0412997156,
-0.0104109161,
-0.067709215,
-0.0102260569,
-0.0178160872,
0.0009948418,
-0.0510623083,
-0.0053643328,
0.0501120426,
-0.0102504957,
0.0414336547,
-0.0096851839,
0.0334570333,
0.054133784,
-0.0220436119,
-0.0263796654,
0.0056027435,
0.0719130933,
0.0381920673,
0.04883679,
-0.0152795706,
0.0599763319,
0.0454643592,
-0.0443167426,
-0.0246279296,
0.0116559137,
-0.0359664336,
-0.0021565026,
0.0491418652,
0.0147717791,
0.0657290667,
0.0181789417,
-0.0052508907,
0.0893501267,
0.1062770188,
0.0037522819,
0.0460103527,
0.0679150596,
0.0658167824,
0.0551019199,
0.0472159199,
-0.0038160093,
-0.0358202457,
0.001179586,
-0.004760934,
-0.0108302943,
0.012954806,
0.0278063025,
-0.0214032978,
-0.0385437533,
-0.0137429647,
-0.0026233012,
-0.032105878,
0.0336202905,
-0.0107922405,
-0.0492585935,
-0.0667740554,
-0.0208991431,
-0.05247657,
0.0024456356,
-0.0784069076,
0.0659275055,
0.0826570541,
0.0688213482,
-0.0380387269,
0.0643425584,
-0.0275821015,
-0.0004580017,
0.047894761,
0.0116788046,
-0.0040036323,
-0.0252387915,
-0.0198200177,
0.0248325225,
-0.0313477889,
0.0212194007,
0.0037681789,
0.0066099842,
0.0080551328,
-0.007688032,
0.0117218196,
-0.0978631824,
0.0823999718,
-0.047003489,
-0.0284198243,
0.0008372039,
0.0030003462,
-0.0005053857,
0.0019243897,
-0.0600291453,
0.0037150511,
-0.0081016142,
-0.0393874831,
-0.0338533521,
0.0095959054,
0.0045670029,
-0.0150438808,
0.0401830971,
-0.0439853556,
-0.0238490757,
0.0382076167,
0.000160406,
0.0007652913,
-0.0037397402,
-0.0433352478,
0.0235010553,
-0.0467037484,
0.0285833906,
-0.0397059843,
-0.0193331894,
-0.0314428806,
0.0252099056,
0.0222139265,
0.0150041757,
-0.0301339626,
-0.0212507732,
0.0548103638,
-0.0062817368,
-0.0132132256,
0.0317803659,
-0.0016287531,
0.0406383313,
0.010146047,
0.024712408,
-0.0042796577,
-0.0438991599,
-0.1030302793,
-0.0019119487,
-0.005119944,
0.0121310931,
0.0226890836,
-0.0610368885,
-0.0302772988,
0.0347059183,
-0.0179581139,
-0.0459081903,
0.0090223197,
-0.0147123979,
0.0324199907,
-0.0385245085,
0.01280024,
-0.0376109071,
0.0239505004,
-0.0338410586,
0.0585573763,
0.0425303988,
-0.0328555629,
-0.0541805252,
0.0403604656,
0.0315051936,
-0.0173171628,
0.0051983455,
-0.0504450798,
-0.0046453923,
-0.0395894833,
0.0315087475,
0.0948081985,
0.0118377088,
0.0134378597,
0.0556151345,
0.0371944718,
0.0207489152,
-0.0173700266,
0.0366461985,
-0.0026401428,
-0.0030184817,
-0.0628770515,
0.0401916467,
0.0432199538,
0.0188959688,
-0.0253829639,
-0.0099975588,
0.054162506,
-0.006560789,
0.002652928,
-0.0054292232,
-0.0598405041,
-0.0251741596,
0.0220041052,
-0.033076562,
-0.0431975089,
0.0541439205,
-0.0451934524,
0.0075272494,
-0.0398180075,
-0.0377046987,
-0.0401798934,
0.0457382463,
0.023574844,
0.0378256813,
-0.019361604,
-0.0074447324,
-0.0396055132,
0.0357216634,
0.0451903529,
-0.0247866418,
0.0376161896,
-0.0298290793,
0.0025782336,
0.017417457,
-0.0072670416,
-0.0247132126,
-0.0257459991,
-0.0256371628,
-0.0129829319,
0.0421761759,
-0.0362288021,
-0.000529359,
-0.0133570591,
-0.0169310533,
0.0840914398,
-0.0120536955,
-0.0161784757,
-0.0381981991,
0.0334329754,
0.0124995485,
-0.0329485722,
-0.0387481377,
-0.0298641175,
0.0200048853,
0.0153079974,
-0.0259191971,
0.0307958834,
-0.0232829899,
-0.0079983221,
0.0190282892,
-0.0379418842,
-0.027363129,
0.0222238991,
0.0073130513,
-0.0550860241,
-0.0126562677,
0.1038622931,
0.0411708876,
-0.0600257665,
-0.0058817822,
-0.0159002151,
-0.0004815557,
-0.0069411816,
0.019597955,
-0.044980865,
-0.0391987339,
0.0202007201,
0.0188268386,
-0.0297246892,
0.0019291291,
-0.0120570073,
-0.0918928385,
0.0215401705,
0.0104078343,
-0.0285011753,
-0.0243951902,
0.0012481411,
-0.0241455846,
-0.0006383784,
-0.047312595,
-0.039140366,
-0.0397045277,
0.0103162797,
-0.0126126027,
-0.0432839617,
-0.022384014,
-0.0176662095,
-0.045520477,
0.0271669459,
0.0698192343,
0.0827194527,
-0.0383105017,
0.0135302357,
0.0208032634,
-0.0136170927,
-0.0094902338,
0.0142985824,
0.0538335517,
-0.0188009646,
0.0242373869,
0.0048857988,
0.0463493876,
-0.0330571234,
-0.0227005351,
0.0604228117,
0.0355529413,
-0.0145686474,
-0.059561085,
-0.0114383437,
0.004632324,
0.0143393176,
0.0707960054,
0.0429108851,
-0.0601912886,
-0.0896383971,
-0.0432475284,
0.0211235452,
-0.0539479442,
-0.0524884015,
0.0046444498,
-0.0102680717,
-0.0212478768,
-0.0785830393,
-0.0357754007,
-0.02344108,
-0.0105037102,
0.0522929654,
0.02283285,
0.016971251,
-0.0047629452,
-0.0644487068,
-0.0141114546,
-0.003471998,
0.0153366886,
-0.0527742505,
-0.0338710025,
-0.0119281514,
-0.056847591,
-0.0059108525,
0.0087028071,
-0.0842384398,
-0.0419583954,
0.0205416661,
-0.0192738418,
0.0206127707,
-0.0050102426,
0.0042565502,
-0.0526466258,
0.0297949929,
0.0338098295,
-0.0119027309,
0.0315944925,
-0.0032304123,
0.0132222408,
-0.0347223058,
0.0086931335,
0.0008216794,
0.0165507775,
0.0148729449,
-0.0343144387,
-0.0075893449,
-0.0054071071,
0.0227591041,
0.0243586432,
0.0061010011,
-0.0235922337,
-0.0087612625,
-0.0675702095,
-0.0441595726,
-0.0035227917,
-0.0098996647,
-0.038013272,
-0.0213119648,
0.0379726849,
0.0174208488,
-0.0326502398,
0.0042030634,
-0.0165511705,
0.0135988072,
-0.0361734666,
0.0261356831,
0.0082349852,
0.0797110423,
-0.016304858,
-0.0127290534,
-0.0200884659,
0.054437764,
-0.021003291,
0.0375542976,
0.0276152715,
0.0347888209,
0.0130204633,
-0.0158213731,
0.0235242117,
0.0474621132,
-0.0724684075,
-0.0324208885,
-0.0211428814,
0.0190030318,
0.0737759024,
-0.0218556281,
0.0632036328,
-0.0390783846,
-0.0055035525,
-0.0262499359,
0.074668996,
0.0216472037,
-0.004071014,
-0.0687490329,
0.0007259872,
-0.0324936323,
0.0004575362,
0.084945187,
0.033493232,
0.0304068159,
0.008168255,
-0.05917117,
-0.0171532687,
-0.021223804,
0.0462819412,
-0.0026755775,
0.035319116,
0.0197348185,
-0.0426659212,
-0.0332959481,
0.0061526592,
0.0174124502,
0.0437774062,
-0.0451184809,
-0.0135621056,
0.0667894036,
-0.0129929427,
0.0118168518,
-0.0630752519,
0.0028000874,
-0.0184940211,
-0.0314336158,
-0.054384172,
-4.764547131e-33,
-0.0175329465,
-0.0857656375,
-0.012326844,
0.0316603072,
-0.0120271277,
0.0074549932,
-0.0329566561,
-0.0275827143,
0.0184635185,
0.025212761,
-0.0066194003,
0.0176143367,
-0.0103337178,
-0.0045205154,
0.0194471125,
0.0084720617,
0.0325050391,
-0.0211762395,
-0.0513192154,
0.0077368123,
0.0322272331,
0.0037707835,
-0.0006993323,
-0.0554813072,
0.006407931,
-0.0683146194,
-0.009853703,
-0.0311438106,
-0.0438420065,
0.0472598709,
-0.0365144387,
0.0412039086,
0.0401665829,
0.0496534631,
0.0050529875,
0.0481042191,
0.0071491771,
-0.0032504441,
-0.0333148502,
0.0033752252,
0.0343151204,
-0.0685229823,
0.0457468927,
-0.0236124806,
-0.0313412994,
0.0047119581,
0.0929196849,
-0.0187128223,
0.0227010753,
-0.0547968931,
-0.094971016,
0.0222382788,
-0.0177699849,
-0.0108824549,
0.0225784089,
0.0444708727,
-0.0188585408,
0.0319975168,
-0.0557545014,
0.023945028,
-0.0069810338,
0.0176370144,
-0.0215540268,
0.0098280562,
-0.0129442792,
0.067725502,
0.032958474,
0.0169839282,
-0.0306629874,
0.0089984108,
0.0299675539,
-0.0052313362,
0.0603270456,
0.0649832785,
0.0342012011,
-0.0220638122,
0.0009972227,
0.0313189179,
0.0401287079,
-0.0321850739,
0.033910498,
-0.0265637916,
-0.0546011887,
-0.0343443826,
-0.0055172043,
-0.0702347606,
-0.0054902621,
-0.0045976294,
0.0286996365,
-0.0262515321,
0.0155009395,
-0.0196186788,
0.0061812107,
-0.0602071732,
-0.0010666555,
-0.0031562648,
-0.0717426017,
0.0671121404,
-0.0004117536,
0.021807434,
-0.0268808901,
-0.0430526324,
0.0352154598,
0.0053985729,
0.0711702332,
0.0117850788,
0.0468288511,
0.0269349422,
-0.0461203121,
0.0170727894,
-0.0205300078,
-0.019768212,
0.0131625682,
0.0265407935,
0.012146526,
-0.0220166054,
0.0382276811,
0.019869918,
0.020934891,
-0.0141907576,
-0.0493788384,
-0.03962446,
-0.0447985008,
-0.0098651508,
-0.0233323928,
0.0096787699,
-0.0298122633,
-0.0005583462,
0.0044293511,
-0.0612223595,
0.0089642759,
-0.0423507951,
2.389e-7,
0.0192440636,
0.0445474684,
0.0245508365,
0.0130945472,
0.0162122045,
0.0606599413,
-0.021361744,
0.0300971903,
-0.0190576334,
0.0281787924,
0.021105092,
0.0203825515,
0.0819949657,
0.0023284284,
-0.071907796,
0.0173230302,
-0.081216909,
0.0139927045,
-0.100266695,
0.0035726279,
0.0840574726,
0.0232570581,
0.031565588,
-0.0371521451,
0.0103762392,
-0.0816892758,
0.0321935788,
-0.0274504405,
0.0161547437,
0.0310900714,
0.0327018686,
0.0095118061,
-0.0035542534,
0.0251038615,
-0.0161914509,
0.00628073,
0.0442747921,
0.0469755679,
-0.0014039899,
0.0644845143,
0.0249603838,
0.008187986,
-0.0037271483,
-0.0602385551,
0.0560737178,
0.0119181927,
-0.0120642241,
-0.0262108352,
0.0161175132,
-0.0579552986,
-0.0133006694,
-0.011178975,
-0.0020066532,
0.0271454118,
0.0224392712,
-0.0162184536,
0.0307578724,
-0.0463320874,
-0.0053664991,
0.0009760326,
-0.033484567,
0.0131562008,
-0.0394532606,
0.021077143,
0.0322860405,
-0.0841107294,
0.0301418379,
2.479233758e-34,
0.0308690593,
-0.043434266,
0.003894863,
0.0229703765,
0.0598373264,
0.0431548171,
0.0277277697,
0.0187548958,
-0.0199718457,
-0.0263557509,
0.0252968036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12155v1 | Identifying Misinformation on YouTube through Transcript Contextual Analysis with Transformer Models | 2023-07-22T19:59:16 | 2023-07-22T19:59:16 | Christos Christodoulou, Nikos Salamanos, Pantelitsa Leonidou, Michail Papadakis, Michael Sirivianos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Misinformation on YouTube is a significant concern, necessitating robust
detection strategies. In this paper, we introduce a novel methodology for video
classification, focusing on the veracity of the content. We convert the
conventional video classification task into a text classification task by
leveraging the textual content derived from the video transcripts. We employ
advanced machine learning techniques like transfer learning to solve the
classification challenge. Our approach incorporates two forms of transfer
learning: (a) fine-tuning base transformer models such as BERT, RoBERTa, and
ELECTRA, and (b) few-shot learning using sentence-transformers MPNet and
RoBERTa-large. We apply the trained models to three datasets: (a) YouTube
Vaccine-misinformation related videos, (b) YouTube Pseudoscience videos, and
(c) Fake-News dataset (a collection of articles). Including the Fake-News
dataset extended the evaluation of our approach beyond YouTube videos. Using
these datasets, we evaluated the models distinguishing valid information from
misinformation. The fine-tuned models yielded Matthews Correlation
Coefficient>0.81, accuracy>0.90, and F1 score>0.90 in two of three datasets.
Interestingly, the few-shot models outperformed the fine-tuned ones by 20% in
both Accuracy and F1 score for the YouTube Pseudoscience dataset, highlighting
the potential utility of this approach -- especially in the context of limited
training data. | [
0.0475734212,
0.057149224,
-0.0252093188,
0.0334826,
-0.015086459,
0.0041272421,
0.0415140316,
-0.0058908015,
-0.0390265733,
-0.0857415572,
-0.0247905497,
-0.0117836772,
0.0057218662,
0.0042518238,
-0.0180670954,
-0.0530478358,
0.0404522531,
0.0336918272,
0.0327753946,
0.024961682,
0.0187924542,
0.0269565433,
-0.0262556039,
0.0282523762,
-0.0060335677,
-0.0077645388,
0.0676840544,
0.0089772735,
0.0913880542,
-0.029801853,
0.0298976675,
0.0354714729,
0.029364014,
0.0497875437,
0.0000016269,
-0.0278737172,
-0.000568175,
0.0165593456,
-0.0154264318,
0.0058540846,
0.0389667489,
-0.0517830811,
0.0141678611,
0.0860949382,
-0.0414840728,
-0.002719475,
0.0658383518,
0.0502957143,
0.0705525801,
0.0928445607,
-0.0448109247,
-0.0476415157,
0.0560979992,
0.0137960082,
0.0380520038,
-0.0173204467,
0.0731025487,
0.0172611028,
-0.0217221826,
0.0437465198,
-0.0155196534,
0.0218145959,
-0.0075777713,
-0.0476081707,
-0.0048850495,
-0.0128214937,
-0.034846276,
-0.0618462041,
0.0131155113,
0.0461535603,
-0.0136120403,
-0.0417693183,
0.0269721225,
0.0080535924,
0.0046309885,
0.0546377972,
-0.0381797105,
0.0209567305,
0.0062653599,
0.0358812176,
-0.0190695357,
0.0046728933,
0.0451821424,
0.0087906206,
0.0318319537,
-0.0152692664,
0.0147919515,
0.0026122944,
-0.0209550578,
-0.0051636165,
0.026122652,
-0.019749796,
0.0227184501,
-0.0073927674,
0.0232338812,
0.0048845899,
-0.0558678582,
-0.044858817,
0.002649691,
-0.0838220567,
0.0187341049,
0.0158910193,
-0.0135933878,
0.0037419151,
-0.0279409792,
0.0157746878,
-0.0083549246,
0.0507263765,
0.0095805479,
0.0033017287,
-0.0647719502,
0.0360322557,
-0.0169816408,
0.0164477583,
0.0176170599,
0.0260262433,
-0.0878600106,
0.0058864295,
-0.0244907625,
-0.0124864345,
-0.032789506,
-0.0212945081,
-0.0074653849,
0.0043122051,
0.0100509571,
0.0494009331,
0.0289220102,
0.0738643631,
0.0036070838,
-0.084581852,
-0.0154485293,
0.0430250205,
-0.0038457667,
-0.0355713889,
0.010928968,
0.005939262,
0.0065010753,
-0.032902509,
-0.010308167,
0.0047143674,
-0.0705120191,
-0.0110512963,
0.0090579484,
-0.0628899112,
0.0006375912,
-0.0134516079,
-0.0059003872,
-0.0058130831,
-0.0175606105,
0.0233614985,
-0.0477685072,
0.0580960251,
0.0508971363,
-0.0004459245,
0.0634255111,
0.0320415646,
-0.0349621475,
0.0356272571,
0.0335598253,
0.0579212978,
0.0390542448,
-0.0104644205,
0.0592992306,
0.0190248843,
0.0519181713,
0.0158657841,
-0.0180843771,
-0.008212666,
-0.0253243614,
-0.0110809179,
-0.0370012037,
0.0356932729,
-0.0029841603,
-0.0191382002,
0.0726489648,
-0.0139614735,
-0.0365486816,
-0.0128932213,
0.0499765053,
0.0532274991,
-0.0052796938,
-0.0272730812,
-0.0329858661,
0.030357765,
-0.027262589,
-0.0261854995,
-0.0133614391,
0.0355770104,
-0.0206346046,
-0.0023529602,
-0.0215363521,
-0.0051577897,
-0.0086183921,
-0.0095858742,
0.0422817096,
0.0284984279,
-0.0464452505,
0.059441328,
0.0271114092,
0.0241248757,
0.0148516437,
-0.0596140362,
0.0021852376,
0.0027194594,
0.0014339346,
-0.0041773794,
-0.0261795186,
-0.0712325051,
0.0007790536,
0.001873141,
0.0332205221,
-0.0180262625,
-0.0209212136,
-0.0014139994,
-0.0208705217,
-0.0297682527,
0.0272920914,
0.010842639,
0.00590197,
0.0450467952,
0.0258722324,
-0.0160862226,
-0.0180587936,
0.0291078836,
0.0166773684,
0.0013581746,
0.0028573351,
0.0194885712,
0.0643079802,
-0.0168648493,
-0.0166762155,
-0.0347312465,
0.0418783128,
-0.0208094064,
-0.023185581,
-0.021638928,
0.0100003919,
-0.0494140014,
0.0114648603,
-0.0746503621,
0.0026556589,
0.0835309625,
-0.0438674316,
0.0320171565,
0.03417252,
-0.0249917097,
0.0184359197,
-0.0453820676,
0.0040846728,
-0.0377596207,
0.0496863648,
0.0103627061,
0.0243016575,
0.0089187417,
-0.0163878724,
0.0189163629,
-0.0464555658,
-0.0086789932,
-0.0081140026,
-0.0009598605,
-0.0254908539,
-0.0674561635,
0.0175275076,
0.0297319405,
-0.0514617227,
0.0050622826,
-0.0107545862,
-0.0507712178,
-0.0146939168,
-0.0195208024,
0.0309140943,
0.026596887,
-0.0155430678,
0.0051030056,
0.0120470664,
-0.0056354399,
-0.0137291793,
-0.0122697456,
0.0144455796,
0.0213841982,
-0.0107160434,
-0.0280823149,
0.005559077,
-0.00825141,
-0.0249649491,
0.0500301346,
0.0040852544,
-0.0601621456,
-0.0046219304,
-0.010011916,
0.0041521005,
0.0020836527,
-0.0392510891,
-0.029267814,
-0.0118934168,
0.0385261029,
-0.0221329108,
-0.0022463086,
0.0749724507,
0.0604816303,
-0.002539725,
0.0460727289,
-0.0011162283,
-0.0219839066,
-0.0137988655,
-0.0250752401,
-0.0548841022,
-0.0577082075,
0.0270962287,
0.013343011,
0.0379468575,
-0.0051575555,
-0.0382294133,
0.0173042994,
-0.0061748638,
-0.0296497103,
0.0175097678,
-0.0330181569,
-0.0043474585,
0.0019082758,
-0.0169975944,
-0.0204914305,
0.0565643981,
-0.0389852002,
0.0377544314,
-0.0156107638,
-0.0285016689,
0.0089941192,
-0.0133409454,
0.0046107541,
0.0400920548,
0.0131908506,
-0.0155450786,
-0.0187452137,
-0.0437395871,
0.0558315814,
-0.017213475,
-0.0068892874,
-0.0090427296,
0.0220902227,
0.0023967056,
-0.035776753,
-0.0887277946,
-0.080774799,
-0.0031246005,
-0.0252930522,
-0.0175652355,
-0.0343023986,
-0.1078520715,
-0.0231335182,
0.0112346876,
0.0199984182,
-0.0089243632,
0.0021964181,
0.044334963,
0.0656498224,
0.0452641882,
-0.0370883532,
0.0346725918,
-0.0301692709,
0.0054696715,
0.0518653505,
-0.0201281011,
0.0344387516,
-0.0146480547,
-0.0479437821,
-0.0123315509,
-0.0252076536,
0.0104502225,
0.0312462188,
0.0371028185,
-0.0235630032,
-0.019632265,
0.0865718722,
-0.0213004015,
-0.0049871742,
-0.0217963643,
0.0365509987,
-0.0539955758,
0.009037287,
0.0177362598,
-0.0795544758,
-0.0245505795,
-0.0204261877,
0.0077244006,
-0.0377404876,
-0.001326007,
-0.0274780281,
-0.0787123889,
0.0453317799,
-0.0079196272,
-0.0151667548,
-0.0318195261,
-0.0496015772,
-0.0057941722,
0.000940247,
0.0177313425,
-0.0366223268,
-0.0084422529,
-0.0246698167,
0.0101699922,
-0.0118636135,
-0.0897883922,
0.0167385265,
0.0035630511,
0.0445004776,
0.0298110116,
0.0389210284,
-0.0641592592,
-0.0620212667,
0.0076354486,
-0.0249378234,
-0.0267198272,
0.0217392966,
0.0965881795,
-0.0433984473,
-0.0081097204,
0.0120385913,
0.0309291743,
0.0071163345,
-0.0535101555,
-0.0227577109,
0.0885780826,
0.0059921592,
-0.0617141016,
-0.0576772578,
0.0167597234,
0.0326214805,
0.0828427076,
-0.0068112742,
-0.0325522386,
0.0212148521,
-0.0085192192,
-0.0288863443,
-0.0024866241,
-0.0151347062,
0.0198044628,
0.0189494491,
-0.0320518501,
-0.064298749,
0.0486559421,
-0.0051966775,
-0.0119222291,
-0.0114286905,
-0.025829453,
0.0459926203,
0.0197371226,
-0.0538279451,
0.013222618,
0.0068372595,
0.0312687717,
-0.0416754968,
0.016439423,
0.0344564058,
-0.0694632977,
-0.017698992,
-0.0037712716,
-0.0637420118,
-0.0370119847,
-0.0122101419,
0.0523385257,
0.0126703354,
0.0398586877,
-0.0175215639,
0.0280248523,
0.0939941108,
0.0935760364,
-0.0129129263,
-0.0310275368,
0.0402418301,
-0.0401294865,
0.0090753287,
0.0080136126,
-0.0136795677,
0.0403332636,
-0.0018434357,
-0.0491729081,
-0.0788239539,
-0.0060168067,
0.016240783,
-0.0320133269,
0.0761311352,
-0.0059068305,
0.0012208326,
-0.0378748812,
-0.0160853453,
-0.014772539,
-0.0016081606,
-0.0039254562,
0.0080593927,
0.0493199639,
0.0037416436,
-0.0262050312,
0.0193829611,
-0.0566065274,
-0.021057155,
-0.0414277464,
0.0098676933,
-0.0019900892,
0.0122277597,
0.0225114152,
0.0220309608,
-0.006448112,
-0.000680265,
0.0501057766,
0.0175293088,
-0.0001159236,
0.0154308509,
-0.0013968011,
0.0080118692,
0.0425321646,
-0.0168368686,
-0.0546259619,
0.0257021058,
-0.0626551881,
0.013123231,
-0.0105887875,
-0.010556696,
0.0237985924,
-0.0073311701,
-0.0218048841,
-0.0173825882,
0.0381181128,
-0.0081350431,
-0.0312610194,
0.0078909947,
-0.0018795425,
-0.0280554313,
0.0216008034,
0.0413937569,
-0.0058578728,
0.0412412658,
0.0203230679,
-0.0658749565,
-0.0310619641,
-0.0002260606,
0.0124501456,
0.0153475581,
-0.0097999107,
-0.012661593,
-0.0435256548,
-0.0455795303,
0.020929778,
-0.0717500895,
0.0403998457,
0.0271897111,
-0.013131273,
0.0546632372,
0.0100380871,
-0.0074028126,
-0.0315198079,
-0.0161751118,
-0.0060338513,
-0.0274936836,
0.0042574429,
-5.7478724e-33,
0.0405182689,
-0.0195405073,
-0.0540368147,
0.0180696901,
0.0105997408,
0.0380176455,
-0.0073373215,
-0.0317414738,
-0.0527434237,
0.054101266,
0.0320429467,
0.0414516591,
-0.0109292194,
0.0626733676,
-0.0280067734,
-0.022948619,
0.078022249,
0.014919511,
-0.0236635711,
0.0123720299,
0.0559880733,
0.0275593419,
0.0577998981,
-0.0983115733,
-0.0098481905,
-0.0020900376,
-0.047111351,
0.0102319149,
0.0066338223,
0.0719734952,
0.0012049815,
0.0346036293,
0.0175407454,
-0.0628413558,
0.0160033572,
0.0424182154,
-0.0514362939,
0.0181332584,
-0.0080779549,
0.0120678972,
0.0057101515,
-0.0114051849,
0.0500530601,
-0.0158681516,
-0.0265416689,
-0.0449042432,
0.0403622091,
-0.0303077977,
0.0319050737,
-0.0737375841,
-0.0699643344,
-0.0149090933,
-0.0082738185,
-0.02954432,
-0.0027753229,
0.0618216097,
0.0209314022,
0.0451839007,
-0.0730491355,
-0.0012415153,
-0.0334608592,
-0.008095663,
0.0440482609,
-0.0177850202,
-0.0326810814,
0.0602762103,
-0.0013525584,
-0.0294378996,
-0.0285515338,
-0.0422079861,
-0.0095967604,
0.0558029637,
0.0421613716,
0.096836105,
0.0413055904,
-0.0589228608,
-0.110979639,
0.0177549981,
-0.0018150568,
0.0221565459,
0.0418516435,
-0.0393239036,
-0.0090474058,
0.0182855651,
-0.0133906156,
-0.0347531512,
-0.0182449073,
0.0096001374,
-0.0123625938,
0.0109602585,
-0.0329383463,
0.0298974514,
0.0365839526,
-0.0976156816,
-0.0006284377,
0.0400566682,
-0.0422164872,
-0.0031670476,
0.0052874507,
0.025731476,
-0.0546530373,
-0.0068578711,
0.0777486488,
0.0275816508,
0.0239796638,
-0.0132861286,
0.0790069774,
0.0387762301,
-0.0463561229,
-0.0084397281,
-0.0003678555,
0.053088434,
-0.0047607799,
0.0661207587,
0.0017916609,
0.0430177338,
-0.0292265881,
0.0069678864,
-0.003919729,
0.0387389511,
0.0366997346,
0.0044346177,
-0.0203958824,
0.0178444907,
-0.0329948664,
-0.0244605616,
-0.0251653139,
0.0324999802,
0.0164407715,
-0.1096824706,
-0.0030824889,
0.006175478,
2.678e-7,
0.0229689516,
0.0734389126,
-0.0160375275,
-0.0706536695,
0.0324244834,
0.0749204457,
0.0438035019,
0.0514561161,
0.0284059308,
-0.0528964475,
-0.003109117,
0.0302602183,
0.0182964429,
0.0240860935,
-0.0352762416,
-0.0540671013,
-0.0814242586,
-0.0063851592,
-0.0093387812,
0.0159649979,
0.0614543967,
0.1007216647,
0.0469506197,
-0.0541178063,
0.0084533216,
-0.0167565085,
0.0584801696,
0.0349538326,
-0.0183585454,
0.0107761398,
0.0047317678,
-0.008352343,
0.0244103782,
0.0105154822,
-0.0500439741,
-0.0123640308,
-0.0180855636,
0.0334273428,
0.0105153788,
-0.0116697364,
-0.0478944331,
0.0231109243,
0.0376413427,
-0.0424509235,
0.0481481887,
-0.0609675832,
-0.0410834551,
-0.0535190292,
-0.0606343299,
0.0153256496,
0.0181434788,
0.0037144446,
0.017679831,
0.0210323706,
0.0162794124,
0.0451276787,
-0.0514080487,
-0.0647127703,
0.0107695656,
0.0087480508,
-0.0460096374,
-0.0116607137,
0.0151748117,
-0.027200358,
0.0654274821,
-0.0169636402,
0.0432558283,
2.090901623e-34,
0.013286911,
-0.0154810511,
-0.0255054105,
-0.0586448833,
-0.0174749605,
0.0520687699,
-0.015072695,
-0.0064488556,
-0.0009096021,
-0.0206951685,
0.0058106072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12134v1 | Modality Confidence Aware Training for Robust End-to-End Spoken Language Understanding | 2023-07-22T17:47:31 | 2023-07-22T17:47:31 | Suyoun Kim, Akshat Shrivastava, Duc Le, Ju Lin, Ozlem Kalinli, Michael L. Seltzer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | End-to-end (E2E) spoken language understanding (SLU) systems that generate a
semantic parse from speech have become more promising recently. This approach
uses a single model that utilizes audio and text representations from
pre-trained speech recognition models (ASR), and outperforms traditional
pipeline SLU systems in on-device streaming scenarios. However, E2E SLU systems
still show weakness when text representation quality is low due to ASR
transcription errors. To overcome this issue, we propose a novel E2E SLU system
that enhances robustness to ASR errors by fusing audio and text representations
based on the estimated modality confidence of ASR hypotheses. We introduce two
novel techniques: 1) an effective method to encode the quality of ASR
hypotheses and 2) an effective approach to integrate them into E2E SLU models.
We show accuracy improvements on STOP dataset and share the analysis to
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach. | [
-0.0147110494,
0.0438497365,
0.0165125933,
0.0168954786,
0.0240274984,
-0.0012340274,
0.0145029621,
-0.0566128232,
-0.0472695604,
-0.0583109781,
-0.0263820998,
-0.0327419676,
0.0140107069,
0.0510693043,
-0.0185902622,
-0.0339906067,
0.0485056825,
-0.0524117164,
0.0003324132,
-0.005752895,
0.0312193297,
0.035122592,
-0.0290620811,
0.0198138654,
0.0031119676,
0.0078751203,
-0.0081906812,
0.0276066139,
-0.0052572577,
-0.0485491231,
-0.0163663272,
-0.0014193961,
0.0846545398,
0.0227432996,
0.000002151,
-0.0281751622,
-0.0661733001,
-0.0058066598,
-0.084884122,
-0.0343205407,
0.0335973538,
-0.0242793541,
-0.0007470743,
0.0366550945,
0.0181236584,
-0.0014151366,
0.0387294441,
0.0302706119,
0.0219998416,
0.04084846,
0.0025373583,
0.0031467783,
0.004909541,
-0.0111301439,
-0.0252795331,
-0.0512351543,
-0.0242049806,
-0.0092653921,
-0.0156643,
-0.0244695004,
-0.0247334279,
0.0446403921,
0.0024761511,
-0.0147797512,
-0.0185484849,
-0.000158699,
-0.0116453897,
-0.0442938879,
-0.0438719727,
0.0767060667,
0.0139469849,
-0.0221061576,
0.0071598305,
-0.0062088273,
-0.0310412403,
-0.0229997505,
-0.0220930669,
0.0347322337,
-0.013238892,
0.0227078311,
-0.0307575632,
0.0464336649,
0.0413191468,
-0.0221570991,
-0.0270448346,
0.0257802494,
0.0014822774,
0.009491466,
-0.0180274732,
-0.0419159457,
-0.0216879044,
-0.009689264,
0.049484361,
0.0012432587,
-0.0642709658,
0.0170279257,
-0.0368470326,
-0.007170354,
-0.0396751128,
0.0035323813,
-0.005001958,
0.0849412158,
-0.0519681983,
0.0076305666,
-0.0018574282,
0.0297287498,
0.0148261711,
-0.0006026269,
-0.0054151644,
-0.0220758915,
-0.0415987,
0.0119135361,
-0.036160741,
0.0063517168,
-0.0689670816,
-0.0198462158,
-0.0423805118,
0.0220677033,
-0.0100731943,
0.0221367981,
0.0100813312,
0.0136651983,
-0.0631627887,
-0.0232276674,
0.0380182751,
0.0643077046,
0.0346953198,
0.0532170013,
-0.024594143,
-0.0666172877,
-0.0043701283,
0.0177298505,
0.0422237851,
0.0319628902,
-0.0188884512,
0.0537489988,
-0.0181872994,
-0.0466234237,
-0.0147054633,
-0.0075801001,
-0.0059101121,
-0.036391791,
-0.0398844071,
-0.02157012,
0.0284399372,
-0.0027405927,
0.0178181697,
-0.030140508,
0.0112620275,
-0.0314408392,
0.0247107465,
0.0791614503,
-0.0387646779,
0.0039931973,
0.026059689,
0.0050404947,
-0.0207422245,
0.0636515394,
0.0622301064,
-0.0326449461,
0.0283794347,
-0.0327212326,
-0.0279047843,
0.0148970941,
0.0084261727,
-0.0207334366,
-0.022256529,
0.0011537242,
-0.0112557011,
0.0161406379,
0.0461780019,
0.0320011228,
-0.032362882,
0.0001388026,
0.0290254895,
0.0215969346,
0.028030701,
-0.0205019526,
0.0246032029,
0.0457049608,
-0.0370016396,
-0.0145695722,
-0.0568756089,
-0.0251383949,
-0.0212606266,
0.0412401631,
0.023326952,
0.0498458482,
-0.0070263161,
-0.0244371984,
-0.0246691871,
-0.0230999961,
-0.0436828509,
0.0694233328,
0.057672821,
-0.0357829519,
-0.0418874621,
0.0555478558,
-0.0111301914,
-0.0603292994,
0.0571289286,
-0.0276432186,
0.0223870706,
0.056372188,
0.0123480037,
-0.033261057,
0.0040495996,
-0.0389405489,
0.0090509299,
0.0109794391,
-0.0077949748,
-0.0034898291,
0.0988755524,
-0.0645024776,
-0.0313625336,
0.0176164024,
-0.0004383826,
0.0509079769,
-0.0777431726,
-0.0218293425,
0.0350486711,
-0.0477649681,
0.0091380076,
-0.0108887497,
0.023703089,
0.0285453461,
0.0180425718,
-0.0058422829,
0.035528563,
0.0260300059,
-0.025470227,
-0.0199084245,
0.0353168324,
-0.0013344231,
0.0063846665,
0.0755695626,
-0.0876469687,
-0.0263414439,
0.0606688522,
-0.0204710178,
-0.0310035162,
0.0339322276,
-0.009432449,
-0.100421682,
0.0106674898,
-0.0018697033,
0.0472972021,
-0.0312182698,
0.0621891581,
0.0365198515,
0.0252388753,
0.0160032194,
0.0022985302,
0.0119020101,
0.0090258941,
0.0253645517,
-0.0004895685,
0.0322462767,
-0.0521476269,
0.0007251762,
0.0411002263,
-0.0192682166,
-0.0126640266,
-0.0130048208,
-0.0319420658,
-0.0488151088,
0.0095832031,
-0.1018266752,
-0.0085600307,
-0.0399679504,
0.0449330248,
0.0308974087,
0.0345166288,
-0.0243081022,
-0.073763296,
0.0094605442,
-0.0059741647,
0.0275773387,
-0.0384461842,
-0.0345334224,
-0.0017639213,
-0.0268944744,
-0.0063039963,
0.0250791591,
-0.0170191471,
0.0177635439,
0.0071911803,
0.0012191894,
-0.0740057975,
0.0223515276,
0.0307443589,
0.0488278195,
-0.0067245197,
0.0008179517,
-0.0104749482,
-0.0120669063,
-0.01241084,
0.0171051621,
0.0236737598,
-0.0060061086,
0.0287239868,
-0.0577489845,
-0.0440499298,
0.0181583129,
0.0133827124,
0.0131215714,
-0.0468639098,
-0.0164598506,
-0.0248555597,
0.0451117493,
0.0347403809,
0.0521879829,
-0.0279544648,
-0.0674317628,
-0.0069253636,
-0.0418102406,
-0.0262086689,
-0.0338843875,
-0.0183768906,
0.0422693864,
-0.0116565851,
-0.0187669843,
0.0491673648,
-0.1175020486,
-0.0375663452,
-0.0691216812,
-0.0416492969,
-0.0103266006,
0.0154979145,
-0.0186609384,
-0.0010390836,
-0.0158640146,
-0.0810416788,
-0.0156362392,
-0.0188167449,
0.0245399345,
-0.0338936895,
0.0338366292,
-0.0682175085,
0.0015566701,
-0.0054969136,
-0.0314388126,
-0.0486151241,
-0.0306478031,
-0.0582477897,
0.0029044717,
-0.0090737417,
-0.0267759934,
-0.0372816995,
0.0327300169,
0.0053929775,
0.0550477952,
-0.0073495973,
0.0174380131,
-0.0323885605,
0.0532885715,
0.0285137594,
0.0384634659,
0.0096855145,
-0.0004808244,
0.0750022307,
0.0190668888,
0.0670403242,
-0.0089351637,
-0.0488069169,
0.0251254477,
0.0423950851,
0.00355181,
-0.0319246054,
0.061162889,
0.0744136944,
-0.0576832853,
-0.0104160272,
0.1485479474,
0.010202569,
0.0040856781,
-0.0378437191,
0.0196228698,
0.0185849182,
0.0292429589,
0.0005015727,
-0.0616423115,
-0.0720838979,
0.0437650234,
0.0404736735,
0.0142556429,
0.0163666699,
-0.0216856804,
-0.0658775643,
0.0433678813,
0.0083480468,
-0.0529548414,
-0.0288549289,
-0.0284371898,
0.0053907884,
-0.0233777333,
0.0801230818,
-0.0208933931,
-0.0279349945,
0.0046902997,
0.0556753427,
-0.0241906829,
-0.0693244413,
-0.0117060961,
-0.0090832161,
0.0893981606,
0.0188789722,
0.0041762758,
-0.0166698229,
-0.0121799912,
0.0415525846,
-0.0097001875,
0.0248001385,
-0.0001026241,
0.0272745453,
-0.0143217733,
0.002618653,
0.0370475017,
0.0294885393,
-0.002809078,
-0.0121438289,
0.0059950706,
0.0429362655,
-0.0345888808,
0.0399533287,
0.0162719004,
0.0213974006,
0.0250113346,
0.0455570333,
0.0174934193,
0.0141514419,
-0.0012220206,
-0.0316125639,
0.0207998492,
-0.0246412512,
0.0395602584,
0.0486402027,
0.0159780011,
-0.0332657769,
0.008694631,
-0.0327054858,
0.0101519655,
-0.0102938246,
0.0027213665,
0.0045176181,
-0.0034199581,
0.0388381779,
-0.0568510033,
0.044188384,
0.0067976904,
0.0321436264,
-0.0838591829,
0.0628432333,
0.032732714,
-0.069438003,
-0.0285918675,
0.0206981599,
-0.0731284097,
-0.0609006137,
0.006360143,
-0.0135114798,
0.024596801,
0.0650590435,
-0.0439077467,
-0.0389208458,
0.0408786684,
0.0095942002,
-0.0924987271,
-0.0121322861,
0.059703175,
0.0079341233,
-0.0291542336,
0.0370063856,
-0.0449977629,
0.0318999924,
-0.0406580605,
0.0168110933,
0.0054787104,
-0.0377355665,
0.0300617144,
0.0193868373,
0.0616968349,
-0.0048751798,
0.0037940575,
-0.0360290036,
0.0601920485,
0.0070099924,
0.0336228311,
0.0005002924,
0.0350841843,
-0.0035824559,
-0.0287120845,
0.0000935905,
0.0248834547,
-0.0463195033,
0.0022673993,
-0.0146165304,
0.07213974,
0.0301500559,
-0.0006671835,
0.0059460239,
-0.0226495992,
0.0022809773,
0.0374948755,
0.0410695858,
0.033451952,
0.0009190344,
0.065512225,
-0.0294185206,
-0.0245416481,
-0.0145319868,
0.0107646026,
-0.0739962682,
-0.0289886221,
0.001090531,
0.0325277075,
0.0080171628,
-0.0146284429,
0.0302201472,
0.0263736937,
0.0341196917,
-0.0368711911,
0.0488927066,
-0.0385078639,
-0.009191433,
0.0800172165,
-0.0136231836,
0.0016105225,
0.0308532193,
0.0333488658,
0.0045532733,
0.0414226353,
-0.0506353751,
0.0093772747,
-0.0568351559,
-0.0457228571,
-0.00584536,
0.0497738682,
-0.0493441783,
-0.0107459789,
-0.0068276264,
-0.0672201142,
0.030125197,
-0.0198952276,
0.0247884169,
-0.0260862932,
-0.0245944094,
0.0290700775,
-0.0284554865,
0.0067928131,
0.0161553696,
-0.0237660855,
0.0090841344,
0.0344434939,
-0.0178536698,
-6.768405371e-33,
-0.012018892,
0.0088082906,
-0.0221030638,
-0.0449734069,
0.0077492432,
0.0111520775,
-0.020500198,
-0.0055798986,
0.0242166761,
-0.0259733573,
-0.0300254114,
0.0491989367,
0.0451541059,
0.0425753109,
-0.0278665572,
-0.007366891,
0.1006456167,
-0.0207658987,
-0.031152904,
-0.0064574475,
0.0586895198,
0.067968443,
0.0555335619,
-0.0673912466,
0.0028164391,
0.0399750844,
-0.0150281796,
0.0039219689,
0.0083165038,
0.0500415936,
0.0171274673,
0.0191491749,
0.0089928927,
-0.0251065809,
-0.0464255661,
0.0114088161,
-0.1008449346,
0.0134725235,
-0.0124115115,
0.0562268198,
-0.0121811246,
0.0205301642,
0.0434079804,
-0.0129057709,
0.019078698,
-0.0180861522,
0.0270716939,
-0.0083841244,
-0.005711081,
-0.0370353274,
0.027805673,
0.0444415584,
-0.0403588302,
-0.0166895948,
0.0673300549,
0.038156312,
0.0166848563,
-0.0301747285,
-0.0479664728,
0.0258969385,
-0.0041247439,
0.0095346561,
0.0781780034,
0.0150129646,
-0.0286603253,
0.0190766398,
-0.0047996901,
-0.1057220921,
0.0112815779,
-0.0292003956,
0.025696367,
-0.0036417553,
-0.0281017367,
0.0550392754,
0.012541363,
-0.0006636933,
-0.0513075218,
0.001384928,
-0.010673481,
0.0263617374,
-0.0069259941,
0.0393708646,
-0.064203158,
-0.0039219968,
-0.0863792375,
-0.0414610989,
-0.0128264409,
0.0016182357,
0.0539099313,
-0.0029305301,
-0.0212240536,
-0.0090683103,
0.0783360675,
0.0011259726,
-0.0041190898,
0.0166208502,
0.0242230706,
0.0049805897,
0.0037993833,
0.0668969303,
-0.0272908714,
0.0028934716,
0.0588465855,
0.0230501816,
-0.0081206309,
-0.0530535392,
-0.0099926591,
0.0447248779,
-0.0562655292,
0.0175951775,
-0.0152323134,
0.0275529996,
-0.0240529813,
0.0407165661,
0.0692485124,
-0.0112777734,
-0.0271789748,
0.0573655814,
-0.0585631169,
0.0395164415,
-0.0374275483,
-0.0083233388,
0.0130977212,
0.0466084667,
-0.0523301773,
-0.0149716036,
0.0149041936,
-0.0581488237,
0.0404041819,
-0.0234983582,
-0.0035143981,
0.0288245641,
2.924e-7,
-0.0161201973,
-0.0401950255,
0.0382341333,
-0.0381241739,
0.0288837887,
0.0346681848,
0.0011477049,
-0.0162610337,
-0.007635552,
-0.0278797429,
0.0017934345,
-0.027099546,
0.054225374,
0.0319646336,
-0.0594500899,
-0.0584111474,
0.0236471463,
0.0298591554,
0.0212535691,
0.0347429961,
0.0648883358,
0.0999605283,
-0.0397388525,
-0.0242296327,
0.0109195514,
-0.0113771502,
0.0211510286,
-0.0232525226,
0.0225498788,
-0.0078472346,
0.0000605843,
-0.0077191368,
-0.0127600394,
0.0381007902,
-0.0304209925,
0.0436938442,
-0.0160092376,
0.0290805362,
-0.002577995,
-0.0208862629,
-0.0372217968,
0.0427822731,
-0.0050476757,
-0.0057658241,
0.0352300145,
-0.0397149213,
-0.0086765913,
-0.0409114882,
-0.0541158877,
-0.0302620176,
-0.0500094928,
0.0277441759,
0.0200470239,
0.028071586,
-0.0107564321,
-0.0178166125,
-0.0228607357,
-0.0875566527,
-0.0131530659,
-0.0340850316,
-0.0459879711,
0.0104176514,
-0.0202200245,
-0.0146840559,
0.072640352,
-0.0491963252,
-0.0069445423,
2.41985063e-34,
0.0342583358,
-0.0091072097,
-0.003110392,
-0.0018918581,
0.0442471541,
-0.0294435509,
0.0205150284,
0.010701566,
0.0355275907,
-0.0443404838,
-0.0299782827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12131v1 | Explainable Topic-Enhanced Argument Mining from Heterogeneous Sources | 2023-07-22T17:26:55 | 2023-07-22T17:26:55 | Jiasheng Si, Yingjie Zhu, Xingyu Shi, Deyu Zhou, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given a controversial target such as ``nuclear energy'', argument mining aims
to identify the argumentative text from heterogeneous sources. Current
approaches focus on exploring better ways of integrating the target-associated
semantic information with the argumentative text. Despite their empirical
successes, two issues remain unsolved: (i) a target is represented by a word or
a phrase, which is insufficient to cover a diverse set of target-related
subtopics; (ii) the sentence-level topic information within an argument, which
we believe is crucial for argument mining, is ignored. To tackle the above
issues, we propose a novel explainable topic-enhanced argument mining approach.
Specifically, with the use of the neural topic model and the language model,
the target information is augmented by explainable topic representations.
Moreover, the sentence-level topic information within the argument is captured
by minimizing the distance between its latent topic distribution and its
semantic representation through mutual learning. Experiments have been
conducted on the benchmark dataset in both the in-target setting and the
cross-target setting. Results demonstrate the superiority of the proposed model
against the state-of-the-art baselines. | [
0.018494945,
0.0416417941,
0.0183249228,
0.0618841611,
0.0086892257,
0.0123210549,
0.0169174485,
-0.0104428539,
-0.040716242,
-0.0263969805,
-0.0041732662,
0.016825838,
-0.0251299981,
0.008600981,
-0.0039272802,
-0.0413322002,
0.0043118456,
0.0108617377,
0.0786285996,
0.0195458271,
-0.0109387776,
0.0125081548,
-0.0373759009,
0.0583235323,
-0.0025171204,
-0.0280460287,
0.010707695,
-0.0189697873,
0.0364641808,
-0.0314756297,
0.0033420126,
-0.0103144413,
0.033339113,
0.0332493819,
0.0000018079,
0.0201535858,
-0.050771568,
-0.0171239283,
-0.0054353555,
0.0059803072,
0.0654576197,
0.0278894305,
0.0032861554,
0.0285899807,
-0.0083992211,
0.033801388,
0.0301019046,
0.1256043017,
0.0826178119,
0.0627306253,
-0.019138772,
-0.0018644925,
0.0121979695,
0.0004844246,
-0.0292401239,
0.0042090612,
0.0034305011,
0.0198500659,
-0.0569991022,
0.0585056841,
0.0148610147,
-0.0027468044,
0.0030537257,
-0.040777415,
-0.0065636705,
0.0180828739,
-0.0022424536,
-0.0105372937,
0.0147862341,
0.0631335452,
-0.0314225294,
-0.0414482839,
0.0245719235,
-0.0446930155,
-0.0096919239,
0.0090619149,
-0.0474483445,
0.0249333028,
0.0003190116,
0.0501211956,
0.0584559366,
0.0258711744,
0.0332195759,
-0.0075114635,
0.0174382105,
0.045368813,
-0.031334579,
-0.0188307725,
0.0033649972,
-0.0012562807,
-0.0385894403,
-0.0298660975,
0.0231684223,
0.0111878589,
0.0109751644,
0.0508156344,
0.0063886298,
-0.0284575857,
0.0406019427,
-0.0853155777,
0.0103852628,
-0.0140880076,
-0.0190510768,
0.0550623313,
0.0118128136,
-0.0436486155,
-0.0314006917,
-0.0390976854,
0.0082552424,
-0.0337787196,
-0.0763757974,
-0.0122184521,
0.0014918755,
0.003021345,
-0.0226611756,
-0.0232240483,
0.0138696143,
0.0064766668,
-0.0362420455,
0.0111042242,
0.014956234,
0.020807134,
0.0101314634,
-0.0376022421,
-0.0176293403,
0.0444761179,
-0.0569835864,
0.0385416411,
0.0338643268,
-0.0254199635,
-0.0339547805,
0.0229427684,
0.00047064,
0.0094565749,
-0.0405374765,
0.0432918221,
-0.0074512698,
-0.0189905055,
-0.0543614402,
-0.0659770668,
-0.0271560978,
0.0091741001,
0.0507058576,
-0.0468870923,
-0.0089101158,
-0.0406052247,
-0.0019750225,
-0.0351532698,
0.0055968775,
0.0106694112,
-0.0126186013,
0.0250454135,
0.0123296529,
-0.0678180084,
0.0521576889,
0.0319375172,
-0.0187304411,
0.0453314967,
0.0380877741,
0.0358607695,
0.0494180769,
0.0317768939,
-0.0309940074,
-0.0649381429,
0.0611745976,
0.0067531369,
0.0578639396,
-0.0187638905,
-0.0790981129,
-0.0311981868,
0.0166369937,
0.0100688608,
-0.0203265566,
-0.0510857999,
-0.0129633136,
0.0420696624,
0.0072952877,
0.0345098376,
-0.0139557319,
0.0453818329,
-0.0457487144,
0.0048709186,
0.0372071676,
0.0344889835,
-0.028292438,
-0.0414102934,
0.0306962915,
0.0301121976,
-0.0297722742,
-0.0834507421,
-0.0055673416,
-0.0202601068,
-0.0209246948,
-0.0150054824,
0.0359742641,
0.0234324578,
-0.0277351346,
0.0433987491,
0.0843350589,
-0.0276602451,
-0.0410409421,
-0.0200334582,
0.0704523101,
-0.0436700918,
-0.022841325,
-0.0373381674,
0.0003485135,
-0.0413368344,
0.0517223068,
0.0303553864,
0.0157099217,
-0.0238946509,
0.0154300975,
-0.0178965069,
-0.0430890955,
-0.0898282379,
0.0240311697,
0.0118664214,
-0.0305512995,
-0.0271063652,
0.0330371782,
-0.0026955281,
0.009588425,
0.0275339335,
0.0078597758,
0.0279454086,
0.0032329471,
-0.0010017316,
0.0363790281,
0.0450947583,
-0.0099733192,
0.0206682552,
0.0425364897,
-0.0313458107,
-0.0645661876,
0.0189141054,
-0.0051125176,
-0.0273939371,
0.0103243655,
-0.077886045,
0.0230393969,
-0.0502302758,
-0.0230453517,
-0.0222802702,
0.0543759428,
-0.0315802321,
-0.0161576625,
-0.0011205723,
-0.0218192115,
0.0030834666,
0.0091947941,
-0.0375392474,
0.0840799138,
-0.0048068468,
-0.0007005284,
-0.0080637857,
0.0130551867,
0.0424237475,
-0.048336383,
0.0299507175,
0.0146172438,
0.0041245548,
-0.0234030411,
0.0336092822,
-0.0704491958,
-0.0246408358,
-0.0199784003,
-0.0639162138,
0.0046309428,
0.0062916433,
0.0155339846,
0.0217652135,
-0.0424484238,
0.0276813786,
0.009352129,
-0.0219154842,
0.0030292221,
-0.0316478647,
-0.0044774683,
0.0490690805,
-0.0287657939,
0.0366482884,
-0.0615817793,
-0.027100686,
-0.0447920375,
0.0853976384,
0.0052861762,
0.0180141032,
-0.0447153188,
0.0222791992,
-0.0175784808,
-0.0202273391,
-0.042146083,
-0.0012840151,
0.0280306842,
0.0172537081,
0.0135184657,
0.0519111305,
0.0253925789,
0.0696170852,
0.0535691194,
0.0006456538,
-0.0541399196,
-0.0239407755,
-0.0081579406,
0.0637604892,
0.0196595155,
-0.0275981016,
0.067107141,
0.0756582469,
0.0018548059,
0.0163351838,
-0.0260129515,
0.0629691631,
-0.0146866338,
-0.0057780105,
-0.003415524,
-0.0162498411,
0.0351684652,
0.0161258876,
-0.0393406823,
-0.0122201359,
0.0721655563,
-0.0338934287,
0.038196478,
-0.0473949239,
-0.071741499,
-0.0347881019,
0.0268895272,
-0.0163070913,
0.0008752786,
0.0283739753,
0.0343241692,
0.0266125575,
-0.0629846528,
0.0261548348,
0.0082652988,
0.0118951714,
-0.0215587653,
0.0119708087,
0.0067205993,
-0.0117771551,
-0.0033948312,
-0.0398973823,
-0.0015665381,
-0.0027002944,
0.0160110574,
-0.0098392991,
-0.0158620812,
-0.02036516,
0.0481448546,
-0.0058457502,
0.0108871469,
-0.0101997014,
0.0055699511,
0.0509185083,
0.0181762297,
-0.0200932063,
0.0383533649,
0.0017606812,
0.048517704,
0.068330124,
-0.008515276,
-0.0437199473,
-0.0794740394,
-0.0251174048,
-0.0526235998,
-0.0098653063,
-0.0307516269,
-0.0510119498,
0.0422543734,
-0.0511030592,
0.0361181051,
0.065990068,
0.01847356,
0.005847632,
0.0125560872,
-0.0078047374,
-0.034985844,
-0.0269345548,
-0.0113077872,
-0.0490182675,
-0.0032365101,
-0.02974906,
0.0000333638,
-0.0148197683,
-0.0172065869,
-0.0146217812,
-0.0175220668,
0.0296779033,
-0.0080025569,
0.0184867419,
-0.0290384274,
-0.0777477622,
-0.0176895577,
-0.0192248318,
-0.0496178232,
-0.0208671819,
0.0173066482,
-0.012341029,
0.0233083069,
-0.0179628413,
-0.0056863055,
-0.0080373306,
-0.0224788468,
0.0317374319,
0.0199003462,
0.0671949685,
0.0366758853,
-0.0153912194,
0.0073787947,
-0.0433807969,
-0.0187515989,
-0.0120827314,
0.0307612475,
0.0122714136,
-0.0202394072,
0.0047246818,
0.0423905849,
-0.0388390012,
-0.0625288188,
-0.0010201936,
0.0648985654,
-0.0551705547,
-0.0090780668,
-0.0073222737,
0.0243983753,
0.0204387996,
0.0548835024,
0.0242225602,
0.0272392035,
-0.041189719,
-0.0338952765,
0.0026356091,
-0.0437806286,
0.0297596268,
0.0003440729,
0.017959388,
-0.0210063178,
-0.0606664307,
-0.0380585715,
-0.0613203123,
0.0517269336,
-0.0477065034,
-0.0066170711,
0.0432076901,
0.0123391403,
-0.003314002,
0.0500560999,
0.0023907938,
-0.0206423625,
0.008150992,
-0.0384973548,
0.0255100336,
-0.0032520276,
-0.046761889,
0.0339104012,
-0.0111839706,
-0.0456492677,
-0.0590182394,
0.0065348926,
0.0146526825,
0.0258005895,
0.0047955387,
-0.026012836,
0.0234662779,
-0.0032533691,
-0.0066840453,
-0.0317467041,
0.0552686043,
0.0128246816,
0.0211959127,
0.0047479677,
-0.0123993661,
0.0730432197,
-0.0056253178,
0.0058035529,
-0.082248807,
0.0083083194,
0.0070576984,
-0.0329979956,
0.0700789094,
0.056511838,
-0.0574280769,
-0.0818395168,
-0.009009745,
-0.03671569,
0.0129812714,
-0.0714666322,
0.0407421328,
-0.0088430522,
-0.0581421405,
-0.0205349158,
-0.0386756584,
-0.0106181279,
0.0677203387,
0.0136771556,
0.0568517111,
0.0059514488,
0.0348608345,
-0.0558708757,
0.0102934353,
-0.0300607719,
0.0202248357,
-0.0046851379,
0.0090691848,
0.0109901726,
0.0567690916,
0.0171056632,
-0.0266794991,
0.0101835476,
-0.004897384,
-0.0804566219,
-0.0259637032,
-0.0147861131,
-0.0308305584,
0.0117359869,
-0.0147091765,
0.0362959541,
-0.0150569063,
-0.0212011728,
0.0086129978,
0.0640293062,
0.0349686816,
-0.0267669261,
0.0439557396,
0.0265679434,
-0.0527904667,
-0.0098212669,
0.0462681875,
-0.0117672356,
0.0168358553,
0.0220192522,
-0.0481323823,
-0.0384895913,
-0.0410464853,
-0.0121057834,
0.0406732671,
-0.0218596216,
-0.011838289,
-0.0102645857,
-0.0047418419,
-0.0137571227,
0.0167524666,
0.0031511001,
0.0254238416,
0.0384275615,
0.0531686433,
-0.0191965587,
-0.0037594275,
-0.0451348834,
0.0164982583,
0.0050768806,
0.0031778379,
-0.0039239596,
-6.116513306e-33,
-0.0097312964,
-0.0356052183,
-0.016082393,
0.0589435995,
0.0346797891,
0.0329477489,
-0.0711483657,
-0.0138751036,
-0.0371419005,
0.056685809,
0.0487208553,
0.0684133172,
0.016698936,
-0.0119624492,
-0.0521508083,
-0.0004176745,
0.0758694932,
0.0034236,
-0.014704261,
0.0428337567,
0.0849388242,
0.0007364034,
0.0347684957,
-0.0843098685,
0.0591672622,
0.0238708835,
0.025318129,
0.0084116915,
0.0177853405,
0.065828681,
-0.0103224562,
0.0482475758,
0.0230782256,
-0.0571916923,
0.0010940117,
0.0332587287,
-0.0701232031,
-0.0319310017,
-0.0108599635,
-0.0786352605,
-0.0087404624,
-0.0472665876,
0.0161614399,
0.0403100774,
0.0184264742,
-0.0469405577,
0.0491089672,
-0.0350684784,
0.0081109945,
-0.0267145913,
-0.0330117941,
0.0544389114,
-0.0462860912,
0.0153999189,
-0.0175159834,
0.0142579516,
0.0423598625,
0.109282963,
-0.0458982177,
0.0073970389,
0.0076495931,
0.0179195441,
0.0172375981,
-0.0575718433,
-0.0264261737,
0.1072927713,
0.0023672816,
0.0176976193,
-0.050340239,
-0.0073130904,
-0.0201163255,
0.0511198305,
0.0626335293,
0.0185069535,
0.0139665706,
0.0019934569,
-0.122816056,
-0.010418959,
0.0744975656,
0.0414395854,
0.0379670896,
0.0155612119,
0.0137150362,
0.0095775267,
-0.0070542418,
-0.0454272404,
-0.0274676755,
-0.0284800325,
-0.0318959169,
0.0273295604,
-0.0145733422,
0.0460786447,
0.0070532765,
-0.0167499706,
0.0384097658,
0.0793408975,
0.0103619331,
-0.0132608721,
0.0204063039,
0.0066894693,
-0.0383683182,
0.005503465,
0.0057244767,
-0.0247441698,
0.0369482227,
-0.0084137488,
-0.0001843046,
-0.0406652391,
-0.0319262743,
-0.0105612855,
-0.0681776404,
-0.0311002024,
-0.038695097,
0.0336507037,
-0.0139546562,
0.0356113575,
-0.0236318167,
0.0504824221,
-0.0075760167,
0.0375279412,
0.0373592712,
-0.0480427966,
-0.0489937067,
0.0139045278,
0.0014005095,
-0.0484143086,
0.0087203961,
0.0263345633,
0.0283149499,
-0.092612192,
0.0084866369,
-0.0198755972,
2.443e-7,
0.0451824591,
0.0255176369,
0.0221749824,
-0.0676721632,
0.0169554912,
0.0312222745,
-0.0271788482,
0.029339293,
-0.0214406513,
-0.0432775244,
-0.0212447997,
0.031737648,
0.0163618755,
0.0697871223,
-0.0305671562,
-0.039878048,
-0.0636721253,
-0.05025151,
-0.0513778999,
-0.0076910579,
0.0622364469,
0.0673924387,
0.0215386655,
-0.0029220136,
-0.0023767371,
0.0192260295,
0.0909945518,
-0.0460813418,
-0.0390240289,
0.012905851,
0.0841266513,
-0.0231458303,
-0.0069555407,
0.0115344543,
-0.0335388668,
0.0227038208,
-0.0024731073,
0.051024884,
0.0458020344,
-0.0303536206,
0.0157841779,
-0.0206126068,
0.0361289494,
-0.020477267,
0.0283585731,
-0.0798723996,
-0.0452221483,
-0.0360410586,
-0.0363623016,
0.0106812296,
0.0109597715,
-0.0031636686,
0.0048034815,
-0.0297819339,
-0.0490873903,
-0.0141809136,
0.0369400382,
-0.0610134751,
-0.0331378058,
0.0312532894,
-0.0349265411,
-0.0109194871,
-0.0189744886,
-0.0301531702,
0.0683190227,
-0.0148391733,
0.0243716687,
2.062395425e-34,
0.0237189531,
-0.030287059,
-0.0425256155,
-0.0074539939,
0.0465865321,
0.0303296372,
-0.0052995142,
-0.0077104676,
0.0320479013,
-0.026035741,
0.0179447997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12114v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12114v3 | A Zero-shot and Few-shot Study of Instruction-Finetuned Large Language Models Applied to Clinical and Biomedical Tasks | 2023-07-22T15:58:17 | 2024-06-09T15:06:57 | Yanis Labrak, Mickael Rouvier, Richard Dufour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We evaluate four state-of-the-art instruction-tuned large language models
(LLMs) -- ChatGPT, Flan-T5 UL2, Tk-Instruct, and Alpaca -- on a set of 13
real-world clinical and biomedical natural language processing (NLP) tasks in
English, such as named-entity recognition (NER), question-answering (QA),
relation extraction (RE), etc. Our overall results demonstrate that the
evaluated LLMs begin to approach performance of state-of-the-art models in
zero- and few-shot scenarios for most tasks, and particularly well for the QA
task, even though they have never seen examples from these tasks before.
However, we observed that the classification and RE tasks perform below what
can be achieved with a specifically trained model for the medical field, such
as PubMedBERT. Finally, we noted that no LLM outperforms all the others on all
the studied tasks, with some models being better suited for certain tasks than
others. | [
0.0825586542,
0.0104698911,
0.0303611215,
0.0269208867,
-0.0208774228,
0.0519010648,
0.0417622589,
-0.0038321766,
0.0153319649,
-0.0720261261,
-0.0583566837,
-0.0447106436,
-0.0223443229,
-0.0170255452,
0.0218156185,
-0.0227726512,
0.0466556884,
-0.0197251495,
0.0130694387,
0.0075562997,
-0.0374456421,
0.016055204,
-0.0362725742,
0.0442243554,
0.0601286665,
-0.0086438917,
0.020865323,
-0.0226407424,
0.0186597928,
-0.0566968285,
0.0250042789,
0.0372127183,
0.0002636778,
0.0062920977,
0.0000017018,
-0.0507149398,
0.0003930737,
0.0362109207,
-0.0561647825,
0.0020300983,
0.0436399803,
-0.0274938624,
0.0005752866,
0.0272453111,
-0.0268213786,
-0.0580996498,
0.0123880375,
0.0673940405,
0.0472595245,
0.0635097772,
0.0068863342,
-0.0428363718,
0.0712711215,
-0.0294329561,
0.0098751662,
-0.0590416566,
0.0515709743,
-0.0247154925,
0.034585733,
0.0277413055,
0.0155195855,
0.0306258444,
-0.0057698898,
0.0450878069,
0.0218539145,
0.0602399446,
-0.0635735467,
0.0030168709,
-0.0132688712,
0.0802617446,
-0.0169635843,
0.0028386277,
0.0143355653,
0.0226844735,
-0.0417803153,
-0.0148676401,
-0.0288020428,
0.0202396177,
-0.018099783,
0.0070774532,
0.046697706,
-0.0191789847,
0.0251839496,
0.0403181426,
-0.0160307512,
-0.0087621771,
0.0230771378,
-0.0369899161,
0.0310468804,
0.0104007544,
-0.0538789667,
-0.0530347042,
0.0254168715,
0.067641288,
-0.0356641524,
0.0105910739,
-0.0226663612,
0.0017159795,
0.0534741729,
-0.0578113608,
0.023132408,
0.0058646952,
0.0002879911,
0.0607305951,
-0.054162953,
0.0322483294,
-0.0141414246,
0.0343574211,
-0.0284925774,
0.0056167371,
-0.0716071725,
0.0029152401,
-0.0294480231,
0.0519278571,
-0.0392464548,
-0.0234997235,
-0.0530131161,
-0.0101631898,
0.0267440826,
0.0083266776,
0.0140381036,
0.0283728093,
-0.0246597491,
0.003946702,
-0.0176453087,
0.0263748169,
0.0022152765,
0.0141533026,
-0.0353416279,
-0.0879212841,
-0.0085656941,
-0.0320236832,
-0.0004387263,
-0.0522504076,
0.0660485476,
0.0629028678,
0.0120214969,
-0.0864426568,
-0.0060358467,
-0.000187379,
-0.008731449,
-0.0808107331,
-0.0004715194,
-0.0462953597,
0.0403619967,
0.0312594213,
-0.0000989146,
-0.0191062056,
0.0377662405,
0.0265454501,
-0.0712514892,
0.0747566447,
-0.0117390631,
0.01547259,
0.0262149889,
0.019951554,
0.0380977169,
0.0437449291,
0.0283613168,
-0.0291860234,
-0.0123984283,
-0.0254032593,
0.0025145803,
0.0081559913,
0.0086057065,
-0.0510128587,
-0.0078028399,
0.0355748087,
-0.0057546734,
0.0596346147,
-0.0139413634,
0.0773890018,
-0.0004904848,
-0.0164720882,
0.0181537345,
0.072960183,
0.0495487377,
0.0041144392,
0.0336021073,
-0.0155352047,
0.0280164182,
-0.0363395847,
-0.0537430868,
0.0098207723,
-0.0116145844,
0.0258964393,
-0.012650894,
0.0087753432,
-0.050810419,
0.0078169322,
-0.028867783,
0.0006340322,
-0.0434196591,
0.0179296248,
0.0553310066,
-0.0055666789,
-0.057977505,
0.04914812,
0.0624523312,
0.0255990885,
0.0005524363,
-0.0684521571,
0.0034391403,
0.0569997355,
0.045367524,
-0.0259140655,
-0.0468180887,
-0.0446716063,
0.0190737043,
0.0233217571,
0.0331287347,
-0.0142137781,
0.0323277079,
-0.0351910815,
0.0136623271,
0.0046969354,
-0.0002559505,
-0.0228215978,
0.0287796482,
0.0354471765,
-0.0136106098,
-0.0133003006,
-0.0219212696,
0.0621625148,
-0.0338994749,
-0.0578630306,
-0.0093735131,
-0.001085574,
0.0272475574,
0.0178181287,
-0.0324938148,
0.0169355087,
0.0274821669,
-0.050823655,
-0.007485278,
-0.0472918637,
-0.0306039602,
-0.0513429567,
0.0057295244,
0.0219546054,
-0.0170727074,
-0.0056225322,
-0.0344094336,
-0.0245898105,
-0.0554995276,
-0.0362275615,
0.0297862981,
0.0046999734,
0.0165921561,
0.0191383269,
-0.0040079844,
-0.0619817823,
0.0392697416,
-0.0077021178,
0.0315576307,
0.0275150444,
-0.01882587,
-0.0408567414,
-0.0216088835,
-0.044942379,
0.0175604243,
0.0089496244,
-0.0203030072,
-0.045812007,
0.0158175863,
-0.0422095656,
-0.0618085489,
-0.0876116082,
0.0408040173,
-0.0015338687,
0.0405269861,
0.029817516,
0.0176624879,
-0.0142865833,
-0.011266117,
-0.0207417998,
-0.0159111004,
0.0280037522,
0.0381621234,
0.0321844481,
0.0351681225,
-0.0138921579,
-0.0224752594,
-0.0031675159,
-0.0371818244,
0.0186924953,
-0.002423906,
-0.0062580165,
-0.0383787751,
0.0455737934,
-0.0147111043,
0.0045266873,
0.0098761935,
-0.0351700298,
-0.0099621033,
0.0179033335,
-0.0000568465,
0.0943484902,
0.0033459992,
0.0342811793,
0.0132250991,
0.0119296461,
-0.0145551264,
0.043172285,
-0.0207080804,
-0.0463364534,
-0.0081897853,
-0.0049862638,
-0.0235133246,
0.102234751,
-0.0054655583,
0.0160834603,
-0.0271366909,
-0.0102280742,
-0.0144811412,
0.0264642164,
-0.023152763,
0.0389080793,
-0.0227829423,
-0.0007651242,
-0.0187748559,
-0.0072971559,
0.0624140091,
-0.0100634554,
-0.0013105922,
-0.0692616329,
-0.0309862047,
-0.0471705906,
0.0106512429,
0.0146753332,
0.0102885915,
0.0073064961,
-0.0323445983,
-0.0082981996,
0.0107214367,
-0.0307543334,
-0.0616906025,
0.0452870987,
-0.0142681915,
0.0355951414,
-0.0288678594,
-0.0477046035,
-0.0438142195,
-0.035119798,
-0.0597785674,
0.0203936864,
-0.0012537787,
0.038287878,
-0.0415912196,
0.0411815532,
0.0161020141,
0.0557196438,
-0.0065078745,
-0.0149105676,
-0.0257882234,
0.0280860811,
0.0727518275,
0.0216974076,
-0.0004072755,
-0.0209149569,
0.0497110449,
0.0463648699,
0.0080538038,
0.0215884633,
-0.0128137814,
0.0007022394,
0.0089694792,
-0.0502753332,
-0.0091271587,
0.0303518772,
0.0597197562,
-0.0834718496,
-0.0243356228,
0.1140221506,
0.0123321638,
-0.0290712025,
-0.0034307817,
0.0326481611,
-0.0058308262,
0.0002994367,
0.0284947958,
-0.0487919189,
-0.0588307194,
-0.0079450319,
0.0258175898,
-0.0231277309,
-0.0408011489,
0.0178507399,
-0.0993410274,
0.0162206721,
-0.0064789494,
-0.0525758006,
-0.0052117091,
-0.0517226718,
0.007273939,
-0.0177700929,
0.0162995514,
-0.0045531327,
-0.0503134206,
-0.0076538236,
0.025295265,
-0.0242774822,
-0.091288656,
0.0506683625,
-0.0385556594,
0.0897716731,
0.0442235358,
0.0022913306,
-0.0140168136,
0.0142320441,
0.025377119,
-0.0217762757,
0.0160475895,
-0.0045836805,
0.0670445934,
-0.0181562062,
-0.0147127742,
-0.0551672354,
0.0288770981,
-0.0448674373,
-0.0028954507,
-0.0157851521,
0.070427224,
-0.0118324682,
-0.0135499146,
-0.02455936,
-0.0049188384,
-0.00079884,
0.0696215406,
0.0018886477,
-0.042738732,
-0.0779963508,
0.0244449135,
0.0150947254,
-0.0195883624,
-0.0448111333,
0.0108074835,
-0.0335831568,
0.0211120266,
-0.0344045423,
-0.0418753549,
0.0560959503,
0.0192324948,
-0.0057122288,
0.0231612455,
0.0338269956,
0.0215040743,
-0.0450288765,
0.0285461545,
-0.0037171068,
0.0034992881,
-0.0787368268,
-0.0372849032,
0.0799860209,
0.0107969595,
-0.0176049303,
-0.0198734645,
-0.0652455837,
-0.0310104266,
-0.00913548,
0.0412782133,
0.0177807808,
-0.0003699059,
-0.0048356261,
-0.0414607786,
0.0384350456,
0.0477355309,
-0.0579680055,
-0.0074425424,
-0.0110203419,
0.0018838524,
-0.0182918683,
0.0354572684,
-0.0231073145,
0.0294776428,
0.0371095687,
0.0473236963,
-0.0153261479,
-0.0133710923,
0.0014499493,
0.0115774432,
0.0305836294,
0.0033035665,
-0.0164421778,
-0.015264675,
0.0250703916,
0.0080218483,
0.0344945006,
-0.0121176997,
-0.0096594272,
0.0371225886,
-0.0041638818,
-0.0225698221,
0.0099378508,
-0.0191321895,
-0.0028166873,
-0.0470928103,
0.0121380156,
0.0086175455,
-0.0075750942,
0.0466208085,
-0.0039565489,
-0.0454077758,
0.0280629508,
0.0378221087,
0.0511672162,
-0.0157809183,
0.0691819638,
0.0009553963,
0.020200612,
-0.0176197998,
0.0397698618,
-0.0587458275,
-0.007363996,
-0.0267860647,
0.060518112,
0.0630479828,
-0.0118109239,
0.0119079994,
0.0071944459,
-0.0201345384,
-0.0259584617,
0.0080030626,
-0.0482174978,
0.0180619285,
0.0672878474,
0.0342206508,
-0.0071106125,
0.0053123455,
0.0859491155,
0.0327727757,
0.0762680098,
0.049836576,
-0.0117002958,
-0.0288466569,
-0.0204502586,
-0.0217293072,
-0.0149851879,
-0.02658909,
0.0424916334,
-0.0343189351,
-0.0427651443,
0.0221279003,
-0.0440243706,
-0.0260674395,
-0.0351232626,
0.0390801579,
0.0157255307,
0.041357059,
-0.0542739816,
-0.0336737372,
0.0299492721,
-0.0093311341,
-0.0229545198,
-0.0146426912,
-5.77081254e-33,
-0.0186014473,
0.001482669,
0.027101405,
-0.0107604843,
-0.0298752282,
0.0365126356,
-0.0222080704,
-0.0086987438,
-0.0549262315,
0.009286534,
-0.0264519323,
0.0003799634,
0.0089208167,
0.0332070999,
0.0003693127,
-0.0589050129,
0.0289698541,
-0.0051281131,
-0.024491163,
0.0233634561,
-0.0121448571,
0.0571867824,
0.0391523764,
-0.0360927135,
-0.0320243686,
-0.017815413,
0.0600159913,
0.005282375,
-0.0102910334,
0.0652970523,
-0.0625565425,
0.0143716959,
0.0519093946,
-0.0347458124,
0.0095278835,
0.0084306933,
-0.108738929,
0.0019599719,
-0.007234897,
-0.0107003441,
-0.0339575522,
-0.0341839418,
0.0644579381,
0.0010162069,
-0.0210491009,
-0.0256724004,
0.0083131827,
-0.0253774263,
-0.0163815208,
-0.0199854933,
-0.0390849747,
0.0189403109,
0.0126198493,
-0.0305028073,
-0.0012289232,
-0.013703567,
-0.0453221314,
0.0394678265,
-0.041073896,
-0.0400773138,
0.0375352055,
0.0353504233,
0.0149758719,
-0.0166780222,
-0.0102720503,
0.0405471884,
0.0171878021,
-0.002373724,
-0.0357070118,
-0.0151163936,
-0.0250896681,
0.050232023,
0.0168221015,
0.0153348325,
0.0253436044,
0.0171580464,
-0.1080083698,
-0.0094551193,
-0.0109193418,
0.0805993229,
0.0304351971,
-0.0212991759,
-0.050125584,
-0.0023034464,
-0.0174325127,
0.0400036424,
-0.0336983614,
-0.0259355344,
0.058349885,
0.0005817996,
-0.0079913354,
0.0082612364,
0.0274916235,
-0.0415194221,
-0.0104284976,
0.0019969968,
0.0348971225,
0.0220682416,
-0.0356624685,
0.0143077103,
-0.0984448344,
-0.0332898572,
0.0213465821,
-0.014387494,
0.0357066505,
0.00019984,
0.011216796,
-0.0211333204,
-0.07304883,
-0.029805569,
-0.0093071982,
0.0190428384,
0.0011869664,
0.0470498353,
0.0355498902,
0.0221909825,
0.0151107116,
0.0859102681,
-0.0243341792,
-0.0210455321,
-0.0335618928,
-0.018919494,
0.0205891207,
0.0010763125,
-0.0320900045,
0.0371929221,
-0.0229634698,
0.0639161021,
-0.0206871387,
-0.0518980697,
-0.0149636026,
0.0096309436,
2.512e-7,
0.0606123917,
0.0635727271,
0.0108263632,
-0.013111447,
0.0234074593,
0.0030845278,
0.0062989127,
0.034107998,
0.0102164829,
0.0000496334,
-0.0139046293,
0.0272122845,
0.0331334956,
0.022434134,
-0.055948291,
0.0045877062,
-0.0750419348,
0.0061214245,
-0.0597200878,
-0.034677282,
0.0513032563,
0.0991520956,
-0.0298474021,
-0.0130948834,
-0.008251423,
-0.0232051909,
0.0512583219,
-0.0082941884,
-0.0173105188,
0.0555463359,
-0.015078499,
0.0562341996,
0.0125933615,
0.0479487218,
-0.0035152952,
0.0156060923,
-0.0044708638,
0.1117762029,
-0.0360536985,
-0.0038801865,
0.0247216728,
-0.020897761,
0.0132028311,
-0.0394614339,
0.0983035862,
-0.1039211974,
-0.0605996214,
-0.0091658989,
-0.0054054591,
-0.0417401455,
0.0305730198,
-0.0178127736,
0.0084738582,
0.0264193639,
0.0217533801,
-0.0231433492,
-0.0375973508,
-0.0815583691,
0.0131294094,
0.0608520135,
-0.0160963126,
-0.0150709338,
-0.0034364995,
-0.0147827882,
0.0139813693,
-0.056668099,
-0.0096903089,
2.205577066e-34,
-0.0090780873,
-0.0068442998,
0.0145913688,
0.0601455607,
0.0102805262,
0.0050424091,
-0.0290681627,
0.0113052251,
0.0099632666,
-0.1019591019,
0.0162311979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12045v1 | Revisiting Distillation for Continual Learning on Visual Question Localized-Answering in Robotic Surgery | 2023-07-22T10:35:25 | 2023-07-22T10:35:25 | Long Bai, Mobarakol Islam, Hongliang Ren | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.RO | The visual-question localized-answering (VQLA) system can serve as a
knowledgeable assistant in surgical education. Except for providing text-based
answers, the VQLA system can highlight the interested region for better
surgical scene understanding. However, deep neural networks (DNNs) suffer from
catastrophic forgetting when learning new knowledge. Specifically, when DNNs
learn on incremental classes or tasks, their performance on old tasks drops
dramatically. Furthermore, due to medical data privacy and licensing issues, it
is often difficult to access old data when updating continual learning (CL)
models. Therefore, we develop a non-exemplar continual surgical VQLA framework,
to explore and balance the rigidity-plasticity trade-off of DNNs in a
sequential learning paradigm. We revisit the distillation loss in CL tasks, and
propose rigidity-plasticity-aware distillation (RP-Dist) and self-calibrated
heterogeneous distillation (SH-Dist) to preserve the old knowledge. The weight
aligning (WA) technique is also integrated to adjust the weight bias between
old and new tasks. We further establish a CL framework on three public surgical
datasets in the context of surgical settings that consist of overlapping
classes between old and new surgical VQLA tasks. With extensive experiments, we
demonstrate that our proposed method excellently reconciles learning and
forgetting on the continual surgical VQLA over conventional CL methods. Our
code is publicly accessible. | [
0.0313763916,
0.0966796279,
-0.0214905944,
-0.01873089,
0.0026702266,
0.0105963321,
-0.014036525,
-0.0075470703,
-0.0395409577,
0.0361220352,
-0.0048686136,
-0.0359048843,
-0.0113230366,
0.0428879671,
-0.0000101376,
-0.0445038751,
0.0485679246,
0.0083997659,
-0.009105172,
-0.0141405892,
-0.0133726681,
-0.03910565,
-0.0498356931,
0.0114217652,
0.002084208,
-0.029592311,
-0.0102525521,
0.0047134869,
0.0474066362,
-0.0589051619,
0.0361840762,
0.0316780657,
0.0282165781,
-0.0042057377,
0.0000022968,
-0.0404245406,
-0.0136602176,
0.0127230529,
-0.0816822723,
-0.057819128,
-0.0212030597,
-0.0237773061,
0.0329297408,
0.0125489403,
-0.0438641794,
-0.0411520936,
0.0302561428,
0.0162468329,
0.08268141,
0.0190238114,
0.0036856029,
-0.0054466482,
0.0242935866,
-0.0208010264,
0.015978964,
-0.0328729227,
0.0071875853,
0.0054530511,
-0.0540841743,
-0.0378051847,
-0.011251702,
0.0632554144,
0.0600985289,
0.0026294549,
-0.0119203106,
0.0487850718,
-0.0382491872,
-0.0285837837,
-0.0108487662,
0.0401021913,
-0.0166755021,
0.005512224,
0.0109574758,
0.0066139838,
0.0305264797,
-0.0316131227,
-0.0880615711,
0.0226161703,
-0.0148232076,
-0.0189546403,
-0.0957682952,
-0.0282520354,
-0.0008213607,
0.0027129781,
-0.0283548962,
-0.0379722193,
0.0036168497,
0.0089846142,
0.000638388,
-0.0210715476,
-0.0387812257,
-0.0236271769,
0.0191712417,
0.0813485384,
-0.0515243188,
-0.0061428281,
-0.029036874,
0.0072473674,
0.0359744988,
-0.0022262167,
0.0075819329,
0.011564469,
-0.0324341804,
0.0156035209,
-0.0609840453,
0.072837241,
-0.0397081524,
0.0468099453,
-0.0290426724,
0.0261817724,
-0.0735179931,
-0.002100741,
-0.007472008,
0.0562303849,
0.0287517961,
0.0145570692,
-0.0214055348,
0.0180338304,
-0.0511887856,
0.0406094752,
-0.0171976667,
0.0942138806,
-0.0508043356,
0.0033239881,
-0.0373109765,
0.0727852061,
0.0130154798,
0.0270369258,
-0.0090271765,
-0.0017090417,
-0.0501625277,
0.0111865858,
0.0106711574,
0.0160207171,
0.0012634825,
0.0755701438,
-0.0367242619,
0.0052400199,
0.0164863411,
-0.0207063258,
-0.0151039399,
-0.0111782094,
0.0812543258,
-0.0192361586,
0.0231458787,
-0.0024256732,
0.0182200186,
-0.0514746755,
0.0240628179,
0.0176778845,
-0.0079743266,
0.0640815124,
0.002669672,
0.0073831794,
0.035236802,
0.031463217,
0.0054856022,
0.0262937527,
-0.0000336109,
-0.0087497933,
-0.0091856178,
-0.0065355236,
0.0405274034,
-0.0264790989,
0.0256507974,
0.0014902478,
-0.0871150717,
0.0082782153,
0.0227831956,
0.0636839196,
-0.0131109357,
0.0594804548,
-0.017425362,
-0.035103742,
0.0402131863,
-0.0044809808,
0.0069494583,
0.0029837664,
-0.0244442634,
-0.0340315178,
-0.0051133409,
0.0198577475,
-0.0758294463,
0.0531524159,
0.0461230315,
0.0025900065,
-0.0721209943,
0.0103975264,
-0.0477505513,
-0.0468625054,
-0.0108845038,
-0.0252745096,
-0.0128558604,
0.0365732871,
0.052095145,
0.0283542499,
0.0028385525,
0.0823549554,
0.0182927847,
-0.0139051452,
-0.0184464939,
-0.0591450818,
-0.0053520738,
0.0201299954,
0.0181520004,
-0.0600918606,
-0.1144531965,
-0.0543130264,
0.0474854484,
-0.017428346,
-0.0063876193,
-0.0278901979,
0.0630561858,
-0.0248899311,
-0.0422212854,
0.0072663212,
0.0026635935,
-0.0353741683,
0.0262096785,
0.0138520664,
-0.0098248888,
-0.0538420305,
-0.0090824766,
0.0485577472,
-0.0319620669,
-0.0139338523,
0.0216737781,
0.0068186135,
-0.0243139062,
-0.0024609743,
-0.0327306017,
-0.0186536014,
0.0389957316,
-0.0332374424,
-0.0179628246,
-0.021771444,
-0.0518137328,
0.0095617613,
0.0490725525,
-0.0405472703,
-0.0137767764,
-0.0076808878,
-0.0379957631,
-0.0449026898,
-0.0151318163,
-0.0008699032,
-0.0195024665,
0.0036172278,
0.0001082667,
0.0413307957,
-0.022569377,
-0.0661606789,
0.0171764493,
-0.052802626,
-0.0016359492,
0.0057087769,
-0.0048441919,
0.0257417038,
-0.0364519283,
-0.0241962858,
-0.0077716648,
-0.0450821891,
-0.0055805445,
-0.0020095545,
0.0231749322,
-0.0229766518,
-0.0405796915,
-0.046696797,
-0.0211029537,
-0.003520221,
-0.0402471907,
0.0209962055,
0.0045135962,
-0.0070029232,
-0.0738633499,
-0.0495202914,
0.0201461036,
-0.0127012627,
0.0229702722,
0.0584375821,
0.0632251129,
0.026274452,
-0.0126736434,
-0.0183113534,
0.0027210824,
-0.0132368505,
0.0039337897,
0.0418071598,
0.0039574741,
-0.0086076204,
-0.057291273,
0.0268457048,
-0.0087369522,
-0.0432701074,
0.0221285913,
-0.0109596774,
-0.0344989039,
0.080930233,
-0.0146771315,
-0.018607771,
0.0489525832,
0.0045068944,
-0.0314037763,
0.032003127,
-0.0537034385,
-0.0749912187,
0.0210166797,
-0.0082081603,
-0.0428716391,
0.0068472726,
-0.0276980978,
-0.0146938944,
-0.0049301721,
-0.0211089924,
-0.0167951025,
0.0060761604,
-0.0503299497,
0.0664026663,
-0.0335221477,
0.0145998467,
-0.0176242236,
-0.0536707528,
0.0561774038,
0.079716906,
0.0539619587,
0.0013092784,
-0.0228100065,
-0.0188868772,
0.0400620066,
0.0046021738,
0.0263495091,
0.0183061175,
-0.0503484793,
-0.121137239,
0.0183243323,
0.0096839359,
-0.0409842283,
0.075946629,
-0.0448849387,
-0.014015764,
-0.0337932818,
-0.0616095029,
-0.0765926763,
0.0106357643,
0.0466466099,
0.010254832,
-0.0308607202,
-0.0022822085,
-0.0105757704,
-0.034115199,
0.0424235538,
0.0633357838,
-0.0134599358,
0.0114871357,
-0.0252592787,
0.0457645394,
0.0304079521,
0.1077919155,
-0.0428912193,
-0.0131219095,
0.0284282696,
0.0491731949,
0.0778532401,
-0.0124205276,
-0.0348183736,
-0.0118791275,
-0.0068410058,
0.0293882824,
0.0463450924,
0.0191653688,
0.0162398033,
-0.0463475809,
-0.0170854367,
0.0311034638,
0.0236898568,
-0.0502391271,
-0.0111946044,
0.0184968226,
0.0128010046,
0.0422443114,
0.0224774592,
-0.0770394057,
-0.0066213254,
0.0097046383,
0.0373675227,
0.0607670881,
-0.0018024733,
0.0254603904,
-0.0190240052,
0.0255493559,
-0.0106366295,
-0.0099283727,
-0.0345578454,
0.0241251718,
-0.0068486342,
-0.0343167149,
0.0030198949,
-0.0129732778,
-0.0276418403,
-0.0020284341,
0.039936211,
-0.044794213,
-0.0499702655,
-0.0074368943,
0.0016314933,
-0.0226279031,
0.0754347444,
0.0030153019,
-0.0442514122,
-0.0473437086,
0.065664649,
0.014472954,
-0.0148322899,
0.0243070479,
0.0597112179,
0.0371153019,
-0.0355162248,
0.0163321923,
0.0471692793,
-0.0095127057,
-0.026324138,
0.0093322759,
0.0081131691,
-0.0049385768,
0.0316665582,
-0.0473683923,
-0.0322520509,
0.009001716,
-0.0026361654,
-0.0126545373,
0.0001959945,
-0.045452375,
-0.0017982415,
0.0294376798,
0.020340072,
0.0297720749,
0.0358869024,
-0.0057270145,
-0.0067434646,
-0.0366266556,
0.0388389118,
0.0216643307,
0.019490378,
0.0064095529,
-0.0350640453,
0.0079573691,
0.0317111015,
-0.0957059339,
0.0021772932,
-0.018166462,
-0.0107241403,
-0.0238100141,
-0.0097537553,
0.0594442859,
-0.00384687,
-0.0128320856,
-0.0297150407,
-0.0603088103,
-0.0188029148,
0.0292853694,
0.0898920447,
0.0152211366,
0.0555892177,
-0.0137172407,
-0.012263271,
0.087999329,
0.0361942686,
-0.0123558119,
0.0154854441,
0.0157686025,
-0.0015303466,
-0.0035223302,
0.0121683627,
-0.0278313272,
-0.0276265219,
0.0141603723,
0.0121805277,
-0.0238451716,
0.0207792781,
0.0276994351,
-0.007248912,
0.0111477012,
0.0165402703,
0.0304244533,
-0.0147809731,
0.0639015585,
0.0518618338,
0.0061738607,
-0.0272385236,
0.0374624431,
0.0329091698,
0.0096324151,
0.0520196185,
0.0026953772,
0.0471787155,
-0.0063483766,
-0.0484313481,
-0.0324800573,
0.0287617613,
-0.0241283532,
0.0187347438,
0.0471702702,
-0.015106474,
0.0394655764,
0.0011056564,
0.0484916605,
0.0186189469,
0.0585735328,
0.0475328341,
0.0369470268,
-0.0209307019,
0.0583063215,
-0.0601384602,
-0.1259425282,
-0.0305475779,
-0.0091631794,
0.034278892,
0.0308778621,
-0.0376605056,
0.0163494535,
0.0058058272,
-0.0051567541,
0.019221019,
-0.0245797932,
0.022958694,
0.0266131945,
0.0302010197,
0.0438230075,
0.0272052325,
0.1113850847,
-0.0392542183,
0.0423696712,
-0.0400052853,
0.0204212591,
-0.0469453931,
-0.0262493882,
0.0448157154,
0.0185084194,
0.016622765,
0.0264936015,
-0.0026558065,
-0.0416319072,
0.0172818974,
0.0038469427,
-0.0171488952,
-0.0486995429,
0.0823814273,
0.0023499173,
0.0012045921,
-0.0225833301,
-0.0037950787,
-0.0019600168,
0.0567539297,
-0.0047493824,
0.0195762273,
-6.507386116e-33,
0.0064497134,
0.0000904313,
0.0317905992,
-0.055424083,
-0.0378189385,
0.0412809327,
-0.0371596515,
-0.0089405384,
-0.0247859191,
0.0169312973,
-0.0054095523,
0.0441608317,
-0.0112969391,
0.0497734845,
0.0510011092,
-0.0991736054,
0.0361558944,
0.0028412784,
0.0022664277,
0.0626851395,
-0.0014270382,
0.0456178859,
0.0158931799,
-0.0632734969,
-0.0191038363,
0.035707172,
0.028245464,
0.0328837968,
-0.0286282506,
0.0087127183,
-0.0323790535,
0.0190846305,
0.0184156299,
-0.0212009307,
-0.034818273,
-0.0523600243,
-0.0844977498,
-0.0353689119,
-0.0718333349,
-0.0104445685,
-0.0859540179,
-0.0095948158,
0.0588620193,
-0.0080182264,
0.0195351783,
-0.0390294082,
0.0217102319,
0.0086414237,
-0.0238974132,
-0.0227592606,
0.0285775829,
-0.0160178877,
-0.0335687138,
-0.0625152364,
-0.0208854042,
-0.0000104011,
0.0046392335,
0.00009256,
-0.0803047344,
-0.0482296422,
0.036956396,
0.0242774785,
0.041026935,
0.0041063502,
-0.0089420583,
0.0324700177,
0.0543699376,
-0.0190137234,
0.0070908591,
0.0027322664,
-0.0152626066,
0.0154516567,
0.0514634512,
-0.0036067986,
0.0620096698,
-0.0183604583,
-0.055996038,
-0.0146209383,
-0.0888595209,
0.1260042787,
-0.0179487355,
-0.01725295,
0.0316897593,
-0.0229644496,
-0.0198500268,
-0.009963708,
-0.0085031241,
0.032542862,
0.0326179825,
0.0211667977,
-0.0055828053,
0.0288237482,
-0.0013165958,
-0.0318770073,
0.0474923924,
0.0051256968,
0.0316067822,
0.0296623986,
0.0234967601,
0.0098945005,
-0.0389693454,
0.0256215408,
-0.0067805527,
-0.0143060246,
0.0193604957,
0.0508366972,
0.0029449447,
0.0427002721,
-0.023938898,
-0.0066023152,
-0.0113962339,
-0.0121421823,
0.0214785822,
0.0541221611,
0.0531634539,
0.0136659378,
-0.0173671599,
0.0148133561,
0.0025653113,
0.0128838858,
-0.0443907082,
-0.022329418,
0.017278146,
0.010083871,
0.0004708727,
-0.0220119543,
-0.0333583467,
0.0194438454,
-0.0234941896,
-0.0810996369,
0.0111905783,
0.0078479722,
3.16e-7,
0.0059671556,
-0.0313138925,
0.0353025161,
-0.0592396557,
0.0368075781,
0.0034979142,
-0.0052138506,
0.0228808485,
-0.0134042529,
-0.035758812,
0.0060087121,
0.0382180661,
-0.0068415231,
0.0091478853,
-0.0399018191,
-0.0009426919,
-0.0297726505,
-0.0268824287,
-0.0173534919,
-0.0528900735,
0.0289244484,
0.0306314807,
-0.0386434346,
-0.0180769674,
0.03752793,
-0.0144126257,
0.0338207781,
0.0074115517,
0.0729388669,
-0.0058474001,
0.0106104566,
0.0280573554,
-0.0217651092,
0.0255884156,
-0.0168422274,
-0.0371645652,
0.0146037554,
0.039670933,
-0.0401806086,
-0.0448916741,
-0.0192127675,
0.0540140085,
0.0234151632,
-0.0188223515,
0.0716542006,
-0.0888012499,
0.0099363374,
0.0234856326,
-0.0161127169,
-0.0110573526,
0.098965399,
0.0212203916,
-0.0124421204,
0.0247694347,
0.005312311,
0.0349921547,
-0.0536619686,
-0.0973875672,
-0.0216618609,
0.0045082248,
-0.0418897346,
-0.0107411481,
0.0110313846,
-0.0590626933,
-0.0049275779,
-0.0277597066,
-0.0172319021,
2.388431411e-34,
0.000189654,
-0.0067154537,
0.0111499382,
0.0716191605,
-0.0261957999,
-0.0140287569,
-0.0140720233,
0.0122970175,
0.0326916389,
-0.0057644011,
-0.0241426881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12996v1 | Extracting Molecular Properties from Natural Language with Multimodal Contrastive Learning | 2023-07-22T10:32:58 | 2023-07-22T10:32:58 | Romain Lacombe, Andrew Gaut, Jeff He, David Lüdeke, Kateryna Pistunova | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, q-bio.QM | Deep learning in computational biochemistry has traditionally focused on
molecular graphs neural representations; however, recent advances in language
models highlight how much scientific knowledge is encoded in text. To bridge
these two modalities, we investigate how molecular property information can be
transferred from natural language to graph representations. We study property
prediction performance gains after using contrastive learning to align neural
graph representations with representations of textual descriptions of their
characteristics. We implement neural relevance scoring strategies to improve
text retrieval, introduce a novel chemically-valid molecular graph augmentation
strategy inspired by organic reactions, and demonstrate improved performance on
downstream MoleculeNet property classification tasks. We achieve a +4.26% AUROC
gain versus models pre-trained on the graph modality alone, and a +1.54% gain
compared to recently proposed molecular graph/text contrastively trained MoMu
model (Su et al. 2022). | [
0.025950104,
0.0838793218,
0.0207916666,
-0.0009786014,
-0.0221080072,
-0.0012810976,
-0.0040163575,
0.0191178694,
0.0431544371,
-0.007605603,
-0.0289666913,
-0.0512408577,
-0.0091301398,
0.0474975891,
0.0539325438,
-0.0142537709,
0.0199212879,
0.0255942903,
0.0000375704,
-0.0246289689,
0.0157101471,
0.0243471824,
0.0139568038,
-0.0081248218,
0.0030265155,
-0.0159191377,
0.0055965157,
0.0180357546,
0.0312210936,
-0.0635339618,
-0.0128874332,
0.029058123,
0.0305125546,
0.0083445758,
0.0000015422,
-0.0506284945,
-0.0191261973,
0.0290935915,
-0.007910748,
0.0044137654,
0.114963077,
-0.0344705544,
0.0386717059,
-0.0024918208,
-0.0320175067,
-0.0207019616,
0.0843666792,
0.0428093486,
-0.0061372044,
0.0510348864,
-0.0122954017,
-0.0393890329,
0.0475507937,
-0.0006499202,
0.0636162981,
0.0042711128,
0.0432728566,
0.0104258284,
0.0188228469,
0.0128999837,
-0.0395980813,
0.0393271707,
0.0028748058,
-0.029764384,
0.0319904238,
0.0429919958,
-0.0052864547,
0.0144283362,
0.0160378851,
0.1059373766,
0.017767936,
-0.0107276086,
-0.0464293435,
-0.0064604138,
-0.0161436386,
0.0343733914,
-0.0487275869,
-0.0208859928,
0.0075674956,
0.0234363601,
-0.0192520171,
-0.0128377052,
0.0548830852,
-0.0071358816,
0.0115522519,
0.0304081757,
-0.0074381856,
-0.0005006667,
0.0246791616,
-0.0077038053,
-0.0433130413,
0.0082297362,
0.0131127294,
-0.0028608439,
0.0275692698,
0.0016714773,
0.0321770683,
-0.0434064046,
0.0442857109,
-0.0434949435,
0.0408810899,
-0.0060629593,
-0.0663906857,
0.0022676142,
-0.0264308117,
0.0113027869,
-0.0548918918,
0.0461487398,
-0.0185853131,
-0.0025526567,
-0.0928582475,
-0.0075278198,
-0.0016608977,
0.0426261052,
0.0011432932,
-0.0141309779,
-0.0428674482,
0.0155901173,
-0.0019896943,
-0.0420973748,
0.0231355447,
0.0767629668,
-0.045294866,
0.0264359638,
-0.0353132784,
0.0450688601,
0.0168898162,
0.0003151182,
-0.0211376343,
-0.0500765033,
-0.0336604789,
0.0144735314,
0.0488891304,
-0.0461529531,
0.0387407765,
0.1044753492,
0.0088289808,
-0.0417361371,
0.0099576637,
-0.0430882573,
-0.0397903509,
-0.0237817578,
0.0355353728,
-0.0640495121,
0.0462916344,
0.029756967,
-0.0087823626,
-0.0810308084,
0.0109982369,
0.0011664764,
-0.0348786116,
0.0909620374,
-0.030550627,
-0.0898844972,
0.0116518633,
-0.012831863,
-0.0399403274,
-0.0241465569,
0.0151341176,
-0.0102395434,
0.0029221557,
0.011939018,
-0.0351902768,
-0.0262057483,
0.0192157831,
-0.0432923287,
0.0046368525,
-0.0027235968,
-0.0030790654,
0.0371834524,
-0.0035638167,
0.0286174249,
-0.0123016508,
-0.0425048843,
0.0481506623,
0.0481786765,
0.0370584577,
0.0100087123,
-0.0000142044,
0.0461653918,
-0.0262813903,
0.0000282761,
-0.0410593227,
0.050720837,
-0.004974063,
0.0443108156,
0.0495628342,
0.0048578987,
0.0111275036,
-0.0191698521,
0.0135894585,
-0.0101345237,
0.0607983656,
-0.0507298112,
0.058695551,
-0.0208762176,
-0.0736471862,
-0.0134038413,
0.055343017,
-0.019057652,
0.033132121,
0.0210913513,
-0.0518845432,
0.0673671514,
0.0159391426,
-0.0509883352,
-0.0017389335,
0.00033403,
-0.0490083732,
0.0122547792,
0.0104874466,
-0.0082041491,
0.0342242047,
-0.0222871341,
-0.0139493747,
-0.0806211159,
-0.0183975007,
-0.0194040351,
-0.0352295116,
0.0096090306,
0.0081698112,
-0.0702985376,
-0.0300357901,
0.0066459044,
0.0453294888,
-0.0264704581,
-0.0025975953,
-0.0143167339,
-0.0079538226,
0.0110985767,
-0.0110504488,
0.0345551111,
0.0138364853,
-0.0491703264,
-0.0232192352,
-0.0399842449,
0.0059986399,
-0.0675524548,
0.0537465401,
-0.0225857273,
0.0178548526,
0.0406837352,
-0.0354664512,
-0.031653583,
0.0770544335,
-0.0305516329,
0.0156831983,
0.0054776021,
-0.0443561897,
0.0089605805,
0.0597535856,
-0.0107257338,
0.0466554426,
0.0094856098,
-0.0033088615,
-0.0158841368,
0.0179372784,
0.0265387148,
-0.0293228701,
0.0125381788,
-0.0192418359,
0.0409511179,
0.0166270863,
0.0522019565,
-0.0324230529,
-0.0059375684,
0.0551585741,
-0.0346308686,
-0.0280019734,
-0.003892496,
0.043009989,
-0.0006563464,
-0.011851741,
0.0433118045,
-0.0115522109,
-0.0310184937,
-0.0171480607,
-0.0544764623,
0.0092040496,
0.0602031425,
-0.0005095839,
-0.0267882552,
-0.065849416,
-0.0573639795,
-0.056374263,
0.0840717182,
-0.0050374041,
-0.0502228178,
0.0535773896,
0.0096559003,
-0.0232641455,
0.0317848623,
0.0182076003,
-0.0054392661,
0.0171405822,
-0.0150462855,
-0.0187562462,
0.0512608029,
-0.0184269417,
0.023551181,
0.0543198399,
0.0215593446,
-0.018393198,
-0.0132842353,
-0.0669732764,
0.028744705,
0.0134843532,
-0.0334374383,
-0.0086129438,
0.0167436916,
0.0168415122,
-0.0034082462,
-0.0233245846,
-0.0039461395,
0.010051569,
-0.0154106393,
-0.0096940501,
0.0197712183,
-0.0022710403,
-0.0114720641,
-0.0123073868,
-0.047022149,
0.091739729,
-0.0009286377,
0.0149725964,
-0.0235680491,
-0.016776599,
-0.0050399047,
0.0520619452,
0.0515324213,
0.0281295963,
0.001719959,
-0.0136907212,
-0.0120890085,
-0.026146017,
0.0448047556,
-0.0320656635,
0.0159719512,
-0.0193955712,
0.0114487372,
0.0179625824,
-0.0308136865,
0.0272508133,
0.0141593749,
-0.0340312719,
0.06348598,
0.0427519754,
-0.0594361648,
0.0015355038,
-0.0057815337,
0.025598662,
-0.002226104,
-0.0295454282,
0.0015110286,
-0.0333207473,
0.0383944623,
0.0280990973,
-0.0588760599,
0.0012438312,
-0.0259817895,
0.0182958432,
0.047251638,
-0.0253957827,
-0.0171319097,
-0.0327190943,
0.0306095351,
-0.0122697363,
0.0130751301,
-0.0269781258,
-0.0135030197,
-0.0221166778,
-0.0511848181,
-0.0196223091,
0.04494524,
0.0133224512,
-0.0314844176,
0.0105064223,
0.0029529554,
-0.0157886185,
-0.0147061152,
0.0332684033,
-0.0974910632,
-0.0398487486,
-0.0706589893,
0.0305255521,
0.022805864,
-0.0308532901,
-0.0065948539,
-0.0341699906,
0.0103864279,
0.0139438082,
-0.0621513873,
-0.0377653018,
-0.0752876922,
-0.0227379315,
-0.0460976921,
0.0029369539,
-0.0150873661,
0.0071196458,
-0.0119561087,
0.0382659324,
0.0095495563,
-0.0383740701,
0.0062861862,
-0.0152986161,
-0.0486743934,
0.0463539734,
0.0209707171,
-0.0069008553,
-0.0264697038,
0.0115920017,
0.0270016883,
0.0290044304,
-0.0035807015,
0.0995444655,
0.0236098412,
-0.0033478206,
-0.0476077721,
0.0117920218,
-0.03212668,
-0.0616871193,
-0.1010408401,
0.0796894282,
-0.0080739111,
-0.0231292844,
-0.0457146764,
0.0053636916,
-0.0218229219,
0.0081958491,
0.0041692718,
-0.0223188438,
-0.0665273517,
-0.0338285901,
0.05188464,
-0.0721748397,
-0.0156889297,
-0.0093340511,
-0.019326847,
0.0102188149,
-0.03505411,
-0.014387222,
-0.0200919323,
-0.0301768873,
-0.0391946696,
0.0084851375,
0.0229454525,
-0.0524393432,
-0.1036408916,
0.0749335364,
0.0187725592,
-0.0046324786,
-0.0193929169,
-0.0502248518,
0.0536803715,
-0.0221740566,
-0.0370284766,
0.0255638119,
-0.0216162447,
-0.0847238451,
-0.0439099371,
0.0003527515,
0.0097563425,
0.0332907215,
0.0307038054,
-0.0677818954,
0.0437828377,
0.0549759939,
0.0109768463,
-0.0447239652,
0.0044883299,
-0.0434510447,
-0.014451568,
-0.0060018413,
-0.0328359008,
0.0047411905,
0.0038563462,
0.0264142752,
0.0320774987,
-0.0239401087,
0.0611177646,
0.0303236768,
0.0564101674,
0.035184335,
0.0197817776,
-0.034218628,
-0.0210141223,
0.038053114,
0.0025252106,
-0.0118864421,
-0.019716762,
0.0235584266,
0.0150662074,
-0.0338363014,
-0.008415008,
0.0085154288,
0.0227640774,
0.0003319029,
-0.0121146459,
0.0137308361,
-0.0256526582,
0.0497197285,
-0.0114740143,
0.0034824796,
0.0230317507,
-0.0261907764,
0.0104969526,
-0.0221115034,
-0.0254900455,
0.0171300042,
0.0359975994,
-0.0623970293,
-0.0022700841,
-0.0280083623,
0.0066967374,
-0.0573543496,
-0.0195487477,
0.0335796438,
0.0032168401,
0.0286641233,
-0.030054694,
-0.0228527803,
-0.0224896669,
0.000073991,
-0.0023523825,
-0.0031708635,
0.0721819475,
0.0336920507,
-0.0058044484,
-0.0028511467,
0.0660505295,
0.0281824861,
0.0536403395,
-0.0281985011,
-0.0540875159,
-0.0142844319,
0.0093604308,
-0.0207510311,
0.0362761877,
-0.0058469595,
0.0082213944,
-0.0299465042,
-0.0749758556,
0.0808766112,
0.0307760164,
0.0068799597,
0.0217922647,
0.0529720746,
0.0117152873,
0.0372917391,
-0.0782104805,
-0.0058552688,
0.0287874397,
0.0181580577,
-0.0028570325,
-0.0219047852,
-5.893485661e-33,
0.0266240761,
-0.0392486788,
-0.0132882968,
0.0224001296,
0.0126206968,
0.0138392933,
-0.0733589828,
-0.0147574395,
-0.0238746181,
0.1135235652,
0.0191329066,
0.025460165,
-0.0057486137,
-0.0027530978,
-0.0271193665,
-0.0105981948,
0.0248187892,
0.0090396423,
0.021275999,
0.0375835747,
0.0671454966,
0.056356702,
0.0894918665,
-0.0582282133,
0.0311029684,
0.0382041745,
0.0343090892,
0.0061731972,
0.0022414827,
0.0474033132,
-0.0323984399,
0.1049956679,
-0.008382882,
-0.029198667,
-0.0248313881,
0.0091976114,
-0.0509017184,
-0.0201863777,
-0.0024136433,
-0.0058581759,
-0.0587824546,
-0.0309029259,
0.0426050834,
-0.0021951708,
-0.0164016783,
-0.0303944461,
0.0612610057,
0.01006342,
-0.0190307759,
-0.0244537778,
-0.045813635,
0.0340916142,
0.0109626763,
0.0255861115,
0.0235970654,
-0.0088363439,
0.0124905519,
0.0566101298,
-0.0450745672,
0.0236348566,
-0.0472398028,
0.0245704949,
0.0204225052,
0.0306187011,
0.0084080705,
0.0581687279,
0.0076475688,
0.0154822851,
0.0081866421,
-0.0100757945,
0.0062703546,
0.0505334958,
0.0434608683,
0.0348081514,
0.0320287496,
-0.0052733775,
-0.1133925542,
-0.0065335515,
-0.0487176552,
0.0285406206,
-0.0069537205,
0.0382760353,
0.0102993585,
-0.0456429385,
-0.0153776053,
-0.0012589,
-0.0307147447,
-0.0377363563,
-0.0354967862,
-0.0776797235,
-0.0227400679,
0.0294342805,
0.0023847618,
-0.0489471704,
-0.0566696413,
0.0741853043,
-0.0045857783,
0.0496866889,
-0.0122901518,
-0.0040645623,
-0.0304858722,
-0.0271774884,
0.0081210611,
-0.0343364589,
0.0325255804,
-0.022177903,
0.0227871165,
0.0462851934,
-0.0052931579,
-0.0164628606,
-0.0473309383,
-0.0275079198,
0.0413322933,
0.0067468295,
0.0302260239,
0.0396608114,
-0.0001595537,
0.0921746492,
0.0581218936,
0.0270192232,
0.006414169,
0.023216622,
0.0188777018,
0.0253971312,
-0.0725248083,
0.0027271498,
-0.0337006114,
0.0254717469,
0.006867663,
-0.0906298533,
-0.0429127775,
0.0187293608,
2.604e-7,
0.1264546961,
0.0252148286,
0.0520207323,
0.0047481786,
-0.0167180467,
0.029288074,
0.0165466964,
0.0274778605,
-0.0477640517,
-0.0410220176,
0.0183675159,
0.0269669928,
-0.0116873449,
0.0131743159,
-0.012324376,
0.0410048366,
-0.0675213933,
-0.0341107287,
-0.0222187545,
0.0381356627,
0.0414266698,
0.065508306,
0.003070655,
-0.0204115901,
0.0194302909,
-0.055983942,
0.0628914014,
-0.0008687613,
0.0205222387,
0.022089567,
-0.0151331313,
-0.0399765037,
-0.0087987734,
0.0362483375,
-0.0187839251,
-0.0058493358,
0.0222536717,
-0.0062108124,
-0.0449023545,
-0.0462582298,
0.0264186859,
-0.0200633891,
0.0228072088,
0.0065561468,
0.014138218,
-0.0529749282,
-0.0620525591,
-0.0188790802,
-0.0458333753,
0.0021774839,
0.041738797,
0.0013643061,
-0.0048753996,
0.0243111085,
-0.0102248769,
0.0139375031,
-0.0249962974,
-0.0676770434,
-0.0298135299,
0.0608791597,
0.0026577071,
0.0070553124,
-0.0072182165,
0.0200659893,
0.0146895926,
-0.0005999574,
-0.0072868657,
1.98524741e-34,
0.0679196119,
-0.0038647496,
-0.0030193396,
0.0041067041,
0.042060215,
-0.0065524988,
-0.0097404858,
-0.0155789796,
0.0107586626,
-0.0970759019,
-0.0368405022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00065v1 | FinPT: Financial Risk Prediction with Profile Tuning on Pretrained Foundation Models | 2023-07-22T09:27:05 | 2023-07-22T09:27:05 | Yuwei Yin, Yazheng Yang, Jian Yang, Qi Liu | q-fin.RM | q-fin.RM, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.ST | Financial risk prediction plays a crucial role in the financial sector.
Machine learning methods have been widely applied for automatically detecting
potential risks and thus saving the cost of labor. However, the development in
this field is lagging behind in recent years by the following two facts: 1) the
algorithms used are somewhat outdated, especially in the context of the fast
advance of generative AI and large language models (LLMs); 2) the lack of a
unified and open-sourced financial benchmark has impeded the related research
for years. To tackle these issues, we propose FinPT and FinBench: the former is
a novel approach for financial risk prediction that conduct Profile Tuning on
large pretrained foundation models, and the latter is a set of high-quality
datasets on financial risks such as default, fraud, and churn. In FinPT, we
fill the financial tabular data into the pre-defined instruction template,
obtain natural-language customer profiles by prompting LLMs, and fine-tune
large foundation models with the profile text to make predictions. We
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed FinPT by experimenting with a
range of representative strong baselines on FinBench. The analytical studies
further deepen the understanding of LLMs for financial risk prediction. | [
-0.0112840887,
0.0649250299,
-0.022486547,
-0.0275815967,
0.020356331,
0.0013495425,
0.0170144625,
0.0434167385,
0.005435694,
-0.0031599759,
-0.0197978355,
-0.0587576069,
-0.02656384,
0.0756305382,
0.04627119,
-0.020076327,
0.0066267769,
-0.0220144801,
0.0225904416,
-0.0008359171,
0.0437562801,
-0.0066037509,
-0.0056473645,
0.0250353068,
-0.0350398049,
-0.0116609829,
-0.0264441911,
0.0127540706,
0.0266411584,
0.0031291498,
0.0420558043,
0.0228560455,
0.012955917,
0.0144490488,
0.0000021234,
-0.042706497,
-0.0504510999,
0.000418572,
-0.0119343325,
0.0101456707,
0.0079474756,
-0.0087179299,
0.0189314019,
0.0300471317,
-0.0716264397,
0.0080750799,
0.0356910005,
0.071914807,
0.0599441193,
0.0605312213,
-0.0139178857,
-0.0843352973,
0.0031073634,
-0.0792866051,
0.0034702837,
-0.0496763736,
0.030215675,
0.0178609956,
-0.0739609897,
-0.0622680038,
-0.0459157974,
0.0112166936,
0.0081101134,
-0.001284965,
0.040936023,
0.0325380862,
-0.0464713126,
-0.000298438,
-0.0397248827,
0.0732177645,
-0.0287536141,
0.0372493826,
-0.0016796681,
-0.0492269769,
0.0107111894,
0.0054887929,
0.0077482169,
0.0157303493,
-0.0139267314,
0.00866271,
0.0204908121,
0.0082260137,
0.0206911191,
-0.0173602626,
-0.0256958101,
0.0371620134,
-0.0112713203,
-0.0062646153,
0.0580827855,
0.0019155672,
0.0057310085,
-0.0279228725,
0.0139936954,
0.0094124097,
-0.0021052621,
0.0075748488,
-0.0019703151,
-0.033616893,
0.0233084131,
-0.0519725531,
0.0471560732,
0.0333673283,
-0.0019430142,
0.0433326401,
-0.0543780141,
0.0357852057,
0.0484536327,
-0.0332262367,
-0.0139331538,
0.0499151051,
-0.0635397732,
0.0116087319,
-0.0447852537,
0.0539469868,
-0.0363835804,
-0.0108356988,
-0.0690036342,
-0.0032665292,
0.0078444201,
0.021625014,
0.0032023019,
-0.0225143973,
-0.0315902233,
0.0386426188,
-0.0427682213,
-0.0329855941,
-0.0625509992,
0.0039622542,
-0.0050593498,
-0.0383864157,
0.0253112949,
0.0123363845,
-0.0540119074,
-0.0111469347,
0.0584685542,
0.0755328387,
0.0597324669,
-0.0530086234,
-0.0631758794,
-0.0154503733,
-0.0134287337,
-0.0497799367,
-0.0278127752,
-0.0160484295,
0.0042325957,
-0.018667331,
-0.0136851724,
-0.0168669019,
0.0163132194,
-0.0075385305,
-0.0126905581,
0.0769992396,
0.0256114323,
-0.0030816165,
0.0066276984,
-0.0457063243,
-0.0148469703,
0.0396179147,
0.0065424126,
0.0546108037,
0.0343072452,
-0.0167656746,
0.0088968268,
0.0613525324,
0.0125250937,
-0.0242692959,
0.029233044,
0.0250080638,
0.0094765201,
-0.0100870756,
0.0561204925,
0.0048359637,
-0.0255506057,
-0.028422147,
0.067718938,
0.028622102,
0.061936643,
0.0460553803,
0.0246275477,
0.0136996629,
0.0291366298,
-0.0247943848,
0.007334583,
-0.023427356,
-0.0590237416,
0.0165599827,
-0.0276921336,
0.050942678,
-0.063512288,
-0.0309177861,
0.0070151086,
-0.0132544991,
-0.0068627857,
0.0001166138,
-0.0084244255,
-0.0203888267,
-0.0605501905,
0.0324292481,
0.0610148497,
-0.0172734465,
-0.0315708555,
-0.0414677747,
0.0407623872,
0.0877826214,
0.0293876454,
-0.0172288548,
0.0111188674,
-0.0229626931,
-0.0193968136,
-0.0008595985,
0.0529679656,
0.0014507102,
0.0052697598,
-0.0533960238,
0.0062961262,
0.0348749273,
0.0035357184,
0.0368897095,
-0.0010498069,
-0.0148473484,
0.0002179415,
-0.0100046098,
-0.073655732,
0.0437188558,
-0.0225401297,
-0.0458808541,
0.0285823084,
-0.0091073178,
0.0089533087,
-0.0118242614,
-0.0052885576,
-0.0248195697,
0.0349509828,
-0.0073604286,
-0.0268251989,
-0.0367814377,
-0.0617063232,
0.0133537501,
-0.0122489193,
-0.0376228802,
0.0101490598,
-0.0284755398,
-0.0579344258,
0.0055972775,
-0.0426226594,
-0.0073854192,
-0.0180443712,
-0.0584032871,
0.0078119496,
0.0216435716,
0.037576437,
0.0039487416,
0.0872586817,
-0.0146831954,
-0.0098993387,
-0.0481709503,
-0.0134479683,
-0.0248809475,
-0.0407425091,
0.0306470543,
-0.059550263,
-0.012295817,
0.0449822471,
0.020075798,
0.0248468388,
0.0014989368,
0.0064882091,
-0.0604423732,
0.002066558,
-0.0334035009,
0.016163107,
0.0099123511,
0.0046726097,
-0.0412293412,
-0.0315408446,
-0.0650144666,
-0.0068187937,
-0.0175412893,
-0.0071082464,
0.0413537696,
0.0143061802,
-0.0177880656,
-0.0375966504,
0.002481404,
0.0002302852,
0.0377476774,
0.0330180451,
-0.060836453,
-0.0150736505,
0.015824331,
-0.0080554523,
0.0163636301,
-0.0214174837,
0.0240713488,
-0.025069179,
0.0008513184,
0.0369838998,
0.0578501932,
0.0064536529,
0.0807160288,
-0.0408737473,
0.0407462195,
-0.0166934989,
0.0416035727,
-0.0429601632,
-0.0018226227,
-0.0288532954,
-0.0233565737,
0.0301750265,
0.028457405,
-0.0111636287,
-0.0038952897,
-0.0898279548,
0.0390381999,
0.0147832241,
0.0099562965,
-0.0248456225,
0.0249088258,
-0.0060927016,
0.0190550368,
0.0005502374,
-0.0287916642,
0.0498220213,
0.0238059387,
-0.0015524117,
0.0120676877,
-0.0614824481,
-0.0805966929,
0.0377694704,
-0.0080057122,
0.0007798953,
0.0163811948,
-0.0074657565,
-0.0457341,
-0.0053005619,
0.0691260397,
0.0109014111,
0.0215481613,
-0.0146150049,
0.006238271,
0.0376947187,
-0.0374889299,
-0.0202256851,
-0.1007150114,
0.00333635,
0.0222023502,
0.0317799859,
-0.0315935127,
-0.0445464626,
0.0266983937,
-0.04660834,
-0.0024308572,
-0.0106568169,
-0.0213927217,
0.0122762276,
0.004172089,
0.0666698739,
-0.0375324339,
0.0680841431,
-0.09297584,
0.0594223849,
0.0174246784,
-0.0103557799,
0.0152347591,
-0.0076658051,
0.0297766328,
-0.0333025716,
-0.0375488997,
-0.0141700022,
0.0495274961,
-0.0133318631,
-0.0430535935,
-0.0076385424,
0.0732702091,
-0.004041051,
0.0351388454,
0.0148226572,
0.0211618021,
0.034495201,
-0.0062133558,
0.0423983932,
-0.0598889776,
-0.0271595512,
-0.0159860756,
0.0339351669,
0.0478776246,
-0.0649067089,
0.0067193042,
-0.1121579334,
0.0530096889,
0.0094194831,
-0.0050962321,
-0.0321640931,
-0.0196803883,
-0.0149789825,
-0.065469563,
0.0214991383,
0.0138177192,
-0.0289591569,
0.0114867194,
0.0177697707,
-0.0707838982,
-0.020163957,
0.0112760905,
-0.0301669836,
-0.032466013,
0.0473239347,
-0.0077597662,
-0.0010626294,
0.0026687183,
-0.0300956853,
-0.0159685314,
0.0156918336,
0.0324361436,
0.0983155593,
-0.0111968182,
-0.0100805927,
0.0115096383,
0.0589870214,
-0.0266591702,
0.0505706109,
0.021832915,
-0.0346673056,
-0.0428903699,
-0.0574990213,
0.0221950002,
0.0198561493,
0.0169685837,
0.0673006997,
0.035190776,
-0.0734757856,
-0.0372007787,
-0.0313048698,
-0.0085859857,
-0.0362950712,
0.0030135042,
0.026329888,
-0.0124122435,
-0.0166794695,
-0.0588550493,
-0.0419659764,
0.0122192828,
0.014043984,
0.0210008156,
0.0058721872,
0.0027100861,
-0.0019421332,
-0.0195568576,
0.046045281,
-0.0368624143,
0.03460823,
-0.0694869906,
0.0372857861,
-0.0011304003,
-0.0422048271,
-0.0694617257,
0.0421695821,
-0.0832920671,
-0.0566663109,
0.0034488288,
0.0560103953,
0.0194099788,
0.005827392,
-0.0269601643,
0.0004169408,
0.064141199,
0.0422572419,
-0.0638036057,
-0.0207043216,
0.0240262318,
-0.0738383681,
-0.0251957476,
0.0201744325,
-0.0079259118,
0.0161381289,
-0.0279026385,
0.0065911105,
-0.0463802032,
-0.0078265164,
-0.0302373078,
0.0299511552,
0.0414264761,
0.0040309555,
-0.0322498418,
-0.0350051187,
-0.0197509527,
0.0469218753,
0.0077838055,
0.0052780542,
-0.0208735429,
0.0769101679,
0.0151032088,
-0.0150348293,
-0.0098862769,
-0.0042142756,
-0.0019847283,
-0.020943258,
0.0263949614,
0.0001747658,
0.0349997915,
0.0436070524,
-0.0427364521,
0.0439476483,
0.0198772606,
0.0687252209,
0.0200670063,
0.024569774,
0.0069271675,
0.0325716734,
0.0751291886,
-0.0245717727,
-0.0300663263,
-0.0143607873,
-0.0506601669,
-0.0607602745,
0.0282493755,
0.0130920056,
-0.0083824722,
-0.0088774851,
-0.0611531474,
0.0040278398,
0.0023886019,
0.0190545227,
0.0172893628,
-0.0431653932,
0.0196451023,
-0.0156114558,
-0.0521445684,
-0.0368639342,
0.1087159291,
0.0447589271,
0.0494464897,
-0.0335679203,
-0.0041638804,
-0.0475325622,
-0.0054521407,
0.0458054319,
0.0133300899,
-0.0250838455,
0.0046984502,
-0.1018883288,
-0.0348780937,
0.0572521649,
-0.0155676436,
0.0167712402,
0.0067546675,
0.0325197801,
0.0042464933,
-0.0159745235,
0.0676031709,
-0.0108284038,
-0.0155320484,
-0.0435419641,
-0.0008885204,
-0.0713885576,
-6.205792469e-33,
-0.0146561516,
-0.0156004764,
0.007217919,
0.0330091231,
0.0068332665,
0.0359324813,
0.0028348109,
-0.0363721102,
0.036247842,
0.0064795166,
-0.0059776828,
0.0448873453,
-0.0008023774,
0.0076631587,
-0.0101994546,
-0.0472149402,
0.0115790311,
-0.0366117917,
-0.024037227,
0.0086777816,
-0.0190945417,
0.053267587,
0.0317226648,
-0.0433107615,
-0.022814773,
-0.0113767134,
-0.0472612418,
-0.024091702,
-0.0121297324,
0.053945411,
0.0106913019,
0.0520225354,
0.0177003108,
-0.0652862862,
0.0258270912,
-0.0136681106,
-0.0443551168,
-0.0447268225,
-0.007908728,
0.0199915729,
0.0099374345,
-0.0223118793,
0.0140500981,
-0.0174487196,
-0.031599652,
-0.0131524941,
0.0293277577,
-0.0220045429,
0.0210670903,
-0.0807922557,
-0.0196582843,
0.0275494885,
-0.0004293187,
0.0271311775,
0.0144389803,
0.062739484,
0.0088029662,
0.0021277836,
-0.0070027867,
0.0104683442,
0.0298351906,
-0.0200216155,
-0.01050446,
0.012370632,
-0.0121878413,
0.0605009161,
-0.0014401828,
-0.0213666465,
-0.0042102584,
-0.0091113858,
-0.0062654652,
0.0715725794,
0.0138868578,
0.0301985852,
0.011253736,
-0.0424031541,
-0.0786404833,
0.0611394085,
0.0192693379,
0.0313399062,
0.035137631,
0.0028899373,
-0.0446096584,
-0.0342225693,
-0.0451124571,
-0.0384455249,
0.0120182885,
0.0218253154,
0.0176268332,
0.0138648534,
0.0118980445,
0.0056972913,
0.0037821697,
-0.0209355224,
-0.0503598079,
0.0143995164,
-0.0080468664,
-0.0324668661,
0.0190074015,
0.0149860596,
-0.0223770849,
-0.0436773933,
0.0157376397,
-0.0395358838,
0.0219688397,
-0.0136464611,
0.0778811201,
0.0157506429,
-0.0347799249,
-0.0011763349,
0.0147583392,
0.0604754016,
0.0204033032,
0.0966008231,
0.0205635522,
0.0297617316,
-0.0141772376,
0.0140336985,
0.0266702324,
0.0605856851,
-0.0055515147,
-0.046014186,
0.0143834986,
0.0385737084,
0.0147360321,
0.0310252458,
0.026347775,
0.0170263685,
0.0651570633,
-0.0588615574,
-0.0383059718,
0.0492092632,
2.729e-7,
0.0524876267,
0.0880126432,
-0.0052316929,
0.0033466418,
-0.0064973137,
0.0590290241,
-0.0231774766,
0.0048501147,
-0.0125073977,
0.0022339411,
0.0743627697,
0.0269869678,
0.0723957196,
-0.0236746278,
-0.0784891546,
-0.033550363,
-0.0464995317,
0.026516255,
-0.0916994959,
0.0249293279,
0.0189229902,
0.0914056227,
-0.0088899992,
-0.081033498,
0.0618774444,
-0.018806858,
0.0516062118,
-0.0496013016,
-0.0192047656,
0.0228960142,
0.0276390575,
0.0422033668,
-0.0106495097,
0.0567441732,
-0.0197961964,
0.0209926795,
0.0011701559,
0.0180665199,
0.0153920539,
0.0294486452,
0.0222203843,
0.0311661102,
-0.0113203162,
-0.005964709,
0.02918032,
-0.0729006454,
-0.0124442391,
-0.030443605,
-0.0670791715,
0.0326612704,
0.045256827,
0.0000518028,
-0.0161179416,
0.0278814416,
0.0148732476,
-0.0301558916,
0.0072524464,
-0.0308983643,
-0.0097620152,
0.0539926887,
-0.0219027009,
0.0125254821,
-0.0396765769,
0.0238279328,
0.03292666,
-0.0978991687,
-0.0039560026,
2.721409012e-34,
0.0571905412,
-0.0201803725,
-0.0132548762,
0.0004962208,
0.0603296012,
0.0075863316,
-0.0070784101,
0.0330081321,
-0.0042020348,
-0.0805499777,
0.001354703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11991v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11991v2 | Psy-LLM: Scaling up Global Mental Health Psychological Services with AI-based Large Language Models | 2023-07-22T06:21:41 | 2023-09-01T04:52:38 | Tin Lai, Yukun Shi, Zicong Du, Jiajie Wu, Ken Fu, Yichao Dou, Ziqi Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The demand for psychological counselling has grown significantly in recent
years, particularly with the global outbreak of COVID-19, which has heightened
the need for timely and professional mental health support. Online
psychological counselling has emerged as the predominant mode of providing
services in response to this demand. In this study, we propose the Psy-LLM
framework, an AI-based assistive tool leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs)
for question-answering in psychological consultation settings to ease the
demand for mental health professions. Our framework combines pre-trained LLMs
with real-world professional Q\&A from psychologists and extensively crawled
psychological articles. The Psy-LLM framework serves as a front-end tool for
healthcare professionals, allowing them to provide immediate responses and
mindfulness activities to alleviate patient stress. Additionally, it functions
as a screening tool to identify urgent cases requiring further assistance. We
evaluated the framework using intrinsic metrics, such as perplexity, and
extrinsic evaluation metrics, with human participant assessments of response
helpfulness, fluency, relevance, and logic. The results demonstrate the
effectiveness of the Psy-LLM framework in generating coherent and relevant
answers to psychological questions. This article discusses the potential and
limitations of using large language models to enhance mental health support
through AI technologies. | [
0.0914612189,
0.0336117335,
-0.0255663302,
0.0005212598,
-0.0269594304,
0.0060139997,
0.0065959878,
0.0209093522,
0.0698403642,
-0.0312642492,
-0.0058379788,
-0.0119322604,
-0.0235558525,
0.0301633812,
-0.0022920019,
-0.0614782088,
-0.0111178085,
0.0218496714,
0.0918797404,
0.0140130464,
0.0200175997,
0.0239115935,
-0.0389984697,
0.0496837534,
0.0297163762,
-0.0090644881,
0.0371730402,
0.0114857145,
0.0174973737,
-0.0967749208,
-0.0047382135,
0.0194590185,
-0.0208693277,
-0.0346909277,
0.000002041,
-0.0532910712,
0.0142539218,
0.009465442,
-0.0090896916,
-0.052733399,
0.0237732828,
-0.0468322299,
0.0225527305,
0.050745219,
-0.0523098409,
-0.0131940963,
0.0285809394,
0.0580533072,
0.0790251791,
0.0609879382,
-0.019444555,
-0.0116834715,
0.0317949168,
0.0136582488,
-0.0266934577,
-0.0377127714,
0.0391367748,
-0.0161131807,
0.0476538427,
-0.0248984955,
0.0253851227,
0.0357377082,
-0.0179832894,
-0.002954413,
-0.0011497588,
0.0127286362,
-0.0359041691,
-0.0308207944,
0.022281345,
0.0809939206,
0.049974788,
0.0056168698,
0.0122955851,
-0.0132626127,
0.0084397448,
0.0214406289,
-0.050028909,
0.0130936736,
-0.0100791641,
-0.0158161055,
0.0444940291,
0.0093055312,
0.008465698,
0.0341157801,
0.0388286337,
0.0444347486,
-0.0074154702,
-0.0349745303,
0.0090001877,
-0.0105300918,
-0.0348648652,
-0.063064985,
0.0408694074,
0.0881283209,
-0.0817795321,
0.0140307005,
0.0088903271,
-0.0502367541,
0.0364296399,
-0.0378232412,
0.0271307137,
0.0393321887,
-0.0047612623,
0.0079805478,
0.0453248769,
0.0245164055,
0.0005305029,
0.0409107991,
-0.0481137596,
0.0103365118,
-0.0773238316,
-0.0107552037,
-0.0453416668,
0.0249547996,
0.0186994784,
-0.0280392002,
-0.04660815,
0.0034664811,
-0.0233749542,
-0.0279010031,
0.0035931028,
-0.0100983698,
-0.0078718048,
0.0071026287,
-0.0217381082,
0.0278740097,
-0.0617483892,
0.0191627946,
0.00304272,
-0.059396755,
0.030419061,
0.0243818108,
0.0185054913,
-0.0049366159,
0.0298791993,
0.0105250282,
0.0150838671,
-0.0159427822,
-0.0534757674,
-0.0379568897,
-0.0265021734,
-0.0290123932,
-0.016772192,
-0.0530477427,
0.0211984627,
0.0168883856,
-0.0087531656,
-0.0241773613,
0.0429450274,
0.0260334574,
-0.0551842377,
0.0338659175,
-0.0617869422,
0.0425212234,
0.0448074639,
0.018641077,
0.0130592436,
0.0249505267,
-0.0052175079,
-0.0116314581,
0.0691643804,
-0.0285929032,
0.0179089084,
-0.0199376848,
-0.0092099737,
-0.042321559,
0.0152011644,
0.0379034318,
-0.053312894,
0.0544222333,
-0.0555519834,
0.0456187241,
-0.0051241992,
0.0067851236,
0.0441976264,
0.0905775875,
-0.0284433179,
0.0513773412,
0.0193431806,
0.0285369735,
0.0150682162,
-0.0158726517,
-0.0249892846,
0.0259418227,
-0.0277696196,
-0.0136082238,
0.0243061241,
0.016236281,
-0.0291163325,
-0.0769816563,
-0.0259714071,
0.0005652635,
-0.0098694554,
0.0477732606,
0.0023376215,
-0.0288909264,
0.004242674,
0.0268033464,
0.0246547237,
-0.0248699486,
0.0041332948,
-0.0665072948,
0.0154933725,
0.1066925675,
0.0252825748,
-0.0415027067,
-0.0448463857,
-0.0120979995,
0.0113836797,
0.0614735633,
0.0183967985,
0.0043929704,
-0.002933766,
-0.0209283028,
0.0085037285,
0.0266280174,
-0.0137938466,
-0.0483581126,
0.0113271317,
0.0341561399,
-0.0145447357,
-0.0170274321,
-0.0385178067,
0.0508619398,
-0.0227067564,
-0.0291756075,
-0.0093890466,
-0.0055782511,
0.0358829536,
0.049940709,
-0.0024078845,
0.0666000843,
0.0351029411,
-0.0459886454,
-0.0448843315,
-0.0019214571,
-0.0215870775,
0.0383853428,
0.0351731405,
-0.0120400907,
0.0001169428,
0.0511431508,
-0.0306970216,
-0.0191915091,
0.0117115891,
-0.0473320447,
0.0296864826,
-0.0135994693,
-0.0126830852,
0.0052955993,
0.0159464516,
-0.0353697613,
0.0253761616,
-0.0111736488,
0.0400708616,
-0.0202858448,
-0.028793091,
-0.0179818142,
-0.0263655353,
-0.006103978,
-0.0076360465,
-0.0159698017,
0.0253762454,
0.0128003843,
0.0083026681,
-0.0519934595,
-0.0293791369,
-0.1590726078,
0.0033629863,
-0.0124865342,
0.004868235,
0.0490173474,
-0.0066106222,
-0.020560557,
-0.0194798578,
-0.0585859306,
0.0158792902,
0.0418259874,
0.034069404,
0.0270942114,
0.0447837934,
0.0064645507,
-0.0369206406,
-0.0147316055,
-0.0352388099,
-0.0145919258,
0.0357469693,
-0.0016328814,
-0.0518781729,
-0.0229468234,
-0.0759276152,
-0.0123898052,
0.017121831,
-0.0647453517,
0.0066684149,
-0.0090846615,
0.014188733,
0.0329407156,
0.032088697,
0.0002097106,
0.0214931257,
0.0247780681,
-0.0193429906,
-0.0102104163,
-0.0202826224,
-0.0447453149,
-0.0470843278,
-0.0358205251,
0.0198243782,
0.0173394978,
0.027518807,
-0.0015799234,
-0.0332540981,
0.0305671524,
-0.0318829566,
0.0056725205,
-0.0363664031,
-0.0177260917,
0.0026989002,
0.0436047837,
0.0119485883,
-0.0124401441,
0.0603676066,
0.0187035371,
0.0194293968,
-0.0805170238,
-0.0600496493,
-0.0537079126,
0.0170285404,
-0.0136882225,
0.0445667394,
-0.0036325685,
-0.009878776,
-0.0128373643,
-0.0391909108,
-0.0330871381,
-0.0546639189,
-0.0103206802,
-0.0580735877,
0.0153438412,
0.0358300582,
-0.018356381,
-0.0323853455,
-0.0688034296,
-0.0646444187,
0.0057964828,
0.014448083,
0.009949117,
-0.0268442333,
-0.0208699014,
0.0572395362,
0.027574541,
-0.0006413172,
-0.044163119,
-0.0019374723,
0.0296617188,
0.0547279418,
0.0282730293,
0.0585788488,
0.0092458241,
0.0313225724,
0.0655252635,
-0.0078526381,
0.0051126098,
0.0250180457,
-0.0094436314,
0.0059262598,
-0.0214390848,
-0.0037497592,
0.0406194888,
0.0211403295,
-0.0321681574,
-0.0205519348,
0.1297820061,
0.0418055728,
-0.0648099184,
0.0114335902,
-0.0872697756,
-0.0419820659,
0.0069732056,
0.0219707415,
-0.0058896551,
-0.0051640915,
-0.0409390666,
0.0404254347,
-0.0349026509,
-0.0225321259,
0.0279420186,
-0.0564991236,
0.0405304171,
-0.0388783254,
0.0133597655,
-0.0157971904,
-0.0103094354,
0.0239242408,
0.0254336894,
-0.0218910668,
-0.0196804125,
-0.0133841187,
0.0120322974,
0.0026965272,
-0.0420809612,
-0.0031738002,
0.0480322018,
-0.0236666761,
0.0493251383,
0.0425840318,
0.067559436,
-0.027716253,
-0.0752227008,
-0.0210538413,
0.03812626,
-0.0004612499,
-0.0027349747,
0.0523653924,
0.0305969696,
0.0165763795,
-0.0497876965,
0.0384635627,
-0.0949461833,
-0.011916114,
0.0450572036,
0.0874210522,
-0.0124517838,
-0.024235798,
-0.0257508382,
0.0479746833,
0.0204894599,
0.0609016232,
0.0149165271,
-0.0342628546,
0.0031769827,
0.0144721027,
0.029233994,
0.026656758,
-0.0531224944,
0.023633305,
-0.0021523647,
0.0071053007,
-0.0865301639,
-0.0372069962,
0.0378429741,
-0.0302641485,
-0.0189046599,
-0.0144764576,
0.0372071713,
0.0288839545,
-0.0549928024,
0.0116500985,
-0.0080832709,
0.0481754802,
-0.049399551,
0.011138292,
0.0500671826,
0.0037554062,
-0.0103195664,
0.0056117186,
-0.0121133085,
-0.0003298611,
0.0167958103,
0.0176718049,
0.012689543,
-0.042842444,
-0.0097599011,
-0.0353171639,
-0.0081093153,
0.0204493571,
-0.0824005455,
-0.0085798893,
-0.0130019458,
0.0396099612,
0.011120881,
0.0357357226,
-0.0158569515,
0.0283515733,
0.0209051892,
0.0557686761,
-0.0203942973,
-0.0465968587,
0.0213655755,
0.055770684,
-0.0002462895,
0.0227986667,
-0.0258672722,
0.0153989233,
-0.036450766,
-0.0148723098,
-0.0122873457,
-0.0303158443,
-0.0088630123,
0.0163232796,
-0.0071937018,
-0.0040024137,
-0.0076577449,
-0.0592916496,
-0.0300071314,
-0.0363634899,
0.0209625922,
-0.0288207028,
0.0031297831,
-0.0048487629,
-0.0084670596,
-0.0137364473,
0.0014126,
-0.0012126622,
0.0436182544,
-0.0088778194,
0.0746435449,
-0.0071302685,
-0.0074668988,
0.0232058465,
0.0376634151,
-0.059253227,
-0.1546588689,
-0.0029703181,
-0.0093397796,
0.0471309572,
0.0253134556,
0.0247169975,
-0.0014152024,
-0.0092227329,
-0.0097654387,
-0.0000968359,
0.0040501887,
-0.0273161922,
0.0471693017,
0.0060595432,
-0.0189402681,
-0.0167922042,
0.0591727868,
-0.0512816943,
0.0085105104,
0.0485211536,
-0.0319373831,
-0.0203550421,
-0.023994606,
-0.0167218838,
0.076262556,
-0.0231552348,
0.0383497961,
-0.0410152376,
-0.0531318225,
0.0159394071,
-0.0382060446,
-0.0379872471,
-0.046353016,
0.0161879286,
0.0498717315,
0.0329455361,
-0.0249888971,
-0.0688864887,
0.0548049919,
-0.052514594,
-0.0111837219,
-0.0376038291,
-6.339532135e-33,
0.0153031908,
-0.0745827705,
0.0168807898,
-0.0020920234,
-0.0011094421,
0.0052210344,
-0.0193979256,
0.0236535966,
-0.0321950428,
0.0295412131,
0.0078166462,
0.0580641478,
-0.0068241064,
0.026893599,
0.0063551138,
-0.0214412082,
-0.0028023568,
-0.0168274995,
0.0055205137,
0.0421874709,
-0.0178229921,
0.0249331389,
0.0255318135,
-0.0963551551,
0.0387118496,
-0.0055945204,
0.0262550134,
0.0469658226,
0.0261933133,
0.0470364988,
-0.0172200855,
0.0578242056,
0.0590363555,
0.0035637869,
0.0290416367,
0.0430396385,
-0.0319262855,
-0.0510476418,
0.026830744,
-0.0431054533,
-0.0764933825,
-0.0146925561,
0.0118918195,
-0.0219379626,
0.0227656532,
-0.014846581,
0.0408621579,
-0.0525376946,
0.0327694528,
-0.0312217493,
-0.0299388152,
0.0033603746,
-0.0181381181,
0.0187434833,
-0.0630369335,
0.0561364181,
-0.0598842166,
0.0526520722,
-0.0299765486,
-0.0176792312,
-0.0056943018,
0.0122269886,
-0.0022866696,
-0.0537716039,
-0.0240528211,
0.0234609973,
-0.0219557155,
-0.0201991014,
-0.0420270376,
-0.0045182621,
-0.0165482759,
0.0226971451,
0.0722845271,
0.0328258835,
0.0120866997,
0.0013881325,
-0.068536818,
0.0114090396,
0.0147523088,
0.0577368997,
0.0413457975,
0.0124884043,
-0.0084114745,
0.0052565257,
-0.0399244986,
-0.0011392344,
-0.0542757809,
-0.0277959537,
0.0282523483,
-0.0079100402,
-0.0218365137,
-0.0210709386,
-0.0176501162,
-0.0433083437,
0.0276990626,
0.0084480466,
0.0277558751,
0.0241464693,
0.0307914019,
0.0074843848,
-0.0499841198,
0.0384531356,
-0.020581115,
-0.0034987738,
0.0532133095,
-0.0058609801,
0.0135467108,
-0.0359432958,
-0.0191001073,
-0.0199548528,
0.0169749036,
0.0438518897,
0.0192088298,
0.0060274866,
-0.0231512003,
0.0242528301,
-0.0171101615,
0.0251136851,
0.0359041765,
-0.0013934155,
-0.0488278754,
-0.03317561,
-0.0008067354,
-0.0087968158,
-0.0584831573,
-0.0240695067,
-0.0437886678,
0.0309305638,
0.0071204496,
-0.0551038422,
-0.0215739291,
-0.0206148177,
2.86e-7,
0.0745922998,
0.0685093626,
-0.0198386628,
0.0341946147,
0.0189708825,
0.0060427706,
0.0297425855,
0.0034385256,
0.0319567136,
-0.0153857451,
0.0096840663,
0.0423111543,
0.035367988,
0.0458139144,
-0.0022348124,
-0.0092052231,
-0.0414192379,
-0.012866904,
-0.0418217964,
0.0318648703,
0.1015146002,
0.0394398272,
-0.0101447385,
-0.0178970378,
-0.033546295,
-0.0241050795,
0.0241838694,
-0.0311264154,
0.0156902708,
0.0505110361,
0.042207066,
0.0125651648,
0.0290848818,
0.0370293073,
-0.0067975181,
-0.0024086176,
0.013326549,
0.0583136417,
-0.0475551821,
-0.0119674234,
0.0033652533,
-0.0045993761,
0.0458387136,
-0.0758122429,
0.0522401109,
-0.1026894525,
-0.0670097396,
-0.0375266299,
-0.0591599494,
-0.0397956111,
0.0164330732,
-0.0325801782,
-0.0478603132,
0.0665485114,
0.0270050727,
-0.0075009009,
0.0245510507,
-0.0280107055,
-0.0200279783,
0.0200804882,
-0.0300963931,
-0.0191211142,
-0.0059157624,
-0.0031684029,
-0.0234379712,
-0.0281542595,
0.0591211878,
2.246587125e-34,
0.0171705857,
0.0482104607,
0.0192376003,
0.0247349646,
0.0489104278,
0.0443152972,
-0.0617941581,
0.0087710023,
-0.0057475022,
-0.0958010405,
0.0082550123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11984v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11984v1 | Learning Vision-and-Language Navigation from YouTube Videos | 2023-07-22T05:26:50 | 2023-07-22T05:26:50 | Kunyang Lin, Peihao Chen, Diwei Huang, Thomas H. Li, Mingkui Tan, Chuang Gan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision-and-language navigation (VLN) requires an embodied agent to navigate
in realistic 3D environments using natural language instructions. Existing VLN
methods suffer from training on small-scale environments or unreasonable
path-instruction datasets, limiting the generalization to unseen environments.
There are massive house tour videos on YouTube, providing abundant real
navigation experiences and layout information. However, these videos have not
been explored for VLN before. In this paper, we propose to learn an agent from
these videos by creating a large-scale dataset which comprises reasonable
path-instruction pairs from house tour videos and pre-training the agent on it.
To achieve this, we have to tackle the challenges of automatically constructing
path-instruction pairs and exploiting real layout knowledge from raw and
unlabeled videos. To address these, we first leverage an entropy-based method
to construct the nodes of a path trajectory. Then, we propose an action-aware
generator for generating instructions from unlabeled trajectories. Last, we
devise a trajectory judgment pretext task to encourage the agent to mine the
layout knowledge. Experimental results show that our method achieves
state-of-the-art performance on two popular benchmarks (R2R and REVERIE). Code
is available at https://github.com/JeremyLinky/YouTube-VLN | [
0.0346376486,
0.0365212858,
0.0176811535,
0.023111837,
0.0139261372,
0.0291795805,
-0.024724327,
-0.0404284671,
-0.0032961392,
-0.0613264963,
-0.0346137807,
-0.0004550993,
-0.0091228923,
0.020648744,
0.0234216116,
-0.0842362195,
0.0005300904,
-0.0565886907,
-0.0277143158,
0.0208835956,
-0.0097694332,
0.0114096515,
-0.0354459956,
0.0079509662,
-0.0338442549,
0.0419946276,
-0.053283561,
0.0113328537,
0.0629813522,
-0.0662243217,
-0.0048205056,
0.0124418288,
0.0989688933,
0.0001819946,
0.0000017801,
0.0105905784,
0.0226583704,
-0.0444769301,
0.0336380079,
-0.0407071933,
-0.010618424,
0.0002547671,
-0.0107909078,
0.0243026987,
-0.0368800685,
-0.0181119423,
0.0459145382,
0.0156901628,
0.0447416827,
0.0589452237,
-0.0252246149,
-0.0493420027,
-0.0269017313,
0.0284565873,
0.0802736953,
0.0222197846,
-0.0006193028,
0.0152945817,
-0.0007742502,
-0.0083730686,
-0.0449577384,
0.0066096107,
0.0601125769,
-0.0238019619,
0.0068961643,
0.0563602112,
0.0249203127,
-0.0290809739,
-0.0278968923,
0.1278021932,
-0.0123938704,
0.0041265041,
0.0267330259,
0.0063282149,
-0.0175101832,
-0.0404559709,
-0.0102255605,
0.0393159986,
-0.0068854815,
0.0100601604,
-0.0442735069,
0.0016016592,
0.003955964,
-0.0366201885,
0.0162115879,
0.0052548307,
0.0193065107,
0.0065474417,
-0.008698524,
-0.0016790415,
0.0129931048,
-0.0420109481,
0.0074498588,
0.0263502691,
0.004154955,
0.052016817,
-0.039556738,
0.044782754,
-0.0601186417,
-0.0704478696,
0.0534238331,
0.0213996228,
0.0104495771,
0.0236514322,
-0.0224888902,
0.044790674,
-0.0192602165,
0.0833464712,
-0.0372827016,
0.0297524985,
-0.0432537422,
0.0696157217,
-0.0456525385,
0.0039362013,
-0.0328513682,
-0.0219348799,
0.0101054125,
0.0318974853,
-0.0360069759,
0.0213015769,
-0.0322718285,
0.0597657822,
0.0023640811,
0.0090016024,
-0.0031587107,
-0.0562647991,
-0.0458327197,
0.0177008528,
-0.0155301858,
-0.0125211524,
0.0176152885,
0.025846919,
0.0353351124,
0.0048146271,
0.0215163883,
0.0880152583,
-0.0248151273,
-0.0427035093,
-0.0528042912,
0.0049497951,
0.0020607847,
-0.0362492613,
0.0483685099,
-0.0809932649,
0.0567250326,
-0.0372385271,
-0.0469276123,
-0.0344251506,
0.0326890349,
0.0229960158,
-0.0200123917,
0.0466045737,
0.0188594181,
0.0125568667,
0.0225735568,
0.0072012665,
0.0318151787,
0.0137650911,
0.0630758554,
0.0529680587,
-0.0025518704,
0.0490516983,
0.0138453692,
0.0455242582,
-0.0118880589,
0.0379191525,
0.0033894775,
0.0114637893,
-0.0007354291,
0.0635238141,
0.0294976663,
0.0507495664,
-0.0534487516,
-0.0185902007,
0.0111353984,
0.0122859627,
-0.0502171926,
-0.0058291336,
0.0868443176,
0.009609458,
0.0125790667,
-0.011802813,
-0.039857354,
0.0568875819,
0.0086917337,
-0.007384331,
0.0291964989,
0.0124581754,
-0.0471908636,
-0.0778923556,
0.0284063201,
-0.0047679185,
0.0767455027,
-0.0100774374,
0.0274181645,
0.0224494189,
-0.0740724951,
0.0070904247,
0.0357997008,
-0.0493600406,
0.0139629422,
0.0395133756,
0.0101680094,
0.0768639073,
-0.0048793093,
0.015465457,
-0.0266330075,
-0.0162961576,
0.0148594016,
0.0007805506,
-0.0126358075,
-0.0481365658,
0.0591928363,
-0.0516324043,
-0.0664727017,
0.0090853544,
0.0049154623,
0.0567763373,
0.0352086686,
0.0149331242,
0.0177646447,
-0.0322188102,
-0.0366034955,
0.050139945,
0.0160629507,
-0.0186851285,
0.0102986842,
0.006949448,
0.0098837875,
0.0127261113,
-0.0207443461,
-0.034663897,
0.0310801435,
-0.0226269849,
0.0032957143,
0.0360927656,
-0.0478467047,
-0.0555093288,
0.0352606662,
-0.0883563906,
-0.0416921116,
0.040049918,
-0.0473877192,
-0.0283390656,
0.0091329236,
-0.0147872977,
0.0089340974,
0.0349380597,
-0.0243020765,
0.0703978911,
-0.0454639755,
-0.0210375432,
0.0461644121,
-0.0258731134,
0.0095627112,
0.0195406321,
0.0095785614,
0.0012143988,
-0.0130533231,
0.0406604335,
-0.0207654182,
-0.0033014212,
0.0003622365,
0.0516517647,
0.02391579,
-0.0420312025,
0.0065336926,
-0.0400242433,
-0.0180543605,
-0.0336996838,
-0.0027522037,
0.033993531,
-0.0484391674,
-0.0073576537,
-0.016357094,
-0.0141107794,
0.04617979,
-0.0089126453,
-0.0243211202,
-0.0016103028,
0.0045147203,
-0.0286041461,
-0.0342045575,
0.0036649336,
-0.0217599757,
-0.0125898309,
0.0435752645,
0.0130630881,
-0.0153303528,
0.0349235684,
-0.0270261727,
0.0405289344,
-0.0254328493,
-0.0568593815,
0.009518588,
-0.0513033755,
0.0175771918,
0.0240718666,
-0.0099931844,
0.0149378255,
0.0355375931,
-0.0400130637,
-0.0233294684,
0.0225838795,
-0.0157678854,
-0.0008530978,
-0.0986565128,
-0.0241320431,
0.0042823185,
-0.0159093626,
-0.0092060249,
0.0594509207,
-0.0649567246,
-0.0443900414,
-0.0164536014,
-0.0357134491,
0.0088861603,
0.0643970966,
-0.0273949169,
0.0322451107,
-0.0191936847,
-0.0197307616,
0.0104628056,
-0.0205449704,
-0.033595778,
-0.0068429252,
0.0129630063,
0.0140130995,
0.0702892467,
0.0702942908,
0.0596275814,
-0.003044253,
-0.002323719,
-0.0357848294,
-0.0188168548,
0.0250998624,
0.0328409374,
0.0244106706,
-0.0790015012,
0.0084905801,
0.0009803702,
-0.0197556093,
-0.0422315449,
-0.0174609125,
-0.0074177026,
-0.0354433842,
-0.0332917497,
-0.0578621216,
-0.0211571697,
-0.0169726815,
0.0138528729,
0.0530339926,
0.0209128521,
-0.0300128106,
-0.0223173425,
0.0005478985,
0.0682007968,
0.0140016619,
-0.0345359892,
-0.0411267616,
0.0179012269,
0.0421021022,
0.0336737446,
-0.0271861255,
-0.0345965549,
0.040991351,
0.0250595827,
-0.0015532993,
0.0207699351,
0.0778626576,
0.0289022308,
-0.0251735058,
-0.046504613,
0.0851675943,
0.0361748151,
0.0036387683,
0.0046962667,
0.0238694586,
0.0083186422,
0.0279094782,
0.0153376367,
-0.0547604188,
-0.0292595252,
-0.0191043541,
-0.0014422535,
0.0409122035,
-0.0061088772,
0.008552881,
-0.0906817913,
0.0530018248,
0.0321522988,
-0.031188732,
-0.0383342728,
-0.0340491794,
0.0079719834,
-0.0500158146,
-0.0360797532,
-0.0061806305,
-0.0258048344,
0.0120821297,
-0.0005840633,
-0.0028994288,
-0.0483623743,
0.0267018974,
-0.0326316506,
0.0424447693,
0.0181017462,
0.0431494042,
-0.0140606919,
-0.0347713269,
-0.025335623,
0.0048260549,
0.0026672187,
-0.0219495147,
0.0259086303,
-0.0221076664,
0.0051558889,
0.0247469619,
0.0757832006,
-0.0492489189,
-0.0203999728,
0.0105894972,
0.0064514377,
-0.0458637327,
0.0043720286,
-0.0154773192,
0.0073983353,
0.0318507031,
0.0539477617,
-0.0224293843,
0.0137170423,
-0.0487116538,
-0.0395611525,
-0.043280758,
-0.0277072825,
-0.0607503355,
-0.0204786863,
-0.0206111316,
-0.0297295414,
-0.0882781446,
-0.0512355603,
0.0757832006,
0.0962234885,
-0.0069358028,
-0.0683891773,
0.0264638513,
0.012699835,
-0.0506095178,
-0.0027690304,
-0.0365928449,
0.0119503094,
-0.0409155749,
-0.0234804805,
0.0242360104,
-0.0480855182,
-0.0052595558,
0.0249255076,
0.0043662824,
-0.0678511634,
0.0016260463,
0.077251181,
0.0124594113,
0.0986702144,
-0.0033516011,
0.0652365312,
0.0388906263,
0.0065419683,
0.006460093,
-0.0114613594,
0.0478450023,
0.039768558,
-0.0085055986,
0.0114852097,
-0.0513457581,
0.0066899019,
-0.0081880139,
0.0123513015,
-0.0358934999,
-0.0214483924,
0.0259713307,
-0.0574282072,
0.0717996061,
-0.011251837,
0.0167740881,
-0.0323767886,
0.0016085937,
-0.0164529551,
0.0082659414,
-0.0663233697,
0.0076262974,
0.0338345282,
0.0568647608,
0.0067464639,
0.0320966057,
0.0066741807,
-0.032394141,
-0.033570081,
-0.0350604467,
0.0283649135,
0.0088555915,
-0.0030097228,
-0.0000379227,
0.0424662903,
0.064798139,
-0.0012329347,
0.0388848484,
0.0131602613,
0.0416458733,
0.0341692865,
-0.0102803726,
-0.0258940514,
0.0357180722,
-0.0464175865,
-0.039795842,
-0.0358702429,
0.0383840427,
0.0883766189,
-0.0140974503,
0.0286144149,
-0.0546587296,
0.0227587465,
0.0068460926,
-0.0017092209,
0.0057763793,
-0.0823379681,
0.0524065197,
0.0050967564,
0.0112952422,
-0.0300509781,
0.0722203031,
0.0487772003,
0.0681910664,
0.026970895,
-0.0056951321,
-0.0376424268,
-0.0146584781,
-0.0115598235,
0.02342101,
-0.0105507793,
0.0226602461,
0.0044029974,
-0.0370960683,
-0.057479132,
0.0245749541,
-0.0172053054,
-0.0223790221,
0.0983690843,
-0.0112876119,
-0.013498826,
-0.0043315226,
-0.0203940403,
-0.0643250719,
-0.0421102792,
-0.0298528075,
-0.0424759053,
-5.124356768e-33,
-0.0156563595,
-0.0249851383,
0.0424664468,
0.0172906499,
-0.0060980688,
-0.0351652615,
-0.0447057784,
0.0191023145,
-0.033026997,
0.0446897149,
0.0326472074,
-0.0001584055,
0.0173605848,
0.0505042449,
0.0131414486,
-0.037536677,
0.0459528044,
-0.0232332014,
-0.0499389395,
0.0284756329,
0.0265643913,
-0.0160908327,
0.0283069778,
-0.0660406798,
-0.0448265895,
-0.0430910476,
-0.0192621034,
0.0399234109,
0.0159826558,
0.0252668336,
0.0210705884,
-0.0101954052,
-0.0147614889,
-0.0318199471,
-0.0195703115,
-0.0142937815,
-0.0898528472,
-0.0163050797,
-0.0221288987,
0.0473375842,
-0.1134622544,
-0.0273104496,
0.0254843365,
-0.0216612481,
-0.0328831486,
0.0097970683,
0.0538035035,
0.0003959995,
0.0080245202,
-0.0006670565,
-0.0379391275,
0.003951468,
-0.0279378779,
-0.0947738513,
0.0356900096,
0.015962027,
0.0417870171,
-0.0690968186,
-0.0476159975,
0.0203900374,
-0.0400987901,
0.0094204703,
0.0799291655,
0.0026993221,
0.0468892641,
0.0678156316,
0.0128396824,
-0.0408116654,
-0.0036799456,
0.0082250861,
-0.0091696922,
0.0775391012,
-0.0249710307,
0.0185090043,
0.002342602,
0.0226345044,
-0.0316898786,
0.0590163879,
-0.0409752503,
0.0355435796,
-0.0347687937,
0.0126449494,
-0.01467562,
-0.0005421307,
-0.0305419285,
-0.0161505956,
0.0250253808,
-0.0394222476,
0.0215804633,
0.0332755111,
0.0118141687,
-0.0627834871,
0.055590149,
-0.0069055716,
0.0014793765,
0.0565959327,
-0.0158751961,
0.0243384484,
-0.0008609762,
0.0148822032,
-0.0710827261,
-0.0320786946,
0.0534883104,
-0.0087544285,
-0.0038107669,
0.0141692162,
-0.0275919214,
0.0778594166,
-0.0018447166,
-0.0018004894,
-0.0385496914,
-0.00238522,
0.0065141958,
0.0154691786,
0.0536096618,
0.0067093703,
-0.0426686257,
0.0407051332,
-0.0086741624,
0.0126437265,
0.0033715423,
-0.0061046118,
-0.0234986562,
0.0159482881,
-0.0324631706,
-0.0026158455,
-0.0693965256,
-0.0353352875,
0.0134447729,
-0.0690860003,
0.0121711036,
0.0352697484,
2.59e-7,
-0.0383297019,
0.0102435434,
0.0114809331,
-0.0078204554,
0.0107614128,
0.0671316385,
-0.0064327708,
0.0247221533,
-0.0384134911,
-0.0594143718,
0.0306682922,
0.0584950186,
-0.0084355874,
-0.0165748745,
-0.0617412552,
0.0286521371,
0.0009942172,
-0.0407581665,
-0.0444598235,
-0.0078413347,
0.0565853752,
0.0848907903,
-0.0055273301,
0.0172507148,
0.0380112231,
-0.0188010167,
0.0153954159,
-0.0103168041,
0.0011096235,
-0.0083394162,
0.0014557972,
0.0508004948,
-0.0599477179,
-0.0372117013,
-0.0441892259,
-0.0163862184,
0.0121399369,
0.0525854677,
-0.0239000954,
-0.0218864176,
0.0033735293,
-0.0172439367,
0.0030373686,
0.003551956,
0.0313250013,
-0.027441686,
-0.0015961892,
0.0080282763,
-0.0073671103,
0.0279398821,
-0.0100846486,
0.0272020251,
-0.0272707138,
-0.0314421989,
0.020478664,
-0.0255653672,
-0.0066623995,
-0.090718776,
-0.0131775504,
-0.0173281636,
0.0021827067,
0.029921392,
-0.0105974823,
0.0240778476,
0.0099862041,
-0.0144984042,
-0.0600308292,
1.664944714e-34,
0.0047595492,
-0.0098782564,
-0.0269162487,
-0.0535131507,
0.0371939018,
0.030551387,
-0.0191334467,
0.0013426858,
0.0132832294,
-0.0297987312,
-0.0144440485
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.