id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15936v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15936v2 | A Theory for Emergence of Complex Skills in Language Models | 2023-07-29T09:22:54 | 2023-11-06T00:36:24 | Sanjeev Arora, Anirudh Goyal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | A major driver of AI products today is the fact that new skills emerge in
language models when their parameter set and training corpora are scaled up.
This phenomenon is poorly understood, and a mechanistic explanation via
mathematical analysis of gradient-based training seems difficult. The current
paper takes a different approach, analysing emergence using the famous (and
empirical) Scaling Laws of LLMs and a simple statistical framework.
Contributions include: (a) A statistical framework that relates cross-entropy
loss of LLMs to competence on the basic skills that underlie language tasks.
(b) Mathematical analysis showing that the Scaling Laws imply a strong form of
inductive bias that allows the pre-trained model to learn very efficiently. We
informally call this {\em slingshot generalization} since naively viewed it
appears to give competence levels at skills that violate usual generalization
theory. (c) A key example of slingshot generalization, that competence at
executing tasks involving $k$-tuples of skills emerges essentially at the same
scaling and same rate as competence on the elementary skills themselves. | [
-0.0131272785,
-0.0051995642,
-0.0441376492,
-0.0199052915,
-0.0149184205,
0.0306135416,
-0.0180268735,
0.0086125266,
-0.0093466183,
0.0055720978,
-0.0430326946,
-0.026697021,
0.0081731481,
-0.0216651782,
0.0607505143,
-0.0570092835,
0.0307875257,
-0.0616504699,
-0.0297151022,
-0.0369879194,
-0.0401529856,
-0.0526631176,
-0.0025257342,
0.0268753897,
-0.0008312347,
0.0116603952,
0.0123845618,
-0.03407491,
-0.0296827517,
-0.00403103,
-0.0093039554,
-0.0111264409,
0.0375370532,
-0.0113791469,
0.0000018614,
-0.0552445427,
0.0366276652,
-0.0104632312,
-0.0268018506,
-0.0212287959,
0.0233510621,
-0.0379592627,
-0.014430454,
0.0214688648,
-0.0318124928,
-0.0533006229,
0.027482111,
-0.008986393,
0.0119645866,
0.0760641843,
0.0181622636,
-0.0647470579,
0.0588347055,
-0.0272838883,
0.0128558772,
-0.0502384044,
0.0282101259,
0.0056131873,
-0.0145034138,
-0.0092502162,
-0.0245555434,
0.0036831901,
0.0396954715,
0.0305650942,
-0.0070771533,
0.0453244261,
0.0589458346,
0.0070407125,
0.0010893252,
-0.0023533574,
-0.0514477566,
-0.0422786959,
-0.0213067103,
-0.0132528301,
0.0408119857,
0.0399185494,
-0.0652881637,
0.0308761261,
0.0245954692,
0.0213187728,
0.0397167653,
-0.0468679704,
0.0465137064,
0.0108871004,
0.0191095974,
0.0696955025,
0.0164845977,
-0.0535840429,
0.0269986913,
-0.0004733237,
0.0014814293,
-0.0279103909,
-0.0378139056,
0.0750866383,
0.0080735702,
0.0304335169,
-0.0117894569,
0.0206774902,
-0.0075205322,
-0.0221304204,
0.0649992153,
-0.0033584551,
0.0220105685,
0.0229450669,
-0.0526623726,
0.0530125871,
-0.0129579511,
0.0263508614,
-0.0461543277,
-0.0086956434,
-0.0780139714,
-0.0210831687,
-0.0300315656,
0.053417515,
0.0488605686,
0.0292905942,
-0.0294953585,
0.0209228303,
-0.0014429328,
-0.0039174343,
0.0278439857,
-0.0308849122,
-0.0453223176,
0.0063211168,
-0.0468721688,
0.0039896136,
-0.0174279511,
0.0417655595,
0.0028862311,
-0.020236725,
-0.0134305749,
0.0170033649,
-0.0012234371,
-0.0147706252,
0.033654768,
0.0717305019,
-0.0129678324,
-0.0118101416,
-0.0736426115,
-0.0096729491,
-0.0258458126,
-0.038874723,
-0.0163649414,
-0.0553021543,
0.0005659049,
-0.0164799672,
-0.0362058841,
-0.0665868446,
-0.0235291645,
-0.0205379967,
-0.0677551776,
0.0224100444,
-0.0375363193,
0.0352575332,
0.0517010912,
-0.0142209036,
-0.0100235157,
0.0579952896,
0.0248976368,
-0.0152931772,
0.0071752253,
-0.0365061276,
0.0317826755,
0.0562605076,
0.0062531689,
0.0006008259,
-0.0113278646,
-0.0415142737,
-0.0026420939,
0.0262607709,
0.0460475795,
0.0164395627,
-0.0490513369,
0.0183599386,
0.0446446985,
0.0979005545,
0.0392090417,
0.0376168676,
0.088947393,
-0.0144857783,
0.0201735031,
0.0609110072,
-0.0426091254,
-0.0247135609,
-0.0130493948,
-0.0148665048,
-0.0241439119,
0.0188293904,
-0.0506042726,
-0.061071597,
0.0043931245,
-0.0203851536,
-0.0056782933,
-0.0180205405,
0.0679613277,
0.0471817218,
-0.0114864679,
0.0189884808,
0.0268192738,
-0.0316710919,
0.0460091978,
-0.0531508774,
-0.0252079275,
0.0180097949,
0.0113534546,
-0.0235138778,
-0.0213790573,
0.0174553972,
-0.0077818036,
-0.0174879413,
0.0420450233,
-0.0240112562,
-0.004845113,
-0.025306778,
-0.012085733,
0.0157998912,
0.0219578575,
0.0114897704,
-0.0350147262,
0.0004277549,
-0.0184741393,
-0.007607908,
-0.0641309321,
0.0372611061,
-0.0377554521,
-0.0454633795,
0.0071756509,
0.0145534975,
0.0477171876,
0.0074259746,
-0.0154970614,
0.0172336511,
0.0114960298,
-0.0205148868,
-0.0079018483,
0.0447292998,
0.0101453485,
-0.0016443466,
0.0433090255,
-0.0273891762,
0.0314117596,
0.01033206,
0.0123591824,
-0.0628519133,
0.0649563968,
-0.0114372745,
0.0616472922,
-0.0044828071,
0.045274321,
-0.0406961478,
0.0095018689,
-0.0344669335,
0.0683642253,
-0.0034677468,
0.0200239066,
-0.0427625738,
0.0098385131,
-0.0102941291,
-0.0520787463,
-0.0051675797,
-0.0084439265,
0.0031624427,
0.0592044927,
0.0192103088,
-0.0245827176,
0.0032903599,
-0.0423970334,
-0.0194715429,
-0.0043548052,
-0.0064252359,
0.0426318981,
0.0147408005,
-0.0364639834,
-0.0094247423,
0.0160197634,
-0.0038306769,
0.0288262814,
0.0425786003,
0.0093258088,
0.0598546267,
-0.0162460674,
-0.0508934706,
0.0018522567,
-0.0257260595,
-0.0362996161,
0.0135747287,
0.0233194586,
0.0673611984,
-0.0540482998,
0.0573202521,
0.0194172449,
0.0273064151,
-0.0247183051,
-0.0424682871,
0.0282936692,
-0.0073141581,
-0.0049028611,
0.0882931203,
0.0013993552,
0.0420800075,
0.0497863404,
0.0281878915,
-0.0068094977,
-0.0097667407,
-0.0515349843,
-0.0416946635,
-0.1026438251,
-0.0302987024,
0.0312342625,
0.1100789681,
0.0108522568,
-0.0159930922,
-0.0226961114,
-0.0041884724,
-0.0005510713,
-0.0251041967,
0.0086520622,
-0.0174947456,
-0.0375650153,
0.0340163521,
-0.0313273743,
-0.0655565709,
-0.0147711104,
-0.0145716425,
0.010418185,
-0.0190108065,
-0.0523004346,
-0.0199725647,
0.0675362051,
0.0395060405,
-0.0037650203,
0.0024290385,
-0.0353357792,
-0.0761788115,
0.0067311497,
0.0448619835,
-0.0011375052,
0.0179783814,
-0.0601167418,
-0.0173675492,
0.0003610942,
-0.0201649908,
-0.0176408216,
0.0121782888,
0.0307380389,
0.0325655229,
0.0236608703,
-0.0457220413,
0.0076808832,
-0.0365490578,
0.0468873791,
0.0040532574,
0.0014588155,
-0.0279000178,
-0.0181437824,
0.0231696963,
0.0186848976,
0.0296394918,
0.0102808084,
-0.059158206,
0.0021176219,
0.0032959715,
0.0524494387,
0.0343105309,
-0.0416111387,
0.0227797348,
0.0287934002,
-0.0534135401,
-0.0485604927,
0.0440327972,
0.027715994,
-0.0297860857,
-0.0090325763,
0.0809565037,
-0.0126772607,
-0.0332082249,
0.0390882604,
0.0291278046,
0.004378689,
0.0418145582,
0.033703614,
-0.0350998342,
0.0247096512,
-0.0199071523,
0.0072174584,
-0.0293761697,
-0.0534818135,
0.0008700901,
-0.1022762284,
0.0155988801,
0.0116994325,
-0.0575949848,
-0.0195492823,
-0.0138773564,
-0.0218199007,
-0.0112148095,
0.0125142764,
-0.0125859901,
-0.0165878963,
0.0114392964,
0.0570137277,
-0.024938181,
-0.1027365699,
-0.020026423,
-0.0688396022,
0.0868771747,
0.0186375994,
0.0033003751,
-0.0609128103,
-0.0148590747,
0.040563684,
-0.0004649006,
0.0171615873,
0.0146535905,
0.0255938079,
0.0088097481,
-0.0185963586,
0.0038279202,
0.0257151946,
-0.0241775904,
0.0176422354,
0.0242984109,
0.0745147243,
-0.0217911936,
-0.0731442645,
0.0267239511,
-0.066374816,
-0.0111744823,
0.0636002794,
0.016535569,
-0.0447054915,
-0.0335009843,
-0.01842127,
-0.0037946403,
0.0216530487,
-0.1003477424,
0.0565137081,
0.0288755037,
-0.0556978136,
-0.0655968487,
0.0027784607,
-0.0053918557,
0.0882150233,
0.0102664204,
0.0216257088,
-0.0048462609,
-0.0149082541,
-0.0172988549,
-0.0071089608,
-0.0083413329,
-0.0422364138,
-0.0655777007,
-0.0151116485,
0.0296730176,
-0.0763600096,
-0.038611304,
-0.081203118,
-0.0786455423,
-0.061875578,
-0.0042424677,
0.0648388341,
0.0258015171,
0.0439385809,
-0.0016749537,
-0.0938943848,
0.0714965388,
0.0199318416,
-0.0071115294,
0.0335527323,
0.028812794,
-0.0255418904,
0.0259256773,
0.0315082856,
-0.0087720808,
0.0332243107,
0.0328207985,
0.0107705984,
-0.051002007,
0.0078640115,
0.0099157607,
0.0029779058,
0.0247370433,
-0.0187849794,
-0.0229600351,
-0.0181581769,
-0.0172481928,
0.0425191522,
0.0006840458,
-0.0313270427,
-0.0074166819,
0.0443000607,
0.0536503866,
0.0300667118,
-0.0089735836,
0.0263728127,
-0.0009655217,
-0.0100398147,
0.0295320041,
0.0101742595,
0.0703318864,
0.0281506144,
0.0346190631,
0.016769588,
0.0200325176,
-0.0521434024,
0.0145593099,
0.0280683022,
-0.0030168535,
-0.006886689,
0.0196306724,
-0.0175924841,
-0.0055887057,
-0.0800785869,
-0.1022051722,
0.0019635824,
0.0629139394,
0.0717422888,
-0.0437844098,
0.0392670594,
-0.0551912077,
0.0141123915,
0.0019282985,
-0.0193328466,
-0.0181996152,
0.0030752462,
0.0350805819,
0.02067619,
-0.0106253391,
0.0166988466,
0.078327544,
-0.0171791334,
0.0573205315,
-0.0473272651,
0.0140168192,
-0.004857759,
-0.0366966166,
0.0372061506,
0.0124213751,
-0.003928097,
0.0283430479,
-0.0467769466,
-0.0608017035,
-0.0662335232,
0.0242617596,
0.0146605093,
-0.0093150232,
0.040066421,
0.0747127607,
-0.0463461429,
0.033796832,
-0.0222668033,
-0.0286792535,
0.0240536071,
-0.0180408526,
0.0235250946,
-5.851246108e-33,
-0.0099995257,
-0.0156641863,
0.0324514061,
0.0443951301,
0.0249632075,
0.0065920991,
0.0296947025,
0.0234801024,
-0.0614299849,
-0.0025036151,
-0.0067757159,
-0.017715998,
-0.0118030431,
0.012525836,
0.0498203337,
0.0102625648,
0.0136515535,
-0.0350658223,
0.0104738502,
0.0161370002,
-0.0083974982,
0.0045497878,
0.0865887329,
-0.0244938508,
0.0134839956,
0.0058401241,
-0.0082626129,
0.0501885787,
0.0265041124,
0.0260161478,
-0.0080014858,
0.0227866266,
0.0367656909,
-0.0835295096,
-0.0081000887,
-0.0410196036,
-0.0227232408,
-0.0308787022,
-0.0028017161,
0.011989898,
-0.0444430783,
-0.04201933,
0.0830611959,
-0.0130484765,
-0.0679594278,
-0.0115062268,
0.0475875251,
-0.0071735731,
-0.0155857978,
0.0079852268,
-0.044039011,
0.0036365194,
-0.0076027531,
-0.0163827669,
-0.0050857309,
-0.0580124855,
-0.0288213789,
-0.0268999878,
-0.0315164886,
0.0161098745,
0.0047511179,
0.0412270017,
0.042102281,
0.0003564663,
0.0241355915,
0.0365419462,
0.1126047745,
0.0442600511,
0.0167160966,
-0.0184087362,
0.0445231348,
0.0409241393,
-0.0097561236,
-0.0004102286,
0.0716809332,
-0.0070641488,
-0.0658460036,
0.0078182369,
0.0572243296,
0.056100253,
-0.0282995813,
-0.0030585749,
-0.0485007055,
-0.0288786497,
-0.0209321454,
-0.0564138144,
0.0143877743,
-0.0338650495,
0.0022660915,
0.0001526662,
0.0401934087,
-0.0260837767,
0.0031468158,
-0.032026086,
-0.0080779558,
-0.0116184484,
-0.0032936076,
0.051487118,
0.0162947141,
-0.0014168115,
-0.0487486348,
-0.0707430169,
-0.0630230382,
0.009548719,
0.0443974063,
0.0686307773,
0.0111611774,
0.0450307168,
-0.0422568992,
-0.0364812762,
-0.0290436577,
-0.0459157936,
0.0659045577,
-0.006266796,
0.0560580157,
-0.0197548307,
-0.0002834271,
0.0361323319,
0.001706388,
-0.0372210443,
-0.015730558,
0.0403939337,
-0.0084442571,
0.0411064215,
-0.0252255276,
-0.0072542629,
-0.0052636829,
0.0034265195,
0.0452750102,
-0.0422315337,
-0.0152386604,
-0.0104037756,
2.641e-7,
0.0187772103,
0.0228246618,
-0.0045581674,
0.035036277,
0.0252769403,
0.0032660072,
-0.0395594388,
0.0089182481,
-0.0291332919,
0.0123879286,
0.0339259394,
0.0485973582,
0.0202281456,
-0.004174416,
-0.0611086302,
-0.0301485937,
-0.0348572396,
0.0268841218,
-0.0075784568,
0.0050162314,
-0.0020850135,
0.0552405119,
0.0312137362,
-0.0470169932,
-0.0195256658,
-0.0606550537,
0.0470485017,
-0.0194176715,
0.0603448413,
0.0396375135,
-0.0123062236,
0.0400175564,
-0.0129587976,
0.0578228496,
-0.0024064681,
0.0499791801,
0.0095748696,
0.0223450754,
-0.0185248926,
0.0548657849,
0.0225217417,
-0.0026312075,
-0.0082238782,
-0.0259227436,
0.0744003057,
-0.0627666265,
-0.0189790335,
-0.0304723028,
0.0119551802,
0.0138539989,
-0.0020707778,
-0.0032482289,
0.0147040728,
0.0134527823,
0.0196865927,
0.0020912678,
0.0022196451,
-0.0550780892,
0.0224461071,
0.081899561,
-0.0308894552,
-0.0806376487,
-0.0066487589,
-0.0194165204,
0.0440466478,
-0.0133626591,
-0.0019470712,
2.310238996e-34,
0.0056903637,
-0.0125296265,
0.0737471655,
0.0192344263,
-0.000707248,
-0.0222226139,
-0.0354750492,
0.0129918279,
0.0448149033,
-0.0538340658,
-0.0143915759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15933v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15933v1 | GeneMask: Fast Pretraining of Gene Sequences to Enable Few-Shot Learning | 2023-07-29T09:17:16 | 2023-07-29T09:17:16 | Soumyadeep Roy, Jonas Wallat, Sowmya S Sundaram, Wolfgang Nejdl, Niloy Ganguly | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale language models such as DNABert and LOGO aim to learn optimal
gene representations and are trained on the entire Human Reference Genome.
However, standard tokenization schemes involve a simple sliding window of
tokens like k-mers that do not leverage any gene-based semantics and thus may
lead to (trivial) masking of easily predictable sequences and subsequently
inefficient Masked Language Modeling (MLM) training. Therefore, we propose a
novel masking algorithm, GeneMask, for MLM training of gene sequences, where we
randomly identify positions in a gene sequence as mask centers and locally
select the span around the mask center with the highest Normalized Pointwise
Mutual Information (NPMI) to mask. We observe that in the absence of
human-understandable semantics in the genomics domain (in contrast, semantic
units like words and phrases are inherently available in NLP), GeneMask-based
models substantially outperform the SOTA models (DNABert and LOGO) over four
benchmark gene sequence classification datasets in five few-shot settings (10
to 1000-shot). More significantly, the GeneMask-based DNABert model is trained
for less than one-tenth of the number of epochs of the original SOTA model. We
also observe a strong correlation between top-ranked PMI tokens and conserved
DNA sequence motifs, which may indicate the incorporation of latent genomic
information. The codes (including trained models) and datasets are made
publicly available at https://github.com/roysoumya/GeneMask. | [
0.0084427921,
0.0498149693,
-0.026923839,
-0.0340416022,
-0.0137749305,
0.0464985408,
0.0663197711,
0.0473749638,
0.0206388794,
-0.0402528457,
-0.0158433877,
-0.0090580033,
0.014890831,
0.0246056877,
0.0628455654,
0.0150037929,
0.0443770587,
0.0181910545,
0.0256280508,
-0.0118411025,
-0.0108131422,
0.0177806001,
0.0291748494,
0.0545970537,
0.0152532002,
-0.0292569082,
0.0384087674,
-0.0403904989,
0.0420515984,
-0.0413053818,
0.0198777746,
0.0447271727,
-0.0051407432,
0.0476169512,
0.0000020444,
-0.004682017,
-4.741e-7,
0.0199248027,
-0.0242353622,
0.0097136497,
0.0015530892,
-0.0099475263,
0.030258961,
0.0078132879,
-0.026677534,
-0.0275471862,
0.0719580278,
0.0226778593,
0.0083877342,
0.0787744224,
-0.0132754119,
-0.075896658,
0.0310928822,
-0.0350440964,
0.039349705,
-0.0095644295,
0.0539044142,
-0.0316959731,
-0.0109190224,
-0.0266934279,
-0.003505795,
0.0583661273,
-0.0325002261,
0.036261797,
0.0241490323,
0.0577547811,
-0.0155778667,
-0.0479326695,
0.0533484854,
0.0340801105,
-0.0554693602,
-0.0808636472,
0.0237381961,
0.011105638,
0.0019084528,
-0.0089097386,
-0.0263593215,
0.0148149338,
-0.0166375358,
0.05492514,
0.0184295475,
-0.0276573393,
0.0559010915,
-0.0257013086,
-0.017670041,
0.0302622132,
0.0143840229,
-0.0117476732,
-0.0504738986,
-0.0444356687,
-0.0320665129,
-0.0272127837,
0.0078317709,
-0.0013509052,
0.0162786245,
-0.0139120314,
-0.0174088217,
-0.062044356,
0.0517556965,
-0.0620404705,
0.0245154202,
0.0188561585,
-0.0018916918,
0.0126604754,
-0.070010066,
0.0066466746,
0.0078325467,
0.0359153524,
0.0069286507,
-0.0257949438,
-0.0622873493,
-0.0081134159,
0.0030902035,
0.0551962256,
-0.0273190495,
0.0142306229,
-0.0509753004,
-0.0417847186,
-0.0088448469,
0.0130198663,
-0.0172247011,
-0.0225089975,
-0.0117113972,
0.0559221916,
0.0592269637,
-0.0106259352,
-0.0132640665,
0.0080863312,
-0.0335982814,
-0.0566439144,
-0.0298952404,
0.0246558655,
0.0171499886,
-0.0121503053,
0.0142294168,
0.06829907,
0.0278398823,
-0.0749427825,
0.0115171243,
0.0119111249,
-0.0405273251,
0.0106763933,
-0.0154521316,
-0.0396003909,
0.0234281309,
0.0308318175,
0.0054138512,
-0.0182291996,
0.0150536895,
-0.0201562811,
-0.048077967,
0.0848331526,
-0.0081323078,
-0.0366216712,
0.0260043237,
-0.0006842184,
0.007168367,
0.0201968085,
0.0167032108,
-0.0055216015,
0.0119613204,
-0.0327427424,
-0.0049067,
0.0338195004,
0.0333555304,
-0.0518350415,
-0.0032375345,
-0.0187351964,
0.0645304397,
0.0046852436,
0.0350841656,
-0.0051504513,
-0.0219852887,
-0.0432659611,
0.0325946175,
0.0753374323,
0.0247155298,
0.0214787405,
0.042462904,
0.0578190684,
-0.0251613315,
-0.0457311235,
0.0040912051,
0.0020650097,
-0.062404681,
0.009372347,
0.0068851486,
0.009083977,
-0.0061736261,
0.0129122585,
-0.0196001716,
0.0048015895,
-0.0197249856,
-0.0141382115,
0.0237946957,
-0.0148437992,
-0.0366501808,
0.0409373231,
0.0291643646,
-0.0191453788,
0.0141604487,
-0.0421351269,
0.0278128553,
0.0050484412,
0.0265210327,
-0.0498338565,
0.0144209452,
-0.0222864281,
-0.0400384553,
0.0022959139,
-0.0262410659,
-0.0132099073,
0.0309716035,
-0.0219905134,
0.0034964224,
0.000692249,
0.0138163306,
0.0387541056,
-0.0395272784,
-0.0183672812,
0.0183543153,
0.0037473687,
0.0127094993,
0.0698135123,
-0.0642044246,
-0.057383962,
0.0169537514,
-0.018643517,
0.0418710001,
0.0028502597,
-0.0615223609,
0.0350559428,
0.0303111766,
-0.0554746278,
-0.0169224143,
-0.0081026992,
0.0045296382,
-0.1058055609,
0.0293243248,
-0.0283929594,
-0.0020828652,
0.0368134268,
-0.0307340808,
-0.0304284524,
-0.004027795,
-0.0643825978,
0.0511782169,
-0.0395836867,
0.0115863206,
-0.0151399467,
0.0212689545,
-0.0386832319,
0.025614934,
-0.0025860555,
0.0376427621,
-0.0104133412,
-0.0263850614,
0.0209128447,
-0.0297665838,
0.0240507331,
0.0023169983,
-0.0111685395,
-0.0441504829,
0.0010467325,
0.0100523001,
0.001820902,
0.0003044812,
-0.1026311591,
-0.0180085972,
0.0203531589,
0.0134791294,
-0.038369026,
-0.0208793115,
0.0134397866,
-0.0194048807,
-0.0476234816,
0.0246987324,
-0.0340320729,
-0.0012977251,
0.0214922931,
-0.0063692438,
-0.046658475,
-0.0222143177,
-0.018687835,
-0.0421102308,
0.0836025923,
-0.0074530067,
-0.0864804164,
-0.0152383009,
0.0095383562,
-0.0168154277,
0.0169430934,
-0.0147147067,
-0.027986832,
-0.0165218543,
0.0041603181,
0.013469073,
-0.0054521244,
0.0156687032,
-0.0220504031,
0.041460149,
0.0290074944,
-0.0345325805,
-0.0168195944,
-0.0359357744,
0.0377924964,
-0.0136626037,
0.0018267734,
0.0260699037,
0.0659766346,
0.0073866947,
-0.0392319597,
-0.0666443557,
0.0141257662,
0.025511682,
-0.031295374,
-0.0190254357,
0.0050054034,
-0.0289300568,
-0.0054347585,
-0.0150016043,
-0.0496685579,
0.0555837043,
-0.0335435234,
-0.0044216523,
-0.0129755624,
-0.0102040563,
-0.027386358,
0.0047310921,
0.0225777961,
0.0435044058,
0.0327437185,
-0.0440043397,
0.0057195416,
0.0337658189,
-0.0267575011,
-0.0567390136,
-0.0368651301,
-0.0257600732,
0.0185889248,
0.0033182034,
-0.0334953591,
-0.0130765755,
-0.01109125,
0.0088810958,
0.0212701615,
0.0620535277,
-0.0143520357,
-0.0301869474,
0.0256460924,
0.0153546734,
0.0551333874,
0.009065235,
0.0192493983,
-0.0067044306,
0.0143359825,
0.0277462956,
-0.0395099595,
0.0298729688,
0.0140773859,
0.0494186692,
0.0317955129,
-0.0023799047,
0.0431272388,
0.0484097265,
0.0286628082,
0.0454116389,
-0.014945901,
-0.0428009331,
0.0092149004,
0.0465970151,
-0.0115540382,
-0.0194798559,
0.1253744811,
0.0431827903,
-0.0399479493,
0.0297895689,
-0.012448757,
-0.0017619883,
0.009337185,
0.0326666981,
-0.1154573336,
-0.0232875478,
-0.002486936,
-0.0069962726,
-0.0439079963,
-0.0460993312,
0.0277645011,
-0.0741675198,
0.0108363004,
0.0434332006,
-0.0611990467,
-0.0255855788,
-0.0526798405,
-0.0540059879,
-0.0335110389,
-0.0156932734,
-0.0072544273,
0.0215380993,
-0.0028057594,
0.0312578827,
-0.0182321984,
-0.0613344461,
0.0330046713,
-0.0324395038,
0.0551912487,
0.0601523779,
0.0287673306,
0.0086491127,
-0.0411189795,
-0.0071887914,
0.0045942287,
-0.0071159587,
-0.0433269627,
0.0738893524,
-0.0070982859,
-0.0295147933,
-0.015015332,
0.0104888035,
-0.0056805727,
-0.0400394015,
-0.0056537543,
0.0514245518,
-0.0073021585,
-0.0425708033,
-0.0154909873,
-0.0003116765,
-0.047408659,
0.0682255775,
0.0381486081,
-0.0245561767,
-0.0122058894,
-0.0241628662,
0.0577118546,
-0.0503926091,
-0.049309697,
-0.0014185613,
-0.0347610414,
-0.0499927439,
-0.075016588,
0.0002436305,
0.0581583753,
0.0268064067,
0.0210390724,
0.0260086842,
-0.0146318646,
-0.0301843081,
-0.0533289276,
-0.0089846691,
-0.013464014,
-0.0060901926,
-0.0501335971,
-0.0433615781,
0.0721559078,
-0.0115129203,
-0.0159385279,
0.0529059395,
-0.0455587283,
-0.0847673491,
-0.0332079902,
0.0667542964,
0.0147969574,
-0.0020722798,
0.0207272694,
-0.0781708509,
0.1134061515,
0.0494654216,
-0.0057651969,
0.0027617104,
0.0272297729,
-0.0427288115,
-0.0076470696,
0.028451493,
-0.0263783932,
0.024736492,
0.0312628448,
0.0368934385,
-0.008330645,
0.0812937841,
0.0359968543,
0.0150659801,
0.1028496325,
-0.0284672063,
-0.050200332,
-0.0191364959,
0.008160417,
-0.0186208636,
-0.0174025521,
0.0098350625,
-0.0115918098,
0.0271701291,
0.0211473927,
-0.0359565765,
0.0120877791,
-0.0179165453,
0.0205615517,
-0.0440005809,
-0.0075509367,
-0.0118987858,
-0.021419812,
-0.0128053864,
0.0065035815,
0.0030787028,
0.0259676855,
-0.0159498248,
-0.0218939055,
-0.0211990066,
-0.0000575984,
0.0050888075,
0.0681724176,
-0.0235351417,
0.0098673841,
-0.0381949469,
0.0315771662,
-0.0275159217,
0.0100566959,
0.0681183338,
-0.0418919064,
0.03416235,
0.0148376366,
-0.0350256898,
-0.0343521573,
0.0489416011,
-0.0565095805,
-0.0260519609,
0.0177671593,
0.0109735401,
-0.0720955282,
-0.0602597781,
0.092585519,
0.0663537383,
0.0664015487,
-0.0318774916,
-0.0362551361,
-0.0317736007,
-0.001694705,
0.0626187325,
0.0288157742,
-0.0220544878,
-0.0141404271,
-0.0449081063,
-0.0491819978,
-0.0017283617,
-0.0257805753,
0.0060509574,
0.014683798,
-0.0142680686,
-0.0010084967,
0.0322354324,
-0.0582634248,
-0.054783985,
0.036904078,
0.0382748358,
-0.0475190133,
-0.0153075,
-6.58236135e-33,
-0.0213709399,
-0.0213267989,
-0.0080831647,
0.0463394225,
0.0170309525,
0.0181176998,
-0.0142808035,
-0.0140254032,
-0.0006948548,
0.0091647832,
0.0125975749,
0.000248048,
-0.0015182939,
-0.0037895397,
0.0011910161,
0.0295425616,
0.0462197065,
-0.0101049524,
0.0087535521,
0.0096290223,
0.0267600939,
0.0648295879,
0.0342752337,
-0.0278545022,
-0.0168787464,
0.0277781337,
-0.0039039634,
-0.0404679403,
-0.0218452662,
0.0081997029,
-0.0180233903,
0.0019675409,
0.003898951,
-0.0154806403,
-0.0232138466,
-0.017868232,
-0.0696642101,
0.0056441147,
-0.0167878829,
-0.0097782994,
0.0125041874,
-0.0527150966,
0.0604369193,
-0.029995257,
-0.0477562174,
0.0275516044,
0.0351041444,
-0.0435544476,
-0.0586697273,
-0.0750297606,
-0.023069622,
0.0287027545,
-0.0019922394,
0.0320442207,
0.081152305,
0.0090041226,
0.007743001,
0.0447209217,
-0.0542510562,
0.0079334201,
0.0435897224,
0.0516206175,
0.0496664718,
0.0289475825,
0.0601568148,
0.0435327552,
0.0791938528,
-0.0543219373,
0.0215376448,
0.0516072996,
0.0313616842,
0.0130790127,
0.048625499,
-0.0026742143,
0.0533198267,
-0.03098353,
-0.0981175005,
0.048896797,
-0.0461788438,
-0.016029207,
0.0109564448,
0.0455791652,
-0.010288775,
0.0047958698,
-0.0227785725,
-0.0439338982,
-0.0202661902,
0.0124850711,
-0.0095863985,
-0.0140387444,
-0.0275230911,
0.0488351472,
0.0259655174,
-0.0114583848,
-0.0302801374,
0.0110984193,
0.0261089411,
-0.0135515044,
-0.001687601,
0.024277214,
-0.0496757366,
-0.0535488576,
0.0575996935,
-0.0364462771,
0.0749174803,
-0.0245542675,
0.0694503412,
0.0050802003,
-0.0688458234,
-0.0312002115,
-0.0152706075,
-0.0083111068,
0.0439670645,
0.0462311693,
0.002861012,
0.0121486681,
0.0308429319,
-0.0005362057,
0.0443374254,
-0.0052062199,
0.0158072654,
0.0254209246,
-0.0269093532,
-0.0061176978,
-0.0288997404,
-0.0112520549,
-0.0026415989,
0.0428596251,
0.0546572246,
-0.0347155146,
-0.0298047196,
-0.0059897699,
2.892e-7,
0.0625833869,
0.0691499412,
0.0076651587,
-0.0292994566,
0.0177427512,
0.042105075,
-0.0047076601,
0.054006137,
-0.0361147746,
0.014673573,
0.0092930151,
-0.0469505377,
0.0423879102,
0.0090774223,
-0.0578993,
0.0111868121,
-0.0302667152,
0.0260231737,
-0.0392350964,
0.0208935048,
0.0317962132,
0.1571297497,
0.0152405705,
0.0112383952,
0.0554945581,
-0.0252012648,
0.0745952651,
-0.0415201336,
-0.0010724638,
-0.004657106,
-0.0399033874,
0.0020868029,
0.0016623798,
0.0269776657,
-0.0418066718,
-0.0088279843,
-0.0037879655,
0.0595906675,
-0.0044067167,
-0.0080979913,
0.0433287434,
0.0236201175,
0.0132008148,
-0.0533442199,
0.0499387793,
-0.0466893092,
-0.0773522556,
-0.01445329,
-0.0010539058,
0.0218441542,
0.0032520108,
-0.0254358035,
-0.0072975019,
0.0496061184,
0.0049171648,
0.0022858423,
-0.0188336205,
-0.0677986369,
-0.0371617526,
-0.0022019427,
-0.0408689342,
0.0127241751,
-0.0313048251,
0.0199416485,
0.0051639704,
-0.0408214256,
0.0201125406,
2.980096059e-34,
-0.0098831337,
-0.0627836362,
-0.0447025709,
0.0514536388,
0.0475695394,
-0.0335900858,
0.0015809636,
0.0419850796,
-0.0103509314,
-0.0766036958,
0.0048245578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.01203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.01203v1 | Analysing the Resourcefulness of the Paragraph for Precedence Retrieval | 2023-07-29T08:55:38 | 2023-07-29T08:55:38 | Bhoomeendra Singh Sisodiya, Narendra Babu Unnam, P. Krishna Reddy, Apala Das, K. V. K. Santhy, V. Balakista Reddy | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Developing methods for extracting relevant legal information to aid legal
practitioners is an active research area. In this regard, research efforts are
being made by leveraging different kinds of information, such as meta-data,
citations, keywords, sentences, paragraphs, etc. Similar to any text document,
legal documents are composed of paragraphs. In this paper, we have analyzed the
resourcefulness of paragraph-level information in capturing similarity among
judgments for improving the performance of precedence retrieval. We found that
the paragraph-level methods could capture the similarity among the judgments
with only a few paragraph interactions and exhibit more discriminating power
over the baseline document-level method. Moreover, the comparison results on
two benchmark datasets for the precedence retrieval on the Indian supreme court
judgments task show that the paragraph-level methods exhibit comparable
performance with the state-of-the-art methods | [
0.0599880852,
0.0059697703,
-0.0135086905,
0.0230629891,
-0.1029564217,
0.029128084,
-0.0081680864,
0.0269770995,
-0.0393793993,
-0.0864217654,
-0.0057934588,
-0.0180956647,
0.0114373481,
-0.0824278891,
-0.0343848839,
-0.0682246909,
0.0255756211,
0.0489134863,
0.1021497548,
0.0424662381,
0.0471194498,
-0.0089907693,
-0.0283830408,
0.0390407704,
-0.0093026217,
0.0036477421,
0.0122668231,
-0.0025843724,
0.0335715637,
-0.0421283208,
-0.0117599955,
0.0460390039,
-0.0085010091,
-0.0047506317,
0.0000013262,
-0.0481657498,
-0.030692501,
-0.0033014384,
0.0286890585,
0.0244042017,
0.023442883,
-0.0077078789,
-0.0016473206,
-0.016579207,
-0.0514104143,
-0.0026745605,
-0.0141059496,
0.0351277031,
0.0124261146,
0.0864968374,
-0.0127169387,
-0.0122767137,
0.0155253978,
0.0121766143,
0.0056313616,
-0.0328558348,
0.0132522518,
-0.0083632031,
0.0243105758,
0.01064236,
0.0350320563,
-0.0285655577,
-0.0051852935,
-0.0119574731,
-0.0149047794,
-0.0165960658,
-0.068160072,
0.0500640869,
0.0249650236,
0.0244240873,
0.0463174544,
-0.0189933814,
0.0223376639,
-0.0013539027,
0.038251482,
0.0438310355,
-0.0377481543,
0.0785522312,
-0.0399993062,
0.0227974541,
0.0248207655,
0.0519571304,
-0.060685847,
-0.0279126428,
-0.0053499877,
0.0889409706,
-0.0043317219,
-0.0680799335,
0.0079108067,
0.0070332577,
-0.0157547705,
0.0118726781,
0.0523959287,
0.0091500469,
0.0043001762,
0.0066585364,
-0.0077568842,
-0.0483293086,
0.0744390339,
-0.0895624757,
0.0249616727,
0.0113769611,
-0.014381933,
0.0590140298,
-0.0210871994,
0.0189941227,
-0.0060003321,
0.0200587977,
-0.0108429976,
-0.0262803771,
-0.0263597388,
-0.0030250058,
0.0086644832,
0.0792905167,
-0.0732868612,
0.0158599187,
-0.0520538688,
0.0015712786,
-0.0203711819,
-0.0012579421,
0.0061426298,
-0.0155924801,
0.0129482578,
-0.0105083277,
-0.0589791127,
-0.0384996086,
-0.016817566,
0.0423655212,
-0.0266077146,
0.0112631824,
0.0199984424,
0.01413716,
0.0093828635,
-0.0086963139,
-0.0208477248,
0.0783451721,
-0.0207528248,
-0.046007324,
-0.0340614282,
-0.0533644408,
-0.0251736231,
-0.0398822874,
-0.0413434058,
-0.06225501,
0.0107715214,
0.0171796791,
-0.0410512574,
-0.0109625412,
0.0293162167,
0.0571889803,
-0.0283390786,
0.0329241417,
0.0315814279,
-0.0284901131,
-0.0490792915,
0.0274471845,
0.0238688756,
0.0091873994,
-0.0024409036,
0.0036359816,
0.0427575335,
0.0097586419,
-0.020803865,
-0.0080749355,
-0.0237387661,
-0.0224460382,
0.0043829195,
0.0213793926,
-0.0156253055,
-0.0210783239,
0.0079009626,
0.0439611413,
-0.0144765545,
-0.0431718342,
0.0022385654,
0.0720588714,
-0.0083514228,
0.0087188203,
-0.0160143599,
-0.0203637667,
0.0294452719,
0.056418892,
-0.0107383737,
-0.0188067462,
0.0108652012,
0.019618867,
-0.0299281441,
-0.0053171343,
-0.0105552906,
-0.0442428216,
-0.0076110745,
0.0194627177,
-0.0395744145,
-0.0191381052,
0.0434449688,
0.0119277928,
-0.0279154629,
0.0174204484,
0.0262660664,
-0.0644983426,
-0.0316992514,
0.0131917605,
-0.022289807,
0.0282465648,
0.042817492,
-0.0803268328,
0.0095508443,
0.0541106947,
0.0019666017,
0.0195264034,
0.0094065266,
-0.004988288,
-0.0280535258,
-0.0228300877,
-0.0307719111,
0.0177282318,
0.0042086183,
-0.0123751536,
-0.0178999919,
0.0121602649,
0.041189339,
-0.0344633497,
0.0377581716,
0.0426163673,
0.0213316102,
0.0109234015,
0.0272940733,
-0.0044095688,
0.0465773828,
0.0175901186,
0.0063291248,
0.0073683527,
0.0376899168,
-0.0206064414,
0.0069088447,
0.0216270722,
-0.0148038995,
-0.0295135602,
0.0112289023,
-0.08884231,
-0.0103734685,
-0.0158031285,
-0.0251779538,
-0.0121744415,
-0.0375517122,
0.0009979865,
0.0344689675,
-0.0313304774,
0.034826111,
-0.0066057541,
-0.0741834715,
-0.0577016808,
0.0440781564,
-0.0073040444,
0.0236641653,
-0.0037850877,
-0.0255409684,
0.0605880469,
-0.0344835259,
-0.0174228121,
-0.0510483198,
-0.0377735123,
0.0052672485,
0.0468799658,
-0.0100278454,
-0.0387460738,
-0.0252119247,
-0.0937448665,
0.0152138127,
-0.0237596594,
0.0161761306,
0.0002909191,
-0.0181858595,
-0.0019588792,
-0.031657692,
0.008444692,
-0.0216297526,
-0.002543543,
0.0297810957,
0.0431922674,
-0.0087607168,
0.0042033852,
-0.0507948101,
-0.0472183973,
-0.0463538207,
0.0485971645,
-0.0042941533,
-0.0112079075,
-0.02806562,
0.0707284287,
0.0196685269,
0.0017106428,
-0.043747481,
-0.0054789707,
0.025429314,
0.0029919762,
-0.0036404561,
0.0421775579,
0.0541023985,
0.0058200178,
0.0200259816,
0.0035630539,
-0.042420648,
-0.0025916877,
-0.0112986937,
0.0637151152,
-0.0022031981,
-0.0096143298,
0.0426202491,
-0.0164820552,
0.0318094119,
-0.0060239946,
-0.0132144326,
-0.0064015803,
-0.013437503,
0.0267724805,
-0.0068336325,
-0.0235932823,
-0.0102193812,
0.0429625846,
0.0047913352,
-0.0359435789,
0.0350147709,
-0.0061468398,
0.0645258799,
-0.048568435,
0.0076975706,
-0.0680154487,
0.0628177598,
0.0060596992,
-0.0165157374,
-0.0627500489,
-0.0442460999,
0.0139795179,
-0.0052463133,
0.0681633279,
-0.019690942,
0.0909039527,
-0.0148793012,
0.0473110303,
-0.0587500408,
-0.0654190034,
-0.0288709383,
-0.0209277775,
0.0342359841,
0.0279039592,
0.030567823,
0.0269822907,
-0.0368074551,
0.0227195527,
-0.0140994042,
0.0016286857,
0.005569478,
-0.0284758825,
-0.0183388125,
0.0532121696,
-0.0063763815,
-0.0684719831,
0.031752903,
0.0135834692,
-0.0271247383,
0.0489532053,
0.0445702821,
-0.012172088,
0.0296037216,
-0.0312248021,
-0.0161119625,
-0.1066613197,
-0.0013364053,
0.0309468769,
-0.0178681351,
-0.0227639675,
0.0230344459,
0.0669750869,
0.0501270145,
-0.0197204202,
-0.0495797619,
0.0062165516,
-0.0334339477,
0.0262065548,
-0.0173246879,
-0.0561842881,
0.0249743462,
-0.0057605724,
-0.0136684077,
-0.0507247597,
-0.0433775187,
0.0113118608,
-0.058565475,
0.0590648651,
-0.0064741634,
0.0164981168,
-0.0450714752,
-0.0383885801,
0.0350486822,
0.0220013335,
-0.0401583575,
0.0471153632,
-0.0719838962,
-0.00840287,
0.0069207335,
-0.0360476114,
0.0519219935,
0.0130136563,
-0.0361768194,
-0.0203715656,
-0.0220757462,
0.0309627838,
-0.0208497979,
-0.0425524265,
-0.0217087511,
-0.06800358,
0.0014209446,
0.0199253038,
0.0136940954,
0.0050214585,
0.0174200069,
-0.0636962354,
-0.0061806226,
0.0203296393,
-0.0185997393,
0.0611080378,
0.0051561156,
-0.0561050214,
-0.0125273298,
-0.0601780452,
0.0173294004,
-0.0243127607,
0.033589825,
0.001542697,
0.0348615162,
-0.0699265003,
0.0137183378,
-0.0230571739,
-0.0888073146,
-0.0023942108,
0.0024708216,
-0.0089397738,
0.0265212059,
-0.0461302735,
-0.004106578,
-0.029647097,
0.0480039343,
-0.0075266627,
0.0660317764,
0.0725227371,
-0.0143141896,
-0.0675310642,
-0.0214638449,
-0.0110934023,
-0.0263594221,
-0.0325155146,
0.0259467401,
0.0233391412,
0.0483820774,
-0.0289499741,
-0.0485538431,
0.042166207,
-0.0202278662,
0.0234467853,
0.006383176,
0.0054843836,
-0.0435121395,
0.0045269113,
0.0004168485,
0.0738425404,
0.0350749381,
-0.0172175243,
-0.0044511599,
0.0229735561,
-0.0192048904,
-0.0304421932,
-0.0115096234,
0.0063409628,
0.054754924,
0.0157519765,
0.0193518382,
0.0151758157,
-0.0227887239,
0.0180567689,
0.0251101218,
0.0637295991,
0.040679656,
0.0020866017,
-0.0193830691,
-0.0023684658,
-0.0527446903,
-0.0065071471,
0.0028098812,
-0.016660193,
-0.0243539307,
0.0048166895,
-0.0242739208,
0.0580813698,
-0.0257161651,
0.0547581054,
-0.0369759947,
0.0479887798,
0.0377018154,
0.0284441542,
-0.0179944504,
-0.0508426018,
0.012777742,
-0.0087496508,
-0.0176648162,
0.0387472473,
0.002569987,
0.0446795896,
0.0331134163,
-0.0000971561,
-0.0238488186,
0.0558559112,
-0.053743124,
0.0460767597,
0.003541495,
-0.0205529742,
0.052935753,
-0.0276651401,
0.0180733539,
-0.019384617,
-0.0065040407,
0.0120438589,
0.0144954305,
-0.0138844326,
0.0238705873,
0.0361955948,
0.0208888836,
-0.0198130962,
0.0307858791,
0.0392013714,
0.0121329119,
-0.0218831822,
0.0165060107,
-0.0772462189,
-0.0013298707,
-0.080955185,
-0.0308993086,
0.0475142039,
-0.0011241395,
-0.0648409352,
-0.0804842561,
0.0504179969,
0.0134724136,
0.0276109669,
0.0061180675,
0.0032941634,
0.0009674742,
0.045621343,
0.0402861238,
-0.0497681387,
-0.0478043482,
0.0117059518,
-0.0422105491,
-0.0267662685,
-0.0189122073,
-4.840830837e-33,
-0.0391547866,
-0.0746475682,
-0.007832895,
0.0696516857,
-0.0125104124,
-0.007636473,
0.0178593174,
-0.0199641678,
-0.0263779592,
0.0445818491,
-0.0040942905,
0.0334301516,
0.0273176413,
-0.0102744596,
0.0560685582,
0.0026609898,
0.0113812136,
0.0120121203,
0.0019932101,
0.000168053,
0.0586711541,
-0.0150671452,
0.0314147659,
-0.0555015765,
0.0349583551,
0.0259325318,
0.0365500487,
-0.0305439457,
-0.0316801108,
0.0584669933,
0.0438891016,
0.0284646433,
0.0469167158,
-0.0091430563,
0.0047193873,
0.0550413691,
-0.0794335008,
-0.0309075881,
0.0297702402,
-0.0321793519,
0.0038441643,
0.0080540609,
0.018322248,
-0.0002485647,
-0.0124484692,
-0.0081576658,
0.0553603247,
-0.0254516602,
-0.0482458174,
-0.0978352278,
-0.0752057061,
0.0499459021,
-0.0268870238,
0.056938529,
0.0432773083,
0.0192047507,
0.0157213528,
0.0371657982,
-0.0908498019,
0.015170577,
-0.0743088424,
0.0264253113,
-0.0676168576,
-0.0374932736,
-0.015042413,
0.0319889076,
-0.017431261,
0.0165547971,
0.0093321186,
-0.0012923428,
0.017913023,
0.0548970439,
0.0145692108,
0.0289956052,
0.0441479832,
-0.0306818895,
-0.0678394511,
0.0210259594,
0.0336987972,
0.0303797815,
0.0362085924,
-0.0309769996,
-0.0657282695,
-0.0197257437,
0.0153877055,
-0.0258076675,
-0.0056258272,
0.0152557464,
0.0211499166,
0.0006988515,
0.0609430298,
-0.0131660486,
0.0210949257,
0.02590359,
0.0274353698,
0.0430166908,
-0.012006796,
0.0339666568,
-0.0201632101,
0.0107376296,
-0.05679138,
-0.0379127525,
-0.0003531119,
0.029733507,
-0.0113207111,
-0.0382801332,
0.0566954352,
-0.0859034508,
-0.0598072782,
-0.0205536261,
0.0445712619,
0.0215055794,
-0.0276725907,
-0.0085969009,
-0.0008087137,
0.0381055176,
0.0468724333,
0.0609470643,
0.0112919221,
-0.0151580218,
-0.0387588367,
-0.0008879558,
0.0178996529,
-0.0421590172,
0.0484473296,
0.0409310609,
0.0026956219,
0.074623853,
-0.0251239073,
0.0230047423,
0.0254286677,
0.0891955122,
2.114e-7,
0.0776157901,
0.0372678488,
0.013943661,
0.001085323,
-0.0114118252,
0.0071291528,
0.0040114969,
0.0206943229,
0.0216212682,
0.0153610865,
0.0477291346,
-0.0095461244,
0.0162254293,
0.0558600686,
-0.0589460433,
-0.0199027937,
-0.0668743402,
-0.1163325608,
-0.0576767437,
0.0263595153,
0.0453037992,
0.0143905897,
-0.0219906922,
0.0106132356,
-0.0364119671,
0.010698623,
0.0564068854,
0.0093462504,
-0.0047084163,
0.015898563,
0.0753104314,
-0.0525639579,
-0.0315251499,
0.0681772232,
0.0105266655,
0.0514335446,
-0.0120349545,
0.0384134986,
0.0016941646,
-0.0062518022,
0.0025083323,
-0.0272787977,
0.0142079219,
-0.0281196963,
0.03322386,
-0.0137996702,
-0.0021945152,
-0.0184574742,
-0.0203722529,
0.0171073992,
0.0265009273,
0.0432824418,
-0.0252158437,
0.0002529571,
0.0153252203,
-0.0308246333,
-0.010524177,
-0.095611915,
0.0464188233,
0.0649669021,
0.0037599169,
-0.0020825132,
0.0186282732,
-0.0157317314,
0.0323768146,
-0.0782684684,
0.0031971438,
1.648712675e-34,
0.0433352552,
-0.0002543966,
0.0084949555,
-0.0159159973,
0.032410115,
0.0377826206,
-0.012796401,
0.0157398097,
-0.0343448073,
-0.0817035437,
0.0359554738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15920v1 | ATESA-BÆRT: A Heterogeneous Ensemble Learning Model for Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis | 2023-07-29T07:35:19 | 2023-07-29T07:35:19 | Elena-Simona Apostol, Alin-Georgian Pisică, Ciprian-Octavian Truică | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The increasing volume of online reviews has made possible the development of
sentiment analysis models for determining the opinion of customers regarding
different products and services. Until now, sentiment analysis has proven to be
an effective tool for determining the overall polarity of reviews. To improve
the granularity at the aspect level for a better understanding of the service
or product, the task of aspect-based sentiment analysis aims to first identify
aspects and then determine the user's opinion about them. The complexity of
this task lies in the fact that the same review can present multiple aspects,
each with its own polarity. Current solutions have poor performance on such
data. We address this problem by proposing ATESA-B{\AE}RT, a heterogeneous
ensemble learning model for Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis. Firstly, we divide
our problem into two sub-tasks, i.e., Aspect Term Extraction and Aspect Term
Sentiment Analysis. Secondly, we use the \textit{argmax} multi-class
classification on six transformers-based learners for each sub-task. Initial
experiments on two datasets prove that ATESA-B{\AE}RT outperforms current
state-of-the-art solutions while solving the many aspects problem. | [
0.0222393181,
0.013854567,
0.0046532764,
0.0381951518,
-0.0236144941,
0.0209132042,
0.0199730732,
-0.0270184167,
-0.040503405,
-0.0627411529,
-0.0673838705,
-0.0595205724,
-0.0164897572,
0.027966354,
-0.0499502569,
-0.0042775786,
0.031478595,
0.0517485365,
-0.0117712794,
-0.0095214071,
-0.0027425156,
0.0384715907,
-0.0117122261,
0.0140634468,
0.0104320161,
-0.0233129542,
0.0247303154,
-0.0314580426,
0.0514471419,
0.0211787,
0.0409299582,
0.0143938214,
-0.0503223762,
-0.0167464856,
0.0000020139,
-0.0252429023,
-0.0503820628,
0.002107318,
0.0333197713,
-0.0367879309,
0.0479585081,
0.0129999416,
0.0407428071,
0.0246162377,
-0.0382940471,
-0.0267076921,
0.0338892564,
0.1202329025,
0.0461587273,
0.0512485206,
-0.0259479452,
-0.0235280022,
-0.0369824842,
0.0092582479,
-0.0406295359,
-0.0271431543,
0.0015058551,
-0.0313278809,
-0.0341280364,
0.0338399336,
0.0085708015,
0.0063992431,
-0.004526332,
0.0059236507,
0.0256530736,
0.0050217365,
0.0476294309,
0.0134734921,
-0.0140864458,
0.0456700362,
0.002759777,
0.0068951207,
-0.0059480919,
-0.017896777,
-0.0263980832,
0.0140419519,
0.02772066,
0.0116582541,
-0.0313194245,
0.0474487022,
0.0003723043,
0.065358527,
-0.0071739149,
0.0247228332,
-0.0100133624,
0.0417176671,
-0.0319725312,
-0.0239682514,
0.0286383983,
0.0831257924,
0.0205523875,
0.0262126364,
0.0271065608,
-0.0094731599,
-0.0064411927,
0.0261874571,
0.0542777814,
-0.006413091,
0.0152198002,
-0.058649037,
0.0348981433,
-0.0172552932,
-0.007087443,
0.035562899,
0.0143913366,
-0.0554584153,
0.0302971061,
-0.0361174606,
-0.014777231,
0.0374510363,
-0.0758069605,
0.0332176834,
0.02917156,
0.0767980888,
-0.0152898338,
0.0202238206,
-0.0720044374,
-0.023786379,
-0.0155532258,
-0.0087741269,
0.0909936428,
0.0037535657,
0.0213193484,
-0.0026591104,
0.0139443921,
0.0652210861,
-0.0135810459,
0.0472749695,
-0.0578037165,
0.0323906019,
0.0168427974,
0.0212060772,
0.0035459825,
-0.0106576569,
-0.0098829698,
0.0131295696,
0.0238958187,
-0.061970599,
-0.0061651696,
-0.0062474394,
-0.0221445691,
-0.0470170379,
-0.0255540125,
-0.0358613208,
0.0260211211,
0.0046703694,
0.001939537,
0.0228953194,
-0.0000184414,
-0.0084821209,
0.0105590047,
0.0454469696,
-0.0110917995,
-0.0178127885,
-0.020818999,
0.0077357581,
0.0376326106,
0.0443353392,
-0.0257339384,
0.0478513539,
0.0061098328,
0.013778138,
0.0407666937,
0.0012987766,
-0.0076778992,
-0.0097838435,
0.0391420051,
-0.0084296484,
-0.0525773279,
-0.0607969202,
-0.0116051026,
0.0243953001,
0.0208831895,
-0.0413474329,
0.017431533,
-0.0476254746,
-0.0326886252,
0.0648106858,
-0.0170317069,
0.020065954,
-0.0191695057,
-0.0380554348,
0.0282850023,
0.0210139714,
-0.035109628,
-0.0298904907,
-0.0092945555,
0.0385350771,
-0.0271261074,
-0.0674214512,
-0.006349002,
-0.0405583754,
-0.0400057361,
0.0266135447,
0.0713182241,
-0.0176581703,
-0.045676861,
0.0019102395,
0.0492738858,
-0.0617614165,
-0.0318999141,
-0.0269669332,
0.0457817987,
0.0459857695,
-0.026948832,
-0.0442107432,
-0.0267341305,
-0.054652337,
-0.0809466392,
0.0066946158,
0.0241190754,
-0.0018367626,
0.0217270795,
-0.0469281562,
-0.0098182298,
0.0304716006,
0.0307290126,
0.0189174581,
-0.0297174677,
0.0393659137,
-0.0179968048,
-0.0025460175,
0.0170941371,
-0.0088911569,
0.0075940951,
0.0033083532,
0.0394992977,
0.0376330093,
0.0380605906,
0.0518408008,
-0.0255891699,
-0.03260554,
0.0262172241,
-0.0452451371,
-0.1266638935,
0.0129225263,
-0.0158176906,
-0.0412265062,
0.0081648706,
-0.0051412298,
0.0051650065,
-0.0325557925,
-0.0242076702,
-0.0057185818,
0.0074989931,
-0.0197810307,
-0.0294058621,
-0.0102300514,
0.0035221567,
0.0168260224,
0.0261346139,
-0.0232005436,
0.0519356728,
-0.0237483196,
0.0156360082,
-0.0829297379,
-0.0784250349,
0.0328421295,
0.0355132706,
-0.0374046303,
-0.0230626725,
0.0200160034,
0.0254484396,
0.0297392514,
-0.0126406131,
-0.0014970175,
-0.0397481807,
-0.0821514651,
-0.0218066312,
0.011135485,
0.0290355757,
0.0127077932,
-0.0151394876,
0.0112765273,
0.0469233394,
-0.0185564589,
-0.0223062485,
-0.0250588581,
0.0170912594,
0.0155966133,
0.0388919264,
0.0185007248,
-0.0124622835,
-0.0072004651,
-0.0208480936,
0.0380149148,
0.0134223811,
-0.0441509411,
-0.0319498815,
0.0068448917,
-0.0346583053,
-0.0098441821,
-0.0093871653,
-0.0159838907,
-0.0453838259,
0.0018329285,
-0.0000871606,
-0.0015551699,
0.0165057369,
0.0287646577,
0.0332378633,
0.0337901153,
-0.0189844929,
0.0176819339,
-0.0741553083,
0.0300959442,
-0.0022099754,
-0.0267367363,
0.0374479368,
0.0543021373,
0.0217035264,
-0.0130661493,
-0.031159902,
0.006499643,
-0.0358666554,
-0.0104777673,
0.0030354292,
-0.0037207112,
0.0124641983,
-0.0252684243,
0.0146870147,
0.0040665683,
0.0617180802,
0.0472877137,
0.0317022093,
-0.0679691136,
-0.0082508512,
-0.0582401976,
0.0544047989,
-0.0444447882,
0.0237186775,
0.048078496,
0.0398000553,
0.0340186171,
-0.0424884148,
-0.0000156607,
-0.0201419946,
0.0622683354,
0.030850295,
0.0231688358,
0.0070833191,
-0.0551492125,
0.0204204228,
-0.0396961197,
-0.0284610335,
-0.0041515017,
-0.0016559897,
-0.0181010049,
-0.0385082886,
-0.0142934257,
-0.0265283696,
-0.0397095606,
-0.0224012956,
-0.0171635672,
0.0447439179,
0.0390161537,
0.0432857908,
-0.0523789488,
0.009026425,
-0.0410123467,
0.008491734,
0.0352079347,
-0.0478655249,
-0.024550667,
-0.0252381489,
-0.0645085648,
0.0337319225,
-0.0173585378,
-0.0104198223,
-0.0615798421,
0.0549269542,
-0.0229624622,
0.0152192442,
0.0807400122,
0.0201416742,
-0.0705561042,
-0.0231469814,
0.0294139646,
-0.0265404079,
0.0266517792,
0.0161869489,
-0.0459844209,
-0.0201224182,
-0.037703231,
0.0224048253,
0.0046638143,
-0.0104186404,
0.0114756394,
-0.082287021,
0.017189255,
-0.0238449648,
-0.0351633243,
-0.0749372989,
-0.0193252079,
0.0170658138,
-0.0719412863,
0.0010322115,
-0.0467990376,
0.0037481068,
0.0202612523,
0.0230152812,
-0.0255538058,
-0.0269278828,
0.032295756,
-0.0020561537,
0.0053682458,
0.0074742651,
0.0172957275,
-0.0286477208,
-0.0468330681,
0.0093536889,
-0.0751393363,
0.0021574879,
-0.0340632349,
0.102905415,
-0.0423619933,
-0.025297245,
0.0117166676,
-0.0070879664,
-0.0550436266,
0.021625977,
0.0062233778,
0.0344099551,
-0.0213683452,
-0.0420094393,
-0.0162930693,
-0.0147557147,
0.0512350313,
0.0477866828,
-0.0346504636,
-0.0804453492,
-0.0199483093,
-0.0005710394,
-0.0342052169,
-0.0378962345,
-0.0237332396,
-0.0324448086,
0.0028570672,
-0.0462580845,
-0.0459577106,
-0.0139885191,
-0.010461322,
0.0307996757,
-0.0133610032,
-0.0117763551,
0.0309050679,
0.0563457385,
-0.0242945626,
0.0102756396,
0.0259658732,
0.0411707908,
-0.0048928647,
-0.0284965206,
0.1145093292,
-0.0140789468,
-0.0306747966,
-0.0418748371,
-0.0132867144,
-0.0325246789,
-0.0082447464,
0.0447570197,
0.0001783707,
-0.0148626026,
0.0187735967,
-0.0132552749,
0.0213245582,
0.0849167407,
0.0031090064,
-0.0109524522,
0.0665579289,
0.0493652672,
0.0004010383,
0.0377719775,
-0.0050437422,
0.0821354017,
0.012573964,
-0.032882899,
-0.0591488928,
-0.0105456458,
-0.0001931008,
-0.0101435101,
0.0374534912,
0.0134897018,
-0.0167943463,
-0.0177179705,
0.0063257702,
0.020162927,
-0.0211986341,
-0.0312327221,
-0.0107109891,
-0.0201042779,
-0.0321318507,
-0.0525519401,
0.0790691525,
0.0184279401,
0.0239595026,
-0.0253392477,
0.0774824172,
-0.0071447701,
-0.0225113612,
-0.0464347042,
0.012123771,
-0.0254943501,
-0.0393811241,
0.0392860137,
-0.0075130104,
0.0266898498,
0.0489560887,
0.0091139171,
0.0362289958,
-0.0457035489,
0.0199510362,
-0.0082278559,
0.0422517397,
-0.0374566205,
-0.0137185967,
-0.0205191132,
-0.0230718441,
0.042426642,
-0.024642108,
-0.002275334,
-0.0052038166,
0.0300135296,
-0.0168705918,
0.0367016867,
0.050099317,
0.0023496745,
-0.0202090684,
-0.0112399878,
0.0606004708,
-0.1235776544,
0.0346030146,
0.0182751529,
-0.0214111935,
-0.056562908,
-0.0086958371,
-0.0092996666,
-0.0366904549,
0.0111590335,
0.0309784487,
-0.0522987209,
-0.0108244512,
0.0347005092,
-0.0343421176,
0.0412995704,
0.0159489736,
0.0261095911,
0.0194920637,
0.0308084004,
0.0441977605,
-0.0562205911,
-0.0048609152,
-0.0371448435,
0.0168643687,
-0.0021290216,
-6.304312855e-33,
-0.0080283713,
0.0055180416,
-0.0474849306,
0.0123248082,
-0.0039872499,
0.0043860045,
0.001168243,
0.0458492003,
0.0057307137,
0.0268202443,
0.0211880468,
0.0067618825,
-0.0045524151,
0.0486353897,
0.0263917726,
-0.0101689184,
0.0452048592,
0.0020883984,
0.0192850698,
0.0509652756,
0.0307244658,
0.0126907146,
0.0712945983,
-0.1073076725,
0.0103143407,
0.0166322663,
-0.0846003592,
-0.0035615067,
-0.0193638559,
0.0545851178,
-0.0173000824,
0.052561108,
0.0530381389,
-0.0382368155,
0.0312813744,
-0.0106974468,
-0.0087001091,
0.0029080133,
-0.0250974074,
0.000275257,
0.0113437707,
-0.0126204081,
-0.0034341589,
0.019747993,
-0.0145840356,
-0.0305002462,
0.027355779,
-0.0265811086,
0.0223733094,
-0.1346310824,
-0.0125300717,
0.0411431529,
-0.0047846022,
-0.0109423408,
0.0127628334,
0.0604024269,
0.0149393184,
0.0324637778,
-0.0204834323,
0.0262062754,
-0.0395384692,
0.0381667949,
-0.0240102131,
-0.0249348525,
-0.0233516432,
0.0529226176,
-0.0110670915,
0.0062160115,
-0.0332893617,
-0.023474494,
-0.0245242827,
0.020605281,
0.0014644652,
0.0190061331,
-0.0068663508,
-0.048784744,
-0.0273215864,
0.0333573744,
0.0635626316,
-0.0277534481,
0.0605095066,
-0.0271238517,
-0.0565351546,
-0.0053837416,
0.0360718593,
-0.0520933345,
-0.013067808,
0.0125939837,
-0.0326539986,
0.0386768356,
-0.0341211595,
0.026652392,
-0.0346273407,
-0.0597354099,
-0.0298054498,
0.0270458888,
-0.0461638607,
0.0367496461,
0.0251200516,
-0.0537142791,
-0.0578804538,
-0.0207245741,
-0.0598850437,
0.0108888689,
-0.004965649,
-0.003813785,
0.1089154258,
0.028815208,
-0.1037760228,
-0.0102347219,
0.0225455891,
0.0259179771,
-0.0119399484,
0.0963027552,
-0.0175168086,
0.013633403,
-0.0332727879,
0.1143169403,
-0.010127564,
0.0842783153,
0.0053363615,
0.0192935746,
0.0139085781,
0.0212609675,
-0.0153944446,
-0.0286126193,
0.0305511691,
-0.0137452716,
-0.0244861972,
-0.027895622,
-0.0233241264,
0.0051268945,
2.69e-7,
0.0598919317,
0.0534773991,
-0.02523355,
-0.0367518589,
0.0197807457,
0.0641876832,
0.0085081104,
0.0076103797,
-0.0026942813,
0.000406225,
0.024842551,
0.0126687773,
-0.0046355505,
0.0398769975,
-0.0453531258,
0.0416172184,
0.0113426149,
0.001621191,
-0.0254320204,
0.0300966594,
0.0681343973,
0.0891053677,
0.0312152915,
0.000743743,
-0.0216688905,
0.0828075036,
0.0533309206,
-0.0194291305,
-0.0069358852,
0.0072238911,
-0.0186546594,
-0.0216346309,
-0.0165792108,
-0.0282517802,
-0.0166953299,
0.032140594,
-0.0082267001,
0.0531711839,
0.0165786818,
-0.0484180264,
0.0370150134,
0.0380816683,
0.0251342263,
0.0139749357,
0.0340181738,
-0.0595339648,
-0.0475746505,
-0.1093488485,
-0.0242314152,
0.0515531823,
0.0431107581,
0.0170794725,
0.000635869,
0.0614645034,
-0.0324476287,
-0.0556211993,
-0.0388220251,
-0.0741477832,
0.0152248656,
0.0475427248,
0.0132468827,
-0.0002139015,
0.0597732216,
0.0081181582,
0.0056393784,
-0.0237963498,
0.0072649149,
2.097435259e-34,
0.0683969632,
-0.0179167055,
0.005479658,
0.033606071,
-0.0119653139,
-0.0268697105,
-0.0404913016,
-0.0223816857,
0.0067078769,
-0.0095943287,
0.0178588796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15833v1 | Dialogue Shaping: Empowering Agents through NPC Interaction | 2023-07-28T22:44:54 | 2023-07-28T22:44:54 | Wei Zhou, Xiangyu Peng, Mark Riedl | cs.CL | cs.CL | One major challenge in reinforcement learning (RL) is the large amount of
steps for the RL agent needs to converge in the training process and learn the
optimal policy, especially in text-based game environments where the action
space is extensive. However, non-player characters (NPCs) sometimes hold some
key information about the game, which can potentially help to train RL agents
faster. Thus, this paper explores how to interact and converse with NPC agents
to get the key information using large language models (LLMs), as well as
incorporate this information to speed up RL agent's training using knowledge
graphs (KGs) and Story Shaping. | [
0.0517673828,
0.0339317657,
-0.0199959856,
0.0479673631,
-0.0051460089,
0.0026876424,
-0.0236901548,
-0.0006541503,
0.0290834699,
-0.0136422226,
-0.005688753,
0.0077881338,
-0.0086940527,
0.0374155305,
-0.0130595556,
-0.0566793196,
0.0121789807,
-0.04914717,
0.0713941753,
0.0199307185,
-0.0179187916,
0.0076489407,
-0.0209387876,
0.0451989919,
-0.0008440401,
-0.0270472933,
-0.0413970202,
0.0036287366,
0.0299029071,
-0.0576000661,
-0.0028692007,
-0.0455787592,
0.028233692,
-0.0074063763,
0.0000019284,
-0.0212815963,
-0.005404199,
-0.0258422084,
-0.0183322467,
-0.0211984757,
0.0257598162,
-0.0052500521,
0.0124006812,
-0.0141166784,
-0.0539150834,
-0.0222141501,
0.0494130254,
0.0793776959,
0.0563437641,
0.0875218511,
0.0077246949,
-0.0141793955,
-0.0385803208,
0.0095172618,
0.0165598802,
-0.0813744515,
0.0093613714,
0.0457776301,
0.0345956683,
-0.0233122762,
-0.0268904679,
-0.0002248908,
0.0053001214,
-0.0291570555,
-0.029884195,
0.0606840439,
0.0352863595,
0.0319597237,
0.0022310636,
0.067981258,
0.0144247105,
0.0030180879,
0.0156403556,
0.0002387829,
0.0292401761,
0.049986247,
-0.0336650088,
0.0311375652,
-0.0173335001,
0.0192039702,
-0.0100670587,
-0.0225860383,
0.0201107394,
-0.0065506944,
-0.0226621907,
0.0600691214,
-0.0358522683,
-0.0398441851,
-0.0155497445,
-0.011897577,
0.0160072595,
-0.066967465,
-0.048458226,
0.0436333381,
-0.0604971498,
0.0350884534,
-0.0196279064,
0.0692428127,
-0.0307454318,
-0.0624138042,
-0.0097129112,
0.0080474112,
0.042191226,
0.0381330997,
-0.0117562227,
0.0457879193,
0.0202146731,
-0.0180295464,
-0.0070892991,
0.0185767282,
-0.0614805818,
-0.020495642,
-0.0528475605,
0.0490132868,
-0.0414682627,
-0.0511669405,
-0.0008542305,
0.0454812162,
-0.0096499827,
0.0556878559,
0.0020136365,
-0.0025161447,
-0.0089212526,
-0.0016079179,
-0.0884328708,
0.0263643023,
-0.0421028621,
0.0071841618,
-0.0052415151,
-0.0110170264,
0.0035367445,
-0.037558943,
0.0092929481,
0.0081712184,
0.0193342902,
0.1111849248,
-0.0003805107,
-0.0184394941,
-0.0322407521,
-0.0257704593,
0.0119065661,
-0.0611269772,
-0.0655530766,
-0.0428538583,
0.0044363029,
-0.0137458425,
0.0338211916,
-0.0295751784,
0.0140570095,
0.0014099402,
-0.0239163283,
0.0818816051,
-0.0014052342,
0.0153211439,
0.0068184324,
0.0055791079,
-0.0060783918,
0.0524063818,
0.062913388,
0.0053021521,
0.0219447743,
0.0170540493,
-0.0011779881,
0.0060197962,
-0.0186979603,
-0.0125070317,
0.0254803635,
-0.004368077,
0.0108766621,
0.0636716634,
0.0214708485,
0.0327620544,
-0.0529361218,
0.0029816085,
0.0941687077,
0.0799592286,
0.0071848449,
-0.0148931546,
0.0369116068,
0.0466448851,
-0.0070820563,
0.0082520247,
-0.0115579674,
0.0097773494,
0.0077311173,
-0.0026491275,
-0.0496740676,
0.0264069848,
0.0027343486,
-0.038646128,
0.043505583,
-0.0246668011,
0.0674974844,
0.039943561,
0.0387916975,
0.0052113757,
-0.0674028844,
-0.0361252874,
0.0353797413,
-0.0508183166,
0.0088467347,
-0.0372378863,
0.0447036624,
0.1012710631,
0.037799418,
-0.0374995954,
-0.0484196804,
-0.0290699527,
-0.0395057015,
0.0209229104,
0.0022074559,
-0.0568279773,
0.0090921521,
-0.033180058,
-0.0243124347,
-0.0336965993,
-0.0167728402,
0.0606851429,
-0.0081655663,
0.0243334267,
-0.0043059229,
0.0238898415,
-0.0528073907,
0.0107584177,
-0.0128043853,
-0.0399079509,
-0.0039207633,
0.0008493817,
0.0005815508,
0.0370221846,
-0.0395827964,
-0.016990006,
0.0248591602,
-0.0094782244,
-0.0254088026,
0.0267771315,
-0.0195199847,
-0.0438570753,
0.0415962338,
-0.0376539901,
0.0129361292,
-0.0183562748,
0.0146367829,
-0.011201906,
0.0080692424,
-0.0349505208,
0.0903435573,
0.0306886435,
0.0316334181,
-0.0048135682,
-0.0384117104,
-0.0317686163,
0.0448767059,
0.0149485366,
-0.0232501775,
-0.0081810858,
-0.0126924133,
-0.0181847028,
-0.0232724603,
0.043716345,
0.0555673391,
0.0487526096,
-0.0162855219,
0.0621827208,
0.0224650409,
-0.0311899837,
-0.0277984161,
-0.0613333583,
-0.015354408,
0.0017614922,
-0.0020087934,
-0.0117694698,
-0.0009480864,
-0.0250320043,
-0.0199264847,
-0.0485566221,
0.0039175926,
0.0174421035,
-0.0150018651,
0.0027542149,
0.0779878125,
-0.0025612884,
-0.0078035151,
0.018706277,
-0.0038679715,
0.0363071561,
0.0273900311,
-0.0181849618,
-0.0210219081,
0.0542921647,
-0.0209279153,
0.0455932394,
-0.0564044602,
-0.036593996,
0.0494088829,
-0.0225417037,
0.0382039547,
0.0579247661,
0.0064855549,
0.0442884155,
0.0479598343,
-0.0538634211,
-0.0354980789,
0.0363085046,
-0.0245620552,
-0.0372094251,
-0.0934808403,
-0.0048705959,
0.0610653982,
0.0744450986,
0.000102352,
0.0020850336,
-0.0861079097,
0.0046939077,
0.0004183994,
-0.0389497243,
-0.0177064091,
-0.0294543672,
-0.0121948123,
-0.023328675,
-0.0332066864,
0.0146064041,
0.086410217,
-0.0296107549,
-0.0096489917,
-0.0236420576,
-0.0362887606,
-0.0366623402,
0.0613409616,
0.0136362584,
0.0323064849,
-0.0044322414,
-0.0198209956,
-0.0260023065,
-0.0536725223,
0.0681815892,
0.0000889339,
0.0387463532,
-0.0512912758,
0.0079117753,
0.0436235033,
-0.0374162644,
-0.0147485994,
-0.0095887072,
-0.0278943237,
-0.0397031158,
0.0309865568,
-0.0563437156,
-0.0117356433,
0.0038474759,
0.0430563577,
0.025526097,
-0.0045354543,
-0.033782836,
-0.020932842,
-0.028716309,
0.0721199214,
0.001434517,
-0.0171742234,
-0.0651176423,
0.0761305019,
0.0344548859,
-0.0032092438,
-0.0477976166,
0.0044988259,
-0.0233852044,
0.0040361653,
-0.0506654382,
-0.0042357538,
0.0384250171,
0.0226376019,
-0.0616829395,
0.0076262611,
0.1054227278,
0.0093434043,
-0.0156205492,
0.013510054,
-0.0299999416,
-0.0022910659,
0.009103436,
0.0173376631,
-0.061106544,
0.0027131806,
-0.0214130208,
0.0280697327,
-0.0083383191,
-0.0715862587,
-0.0183532014,
-0.1131338924,
-0.0117473276,
0.0066299825,
-0.0395358466,
-0.0411655568,
-0.0030294247,
-0.0103643415,
-0.0063087298,
-0.0181597397,
-0.0144596156,
-0.0094024036,
0.0018629925,
0.0026234358,
0.0017178287,
0.0302600414,
-0.0211353321,
-0.0815823004,
0.0897847414,
0.0443708748,
0.0603064224,
0.0170821361,
0.0449896567,
-0.0489429571,
0.072139971,
0.0203346722,
-0.0162194483,
0.0129772834,
-0.0549567118,
-0.0033313371,
-0.0132778874,
0.0323494859,
0.0202997755,
-0.0163939483,
0.053109929,
0.0506180152,
-0.0053194091,
-0.0377043597,
0.0215647127,
0.0258856509,
0.0603758283,
0.0548710786,
-0.0097265244,
-0.0469604842,
-0.0121065769,
-0.0076276623,
-0.0247079935,
-0.0028818876,
-0.0337800309,
-0.01094859,
-0.024482524,
0.0575276911,
-0.0550113767,
-0.0595495999,
0.0145308832,
0.0385319814,
0.024374444,
0.0599881411,
0.0523880199,
0.0250451751,
0.0305459443,
0.0006484856,
-0.0378019735,
-0.0163777452,
-0.0280902237,
-0.0429703407,
0.0190862045,
-0.0509476475,
0.0221582744,
-0.0027456663,
0.0065152962,
-0.0565361343,
-0.0344545506,
0.0266610757,
0.0024477292,
0.0798498616,
0.0394153297,
-0.0474408269,
0.0313250646,
-0.0081225261,
-0.0703509599,
0.0233018696,
-0.0011718123,
0.0445560776,
0.0289570913,
0.0198570807,
-0.0685628578,
-0.0128228515,
-0.0370706655,
0.0383622721,
-0.070591934,
-0.0449739173,
0.0147768836,
-0.0053982195,
-0.0304925162,
-0.0144597841,
-0.0073681199,
-0.0321271643,
0.034551952,
-0.0621536635,
-0.0005314427,
-0.0426610149,
0.0060973107,
0.0435999185,
0.0214782152,
0.0235780943,
0.0009998058,
-0.0177342873,
0.0044748168,
-0.0071547949,
0.0129815191,
0.0648206472,
-0.0026848305,
0.0496074446,
-0.0036103558,
0.0249683354,
0.0185526572,
-0.0056096348,
0.0309586301,
0.0432912931,
0.0634569526,
0.0511368662,
-0.0379598811,
-0.012215266,
-0.0017427612,
-0.019624969,
-0.0501186065,
0.0379981175,
0.0242952015,
0.0449056737,
0.0258217268,
0.0415701643,
-0.067904897,
0.024583023,
0.0173970554,
-0.0114623131,
0.0175208393,
-0.0275081191,
0.0038310753,
0.0432806052,
-0.0275460575,
0.0350687057,
0.0488144718,
0.0429245569,
0.0948985964,
-0.0091654873,
-0.0455373339,
-0.0406582803,
-0.0234891698,
0.026617676,
0.0529530719,
-0.0178707987,
0.0282481425,
-0.0500393063,
-0.0149138803,
-0.0611304976,
0.0620408431,
-0.0148133812,
-0.039279785,
0.0173087455,
-0.0154812187,
0.0229606926,
-0.0388591997,
-0.0722454265,
0.0079386542,
-0.0485184193,
-0.012695305,
-0.007588692,
-5.118884107e-33,
-0.0508112609,
-0.0531145334,
0.0520399585,
0.0402415879,
-0.0672108531,
-0.0009026046,
-0.0279281456,
-0.0158301126,
0.0084015122,
0.0382363535,
0.0034774838,
0.0148828709,
-0.0086850645,
-0.0090144398,
-0.0278758332,
-0.0230038315,
0.0316642039,
0.0186823476,
-0.0437872298,
0.0237382241,
0.0434796549,
0.0177030116,
0.0281063449,
-0.0959425196,
0.0166046731,
0.0024510904,
-0.0034052667,
0.0254684277,
0.0276373588,
0.0257357247,
0.0170649216,
-0.0046998262,
0.0051106769,
-0.0313706808,
-0.0049165501,
0.0153681673,
-0.050261423,
-0.0155273201,
0.0374410637,
0.0067750341,
-0.0151545629,
-0.0465776883,
-0.0114692319,
0.0148245953,
0.0396508835,
0.0070008258,
0.035464108,
-0.0099217743,
-0.0102790538,
-0.0000416332,
-0.0823171884,
0.0065611922,
-0.0445217788,
-0.0252349656,
0.0115922326,
0.0006146935,
-0.000198542,
-0.0468628965,
0.0015268886,
0.048653353,
0.0577271059,
-0.0006572515,
0.0038065317,
0.0741357729,
0.043900568,
0.0411220528,
-0.0012942555,
-0.007474333,
-0.0540682971,
-0.0211100951,
0.019871749,
0.0329569131,
-0.0051689539,
0.0346760824,
-0.0385731161,
0.0140390303,
-0.0610296614,
0.0086652162,
0.0497147068,
0.0532877594,
0.0085483156,
0.0062900828,
-0.0680892915,
-0.0104016624,
-0.0593606979,
0.0099025508,
0.0290512219,
-0.0728224739,
0.0211466923,
-0.0059675579,
0.0154418563,
-0.0619488284,
0.0149408914,
-0.0369511433,
0.0006816009,
0.0530423708,
-0.0318399221,
0.0118676042,
-0.0438572541,
-0.0157722048,
-0.0546491258,
-0.0235313717,
0.0337421969,
-0.0361954048,
0.03243839,
0.0255774539,
-0.0335201025,
0.0515977405,
-0.0219229087,
-0.0039562318,
0.0088428138,
0.0235887282,
0.0185063984,
0.0103475321,
0.0166096091,
-0.0444819927,
-0.0151474653,
0.0471827984,
-0.0187682118,
-0.0461440533,
0.0093797287,
-0.0223507602,
-0.0188238211,
-0.014415944,
-0.0396830179,
0.0107778935,
-0.0415852889,
0.0548485927,
0.026388403,
-0.0413018614,
-0.0082741827,
0.0125968661,
2.742e-7,
-0.0546393134,
0.0405502208,
-0.0000499888,
0.0529305302,
-0.0186923631,
0.0542389005,
0.0079677766,
0.0133129414,
-0.0126633672,
-0.0110499803,
0.0540561453,
0.0615478717,
0.0008729309,
0.0088940924,
-0.0838982388,
-0.0304341149,
-0.0429806001,
-0.044278048,
-0.0536053553,
-0.0130429603,
0.0431086197,
0.0344955996,
0.0454443693,
0.0051466301,
0.0314926505,
-0.0187048968,
0.0130169895,
-0.0530529208,
-0.0203934144,
0.0354534723,
0.0029901389,
-0.0166940894,
-0.0556600094,
0.0003088628,
0.007780219,
0.0512989685,
-0.0347625501,
0.0463705994,
-0.0262426734,
0.0080161849,
-0.0005648279,
-0.0046882271,
-0.0251545217,
-0.0045077573,
0.0570529476,
-0.0358769409,
-0.0289378427,
-0.0087929303,
0.0294301249,
-0.0618007928,
-0.0598120093,
-0.0345520154,
0.0039321091,
-0.0044285706,
-0.0084966421,
0.0022544053,
0.0195379686,
-0.0608064346,
0.0291200764,
0.0389961824,
-0.0028063527,
-0.0672353655,
-0.0258398131,
-0.0032930223,
-0.0065902392,
-0.0304280352,
0.0336589627,
2.129706482e-34,
-0.0335679911,
-0.0043531125,
-0.0144511489,
0.0121187167,
0.0492068157,
0.0289542638,
-0.0179504659,
0.0138195073,
0.0692666173,
-0.0803155676,
-0.0021612532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15818v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15818v1 | RT-2: Vision-Language-Action Models Transfer Web Knowledge to Robotic Control | 2023-07-28T21:18:02 | 2023-07-28T21:18:02 | Anthony Brohan, Noah Brown, Justice Carbajal, Yevgen Chebotar, Xi Chen, Krzysztof Choromanski, Tianli Ding, Danny Driess, Avinava Dubey, Chelsea Finn, Pete Florence, Chuyuan Fu, Montse Gonzalez Arenas, Keerthana Gopalakrishnan, Kehang Han, Karol Hausman, Alexander Herzog, Jasmine Hsu, Brian Ichter, Alex Irpan, Nikhil Joshi, Ryan Julian, Dmitry Kalashnikov, Yuheng Kuang, Isabel Leal, Lisa Lee, Tsang-Wei Edward Lee, Sergey Levine, Yao Lu, Henryk Michalewski, Igor Mordatch, Karl Pertsch, Kanishka Rao, Krista Reymann, Michael Ryoo, Grecia Salazar, Pannag Sanketi, Pierre Sermanet, Jaspiar Singh, Anikait Singh, Radu Soricut, Huong Tran, Vincent Vanhoucke, Quan Vuong, Ayzaan Wahid, Stefan Welker, Paul Wohlhart, Jialin Wu, Fei Xia, Ted Xiao, Peng Xu, Sichun Xu, Tianhe Yu, Brianna Zitkovich | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | We study how vision-language models trained on Internet-scale data can be
incorporated directly into end-to-end robotic control to boost generalization
and enable emergent semantic reasoning. Our goal is to enable a single
end-to-end trained model to both learn to map robot observations to actions and
enjoy the benefits of large-scale pretraining on language and vision-language
data from the web. To this end, we propose to co-fine-tune state-of-the-art
vision-language models on both robotic trajectory data and Internet-scale
vision-language tasks, such as visual question answering. In contrast to other
approaches, we propose a simple, general recipe to achieve this goal: in order
to fit both natural language responses and robotic actions into the same
format, we express the actions as text tokens and incorporate them directly
into the training set of the model in the same way as natural language tokens.
We refer to such category of models as vision-language-action models (VLA) and
instantiate an example of such a model, which we call RT-2. Our extensive
evaluation (6k evaluation trials) shows that our approach leads to performant
robotic policies and enables RT-2 to obtain a range of emergent capabilities
from Internet-scale training. This includes significantly improved
generalization to novel objects, the ability to interpret commands not present
in the robot training data (such as placing an object onto a particular number
or icon), and the ability to perform rudimentary reasoning in response to user
commands (such as picking up the smallest or largest object, or the one closest
to another object). We further show that incorporating chain of thought
reasoning allows RT-2 to perform multi-stage semantic reasoning, for example
figuring out which object to pick up for use as an improvised hammer (a rock),
or which type of drink is best suited for someone who is tired (an energy
drink). | [
0.051007878,
0.0471717454,
0.0100361798,
0.0169711318,
-0.0206633583,
0.0308011547,
-0.012166868,
-0.0376859009,
0.0087126484,
-0.08302214,
0.0025665408,
0.0137425903,
-0.0308624487,
0.085100852,
0.0245092474,
-0.0519253463,
0.0214206185,
-0.0582679659,
0.0059707453,
0.0160727277,
0.0248347688,
0.01284914,
-0.043051254,
0.0575494021,
-0.0258247145,
0.00587002,
-0.0396953784,
-0.0024953017,
0.0248285718,
-0.0343068428,
-0.0169928614,
-0.0121489111,
0.1070497185,
0.0066870139,
0.0000017442,
-0.0726955682,
0.0218021329,
-0.0056033363,
0.0114040235,
-0.0570258014,
-0.0103277005,
-0.0117069446,
0.0335062854,
0.0442785099,
-0.0419518016,
-0.0060300324,
0.0586375706,
0.0223389994,
0.0537304319,
0.0459880345,
-0.0004778705,
-0.0119084651,
0.0176815335,
0.0200366843,
0.0279764421,
-0.0185479168,
0.0141671244,
0.0324559063,
0.030090699,
0.0084173232,
-0.0551979989,
-0.0106187062,
0.0314249843,
-0.0224239156,
-0.0054594842,
0.0574645586,
-0.0336242057,
-0.0415697321,
-0.0211735759,
0.0588438176,
-0.0133223841,
-0.0333638713,
0.030363543,
0.0227825101,
0.015857162,
0.0009920978,
-0.0339243449,
0.0568254404,
0.0078304075,
-0.0151013322,
-0.0505255312,
-0.0238372386,
-0.0063902219,
0.0317699313,
-0.0371830761,
0.0656893626,
-0.0213324856,
0.012228651,
0.0007820296,
-0.0048209615,
-0.0234431699,
-0.066112265,
-0.0198627319,
0.0850288719,
-0.0321966074,
0.0191305634,
-0.0427883379,
0.0266521517,
-0.036529392,
-0.005274314,
0.0520387404,
0.0415760912,
-0.0220174585,
0.067804113,
-0.0238751415,
0.0719156489,
-0.0224349014,
0.0658111796,
-0.0273623504,
-0.025656091,
-0.0772059038,
-0.0009959406,
-0.0298772156,
0.0320587568,
-0.0199121777,
-0.0606921576,
0.0128933229,
0.0592969432,
-0.021994995,
0.0070921006,
-0.0220628344,
0.0481417589,
-0.0071015968,
-0.0173990596,
-0.0671733767,
0.0168268736,
-0.0298096277,
0.0455604382,
0.0056230319,
-0.0185161717,
-0.0024746077,
0.0061577959,
0.0465930104,
0.0023482784,
0.0115134167,
0.1021315381,
-0.0270799417,
-0.0217560902,
-0.006036324,
-0.0259107333,
0.0147076901,
-0.0263486393,
0.0503429696,
-0.0734838918,
0.0366698354,
-0.002371605,
-0.0316714384,
-0.0125768976,
0.0173913836,
0.018071657,
-0.0098051317,
0.0960996002,
-0.0331170373,
-0.0075273104,
0.0009435114,
-0.0081808465,
-0.0245963503,
0.0379836857,
0.0588331968,
0.0331543237,
0.0111172814,
0.036621172,
0.0151647329,
0.0110075325,
-0.0287075713,
-0.0105911782,
-0.0315084681,
0.0275476407,
0.0072898301,
0.0425921679,
0.0200115424,
0.0092015695,
-0.0410452336,
0.0260782298,
0.0545135997,
0.0537661761,
-0.0485142395,
-0.0154495565,
0.0434517264,
0.012702358,
-0.0201822016,
-0.0704764426,
-0.0559522435,
0.061724551,
-0.0110512692,
-0.0017246216,
-0.0499530323,
0.0068047452,
-0.0295397919,
-0.041090358,
0.0075886338,
-0.0011468024,
0.0424662903,
0.0305342693,
0.0553173497,
0.0248773023,
-0.0151993213,
-0.0138420565,
0.0127011351,
-0.0325242132,
0.0272516254,
-0.0553405397,
0.0063173366,
0.0364037156,
0.0133526288,
-0.0160908289,
-0.0390474647,
-0.0166738704,
0.0469572321,
0.025048757,
-0.0215842407,
-0.019027574,
-0.0119285332,
-0.0129185673,
-0.0619140789,
-0.0069789723,
-0.0342351384,
-0.0063027088,
0.0103577878,
-0.015849296,
-0.0167814195,
-0.0209943932,
0.0014019964,
0.0360035412,
0.0559007898,
0.0086617908,
-0.0191837382,
0.0185244847,
0.0245047901,
-0.0155202085,
-0.0016887352,
0.0016086183,
0.0051128748,
-0.0167596266,
-0.0458939858,
0.0048815589,
0.0067891758,
0.0007722789,
0.04618847,
-0.0544175655,
-0.0238907523,
0.0592258126,
-0.0597129241,
-0.0284955297,
0.0102272332,
-0.0154784061,
0.0166147649,
-0.0026447983,
-0.0210741777,
0.0350150578,
-0.024085477,
-0.0061582956,
0.0353103504,
-0.0204367694,
-0.0357391052,
-0.0114465915,
0.017611701,
-0.0256468672,
-0.025266869,
0.0051671723,
0.0136685483,
-0.0201426893,
0.0150679955,
0.036506515,
0.0381456502,
-0.041810926,
0.010621259,
-0.0671034828,
-0.0218830053,
-0.0095255813,
-0.0152115617,
0.0190766118,
-0.0035498133,
0.0140473451,
-0.0480762534,
0.0072965855,
0.0325447917,
-0.0133054741,
0.0157528874,
0.05156352,
0.0255672,
-0.0171381831,
-0.0263858829,
0.0070376038,
-0.0170561913,
0.0097150225,
0.0422513783,
0.001130505,
-0.0388716869,
0.0129340347,
-0.0720341355,
0.0679988116,
-0.031116128,
-0.0510756411,
0.0668192953,
-0.0594329573,
-0.0200461894,
0.1046782658,
-0.0041137189,
0.0065340335,
0.0567896217,
-0.004896943,
-0.0465443172,
0.0181235187,
-0.0160349328,
-0.0526808016,
-0.0507858507,
0.040915329,
0.0045988704,
0.0454062931,
-0.0351877958,
-0.0122652203,
-0.0715649351,
0.0104601383,
-0.0086716656,
-0.0458753556,
-0.0765177161,
0.029195277,
-0.0258377343,
0.0345257185,
-0.0377121232,
-0.0569131002,
0.0493775494,
0.0024495942,
-0.0026879434,
0.0128468145,
-0.0100092096,
-0.0031436575,
0.0807857513,
0.0565636344,
0.030571321,
-0.0163344499,
-0.0048971246,
-0.0630433187,
-0.0095932586,
0.0075575123,
0.018946344,
0.0229047015,
-0.0883841515,
0.0277179498,
0.0015622538,
-0.0372619405,
-0.0241083354,
0.0118854344,
-0.0418917537,
0.0250089765,
-0.078399919,
-0.0635874942,
0.0029048023,
-0.023267597,
0.0458726622,
0.0513046235,
0.0107692452,
-0.0341061465,
-0.0493662357,
-0.0185800958,
0.1003704593,
0.0329463184,
-0.0330095254,
-0.0012162463,
-0.0276594143,
0.0487219878,
0.0669438764,
-0.0445849076,
-0.0567207895,
0.0407403931,
0.0148489745,
-0.007724944,
0.03384839,
0.0658974722,
0.0461280495,
-0.0451170579,
-0.0357653871,
0.0776185542,
0.0172256865,
0.0277271438,
-0.0062966319,
0.0293756649,
0.0264162477,
0.0573382489,
0.0344529673,
-0.0386762545,
-0.0445184074,
0.0029788113,
-0.0088290535,
0.0125399232,
-0.0401046611,
-0.0187794864,
-0.1170999482,
0.0006667753,
-0.0355347618,
-0.0446385145,
-0.0475364886,
0.0079548797,
0.0272400491,
-0.0104354853,
-0.0593694858,
0.0134418961,
-0.0205998216,
0.0053257956,
-0.0004731921,
-0.0042065326,
-0.0016864422,
0.0291820914,
-0.0509863533,
-0.0101116244,
0.0272753835,
-0.0040295515,
-0.0149907172,
-0.0050296201,
0.0292343479,
0.018608816,
-0.0011432127,
-0.0128253978,
0.0087243142,
-0.0459635518,
-0.0276648942,
0.0044686007,
0.0682028681,
-0.0410215668,
-0.0493282564,
-0.0310196895,
0.0612537749,
-0.013977292,
-0.0038920818,
-0.0257070269,
-0.0270607658,
0.0047381362,
0.0329422839,
-0.0114587983,
-0.0315693021,
-0.0544768125,
-0.0294088591,
-0.0784941688,
-0.0035744556,
-0.0429297723,
-0.0208710674,
0.0425457098,
-0.0061279596,
-0.0852994621,
-0.0311571695,
0.0709921867,
0.0598848537,
-0.0117438594,
-0.0559910946,
0.0309787542,
0.0541932173,
-0.0597980991,
0.0473884456,
-0.0394264236,
0.0000832543,
-0.0098967366,
-0.0013968237,
0.0315468237,
-0.037921045,
-0.059865512,
0.0037655963,
-0.048353266,
-0.0419578478,
-0.0295689087,
0.0828477815,
0.0220832154,
0.0411591157,
-0.0037790905,
-0.0333237797,
0.0410121158,
0.0092624193,
0.0111986129,
-0.0048611201,
0.0027181837,
0.0262781661,
0.0163996164,
0.0249579698,
-0.0789158493,
-0.0027090805,
-0.0066007324,
0.0239802133,
-0.0320057012,
0.0015487296,
0.0303984508,
-0.0336930417,
0.050417345,
0.0091141416,
0.0137795834,
-0.0398694091,
0.0081419591,
0.0153217129,
-0.0003379131,
-0.0893353745,
0.0132779786,
0.0012818959,
0.0262724292,
0.0229921341,
0.0090188477,
0.0214501787,
0.0111036533,
0.00967809,
-0.041986689,
0.0486425199,
0.0385131165,
0.0158488471,
0.010388175,
-0.0143878832,
-0.0185682196,
-0.0105111245,
0.0289779902,
-0.0062333075,
0.0656578988,
0.0537599437,
-0.0097885812,
-0.0243008453,
0.0350044221,
-0.0754209086,
-0.097130768,
-0.0028262709,
0.0169184487,
0.033047732,
0.0092219822,
0.0048241522,
-0.0646932721,
-0.0040050596,
0.0085906973,
0.0611000471,
0.0087403199,
-0.0443890952,
0.0768052116,
0.0326140709,
0.0087721869,
0.0012107902,
0.0555265583,
0.0150874043,
0.0573714636,
-0.0055372263,
-0.0017760507,
-0.0321357474,
-0.0396520309,
-0.0096976077,
0.0052171969,
0.0197512601,
0.0331869237,
-0.0054267296,
-0.0674583986,
-0.0398528799,
0.0604103059,
-0.0226101577,
0.0135234902,
0.0624925345,
0.0082674623,
0.0167329106,
-0.0375423729,
-0.0003191991,
-0.0349678397,
0.0161513072,
-0.0172067415,
-0.0192096066,
-5.199613018e-33,
0.0116614643,
-0.0281398091,
0.0468470715,
-0.0080753593,
-0.0029265322,
-0.0238145515,
-0.0145934327,
-0.0036349986,
-0.0193255506,
0.0191099811,
0.0067620068,
0.0191527661,
0.0041358196,
0.0495884754,
0.0299443845,
-0.0378309153,
0.0172769465,
-0.0040855221,
-0.008029744,
0.01471473,
0.0535039976,
0.0082476959,
0.0286738668,
-0.0199086722,
-0.0097451536,
0.0054606432,
-0.0224620681,
0.0662144944,
0.0156174721,
0.0516585037,
0.0060410425,
-0.0031803539,
0.0260371584,
0.0121578816,
-0.0323565602,
0.0425208621,
-0.079857327,
-0.038401179,
-0.0057200566,
0.0121518029,
-0.095348686,
0.019377891,
0.0223333966,
-0.0115003912,
0.0371436477,
-0.0351102352,
0.0444993488,
0.0066495449,
0.0172034949,
0.002934444,
-0.023622537,
-0.0336969756,
-0.013696759,
-0.0601324588,
0.0010538399,
0.0438572057,
0.011133885,
0.0134954369,
-0.0129666431,
0.0055483249,
-0.0362415276,
0.002319044,
0.0712459832,
0.0434111543,
0.0305775888,
0.0689996183,
-0.004965839,
-0.0520529225,
0.0094147287,
-0.0018358149,
0.0237226561,
0.0573928468,
0.0090191821,
0.0395306274,
0.0075913714,
0.0474123172,
-0.0712249503,
-0.0041237432,
-0.0676341951,
0.1039737463,
-0.0345389023,
0.0096028922,
-0.0057663121,
0.0161917321,
-0.0350047275,
0.0021812641,
-0.0338766128,
0.0068654041,
0.082945779,
0.018508302,
-0.0095331464,
-0.0102230245,
0.0527041964,
-0.0570150986,
-0.0210816674,
0.030440351,
-0.0246620588,
0.0510805398,
0.0007385479,
0.0068218005,
-0.037114609,
-0.0204037968,
0.0314930677,
-0.0207111575,
-0.0048211096,
0.0225798581,
0.0057613119,
0.0653007105,
-0.016496256,
-0.0066051767,
-0.0613591149,
-0.0114136077,
0.0219824426,
-0.0027324082,
0.0497994497,
0.0240516327,
-0.0495021343,
0.0537990667,
-0.0401640758,
-0.0334534384,
-0.000633289,
-0.0146780601,
-0.0185265802,
-0.0101668155,
-0.0366091318,
-0.0061604986,
-0.0556213893,
0.0547860302,
0.0017656471,
-0.047772821,
-0.0053188074,
0.0627582222,
2.449e-7,
0.015791947,
0.0085724359,
-0.00269459,
0.0469240136,
0.0150559284,
0.0528804883,
0.000890894,
0.0634929389,
-0.0048970585,
-0.0348166078,
-0.0055921492,
0.0717727318,
0.0113809211,
-0.0388288647,
-0.0463643856,
-0.0026388946,
0.0021613562,
-0.0480418988,
-0.0585139543,
-0.007441598,
0.0682477355,
0.0744237676,
-0.0043532616,
-0.003165063,
0.0514280647,
-0.0544065908,
0.0563443266,
-0.0339956619,
0.0202597957,
-0.0340036377,
-0.0225858446,
0.0187774114,
-0.0156524796,
0.0177337099,
-0.0167581439,
-0.0258275755,
-0.0037861038,
0.037467733,
-0.0305369012,
-0.0055824406,
-0.0295175295,
0.0018154941,
0.0009505703,
-0.0522029027,
0.0898779556,
-0.0947299153,
0.0146912783,
0.0110405255,
0.0051704259,
-0.0136464965,
-0.0330315568,
-0.008109278,
-0.0253798235,
0.0007475569,
0.0029691183,
0.0031765844,
-0.0063134795,
-0.0785514042,
0.0090517709,
-0.0079411333,
-0.0245734304,
-0.0053809043,
-0.0269788615,
-0.0082894564,
0.0385048613,
0.0029109383,
-0.057448633,
1.502796977e-34,
-0.0204011388,
0.0041452055,
0.0052763713,
-0.009707801,
0.0244938694,
0.0200980771,
-0.0044250567,
0.0094067762,
0.0304223932,
-0.0513015427,
-0.0333962701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15776v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15776v2 | Select and Augment: Enhanced Dense Retrieval Knowledge Graph Augmentation | 2023-07-28T19:33:18 | 2023-10-25T10:35:03 | Micheal Abaho, Yousef H. Alfaifi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Injecting textual information into knowledge graph (KG) entity
representations has been a worthwhile expedition in terms of improving
performance in KG oriented tasks within the NLP community. External knowledge
often adopted to enhance KG embeddings ranges from semantically rich lexical
dependency parsed features to a set of relevant key words to entire text
descriptions supplied from an external corpus such as wikipedia and many more.
Despite the gains this innovation (Text-enhanced KG embeddings) has made, the
proposal in this work suggests that it can be improved even further. Instead of
using a single text description (which would not sufficiently represent an
entity because of the inherent lexical ambiguity of text), we propose a
multi-task framework that jointly selects a set of text descriptions relevant
to KG entities as well as align or augment KG embeddings with text
descriptions. Different from prior work that plugs formal entity descriptions
declared in knowledge bases, this framework leverages a retriever model to
selectively identify richer or highly relevant text descriptions to use in
augmenting entities. Furthermore, the framework treats the number of
descriptions to use in augmentation process as a parameter, which allows the
flexibility of enumerating across several numbers before identifying an
appropriate number. Experiment results for Link Prediction demonstrate a 5.5%
and 3.5% percentage increase in the Mean Reciprocal Rank (MRR) and Hits@10
scores respectively, in comparison to text-enhanced knowledge graph
augmentation methods using traditional CNNs. | [
0.0496186502,
-0.0144868894,
-0.0185751505,
0.052164834,
0.0106942896,
-0.0061650183,
-0.0486382321,
0.02941164,
0.0862730071,
-0.0708315,
0.0103714187,
0.0329943411,
-0.0565997735,
0.0393046588,
0.0625150055,
-0.0096547818,
0.0151554588,
0.040240068,
-0.003311333,
0.0052512814,
0.0182525683,
0.05845806,
0.0254455786,
0.0032521533,
0.0145785073,
0.0184475519,
0.0066708983,
0.0052212859,
0.0280197691,
-0.026476616,
0.0088075763,
0.0285280608,
0.0240346529,
-0.0222819801,
0.0000019673,
-0.0353993773,
-0.0063769212,
0.003680764,
-0.0600295216,
-0.0152986581,
0.0005424704,
-0.0359636284,
0.076361537,
-0.0365419462,
-0.0097591076,
-0.0179696418,
0.0079203732,
0.073608771,
-0.0060326313,
0.066988647,
-0.0090125967,
0.001168359,
0.0126776733,
-0.0299099889,
0.0078163622,
-0.0227671936,
0.0174483415,
0.0177351758,
0.0019919479,
0.0818036124,
-0.0108096795,
0.0314954855,
0.0163413007,
-0.0206552129,
0.1381852031,
0.0345637016,
-0.0066774362,
0.0265677497,
0.0342392772,
0.1066623181,
0.0113839442,
-0.0128145684,
0.0096874097,
-0.0016188631,
0.0144312009,
0.0199075826,
-0.0116103841,
-0.035493385,
-0.0047490643,
0.014449832,
-0.0411790498,
0.032559827,
0.051020205,
0.0237181876,
-0.0112167709,
0.0297743957,
0.0014341224,
-0.0294714309,
0.0416557454,
0.0489395559,
-0.0386315696,
-0.0347048044,
0.0128906826,
0.0183331724,
-0.0084794136,
0.0219522193,
-0.0182042476,
-0.0391494632,
0.0211403593,
-0.0322551243,
-0.0476031229,
0.00350114,
-0.0193072278,
0.0531715974,
-0.0611579157,
0.0145049179,
-0.0137169929,
-0.0109292483,
-0.0465833507,
-0.0182153843,
-0.0657258555,
-0.0213783029,
-0.0357222483,
0.0591873378,
-0.0371977314,
-0.024859352,
-0.0295700748,
0.0199348181,
-0.0388826244,
0.026557833,
0.0214615185,
0.0627521798,
-0.0225070715,
-0.0146820759,
-0.0570108257,
0.0070224642,
-0.0316684805,
0.0056985719,
-0.0104800854,
0.0001175849,
-0.0235123914,
0.0046927524,
0.0430890583,
-0.0737943575,
-0.0177266188,
0.0269833189,
0.0023350215,
-0.0208714921,
0.0003768409,
-0.0486644767,
0.0044222395,
-0.0159533788,
0.0069270832,
-0.0286350604,
0.0427101217,
0.0099354861,
-0.0126384683,
-0.0474966988,
0.028230926,
-0.014293191,
-0.0466047451,
0.0429861583,
-0.0540303811,
-0.0434109308,
-0.0149822384,
0.0115179522,
-0.0197805259,
0.0665876493,
0.0059154872,
0.0126412241,
0.0682249144,
0.0187299717,
-0.0467036217,
-0.0173030533,
0.0519955531,
-0.0028366453,
0.0243680365,
0.0249680448,
-0.0204277299,
0.0358176194,
0.0411729328,
0.0110187251,
-0.0329146087,
-0.0098434286,
0.0337033793,
0.0095466916,
0.0211189613,
0.0025323336,
0.0341185331,
0.041174341,
-0.0009211512,
-0.0081065809,
-0.0180541035,
0.0421696641,
-0.0109090609,
0.0099141113,
0.0242979378,
0.0270805322,
-0.0149246017,
0.0062285848,
-0.0010713808,
-0.0184752122,
0.0600769445,
0.0257169735,
0.0646370873,
0.0231609643,
-0.001945844,
0.0406428091,
0.0327882208,
0.0010076866,
0.0299220458,
0.0130832801,
-0.0375273451,
0.0598773584,
0.0302266143,
-0.0201843418,
-0.0302973296,
-0.0277982745,
-0.0342211127,
0.0049342131,
0.0345004387,
-0.0466519594,
-0.0145262191,
-0.0478158221,
-0.0542368367,
-0.0515730344,
0.0122073703,
-0.0093914755,
0.0499792546,
0.0468062237,
0.0738791227,
-0.0808474943,
-0.0130820675,
0.0145036448,
-0.0121642929,
0.0008983397,
0.0130959535,
0.0207239725,
-0.0239228513,
0.0528950989,
0.0295187123,
-0.0002867888,
0.039133314,
-0.0216302034,
-0.0600553229,
-0.0129804946,
0.0015732739,
-0.0413637497,
0.0163846388,
0.0159532875,
-0.0013058807,
0.0014255199,
-0.0323333405,
-0.0293280203,
0.0193486325,
-0.0220677778,
0.0454541855,
-0.0084240334,
-0.039130345,
-0.0008770743,
-0.015427866,
-0.0198187009,
0.0747798681,
0.0236158334,
0.0238903835,
-0.0063762213,
-0.0147754299,
0.0060853474,
-0.038421195,
-0.0679043308,
-0.0319823027,
0.0083947545,
-0.0038463227,
0.0303713623,
-0.0544729941,
-0.0809798911,
0.0374139138,
-0.105262965,
0.0085764267,
-0.0043096738,
0.0023736611,
-0.0021741418,
-0.0051754783,
0.0443285592,
-0.0095722126,
-0.0242528096,
0.0025643278,
-0.0235863123,
0.010968145,
0.0178434886,
0.005907103,
0.0334824137,
-0.0087515712,
-0.0188074093,
0.0016371388,
0.0561784767,
0.0172421038,
-0.0540840179,
-0.0162806418,
0.0408699587,
-0.0517918468,
-0.0227624457,
-0.040821936,
0.0557321422,
-0.0486433208,
-0.013257592,
0.0096055306,
0.0130415605,
-0.0326846689,
0.0438351594,
-0.0052283644,
0.0223783404,
-0.0581856072,
0.002961243,
-0.0232005715,
0.0465117767,
-0.0281349663,
0.020826323,
-0.0109187746,
-0.0085004289,
-0.0069291387,
-0.0549019389,
-0.0515832677,
-0.0304400977,
-0.0044188169,
0.0025214553,
-0.0495610684,
0.0004084274,
0.0197830442,
-0.0075890478,
-0.0388216153,
-0.0029277802,
0.0842736438,
0.0373935066,
0.0036920791,
-0.0058161705,
0.0015994069,
-0.0227128472,
0.0636619553,
0.0076090535,
-0.0109648891,
-0.0037476611,
0.0081885178,
-0.0072759571,
0.0412473492,
0.0090581952,
-0.0496306531,
0.0570351109,
0.0029339564,
0.0242955815,
0.0140796844,
-0.0393542647,
-0.0122201322,
0.005588904,
-0.0168036632,
0.0559358969,
0.0383682698,
-0.0013789785,
-0.0089470241,
-0.0096359868,
0.0130527169,
-0.0054350295,
-0.0132102035,
-0.0099612307,
-0.02512029,
0.0362540036,
0.0841550156,
0.0300660487,
-0.0106142201,
0.0319486745,
0.0081539806,
0.0277807526,
-0.0090931095,
-0.0639157519,
0.0055067334,
-0.0094286855,
-0.0040720426,
-0.0670332685,
-0.0333617106,
-0.0150837284,
0.0407575108,
-0.022363957,
-0.0113941114,
0.05640091,
0.0191997755,
-0.0471559018,
0.0022268135,
0.0234195832,
-0.0087500615,
0.0448063053,
0.0112139992,
-0.0963619277,
-0.005931084,
-0.01445382,
-0.0048380997,
0.0299189482,
-0.0409741141,
0.0283618383,
-0.1187254563,
-0.0016328439,
-0.0133522358,
0.0185399316,
-0.045741424,
-0.0610526092,
0.0152667947,
-0.024294205,
-0.0172300935,
-0.0151484367,
0.0056276219,
0.0196031071,
0.0148294959,
0.0342213437,
-0.051633548,
0.0182258878,
-0.0380805507,
0.0251281932,
-0.014898912,
0.0363741815,
-0.0053899046,
-0.0031228515,
-0.0591002963,
-0.0287826937,
-0.0164338164,
0.0147974296,
0.1041803211,
-0.0080854706,
0.0090398276,
-0.0220359117,
-0.0153383696,
0.0034765315,
-0.0176251791,
-0.0354957208,
0.0789743885,
-0.0017888172,
-0.0001906496,
-0.0029575857,
-0.0418112986,
0.0214098189,
0.0549551845,
-0.0083260993,
0.0111484323,
0.0301881526,
-0.0156020364,
0.0194808729,
-0.0737347528,
-0.0083112624,
0.0246578138,
-0.0537052155,
0.0381257422,
-0.0638315827,
-0.0690674856,
0.0534841269,
0.0016207957,
0.0276158657,
0.040771123,
-0.0020218154,
-0.033222165,
-0.0640330464,
0.0264837854,
-0.0243765879,
0.0125319799,
0.0471618474,
-0.0191581752,
0.0143572958,
-0.0384745337,
-0.0205090977,
0.0003911619,
-0.0325345695,
-0.0400030129,
-0.0467441529,
0.0236563534,
0.0080669634,
0.070450604,
-0.053399656,
-0.0410402119,
0.0419626683,
0.0241401289,
-0.0942114815,
-0.0118890321,
-0.0062044952,
0.0090379659,
-0.0203519594,
0.0396155044,
-0.0846220329,
-0.0000876621,
0.0066794618,
0.0398824029,
-0.0117906276,
-0.0549049191,
-0.0050039976,
0.0515158847,
0.0078364862,
0.0214915555,
0.0570686311,
-0.066897139,
0.0093075046,
-0.0113463979,
-0.0324022435,
-0.0228723586,
0.021422198,
0.0228265375,
0.0134733059,
-0.0143767865,
0.0244225468,
0.0393867716,
0.0450103618,
-0.0805932507,
-0.0416900106,
0.0012831368,
-0.0163042843,
0.0428652577,
0.025877621,
-0.0477635376,
0.020884525,
0.0170447957,
0.0145404488,
-0.0430244207,
-0.0131504694,
0.0387141183,
-0.0316624381,
-0.0476546437,
0.0064574899,
-0.0480571613,
-0.007373353,
-0.0031260224,
-0.0046322457,
0.0455788448,
-0.05093145,
0.0696513653,
-0.0167570896,
-0.0418609604,
0.0002226808,
0.0135603379,
0.0145255541,
-0.0160374101,
0.0234844759,
0.0080827102,
-0.0249933209,
0.0145215821,
0.0225294456,
-0.0089706238,
0.0666544437,
-0.0188304242,
-0.0550517477,
-0.0353822857,
-0.0222940706,
0.0162213761,
0.0572624952,
-0.011522579,
0.0069039976,
-0.0297439173,
-0.0790997744,
0.071806401,
-0.0592494309,
-0.0404472835,
-0.0115185995,
0.0517757349,
0.0239411257,
0.048369851,
-0.0212156978,
-0.0395930596,
0.0105153332,
-0.0173426941,
0.019518422,
-0.0295067262,
-6.3174828e-33,
-0.0127388462,
-0.0260820538,
-0.0041062962,
-0.0274224784,
-0.0485610515,
0.0099719428,
-0.0276758224,
-0.0337046459,
-0.0411684066,
0.0312731899,
0.009238652,
-0.0086548999,
-0.012969777,
0.0159996692,
0.0030149466,
-0.0194738526,
0.022628203,
-0.0027251337,
0.0280334894,
0.0453265682,
0.0575192869,
0.0416569784,
0.0732890964,
-0.0716011375,
0.0840493888,
0.0068650823,
0.0225393996,
0.0019838961,
0.0371845029,
0.0496427231,
-0.0080232648,
0.0794380754,
0.0308787655,
-0.053391438,
0.0129085258,
-0.0237139277,
-0.1166836098,
-0.0226688292,
0.0064154333,
-0.0149849374,
-0.0165131893,
-0.0153390905,
0.0392025486,
-0.0098661995,
0.0458103381,
-0.0389408246,
0.066507943,
0.0018491165,
-0.0606918372,
-0.038988661,
-0.0359090455,
0.0182650369,
0.0003373192,
0.0446601659,
0.0315303467,
0.0044063716,
0.0309564155,
0.0295029227,
-0.0887901857,
-0.0282364264,
-0.0444781184,
0.0008492139,
-0.0097175343,
-0.0151972715,
-0.000468402,
0.0709340572,
-0.0588161349,
0.0040354664,
-0.08838664,
0.0359957218,
-0.0185849033,
0.0499173813,
0.0366955809,
0.0464345366,
0.0181586072,
-0.0512591787,
-0.0718381032,
0.0040005473,
0.0158618446,
0.0046746712,
-0.0084112827,
0.0209107697,
-0.0522269569,
-0.0460254923,
-0.0254537091,
-0.0001503264,
-0.0327349305,
-0.0542062894,
0.0128988437,
0.0272263829,
-0.0275659598,
0.0886410028,
-0.018360354,
-0.0535991713,
-0.0154257258,
0.0439248309,
-0.0069157598,
0.0001104601,
0.0168202147,
0.000463531,
-0.0539942458,
-0.0262301452,
0.0517407805,
-0.0284130033,
-0.0112534249,
0.0167778861,
0.0627404004,
-0.038634643,
-0.0106859328,
0.0180546697,
-0.0406626053,
-0.0323665328,
-0.0329180919,
0.0226888452,
0.0190316401,
0.0563427992,
-0.0055420329,
0.0149366977,
0.0891637802,
0.0132077429,
-0.0181926936,
0.0019779464,
0.043762859,
-0.0098134438,
-0.0000550644,
-0.0051516839,
0.0010568899,
-0.0171681177,
-0.0185358841,
-0.0533357747,
-0.0075707431,
-0.0064039505,
2.821e-7,
0.0441503674,
0.0124455448,
0.0196127407,
-0.0003812163,
-0.003585374,
0.0100588789,
0.0324745513,
0.046302516,
0.010232077,
-0.0425219089,
0.0046079769,
0.0220847372,
0.0049614077,
0.0263411161,
-0.0875302926,
-0.0035674709,
-0.0243049785,
-0.0504218377,
-0.0008360872,
-0.0152376685,
0.0430429839,
0.0291454159,
0.0611869022,
0.0382147022,
0.0032797225,
-0.062144652,
0.052511584,
-0.0035147353,
0.0200499725,
0.0227833334,
0.0534469001,
0.0466351844,
-0.0345381759,
0.0546734035,
-0.046798382,
0.0348590128,
0.0528530814,
0.0493265875,
-0.002914917,
-0.0018655113,
-0.0474654473,
-0.0436485894,
0.044312723,
-0.041750364,
0.0888636932,
-0.0321276598,
-0.00290317,
0.0603448041,
-0.0526281074,
0.0131815206,
-0.0149158621,
-0.0059874612,
-0.0004198134,
0.004802939,
0.0210031457,
0.0474740714,
-0.0264839958,
-0.1123529226,
-0.0087188538,
0.0236774851,
-0.037597023,
-0.0399085432,
-0.0114142466,
-0.005083723,
0.0288560838,
-0.0537471473,
0.0407781303,
2.633153264e-34,
0.0071735932,
0.0369346291,
-0.0118290661,
0.0314787962,
0.0388639383,
-0.0289961565,
-0.0340078548,
-0.0083349198,
0.0327117182,
-0.0986801535,
0.00417234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15771v1 | The Hydra Effect: Emergent Self-repair in Language Model Computations | 2023-07-28T19:13:26 | 2023-07-28T19:13:26 | Thomas McGrath, Matthew Rahtz, Janos Kramar, Vladimir Mikulik, Shane Legg | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We investigate the internal structure of language model computations using
causal analysis and demonstrate two motifs: (1) a form of adaptive computation
where ablations of one attention layer of a language model cause another layer
to compensate (which we term the Hydra effect) and (2) a counterbalancing
function of late MLP layers that act to downregulate the maximum-likelihood
token. Our ablation studies demonstrate that language model layers are
typically relatively loosely coupled (ablations to one layer only affect a
small number of downstream layers). Surprisingly, these effects occur even in
language models trained without any form of dropout. We analyse these effects
in the context of factual recall and consider their implications for
circuit-level attribution in language models. | [
0.0017273215,
0.0290755443,
-0.0371865965,
0.0178529788,
-0.0177845247,
0.0235734954,
0.0265487265,
-0.0433312058,
-0.0045435634,
-0.0366370864,
-0.0207594745,
-0.0401958972,
0.0375223458,
-0.0108838324,
0.0356089547,
0.0107410252,
0.0543052517,
-0.0272844657,
0.0012134843,
-0.0531444438,
-0.0184328426,
-0.0140562877,
-0.0032721276,
0.0300264955,
0.0339539051,
-0.0096085975,
-0.0014117152,
0.0022253543,
-0.0093802158,
0.0122812502,
-0.0258101448,
0.0414942242,
-0.0441988669,
0.052222833,
0.0000019325,
-0.0534796678,
0.0247746147,
-0.0090116402,
-0.0608657934,
0.0415016711,
-0.0005203106,
0.0404028893,
-0.0248212535,
-0.0097247288,
0.0069263992,
0.039524857,
0.0662496984,
0.0074395519,
0.0230103247,
0.0557049066,
0.0028668838,
-0.0410054587,
0.0175358206,
-0.0108109638,
0.0336160585,
-0.0221263207,
0.0220729522,
-0.0320244655,
-0.0495346524,
-0.0534765236,
-0.0236924831,
0.0304620788,
0.0259123351,
0.0060719457,
0.0112960925,
0.0728646517,
-0.044521343,
-0.031734217,
-0.0067671747,
0.0149158472,
-0.0076341946,
-0.0600885525,
-0.0066477996,
0.0013614364,
0.0220480859,
0.0446389802,
-0.0430336595,
0.005529155,
0.0003967151,
0.0083550448,
0.0639320463,
-0.0393962376,
0.0671523884,
0.0043767341,
-0.0075381971,
0.0594285093,
0.0124519086,
-0.0295236427,
-0.0451893695,
0.0282649379,
0.0111618657,
-0.0689720735,
0.0190916304,
0.0209018365,
0.0257452372,
0.027268298,
-0.0160107519,
0.0081455903,
-0.0156594794,
-0.094503358,
0.0488267951,
0.0377597101,
0.0028548357,
0.008774505,
-0.0689012632,
0.0376358852,
-0.0294718742,
0.0276871677,
-0.004465844,
0.0361966528,
-0.0066646491,
-0.0413282402,
-0.0083454689,
0.0383679941,
0.0460033529,
0.0062831496,
-0.0450400934,
0.0183535349,
-0.0147730513,
-0.02393963,
-0.0736873671,
-0.0002542294,
-0.0377798565,
-0.0083655268,
-0.0384403728,
0.0704403445,
0.0019976331,
-0.0031232981,
-0.0114568006,
-0.0370833948,
-0.0445886999,
-0.004563767,
-0.0290966891,
-0.0094815837,
-0.0097707631,
0.0334124267,
-0.0238295458,
-0.0389587283,
-0.0587805249,
0.0248017479,
-0.0087699704,
-0.0619100817,
0.0189354643,
-0.0465408228,
0.001621259,
0.0199976154,
0.0011554502,
-0.0598919801,
0.0163241718,
-0.0008724373,
-0.0640708283,
0.0279069357,
-0.0037324142,
0.003587649,
0.0085939765,
-0.0044167587,
0.0507676005,
0.0765235871,
0.0379261263,
0.0246552862,
-0.0049010911,
-0.0222989693,
0.0173470993,
0.0157948639,
0.0386998579,
0.0254266616,
-0.0449015833,
-0.0407200195,
-0.0151227834,
0.0250476487,
0.0421947949,
0.0037224942,
-0.0221649483,
-0.0139285466,
0.0618508011,
0.0238775685,
0.0460905656,
0.0352173187,
-0.0197994541,
-0.0781441778,
0.0146997347,
0.0752918273,
-0.0934928507,
0.0671546832,
-0.0070380154,
0.0084908819,
0.0033715749,
0.001299678,
-0.0363888554,
-0.0464171395,
-0.0355587564,
0.0528783686,
-0.0520825237,
0.0355399065,
0.0370857939,
0.0273880865,
0.0120026777,
0.0820576474,
0.0239003319,
-0.0240349844,
0.0183502417,
-0.0639923662,
-0.0044290121,
0.0598787144,
0.0347381048,
-0.0355599336,
-0.04029366,
0.0084050903,
-0.017846318,
0.0680530816,
0.0157341342,
0.0039132065,
0.0150651224,
-0.0266823452,
0.0171245597,
-0.0225811508,
0.0273123905,
0.0335567221,
-0.0292133112,
-0.040047396,
-0.010221987,
0.0054673813,
-0.0484973565,
0.0290710963,
-0.016600512,
-0.019422356,
-0.008653095,
0.0150734149,
-0.0127646392,
0.0071472349,
-0.0251155645,
0.0217621848,
0.0291861929,
-0.0135763977,
-0.0219778921,
0.030833669,
-0.048089087,
-0.0179304685,
0.0548600256,
0.0310460813,
-0.0177047625,
-0.007422091,
0.04064909,
-0.0647115335,
0.0867513716,
-0.0555424094,
0.0718903616,
-0.0328151509,
0.045873154,
-0.0378659517,
0.0005901802,
-0.0365413837,
0.0646554604,
-0.0136609375,
0.0038967954,
0.0225656573,
0.0348254293,
-0.0034021987,
-0.001887163,
-0.0014977895,
0.018306138,
-0.0121442461,
-0.0135437734,
0.0167157296,
-0.0638267249,
-0.0280715097,
-0.0199094154,
0.0210516769,
-0.0101266466,
-0.0218099467,
0.0130732255,
0.0305013638,
-0.014214634,
-0.0017387845,
-0.0110389525,
0.0007852181,
0.0038674125,
-0.0188399833,
0.0601438433,
0.0081492458,
-0.0363692716,
0.011980895,
-0.0266474709,
-0.0245708879,
-0.0152674997,
0.0674758554,
0.0222144499,
-0.0336240456,
-0.0826092288,
0.0065604229,
-0.0294861458,
0.0005307232,
-0.0047271578,
-0.0301675405,
0.0462890267,
0.0136904502,
0.0862921178,
0.0729992315,
-0.0299890097,
0.0456714295,
0.1074605212,
-0.0002850963,
-0.0144512709,
0.0001240339,
-0.0534533411,
-0.0143441726,
-0.046345748,
-0.0452327468,
-0.0611919872,
0.0979163051,
0.0106656142,
-0.0126418862,
-0.0444077179,
-0.0082522854,
-0.0232737139,
-0.0663222745,
-0.0110527948,
-0.0388208851,
-0.036554914,
0.0528462268,
-0.0100690471,
-0.0483264327,
0.0505978428,
-0.0038940497,
0.0059028049,
-0.0203295797,
0.0223349128,
0.0030815722,
0.0424021967,
0.0302607045,
0.0235362928,
0.0692342371,
-0.0631306991,
-0.0427181832,
-0.000765713,
0.0153966164,
-0.0072251214,
0.034950763,
-0.0304458588,
-0.0013286601,
0.0123114195,
-0.0200493895,
-0.0435643345,
0.0196122266,
0.0109611759,
-0.0194054935,
-0.0318255201,
-0.0069957725,
-0.0785410628,
-0.0428143628,
0.0458683111,
0.034201052,
-0.0301658064,
-0.0111538628,
-0.0096085193,
0.0110916682,
0.0025285501,
0.0386056714,
0.0765989348,
-0.02968329,
0.0460280105,
0.0223324988,
0.0747028366,
0.0191408731,
-0.0310010351,
0.0239014067,
0.0427102298,
-0.0278208908,
-0.0083390465,
-0.0058569657,
0.0451214947,
-0.0548326112,
-0.0388349444,
0.0828782395,
0.0180696454,
-0.0588313043,
-0.0020674949,
-0.0331750587,
0.0183881857,
0.0672288463,
-0.002083895,
-0.0287810806,
0.0029706862,
0.0314764902,
-0.0037088406,
-0.0082327649,
0.0088429684,
0.0086584678,
-0.0524278432,
0.0294233225,
0.0025946405,
-0.036422126,
0.0340393595,
-0.0570393689,
-0.0022317087,
-0.0094477031,
0.0233961158,
0.0274075866,
-0.0254998207,
-0.0017464927,
0.0313693509,
0.0156361628,
0.0009200303,
-0.0059694787,
0.0034659072,
0.0511279739,
0.0472983643,
0.0019623856,
-0.0446486399,
0.0147681767,
0.0652066544,
-0.0165317114,
0.0317944475,
-0.0082962122,
0.0285432097,
0.0276213344,
-0.0117243342,
-0.02313051,
-0.0073023853,
-0.0063207122,
-0.023564009,
-0.0467175245,
0.0404567085,
-0.0248853117,
-0.0177748688,
-0.0001502308,
-0.0023649589,
-0.075201951,
0.0257669985,
0.0618749894,
-0.0269672927,
-0.0188782867,
-0.0371990725,
-0.0088549051,
-0.0367167331,
-0.0548995882,
0.0594140328,
0.0210526437,
-0.0742660314,
-0.022211941,
-0.0157183465,
-0.020044094,
0.035674803,
0.0466062464,
0.0073717097,
0.0272019729,
-0.0385549814,
-0.0123018594,
0.0281412546,
-0.0233119316,
-0.0070702331,
-0.0362148769,
-0.0314266942,
-0.0245182011,
-0.0602502488,
-0.004799631,
0.0403650552,
-0.0656600073,
-0.08117266,
0.0746699125,
0.0495737307,
0.0313278921,
0.0233114734,
0.0056655724,
-0.0683947653,
0.0177795961,
0.0259631127,
0.0106388154,
0.0508897305,
-0.005294608,
-0.0515051298,
-0.0075538228,
0.0406868719,
0.0079462007,
0.0096240668,
0.0843715146,
0.0428074449,
-0.0015900499,
0.0181402676,
0.0490318909,
-0.0010450693,
0.0481618829,
-0.0060482714,
-0.0108301453,
-0.0172068179,
0.0145842712,
0.0032879005,
-0.0003057785,
0.0216430314,
-0.018537255,
0.0476394035,
0.0100408792,
0.0207662974,
-0.0608449616,
-0.0047778841,
0.0120484885,
-0.0502258092,
-0.0039543444,
0.010273722,
0.0132378452,
0.0288916584,
0.0504220948,
-0.0078143263,
0.0668342113,
-0.000542755,
0.0222175457,
0.0127497455,
0.0247755926,
0.0266299602,
0.0184004959,
-0.0568657666,
-0.0151331881,
-0.1073487476,
-0.0478214435,
0.0288566407,
-0.001980152,
0.0488703363,
-0.0122577688,
0.0348024853,
-0.0334719792,
0.0001110831,
-0.0120371133,
0.0198394544,
0.0170394164,
-0.0276141632,
-0.00999997,
0.0021605575,
-0.001855965,
-0.0170944221,
0.0574806146,
0.0440424234,
0.0396014564,
-0.0215989687,
0.0050701019,
0.0075957864,
-0.0906460583,
-0.060754057,
0.0490952916,
-0.0542683639,
-0.0236375183,
-0.0898688212,
-0.0842371434,
-0.0342603289,
-0.0219210796,
0.0737169161,
-0.0472799055,
-0.0045165955,
0.0591402985,
-0.0185961556,
-0.0242626816,
-0.0160563514,
0.0586807355,
-0.0230001211,
0.005296973,
0.0077750385,
-6.394432864e-33,
-0.0377959087,
-0.0248705205,
0.0246509686,
0.0041290438,
-0.0100018745,
0.0306956638,
-0.0599298775,
0.0604607612,
-0.0178460348,
0.0054699737,
-0.0190470573,
0.0268789306,
0.0190012008,
-0.0081005385,
0.0466344804,
0.0022528162,
0.031097101,
-0.0024147741,
-0.0344629325,
0.0204934832,
0.057697922,
0.0258181859,
0.0970632061,
0.0011691338,
0.028819479,
0.0197880883,
0.0054097953,
0.0042994535,
-0.0515701249,
0.0293901823,
-0.0323862955,
0.0700911582,
0.0300145559,
-0.0643190593,
-0.0175625198,
-0.0264861472,
-0.0605860278,
-0.0203446131,
0.0487303734,
0.0021753686,
-0.028975822,
-0.0448581092,
0.0778567344,
0.0090319002,
-0.0421781912,
-0.0337789655,
0.0313793607,
-0.0127239721,
-0.0655602962,
-0.0040966151,
-0.0848512799,
-0.0096751805,
-0.0026155708,
-0.0174784139,
-0.0027044222,
-0.0193284284,
-0.0224417616,
0.0280510541,
-0.0613766238,
0.0262623075,
-0.0191908982,
0.0522464365,
0.0494535491,
0.0611331463,
0.0173517335,
0.0566411018,
0.0552520044,
0.0780159608,
-0.0435751528,
-0.0392542221,
0.0600611605,
0.001655466,
0.0663657412,
-0.0027231679,
0.0471848473,
-0.0440498739,
-0.0347781144,
-0.0427134857,
0.0258800983,
0.0288928673,
0.0331095085,
0.0178421494,
-0.0174987968,
-0.0190257523,
-0.0394226722,
0.0149924513,
-0.040086966,
-0.0088133747,
-0.0120312236,
-0.0034132914,
0.0011753215,
0.0172859207,
0.0175805259,
-0.0125562539,
0.0213355273,
-0.0188073963,
0.0101503618,
0.0189543888,
-0.0050968206,
0.0262836926,
-0.0532369651,
0.0109349797,
-0.0636073425,
0.0302668195,
0.0102737835,
0.0130130947,
0.0280070212,
0.0329390615,
-0.0286841709,
0.0094297491,
-0.0601393767,
-0.0216637794,
0.0423832387,
0.0043371944,
0.0324426331,
0.0147794383,
-0.0044786162,
-0.0063041518,
0.0403262302,
0.0022918209,
-0.0334193036,
0.0640189424,
-0.0186909027,
0.0421191752,
-0.0430667736,
-0.0226479787,
-0.073694177,
0.0603583567,
0.0242467616,
-0.0873199478,
-0.0388282202,
-0.0033632691,
2.707e-7,
0.0315769278,
0.0386937298,
-0.0017118192,
0.0261967909,
0.0492471717,
0.0223523416,
-0.0217574053,
-0.0049794568,
0.035341274,
0.0105688814,
-0.0278744586,
0.0195215698,
0.0267508607,
0.0166732073,
-0.0483124927,
0.0092284838,
-0.0499120243,
0.0157969259,
-0.0295847468,
-0.0166342575,
-0.0615374446,
0.0324065387,
0.0421949886,
-0.0323869549,
-0.0078139054,
-0.0269400366,
0.0548096225,
0.0064985841,
0.0215610936,
0.0234788451,
-0.0471473671,
0.0330995619,
-0.0088528087,
0.0296132267,
-0.0281968713,
-0.0076517817,
-0.0001794528,
-0.0047356696,
-0.0138285579,
-0.0119563071,
-0.0257283896,
-0.014955732,
0.0310210939,
-0.0965190455,
0.0144103635,
-0.0251700748,
-0.0350093134,
-0.0210597552,
0.0328054726,
0.0062265871,
0.0303254295,
0.0096626393,
-0.0075873984,
0.0161281228,
-0.0306045208,
0.006930849,
0.0015720379,
-0.0724756047,
-0.0658253133,
0.0018015242,
-0.0332756862,
-0.0293718744,
-0.0224545076,
-0.0328335464,
0.0444121361,
-0.0616420843,
-0.0407606959,
2.28715821e-34,
0.011289062,
-0.0224923734,
0.0272862557,
0.0712646917,
0.0130100753,
-0.0416098237,
-0.0163932089,
0.0092130406,
0.0090294005,
-0.0455529168,
-0.0269905217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15770v2 | CHATREPORT: Democratizing Sustainability Disclosure Analysis through LLM-based Tools | 2023-07-28T18:58:16 | 2023-10-11T16:49:29 | Jingwei Ni, Julia Bingler, Chiara Colesanti-Senni, Mathias Kraus, Glen Gostlow, Tobias Schimanski, Dominik Stammbach, Saeid Ashraf Vaghefi, Qian Wang, Nicolas Webersinke, Tobias Wekhof, Tingyu Yu, Markus Leippold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the face of climate change, are companies really taking substantial steps
toward more sustainable operations? A comprehensive answer lies in the dense,
information-rich landscape of corporate sustainability reports. However, the
sheer volume and complexity of these reports make human analysis very costly.
Therefore, only a few entities worldwide have the resources to analyze these
reports at scale, which leads to a lack of transparency in sustainability
reporting. Empowering stakeholders with LLM-based automatic analysis tools can
be a promising way to democratize sustainability report analysis. However,
developing such tools is challenging due to (1) the hallucination of LLMs and
(2) the inefficiency of bringing domain experts into the AI development loop.
In this paper, we ChatReport, a novel LLM-based system to automate the analysis
of corporate sustainability reports, addressing existing challenges by (1)
making the answers traceable to reduce the harm of hallucination and (2)
actively involving domain experts in the development loop. We make our
methodology, annotated datasets, and generated analyses of 1015 reports
publicly available. | [
-0.0101565905,
0.0677058548,
-0.0285948049,
0.0226370748,
-0.0392733887,
-0.0220678672,
-0.038805455,
0.0046144021,
0.0077639767,
-0.019458361,
-0.0002411088,
0.1319667995,
0.0221266989,
0.0893117487,
-0.003372052,
-0.0009136593,
0.027166171,
0.0223703291,
-0.0251788534,
0.0097755464,
0.0061840666,
-0.0005129456,
-0.0025755253,
0.0092055136,
-0.0287725367,
-0.008563011,
-0.0386939049,
0.0120594269,
0.0044307578,
0.0030201748,
-0.0146973133,
0.059942387,
0.0218187235,
-0.012285566,
0.0000023767,
-0.0517649092,
-0.0380834974,
-0.0115756355,
0.0117739756,
0.052926559,
0.0472080708,
-0.0110325674,
0.0115303714,
0.0127375368,
-0.0215728376,
0.0119431429,
0.0229726899,
-0.0146756368,
0.0465531982,
-0.0263181236,
0.0078711789,
0.0024314523,
-0.0002563114,
-0.0104656089,
0.0026951842,
0.0231070705,
-0.0106265023,
0.0071151494,
-0.018453341,
-0.0629772693,
-0.0072059492,
0.0768016502,
0.0078610126,
-0.0500885881,
0.0154063497,
-0.0319537371,
-0.0022687681,
-0.0221913755,
-0.0173903834,
0.0372646749,
0.0723944902,
0.022248216,
0.0014093578,
-0.0278470796,
0.0507810898,
-0.0094301216,
-0.016292017,
0.0363279842,
-0.013835635,
-0.0301398821,
0.0001038542,
0.0211792979,
-0.0180490427,
0.0390690751,
-0.0275491625,
0.0384972356,
-0.0572769083,
-0.0189243164,
0.023109898,
0.0101510715,
0.0507429577,
-0.0305156223,
-0.0133969998,
0.0171558913,
-0.0231142174,
0.0123822,
0.0431822948,
-0.0100344783,
0.039144326,
-0.0251428001,
0.0317406952,
0.0074877436,
-0.007226489,
0.0298853256,
0.0406344235,
0.0394785926,
0.0035447155,
0.0271466933,
0.0067403489,
-0.0000206228,
-0.0004599931,
0.0020395881,
0.0001168324,
0.0331581756,
-0.0636428073,
0.0449055023,
0.0055096662,
0.0148810772,
-0.0613494739,
0.0586252548,
0.0140772676,
0.032448072,
0.0538843237,
-0.0274626687,
-0.0246005524,
0.0058152718,
-0.0524944738,
0.0335189104,
-0.0162569247,
-0.0239928514,
0.0305944327,
0.0129488939,
-0.0046912264,
0.0458349027,
0.0121537754,
0.0916579664,
0.0411795415,
0.017061973,
-0.0520026684,
-0.0500074327,
0.0542748496,
-0.0340901576,
-0.0275122076,
-0.0251412094,
0.0229349192,
-0.018199861,
-0.0175211504,
-0.0625384524,
-0.0036769467,
0.0023221718,
0.0322127752,
0.039438393,
-0.1032743752,
0.0124420449,
0.0206849612,
0.030701736,
-0.0158331003,
0.0774120912,
0.0619236641,
0.0111194616,
0.0349626243,
0.0032070081,
0.0206156708,
0.0215267614,
-0.008958417,
-0.0026455289,
0.0227489732,
0.0500374921,
-0.0665199682,
-0.0272596572,
0.0215239283,
-0.0233166739,
0.0143976668,
0.0449071527,
0.0271578617,
0.0209905747,
0.0270308368,
0.0522025637,
-0.023905687,
0.0136450883,
0.0084532034,
-0.0353045762,
-0.0031135108,
0.0339071564,
0.0544174016,
0.0084282029,
-0.035744302,
0.0050702784,
-0.0061823782,
-0.0923103541,
-0.0025954586,
0.0272081364,
-0.0125395674,
0.019413244,
-0.0245558303,
0.0242143739,
-0.022908289,
0.0952084139,
0.0156411491,
-0.0571550392,
-0.0125779901,
-0.0488605238,
0.0742033124,
0.0668168589,
0.0157255698,
-0.0391773544,
0.0176950544,
-0.0251933262,
-0.0304163955,
0.0204758011,
0.0287392326,
-0.0075438372,
-0.0372041278,
0.0148259634,
-0.0383061953,
-0.0314425528,
0.0163788144,
0.0228530373,
-0.0261006784,
-0.0072610034,
-0.0142755928,
-0.0495185219,
-0.0071277977,
0.0617855862,
0.0295291338,
0.0094802938,
0.0245689731,
0.0149459448,
0.0102247382,
0.045230709,
0.0112119289,
0.0442275964,
0.0157954451,
-0.0180621352,
-0.0805309042,
0.0072993217,
0.0562599935,
0.0519445688,
-0.0033896889,
-0.0680718124,
0.0038243246,
0.0174087472,
-0.0394658931,
0.0090507166,
-0.0281420462,
0.0065895813,
0.0002433459,
-0.0258770306,
-0.0470187925,
-0.0092491144,
0.0139667848,
0.0190206766,
0.0589090846,
-0.0336115956,
0.0022523827,
-0.0289714541,
-0.0418102965,
0.0007808711,
-0.0207676217,
0.0736241564,
-0.0063039376,
-0.0407431312,
0.024476096,
0.0282940865,
0.0173983872,
-0.0339948311,
0.0334070735,
-0.0796609223,
0.0048039826,
-0.0030525906,
-0.0063238968,
-0.0022009846,
-0.0283378903,
-0.0435699299,
0.0425265022,
-0.0120441942,
-0.0357010812,
-0.0222578626,
0.0102145467,
0.0456920825,
0.0244982708,
0.0219373479,
-0.0212504249,
0.0264831427,
-0.0047132932,
0.0297914073,
0.0761780962,
-0.1033297703,
-0.0670336783,
0.0591854192,
-0.0170142408,
-0.0249198247,
0.01908594,
0.0060629998,
-0.0074806944,
0.0152140427,
-0.0353467613,
0.0100955293,
0.0248854961,
0.0674720034,
0.0005121225,
-0.0211446695,
-0.0631331056,
-0.0012281177,
0.0456316099,
0.0233843364,
0.0368488096,
-0.048536282,
0.0634359047,
-0.0511515625,
-0.0376186222,
0.0189922303,
0.0214341618,
0.0266319849,
-0.01298487,
-0.0267740525,
0.0153517658,
-0.0640991554,
-0.0141541287,
0.0886981338,
0.0244225878,
-0.0643654317,
-0.0149913374,
0.0036594288,
0.0114396876,
-0.0307734199,
-0.0047426079,
-0.068712689,
0.073093161,
-0.0675905049,
-0.0106570274,
-0.0153635973,
-0.0011460861,
-0.0034759142,
-0.026825577,
0.0283747092,
-0.011409035,
0.0514788516,
-0.0133083267,
0.0230604839,
-0.0144281546,
-0.0219901111,
-0.0160371736,
-0.0491431132,
-0.021918118,
0.023534786,
-0.0045492374,
-0.0387528501,
-0.063178435,
0.0058103628,
0.0417612754,
0.0080179032,
0.0317774564,
-0.0314805843,
0.0068396255,
-0.0868498012,
-0.0303743593,
-0.0003163145,
0.0419445969,
-0.0060519627,
0.0014507985,
0.0384959094,
0.0138361668,
0.0271857437,
0.0182547569,
-0.0369945094,
-0.0391605049,
-0.0010663337,
0.058779642,
-0.023280587,
-0.0191870946,
-0.0461069383,
0.02271007,
0.0404731333,
0.0037153722,
-0.0277115796,
0.0150339613,
-0.0147104198,
0.00649906,
0.0156263988,
0.0488942862,
-0.0794514343,
0.0012670124,
0.0081052426,
0.0320994034,
-0.0400266871,
-0.0720912591,
-0.0383859873,
-0.0568567105,
0.0846915171,
-0.0069032595,
-0.0202705935,
-0.0325863995,
-0.0454791822,
-0.0035501572,
-0.0559265204,
-0.0438309759,
-0.0435694717,
-0.0178443361,
-0.0326835737,
0.0248480458,
-0.0771147534,
0.0271768551,
-0.0094956439,
-0.012431873,
-0.0544623025,
0.0795032829,
0.0232700855,
-0.0420797393,
0.0143538266,
0.0297144428,
0.0145857446,
0.0029190441,
-0.0105616692,
0.0305432826,
0.0105697541,
-0.0129899085,
0.0056290766,
0.0131412279,
-0.0353811197,
0.0034276571,
0.0572373234,
0.0731673911,
-0.0012455946,
-0.0070173824,
0.0186755359,
0.0190668292,
-0.0124333464,
0.039830178,
-0.0022540251,
0.0046874457,
-0.0137837827,
-0.0794141442,
-0.0135270366,
-0.0084331874,
-0.0110553829,
0.0167406984,
-0.0562522262,
-0.0316389278,
-0.0205209833,
-0.0535462983,
0.0395068638,
0.0181442704,
-0.0326053947,
-0.0004317618,
0.0228388868,
0.0151238162,
-0.0482668169,
0.0041254503,
-0.0458779708,
0.0712552071,
0.0060453527,
-0.0096252747,
0.0279603433,
0.0943200141,
-0.010165914,
0.0433072336,
-0.0405605696,
-0.0220144726,
0.0038532047,
0.0119729117,
0.029487377,
-0.0613477528,
0.0003873937,
0.0198346153,
0.0332858898,
0.1295312792,
-0.0744124353,
-0.0039752885,
0.0263965689,
0.040361058,
-0.0162012205,
-0.0062006544,
-0.0276415106,
-0.0568486229,
-0.0286694858,
0.0397296697,
-0.0273393784,
-0.0177207272,
0.0063874037,
0.0124103297,
-0.0396821685,
0.0046350509,
-0.011841693,
-0.0294841696,
0.0010960568,
0.0163913295,
-0.0038926215,
-0.0347858034,
0.0290241148,
-0.0314883403,
-0.0293734856,
0.0059107225,
0.1167819574,
-0.067344211,
-0.0273998138,
-0.0623074956,
0.1045117974,
-0.0020549465,
0.0215825196,
-0.0280897841,
0.0024272013,
-0.0417375751,
-0.0468341857,
0.0339079164,
0.0080164848,
0.037704207,
-0.0109170498,
-0.0030801033,
0.062441133,
-0.0025987197,
0.032241039,
0.0183476321,
-0.0925332457,
-0.0010510957,
0.0468613431,
-0.0197693277,
0.1082859114,
-0.0509893037,
-0.0426686853,
-0.0245164353,
0.0465035103,
0.0082783801,
0.0061876527,
-0.0195031017,
0.0434433706,
0.0116363736,
-0.063959673,
-0.0656875893,
0.0297598094,
0.0135184666,
0.0019297053,
-0.0662413687,
-0.0333693884,
-0.0461434573,
-0.0761770085,
0.0009449912,
-0.0295846313,
0.0316433199,
-0.0253092516,
-0.0886515304,
-0.0393018536,
0.0483601689,
-0.0137694944,
0.001168881,
-0.0256716534,
-0.0293246936,
0.0233402867,
0.0377641544,
-0.040716622,
-0.0136682158,
-0.0049717803,
-0.0691269413,
-0.0130160591,
0.0112672579,
-6.213940114e-33,
-0.0281663816,
-0.0654991344,
0.0063154725,
0.0024647438,
-0.0012232909,
0.001223932,
0.0015289907,
-0.0102776783,
-0.0520572998,
0.0645049214,
-0.0342578143,
0.0143707599,
0.0215762332,
-0.0429921001,
0.0326298885,
-0.0018041913,
0.0103284083,
-0.0141319316,
-0.0102915782,
-0.0545053631,
-0.0027615486,
0.013948475,
0.023470087,
-0.0892328247,
0.0563379936,
-0.0188037641,
-0.0752826184,
0.0242318437,
0.0057708723,
0.0141529134,
0.0140407374,
0.0232835673,
0.0075227949,
-0.0382628255,
-0.0286950748,
0.0513372645,
-0.0562920012,
-0.0523066409,
-0.0003794119,
-0.0234623421,
0.0084363027,
0.0178953949,
0.0133939506,
0.0414462648,
-0.0162257459,
-0.0072335848,
0.0214568619,
-0.0430048332,
0.0057204263,
-0.0816879049,
-0.0428968593,
0.0131860133,
-0.0146548264,
0.0712133944,
-0.0440351367,
0.0689457133,
-0.0063940044,
0.0008761875,
-0.0204811357,
-0.0054179672,
0.0450198278,
-0.031691961,
0.0558619611,
-0.0039550294,
0.0093289418,
0.0076105241,
-0.0213610865,
0.0546519682,
-0.0324431285,
0.0048376075,
0.0062142005,
0.0613951348,
0.0283587985,
0.022183599,
-0.0393789858,
-0.0175566543,
-0.0601609424,
0.0542240664,
0.0284018051,
0.0410170965,
0.0052225869,
-0.049097348,
-0.0011005504,
-0.0188650247,
-0.016376067,
0.0087984232,
-0.030922154,
0.0333431885,
0.0123866508,
-0.0015202787,
-0.0333856381,
-0.0239935946,
-0.035960272,
-0.0184272751,
-0.0084905252,
0.0259529315,
0.0214129854,
0.004883253,
0.0395490676,
0.0027553579,
-0.0204523969,
0.0060439231,
-0.0588809587,
0.0685334504,
0.0336650833,
-0.0035267167,
0.0237561781,
-0.0202749427,
-0.0475382172,
0.0043922304,
-0.0252959449,
0.0280717202,
-0.0107816178,
-0.0615539216,
-0.0282478277,
-0.0028759078,
0.0040204162,
0.0030728735,
-0.0052009793,
0.0244867299,
0.0043256641,
0.0413202234,
-0.0340254493,
0.0432318635,
-0.0016337674,
-0.0284167267,
0.0137537997,
-0.0266142264,
0.0633534193,
-0.0041705319,
-0.0092691407,
0.0086098062,
2.94e-7,
0.0383322239,
-0.0257922783,
-0.0195072219,
0.0344670899,
0.0231831763,
0.0399088822,
0.0362995341,
0.0198727734,
-0.0363560989,
-0.0345771275,
0.0293117873,
-0.0201476943,
0.0252621602,
0.0438093692,
-0.0218513533,
-0.0709607527,
0.0241468381,
-0.0371700004,
-0.0983368382,
0.0085103521,
-0.012900522,
-0.0128173269,
0.0038430325,
-0.0111118779,
0.0067535997,
-0.0438037515,
0.0281476974,
-0.0708365962,
0.0184437782,
0.0242495425,
0.0446748398,
-0.0264820028,
-0.001079705,
-0.0148850149,
-0.0239907932,
0.0055018393,
-0.0204449464,
0.0658504963,
0.0558900908,
-0.0484908223,
0.0147448098,
-0.0631397218,
0.0214997809,
-0.0015033437,
0.0168982334,
-0.0019331581,
-0.0009056158,
-0.0141425347,
0.0080976747,
0.0192623902,
-0.0081180157,
-0.0466832295,
0.0166484714,
0.0311086383,
-0.0121753812,
-0.027623225,
0.0090793045,
-0.0168645866,
0.035341125,
-0.0494602695,
-0.0338486992,
0.0049294452,
-0.0025255135,
0.0418179445,
0.0443884842,
0.0187352039,
0.0432706103,
2.701470608e-34,
0.0050570844,
-0.0362860747,
-0.0158495959,
0.0124613689,
0.101081185,
0.062421836,
-0.0176456627,
0.0422282442,
0.0050486,
-0.0361350439,
0.0018339296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15759v1 | Lessons in Reproducibility: Insights from NLP Studies in Materials Science | 2023-07-28T18:36:42 | 2023-07-28T18:36:42 | Xiangyun Lei, Edward Kim, Viktoriia Baibakova, Shijing Sun | physics.chem-ph | physics.chem-ph, cs.AI, cs.CL | Natural Language Processing (NLP), a cornerstone field within artificial
intelligence, has been increasingly utilized in the field of materials science
literature. Our study conducts a reproducibility analysis of two pioneering
works within this domain: "Machine-learned and codified synthesis parameters of
oxide materials" by Kim et al., and "Unsupervised word embeddings capture
latent knowledge from materials science literature" by Tshitoyan et al. We aim
to comprehend these studies from a reproducibility perspective, acknowledging
their significant influence on the field of materials informatics, rather than
critiquing them. Our study indicates that both papers offered thorough
workflows, tidy and well-documented codebases, and clear guidance for model
evaluation. This makes it easier to replicate their results successfully and
partially reproduce their findings. In doing so, they set commendable standards
for future materials science publications to aspire to. However, our analysis
also highlights areas for improvement such as to provide access to training
data where copyright restrictions permit, more transparency on model
architecture and the training process, and specifications of software
dependency versions. We also cross-compare the word embedding models between
papers, and find that some key differences in reproducibility and
cross-compatibility are attributable to design choices outside the bounds of
the models themselves. In summary, our study appreciates the benchmark set by
these seminal papers while advocating for further enhancements in research
reproducibility practices in the field of NLP for materials science. This
balance of understanding and continuous improvement will ultimately propel the
intersecting domains of NLP and materials science literature into a future of
exciting discoveries. | [
0.0163537618,
0.0841617808,
-0.0279105399,
0.0563894324,
-0.0319550633,
-0.0136383781,
0.0030249548,
0.0013869354,
0.0045669326,
-0.0094539924,
-0.0226885658,
0.0365388393,
0.0227467604,
0.0373621769,
0.0105882753,
-0.0053304117,
0.037454173,
0.0097491154,
0.0039649443,
0.0052996534,
-0.0030310494,
-0.025273012,
0.0098936372,
0.0483953655,
0.034014903,
0.0064095873,
0.0005752244,
-0.0350268893,
-0.0053522182,
-0.024936812,
-0.0022345125,
0.0664248168,
0.0260983985,
0.0418043919,
0.0000022187,
-0.0622754805,
0.0079239113,
0.0813673437,
0.0325756669,
0.0253807902,
0.0667088628,
-0.085673824,
-0.013687633,
-0.0107708666,
-0.0062410468,
0.009019169,
0.0631448403,
0.036408104,
0.0065152659,
-0.0172516257,
-0.0181662124,
-0.0183935426,
0.0706190839,
0.0040396373,
0.0509775169,
-0.004582861,
0.0011505448,
0.0646020174,
0.0281926878,
0.030274421,
0.0066128327,
0.0708162487,
-0.0189694464,
-0.0059877401,
0.0529354326,
0.018089775,
-0.0546479635,
-0.0067335651,
0.0008006879,
0.0739691332,
0.0329766795,
-0.0113723418,
-0.0282668937,
-0.0312412716,
-0.0693559274,
0.0527348034,
-0.0185701866,
-0.0105422828,
0.0080717718,
0.0112838997,
-0.0068984516,
0.000125741,
0.0321257673,
0.0071442798,
0.0164810009,
0.0551485047,
-0.0162864011,
-0.0560877621,
0.0233384222,
0.0276809502,
-0.0116390735,
-0.0053230049,
-0.0163572095,
-0.0381127261,
0.0637093857,
0.0126227774,
-0.0015000423,
0.0129018035,
0.0600599721,
-0.0588277355,
0.0623501316,
0.0287130792,
-0.0068599083,
0.0189041309,
-0.0382050201,
0.0102176182,
0.0153477686,
0.0126756253,
-0.0495462306,
0.0072618751,
-0.073164247,
-0.0541051961,
-0.0161715336,
-0.0000221331,
0.00386293,
-0.0515764542,
-0.0050489237,
-0.0035234415,
-0.0132579105,
0.0250468757,
-0.0091931745,
0.0216695517,
-0.0293147229,
0.0106716529,
-0.0320614427,
-0.0356336571,
0.0017699181,
0.0326501578,
-0.038563855,
-0.054937046,
-0.0246352199,
-0.0145956185,
-0.0243528374,
0.0296327379,
-0.0144904284,
0.0673844218,
0.0030904822,
-0.048546046,
0.0064154449,
-0.0281688161,
-0.0115962597,
-0.0150021343,
0.022909997,
-0.0576615185,
0.0655817389,
0.0354862586,
0.0000361458,
-0.0513981134,
0.0008688863,
-0.0085488539,
-0.0397873297,
0.0987144262,
-0.0349503048,
-0.0561995991,
0.0099675227,
-0.0050657247,
0.0289964844,
0.0138205523,
0.0594164766,
0.0010413718,
0.0183361303,
-0.013749795,
0.0029240628,
-0.0307592917,
-0.0025328679,
-0.0421348661,
-0.0193893798,
-0.0150817465,
-0.013145335,
0.0233889706,
0.0192961954,
0.0179856904,
-0.0121803861,
-0.0001720837,
0.0174278952,
0.064334251,
0.0217537507,
0.0525785349,
0.0108514046,
0.0509270318,
0.053112343,
-0.0331283212,
0.0149844112,
0.0162579063,
-0.0052065961,
-0.0107283695,
0.0429408439,
0.0034497287,
0.0227403603,
-0.0717446133,
-0.0601167716,
-0.0356200635,
0.0185976084,
-0.0863222703,
0.044349242,
-0.0053331391,
-0.0353678875,
-0.0049958634,
0.0279650912,
-0.0320192613,
-0.0517310984,
0.0039778282,
0.0347722694,
0.041087728,
0.0510162264,
-0.053742826,
0.0101111839,
0.0156231374,
-0.023373317,
0.0176980998,
-0.002182883,
-0.0194472447,
0.0285187941,
-0.0263952333,
-0.0488864519,
-0.0471547619,
-0.0006472559,
-0.0072779586,
-0.0168388207,
-0.0346035659,
-0.0062050852,
-0.0201817472,
-0.0737352148,
0.0612547174,
-0.0405596346,
-0.0074077286,
-0.0046520103,
-0.0183652416,
0.0376862027,
0.0167214051,
0.0115484502,
0.045288261,
0.064764224,
-0.0250090901,
-0.0512920506,
-0.0156147378,
-0.0080209421,
-0.0114259655,
0.0237599257,
-0.0710696802,
0.065927729,
-0.0069889049,
-0.0319636948,
0.0094089359,
0.0542875566,
0.0008424107,
0.0295396112,
-0.0212645028,
-0.0224252492,
-0.01642574,
0.0542851388,
-0.0292308275,
0.0337038338,
-0.0302806851,
0.041876059,
-0.0125190727,
-0.0172692593,
0.0592823923,
0.0143489223,
-0.031855002,
0.0287805758,
0.0209255405,
0.0455741957,
0.0308195259,
-0.0157965645,
0.0005819432,
-0.0394872278,
-0.0029492774,
-0.0058436329,
0.0270753149,
0.0058144936,
0.0155916149,
-0.0395344533,
0.000810076,
-0.0090187043,
0.0827161297,
-0.0198669434,
-0.0339022912,
-0.0582361184,
0.0946037918,
-0.0263733473,
-0.0145990988,
-0.0341532975,
-0.0431682393,
-0.0371650904,
0.0649799481,
0.0158849321,
-0.0034441967,
-0.0726511627,
0.0503384136,
0.0071695717,
0.0313079804,
-0.0355085805,
-0.0202028342,
0.050515119,
0.0346436203,
0.0002439871,
0.0195346586,
0.0080562094,
0.0435644723,
0.0608200468,
0.0208506789,
-0.0246599726,
-0.0316666588,
-0.0250536595,
0.0198289752,
0.0314328074,
-0.0391168036,
0.0611721836,
0.0277371183,
-0.0066911569,
0.0264408309,
-0.0070627765,
0.0481572039,
-0.0080369972,
-0.050208535,
0.0188083388,
-0.0095585091,
0.0183022004,
0.003414629,
0.015869692,
-0.036182493,
0.0800376236,
-0.0651577637,
0.0027811008,
-0.0844953135,
-0.0021193323,
-0.0223819148,
0.0186181981,
0.0083300667,
0.0322290473,
0.0518456437,
0.0305703208,
-0.0019436501,
0.0078303907,
0.0371862017,
0.0045055463,
-0.031474106,
-0.0112249805,
0.0320140198,
0.013648456,
-0.0316608399,
-0.0135027003,
-0.0098148212,
-0.0156809818,
0.0547507741,
0.0592459254,
-0.049835667,
-0.0127826184,
0.0394957475,
0.0885460228,
-0.0345989913,
0.0141961295,
-0.0199187733,
-0.0632266402,
0.0323011838,
0.0185941029,
-0.0274340566,
0.0550523698,
0.0266610403,
0.0078995079,
0.0439465716,
-0.0054665334,
0.029257169,
-0.1006191671,
0.0149772735,
0.0270589348,
0.000031007,
-0.0080420766,
-0.002521961,
-0.0034442255,
-0.0228598192,
0.0112189408,
0.0271995738,
0.03415462,
-0.0193767697,
0.008808733,
0.015920924,
-0.0061331592,
0.0021702824,
-0.0135179739,
-0.0603159368,
-0.0145285446,
-0.0011700257,
0.0381971225,
-0.0049869283,
-0.0256517529,
-0.0137704909,
-0.0995429605,
0.0625031292,
-0.0182528086,
-0.0523626506,
-0.0698163584,
-0.0806547105,
-0.0209957473,
-0.0062631578,
-0.0197447669,
0.0299299676,
-0.050223399,
0.0047281589,
0.0245818198,
-0.0807424188,
-0.1139406115,
0.0283457749,
-0.0297245588,
0.0184563603,
0.0583029054,
0.0474422723,
-0.0378681384,
-0.0161909144,
0.0066524702,
-0.0119875455,
0.0177435894,
-0.0394709632,
0.0496596135,
0.0151765551,
-0.0041761147,
-0.0238964967,
0.0411131196,
-0.0168086421,
-0.0489717498,
-0.0190245416,
0.0861377642,
-0.0235471148,
0.0022688522,
-0.0622138865,
-0.0051825447,
0.0193319749,
0.0489268228,
-0.015258776,
-0.0092435675,
-0.0985625684,
-0.0280841049,
0.0251329727,
-0.0126984324,
-0.0247923341,
0.0028460014,
-0.0037716525,
0.0045380695,
-0.0439280048,
-0.0436044373,
-0.0101200948,
-0.0090068206,
0.0008191139,
0.0013729675,
0.0226846971,
-0.0264160857,
-0.0496046841,
0.0103138741,
-0.0038236473,
0.0055654477,
-0.006770296,
-0.0214702282,
0.0205649082,
-0.0194486827,
-0.0264306925,
0.0275410172,
-0.0117382752,
-0.0382870212,
-0.0056914845,
0.0335332081,
0.0218176153,
0.0104030902,
-0.0279044528,
-0.0696161985,
0.0496023037,
0.0339278989,
-0.0344811492,
-0.0215590037,
0.0077399374,
0.0024371615,
-0.0078836102,
-0.0385082439,
0.0019620913,
-0.0001200311,
-0.0189090464,
-0.0089526847,
0.0177151393,
-0.0505921058,
0.0178037416,
0.013028238,
0.0331542715,
-0.0098451758,
0.0384518318,
-0.0224889182,
-0.0251118466,
0.0369982608,
0.0134085547,
-0.0624116249,
0.0232537705,
0.0362543426,
-0.0393577591,
-0.0216898024,
0.0092216758,
-0.0138946166,
0.0622012764,
-0.0136134913,
0.0850383043,
0.0379154943,
0.0571767911,
0.0359154902,
0.0022935877,
-0.0254820641,
0.0092797773,
-0.0771221891,
0.0569507591,
-0.0402746499,
0.011960838,
0.0198823437,
0.0487604439,
-0.0413827971,
0.0668927431,
-0.061322052,
-0.0703182518,
-0.0763895735,
-0.0196683872,
-0.0045012152,
0.0178266205,
0.037093088,
-0.0528200641,
-0.0094885435,
-0.0192040056,
0.0616851002,
-0.0028481109,
-0.0017398618,
0.0271091573,
0.0072298138,
-0.0311723351,
-0.0271600541,
0.0675702021,
0.0386862494,
-0.0295578483,
-0.0489052236,
-0.0543255694,
-0.0244438499,
-0.0370521247,
-0.0107968198,
0.0086466493,
-0.0366228409,
-0.0549073592,
-0.0582997464,
-0.0224784836,
0.0085429484,
0.0609330311,
0.0024308548,
-0.0127923246,
-0.0069550914,
0.0982266665,
0.00711584,
-0.0247428212,
-0.0295895152,
-0.0078899143,
-0.0259049628,
-0.0396882817,
0.0035931373,
-5.901313718e-33,
-0.0073765465,
0.0229524132,
-0.0025489856,
0.0048023867,
0.0112716481,
-0.0247872565,
-0.0541843213,
-0.025575649,
-0.0197500791,
0.0223569311,
-0.0190607924,
-0.0006352128,
0.0146542201,
-0.0369077921,
0.0639107004,
0.0139114577,
0.0064620478,
0.0099579273,
-0.0290964581,
-0.0158285592,
0.0200057477,
0.0287404992,
0.0838049501,
-0.0728021711,
0.0652166456,
0.0165606327,
0.0439185053,
-0.0751410648,
-0.0068694958,
0.060028486,
-0.0668772757,
0.0268712323,
0.0077904211,
-0.0234173704,
-0.0463908017,
-0.0094959373,
-0.0540526733,
-0.0214431845,
-0.018066192,
-0.0064805709,
-0.0179463066,
0.0472174063,
0.029335672,
0.00187148,
-0.0763936564,
-0.0006682553,
0.0517081767,
-0.0375347733,
-0.0102645652,
-0.0014530707,
-0.1049797311,
-0.0102524422,
0.0060801632,
0.0432069823,
0.0544246845,
0.0228682254,
-0.0040512187,
0.0432920568,
-0.0786674917,
0.0184427127,
0.0123419194,
0.0342606567,
0.0521339141,
-0.0044276137,
0.0249934457,
0.0222545788,
0.0349958017,
0.0049748705,
0.0054661483,
0.0112719852,
0.0257908106,
0.0908875391,
0.0560470559,
0.0460513085,
0.0654110536,
-0.0368035361,
-0.092776008,
-0.0109330304,
-0.0257702861,
0.0345981419,
0.0458844118,
0.0256808568,
-0.0114733363,
-0.0466727689,
-0.0486810952,
-0.0151987551,
0.0175922085,
-0.0416225865,
-0.0085192639,
0.0009357797,
-0.0647988245,
-0.0081480872,
0.0081655374,
-0.0708246678,
-0.0367617235,
0.0348954424,
-0.0163030047,
0.051247485,
-0.00161353,
-0.0012034468,
-0.1097815782,
-0.0269017182,
-0.0394856259,
0.0201146659,
0.0653136075,
-0.0180213153,
-0.0100223981,
0.0273935143,
-0.0119854957,
0.0098670833,
-0.0393718667,
-0.0624957681,
0.0218698308,
0.0114822043,
0.0046627796,
0.0127826193,
-0.0059082783,
-0.0011412646,
0.0077892691,
0.0245172959,
0.0191647243,
0.0240201093,
-0.0005541817,
-0.0081360089,
0.0261314437,
-0.0117439432,
-0.0640543029,
0.0508520827,
0.0696044564,
-0.0200235024,
-0.0052730674,
0.0303133372,
2.995e-7,
0.0767954215,
0.0402098745,
0.0530163758,
0.0037448916,
-0.0205028448,
0.0306998529,
-0.0465998538,
0.0139276125,
-0.0118835513,
0.0006692905,
0.0207977947,
0.0145386346,
0.0334443599,
0.0215856973,
-0.0606625304,
-0.0297022164,
-0.0087055666,
-0.0310568456,
-0.0635079071,
-0.0006994895,
0.0143892355,
0.034809459,
-0.0179855935,
-0.0205210466,
-0.0217876155,
-0.0435008071,
0.0400409177,
-0.0505463779,
0.0322282985,
0.0592429712,
0.0359454937,
-0.0373261943,
-0.0132667394,
0.0249780137,
-0.0203431491,
-0.0007604295,
0.0371728688,
0.0011908717,
0.0300036594,
0.0118963653,
0.0098194415,
-0.0515197963,
0.0190571304,
-0.0275532473,
0.0291265007,
-0.0178002287,
-0.0412250608,
-0.0201410353,
-0.0021935967,
-0.0043789209,
0.04790866,
-0.0151656475,
0.0150439506,
-0.0322472118,
-0.016517885,
0.0297756251,
-0.0187986363,
-0.0507103801,
0.0008387407,
0.0135523845,
-0.0217322987,
-0.0377177447,
-0.0040568113,
-0.015631238,
0.0592635013,
-0.0160285588,
0.0125540774,
2.826422902e-34,
0.0378310941,
-0.0132938661,
0.0324746519,
0.0220032148,
0.0259124059,
0.0005420342,
0.0345657729,
0.0113469204,
-0.0246350057,
-0.0670659691,
0.0068840603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15752v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15752v1 | Resume Evaluation through Latent Dirichlet Allocation and Natural Language Processing for Effective Candidate Selection | 2023-07-28T18:11:17 | 2023-07-28T18:11:17 | Vidhita Jagwani, Smit Meghani, Krishna Pai, Sudhir Dhage | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose a method for resume rating using Latent Dirichlet
Allocation (LDA) and entity detection with SpaCy. The proposed method first
extracts relevant entities such as education, experience, and skills from the
resume using SpaCy's Named Entity Recognition (NER). The LDA model then uses
these entities to rate the resume by assigning topic probabilities to each
entity. Furthermore, we conduct a detailed analysis of the entity detection
using SpaCy's NER and report its evaluation metrics. Using LDA, our proposed
system breaks down resumes into latent topics and extracts meaningful semantic
representations. With a vision to define our resume score to be more
content-driven rather than a structure and keyword match driven, our model has
achieved 77% accuracy with respect to only skills in consideration and an
overall 82% accuracy with all attributes in consideration. (like college name,
work experience, degree and skills) | [
0.0705774277,
0.0373887047,
-0.0081878947,
-0.0384441465,
0.0043452904,
-0.0074545238,
-0.0134041393,
-0.0014190394,
-0.0245550256,
-0.0741682872,
0.007445368,
0.0024482047,
-0.0048740217,
-0.0058984845,
0.0064652651,
-0.0141236093,
0.0088083204,
0.0464417115,
0.0377164036,
0.0274393037,
0.0027944846,
0.0306659434,
-0.0124959871,
0.059525352,
0.0379046723,
-0.0053916597,
0.0347183272,
0.0002172103,
0.0364920087,
-0.0236962344,
0.0225581527,
0.0427501053,
-0.022593651,
-0.0502782874,
0.0000019447,
-0.0360199064,
-0.0323535539,
0.0120385326,
0.0038216466,
-0.0557382368,
0.1110398024,
0.0653219149,
0.0294618309,
0.0269880686,
-0.0051226886,
0.0178058203,
-0.0048227664,
0.0646518543,
0.0423413701,
0.0454722643,
-0.0003919099,
-0.0430992879,
-0.0052215941,
0.0035264224,
0.0161048826,
0.0054547624,
0.0077924966,
-0.0431437679,
0.0143028889,
0.028216064,
0.0221590064,
-0.0097013526,
-0.0804885253,
-0.0727250278,
0.109554559,
0.0297902338,
0.020106066,
0.0032232592,
0.0103201419,
0.0162663534,
0.0210328996,
0.009465686,
0.0064381366,
-0.0517766178,
0.0309271608,
0.0279435087,
-0.0284487698,
-0.0029300973,
-0.0388074741,
-0.0097509092,
0.0158485938,
0.0226233043,
-0.0304770283,
-0.0323797688,
0.0475145839,
0.0502115451,
-0.0022006272,
-0.0345820822,
0.0373598859,
-0.0047070156,
0.0881669298,
-0.0527329445,
0.0605808161,
0.0124795046,
-0.0014757421,
-0.004954143,
0.0110351117,
-0.0240623187,
0.0378265679,
-0.0127226515,
-0.042547822,
-0.0228838976,
0.0100311525,
0.0473759919,
0.001556185,
0.0102438843,
0.0234268587,
-0.0426793918,
-0.0295805056,
-0.0101274736,
-0.1085915864,
-0.0125165684,
-0.0182380993,
0.0477827601,
0.0072252462,
0.0310324989,
-0.0501358435,
-0.0150876604,
-0.0288788602,
-0.0326235779,
0.0327826478,
0.0308393016,
0.0131143667,
0.0645782575,
-0.0723596662,
0.0056342478,
0.0123987012,
0.0000792034,
-0.0379627272,
0.0291396976,
0.065790385,
-0.0019282242,
0.036405433,
-0.0194449555,
0.0228706822,
0.0111560179,
0.0590778477,
-0.0341123641,
-0.0461113341,
-0.0179107692,
0.0104843779,
-0.0153273921,
-0.0242580622,
-0.0434580147,
0.009200234,
0.0288802348,
-0.0175500456,
-0.0325450301,
0.0256164037,
0.0640651733,
-0.0477616414,
0.0335438587,
-0.0129934754,
0.0266103856,
0.0770029277,
-0.0211068932,
0.0052649523,
0.0003124461,
0.0166828856,
0.0719591677,
0.0276620686,
-0.0267757606,
0.0322330408,
-0.0015201351,
-0.029306151,
-0.0046280292,
0.0327754021,
0.0621537156,
-0.0189224239,
0.0023444856,
0.0272544976,
-0.0030161296,
-0.01320598,
0.0415705927,
0.0164931305,
0.0534709506,
0.0307829306,
0.0090141231,
0.0397806019,
0.067212224,
0.0006538981,
-0.0318603553,
-0.0296100415,
0.0300550722,
-0.0111387456,
-0.0526589341,
-0.0115112364,
0.045408383,
-0.0159009527,
-0.0102015296,
-0.0114112506,
0.0075958399,
-0.029989589,
-0.0143388649,
0.020643888,
0.0021314661,
-0.0506673716,
0.0315999053,
0.0365540721,
-0.0316553749,
0.0259374492,
-0.0126617439,
-0.0178182684,
0.1021322161,
0.039656993,
-0.0386605412,
-0.0241315719,
-0.0667045936,
-0.0458698682,
-0.0022752306,
0.0389104411,
-0.0138910292,
-0.0084117064,
-0.0236762203,
-0.0424276479,
0.0193259977,
-0.0027413352,
0.0190771632,
0.0087846778,
0.0812726766,
0.0090531716,
-0.0518553779,
-0.0056591406,
0.0467055626,
0.0544907972,
-0.0088377232,
0.0534396991,
0.0029663686,
-0.0287309363,
0.0390444882,
0.0038737694,
0.0141787846,
-0.0034531914,
-0.0133401724,
-0.0369170457,
-0.0299448185,
0.0038616017,
0.0036711863,
-0.0241244957,
-0.0072600134,
-0.0314043984,
0.0051745283,
-0.0002811379,
-0.0132926246,
-0.006197691,
0.0160786621,
-0.0303554442,
-0.0265530758,
0.0097844442,
-0.017328782,
-0.0124440137,
-0.0592094734,
0.0940426886,
0.0398707539,
0.0304753277,
0.0133792637,
-0.0254647061,
0.0209375713,
-0.1251848489,
-0.035599228,
-0.0431536473,
-0.0084236059,
0.0023328019,
0.0251953639,
0.0053498982,
-0.0455244742,
-0.0266100299,
-0.0665514693,
0.0440875143,
0.010073497,
0.042327743,
0.0142908907,
-0.0336245224,
0.0001918303,
-0.008297123,
-0.042501159,
0.0104735345,
0.0154725676,
-0.0471842401,
0.0273196753,
-0.0119902985,
-0.0202937424,
-0.0274980739,
-0.0034046429,
-0.0360807255,
-0.0013261723,
0.068147935,
4.641e-7,
-0.0681551173,
0.0244309492,
-0.0066405185,
-0.0196296982,
0.0400805436,
0.0234653242,
-0.0335472599,
0.0198683348,
0.0105735604,
0.0162798017,
-0.0070062531,
0.0475495607,
0.0133726839,
0.008002528,
0.0142525444,
-0.0141919032,
-0.0037173319,
0.0785880983,
-0.0365586989,
-0.0493336394,
0.0181523412,
-0.047247339,
0.0216868818,
-0.0160654597,
-0.0074916212,
0.0135125322,
-0.0354353413,
0.0128647136,
-0.0465504229,
0.0239158589,
-0.0033036217,
0.003575969,
0.0288837608,
-0.0023176835,
0.0094924988,
0.0038737559,
0.0360849239,
-0.0348179601,
-0.0575171933,
-0.063554652,
0.0273743253,
0.0079538608,
-0.0119688688,
-0.0499454476,
-0.0495748781,
-0.0017724683,
-0.0155319162,
0.0091293864,
-0.0265861936,
-0.0320945382,
0.0247971583,
-0.0063326694,
-0.0048124571,
0.0139337284,
-0.0562708303,
-0.0427734926,
-0.0039741793,
0.0493922234,
0.0197618809,
0.0176619086,
-0.0599683374,
0.001234645,
-0.0131491628,
-0.0092509165,
-0.0104506928,
-0.0254122689,
-0.0178654082,
0.0585362576,
0.0498125404,
0.0092426417,
0.0019936329,
0.0259497408,
-0.0218081679,
0.0175867528,
-0.0161018427,
0.014252983,
0.0023956292,
-0.0176989529,
0.0379371718,
-0.1123006493,
0.0051819449,
0.005936035,
-0.0208331198,
-0.0254769064,
0.0308913141,
0.0757421106,
0.01470022,
-0.0526393317,
-0.0231393259,
0.0061676116,
-0.0758858547,
0.0169927161,
0.0646611974,
0.0155253205,
0.0022383418,
-0.0220451076,
0.0418081321,
-0.004925922,
-0.0386262573,
-0.0086235497,
-0.0545723513,
0.0545086004,
-0.051601585,
-0.0228719395,
0.0071203364,
-0.0808572099,
-0.0165553037,
-0.0365053229,
-0.0600271672,
-0.0390751995,
-0.0618109033,
0.012922734,
0.0278817061,
-0.009302346,
-0.0387040302,
0.0716494843,
-0.0375241376,
0.0217126943,
0.0232239608,
0.0727871209,
-0.0234198701,
0.0049863122,
-0.0553846918,
-0.0248026866,
-0.0135227935,
0.0381232388,
0.0253428258,
-0.054916732,
0.0174460094,
-0.0135339154,
-0.0331107713,
-0.0418321788,
-0.0009641128,
0.0953308493,
0.0583218038,
-0.0190747734,
0.0336120985,
-0.0541490428,
-0.0027409052,
0.0249798819,
0.0905315429,
-0.0121393027,
-0.0761115551,
0.0109705189,
0.006524669,
-0.0056031421,
0.029926857,
0.0241704173,
0.0239494964,
-0.0587176196,
-0.0172340237,
-0.038721364,
-0.0597974099,
0.0404550023,
0.0106493281,
0.0250872429,
0.0532743037,
-0.0115824677,
0.0035429415,
-0.0533853993,
-0.0117329825,
-0.0104821995,
0.0628188029,
-0.0526149869,
-0.0225710385,
-0.023270335,
-0.0482049398,
-0.0693523884,
-0.0877041668,
-0.0415395908,
0.027660938,
-0.0377194658,
-0.0341446809,
0.0125820776,
-0.0224836487,
-0.0322315395,
-0.0832614377,
0.0293227211,
0.036554344,
-0.059303347,
-0.0020177318,
-0.0421217829,
0.0225791223,
-0.002672815,
0.0000117287,
-0.031066563,
0.0344050564,
0.0311525576,
-0.025615871,
0.0532150269,
-0.0440026559,
-0.0334126465,
0.0244245566,
0.0086221118,
0.0155014098,
-0.0188588835,
-0.0661884472,
-0.0072413809,
0.0065181521,
0.0018677432,
-0.0141211394,
-0.0067916033,
0.0402899422,
0.0174333565,
-0.0199188981,
-0.0095686987,
-0.0258473456,
0.0356269479,
-0.059343379,
0.0405809246,
-0.0179961752,
0.0492784157,
-0.0251299329,
-0.0170218851,
0.0216117594,
-0.0404935069,
0.0339947417,
0.0188955739,
-0.0180047695,
0.024945071,
-0.0069297017,
0.0154258441,
0.0066686287,
0.0365007371,
-0.0300816018,
-0.0145285511,
-0.0248507876,
0.0479558706,
0.0126059689,
-0.0266812388,
0.0389587656,
-0.0058768573,
0.0089701209,
-0.0112829981,
-0.008497213,
0.0219397414,
-0.024909813,
0.0116516305,
0.009021786,
0.0052865711,
-0.0055828206,
-0.0070480038,
0.0372974016,
-0.0410589166,
-0.0266524348,
-0.0551732555,
-0.0300549474,
0.0363649987,
0.0618234687,
0.053019803,
-0.0084250318,
0.0144265816,
-0.0679890886,
-0.0190627575,
0.0307784695,
-0.0143627943,
-0.0135606304,
0.0023703121,
0.0272730235,
0.0347898901,
0.0128598874,
0.001555635,
-0.0812903494,
0.0043763188,
-0.0074771205,
0.008462864,
-0.0766342357,
-5.955540007e-33,
-0.0234571751,
-0.0787992105,
0.0430115275,
0.0378847346,
0.0210667141,
0.0151754757,
0.0509862676,
-0.0432941169,
0.0370072201,
0.0000972107,
-0.0220605899,
0.0156546067,
0.0083750263,
0.0001531068,
0.03199552,
0.0094215479,
0.0455034636,
0.0142629333,
-0.0323564298,
0.0332709812,
-0.002675835,
0.0438476242,
0.0656518787,
-0.066245459,
0.0270055328,
-0.0076047499,
-0.0017183991,
0.0065869819,
0.0827605426,
0.052228149,
-0.0189604778,
0.0111342547,
0.0391254313,
-0.073570177,
0.0318134837,
0.002245835,
-0.0680212528,
-0.0307197943,
0.0247651581,
0.0248401128,
0.0512350574,
-0.014388172,
-0.0113465814,
-0.0046021189,
-0.0062723393,
0.0073637315,
0.1063043848,
0.015033477,
0.0218141451,
-0.0379993953,
-0.0103690522,
0.0178004857,
-0.0112510417,
0.0451691337,
-0.0245983731,
-0.0541837513,
-0.0012205961,
0.0709477812,
-0.1000043303,
-0.0028798839,
-0.0384786576,
0.0137367947,
-0.0166123565,
-0.0600218661,
-0.0506582409,
0.0578010902,
0.0550011359,
0.0122045269,
0.0344786979,
-0.0447205603,
-0.0013161917,
0.0217221789,
-0.0035976882,
-0.0105490703,
0.050512325,
-0.0360709094,
-0.0137455752,
0.0496519953,
0.0050495155,
-0.0057447925,
-0.0087752696,
-0.0005862075,
-0.0365308113,
-0.0155299753,
-0.0150920097,
-0.0260998942,
-0.0468026362,
0.005481401,
0.0483346768,
-0.0001843295,
0.000544699,
-0.0003798395,
-0.0312272385,
-0.0238083042,
-0.0122229923,
0.0226771701,
-0.027993897,
0.0013973686,
-0.0070252051,
-0.0144964522,
-0.0567055903,
-0.0046372246,
0.0054861726,
-0.0412441529,
0.0150913056,
0.0185687542,
0.0035890879,
0.0118704215,
-0.0643263236,
-0.0118932901,
0.0302940607,
-0.0121117299,
-0.0491360128,
0.0613991879,
0.0119350199,
0.0036046298,
0.0110698249,
0.0258287396,
0.0479073226,
0.0317305289,
-0.0232253671,
-0.0856011435,
0.063456513,
0.0156589281,
-0.0179989245,
-0.0043030377,
-0.0128175253,
-0.0041195988,
0.0068872734,
-0.0311691519,
0.0086311847,
-0.0023020853,
2.611e-7,
0.065476194,
0.0138196368,
-0.0872544721,
-0.0310883038,
0.0343706496,
0.0022582728,
0.0140140867,
0.0399104506,
0.0427171662,
0.0697972253,
-0.0246893838,
-0.0047017513,
-0.027515322,
0.004958956,
-0.0993765816,
-0.0003829863,
0.0257031117,
-0.0455374718,
-0.0422717705,
0.0439513959,
0.1017625332,
0.0383346826,
0.0767954066,
-0.0123876072,
-0.0575743653,
-0.0112372348,
0.0014796394,
0.014365661,
-0.036529094,
0.0316166915,
0.0958628356,
0.0240681581,
-0.015225512,
0.0414288379,
-0.0137025146,
0.0355644375,
0.0662684813,
0.0673311949,
-0.0465630777,
0.0326320194,
0.0150365606,
-0.043400947,
-0.0339373574,
0.0211489834,
0.0342254303,
-0.0190760549,
-0.0128562404,
-0.0005494277,
-0.0655147433,
0.0072671939,
0.0035392037,
0.061773777,
-0.0299624819,
0.0067487047,
0.0032976782,
-0.035760805,
-0.0575126782,
-0.0233228114,
0.0455982834,
-0.0052130539,
-0.0076282006,
-0.0519716181,
0.002573407,
-0.0194419511,
0.048106242,
-0.0638322905,
0.0088999299,
2.360186027e-34,
0.0237593688,
0.0162703898,
-0.0316120051,
-0.0091577144,
0.0221778732,
0.0297800303,
0.022190785,
0.0073005091,
-0.0184736066,
-0.0281877834,
0.0015869604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15745v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15745v2 | Context-VQA: Towards Context-Aware and Purposeful Visual Question Answering | 2023-07-28T18:01:08 | 2023-08-30T15:58:56 | Nandita Naik, Christopher Potts, Elisa Kreiss | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual question answering (VQA) has the potential to make the Internet more
accessible in an interactive way, allowing people who cannot see images to ask
questions about them. However, multiple studies have shown that people who are
blind or have low-vision prefer image explanations that incorporate the context
in which an image appears, yet current VQA datasets focus on images in
isolation. We argue that VQA models will not fully succeed at meeting people's
needs unless they take context into account. To further motivate and analyze
the distinction between different contexts, we introduce Context-VQA, a VQA
dataset that pairs images with contexts, specifically types of websites (e.g.,
a shopping website). We find that the types of questions vary systematically
across contexts. For example, images presented in a travel context garner 2
times more "Where?" questions, and images on social media and news garner 2.8
and 1.8 times more "Who?" questions than the average. We also find that context
effects are especially important when participants can't see the image. These
results demonstrate that context affects the types of questions asked and that
VQA models should be context-sensitive to better meet people's needs,
especially in accessibility settings. | [
0.0174784549,
0.0295336079,
-0.0317278057,
0.0365785398,
0.0339037627,
0.0186763145,
0.0641286597,
0.0053947144,
0.0235616695,
-0.0532419197,
-0.0391913392,
-0.0162838679,
-0.0023777664,
0.0313256271,
0.0369139053,
-0.1062335819,
-0.0193765182,
-0.0125380252,
-0.0408892855,
0.0296993647,
0.0361429639,
0.000313824,
0.0067512947,
0.0252090003,
0.022952782,
-0.027981298,
-0.0010564935,
0.0461974964,
-0.0052853166,
-0.0460484587,
0.0051287096,
0.0423332527,
0.0548987165,
-0.0647546202,
0.0000020262,
0.008385485,
0.0662918314,
-0.038824793,
0.0096251508,
0.0176493619,
-0.032496769,
0.001407064,
0.0449433886,
0.0401619002,
-0.021759009,
0.0045191511,
0.0450564958,
0.0313148312,
0.0291245691,
-0.0201019105,
-0.0187718067,
0.0076857512,
-0.0494570471,
0.0047773286,
0.093323864,
-0.0550890639,
-0.014570185,
0.0242691096,
-0.0047241128,
0.0094856527,
-0.0194378477,
0.0525847785,
0.0278499909,
0.0219966713,
0.0225520469,
0.0510242954,
-0.0280267913,
-0.0119707044,
0.0143294018,
0.1049796194,
0.0707202628,
-0.0133157969,
-0.0074544894,
0.0155980429,
0.0165876057,
0.0380154066,
-0.0931108743,
0.0210904907,
-0.0084062349,
-0.0129580898,
-0.0711396039,
0.0448865555,
0.0204034783,
0.0261519849,
0.0473424569,
-0.0369234048,
0.0059865257,
0.0112295896,
-0.0444143564,
0.0109210638,
-0.0413619168,
-0.0460895412,
-0.0294129867,
0.029988341,
0.0224895179,
0.017722534,
-0.0070773698,
0.0204115678,
0.0059175119,
-0.0169147737,
0.0170001145,
-0.0009677781,
-0.0782588497,
0.0801261365,
0.0045768558,
0.042103149,
-0.0246211831,
-0.0048754425,
-0.001097408,
0.0221439376,
0.0106631713,
-0.0393262766,
-0.0215130784,
-0.0364195146,
-0.0593226366,
-0.015921304,
0.0098563889,
0.0433207825,
-0.0144075556,
-0.0401856974,
-0.0213106908,
0.0546774641,
-0.0233364701,
0.0221722014,
-0.0592251606,
0.0207670908,
-0.0533755645,
0.0276936628,
-0.0165436976,
-0.0423227362,
0.0135657545,
0.000645567,
0.0458905175,
-0.0154348323,
-0.0254689995,
0.0431289114,
-0.0096607674,
-0.0139688291,
-0.0405455157,
-0.0504359566,
0.0325065814,
0.0074106678,
-0.0064935246,
-0.0356801711,
-0.0071439017,
-0.0016230507,
-0.0130969072,
-0.0106049208,
-0.0023588014,
0.0614994727,
-0.0326737314,
0.084623307,
0.0075212028,
0.0030869318,
0.0470686369,
0.0390718542,
0.0153944595,
0.0715050921,
-0.0225145798,
0.0107091786,
0.0818986744,
-0.0152026201,
0.0319142193,
0.0100381458,
-0.0157446731,
-0.0041856677,
-0.0319563225,
0.0498675518,
-0.0080634365,
-0.0041286955,
0.0094628399,
0.0167350732,
-0.0450223908,
0.0035317428,
0.0492576733,
0.0427288674,
0.0368723832,
-0.0199855734,
-0.0213892069,
-0.0395557843,
0.0084509617,
-0.0004413143,
-0.0096085044,
0.085433431,
-0.0051388834,
0.014968114,
0.0078197056,
0.0274073295,
-0.0724605024,
-0.0605465174,
-0.0230692774,
0.0065656365,
0.0357953794,
0.0165199973,
0.0365093648,
0.0320242904,
-0.0253738053,
-0.0514600091,
0.0036465672,
-0.0675298348,
-0.0261747222,
-0.0306973755,
0.0485932864,
0.0652204528,
0.0443418175,
0.0037475373,
0.0180811621,
0.0091946041,
0.0612925179,
0.0194074716,
-0.0281361844,
0.024586942,
0.0064014625,
-0.0357487425,
-0.0564933829,
-0.0164826903,
-0.0093540838,
-0.0330493934,
0.0325747803,
0.0106942002,
0.01232378,
-0.0679501295,
0.0386029072,
0.0148128048,
0.0215141121,
0.0012975037,
-0.0348970555,
0.0411296897,
-0.0279165562,
0.0326013379,
0.0264158901,
0.0272226073,
-0.0101008499,
-0.0106068989,
0.0301886648,
0.0372242406,
-0.0514681339,
-0.0037146858,
0.0042803893,
-0.1050191522,
0.0054569342,
0.0265583452,
0.0021420477,
0.0119119501,
0.0256274622,
-0.050237868,
-0.0137475124,
-0.0489778183,
-0.0402344204,
0.0167192332,
-0.0049403808,
-0.0198822711,
0.0887529254,
-0.0170268044,
-0.0156036299,
0.0264563989,
-0.0073105269,
0.0016994929,
-0.0290532652,
0.0295751207,
-0.0209580101,
0.0116835888,
0.0194661245,
0.0264978278,
0.0058243419,
-0.0693552122,
0.0514350124,
-0.1116547137,
-0.0534934439,
-0.0315963924,
-0.0160281695,
0.053316623,
0.0382935628,
-0.003489119,
-0.0537496656,
-0.0398976468,
0.0503338762,
-0.0437227748,
0.0235380586,
0.0412106253,
-0.0030358122,
0.0252398103,
-0.045497667,
-0.0349924564,
0.0202101879,
0.0978390798,
0.0523805059,
0.0114224544,
-0.0294228941,
-0.0116801793,
-0.0301689859,
0.0112349913,
0.0081706429,
-0.0055513913,
0.0221497379,
-0.005849042,
0.0035074777,
0.0405249931,
0.0038533744,
0.0102228262,
-0.0148789482,
0.0170015153,
-0.0277291853,
-0.0151951769,
0.0119126998,
-0.0011837904,
0.0123452116,
-0.0830341056,
0.0097529981,
0.0099882577,
-0.0313378945,
0.0141315972,
-0.0427104384,
0.0431302227,
0.0133013986,
-0.0317055248,
-0.0952903405,
0.0158555955,
0.0185849741,
0.0778216943,
-0.0162948091,
-0.0327235498,
0.0346577764,
0.0119167138,
0.0204167683,
0.0371493474,
0.0207530465,
-0.0579998195,
0.0623445287,
-0.0066826004,
0.0172982588,
-0.0134373028,
-0.0103652021,
-0.0266679954,
-0.0179671217,
0.0110823456,
-0.0143781221,
0.0447928421,
-0.0494383872,
-0.0117569156,
-0.0072233486,
-0.0449670032,
-0.0258263312,
-0.0445250273,
-0.0399690382,
-0.0159976818,
-0.0526203327,
0.0061229742,
0.005340544,
0.0488484465,
0.0294687171,
0.0140445922,
0.0191934779,
-0.0234535784,
0.0145766167,
0.0742294416,
0.0701852068,
0.0512748286,
-0.0036921229,
-0.0080084801,
0.0061700894,
0.0495668389,
0.0219402183,
-0.0523970984,
0.0061768093,
0.008566306,
0.025040539,
0.0414049923,
-0.0292913783,
0.0388653353,
0.0606480539,
-0.0254738759,
-0.0111365346,
0.0725390911,
0.0292900763,
-0.0508900769,
-0.0206804965,
-0.0272522178,
0.0143507579,
0.0315907709,
0.0193864722,
-0.1261520535,
-0.0607522354,
-0.0236863066,
0.0323992223,
-0.0163909625,
0.0308556911,
0.0174573921,
-0.0657532886,
0.0322562084,
-0.0220396928,
-0.0036550919,
-0.0331344269,
-0.0276748631,
0.0103236092,
-0.0085158525,
0.0139537249,
0.0258225035,
-0.0716806576,
0.0179331694,
0.0021374205,
0.0109314732,
-0.0211916436,
0.0027372236,
-0.0370998681,
-0.0162388273,
0.0474631228,
-0.0148768714,
-0.0064426013,
-0.0781819597,
0.0225225817,
-0.0697978288,
0.0341338068,
-0.0221682098,
0.0509118661,
-0.0061323796,
-0.0306669064,
-0.0608638674,
0.0706117377,
-0.024944786,
-0.0427741371,
0.0195226017,
-0.00820251,
0.0032938391,
-0.0235986523,
-0.0552853383,
-0.0250104032,
-0.0203935653,
0.0193802174,
0.0483446121,
-0.0406213515,
-0.0239810497,
-0.0202779714,
0.0041192006,
-0.0277366117,
-0.048391968,
0.0015874003,
0.0178579651,
-0.0291479789,
-0.0846661478,
-0.0152377104,
0.052547019,
0.0043083159,
-0.0400804467,
-0.0283480939,
-0.015401057,
0.0588334985,
-0.0618351065,
0.0506329387,
0.00561092,
0.0165669136,
-0.0330819152,
-0.0129251583,
-0.0153033268,
-0.0744826421,
-0.0084846644,
-0.0009539282,
-0.0398589037,
0.0205056574,
-0.0124662127,
0.0190797895,
0.0123017011,
-0.0248534679,
0.0304934867,
-0.0830622464,
0.0049512386,
0.0441362336,
0.0380039662,
-0.0083863242,
-0.0284152664,
0.003913383,
0.0136039266,
-0.0109196138,
-0.0465759188,
-0.0148545587,
-0.0116504058,
0.0135987923,
-0.0700724274,
0.0351315178,
0.0116594322,
-0.0063727377,
0.0136418939,
0.0146470331,
0.0011979331,
-0.0039368519,
0.022552589,
-0.0045682429,
0.041049961,
-0.0392001644,
0.0273708869,
-0.0139035583,
-0.0003052384,
-0.0173294935,
-0.0202057697,
-0.0276476145,
-0.0264437106,
-0.086352028,
0.0225378387,
0.0714586228,
-0.0000529241,
-0.0712253749,
-0.009589415,
-0.0085326843,
0.0102483062,
-0.0253499858,
0.0594320595,
0.0099071776,
0.0685628057,
0.0000476125,
-0.0344344974,
-0.0291334428,
0.0453912206,
-0.0242394432,
-0.0266108438,
0.0192173142,
0.0267164893,
0.0274073984,
0.0028408335,
-0.0308820177,
0.0394437425,
-0.0212374032,
0.0338948108,
-0.0184219796,
0.0287044551,
0.0004342006,
0.0617948659,
0.064373225,
0.0185008291,
-0.0024582336,
0.0633455738,
0.0099338498,
0.0136626502,
-0.0174955744,
-0.0146272816,
-0.0048388122,
0.0331262983,
0.0174768791,
0.0240602866,
0.0141600911,
0.0413664766,
-0.0396462344,
-0.0521711782,
-0.0145404506,
0.0265414156,
0.0000043595,
0.0260244142,
0.0657683834,
0.0200212728,
0.0234728996,
-0.0489096865,
0.0008896357,
0.0172337499,
-0.0897893384,
0.0008793233,
-0.0111990571,
-6.478370507e-33,
-0.0042773285,
-0.0547455959,
-0.0050767134,
-0.0352987945,
-0.0003828585,
0.0393767543,
-0.0189079847,
0.0049767131,
-0.0132045476,
-0.006972597,
-0.0042515001,
-0.0035364283,
0.0008676403,
0.0368845277,
-0.0143540716,
-0.0528060384,
0.0230245162,
0.0239306744,
-0.0185251292,
0.0290049184,
0.0074127852,
-0.0302906688,
0.016331736,
-0.048070699,
0.0026362501,
-0.0223696176,
-0.0233780425,
0.0109712845,
0.0517574176,
0.0840499699,
-0.0293000583,
0.0304467939,
0.0384117812,
0.0170614999,
-0.0011323032,
0.1093098521,
-0.0985013545,
0.0006353647,
0.039003551,
0.0157508198,
-0.1277657002,
-0.0270306282,
0.0134611493,
-0.0109618064,
0.0071655279,
-0.0486417934,
0.061750941,
-0.0278524291,
0.0104306657,
0.0066068075,
0.0054696803,
-0.009941576,
-0.04022073,
-0.0057185385,
-0.0025509535,
0.0837097764,
0.0082727214,
0.0435756855,
-0.0313829854,
0.0642784238,
-0.0010193326,
-0.0035341799,
0.089796342,
0.0327130221,
0.0208606776,
0.031712845,
0.0237235799,
-0.0254708007,
-0.0555055626,
-0.072044909,
-0.0177517813,
0.0258038417,
0.0406634994,
0.0518277176,
0.0250845198,
-0.0024380239,
-0.053924907,
0.0369411223,
-0.0570451245,
0.03993861,
0.044828739,
-0.0148628242,
-0.0470877104,
0.034762729,
-0.0580742694,
-0.0068673175,
-0.0848730803,
-0.0069016349,
0.0556184389,
0.030085532,
-0.0165164061,
0.0235417336,
0.0066664112,
-0.027320452,
-0.0183477458,
0.0216926169,
0.0112515697,
0.0268462822,
0.0203348119,
-0.0056492132,
0.0156645887,
0.0357281677,
0.0503151231,
0.0275734123,
0.0017563975,
-0.0064772959,
0.0126675898,
-0.0276900064,
-0.0312052965,
-0.0261633433,
-0.0439099297,
-0.0161367469,
-0.0339358747,
-0.0326903872,
0.0159931518,
0.0287669748,
-0.0726136863,
-0.003592724,
-0.0135959974,
-0.0080967527,
-0.028586546,
-0.0457616784,
-0.0326992124,
0.0292950198,
-0.03485227,
-0.0250095706,
-0.0364650749,
0.0220552664,
0.0045417235,
-0.0456211716,
-0.0377228819,
0.052920565,
2.553e-7,
0.0353639424,
0.0124695553,
-0.0008179595,
0.0206713807,
0.0228465367,
0.0326467305,
0.0328455195,
0.0127638588,
0.0074272496,
-0.0017500247,
0.017997982,
0.0369651727,
-0.0084662,
-0.0235284194,
-0.0085328752,
0.0346397273,
-0.0277757663,
0.0144482814,
-0.0356325284,
-0.0057417145,
0.0338157155,
0.0180379543,
-0.0548148155,
-0.0113041233,
0.0189842936,
-0.0604671836,
0.0552879199,
-0.0553082153,
0.019535156,
-0.048759535,
-0.0155382883,
0.0536012053,
0.0268532131,
-0.034291096,
-0.0232588034,
-0.0263871122,
0.0597248524,
-0.0027906855,
-0.0145604471,
-0.0454772227,
-0.0273347516,
0.0331582576,
0.0233665686,
-0.0616846681,
0.0832000673,
-0.0329076871,
-0.0187053531,
0.0132902814,
-0.0228694342,
-0.0161888059,
0.0335037485,
-0.0005955225,
-0.0406789333,
-0.0236593485,
0.0165876597,
-0.022320386,
-0.0244113803,
-0.0602519959,
-0.0142313251,
-0.0088479985,
0.0073399446,
-0.0183829926,
-0.0642041042,
0.0158837605,
0.0053337961,
0.0183013789,
-0.0435106531,
1.309742349e-34,
0.0353299826,
0.0349675454,
0.0164477639,
0.02703318,
0.0129074631,
-0.0401002429,
0.0008582458,
-0.0283166878,
0.0449497923,
-0.0753854215,
0.0205769595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15703v1 | Uncertainty in Natural Language Generation: From Theory to Applications | 2023-07-28T17:51:21 | 2023-07-28T17:51:21 | Joris Baan, Nico Daheim, Evgenia Ilia, Dennis Ulmer, Haau-Sing Li, Raquel Fernández, Barbara Plank, Rico Sennrich, Chrysoula Zerva, Wilker Aziz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances of powerful Language Models have allowed Natural Language
Generation (NLG) to emerge as an important technology that can not only perform
traditional tasks like summarisation or translation, but also serve as a
natural language interface to a variety of applications. As such, it is crucial
that NLG systems are trustworthy and reliable, for example by indicating when
they are likely to be wrong; and supporting multiple views, backgrounds and
writing styles -- reflecting diverse human sub-populations. In this paper, we
argue that a principled treatment of uncertainty can assist in creating systems
and evaluation protocols better aligned with these goals. We first present the
fundamental theory, frameworks and vocabulary required to represent
uncertainty. We then characterise the main sources of uncertainty in NLG from a
linguistic perspective, and propose a two-dimensional taxonomy that is more
informative and faithful than the popular aleatoric/epistemic dichotomy.
Finally, we move from theory to applications and highlight exciting research
directions that exploit uncertainty to power decoding, controllable generation,
self-assessment, selective answering, active learning and more. | [
0.0392230973,
0.0771626979,
-0.0167193934,
-0.0228373576,
-0.0202550497,
-0.0112166815,
-0.0219759066,
-0.0350860879,
-0.0312070604,
-0.0668868721,
0.040491689,
-0.0882266536,
0.0169814322,
0.0249899533,
0.0332095958,
-0.090150103,
0.0307028927,
-0.0138880359,
0.0724136904,
-0.0169217158,
0.0042110085,
-0.0005417558,
-0.0059830593,
0.0471532047,
-0.0288057048,
0.0252389498,
-0.0151239187,
0.0143855838,
0.0075693936,
-0.0429143831,
0.0015875094,
0.038724605,
-0.0246160962,
0.0259782262,
0.0000021457,
-0.0428901054,
-0.0119364504,
-0.0130689107,
0.0123491008,
-0.0037939628,
0.0515787415,
0.0374827608,
-0.0182365254,
0.00179147,
-0.0350406058,
0.0007614848,
0.0549009889,
-0.0081647737,
0.0467700809,
0.0485318042,
0.0104895346,
0.0028154713,
-0.0245699212,
-0.0155019816,
0.008395141,
-0.0266309921,
-0.0080893952,
-0.0206412226,
0.0009572603,
0.0072544506,
0.0057712761,
0.0167109054,
-0.0001420527,
0.0051397313,
-0.0173890907,
-0.0021447064,
-0.0014809808,
-0.0592892691,
-0.0072266697,
0.0293865595,
0.0220597871,
0.0018712581,
0.0016141594,
-0.031867452,
0.003637719,
0.0317935534,
-0.0142520629,
0.0839930847,
-0.0196696892,
0.0088344412,
0.0027937281,
0.0340153836,
0.0015678033,
0.0167367142,
-0.004658862,
0.0728210732,
0.0013887895,
0.0091100121,
-0.0040615289,
0.0363365188,
-0.0419686288,
-0.0750441551,
-0.0002898799,
0.0440292768,
-0.0554494895,
0.0281600207,
-0.0868207365,
-0.0111309355,
0.0379417054,
-0.0390644856,
0.0009984541,
0.008161339,
0.0269692093,
-0.0360462591,
0.049167078,
0.027869897,
0.0149885444,
-0.0264743716,
-0.0414988846,
0.0159363076,
-0.0222697649,
-0.0297595132,
-0.0433813259,
0.0264999848,
-0.0370775051,
-0.004736763,
-0.0717074424,
-0.0042610043,
-0.0612167716,
0.0110522378,
-0.0256462973,
0.0394397303,
-0.0798190683,
0.0043681934,
-0.0388462394,
-0.0035802457,
-0.0121759251,
0.005721224,
0.0343980938,
-0.067241624,
0.0123412237,
0.0161910895,
-0.0119565837,
0.0087223342,
-0.0297519471,
0.0563515238,
-0.0138195585,
0.0017439871,
-0.0426608361,
-0.087490961,
-0.0475958064,
-0.0529268906,
-0.0221016202,
-0.0686328337,
-0.0341332667,
0.0081518302,
-0.0043732701,
-0.0640163943,
0.0366572961,
0.032256376,
-0.0134880245,
0.0473079681,
-0.0221521296,
-0.0022309767,
0.0197411031,
0.0034052308,
-0.0007068504,
0.0686509386,
0.0656354651,
0.0343630798,
0.0433937684,
0.0106642749,
0.016148299,
-0.0205645747,
0.0080386484,
-0.0472956561,
-0.0027909558,
-0.0436967984,
-0.052553799,
0.002532749,
-0.0214055981,
0.091929704,
-0.002993749,
0.0298184678,
0.056378182,
0.0021253864,
-0.0176655501,
-0.0057335435,
0.0586437359,
0.0117650228,
0.0214445572,
0.0275804754,
0.011464824,
0.0169367567,
-0.0304291658,
0.0527551174,
0.0133165196,
0.0476265475,
0.010163038,
-0.0819930807,
-0.0323675163,
-0.0056884708,
0.0358851738,
0.0041911574,
0.0282284431,
-0.0031091112,
-0.0145268189,
0.0152076678,
0.0093112057,
-0.0558119155,
0.0318236053,
-0.0460262783,
0.0302839465,
0.0466882326,
0.0383507833,
0.0112192295,
-0.0132912444,
-0.0067393309,
-0.0046418444,
0.0486825444,
0.0652840212,
-0.0141761564,
-0.0165908877,
-0.0486569703,
-0.0110552972,
-0.0115582012,
0.0204967558,
0.0197325181,
0.005425177,
0.0335014425,
0.017764762,
0.0054980288,
-0.0469618253,
0.0128850779,
0.0145288687,
-0.0258127674,
0.028202856,
-0.0206979997,
0.0433956534,
0.027642265,
-0.0269137789,
0.060272783,
0.0011601566,
0.0067994748,
-0.0585557893,
0.0472123362,
-0.0276613384,
0.0117059126,
0.0168587472,
-0.0446639135,
0.0001401862,
-0.0343581736,
-0.0175913069,
-0.0581669472,
0.0296899881,
-0.0710827634,
-0.0145304818,
-0.0365386307,
0.0237477366,
0.0136791477,
0.0092963129,
-0.0770596191,
0.0824205056,
0.0068714991,
0.0171044916,
0.0374210961,
0.021935327,
0.0422879755,
-0.0456720777,
-0.0325298309,
0.0292674396,
0.000705842,
0.0212207325,
0.0676562786,
0.021755388,
-0.0244361181,
-0.0246187523,
-0.0247041043,
0.0010645536,
-0.0128231505,
0.0203505754,
0.0229312498,
-0.0221243333,
0.0044471361,
0.0114719654,
-0.0419848114,
-0.0077153598,
0.0517632179,
-0.010201253,
0.0436018445,
0.018316187,
0.0190095752,
-0.0233823359,
0.0190947987,
0.0078227697,
0.0224793665,
0.0504863337,
-0.0018205615,
-0.0939450338,
0.0448663682,
-0.0489354059,
-0.0143850846,
0.027545983,
-0.0321842991,
0.0191912409,
0.0142035913,
0.0010259412,
-0.0042203092,
0.0524436347,
0.0379078127,
0.0416593477,
-0.0455572456,
-0.0028998121,
0.0012324047,
-0.0462969542,
-0.0062120524,
0.0316942483,
-0.0584147274,
0.0214832779,
0.0390623286,
0.076221168,
-0.0185148325,
-0.0754138231,
0.0660124123,
-0.0617086291,
-0.0490700975,
-0.0085688252,
-0.0316331126,
0.0075974511,
0.0666743889,
0.0004037692,
-0.0322372727,
0.0946283117,
-0.0214720368,
0.0494164154,
-0.0547794476,
-0.0069123358,
0.004162889,
0.0201511141,
0.0096480697,
0.0302621182,
0.0365239792,
0.0007909119,
-0.0495816544,
-0.0299218837,
0.0380032621,
-0.0554960407,
0.0072427611,
-0.1018674597,
-0.0211630166,
-0.0119120479,
-0.0133280596,
-0.0445229635,
-0.0363605879,
-0.0017228533,
-0.0073390086,
0.1035957411,
-0.0224215966,
0.0035349845,
0.0110005839,
0.0117830522,
-0.0229309257,
-0.0269903056,
-0.0225792192,
-0.0128215784,
0.0331304297,
0.0351316594,
0.0192123074,
0.0926162526,
-0.002031645,
-0.0206040442,
0.0504367724,
-0.0152828284,
0.0313780084,
-0.0105755739,
0.0017264602,
0.016899582,
-0.0279226806,
-0.0349828862,
0.057231117,
0.0771111697,
-0.0251616258,
-0.0427470617,
0.1160185784,
0.0329183377,
0.0366049409,
0.0111367339,
-0.0359994993,
0.0485453308,
-0.0040313974,
0.0317143016,
-0.0512876809,
-0.0089804307,
-0.0074747116,
0.0594785213,
-0.0702779144,
-0.0128252199,
-0.0311831553,
-0.0981945246,
0.0508969091,
0.0312412679,
-0.0398496687,
-0.0350027941,
0.0143164964,
-0.0391583368,
0.0093430681,
0.0171400346,
0.0116505101,
-0.0037737112,
0.0578496046,
0.0685540885,
-0.0638924465,
-0.0672006384,
-0.0573482215,
0.0087525807,
0.0673756748,
0.0357144251,
0.0224997718,
0.0050347485,
-0.0091122771,
-0.0461676084,
-0.0618407205,
0.0187515114,
-0.0052875048,
0.0060491357,
0.0411341898,
-0.021426091,
-0.0437501296,
0.0095494036,
-0.0087345727,
-0.0379226282,
-0.0205176026,
0.0335689373,
-0.0394006744,
-0.0156770498,
-0.0227643345,
0.0206453167,
0.0642021149,
0.0705641881,
-0.007647723,
-0.0259042066,
-0.0418350287,
-0.0606767386,
0.0564740337,
-0.0806869641,
-0.0128878476,
0.0433188528,
0.0155080454,
-0.0320482664,
-0.0947329998,
-0.0607873686,
-0.0070669469,
0.0276015922,
0.0120890643,
-0.0286944788,
0.0667146891,
-0.0017682274,
-0.0442707539,
-0.0289454479,
0.0271805115,
0.0166666359,
-0.0252764747,
-0.0451467857,
0.0130317919,
-0.0281607565,
0.0029975316,
0.0710114315,
-0.062853761,
-0.0922097117,
0.0308688097,
0.0618469976,
0.0342872143,
-0.0159996841,
-0.0112508349,
-0.0669080168,
0.0549755059,
0.0706992373,
-0.0102835363,
0.0178131219,
0.0090584392,
0.0533798598,
-0.0147698363,
0.0150250848,
-0.0321217738,
-0.0138603691,
-0.0315148719,
0.0565002002,
-0.0209654272,
-0.0551712215,
0.0286579821,
0.0240790509,
-0.0062919324,
-0.0781304315,
-0.0045229574,
-0.0219872016,
-0.0422299542,
-0.0374107137,
-0.0215646569,
-0.0392179824,
-0.0196620394,
-0.007362972,
-0.0349797159,
-0.0150521332,
-0.0013279745,
-0.0261014123,
0.0301223863,
0.0033964552,
-0.0151452292,
0.0102189677,
0.023867514,
0.0020490345,
-0.0178083032,
-0.0079069417,
0.0267605335,
-0.0394851081,
0.0326477252,
0.0183341801,
0.0415282808,
0.0188463815,
-0.0246840492,
0.0100222277,
-0.0068388302,
-0.0603230298,
-0.0517338216,
-0.0319663584,
0.021528054,
0.029526893,
0.0207508467,
0.0579893999,
-0.0536291227,
0.0039354381,
-0.0107323993,
0.040947035,
0.0512099974,
-0.0245422032,
0.0457795337,
-0.0046066879,
-0.0358761325,
-0.0140929557,
0.0847007185,
-0.0013084579,
0.0200036187,
-0.0372186303,
-0.0568206459,
-0.0413544588,
-0.0458396077,
-0.0303482953,
0.027465133,
-0.0012545004,
0.0128774298,
-0.0829053074,
-0.0490825474,
0.0129868304,
0.0551683605,
0.0673635378,
-0.0330590978,
0.0568340085,
0.0375578627,
0.005909191,
0.0140548833,
-0.0444112532,
0.0236326158,
-0.0179114211,
0.0402079448,
-0.0429748222,
-6.701541048e-33,
-0.0476498008,
-0.0896902829,
-0.0105896825,
-0.035259556,
-0.0121810995,
-0.0283684749,
-0.018652143,
0.04974401,
0.0300426893,
0.0383760408,
0.009221199,
-0.0238360465,
0.0172121599,
0.0503092967,
0.0197955184,
-0.0039344425,
0.0373213477,
0.0047981767,
-0.0252007358,
0.0009261758,
0.081684798,
-0.0191333909,
0.0337563828,
-0.0455274023,
0.0586142354,
0.0113792326,
-0.0243488941,
0.0052878833,
0.0116614979,
0.0364070944,
-0.0115083745,
0.0517241955,
-0.0092442995,
-0.0229853652,
-0.031039888,
-0.0119227553,
-0.010066824,
-0.0565333255,
-0.0022380075,
0.0412674472,
-0.0198178608,
-0.0220494717,
0.03162935,
-0.0325440876,
-0.0482904874,
0.0494466349,
0.0233899858,
-0.0185731724,
0.0010237421,
-0.0623994991,
-0.0314953551,
0.0241308492,
-0.0170218088,
-0.0180733558,
-0.023226155,
0.0458849706,
-0.0315185338,
-0.0425436758,
-0.0338947102,
0.0161138214,
0.018516358,
0.0203179773,
0.0684895962,
0.0041113836,
-0.0170496516,
0.0440820567,
-0.0259652399,
-0.0107837943,
-0.0471150614,
0.0210354701,
-0.0283622593,
0.0168512315,
0.0234194342,
0.0958062336,
0.0090160687,
-0.0046035219,
-0.0704684928,
0.0375854634,
0.0217794441,
0.0135583999,
0.0338707343,
-0.0130957747,
-0.0381289721,
-0.0375418812,
-0.0282261223,
-0.053997837,
-0.0026486639,
-0.0250180494,
0.018558016,
-0.0169860236,
-0.0555611327,
-0.0090231365,
0.0157522764,
-0.0143180722,
-0.0258345008,
0.0072541838,
-0.0259116981,
0.0136594381,
-0.0059496854,
0.0088089779,
0.0103356382,
0.0149257416,
0.0410400778,
0.038975656,
-0.0099535519,
0.013440799,
-0.0183443613,
0.0250484794,
-0.0380704179,
0.0428094938,
-0.0145040657,
0.0828773603,
-0.007958957,
-0.0438511036,
0.0253042411,
-0.0162807088,
-0.0257249735,
0.0305046793,
-0.0098333405,
0.0018502314,
-0.0077550947,
0.005679986,
0.0107688392,
0.017037062,
-0.032376904,
0.0050009894,
0.000199973,
-0.0134860361,
0.0008586014,
-0.0227319226,
-0.0167213157,
-0.0029165784,
2.881e-7,
0.0283509418,
0.0513854511,
0.0239372961,
0.0585000291,
0.0252627935,
0.0363052636,
0.0287071206,
-0.0001139913,
-0.0242888257,
-0.0088686291,
-0.0191323925,
-0.0024707543,
0.0357855931,
0.0653678775,
-0.0123095578,
-0.0268758517,
-0.0215007383,
0.0376810357,
-0.0007371178,
-0.0194401033,
0.1093173996,
0.0360794552,
-0.0148638515,
0.0161413047,
0.0046838899,
-0.005353671,
0.0641975701,
-0.011967984,
-0.0244011078,
0.0411701724,
0.0604917146,
-0.0006712896,
0.0127182407,
0.0096397158,
0.0003759998,
-0.035025835,
-0.0052378355,
0.0306623187,
0.0315683857,
-0.0216888525,
0.0031535067,
-0.0075723985,
0.0337404832,
-0.042022083,
0.0228845719,
-0.0592119433,
-0.053001143,
-0.0181125458,
-0.017642403,
-0.0240856782,
0.0163551066,
-0.0024535344,
-0.0432189815,
-0.0016332018,
-0.0063768439,
0.0406321995,
-0.0038647151,
-0.0323590189,
-0.0239432212,
-0.0024919219,
-0.0146547519,
-0.0230906643,
0.0043155756,
0.0508919768,
0.0166835431,
-0.0583393723,
0.0080867568,
2.532900126e-34,
0.0377688259,
0.004070865,
-0.0323109552,
-0.0257091001,
0.0465509146,
0.0300938021,
-0.0092979092,
0.0052974336,
0.0508935899,
-0.009380647,
-0.0374873653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15644v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15644v2 | Scaling Data Generation in Vision-and-Language Navigation | 2023-07-28T16:03:28 | 2023-08-09T23:51:22 | Zun Wang, Jialu Li, Yicong Hong, Yi Wang, Qi Wu, Mohit Bansal, Stephen Gould, Hao Tan, Yu Qiao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent research in language-guided visual navigation has demonstrated a
significant demand for the diversity of traversable environments and the
quantity of supervision for training generalizable agents. To tackle the common
data scarcity issue in existing vision-and-language navigation datasets, we
propose an effective paradigm for generating large-scale data for learning,
which applies 1200+ photo-realistic environments from HM3D and Gibson datasets
and synthesizes 4.9 million instruction trajectory pairs using fully-accessible
resources on the web. Importantly, we investigate the influence of each
component in this paradigm on the agent's performance and study how to
adequately apply the augmented data to pre-train and fine-tune an agent. Thanks
to our large-scale dataset, the performance of an existing agent can be pushed
up (+11% absolute with regard to previous SoTA) to a significantly new best of
80% single-run success rate on the R2R test split by simple imitation learning.
The long-lasting generalization gap between navigating in seen and unseen
environments is also reduced to less than 1% (versus 8% in the previous best
method). Moreover, our paradigm also facilitates different models to achieve
new state-of-the-art navigation results on CVDN, REVERIE, and R2R in continuous
environments. | [
0.0247348249,
0.0421434641,
0.0057095485,
0.0094316788,
-0.0061998721,
0.0322718807,
-0.0211582016,
-0.0360637903,
-0.0178430807,
-0.0333537087,
-0.0339536667,
-0.0209190045,
0.0065880823,
0.0221783202,
0.0342244096,
-0.0549767129,
0.0106100291,
-0.0737976357,
-0.052418083,
-0.0011440183,
-0.0217101034,
-0.015084086,
-0.0226800442,
0.0262710545,
-0.0123855425,
0.0232000258,
-0.0415618606,
0.0422619805,
0.0288998615,
-0.0990756378,
-0.0072885659,
0.0126150334,
0.1190233454,
0.0189503506,
0.0000020792,
-0.0154105313,
0.0137718385,
-0.036234118,
0.0197197124,
-0.0392744653,
0.0477460288,
-0.0105841598,
-0.0052717244,
0.0495850742,
-0.031108886,
-0.0412882566,
0.0209094398,
-0.0082691805,
0.0524596721,
0.0644032508,
-0.0141878072,
-0.0086087445,
-0.0145393834,
0.0062170485,
0.0365960449,
-0.0094924439,
0.0213568565,
0.0517846197,
-0.0011451393,
-0.0015908648,
-0.0463526808,
0.0250319205,
0.0465867259,
-0.0013012295,
0.0257386062,
0.0616342798,
-0.0353660546,
-0.0377870351,
-0.0459980592,
0.0786460489,
-0.0259709992,
-0.0305070411,
-0.0114938561,
0.0253788065,
-0.0200158879,
-0.023340961,
-0.020047158,
0.0369990394,
-0.0114960056,
0.0295015853,
-0.0386652909,
-0.0336538255,
0.0075402344,
-0.0249667317,
-0.0164774694,
0.0027604478,
0.0196370427,
0.0128466208,
0.0346461125,
0.0147488983,
-0.0204788111,
-0.0334031433,
-0.0435079373,
0.0297378432,
-0.049409166,
0.0413842164,
-0.0612880327,
0.0249056909,
-0.0305733681,
-0.039756991,
0.0822436363,
0.0220462997,
-0.0383216701,
0.0348838903,
-0.0569191799,
0.0495618396,
-0.0307417288,
0.0607024394,
-0.015435339,
0.001103148,
-0.0370301865,
0.0510997511,
-0.0500032194,
0.0075257132,
-0.0287063271,
-0.0227641296,
0.0036849501,
0.0308454465,
0.010209891,
0.0371961631,
-0.0409332253,
0.0307611469,
-0.0464464016,
0.0184343699,
-0.0322692506,
-0.0439201817,
-0.0205213092,
0.0301300846,
-0.0165118296,
-0.0135002313,
0.0226252917,
0.0252094883,
0.0104719866,
0.0081664026,
0.0201776028,
0.1166639999,
-0.0167185534,
-0.0533107109,
-0.0395365432,
0.012306544,
0.022056831,
-0.0420376286,
0.0336661115,
-0.0657132566,
0.0393414646,
-0.02149144,
-0.03280003,
-0.0078029651,
0.0209064446,
0.0250797365,
-0.013434778,
0.0621728487,
-0.0127813648,
0.0101309931,
0.0149519639,
-0.0326028913,
-0.0048297187,
0.0591440052,
0.0523772724,
0.0295870155,
-0.0060450467,
0.0382415093,
0.0265119895,
0.0384640396,
0.0012528402,
0.0489197932,
-0.004974992,
-0.0042660022,
0.0230172742,
0.049691882,
0.0119166262,
0.0358548798,
-0.0651673973,
-0.0200112872,
0.0204228852,
-0.001267792,
-0.0069122282,
-0.0087067066,
0.0535931103,
-0.010239467,
0.0221516956,
-0.0442961529,
-0.0610783026,
0.0500143878,
-0.0038157329,
-0.0054414584,
-0.0318729728,
0.04764992,
-0.0387533195,
-0.0491012596,
0.0237507727,
0.0280632563,
0.0141887087,
0.0012638696,
0.0496389158,
0.0103086866,
-0.06300091,
-0.0373157971,
0.0508369952,
-0.0582926683,
-0.0036864225,
-0.0105764177,
0.0012640919,
0.0639409497,
0.0354545154,
0.0128547894,
-0.0317864977,
-0.0152483406,
0.0486394353,
0.0431356579,
-0.0029847617,
-0.0166063346,
0.0633179396,
-0.0391521007,
-0.0609471165,
0.023074165,
-0.020285733,
0.0787178203,
0.0353576019,
0.0241004135,
-0.0062512322,
-0.0265139658,
-0.0263673905,
0.0637574792,
-0.0019654534,
-0.0046603805,
0.0040299133,
-0.0015382273,
0.0054538399,
0.0107563473,
-0.0115648126,
-0.0422729924,
0.0230703074,
-0.0053949463,
0.038998004,
0.0128159979,
-0.0441870093,
-0.0274579786,
0.0121619012,
-0.075477168,
-0.0115854731,
0.0316226706,
-0.0219051447,
-0.0204395708,
-0.0427612588,
-0.0217587389,
0.0116756214,
0.0249187015,
0.0099519799,
0.0420231186,
0.0159737132,
-0.0228856765,
0.0259797759,
-0.0255524628,
-0.0102428133,
0.0237558465,
0.0301756226,
0.0075962734,
-0.0296813529,
0.010910023,
-0.0319902524,
0.0200934187,
-0.0064867986,
0.0363728479,
0.0314256586,
-0.0391838662,
0.016420126,
-0.045424711,
-0.0206222013,
-0.0372045934,
-0.0134638231,
0.0272364281,
-0.0614151433,
0.003743435,
-0.0158870164,
0.0131668253,
0.0706785694,
0.0220781881,
-0.0079141827,
0.0097646331,
0.0111604566,
-0.0670090765,
-0.0575775765,
0.0096739754,
-0.0069361459,
-0.0217481218,
0.0261932723,
-0.0049080895,
-0.0475088544,
0.0271750595,
-0.0467830077,
0.0703610703,
-0.0564527176,
-0.0574313812,
0.0335730761,
-0.0664703995,
0.0037488884,
0.0398421101,
-0.0258808043,
0.0047259317,
0.0591949224,
-0.022684617,
-0.0456649438,
0.0153000457,
-0.0065756175,
-0.0337820984,
-0.054125756,
-0.009356603,
-0.0194393136,
-0.0063491454,
-0.0361840017,
0.0340954699,
-0.0643055215,
-0.0121850995,
-0.0120971203,
-0.0662867427,
-0.0269466508,
0.0631436631,
-0.0252281092,
0.0040758029,
-0.0434736162,
-0.0303782448,
0.0070782048,
-0.0098437704,
-0.0104549853,
0.000181294,
-0.00343671,
0.0172935911,
0.0686091706,
0.0555884987,
0.0148950797,
-0.0283912718,
-0.0074799708,
-0.020690171,
-0.0289325025,
0.0172278546,
0.0150143988,
0.0567447357,
-0.1215875149,
0.0146995541,
-0.0053120786,
-0.038257651,
-0.0481095836,
0.0213328898,
0.00354386,
-0.0235188492,
-0.0333330557,
-0.0470750034,
-0.0464445911,
-0.01299561,
0.0315736569,
0.0505808815,
0.011651339,
-0.0414159261,
-0.0312705599,
-0.0191792585,
0.060914848,
0.0305824149,
-0.0118160201,
-0.0631040335,
0.0178551134,
0.046471443,
0.0508155301,
-0.0375618711,
-0.0597518347,
0.0414134525,
0.0115979705,
0.0414918996,
0.0221357532,
0.0582057759,
0.0246007983,
-0.0504057817,
-0.0388245359,
0.070797123,
0.0215965658,
-0.0160834454,
-0.0190525837,
-0.0008876304,
0.0342824683,
0.0407493189,
0.0259797201,
-0.0422811098,
-0.0110661704,
-0.0042075953,
0.0231804401,
0.0286261011,
-0.0130149303,
-0.002769629,
-0.0815265477,
0.0473217852,
0.0290901586,
-0.0822635144,
-0.043827761,
-0.0261556078,
-0.0025839903,
-0.0400285311,
0.0082547301,
0.0267164651,
-0.0118552055,
-0.0134400083,
0.0012062838,
0.0233776774,
-0.0067611197,
-0.0016263846,
-0.0371895991,
0.0206129998,
0.0332873948,
0.021849256,
-0.0122420937,
-0.0345064327,
0.0134592643,
0.0460489355,
0.0274943132,
-0.0278629549,
0.0535326041,
-0.0180487223,
-0.0223831721,
0.0286981296,
0.0625181422,
-0.0207336936,
-0.0116793988,
0.005753071,
-0.0083010243,
-0.025732832,
0.0240287185,
-0.0010673481,
-0.0183219649,
0.0192756634,
0.0212951899,
-0.0414088406,
0.0011804675,
-0.0400224626,
-0.032258641,
-0.0080965878,
-0.0426109955,
-0.0373666622,
0.0185274929,
-0.043389257,
-0.0168256145,
-0.0963739827,
-0.0476228483,
0.0684444457,
0.1108284071,
-0.0045108064,
-0.077733539,
0.0109027466,
0.0154429059,
-0.0236787871,
-0.0014807393,
-0.068216376,
0.0161959156,
-0.0548596792,
-0.007200446,
0.0181737933,
-0.050316982,
0.0079778777,
-0.0170243196,
-0.0492633358,
-0.0729897469,
0.0458089076,
0.0695215985,
0.013806276,
0.07440456,
0.0226585511,
0.0060684616,
0.0532875173,
0.0193194002,
0.0274254549,
0.0375423804,
0.0223607458,
0.0144072063,
0.0081045981,
0.0068337144,
-0.0702460483,
0.0083051957,
-0.0094518969,
0.0114886612,
0.011516884,
0.01485202,
0.0242389366,
-0.0444715135,
0.0605823584,
0.0038595553,
0.0565520339,
-0.0227505229,
0.0130298482,
-0.0411959179,
0.0143714454,
-0.0640766174,
0.0328050815,
0.0228919666,
0.0454139113,
0.0203311108,
0.0067489515,
0.0149901388,
-0.0120631726,
-0.0556303561,
-0.0353088789,
0.0062805344,
0.0008652273,
0.0119200237,
0.0082670497,
0.0011352344,
0.0574714132,
-0.0174193811,
0.0409772471,
0.0182182249,
0.0403081439,
0.0449240841,
0.0085245818,
-0.0397817343,
0.0162673444,
-0.0542478226,
-0.0840798169,
-0.0341673419,
0.0807827264,
0.0832952783,
0.004478984,
0.0409410037,
-0.077108331,
0.0167683382,
0.0127882501,
-0.0220955778,
-0.0005643053,
-0.045934584,
0.0674701035,
0.0262900554,
0.0249057505,
0.004836488,
0.049132362,
0.019914899,
0.0729656368,
0.0017568113,
0.0265518911,
-0.0433855057,
-0.0164787956,
0.0366048291,
-0.0050578564,
0.0059067504,
0.0192357842,
0.0164732561,
-0.0328313783,
-0.0503929444,
0.0726325288,
-0.0298484769,
-0.032441508,
0.0694129094,
-0.0113450512,
0.0014382376,
-0.0332241543,
-0.0203028955,
-0.0580107234,
-0.0138063002,
-0.0168428328,
0.0102666058,
-5.722973226e-33,
-0.013486526,
0.0033341337,
0.071591869,
-0.0220346488,
-0.0162192043,
-0.0305028018,
-0.0145807462,
-0.0065691005,
-0.0511519015,
0.0183385666,
0.0086617013,
0.0223022643,
0.0117002055,
0.051874809,
-0.006673825,
-0.0069692042,
0.047786627,
-0.0017591972,
-0.0528183617,
0.0186568871,
0.0152751058,
-0.0156827103,
0.0095455544,
-0.0547073781,
-0.0321924984,
-0.0174031351,
-0.0283459798,
0.0352310091,
-0.0078190872,
0.0345182605,
0.0036527729,
-0.0065225735,
-0.021063583,
0.003874534,
-0.0396179073,
-0.0368112475,
-0.0725374892,
-0.0444987938,
-0.0565351844,
0.0519927517,
-0.0874458477,
0.0134578403,
0.0480366834,
-0.0277250111,
-0.005506462,
0.0203747433,
0.0298879761,
-0.0155722219,
-0.0317846611,
0.0093701705,
-0.0404613093,
0.007970091,
0.0162461568,
-0.0603684746,
0.0376342423,
0.0501124337,
0.0202863701,
-0.0074197203,
-0.0510772094,
0.0205207933,
-0.0139280446,
-0.0119956601,
0.0450888947,
0.0759547353,
0.0575905144,
0.0488930829,
0.0456944369,
-0.0083799651,
0.0307858717,
0.010056749,
0.0358762778,
0.0413554311,
-0.0155277476,
0.059572991,
0.000705943,
0.0232398752,
-0.0152312098,
0.032790795,
-0.0571312234,
0.0453593247,
-0.0226716418,
0.0137509229,
-0.0446130186,
-0.0003898733,
-0.0430839099,
0.007541256,
0.0105016129,
-0.0328583084,
0.0401300937,
0.0486090295,
-0.0156827755,
-0.063021563,
0.0458985977,
-0.0152769014,
-0.0288662463,
0.0184370372,
-0.0375761576,
0.0363899171,
0.0005064599,
0.005184073,
-0.0748912692,
-0.0457658358,
0.0535663478,
0.0069153295,
-0.0110203354,
0.0015346003,
-0.0291297082,
0.0811581016,
-0.038252715,
0.0160263758,
-0.0442642905,
-0.0009831522,
0.0559221692,
0.0024509851,
0.0662550032,
-0.0225265436,
-0.0208277889,
0.0722439811,
-0.0084490674,
-0.072081767,
0.0026626384,
-0.0214577727,
-0.0137258098,
0.0306113623,
-0.0419919342,
0.0153074292,
-0.0826290101,
-0.0025126273,
0.0100899758,
-0.0815732479,
-0.0063103936,
0.02790148,
2.77e-7,
-0.0327844024,
0.0371900424,
0.019810522,
0.0306321476,
-0.0175877474,
0.0357316956,
-0.0050200513,
0.0299517456,
-0.0203159694,
-0.0488193333,
0.0281623881,
0.0621373914,
-0.0223394148,
0.0046139639,
-0.023603972,
0.0173010584,
0.0103752539,
-0.0287908986,
-0.0425624326,
-0.0107859476,
0.0613312609,
0.0927717537,
-0.0247773957,
-0.0027728046,
0.0572052933,
-0.0277324766,
0.0423719324,
-0.020318903,
-0.0185316373,
-0.0328317098,
-0.0055373237,
0.0917977542,
-0.0590203479,
-0.0227056816,
-0.0200142562,
0.0234123114,
-0.0312126502,
0.0263158288,
-0.0209404565,
-0.0151465721,
0.0250664651,
0.0171384476,
-0.002248958,
-0.0345593058,
0.0475541987,
-0.040411301,
0.0403135195,
0.0131704947,
0.0095983436,
0.0230101645,
-0.009166074,
-0.0250409842,
-0.0317829549,
-0.0209769774,
0.0051260269,
-0.0010098193,
-0.0134210233,
-0.0555874519,
0.02621709,
0.0094379466,
0.0063891835,
-0.0043954076,
-0.0244195368,
0.0131875975,
-0.0171458069,
0.0024019524,
-0.0436665379,
1.886930623e-34,
0.0243516471,
-0.0489599854,
0.0264826622,
-0.0510817878,
0.0152091896,
0.0136880614,
-0.0035891142,
0.0124326665,
0.0174831189,
-0.0312654264,
-0.0266045574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15593v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15593v3 | Robust Distortion-free Watermarks for Language Models | 2023-07-28T14:52:08 | 2024-06-06T04:53:25 | Rohith Kuditipudi, John Thickstun, Tatsunori Hashimoto, Percy Liang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | We propose a methodology for planting watermarks in text from an
autoregressive language model that are robust to perturbations without changing
the distribution over text up to a certain maximum generation budget. We
generate watermarked text by mapping a sequence of random numbers -- which we
compute using a randomized watermark key -- to a sample from the language
model. To detect watermarked text, any party who knows the key can align the
text to the random number sequence. We instantiate our watermark methodology
with two sampling schemes: inverse transform sampling and exponential minimum
sampling. We apply these watermarks to three language models -- OPT-1.3B,
LLaMA-7B and Alpaca-7B -- to experimentally validate their statistical power
and robustness to various paraphrasing attacks. Notably, for both the OPT-1.3B
and LLaMA-7B models, we find we can reliably detect watermarked text ($p \leq
0.01$) from $35$ tokens even after corrupting between $40$-$50\%$ of the tokens
via random edits (i.e., substitutions, insertions or deletions). For the
Alpaca-7B model, we conduct a case study on the feasibility of watermarking
responses to typical user instructions. Due to the lower entropy of the
responses, detection is more difficult: around $25\%$ of the responses -- whose
median length is around $100$ tokens -- are detectable with $p \leq 0.01$, and
the watermark is also less robust to certain automated paraphrasing attacks we
implement. | [
0.0660032183,
0.0300222654,
-0.0179867689,
0.0270074196,
-0.0690731779,
-0.0274009295,
0.0016783531,
0.0573943146,
-0.0104796076,
-0.060532432,
0.0372176506,
0.0199289881,
0.0013058006,
-0.0054961904,
0.0515494868,
-0.0568882674,
0.0250058901,
-0.030425977,
0.0141524794,
0.0001520482,
0.0058950162,
-0.0172238834,
0.0517855324,
0.0195470825,
0.0001411191,
-0.0012494075,
-0.0157868825,
0.0293845199,
-0.0214812122,
0.0024336919,
-0.0603851005,
0.0497316383,
-0.0200502183,
0.0784807727,
0.0000022724,
-0.0448520519,
-0.041246552,
0.0475612171,
-0.0532431416,
0.0761762783,
0.0359983332,
0.0015542168,
-0.0380257778,
0.0201689564,
-0.0208423603,
0.0664290488,
0.0376899987,
0.0443723015,
0.1031165272,
0.0406564772,
-0.0157601964,
-0.0125091719,
0.0308244228,
-0.0068107364,
0.0491935201,
-0.0052685835,
0.028960757,
-0.0162355602,
0.0029967588,
0.0566369034,
0.0149741722,
0.0452017635,
-0.0114749689,
-0.0374850817,
-0.0496768355,
-0.0115511231,
-0.0113514392,
-0.0100345192,
0.0010340231,
0.020691501,
-0.0563656315,
-0.0287345797,
0.0189414378,
-0.0104760947,
0.0095535219,
0.0510988794,
-0.0321846418,
0.0297681689,
0.0342853665,
-0.0054640681,
-0.0215750504,
-0.0051258979,
0.0384748951,
-0.0221346989,
0.0036992386,
0.0379446745,
0.03950876,
-0.0161927305,
-0.0718892589,
-0.0442791432,
-0.0201503411,
-0.0436173677,
0.0235687736,
-0.000803789,
0.0711838305,
0.0012291165,
-0.1347447038,
-0.0830850154,
0.025300581,
-0.0276068039,
0.0448511951,
0.0153839942,
0.0141790602,
0.0465894453,
-0.0523665398,
0.0658401027,
-0.0449907184,
0.0512736291,
0.0202897564,
-0.0083307829,
0.0268080812,
-0.0344334468,
-0.0290266238,
0.0459256135,
-0.0285312105,
0.0096461959,
-0.0311324801,
0.047089342,
0.0267513171,
0.0360007882,
-0.0285222996,
-0.0132245542,
-0.0042080297,
-0.006341341,
0.0389066972,
-0.0518706553,
0.017481884,
-0.0142923761,
-0.0234245192,
-0.0500233881,
-0.0209877826,
0.0363934077,
-0.0029426825,
-0.0036617117,
-0.0213236678,
0.1202921942,
0.0382643975,
-0.0367630497,
-0.0306940917,
-0.0665154979,
-0.016573444,
0.0236554537,
-0.0032534976,
-0.0515267588,
-0.0185715035,
-0.0050286525,
0.0117335524,
-0.028500244,
0.0221272521,
0.0109394928,
-0.0594051629,
0.0482418612,
-0.030035682,
-0.0185947232,
-0.024318736,
-0.0204971414,
-0.0048942128,
0.0150644723,
0.061823789,
0.0412245169,
0.0933248028,
0.0164339151,
0.0211993512,
0.0487458892,
0.0036081737,
0.0280237123,
-0.0018259955,
-0.0221104845,
0.0496899225,
-0.0459027588,
-0.0192767177,
0.0539938696,
0.0091378018,
-0.0602189489,
0.0831846371,
0.067686066,
-0.0640014112,
-0.0058260434,
-0.0249256957,
0.0134749198,
0.0236403104,
-0.0076987743,
-0.0172034167,
-0.0090295626,
-0.0208255667,
-0.0038258303,
0.0306630209,
-0.0374201573,
0.0059036412,
0.0127251185,
-0.0383293256,
-0.0344150625,
0.0006949949,
-0.0205610227,
0.0061546275,
0.0347427949,
-0.0346960984,
0.0286574736,
-0.0164913256,
-0.0117088305,
0.0070702401,
-0.0831519961,
0.008274937,
0.0366269201,
0.0784656331,
-0.005441993,
0.1147777513,
-0.0268584043,
-0.0163624287,
0.0368706621,
-0.016728444,
0.0205415878,
-0.0021397306,
-0.001801976,
-0.0031225213,
-0.0232005697,
0.009846855,
0.0087042088,
0.0254634526,
0.0367544815,
0.0326994471,
-0.037372876,
0.0010914203,
0.0012895371,
0.0430506878,
-0.0350065157,
-0.000101137,
-0.0262227319,
0.0150000788,
0.0288831834,
-0.0305148419,
0.0469013155,
0.0166160837,
-0.0205396526,
0.0041317856,
-0.0065301633,
0.0241809431,
0.0413440987,
0.0381697081,
-0.0409969687,
0.0171618536,
0.04506585,
-0.0015806562,
-0.0234592892,
0.0502219237,
-0.074792482,
0.0483158641,
-0.0271608159,
0.0338473059,
-0.0308344346,
0.0426058881,
-0.0331682526,
-0.0126277367,
0.0141634243,
0.0126241213,
-0.0159915593,
-0.006562571,
0.0245847404,
-0.0039434419,
-0.0628106743,
-0.0221237671,
-0.0291667469,
0.0006873018,
0.0268723629,
-0.005748163,
0.0093675302,
-0.0222503953,
-0.0030881634,
-0.0114170406,
-0.0064686676,
0.0177126303,
0.0330389924,
0.0246990323,
-0.0042531327,
-0.0341419689,
0.0006480922,
-0.074138768,
0.0076673366,
0.0136338146,
0.0608164035,
-0.0109511446,
-0.0380108766,
-0.0137249455,
-0.0148171885,
0.005239631,
0.0725993663,
0.0147201549,
-0.0721708164,
-0.0595813841,
0.0078193657,
-0.0073763337,
-0.0134934932,
0.0001665513,
-0.0531060435,
-0.007624757,
0.0034358986,
0.0003484999,
0.0563783795,
0.0287218615,
-0.0052640238,
-0.0142515879,
0.043723911,
-0.020907592,
-0.0484207273,
-0.023929555,
-0.0058215233,
-0.0064353482,
-0.0529554002,
0.0542514138,
0.0204688758,
0.0433829874,
-0.0059731053,
-0.0286793243,
0.0371415727,
-0.0057531651,
0.0091421595,
-0.0062351134,
-0.0115118008,
-0.0393292084,
-0.0005978321,
-0.0220816601,
-0.0488859192,
0.0127677554,
-0.0560788102,
0.0069095134,
-0.0048171976,
-0.0126288291,
0.0426329225,
0.0100740818,
0.0045376751,
0.0268682446,
0.0220494866,
-0.0130358003,
-0.0149085326,
-0.0347106569,
0.0832983255,
-0.0443849228,
-0.0213367622,
-0.0263017658,
0.002062222,
0.0025094915,
0.0166965201,
-0.0101441033,
-0.0960597396,
0.0033056343,
0.0023810528,
0.0285940617,
-0.0178286936,
-0.0089766989,
0.0011564294,
0.0795284808,
0.0198451709,
-0.0282013528,
0.007863556,
-0.0477485694,
0.0619958192,
0.0168718658,
-0.0722721294,
-0.0069348072,
-0.0322656371,
-0.0126702245,
0.0715752393,
0.0623836666,
0.0095151868,
0.0388738289,
-0.0135341063,
0.0177330468,
-0.0113655888,
-0.0308804382,
0.0328010991,
0.0170812439,
0.0118860723,
0.0282419343,
0.0524075329,
0.0255930554,
0.0190694463,
0.0205586124,
-0.0025789849,
0.0167792495,
0.0071864785,
-0.0200755782,
-0.0808076784,
-0.004338365,
0.0441633947,
0.0563627444,
-0.0295433477,
-0.0146730151,
-0.0397280194,
-0.0527467914,
0.0099667171,
0.0162088592,
-0.0035853863,
-0.0220200103,
-0.0583582632,
-0.0088510439,
0.0747052878,
-0.0023283395,
-0.0537287854,
0.0251660701,
-0.0017701639,
0.0314176455,
-0.0378789455,
-0.0259181,
-0.0085985996,
-0.0186869744,
0.0249167662,
0.0547396578,
0.0121479332,
-0.0050144461,
-0.0193748549,
0.0208297707,
0.0102382414,
-0.0208613928,
0.0190553498,
0.0207841899,
0.034241993,
-0.0404375754,
0.0083665121,
-0.0023256915,
0.0196961295,
-0.0158349201,
-0.0095446436,
0.0277691223,
0.0168291405,
-0.0042655887,
0.0119668571,
-0.0466523804,
0.0238146894,
0.035193231,
0.00558325,
-0.0376716331,
-0.0493308268,
-0.0718654916,
0.0309465192,
-0.0404554084,
-0.0435296521,
-0.0239314102,
-0.0359309055,
-0.0272270869,
-0.062738806,
0.0432312414,
-0.070055306,
0.034110114,
0.0527474619,
0.0386497304,
0.0421117395,
-0.0160528235,
-0.0127106179,
-0.0736449584,
-0.1083946526,
0.0393201299,
-0.0627900735,
0.0082373293,
0.0023668506,
-0.0147373891,
-0.0392658338,
0.041619461,
-0.0966117382,
-0.0737643316,
0.0488931015,
0.0384998843,
0.0300818644,
-0.0277983733,
-0.0301824603,
-0.0535693429,
0.0531239994,
0.0099763786,
-0.0086410567,
0.0134806996,
0.0318853296,
-0.0158414282,
0.0034663286,
0.013595161,
-0.0543600693,
-0.0226065125,
0.0627348348,
-0.0194212738,
-0.0518801138,
-0.0399938449,
-0.0041348338,
0.0759217665,
0.0071448823,
0.0034911206,
0.0044905627,
0.0403606631,
0.0405625664,
-0.0483311899,
-0.0152531667,
0.0020161425,
0.0085140131,
0.0005085788,
-0.0299767312,
0.023960799,
0.005638428,
-0.0297718681,
-0.0051181931,
0.0338696577,
-0.0021184601,
-0.0401954949,
0.036916405,
0.0269740876,
-0.0057826545,
0.013415684,
0.0403940491,
0.0215307456,
0.0286479294,
0.0019659754,
-0.0125912912,
-0.0003174588,
-0.0279118307,
-0.0056555294,
0.0495250709,
-0.0807073116,
-0.0049446011,
-0.0004854285,
0.0462084673,
0.0104800435,
0.0168515798,
-0.0028379685,
-0.0406233072,
0.0136752147,
-0.0218042508,
0.0122668101,
-0.0034827914,
-0.0333326459,
-0.0120032886,
-0.0268340595,
-0.0141612533,
0.0707636178,
0.0276661962,
0.0470615365,
0.0265493225,
0.0151933869,
-0.034444496,
-0.0385222547,
0.0012007493,
0.0214162841,
0.017297782,
-0.0445181094,
-0.0448702499,
-0.0335011408,
-0.046725288,
0.019094279,
-0.0030699021,
0.0289700292,
0.0161554106,
-0.0334448926,
0.0279138051,
-0.0118743964,
0.0126426928,
-0.0624010563,
0.0708034337,
0.0386752412,
-0.0497633293,
0.009430496,
-5.801378331e-33,
0.0168435015,
-0.022957636,
-0.0757825896,
-0.0390213132,
0.060414765,
0.0330123007,
-0.02343872,
0.0088127758,
-0.0131601989,
-0.0255985167,
-0.0267375801,
-0.0156665221,
0.017901618,
-0.0041973675,
-0.0631109551,
-0.0056776959,
0.0254059937,
-0.0115700345,
-0.0117500257,
0.007135415,
0.0616640113,
-0.0298248455,
0.0226834882,
-0.0569633842,
0.0425472409,
-0.0293271691,
-0.0414260291,
-0.0433884189,
-0.0013420309,
0.0353806242,
0.0060655745,
-0.0019747061,
-0.0364748798,
-0.0023946334,
-0.0384261496,
0.0224142633,
-0.0183931775,
-0.015803244,
0.0308950841,
0.0472641215,
0.0458004884,
-0.0671805888,
-0.0063107815,
-0.028275067,
-0.0216447189,
0.0534699522,
0.002072436,
0.0241173878,
-0.0223129466,
0.0044299206,
-0.0012239907,
-0.0016418382,
-0.0267930347,
0.0287736095,
0.0036946419,
-0.0104010077,
0.0562777817,
0.0193865597,
-0.0824551806,
0.0439257957,
0.017836025,
0.0101220235,
0.0069139218,
-0.0215456951,
0.0067014834,
0.0040994049,
-0.0360112078,
-0.0054005319,
0.022768097,
0.0003590254,
0.0126748206,
-0.0317286588,
0.0695446432,
0.0727543384,
0.0753459334,
-0.0200697817,
0.0019876081,
0.030064594,
-0.0005924884,
-0.0263474099,
0.0836577937,
0.0010775734,
-0.0635189936,
0.0033606847,
-0.0340435095,
-0.0411837697,
-0.0140989497,
-0.0304657705,
0.0135849472,
0.0244839545,
-0.0459851772,
-0.0114831198,
0.0151431086,
-0.073991999,
-0.0655386671,
-0.017798584,
-0.0146720419,
0.0274967179,
-0.0310902819,
0.0225871578,
0.0533547811,
0.0147776278,
0.0354224704,
-0.0434757397,
0.015184083,
-0.01483934,
0.0256755613,
0.0137152094,
-0.1059890091,
-0.0003047356,
0.0236567985,
0.033710327,
0.0217114352,
-0.0204755664,
0.0162141249,
-0.0173905808,
0.0107862968,
-0.0543994419,
0.0080517177,
-0.034673892,
0.0089497268,
0.0350362919,
-0.0401175544,
0.0178695843,
0.0018135136,
0.0213513691,
-0.0270990469,
0.086450316,
0.0250304732,
-0.0065114,
-0.0081623439,
-0.0086843045,
2.998e-7,
0.0189741272,
0.0208606739,
0.0527326874,
0.0031162729,
0.0350389704,
0.0554921441,
0.0191756636,
0.0167988446,
-0.0550528914,
-0.011334369,
-0.0611229427,
-0.0389356501,
0.0408674292,
-0.0285282843,
-0.0852067545,
0.0205449611,
-0.0464489982,
0.0208667479,
-0.0444013216,
-0.0068432442,
0.0337622911,
0.1038008109,
0.0394712314,
-0.003552106,
-0.032435257,
-0.0839775354,
0.0230416339,
-0.0197032113,
-0.00336797,
-0.02406062,
0.0003082449,
0.0287945792,
0.0418461971,
0.0151697565,
-0.040784888,
-0.0411093682,
0.0149931684,
0.0407370217,
0.0119198784,
-0.0035934607,
-0.0436718203,
-0.0473919027,
-0.0045432351,
-0.0611497164,
0.0424005315,
0.0981071591,
-0.0078693815,
-0.0394144543,
-0.054978475,
-0.0315389261,
0.0310208071,
-0.0187944695,
-0.015072125,
-0.009471654,
0.0197744705,
0.0394261591,
-0.0039243605,
-0.0290669017,
-0.0337513797,
-0.0795846879,
-0.0071197138,
-0.0012454848,
-0.0479576141,
0.0233088695,
0.0599530451,
-0.0402319841,
0.0365866348,
2.918769922e-34,
-0.0092569413,
-0.04896909,
-0.0031021649,
0.0478574224,
0.0331043489,
0.0172337946,
0.0356171131,
0.0207712539,
0.0243212469,
-0.0356541649,
-0.0296085663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15582v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15582v1 | When to generate hedges in peer-tutoring interactions | 2023-07-28T14:29:19 | 2023-07-28T14:29:19 | Alafate Abulimiti, Chloé Clavel, Justine Cassell | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores the application of machine learning techniques to predict
where hedging occurs in peer-tutoring interactions. The study uses a
naturalistic face-to-face dataset annotated for natural language turns,
conversational strategies, tutoring strategies, and nonverbal behaviours. These
elements are processed into a vector representation of the previous turns,
which serves as input to several machine learning models. Results show that
embedding layers, that capture the semantic information of the previous turns,
significantly improves the model's performance. Additionally, the study
provides insights into the importance of various features, such as
interpersonal rapport and nonverbal behaviours, in predicting hedges by using
Shapley values for feature explanation. We discover that the eye gaze of both
the tutor and the tutee has a significant impact on hedge prediction. We
further validate this observation through a follow-up ablation study. | [
0.0695873424,
0.0046751779,
-0.0329414755,
0.0178330932,
-0.004699836,
0.0075742747,
0.0846984684,
-0.0295935795,
-0.0373640358,
-0.0014199764,
0.0000241641,
-0.0449169539,
0.0158957541,
0.0375642553,
0.0472279862,
-0.0918920562,
-0.0212433618,
0.0272601694,
0.0173936523,
0.0210950151,
0.0412457958,
0.0005317928,
-0.0203474313,
0.0911697596,
-0.0319179147,
-0.0248398054,
-0.0641602576,
-0.0096411137,
0.0153353065,
0.025481252,
0.0464579053,
0.0385292657,
0.0012340525,
-0.0012535207,
0.0000020317,
-0.009488456,
-0.0063214749,
-0.0368506126,
-0.007375109,
-0.0206766799,
0.0327106826,
-0.0192171354,
0.0363665149,
0.0202871263,
-0.0882064402,
0.0101008322,
0.0461580381,
0.0268742181,
0.064808026,
0.0079304809,
0.0028038074,
0.0119081419,
-0.0037026405,
-0.0299401246,
0.0228655878,
-0.0608945154,
0.0142535837,
-0.0158278756,
-0.0541140437,
-0.0253221374,
-0.053531833,
0.0165522229,
0.0061761895,
-0.0650268719,
0.0724971443,
0.0253290106,
-0.0386631079,
-0.0311590601,
-0.020616347,
0.0352229998,
-0.0145225627,
0.0164231975,
0.0179144852,
-0.018239744,
0.0694284663,
0.0798946396,
-0.0705927983,
-0.0193443932,
0.0249992218,
0.0118340487,
-0.0186794978,
0.0143430466,
-0.0075581125,
0.0064040208,
0.0698669553,
0.0063120704,
-0.0659938157,
-0.0080059636,
0.0114795789,
0.0126837669,
0.0559426062,
-0.0320061184,
-0.0077585652,
0.0418381654,
0.002440314,
0.0010483874,
-0.0213895924,
0.0197656062,
-0.0028075499,
0.0246510543,
0.0336817019,
0.0165952537,
-0.0035652812,
0.0171483997,
-0.0004239421,
-0.0006170032,
0.0188393164,
-0.0189455058,
0.0295158066,
0.0506650992,
-0.0747874603,
-0.0177124497,
-0.0402833894,
0.0029661648,
0.0477581806,
-0.0202837158,
-0.0138834547,
0.0369876586,
-0.0083193313,
0.043567121,
-0.0060607507,
0.0463722982,
0.0112419249,
0.026490543,
-0.0136619704,
0.0408010557,
-0.0346437097,
0.0050336882,
-0.006912115,
-0.0821996927,
-0.0026150695,
-0.0180488341,
0.0356054418,
-0.0009071058,
-0.0113469055,
0.0611012802,
0.0034645069,
-0.029535763,
-0.0130600305,
-0.035789147,
-0.0038906496,
-0.0368364081,
0.0231091324,
-0.0184203088,
0.0168434363,
-0.0412862487,
-0.0183076952,
-0.0234999377,
0.0111479778,
-0.0205247179,
0.0048674587,
0.0736685991,
0.0148185464,
0.0116649577,
0.0173300989,
0.0189218707,
-0.0820949003,
0.0115494588,
0.037048094,
-0.007420463,
0.0290842187,
-0.0692092925,
0.0494557656,
0.0069738599,
0.0341152325,
-0.0109976893,
0.067017667,
-0.0446792096,
0.0073344368,
0.0155087868,
-0.0026607048,
-0.0205541179,
-0.0068867938,
-0.0599397905,
0.0596982986,
0.071180366,
-0.0296656322,
0.0463484228,
-0.0267039686,
0.0814087018,
-0.0039452105,
0.0394223258,
-0.0480654091,
0.0238103941,
-0.0160325374,
-0.0400549583,
-0.0179956313,
0.0070099905,
-0.0344112404,
-0.0674531236,
-0.0042753704,
0.0065915408,
0.0061106789,
0.0056867907,
0.0148077225,
-0.0443603992,
-0.0438240655,
-0.0060328967,
-0.0024786657,
-0.0335486755,
0.0112047391,
-0.0428905822,
0.0265525766,
0.0481672511,
0.0050049028,
0.000616074,
-0.0270624626,
-0.0330984406,
-0.0089898175,
-0.015755821,
0.0369007476,
-0.0251944661,
0.0692064539,
-0.0068154181,
-0.0112947635,
-0.0140419761,
0.0216708109,
0.020059742,
-0.0190088451,
-0.0001628356,
0.0011827609,
0.0519690029,
-0.0146620814,
0.0208898652,
-0.0378935374,
-0.0524976999,
-0.0346691273,
0.0483344086,
0.0034494621,
-0.0041445335,
0.0016654233,
-0.022361625,
0.0299149211,
0.0239492916,
0.0244174749,
0.0197617281,
-0.0493951328,
0.0148103964,
0.0356751233,
-0.042840708,
-0.0197643805,
-0.0229266137,
-0.01791922,
-0.0092047174,
0.0665029809,
-0.0337779745,
0.03273746,
0.0326696113,
-0.0049173278,
-0.030349521,
0.0152126541,
0.0225047581,
-0.0226276089,
-0.000418186,
-0.0094959531,
-0.0553014092,
-0.0223475937,
0.0065171421,
-0.0501000024,
0.0277052689,
-0.0296723843,
-0.0328231268,
0.010472049,
-0.0021891317,
0.0205894932,
-0.0470673367,
-0.0127274096,
-0.0591942295,
-0.0499304347,
-0.0014370572,
-0.0194928218,
-0.0110136587,
-0.0586957559,
-0.0137262978,
-0.0504945703,
-0.0409022979,
0.0143248625,
-0.0049399934,
-0.0226610359,
0.0336633138,
0.0411702208,
-0.0264894385,
-0.0362677537,
-0.026492795,
-0.0178184807,
0.0651803836,
0.0522904508,
-0.0169074629,
0.0054905936,
0.0016464819,
0.0105697438,
0.0484640487,
-0.0593601279,
-0.0226363894,
0.0134870214,
-0.0085066473,
-0.0185622554,
0.0846190229,
0.0114687439,
0.0782242939,
0.0430807136,
-0.0293785166,
-0.0328387581,
0.0131062409,
0.0042104707,
-0.017390389,
-0.0519800633,
-0.0781219453,
-0.0399056971,
0.0135628693,
-0.0164762903,
-0.007616993,
-0.0632353872,
0.0659206733,
0.06220093,
-0.0535401329,
-0.0458720624,
-0.0264329966,
0.0049997782,
-0.0045222701,
0.0162044633,
-0.0601128079,
0.0703145415,
0.0109003289,
-0.031279251,
0.0537089743,
-0.0246541966,
0.0138503658,
0.0555813126,
-0.0403770469,
-0.0203680377,
-0.0604025684,
-0.0371412449,
-0.027238518,
-0.0061936337,
0.0520386696,
-0.0119372178,
-0.0429376289,
-0.0540563799,
-0.0643108934,
0.0239729676,
0.0301684141,
-0.0432681702,
-0.050360918,
-0.0349996239,
-0.0145881614,
0.0009084352,
-0.0292295516,
-0.0231495351,
-0.026761597,
-0.023408033,
-0.0267246626,
-0.0254517365,
-0.0103140306,
-0.0044691199,
-0.0227886587,
0.0239615552,
0.000462514,
-0.0096948622,
-0.0116786472,
0.0485763028,
0.0578831472,
0.0373045839,
-0.0354124233,
-0.0061412151,
0.0001416899,
0.0169375334,
0.0182900634,
-0.0497241318,
0.0364392772,
-0.0143179819,
-0.0407414213,
0.0272982437,
0.0668312833,
0.0464875512,
-0.0368174724,
0.006822852,
-0.0327229127,
0.0109036518,
-0.0425460897,
-0.0049904068,
-0.0831070244,
-0.0060038744,
-0.0357326418,
0.0525205396,
0.0252721906,
-0.0365083888,
-0.0038651484,
-0.0482962467,
0.0605910197,
0.0091049718,
-0.0416943207,
-0.0164555274,
-0.0414003991,
-0.0239380822,
-0.022573445,
0.0212811343,
-0.0288558397,
-0.0069343951,
0.0107897921,
0.045288872,
-0.0195008516,
0.0112848068,
0.0289144572,
-0.0269232243,
-0.0255640391,
-0.0005787915,
0.0455434173,
0.01519405,
-0.0496796332,
-0.0889016464,
0.0645042211,
0.0362550765,
-0.0107617145,
0.1167305857,
-0.0563719533,
0.023178922,
-0.0078003397,
0.0501175746,
-0.0101615684,
0.0241547991,
0.0575070046,
0.0208081882,
-0.0521417595,
-0.0231071971,
0.0252091531,
0.0412247926,
0.0486740433,
0.0339035317,
0.0150832757,
-0.0456956215,
-0.0115734097,
0.0024147239,
-0.0097398032,
0.007736831,
-0.0304689668,
-0.02350026,
0.0442650914,
-0.0058464687,
0.0067432136,
-0.0662672967,
0.0182606746,
0.0236873496,
-0.0110537568,
-0.0077531356,
0.0321407616,
0.0352877975,
-0.0093140062,
0.055175107,
0.0493832193,
0.0165892318,
-0.0226879027,
-0.0319358222,
-0.0469832793,
-0.0795209557,
-0.0017527916,
-0.0111489194,
-0.0197892394,
-0.0451127626,
0.0038078965,
0.0668949857,
0.0309636369,
0.0429526381,
0.0367083661,
-0.0350517444,
-0.0365430899,
-0.0326659121,
0.0238071568,
0.012747379,
0.0290155858,
-0.0075055659,
0.021538686,
0.0125906728,
0.0011024748,
-0.0166696981,
-0.0173396375,
-0.0564546101,
-0.0587808229,
-0.0398750231,
-0.0283692069,
-0.0359495878,
0.0825035125,
-0.0031113862,
0.0006014757,
0.0062232697,
0.0207402408,
-0.0176504124,
-0.0049169199,
-0.0362765528,
-0.0187804382,
0.0269744899,
0.0230438821,
-0.0039792708,
-0.0348089747,
-0.0438011251,
0.0258476269,
-0.068080321,
0.0598326512,
0.0139344186,
-0.009276866,
0.0191873107,
0.0564658381,
0.0099592274,
-0.0163878351,
0.0498627722,
0.0321455225,
0.0510479882,
0.0701197311,
0.0278482214,
0.0148108518,
0.0317860059,
0.0356197953,
-0.040941231,
-0.0767187625,
-0.0195902493,
0.0068788356,
-0.0305634011,
-0.0292036515,
0.0095566269,
-0.0162026137,
0.0115310298,
0.0245553441,
0.0757477283,
-0.0172448009,
-0.0858337954,
0.0342603102,
0.0015821819,
-0.0248389915,
0.0252477583,
0.0453168564,
0.0107640242,
0.009270235,
0.0033554917,
-0.0293052159,
-0.0179132596,
0.0361101143,
0.1166495085,
0.0633783713,
0.0128716938,
0.0373470485,
-0.0627133027,
-0.0131702349,
-0.0570994876,
0.0264833309,
0.0043520941,
-0.0248949733,
0.0281352084,
0.0155949211,
-0.004459593,
0.000405305,
-0.0470337868,
0.040604312,
-0.0218188725,
-0.0040562786,
-0.03173621,
-5.661758623e-33,
0.0034538342,
-0.1036278307,
-0.0101663917,
0.068956919,
-0.0206724592,
0.0147024412,
-0.0276350304,
0.0119320648,
-0.0172291044,
0.0057850406,
-0.0109465066,
0.0579062626,
0.0061513172,
-0.0195685253,
0.0436206609,
-0.011171503,
-0.0005413917,
-0.0039655725,
0.007110931,
0.0274604782,
-0.026147427,
0.0075201183,
0.0715896115,
-0.0882390216,
0.066905804,
-0.0286985058,
-0.0178795345,
-0.0123176435,
-0.0341190472,
-0.0079649398,
0.0113799842,
0.0340762287,
-0.0162145961,
0.0138319852,
0.0311730821,
0.0504054278,
-0.032791499,
-0.0353384577,
-0.0292660166,
0.0253286622,
-0.0723124743,
-0.003506012,
0.0004106562,
0.0182459727,
-0.0105022406,
-0.0389984474,
0.0694821179,
0.0328759588,
0.0048413151,
0.0472851619,
-0.0019989978,
-0.0100137321,
-0.0799387619,
-0.0663441345,
0.0461717173,
0.0856464803,
0.0236042999,
-0.0265589841,
-0.0650679469,
0.0576347858,
-0.0162016805,
-0.019894151,
0.0259924587,
-0.0132178692,
0.0359994359,
0.0435335524,
0.0091959257,
0.0205057338,
-0.005835284,
-0.0957662091,
0.0395591222,
0.0676577985,
0.0409058034,
-0.0186105072,
0.0107231876,
0.0025194394,
-0.0308325533,
0.0204492118,
0.088398844,
0.0430233665,
-0.0543993898,
0.0032067108,
-0.0441208072,
-0.0346873179,
-0.0235980824,
-0.0570643544,
0.0345584452,
-0.0286217202,
-0.0000766233,
0.0028015424,
0.0310693309,
0.0303863697,
0.0039534019,
-0.0535210408,
0.0068177055,
0.0184145626,
-0.0119241951,
0.0098518198,
0.0011279141,
-0.01937709,
-0.0162800346,
-0.0078593539,
0.0141195105,
-0.0845721215,
0.0570255518,
0.0022790493,
0.0104842521,
0.0287185702,
0.0185316764,
-0.0154889105,
-0.0085632484,
0.012451387,
0.0280760434,
0.0125447232,
0.0135028949,
-0.0255091712,
-0.0429492556,
0.0339787863,
-0.013216679,
0.0355635732,
-0.0304945149,
-0.0275165699,
-0.0130747436,
-0.0268989615,
-0.0086807245,
-0.0121647026,
-0.0217593536,
-0.0136184944,
0.0296119042,
-0.0211978722,
-0.0070942924,
-0.0672844946,
2.724e-7,
-0.0114182252,
0.0908975601,
0.0400225706,
-0.0393120944,
-0.005184921,
0.0625472888,
-0.0061152745,
0.0485735498,
0.0549918823,
-0.0121130068,
0.0630269498,
-0.0011693257,
0.0628357083,
0.0253110714,
-0.0557848215,
-0.0484714545,
-0.061672695,
-0.0273429491,
0.0219782107,
-0.0149675049,
0.0264186449,
0.013180593,
0.0353267938,
-0.0064848764,
0.0111402422,
0.016705662,
-0.0196086578,
-0.0161779914,
0.0100503806,
0.009236644,
0.0314313769,
-0.079950884,
-0.0011676418,
0.0804672092,
-0.0312280115,
0.0402770452,
-0.0177580789,
0.0229886714,
-0.047591079,
0.006784047,
0.0211134497,
0.0287993383,
-0.0056954939,
-0.0349729024,
0.0217777286,
-0.0221716333,
-0.0141524719,
0.0521024466,
-0.0691528395,
-0.0152881099,
0.0290774666,
0.014599788,
0.0363943391,
0.0268195514,
0.0039799134,
-0.0513416864,
0.0308697298,
-0.0339197144,
-0.0279650316,
-0.0124403927,
-0.0258788075,
-0.0382775925,
0.0186780244,
-0.0278167259,
0.0096006198,
-0.0148876878,
0.0002172012,
1.672820756e-34,
-0.0204526484,
0.0145493979,
0.0446990244,
-0.0009609928,
0.0548098609,
0.004286333,
-0.0122004198,
0.0387610458,
0.1032122746,
-0.0014810814,
-0.0224425271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15555v1 | All-for-One and One-For-All: Deep learning-based feature fusion for Synthetic Speech Detection | 2023-07-28T13:50:25 | 2023-07-28T13:50:25 | Daniele Mari, Davide Salvi, Paolo Bestagini, Simone Milani | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.CR, eess.AS | Recent advances in deep learning and computer vision have made the synthesis
and counterfeiting of multimedia content more accessible than ever, leading to
possible threats and dangers from malicious users. In the audio field, we are
witnessing the growth of speech deepfake generation techniques, which solicit
the development of synthetic speech detection algorithms to counter possible
mischievous uses such as frauds or identity thefts. In this paper, we consider
three different feature sets proposed in the literature for the synthetic
speech detection task and present a model that fuses them, achieving overall
better performances with respect to the state-of-the-art solutions. The system
was tested on different scenarios and datasets to prove its robustness to
anti-forensic attacks and its generalization capabilities. | [
0.0178849902,
0.0208651572,
0.0152586084,
0.0611858666,
-0.053993091,
-0.0192807484,
0.048959408,
-0.033133354,
-0.0087393438,
-0.0250154175,
-0.0049840049,
-0.0452610925,
0.0208518524,
0.0893306807,
0.0129679879,
-0.0010498735,
0.0082687261,
-0.0179560576,
-0.0038925929,
-0.0104717771,
-0.0025890353,
-0.0042851972,
-0.0511405952,
0.0454733148,
-0.0825945362,
0.0217569917,
-0.0036025986,
0.0193097871,
0.055529952,
0.0468307994,
-0.0136192441,
0.0111250971,
0.036417339,
0.1130007952,
0.0000018732,
-0.0340946354,
-0.0340959132,
-0.0111595318,
-0.0793423802,
-0.0234933253,
-0.0027649922,
0.0311243385,
-0.0795540512,
0.0507199988,
-0.0554279648,
-0.0066347965,
0.0052162805,
0.0600418039,
0.020958269,
0.0504700467,
-0.0296629816,
-0.0584193952,
0.0658924356,
0.0050052931,
-0.0187260322,
-0.0058143614,
-0.01082105,
-0.056778539,
0.0122135179,
-0.0618766099,
0.0418471619,
0.0115484409,
0.0193636622,
-0.0443122201,
0.0261173993,
-0.0099791829,
-0.0875321329,
-0.0249620639,
-0.0154509647,
0.0523347557,
-0.0649727285,
-0.0020273295,
0.0015393926,
0.0024802268,
0.0086856801,
-0.0140068587,
0.0234048963,
0.0152284689,
0.0034293255,
-0.0014396315,
-0.0350268781,
0.014236575,
0.0354149081,
0.0174718183,
-0.0035648167,
-0.0475608297,
0.0193725564,
0.0053383936,
-0.0035552334,
-0.0591001473,
-0.0342816338,
0.0064167427,
0.0363951549,
-0.0136637986,
0.0030062345,
-0.0658095181,
-0.0643751621,
-0.0666596591,
-0.0205364134,
-0.0077193039,
0.0043157251,
-0.0126716113,
-0.0737355351,
0.0229574386,
-0.0428958312,
0.0397995152,
-0.0525362603,
-0.0077093714,
-0.018698588,
-0.0187017694,
-0.0202231221,
-0.0128065348,
0.0046460358,
0.0417929329,
-0.0281183384,
-0.0263855308,
-0.030367529,
-0.0248814113,
-0.0495036729,
0.0252093989,
0.0067908769,
0.0318757333,
-0.0124364039,
-0.0065927496,
0.0132038146,
0.0027040788,
0.0307881068,
0.0883961245,
-0.0111319236,
-0.0806306973,
0.0068663261,
0.0290531386,
0.0139215682,
-0.0001071804,
0.0595775135,
0.0533494838,
0.0111634061,
-0.0395988524,
-0.0369210579,
0.0065242359,
-0.0060113105,
-0.0343066305,
-0.0117158163,
-0.0858397335,
0.0291719045,
-0.0727526546,
-0.0034840517,
0.0197457969,
-0.0223056283,
-0.0121532548,
0.0252571329,
0.0261416323,
-0.0466522835,
0.0177422073,
0.0436858423,
-0.0257049911,
0.0199641902,
0.0338952057,
0.0399944708,
0.0215856452,
0.027543623,
-0.0163176097,
0.0127934767,
0.0445731208,
-0.0140324878,
0.0247140229,
-0.0061449544,
-0.0401010998,
-0.0072351415,
-0.0055756276,
0.0182099435,
-0.0236401688,
-0.0019334408,
-0.0624769405,
0.0354118794,
0.0270804707,
0.0216731802,
0.016751444,
0.0620661154,
-0.0022297467,
-0.0130081018,
-0.0211867113,
0.0433416255,
-0.0317565389,
-0.0430199578,
0.0009185825,
-0.0019356201,
0.0657283589,
-0.0146418484,
-0.0021234814,
-0.0014599573,
-0.0563106649,
-0.0508859418,
0.0260644406,
0.0306196138,
0.0160721503,
-0.0553807914,
0.0109101925,
-0.0516189858,
-0.030183645,
-0.0257082675,
-0.031758029,
0.0410310179,
0.0731175393,
0.0135179013,
-0.0110226301,
0.0303499922,
-0.0558549017,
-0.0598107316,
0.0258681048,
-0.0404625423,
-0.0009418812,
0.0472566187,
-0.0280553084,
-0.061446093,
-0.0385735296,
-0.0246999022,
0.0648396537,
-0.0368904769,
-0.0095355166,
0.0379099883,
0.0128718866,
0.0235914886,
-0.0319022723,
0.0080443658,
-0.0375727303,
0.0348470435,
0.021410387,
0.0608381517,
0.039902173,
-0.0216762144,
0.0183847919,
0.04271207,
-0.0381496437,
-0.0152094895,
-0.0066322964,
0.0108104758,
-0.0030236756,
0.0568512939,
-0.0612186417,
0.0436709598,
0.0722965896,
-0.0142060416,
-0.0527788922,
0.0422650762,
0.0017809799,
-0.0130368173,
-0.0437327437,
0.0254677497,
0.0190641265,
0.0505258366,
0.0196112618,
0.0117018931,
0.0331078805,
-0.0600197837,
-0.0017685217,
0.0212371126,
0.0613724962,
-0.0256251935,
-0.0273843799,
0.002793785,
-0.030554682,
0.0048863213,
-0.0092427973,
-0.0326216929,
-0.0183269996,
-0.0066825207,
-0.054706499,
0.0155899404,
-0.0408439301,
-0.0216658842,
-0.0261801295,
-0.0189410001,
-0.0185795296,
0.000806606,
-0.0249893479,
-0.0648160726,
0.0101423124,
-0.030682493,
-0.0754718259,
-0.0043842886,
-0.0488153882,
-0.0020954185,
-0.0133453226,
0.0118988743,
-0.0122045875,
-0.0324702933,
-0.0233382843,
-0.0003196459,
-0.0462920777,
0.0062581566,
0.0447726138,
-0.0105483886,
0.0058863969,
0.0013491766,
-0.0012110731,
0.0327102728,
0.0401438549,
0.0277005788,
-0.0556520373,
0.013873633,
0.0331222676,
0.0024957557,
0.0097875735,
0.0344638526,
0.0601446442,
-0.0255329125,
0.0208024178,
-0.0371631645,
-0.0074032242,
0.0243145823,
0.0204374716,
-0.0056289532,
-0.0360917933,
0.0441892147,
-0.0392102934,
0.0228707064,
-0.0559431612,
-0.0016782095,
0.0102790073,
-0.0029336752,
-0.0073459586,
0.01069385,
-0.0658032596,
-0.0093756942,
-0.004665751,
-0.0984632596,
-0.0154073872,
-0.0271982532,
0.005110017,
0.0015718188,
-0.0384205692,
-0.0327093937,
-0.0051158359,
0.0136880893,
0.0581984371,
-0.0730126724,
-0.0032631571,
0.0091319429,
0.0202637911,
-0.0412529185,
0.0329221264,
-0.0665926933,
-0.062303897,
-0.0135463979,
-0.0150174759,
-0.0241868552,
-0.0555162132,
-0.0197499711,
0.0141021004,
0.0000436841,
0.0670679435,
0.020163931,
0.0420813337,
-0.0339961126,
0.0830031186,
0.046837654,
0.0351442993,
0.0167748369,
0.0419420116,
0.0179465413,
-0.0101369442,
0.0477586426,
-0.0025250653,
-0.0664741024,
-0.0069870427,
-0.0052591148,
0.040030729,
0.0033950498,
0.0016931543,
-0.0258127898,
-0.0227409024,
0.0366181582,
0.0587761514,
0.0107017513,
-0.0049929488,
-0.0179436877,
0.0303436257,
0.0054990724,
0.0054153907,
-0.0586005673,
-0.0374586768,
-0.0149805555,
0.0629971474,
-0.0050827893,
-0.0435633808,
0.032608036,
-0.0044786497,
-0.1036952585,
0.0282951146,
0.0202717874,
-0.003476108,
-0.0668935031,
0.0136375176,
-0.0262705144,
-0.0182928666,
0.0586769693,
-0.049222298,
0.0341294408,
-0.0280315094,
0.0081315516,
-0.0212414395,
-0.0183264725,
-0.0008866864,
-0.0222200919,
0.0500461534,
0.0563755818,
0.0159349032,
-0.030578142,
-0.0425301939,
-0.0225468427,
0.034817718,
0.0168217774,
0.0349687375,
0.0604625121,
0.0165108759,
-0.0268779881,
0.0673544407,
0.0328067504,
-0.0265463591,
-0.0157063883,
-0.0131472889,
0.0204359125,
-0.0086302496,
0.0159939285,
-0.0255695973,
0.0126953367,
0.0215036515,
0.046702493,
0.0223625824,
0.0087368125,
0.0194379203,
0.0385714397,
0.0107522961,
-0.0249678418,
-0.0336976238,
0.0455213711,
0.0482204109,
-0.0558687933,
-0.0305971541,
-0.0101233497,
-0.0202591624,
0.0287551563,
-0.0062050219,
0.0284762327,
-0.0315930955,
0.0115019158,
-0.0855465308,
0.0475701764,
0.0066120871,
0.1032987908,
-0.0263712648,
0.0313390829,
-0.0127856489,
-0.0505157374,
-0.022445783,
0.044472713,
-0.0455609486,
0.0021769213,
0.0302242693,
-0.019546913,
0.0122548044,
0.0341540538,
-0.0415644906,
0.0033072249,
0.0609480031,
0.0169355031,
-0.0112715689,
-0.0374830663,
0.108596161,
-0.0883195251,
-0.0408235267,
0.0054106256,
-0.0249543041,
0.0316190161,
-0.0088824918,
-0.0495587103,
-0.0146365911,
-0.0378426574,
0.0234300997,
-0.0052498081,
0.0345959291,
-0.0346888863,
0.0587623864,
-0.0161212869,
0.0317385308,
0.0117188627,
0.0085679693,
-0.022344796,
0.0019458252,
0.0337531641,
0.0073525705,
0.0407918245,
0.0355248637,
0.0078083719,
-0.0240615085,
0.024537703,
0.0191116706,
0.022450801,
0.0288584065,
-0.0321160592,
0.0041261669,
0.0005853508,
0.0800306946,
0.0455016382,
0.0118303848,
0.0399191715,
0.0065666083,
-0.0096573699,
-0.0203968789,
0.0153886564,
0.0238600858,
-0.0053241127,
-0.0097668637,
-0.0431307442,
0.0313855335,
0.0606713071,
-0.0614195988,
0.0213623345,
-0.0087873219,
-0.0018422692,
-0.0234983359,
0.0070433994,
-0.0416893363,
-0.0127634499,
-0.0397661477,
0.0213316958,
0.0001997455,
0.0153168598,
0.0565583929,
0.0019417992,
0.036744453,
-0.025620155,
0.0460601822,
-0.0454498604,
-0.0318129063,
-0.0147401169,
0.0089407237,
-0.0062655997,
0.0153334774,
-0.0213941745,
-0.04888127,
0.0427671336,
-0.0248677433,
0.0023777504,
0.0316252112,
0.0321969166,
0.0029475689,
-0.0347844809,
0.0469458066,
0.0444119684,
-0.0056685875,
0.0319722742,
0.0027743205,
0.014012537,
-5.213602136e-33,
0.0205696337,
0.00883085,
-0.0156515539,
0.0143772671,
-0.0071716597,
0.0172935426,
0.0344784334,
0.0005384153,
-0.0014690952,
-0.011479714,
-0.0374604948,
0.0535627902,
0.0156331975,
0.0295640491,
-0.0481004789,
-0.0347170532,
0.0704817846,
0.0021526671,
0.0260766763,
0.011455928,
0.0620966405,
0.0228275433,
0.0366243646,
-0.0856967717,
-0.0453751422,
-0.0180567857,
-0.0295371208,
-0.0059254104,
-0.0628134236,
0.0487663969,
0.0170505326,
0.0399528332,
-0.007201212,
-0.0245784558,
-0.02984556,
0.0246932283,
0.0071178568,
0.0087186806,
-0.010820901,
0.0344181992,
0.0099173645,
-0.0471471474,
0.0470877029,
0.0245267507,
-0.0389626622,
0.0038379009,
0.0384232253,
-0.0803744271,
0.0023538261,
-0.0780912712,
-0.0270378366,
0.0248028766,
-0.0245252438,
-0.0223800167,
0.043879021,
0.0279465839,
0.0012959113,
-0.0316889212,
-0.0679569095,
0.0428266786,
0.0174738336,
0.0099204145,
0.0145719051,
0.0101782056,
0.002375582,
0.0647874251,
0.0281966738,
-0.0423126593,
0.0229989402,
0.0098476438,
0.0402462818,
0.0757385343,
0.0941805989,
0.1029578224,
0.0690639168,
-0.0211596265,
-0.049602773,
0.0288332496,
0.0106640095,
-0.025372263,
-0.0264515597,
0.038696643,
-0.0202811807,
0.0334879868,
-0.057540711,
0.0085580805,
-0.0156276617,
0.0047948938,
-0.0043753474,
0.0244782958,
-0.0014156367,
0.0074379789,
0.0228673983,
-0.0408276059,
0.0569931455,
0.0185003988,
-0.0138770277,
-0.0015968895,
0.0305425692,
0.0047475663,
0.0099368924,
-0.0313284919,
0.1085687354,
0.0057318518,
-0.011073756,
-0.0303306114,
0.0197100025,
0.0604369268,
-0.0265605021,
0.0049463147,
0.0185182076,
0.0249384791,
-0.0025509128,
0.0164001547,
0.0028397967,
-0.0045227893,
-0.0146261863,
-0.0072287079,
-0.0391155519,
0.0461336672,
-0.0042755371,
0.0528545566,
-0.0066640363,
0.0218942333,
-0.0018282156,
0.0207333528,
-0.0342561528,
-0.0339632966,
0.0537164658,
-0.0339019708,
0.0231488291,
-0.0145620583,
2.596e-7,
-0.0909558311,
-0.067176044,
0.0408794433,
-0.0668964908,
-0.0087197246,
0.0461724028,
0.0037355474,
-0.009678551,
-0.024778977,
-0.0708382726,
0.011556997,
-0.0029805203,
0.0633695573,
0.0134287355,
-0.0800555497,
0.0118255122,
-0.0259985477,
-0.0136669502,
-0.0608839989,
0.0257695746,
0.0096114604,
0.105110459,
0.0101015205,
-0.0876929238,
0.0668723211,
-0.0249246005,
-0.0053617922,
0.0457953513,
-0.0257574525,
-0.0616824552,
0.05037947,
0.0231904164,
0.0076094964,
0.0574878044,
-0.0282818172,
0.0456985012,
0.0336397029,
0.0084435912,
0.0184327774,
-0.0803612024,
-0.0417666063,
0.0150601035,
-0.0058476334,
0.0364207998,
0.0470025316,
0.0499146879,
-0.0095900195,
-0.0549449474,
-0.0686322302,
0.0228565466,
0.0093410118,
-0.006842976,
0.0490359589,
0.0020288618,
0.0184326712,
-0.035885822,
-0.0012384155,
-0.0395892672,
-0.0084085958,
0.0252008364,
-0.058625441,
0.0123056257,
-0.0190837216,
-0.016916804,
0.0630132109,
0.0117304362,
-0.0010393617,
1.837271038e-34,
0.0077453363,
-0.0193969533,
0.0290052611,
-0.023018904,
-0.0218253639,
-0.0049223662,
-0.0248372816,
-0.0141668878,
-0.0027214566,
-0.0198633652,
-0.0353262015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15554v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15554v1 | 'What are you referring to?' Evaluating the Ability of Multi-Modal Dialogue Models to Process Clarificational Exchanges | 2023-07-28T13:44:33 | 2023-07-28T13:44:33 | Javier Chiyah-Garcia, Alessandro Suglia, Arash Eshghi, Helen Hastie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Referential ambiguities arise in dialogue when a referring expression does
not uniquely identify the intended referent for the addressee. Addressees
usually detect such ambiguities immediately and work with the speaker to repair
it using meta-communicative, Clarificational Exchanges (CE): a Clarification
Request (CR) and a response. Here, we argue that the ability to generate and
respond to CRs imposes specific constraints on the architecture and objective
functions of multi-modal, visually grounded dialogue models. We use the SIMMC
2.0 dataset to evaluate the ability of different state-of-the-art model
architectures to process CEs, with a metric that probes the contextual updates
that arise from them in the model. We find that language-based models are able
to encode simple multi-modal semantic information and process some CEs,
excelling with those related to the dialogue history, whilst multi-modal models
can use additional learning objectives to obtain disentangled object
representations, which become crucial to handle complex referential ambiguities
across modalities overall. | [
0.0926690474,
0.0466341265,
-0.0223417059,
0.0305714421,
-0.0142103424,
-0.0058788816,
-0.0165659655,
-0.0242206175,
-0.0371890441,
-0.0659322217,
-0.0504435636,
-0.0139760626,
0.0357163548,
0.0264787022,
-0.0025303906,
-0.0856390521,
0.043219965,
-0.0213221218,
0.0073760226,
0.0208399687,
0.0232665278,
0.0016104585,
-0.0269906241,
0.0702774301,
-0.050442338,
-0.0320899151,
-0.0539644361,
0.0473956056,
-0.0163071603,
-0.0188184232,
-0.0123260282,
0.0307594687,
0.0407336131,
0.020597836,
0.0000018201,
-0.0126448702,
0.0453200713,
-0.0422041118,
-0.0241927467,
-0.0331044793,
0.0191247445,
-0.0301491525,
0.007088542,
0.0087471511,
-0.0030775075,
-0.030948868,
0.0693911016,
0.0663446933,
0.1033738106,
0.0466875508,
-0.0126238437,
-0.0178153422,
0.0070657595,
-0.0483040661,
-0.0107101956,
-0.0531079955,
-0.0001559195,
0.0108419256,
-0.0204713717,
0.0285111181,
-0.0425823517,
0.0251833498,
0.0135027636,
-0.0088862488,
-0.0005874899,
0.022119116,
-0.0009518628,
-0.0366211683,
-0.0327716246,
0.1126204357,
0.0366334282,
0.0300440323,
-0.0144677814,
0.0179184899,
0.0048664995,
0.0158410203,
-0.0481174067,
0.0115910713,
-0.0021451612,
-0.0075313766,
-0.0555888377,
-0.0017274179,
-0.0036529773,
0.0186286941,
0.0022732269,
0.0117626442,
-0.0230925549,
0.0110214232,
0.0043911445,
-0.0008053839,
-0.0028858436,
-0.0682771429,
-0.0160542335,
0.0197635517,
-0.0621439032,
0.0174338371,
-0.0428192131,
0.0322576426,
0.0055880588,
-0.0138512347,
0.0379696712,
0.0144705595,
-0.0475952365,
0.0514585041,
0.0282552894,
0.0373702087,
-0.0581949688,
0.022417374,
0.0014664741,
-0.0396444388,
-0.0646415576,
-0.0160245653,
-0.0457476787,
0.0258976743,
-0.0851923376,
-0.0460207574,
0.0127617326,
0.054051321,
-0.0369541012,
0.0322184525,
-0.028195668,
0.0279915817,
-0.036882367,
0.0025628228,
-0.0507760309,
0.0633511767,
-0.0517881624,
0.049162887,
0.01459873,
-0.0611659884,
-0.0221320931,
0.0446749628,
-0.0140644666,
-0.0363968611,
-0.0193515643,
0.094286643,
-0.0496403202,
-0.0333071314,
0.009449455,
-0.0406528339,
-0.0669598281,
-0.0506170392,
0.0371356308,
0.0156374834,
0.0193346422,
-0.0079888105,
-0.0089899469,
-0.0379314609,
0.0266684461,
-0.022528898,
-0.0491861366,
0.0812129453,
-0.0082355738,
-0.0007553367,
0.0088657802,
0.0326676145,
-0.0088656545,
0.0633473918,
0.0449501947,
0.0030298587,
0.0191951394,
0.0025983991,
0.0163271204,
-0.0179139171,
0.0095123183,
0.0121920863,
-0.0427301489,
0.0237592887,
-0.0470412225,
0.0455603711,
0.0365039185,
0.04831177,
-0.0319351889,
-0.0432916097,
0.0617578588,
0.0247332435,
-0.0399409533,
-0.0066851056,
-0.0141799496,
0.027069699,
-0.0217679758,
0.0040394948,
-0.0458396822,
0.0673960373,
-0.0054638064,
-0.0142119769,
0.0212080013,
-0.0251812786,
-0.0567793362,
-0.0234034639,
0.0221737437,
0.0012998822,
0.0027671955,
0.0010099928,
0.0190507937,
0.0374931842,
-0.0231355987,
0.0670509487,
-0.0090451464,
-0.0126173887,
-0.0309509244,
-0.0283980109,
-0.0193802528,
0.0371049605,
0.0259776413,
-0.000157724,
-0.0380989164,
-0.0530885682,
0.0372048989,
0.0918046534,
0.0138206538,
-0.0104027139,
0.093853265,
-0.0241495464,
-0.0258460101,
-0.0496117733,
0.0009445763,
0.0118904104,
-0.0177250523,
-0.042675335,
-0.010962327,
0.0029815496,
0.0873631537,
0.014484209,
0.054037787,
0.0300086904,
-0.0126509639,
0.0171821434,
0.0264814682,
0.0074256263,
-0.0152757727,
-0.0140603324,
0.0298447087,
-0.0164327975,
0.018629536,
0.0540454239,
-0.0344270989,
-0.0440403558,
0.0322699845,
-0.0281075817,
-0.0136111677,
-0.0005178722,
-0.0582262687,
-0.0655076578,
0.0746892691,
-0.0234592017,
0.0324056521,
-0.0403293595,
-0.0065040668,
0.0069755726,
0.0275875032,
0.0150186131,
0.0087476429,
-0.0400939099,
-0.0208245181,
0.0590633899,
0.0282851513,
0.017939752,
-0.006936132,
0.0171195343,
0.0317198224,
-0.0041370867,
0.0114713823,
-0.0155132804,
0.0045111133,
-0.0500460118,
-0.0602456629,
-0.064018555,
-0.0476694293,
-0.0046023289,
-0.0215962082,
0.0243512616,
0.0109026236,
0.0161840618,
-0.0552206635,
0.0002352512,
0.0025883797,
0.0061341221,
0.0011501014,
0.0590399094,
0.0250331908,
0.0051841554,
-0.0599045083,
0.0288255922,
0.044158265,
0.062161658,
-0.0194381066,
-0.0234384891,
-0.0462741628,
0.0061724926,
-0.0378266424,
0.0429008976,
-0.0186117273,
-0.0424704552,
0.0438237749,
0.0248029549,
0.0403606035,
0.0517983548,
0.0055839424,
0.0814199597,
0.0275212396,
-0.0864229798,
-0.0532777421,
0.0412493348,
0.0093576098,
-0.0287622269,
-0.0470863469,
0.0011157776,
-0.0168642439,
0.0468108319,
-0.012999001,
0.0460604355,
-0.0427520685,
0.0162690785,
0.0594040491,
-0.0664780661,
-0.0399922244,
-0.0006659691,
-0.0138969151,
0.0610751696,
-0.041523736,
-0.0313192457,
0.0370761268,
-0.0275668819,
-0.0367142409,
0.024133794,
0.0111421254,
0.0044406792,
0.0765771568,
-0.0313780122,
0.0067218258,
0.0051151705,
-0.0353958197,
-0.0675399452,
-0.0399951637,
0.0138115305,
-0.0012738532,
0.050010778,
-0.0452706218,
0.0067768502,
0.0028918451,
-0.018735243,
-0.0220793076,
-0.0246869735,
-0.0375148356,
-0.0097990232,
-0.0314037167,
-0.0133310007,
-0.0424182415,
0.0258183517,
0.0136466762,
-0.0078941416,
0.0067988704,
-0.0062321234,
-0.0458956622,
0.0380917229,
0.048560366,
0.0756760314,
-0.0139704105,
-0.033429116,
0.0459122844,
0.0504083373,
0.0287783854,
0.0103544574,
-0.0397708863,
0.0251274593,
0.0016686537,
0.0544058159,
-0.0200426094,
-0.0015072112,
0.0798272192,
-0.0162053853,
-0.0327953435,
0.0681311116,
0.0114153065,
-0.0210946985,
-0.0202170722,
-0.0092989048,
0.0361512937,
0.01073837,
0.0071419938,
-0.08643426,
-0.0661776811,
0.0239974465,
-0.0350852683,
0.0140392147,
-0.0079860194,
-0.0354971513,
-0.0661040619,
0.0286899954,
-0.0142041389,
-0.0571829155,
-0.0651881397,
0.0298186,
0.0302409548,
0.0139014013,
0.0337930843,
-0.0120970383,
0.0109839207,
-0.0230814219,
-0.0038897565,
0.0289807338,
-0.0418189019,
0.0119777462,
0.0054292749,
0.0649958178,
0.039751187,
0.0244458783,
0.025111299,
-0.0084969709,
0.0143913869,
-0.0092572886,
-0.0097210761,
-0.0134776626,
0.0543965064,
-0.0123409703,
-0.0213671438,
-0.0042535616,
0.0076992726,
-0.0013863278,
-0.0332734175,
-0.011288167,
0.014200802,
-0.0546409041,
0.0484479479,
-0.0190162193,
0.0547330864,
0.0226550866,
0.0477639735,
0.059302479,
-0.0477094352,
-0.0275160111,
-0.0209273621,
0.0389398597,
-0.0139990738,
0.0410534814,
0.0009959944,
0.0097441925,
0.0064595244,
-0.0537153967,
-0.025020821,
-0.0068885586,
0.0160292294,
-0.0004323071,
-0.0180144571,
0.0147761283,
0.0005176871,
-0.0167805161,
0.0380638912,
-0.0238456521,
0.0186333396,
-0.0473555662,
-0.004926648,
0.0168983862,
-0.0264048558,
-0.0226934403,
0.0189249013,
-0.068155922,
-0.0245824493,
-0.063433148,
0.0620034449,
0.0265995152,
0.060868457,
0.0000988331,
-0.0407299586,
-0.0533199087,
-0.0067728418,
-0.0172856748,
0.0095303738,
0.0434938595,
0.0430547111,
-0.0291232392,
0.0398085192,
-0.0211465824,
0.0304155722,
0.0126767317,
0.0251759067,
-0.0513918065,
-0.0821143091,
0.0014391765,
-0.0500036851,
0.0491070971,
0.037270382,
0.0306018796,
0.0023879188,
0.0175722931,
0.0289682858,
0.0004815168,
-0.0861312896,
0.0024311177,
-0.0184216332,
-0.0267263986,
0.0141947931,
-0.0233407151,
-0.019209018,
0.0753876194,
0.0043167975,
-0.0365824029,
0.0032957098,
0.0191036426,
-0.0386763327,
0.034180522,
0.0067467093,
0.0357108563,
0.0057150982,
0.0266690906,
0.027683055,
0.1099538282,
0.0221580379,
-0.058747869,
0.0030772667,
0.0325041376,
-0.0340743139,
-0.0148253934,
0.0143906409,
0.044865001,
0.0345339328,
0.0632329658,
0.0322477184,
0.0037685987,
0.0097568892,
-0.0015336502,
0.0990942121,
0.0135273803,
-0.0494940579,
0.0687590986,
0.0191015042,
-0.0177216716,
0.0230395347,
0.0312539525,
-0.0147879533,
0.0115319612,
-0.0064354655,
0.014266381,
-0.0655164272,
-0.0380136594,
-0.0158534534,
0.0256828163,
0.0358724669,
0.0680858418,
-0.0638126805,
-0.0341211222,
0.0118240137,
0.0016503849,
-0.0069555957,
-0.0137741156,
0.0237058848,
0.0196529813,
0.0578893088,
-0.0541972332,
-0.0255120248,
-0.0163820814,
0.0186323337,
0.0218095463,
-0.0370559506,
-5.9023555e-33,
-0.0795929134,
-0.0220448375,
0.0100121843,
-0.0298454445,
-0.0499723218,
-0.0018089876,
-0.0586965866,
-0.007066194,
-0.0413735658,
-0.0024109816,
0.0007236285,
0.051092837,
-0.0015521046,
0.0392091945,
-0.0107413242,
-0.026482299,
0.0463512726,
0.0088191656,
-0.0123288184,
0.0221696347,
0.0491056181,
-0.0118730133,
0.0304890238,
-0.0679306239,
-0.0157623738,
0.0352571011,
-0.043453481,
0.0564048551,
0.016036367,
0.0453240201,
-0.0085312817,
0.0363145471,
-0.0039772871,
0.0166745037,
-0.0173947252,
0.0104337754,
-0.0865129083,
-0.0204737317,
0.0421643294,
0.0278831851,
-0.0591836236,
-0.0062688556,
0.0203045122,
0.003771517,
0.0374376737,
-0.0210881289,
0.0129261753,
-0.0312915817,
-0.0135801313,
0.0508869775,
-0.0127233732,
-0.0077600498,
-0.0265309289,
-0.0730630606,
0.0131193521,
0.0724782199,
0.0077878744,
-0.0171847325,
-0.0344367735,
0.0070609599,
0.0017855981,
0.0013952532,
0.0329484642,
0.0672001019,
0.0204515439,
0.0742196962,
0.0370020643,
-0.0107708611,
-0.0217020754,
-0.0274524484,
-0.0025835412,
0.0472627431,
-0.007519891,
0.0702857524,
-0.0345130563,
0.006319507,
-0.0257900544,
-0.0409233533,
-0.0113351494,
0.080791831,
-0.005759709,
-0.0004300166,
0.0231062956,
-0.0025735972,
-0.054161977,
-0.0193275977,
-0.0318676569,
-0.0112727592,
0.0501206703,
0.0208024476,
-0.0054096263,
0.0252067409,
0.0469812863,
-0.0348853655,
-0.0169288628,
0.0191923641,
-0.0261837784,
0.0528307259,
0.010876406,
0.0007109859,
-0.017963713,
-0.0142339682,
0.083059594,
-0.0393188,
0.0100807948,
0.0174390599,
-0.0019392881,
-0.0011545988,
-0.0480431244,
-0.0300603695,
-0.0323441438,
0.0587016046,
-0.0695125535,
-0.015429318,
0.0069920318,
0.010122424,
-0.0685269609,
0.045605503,
-0.0317008756,
0.0047021578,
-0.0188841783,
-0.0373611823,
-0.0082813976,
0.0417349897,
-0.0234597418,
0.000061534,
-0.0085982149,
-0.06356702,
0.0457085297,
-0.060048148,
-0.0186337549,
0.0042825844,
2.567e-7,
-0.0016351985,
0.0201410316,
0.0322453082,
0.0004292752,
0.0341344103,
0.0652707368,
-0.0364508927,
0.0151663981,
0.0082675256,
-0.0491394475,
-0.0064612371,
0.0261143334,
0.0713807568,
-0.0096115274,
-0.0081045507,
0.0261861905,
-0.0706544742,
-0.0050759991,
-0.008857009,
-0.0116635393,
0.0398828387,
0.0404774211,
0.0048516239,
0.0013986257,
-0.0042909114,
-0.0059333048,
0.0772307888,
-0.07276427,
0.0073992084,
-0.0190856643,
-0.006990266,
-0.0007020593,
0.0095175318,
0.0391721167,
0.0448668338,
0.0020731129,
-0.0090522952,
0.0756729543,
-0.0085076038,
-0.0660435036,
-0.0538128279,
0.0243205354,
-0.0115039758,
0.0021031075,
0.0320984237,
-0.0670838654,
-0.0383971594,
-0.0332280025,
-0.02871323,
-0.0096414043,
0.0169920344,
-0.0163667277,
-0.0543480292,
0.014014625,
0.012545472,
-0.0115795964,
0.005206258,
-0.0690127686,
-0.0122804744,
0.001660583,
-0.0291175488,
0.0055196402,
-0.0126025612,
-0.0511712171,
0.0333680138,
-0.0327335671,
-0.029481627,
1.686803514e-34,
0.0176137034,
-0.0156759266,
0.0087416274,
0.0499471426,
0.0245321672,
-0.0138821481,
-0.0285437088,
-0.0072395355,
0.0239044167,
-0.0355042368,
0.0101845637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15543v1 | Oracle Computability and Turing Reducibility in the Calculus of Inductive Constructions | 2023-07-28T13:16:46 | 2023-07-28T13:16:46 | Yannick Forster, Dominik Kirst, Niklas Mück | cs.LO | cs.LO, cs.CL, math.LO | We develop synthetic notions of oracle computability and Turing reducibility
in the Calculus of Inductive Constructions (CIC), the constructive type theory
underlying the Coq proof assistant. As usual in synthetic approaches, we employ
a definition of oracle computations based on meta-level functions rather than
object-level models of computation, relying on the fact that in constructive
systems such as CIC all definable functions are computable by construction.
Such an approach lends itself well to machine-checked proofs, which we carry
out in Coq.
There is a tension in finding a good synthetic rendering of the higher-order
notion of oracle computability. On the one hand, it has to be informative
enough to prove central results, ensuring that all notions are faithfully
captured. On the other hand, it has to be restricted enough to benefit from
axioms for synthetic computability, which usually concern first-order objects.
Drawing inspiration from a definition by Andrej Bauer based on continuous
functions in the effective topos, we use a notion of sequential continuity to
characterise valid oracle computations.
As main technical results, we show that Turing reducibility forms an upper
semilattice, transports decidability, and is strictly more expressive than
truth-table reducibility, and prove that whenever both a predicate $p$ and its
complement are semi-decidable relative to an oracle $q$, then $p$
Turing-reduces to $q$. | [
-0.0351734199,
0.0242379848,
-0.0022507391,
-0.0344882272,
-0.0023143832,
-0.0137281418,
-0.0644331351,
-0.0286648497,
0.0135849612,
0.0429310724,
-0.0331756361,
0.0567260496,
-0.0104057966,
0.0287355054,
0.0400291122,
-0.0114857303,
0.0220233388,
-0.0554083511,
-0.0362402573,
-0.0132440012,
-0.0299319886,
-0.0450001545,
-0.0135897454,
-0.0146701271,
0.0227070972,
-0.0887734592,
0.0049175476,
-0.0497133248,
-0.0167297497,
0.0647592098,
-0.0339069404,
0.0064448491,
-0.1015827656,
0.0582009181,
0.0000015377,
0.016003862,
-0.0284168664,
0.0670556203,
-0.0714894459,
0.0143547682,
-0.0554527901,
-0.0059466879,
-0.0328881256,
0.0406132266,
-0.0169145409,
-0.0103578633,
0.0447488688,
-0.0334199443,
0.0316898935,
0.0349492878,
0.0297861919,
-0.0494999997,
0.0557210445,
0.0214344077,
0.034094546,
-0.0093681924,
-0.0319794826,
-0.0029941783,
0.0532443598,
-0.0232255943,
0.0531796999,
-0.0074647386,
0.0219740476,
-0.0493472181,
-0.0200701319,
0.0026062171,
0.0055213873,
0.0062559145,
0.0184419751,
-0.0186753515,
0.052622959,
-0.0435162894,
-0.0855278298,
0.073780708,
0.0188598186,
-0.0231067128,
0.0311605856,
0.0206628107,
-0.014308814,
0.0081859697,
0.0560495853,
-0.0127003361,
0.0395736322,
-0.0472011268,
-0.0202729944,
0.0435617678,
0.0185670555,
-0.0318155028,
-0.0075236866,
0.0161136184,
0.0656255931,
0.0184475984,
0.0063213934,
0.0065488201,
-0.0613876656,
-0.0426216759,
0.0279982649,
0.0344378725,
-0.0138763469,
-0.0382940918,
0.0113623282,
-0.0125440219,
0.0397057869,
0.0318637155,
0.032021068,
0.0309957843,
-0.0134735396,
0.0363862552,
0.0116947703,
-0.001848986,
-0.0037655409,
-0.0261090044,
-0.0212510005,
0.0634706542,
0.0596827939,
0.0586612336,
-0.0115776351,
0.0250902083,
-0.0492592938,
0.0508667231,
-0.0524491072,
-0.0891312733,
-0.0624761581,
-0.0125329355,
-0.0187861435,
-0.0442537293,
0.0169853549,
0.0048922226,
-0.0361717641,
-0.0522383228,
-0.0073562651,
-0.0145592447,
-0.0642375574,
0.0085232193,
-0.0091435844,
0.0616928488,
-0.0243901331,
0.0091907252,
-0.0259589069,
-0.0202827696,
0.0607310459,
-0.0238827821,
-0.036180336,
-0.0055049192,
0.0341662653,
-0.0128255161,
-0.0254349113,
-0.0057090558,
-0.0755901039,
-0.0026460914,
0.0212965924,
0.0405005552,
-0.0294025354,
-0.0008088283,
-0.0418075547,
-0.0377199091,
-0.0688660666,
-0.0245297998,
-0.0130517324,
-0.0161250047,
0.0012071936,
-0.0150605422,
0.0263042897,
0.0195294507,
-0.0352477618,
-0.0614285059,
-0.0413628556,
0.0237287339,
0.0173186716,
-0.0080341296,
-0.0332656391,
0.0794328004,
-0.001739673,
0.0090716844,
-0.0050663226,
-0.0797423571,
0.0483066812,
0.0220654011,
0.0309175383,
-0.0233164765,
0.0639731139,
0.0907886699,
-0.047697559,
-0.0277422536,
-0.0547381677,
0.0567839034,
-0.0150757255,
-0.0032915573,
-0.0028887878,
-0.0933838785,
0.0085930005,
0.0186353438,
-0.03506428,
-0.0110913897,
0.0246317256,
0.0462513641,
0.0086043179,
-0.0683129057,
-0.0594551899,
-0.0364391319,
-0.0186256338,
-0.0383492857,
0.0713892505,
-0.0221123826,
-0.003317646,
-0.0909370184,
0.0285734963,
-0.0191448908,
-0.0176299512,
0.0310620219,
0.0244302582,
-0.0305243954,
-0.0322958007,
0.0381866433,
0.0252895262,
0.0187746082,
0.0370416343,
-0.0497092418,
-0.0415991247,
-0.0177605208,
-0.0436867326,
0.0368926786,
-0.0108639216,
-0.0001115609,
0.0344087668,
-0.0625592247,
-0.0369919911,
0.0546627343,
0.0111497603,
0.0385077335,
-0.0362622216,
0.0591281988,
0.0505746864,
0.0329281874,
0.0085418206,
0.0191312954,
0.0045397356,
-0.0126326745,
-0.0230166726,
-0.0996018127,
0.0061526056,
-0.0084425369,
-0.0256849285,
0.0318494588,
0.0281539075,
-0.0037861052,
0.0290151592,
0.0123320352,
0.0661039129,
0.0164305214,
-0.0386291295,
0.0331147648,
0.023113478,
0.0031212824,
0.0201662406,
0.0432387516,
-0.0516729355,
-0.0641597882,
0.0249093175,
-0.0155596016,
0.0383971445,
0.0211646147,
0.0314321704,
0.0151647767,
0.0245535094,
0.0033895234,
0.002430951,
0.0098605286,
0.0461287759,
-0.0245823525,
0.0053191963,
0.0097739631,
0.0436223932,
0.0241521932,
0.0264921505,
0.0375620872,
-0.0085695451,
-0.0039065382,
0.0173323639,
0.0278974511,
-0.0033055539,
-0.0175569952,
0.0138870897,
-0.0378776677,
-0.0121679977,
0.0291699655,
-0.0570857413,
-0.0278482251,
-0.0044356552,
0.0231975876,
0.0061600418,
-0.0007829947,
-0.0311689414,
0.0293879416,
0.0301422309,
0.0275683273,
-0.0211344436,
0.0401659831,
0.0155973369,
0.0323561057,
-0.0452645868,
0.0402079299,
0.0610439479,
0.0085610868,
0.0172025766,
-0.0685607791,
0.0379510261,
0.0504480414,
0.001812479,
0.0443954319,
-0.0800429881,
-0.0082742414,
-0.0199943669,
0.0140754487,
0.0127662504,
0.0439280383,
0.0006733726,
-0.0207619872,
-0.0380025022,
-0.0411195271,
-0.0045691836,
-0.033300478,
-0.0156724267,
-0.0132404389,
0.0009744049,
-0.0032196313,
-0.0300004967,
-0.0577774234,
0.0356449448,
0.0269950796,
-0.0223873667,
0.0396111384,
0.0379853025,
0.0115427291,
-0.0114155561,
0.0256194789,
-0.0038937039,
0.0381792113,
0.0252865683,
-0.0245826505,
-0.0328467749,
-0.0429737121,
-0.0409296453,
0.0862510055,
-0.0134623069,
0.0110704936,
-0.0082170051,
0.0395274162,
0.0043094042,
-0.0124573587,
-0.0064787115,
-0.0255419631,
0.055962339,
-0.0168635249,
-0.0377103835,
-0.0885991752,
-0.0733020455,
0.0624528192,
-0.0334037542,
0.0213938169,
0.0406695195,
0.0138435429,
-0.0172666516,
-0.0312555954,
0.005968343,
0.0012213679,
0.0112800924,
-0.0291233584,
-0.0391532034,
-0.0214105379,
-0.0452670269,
-0.0209496245,
-0.0115654459,
-0.0147205619,
-0.0228758641,
0.0060389438,
0.0242532734,
-0.0166822951,
0.0016215985,
0.017634593,
0.0183817707,
-0.1288025826,
0.0184276663,
0.0220410135,
-0.0411649756,
-0.0521412194,
0.0150442058,
-0.0080377292,
-0.0437742397,
0.0271692574,
0.05025056,
-0.0631384924,
-0.0389584787,
0.0374247171,
0.0058896253,
0.0085933516,
-0.0676067472,
0.0230350494,
-0.013705397,
0.0405335724,
0.026520744,
0.0042790491,
0.0182279069,
-0.0486640856,
0.0387661755,
-0.0484744571,
-0.0194971636,
0.0104953684,
-0.0054628686,
-0.0469525084,
-0.0046969932,
-0.0057461695,
-0.0516929105,
0.0354610942,
-0.0615328103,
-0.019718999,
0.0191046707,
0.031875819,
0.0603352934,
0.0686186776,
0.000961035,
0.0491670072,
0.0716463998,
-0.020990992,
-0.0684006587,
-0.0180650465,
-0.0313230939,
0.0080830017,
0.0293173622,
-0.0250594895,
0.0321522392,
-0.0113852043,
-0.036430195,
-0.0373054743,
0.0113440072,
-0.0512571856,
0.0286842734,
-0.0214924999,
-0.073301062,
0.0159156956,
0.012988341,
0.0211442113,
0.0005354325,
-0.0258526895,
0.0350357629,
0.0172519367,
-0.0228727665,
-0.0320350267,
-0.0018650319,
-0.0728816167,
0.0085062645,
-0.0736073628,
-0.0115682865,
-0.0188691504,
-0.0150720561,
-0.0322421528,
-0.0041548032,
0.075979434,
0.006319582,
0.0313482545,
0.0655975714,
0.0225719977,
-0.0645380914,
-0.0118903015,
0.0211785492,
0.0235970356,
0.044867821,
-0.0399168469,
-0.0101918019,
0.070464246,
-0.0592794791,
0.0176495537,
0.0282892101,
0.0113105783,
-0.0238841493,
-0.0591890812,
0.005446563,
0.0448408015,
0.0267269257,
0.0384371616,
0.0239461008,
0.0277403258,
0.0472627804,
-0.0041755354,
0.0113413706,
0.007648089,
0.0176494401,
-0.0259734727,
-0.0681281835,
0.0277865399,
-0.0325841382,
0.0356305055,
0.0086001409,
-0.0590101071,
0.0169620868,
0.0237004589,
0.0228798892,
0.01582513,
0.0374563485,
0.0226932243,
0.050121367,
-0.0153148333,
0.0089606363,
0.0577450134,
0.0023703456,
0.0337818749,
-0.0345741287,
-0.0089117046,
0.0437924974,
0.0592154264,
-0.0409374349,
0.039865952,
-0.007471242,
-0.054109849,
0.0313205011,
0.0760926902,
0.0155060031,
0.0288944487,
-0.0524682552,
0.0052061924,
-0.000539383,
-0.0207427964,
0.0087276828,
0.0597753339,
-0.0318190865,
-0.006896433,
0.0470176451,
0.036068894,
0.0342093222,
0.0370289423,
-0.0872379318,
-0.0149621041,
-0.0270386282,
-0.010299067,
-0.0681331605,
-0.0717733577,
-0.0650359392,
0.0159693938,
0.019080339,
-0.050096117,
-0.0873255506,
-0.0651985407,
0.0473603271,
0.0113957301,
0.0178926867,
-0.0115546482,
-0.009429005,
0.0359734371,
0.0523195043,
-0.0089623686,
-0.0473005846,
0.0331766456,
0.0470895693,
-0.0270847715,
0.0727606639,
-4.140603546e-33,
-0.0427929536,
0.0586936958,
0.0375491977,
0.0437643752,
0.0076584602,
0.0291833244,
0.0092074256,
0.0116387215,
0.0075790207,
0.0197580289,
-0.0417608097,
0.0263777915,
0.0188513193,
-0.0192011055,
-0.0665776432,
-0.0011127781,
0.0366908684,
-0.0393777452,
-0.0310199726,
-0.0369355828,
-0.0189162176,
-0.0630555749,
0.0117910197,
0.0220597591,
0.0702712238,
-0.0209934972,
-0.0136889117,
0.0007793442,
-0.0434622169,
0.0656001568,
-0.0270733163,
0.0424579792,
-0.0147351185,
-0.0062941401,
-0.0114954328,
0.047094062,
-0.0261430126,
0.0169115495,
0.0454962328,
-0.0065188948,
-0.0511014052,
-0.0535899028,
0.0210592244,
0.0101835579,
-0.0140380114,
-0.0151758669,
-0.0348123275,
-0.0068930788,
0.0143535426,
0.0069698994,
-0.029970387,
0.0075499145,
-0.0451249145,
0.0070235035,
-0.0119301518,
0.0391378514,
-0.0030675293,
-0.0437272452,
-0.0265887324,
0.0183237884,
0.022635309,
-0.0126509583,
-0.0138801476,
-0.0470595658,
0.0121523393,
-0.0360347889,
0.0376328789,
0.0190755278,
0.0217234455,
0.0377346948,
-0.0762533247,
0.0534886979,
0.0069905519,
0.004021599,
0.0286006145,
0.0018001547,
-0.0025290316,
0.029723864,
0.0139001505,
0.0156678483,
0.00293206,
-0.0186216701,
-0.0557702258,
0.0006097827,
-0.0346324332,
0.009513434,
-0.0116473148,
0.0502453372,
-0.0231297035,
0.0017724886,
-0.0059487508,
0.0029370619,
0.0360974409,
-0.0225092899,
0.0057875174,
0.0280586127,
-0.0153273111,
-0.0189884678,
0.0272522941,
0.0321050584,
0.0340738632,
-0.0005866765,
-0.0701929927,
0.0218611434,
0.0268025808,
0.0257815085,
0.0107256267,
0.0338162854,
0.0162479877,
-0.0193892624,
-0.0077134129,
-0.0099495137,
0.0033633613,
0.0070312023,
0.0476313308,
0.002067067,
0.0202400349,
-0.0014537107,
-0.0510548204,
-0.0076561756,
-0.0051779724,
0.0703148544,
0.0526437908,
0.0178938024,
0.0366940498,
-0.0481174514,
0.0130925216,
0.013819742,
0.0105954735,
-0.0341193676,
-0.0036915117,
-0.0009650932,
2.578e-7,
-0.0057628765,
-0.0746558011,
0.0461440235,
0.0822216645,
-0.0145524452,
0.0041377023,
0.0562361628,
0.0046210666,
-0.0005898122,
0.0348845609,
0.0153787658,
0.0164487194,
-0.0321146064,
-0.0479113534,
-0.0062686601,
-0.0941433832,
-0.0080434503,
-0.0202364791,
0.0123861264,
-0.0128762126,
0.0277642924,
-0.0062981909,
0.0064132777,
-0.0102737732,
0.0110198185,
-0.0255068056,
0.0253713261,
0.0324476957,
-0.000134815,
0.0121600451,
0.0364016481,
0.0265592113,
0.0018390887,
-0.0028021049,
0.0391209386,
0.0105131194,
0.0352463201,
0.0235295538,
0.036208313,
0.0570459627,
-0.0251670554,
-0.0683957636,
0.0109344181,
0.0476664156,
0.0841644928,
0.019945085,
-0.0209381096,
0.0180933755,
-0.0202159062,
-0.0510827079,
0.0495385192,
-0.0088841096,
-0.0281704087,
-0.0128484238,
0.0110996533,
0.0128068579,
-0.0475541241,
0.013757105,
-0.0412774496,
0.0163127501,
0.0061622537,
-0.0163338594,
0.0377813168,
0.0052271299,
-0.010820481,
-0.0289864801,
-0.0199938435,
2.187304328e-34,
0.0350503214,
-0.0254051518,
0.1073879972,
-0.0079616774,
0.0465694368,
-0.0434268154,
0.0130778896,
-0.0114082275,
0.0693490878,
-0.04212825,
-0.010316344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15508v1 | The Road to Quality is Paved with Good Revisions: A Detailed Evaluation Methodology for Revision Policies in Incremental Sequence Labelling | 2023-07-28T12:08:15 | 2023-07-28T12:08:15 | Brielen Madureira, Patrick Kahardipraja, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incremental dialogue model components produce a sequence of output prefixes
based on incoming input. Mistakes can occur due to local ambiguities or to
wrong hypotheses, making the ability to revise past outputs a desirable
property that can be governed by a policy. In this work, we formalise and
characterise edits and revisions in incremental sequence labelling and propose
metrics to evaluate revision policies. We then apply our methodology to profile
the incremental behaviour of three Transformer-based encoders in various tasks,
paving the road for better revision policies. | [
0.0310369618,
0.0646345541,
0.0031769767,
-0.0113313217,
-0.0232562739,
0.0164478049,
-0.0026212779,
-0.0200516488,
-0.0864298046,
-0.0309289191,
-0.0035801218,
-0.0100848991,
0.0333389118,
0.0723402873,
0.0174610913,
-0.0495526828,
0.0651779547,
-0.0011392677,
0.0197293535,
0.0210076682,
-0.0125976512,
-0.0584786832,
-0.0233241674,
0.0597326569,
0.0117639685,
-0.0076879594,
-0.0602777712,
-0.0283095557,
0.0153574366,
-0.013068039,
-0.0145650869,
0.0750822797,
-0.0047615608,
0.0784606189,
0.0000017619,
-0.0438508391,
-0.0222066566,
-0.0030954902,
-0.0336249545,
-0.0031845621,
-0.0315286741,
-0.0237394851,
-0.0531516336,
0.0066804383,
-0.011824891,
-0.0236030165,
0.093122907,
0.0186206792,
0.1079134122,
0.0678315088,
0.004712719,
-0.0327913575,
0.020979017,
-0.0225734394,
0.0067528305,
0.0105651952,
0.019358376,
0.0039769262,
-0.0151839722,
-0.0135948695,
-0.0300369095,
0.0437925048,
0.0583317354,
-0.0648090914,
-0.0006808559,
-0.0081926845,
0.0148617243,
-0.0599180236,
-0.0287019536,
0.0075721312,
-0.0069372961,
0.0248250682,
-0.0257582888,
-0.0234710295,
-0.0222217403,
-0.0676830932,
-0.0356247351,
0.0283985548,
-0.0126715833,
-0.022443613,
-0.058955811,
-0.0018882598,
-0.0014686264,
-0.0412667543,
-0.0042602518,
0.0403914899,
0.0336797573,
-0.0156791136,
-0.0521671437,
-0.0100802733,
0.0443432443,
-0.0860318914,
0.0481270403,
0.0511710644,
-0.0577482283,
0.007419012,
-0.0167709421,
-0.0121029494,
-0.0108251963,
-0.0191952288,
-0.001602667,
0.0416911021,
0.0140652359,
-0.0005272715,
0.024241183,
0.1117466316,
-0.0056872368,
0.0578030236,
-0.0283708852,
0.0073042074,
-0.033282917,
-0.0363674648,
-0.0375763476,
0.0288113449,
-0.014228628,
-0.0171920694,
-0.0423266403,
0.056664329,
0.0066729486,
0.0560928062,
0.0120195616,
-0.037319757,
-0.0566704087,
0.0046970122,
-0.0181559697,
0.0181199387,
0.0108295614,
-0.0186659712,
0.048095677,
-0.0340055227,
-0.0436187796,
-0.0069944649,
-0.0104563059,
-0.0026036392,
-0.0477079637,
0.0676829815,
-0.0324575342,
-0.0347795598,
0.0322038941,
-0.0371553637,
0.0065201093,
0.0064420062,
0.0034624133,
-0.0202643424,
-0.0043598642,
-0.0025932186,
-0.0066562435,
-0.0586566888,
0.0058756652,
0.0081108259,
0.0342007279,
0.0561613552,
-0.0349998921,
-0.0107298577,
0.0272183679,
0.0084642237,
0.0080555901,
0.0180313177,
0.0686320662,
-0.0046614925,
0.0484427623,
-0.0181111265,
0.0413115732,
0.0405025184,
-0.0360613726,
-0.0230955314,
-0.023174502,
-0.0191039965,
0.0585355982,
0.036878664,
0.0085745538,
0.0361065716,
-0.0445459634,
-0.0270232689,
0.0563267022,
-0.0091143483,
0.0181569215,
-0.0427800827,
0.0137825245,
-0.0053091259,
-0.0148687446,
0.0298107937,
0.0244859532,
0.058085978,
0.0487441123,
0.0164677706,
0.0437880009,
-0.0136244884,
0.0002827406,
-0.0699296072,
-0.0084128119,
0.0312282778,
-0.0091247568,
-0.0507398956,
0.0175039023,
0.0568356812,
-0.0522710532,
0.0435608029,
-0.0190286953,
-0.0591474734,
-0.0164636485,
-0.052135285,
-0.024390053,
0.0383512639,
0.0768378079,
0.0013607126,
-0.0551101007,
-0.0209875237,
-0.0574046411,
0.0393055491,
0.0190740153,
-0.0525686033,
0.0121839894,
-0.0309154429,
-0.0727433637,
0.0126044014,
0.0026214039,
0.0267537031,
-0.0063357246,
-0.0326596834,
0.0115650697,
0.0352140591,
0.0133662615,
0.0282518957,
0.0023482773,
-0.0111016417,
0.0139143486,
0.0077429856,
0.044629544,
0.0262430795,
-0.0294624064,
0.0208554361,
0.0373878367,
0.0218161102,
-0.017287327,
0.0282004271,
-0.030627707,
-0.0462457202,
0.0327793993,
0.0138032427,
-0.0163853746,
-0.0263481401,
-0.0445237048,
-0.0524352267,
-0.0456052572,
-0.082466349,
-0.0186118484,
-0.0231247824,
0.0475781411,
-0.0084853051,
-0.0279565938,
-0.0237835422,
-0.0094184186,
-0.0328355245,
0.015772488,
0.0304652173,
0.0075895544,
0.0152871162,
-0.0548934527,
-0.0255392306,
0.0708638132,
-0.0213270783,
-0.0320630707,
0.0270542223,
-0.0066768476,
-0.0166140031,
-0.0287854206,
-0.0179771911,
-0.0165651422,
-0.0187929738,
0.0259516668,
-0.0030199252,
0.0094679007,
0.0140667716,
-0.0466948971,
0.0045275684,
-0.0278437752,
0.0098468931,
0.0129336128,
0.0364048257,
0.0568001345,
-0.0834645405,
-0.0170155,
-0.0181297064,
0.0292680468,
0.0422893465,
-0.0012596581,
-0.0485356078,
-0.1150558144,
-0.0646326169,
-0.032267116,
-0.0243394412,
-0.0004130531,
-0.0295549296,
0.0389722139,
0.0531344935,
0.029837355,
0.0126400357,
0.027026223,
0.0461706631,
0.0369599424,
-0.0279106013,
-0.0009552097,
-0.0042869779,
-0.0350346416,
-0.0311536808,
-0.0175070986,
0.0172858555,
0.0239509791,
0.0766064674,
-0.0308911894,
0.0397948809,
-0.0452730507,
0.0102055259,
0.0031203283,
-0.0281272586,
-0.0306354426,
-0.0738679096,
-0.0522489138,
0.0495935418,
0.0026733545,
-0.0551420413,
0.0709265396,
-0.0296614859,
-0.0049892198,
-0.0418707244,
0.0233796723,
0.0131550143,
0.0681769252,
0.0279689748,
-0.0072710449,
0.0433429964,
-0.0475462452,
-0.0345852003,
0.0568739772,
0.0217325892,
-0.0263397712,
0.0417173766,
-0.0652448386,
-0.0131364213,
-0.01627874,
-0.0281833168,
-0.0468579344,
0.0243354309,
0.0129574966,
0.0303771924,
0.0064039454,
-0.0158116929,
-0.0587119535,
0.0494513214,
0.0196752977,
0.0785454363,
-0.0010486274,
0.00129517,
-0.0400606953,
0.009011168,
0.001964258,
0.0253939051,
0.0289418977,
-0.0045291991,
0.0342774838,
0.0364284776,
0.0148624415,
-0.0005314123,
-0.0059727198,
-0.0031061934,
0.0001949742,
-0.0586981513,
0.0126825646,
0.0299833734,
0.016139064,
-0.0491775572,
-0.0431089625,
0.0871293247,
0.0292244293,
-0.0475583784,
0.0138577521,
0.0005025138,
0.0238687992,
0.0342635587,
0.0023969419,
-0.0772487074,
-0.0005144901,
0.027062593,
0.042536661,
-0.0171531104,
0.0102258129,
-0.0222628564,
-0.078194961,
0.0386794284,
0.0118836779,
-0.0442828834,
-0.0177110024,
-0.0432889163,
0.0017299937,
0.0025518038,
0.0237439461,
0.0512677282,
0.0268212371,
-0.0051118336,
0.0408267006,
-0.0049405587,
-0.0546710491,
-0.0401346833,
0.0145640261,
0.0237271115,
0.0652509704,
-0.016512176,
0.0290012192,
-0.0341119245,
0.042569194,
-0.0070254127,
0.0146320183,
-0.0083589433,
0.0279284567,
0.0085072182,
-0.0152354641,
-0.0085526416,
-0.0139839565,
0.0167389717,
-0.0522320345,
-0.0173101891,
0.0249261353,
-0.0541561805,
0.0306650903,
-0.0051796259,
-0.0156230386,
0.0006743406,
0.0103084985,
0.059104301,
-0.0172000192,
-0.0094775427,
-0.056244567,
0.0373316295,
-0.0144969821,
0.0033654252,
-0.034300074,
-0.0180290639,
-0.0676583648,
-0.0580013879,
-0.0334703699,
-0.0203863867,
0.0156907644,
0.0116002774,
-0.0542099141,
0.0394637696,
0.0095516052,
-0.0707317591,
-0.0635382384,
0.0371145681,
0.0042199218,
-0.0716952458,
0.0000760537,
0.033803001,
0.0529698022,
-0.0473320447,
0.0112572806,
-0.0511916615,
-0.0429738984,
0.0399773084,
0.0761015192,
0.0294790044,
0.0254046172,
0.0006347321,
-0.0426822267,
-0.0010058543,
0.0169579964,
0.0209204983,
0.0332929343,
0.0250359103,
-0.0247594453,
-0.049557548,
-0.0008983304,
-0.0379106551,
-0.0015174813,
-0.0086884778,
0.0521481261,
-0.0109657934,
-0.0863138735,
0.0077291294,
-0.029914882,
0.0628522635,
0.0065082377,
0.01340329,
-0.001568937,
0.0700278208,
-0.0068680383,
0.001674888,
-0.0349539146,
0.0215550046,
-0.0302235801,
-0.0108005702,
0.0003708667,
0.071395725,
-0.030276686,
0.0017479472,
-0.0184231605,
0.0040139696,
-0.011730507,
0.0168783013,
-0.0097964797,
-0.0020221539,
-0.0154071208,
0.0216461904,
0.0428673066,
0.0345650427,
-0.0019239947,
0.053965684,
0.0469907299,
0.0306848977,
0.0056498912,
0.0617899559,
-0.0574308559,
-0.0015698617,
-0.0423701853,
-0.0094837118,
0.0221326668,
0.0621595867,
0.0608188547,
0.0017915848,
0.0059432006,
-0.0210457537,
0.0442385115,
0.009924789,
-0.0567146316,
0.0131394304,
0.0094728163,
-0.000505199,
-0.0017587387,
0.0403221138,
-0.047838483,
0.0460495166,
-0.0508713163,
-0.0091622956,
-0.043446172,
-0.0448751971,
-0.0289114509,
-0.0221984182,
-0.0064330022,
-0.0405340455,
-0.018777268,
-0.0008359029,
0.0204252061,
0.0276229363,
0.043619629,
-0.0012259256,
0.0588463172,
0.0158981103,
-0.0068015731,
-0.0569284968,
0.020972291,
-0.0254873224,
-0.015049953,
-0.0067544444,
-0.0129588488,
-5.381366486e-33,
-0.0657091364,
-0.0425933562,
0.0195199531,
0.0230734069,
-0.0357573666,
-0.0233550873,
-0.0602479428,
-0.0008472222,
0.0618353821,
-0.014464925,
0.0168049932,
0.0154478671,
0.0191618782,
-0.0082091512,
0.0322542079,
-0.0210864842,
0.0874889046,
0.0075900587,
-0.0561133623,
0.0206852928,
0.0516835563,
0.0056071621,
0.094589904,
-0.032570336,
0.0165920593,
0.0551843047,
-0.0126073211,
0.0089121265,
-0.0283351932,
0.060725078,
0.01566061,
0.0006469928,
-0.0013095774,
-0.1027768254,
-0.0403267257,
0.0025703206,
-0.0285449121,
-0.0126850018,
-0.0384154394,
0.0664861426,
0.0029089509,
-0.054196123,
0.0451303534,
-0.0004129893,
-0.0691571757,
-0.0083870739,
0.0172172729,
-0.0132530099,
-0.0416275486,
-0.0225248765,
-0.0328033715,
0.0314186625,
-0.0055213142,
-0.0344998017,
-0.0113484636,
0.0472318716,
0.0116702933,
-0.056462951,
-0.0934956372,
0.0202972852,
0.0410589315,
0.0385273546,
0.0448537841,
0.0301932599,
0.0220931396,
0.035290204,
0.0079273237,
0.0070601054,
0.0161539838,
0.023053471,
-0.0087949689,
-0.008287889,
0.0743951127,
-0.011489246,
0.0339392126,
0.0132048773,
0.0030800409,
0.032043457,
-0.0569363199,
0.0711781904,
0.0094007617,
0.027954923,
0.0300816949,
0.0042474377,
-0.0513457172,
0.0057646162,
0.0034336126,
-0.0321107171,
0.0347146243,
0.0077083977,
0.000446634,
0.0256983712,
0.061085958,
0.0122212274,
-0.0012340304,
0.0035183004,
-0.0345437936,
0.0500267521,
-0.0220002308,
-0.020026058,
-0.0344189294,
0.0089318128,
0.0656972229,
0.0316708051,
0.0240025632,
-0.039883852,
-0.0011550565,
0.0558044501,
-0.0468987562,
0.014856237,
0.0104488628,
0.022328347,
-0.0171449948,
0.0082616434,
0.0272054262,
0.0022088527,
-0.0313940346,
0.0680386499,
-0.033615496,
-0.0401385576,
-0.0445933118,
0.040816199,
0.0388247073,
0.0424383134,
-0.0242187083,
0.0198972896,
-0.0346033312,
0.0420188718,
-0.0233470257,
-0.0261630397,
-0.0132599026,
0.0387739204,
2.504e-7,
0.0160276499,
0.0474894643,
0.0974851474,
-0.0153959859,
0.0502338484,
0.0144581767,
-0.0214881916,
0.0136143016,
0.0267346539,
-0.0217424668,
0.0061500217,
-0.0466114096,
0.0214235317,
0.0190532301,
-0.0320827551,
-0.0580314323,
-0.1187939942,
0.0097167306,
-0.0425166227,
0.0088145277,
0.0615382977,
0.0748984963,
-0.0015157993,
0.0353977121,
0.0008275603,
0.0086931121,
0.0320735127,
0.0386660919,
0.0256871078,
0.0211012922,
0.0176793337,
-0.010045344,
0.0113264415,
0.0116015822,
-0.0244191792,
-0.0170214605,
0.0109857731,
0.0491929166,
-0.0281134937,
-0.0361406319,
-0.0107148858,
0.0587516949,
0.0019906058,
-0.0193020608,
0.0259433948,
-0.0223663449,
-0.0326568559,
0.0241943002,
-0.0270084646,
-0.0050617182,
0.0311320927,
-0.0118001746,
-0.0142492224,
0.0279683229,
0.0137503901,
0.0771022961,
-0.0046994938,
-0.0505487658,
-0.0008001346,
-0.0468260013,
-0.0372734405,
-0.0424722359,
-0.0668335631,
-0.0323300324,
-0.0047849808,
-0.0101641063,
-0.043962989,
2.215728332e-34,
0.018938126,
-0.0272228159,
0.0094115622,
0.0230770316,
0.0221754331,
-0.0089451354,
0.0449316874,
0.039451167,
0.0026660666,
-0.0624625161,
-0.0413766839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15504v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15504v2 | Exploring Format Consistency for Instruction Tuning | 2023-07-28T12:00:13 | 2024-01-08T13:26:37 | Shihao Liang, Runchu Tian, Kunlun Zhu, Yujia Qin, Huadong Wang, Xin Cong, Zhiyuan Liu, Xiaojiang Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction tuning has emerged as a promising approach to enhancing large
language models in following human instructions. It is shown that increasing
the diversity and number of instructions in the training data can consistently
enhance generalization performance, which facilitates a recent endeavor to
collect various instructions and integrate existing instruction tuning datasets
into larger collections. However, different users have their unique ways of
expressing instructions, and there often exist variations across different
datasets in the instruction styles and formats, i.e., format inconsistency. In
this work, we propose a framework named Unified Instruction Tuning (UIT), which
calls OpenAI APIs for automatic format transfer among different instruction
tuning datasets such as PromptSource, FLAN and CrossFit. With the framework, we
(1) demonstrate the necessity of maintaining format consistency in instruction
tuning; (2) improve the generalization performance on unseen instructions on
T5-LM-xl; (3) provide a novel perplexity-based denoising method to reduce the
noise of automatic format transfer to make the UIT framework more practical and
a smaller offline model based on GPT-J that achieves comparable format transfer
capability to OpenAI APIs to reduce costs in practice. Further analysis
regarding variations of targeted formats and other effects is intended. | [
0.0174457673,
0.0456142761,
-0.0152937584,
0.0087651983,
-0.0208002385,
0.0211354028,
0.007192445,
0.0270003453,
-0.0405017324,
-0.0081822369,
-0.0741841868,
-0.0153273614,
0.0311062038,
-0.0014701074,
-0.0022763102,
-0.0760235488,
0.0704457089,
-0.0312428176,
-0.0020034711,
0.02600432,
-0.0080750538,
0.0121794855,
-0.0256345812,
0.053278774,
0.0130804982,
-0.0107485866,
-0.0190170668,
0.0217109378,
0.0047309282,
-0.0070227208,
0.0014141815,
0.0696225762,
0.0246107541,
0.0016280258,
0.0000021833,
-0.0167084653,
0.0013799559,
-0.0126967635,
-0.0251396094,
0.0438311994,
0.0309132412,
-0.0242106505,
-0.0077032903,
0.0127342585,
-0.0007555511,
-0.0249267258,
0.0669233054,
-0.0017082181,
0.0703748912,
0.1047509834,
0.003623246,
-0.0154092954,
0.004964082,
-0.0043412386,
0.0045442628,
-0.0165653769,
0.0005281502,
0.0094729792,
0.0089618405,
0.0210799873,
-0.0152773131,
0.0076994775,
0.0286119953,
0.0227220133,
-0.0315051377,
0.0004726591,
-0.0172010548,
-0.0041801734,
-0.0603883266,
0.0777386501,
0.0059712571,
0.000481507,
-0.0118304379,
0.0055950335,
0.0051570092,
-0.0020134992,
-0.0319259353,
0.0421802998,
0.0076302444,
0.0177931655,
-0.0013789397,
-0.0293398388,
0.0248238724,
-0.0162770525,
-0.0243158061,
0.0575943738,
0.0122336959,
-0.0273370892,
-0.0100059751,
-0.0229270998,
-0.0752813667,
-0.0420222506,
0.0382524431,
0.0396874808,
-0.0530153513,
-0.011701325,
-0.1068627015,
-0.037729457,
0.0117234373,
0.0107926102,
0.1135543808,
0.0857018456,
-0.0442865267,
-0.027490247,
-0.0178256277,
0.0688347518,
-0.0289865285,
0.0583076887,
-0.0523028895,
0.0281649549,
-0.0752703696,
0.0285036135,
-0.0107701365,
0.0256684627,
-0.0701888204,
-0.014664473,
-0.0474795848,
0.0457856432,
0.0108663328,
-0.0305083599,
0.0518127121,
-0.0294139627,
-0.0755754039,
-0.0056827599,
0.0049538855,
0.0245133545,
-0.0298154224,
0.0234882999,
0.0162912831,
-0.0594360791,
-0.0209550653,
0.0181612093,
0.0117521742,
-0.0213747509,
0.0104492679,
0.0173785891,
-0.0309778806,
0.0029980841,
-0.0626927316,
-0.0045540533,
0.009507644,
-0.0275674872,
-0.0001126774,
-0.0529792048,
0.0217541866,
-0.0188026577,
-0.006232298,
-0.0331224799,
-0.011759528,
0.0390523709,
-0.0211210996,
0.0399367027,
-0.0111834491,
0.0316257961,
0.0395083465,
-0.0122511499,
0.0262894463,
0.0283796154,
0.0269543454,
-0.0171781834,
0.0223894734,
-0.0258318,
-0.0243785251,
0.0493275821,
0.015499345,
-0.0020083124,
-0.0390276015,
-0.0202502608,
0.060112372,
-0.0010505207,
0.0632459521,
0.0592585877,
-0.0257719122,
-0.0099734617,
0.0371936485,
0.0242278352,
0.0275702141,
-0.0288916044,
0.0887433141,
0.0287197493,
-0.0150428461,
0.0557412244,
-0.0459391326,
-0.0165117197,
-0.00221547,
0.0212683789,
0.017270809,
0.0108717717,
-0.0541156866,
-0.0172319617,
-0.0137783941,
-0.0322530307,
-0.0091090323,
-0.0161642265,
0.0241269395,
0.0039961906,
-0.0676191822,
0.0367270596,
0.0638519526,
-0.0443810113,
-0.0255778432,
-0.056977395,
0.0047903662,
0.0565536767,
0.0107813478,
-0.0012988894,
-0.0160386488,
0.0249109343,
0.0233689416,
0.0055482537,
0.033271648,
-0.0069113825,
0.0475755371,
-0.1062778383,
-0.0243291128,
0.0106478836,
0.0097396765,
0.0246795248,
0.0308003612,
-0.0068308399,
0.0145799275,
0.0004144618,
-0.0267090462,
0.0588834211,
-0.0026125708,
-0.035238266,
0.0048700054,
0.011049984,
0.0347278267,
0.0171539411,
-0.013755356,
-0.0047685462,
0.0177140404,
-0.0167247131,
0.0710869059,
-0.0469184443,
-0.0794540197,
0.0104376338,
0.0228032935,
0.0094559826,
-0.0062039131,
0.0460735522,
-0.0227183048,
-0.0417621061,
-0.0137765361,
-0.0178667679,
0.0429017097,
-0.0146387359,
0.0132671716,
0.0331380256,
0.0138384551,
-0.0241910405,
0.0372892134,
-0.0433505066,
-0.0349781327,
0.0666201487,
0.0164562408,
-0.0044984263,
-0.044320032,
0.008777136,
-0.0072963783,
-0.0271255299,
-0.0233819969,
-0.0037476073,
0.0523201898,
-0.0184902623,
-0.042295333,
-0.0977288038,
0.0292542763,
-0.0312637761,
0.0108702211,
0.0567410775,
0.0293220654,
-0.0071876273,
-0.0203773156,
-0.001137117,
-0.0112542752,
-0.0259039421,
0.0132257985,
0.0021091159,
0.0298508033,
-0.0453504957,
-0.0305501763,
-0.030137822,
-0.0080642682,
-0.0124358432,
-0.0375278704,
0.0011506267,
-0.0765896887,
0.0368779227,
-0.0025648118,
0.0294784121,
0.0127569837,
-0.0353299901,
0.0326690935,
-0.0057593351,
0.0398162641,
0.0904915035,
-0.0277681686,
0.0264744703,
0.0468794629,
-0.016614873,
-0.0490377322,
0.022395324,
-0.0209638812,
-0.0448405482,
0.0024625917,
-0.0637496635,
0.0128680449,
0.0380578302,
0.0239194781,
0.0626681671,
-0.1055203006,
-0.0579317175,
-0.0074271848,
-0.0294192266,
0.0094111757,
0.0033571604,
-0.0395117179,
0.0036336416,
-0.0266353451,
-0.0791093931,
0.0429191627,
-0.019222999,
-0.0002194855,
-0.0443480574,
-0.0025059506,
0.0045302203,
0.0143246586,
-0.0167079233,
0.0001341733,
-0.0009917928,
-0.0395089239,
-0.0407333747,
0.0085505759,
0.0041195652,
-0.0007437081,
0.0375268608,
-0.0869430304,
-0.0103796003,
0.0073760506,
-0.003035072,
-0.01423865,
-0.0067118057,
0.0214276407,
0.0030093791,
0.0262547284,
-0.0454380661,
-0.0407490805,
-0.0048479391,
0.0062200967,
0.065765731,
-0.0276420396,
0.009498179,
-0.0357232243,
-0.0091149164,
0.0412194878,
-0.0036462056,
-0.0484485961,
-0.0316131748,
0.0243846569,
0.0030926433,
0.0148240933,
-0.0365342945,
-0.0312381834,
0.021702446,
0.0263271723,
-0.0220897626,
-0.0308559183,
0.1131960973,
0.1078589261,
-0.027247129,
-0.0205093827,
0.111371085,
0.043689087,
-0.0575968325,
0.0085811168,
0.0158114266,
0.0384922922,
-0.0028243053,
0.0169093963,
-0.0768111199,
-0.0364958718,
-0.002426299,
0.0714263469,
0.0166397169,
0.018814303,
-0.0039976076,
-0.0828151628,
0.0247974228,
0.0340472199,
-0.0671851262,
-0.0781314969,
-0.0267074779,
0.0037058319,
0.0101884725,
0.0842747018,
0.0080442112,
-0.0211739298,
0.0133787803,
0.0478023291,
-0.0064435471,
-0.0872181877,
0.0087202536,
-0.0107213715,
0.081964463,
0.080092594,
-0.0361606739,
0.0300766509,
-0.0745771825,
0.0150428461,
0.0101059545,
0.0338206179,
-0.0548451245,
0.0414976738,
0.0159223601,
-0.0012613849,
-0.0149464635,
0.0562612116,
-0.0399317667,
-0.0112609165,
0.0019109112,
0.0447857976,
-0.0325078592,
0.0212530382,
-0.0085175289,
-0.025129145,
0.0179906208,
0.0377416611,
0.0447772369,
-0.0483723842,
0.000819938,
-0.0148211168,
0.0055479426,
-0.0897378251,
0.0012387679,
0.0118452599,
-0.060239587,
-0.0420306064,
-0.0434043631,
-0.037204355,
0.0260036923,
0.0284625683,
0.0350231528,
-0.0327510126,
0.0157239288,
0.0196910892,
-0.0010255766,
0.0287258569,
-0.0119514167,
0.0019166435,
-0.1211893111,
-0.0907530114,
-0.009798076,
0.0071590501,
0.0288278423,
0.0167247634,
-0.0611198656,
-0.0502257422,
0.0455937907,
0.0754944384,
0.017079819,
0.0592504069,
0.0128303375,
-0.0189170633,
-0.0328627303,
0.0102570215,
-0.0329604819,
0.0319883488,
0.0294086691,
-0.0266340189,
0.0192117989,
0.0109628895,
-0.0366072506,
0.0325770937,
0.0114395339,
0.0259374212,
-0.0514254868,
-0.0073143924,
0.0482408442,
0.0215428472,
0.0262931287,
0.0199303962,
0.0017741615,
-0.0078458413,
0.015448886,
-0.0188533999,
0.0218171608,
-0.0529064909,
0.0114745833,
0.0210876055,
0.0094308555,
0.0016063796,
-0.01757963,
-0.0203159209,
0.0081571704,
-0.0736365095,
0.0254408978,
-0.0148953414,
0.0766022205,
-0.0099641755,
0.0313771889,
-0.0231492314,
0.0377026461,
-0.0009098299,
0.0472557172,
0.0105043445,
0.0985335857,
-0.0033953558,
0.0448235683,
-0.0237025246,
0.0423450172,
-0.0183780901,
-0.0124021294,
-0.0380739085,
-0.0266676378,
0.0250782445,
-0.0192268174,
0.0243069027,
0.0099354535,
0.0173034929,
-0.0360631421,
0.0424211286,
0.0025332964,
0.0045138719,
-0.0153826587,
0.0148686506,
0.0052392166,
-0.0375761688,
0.1001879424,
-0.0388054848,
0.0406303853,
-0.0148811964,
0.0190114249,
-0.0492471121,
-0.0290482827,
0.0302253943,
0.0532672293,
-0.0571583025,
-0.0099045886,
0.0270361714,
-0.048872672,
-0.0487496033,
0.0226983503,
0.0194028746,
0.0082589667,
0.0651676506,
0.0050121956,
-0.0466537997,
-0.0584039912,
-0.0059189149,
-0.0226150155,
0.0062591955,
-0.0385448635,
-0.0291654933,
-6.472570177e-33,
-0.0450280644,
0.0300913658,
-0.004669074,
-0.0122830207,
0.0080869747,
-0.0130355507,
-0.0159770194,
0.0053747869,
-0.0187392142,
-0.0249387827,
-0.0065624844,
-0.0031671505,
0.0328159407,
0.0031042581,
0.0327097625,
0.0124619659,
0.027648313,
-0.0530002154,
-0.0384781957,
0.0213257074,
0.0207689237,
-0.0047319131,
0.0427945033,
-0.0552622043,
0.0170552656,
0.0129681891,
-0.0216499902,
0.0058615338,
-0.0100107603,
0.0714248344,
0.0125918649,
0.0200641546,
-0.008991112,
-0.0315384902,
-0.0418053642,
0.0203793962,
-0.0178312249,
-0.0399660133,
0.034833461,
0.0138703203,
-0.045821216,
-0.0610455088,
0.0055517242,
-0.0249528047,
-0.0587366819,
0.0107519561,
0.0122103216,
-0.004322696,
0.0016446472,
0.0602744371,
-0.0343588032,
0.0064760218,
-0.0045431852,
-0.0560300425,
0.0211657379,
0.0335659944,
-0.0241176952,
-0.0533400029,
-0.0290465541,
0.0379684046,
0.0515998676,
0.0687723607,
0.0346885659,
0.025851436,
-0.0052365977,
-0.0089801857,
0.0163553897,
-0.0170955174,
0.0083515923,
0.0051712808,
0.0273022503,
0.041837059,
-0.0030387372,
-0.048119463,
0.0274638776,
-0.0200379435,
-0.0303937197,
0.0303977542,
0.0177989863,
0.0181397423,
-0.0115188826,
0.0183705986,
-0.0386327356,
-0.0030229099,
0.0230205636,
-0.012589871,
-0.0289210975,
-0.0270518605,
0.0564668663,
0.0015646095,
-0.0006856892,
-0.0359693952,
0.0539726391,
0.0074876058,
0.0346040763,
-0.0438119471,
-0.018757131,
0.0319707617,
-0.0083340164,
-0.0328751504,
-0.0987191051,
-0.0864633769,
0.0637844056,
0.0031943924,
0.0474282987,
-0.0005624836,
0.0083264019,
0.0436946154,
-0.0339872651,
0.0016282666,
0.0102197565,
0.0000349797,
0.017930096,
-0.0185388401,
0.0335625224,
0.0217721146,
-0.0251489673,
0.0610055961,
-0.0189734474,
-0.0520063117,
-0.030492587,
-0.0584020838,
0.0267218221,
0.0224933363,
-0.0361488797,
-0.0030055291,
-0.0275370795,
-0.0067177541,
-0.0204214379,
0.0046818079,
-0.0421692245,
0.0501257591,
2.832e-7,
0.0319264121,
0.0286954977,
0.0328031667,
0.0336645283,
-0.0154182026,
-0.0152684208,
-0.0033346696,
-0.0007208095,
0.0013994643,
-0.0165818706,
0.0431204699,
0.030661514,
0.0306317396,
-0.0331548564,
-0.0302329361,
0.0038524962,
-0.0446661636,
0.0520981736,
-0.0643688515,
0.0156290624,
0.003867534,
0.0717380121,
-0.0198703166,
0.0072336937,
0.0174095593,
0.05793548,
0.010921957,
-0.0313025638,
0.0247412473,
0.0091592204,
0.0037527892,
-0.0106919371,
-0.0421671122,
0.0332245827,
-0.0306357872,
-0.0015802125,
-0.0071102888,
0.1097508818,
-0.0492456444,
-0.0238080323,
0.0147713562,
0.0182988346,
-0.0260631647,
-0.0372537747,
0.0307191405,
0.0023032611,
0.0095551619,
0.0066382708,
0.0033069225,
0.0246412624,
-0.0046939338,
-0.0159151368,
0.0211060233,
0.0252177007,
0.0406550318,
0.0176848173,
-0.0318222567,
-0.031923458,
-0.006502239,
0.0217036121,
-0.0354975201,
-0.0219822917,
-0.0698854774,
-0.0279614907,
0.0256933197,
-0.0124373566,
0.005884707,
2.754088673e-34,
-0.018601099,
-0.0188178495,
0.0733362064,
0.0306868963,
0.0104512749,
-0.003737763,
-0.0220024418,
0.0616509803,
0.0231638364,
-0.0937279612,
-0.0415792949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15494v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15494v2 | ETHER: Aligning Emergent Communication for Hindsight Experience Replay | 2023-07-28T11:42:31 | 2023-12-17T10:30:11 | Kevin Denamganaï, Daniel Hernandez, Ozan Vardal, Sondess Missaoui, James Alfred Walker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Natural language instruction following is paramount to enable collaboration
between artificial agents and human beings. Natural language-conditioned
reinforcement learning (RL) agents have shown how natural languages'
properties, such as compositionality, can provide a strong inductive bias to
learn complex policies. Previous architectures like HIGhER combine the benefit
of language-conditioning with Hindsight Experience Replay (HER) to deal with
sparse rewards environments. Yet, like HER, HIGhER relies on an oracle
predicate function to provide a feedback signal highlighting which linguistic
description is valid for which state. This reliance on an oracle limits its
application. Additionally, HIGhER only leverages the linguistic information
contained in successful RL trajectories, thus hurting its final performance and
data-efficiency. Without early successful trajectories, HIGhER is no better
than DQN upon which it is built. In this paper, we propose the Emergent Textual
Hindsight Experience Replay (ETHER) agent, which builds on HIGhER and addresses
both of its limitations by means of (i) a discriminative visual referential
game, commonly studied in the subfield of Emergent Communication (EC), used
here as an unsupervised auxiliary task and (ii) a semantic grounding scheme to
align the emergent language with the natural language of the
instruction-following benchmark. We show that the referential game's agents
make an artificial language emerge that is aligned with the natural-like
language used to describe goals in the BabyAI benchmark and that it is
expressive enough so as to also describe unsuccessful RL trajectories and thus
provide feedback to the RL agent to leverage the linguistic, structured
information contained in all trajectories. Our work shows that EC is a viable
unsupervised auxiliary task for RL and provides missing pieces to make HER more
widely applicable. | [
0.0607957356,
0.0712470487,
-0.0176446252,
-0.0060642622,
-0.0309841894,
0.0013584183,
-0.0435495451,
0.0000724835,
0.0276347306,
-0.0347921923,
-0.0332474858,
0.0233282652,
-0.0170283709,
0.0685014129,
0.0136560984,
-0.057526879,
0.0514276288,
-0.0076440019,
0.0284117777,
0.0175331719,
0.0062464834,
-0.0255547073,
-0.0281228609,
0.0540239587,
-0.0176356882,
0.0185168516,
-0.0621853024,
-0.0297342706,
0.0267639216,
-0.0463791825,
-0.0156349726,
-0.0191447772,
0.0573989451,
0.0055258656,
0.0000020815,
-0.0271617603,
0.0059727938,
-0.0416150577,
-0.0162114277,
-0.0668859184,
0.0390572734,
0.0282603297,
-0.0109107429,
-0.0159903672,
-0.0547960587,
-0.0266876742,
0.0608915016,
0.0632529557,
0.0583877042,
0.0626606867,
0.0038764919,
-0.0148539497,
0.0119737862,
0.0125391986,
0.0109028667,
-0.0642528459,
0.0054863598,
-0.0148495305,
0.0061088153,
-0.0054868474,
-0.0208544135,
0.0025171828,
0.0272056218,
-0.0045124171,
-0.0131451841,
0.071818158,
0.0578035191,
-0.0148762222,
-0.0425519645,
0.034140341,
0.0196110513,
-0.0043529659,
-0.0025667639,
-0.0004658224,
0.0116717704,
-0.0157379378,
-0.0004768882,
0.0278112032,
-0.0162063558,
0.036860086,
0.0327648185,
0.0222790539,
-0.0010872991,
-0.001805351,
0.0068493877,
0.0607078746,
-0.0297979861,
-0.0193081461,
0.0208230261,
0.0247341059,
0.0444734246,
-0.0647239164,
-0.0208215993,
0.0388447829,
-0.0774165615,
0.0344420262,
-0.0150065711,
0.0157247949,
-0.0410784595,
-0.0178363696,
0.0856445432,
0.041639328,
-0.0043089045,
0.0220895633,
-0.0015201239,
0.068268694,
0.0208319575,
0.0190515555,
-0.0190255791,
0.0309960619,
-0.0560425557,
-0.0216446575,
-0.0676279441,
0.0609732755,
-0.0107389111,
-0.0258363113,
-0.0344933234,
0.0351441838,
-0.0632139146,
0.0358828232,
-0.0360073894,
0.027216807,
-0.0494394526,
0.0078357588,
-0.116139397,
-0.0122775445,
-0.0477694459,
0.0122216335,
0.0281370487,
-0.0180397946,
-0.0073873741,
0.0190430656,
-0.0069946637,
0.0161030181,
-0.0197828393,
0.0999002978,
-0.0218909327,
-0.0179951005,
-0.0677598864,
-0.0243241787,
0.0114949923,
-0.0487519875,
0.03806087,
-0.0266140103,
0.0142326336,
-0.0391590782,
-0.0207261853,
-0.0519098602,
0.0156918447,
0.0216825828,
0.0242282655,
0.1141453236,
0.0145870959,
-0.0444676131,
-0.0281905979,
-0.0057037799,
0.0070298924,
0.0662049204,
0.0494947992,
0.0314590968,
0.0050907023,
0.0464557707,
0.0086463448,
0.006484949,
0.0192564279,
0.0021844229,
-0.0432300642,
-0.0214753319,
-0.0436265878,
0.0627016053,
0.0232407022,
0.0052058049,
-0.026780691,
0.0069800462,
0.0324744582,
0.0524366163,
-0.002992616,
-0.012907438,
0.0583580062,
0.0303881429,
-0.0436523072,
0.0254365951,
-0.0467049144,
0.067494601,
-0.0231948979,
0.0011952518,
-0.0140024535,
-0.0241302997,
-0.0264853872,
-0.0685367212,
0.0413875133,
-0.0121550113,
0.0393558778,
-0.0006238867,
0.0172351729,
0.0210952647,
-0.066191718,
-0.0365639552,
0.0261946134,
-0.0293402299,
-0.0030348897,
-0.0664746165,
0.0413453914,
0.0765499547,
0.0241826456,
-0.035651464,
-0.0178132113,
0.0160859916,
-0.050740812,
0.0515895747,
0.0099438382,
-0.0266623348,
-0.0026118427,
-0.0158887394,
-0.0525837764,
-0.0195927899,
0.0017487874,
0.0551303513,
-0.0089636762,
-0.0079737082,
-0.0353627689,
0.0614828803,
-0.0378801711,
0.0371945053,
0.0121389274,
-0.0326661766,
0.0020054525,
0.0035689499,
0.0435804315,
-0.0166413952,
0.0013752081,
0.0282013062,
0.0230640508,
0.0121957352,
-0.0316164047,
0.0541678295,
-0.0602883138,
-0.0553292073,
-0.003053274,
-0.0614864826,
0.0098020937,
-0.0038593803,
-0.0110597825,
-0.0412603505,
0.0596586168,
-0.0507779308,
0.0354066491,
-0.009601281,
0.0029440904,
0.0102910455,
-0.0547485203,
-0.0104546649,
0.0662022159,
-0.0009633442,
-0.0469955057,
-0.0101495013,
0.0031484724,
-0.0226362851,
-0.0359938294,
0.0304356776,
-0.0137182241,
0.0223611929,
0.0121008428,
0.0644189492,
0.0305384509,
-0.0649897307,
-0.0330195278,
-0.046706669,
-0.0091444803,
-0.0331586748,
0.0055579152,
0.000487093,
-0.0383295193,
0.0032101101,
-0.0477244556,
-0.041882433,
0.0525115281,
0.0210924167,
0.0076541537,
0.0541137345,
0.0447191298,
0.012473641,
-0.0489444286,
0.0238229297,
-0.0232863482,
0.0085151214,
0.0350345224,
0.0016599928,
-0.0851447955,
0.0293594692,
-0.0151530011,
0.0497666821,
-0.0365988463,
0.0003154812,
0.05210495,
0.0111061474,
0.0366641507,
0.045319356,
0.0020874026,
0.0995128453,
0.0519333594,
-0.0236523692,
-0.0501083992,
0.0490647741,
-0.047143992,
-0.0417811759,
-0.0429530405,
0.0175019298,
0.0279456768,
0.0454905182,
-0.0119207967,
0.0145820398,
-0.0862041339,
0.0349614695,
-0.0058172559,
-0.0462429114,
-0.0349870659,
-0.0303904954,
-0.0233465303,
0.0226160958,
-0.0063817338,
-0.0231144913,
0.1020464599,
0.0464610867,
-0.0073563978,
-0.0184987169,
-0.0199291129,
0.0004676723,
0.066511251,
0.0186586343,
0.0046922704,
0.0298666973,
-0.0210019369,
-0.067921795,
-0.0132266274,
-0.0007750425,
0.0126807848,
0.0114637427,
-0.0610384196,
0.0076204548,
0.0274099912,
-0.0503487289,
-0.0647578612,
0.006065846,
-0.0246960167,
0.0041554207,
-0.0151970135,
-0.0038234799,
-0.0682229474,
-0.0052343882,
0.0262959544,
0.0077434648,
0.0119776241,
-0.0629659519,
-0.0347184911,
-0.0328057334,
0.0517966785,
0.0220102184,
0.0065298015,
-0.0326909646,
0.0259759072,
0.0589941703,
0.046780657,
-0.0353293344,
-0.0265243668,
0.0304127112,
0.0032707669,
-0.0449845269,
0.0047834828,
0.0751495808,
-0.0065969643,
-0.0413869508,
-0.0466112867,
0.0618342683,
0.0193764027,
-0.0329515152,
0.0054449593,
-0.0109649394,
0.029233845,
0.0179808252,
0.0471085235,
-0.0883133113,
-0.0194686353,
-0.0227461923,
0.0207067188,
-0.034633588,
-0.0407658517,
-0.0161394496,
-0.11704541,
0.0064166128,
0.0008350412,
-0.0638618022,
0.0047774645,
-0.0180855617,
-0.0299471263,
-0.0008340874,
-0.0268293396,
0.0166669227,
0.0085165203,
-0.0101027284,
0.0022382408,
-0.0117198778,
-0.0247911811,
0.0104235709,
-0.0578185916,
0.0253436808,
0.0608278252,
0.054371763,
0.0153399082,
-0.0266766734,
-0.0537049808,
-0.0254067592,
0.0359977819,
0.0163721107,
0.0399061851,
-0.0433639884,
-0.0013830031,
-0.0152963009,
0.0255123489,
0.0069244662,
-0.0082966583,
0.0110545922,
0.0535932221,
-0.0570722967,
-0.0035881528,
-0.0055081029,
0.0387649015,
0.0299840383,
0.0277091525,
-0.0110956263,
-0.0395152792,
-0.0619401038,
-0.0091835549,
0.0072019412,
-0.0555731766,
-0.0564588457,
-0.0025619657,
-0.0140033718,
0.0164784901,
-0.0796009973,
-0.0915292203,
-0.0111689428,
0.0377322547,
0.0190304071,
-0.0519430712,
0.0518544614,
-0.0032438517,
-0.0089719491,
-0.0089437375,
-0.0340227224,
-0.0107133547,
-0.0252181925,
-0.0221718121,
0.009777328,
-0.0089731095,
-0.0023342904,
0.0199550502,
-0.0092558172,
-0.0278842021,
-0.0145052793,
0.0730185956,
0.011953881,
0.0478139892,
0.006211997,
-0.0034323244,
0.0200010482,
0.0281690359,
-0.011792168,
0.0073424214,
0.0245457087,
0.0134445913,
0.0039800038,
0.036809288,
-0.0594036095,
-0.0098350132,
-0.0008045668,
0.0328049846,
0.0103373658,
0.0055014919,
0.047172524,
-0.0418954454,
0.038797494,
-0.0445403345,
-0.0025733386,
-0.0117639862,
-0.0103530362,
-0.0254189316,
-0.029268181,
-0.0370022319,
0.0022981579,
-0.0082182614,
0.0142102856,
0.0423888117,
-0.0198653881,
-0.0142620951,
0.0131222773,
-0.0232843682,
-0.0037881448,
0.0699053556,
0.0415433683,
-0.0141776279,
0.02599217,
0.0016970886,
0.0000525239,
0.0143462159,
0.0553913452,
0.0014755477,
0.0877610818,
0.0580611862,
-0.0309394561,
-0.0204635337,
0.0100651318,
-0.0577507615,
-0.0210946072,
0.0183520559,
0.0360533185,
0.068854101,
0.0071187387,
-0.0124610635,
-0.0789336115,
0.0382819101,
0.0173115097,
-0.0088479472,
0.004323835,
-0.0962072536,
0.0421429612,
0.0187961198,
0.0037056296,
0.0091684982,
0.0471961349,
0.0151801119,
0.0559093617,
-0.0220755637,
0.0144864712,
-0.0306017641,
-0.0383476615,
0.033064913,
0.0226807985,
-0.0138527295,
0.0044853278,
-0.0504901633,
-0.0157745313,
-0.0150332712,
0.05372921,
-0.0020165446,
-0.0398292355,
0.0748057142,
0.0177084934,
0.0037819352,
-0.0465237275,
-0.0263989978,
-0.002333727,
0.0184415877,
-0.0044214781,
-0.0573580936,
-5.863234681e-33,
-0.0488452129,
-0.0479311123,
0.086856395,
-0.0034448304,
-0.017055627,
-0.0099836057,
-0.0500819981,
0.0024163625,
0.033018142,
0.0455024093,
-0.0018346837,
-0.0066203377,
0.0053290017,
0.0093681887,
0.0201246366,
-0.0205457862,
0.0269602202,
-0.0190429483,
-0.0338525027,
0.0164454225,
0.0495242886,
-0.0108290426,
0.0469795056,
-0.0501269139,
0.035017252,
0.0439615771,
-0.0119054494,
0.0366841182,
0.006745636,
0.0591294542,
0.003091519,
0.0166968983,
0.0018741499,
-0.0389983431,
-0.0243397653,
-0.0074688718,
-0.0437637679,
-0.0856183991,
0.0193207841,
0.0067873308,
-0.1043955013,
0.0170227271,
0.0105402078,
-0.0120035661,
-0.0713983625,
0.0270612314,
0.0234739743,
-0.0051772683,
-0.0149767091,
0.0174839552,
-0.075524427,
-0.0134443296,
-0.0070509878,
-0.0280963015,
0.0236436855,
0.0441500396,
0.0037225906,
-0.0339593962,
-0.0544440672,
0.0437143557,
0.0004579241,
-0.0217162259,
0.0477885567,
0.0325944237,
0.0206472035,
0.0613394231,
0.0307800863,
0.0051140836,
-0.0667264313,
-0.0133941583,
-0.0006147244,
0.036384549,
0.0419723317,
-0.0081095416,
-0.0073347385,
0.0126984185,
-0.0295880605,
0.0277954731,
0.0000467814,
0.0789998323,
0.0091806883,
0.0399939865,
-0.0538545139,
-0.0203479286,
-0.0419480838,
0.0251527317,
-0.0016194676,
-0.0283964276,
0.0298784487,
0.0318909809,
0.0281530432,
-0.0212880727,
-0.0001173182,
-0.0298362374,
-0.0079164198,
0.0089956056,
-0.0161288343,
0.0129468907,
-0.0165520906,
0.0048397118,
-0.0505240448,
-0.0189700276,
0.0290407278,
-0.0122883366,
0.017583413,
0.0182662066,
-0.0152561376,
0.0547215752,
-0.0433025733,
0.0143042095,
-0.0269827563,
0.0085593937,
0.0126024056,
-0.0758885592,
0.0492924266,
0.0037735873,
-0.0278123152,
0.0466293842,
0.0105547234,
-0.0363353416,
-0.0067269118,
0.0052042748,
-0.0177885238,
0.0314214937,
-0.0168196037,
0.0189061463,
-0.0359325968,
0.0277944449,
-0.0274338704,
-0.0437273085,
-0.0046356185,
0.0534230545,
2.906e-7,
-0.0557231121,
0.0365190394,
0.058182817,
0.0081458697,
0.0286053922,
0.0578648858,
-0.0233160276,
0.0344801955,
-0.0217507575,
0.0294242688,
0.038230136,
0.0293784719,
0.005891209,
-0.0069297776,
-0.0375515223,
0.0068761944,
-0.0661619082,
-0.0346182212,
-0.0417241678,
-0.0096526165,
0.0745450258,
0.0451380722,
0.0189561844,
0.014207691,
0.0424956717,
-0.0133685106,
0.0407686271,
-0.0267883018,
-0.0085248882,
-0.0228100698,
-0.0010183095,
0.0295857359,
-0.0243171025,
-0.001908722,
0.0145754209,
-0.0024694528,
-0.0400443412,
0.0270337425,
-0.0216588657,
-0.0215482656,
-0.0154682919,
0.0344516486,
0.0186217576,
-0.0133932056,
0.0321743786,
-0.0821407214,
-0.0282683875,
0.0003049248,
0.023252951,
-0.0254728291,
-0.0174157359,
0.0231182873,
-0.0518517457,
-0.0197615512,
0.0077065909,
0.044312831,
0.0010148981,
-0.0862355009,
0.022220917,
0.0604619682,
0.0145287048,
0.0123650637,
-0.0442604013,
0.050113555,
0.0151659651,
-0.0644702688,
-0.0132417427,
2.262718259e-34,
-0.0153845213,
-0.019458171,
0.0004974526,
0.0084593827,
0.045111455,
0.0296623372,
-0.0048520123,
0.0286397282,
0.0959933251,
-0.0171618331,
-0.0406651422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15493v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15493v1 | The timing bottleneck: Why timing and overlap are mission-critical for conversational user interfaces, speech recognition and dialogue systems | 2023-07-28T11:38:05 | 2023-07-28T11:38:05 | Andreas Liesenfeld, Alianda Lopez, Mark Dingemanse | cs.CL | cs.CL | Speech recognition systems are a key intermediary in voice-driven
human-computer interaction. Although speech recognition works well for pristine
monologic audio, real-life use cases in open-ended interactive settings still
present many challenges. We argue that timing is mission-critical for dialogue
systems, and evaluate 5 major commercial ASR systems for their conversational
and multilingual support. We find that word error rates for natural
conversational data in 6 languages remain abysmal, and that overlap remains a
key challenge (study 1). This impacts especially the recognition of
conversational words (study 2), and in turn has dire consequences for
downstream intent recognition (study 3). Our findings help to evaluate the
current state of conversational ASR, contribute towards multidimensional error
analysis and evaluation, and identify phenomena that need most attention on the
way to build robust interactive speech technologies. | [
0.0105875237,
0.0374774709,
-0.0065982528,
0.0395131297,
-0.0182737391,
-0.0216233544,
0.0384640396,
-0.0112483045,
0.0323778875,
-0.0181118343,
-0.0425154343,
-0.0520234853,
0.0984693766,
0.0362191275,
-0.0193715859,
-0.0327920429,
0.0470817648,
-0.0758779943,
0.0141785778,
-0.0068826014,
0.0099918405,
0.0003351756,
-0.076707989,
0.0589949861,
-0.0088962875,
0.0088479472,
-0.022945147,
-0.0046143965,
-0.006380734,
-0.0240524486,
-0.0341040529,
0.0211915169,
-0.0065767025,
0.0780294687,
0.0000016348,
-0.0525699556,
0.0308985673,
0.0112287346,
-0.0701618046,
0.0216630232,
0.02547138,
0.0242757145,
-0.0188236497,
0.0539236143,
-0.0156672169,
0.0296922904,
0.0721267909,
0.0347843915,
-0.0197405741,
-0.0013590477,
-0.0201136041,
0.0395280384,
0.0138873756,
-0.0187215712,
-0.0218224861,
-0.0523434915,
-0.0216295291,
-0.0223999433,
0.0108437147,
-0.0252431985,
-0.0070869778,
0.0498163551,
-0.0100444481,
-0.0200701542,
-0.0158644263,
0.0004821997,
-0.0298842043,
-0.0651799142,
-0.0830127969,
0.0517753772,
0.0300069861,
0.0227698628,
0.0147722457,
-0.0058234809,
-0.0301628914,
-0.02920877,
0.0106329201,
0.0029865212,
-0.055436369,
-0.0364191458,
-0.0213779435,
0.0404143147,
0.0060123107,
-0.0152067784,
0.0152109386,
0.030073693,
0.0225800257,
-0.0318513662,
0.0154534075,
0.0012562184,
0.0369747765,
-0.0293219797,
0.0568320118,
0.001873113,
-0.0922016129,
0.0202239174,
-0.0636525676,
0.0104788262,
0.0269113928,
-0.0531092547,
0.016082162,
0.0563432798,
-0.0476285219,
0.0109238271,
0.0574293919,
0.0773306265,
0.0233754478,
-0.0571553595,
0.0071233697,
0.0090549784,
0.0178532396,
0.0014073205,
-0.0381141342,
-0.0055411132,
-0.0825663731,
-0.0707462206,
-0.0331939757,
0.0543122105,
0.017286893,
0.0128080556,
0.0225023963,
-0.0230169091,
-0.0095214406,
0.0144212572,
-0.031855043,
0.0288470481,
0.0034876508,
0.0500879847,
-0.0088539086,
-0.1013168842,
-0.0038307491,
0.0147929657,
0.0557018071,
-0.0158445556,
-0.0206846558,
0.0552295931,
-0.0342731997,
-0.0365913771,
0.0052190088,
0.0054919855,
-0.0611527748,
-0.0452815518,
-0.0534431748,
-0.0071765506,
0.0524580106,
0.0278148502,
-0.0310098715,
0.0004625771,
0.034379825,
0.0070308684,
0.0077568716,
0.0769319236,
-0.0172764864,
0.0173478015,
0.0366557837,
0.0115722669,
0.0216454752,
0.0278622564,
0.0432321541,
-0.0446903035,
0.0304263718,
-0.031814564,
-0.0025344156,
0.0508452021,
-0.0470187701,
-0.0202807412,
0.0217572451,
-0.013762922,
0.0083701219,
0.0312566534,
0.0347053073,
0.0812215507,
-0.0260283668,
0.0092425626,
0.071302332,
0.0567540154,
-0.0214329585,
-0.0177465491,
0.005290742,
0.0240039192,
-0.0058722966,
-0.0100037372,
-0.0097397929,
-0.021943504,
0.0091326581,
0.0019139574,
0.039161671,
0.0268242564,
0.0029994082,
-0.0430768281,
-0.0299226195,
-0.013347825,
0.0076527484,
0.0543735996,
0.0341630168,
-0.0129134953,
-0.0604051575,
0.0294528119,
-0.0196110196,
-0.0640051216,
-0.0048965383,
-0.0329590552,
-0.0510287434,
0.1041227207,
0.0274758749,
-0.029540712,
-0.0548228137,
0.013429163,
-0.0092206076,
0.0644173101,
0.0516475514,
0.0092573967,
0.0750083625,
-0.0575017855,
-0.0085078171,
0.0321397185,
-0.0161276963,
0.0615757182,
-0.0069047692,
0.06161635,
-0.0028208822,
0.03876644,
0.0226599872,
-0.0160988607,
-0.025273826,
0.0001482828,
-0.0034762961,
0.0021739176,
0.0477769561,
0.0299005304,
-0.0440070964,
-0.0212625898,
0.0202689357,
0.0052826768,
0.0399156623,
0.0667385533,
-0.0606127344,
-0.0343467407,
0.0506999269,
0.0070062499,
-0.0304723661,
0.0170137174,
0.0422429107,
-0.0588664077,
0.0186065789,
-0.0422870107,
0.0249400008,
-0.0145963756,
0.0754316375,
0.0356045514,
0.0367245339,
0.0084518762,
-0.0154380016,
0.0003246701,
0.0098930383,
0.020641569,
0.0036612907,
0.0241764076,
-0.0890786424,
-0.00514988,
0.0660214275,
-0.0516913608,
-0.0168492068,
0.0107463403,
-0.0139749609,
-0.040654216,
0.0018216654,
-0.1192429438,
-0.0265334602,
0.015936574,
-0.0012644071,
-0.0310182963,
0.0396539867,
0.000009007,
-0.041990988,
-0.0131035317,
-0.0130923474,
0.0134461457,
-0.0145707065,
-0.0175246745,
0.0066546579,
-0.0667023361,
-0.0495536663,
0.0235993806,
0.0148958918,
-0.0061467993,
-0.0008975107,
-0.0844954401,
-0.0488896444,
0.0097900033,
-0.0106306737,
0.055817198,
-0.0250960402,
-0.0152271772,
0.0384333506,
0.0234077275,
0.0263699833,
0.0249772463,
0.0045616943,
0.0237847157,
-0.000430406,
-0.0555737466,
-0.026153408,
0.0410578996,
0.0329683684,
0.0264935903,
-0.0135820108,
0.0159182474,
-0.013906288,
0.0452508256,
0.0341126211,
0.0597026423,
-0.019687688,
-0.0169333965,
-0.016350884,
-0.0688552931,
-0.038928017,
-0.0294955987,
-0.0532685295,
0.0380605049,
-0.0196381584,
-0.0289327558,
0.0038257944,
-0.0752804205,
-0.0600994825,
-0.0153668299,
-0.0224203654,
-0.0124011552,
0.0103515498,
-0.0455711782,
-0.0137050943,
0.0130447252,
-0.0954264179,
-0.0074159135,
0.0123019349,
0.0068142242,
-0.0708887801,
0.0604770072,
-0.0623322986,
0.0106319105,
-0.0167472623,
-0.0446945466,
-0.0177747421,
-0.0139821107,
-0.0275226664,
-0.0207637176,
0.0359761715,
-0.0472674929,
-0.0054937261,
0.0198305529,
-0.0050819465,
0.0741033331,
0.0136251813,
-0.0085603138,
-0.026663417,
0.0336057469,
0.0320729762,
0.0504327789,
-0.0069833817,
0.0147459237,
0.0612300597,
0.0057348162,
0.0666717067,
-0.0186612438,
-0.0459195748,
0.0008434814,
0.0613614097,
0.0033310626,
-0.0271186884,
0.0314724073,
0.0655972213,
-0.0110473428,
0.0197303034,
0.0876592472,
0.0029589564,
-0.0062164599,
-0.0203461144,
-0.02267709,
0.0029066019,
0.0243770108,
-0.0273143277,
-0.0617312454,
-0.0201132167,
0.0578618944,
0.0320102461,
-0.0030723356,
0.0358233079,
-0.0248792786,
-0.0873811841,
0.0336330459,
-0.0094971089,
-0.0598205402,
-0.0029681162,
-0.0067983125,
-0.0149855474,
0.0162186977,
0.0814681724,
0.0017739827,
-0.020458594,
-0.0290783737,
0.0147545505,
-0.0749520957,
-0.0505452678,
0.0383136831,
0.0213838536,
0.0776365474,
0.0382675603,
0.036930725,
0.0251877345,
-0.0296257455,
0.0399070308,
0.0034476067,
0.018782163,
-0.0365606695,
0.0178270545,
0.0261575375,
-0.005948917,
-0.0114673376,
-0.0005716755,
-0.0074386033,
-0.0086587984,
0.0322472453,
0.003713758,
-0.066431202,
0.0245901588,
0.0182736907,
0.0225518309,
0.0493030697,
0.0333077759,
-0.0198606588,
-0.0266257115,
-0.0306372531,
0.0441572256,
0.0367739834,
-0.0333989412,
-0.0125945108,
0.0135659166,
-0.0120567046,
-0.051142849,
-0.0302514154,
-0.0622102283,
-0.0138579067,
0.0446193404,
0.0161112379,
0.0293574836,
-0.0294966772,
0.0747435316,
-0.013000763,
-0.0194681156,
0.027709607,
0.0322804041,
-0.0760780573,
0.0218979027,
-0.0433146171,
-0.0416441895,
-0.0064662006,
0.0534298047,
-0.0312521234,
-0.0742857531,
0.0454036146,
-0.0103357192,
0.0284863655,
0.0244916975,
-0.0134879779,
-0.0516078994,
-0.0209350716,
0.0106852017,
-0.0074761929,
0.0263962783,
0.035132505,
0.0380948894,
-0.0189768281,
0.0029841149,
-0.0386790037,
-0.0039053319,
-0.0669669583,
0.0212000459,
-0.043104846,
-0.1090634689,
-0.026195202,
0.0481645428,
0.0857613236,
-0.0123290997,
0.0092981691,
-0.0274805054,
0.0545797534,
-0.0055640056,
0.0476497114,
-0.0589409284,
-0.0293809716,
-0.0096807145,
0.0180422422,
-0.000883711,
0.015605879,
-0.0499767922,
-0.0669919029,
-0.0073699043,
0.0347284712,
0.0270171221,
0.0073813698,
0.0079443837,
0.0157785323,
-0.0116411308,
0.0676074326,
0.0329817049,
0.0013147227,
0.0097641768,
0.0662001073,
-0.0257504135,
-0.03089137,
0.0454538614,
0.0100886645,
-0.039440155,
-0.0343856961,
0.0247953124,
0.0307492558,
0.0238289852,
0.0107850134,
0.0631538555,
-0.004159959,
0.0423767939,
-0.0398336612,
0.0652695522,
0.0040722215,
-0.0244170874,
0.0197769981,
-0.0000877164,
-0.0295407698,
0.0047526811,
0.0485852398,
-0.0342267193,
0.0016358431,
-0.0069056652,
0.0023220049,
-0.0386481658,
-0.0615387149,
-0.0202162489,
-0.0169538762,
-0.0471128374,
-0.0609476827,
-0.0302719679,
-0.0403628871,
0.0285114944,
0.0183551311,
0.0162751749,
-0.0404063314,
0.0058541209,
0.0193926096,
-0.0137250358,
-0.0193324182,
-0.0183466189,
-0.0233507827,
-0.057065133,
-0.0168867745,
-0.0196186099,
-5.315723575e-33,
-0.0338958986,
-0.0131106731,
0.0253635291,
0.0047181603,
-0.0401390046,
0.0323355161,
-0.0097882906,
0.0365059525,
-0.0079253493,
-0.0306154881,
-0.0224282965,
0.024126932,
0.0390546955,
0.0006697751,
0.0089296931,
-0.0008625151,
0.0489182398,
0.0208928492,
-0.0063314289,
-0.0386423953,
0.0342127346,
-0.0050629843,
0.0136450026,
-0.0388531759,
0.0073731598,
0.0543297678,
0.0131561765,
-0.02431117,
0.0306992158,
0.0305870976,
0.0029578877,
0.0741073713,
-0.0083238911,
-0.0144598,
0.0056812582,
0.0397471637,
-0.0617385134,
-0.0305179413,
0.0130219543,
0.1013399512,
0.003548969,
0.0175490454,
0.0151769454,
0.0058132829,
-0.0665856451,
0.0142772915,
0.0008406813,
0.0062140296,
-0.0528152287,
-0.0207961872,
-0.0322008133,
0.0243232306,
-0.0280675199,
-0.0247764401,
0.0440556258,
0.072175771,
0.0223099813,
-0.0483872928,
-0.0491857119,
0.0407195613,
-0.0212993883,
0.0068652532,
0.0362605862,
0.034184251,
0.0023197967,
0.0512194559,
0.0486526713,
-0.0169288367,
0.0375121012,
-0.0414890498,
0.0361180976,
0.0249134526,
-0.0177941937,
0.0258697625,
0.0089320531,
-0.0281794108,
0.0058592171,
-0.0029675325,
0.0288825426,
-0.003256371,
-0.0061763842,
0.0249189176,
-0.0752483159,
-0.0012508169,
-0.0491795801,
0.0565962009,
-0.0283284858,
0.0013486787,
0.0704914778,
0.017387433,
0.0516357496,
0.0134490011,
0.0562091507,
0.0222008731,
-9.748e-7,
-0.0112730348,
0.0160382427,
0.0014739428,
-0.0186701901,
0.0081786662,
-0.0513826199,
-0.0120443599,
0.0163952019,
0.0592518933,
0.0299417414,
-0.0370067619,
-0.0532989167,
0.0217520595,
-0.0583773367,
-0.0020392928,
0.0085803112,
0.0596132912,
0.0147030177,
-0.0129600391,
0.0837631896,
-0.0786427632,
-0.0368992053,
0.0485816114,
-0.0128195472,
-0.0060300846,
-0.0492078327,
-0.036737144,
-0.0133516053,
-0.0080476543,
-0.0307986122,
0.0070359362,
0.0043844432,
-0.0140114836,
-0.0040091374,
-0.0144376699,
-0.0133716129,
-0.032522127,
2.495e-7,
-0.0325872265,
0.0339446403,
0.0278586075,
0.0412846208,
0.0128823407,
0.0036564341,
0.0152894314,
0.0074626794,
-0.0247968584,
0.0614086501,
0.0206106007,
-0.0334573649,
0.0730039105,
0.010629043,
-0.0411455669,
-0.0747194141,
-0.0371068344,
0.0279433914,
-0.0079936776,
0.0386571586,
0.0482137054,
0.0168727655,
-0.0229888745,
-0.0150695406,
-0.0182506684,
-0.0464941636,
0.0308560077,
-0.026120821,
0.027155472,
0.0080611743,
0.0148005318,
-0.0323226228,
-0.0176960137,
0.0291734636,
-0.0275194552,
-0.0034674397,
0.0046748635,
0.0044157938,
-0.0334297456,
-0.0679777861,
-0.0107357949,
0.0364452973,
-0.0468767621,
-0.0218948536,
0.0523944907,
0.0070907841,
-0.0334315933,
-0.030792091,
-0.0063108508,
-0.0178455673,
0.0105064847,
0.0227303915,
0.0224739108,
-0.0057247337,
-0.0118596014,
-0.0207122546,
-0.0153870946,
-0.0428574383,
0.025533963,
0.0301012266,
-0.0330717564,
-0.0237148926,
-0.0447260439,
-0.0129374638,
0.0186324641,
-0.0092866085,
-0.0173339341,
1.580714575e-34,
0.0218089037,
-0.0393372402,
0.0234279688,
0.0324594229,
0.0365952067,
-0.0265635177,
0.0319922492,
0.0598688461,
0.0436296649,
-0.0253479555,
-0.0284355376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15484v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15484v3 | Minimally-Supervised Speech Synthesis with Conditional Diffusion Model and Language Model: A Comparative Study of Semantic Coding | 2023-07-28T11:20:23 | 2023-12-18T12:48:01 | Chunyu Qiang, Hao Li, Hao Ni, He Qu, Ruibo Fu, Tao Wang, Longbiao Wang, Jianwu Dang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | Recently, there has been a growing interest in text-to-speech (TTS) methods
that can be trained with minimal supervision by combining two types of discrete
speech representations and using two sequence-to-sequence tasks to decouple
TTS. However, existing methods suffer from three problems: the high
dimensionality and waveform distortion of discrete speech representations, the
prosodic averaging problem caused by the duration prediction model in
non-autoregressive frameworks, and the information redundancy and dimension
explosion problems of existing semantic encoding methods. To address these
problems, three progressive methods are proposed. First, we propose
Diff-LM-Speech, an autoregressive structure consisting of a language model and
diffusion models, which models the semantic embedding into the mel-spectrogram
based on a diffusion model to achieve higher audio quality. We also introduce a
prompt encoder structure based on a variational autoencoder and a prosody
bottleneck to improve prompt representation ability. Second, we propose
Tetra-Diff-Speech, a non-autoregressive structure consisting of four diffusion
model-based modules that design a duration diffusion model to achieve diverse
prosodic expressions. Finally, we propose Tri-Diff-Speech, a non-autoregressive
structure consisting of three diffusion model-based modules that verify the
non-necessity of existing semantic encoding models and achieve the best
results. Experimental results show that our proposed methods outperform
baseline methods. We provide a website with audio samples. | [
-0.0142904324,
0.0370257981,
0.0134036429,
-0.0180870015,
-0.0214994345,
-0.0349263251,
0.0313120298,
-0.008711122,
-0.070118092,
0.0020180522,
-0.0306858644,
-0.0240204111,
0.0421992317,
0.038586393,
0.0282314308,
-0.0919568986,
0.0235038791,
-0.055693239,
-0.0423722044,
-0.027920749,
0.0075955908,
-0.0196843799,
-0.0286434703,
-0.0023298615,
-0.0316531099,
0.0054269633,
-0.0415374264,
-0.0124043273,
0.014149393,
-0.0241070297,
-0.0428901277,
0.0223857425,
0.0786880925,
-0.0243808217,
0.000002173,
-0.0208627079,
0.0039091422,
-0.0005002068,
-0.0365965553,
-0.0174759664,
0.0374212638,
-0.0127788186,
-0.0105500352,
0.0254976675,
0.0169660971,
-0.0350423642,
0.0366132446,
0.0057534082,
0.061004471,
0.0659841523,
-0.0134239793,
-0.0715097338,
0.0324727148,
-0.0580207482,
0.0197171718,
0.0418843776,
-0.0246245041,
0.0044046841,
0.0416620448,
0.0094777476,
-0.072563529,
0.0681803674,
0.0031139217,
-0.003734401,
0.0605131015,
0.0338167734,
0.0655019581,
-0.0623345822,
-0.0258058086,
0.0699385181,
0.0208849162,
0.0295435525,
0.027662605,
0.0113289915,
-0.0220172368,
-0.0082847988,
0.0085362336,
-0.0033614847,
0.0453164764,
0.0010224321,
0.005262963,
0.0555403493,
-0.0058537605,
-0.0576495975,
-0.0003015187,
-0.0063915076,
0.0362667032,
-0.0294051133,
-0.0225194395,
-0.0417225063,
0.0276787262,
0.0089711742,
0.0266253632,
-0.0080233617,
-0.0128173642,
-0.0037964722,
-0.0446160026,
-0.0207552388,
-0.0448534712,
0.0180554092,
0.0113662565,
0.0555547178,
-0.0021986789,
-0.0102040777,
-0.0489742719,
0.0371895954,
0.0051182667,
-0.0343285911,
-0.0657628328,
0.0079631163,
-0.013674018,
0.0243107714,
-0.0448742993,
0.0498888008,
-0.0408399813,
-0.0202103555,
-0.0351710841,
0.0344300531,
-0.0228075329,
0.0206534564,
0.0130415624,
0.0160186421,
-0.0625124201,
0.0020088246,
-0.0213614739,
0.027588537,
-0.0074663013,
0.0154433623,
0.0339697376,
-0.0180588756,
-0.0244590919,
0.0174539983,
0.0376601629,
0.0198847819,
-0.0023206761,
0.0642218888,
-0.0183243938,
0.0108678481,
-0.0232491847,
-0.0491050854,
-0.026548611,
-0.0336792916,
0.0016164054,
-0.0854020715,
0.039385058,
-0.0293290615,
-0.0113672577,
-0.032497324,
-0.0150393657,
-0.0340069607,
0.0217441842,
0.0174404662,
-0.0137960715,
0.0376590081,
0.0766361803,
0.0111863092,
0.0051249401,
0.0255262442,
0.0611175187,
-0.0182898249,
-0.0342336036,
-0.0226831585,
-0.0293474179,
0.0279613193,
0.0106732305,
0.0432535559,
-0.0472440049,
-0.0374125354,
0.0262632761,
0.0358050056,
0.0681818947,
0.0661643296,
-0.0212118942,
-0.0204192214,
0.0482116006,
0.0383091904,
0.0277068801,
0.0062147346,
0.0979743898,
0.0412992239,
-0.0208057724,
0.0018778845,
0.0501948148,
0.0067564966,
0.0251319613,
0.016675489,
0.0491554216,
0.011950206,
-0.0627007559,
-0.0280007962,
0.0315290838,
-0.0573177077,
0.0213289037,
-0.0207642019,
0.0456243344,
0.0179642811,
-0.0704035163,
0.0530864932,
-0.0190264191,
-0.0515377782,
0.0377665423,
-0.0075643295,
0.0266759004,
0.0712944642,
0.0030737582,
-0.0069780359,
0.0309284553,
-0.0627919436,
0.0012655199,
0.0512634777,
0.0064078472,
-0.0051487093,
0.0225066207,
-0.0562423803,
-0.0274575986,
0.0188203398,
0.0017723991,
0.0213855673,
-0.0467735529,
0.0554545708,
0.0478229746,
0.0254872125,
0.0373556577,
-0.002697411,
-0.0393243842,
-0.0187573377,
0.0077600614,
-0.0052195187,
0.0519895554,
0.0265901182,
-0.0234921109,
0.0420227796,
0.0056767217,
-0.0564575605,
-0.0048986026,
0.001820371,
-0.09804786,
-0.1035571247,
0.0329023376,
-0.0215836372,
0.0464007743,
0.0141702555,
0.0197206941,
-0.1030148491,
0.0484630615,
-0.0422905758,
0.0148060694,
0.0003447026,
0.0261826105,
0.049215924,
0.0322857946,
0.0351128429,
-0.0024858639,
-0.0222148355,
-0.0124314521,
0.0548374131,
0.096027866,
-0.0059178933,
-0.0492313243,
-0.0132447891,
0.0339635909,
0.0061793337,
0.029653158,
-0.006860042,
-0.0390041135,
-0.0227934178,
-0.0360771269,
-0.0553141683,
0.00639778,
-0.002735964,
-0.0053516552,
0.0048765368,
0.0403774865,
0.0099357348,
0.0021118536,
-0.0439970195,
-0.0268829912,
-0.0050491886,
-0.0121110557,
-0.0401256382,
0.0065653306,
-0.0481460169,
-0.0091899214,
-0.021236632,
0.0292477012,
0.0166123491,
-0.0653785542,
-0.0309792459,
-0.0334416144,
0.0173956547,
-0.0161224324,
0.0269815363,
-0.0053846464,
-0.0252124965,
0.014125824,
-0.006217917,
0.1288565993,
-0.0322936736,
0.0154202711,
0.0120108165,
0.0341091864,
-0.0255388115,
-0.0369414389,
0.0125150615,
-0.003661935,
0.0565071665,
0.0030005749,
-0.0162518062,
-0.0185620319,
0.0125076482,
0.0843855217,
0.0269825887,
-0.0849287361,
-0.0492906868,
0.0069438484,
-0.0486169159,
0.0065545975,
-0.0271982308,
-0.0311079789,
-0.0242519397,
-0.0242474638,
-0.0266601983,
0.0412913598,
-0.0571718626,
-0.0451077037,
-0.0467707627,
-0.0526730418,
0.0334462821,
-0.0091082277,
-0.0193657223,
0.0272532422,
-0.0296512339,
-0.004868078,
-0.0515936315,
0.0208721161,
0.0105683655,
-0.0429869257,
0.0221744105,
-0.0110152522,
-0.0044270018,
-0.0132636782,
0.0252139885,
-0.0202032793,
-0.0755319223,
0.0073551009,
0.0377924144,
-0.034019772,
0.0048088739,
0.0023929107,
0.0472810566,
0.0039573824,
0.0410003848,
0.0174142029,
0.0184623748,
-0.016554974,
0.0436066836,
0.0347672291,
0.0136720827,
-0.049359832,
-0.0522772856,
0.0792827979,
-0.0246264134,
0.0245909467,
0.0148509936,
-0.0444873869,
0.0203055628,
-0.0179166719,
0.0376100503,
-0.0152330883,
0.0368951485,
0.026903173,
-0.0308514778,
0.026057953,
0.0908502117,
-0.0237607528,
-0.0018150372,
0.0147069991,
0.0241048448,
0.0854028091,
-0.0264407676,
-0.0152169047,
-0.0275304578,
-0.018533159,
0.022614345,
0.0255585406,
0.0018075547,
0.0236724727,
-0.040244244,
-0.055577442,
0.0250097383,
0.0648213178,
0.0224466808,
-0.0147416219,
-0.0294313375,
-0.0398518518,
0.0575703345,
-0.0248436201,
0.0364234895,
-0.014909884,
-0.0123384828,
0.0301854275,
-0.0514639616,
-0.0567498989,
-0.031295266,
-0.0203709379,
0.0708134472,
0.0719997883,
-0.0017974149,
-0.0019902869,
-0.0611703657,
0.0420640372,
-0.0206317678,
0.0077447593,
0.0001565096,
0.0185691901,
0.011901943,
-0.0056341263,
0.0246651843,
0.0405223593,
-0.0256252475,
0.0184902046,
-0.0161801968,
0.0807076693,
-0.0429344438,
-0.0262431577,
-0.0134548387,
0.0284814369,
0.0235108063,
0.0570311584,
0.0209754128,
-0.0516149811,
-0.009875752,
0.0101408362,
0.0212948006,
0.0089026084,
0.0043140016,
0.0030239383,
0.0009563533,
-0.0851985663,
-0.0570740029,
-0.022378156,
-0.023639081,
0.0367319062,
-0.0008873773,
0.0258282088,
-0.0017931525,
-0.0315437578,
-0.0474674739,
-0.0112387864,
0.0135599598,
0.0063415635,
-0.0445968062,
-0.019996766,
0.0287674833,
-0.0365670249,
-0.002306476,
-0.0444264375,
-0.1002035365,
-0.0596576594,
-0.0163817946,
-0.0120070083,
0.0066343783,
0.0602436699,
-0.0229584239,
0.0237554535,
0.1388009191,
-0.0024975801,
-0.0192786455,
0.0638553426,
0.0497945324,
-0.0175109264,
-0.0189036261,
-0.0080669504,
-0.041905269,
0.0419666395,
-0.0294138826,
0.0427763797,
0.0161992032,
-0.0077355825,
-0.0065287151,
-0.0242669154,
0.0047682533,
-0.0108003365,
0.0289521199,
-0.0396435969,
-0.0108472798,
-0.0015024855,
0.0258311722,
-0.0534263887,
0.0151596712,
0.0440496989,
0.0255859774,
0.0148782013,
-0.0172206089,
-0.0034559327,
-0.0189962108,
0.0395908915,
0.0501123294,
-0.0008692266,
0.0024057089,
0.0086972192,
0.0156404991,
-0.0224296879,
-0.0073124724,
-0.0275569707,
-0.0164357517,
-0.0129717151,
0.0145051675,
0.0172886141,
0.011597869,
-0.0132561689,
0.0174410529,
-0.0160920545,
0.0073086307,
-0.0095147332,
0.0050787274,
0.0104085971,
0.0427891016,
0.0337546542,
-0.0070922105,
0.048800882,
-0.0422938801,
0.0164112393,
-0.0278550703,
0.0203321651,
0.0435332246,
0.0043584579,
-0.0049616368,
0.0054818424,
0.0399516784,
-0.0151436441,
0.0203814693,
-0.0520313308,
0.0402224287,
-0.0221103877,
-0.0186807625,
-0.0637861565,
0.0140088983,
-0.0003314491,
-0.0383003876,
-0.001615818,
-0.0382162519,
0.0012988909,
-0.0277578402,
-0.011833488,
-0.0116840899,
0.0754917264,
-0.0357818604,
-0.038655404,
0.0330173932,
0.0048615029,
-0.035504505,
0.0142535362,
-0.0351270288,
0.0168669038,
-6.322894482e-33,
-0.0496458858,
0.0178527404,
-0.0016506681,
-0.0523140021,
-0.0670880154,
-0.0148317823,
-0.0556494482,
-0.0177153181,
0.0052602049,
-0.001408251,
-0.0103872642,
0.0174972937,
0.0178379714,
0.0183366984,
-0.0048311646,
0.0079668751,
0.1081736535,
-0.0359520279,
-0.0108502181,
0.0509660989,
0.0307202991,
0.0489977784,
-0.0262543745,
-0.0396782123,
0.0045760213,
-0.0097469529,
0.0126799503,
-0.0462267101,
0.0528893396,
0.0253759641,
-0.0179349054,
0.0571513288,
-0.0127450237,
-0.0163416434,
-0.0751089975,
0.0418350212,
-0.0714976788,
-0.0487413071,
-0.0019755964,
-0.0113641527,
-0.0403834172,
-0.0442567207,
0.0324646905,
0.0114383083,
-0.0156643558,
-0.0151976636,
0.0188639611,
-0.0281821694,
0.0024957189,
-0.0327877142,
-0.0196758211,
0.0377511643,
0.0038401955,
-0.0051075891,
0.0670801178,
0.0587292723,
-0.0053761457,
-0.0202251207,
-0.054096479,
0.0436118096,
-0.0103506474,
0.0671761185,
0.0180625673,
0.0408403724,
0.0251844823,
0.0284710675,
0.066183202,
-0.0436864719,
0.0414922424,
0.0251874886,
0.02153931,
0.0312382746,
0.0196679458,
-0.021484727,
0.0354899168,
-0.0498629659,
-0.0125222774,
-0.0145746553,
-0.0198627952,
-0.0143430997,
0.0183966998,
0.0391929187,
-0.016477352,
-0.0331670977,
-0.0763958544,
-0.0038560175,
0.0041322992,
-0.0415127315,
0.0584530681,
0.0068269237,
0.0307677686,
-0.0356574394,
0.0814362839,
0.0022157226,
0.0064549036,
-0.0083639529,
-0.0611847714,
0.0303590111,
0.0196663849,
-0.0066257482,
-0.018571727,
-0.0377144329,
0.0905410275,
0.0127657596,
0.0063573504,
0.0064355391,
-0.0687622726,
0.0697577,
-0.0327042341,
-0.0119994478,
-0.0008081613,
0.0057825795,
0.0036459519,
-0.01884358,
0.0087137865,
0.0080501586,
-0.0310143139,
0.0520791709,
-0.0412249081,
-0.0153414877,
0.0324172638,
0.0000642792,
0.0203721337,
0.0395575613,
-0.0231298134,
0.028890973,
-0.0145701934,
0.0630567297,
0.1019465476,
-0.0273302812,
-0.0007123241,
0.0422823504,
3.063e-7,
-0.0675060675,
-0.0422333814,
0.0215145703,
-0.0428337827,
0.0378038883,
0.0238907561,
-0.0353755169,
0.0129483184,
-0.0189785156,
-0.010525533,
0.0098899351,
0.0096224463,
0.0691465735,
-0.0121804401,
-0.0756944716,
-0.0212356877,
-0.0324239768,
0.0258635078,
-0.0385660008,
0.0120938681,
0.0429703631,
0.0664730519,
-0.0161234494,
-0.0144426832,
0.0047133933,
0.0202102624,
0.0450792462,
-0.0090511898,
0.0039374819,
-0.0211279634,
0.0043840031,
-0.0343450718,
-0.0109303081,
0.0166628547,
-0.057578247,
0.0267119873,
0.014630748,
0.0527619347,
0.0040272339,
-0.0521099679,
0.0347461291,
0.0461662933,
-0.0635393634,
0.0575887933,
0.0304576661,
0.0134636778,
0.0135245454,
0.0309605747,
-0.0632755533,
0.0226851683,
-0.0036464485,
-0.0192170814,
-0.0284195803,
-0.0273816232,
0.0248193145,
0.018996099,
0.0092995204,
-0.0164757166,
0.0198315065,
0.0027458272,
-0.0754783228,
-0.0681814849,
-0.0308537371,
0.0245977473,
0.0496927164,
-0.0090619065,
-0.0215265173,
2.734636538e-34,
0.0248693284,
-0.0361901484,
0.0264699403,
-0.0277024563,
-0.012741873,
-0.050650645,
-0.0032869244,
0.0025720927,
0.0426339395,
-0.0540445931,
-0.0767628551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16806v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.16806v2 | Testing the Depth of ChatGPT's Comprehension via Cross-Modal Tasks Based on ASCII-Art: GPT3.5's Abilities in Regard to Recognizing and Generating ASCII-Art Are Not Totally Lacking | 2023-07-28T10:45:14 | 2024-02-06T05:01:11 | David Bayani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Over the eight months since its release, ChatGPT and its underlying model,
GPT3.5, have garnered massive attention, due to their potent mix of capability
and accessibility. While a niche-industry of papers have emerged examining the
scope of capabilities these models possess, the information fed to and
extracted from these networks has been either natural language text or
stylized, code-like language. Drawing inspiration from the prowess we expect a
truly human-level intelligent agent to have across multiple signal modalities,
in this work we examine GPT3.5's aptitude for visual tasks, where the inputs
feature content provided as ASCII-art without overt distillation into a lingual
summary. We conduct experiments analyzing the model's performance on image
recognition tasks after various transforms typical in visual settings, trials
investigating knowledge of image parts, and tasks covering image generation. | [
0.0124257682,
0.0466247611,
-0.0293991007,
0.0607910492,
-0.0418987647,
0.0341640301,
0.0204574559,
0.0099738371,
0.0233202893,
-0.0259027928,
-0.0538303927,
-0.0110543594,
-0.0027668395,
0.0884491503,
0.0348874219,
-0.0416350365,
0.0111676045,
-0.038490884,
-0.0054205633,
-0.0055333464,
-0.0053901575,
0.002054082,
0.0023269588,
0.059653312,
-0.0039885589,
-0.0115253981,
-0.0388374105,
0.0021563873,
0.0192635283,
0.0072217016,
-0.0416229405,
0.0334366523,
0.0283525474,
0.0680944547,
0.0000019232,
-0.0075387927,
0.0236089192,
-0.004019205,
-0.0063241948,
-0.0288039222,
0.0504252166,
-0.0199409928,
-0.0324798264,
-0.0282068495,
-0.0622764044,
0.0068973545,
0.0841596201,
0.0681891888,
0.0525302552,
0.0609511882,
-0.0148620466,
-0.0097452141,
0.0265945978,
-0.0207710266,
0.0380217806,
-0.053381566,
-0.0109336991,
0.0040637064,
0.0352602713,
0.0449843295,
-0.0227324646,
0.0474755652,
0.064546369,
-0.0058245063,
-0.0272073559,
0.0793513954,
-0.0074352226,
-0.0164906513,
-0.0250795409,
0.0427975208,
-0.018402826,
-0.0118773142,
-0.0022298808,
0.0102142412,
0.0258784257,
-0.0012076168,
-0.0492554829,
0.021311745,
-0.0407117754,
0.0026707153,
-0.0352365598,
-0.0092595676,
0.0167812053,
-0.0207027625,
0.0001409028,
0.008319051,
-0.0114796804,
0.0118208388,
-0.0128878476,
0.0126382457,
-0.0302615613,
-0.0618362539,
0.0211843215,
0.034503486,
0.015471804,
0.0014442308,
-0.011974684,
-0.0209775027,
-0.0112513183,
-0.0275649838,
0.0116476221,
0.0437373929,
-0.046705924,
0.0518340878,
-0.0356594846,
0.061552275,
-0.0277773198,
0.0649288371,
-0.0076500843,
0.0108745554,
-0.0854558051,
-0.0575400479,
-0.0642714873,
0.0042488002,
-0.0088058962,
-0.0429244936,
-0.0145114632,
0.0152531248,
-0.0106913848,
0.00405908,
0.0157595668,
0.015667852,
-0.0534413047,
-0.0214605499,
-0.0097628441,
0.016025681,
-0.0311888065,
-0.0073687481,
0.0347785428,
-0.0395330414,
-0.0117926765,
0.0129070459,
-0.0024061678,
-0.0099835442,
-0.0063254773,
0.1264826804,
-0.0408494435,
-0.0265434477,
-0.0235484969,
-0.0021179416,
-0.0114829289,
-0.0608564466,
0.0561213493,
-0.0393404774,
0.0034393368,
-0.0018080062,
0.0014472418,
-0.0247487873,
-0.0217199251,
0.0122328652,
-0.0061331159,
0.0917711556,
0.0116087152,
-0.0238857102,
0.0225634594,
0.0331070498,
-0.0478450097,
0.0310322642,
0.0399815291,
0.072728999,
-0.005694346,
-0.0203885864,
0.0032137821,
0.0358457491,
-0.0301505364,
-0.0187562127,
0.0105268275,
-0.0383982062,
0.0140531883,
0.0362136774,
0.0489355028,
0.0372910611,
-0.0476708934,
-0.0525544174,
0.0762109682,
0.0631519333,
0.0165100005,
0.0436783209,
0.0773393586,
0.013842714,
0.0220598336,
0.0413640067,
-0.0805234239,
0.0590027831,
0.0185503196,
0.0120545207,
-0.0480177142,
0.0444484688,
-0.0299166366,
-0.0420299321,
0.0245430302,
-0.0141479513,
0.0580353774,
-0.0285410993,
0.0451163016,
0.0183895119,
-0.0493264683,
-0.0698864982,
-0.0257109161,
-0.0329142399,
-0.0034648979,
-0.1079444513,
0.0203323457,
0.069214955,
0.0288045704,
-0.0172651391,
-0.007336353,
0.0185666345,
0.0023445417,
0.0559033044,
-0.001581245,
0.0173206422,
0.0194658674,
-0.0387588739,
-0.0239778794,
-0.0285050981,
0.0091721602,
0.095575355,
-0.033329919,
0.0148492455,
-0.0126584619,
-0.0158726051,
-0.0010742449,
0.0202837139,
0.0167493168,
-0.0162026808,
-0.0251400806,
0.0062953793,
-0.0002493648,
-0.0008526053,
-0.0411705337,
0.0080561889,
-0.0162172206,
-0.0371936373,
-0.0158206783,
0.0391937271,
-0.0465675183,
-0.013230294,
0.0062587336,
-0.0768534765,
-0.0314419754,
0.0298047755,
0.0004379279,
-0.0350647494,
0.0439442284,
-0.0477776192,
0.0317044184,
-0.0431085937,
-0.0273970831,
0.0259573255,
0.0048512868,
0.0089790681,
0.0723001212,
0.0290807225,
-0.0347631983,
-0.0148224272,
-0.0123760141,
0.0266410187,
-0.033409182,
0.0064723161,
0.0344658308,
0.0167216919,
0.0045490488,
0.0186229628,
0.0541390106,
-0.0246322937,
-0.0304471646,
-0.0981579646,
-0.0205075163,
-0.0172192845,
0.0112422341,
0.000947853,
-0.0118169468,
-0.0180330481,
-0.0356279612,
-0.0625109747,
0.0741010457,
0.0152604766,
0.0144091379,
0.0359370373,
0.0219457075,
-0.0162303578,
-0.0189209376,
-0.0166027751,
0.0046793194,
0.0130233513,
0.0657460988,
-0.0356436148,
-0.0298178103,
0.0236790888,
-0.0234363172,
0.0089185042,
-0.0240482856,
-0.0551555716,
0.0508516468,
-0.0122838179,
0.0154506946,
0.0860387459,
0.0050230604,
0.026289396,
0.0175509825,
0.0018080315,
-0.0222637579,
0.0093949763,
0.0061857724,
-0.0172643885,
-0.0187893882,
-0.0104221907,
0.0013243898,
0.0859069377,
-0.0050503733,
0.0314619541,
-0.0928959846,
0.0330955349,
0.0039695986,
-0.0552033447,
-0.0493131168,
0.0133061325,
0.0070388638,
0.0351137035,
-0.0590204746,
-0.067797713,
0.0698416159,
-0.0264122561,
-0.0365042388,
0.0369002409,
-0.0051363222,
-0.0139192175,
0.0946872383,
0.0434074365,
0.0420429483,
0.0141961407,
-0.0575894155,
-0.0587279201,
0.0509882681,
0.0410629846,
-0.0010019996,
0.0198100563,
-0.0458494276,
0.0078822672,
-0.0421729125,
-0.0326774791,
-0.0095756361,
0.0295858029,
-0.0111006424,
0.0127225723,
0.012035571,
-0.0601830371,
-0.0027457292,
0.0221974906,
0.0262795873,
0.042838648,
-0.0292123146,
-0.0325870141,
-0.0269919522,
0.0238289703,
0.0173035897,
0.033061441,
-0.0276209842,
-0.014085819,
0.0142696667,
0.0548080951,
0.001556343,
-0.0071002729,
-0.048966635,
0.0464100279,
-0.0044748783,
0.0153464926,
-0.0435310192,
0.0227026623,
0.0616727322,
-0.0674521402,
-0.0166783892,
0.0640707389,
0.0049803499,
-0.0486199372,
-0.0111736823,
0.0127399722,
0.0027740726,
0.0088379197,
0.0263901241,
-0.1080603749,
-0.0147543047,
-0.0021749116,
-0.0146692712,
0.0071582072,
-0.0328244716,
-0.0045753038,
-0.0719809607,
0.0834725946,
0.0134246526,
-0.044981841,
-0.0388863608,
0.0027864573,
0.0098296776,
0.0160722695,
-0.0129399393,
-0.0193221271,
0.0026035241,
-0.0095811579,
0.010876921,
0.0134620257,
-0.0246545821,
0.0208997205,
-0.0016257567,
0.0380716585,
0.0535537116,
0.0248129275,
-0.0066831261,
-0.0391897261,
0.0138685498,
0.0240486618,
0.0444358103,
0.0004675511,
0.0602376945,
0.0061862734,
-0.021623509,
-0.0076229894,
0.0238742456,
-0.0228732359,
-0.0253459848,
-0.0228077453,
0.0465859324,
-0.0299749076,
-0.0356854349,
-0.0144436574,
-0.0103620766,
-0.0062298351,
0.0475862399,
0.0469805039,
-0.002153137,
-0.0936664641,
-0.066145815,
0.0137047879,
-0.0645206571,
-0.0846282914,
0.026897328,
0.026614897,
-0.0868454129,
-0.0532619245,
-0.0472801328,
0.0118413959,
0.0479061641,
-0.0118756406,
-0.0302093271,
0.0149843628,
0.0209486224,
-0.0371650569,
0.0050150855,
-0.0056306808,
0.0022025744,
-0.0302639157,
-0.0355327874,
-0.0297988113,
-0.0836054683,
-0.0244494677,
0.0311243199,
-0.0551114492,
-0.0408865809,
0.0085967267,
0.0527746342,
0.0301160812,
-0.00101358,
-0.0252480023,
-0.0243431367,
0.0148691107,
0.0377536789,
-0.0039186007,
0.0026279914,
0.0332502462,
-0.0104199154,
-0.018542733,
0.0116125634,
-0.0152205722,
0.03639948,
0.0082467897,
-0.0225048214,
-0.0016660505,
0.0073054596,
0.0293031763,
0.0016190102,
-0.0175026488,
-0.0065437085,
0.0244270191,
-0.0374177769,
-0.0354417413,
-0.007310614,
0.0431764834,
-0.0647767708,
-0.0425730422,
0.0190670881,
-0.008041149,
0.0225616973,
-0.0035239968,
0.0138130095,
0.0124380328,
-0.0387509391,
0.0036439288,
0.0134729641,
0.0384122506,
-0.0167048238,
0.0163002536,
0.0086261975,
0.0285008717,
-0.0195830632,
0.0493217185,
-0.0095896088,
0.0703644976,
0.029729588,
-0.0178569108,
0.0097801723,
0.0863483325,
-0.0939458013,
-0.0660865754,
-0.0006355088,
0.0890957788,
0.05967886,
0.0138307922,
0.0108087324,
-0.0681906343,
0.0134536615,
-0.0085980361,
0.0306173917,
0.0365429707,
-0.034734197,
0.0029526984,
0.0228069015,
0.0096242474,
-0.059925504,
0.0918204337,
-0.0328565016,
0.0421668403,
0.0055436627,
-0.0211132243,
-0.0377134979,
-0.0347232334,
0.0036813091,
-0.0303134676,
0.0060460893,
0.026080247,
-0.0150839081,
-0.093701072,
-0.0337316915,
0.0570269972,
0.0266843196,
-0.006107124,
0.0308113266,
0.0620732754,
0.0026594349,
-0.0257592928,
0.0102228625,
0.0059248148,
-0.0306133144,
0.0160340425,
-0.0180123039,
-5.921213736e-33,
-0.038151931,
-0.0271496996,
0.0515602306,
0.0213507041,
-0.0120874252,
0.0102264257,
-0.0544338264,
0.0041416865,
0.0066084079,
0.023538921,
-0.012750499,
0.0104062967,
0.0127857821,
-0.0119922962,
0.0060651032,
-0.0213000532,
0.0271310266,
-0.0236118753,
-0.0286327489,
0.0505840406,
0.016098043,
-0.0016510402,
0.0736529678,
-0.0881827921,
0.0111174956,
0.0186248347,
-0.0231128,
-0.022741491,
0.0055553103,
0.0752277449,
-0.0318625607,
0.0244055558,
0.0563806817,
-0.0141726946,
-0.0121606095,
0.0323356874,
-0.0753084794,
-0.0169146322,
-0.0280515105,
0.0443072207,
-0.052840367,
-0.0374990031,
0.0245591924,
-0.0400566049,
-0.0313562751,
-0.0081788525,
0.0333154537,
-0.0108789504,
0.0301085785,
0.0104261152,
-0.0794346333,
0.0170223657,
-0.0218869764,
-0.0526128523,
0.02553875,
-0.0114002069,
-0.000020033,
-0.0009827843,
-0.0104330285,
0.0383474901,
0.00919508,
0.0151963839,
0.0507706292,
0.0130039304,
0.0302369501,
0.0376135744,
0.0574034862,
0.0116744312,
-0.0310946591,
-0.0324106105,
0.0246585961,
0.0347874165,
0.0088008558,
0.0389736407,
0.0451214835,
0.0055075148,
-0.0246417336,
0.0234906692,
0.0084625334,
0.0542319156,
-0.0254522525,
0.025672527,
-0.0357662477,
0.0169735793,
0.0177719835,
-0.0340592004,
-0.0197788831,
-0.0542020686,
0.0264811367,
0.0000853665,
0.031502489,
-0.0041150856,
0.0425134934,
-0.0296515748,
0.028752517,
-0.0274853539,
-0.0189460441,
0.0523352325,
0.0161896665,
0.0279554911,
-0.0173062235,
-0.0166007038,
0.0451103374,
0.0276472792,
0.0237391647,
0.0189021938,
0.0166895594,
0.0561125763,
-0.0329754353,
-0.0182740483,
-0.045897454,
0.0084486511,
0.0239513386,
0.0094609288,
0.0404148661,
-0.0207895618,
-0.0338370614,
-0.0030825997,
-0.0363536142,
0.0021335322,
-0.0475797914,
-0.0009757575,
-0.0372868031,
0.0057028062,
-0.0461417474,
0.0011233411,
-0.0506457835,
-0.0097968709,
0.0111612668,
-0.0657840073,
-0.0255425479,
0.039064195,
2.823e-7,
0.0088573722,
-0.0042404868,
0.0525007434,
0.0595067553,
0.0432216935,
0.0272882655,
-0.034581162,
0.0308447089,
-0.002798443,
-0.0370136499,
0.0141497655,
0.0600627549,
0.0333112031,
0.0206135586,
-0.0361192264,
0.0353243761,
-0.0093213068,
-0.0037237769,
-0.0456648096,
0.0182875078,
0.0801524073,
0.047567606,
-0.055329334,
-0.0088550905,
0.0480265766,
-0.0742263719,
0.071256876,
-0.0309313834,
0.0089397766,
-0.0390250273,
0.0164034087,
0.0279656723,
-0.0263631232,
0.0422102325,
0.020952262,
-0.0379366241,
0.026812328,
0.0183649398,
-0.0305465404,
0.0112622594,
-0.0183190405,
-0.0050534434,
0.0068088761,
-0.0355288275,
0.0528913848,
-0.0410642251,
-0.0407856666,
-0.0153566776,
0.0174638052,
-0.0413035601,
-0.0007848168,
-0.0164483897,
-0.0471282713,
0.0107951043,
0.0102510769,
-0.0223575979,
0.0022164178,
-0.0591070578,
0.0285675246,
-0.0237836186,
-0.055413831,
-0.0248549953,
-0.1037290618,
0.0017203616,
0.072610572,
-0.0356343612,
-0.0415725596,
2.122341964e-34,
0.0096808616,
-0.0300013442,
0.0249783285,
0.0272796042,
0.0295017287,
0.0217857361,
0.0348192416,
0.0023195737,
0.0117300348,
-0.0506507605,
-0.0415210575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15460v1 | Cross-Modal Concept Learning and Inference for Vision-Language Models | 2023-07-28T10:26:28 | 2023-07-28T10:26:28 | Yi Zhang, Ce Zhang, Yushun Tang, Zhihai He | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large-scale pre-trained Vision-Language Models (VLMs), such as CLIP,
establish the correlation between texts and images, achieving remarkable
success on various downstream tasks with fine-tuning. In existing fine-tuning
methods, the class-specific text description is matched against the whole
image. We recognize that this whole image matching is not effective since
images from the same class often contain a set of different semantic objects,
and an object further consists of a set of semantic parts or concepts.
Individual semantic parts or concepts may appear in image samples from
different classes. To address this issue, in this paper, we develop a new
method called cross-model concept learning and inference (CCLI). Using the
powerful text-image correlation capability of CLIP, our method automatically
learns a large set of distinctive visual concepts from images using a set of
semantic text concepts. Based on these visual concepts, we construct a
discriminative representation of images and learn a concept inference network
to perform downstream image classification tasks, such as few-shot learning and
domain generalization. Extensive experimental results demonstrate that our CCLI
method is able to improve the performance upon the current state-of-the-art
methods by large margins, for example, by up to 8.0% improvement on few-shot
learning and by up to 1.3% for domain generalization. | [
0.0199191608,
0.0445468687,
0.0168204084,
0.0559587069,
-0.0430702828,
0.0131508159,
0.0087415744,
0.0004089274,
-0.0276171584,
-0.094869107,
-0.0508929566,
-0.0228466913,
0.0076533863,
0.0349967405,
0.0102187786,
-0.0491497926,
0.0031946462,
-0.0230258647,
0.0024675615,
0.0191195253,
0.0522242077,
0.0253813993,
0.0224756934,
0.015886914,
-0.0054676025,
-0.0115244426,
0.0329661518,
-0.0033378389,
0.0253280792,
0.0018172163,
-0.0263513196,
0.0298110377,
0.0626939833,
-0.012828677,
0.0000019898,
-0.0540212467,
-0.0058982885,
0.0112074995,
0.0177349318,
-0.0212338548,
0.0451188125,
-0.05339453,
0.0419908948,
-0.02701726,
-0.0135231297,
-0.0468285047,
0.0627734959,
0.0691704899,
0.0132722957,
0.0481733903,
-0.0381801054,
-0.0262165722,
0.0086687226,
-0.031466458,
0.051184874,
-0.0420260504,
0.0281045847,
0.0349317975,
-0.003757026,
0.0165791363,
-0.0428006165,
0.0316609591,
-0.0041548731,
0.0159563124,
-0.0235878322,
0.037046954,
-0.0175921731,
-0.034251608,
-0.0010091058,
0.087622419,
-0.0174516812,
-0.0446398333,
-0.0349690206,
-0.035494335,
-0.0222992282,
0.0151935769,
-0.0167351943,
0.0385298245,
-0.0121099111,
0.0256752111,
-0.0153971678,
0.0322117433,
0.0023718611,
0.0111685609,
-0.0297933184,
-0.0455639698,
0.0113536865,
0.0180472415,
-0.0349752866,
0.0297497455,
-0.0566636734,
-0.0266915224,
-0.0464857854,
-0.0024555468,
0.0263679773,
0.0033609029,
-0.0640037581,
-0.0339169018,
-0.0165681373,
-0.0290811267,
0.0352784581,
0.0242522545,
-0.0517356098,
0.0927721709,
-0.0389256515,
0.0402852371,
-0.0085094078,
0.0189419612,
-0.046056211,
-0.044990249,
-0.0369118936,
0.0207861587,
-0.0409243368,
0.0147874178,
0.0065001799,
-0.0449896008,
-0.0323509313,
-0.0009534838,
0.0064443303,
0.0045936997,
0.0166868884,
-0.0181804206,
-0.0247200951,
-0.0558667369,
-0.0101401508,
0.0044497866,
0.002987843,
0.0371780135,
-0.0587006994,
-0.0416576415,
0.0125713674,
0.0400353149,
0.038282223,
-0.0216530599,
0.0130492747,
0.0663512126,
-0.0255141705,
-0.0688499957,
-0.0345176384,
-0.0236456189,
-0.0301905293,
-0.0515652522,
-0.0083630234,
-0.0623278618,
0.0071640885,
0.0126672406,
0.001456051,
-0.0405764766,
0.0146700609,
0.0041003022,
-0.0532562658,
0.1200475469,
-0.0077870367,
-0.0187192038,
-0.0001900538,
0.0056313868,
-0.0019874678,
0.0813229308,
0.008142666,
0.0476394035,
0.0146006634,
0.0281469449,
0.0202350169,
0.0360052846,
-0.0045694313,
-0.007019002,
-0.0751626119,
-0.0018541225,
0.0331607908,
0.0132786082,
0.0122267874,
0.0367593393,
-0.0181056764,
0.0149942497,
0.0552917346,
0.0242479034,
0.0002710812,
0.0086401785,
0.062563628,
0.0252329577,
-0.0122120595,
-0.0375991054,
-0.0357194394,
0.0058485945,
-0.0112052551,
0.0058052363,
-0.0293147657,
0.0260370541,
-0.0631020144,
-0.0284950715,
0.0038953065,
-0.0447683483,
-0.0118384352,
0.0284714047,
0.0896390378,
0.0167177394,
-0.0012968783,
0.0100471126,
0.0544715859,
0.0026119328,
-0.0156354923,
-0.0277158767,
0.025181355,
0.0383856632,
0.0009780339,
-0.0125780925,
-0.0119179161,
0.0056631467,
0.0500546545,
0.0201249588,
0.017946586,
0.0125370529,
0.0083071515,
-0.0662620813,
-0.0737661868,
-0.0124420198,
-0.0059060194,
0.0090757422,
-0.0016891571,
0.0282276627,
0.0422087051,
-0.0318628848,
-0.0054978859,
0.0585660897,
0.0306196529,
-0.0069401748,
0.0061727874,
0.0446219482,
-0.0131709734,
-0.0429321229,
-0.0331443921,
-0.0004863236,
-0.0161330625,
-0.0453293622,
0.0096467128,
0.0193361305,
-0.0309091732,
-0.0178030282,
0.0130109554,
-0.0274090003,
0.0090744244,
-0.0232673418,
-0.0265073404,
-0.0198018197,
0.0230528656,
0.0084560858,
0.0080772927,
-0.0425015241,
0.0023959691,
0.0088722054,
0.0329647474,
-0.0122749945,
0.0449856445,
0.0124742696,
-0.0127480198,
0.0074512837,
0.0071764956,
0.0129419761,
0.0098982425,
-0.04315475,
-0.0488495491,
-0.0113853328,
0.0176928509,
0.0150885079,
0.0290668085,
-0.011948701,
0.0148531748,
-0.0712206438,
-0.0467442535,
-0.0164058506,
-0.0374441817,
-0.0039778682,
0.001063892,
0.0029370536,
-0.0632103086,
-0.0026859553,
0.0454764403,
0.0091810627,
0.0018306189,
0.0072181607,
0.0466242358,
0.0155157698,
-0.014519088,
0.0201351531,
0.0279717036,
0.0887137949,
0.0133542288,
-0.0528638288,
-0.0205207393,
0.0877755731,
-0.0138440719,
0.0606565513,
-0.0248295311,
0.0067264196,
-0.0235276781,
-0.0359633081,
0.0188087765,
0.0551255941,
-0.0063768122,
-0.0257284995,
0.0098659527,
-0.0172783602,
-0.0479668863,
-0.0238932241,
0.0059450096,
-0.0276540369,
-0.0159134977,
0.0008540325,
-0.027696453,
0.0501676276,
-0.0191610064,
0.0005722936,
-0.0590909272,
0.0172235109,
0.0021936835,
-0.0354875028,
-0.0781148225,
0.0160135496,
0.0487060323,
0.0041506174,
-0.0317615867,
-0.0642421395,
0.0422413014,
-0.0507388934,
0.0170625336,
0.0048090573,
-0.0142235709,
-0.0274567455,
0.0851624086,
0.0294916686,
0.0312666111,
0.0637300238,
0.0301216189,
-0.056950435,
-0.0297861136,
0.0243351571,
0.0153829316,
0.0511947908,
-0.0489870906,
0.0515925474,
-0.0259285364,
-0.0332800113,
-0.0429107063,
-0.0207403433,
-0.0636956319,
0.000468647,
-0.0503788069,
0.0148485387,
-0.0229701381,
0.0540878996,
0.0219382811,
0.024367189,
0.0098692374,
0.0014814123,
0.0007324573,
0.0482272431,
0.0607903041,
-0.0191745777,
-0.0527672432,
-0.0122453663,
-0.0045700399,
0.032663025,
-0.0176894963,
0.0107785873,
-0.0493020415,
-0.0005980517,
0.0175539851,
0.0361420587,
0.0014541494,
0.0224304385,
0.0147947175,
-0.034132313,
-0.0311461966,
0.0754502341,
0.0019873695,
-0.0585912317,
-0.068333149,
0.0286747999,
-0.0073865489,
0.0199526362,
0.0296633523,
-0.064626947,
-0.0671045035,
-0.0295323953,
-0.0653062239,
0.0251320712,
0.0305327624,
-0.0537617467,
-0.0827777982,
0.0147813307,
-0.007505117,
-0.0354358032,
-0.042643439,
0.0092028622,
-0.0052604876,
-0.0262122769,
-0.051982861,
-0.034135174,
-0.0180882886,
-0.0088682929,
-0.0131092081,
0.0208200216,
-0.0321687646,
0.0247087721,
-0.0618367679,
-0.021436315,
0.0332535952,
-0.0008465934,
-0.015901586,
-0.0586383529,
0.0127351722,
-0.0610655993,
0.0070644119,
0.0075116972,
0.0583142713,
-0.0550901331,
-0.0329876132,
0.0492482409,
0.026430998,
-0.0011532931,
-0.0272305012,
-0.0124733951,
0.0230803285,
-0.0072650327,
-0.0170057956,
-0.0392087027,
-0.0006100124,
0.0013760937,
0.0392708853,
-0.0076617445,
-0.0590362772,
-0.0091518722,
0.0051932372,
-0.0338171348,
-0.0253668409,
-0.0283941068,
-0.0109745394,
-0.003099205,
0.0053451983,
-0.0317591541,
0.0022406341,
0.0506520346,
0.035135027,
-0.0015902362,
-0.0040695313,
-0.0002387224,
0.0255761798,
-0.0805681944,
0.0587690175,
-0.0592552423,
0.0500093214,
-0.0244255867,
0.0129838865,
0.0841839239,
-0.0705322325,
-0.0418315008,
0.0199597087,
-0.0867296308,
-0.0025671786,
-0.0385679044,
0.0638498291,
0.0011578578,
0.0494790748,
-0.0099116247,
-0.0430620164,
0.0522390343,
0.0395539366,
-0.0109335976,
-0.0059015392,
-0.0224782843,
-0.043606203,
-0.0105116842,
0.0151558844,
-0.0394279696,
0.0624365844,
0.0684621781,
-0.017741926,
-0.0225291103,
-0.0127655957,
0.0182248298,
-0.0110209119,
0.062630564,
-0.0280286074,
0.0114193587,
-0.0433454737,
0.0035916583,
0.0266754422,
-0.0229900889,
-0.0809576735,
0.0160023551,
0.014106771,
0.0215943605,
0.0169674158,
0.0072615421,
0.0209435578,
0.0133842127,
-0.0055002547,
-0.0386970565,
0.038994927,
0.0246208254,
-0.0018651546,
0.0014537279,
0.0048192949,
0.0246731192,
-0.0109545803,
0.0142893773,
-0.0365206078,
0.0599961057,
0.0247043911,
-0.0096311551,
-0.06536562,
0.0382928811,
0.0039408067,
-0.0127734449,
-0.0774842277,
0.0485249236,
0.0556821041,
-0.0149541209,
-0.0370291248,
-0.0225695353,
-0.0217144582,
-0.0279035605,
0.0312587619,
0.0013730699,
-0.0145731568,
0.0650299415,
0.0017184535,
-0.0118949218,
-0.0099311471,
0.0693633109,
0.0343265533,
0.0293628722,
0.0120093161,
-0.0076845773,
-0.0297254324,
-0.0045337561,
0.0599576458,
0.0012899229,
-0.0092548328,
0.0384237655,
-0.0218846779,
-0.0528414436,
0.0313118175,
0.0113265282,
-0.0229878332,
0.0628767833,
0.0588096716,
0.0498223007,
0.0350172892,
0.0206838343,
-0.0031214608,
-0.0283812825,
0.0049794409,
0.0309416391,
0.0044297129,
-5.275130082e-33,
-0.0321466923,
-0.0007275386,
0.0459855907,
0.0282103345,
-0.013401513,
0.0172520969,
-0.0031755271,
0.0023477965,
-0.0291338619,
0.0105778072,
0.0424888879,
-0.0049960958,
0.0134476637,
0.0443441831,
0.0058388403,
0.0097647216,
0.0363581665,
0.0124995392,
0.0170805268,
0.0174363125,
0.019560609,
0.0238917489,
0.0539117157,
-0.0362888202,
-0.0204174183,
-0.0096647246,
-0.0174615681,
0.0025436864,
0.0509300195,
0.0497675799,
-0.0270778351,
0.0101230498,
0.0215951689,
0.0130110541,
-0.0280629396,
0.0216034725,
-0.0466081537,
-0.0066764792,
0.0158177949,
0.0195086543,
-0.0419064984,
0.0210239701,
0.0151769845,
-0.0269813072,
0.0211043768,
-0.0220494326,
0.0795335546,
-0.0385797098,
0.0042456528,
-0.0252766218,
-0.0565570034,
0.0339162871,
0.0105438521,
-0.0359476767,
0.0715523288,
0.0021188038,
0.0407307521,
0.0576071814,
-0.0328702442,
0.0358171128,
-0.0166906565,
0.0276504103,
0.0593513772,
0.0602041632,
-0.0001253462,
0.0524432398,
-0.0239177328,
-0.0626024827,
-0.0167104155,
0.0001083304,
0.046424821,
0.0570302233,
0.0235253107,
0.1127378419,
0.0138580408,
0.0089362217,
-0.0562625341,
0.0154366558,
-0.0473098308,
0.0645867437,
0.0155603513,
-0.0097929742,
-0.0042278795,
0.0001648357,
-0.0677973405,
-0.0173777267,
-0.0627433583,
0.0013119149,
0.05070531,
0.0484760068,
-0.0166198537,
0.0207998417,
0.0787742212,
-0.0540061519,
-0.0240192711,
0.0191595387,
-0.0214804951,
0.0155434106,
-0.0141894938,
0.0265105348,
-0.0833660886,
-0.0626696274,
0.0467556678,
0.0049512526,
-0.0304324087,
0.0162019823,
0.0870362222,
-0.0031709766,
-0.0437516272,
0.0067242086,
-0.0213351753,
-0.0491790585,
-0.0131004909,
0.0604312681,
0.0094277132,
0.0539136827,
-0.0461649038,
0.0104098199,
0.0031107827,
-0.0392237008,
0.0129343281,
-0.0400354639,
0.0070220637,
0.0363890417,
-0.0100233816,
-0.016577173,
-0.041042529,
-0.0232991949,
0.0257864017,
-0.035400562,
0.0051195365,
0.0475961193,
2.599e-7,
0.0288659949,
-0.0124522597,
-0.0094925463,
0.0127471918,
-0.0117925601,
0.0657209605,
-0.0030166805,
0.0328518599,
0.0239418671,
-0.0107466206,
0.0204785578,
0.0350802392,
0.0230188165,
-0.0170708448,
-0.0357034914,
0.0636549443,
0.0015325519,
-0.0257726982,
-0.046293065,
-0.0139416046,
0.0409141183,
0.1391874403,
-0.0026436802,
-0.0060491129,
0.0429853536,
-0.0768725649,
0.114904806,
-0.0385696851,
-0.0158343427,
0.0218279902,
-0.0542975664,
0.0296382215,
-0.0543526672,
0.0453310907,
0.0066865184,
0.0084378142,
0.0735741034,
0.0047283573,
-0.0106956325,
0.0488155559,
-0.0445135608,
0.0353616625,
-0.0208722744,
-0.041794017,
0.0861032754,
-0.1103761345,
0.0091996789,
-0.055954922,
-0.0039301692,
-0.0066074315,
0.0297255777,
0.003266396,
-0.0313874781,
0.0077387844,
0.0586630628,
-0.0010683261,
-0.057436917,
-0.0890937001,
-0.0020640674,
-0.0065104146,
-0.0151412245,
0.0070992419,
-0.0445832349,
-0.0388959274,
0.0489708558,
-0.0302220285,
-0.0137791419,
1.83599154e-34,
0.011918569,
-0.0021874441,
-0.0287367757,
-0.031449765,
-0.000305385,
-0.0100597888,
-0.039233122,
-0.0073277354,
-0.0206838232,
-0.064200215,
0.012216147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15455v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15455v2 | Trie-NLG: Trie Context Augmentation to Improve Personalized Query Auto-Completion for Short and Unseen Prefixes | 2023-07-28T10:17:30 | 2023-10-23T05:16:56 | Kaushal Kumar Maurya, Maunendra Sankar Desarkar, Manish Gupta, Puneet Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Query auto-completion (QAC) aims to suggest plausible completions for a given
query prefix. Traditionally, QAC systems have leveraged tries curated from
historical query logs to suggest most popular completions. In this context,
there are two specific scenarios that are difficult to handle for any QAC
system: short prefixes (which are inherently ambiguous) and unseen prefixes.
Recently, personalized Natural Language Generation (NLG) models have been
proposed to leverage previous session queries as context for addressing these
two challenges. However, such NLG models suffer from two drawbacks: (1) some of
the previous session queries could be noisy and irrelevant to the user intent
for the current prefix, and (2) NLG models cannot directly incorporate
historical query popularity. This motivates us to propose a novel NLG model for
QAC, Trie-NLG, which jointly leverages popularity signals from trie and
personalization signals from previous session queries. We train the Trie-NLG
model by augmenting the prefix with rich context comprising of recent session
queries and top trie completions. This simple modeling approach overcomes the
limitations of trie-based and NLG-based approaches and leads to
state-of-the-art performance. We evaluate the Trie-NLG model using two large
QAC datasets. On average, our model achieves huge ~57% and ~14% boost in MRR
over the popular trie-based lookup and the strong BART-based baseline methods,
respectively. We make our code publicly available. | [
0.0737266913,
0.0205246601,
-0.0165445842,
-0.0116705662,
-0.0212065894,
-0.0251895338,
-0.009056543,
-0.0061731483,
0.0082855104,
-0.0521599688,
-0.0292892009,
-0.0428016372,
-0.0143207712,
0.046453163,
0.0334511288,
-0.0457942411,
0.0352046601,
-0.0053429031,
-0.0605313741,
0.0178762265,
0.0043494171,
0.0180007648,
0.0238532946,
0.0728437454,
-0.004789663,
0.02741904,
-0.0399648659,
0.0056785434,
-0.0282090586,
-0.0253259409,
0.0030095328,
0.0613770336,
0.008992197,
0.0020078751,
0.0000017438,
-0.0633753985,
-0.0344499536,
-0.0251798667,
-0.0174080618,
-0.0277200304,
0.0138204098,
0.0558439828,
0.039675124,
0.0438835099,
-0.043463327,
0.05863728,
-0.0014945068,
0.0322170258,
0.0235127155,
0.0472793505,
0.0194884259,
0.0108347628,
-0.0244171321,
-0.0491227768,
0.0782874674,
-0.0208111387,
-0.0180559587,
-0.0154977376,
0.0440808944,
0.0247495826,
-0.0115153976,
0.0100661721,
-0.0005059082,
0.0007400027,
0.0149997035,
0.016606696,
-0.0119810402,
0.0144668333,
-0.0223307665,
0.0678359419,
-0.0149229215,
-0.0058121355,
0.0226516984,
0.0178671423,
-0.0043449523,
-0.0258860681,
-0.0226693284,
-0.0306474641,
0.0033312675,
-0.006847511,
-0.0075254948,
0.0049278471,
0.0099664144,
0.0102886828,
0.0045481585,
0.0629006624,
0.0314105637,
-0.0049948739,
-0.0347656235,
-0.009478705,
0.0345222168,
-0.0313483663,
0.0384983085,
0.0133138606,
-0.0477271862,
0.0333331898,
-0.0702753514,
0.0072231181,
0.0255974457,
-0.0055767256,
-0.0284079928,
0.0527209714,
0.0106800431,
0.0169961322,
-0.0468173772,
-0.0014646626,
0.0255930182,
-0.0060573239,
-0.0399529785,
-0.0230836626,
-0.0563607626,
-0.0058535137,
-0.055514358,
0.0410424061,
-0.0338754021,
-0.0334282219,
-0.0702040568,
0.0111191515,
0.0313087031,
-0.0269252732,
0.0554086305,
0.0867792293,
-0.0795952305,
-0.0060510379,
-0.0097567067,
-0.028922271,
-0.0539014451,
0.0023535669,
0.0550758652,
-0.0330687836,
-0.0042668711,
0.0135425301,
0.0340236947,
-0.0159372184,
-0.0152647281,
0.001640924,
-0.02472803,
-0.0705543235,
-0.0626640841,
-0.1017447934,
0.0123483492,
-0.023409104,
-0.0496683344,
-0.0431115143,
0.0379748382,
-0.0200154763,
0.0004802994,
-0.0034051139,
0.0219327882,
0.0417083278,
-0.018799752,
0.0501781814,
-0.040358454,
-0.0052814423,
0.023854956,
0.0136685027,
0.0290266648,
0.0491496138,
0.0010906637,
0.0736729652,
0.0424103476,
0.0086356159,
-0.0122923637,
-0.0023204535,
0.032491006,
0.0008476017,
-0.0376001336,
0.0100129377,
-0.0644753426,
0.0265143272,
0.0077511212,
0.0372234471,
0.0016920511,
-0.0249702856,
0.0025748801,
0.0081068706,
0.0201528855,
0.0041575325,
0.0762338117,
0.0392440483,
-0.0304153059,
0.0040915683,
-0.0229440499,
0.0072692046,
-0.0520127825,
0.0112452628,
0.0712262318,
0.0527086072,
-0.0394267626,
-0.030502975,
0.0335654989,
-0.0182220731,
-0.0182540026,
-0.0042123543,
0.0325575881,
0.0245540813,
-0.0492641367,
0.0128118945,
0.0031738563,
-0.0371322371,
0.0723531321,
-0.04280065,
0.0252947379,
0.088855356,
0.0589953363,
0.0107436366,
-0.0447179303,
-0.0187075306,
-0.0265608765,
0.0111446818,
0.0192259196,
-0.0057921666,
0.0125228669,
-0.0631012991,
-0.0564974248,
0.0494409986,
0.0141566312,
0.0120564383,
0.0395375676,
0.0252936278,
0.078107357,
-0.0357340835,
0.0273390897,
0.0027388909,
-0.0312231351,
-0.0315656811,
0.0631459504,
-0.0033848814,
0.013706129,
0.0362806283,
0.0274496339,
0.0132405935,
0.0036044181,
-0.013462292,
-0.0209761746,
0.0165990833,
-0.024266744,
-0.0387794971,
0.0045520626,
-0.0132698705,
0.0190871712,
0.0261942465,
-0.0171092674,
-0.0778212324,
-0.0107235769,
-0.0406688489,
0.0664256364,
-0.0474744923,
0.020752592,
0.0397847965,
0.0062927017,
-0.0199903678,
0.053617999,
-0.0127016855,
-0.0014361583,
0.0330608152,
-0.0057994528,
0.012160873,
-0.0492503345,
-0.0309045091,
-0.0563589558,
-0.0066584744,
0.0265405271,
0.0648494363,
0.0185873844,
-0.0667537823,
0.0199741777,
-0.0845781192,
-0.0022613606,
-0.0304121748,
-0.0003225259,
0.011406186,
0.0713588744,
-0.0219931491,
-0.0379336178,
-0.0415670834,
-0.0271499641,
0.006972651,
0.0166340247,
0.0243199952,
0.0386352539,
-0.0210986435,
-0.0680855736,
-0.0197973214,
-0.0083370637,
0.0107347108,
0.0284865499,
-0.0148380632,
-0.0263736732,
0.0032986039,
-0.0256407894,
0.0041705635,
-0.0055994284,
-0.016089974,
-0.0196516216,
-0.0405186117,
0.0140839452,
0.0015364694,
0.0364290401,
-0.0189346503,
-0.0014153171,
-0.0000266598,
-0.0651977137,
-0.0046964278,
-0.0807713717,
0.0152402604,
0.0224209633,
-0.0593453795,
0.0599156767,
0.0194401089,
0.0114576444,
-0.0070824451,
-0.0484650023,
0.0043714051,
0.0090322793,
-0.0467089973,
-0.042774424,
0.0292430744,
-0.0190843381,
0.0266097337,
0.0186980311,
-0.0223384071,
0.0980218723,
0.0014166081,
0.0224029124,
-0.0592245199,
-0.0112296697,
-0.0391685627,
0.0265854429,
-0.0090333801,
0.0354625061,
-0.0048569846,
-0.0856587365,
-0.0241050906,
-0.0203860756,
-0.0185047891,
-0.0189223699,
0.0372221917,
0.0047489447,
-0.001836967,
0.0743235126,
-0.0006077984,
-0.0639902428,
-0.0458566509,
-0.0152127426,
-0.0081120674,
0.054803092,
-0.0388491452,
-0.0183624197,
0.0016993682,
-0.0041712429,
0.0119254738,
-0.0254714116,
-0.0404762998,
-0.000919502,
0.0363203995,
0.0787877142,
0.0187660251,
0.0003765654,
0.0136451842,
-0.0300043728,
0.0280218832,
0.1018212214,
-0.0407422185,
0.0041585136,
-0.0131746484,
0.0436835401,
-0.058547359,
-0.0114695998,
0.072010465,
-0.0198824294,
-0.0136612207,
-0.0335103273,
0.094901368,
0.0559897684,
-0.0297466535,
0.0000169718,
0.007796498,
0.0482049286,
0.0217427164,
0.0514594913,
-0.0740481466,
-0.037758138,
-0.0093683377,
0.0545755178,
-0.0032666775,
-0.035565611,
-0.0323914886,
-0.1358712912,
0.0080792131,
-0.0052542593,
0.010694907,
0.0103087202,
-0.0077544586,
0.0085658329,
-0.0019321401,
0.0178415794,
0.0186436139,
-0.0237271935,
0.0198746361,
0.0262392741,
-0.0224284399,
-0.0743273124,
-0.0112827225,
-0.0499767922,
0.0213175751,
0.003841918,
0.0187282041,
0.0281207897,
0.0080061313,
0.0133619439,
0.046704296,
0.0407908224,
-0.0295750257,
0.0397973582,
-0.0037741193,
0.0093561681,
-0.0353079699,
-0.0063683311,
-0.0356936269,
0.0196977891,
0.0059634023,
0.0422896035,
-0.0351312831,
0.0459603556,
-0.0390676185,
0.0213844813,
0.0198664237,
0.0618102103,
0.0221675672,
-0.0369105339,
-0.0221224073,
-0.0151723539,
0.0226014331,
-0.0534212328,
-0.0076914905,
-0.0062304647,
-0.0243797656,
-0.0038089918,
-0.0776211843,
-0.050685361,
0.0201934408,
0.0597673282,
0.0340370871,
0.0472067893,
0.0090501821,
-0.0172478259,
-0.0288567822,
0.0078077675,
-0.0217378326,
-0.0283442773,
-0.0861755684,
0.0004631924,
0.0439983197,
-0.0713680759,
0.0015543358,
0.0239644907,
-0.0516392812,
-0.0412667729,
-0.0267642904,
0.0654211193,
0.0183740724,
0.0443921275,
-0.049560532,
-0.0742870942,
0.0009008003,
0.0464991294,
0.0188127235,
-0.0363421887,
-0.0125553366,
0.0015935227,
-0.0174952839,
0.0343747251,
-0.0566547848,
-0.0460643284,
-0.0627669469,
0.0468965285,
-0.0176875833,
-0.027392447,
0.0462195352,
0.0096185338,
0.0274151452,
-0.0515475832,
0.0665708482,
-0.0189990252,
0.0271041337,
-0.0272997655,
-0.0043110005,
-0.025401745,
0.0178087465,
0.0241374113,
0.0043708291,
0.0021149945,
-0.0216540974,
-0.0689508915,
0.0531788878,
-0.0440833494,
-0.0302707404,
-0.0508705862,
-0.0115769319,
0.0402920693,
0.0083067045,
0.0082204696,
0.0142533304,
0.0574213415,
0.0395938046,
-0.0622867979,
0.0381815024,
-0.0119784204,
-0.0052889171,
-0.0186405182,
0.0540759154,
-0.046550177,
-0.0273793899,
-0.0512632579,
0.0029622125,
0.0535960048,
-0.0219563171,
0.0098986514,
-0.0176529028,
0.0133118862,
-0.02096048,
0.0470315814,
0.0138231218,
-0.0299787838,
-0.0317941234,
-0.0032151283,
-0.0327097662,
0.0316959955,
0.0855979249,
-0.0087077422,
0.017672576,
0.0109395152,
-0.0560725331,
-0.0390725173,
0.006196524,
0.0184781235,
0.0493251719,
-0.0347536504,
-0.0060567698,
-0.0392501317,
-0.0477774553,
0.0474233553,
-0.0294144079,
0.0036954279,
0.027377218,
0.1173383892,
0.0777492002,
-0.0187876746,
-0.014884945,
-0.0507400222,
-0.0103277387,
-0.0162360054,
-0.0385088623,
0.007504845,
-6.124882826e-33,
-0.0132387429,
-0.0245307051,
0.0137783,
-0.0254936721,
-0.0061331047,
-0.0082791764,
-0.0251951944,
0.0018750422,
0.0255749952,
-0.0322201736,
-0.0286369212,
-0.0081815645,
0.0234537628,
0.0477452278,
0.0110619785,
-0.0336588882,
0.0518399514,
0.01314345,
0.0080048544,
0.0439908616,
0.0500828624,
0.078022927,
0.0065517351,
-0.0679383799,
-0.0071863793,
0.010484051,
-0.0080323108,
0.0035655128,
0.014002095,
0.0905109867,
-0.0100880321,
0.05780489,
0.0116086509,
-0.0270896554,
-0.0105431834,
-0.021237921,
-0.047506582,
-0.047727894,
0.0191344414,
-0.0142151238,
-0.0202173293,
0.005417834,
0.0334234238,
-0.0503866039,
-0.0232990459,
0.070208095,
0.0350660644,
0.0086059235,
-0.0363635942,
-0.0764758438,
-0.0259596854,
0.0140064834,
0.0069371373,
-0.0296902061,
0.0168086626,
0.0661415607,
0.009839165,
0.0002829548,
-0.0096367607,
0.0420712382,
-0.0023190293,
0.0297378656,
0.0629791766,
0.0212926529,
-0.0234889202,
0.0334428847,
0.0197636392,
0.0047039902,
0.0180401076,
0.0021374887,
-0.0084548593,
0.0385215282,
-0.0140017476,
0.0300891791,
-0.0085922768,
0.004388643,
0.0059639756,
0.0808806345,
0.0447789468,
-0.0072522247,
-0.0032721614,
-0.0422170982,
-0.0669470504,
-0.0085533354,
-0.0231309105,
0.0242177099,
-0.0496658832,
-0.02695648,
0.0606025085,
0.0486334115,
-0.0439251661,
-0.0018228067,
0.0205073282,
-0.0098699294,
-0.0333737247,
0.0265886243,
-0.0032573882,
-0.0420455076,
0.0054923929,
0.0270260535,
-0.013035153,
0.0127281696,
0.0110643432,
-0.0616810359,
-0.0363530926,
-0.02686961,
-0.0235958062,
0.0334153101,
-0.0352979898,
0.0158840492,
0.0006076847,
0.031211542,
-0.0165398512,
-0.0227630921,
0.0551660545,
0.0130801778,
-0.043741148,
0.0785329789,
0.042687837,
0.0292380862,
-0.0026024526,
-0.0668119639,
0.0258297604,
0.03518131,
-0.0114212399,
0.0087857414,
-0.0135921491,
-0.0005611084,
0.058771845,
-0.0273057558,
-0.0223144218,
-0.0098307086,
2.579e-7,
0.01579828,
0.036894992,
0.0294574406,
0.0298627671,
-0.0552025028,
0.0301394127,
0.0239774715,
0.0530639365,
-0.0036433868,
0.0161863323,
0.0178180635,
-0.0499532893,
0.0006221706,
-0.007198601,
-0.0677213594,
0.0177699197,
-0.0396828689,
-0.0107084233,
-0.0549037308,
-0.0357925072,
0.0387498811,
0.0679552034,
0.0260922741,
-0.0053043389,
-0.0223380756,
-0.0427915864,
0.0327251591,
-0.0118847629,
-0.0739310384,
0.047815714,
0.0788824335,
0.0318561792,
0.006462662,
-0.031185355,
-0.0540843867,
0.017147487,
0.028283203,
0.0141348187,
0.0232954733,
-0.0634588078,
0.0156105906,
-0.0046539619,
0.0284913722,
-0.0003050877,
0.0437878743,
-0.0090501793,
0.0468608923,
0.0314906873,
-0.0104466015,
0.0130826691,
0.0165227875,
-0.0380971581,
-0.026970733,
0.0018047318,
0.0311565716,
0.0437587127,
-0.0106239431,
-0.0888779089,
0.0047768927,
-0.014379452,
-0.0581855476,
0.0165338367,
-0.0314721242,
0.0146472631,
-0.0167478304,
-0.0167936627,
-0.0131798545,
2.409482173e-34,
0.0390732847,
0.035721872,
0.0139759658,
0.0220492519,
0.0270410888,
0.0062779835,
0.0081471745,
0.0036361455,
0.0777601004,
-0.058230143,
-0.0571653545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15453v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15453v2 | From Probabilistic Programming to Complexity-based Programming | 2023-07-28T10:11:01 | 2023-09-11T14:06:27 | Giovanni Sileno, Jean-Louis Dessalles | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The paper presents the main characteristics and a preliminary implementation
of a novel computational framework named CompLog. Inspired by probabilistic
programming systems like ProbLog, CompLog builds upon the inferential
mechanisms proposed by Simplicity Theory, relying on the computation of two
Kolmogorov complexities (here implemented as min-path searches via ASP
programs) rather than probabilistic inference. The proposed system enables
users to compute ex-post and ex-ante measures of unexpectedness of a certain
situation, mapping respectively to posterior and prior subjective
probabilities. The computation is based on the specification of world and
mental models by means of causal and descriptive relations between predicates
weighted by complexity. The paper illustrates a few examples of application:
generating relevant descriptions, and providing alternative approaches to
disjunction and to negation. | [
0.002929592,
0.0278389659,
-0.0241539683,
-0.0221666433,
-0.055915989,
0.0053924774,
-0.0799774081,
-0.0424060822,
0.0284454823,
0.001812803,
0.0756564289,
0.0222906303,
-0.0041096043,
0.0511722192,
-0.0037229317,
-0.0727715567,
0.026522018,
-0.0124301864,
0.0220082644,
-0.0108842077,
-0.0147350598,
-0.0480194539,
-0.0378339216,
0.0496926866,
0.0437316522,
-0.0080353916,
-0.0188548714,
0.0248968508,
-0.0121670244,
-0.033855848,
-0.0586145371,
0.0241318848,
-0.016094435,
0.0016257882,
0.0000023581,
-0.0725392848,
-0.0226474777,
0.0172836259,
-0.0101839695,
-0.0090301223,
-0.0437545441,
0.0647528768,
-0.0043096794,
0.0141746467,
-0.016122289,
0.0173276048,
0.0811587125,
-0.0045397235,
-0.0292603653,
-0.001547846,
-0.0170643106,
0.002277965,
-0.0338361934,
-0.0003911985,
0.0621360764,
0.0055977558,
0.0147013515,
-0.0405361988,
0.0350959711,
-0.0592111871,
0.0083319675,
-0.0238328055,
0.0190101992,
0.0185613334,
-0.0130061917,
0.0053963899,
0.0595110059,
-0.0245516188,
-0.0139755988,
0.0004337254,
0.0376894437,
-0.0201827753,
0.0136052091,
-0.0207272284,
-0.0007067829,
0.0232197065,
-0.0044648959,
0.030918749,
-0.0364767276,
0.007780354,
0.0045259777,
0.0623377077,
0.0258448664,
-0.021629462,
-0.0141383549,
0.0587970503,
-0.0107046142,
-0.0030688795,
-0.0110819675,
0.0215717535,
0.0007147767,
-0.0196729228,
-0.0085710492,
0.0011406597,
0.0085308859,
-0.0157900844,
0.0154552953,
0.0177892447,
-0.006883855,
-0.0333799683,
0.0777519643,
0.0162308775,
0.0510158129,
0.0386272408,
0.0426425934,
0.0341320261,
-0.0025773901,
-0.0759020522,
-0.0226930864,
0.0417043902,
-0.0303305145,
0.0145639842,
0.0045230836,
0.0136040607,
-0.0262072515,
-0.0025074196,
-0.0455415584,
0.0398430452,
-0.0736205205,
0.0075479145,
-0.070727624,
-0.0104003865,
-0.0064587519,
0.0128083592,
-0.1042802483,
-0.0274718795,
-0.0537479632,
-0.007829003,
-0.0118524246,
-0.0090946434,
0.0205999091,
0.0015460839,
0.0114145512,
0.0173583329,
-0.0106304642,
0.0705243498,
0.0280275866,
0.0153663736,
-0.052336514,
-0.0678916872,
0.0215053018,
-0.0083743297,
-0.0067184479,
-0.0902952999,
-0.023313256,
0.003819254,
-0.0190933701,
-0.024878772,
-0.0050497726,
-0.0242450982,
0.0083859516,
0.0606113859,
-0.0289580002,
0.0159183331,
-0.0296974629,
0.0127733722,
-0.0281859543,
0.0467802882,
-0.0297607817,
0.0082343863,
0.0051392922,
0.0236279946,
0.0810641646,
-0.0173634142,
-0.0277610235,
-0.0284141041,
0.0242890082,
-0.0104392981,
-0.0156269073,
-0.0428326689,
-0.054953523,
0.0210328419,
-0.028652424,
0.0509158075,
-0.0073546437,
-0.0277746879,
0.0294443462,
-0.0079040611,
0.0275016334,
-0.0054229065,
0.0199678428,
0.0359175317,
-0.0413892828,
0.075243555,
-0.0637339354,
0.013856845,
0.0134436451,
-0.0377725363,
-0.0013674451,
-0.0868003666,
0.0100957435,
0.0021721967,
0.0262698494,
-0.0069391099,
0.0621226095,
-0.0090790391,
-0.0014733945,
-0.0567303821,
0.0067307232,
-0.0165227614,
-0.0717019066,
-0.045955997,
0.0055227065,
0.0737682283,
0.0247634221,
-0.075706169,
0.0521416776,
0.0103325918,
-0.0376523994,
-0.052331917,
0.0443985946,
0.0203603394,
0.0045538051,
-0.0064556296,
-0.0102852294,
0.0192287359,
0.0444764793,
0.0331370793,
0.0273318887,
-0.0104389666,
-0.0175949503,
0.0550323725,
0.0174617805,
-0.016318569,
0.0282754917,
-0.0023501809,
-0.0055511724,
0.0098689515,
0.0361671671,
0.0026091516,
-0.024759613,
0.0585672669,
0.0476995111,
-0.0098999469,
-0.0283344965,
0.0153029868,
0.0386078767,
0.0121547608,
0.0273488089,
-0.0996574685,
0.0127592376,
-0.00834083,
0.0038343312,
-0.0252553504,
0.0660095587,
-0.0456459746,
0.0057376027,
0.0071272179,
0.0300962217,
-0.0238926467,
-0.0143654067,
-0.0209620818,
0.0357475653,
0.015441725,
0.0443612114,
-0.0076306327,
-0.0530490763,
0.0488683321,
-0.0346857458,
-0.0250758287,
-0.0589825585,
-0.015394873,
-0.0037034706,
0.053419482,
-0.0122084003,
0.019514123,
-0.0070468667,
-0.0625181198,
0.0017999591,
0.0159985945,
0.0235649012,
-0.0246545896,
0.0128940511,
0.0067492211,
-0.0093098693,
0.0244311988,
0.0402678363,
-0.0180842672,
0.0258561056,
0.0246749576,
0.0085362084,
-0.0601837002,
-0.0118881827,
-0.019195687,
-0.0342079736,
0.0198187698,
0.052164156,
-0.0221607853,
0.0020731888,
0.0190193523,
-0.0081991134,
0.0105297845,
-0.0258960202,
0.0070755766,
0.0194606464,
-0.036254365,
0.0467300452,
-0.0187313892,
-0.0608525686,
0.0421297327,
0.0860424787,
-0.0168034267,
0.0153940301,
-0.0001928299,
-0.0159377307,
-0.021107642,
0.0201140027,
-0.0913973004,
-0.015551704,
0.0114800334,
-0.0100831948,
-0.0192627031,
-0.0359611921,
0.0456246324,
-0.0159208588,
-0.0206241272,
0.0312713943,
-0.0300979186,
0.0118537107,
0.1025488824,
-0.0042201951,
-0.0366947092,
0.0694005415,
0.0229519382,
0.0384741612,
-0.0229188763,
-0.0364434049,
0.0305863526,
0.0837316066,
0.0432825089,
0.0270459019,
0.0364439599,
0.0348839909,
-0.0342383757,
-0.018591471,
0.0499344356,
-0.0209678188,
-0.0073020309,
-0.0706913769,
-0.0372451767,
0.0135790762,
-0.0221093036,
0.0013936766,
0.0068489257,
-0.0278769936,
-0.0224350262,
0.0505722687,
-0.0061795684,
-0.0090043629,
-0.0017962729,
0.0089037428,
0.0108994991,
0.022388164,
-0.046332635,
0.0105195828,
-0.0887793601,
0.0160541832,
-0.0265721343,
0.0797350854,
-0.0329202451,
-0.0133450767,
0.0352440923,
0.0017415435,
0.0227750335,
0.0026158988,
-0.012197854,
-0.0190518852,
0.0188835263,
-0.0277015157,
0.083372198,
-0.0326650776,
0.004338704,
0.026147671,
0.0478541255,
0.0377806537,
0.0089564063,
0.0276315622,
-0.0616572239,
-0.0018011781,
0.058746513,
0.0380505472,
-0.0559355021,
-0.0024039056,
-0.0066463412,
0.0339659601,
-0.0884225741,
-0.0534416921,
0.0342750587,
-0.0337704867,
0.0396738574,
-0.0108067719,
-0.0026685395,
-0.0687869564,
-0.0471853428,
-0.0150389336,
0.0058859289,
-0.136874035,
0.0162868872,
-0.0028166806,
0.0363795981,
-0.0154834809,
-0.0792315081,
-0.0342062637,
-0.0179432873,
-0.002991165,
0.0446176194,
0.0068365121,
-0.02512623,
-0.0316723846,
0.0325946026,
-0.0130867297,
0.031288363,
0.0110433921,
-0.0315991975,
-0.0006926766,
0.0724533647,
-0.02620106,
-0.0754008293,
-0.0250181444,
-0.0054701199,
-0.0050225016,
0.0482166931,
0.0644280538,
-0.0313150808,
-0.046920184,
-0.0428588241,
-0.0169333573,
0.0363071077,
0.0794908553,
-0.0076555088,
0.0145836566,
-0.0402951501,
-0.0636409745,
-0.0346962288,
0.0352031253,
0.009963478,
-0.0333578363,
0.0302900039,
-0.0646123737,
-0.0282621477,
-0.0054062326,
0.021327924,
0.04421537,
-0.0227163713,
-0.0237012189,
0.0287537668,
0.0287741441,
-0.1212693155,
-0.040466439,
0.0394399986,
0.0350924917,
0.0218384322,
0.039425835,
-0.0016954092,
0.0029114839,
-0.0397290029,
0.0188877024,
-0.0422822647,
-0.0340298191,
0.0173668656,
0.0569453947,
0.0423070416,
-0.0590591058,
-0.021998629,
-0.0111918561,
-0.0207435843,
0.0217124838,
0.0111865355,
0.0246760473,
0.043997664,
0.0086471224,
0.0161914509,
-0.0022571634,
-0.0322770067,
-0.0257203504,
-0.0295983814,
0.0436110571,
-0.0198568236,
-0.014129892,
-0.0202531181,
0.0436614007,
0.0350752063,
0.0360515676,
-0.0408295058,
-0.0148042822,
-0.0107055055,
-0.0153043522,
-0.0315795727,
-0.0473730676,
-0.0144923329,
0.0035430193,
0.0576158054,
0.005594797,
0.0107040526,
0.0026943369,
-0.0382559672,
0.0378416665,
0.0220564473,
0.0795453265,
-0.010770658,
0.0484139472,
-0.0276613906,
-0.0036959255,
0.0143838637,
-0.0010021623,
0.0263032764,
-0.0001937011,
-0.013222063,
0.0365026742,
-0.0031227784,
-0.0090190591,
-0.0480623879,
-0.0281881504,
-0.0430405699,
0.0430250354,
0.0688021258,
0.040222019,
0.0293304343,
0.0099924421,
-0.0788287148,
0.0149950627,
-0.0271006394,
-0.006605648,
0.0146038411,
0.0348696858,
0.0067798328,
0.0293117203,
-0.0053243069,
-0.0452717729,
0.0794830024,
-0.0002275119,
0.004688812,
-0.0578676201,
-0.0412839316,
-0.0268493462,
-0.0396944135,
-0.0420532227,
0.1185171157,
-0.0061286977,
0.0249504671,
-0.0828372836,
-0.0259147696,
0.0044132755,
0.0425802916,
0.0237227213,
-0.0059471745,
0.0423398651,
0.0472868904,
0.0220023859,
-0.0261734799,
0.0083034625,
-0.002641306,
-0.0084989518,
0.012810342,
-0.0129124643,
-6.929539933e-33,
-0.0176992994,
-0.0383676775,
-0.0133461878,
0.0217215624,
0.0413704403,
-0.0563769713,
-0.02330851,
0.0723972246,
-0.0020256091,
0.0479741059,
0.0555251837,
0.0177558754,
0.0033652815,
-0.0432548225,
0.0128056286,
0.0294338726,
0.02111472,
0.0328167006,
0.0009145635,
-0.0793025196,
0.0089921216,
-0.0341731198,
-0.0188711919,
-0.0898353979,
-0.0096086506,
0.0115696974,
-0.0001662226,
0.035066694,
0.0036998903,
0.00798182,
0.0316158868,
0.0245271735,
-0.0006456386,
-0.0005098831,
0.0036805635,
-0.0452320725,
0.000295107,
-0.0717828199,
0.0389642492,
-0.0274332128,
0.0082311872,
-0.034246143,
0.0049187397,
0.0230573583,
-0.0377777331,
0.0138362842,
0.0364607386,
-0.0242618844,
0.0275497343,
-0.005093107,
-0.0045180754,
-0.0027773681,
-0.0136825126,
0.0099463677,
-0.0105323736,
-0.0008527657,
-0.0303360019,
-0.0706288591,
0.0459134318,
0.0439489223,
0.0495286882,
-0.0035263023,
0.0284650829,
0.0041245189,
0.0404068716,
-0.0126907257,
0.0544358119,
-0.007982878,
-0.0633672401,
-0.0167601481,
-0.014968277,
0.0154677667,
0.026523225,
0.0561916679,
0.0326982029,
0.03365843,
-0.1271924525,
0.040190246,
0.025819337,
0.0045904522,
0.05810339,
0.0010754385,
-0.0754043385,
-0.0642553344,
-0.0088488031,
0.0208643749,
-0.042837441,
0.0025546579,
0.0088887578,
-0.0167654064,
-0.0104458025,
0.0172149334,
-0.0336536355,
-0.0130908201,
-0.0219037365,
0.0041222065,
0.0251429342,
-0.0158652738,
0.0066565364,
0.0120790228,
0.0163267646,
0.0107737025,
-0.0066355309,
0.0087259384,
0.0445325039,
0.0397256725,
-0.0463477522,
0.0122783678,
-0.0455140509,
-0.0124357715,
-0.0239886027,
0.0036949159,
0.019338131,
-0.0559267551,
0.0281826332,
-0.0251332521,
0.0041540805,
-0.0025907832,
-0.0115441578,
0.0068125124,
-0.0249618702,
0.0463655405,
-0.0118463449,
0.0175458938,
0.0023967475,
-0.0417681597,
-0.0379028507,
0.0010790128,
-0.0011252759,
-0.0183725674,
-0.0458150096,
0.0310827587,
3.176e-7,
0.0105330497,
0.030736519,
-0.0125410547,
0.0842618942,
0.0429961272,
0.0311317388,
0.0024330888,
-0.0286760516,
0.0104010701,
0.0028073315,
0.0197165515,
0.0225394685,
0.0127263609,
-0.0001274053,
-0.0066990172,
-0.0053595672,
0.0385752432,
-0.0116792694,
0.0099581266,
0.0463397242,
0.1405969858,
0.026968237,
0.061132472,
0.0486175157,
0.037480589,
-0.0377969071,
-0.0124064777,
-0.0566766784,
0.0635951981,
-0.0069868257,
0.004376167,
0.0203839466,
0.0071931849,
0.0528356396,
-0.0036145612,
-0.0379854999,
0.0014465095,
0.0402438827,
-0.0167685859,
0.0265016239,
0.0363293663,
-0.0588316359,
-0.0014285219,
-0.0214863345,
0.0538738295,
-0.0439422801,
-0.0229658484,
0.0402528495,
-0.0526322238,
-0.0376375839,
0.0136826215,
0.0428176001,
-0.0540497266,
-0.0633869916,
-0.0019017338,
0.0246695373,
0.0121955089,
0.0109223248,
-0.0233925115,
0.0222455189,
0.0260574184,
-0.0716779977,
-0.0387751982,
0.0118069844,
0.0165087823,
-0.0258623734,
-0.0073860893,
3.43926252e-34,
0.0518028997,
0.0269742031,
0.0070849885,
-0.0971850604,
0.0191740375,
0.000283577,
-0.0537611395,
-0.0123237576,
0.0521416441,
-0.0257804897,
-0.0291911177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15432v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15432v2 | CFN-ESA: A Cross-Modal Fusion Network with Emotion-Shift Awareness for Dialogue Emotion Recognition | 2023-07-28T09:29:42 | 2024-04-13T01:05:05 | Jiang Li, Xiaoping Wang, Yingjian Liu, Zhigang Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal emotion recognition in conversation (ERC) has garnered growing
attention from research communities in various fields. In this paper, we
propose a Cross-modal Fusion Network with Emotion-Shift Awareness (CFN-ESA) for
ERC. Extant approaches employ each modality equally without distinguishing the
amount of emotional information in these modalities, rendering it hard to
adequately extract complementary information from multimodal data. To cope with
this problem, in CFN-ESA, we treat textual modality as the primary source of
emotional information, while visual and acoustic modalities are taken as the
secondary sources. Besides, most multimodal ERC models ignore emotion-shift
information and overfocus on contextual information, leading to the failure of
emotion recognition under emotion-shift scenario. We elaborate an emotion-shift
module to address this challenge. CFN-ESA mainly consists of unimodal encoder
(RUME), cross-modal encoder (ACME), and emotion-shift module (LESM). RUME is
applied to extract conversation-level contextual emotional cues while pulling
together data distributions between modalities; ACME is utilized to perform
multimodal interaction centered on textual modality; LESM is used to model
emotion shift and capture emotion-shift information, thereby guiding the
learning of the main task. Experimental results demonstrate that CFN-ESA can
effectively promote performance for ERC and remarkably outperform
state-of-the-art models. | [
0.0134897884,
0.0691121742,
-0.0010143756,
0.0468498878,
0.0084958402,
0.0097100148,
0.0217472222,
-0.0351825021,
-0.0234908443,
-0.0637614354,
-0.0752759948,
-0.0079195714,
-0.0064040851,
0.0348172076,
0.0043246793,
-0.0563981198,
0.0071415929,
0.0452805236,
-0.0032196101,
0.0101168575,
0.0373400077,
0.0317294672,
-0.0577278845,
0.0185282174,
-0.0649448931,
-0.0109180948,
-0.0474099107,
0.041868519,
0.0446019694,
-0.0330801792,
0.014020971,
0.0113322185,
0.0400857031,
-0.016410267,
0.000001925,
-0.0030486344,
-0.0012174356,
-0.0247577336,
-0.0076033757,
-0.0381943993,
0.051896695,
-0.0259323213,
-0.0289757047,
0.009023306,
0.002772833,
0.0085428404,
0.0724631101,
0.0572733842,
0.0756483823,
0.0819948688,
-0.0426285975,
-0.0116100479,
0.0259944871,
-0.0146332476,
-0.0004088992,
-0.0191479828,
-0.0027729759,
-0.0048444667,
-0.0081528425,
-0.0424458981,
-0.0766720623,
0.011279162,
0.0017817486,
-0.0039429497,
0.0102288118,
0.0273849983,
-0.0089969002,
-0.0206815414,
-0.0461087823,
0.0915270597,
-0.0193706974,
0.0474265628,
-0.0265262797,
-0.0031679706,
0.0228151884,
-0.0076624863,
-0.0231106468,
-0.0041162842,
-0.0126087843,
0.0043638139,
-0.0519714653,
0.03627811,
0.0001594975,
-0.0020840445,
-0.0105359927,
-0.0048798211,
-0.0326033272,
0.0043567773,
0.0274580941,
0.0021865661,
-0.0072218115,
-0.0071725626,
-0.0074223923,
-0.0092608072,
0.0112217525,
0.0112876752,
-0.0335438065,
-0.0077741691,
-0.0361800045,
-0.0232133828,
-0.0220885146,
0.0166726653,
-0.0757786557,
0.0458289608,
0.0142557248,
0.005891196,
-0.0339411832,
0.0010357315,
-0.022067057,
-0.0472842529,
-0.0399998613,
0.011432468,
0.011296317,
-0.0067961873,
-0.0555932075,
-0.0787625238,
-0.072488457,
0.0075691273,
-0.0119295092,
0.010268366,
0.010937917,
0.0172373336,
0.0065251123,
0.004088657,
-0.0003130603,
0.0670084879,
0.0076676691,
0.0621552356,
0.0153819257,
-0.0553472526,
-0.0088395877,
0.0288552288,
0.0205510668,
-0.0221677441,
0.0357051082,
0.0807081833,
-0.0297894161,
-0.0345115699,
-0.0233719423,
-0.0057737357,
-0.0656908378,
-0.036392387,
0.0604729392,
0.0157859921,
0.0658403412,
-0.025817994,
0.017020328,
0.0087516503,
0.000049223,
-0.0669770762,
0.0035842101,
0.0800075009,
0.0014695995,
-0.0174190681,
0.020219015,
-0.0025045758,
-0.0337861925,
0.0490688682,
0.0346226245,
0.0445646532,
0.0429993272,
-0.0159460735,
0.0318013243,
0.0312210992,
-0.0098221255,
-0.0276117679,
0.0054167556,
-0.0595842041,
-0.0019417385,
0.0481294356,
0.0551154204,
0.0097252373,
-0.0387636684,
-0.0294443294,
0.033679951,
0.0056885728,
0.0026322687,
0.0358726494,
-0.0256588385,
0.0192813668,
-0.0101333065,
-0.0231884513,
-0.0212324597,
0.0747403949,
-0.0360356718,
-0.0382467061,
0.0461452007,
0.0133352811,
-0.0261753798,
-0.022203451,
0.012145509,
-0.038646128,
-0.0044119107,
0.0136838686,
0.0338653214,
-0.0219225697,
-0.0569554418,
0.0075784484,
0.0202496033,
-0.0518258438,
-0.0123339165,
0.0139329704,
-0.0003957344,
0.0337759815,
0.0102199288,
-0.0502933376,
-0.0370170176,
-0.0128141269,
-0.0241956636,
0.0195389409,
0.0060414989,
-0.0093360757,
0.0877195075,
-0.0792045891,
-0.0346461758,
-0.0121870097,
-0.0111142714,
0.0356786922,
-0.0616113022,
0.0313981064,
-0.0020597933,
0.0131998081,
0.0965654179,
-0.0065096011,
-0.0166795291,
0.024494715,
-0.0168268066,
0.0279017463,
0.0381953418,
0.00656329,
-0.0136044109,
-0.0317780748,
-0.0001473739,
-0.0371498615,
0.0024151832,
0.0554868877,
-0.0603735298,
-0.053805571,
0.0331158303,
-0.033548288,
0.0167202037,
0.0049963654,
-0.0540786944,
-0.0429279134,
0.0493291728,
0.0001722647,
0.0434357002,
-0.0351104699,
0.0012777508,
0.0202814825,
0.0585285686,
0.0546452589,
0.0003262952,
-0.0128602525,
-0.028625926,
0.0055698142,
0.0075292191,
-0.0024448433,
0.0014750831,
-0.0171118043,
0.0276250225,
0.0019401771,
0.0001444509,
-0.0207174923,
-0.0242896788,
-0.0637340993,
-0.0599987097,
-0.1222931966,
-0.0052337507,
0.0073819603,
-0.0128949303,
-0.0038613926,
0.0222225059,
-0.0385479704,
-0.0289849471,
-0.0415096469,
0.0505777225,
0.0267304555,
0.0017920501,
-0.0031486726,
0.0163753554,
0.0234308597,
-0.0740620196,
0.0263948068,
0.007717825,
0.0452233143,
-0.0557686612,
-0.0310413111,
-0.003682714,
-0.0082014361,
-0.0366047248,
0.0614791922,
-0.0343594886,
-0.0658500046,
-0.014261011,
0.0049055726,
0.0099218162,
0.0388799869,
0.0165828299,
0.0692011937,
-0.0116773238,
-0.0609931983,
-0.0435535461,
0.059216693,
0.0213662852,
0.0358684435,
-0.0325458199,
0.0246744063,
-0.0142464777,
0.0455215313,
-0.0073010703,
0.0399674065,
-0.0292448569,
-0.0281960089,
0.073584795,
-0.0770003796,
-0.0048822914,
-0.0299422015,
-0.0118123787,
-0.0205908008,
-0.0285427906,
-0.0118858106,
0.025980711,
-0.0152292969,
-0.0623187087,
-0.047409866,
-0.0107299592,
-0.0195376351,
0.0464386269,
-0.0571589954,
0.0129776718,
0.0175432041,
-0.0058675003,
-0.0216863696,
-0.0490052812,
-0.000313862,
-0.029779939,
0.0253980309,
0.0007642109,
-0.0322458595,
0.008639928,
-0.0170567539,
-0.0100972159,
-0.0558361784,
-0.0361498408,
-0.0152045256,
-0.0258075725,
-0.0114664026,
-0.024325436,
-0.0247425064,
0.0453327931,
-0.0169603117,
0.0090800514,
-0.0027937347,
0.003607569,
0.0807446837,
0.0338430367,
0.0419849418,
-0.01701984,
-0.0383913517,
0.0495698079,
0.0451405607,
0.0120945452,
-0.0070217475,
-0.0228122491,
0.0326956958,
-0.0024385436,
0.0667402148,
-0.0207473245,
-0.0335848704,
0.0549426451,
0.0084703714,
0.0369721092,
0.0758575499,
0.0080202566,
-0.0640445575,
-0.0128372051,
-0.0105854236,
0.0066000195,
-0.0086206542,
0.0045848764,
-0.031726934,
-0.0611230545,
0.007699965,
-0.0062239631,
0.0325445905,
-0.0043456149,
-0.0193366557,
-0.0655445382,
0.0126300827,
0.0077595385,
-0.0187888909,
-0.0225626808,
-0.0140097607,
0.0520805307,
-0.0113895535,
0.0049705789,
-0.0620820411,
0.0278809592,
-0.0344535932,
0.0551914871,
0.0400407761,
-0.0523498096,
0.0060238461,
-0.0257713534,
0.0225626919,
0.0017860356,
0.0832944363,
-0.0144341737,
-0.03761838,
0.0592132993,
-0.0057423031,
-0.002086577,
-0.0007670861,
0.0541879907,
-0.0659192279,
-0.0142122749,
0.0153813148,
0.0091936504,
-0.011852799,
-0.0047088964,
-0.0276595708,
0.0440634005,
-0.0325181,
0.0055729509,
-0.0246002879,
0.0300044157,
0.0200220551,
0.0099434005,
-0.0051644417,
-0.0517027676,
0.001829952,
0.0029220083,
0.0252399817,
0.0084471954,
0.0295599252,
0.013176024,
0.0154325999,
-0.031626787,
-0.0434631817,
-0.0484735668,
-0.0180085972,
0.0208607055,
-0.0218485035,
-0.0506633893,
-0.0161621794,
0.015288271,
-0.0037524265,
0.0355642848,
0.0175418202,
0.0196283162,
0.0057662819,
0.0370228626,
0.0404725522,
-0.0189725347,
0.0144598428,
0.0098385513,
-0.0030162598,
-0.0452966988,
-0.0325094834,
0.0168776009,
0.0074185524,
0.0261848886,
0.0467051454,
-0.0068233828,
0.0398009717,
0.0185726136,
-0.0343231112,
0.0217512585,
0.0655290782,
0.0158001408,
-0.0345234983,
-0.0013195518,
-0.0392277427,
0.0455681011,
-0.0274586864,
0.0090554822,
-0.0207473207,
-0.103273809,
-0.0290570576,
-0.0527457073,
0.0428055227,
0.0075939386,
0.0073110755,
-0.0439157747,
-0.0049212668,
0.0180416368,
0.0336133465,
-0.0686078221,
-0.0237374436,
-0.012642663,
-0.0173803549,
-0.0322926044,
-0.0080101676,
0.0302240718,
-0.0102889063,
0.0032134578,
0.0292836018,
0.0701684877,
0.0069987252,
-0.0643498898,
0.0400297865,
0.008447025,
-0.014654858,
0.0179168191,
-0.0043401401,
-0.0164882299,
0.0983839706,
0.01244146,
-0.0758028328,
0.010291216,
0.0767148882,
0.0071796817,
0.0780771151,
-0.0167740081,
0.0110033862,
0.0376512446,
-0.0064207292,
0.0304872673,
-0.0090732677,
0.0313928649,
-0.0018490879,
0.048072584,
-0.0470489524,
-0.0405714363,
0.0579014197,
-0.0107639031,
-0.0279199909,
0.0161346775,
0.0083727874,
-0.0663311779,
0.0549670607,
-0.0395459421,
0.0063573667,
-0.0648496449,
0.0015513877,
0.1011039391,
-0.0275414325,
0.0117713893,
0.0439874455,
-0.0137202376,
-0.0341147482,
0.0502877943,
-0.0138588101,
-0.0175799243,
0.0012717936,
0.0214552935,
0.0499797091,
-0.0055449535,
0.0189814568,
-0.0176668204,
0.0018429427,
-0.0314628445,
0.0187897552,
0.0187531207,
-5.297861571e-33,
-0.0203724522,
0.0149572203,
-0.0285837464,
-0.0265694764,
-0.0548001863,
0.0314125977,
-0.0268131569,
0.038440004,
-0.0064816233,
0.0257545393,
0.0132924365,
0.0336429365,
0.0044121365,
0.0194651261,
-0.0090318108,
0.0042676963,
0.0176861845,
-0.0069910856,
0.0002464211,
0.0161549225,
0.0505907424,
0.0293240026,
0.0728155077,
-0.110750787,
-0.0162441339,
0.037726339,
-0.0480199158,
0.0026732446,
0.0598190315,
0.0451448001,
-0.0018244624,
0.040722575,
-0.0028055806,
0.0030000033,
0.0050520455,
0.0456615277,
-0.0283901338,
0.0209716391,
-0.0115563516,
0.019111935,
-0.0478728861,
-0.0415346511,
0.0224401522,
0.0388184041,
0.0298711769,
-0.0321073607,
0.0152436718,
-0.0120214131,
0.0400884561,
-0.0431887321,
-0.010488824,
0.0284696426,
-0.0346972235,
-0.0547315218,
0.0235616714,
0.0912881717,
0.051417429,
-0.0189672243,
-0.0278486405,
0.0079590566,
-0.0713344887,
-0.0313668996,
0.0356498286,
0.0209290907,
-0.0293250661,
0.0919760466,
0.014439215,
-0.0230242945,
0.003023224,
0.0192907192,
0.0239132699,
0.0682856441,
0.0003413661,
0.0767849907,
-0.0281794984,
0.0143055264,
-0.0008492388,
0.0478033051,
0.0240393523,
0.0076179253,
0.0051010521,
0.0362474099,
0.0040164827,
0.0148418564,
0.0034631293,
-0.0108450744,
-0.0092677558,
-0.017313486,
0.0284240544,
0.0069707823,
0.0257104132,
0.0154092479,
0.0502564944,
-0.0238142274,
0.0164958593,
0.0574007966,
-0.0201371964,
0.0719653592,
-0.0124127809,
-0.0024472254,
-0.0252759308,
-0.0286984071,
0.0825972334,
-0.0082305791,
0.0499811843,
-0.0039709853,
-0.0055510206,
0.058281038,
-0.0176297538,
-0.0367835201,
-0.0102688167,
0.0536470078,
-0.0341061503,
0.0575481914,
-0.0269634966,
0.0276534241,
-0.0485127456,
0.000727836,
-0.0259493031,
0.0551192425,
-0.0323024914,
-0.0548700243,
0.0192677416,
0.0560779236,
-0.0412119962,
0.0136196893,
-0.0171640627,
-0.0756284967,
0.0100574633,
-0.0232331567,
-0.0079442142,
0.0329044908,
2.731e-7,
-0.0266250446,
-0.017290784,
0.049971398,
-0.0712393969,
0.0474243015,
0.068330422,
-0.0224954486,
0.0524481162,
0.0531273633,
-0.0685709864,
0.0567892417,
0.0154768489,
0.0599875562,
0.0043504108,
-0.0401135236,
-0.0485740341,
-0.0173873324,
-0.0005478848,
-0.0121265985,
0.0317474529,
0.0768166557,
0.0794632956,
0.0224207956,
-0.0198139977,
0.0061968253,
0.0281824432,
0.0660169125,
-0.0383077115,
-0.0291447174,
-0.0205959603,
-0.0228346195,
-0.0331737101,
-0.0304175988,
-0.0169669371,
0.0111938026,
0.005843679,
0.0401922613,
0.0227520857,
0.0028958116,
-0.1232103333,
-0.0005402534,
0.072111018,
-0.0545656532,
0.0065504895,
0.0378807448,
-0.035490904,
-0.0542283505,
-0.0521061607,
-0.0413576253,
0.0133885844,
0.0243626554,
-0.009983113,
-0.0576709174,
0.0334448516,
0.0232039224,
-0.0215382669,
-0.05612427,
-0.1058991179,
-0.0007329415,
0.0140592819,
-0.0626393184,
-0.0091857221,
-0.006994932,
-0.0117423777,
0.0245472137,
-0.0576325282,
-0.0148908859,
1.500499598e-34,
-0.0168832764,
-0.0276358724,
0.0176049564,
0.0135291917,
0.0138461972,
0.0063219951,
-0.0324473679,
-0.0383592844,
0.0236484222,
-0.0421863534,
-0.0034307351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15425v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15425v1 | A Critical Review of Large Language Models: Sensitivity, Bias, and the Path Toward Specialized AI | 2023-07-28T09:20:22 | 2023-07-28T09:20:22 | Arash Hajikhani, Carolyn Cole | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper examines the comparative effectiveness of a specialized compiled
language model and a general-purpose model like OpenAI's GPT-3.5 in detecting
SDGs within text data. It presents a critical review of Large Language Models
(LLMs), addressing challenges related to bias and sensitivity. The necessity of
specialized training for precise, unbiased analysis is underlined. A case study
using a company descriptions dataset offers insight into the differences
between the GPT-3.5 and the specialized SDG detection model. While GPT-3.5
boasts broader coverage, it may identify SDGs with limited relevance to the
companies' activities. In contrast, the specialized model zeroes in on highly
pertinent SDGs. The importance of thoughtful model selection is emphasized,
taking into account task requirements, cost, complexity, and transparency.
Despite the versatility of LLMs, the use of specialized models is suggested for
tasks demanding precision and accuracy. The study concludes by encouraging
further research to find a balance between the capabilities of LLMs and the
need for domain-specific expertise and interpretability. | [
0.0546397567,
0.0483733043,
-0.0365273394,
0.0156940855,
-0.0123256724,
0.0133918459,
0.0181281157,
0.0055685416,
0.0341053531,
-0.0656320602,
0.0114786141,
-0.0129114315,
-0.0156246759,
0.074022077,
-0.0111857085,
0.0076130349,
0.0745994672,
-0.0116720861,
0.0329206474,
-0.0013831386,
0.0017839475,
0.0397890285,
0.037190754,
0.0257507861,
-0.0043126117,
-0.0364813395,
0.0475285947,
-0.0158866104,
0.0069929836,
-0.0125291757,
0.01190052,
0.0235801246,
0.0288390554,
0.0497171953,
0.0000022795,
-0.0519543104,
-0.004910293,
-0.0054985704,
-0.0329773873,
0.0530047677,
0.0799242929,
-0.0254305732,
-0.0011743394,
0.0133011285,
-0.0370108709,
-0.0333613753,
0.0439479128,
0.0310541429,
0.0392259806,
0.0827271044,
-0.0212071203,
-0.0123929679,
-0.0088055246,
-0.0461365841,
-0.0542306639,
-0.0351984985,
0.0637606755,
0.0300470479,
-0.0038806133,
-0.0111636072,
0.0228842627,
0.0458755791,
-0.0205431934,
0.0179717802,
0.0092814518,
0.0123846261,
-0.025428867,
0.0333993882,
0.0053266943,
0.0277715679,
0.0141457831,
-0.0262629855,
-0.0071649733,
-0.0460423604,
0.0217664018,
0.0064953039,
-0.0036189391,
0.0038652821,
-0.0235085003,
0.0265032575,
0.0424421988,
0.0047268881,
0.0177034847,
0.0238620974,
-0.0498867854,
0.0566720441,
-0.0155286724,
-0.0306590535,
0.0109975534,
0.0154472766,
-0.0183852036,
-0.0438094102,
0.0203923844,
0.0048543825,
0.0016663378,
0.050439816,
-0.0446054526,
-0.045988027,
0.013886488,
-0.0867889822,
0.0051559005,
0.0094959801,
-0.0015632944,
0.0198787004,
-0.0320673883,
0.0412413813,
-0.0463048443,
-0.0006027927,
-0.0447375104,
-0.004561075,
-0.0286012106,
-0.028751865,
-0.0454056747,
0.0248753782,
-0.0553774647,
-0.0393821187,
-0.0382354446,
0.016923368,
-0.0218959283,
-0.0012615126,
0.0118753146,
-0.0240579601,
-0.0304328054,
-0.0123407263,
-0.0255702194,
-0.0036111244,
-0.0265811235,
0.0236777049,
-0.029890269,
-0.0122384736,
0.0365778804,
0.0383011401,
0.0083464421,
-0.0213504676,
-0.0045832451,
0.0477763824,
0.0098454896,
-0.0213861726,
-0.0897002667,
-0.0232844986,
-0.0519913658,
-0.0469712391,
-0.0414522626,
-0.0419277065,
-0.0342694744,
-0.001550678,
-0.0190149359,
-0.0737782866,
0.0161597226,
-0.0029644014,
-0.0477295071,
0.0240896642,
-0.0472359844,
0.0177240036,
0.0499729291,
-0.0082977619,
0.0331855305,
0.0956124067,
0.030450318,
0.0435000919,
0.0655510947,
0.0014132372,
-0.0056351102,
0.0668377057,
-0.0133476909,
0.0304012969,
-0.0225711372,
0.0276872087,
-0.0221813153,
-0.0257677045,
0.0411264785,
0.0298799891,
0.0294681862,
0.0123436302,
0.0833452716,
0.033810474,
0.0101954797,
-0.0039013466,
0.0246494282,
0.0400977097,
-0.0236243196,
0.0081697451,
0.0182353575,
-0.080610536,
0.0099766012,
0.0263001453,
-0.0627381653,
0.026700709,
-0.0029336715,
-0.0363480896,
-0.0392341129,
-0.0023224705,
0.0407132879,
0.023212675,
0.1061616987,
-0.017571168,
-0.0517647415,
0.0626150444,
0.0066493801,
-0.0031953533,
-0.0072134384,
-0.0411841571,
0.026740836,
0.0502925292,
0.0600632541,
-0.0474687144,
-0.0143434862,
-0.0054145162,
0.0089419466,
0.0540378243,
0.051229842,
0.0178203508,
-0.0440131091,
-0.0322109051,
0.0091711236,
-0.0105641624,
0.0419350043,
0.0327920988,
0.0222079773,
0.0449271388,
0.0063545997,
-0.0369868279,
-0.0669888034,
0.0438780002,
-0.0027963824,
-0.0320315585,
0.0079211313,
0.0056505254,
0.017705312,
0.0329930745,
-0.022346653,
-0.0232111849,
-0.0142470961,
-0.0389963575,
-0.0082712257,
-0.0123155899,
-0.0029757658,
0.047482878,
-0.0126732253,
0.0061706104,
-0.004990052,
0.0238086563,
-0.0256605707,
-0.0115417223,
-0.0033896279,
-0.0072353198,
0.0115229506,
-0.0636119395,
-0.0106497463,
-0.034546338,
0.035569232,
-0.0489148498,
0.0985341892,
0.0141429109,
-0.0386125036,
0.0165064279,
0.0154806552,
0.0666826069,
-0.052227132,
0.0012324303,
0.0462337919,
-0.0269408617,
0.0125715761,
0.0326154158,
-0.0091862315,
-0.0083240364,
-0.0140230972,
-0.0581772216,
-0.0296126679,
-0.0325778574,
0.0265203062,
0.0244958661,
0.0178725068,
-0.0530094579,
0.0200515054,
-0.0015542858,
-0.0184808522,
0.0439361669,
0.0027727608,
0.0180770122,
0.0301869176,
-0.0241803378,
-0.0320907086,
0.012607241,
-0.0130352713,
0.0407063998,
0.0235296246,
-0.0869412795,
-0.1147891879,
0.0791650116,
-0.0266052037,
0.0363919213,
-0.0079633221,
-0.0384131633,
-0.0059051914,
0.0079204049,
-0.0063423119,
0.0361937881,
0.0038842158,
0.0335388854,
0.0049667158,
-0.0149700502,
-0.0273442231,
-0.0013869073,
-0.0158920493,
0.0285448823,
-0.0325363725,
-0.0257672518,
0.0795622841,
0.0368225873,
0.0336217396,
-0.0299433246,
-0.0419553928,
-0.00414408,
-0.0568655506,
-0.0072854534,
0.00626624,
-0.0520349406,
-0.0177204888,
0.06911017,
0.0007298457,
-0.0602451488,
0.0254108626,
-0.023003893,
0.0282005277,
-0.0427580699,
-0.0574366525,
-0.053219039,
0.0648292601,
-0.0301721115,
0.0463371053,
-0.0045981533,
-0.0532434694,
-0.027182078,
-0.01055256,
-0.0061145732,
-0.0081993984,
0.0737883747,
-0.0489574932,
0.0492501147,
0.0030089105,
-0.0042505218,
-0.0409993082,
-0.0404497199,
-0.0243550427,
-0.0018561868,
0.067749247,
-0.0048484472,
-0.0488788523,
0.0519697703,
-0.0675745755,
0.0376486704,
-0.0005943369,
-0.0077741626,
-0.0202537496,
-0.0232039727,
0.0643888563,
-0.0472091436,
0.0244831517,
0.0064636897,
0.0343167782,
0.0062493514,
-0.0092603778,
0.0125570502,
-0.0417595655,
-0.0474758483,
0.0131467702,
-0.0772742406,
0.0132060954,
-0.0033399535,
0.0392631814,
-0.063826181,
-0.0067707808,
0.1074230373,
0.0018218613,
-0.0230715685,
0.0309994388,
0.0278171841,
-0.0200301502,
0.02044365,
0.0319367126,
-0.0960975885,
-0.0177930593,
-0.0171379615,
0.0077999351,
-0.0122814775,
0.0019968224,
-0.0376019552,
-0.0783068687,
0.0499899164,
-0.0021069548,
-0.0530832224,
-0.0223681033,
-0.0111642843,
-0.0194697548,
-0.0403444581,
0.0148701528,
-0.0420473628,
-0.0344250202,
-0.027428342,
0.0217402559,
-0.0620376617,
-0.0683220699,
0.0047673988,
-0.0200060122,
0.0048575676,
0.0733625516,
0.0182983484,
-0.0305299107,
0.0474229604,
0.0449108258,
-0.0175121147,
0.0198652241,
0.0039207516,
0.051754389,
-0.0197320711,
-0.0117700547,
0.0139650907,
-0.0035286902,
-0.0309555531,
0.0372392796,
0.0373348072,
0.0415655933,
-0.0254844297,
-0.0395961776,
-0.0085407337,
-0.0065603298,
0.0075240075,
0.0637056977,
-0.0160672087,
-0.0443005562,
0.0020535579,
-0.0341538787,
0.014290317,
0.0182452761,
0.0046518813,
0.0443231203,
-0.0333402827,
-0.0523578338,
-0.0421205647,
-0.0462366343,
0.0312864445,
-0.0128222043,
0.0260095224,
0.0702693909,
0.0138813239,
-0.0039905529,
-0.0193696842,
-0.0205243118,
-0.0504126176,
0.0524830408,
-0.0490192771,
0.0049060942,
-0.0074796528,
-0.0152027253,
-0.037191987,
0.0000208304,
-0.1120461598,
-0.0642552078,
-0.0104068406,
-0.0124875,
0.0338800065,
-0.0168827809,
-0.0479122773,
-0.0321926847,
0.0276312307,
0.0409247242,
-0.0116647463,
-0.0069018276,
0.0115866996,
-0.0400818326,
-0.0048775007,
0.0060692537,
-0.0462015532,
0.034518566,
0.0162092969,
-0.0172223393,
-0.0257184878,
-0.0109678805,
0.0119018639,
0.0163371395,
0.0298209339,
-0.0032871689,
-0.0130893625,
-0.0864645466,
-0.0428593382,
0.009174142,
-0.0104831336,
-0.0422141142,
-0.0132430997,
0.031447608,
-0.0086855367,
-0.0169775765,
0.018371122,
-0.0641664863,
-0.0012608622,
-0.0579612553,
0.0332359858,
0.011167936,
0.0373211578,
0.0314606391,
-0.005887663,
-0.0356213599,
0.010810799,
-0.0051845177,
0.0027986951,
0.0049097338,
0.0658218488,
0.0315015987,
0.0212705545,
0.0099032111,
0.0165928937,
-0.0183909778,
-0.0422605574,
0.0026614405,
-0.0115152271,
0.0571236238,
-0.0189210847,
0.0113239121,
-0.0492113866,
0.0123971347,
-0.0264539253,
0.0328111872,
0.0489303805,
-0.0266726352,
-0.0101532741,
-0.0017620898,
-0.0587472618,
0.0075305812,
0.0884641632,
0.0459255092,
0.0520666204,
-0.006607905,
-0.0577951334,
-0.0334987454,
-0.0404842198,
0.0210751723,
0.0393092185,
-0.0399742834,
0.0007535819,
-0.0816641673,
-0.0596749634,
-0.0420745276,
-0.0380585007,
0.0169573259,
-0.0354612656,
-0.0292065069,
0.0461861081,
0.0093696136,
-0.0161500853,
-0.0562433228,
-0.0539723448,
-0.0545129701,
0.0004199084,
-0.0216729026,
-6.467528041e-33,
0.0102762431,
-0.085997574,
0.0060846424,
-0.0152985808,
-0.0114975693,
0.0306663439,
-0.0027612471,
-0.0180607084,
-0.033222612,
0.0056017153,
0.0158065315,
0.0412816554,
0.0138083063,
-0.0137928175,
-0.0007250659,
0.0073929341,
0.0378975943,
0.0072329561,
-0.0128589906,
0.0100689521,
0.0485690869,
0.0064909491,
0.0764917806,
-0.0682013258,
0.0540707707,
-0.0107160127,
-0.0409732461,
-0.0208120756,
0.0178583097,
0.0609253906,
-0.0040625227,
0.0567621998,
0.0306412391,
-0.038657371,
0.0018075329,
0.0260352753,
-0.0148415193,
0.0032108929,
0.0201985594,
0.0321549736,
0.0819320381,
-0.0222939141,
0.0156295244,
-0.0164556075,
-0.0194712989,
0.036765907,
0.0548558608,
-0.0434213765,
-0.0189991705,
-0.0268573593,
-0.0820585042,
0.0411079563,
0.02428337,
0.0551690832,
0.0122813815,
0.0163353514,
-0.0014671856,
0.0288183372,
-0.0039968826,
0.0107678454,
0.0465233847,
-0.0064413152,
0.0591690913,
0.0291028135,
-0.003646645,
0.0458164848,
0.000967191,
0.0438923836,
0.0036905669,
-0.0382792391,
0.0268715099,
0.0407556705,
-0.0017237247,
0.0239439849,
0.0403352864,
-0.0358966701,
-0.0556835458,
0.0065573263,
0.0145340897,
0.0017134231,
0.048159346,
0.0064278827,
-0.0756113455,
-0.0544515736,
0.01403399,
-0.0016961312,
-0.0150376121,
-0.0201837476,
0.0564433746,
0.0087306462,
-0.0342299417,
0.0535555035,
0.0302672684,
-0.0603068918,
-0.013610106,
0.0014878343,
-0.004371813,
-0.004294747,
0.0022094641,
-0.0017695919,
-0.0620413944,
-0.0330117829,
-0.0174541101,
0.0339255109,
0.0146994516,
0.001006322,
-0.0010161535,
-0.0152601041,
-0.0296220221,
0.0403930098,
0.0006452033,
0.0283562019,
-0.0073511116,
0.0201353244,
0.0340763852,
-0.0377762504,
0.016309144,
0.0401706882,
0.0612925068,
-0.0137651479,
-0.0065820096,
0.0010812593,
-0.0074338112,
0.0278176814,
-0.0307391044,
-0.003382649,
0.0103326663,
-0.0251862947,
0.0483697765,
-0.0260173064,
-0.021847738,
0.0026488227,
2.807e-7,
0.0541827865,
0.0725111961,
-0.0008484536,
0.0807385966,
0.0020758952,
0.0229411758,
0.0377646014,
-0.0142527437,
-0.0383509248,
0.027931137,
0.0491894074,
-0.0030117559,
0.0352734998,
0.016730018,
-0.0631715879,
0.038103316,
-0.0335505307,
0.0427421518,
-0.1147091538,
0.0205459092,
0.0037531357,
0.0595582724,
0.017538514,
-0.0082079517,
-0.0126128197,
-0.070236899,
0.0527798645,
-0.0515129492,
0.0499871038,
0.0824190527,
0.0529984422,
0.0450864881,
-0.0372700617,
0.0158110131,
-0.0130838417,
0.0331037045,
0.0372459441,
0.0536360592,
0.0050647729,
0.0770079568,
0.0030941162,
-0.0444453433,
-0.0207707435,
-0.0626861826,
0.032924246,
-0.0285195969,
-0.028764762,
-0.0441748351,
0.0097990017,
-0.023548292,
-0.0214564763,
-0.0090183038,
0.0187697113,
-0.0000655476,
0.0154569466,
-0.0242667608,
-0.0152497217,
-0.0485760272,
0.0212306455,
0.0208109301,
-0.0285382047,
-0.0020551286,
-0.0069384701,
0.0408504233,
0.0384064764,
-0.0385532416,
0.0558277667,
2.77609154e-34,
0.0393405035,
-0.0099071125,
-0.0443641134,
0.0007432553,
0.0656822473,
0.0211521387,
-0.0117238695,
0.0032587342,
-0.0126351975,
-0.0751417428,
0.0004368438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15413v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15413v1 | Improving Social Media Popularity Prediction with Multiple Post Dependencies | 2023-07-28T09:06:50 | 2023-07-28T09:06:50 | Zhizhen Zhang, Xiaohui Xie, Mengyu Yang, Ye Tian, Yong Jiang, Yong Cui | cs.MM | cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL | Social Media Popularity Prediction has drawn a lot of attention because of
its profound impact on many different applications, such as recommendation
systems and multimedia advertising. Despite recent efforts to leverage the
content of social media posts to improve prediction accuracy, many existing
models fail to fully exploit the multiple dependencies between posts, which are
important to comprehensively extract content information from posts. To tackle
this problem, we propose a novel prediction framework named Dependency-aware
Sequence Network (DSN) that exploits both intra- and inter-post dependencies.
For intra-post dependency, DSN adopts a multimodal feature extractor with an
efficient fine-tuning strategy to obtain task-specific representations from
images and textual information of posts. For inter-post dependency, DSN uses a
hierarchical information propagation method to learn category representations
that could better describe the difference between posts. DSN also exploits
recurrent networks with a series of gating layers for more flexible local
temporal processing abilities and multi-head attention for long-term
dependencies. The experimental results on the Social Media Popularity Dataset
demonstrate the superiority of our method compared to existing state-of-the-art
models. | [
0.0234598871,
0.0835371986,
-0.015538781,
0.0036879436,
-0.0120785199,
-0.0340111814,
-0.021309901,
0.0004908235,
0.0294714849,
-0.0165567044,
0.0098178638,
-0.0488932468,
-0.0146567402,
0.0417245105,
-0.0034651326,
-0.0564741828,
0.0163639635,
0.0396040007,
-0.0222686678,
0.0173474588,
0.0547020398,
0.028103957,
0.0395267792,
0.0078919502,
-0.044809971,
-0.0266215112,
-0.0006356438,
0.0103924507,
0.0110568833,
-0.0718835071,
0.0343954265,
0.0415532365,
0.0914279446,
0.0091731288,
0.0000020797,
0.0157891903,
0.0107715381,
-0.046674069,
0.0599708632,
-0.0166376177,
0.016203858,
-0.0350780264,
0.0390346982,
-0.0263029523,
-0.058077246,
0.0441930778,
0.0430861264,
0.0443452671,
0.0306170564,
0.0236897394,
-0.0292039607,
-0.0481467769,
0.0361719169,
-0.0406611562,
0.0785259008,
-0.0424721092,
-0.0012464548,
-0.0207806807,
-0.0003984888,
0.0041815685,
-0.0232647397,
0.0290033128,
0.0199858733,
0.0070312032,
0.0172754023,
0.0303820763,
0.0466834791,
-0.0301038045,
-0.0262460504,
0.0771415904,
-0.0360985324,
0.0000225755,
0.0124183651,
-0.0064617367,
-0.0086373631,
0.0261734836,
-0.0461077057,
-0.0379799828,
0.0191522557,
0.0368762016,
-0.020292649,
0.0252873693,
0.0002845623,
-0.0239998456,
0.0139667392,
0.0126308119,
-0.0034498016,
-0.0271908902,
-0.0430234298,
0.0172379054,
-0.0285585988,
-0.03518093,
0.01647784,
-0.0180880725,
0.0033091407,
0.0097067654,
-0.01559324,
-0.0114847505,
0.0131955286,
-0.0889152214,
0.0217987541,
-0.0381990112,
-0.0278278627,
0.0366288535,
0.0345803425,
0.0083159423,
-0.0575349629,
-0.0638201833,
0.026631562,
0.0510658883,
-0.0739671513,
0.0016651985,
0.0330181532,
0.0177193787,
0.0183175839,
-0.0488157719,
-0.017443141,
0.0068775984,
-0.0228938796,
-0.010820346,
-0.0213264469,
0.0834344029,
-0.0411839783,
0.0193779711,
-0.0147211403,
0.0394976661,
-0.0113114081,
0.0054635853,
-0.0001462781,
0.0362544693,
0.0146896616,
0.0121550448,
0.093813248,
-0.0315515436,
-0.0062254122,
0.0265921876,
0.0325059816,
-0.0103207212,
-0.0509275571,
-0.024673678,
-0.0077864295,
-0.0344489366,
0.0296285301,
-0.0612786599,
0.0271146093,
-0.021920884,
-0.0236367006,
0.0028289962,
-0.0009768103,
0.0226216111,
-0.0273779146,
0.0359596089,
0.0468552411,
-0.0358162969,
0.0134295654,
0.0290666502,
0.039445255,
0.0539023168,
-0.0086111883,
0.1209602207,
0.0541076399,
-0.0220939294,
0.0213473532,
0.0471144728,
0.0068069976,
-0.0305512976,
-0.0217220597,
-0.0153336506,
-0.0255329777,
-0.0279067196,
0.044313062,
-0.0109424358,
0.0155489706,
0.0111131715,
0.0703861713,
-0.0290989093,
0.013804717,
0.0190370996,
0.0495329835,
0.0331066512,
-0.0321220011,
0.0053321272,
-0.0171248,
0.0863389596,
0.0034323649,
0.0016037326,
0.0234581437,
0.0509157665,
-0.044036869,
0.0042467308,
0.0435886085,
-0.0214357041,
0.0102530429,
-0.0009116048,
0.0220872853,
0.0117263552,
-0.0434967801,
0.0451603867,
0.0330583937,
-0.0046066418,
-0.0108931931,
0.0219070483,
0.0062118168,
0.046473477,
-0.0032893212,
-0.0237413552,
0.0150705902,
0.0040376624,
0.0321253389,
0.0060974271,
-0.0392833017,
-0.0101242429,
0.0010498334,
-0.044098407,
-0.0003185034,
0.0244060475,
0.011981721,
0.0146667333,
-0.0126190362,
0.0457012616,
0.0240206756,
0.039675571,
0.0085522765,
-0.0347327888,
0.0337084457,
-0.0082441401,
0.0109991664,
0.0153547777,
0.0542802326,
0.0371482298,
0.002995542,
-0.0156618487,
0.029133549,
-0.0503798947,
-0.044150386,
-0.0138620101,
-0.0594365522,
-0.0212667026,
0.0218547806,
-0.0339963101,
-0.0038688418,
0.0531789623,
-0.0573321208,
-0.0177100319,
0.1211894974,
-0.0108248591,
0.012004815,
-0.0122932503,
-0.0617969371,
0.0235350728,
0.0616588593,
-0.0011155128,
0.049052719,
-0.0378301218,
-0.010373312,
-0.0273100771,
-0.0378704481,
-0.0176705848,
0.0363059565,
-0.0315284207,
0.0020835251,
0.0145673202,
0.0130255939,
0.033595942,
-0.0126584573,
-0.0296016671,
-0.0248378087,
-0.096771121,
0.0174343437,
-0.0306743365,
-0.0066806953,
0.009405788,
0.0145353284,
0.0286235176,
-0.0509643517,
-0.0597716719,
0.0348113365,
-0.0524605252,
0.0200903565,
0.0034586752,
0.0219650641,
0.0108498298,
-0.0374165699,
-0.0496417768,
-0.001293822,
0.0503811575,
-0.0042004134,
-0.0279026274,
0.0299542118,
-0.0506637692,
-0.0536933951,
0.0330260657,
-0.0210673995,
-0.010577986,
-0.0228694081,
-0.0551453754,
0.0308773946,
-0.0204881504,
0.0388634987,
-0.0110384943,
-0.0221471116,
-0.0297096781,
-0.016407432,
0.0069809831,
-0.0411145017,
0.0509148389,
0.0048025665,
-0.0215014536,
-0.0116403122,
0.041654963,
0.0033138758,
0.0076308427,
-0.0347694084,
0.00176703,
0.0216708146,
-0.0020864462,
-0.0051268255,
0.0342667811,
-0.0030791871,
0.0018525322,
-0.0377913862,
-0.017619865,
0.0428226441,
0.0222868323,
-0.0063523836,
0.0316827819,
-0.0246440992,
-0.056990888,
0.0680126473,
0.0763373896,
-0.0128391581,
0.0283941496,
-0.0107961427,
-0.0039734817,
0.0241695959,
-0.0039918381,
-0.0045230328,
0.0162891019,
0.0251575187,
-0.0062499279,
-0.0009460819,
-0.0243231691,
0.0147757111,
-0.0714607537,
-0.009522588,
-0.0430764593,
-0.0361918733,
-0.0306598395,
0.0063975998,
-0.0484429039,
-0.018912442,
0.0271437448,
-0.0162963104,
-0.0145404208,
0.0280935857,
0.0838708207,
0.0669561997,
-0.0146428319,
-0.0476161055,
-0.0207917076,
-0.0021104859,
0.0329900347,
-0.0027145005,
-0.017137114,
-0.0657580569,
0.0268313866,
0.0176528841,
0.0103303054,
-0.0188897438,
0.0109364223,
0.0295782257,
-0.0391687788,
0.0345063284,
0.0874858573,
-0.0058763414,
-0.0683574229,
0.0107919443,
0.0455844924,
0.0023164852,
0.0276432429,
0.0269344654,
-0.0665237755,
-0.0336127914,
-0.0666595548,
-0.0141122518,
0.0332008712,
-0.0357214846,
-0.0089583453,
-0.0676579252,
0.0455395207,
-0.0182119198,
-0.0346598215,
-0.0210305844,
-0.0364648774,
-0.0092950808,
-0.0059330054,
-0.0344906747,
-0.0108029228,
0.0007916697,
-0.0249440167,
0.0132108573,
-0.0337888375,
-0.0231850762,
0.0510687977,
-0.0167651735,
-0.0010513343,
0.0313214883,
0.0307872389,
-0.01906747,
-0.0311473943,
-0.0033497526,
0.0225978848,
0.0247588959,
-0.0091683455,
0.0776765421,
-0.0216897652,
0.0003602658,
-0.032537546,
0.0057115187,
-0.0427583121,
-0.0213557202,
0.0074184886,
0.0738388374,
0.000566455,
-0.0896951184,
-0.0583520271,
0.0177701004,
0.0501931831,
0.0067500193,
0.0465230085,
-0.0824246183,
-0.0113620907,
-0.0121374521,
0.0095009254,
-0.0635508895,
-0.0272401422,
-0.0434292145,
0.0083228284,
-0.0509140342,
-0.0652384907,
-0.0192666911,
-0.0223083645,
0.0015713455,
-0.0237896927,
0.0053395266,
0.0250456128,
-0.0285393875,
-0.0419263169,
0.0097007249,
0.0417663306,
-0.0217497963,
-0.0095689353,
0.0064038886,
0.0526638962,
-0.0291902479,
-0.0305317063,
-0.0025641019,
-0.1160298511,
-0.0281328876,
0.0009650078,
0.0372790433,
0.007126647,
0.0543248132,
0.0029800041,
-0.0480939336,
0.0315753445,
0.0540253147,
0.0025644444,
-0.0128371036,
0.0144652678,
-0.0305167902,
-0.0023048203,
0.0239110608,
-0.0089840544,
0.0647417977,
-0.0217125993,
-0.0429185703,
-0.011585366,
-0.0070735533,
-0.0405394845,
-0.0294590704,
0.0427833498,
0.018339131,
-0.0080392677,
-0.046371758,
-0.0331624672,
0.0299320128,
-0.0004995615,
-0.061287608,
0.0049861646,
0.0301198717,
0.0115390625,
-0.0578004643,
-0.0125059485,
0.0594484508,
-0.02807655,
-0.0809362382,
0.0196808819,
-0.0146327624,
0.0297202598,
-0.0063439915,
0.0250786915,
0.0179916099,
0.0016589802,
0.0261935573,
0.0266722944,
-0.0087249801,
0.0321060494,
-0.038532313,
-0.0179634094,
-0.0085867131,
0.0451208577,
-0.0420793891,
0.0184580162,
-0.0270766728,
-0.0146638872,
0.0880450904,
-0.0468995273,
0.0153808631,
0.0254698973,
0.0131770661,
-0.0036464545,
0.0214397125,
-0.0172574539,
-0.0219739527,
0.0165884364,
0.0098065287,
-0.0073280549,
0.0515318066,
0.0925074518,
0.0063610971,
-0.0248033442,
0.0402245186,
-0.0080174971,
-0.0183270331,
0.0259583779,
0.0026994087,
0.0566619299,
0.0010948575,
0.0301733073,
-0.0072909882,
-0.0687142313,
0.0718116015,
-0.0462697744,
0.004002925,
0.0453171358,
0.0469083674,
0.0517401248,
0.0445861742,
0.0177949052,
-0.0497406162,
-0.0215709787,
-0.0298366733,
-0.0368417837,
-0.0133844633,
-6.98743303e-33,
0.0249380264,
0.0004674724,
-0.0519617572,
0.0141764972,
-0.0547619872,
0.0121246753,
-0.0479085781,
-0.0139619829,
0.0348521732,
-0.0057888404,
-0.0107068345,
-0.0174749345,
-0.0093468102,
0.0612292178,
0.0693886951,
-0.0091878567,
0.0259943195,
0.0265555345,
0.0247699302,
0.0586882196,
0.067791149,
0.0605276041,
0.0639091954,
-0.0526406765,
-0.0096918959,
-0.0281974133,
0.0322554484,
-0.0115808407,
0.0514160395,
0.0451351851,
-0.0224154051,
0.0604670234,
0.0442194939,
-0.0496191569,
-0.0347091779,
0.0727872998,
-0.0735581741,
-0.0555101857,
-0.0251573138,
-0.0510551035,
-0.047240559,
-0.0008885998,
0.0459258296,
-0.0161289647,
0.0329593793,
-0.0002924621,
0.0626526847,
0.0271821488,
0.0381281376,
0.0114886863,
-0.0198702868,
0.0318903252,
-0.0266029928,
0.0180866458,
0.0074771671,
0.0219392236,
0.0425672084,
0.0697820187,
-0.0974782407,
0.0129398024,
-0.0546443984,
0.0395988226,
0.0235287938,
0.0117797665,
0.0003405118,
0.0642872229,
-0.0065599559,
0.0172865372,
-0.0145397205,
0.0122235725,
-0.0218731537,
0.063836433,
0.0078636901,
-0.0072602695,
0.0891529396,
-0.0266525298,
-0.0943123177,
0.0191990715,
0.0236400981,
0.0124207996,
0.0158267356,
0.0238498896,
-0.0100497268,
0.0063081398,
0.0227818545,
0.00005965,
-0.0448814183,
-0.0542551801,
-0.0248277187,
0.0249779988,
0.0171761587,
0.0770166591,
0.0358469896,
-0.0361562073,
-0.0307241883,
0.010754155,
-0.0099228276,
0.0409703068,
0.0366325118,
0.014280729,
-0.0477850959,
0.0303399768,
-0.0088067595,
-0.0195002593,
-0.0053317831,
0.0066173989,
0.031731803,
0.0332561135,
-0.0129877478,
-0.0220274515,
-0.0321403407,
-0.0194794089,
-0.037715055,
0.0521235913,
0.0165646002,
0.0231292304,
-0.0696661398,
0.0309678055,
0.0262644347,
0.0608109608,
-0.0261099674,
-0.0222535282,
-0.0105762389,
0.0165843014,
-0.0108753564,
-0.0513072424,
-0.0494857542,
-0.0224634036,
-0.0207609423,
-0.0831838548,
-0.0274576508,
0.035073407,
2.999e-7,
-0.0092017744,
0.0340495296,
-0.0267749727,
0.0073653939,
0.0761437118,
0.0282898266,
-0.0126556084,
0.046704255,
-0.0058217687,
-0.0366771668,
0.0042679636,
0.0324431174,
0.0089652063,
0.0105358651,
-0.078601338,
-0.0343972221,
-0.037411727,
-0.0169829652,
-0.0395219363,
-0.0339135267,
-0.0032146764,
0.093113102,
0.0460356586,
-0.0222434066,
0.0295218062,
0.0066147214,
0.0532067269,
0.0154916421,
-0.0242348518,
-0.017071126,
-0.00072334,
0.0147322332,
-0.0647066906,
-0.008013932,
-0.0679426268,
-0.0060932827,
0.0240306444,
0.0031908283,
-0.0182083957,
-0.0515983701,
0.0205376465,
0.0639648885,
-0.0006073292,
-0.0107230926,
0.0694163963,
-0.0299075507,
-0.0807450935,
-0.0597903393,
-0.0369568914,
0.0402685218,
0.0321606025,
0.0082389452,
-0.028276911,
0.0039554746,
-0.0148446709,
-0.0316946022,
-0.0423477553,
-0.1037981957,
0.0046634898,
0.0368036628,
-0.0413773656,
0.0074698902,
-0.0531530008,
-0.0366991386,
0.0184878614,
-0.007944189,
-0.0024641482,
2.233119449e-34,
0.0208479594,
0.013523181,
0.0122717666,
-0.0245621279,
-0.0345476344,
0.0063467668,
-0.0787182897,
-0.015277667,
0.03575252,
-0.0443248115,
-0.0060074744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15411v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15411v2 | Investigating the Learning Behaviour of In-context Learning: A Comparison with Supervised Learning | 2023-07-28T09:03:19 | 2023-08-01T16:04:09 | Xindi Wang, Yufei Wang, Can Xu, Xiubo Geng, Bowen Zhang, Chongyang Tao, Frank Rudzicz, Robert E. Mercer, Daxin Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capacity for in-context
learning (ICL), where learning a new task from just a few training examples is
done without being explicitly pre-trained. However, despite the success of
LLMs, there has been little understanding of how ICL learns the knowledge from
the given prompts. In this paper, to make progress toward understanding the
learning behaviour of ICL, we train the same LLMs with the same demonstration
examples via ICL and supervised learning (SL), respectively, and investigate
their performance under label perturbations (i.e., noisy labels and label
imbalance) on a range of classification tasks. First, via extensive
experiments, we find that gold labels have significant impacts on the
downstream in-context performance, especially for large language models;
however, imbalanced labels matter little to ICL across all model sizes. Second,
when comparing with SL, we show empirically that ICL is less sensitive to label
perturbations than SL, and ICL gradually attains comparable performance to SL
as the model size increases. | [
0.0067022834,
-0.0122336634,
-0.0083318055,
0.0406800285,
-0.0176785905,
0.0339522325,
0.0222422332,
-0.0083027836,
0.0093401168,
-0.0779294297,
-0.0782087445,
-0.0095693842,
0.0067924224,
-0.0254342742,
0.0307479221,
-0.041209057,
0.027006479,
-0.0507395156,
0.0218743067,
-0.0099366112,
-0.0103814583,
-0.0143568115,
-0.0104374876,
0.0119040087,
-0.0321697146,
-0.0188934878,
0.012726781,
0.0218290016,
-0.00203706,
-0.0399139635,
0.0261916332,
0.0468900017,
0.008051754,
0.046487961,
0.0000020898,
-0.0760901347,
0.012905742,
-0.0222103801,
-0.0292048305,
0.0235530585,
0.0334042683,
0.0182548333,
-0.0050496757,
0.0352482833,
-0.0226419754,
0.0028730705,
0.0305201076,
0.0757670701,
-0.0036615338,
0.0440115221,
-0.01465513,
-0.018100461,
0.0010549882,
-0.0228776485,
0.0137267988,
-0.0747224912,
0.0312132929,
-0.0311873239,
-0.0241602603,
0.0113022728,
-0.0132433064,
0.0326091573,
0.0266016591,
0.0127498358,
0.023249289,
0.0737625062,
-0.0376649685,
-0.0085368734,
-0.0216472205,
0.072169207,
-0.0371879824,
-0.021368742,
-0.0281979423,
-0.0237205345,
0.0512782037,
-0.0347225629,
-0.0411102995,
0.033406049,
0.0095985932,
0.027400814,
0.0174684171,
0.0240452979,
0.0483550951,
-0.0047179074,
0.0054474794,
0.0494439527,
0.0030740052,
-0.066818215,
0.0307921506,
0.0182606615,
-0.056237679,
-0.035067983,
-0.0197678991,
0.0267202519,
-0.043167606,
0.0352454409,
-0.054067377,
-0.0120685799,
0.0207849499,
-0.0523484387,
0.017002983,
0.0173322055,
-0.0619338602,
0.0586175919,
-0.0094869081,
0.0163172688,
0.0370847322,
0.0503430627,
-0.0305277817,
-0.0135653624,
-0.0295770243,
0.0107071158,
-0.043548841,
0.0123449871,
0.0169090778,
-0.0012856738,
-0.0330199823,
0.0495787263,
-0.0076740202,
0.0013584739,
0.0147791859,
-0.0224921778,
-0.0306607112,
-0.0015119686,
-0.0078185517,
-0.0005364466,
0.005881072,
0.0399506837,
-0.0047100368,
-0.059307754,
0.003552621,
-0.0007993548,
-0.0025979604,
-0.029577611,
0.0334663205,
0.0732907653,
-0.004490261,
-0.0786598772,
-0.0456606373,
0.0069563529,
-0.0036568318,
-0.0450307094,
-0.0390349291,
-0.040109016,
-0.0084237373,
0.0271988735,
0.0151304184,
-0.0370131768,
-0.0017774472,
0.0125538437,
-0.027145328,
0.0655339807,
0.0019916284,
0.0023058781,
0.0432394035,
0.0083454754,
-0.0007592267,
0.0561655499,
-0.0124272825,
-0.024826467,
0.0419132449,
-0.0192272626,
0.0313022807,
0.0384272486,
0.0294784103,
0.0361881442,
-0.0325826742,
-0.0084368158,
0.0788504854,
0.0017459381,
0.0224620681,
0.0193787757,
0.0042757811,
0.0025620495,
0.1094679385,
0.0296916422,
-0.0049350411,
-0.0338562764,
-0.0264162812,
-0.0095017366,
-0.0053048334,
0.0072033377,
-0.0824681967,
-0.0105114039,
-0.0288386121,
-0.011772221,
0.0450648479,
-0.0322794393,
-0.036037609,
-0.0426287949,
-0.0236734767,
-0.0130076213,
-0.02513735,
0.04010107,
0.0547950454,
0.035295777,
-0.0295564681,
0.0278807934,
0.0627768338,
0.0053331335,
-0.013404239,
-0.0508566611,
0.007621136,
0.0216039252,
0.0263756067,
-0.0616206713,
0.0043727718,
-0.0251016077,
0.0463217609,
0.0191689283,
0.0345379747,
-0.0153320888,
0.0245385226,
-0.0293129589,
-0.0272762589,
0.0087667927,
0.0309027229,
-0.0062652146,
0.0062410887,
0.0158594139,
-0.0093411086,
-0.0415038392,
-0.0482650734,
0.0517274179,
-0.0095749618,
-0.0760923177,
0.0362181216,
0.0235074703,
0.0030559597,
-0.0260558557,
-0.0169223323,
-0.0050633866,
0.0299855974,
-0.0165732205,
-0.0011921711,
-0.0158455167,
-0.0871653557,
-0.040062394,
0.0573374555,
0.0179583896,
-0.0238890462,
-0.0229692794,
-0.0352133773,
-0.0210583452,
-0.0207564868,
-0.0250461306,
0.0506490991,
-0.0173776243,
0.0329478756,
-0.0236356668,
0.0208431035,
-0.0648918748,
0.0728431717,
0.0246653873,
-0.0019175219,
-0.0309814177,
0.0574141555,
0.0040076561,
-0.0075257146,
-0.0148717305,
-0.0251470767,
-0.0081794811,
-0.0030921251,
-0.0167005565,
-0.0038815495,
-0.0452182628,
0.0081029637,
-0.1090423167,
-0.0196295362,
-0.0312445723,
-0.0317369588,
0.030815782,
-0.005416085,
-0.0133334771,
-0.0494741276,
-0.0284626633,
-0.0396207348,
0.0012848327,
0.0382796898,
0.0212141946,
0.0217936542,
-0.0128153032,
-0.01349614,
0.0010320657,
-0.009309737,
0.0496484153,
0.0312141534,
-0.015662726,
-0.068426609,
0.0521620438,
0.0122417863,
0.0345914699,
0.0024007326,
0.0130900135,
-0.0083327247,
-0.0084142825,
0.0351702869,
0.0707658976,
0.0073929997,
0.059747722,
0.0848495588,
0.0241621472,
-0.0322443992,
-0.0012578276,
-0.0100218439,
-0.0446844511,
-0.0341240689,
0.0126065575,
0.0175376721,
0.0757991821,
0.0012217076,
0.0065850369,
-0.0029312207,
-0.0023379375,
-0.029950235,
-0.0188512485,
-0.1014864817,
0.0043521752,
-0.0429503918,
0.0636224374,
0.0064188442,
-0.0662430823,
0.0283191931,
-0.0107316915,
-0.008385634,
-0.0600288212,
-0.0448195636,
-0.0090143532,
0.0404680148,
-0.0117272278,
0.0198104754,
0.0354957245,
-0.0157913137,
-0.0693799332,
-0.0234920233,
0.0277994871,
-0.008041054,
0.0400209427,
-0.0323563553,
0.0159557778,
-0.0102870362,
-0.0394964032,
-0.0722556114,
-0.0652275905,
-0.0232397001,
0.0232133735,
-0.0395500436,
0.0119841266,
-0.0161927659,
-0.0104296133,
0.0216419064,
0.0420356169,
0.0150310742,
-0.0303012338,
0.0016253002,
0.0507872403,
0.0176402498,
-0.0340135954,
0.0061461553,
-0.0459428951,
0.0225469209,
0.0136743523,
0.0307665039,
-0.0152343046,
0.0052156667,
0.0053306958,
0.0348665453,
-0.0103860162,
0.001819994,
0.070708327,
0.02141596,
-0.0679599866,
-0.0242766347,
0.1135608554,
0.0215071309,
-0.1083320826,
0.003639797,
-0.0068942308,
-0.000258518,
0.0586130768,
0.0073513305,
-0.0476962738,
-0.0375924446,
0.0266998764,
0.0035733059,
-0.0113992142,
-0.0049245879,
-0.0109644579,
-0.1245035008,
0.0367809273,
-0.0045870384,
-0.0790704712,
-0.0332262628,
-0.046604272,
-0.0108640576,
0.0141462954,
0.0495041981,
-0.0073695383,
-0.0265341084,
-0.0233087149,
0.0379806086,
0.0076886644,
-0.1065268219,
0.029246565,
-0.0325420387,
0.0533447191,
0.0513200834,
0.019938875,
-0.0379502997,
-0.0361502357,
0.1102868319,
0.0068908636,
0.0150207607,
-0.0158229955,
0.0399417914,
0.0027818915,
-0.0118586421,
0.0079646958,
0.0140003655,
-0.0413973443,
-0.0108446535,
0.0424186476,
0.0636790469,
0.0010924789,
-0.0051442431,
0.0104983039,
-0.047997959,
0.0619570166,
0.0866102576,
0.0351480171,
-0.0542995892,
-0.017877914,
-0.0232062917,
0.0091810478,
0.0201391559,
-0.0036996605,
0.058207646,
-0.0332638547,
-0.0488833338,
-0.0325300097,
-0.041444093,
0.0179269314,
0.0251809414,
0.0224115234,
0.0362545028,
-0.0412035249,
0.0319479667,
-0.0333395004,
0.0422711223,
-0.0491449945,
0.0312844627,
-0.0688649267,
-0.0232956428,
0.0253904294,
-0.03123964,
-0.0307594072,
-0.0013379868,
-0.0577888638,
-0.0631689802,
0.0136164268,
0.0203204043,
0.0138474377,
0.0865246579,
-0.0141963363,
-0.0522460416,
0.0655373335,
0.0534552597,
-0.0305708703,
0.0312063135,
0.0119008273,
-0.0271639843,
0.0068374509,
0.0290299077,
-0.0503755249,
0.023914475,
0.0554362051,
0.0037550828,
-0.0274473261,
0.0075366804,
0.0256042089,
-0.0157316998,
0.0895117223,
-0.02233232,
-0.013380398,
-0.0038057677,
0.0334543362,
0.0296532605,
-0.0403585956,
0.0117282746,
-0.0124835819,
0.0163749848,
0.0267680027,
-0.0067012492,
0.036947865,
-0.0004461213,
0.0441879407,
0.0157731995,
-0.0181648787,
0.0138052208,
0.0287795104,
0.0541026704,
0.0380507447,
-0.0223408248,
0.0278293807,
0.0320749953,
0.050680019,
0.0227626525,
0.0256820135,
0.0332168601,
0.0152774062,
-0.0271204412,
0.0110630402,
-0.0807065144,
-0.004701212,
-0.0193726588,
-0.0015307625,
0.0711316094,
-0.0429133624,
-0.0168534517,
-0.0264442433,
-0.0136618726,
-0.0442225859,
-0.0048330911,
-0.0111744208,
-0.028152518,
0.0266112294,
0.010003441,
-0.0172612015,
0.0412946753,
0.0956210047,
0.0096455561,
0.0492454059,
-0.0028260329,
0.0144981062,
-0.0099195084,
0.0356602818,
0.0371215418,
0.0444828868,
-0.0069790776,
0.0281371083,
-0.0256974641,
-0.0711458251,
-0.0174786188,
-0.0376901999,
0.0148296114,
-0.0123417974,
0.0403206572,
0.0472811423,
-0.0047575035,
0.0045957952,
-0.0170144998,
-0.0072899936,
0.0089954734,
-0.0194972847,
-0.0346165039,
-6.462222154e-33,
-0.0056302738,
-0.0282943118,
-0.0119159464,
0.0131995827,
0.0315967016,
0.0036645238,
-0.0454491191,
0.0155520234,
-0.0103108715,
0.0162811652,
-0.0148050059,
0.0109147131,
0.0114586065,
0.0321649872,
0.0089440774,
-0.0392057449,
0.0469690971,
-0.0109591885,
-0.0034597071,
0.0317642651,
0.0080545144,
0.0327778943,
0.0488454141,
-0.0864020735,
0.0237450507,
-0.0325214341,
0.0095539093,
0.0116245123,
-0.0115718059,
0.0325148478,
-0.026427364,
0.076886408,
0.0357463844,
-0.0335576683,
-0.0051886616,
0.0249255151,
-0.0608547181,
-0.0088196574,
-0.0350392684,
0.0410979763,
-0.0038997487,
-0.0147869596,
0.0329233967,
0.0126488237,
-0.036388427,
-0.0128939161,
0.0624022223,
-0.0054370603,
-0.0617598929,
-0.0342790745,
-0.045659855,
0.0120845735,
0.0075639863,
-0.0118126068,
-0.0160146747,
0.0142662702,
0.0034006902,
0.0401601233,
-0.0516962223,
0.0002894152,
0.0033399404,
0.0138293095,
0.02304326,
0.0672990084,
0.007346401,
0.0385026298,
0.008914833,
0.0465725549,
0.0264521576,
-0.0416790135,
0.0416955613,
-0.0051782909,
0.0203623138,
0.0298100915,
0.0710048378,
-0.0041575758,
-0.0699883774,
0.0002589533,
-0.0017556655,
-0.0334705636,
0.0286257397,
0.0189404637,
-0.0464994609,
-0.0510454141,
-0.0492071733,
-0.0265235249,
-0.0523974262,
0.00828146,
0.0602578856,
0.0252869464,
0.0153727951,
-0.0036245838,
0.0025748669,
-0.0360970199,
-0.0823076218,
0.0058079851,
0.0079379668,
0.0000514791,
-0.0021684435,
-0.0179187581,
-0.0445374548,
-0.0295963101,
-0.0033148678,
0.0231777169,
0.014812395,
-0.0105824582,
0.0930150598,
0.0161573421,
-0.0711766928,
-0.0047711264,
-0.0199578088,
0.0196612626,
0.0534580164,
0.0298637934,
0.0285551734,
0.0020986602,
-0.0134843802,
0.0734303594,
0.0288298037,
-0.0379041173,
-0.0095054442,
-0.0274857637,
-0.0618329346,
-0.0093578519,
-0.0403796174,
-0.0493150018,
-0.0091920001,
0.0164498724,
0.0593674369,
-0.0346997418,
-0.0134772025,
-0.0408746116,
2.753e-7,
0.0142525937,
0.0320056081,
-0.0226526149,
-0.0301920678,
0.036879994,
0.0615365021,
-0.0502948686,
0.0171591137,
0.0237502642,
-0.0004750559,
-0.0275300127,
0.0165522192,
0.0311398339,
0.0158331748,
-0.0576215684,
-0.0042378255,
-0.0746794045,
0.0361765735,
-0.0315494984,
0.0414640084,
0.0119820619,
0.0954411849,
0.0322888382,
-0.0559883304,
0.0215774532,
-0.0594235584,
0.0638839155,
-0.0418892577,
0.054690402,
-0.0161959846,
-0.0237327721,
0.0382912718,
0.0195797011,
0.0598126724,
-0.0292013772,
0.0009310698,
-0.0313853472,
0.024095254,
-0.0284129418,
-0.0144708045,
-0.0120089427,
0.0502581224,
0.0061211796,
-0.0672314093,
0.0763414875,
-0.0674319342,
-0.017978128,
-0.0514135472,
0.012920538,
-0.0517521426,
0.0316658579,
-0.0002040963,
-0.0147472257,
-0.0009402527,
0.0026294326,
-0.007638969,
-0.0354800448,
-0.09454377,
-0.0463158786,
0.0321362615,
-0.0225224327,
-0.042139899,
-0.0105848974,
0.0444437899,
0.0303425137,
-0.0273926128,
0.0222506095,
2.257741923e-34,
0.0154450806,
-0.0031367315,
0.0359790623,
0.0538488179,
-0.0326430276,
-0.006475586,
-0.0059898994,
-0.0099322302,
0.0384504311,
-0.0263424609,
0.023747379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15410v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15410v1 | Towards a Fully Unsupervised Framework for Intent Induction in Customer Support Dialogues | 2023-07-28T09:03:14 | 2023-07-28T09:03:14 | Rita Costa, Bruno Martins, Sérgio Viana, Luisa Coheur | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2; I.7 | State of the art models in intent induction require annotated datasets.
However, annotating dialogues is time-consuming, laborious and expensive. In
this work, we propose a completely unsupervised framework for intent induction
within a dialogue. In addition, we show how pre-processing the dialogue corpora
can improve results. Finally, we show how to extract the dialogue flows of
intentions by investigating the most common sequences. Although we test our
work in the MultiWOZ dataset, the fact that this framework requires no prior
knowledge make it applicable to any possible use case, making it very relevant
to real world customer support applications across industry. | [
0.0570319071,
0.0402862914,
-0.0128758177,
0.0423924886,
-0.0409406126,
0.0226122681,
0.0023124879,
-0.0295094214,
0.0433193222,
-0.0449847132,
0.0033546621,
-0.0252924766,
-0.0061049229,
0.0511203855,
-0.0054512732,
-0.0486433171,
0.0161257517,
0.0240364168,
0.0586265102,
0.0455095433,
0.0360254757,
0.0142313642,
-0.0540374778,
0.0291841608,
-0.0439189784,
-0.0133321797,
-0.029908061,
0.0138993487,
0.0101663135,
-0.0144216232,
0.0381898507,
0.0616982058,
0.0337907746,
-0.0000356045,
0.000001785,
-0.0799443424,
-0.0228121094,
-0.0422433913,
-0.0857718363,
-0.0281712133,
-0.0161482356,
-0.0064913947,
-0.004452128,
0.0417290218,
-0.0594841018,
0.0493556261,
0.0079099126,
0.050409738,
0.0847754031,
0.0749926046,
-0.0377237648,
-0.0077713458,
-0.0015290142,
0.0179090835,
0.0083949603,
-0.0312193893,
0.0186658297,
0.0180999003,
-0.0363952406,
-0.0100457454,
0.0203577131,
0.0197487958,
-0.0382718369,
-0.0350872129,
-0.0157588962,
-0.0067550465,
-0.0330360346,
-0.0432115048,
-0.0436328538,
0.0875868425,
-0.0087672006,
0.0213486888,
0.0072087487,
-0.0140526472,
0.0029962109,
-0.000039185,
-0.0216002315,
-0.0016590508,
-0.0166408457,
-0.0346862897,
0.0024233854,
0.0362518989,
-0.0028315652,
-0.0399989597,
-0.0368198194,
0.0560430698,
-0.0046760091,
-0.0406964831,
0.0159827173,
0.0090290271,
-0.012596746,
-0.0484205149,
0.0249227136,
0.011926434,
-0.0604844503,
0.0361113101,
0.0078102313,
0.00192014,
0.0268929899,
-0.0527295023,
0.0106068766,
0.0056077233,
-0.0575523153,
0.0431011394,
0.0026738076,
-0.0424059145,
0.0246083494,
-0.0220150482,
-0.0324972235,
0.0374831632,
-0.0442845672,
0.0145769669,
-0.0594721437,
-0.0045491816,
-0.0580807552,
-0.0274515711,
-0.0150039941,
0.0540464595,
0.0074609951,
0.0389332958,
0.0057163965,
0.0034281246,
-0.0307761747,
-0.0106811486,
-0.0008400371,
0.0217415225,
-0.0666305795,
0.0453389101,
0.0074543483,
-0.0675820932,
-0.003471771,
0.0626559407,
0.0364643559,
0.0160223916,
-0.0140694045,
0.0088106859,
0.004789901,
-0.056695316,
-0.0676708743,
-0.0636070073,
-0.0021016882,
-0.0270452183,
-0.0234659705,
0.0017384099,
0.0403643325,
-0.0139997872,
-0.0146600483,
0.0121728443,
0.0178358331,
0.012369439,
0.0051308689,
0.0669999346,
-0.0664561912,
0.0173891746,
0.0336332805,
0.0009355786,
0.0519544855,
0.0423401333,
0.0062017241,
0.025889881,
0.0790154934,
-0.0024054504,
0.0660910159,
0.0391814597,
0.0061798082,
-0.0297644585,
0.0441117547,
0.0336635858,
-0.0485059358,
0.0435805023,
0.0131109003,
0.0026116595,
-0.0122827534,
-0.0169871897,
0.0175035167,
0.0591952354,
-0.0276712235,
-0.0016290681,
0.0586785823,
0.0506424084,
-0.0297627896,
0.0433938615,
-0.0025080293,
-0.0051987055,
-0.0122519601,
0.0106407022,
0.0309473909,
-0.0018666819,
-0.0339232795,
-0.037258327,
0.0021069602,
-0.0352165885,
-0.0008242012,
-0.0037413382,
0.0166246444,
0.0360746235,
-0.0344158337,
0.0302163828,
0.0018711644,
-0.0471947193,
-0.0561086275,
-0.0115426471,
0.0186972469,
0.0645188987,
0.0401001796,
-0.0604815446,
-0.0581197999,
-0.0386219658,
-0.0233767107,
0.0221271329,
0.0199070927,
-0.031739559,
0.019894639,
-0.0667062104,
-0.0192403253,
0.0456331596,
0.0071590175,
-0.0025163661,
-0.0273240823,
-0.0543961115,
0.0103666019,
0.0215924643,
0.0128242942,
0.003515685,
-0.0045722751,
-0.0363201685,
0.0110298768,
0.0334227793,
0.0447193533,
0.0697894469,
0.0088966042,
-0.034012109,
0.0202594455,
-0.0098131392,
-0.0212273095,
0.0763245076,
-0.0235509705,
-0.0657444745,
0.0050306572,
-0.0181820951,
-0.0445227623,
0.0001595831,
-0.0189446192,
-0.0646774247,
-0.0209829863,
-0.0402791388,
0.041009184,
-0.0525057651,
-0.0328920111,
0.0647397861,
0.0180018973,
-0.0093859639,
0.0341915824,
0.0093239453,
-0.0075947191,
0.0149937812,
-0.0133250235,
0.043942567,
-0.0414134562,
-0.0024214524,
-0.0064193709,
-0.0285010319,
-0.0096092932,
0.034790609,
-0.007895031,
-0.0636933446,
0.0409152843,
-0.096632719,
-0.0091897929,
-0.0259532314,
0.0139506729,
-0.0088792946,
0.0404163003,
-0.0259348676,
-0.0239622202,
-0.0558016375,
-0.0076910579,
0.0247063246,
-0.0179787837,
0.0564954281,
0.0087966826,
-0.0555527136,
-0.0518922135,
0.0324196406,
-0.0345628299,
-0.0170387235,
0.0107515296,
-0.056408979,
-0.0775472596,
0.0052086101,
-0.0233676303,
0.007940162,
-0.0058959364,
-0.0637863502,
0.0170615595,
-0.0153729916,
0.0066800318,
0.0491862781,
0.0399475396,
0.0137822991,
-0.0337275006,
-0.0028220452,
-0.0294882767,
0.0252378993,
-0.0494832397,
0.0055575492,
-0.0221517347,
-0.0335880816,
0.0642459244,
0.051834926,
0.016389586,
0.0230853278,
-0.0234466307,
-0.0929332152,
0.0270020161,
0.0080082342,
-0.0257941373,
0.0059443871,
-0.0397013575,
0.0947554111,
0.0489625186,
-0.0556899942,
0.0452563651,
-0.0354186483,
-0.0505663082,
-0.0719884485,
-0.0200654231,
-0.0278318711,
0.0698769242,
-0.0170005672,
0.0233882368,
0.0226788186,
-0.0498244651,
0.0359814279,
0.0114664277,
0.0131297456,
-0.0161837768,
0.0287991017,
-0.0305727031,
0.0154111004,
0.0216590576,
0.0006827497,
-0.061083734,
-0.0837348849,
-0.0184713937,
-0.0329717249,
0.0584445819,
-0.0270900782,
-0.0250322036,
0.0095887734,
-0.0132701956,
0.0829760656,
0.0368345864,
-0.0129068857,
-0.0116526978,
0.0287606213,
0.0385162383,
0.0476615764,
-0.0278096963,
0.0158272926,
0.0515644513,
0.0149907833,
-0.0061433604,
-0.0053742151,
-0.0155497203,
-0.0067032035,
0.00888432,
-0.0192355923,
0.0261855312,
0.0097180782,
0.0318253636,
0.0117767649,
-0.0150150936,
0.1143629253,
0.0419342816,
-0.0393154584,
0.0023388171,
-0.0047099497,
-0.004822765,
0.0220451336,
0.0043223551,
-0.1007202789,
-0.0387887433,
-0.0111477114,
0.0346216448,
-0.0122263115,
-0.0251934826,
-0.0120447697,
-0.0737921074,
0.0766110346,
-0.0142856408,
0.0047839922,
-0.0309245344,
-0.0209228769,
-0.0054021026,
-0.0005950237,
0.0182545073,
-0.0272024106,
0.0154560283,
-0.042317573,
0.0288456678,
-0.0752065107,
-0.0739907324,
-0.0030924045,
0.0006400474,
0.0837395117,
0.0438352525,
0.0050218394,
0.036800161,
0.0084714787,
0.0055819224,
-0.0016217645,
0.0083210701,
0.007723731,
0.069962956,
-0.0250634812,
-0.0084019201,
0.0215232596,
0.0617951341,
-0.0904166698,
0.0011604346,
0.0295135286,
0.0246219896,
-0.060251873,
0.0227883551,
-0.0008935418,
0.0471762456,
0.0749697089,
0.0808452442,
0.0275431927,
-0.0280418806,
0.0414278395,
-0.0289847385,
-0.0000196834,
0.029523395,
-0.0195135772,
-0.0048346836,
0.0157564767,
-0.0109097669,
-0.081191726,
-0.0839233398,
0.0401354805,
0.0335603505,
0.0163127109,
-0.0048677088,
0.0090662334,
0.0101742931,
-0.0081932964,
0.0118974727,
-0.0116493003,
0.0192806516,
-0.059237089,
-0.0344643667,
0.0024048437,
-0.0136681311,
-0.0172716044,
0.0010294386,
-0.0166334808,
-0.0366625562,
-0.0046714945,
0.0425237343,
0.0224868022,
0.0411408432,
0.0059878388,
-0.0054610646,
-0.052589938,
0.0492898971,
-0.0357993767,
-0.0669268742,
0.0473305061,
0.0731337294,
-0.029911885,
0.0382756256,
0.0143318446,
0.0341931097,
-0.0670131147,
0.0368771814,
-0.0913493559,
-0.0851949602,
0.0371351577,
0.0247461349,
0.0497820489,
-0.001404401,
0.0123507893,
-0.0483144186,
0.0316721238,
0.0049235872,
-0.027611712,
-0.0376788042,
0.0177424867,
-0.0208277702,
-0.0364752635,
0.0068780691,
-0.0130069926,
-0.0956479758,
-0.0168565493,
-0.0002626466,
0.0143644148,
0.0352174565,
0.0255196467,
-0.0336032882,
-0.0335231274,
-0.0051074154,
0.0185115021,
0.0090209218,
0.043541044,
0.0300786663,
0.0729615092,
0.0324828103,
0.0040276311,
0.0134879304,
0.0266973823,
-0.0258097351,
-0.0237030089,
-0.0170121957,
0.0436823033,
0.0400593355,
-0.064123936,
0.0434426479,
-0.0458937436,
0.0394498967,
-0.0098337755,
0.0815752223,
0.0050830641,
-0.0161491912,
0.0137775922,
0.0115385056,
-0.0499585122,
-0.0035892166,
0.0551282689,
-0.0636096671,
0.0121853203,
-0.021876784,
-0.0111842481,
-0.0943193063,
-0.0141699454,
0.0404734053,
0.0370885246,
-0.0246536192,
0.0086719133,
-0.0442751944,
-0.0238248724,
-0.0332390629,
-0.0040017366,
0.0272981282,
0.0035157753,
0.0630229861,
0.0425866842,
-0.0155238453,
0.0157044698,
-0.0126390578,
0.0024416386,
-0.0469441041,
0.0017186549,
-0.0311840363,
-5.804878366e-33,
-0.0020380109,
-0.0151395351,
0.011558149,
0.023920957,
0.0367021412,
-0.008321722,
-0.0246160235,
0.008918779,
0.0248872619,
0.0230734833,
-0.0116072334,
0.0131056858,
0.0189206973,
0.0182222147,
0.0225279201,
-0.0015309108,
0.0536959432,
-0.0178694688,
-0.006193955,
0.0201902222,
0.0394493639,
0.0271006431,
0.0251285415,
-0.1043571979,
0.0516324118,
-0.0320960358,
-0.0102437306,
0.0490144826,
0.0252327397,
0.0326996483,
-0.0181882977,
0.012736721,
0.0156098129,
-0.0177369658,
0.0322405733,
0.0636595786,
-0.0246306118,
0.0019457643,
0.0094667003,
0.0246998202,
-0.0481862351,
0.0373405553,
-0.0226679724,
-0.0205768663,
0.0209619403,
0.0421363488,
0.0182387289,
-0.0167832561,
0.0016303312,
-0.0070857629,
-0.0731330067,
0.0283500571,
-0.0487209707,
-0.0689116344,
0.0360899642,
0.0511690862,
0.0072611184,
-0.0245149564,
0.0019557134,
0.0177842434,
-0.0418827794,
-0.0059170919,
0.0079777343,
-0.0189923383,
-0.0443298072,
0.0455694273,
-0.0035480971,
-0.0265335552,
0.0286496375,
0.0092077507,
-0.056319572,
0.0554759242,
-0.0149417901,
0.0122764762,
-0.0110132219,
-0.0091221482,
-0.0289402474,
0.0591434948,
0.0645427108,
-0.0350770727,
-0.0171160642,
-0.0205913689,
-0.052602917,
0.0197680574,
0.0281989556,
-0.0204096697,
0.0102269938,
-0.0079191448,
0.014520172,
0.0259942934,
-0.0195345841,
0.0250328574,
0.0151005937,
-0.0130520239,
0.0062523149,
-0.0111419633,
-0.0116948271,
-0.0127722686,
-0.0069574979,
-0.0035951021,
-0.0616165288,
-0.0237314552,
0.0058455518,
0.0050948104,
0.0234068986,
0.0073545291,
0.039987538,
-0.0112578226,
-0.0216704793,
-0.0051053031,
-0.0067228321,
0.0348877311,
-0.0863048732,
0.0308971107,
0.0287041757,
0.0146620777,
-0.0344415903,
0.0783259496,
-0.0233667605,
0.0149826873,
-0.0374114476,
-0.0253750701,
-0.0209081937,
0.0149449669,
-0.0376866721,
-0.0159094222,
0.0195524581,
-0.0357913934,
0.0000815869,
-0.0355828628,
0.0102013126,
-0.0243639853,
2.572e-7,
0.0091336742,
0.0570381917,
0.031873025,
0.0241315439,
0.022215724,
0.043602936,
-0.0037926417,
0.0296238009,
0.0010079219,
-0.0432075523,
0.0730692297,
-0.041642867,
0.027683448,
-0.0127396574,
-0.1022592783,
-0.0543219708,
-0.0147753153,
-0.0180059243,
-0.0704998076,
0.004158577,
0.1071694046,
0.0706541911,
-0.0176735725,
-0.0089813471,
0.0159291197,
0.0081056142,
0.0136897098,
-0.0450877696,
-0.0001756326,
0.0203864984,
0.073619023,
0.0024960525,
-0.014122325,
0.0234749224,
-0.0084631946,
0.03415123,
-0.0136582749,
0.061803665,
0.0199281964,
-0.0447190069,
-0.0265835375,
0.0224557426,
0.0270111263,
-0.0059885322,
0.0037827785,
-0.0325136818,
-0.0180558916,
0.0117450356,
-0.016350992,
-0.0015927849,
0.0021506737,
0.019462591,
-0.0078325896,
0.0463342182,
0.0328446403,
-0.0283251926,
0.0077913851,
-0.1041456014,
0.0394097157,
0.0298506543,
-0.0276957136,
-0.0126524987,
0.0001177497,
-0.0094863009,
0.0061227735,
-0.0145036243,
-0.0069816709,
1.888177749e-34,
0.0315972418,
0.0086082481,
0.0321860611,
0.0408986136,
0.0152367633,
-0.032023523,
-0.0002771058,
0.0149804372,
0.0268979296,
-0.0537934117,
0.0010511581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15376v1 | Multilingual Tourist Assistance using ChatGPT: Comparing Capabilities in Hindi, Telugu, and Kannada | 2023-07-28T07:52:26 | 2023-07-28T07:52:26 | Sanjana Kolar, Rohit Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research investigates the effectiveness of ChatGPT, an AI language model
by OpenAI, in translating English into Hindi, Telugu, and Kannada languages,
aimed at assisting tourists in India's linguistically diverse environment. To
measure the translation quality, a test set of 50 questions from diverse fields
such as general knowledge, food, and travel was used. These were assessed by
five volunteers for accuracy and fluency, and the scores were subsequently
converted into a BLEU score. The BLEU score evaluates the closeness of a
machine-generated translation to a human translation, with a higher score
indicating better translation quality. The Hindi translations outperformed
others, showcasing superior accuracy and fluency, whereas Telugu translations
lagged behind. Human evaluators rated both the accuracy and fluency of
translations, offering a comprehensive perspective on the language model's
performance. | [
0.0590966344,
-0.0256541297,
-0.042488087,
0.0591979362,
-0.0724701434,
0.0003454608,
0.0046796179,
0.0095419697,
0.0282340143,
-0.0355676264,
-0.0350887999,
-0.056363035,
0.0308012292,
0.047861021,
-0.0072409562,
-0.061490301,
0.035026975,
0.0077093281,
0.0069713104,
0.0200406518,
-0.0157431718,
0.0378466919,
-0.0228378046,
0.0726357177,
0.0244644973,
-0.0162451323,
0.0054501533,
0.0238494761,
0.0310375281,
-0.0258928183,
-0.0272115357,
-0.0064024217,
0.030401025,
0.0144873224,
0.0000021405,
-0.0361188389,
0.0149351582,
0.0196464993,
-0.0054866928,
-0.0176661238,
0.0676051825,
0.02183179,
0.0368660279,
0.0490380898,
-0.0057575698,
0.0126152178,
0.058215823,
0.013617631,
0.0255843122,
0.0779443905,
-0.0174526591,
-0.0236778911,
-0.0163803343,
0.0157625508,
-0.0147438599,
-0.0309986621,
-0.0224121641,
-0.001043663,
-0.0088497046,
-0.0073637124,
-0.0048201135,
0.0496255085,
-0.0183072593,
0.0043970845,
-0.0021184194,
0.0165008176,
-0.03483117,
-0.0425958708,
0.0068843164,
0.0482775196,
-0.0133626945,
0.0085838893,
-0.0487385504,
-0.0088832313,
-0.0416709855,
0.0073161037,
-0.0224705171,
0.0155650768,
-0.0029073509,
0.0479496345,
0.0172979888,
0.0434260108,
0.003877382,
0.0089692147,
0.030923862,
-0.0108489832,
0.0094626183,
-0.0216677431,
-0.0463206917,
0.0121020274,
0.0036052696,
0.0063445196,
0.0373019502,
0.0197886992,
-0.0188236553,
0.0426583961,
0.0382454097,
-0.0156789571,
0.0057764272,
-0.0765174925,
0.0199157652,
0.0805746317,
-0.045415353,
0.0233483221,
0.0118304128,
0.0442567021,
0.0157583989,
0.0390955508,
-0.0617380366,
0.0073287608,
-0.0315899812,
-0.0002273017,
-0.0067703454,
-0.0142118782,
-0.0434168093,
0.001204272,
-0.0347762406,
-0.0014581924,
0.0252701007,
0.0033359812,
0.0265943501,
-0.0234646723,
-0.0584490485,
-0.043864511,
-0.02260416,
0.043448057,
-0.0268929191,
-0.0028821416,
-0.0104318121,
-0.0637681112,
0.037991561,
0.0193806738,
-0.0168429408,
-0.0146726612,
-0.0564785302,
0.0460865609,
-0.0309488457,
-0.041639898,
-0.0760660544,
0.0181158576,
0.0008839279,
-0.0678041726,
-0.0275144093,
-0.0518692955,
0.0635815114,
0.0201939829,
-0.0098909093,
-0.0276174955,
0.0157772265,
0.0147909718,
-0.0552005172,
0.0391778201,
-0.0093163904,
0.0264153313,
0.0591865331,
0.0246213842,
0.0237307996,
0.0361897089,
0.0385803469,
0.0385596901,
0.0444259308,
-0.006813067,
0.0072540566,
0.011600011,
-0.041393552,
0.0217342582,
-0.0167541876,
0.0218639318,
-0.0079715457,
0.0184423812,
-0.0423917808,
0.0602749959,
0.0065105185,
0.1060652807,
0.046357803,
0.0379744358,
0.0085013267,
0.0838673785,
0.0373740308,
0.00873587,
-0.0110721393,
0.0075595449,
0.0118734492,
0.0011297821,
-0.008893487,
0.0143517461,
0.0445221663,
0.0365173444,
0.0205081906,
-0.0291364752,
-0.0212889649,
-0.0440890379,
0.0599878393,
-0.040006578,
0.0118030207,
-0.0148029551,
-0.0685062781,
-0.0308077708,
0.0144254137,
-0.0739554092,
0.0223660953,
-0.0275249239,
-0.0026760881,
0.098495394,
0.028670961,
0.0307878219,
0.0340249054,
-0.0232625194,
-0.0025041862,
0.0496150963,
0.074406825,
0.0240091681,
-0.0006390789,
-0.0616215207,
0.0353542902,
0.0278401747,
-0.0078403,
0.0014777528,
-0.0163194053,
0.0737286657,
0.0292309169,
0.0103117302,
-0.0640262589,
0.0132683879,
0.027162483,
-0.0108870519,
-0.0023097983,
-0.0072269901,
0.00644603,
0.0485070609,
-0.0176143795,
-0.0178228412,
0.0112809502,
-0.0030939069,
0.0006799293,
0.0612713732,
0.0099445255,
-0.0088958861,
-0.0021591177,
-0.0348012596,
-0.0075026439,
0.0106328446,
-0.0224463399,
-0.0465560481,
-0.0232813768,
-0.002868081,
0.0413009711,
-0.0063799541,
0.0360499695,
-0.0088109262,
-0.0081805103,
-0.0296827704,
0.0375655331,
0.0222519785,
-0.0384023339,
-0.0008907804,
0.0048628412,
0.0572973378,
-0.0318775252,
-0.0255476739,
0.052039735,
0.0269197058,
0.0636976585,
0.0292199552,
0.0406754576,
-0.0444859862,
-0.0176926591,
-0.1316635162,
-0.024408197,
-0.001983243,
0.0141838994,
0.0343218707,
0.034802679,
-0.0054496257,
0.0253819376,
-0.0042252303,
0.0109296134,
0.0079044569,
-0.0221665315,
0.0090696616,
-0.0099230548,
-0.0153372716,
-0.0161042344,
0.0268581361,
0.0063721752,
0.0135682728,
0.0588742532,
-0.0565451495,
-0.0708470866,
-0.0039919834,
-0.0557210371,
-0.0377426967,
0.0200274326,
-0.0950596109,
-0.02266814,
-0.0063274759,
0.0209431909,
-0.0089489901,
0.0199281946,
-0.01885245,
0.0132736694,
-0.0041790591,
-0.0157297626,
-0.0220660064,
-0.0119139794,
-0.0502701476,
-0.0038345922,
-0.0660545006,
0.0104402788,
-0.0335128717,
0.0075184884,
0.0208006855,
-0.0633373559,
-0.0348580442,
-0.0734815672,
0.0193233881,
-0.0125619825,
0.0524604917,
-0.0394688286,
0.0952602476,
-0.0102396021,
-0.0321347937,
0.0239049979,
-0.0232046116,
0.0061164973,
-0.0997827649,
0.0215178244,
-0.0249726698,
0.0449488647,
-0.0509346239,
0.062515527,
-0.0549875721,
-0.008343434,
0.0075288913,
-0.0090205679,
-0.0114081604,
-0.0394857861,
0.0019036242,
-0.0863175169,
0.0143507048,
0.0135441255,
0.0047160918,
-0.0125283785,
0.0045416937,
0.0078940634,
-0.0200256053,
0.0457387567,
0.0060133953,
0.00561054,
0.0562458485,
-0.0086376676,
0.0050418056,
-0.0043037995,
0.0141230589,
0.0143877286,
-0.0065891654,
0.0326547362,
0.0642844811,
-0.0123035666,
0.0271313172,
0.0159933157,
-0.0162828863,
-0.0209262595,
-0.0530141965,
0.0170016866,
-0.0030226193,
0.0189732239,
-0.020712005,
-0.0577365011,
0.0357103981,
0.0350561254,
-0.0064403629,
-0.0127083044,
0.0819023401,
0.0441925377,
-0.0749317855,
-0.0338688754,
-0.0978774205,
-0.0319843963,
-0.0221427362,
0.0473919772,
-0.0490831956,
0.0002257588,
0.0085429549,
0.0064136703,
-0.0090775462,
0.0473961458,
-0.0500147864,
-0.0727185607,
0.0265148468,
-0.0030975167,
-0.0416267775,
-0.0364716537,
0.0007130848,
-0.0541972108,
0.0062000095,
0.0309093837,
-0.0003464662,
-0.0010144722,
-0.0194368679,
-0.0026784306,
-0.0069877789,
-0.0715581328,
0.0008992019,
-0.0568334647,
0.0628292635,
0.0679861978,
0.0489312373,
-0.0284058806,
-0.0442529432,
0.0081760557,
0.0228118133,
0.0350792706,
-0.0066156965,
0.0349193066,
-0.0169877186,
0.0043211509,
0.025904486,
-0.0237885769,
-0.0221746452,
0.0096419593,
0.0316738151,
0.0008504669,
-0.0007997893,
0.0311879683,
0.0104047963,
0.0048677009,
0.0166817792,
0.0207842682,
0.0098422812,
-0.0262356959,
0.0046607438,
-0.0376676805,
-0.0096174628,
-0.0197900794,
-0.0129352864,
0.0353243761,
-0.0765529573,
-0.0998793244,
-0.0693187267,
-0.0743136406,
0.0308264811,
0.0080477111,
0.0563823991,
0.0318003967,
-0.0004196095,
0.0404649302,
0.0337073803,
0.0020230371,
-0.034303546,
0.0340206176,
-0.09761177,
0.0164638273,
0.0119695254,
-0.0465413556,
-0.001279369,
0.008661462,
0.0077547804,
-0.0330872722,
0.0290326513,
0.0666004047,
0.0302520115,
-0.0340746231,
-0.0211123358,
-0.0419446267,
-0.0548861735,
0.0111492407,
-0.0213126335,
-0.0288015176,
-0.0078519415,
0.018607486,
0.0099108182,
0.0203474164,
-0.0190224331,
-0.0076631624,
-0.0532601215,
0.0465326943,
0.0055383802,
-0.0579866581,
0.0572733358,
0.0619627871,
0.0207156688,
-0.0516925231,
0.0078259427,
-0.0403349251,
-0.005023201,
-0.0055866605,
-0.012272154,
-0.034684103,
-0.0279530901,
0.0497555174,
0.0095288651,
0.0184713434,
-0.0312154125,
-0.0684601888,
-0.0472126752,
0.02061796,
0.0241834633,
-0.0261526816,
0.0620228536,
0.001232435,
0.0196562316,
-0.046585355,
-0.0035771993,
-0.0304660965,
0.0006882607,
-0.0146836052,
0.1010141,
0.0141793732,
0.0175316259,
0.0185624957,
0.0542195402,
0.0800192729,
-0.05999282,
-0.0051864805,
0.0731577128,
0.0682213753,
0.0251330957,
0.061559312,
-0.0180232693,
-0.0018588746,
-0.0056953472,
0.0297610573,
0.0066443053,
-0.0288913306,
0.0362718515,
-0.0308127757,
-0.0181733686,
-0.0109561319,
0.0337716863,
-0.0505055003,
-0.0317622572,
-0.006420048,
-0.0219931435,
-0.0248032752,
0.0082509778,
-0.0169116072,
0.0102176163,
0.0029673108,
-0.0149358986,
-0.0569991134,
-0.0534033775,
-0.0262184087,
0.0015631084,
0.0293827914,
-0.0563322566,
-0.0030832542,
0.0651483089,
0.0050003468,
-0.025521744,
-0.05604757,
-0.005281223,
-0.0568632893,
0.0204949062,
-0.0304869246,
-6.427016098e-33,
-0.0225576889,
-0.0117297852,
0.03163803,
0.0118101556,
0.0022602829,
-0.0189889874,
-0.0197866932,
0.0232062005,
-0.0101126404,
-0.0008114693,
-0.0242014248,
-0.032602746,
0.0167554319,
-0.0267677363,
0.000054418,
-0.0180944521,
0.0336681753,
0.0315209739,
-0.045057334,
-0.0048329649,
0.02872709,
-0.0003757426,
0.0834461749,
-0.079851836,
0.0494864173,
-0.0909058377,
-0.0477428325,
0.001779601,
0.0158081185,
-0.0030692464,
-0.0120000839,
-0.0002218427,
0.0375638418,
-0.011664493,
0.0251867119,
-0.0187374894,
-0.0194542296,
-0.0180357993,
0.0594909526,
0.066667825,
-0.0152333574,
-0.0146987243,
0.0081174336,
-0.0211109519,
-0.0366476588,
0.0581687167,
0.0205182377,
-0.0230834093,
-0.0154360393,
0.0558399595,
-0.0805035681,
0.0113642272,
-0.0034128374,
-0.013561802,
0.0256046318,
0.0647696108,
-0.041635856,
-0.0237065777,
-0.0348102525,
0.0106553845,
0.0195993744,
0.0054484447,
0.0782628059,
-0.0222723465,
-0.0658833086,
-0.0318656117,
-0.0065140859,
-0.0291299857,
-0.0204099566,
-0.0122346077,
-0.0003522566,
0.0127896266,
0.0084988065,
0.0720754117,
0.0111218272,
-0.1032618657,
0.0240399335,
0.0460952558,
0.0318308175,
0.0060057645,
0.0146721769,
0.0202707313,
-0.0306336302,
-0.0420512073,
-0.009888472,
0.0085731596,
-0.0254292991,
-0.0976950452,
0.054574199,
-0.0195187088,
-0.0329621844,
0.0143700521,
0.0701805204,
-0.0209947508,
0.0283109285,
-0.0453409627,
-0.0377669334,
-0.000778009,
-0.0251391046,
0.0392653421,
-0.0679683909,
-0.0431354865,
-0.0321389101,
0.0392225496,
0.0028547924,
-0.0140380124,
-0.0205245372,
-0.0151594663,
-0.0213874467,
0.0307532381,
-0.0241115876,
-0.0153564913,
0.0091858255,
0.0248463675,
0.0039879093,
-0.0139202718,
-0.0284659248,
0.038603045,
0.06963633,
0.0136996219,
-0.037659619,
-0.0393362753,
0.0143023618,
0.0152621968,
-0.0593333021,
0.0353057683,
-0.0402006172,
-0.020875318,
0.0174851585,
-0.0375999361,
-0.0254358742,
0.0303838626,
2.953e-7,
0.0283134673,
0.0822124109,
-0.0311660897,
-0.0018555268,
-0.044813823,
0.0115066292,
-0.0268143658,
0.0006424275,
0.0235760026,
0.0713379905,
0.0098427022,
0.0033035555,
0.0251940805,
0.0631069094,
-0.0420519151,
0.0024282124,
-0.0682994425,
0.0201882347,
-0.0560399406,
0.0257636309,
0.0299712475,
0.0565339737,
0.0084971879,
0.0000090302,
-0.0161726531,
-0.0519717,
0.0439856015,
-0.035755109,
-0.021250641,
0.0360255204,
0.0417017564,
0.0679100379,
-0.0431710556,
-0.0032969418,
0.0026455629,
-0.0251454413,
0.0765235126,
0.0625727698,
-0.007904835,
0.0321519524,
0.039791204,
0.00426551,
0.0007820672,
-0.0871514976,
0.0300633479,
0.0166465193,
-0.018908361,
0.0032748824,
0.0129010435,
0.0295312703,
0.0430418402,
-0.0396611728,
-0.0044321124,
0.0077102175,
0.0342974328,
-0.0358356908,
-0.0237080399,
-0.0096986871,
0.0050249151,
-0.0194659792,
0.0278168116,
-0.0233317539,
-0.0132838627,
0.0073951799,
-0.0181203578,
-0.0475091748,
0.0111755375,
2.067486326e-34,
0.0556755923,
-0.0282677822,
0.0133974869,
-0.0168603379,
0.0803091154,
-0.0026709146,
0.0416919328,
0.0042328052,
-0.0275940727,
-0.0037369032,
-0.0285638105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15343v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15343v2 | Med-HALT: Medical Domain Hallucination Test for Large Language Models | 2023-07-28T06:43:04 | 2023-10-14T17:04:12 | Ankit Pal, Logesh Kumar Umapathi, Malaikannan Sankarasubbu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML | This research paper focuses on the challenges posed by hallucinations in
large language models (LLMs), particularly in the context of the medical
domain. Hallucination, wherein these models generate plausible yet unverified
or incorrect information, can have serious consequences in healthcare
applications. We propose a new benchmark and dataset, Med-HALT (Medical Domain
Hallucination Test), designed specifically to evaluate and reduce
hallucinations. Med-HALT provides a diverse multinational dataset derived from
medical examinations across various countries and includes multiple innovative
testing modalities. Med-HALT includes two categories of tests reasoning and
memory-based hallucination tests, designed to assess LLMs's problem-solving and
information retrieval abilities.
Our study evaluated leading LLMs, including Text Davinci, GPT-3.5, LlaMa-2,
MPT, and Falcon, revealing significant differences in their performance. The
paper provides detailed insights into the dataset, promoting transparency and
reproducibility. Through this work, we aim to contribute to the development of
safer and more reliable language models in healthcare. Our benchmark can be
found at medhalt.github.io | [
0.0062199323,
0.043436788,
-0.0108566349,
-0.011615213,
-0.043148905,
0.0345920809,
0.0123442225,
0.0522543751,
0.0205352437,
-0.0049996516,
0.0297589507,
-0.0763810575,
0.0082947537,
-0.0035065012,
0.0138495713,
-0.0339817517,
0.0487094522,
-0.0185303688,
0.0126449373,
0.0003575989,
-0.0330792181,
-0.013631735,
-0.0398334749,
0.0469228737,
0.0215282608,
-0.0276339743,
0.0215355381,
-0.0037556752,
0.0081416722,
-0.0693316981,
-0.0186582357,
0.0672183931,
-0.0334364027,
0.0611446798,
0.0000020981,
-0.0777398422,
-0.0176697075,
0.0083623175,
-0.0185190514,
-0.0089441538,
0.0281646587,
0.0043161339,
-0.0105717117,
0.034778811,
-0.0150521118,
-0.0189908948,
0.0229330268,
0.0732666701,
0.0412753485,
0.0552415103,
-0.0162721518,
0.0118815443,
0.038085971,
-0.0037643414,
0.0709761232,
-0.0212228224,
0.0441130735,
0.0322392508,
0.0302822851,
-0.0658829883,
0.0136622349,
0.0386603698,
0.0029592183,
0.060290698,
-0.0391417257,
0.0498078018,
-0.072003521,
-0.0275109913,
0.019952774,
0.0343725309,
-0.0110970708,
-0.0266551189,
0.0280929543,
0.0314602628,
-0.0079628397,
0.0223543029,
-0.0515366048,
0.0159117579,
-0.0407291092,
-0.0211360343,
0.018295994,
-0.0071482253,
0.0625752136,
-0.0098650791,
-0.0540348813,
0.0487809815,
0.0194806103,
-0.0527513698,
0.0622701868,
-0.0267155487,
-0.0079803411,
-0.0197231714,
0.0460015833,
0.0118326144,
-0.0606295429,
-0.0070989877,
-0.0012293154,
-0.0102376323,
0.1055244282,
-0.0893347487,
0.0139462519,
0.0120855179,
-0.0467152633,
0.0375580862,
-0.0384812728,
0.0267726034,
-0.0513875596,
0.0749423355,
-0.0280921068,
0.0346822217,
-0.0378539972,
-0.0171575323,
-0.0137017388,
-0.0078625614,
0.0276412498,
0.0036473146,
-0.0789671391,
-0.0373168215,
-0.0241085161,
0.0283728782,
-0.019535102,
0.0264423918,
0.0038800396,
-0.0024925915,
-0.020152295,
-0.0009851414,
-0.0253949109,
-0.0063109272,
-0.0022658349,
-0.0479276627,
0.0057039517,
0.0069408654,
-0.0171703324,
-0.0000178212,
0.0180326048,
0.0323618203,
0.0199766215,
0.005660777,
-0.0119603509,
-0.035859514,
-0.0078587048,
-0.0708295703,
0.0582129546,
-0.0597987249,
0.009937929,
0.0151453046,
-0.0027352485,
-0.0584439076,
0.0228525084,
0.0310301222,
-0.0449641533,
0.057070516,
-0.0329060294,
-0.0003355407,
0.0301501323,
0.0636735037,
-0.0212112628,
0.049107153,
0.0009366052,
-0.0046783257,
0.0008103893,
-0.0354295261,
0.0453242697,
0.0030508656,
0.00522367,
-0.0067071249,
-0.0226091407,
0.0119536035,
0.0358346589,
0.0530481301,
-0.064474307,
0.0923312381,
0.0062232972,
-0.010671136,
0.0252758022,
0.0449257679,
0.0272922739,
-0.0165678561,
-0.0131066823,
-0.0340162627,
0.0118037816,
-0.0070645176,
-0.0340343416,
-0.0049677338,
-0.02726309,
0.0084012672,
0.0179590303,
-0.0163663458,
-0.0141528109,
-0.0298693031,
-0.058330141,
0.0019843739,
-0.0016453613,
0.0036787279,
0.0464393049,
-0.0348053835,
-0.060729064,
0.0642719567,
0.0336878113,
-0.0467832126,
-0.0290626176,
-0.0562854558,
-0.0291073564,
0.0825832933,
0.0496836305,
-0.0375151522,
-0.0158872437,
-0.0355653353,
0.0401508473,
0.017749263,
0.0077171135,
0.0110886982,
-0.0017113908,
-0.0473779142,
0.0076485844,
0.0427814052,
0.0529577993,
-0.0240682475,
-0.0112903044,
0.03110037,
-0.0033911776,
-0.0377484933,
-0.0408656113,
0.0434312709,
-0.059244778,
0.0043954942,
-0.0350742154,
-0.0169894136,
0.0284587685,
-0.0010459509,
-0.0243924204,
0.0408490933,
0.0313716792,
-0.0385532752,
-0.0174007472,
0.0084173502,
-0.0325269625,
0.0139576914,
0.0243830942,
-0.0232843906,
0.0143372957,
-0.0060263113,
0.0049468004,
-0.0235743746,
-0.0209655184,
-0.0646668375,
0.0322238021,
-0.0156603567,
0.0518720187,
-0.0078395624,
0.0216507148,
-0.0238118134,
0.0563667566,
-0.0546033494,
0.0462863483,
0.0150723392,
-0.0208737254,
0.0034338692,
-0.0236858744,
-0.0453096852,
0.0309156645,
-0.0141953425,
0.0306598097,
-0.0463145785,
-0.0224796198,
-0.0583285205,
-0.0264342632,
-0.0958045498,
-0.0045202449,
-0.0112704728,
0.0033223436,
0.01587121,
-0.0200648978,
-0.0137766078,
0.0075640264,
-0.0049252361,
-0.0112286797,
0.0338989049,
0.0479279384,
-0.0133333001,
0.0045425398,
-0.0351555124,
-0.0072452878,
0.000259744,
-0.052620519,
0.0418189727,
-0.0021230145,
-0.0130275479,
-0.0202702396,
0.0415730104,
-0.043403022,
-0.0155187389,
-0.0154543929,
-0.017289646,
0.0405418277,
-0.0187397581,
0.0219624601,
0.0672780424,
0.0067639458,
0.0146171926,
0.0573900305,
-0.0238603763,
0.0039705997,
-0.0038059698,
0.0097614545,
0.008399087,
0.026235994,
-0.0826407596,
-0.0092585031,
0.0751735717,
0.0182875469,
0.0245975591,
-0.0431620516,
0.0173426736,
-0.0592536665,
-0.0049747773,
-0.0197966546,
0.0116819581,
-0.0459564663,
0.0762011409,
0.0001448734,
-0.0374230258,
0.0796967372,
-0.0259490851,
0.0433724485,
-0.0666107833,
0.0160077307,
-0.008800745,
0.0106509794,
-0.0201715194,
0.0194562878,
0.0066217571,
-0.0083124628,
0.0028763292,
0.0003702116,
-0.0240679681,
-0.0881055668,
0.0458238311,
-0.0186705105,
0.0158771519,
0.0226015709,
-0.0310376082,
-0.0542262904,
0.0029801957,
-0.0206655432,
-0.0287635978,
-0.0272273365,
0.0241867192,
-0.0885553807,
0.0295268334,
-0.0124594299,
0.0498166531,
0.0103683807,
-0.0073654191,
0.027225066,
-0.0353007689,
0.0059119621,
-0.0169314723,
0.0407702029,
-0.0433145761,
0.0391644351,
0.0745542273,
0.0565548614,
0.0397979654,
0.0072139916,
-0.0059737759,
-0.0001630724,
-0.0430315025,
-0.0179900881,
0.0223130491,
0.007957614,
-0.0521858484,
-0.0245924722,
0.1033503115,
0.0445786305,
-0.0586501807,
0.0145175429,
-0.0696861446,
0.0220098477,
0.0063172327,
-0.007355968,
-0.0726442337,
-0.0120134288,
0.0170036387,
0.0231806003,
-0.030594172,
-0.0157895349,
0.0174654294,
-0.0235237069,
0.0224698223,
0.0090005724,
-0.0412158668,
-0.0006544061,
-0.0422480628,
0.0068988316,
0.0110517722,
0.0243361313,
0.0098111201,
0.0029534616,
-0.0297614094,
-0.0133459652,
-0.0681410879,
-0.0634790584,
0.06878791,
-0.0064690346,
0.049155727,
0.071366623,
0.0204380453,
-0.0282704718,
-0.0802367404,
0.02742799,
-0.0153567381,
-0.0104805902,
-0.0069629443,
0.0848607868,
0.0446407311,
0.0263940282,
-0.0281025916,
0.0072396658,
-0.0484982915,
-0.027492689,
0.0144566549,
0.0702658221,
-0.053904172,
-0.0544018559,
-0.025883805,
0.064240016,
-0.007584448,
0.061637748,
0.011971009,
-0.0022306663,
-0.0336996168,
-0.0103272824,
0.0635388196,
-0.0103521775,
-0.0457453728,
0.0643240809,
0.0420254283,
-0.0325049311,
-0.0399389453,
-0.0131708151,
0.0359207578,
0.0260023698,
0.0101677841,
0.0437363237,
-0.0004749869,
0.0141207799,
-0.059148971,
0.0484723784,
0.0203254558,
0.0138929328,
-0.0688189343,
-0.0092992429,
0.0318932571,
0.0080339201,
-0.0178764798,
0.02962997,
-0.0497771576,
-0.0158285704,
0.0632132962,
0.0212876853,
0.0374428406,
-0.0151042556,
-0.0213978589,
-0.0122968629,
0.0273004826,
0.0097643463,
-0.0314584188,
-0.0050009056,
-0.0068859332,
-0.0204240866,
0.0086169485,
0.0006905237,
-0.0122461962,
0.0100559946,
-0.0132168699,
0.0409030244,
0.0005877501,
0.0347694606,
0.0292647984,
0.031010177,
0.0218300931,
-0.0073744897,
-0.0249652732,
0.0024318532,
0.0117118219,
-0.0360352248,
-0.0055760732,
0.0131084248,
-0.0147809396,
0.0409580469,
-0.0171324052,
-0.0067618154,
-0.0343763009,
-0.0656658188,
-0.0574732162,
-0.0251004603,
0.0203011204,
0.0045680609,
0.0265471935,
0.0724600255,
-0.0370411947,
-0.0063570482,
-0.0020060115,
-0.0065022707,
0.0762077719,
0.0000444882,
0.1066272631,
-0.0259423554,
-0.0068431636,
-0.0160073508,
0.0200893823,
-0.0419712737,
-0.0782011822,
0.0016991374,
0.0297820289,
0.0276321117,
0.0103499983,
0.0327827707,
-0.0345553569,
0.0263057221,
-0.025519561,
-0.0226160735,
0.0071432595,
0.0022642033,
0.0201809201,
0.0212434046,
-0.0083614755,
-0.0030658841,
0.0814926475,
0.0036107353,
0.0387978032,
-0.0050444007,
-0.0361083709,
-0.0457625575,
-0.0528406203,
-0.0335024297,
0.0220643431,
-0.0564158447,
-0.0262968168,
-0.0966936946,
-0.0349184312,
0.0093453759,
-0.0132264281,
-0.0080038784,
-0.0106330533,
0.007046219,
0.0739742294,
-0.0246198606,
-0.0186339803,
-0.0068098954,
0.0218403488,
0.0006570554,
-0.0206765272,
0.0159449615,
-6.329018073e-33,
0.029491825,
-0.0218730364,
0.0289058201,
-0.0628103539,
-0.0042765001,
0.006176332,
-0.0316453613,
0.0274237692,
0.0056698439,
0.0100752935,
-0.0378902629,
0.0332070738,
0.0195079129,
0.0170946941,
-0.0115294764,
-0.0432209633,
0.001666122,
0.0219295379,
-0.0329224356,
0.0246357601,
-0.0074470784,
0.0274600144,
0.0299170334,
-0.0806325078,
0.0325116441,
-0.0124405101,
0.0217277147,
0.0098317796,
-0.0355992392,
0.0511213988,
-0.0305627082,
0.030622825,
0.0305718351,
-0.0231302753,
0.0138698211,
-0.0243456662,
-0.0215212144,
-0.0043453919,
0.0192935076,
-0.003777029,
-0.0279169213,
-0.0432892404,
0.0561408512,
-0.0134371193,
-0.0213373974,
-0.0080554998,
0.0038358117,
-0.0363434255,
-0.0233827922,
0.0166805126,
-0.0218141861,
0.0249182303,
-0.0028618418,
0.009759916,
-0.0171218552,
0.0240896344,
-0.0388655588,
0.0147971762,
-0.0656692609,
0.0081240628,
0.0199283417,
-0.0074551567,
0.0400271416,
-0.0383326337,
-0.0037513878,
0.078086704,
0.0684830546,
0.0409331322,
-0.0284084398,
-0.019106904,
0.0006917595,
0.0453094803,
0.0715025365,
0.000258985,
0.0460981838,
-0.0411611833,
-0.0690811276,
0.0251539983,
-0.0720802769,
0.0338938087,
0.082945995,
-0.0284615271,
-0.1001123637,
-0.0349642001,
-0.0217748191,
0.0463663116,
-0.03942848,
-0.0304285493,
0.0506701022,
-0.0224518422,
0.0041611688,
-0.0128969476,
0.0227035042,
-0.0169056747,
0.0313583426,
-0.0213195961,
0.0198580083,
0.0096983779,
-0.0422759205,
0.0206212774,
0.0026268004,
-0.0014207509,
0.0023283977,
0.0131993042,
0.0626446679,
-0.0126827862,
-0.00262146,
-0.0562686846,
-0.0775052235,
-0.0001323089,
-0.0128459521,
-0.0052475822,
0.0180470236,
0.0017728894,
0.062095996,
0.0142310215,
0.0075417603,
-0.0007732325,
0.0246705636,
-0.0139676994,
-0.0314223319,
-0.0023825986,
-0.0354158469,
0.0120663084,
-0.0308627468,
-0.0083445022,
-0.0493765548,
0.0308742542,
0.0461343266,
-0.0722423941,
0.009912665,
-0.0062193549,
2.83e-7,
0.0465953909,
0.0956004336,
-0.0179898944,
-0.0263732299,
0.0105619198,
-0.0008465964,
-0.0163847208,
-0.029741548,
0.0309823956,
-0.0270002298,
0.0011375743,
0.0113075189,
0.0677121431,
0.0617341548,
-0.0597298294,
-0.05175611,
-0.0474727117,
0.0023028185,
-0.0598095506,
-0.0270505585,
0.0166517925,
0.0406156369,
-0.0343116373,
-0.0312332176,
0.0200112183,
-0.0466100611,
0.0305397138,
-0.0364912152,
0.0082693594,
0.0380660482,
0.0353889689,
0.0121304449,
0.0355064645,
0.0753500387,
-0.0083497725,
-0.0439990573,
0.0035993231,
0.061969351,
-0.032034345,
0.002394578,
0.0115901856,
-0.0212933868,
0.0304700285,
-0.0750085488,
0.0717109293,
-0.008264021,
-0.0456051156,
0.0230634585,
-0.0293052234,
-0.0441343375,
0.1183113456,
0.0020478053,
-0.0200917963,
0.0313758068,
0.0005063707,
0.0340971351,
-0.0091697136,
-0.0348039307,
-0.0049985694,
0.0382145494,
-0.0267205127,
-0.0459832735,
0.0113887358,
-0.0060122805,
-0.0299980585,
-0.1047682762,
0.0061729774,
2.820738744e-34,
0.0289417934,
0.0042542159,
0.030958226,
0.0189773329,
0.0460759513,
-0.0081853997,
0.0598484203,
0.021605365,
-0.0119332662,
-0.063826263,
0.0221088231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15341v1 | Teach Me How to Improve My Argumentation Skills: A Survey on Feedback in Argumentation | 2023-07-28T06:33:09 | 2023-07-28T06:33:09 | Camélia Guerraoui, Paul Reisert, Naoya Inoue, Farjana Sultana Mim, Shoichi Naito, Jungmin Choi, Irfan Robbani, Wenzhi Wang, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL | The use of argumentation in education has been shown to improve critical
thinking skills for end-users such as students, and computational models for
argumentation have been developed to assist in this process. Although these
models are useful for evaluating the quality of an argument, they oftentimes
cannot explain why a particular argument is considered poor or not, which makes
it difficult to provide constructive feedback to users to strengthen their
critical thinking skills. In this survey, we aim to explore the different
dimensions of feedback (Richness, Visualization, Interactivity, and
Personalization) provided by the current computational models for
argumentation, and the possibility of enhancing the power of explanations of
such models, ultimately helping learners improve their critical thinking
skills. | [
0.0149598401,
-0.0131916059,
-0.0185230896,
0.0232084487,
-0.0115532838,
0.0088072307,
0.0176493265,
-0.0304808896,
0.0033954259,
-0.015338135,
0.0424930342,
0.0079556201,
-0.0020188,
-0.0530557223,
-0.0076661604,
-0.1372930557,
0.0011576447,
-0.0273965411,
0.0884900987,
-0.0089322366,
0.0257971901,
-0.0291292556,
-0.051107429,
0.04699542,
-0.009925277,
-0.0619461089,
-0.0251371078,
-0.009207366,
0.0084721418,
-0.0377842635,
-0.0174433179,
0.0392281264,
-0.0203731358,
0.0153560527,
0.0000022414,
-0.0274508521,
0.0064678588,
-0.0169999953,
-0.0541784875,
0.0572297089,
0.0762445703,
0.0705695152,
0.0015947323,
0.0383132659,
-0.0008184094,
0.0105955461,
0.0369490348,
0.0621479973,
0.080708608,
0.0018096876,
0.019357698,
-0.0155680245,
0.0034678099,
0.0310979504,
-0.0164035242,
0.0522993281,
-0.0182635318,
0.0804748088,
0.0450488217,
0.0051638517,
-0.0174842272,
-0.0032756717,
0.0188682731,
-0.0611133836,
-0.0077919113,
0.0087257791,
-0.0017513431,
-0.0165186953,
-0.0000405539,
0.0146493278,
0.0258291475,
-0.0326721445,
-0.0380301401,
-0.0220556818,
0.0588275455,
0.0243253913,
-0.0922325104,
0.0296589807,
-0.012898664,
0.0130649898,
0.0153387664,
0.0170367695,
0.0054845717,
0.0377861336,
0.0765399113,
-0.0338651575,
-0.0240056328,
-0.0105437534,
0.0087468876,
0.0257042442,
0.0084281852,
-0.0213277154,
0.0066057192,
0.0543365404,
-0.0171451867,
-0.0039967299,
0.0335543454,
0.0054259403,
0.0085762003,
-0.0603421852,
0.0698613822,
0.0111448644,
0.0244017243,
0.0046351538,
0.0220271349,
-0.0245470423,
-0.0299895704,
0.0380130671,
0.0289488267,
0.0147292335,
-0.0564724989,
-0.0076486906,
-0.019938238,
0.0165307112,
0.0004182212,
0.0100204768,
0.0100716557,
-0.0202872287,
-0.0744447485,
0.0039546574,
-0.0196879283,
0.0098582339,
0.0232101548,
0.0001854922,
-0.0698056296,
0.0302546155,
-0.0621702857,
0.0097092232,
0.0243913326,
-0.0117820073,
-0.0277325753,
0.022328781,
0.0098156231,
0.0207492039,
-0.0161731336,
0.0134175029,
-0.0262758117,
0.0659488589,
-0.0233882982,
-0.0476767309,
0.0033487694,
-0.0019383879,
0.0103659956,
-0.0467359349,
-0.0461257696,
-0.0384316184,
0.0330259688,
-0.0152785489,
0.0045429631,
0.0178108942,
0.0076334355,
0.0149830086,
-0.046089597,
-0.0248402357,
0.0649080873,
0.0457076058,
-0.0201983713,
0.0172123797,
0.020886628,
0.007123895,
0.0195210986,
-0.0354838595,
0.0563944615,
-0.050768178,
-0.0064113545,
-0.0060210261,
0.0356543176,
-0.0313543379,
-0.0830151811,
0.0431508347,
-0.0638809279,
-0.0001210769,
-0.0515535884,
0.0265595652,
0.0116575016,
0.0268123131,
0.0264724866,
0.0097895302,
-0.0028957194,
-0.0082015172,
0.0392378271,
0.003612835,
0.0030683498,
0.036294952,
0.034661442,
0.0072603403,
-0.0267916657,
-0.0200877655,
-0.0041902852,
-0.0719145015,
-0.0236110296,
0.0069431812,
0.0274501294,
0.0214530695,
0.0122109493,
0.0367069058,
0.0284027401,
-0.0162761938,
0.0343196802,
-0.0438292213,
-0.015692696,
-0.037538711,
0.0758095905,
0.01622466,
-0.022337554,
-0.0121986382,
-0.0166137833,
-0.0384956338,
0.0736439675,
0.0714269876,
0.0815543681,
-0.0268424451,
-0.0580851883,
-0.0184802338,
-0.0406657793,
-0.0598733462,
0.0259377398,
0.0410779119,
-0.0119654769,
-0.0010029827,
0.0223425757,
0.0182614122,
-0.0678183511,
0.0161141343,
0.0516676009,
0.0221319403,
-0.0187383685,
0.0012755069,
0.0385453328,
0.0542827956,
0.024164401,
0.021471262,
0.0212785974,
0.0328449085,
-0.010053522,
0.0226572156,
-0.0104780411,
0.0557538271,
0.0335592851,
-0.0429948457,
0.0230477005,
-0.0339700468,
-0.0074958527,
0.0063738218,
0.0736807734,
-0.0117030637,
0.0219372511,
0.0311574545,
0.0136073902,
-0.032544449,
-0.0273040347,
-0.0103766816,
-0.0009664291,
0.0490354262,
-0.0027961622,
-0.0086831925,
0.0399108492,
0.026797289,
-0.0434759408,
-0.0033057795,
-0.0091825053,
0.000094884,
0.0026293779,
0.0351219065,
-0.0558014177,
-0.0785538927,
0.040230941,
-0.0531380028,
-0.0458826572,
0.0156449173,
0.0317279771,
-0.0134187862,
-0.0551227927,
0.0026571371,
-0.0106087662,
-0.0022215596,
-0.0310303979,
-0.0174583774,
-0.0082023777,
0.0249879342,
-0.0097113838,
0.0077095893,
-0.0269725118,
-0.0189088993,
-0.0352810472,
0.0172384139,
0.0697631761,
0.0188894086,
-0.0182751231,
-0.0475878008,
0.0171698071,
-0.009094296,
0.0124051487,
0.0092128227,
0.0885343999,
0.0324406289,
0.0151352193,
0.0378856473,
0.0392547585,
0.0629685968,
0.0397074483,
-0.0168421511,
-0.0621639043,
0.0114084631,
-0.0138455965,
0.035782896,
-0.0147690605,
-0.011833285,
-0.0127498517,
0.0409450978,
0.0027393186,
0.03946805,
-0.0406887271,
0.0877091736,
-0.025887819,
0.0169019364,
-0.0136546148,
-0.0450039618,
0.0077110673,
0.0138654159,
-0.0265967958,
0.0018711747,
0.0479164645,
-0.0362856947,
0.0586386174,
-0.0136970785,
0.0013535534,
-0.0118030328,
0.0203862321,
-0.0412121639,
-0.0024714733,
0.0238368772,
0.0093449652,
0.0399842486,
-0.0508480854,
0.0953947455,
-0.061856512,
-0.0203419793,
-0.0456262268,
-0.0867169574,
0.0244838968,
0.0030841148,
-0.0190287698,
0.0487589985,
-0.0485202968,
-0.0265959762,
0.0199074745,
0.0013361905,
-0.0108512565,
-0.0059134886,
0.0394544601,
-0.0235885587,
-0.0107061854,
-0.0237836614,
0.0576071106,
-0.0209701266,
-0.0383127742,
0.0385392345,
0.0378185138,
-0.0245157294,
0.0510255955,
0.082276918,
-0.0086058332,
-0.0245586354,
-0.0630115494,
-0.0296436939,
-0.0126905972,
-0.0261774957,
0.0141305681,
-0.0395113192,
0.0491016619,
-0.0659687743,
0.0148366708,
0.0574123748,
0.0168245193,
0.0017038912,
0.0046873977,
-0.0728161633,
-0.0196206812,
0.0232666228,
0.0091893477,
-0.0588566512,
-0.003513176,
-0.0109185483,
0.029922599,
-0.036498975,
-0.007464332,
0.0409505516,
-0.0756302699,
0.0546080433,
0.0136142345,
0.0557859242,
0.0260818694,
-0.0305595249,
-0.0265147872,
-0.001406063,
-0.0473544039,
0.0104072206,
0.0232959054,
0.0246004239,
0.0671390966,
-0.0112270368,
0.0289491154,
-0.0197866186,
0.0010465141,
0.0112698115,
-0.0437461622,
0.0316239856,
0.0020633657,
-0.0643542334,
0.0195224285,
0.0255621616,
0.0058296053,
-0.0230095405,
0.0160996914,
0.0182121508,
0.0225268081,
-0.0748249739,
0.0333541408,
0.071283713,
-0.0873124599,
0.0607739724,
0.0563616455,
-0.012330926,
-0.009184585,
-0.0630488321,
0.0317019671,
-0.0487908013,
0.0119898729,
0.0554364622,
0.0015700592,
0.0016944236,
-0.0702526718,
-0.0097850524,
-0.07557901,
-0.0541261323,
-0.0350229628,
0.0674249232,
0.051169578,
-0.0064544817,
-0.0129614417,
-0.0065139127,
0.0398411304,
-0.0285108313,
-0.0109260296,
-0.0087406505,
0.0254683122,
-0.028674081,
0.0228332914,
-0.0074625965,
-0.0063359081,
-0.0133029092,
-0.0017639266,
-0.0294448491,
-0.0274150427,
-0.03211876,
-0.0010047565,
0.0268136188,
-0.0389235467,
-0.0388695262,
0.0669404343,
0.0229208637,
0.0322993211,
0.0116210915,
-0.045043543,
0.017342966,
-0.0331662819,
0.0284393951,
-0.0593360737,
-0.0093842596,
-0.0386272445,
0.0197725147,
-0.0594017468,
0.0569151305,
0.0182445366,
0.0051050796,
0.0174491275,
-0.0341984667,
0.06155435,
0.0224217549,
0.0215688143,
0.0691594779,
0.0341655575,
-0.0629527122,
-0.0063780658,
0.016648002,
-0.0498905033,
-0.0269292314,
0.0356595367,
0.0043994095,
-0.0144376783,
-0.0614268333,
0.026326621,
-0.0226272568,
-0.0485105962,
0.0245246384,
-0.0084534334,
0.0528722592,
0.0078255171,
0.0035206114,
-0.027907066,
0.0141903069,
-0.0285867769,
0.0050648912,
-0.0010094095,
0.0484393276,
0.010468551,
0.0889151692,
-0.0129289962,
-0.0019317208,
0.0587355942,
-0.0083212033,
-0.0314228013,
-0.0621521138,
0.0006739853,
-0.0003917251,
-0.031016605,
0.0032160629,
0.0018921231,
0.0010722167,
0.000110164,
0.0263357572,
0.0189268738,
-0.0081880819,
-0.0331970267,
0.0536408611,
0.0199827924,
-0.0195808746,
-0.0478728488,
-0.0098613286,
-0.0917993486,
-0.0018589358,
-0.0115879616,
-0.0415663831,
-0.0262108874,
-0.0289356001,
-0.0379821658,
0.0457470603,
0.0152106537,
-0.0111873196,
-0.0452210568,
-0.0083668809,
-0.0390294343,
0.0368112363,
0.0279808771,
-0.0088832518,
0.0022717798,
0.0352351032,
-0.0059245448,
-0.0100546461,
-0.0236553475,
0.0477402583,
-0.0457060859,
-0.0031601009,
0.0059655895,
-6.059553992e-33,
-0.030353684,
-0.048326578,
-0.0154013457,
0.0839536935,
0.000049412,
-0.0402219258,
-0.0318969786,
0.0742293894,
-0.0112193143,
0.0574142151,
0.0280569494,
-0.0090446668,
-0.0151701616,
0.0269168951,
0.0072094058,
0.0087014548,
0.0357419401,
0.0398713537,
-0.0162865333,
0.0129934791,
-0.0035610623,
-0.053095486,
-0.0043892851,
-0.0752749816,
0.0491524301,
0.0000491198,
-0.0090755736,
-0.0109218638,
-0.0511072315,
0.0622288585,
0.0167297591,
0.0593755133,
-0.0009123228,
-0.0455788635,
0.0066705132,
0.0073789288,
-0.0441799276,
-0.0354181528,
0.0303125475,
-0.041109886,
-0.0409160331,
-0.0583423227,
0.0143375704,
0.040488936,
-0.0236776471,
-0.0431301855,
0.0124182487,
-0.0312506929,
0.0096986946,
0.0289682373,
-0.0501737557,
0.0228709895,
-0.0581684746,
-0.0053403485,
-0.0071698371,
0.0600288324,
-0.0017623578,
0.017128149,
-0.0511092469,
0.075853847,
0.0366817191,
-0.0142886294,
0.0529190041,
-0.0323423035,
0.0196703617,
0.013318195,
-0.0041033179,
0.0021350388,
-0.06482324,
0.0268393662,
-0.0196172111,
0.0452746712,
0.1120309755,
0.0665723383,
-0.0006389113,
-0.034611322,
-0.0394259617,
-0.0074508111,
0.0140840635,
0.0744964927,
0.0149094136,
-0.009274859,
-0.0274281204,
-0.000459045,
-0.0641295537,
-0.1041067839,
-0.0034409242,
-0.042201858,
-0.0128547763,
-0.0106680775,
-0.0354241952,
-0.0007160389,
-0.078942135,
0.0171506479,
0.011090599,
-0.0237500239,
0.0218657143,
0.0330650024,
-0.0238619056,
-0.0609141812,
-0.0191859156,
-0.0112350946,
-0.0157468244,
-0.0060327672,
0.0458306707,
-0.0160866007,
0.0214395858,
-0.0441354588,
-0.0066801105,
-0.0312478784,
-0.0293132626,
0.0162969474,
-0.0071799066,
0.0095787467,
-0.0000951918,
0.0443511866,
-0.0182393864,
0.0283634681,
-0.0169243552,
0.0298901536,
-0.0040437682,
-0.0495639592,
-0.0202445369,
-0.0396420211,
0.0077823568,
-0.0254427306,
0.0134004308,
0.0226084888,
0.0249350239,
-0.0750996098,
-0.0041034124,
-0.0117910793,
2.638e-7,
0.0369503796,
0.0531091988,
0.0252375025,
-0.0616016611,
0.0115685463,
0.025983233,
-0.0113295345,
-0.0454176739,
0.0549622811,
-0.0127203204,
-0.0512206219,
0.013658884,
0.0352868363,
0.0322250836,
-0.0405468754,
-0.1093361676,
-0.0387221165,
-0.0231357105,
-0.0128600392,
0.0475694016,
0.0671822727,
-0.0290331356,
0.0340947472,
0.0049874107,
-0.0286973473,
0.0231818147,
0.042196136,
-0.0385530442,
0.022470817,
-0.0147121642,
0.0196101628,
-0.0462847948,
0.0532634184,
0.0114568891,
-0.0215341672,
-0.0374245346,
-0.0445954949,
0.0171813667,
0.0060817935,
0.0004716626,
-0.0226390567,
0.012056957,
0.0495515391,
-0.0445984714,
0.0089426367,
-0.0703299418,
-0.03654195,
-0.0070305308,
-0.0385118872,
-0.0132770156,
0.0311180837,
-0.0113850394,
-0.0237648897,
-0.0393693931,
-0.0124121662,
-0.0034963698,
0.010334543,
-0.008841252,
-0.0176936444,
-0.0049142013,
-0.0037939439,
-0.0123885199,
-0.0308317784,
-0.0567717403,
0.0136666223,
0.0235835984,
-0.0050128102,
1.626932395e-34,
0.0283196587,
-0.002400927,
0.0937784687,
-0.0254109781,
0.0482123829,
0.0505449921,
0.0627035797,
-0.0172326434,
0.052464325,
0.0048343381,
-0.0280006528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15337v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15337v3 | Skeleton-of-Thought: Prompting LLMs for Efficient Parallel Generation | 2023-07-28T06:31:34 | 2024-03-02T02:45:33 | Xuefei Ning, Zinan Lin, Zixuan Zhou, Zifu Wang, Huazhong Yang, Yu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This work aims at decreasing the end-to-end generation latency of large
language models (LLMs). One of the major causes of the high generation latency
is the sequential decoding approach adopted by almost all state-of-the-art
LLMs. In this work, motivated by the thinking and writing process of humans, we
propose Skeleton-of-Thought (SoT), which first guides LLMs to generate the
skeleton of the answer, and then conducts parallel API calls or batched
decoding to complete the contents of each skeleton point in parallel. Not only
does SoT provide considerable speed-ups across 12 LLMs, but it can also
potentially improve the answer quality on several question categories. SoT is
an initial attempt at data-centric optimization for inference efficiency, and
showcases the potential of eliciting high-quality answers by explicitly
planning the answer structure in language. | [
0.0581902452,
0.07373669,
-0.0163431615,
0.0392391421,
-0.0322076268,
0.006311554,
-0.018142065,
-0.0080581987,
0.0001550443,
-0.034912385,
0.0170922522,
-0.0436238684,
0.0055669397,
-0.01332111,
0.0137040373,
-0.023558585,
0.0224636775,
-0.0475304648,
0.0096118934,
-0.0359707028,
-0.01307349,
0.0220619664,
-0.0115940748,
0.0321593322,
0.0066460734,
-0.0461818613,
-0.0366714224,
0.0074514388,
-0.0121330377,
-0.0440301262,
0.0020368334,
0.0463490039,
-0.0191166066,
0.046898488,
0.0000021854,
-0.0367707238,
0.0061041722,
0.0137516223,
-0.0268695466,
0.0318355933,
0.0115003986,
0.0132269748,
0.0141636496,
0.0337776244,
-0.0497530326,
-0.0008192419,
0.0483330674,
-0.015115208,
0.0539913513,
0.0513375588,
0.0000744282,
-0.0214139987,
0.0334221423,
-0.0013199748,
-0.0155102285,
-0.0037877988,
-0.0134610217,
0.0279477723,
0.0403012782,
0.0271619335,
-0.0267534889,
0.0540728308,
0.0441189297,
-0.0164180901,
-0.0036660959,
0.035401538,
-0.0062404922,
-0.0261077229,
-0.0201181751,
0.0624954551,
0.0057974569,
-0.0291996971,
-0.0008775396,
-0.0111048743,
0.0012339776,
-0.0015119532,
-0.0549773239,
0.0647591054,
-0.0245076977,
0.0111244861,
0.0525314435,
-0.019196,
0.0201275852,
0.0029047697,
-0.0119669493,
0.0710451677,
0.0245260783,
-0.0117294211,
-0.0280728657,
0.0121094398,
-0.0101773497,
-0.0842094421,
-0.0032112531,
0.0620044097,
-0.0465325266,
0.0094854608,
-0.0438960493,
-0.0768835619,
0.036610648,
-0.0340392329,
0.0616161041,
0.0582715832,
0.0154728321,
0.005062426,
-0.0192434061,
0.0126657905,
-0.038725324,
-0.0099988664,
-0.0713595077,
-0.0098729385,
-0.0277200732,
-0.0221473575,
-0.0366354808,
0.0629755333,
-0.0467937589,
-0.0226139966,
-0.0097008422,
0.0650373176,
0.0184444971,
-0.0330292396,
0.0039699287,
0.0304285474,
-0.0097748581,
-0.0230539422,
-0.0186054092,
0.0423341729,
-0.0402860753,
0.0010968071,
0.0192865878,
-0.0419029891,
-0.0043040444,
0.0152441291,
0.0095905904,
0.0050848126,
0.0127534606,
0.0722024143,
-0.0275148414,
0.0204203818,
-0.0225773919,
-0.0712255687,
-0.0087302588,
-0.0588753819,
-0.0000309438,
-0.1053379402,
0.0268330649,
0.0476202667,
-0.0220271144,
0.018577626,
0.0186830927,
0.0355249196,
-0.0150753576,
0.0257835183,
-0.0586974248,
0.0436429903,
0.0439769626,
0.0131036555,
0.0176508911,
0.0886191353,
0.0317906514,
0.0228294395,
0.0299972259,
0.0089596519,
-0.0204521902,
0.0455589667,
0.0277826823,
0.0109795164,
0.0041141552,
0.0242826138,
0.0099954233,
0.0521343574,
0.0266895406,
0.0473013408,
-0.0419899449,
-0.001924071,
0.059907224,
0.0707058907,
-0.0111034466,
0.0166924186,
0.0517770909,
-0.0022911241,
-0.0016623577,
0.0147075718,
-0.0122857913,
0.0564564951,
0.0018429909,
0.0230732299,
0.0540938973,
0.0391332507,
-0.0132793197,
-0.0054308982,
-0.0118782492,
0.0100470269,
-0.0399012193,
0.0385995284,
-0.0066815224,
0.0223479718,
-0.0454881489,
0.0650039911,
0.0110907219,
-0.0656456128,
-0.0119384462,
-0.0446781889,
0.0420018323,
0.0553912111,
0.0466011576,
0.0462340713,
-0.0457101315,
0.0096568624,
0.0384758301,
0.0783023685,
0.0248002969,
-0.0231444091,
-0.0045891441,
-0.0278899055,
-0.0050288369,
-0.0045868778,
-0.0017385144,
0.006546733,
0.0345494784,
-0.009283226,
0.0190394074,
-0.0094643999,
-0.0128589161,
0.0197937526,
-0.0306841973,
0.0115371328,
0.0139761241,
-0.0052508358,
0.016611496,
0.0012868043,
-0.0079280082,
0.0390602089,
0.0129317883,
-0.0640552416,
-0.0168896224,
-0.000084407,
-0.0542850941,
-0.0519778356,
0.0343357883,
-0.0298899096,
-0.0001326882,
0.0190518554,
-0.0069573219,
-0.0378640518,
0.0000165529,
-0.0648220703,
0.047711812,
-0.0187269058,
0.0178676359,
0.0118787969,
-0.0157053582,
-0.0327576026,
0.0506735668,
-0.0294564795,
0.0374970064,
0.0539679602,
0.0332734734,
0.0251919106,
-0.0442204252,
0.0193491001,
0.0369949713,
-0.0130131599,
0.0089175608,
0.0269374736,
0.0213410668,
-0.0321770683,
-0.0148143182,
-0.1078071371,
-0.0050548259,
-0.011794338,
0.0178190824,
0.0382175148,
0.0286789741,
0.0125677194,
0.0044909031,
-0.0662174821,
0.0633341521,
0.0398817174,
0.0430426896,
0.0112329591,
-0.0148032801,
-0.0324373879,
-0.0056932871,
-0.0091302404,
-0.0027313055,
0.0407857113,
0.0109615745,
-0.0131356409,
-0.078719154,
0.015358788,
-0.0271081012,
0.0055805119,
0.0195871647,
-0.0553269237,
0.0325538144,
-0.0307944845,
0.0615761951,
0.0219660606,
0.0169765074,
-0.0305635147,
0.0494785085,
-0.0118495896,
-0.0557909831,
0.0081400331,
-0.0353145972,
-0.0063446201,
-0.0241153166,
-0.0643957108,
0.0195993688,
0.0884388536,
0.0188260041,
-0.0267714988,
-0.0561714396,
0.0125937639,
-0.0072531011,
-0.0268290006,
-0.0200199224,
-0.0261809714,
-0.022338938,
0.070123665,
-0.0201325249,
-0.0602497868,
0.0516629927,
-0.0290065389,
0.007955811,
-0.0027558196,
0.0005388605,
-0.037008781,
0.091102317,
0.0140872793,
0.0268593654,
-0.0469021313,
-0.0098739536,
-0.0674001202,
0.0335716717,
0.014302385,
-0.0427150764,
0.0284825433,
-0.0392246284,
0.0021028609,
-0.0403962508,
-0.0486870371,
-0.0324379019,
0.0023835762,
-0.0478540808,
0.0037526183,
0.0450680852,
-0.0336516127,
0.0186742898,
-0.0305209924,
-0.0122980122,
0.0168634057,
-0.0520770438,
-0.0124711599,
-0.0054144757,
0.0574068055,
0.0727543533,
0.0136907613,
0.0263981018,
-0.0436868593,
0.043507874,
0.089369528,
0.0183651298,
0.019334916,
-0.0268796049,
-0.0198440775,
0.0524139367,
0.0047177859,
-0.030745022,
0.0272350479,
0.0414578319,
-0.0476899669,
-0.0482890829,
0.1003050357,
0.0376579501,
-0.0378590748,
0.0163983759,
-0.0387368724,
0.0585323088,
0.0164108649,
0.047522001,
-0.0967085063,
-0.037319988,
0.0073202262,
0.0226537548,
-0.0190024208,
-0.0247636996,
-0.0369759016,
-0.1262572408,
0.0307480898,
-0.0000157645,
-0.0214709863,
-0.0036160396,
-0.014200734,
-0.0518032946,
0.0547894239,
-0.0211105365,
0.0709815025,
0.0080044623,
0.0335743651,
0.0052448451,
-0.0183738172,
0.0268078074,
0.0089814011,
-0.0048960666,
0.0460168198,
0.0366933234,
0.0138712842,
0.0324968211,
-0.0495651215,
0.0376658477,
-0.0290365294,
-0.0153242908,
-0.0327568464,
0.0078602443,
0.0157925133,
-0.0023627141,
-0.0356466547,
0.0232912507,
-0.0498688146,
-0.0163976252,
0.0085544437,
0.0845900401,
-0.0390871838,
-0.00472771,
-0.0462807305,
0.0059375879,
-0.0049490589,
0.062010441,
0.0385853127,
-0.0726272017,
-0.0460773967,
-0.0299952514,
-0.0257705972,
-0.0855410993,
-0.0043767267,
0.0028511637,
0.0193045232,
0.0187551919,
-0.0687651187,
-0.0174070019,
0.0149345621,
0.0279470403,
0.0126404045,
0.0152808335,
-0.0289820358,
-0.0113649638,
-0.063173458,
-0.0262934919,
-0.0135744568,
0.0042792908,
-0.0549646541,
-0.0149765424,
0.0106674535,
-0.0359769315,
0.0098944595,
0.0536910035,
-0.1203715056,
-0.0695632249,
-0.0146431178,
0.0418580361,
0.0187987406,
0.0255382508,
0.0240472779,
-0.0631004125,
0.0288112853,
0.0521346107,
-0.068722412,
0.0307770371,
-0.0099581648,
0.0490663424,
0.0095745558,
0.0433282517,
-0.0410209857,
-0.0060216384,
0.0034016669,
0.0564960055,
0.002417925,
-0.0563833974,
0.0099141011,
0.0509570912,
-0.0496993326,
-0.0304783862,
0.0007145874,
-0.0071187522,
0.0430825166,
-0.0396261215,
-0.0113966092,
-0.0577582791,
0.0098702861,
0.0052387165,
-0.0442980677,
0.0188755263,
-0.0116509907,
0.0131936949,
0.0294530038,
0.0034322678,
0.005960559,
-0.0105452193,
-0.0057766871,
0.0534932949,
-0.0107492823,
-0.027672112,
0.0124286748,
-0.0172405615,
0.0348050073,
-0.0239758268,
0.0458487757,
0.0238010325,
-0.0103491861,
0.0054483996,
-0.0035153527,
-0.0694263056,
-0.1127863824,
-0.0114706615,
-0.0194556043,
0.0392122306,
0.0414243937,
0.0569832809,
-0.027606165,
-0.0075249327,
-0.0069860574,
0.0459820032,
0.0128706293,
-0.0365209766,
0.035984803,
0.020156268,
-0.0149818454,
-0.0326892547,
0.0898764133,
0.0008989758,
0.0173399225,
0.0239094421,
-0.0114825908,
-0.0364313275,
-0.0388724618,
-0.0343654267,
0.0230858959,
-0.0064731538,
0.0167333242,
-0.0359231792,
-0.0574011095,
-0.0052180062,
0.0238312799,
-0.0094824387,
-0.0082484223,
0.0407366194,
0.0370823778,
0.0298777465,
-0.0502981693,
-0.0532481,
0.0564031787,
-0.0581423901,
-0.0346433446,
-0.0248601194,
-6.679489509e-33,
-0.0173317064,
-0.0826504678,
0.0463884287,
0.0007386259,
-0.0282595903,
0.000304266,
-0.0407816097,
0.0276538078,
0.0153452205,
0.0123188868,
-0.0092404457,
0.0173159875,
-0.0104480078,
0.0452608615,
0.0207614042,
0.0062885741,
0.0230434369,
-0.0348748304,
-0.0132892625,
0.0187641773,
0.0223988593,
0.0182743277,
0.0061962651,
-0.0048612691,
-0.0097319288,
-0.0221925415,
0.0203895234,
0.0152169159,
-0.0150665091,
0.0337217264,
-0.0344444476,
0.054338716,
0.0265708454,
-0.0279418826,
-0.0277960002,
0.0082040532,
-0.0518163219,
-0.0353926755,
0.0349614173,
0.0067907167,
-0.0809570178,
-0.0516255908,
0.0145849921,
-0.0006620922,
0.0008705938,
-0.042755872,
-0.0001574343,
-0.0269231573,
-0.025746977,
-0.0506395772,
-0.0512028895,
0.0052554742,
-0.007466821,
-0.0063380846,
0.0231023654,
0.0414047837,
-0.0183163173,
0.0075580953,
-0.0017019726,
0.0186490919,
0.0394353122,
0.0576721504,
0.0482232235,
0.013998175,
0.0212240666,
0.0484290868,
0.0218649395,
-0.0112516321,
-0.0264627412,
0.0169637892,
-0.0068926942,
0.0376759693,
0.0495646745,
0.0474751852,
0.0119833499,
0.0131026004,
-0.0758356228,
0.0217509642,
0.0161640383,
-0.0057945182,
0.0451076254,
-0.018335022,
0.0233914834,
-0.02992112,
-0.0475110374,
0.0036006321,
-0.0274701212,
0.0032506608,
0.0325351432,
0.0001740622,
-0.0181143656,
-0.04408985,
0.0546099357,
-0.0382434949,
0.0017006241,
0.0337210968,
-0.0437283553,
0.0268582385,
-0.003707286,
0.0209019799,
-0.0506570935,
0.018379638,
-0.0104667777,
0.0048387488,
0.0076504028,
0.0302857216,
-0.0062277531,
-0.0011569979,
-0.0768780559,
-0.0015666591,
-0.0593035966,
0.0396996252,
0.0079355789,
-0.0047311652,
0.0477843545,
-0.0242156554,
-0.0094390819,
0.0398422852,
-0.008886233,
0.0105025778,
-0.0236471165,
0.0025099807,
0.0014262712,
0.0239173155,
-0.0377516635,
0.0136650363,
-0.0296948105,
0.0282826275,
0.0204889942,
-0.0693606585,
-0.0347984806,
0.016968498,
2.794e-7,
0.0449594855,
0.0349087268,
0.0183884203,
0.0644995123,
0.0483977459,
0.0090270219,
0.0359794199,
0.0045899819,
0.0208572783,
-0.0292406715,
-0.0210929476,
0.0171548855,
0.0495128408,
0.037871372,
-0.1078325212,
0.036769852,
-0.0588527285,
0.0346120745,
-0.0446389243,
-0.0302665383,
0.0295479912,
0.0357512832,
-0.0259180535,
-0.0415674672,
-0.0001950799,
0.0269032493,
0.0678969994,
-0.0141216544,
0.0010899287,
0.0186884459,
-0.0091779754,
-0.0043563056,
0.0034442882,
0.0230715442,
-0.0131813008,
-0.0278591979,
-0.0184798408,
0.0355119891,
0.0233552083,
-0.0293438639,
0.0243748538,
-0.0478054248,
0.012894365,
-0.0503769331,
0.0671695992,
-0.0460899062,
-0.0526347011,
-0.0628318489,
0.001913024,
-0.0250784121,
-0.0213092882,
-0.0338045619,
0.0263427347,
0.0155722853,
0.0098074088,
-0.0179816186,
0.0091158357,
-0.0446851924,
-0.0537089072,
0.0029850199,
-0.0410965085,
-0.0769301653,
-0.0566588193,
0.0170550365,
0.0064247642,
-0.0765748024,
-0.0021929445,
2.921516262e-34,
0.0282489303,
-0.0108968811,
0.0415972844,
0.0840614215,
0.0175203867,
-0.0219673086,
0.0435829051,
-0.0011859873,
0.032003019,
-0.0929667577,
-0.0575881973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15335v1 | BARTPhoBEiT: Pre-trained Sequence-to-Sequence and Image Transformers Models for Vietnamese Visual Question Answering | 2023-07-28T06:23:32 | 2023-07-28T06:23:32 | Khiem Vinh Tran, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual Question Answering (VQA) is an intricate and demanding task that
integrates natural language processing (NLP) and computer vision (CV),
capturing the interest of researchers. The English language, renowned for its
wealth of resources, has witnessed notable advancements in both datasets and
models designed for VQA. However, there is a lack of models that target
specific countries such as Vietnam. To address this limitation, we introduce a
transformer-based Vietnamese model named BARTPhoBEiT. This model includes
pre-trained Sequence-to-Sequence and bidirectional encoder representation from
Image Transformers in Vietnamese and evaluates Vietnamese VQA datasets.
Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed model outperforms the strong
baseline and improves the state-of-the-art in six metrics: Accuracy, Precision,
Recall, F1-score, WUPS 0.0, and WUPS 0.9. | [
0.0317599066,
0.0617556125,
-0.0076913326,
0.0389043204,
-0.0022131372,
0.0016964064,
-0.011865438,
0.0098988805,
0.0204224307,
-0.0596715324,
-0.0302088279,
-0.0746004656,
-0.0010219614,
0.0120997187,
0.0028214927,
-0.0847110748,
0.0348694883,
-0.0192532651,
-0.0445085876,
-0.0158575028,
0.0152939996,
-0.0110939061,
0.0009914911,
0.0381474234,
0.0010391698,
-0.0096766204,
-0.017491065,
0.0210371707,
0.0111018494,
-0.0325869992,
0.0142584862,
0.0599766336,
0.0042698607,
-0.0121683665,
0.0000020462,
0.0011197198,
0.011843957,
-0.0223067217,
0.0084736273,
0.0166732073,
0.0059478236,
-0.0422297902,
0.0328015201,
0.0282475147,
-0.0424535014,
-0.0581864938,
0.0543661714,
0.0432331376,
0.0987493247,
0.0605735928,
-0.0209624078,
-0.0307394527,
0.0173072238,
-0.0247622579,
0.0167149138,
-0.0165648349,
-0.00251554,
0.0073526483,
0.001151517,
-0.0360017046,
-0.0598646104,
0.041783575,
0.0477712713,
0.0087762605,
-0.0108328685,
-0.0031628031,
-0.0346871503,
-0.0260503292,
-0.0191721842,
0.0746401027,
-0.0281423554,
-0.000615072,
-0.0503921844,
0.0104258154,
-0.0097358888,
0.0106056239,
-0.0422141366,
0.034595117,
-0.0022433763,
0.0025306847,
-0.0186296962,
0.0262491237,
-0.0220323857,
0.0087348027,
-0.0033512756,
-0.0398169234,
0.0040336759,
0.0076653878,
-0.0452587754,
0.0209305361,
-0.0452960208,
-0.038073685,
0.0093681384,
0.0697668791,
0.0102264658,
-0.0140939411,
-0.0066583818,
-0.0353916362,
-0.0086036287,
-0.0477428287,
0.0322253294,
0.0424040742,
-0.0702012554,
0.0204460919,
-0.0331272036,
0.1187405139,
-0.0226893928,
0.0626059324,
-0.068940565,
-0.0321406946,
-0.0080044307,
-0.0232322272,
-0.0579125583,
0.0216771439,
-0.0460109562,
-0.045867838,
-0.0225046854,
-0.0017854732,
-0.0065808673,
-0.0477815866,
0.0519069582,
0.046060767,
-0.0368884504,
0.0037534242,
-0.0227221344,
0.0801962018,
0.0044006594,
0.0194527954,
0.0082550375,
-0.0274372548,
0.0016990792,
0.0350247547,
0.0045501273,
-0.0188204329,
0.0149416327,
0.0623381585,
-0.0517569594,
-0.0288270079,
-0.002781187,
0.0334647112,
-0.0067994297,
-0.033349216,
0.052032195,
-0.053810399,
0.0265551116,
0.0216292255,
0.0240521207,
-0.0039340784,
0.0063724923,
0.0117076449,
0.0015966994,
0.0835159943,
0.0024568904,
-0.0034688099,
0.0231562909,
0.0335722864,
0.0236361939,
0.0577571765,
0.0126201576,
0.0433069393,
0.0444716774,
-0.0297607724,
0.0284236018,
0.029347619,
-0.0294554234,
0.0012090175,
0.0083682621,
0.0355027169,
-0.0072625745,
0.002456133,
0.0393891111,
0.0490927137,
-0.018541608,
-0.0388684459,
0.0443753228,
0.0135865416,
0.0315824188,
0.008376413,
0.0347047336,
0.0162812173,
0.0279397909,
-0.0150359692,
-0.0341220684,
0.0673344284,
-0.0218198616,
0.0167885087,
-0.0117960237,
0.0395714454,
-0.0640359819,
-0.0501576513,
0.0104579469,
-0.0177845582,
0.0028457539,
0.0318788849,
0.024626838,
0.0394778065,
-0.0610588007,
0.0431133993,
-0.0129837384,
-0.0209942069,
0.0145845469,
-0.0313491412,
0.0044713444,
0.0291112028,
0.0200750344,
0.0311238766,
-0.0041695666,
0.0078073279,
0.0101713417,
0.0388274677,
-0.0119689927,
-0.0030350552,
0.0240510982,
-0.0364805907,
-0.02847993,
0.0027024783,
-0.0114471214,
0.0325889736,
0.0346607566,
0.0211319271,
0.018517565,
-0.0154230464,
0.000232164,
0.0356958807,
0.0407062508,
-0.0108370753,
-0.0059092627,
0.0166441556,
0.0088679912,
-0.0035676297,
-0.0013068565,
-0.0010164287,
0.0469047017,
-0.0492389128,
0.0028706559,
0.0004058428,
-0.0470786914,
-0.0692771152,
0.0364525355,
-0.0726233795,
0.0212574769,
0.0884493664,
-0.0417894013,
-0.0337606035,
-0.0386639759,
-0.0203610007,
-0.0263550468,
-0.0911703482,
0.0105313351,
0.0208816305,
0.0520349629,
-0.0106009999,
0.0348836109,
-0.0458748564,
0.0118766353,
0.0170966182,
0.0076250415,
0.0211331509,
-0.032759469,
-0.027343845,
0.029053323,
0.0111909043,
0.0280952137,
0.0010616266,
0.037809249,
-0.0043450077,
-0.0191300996,
-0.0804437622,
-0.0001805657,
-0.0315593779,
-0.0197094511,
0.0144757796,
-0.0126154944,
-0.0067494656,
-0.0494142808,
-0.0443057008,
0.0255974606,
0.0523165092,
0.0197572652,
0.0106702857,
0.0073245713,
0.0342392288,
-0.0229318906,
-0.0314386338,
0.059126094,
0.0538891479,
-0.0203677043,
-0.0422027931,
-0.0345141217,
-0.0116641531,
-0.0047938782,
-0.007763661,
0.0016617209,
-0.0774419904,
-0.0311556011,
-0.0019881334,
0.0177879371,
0.0475162752,
0.0421086699,
0.0217620824,
-0.0163873266,
-0.0096752504,
-0.0039428747,
-0.0222670026,
-0.027670728,
-0.049221132,
-0.0182706285,
-0.0310896151,
-0.0395602174,
0.0464569591,
-0.0400288962,
0.01405528,
-0.0564048812,
-0.0267077629,
0.007316676,
0.0030456712,
-0.0407309942,
-0.0023956902,
-0.0044354177,
0.0319079086,
-0.0386278629,
-0.0417203121,
0.0392005257,
-0.0243348237,
-0.0183631033,
-0.0252271406,
0.0263117086,
-0.0364574492,
0.0702317357,
0.0526379272,
0.0102723464,
-0.0087134019,
-0.0279106684,
-0.0567454733,
0.01264189,
-0.0122341178,
-0.0551856197,
0.0599244758,
-0.0051097544,
0.0026659078,
-0.0466364548,
-0.0146947959,
-0.0685967281,
0.0055774692,
-0.0286166538,
0.0234086011,
-0.0129064657,
0.0073850825,
-0.0235873032,
0.0786902457,
-0.0080139674,
0.0279713869,
-0.0018473314,
0.0185822528,
-0.0204996802,
0.0958147347,
0.0630575493,
0.0386204198,
0.0071499245,
-0.0320224017,
0.0405466706,
0.0565421581,
0.0216396451,
0.0013328247,
-0.0296089109,
0.0197699182,
0.0268303454,
0.0059510125,
-0.002469592,
0.024887044,
0.0398311988,
-0.0495625548,
-0.0043261051,
0.0806457847,
0.0082294075,
-0.0456692018,
-0.017299246,
0.0160959587,
0.0100471936,
0.0413777046,
0.0452106334,
-0.0795097128,
-0.046907872,
-0.0306660775,
-0.0227878299,
0.0434163399,
0.0140760532,
0.0005601487,
-0.1160538197,
0.0340764895,
-0.0099619729,
-0.0222998988,
-0.0237404108,
-0.005810196,
-0.0405431762,
-0.0125162508,
0.0201265346,
-0.014436909,
-0.0193684101,
-0.0067779259,
0.0193388555,
-0.0004947003,
-0.0063655199,
0.0386933945,
-0.0307413284,
-0.0253440514,
0.0504920632,
-0.0201089811,
-0.0087401029,
-0.0467359908,
0.0059943427,
-0.0626283139,
0.0113844117,
0.0426321328,
0.0538062304,
-0.030428553,
-0.0278175566,
-0.0005033202,
0.0004012124,
-0.0396798104,
-0.0044495105,
-0.0086856838,
0.0453999043,
-0.0032242001,
-0.00641183,
-0.024281336,
0.0207503606,
-0.0096384101,
0.03214477,
0.0204264205,
-0.0531487986,
-0.0314119272,
-0.0043449514,
0.0076409895,
-0.0488302559,
-0.0660601556,
0.0328794532,
0.0201000385,
-0.0383198895,
-0.0994470268,
-0.0372173302,
0.0193415452,
0.0525241196,
-0.034712512,
-0.0424056016,
0.009027129,
0.0315049104,
-0.0720840842,
0.0754339993,
-0.0158604104,
0.0259667225,
-0.0632115006,
-0.0081397947,
0.0126483236,
-0.046026092,
0.0061473162,
-0.0175317191,
-0.0647387579,
-0.0024627279,
0.0040252032,
0.0976948813,
0.0115424413,
0.0292605702,
0.0144435717,
-0.0002872953,
-0.0120929806,
0.0648022294,
-0.0036511982,
-0.0024620774,
0.0089643719,
-0.0532476753,
-0.0260825288,
0.0202577822,
-0.0177932903,
0.0231283754,
0.0144941807,
0.0465392172,
-0.0083295302,
-0.0385491922,
0.0358698741,
0.0075122789,
0.0534492657,
-0.0280331299,
0.018565841,
-0.0106000053,
0.0179645605,
0.0070948126,
0.0131849861,
-0.0533361584,
-0.0102916416,
0.0170683283,
0.0017026144,
0.0111144269,
0.0104895076,
-0.0097791608,
-0.0174045004,
0.0126261916,
0.01149882,
0.0224105269,
0.0112217674,
-0.0138733732,
0.0213663988,
-0.0048735482,
-0.0251961313,
0.0194371566,
0.0518692844,
0.0062324377,
0.1140806824,
0.0103594111,
0.0162181426,
-0.0090230498,
0.0388746522,
-0.021524271,
-0.0498831794,
-0.071592696,
0.0139873521,
0.0719631389,
-0.0326681919,
0.0088224914,
0.0081766043,
-0.0055172569,
-0.0317658037,
0.0164057147,
-0.0122262426,
-0.054813385,
0.0644119605,
0.0067456034,
0.00854408,
0.0266288817,
0.0782091767,
-0.014494787,
0.0268740822,
0.0230910145,
0.002104335,
-0.0230481811,
-0.0512127616,
0.043042779,
-0.0265492089,
-0.0315217189,
0.0306829158,
-0.00858087,
-0.0705830455,
-0.000964781,
0.0076980344,
-0.0039871847,
0.0292514767,
0.0391490608,
0.0318348333,
0.0336141735,
-0.0224219486,
-0.040820878,
0.0001329558,
-0.0608691908,
0.0282468908,
0.0311353728,
-6.343790363e-33,
-0.064681381,
-0.0210412126,
0.0191435348,
-0.0401322432,
-0.0148561988,
-0.0031750766,
-0.0084691988,
0.0231956989,
-0.048843123,
-0.02565163,
-0.0090634301,
-0.0170201436,
0.0204379093,
0.0868245214,
-0.0096655646,
-0.0387509689,
0.0168688148,
0.0233877599,
-0.0090436665,
-0.0179615095,
-0.0194373522,
0.0241334233,
0.0515333787,
-0.0044064908,
-0.0422272719,
-0.0149733461,
-0.0049298783,
-0.0107695209,
0.0251344144,
0.0655075163,
-0.0359077603,
0.0526212938,
0.0215581488,
-0.0164592657,
-0.02883734,
-0.0300254952,
-0.0968664736,
-0.0023956876,
-0.0097643593,
0.0809193179,
-0.0757652819,
0.0024512522,
0.0061755953,
-0.015617813,
0.0260876305,
-0.0412718058,
0.0303148758,
-0.0510684289,
-0.008107041,
0.0066523524,
-0.0258341525,
-0.011201934,
-0.0065139206,
-0.0405477025,
-0.0054362919,
0.0840011686,
-0.016114654,
-0.0029146178,
-0.0866571292,
-0.012359729,
0.0336450301,
0.0305122156,
0.0586049631,
0.0549890399,
0.0161765795,
0.0020306972,
0.0350425914,
-0.0711166188,
-0.0033765642,
0.0026163752,
0.0076863449,
0.0176209006,
0.0912905559,
0.0339531004,
0.0803259164,
-0.0061995108,
-0.0403602384,
0.0252142269,
-0.0784855932,
0.0494966879,
-0.0046679662,
0.000840207,
0.0262666177,
-0.0116295898,
-0.0130997635,
-0.0161125865,
-0.0139527889,
-0.0614407696,
0.0447722189,
0.0389562286,
-0.0065363301,
0.0379010551,
0.0911936313,
-0.0855198428,
0.038395185,
-0.0057107857,
-0.0287459828,
0.0256561153,
-0.0142386034,
0.0578933321,
-0.0402407162,
0.0080390796,
0.037255004,
-0.0110437404,
-0.0426248908,
0.017609423,
0.0409268849,
0.0173836257,
-0.0515870973,
0.0017442637,
-0.0176912639,
0.0276383851,
-0.0335781313,
0.0631600246,
-0.0060514947,
0.0200012159,
-0.0382602103,
0.0541542731,
-0.0434418581,
-0.0160778668,
-0.0348223448,
-0.0311391093,
0.0301269125,
0.044202663,
-0.0213941988,
0.0561211035,
-0.0862002224,
0.038177982,
-0.0363482907,
-0.0548241995,
-0.0046775686,
0.0567347296,
2.627e-7,
0.0827869847,
-0.0150563251,
0.051570259,
0.014608603,
-0.0131070744,
0.0069624768,
-0.0165889971,
-0.0089086005,
0.0297371242,
-0.0103162294,
0.0157693941,
0.0457401611,
0.046923358,
-0.0110152243,
-0.0423037671,
0.0206176527,
-0.0627860352,
-0.0001297111,
-0.026706703,
-0.0192766059,
0.0666757673,
0.1030163839,
-0.0689934865,
-0.0061772163,
-0.0053525064,
-0.0400053412,
0.104403764,
0.0075965896,
0.0084881177,
0.0009135503,
0.0004205212,
0.0024405862,
0.0013371058,
-0.0010608668,
-0.0084759928,
-0.0137748253,
0.0658767819,
0.0218146238,
-0.0103628077,
-0.0504300334,
-0.0301467199,
0.0281897616,
-0.0158223547,
-0.052118253,
0.0804299489,
-0.0669675916,
-0.0224570744,
0.0130721191,
-0.0722641945,
0.0185528416,
0.0355627984,
-0.0216419213,
-0.0337473154,
0.0350992531,
0.0785280392,
-0.0230879746,
-0.0133462623,
-0.0476307832,
-0.0119922869,
-0.0352528356,
-0.0247251932,
0.0134453997,
-0.0428659134,
0.0053722328,
0.0275281575,
0.0063679074,
-0.0383146107,
1.897990602e-34,
0.0246709138,
0.0028581212,
0.0095591331,
0.0129817929,
0.00844716,
-0.0370985642,
-0.0163694974,
-0.0258947853,
-0.001787765,
-0.071897611,
-0.0207108893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15331v1 | Tutorials on Stance Detection using Pre-trained Language Models: Fine-tuning BERT and Prompting Large Language Models | 2023-07-28T06:15:27 | 2023-07-28T06:15:27 | Yun-Shiuan Chuang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents two self-contained tutorials on stance detection in
Twitter data using BERT fine-tuning and prompting large language models (LLMs).
The first tutorial explains BERT architecture and tokenization, guiding users
through training, tuning, and evaluating standard and domain-specific BERT
models with HuggingFace transformers. The second focuses on constructing
prompts and few-shot examples to elicit stances from ChatGPT and open-source
FLAN-T5 without fine-tuning. Various prompting strategies are implemented and
evaluated using confusion matrices and macro F1 scores. The tutorials provide
code, visualizations, and insights revealing the strengths of few-shot ChatGPT
and FLAN-T5 which outperform fine-tuned BERTs. By covering both model
fine-tuning and prompting-based techniques in an accessible, hands-on manner,
these tutorials enable learners to gain applied experience with cutting-edge
methods for stance detection. | [
0.0335489064,
-0.0011312879,
0.0094724251,
0.056049671,
-0.0194900502,
0.0369252972,
-0.0061406675,
0.0082964338,
0.0039292309,
-0.0631470159,
0.0069424729,
-0.0350160152,
-0.0184150524,
0.0152502684,
-0.0064122062,
-0.0533675142,
0.0562049858,
0.0234030988,
0.0548559614,
-0.0151957991,
0.0738354251,
0.0487904325,
-0.0528715104,
0.0418855213,
-0.0455194488,
-0.0276833288,
-0.0254476499,
0.0124637596,
0.0440487862,
-0.0198335815,
0.0326154865,
0.0603238568,
0.0256108493,
0.0297089294,
0.0000020576,
-0.0455021188,
-0.0546881147,
-0.031297829,
0.0003805346,
-0.0019176098,
-0.0240998492,
-0.0109459935,
-0.0083410777,
0.0248251017,
-0.0709023625,
0.0019478534,
0.0366151147,
0.0587256029,
0.105541043,
0.0775020644,
-0.0090199932,
-0.0191967133,
-0.0290235728,
-0.0118321693,
-0.0393491834,
-0.0245407876,
0.0354398526,
-0.0460808836,
-0.0440114215,
0.0554374456,
-0.0187502019,
0.005162905,
0.0264860578,
-0.0188091695,
-0.0523012467,
0.0102683185,
-0.0434375331,
-0.038699504,
-0.0114777433,
0.0497397706,
0.030634949,
-0.0254210327,
0.0066215694,
-0.0176573079,
0.0242829453,
0.0302973464,
-0.0051447409,
0.0179698877,
-0.0318221748,
0.0204608999,
0.0015519308,
-0.0264261812,
-0.0276800618,
0.0486101247,
-0.0073870933,
0.0239224676,
-0.0094393287,
-0.0205079392,
0.0068839807,
0.0206749439,
-0.0266122073,
-0.0393443219,
0.0459254831,
0.0344049111,
-0.0318579189,
0.0286930222,
-0.0465485491,
0.0200689565,
0.0340610817,
-0.0290318672,
-0.0212887377,
0.0192669276,
-0.0274712835,
0.0437427089,
-0.0237158146,
0.039399717,
-0.0288032126,
-0.0192536935,
0.0013523034,
0.033062689,
-0.0331912972,
-0.0200256296,
-0.0490253903,
0.0149555774,
-0.0591345094,
-0.0255085081,
-0.0372730456,
0.0039237021,
0.003233999,
0.0045589837,
0.0142209847,
-0.0145336119,
0.0072718672,
0.0150408586,
-0.0002464804,
0.0625761598,
-0.0158653203,
0.0008957304,
-0.0154133467,
-0.0502398685,
-0.0152828759,
0.0097374488,
0.0173343215,
-0.0049011461,
0.0129067209,
-0.0248827152,
0.0210207999,
-0.0224385243,
0.0354054831,
0.0175690539,
-0.0542246513,
-0.0728633851,
-0.024118349,
-0.0807420611,
0.0104650771,
0.0197407976,
0.0113549996,
-0.005761683,
0.0201378204,
0.0382093526,
0.0466964357,
0.0726298839,
-0.0116665531,
-0.017708078,
-0.0020515865,
0.0065751029,
0.0279424619,
0.1092815474,
-0.0044694026,
0.0201586094,
0.0280374065,
0.0134699363,
-0.0218073037,
0.0422924682,
0.0283934362,
-0.0060062017,
0.0153889051,
0.0232009236,
-0.051104743,
-0.0097701931,
-0.0325963348,
0.0676568076,
0.0165767018,
0.0004402088,
0.0500922613,
0.0520267598,
0.0255001541,
-0.0111908903,
0.0156985857,
0.0460680202,
0.032947015,
-0.0155982766,
-0.0155393397,
0.0202595908,
-0.0272654984,
-0.0008085716,
-0.0506526418,
0.050432004,
-0.0276601184,
-0.0301010888,
-0.0170460548,
0.010982764,
-0.0089263124,
-0.0116619049,
0.0159740895,
-0.0002905025,
-0.0759777054,
0.0589541532,
0.0134101883,
-0.0646660477,
-0.0233136062,
-0.0514299646,
0.0259232894,
0.038789548,
-0.0019647216,
-0.0425961465,
-0.0741129592,
-0.0317877345,
0.011222952,
0.0919115916,
0.0148067633,
-0.0179262739,
-0.0323573239,
-0.0232301522,
0.0007627318,
0.004013191,
0.0087300763,
0.0126046631,
0.0059898249,
0.0350282602,
-0.0142444074,
-0.0002636189,
0.0558393076,
0.0327210128,
0.0495661274,
0.0060250731,
-0.0049118455,
0.0478531308,
0.0046803672,
0.0601453148,
-0.005639663,
-0.0271479785,
0.0220724568,
0.0020189777,
-0.0129183009,
0.0097568361,
-0.0343002528,
-0.0890933424,
0.0581257716,
-0.0108736185,
-0.0789298564,
0.0318410434,
-0.0353525877,
-0.0145269791,
-0.0205930695,
-0.046555046,
-0.0025347136,
-0.0744191483,
-0.0157091022,
-0.0361156426,
-0.0039393795,
-0.0176522825,
0.0566481277,
0.0031133115,
0.003887871,
0.0156231849,
-0.0094655976,
0.041030027,
-0.0440596044,
-0.0438166447,
-0.0155755961,
-0.0043567349,
-0.0019102197,
0.0383377932,
0.0624144375,
-0.0297634453,
-0.0080672428,
-0.1034450457,
-0.0099380389,
-0.046929922,
0.0248033907,
0.0247598961,
0.0045759007,
-0.0216684919,
0.0031490338,
-0.0371270142,
-0.0370179936,
0.003890818,
0.0059692897,
0.0444060601,
-0.0368446447,
-0.0137577485,
-0.0316739492,
0.0325807333,
-0.0305976253,
-0.0071889656,
0.0111634191,
-0.0887679458,
-0.0341772735,
-0.0191954039,
0.0046167774,
0.0149914315,
0.0215038266,
-0.0826853514,
0.0526366793,
-0.0160965305,
0.0471234657,
0.049383305,
0.0526365824,
0.0980680585,
-0.0405098945,
0.0320016518,
-0.0477415361,
0.0171998497,
-0.0268427711,
0.031511046,
-0.0126636671,
0.0167105589,
0.0175358132,
0.0521160029,
-0.0170105472,
-0.0050234133,
-0.0803477839,
0.0208310951,
-0.0405279249,
-0.0072134971,
0.0166368317,
-0.003897622,
-0.0399262942,
-0.0263924189,
0.0032298109,
-0.0159436706,
0.0869149268,
-0.0049216235,
-0.0147787128,
-0.0546861403,
0.001421522,
-0.0317753181,
0.0506608672,
0.0065093525,
-0.0006237849,
0.0267712083,
-0.0250486452,
0.0331136659,
-0.0287256651,
0.0006925658,
-0.0300472192,
0.024061963,
0.000031907,
0.0405323058,
-0.0042262767,
-0.0348594896,
-0.0124631133,
-0.0704027265,
-0.062314,
-0.0274813678,
-0.0024800925,
-0.0342372693,
0.0659094676,
0.0272287447,
0.0036175272,
-0.0031833579,
-0.0339122154,
0.0252366625,
0.000157421,
0.0199948717,
0.0284754764,
-0.0185869914,
0.0108033093,
-0.0483710319,
0.0174038913,
0.0639461279,
0.0064157294,
0.0303291697,
-0.0242059361,
-0.032821849,
0.035364043,
-0.0284144245,
0.034269955,
-0.0405485518,
0.1027700752,
-0.012356922,
0.0042605135,
0.1308392584,
0.056901779,
0.0128060617,
0.0034624122,
0.0543676354,
0.0007034618,
-0.0032308889,
-0.0054266299,
-0.0804173499,
-0.047372859,
-0.0166261084,
0.0165072456,
-0.0168670882,
-0.0090378439,
0.0072382004,
-0.1018086225,
-0.000290481,
-0.0360669605,
-0.0301956944,
-0.0488963611,
-0.0427961461,
0.028162485,
-0.0276191905,
0.0214859825,
0.0046711448,
-0.0029254763,
-0.0005528018,
0.0376530178,
-0.0354147255,
-0.022549998,
-0.0094131893,
-0.0602735542,
0.0375431292,
0.0293578543,
0.051417958,
-0.0066614687,
-0.0540054627,
0.0217062421,
-0.0328586288,
0.0058546169,
-0.0453907847,
0.0254367553,
-0.0353928134,
-0.0261953007,
-0.0519270152,
0.0306401514,
-0.014780187,
0.0174904391,
-0.0330074877,
0.0049630483,
-0.0051236101,
0.0161993261,
-0.0200983249,
0.0504421405,
0.0509886928,
0.0566007495,
0.0542359687,
-0.0747218654,
-0.0230449289,
-0.0571687445,
-0.0089398958,
-0.0955215394,
-0.0361463986,
-0.0435757563,
-0.0244582221,
-0.0059965421,
-0.0583444871,
-0.0025586695,
0.0488808677,
0.0469179489,
-0.0264578033,
-0.0189342257,
0.029331347,
0.0527183227,
-0.045550745,
0.0355563574,
0.0240881592,
0.0505006574,
-0.0226826947,
-0.036185082,
0.0611960068,
0.0242850482,
-0.017778784,
-0.0339934751,
-0.0446058251,
-0.0378910489,
0.0161615796,
0.040495865,
0.0151738776,
0.007291615,
-0.0294571724,
-0.0067189159,
0.0042822706,
0.1168343499,
-0.0177361332,
0.0027262557,
0.0358723402,
0.0380745567,
-0.0132044628,
0.0295164362,
-0.0077800076,
-0.0040298058,
0.0135301081,
0.0197707601,
-0.0328203142,
0.003476047,
0.0109098898,
0.0163072925,
0.037394058,
-0.0038420158,
-0.0867181718,
-0.0092683332,
-0.0148395151,
-0.0263449885,
-0.0392532162,
-0.0401255377,
0.0051633161,
-0.0130881285,
-0.0436687358,
-0.0392902046,
0.0283231251,
-0.0430568382,
0.0938395411,
-0.0519054942,
0.0802112296,
0.041336149,
0.0320164673,
-0.0046706754,
-0.0385709181,
-0.0375129692,
-0.024557868,
0.0239168443,
-0.0311748181,
0.0247106291,
0.074825421,
0.0229770504,
-0.0238000769,
0.0155218216,
0.0536221936,
-0.0089544747,
-0.0022733994,
-0.0405082218,
0.0405007601,
0.012234224,
-0.0206688512,
0.0441764183,
0.0002552226,
-0.0251759049,
-0.010068018,
0.0060537513,
-0.0320361294,
-0.0258943122,
0.0612672046,
0.0247312542,
-0.0126689197,
-0.0148593616,
0.0132510234,
-0.0464049876,
0.0238918718,
0.064320378,
0.0046768347,
-0.0323994383,
0.0028883833,
0.0031358446,
-0.0089233611,
0.0055120904,
0.045139391,
-0.0654873177,
-0.0293798689,
0.0070949472,
0.0279134419,
0.008144401,
0.0599559546,
0.0155170718,
0.0487559438,
0.0118197454,
0.0176897198,
-0.0451984182,
0.0419615619,
-0.001795951,
-0.0351786315,
-0.023991378,
-6.606245191e-33,
-0.0247677993,
-0.0510308594,
-0.0398686603,
-0.0135423876,
-0.0266959071,
-0.0036400692,
-0.0097916769,
0.0222791936,
-0.0240386706,
0.0620242879,
0.0040354081,
0.0332357623,
0.0079815723,
0.0344754793,
-0.0380282365,
-0.0221100971,
0.0263672769,
0.0119758584,
-0.0487898141,
-0.0002793646,
0.0339239053,
0.0020644101,
0.0383844152,
-0.0599461943,
0.0339444242,
-0.0090131396,
-0.0657772124,
0.0434444882,
-0.0075499266,
0.0756619945,
-0.0134971133,
0.0227597542,
0.0287067238,
-0.0122999009,
0.0190682858,
0.1073636413,
-0.0569510385,
-0.0090821926,
0.0348348133,
0.0388856791,
0.0080948044,
0.0129685607,
-0.0134239784,
-0.0220777411,
-0.0235258415,
0.0348946825,
0.0151278051,
-0.0049031037,
0.0674260631,
-0.0233032964,
-0.0416770764,
0.0254639778,
-0.0300556663,
-0.0763373747,
-0.0194394402,
0.0425608493,
0.0041213557,
0.0151552595,
-0.0244810507,
0.010994927,
-0.0312283766,
0.0041837287,
0.0059754103,
0.0088455286,
0.0009645277,
0.0586366281,
-0.0429865792,
0.005157866,
-0.0434234329,
-0.0161512662,
0.0246165767,
0.0222049616,
0.069611147,
0.0468838103,
-0.0080304258,
-0.0043575801,
-0.050313428,
0.0118052308,
0.0820741802,
0.0194869619,
0.0009913458,
-0.0054998123,
-0.0130077424,
-0.0127491727,
0.0017033548,
-0.0325496197,
-0.0224916786,
0.008901705,
-0.0183926616,
-0.0170624908,
-0.0748877153,
0.0232235044,
0.0393826328,
-0.019861307,
-0.0204140116,
0.0251741596,
-0.0154454466,
0.0304924771,
0.0104126809,
0.0351873264,
-0.0278502982,
-0.0235534385,
0.0204523485,
0.0141179422,
-0.0052959509,
-0.0018521583,
0.0542548224,
0.006392159,
-0.0799420848,
0.0037516046,
-0.0050045173,
0.0241027344,
-0.0585951544,
0.0596191697,
0.0328380428,
-0.0052331248,
-0.0261025205,
0.0560725108,
0.0009651642,
-0.0036981266,
-0.0551799089,
0.0346790515,
-0.0454164259,
0.0229659323,
-0.0236560069,
-0.0251929518,
-0.0019567332,
0.0490945093,
-0.0417355448,
-0.0981787518,
0.0049245092,
0.0097658318,
2.74e-7,
0.0477284528,
0.0683070943,
0.0417946391,
-0.0229303334,
0.0460432284,
0.0472694784,
0.001070639,
0.0151671181,
0.0242775381,
-0.0169634819,
-0.0374365486,
0.0358942524,
0.0265106279,
0.0025624563,
-0.0889399201,
0.0098995268,
-0.0214531664,
-0.0089655928,
-0.0303786751,
0.0464081541,
0.0017729793,
0.057265725,
0.0325592943,
0.021047134,
0.0217556227,
0.0033763449,
0.0220854431,
0.0197448805,
0.0017996475,
0.0082867527,
-0.0017121831,
-0.0843311176,
-0.0010760661,
0.0006530886,
-0.0014507006,
0.0276812352,
0.0031373238,
0.0778606385,
0.0080123786,
-0.0228360351,
-0.0195483286,
-0.0097711952,
-0.0004304021,
-0.047882054,
0.0656942874,
-0.0630308613,
-0.0161868315,
-0.0437171385,
-0.0343823172,
0.0039924132,
0.0094181634,
-0.0105094276,
-0.0457259342,
0.0388672613,
0.0116920378,
-0.0352537334,
-0.0147291292,
-0.0662745312,
-0.023831116,
-0.0503336154,
-0.0394113436,
-0.0344063975,
0.0210900549,
-0.0363275446,
0.0156249711,
-0.0616888516,
-0.0102749821,
2.462282991e-34,
0.031428691,
-0.0286147967,
0.0291317143,
0.0313701779,
0.0158779919,
0.033377517,
-0.0071195858,
0.0143917557,
0.0500949584,
-0.0323595293,
-0.0143213142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.01420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.01420v1 | SAP-sLDA: An Interpretable Interface for Exploring Unstructured Text | 2023-07-28T05:43:39 | 2023-07-28T05:43:39 | Charumathi Badrinath, Weiwei Pan, Finale Doshi-Velez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | A common way to explore text corpora is through low-dimensional projections
of the documents, where one hopes that thematically similar documents will be
clustered together in the projected space. However, popular algorithms for
dimensionality reduction of text corpora, like Latent Dirichlet Allocation
(LDA), often produce projections that do not capture human notions of document
similarity. We propose a semi-supervised human-in-the-loop LDA-based method for
learning topics that preserve semantically meaningful relationships between
documents in low-dimensional projections. On synthetic corpora, our method
yields more interpretable projections than baseline methods with only a
fraction of labels provided. On a real corpus, we obtain qualitatively similar
results. | [
0.0170842819,
0.0259816926,
-0.0213476773,
0.0403499343,
0.0013384289,
0.0011677545,
0.0155161917,
-0.0096274503,
-0.0633777454,
0.0090262648,
-0.0366992615,
0.0081749531,
-0.0093836505,
0.0505478494,
-0.0035262024,
-0.1081834063,
0.0125405574,
-0.0021826306,
-0.0258202776,
0.019512007,
0.0276567042,
-0.0296982098,
-0.0029684978,
-0.0045489725,
-0.0188340005,
-0.0139724985,
-0.0323830694,
-0.0313074514,
-0.0069222338,
-0.0071212468,
-0.0203130879,
0.0582406521,
0.0474869013,
-0.0087205973,
0.0000018604,
-0.0256823357,
-0.0383970216,
-0.0327282213,
0.0113559011,
0.0117509039,
0.1016212255,
-0.0612648986,
0.0243231673,
-0.009826838,
-0.0167217497,
-0.0276557729,
0.0171965566,
0.0626970232,
0.0364420079,
0.0246885121,
-0.0441909432,
-0.0247114394,
-0.0037207166,
-0.0031884173,
0.0055908198,
0.0058395024,
-0.018270418,
0.0014301084,
0.008821615,
0.039218314,
0.0000469115,
-0.0019890189,
-0.0119278422,
-0.0118395174,
0.0948505998,
0.0120672463,
-0.0202181954,
-0.0404295325,
0.0367870592,
0.0673313662,
0.0335533805,
-0.039122384,
0.0380369127,
0.0050079762,
-0.020225849,
0.0457647108,
-0.0590267852,
-0.0258728862,
-0.0292115211,
0.0284098834,
0.0281566214,
0.0411597937,
0.0015546319,
-0.0305075776,
0.0124025503,
0.045030538,
0.0017966421,
-0.0220435187,
-0.0039988793,
0.0189792309,
0.0146200284,
-0.0027624338,
0.0327476226,
-0.0177262574,
0.0057432279,
0.034464296,
-0.0238326211,
-0.0407265909,
0.026170399,
-0.0467727482,
-0.0117850481,
-0.0238979291,
-0.0031907945,
0.0253791083,
0.0314407796,
0.0054151122,
-0.006365261,
0.0153499246,
-0.0586459935,
-0.0416202918,
-0.0225244891,
0.0236368887,
-0.0121150417,
0.015800219,
-0.0194271412,
0.0037755144,
-0.0061900355,
0.0493565053,
-0.0160165671,
-0.0252572838,
-0.0500907451,
0.0059827939,
-0.0328728333,
-0.0054396624,
-0.0384995565,
0.0383756086,
-0.0745775774,
0.0486654863,
-0.1085673496,
0.030477196,
-0.0030932543,
0.0552035719,
0.0170346778,
-0.0132092498,
-0.0240724515,
0.0466128811,
-0.0169032272,
-0.0427474454,
-0.0715043619,
-0.0128859878,
0.0094656656,
-0.009634654,
0.0387747213,
-0.073381871,
0.0058203582,
0.0064289565,
-0.0222053472,
-0.0253235176,
-0.027511403,
0.037129689,
-0.0318616517,
0.088735126,
-0.0434765182,
0.0038649323,
0.0559450574,
0.0172602199,
-0.0400877856,
0.0387053601,
0.0112870922,
0.0548278093,
0.0325849913,
-0.000671352,
-0.0073221838,
-0.0003555952,
0.0062152543,
0.0390430652,
-0.023492774,
0.0139307035,
-0.0228721984,
0.0122329239,
0.0777769238,
0.0085062841,
-0.031363681,
-0.0326871201,
-0.0110937115,
0.0929868892,
0.0203538742,
0.0555347688,
-0.0074085738,
0.0401831307,
-0.0047210939,
0.0152586382,
0.0148695214,
0.0176482052,
0.026769856,
-0.040866375,
0.0326911248,
-0.0417444371,
-0.0213726629,
-0.0289860666,
-0.0036256183,
0.0015041135,
0.0179311279,
-0.0628774017,
0.0749036148,
0.0149044236,
0.032762669,
0.0177857224,
0.0479123034,
-0.036605563,
0.0023851746,
0.0513688959,
0.0674589425,
0.0635815933,
0.0333813727,
-0.082247816,
-0.0103463847,
0.0008368986,
0.0356190875,
0.0195149239,
-0.0326510258,
-0.0510457084,
-0.0105135757,
-0.02096829,
-0.0190501399,
-0.0107215457,
-0.00210742,
0.045472879,
-0.0110779721,
0.0048004659,
-0.0246249493,
-0.1096756309,
0.0468727574,
0.039576795,
-0.0074652135,
-0.0048019071,
0.0360707082,
0.0028164627,
0.0154866492,
0.0368851572,
0.0156499185,
0.0048274091,
0.0373111293,
-0.0688460767,
-0.0348533168,
-0.027188981,
-0.0160489529,
-0.0056106918,
0.004064498,
-0.111763984,
-0.0046774647,
-0.0170366503,
-0.0028797274,
-0.0337535292,
0.077975817,
-0.0375630595,
-0.0197643582,
-0.0404111035,
-0.0245298762,
-0.0056949803,
0.0082555944,
-0.0285343453,
0.0785781071,
0.0320475064,
0.025514042,
0.0540005416,
0.0031986958,
0.0662464201,
-0.0164308753,
0.0520871282,
-0.0021155491,
0.0126139615,
0.0297400448,
0.0421705544,
-0.0164194554,
-0.0310751423,
-0.0038667053,
-0.0624539219,
0.0030485997,
-0.0205091387,
0.0447835736,
0.0510824099,
-0.0227117315,
-0.017468011,
-0.0325551927,
-0.0214408822,
-0.0115707768,
-0.0364835151,
-0.0107840905,
0.0467112437,
-0.0022920037,
0.0573609695,
-0.0346654393,
-0.0020932322,
-0.0180927515,
0.0340122841,
0.0257245861,
-0.0457585007,
-0.0325654149,
0.0082053002,
0.0134989144,
0.0052222498,
0.0030389593,
0.0287167411,
0.002525449,
-0.0194107387,
0.0604373701,
-0.0214007124,
-0.0065279943,
0.0747271776,
0.068434082,
0.0066073108,
-0.0508337021,
-0.0154550513,
-0.0073583191,
0.0826196298,
-0.0178567525,
-0.0243215412,
0.0667722374,
0.0341155939,
0.0227244552,
0.0123902345,
-0.0330548845,
-0.0005537737,
-0.0464536138,
0.0024012385,
-0.0644413158,
-0.0085849483,
0.0038432558,
0.0203879364,
0.0128227212,
-0.0308229551,
0.0174456667,
-0.0120166726,
0.019351678,
-0.078627564,
-0.0199676827,
-0.0526846871,
0.0522251725,
-0.0098636122,
-0.0027400618,
-0.0427404456,
-0.0205646548,
0.007355629,
0.0751864091,
0.0268134214,
0.0379850194,
0.0528469756,
-0.0469810329,
0.0101368353,
-0.0180663336,
-0.0032841808,
-0.0423389189,
-0.0620555952,
0.0041424925,
-0.0173662473,
0.0008237027,
-0.0108732609,
-0.041319564,
-0.0231508818,
0.0129454397,
0.028581582,
0.0186682492,
-0.0262257699,
-0.0099166119,
0.0576510355,
0.0456048697,
-0.0095827794,
-0.0288004074,
0.0021780466,
0.0121312346,
0.0413237587,
0.0081259916,
-0.0372822508,
-0.0290150531,
0.0378229618,
-0.0019110356,
-0.0274304766,
-0.0164375938,
0.0057255244,
-0.015980348,
0.0184037965,
-0.0228406098,
0.0891231671,
0.0585399605,
-0.098937735,
-0.0073245,
-0.0562021509,
0.0457361899,
0.0160763375,
0.0286157504,
-0.041906666,
-0.0235217791,
-0.0159327518,
0.0451116003,
0.0272008944,
-0.0478421561,
-0.0228420701,
-0.0466385148,
0.0200823974,
-0.007141599,
-0.0435124226,
0.0077286283,
-0.138058126,
0.0237829853,
-0.016083084,
-0.0552421808,
-0.0329790935,
-0.012504993,
0.0250222124,
0.0290351622,
-0.0615776367,
-0.0033014433,
-0.0142167676,
-0.0158087462,
0.0107537797,
-0.0058698161,
0.0328282826,
-0.0036072577,
-0.0093077412,
-0.0411575846,
-0.0323247351,
-0.0092944503,
0.0021098193,
0.0757994726,
-0.0017404736,
0.0148697011,
-0.0043658498,
0.0554015785,
-0.0743297338,
-0.023032723,
0.0511647686,
0.1006700173,
-0.0251781065,
0.002977221,
-0.0513522513,
-0.0268613584,
0.0106074214,
0.0375934355,
0.0223977286,
-0.0250369869,
0.0068512261,
-0.0162302591,
0.0366481729,
0.0685767904,
0.0062266467,
0.0012944894,
-0.0655001998,
-0.067081511,
-0.0798068345,
-0.0543945096,
0.0131650688,
0.0347295813,
-0.0187559035,
0.0178543273,
0.0218145214,
-0.0540667064,
-0.0625910833,
0.0232186429,
-0.0241504908,
-0.0116248634,
-0.0050648074,
-0.0310392268,
0.0369663909,
-0.0180445369,
-0.0005922632,
-0.0124817276,
-0.0538084768,
-0.0050531086,
-0.0163228456,
-0.0556270331,
0.0158139281,
0.0343140922,
-0.0363087803,
-0.0498767421,
0.0218812767,
0.0520046763,
-0.0448704585,
-0.0018891301,
-0.0056702709,
0.006881041,
0.0106719993,
0.0324819535,
-0.0219914746,
0.0629552975,
-0.0226449892,
-0.0018069672,
-0.0489377156,
-0.0421000533,
0.0063328524,
-0.0016297925,
0.0832060426,
0.0151445204,
-0.0193931758,
-0.0575922802,
-0.022630807,
-0.0232737996,
0.0014928516,
-0.0026095826,
0.0012271041,
-0.0023982821,
-0.0168490093,
-0.035453856,
0.0275657885,
-0.0540619381,
0.0244750436,
-0.0239749067,
0.0032846846,
0.0932882279,
0.0148548,
-0.0670257062,
0.0416506045,
0.0120936539,
-0.027985163,
0.0034314927,
0.0400680862,
-0.008941968,
0.001674911,
0.0161505137,
0.0207157005,
-0.0279203784,
0.029973669,
-0.0463842973,
-0.0300194658,
0.0082545551,
0.0126954764,
-0.0044570877,
-0.0045872387,
0.0325854495,
-0.0377956629,
0.0049192249,
0.0168124419,
0.020619344,
-0.0078321332,
0.0042489902,
0.0018790696,
0.0170461182,
-0.0126090748,
0.0256236307,
0.0938895419,
0.0193093214,
0.0088256067,
-0.0103020659,
-0.0349370353,
-0.0442301221,
-0.002440362,
0.0248148441,
0.0393931791,
-0.0122373998,
-0.0050799469,
-0.0563663431,
-0.0160809327,
0.0537796058,
-0.0637221336,
-0.0318915434,
0.0037465654,
0.0697524771,
0.045907408,
-0.0374890529,
0.0669337586,
-0.0297883227,
0.0233437065,
0.0056107044,
-0.0667723864,
-0.0123779932,
-6.263345407e-33,
-0.0009481933,
-0.0519645438,
0.0058606798,
-0.0142783616,
0.0264322143,
0.0014423409,
-0.0355600528,
0.0154314488,
0.053273581,
0.0422531888,
-0.0172070302,
0.0090694372,
0.0119396215,
-0.0238217469,
0.0236179307,
-0.0046091154,
0.0085087977,
0.0160924718,
-0.0195099767,
0.0475407578,
0.0709836334,
0.0324467458,
0.0020570287,
-0.0912920013,
0.0427430272,
0.0219434574,
0.0247537773,
0.0117154224,
0.1259735525,
0.0141567262,
-0.0533602349,
0.0530830473,
0.0467038043,
-0.0389117338,
-0.0268874597,
0.07145603,
-0.0443620123,
-0.0906820372,
-0.0253088847,
-0.0112607582,
-0.0145100113,
-0.0411836542,
0.0204688106,
0.0187719259,
0.0078645023,
0.0042131953,
0.0817501694,
0.0009139171,
-0.0382066183,
-0.0525413603,
-0.0492993183,
0.0317030959,
-0.0367607623,
-0.0076259235,
0.0395786725,
-0.0102162715,
-0.0048431279,
0.0189989433,
-0.0241990946,
0.0454226471,
-0.0313934721,
-0.0064454642,
0.023785742,
-0.054232765,
-0.0044576866,
0.0815920159,
0.0055658072,
-0.0161326323,
-0.0098504256,
-0.0212555546,
0.0250106677,
0.0179745834,
0.0068009594,
0.0323281698,
0.0233988594,
0.037157353,
-0.0308148582,
0.0983811319,
-0.0115311882,
-0.0181828234,
-0.007725413,
0.0398664139,
-0.0383023135,
-0.0486471206,
-0.01279335,
0.0125463987,
-0.0170384515,
-0.0269196834,
-0.0051698503,
-0.0374623016,
-0.0439131074,
-0.0088176802,
0.0105532696,
-0.0215529799,
0.0036898805,
0.0107079465,
0.0030948699,
0.0315482877,
0.0324560106,
-0.0090198815,
-0.0579879135,
-0.0342740417,
0.0284559857,
0.0180648472,
0.0279490668,
-0.0228180531,
0.0025908398,
-0.017780086,
-0.0284484886,
-0.0060911039,
-0.0050271684,
-0.0407653786,
-0.0171173494,
0.0420918316,
0.0048489589,
-0.0087109031,
-0.00447152,
0.0747031569,
0.0365626626,
0.0543233454,
0.0046063457,
-0.0141387815,
-0.026781382,
0.0044756141,
-0.0181761812,
-0.0183021631,
-0.0302073192,
-0.0140606035,
0.0523850322,
-0.0774865448,
0.0076698842,
-0.0473702736,
2.703e-7,
0.0226692613,
0.0730265677,
0.037226256,
-0.069945842,
0.0704530254,
0.0494127609,
0.0010751208,
0.0677028298,
-0.065702267,
-0.0083791986,
0.026743805,
0.0069413329,
0.0054204781,
0.063238509,
-0.0720099136,
0.0181174688,
-0.0293614194,
0.0146239242,
-0.0546228327,
0.024468204,
0.0328570493,
0.0608180128,
0.0159515608,
-0.0191828012,
-0.0003587439,
-0.0109595889,
0.034861166,
-0.0191142075,
-0.007409621,
0.0044600032,
0.0536642969,
0.000401267,
-0.009269869,
-0.018754283,
-0.0034426814,
-0.0043220026,
0.03512628,
0.0256197844,
0.0049943174,
0.0134531679,
-0.0036856746,
-0.0358109809,
-0.0069449469,
0.0029733386,
0.0447848774,
-0.0282666907,
-0.0507703349,
0.0428683572,
0.0049979934,
0.0098184822,
-0.0246093906,
0.0234589409,
-0.0210926738,
0.0339903235,
0.0035169863,
-0.0246330518,
-0.006893001,
-0.0176029764,
0.0099780345,
-0.0054854671,
-0.0684589744,
0.0033455086,
-0.0347253159,
0.0569497533,
0.0473060235,
-0.0293718781,
0.0571932532,
2.005027398e-34,
0.0176430251,
0.0314234011,
-0.0410094708,
-0.0212691333,
0.0019089701,
-0.0259353053,
-0.0325976945,
0.0233711004,
0.0202047862,
-0.0713886172,
0.0198467374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15311v1 | TrafficSafetyGPT: Tuning a Pre-trained Large Language Model to a Domain-Specific Expert in Transportation Safety | 2023-07-28T05:17:11 | 2023-07-28T05:17:11 | Ou Zheng, Mohamed Abdel-Aty, Dongdong Wang, Chenzhu Wang, Shengxuan Ding | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable effectiveness in various
general-domain natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, their
performance in transportation safety domain tasks has been suboptimal,
primarily attributed to the requirement for specialized transportation safety
expertise in generating accurate responses [1]. To address this challenge, we
introduce TrafficSafetyGPT, a novel LLAMA-based model, which has undergone
supervised fine-tuning using TrafficSafety-2K dataset which has human labels
from government produced guiding books and ChatGPT-generated instruction-output
pairs. Our proposed TrafficSafetyGPT model and TrafficSafety-2K train dataset
are accessible at https://github.com/ozheng1993/TrafficSafetyGPT. | [
0.0478410237,
0.0336432792,
-0.0077280556,
0.060154561,
-0.0007514418,
0.0131074926,
0.0160249472,
-0.0091362949,
0.0153512163,
-0.0706117973,
-0.0474142469,
-0.0269857775,
-0.0502955206,
0.0283445287,
0.0227493402,
-0.0548204072,
0.018861128,
-0.072915785,
0.0185776222,
0.0258088931,
0.0341584198,
0.0333252251,
-0.0238858741,
0.0328746103,
-0.0175201297,
-0.0059356047,
0.0206192099,
-0.0173978098,
0.0578342155,
-0.0542757511,
0.032490246,
0.0425282381,
0.0697979033,
-0.0161089543,
0.0000021021,
-0.0193975735,
0.0260641463,
-0.0039342572,
-0.0258836374,
0.0135497935,
0.0445542336,
0.0095743351,
-0.0002293967,
0.044308465,
-0.0218900628,
-0.0197516978,
0.009238177,
0.089113377,
0.0880885199,
0.0928672254,
0.002014959,
-0.0365833715,
0.0180014353,
-0.0331266187,
-0.0048757405,
-0.0556615889,
0.0235376526,
0.0429926068,
0.0177996214,
0.049092453,
-0.0229934063,
0.0320704617,
0.0294874553,
-0.0031547428,
0.0061411792,
0.0225103628,
-0.0088303173,
0.0133107007,
-0.0120209586,
0.1088902354,
-0.0217836071,
-0.0280739684,
0.0170006994,
0.0064501301,
-0.0211514849,
-0.0244532116,
-0.0163331348,
-0.0181140956,
0.0116727343,
0.0232041124,
0.0152053665,
0.0363172367,
0.0177093353,
0.0330048762,
-0.0108539276,
0.0350297727,
-0.0108189536,
-0.0315535478,
0.0467651524,
0.0139749479,
-0.0276150461,
-0.0342083126,
0.0236557294,
0.0140594197,
-0.0414679945,
0.0090254042,
0.0158523452,
-0.013651832,
0.0333777517,
-0.0756201074,
0.0161476173,
0.0131730651,
-0.0525364242,
0.0235556718,
0.0020876972,
0.0239122957,
-0.0028124363,
0.0445786566,
-0.0548520163,
0.000943184,
-0.037344791,
-0.0153933736,
-0.0413796231,
0.0047435407,
-0.0367888995,
0.0174370557,
-0.0532872416,
0.0057490948,
0.024287492,
-0.0128170121,
-0.0048320815,
0.0180443879,
-0.0411611274,
-0.0355357081,
-0.0270438045,
0.0019117034,
-0.0151719628,
0.0622519962,
-0.0144496076,
-0.015164854,
-0.003365227,
0.0257902239,
-0.0120473932,
0.0018966461,
0.0122940121,
0.0952751264,
-0.0257573556,
-0.0457359143,
-0.0839995295,
-0.0271574892,
-0.0013287388,
-0.0477959737,
0.0078986175,
-0.0435056798,
0.0408419855,
-0.0140612246,
0.0185507964,
-0.034360189,
0.0132546248,
-0.0073955902,
-0.0188219231,
0.0784136206,
-0.0073111146,
-0.0109886751,
0.0433557592,
0.0259846561,
0.0571908392,
0.0609523132,
0.0429497808,
0.0462493487,
0.0273325108,
0.0000184378,
0.0140657974,
0.0173485577,
-0.0016197264,
0.0092918836,
-0.01044943,
0.0294670928,
-0.0022659411,
0.0411235541,
0.0447754785,
0.0237445887,
-0.0141148269,
0.0195949748,
0.0311408602,
0.0500606485,
0.0032203218,
0.0020984286,
0.0377039947,
0.0558084361,
0.0072799493,
-0.0282293055,
-0.0217814576,
0.0059529594,
-0.042520158,
-0.0019630943,
0.0389131419,
0.0343184061,
-0.0395967215,
-0.0291709416,
0.0364870653,
-0.0088020517,
-0.0043174112,
0.000490026,
0.016774701,
-0.0181613378,
-0.0405955426,
0.0379374065,
0.015592468,
0.0249355454,
0.0009801409,
-0.0577282645,
-0.0288151484,
0.0784496516,
0.0002275597,
-0.001695748,
-0.0626212955,
-0.0389315262,
0.0303643774,
0.0254506748,
0.0087172715,
0.0085168881,
0.0038673349,
-0.083221294,
-0.0323947147,
0.0213047862,
0.0240705553,
-0.0236694831,
0.0334826671,
0.0399014764,
0.0639341548,
-0.0288485568,
-0.0565056168,
0.0388122462,
-0.0059418208,
-0.0394368805,
-0.0275146868,
0.0029004479,
0.0169471409,
-0.0153030856,
-0.0285610706,
-0.000885331,
0.0327349938,
-0.022053143,
-0.0152937211,
-0.0053252783,
-0.0519914813,
0.0275450777,
0.0287943985,
-0.0413449332,
0.0126638357,
0.0443569534,
-0.0815428197,
-0.0217676144,
-0.0673100874,
-0.0300226081,
-0.0293230824,
-0.015393815,
-0.0047133388,
0.0578606911,
-0.0001308969,
-0.0180674251,
0.0462424867,
0.0241440181,
-0.009821414,
-0.0346955433,
0.0020970644,
0.0325820297,
-0.023662705,
-0.0207498837,
-0.0095672179,
-0.0066121067,
0.0483318567,
-0.0341733284,
0.0405033417,
-0.0569265336,
-0.0265257433,
-0.0312448554,
0.0034172314,
-0.0322541595,
0.0278334748,
0.0162399635,
-0.0354709812,
-0.048598703,
-0.0146201253,
-0.0142434733,
0.0018393316,
0.019165352,
-0.0252864789,
0.0178090278,
-0.0079218522,
-0.0111024296,
-0.0449264757,
-0.0102974847,
-0.0181557368,
-0.0000564377,
0.0247727558,
-0.0435657874,
-0.0578044914,
0.0458039232,
0.0049554403,
0.0347444639,
-0.0056454674,
-0.07941477,
0.0014800297,
0.0349910967,
0.032404691,
0.0178975612,
0.0310611874,
-0.0164003707,
0.0301492754,
-0.0169358496,
-0.0371493958,
0.0273717102,
-0.0426237248,
-0.0492312573,
-0.0333513319,
0.0148218172,
-0.006286446,
0.0503626317,
-0.0241896119,
0.0120180026,
-0.0290421825,
-0.0578953177,
-0.0367050208,
-0.0155070946,
-0.030870663,
-0.0145280175,
0.0056366506,
0.0410664789,
0.0088987844,
-0.0164476354,
0.0409981832,
-0.0194076616,
0.028558217,
-0.0739963651,
0.0060857986,
-0.043693427,
0.0680242926,
-0.0023718225,
0.0190426335,
0.0296343379,
-0.0119405268,
0.0041100294,
0.0070727966,
-0.0528258421,
-0.0241005179,
0.0249962118,
-0.0455885977,
0.0279586725,
-0.019346809,
-0.0600330457,
-0.0415027849,
-0.0619578175,
-0.0492146127,
-0.0201482084,
-0.0105554163,
-0.0189344566,
-0.051535707,
0.0100510148,
0.0009142299,
0.0402029678,
0.0025041064,
0.0173907038,
-0.0385601334,
0.0212098137,
0.0767864063,
0.0350078121,
-0.0065337587,
-0.0277941264,
0.0082082637,
0.0433454141,
0.0081420885,
-0.0099614244,
-0.0507450774,
-0.0075600105,
0.023496503,
-0.0353318192,
-0.0078927139,
0.050498914,
0.0285996906,
-0.0702204704,
0.0077951793,
0.0807097033,
0.0083098374,
-0.0328569524,
0.0227958132,
0.0147324624,
-0.0012851486,
-0.0062977984,
0.0333621576,
-0.0631462857,
-0.0442680754,
-0.0003872293,
0.0108403452,
0.0205754451,
-0.0021952074,
0.0093278075,
-0.0759055838,
0.0397382155,
0.0003551932,
-0.0449759178,
0.0025460513,
-0.0366988219,
-0.0285182949,
-0.0094012525,
0.0441300608,
-0.0116122467,
-0.0463160276,
-0.0232220478,
0.053574577,
-0.0136900162,
-0.0889179483,
0.0368107185,
-0.0344742164,
0.1120456904,
0.0343225971,
-0.0059723104,
-0.0337072723,
-0.018685054,
0.0539400876,
-0.0007954983,
0.0019907171,
-0.0138721662,
0.0374779813,
-0.0520575643,
-0.0228096489,
-0.0240904391,
0.0393310376,
-0.0517443419,
-0.0024696134,
0.0234823674,
0.0455058515,
-0.0358581319,
0.0213643853,
-0.0488591455,
0.0520571359,
-0.0207742956,
0.041871462,
-0.0158508644,
-0.0412413925,
-0.005275663,
-0.0216581114,
-0.02547203,
-0.0319256,
-0.074785091,
0.0102702165,
-0.0160694458,
-0.0283821318,
-0.0235081501,
-0.0223478321,
0.0305812135,
-0.0195852742,
0.0246608388,
0.0165323373,
0.0341754556,
-0.0178751256,
-0.0222391691,
0.0707821772,
-0.054022789,
0.0258957874,
-0.0767482445,
0.0522385165,
0.0703852326,
0.0059000165,
-0.0567058362,
0.0469686761,
-0.0598952845,
-0.0644739941,
0.0266197454,
0.0178439487,
0.0170682948,
-0.012946683,
-0.0316948593,
-0.0914665088,
0.0442329571,
0.061183285,
-0.0823120475,
-0.01501875,
-0.0124248359,
-0.0271116979,
0.0058592744,
0.0208994709,
-0.0163350366,
0.0472444408,
0.0258714799,
-0.0058499184,
-0.0436876528,
-0.0214807447,
-0.0047897482,
0.0271086469,
0.0466024578,
0.0134323593,
0.0381158851,
-0.0558730438,
0.0484526008,
0.0194480512,
-0.0029492392,
-0.0190366376,
0.0096288556,
0.028526023,
-0.0331724957,
-0.021010356,
-0.033465717,
0.0087723648,
0.0268472675,
0.0110683301,
0.030122228,
0.0240923353,
0.0087008327,
0.0108844889,
-0.0253391415,
-0.0143535426,
0.0058439099,
0.032299269,
0.0427241884,
0.0056255711,
0.0521460623,
0.0058211028,
0.0148837892,
-0.0472461693,
0.0422006696,
-0.0104726646,
-0.0668078363,
-0.0525277779,
0.0629521832,
0.0509212241,
0.0182412714,
0.0167425759,
-0.040549051,
0.0206750538,
-0.0264523625,
0.0432842709,
0.0065940069,
0.0187617373,
0.0853134543,
-0.0081670936,
-0.0193410199,
-0.0077557694,
0.1088340953,
0.037752673,
0.0512764715,
0.0358948819,
-0.015574309,
-0.0448147506,
-0.0288092177,
0.0097871274,
-0.0037044745,
-0.0288860928,
0.0032316367,
-0.0143228192,
-0.0520374142,
0.0055458019,
0.0123081375,
-0.021329131,
-0.0152264293,
0.0226327572,
0.0042798561,
0.0196017437,
-0.0352014229,
0.0186347179,
-0.0443135463,
0.0094910525,
-0.0109823374,
-0.000407748,
-6.58016391e-33,
-0.0375097133,
-0.0127410153,
0.0339072756,
-0.0031717892,
-0.033654131,
0.0006533256,
0.0084622148,
0.0090963999,
-0.018426517,
-0.0090101268,
-0.0266674273,
0.0330077223,
0.0265446939,
-0.0027752069,
0.0072190422,
-0.0263330471,
0.0329028182,
-0.0001418351,
0.0100913625,
0.0343887471,
0.0145877171,
0.0238861479,
0.0497134514,
-0.1071598604,
0.0157300942,
-0.0275335331,
-0.0367337689,
0.0171323009,
-0.0395928323,
0.0789977163,
-0.0511662364,
0.0622530691,
0.0299865212,
-0.0492934063,
-0.0007793266,
0.0577250645,
-0.0392993204,
-0.0124230012,
0.0437095314,
-0.009332384,
-0.0287090819,
-0.0687072724,
0.0509993695,
0.0132957557,
-0.0216200314,
0.0199154858,
0.0320791155,
-0.0234411899,
0.0196547005,
0.0121865422,
-0.0819048956,
0.0242874753,
-0.013575457,
-0.0208321828,
0.021662591,
0.0111510437,
-0.0100852223,
-0.0128590902,
-0.0358929299,
-0.0091100922,
0.0607533976,
0.0540317707,
0.0361553468,
0.0006504736,
-0.044289574,
0.0695073158,
-0.051575046,
-0.0271337163,
-0.0216272585,
-0.0424677022,
0.0033933101,
0.0495868139,
-0.0093288301,
0.0513169318,
0.0131754037,
-0.0581690446,
-0.1301919073,
0.0182867739,
-0.0207988434,
0.0656665564,
0.0534181707,
-0.0225723814,
-0.0686695278,
-0.0041077328,
-0.0453444161,
0.0488012284,
-0.0142459963,
-0.0233776979,
0.0309290495,
0.0408539027,
-0.0105029698,
-0.0040181368,
0.0064535146,
-0.0314427093,
0.0121198045,
-0.0342137292,
-0.0221393593,
-0.008641459,
-0.0150134405,
0.038856741,
-0.1239440441,
-0.0254434589,
0.0018710968,
-0.0503413677,
0.0211837832,
-0.0176562238,
0.0280417018,
0.0206811726,
-0.0687847361,
0.0175461527,
-0.0096423076,
-0.0037434197,
0.0339800604,
0.0405491628,
0.0206081513,
0.0129353162,
-0.0123837758,
0.0164900962,
0.013403561,
-0.0217804555,
-0.0044743512,
-0.0327637121,
-0.0004390705,
0.0384294614,
-0.0189909991,
0.0323815234,
0.0068513718,
-0.0387538858,
0.0195622798,
-0.046306923,
-0.006467477,
0.0014910762,
2.696e-7,
0.0338483155,
0.0608084649,
-0.0040318305,
0.0487048961,
-0.0031882185,
0.0400372781,
0.0030639609,
0.0425929427,
0.0223365985,
0.0175641477,
-0.0186475851,
0.0387114175,
0.0441020802,
0.0254210718,
-0.065138638,
-0.0091695394,
-0.024558749,
0.014921899,
-0.0740529969,
-0.0185512081,
0.0962440372,
0.117799595,
-0.0160615146,
-0.0280181207,
-0.0180885475,
-0.0305924825,
0.042832844,
-0.0552587621,
-0.0366487578,
0.043737907,
0.0605017766,
0.0947265774,
-0.0274461508,
0.051524125,
-0.0026788162,
-0.0007243878,
-0.0067292806,
0.099938795,
0.0015338943,
-0.0044291764,
0.0264810454,
-0.0266614873,
-0.0210940298,
-0.0377939716,
0.0452960059,
-0.0504336841,
-0.0108126951,
-0.0051324605,
-0.0449622497,
-0.0324889608,
0.0179526173,
-0.018116409,
-0.0139975064,
-0.0153337428,
0.0231291372,
-0.0169026535,
-0.0560418032,
-0.0628394932,
0.0022726862,
0.0056214798,
-0.0056096185,
-0.0217901468,
-0.0329494402,
0.0464661159,
0.0321093835,
-0.0570501164,
0.012410352,
1.978148985e-34,
0.030062018,
-0.0104589676,
-0.0054385471,
0.0073790387,
0.0337908864,
0.0267831646,
-0.0045411102,
0.0080053462,
-0.0352396071,
-0.0882461369,
0.0004932574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15293v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15293v1 | WC-SBERT: Zero-Shot Text Classification via SBERT with Self-Training for Wikipedia Categories | 2023-07-28T04:17:41 | 2023-07-28T04:17:41 | Te-Yu Chi, Yu-Meng Tang, Chia-Wen Lu, Qiu-Xia Zhang, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Our research focuses on solving the zero-shot text classification problem in
NLP, with a particular emphasis on innovative self-training strategies. To
achieve this objective, we propose a novel self-training strategy that uses
labels rather than text for training, significantly reducing the model's
training time. Specifically, we use categories from Wikipedia as our training
set and leverage the SBERT pre-trained model to establish positive correlations
between pairs of categories within the same text, facilitating associative
training. For new test datasets, we have improved the original self-training
approach, eliminating the need for prior training and testing data from each
target dataset. Instead, we adopt Wikipedia as a unified training dataset to
better approximate the zero-shot scenario. This modification allows for rapid
fine-tuning and inference across different datasets, greatly reducing the time
required for self-training. Our experimental results demonstrate that this
method can adapt the model to the target dataset within minutes. Compared to
other BERT-based transformer models, our approach significantly reduces the
amount of training data by training only on labels, not the actual text, and
greatly improves training efficiency by utilizing a unified training set.
Additionally, our method achieves state-of-the-art results on both the Yahoo
Topic and AG News datasets. | [
0.020493092,
0.0330394171,
0.018109506,
0.0104871672,
-0.0084891813,
0.0373647697,
0.0223173629,
0.0374862105,
0.0396993756,
-0.1057300046,
-0.0317004882,
0.0189131703,
-0.0160981864,
-0.0324700139,
-0.0011599837,
-0.0026408688,
0.0299330819,
0.0212866124,
-0.0284869187,
-0.0266248398,
0.0014419712,
0.018041715,
-0.0442580618,
-0.0308796391,
-0.0350925624,
-0.001827054,
-0.0173664931,
0.033768218,
0.0175339412,
-0.0224773381,
0.0584010445,
0.1004262939,
0.019446034,
0.019165786,
0.0000019229,
-0.069012098,
0.002076803,
-0.0213698912,
-0.0239017885,
-0.0108496156,
-0.0018071798,
-0.0481181368,
0.0226203911,
0.0068080029,
0.0063668685,
-0.0251877196,
0.0509370379,
0.068057999,
0.0461038984,
0.0717222467,
-0.0219712686,
-0.0758130252,
0.0463078842,
-0.0142663522,
0.0495535098,
0.006671777,
0.0439843573,
-0.0510361791,
-0.0549066067,
0.0112046227,
-0.0163344778,
0.0081786895,
0.0017610682,
0.0208414812,
0.0670325756,
0.0334714018,
-0.0744052902,
-0.0457017049,
0.0091277957,
0.0613173433,
-0.0105658956,
-0.0488978103,
0.0204429142,
0.0140904589,
-0.0261853524,
0.0291741695,
-0.0118468683,
0.007902056,
-0.0027325691,
0.0039453199,
0.0142907519,
0.0112287309,
-0.0054033464,
0.0157588366,
-0.0268376097,
0.0113631897,
0.0192008037,
-0.0319630615,
0.0152433226,
0.0428411514,
0.0062159123,
-0.0546061359,
-0.0234737284,
0.040446084,
0.0326525085,
0.0102951564,
-0.0217874162,
-0.0276651122,
0.0406132899,
-0.0744007304,
-0.0498385765,
0.0067793722,
-0.0021948505,
0.0512064174,
-0.0437610112,
0.0002051469,
0.0041145636,
0.0042226501,
-0.0070148543,
-0.0060625286,
-0.1083023995,
-0.0033400331,
-0.0662529767,
0.0532028414,
0.0393577255,
-0.0014878709,
-0.0372513793,
-0.0011409129,
0.0218372028,
-0.0026669467,
0.029950507,
-0.0160977896,
-0.0523014888,
0.0056024026,
-0.0096345553,
0.0538935885,
-0.0335334204,
0.0189608838,
-0.0471107513,
0.0415820219,
-0.0026477759,
0.0109257279,
0.0320566036,
-0.0274741929,
0.0202970728,
0.0220072102,
-0.0180389546,
-0.0626956224,
-0.0581671372,
-0.001898084,
-0.0246852506,
-0.0229392108,
0.0317503288,
-0.0705829933,
0.0191732496,
0.0319031551,
0.0099272626,
-0.0045981999,
0.0049002552,
0.0235570241,
-0.0391930975,
0.0963624343,
-0.0549685098,
-0.0032584651,
0.0424797796,
0.0257806983,
0.019575825,
0.106325157,
-0.0197383203,
0.0104835415,
0.0587539151,
0.0005883723,
0.0247325506,
0.016984446,
0.0382980146,
0.0142691294,
0.0153711997,
0.0230810884,
-0.0154888127,
0.0220114831,
0.0186564717,
-0.013109671,
-0.0145583954,
-0.0170419011,
0.045142062,
0.0543463267,
0.0618918464,
0.0421294793,
0.0022678617,
0.0176983848,
0.0194325186,
-0.0134943658,
-0.0082461946,
0.0101173399,
-0.0476488546,
0.0022381186,
-0.0137161249,
0.0043653175,
-0.0623511299,
0.0123288454,
-0.0158066023,
-0.0546003729,
-0.0021730538,
-0.0363938585,
0.0747872815,
0.03339798,
-0.0045239776,
0.1135002002,
0.0513753183,
-0.0398681946,
-0.0008966018,
-0.0303699393,
0.0195752252,
0.0189105533,
0.0336010568,
-0.0515093431,
-0.0301999226,
-0.0466554761,
0.0360243879,
0.0303575005,
0.0066141947,
-0.048676312,
-0.0092168562,
-0.0263976548,
-0.0243303794,
-0.0111006452,
0.0372066051,
-0.0195181593,
0.0189692993,
0.0511569008,
0.0296592806,
-0.0303636324,
0.0308076981,
0.0300228465,
-0.0036346528,
-0.0353927724,
0.0020621547,
0.0122844633,
-0.0224137884,
0.0120870741,
-0.0345356464,
-0.0227658916,
0.0316898488,
-0.0302942265,
-0.0505877957,
-0.0201147627,
0.0070520639,
-0.0776933879,
0.0409815162,
0.005232424,
-0.0027139783,
0.0576196462,
-0.0312702693,
-0.0083967894,
0.0001111548,
0.0080236597,
0.016746331,
-0.016854912,
0.0083096335,
-0.0060542682,
0.0033381358,
-0.0222350564,
0.0711869374,
0.0396579169,
0.016556805,
-0.0143563999,
-0.040066991,
0.0479121171,
0.000494894,
-0.0430806242,
0.02973851,
-0.0171130169,
0.0347304121,
0.033332482,
-0.0027732351,
-0.0603730567,
-0.0169348288,
-0.1139469147,
0.0167537816,
-0.0149065536,
0.0218241457,
0.0371589474,
-0.027717093,
0.0061666528,
0.0038211124,
-0.0163236912,
0.0110690715,
-0.0638618767,
0.0150892083,
0.0336657502,
-0.0226311088,
0.0048142602,
0.0119828889,
-0.0272303205,
-0.0428019315,
0.0697072297,
0.0066333879,
-0.0164342988,
-0.0042506945,
0.0127499206,
-0.0288802516,
-0.0061518322,
0.0140752643,
-0.0287791342,
-0.0166641362,
-0.0102530243,
-0.0091400957,
0.0353120044,
0.0460951179,
0.0113124577,
-0.0158354808,
0.0010180696,
-0.0365277901,
-0.0008551349,
-0.0250019766,
0.0131515851,
-0.01422993,
0.0054338924,
0.0001341129,
0.0825939402,
-0.0269946195,
-0.0152592305,
-0.0436412357,
-0.0060106269,
-0.0075709079,
0.0081363283,
-0.0546361096,
0.0110346992,
0.0275279935,
-0.0042999797,
-0.0109587591,
0.0174844787,
0.0520720035,
0.0007963256,
0.0082390187,
-0.0514703169,
0.0205852278,
-0.0296074562,
0.0553388447,
-0.0092783598,
0.0175474845,
0.0466058552,
0.0180421863,
-0.027783975,
0.0005121459,
-0.0046974295,
-0.0183982644,
0.0249849912,
0.0248272344,
0.0340521112,
-0.0462087989,
-0.0233638361,
-0.0215856098,
-0.0704765692,
0.0126105966,
0.0081099505,
-0.0500264987,
-0.0038859129,
-0.0187488068,
0.0029511065,
0.0005405088,
0.0385968611,
-0.0191678759,
-0.0317591392,
0.0119996779,
0.0794128105,
0.0364268906,
-0.0459061936,
-0.0584008619,
0.0296226107,
0.0096816206,
0.0293949787,
0.0164066628,
0.0299267489,
-0.0147354919,
-0.0105808498,
0.0129825752,
-0.0937062204,
-0.0045379563,
-0.0467959903,
0.0079266904,
-0.0059009865,
-0.0188571326,
0.1174624041,
0.0477047265,
-0.052906774,
-0.0272801723,
-0.0242780186,
-0.0183396339,
0.0297642238,
0.01372243,
-0.070204556,
-0.0531554744,
-0.0317430571,
0.0079080649,
0.0114416946,
-0.0440079756,
0.0145263961,
-0.0968774259,
-0.0255066808,
-0.0181324054,
-0.0044425502,
0.0027358339,
-0.0867385343,
-0.0076862648,
-0.0378063321,
-0.0345834531,
-0.0115805101,
-0.0087464722,
0.0120669296,
0.0146734128,
-0.014192991,
-0.0651127771,
0.0355367959,
-0.0117894048,
0.0519053824,
-0.000244777,
0.0266969409,
-0.0299501065,
0.0179105289,
0.0205465853,
-0.0610731579,
-0.0244160891,
-0.0146183902,
0.1061893627,
-0.0526390001,
-0.000608206,
0.0144065982,
-0.0145399636,
-0.0307186823,
-0.0409248956,
-0.0060983426,
0.056960579,
0.0355413929,
-0.0141485455,
-0.0391933285,
-0.0252190698,
0.0236087646,
0.0690106004,
0.0026867716,
-0.0416252241,
-0.0010640984,
-0.0030260808,
-0.0232053567,
-0.022690976,
-0.068027854,
0.0072335321,
-0.0091487085,
-0.086262472,
-0.0683922544,
-0.0446718633,
0.0255515631,
0.0344550386,
-0.0194068663,
-0.0258612689,
-0.0215755012,
0.0115620028,
-0.0888760164,
0.0314582177,
-0.0277726576,
-0.0196255762,
-0.0232425909,
-0.0234289318,
0.0895667747,
-0.0213421471,
-0.0089771487,
-0.0333773792,
-0.0417113975,
-0.0452782139,
-0.0063698804,
0.0437713414,
0.0209908299,
0.0239640679,
-0.0036712929,
-0.0570216477,
0.0948777646,
0.1220116988,
-0.0451588146,
0.0018010422,
0.0230302718,
0.0131429518,
-0.0019501151,
0.0371480808,
-0.0287391394,
0.045846764,
-0.0134726753,
0.0122829862,
-0.0389352664,
0.0161606632,
0.0048414222,
0.0040880865,
0.0572527871,
0.0007497121,
-0.0022065865,
-0.0392413661,
0.0129125994,
0.000468217,
-0.0125133358,
0.0166098457,
0.0133518446,
0.0271056816,
-0.0420979671,
-0.0231373385,
0.0562990718,
-0.041863896,
0.0114227375,
-0.0459306128,
-0.0191468764,
0.0335512459,
0.0394010507,
-0.0100576058,
-0.0019974548,
-0.0205402151,
-0.0572169796,
0.0414028615,
-0.0133707672,
-0.0402914174,
0.0302657876,
0.0148274023,
0.0150856683,
-0.0079008704,
0.0291306227,
-0.0449720323,
0.0100971833,
-0.0138743473,
-0.0039075748,
0.0459929891,
-0.0309682433,
0.0400037952,
-0.022090489,
-0.0465221666,
-0.0038216501,
0.0240772627,
-0.0099571534,
0.0182856489,
0.0212136712,
0.0143174166,
-0.0141084502,
0.0228722934,
0.0739321336,
0.0150176175,
0.044919651,
0.032353919,
-0.0228184666,
-0.0266261529,
0.0080232183,
0.0265996568,
-0.0105998535,
-0.0201020595,
-0.0131978039,
-0.0075201038,
-0.0477702841,
0.0577813052,
-0.0511742346,
0.0153852385,
0.0354007632,
0.0372164063,
0.0536562018,
0.0324332528,
0.0171905588,
-0.0257496648,
0.0139549859,
-0.0038362418,
-0.0086880559,
-0.032730829,
-6.521843962e-33,
-0.0029350172,
-0.001997039,
0.0027051445,
-0.0043657748,
0.0198332537,
0.0217058845,
-0.0086898608,
0.0176884308,
-0.0292179845,
0.021065861,
-0.010414659,
0.005859327,
-0.0054394654,
0.0009513539,
0.00202513,
-0.0316516422,
0.0275202841,
-0.0047965916,
-0.0390172563,
0.0076655764,
0.012789797,
0.0297885351,
0.0862797722,
-0.0806188658,
-0.0100204544,
0.0039404505,
-0.0064121298,
-0.0092718368,
0.0838298425,
0.0503278337,
-0.0139051713,
0.0796050057,
0.0526486821,
-0.0280303508,
0.0351046547,
0.0254470687,
-0.0927919745,
-0.0414756574,
-0.0582524948,
0.0086813495,
-0.0099465763,
0.002306839,
0.0294388626,
0.0074462662,
0.0020052199,
-0.0415116809,
0.0606577583,
0.0074430257,
0.0019654774,
-0.0405461565,
-0.0543744415,
0.0145063726,
0.009958745,
-0.0422939807,
0.0114636319,
0.0447724499,
0.0557610132,
0.0134202503,
-0.0808098316,
0.0209715776,
-0.0225485899,
0.0335696675,
0.0125267496,
-0.0358292125,
-0.0153214503,
0.0419531167,
0.0078957016,
0.0270424969,
-0.0304967128,
-0.0220033526,
0.0352298878,
0.0125075737,
0.0383458436,
0.0540711395,
0.0763074681,
-0.0311780069,
-0.0907981992,
0.0493744351,
0.0063170036,
0.0188191999,
-0.0131339142,
-0.0059678759,
-0.013469032,
-0.003165124,
-0.0194282327,
-0.0208065566,
-0.0458315238,
-0.0117158815,
-0.0115262466,
0.0448780954,
-0.040247675,
0.064087674,
0.0033613078,
-0.0406258889,
-0.0439933911,
0.0436795689,
-0.0162265487,
0.0597300716,
-0.0100829145,
-0.0189905018,
-0.0678926632,
-0.0382106528,
0.0393567905,
0.035024818,
0.0393839106,
0.0168125555,
0.0708770007,
0.0315889716,
-0.0547204502,
-0.01075425,
-0.0078080902,
-0.0351019911,
-0.0154142966,
0.0159920938,
-0.0057269018,
0.0425141044,
0.0074653225,
0.0466258042,
0.0663519129,
-0.0086651044,
-0.0022959202,
-0.0289382655,
0.01965186,
0.0094168261,
0.0198049322,
-0.0165988188,
0.0139379445,
0.0131505877,
-0.0011576014,
-0.0715365261,
-0.0141455866,
-0.0439387709,
2.726e-7,
0.0607241802,
0.0539190397,
-0.0109361382,
-0.0051537692,
0.0245226771,
0.0391495042,
-0.0108236661,
0.0688688755,
-0.0059553506,
-0.0326860696,
0.0131942183,
0.0312639512,
-0.0141413836,
0.0199373811,
-0.0784008205,
-0.0573808812,
-0.0307717919,
0.0359630138,
-0.0596376956,
0.0002746305,
0.0692995712,
0.06231042,
0.0261999201,
-0.0152341342,
-0.0081822136,
-0.0276218541,
0.0920367017,
0.0081411051,
0.0290654805,
0.0403380245,
0.0114787938,
0.0458977185,
-0.0126073901,
0.0287114084,
-0.0548285693,
-0.0000117088,
-0.0167326853,
0.013744981,
-0.0504192486,
-0.0383539833,
0.025914453,
-0.0221908726,
0.0054139346,
-0.0265266057,
0.0902778804,
-0.0757381916,
-0.021658197,
0.0278722141,
-0.04401372,
0.0283845756,
0.0366246253,
-0.0196289234,
-0.0473948494,
0.0123858079,
0.0158067346,
0.0327188149,
-0.0315294936,
-0.1019569561,
-0.0038765536,
0.0136561543,
-0.0203041043,
0.0091329496,
-0.0080337273,
-0.0150779169,
0.0286197178,
-0.0772626996,
0.040216282,
2.477544903e-34,
0.0102419257,
0.004189725,
-0.0172677916,
0.0168165807,
-0.004967662,
-0.0400582254,
-0.051104337,
-0.0322337709,
0.0076219402,
-0.0227457099,
0.0081053786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15290v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15290v1 | ChatHome: Development and Evaluation of a Domain-Specific Language Model for Home Renovation | 2023-07-28T04:04:43 | 2023-07-28T04:04:43 | Cheng Wen, Xianghui Sun, Shuaijiang Zhao, Xiaoquan Fang, Liangyu Chen, Wei Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the development and evaluation of ChatHome, a
domain-specific language model (DSLM) designed for the intricate field of home
renovation. Considering the proven competencies of large language models (LLMs)
like GPT-4 and the escalating fascination with home renovation, this study
endeavors to reconcile these aspects by generating a dedicated model that can
yield high-fidelity, precise outputs relevant to the home renovation arena.
ChatHome's novelty rests on its methodology, fusing domain-adaptive pretraining
and instruction-tuning over an extensive dataset. This dataset includes
professional articles, standard documents, and web content pertinent to home
renovation. This dual-pronged strategy is designed to ensure that our model can
assimilate comprehensive domain knowledge and effectively address user
inquiries. Via thorough experimentation on diverse datasets, both universal and
domain-specific, including the freshly introduced "EvalHome" domain dataset, we
substantiate that ChatHome not only amplifies domain-specific functionalities
but also preserves its versatility. | [
0.0213682577,
0.080539763,
-0.0287814382,
0.0132289715,
-0.0281637441,
0.003770947,
0.0109890075,
0.008274572,
-0.0228654444,
-0.051517874,
-0.0918643102,
-0.0101006739,
-0.0145780118,
0.0151801454,
-0.0105225034,
-0.0321300775,
0.0006176361,
0.0061746659,
-0.0149446288,
-0.0148106096,
-0.0068673235,
0.0281347372,
-0.0258937273,
0.0388500392,
-0.0006404543,
-0.0372869559,
-0.022389207,
-0.0052196584,
-0.0179182645,
0.0016999159,
0.0672474056,
0.103160359,
0.0445944183,
0.0496424474,
0.0000022693,
-0.0232824143,
-0.0245617051,
-0.0288647544,
0.0226415191,
-0.019567119,
0.0820170417,
-0.0416799076,
-0.0127284303,
-0.0051525314,
-0.039540831,
-0.0306355618,
0.0370523669,
0.0641072989,
0.0175504647,
0.0837247893,
-0.012346168,
-0.0914695263,
0.0029068466,
-0.0445151813,
0.0111557664,
-0.0363253243,
0.038315881,
0.0151031204,
0.0213907789,
0.0053803227,
-0.0291025303,
0.0321314596,
0.0048947991,
-0.002794821,
0.0114139495,
-0.0055814902,
0.000290195,
0.0113799246,
-0.0249132961,
0.0525676347,
-0.005528158,
0.0024438852,
0.0206622388,
-0.001928514,
0.003373126,
0.0021731192,
-0.0521432795,
-0.0165970456,
0.0292944387,
-0.0064776749,
-0.0385874137,
-0.0084246956,
0.0019903407,
0.0010530452,
0.0174539853,
0.0464881435,
-0.0007787143,
0.0062106503,
-0.0217785947,
0.0302269626,
0.0444579534,
-0.0489107408,
0.0234053172,
0.0328981355,
-0.0219306387,
0.0252387933,
-0.0299300365,
0.0220282301,
0.0195116252,
-0.039988257,
0.0132670607,
0.0094833532,
-0.0289791375,
0.0508369058,
0.0008719642,
0.0487553626,
0.0120740552,
0.0153577561,
-0.0734642372,
0.0381100178,
-0.0969005451,
-0.0024742435,
-0.0606884509,
0.017444564,
-0.0489042997,
-0.0166307073,
-0.0275174454,
0.015590718,
0.0082257064,
-0.0045775408,
0.0375002511,
0.021346787,
-0.0769366547,
-0.0673391372,
-0.0106256669,
-0.0073111146,
-0.0274370108,
0.0642704368,
-0.0352315381,
-0.039679274,
0.0381047614,
0.0303978566,
-0.0290681235,
-0.0332178921,
-0.0161312204,
0.0461846814,
-0.0154355317,
-0.0100601139,
-0.0325393565,
-0.040372923,
0.0140326545,
-0.0288269557,
0.037522193,
-0.0418962017,
-0.0195079688,
-0.0018611487,
0.0069678617,
-0.0756641105,
-0.0413177162,
-0.0332339779,
-0.0165599827,
0.0705456659,
-0.0628277436,
0.0197612066,
0.0644652396,
0.0174111072,
0.0030017721,
0.0698748678,
-0.0132795768,
0.058558289,
0.0260420125,
0.0169453286,
0.02189002,
0.0181936789,
-0.0305875018,
0.0167822335,
0.0048465105,
0.0191167947,
0.0159733165,
-0.0051352782,
0.0039869468,
0.0063106674,
0.039805945,
0.0317904241,
0.052304443,
0.0155789182,
0.024946671,
0.0369946621,
0.0378707759,
0.0619749799,
-0.0004022703,
-0.0113802487,
-0.0239013527,
-0.0116712265,
-0.0010344408,
0.0167493895,
-0.0245780312,
0.0121880267,
-0.034470994,
-0.0415211506,
0.011063084,
-0.021286035,
0.013679605,
-0.0063874773,
0.0675118119,
0.0302509964,
-0.0336633697,
0.0188098792,
0.0144630829,
0.0068950322,
0.0239124205,
-0.0652342588,
-0.0155189903,
0.1269046366,
0.0289520696,
-0.0343039259,
-0.0288302433,
-0.0047128201,
0.0625476837,
0.0305811893,
0.0633662567,
-0.0141978748,
0.0080508422,
-0.037863031,
-0.0725557506,
-0.044865042,
0.0524582304,
0.0230349395,
-0.0110711847,
-0.0123579148,
0.0162260626,
-0.0464907996,
-0.0480853729,
0.0384848155,
0.0206595119,
-0.0282485355,
-0.0227011554,
-0.0055508697,
-0.0290286485,
0.0035458368,
-0.0085429903,
-0.034123268,
0.015196003,
-0.0181236565,
-0.0508881882,
0.017810367,
-0.0516093485,
0.0113249775,
0.0234923735,
-0.0350502543,
0.0139199374,
0.0280182883,
-0.0846136361,
-0.0094918488,
0.0122146225,
-0.0132378722,
0.0233988538,
-0.0308681391,
0.0165742338,
-0.0055577252,
-0.0607092865,
-0.0726109818,
0.0661193579,
0.0101060588,
-0.0020057454,
-0.0176761411,
0.0102077667,
-0.005197288,
-0.0081394417,
-0.0197964981,
-0.0365706272,
-0.0167853814,
0.0566179045,
-0.0009053555,
0.0745914876,
-0.0353861377,
0.013122526,
-0.0797545239,
-0.059093181,
-0.0509350337,
0.0154272867,
0.0398856588,
-0.025941154,
-0.0266796462,
-0.0521313772,
-0.011973084,
0.026203502,
-0.032803189,
0.0159121584,
0.0605047233,
-0.0089345742,
-0.0272393506,
-0.0406299792,
-0.0212167818,
0.0298285652,
-0.0128356367,
0.0608694516,
-0.0045927949,
-0.0554178096,
0.0197021421,
0.0190712251,
-0.0021760256,
0.0082964143,
-0.0705648288,
-0.0290041678,
-0.0047458224,
0.0445250869,
-0.0096235499,
-0.0182690304,
-0.0036148478,
0.0308690537,
-0.0357107185,
-0.04531442,
-0.0014677799,
-0.0497387089,
-0.0515998639,
-0.0317390412,
0.0167973507,
0.0451439917,
0.0458672605,
-0.0311799608,
-0.0027214172,
-0.0523736738,
0.0185345709,
-0.032800056,
-0.0071728462,
-0.0122556547,
0.0048444825,
0.0107709831,
0.0697957873,
0.0103855887,
-0.0514017008,
0.0388875864,
0.0156005528,
0.0110539328,
-0.0821812525,
-0.0050995885,
-0.0482817143,
-0.0043600183,
-0.0041075121,
0.0144639239,
0.050602179,
-0.043389596,
-0.0332685374,
0.01326402,
0.0350381024,
0.0014510463,
0.0587230325,
-0.0883216038,
0.0176738314,
-0.0044448636,
-0.0569533966,
-0.0366732925,
-0.0078618042,
-0.0125722969,
-0.0111758336,
0.0059936084,
0.0120875156,
-0.0515428446,
0.0084143961,
-0.040847633,
0.0704687983,
0.008170668,
-0.0147770634,
-0.0084534865,
0.0182419121,
0.0371035859,
0.0405140147,
-0.0900782496,
-0.0091751236,
-0.0328239985,
0.0012346263,
0.0123131508,
-0.0005769548,
-0.0557512529,
0.0420892648,
0.0258475766,
-0.0528951585,
-0.0327901952,
0.0219971538,
-0.0091929985,
-0.0426533036,
-0.0152441245,
0.0831970051,
0.0202181749,
-0.0406933278,
-0.0099672712,
-0.0201498438,
-0.0034769287,
0.0142015461,
0.0019866964,
-0.060968481,
-0.0333444998,
0.0063079866,
0.0262130201,
0.0703491569,
0.0172481593,
-0.010155553,
-0.0639553294,
0.0413454995,
-0.0071442476,
-0.027993707,
-0.032365445,
0.0042659719,
-0.0020148105,
-0.0366477631,
-0.0347940475,
-0.0033946261,
-0.0413143374,
0.0110722808,
0.0247593839,
-0.0240870118,
-0.0914334655,
0.0274725631,
-0.0087728752,
0.0528825559,
0.0884835869,
0.0006313577,
0.0355797224,
-0.0220819321,
0.0679225549,
0.0098745059,
0.01944183,
-0.026892256,
0.045295231,
0.0156043032,
0.0182245262,
0.051065594,
0.0363687612,
-0.0780336261,
0.0214955583,
0.0562144555,
0.0488683246,
-0.0380286239,
0.0317758881,
-0.0150687881,
-0.0047993986,
0.0488516837,
0.0366919972,
-0.0041987821,
-0.0323784947,
-0.0295955986,
-0.0325583294,
-0.0410145447,
0.0068975282,
-0.0444281884,
0.0034940576,
-0.0732628033,
-0.0213599764,
-0.0738766193,
-0.0469084866,
0.0278004352,
0.0073117423,
0.0479914211,
-0.0402947664,
-0.0067273527,
0.0229331013,
-0.0456319377,
0.0150501821,
-0.0529137738,
0.0257261582,
-0.0676980391,
-0.0134798931,
0.0810954124,
-0.0470547378,
-0.0162600931,
-0.0104830507,
-0.0278768502,
-0.0041596638,
0.0367131233,
0.0636754557,
0.0238468144,
0.0073890295,
-0.0110778967,
-0.0431168638,
-0.0146854958,
0.0083787832,
-0.0645284876,
-0.0336802118,
0.0637582019,
0.0007879025,
0.0058921203,
0.0420076251,
-0.0261850879,
0.0710641146,
0.0021058179,
0.0446799845,
-0.0030598217,
0.0116054323,
0.013627816,
-0.0210220441,
0.0281374063,
0.0006568073,
-0.0132444697,
-0.0376685858,
0.0313391611,
0.0086680185,
-0.006747352,
-0.0237572026,
0.0102891754,
0.0437370948,
-0.0010468094,
0.0016509654,
0.0446627252,
-0.0232271012,
0.0382212587,
-0.0583850816,
-0.0089209741,
0.0025661495,
0.0398800708,
0.0414541326,
0.0332153849,
0.0179339517,
0.0480074473,
0.0166647006,
0.0296862144,
-0.0054037254,
0.0391983911,
0.0027389785,
0.0229368173,
-0.0445463955,
0.0415974408,
0.0128174378,
-0.0383020379,
-0.0234993435,
0.046768494,
0.0486109257,
0.009159537,
0.0271807481,
-0.0252961386,
0.0207651127,
-0.0599368252,
0.0367262065,
0.0487472862,
-0.025161203,
0.0072307596,
0.0030991747,
-0.0240140334,
-0.017731145,
0.0825942382,
-0.0009330012,
0.0320094712,
-0.0121312868,
-0.0157710146,
-0.0470338725,
-0.0349870659,
0.0311266389,
0.032556802,
-0.0322239026,
-0.0299003143,
-0.0481199771,
-0.0079715466,
-0.0487144738,
-0.0297872424,
0.0102916164,
-0.0062699742,
0.0847326219,
0.0877250209,
-0.0311160963,
-0.0076601407,
-0.0280107353,
-0.0051576965,
-0.0093750963,
0.0210763104,
-0.0225198809,
-6.082568702e-33,
-0.0010434337,
-0.0242824331,
0.0429343693,
0.0012725126,
0.0194769483,
-0.0088548046,
0.0082551874,
-0.0099548064,
0.0087678414,
-0.0162194856,
0.0002639772,
-0.0084744217,
0.0276969392,
0.0353449993,
0.070810169,
0.008604819,
0.0699836612,
-0.035594359,
-0.017091481,
0.0086972667,
-0.03138154,
0.043343965,
0.0829388648,
-0.0857539922,
-0.021234436,
0.008953833,
-0.0006517284,
0.0219331924,
0.0570138507,
0.0225992147,
-0.0218245909,
0.0348053947,
0.0254935827,
-0.0580198914,
-0.0373955294,
-0.0320868418,
-0.0940806195,
-0.0271172095,
0.0177030805,
0.037926618,
-0.0055635329,
-0.0166228693,
0.0160650294,
0.0050955876,
-0.0357784443,
-0.0032910162,
0.075298965,
-0.0376158021,
0.0183213912,
0.0239289664,
-0.1237774938,
0.0339219794,
0.0119498856,
-0.021624729,
0.0425377004,
0.0156546645,
0.0150282234,
0.0205176231,
-0.0763076246,
0.0224994179,
0.0658417791,
0.0522709712,
0.1098078266,
-0.0273950119,
-0.047161039,
0.0236926619,
0.0297667067,
0.0261208825,
0.0445003062,
-0.0037135398,
0.019989375,
0.0560579859,
-0.0008295254,
0.0284686312,
0.0301212575,
0.014137784,
-0.0137975169,
0.0379435606,
-0.0019491669,
0.0492881685,
-0.0022776339,
0.041933354,
0.0004259057,
-0.0132968547,
-0.0106435996,
0.0297243688,
-0.0212760326,
-0.0335919447,
0.0307194777,
0.0126311816,
0.0118974224,
0.0001707483,
-0.0046087559,
-0.0159394387,
-0.0418835692,
0.0084728664,
-0.0427654311,
-0.0094583007,
-0.0146181276,
0.0522901863,
-0.0335037522,
-0.0084126024,
0.0144067528,
0.0861954391,
-0.0149912937,
-0.007669759,
-0.0022755063,
0.052534733,
-0.0321360677,
0.0049400986,
0.0017803193,
-0.0308146775,
-0.0159839485,
0.0567734167,
0.0370398201,
-0.0134250289,
-0.0405587107,
0.0634660423,
0.0084275594,
-0.0298938397,
-0.0238347929,
-0.0068383915,
0.0008907783,
0.0010628569,
-0.0258421674,
-0.0011317473,
-0.0502404943,
-0.0474651866,
0.0587920211,
-0.0344202593,
-0.0128322039,
-0.0113136964,
2.826e-7,
0.0254506767,
0.070541434,
0.0140431235,
0.0258228015,
-0.00778428,
0.0270904247,
-0.0143441074,
0.0116268508,
0.0022995637,
0.0294436179,
0.0443571955,
-0.0058998652,
0.0679635182,
-0.0102002183,
-0.0801780894,
-0.016780939,
-0.0158123877,
0.020981444,
-0.0959926248,
-0.0240119305,
0.0340672657,
0.0485187061,
-0.0115017258,
-0.0197404418,
0.0134258997,
-0.032025598,
0.0006878112,
-0.0459706746,
0.0182450134,
0.055831518,
0.0058512925,
0.035694737,
-0.009579353,
-0.0310723837,
-0.0444928743,
0.003964812,
0.0283463933,
0.0669658482,
-0.0009728132,
-0.0144002615,
0.0240909234,
-0.0218196232,
-0.007669047,
-0.0368724428,
0.0251393206,
-0.074454926,
0.0013250461,
0.0377668254,
-0.0229950137,
-0.0098391781,
-0.0049519902,
-0.0087078633,
-0.0371776186,
0.0067181056,
0.0322906524,
-0.0062565813,
-0.0489403345,
-0.0750926509,
0.0424307734,
0.0072820075,
-0.074819915,
-0.0052400422,
-0.0388364717,
-0.004921386,
-0.0205363575,
-0.0381896123,
0.0020401583,
2.263481412e-34,
0.0105033889,
-0.002343453,
-0.0160079487,
0.0367214158,
0.0003819357,
0.0250248499,
-0.0093836421,
0.0121672489,
-0.0033049514,
-0.0793394148,
0.0156241814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15286v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15286v1 | Multilingual Lexical Simplification via Paraphrase Generation | 2023-07-28T03:47:44 | 2023-07-28T03:47:44 | Kang Liu, Jipeng Qiang, Yun Li, Yunhao Yuan, Yi Zhu, Kaixun Hua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexical simplification (LS) methods based on pretrained language models have
made remarkable progress, generating potential substitutes for a complex word
through analysis of its contextual surroundings. However, these methods require
separate pretrained models for different languages and disregard the
preservation of sentence meaning. In this paper, we propose a novel
multilingual LS method via paraphrase generation, as paraphrases provide
diversity in word selection while preserving the sentence's meaning. We regard
paraphrasing as a zero-shot translation task within multilingual neural machine
translation that supports hundreds of languages. After feeding the input
sentence into the encoder of paraphrase modeling, we generate the substitutes
based on a novel decoding strategy that concentrates solely on the lexical
variations of the complex word. Experimental results demonstrate that our
approach surpasses BERT-based methods and zero-shot GPT3-based method
significantly on English, Spanish, and Portuguese. | [
0.0217609089,
0.0304401368,
-0.0055378471,
0.0404169448,
-0.0478644744,
-0.001703303,
0.0043817372,
0.0290179644,
-0.0428986624,
-0.0224667806,
-0.0205190647,
0.0395865738,
0.0152959488,
-0.0642615333,
0.0361358449,
-0.0628234521,
0.0506654643,
-0.0084931422,
-0.0431771055,
-0.0021145381,
-0.01324757,
0.0528254062,
0.0320368372,
0.0443577543,
0.0353024304,
-0.0005076265,
0.0273494702,
0.0216769017,
0.0096822726,
-0.0013387527,
0.0282353424,
0.0089820474,
0.0083738035,
0.0291704759,
0.0000018733,
-0.0201648735,
-0.0421504304,
-0.0177193545,
0.0140092866,
0.0400399901,
0.0810336024,
-0.043620728,
0.0148656946,
0.0098511996,
-0.0309755635,
-0.0173777938,
0.0447511114,
-0.0106880367,
0.0485887527,
0.0439867117,
-0.0342737734,
-0.0724922642,
-0.0491789915,
-0.0313257687,
-0.0004504366,
-0.0302241929,
-0.0138053568,
-0.0157263186,
-0.0379807241,
-0.0253985263,
-0.0450852476,
0.0505668595,
0.0127979834,
0.0286003686,
-0.0072903391,
-0.0031539642,
-0.0106679993,
-0.0200849921,
-0.0057057026,
0.084146753,
-0.1192794591,
-0.0541937798,
-0.0137982937,
-0.0225041006,
-0.011626292,
0.0067505478,
-0.066459097,
0.0057853023,
0.0241745673,
0.0332625769,
0.0020035752,
0.0069139902,
0.023567697,
0.0320611186,
-0.0192855783,
-0.010196765,
0.0747427642,
-0.0261240304,
-0.0336142667,
-0.0034253057,
-0.0212921817,
-0.0207584351,
0.034878578,
0.0011574841,
-0.0223286711,
0.0256069936,
-0.0731751174,
-0.1044336781,
0.0328771546,
-0.0667472035,
0.0557835773,
0.0557980575,
0.0238414183,
0.0426271185,
-0.0581470802,
0.0334498025,
-0.044132188,
0.0172607843,
-0.0656568184,
-0.0370175876,
-0.0227460228,
0.0248482227,
-0.0609631352,
0.0462690517,
-0.0465260521,
-0.0286997762,
-0.0434725955,
0.0019011848,
0.0413118042,
-0.0487940311,
0.0202184115,
0.0228513516,
-0.0411434881,
-0.0259093717,
0.0215556193,
0.0720096901,
-0.0260221288,
0.0145992441,
-0.0380563177,
-0.0618193187,
-0.0452678241,
0.0209293701,
0.0556477159,
-0.0411206037,
0.0229995977,
0.0408067778,
-0.0325133353,
-0.0422198027,
-0.035089165,
-0.0314428248,
-0.0058807987,
-0.0414474159,
-0.0081875911,
-0.058261361,
0.0647164881,
-0.0338701755,
-0.0008628516,
-0.0395848081,
0.0187923498,
0.02924118,
-0.0486414693,
0.0559135303,
-0.0305214748,
-0.0236308444,
-0.0116508007,
-0.014889922,
0.0090739531,
0.0399533398,
0.0372296982,
0.0061495863,
0.0499521755,
0.0258230623,
-0.0050686514,
0.0386863425,
0.0252026077,
0.0211087484,
-0.0131218778,
-0.01968766,
-0.0233992729,
0.0230711401,
0.0575863831,
0.0490254685,
-0.0734244287,
0.0097485967,
0.0592381768,
0.0578324012,
-0.0116974246,
0.0627553016,
0.0915764123,
0.0205112025,
0.0009035416,
0.011725598,
0.017173199,
0.0002041627,
-0.0053475513,
0.0377043299,
-0.000610459,
0.0589677654,
-0.0238588229,
-0.0153109524,
0.0189321749,
-0.0412867777,
0.0335185789,
-0.0133756073,
0.0074692881,
0.0311843529,
-0.0948102549,
0.0930459052,
-0.0149342827,
-0.0743310004,
0.0153460773,
-0.0142103629,
-0.022008827,
0.0970603898,
0.0661816522,
0.019675903,
-0.0522642136,
-0.0069984165,
0.0022910249,
0.0394257233,
0.0398159139,
0.0027280303,
0.0646657124,
-0.1029430032,
-0.0063028769,
-0.0464113466,
-0.0046065636,
0.0349739306,
0.0283521116,
0.0045992397,
0.0498223379,
-0.0289442893,
-0.0398480892,
0.0309642553,
-0.0512456894,
-0.040625982,
0.0375701599,
0.0080466988,
0.0064512938,
0.0162295364,
0.009239614,
0.0159490183,
0.0028250406,
-0.05246998,
-0.0194035191,
0.0502928495,
-0.0372342467,
-0.0774322301,
0.0095516713,
-0.0561430678,
-0.008638395,
0.0279628299,
-0.0158878099,
-0.0432659797,
0.0155661562,
-0.0446978435,
0.0528128669,
-0.0523761064,
0.0456215031,
-0.0238768104,
0.0549993478,
-0.0131840473,
0.0292147975,
0.0054936251,
-0.0011149242,
0.0586378612,
-0.0178320613,
0.0542384237,
-0.0050635925,
-0.0134175848,
-0.0025808052,
0.0164697263,
-0.0008117105,
0.0200317297,
0.0462025106,
-0.0013808715,
-0.0037366275,
-0.0965017676,
0.016007401,
-0.0033914356,
-0.0063122767,
0.0567961186,
0.0552222989,
0.0151381074,
-0.0279481411,
0.0295218267,
0.0118004708,
0.0141545814,
0.0087260762,
0.0411343724,
-0.0147747817,
-0.0110279405,
-0.0383225717,
0.0082523413,
0.0203555636,
0.0718010291,
-0.0007908745,
-0.0126283681,
-0.0111677237,
0.0029082277,
-0.0338680521,
0.002117394,
0.0475123264,
-0.057617344,
-0.0335391015,
-0.0058561219,
0.0264297687,
0.0500225052,
-0.001609171,
-0.0250878315,
0.043309059,
0.0080931792,
-0.0408717729,
-0.0067494349,
-0.0001843464,
-0.0390352868,
-0.012706494,
-0.0286449455,
0.0303490572,
0.0196129102,
0.0427414253,
-0.0108121829,
-0.0881926492,
0.0132566141,
0.0294006858,
-0.0295651257,
-0.0034362928,
0.0021270853,
-0.021809034,
0.005838457,
-0.0381971933,
-0.0114713516,
0.0573357381,
-0.0048373831,
-0.0134596219,
-0.0718260184,
0.0225787573,
-0.0279493146,
0.0155654298,
-0.0502041467,
0.0558422171,
-0.0158986058,
0.0040525114,
-0.0396333225,
-0.047550492,
0.020585604,
-0.0124446787,
0.0109302271,
-0.0688210651,
-0.0026508442,
0.0092400014,
-0.0394583791,
-0.0055836416,
-0.0396587513,
0.0041057398,
0.0008881202,
0.0166753028,
-0.0059623243,
0.0031222557,
-0.0497832,
0.0064164847,
0.0797253698,
-0.0109940646,
0.0086717773,
-0.0329811722,
0.0371655934,
0.0326895118,
-0.0041188146,
0.0052120318,
-0.0296898168,
0.0103091383,
-0.0031753783,
0.0098401541,
-0.0064242459,
-0.0184201151,
0.0048326193,
0.0206651352,
-0.0300727561,
-0.0110034179,
-0.0210423134,
0.0027613023,
-0.0197990648,
0.0067887837,
0.0965263695,
0.0167193301,
-0.0331360102,
0.0104203941,
-0.0322124064,
0.0244619716,
-0.0025489645,
0.0200977623,
-0.082117185,
-0.0282579437,
-0.0201637112,
-0.0243788883,
0.0259707458,
0.0029096315,
-0.0380047783,
-0.0855658352,
0.0103611154,
0.0322397351,
-0.0508839153,
-0.027306892,
0.0137582067,
-0.0233054552,
0.0028482794,
0.0268368665,
-0.006373927,
-0.0101908203,
0.0026825934,
-0.0432010069,
0.0089765433,
-0.0878174454,
-0.0122035388,
-0.0495385379,
-0.0188419428,
0.0460526571,
0.0501023196,
0.0203079861,
0.008975408,
0.0253808629,
-0.0164611582,
-0.0136045385,
-0.0081974668,
0.027811395,
0.0231745895,
-0.0131088775,
0.0283221789,
-0.0009975046,
-0.0284782089,
0.0011753144,
0.0196068231,
0.0342366546,
0.0355177969,
-0.0070802458,
0.0196942668,
-0.010531975,
-0.0015179079,
0.0673733354,
0.0409033857,
-0.0177444201,
-0.0474392697,
0.0183230266,
-0.0276917815,
-0.1086176634,
-0.023324538,
0.0046631019,
-0.0598514676,
-0.0412145928,
-0.0621704571,
-0.0530326478,
0.0004547668,
0.0073774727,
0.0328209996,
0.0452778302,
0.0078281127,
-0.0065752584,
-0.0113591366,
-0.0133627448,
-0.0272233952,
0.0164077394,
0.024985496,
0.0171033293,
0.0197042413,
-0.0095859496,
0.0106973946,
0.0067213988,
-0.068795681,
-0.0474360064,
-0.0220199358,
0.072596401,
0.0186296515,
0.0469094813,
-0.0134200351,
-0.0126696462,
0.0510203876,
0.0019541364,
-0.0137048569,
0.060022343,
0.0430312157,
0.0291967429,
-0.000237625,
0.0666402876,
-0.0060319887,
-0.0077739991,
0.0252632052,
0.0686973557,
-0.0068548648,
-0.0335683823,
0.0213359855,
-0.0003487054,
-0.0265099742,
-0.045270592,
0.0152466083,
-0.0047099236,
0.0066478741,
-0.027749477,
0.0054786992,
-0.0405700952,
0.0142622795,
0.0573422275,
0.0093049463,
-0.0174928997,
0.0122315306,
-0.0467667207,
-0.0203140844,
0.0036465519,
-0.0394514948,
-0.0193687286,
-0.0116499653,
-0.0137779834,
0.0114183491,
-0.0207210556,
-0.003735641,
-0.0643804371,
-0.0325672217,
-0.0522737801,
-0.0034816037,
-0.0017770351,
-0.019730119,
-0.0794884488,
0.0530988239,
-0.0262027774,
-0.025363123,
-0.0154686058,
0.0433185138,
0.0898297653,
-0.0012516396,
0.1011902913,
0.0022958808,
-0.0417920128,
0.0166736934,
0.0502437428,
-0.0238152072,
0.005624583,
-0.0287596397,
-0.0162733048,
0.0047092764,
0.0140946517,
0.0793564543,
0.0062407539,
0.0493182242,
0.0024870399,
-0.0134811793,
-0.0261283219,
-0.0376290791,
0.0222869944,
0.0328108817,
-0.015434579,
-0.0238619335,
-0.025407156,
-0.0420120247,
0.0285126008,
0.0022585066,
-0.0198699534,
-0.0011790768,
0.0489303507,
0.0567376129,
-0.0394623056,
-0.0114034964,
-0.019328611,
0.0204298906,
0.020895442,
-0.0406121165,
-0.068460457,
-5.787445785e-33,
-0.0064154859,
0.0131960101,
0.0033112962,
-0.0506049581,
-0.0353147238,
-0.0034682176,
-0.0432349034,
-0.0490207709,
-0.0232890137,
0.0008845581,
0.0026980825,
0.002104911,
0.0191321112,
0.0332695171,
0.0246597845,
0.0041438714,
0.0684668273,
0.004891098,
-0.005100335,
-0.0043650558,
-0.008228641,
0.0452782586,
0.0742674693,
-0.0394501463,
-0.0090566445,
-0.013373524,
-0.0222631041,
-0.0087498222,
0.0440086648,
0.0347108059,
-0.001432473,
0.0393923521,
0.0035496892,
-0.0165801011,
-0.0441438705,
-0.0257173777,
-0.057739269,
-0.0196604449,
0.063116312,
0.0054293531,
-0.0457361899,
-0.0888307691,
0.0536938533,
-0.0509951003,
0.0174127612,
0.029245995,
0.0164094362,
-0.0483573936,
-0.0040513547,
-0.0057182582,
-0.0619472228,
-0.0107811922,
0.0010162797,
-0.0117654623,
0.0022382683,
0.0937270448,
-0.0409423746,
0.0480472147,
-0.0309803188,
0.0215894338,
-0.0157386623,
0.0174961518,
0.0385258794,
-0.0116768479,
0.0302797426,
0.0164857376,
-0.0024715604,
-0.0191697124,
0.0097486284,
-0.0012839745,
0.024655981,
0.0094502578,
0.0465605408,
0.0810667947,
0.0486236885,
0.0100605199,
-0.0363808833,
0.0052049924,
0.0202433821,
0.0016782888,
0.0409136191,
-0.0043062279,
0.0286216885,
-0.0059648962,
-0.0317855477,
-0.0302420799,
-0.0132108843,
-0.0429019257,
0.027432574,
0.0146201551,
-0.044742059,
0.0105190128,
0.0585548766,
-0.0231077261,
0.0094903493,
0.0424158126,
-0.0185211468,
0.0228588842,
0.0250561275,
0.0388235524,
0.003610275,
-0.0199826472,
0.0114946095,
0.0232564639,
0.0197538882,
-0.0032362808,
0.0241302997,
0.0295205582,
-0.0335271806,
0.0157160517,
-0.0289920978,
-0.0644625872,
-0.0181278661,
-0.015006938,
-0.0049872003,
0.0452725925,
-0.0013076368,
0.0073246351,
0.0426160619,
-0.0341533832,
0.0092172585,
-0.0085995272,
0.0430720858,
0.0611239523,
-0.0107826572,
0.0101559181,
-0.0407364033,
0.0079562273,
0.0158447176,
-0.0555538312,
-0.0172066372,
-0.0150296865,
2.636e-7,
0.0487533025,
0.026593823,
0.0155179864,
-0.0150831696,
-0.0086459108,
-0.0036512611,
0.0318825208,
0.0280887876,
-0.043416772,
0.0502447002,
0.0405924506,
0.0311418287,
0.0390696228,
-0.0347677469,
-0.1087411344,
-0.0071255434,
-0.0385964848,
-0.0120799663,
-0.0628867298,
-0.0339310206,
0.0421871096,
0.0840072706,
0.0282301251,
-0.0131097222,
-0.0301640779,
-0.016651025,
0.0690191463,
-0.0288959593,
-0.035099566,
-0.0076725478,
0.0011928373,
0.013082969,
-0.0252458192,
-0.0095349494,
-0.0246469397,
0.0046194708,
0.0476463772,
0.0833185539,
-0.0175936911,
0.005132895,
-0.0059361788,
-0.0662618503,
-0.0379725508,
-0.0361509323,
0.0707077757,
-0.0556630529,
0.0300997235,
-0.0041167932,
-0.0145298671,
0.0642140359,
0.0633217171,
-0.0660487935,
-0.0593568794,
0.0206355918,
0.0503764935,
0.0360567011,
-0.0392921679,
-0.0413526334,
-0.0191368256,
-0.0066891625,
-0.0227275454,
0.0299612079,
-0.014052053,
-0.0204600878,
0.063200213,
-0.0456047356,
0.039928589,
2.186177965e-34,
0.0427297018,
-0.0171349812,
0.0386958867,
0.0208582003,
0.0253036413,
-0.035024181,
-0.0128005212,
0.0371760949,
0.0081788627,
-0.0181732234,
-0.0324597396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00085v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00085v2 | Reasoning before Responding: Integrating Commonsense-based Causality Explanation for Empathetic Response Generation | 2023-07-28T01:52:16 | 2023-09-05T05:45:30 | Yahui Fu, Koji Inoue, Chenhui Chu, Tatsuya Kawahara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent approaches to empathetic response generation try to incorporate
commonsense knowledge or reasoning about the causes of emotions to better
understand the user's experiences and feelings. However, these approaches
mainly focus on understanding the causalities of context from the user's
perspective, ignoring the system's perspective. In this paper, we propose a
commonsense-based causality explanation approach for diverse empathetic
response generation that considers both the user's perspective (user's desires
and reactions) and the system's perspective (system's intentions and
reactions). We enhance ChatGPT's ability to reason for the system's perspective
by integrating in-context learning with commonsense knowledge. Then, we
integrate the commonsense-based causality explanation with both ChatGPT and a
T5-based model. Experimental evaluations demonstrate that our method
outperforms other comparable methods on both automatic and human evaluations. | [
0.0355704203,
0.013433828,
-0.0190779325,
0.0438023098,
0.021784896,
0.029524317,
-0.0016071027,
-0.0205481965,
0.0338968933,
-0.018043749,
0.0208402779,
0.016521547,
-0.0211556125,
-0.0017578386,
0.015792463,
-0.0765396506,
0.0172147118,
0.0576154739,
0.0297441054,
-0.0028411841,
0.0101350965,
0.0287824199,
-0.0221457966,
0.0698270127,
-0.02983821,
-0.0211196914,
-0.0354323722,
0.044453118,
0.024835214,
-0.0250279922,
0.0282749198,
0.0043309527,
0.006204972,
-0.0148564465,
0.0000020338,
-0.0267155617,
0.0131750628,
-0.0081610605,
0.0138311954,
-0.0031262101,
0.0488684662,
0.013067388,
0.0136465766,
0.0292098932,
-0.0468988977,
0.0367098562,
0.0569339208,
0.0335559882,
0.0726943538,
0.0367886536,
-0.0312272105,
-0.0480740704,
-0.0381051786,
-0.0019718665,
0.0449169949,
-0.008470933,
-0.0016874711,
-0.0138191851,
0.0336100385,
-0.0430597775,
-0.0309123676,
-0.0080826916,
0.0160909593,
-0.0217025001,
0.0105243027,
0.0265505798,
0.0546761677,
-0.0122211426,
-0.0187566876,
0.0957051069,
0.0419675484,
0.0207244512,
0.0407842733,
-0.0116157997,
0.0220721848,
0.0025135893,
-0.0322966613,
-0.0419863723,
-0.0054036602,
0.0020539246,
-0.017202327,
0.0420983136,
0.0106810788,
0.0506779142,
0.0070412154,
0.0163388308,
-0.0154639091,
0.0012236855,
-0.0352641009,
0.0091339312,
0.0100691477,
-0.0039724889,
-0.0139563857,
0.0600152835,
-0.0315992124,
0.0091006299,
0.0002579274,
0.044764258,
0.0028620397,
-0.0323444977,
0.0143425204,
0.0692465529,
-0.0081418855,
-0.0082358448,
0.0083886292,
0.0009949711,
-0.0123787299,
-0.0174949411,
-0.0423534401,
0.03820429,
-0.0697997063,
-0.016963724,
-0.0062769982,
0.0096646491,
-0.0801448524,
-0.0025367693,
-0.0641561225,
0.036279168,
-0.0371041149,
-0.0372406878,
-0.013919455,
0.037710581,
-0.0411971211,
0.0024777858,
-0.0481748097,
0.0436819792,
-0.086137414,
0.0177517589,
0.0292571522,
-0.0291424599,
-0.0222942326,
0.0112900566,
0.0225856733,
-0.022445865,
-0.0018854642,
0.0345705487,
-0.009199271,
0.019807158,
-0.0478240624,
-0.0271358714,
-0.0159093607,
-0.0388788208,
-0.0148251196,
-0.0056584096,
0.019852398,
0.026567407,
-0.0239211675,
0.0323862694,
0.0102114538,
-0.0137931993,
-0.0555967353,
0.0625726879,
-0.010432397,
0.0130026257,
-0.0072001875,
0.0322715603,
0.0075538475,
0.0362566561,
0.0013341404,
0.0241567437,
0.0197963547,
-0.0028550741,
0.0352123156,
-0.022280233,
0.0177430399,
-0.0322676152,
0.0036250346,
-0.0321262255,
-0.0729488358,
0.0313145779,
0.0576535873,
-0.0039784815,
-0.0434266813,
0.0007432635,
0.0470236912,
0.0583385155,
-0.0041944603,
0.0816967115,
0.0187037829,
0.0017359126,
-0.0250836425,
0.0409536287,
-0.0442481674,
0.0797133073,
-0.0237162765,
-0.0005144989,
-0.0228220001,
-0.0191978868,
-0.0399160162,
-0.0155686727,
0.0035620925,
-0.0122192828,
0.0202947818,
0.0078644594,
-0.0076665329,
-0.0300991368,
-0.041328527,
0.0059295814,
0.0184597857,
-0.086736232,
-0.0006117374,
-0.0596892983,
0.0035406286,
0.1049079522,
0.0272885021,
-0.0309172776,
-0.0444674864,
0.0005773649,
-0.0249865726,
0.0392929129,
0.0310440734,
-0.0330191813,
0.0618943647,
-0.0441408865,
-0.0114904912,
-0.0081567978,
-0.0127483876,
0.0304169618,
-0.0599743947,
0.0065295836,
0.0166398957,
0.0354816578,
0.0698071867,
0.0160635244,
-0.0084278956,
-0.0156723969,
-0.0172748305,
0.0113796582,
0.0490816683,
0.021790497,
0.0223116707,
-0.0038578564,
-0.0068988544,
-0.005338904,
-0.0013158411,
0.1047350764,
-0.0534963831,
-0.0815363452,
0.0301115233,
-0.0439638197,
-0.0151428748,
0.0299079493,
-0.0312068108,
-0.0319964103,
0.0394631773,
-0.0116802249,
0.0324405655,
-0.0807584375,
-0.0315335579,
-0.0074496306,
-0.0168543253,
0.0160953496,
0.0522040799,
0.0064034145,
-0.0208399985,
0.0139165297,
-0.022315355,
-0.0056288014,
-0.0261069946,
-0.0086326404,
0.0011806954,
-0.0060741091,
-0.0188176297,
-0.0059880563,
0.0282459315,
-0.0627566203,
-0.0167375077,
-0.1155645847,
-0.0291657355,
-0.0095310798,
-0.0193326809,
-0.0019923397,
0.0213092566,
-0.0010671037,
-0.0086456221,
-0.0353772342,
0.0574261956,
0.0397747196,
0.0051745288,
0.0241881981,
0.0086017409,
0.0030965309,
-0.0527997129,
0.0240241103,
-0.0388969705,
0.0137062548,
0.0106682163,
0.0249488745,
-0.0209695697,
-0.0111987507,
-0.0475664884,
0.0169262439,
-0.0103951665,
-0.1176692396,
0.0125671895,
0.0001149242,
-0.010134059,
0.0449204966,
0.0411653146,
0.0731151253,
-0.0050800829,
-0.0231667906,
-0.0600576475,
0.0617422648,
-0.0591921061,
0.0324805938,
-0.0136224488,
-0.0242676754,
-0.0383264609,
0.0648926124,
0.0029605064,
0.0078435065,
-0.0974167213,
0.0007318839,
0.0367053747,
-0.041577667,
-0.0462351367,
-0.0276119094,
-0.0220213495,
0.000149573,
-0.0193478353,
-0.0243730266,
0.0917377025,
0.0391558185,
-0.0336110331,
-0.0283538196,
0.044059176,
0.0069332877,
0.0618895739,
-0.0569698922,
0.0204072669,
-0.0061609815,
-0.0038632606,
-0.0350874066,
-0.0448197573,
0.0504460447,
-0.0196662787,
-0.0022670035,
-0.0303408392,
-0.0134835746,
0.0148520153,
-0.0483554229,
-0.0224388372,
-0.053123299,
-0.0062420596,
-0.017808849,
0.0014021652,
-0.0187004749,
0.0111585213,
0.0073951101,
0.0457980931,
0.0004424152,
-0.0208700486,
-0.030218605,
0.0037485906,
-0.0025015024,
0.0480135083,
0.0184663106,
0.0324662067,
-0.0106633194,
0.0538600907,
0.0228943415,
0.0626476258,
-0.0511162542,
0.0054210401,
0.0385110937,
0.0079955906,
0.0239677224,
0.0171466842,
0.0176983774,
0.0414057076,
-0.0045573227,
0.0089569874,
0.0926303491,
0.0247831549,
-0.0234589186,
0.0256600063,
-0.0372807048,
0.0055858889,
0.0118287252,
-0.0017424736,
-0.0474874526,
-0.0402753614,
-0.0153473094,
0.0399844795,
-0.0047516236,
-0.0393146425,
0.026175227,
-0.0680170357,
0.0422776863,
0.0062455102,
-0.0230809376,
-0.0225975867,
0.0141941803,
-0.0055074841,
0.0190370735,
-0.0284108222,
-0.0063360948,
0.0181537103,
-0.0003026571,
0.028198177,
0.006191601,
-0.056474518,
0.0132715115,
-0.0162811875,
0.0592672266,
0.0500645712,
0.09540499,
0.0227171294,
-0.0315115899,
-0.0268465001,
-0.0123369321,
0.0464075543,
-0.0384273082,
0.0041746786,
0.0164674725,
0.0144121023,
-0.0425863937,
0.0637172312,
-0.0447949208,
-0.0194983538,
-0.0029679525,
0.0636866167,
-0.037009269,
-0.0025153388,
-0.029196281,
0.0513714962,
0.0674435869,
0.0705713704,
0.0316696614,
-0.0384408087,
-0.0335831232,
-0.0106071765,
0.0004624357,
-0.0089255217,
-0.0192231573,
-0.0341879539,
0.0221415181,
-0.0233896822,
-0.0762756318,
-0.0688379109,
-0.0145348152,
0.051954072,
-0.0335571058,
-0.0291502811,
-0.0169197712,
0.0270938072,
-0.0157623515,
0.0268056821,
0.026487967,
-0.0059376787,
0.0102107478,
0.0145870084,
0.0227726679,
-0.0458771177,
0.0064854291,
0.0312525332,
0.0371644981,
-0.0504627042,
-0.0251979493,
0.0838393867,
0.0273900423,
0.0422519855,
-0.0068805809,
-0.0448688157,
0.0079302089,
0.0439416468,
-0.0394370668,
-0.0116306394,
0.053798832,
0.0448438302,
-0.0035670884,
0.0311521143,
-0.0452903323,
0.0160831679,
0.0144872582,
0.038285397,
-0.0084949778,
-0.0239844695,
0.0000344084,
-0.0027442393,
0.0337503627,
-0.025955651,
-0.0371808931,
-0.0024973794,
-0.0075588818,
-0.0464667454,
0.0122203482,
-0.0545000099,
0.0012747674,
-0.017737098,
0.0196116976,
-0.0412076376,
-0.0860261843,
-0.0464946851,
-0.018393293,
-0.0134737017,
0.036976736,
0.0033662503,
0.016357854,
0.0053428137,
0.0294803865,
-0.0071666068,
-0.0334578976,
0.0043038749,
-0.006803879,
0.0023399726,
0.1286080331,
0.0328881331,
-0.0189263858,
-0.0056280135,
0.0158080943,
-0.0546292849,
0.0373108983,
-0.0183363762,
0.0398330577,
0.0450708494,
0.0041020224,
0.0397649519,
-0.0279598553,
0.0222703479,
0.005414804,
0.0881307051,
0.0247760918,
-0.046937868,
-0.0026088282,
0.0150238127,
-0.0275036283,
-0.0324096382,
0.0556642525,
-0.0919165835,
0.0224848893,
-0.0101047587,
-0.0252102371,
-0.0248097423,
-0.0262788646,
0.0510627218,
0.0217514131,
0.0034388243,
0.0243830979,
-0.0923273414,
-0.0498596914,
-0.0091169616,
0.0023348432,
0.0005859921,
-0.0325789265,
0.0320894606,
0.0499428362,
-0.0020555924,
-0.0215259269,
0.0037390711,
0.0374369211,
-0.1203568131,
0.0023941647,
-0.0333219096,
-6.057337451e-33,
0.0062225754,
-0.0271887686,
-0.0167609882,
0.00921336,
-0.0336149074,
-0.0045843399,
-0.0523178093,
-0.0106350677,
0.0005827914,
0.0519009903,
-0.0246823244,
0.039562121,
0.0010952378,
-0.0113935582,
-0.0092673004,
-0.0296681188,
0.0243586972,
0.0172626413,
-0.0234656613,
0.0631276965,
0.0319859646,
0.025146788,
0.0252730977,
-0.0760041699,
0.0139208501,
-0.0081767971,
-0.0207633432,
0.0186013766,
0.0110907117,
0.0344661623,
-0.020485023,
0.0482578501,
0.0225353502,
-0.0062344549,
0.0342084728,
0.0422712043,
-0.0170459859,
-0.0347762592,
0.0348904729,
-0.0475363508,
-0.0543621592,
-0.0270011686,
-0.0064586219,
0.0216720048,
-0.0376496352,
-0.0109001808,
0.0138716595,
-0.0072286883,
0.0221152101,
-0.0657018721,
-0.0415828973,
-0.0148342447,
-0.0549852438,
-0.0583655238,
-0.022409346,
0.0400255919,
-0.0140726082,
-0.0011036325,
0.0104250563,
-0.0141100669,
-0.0364321545,
-0.0574202538,
0.0294821449,
-0.0139820511,
0.0184621345,
0.0585458577,
-0.0396168344,
0.007983584,
-0.0732791573,
-0.0065280781,
-0.0057771476,
0.0456233397,
0.0596999153,
0.1061056629,
-0.0127121732,
-0.0389671698,
-0.0414908379,
0.07377702,
0.0488169529,
0.0430206694,
0.0472775288,
0.0130296135,
-0.0290479101,
0.0069000889,
0.0036347057,
-0.0345225707,
-0.0359555893,
-0.0420399942,
0.0135461334,
-0.0104157003,
-0.0220192391,
-0.0315483436,
0.0092430012,
-0.0385542847,
0.0419059023,
0.0615232661,
-0.0267726313,
-0.0130720427,
-0.0000057285,
-0.0037236859,
0.0137146674,
-0.0114553273,
0.0305749513,
0.013572678,
0.0265390538,
0.0102619613,
-0.003868941,
0.0128940549,
0.0121900151,
-0.0108420067,
-0.0390352383,
0.0481454432,
-0.0334309526,
-0.069529742,
-0.0094952835,
0.0228654258,
-0.0074757664,
-0.0209060442,
0.0016783461,
0.0233956352,
-0.0043629631,
-0.0322493538,
0.0112474663,
0.041998893,
-0.0403108224,
0.0099810278,
0.008367612,
-0.0441278741,
0.0153880836,
-0.0387273841,
-0.0398941524,
0.0201555304,
2.711e-7,
-0.0337694883,
0.022712836,
0.0116228787,
-0.0403022431,
0.0180533659,
0.0718731135,
-0.0006556698,
0.0334660858,
0.0559667721,
0.0020323456,
0.0738751069,
0.0070391274,
0.0894741789,
-0.00979912,
-0.058828678,
0.0151647041,
-0.0524972007,
-0.022611808,
0.0066598305,
0.0227533113,
0.1208928451,
-0.0030705654,
0.034125194,
0.0117887193,
0.0475879163,
0.0187757276,
0.0374224633,
-0.0809603706,
0.0034470868,
-0.0296043437,
0.007119562,
-0.0721999407,
0.0171103626,
0.0084027806,
-0.0081663495,
-0.0159438197,
-0.0121086752,
0.0533382222,
-0.0271809343,
-0.0839214846,
-0.0019831734,
-0.0058630509,
0.0351764224,
-0.0859045386,
0.0170610175,
-0.0720358416,
-0.0120042367,
0.0149052851,
-0.011086069,
-0.015762426,
-0.0461740717,
-0.0244666301,
-0.0415076427,
0.0167174358,
-0.0002873407,
-0.0236605927,
-0.0023530466,
-0.0932497904,
0.0138777485,
0.0184482746,
-0.0256626662,
-0.0582310706,
-0.0197537504,
0.010234829,
0.0708247796,
-0.0410797261,
-0.0041121943,
1.973109971e-34,
-0.025266055,
0.0037388683,
0.0042361976,
0.0092269713,
0.0606043525,
0.0222198199,
0.0075048301,
0.0235841777,
0.0911705196,
-0.0300215092,
-0.0125957727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00002v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00002v3 | An Overview Of Temporal Commonsense Reasoning and Acquisition | 2023-07-28T01:30:15 | 2023-11-16T12:33:12 | Georg Wenzel, Adam Jatowt | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | Temporal commonsense reasoning refers to the ability to understand the
typical temporal context of phrases, actions, and events, and use it to reason
over problems requiring such knowledge. This trait is essential in temporal
natural language processing tasks, with possible applications such as timeline
summarization, temporal question answering, and temporal natural language
inference. Recent research on the performance of large language models suggests
that, although they are adept at generating syntactically correct sentences and
solving classification tasks, they often take shortcuts in their reasoning and
fall prey to simple linguistic traps. This article provides an overview of
research in the domain of temporal commonsense reasoning, particularly focusing
on enhancing language model performance through a variety of augmentations and
their evaluation across a growing number of datasets. However, these augmented
models still struggle to approach human performance on reasoning tasks over
temporal common sense properties, such as the typical occurrence times,
orderings, or durations of events. We further emphasize the need for careful
interpretation of research to guard against overpromising evaluation results in
light of the shallow reasoning present in transformers. This can be achieved by
appropriately preparing datasets and suitable evaluation metrics. | [
0.0662736148,
0.068830587,
-0.0116723645,
-0.0048561203,
-0.0561908148,
0.0077810092,
0.0054518669,
-0.0205611158,
-0.000609137,
-0.0574395247,
0.0292746853,
-0.0288947001,
0.0178194549,
0.0146013144,
-0.0216879454,
-0.070640251,
0.0636840016,
0.0160812642,
-0.0149958562,
0.030291019,
-0.0100963721,
-0.0018707233,
-0.0405820347,
0.0354578905,
0.0262936838,
-0.0332652591,
-0.0092066275,
-0.073157832,
0.0529178046,
-0.0271420293,
-0.0265829787,
0.028420018,
0.0425763093,
0.0266758762,
0.0000017478,
-0.0262072235,
0.0226697996,
-0.0179422218,
-0.017210532,
0.0074212332,
0.014533082,
-0.0037507145,
0.010410402,
-0.0020504706,
-0.0686031729,
0.0017256226,
-0.0071949442,
0.0353955328,
0.011416805,
0.0594642833,
-0.0061876788,
-0.0200237241,
0.0278954804,
-0.0191365164,
0.015074105,
-0.0471366271,
-0.0074887844,
0.0198788047,
0.0569656603,
-0.0215671994,
-0.006710826,
0.0145613356,
0.04023505,
-0.0032314672,
0.0146595584,
0.0889325812,
-0.0430521294,
0.0440435335,
-0.0393243805,
0.0280093309,
0.0413470566,
-0.0347630903,
-0.0111252284,
0.034949813,
-0.0093546798,
0.0038156933,
-0.0326941609,
0.0106785847,
0.017843442,
0.0223065354,
0.0346934162,
0.0276860241,
0.005592105,
0.0518580452,
-0.0224922467,
0.0919346511,
0.0110868607,
-0.013683755,
-0.0585772656,
0.0053266562,
0.0125017297,
-0.038864933,
0.0093528535,
0.0811005011,
-0.0007402036,
0.0255959798,
-0.0077207899,
0.0239482559,
0.0023746046,
-0.0438920036,
-0.0198169667,
0.0509493873,
0.0031799402,
0.0596293733,
-0.0295856036,
0.0492547676,
-0.0230383631,
0.0216710996,
-0.0227911696,
0.0043434422,
-0.0764933228,
-0.0093329269,
0.0052740215,
0.0014761245,
-0.0283695329,
0.01332568,
-0.0701573715,
0.0336857922,
0.021963805,
-0.0357391685,
-0.0089713959,
0.0326935537,
-0.050862968,
-0.0137666333,
-0.0846590847,
0.0241235644,
-0.0341062546,
0.0551130623,
-0.0096491817,
-0.0308096875,
-0.0210728683,
-0.0083790161,
0.0252267104,
-0.0631826222,
-0.0296073537,
0.0338690728,
-0.0563876219,
-0.0409612171,
-0.0767454058,
-0.0265327375,
-0.0213132426,
-0.0248425268,
-0.0056822738,
-0.0484430492,
0.0169689599,
0.0154063776,
-0.0382627696,
0.0324101336,
0.0018907249,
0.0013190234,
-0.0118692722,
0.0572371297,
0.023657538,
0.0240444671,
-0.0058510462,
0.0098594865,
0.0415167511,
0.0257093422,
0.0361475311,
-0.0283727497,
0.0150458245,
0.0196335223,
-0.0285527781,
0.0065508829,
-0.0010443785,
-0.0130205406,
-0.0548046604,
0.0027374385,
-0.0347392745,
0.0159415342,
0.0480681881,
0.0068618106,
-0.0314629748,
-0.0202327017,
0.0581803508,
0.0448003486,
-0.0189718362,
-0.0149041619,
0.0468392745,
-0.0317250788,
0.0191135518,
0.012597804,
-0.0446617194,
0.0306057576,
-0.0211750753,
0.0224100165,
-0.0657486543,
0.0163570438,
-0.0225148275,
-0.0190146957,
-0.0117842657,
-0.0004620445,
0.0489535369,
0.0012654141,
0.0540017188,
0.0025734608,
-0.0201135706,
0.0790269896,
0.0138496626,
-0.0317741521,
-0.0043420005,
-0.0305980425,
-0.0005022519,
0.0592927523,
0.0373985544,
-0.0253792666,
-0.0724916905,
-0.01572093,
0.0107515352,
0.0301623009,
0.0511494577,
-0.02564607,
-0.002290613,
-0.0156889912,
-0.0222973526,
0.0063514174,
-0.0070328941,
-0.0023170924,
0.0373092033,
0.0205815695,
0.0072241249,
-0.031635467,
0.0175537113,
0.0434414521,
-0.0434247479,
-0.016798757,
-0.0567951687,
0.0170942117,
0.0279372185,
0.0053322529,
0.0229454227,
0.0065467576,
0.0390688479,
-0.0345289819,
-0.0078433556,
0.1069199294,
-0.0621718727,
-0.0646717399,
0.0398609824,
0.0013527739,
-0.0499798469,
0.0419594459,
-0.0345648378,
-0.0355608836,
0.0297350604,
-0.0118789086,
0.0694887713,
-0.0581073277,
-0.0045548771,
-0.0038362159,
0.0097116353,
-0.0197825059,
0.1184197292,
-0.028038688,
-0.0045859967,
0.0037612554,
0.0049325204,
-0.0046854317,
-0.0348901078,
-0.0072602136,
-0.0127103766,
0.0031157765,
-0.0313079543,
0.0103353672,
-0.0196953248,
-0.0685029775,
-0.0111876624,
-0.0881742761,
-0.006563507,
-0.0066473796,
0.0140691837,
-0.0033644931,
-0.0205026101,
0.0086603398,
-0.0124992169,
-0.0071589537,
-0.02671583,
0.0269210208,
0.0304514542,
0.0545844249,
0.0401893221,
-0.0236799754,
-0.0087752808,
-0.0136838788,
-0.0646357089,
0.0436952896,
0.0104384478,
0.0184561163,
-0.0166107174,
0.0031828983,
-0.0388720445,
0.0118685802,
-0.0219248533,
-0.0398308896,
0.0269902665,
-0.0098476419,
0.0558157861,
0.076078631,
0.0281396229,
0.0356305242,
0.0686497167,
-0.0147066079,
-0.0174767021,
0.0285062231,
-0.0434187055,
0.0265689548,
-0.0250212196,
-0.0080658011,
-0.0558094792,
0.0872444361,
-0.0230555404,
0.0065056691,
-0.0463869646,
-0.0065875016,
-0.0234034173,
-0.0084930696,
-0.0163763482,
-0.0244543813,
-0.0327934474,
0.0377056114,
-0.051984679,
-0.0167717095,
0.0705763325,
0.0147558916,
0.0003187586,
-0.0291836541,
-0.014355218,
-0.0467563607,
0.1071417853,
0.0080305636,
-0.0206301864,
-0.0216748435,
-0.0380854495,
-0.0492231995,
-0.0334891379,
0.0374966189,
-0.0208457988,
0.0584795401,
-0.0430107675,
0.0284608565,
-0.0137754204,
-0.0225246008,
-0.057660833,
-0.0811166987,
-0.0233237706,
-0.006727952,
-0.0497353151,
0.0166210644,
-0.074921988,
0.02771548,
-0.0107442234,
0.0285304785,
-0.0208435655,
-0.0232465863,
-0.0068338378,
0.0596710332,
0.0287761614,
0.0582232662,
0.0132266674,
0.0156708714,
0.00722021,
0.0202796198,
0.0861624628,
-0.0520685427,
-0.0489593372,
0.0334232002,
-0.0089582186,
-0.0353864953,
-0.0053131506,
0.0371845998,
0.0398870818,
-0.0683109015,
-0.0279250331,
0.0900651962,
0.0707528889,
0.00646494,
0.0117138615,
-0.008918656,
0.0054574553,
0.0172241647,
-0.0046786368,
-0.0620540194,
-0.0145768765,
0.0070880563,
-0.0112222275,
-0.0415206589,
-0.0613854788,
0.0047152033,
-0.0988664478,
0.0042134356,
-0.0052840346,
-0.0663392395,
0.0052345572,
-0.0354221538,
0.0065574609,
-0.0091081113,
0.0061413888,
0.0115228686,
-0.0062605827,
-0.0029849582,
0.0310222376,
-0.0141005926,
-0.0750257149,
0.0613633208,
0.0107645933,
0.0709867999,
0.0296956915,
0.0623284914,
-0.0093711168,
-0.0606651753,
0.0033322028,
-0.01466903,
0.0207032897,
0.0151161151,
0.0167200658,
-0.0032916253,
-0.007110294,
-0.0240238756,
0.0385388769,
0.0038964243,
-0.0639057532,
-0.0344523862,
0.1190202981,
-0.0221301001,
0.0048080105,
-0.0403989479,
0.006594744,
0.0010993452,
0.0698344931,
0.0095075723,
0.0270761494,
-0.0400696993,
0.0235420689,
-0.0279851109,
-0.0798383281,
-0.0347422622,
0.0067458604,
0.0098822825,
-0.0039857766,
-0.0516255349,
-0.0655443221,
-0.0287311841,
0.0039429013,
-0.0100758933,
-0.0014931429,
0.0177725758,
0.0176229104,
-0.0694444031,
0.071144186,
0.0023461096,
0.0007731145,
-0.0127535788,
0.0060118162,
0.0249220766,
-0.0104167797,
-0.026916001,
0.0379872844,
-0.0629664138,
-0.049673561,
0.0252802372,
0.0080994563,
0.021494668,
0.0545966364,
-0.0158863347,
-0.0084291399,
0.0465756692,
0.0300416686,
-0.0219742563,
-0.0025666826,
0.0321812741,
-0.0020478661,
-0.0000214639,
0.0318230167,
-0.0408979841,
0.0105248354,
-0.0188174769,
0.042854894,
-0.0412836969,
0.0000710487,
0.0158575904,
-0.0422086418,
0.0332238972,
0.0182528272,
0.0124151949,
-0.0110256998,
-0.0083372239,
-0.0414110795,
0.0007687124,
0.0022518798,
-0.0011797835,
0.0191105641,
0.0147918584,
-0.0371238217,
0.0461019725,
-0.0243932661,
0.0277387891,
-0.0111971386,
0.0197010431,
0.0259541608,
-0.0158150718,
-0.015632676,
0.0145050958,
-0.0280349348,
-0.0277000684,
-0.0372894593,
0.0161357988,
-0.0026636256,
0.0450942405,
0.0251929611,
0.0078744134,
-0.0258112177,
-0.0193238836,
-0.1456354558,
0.0716691241,
0.0332899764,
0.0046519195,
0.0442004055,
-0.0750238523,
0.0396590717,
-0.0235828087,
-0.0057362025,
0.0191814899,
0.0336938016,
0.0249040313,
-0.0154661657,
0.0213331766,
0.0278901942,
-0.0050363792,
0.0151215447,
0.0611507185,
-0.0287058428,
0.0511845239,
0.0176877249,
-0.0292609427,
-0.0038356348,
-0.05308998,
-0.0311161131,
-0.0167467687,
-0.0216671191,
0.0024714398,
-0.0916777477,
-0.0504446477,
0.0471384339,
0.0099889198,
0.0189667102,
-0.0288953558,
-0.0095005464,
0.0571251139,
0.0392297022,
-0.0571133047,
-0.0211900733,
0.031438373,
-0.0007295755,
0.027680587,
-0.0804795772,
-5.900127571e-33,
-0.0168556161,
-0.0299725123,
0.0290468317,
-0.0274485201,
-0.0500018559,
0.0304440614,
-0.0462025963,
-0.0190181956,
-0.0139011359,
0.0225870833,
-0.0322407968,
0.0538430475,
0.0196374487,
0.0022075044,
0.0249977931,
-0.0009276614,
0.0205312334,
-0.0093208272,
-0.0263097268,
-0.0041482407,
0.0758540183,
0.0147918565,
0.0537069179,
-0.0073875161,
0.0171974711,
0.0090078041,
0.0228421893,
0.0399968252,
-0.0054321112,
0.0790480599,
0.0030953437,
0.0144212376,
0.043791268,
-0.0439814068,
-0.0027212661,
0.0391761325,
-0.1173713803,
-0.054482393,
0.0407837369,
0.0078466777,
-0.0206749942,
-0.0192093123,
0.0105961943,
-0.0067978068,
0.0114835994,
-0.0192874689,
0.0409480929,
-0.0637178123,
-0.0257132761,
-0.0689069405,
-0.0355223082,
0.035155531,
-0.0206647031,
-0.0211870223,
0.011239361,
0.0144184539,
0.0235050358,
-0.0026212311,
-0.0572039671,
0.0295477528,
0.0054280129,
0.0038298406,
0.0298431292,
-0.0004720249,
-0.0005307377,
0.0384684876,
-0.0426338352,
0.0164138954,
-0.0504079983,
0.0257892683,
0.0288877115,
0.003645675,
0.0210930463,
0.0169001184,
0.0343731269,
0.0020303917,
-0.035600543,
0.0310432725,
0.0302185584,
0.0637771338,
0.0290249828,
-0.0064040376,
-0.0082692141,
0.0208351258,
-0.0147490408,
0.031829901,
-0.0117098494,
0.0077368552,
-0.0014077757,
0.0091446741,
0.0083576422,
0.0226294864,
0.0359383747,
-0.0175466239,
-0.0084750121,
0.038668111,
-0.0213506725,
0.0050157029,
-0.001026924,
0.0308845416,
-0.0567137077,
0.0057543255,
0.046394594,
-0.000974565,
-0.0084557952,
-0.0100946063,
0.034035068,
0.0235898253,
-0.003630454,
-0.0178654194,
-0.0133955898,
0.0092907362,
-0.0135902623,
-0.025417123,
0.0591350012,
0.0303188581,
-0.0087565053,
0.02601384,
0.0115800425,
0.0195974614,
-0.0186995082,
0.0366347246,
0.0182490349,
0.0293425284,
-0.004737284,
0.0100660892,
-0.0450942107,
0.0376255959,
-0.0044242735,
-0.0225444436,
-0.0134045873,
0.0379881933,
2.398e-7,
0.0278838035,
0.0164288264,
0.0275272541,
0.048167333,
0.0028584963,
-0.0058466666,
-0.0243600868,
-0.0215972811,
-0.0013524499,
0.0097779203,
0.0510895364,
0.0485359877,
0.0453609675,
0.0277328528,
0.0110639008,
-0.0378452465,
-0.0818868801,
-0.0241038501,
-0.043114718,
-0.0109425252,
0.0842689648,
0.0851020887,
0.0483303443,
-0.0059004752,
-0.0036607832,
-0.0685037822,
0.0667985007,
0.003692983,
-0.0374606065,
0.0037962301,
0.0406715833,
0.0020126025,
-0.0191201121,
0.0489208028,
-0.0041091926,
0.0109394668,
-0.053208936,
0.0238260627,
-0.0272693615,
-0.0390243009,
-0.0230608582,
-0.0398706049,
-0.0098959748,
-0.0251764078,
0.1084554046,
-0.0984243602,
-0.0377081782,
-0.0038481453,
-0.0231379569,
0.0408757031,
-0.0101114083,
0.0317660794,
-0.0233938266,
0.0081764339,
0.0088712024,
-0.012321773,
-0.0130041363,
-0.1354514062,
-0.0273079462,
0.0470721014,
-0.0123032518,
-0.0357742794,
-0.0163699891,
-0.0289065745,
0.0381467491,
-0.0590449907,
-0.0134722535,
2.136175604e-34,
0.0025300889,
0.0379827879,
-0.0307824109,
0.0092523657,
0.0241606291,
-0.0209707879,
0.0375110172,
-0.0099570826,
0.0473607741,
-0.0621902868,
-0.0054836236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15217v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15217v2 | Open Problems and Fundamental Limitations of Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback | 2023-07-27T22:29:25 | 2023-09-11T17:25:24 | Stephen Casper, Xander Davies, Claudia Shi, Thomas Krendl Gilbert, Jérémy Scheurer, Javier Rando, Rachel Freedman, Tomasz Korbak, David Lindner, Pedro Freire, Tony Wang, Samuel Marks, Charbel-Raphaël Segerie, Micah Carroll, Andi Peng, Phillip Christoffersen, Mehul Damani, Stewart Slocum, Usman Anwar, Anand Siththaranjan, Max Nadeau, Eric J. Michaud, Jacob Pfau, Dmitrii Krasheninnikov, Xin Chen, Lauro Langosco, Peter Hase, Erdem Bıyık, Anca Dragan, David Krueger, Dorsa Sadigh, Dylan Hadfield-Menell | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a technique for training
AI systems to align with human goals. RLHF has emerged as the central method
used to finetune state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs). Despite this
popularity, there has been relatively little public work systematizing its
flaws. In this paper, we (1) survey open problems and fundamental limitations
of RLHF and related methods; (2) overview techniques to understand, improve,
and complement RLHF in practice; and (3) propose auditing and disclosure
standards to improve societal oversight of RLHF systems. Our work emphasizes
the limitations of RLHF and highlights the importance of a multi-faceted
approach to the development of safer AI systems. | [
0.0760882497,
0.0963680521,
-0.0174812153,
0.0150855212,
-0.0443650857,
0.0003500744,
0.0022479913,
-0.0007526457,
0.0206002947,
-0.0254633352,
-0.039828252,
-0.0082751112,
0.0110860597,
0.029178407,
0.031173341,
-0.0314035527,
0.042734459,
-0.0843466669,
0.0204322934,
0.0001856426,
0.0147783319,
-0.0073466403,
0.0079829562,
0.0566331148,
0.0057849311,
-0.0001699776,
-0.0182535127,
-0.0315776281,
0.0097691063,
-0.0168683734,
-0.0092123225,
0.0236870069,
0.0368955061,
0.0889308676,
0.000002006,
-0.0507609993,
0.0097754551,
0.0037898989,
-0.0168058518,
0.0235880297,
0.0546190441,
-0.0154483216,
-0.0265137441,
0.0173846204,
-0.0258232187,
-0.015348223,
0.0488569736,
0.030560419,
0.057956066,
0.0776244104,
0.017401401,
0.0023472465,
0.0347706527,
-0.0133543313,
0.0009726278,
-0.0569048487,
0.0390754119,
0.001887867,
0.0400718749,
-0.0188117009,
-0.0062397462,
0.0258947723,
0.0290905572,
-0.0245317649,
-0.0194776356,
0.0424458385,
-0.0139686018,
-0.0506535843,
-0.0255784485,
0.0630358607,
-0.0006586458,
-0.0240866244,
0.0150316954,
-0.0047634486,
0.0142790489,
-0.0075750821,
-0.0095206443,
0.054923553,
-0.0342432521,
0.0084433639,
0.0129001467,
-0.0097376946,
0.0329931118,
0.0222896878,
0.0216804389,
0.0355141163,
-0.0219114423,
-0.0515590273,
0.0182103086,
0.0280306768,
0.0240049921,
-0.0514065698,
-0.0141237779,
0.0250337422,
-0.0656999052,
0.0052609388,
-0.0429973453,
-0.0047979769,
0.0252723638,
-0.0564547218,
0.0352298543,
-0.003832656,
0.012647571,
0.014283807,
0.0199397821,
0.0602378212,
-0.0216536392,
0.0593282618,
-0.0266647525,
0.0495171063,
-0.006185994,
0.0061530001,
-0.0238940064,
0.0484384559,
0.0033925476,
0.0080907717,
-0.0401833914,
0.0396244228,
-0.062797673,
0.0842144862,
-0.0344820991,
0.0144306924,
-0.022033155,
0.0003064529,
-0.0530176051,
-0.0295038261,
-0.0190207064,
0.0082066348,
-0.0003971648,
-0.0262412857,
0.0048703719,
0.0146905398,
-0.0458617099,
0.0021846248,
-0.0063913688,
0.1070483774,
0.0197867174,
-0.009302346,
-0.0207459368,
-0.0345675536,
-0.0192845631,
-0.0655956343,
0.0053072465,
-0.0736744925,
-0.0153691592,
-0.0401090533,
-0.0177413262,
-0.0260738134,
0.0039710859,
0.0003084247,
-0.0413014926,
0.0767841414,
-0.0172128305,
0.0148000745,
0.0001712844,
0.0193815194,
-0.0037003423,
0.0477506146,
0.0490774773,
0.0362934247,
0.0425766446,
0.0142794717,
0.0768038407,
0.0183157437,
0.0156195611,
0.0337993875,
-0.0128867663,
0.0218493491,
-0.0238759834,
0.0440642796,
0.0069836453,
0.0719224513,
-0.0210217889,
-0.0033424592,
0.0634543598,
0.0604004711,
-0.0242370814,
0.0016861834,
0.0252637733,
0.0118045108,
0.0045146379,
0.0090788305,
-0.0418593623,
-0.0027528699,
-0.033132039,
0.0097627304,
-0.0071460102,
-0.0123792244,
-0.0269412268,
-0.0445277877,
0.0055907778,
-0.0514479615,
0.0373135135,
0.0593125299,
0.0532302894,
-0.0000452684,
-0.0277271271,
-0.0550516807,
0.0444029979,
-0.0059423563,
0.0069265664,
-0.1039912179,
0.0537280962,
0.0900987908,
0.0456338301,
-0.0332493372,
0.017056521,
-0.0520855561,
-0.0134713175,
0.0275339521,
0.0264622979,
-0.0202501956,
0.0038752714,
-0.0036029541,
-0.0141319893,
0.0169917643,
0.0002266571,
0.0294805989,
0.0202596318,
-0.0247970074,
-0.0246592481,
0.035253901,
-0.0922588184,
0.0309685692,
0.0051564653,
-0.0346395411,
-0.0192895792,
0.0072062784,
0.0200067293,
0.0014352985,
-0.0274353903,
0.0312145595,
0.0279794838,
0.0123617416,
-0.0227636676,
-0.0268009696,
-0.0209243037,
0.0196985882,
0.0169767532,
-0.0264053904,
-0.0132798683,
0.0441963598,
-0.0296280589,
0.0006193692,
0.0002674007,
-0.0383668989,
0.0473808348,
-0.0001422843,
0.0236297771,
-0.026674768,
-0.0482424423,
-0.0459077507,
0.0210309271,
-0.0116598997,
-0.0246926825,
-0.0472877361,
0.000003686,
-0.0158544201,
-0.0527830012,
-0.027725596,
0.0417599417,
0.011930895,
0.0458769649,
0.0663011447,
0.0495949984,
-0.0180583447,
-0.0246925689,
-0.051969111,
-0.0393788181,
-0.0082361456,
-0.002543408,
-0.0291641299,
-0.0152230458,
-0.0059666145,
-0.0287122652,
-0.0184797067,
-0.0275321901,
0.0171312205,
0.0253705624,
0.027429644,
0.0233806334,
-0.040846087,
-0.0292406511,
-0.0255995542,
-0.017104676,
0.0164063126,
0.0202042237,
0.0048346468,
-0.0709420964,
0.0479143858,
-0.0118787736,
0.0415684022,
-0.0126964841,
-0.0292696245,
0.046964515,
-0.0053183637,
0.0038740137,
0.0844160542,
0.0057889773,
0.0401076041,
0.0491692945,
0.0211495254,
-0.0654933825,
0.0070227631,
-0.0140442839,
-0.0761557296,
-0.0174648724,
-0.0026107291,
0.0086559597,
0.0048975307,
0.0050168922,
0.015177221,
-0.0577771962,
0.0465414077,
-0.0431857742,
-0.0698505789,
-0.052325137,
-0.0748907849,
-0.0477752313,
0.0355727151,
-0.0122552803,
-0.0725725442,
0.1135554463,
0.0060750991,
0.0259423722,
-0.0141751524,
-0.0171054471,
-0.0343443267,
0.0284430385,
-0.0110723656,
0.034081351,
0.0125403581,
-0.0041276105,
-0.0320437551,
-0.0450156517,
0.0112513211,
-0.0393320508,
0.0452361964,
-0.0238369573,
-0.009991955,
0.0119351242,
-0.0802683309,
-0.0609433465,
-0.0449237414,
-0.0465350337,
-0.0121270614,
-0.0017582292,
-0.0201951526,
-0.0075899586,
-0.0007388926,
0.0749081448,
0.0036635557,
-0.0048826518,
-0.0334913135,
-0.005935696,
-0.0346251018,
0.0531802438,
-0.0522649698,
0.0499034114,
-0.0494771339,
0.0238440745,
0.0411665142,
0.0793310478,
0.0358037911,
-0.0019288582,
0.0136149749,
0.0230974033,
0.00791285,
0.0058641504,
0.055079706,
-0.0033010454,
-0.0401437841,
-0.03228328,
0.069836542,
0.0165033974,
-0.0622602478,
0.0237630624,
-0.0033861897,
0.0319560878,
-0.0037992205,
0.0331857987,
-0.0671733022,
0.0069459234,
0.0043805051,
0.0821569636,
-0.0448384024,
-0.0278783366,
0.0229293108,
-0.1288461387,
0.0436284356,
0.0163497683,
-0.0299025942,
-0.0415517204,
-0.0320381746,
-0.0264693499,
-0.0303813107,
0.0304257944,
0.013489496,
-0.0144443773,
-0.0351906456,
0.0279011,
-0.0481274053,
-0.010293832,
0.0259248354,
-0.0782235712,
0.0883261189,
0.1171540841,
0.0105354628,
-0.0269479174,
-0.0151450615,
-0.0036376582,
0.0434660651,
-0.0078772064,
0.0199860018,
0.0202382691,
-0.0267771166,
-0.0041991128,
-0.0440579019,
0.0330487825,
-0.0052835275,
-0.013886054,
0.0286017656,
0.0684759542,
-0.0317085795,
-0.030353168,
-0.0139620565,
0.0101445504,
0.0278364047,
0.0695349425,
-0.0101799611,
-0.0615811683,
-0.0357417762,
-0.0080288351,
-0.0160761196,
-0.0242844205,
-0.0474018976,
-0.0018953638,
-0.0031471595,
-0.0226006582,
-0.058160726,
-0.0646227226,
-0.0217432212,
0.0094947265,
0.0163889229,
-0.0403611399,
0.0372921638,
0.0321724564,
0.0293656923,
0.0089614801,
-0.0305892974,
0.0157325063,
-0.0647559538,
0.0134209516,
-0.0196516979,
-0.0283105485,
0.00603894,
0.0295124371,
-0.0386659577,
-0.0460693352,
0.0249270499,
0.0701373741,
0.0268471371,
0.0427405126,
-0.0348793827,
-0.0395207629,
0.0475598089,
0.0079465639,
-0.046112407,
0.0184695721,
0.0493445583,
0.0155549357,
0.0093586901,
0.0193961281,
-0.0619465671,
-0.0273562185,
0.0448966175,
0.0032503752,
-0.0233547483,
-0.0061327135,
0.0317087471,
0.0361725129,
0.0060449196,
-0.035001561,
0.0028218722,
-0.0146138007,
-0.0053732363,
-0.0193738863,
-0.0199764594,
-0.0294226669,
0.0138085876,
0.0217057113,
0.0160013996,
0.0053655705,
-0.0161349848,
-0.0111611458,
0.0336620919,
-0.0181420147,
0.0214175787,
0.029597152,
0.0441771001,
0.0421761461,
0.0084948838,
-0.0074406592,
0.0692807212,
-0.0046111369,
0.0446428657,
0.0219841618,
0.0631550327,
0.0323938653,
-0.0044304905,
0.0060337377,
0.028904641,
-0.0595181882,
-0.0874569565,
0.0019976005,
0.0527571216,
0.0295233335,
0.0543885268,
0.0162851326,
-0.0382096767,
0.0154818324,
-0.0099004023,
0.0021606127,
-0.0290062409,
-0.0276494753,
-0.0175180379,
0.0386807024,
-0.0300860871,
0.0152630536,
0.0547876172,
0.0259574931,
0.0379785113,
-0.0384828225,
-0.0105309412,
-0.0130586391,
-0.0473049097,
0.0304487552,
0.0013571839,
-0.0355671756,
-0.0434247665,
-0.088064611,
-0.0681338087,
-0.0259491056,
0.0518387333,
0.0056674089,
-0.0128046097,
0.0143707916,
0.0270255022,
0.011600039,
-0.0179210529,
-0.0543671101,
-0.0299718957,
-0.0100962482,
-0.0394432805,
-0.0289660543,
-5.777671549e-33,
0.0076308092,
-0.0263977759,
0.0118438639,
-0.0106408279,
-0.031963408,
-0.0053427638,
-0.0103302915,
0.006845505,
-0.0002180507,
0.0035523521,
-0.0125824483,
-0.0040793722,
0.007414564,
-0.0181976389,
0.0320651084,
-0.0361147746,
0.0059422534,
-0.0242243875,
-0.0262333341,
0.0296217054,
0.0100202234,
-0.0175460707,
0.0028215847,
-0.083008036,
0.0579502769,
0.0189841595,
-0.0446092114,
0.0328061841,
-0.0540799275,
0.0780669078,
-0.0003890754,
0.0494991243,
-0.0095634535,
-0.0357635804,
-0.0023184568,
0.0496648401,
-0.0287786406,
-0.0089493962,
0.0060929512,
-0.0147816204,
-0.0292635448,
-0.0198520366,
0.0609065667,
-0.0157163907,
-0.0355068967,
0.042927891,
0.0168258864,
0.0015256782,
-0.0152721647,
-0.0103033781,
-0.068098262,
0.000711732,
-0.0076818578,
0.0002531752,
0.0100091211,
0.0631460771,
-0.0242934786,
-0.0398785025,
-0.049833592,
0.0301180091,
0.0472544283,
-0.0346806906,
0.0504255742,
0.0415085107,
0.0140027469,
0.0396615677,
0.0300423168,
0.0212303195,
-0.0332803391,
-0.0443460084,
0.0299548414,
0.0189828239,
0.0342020877,
0.0433423556,
-0.0475046374,
-0.0209999662,
-0.0470348448,
0.0044222432,
-0.0191187393,
0.0686954707,
0.0599401668,
-0.0010276193,
-0.1310297251,
-0.0328851081,
-0.0213598087,
0.0036729616,
-0.0210705455,
-0.0116788475,
0.0413211659,
0.0270748939,
-0.0285511259,
-0.0186550617,
0.0178259965,
-0.06008159,
0.0150781376,
0.0002346621,
-0.0045692804,
0.0121454475,
-0.0289387349,
-0.010039039,
-0.0825594962,
-0.0097470237,
-0.0104337716,
-0.0021801805,
0.0293895341,
-0.0011829976,
0.0200165082,
0.0384495519,
-0.0349297598,
0.0126772486,
-0.0130038289,
0.0413360894,
0.0651869252,
-0.020295646,
0.0485446714,
-0.0082682669,
0.0064090691,
0.0274809189,
0.0030847865,
-0.0372153744,
-0.0273810104,
0.0321696028,
-0.0207277462,
-0.0086230617,
-0.0273414496,
0.0011946153,
-0.0269130934,
0.0550239943,
0.0534517206,
-0.0416943841,
-0.0106586898,
-0.0086296415,
2.752e-7,
-0.0373082533,
0.0251985528,
0.0314421393,
0.0204057749,
-0.0174666066,
0.0764541551,
0.0110155689,
0.055855412,
0.0109642437,
0.0070658531,
0.03889741,
0.0209604446,
0.0382536016,
0.028333148,
-0.0408834852,
-0.0281688012,
-0.0927604213,
0.0057922313,
-0.068532072,
-0.0097792652,
0.0364215411,
0.0527230166,
0.0540421531,
-0.0284561515,
0.0232850742,
-0.0298262537,
0.0279626176,
-0.0449540466,
-0.0139460899,
-0.0063390457,
0.0256117601,
0.0464778952,
-0.000393763,
0.0117388498,
0.0230296738,
-0.0123412861,
-0.0404821783,
0.078997232,
-0.0255758837,
-0.0353877805,
-0.034980271,
-0.0259312317,
0.0206547212,
-0.0566584244,
0.0437289961,
-0.0464239754,
-0.0073774038,
-0.030610133,
0.049991589,
-0.044159282,
0.0187602956,
-0.0243507549,
-0.0131583484,
-0.0066714245,
-0.0006001496,
0.0055123409,
0.01042563,
-0.0505781621,
0.0083492799,
0.0227498095,
0.0008615101,
-0.0602994561,
-0.0118041327,
0.0496712252,
-0.0382932611,
-0.0705721229,
0.0186012983,
2.536515919e-34,
0.002020021,
-0.0348526314,
-0.0022173147,
-0.0216124188,
0.0563274175,
0.0599325672,
-0.0401312299,
0.0063342475,
0.0668564141,
-0.0441033766,
-0.0298793223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15199v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15199v2 | PromptStyler: Prompt-driven Style Generation for Source-free Domain Generalization | 2023-07-27T21:14:46 | 2023-08-15T08:30:45 | Junhyeong Cho, Gilhyun Nam, Sungyeon Kim, Hunmin Yang, Suha Kwak | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In a joint vision-language space, a text feature (e.g., from "a photo of a
dog") could effectively represent its relevant image features (e.g., from dog
photos). Also, a recent study has demonstrated the cross-modal transferability
phenomenon of this joint space. From these observations, we propose
PromptStyler which simulates various distribution shifts in the joint space by
synthesizing diverse styles via prompts without using any images to deal with
source-free domain generalization. The proposed method learns to generate a
variety of style features (from "a S* style of a") via learnable style word
vectors for pseudo-words S*. To ensure that learned styles do not distort
content information, we force style-content features (from "a S* style of a
[class]") to be located nearby their corresponding content features (from
"[class]") in the joint vision-language space. After learning style word
vectors, we train a linear classifier using synthesized style-content features.
PromptStyler achieves the state of the art on PACS, VLCS, OfficeHome and
DomainNet, even though it does not require any images for training. | [
0.0261982568,
0.036345724,
0.0127209248,
0.0127999214,
-0.0102921836,
0.0040601678,
0.0430783033,
0.0476632677,
-0.0281240083,
-0.0365931205,
-0.0538628958,
-0.0592616126,
-0.0134417843,
0.0377192423,
0.0327713452,
-0.0797587261,
-0.0225296356,
-0.0264728833,
-0.0025985292,
-0.0062454301,
0.0368925706,
0.000821217,
-0.0143445088,
0.0032282108,
-0.041178748,
-0.00058894,
-0.0481913164,
0.0373755358,
0.0103455763,
0.0148214819,
0.0062108887,
0.0444947556,
0.0241017658,
-0.0246687792,
0.000001906,
-0.0393753201,
0.0138308816,
0.0000528127,
0.0689785108,
-0.0202968605,
0.0568422191,
-0.0156168267,
-0.0166677963,
-0.0275821425,
-0.0201013628,
-0.0422231629,
0.0999500304,
0.0993221328,
0.0600142628,
0.0753546059,
-0.0295094941,
-0.0388286971,
-0.0151703982,
-0.0266203657,
0.0511704199,
-0.03061812,
-0.0014634815,
-0.0527319126,
-0.0113482093,
0.014124441,
-0.0246903095,
0.023399327,
-0.0248173904,
-0.018598374,
-0.0141056655,
0.0174907409,
-0.0216634218,
-0.0037871466,
-0.0331141762,
0.0796380192,
0.019276429,
0.0047872406,
-0.0044992617,
-0.0196250044,
0.0401251987,
0.0528393947,
-0.0279853903,
0.0208327901,
-0.0208452828,
-0.0092296712,
-0.0814835355,
0.0252409335,
-0.0151071027,
-0.0413735099,
0.020167172,
-0.0172587615,
0.044539094,
-0.0211392362,
-0.0174499992,
-0.0012859501,
-0.0230816938,
-0.0418806486,
0.0281672962,
0.014334741,
-0.0118485317,
0.0137735624,
-0.0679281801,
-0.017776221,
0.0062490953,
0.0072568716,
0.0961350724,
-0.0305669904,
-0.0856279209,
0.0141072115,
-0.0277857985,
0.0529587306,
-0.0570089035,
0.0300526228,
-0.0556893498,
-0.0094114803,
-0.0334827341,
-0.0176137481,
-0.0407090522,
-0.0090461858,
-0.0313084722,
-0.0345891006,
-0.0121131279,
0.009620674,
-0.0285839997,
-0.0127783855,
0.0334972069,
0.029329028,
-0.0532694459,
-0.0247558895,
0.0019134949,
0.0009832189,
-0.0104681775,
0.0231642332,
-0.012712487,
-0.0309066605,
0.0100283157,
0.0283283666,
0.0478776768,
-0.0098131904,
-0.0171571076,
0.05986242,
-0.0464443825,
-0.0169999059,
-0.0462783091,
0.0023434341,
-0.0441838913,
-0.0010132176,
0.0444044545,
-0.0577198081,
-0.035858769,
-0.0158067979,
-0.007782626,
-0.0397661924,
-0.0122607369,
0.0055473153,
-0.0115710031,
0.0769568011,
-0.0022139431,
-0.0053140195,
0.0352237634,
-0.0314050913,
-0.0026721326,
0.0390081853,
0.006083617,
0.0581727698,
0.0313916244,
-0.0049758391,
0.016248893,
0.0486287288,
0.0207999237,
0.0083541451,
-0.0431766734,
-0.0510784797,
0.0780700594,
0.0172899831,
0.0300689284,
0.0440110378,
0.0015481438,
-0.0064722458,
0.0457408018,
-0.0191005133,
0.0688921735,
0.0113116289,
0.1023568958,
0.0110856239,
-0.0169516671,
0.0375447012,
-0.0268416852,
-0.0207524206,
-0.0205115154,
0.0432372279,
-0.0260533504,
0.0110019958,
-0.0551868789,
-0.0259591937,
0.0546159446,
-0.0077221021,
-0.0063424255,
-0.0263646301,
0.0539686792,
0.0798273236,
-0.0546924509,
0.0000728789,
0.0205916967,
-0.0516841784,
-0.0041715801,
-0.0215244722,
0.0298931096,
0.0613869913,
-0.0149648217,
-0.010432465,
0.0189524274,
-0.0141083244,
0.0886121318,
0.0505867153,
0.0234316476,
-0.0156559367,
0.021143131,
-0.0568871647,
-0.0483245477,
-0.0188561976,
-0.0099861296,
0.0418518856,
-0.0601467304,
0.0297662895,
0.031958051,
0.0145533299,
0.020497987,
0.0533630289,
0.0144111756,
-0.0540499017,
0.0222282093,
0.0263026617,
-0.0287178699,
0.0123546151,
-0.057134904,
0.0011562018,
-0.0235685632,
-0.0742388368,
0.0121560981,
0.0143129826,
-0.07177376,
-0.0216651876,
0.0025980277,
-0.0552283265,
0.0074796407,
-0.0199793093,
-0.0270445757,
-0.045443017,
-0.0146309854,
-0.0215035658,
0.0185529552,
-0.0512012169,
0.0021850956,
0.0005214371,
0.0232222155,
-0.0220409539,
0.0376936011,
0.0454416834,
0.0050386102,
0.0185743738,
0.0530097187,
0.0005138463,
-0.0125838313,
0.0010928289,
-0.0176790673,
-0.0202725884,
0.0064208126,
0.0068945065,
0.0411289185,
-0.0232387464,
-0.0131930467,
-0.0723545104,
-0.0445732102,
-0.0379126444,
-0.0074320701,
-0.0073150382,
0.018556226,
-0.0207250547,
-0.0425091721,
-0.0680394918,
0.0133447554,
-0.0308256745,
0.0025162457,
0.0473646931,
0.0003921567,
-0.0328724198,
0.0074805026,
-0.0269985721,
0.030122472,
0.0574026033,
0.0218022168,
-0.0000669546,
-0.078136459,
0.0507487282,
0.0044371351,
0.0371305123,
0.0051257573,
-0.0102792559,
0.0065697855,
-0.0433813557,
0.0212815385,
0.0476289317,
0.0813344195,
-0.0149005745,
0.0003971952,
-0.0059278202,
-0.032895755,
-0.0068614106,
-0.0222139116,
-0.0103107402,
0.0083420584,
0.0006055419,
0.0403377898,
0.0193837062,
0.0269962307,
0.0104990024,
-0.0701065585,
0.0181513019,
0.0214225035,
-0.0585306287,
-0.0337189026,
0.0146594085,
-0.0338287167,
0.005084679,
-0.000186258,
-0.064762421,
0.0366294011,
-0.0537528507,
-0.0064083044,
0.0246113744,
0.0022664084,
-0.0109642521,
0.0251205806,
0.0065956446,
0.0401166566,
0.0735301897,
-0.062711373,
-0.0558461845,
-0.0070555839,
0.0451459028,
0.0046080588,
0.0474672019,
-0.0397973694,
0.0039086784,
-0.0191771686,
-0.0187382475,
-0.0624783747,
-0.0415658876,
0.0256157964,
0.0030439368,
-0.0299006272,
-0.0219870731,
0.0267121214,
0.0103603769,
0.0038273316,
0.0483893417,
-0.0320079103,
-0.0154908868,
-0.0102563016,
0.0938535929,
0.0508678779,
0.0305115469,
-0.0782207549,
-0.0068827532,
-0.0624594353,
0.0041199229,
0.0256825108,
0.005717251,
-0.0482768044,
0.0306174196,
0.0379066207,
0.0101233153,
-0.0375907719,
0.0347029306,
0.0837843344,
0.0025233456,
-0.0124776987,
0.0916997194,
0.0321868472,
-0.0339684486,
-0.0310539026,
0.0221988559,
0.0057337875,
0.0184764508,
0.0291151423,
-0.0615059324,
-0.0312830359,
-0.020741079,
-0.0129611818,
0.0200781915,
0.0177851468,
-0.0220169052,
-0.0768246204,
0.0353331268,
0.0087827696,
-0.0517473221,
-0.0301170871,
0.0045731948,
0.0158884618,
0.0207577366,
-0.0543814413,
-0.0159588736,
-0.0240853839,
-0.0330346487,
0.0323492065,
0.0523180515,
-0.0401668847,
-0.0380140543,
-0.0222184062,
0.0288841035,
0.087786831,
0.0144587355,
-0.011311763,
-0.1256185323,
-0.0032506369,
-0.0384147875,
0.027056545,
-0.0174583662,
0.0420545265,
0.0013356762,
-0.0132739907,
0.0275413897,
0.0531450622,
0.0067878524,
0.016718775,
0.0184917096,
0.0010012465,
-0.0108385701,
-0.0492559262,
-0.0468992367,
-0.0010463995,
0.0504301041,
0.0260925405,
0.0261497051,
-0.0728423148,
-0.024944067,
-0.0615883432,
0.0161159504,
-0.0108275171,
-0.0340926945,
-0.0086449403,
-0.0312820002,
-0.0347748101,
-0.0824685246,
0.0191427786,
-0.0026987102,
0.0892629847,
0.0001623259,
-0.0515869111,
-0.0583798662,
0.0277172308,
-0.0592514351,
-0.0113956006,
0.0014678631,
0.0527283773,
-0.0273396354,
-0.020841293,
0.0627378449,
-0.0819514841,
-0.038555488,
0.0092433272,
-0.0140289562,
-0.0477497466,
-0.0144447675,
0.0676858425,
0.0110940691,
0.0114366496,
-0.0063673151,
-0.0623154156,
0.0903392956,
0.106150806,
0.0358566009,
-0.0065806331,
0.0461998954,
-0.0361430012,
0.0110729644,
0.0066454038,
-0.0502579957,
0.0535261482,
0.0345129669,
0.0079921326,
0.0409889445,
-0.0239195488,
0.0072065103,
-0.0182897411,
0.0182363521,
-0.0386708379,
0.0152507899,
-0.0315425396,
-0.0052270941,
0.0099155279,
-0.0098730354,
-0.0607846603,
0.0058133653,
-0.0145464363,
0.0179703459,
0.007450352,
0.0088578444,
-0.0273229945,
0.0295308866,
-0.0492760465,
-0.0013106798,
0.0635101646,
0.0679305345,
0.0067075472,
0.012715538,
0.0211614184,
0.0563507639,
0.0139892409,
0.0354301594,
-0.0091755334,
0.0769946128,
0.0255392455,
0.0078770835,
-0.0537422039,
0.0468587838,
-0.0300458167,
0.0285058804,
-0.0546464026,
0.0788386688,
0.0143086994,
-0.0418618731,
0.0110278586,
0.0031648767,
-0.0014773811,
-0.0109517733,
0.0471098982,
0.0451432578,
-0.0416758135,
0.0406257696,
0.0128110694,
0.0019445384,
-0.0273990855,
0.081273742,
-0.0067269588,
0.0066493079,
-0.0353765115,
0.0068809702,
-0.0554659404,
0.0086096218,
0.0429450609,
0.0070056287,
0.0240919832,
0.0115437219,
-0.037390735,
-0.0388514064,
0.0440141298,
-0.0165974498,
0.0178954005,
0.0436685681,
0.0593377687,
0.0626579747,
-0.0095504792,
-0.0016571746,
-0.0131275086,
0.0107130697,
0.0214191582,
0.0103826271,
-0.020152986,
-5.448038321e-33,
-0.0258172527,
-0.0236982778,
-0.0106515763,
0.0258997232,
-0.0116945291,
-0.0056447438,
-0.0158491675,
-0.0079971822,
0.0024535402,
0.0288169272,
-0.0291463509,
-0.0377818421,
0.0330862738,
0.0501241609,
0.0001154072,
0.0135546355,
0.055868417,
0.0098863328,
-0.0369197167,
0.0408082679,
0.0387784429,
0.0413694903,
0.0488266535,
-0.0784525722,
-0.0046198484,
-0.0029152993,
-0.0168773569,
-0.0022373409,
0.0726738945,
0.0247760508,
0.0028083208,
0.0273081306,
-0.0004420193,
-0.0533449426,
-0.0054370188,
0.0635828599,
-0.0538583472,
-0.0213934425,
-0.0177863203,
-0.0023826701,
-0.0213692542,
-0.0405103005,
0.0340927355,
-0.0315610617,
0.0085960841,
0.0160046164,
0.0758457109,
-0.0338615254,
-0.0101731978,
-0.0514644496,
-0.0607998036,
0.0049170395,
0.0021247407,
-0.0474758893,
-0.0089223776,
-0.0154068302,
0.0266805124,
-0.0067087435,
-0.0232700817,
0.051984638,
0.0170470402,
0.0149229513,
0.0541865826,
0.0768856183,
-0.0089131324,
0.0229331776,
0.0092047686,
0.0085879108,
-0.027334122,
-0.0088159088,
0.0109145753,
0.0434326231,
-0.0158540849,
0.074995406,
0.002341408,
-0.0135362595,
-0.0017793507,
0.0374422707,
0.0022740848,
-0.0165154822,
-0.025839787,
0.0287367404,
-0.0007269423,
0.0011983892,
-0.0153706241,
-0.0423574261,
-0.0185210351,
-0.0314571112,
0.0152347973,
0.0190521851,
-0.0267184582,
0.0219162907,
0.0336712748,
0.0091540907,
-0.0375451259,
-0.0045272172,
-0.0308319442,
0.0451965928,
-0.0188125577,
-0.0460993797,
-0.0011585826,
-0.0443311557,
0.0685959831,
0.0360487625,
-0.0186757203,
0.0129405633,
0.0587424226,
0.0451379046,
-0.0629365742,
-0.0088507719,
0.0037271739,
0.002858317,
0.0236449726,
0.0204592776,
0.0230124388,
-0.01766688,
-0.071137175,
0.0365331694,
-0.0100041153,
-0.0351188928,
0.0129612274,
-0.0181125142,
-0.0042493399,
0.0299364142,
-0.0601090193,
-0.0175666083,
-0.0422634706,
0.0192460287,
0.0409677699,
-0.0482238494,
-0.0165910702,
-0.0046088025,
2.664e-7,
-0.002463537,
-0.0274417661,
0.0329021923,
0.0406890325,
0.0182013121,
0.0524782017,
0.0162853654,
0.0600639358,
-0.0067132101,
-0.041697517,
-0.0060416036,
-0.0091408379,
0.02477815,
-0.0374664366,
-0.0793813542,
0.0145339938,
0.0117377872,
0.0237893891,
-0.0341835022,
0.0370022245,
0.050955914,
0.0566270649,
-0.0107379612,
-0.0446562842,
0.0781394169,
-0.0180287827,
0.0586827472,
0.0027035445,
0.0340470076,
-0.0110929357,
0.0191144049,
-0.0379388854,
-0.0344795734,
0.0253718961,
-0.0133386943,
-0.0090764966,
0.0566852354,
0.0244924892,
0.0141408099,
0.0309270304,
-0.0300898813,
0.0288538001,
0.0033869089,
-0.008609172,
0.0692572072,
-0.015174984,
-0.0142555153,
-0.0733126998,
-0.0222264547,
-0.0023038224,
-0.0105621135,
-0.0497319847,
0.0002457979,
0.0412566587,
0.008478106,
-0.0152809508,
-0.025480764,
-0.0594540872,
-0.0519112423,
-0.050223615,
-0.021368593,
-0.0077063357,
-0.0422286466,
-0.0006795388,
0.0487371609,
-0.0255551226,
0.0047883731,
1.862096583e-34,
0.0015725235,
-0.0076750633,
0.0177875683,
-0.0020132121,
-0.0273861922,
0.0179578979,
0.0221313387,
0.0004564717,
0.0160655398,
-0.048498977,
-0.0310739819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15190v1 | f-Divergence Minimization for Sequence-Level Knowledge Distillation | 2023-07-27T20:39:06 | 2023-07-27T20:39:06 | Yuqiao Wen, Zichao Li, Wenyu Du, Lili Mou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.6; I.2.m; I.5.1; I.7.m | Knowledge distillation (KD) is the process of transferring knowledge from a
large model to a small one. It has gained increasing attention in the natural
language processing community, driven by the demands of compressing
ever-growing language models. In this work, we propose an f-DISTILL framework,
which formulates sequence-level knowledge distillation as minimizing a
generalized f-divergence function. We propose four distilling variants under
our framework and show that existing SeqKD and ENGINE approaches are
approximations of our f-DISTILL methods. We further derive step-wise
decomposition for our f-DISTILL, reducing intractable sequence-level divergence
to word-level losses that can be computed in a tractable manner. Experiments
across four datasets show that our methods outperform existing KD approaches,
and that our symmetric distilling losses can better force the student to learn
from the teacher distribution. | [
-0.0125417029,
0.0842170566,
-0.0026184088,
0.0326096714,
-0.050150428,
0.0244020093,
-0.0265238788,
0.0087446673,
-0.0401904918,
0.0017252872,
0.0414034761,
-0.0173393115,
0.0432475582,
0.0265559778,
0.0115917847,
-0.0563027188,
0.0327632837,
-0.0396113023,
-0.0032666435,
-0.0160801522,
0.0084106652,
-0.0055952519,
-0.002105698,
0.0017341893,
0.0146247214,
-0.0228783935,
-0.0361588784,
-0.0201865509,
0.0214588549,
0.0171308164,
0.0109357331,
0.0667302012,
0.0252081994,
0.0037064981,
0.0000020921,
0.0012701874,
-0.0061896583,
-0.0055640298,
-0.0387701094,
0.0483021848,
-0.0148556922,
-0.0128828036,
0.0404983051,
-0.0019231829,
-0.042079486,
-0.0297201257,
0.0365374982,
0.0216282457,
0.0854014456,
0.0697923675,
0.0230759494,
-0.0960916057,
0.0265132524,
-0.0248394571,
-0.003386368,
-0.0276362021,
0.0469455943,
0.0006729683,
-0.0525268465,
-0.0400688574,
-0.0514526665,
0.0608921647,
0.0001423198,
0.0220005605,
0.0086441012,
-0.002601245,
-0.0256540049,
-0.0385225713,
-0.0028513165,
0.0669815615,
-0.034034878,
-0.0155077465,
0.0174888391,
0.0077378866,
-0.0144900773,
0.0162877198,
-0.0384782217,
-0.0136658838,
0.0128549347,
0.0262224898,
-0.0055285217,
-0.030139083,
0.0336245671,
-0.0236514825,
-0.0618439205,
0.0030381468,
0.0036229684,
-0.0193181206,
-0.0014929568,
-0.0110610267,
-0.070666559,
-0.0190238431,
0.0165117886,
0.0048018089,
0.0133326482,
0.0178313628,
-0.0299359895,
-0.0602631681,
-0.0252647717,
0.0230907053,
0.0300187953,
0.0193326306,
0.0289894808,
0.0093044927,
0.0162392966,
0.0401695557,
0.0280971099,
0.0009515699,
-0.0231412798,
0.0299511012,
-0.0754890293,
-0.00850676,
-0.0301148631,
0.0197636802,
-0.049708467,
0.0010665091,
-0.0080238022,
-0.0381082594,
-0.0273379404,
-0.0281318184,
0.0300237741,
0.0168775469,
-0.0075647593,
0.0153870173,
-0.0054071555,
0.0926787481,
-0.0361837521,
-0.015087802,
0.0199926011,
-0.0115804905,
-0.0348736383,
-0.0179516189,
0.0379322805,
0.0134153729,
-0.0179057084,
0.0025995236,
0.0045752493,
-0.0411441922,
-0.0475647897,
-0.0452229604,
-0.0204640292,
-0.0997855216,
-0.0240479205,
-0.0797568411,
0.0589986891,
-0.009719546,
0.0111139053,
-0.0780358538,
0.012717328,
-0.0087429946,
-0.013101317,
0.0640837923,
0.0008036771,
0.00928587,
0.0089318203,
0.0379348211,
-0.0053201942,
0.0832111388,
-0.0061732382,
-0.0105568739,
0.0096610822,
-0.0215398744,
-0.0416287966,
0.0161036048,
0.0651738569,
0.0273298342,
-0.0454463102,
-0.0379966162,
-0.033844661,
-0.0007699892,
0.0295245182,
0.0487964191,
-0.0510102287,
-0.006850169,
0.0348218307,
0.0412198678,
0.067268528,
0.0231672805,
0.0043463018,
0.0407586619,
-0.0002671683,
0.0502645746,
0.0104230959,
-0.024388263,
-0.0041440707,
0.0031250161,
0.0482584126,
0.0555371679,
-0.0229622126,
-0.0504542924,
0.0355489738,
-0.0050947187,
0.0162360594,
0.0121521456,
0.0302630179,
0.0196660738,
0.008936841,
0.0628129393,
0.0575456582,
-0.0662899688,
0.0160554275,
0.0165447798,
-0.0030473857,
0.0429480188,
0.0238518156,
-0.0324365012,
0.0038299474,
-0.0033002696,
0.0064785192,
-0.0359432176,
0.0002108382,
-0.0227146391,
0.0360071734,
-0.0261697061,
-0.0542150959,
0.0435756445,
0.0335890464,
-0.026535295,
0.0256634653,
0.0161423031,
0.046038419,
-0.0671826154,
-0.0261846744,
0.0222921334,
-0.0446092673,
-0.0548421741,
-0.0183924921,
0.0363898724,
0.0342623033,
0.0314978957,
0.0029145065,
0.0091799572,
0.0511068515,
-0.0304636583,
-0.0097640129,
-0.061629504,
-0.0248704329,
-0.1135529354,
0.0742294714,
-0.0597238988,
0.0287914891,
0.0506651364,
-0.0766330734,
-0.0505881533,
0.0025766261,
-0.0197409447,
0.0363203622,
-0.0194383096,
0.0476174653,
0.0270010997,
0.0196900312,
-0.0171990395,
0.0498060249,
-0.0675536245,
0.0308385603,
-0.0378593095,
-0.0486785881,
-0.0470748246,
0.0165469069,
-0.0363641754,
0.0090665715,
-0.0237839222,
0.0256048385,
0.0364045799,
-0.0290542226,
-0.0297496263,
0.0125904158,
-0.0274738111,
0.0144338226,
-0.0328262672,
0.0399277508,
0.004208338,
0.040005032,
0.0288135968,
0.0146687087,
-0.024346929,
0.0123465359,
-0.0253388807,
0.0145767201,
0.0034792016,
-0.0046440233,
-0.0213490296,
-0.0003108882,
-0.0420332253,
0.0068866634,
0.0710590482,
-0.0878667459,
-0.0004364797,
-0.0347249806,
0.0295091532,
-0.0496123619,
0.0268383995,
-0.0052896966,
-0.0007693805,
-0.0132288067,
-0.0323127508,
0.01877282,
0.0039312663,
-0.0174289402,
0.0208622161,
0.0292383991,
-0.0024874017,
-0.0606285445,
0.0042910189,
-0.043404337,
0.020410683,
-0.0414827913,
-0.0253984146,
0.000257505,
0.080567874,
-0.0169661529,
-0.0198267847,
-0.039629288,
0.0095834145,
0.0091683539,
-0.0408747047,
-0.0290597882,
0.0298034474,
-0.0209370814,
0.011343318,
-0.0162527654,
-0.0327325761,
0.0541015603,
-0.0165293887,
0.0230793562,
-0.0388282016,
-0.0139299994,
-0.0014103645,
0.0426431559,
-0.0239356663,
0.0192459412,
0.0044926917,
0.0003377307,
-0.0504810102,
0.0136930915,
0.0432102233,
-0.0259026177,
0.0941556469,
-0.0507070087,
-0.0183148235,
0.00943093,
-0.0051118284,
-0.0008085708,
-0.0362980776,
0.0222962908,
0.0130276876,
0.023360664,
-0.0242078379,
-0.0450565554,
-0.0082855653,
0.0062416601,
0.0286470652,
0.0343783759,
0.0004090746,
-0.0247904547,
0.0630762726,
0.043390397,
0.0081842234,
0.0088513177,
-0.0457052924,
0.0395242013,
0.0541776307,
0.0502087139,
-0.0181455091,
0.0110569689,
-0.0037411682,
0.0298934858,
-0.0345494412,
-0.0294195507,
0.0230725631,
0.0271383766,
-0.0615555085,
0.0007759026,
0.0721409172,
-0.0034427319,
-0.0178207085,
0.0314592384,
0.0552766807,
0.0972366557,
0.0036355811,
-0.0185955819,
-0.1014159471,
-0.0409306735,
-0.0035702754,
0.0446830764,
0.0473187678,
-0.0469044559,
-0.0010240411,
-0.0635341927,
-0.0165835936,
0.0474564396,
-0.0129517643,
-0.0747331828,
-0.0499348529,
-0.0162455365,
-0.0055639152,
-0.016499171,
0.0170382764,
-0.0169023369,
0.0206467975,
0.022354627,
0.0122416085,
-0.0562075302,
-0.0206306484,
-0.0134489341,
0.0136083057,
0.0461042225,
0.0148899183,
0.0299149882,
-0.0253042597,
-0.0480880179,
-0.0317585282,
-0.0364196226,
-0.024370838,
0.0498567633,
-0.0025738806,
0.0072205947,
0.0353755504,
0.0384777263,
-0.039056696,
0.0055393847,
0.0174786747,
0.0779441297,
0.0315593854,
-0.0487508737,
0.0058834101,
-0.0403390117,
0.0334568843,
0.0898363963,
0.0548312254,
-0.006783295,
-0.0228971597,
-0.0104256412,
0.0220120326,
0.0233369749,
0.0007091174,
-0.0141792223,
-0.022887243,
-0.0419156849,
-0.0649312884,
0.0020630376,
0.0318620615,
0.0418549553,
-0.0096787959,
0.014931391,
0.0421669967,
0.0136666605,
-0.070555985,
-0.0107068121,
-0.0051565422,
-0.0023727075,
0.0077218302,
-0.0041863909,
-0.0399259925,
0.0109873768,
-0.0450969189,
0.0247077402,
-0.1323182285,
-0.0754144266,
0.0179432612,
0.0241928995,
0.0135768997,
0.0557037964,
0.0235883687,
-0.0242100246,
0.075549528,
0.0373626798,
-0.024680296,
0.0162751712,
0.0534788668,
-0.037362244,
0.0085198758,
0.0658910796,
-0.0095700677,
-0.0300469752,
0.0061567933,
0.1095836759,
-0.0193539355,
-0.0318357386,
0.0071544065,
0.0416014865,
0.0550803132,
-0.0046030232,
-0.0256455727,
-0.0009055299,
0.0244453046,
0.0325251408,
-0.0013747542,
-0.0718686357,
0.0069311415,
0.0292856842,
-0.00128999,
0.0087818857,
0.017344946,
0.054453712,
-0.0308318362,
-0.0385855213,
0.0127292285,
0.0258112717,
-0.0247496311,
0.0897234157,
-0.0090433545,
0.008112927,
0.0209912043,
0.0045373715,
-0.0036186283,
-0.031569045,
0.0279582292,
0.0063134856,
0.0519005023,
-0.0273578875,
0.0028687401,
-0.0435963199,
-0.05466922,
-0.0306704585,
0.0169038344,
0.0311921891,
-0.0001509912,
0.0686540902,
-0.0061889747,
-0.0054974123,
-0.0371427909,
0.0264162924,
-0.0310171172,
0.0242696647,
0.0072993161,
0.0254012551,
-0.000699868,
0.025916202,
0.1159084067,
-0.0104124816,
0.0733719543,
-0.0282771531,
-0.0011883293,
-0.037331,
-0.0767840967,
0.0274945665,
0.0664421618,
-0.00737079,
-0.0024539712,
-0.0491443686,
-0.0813012943,
-0.0271957815,
-0.0361661017,
-0.0071301484,
0.0016159447,
0.0609978661,
0.0342875794,
-0.0369632207,
-0.018163126,
-0.0299189594,
0.0033568975,
-0.0116918022,
-0.0611695535,
0.0386515409,
-6.182873268e-33,
0.0036316288,
0.0306467973,
-0.0286081228,
0.015475668,
-0.0458703898,
0.0158235654,
-0.0076465821,
0.001110918,
0.0042298022,
0.040190991,
-0.006352121,
0.0294386838,
0.0082146544,
0.0441095307,
-0.0203649011,
-0.0041419473,
0.0841286182,
0.0133303292,
0.0033827934,
0.0488111041,
0.0364392735,
0.0657695159,
0.0444559157,
-0.0108658485,
-0.0000794115,
-0.0366154276,
0.0193924271,
0.0204622224,
0.0275515858,
-0.001587134,
-0.0241551567,
0.0546468124,
-0.0144657493,
-0.0637204498,
-0.052936893,
-0.0192794986,
-0.1037982851,
-0.0283718314,
0.0279270113,
-0.0278477687,
-0.0324917547,
-0.0057394519,
0.0577493049,
0.0034643651,
0.0375704095,
-0.0423856005,
0.0089802453,
0.0091222059,
-0.0480939746,
-0.0433829576,
-0.0475800745,
0.0241840612,
-0.0395045578,
-0.0399952233,
0.0732895061,
-0.0156760607,
0.0015438477,
-0.0480618291,
-0.0390182436,
0.0182836168,
0.0624312572,
0.0888584703,
0.0563064478,
0.015148879,
-0.0074821408,
0.0424822159,
0.0245018546,
-0.0335313715,
-0.0056847273,
-0.0168345403,
0.0434539504,
0.0658027679,
-0.0392459966,
0.0153855495,
0.0690409616,
-0.0186692942,
-0.0618097037,
0.003408066,
-0.0309577268,
0.0499746092,
-0.056365896,
0.0161417369,
0.0036081588,
-0.042623885,
-0.0646571442,
-0.0129543524,
0.0065682563,
0.0100445691,
0.0179533474,
0.0185212884,
-0.0638752878,
-0.0279077888,
0.0024066714,
-0.080662705,
0.0066132969,
0.058138784,
0.0038142626,
-0.0054562911,
0.015116076,
0.0136843389,
-0.0651622713,
0.0043256031,
-0.0079997675,
-0.0219993535,
0.0048467126,
-0.0164196268,
0.0249955002,
0.0212415289,
-0.0342945978,
-0.0183953829,
-0.047550384,
-0.0135432873,
-0.0048337118,
0.0494242087,
0.0663007647,
-0.0048337295,
-0.0084165232,
-0.0244824924,
0.0433620177,
0.0041785841,
-0.0048253308,
0.0314140692,
0.0347703509,
0.0279462785,
-0.0027882876,
-0.0267337728,
-0.0348782949,
-0.0070279464,
0.0447941422,
-0.0265366919,
-0.0201050267,
0.0159176849,
2.657e-7,
0.0314634591,
0.0100906175,
0.0213207062,
-0.0117722768,
-0.0060290173,
0.0221091975,
-0.0043767728,
-0.0088327006,
-0.0244215298,
-0.0372603796,
0.0328629054,
0.039973069,
0.0432403833,
0.0097697051,
-0.0753066987,
-0.0124859465,
-0.0400824696,
-0.0200054739,
-0.0110476436,
-0.0461381227,
0.027907446,
0.0518832132,
0.0283578523,
-0.0363093838,
0.0145135624,
0.0026585546,
0.0048827995,
0.0198622774,
0.0521414056,
0.0285262894,
0.0371010453,
-0.0442874618,
0.0151452851,
0.0153900571,
-0.0357470252,
0.0203083158,
-0.0029833894,
0.0755231008,
-0.007348571,
-0.0159924217,
-0.0321890116,
0.0009327487,
-0.0023499574,
-0.0495199822,
0.0530669875,
-0.0017938054,
0.0208069328,
-0.0243654847,
-0.0623407178,
-0.0247062892,
0.02476638,
0.0218060371,
0.0232188608,
0.0405470319,
-0.0001114921,
0.0026033672,
-0.0417933576,
-0.0584099703,
-0.0046996358,
0.025036199,
-0.0257908683,
-0.0559660681,
-0.0270314757,
-0.019427292,
-0.0085717607,
-0.033072494,
-0.000402135,
2.355989833e-34,
0.0152083188,
0.006816763,
0.0066346265,
0.0059162723,
-0.0111002252,
-0.0542363785,
-0.0612688772,
0.0086347656,
-0.0155061027,
-0.0676531792,
-0.0115824826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15176v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15176v3 | RCT Rejection Sampling for Causal Estimation Evaluation | 2023-07-27T20:11:07 | 2024-01-31T12:40:40 | Katherine A. Keith, Sergey Feldman, David Jurgens, Jonathan Bragg, Rohit Bhattacharya | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME | Confounding is a significant obstacle to unbiased estimation of causal
effects from observational data. For settings with high-dimensional covariates
-- such as text data, genomics, or the behavioral social sciences --
researchers have proposed methods to adjust for confounding by adapting machine
learning methods to the goal of causal estimation. However, empirical
evaluation of these adjustment methods has been challenging and limited. In
this work, we build on a promising empirical evaluation strategy that
simplifies evaluation design and uses real data: subsampling randomized
controlled trials (RCTs) to create confounded observational datasets while
using the average causal effects from the RCTs as ground-truth. We contribute a
new sampling algorithm, which we call RCT rejection sampling, and provide
theoretical guarantees that causal identification holds in the observational
data to allow for valid comparisons to the ground-truth RCT. Using synthetic
data, we show our algorithm indeed results in low bias when oracle estimators
are evaluated on the confounded samples, which is not always the case for a
previously proposed algorithm. In addition to this identification result, we
highlight several finite data considerations for evaluation designers who plan
to use RCT rejection sampling on their own datasets. As a proof of concept, we
implement an example evaluation pipeline and walk through these finite data
considerations with a novel, real-world RCT -- which we release publicly --
consisting of approximately 70k observations and text data as high-dimensional
covariates. Together, these contributions build towards a broader agenda of
improved empirical evaluation for causal estimation. | [
-0.0130123915,
0.1052815542,
-0.0367920995,
-0.0402159318,
-0.0287854671,
0.0355061032,
0.051740177,
0.0292564835,
0.0209924038,
-0.0131620076,
0.0547873527,
0.0459143259,
-0.0171819869,
0.0294876453,
0.0449685343,
0.0019508182,
0.0183281749,
-0.0083991708,
0.033690121,
-0.0348231494,
-0.0527371839,
-0.0250520334,
0.0033111786,
0.0236396547,
0.0035220284,
-0.0014266187,
0.0413571745,
0.0172297135,
-0.0030619102,
-0.034128312,
0.0344620571,
0.0300573595,
0.0034433133,
0.0563357845,
0.0000021539,
-0.0244328603,
-0.0274971593,
0.0272388831,
-0.0212518591,
0.01986349,
0.0097120525,
0.000664559,
0.0516041741,
0.0205458552,
0.0283758417,
-0.0103505207,
0.0297077298,
0.0403225794,
-0.0424668007,
0.0332781002,
-0.0097126234,
0.0159811229,
-0.0232382193,
-0.0571454428,
0.0304780416,
0.0214256924,
0.0274256933,
-0.017801648,
-0.0256423429,
-0.0424291193,
-0.0276237484,
0.0157924481,
0.0265797563,
0.032615114,
0.0105902851,
0.0173424762,
-0.0379838049,
0.0128132198,
0.0004470864,
0.0553889386,
0.0679478273,
-0.0114208609,
0.0404825322,
-0.0255570058,
0.0532299317,
0.036484316,
-0.04430224,
-0.0199267361,
-0.0111447331,
-0.0084569212,
0.0104243681,
0.0026435473,
0.0528216437,
0.0204918347,
0.0182598326,
0.0541790314,
0.0033984322,
-0.050581295,
0.0184056703,
0.0709305853,
0.0532115027,
-0.0149174016,
-0.0227681715,
-0.0595909506,
-0.0461492203,
-0.013076175,
0.0298050959,
-0.0485810526,
0.0298540164,
0.0194778722,
0.0263495557,
0.0037146388,
-0.0338441916,
0.0214943681,
0.0105269039,
-0.0042749266,
-0.0455696359,
0.105507955,
0.0222749617,
0.0365476571,
-0.0335514843,
0.0110106794,
0.0346075445,
0.0072522294,
-0.0340572409,
0.0384901315,
-0.0514509343,
0.0105890147,
-0.0385255702,
-0.0189195015,
-0.0538053289,
0.027615035,
-0.0467388295,
0.028536329,
-0.0073578916,
-0.0032610181,
-0.0405917503,
0.0484312102,
-0.0196241252,
-0.0415362902,
-0.0302793346,
0.0085557261,
0.0234978925,
-0.0444954,
0.0335807428,
0.0735210255,
0.0612271316,
-0.0395084508,
-0.0029504595,
-0.024894014,
-0.0348573774,
-0.0219956897,
0.0272887684,
-0.0508605652,
-0.0037369295,
0.0017480589,
0.0257571489,
-0.0383662358,
-0.0353765637,
-0.0229713805,
-0.0845933631,
0.0007098947,
-0.0134945866,
-0.0072159418,
-0.0179496873,
-0.0136868106,
-0.0082334196,
0.0669083446,
0.0326470099,
0.0026792914,
0.0392882749,
-0.0243978295,
0.0113072507,
0.0070711672,
0.0704705343,
0.0192434881,
-0.0220431481,
-0.0197664965,
0.0105597982,
0.0003004089,
-0.0049970862,
-0.0379031152,
-0.0540135466,
0.0380320027,
0.0323225074,
-0.0367667787,
-0.0159068406,
0.0203941632,
-0.0026757962,
-0.0455785468,
-0.0378270969,
0.0056013702,
-0.0666836724,
0.0035435779,
-0.0553704761,
-0.0222331956,
0.0390702412,
-0.0252839513,
-0.0266560111,
-0.0260111205,
0.023633251,
0.0392883271,
-0.0329230465,
0.0226425268,
0.0720653087,
-0.0138409445,
-0.006651158,
-0.0677863583,
0.0441947393,
0.0140297208,
-0.0125492858,
0.0205361079,
0.0132196881,
0.0021186303,
0.0415677205,
-0.0536110513,
0.042219609,
-0.0367824771,
0.0137769766,
-0.0365427434,
0.0190352723,
0.0002510358,
0.0306791514,
0.0512381531,
-0.0355830118,
-0.0028679015,
0.0477763414,
0.0521661192,
0.0257177819,
0.0137074264,
-0.035722848,
-0.0535146967,
-0.0460896678,
0.0330631547,
-0.0108623924,
-0.0450137779,
0.0280153453,
-0.0261100661,
0.0665175989,
-0.0133817205,
-0.0638955832,
-0.0156035563,
-0.0166197531,
-0.0021939601,
-0.0228840578,
-0.0006916397,
0.060018722,
-0.0422598608,
-0.0538571402,
-0.1056621894,
-0.0372451544,
0.0327487662,
-0.0596995354,
0.0069511975,
0.0608821809,
0.0245608464,
0.0313827954,
0.0178709272,
-0.0178756118,
-0.0180208329,
0.024807727,
-0.0058504432,
0.0098697888,
0.0065505966,
-0.0010554455,
0.0074381861,
-0.062326625,
0.0228419807,
-0.0591323934,
-0.0270801652,
-0.0436651334,
-0.0373566747,
-0.0589061528,
0.0315734334,
-0.0210034475,
-0.0198444501,
0.0061560031,
-0.0450525135,
0.0182541106,
-0.0324733369,
-0.0227509197,
-0.0276184902,
-0.0025966708,
-0.0035214599,
-0.0340037234,
-0.0040319557,
-0.0446492657,
0.0474899225,
0.0562159531,
-0.0017999361,
-0.0221247561,
-0.0101680551,
-0.0778426975,
-0.0370482057,
-0.0530338623,
0.0548133329,
0.0676701888,
-0.0150441658,
0.0067097545,
-0.0438553542,
0.0115766237,
-0.0257525686,
-0.0167161096,
0.0202684887,
-0.0390391834,
0.0198821891,
-0.042902492,
0.0812968239,
-0.0284395609,
-0.0002418428,
0.0330746882,
0.0249856003,
-0.0360702947,
0.0026154937,
-0.056777209,
-0.0248482376,
-0.0079964008,
-0.0249435734,
0.0180885214,
0.0059560551,
-0.0043749069,
0.0046296222,
-0.0369818732,
0.0342813693,
0.0212842561,
-0.0308949333,
-0.0586479418,
-0.0039735134,
-0.0308068208,
0.0359579362,
-0.0623228922,
-0.1033707187,
0.0336287171,
0.0412904508,
0.0317543894,
-0.028380882,
0.0438089967,
0.0044801822,
0.0022303148,
0.046983026,
-0.015999211,
0.0415748358,
0.0428080633,
0.0061036083,
-0.0223977994,
0.03840499,
0.0120438831,
-0.0138107138,
-0.0751811564,
0.028673945,
0.0271605868,
-0.0643015504,
-0.0361470059,
-0.0770882815,
-0.0061025983,
-0.028699955,
0.0431478508,
0.0018790157,
-0.0270127356,
-0.0606628768,
0.032950379,
0.0251698941,
-0.0231807325,
-0.0097725978,
0.021208819,
-0.0687796697,
0.0264583379,
-0.0358159356,
0.0571659245,
-0.053106159,
0.0092462199,
-0.0164555777,
0.0413911343,
0.0098148771,
0.0011611708,
0.0532888323,
-0.0164571479,
-0.0093191853,
0.0157735273,
0.0132176848,
0.0145817222,
0.0310073663,
0.0008639658,
0.0556743853,
0.0072904276,
-0.0568711013,
0.0428881273,
0.029968217,
0.0493887588,
0.0019365418,
-0.0087486301,
-0.0780088976,
-0.0030301015,
0.0069121276,
0.0358017534,
-0.0420510508,
-0.0299159251,
0.0507399552,
-0.1006581634,
0.0622096844,
0.004228245,
-0.057833828,
-0.0330304429,
-0.0319280401,
0.0140235629,
-0.0661195517,
-0.0423990265,
-0.0026901725,
0.0007734218,
0.0052932519,
0.0105567584,
-0.0281352438,
-0.0577155128,
-0.0115933046,
-0.0399687178,
0.0536873303,
0.0315407477,
0.0143988365,
-0.0226736907,
0.0370048992,
-0.0237932298,
0.0051106685,
-0.0275941137,
0.0153242545,
0.1406280845,
0.0395596474,
-0.0133979972,
-0.0254691653,
0.0595366657,
-0.0452209227,
-0.0086872466,
0.0403855294,
0.0357511081,
-0.0046987794,
-0.0063980073,
0.0270691533,
-0.0343549401,
0.007418822,
0.0587195978,
0.0027104856,
-0.0304949451,
-0.0383006334,
0.0031828668,
-0.0367189161,
-0.0471282676,
0.0287806354,
0.0014826879,
-0.0201100931,
-0.0303969104,
-0.0095709078,
-0.0202168878,
0.0263579581,
0.0100625493,
0.0041740965,
-0.0055481121,
-0.0157551393,
-0.0318345316,
-0.0237019863,
0.0433408692,
-0.0196154676,
0.0114702489,
-0.0006616864,
-0.0271667838,
-0.044385951,
-0.0340807587,
-0.0223390646,
0.0595872439,
-0.0566638559,
-0.0492340103,
0.036565952,
0.034259785,
0.0266564935,
0.0779081509,
-0.0035616723,
-0.0199473277,
0.0090948595,
0.0038456121,
-0.008013539,
0.0159236062,
0.0027690218,
-0.0482279807,
-0.00285112,
-0.0152341593,
-0.0296233129,
0.0044572093,
0.0425200723,
-0.0243635923,
0.0115031479,
0.0194206741,
0.0184331369,
0.0036122263,
0.1197645366,
-0.0463025905,
-0.01910647,
-0.01923999,
-0.0050400211,
-0.0023597844,
0.0143986037,
0.0101193925,
-0.0039482699,
0.022183938,
0.0382071175,
-0.0468280353,
-0.0159567818,
-0.060517922,
0.0041314648,
-0.0655067489,
0.0445568152,
0.00127398,
0.0276872162,
0.0267663486,
0.0154084992,
0.0276801009,
0.0247295946,
0.0366156623,
0.055599425,
0.0253284406,
0.0059034862,
0.0156419203,
0.049670402,
-0.0099003306,
-0.0352304466,
-0.0914226994,
0.0159704555,
0.0004777265,
0.0067220265,
0.0205776393,
-0.0522192195,
0.0416271016,
-0.0297245048,
-0.0136090647,
-0.0539833196,
0.00816222,
0.001081351,
0.0123862047,
0.0092925169,
-0.0189254433,
-0.0568044037,
0.0144463135,
0.0504463352,
0.0514031462,
0.0587277785,
-0.0692369044,
-0.0230377875,
0.0034752144,
-0.0489555113,
0.0211363342,
0.0187523607,
-0.0206130594,
-0.0231385231,
-0.0976979733,
-0.0583267026,
0.0173253212,
-0.0109944884,
0.0495859496,
0.0133608542,
-0.0482401289,
-0.0165318511,
-0.0193609297,
-0.004343553,
-0.00723487,
0.0377585664,
-0.0673058704,
-0.0743874237,
-0.0381684005,
-6.263988256e-33,
-0.0025156222,
-0.0183354411,
-0.0517410897,
-0.0145850079,
0.0067134979,
0.0253933072,
-0.0345921069,
0.0017701022,
0.0418135449,
0.026586704,
-0.0074926713,
0.0226779524,
0.0107853077,
0.0382733233,
0.0318167917,
-0.0259488877,
0.0192804746,
0.0016397291,
-0.022379484,
0.0297901854,
-0.0184239596,
0.0286910702,
0.0252773874,
-0.0853990093,
0.0413719453,
0.0315815806,
0.023746768,
-0.049731452,
-0.0609678216,
0.0462653562,
0.0158425216,
0.0407734141,
0.0125921397,
-0.0460740626,
0.0226951763,
-0.0131783783,
-0.0790346488,
-0.000823241,
0.0287369825,
-0.0049216547,
-0.0191487242,
-0.0108300205,
-0.0061390973,
0.037505459,
-0.0326425023,
0.0077051544,
0.0171461422,
-0.0269146468,
-0.004997116,
-0.017707251,
-0.0348383822,
0.0203719549,
-0.0685723573,
0.0400761142,
-0.0226740688,
0.0670827031,
0.0102341371,
0.0550755747,
-0.0008374124,
0.0187733714,
0.0248185657,
-0.0414091498,
0.0038911118,
0.0405304134,
0.0216092523,
0.0679744855,
0.0005511669,
0.0172667224,
-0.0106828958,
-0.0098676626,
0.022323126,
-0.0046825097,
0.040405713,
0.1191113442,
0.0793684348,
-0.006763068,
-0.1039397269,
0.0280693304,
-0.0071478095,
-0.0409121253,
0.0326692015,
-0.0171810351,
-0.0160383917,
-0.0084659262,
-0.0548629649,
-0.0594116189,
-0.0011029092,
0.0208333805,
0.0353009775,
0.0245389361,
-0.0225806683,
-0.0092274128,
0.0723247081,
-0.0199636035,
-0.0098506659,
0.0055761142,
-0.0208950732,
0.0043744347,
0.0136535354,
-0.0161536075,
-0.0382771231,
-0.0049053412,
0.0181151815,
0.0588652045,
0.0796936974,
-0.019751234,
0.0612383559,
-0.0364649557,
-0.0362810008,
0.0221794154,
-0.0290455148,
0.0235222578,
0.0182092227,
-0.0318182036,
0.0521899685,
0.0145856254,
0.0106654558,
0.003151404,
0.0196404662,
0.0134434095,
-0.0095862886,
-0.0348104723,
-0.0266448986,
-0.025183348,
-0.0163821951,
-0.0078015206,
0.0552960373,
-0.0315381773,
-0.002196806,
-0.0543948933,
0.0032085865,
-0.0340850726,
2.738e-7,
0.0498265438,
0.0341672786,
0.0565672144,
-0.0198922362,
0.0539562479,
0.0002447726,
0.0148496656,
0.0535861067,
0.0091724796,
0.0094740968,
0.038962245,
0.0087459898,
0.0609808452,
-0.054189235,
-0.0219696593,
0.0018762155,
-0.0390257724,
0.010630778,
-0.0315333828,
-0.0190196205,
0.0345597863,
0.0337003767,
0.0227423236,
-0.0017552528,
0.0048065237,
0.0316275209,
0.031172622,
-0.0765212923,
0.0183626357,
-0.0099476017,
-0.0067888312,
0.0019522612,
0.0028552141,
0.0847735181,
-0.0315993316,
-0.0245672092,
-0.0373862758,
0.0278892927,
0.0042812889,
0.0265533049,
-0.0416125804,
-0.009499087,
0.0382002778,
-0.0301891342,
0.0623332821,
-0.0181714855,
-0.0316275917,
0.0226830635,
-0.0385805331,
0.0053742761,
0.0750330761,
0.0279795248,
0.0453763604,
0.0150822205,
0.002999617,
0.040975526,
-0.0014486276,
-0.0072948295,
-0.0093346713,
0.0423113964,
-0.020573454,
-0.0352416523,
0.0111834556,
-0.0002825091,
-0.0157964714,
-0.0362135842,
0.0129637672,
2.806850232e-34,
0.0345017128,
0.0220702514,
0.0230947267,
-0.0937049612,
0.0465911739,
-0.0104559287,
-0.0007422348,
-0.0268249009,
0.0206287615,
-0.0670606792,
0.0540273972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15164v1 | VISU at WASSA 2023 Shared Task: Detecting Emotions in Reaction to News Stories Leveraging BERT and Stacked Embeddings | 2023-07-27T19:42:22 | 2023-07-27T19:42:22 | Vivek Kumar, Sushmita Singh, Prayag Tiwari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Our system, VISU, participated in the WASSA 2023 Shared Task (3) of Emotion
Classification from essays written in reaction to news articles. Emotion
detection from complex dialogues is challenging and often requires
context/domain understanding. Therefore in this research, we have focused on
developing deep learning (DL) models using the combination of word embedding
representations with tailored prepossessing strategies to capture the nuances
of emotions expressed. Our experiments used static and contextual embeddings
(individual and stacked) with Bidirectional Long short-term memory (BiLSTM) and
Transformer based models. We occupied rank tenth in the emotion detection task
by scoring a Macro F1-Score of 0.2717, validating the efficacy of our
implemented approaches for small and imbalanced datasets with mixed categories
of target emotions. | [
0.0107937977,
0.0576080829,
0.0255018957,
0.0284390524,
0.0133059165,
0.0062832525,
-0.0091592353,
-0.0327765234,
0.0246812105,
-0.062331479,
-0.0439896695,
-0.0616301745,
-0.0363808908,
0.0173749086,
-0.0284325462,
-0.0450779088,
0.0309480727,
0.0783059075,
0.0125988582,
-0.0002783006,
0.0211613663,
0.0267967042,
-0.0016690021,
0.0149781909,
-0.0143510085,
-0.0464630574,
-0.0049869618,
0.0272912774,
0.0407952629,
-0.0323758535,
0.053728845,
0.0779013187,
0.0475142077,
0.0401612259,
0.000002141,
0.0013941138,
-0.0107939141,
-0.0214369074,
-0.0291707795,
0.0038574105,
0.0287910644,
-0.0073894677,
-0.0147225549,
-0.0107073514,
-0.0175422728,
-0.0464679822,
0.030265348,
0.0944590047,
0.0847220123,
0.0859562978,
-0.0229494404,
-0.0099683879,
0.0164564569,
-0.0237068497,
-0.0108284559,
0.0095216297,
0.0152096264,
-0.0348490514,
-0.0142002739,
-0.0167359784,
-0.0299192313,
0.004929238,
0.0299475715,
0.0000010779,
-0.0147031825,
0.0260076225,
-0.0242692791,
0.000357353,
-0.0124905175,
0.090512231,
-0.0185061004,
0.0085186595,
-0.0447309986,
0.0046498268,
-0.0090671713,
-0.0398116224,
-0.0217524599,
0.0086182207,
-0.0001134548,
0.0287677199,
-0.0108188232,
0.0233640112,
0.0194233619,
0.0429857709,
-0.0151242716,
-0.0055807573,
-0.0040386342,
-0.0431399271,
0.0251157228,
-0.0057169609,
0.0005925467,
0.0072549963,
0.043312341,
-0.0089941779,
0.002518405,
0.0048227576,
-0.0191797391,
-0.0392880812,
-0.0236451067,
-0.0840843841,
0.0149707887,
0.0317277089,
-0.0485482886,
0.0082652783,
0.0082755182,
0.0186990518,
-0.0091006765,
-0.0096266968,
-0.0188800879,
0.0230966341,
-0.0245873611,
0.0171102844,
0.0127058458,
0.0580819659,
-0.033058323,
-0.0251563769,
-0.0407327712,
-0.0149769606,
-0.0303694531,
0.0017207456,
-0.013795902,
0.0402491689,
-0.0022251122,
0.0009312753,
0.0159422569,
0.0600893274,
-0.0295279492,
0.0118356859,
-0.023823414,
-0.0160304476,
-0.0086401487,
0.030474171,
0.0163990557,
-0.0236982219,
0.0217136703,
0.0121618258,
-0.0106052049,
-0.0443337113,
-0.0291403197,
-0.0014592831,
-0.0233784039,
-0.0236756504,
0.0450285636,
-0.0192040317,
0.049459748,
-0.0357997864,
0.0007335101,
0.0049133976,
0.0164115671,
-0.0090284105,
-0.0218948834,
0.0676076338,
0.0377199575,
-0.0647390485,
-0.0024364546,
0.0260620005,
0.0690704063,
0.0721096173,
0.0327134095,
0.0653376207,
0.0339723863,
-0.0121547077,
0.0203250013,
-0.0148636112,
0.0129356645,
-0.0133921439,
-0.0167715847,
-0.0166055243,
-0.0339716636,
0.0475714318,
0.0361258015,
0.0320476219,
-0.0239074714,
-0.0133906258,
0.038212765,
0.0434218384,
-0.0014442027,
0.0761782974,
-0.0136616388,
0.0333139487,
0.0011031348,
-0.0189753138,
-0.0186262354,
0.0455917008,
-0.0126550319,
-0.0277640074,
-0.018573679,
0.0070855762,
-0.0314034671,
-0.0165800825,
0.0030310904,
-0.0206342619,
-0.0056745298,
-0.00961335,
0.001851303,
-0.0201090053,
-0.0657018423,
0.084143348,
-0.0008794303,
-0.0962923169,
-0.0026871832,
-0.0301043037,
0.0025487912,
0.0533172451,
0.019309165,
-0.0174310803,
-0.055865135,
-0.0497344323,
-0.0065679252,
0.0523886532,
0.0110918824,
0.0085537173,
0.0224247258,
-0.0670489073,
0.0047576604,
-0.0417754129,
0.0009789937,
0.0220241658,
-0.0587611273,
0.0350394696,
0.0021356186,
0.0030226419,
0.015280189,
0.0311284959,
-0.0172712859,
-0.0396738164,
-0.0005890589,
0.0294747278,
0.0065520513,
0.0380845889,
-0.0116388761,
-0.0140455524,
0.0413876735,
-0.0291617606,
-0.0381445214,
0.0121268565,
-0.0367632397,
-0.0605492033,
0.0257820785,
-0.0465704277,
-0.0041290377,
0.067612201,
-0.053056132,
-0.017131228,
0.0057770694,
-0.02808824,
0.0078938976,
-0.0366922021,
0.0055663702,
-0.0225176029,
0.058235053,
-0.0094684307,
0.0512529761,
-0.0404541753,
-0.0113410931,
-0.0046027149,
-0.0098190373,
0.0177494548,
-0.005668459,
-0.0622665323,
0.0114009101,
0.0157692451,
-0.0003293157,
0.0098137781,
0.0049286429,
-0.0669516176,
-0.0555686206,
-0.0967495292,
0.0117876995,
-0.0086195488,
0.0169532187,
-0.0066152331,
0.0042424677,
-0.0220260192,
0.0229358785,
-0.0286034867,
-0.0213663615,
-0.0282969829,
0.0080578253,
0.02340216,
-0.0194237977,
0.0204143077,
-0.0728056952,
0.0067183003,
-0.0579888932,
0.0437746495,
-0.001210103,
0.0045517553,
-0.0047544143,
-0.003160717,
-0.0018833735,
0.0339410268,
-0.0003989615,
-0.083021462,
-0.0015265575,
0.0090471497,
0.0546875149,
0.093143411,
0.0354104191,
0.1196331009,
0.0019497738,
0.0141037805,
-0.0397852473,
0.0624390021,
-0.0160082206,
0.0357000232,
-0.0115580065,
0.0205781851,
-0.0127425501,
0.0341622755,
-0.0049017463,
0.0043749018,
-0.0264538694,
-0.029538326,
0.0176868197,
-0.0235080831,
0.03034514,
-0.0289529897,
-0.0233960189,
-0.0246205404,
-0.0164983831,
-0.0073829764,
0.0166493431,
0.0332232937,
-0.0192505736,
-0.1008231416,
0.0133082075,
-0.0362672023,
0.0474446043,
-0.0434535779,
-0.0071434593,
-0.0660651326,
-0.0039738724,
-0.0266841408,
-0.030945655,
-0.0638919398,
-0.051189132,
0.0159842856,
0.0164327342,
-0.031692367,
0.003621184,
-0.0318698287,
-0.0536974072,
-0.0585876964,
-0.0249697957,
0.0057282206,
0.0511845574,
-0.0126950219,
-0.045682352,
-0.0299654882,
0.0299625043,
-0.0358939879,
-0.000570262,
-0.0112030059,
0.0147916758,
0.0502548143,
0.0419173539,
-0.003755057,
0.0310260858,
-0.0020036807,
0.06454622,
0.0416497104,
0.0598855019,
0.0145988949,
-0.054536622,
0.0108055193,
0.0320860185,
-0.0122214705,
0.007620269,
-0.0558187105,
0.0139236413,
-0.0601965301,
0.0020541437,
0.1397998184,
0.0260194205,
-0.0613750555,
0.0066831433,
-0.0245791283,
-0.0226802249,
0.000183493,
0.027322514,
-0.0734696165,
-0.0331333838,
-0.031512659,
-0.0155662652,
0.0366316028,
-0.0246880129,
0.0110214138,
-0.10086862,
0.0205835905,
-0.0002943432,
0.0147507153,
-0.0462486856,
-0.0207437482,
0.0076740519,
0.0098903691,
0.0193187371,
-0.0669453517,
0.0060278038,
-0.0244419388,
0.0308174659,
-0.039701432,
-0.0306701791,
0.029154025,
-0.039079383,
-0.0003734833,
0.0125846863,
0.1125833318,
-0.0370076075,
-0.068597354,
0.0291257054,
0.000468472,
-0.0314841382,
0.0019553681,
0.0454719588,
-0.0754023418,
-0.0236308053,
-0.0295613855,
0.0390327834,
-0.0377368554,
-0.0071202321,
-0.0601911955,
0.081503354,
-0.0310444757,
-0.0269281697,
-0.043282669,
0.0267017316,
0.0331711359,
0.0631548688,
0.0259433351,
-0.063770704,
-0.0238370914,
-0.0087412158,
0.0485580489,
-0.0667540208,
-0.0206675343,
0.0083945757,
0.0081502562,
-0.0040421821,
-0.0514834449,
-0.0893168375,
0.0193161033,
-0.000098849,
-0.0357026383,
-0.0543042235,
-0.0226886161,
0.012657064,
-0.0680635795,
0.0550099835,
0.0346858241,
0.0240163449,
-0.0419082381,
0.0011389524,
0.0415221341,
0.0078628948,
-0.0391023159,
-0.0061637354,
-0.0344535448,
-0.021880243,
0.025551578,
0.0008725005,
-0.0005922342,
0.0132267531,
0.0283948816,
-0.0006019818,
0.0761641786,
0.0573329255,
-0.0150801223,
-0.0238619484,
0.0683003366,
0.0244382918,
-0.016459737,
0.0185290202,
-0.0214815568,
0.0472748391,
-0.0007119447,
0.0320063122,
0.0416653864,
-0.0373365507,
-0.0194502249,
-0.0351496823,
0.0609618612,
0.0183550585,
-0.0297170058,
-0.0439738296,
-0.0009714701,
0.0189912636,
0.0097878929,
-0.0342807919,
-0.0365598947,
0.0215494614,
-0.0161111206,
-0.0647566766,
-0.0055018188,
0.0026384192,
0.0063164961,
-0.0361060351,
0.0732166469,
0.0289650001,
0.0006406849,
-0.046588432,
0.0441448018,
-0.038288787,
0.0020141215,
-0.0013913027,
-0.0009919684,
0.0011574213,
0.0378107913,
0.0075540482,
0.0081531052,
0.0030484756,
0.0520686544,
-0.0231791995,
0.025579758,
-0.037192151,
-0.0178594161,
0.0343876258,
-0.060106229,
0.0190840457,
-0.0160886459,
0.0305035841,
0.00245094,
-0.0007158428,
-0.0523217544,
-0.0352663249,
0.0204666462,
0.0137523143,
-0.0208988003,
-0.0130363861,
0.0376500413,
-0.0640287027,
0.0796375051,
0.0422031507,
-0.0072348793,
-0.0428743847,
-0.0176923908,
0.115866825,
0.0212270971,
0.0054902514,
0.0505321808,
-0.0423132181,
-0.0321253464,
0.0516941771,
-0.0288208686,
-0.031661056,
-0.0069458019,
0.0251799859,
0.057412982,
-0.0168683082,
0.0153144151,
-0.0127624227,
0.0385411568,
-0.0177245568,
-0.0409852825,
-0.0302434377,
-6.531993621e-33,
-0.0018698716,
0.0110360943,
-0.0439849719,
0.0302776471,
-0.0482027009,
0.0291961525,
-0.0156545509,
-0.0089032147,
-0.034403719,
0.0645645484,
-0.0124680223,
0.0407580882,
-0.0026825732,
0.0313317366,
-0.0069678226,
-0.0371359996,
0.0310854502,
0.0061281072,
0.0011386027,
0.0369978584,
0.048937913,
0.0692284852,
0.1045355201,
-0.0591742583,
0.0093048587,
-0.0031275973,
0.0175918173,
0.0045781778,
0.0658204854,
0.0619219951,
-0.0326520242,
0.0527064465,
0.0283153541,
-0.0281021874,
0.0331636816,
0.0724662393,
-0.0355551355,
-0.0155980019,
-0.0137947071,
0.0364917815,
-0.0615243986,
-0.0403859355,
-0.0019699151,
0.0408508405,
0.0051812469,
-0.043630451,
0.0080733346,
-0.0069191665,
0.0206054952,
-0.0684263036,
-0.0449772254,
0.00135461,
-0.0173013117,
-0.030055603,
0.0081235524,
0.0078931954,
0.0290846471,
0.0336135253,
-0.0774134025,
-0.0414035246,
-0.035113994,
-0.0021664239,
0.0182807893,
-0.0136310393,
-0.0353179984,
0.0949387327,
0.0193186942,
-0.003945393,
-0.0146315712,
0.0234916396,
0.0349755138,
0.0258348733,
0.0439139046,
0.0233735424,
0.0265573375,
0.0136046978,
-0.0450313874,
0.035059277,
0.0565029271,
0.0454914607,
0.046577245,
0.0045449589,
-0.0182257649,
0.0068664462,
-0.0078044734,
0.0078288158,
-0.0174588915,
-0.0114322919,
0.0184248425,
-0.0180286579,
0.0098255109,
0.0123547362,
0.0064893053,
-0.024436675,
-0.0006157142,
0.0511579961,
0.0011791069,
0.0241731443,
0.0012017509,
0.0226117894,
-0.0088974852,
-0.0053639826,
0.0383414216,
0.0364451297,
0.0267089158,
0.0042651873,
0.0304258801,
0.0430823043,
-0.0560238771,
-0.0176097117,
-0.0224794634,
0.0038492519,
-0.0114431111,
0.0687836558,
-0.0325635262,
0.0273321513,
-0.0030707757,
0.0368048325,
0.0139297778,
0.0595558882,
0.014802102,
-0.0271733329,
-0.0197493937,
0.0273198802,
-0.0188309327,
-0.012737114,
-0.009591396,
0.0029385677,
-0.0009363245,
-0.0911803693,
0.0009437866,
-0.0289781392,
2.889e-7,
0.024688974,
0.0631232709,
0.0443996526,
-0.0453573763,
-0.0014849245,
0.0316737965,
-0.0100143896,
0.0628029257,
0.0058802096,
-0.0206120778,
0.016738303,
0.0080748415,
0.034486793,
-0.0092487689,
-0.088390097,
-0.0069808322,
-0.0696158037,
0.0184302405,
-0.0286675338,
-0.0082878247,
0.0982070863,
0.0994047895,
0.0251129735,
-0.0152020315,
0.0180461593,
0.010155268,
0.0360251553,
-0.0439595655,
-0.0000670756,
0.0171108134,
0.0150878653,
-0.005063734,
-0.0030834212,
-0.0274691842,
-0.0125176683,
0.0258712247,
0.0256440677,
0.0236809105,
0.0016822715,
-0.0605881475,
0.0263256002,
0.0149328327,
-0.0196613707,
-0.0046918984,
0.0453159213,
-0.0798193067,
-0.0451674871,
-0.0421558619,
-0.0386415794,
0.0080194455,
0.0418863557,
-0.0228371471,
-0.0247464031,
0.0138702719,
-0.0056281821,
-0.0208431277,
-0.0102199838,
-0.097694695,
-0.0116506349,
0.0198644623,
-0.0609822124,
0.0152008291,
-0.0249561258,
-0.0281555001,
0.05758214,
-0.0274261348,
0.0086737145,
2.431946283e-34,
0.0353495814,
-0.0023773408,
-0.0030992562,
0.0571341105,
0.0192962047,
0.0174656864,
-0.0309212022,
-0.0475871488,
0.0516383126,
-0.0574111715,
0.0089227948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07931v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07931v2 | Distilled Feature Fields Enable Few-Shot Language-Guided Manipulation | 2023-07-27T17:59:14 | 2023-12-30T01:10:41 | William Shen, Ge Yang, Alan Yu, Jansen Wong, Leslie Pack Kaelbling, Phillip Isola | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | Self-supervised and language-supervised image models contain rich knowledge
of the world that is important for generalization. Many robotic tasks, however,
require a detailed understanding of 3D geometry, which is often lacking in 2D
image features. This work bridges this 2D-to-3D gap for robotic manipulation by
leveraging distilled feature fields to combine accurate 3D geometry with rich
semantics from 2D foundation models. We present a few-shot learning method for
6-DOF grasping and placing that harnesses these strong spatial and semantic
priors to achieve in-the-wild generalization to unseen objects. Using features
distilled from a vision-language model, CLIP, we present a way to designate
novel objects for manipulation via free-text natural language, and demonstrate
its ability to generalize to unseen expressions and novel categories of
objects. | [
0.0584095456,
0.0589525737,
0.069546476,
0.0181096327,
-0.0204551425,
0.0033364415,
0.0439042971,
-0.016443152,
-0.008765623,
-0.0855869725,
-0.0400662981,
0.0000596994,
-0.0107763642,
0.0155909937,
0.0031365624,
-0.0830587968,
0.0158496276,
-0.0282132234,
-0.017531544,
0.0090480614,
-0.0080513228,
0.0324209817,
-0.0423075221,
0.0024313168,
-0.052491203,
0.0301023349,
-0.0772820115,
0.0267471783,
0.0036837894,
-0.0370621532,
-0.0479335636,
0.0443044417,
0.0556478798,
0.0154513251,
0.0000019016,
-0.0530995317,
-0.0144257303,
0.0225547608,
0.0287025161,
-0.0378400311,
0.0422363356,
-0.0321845189,
-0.0196967144,
-0.0159276575,
-0.0149208894,
-0.0082360823,
0.0476976745,
0.047237087,
0.0592773333,
0.0505130254,
-0.0115086259,
-0.0276021212,
-0.0095964111,
-0.0156595912,
0.0610218085,
-0.03359868,
0.0103612663,
0.0020235886,
0.0278751701,
0.0350720063,
-0.0311164968,
0.0120664956,
0.0084352242,
-0.004603765,
-0.0018482328,
0.0081771761,
-0.0560869165,
-0.0231672414,
-0.0034996143,
0.0593786538,
-0.0584453419,
0.0065926956,
-0.0007505094,
-0.0181150772,
0.0242481828,
0.0328519344,
-0.0545810089,
0.0439275689,
0.0317330174,
-0.0173946675,
-0.0717403069,
-0.0300914273,
-0.0026907197,
-0.0339609534,
0.0113834459,
0.0445330441,
0.0074000354,
0.0427522585,
0.0065587177,
-0.0367689319,
-0.0241343789,
-0.0359719954,
-0.0241635144,
0.0041461512,
-0.0030648699,
0.0092231454,
-0.0461817682,
0.0276197083,
-0.0232965183,
-0.0540570654,
0.055540964,
0.0309064649,
-0.0571980886,
0.0537124388,
-0.0337474532,
0.0147022111,
-0.0166639816,
0.0663593709,
-0.0460488349,
-0.0031212887,
-0.0224771518,
-0.0074642552,
-0.0372985154,
0.0372556262,
-0.0400791988,
-0.0403503515,
0.0063473415,
0.0025642817,
-0.0293775797,
0.0127107752,
0.0081552221,
0.034847565,
-0.0036988736,
-0.0247547608,
-0.0360226668,
-0.0061971522,
-0.0277079064,
0.0282393973,
-0.0145287551,
-0.0139434803,
-0.0149668902,
0.0315201692,
0.0602731593,
-0.0307143405,
0.0229049679,
0.0934575647,
-0.0001577314,
-0.0326712839,
-0.0005967896,
-0.0032551603,
-0.0452831872,
-0.0035291617,
0.0496814623,
-0.0611452162,
-0.0033007562,
-0.0129353162,
-0.013598904,
-0.061021734,
0.0200728197,
0.0244540386,
-0.0245391075,
0.0803076401,
0.0067769648,
-0.0068464107,
0.0341666043,
-0.0275481921,
-0.0221739355,
0.0108058862,
-0.0086564953,
0.0402228422,
-0.0119217755,
0.0295382701,
0.0350041166,
0.0424001627,
-0.0385052785,
-0.0124058118,
-0.0871512592,
-0.0371544622,
0.0086740591,
0.0273888409,
0.0284532271,
-0.0234136619,
-0.0115773743,
-0.012501983,
0.0128427502,
0.0511721894,
-0.0252055973,
0.0053231786,
0.037263941,
0.0347347483,
-0.0260293968,
-0.0763704851,
-0.0660912693,
0.0698491856,
0.0096327262,
-0.0252526607,
-0.0413725823,
-0.0005505105,
-0.0266777631,
-0.0140136695,
-0.0080466289,
0.0023612145,
0.0173669029,
-0.0161818564,
0.0765543208,
0.0248122569,
-0.0098356269,
0.0142993638,
-0.0018817327,
-0.0294233561,
-0.0321420394,
0.0317826532,
-0.0379868634,
-0.0049842647,
-0.0302649215,
-0.0293898508,
-0.0354970992,
0.0052229804,
0.0549920648,
0.0526185967,
0.0174465571,
-0.0020577393,
0.0157912113,
0.0310928766,
-0.0326214172,
-0.0528136007,
-0.0075022504,
0.0405538119,
0.010037235,
-0.0097331582,
-0.0083964532,
-0.0219249539,
0.0140599404,
0.0335893668,
0.0322243758,
-0.0240089837,
-0.0075786295,
0.0452598482,
-0.0227703471,
0.0144111319,
0.0103241922,
-0.0132939117,
0.0050852215,
-0.0148551511,
-0.0055924156,
0.0060996325,
-0.0058799405,
-0.0202404521,
0.0389320292,
-0.0096884426,
-0.0081893047,
0.0026295348,
-0.0518289097,
-0.0148764187,
0.0422503725,
0.031773638,
0.0315501727,
0.0321715809,
-0.0094219465,
0.0128320428,
-0.0280369818,
-0.0208627209,
0.0380358472,
-0.021294903,
-0.0152886203,
-0.0143393539,
-0.0441802032,
0.0406967811,
-0.0033524381,
-0.0192646794,
-0.0141605176,
-0.0331109203,
-0.0025394505,
0.0442723334,
0.0584591962,
-0.0297879912,
-0.0063840994,
-0.035909541,
-0.0368777215,
0.0021184431,
-0.0152653409,
0.0216017589,
-0.0205135997,
-0.0073109451,
-0.0381070152,
0.0000252106,
-0.0166085362,
-0.041406475,
-0.0319507942,
0.0261673555,
0.0366798267,
0.0078274263,
-0.0139841456,
0.007480674,
-0.0298087783,
0.0236159358,
0.0513742343,
-0.0185103174,
0.0125373043,
0.0104165077,
-0.0545386225,
0.0334476009,
0.0051954305,
-0.0080616837,
0.0330456235,
-0.0717591643,
-0.0464835204,
0.0880936831,
-0.0780487582,
-0.0081177009,
0.0263847336,
0.0187750347,
-0.0359003879,
0.0107313236,
-0.0326913074,
-0.0302424263,
-0.0193959549,
0.0569777749,
-0.0126225874,
0.0317407139,
0.0078199301,
0.014508999,
-0.0667441264,
0.0365183018,
0.004369746,
-0.0509882905,
-0.0660664141,
0.020927893,
-0.0250645094,
0.0052547841,
-0.0511223599,
-0.0151900221,
0.0074777999,
-0.0226441603,
0.0014206438,
0.0499954782,
-0.0034248319,
-0.0157216974,
0.098286964,
0.0482529365,
0.0418540873,
0.0043543703,
-0.0229141451,
-0.0374294296,
0.0207787026,
0.0017010652,
0.0278917737,
-0.0182544608,
-0.0639115497,
0.0223965663,
0.0052228719,
-0.0346553177,
-0.0135889454,
-0.0208748449,
-0.0298220776,
0.0183850918,
-0.0577211753,
-0.0835900232,
-0.0151810702,
-0.023355009,
0.0453578644,
0.0989918411,
-0.0222801473,
-0.0172859114,
-0.0266587306,
0.0114809778,
0.0292501803,
0.0322617479,
-0.0952896327,
0.0130933821,
-0.0292012971,
0.0274162088,
0.0119098164,
-0.0104423445,
-0.0535152704,
0.0644229203,
0.012384343,
-0.0034874985,
0.0341120884,
0.0096753277,
0.0348787084,
0.0103742573,
-0.0236392524,
0.0561825447,
0.0340797901,
0.0119021162,
-0.006369079,
-0.0119682392,
-0.0029639343,
0.0757184774,
0.010733881,
-0.0620666668,
-0.0621623918,
0.0075714472,
-0.0501683578,
0.0583848432,
-0.0243272539,
-0.0274082161,
-0.1286600828,
0.025737308,
-0.0062663467,
-0.0830264837,
-0.0485981479,
0.0009086384,
0.0297208223,
-0.0507152602,
-0.0740266666,
-0.0276392065,
0.0079090297,
0.0100509329,
0.0024401434,
0.0354400165,
-0.0282306913,
0.0207328089,
-0.0124488138,
-0.0316262618,
0.0256201643,
0.0013119895,
-0.0422349051,
0.016786417,
0.0220319685,
0.0962142795,
0.0067690341,
-0.0002015888,
0.0234177429,
-0.0198939778,
-0.0136790089,
0.0387882441,
0.0621643662,
-0.028570205,
-0.0773512274,
-0.0711003169,
0.0472504348,
0.0220168587,
0.0191595647,
-0.0275273304,
-0.037778832,
0.0100157969,
0.0479566045,
-0.0115006799,
-0.0536507964,
0.0424372293,
-0.0301605556,
-0.0333885252,
0.0366494395,
-0.0551662892,
0.0013428044,
0.0246842578,
-0.0305466857,
-0.0417765118,
0.0221079718,
0.1133325696,
0.0471794866,
0.0006993903,
-0.0372376703,
0.0031887819,
0.0206325725,
-0.0485503003,
0.045851998,
-0.0045823096,
-0.0107806828,
-0.0148873152,
-0.0048132851,
0.0333249085,
-0.0226327274,
-0.0520031303,
-0.0165437534,
-0.0297752712,
-0.0167752989,
-0.0191807486,
0.0923481584,
0.0058826641,
0.0156271067,
-0.026564192,
-0.0137196891,
0.0458080284,
0.044159282,
-0.0094398968,
0.0421169065,
0.0012744574,
0.0097657712,
0.0017957072,
0.0074616787,
-0.0364899114,
0.028268395,
-0.0064601372,
-0.0248935837,
-0.0284566432,
-0.0218764488,
0.0317955427,
-0.0331843495,
0.0866187736,
0.0054610325,
0.0408084244,
-0.0576544255,
-0.0034995894,
-0.0153737385,
-0.0094830217,
-0.0843087584,
0.0219065845,
0.0056988117,
0.007858959,
0.0177340489,
0.0221257415,
-0.0029660321,
0.0398113318,
0.0000462392,
-0.0366057344,
0.0436133035,
0.0105224513,
-0.0162163004,
0.0387288593,
0.0113619007,
0.0145287812,
-0.0699632391,
0.0505329184,
-0.0064119603,
0.0413076282,
0.0260805413,
-0.0207800735,
-0.0113898646,
0.0288227387,
-0.0119867399,
-0.1175047681,
-0.0504080281,
0.0233483762,
0.0408660397,
-0.0280964058,
0.0026392913,
-0.0596020557,
-0.0214794371,
0.0283042956,
0.0263221841,
0.0468753986,
-0.0402964279,
0.0414456576,
0.0287833679,
0.0034927381,
-0.0045754267,
-0.0057479148,
-0.0036796604,
0.026321074,
0.0282731522,
0.0145204728,
-0.0407086313,
-0.0325450599,
0.0573298261,
0.034224119,
0.0012108824,
0.0469096154,
-0.029310666,
-0.0252146628,
-0.0216484703,
0.0375510901,
-0.0300606601,
0.0305595808,
0.0580407269,
0.0099709826,
-0.0229651183,
-0.0246350616,
0.0135688893,
-0.0479851551,
0.0105365524,
-0.0189382266,
-0.0191662461,
-5.447539838e-33,
-0.0004514894,
-0.034881562,
0.0029580165,
-0.0135959443,
0.0357060209,
-0.0476595871,
-0.006129486,
0.0524730347,
-0.0343116522,
0.0408859216,
0.0054009897,
-0.0131934388,
0.0009684315,
0.0498333909,
0.0158003271,
0.0102086933,
0.0026109628,
-0.0146961845,
-0.0128116049,
-0.0019077749,
0.0402406529,
0.0334793776,
0.0878352597,
-0.0194119215,
-0.0108814714,
0.0406817421,
-0.036719732,
0.0481352583,
0.0350829028,
-0.0115930233,
-0.0068192622,
-0.0267779864,
-0.0151154557,
-0.0228687506,
-0.0138650332,
0.0136833992,
-0.070289433,
-0.0392523296,
-0.043393366,
0.0327711292,
-0.0360572636,
0.0510575511,
0.0184431653,
-0.0097832084,
0.0240949094,
0.0001984406,
0.0237705167,
-0.0046811793,
0.0068790936,
0.0351018794,
-0.0070572859,
0.0085394578,
0.0066283867,
-0.0591043644,
0.0389313437,
0.0092557343,
0.046851851,
0.016742738,
-0.0124497525,
-0.0110602975,
-0.0223511737,
0.0221626032,
0.0378046781,
0.0148340715,
-0.0062460732,
0.094998382,
0.0040860968,
-0.0896952748,
0.0222025122,
0.0002367727,
0.0182757266,
0.0811998099,
-0.0467623547,
0.0711419657,
0.0662875175,
0.0893342793,
-0.0401140526,
0.0132244173,
-0.1207564101,
0.0831160918,
-0.023133764,
-0.0092976177,
0.0063551534,
-0.0000846757,
-0.0409968682,
0.0208896752,
-0.0284039434,
0.0085858377,
0.0489767827,
-0.0008953315,
-0.0023192777,
0.0043455875,
0.048310481,
-0.003116972,
-0.0159141421,
0.0520338938,
-0.0234605558,
0.0633651391,
-0.0099936659,
-0.0049891798,
-0.0504922271,
-0.0145814475,
-0.0129399793,
0.0019432426,
0.0104343221,
0.0204293504,
0.021229919,
0.0743023157,
-0.0278316494,
0.0182904582,
-0.0295033548,
-0.0333411321,
-0.0280296654,
0.0614531264,
0.0449732207,
0.0127005978,
-0.0240065157,
0.0433435552,
-0.0304712616,
-0.0281556007,
0.0125801023,
0.0216453373,
-0.0285638366,
-0.0045249811,
-0.0410982408,
-0.0408685915,
0.0024446957,
-0.019728601,
0.0693517625,
-0.0638763085,
0.0115283551,
0.031477049,
2.616e-7,
0.0360849462,
0.0182214286,
0.0042593498,
0.0417307653,
-0.0401171558,
0.0631420836,
-0.0009764138,
0.0468586646,
-0.0517006628,
-0.0001688379,
0.0165448822,
0.0509250239,
-0.023432631,
-0.0181957018,
-0.1257853359,
0.0782120526,
0.0234270431,
-0.0170650575,
-0.0443171412,
0.0045681936,
0.0441020019,
0.1094098017,
0.0143909166,
-0.0042737345,
0.0004055295,
-0.0253724214,
0.0457277,
-0.0435284451,
0.0477579683,
-0.002082207,
-0.0154135916,
0.0180597752,
-0.0260299221,
0.0006280602,
-0.0250161961,
-0.0097227646,
0.0271709803,
0.0439681262,
-0.032901179,
-0.0123788603,
-0.0340178572,
0.0168833677,
-0.0047491202,
-0.0085432716,
0.0322176591,
-0.1161300838,
0.0074142581,
-0.0138859097,
-0.0011106989,
0.0226264372,
-0.0029540739,
-0.000643866,
-0.0009021051,
-0.0208944511,
0.037042845,
-0.0109486561,
-0.0262599327,
-0.0631781146,
-0.0504371151,
0.0267889611,
0.0025866551,
-0.00167958,
0.0176101904,
-0.0675540566,
-0.006747751,
-0.0118879247,
-0.0291454121,
1.746593587e-34,
-0.0075149029,
0.0522286445,
-0.0163415018,
0.0258663408,
0.0211294238,
0.0238770545,
0.0243823957,
0.0343763642,
0.0186270066,
0.0105474386,
-0.0297502894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15054v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15054v3 | A Geometric Notion of Causal Probing | 2023-07-27T17:57:57 | 2024-02-24T19:53:58 | Clément Guerner, Anej Svete, Tianyu Liu, Alexander Warstadt, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL | The linear subspace hypothesis (Bolukbasi et al., 2016) states that, in a
language model's representation space, all information about a concept such as
verbal number is encoded in a linear subspace. Prior work has relied on
auxiliary classification tasks to identify and evaluate candidate subspaces
that might give support for this hypothesis. We instead give a set of intrinsic
criteria which characterize an ideal linear concept subspace and enable us to
identify the subspace using only the language model distribution. Our
information-theoretic framework accounts for spuriously correlated features in
the representation space (Kumar et al., 2022). As a byproduct of this analysis,
we hypothesize a causal process for how a language model might leverage
concepts during generation. Empirically, we find that LEACE (Belrose et al.,
2023) returns a one-dimensional subspace containing roughly half of total
concept information under our framework for verbal-number. Our causal
intervention for controlled generation shows that, for at least one concept,
the subspace returned by LEACE can be used to manipulate the concept value of
the generated word with precision. | [
-0.0138294939,
0.0863664448,
-0.057647191,
0.0379928127,
-0.0436254367,
0.010229107,
-0.0055296971,
0.0226239543,
-0.0814998895,
-0.0513339043,
0.0212790482,
-0.0597313307,
0.0175459124,
0.0448790342,
0.0918011591,
-0.0025483808,
0.0283250306,
-0.031377431,
0.0351023152,
0.0014795123,
-0.0731348395,
-0.0445614122,
-0.021901967,
0.0182646159,
-0.0518480204,
0.0187295713,
-0.0008363173,
-0.0552753285,
-0.0349081643,
-0.0049541742,
-0.0462888218,
0.0377795584,
0.0460486002,
0.0313282646,
0.000002115,
-0.0457645878,
0.0024972409,
-0.0287507959,
-0.0265133213,
0.0021857452,
-0.0336473733,
-0.0454180576,
0.0014161648,
-0.0316422805,
-0.0235870909,
-0.0219539795,
0.0540368445,
0.0291797929,
-0.0246087164,
0.0491091497,
-0.0180150848,
-0.0323480852,
0.0275976174,
-0.0339665152,
0.0719820857,
0.046981737,
0.0189868435,
0.0215572249,
-0.0195863247,
0.0228267461,
-0.0636530966,
0.0019646876,
0.0345211737,
0.030196961,
0.0749298036,
0.0201421231,
0.0118444189,
-0.0502215177,
0.0374443308,
0.0608596429,
0.0212609302,
-0.0231796559,
0.007079287,
-0.0044879187,
0.036998,
0.0225023124,
-0.019325817,
0.0205783732,
0.0401747338,
0.0120557509,
0.0320784189,
-0.0047996393,
0.0264201965,
-0.0038019605,
-0.031213047,
0.0424682349,
0.0256052688,
-0.002263065,
-0.0566617362,
0.0212883726,
-0.0661839917,
-0.0334309638,
-0.070113793,
0.011319221,
0.0213003885,
0.0233980268,
0.0025045525,
-0.0115421042,
-0.0015005211,
-0.0391491726,
0.0724334866,
0.0413342007,
0.0290503856,
-0.0207898822,
-0.0281684529,
0.0791944042,
-0.0008001463,
0.0465830714,
-0.0371405855,
0.0662975088,
0.0168254822,
-0.0464960523,
-0.0219125152,
0.0156710763,
0.037560381,
-0.0157164652,
-0.0493552946,
0.0498399362,
-0.0070842453,
0.0079715224,
-0.0498068817,
0.0068080551,
0.0082689431,
0.0223790389,
-0.0088836374,
-0.0238653719,
-0.0435956605,
0.0551937222,
-0.0204750337,
-0.0638041869,
-0.017025847,
-0.0014705723,
0.0116270464,
-0.0230126213,
-0.0138481148,
0.052259516,
0.0109191937,
-0.0506121404,
-0.005303984,
-0.0682476908,
-0.0087264115,
-0.0247654505,
0.013960802,
-0.0570113473,
-0.0345527343,
0.0475289263,
-0.0255185459,
-0.0255740564,
0.0050008744,
-0.0329591259,
-0.0302243978,
0.0348350517,
0.0240423437,
0.0333547331,
0.0125765372,
-0.0013435371,
0.038784489,
0.0682925656,
0.0493989438,
0.0168858543,
0.0270753745,
-0.0183879863,
0.0253624115,
0.0300055612,
0.0478639081,
0.001424648,
-0.0973053202,
-0.0676536188,
0.0324644074,
0.019029323,
0.0377594866,
0.0107262246,
-0.059960071,
0.0037974252,
0.0588167384,
0.0496092997,
0.0093118967,
0.0373479873,
0.0546294786,
-0.0623556897,
-0.0139529221,
0.0603391863,
-0.037404988,
0.023524126,
-0.0289540943,
0.0084759509,
0.0375427566,
-0.0140812369,
-0.032988742,
-0.0414043516,
-0.0215351675,
0.0044589401,
0.0072926157,
-0.0356377028,
0.0523117222,
0.0174264405,
0.007783174,
0.0272473935,
-0.0025491219,
-0.0398926325,
0.0315386206,
-0.055804383,
0.0479323976,
0.023112338,
0.0416130498,
-0.008712749,
0.0041860556,
0.0305751469,
-0.0477068983,
0.035776373,
0.0486990325,
-0.0267939866,
-0.0342921503,
0.0107097952,
-0.0051962845,
-0.0385260768,
0.045682855,
0.0125797633,
-0.0369732045,
-0.0313516222,
-0.0144007187,
-0.0384901911,
-0.012462805,
0.0304285735,
-0.0210534409,
-0.0586057715,
-0.0188030973,
0.0081928512,
-0.005928346,
-0.0218925737,
-0.0166874379,
0.0641836971,
-0.0031285533,
-0.0399831273,
-0.0091677867,
0.0246104486,
-0.0248039979,
-0.0025583496,
0.0099701099,
-0.0039808108,
0.0634382069,
0.0013355506,
0.0226957221,
-0.0415075533,
0.1086496115,
-0.0652294904,
0.0485913828,
-0.018053649,
0.0335591622,
-0.0212484598,
0.014568558,
-0.0156555958,
0.0809759572,
-0.0026875159,
0.0410697646,
0.0289725978,
0.0241082981,
0.0467881225,
0.0130708562,
0.0261216331,
-0.0038300322,
0.0098512266,
0.0060067391,
0.066080004,
-0.0386089198,
-0.0173945762,
-0.0252529774,
-0.0272311941,
-0.0574656762,
-0.0316376239,
-0.007663317,
0.0377290882,
-0.0245372318,
0.0096272444,
0.0048054941,
-0.0287872311,
0.0041003851,
0.0484296381,
0.0459687747,
0.0341300517,
-0.0107843177,
-0.0166815836,
-0.0213330351,
-0.006305859,
-0.0097459909,
0.0525695346,
0.0596579909,
0.0043278076,
-0.0480000451,
0.0381842032,
-0.0452513769,
0.0073466673,
-0.0140237035,
-0.0028615068,
0.0263973624,
-0.0420539528,
0.032389652,
-0.0136642708,
-0.0029764248,
0.082643725,
0.066322349,
-0.0039754789,
-0.0206092931,
-0.0437900908,
-0.0693070367,
0.0259853508,
-0.0016286558,
-0.0329641663,
-0.0262754988,
0.1006208435,
0.0481850766,
-0.0434891842,
-0.0511373989,
0.0530305058,
-0.01729629,
-0.0251079109,
-0.0638751164,
0.0031278869,
-0.0245619155,
0.085455589,
-0.0176622495,
-0.0860767141,
0.0128417658,
0.0141218556,
0.0186031405,
-0.0044435048,
0.0413378887,
-0.0220041052,
0.0571490563,
0.0742012039,
0.0027794864,
0.0318558402,
6.055e-7,
-0.0558206402,
0.0310589988,
0.0183362868,
-0.0043235272,
0.0308469366,
-0.0763740242,
0.0262409989,
0.0158256609,
-0.0166947488,
-0.0721933544,
-0.0038591896,
0.0485570244,
0.0147291161,
0.0485882238,
-0.0243701395,
0.005653135,
-0.0202641189,
0.0368984863,
0.0537186004,
-0.0156733245,
-0.0060428879,
-0.0187144782,
0.0269515645,
0.0559222214,
0.0152271381,
0.053804718,
-0.0457214192,
-0.022292899,
-0.0003065635,
-0.0511625893,
0.039827656,
0.0137567325,
0.0529883541,
0.0411526598,
-0.0018297422,
-0.0370590203,
0.0516380444,
0.0007018753,
-0.0072666421,
-0.0731686503,
0.071631074,
0.0550488755,
-0.024011761,
0.0441351868,
-0.0181795023,
0.0130041037,
0.0378345326,
-0.0040536528,
-0.0405365489,
0.0405164361,
-0.0082227476,
-0.0678059533,
-0.05472726,
-0.0124249877,
-0.0319097042,
-0.0830432996,
0.0163046494,
0.0134323705,
-0.0734551325,
-0.0239914544,
-0.0284842551,
0.0085695535,
0.0324858986,
0.0039700167,
0.0109165618,
-0.0163903609,
0.0426301137,
-0.0054587368,
0.0083875209,
-0.0415519923,
-0.0408322178,
0.0133964317,
0.0363530219,
0.0394044891,
0.0267359726,
-0.0345514156,
-0.0544100218,
-0.0208008178,
-0.0041919495,
0.0145709049,
0.0203054342,
0.0495152436,
0.0582807586,
-0.0241154525,
0.0054111974,
0.0414421484,
-0.0405346528,
-0.0278815851,
-0.0636495724,
0.0531243533,
-0.0565736741,
-0.0043780818,
0.019250378,
-0.0005427892,
-0.0125327026,
0.0288392212,
0.0724611953,
-0.0313232914,
-0.0047175791,
-0.0228691995,
0.0113922087,
-0.0099943634,
-0.0655340254,
-0.0407294147,
0.0609230101,
-0.0670115054,
-0.1062681377,
-0.0127324872,
0.0041157319,
0.0288150441,
0.0060236026,
-0.0134960646,
-0.0346015841,
-0.0700690299,
-0.0303159431,
0.0208405014,
0.0109453257,
0.0001648656,
-0.0394193791,
-0.0616220497,
-0.0409657471,
-0.0913998038,
-0.0291075725,
-0.0019828591,
-0.0428042449,
-0.0670530796,
0.0147506511,
0.0170030072,
0.0282484889,
0.0029072075,
0.0173133519,
-0.0225311406,
0.0613177046,
-0.0052600023,
-0.036901217,
0.0456136465,
-0.0151283396,
-0.0022958568,
-0.0080138631,
0.0462980382,
-0.0047013685,
0.0447954834,
0.0290430412,
0.0126249241,
-0.0240015816,
0.0045439363,
0.0401484668,
0.0099997381,
0.0577707179,
-0.0285553019,
-0.0096471095,
-0.0349329971,
-0.0271143615,
-0.0437446013,
-0.0148635609,
-0.0255768858,
-0.0106403017,
0.0068301149,
0.0544399582,
-0.042098742,
-0.0471188612,
-0.0064904038,
0.0522619523,
0.0223620962,
-0.0440189689,
-0.0241432432,
0.0387246571,
0.0131076807,
0.02428375,
0.0476711132,
0.0372406803,
-0.0520184115,
0.0360137708,
-0.005060398,
0.0567626096,
0.0221433342,
0.0331905745,
-0.057507854,
-0.0082078539,
-0.0576960444,
-0.0231176633,
0.0072487001,
-0.0226987284,
0.0395194143,
-0.0173307173,
0.0220181569,
-0.0774353445,
-0.0074603171,
0.0001354402,
0.0266771205,
0.0000576625,
-0.0356467627,
0.0189251527,
0.0158048961,
-0.0259360075,
-0.0245197862,
0.0623237751,
-0.0100783976,
0.035887897,
-0.0603073835,
0.0201445986,
-0.0044650957,
-0.0108098537,
0.0316246301,
0.0127672888,
-0.0244393498,
0.0603611507,
-0.0948336348,
-0.0461393371,
0.0021774375,
-0.0134735527,
0.0093974993,
-0.0058938637,
0.0354443341,
0.024565151,
-0.0382595509,
0.0275258161,
-0.0353318676,
0.0017222856,
-0.0022203794,
0.0065404833,
-0.0333252177,
-6.484422834e-33,
-0.0245736595,
-0.0527013354,
0.0152617358,
0.0299248453,
0.0118892351,
0.0027339044,
-0.0198714845,
0.0527046472,
0.0024482475,
0.0059601408,
0.0228940658,
-0.0171042122,
-0.0115163233,
0.0188113246,
0.0416876003,
0.0061374051,
0.0127227828,
-0.0165795684,
-0.0566468015,
0.0221216399,
0.0704632178,
-0.0068610325,
0.0460865162,
-0.0170262158,
0.050573878,
0.0253097918,
0.0259985887,
-0.003758407,
-0.0386759639,
0.0186232366,
-0.0477268361,
0.0346594155,
0.0445579924,
-0.0795805156,
-0.014104127,
-0.0144031784,
0.0077185989,
-0.0642133281,
0.0262659658,
0.0087786196,
-0.0230101291,
-0.050578054,
0.0212782901,
-0.0414805673,
-0.049502138,
0.0211938731,
0.0370755009,
-0.0268190578,
-0.0130521469,
0.0074780621,
-0.10066019,
-0.0102452729,
-0.0067203632,
0.009221348,
0.0421962664,
-0.0020731722,
-0.0292710438,
-0.0424906872,
-0.0134855546,
0.0698055401,
0.0296968222,
0.0492827967,
0.0041135545,
0.036289636,
0.0156969372,
0.05337549,
0.0391136855,
-0.0485411659,
-0.0418805256,
0.015531295,
0.0552161522,
0.0265570898,
0.0410502441,
0.0061289156,
0.069950074,
-0.0308233835,
-0.0220140703,
-0.0223557595,
0.0291720275,
-0.0097307451,
0.0258465894,
-0.04496032,
-0.0192289185,
-0.0394947417,
-0.0381943956,
-0.0244281106,
-0.0671354905,
-0.013380982,
0.0115287779,
0.0127345454,
0.0463557653,
-0.0520175844,
0.0221342053,
-0.0252062045,
-0.0206186846,
0.0466649495,
-0.0518757813,
0.0516303368,
0.0102093909,
-0.0240406729,
-0.0494147092,
-0.0326482691,
0.0197566692,
0.0206089877,
-0.0018271661,
0.0291589666,
-0.0006305593,
0.0362615846,
-0.0199042317,
-0.0030026997,
-0.0444074571,
-0.0569839031,
0.045525685,
-0.0121515812,
0.0124911247,
0.0135743655,
-0.0255345926,
-0.014563404,
0.0109111052,
0.0168397911,
-0.0033970724,
-0.0195010062,
-0.0439323895,
0.0333181433,
-0.0489300042,
-0.0244425666,
-0.0315010473,
0.0521321706,
0.078948833,
-0.0311020557,
-0.0051194225,
-0.0386808254,
2.983e-7,
0.0381813943,
0.0319827087,
-0.0155414687,
0.009791865,
0.0452581979,
-0.0141168768,
-0.0209327098,
0.0277850479,
0.0008099236,
-0.0152379684,
0.0170792453,
-0.017634701,
-0.0096168183,
0.0072381785,
-0.0188940465,
0.0482630134,
0.0119074173,
0.01497549,
0.0110222725,
0.0072274716,
0.0368310027,
0.0372876935,
0.0065146647,
-0.0169163253,
-0.0000379799,
0.0204830468,
0.0534063429,
-0.0317190029,
0.0136181153,
0.0151896682,
0.0256200042,
0.0059918971,
0.0063953418,
0.0346534811,
-0.0084371641,
0.0380865969,
-0.0155025059,
0.0131424014,
0.0073170238,
0.0038743725,
-0.0396539792,
-0.0064642131,
-0.0250105038,
0.0029461705,
0.045961611,
-0.0440269448,
-0.0399558842,
0.0200244375,
0.0182553213,
0.0590090193,
-0.0065536271,
-0.0115881469,
-0.0126315113,
0.018681271,
0.0153915565,
0.0260385443,
0.0294846222,
-0.0380810164,
-0.0148525424,
0.0095863333,
-0.0508436561,
-0.0718004853,
-0.0533254892,
-0.01521926,
0.0014075137,
-0.0350919813,
-0.0153623801,
3.06001016e-34,
0.0126524474,
-0.0030466097,
0.0184247699,
-0.0294990614,
-0.00199359,
-0.0586193316,
-0.0014540179,
0.0388987623,
0.0560783185,
-0.0601788014,
-0.0107027069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15051v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15051v4 | Matching Patients to Clinical Trials with Large Language Models | 2023-07-27T17:56:56 | 2024-04-27T19:21:54 | Qiao Jin, Zifeng Wang, Charalampos S. Floudas, Fangyuan Chen, Changlin Gong, Dara Bracken-Clarke, Elisabetta Xue, Yifan Yang, Jimeng Sun, Zhiyong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Clinical trials are often hindered by the challenge of patient recruitment.
In this work, we introduce TrialGPT, a first-of-its-kind large language model
(LLM) framework to assist patient-to-trial matching. Given a patient note,
TrialGPT predicts the patient's eligibility on a criterion-by-criterion basis
and then consolidates these predictions to assess the patient's eligibility for
the target trial. We evaluate the trial-level prediction performance of
TrialGPT on three publicly available cohorts of 184 patients with over 18,000
trial annotations. We also engaged three physicians to label over 1,000
patient-criterion pairs to assess its criterion-level prediction accuracy.
Experimental results show that TrialGPT achieves a criterion-level accuracy of
87.3% with faithful explanations, close to the expert performance
(88.7%-90.0%). The aggregated TrialGPT scores are highly correlated with human
eligibility judgments, and they outperform the best-competing models by 32.6%
to 57.2% in ranking and excluding clinical trials. Furthermore, our user study
reveals that TrialGPT can significantly reduce the screening time (by 42.6%) in
a real-life clinical trial matching task. These results and analyses have
demonstrated promising opportunities for clinical trial matching with LLMs such
as TrialGPT. | [
0.0521413498,
0.0950909927,
-0.0103702573,
-0.0236559547,
-0.0245512854,
0.0147162266,
0.0320260078,
0.0072326716,
0.0174817573,
-0.0148782227,
0.0019146076,
-0.0551758334,
-0.0201251823,
0.0358883962,
-0.0041631423,
-0.0293452945,
0.0098910518,
0.0156325363,
0.045925986,
-0.0102582695,
-0.0262963623,
0.0290302169,
-0.0162646789,
0.074461855,
0.0368811972,
-0.0197003763,
0.0735806599,
-0.0188160166,
0.0056121228,
-0.0601838641,
-0.0031089042,
0.0495105162,
-0.0204792954,
0.015568167,
0.0000017362,
-0.0845953599,
-0.0334052891,
0.0245768521,
-0.0524405763,
-0.0351064242,
0.0446916111,
0.0129218977,
0.0150408838,
0.0210483633,
-0.0131454878,
-0.0243221223,
0.0541339926,
0.0101863444,
0.0136030903,
0.0447661802,
-0.0149310585,
0.0255419575,
0.0131573007,
-0.0617998093,
0.0360510051,
-0.0590758771,
0.0414403342,
-0.0250137504,
0.0301889013,
-0.0032334644,
0.0332592651,
0.0156059312,
-0.0399100222,
0.0002745021,
0.0320135839,
0.0390957817,
-0.0545282438,
-0.0209727157,
-0.0022814295,
0.0409981534,
0.0235700123,
0.0016334137,
0.015102651,
0.0051388904,
0.0023986869,
0.0310038533,
-0.0254554395,
0.0125216562,
-0.022639364,
0.0136371991,
0.0283968039,
0.007142277,
0.0322865695,
-0.0017203704,
-0.0169727635,
0.04364115,
0.0157248788,
0.011175639,
0.0317843445,
0.0041036317,
-0.0072594984,
-0.0628801286,
0.0487722047,
0.0079100551,
-0.0671490654,
-0.0019046662,
-0.0131387301,
-0.0045435205,
0.0882099122,
-0.0609260723,
0.0149321025,
-0.0046926336,
0.0129243657,
0.0715552494,
-0.0130794318,
0.0219856985,
0.0009145815,
0.0159645341,
-0.0541703776,
-0.0014856274,
-0.0386171043,
0.0088560469,
-0.0155541236,
0.0169912875,
-0.0058955154,
0.0043629576,
-0.0999750942,
-0.0083346255,
-0.033187449,
0.010764515,
0.0423383452,
0.0221057069,
-0.0218461566,
-0.0032005564,
-0.0529405996,
-0.0107605122,
0.0112316804,
0.0066964212,
-0.0150291147,
-0.0387570858,
0.0497598425,
-0.0046797902,
-0.0012822326,
-0.0429001376,
0.0386719592,
0.0433491617,
0.0297478456,
-0.0197083,
0.0126515087,
-0.0262542777,
-0.0281167086,
-0.0221151672,
-0.0275730323,
-0.0546311997,
0.0469752401,
0.0273121279,
0.0247837529,
-0.0682485774,
-0.0111344922,
0.0125842374,
-0.0461434722,
0.0723901093,
-0.0230982974,
0.0176708475,
-0.0109652178,
0.0011801055,
-0.0293891244,
-0.0074050161,
0.0082691219,
-0.0180973019,
-0.0200610366,
-0.0327362828,
0.011006223,
0.0301262643,
0.0197432339,
-0.0148784816,
-0.0139799351,
0.0345804803,
0.0307060741,
0.0734487921,
-0.0248430874,
0.0340932086,
-0.0100482628,
-0.0315048322,
0.0446601249,
0.0608280674,
0.0454890728,
0.0256518181,
-0.0355430543,
-0.017695453,
-0.0366112851,
-0.0583513118,
-0.032484971,
0.008683105,
-0.013164294,
-0.0282985792,
0.0071924268,
0.0242741089,
-0.0321170054,
0.0041504451,
-0.0261092875,
-0.0064178077,
0.0057499912,
0.0357379429,
0.0211492125,
-0.0462031774,
0.0000139783,
0.0405993611,
0.0458511338,
0.0105597898,
-0.0348727405,
-0.0794495046,
-0.0472026505,
0.0644877926,
0.0355661958,
-0.0232356358,
-0.0155439582,
-0.0013411288,
-0.0009073517,
-0.0173807479,
0.0480500758,
-0.0042115492,
-0.0322164409,
-0.016439911,
-0.0338814929,
0.0677653775,
-0.0062014153,
-0.0009276677,
0.0113140577,
0.0219115131,
-0.038442716,
-0.0753764883,
-0.0381851159,
0.051667504,
-0.0384223275,
-0.0256066192,
0.0201908667,
-0.0087118046,
0.0539236926,
0.0061010751,
0.0076968255,
0.0253427923,
0.0089624124,
-0.0313047022,
0.0052266954,
-0.0170561168,
0.0287723467,
-0.025450075,
0.0085729752,
-0.0272615831,
-0.0093590561,
-0.0148401372,
-0.0305506736,
-0.0040446506,
-0.0170794856,
-0.0272613335,
0.0197142642,
-0.0036742433,
0.0181073751,
0.0058059138,
-0.0082902014,
-0.0634940565,
0.0333541334,
0.0183946099,
-0.0116439927,
0.0355310664,
-0.0922081769,
-0.010936778,
-0.0446359962,
-0.0177247617,
0.0289933346,
-0.0006885838,
-0.0005392526,
-0.0034419273,
-0.0087975403,
-0.0157564115,
-0.0297749937,
-0.1008006558,
0.0284718387,
0.0351984687,
-0.0000795528,
-0.0180319492,
0.0207977984,
-0.0036425423,
-0.0329227298,
-0.0644613951,
-0.0221051965,
0.0403322726,
0.005951101,
-0.0091001056,
0.0414939746,
-0.0279397499,
-0.027156068,
-0.0173280668,
-0.0335095562,
0.0543794036,
0.0215257946,
-0.0425423123,
-0.0242677238,
0.0171373785,
-0.0463228449,
-0.0072131525,
0.0056281071,
0.0132981436,
0.0002339793,
-0.0034160789,
-0.0418713279,
0.0200774297,
-0.013398055,
-0.0192639865,
0.0697006658,
0.0186564736,
-0.0349979475,
0.0071858019,
-0.0234549325,
-0.0667110085,
0.0010382883,
-0.0442042463,
-0.0108906021,
0.0554545484,
0.0075307474,
-0.0082041323,
-0.0348562486,
-0.001434778,
-0.0291623995,
0.0364668481,
-0.0702339485,
0.0156367123,
-0.0153317805,
0.0330069885,
-0.0234090462,
-0.0601019301,
0.1313964725,
-0.0164016224,
0.0415351652,
-0.0706439912,
-0.0098148575,
-0.0334742703,
-0.0118238153,
0.0235177111,
0.0258237682,
0.0058787409,
0.0120266005,
0.0155792376,
-0.0233865585,
0.0103239855,
-0.0527058169,
0.0981647,
-0.0249285251,
0.0569359586,
0.0034409452,
-0.0343159288,
-0.0347961262,
-0.0447861478,
-0.0303377807,
-0.0149313621,
0.0254851766,
0.0348117016,
-0.0793964788,
0.0173364189,
-0.0275996588,
0.0728499666,
0.0049847192,
-0.0104572596,
0.0175674092,
-0.0625941828,
0.0399091542,
-0.0125408834,
0.0069547268,
-0.0262001101,
0.022259986,
0.0362291634,
0.003420033,
0.0192741472,
-0.0014482959,
0.0227414705,
0.0174932685,
-0.0578658208,
-0.008525257,
0.0583766475,
0.0196036026,
-0.0395222865,
0.0365421735,
0.1074211225,
0.0175265744,
-0.100282684,
-0.0055328235,
-0.0033420217,
0.0065924292,
0.0042290753,
0.0220907982,
-0.0569666363,
-0.0333624482,
0.0034803245,
0.0389614329,
-0.0165624693,
-0.0220548082,
-0.0195801649,
-0.0209663101,
0.049588047,
0.0285309423,
-0.0248112287,
0.0067255232,
-0.0489875972,
0.0024288672,
-0.0325213186,
-0.0323300399,
-0.0128376791,
-0.0066928375,
-0.0054424349,
-0.0120547367,
-0.081476219,
-0.0702134296,
0.072031565,
-0.0388337821,
0.0570490994,
0.0443225428,
0.0364835225,
0.006923689,
-0.0232393984,
-0.0118963644,
-0.0052000177,
-0.0136319557,
0.0109196194,
0.0953555256,
0.0274093859,
0.0188508742,
-0.0594172142,
0.0210329164,
-0.0553188436,
-0.0268938243,
0.0111127589,
0.0861420333,
-0.0408229381,
-0.0036294549,
-0.0345106721,
0.0162526034,
-0.0089048455,
0.0582132563,
0.0074181948,
-0.0259046424,
0.0198896397,
-0.0021571151,
0.0316487774,
-0.004750717,
-0.0226773135,
0.0462029316,
-0.0386764444,
0.0224794764,
-0.035508763,
-0.0222200938,
0.0735950992,
-0.004653947,
0.0123723717,
0.0740149915,
0.0063907211,
-0.0116297863,
-0.0136655439,
0.0979648679,
0.0065543968,
0.0439225808,
-0.0697399229,
-0.0330461375,
0.0337916166,
-0.0237227567,
-0.0259592924,
0.0106004244,
-0.0144144529,
-0.0150518594,
-0.0200876817,
0.0075288219,
0.0333688669,
-0.0064210063,
0.0004523136,
-0.0325768851,
0.0103165489,
-0.0056873574,
0.0325327516,
-0.0356236435,
-0.0595852919,
-0.0379918627,
-0.0344402008,
0.0006461754,
-0.0265348814,
0.0438191183,
0.0035423234,
0.0053727995,
-0.0028373017,
-0.0080882553,
0.0600804687,
0.0462197922,
0.0723172575,
-0.0359464996,
-0.0251449086,
-0.0362351984,
0.0208323766,
0.0013577148,
0.009813766,
-0.0201149695,
-0.028501194,
0.0427047089,
-0.0075806272,
-0.010117894,
-0.0544036515,
-0.0692540631,
-0.0430506691,
-0.0590849109,
0.0447663851,
0.0133627625,
-0.0110974386,
0.0807630867,
-0.0077896644,
0.0199020337,
0.0235354435,
-0.0113230906,
0.0391127765,
-0.0350488648,
0.0473586321,
-0.0132917957,
0.0443651639,
-0.0031385073,
0.0247472618,
-0.0213191882,
-0.0847397521,
-0.0126121724,
0.004331687,
0.0492736995,
-0.0025030249,
0.0436106585,
-0.0123070115,
0.0115068881,
-0.0578870252,
0.0017991491,
0.0119055072,
0.0072601908,
0.0445992313,
0.0163064525,
-0.0274284035,
-0.0385987982,
0.088929072,
0.039704904,
0.0251364168,
-0.0487041436,
-0.0486530066,
-0.0201176703,
-0.0215071719,
0.0201544203,
0.0049784742,
-0.0584319308,
-0.0091325715,
-0.0548721626,
-0.0255793072,
0.0158672407,
-0.0232127253,
-0.0233479477,
-0.0154652856,
0.0260739271,
0.0628315434,
-0.0121084098,
-0.0536873527,
-0.0456956849,
0.0265547633,
-0.0117178475,
-0.028844459,
-0.0191685539,
-4.984361636e-33,
0.0089399703,
-0.0058354433,
0.0021194334,
-0.0193693005,
0.034103144,
0.0087602278,
-0.0159025043,
-0.0108143287,
0.03499832,
0.0305755362,
-0.0123415748,
0.0010284681,
0.0015513613,
0.0231538676,
0.0142938495,
-0.0236991644,
0.0327640623,
0.0349286161,
-0.024431251,
0.0296407249,
-0.0416410118,
0.0071291314,
0.0051929993,
-0.0515373871,
0.0254968107,
0.0239954647,
0.0332297832,
0.0126265641,
-0.0132272271,
0.100503929,
-0.0014343867,
0.0351419672,
0.0467465371,
-0.0155501664,
0.001344446,
-0.0242389999,
-0.0302022155,
0.0099171707,
-0.0163187645,
-0.027688466,
0.0163041819,
-0.0080841258,
0.0383356735,
-0.0115642678,
-0.0527003743,
-0.0085215317,
0.039314203,
-0.0455101393,
-0.025296744,
-0.0141297299,
0.0011232597,
0.0430962257,
0.0035532145,
0.0075884396,
-0.0061701178,
0.0279949419,
-0.0367733985,
0.0555927046,
-0.0311860014,
0.0325187594,
0.0044679851,
0.0296565499,
0.0085587557,
-0.0087934611,
-0.0611673072,
0.0831232145,
-0.0128830476,
-0.0014037963,
0.0185956955,
-0.0119571127,
-0.0500517525,
0.0218345225,
0.0458207503,
0.0155033348,
0.0295407437,
0.0057485667,
-0.0933922902,
0.0643286631,
-0.0437850021,
-0.0024379687,
0.0465186946,
-0.0181246903,
-0.0288794022,
-0.0383343287,
-0.0598806031,
0.0198697206,
-0.0537713021,
-0.0090395836,
0.0565922819,
0.0055352882,
-0.0038376942,
0.0016141388,
0.0400169678,
-0.0267725009,
-0.0451382399,
-0.0203539412,
0.030688433,
0.0112051265,
-0.0274480935,
0.0266121365,
-0.0368448608,
-0.0035112565,
0.0070729842,
-0.0483371019,
0.0426158346,
0.0204783622,
0.0057624346,
-0.0688228011,
-0.0619827062,
0.0057963599,
0.0137102306,
-0.0051649455,
-0.0128626442,
0.0149690425,
0.0549021065,
0.0324817151,
0.0496920198,
0.0685005113,
0.0136628151,
-0.0350098424,
-0.0392637923,
-0.0619795471,
-0.0130885746,
0.011997655,
-0.0418879166,
0.038459219,
-0.022362262,
0.0288393553,
0.0422475934,
-0.0397855118,
-0.0111252405,
-0.0203476567,
2.517e-7,
0.0747455731,
0.0724355429,
-0.0511587448,
-0.0293001756,
0.0281822439,
0.0105588613,
-0.00981142,
0.012143068,
0.0522252172,
0.0034060238,
0.0370840207,
-0.010238192,
0.0522161461,
0.0334986709,
-0.0476006679,
-0.0332507752,
-0.0619646236,
-0.0186682642,
-0.0531156845,
-0.0108691817,
0.046769578,
0.0898025408,
-0.0069157397,
-0.0164436176,
0.0269766506,
-0.0501541346,
0.035896387,
-0.0578897856,
-0.0438147709,
0.0629313812,
0.0262494553,
-0.0332080871,
0.0066798874,
0.1002352834,
-0.0308249407,
0.0129488772,
-0.0080355592,
0.0904687569,
-0.0646324754,
0.0495980382,
-0.0098808138,
-0.009591734,
0.0283477157,
-0.0295777563,
0.0376399979,
-0.0493131317,
-0.0325682051,
-0.022454299,
-0.0201908238,
-0.046606794,
0.0943904594,
0.0141892033,
-0.0115375081,
0.0188121852,
0.053209573,
0.0295583364,
-0.0535845086,
-0.0511128642,
0.0044896728,
0.0551085137,
-0.0692979768,
-0.0276591517,
0.0166859906,
-0.0089036571,
0.0053919698,
-0.0675204545,
0.0356607772,
2.286885229e-34,
0.0495546013,
0.0312894844,
0.0197396725,
-0.0281809103,
0.0650805905,
-0.0024684349,
0.0290083736,
0.0213906169,
0.0041720867,
-0.0776122659,
0.0171273015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15043v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15043v2 | Universal and Transferable Adversarial Attacks on Aligned Language Models | 2023-07-27T17:49:12 | 2023-12-20T20:48:57 | Andy Zou, Zifan Wang, Nicholas Carlini, Milad Nasr, J. Zico Kolter, Matt Fredrikson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Because "out-of-the-box" large language models are capable of generating a
great deal of objectionable content, recent work has focused on aligning these
models in an attempt to prevent undesirable generation. While there has been
some success at circumventing these measures -- so-called "jailbreaks" against
LLMs -- these attacks have required significant human ingenuity and are brittle
in practice. In this paper, we propose a simple and effective attack method
that causes aligned language models to generate objectionable behaviors.
Specifically, our approach finds a suffix that, when attached to a wide range
of queries for an LLM to produce objectionable content, aims to maximize the
probability that the model produces an affirmative response (rather than
refusing to answer). However, instead of relying on manual engineering, our
approach automatically produces these adversarial suffixes by a combination of
greedy and gradient-based search techniques, and also improves over past
automatic prompt generation methods.
Surprisingly, we find that the adversarial prompts generated by our approach
are quite transferable, including to black-box, publicly released LLMs.
Specifically, we train an adversarial attack suffix on multiple prompts (i.e.,
queries asking for many different types of objectionable content), as well as
multiple models (in our case, Vicuna-7B and 13B). When doing so, the resulting
attack suffix is able to induce objectionable content in the public interfaces
to ChatGPT, Bard, and Claude, as well as open source LLMs such as LLaMA-2-Chat,
Pythia, Falcon, and others. In total, this work significantly advances the
state-of-the-art in adversarial attacks against aligned language models,
raising important questions about how such systems can be prevented from
producing objectionable information. Code is available at
github.com/llm-attacks/llm-attacks. | [
0.0488999113,
0.0743140131,
-0.0268917102,
0.0633544922,
-0.0324076228,
-0.0071552391,
0.0222534239,
0.0144051155,
0.0448027588,
-0.0350222588,
-0.0440040454,
-0.0260163546,
-0.0034241299,
0.0092087733,
0.0616012663,
-0.0074647903,
0.0383043028,
0.0020596357,
-0.0137812831,
-0.0241359342,
0.0066001443,
-0.0003748096,
0.0203189421,
0.0370447114,
0.0131056737,
-0.0198656861,
-0.0155204907,
0.0214804392,
-0.0051248381,
-0.032236509,
0.034463305,
0.0428730324,
-0.0327483751,
0.0807768553,
0.0000020573,
-0.0397837386,
-0.0475125648,
0.0095261931,
-0.0376338661,
0.0410792492,
0.0206466187,
-0.0064339433,
-0.0351960249,
0.021147741,
-0.0523517616,
0.0124365417,
0.0328339562,
0.0253759548,
0.1039464921,
0.1134788394,
0.0065010986,
0.0037812903,
0.0452933274,
-0.0465819538,
0.0137394471,
-0.0541487485,
0.0224580504,
-0.0413859598,
0.0041576186,
0.0221952014,
0.0156239988,
0.0170538444,
0.0179492626,
-0.0121789062,
-0.041419141,
-0.0123345992,
-0.0395423435,
-0.0343731418,
0.0100983884,
0.071799852,
-0.0197689906,
-0.024659792,
0.0234747659,
0.0070942994,
0.0288231838,
-0.0095602069,
-0.0373373516,
0.032764513,
0.00716752,
0.0073096049,
0.0161378887,
-0.0287894793,
0.0562277697,
0.0206180047,
0.0058403555,
0.0248608943,
0.0319654234,
-0.0421582125,
0.0009211546,
-0.0337580703,
0.0073082433,
-0.0721460283,
-0.0038172118,
0.0170818437,
-0.0358502269,
0.0237902869,
-0.0911232084,
-0.0389364325,
0.0472320132,
-0.035623759,
0.0481809266,
0.0380474813,
-0.0188939739,
0.0292581245,
-0.0220256299,
0.0286554154,
-0.0628227293,
0.0530571453,
-0.0116692362,
0.0236499663,
0.0364657789,
-0.0273636393,
0.0150758931,
0.0132951336,
-0.0274692532,
0.013999884,
-0.0147511922,
0.0479941741,
-0.0113097578,
0.0392367542,
-0.0231348146,
0.0347254388,
-0.015729608,
-0.0128702316,
-0.0047552772,
-0.036571525,
0.0114770699,
-0.0143558793,
0.0065209963,
-0.1009605005,
-0.0260980166,
0.0190791059,
-0.0616855547,
-0.0310681481,
0.0160049535,
0.1218230799,
0.0131980497,
-0.0289311782,
-0.0495527945,
-0.0424527265,
-0.0117645729,
-0.044916641,
0.0268095396,
-0.0606685616,
-0.0119816205,
-0.0197837204,
-0.0457082577,
-0.0732679442,
0.0117403679,
0.0178061202,
-0.0264281146,
0.0741146579,
0.0215068217,
-0.0236248188,
0.0218547489,
0.0276580304,
-0.0173008852,
0.0811804011,
-0.0061718267,
0.0603400245,
0.0521921217,
-0.0050187246,
0.0164597426,
0.0724132508,
0.0389834531,
0.034493193,
-0.0144160604,
0.0064355568,
0.0125252884,
0.0035242178,
-0.0217359252,
0.072330676,
0.0053987042,
-0.086900644,
0.0879647732,
0.0266415905,
-0.0400893614,
0.0292061344,
0.0090917526,
-0.0267917328,
-0.006754234,
0.0362740569,
-0.0717620775,
0.00417274,
-0.0755042136,
-0.0222000778,
0.0258763935,
0.0338226222,
-0.0113769798,
-0.0502153412,
0.0060090707,
0.0106623285,
0.0130516645,
0.0172529593,
0.0144949406,
0.0185343567,
-0.0402341932,
0.0345251374,
0.034102723,
-0.0355296843,
-0.0178577751,
-0.0757891089,
0.0265357681,
0.0055642705,
0.082421869,
-0.0340926275,
-0.0055413558,
-0.0114306109,
-0.0158385318,
0.0503506884,
0.0438672118,
0.0045737922,
-0.0335746631,
-0.0194008071,
-0.0198354982,
-0.0212404523,
0.0187832918,
0.0107637774,
0.0116779609,
-0.003940661,
-0.0068671578,
-0.0187364351,
-0.0187758151,
0.0299428776,
-0.0206465255,
-0.0694071576,
-0.0066386033,
0.0360008217,
0.0446275137,
-0.0042052339,
-0.0013424107,
0.0177135486,
0.0715298057,
-0.017535096,
-0.0047650663,
-0.0274954382,
-0.0168269072,
-0.0127273304,
0.0349920839,
-0.0318583213,
-0.0223986953,
0.0632564276,
-0.0387634151,
0.0058309659,
0.0360667109,
-0.0356233791,
0.0401845686,
-0.0118737621,
0.0199372526,
0.0020133851,
0.0171873998,
-0.0503449142,
0.0449722968,
-0.0236735623,
0.013481684,
0.0299738683,
-0.0097950147,
0.0138782645,
-0.049811177,
-0.0471308045,
0.0268353056,
-0.0267911628,
0.0244386215,
0.0099777319,
0.0061708558,
-0.0051200204,
-0.0373219214,
-0.0440901667,
-0.0088985106,
-0.0115208076,
0.0197920203,
0.035213761,
0.01034493,
-0.0244754627,
-0.0053185336,
-0.055136852,
-0.0212239511,
0.0182935428,
0.0374100357,
0.0211267006,
-0.0078997249,
-0.0471450016,
-0.0428856201,
-0.0063724737,
-0.0036469933,
0.0585060231,
-0.0274328925,
-0.0156123796,
-0.0161453746,
0.003327718,
-0.0373295583,
0.047307916,
-0.0241967514,
-0.0621407889,
0.0466434509,
0.0048877462,
-0.0441697091,
0.1025609896,
0.0393206328,
0.059943229,
0.0388010368,
0.0289158318,
-0.0570050478,
0.0001199584,
0.0066286055,
-0.0240008738,
-0.0296618566,
-0.0466465205,
0.0326415971,
0.0684665293,
0.034390226,
0.0071739648,
-0.0372674465,
0.0604246669,
0.0141006457,
-0.0461902246,
-0.0053586653,
-0.0052338634,
-0.0508054271,
0.0161844697,
-0.0088287331,
-0.0820554346,
0.0559618473,
-0.0579701737,
0.0148324762,
-0.0105950022,
-0.0286953691,
-0.0046257298,
0.066375576,
-0.0126478681,
0.0312622339,
0.0689765438,
-0.0166836102,
-0.0794785097,
-0.0049469154,
0.0401915945,
-0.0368436836,
0.0390745997,
-0.0265123155,
0.0064169224,
-0.0091364458,
-0.0349334814,
-0.0874906182,
-0.0621134788,
-0.000124034,
-0.0157016069,
0.0309763905,
-0.0078616804,
-0.0170331877,
-0.0290243253,
-0.0063964156,
-0.0275965687,
-0.0306041893,
0.0198401511,
-0.0306630041,
0.0290325843,
0.0597183406,
-0.0000188163,
0.0107971737,
-0.0288969446,
0.0037026475,
0.0746956468,
-0.0130855292,
0.0162387807,
0.0139469374,
-0.0025479575,
0.0344014056,
0.0009289275,
-0.0160757639,
0.003655693,
0.0247286558,
-0.0350634493,
0.0034898105,
0.0388966799,
0.0142910182,
-0.0060344744,
0.0243222211,
0.0000813252,
0.0635997579,
0.0121373357,
0.0188137852,
-0.0889338329,
-0.023269726,
0.0119758891,
0.0441036373,
-0.0231420323,
-0.0132431854,
-0.0447563231,
-0.1348086149,
-0.0057080272,
0.0206576623,
-0.020449331,
0.0140931644,
0.0159454383,
-0.0076748752,
-0.0041207466,
0.0556339808,
-0.0147736138,
0.007822549,
-0.0030514637,
0.0035654132,
0.0187081527,
-0.0074305604,
-0.0139428321,
-0.0204371829,
0.0772134066,
0.0873024315,
0.0126573145,
-0.0094711073,
-0.0277553331,
0.0669355914,
0.0064266245,
-0.0247243699,
0.0029129328,
0.0239955373,
-0.0032343613,
-0.0371103473,
0.002399785,
0.0284954328,
0.0035047589,
0.0240137,
0.0156175829,
0.0472625419,
-0.004755286,
-0.0118865548,
-0.0365540646,
-0.0059641735,
0.0231130514,
0.0836380795,
0.0254992545,
-0.0551583804,
-0.0230615959,
-0.0942732021,
-0.0266158879,
-0.0142535241,
-0.0507330112,
0.0170493685,
0.0007108436,
-0.0081243962,
-0.075951986,
-0.0084121991,
-0.0264169089,
0.009241784,
0.0367593542,
-0.0135291424,
-0.0189291183,
-0.0005328212,
0.0107331406,
-0.0053057242,
-0.0111958198,
0.0209912471,
-0.0881130472,
-0.0164547563,
0.0028245123,
-0.0465060771,
0.0006485308,
-0.0198062751,
-0.063653931,
-0.1003653035,
0.0051054684,
0.0630049706,
0.0264987461,
0.0316922851,
-0.0182358902,
-0.0442547947,
0.0446677692,
0.0721587464,
-0.0169047657,
0.0364810117,
0.0753889978,
-0.0141590815,
0.0088901082,
0.0549905226,
-0.0639570206,
-0.0116135487,
0.0630976483,
0.0060045631,
-0.0502659269,
-0.0423343182,
0.0304478966,
0.0301619321,
0.0171528012,
-0.0097986087,
-0.0265057087,
0.0126279015,
0.0255530812,
0.0011099173,
-0.0341143496,
-0.0138955582,
0.0001779504,
-0.0022615429,
-0.0184608493,
0.025752116,
0.0093714176,
-0.0118931234,
0.0426045842,
-0.0293717291,
0.0338093378,
0.0079431152,
0.0138563877,
0.0363586955,
0.0237116218,
-0.0096868025,
0.0608740784,
-0.0049643856,
0.0335498303,
0.0045262114,
0.0390421562,
0.008568177,
-0.0027598271,
0.006031875,
0.0493833795,
-0.0577829741,
-0.0474814177,
0.003146118,
0.0330477916,
0.0263940282,
-0.0103008486,
0.0009276975,
0.0025702813,
-0.0070484313,
-0.017415015,
-0.0274225473,
0.0176476501,
-0.0419676304,
0.0376945809,
-0.0055023157,
-0.0112068439,
0.0092867762,
0.0555759594,
-0.0087350756,
0.0635329187,
0.0323729105,
0.0069773667,
-0.0436047167,
-0.0483145006,
0.0642625317,
-0.0117749125,
-0.0146937221,
-0.0290803872,
-0.0455002002,
-0.0770146251,
-0.0390170813,
0.0135798054,
-0.0098879812,
-0.0101726577,
-0.004258363,
0.0562296435,
0.0154915722,
0.0378637649,
-0.0373276845,
0.0338130854,
-0.0198197048,
-0.0699188411,
0.0136314798,
-6.283977537e-33,
0.0069179097,
-0.0236680768,
-0.0293065291,
-0.0190072693,
0.0075624166,
-0.0074190921,
-0.0308096781,
-0.0022776292,
-0.0528795831,
-0.0332497507,
-0.0205862839,
-0.0068300646,
-0.007074913,
0.0124829914,
-0.0515468009,
-0.0542301163,
0.0188130457,
0.0025764513,
-0.0444249734,
0.0155371996,
0.0566422902,
0.0050132624,
-0.0006996716,
-0.0311816894,
0.0468699895,
-0.0346601643,
-0.0512238368,
0.0218405556,
-0.0552947335,
0.0722471327,
-0.0085090213,
0.0187486932,
-0.0091977883,
-0.0074636359,
0.0040178602,
0.0465042964,
0.0076073939,
-0.0090960078,
0.0322300605,
-0.0080174413,
-0.0107424939,
-0.0535468981,
0.0519601032,
-0.0172298364,
-0.0161725767,
0.0105100442,
0.0085376566,
-0.0096066883,
-0.0155164357,
-0.002996112,
-0.0430511571,
-0.0010817135,
-0.0132039702,
-0.0421579033,
-0.0210123006,
0.0259251837,
0.0367214978,
0.0119023314,
-0.0267724022,
0.0359771736,
0.0136641227,
0.0254125651,
0.0726564974,
-0.0039458773,
0.0168325473,
0.076505743,
-0.0051957034,
-0.0021898525,
-0.0168357193,
-0.0010112667,
-0.0112438248,
0.0635952875,
0.058598496,
0.0569988973,
0.026031252,
-0.0341854133,
-0.0459218659,
0.0343519077,
0.0350072421,
0.0101604275,
0.0267637428,
-0.0012381074,
-0.0430071577,
-0.0037371141,
-0.0125143155,
-0.0474771373,
-0.0254797004,
-0.0373201296,
0.0191193353,
0.0056044888,
-0.0415712744,
-0.0643243492,
0.0001278225,
-0.0627020821,
-0.0135266474,
0.0315424949,
-0.0164249316,
-0.0419724099,
0.0240237936,
0.0076011787,
-0.0036520499,
0.0196054205,
0.0090317829,
-0.0674833432,
0.018301608,
0.0206512176,
0.0363000333,
0.0407494754,
-0.0615456551,
0.0010655111,
-0.0308007933,
0.0403450206,
0.0111679863,
0.0123403864,
0.0383632369,
-0.0280531589,
-0.0082712965,
0.0177675933,
0.0128784338,
0.023743676,
-0.0743373409,
0.0085348403,
-0.024702007,
0.0311463643,
-0.0369655453,
0.0043972423,
-0.0122116776,
0.0631768182,
0.0476280749,
-0.0803789571,
-0.0015214119,
-0.040900778,
2.809e-7,
-0.0002652414,
0.0051122336,
0.0091326702,
0.035958264,
0.0298863817,
0.0780135095,
-0.0195379928,
0.0656297505,
-0.0210741628,
-0.0574303828,
-0.0340181626,
-0.0126107549,
0.0478039123,
0.0204295721,
-0.0660346374,
0.0364829078,
-0.0859304965,
0.0065637231,
-0.0575045943,
0.0024215966,
0.0474811159,
0.1278711408,
0.0168952402,
-0.0269384477,
0.0012386919,
-0.0303844027,
0.0276245605,
-0.0215609446,
-0.0127107892,
-0.0067031672,
0.0264191553,
-0.0056692725,
0.0146641908,
-0.0184020437,
-0.0232344847,
-0.0008092106,
-0.0330729894,
0.0425538644,
0.0402424894,
-0.0611357316,
-0.0154696843,
-0.0455564409,
-0.0021854958,
-0.0465678088,
0.0810818523,
0.0390105173,
-0.0115832826,
-0.0405701548,
0.0223793276,
-0.0310838576,
0.0329680555,
-0.0464341603,
-0.0211325698,
-0.0008098776,
0.0052582351,
0.0035678437,
0.0165557954,
-0.0596826784,
-0.0318188295,
-0.0429512449,
-0.02333734,
-0.0437684394,
-0.0103599718,
0.0387437306,
0.0075615784,
-0.0307819489,
0.0005232657,
2.655093452e-34,
-0.0009043965,
-0.0286132377,
0.0173637681,
0.007520074,
0.0124835726,
0.0054708468,
0.0439332053,
0.0127354749,
0.0235720165,
-0.0593397021,
-0.03222939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15020v1 | SuperCLUE: A Comprehensive Chinese Large Language Model Benchmark | 2023-07-27T17:24:09 | 2023-07-27T17:24:09 | Liang Xu, Anqi Li, Lei Zhu, Hang Xue, Changtai Zhu, Kangkang Zhao, Haonan He, Xuanwei Zhang, Qiyue Kang, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown the potential to be integrated into
human daily lives. Therefore, user preference is the most critical criterion
for assessing LLMs' performance in real-world scenarios. However, existing
benchmarks mainly focus on measuring models' accuracy using multi-choice
questions, which limits the understanding of their capabilities in real
applications. We fill this gap by proposing a comprehensive Chinese benchmark
SuperCLUE, named after another popular Chinese LLM benchmark CLUE. SuperCLUE
encompasses three sub-tasks: actual users' queries and ratings derived from an
LLM battle platform (CArena), open-ended questions with single and
multiple-turn dialogues (OPEN), and closed-ended questions with the same stems
as open-ended single-turn ones (CLOSE). Our study shows that accuracy on
closed-ended questions is insufficient to reflect human preferences achieved on
open-ended ones. At the same time, they can complement each other to predict
actual user preferences. We also demonstrate that GPT-4 is a reliable judge to
automatically evaluate human preferences on open-ended questions in a Chinese
context. Our benchmark will be released at https://www.CLUEbenchmarks.com | [
0.0359159335,
0.0422627926,
-0.0145113477,
0.0649903566,
-0.0305053517,
-0.0033924934,
0.0072686472,
0.0119907176,
0.0398153849,
-0.0214735623,
-0.0497753359,
-0.077790767,
-0.0071008131,
0.0181284901,
0.012713233,
-0.0397958569,
0.0334242247,
-0.0115855355,
-0.017587658,
-0.0128326807,
0.0221493598,
0.000665765,
0.0101259779,
0.0532660894,
0.036232207,
-0.0191949811,
-0.0104251252,
0.0143052498,
-0.0172569212,
-0.0439767726,
0.021332968,
0.049097497,
-0.0168538224,
0.0450195,
0.0000021577,
-0.0639419928,
-0.0290762894,
-0.0208251867,
-0.0386729501,
0.047876697,
0.0293262005,
0.0609381832,
0.0039558378,
0.0386974961,
-0.0543292277,
-0.0288429409,
0.0169032291,
0.0329192802,
0.0481522866,
0.0465851873,
0.0042529278,
-0.0146085294,
0.0111733237,
-0.0403621569,
0.003712442,
-0.0770387724,
0.0042975913,
0.0129962508,
0.0386418961,
-0.0094913682,
-0.0124565447,
-0.0123009495,
0.0093903961,
0.0019545902,
-0.0360945463,
0.0151226353,
-0.0465411656,
0.0231507942,
0.0147969825,
0.1200502142,
-0.0134493774,
0.0019304694,
-0.006326241,
-0.0034378611,
-0.0157731269,
0.0077842455,
-0.0522200502,
-0.0141478535,
-0.0106388591,
-0.0096468553,
0.0167265031,
-0.0250234008,
0.0351485461,
0.0224844404,
-0.0407490134,
0.1023106351,
0.026899701,
-0.0126079349,
0.0211957768,
-0.0172925573,
-0.0249462668,
-0.0529389046,
0.0214002784,
0.0064018643,
-0.0822130293,
0.0307392478,
-0.0005479697,
0.0293746963,
0.0237227958,
-0.0819241032,
0.0349361375,
0.039186433,
-0.0064893835,
0.0725411624,
0.0060767019,
0.060820628,
-0.0136820432,
-0.0125756413,
-0.0651560724,
-0.0034150076,
-0.0133625204,
0.0043455865,
-0.0156567041,
0.0388704985,
-0.0369687229,
-0.0259329211,
-0.0427595451,
0.0325462483,
0.0150426859,
0.0229184944,
0.0112353899,
-0.0128444498,
0.0088164639,
-0.0179246459,
-0.0537091382,
0.0417719297,
-0.0561350919,
-0.0075185942,
-0.0067185899,
-0.0667035058,
0.0387018025,
0.0245490838,
-0.0179422479,
-0.0461212769,
0.006273251,
0.0634953976,
0.0008229403,
-0.0018821475,
-0.0144111402,
-0.0116300108,
0.0022483086,
-0.054190319,
-0.0299432967,
-0.0745749772,
0.0125327082,
0.0203480292,
0.013962728,
-0.0228033811,
0.0069445679,
0.0242059939,
0.0075595919,
0.0364809074,
0.0172312558,
-0.0043498273,
0.0165839884,
0.0097337579,
-0.0041675521,
0.0693388954,
0.0098813102,
0.024623787,
0.0754120424,
-0.0191326253,
-0.0046896357,
0.0619314872,
-0.0264232345,
0.0105064902,
-0.0352598988,
0.0590848587,
0.0405673496,
0.0357025266,
-0.0143587617,
0.0625006035,
-0.0144921094,
-0.0194767527,
0.0908376649,
0.0427021086,
0.0035611584,
-0.0065075341,
-0.0038576808,
0.00116041,
0.0168136656,
0.0268986151,
-0.0196758229,
0.0090271998,
-0.0440361612,
-0.0035190419,
0.0421719253,
0.0085661039,
-0.0352174081,
-0.0621742643,
-0.0121932514,
0.0032375865,
-0.0052609667,
0.0325644612,
0.0386180021,
-0.0613134243,
-0.0354437009,
0.0247968696,
0.0185275432,
-0.0447431058,
-0.0017609731,
-0.0561298244,
0.0161053091,
0.0677311346,
0.0600290224,
-0.028139431,
-0.0306265969,
0.0095256809,
-0.0111118611,
0.0491330773,
0.0821113661,
-0.0242457613,
-0.0254677609,
-0.0441862717,
-0.0050413529,
0.0405046381,
-0.0015857341,
0.0127972765,
0.0122346906,
0.0094983205,
-0.0039558639,
-0.0504321791,
-0.023448579,
0.0064821043,
-0.0312004089,
-0.0353809446,
-0.0014715233,
-0.0010433736,
0.0127007365,
0.0152622787,
-0.0104934536,
0.0087900972,
0.0229355767,
-0.0055687926,
-0.0164533369,
-0.0043011219,
-0.042864494,
-0.0237473454,
0.0554757975,
-0.0256350897,
-0.0121104531,
0.0549024902,
-0.0236648154,
-0.0317927115,
-0.0293713436,
0.0018090139,
0.0514119565,
-0.0569588915,
0.0456398837,
-0.0330557227,
-0.013213261,
-0.0654427558,
0.0645589232,
-0.0115982769,
0.0496731065,
0.001343113,
-0.0036300335,
0.0186430011,
-0.050604593,
-0.0664006472,
0.0698813573,
0.0161949918,
0.0442438349,
0.0275545809,
-0.0010209952,
-0.0760425851,
-0.0175842755,
-0.1105590686,
0.0296031386,
-0.0402556956,
0.0184929818,
0.0239664465,
0.0026022489,
-0.0185682755,
0.0001958355,
-0.0737133399,
-0.0083436184,
-0.0221392326,
0.0241300482,
0.0149376588,
0.0115173897,
0.0160891693,
-0.0511459447,
-0.0167620704,
0.002007395,
0.0328675844,
-0.0167066865,
0.0295573305,
-0.0043927603,
0.0053655081,
-0.0353407115,
0.0038686511,
-0.0398296043,
-0.0460603684,
0.0133799259,
-0.0461302996,
0.0321950801,
0.05233353,
0.0300252251,
-0.014533584,
0.0321462713,
-0.0031975452,
-0.0514160395,
0.0062719285,
-0.0013751334,
-0.0349448323,
-0.0504532717,
-0.0203915294,
0.0009272142,
0.0574862659,
0.0031459075,
0.0038612059,
-0.0188429691,
0.0017395484,
-0.0415100306,
0.0164269526,
-0.0666109025,
0.034000881,
-0.0434820652,
0.0286971554,
-0.0002745066,
-0.0280003697,
0.057348974,
-0.0164987203,
0.0057305051,
-0.0432461984,
-0.005780539,
-0.0432307273,
0.0573323704,
0.0020985878,
0.0236170851,
-0.0130316745,
-0.0210636426,
-0.0485450663,
-0.0116408607,
0.0074925036,
-0.0756833702,
0.0673014298,
-0.0462262891,
-0.0026672329,
-0.0103557752,
-0.0593472905,
-0.0355629586,
-0.0336322412,
-0.0449483916,
-0.0113584734,
0.0565390326,
-0.0160231479,
0.0294709988,
0.0213066339,
0.0028597568,
0.0271087773,
-0.0257642455,
0.0000358529,
0.0143197663,
0.0544547178,
0.0711537749,
0.0288024489,
0.0080832588,
-0.0232962761,
0.0641187951,
0.077264756,
0.0740551054,
-0.0159204081,
0.0058112666,
-0.0023775017,
0.0500920527,
-0.0459055081,
-0.0428842939,
0.0250659697,
0.0470764562,
-0.0487511531,
0.0265322942,
0.1282843798,
0.0507518649,
-0.0418437235,
-0.0095176529,
-0.0341091976,
0.0464871041,
0.0391803011,
0.0386833213,
-0.0960820839,
-0.024153091,
0.0061291894,
0.0350685269,
0.0108422795,
-0.0413341932,
-0.000969023,
-0.1501725912,
0.0019072159,
-0.0168339536,
-0.0486486033,
0.0324930735,
-0.0255911648,
0.0082139187,
-0.0237080548,
0.0363514088,
0.033717759,
0.0108557083,
0.0017373181,
-0.0048513389,
-0.0413222089,
-0.0137632824,
0.0743388981,
-0.0439972989,
0.03206769,
0.0508794002,
0.0395395234,
-0.0143350624,
-0.0030448467,
0.0456695706,
-0.0200396683,
-0.0144807938,
-0.0257643033,
0.039735917,
0.0037974396,
-0.0117605301,
-0.024764454,
-0.0004627859,
-0.0100136017,
0.0385184735,
0.0649134219,
0.0512722172,
0.0013967078,
-0.009838325,
0.0097546494,
-0.0172440093,
0.0114144254,
0.0858082995,
0.0327320211,
-0.0859780982,
-0.020314198,
-0.0400562845,
-0.0339788422,
-0.0370121934,
-0.047030095,
0.0084591964,
0.0049455049,
0.0271827746,
-0.0775794759,
-0.0249622315,
0.0115788244,
0.03224352,
-0.0055185705,
0.0313984044,
0.0112083703,
-0.0027489013,
0.0015993909,
0.0142066134,
-0.0233781915,
0.0226350501,
-0.1089441031,
0.0036875717,
0.0637258142,
-0.035321977,
-0.0010923959,
0.011600052,
-0.063136965,
-0.0556259938,
-0.0056639421,
0.0317015015,
0.0209056642,
-0.0165194981,
-0.0168219227,
-0.0446043834,
-0.0161768515,
-0.0090777203,
-0.0143127302,
-0.0057674297,
0.0131933382,
-0.0037014564,
-0.0107930033,
0.0317036919,
-0.0358268693,
0.0044896235,
0.0016027109,
0.035294719,
-0.0336958915,
-0.0533969961,
0.0336708724,
0.0578213036,
0.0303390436,
0.0078631882,
-0.0088587962,
-0.0113736903,
0.0412197746,
-0.0347664766,
-0.0362886041,
-0.0185552966,
-0.0267530475,
0.0513917916,
-0.0115205115,
-0.0231634565,
0.0278400052,
-0.0008367936,
0.0202958975,
-0.0520589426,
0.009263006,
0.0232621487,
0.0167936161,
0.0249497537,
0.0036708808,
-0.0270070657,
0.005751153,
0.0279054269,
0.0763139203,
-0.0148883061,
0.0654843673,
-0.0031059126,
-0.0143578406,
0.0365724675,
0.0272055231,
-0.0472732671,
-0.0901085511,
0.00416202,
0.0151749896,
0.0768320039,
-0.0122987749,
0.0146038653,
0.0010539559,
-0.0158040319,
-0.0487952605,
0.0121708484,
0.005222531,
-0.028656384,
0.0169313084,
0.041192878,
-0.0363211259,
0.0229171086,
0.0827007368,
0.0129959378,
0.0151806902,
0.0573122129,
0.0005253528,
-0.0378199145,
-0.0008244871,
0.0077794455,
0.0357579961,
-0.0417582728,
-0.0122074392,
-0.0847748071,
-0.0623253509,
0.0119576743,
0.0199721735,
0.0149692064,
0.0113188298,
0.0318263099,
0.0614750609,
-0.0060060476,
0.010084128,
-0.078366816,
0.0123837637,
-0.0366769321,
0.0022443198,
0.0062764557,
-6.943415909e-33,
-0.0046993787,
-0.0335443504,
0.0231249053,
-0.040759068,
-0.0114026479,
-0.0152664948,
-0.0278592519,
0.0380558334,
-0.0613693893,
-0.0210305341,
-0.0355853029,
0.0077603664,
0.0130852358,
0.017411964,
-0.0070193941,
-0.0343660042,
0.0159675889,
0.0013189215,
-0.0186464135,
0.0112621067,
0.0338482112,
0.0141202454,
0.0155716799,
-0.0374569073,
0.0259617176,
-0.0160421692,
0.0143181169,
0.0194203388,
-0.021810133,
0.0767612904,
-0.0013301452,
0.0525367372,
0.0281795803,
-0.0280294344,
-0.0151486807,
-0.0138827311,
-0.0386263616,
-0.0284850392,
0.0248599425,
0.0211255867,
0.0095543647,
0.0037660662,
0.0153038828,
-0.0067377514,
-0.0067588929,
0.0087696584,
0.0279046316,
-0.0245575309,
-0.03326324,
0.0002081335,
-0.0031113504,
0.0217568539,
-0.0039466983,
0.010384066,
-0.0326671787,
0.0442839377,
-0.0087387888,
0.0374335125,
-0.0569506027,
0.0298840739,
0.0141547136,
0.0495997705,
0.0551177822,
0.0061229579,
0.0061153029,
0.0507760309,
0.0185412336,
0.0124406312,
0.0165414978,
-0.0128171034,
0.0254179686,
0.0542905182,
0.042528186,
0.068196781,
0.0369064994,
-0.0299296603,
-0.0727552697,
0.0475069918,
0.0576055832,
-0.0121674733,
0.0124894157,
0.0307781305,
-0.050741367,
-0.0200516954,
-0.0462959222,
0.0278866719,
-0.0670156777,
-0.0432006121,
0.0362700261,
-0.0287616197,
-0.0166280027,
-0.0304080825,
0.037063498,
-0.0499266051,
-0.0370339081,
0.0144017963,
-0.0162609704,
0.0119161634,
-0.0084050773,
0.0487485901,
-0.0475260466,
-0.0110373739,
-0.0425473638,
-0.0062496844,
-0.0102663897,
0.0152593879,
-0.0203288347,
0.0010033954,
-0.0622298867,
-0.0086891977,
-0.0140312267,
-0.0381217562,
0.0149256121,
0.0188633036,
0.0328757539,
-0.0275604632,
-0.0048193047,
0.0668717176,
0.0173639953,
-0.0118018892,
-0.0709241852,
-0.058951769,
-0.0046370532,
0.0062236069,
-0.0092421984,
0.0191065371,
-0.0372734368,
0.0346116535,
0.0275698882,
-0.027238261,
-0.0229975805,
-0.0112831462,
2.826e-7,
0.0538768359,
0.0582224578,
-0.0115256943,
0.0340581052,
-0.0144882631,
0.03067334,
-0.0393931307,
0.0032874171,
0.0205705259,
0.0050671226,
0.0227961056,
0.0129881809,
0.0733030811,
0.0402575321,
-0.1040221825,
0.0094565917,
-0.039499484,
0.0186808538,
-0.0386086591,
0.0177309848,
0.0301957168,
0.0874950588,
-0.0040341485,
0.0120448219,
-0.007004987,
-0.0301876199,
0.0375193991,
-0.0310860407,
-0.0478980206,
0.0444242172,
0.01755541,
0.0140909459,
-0.0233883951,
-0.0068480293,
-0.0247755367,
-0.0020784442,
0.0505186096,
0.069968462,
0.0252218265,
-0.047353372,
0.0013994405,
-0.0245858338,
0.0068862797,
-0.0828377157,
0.0853520855,
0.0202413425,
-0.0230430234,
-0.0135872522,
-0.0069770529,
-0.0498639047,
0.0419518761,
-0.0456846617,
-0.0321631581,
0.0230815914,
0.0060200104,
-0.0151812155,
-0.0126264365,
-0.0412572362,
-0.0555383898,
0.0021812583,
-0.0426147692,
-0.097913675,
-0.0219713151,
-0.0119546037,
-0.0389411226,
-0.0195880439,
0.0140661197,
2.418670544e-34,
0.0405844152,
0.0245653819,
0.0195977353,
0.0141183361,
0.0424797013,
0.0098473309,
-0.008248819,
0.0055195824,
0.0123144249,
-0.0906641781,
-0.0142821763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15002v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15002v5 | Gzip versus bag-of-words for text classification | 2023-07-27T16:57:32 | 2023-08-08T17:39:57 | Juri Opitz | cs.CL | cs.CL | The effectiveness of compression in text classification ('gzip') has recently
garnered lots of attention. In this note we show that `bag-of-words' approaches
can achieve similar or better results, and are more efficient. | [
0.0037214675,
0.051049877,
-0.0028185274,
0.0160858016,
-0.0523880385,
0.0295166243,
0.0137160262,
0.1053429395,
-0.0056497389,
-0.0466787778,
0.0336996987,
0.0101164142,
0.030997254,
-0.0149365254,
-0.0094111804,
-0.004831844,
0.030033635,
0.0376311205,
-0.0340870284,
0.0165720116,
-0.0011394139,
0.0201991368,
0.0360099338,
0.0237093456,
0.0196600538,
0.0158675704,
-0.0338307917,
-0.0024886851,
-0.0208024029,
-0.0004104307,
-0.0196326338,
0.0276482198,
0.0032975927,
0.0058879638,
0.0000011207,
-0.0564305484,
-0.0534179769,
0.0082581872,
-0.0546431951,
-0.0055285036,
0.0667949691,
-0.0398330055,
0.0345550068,
0.0254726969,
-0.0097112628,
-0.0627144799,
0.0458526127,
0.0591286309,
0.0267806649,
0.0693792552,
-0.0324437581,
-0.0287241694,
-0.0066800802,
-0.0418829285,
0.0073505417,
-0.0219199993,
0.0286041964,
-0.0342033133,
-0.0061528091,
0.0441864617,
-0.0508821718,
-0.0176361091,
-0.0090919314,
0.0563752204,
0.02268162,
0.0089812716,
-0.0613179207,
0.0049512568,
0.0112781757,
-0.020448273,
-0.0774202943,
-0.0766564608,
-0.0293254498,
0.0127190165,
0.0133262379,
0.0458513163,
-0.0114285043,
0.0111185415,
-0.0253068395,
0.0133376913,
0.0011620492,
0.0832885727,
-0.0129186958,
0.0162349232,
0.0043471768,
0.0147756515,
-0.0299861208,
-0.0454237275,
0.0106874788,
0.0140817519,
-0.0139860446,
-0.0350729786,
-0.0028027096,
0.0284013748,
0.0871245489,
-0.0247199535,
-0.0746402889,
-0.0245361421,
0.0604629181,
-0.0567770749,
0.0020755157,
0.0171209071,
0.0253665671,
0.0024991154,
-0.0311854351,
0.0525447764,
0.056413509,
-0.0035197369,
-0.0089962967,
0.0048341244,
-0.0463432558,
0.0001346538,
-0.0689949244,
0.046941001,
-0.0087305959,
-0.0102847163,
-0.0675573796,
0.0364891551,
0.0174431354,
-0.0408411622,
-0.0156977791,
-0.0100153014,
-0.017427031,
0.0438026749,
0.0163468719,
-0.0444942303,
-0.0544931702,
0.0341660976,
-0.0442906879,
-0.0024394628,
-0.002534224,
0.0340632796,
0.0468039624,
0.0112151168,
0.049081821,
-0.0089598764,
-0.0065652854,
-0.0548302196,
-0.0381413512,
-0.0106422091,
-0.0043945494,
0.0122643542,
-0.0174619183,
-0.0336371064,
0.0151675092,
-0.0113830669,
0.0039069522,
0.0182093699,
-0.0283025578,
0.0173257291,
-0.0516070239,
0.0136842672,
0.0120095061,
0.0197261497,
0.0756747425,
0.0043575848,
0.0448763818,
0.0096023604,
-0.0256012585,
0.0580996498,
0.0259963311,
-0.0499999151,
0.0308574047,
-0.0108528789,
0.0088199768,
-0.028581582,
-0.0023782353,
-0.014893827,
0.0109521821,
-0.0150091453,
0.0145597421,
0.0337916687,
-0.0504604727,
-0.0454807095,
0.0124709764,
0.1161116436,
0.0407254249,
0.0734187663,
-0.0543255471,
0.0189843308,
0.0214154422,
0.0166237298,
0.0297014117,
-0.033246845,
-0.0435208715,
-0.0333947726,
0.0308265425,
-0.0123691289,
-0.0183676668,
-0.03702797,
-0.0343397632,
-0.0233261343,
0.0798992217,
-0.0241532307,
-0.001395029,
0.0002118444,
0.0255030897,
-0.0193078313,
0.0218928661,
-0.0194702577,
-0.0299218521,
-0.0394751169,
-0.016354043,
-0.0233978387,
0.0311083198,
-0.0026724376,
0.0197868012,
-0.0173199959,
-0.017748028,
-0.0635519698,
0.0120135136,
-0.0302140396,
-0.0081718788,
-0.0524582379,
0.0068854289,
0.0230846312,
0.0105171101,
-0.0518639609,
0.0611989163,
0.0425989032,
0.0139131574,
0.0258448217,
0.0002647489,
0.0215156563,
0.0552903302,
-0.0253614876,
0.0430850424,
0.0107956557,
0.0730928853,
-0.0136748897,
-0.0159826167,
-0.0232709814,
0.0424909517,
-0.0549972951,
-0.0718226358,
-0.0551699959,
0.0228693429,
-0.0219451282,
0.0199979674,
0.0299330968,
0.036926683,
0.0648235083,
-0.0308378302,
0.0022502074,
-0.0001671995,
-0.0498439446,
0.0313907377,
-0.040609736,
-0.0033653169,
-0.0213754494,
0.0643975288,
-0.0487848856,
0.0360116698,
0.0256690215,
0.0396329276,
-0.0814629346,
-0.04406498,
0.0618919544,
-0.0040614759,
0.0088534048,
0.058932215,
-0.0476340875,
0.0218838956,
0.0318877399,
0.0355318971,
0.0242050532,
-0.0001552984,
-0.0891971886,
-0.0040997989,
0.0037215522,
0.0295685809,
0.0089782644,
-0.0340049937,
-0.0005645406,
-0.0030261318,
-0.0469327793,
-0.0138718989,
0.0229646768,
-0.0003294563,
0.0373149849,
-0.0418131649,
0.0073142918,
0.0438812114,
-0.044132255,
0.0300823841,
0.0775924698,
-0.0280290246,
-0.0660340935,
0.0177259371,
0.0083542885,
-0.0214282759,
-0.0252082404,
0.0380565263,
-0.0284129903,
-0.0405603647,
0.0007512935,
-0.02447455,
0.0403917767,
0.0406567268,
0.0713414848,
0.027544314,
0.0358494669,
-0.0214390382,
-0.0123872217,
-0.0466898382,
0.0045825811,
-0.0194158386,
-0.0338440277,
0.0177814253,
-0.0038373761,
-0.0004972519,
0.0030403503,
-0.0239447448,
-0.0196577627,
-0.0172071233,
0.0096613597,
-0.0391879529,
-0.0453341715,
0.0256841946,
0.0148711307,
0.0220505651,
-0.0548332185,
0.0417892374,
-0.0311848857,
0.0092096552,
-0.0890706927,
-0.0691122636,
-0.049451001,
0.0523438565,
-0.0239055119,
0.0782327577,
0.0336027704,
0.0314744301,
0.0215454046,
-0.0117406854,
0.0127100879,
-0.0516553298,
-0.0183065403,
0.0402414314,
0.0188675653,
-0.0402148813,
-0.0306581296,
-0.0151670994,
-0.0812525973,
0.0188809615,
0.0228704251,
0.0360318236,
-0.0256224461,
-0.0518251695,
0.065179117,
0.014457331,
0.0222261865,
-0.0059824227,
-0.0195993315,
0.0657923371,
0.0443627201,
0.0168364868,
0.0025853894,
-0.02911672,
0.0130870482,
-0.0383750312,
0.0361930244,
0.0084534679,
0.0470524319,
-0.0022695041,
-0.0037083502,
0.0526306666,
-0.0245452337,
-0.0194830243,
-0.0019709365,
-0.0170212463,
0.0020681347,
0.0112656513,
0.0760081261,
0.0356020369,
-0.0640323609,
0.0059885662,
0.0355744399,
0.0019101675,
-0.0025218474,
0.0432059504,
-0.0262148902,
-0.0169476531,
-0.0215601828,
-0.0073721451,
-0.0493117534,
0.011926474,
-0.0106793763,
-0.066435501,
0.0361960866,
0.011892193,
0.0042256587,
-0.0073460066,
-0.0717035159,
-0.0116000259,
0.0041103614,
-0.0861873254,
-0.0550876893,
-0.0410170853,
-0.0312639512,
0.0387882032,
-0.0381844826,
-0.0170562491,
-0.0075379699,
0.0666609481,
0.003060411,
-0.0088847782,
0.0051100622,
-0.047378175,
-0.018026473,
0.0083194999,
0.0172978882,
-0.0361863635,
-0.0431854613,
0.0361956842,
-0.0126302689,
0.0411978327,
0.0233732536,
-0.0035230834,
-0.0035795725,
-0.0261251796,
-0.0036990254,
0.0528152324,
-0.022292234,
-0.0480339527,
-0.028197905,
-0.0129696634,
-0.046378918,
0.0323021114,
-0.0092899362,
-0.0544771589,
-0.0131034106,
0.0145941842,
-0.0306495465,
0.0547374487,
-0.0373120978,
0.0109866979,
-0.0397633612,
-0.0873107314,
-0.0748483315,
0.0215202421,
0.026916679,
0.0570394248,
-0.0251646563,
-0.0203813221,
-0.0151132345,
0.0305745024,
-0.0795792714,
-0.0210562013,
0.0297266729,
-0.0068829437,
-0.0266463161,
0.0098785143,
0.0304830801,
0.0093355253,
-0.0297418144,
0.0454780571,
-0.0860491544,
-0.0372441597,
-0.0159025807,
-0.0012178553,
0.0287760384,
-0.0121472394,
0.0073444829,
-0.0870873854,
0.0344627872,
0.0666013286,
-0.0246974174,
0.040604867,
0.0160614792,
-0.0388318859,
-0.0356854834,
0.0105965398,
-0.0055897245,
0.0880048275,
-0.0480737202,
-0.0621268861,
-0.0601587854,
-0.029500654,
-0.0009006528,
0.0174762011,
0.0315681808,
-0.0141871339,
-0.026415633,
0.0238710493,
0.0168624576,
0.0405922569,
0.012385739,
0.0219386313,
-0.0059734262,
0.0429693088,
0.0196035672,
-0.0203958284,
0.0377767533,
0.0414938964,
-0.0044048917,
0.0547383763,
-0.0268564094,
-0.0057924893,
0.0177599676,
-0.0148349097,
0.0528662167,
-0.055730965,
-0.0884697363,
0.0303163864,
-0.0343826152,
-0.0347066633,
0.0029212171,
-0.007934303,
0.0646980107,
-0.060487818,
0.0403899513,
-0.0563487783,
0.0199551582,
-0.0121187614,
0.0095341774,
-0.0001584194,
-0.0482440889,
-0.0540828221,
-0.0313325599,
-0.0327082388,
-0.0132972309,
-0.0153368302,
0.0080443295,
0.0147265568,
-0.0232513621,
0.0169280749,
-0.0681937709,
0.0269331485,
0.0574847087,
0.030625442,
-0.0472589321,
0.0076576355,
-0.058379285,
-0.0190064907,
0.0003666405,
-0.0078944415,
0.0515982211,
0.0251079109,
-0.009809643,
-0.0345145315,
-0.0084689846,
0.0829842165,
-0.0093073184,
0.0720391423,
0.0297029391,
0.02861665,
0.0478503704,
0.0498763844,
0.0384694114,
-0.0306141432,
0.0054156748,
-0.0669303238,
-0.0031656288,
-0.0114883417,
-4.517783683e-33,
0.0470331945,
0.004789155,
-0.0424792729,
0.0110989371,
-0.0046904059,
0.0276647024,
0.0321184546,
-0.0293580797,
0.004627001,
-0.0271331165,
-0.0335549079,
-0.00840584,
0.0021892439,
-0.0004404529,
0.0170550905,
0.023363011,
0.0346103869,
-0.0081993071,
-0.0493201874,
0.0135472789,
0.0439908095,
-0.0030740756,
-0.0069847228,
-0.0611460619,
-0.0593772419,
-0.0194435585,
-0.015036325,
-0.0203433614,
0.0147815812,
0.0477485396,
-0.0436990932,
0.0224818587,
0.0488497578,
-0.0349457487,
0.0348300003,
0.0363848805,
-0.0281800088,
-0.0305564981,
-0.0288540721,
-0.0378256738,
0.0159808975,
-0.0109533612,
0.0185586978,
0.009994382,
-0.0257086288,
-0.0068955394,
0.0104771117,
-0.0290730931,
-0.0736939758,
-0.0813836232,
0.0031315156,
0.0209540129,
-0.0069015627,
0.0198240224,
0.056863945,
0.0244153049,
-0.0222736821,
0.026178604,
0.0486743711,
0.0050328136,
-0.0164942201,
0.0580987446,
-0.0198401883,
-0.0336764604,
0.0121704619,
0.0122734988,
-0.0267039221,
0.0036327643,
-0.0102141164,
0.0250235889,
0.0117432028,
-0.0283723921,
0.0351962894,
0.0792812854,
0.1247107685,
-0.0638850853,
-0.0490930863,
0.0402708724,
0.072244212,
-0.0078922464,
0.0043083928,
0.0223372057,
-0.05654452,
-0.0022377691,
0.0161071494,
0.0102460757,
-0.0021901997,
-0.024624534,
-0.0074849352,
0.0409468487,
-0.0192686226,
0.0429015458,
0.0189969726,
-0.022453079,
-0.0089761876,
-0.0039944756,
-0.01253876,
0.0593606308,
0.0035589349,
-0.0195155982,
-0.0067002466,
-0.0229079742,
0.0103270179,
-0.0087249642,
0.0239630025,
-0.0394059569,
0.0853925422,
0.0340024754,
-0.055012729,
-0.0046666558,
0.0265321936,
0.0246566869,
0.0045082406,
0.0418021418,
-0.0130607411,
0.0204072893,
0.0388550721,
-0.0170737002,
-0.0230259355,
0.0075750579,
0.0127132731,
-0.0366574675,
0.0357295871,
-0.0164627079,
0.0175726749,
-0.0023530871,
-0.0129545936,
0.0038589737,
-0.0019222061,
-0.0505429395,
0.0072937068,
0.0131732272,
1.945e-7,
0.0430125855,
0.0455523543,
0.0093866177,
-0.0589153543,
0.0276279598,
-0.0070329146,
0.0090519078,
0.0528794043,
-0.0541589409,
0.0710861385,
0.0086038951,
0.0052906778,
0.0454727225,
0.0416529663,
-0.052296225,
0.0038783667,
-0.0552164279,
0.0047929646,
-0.0226438399,
0.0220935065,
0.0985290334,
0.1051436365,
0.0215688646,
-0.0167392921,
-0.0257161446,
-0.0250773206,
0.0093923286,
-0.0228435826,
0.0365782902,
0.0043201027,
0.0359418951,
0.0208441708,
0.0079468647,
-0.0012162413,
-0.0263532959,
0.0340846516,
0.0024173574,
0.0558478311,
-0.000398863,
-0.0139740398,
-0.004595018,
-0.0188873298,
-0.0165659338,
-0.0076440629,
0.0503745154,
0.0065306067,
-0.0091427555,
-0.0025613834,
0.0408573188,
-0.0026672787,
0.0514944568,
0.0079111485,
0.0132337585,
0.0557912961,
0.0056651649,
-0.0206289161,
0.0024327072,
-0.1064895466,
0.007646665,
0.0252995715,
0.001201238,
0.0570595302,
0.0084267855,
0.0151322298,
0.0971963033,
-0.0113061974,
0.0032316528,
1.365304661e-34,
-0.0053268955,
0.0230738837,
-0.0138110491,
-0.0215865187,
-0.0408350863,
-0.0354775749,
0.0410570092,
0.0353344269,
-0.0035971813,
-0.0511138998,
0.0090691103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14995v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14995v2 | TransNormerLLM: A Faster and Better Large Language Model with Improved TransNormer | 2023-07-27T16:45:33 | 2024-01-19T07:47:01 | Zhen Qin, Dong Li, Weigao Sun, Weixuan Sun, Xuyang Shen, Xiaodong Han, Yunshen Wei, Baohong Lv, Xiao Luo, Yu Qiao, Yiran Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present TransNormerLLM, the first linear attention-based Large Language
Model (LLM) that outperforms conventional softmax attention-based models in
terms of both accuracy and efficiency. TransNormerLLM evolves from the previous
linear attention architecture TransNormer by making advanced modifications that
include positional embedding, linear attention acceleration, gating mechanisms,
tensor normalization, and inference acceleration and stabilization.
Specifically, we use LRPE together with an exponential decay to avoid attention
dilution issues while allowing the model to retain global interactions between
tokens. Additionally, we propose Lightning Attention, a cutting-edge technique
that accelerates linear attention by more than twice in runtime and reduces
memory usage by a remarkable four times. To further enhance the performance of
TransNormer, we leverage a gating mechanism for smooth training and a new
tensor normalization scheme to accelerate the model, resulting in an impressive
acceleration of over $20\%$. Furthermore, we develop a robust inference
algorithm that ensures numerical stability and consistent inference speed,
regardless of the sequence length, showcasing superior efficiency during both
training and inference stages. We also implement an efficient model parallel
schema for TransNormerLLM, enabling seamless deployment on large-scale clusters
and facilitating expansion to even more extensive models, i.e., LLMs with 175B
parameters. We validate our model design through a series of ablations and
train models with sizes of 385M, 1B, and 7B on our self-collected corpus.
Benchmark results demonstrate that our models not only match the performance of
state-of-the-art LLMs with Transformer but are also significantly faster. Code
is released at: https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/TransnormerLLM. | [
0.0104291476,
0.0652870387,
0.0012522931,
0.0577097982,
-0.0114062084,
-0.0033766243,
-0.0031083913,
-0.0270178802,
-0.0124121783,
-0.0325634964,
-0.0332605802,
-0.0376098678,
0.0000224784,
0.039809525,
0.0443823263,
-0.0314627811,
0.029234631,
-0.0359677449,
0.011842642,
0.0069027646,
0.0209890269,
0.0059574069,
0.0426902026,
0.0455807783,
0.0130632045,
0.0018014072,
-0.003019959,
0.0077959499,
0.0205020476,
0.0024603945,
-0.0061020753,
0.0513533242,
0.0557606556,
0.0399177857,
0.0000021035,
-0.0020669536,
-0.006365947,
-0.0080241077,
0.0174467769,
0.0447929315,
0.0197491236,
-0.0280395132,
0.0151840765,
0.0141947893,
0.0051879054,
-0.021573836,
0.051434163,
0.0292001422,
0.0500977039,
0.078282848,
0.0041700387,
-0.0365775861,
0.0332594141,
-0.0669336095,
-0.0285707433,
-0.0657612309,
0.033319883,
-0.0328263454,
-0.0039914204,
0.0231976267,
-0.036748983,
0.042242907,
0.0414661877,
0.0089401836,
0.0315053724,
0.0576710589,
-0.0328001641,
-0.0289034024,
-0.0123678511,
0.0990366489,
-0.0388877913,
-0.0324670784,
0.0095524183,
0.0132407332,
-0.0096013453,
-0.0400258973,
-0.0489242449,
0.0431485623,
0.0362007096,
0.0348664075,
0.0326249115,
-0.0232451409,
0.0596244633,
0.0134895677,
-0.0396159738,
0.011489274,
0.0438171662,
-0.0136729572,
-0.0274865273,
0.0074391016,
-0.0568994693,
-0.0286139678,
0.0226982441,
0.029027503,
-0.0326436199,
-0.0044727246,
-0.0540718585,
-0.0513374321,
0.0154419662,
-0.0340781286,
0.0246457122,
0.0509334095,
-0.0271944292,
0.0804844052,
-0.0546038859,
0.0607362464,
-0.0263858475,
-0.0169431828,
-0.0322854109,
-0.0261166412,
0.0168123301,
0.0172352251,
-0.0175436493,
0.009127629,
-0.0477065444,
-0.0406310186,
-0.0194719825,
0.0105763748,
0.0087850383,
-0.0177030936,
0.0041028848,
0.0146571668,
-0.0186537243,
-0.0044138008,
0.0199907608,
0.0447775126,
-0.0243749991,
-0.0111720748,
-0.0070389393,
-0.0375029966,
-0.0549301244,
0.0268875435,
0.0260602105,
-0.0347220674,
0.0291794389,
0.0649290979,
-0.0144713484,
-0.0512866303,
-0.014055362,
0.0159362517,
-0.0131959096,
-0.073124066,
-0.0206400622,
-0.0568906479,
0.0600164384,
0.0010889475,
-0.0094196675,
-0.0197153185,
0.0237537026,
0.0416637361,
-0.0431406051,
0.0385175273,
0.0204981137,
0.0050412668,
-0.007265111,
-0.0081379311,
0.0012612188,
0.0521383919,
0.0103470013,
0.0186662376,
-0.0062901056,
-0.0207064711,
-0.0076340456,
0.0530961491,
0.0450681672,
-0.0054938905,
-0.0344831757,
0.0049656914,
0.0092338128,
0.0334161334,
0.0741580501,
0.0683710501,
-0.0357617959,
-0.0353116356,
0.0709507167,
0.0488265157,
-0.0235901568,
0.0424361601,
0.0279520899,
0.0024094717,
-0.0353579409,
-0.0408121161,
-0.0872970521,
0.0723210797,
0.0155350883,
0.0114794904,
0.0864889845,
0.0476944037,
-0.0293221977,
0.0085856318,
-0.0073578134,
-0.0141057353,
0.0152627239,
0.0109166745,
0.0480107814,
-0.028444292,
-0.056141898,
0.0910374895,
0.0593082123,
-0.0290152449,
-0.0001415057,
-0.0224761646,
0.0308823194,
0.0261177775,
0.0174209997,
0.0023759569,
-0.0287758261,
-0.0247431491,
0.0085300906,
0.0713687465,
0.0226385761,
0.0356228501,
-0.0072751604,
-0.0748301744,
0.0178749599,
-0.0164196696,
0.0058320584,
0.0143256998,
0.0298074875,
0.0142787471,
0.0339163207,
-0.0277552996,
-0.0200906172,
0.0273694396,
-0.0253332295,
-0.0357142091,
-0.012697977,
-0.0095782811,
0.0326152854,
-0.000545605,
-0.0067778141,
0.0102009615,
0.0519967042,
-0.0524048954,
-0.0241567716,
-0.0183970314,
-0.0629808232,
-0.0355729498,
0.0472900197,
-0.0012199477,
-0.0333166644,
0.0579975992,
-0.0439245291,
-0.0449415669,
0.0791348815,
-0.0428840816,
0.0495197773,
-0.0251766499,
0.0065868786,
0.0110659236,
0.047154136,
-0.0192019809,
0.0373234004,
-0.0176755507,
0.0304385591,
0.0238213204,
-0.0123123247,
-0.0179671664,
-0.0165960491,
-0.039061036,
-0.0031680888,
-0.0174869485,
0.0038294629,
-0.0163873918,
-0.0057745329,
-0.0063434169,
-0.0097365212,
-0.082191661,
-0.0033020959,
-0.0360518768,
0.0014568176,
0.0108766686,
0.0386677496,
0.0081467154,
-0.0036725388,
-0.0189223289,
0.0013770426,
-0.0173738636,
0.0109104542,
0.0019283313,
-0.0333893001,
-0.0181783978,
-0.0552265495,
-0.0254093222,
0.0107910847,
0.0408147871,
-0.0150884679,
-0.012396018,
-0.0300552957,
-0.0302005447,
-0.0191764645,
0.0240517538,
-0.0238219686,
-0.0371114425,
-0.0242975131,
-0.0319626406,
0.0683845952,
0.0743387192,
0.0038337037,
-0.0368504152,
0.0324408934,
-0.0086889295,
-0.0489231385,
0.0318208858,
-0.0108442288,
-0.0031619607,
-0.0178885013,
-0.0238854233,
-0.0105411727,
0.1155376285,
-0.0352812,
-0.0084732529,
-0.0527712665,
-0.0302321948,
-0.0086607998,
0.0047807279,
-0.0030661877,
-0.0060359761,
-0.0351563431,
-0.0292069037,
-0.0474916212,
-0.0427170806,
0.093457967,
-0.0412657969,
-0.0270988736,
-0.0369316116,
-0.0165855158,
-0.0475132689,
0.0265696794,
0.0232729316,
0.0260112435,
-0.0256713759,
-0.0229547061,
-0.0119978394,
0.0086997403,
-0.0321009643,
-0.005034056,
0.0679228306,
-0.008352953,
0.006898528,
-0.0373546369,
-0.0230705496,
-0.0034564375,
-0.0273449291,
-0.0459685735,
0.023421146,
0.0410160497,
-0.0332085229,
-0.0545484461,
0.0211724173,
0.0182677619,
0.0513568148,
-0.0290635861,
0.0415141396,
-0.0201556236,
0.0180022009,
0.0608773865,
0.0018426968,
0.0181282237,
-0.0381302834,
-0.0201393273,
0.0808595195,
0.0418579094,
0.0153108006,
-0.0458057597,
-0.0219758358,
0.0137085849,
-0.0089467233,
-0.0128563289,
-0.016989002,
0.0541322827,
-0.0680733547,
-0.0027091035,
0.1023542583,
-0.0153720025,
-0.05960612,
0.0066752736,
0.0042863614,
0.0235938784,
0.0163771696,
0.0167257898,
-0.0379676297,
-0.0659332797,
0.0233962983,
0.0109702731,
0.0520119295,
-0.0304786321,
-0.0001395872,
-0.0785805956,
0.0106799686,
0.0143621136,
-0.0571620092,
-0.0469919667,
-0.0475909039,
0.0219205525,
-0.0140645485,
0.0252367929,
0.0429306291,
0.00924676,
-0.0052234568,
0.004897756,
0.0141755231,
-0.0275283549,
0.0311205909,
-0.0563724339,
0.0488558896,
0.0135037331,
0.0027388306,
0.0126245646,
-0.0340793505,
0.0673038214,
0.0072581782,
-0.0169687178,
-0.0099259736,
0.0054419199,
-0.0315326229,
-0.0247704331,
-0.0194067787,
0.0460495912,
-0.0591579452,
0.0003561223,
-0.0147358896,
0.1108897328,
0.0403029434,
-0.042785909,
-0.0342968181,
-0.0023287248,
-0.0300147794,
0.0885429233,
0.0495247506,
-0.0518323965,
-0.0418545604,
-0.0118956398,
-0.0345158689,
-0.014008197,
-0.0445839837,
-0.03791105,
0.0270680636,
-0.0316792168,
-0.0318706967,
-0.0095296828,
0.0358682945,
0.0039976211,
-0.0022828979,
-0.0119118029,
0.0050028749,
-0.0365897343,
-0.0432177112,
0.0843139738,
-0.0469498895,
0.0076252003,
-0.0545925125,
0.0202773698,
0.0466020331,
0.0051214974,
-0.0078342892,
0.068177186,
-0.1064959168,
-0.0614857301,
-0.0251205657,
0.0295385867,
0.0097779045,
0.0221027695,
-0.0322501175,
-0.0519044995,
0.0609640889,
-0.0005435356,
-0.0518647283,
0.0359888189,
-0.0031197055,
-0.0301736426,
0.0143111479,
0.0551197678,
-0.0239170771,
-0.0121986503,
0.0306719169,
0.0502176024,
-0.0077423989,
-0.0134664299,
-0.0205981992,
-0.002387912,
0.0412367433,
0.0041094488,
0.0374478996,
-0.0239390992,
0.011335006,
0.0161962248,
-0.0111581739,
-0.0488891229,
0.0026393081,
0.0359181948,
0.0058272351,
-0.0107749775,
-0.0085777026,
0.0452442579,
-0.0147819994,
-0.0169719383,
0.0255657248,
-0.0080477316,
-0.0145522207,
0.0443131812,
-0.0065298686,
-0.0228979718,
-0.0379397608,
-0.0325966775,
0.0379977487,
-0.0418503173,
0.0068202312,
0.0120781343,
-0.0138892801,
-0.0178326927,
0.0012787319,
-0.0480964519,
-0.0339691639,
-0.0211363845,
0.0110110613,
0.0665005147,
-0.0109596476,
0.0730854049,
0.0064277668,
-0.0204721782,
-0.0226438157,
0.0174543615,
-0.0197194386,
-0.025628712,
0.034605477,
0.0161264595,
-0.018779425,
0.0279127061,
0.0678111538,
0.0097746244,
0.0062800087,
0.0178609975,
0.0030899665,
-0.0331107229,
-0.0239134934,
-0.0084827812,
0.020338254,
-0.0345049351,
0.0159420799,
0.0123224277,
-0.071934849,
0.0079002585,
-0.040029712,
-0.0254544374,
-0.0242064781,
0.0182950441,
0.0416220054,
0.0062066261,
-0.0230799522,
-0.0192061495,
0.053800568,
0.0280060321,
-0.0544836372,
-0.0202945378,
-6.96475407e-33,
-0.0108338017,
0.0299042445,
0.0034775489,
-0.0361426957,
-0.0600442179,
0.0193016194,
-0.0493612923,
-0.0052176267,
-0.0286123604,
-0.0033916051,
-0.0019416277,
0.013352925,
-0.0171315838,
0.0439297371,
0.0158876181,
-0.0089489492,
0.0279499013,
0.0078362161,
-0.0106916847,
0.0360191278,
-0.0046828603,
0.0485232063,
0.0751570612,
-0.0075230575,
-0.0114696799,
0.0001914879,
0.007468415,
0.0048318943,
-0.0041169855,
0.0301138461,
-0.0288756322,
0.0285338294,
0.010885465,
-0.0498455912,
-0.03220753,
0.0253551137,
-0.0718234032,
0.0062971716,
0.0185687169,
-0.0038932795,
-0.0284405835,
-0.0301792715,
0.0778294429,
0.0123215215,
0.0363631658,
-0.0377735011,
0.0227775984,
0.0019988315,
-0.0429622605,
0.0136737293,
-0.0290055498,
0.0355357267,
-0.0093163112,
-0.0119743152,
0.0114075365,
0.026908718,
-0.0154575221,
0.0642319918,
-0.0692256168,
-0.0095168725,
0.0017461977,
0.0570599288,
0.0506947637,
0.013461858,
0.0199165866,
0.0375437625,
0.0166508984,
-0.009120536,
-0.0486405082,
-0.0247523542,
0.0304943528,
0.0360735953,
0.058060661,
0.0093075028,
0.0047360831,
0.0249992646,
-0.0724332705,
-0.0243277699,
0.0122374753,
0.0733588263,
0.0751294345,
0.0328580663,
0.0010319073,
-0.0170118529,
-0.0149209602,
-0.0252016429,
-0.0480960198,
0.0068228226,
0.0097882347,
0.0317031033,
-0.0270790048,
-0.0115587413,
0.0556719676,
-0.0392156243,
0.0161995497,
0.0328620933,
0.0228299089,
-0.006148892,
0.0177979302,
0.0397101976,
-0.0804944783,
0.0006139061,
0.0032518688,
-0.0335192196,
-0.0113760959,
0.0128547838,
0.0249121711,
0.0179486312,
-0.0594555959,
-0.0354610607,
-0.0499075912,
0.0005224462,
-0.0172803104,
0.0485591255,
0.049681101,
-0.001659199,
0.017912142,
0.06544891,
0.0205906928,
0.0446608402,
-0.0024437683,
-0.0042719012,
0.0133540165,
0.0209470913,
-0.0239027049,
0.0070064417,
-0.0524753667,
0.0166520122,
0.0188558418,
-0.0733211339,
-0.0282192566,
0.0166786797,
2.845e-7,
0.0265041497,
0.0368557945,
0.0049072234,
0.0095506487,
0.0190852322,
0.0355285704,
-0.0022597609,
0.0605182163,
0.040857058,
0.0137063134,
0.0075489557,
0.0420675054,
0.0430044048,
-0.0163146686,
-0.1178059056,
-0.0136545738,
-0.106851764,
0.0041014762,
-0.0449550338,
-0.0337896012,
-0.0277473442,
0.1517107189,
0.0282074045,
-0.0039508548,
0.0422094576,
-0.0382085443,
0.0456384309,
-0.0269460063,
-0.0314584039,
0.0026548561,
-0.008539727,
0.019708205,
-0.0200194214,
-0.0150286732,
-0.0064246454,
0.0339486524,
0.0001318909,
0.0838063657,
-0.0017850571,
-0.0391400792,
0.0166816972,
-0.0191574339,
0.0017314802,
-0.078101851,
0.0693194494,
-0.0346467122,
-0.0313730277,
-0.0447860472,
-0.0399866551,
-0.0119945845,
0.0230845194,
-0.0004992118,
-0.016157994,
0.0298734102,
0.035833519,
-0.0151892072,
-0.0240615997,
-0.1109387353,
-0.0443813168,
-0.0005904842,
-0.0771447346,
-0.0179358926,
-0.075966306,
-0.0276715942,
0.0296474099,
-0.0208865106,
0.0004776021,
2.92634084e-34,
0.0485148393,
-0.0283494387,
-0.0048033316,
0.0293357726,
0.0288364571,
-0.020413518,
-0.0198887791,
-0.006233722,
0.0054627745,
-0.1068240851,
-0.0288935509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14988v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14988v1 | Incrementally-Computable Neural Networks: Efficient Inference for Dynamic Inputs | 2023-07-27T16:30:27 | 2023-07-27T16:30:27 | Or Sharir, Anima Anandkumar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Deep learning often faces the challenge of efficiently processing dynamic
inputs, such as sensor data or user inputs. For example, an AI writing
assistant is required to update its suggestions in real time as a document is
edited. Re-running the model each time is expensive, even with compression
techniques like knowledge distillation, pruning, or quantization. Instead, we
take an incremental computing approach, looking to reuse calculations as the
inputs change. However, the dense connectivity of conventional architectures
poses a major obstacle to incremental computation, as even minor input changes
cascade through the network and restrict information reuse. To address this, we
use vector quantization to discretize intermediate values in the network, which
filters out noisy and unnecessary modifications to hidden neurons, facilitating
the reuse of their values. We apply this approach to the transformers
architecture, creating an efficient incremental inference algorithm with
complexity proportional to the fraction of the modified inputs. Our experiments
with adapting the OPT-125M pre-trained language model demonstrate comparable
accuracy on document classification while requiring 12.1X (median) fewer
operations for processing sequences of atomic edits. | [
-0.0070041069,
0.0953117013,
-0.000480907,
-0.0021200362,
-0.0202428922,
-0.0094667766,
0.0154526699,
-0.0132515654,
-0.0294979867,
-0.0126989437,
-0.0073314849,
0.0151909981,
-0.010341418,
0.035051778,
-0.0285302643,
-0.0048151053,
0.0377930962,
0.0083011677,
-0.0021123798,
-0.0213631392,
-0.0116356472,
-0.0326891653,
-0.0205384586,
0.0168936495,
-0.0130282985,
-0.0324973874,
-0.0373773165,
-0.016522551,
-0.0160057023,
0.0233780667,
0.0054729101,
0.031514477,
0.0405657813,
0.048724398,
0.0000023133,
0.0010735492,
-0.0143805062,
-0.01140559,
-0.0715740398,
-0.0046917088,
0.0320053883,
-0.0070893178,
-0.0345657617,
-0.0072661336,
-0.0155995851,
-0.0481226854,
0.0593267642,
0.0091310963,
0.0656761527,
0.0538251922,
-0.0016020751,
-0.0237348098,
0.0625784993,
-0.0513107516,
0.0108049745,
-0.002325563,
-0.0143477367,
0.0034151238,
-0.0386463441,
-0.0175289977,
-0.0162042715,
0.0466630645,
0.0761326477,
-0.0258570258,
0.0417044386,
0.0304906555,
0.0022053784,
-0.0025470762,
0.0115050105,
0.0367004313,
-0.0956889018,
0.0041685957,
-0.0086804628,
-0.0355376489,
-0.0256101172,
-0.0594853312,
-0.0222685374,
-0.0067857676,
0.0083544329,
0.0162967462,
-0.0157197695,
-0.0084837358,
0.0593787991,
0.0418868177,
-0.0178673919,
0.0249603521,
0.0037455519,
0.0259513054,
-0.0319079012,
-0.0131389527,
-0.0172591899,
-0.0667790547,
0.0143215191,
0.0703707412,
-0.0398936011,
-0.0042730952,
-0.0717978179,
-0.0332566872,
-0.0349758826,
-0.0470036454,
0.0486399457,
0.0407828242,
0.0157904401,
0.0375355184,
-0.0239491276,
0.0272376109,
-0.0526096225,
0.0128378766,
-0.0271142144,
0.0166953951,
-0.0143392663,
-0.0290894452,
-0.0342802443,
0.0891282335,
0.0227257181,
-0.0204736311,
-0.0707472265,
0.0519294292,
-0.0135652786,
0.0034258992,
0.002375718,
-0.0119953956,
-0.045099467,
-0.0033363968,
0.0075784852,
0.0048660352,
-0.0109017929,
0.0290777348,
0.0116475169,
-0.0267922562,
-0.0068534785,
-0.0165313315,
0.0350814201,
0.0027404581,
0.0173768401,
0.037052989,
-0.0395514518,
-0.0808841214,
-0.0200039949,
-0.0294221081,
0.0343572125,
-0.0297734011,
0.0245242175,
-0.0453140363,
0.0210860763,
-0.0158849992,
-0.006929372,
-0.0792350248,
-0.0100136604,
0.0294806361,
-0.0266122874,
0.0590382889,
-0.0134740667,
-0.0238433462,
0.0368382856,
-0.0086132782,
0.020153638,
0.0370154642,
0.0617096908,
0.0424189381,
0.0142529374,
0.037005499,
0.0104918685,
0.0258743837,
0.0168044437,
-0.0212439038,
-0.0421509966,
-0.0248331763,
-0.0701609626,
0.0331345424,
0.0190875679,
0.0202824455,
-0.0580417439,
-0.0063118949,
0.0319475085,
0.0050176331,
0.0405681059,
0.0385753214,
0.0030536568,
0.0036271939,
0.0088715786,
-0.0085793985,
-0.0488697886,
0.0733379498,
0.0376733802,
-0.0219620634,
-0.009274737,
-0.0019146631,
-0.0376834795,
-0.072867848,
0.0251265746,
-0.0176266339,
0.0043782215,
0.0004585091,
0.04368788,
0.0555069409,
0.0037603113,
0.0539683923,
0.0032588823,
-0.0653679222,
0.0056212791,
-0.0515210442,
0.014613458,
0.0606865399,
0.062684536,
-0.0418634973,
-0.013364966,
0.0052724844,
-0.0007519065,
-0.0189998709,
0.0176830348,
-0.0238882992,
0.0339340754,
-0.0274639744,
-0.0302593615,
-0.0034954378,
0.0171096548,
0.004408685,
0.0349863358,
-0.0010206408,
0.0088973576,
-0.0021733937,
-0.0036270523,
0.0236866064,
-0.0138381086,
-0.0414490215,
0.0770186558,
0.0059635341,
0.0182187259,
-0.0108744921,
-0.0188063271,
-0.0030568982,
0.0198609177,
-0.0555214584,
-0.0363279283,
-0.004668402,
-0.031574931,
0.0108572254,
0.0266897026,
0.0398457572,
0.0214027371,
0.0049973587,
-0.0782963261,
-0.0073100235,
0.0065373299,
-0.0445674807,
-0.0032016032,
-0.0301018357,
0.0033745954,
0.0079114651,
0.0172696002,
0.0120513169,
0.0121172378,
-0.031298589,
-0.0101193609,
0.0260351524,
0.0097033428,
-0.021841526,
0.0133045958,
-0.026957361,
0.0055366531,
-0.0202021357,
-0.0042062104,
0.0164899193,
-0.0183636565,
0.0393203609,
-0.0348092988,
-0.0520656891,
-0.0159817897,
-0.0379767679,
0.0157280285,
0.003232853,
0.0352221094,
0.0452291369,
-0.031222377,
-0.0105113583,
0.0268623028,
-0.0165524501,
0.0285812058,
0.0208001938,
-0.0028749402,
0.0086086569,
-0.0203914307,
-0.0749544427,
0.0298605654,
0.0706759915,
-0.018228801,
-0.0028847172,
-0.0638975948,
-0.0454400666,
-0.0141766351,
0.0345727131,
-0.0128786666,
-0.0355947427,
-0.0078516928,
-0.0225573443,
0.0072196289,
0.0552408621,
0.0215275306,
0.0174398609,
0.0442090333,
0.004551609,
0.002554114,
0.0153169837,
-0.0289532822,
-0.0021315482,
0.008279046,
0.0077203647,
-0.0244053751,
0.0476796813,
-0.0485482663,
-0.0246527679,
-0.0036073849,
0.0354794078,
-0.0042726551,
-0.0400624871,
-0.0605609044,
-0.0282052383,
-0.012398649,
0.0080026519,
0.0103258947,
-0.0422524251,
0.0515008755,
-0.0014781717,
0.0248415563,
-0.0133045865,
-0.0214141794,
0.0148289017,
0.0438077599,
0.0670132115,
0.0137528442,
-0.0273831692,
-0.002990263,
-0.0534882993,
0.0118217487,
0.0058714123,
-0.0230043791,
0.0783354491,
-0.036196474,
0.0283392947,
-0.010817619,
-0.0478083231,
-0.0571713373,
-0.0306575745,
0.00930213,
0.0433487743,
0.0053982236,
-0.0366287977,
-0.0153867677,
-0.0102795418,
0.0031221528,
0.1369796097,
-0.0319024101,
-0.0212655365,
-0.0105107687,
0.039280016,
-0.0042051836,
0.0314746276,
0.0112458486,
0.0007646206,
0.0023018182,
0.0735991746,
0.0308958907,
0.0087310141,
-0.0775446147,
0.0198410042,
-0.0081401458,
-0.0383718573,
0.0078245569,
-0.0234538354,
0.0010817961,
-0.0723816603,
-0.0231160913,
0.0630825907,
0.013491787,
-0.0652061403,
-0.0077552395,
0.0390269719,
-0.0113566881,
0.0153734945,
0.0480963252,
-0.0696972609,
-0.0203640312,
0.0433235988,
0.0266299341,
-0.0130426791,
-0.0348032974,
-0.0285076313,
-0.0280792303,
0.008280159,
-0.024049703,
0.0364173502,
0.0342515409,
-0.0210469738,
-0.0081199706,
-0.0117272055,
-0.0158619117,
0.0227771103,
0.0169247147,
-0.0264367368,
-0.0035736174,
-0.0223980546,
-0.0038913821,
0.002332808,
0.0080307908,
-0.0171952769,
0.0348272808,
0.0139286937,
-0.0195367336,
-0.0061360947,
0.06878452,
-0.0335776247,
-0.0028046072,
0.0066160569,
0.0446158908,
0.0095441407,
-0.0216618516,
0.0284959748,
0.0187410954,
-0.0017546113,
-0.03799548,
-0.0333218612,
0.019625416,
-0.0129208313,
0.0210076366,
-0.0261748992,
-0.0575032793,
-0.0237271115,
0.001655277,
0.0027802987,
-0.0520434119,
-0.0203704126,
-0.0035880082,
0.0008733169,
-0.0059102033,
0.005222796,
-0.0198989902,
-0.0357195102,
-0.0900890306,
-0.0382267684,
-0.020018274,
-0.0192072541,
0.0026720469,
-0.0140058361,
-0.0580468215,
0.0836293399,
-0.0036467928,
-0.1284001917,
-0.015914226,
0.0156732667,
0.018607365,
-0.0159308165,
0.0173216257,
0.0331345201,
-0.0222298857,
-0.0453397818,
-0.0202204455,
-0.1176485419,
-0.0139663694,
0.0511970147,
0.055070743,
0.0131157069,
0.0282136537,
-0.0125838015,
-0.0585269965,
0.0678930804,
0.0394503325,
-0.0148757277,
0.0461339578,
0.0155483484,
-0.0455661602,
-0.0045456262,
0.030610716,
-0.0192783847,
0.051547002,
0.0305311065,
-0.0169119705,
-0.0377372652,
-0.0086728921,
-0.0160644315,
-0.0210652538,
0.0360706635,
0.0470502004,
0.0675724745,
-0.0248818547,
0.0501751043,
0.0387405306,
0.0267227367,
-0.0670500845,
0.0132951243,
-0.0101234931,
0.0269499477,
-0.0272451937,
0.027861936,
0.0559341758,
-0.0352948681,
0.0108922785,
-0.0489037856,
-0.0445557684,
0.0438765548,
0.006732353,
0.0073058475,
-0.0443518795,
0.0122857997,
-0.0023584687,
0.0074713691,
-0.0497981906,
-0.0045477469,
0.0463428907,
0.0208448451,
-0.0823872015,
0.0576378815,
-0.0636792108,
-0.0485238582,
-0.0401344746,
0.0264516603,
0.0139749143,
0.0668339729,
-0.0020363014,
-0.0594105758,
-0.0085422853,
-0.0180649757,
0.0142841656,
0.0286785923,
-0.0201607198,
0.007633626,
0.0243966542,
0.0262805745,
0.0007229901,
0.0707286671,
-0.0517755523,
0.0167886876,
-0.0364012569,
-0.0036132461,
-0.0416893587,
-0.0277979784,
-0.068542026,
0.0493885688,
0.0261903573,
-0.0065949643,
0.033225961,
-0.0240921881,
0.0428237319,
0.0083418852,
0.0131442454,
-0.0286812689,
0.0244453084,
0.0490856729,
0.0174811278,
-0.0330009274,
-0.0064552417,
0.0072631985,
-0.0199720934,
-0.0157303922,
0.0290180948,
-6.606998977e-33,
0.0106576085,
-0.0014039982,
0.021893844,
0.0091310544,
-0.0674693286,
0.0483396649,
-0.0159208961,
-0.0230316315,
-0.0079351049,
0.0144574158,
-0.0495778248,
0.0669298992,
0.0096576782,
0.0273889657,
0.0169197004,
-0.0211487059,
0.0895064995,
-0.0015414306,
-0.0021090512,
0.0402220786,
0.0606194846,
0.022661455,
0.0665698797,
-0.0379183628,
-0.0340380743,
0.0452860259,
-0.0210466143,
0.0125625171,
-0.0211905204,
0.0301869512,
-0.0206275042,
0.0426694602,
0.0202470105,
-0.0108542284,
-0.0158658698,
0.0035477881,
-0.1083218157,
-0.0305558164,
-0.0646564141,
0.0572061278,
-0.0443087779,
-0.0376001708,
0.0842504948,
0.0263708029,
-0.030313896,
-0.0468010865,
0.0094091054,
-0.024939917,
-0.0472563207,
-0.0426095836,
-0.032117974,
0.0248654522,
0.0328394175,
0.0034478426,
0.0253272038,
0.0133709516,
-0.0231253635,
-0.037240725,
-0.1465960741,
-0.0165545102,
0.0202765577,
0.0675553679,
0.0010729729,
0.0094978688,
0.0156455301,
0.0313929766,
0.0797471628,
-0.0364930741,
-0.0388564579,
0.0189349428,
0.0423480198,
0.0020641217,
0.0334999263,
0.001530324,
0.1211800948,
-0.0277412012,
-0.0431743041,
-0.025504116,
0.0572488569,
0.047199294,
0.0654260963,
-0.0015282169,
0.0124239298,
-0.0299361479,
-0.042557966,
0.0117124394,
-0.0449223891,
-0.0270686019,
-0.0124416286,
0.046519842,
0.0050535491,
0.0163281076,
0.0065789986,
-0.0209712032,
-0.0081048757,
0.01369265,
-0.0003376995,
0.0372810103,
0.0223802235,
-0.0009055926,
-0.0172224455,
0.0159675758,
-0.0427663028,
-0.006522737,
0.0089426804,
0.0207503587,
0.039697554,
0.1055296287,
-0.0410189815,
-0.0345381461,
-0.0046006045,
0.0261644404,
0.0002637775,
0.069945991,
0.0377609991,
0.0092940256,
-0.0026896752,
0.0573633909,
-0.0118858181,
0.0270375069,
-0.0253245253,
0.0110571506,
0.0576691031,
0.0613937266,
-0.0112776794,
-0.0244793575,
-0.0433643684,
0.0386299416,
0.0069336602,
-0.1410093606,
0.0053543192,
0.0525951684,
3.169e-7,
0.0119702807,
0.01514656,
-0.0113088777,
-0.0134368995,
0.0466487966,
0.0044192229,
0.0217397213,
0.0114311753,
0.0030800144,
0.0422112867,
0.0371955596,
0.0127534838,
0.0177890398,
0.0318430476,
-0.0460085608,
-0.0559980646,
-0.0718710646,
0.0214172695,
-0.0207999535,
-0.0328337625,
0.0090031223,
0.0774221346,
0.0344972797,
-0.0314641483,
0.053013131,
-0.0055743624,
0.0320443846,
0.0315848403,
0.0613285266,
0.013345493,
0.0576120056,
0.0282233804,
0.0098413555,
-0.0171632133,
-0.025249714,
-0.0011588631,
-0.0216061603,
0.0594828501,
-0.0155399814,
0.0083162254,
0.0096749738,
-0.0000518162,
-0.0030192232,
0.0039443295,
0.0678357631,
-0.0856351107,
0.0059247371,
-0.0411033258,
0.0065160599,
-0.0092116585,
0.020584669,
0.0282618534,
-0.0057277451,
0.0281625856,
0.0419427492,
0.0120925065,
-0.017784154,
-0.092291221,
0.0083020907,
-0.0089936573,
-0.04277597,
-0.0381663591,
-0.0831429139,
-0.0335825123,
0.0715129748,
-0.0297946651,
-0.0296531506,
2.694624042e-34,
0.0186614264,
0.008179782,
0.0045759832,
0.0145887425,
-0.0258432142,
-0.0008227436,
0.0582296997,
-0.0221324917,
0.0007309676,
-0.0611367673,
-0.055378288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14936v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14936v1 | PanGu-Coder2: Boosting Large Language Models for Code with Ranking Feedback | 2023-07-27T15:28:29 | 2023-07-27T15:28:29 | Bo Shen, Jiaxin Zhang, Taihong Chen, Daoguang Zan, Bing Geng, An Fu, Muhan Zeng, Ailun Yu, Jichuan Ji, Jingyang Zhao, Yuenan Guo, Qianxiang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL, cs.SE | Large Language Models for Code (Code LLM) are flourishing. New and powerful
models are released on a weekly basis, demonstrating remarkable performance on
the code generation task. Various approaches have been proposed to boost the
code generation performance of pre-trained Code LLMs, such as supervised
fine-tuning, instruction tuning, reinforcement learning, etc. In this paper, we
propose a novel RRTF (Rank Responses to align Test&Teacher Feedback) framework,
which can effectively and efficiently boost pre-trained large language models
for code generation. Under this framework, we present PanGu-Coder2, which
achieves 62.20% pass@1 on the OpenAI HumanEval benchmark. Furthermore, through
an extensive evaluation on CoderEval and LeetCode benchmarks, we show that
PanGu-Coder2 consistently outperforms all previous Code LLMs. | [
0.0177766271,
0.0777780712,
-0.0068401759,
0.0165748838,
0.0275089592,
0.0022160339,
-0.0345277749,
0.0106174583,
-0.0105691366,
-0.0298912395,
-0.0295006856,
-0.0197455417,
-0.0123982904,
0.0233481172,
0.0327404626,
-0.0167447515,
0.0222138651,
-0.0578253642,
-0.027557509,
-0.0010807944,
-0.0176189207,
0.0091595361,
0.021750804,
0.0538233072,
0.0177815482,
-0.0156996269,
-0.0192260146,
0.0134211825,
0.0286831148,
-0.0512286127,
0.0490859523,
0.0744225234,
0.0090764863,
0.0315305069,
0.0000021857,
-0.0251442958,
-0.0112559497,
-0.0045948643,
0.0496738032,
0.0451966859,
-0.0070645977,
0.0026034103,
-0.0384128951,
0.0323861875,
-0.0415383615,
-0.0165805146,
0.037660446,
-0.0071195858,
0.072203435,
0.0722991005,
0.014020592,
-0.0292059779,
0.0250233486,
-0.0517195761,
0.0188034009,
-0.0387267135,
0.0029453761,
0.0091286898,
-0.0008729753,
0.0035071052,
-0.0282582603,
-0.0203495603,
0.0442541651,
-0.0065495376,
0.018011542,
0.0458757468,
-0.0452963524,
0.0164693091,
-0.0005007497,
0.0672877729,
-0.0803872123,
-0.0416582748,
-0.0046562264,
-0.0071449922,
-0.0407008342,
-0.0810550973,
-0.0123928357,
0.07200744,
0.009027076,
0.0302297771,
0.0200708602,
-0.0253654346,
0.0206961948,
0.0280676205,
-0.0294006355,
0.036350973,
0.0330372378,
-0.0335359387,
-0.0310996659,
-0.005704314,
0.0007412204,
-0.0479290634,
-0.0224801544,
0.0620914884,
-0.0544249304,
-0.0023640504,
-0.0573487431,
-0.0161629822,
0.0111904722,
-0.0182327516,
0.060324505,
0.0530780517,
-0.005149256,
-0.0155799342,
-0.0852230638,
0.0875129625,
-0.0213355701,
0.0122004617,
-0.0391677842,
0.0372957624,
-0.0202382393,
0.0180356782,
-0.013500913,
0.0525337011,
-0.0271436553,
0.012927874,
-0.0689165294,
0.0184804648,
0.0007282376,
0.0638056099,
0.0061378088,
0.0052014864,
-0.0763324946,
0.032184761,
0.0100138923,
-0.0024427865,
-0.0165230967,
-0.0561353974,
-0.007262371,
-0.0310632121,
0.0147100827,
0.0187029056,
-0.0244152099,
-0.0329985172,
0.0239318125,
0.0187845007,
-0.0338643454,
0.0071392022,
-0.0038243553,
-0.0236766543,
-0.0003250667,
-0.0544270165,
0.0051385886,
-0.0611702129,
-0.0479192138,
-0.0197212994,
0.0111366343,
-0.0308019686,
0.0437426008,
0.0062639485,
0.0192241687,
0.0000604373,
-0.0454292931,
-0.0039445548,
-0.0223626345,
0.0224794559,
0.0016114358,
0.0377627201,
0.0468377359,
0.0606898926,
-0.0357981808,
-0.025742488,
0.0055715204,
0.0424435548,
0.0104804188,
0.0156665295,
-0.0012207633,
0.0227516033,
0.0284382161,
0.001497405,
0.0447583273,
0.0258558933,
-0.0040035681,
0.0457154959,
0.008006976,
-0.0044873534,
0.0288754199,
0.0555738397,
0.0628717989,
-0.0149341337,
0.0001035811,
-0.0024608967,
-0.0120665012,
0.0589100085,
-0.0212364048,
0.028056711,
0.0242490098,
0.0571214855,
-0.0168250669,
-0.0548187084,
0.0144910719,
-0.0113280518,
-0.033171989,
-0.0003035837,
0.0217474271,
0.0010173323,
-0.0596639477,
-0.0331685096,
0.0043208795,
-0.0876401886,
-0.0110709472,
-0.0719598979,
0.0419995226,
0.0425271653,
0.0411472432,
-0.0396091305,
-0.0217953287,
-0.0053182365,
-0.0237387624,
0.0077454392,
0.0211186782,
0.0058096191,
-0.0074801003,
-0.0498803146,
-0.0086052595,
-0.0240098294,
-0.0122549264,
0.0552424043,
0.0224249214,
-0.0165913273,
0.0441433899,
0.0234517138,
-0.1007905528,
0.0413745604,
0.0033744017,
0.0002792135,
0.0314882845,
-0.0030252109,
0.0362102985,
-0.0268192776,
-0.0453667641,
0.0175254606,
0.0236901715,
-0.0217592064,
0.0152726788,
-0.0541340858,
-0.0325823463,
-0.053610988,
0.0239592697,
-0.0186143648,
-0.0176178887,
0.07508865,
-0.0309491456,
-0.0206069499,
0.0353972055,
0.0113178184,
0.0199639313,
-0.0348740518,
0.0164157003,
-0.0050072842,
-0.0127888899,
-0.0268170107,
0.0713598281,
0.0056175897,
0.0564693511,
0.044869978,
0.0914903656,
0.0078813126,
-0.0168336313,
-0.0192383025,
0.0070509869,
-0.02912605,
0.0362607948,
-0.0029511845,
0.0625613183,
-0.0178040732,
-0.0607886538,
-0.0764876679,
0.0597976483,
-0.027065672,
0.0030588871,
-0.0096020447,
-0.0029145277,
0.0122064697,
-0.0156224351,
-0.057728909,
-0.0161120687,
0.0082885362,
-0.0178103168,
-0.0001231725,
-0.0253262632,
-0.0460341014,
-0.0649686977,
0.0015969656,
-0.0065047746,
0.0240264721,
-0.0113316718,
0.0173860416,
-0.0549110584,
0.0904175565,
-0.0291001778,
0.0347263329,
-0.0002189335,
-0.0727544948,
0.0281503592,
-0.0609848388,
0.0874972045,
0.0580800325,
0.0071103,
0.0353666246,
0.0554198138,
0.033274848,
-0.040062461,
0.0359110162,
0.0058198241,
-0.0820238665,
0.0109449029,
-0.025347501,
0.03990338,
0.0696902946,
0.0241026487,
-0.0241172295,
-0.0847907439,
0.0139917117,
0.0209382717,
-0.0194566529,
-0.0137918582,
0.0117930537,
-0.0227658525,
0.037665166,
-0.0272371452,
-0.0808041915,
0.040763054,
-0.023396682,
0.0018500303,
-0.0220774021,
-0.0076988116,
-0.0464206785,
0.0074055265,
0.0060123247,
0.0321885012,
-0.0625319704,
-0.0182016604,
-0.0266716257,
0.0276311468,
-0.0204999428,
-0.0546974503,
0.0268889945,
-0.0269886684,
0.0224196482,
-0.0157917459,
-0.0395182818,
-0.0490079261,
0.0087029282,
0.0198199078,
0.0133064911,
0.0422211215,
-0.0121538183,
0.0839075446,
0.0145847956,
0.0033452036,
0.042816598,
-0.0304155238,
-0.0239094291,
-0.0224501248,
-0.013523547,
0.0137807885,
-0.0521100014,
-0.012400235,
-0.0373800583,
0.0042480621,
0.0129422555,
0.050760299,
0.05723368,
-0.0698596835,
0.0495051444,
0.0208964385,
-0.0009271715,
0.0168042649,
0.0758714527,
0.0393656977,
-0.0338013507,
-0.0537751615,
0.0911257714,
0.0552734882,
-0.0418037027,
0.0126803461,
0.0209807195,
0.0786324292,
0.0376993679,
0.041952692,
-0.0605856217,
0.0031967643,
-0.0254145414,
0.0302715972,
-0.019563267,
-0.0168390851,
-0.0069829607,
-0.151887089,
0.0358898602,
0.0407366827,
-0.041131068,
-0.0441439338,
0.0122717759,
-0.0283466447,
0.0336482003,
-0.0288328659,
0.0465449132,
-0.0205640625,
0.0379013717,
0.0311811715,
0.0114247939,
-0.0161595996,
0.0099620279,
-0.0554402098,
0.0504087172,
0.1214041412,
0.0143854097,
0.0029008738,
-0.0057702777,
-0.040843118,
0.0082694301,
0.0367660858,
-0.0269577261,
-0.0214511268,
0.0128400074,
-0.0401552841,
0.0082147224,
0.0196401365,
-0.0421268716,
0.0110388221,
0.0380509496,
0.0444280654,
-0.0157810505,
-0.0134729492,
-0.0064223674,
-0.0150273461,
-0.0101196645,
0.0183696076,
0.022785645,
-0.0308990777,
-0.008493701,
-0.0606777333,
-0.0095295869,
-0.1057248712,
-0.0203915965,
0.0063650333,
-0.0287431255,
0.0166179407,
-0.0626386628,
0.0062615061,
0.0094198799,
0.0389809906,
0.0088433418,
-0.0347446203,
-0.0125093926,
-0.0019267641,
-0.0634858683,
-0.0152086532,
-0.0058530504,
-0.0017508562,
-0.0530890673,
-0.0301927589,
0.0118623013,
-0.0460484773,
0.0118537089,
-0.0043264469,
-0.0857225358,
-0.0340869911,
-0.0402010009,
0.0951469094,
0.0091827754,
0.0144946706,
-0.0045600832,
-0.0273842886,
-0.0567537732,
-0.0069062142,
-0.010252675,
0.0301720351,
0.0229255315,
-0.0154716913,
0.0115046054,
-0.0052043661,
-0.0625451654,
0.0144854616,
0.0336054675,
0.0356438458,
0.0328301452,
0.0061942781,
0.0395982116,
0.0338524729,
-0.0009821124,
-0.0268610064,
-0.0506816283,
-0.0256896224,
0.0167787895,
-0.0118332971,
-0.0171583388,
-0.0443610102,
0.0478405729,
0.033315748,
-0.0068973969,
-0.0095020356,
0.0114838611,
0.0378375836,
0.0463936813,
-0.0292808246,
0.0243781377,
-0.0062955348,
0.038437698,
0.0736735016,
-0.0009075827,
-0.0286671165,
0.0156546701,
0.0391194113,
0.0272195823,
0.0120619116,
0.0775669962,
0.0234828759,
0.0353413299,
0.0211643856,
0.0213656295,
-0.0371681824,
-0.0753872469,
-0.0646610409,
-0.0315044858,
0.0689021572,
0.0705934241,
0.0236689374,
-0.0246791132,
0.0242766365,
-0.0042824256,
0.0353821442,
-0.0114781158,
-0.0226304214,
0.0282390434,
0.0112756714,
-0.0018334981,
-0.0137155559,
0.090339832,
0.0207240786,
-0.0066321902,
0.0009288602,
0.0318533592,
-0.0352469571,
0.0113702491,
0.0415112153,
0.0142652085,
0.0016640734,
0.0026546887,
0.0176495463,
-0.0433892533,
-0.0092655718,
0.0374601297,
0.0200056229,
-0.0067302687,
0.0173967406,
0.0367490128,
-0.0342202857,
0.0145682888,
-0.058571782,
-0.0198391005,
0.0110824583,
-0.0245792884,
-0.0188335478,
-6.639605721e-33,
-0.0420008525,
-0.026740836,
-0.0021735094,
-0.0096108001,
-0.0289606731,
-0.0164792854,
-0.0406155586,
-0.0075608161,
0.0172472894,
-0.0385597534,
0.019467853,
0.0266682394,
-0.0085641844,
0.0111262472,
0.0360794216,
0.0178094059,
0.0478458554,
0.0224868096,
-0.0480583385,
0.0435783453,
-0.0376145467,
0.0275953505,
-0.0068342066,
0.0075781038,
-0.0337473936,
-0.0133326566,
-0.0180814154,
0.0018924767,
-0.0309684277,
0.0306388028,
-0.0008913844,
0.022218002,
-0.0031867903,
-0.0324458554,
-0.0104400916,
-0.0139479376,
-0.0204218943,
-0.0324859098,
-0.002456832,
-0.0085833007,
-0.0087701082,
-0.0567005575,
0.0443427674,
0.0204964876,
-0.0441923141,
-0.0076892469,
0.0072918022,
-0.0321123526,
-0.0116248373,
-0.0738826096,
-0.0905124769,
0.0136023536,
-0.0370272212,
-0.0247828681,
-0.0141352471,
0.0025001641,
-0.016038347,
0.0468820147,
-0.0023035128,
0.0216545295,
0.0379504524,
0.0902430788,
0.045563858,
0.0276349317,
-0.0253862962,
0.0142699936,
0.0459331572,
0.0029365015,
0.0066385665,
0.0244649965,
0.0496962965,
0.0321544819,
0.0463078134,
0.0283926055,
0.0218036324,
0.0017486763,
-0.067945309,
0.0221272968,
-0.0047157262,
-0.0188373048,
0.0317951888,
0.0047283811,
-0.0198163129,
-0.0052939584,
-0.0343053415,
-0.0188580584,
-0.0439227261,
-0.0437342934,
0.0813640058,
0.0247462373,
-0.028282946,
-0.0107826302,
0.0171186756,
-0.0224644039,
0.0303650759,
0.0047560954,
-0.0625623539,
0.0375145003,
-0.0410605855,
0.0181288626,
-0.0334377848,
-0.0330914445,
0.0420389734,
-0.0399388038,
0.0393606983,
0.0198593549,
0.0070935637,
0.0231109764,
-0.0577606633,
-0.0006134537,
-0.0456554852,
0.0005719108,
0.0419763215,
0.0609058924,
-0.0135862343,
-0.0277851373,
0.0226668194,
0.0715396702,
-0.0239681415,
-0.0099294242,
-0.0586305633,
-0.0226445198,
0.0241256375,
0.0328043774,
-0.0336036719,
0.0033730417,
-0.037564341,
0.0619516186,
0.0158178806,
-0.0465857945,
-0.071661517,
0.0223754086,
2.86e-7,
0.0180770736,
0.0320821181,
-0.0169683136,
0.0345092788,
-0.0149901267,
0.0173705723,
-0.0445199236,
0.0342487805,
0.0464680046,
0.0257747471,
0.0061756819,
0.0023706702,
0.038728293,
0.0181816071,
-0.032507889,
0.0153488284,
-0.0314418487,
0.0014684922,
-0.0629387945,
-0.0198702179,
0.0242485274,
0.0864433646,
-0.0388523601,
0.007545677,
0.0415412225,
0.0181613173,
0.028823249,
0.0186061878,
-0.0144149447,
0.0228424352,
-0.0611592866,
0.0094765723,
-0.0539330393,
-0.0392098911,
-0.0078489818,
0.0047637918,
0.0188019872,
0.0629262403,
-0.0247576423,
0.0386519693,
0.062124528,
0.0332423933,
0.0085061947,
-0.0687058046,
0.0294709392,
-0.0079144128,
0.0291710943,
0.0085681574,
-0.0013513453,
-0.0051280023,
-0.0239734985,
-0.0736979246,
0.0235992316,
0.0226589143,
-0.0051426408,
0.013206413,
-0.0282826796,
-0.0334258303,
-0.0371555276,
-0.0021361287,
-0.002058181,
-0.0635981858,
-0.0685708672,
0.0093734404,
-0.0165895019,
-0.0498264097,
0.0226288345,
2.61963439e-34,
0.0262356419,
-0.0504579283,
0.0253418554,
0.0141473487,
0.0440194458,
-0.0009101263,
-0.0292843189,
0.0261102598,
0.0042191898,
-0.0222358629,
-0.0569902658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14913v1 | ARC-NLP at PAN 2023: Transition-Focused Natural Language Inference for Writing Style Detection | 2023-07-27T14:56:06 | 2023-07-27T14:56:06 | Izzet Emre Kucukkaya, Umitcan Sahin, Cagri Toraman | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of multi-author writing style detection aims at finding any
positions of writing style change in a given text document. We formulate the
task as a natural language inference problem where two consecutive paragraphs
are paired. Our approach focuses on transitions between paragraphs while
truncating input tokens for the task. As backbone models, we employ different
Transformer-based encoders with warmup phase during training. We submit the
model version that outperforms baselines and other proposed model versions in
our experiments. For the easy and medium setups, we submit transition-focused
natural language inference based on DeBERTa with warmup training, and the same
model without transition for the hard setup. | [
0.0245440695,
0.1095512062,
0.0005093814,
0.0350081548,
-0.0448017381,
-0.006116109,
0.0302592162,
0.0038459445,
-0.035530366,
-0.0317167975,
0.0102855023,
0.0017143119,
0.0147313923,
-0.0003255654,
0.0188366212,
-0.0657645017,
-0.0033052564,
-0.0095852995,
0.0005965657,
0.0164879262,
0.0637011379,
0.0074602831,
-0.0106944647,
0.0410844795,
0.0197532121,
-0.0462512225,
-0.019903576,
0.0380104482,
0.0415121131,
-0.0173369106,
0.0492411032,
0.0798549056,
0.0346434936,
0.0229847077,
0.0000020181,
-0.0185060576,
-0.0396643206,
-0.0245310329,
0.0130024301,
-0.0314622074,
0.0162965003,
-0.0275826175,
-0.0010996786,
0.0099562984,
-0.0157217924,
-0.0328406133,
0.0541026182,
0.0756809935,
0.0626012012,
0.097232759,
-0.0305242538,
-0.0699594542,
0.0064333738,
-0.0140314065,
-0.0395914353,
-0.001079332,
0.044829648,
-0.0575776622,
0.0000612883,
0.0134639861,
0.0037843292,
-0.0007131026,
0.018753523,
-0.0209935959,
-0.0234606862,
-0.0085321199,
-0.0395226926,
0.0101869721,
-0.0185439866,
0.0311197788,
-0.0264436007,
-0.038396202,
0.0348400101,
-0.0038802638,
-0.0028440126,
0.0052769058,
-0.016475793,
-0.0062198984,
-0.0505370982,
0.0107658021,
0.0054021608,
0.0333441272,
-0.0137949539,
0.0067308135,
-0.0107724685,
0.0372342095,
0.0170629881,
-0.0445881225,
-0.0349958315,
0.0232528597,
0.0025466539,
-0.0446323566,
0.0584874079,
-0.0021346097,
0.0420845821,
-0.0438560434,
-0.0602319762,
-0.0575581565,
-0.0230048466,
-0.0175613854,
0.0493497849,
-0.0193922129,
-0.0118259313,
-0.0089581637,
-0.0458795801,
0.0456390381,
-0.0331595577,
-0.0040713218,
-0.0207500625,
-0.0069653015,
-0.0159533303,
0.0002328135,
-0.0559324138,
-0.0068375072,
0.0074554938,
0.0006624559,
0.0028251288,
-0.0215125661,
0.01835729,
-0.0197984464,
-0.0016146556,
-0.0132284872,
-0.0413347781,
-0.0247657187,
0.05210853,
0.0573956557,
-0.0097773168,
0.0191977341,
0.0051055732,
-0.0358506665,
-0.0378873833,
0.0538105257,
0.0510437824,
-0.0391861536,
-0.0034826226,
0.0071414686,
-0.0376757681,
-0.0153151313,
-0.0232500322,
-0.0105370246,
0.0067582782,
-0.0504352935,
0.0150875831,
-0.0784069598,
-0.0055403085,
0.0038041451,
0.0159712154,
-0.0564302504,
-0.0111532239,
0.0260655377,
-0.0167640895,
0.0415256396,
0.0095987832,
-0.0162601322,
0.0276788305,
-0.0132597201,
0.0005968399,
0.0710908771,
0.0558308996,
0.0339471847,
0.0262054261,
0.0246203542,
0.020495683,
0.053221073,
-0.0099978279,
-0.0040491079,
-0.0009508359,
-0.037998084,
0.0306634232,
0.031285435,
0.0424608923,
0.0213091224,
-0.0355252847,
-0.038073957,
0.0511437096,
0.0151864346,
0.0478333086,
0.0375511982,
0.0571500175,
0.0554781221,
0.0052593271,
0.0557364337,
0.0128774829,
0.0126208831,
0.0136073465,
0.0027345638,
-0.0045580491,
0.0165516715,
-0.023900006,
0.0156745855,
0.0028146275,
-0.006849525,
-0.0363336541,
-0.0701008663,
0.0300312582,
0.0311247632,
-0.055951532,
0.0129410364,
-0.0074949288,
-0.0728156641,
-0.0210980736,
-0.0126193548,
-0.0182864796,
0.0674526393,
0.0439866856,
-0.0022732974,
-0.0197378155,
-0.0166490767,
0.0213783942,
0.0476245396,
-0.017095767,
-0.0069192937,
0.0414970182,
-0.043699488,
-0.0093042208,
-0.0344049633,
0.0203388613,
0.0038972606,
0.0042438121,
0.0218527317,
0.0065446678,
-0.0206783433,
0.0028593221,
0.062778458,
-0.045786418,
0.017771909,
0.0013592693,
0.0327226184,
-0.0402361229,
-0.0347824991,
-0.0452480763,
-0.0245164186,
-0.0215324536,
-0.0990989283,
-0.0139236078,
0.0558832139,
-0.0210574847,
-0.086558491,
-0.0167574007,
-0.055793494,
-0.000232979,
0.0237998832,
-0.03298264,
-0.0511406288,
-0.0045339689,
-0.0274530947,
-0.0205820352,
-0.0198305864,
-0.0162922218,
-0.009700398,
0.0308779106,
-0.0177101213,
0.0489471219,
0.0132766366,
0.0059368103,
-0.0013487963,
-0.0184030998,
0.0293306354,
-0.008941019,
-0.0141258985,
-0.0247141384,
-0.0034400949,
-0.0238177758,
0.0397575796,
0.0328195915,
0.0114045311,
-0.0704668909,
-0.0699789524,
-0.0073850011,
-0.0355103575,
0.0338946432,
0.0314387865,
0.0136468988,
-0.0267651789,
-0.0207242016,
-0.031837374,
-0.0545847155,
-0.0039497884,
-0.0074730357,
0.0603065081,
-0.0303549059,
-0.0339648165,
-0.0370419584,
-0.0091918213,
-0.0143174119,
0.0692480803,
0.0404810607,
-0.0661714748,
-0.033895243,
-0.0319512561,
0.0303687882,
0.0091594523,
-0.0008386984,
-0.0392575748,
0.0129257357,
-0.0201115236,
0.0773433745,
0.1181943566,
0.0486380048,
0.0375036187,
-0.0018905152,
-0.0057110181,
0.0151032535,
-0.0025049222,
0.0056365826,
0.0733283311,
-0.0010067263,
-0.0415910184,
0.0358024463,
0.0577799119,
-0.0008327661,
0.0200515948,
-0.0185390208,
-0.0262017231,
0.016370777,
-0.0064988215,
0.0916844085,
-0.0207550488,
-0.021161437,
0.0076520243,
-0.0279123597,
0.0007052237,
0.0687337294,
-0.0408607833,
-0.0194808617,
-0.0412453152,
0.0019281801,
-0.0499233603,
0.0497536771,
0.0270620398,
0.0135650765,
0.019937411,
-0.055050876,
-0.0340560116,
-0.003126693,
0.0571135804,
0.0039330395,
0.033912506,
-0.0486593135,
0.0406699888,
-0.0422917344,
-0.0334360376,
-0.0457722582,
-0.0470209382,
-0.0279622562,
0.0042952243,
-0.0180779789,
-0.0455005243,
-0.0453369953,
0.0209939815,
-0.0382390656,
0.1151425615,
-0.053353671,
0.0169354621,
-0.0305906646,
0.0722559839,
0.0080327298,
-0.0186432712,
-0.0618302524,
-0.0872015283,
0.0422637723,
0.0318123251,
-0.0164300445,
0.0476524457,
-0.0588267669,
-0.0274972189,
0.0153798787,
-0.0557158738,
-0.0212484431,
-0.0232030656,
0.0621029064,
-0.0664310828,
-0.047945004,
0.1082888842,
-0.0078096143,
-0.0559991337,
-0.0376265161,
0.0126532307,
0.037666332,
-0.0157468859,
0.0132533079,
-0.0670562759,
-0.0684683472,
0.0259983856,
0.0090908669,
-0.0095645776,
-0.0132121406,
0.0030672238,
-0.0413944162,
0.0081404354,
-0.0201780964,
-0.0016379135,
0.001846751,
-0.0229458809,
0.045006901,
-0.0058117653,
-0.0231810194,
-0.0135971839,
-0.0179308709,
0.0070849177,
0.0209293682,
-0.0421141759,
-0.0433738343,
-0.0470047481,
-0.0568145923,
0.0005536276,
0.0512211882,
0.0312243439,
-0.0236435123,
-0.0256843437,
0.0034919924,
-0.0302224346,
0.0073216166,
0.0140539967,
0.0703248382,
-0.027634196,
0.006657254,
-0.0198336784,
0.0357118435,
0.0013980442,
-0.0005751536,
0.0431548916,
-0.0115017062,
-0.0275703445,
-0.0550245978,
-0.0278524458,
0.029515421,
0.0039319918,
0.0213543791,
0.0335403495,
-0.051986549,
-0.0945269093,
-0.0514765345,
0.0302747153,
-0.060831558,
-0.0253383387,
-0.0445318185,
0.0201676432,
-0.0073377979,
-0.0766709,
0.0119117079,
0.0020328611,
0.0480742417,
-0.0086605009,
0.0145097142,
0.0013300828,
-0.0132535538,
-0.0646339357,
-0.020805167,
0.002918886,
0.0241757464,
-0.0402195193,
0.0053588669,
0.0257796105,
0.0216581766,
0.0064991745,
0.0311036743,
-0.1171118468,
-0.0352104306,
0.0343077555,
0.0015266618,
0.0157269482,
0.0539523363,
-0.0306184217,
-0.0286835097,
0.0486629233,
0.067718327,
0.0202015378,
0.0204101205,
0.0361652859,
-0.0304233897,
-0.0179587547,
0.0179212764,
0.0160036851,
0.0184234884,
-0.0051860884,
0.0135660777,
0.0135618858,
-0.0395572819,
-0.0021772285,
-0.0507209972,
0.0150170233,
0.0174259227,
0.017502252,
-0.0285594147,
0.010959411,
-0.0145763448,
-0.0007524446,
-0.0489594154,
0.0129034203,
-0.0195851568,
0.0496548042,
-0.0064065843,
0.0497433729,
0.0190546103,
0.0176847707,
-0.04425456,
0.0515986905,
0.0287449528,
0.0970548615,
-0.0290329214,
-0.0089367907,
-0.0131317312,
0.0196990184,
-0.0049571604,
0.0416335277,
-0.010713378,
0.0359067917,
0.0622497424,
0.0068917647,
-0.0021797048,
0.0363117941,
-0.080685623,
0.0503846221,
-0.0471501127,
-0.0133647881,
0.0333407037,
-0.0032089483,
0.1023406237,
0.0087192189,
0.0188404229,
0.006013968,
0.0555921532,
0.00169542,
-0.0184903499,
-0.0150420815,
-0.0068279277,
0.0085489396,
0.0190575588,
0.0704173595,
0.0096788071,
0.0151203386,
0.0059225243,
-0.0196729656,
0.0069940616,
-0.0205474049,
0.01428656,
-0.0312804468,
0.0449061468,
-0.004611203,
0.0093095303,
-0.0002163765,
0.0538205691,
-0.0250945445,
0.0121041313,
-0.0012041077,
0.0119946478,
0.0283891261,
0.0050793313,
-0.0529095195,
-0.0219175555,
0.0379621908,
0.046623528,
-0.0363505594,
-0.0340311863,
-6.516897335e-33,
-0.014264321,
-0.0250727944,
-0.0394176841,
0.0337797441,
-0.0536256284,
-0.007682729,
-0.0477980375,
-0.0582089983,
-0.0047405334,
0.0304942802,
-0.010457187,
0.0394915231,
0.0085583711,
0.0290713962,
0.0111914901,
-0.0012414869,
0.0869955495,
0.0072562653,
-0.0468418002,
0.0112794545,
0.0409119166,
0.0279947761,
0.0901688784,
-0.014385568,
-0.0081697404,
-0.0562600829,
-0.0333944038,
-0.0203267317,
-0.0090603707,
-0.0063236263,
0.0267445222,
-0.017383974,
0.0293942448,
-0.0288019441,
-0.0135881752,
0.0247351173,
-0.0592846312,
-0.0425614901,
-0.0354063325,
0.0395768322,
-0.007294605,
-0.0315992087,
0.040580593,
-0.0179066267,
0.0400931239,
-0.0131076751,
0.0767827109,
-0.0114092939,
0.0205202792,
-0.0475803725,
-0.0390606485,
0.0501270965,
-0.0090257414,
-0.0110946698,
0.0256171934,
0.0527928546,
-0.0011228455,
-0.046766445,
-0.0575195402,
-0.0159600694,
0.0032652742,
0.0414246581,
-0.0516477115,
0.0165420976,
-0.0142296758,
0.0378605649,
-0.0326276906,
0.0226687267,
-0.0105486289,
0.0227893796,
0.048783347,
0.0083684912,
0.0181496143,
0.0166221634,
0.0218264628,
0.031624157,
-0.0277831275,
0.0431232043,
0.048064854,
0.0451231077,
0.0215684492,
-0.0077818232,
0.0058773803,
-0.0422516428,
-0.0373568982,
-0.070665732,
0.0030974487,
0.0124450913,
-0.0010637352,
0.021134356,
0.0000473508,
0.0079613263,
0.0431759804,
-0.0308365487,
-0.0276250094,
0.0205606483,
-0.0496758558,
0.06615033,
-0.006796923,
0.0294951871,
-0.0233800281,
-0.0261174589,
0.0580606125,
0.0718423799,
0.0169446412,
-0.0282976329,
0.0746975541,
0.0140799843,
-0.0729585588,
-0.0206924826,
0.0109255919,
0.0148767009,
-0.0298075359,
0.0505198762,
0.0117907505,
0.0067211445,
-0.0067994674,
0.0624741018,
0.0062250709,
0.0340971313,
-0.0440961942,
0.0136254951,
0.0149316322,
0.0480307639,
-0.0409659743,
0.0159458555,
-0.0419483744,
-0.0287447944,
-0.023365112,
-0.0670383647,
0.019682318,
-0.0004156522,
2.713e-7,
0.0234146491,
0.0028459174,
0.0859534591,
-0.0048762788,
0.0216984656,
0.0197099485,
0.0093237348,
0.0532848872,
0.0062562977,
0.0158722345,
0.0254727695,
0.0068902178,
0.0764433369,
0.0134653784,
-0.0806451812,
0.0163761303,
-0.0535159074,
0.0070606805,
-0.0676761866,
-0.027730912,
0.0507706329,
0.0216923729,
0.0074708583,
0.0125105325,
0.0181441419,
0.0065678651,
0.0682130456,
0.0417270027,
0.0459203757,
0.0107076196,
0.0671535879,
-0.0480402596,
0.0097803595,
0.0327080488,
-0.0011081337,
0.0339387543,
-0.0110768275,
0.0406072438,
0.0146688148,
0.0396427102,
0.0339439958,
0.0098498939,
-0.01114963,
-0.0377387814,
0.0912446454,
-0.0250460692,
-0.0214087591,
-0.0641532466,
-0.0648782328,
-0.0042477204,
-0.010493177,
0.0165744741,
-0.0432478003,
0.0481273867,
0.0413766578,
-0.0203248467,
-0.0103197517,
-0.0719701722,
-0.0183168128,
-0.0358554758,
-0.0198250655,
0.0455364026,
-0.0459594727,
-0.0302053392,
-0.0042592334,
-0.0513251051,
0.020554794,
2.709823505e-34,
0.0224789567,
-0.0337849855,
-0.0173752159,
0.0224632211,
0.0177451875,
-0.0097244354,
0.0160609912,
0.0047221007,
-0.0280654505,
-0.0724485517,
-0.0034881635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14912v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14912v1 | ARC-NLP at PAN 2023: Hierarchical Long Text Classification for Trigger Detection | 2023-07-27T14:55:10 | 2023-07-27T14:55:10 | Umitcan Sahin, Izzet Emre Kucukkaya, Cagri Toraman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Fanfiction, a popular form of creative writing set within established
fictional universes, has gained a substantial online following. However,
ensuring the well-being and safety of participants has become a critical
concern in this community. The detection of triggering content, material that
may cause emotional distress or trauma to readers, poses a significant
challenge. In this paper, we describe our approach for the Trigger Detection
shared task at PAN CLEF 2023, where we want to detect multiple triggering
content in a given Fanfiction document. For this, we build a hierarchical model
that uses recurrence over Transformer-based language models. In our approach,
we first split long documents into smaller sized segments and use them to
fine-tune a Transformer model. Then, we extract feature embeddings from the
fine-tuned Transformer model, which are used as input in the training of
multiple LSTM models for trigger detection in a multi-label setting. Our model
achieves an F1-macro score of 0.372 and F1-micro score of 0.736 on the
validation set, which are higher than the baseline results shared at PAN CLEF
2023. | [
0.0439805798,
0.0050446391,
-0.0137180556,
0.0657024607,
-0.0402638167,
0.0113113439,
-0.0046229544,
0.0287344214,
0.03694712,
-0.047445897,
-0.0166661721,
-0.037577793,
-0.0169767272,
0.0750135407,
-0.0327511057,
-0.0171527136,
-0.0062581557,
0.0069551552,
0.0329632759,
0.0245228466,
0.0258928146,
0.0548363738,
-0.0028400158,
0.043298997,
-0.023837531,
-0.0165833831,
0.0402878635,
0.0025970072,
0.0308026131,
-0.0443762876,
0.0446979478,
0.0216862541,
0.063642107,
0.0620052963,
0.0000018969,
-0.0148472572,
0.0068545104,
-0.0364035703,
0.0392143354,
-0.0268479735,
0.0322503261,
-0.0613959208,
0.0072088726,
0.0213523936,
0.0088140154,
-0.0290061589,
0.0206483752,
0.1098098233,
0.0663793162,
0.0781905726,
-0.0277201869,
-0.0600417107,
0.0214736424,
-0.0240980871,
0.0172661729,
0.0054026651,
0.0322072469,
-0.0502333343,
0.0252050441,
-0.0082266927,
-0.0244492311,
0.0304359198,
0.0269796532,
-0.0080764806,
0.0063822209,
0.0089862542,
-0.0151234474,
-0.0064339079,
-0.0068082334,
0.036025662,
-0.0459052473,
-0.0280943774,
0.0071633509,
0.0007000556,
-0.0250718258,
0.0146871209,
-0.0312273093,
-0.0263527744,
-0.0056077517,
-0.0013249147,
0.0234360304,
0.0149032706,
0.0234760903,
0.0157658104,
0.0042383177,
0.0123210242,
0.0187312104,
-0.02444591,
-0.0198925901,
-0.0191019215,
0.0195016321,
-0.0507690646,
0.0589354597,
0.0268246513,
0.0029800565,
-0.0179338995,
-0.04966015,
-0.0442791693,
0.000718066,
-0.0568810552,
-0.0187063031,
-0.0039847596,
-0.0471426621,
0.0207154751,
-0.0046364274,
0.0145004075,
-0.0141369263,
-0.0128001999,
-0.0118599068,
0.0453454033,
-0.0109236613,
0.0016527269,
-0.0321682729,
-0.0129580917,
-0.0322721824,
-0.0228099264,
-0.0372635201,
-0.0101033291,
0.0167195089,
-0.0014618188,
-0.0248001907,
-0.0011476267,
-0.0372742042,
-0.002078607,
0.0258716252,
0.0612579994,
-0.0348726287,
-0.0013163043,
-0.0132028861,
-0.0169622898,
-0.0011361318,
0.0136799058,
0.0399873666,
-0.012195779,
0.0322780199,
0.0206334479,
0.0172933713,
-0.0572430007,
-0.0617219545,
-0.0338481665,
-0.0391280949,
-0.03308798,
0.0176429674,
-0.0470782667,
0.021923421,
-0.0406846479,
0.0331132263,
-0.0111227687,
0.0116025768,
0.0154027874,
-0.0117842043,
0.0569144227,
0.0000816626,
-0.0269441437,
0.0272493139,
0.0395321883,
0.0426225886,
0.0410380736,
0.0640588626,
0.0837040767,
0.0605453439,
-0.019491436,
0.0227651317,
0.0195792839,
-0.0334697701,
0.0073233359,
0.010686378,
-0.0221045353,
-0.046812892,
0.0368966237,
-0.0172768757,
0.0117339687,
-0.0113720819,
-0.0220110323,
0.0334243998,
0.0548096001,
0.0127672404,
0.0343427025,
0.0465446413,
0.0021387725,
-0.0528458357,
0.0101850657,
-0.0086800735,
0.0116850315,
-0.0006820302,
-0.01294911,
-0.0177780855,
-0.0012858999,
-0.0109816324,
0.0107047157,
-0.026715409,
-0.0295383744,
-0.0292964056,
-0.0295859855,
0.0355903171,
0.0248229988,
-0.0557252578,
0.0109282434,
-0.0083135832,
-0.061543826,
0.0345112942,
-0.0066433218,
0.0199791305,
0.0829478726,
0.0451287515,
-0.0221027751,
-0.0229498874,
-0.0799941644,
0.0396221988,
0.0474604815,
-0.0303554982,
-0.0013688027,
0.0159439519,
-0.0447101593,
-0.005559749,
-0.0048510516,
0.0030997009,
0.0354133286,
-0.0281798802,
-0.0196972769,
0.0005903102,
0.0113321813,
-0.0327985808,
0.0494495034,
-0.0549386032,
-0.0494776331,
-0.0434450023,
0.025551768,
0.0142484698,
0.0016658286,
-0.0350142866,
-0.0336823352,
0.0415001884,
-0.0834963769,
-0.0458434336,
-0.0112531008,
-0.0075031375,
-0.0094376123,
0.0282593649,
-0.0679316372,
0.0158528332,
0.0374736115,
-0.0427566916,
-0.0293029603,
-0.006792122,
-0.0226724818,
-0.0393828079,
-0.023660291,
0.0035025014,
-0.0108403033,
0.0056555872,
-0.0259282235,
0.0267765764,
-0.0286530405,
0.0228928104,
-0.0502587743,
-0.0135251069,
0.0236956086,
0.0144080408,
-0.074238576,
0.0328669809,
0.0132226078,
-0.0140416799,
0.0539239608,
-0.0009641259,
0.0066602686,
-0.0381377861,
-0.0559198856,
0.0172789209,
-0.0243270416,
-0.0135515165,
0.0217742603,
-0.0008486013,
-0.0191875808,
-0.0116105173,
-0.0462301746,
-0.039136976,
-0.0070320051,
0.0370305367,
0.0122520644,
-0.0259584244,
-0.0230755955,
-0.0276212674,
-0.0101285409,
-0.0408066288,
0.0556877181,
0.0351523757,
-0.0261818338,
-0.0254348814,
-0.0242881849,
0.0057452191,
0.0002437316,
-0.0187539719,
-0.0334025584,
-0.0171018392,
-0.0066155368,
0.0325624235,
0.0233303607,
0.0541891903,
0.062297605,
0.0235913508,
-0.0085231923,
0.0120568201,
0.0008065983,
-0.0181889795,
-0.0282931514,
-0.0269269124,
-0.0090243677,
0.0383979939,
0.0813725144,
0.0057635172,
0.0159214642,
-0.0576092452,
-0.0350915268,
0.0065774349,
0.0319596902,
-0.0153858699,
-0.0800121948,
-0.03450666,
0.0196982622,
-0.0102431271,
-0.0544841066,
0.0731446818,
-0.0152317118,
-0.0008928418,
-0.0582725368,
-0.0052894601,
-0.0381918103,
0.0664759278,
0.0266198274,
0.0327934176,
0.0196832512,
-0.0228900835,
0.0003131291,
0.0027210407,
0.0056966795,
-0.0337408073,
0.0430299565,
0.011496366,
-0.0081636338,
0.0033259594,
-0.0237832312,
-0.0252816379,
-0.0589244217,
-0.0450985245,
-0.0625256002,
-0.0210767202,
-0.0194664877,
0.0061636125,
0.003236918,
0.0008792733,
0.0361974984,
-0.0095718456,
-0.0242150836,
0.0192180146,
0.0545753427,
0.0824577808,
-0.0475407429,
-0.0060203411,
-0.026309533,
0.0065550893,
0.0683093742,
0.0113804201,
0.0368688479,
-0.034946043,
0.0191170014,
0.0401550047,
-0.0500828251,
-0.0026206733,
-0.0216227695,
-0.0220456161,
-0.1006365269,
-0.0117771784,
0.1131672487,
0.013095797,
-0.025838159,
0.0115897292,
0.041970741,
0.0135119399,
0.017298609,
-0.0257888306,
-0.0924199447,
-0.0270137433,
-0.0170557685,
0.0046805642,
-0.002064802,
-0.0282545481,
-0.0097155403,
-0.0424297377,
0.0137561839,
0.0107637728,
-0.0216307212,
-0.0445847921,
-0.0120745096,
0.0070784274,
0.0297440086,
-0.0195838008,
-0.0249300431,
-0.0143449213,
-0.0355982184,
-0.0370835029,
-0.0258720126,
-0.037276689,
0.0320878141,
-0.0542529225,
0.0143168243,
0.044462204,
0.0801843479,
-0.018426938,
-0.0180533174,
0.009816465,
-0.0017185644,
-0.0011674296,
0.0106841922,
0.0283795651,
-0.0323649049,
0.0087003559,
-0.0007892768,
0.0743483528,
-0.0533921905,
-0.0138688404,
0.0032484008,
0.0719383284,
-0.0110640414,
-0.0695264041,
-0.0382332355,
0.0407392159,
0.0279321875,
0.0598701313,
0.0487852842,
-0.0718500093,
-0.0292852968,
-0.0137159536,
0.0174534544,
-0.026399143,
-0.0442428179,
-0.0328470767,
-0.0226181857,
-0.0658419207,
-0.0754360259,
-0.0453499407,
0.0130786281,
0.0143410666,
-0.00071195,
-0.025928719,
-0.0255095474,
-0.0042113191,
-0.0188453663,
0.0291693788,
0.0007579373,
0.0287393034,
-0.0415880866,
0.0753697306,
0.0518382154,
0.0080281589,
-0.0215881001,
0.0524004884,
-0.1199083701,
-0.0311961994,
0.0406623967,
-0.0114308475,
0.0116303777,
-0.0158388261,
-0.0047808443,
-0.0644529462,
0.0740181431,
0.0492454506,
-0.0434863046,
-0.0036121979,
0.0112737119,
-0.0124240434,
-0.0191694945,
0.0219991058,
-0.0169282947,
0.0558450967,
-0.0037009532,
0.0024412679,
-0.0044076857,
-0.0368590467,
-0.0225146804,
0.0006545117,
0.0634488016,
-0.0586023778,
-0.0364829414,
-0.0491956547,
-0.0096212951,
0.0328277275,
-0.0038897078,
-0.0155557608,
0.0096096359,
0.0478234179,
-0.0198881403,
-0.0580302849,
-0.0295533389,
0.0121095711,
0.0093594175,
-0.0370593444,
0.0423151888,
0.0230575185,
0.028263757,
0.0188713837,
0.0188745968,
-0.0330432169,
0.0407951623,
-0.0208501462,
0.0095779803,
-0.0025980135,
0.0331960246,
0.0305992942,
0.0167647116,
0.0122773228,
0.0477057174,
-0.0600036494,
0.0401245244,
-0.0042957766,
-0.0733399913,
0.0735360831,
-0.035025768,
0.0534540378,
-0.0280701406,
-0.0001163185,
-0.0020652914,
0.0261886939,
-0.0060651843,
-0.0207144283,
-0.0007210737,
0.0242076367,
-0.0198871605,
0.0322967768,
0.0713297203,
-0.0239070076,
0.0289749932,
0.0945147425,
-0.0252191313,
-0.0212290902,
-0.0007455397,
-0.0379494503,
0.0499892421,
0.0093511073,
0.0170538966,
-0.0465268977,
-0.0116376551,
0.0876183212,
-0.0306129269,
-0.0127134621,
-0.002975831,
0.0370571837,
0.018343702,
0.0321916528,
0.0307014156,
-0.002061059,
0.0134333614,
0.0256711505,
-0.0523520857,
-0.0129115311,
-5.490981334e-33,
-0.0012706317,
-0.0124657555,
-0.0469639339,
0.0803580359,
-0.0564813577,
0.0062698652,
-0.0055022906,
-0.0189111605,
0.0197331365,
0.0348595791,
0.0308756214,
0.0436496586,
-0.0074763261,
0.0126888007,
0.0053775017,
-0.059161067,
0.064189218,
0.0143286875,
-0.0350954346,
0.0331930704,
0.0838724747,
0.0552556217,
0.0693215802,
-0.0772837847,
-0.0086870799,
-0.0355313905,
-0.0296123903,
0.0025297001,
0.0586740598,
0.0516913719,
-0.019470308,
0.0760272816,
0.0422442518,
-0.0108945789,
0.0152857108,
0.0466335602,
-0.0680660754,
-0.0336410478,
-0.0186905749,
-0.0030616284,
0.0091445986,
-0.027331179,
0.0354492702,
0.0091697667,
0.0388734266,
-0.0818418339,
0.0470845141,
-0.0268204343,
0.0115954001,
-0.0768525004,
-0.0577771217,
0.0048890365,
0.0049964557,
-0.0133736758,
0.0145919984,
0.0441631451,
0.0180857126,
0.0641431138,
-0.1145980135,
-0.0071558836,
-0.0155323958,
0.042022679,
-0.0162618402,
-0.0015622132,
-0.0301774386,
0.0665627867,
-0.0164030381,
0.0245488361,
-0.0455757268,
0.0447966605,
0.0180218611,
0.0114903282,
0.0471651517,
0.0566086844,
0.0794550553,
0.0052918647,
-0.0620946661,
0.033073552,
0.01416134,
0.0661941245,
0.0426733643,
0.0008142702,
-0.0296817236,
-0.0200221241,
-0.0184530187,
0.006167565,
-0.0125118755,
-0.0354606695,
-0.0019072861,
-0.0019584238,
0.017365858,
0.0261410661,
0.0022894263,
-0.0260981638,
0.0207162295,
0.0483765453,
0.0030856263,
0.0256087743,
-0.0056434902,
0.03967591,
-0.0032170962,
0.0343947522,
0.0204804614,
-0.0226068776,
0.0362868682,
-0.0156874694,
0.0555991791,
0.0558259599,
-0.1076430753,
-0.0149949687,
0.0057489653,
-0.0087892981,
0.00180214,
0.0802067518,
0.014373255,
0.004870526,
0.005508096,
0.0572043024,
0.0062574083,
0.0284015555,
-0.0069836723,
-0.0040904414,
-0.0165076163,
0.0082625113,
0.002738717,
-0.022417888,
-0.001791556,
0.0286629628,
0.0259528793,
-0.1087812036,
0.002032009,
-0.0293230843,
2.654e-7,
-0.0032191535,
0.0147641841,
0.0434868485,
0.0019348603,
0.0021467314,
0.0339860879,
0.0293694437,
0.0524349958,
0.0113391159,
0.0016275164,
-0.0081238262,
-0.016284978,
0.0605386235,
0.0368258804,
-0.0936327651,
0.001339822,
-0.08530166,
0.0251931883,
-0.0554241277,
-0.0232603122,
0.0595747493,
0.0507050827,
0.0708397403,
-0.0443895832,
0.0439813808,
-0.0331668966,
0.0384813771,
-0.0493885688,
-0.0053387992,
0.0246065557,
0.0172948539,
0.0472547337,
-0.0124168685,
-0.0058476767,
-0.0501242429,
0.0203624777,
-0.0094792834,
0.0365754999,
-0.0110631511,
0.0068363906,
0.0446869284,
-0.0015623408,
-0.0282315519,
-0.0340520814,
0.052850876,
-0.0383814164,
-0.0173753258,
-0.0192748532,
-0.0025144091,
-0.0461209826,
0.0292601772,
-0.0520328097,
-0.0430868007,
0.0240890197,
0.0514190085,
0.0180881191,
0.0120591605,
-0.1032908931,
0.0152399149,
0.0584496595,
-0.0315544382,
0.0345102921,
-0.0422822349,
-0.0272960588,
-0.0101990085,
-0.0473164581,
0.0030996003,
2.66297753e-34,
0.0070740548,
-0.0302380845,
-0.0334236883,
0.0097045107,
0.0223778747,
0.0121241203,
0.0096998932,
-0.0041029113,
0.0237546172,
-0.062840119,
0.0094120586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14899v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14899v2 | Retrieval-based Text Selection for Addressing Class-Imbalanced Data in Classification | 2023-07-27T14:42:16 | 2023-11-09T19:39:23 | Sareh Ahmadi, Aditya Shah, Edward Fox | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper addresses the problem of selecting of a set of texts for
annotation in text classification using retrieval methods when there are limits
on the number of annotations due to constraints on human resources. An
additional challenge addressed is dealing with binary categories that have a
small number of positive instances, reflecting severe class imbalance. In our
situation, where annotation occurs over a long time period, the selection of
texts to be annotated can be made in batches, with previous annotations guiding
the choice of the next set. To address these challenges, the paper proposes
leveraging SHAP to construct a quality set of queries for Elasticsearch and
semantic search, to try to identify optimal sets of texts for annotation that
will help with class imbalance. The approach is tested on sets of cue texts
describing possible future events, constructed by participants involved in
studies aimed to help with the management of obesity and diabetes. We introduce
an effective method for selecting a small set of texts for annotation and
building high-quality classifiers. We integrate vector search, semantic search,
and machine learning classifiers to yield a good solution. Our experiments
demonstrate improved F1 scores for the minority classes in binary
classification. | [
0.047556676,
0.0312057287,
-0.0135890534,
-0.0677461997,
-0.0139996065,
-0.0093104597,
-0.0075564412,
0.0451666377,
-0.0076096747,
-0.092560485,
0.0769983903,
0.0150264036,
-0.0274107493,
-0.003269294,
-0.0411146842,
-0.0452989899,
0.024273403,
0.0619730577,
0.0073263329,
-0.007764616,
0.011948063,
0.0246482026,
-0.0076747234,
0.0314840749,
-0.0175142735,
0.0291536655,
0.0296645556,
0.0191017725,
0.0119250081,
-0.0231089871,
0.0592490733,
0.0481320135,
-0.0370247103,
-0.011860162,
0.0000018529,
-0.0514556468,
-0.0597475879,
0.0467107482,
-0.0379897542,
-0.0419242978,
0.0432102717,
-0.0039749006,
0.0464721248,
0.0241572913,
0.0105992835,
0.0192143172,
0.0488427654,
0.0717397258,
0.0404920802,
0.0105266981,
-0.0070803263,
-0.0127136419,
-0.0206440799,
0.013557503,
0.0717676207,
0.0063378224,
0.0421012342,
-0.0591244325,
0.0057404125,
0.0126292538,
0.0130350376,
0.0128266905,
-0.0160189252,
0.0154230874,
0.0735707283,
0.0469834954,
-0.0951595902,
-0.0075864624,
-0.0092415325,
0.0340284072,
0.0120630395,
-0.0081150504,
0.0117629888,
-0.0274570771,
0.0020135639,
0.0164247155,
0.0087996777,
0.0030785955,
-0.004643078,
0.0448647067,
-0.0111906491,
0.0381696448,
0.0135916406,
0.0266197976,
0.0233367067,
-0.0261017438,
0.0122231813,
-0.0500622801,
0.0148422746,
0.0296251383,
-0.0040319772,
0.0088209007,
0.0263024326,
0.0184492487,
-0.0072784866,
0.0104032643,
0.0235622041,
-0.0443732254,
0.0988708586,
-0.0490797088,
-0.0119985528,
0.027507076,
0.0024827332,
0.0226068869,
0.0321025178,
-0.0261118766,
0.0662725866,
0.0073010516,
-0.0295284707,
0.0022172711,
-0.0625126511,
0.0079518585,
-0.0371206291,
0.0170642976,
0.0146153672,
0.0320333838,
-0.0822764561,
-0.045453243,
-0.0013147255,
-0.0228731669,
-0.0047591478,
0.0359614938,
-0.050950937,
0.0666141808,
-0.0449100025,
-0.0121920761,
0.0040092594,
0.0005916192,
-0.0352604464,
-0.0310632866,
0.0361230783,
0.0206505563,
-0.0137981083,
-0.0458578393,
0.0363962501,
-0.0173083898,
0.0303221699,
-0.0568040833,
-0.0533874072,
-0.0057597319,
0.0066110338,
0.0237860214,
-0.0039583989,
-0.0363627896,
-0.0069590034,
-0.0108760111,
0.005479096,
0.0328843817,
0.0051926589,
0.0355807766,
-0.024613671,
0.0121514127,
-0.0040108357,
0.0158468876,
0.0707753226,
-0.0022542411,
-0.0127615724,
0.0522946678,
0.0036070345,
-0.0305064842,
0.0624938756,
0.0058228285,
-0.0111045828,
-0.0106213596,
0.0194872729,
0.0025870402,
0.0220277626,
0.0029130829,
-0.0349573344,
0.0286922231,
-0.0317378156,
0.0240412708,
-0.0027747052,
-0.030536551,
-0.0066581406,
0.0546850748,
0.0238502789,
0.0245986953,
-0.0416415557,
0.0160195343,
-0.04858955,
-0.0452381149,
0.0126176002,
-0.0034446437,
-0.0100028068,
-0.0403743014,
0.0375112072,
-0.0212643743,
-0.0289727151,
-0.0345252417,
-0.0343007408,
0.0286286436,
0.0010600034,
-0.0004547999,
0.0553194769,
-0.0022599807,
0.0156129692,
0.0606799312,
0.0172143076,
-0.0020801357,
0.011880747,
-0.0156749375,
-0.0253423415,
0.0269032735,
0.0483350083,
-0.0847420692,
0.0182858091,
-0.0338022225,
-0.0249917116,
0.0077667339,
0.0250469018,
0.0100329313,
-0.0012353976,
-0.034138713,
-0.0242803674,
0.0600165017,
0.0106867785,
-0.0537631698,
-0.0258483943,
0.0446620993,
-0.0100733414,
-0.0331886783,
-0.0879233479,
0.081690304,
0.0194963925,
-0.0185558032,
0.0465086736,
0.0072826636,
0.0294511132,
0.0057217595,
-0.0100712907,
0.0115954252,
0.0156883616,
-0.0215478465,
-0.0682788119,
-0.044988025,
0.0417914577,
0.018759599,
-0.0008450166,
-0.0474113673,
-0.0080450233,
-0.0121884011,
-0.0301579535,
-0.0254781656,
-0.0272631347,
-0.0464709327,
-0.0053000748,
-0.038994059,
-0.0184168965,
-0.012175804,
-0.0250452682,
-0.0870738998,
0.0258264355,
0.0163250994,
0.0439611077,
-0.0558832549,
-0.0971848592,
0.0413307659,
-0.047360681,
-0.0187669042,
-0.0061534788,
0.0036730021,
0.0301130228,
0.0671938881,
-0.006914366,
-0.0185487699,
0.0075508123,
-0.0764480233,
0.0038452439,
-0.0235601533,
-0.0099197747,
-0.0248191897,
-0.0005882708,
-0.0012541527,
-0.044988852,
-0.0239517093,
-0.0336076953,
0.007060315,
0.0464069918,
0.0177481957,
0.0223184377,
0.0685659796,
0.0254628584,
-0.030543495,
-0.0224854555,
0.0575083829,
0.066719301,
0.0024921363,
0.0104277795,
0.0294619072,
-0.0355758518,
-0.0103993388,
0.0218841303,
0.0281335153,
-0.0186859202,
0.0025603119,
-0.0458436646,
-0.0039775767,
0.0257589407,
0.0227162614,
0.0515548959,
0.0322364531,
-0.0236008335,
0.0061132768,
-0.0694794953,
0.0271340646,
0.012987894,
-0.056303557,
0.032845147,
-0.0245768167,
-0.0107120471,
-0.0086378241,
-0.0574624948,
-0.0235599503,
-0.0182691999,
0.012662285,
-0.1166056171,
0.0220472701,
0.0203434378,
0.0414152145,
-0.0153606981,
-0.0180588439,
0.072121121,
0.0409929231,
0.0383489318,
-0.0828848109,
0.0085486267,
-0.0287450664,
-0.0149206677,
-0.0173576567,
0.03264869,
-0.0244209338,
0.0277785007,
0.0001311001,
-0.0243821703,
0.0354194827,
-0.0403288081,
0.006089393,
0.0139919315,
0.02062965,
-0.0046302895,
-0.0667720661,
-0.048216626,
-0.0621279739,
0.0126979668,
0.0134986024,
-0.028849544,
0.0302066468,
-0.116065532,
0.0214957576,
-0.0391764529,
0.0059679681,
-0.0025311417,
-0.0537238158,
0.0483486839,
-0.0238981582,
0.0219857544,
-0.0230384693,
-0.0124977399,
-0.0191493165,
-0.0097970031,
0.0464728624,
0.0354594216,
0.0020795346,
0.0251419675,
0.0095323296,
0.0188217163,
-0.1033467427,
-0.0124474466,
-0.0290060006,
-0.0146730999,
-0.0283134915,
0.0018705223,
0.0626844093,
0.0223227832,
-0.0698882639,
0.0177840739,
-0.0301937778,
0.0146228885,
0.0249891207,
0.0568662882,
-0.0621195883,
-0.0078898882,
0.004873523,
0.0661529899,
-0.0821122602,
-0.0453065857,
0.0108304257,
-0.0784755647,
0.0230454654,
-0.0009844094,
-0.0254431441,
-0.0209706444,
-0.066514127,
0.0108167911,
-0.0513383485,
-0.0266614761,
-0.0277354829,
-0.0119046783,
0.0239031818,
0.0377144217,
-0.0310435072,
-0.04910383,
0.0142575279,
-0.0207628086,
-0.0025634046,
0.0146717131,
0.058533635,
-0.0168430787,
-0.0044586509,
-0.0139900725,
-0.0628463849,
0.0181178935,
-0.0288253911,
0.0987319648,
-0.0487659983,
0.0092385327,
-0.0310807936,
-0.0045128772,
0.0056873607,
-0.0211212356,
0.0390460491,
0.0659954399,
-0.0422778428,
0.0059463913,
-0.0812922418,
-0.0353500247,
0.0342059955,
0.0491569825,
-0.0328632481,
-0.02497462,
-0.0304961875,
-0.0184280816,
0.0336745754,
0.0272121262,
0.0486928709,
0.0920608938,
-0.0554909483,
-0.0334714688,
0.0040637916,
-0.0321863703,
0.0179262757,
0.0227363817,
0.016660437,
0.0213186052,
-0.0061290786,
0.0162068512,
-0.0222946517,
0.0117704393,
0.0153783085,
0.0379173346,
0.0119170379,
-0.0075265234,
0.0132067967,
-0.0472529605,
-0.035649959,
-0.0701982453,
0.0416840576,
-0.0215758197,
0.0139639257,
0.0249030069,
0.0227983072,
0.014577847,
0.0040679076,
-0.0912485272,
0.0817536041,
0.0976991802,
-0.0256464593,
-0.024472991,
-0.0314272717,
-0.0338685103,
-0.0334460624,
-0.0081580263,
-0.0572507717,
0.0357320346,
0.0139499484,
0.0208258312,
-0.0434005,
0.0107614566,
0.0029228849,
0.04099622,
0.0542622767,
-0.0183022749,
-0.0198990311,
-0.0417439304,
0.0193871818,
0.061247468,
-0.0046385541,
0.0134998243,
0.0323220827,
-0.0242070463,
0.0140412953,
-0.0399044417,
0.0188206267,
-0.0333402306,
0.010761898,
-0.0299303476,
0.0306102633,
0.0236203875,
0.0470650978,
0.0175401457,
0.0099111274,
-0.0080634188,
-0.0090272306,
0.0107194586,
0.0477214791,
0.0133744637,
-0.0000527536,
0.0505627319,
0.0442436375,
-0.0397066064,
-0.0514758043,
-0.0538478419,
0.0356978215,
0.0153644383,
-0.032930702,
0.0284180623,
-0.0239745136,
-0.0004741218,
-0.0317946374,
-0.0192895588,
-0.035685353,
0.0109752119,
0.0215574391,
-0.0016807821,
0.0186668299,
-0.0073357034,
-0.0328044258,
0.0306734219,
0.0137374289,
0.0075195441,
0.0426055938,
-0.0367459431,
-0.0597322322,
-0.0288355034,
0.0061416882,
0.0774932951,
0.0209688749,
-0.024438858,
-0.0146145662,
-0.0716501847,
0.0043508569,
0.0517470948,
-0.029230617,
-0.0023601635,
-0.0124756126,
0.0342040919,
0.0405141599,
0.0175246559,
-0.0044083484,
-0.0588775091,
-0.0230277851,
-0.1131407022,
0.0174775459,
-0.022182418,
-5.793876106e-33,
0.034073811,
-0.0518195219,
-0.014005051,
0.0056831213,
0.0159905683,
0.0164443385,
0.0182811245,
-0.036706131,
0.0225014891,
0.0199545268,
-0.00674746,
-0.0094412388,
-0.0038833087,
0.0257928129,
0.0184633695,
-0.0102066314,
0.0476951338,
0.0090968497,
-0.0336268842,
0.0173749663,
0.0248834584,
0.0621160939,
0.01444594,
-0.0556013025,
0.0102222068,
0.0278189462,
0.0161592588,
0.0490465127,
-0.0062889438,
0.030624358,
0.0009018732,
0.128010571,
0.035534583,
0.003961463,
0.0407863371,
-0.0184181426,
-0.0260355677,
-0.0670366585,
-0.0397648066,
-0.010901846,
0.0165637098,
0.0108824745,
0.0370971821,
0.0316061676,
-0.0397986397,
0.0017616048,
0.0822909549,
-0.0002879926,
-0.0481306836,
-0.0682993829,
0.0253863391,
0.0353833623,
-0.0349904001,
0.0387266502,
-0.0425859354,
0.0385867804,
0.0015690733,
0.0446949154,
-0.0381975472,
0.0134225516,
-0.0262994952,
-0.0327375717,
-0.0414337777,
0.0174097996,
0.0005158158,
0.0819953084,
-0.0009371742,
0.0170232095,
0.0424443968,
-0.0377592333,
0.0048752888,
-0.0168348365,
0.0404062457,
0.0605323985,
0.0906897411,
-0.0317301527,
-0.0632146671,
0.040641088,
0.0168183986,
0.022441972,
0.0300620981,
-0.0096636172,
-0.0724831223,
-0.0441735499,
-0.0459016934,
-0.0296753813,
-0.0144293644,
-0.0113087874,
0.0000682248,
0.0343130976,
-0.0366903283,
0.0630332679,
0.005608785,
0.0160860755,
-0.0502921641,
-0.0040556574,
0.0073062982,
-0.0428920388,
-0.0133396955,
-0.0174404215,
-0.0493974872,
-0.022701202,
0.0386678465,
-0.0190489963,
0.0007818251,
-0.041714251,
0.040591985,
0.0027189692,
-0.0241132826,
-0.0128093204,
0.0452366136,
0.0187157448,
-0.0102186324,
0.0127812568,
-0.0064608804,
0.0444221199,
0.0392888486,
0.0590291657,
0.0131841069,
0.0279648434,
-0.0170989931,
-0.0520104505,
0.007724802,
-0.0161951315,
-0.0016912377,
0.0059383358,
0.0117514916,
0.0165756941,
0.0199733097,
-0.0814380944,
0.0116536133,
-0.0287364051,
2.654e-7,
0.0894027129,
0.0411548093,
-0.0193648264,
-0.0574029684,
0.0118067376,
0.0259874705,
0.0285091549,
0.0398134291,
-0.0082496824,
0.0415229872,
0.0446476042,
-0.0047503361,
0.0205528475,
0.0420752689,
-0.0552306995,
-0.052055981,
-0.0867460147,
-0.0280780755,
-0.039943669,
0.0294564757,
0.0720577911,
0.0507283993,
0.0187942144,
-0.0313131958,
0.0087519139,
-0.0356484018,
0.0215999708,
-0.0093965353,
0.0170803796,
0.0142648164,
0.0360285752,
0.0254262108,
0.0220583826,
0.032343775,
-0.0303331316,
0.0046518371,
-0.0008571064,
-0.005653827,
-0.0639612898,
0.002007026,
0.0070380201,
0.0489718281,
0.0043403879,
-0.0128706964,
0.0363691822,
-0.0344020464,
-0.0261554755,
-0.0105548585,
-0.0170238335,
-0.0212495532,
0.0791410878,
-0.0003579533,
-0.0527708866,
0.0377142616,
0.0060452549,
0.0087031089,
-0.008730039,
-0.0570041798,
0.0250851307,
0.0156471618,
-0.0198381133,
-0.0142783225,
0.0059544034,
0.0604747459,
-0.0136213275,
-0.0547686592,
0.0152666457,
2.352445442e-34,
0.0388484262,
0.0114700198,
-0.0388559662,
-0.0106663369,
-0.0315853804,
0.0231216494,
0.0069719269,
0.003489831,
0.004144676,
-0.0284109116,
-0.0059883106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14878v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14878v1 | MESED: A Multi-modal Entity Set Expansion Dataset with Fine-grained Semantic Classes and Hard Negative Entities | 2023-07-27T14:09:59 | 2023-07-27T14:09:59 | Yangning Li, Tingwei Lu, Yinghui Li, Tianyu Yu, Shulin Huang, Hai-Tao Zheng, Rui Zhang, Jun Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Entity Set Expansion (ESE) task aims to expand a handful of seed entities
with new entities belonging to the same semantic class. Conventional ESE
methods are based on mono-modality (i.e., literal modality), which struggle to
deal with complex entities in the real world such as: (1) Negative entities
with fine-grained semantic differences. (2) Synonymous entities. (3) Polysemous
entities. (4) Long-tailed entities. These challenges prompt us to propose
Multi-modal Entity Set Expansion (MESE), where models integrate information
from multiple modalities to represent entities. Intuitively, the benefits of
multi-modal information for ESE are threefold: (1) Different modalities can
provide complementary information. (2) Multi-modal information provides a
unified signal via common visual properties for the same semantic class or
entity. (3) Multi-modal information offers robust alignment signal for
synonymous entities. To assess the performance of model in MESE and facilitate
further research, we constructed the MESED dataset which is the first
multi-modal dataset for ESE with large-scale and elaborate manual calibration.
A powerful multi-modal model MultiExpan is proposed which is pre-trained on
four multimodal pre-training tasks. The extensive experiments and analyses on
MESED demonstrate the high quality of the dataset and the effectiveness of our
MultiExpan, as well as pointing the direction for future research. | [
-0.0356902033,
0.0724631175,
-0.0023127748,
0.0180345364,
0.0066629644,
0.0332419276,
-0.0033668608,
-0.0070119086,
-0.086086534,
-0.0344352052,
-0.020888133,
-0.0335320383,
-0.0168145932,
0.0257927198,
0.0398343541,
-0.0623640232,
0.055349201,
0.0422652625,
-0.0534511432,
-0.0112679889,
0.0247376636,
-0.0001181115,
-0.0212772563,
0.031746611,
-0.0494768433,
0.011634158,
-0.0582043752,
0.034150891,
0.0586149767,
-0.0468252264,
-0.037884362,
0.0374612957,
0.0505438447,
0.0136114992,
0.0000020748,
-0.0550837889,
-0.0410598591,
0.0018249152,
-0.0283135362,
-0.029537864,
0.011072482,
-0.0337322764,
0.0083126258,
-0.0336194597,
0.0099771526,
-0.0408909097,
0.0868853107,
0.0383822061,
0.0474066809,
0.0563833341,
-0.027756365,
-0.0499700159,
0.0423948914,
-0.0120349126,
0.0318628028,
-0.0331440382,
0.0380857885,
-0.01914699,
-0.0394619405,
0.0378279947,
-0.0283389185,
-0.0121583492,
0.0120248813,
0.0297233965,
-0.0095699327,
0.0234051999,
0.0283385459,
-0.0174219031,
-0.0051575052,
0.0917001367,
0.0187310837,
0.0052084439,
-0.0028098505,
-0.0369715132,
-0.0153136374,
0.0068386258,
-0.0055976096,
-0.0204433817,
-0.0008728321,
0.0294871479,
-0.0336750075,
-0.0179542638,
0.0253825504,
0.0005373447,
-0.0116004916,
-0.0402592123,
0.035956122,
-0.0130177429,
-0.012376098,
-0.0011583853,
-0.0261711851,
-0.0276536979,
-0.0079359654,
0.0199286044,
-0.0082078101,
0.0175902862,
-0.0645497367,
-0.0426030792,
0.0233209506,
0.033910282,
0.0183517542,
0.03431971,
-0.0487038344,
0.0388206914,
-0.020841321,
-0.0302199535,
-0.0267717913,
0.0347356088,
-0.0138811748,
-0.0470491275,
-0.0498466305,
0.0126120588,
-0.0153453397,
0.01405642,
-0.0047038575,
0.0002938797,
-0.0488173403,
-0.0290050376,
-0.0120673208,
0.0026100047,
0.0086457124,
-0.0073354193,
-0.0350776762,
-0.0064066541,
-0.039621383,
0.0563621484,
-0.0939519629,
0.0534417555,
-0.0045399526,
-0.023962317,
0.0088745644,
-0.0117628751,
0.0351234376,
-0.0086733531,
0.0092020417,
0.0583748408,
0.0008243435,
-0.0613058433,
-0.0654557124,
-0.0281327069,
-0.0121990358,
-0.0391445197,
-0.0120435227,
-0.0537687466,
0.0448165759,
-0.001635171,
-0.0002519904,
-0.0330949314,
0.002196396,
-0.0484852865,
-0.0009222226,
0.0908240005,
-0.0772887245,
0.0388860554,
-0.007542023,
-0.0160900764,
0.0084841494,
0.0873246267,
0.0289738365,
-0.0366628766,
0.0360013135,
-0.021593459,
-0.0272894055,
0.024925191,
0.0328843519,
0.0141700609,
-0.0206139721,
-0.0226412676,
-0.03830266,
0.0411650538,
0.0004350408,
-0.0233142711,
-0.0424802005,
-0.0583979823,
0.0187234115,
-0.0294534899,
0.0124526741,
0.0206260942,
0.009513123,
-0.0286490303,
-0.0133538246,
-0.0240354743,
-0.0293790549,
0.011871676,
-0.0253588799,
-0.0062132808,
-0.0115392888,
0.0514958538,
-0.0312676281,
0.0200366434,
0.0266562589,
-0.0337955542,
0.0255640261,
-0.0476580523,
0.066612415,
-0.0189071409,
-0.0082265604,
0.0804050937,
0.0839787796,
-0.0566937029,
0.0018280306,
-0.0152643062,
0.0138932383,
0.033138562,
-0.0115678003,
-0.0205043033,
-0.0676651448,
-0.0007478551,
-0.0125907967,
0.0301473588,
0.0071090963,
-0.0044966768,
0.04458303,
-0.0619207062,
-0.0827609301,
0.0118669234,
-0.0058439374,
0.0476422943,
0.0179634672,
0.0205727816,
0.0187523197,
-0.0413597673,
0.0553588867,
0.0424745791,
0.0252600648,
0.0580882169,
-0.0161312819,
0.0343212113,
0.0033442716,
0.0358839892,
-0.0017569755,
-0.0452490039,
0.0255001932,
-0.0149364658,
-0.0001433875,
0.0073296595,
-0.0195872039,
0.0021355108,
0.03746856,
-0.035615772,
-0.0109372893,
0.0128977457,
-0.017590655,
-0.073266305,
-0.0009481481,
-0.0066925604,
-0.0065249885,
-0.0140460888,
0.0072768806,
-0.0119738486,
0.0281690918,
-0.0103705777,
0.0757858902,
-0.016901765,
0.0000238612,
-0.0011186914,
0.0200463869,
0.0165215041,
-0.0089854943,
-0.0377153531,
0.0125772543,
0.0209423658,
-0.0226840526,
0.0131164063,
-0.0362803824,
-0.0596337207,
0.0057998202,
-0.1183188632,
-0.0007105922,
0.0087807765,
0.0147913415,
0.0351723582,
0.0048028207,
-0.0215374567,
-0.0182828438,
-0.0263923556,
0.0778752938,
-0.0120175164,
0.0028163721,
0.0108800745,
-0.0003406346,
-0.0171031617,
0.0238755345,
0.0098613668,
-0.0357050486,
0.0161357634,
-0.0060886522,
-0.0177556146,
-0.03999855,
0.0223286003,
-0.0508665703,
0.0230052043,
-0.0001168496,
-0.0236213468,
0.0180949867,
0.0144458832,
0.0163803119,
0.0048211105,
-0.0002036724,
0.025427809,
0.005121449,
-0.0187961124,
-0.0338959955,
0.0156215113,
-0.0087605119,
0.037716385,
-0.0392678306,
-0.0292720292,
-0.0605999492,
0.0384707861,
-0.002277486,
0.0030980946,
-0.0690837651,
0.0176007804,
0.0394061878,
-0.0439610854,
0.00078664,
0.0365652591,
-0.0117982198,
0.0115136011,
-0.033965636,
-0.0098231081,
0.0467426628,
-0.0292302277,
-0.0180010423,
0.027102096,
0.0365775712,
-0.0183908399,
0.0517209582,
0.0052287052,
0.0322289281,
0.0271165557,
0.0011711655,
-0.0590584502,
-0.0014394199,
0.0232132506,
-0.0103652766,
0.0378367603,
-0.0032259314,
0.0141230561,
-0.0429395959,
-0.0060001225,
-0.0192110725,
-0.0305271316,
0.0189861283,
0.0029525044,
-0.0062456643,
-0.0177988391,
-0.0460797362,
0.0009881746,
0.0115688378,
-0.0031914967,
0.0007522824,
-0.0039643771,
-0.0356880352,
0.0529075116,
0.0344158113,
0.0843521431,
0.0124312155,
-0.0112547148,
-0.0153306415,
0.0239972826,
-0.019442739,
-0.0148922587,
-0.0433602706,
0.0398668386,
-0.008452219,
0.0143137332,
-0.0222067889,
-0.0116707468,
0.0826208591,
-0.0190817527,
0.0380809717,
0.07317359,
0.0113149146,
-0.0136992084,
0.0064512934,
0.035344895,
0.0253926739,
0.0340220593,
-0.0432754457,
-0.0892902762,
-0.0545902885,
-0.0051220166,
-0.0248111766,
-0.0014668651,
-0.0572817996,
0.0193355437,
-0.0937372148,
0.000715923,
0.0073485039,
-0.0801080391,
0.0060360124,
-0.013588802,
0.0515555404,
-0.0270252284,
-0.0245344434,
-0.0168754663,
0.020655781,
-0.0088487053,
0.0275128242,
0.0687732175,
-0.0603799932,
-0.0026957644,
-0.0674537569,
0.0591414422,
0.0027451192,
0.0151298176,
-0.0318595283,
-0.0192305371,
-0.0075295563,
-0.0457677729,
-0.0060995477,
0.0233940464,
0.0592429489,
-0.026091449,
-0.041107703,
0.0092815245,
0.0146912718,
-0.0192530658,
-0.0112646436,
-0.0131927915,
0.0398453772,
0.0040484495,
0.0614254959,
-0.0292226393,
-0.0383967012,
0.0054053543,
0.0473839007,
-0.0005059584,
-0.0370007418,
0.0531737506,
0.0234591346,
0.0231128745,
0.0094845034,
0.0242304448,
0.0348419659,
-0.0323027745,
-0.0394304432,
-0.0487639531,
-0.0612250827,
0.0204431843,
0.0645809248,
0.0266741421,
0.0054903203,
-0.0142479753,
0.0139929382,
-0.0432849638,
0.0476159304,
-0.0012551798,
0.0235517584,
-0.0100966189,
-0.0402422398,
0.0338259675,
-0.0050456724,
-0.0045508766,
-0.0117765712,
-0.0785594881,
-0.0636350289,
-0.0175208244,
0.0023647659,
0.0138277356,
0.0307302196,
0.0067296517,
-0.0591954738,
0.0366611741,
0.035222955,
-0.0364394151,
0.0119359698,
0.0090248212,
0.0208821092,
-0.0122385547,
0.0237939656,
-0.0342801586,
0.0378121287,
0.0061279521,
0.0345519483,
-0.0578753613,
-0.068419449,
0.009719017,
0.0077600586,
0.0329228118,
-0.0261325147,
-0.0017737054,
-0.0526147485,
0.0073288875,
-0.0307572056,
-0.0089828661,
-0.0306979734,
-0.0332920104,
0.013909691,
-0.0006395594,
-0.0019909162,
0.039188806,
0.0374218561,
0.0037233571,
-0.0336737335,
0.0281652845,
0.0124157397,
0.0299038924,
-0.0117204972,
0.023089515,
0.0169192497,
0.0361378342,
-0.0091750203,
-0.0057717399,
-0.0538097359,
0.0954516605,
0.0226027928,
-0.0091036307,
-0.053048268,
0.0397878215,
0.03247324,
0.0371980406,
-0.0361604504,
0.0835067555,
0.0198358633,
0.023930328,
0.0830547065,
0.0166116524,
-0.0143024959,
0.0022443552,
0.0391757451,
-0.0209376458,
0.0127989529,
0.0797917992,
0.0088697569,
-0.0105799856,
-0.0160964373,
0.0362192765,
-0.0409110896,
0.06005105,
-0.0349775851,
0.0382109582,
-0.0372565165,
0.0162565708,
0.0550684445,
-0.0088161379,
-0.0034355349,
0.0128199216,
-0.0315001532,
-0.0340078287,
0.0291684885,
0.0083287675,
-0.0137743382,
0.0596772619,
0.0412462614,
0.0261339284,
-0.0243509319,
-0.0196829066,
-0.006205902,
-0.0336060487,
-0.0034509029,
0.0128577473,
0.0183099918,
-6.116756119e-33,
-0.0611991584,
0.014554034,
0.0001789527,
-0.0502980798,
-0.0199052598,
0.0179153364,
-0.0034487329,
0.0456248596,
-0.0141339302,
-0.0052930103,
0.0334272981,
-0.0040209028,
0.0165583976,
0.0250248089,
-0.0100349188,
-0.0271531641,
0.0488731675,
-0.0067390883,
-0.0074684904,
-0.0018568755,
0.0266933702,
0.0141335158,
0.085120976,
-0.0952478722,
-0.0148610966,
0.0350212976,
-0.0322245546,
0.0046032085,
0.024474673,
0.0587105751,
0.0033941078,
0.0377117023,
0.0146367373,
-0.0168968886,
-0.0190342143,
-0.0300910901,
-0.095254764,
-0.0250951964,
-0.0178611372,
0.0249887723,
-0.0469673835,
-0.0099597573,
0.0540544614,
-0.0090780361,
0.0148457019,
0.0098697208,
0.0606508851,
-0.0394879319,
0.0323750414,
-0.0051286635,
-0.0209951233,
0.0336087272,
0.001912697,
-0.0056349183,
0.0114930896,
-0.0082606012,
0.0471700765,
-0.003086206,
-0.0518603288,
0.0178910512,
0.0137395887,
-0.0598116666,
0.0208107065,
0.0432667211,
0.0161783826,
0.0738181397,
0.0444635525,
-0.0444543548,
-0.0087686479,
0.0108546689,
0.0523168035,
0.0530673489,
-0.0069543524,
0.1366862059,
0.0098490436,
0.0026080459,
-0.0529385582,
0.0641957447,
-0.0230921097,
0.0197157133,
-0.0238238424,
0.0337468348,
-0.0280274767,
0.0235022437,
-0.014656648,
-0.0333347395,
-0.0420044325,
-0.0253223702,
0.025191417,
-0.0128655657,
-0.0561165325,
0.059222497,
0.0513673238,
-0.0178493466,
-0.0479519889,
0.0076389103,
-0.0027130099,
0.0286548454,
-0.0078274738,
-0.0294334032,
-0.0303846486,
-0.0870307907,
0.1039481461,
-0.0203408152,
0.02396583,
-0.0072832825,
0.0409451872,
0.0130392471,
-0.0752383247,
0.0070597865,
0.0060019675,
-0.035046719,
-0.0097481403,
-0.007126241,
0.0551245399,
-0.0259882547,
-0.0220628511,
0.005508773,
0.0667785853,
0.0037159494,
-0.0307457279,
-0.0474777259,
0.0540592559,
0.0512636118,
0.0100939553,
0.0108049223,
-0.0181231163,
-0.1241254807,
0.0643718764,
-0.0681370944,
-0.0053700204,
-0.0028071138,
2.762e-7,
0.0342849903,
0.00583188,
0.0378358476,
-0.027157113,
0.0223998707,
0.0600931384,
-0.0317086764,
0.0474094488,
-0.0342350341,
-0.0808612406,
0.025445519,
0.0233240724,
0.0017237528,
0.0372351408,
-0.002944432,
0.0348645151,
0.0231088512,
0.0292228349,
-0.0490678325,
0.0857744962,
0.1114919931,
0.0907040313,
0.0302113052,
-0.0061743227,
0.0271482114,
-0.0052912356,
0.083107166,
-0.041322574,
0.0010012116,
0.011986238,
-0.027926771,
0.0372128449,
-0.0058282237,
0.0759732202,
0.0148338908,
0.0339376517,
0.0445410945,
0.0039305235,
-0.0317985564,
-0.0003041072,
-0.0138339344,
-0.0002987514,
-0.0347220264,
-0.0241281055,
0.0763678923,
-0.0284428168,
-0.0361514241,
-0.0343265608,
-0.0530650578,
0.0562716722,
0.0062023201,
-0.0019244807,
-0.029670151,
0.0039211335,
0.018972015,
-0.0025014598,
-0.0507902876,
-0.0801445991,
-0.0126373926,
0.0084547801,
-0.0413121954,
-0.0060639805,
-0.0200933218,
-0.0716572329,
0.0340903252,
-0.0681247786,
-0.034310244,
2.460223121e-34,
-0.0313427895,
-0.0138803767,
0.0002687832,
-0.0138192484,
0.0056705121,
-0.0481530055,
-0.0352558643,
-0.0153169939,
-0.0443147682,
-0.0237734187,
-0.0123879239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15097v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15097v1 | Cascaded Cross-Modal Transformer for Request and Complaint Detection | 2023-07-27T13:45:42 | 2023-07-27T13:45:42 | Nicolae-Catalin Ristea, Radu Tudor Ionescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM, eess.AS | We propose a novel cascaded cross-modal transformer (CCMT) that combines
speech and text transcripts to detect customer requests and complaints in phone
conversations. Our approach leverages a multimodal paradigm by transcribing the
speech using automatic speech recognition (ASR) models and translating the
transcripts into different languages. Subsequently, we combine
language-specific BERT-based models with Wav2Vec2.0 audio features in a novel
cascaded cross-attention transformer model. We apply our system to the Requests
Sub-Challenge of the ACM Multimedia 2023 Computational Paralinguistics
Challenge, reaching unweighted average recalls (UAR) of 65.41% and 85.87% for
the complaint and request classes, respectively. | [
0.0441034175,
0.0530893579,
-0.0000189501,
0.0269542336,
-0.028040247,
-0.0057608988,
-0.0004483832,
-0.0070080892,
-0.0102024283,
-0.0836255923,
-0.059571173,
-0.0605020784,
0.0144386906,
-0.0226781517,
-0.0058776354,
-0.0536612906,
0.0058288537,
-0.0207065381,
0.0163225159,
0.0396528579,
0.0292843822,
0.0133482534,
-0.0302073732,
0.0277710557,
-0.0743647516,
-0.0140967695,
-0.0143626994,
0.0467205532,
0.0239707753,
0.004814887,
0.0545711964,
0.0300935656,
0.0091306232,
0.0421230607,
0.0000018389,
-0.0416050293,
-0.0152646592,
0.0157091562,
-0.0276558977,
-0.0025586335,
0.0045521613,
0.0062213293,
-0.0351350084,
0.041819714,
0.0167462621,
0.0210422594,
0.0377807356,
0.0835878626,
0.0899830312,
0.0608655401,
-0.0252415258,
-0.0299904104,
0.0298382509,
0.0060708174,
0.0470323637,
-0.0417588055,
-0.0336764567,
-0.0064548692,
0.0380842127,
-0.0310339127,
0.0006052132,
0.0369805917,
-0.0137475561,
-0.0490259975,
-0.0300611705,
-0.0090304883,
-0.0555932,
-0.0330341086,
-0.0396147221,
0.0727447644,
0.0032716671,
0.0101580434,
-0.012685528,
0.0253711212,
-0.0154753048,
-0.0443009548,
-0.0518147387,
-0.0051245163,
-0.0139875337,
-0.0161955021,
-0.0304096658,
0.0655445531,
-0.0040957374,
-0.0497020595,
-0.0072831674,
-0.032811109,
0.0018605139,
-0.0523553528,
-0.0013998268,
-0.0022523382,
0.0440484434,
-0.0045080846,
0.0712903738,
-0.0105453357,
-0.0246146284,
-0.0268193185,
0.0000160724,
-0.0650719032,
0.0108163506,
-0.0463368632,
0.0631177723,
0.0267702918,
-0.1058537364,
0.0444640592,
-0.0068799378,
0.0494667962,
-0.0397618636,
-0.0106507158,
-0.0479764044,
-0.0217808429,
-0.0395917781,
0.0242614597,
-0.0348751992,
0.0138099436,
-0.024678506,
-0.0221851617,
-0.0178610384,
0.0032267482,
-0.0134969978,
-0.0094639948,
0.0493256003,
-0.0091836303,
-0.0413354263,
-0.0085633378,
0.0068312977,
0.0631452277,
0.0309097525,
-0.0003215839,
-0.0181119684,
-0.0401732177,
0.0023574734,
0.0377232321,
0.0158313345,
-0.0055232667,
0.002255907,
0.0587201603,
-0.0365426578,
-0.0192115009,
-0.0426672474,
0.0001560094,
-0.0472778678,
-0.0567679517,
-0.0160814803,
-0.0162713695,
0.0211591329,
-0.0157130118,
-0.0075488095,
0.0740895122,
0.0023494195,
-0.009819991,
-0.0285424478,
0.0534062609,
0.080831483,
0.0360125042,
0.0734926835,
0.0008487359,
0.0087465299,
0.0435206965,
0.0474948362,
0.0075141378,
0.0412865169,
-0.0199858621,
0.0594237372,
0.0519612171,
-0.0081196642,
-0.0035129453,
-0.0056856088,
-0.01324159,
0.0010182709,
0.0038803548,
0.0161853712,
0.0790417716,
0.0012070648,
-0.033003021,
0.0655417517,
0.0210764129,
-0.0163188521,
-0.0074425326,
0.0429248549,
0.0077394987,
-0.0524506792,
-0.0037023474,
-0.0088664191,
0.0277940016,
-0.0424870737,
-0.0144828362,
0.0563435666,
-0.0062650256,
-0.0325166434,
-0.0166137964,
0.0077168015,
-0.0448038243,
-0.0216022115,
0.0136313271,
0.0196415279,
0.0058308835,
-0.0701051876,
0.0551749244,
-0.0390165038,
-0.0601461902,
-0.023564877,
-0.0197085217,
0.0341769494,
0.0673709139,
0.0127425296,
0.0055109672,
-0.0192479622,
-0.0708271861,
-0.0177384857,
0.0357310586,
0.0386384539,
-0.0017010593,
0.0152427852,
-0.0548179187,
-0.0201860964,
0.0324306674,
-0.0222005304,
0.0010449078,
-0.0384111404,
0.0287497137,
0.020086458,
-0.0210534409,
0.0040230504,
-0.0315282531,
0.038942676,
-0.0062903618,
0.0163286775,
0.0305171255,
0.082834363,
0.0486485511,
0.0060077477,
0.0044425507,
0.0182030015,
-0.0552530065,
-0.0006127174,
0.04322863,
-0.0343239382,
-0.0119401244,
0.0179898217,
-0.0419954173,
-0.0077129407,
0.0594529286,
0.013377903,
-0.0404234491,
0.032578744,
-0.0510659032,
0.0757649839,
-0.0457738116,
0.0470633991,
0.0373675153,
0.0302936956,
0.0129875885,
-0.0156028876,
0.0021690507,
-0.0365471728,
-0.0034722004,
-0.0268487781,
0.0203995053,
-0.007173676,
-0.053782668,
0.0323775075,
-0.0204689261,
0.0179096479,
-0.0047533554,
-0.0162306242,
-0.0268630832,
-0.0189337637,
-0.1243025139,
0.0037490514,
-0.0151632717,
-0.0120573575,
-0.0356260501,
0.0286653768,
0.019674046,
-0.006030845,
-0.0353368521,
-0.036167562,
0.0277640224,
-0.0018275799,
-0.0138048539,
-0.0323058106,
-0.0486794002,
-0.0252198577,
0.0051481104,
-0.0098999646,
0.0133452425,
-0.0251401272,
-0.0462868363,
-0.0512319878,
-0.0380521864,
0.0220071394,
0.0337827466,
-0.0114643192,
-0.0513305627,
0.0015667175,
0.0153127871,
0.0733296797,
0.0420886315,
0.0434268825,
0.0047660093,
-0.0304122586,
-0.0091457376,
-0.0392832011,
0.0500914715,
-0.0209598038,
-0.0474909469,
0.0164972506,
-0.0364731774,
0.0265571941,
0.0738504976,
0.0039502541,
0.0515096225,
-0.0307387449,
-0.0843488201,
0.0205702558,
-0.0262073241,
0.0177410897,
-0.0215315782,
-0.0287469998,
0.041001901,
0.0135789262,
-0.0259000883,
0.0342041999,
-0.058569666,
-0.0324768573,
-0.045082543,
-0.0203556549,
-0.0104558561,
0.0675666928,
-0.0419335403,
0.0378152207,
0.0459353887,
-0.0613459758,
0.015085482,
-0.0268991683,
0.0310590621,
-0.0407559536,
0.0279280245,
0.00688772,
0.0046256334,
0.009083949,
-0.0336914062,
-0.0440884791,
-0.0234390981,
-0.0280124266,
-0.0206009857,
-0.0065358416,
-0.027090909,
-0.0734634623,
0.0499354862,
0.010520502,
0.0348778255,
0.0031991783,
0.0216128081,
0.0205685962,
0.0497570857,
0.0031492084,
0.0734244138,
-0.0310396794,
-0.0207897332,
0.0001901886,
0.0300266147,
0.0656016394,
0.0313152596,
0.0050975503,
0.003158547,
0.0308112353,
0.0344231576,
-0.0241470281,
-0.0299383923,
0.0066715106,
-0.0360502899,
0.0330787599,
0.0589841194,
0.0153906019,
-0.0540669337,
-0.015035999,
-0.0253299754,
-0.0262499098,
0.0234447848,
0.0349389985,
-0.0545179918,
-0.0381564014,
0.030382121,
0.025031399,
-0.0044914344,
0.0411537699,
-0.0099653266,
-0.0846072212,
0.0504734889,
0.0062492569,
0.0313658938,
-0.0790442899,
0.0084517486,
-0.0141662415,
0.004871679,
0.0562441126,
-0.0408360772,
0.0134879332,
-0.0687762573,
0.0182564706,
-0.0439156629,
-0.044492092,
0.0439869873,
-0.0147368042,
0.0368953049,
0.0474555306,
0.0338790119,
0.0167043097,
-0.0830430165,
0.0301552806,
-0.0196024552,
-0.0111473585,
0.0118684685,
0.0168776996,
-0.0384957828,
-0.0053947018,
0.0072837323,
0.0125962263,
-0.0077382876,
0.01177222,
-0.0053815087,
0.0824463814,
-0.0101914853,
-0.0186350271,
-0.0096337777,
0.0578683913,
0.0406908318,
0.0698405281,
0.0085080527,
-0.0426961854,
-0.0119071295,
0.0157124307,
-0.012496084,
-0.0276575349,
-0.0021969795,
0.0557763688,
0.008862731,
-0.0756583735,
-0.03525443,
-0.0102924127,
-0.0089491159,
-0.0126983756,
0.0220635869,
-0.0366258956,
0.0114992848,
0.0354859047,
-0.0402846262,
0.0085546104,
0.0191368423,
0.0405213237,
-0.0976418182,
-0.0074571064,
0.0456754267,
-0.0293378048,
0.0000651315,
0.0165980067,
-0.0659461543,
-0.0411096662,
-0.0325766392,
0.023220595,
0.0137035651,
0.066856876,
-0.0085375644,
-0.0103928261,
-0.0184012111,
0.0213157162,
-0.0550339557,
-0.0256881583,
0.0765622556,
0.0079125836,
-0.0345772319,
0.0219292101,
-0.0440807566,
0.028701812,
-0.015820533,
0.0316665247,
-0.0412003323,
-0.0359768197,
0.0118051833,
0.0040191598,
0.0351207964,
0.0138493693,
-0.0031715485,
-0.0453810319,
0.0450349525,
0.0390280709,
0.0376257487,
-0.0539098345,
-0.0062627904,
-0.0332565233,
-0.0241632294,
0.0108558526,
-0.0011293887,
-0.0505046099,
-0.0544298813,
-0.0273716878,
0.0773398504,
-0.0086210649,
-0.0106768776,
0.0003135455,
-0.0061304201,
-0.0156420283,
0.0290648472,
0.0436414741,
0.0235924609,
-0.0075844894,
0.0457162,
-0.0042942828,
0.0241188034,
0.0066570682,
0.0336838625,
0.0130558033,
-0.0078807818,
-0.0053299498,
0.0021543601,
0.0139767863,
-0.028615389,
0.0450065807,
0.0086723557,
0.0404592045,
-0.0104421321,
0.0639904886,
-0.0422203243,
-0.0060696881,
-0.0017536212,
-0.0067273267,
0.0057197921,
0.0340432897,
0.0340601988,
-0.070530057,
0.0026953896,
-0.0111472625,
0.006185608,
-0.0873578861,
-0.0314787403,
0.081426926,
-0.0260825548,
-0.0045216205,
-0.0098456424,
-0.027894767,
-0.0471190475,
0.0241520721,
-0.0266342871,
-0.0088238288,
-0.0128633827,
0.0316721164,
0.0357894972,
-0.0025964251,
0.0105799623,
0.0036785817,
-0.041128207,
-0.0083058327,
-0.0055048764,
0.0100787105,
-6.245023124e-33,
0.0083099157,
0.008094837,
-0.031659022,
0.0349184573,
-0.0438097343,
0.0340937264,
-0.0085494136,
0.0024630614,
0.0419024862,
-0.0080555398,
-0.0093173208,
0.0018836425,
0.0198400915,
0.0094188247,
0.0227808375,
-0.0180683751,
0.0826976746,
-0.0082737571,
-0.0079411883,
0.0544879027,
0.0266783237,
0.0483539477,
0.0636029616,
-0.0899362117,
-0.0070647853,
0.0139389075,
-0.02707747,
-0.0150868054,
0.0402157269,
0.0822344124,
0.0042626108,
0.0439945012,
0.0009371674,
-0.0218410511,
0.0254561175,
0.0669182837,
-0.0553369075,
0.0180983134,
0.0102199875,
0.0486139916,
0.0108450539,
-0.0085924575,
0.0183592122,
0.014850419,
0.0051877904,
-0.012720664,
0.0145035712,
-0.0053471266,
0.0089740166,
-0.0463268831,
-0.0601272956,
0.004670647,
-0.0516470075,
-0.0609426983,
0.0317362957,
0.0957011878,
0.0107771782,
0.0349006988,
-0.0452768058,
0.0265647806,
-0.0556814633,
0.0019834586,
0.0221453905,
-0.0199403632,
-0.0715610683,
0.0288369656,
0.0165804103,
-0.0338947512,
0.0099269226,
-0.0289481543,
0.0020799614,
0.0521670505,
-0.0030187266,
0.0149375936,
-0.0102838408,
-0.0381604321,
-0.0081402278,
0.0437859148,
0.0652689189,
0.0077373073,
0.0434843227,
0.0136754382,
-0.0261408035,
0.0116627654,
0.0046773707,
-0.0295534898,
-0.0432353802,
0.0011202239,
0.0357729308,
0.0392033011,
0.0090140142,
-0.0177729819,
0.0694633275,
-0.0133904759,
0.0076177972,
-0.0186836962,
0.0107306046,
0.0303013697,
-0.0263191089,
0.0253668372,
-0.0254401732,
-0.0089461412,
0.0432034135,
0.0130393058,
0.010957432,
-0.0115897581,
0.0329758078,
0.0587180592,
-0.0589169785,
-0.0090776002,
0.0264641345,
0.0374229401,
-0.0447946638,
0.0903761387,
0.0233917311,
0.0097881155,
-0.0295273568,
0.0286116488,
-0.0583720356,
0.0327327885,
-0.0513205566,
-0.0295842066,
-0.0046445839,
0.0572444014,
-0.0523180664,
0.0121829724,
-0.0181344561,
-0.0182771515,
0.0385901369,
-0.0558787994,
-0.0025839962,
0.0152426977,
2.758e-7,
-0.0374994688,
0.0229731314,
0.018262947,
-0.0373586863,
0.0092269303,
0.049402304,
0.0053280387,
0.0167780109,
0.0182366557,
-0.0253078621,
0.0247739311,
-0.0510974415,
0.0872352794,
0.0085511319,
-0.1059649214,
-0.035021916,
-0.0585669875,
-0.0066596447,
-0.0446794517,
-0.0003286244,
0.0717898831,
0.106256254,
-0.010864906,
-0.0412242003,
0.010118885,
0.0259850584,
0.0262284148,
-0.0583288707,
-0.0425687209,
-0.0213481244,
0.0149194077,
-0.0235306975,
-0.0010505837,
0.0330882072,
-0.0437785275,
0.0060627339,
0.0161614772,
0.0364343785,
0.0142537309,
-0.1017511338,
-0.0332128294,
0.0777389109,
-0.0414127298,
-0.0333934464,
0.0130536146,
-0.0064962972,
-0.0279212818,
-0.0204574857,
-0.0116604855,
0.0016125275,
0.0028276639,
-0.0075186724,
-0.029539356,
0.0280417707,
0.0341838114,
-0.0223311335,
0.0131913656,
-0.0896463096,
0.0544828363,
0.0068136132,
-0.0292882565,
-0.0073934225,
-0.0106727779,
-0.0707467571,
0.0282859635,
0.0091872998,
-0.0013846344,
2.096813303e-34,
0.0810203776,
-0.0125314835,
0.044504676,
0.008318495,
0.0078461496,
0.0037138613,
0.0068790293,
-0.0146339433,
0.0011462296,
-0.0450066365,
-0.0447731055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14856v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14856v1 | Exploiting the Potential of Seq2Seq Models as Robust Few-Shot Learners | 2023-07-27T13:37:06 | 2023-07-27T13:37:06 | Jihyeon Lee, Dain Kim, Doohae Jung, Boseop Kim, Kyoung-Woon On | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning, which offers substantial advantages over fine-tuning, is
predominantly observed in decoder-only models, while encoder-decoder (i.e.,
seq2seq) models excel in methods that rely on weight updates. Recently, a few
studies have demonstrated the feasibility of few-shot learning with seq2seq
models; however, this has been limited to tasks that align well with the
seq2seq architecture, such as summarization and translation. Inspired by these
initial studies, we provide a first-ever extensive experiment comparing the
in-context few-shot learning capabilities of decoder-only and encoder-decoder
models on a broad range of tasks. Furthermore, we propose two methods to more
effectively elicit in-context learning ability in seq2seq models:
objective-aligned prompting and a fusion-based approach. Remarkably, our
approach outperforms a decoder-only model that is six times larger and exhibits
significant performance improvements compared to conventional seq2seq models
across a variety of settings. We posit that, with the right configuration and
prompt design, seq2seq models can be highly effective few-shot learners for a
wide spectrum of applications. | [
0.0176523291,
0.0631723702,
0.0341778994,
-0.0129334722,
0.0164865069,
0.0374942124,
0.0299443025,
-0.0416251309,
-0.0547319725,
-0.043251276,
-0.0285720713,
-0.0002331114,
-0.0095650526,
0.0074548167,
0.0003320568,
-0.050989598,
0.0238869842,
-0.0070467331,
-0.011247375,
-0.0019619816,
-0.0068931091,
0.0140178949,
-0.0074573304,
0.0375556909,
0.0360408761,
-0.0016459472,
-0.0263654739,
0.0404899605,
0.043828804,
-0.0143372249,
0.0056913327,
0.0750700235,
0.0451246388,
0.0333134159,
0.0000019045,
-0.0244888328,
-0.0076867114,
-0.0148255685,
-0.054276187,
0.0100156553,
0.0208509825,
-0.0852297768,
-0.0147471623,
-0.0049739927,
-0.0038762246,
-0.0267396793,
0.0700282529,
-0.0040472141,
0.0730635747,
0.0627323985,
-0.0104980916,
-0.0860326812,
0.0002313658,
-0.0399927422,
0.0253003407,
-0.0670375004,
-0.0003349617,
-0.0285238568,
-0.0197841637,
-0.0085561303,
-0.0456251055,
0.0333422162,
0.0238354336,
0.0024227633,
0.0122910459,
0.0528002083,
-0.0378889591,
-0.0164130554,
-0.0019185218,
0.0472193062,
-0.0105239907,
0.0123177245,
-0.0334384553,
0.0012663692,
-0.0071035307,
-0.028863173,
-0.0564766191,
0.0257931203,
-0.0109062009,
0.0019002358,
-0.0329375044,
0.0520789474,
-0.0129895909,
-0.0191739537,
-0.0199884046,
-0.0558370948,
0.0027258634,
0.0012099023,
-0.0299046189,
0.0364015065,
-0.0271899495,
-0.0267769191,
-0.023331454,
0.0403372757,
-0.0247253217,
0.0119367065,
-0.0499356017,
-0.0371866859,
-0.0273534358,
-0.0043861247,
0.049336873,
0.0635632351,
0.0021513691,
0.0630804896,
-0.0320328213,
0.0388241112,
0.0572562926,
0.0178850256,
-0.0334958732,
0.0050619957,
-0.0504014641,
-0.0123721659,
-0.0531928912,
0.0157532692,
-0.0330040343,
-0.0344560035,
-0.0480052792,
0.0479561575,
-0.0020673655,
0.0228767116,
-0.0015866421,
0.0029417078,
-0.0517390035,
-0.0042792303,
0.0340814218,
0.0610725917,
-0.012972963,
0.0079830876,
0.0319034122,
-0.0219529308,
-0.031482283,
-0.0044175428,
0.0088217231,
-0.035210371,
-0.0046079815,
0.027319653,
-0.055690635,
-0.0663112998,
-0.022292668,
0.0090567293,
-0.0310768466,
-0.0254219919,
-0.0257820301,
-0.0535232164,
0.0407450385,
0.0020009091,
0.0094820317,
-0.0154735809,
-0.0137315523,
0.0045475918,
-0.0145811299,
0.0545824021,
0.0198440049,
-0.0077294572,
0.0268647168,
0.0089077018,
-0.0044287215,
0.1013257951,
0.0132655865,
0.0283540897,
0.0018228668,
0.0235445686,
-0.0060034958,
0.0178208686,
0.0026156974,
0.0389755294,
-0.052414488,
-0.0362388752,
0.0133052533,
-0.0280291326,
0.0369853117,
0.0423525572,
-0.0802690163,
0.0301350765,
0.0653614625,
0.0439754687,
0.0337615572,
-0.0077726454,
0.0407551937,
0.0085351011,
0.0084561175,
0.0353308022,
-0.0308354087,
0.0898669213,
-0.0121386386,
0.0384183154,
0.0283963811,
0.018003663,
-0.0599741712,
-0.05511076,
0.0057039396,
-0.014293259,
-0.0015668238,
0.0060296804,
0.0517516695,
0.0434772708,
-0.0696129128,
0.0126260519,
-0.0210039224,
-0.0604295954,
0.0234068595,
-0.0370399468,
-0.0045730006,
0.0585718304,
0.0434953794,
0.0164227746,
-0.0172824524,
-0.0201800801,
0.0252817906,
0.0531909317,
0.0384191051,
-0.0290853549,
0.0392883159,
-0.0477625765,
-0.0471704416,
-0.0283687487,
0.0368328243,
-0.0173985474,
-0.0105780456,
-0.003075768,
-0.0176049359,
0.0287131779,
0.0074622505,
0.0236945394,
-0.0266101938,
-0.0496560074,
0.0098879449,
0.0113358833,
-0.0259433519,
0.005233984,
-0.0263160467,
0.0078663891,
0.0084007001,
-0.0248657893,
-0.0024287554,
0.0300130919,
-0.0614169165,
-0.1153207496,
-0.0192572381,
0.0033835578,
0.0324308425,
-0.0150090437,
-0.0568503588,
-0.0260077622,
-0.0068287659,
-0.0269842204,
0.0068158656,
-0.0416167192,
-0.0049762228,
0.0124310618,
-0.0215758979,
-0.0278690979,
0.0537553281,
-0.0097479206,
-0.0168207083,
0.043040432,
0.0180714726,
-0.0204692278,
-0.0451674238,
-0.0065675965,
-0.0017797102,
0.0142361233,
0.0092006512,
0.0233073737,
0.0092008365,
-0.0023955987,
-0.0101025505,
-0.0829147771,
-0.0195961185,
-0.0477367081,
-0.0159087218,
0.0247036573,
0.0248335693,
0.0140807219,
-0.0222084988,
-0.0207333304,
-0.0196402129,
-0.0124470973,
0.0235602483,
-0.0007065053,
0.0192943066,
0.0101239085,
-0.0124628302,
-0.0333457142,
0.0183509439,
0.0549648628,
-0.0373420678,
-0.0167270992,
-0.0182645209,
0.0208412185,
0.0095746508,
0.0021106149,
0.0059829126,
-0.0031851726,
0.021514101,
-0.0007870828,
0.0200905669,
0.0805632323,
0.0187373292,
0.0387579054,
0.0141691528,
0.0097543942,
-0.0344390869,
0.0207559839,
-0.0342718065,
-0.0310119744,
-0.0279413555,
-0.0056402492,
-0.0123706413,
0.0705017447,
-0.0148975682,
0.0437496305,
-0.1082040519,
0.0456024557,
0.021997232,
-0.0279146582,
-0.0640548021,
-0.0169623382,
-0.0086521991,
0.0241781492,
-0.034592323,
-0.0055378596,
0.0795821473,
0.0237999633,
-0.0204014853,
-0.0199708398,
0.0219390001,
-0.0277950019,
0.029740572,
-0.0281001888,
0.0439986959,
-0.0149726914,
-0.0207938477,
-0.0732853338,
-0.0231959149,
0.0373305827,
-0.0156475231,
0.0248956624,
-0.0075619188,
-0.0043022078,
-0.0452837944,
-0.0366122238,
-0.0200398099,
0.0319477879,
-0.0366550349,
0.0451010466,
-0.0474127159,
0.0142876236,
-0.0337953195,
0.032180313,
0.0032979853,
0.0711706355,
-0.0455819182,
-0.0216259062,
-0.0303246621,
0.0267768279,
0.0582956299,
-0.0095091555,
-0.0172490384,
-0.0876375288,
0.1241766736,
0.0524927191,
0.0261046998,
-0.0016402064,
0.0123830633,
0.0370383859,
0.0517495647,
0.0076719932,
0.0236248747,
0.0253372919,
0.0954223722,
-0.0356929787,
-0.025749566,
0.0994066745,
0.0180355869,
-0.0360401012,
-0.0133150388,
-0.0172179751,
0.0053875218,
0.0313442349,
0.0138088129,
-0.0944432542,
-0.078279525,
-0.0048169796,
0.0310804602,
0.0286554918,
0.0147786867,
-0.0210322831,
-0.0889159665,
0.0359780304,
0.0446785912,
-0.0830655769,
-0.0146821374,
0.0022422366,
-0.0230752286,
-0.0702492818,
0.029435128,
0.0311158169,
-0.0097396327,
-0.0026850854,
0.0333214588,
0.0486096218,
-0.0524491146,
-0.0138014369,
-0.0372841619,
-0.0037778148,
0.0902840272,
-0.0161462929,
0.0192659441,
0.0060094902,
0.0268552508,
-0.045196116,
0.0054237442,
0.0185364615,
0.0455472693,
-0.0649745762,
0.0029984268,
-0.0012789486,
0.0355936848,
0.0151484767,
-0.026665397,
-0.047609847,
0.0235601626,
-0.0013353608,
-0.0155964447,
-0.011829623,
-0.0074752127,
-0.0192878246,
0.0841042176,
0.0221261568,
-0.0456832498,
-0.0209444296,
-0.0283819549,
-0.0269758869,
-0.0773622766,
-0.005446984,
0.0233525038,
0.0148353651,
-0.0633776113,
-0.0572742559,
-0.0512537062,
0.0377228782,
0.0193311349,
-0.0411723107,
0.0043124701,
-0.0297518522,
0.0218081754,
-0.0225767363,
-0.0454484411,
0.0056165215,
0.0178393647,
-0.040549513,
0.0026279748,
0.0497180186,
-0.0199831799,
-0.0025086605,
-0.0437481962,
-0.0951747075,
-0.0544459298,
-0.0281057023,
0.0489105806,
0.0193527732,
0.0403371789,
-0.0103404652,
-0.0294773709,
0.0533185974,
0.0884979665,
-0.0104661509,
0.0185282286,
0.04505473,
-0.0129756657,
-0.0357523821,
0.0332408547,
-0.0403014682,
0.0242600255,
-0.0233431552,
0.0549477972,
-0.0578797869,
-0.0230014138,
0.0372584201,
-0.0564387925,
0.0288468879,
-0.0053347806,
-0.0206709187,
-0.0011986003,
0.0117350146,
0.0019651777,
0.0195563827,
-0.0608733706,
-0.0269813761,
0.0057727839,
-0.0039805393,
0.0165655483,
0.0549182445,
0.0045604459,
0.0435252041,
-0.0756421089,
-0.0006778256,
-0.0129665229,
0.0043112016,
-0.0089211958,
0.0101231318,
-0.0388317183,
0.030767547,
0.0053011919,
0.0060435128,
-0.0173299573,
0.0516867898,
0.0453693792,
0.0314469077,
0.0235530585,
0.0425596237,
-0.0619853325,
0.0069941105,
-0.0602299012,
-0.005066019,
0.0518411174,
0.0033341926,
0.0023816924,
0.0193113629,
-0.0025915313,
-0.0441460647,
0.013726254,
0.0182064623,
-0.0192109644,
0.0242475346,
0.0296989158,
0.0393102728,
-0.0133546507,
0.0650059134,
-0.0087730112,
0.040544413,
-0.0031818498,
0.029609967,
-0.0219352804,
-0.040365085,
0.0358639657,
0.0062595829,
-0.0248218402,
0.0108863721,
-0.0519603305,
-0.0314069614,
0.0038268387,
-0.0319492146,
0.0072718775,
-0.008046288,
0.0468370169,
0.0109423436,
-0.0076693725,
-0.0364707038,
-0.0184886493,
-0.032672137,
-0.0108252252,
0.0142813856,
0.0266781356,
-6.188013117e-33,
-0.0350954756,
0.0295213629,
0.0422574878,
-0.0257702861,
0.0131466836,
-0.0263761561,
-0.044141572,
-0.0025898793,
-0.0074158655,
-0.0047010826,
0.0012991026,
0.0173202995,
0.0099023646,
0.0147531405,
-0.001668525,
0.0150150117,
0.0925581306,
-0.0167673193,
-0.0551673248,
0.0022052696,
0.0276176818,
0.0206828527,
0.0430073328,
0.0365874842,
-0.0135355704,
0.0100213159,
-0.0260669515,
0.0075017684,
0.0411857031,
0.0477845632,
0.013424404,
-0.0170566458,
-0.0052324887,
-0.0427982211,
-0.0548077859,
-0.0051930645,
-0.0830789283,
-0.0188617334,
-0.023054814,
0.012591118,
-0.0257754121,
-0.0271032918,
0.0223274417,
-0.0158284847,
-0.0209179148,
-0.0610060096,
0.0136554539,
-0.0343658663,
-0.0368484408,
-0.0698506236,
-0.0266617481,
0.0155364247,
-0.0086720102,
-0.0367612652,
0.0350480415,
0.0848594382,
-0.0003359264,
0.0238475241,
-0.0348875895,
0.0164906122,
0.0080007492,
0.0348079987,
0.0666467026,
0.0493886098,
-0.0012655626,
0.0286742467,
0.0073560337,
-0.0370584577,
-0.0077131893,
0.0206556693,
0.0186013114,
0.0166930631,
0.0487709567,
0.0357025303,
0.0719891712,
0.0199389365,
-0.0620519072,
0.0597579665,
-0.0059788073,
0.050008148,
0.0525754839,
0.0268719699,
0.0088256449,
-0.0177252311,
-0.0498143248,
-0.0063293851,
-0.0142634194,
-0.0166458506,
0.0269373786,
0.0786015168,
-0.0124425143,
0.0019592452,
0.0793657228,
-0.0077046007,
0.0487639941,
0.0487215929,
-0.0403314903,
0.0134654557,
0.0112247886,
-0.0046827169,
-0.0465585105,
0.0097378669,
0.080569081,
0.0258883704,
-0.0205409918,
0.0207309052,
0.066656515,
0.0393364131,
-0.0480957478,
-0.0059059341,
-0.0395246968,
0.0239982232,
-0.003532435,
0.0501831584,
0.0138556091,
0.0115361996,
-0.0347164981,
0.0556183457,
-0.0621035844,
-0.0205809157,
-0.0339528881,
0.0067137033,
0.0068459124,
0.0410255156,
-0.0079795308,
0.0009347547,
-0.0157836787,
-0.000804757,
0.0172505472,
-0.0430989899,
-0.0291623585,
0.043767944,
2.52e-7,
0.0089551639,
-0.0035114686,
0.0147160012,
-0.01772088,
0.0048295348,
0.0388574675,
-0.0454325527,
0.0494685061,
0.0136973783,
-0.003967545,
0.0228701402,
0.0745455846,
0.0408116505,
-0.0098988526,
-0.0855228305,
0.0217140727,
-0.0705234185,
0.0632660091,
-0.0283864606,
-0.0131458789,
0.0470334962,
0.0774341822,
-0.0421535745,
0.0070067896,
0.044822067,
-0.0074993591,
0.0919835418,
0.017043788,
-0.0042963326,
-0.0026184076,
-0.0395101346,
-0.0004567142,
-0.011961502,
-0.0007674602,
-0.0127897598,
-0.0005184114,
0.004495156,
0.0706849173,
-0.01826239,
-0.048512876,
-0.0030667672,
0.0433229171,
-0.0029036605,
0.0099477405,
0.0653728172,
-0.0934058279,
-0.009374354,
0.011952878,
-0.0561527945,
0.0444697849,
-0.0065192729,
-0.0114561375,
-0.0263026953,
0.0006587915,
0.0280485377,
0.0500123128,
-0.0125039909,
-0.0650186539,
-0.026027713,
-0.0057906029,
0.0302424934,
-0.0553104803,
-0.0392780788,
0.0112805115,
-0.0205098931,
-0.0333108492,
-0.0313670225,
2.173366225e-34,
0.0436967239,
-0.0078754937,
0.0069987243,
0.0414319076,
-0.0231178347,
-0.0371179394,
-0.0508959852,
0.0062724617,
0.0562804975,
-0.0620119497,
-0.0270351432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14852v1 | ArcGPT: A Large Language Model Tailored for Real-world Archival Applications | 2023-07-27T13:31:45 | 2023-07-27T13:31:45 | Shitou Zhang, Jingrui Hou, Siyuan Peng, Zuchao Li, Qibiao Hu, Ping Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Archives play a crucial role in preserving information and knowledge, and the
exponential growth of such data necessitates efficient and automated tools for
managing and utilizing archive information resources. Archival applications
involve managing massive data that are challenging to process and analyze.
Although LLMs have made remarkable progress in diverse domains, there are no
publicly available archives tailored LLM. Addressing this gap, we introduce
ArcGPT, to our knowledge, the first general-purpose LLM tailored to the
archival field. To enhance model performance on real-world archival tasks,
ArcGPT has been pre-trained on massive and extensive archival domain data.
Alongside ArcGPT, we release AMBLE, a benchmark comprising four real-world
archival tasks. Evaluation on AMBLE shows that ArcGPT outperforms existing
state-of-the-art models, marking a substantial step forward in effective
archival data management. Ultimately, ArcGPT aims to better serve the archival
community, aiding archivists in their crucial role of preserving and harnessing
our collective information and knowledge. | [
0.0197195522,
0.1152517423,
0.0200074483,
0.0552783124,
-0.0448436774,
0.0584690422,
-0.013425149,
0.0352160931,
-0.0122491745,
-0.0279662721,
-0.0389537215,
0.0022940503,
-0.0440576375,
0.0068438579,
-0.0526189543,
-0.0160393137,
0.0422895364,
-0.0213662274,
0.0142430961,
0.0038286578,
-0.0107628778,
0.0148433698,
0.0032079096,
-0.0372973308,
-0.0307285488,
-0.0228213631,
-0.0519169979,
0.0206918512,
-0.0219570864,
-0.0125371451,
0.0089344624,
0.0209576301,
0.0498440489,
0.0716324076,
0.000001838,
-0.0629922524,
-0.0469343849,
0.0249496736,
-0.0696218461,
0.026524635,
0.0755599961,
0.0001833388,
-0.0447111204,
-0.0310317669,
-0.034186013,
-0.0413704105,
0.0244766232,
0.0261037052,
0.0343193337,
0.0762386993,
-0.0028694721,
-0.020534236,
0.0218708199,
-0.0416447967,
0.005739768,
-0.0495810769,
0.0138125531,
0.0361438841,
0.0104427962,
0.0229490362,
0.0058585014,
0.0670570657,
0.0204415936,
-0.0073377024,
-0.0407402664,
0.0093937237,
-0.0096584028,
0.0369148031,
-0.0115717864,
-0.006482638,
0.0296096653,
-0.0148637537,
0.012193813,
0.0423429273,
-0.0350555182,
0.002478377,
-0.0534681305,
0.0629231036,
-0.0239272658,
-0.0004698806,
-0.0351012312,
0.005901169,
0.0311160125,
0.0250751209,
-0.0071985153,
0.0133924708,
-0.0036016179,
-0.0104952343,
0.0219235551,
0.0120370183,
0.016464144,
-0.0249786917,
0.0381928608,
0.0473071449,
-0.0092592593,
-0.0051090783,
-0.0228914134,
0.0018082382,
0.0298445188,
-0.0045360983,
-0.0072671543,
-0.0066811256,
-0.0414223149,
0.0849697515,
-0.0077403663,
0.0498750061,
-0.0271500442,
-0.0333456956,
-0.0000588959,
-0.0270865168,
-0.0556421168,
-0.0267970338,
-0.0230293144,
0.0424364954,
-0.0501169786,
-0.0068238066,
-0.0149918282,
-0.0068754517,
0.0296908505,
0.0217835661,
0.0303682517,
-0.0327781923,
-0.0237633511,
-0.0223490633,
-0.0195994936,
-0.0000898084,
-0.0150793027,
0.007793291,
-0.0300951358,
-0.0505296737,
0.0178180803,
0.0323560536,
0.005018652,
-0.0498030186,
0.0409177281,
0.0508458167,
-0.0162978321,
-0.0105955433,
-0.0933673158,
-0.0217345972,
0.0320010744,
-0.0743688568,
0.0424150936,
-0.0500713661,
0.0452330969,
0.0044058473,
0.0019446485,
-0.0248478074,
-0.0590025671,
-0.0182070956,
-0.0400620401,
0.0675712079,
0.0035476869,
-0.0177387539,
0.0529158749,
0.0130428886,
0.0207554493,
0.0208999217,
0.0222353302,
0.0471974313,
0.0312944278,
0.0486196503,
0.0105800591,
0.058018595,
0.0030758539,
0.0079725767,
-0.039263662,
0.0560749695,
-0.0201534182,
0.0235625878,
0.0453361571,
0.0895591304,
-0.0089482116,
-0.0580262765,
0.0274319351,
0.0261885021,
0.0296993703,
0.0519272462,
0.0149712367,
0.0038747545,
0.0140871042,
-0.0348229818,
-0.0250406899,
0.0162796378,
0.0163123943,
-0.0099834967,
-0.0432065614,
0.0208428968,
-0.0189252999,
-0.0038427247,
-0.0066912943,
-0.0134492842,
-0.0071106963,
-0.0339941457,
0.0342052281,
0.0105148563,
-0.0326646902,
0.0567351095,
-0.0138856778,
-0.0451122262,
-0.0040243287,
-0.0659224242,
0.0227286872,
0.0442936718,
0.0521506183,
-0.0590346009,
-0.0143888919,
-0.0071077673,
0.0377260782,
0.0302931815,
0.0606192276,
-0.0206291694,
0.0286482256,
-0.0766467378,
-0.0467141904,
0.0161986016,
0.0238714796,
0.0259839762,
0.0346607864,
0.029736286,
0.0282022823,
-0.0601533018,
-0.0086033344,
0.0351149552,
-0.0408357382,
-0.0388935432,
-0.0329665989,
0.0036141304,
0.0078975763,
0.0184934307,
-0.0202391446,
-0.0316612646,
0.0470675267,
0.0076261475,
-0.0029239657,
-0.0204720721,
-0.0192581378,
0.0148101766,
0.0388345718,
-0.0000512321,
0.0105950041,
0.0016523992,
-0.065648295,
-0.0363871455,
-0.0353224725,
-0.0134937335,
0.0357806496,
-0.0525298081,
0.0316667706,
0.0102432827,
-0.0122471498,
-0.0598022006,
0.0916761458,
-0.0088365087,
-0.0462692566,
0.0319362432,
-0.0535810366,
0.0268485807,
-0.0022082261,
-0.0258045234,
0.023681527,
0.0017938603,
0.0435982868,
0.0412881896,
0.0036790438,
-0.0478806049,
-0.0196725018,
-0.0647104159,
0.0188952144,
-0.0383308828,
0.0481024645,
-0.0143246166,
-0.004857027,
-0.0194003135,
-0.0078107426,
0.0076545216,
-0.0184211489,
-0.0134587977,
0.0295761023,
0.0331691355,
0.0362843573,
0.0066047446,
-0.0529761724,
-0.0271382462,
0.0429190658,
0.0124613447,
-0.0050165672,
-0.0957312956,
-0.0202775449,
0.0466378294,
-0.0162867326,
0.0262964536,
-0.0284135509,
0.0049628341,
0.0177367311,
-0.0633154884,
0.0019954864,
0.0253010467,
-0.0482578054,
-0.0209033713,
0.0134389568,
-0.0274230111,
-0.0578453466,
-0.0020013845,
0.0091288267,
-0.0245917253,
-0.0032450745,
0.0390580259,
-0.0142663643,
-0.0314477719,
-0.0355867967,
0.0466470383,
-0.0367858373,
-0.0396158919,
-0.0191753171,
0.0235895608,
-0.0225927159,
-0.0336888246,
0.0010678115,
0.0448043048,
-0.0121330908,
-0.0474143997,
-0.0019504479,
-0.0068385489,
-0.0000548121,
-0.0005669514,
-0.0293410495,
-0.0725152716,
0.1213801876,
-0.0008443079,
0.0035149097,
0.0203062482,
-0.0479790606,
-0.047599569,
0.0092087863,
-0.0178206023,
-0.051707983,
0.0404886864,
-0.0171852671,
0.0444569923,
0.0008803152,
-0.0214777645,
-0.0210489966,
-0.0118137337,
-0.0110557666,
0.0033875951,
-0.059589617,
-0.0198017489,
-0.079783231,
0.0349610932,
0.0055467291,
0.1068401039,
0.017628938,
-0.0037110562,
-0.0216315184,
0.038853731,
0.018669486,
-0.0066689593,
0.0277318694,
0.0147601943,
-0.0109731704,
0.0330471843,
0.0169525798,
-0.0121118808,
-0.0330035873,
0.0097854212,
0.0176056903,
-0.0434359722,
-0.0314391032,
-0.0195327047,
-0.0025300407,
-0.0569469333,
0.0029984349,
0.0739716366,
0.0301934686,
-0.0910981447,
-0.0289563425,
-0.0278663188,
0.0107739829,
-0.0007614528,
0.0072242911,
-0.0908150747,
-0.011591468,
0.0196644086,
0.001203133,
0.0335902125,
-0.0372430906,
-0.0031914762,
-0.0932206884,
0.0377928652,
0.0250863861,
-0.0093208719,
0.0000455467,
-0.0424483605,
-0.0037049293,
-0.059755709,
0.0093138693,
0.0099755395,
-0.0477990396,
-0.0098290285,
-0.0105687762,
-0.0209677741,
-0.0109539833,
0.0270675048,
-0.0454242378,
0.0436016619,
0.0627084151,
0.0302107763,
0.0019596689,
0.0106193023,
0.075170815,
0.0379121862,
0.0112615852,
-0.0532862768,
0.0758730099,
0.0270923283,
0.0269406028,
0.0001207021,
0.0107190898,
-0.0368682556,
0.0134495525,
0.0158945322,
0.0783306584,
-0.0366639346,
0.0331795402,
-0.0055761891,
-0.0750597566,
0.0174299385,
0.04515424,
-0.0174594093,
0.0200319644,
-0.0149264764,
-0.0262617152,
0.0113899428,
-0.0023686581,
0.0039554876,
-0.0076238825,
-0.0694741756,
0.0176783819,
-0.0816803128,
-0.0250028651,
0.0041733328,
0.0219337698,
-0.0111249015,
-0.0368741713,
-0.0358383097,
-0.0279559568,
-0.1115810573,
0.0213503074,
-0.086152181,
0.0208772533,
-0.0616174564,
0.0100573814,
0.0410205834,
0.0191507898,
-0.0201356914,
0.0288933627,
-0.0540694036,
-0.0321971476,
0.0684861615,
0.0092163365,
0.0269985907,
0.0259602796,
0.0244309213,
-0.0345880538,
0.0041684574,
0.0083959233,
-0.030970417,
-0.0251783766,
0.0022751305,
-0.0232800357,
-0.0356821828,
0.0372032039,
-0.0429018028,
0.019524578,
-0.0097400816,
-0.0023589053,
-0.0491800345,
-0.0445299819,
-0.0309065394,
0.040145278,
0.0208101049,
0.0127948876,
-0.0374182984,
0.0135412393,
0.0172322746,
0.004982783,
-0.0033462448,
-0.0111439694,
0.0098970896,
0.0172443707,
-0.0100353453,
-0.0160810146,
0.0559671372,
0.0375382639,
0.0353624113,
-0.0600897335,
0.0126862265,
0.00222503,
0.0242942702,
0.0359786451,
0.0277377721,
0.002927348,
0.0649973899,
0.0376414843,
0.0761886388,
-0.0168503467,
0.0397075675,
-0.019594783,
0.0416962393,
-0.0162344202,
-0.0275018271,
-0.0199577361,
-0.0234691706,
-0.0198475085,
0.0392093807,
0.1052580029,
-0.031004196,
0.0623253882,
-0.0543238483,
-0.0014223261,
-0.0349473916,
0.0118248081,
0.0643955544,
-0.0017826572,
-0.0101268692,
0.0171931852,
-0.0103572998,
0.0612600744,
-0.0072816005,
0.0170958862,
0.0738495439,
-0.0036826069,
-0.0206700992,
-0.044231914,
-0.0365193374,
0.0069836681,
-0.0562191904,
0.0067451913,
-0.0212565176,
-0.0384364054,
0.0068841856,
0.0175464228,
-0.0018082464,
-0.0212836415,
-0.0300105996,
0.0172978938,
0.0219357815,
0.0063686338,
0.0182868317,
-0.0328724757,
-0.0115761897,
-0.023274418,
-0.0254691802,
-0.0117563978,
-5.378173916e-33,
-0.0018506289,
-0.0204482358,
0.0514405929,
-0.0207309406,
-0.0408935845,
0.0300639831,
-0.0091472417,
-0.0302200709,
-0.001152374,
-0.0299549773,
-0.0370563492,
0.0368589796,
0.038568221,
-0.021409031,
0.0127461534,
-0.0066957735,
0.0676305741,
-0.0316561274,
-0.0213372521,
-0.0068215793,
0.0307289753,
0.0315135382,
0.0376601703,
-0.075020209,
0.0279942434,
0.0006229856,
-0.0093783801,
0.0247597527,
0.0311423633,
0.0588913858,
-0.041693747,
-0.0462345146,
0.0117913662,
-0.055357758,
-0.0223195404,
0.0052644601,
-0.101604782,
-0.0000146698,
0.009521706,
0.0724214539,
0.0787855536,
-0.0427217931,
0.0026744122,
0.0037954203,
-0.0252431948,
0.0044160155,
-0.0232499968,
-0.0131191853,
-0.0040389812,
-0.0448662341,
-0.0348448493,
0.0442529954,
0.0470689721,
0.0019750646,
0.103481479,
-0.0578083917,
0.0082845762,
0.0307269488,
-0.0613383986,
-0.0127728758,
-0.0176033694,
0.041964747,
0.0489759259,
-0.0278003011,
-0.0510827601,
0.0440580994,
-0.0053876345,
-0.0093962476,
0.0049593546,
0.0415041149,
-0.0090213427,
0.0490295738,
0.007246335,
0.0219046306,
0.0342657566,
0.0232230648,
-0.0291320924,
0.0144359507,
0.0243041646,
0.0692032576,
-0.0079216491,
0.0504960977,
-0.0119822938,
0.0365989916,
-0.0435284339,
0.0549485721,
-0.0251998734,
-0.0184655357,
0.026707964,
0.0212278124,
-0.0079793222,
0.0109960902,
0.0607239977,
-0.0376973711,
-0.0582039952,
0.0518381782,
-0.0070816739,
0.0259727165,
-0.0079070786,
0.0237742513,
-0.0435290374,
0.0037207967,
0.0231847446,
0.0149761224,
0.0055064163,
-0.0154396165,
0.0539737642,
0.0509702861,
-0.062300805,
0.0324630477,
0.0241850913,
-0.0172229819,
-0.0198306683,
0.0218265858,
0.0022592747,
-0.0065850927,
0.0401280746,
0.0427387208,
0.0241517499,
-0.0360136814,
0.0120243216,
0.0323450789,
0.0397900194,
-0.0008696579,
-0.002280206,
0.0067256284,
-0.0276059806,
-0.0208888184,
0.0187601913,
0.0010724547,
0.0282982625,
0.0361148417,
2.486e-7,
0.0663254634,
0.0602205433,
0.0707346499,
0.0197359622,
-0.0190949589,
-0.017352771,
-0.049837824,
-0.0168039296,
-0.0736293942,
-0.0086214915,
0.0331997611,
0.0151277184,
0.0922385901,
0.0364080258,
-0.0406764634,
-0.0223482959,
-0.0459869467,
-0.0330288038,
-0.0825116783,
0.0403069109,
0.022306839,
0.0867145061,
-0.0152213359,
-0.0509108901,
-0.0177885108,
-0.0462036021,
0.0369695686,
-0.050148841,
-0.0216673166,
0.0164438486,
0.005642395,
0.0175117869,
-0.0247328449,
-0.023706194,
0.0030975582,
0.0021497777,
0.0058605396,
0.1298525482,
0.0309337936,
-0.0123983501,
0.0138173318,
-0.0098514678,
-0.0299686566,
0.0234362148,
0.0348156504,
0.055413533,
0.0147606404,
0.021011468,
-0.0433845222,
0.0156303477,
-0.0069051641,
-0.0059403679,
0.0018088055,
-0.0107614491,
0.0233724769,
0.0152103202,
-0.0572724454,
-0.0861957669,
0.0043849098,
0.0126674362,
-0.0440817326,
-0.0265279096,
-0.0216144901,
-0.0163135044,
-0.0389810726,
-0.0421142578,
0.0004754559,
2.249219589e-34,
0.0567405857,
-0.0206166841,
-0.0318804346,
0.0086390711,
0.0197812878,
0.0027078451,
-0.0301760398,
0.0252672583,
-0.0155651951,
-0.049480807,
0.013743924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14850v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14850v4 | Turkish Native Language Identification | 2023-07-27T13:28:31 | 2023-11-04T11:23:55 | Ahmet Yavuz Uluslu, Gerold Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present the first application of Native Language
Identification (NLI) for the Turkish language. NLI involves predicting the
writer's first language by analysing their writing in different languages.
While most NLI research has focused on English, our study extends its scope to
Turkish. We used the recently constructed Turkish Learner Corpus and employed a
combination of three syntactic features (CFG production rules, part-of-speech
n-grams, and function words) with L2 texts to demonstrate their effectiveness
in this task. | [
0.0240394939,
0.0265564024,
-0.0252260976,
0.0376902297,
-0.0573158525,
0.0373628326,
0.0676196069,
0.0033613059,
0.0280604959,
-0.028075438,
-0.0166764818,
-0.0546981543,
0.0125317816,
0.0129315695,
0.0027642981,
0.0266641732,
0.0225952659,
-0.0198126137,
0.0392436869,
0.0214881934,
0.0439947434,
0.0384251773,
-0.0056611057,
0.0520558357,
-0.036115136,
-0.0155499997,
0.036401391,
-0.0251175929,
0.0019904587,
0.0037085728,
0.048457738,
0.044507198,
-0.0556311756,
0.0583448708,
0.0000015388,
-0.0448812172,
-0.0550449714,
-0.0453144051,
0.0093571926,
-0.0622336753,
0.0700064749,
0.0366361253,
-0.0288354345,
0.0186396763,
-0.0209808834,
-0.0392566808,
0.0289942641,
0.0456370562,
-0.0080526955,
0.0481391922,
-0.0149039086,
-0.062236093,
-0.0150610637,
0.0471825972,
-0.019159168,
0.0174697246,
0.0111801829,
-0.050969936,
-0.0733036101,
-0.0999751538,
0.0275447592,
0.0455802567,
-0.0649310574,
-0.023851756,
-0.0269856006,
-0.0123763522,
-0.0253560096,
-0.0164923649,
0.0375874825,
-0.0248358399,
-0.0286084842,
-0.0663609281,
0.0465627201,
0.0257294625,
-0.0233352967,
0.0233247746,
0.0195334479,
0.0170870479,
-0.1001857519,
-0.019418152,
0.0956519842,
0.042521473,
-0.0210671853,
-0.0355509147,
-0.0121532967,
0.0575006008,
0.0262976605,
0.0171027407,
-0.0132702915,
0.001995119,
0.0466823466,
-0.0112453876,
0.0355610512,
0.0211337395,
0.0159361232,
-0.0180091262,
-0.0253518745,
-0.0918618664,
-0.0364171192,
-0.0689279437,
0.0363172963,
-0.0033317809,
-0.0047957227,
0.0288488623,
-0.0691265017,
-0.0014804146,
0.0643549338,
-0.0206016377,
-0.04155422,
0.004533492,
-0.0114205619,
-0.014313831,
-0.0376703851,
0.0076232678,
-0.0114476196,
0.0363470055,
-0.0465056151,
-0.0284585636,
0.0167893767,
0.0253755115,
-0.048655998,
-0.0638046861,
-0.0403593779,
0.0188527666,
0.0089372257,
-0.0152418837,
0.0136084296,
-0.0234865062,
-0.076620549,
-0.0517376438,
0.0340538137,
0.0484341979,
0.056595318,
0.0246030763,
0.0089526186,
-0.0111453608,
-0.0268959943,
-0.0577179082,
-0.0356499553,
-0.0000622588,
-0.0237412825,
-0.0173997283,
-0.0097082835,
-0.0542580374,
-0.0096979495,
0.0122459829,
-0.0120602185,
-0.0815661773,
-0.0333462134,
0.0156029323,
0.0400727056,
-0.0060193921,
-0.0017522174,
0.0148721952,
0.0398023389,
-0.0319363922,
0.0718062147,
-0.0070204046,
0.0208809189,
0.011531827,
0.0503876694,
-0.0125859221,
0.0311976802,
0.0631288216,
-0.0411918797,
-0.0462883823,
-0.0371537134,
-0.0357378349,
0.0508718006,
-0.0156867485,
-0.007625666,
0.021201212,
0.0578393042,
0.0407394916,
0.0239533968,
0.0901740342,
0.0214188509,
0.020444544,
0.0545272902,
0.0340347812,
0.0651287064,
0.0520902276,
0.0363306403,
-0.0439905003,
-0.0132599976,
-0.0251848847,
-0.0361738279,
0.0783225819,
0.0171010569,
-0.0174547303,
-0.0114431297,
-0.0155613003,
0.001686722,
-0.0281170737,
0.037641611,
0.0002043844,
0.0175361913,
-0.0320282727,
0.0053214883,
-0.0286187902,
0.031657014,
-0.0153223993,
0.058524482,
0.0129631069,
0.0470855348,
-0.0450498164,
0.044720836,
-0.0338842571,
-0.0195009038,
0.017631501,
-0.001924085,
-0.0351045765,
0.0277023837,
-0.0165997706,
0.0371740386,
0.0422726497,
0.0234824009,
0.0299860649,
-0.0246188622,
0.0250024423,
0.010249896,
-0.006722061,
-0.0238722134,
0.0498293601,
-0.036349833,
-0.0342772938,
0.0403832607,
0.010057996,
-0.0135299247,
0.0235522315,
-0.0152328061,
-0.0010165946,
-0.0124091571,
-0.047213532,
0.0289319698,
0.0618191957,
-0.0187349711,
-0.0424389727,
0.0286249295,
-0.0019639519,
-0.0185498446,
0.0107722031,
-0.0042969682,
-0.0445156321,
0.0415909588,
0.0272855703,
0.0420174114,
-0.0318863541,
0.0421070345,
-0.0004900209,
-0.0210196637,
-0.0284411535,
0.012468012,
0.044552438,
0.0349662565,
-0.0652158931,
-0.069678545,
0.0733703896,
0.0037244773,
-0.0519132912,
-0.0013553612,
-0.0580873564,
-0.0238591135,
0.0324116871,
0.0167164132,
-0.0140256165,
-0.012049132,
-0.0408816934,
-0.0062949304,
-0.035281457,
0.0777334794,
0.0050871898,
-0.0087847868,
-0.0301785693,
-0.0116916979,
-0.0409880243,
-0.0334575064,
0.0409790836,
-0.0756693929,
0.0433070883,
-0.0242844652,
0.0003079138,
-0.0079393759,
0.0016844841,
-0.0054974928,
0.0175754633,
0.0316543318,
-0.0674315467,
-0.0268982798,
0.0087365378,
0.0167108402,
0.0187583752,
0.004263931,
-0.0246140193,
-0.0246445928,
0.0058559342,
0.0201835297,
0.0283484887,
-0.0401208028,
-0.0329933837,
0.0260548107,
-0.0140042715,
0.0341114327,
-0.0508925654,
0.0205609277,
-0.0025680715,
-0.011211887,
-0.0073890816,
0.0159151945,
0.053467039,
-0.004857996,
-0.0211057551,
0.0213672407,
0.016223222,
-0.0432792492,
0.0341005586,
-0.0309777558,
-0.0145618357,
-0.0185966622,
0.0362762809,
0.0176627263,
-0.0233447794,
0.0181015432,
-0.0551409274,
-0.0045957291,
-0.0572229214,
-0.0190140978,
-0.0341469459,
0.0163732488,
0.0314211659,
0.0355831049,
0.0422094129,
-0.0557243489,
-0.0078070662,
0.0136557417,
0.0521651581,
-0.0118217301,
0.0323196761,
-0.0492054969,
-0.0384197943,
-0.0153987333,
-0.0378043689,
-0.046459794,
-0.0425239988,
-0.0007111775,
-0.0147307683,
0.0325416028,
-0.0360599272,
-0.0006555758,
-0.0093913563,
0.0209466442,
0.0543756075,
-0.0013570859,
0.0213047694,
-0.019836247,
0.0865472928,
0.0137780542,
-0.0387588441,
-0.0230317023,
0.0289224721,
0.0307708029,
0.0281900223,
-0.0278072935,
0.0195092559,
0.0143675366,
-0.0262096301,
0.016433619,
-0.0551652499,
-0.0385315828,
0.0108343074,
0.0305967387,
-0.0219594631,
-0.0048617278,
0.0861630216,
0.0228028186,
-0.034518946,
-0.0318778157,
-0.016513383,
-0.0228949953,
0.0252639204,
0.0509782247,
0.0066108066,
-0.0085795345,
0.0234472919,
0.0160140861,
-0.0430469178,
0.0051647802,
0.0062041976,
-0.0639312491,
0.0009475531,
0.0218485948,
-0.0829030797,
0.0218878724,
-0.0112443175,
-0.0283761844,
-0.0153219039,
-0.0787680373,
-0.0019746148,
-0.0400678664,
0.0296245199,
0.0256468765,
-0.0946444497,
-0.068767257,
-0.0112969829,
-0.0186537374,
0.0051756431,
-0.0071433312,
-0.0206647441,
-0.0403959788,
0.0399320722,
0.0087904278,
-0.0386601798,
0.0054818555,
-0.0186778046,
0.054177735,
0.0033530009,
0.0033763996,
-0.0606965199,
0.0239188578,
-0.020707801,
-0.0035896567,
0.0206895079,
-0.0083402116,
0.0172275119,
-0.0026897339,
0.0404255055,
0.0235669985,
0.0249748565,
0.025401663,
0.0271233339,
-0.0315608829,
-0.0281565506,
-0.0611220077,
0.008678738,
-0.0183450431,
-0.0472982079,
0.0091945827,
0.0133282216,
-0.038557414,
-0.0735595003,
0.0013854717,
0.0339929685,
0.022499932,
0.0341234356,
0.0468369573,
-0.0333350003,
-0.026213089,
-0.0194861554,
-0.004618899,
-0.0137573937,
0.0072774738,
-0.0575561523,
-0.0034433659,
0.0637576804,
-0.0082866596,
0.000214973,
-0.0058111013,
-0.0735957846,
-0.016125381,
0.0445176847,
0.0023262049,
0.0104162199,
-0.005399616,
-0.0109110232,
-0.0283016283,
-0.008589129,
0.0132645816,
-0.020472277,
0.0091265421,
0.0184045546,
-0.0201636869,
-0.0523164235,
0.0132044917,
0.0078071267,
0.0254631527,
0.0670247599,
-0.075646624,
-0.0011855665,
0.0172678512,
-0.0036289659,
0.0619059205,
0.0302911177,
-0.0425838791,
0.0226993822,
-0.0613070019,
-0.0177074149,
0.0101468824,
0.0185638014,
0.0112209665,
0.0025838378,
0.0127613004,
0.0198695827,
-0.0249289609,
0.0017278362,
-0.0293690488,
0.0205918811,
-0.0228087064,
0.0435829647,
0.0164028984,
0.0495395586,
-0.016483115,
0.0218361095,
-0.0210915934,
0.0512671433,
0.0128245121,
0.0567813739,
-0.0217905119,
0.0233884845,
-0.0151398657,
0.0095908763,
-0.0256725717,
0.0481409803,
0.0082606198,
0.0155876596,
-0.0173354484,
0.0032217843,
0.0818216279,
-0.0713896304,
0.0566100739,
-0.0297518186,
0.0167224407,
-0.0368279405,
0.0453068204,
0.0153511511,
-0.0513748974,
-0.0255944598,
-0.0622531064,
-0.041405838,
0.0045537222,
0.0611420125,
0.0220349263,
-0.0272439849,
0.0082744183,
0.0133933825,
-0.0191660263,
-0.0089921718,
0.0246502813,
0.0179653931,
-0.0225952007,
0.0010883124,
-0.0729007497,
-0.0407795645,
0.0341047719,
-0.012681759,
0.0356365331,
-0.0362333357,
-0.0002971751,
0.0301993359,
0.0141213648,
0.0061942153,
-0.0595939867,
-0.0015532863,
0.0136664174,
-0.0031977938,
-0.0201758258,
-4.732783804e-33,
-0.0013156279,
-0.0422896929,
-0.0453954302,
0.0359095857,
0.0747879446,
-0.0560437962,
0.008718743,
0.0300211739,
0.0230261814,
-0.0166988205,
-0.0583682954,
0.0113751199,
0.0241372176,
-0.0174833033,
-0.0220107194,
0.0020249977,
0.03094556,
-0.0264867395,
-0.0258012228,
0.0082342131,
0.0821346715,
0.0211588554,
0.1036983952,
-0.0458862036,
-0.004118084,
-0.0404937305,
-0.0051783123,
0.0052762865,
-0.0013080995,
0.018373847,
-0.0188895389,
0.0339734256,
0.0160740186,
-0.0031989962,
-0.0055077928,
-0.0076631159,
-0.0116666397,
-0.018333409,
-0.0372036621,
0.0284187235,
0.040546611,
-0.0431324132,
-0.0199631788,
-0.0381577276,
-0.0652307346,
0.0339432918,
0.0661002547,
-0.0098507348,
0.007606368,
-0.0162539016,
-0.0723287091,
0.0512375496,
-0.010580617,
0.0654034466,
0.0606287047,
0.0817315653,
-0.0055016251,
-0.0965335816,
-0.0262960084,
0.0140325138,
-0.0112081002,
0.0501003638,
0.0137109905,
0.0126038417,
-0.0349335968,
0.0347839631,
0.0235813782,
0.0195245892,
-0.0084777633,
0.0354128666,
0.0416567363,
-0.0515358932,
0.0245897286,
0.0722432211,
0.0430334285,
-0.0649547726,
-0.0472136661,
0.0366480313,
0.0735304207,
-0.0059300126,
-0.0275307987,
-0.0593435615,
-0.0396058001,
-0.0559574403,
-0.0208443999,
-0.031225156,
0.0212460943,
-0.0163296685,
0.0236118045,
-0.0385401174,
0.0078324182,
-0.0654717088,
0.0348781273,
-0.0094702179,
0.0467856899,
-0.0189454667,
0.0081126913,
0.0532594174,
-0.0323226303,
0.0347972549,
-0.0276265852,
-0.0747277066,
-0.0290183239,
-0.0201487951,
0.0616651401,
0.0242485534,
0.041288659,
0.0185163841,
-0.0607568845,
0.045404207,
0.014355476,
0.0317674987,
0.0283485204,
0.0353549235,
0.0117976312,
-0.0162485261,
0.0365067422,
0.0069557396,
0.0453360528,
-0.0141186081,
-0.0158672538,
-0.0632884428,
-0.024823945,
-0.020128008,
-0.0137138097,
0.0228393562,
0.0028862157,
0.0195965618,
0.0319940746,
0.0141119407,
0.0434053466,
-0.0384395048,
2.256e-7,
0.0040321285,
-0.0148307486,
0.0137343854,
-0.0164178107,
0.0332565829,
-0.0047358219,
0.0000687544,
0.0098235235,
0.0062145079,
0.0685784891,
0.0040235813,
-0.0529490001,
0.0971804783,
-0.0025608568,
-0.1237200052,
0.0055338312,
-0.01233612,
0.0653934255,
-0.0414340347,
0.0581957139,
-0.0136253061,
0.0599129722,
-0.0090493774,
0.0031002855,
-0.0319114178,
-0.0706243441,
0.0229234379,
-0.0425653681,
-0.0158673748,
0.0523131639,
0.0756436586,
-0.0335372426,
0.0105944565,
0.0030153014,
-0.0431188457,
0.0345602147,
0.0115458621,
0.0856331959,
0.0075891088,
0.0761381611,
0.0138156526,
0.022809973,
-0.0147909271,
-0.0248012487,
0.0460126027,
0.0400303118,
-0.0454168916,
-0.0194529537,
0.0639631003,
-0.0426012501,
-0.0410011709,
0.015926417,
-0.0354050212,
0.0504358374,
0.0272429772,
-0.0213626679,
0.0142264133,
-0.0204654355,
-0.0217954256,
0.0412607156,
0.0096674887,
-0.0106279962,
0.0152700804,
0.0121878507,
0.0340900347,
0.0136203282,
0.0273085646,
1.819881872e-34,
0.0033442276,
0.026008483,
-0.0088953488,
0.0197294895,
0.0258063953,
-0.0082309963,
0.0198796522,
0.0449936204,
0.003216255,
-0.0267448761,
0.0210646484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14818v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14818v1 | What Makes a Good Paraphrase: Do Automated Evaluations Work? | 2023-07-27T12:51:16 | 2023-07-27T12:51:16 | Anna Moskvina, Bhushan Kotnis, Chris Catacata, Michael Janz, Nasrin Saef | cs.CL | cs.CL | Paraphrasing is the task of expressing an essential idea or meaning in
different words. But how different should the words be in order to be
considered an acceptable paraphrase? And can we exclusively use automated
metrics to evaluate the quality of a paraphrase? We attempt to answer these
questions by conducting experiments on a German data set and performing
automatic and expert linguistic evaluation. | [
0.0352526382,
0.0192745589,
-0.0197509117,
0.0330528729,
-0.0828967914,
-0.0036937683,
-0.0102887917,
-0.0014403259,
-0.065853782,
-0.0504135862,
0.0122433985,
0.0248231683,
0.0415361412,
-0.0345371813,
0.024206344,
-0.0862893909,
0.0090711173,
-0.0107304677,
0.0191965327,
0.0059019863,
0.0225282777,
0.0374833867,
0.016805226,
0.0493299924,
0.0598201975,
0.0127986735,
0.0463468544,
0.0254694335,
0.0272886809,
0.0234251991,
-0.0060045458,
-0.0383249335,
-0.0083504766,
0.0227360725,
0.0000015034,
-0.0775366202,
-0.0311143529,
-0.0054697176,
0.0229296926,
0.0506223142,
0.0958162099,
-0.0344542228,
0.0241487995,
-0.0064760474,
-0.0272000488,
0.0314216949,
0.0075461129,
-0.0006938024,
0.1062517613,
0.0067302412,
-0.0176410936,
-0.0924746543,
-0.0274965577,
0.0335868038,
-0.0242748074,
-0.0183899961,
-0.0040428885,
0.019525392,
-0.0174571481,
-0.0382541642,
-0.0150547512,
0.0397048704,
-0.0404581018,
0.0481577069,
-0.0008285229,
-0.0397441946,
-0.0446091406,
-0.0202434398,
0.0275552478,
0.0522559434,
-0.0127548706,
-0.0406522304,
-0.0037369167,
-0.0243053082,
-0.0202281512,
0.0743625313,
-0.0494770668,
0.0111029893,
-0.0096108317,
0.0028253691,
0.0137982424,
0.0543841347,
-0.0146357501,
0.0307621378,
-0.0069051203,
0.0266329311,
0.0241356883,
-0.0288946629,
-0.0439717285,
0.0177185684,
-0.0478098169,
0.0125936121,
0.0161010493,
0.0093011716,
0.0132677425,
-0.0023674988,
-0.0452060923,
-0.0711245909,
0.0486659184,
-0.0278288331,
0.0630313307,
0.0057160077,
0.010859184,
0.039473366,
-0.0262611397,
0.0432441421,
0.0063394019,
0.0450940467,
-0.078360118,
-0.0297069717,
-0.0594634749,
0.0487043634,
-0.0708739907,
0.0297922418,
0.0108509688,
-0.02005977,
-0.0526507124,
-0.0268535316,
0.0357750803,
-0.018560918,
-0.0290957261,
0.0154070212,
-0.0398476161,
0.0180067997,
-0.0142740542,
0.004177128,
-0.0645694137,
0.0279757436,
-0.0581994168,
-0.0254441705,
-0.0068382355,
0.0384448431,
0.0524525717,
-0.0082582729,
0.0104744351,
0.0436813012,
0.0235077608,
-0.0068036015,
-0.0083735958,
-0.0452320836,
-0.0090581719,
-0.0585060902,
-0.0200319625,
-0.0551907532,
0.0463902801,
0.015148513,
0.0151784951,
-0.0314535089,
-0.0045653135,
0.0170098804,
-0.0172273032,
0.0282881539,
-0.009246273,
0.0044108597,
-0.0243421085,
-0.0160686634,
-0.0521341115,
0.0013729548,
0.045754984,
0.0144111253,
0.0602044761,
0.0216172002,
-0.0003750014,
-0.0149663789,
0.0054301783,
-0.0024179567,
-0.0106558157,
0.0379627831,
-0.0354759768,
0.0462467819,
0.0170533545,
0.0491632894,
-0.0378996357,
0.0240521561,
0.062651135,
0.0745195821,
0.0280685537,
0.030713724,
0.0574434735,
0.0412908755,
0.0465865582,
0.0345503502,
0.0252980907,
-0.0310613606,
0.0222870465,
0.0697149187,
-0.0261898022,
0.0530609637,
0.0361572243,
-0.0298589449,
-0.0120616993,
-0.0068682088,
0.0077840597,
-0.0155148851,
-0.0203205869,
0.0197715387,
-0.0165464543,
0.0599372908,
-0.0351071805,
-0.0278820824,
-0.0030704078,
-0.0324650593,
-0.0192810372,
0.0684768707,
0.0642938614,
-0.0041772602,
0.0159903653,
-0.0273262281,
-0.0030352746,
0.0188157819,
0.0341751799,
-0.0063824006,
0.0388738811,
-0.0609535351,
0.0016653567,
-0.0387466066,
0.0326088071,
-0.0289330781,
0.0067340462,
0.0036554369,
0.0431172177,
-0.0440087318,
-0.081265457,
0.0322599001,
0.0310038552,
-0.0015315821,
-0.0000504446,
0.0039999885,
-0.0185876526,
0.0336467028,
-0.020561045,
0.052560553,
-0.0295768958,
-0.0495544747,
-0.0042205085,
0.0642135888,
0.0047837477,
-0.0265153628,
-0.02510616,
-0.1078758538,
-0.0053896508,
0.0117933135,
-0.0129085751,
-0.0302196667,
0.0273129474,
-0.0884495229,
0.0425108001,
-0.0259896889,
0.0373939462,
-0.0577734299,
0.0151351672,
-0.0288589969,
0.0444045402,
0.0520710535,
0.0269043427,
0.0064543253,
-0.044919841,
0.0637008846,
0.0129303839,
-0.0285823159,
-0.0400073603,
0.0081319911,
0.0433630198,
0.0039720833,
-0.0191954691,
-0.0486076623,
0.0042117024,
-0.0468708538,
-0.0047776126,
-0.0034586147,
-0.0125772571,
0.0599351339,
0.007023233,
0.0089791389,
0.0183979776,
0.0516199991,
-0.017650241,
-0.0014769216,
-0.0171338338,
0.0618635379,
0.022279378,
-0.0178064629,
-0.0634512305,
0.0015575716,
0.0005455906,
0.0592115261,
0.0530015491,
-0.0039713103,
-0.0257377755,
0.0047345171,
-0.0397405922,
-0.0421316475,
0.0280268379,
-0.0560741164,
-0.0161944404,
-0.001946801,
-0.001927912,
0.0548254251,
0.0228288267,
-0.0671909824,
0.049301438,
0.0370634124,
-0.0260078218,
-0.0671041831,
-0.0064090979,
-0.0071138288,
0.003882596,
-0.0588695407,
0.0340426564,
-0.0230264757,
0.0710221156,
-0.0055080219,
-0.0359714255,
0.0398727134,
-0.0516846366,
0.0039099189,
-0.0375217572,
-0.0246531591,
-0.033305008,
0.046190463,
0.0075374199,
-0.0115275951,
0.0915308595,
-0.0172234625,
0.0071176863,
-0.0811229795,
-0.0544693209,
-0.0269205049,
0.0278163496,
-0.0439705923,
0.0529798158,
0.006247119,
0.0170839224,
-0.027040204,
-0.04242732,
0.1038096398,
-0.0147001417,
0.0408373773,
-0.0507485494,
0.021459762,
0.0326725729,
-0.021961581,
0.0164379887,
-0.0970641598,
-0.0476295687,
0.0095413048,
0.0247089379,
-0.0009780236,
0.0027976553,
-0.0021355948,
0.0496265702,
0.0223554075,
-0.0107573383,
-0.0062344563,
-0.0353985801,
0.0224166308,
0.0324978195,
0.0077764164,
0.0051680161,
-0.0173622817,
0.0049345093,
-0.0111063607,
0.0361887664,
0.0310665946,
-0.03258029,
-0.0228062384,
-0.0334941074,
-0.0431726016,
-0.0412847996,
-0.0221947804,
0.0163331404,
-0.0061608404,
0.0109284837,
0.064531669,
0.0030954713,
0.0098527195,
-0.0016920953,
-0.027580006,
0.0085995812,
-0.0153821502,
-0.0004471988,
-0.0399353094,
-0.0077089849,
-0.0169192739,
0.0431475267,
-0.0174491629,
0.0013880916,
-0.0239362456,
-0.0452834889,
0.0133135812,
0.0110773863,
-0.0173961781,
-0.048791796,
-0.0041332883,
-0.0445972681,
0.0072826613,
-0.0248701554,
-0.0041655828,
-0.0593558066,
0.032381583,
-0.0323910005,
-0.0507681072,
-0.0466573425,
0.0198290795,
-0.0576395392,
0.0184037741,
0.0277719367,
0.0619588159,
0.0041825548,
0.0152404532,
-0.0316605344,
-0.0477428436,
0.0007313084,
0.0366500579,
0.0399981663,
0.0119312378,
0.0144626955,
0.0009443889,
-0.0339508504,
-0.0036751649,
-0.008897881,
0.0431096479,
0.0265650488,
-0.0080299778,
0.0035007675,
0.0138637945,
0.0618982129,
-0.0111351274,
0.0824443772,
0.0616801083,
0.0227977745,
-0.0097425599,
0.0274274796,
0.0050493288,
-0.0882758424,
-0.0706080124,
0.0289410204,
-0.0525937304,
-0.0170390066,
-0.0761916712,
-0.040025197,
-0.0328417942,
0.054294318,
0.0424742214,
0.0705410987,
-0.0392775573,
0.0307806768,
-0.0083307363,
0.0095967175,
0.0089603662,
0.0167094525,
0.035181459,
0.0079466132,
0.0711686015,
0.0196963176,
-0.0304531865,
0.0193778351,
-0.03232022,
-0.0176260844,
0.0295908302,
0.0117596658,
0.0320882462,
0.0113845626,
-0.0067234193,
-0.0151011124,
0.0335821286,
-0.0280177053,
-0.0352473147,
0.0475654267,
0.0374935679,
0.0032298074,
-0.0288787801,
0.0293703638,
-0.0370900556,
-0.0189535897,
-0.004704616,
0.0349218398,
-0.0174658634,
-0.0400749408,
0.0400686748,
0.0517184325,
-0.0206097793,
-0.0432136171,
-0.0008176624,
0.0376894586,
-0.0066083074,
0.0099432347,
-0.0123041105,
-0.024776116,
0.0036639795,
0.0539072081,
0.037516892,
-0.0242386311,
0.0213357881,
-0.0566852614,
-0.0201910026,
0.003533761,
0.0041688308,
0.006101266,
0.0193436649,
-0.0291186944,
0.001302761,
-0.0446951501,
-0.0087865591,
-0.0427457616,
-0.0038286301,
-0.0078804437,
-0.0042626522,
0.01340973,
-0.0254772753,
-0.0616649799,
0.0503347404,
-0.0732540637,
-0.0364557169,
-0.0160188228,
0.0388359576,
0.0378683247,
-0.0120031703,
0.0925116464,
-0.0039514871,
-0.0077746981,
0.0215245187,
0.0718628466,
-0.0190750435,
0.0301302392,
-0.0053750607,
-0.0192201044,
0.0203488227,
0.0044524125,
0.0276166275,
0.0243917275,
0.0174464118,
-0.0165411569,
-0.0233365819,
-0.0309382807,
-0.0463122651,
-0.0266313124,
0.0114300624,
0.0076250033,
-0.0308577064,
-0.060343504,
-0.0100746835,
0.0185422469,
0.0290619899,
0.0225281119,
-0.0416955613,
0.0559994094,
0.0492179543,
0.0108839739,
-0.0122063104,
-0.0514658056,
0.0593890734,
0.0270757023,
0.0037887434,
-0.0728182569,
-5.441614612e-33,
0.0041287122,
0.0259865429,
-0.0217952337,
-0.0278850682,
-0.0093867658,
-0.0221033413,
-0.0312105697,
-0.0331965648,
-0.0050878888,
0.0090679508,
-0.0046625622,
-0.0027545458,
0.027704265,
-0.0167633593,
0.0263667572,
-0.0103083253,
0.0238498747,
-0.0049396772,
-0.0541536622,
-0.0360279307,
-0.0141949356,
0.0074167196,
0.03399406,
-0.0814655274,
0.018333409,
-0.0431549475,
-0.0214518961,
-0.0658517852,
0.0474541485,
0.0236233361,
0.0306757856,
0.0577218235,
0.0156950373,
-0.0232563931,
-0.0236337036,
-0.0289184973,
-0.0629340038,
-0.020244116,
0.1019724607,
0.001358205,
-0.0606936961,
-0.0264870208,
0.0489223711,
-0.0367411673,
-0.0120885223,
0.0290465206,
0.0671609864,
-0.0280665737,
0.0081004007,
-0.0066109458,
-0.0465243421,
-0.0027482293,
0.0001334081,
0.0288784523,
0.0342047885,
0.0547277741,
-0.0221382137,
0.0474404581,
-0.0101163583,
0.0433795303,
-0.033344049,
0.0147531703,
0.0011257395,
-0.0407256372,
-0.0010688317,
0.016036557,
-0.0123320883,
-0.035758134,
0.0134851225,
0.0076546809,
0.0100066876,
0.0183138754,
0.0446503088,
0.0927263424,
0.0051673208,
0.0363144167,
0.0237097759,
0.0101725003,
0.0157437064,
-0.0062635331,
0.0306037795,
-0.0257952511,
-0.0370308198,
-0.0045377663,
-0.0388909951,
-0.0314189196,
-0.0054638777,
-0.0327274501,
0.0314750299,
0.0115548335,
-0.0737903863,
-0.0226536691,
0.0208826251,
-0.0371894054,
0.001824117,
-0.0230520535,
-0.0343603343,
0.0418507569,
-0.0048569725,
0.0231441129,
0.0100419717,
-0.0201779567,
-0.0136860525,
0.0984193385,
0.0826734081,
-0.0477311462,
0.0064406767,
0.0088159274,
-0.0133936377,
0.0168684255,
0.005142787,
-0.0777789727,
-0.0442792475,
-0.1103743017,
-0.034327466,
0.0668006539,
0.0134274038,
-0.0271523483,
0.0086970832,
-0.0296062361,
0.0130146677,
0.0041377414,
0.043919798,
0.0362817645,
-0.0438431278,
0.0138510447,
-0.0155070284,
-0.0163440462,
0.0028216434,
-0.0078320019,
-0.0045383372,
-0.0490850545,
2.296e-7,
0.0735867545,
0.0431630649,
0.0032221666,
-0.0083925249,
-0.037730176,
0.0175717883,
0.0254586041,
0.0091263987,
-0.0191011783,
0.0087351426,
0.0513481982,
0.011689065,
-0.0135752168,
-0.0142978905,
-0.0877120867,
-0.0255841184,
-0.0746341571,
0.0116459625,
-0.0398404039,
-0.0191288777,
0.0765323043,
0.0797286779,
0.0238697976,
-0.0000769751,
-0.0453303717,
-0.0768456236,
0.038509164,
-0.0265580975,
-0.0287854373,
0.0287040547,
0.0480845608,
0.0279025845,
-0.0177850388,
0.0296069812,
0.0104401158,
-0.0083027435,
0.0791951939,
0.0459175557,
-0.0017265533,
-0.0071270745,
-0.0362375192,
-0.0588056147,
0.0111065852,
-0.0635289997,
0.0400810204,
-0.0587642305,
0.0108917356,
0.0026255145,
-0.0417350903,
0.0292579681,
0.0360315591,
-0.0106145591,
-0.0446829498,
0.0062880274,
0.0142363282,
0.0224734619,
-0.0336130597,
-0.0439288318,
-0.0261263084,
0.0243963301,
-0.0006099163,
-0.0330612659,
0.013376792,
-0.0003114758,
0.0345789008,
-0.0745752528,
0.0099473037,
1.470288475e-34,
0.0491544046,
-0.0034261378,
0.0365221724,
-0.0064785178,
0.0385787636,
-0.0074390974,
-0.0136227468,
0.0039369697,
-0.0130256591,
0.0166211072,
-0.0191959962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14817v1 | Models of reference production: How do they withstand the test of time? | 2023-07-27T12:46:38 | 2023-07-27T12:46:38 | Fahime Same, Guanyi Chen, Kees van Deemter | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, many NLP studies have focused solely on performance
improvement. In this work, we focus on the linguistic and scientific aspects of
NLP. We use the task of generating referring expressions in context
(REG-in-context) as a case study and start our analysis from GREC, a
comprehensive set of shared tasks in English that addressed this topic over a
decade ago. We ask what the performance of models would be if we assessed them
(1) on more realistic datasets, and (2) using more advanced methods. We test
the models using different evaluation metrics and feature selection
experiments. We conclude that GREC can no longer be regarded as offering a
reliable assessment of models' ability to mimic human reference production,
because the results are highly impacted by the choice of corpus and evaluation
metrics. Our results also suggest that pre-trained language models are less
dependent on the choice of corpus than classic Machine Learning models, and
therefore make more robust class predictions. | [
0.0679158568,
0.048005987,
0.0029004416,
0.0137383342,
-0.0393392332,
-0.0219062176,
0.018697517,
0.0106080994,
-0.04634922,
-0.1149812639,
-0.0355293155,
-0.0203130525,
-0.0053784116,
0.0112333382,
0.0348806791,
-0.0409903377,
0.0415163152,
0.0018847375,
0.0008837269,
0.0255446583,
-0.016423529,
-0.0029212148,
-0.0017666665,
0.0409281738,
-0.072097756,
0.0150307678,
0.0608558655,
-0.0193541162,
-0.0244403072,
-0.0242956858,
0.0164718628,
0.0467224047,
-0.0247220192,
-0.0309599023,
0.0000017899,
-0.082164377,
0.0153704435,
-0.0032213356,
-0.0086224377,
0.043866694,
0.0730898529,
0.0149087301,
-0.0020698265,
0.0012477038,
-0.0466275513,
-0.0148487566,
0.0631061569,
0.0379355103,
0.04259976,
0.0583087727,
-0.0031254699,
-0.0404325761,
0.0091860443,
-0.0289414432,
0.0219304617,
-0.0631523132,
0.0166070648,
0.0032738408,
0.0041065086,
0.0252793618,
-0.0008227052,
0.0096789757,
-0.0017576343,
-0.00398312,
0.0509183146,
0.0442708358,
-0.0729537681,
0.0016443096,
0.0141819045,
0.0624342002,
0.0000730728,
-0.0477451347,
0.0025937215,
0.024168605,
-0.0086517008,
0.0245730374,
-0.0216909479,
0.0201422162,
0.0150426272,
0.03481948,
0.018390568,
0.0056542945,
0.0114132948,
0.0293270368,
0.0351390429,
0.0371766351,
0.0355049707,
-0.0274828877,
0.0384456851,
0.0495205633,
-0.026057275,
-0.0524449535,
-0.043864321,
-0.0136602158,
-0.0190476291,
0.0363433659,
-0.052407302,
-0.0024884013,
0.0462059602,
-0.0200531464,
0.0188711267,
0.0082521625,
-0.0247788262,
0.0199950952,
-0.0653003752,
0.0618664399,
-0.0085443445,
-0.0308450796,
-0.025118446,
-0.0270029474,
-0.0741172507,
-0.0077933487,
-0.0459857956,
0.0205149222,
-0.0194193013,
-0.0263312813,
-0.0771188512,
-0.0032325042,
-0.0106440401,
-0.0384648964,
-0.0131908813,
0.0318612568,
-0.0404573828,
0.0299864784,
-0.0545252264,
-0.0100109298,
-0.0370119736,
0.0042352984,
-0.01211417,
-0.0905312523,
-0.0188802406,
0.0156712718,
-0.0204421021,
-0.0521838702,
-0.0244186167,
0.0379600786,
0.0235971101,
-0.0237454548,
-0.0187209044,
-0.0605183728,
-0.0461970754,
-0.058717113,
0.0330414958,
-0.045497112,
-0.0008745175,
0.0177614801,
0.0075646536,
-0.0902437195,
0.0089551713,
0.0208558459,
-0.0252843313,
0.0506329574,
0.00416097,
0.0097840531,
-0.0297685303,
-0.015392418,
0.0271910056,
0.0286827423,
0.0191971753,
-0.0594251752,
0.0382301398,
-0.0030964192,
0.0226029996,
0.0107379016,
0.0347443372,
-0.0244536381,
-0.0137188388,
-0.0068438719,
0.0036612777,
0.0475071669,
0.0435528196,
0.0525165126,
-0.0305611063,
-0.0138909481,
0.0281164721,
0.0266764779,
-0.0181615874,
0.0267398395,
0.0767144114,
-0.0184525568,
0.0224965457,
0.017966751,
-0.0484325625,
0.0092189973,
0.0051295962,
0.0371549316,
0.0406767614,
-0.0274579953,
-0.0241463892,
-0.0145686306,
-0.0082683563,
0.002003018,
-0.0375084132,
-0.033944644,
0.0350575894,
0.0481344797,
-0.0217047837,
0.0764184445,
0.048796162,
-0.0613341033,
0.0098428214,
-0.0410814695,
0.0067148604,
-0.0034699896,
0.0469058529,
-0.0066641122,
-0.013712991,
-0.0065152282,
0.003917688,
0.0545209311,
0.0847392306,
-0.0119377784,
0.0056233965,
-0.0084843067,
-0.0165160783,
-0.0393034406,
0.0396202281,
-0.0110624274,
0.0250475463,
-0.0394668803,
0.0327739529,
-0.0663020313,
-0.0440279134,
0.0706050843,
-0.0218246095,
-0.0189090818,
0.0127371708,
-0.0020727993,
0.0485665463,
-0.0172329806,
-0.0305480268,
0.0464657992,
0.0465119854,
-0.0262005217,
0.0424744152,
0.0464092568,
-0.035714902,
-0.0163737871,
0.0244031455,
-0.0473692864,
0.0071437852,
-0.0141928056,
-0.0108364327,
-0.057424143,
0.0190275703,
-0.0211715959,
0.0645024404,
-0.0417747013,
0.0070694471,
0.0180218406,
0.0072131767,
-0.0288921315,
0.0756483003,
0.033920344,
0.0385262705,
0.0436237305,
-0.0002891558,
0.030877104,
-0.0265693925,
-0.0045968653,
-0.0494581386,
0.0111583117,
-0.0244034939,
0.0466423035,
0.0015532481,
-0.0644128323,
-0.017803032,
-0.0310134757,
-0.0137245804,
-0.0111205662,
-0.0075958897,
0.0336267054,
-0.0190626513,
0.0002388318,
-0.0120620709,
0.0069823051,
-0.0092124129,
0.0082865478,
0.0518990159,
0.0624248236,
0.0016932297,
0.0239618979,
-0.0621030852,
-0.0071365801,
-0.010551095,
0.0641313195,
0.049911242,
0.0255080648,
-0.0392429754,
0.053428296,
-0.0126778604,
-0.0108942417,
0.0255033653,
0.0011749238,
0.0163466483,
0.0120797819,
0.0500125028,
0.0193961132,
-0.009121595,
0.006963328,
0.0434225388,
0.0145678045,
-0.0631739795,
-0.0071935197,
-0.0475928187,
-0.058254946,
-0.010943641,
-0.0290108044,
0.0230565909,
0.0369311906,
0.005447323,
-0.008251003,
-0.0170664154,
0.0508864485,
-0.0043278639,
-0.0311799664,
-0.027529018,
-0.0087519744,
-0.014434292,
0.059412472,
-0.0225551613,
-0.0311808586,
0.0333130285,
-0.025125578,
-0.0035539169,
-0.0391975604,
0.0414643623,
-0.02381441,
0.0239490364,
0.0244144276,
-0.0077742138,
0.0508448258,
-0.0099472925,
-0.0285757966,
0.0374150276,
-0.0060462863,
0.0157712698,
0.0568442233,
-0.053545136,
0.0353829414,
0.0415413454,
-0.0156819802,
-0.0694172308,
-0.0432836413,
-0.0373368077,
0.0421559997,
-0.0151546923,
0.0139699848,
-0.0396038778,
0.0218371693,
-0.0086643351,
0.0058257161,
0.0057808245,
-0.043272689,
-0.0135829579,
0.0166568998,
0.0481810607,
0.0067440677,
0.0199209489,
0.0328634121,
-0.0520806015,
0.0187229365,
0.0422997065,
0.0565799326,
-0.0450116061,
-0.0041758968,
-0.0119783739,
-0.0571379028,
-0.057726033,
0.0360891409,
0.0003765779,
-0.050044436,
-0.0707728788,
0.1218001246,
0.0182434991,
-0.0393675677,
0.0158765931,
-0.01123848,
0.0436057858,
0.0288341139,
0.006716101,
-0.0545307361,
-0.0463119522,
-0.0138281835,
-0.0183805358,
-0.0108662471,
-0.049827341,
0.0104376916,
-0.1618146151,
0.0348935649,
-0.0230301972,
-0.0484343842,
-0.0153095163,
-0.0552958325,
0.0283557437,
-0.0259361379,
-0.0020212329,
0.0112994146,
-0.0273535792,
0.0320029519,
0.0153994542,
-0.0277046636,
-0.0525740162,
0.0102868006,
-0.0620937198,
0.0363636091,
0.0900652707,
0.0613844022,
0.0307558384,
-0.024811998,
0.0524754487,
-0.0873144865,
0.0248048715,
-0.0229480453,
0.073410742,
0.0114147095,
-0.008688706,
0.0165652744,
0.0272903796,
-0.0590335317,
-0.001392263,
-0.0020279023,
0.0573541932,
0.0062024086,
-0.007164544,
-0.0346744843,
0.0344644301,
0.0072637117,
0.0943231434,
0.0360994525,
-0.0113941683,
-0.0548276678,
-0.0265564527,
0.0582443252,
-0.0302870385,
-0.0323284045,
-0.0120734395,
-0.0559290946,
0.0069655497,
-0.1148154065,
-0.0371016338,
0.0184271764,
0.0058142021,
0.0090794889,
0.0063708047,
0.0060015656,
-0.0097302515,
0.0099357637,
0.0265985988,
-0.0163517781,
-0.0219914038,
-0.0464831851,
-0.0186062045,
0.0637450665,
-0.0103451023,
-0.0397651307,
0.0281421896,
0.0203765351,
-0.0278807376,
0.0065842695,
0.0655244291,
0.0236979723,
0.0072516403,
-0.0082819555,
-0.0270052478,
-0.0139412144,
-0.0096390555,
-0.0037685086,
0.0393946841,
-0.0073037408,
-0.0243490823,
-0.0164416488,
0.0338055454,
-0.0440734625,
0.033353176,
0.0252128467,
0.0380388089,
-0.0087700952,
-0.0639743209,
0.0496207587,
-0.0063749691,
0.0598552041,
-0.0423536971,
0.0122565525,
-0.0069596046,
-0.0273694918,
-0.0069968756,
-0.0141477007,
-0.0240371637,
0.0228430331,
0.0007076556,
0.039502833,
-0.0214515701,
-0.0188825913,
-0.0632417127,
0.0996774584,
0.0145512018,
-0.0446148179,
0.0703546777,
0.0306356996,
-0.0339137241,
-0.0074246442,
0.0019177129,
-0.0067344625,
-0.0058459276,
0.0516529717,
-0.0239297021,
0.0166783668,
0.0141527178,
0.0097104972,
0.0175389685,
-0.0419170149,
-0.0705756396,
0.0454745814,
-0.0206474625,
-0.0101174451,
0.0534100942,
-0.0371085107,
0.0875122249,
-0.0639480576,
-0.0157526787,
-0.0228562597,
0.0449514575,
0.0114562167,
0.0212125555,
0.0125043709,
-0.0012293441,
-0.0190284513,
0.0074425465,
0.07641083,
0.0427613556,
0.0586380251,
0.0102819093,
-0.0310292803,
-0.038724687,
-0.0215367731,
-0.059078224,
0.0033337232,
0.034393806,
0.0495464392,
-0.0654794276,
-0.0374859832,
0.0712388754,
-0.0113741569,
0.0088898651,
-0.0254622679,
0.0711364001,
0.0636268109,
0.0096702632,
-0.0011566589,
-0.0361553952,
-0.0009793794,
-0.0190909524,
-0.0067068809,
-0.1078144014,
-6.011043912e-33,
-0.0411068127,
-0.0372842625,
0.0015596597,
-0.0113958586,
-0.0247877818,
0.008174466,
-0.0552469641,
-0.0185173806,
-0.0148578985,
0.0226576608,
-0.0251005739,
-0.0185343642,
0.0064644441,
0.020454878,
0.038088493,
-0.0232438743,
0.0323773772,
-0.0226486083,
-0.0318411104,
0.0096689546,
0.0579602085,
0.0249574818,
0.050678324,
-0.0706563964,
0.0036776881,
0.0250020046,
0.0179466475,
0.002464103,
0.0152549464,
0.0623583645,
-0.0299572162,
0.0676026344,
0.0430783108,
-0.0259554368,
-0.0114841107,
0.0097234091,
-0.0932781398,
-0.023091875,
0.0243637655,
-0.0323944092,
0.0132030491,
-0.021995414,
0.0581691191,
0.0051959665,
-0.0345019177,
0.0009270989,
0.0573389158,
-0.0479032174,
-0.0572485775,
-0.0346339531,
-0.102419503,
0.0080416799,
0.0171382912,
0.0087007899,
0.0108495113,
0.0512255095,
-0.0414565168,
-0.0154910544,
-0.0408827849,
0.0227988362,
-0.0357500352,
0.0470376126,
0.0105068218,
-0.0173960961,
0.02895201,
0.0596541837,
0.0086750258,
-0.0111484015,
-0.003590432,
-0.0337692648,
0.0036775987,
0.0750554502,
0.0293254331,
0.0750930607,
0.0339162312,
0.0081993341,
-0.0376125537,
0.0070296112,
0.0274457689,
0.0554273017,
0.0145800812,
-0.0461386628,
-0.0117698219,
-0.0088310186,
-0.0393834151,
0.0054371511,
-0.0183395743,
-0.0326698311,
0.0456227474,
0.0010395458,
0.0117269875,
0.036961738,
0.0312756933,
-0.0049917134,
-0.0147849042,
0.036072731,
-0.02163467,
0.0221781097,
0.0017732396,
-0.0246157795,
-0.0687162951,
-0.0295220353,
0.0130058071,
0.0201125015,
0.0195463728,
0.0057082353,
0.0359744951,
-0.0133367656,
-0.0422799923,
-0.0079606529,
-0.0323803537,
0.012723783,
-0.0274999794,
-0.0294920076,
0.0037457196,
0.0363209508,
0.0129977148,
0.0389739834,
-0.0005416579,
-0.0038699857,
0.0139319571,
-0.0044535575,
0.043932993,
0.0195367783,
-0.029786326,
-0.0107431998,
-0.0168286711,
0.0369653329,
0.0287956428,
-0.0322092362,
-0.0213304833,
-0.0105040036,
2.515e-7,
0.0760067403,
0.0189424288,
0.0149611784,
-0.0045707393,
0.0168529805,
0.0056057605,
0.0143502764,
0.0095170131,
0.0265369937,
0.0093831252,
-0.0118890218,
-0.0210490301,
0.0150261419,
-0.0155754564,
-0.0628414229,
-0.0373742916,
-0.0608498305,
0.0032520045,
0.0051440015,
-0.0189940538,
0.0213316083,
0.0589690022,
0.0028247654,
-0.0266475156,
-0.0437737778,
-0.0462340415,
0.0637795851,
-0.0576232001,
-0.0094872443,
0.0395512022,
0.0367927179,
0.0526804328,
0.0048523354,
0.0454448275,
-0.0110567184,
0.008364656,
0.0373433046,
0.0197034646,
0.023275489,
-0.0464656912,
0.0063987668,
-0.0000252443,
0.0162931718,
-0.0134133957,
0.0419322848,
-0.0512858406,
0.0232130587,
-0.0190328639,
-0.068134971,
0.032483574,
-0.0006104785,
-0.0241068117,
-0.0273331255,
-0.0020367152,
0.0182963889,
0.0099486131,
-0.0386048183,
-0.0475509912,
-0.0333285853,
0.0472539477,
-0.0313824117,
-0.0303722639,
0.0023132314,
-0.0176750943,
0.0356542356,
-0.0333745554,
-0.0040945988,
2.192831447e-34,
0.028607402,
0.009183269,
0.0354202129,
0.046231959,
0.0113912718,
-0.01141035,
-0.0278129745,
0.0118804537,
0.0156000983,
-0.057054624,
0.0037568873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14785v1 | Improving Aspect-Based Sentiment with End-to-End Semantic Role Labeling Model | 2023-07-27T11:28:16 | 2023-07-27T11:28:16 | Pavel Přibáň, Ondřej Pražák | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a series of approaches aimed at enhancing the performance
of Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) by utilizing extracted semantic
information from a Semantic Role Labeling (SRL) model. We propose a novel
end-to-end Semantic Role Labeling model that effectively captures most of the
structured semantic information within the Transformer hidden state. We believe
that this end-to-end model is well-suited for our newly proposed models that
incorporate semantic information. We evaluate the proposed models in two
languages, English and Czech, employing ELECTRA-small models. Our combined
models improve ABSA performance in both languages. Moreover, we achieved new
state-of-the-art results on the Czech ABSA. | [
0.0516488254,
0.0234924983,
0.0049586557,
0.0510936081,
-0.0208460074,
0.0141467284,
-0.0326619931,
-0.0438511372,
-0.0630035251,
-0.0365445204,
-0.0282466896,
-0.0172408447,
-0.0453449972,
0.0409500003,
-0.0323914215,
0.0027492198,
0.0421231911,
0.0392009467,
0.0142537458,
-0.009744918,
0.014788839,
0.020646194,
0.0246935319,
0.0013207659,
-0.0170083866,
0.0104320841,
0.0271511283,
0.0041806465,
0.0619268119,
-0.0155217201,
-0.0100123435,
-0.0023455636,
-0.0186830442,
-0.0186205655,
0.0000020584,
-0.0029369795,
-0.0566645637,
0.0138789741,
0.0584265813,
-0.0239199046,
0.0764126331,
-0.0462998413,
-0.0054469653,
0.0112055186,
-0.0477931537,
-0.0324302278,
0.0533865094,
0.0912378803,
0.048905775,
0.0737495646,
-0.032885775,
-0.010644651,
0.0105653806,
-0.0378507487,
-0.0411675647,
-0.0442621931,
0.0222545657,
-0.016280584,
-0.0617043413,
0.0638848543,
-0.0181209631,
0.0363893248,
0.0341584682,
-0.0193281919,
-0.0194175728,
-0.012525524,
0.0626055077,
0.0112896683,
0.0010469083,
0.0120088961,
0.027723752,
0.0140936961,
0.0119017204,
-0.0088076917,
-0.0335966833,
0.0484719425,
0.0245055147,
0.0123804566,
0.0169612095,
0.0302703716,
0.0676530972,
0.0735589638,
-0.0219180305,
-0.0194254853,
-0.0101436228,
0.0692806467,
-0.0099628679,
-0.0353886001,
-0.0086274398,
0.0344542079,
0.0053192452,
-0.0022100776,
0.0325360335,
-0.0136644049,
0.045477815,
0.0492535271,
0.0130691249,
0.0208647158,
0.0074939588,
-0.04687443,
-0.0227192026,
0.0346434861,
-0.0318754315,
0.0217691064,
-0.0116041861,
-0.0039504664,
0.0181073099,
-0.0088409111,
-0.0404864363,
-0.0107325008,
-0.057865642,
-0.0116407806,
-0.0026117095,
0.0346061774,
-0.0554829873,
0.0004480924,
-0.060268227,
0.0021042908,
-0.0270010885,
0.0158067476,
0.0633001328,
-0.0047264514,
0.0031962912,
0.0312112775,
-0.0146931987,
0.0851238593,
-0.0105884615,
-0.0002658838,
-0.0394218117,
0.0220462438,
0.0159679763,
-0.0115445768,
-0.0022723416,
-0.0293168295,
-0.0179036837,
-0.0094563896,
0.0396108665,
-0.0345722288,
0.0291627552,
-0.0427621081,
-0.0086393403,
-0.0432312228,
0.001693301,
-0.0481209457,
0.0340030827,
0.0035819917,
0.026563555,
-0.0227220673,
0.0148366084,
0.0090216203,
-0.0205219276,
0.0595082305,
-0.0353871137,
-0.0242273938,
-0.0656294003,
0.0233358741,
0.0916979536,
0.0356450155,
-0.0239890013,
0.0151603641,
0.0334835649,
0.0056492751,
0.0059517808,
0.0073411805,
-0.0221796557,
-0.0003140929,
0.0314750113,
-0.0120467767,
-0.0224184413,
-0.0963407904,
0.0171542801,
0.0289417002,
0.0048946403,
-0.0378376208,
0.0416259542,
-0.0392143168,
-0.025159739,
0.0728168413,
-0.0067262612,
0.021693645,
-0.0033906018,
-0.0245128796,
0.004726666,
0.0169696994,
0.0095004467,
-0.0217418093,
-0.0377205424,
0.0235127416,
-0.0227669347,
-0.0545441136,
-0.0022693768,
-0.0378564149,
0.008179443,
0.0047187619,
0.0440875553,
0.0354174823,
-0.0523506962,
0.0513781682,
0.0720902532,
-0.0496954098,
-0.0065761884,
-0.0208651591,
0.0112694241,
0.0333078578,
-0.003354501,
-0.0512813665,
-0.0294015743,
-0.0152417095,
-0.0748522058,
0.0276379548,
0.0094412109,
0.003886363,
-0.0355365798,
-0.0237709712,
-0.0123149129,
0.0067726634,
0.0338012539,
0.0085963281,
-0.026671933,
0.0425252318,
0.0045499238,
-0.0280713663,
0.0184975732,
-0.0173930153,
0.0275002085,
0.0067535923,
0.0195931867,
0.0183874983,
0.0228179228,
0.070167087,
-0.0001687025,
0.00703238,
0.0291822888,
-0.0458154902,
-0.0617422052,
0.0453674458,
-0.0718813613,
-0.0823298022,
0.0006932876,
-0.0014752451,
-0.0048340317,
0.0465165861,
-0.0245265998,
-0.0269021951,
0.0030087677,
-0.017324619,
-0.000341631,
-0.0088857505,
0.0114046345,
0.0351056643,
0.0149890734,
-0.0215128455,
0.0399825051,
-0.04488023,
0.0114347376,
-0.0302205831,
-0.0136424759,
0.0142672826,
0.0031404418,
-0.0630173907,
0.0236856844,
-0.0075108968,
-0.0177042633,
0.0417560264,
-0.0134244524,
0.021967601,
-0.0382330008,
-0.0658698082,
-0.0390916914,
0.0165524837,
0.0414930023,
0.0610101484,
0.007102726,
0.0362085886,
0.0363553986,
-0.0503739975,
-0.0037654634,
-0.0177896898,
0.0054747188,
-0.0242460072,
0.0284539927,
-0.0233464371,
-0.0400657021,
0.0059681451,
-0.0361745059,
-0.0051841005,
0.0219296627,
-0.0093573825,
-0.0519303121,
0.0415762998,
-0.0036198408,
0.0326613337,
-0.0364239626,
-0.0456087515,
-0.052358944,
0.0332851112,
-0.0141152935,
0.0065354118,
-0.0058831265,
0.0444720089,
0.024879422,
0.0079921931,
-0.0066215652,
0.0105829341,
-0.0939160511,
0.0258174129,
-0.0445728265,
-0.0491339751,
0.0484562553,
0.0751480162,
-0.0056493352,
0.0114090582,
-0.0203542486,
-0.0299420655,
-0.0763909146,
-0.0167787485,
0.0462645441,
-0.0087528955,
0.0107098334,
-0.0015762243,
-0.015532719,
0.0529729798,
0.0453014858,
-0.004955336,
0.0135984998,
-0.0759132281,
-0.0041091586,
-0.0506340899,
0.0629860312,
0.0025401164,
0.0364162922,
0.0063402918,
0.0168856923,
0.0272685196,
-0.0563868731,
-0.0137566281,
-0.019556243,
0.0206308402,
0.0446710512,
0.0057958169,
0.0110152708,
-0.0598508418,
0.0283888243,
-0.0692279264,
-0.0257502049,
0.0258320067,
0.0204106532,
-0.0267548561,
0.0075535798,
0.0337944403,
-0.0200398248,
-0.0206377115,
-0.0173468944,
-0.0159967318,
-0.0075346758,
0.0360857807,
0.0625375807,
-0.078996338,
0.0239095222,
-0.0192573089,
0.0239004418,
0.0758948252,
-0.0502157062,
-0.011251267,
-0.0034445419,
-0.0337902717,
0.0500310585,
-0.008598784,
-0.0091595277,
-0.06633275,
0.046428822,
-0.051968351,
-0.0165870171,
0.1043900624,
0.0359125771,
-0.0617996566,
0.0068411911,
0.0024293351,
-0.0025056163,
0.0320453309,
0.0197421908,
-0.0530375727,
-0.0177544747,
-0.0216256399,
0.0155119617,
-0.0515856892,
-0.0085711675,
0.0385859311,
-0.1228334531,
0.0220742505,
-0.0543453619,
-0.0703665018,
-0.0478824452,
-0.0496950597,
0.0294085592,
-0.0670000836,
-0.0211870056,
-0.0438616872,
-0.001672926,
-0.0104676606,
-0.0065708244,
-0.0217125826,
-0.006703123,
0.0217863284,
-0.0078285066,
0.0312460139,
0.0417652577,
0.0522726178,
-0.0132953171,
-0.0248898864,
0.0014607346,
-0.022493897,
0.0006161192,
-0.0340371616,
0.0728516132,
-0.0446120538,
-0.04685333,
0.0012053328,
-0.0213537049,
-0.0401807576,
0.0143586816,
-0.0322362669,
0.0218440779,
0.0320572741,
0.0048283418,
0.0100613963,
0.0129101127,
0.0438613631,
0.0702669695,
-0.0221228469,
-0.039541278,
-0.0126145184,
0.0128472643,
0.0072717103,
-0.0109353662,
-0.0722820312,
-0.053640727,
0.003869097,
-0.0916590244,
-0.0540232733,
-0.0556626879,
-0.0018501066,
0.0017766495,
-0.0154544106,
0.0154106282,
0.0548179485,
-0.0151113048,
-0.0674550757,
-0.0136962375,
-0.0432986878,
0.0287086759,
0.0127426591,
-0.0235020127,
0.0936137512,
-0.0137727102,
-0.0301413964,
-0.0293324813,
-0.007843053,
-0.0140774837,
0.0289016888,
0.0302764028,
0.0087282462,
0.0080179768,
-0.0132533861,
-0.025324218,
0.0024694987,
0.0325904191,
-0.0266139042,
0.0236798301,
0.0348513313,
0.044926405,
0.0070870556,
0.0345541313,
-0.0147691658,
0.0536771007,
0.0159726348,
-0.006193113,
-0.0519546308,
-0.0622856915,
0.0131690437,
0.0019411758,
0.0457356982,
0.060072843,
0.0084197121,
-0.0202755705,
0.0181466509,
-0.0306432527,
-0.0298313145,
-0.0484398231,
0.0078931684,
-0.0014300864,
-0.0059628743,
-0.0386688784,
0.0732657835,
0.0202296767,
-0.0040905867,
-0.0451204479,
0.0526625924,
0.024566127,
0.0084236665,
-0.0478310399,
0.0386517793,
0.0028647128,
-0.0548786409,
0.0533527248,
0.000973354,
0.0039510457,
0.0246519223,
-0.0071283872,
-0.0097375289,
-0.0143643692,
0.0406274013,
-0.0283919051,
0.0313095227,
-0.0270935092,
-0.0018323731,
-0.0090885479,
-0.0365795977,
0.1203383058,
-0.0455972031,
0.0104215406,
0.0178981442,
-0.0186873116,
0.0006759951,
-0.0027226584,
0.0711142793,
-0.0006821965,
0.006511156,
0.0024583146,
0.0106983883,
-0.0696297362,
0.0611960515,
-0.0202105455,
-0.0245262291,
-0.0299618654,
0.028104363,
0.0188541226,
-0.0203106534,
-0.0056641754,
-0.0007318273,
-0.0707826763,
-0.0587722063,
0.0137316799,
-0.0224729087,
0.0170707032,
-0.0014111592,
0.0359590128,
0.0045128451,
0.0386066176,
0.0174377896,
-0.0643757507,
-0.0509631112,
-0.0259207524,
-0.0082828151,
-0.0059902584,
-6.618033195e-33,
-0.0356365032,
-0.0022005588,
-0.0367937237,
0.0268159173,
-0.0101322429,
0.030121265,
-0.0341740325,
0.007773072,
0.0262204427,
0.0626637563,
0.0296345074,
0.008459283,
0.0118392026,
0.0333498642,
-0.0151261371,
-0.0014165899,
0.0754085109,
0.0295814201,
0.0136618465,
0.0360104628,
0.054975383,
0.0041735419,
0.0859969929,
-0.1521560401,
0.0187175907,
0.0220193565,
-0.062147636,
0.0156729911,
0.0224626232,
0.0597939864,
0.0011699917,
0.0357503407,
0.0410893969,
-0.0898951218,
0.0136334477,
0.0134336604,
-0.0548660196,
-0.0175154638,
0.0316279791,
0.0138627244,
-0.01858503,
-0.0336934552,
0.0176174585,
0.0054648891,
-0.0059022913,
0.016890632,
0.0198756829,
0.0027816233,
0.0355276577,
-0.1104122698,
-0.0673464239,
0.0257667787,
0.0204894636,
-0.0314276293,
0.0269594118,
0.0285714883,
0.0339726396,
0.0143903792,
-0.0366932563,
-0.0094289277,
-0.0390312262,
0.0483725555,
-0.0162904579,
0.0036067413,
-0.0081828507,
0.0357731916,
-0.005446082,
0.0301952474,
-0.0099857645,
0.0444246195,
-0.0191546381,
0.0361766815,
0.0255749617,
0.0162115674,
-0.0228323508,
-0.000507606,
-0.0314271972,
0.0120505663,
0.0285906456,
0.0045758095,
0.0784748346,
-0.0076442393,
-0.0533520915,
-0.0176353641,
-0.0137855075,
-0.0020827288,
-0.0378470272,
-0.0010349797,
0.003441208,
0.0272714607,
-0.0804629698,
0.0555657744,
-0.0214923546,
-0.071122475,
0.0018903908,
0.0005247966,
-0.0378802493,
0.0520791598,
-0.0317180194,
-0.0193113014,
-0.0538322553,
-0.0184550732,
-0.0217350908,
0.0152067728,
-0.0159258172,
0.0055057872,
0.0418723896,
0.0217066221,
-0.0730390325,
-0.0044981139,
-0.0167537928,
0.0302121416,
0.0006141515,
0.0599263646,
-0.0009668857,
-0.0033128806,
-0.0368802473,
0.0840427876,
0.0397983044,
0.0401192717,
-0.0120647224,
0.0124281561,
0.0235870313,
0.0376960672,
-0.0239972919,
-0.0184503645,
0.0193346851,
0.0073707551,
-0.0089520663,
-0.0089554042,
-0.0086571993,
-0.0042415163,
2.925e-7,
0.0473389849,
0.0231723245,
-0.0159541648,
-0.0031981943,
0.0204959065,
0.0539765805,
0.037494991,
0.0174864177,
0.0372661948,
-0.0009459511,
0.00023909,
0.0062096631,
-0.0252327677,
0.0086675128,
-0.0565588251,
0.0631983727,
0.0012513462,
-0.0314225256,
0.0212065466,
0.0530336276,
0.0727095678,
0.1132563576,
0.0237309858,
-0.0022428823,
-0.0480819531,
0.0369126685,
0.0642726347,
-0.0071622455,
-0.044014208,
0.0365763269,
-0.0144933406,
0.0133637339,
-0.0118397363,
-0.032526318,
0.0210486092,
0.0354301706,
-0.015356835,
0.0337354131,
0.0052939076,
-0.0580509678,
0.0301669687,
0.0150211621,
0.0023077424,
-0.0109112421,
0.0520453975,
-0.062208876,
-0.063229546,
-0.0507735312,
-0.0408915505,
0.069988437,
-0.0094659012,
0.0185863152,
-0.041701816,
0.0340679027,
-0.0219740141,
-0.0425898619,
-0.0542824529,
-0.051732067,
-0.020833753,
-0.0379865132,
0.0148332696,
-0.0329353288,
0.029167369,
0.0273232814,
-0.041715648,
-0.0124367476,
0.006509921,
2.808469522e-34,
0.034674935,
0.0100713074,
-0.038196221,
0.0460188538,
0.0063368129,
0.0053554941,
-0.0412230939,
0.0146184945,
-0.0125368582,
-0.0143019482,
0.0061511248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14783v1 | Emotion4MIDI: a Lyrics-based Emotion-Labeled Symbolic Music Dataset | 2023-07-27T11:24:47 | 2023-07-27T11:24:47 | Serkan Sulun, Pedro Oliveira, Paula Viana | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | We present a new large-scale emotion-labeled symbolic music dataset
consisting of 12k MIDI songs. To create this dataset, we first trained emotion
classification models on the GoEmotions dataset, achieving state-of-the-art
results with a model half the size of the baseline. We then applied these
models to lyrics from two large-scale MIDI datasets. Our dataset covers a wide
range of fine-grained emotions, providing a valuable resource to explore the
connection between music and emotions and, especially, to develop models that
can generate music based on specific emotions. Our code for inference, trained
models, and datasets are available online. | [
0.0011180607,
0.0552494787,
-0.0128981452,
0.041712977,
0.0021875403,
0.0225575101,
0.0295960177,
-0.0267072488,
-0.0072160126,
0.0240722913,
-0.0873707682,
0.0143978857,
-0.0311579537,
0.003269807,
0.0190790594,
-0.0504288822,
-0.002465426,
0.0708684251,
0.0845408291,
0.0094514517,
-0.0097114937,
0.0568099804,
-0.0109303035,
0.0532930456,
-0.0589744002,
-0.017002441,
-0.0259813517,
0.0606954731,
0.0160317328,
-0.0305095129,
-0.0250878129,
0.0334593579,
0.000686853,
0.0106353825,
0.0000017644,
0.0123889204,
0.0234899987,
0.0064235348,
0.0372263901,
-0.0282981414,
0.0572146289,
-0.0241450369,
-0.0190639105,
0.0063467789,
-0.0129955728,
-0.0410369933,
0.0412327833,
0.0025756503,
0.0860529691,
0.0824667513,
-0.0151117453,
0.0079287384,
-0.0095174555,
-0.0500806086,
0.0315486304,
0.0295760445,
0.0089713791,
0.0305204112,
0.0430610105,
-0.0720162913,
-0.0290505476,
0.0194016527,
0.028223617,
0.0501498058,
0.0386002474,
0.0431808718,
-0.0546942949,
-0.0161416698,
-0.0002553713,
0.0618371442,
-0.005362513,
-0.015688356,
0.0101824692,
-0.0077289017,
0.0160987843,
-0.044024501,
-0.0055192634,
0.0020518941,
0.0037532437,
0.0197423417,
-0.0058736675,
0.0084620323,
0.0221796799,
0.0172256194,
0.0151946582,
-0.0161169805,
-0.0106305908,
-0.0390954986,
0.0632865876,
-0.0401131548,
-0.0249478165,
-0.023597246,
0.009060883,
-0.0336161368,
0.0261790026,
-0.0011785766,
-0.0869145766,
-0.0325050466,
-0.023545431,
-0.0435278416,
0.0190668162,
-0.0018501523,
0.0212035496,
0.0701224729,
0.0179804862,
-0.0271638725,
-0.0046524331,
0.0112569369,
-0.0177607704,
-0.0293159205,
-0.0270167161,
0.0000600306,
-0.0391603708,
-0.0015864992,
0.0397160575,
-0.0323163122,
-0.0246321261,
-0.0199709311,
-0.0474364161,
0.038127929,
0.0165550485,
-0.0032060319,
-0.0116990609,
-0.0033593448,
0.0501427613,
-0.0086466232,
-0.0519790016,
0.0428744517,
0.004073306,
0.0098400312,
0.0264227744,
-0.0221894365,
0.0136880316,
0.0039616195,
0.0790581852,
0.0541161895,
0.0748526827,
-0.0526608974,
0.0046129702,
-0.0351067856,
-0.0127667105,
-0.0392143428,
-0.0414612144,
-0.03283526,
0.0541344061,
-0.0310286563,
-0.0047588702,
-0.0578629263,
-0.0083861155,
0.0039205616,
0.0006780093,
0.0349291265,
-0.0092607839,
-0.0035344369,
-0.0515636764,
-0.0092184814,
-0.0300237518,
0.0106147779,
0.06184946,
0.0617193654,
0.0478663333,
-0.0310139619,
0.0423948467,
0.0159210693,
0.0133655425,
-0.033286199,
-0.0339563899,
-0.0378792733,
-0.008369158,
0.0964917839,
0.007471405,
0.012894596,
0.0194780771,
-0.044199761,
0.0138980271,
0.0391828679,
-0.0001038908,
0.0648408979,
-0.0188144054,
0.0030969575,
0.0402215533,
-0.0496275127,
0.0111531671,
0.065933302,
0.0492832996,
0.0153968679,
0.0528018773,
0.0056263232,
-0.012116136,
-0.0008073167,
-0.0271646604,
-0.0002613022,
-0.0345388427,
0.0113653112,
0.0339882895,
-0.0004174671,
-0.0305749122,
0.0197900534,
0.0206633247,
-0.0754673555,
-0.01082596,
-0.003930802,
0.0555299781,
0.0281148627,
0.0347821638,
-0.0640664995,
0.0213911738,
-0.036616385,
-0.0177265014,
0.023703495,
-0.0339415707,
-0.0308733955,
0.0262881387,
-0.0073780455,
0.0316827185,
-0.0071855136,
-0.0097813234,
0.0126252258,
-0.0526526049,
0.0091035794,
-0.0182798728,
-0.0510974228,
0.0102694184,
0.001809224,
0.0087701203,
-0.0390915684,
0.0452273004,
0.0384935439,
0.0269937199,
0.0207991954,
-0.0293961465,
-0.0059538051,
0.0280330554,
0.0066526211,
0.0212925319,
-0.0125878053,
0.0072731739,
-0.016775962,
0.0483290628,
-0.0337004326,
0.0293170176,
0.0486930124,
-0.030704258,
-0.0200028121,
0.0830571577,
0.0302026141,
0.0187984463,
0.0364167504,
-0.0062814229,
-0.0206088815,
0.0221154485,
0.0437839292,
-0.0042126873,
0.0180392042,
0.0033936461,
-0.005688394,
-0.0188078005,
0.0233155731,
0.0349146761,
-0.0318980627,
0.0509924814,
0.0150227118,
-0.019714782,
-0.0472516753,
-0.0585090891,
-0.0402691849,
-0.0591262169,
-0.0784972161,
0.0358252041,
0.002486489,
-0.0378717855,
0.0052037607,
-0.0367574356,
-0.0315005928,
-0.0218541585,
-0.0351649411,
0.0096422415,
-0.0154127609,
0.0024566208,
-0.0396041423,
-0.0329159945,
-0.0237153657,
-0.0253303126,
-0.0214977749,
-0.0189689584,
-0.0036759635,
-0.0221421365,
0.0482490845,
0.0210342277,
-0.0082949819,
-0.0785982981,
-0.0059892628,
-0.006575611,
-0.0223621447,
0.0003169813,
-0.0484790057,
0.0054275398,
0.0144038992,
-0.0393561535,
0.0508867055,
0.0485329069,
0.0012627704,
0.0098188063,
0.0357664376,
0.0230249986,
0.0376936682,
0.0152369831,
-0.0331624709,
-0.0258269813,
0.0487148315,
0.0461264998,
-0.0286794528,
0.0039285766,
0.0468010195,
-0.0165416207,
0.0325907879,
-0.0003827665,
0.0241751261,
0.0124309184,
0.0122375023,
-0.0087856995,
-0.0434266403,
0.0142645566,
0.0311136786,
-0.023303993,
-0.0153322555,
-0.043781247,
-0.023416236,
0.096140869,
-0.0606059842,
-0.0016293214,
0.0273439679,
0.0095335823,
-0.0159084015,
-0.011756964,
-0.0175691154,
-0.0588861182,
-0.0243414231,
-0.042721387,
-0.0181495585,
0.0134668844,
-0.0282598082,
0.0282409806,
-0.0322007239,
-0.0206730366,
-0.0228958447,
-0.0194955152,
-0.0304869339,
0.0373850353,
-0.075898625,
0.014726718,
-0.0032796145,
0.0065748892,
-0.0008284117,
0.00433699,
0.044138886,
0.0258702319,
-0.0622650497,
0.0225147754,
-0.006840928,
0.0115360552,
0.0008108335,
0.0138061177,
-0.0019514266,
-0.0130576994,
-0.0097548449,
-0.0018535694,
0.0266830288,
0.0130915344,
0.0049391566,
-0.0393060967,
-0.0401982255,
0.0163085125,
0.0951600224,
0.0388810113,
-0.0389019027,
0.0054964405,
0.0512928367,
0.0005083576,
0.0250979308,
-0.0000734787,
-0.0401891582,
-0.030632114,
0.0232247971,
0.0188452546,
0.0124521721,
0.0034112534,
-0.0199409891,
-0.0351525322,
0.008192027,
0.0039725052,
-0.0763474032,
-0.0408078283,
-0.0047496599,
-0.0062991302,
-0.009416542,
-0.027207505,
-0.0281610712,
0.0101141203,
0.0334441178,
0.0052473829,
0.0004619144,
-0.029065568,
-0.0003898621,
-0.0568028241,
0.0726650357,
0.0028946612,
0.101029776,
-0.0160423871,
-0.0308671556,
-0.0016611376,
0.007633382,
-0.0434934609,
0.019950252,
0.0540444702,
0.0267686993,
-0.0274983402,
-0.0151482671,
0.0651370957,
-0.0816881508,
0.0134408269,
0.0221065972,
0.0453944132,
-0.0102174636,
-0.0358253084,
-0.0324272625,
0.0234704278,
0.0211729351,
0.0507090613,
0.0260126125,
-0.043649774,
0.0090796202,
-0.0221569631,
0.0339675322,
-0.0151849119,
-0.0316287167,
-0.0356175229,
-0.0243975017,
-0.0390259176,
-0.0531099029,
-0.0314784162,
0.0341970772,
0.0253957361,
0.0041168332,
-0.0431825779,
-0.0561366081,
-0.0296150651,
-0.0913861096,
0.0603725202,
0.0268501211,
0.0492019802,
-0.0056683607,
-0.0598515049,
0.0045928527,
-0.0001262184,
-0.0147422235,
0.0078083482,
-0.0822022036,
-0.0318568461,
-0.0011217095,
0.0246209875,
0.011741586,
-0.0081815496,
0.0101826675,
-0.0158053953,
-0.0106131453,
0.0215958655,
0.0405882746,
0.0035834496,
0.0735020116,
-0.0026324606,
0.0273541063,
-0.0116753122,
-0.0421340913,
0.0399390198,
0.0390323959,
-0.0163960699,
0.0362509303,
0.0264282022,
0.0226981808,
-0.0245660581,
0.0438703559,
0.0103942286,
-0.0651137829,
-0.0266690683,
-0.0259873345,
-0.0250622593,
-0.0298082046,
-0.0378894024,
-0.0088533526,
0.0445947647,
0.0566352233,
-0.0601640977,
-0.1100136638,
0.0495353267,
-0.0576874092,
-0.0060763513,
-0.0023197769,
0.0152264861,
-0.019757906,
0.0259869564,
0.0115277786,
0.0188279152,
-0.0062811072,
0.0353769921,
-0.007590238,
0.0319578201,
-0.0391358659,
0.021293683,
-0.0247710794,
-0.0110387616,
0.0316143781,
-0.0133794211,
-0.0155012282,
-0.0393034592,
-0.0213101376,
0.0485715903,
0.0044725682,
0.0322794802,
-0.0130727245,
0.0088423239,
0.0197998583,
0.0206118673,
-0.0185421035,
-0.0419370942,
-0.0050446116,
0.0064634937,
-0.009286209,
-0.027740363,
0.0393781736,
-0.0557662919,
0.0612469018,
-0.0030501995,
0.006972265,
0.0049199387,
0.0594507828,
-0.0035856881,
-0.033242844,
0.0268564317,
0.0598999523,
-0.0523219146,
-0.0269701891,
0.0562987588,
0.0049043833,
0.0150154745,
-0.0157879349,
0.0023955083,
0.0051477323,
-0.0098344181,
0.0344716012,
-0.0088479025,
-0.034861505,
-0.0601397045,
-0.0434128344,
-0.0343652852,
-5.04882097e-33,
0.0079493262,
0.032369066,
-0.0841931701,
0.0277023371,
-0.0521116257,
-0.0142117925,
-0.0327618942,
0.0185365416,
0.0311615374,
0.0346751064,
-0.0105280234,
0.0646430105,
-0.0105556622,
0.0210125092,
0.0480492041,
-0.0332193188,
0.0516296923,
-0.012120788,
-0.0264284182,
0.0411148258,
0.0284772087,
0.0342867039,
0.0368301868,
-0.0660905838,
0.0134499958,
0.0064309314,
0.0024613715,
-0.0211632177,
0.0183054265,
0.0283578001,
-0.0069145146,
0.0409214981,
0.0039915941,
0.0206816122,
0.0003752856,
-0.0161479115,
0.0122283762,
-0.034896858,
-0.0347680673,
0.0360216163,
0.0078645451,
-0.0487100631,
0.0049324585,
0.0244452897,
-0.029821964,
-0.0340867117,
0.0505361035,
-0.0284489617,
-0.0206902511,
-0.1333949119,
0.0011865128,
-0.0159295797,
-0.0373294875,
-0.0443229936,
0.0083310576,
0.0689510256,
0.0050418312,
0.0429171063,
-0.005903088,
0.0136416573,
-0.0043015545,
-0.0290418789,
-0.0080668135,
-0.0047647934,
0.0353027806,
0.0868631825,
0.0209984351,
-0.0450396091,
-0.0294763967,
0.0760092288,
0.007686215,
0.0345187038,
0.0491828062,
0.0123503478,
0.0793316513,
0.0049309721,
0.0188748445,
0.0628170967,
0.0269728806,
-0.0368944369,
0.0233633555,
0.0657298416,
-0.0393363535,
0.0357578322,
0.0219999366,
-0.0537432656,
-0.0241665635,
-0.0335314758,
0.0207114443,
-0.0608057119,
0.0014745189,
-0.018377455,
-0.0540027097,
-0.0283463839,
-0.0327298902,
0.0198877566,
-0.0128710307,
0.0589762554,
0.0007343307,
-0.0182487704,
0.0213290341,
-0.001689094,
0.0860029086,
0.0148754735,
0.0850326419,
-0.0196902156,
-0.0047232057,
0.0924058333,
-0.0787070394,
0.0017299027,
-0.0430731885,
0.0064872047,
0.0209633689,
-0.0220522564,
0.0002398499,
0.0133574614,
-0.0087061441,
-0.008411481,
-0.0128300367,
0.028449785,
0.0068699787,
-0.0060070953,
-0.0358018279,
0.0043393672,
0.0017314018,
-0.0082022343,
-0.0289907046,
-0.0574268252,
-0.0041081104,
-0.0178234149,
-0.0247758627,
-0.020421274,
2.525e-7,
-0.0076754061,
-0.0125449253,
-0.0106036635,
0.0043346435,
0.0217416156,
0.0288997833,
-0.1240847036,
0.0192286484,
0.0098388847,
-0.0209651496,
0.0989094973,
-0.0440638922,
0.0872134939,
0.0179323982,
-0.1159922406,
0.0265328735,
-0.0383110419,
0.0075871507,
-0.0763431713,
-0.0276052132,
0.0631313771,
0.1106058806,
0.0874895602,
0.0028491411,
0.0266366377,
0.0284023248,
0.0057932055,
-0.0689624101,
0.0767672434,
-0.0844354033,
-0.0165615585,
-0.0190943759,
-0.0408003666,
-0.0209857635,
-0.0436098911,
-0.0081728278,
0.0410094149,
0.0170426592,
0.0398897603,
-0.004576386,
0.0322809555,
0.0197016578,
0.0122560263,
0.0062432732,
0.030979624,
-0.0265338216,
-0.0446680114,
-0.0432900265,
-0.0337563604,
0.0041908612,
0.0329657048,
-0.0382606015,
-0.0557369627,
-0.0245490056,
0.0030469657,
-0.0441903211,
0.0269737486,
-0.0692259073,
0.0386544801,
0.0410987735,
-0.0299609285,
0.0106800292,
-0.0188866518,
0.0319184959,
0.0222689603,
-0.060437046,
0.0021737772,
1.815328209e-34,
0.0348970406,
-0.0649740249,
-0.0200994052,
0.02213444,
0.0483489595,
-0.0176117122,
-0.0603908449,
-0.035892982,
0.0133841904,
-0.0366807058,
0.0161286648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.16732v1 | LLMediator: GPT-4 Assisted Online Dispute Resolution | 2023-07-27T10:25:29 | 2023-07-27T10:25:29 | Hannes Westermann, Jaromir Savelka, Karim Benyekhlef | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | In this article, we introduce LLMediator, an experimental platform designed
to enhance online dispute resolution (ODR) by utilizing capabilities of
state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4. In the context of
high-volume, low-intensity legal disputes, alternative dispute resolution
methods such as negotiation and mediation offer accessible and cooperative
solutions for laypeople. These approaches can be carried out online on ODR
platforms. LLMediator aims to improve the efficacy of such processes by
leveraging GPT-4 to reformulate user messages, draft mediator responses, and
potentially autonomously engage in the discussions. We present and discuss
several features of LLMediator and conduct initial qualitative evaluations,
demonstrating the potential for LLMs to support ODR and facilitate amicable
settlements. The initial proof of concept is promising and opens up avenues for
further research in AI-assisted negotiation and mediation. | [
0.0817447379,
0.0581701361,
-0.024223676,
0.0158752427,
-0.0736342669,
0.0000681301,
0.0527048819,
0.0459948964,
0.0233462602,
-0.0513845198,
-0.0013834833,
-0.0301808231,
-0.0155459391,
0.0157054495,
-0.0088274861,
-0.0514394976,
-0.0018929864,
-0.0000134993,
0.080105722,
-0.0015244437,
0.0526541956,
0.0249940827,
-0.0271863509,
0.0424358286,
-0.0714038014,
-0.0066400073,
-0.0355427824,
0.0122766513,
-0.0015289999,
-0.0084585873,
-0.016484892,
0.095799692,
0.0252516121,
0.0668998957,
0.0000021291,
-0.0780907199,
0.0148814498,
0.0215981659,
-0.0122463647,
0.0279627834,
0.0491302349,
-0.0360369794,
-0.0475483835,
0.0446714908,
-0.0487666391,
0.0057799844,
0.0168702286,
0.0479115099,
0.0612939,
0.0616753846,
-0.0255677607,
-0.0187249761,
0.036360994,
-0.0309366267,
-0.0616737083,
-0.0571039617,
0.0136188995,
0.0108856149,
0.0350103043,
-0.0294552017,
0.016647134,
0.0166579653,
0.0103221387,
-0.0498819165,
-0.118193008,
-0.0030630885,
-0.0746212602,
-0.028228648,
-0.0000138567,
0.038123671,
0.0962227434,
-0.0029602526,
-0.0069906972,
-0.0038931323,
0.0310021993,
0.0508406423,
-0.0446138829,
0.0615640096,
-0.004447083,
0.018522229,
-0.0106919743,
-0.0086104479,
-0.0037730993,
0.0133168548,
-0.0138848675,
0.0595890358,
-0.0015938141,
-0.010310512,
-0.0135073168,
0.0115681943,
0.0274898261,
-0.0766526461,
0.0351749472,
0.0456613824,
-0.0502189361,
0.0227411781,
-0.0244964287,
-0.0117569538,
0.0316379853,
-0.0691652,
0.0352872349,
0.0057965806,
0.0031586192,
0.0305805877,
0.0446233861,
-0.0185748618,
-0.0033084548,
0.0049798456,
0.0627684817,
-0.0101634366,
-0.0517691374,
-0.0096721267,
-0.0573230758,
0.0158957839,
-0.0742532536,
-0.0136456126,
0.0086946841,
0.0200977568,
-0.0362979807,
0.0216897633,
0.0009432557,
-0.0207455754,
-0.003390311,
-0.0150706302,
-0.062942937,
0.0068517723,
-0.0416239798,
0.0160316881,
0.0090225041,
-0.1016550064,
0.0320638604,
0.0169290211,
-0.0130908228,
0.0024016886,
-0.0163481757,
0.0740863681,
-0.0249041952,
0.0026949674,
-0.0145472828,
-0.0469461605,
0.0105461273,
-0.0793910548,
-0.0506497547,
-0.0831559673,
0.0494863763,
-0.0031025587,
-0.0465485416,
-0.0661995262,
0.0410276763,
0.0144106625,
0.0027518722,
0.0343871079,
-0.0364108458,
0.026788637,
0.0503993072,
0.0344026387,
0.0084836548,
0.0133347828,
0.0232029967,
0.001954586,
0.0233263467,
0.0049513145,
0.0385820828,
0.0381832421,
-0.0184396822,
0.0153538249,
-0.0081950985,
-0.0023525485,
-0.0342311077,
0.0410763919,
-0.0434147529,
0.0850804597,
-0.0425753072,
0.0051694317,
0.0951146409,
0.074033834,
-0.0496522635,
0.0637125149,
-0.032979507,
0.0347864553,
0.0028665198,
-0.046297051,
-0.0510263927,
0.029406162,
-0.0215845611,
-0.0363415033,
0.0247638896,
0.0320073776,
-0.0188550539,
-0.0430102274,
0.0024451341,
-0.0058289575,
0.0377522819,
0.0132323662,
0.0174226742,
-0.0128695592,
-0.0092210593,
0.0098123467,
-0.0027133771,
-0.0213272739,
-0.0573906936,
-0.0458708182,
0.0071921828,
0.0477366224,
0.0552944914,
-0.009474352,
-0.0307280961,
-0.0506937541,
0.0124834199,
0.0869287103,
0.0737311542,
0.0181263555,
-0.0458409488,
-0.0362981111,
-0.0283054877,
0.0254290551,
-0.0007120938,
0.0265493151,
0.0198855903,
0.0152428895,
0.0190872997,
0.0011242145,
0.0060280045,
-0.0229939669,
0.0278675985,
-0.0246747565,
-0.0237630121,
-0.00417885,
0.0457324833,
0.0333222635,
-0.0199630335,
-0.0208864212,
0.0352468677,
0.0126088923,
-0.0425528958,
0.0517461486,
0.0262885299,
0.0554375835,
0.0394293405,
-0.0120451469,
-0.0014789444,
-0.0169134401,
-0.0182780102,
-0.0190359335,
0.0091281384,
-0.0097994497,
0.0017495984,
-0.0550648011,
-0.0098147895,
0.00265267,
-0.0305129662,
-0.0019016492,
0.0040150383,
0.0355270542,
-0.0493242219,
-0.0147951161,
-0.0222361721,
0.0312758423,
-0.0137122069,
-0.0087579349,
0.051183641,
0.0006302935,
0.0220312774,
0.0218941383,
-0.0023948175,
-0.019859774,
-0.0301769227,
-0.0848428383,
-0.0168695841,
-0.013416905,
0.0034633984,
0.011135987,
-0.0009831184,
-0.0124048004,
0.0049768998,
-0.035703171,
-0.0147530483,
0.0507322066,
0.0134135159,
0.0088235745,
-0.0159902293,
-0.0058598248,
-0.0096131228,
0.0067717847,
-0.0076164771,
0.0006319754,
0.0084646605,
-0.0700936392,
-0.0402262993,
0.0255737007,
-0.0409958512,
0.016015416,
-0.0056992834,
-0.059270069,
0.0540787168,
-0.0037968573,
0.0134596201,
0.0308969058,
0.0515466295,
0.0730918795,
0.025256969,
-0.0252319146,
-0.0640456229,
0.0006312517,
0.0145716555,
-0.0361999236,
-0.0520597883,
-0.0189240947,
-0.0228629522,
0.0111719426,
0.002800832,
0.0370555706,
-0.0281837098,
0.0312868766,
0.0011365017,
-0.0068907537,
0.0141430218,
-0.0141314631,
-0.0308298077,
0.050650768,
0.0221565198,
-0.0522929281,
0.0499599166,
-0.0021144182,
0.0214338321,
-0.0195178762,
-0.0218265112,
-0.0203574151,
0.1027273312,
-0.0383043811,
0.0233352985,
-0.0165534038,
-0.0371469259,
0.0332584567,
-0.0534688607,
0.0653831139,
-0.03876004,
0.0195360016,
-0.0831973255,
0.024691591,
0.0064113298,
-0.0303767547,
0.0099327303,
-0.0093908459,
-0.0318166725,
0.030208284,
0.0022301427,
0.0190505628,
-0.028380448,
0.0030916869,
0.0331620723,
0.0438171886,
0.0407333747,
-0.0073616286,
-0.0059691402,
-0.0362887457,
-0.0049210046,
0.0526709892,
0.0100816665,
-0.0091116475,
-0.0061928178,
0.0565756559,
-0.0164412037,
-0.0760494694,
0.0215169415,
-0.0343945473,
0.0132331187,
-0.0046947692,
-0.018019693,
-0.0000805377,
0.042161528,
-0.0477401577,
0.0159517862,
0.0728284121,
0.024085274,
-0.030485915,
-0.0163418315,
-0.0424849503,
0.0015611432,
0.0089623425,
0.0170737505,
-0.1128526554,
0.0334501341,
-0.0047807931,
-0.016752461,
-0.0376543887,
-0.0178031232,
0.0167161301,
-0.0803489909,
0.092663385,
0.0227480922,
0.0076629533,
-0.0015902292,
0.043642614,
-0.0017134557,
0.0195065401,
0.0275426507,
-0.0268440079,
0.0421126261,
-0.0220171865,
-0.0110762138,
-0.0147988563,
0.0185644589,
-0.0076260837,
-0.0566116199,
0.0704183355,
0.0236697011,
0.0402532108,
0.0079259407,
0.0103337867,
0.0288258139,
0.0508911088,
-0.0217644442,
0.0058129937,
-0.0117804147,
0.0327857584,
0.0181660838,
-0.0432587899,
0.0359076113,
-0.0035335263,
-0.0455988497,
0.0411925502,
0.070366405,
-0.0403483659,
0.0000517034,
0.0271020513,
-0.0117756519,
0.0320801735,
0.0050537721,
0.0148990825,
-0.0132081136,
-0.0826451927,
-0.0372637697,
-0.0035757846,
0.0242883228,
-0.0396049246,
-0.0316596292,
0.03425752,
0.0020250832,
-0.0214472692,
-0.0725240633,
0.0203722399,
0.0427685641,
0.0093231639,
-0.0169187151,
0.0304059051,
0.0043961075,
0.0096698049,
0.0094446978,
-0.0367422998,
0.0336639993,
-0.0360722914,
0.0121609131,
-0.0208804104,
-0.0125581566,
0.0160904657,
0.0153900133,
0.0254523791,
-0.0525492206,
-0.0252320878,
0.0277358424,
0.0288716033,
-0.0156647786,
-0.0046840259,
-0.0757811889,
-0.0265815668,
0.013590659,
0.0091417925,
0.0026204856,
0.0437200665,
0.0385444313,
-0.007001088,
0.0150881726,
0.0071488041,
0.0361225605,
0.0060936161,
0.0341115817,
-0.0078243557,
-0.0731427297,
0.042524036,
0.030572284,
-0.0294844601,
0.0274060741,
-0.0393379554,
-0.0204667002,
0.0036714305,
-0.0481299721,
-0.0028373306,
-0.0253197011,
-0.0090476871,
-0.0262559205,
-0.0183819048,
0.0100133326,
0.0273678005,
-0.040703997,
0.0004510358,
-0.0034820316,
0.0517588705,
-0.0243521687,
-0.0321575664,
0.0169709958,
-0.0097607337,
0.0051228907,
0.0302832387,
-0.0166921746,
0.0484585688,
-0.0334228501,
0.0870711133,
0.0132045653,
0.0024905328,
0.0342757627,
0.0170814358,
-0.015638845,
-0.0936114267,
0.0263465121,
0.0675794482,
0.0663445294,
0.0315152742,
0.0297069326,
-0.0610168204,
-0.0051603462,
-0.0075635714,
0.009928084,
-0.0058222115,
-0.0306874588,
0.0247630421,
0.0285019726,
-0.0135427527,
0.0276830066,
-0.0072388286,
-0.06250301,
0.022101108,
-0.0026852828,
-0.0361922495,
-0.0286299288,
-0.0688315704,
-0.017701041,
0.0150865596,
-0.0206251759,
-0.0530485362,
-0.0594585016,
-0.0139998421,
-0.0756585523,
0.0074767936,
-0.0306193344,
-0.0378280059,
-0.008731626,
0.0280960184,
0.0281713102,
0.0024540671,
-0.0427612551,
0.0468956381,
-0.0201873649,
-0.0209605787,
-0.0142833358,
-6.184904669e-33,
-0.0135195469,
-0.0688951686,
0.0297802947,
0.0422354378,
-0.0176183302,
-0.076162599,
-0.0346879698,
0.0302603394,
-0.0009538107,
0.0460493453,
-0.0389758088,
0.0295339022,
0.0311711878,
-0.0194771457,
0.024483813,
0.007718693,
0.0157569125,
0.0046601426,
-0.0166577995,
0.0125260381,
-0.0142078232,
-0.0233965665,
-0.0091264648,
-0.1244537905,
0.0199051443,
0.0134977419,
-0.0251969099,
0.0035601028,
-0.0682173595,
0.0618566163,
-0.0067221662,
0.0218934771,
0.0114514921,
-0.024240667,
0.0145738898,
0.0309745837,
-0.0396464393,
0.0085982364,
0.0264609735,
-0.0186157431,
0.00315597,
-0.0323326848,
-0.0044240714,
-0.0302811991,
-0.0315669291,
-0.0001696907,
-0.01579131,
0.0053459476,
-0.0146117713,
-0.0141100297,
-0.0793726072,
0.0392319411,
-0.0224465281,
0.0018464305,
0.0370625332,
-0.0336092226,
-0.0241303351,
-0.0274582207,
-0.08569967,
0.0285541024,
-0.0247015059,
-0.0327436849,
0.0408311896,
-0.0631287023,
-0.04531423,
0.0195414927,
-0.0202704556,
0.030540891,
-0.0336759202,
-0.037838757,
-0.0071482947,
0.0789848194,
0.0481074415,
0.0645474643,
-0.0475192405,
-0.0484504029,
-0.0287037473,
-0.005040748,
0.0499019399,
-0.000393824,
0.0482748412,
0.0208930057,
-0.0132599669,
-0.0169388168,
-0.033862412,
-0.0436954163,
-0.0372472405,
-0.0616026074,
0.0373574868,
0.0053623081,
0.0344786495,
-0.0185608026,
0.015441712,
-0.0195453446,
-0.0136221219,
0.0111566139,
0.0334939957,
0.0447875038,
-0.0084449938,
-0.0051419702,
-0.0198949706,
-0.0081469016,
-0.0084759779,
-0.0174232442,
0.0273567438,
0.0029648165,
0.0028762294,
-0.0051309178,
-0.0438954085,
0.0173765719,
-0.0079976982,
0.0643670633,
0.0144702746,
-0.0184083544,
-0.0050811647,
0.0067098229,
0.0060688127,
0.0063551129,
0.0279861726,
-0.0436767489,
-0.0508228466,
0.0062729069,
-0.0237417426,
-0.036825534,
-0.0069120978,
0.0360336974,
-0.0140802702,
0.0599349029,
0.0407555513,
0.0251147803,
-0.0087605501,
-0.022409929,
2.746e-7,
0.0367435291,
0.0708931535,
0.0080808857,
0.0194632076,
0.0295417216,
0.0295346342,
0.0056682844,
0.0455109254,
0.0261778869,
-0.0076979427,
0.0325233415,
0.0202471875,
0.0680342913,
0.0662624165,
-0.0347188078,
-0.0090168212,
-0.0059579057,
-0.0724032447,
-0.0928605422,
0.0407874249,
0.0959941372,
0.026992809,
0.0237969402,
0.0028282276,
-0.0297404081,
0.0243221261,
0.0279334635,
-0.0629108995,
-0.0325047448,
-0.0009724388,
0.0362165943,
-0.0710407123,
0.0033211063,
0.0280615035,
-0.0031376942,
0.0213082861,
-0.0519535132,
0.0906777531,
-0.0157799087,
0.0142342206,
0.0048573823,
-0.0387453176,
0.0311407521,
-0.0531963743,
0.0081990585,
-0.0314107127,
-0.0391052775,
0.0121913683,
0.0012608561,
-0.0844970569,
0.0021307881,
-0.0216524769,
-0.0160229318,
0.0039952551,
0.0060352413,
-0.0070749866,
0.040399909,
-0.0259432252,
0.0076241256,
0.0346432664,
-0.0367604569,
-0.0034120348,
-0.0179085471,
-0.014970188,
-0.0006771527,
0.0073435493,
0.0328219756,
2.086170717e-34,
0.017260449,
0.0223592911,
0.0165524464,
0.0512198471,
0.0767781585,
0.0630847141,
0.0171341524,
0.0351533592,
-0.0100428881,
-0.0643289536,
0.0056181937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14743v2 | Turning Whisper into Real-Time Transcription System | 2023-07-27T10:00:05 | 2023-09-21T09:41:17 | Dominik Macháček, Raj Dabre, Ondřej Bojar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Whisper is one of the recent state-of-the-art multilingual speech recognition
and translation models, however, it is not designed for real time
transcription. In this paper, we build on top of Whisper and create
Whisper-Streaming, an implementation of real-time speech transcription and
translation of Whisper-like models. Whisper-Streaming uses local agreement
policy with self-adaptive latency to enable streaming transcription. We show
that Whisper-Streaming achieves high quality and 3.3 seconds latency on
unsegmented long-form speech transcription test set, and we demonstrate its
robustness and practical usability as a component in live transcription service
at a multilingual conference. | [
-0.0419738665,
0.0267468095,
0.0246932916,
0.0028852457,
-0.0388319604,
-0.0123236263,
0.069472231,
-0.0102217989,
-0.0070365197,
0.0381479636,
-0.0407075398,
-0.0110939536,
0.0403084122,
0.0555950925,
0.0524502024,
-0.0421419702,
0.0389212407,
-0.0513950884,
0.0182944536,
-0.0343148708,
0.0212743785,
-0.0043434054,
-0.0665236115,
0.0270723216,
-0.0142041063,
-0.0162408892,
-0.0060556754,
0.013472571,
0.0243552141,
0.0054648467,
-0.0364206508,
0.0121022165,
0.0313695185,
0.0359569974,
0.0000017458,
-0.0299168918,
-0.0275525078,
0.0552907214,
-0.0110015441,
-0.0016726665,
0.0045787441,
0.0474357978,
-0.0527960435,
0.055561047,
-0.0108109098,
-0.0173855256,
0.0402332991,
-0.0022098566,
0.0243947767,
0.0317604877,
-0.0189274028,
-0.0489552766,
0.027795231,
-0.0349720754,
-0.0143182809,
-0.0632883757,
-0.0330411643,
-0.0262577515,
-0.0129507584,
-0.0429708362,
0.0198602751,
0.0838163123,
0.0012669042,
-0.067688562,
0.0083363475,
-0.0115009425,
-0.0488374308,
-0.0636332855,
-0.0325572565,
0.0540584363,
-0.0159114469,
0.0114113046,
0.0376048349,
0.0074019339,
-0.010372553,
-0.0503887758,
-0.0212088637,
-0.0002077677,
-0.0060153371,
-0.0189250913,
-0.0255197287,
0.0383045413,
0.0245003663,
-0.0447394922,
0.0302927848,
-0.0163900107,
0.0299114324,
-0.008471624,
-0.0250734538,
0.007276006,
0.0294974521,
0.0062021408,
0.1022043452,
0.0157651976,
-0.0311266873,
-0.0091563016,
-0.0144699356,
-0.0277895071,
-0.0240094811,
-0.0303549245,
0.0250083636,
0.0897239298,
-0.0388456099,
0.0241823159,
-0.0038523842,
0.0421991013,
0.0058684363,
-0.0372061096,
-0.0241743904,
-0.0127150463,
0.0385049619,
0.0006542413,
-0.0409839377,
0.0003752197,
-0.0567448288,
-0.0427304432,
-0.0468477122,
0.0139202019,
-0.0213883799,
0.056981124,
0.0511872396,
-0.0266665313,
-0.0510205254,
-0.0187661164,
0.0456684195,
0.05237858,
0.0110254586,
0.0318388268,
-0.0053622979,
-0.0766215622,
-0.0041252803,
0.0233435538,
0.0194690544,
0.0332196578,
-0.0190717671,
0.0372241065,
-0.0074825366,
0.0174523164,
0.0347309932,
0.0150670856,
-0.0223317016,
-0.0375243761,
-0.0243136976,
-0.0706522241,
0.0608964078,
0.0024074942,
0.0180446524,
-0.0399984941,
-0.0092691993,
-0.0511662886,
0.0369202755,
0.0510208309,
0.0055739395,
0.0378380232,
0.0371236317,
0.0019838733,
-0.0147275254,
0.019849617,
0.0698751286,
-0.031640213,
0.0383986309,
-0.041153051,
-0.0093869846,
0.1102807447,
0.0207319912,
0.0253495425,
-0.0133883255,
-0.0048102275,
0.0468427688,
0.0176246893,
0.0115566785,
0.0330913402,
0.0056053214,
-0.0421545357,
0.0714026019,
0.0841377825,
0.0149500975,
-0.0100500127,
0.039214097,
0.0356627814,
-0.0186271109,
-0.029169945,
0.0060058548,
0.0279367324,
0.0277031157,
0.0216862727,
0.0872221664,
0.0634180382,
-0.0407790765,
-0.0008625707,
-0.012552659,
-0.0301810652,
-0.0332684703,
0.0477456041,
0.0145944785,
-0.0055492567,
-0.053619992,
0.0445659384,
0.0070598158,
-0.0917672589,
0.0084561585,
-0.017408751,
0.0013665508,
0.061863739,
0.0048196749,
-0.002557782,
-0.0133187892,
-0.0541947111,
-0.0410847776,
0.0379376747,
0.0279677771,
-0.0020892401,
0.0415138006,
-0.0240718052,
-0.009749488,
0.0851161033,
-0.0190175045,
0.0632356554,
-0.0204259455,
0.0297310799,
-0.0149269234,
-0.0081287473,
-0.0312187467,
-0.0420601368,
-0.0466266423,
0.0137848454,
0.004596415,
-0.0026690641,
0.0779263079,
0.0326525047,
-0.0366225466,
0.0008289149,
0.0225693751,
-0.0136650642,
0.0226096995,
0.0901140273,
-0.0583134666,
-0.0051658074,
0.0424637832,
-0.0116964756,
0.0084734978,
0.0215987079,
0.0297613852,
-0.0604602545,
0.0182635635,
-0.0214611571,
0.0308391117,
-0.0245595537,
0.0358597264,
0.0098068295,
0.0000026887,
0.0279405247,
-0.0665125698,
0.0063647525,
-0.005782323,
-0.0234927516,
-0.0017327779,
0.0126415165,
-0.0569764189,
-0.0040996782,
0.0630084425,
-0.0097609814,
0.0261121951,
-0.0165875796,
0.0072389902,
-0.0130003504,
-0.0173656531,
-0.0704658553,
0.0267641824,
-0.0133172888,
0.002732245,
0.0078710588,
0.0573708825,
-0.0181414764,
-0.0502347536,
-0.0318646282,
0.0003291788,
0.0193328783,
-0.0130223902,
-0.050854288,
-0.0417009108,
0.0010229294,
-0.0390119478,
0.019497769,
0.0429437198,
-0.0215745922,
-0.0236880817,
-0.0157093424,
-0.0670395866,
0.0113035394,
-0.011419612,
0.027504677,
0.0154718272,
-0.0444915928,
0.0196557157,
0.0249556806,
0.0379906781,
0.0244329628,
-0.0226948429,
-0.0241751578,
0.0099096447,
-0.0177795105,
-0.0759363025,
0.0189567115,
0.0118743749,
0.0156576894,
-0.0197601523,
0.0277985856,
-0.0392050743,
0.0447339565,
0.0412455797,
0.0135010481,
-0.0449746437,
-0.04017739,
-0.0203451328,
-0.0150808245,
0.0067392052,
-0.0152132865,
-0.0390836336,
-0.0076419739,
0.027559245,
-0.0488232784,
0.0216836184,
-0.0818966031,
-0.0692229941,
-0.0209622923,
-0.0656766146,
-0.0143751167,
0.0150887519,
-0.0484154001,
0.007482565,
-0.0559603758,
-0.0675379559,
0.0117337015,
0.014391901,
0.0345741548,
-0.0745710358,
-0.0132816583,
-0.0321682245,
-0.0028684295,
-0.0297418293,
-0.0500436909,
0.0051556113,
0.0001125099,
-0.0404096246,
-0.0012513931,
0.0073395018,
-0.0695454776,
-0.0406807177,
0.0751730353,
0.0236543678,
0.0716251209,
-0.0194266774,
0.0240141917,
-0.0118011795,
-0.012796375,
0.0011866252,
0.019072121,
0.0019758455,
0.0039955592,
0.0445262305,
-0.0033127523,
0.053479068,
-0.0000195935,
-0.0427703224,
0.0070983195,
0.0585760102,
0.0171262305,
-0.0388625786,
0.0280864052,
0.0765421242,
-0.029993536,
0.0357815102,
0.1217120364,
-0.0351646319,
-0.0486518405,
-0.0242486391,
-0.0131468074,
0.0526511408,
0.0106376046,
0.005177536,
-0.0406770781,
-0.0023228365,
0.0470127277,
0.0648024157,
0.0486851521,
0.0171455704,
-0.0056377803,
-0.0259701163,
0.033657413,
0.0443949141,
-0.0713099688,
-0.0294559468,
-0.0331253931,
-0.0396989845,
-0.0330747217,
0.0548946038,
-0.0001033578,
0.0167265106,
-0.031059904,
-0.0004732921,
-0.0557074808,
0.0037963281,
0.0270080809,
-0.0356262699,
0.1030384302,
0.0632195547,
0.039381627,
0.0211109873,
-0.0235910695,
-0.0031680956,
0.0447691195,
-0.0344981514,
-0.0056456248,
-0.0369622484,
0.0087726125,
-0.0322469994,
0.0121228909,
0.0402079932,
-0.002247063,
0.0682231337,
0.0280237645,
0.0337654725,
0.0053558848,
0.0336601771,
0.0177370496,
0.029137481,
0.0210249107,
0.0281699225,
-0.0215952583,
-0.025434792,
0.0019515691,
0.0054767975,
0.0009989538,
-0.0041681002,
-0.0286678858,
0.0016565007,
-0.0143352523,
-0.0541607812,
-0.0133899515,
-0.0037941346,
0.0079680895,
0.0148759577,
0.0305143464,
0.0116726235,
0.0601203032,
0.0156635027,
-0.0282534044,
-0.0329447873,
0.00042334,
0.010547867,
-0.0313187875,
-0.0184431411,
0.0460784361,
-0.0150897782,
-0.0006542189,
0.0035169383,
-0.0809105933,
-0.0607535876,
0.0281743854,
0.009064449,
0.0199077539,
0.050173182,
-0.0588817783,
-0.0105216037,
-0.0002172665,
-0.0129642487,
-0.066760242,
-0.0012135936,
0.0650340468,
-0.0005137282,
-0.0002555737,
0.0378401428,
-0.0599194765,
-0.0265481994,
-0.0543440469,
-0.0143536115,
-0.0309016258,
-0.0893153995,
-0.0434286445,
0.0318132453,
0.0063458164,
0.0168606676,
-0.0118948519,
-0.0208434667,
0.0468815342,
-0.0314026996,
0.045694612,
-0.036875546,
0.0115646534,
0.0069795782,
-0.0289846268,
0.0108409226,
0.0344000161,
-0.0107378745,
-0.0752008185,
-0.0265560951,
0.0206739381,
0.0206050631,
-0.0636703745,
0.0188764203,
0.0036448312,
-0.0118597765,
0.0529317521,
0.026367845,
-0.0062627573,
-0.0312373191,
-0.0317697115,
-0.0245635696,
0.0306370631,
0.0829501003,
-0.0077471086,
-0.0292594098,
-0.0555908419,
0.0198926423,
0.0570603721,
0.0839957371,
0.0343754999,
0.0956104323,
-0.0003332704,
0.0354187302,
-0.0427509919,
0.0509369709,
-0.0358777121,
-0.0143957594,
-0.0190390311,
-0.0069591147,
-0.003719209,
0.0421572328,
0.016174702,
-0.0010526103,
-0.0029967467,
-0.0022707472,
0.016392393,
-0.020366203,
-0.033918906,
-0.0141409347,
-0.0085689025,
-0.0321924724,
-0.0320068747,
0.0251746997,
-0.0373353027,
0.0249227006,
0.0222617034,
-0.0336159281,
-0.0217950549,
-0.0073996652,
0.0397780575,
-0.0348153338,
0.0016013084,
-0.0120262923,
-0.026187934,
0.0123208044,
-0.0254818145,
0.0513516292,
-5.882596909e-33,
-0.0289488044,
-0.0445760302,
0.0241573639,
0.0141193271,
-0.0404305346,
-0.0188929979,
-0.0399560072,
-0.0214857478,
0.0086933542,
-0.0172949098,
-0.0334977545,
0.0436576344,
0.04922143,
0.003720731,
-0.0091801053,
0.0050231116,
0.0739935935,
-0.0276675597,
0.014968154,
0.0455914214,
0.0067200945,
0.0290088858,
0.0090686325,
-0.0397903547,
0.0216161478,
-0.0074777836,
-0.017662745,
-0.0298305508,
0.0100637292,
-0.001503533,
0.0115113044,
0.007646658,
-0.052022174,
-0.0231126398,
-0.0514047891,
-0.0090237102,
-0.0539533682,
0.0149793588,
0.0058559929,
0.0675797164,
0.010661507,
0.0279398169,
-0.0110803219,
0.0231948458,
-0.04670614,
-0.0207456164,
0.003563965,
-0.0066750278,
-0.0547858961,
-0.0603067018,
-0.00036563,
0.0362966582,
-0.022704225,
-0.029806681,
0.0849406272,
0.0216828436,
-0.0167217609,
-0.0719870999,
-0.0702509731,
0.0478146672,
-0.0311671123,
0.0241730772,
0.04843954,
-0.0189577471,
-0.0117260329,
0.0071081407,
0.0203546677,
-0.062648654,
0.0299008172,
0.022125924,
0.0274326093,
0.0014730338,
0.0242736656,
-0.01376196,
-0.0266866852,
-0.0376138277,
-0.0119388737,
0.0071935575,
0.0587793179,
-0.0063368077,
0.0307285152,
0.0570344478,
-0.045484025,
0.0349839889,
-0.0789915323,
-0.0287644751,
0.0080460003,
-0.0299349912,
0.0335915536,
0.0122257648,
0.0186923184,
-0.013208909,
0.0906089842,
0.0147840856,
-0.0092930933,
-0.010925361,
0.0057626767,
-0.0092315292,
-0.0375983119,
0.0390416458,
-0.0237117521,
0.0039777537,
0.015814608,
0.0326340795,
0.0353730582,
-0.0115421126,
-0.0162549224,
0.064065434,
-0.0541895404,
0.0167249367,
0.0026375642,
0.0276152864,
0.0140679255,
-0.0245112292,
0.0558690317,
-0.0368977934,
0.0095914891,
0.0833765641,
-0.0468695387,
0.0007305496,
-0.0348045975,
-0.012038935,
-0.0001785318,
0.0135059441,
-0.0864161029,
0.037511915,
-0.026176285,
0.046932146,
0.0164811425,
-0.0164595246,
-0.0190318786,
-0.0242120717,
2.6e-7,
-0.0471726283,
0.0326358303,
0.0269334149,
0.0021286847,
0.0411611125,
0.011280016,
-0.0187089629,
0.0363286585,
-0.0177365169,
0.0470622219,
-0.0227185227,
-0.0188323688,
0.1255307645,
0.042177204,
-0.0981911793,
-0.0611761287,
-0.0968515426,
0.0403334424,
-0.0075292899,
0.037574023,
-0.0264895316,
0.0520426631,
-0.0199193321,
0.0118670547,
0.0435960218,
0.0053545251,
0.009209455,
-0.000819196,
-0.0439170599,
-0.0290530641,
0.0329814032,
0.0250133295,
-0.0362028293,
-0.0199315548,
-0.0519380048,
0.0201825295,
0.0013195093,
0.0794297457,
0.0122666378,
-0.0578365885,
-0.012380938,
0.0082887309,
-0.0289992914,
-0.0221622456,
0.0168600697,
0.0431389771,
0.0031186051,
0.0066334461,
0.0094091818,
-0.0115570342,
0.03253581,
-0.0017320312,
0.0182971638,
0.0204824395,
-0.0085271094,
-0.0297291167,
-0.004402997,
-0.0222871583,
-0.0057521574,
-0.0262959562,
-0.0179942697,
-0.0295267571,
-0.0344622806,
0.0056263669,
-0.0176374596,
0.0212766919,
-0.0052069132,
1.888656557e-34,
0.0264192261,
-0.0154108517,
0.0230194498,
0.0573259592,
0.0023689717,
-0.0443338528,
0.0510618351,
0.0346646644,
0.0069009839,
-0.010902293,
-0.0808549374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14712v1 | Evaluating Generative Models for Graph-to-Text Generation | 2023-07-27T09:03:05 | 2023-07-27T09:03:05 | Shuzhou Yuan, Michael Färber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have been widely employed for graph-to-text
generation tasks. However, the process of finetuning LLMs requires significant
training resources and annotation work. In this paper, we explore the
capability of generative models to generate descriptive text from graph data in
a zero-shot setting. Specifically, we evaluate GPT-3 and ChatGPT on two
graph-to-text datasets and compare their performance with that of finetuned LLM
models such as T5 and BART. Our results demonstrate that generative models are
capable of generating fluent and coherent text, achieving BLEU scores of 10.57
and 11.08 for the AGENDA and WebNLG datasets, respectively. However, our error
analysis reveals that generative models still struggle with understanding the
semantic relations between entities, and they also tend to generate text with
hallucinations or irrelevant information. As a part of error analysis, we
utilize BERT to detect machine-generated text and achieve high macro-F1 scores.
We have made the text generated by generative models publicly available. | [
0.0134524722,
0.0188850779,
0.0229506493,
0.0256003588,
-0.0216244012,
0.0023679857,
0.0214833897,
0.0006634817,
0.0363633186,
-0.0571284704,
0.0076454571,
-0.0314298309,
0.019467162,
0.0718845502,
0.0637024119,
-0.0576250553,
-0.0036419514,
0.0222031884,
-0.0037128064,
-0.0038078348,
0.0059664692,
0.0651093498,
0.0203890894,
0.0240598973,
-0.0363342017,
-0.0114376089,
0.0144131482,
0.0585100017,
0.012885998,
-0.0475517027,
-0.0348981917,
0.0452791154,
0.0169519018,
0.0311290473,
0.0000017759,
-0.0111225136,
-0.0195252914,
0.0267245639,
0.0167600792,
-0.0076621659,
0.050786458,
-0.0267319791,
0.0035450056,
0.0173341651,
-0.0288845096,
-0.0299432743,
0.0384884365,
0.025085846,
0.0466401055,
0.0886353329,
-0.0389975198,
-0.0270110276,
0.0133014694,
-0.0441839509,
0.0257131904,
-0.013799361,
0.009803866,
0.0159033593,
0.0037164229,
0.0037049011,
-0.0458818413,
0.00834936,
0.0079352316,
-0.0236407816,
0.0516754165,
0.0600903109,
-0.0072463793,
-0.0058206832,
0.0304242633,
0.0952074304,
-0.0012984592,
-0.0445267968,
0.0332872681,
-0.0117749227,
-0.0143075269,
-0.0017578368,
-0.0450370833,
0.032867521,
-0.0220751129,
0.0311872773,
-0.0041934545,
-0.0323612392,
0.0390148535,
-0.0130416118,
-0.0002068879,
0.0062977825,
0.0322215632,
-0.008085533,
-0.0147140883,
0.0413822941,
-0.0225814916,
-0.068607904,
-0.000749885,
0.0248657018,
-0.0250302739,
0.0106736142,
-0.0749884024,
-0.0139263906,
-0.0141893532,
0.0113355424,
0.0408328474,
0.0031300413,
0.0224536806,
-0.0025014847,
-0.0309101809,
0.0351942703,
-0.0166498646,
0.0360985696,
-0.0281027686,
0.0193336941,
-0.0386426598,
0.0152224004,
-0.041200716,
0.0294587426,
-0.0287760384,
-0.04906746,
-0.0551893748,
0.0331217311,
0.0122626023,
0.015432517,
0.024487609,
0.0243197791,
-0.0368136577,
-0.0191011056,
0.0162085891,
0.0013220942,
0.0100147966,
-0.0219053235,
0.0203506667,
-0.0251295455,
0.0026808043,
0.0370891988,
0.052512791,
-0.0163443256,
-0.0241895113,
0.0584308766,
0.0044519026,
-0.0168050136,
-0.0257267077,
-0.021894576,
-0.0276685394,
-0.06474711,
0.0309268702,
-0.073738426,
0.0275412928,
0.01364836,
0.0022591527,
-0.0262149256,
0.0379039124,
0.0123684956,
-0.0278457329,
0.0322528891,
-0.0500505827,
0.0239477903,
0.016698746,
-0.0338211246,
0.0063409843,
0.0370400622,
0.0663240924,
0.0447931923,
0.0145718632,
0.0115305791,
0.0011810955,
0.0252995007,
0.0329344012,
0.0109332306,
0.0040529398,
-0.0312502868,
-0.0293721389,
0.023604013,
0.0257263873,
0.1030567139,
-0.0213125609,
0.0224165302,
0.0663230717,
0.0250879861,
0.0179920457,
0.009304544,
0.0918740556,
0.0321566276,
-0.0197038446,
0.0224149302,
-0.0190303791,
0.0182963219,
0.0113657909,
0.0629256666,
0.0418890454,
0.0020928939,
-0.0085695861,
-0.0008491161,
-0.01325534,
-0.023876626,
0.0404762253,
-0.0455037095,
0.056886211,
0.0382661819,
-0.0871850103,
0.0055642133,
0.0186089594,
-0.0529251285,
0.0559998564,
-0.0190211888,
0.0065297214,
0.1029051915,
0.0658418834,
0.0536712632,
-0.0265347399,
-0.0214711651,
-0.0132378116,
0.079017587,
0.0249847863,
-0.002594203,
-0.0273061637,
-0.0334234387,
-0.0354313143,
-0.0379153565,
-0.0011002724,
0.0312734731,
-0.0082441447,
-0.0013998611,
0.0355398878,
-0.0788531378,
-0.0540212542,
0.0250016991,
-0.016082691,
0.0062825223,
0.0017080934,
-0.0140267257,
-0.0172034353,
0.0340498798,
-0.0290416535,
0.037994612,
-0.0009409111,
-0.0129135596,
-0.0021842062,
0.0216835793,
-0.020933006,
-0.0652801692,
0.0079441732,
-0.0501907282,
-0.0111568635,
-0.0212265849,
-0.0306682307,
-0.0717417598,
0.0164632481,
-0.0680923462,
0.0149784032,
-0.02351618,
-0.0041746022,
0.0342766009,
0.0047787535,
0.0126029076,
0.0669248626,
0.0018779751,
0.0064154994,
0.00654857,
0.0499399602,
0.0034861199,
-0.0576837659,
0.0126473047,
0.025417503,
0.017968202,
0.0031811818,
0.0203227364,
0.0387113281,
-0.0390683226,
-0.0006743329,
-0.1121135578,
0.0134174004,
-0.0135108465,
0.0215577036,
0.0297730565,
0.0005045867,
-0.0000789953,
0.0145435557,
-0.0589263253,
0.0347716361,
0.0380033627,
-0.0002274229,
0.0510399304,
-0.0270785224,
-0.0028956491,
-0.0302011985,
-0.0245015733,
-0.0172308534,
0.0681497231,
0.0655780211,
-0.0308436751,
-0.0182446986,
0.0553883202,
-0.0539944582,
-0.0100004505,
0.0173909385,
-0.0169107057,
0.0324107967,
0.0070841755,
0.0836928263,
0.0082642995,
0.0284463726,
0.0401122682,
-0.0052295174,
-0.0144542418,
-0.0170582514,
-0.0155398007,
-0.0652068034,
-0.0008832744,
-0.019066941,
-0.06426844,
0.0165727809,
0.0263281073,
0.0306489076,
0.0068239202,
-0.0827241093,
0.0017269492,
-0.012490442,
-0.0071818056,
0.0004561045,
0.0016926927,
-0.0111051239,
0.0003275039,
-0.0452100635,
-0.0168248322,
0.0446717031,
-0.0533490293,
0.0117588323,
0.0342949331,
0.0195549764,
-0.0430871658,
0.0393363275,
0.0586077794,
0.035501346,
-0.0082848677,
-0.0245973542,
-0.0313481539,
0.030217465,
0.0367759839,
-0.0328372419,
0.0049597616,
-0.0100464588,
0.0263862461,
-0.0083667077,
-0.0053596194,
-0.0211653933,
0.0102040917,
0.0168733429,
0.032507021,
0.0455547534,
-0.0370927937,
0.0009074698,
0.0096871369,
-0.010905236,
0.0106738172,
-0.0456350185,
-0.0225347783,
-0.0429783911,
0.0632032901,
0.0654061362,
-0.0531040393,
-0.0275065843,
-0.0628085732,
-0.0160921942,
0.0228715725,
-0.0024677969,
0.0263004266,
-0.0206381101,
-0.0102572832,
-0.0283624362,
-0.0058838935,
-0.0346137658,
-0.0045886296,
0.059594702,
-0.0194759276,
-0.0207135379,
0.0969496667,
0.0081822881,
-0.0028096244,
-0.000569143,
0.0435160734,
0.0535538644,
-0.0119274911,
-0.0049669337,
-0.1145840138,
0.0035514873,
-0.0176818259,
0.0448708758,
0.0013009097,
-0.041331131,
-0.0338883065,
-0.142357111,
0.0320229866,
0.0426655188,
0.0019737766,
-0.0240236986,
-0.0300971624,
-0.0348346606,
0.0067536351,
-0.0092020622,
-0.0330765545,
-0.0297728889,
0.036240302,
0.0302041899,
-0.0030589122,
-0.0474773385,
-0.0107603772,
-0.0079740407,
0.0352702476,
0.0265861955,
0.0550158024,
0.0182942003,
0.0086058546,
0.0194063038,
0.0180817209,
-0.0207529105,
-0.015629936,
0.0632562563,
-0.0365078077,
-0.0074318564,
-0.0156960487,
0.0319457203,
0.0003755902,
-0.0189781561,
-0.0384231098,
0.0409852527,
-0.0108456137,
-0.0475736894,
0.0001639659,
0.0255894829,
0.0136428056,
0.0342803635,
0.0658044294,
-0.0032616905,
-0.0690854192,
-0.0411750823,
0.0447868146,
-0.1189391613,
-0.0070332792,
0.0213612635,
-0.0475941338,
-0.0295868851,
-0.0876230896,
-0.0486786179,
0.0279284865,
0.0145762954,
-0.0129130827,
-0.0129864933,
0.0022349763,
-0.0403349362,
-0.0475475639,
-0.0058422196,
-0.0242301766,
0.0156003525,
-0.0427099019,
-0.0578810088,
0.0010835942,
-0.0133751556,
-0.0036625362,
0.0358232334,
-0.0806692317,
-0.0681802332,
-0.0325526595,
0.0299173463,
0.0205643438,
0.0237280875,
-0.015973635,
0.0170048308,
0.0567235425,
0.0746848509,
-0.0077464785,
-0.0125403125,
-0.0014613324,
0.03893473,
-0.0144328224,
0.02508834,
-0.0516349263,
0.0382186286,
0.0067545068,
0.0688934103,
0.0139771365,
-0.0440093242,
0.0144984219,
0.0645444244,
-0.0122735025,
-0.0583209768,
-0.0079897353,
-0.0575963259,
-0.0523483269,
-0.0630497262,
-0.0161548406,
-0.0549929254,
-0.0175430309,
0.0320304148,
0.0103322016,
0.0039260797,
-0.0205092505,
-0.0278186463,
0.0462805741,
-0.0512526445,
-0.0291361064,
-0.0298569184,
-0.0258165654,
0.0411344618,
-0.0234131049,
-0.0446082056,
0.0290049426,
-0.0209436491,
-0.002958945,
0.0039469176,
0.0413582511,
0.011130319,
-0.0075974823,
-0.0061738682,
0.0151340058,
-0.0224212706,
0.0138786547,
-0.0769684389,
0.0517776981,
0.0447079502,
0.0538567714,
0.0960588977,
-0.0368295945,
0.0009832145,
-0.0391094647,
0.085764043,
0.0046061371,
-0.0580061264,
0.0273569189,
-0.0203449633,
-0.0163285863,
-0.0149188275,
0.0895053074,
0.073456049,
0.0031132384,
0.012552591,
-0.0133367591,
-0.0529383905,
-0.0348586366,
-0.0201416127,
-0.0167381745,
0.0204412248,
0.0035563775,
-0.0497133359,
-0.0878489986,
0.0316541679,
0.0318295918,
0.0248755179,
0.0158847943,
0.020235043,
0.0042656818,
0.0083518494,
0.001038042,
-0.0552473702,
0.0624991618,
-0.0141353859,
-0.0106358659,
-0.0128474422,
-6.143821142e-33,
-0.0554358177,
-0.0964793712,
0.0174996089,
-0.0066788709,
-0.0587188751,
0.002416413,
-0.0705521032,
0.0033520483,
0.0273489971,
0.0152674373,
0.0125423158,
-0.0032691411,
0.0080119921,
0.0591552258,
-0.0500250384,
-0.01375663,
0.0534603782,
-0.0198615659,
-0.0419823229,
0.0889470801,
0.0502942652,
0.0169581641,
0.0413536914,
-0.0290714353,
0.0276082102,
-0.0672121421,
-0.0250313766,
-0.0161816776,
0.0323400311,
0.0152799338,
-0.025919795,
0.0432942621,
0.0283933412,
0.0269789007,
-0.0180106051,
0.0130096283,
-0.0521415472,
-0.0095114317,
0.0018252555,
-0.0178003646,
-0.060729593,
-0.0389721505,
0.0173922293,
-0.0160678457,
0.0148689961,
-0.0525211357,
0.0454139337,
-0.011793985,
-0.0351281092,
-0.0452378541,
-0.0666353106,
0.0366268046,
-0.0038163445,
-0.0167654883,
-0.0074147838,
0.0295352954,
0.0016317092,
-0.0120664947,
-0.0199669022,
0.0326052643,
-0.0088336188,
-0.0157826077,
0.0441154055,
0.0135080321,
0.0254484918,
0.0457149744,
0.0027638979,
0.0340185724,
-0.0442333482,
0.022623457,
-0.0104122721,
0.0704963729,
-0.0008241811,
0.0417159088,
-0.0277035199,
-0.0222414713,
-0.0576310791,
0.0335316882,
-0.0495462567,
-0.0188814141,
0.0114800297,
-0.015095585,
0.0059559704,
-0.047902897,
-0.0076255081,
-0.0490781404,
-0.0081011569,
-0.035916388,
0.0110461311,
-0.0015383915,
-0.0332645811,
0.001593514,
0.0102624539,
-0.032151565,
-0.0224461388,
0.0441223085,
-0.0440540649,
0.040904332,
-0.0323447846,
0.022397304,
-0.0604582503,
-0.0555295274,
0.0664167926,
0.0435804762,
0.0008379314,
0.0200452004,
0.0398516953,
0.0138404239,
-0.0320315324,
0.0048679742,
-0.058938697,
0.0112246126,
-0.0368583016,
-0.0222540647,
0.0438009724,
-0.0059155836,
-0.0162464436,
0.023801947,
0.0185045712,
0.0370969325,
0.0070293136,
0.0200519096,
0.0092547499,
0.0399895199,
-0.0512972251,
0.0290258937,
-0.0294201504,
0.0235904194,
0.0401642695,
-0.0418709405,
-0.0205062944,
-0.0144094853,
2.471e-7,
0.0553284846,
0.0393355787,
0.0637335628,
0.0361698866,
0.0092954291,
0.0096856588,
-0.0025802304,
0.0585610345,
0.0064691994,
-0.0014980121,
0.0323633738,
0.0236807987,
0.0366421416,
0.0404398143,
-0.026754532,
0.0514435992,
-0.0786273181,
-0.0040088571,
-0.0571415536,
0.0088483216,
0.0710782707,
0.0111058801,
-0.0065507959,
-0.0031946667,
0.0138919242,
-0.0398554541,
0.0945026129,
-0.0018652295,
-0.0491081625,
0.0065325857,
0.0133014247,
0.0030537697,
-0.0212064944,
0.0054847072,
-0.0140394652,
-0.027391972,
0.0387544483,
0.0442162082,
-0.003065129,
-0.0089069447,
0.0245643742,
-0.0375126675,
0.0036733081,
-0.0282355696,
0.0480754673,
-0.0561897568,
-0.0429984294,
0.0236422848,
-0.0454981886,
0.0133958766,
-0.0013838855,
-0.0480560474,
-0.0457562916,
0.0285010226,
0.0383978561,
0.0040025329,
-0.0038294503,
-0.0042145313,
-0.0025943965,
0.0062669767,
-0.0269329995,
-0.0494024679,
-0.015491724,
0.0277765021,
0.0000857361,
-0.0106875151,
0.0018204751,
2.248971174e-34,
0.0420458764,
0.0044048522,
-0.0116533134,
-0.0529815145,
0.0313324369,
-0.020852847,
0.0110103246,
0.0206921082,
-0.0023026203,
-0.09414877,
-0.0321206599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14666v1 | Improving Natural Language Inference in Arabic using Transformer Models and Linguistically Informed Pre-Training | 2023-07-27T07:40:11 | 2023-07-27T07:40:11 | Mohammad Majd Saad Al Deen, Maren Pielka, Jörn Hees, Bouthaina Soulef Abdou, Rafet Sifa | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper addresses the classification of Arabic text data in the field of
Natural Language Processing (NLP), with a particular focus on Natural Language
Inference (NLI) and Contradiction Detection (CD). Arabic is considered a
resource-poor language, meaning that there are few data sets available, which
leads to limited availability of NLP methods. To overcome this limitation, we
create a dedicated data set from publicly available resources. Subsequently,
transformer-based machine learning models are being trained and evaluated. We
find that a language-specific model (AraBERT) performs competitively with
state-of-the-art multilingual approaches, when we apply linguistically informed
pre-training methods such as Named Entity Recognition (NER). To our knowledge,
this is the first large-scale evaluation for this task in Arabic, as well as
the first application of multi-task pre-training in this context. | [
0.035406366,
0.0834750608,
0.0034493175,
0.048443798,
-0.0511956438,
0.0671389475,
0.0565210953,
-0.0281037893,
-0.0093394006,
-0.0564902686,
0.0117705399,
-0.0582683608,
0.0311748721,
-0.0171949975,
0.0204042047,
0.0111700166,
0.0292552095,
-0.039421197,
0.0070734397,
-0.0008312896,
0.0235029291,
0.0369580947,
-0.017662935,
0.0053281207,
-0.0190720391,
0.0011254962,
-0.0055790553,
-0.0308372751,
0.0380712189,
-0.0042526652,
-0.0225988589,
0.0613120757,
-0.0210073628,
0.0448990203,
0.0000019799,
-0.0889697447,
-0.0740301013,
-0.0196710713,
-0.0387982391,
-0.0617013201,
0.0336863957,
-0.0835472196,
-0.0393459499,
0.0055481363,
-0.02012996,
0.0100564016,
0.0571126454,
0.0979431495,
0.0637950003,
0.0494607277,
0.0007262202,
-0.0533955246,
0.01848525,
0.0166901927,
-0.0322573446,
0.0003492541,
0.0020141662,
-0.0131846424,
-0.0345196426,
0.0217978358,
-0.0178738032,
0.0286921002,
0.0388962701,
-0.002867541,
-0.0613744594,
-0.0192753933,
-0.0833149105,
-0.0362191685,
0.0248851441,
0.0063276985,
-0.0354374908,
-0.0459073335,
-0.0157846212,
0.0069738957,
-0.0067508072,
-0.0041524349,
0.0200612471,
0.0598963201,
-0.0554967485,
0.0137090953,
0.085457705,
0.0135872299,
-0.0062100147,
-0.0057614436,
-0.0679457039,
0.0193479508,
-0.0008703445,
-0.0260928944,
0.0435463674,
0.023675438,
-0.0373056307,
-0.0369023792,
0.0133582233,
-0.0135020716,
0.0108171701,
-0.0137736974,
-0.0369728059,
-0.0529123247,
0.0081934594,
-0.0745589063,
0.0088962112,
0.0465345681,
-0.0102536669,
0.0366546623,
-0.0602361709,
0.0424984023,
0.0042836801,
0.0197493136,
-0.0267617591,
-0.0331683829,
-0.037579421,
0.0106952274,
-0.0319366865,
0.04703217,
-0.0809437409,
0.0323350243,
-0.0489461832,
0.0207462832,
-0.0211938191,
0.0041264892,
-0.0002718038,
-0.0355664641,
-0.0047653834,
-0.0131471651,
-0.0333622061,
0.0224172529,
0.0286781322,
0.0243609603,
-0.0774970204,
-0.1075773314,
-0.0028829502,
-0.0003056698,
0.0008985119,
0.0022482038,
0.0234193765,
0.0792709589,
-0.0153649645,
-0.0853203088,
-0.0655946806,
0.0570942461,
0.0012440108,
-0.0435037911,
-0.0154480943,
-0.0658657327,
0.0674091429,
0.0213486273,
-0.022462476,
-0.0068263076,
0.0078914734,
-0.0022110045,
0.0086158058,
0.0860550404,
0.0227738172,
-0.016627254,
0.060010016,
-0.0048963893,
0.0479168892,
0.0551311634,
0.0042793127,
-0.0338361785,
0.0340520665,
0.0296186507,
-0.0012178982,
0.0262705963,
-0.0004174286,
0.0011022676,
0.0105835199,
-0.0218399242,
-0.0114812367,
-0.0024629035,
-0.028085012,
0.0025689758,
-0.0085690813,
-0.0521032214,
0.0229438115,
-0.0189484861,
-0.0148181701,
0.0091158524,
0.0124029228,
0.0506787598,
0.0088252397,
-0.0094702318,
-0.014472249,
0.0136138732,
0.0039572236,
0.0137573425,
0.0031102505,
0.0960619301,
-0.0212377496,
-0.0784101039,
-0.0118670771,
-0.0454917997,
0.0074071358,
0.0059745326,
0.1003198475,
0.0271050911,
-0.0638204962,
0.0508989096,
0.0541413575,
-0.0236059856,
-0.0255544037,
-0.0492140204,
-0.0152106499,
0.0024559002,
-0.0279638879,
-0.028283393,
-0.0375037342,
-0.0452799536,
0.004224244,
0.0622265153,
-0.0043840883,
0.0045679808,
0.0193011519,
-0.0044312738,
-0.0180941485,
0.0032204078,
0.0226792321,
0.0020957768,
0.0140643045,
0.0499436893,
-0.0054506864,
-0.022643324,
-0.0275630243,
0.0422364064,
-0.0145631777,
0.0080652358,
0.0085274354,
0.0581722111,
-0.0000971374,
0.0376064815,
-0.0230761189,
-0.0187097937,
0.0211555548,
-0.0555626862,
-0.0559439994,
0.0166847073,
0.0141822388,
-0.0392216109,
0.0307045914,
-0.0455469862,
-0.0259036925,
0.040401943,
-0.0410396345,
-0.0064236205,
0.0194364432,
-0.0084309522,
0.0276349857,
-0.0172462855,
0.0697809234,
0.0032977071,
0.0276388526,
-0.0068315133,
0.061466597,
-0.0502152257,
0.0207569897,
-0.0017008244,
-0.0298329331,
0.0791101083,
0.0101921875,
-0.0315971039,
0.0204136781,
-0.0180728976,
-0.0122865327,
0.0390120447,
-0.0168620236,
0.0135326767,
-0.0427895896,
-0.0498946495,
-0.018350862,
-0.0270024538,
0.0411135443,
-0.0097188316,
0.000985443,
-0.0193086304,
-0.0153313642,
0.0405329168,
-0.0503630377,
0.036400456,
0.0061773788,
0.0349270813,
-0.0539280139,
-0.0005291639,
-0.0175426751,
0.0077327858,
-0.0115634697,
0.0703468323,
0.044677794,
-0.0299505312,
0.0068602338,
-0.017243119,
-0.0251873042,
0.0305557922,
-0.0112970397,
-0.0031939861,
0.0291087143,
0.0096584223,
0.0260412637,
0.0594793335,
0.0223763715,
0.0216583908,
0.0034729962,
0.0070721661,
-0.0328682922,
0.0150447795,
-0.0262892116,
-0.0004289305,
-0.0431141183,
-0.0539489873,
0.0138910888,
0.0494296066,
-0.0079663713,
-0.0115906056,
-0.0150179099,
0.0402950123,
-0.0259209573,
0.0245969649,
0.0291325785,
0.0200577602,
0.0262938794,
0.0548199378,
0.0058306744,
-0.0176289696,
0.0464716777,
-0.0320914052,
0.030752087,
-0.0488367453,
-0.0134749534,
-0.0472734496,
0.0321341269,
0.0049668294,
0.0127153751,
0.0228484422,
0.0027472677,
0.0029287369,
0.028590275,
0.0451520942,
0.0053226636,
0.0345237702,
-0.0380395874,
0.005882388,
-0.0340608731,
-0.0387228727,
-0.0442219041,
-0.0099651041,
-0.0356045701,
-0.0225258581,
0.0145461485,
0.0106778489,
-0.068205297,
0.0384863429,
-0.0058243093,
0.0516277477,
0.0116764121,
-0.0038040958,
-0.0111776497,
-0.0078118909,
0.0212531667,
0.0258800164,
0.0648983121,
-0.0104995947,
-0.0041243401,
0.0233121458,
-0.0605514534,
-0.0192452949,
-0.0306320768,
-0.0261778645,
0.0198851265,
-0.0458821468,
-0.0120292874,
-0.060601864,
-0.0226673149,
-0.0375025757,
0.0127383117,
0.1055848077,
0.0212902725,
0.0133382659,
-0.0151330428,
-0.0165941063,
-0.039422188,
0.0038281751,
-0.0087364232,
-0.1406577677,
-0.0090171313,
-0.0005600884,
-0.0302153751,
0.0041863881,
-0.0208118297,
0.029107159,
-0.1016351581,
0.0162835997,
-0.0398128219,
-0.0680169985,
-0.0502978452,
-0.0579705201,
-0.0141219981,
-0.0495170914,
-0.015011359,
-0.0610140003,
-0.0061323335,
0.0222820565,
0.0072782226,
0.0315937921,
-0.0548175201,
0.0071768332,
-0.038144093,
-0.0199205726,
-0.0085456632,
0.0025012845,
-0.0292575266,
-0.0411997214,
-0.0071367645,
-0.0361808985,
-0.0535413027,
0.005849543,
-0.0034881621,
-0.0225937478,
0.0003776742,
-0.0367985182,
-0.0251877904,
-0.0367416702,
-0.0016353487,
-0.0075117331,
0.0430866331,
-0.0013571274,
0.0188462008,
0.0146005359,
-0.0008476445,
-0.0132931005,
0.05278055,
-0.0441532247,
-0.0190804936,
-0.0571632236,
-0.010030956,
-0.0241675824,
-0.0162203647,
-0.0219273642,
0.0129038161,
0.0240510255,
0.0100623155,
-0.0579134673,
-0.0186857972,
0.0060520768,
0.0343904309,
-0.0191408712,
-0.0067226957,
0.0300268177,
0.0048906589,
-0.0651372001,
-0.00877879,
0.0184850115,
0.0078784106,
-0.0435611308,
0.0017283775,
0.0091765393,
-0.038593702,
0.002082844,
-0.0011137759,
-0.0782482773,
-0.0251418483,
0.0073945285,
0.0037964806,
0.0091765495,
0.0366202444,
-0.0025207563,
0.0233184583,
-0.0115855569,
0.0488137268,
-0.0327816978,
0.0023548396,
0.0441839546,
-0.000737938,
-0.0258075371,
0.0391101614,
0.0327253565,
0.0395175889,
0.0168598462,
-0.0289665964,
-0.0304396525,
-0.0622554161,
0.0103629651,
-0.044467926,
0.0316839591,
0.0007484184,
-0.0409926325,
-0.0524548665,
0.0344890133,
0.0181455612,
0.0051048254,
-0.0063072885,
0.0001412487,
-0.0036571242,
0.0437391624,
-0.0117768971,
0.0635934398,
-0.0127711929,
0.0006765811,
-0.0032838688,
0.035873156,
0.0492749885,
0.0201216955,
-0.0263776407,
-0.0157913938,
0.0208542123,
-0.0315159149,
0.0220705923,
0.0514709949,
-0.0259619597,
0.0420436673,
0.0137116369,
0.0135583812,
0.0141245108,
0.0411659963,
-0.00784468,
-0.0074870959,
-0.0315118581,
0.0188248139,
0.0445265323,
-0.0528087169,
0.0286430009,
0.0129541419,
-0.0084717097,
0.0184528679,
0.0355367474,
0.004691042,
-0.0136849489,
0.0073726606,
-0.0012151335,
-0.007238002,
0.0497356839,
0.0274807829,
0.0125465291,
-0.0001775219,
0.0497050807,
-0.0192691218,
-0.0201091878,
-0.0375383385,
-0.0022611248,
-0.0294801909,
-0.0215049572,
0.0256057102,
-0.0578259639,
-0.0765633136,
0.0409075618,
0.0058850972,
0.0303306095,
0.0186015945,
0.0083299931,
0.0799787566,
0.031582877,
-0.0258368645,
-0.0512753166,
0.0100979879,
0.0253507104,
-0.0105869686,
-0.0049994779,
-5.407786089e-33,
0.0024921426,
-0.0396980643,
0.0025734827,
0.014008496,
0.0374349058,
-0.004259543,
-0.0213847104,
-0.0147752082,
-0.0330421701,
0.0185766835,
0.000044496,
0.0266714133,
0.0350438319,
0.0071765026,
-0.0035782976,
-0.033253029,
0.0514987484,
0.0271500908,
-0.0359187163,
-0.022075329,
0.0345175043,
0.0240519233,
0.117763713,
-0.0800433382,
0.023195494,
-0.0220086351,
0.0012852531,
0.031711597,
0.023670679,
0.078104198,
-0.0233938079,
0.0300521459,
0.0268384889,
-0.1017013863,
0.0357595533,
-0.0443307795,
-0.0977647156,
0.0018993855,
-0.0200244579,
0.0414646342,
-0.0126028694,
0.005535909,
-0.0141642615,
0.0209590886,
-0.0227132477,
0.0233676303,
0.0215601493,
-0.008463583,
0.0564526133,
-0.0193848424,
-0.1287115663,
0.0610852279,
0.0038011933,
0.0225240216,
0.0223277844,
0.0140969865,
0.006033598,
-0.0126461126,
-0.0834187418,
-0.0111969253,
0.0433014408,
-0.0282331314,
0.0367253385,
-0.0210972559,
-0.0691563487,
0.0047623813,
-0.0095229447,
-0.0072693229,
0.0039786818,
0.0147599569,
0.0202479511,
-0.0095267035,
0.0338489041,
0.084398739,
0.021832278,
0.001272183,
-0.086311385,
0.0226555821,
-0.0320915468,
0.0443474948,
0.0054151369,
-0.0466118343,
-0.0522049442,
-0.0110780476,
0.0104625262,
-0.0386435576,
-0.0218255874,
0.0209566224,
0.0142780971,
0.0146955224,
-0.0649974942,
0.0612384044,
0.0060236286,
-0.0272140037,
0.0044089435,
0.0209721457,
0.0030282976,
-0.0144426133,
0.0134148039,
0.0343293212,
-0.0640933216,
-0.0293263104,
0.0274497364,
0.0384978838,
0.0304629784,
-0.0117250644,
0.0481442958,
0.0034480439,
-0.0904123485,
0.0501873232,
-0.0110657942,
0.0546291247,
-0.0035975697,
0.0817021802,
0.0211642403,
0.0056224666,
-0.0088902805,
0.0392999686,
0.0237190053,
-0.0232197735,
-0.0530311279,
0.0600953363,
-0.006400181,
-0.0097184358,
0.0060230168,
0.0069524446,
-0.0350204594,
0.0342036113,
-0.0453131832,
-0.0876357034,
-0.0039044626,
0.0004158892,
2.591e-7,
0.0280817766,
-0.0032472517,
0.0308506712,
-0.0238658451,
-0.0174925439,
0.0270691756,
0.0431544818,
0.0107803317,
-0.0010608052,
0.0511481129,
-0.0170850586,
0.0178314392,
0.0193416514,
0.0106452852,
-0.0666776672,
0.0023852272,
-0.0159211736,
-0.0100994939,
-0.0520902574,
0.0117385704,
0.0433336683,
0.1495658457,
-0.0183074754,
-0.0064395824,
-0.0622617751,
-0.0300307944,
0.0581705235,
0.0205322653,
-0.0065176846,
0.0199486613,
0.061087925,
-0.0164900571,
0.0036409497,
0.0285752956,
-0.0281060059,
0.0450373292,
0.0179802105,
0.0591163523,
0.0176839232,
0.031517528,
-0.0153374514,
-0.0287860911,
-0.025696395,
-0.0634075478,
0.0922987312,
-0.0396640263,
0.0063406168,
0.0036515822,
-0.0244643986,
0.0275213663,
0.051851429,
-0.0035961671,
-0.0050944914,
0.0316950455,
0.0532597005,
-0.0217740238,
0.0094279833,
-0.0312740132,
0.0450407974,
-0.0014459839,
0.0223538317,
0.0349263623,
0.0224584565,
-0.0149546564,
0.0540518165,
0.0174247529,
0.0297127366,
2.074661663e-34,
0.0348492563,
0.0197800566,
-0.0059925504,
-0.0039325757,
0.0493307486,
0.0027522852,
-0.0545798577,
0.0010251254,
-0.0192767642,
0.0012401275,
0.0316866562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14632v1 | Metric-Based In-context Learning: A Case Study in Text Simplification | 2023-07-27T05:45:35 | 2023-07-27T05:45:35 | Subha Vadlamannati, Gözde Gül Şahin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning (ICL) for large language models has proven to be a
powerful approach for many natural language processing tasks. However,
determining the best method to select examples for ICL is nontrivial as the
results can vary greatly depending on the quality, quantity, and order of
examples used. In this paper, we conduct a case study on text simplification
(TS) to investigate how to select the best and most robust examples for ICL. We
propose Metric-Based in-context Learning (MBL) method that utilizes commonly
used TS metrics such as SARI, compression ratio, and BERT-Precision for
selection. Through an extensive set of experiments with various-sized GPT
models on standard TS benchmarks such as TurkCorpus and ASSET, we show that
examples selected by the top SARI scores perform the best on larger models such
as GPT-175B, while the compression ratio generally performs better on smaller
models such as GPT-13B and GPT-6.7B. Furthermore, we demonstrate that MBL is
generally robust to example orderings and out-of-domain test sets, and
outperforms strong baselines and state-of-the-art finetuned language models.
Finally, we show that the behaviour of large GPT models can be implicitly
controlled by the chosen metric. Our research provides a new framework for
selecting examples in ICL, and demonstrates its effectiveness in text
simplification tasks, breaking new ground for more accurate and efficient NLG
systems. | [
-0.0061992123,
0.003504273,
-0.00222243,
0.0116186338,
-0.0601597279,
0.0276923552,
0.0183911864,
0.0738477707,
-0.0095530534,
-0.0330427922,
-0.000342388,
0.0102802962,
0.041619584,
-0.0324419625,
0.0339139849,
-0.0502099209,
0.0291122664,
0.0093242181,
-0.0033200274,
0.0263701566,
0.0046890969,
0.0071851285,
0.0209342279,
0.0535854325,
-0.0028744184,
-0.019893162,
0.0343581997,
0.0209028684,
0.0024817707,
-0.0044167088,
0.035500139,
0.0495979823,
0.0218061861,
-0.0154421395,
0.0000021226,
-0.0322283581,
-0.0307903942,
0.0200840812,
0.0113271382,
0.0541034266,
0.0658434182,
-0.0146449255,
-0.0162396636,
0.0334625021,
-0.0420938693,
0.0045793364,
0.0327083431,
0.0533414446,
0.0464730971,
0.0848323852,
-0.0451005287,
-0.0198219214,
-0.033627823,
-0.0397007093,
-0.0489732884,
-0.0293421149,
0.0447300151,
0.0122370776,
-0.015613528,
-0.0279817134,
-0.0146535505,
0.0224696044,
-0.0062188185,
0.0209501199,
-0.0072711133,
0.0054091751,
-0.0516335145,
0.005509512,
0.0442867689,
0.0727688298,
-0.0510103628,
-0.0627180114,
0.025455514,
0.0073379143,
0.007141029,
-0.0167515781,
-0.0616658814,
-0.0673265457,
-0.0021901918,
0.0362999998,
-0.0421493277,
-0.0112746647,
0.0332081951,
0.0188829973,
-0.0305605941,
0.0052873036,
0.0344580933,
-0.0434348807,
-0.0301452689,
-0.0264335219,
-0.0703195333,
-0.0480018556,
0.0352583006,
0.0043652439,
-0.0332541168,
0.0165552385,
-0.0593057498,
-0.0804920346,
0.0091918772,
-0.0305037592,
-0.0022416636,
0.0373261236,
0.0367573202,
0.0394591764,
-0.0453896672,
0.0718160868,
0.0334803276,
0.0040650112,
-0.0321550258,
-0.0081378967,
-0.0356899984,
0.0251144785,
-0.0822151005,
0.0354525037,
-0.0116063775,
-0.0424689166,
-0.0515123792,
0.0114680463,
0.0077138115,
-0.0268408004,
0.0444086939,
-0.0373798981,
-0.029941801,
-0.0147014149,
0.0390913486,
0.0332143903,
-0.0360411853,
0.0109716663,
-0.0271187797,
-0.037519142,
-0.0165916234,
-0.0007141735,
0.0409677476,
-0.0018539513,
0.0086066416,
0.0049205688,
-0.0210215002,
-0.0590175688,
-0.0281852894,
0.0286573581,
0.0172747169,
-0.0321740583,
-0.0571013764,
-0.069481805,
-0.0164621528,
0.0044331471,
0.0168349929,
-0.0446366407,
-0.0054475395,
0.012369765,
-0.0269165672,
0.037756782,
-0.0115680266,
0.020705523,
0.0114036752,
0.0042412234,
0.0059457934,
0.0804287344,
0.030035004,
0.0030368138,
0.0636109412,
0.0049030376,
0.0120645938,
0.0625066757,
0.0352221392,
0.0456384011,
-0.0118999351,
-0.0107062049,
-0.0398974046,
0.0294351764,
0.0169008896,
0.054495126,
-0.0651184693,
0.0056454204,
0.0680264086,
0.0523325652,
0.0376028046,
0.023656005,
0.0200065877,
0.0437841415,
0.0161514785,
-0.0007554758,
0.0002779168,
-0.0227604043,
-0.0139413979,
0.0347843952,
0.0630069301,
0.0274226647,
-0.0347745866,
-0.0318894386,
-0.0092132809,
-0.0317875855,
0.0021507158,
0.0053285649,
0.0383726805,
0.0325028077,
-0.0971392617,
0.0355700962,
0.0125488751,
-0.0554413907,
-0.0187584572,
-0.0318656117,
-0.008871817,
0.0349274538,
0.0871406347,
-0.0403416529,
-0.0309934076,
-0.0137143023,
0.007010987,
-0.0178071409,
0.0488035195,
-0.021192573,
0.0140371714,
-0.0756292716,
-0.0076081478,
0.033842627,
0.0243799947,
-0.0146747166,
0.0747507885,
-0.0054192021,
0.0053456426,
-0.0934488699,
-0.0096084978,
0.0415896513,
0.0037025511,
-0.0259272102,
0.043555405,
0.0175727438,
0.0290815867,
-0.0060164309,
-0.0165671762,
-0.0041270191,
0.0125979334,
-0.0283772927,
-0.00599025,
-0.0198077448,
-0.0630652159,
-0.0835099369,
0.0191492178,
-0.0436102301,
-0.0245472677,
0.0507690534,
-0.0573147424,
-0.0137905581,
-0.0229577105,
-0.04687538,
0.0589300282,
-0.0513247587,
0.043192625,
-0.0170141403,
0.0010829084,
-0.056660533,
0.0553832576,
0.0273197554,
0.0165627729,
0.0230961163,
-0.004367643,
0.0417168327,
0.0004918421,
0.0205348674,
-0.0144447945,
-0.038584549,
-0.0049271034,
0.0413864516,
0.0281099807,
-0.0080188615,
-0.0031433459,
-0.1277063042,
-0.0046331817,
-0.0301901456,
0.0090067331,
0.0350405611,
0.0477081165,
-0.0206835642,
-0.0093148733,
-0.0139884092,
-0.0570153669,
0.0018966072,
0.0149924392,
0.0408300832,
0.0105549907,
-0.0250390731,
-0.0213997494,
-0.0147982417,
0.0073478841,
0.0601611137,
-0.0371199325,
-0.037718527,
-0.0110456711,
0.0561058819,
0.009119872,
0.0019469842,
0.0117503852,
-0.0138605749,
-0.0365497023,
-0.0026941991,
0.0651911497,
0.0838439986,
0.0258379113,
0.0317944176,
0.0077039106,
0.022802582,
-0.0488907993,
0.0018445407,
-0.0166807119,
0.0340805389,
-0.015954148,
-0.0300925765,
0.0572687574,
0.0165629704,
-0.0021228665,
0.0143803386,
-0.0721530691,
0.0024925275,
-0.0166373719,
-0.0024133592,
-0.0438020565,
-0.0175268874,
-0.0148280123,
0.0175113063,
-0.0082440898,
-0.0342634879,
0.0571222045,
-0.0002170582,
0.0150623173,
-0.091763936,
0.003903565,
-0.0368207097,
0.0024785809,
-0.0154925063,
0.0386321694,
-0.0041564619,
-0.0072531719,
-0.0411497951,
-0.0146191353,
0.0277096462,
-0.0254470743,
0.0230925195,
-0.0607398599,
0.0210038908,
-0.0173295345,
-0.0677487031,
-0.0084132273,
-0.0323035307,
0.0113591179,
0.0082455734,
0.0131297996,
-0.0115139568,
-0.0229031723,
0.0123449843,
0.0026678666,
0.0827810168,
-0.0180011056,
-0.0052367579,
-0.0062412121,
0.0392776392,
0.0482896529,
-0.0451818556,
0.0249407645,
-0.0034337023,
0.027408231,
0.0260699745,
0.0562567487,
-0.0208673514,
-0.0114298472,
-0.0137745216,
0.0193805471,
-0.0561644286,
-0.0250136629,
0.0507410765,
0.0339141823,
-0.0445004031,
-0.0070103351,
0.1175554469,
0.038551148,
-0.0368698314,
0.0082157971,
0.0404630154,
0.0334438384,
-0.0131502515,
-0.001794812,
-0.0583255962,
-0.0338573791,
0.044046659,
0.0065265046,
-0.0068868641,
0.0085149473,
-0.0168433953,
-0.0853042305,
0.0429033339,
0.0110108331,
-0.0504094847,
-0.0432901531,
-0.0576282889,
0.0420048051,
-0.0176940896,
0.0163823105,
0.0029441563,
-0.0378576182,
0.0096452171,
-0.0163968671,
-0.0510921925,
-0.1078120321,
-0.012612029,
-0.0033737984,
0.0022329893,
0.024722876,
0.0501578003,
0.0382642969,
-0.0087185157,
0.0491736531,
-0.0020400281,
-0.0167696923,
-0.0457174741,
0.0360607132,
0.0384598337,
0.0094548669,
0.0021745763,
0.0192932244,
-0.0207497142,
0.0099003864,
-0.0010197026,
0.0459132157,
0.0202288646,
-0.0013035585,
0.0263038781,
-0.0474044271,
-0.0088123102,
0.0763792247,
0.0475000106,
-0.0081024831,
-0.0575123504,
-0.0030959107,
-0.0108654285,
-0.0413266309,
0.004968043,
-0.0292759519,
-0.0288424194,
-0.0394936539,
-0.0719239637,
0.0044666408,
0.0460889302,
0.0461142398,
0.0028897384,
0.0102519933,
0.0050778948,
0.0225642435,
-0.0289841965,
0.001304609,
-0.0116163846,
0.0224768836,
-0.0569235496,
0.03528402,
0.0092265867,
0.0118924649,
-0.0232519992,
0.0461728983,
-0.0621011816,
-0.0559670031,
-0.0128470855,
0.0205399767,
0.0213598236,
0.0465917438,
-0.018413607,
-0.029215904,
0.0512803122,
0.0310918521,
-0.0359835699,
0.0353524163,
0.0329768248,
-0.025524376,
0.0051103481,
0.0494515672,
-0.0447742939,
0.0154227251,
-0.0061216722,
0.0172850471,
-0.0518003404,
0.0047023697,
0.0148735251,
0.0303725079,
0.0160597377,
-0.0016993493,
-0.0326572768,
-0.0038101173,
0.0281590428,
-0.0314107798,
0.01570368,
-0.0174082164,
0.0423667915,
0.0125960363,
0.0401824303,
-0.0614276938,
0.0712854266,
0.0027786912,
-0.0135579547,
-0.0273486339,
-0.006966522,
-0.0394738466,
0.0129872635,
0.0306939743,
-0.030225696,
-0.0373515338,
-0.0354189016,
0.0138113583,
-0.0164834186,
-0.0517566018,
0.0052752383,
0.0208202731,
0.0433371775,
-0.0169654004,
0.0559610128,
-0.0270681158,
-0.0113589307,
-0.0495387651,
0.0443443507,
0.0382838435,
-0.0201272294,
0.0983912274,
-0.0363604054,
-0.0428140201,
-0.0292449687,
0.0038027852,
0.0227772519,
0.005352431,
-0.0299339406,
0.0023406518,
-0.0126561895,
0.045337256,
0.0939002186,
-0.0372418128,
0.0315189958,
0.0085131042,
-0.0137786483,
-0.0543628894,
-0.0145225376,
0.0113993026,
0.0459350944,
0.0155482246,
-0.0065151071,
-0.0342513584,
-0.0492323004,
-0.0060318839,
-0.0321444497,
-0.0388471372,
-0.0315859243,
0.0562182181,
0.0535458848,
-0.001012854,
-0.0092381286,
-0.0103759402,
-0.0631334037,
-0.0261783246,
-0.0594630726,
-0.0308954399,
-6.201114002e-33,
0.0076506832,
0.0087277303,
-0.0094561558,
-0.032785967,
-0.0210464932,
-0.0024119704,
-0.0543333404,
-0.0287287626,
-0.0157586895,
0.006811067,
-0.0400925577,
0.010082691,
0.009978734,
0.0163202826,
-0.0590920001,
0.0343602896,
0.0608850196,
-0.0016421006,
-0.0360238887,
0.0136391595,
-0.0256752968,
0.0220627468,
0.0329331793,
-0.0860983357,
-0.0471980087,
0.0284977611,
-0.0532896519,
-0.0020087596,
0.0393625461,
0.0270945709,
-0.0087546166,
0.0236963984,
0.0165050253,
-0.0469308309,
-0.0203430094,
0.0361418761,
-0.0822820887,
-0.0247424375,
0.0297975913,
-0.0118152732,
-0.0114802578,
-0.041480545,
0.0584016517,
-0.0141697982,
-0.0115663204,
0.0018662056,
0.0202930607,
-0.047964558,
-0.0290612672,
-0.0905292705,
-0.0466029085,
0.0438453406,
-0.0405136757,
-0.022463562,
0.0205629766,
0.033202026,
-0.0379625894,
0.0496776775,
0.01687604,
0.0219507981,
0.0318675563,
0.0587133877,
0.0356020592,
-0.0262950901,
0.03171058,
0.0324951634,
-0.0385976285,
0.0054685152,
0.0219671689,
-0.0791120529,
0.0404261164,
0.0268717576,
0.0580784306,
0.0530555062,
0.0316508412,
-0.0022575718,
-0.0813910589,
0.0434476547,
0.0376707129,
-0.0144560607,
0.0086959563,
0.0288364831,
-0.0530860573,
-0.0150887761,
-0.0264696255,
-0.0058174613,
-0.0195734687,
-0.0151424855,
0.0241872892,
0.0383300297,
-0.0192090236,
0.0310257189,
0.0225430205,
-0.0137098255,
-0.0198233873,
0.0286392439,
-0.008589603,
0.0071042888,
0.0267990269,
-0.0072484748,
-0.0211385991,
-0.0015619373,
0.0332169905,
0.0352998562,
0.0025025259,
-0.0254905913,
0.0377453975,
0.0112521835,
-0.0874473155,
0.0210028049,
0.0325099267,
-0.000726538,
0.0072207218,
-0.0232847203,
0.0170056857,
0.0202890988,
0.023871379,
0.0495073982,
0.026111111,
-0.0421930216,
-0.0186918229,
0.0119305607,
0.0042676479,
0.0162005685,
-0.0121611077,
-0.0110076517,
-0.0246065184,
0.0277480632,
0.07567285,
-0.0300711151,
-0.049136661,
0.0001014211,
2.76e-7,
0.0632627457,
0.0775407851,
0.0279224981,
-0.0226544049,
0.002610821,
0.0258610956,
0.0211466439,
-0.0065903966,
-0.0184797719,
0.0490865037,
0.0770793632,
-0.0166782681,
0.0476903319,
-0.0103961267,
-0.0872774422,
0.056577377,
-0.0544673577,
-0.0359726436,
-0.0593732633,
-0.0150278332,
0.0168447215,
0.0993583202,
0.0068191998,
0.0102473311,
-0.0051305597,
-0.0510635972,
0.0370213836,
-0.0716594756,
0.0107540879,
0.0380782858,
0.0170653947,
-0.0100823306,
0.0138260014,
-0.0013009206,
-0.019677937,
0.0034446823,
0.0370046236,
0.0912322998,
-0.0084544132,
0.0235493649,
-0.0001093915,
-0.0251527037,
-0.0071154139,
-0.0668987185,
0.0660577267,
-0.0567166433,
0.0239033643,
-0.0106582642,
-0.0126014389,
-0.0058729867,
0.016642414,
0.0017545804,
-0.024219038,
0.0468476936,
0.0249847136,
0.0155632459,
-0.0038525446,
-0.0861467794,
0.0010537277,
0.0190266613,
-0.0293242019,
0.0035597296,
-0.0414806381,
0.0405532271,
0.0668577626,
-0.0332387947,
0.0335053019,
3.192144679e-34,
0.0506186932,
-0.0283448379,
-0.0028430836,
0.0230620634,
0.0242118984,
-0.0416203178,
-0.0112137375,
0.0082887737,
0.0010477118,
-0.068279244,
0.0026420546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14544v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14544v1 | Speed Reading Tool Powered by Artificial Intelligence for Students with ADHD, Dyslexia, or Short Attention Span | 2023-07-26T23:47:14 | 2023-07-26T23:47:14 | Megat Irfan Zackry Bin Ismail Ahmad Nazran bin Yusri Muhammad Hafizzul Bin Abdul Manap Muhammad Muizzuddin Bin Kamarozaman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents a novel approach to assist students with dyslexia, ADHD,
and short attention span in digesting any text-based information more
efficiently. The proposed solution utilizes the Multilayer Perceptron (MLP)
algorithm for complex text processing and summarization tasks. The tool
leverages the T5 (Text-to-Text Transfer Transformer) model from Hugging Face,
which treats every NLP task as a text generation task. The model is fine-tuned
on specific tasks using a smaller dataset. The NLTK's Punkt Sentence Tokenizer
is used to divide a text into a list of sentences. The application is served
using Flask, a lightweight web server and framework. The tool also applies
principles from Bionic Reading to enhance readability, which includes a bolding
function and adjustments to line, word, and character spacing. The paper
discusses the methodology, implementation, and results of the AI-based speed
reading tool. | [
0.0090859244,
-0.0652210191,
-0.0291350018,
0.0181505866,
-0.0221807081,
0.0184308644,
0.0489473976,
-0.0255244449,
0.0555344895,
-0.0374210626,
0.0075333235,
-0.011876747,
0.013378852,
0.0536539592,
-0.0019957258,
-0.1248744056,
0.0131683191,
-0.0234163366,
0.0324477516,
0.0189789906,
0.0239346828,
-0.0030425093,
-0.0351386629,
0.0386710241,
0.0497756563,
-0.046109356,
0.0085809976,
-0.0108083729,
0.0410578102,
-0.0428930484,
0.0155790728,
0.020635942,
-0.0322141647,
0.0356461369,
0.0000023419,
-0.0043735369,
0.0017007597,
-0.0003033307,
0.0324362628,
0.0180194173,
0.0954343081,
-0.0196990632,
0.0007210568,
0.0330224968,
0.003799818,
0.0157854874,
0.0538223386,
0.0668141395,
0.0520163812,
0.0533026606,
-0.0022684471,
-0.0203258414,
0.0623353608,
0.0410245024,
0.0200693682,
-0.0172512345,
-0.0096336249,
-0.0116397543,
0.06478104,
-0.0000316683,
-0.0110085467,
0.0828871131,
0.0091637094,
-0.0059650033,
0.0529149771,
0.0226965602,
0.0065669627,
-0.0316338353,
-0.0458561108,
0.0673978999,
0.0022578477,
-0.0081049474,
0.0022279157,
0.0140600316,
-0.0114814267,
0.0255130623,
-0.0679082423,
-0.005602784,
-0.0279265475,
-0.0023426213,
0.0165137816,
-0.0291585214,
-0.0058453097,
-0.0195897147,
0.0137324855,
-0.0137454476,
0.0047098165,
-0.0602118261,
-0.0537743978,
0.0344474912,
0.0268561058,
-0.018287003,
0.0796774253,
0.0312405322,
0.02732688,
-0.0101840477,
-0.0814322755,
-0.139620319,
-0.0054468201,
-0.0533802994,
0.0421912819,
0.0370642282,
-0.0198458489,
0.0043422077,
-0.0367604122,
0.0184669904,
0.0175881926,
0.0429963395,
-0.0297342036,
0.0662528351,
-0.0044162623,
-0.0131737972,
-0.0095627438,
0.0448395275,
-0.0508615971,
-0.0541418418,
-0.0575197227,
0.0099130534,
0.0450901054,
-0.0425569713,
-0.0022379409,
0.0111421589,
-0.0103427526,
0.0018157243,
-0.0073981411,
0.0603067614,
-0.0271635503,
-0.014948816,
0.0099659087,
0.0089591704,
0.0049672085,
-0.0112459213,
0.0303142276,
-0.023514498,
0.0096085966,
0.073018916,
-0.0315610766,
-0.033905372,
-0.0861750618,
0.0041259197,
0.0046582501,
0.0166965462,
-0.0250820536,
-0.0529436208,
0.0092600575,
0.0288041178,
0.0072536715,
-0.0192600098,
-0.0079259723,
0.0482604392,
-0.0151181286,
0.0097773829,
-0.058255747,
-0.0021361408,
0.0771863982,
0.0157187469,
0.0181772746,
0.0432461202,
0.060794428,
0.0165127739,
0.0221976638,
-0.0284333006,
0.0018785237,
0.0271231681,
-0.0234507173,
-0.0312044136,
-0.017556807,
-0.0635146201,
-0.066744782,
-0.0044930778,
0.0097334795,
0.0534536615,
-0.013518774,
0.0475492701,
0.0773172751,
0.0617889948,
0.0358626917,
0.0246942062,
-0.0122502372,
0.0428512618,
0.0423866697,
0.025317356,
0.0166127477,
0.0565052778,
-0.0463419631,
0.0267790742,
0.009865921,
0.0622233674,
0.0193159189,
-0.0341758467,
0.0254815277,
-0.0022471107,
0.0040890668,
0.0187691785,
0.0469767377,
-0.01977624,
-0.0522529818,
0.0050000902,
0.0141170043,
-0.050690867,
0.0088141374,
-0.0084543377,
-0.0320647806,
0.104552269,
0.0402723439,
-0.0432435386,
-0.0037160348,
-0.0126218591,
-0.0315519683,
0.0459390432,
-0.0106927054,
0.008058764,
-0.0065246751,
-0.0627419949,
0.0115177762,
0.0323903151,
0.0102134114,
-0.009899551,
-0.0243581682,
0.0589800291,
0.0119530251,
0.0297303498,
-0.0558078587,
0.051825501,
-0.0466637649,
-0.0289335474,
-0.0272175632,
0.0187073536,
-0.0036875622,
0.0338795856,
-0.0049198861,
0.0005247798,
0.006358447,
-0.0168001298,
0.0017492315,
-0.0125424741,
-0.0271034017,
-0.0192427766,
0.0342610367,
-0.05850311,
0.0308925174,
0.0485834368,
0.0648248568,
-0.0421012901,
0.0422321782,
-0.0705981851,
-0.007274522,
0.0141673554,
0.0458512791,
-0.0066189948,
0.0250387639,
-0.0400610641,
0.056205593,
0.0338590033,
-0.0206483621,
-0.0148480274,
-0.0230003893,
-0.0339972191,
-0.0047754836,
-0.0047164476,
-0.0130818188,
-0.0127044795,
0.007778001,
0.014915254,
0.0068505886,
-0.0381108597,
-0.0167900939,
-0.0595615916,
-0.0341411717,
0.0178360716,
-0.0265041757,
0.0114550982,
0.0088998349,
-0.0085789198,
-0.0006264232,
0.02000257,
0.0252660625,
-0.000956629,
-0.0079042148,
0.0231250301,
0.0127585633,
-0.0391046181,
-0.0386737436,
-0.0503359623,
-0.040482752,
0.0329947211,
0.0685583428,
-0.0676855892,
-0.0153252911,
-0.002815098,
0.0127831716,
-0.0124767516,
0.0393542685,
-0.0317482203,
0.0069999695,
0.0007673772,
0.0892497748,
0.1078284755,
0.0451098867,
0.0177154001,
0.0300729442,
-0.0370195322,
-0.0092363572,
0.0261275005,
0.0055541443,
0.0925578699,
0.0173026267,
-0.0355144367,
0.0268169884,
0.0253474563,
0.0640806258,
0.0048962389,
-0.0482515767,
0.0047213333,
-0.0125829717,
-0.0019744565,
-0.0425707176,
-0.034431871,
-0.0280316658,
0.014317493,
-0.0037825408,
-0.0103349518,
0.0822699964,
-0.0244595967,
0.0013074575,
-0.0667707101,
-0.0128518771,
-0.011105312,
0.018998567,
-0.0037532374,
0.0157768279,
-0.0601121746,
-0.0505219437,
0.0095994435,
0.0252706762,
0.0248886347,
-0.0070987972,
0.0614906065,
-0.0587676577,
-0.0347613543,
-0.0245123319,
-0.0032846204,
-0.0138288401,
0.0290679615,
-0.0250907987,
-0.0875328705,
0.0272777267,
-0.0457589701,
-0.0930456072,
-0.0168162305,
0.0774674639,
0.1035727262,
-0.0360569544,
-0.0001674607,
0.0033771899,
-0.0065103481,
0.02891545,
-0.0862957984,
0.0078461496,
-0.0558650345,
0.0719468966,
0.0463990644,
0.0332859792,
-0.0241469853,
0.0274311192,
0.0015802857,
0.026416501,
-0.0193749815,
0.0045787352,
0.008914018,
0.01001109,
-0.0755074769,
0.0120226284,
0.0510688424,
0.0284865461,
-0.0564689413,
-0.0148098245,
-0.0450476222,
-0.0115258321,
-0.0361446999,
0.0279216375,
-0.0570658855,
-0.0461877696,
0.0001021856,
0.0741016045,
-0.0236583762,
-0.0395280607,
-0.0111384913,
0.0030455184,
-0.004335226,
0.0360414423,
-0.0582079105,
-0.0329999961,
-0.0220348258,
-0.0309280772,
0.0538186468,
0.0267873649,
0.0037126958,
-0.0245123152,
0.020032594,
-0.0048058503,
-0.0359599032,
-0.0095561566,
-0.0140971253,
0.028697418,
0.0423325598,
0.033640597,
0.0220776908,
-0.0205781572,
-0.0327542461,
0.0305741765,
0.0222958196,
-0.0220552944,
-0.0202149972,
0.061195191,
-0.02846637,
-0.0052418071,
-0.0393978991,
0.0473644994,
-0.0273865163,
0.0017741704,
0.0437150113,
0.0305772256,
0.0259375479,
-0.0122390334,
-0.0574998707,
0.0258146971,
-0.0299001634,
0.0296700094,
-0.0001760707,
-0.0526997373,
-0.0422662757,
-0.0234091617,
-0.0364790559,
-0.0898241997,
-0.0669122264,
0.0105276294,
-0.0234098081,
-0.0657976344,
-0.0712736398,
-0.0272311345,
0.0558874086,
0.0304756742,
0.0407831147,
0.0267733335,
0.0310374834,
0.0459679142,
-0.0284960717,
0.0095804585,
0.0306172501,
-0.0104620364,
-0.0838911831,
-0.0286169834,
-0.04186441,
-0.0581233762,
0.0174898691,
0.0613030642,
-0.0402705036,
-0.0381658226,
0.0483714454,
0.0208626576,
0.017418569,
-0.0105476649,
0.023540603,
-0.0348316506,
0.023656413,
0.0541243106,
-0.0531015508,
-0.0175604913,
-0.0356159955,
-0.0616791211,
0.0096500712,
-0.0220332313,
-0.0009278404,
0.0315857045,
-0.023647232,
-0.011974372,
-0.0166966487,
-0.0123848375,
-0.0117097199,
0.0762675628,
-0.0168847088,
-0.0080044307,
-0.0487758964,
-0.0474453606,
-0.0216922946,
-0.0565615557,
0.0272077452,
-0.0327870846,
0.0194951147,
0.0240363553,
-0.0082751187,
-0.0073674503,
-0.033312548,
0.0177770052,
-0.0795982927,
-0.0276808552,
0.0801607519,
-0.0505251177,
0.0636276603,
-0.0027884371,
-0.0247148909,
-0.0169374086,
-0.0422403403,
-0.0414278097,
0.0448428877,
0.0093000298,
0.0497999229,
0.0244191792,
-0.0341506861,
-0.0071464921,
0.0398351327,
-0.0542178154,
0.0266400129,
-0.062441811,
-0.0132890074,
-0.0165348165,
0.0164815933,
0.0379636101,
-0.0269078445,
0.0058986801,
-0.0203477908,
0.0219800472,
0.0269037187,
0.0005079586,
-0.0408065729,
0.0049661188,
0.0404866748,
-0.0483434126,
0.0580770746,
-0.0248955451,
-0.051779259,
0.0444595404,
-0.0328836441,
-0.0750730932,
-0.0114217671,
0.0004149307,
0.0763004273,
0.0044285208,
0.0061419201,
-0.0142276706,
-0.009413722,
0.0310742911,
0.0035963627,
0.0291665308,
-0.0311738048,
-0.0324534066,
0.0099906521,
-0.0133634452,
-0.0626323968,
-0.0140224798,
0.0398134552,
-0.0250528008,
-0.0080624232,
0.0010681986,
-6.285854655e-33,
-0.0188390799,
-0.0717830956,
0.0270952582,
0.0458096527,
-0.0299937893,
0.019864846,
-0.0322952308,
0.0277352799,
0.0126652401,
-0.008003735,
-0.0147486432,
0.0212048702,
0.0129292514,
0.0427879281,
-0.0149323167,
0.0343511589,
0.0002773663,
-0.0152805904,
-0.0138866026,
0.0221473724,
0.0174985621,
0.0250756703,
0.0435410142,
-0.0254835431,
-0.0020357401,
-0.0112139918,
0.014803037,
-0.0555013418,
0.0235256851,
-0.0261339787,
-0.0344248749,
0.048823677,
0.0091504427,
-0.0077968594,
-0.0026730075,
0.0681442767,
-0.0463678017,
0.011824281,
-0.0048322375,
0.0080961669,
-0.0222083833,
-0.0263609514,
0.0525974482,
-0.0061251572,
0.0176966786,
-0.0254731495,
0.0704814121,
-0.0750773847,
-0.0061285053,
0.0247582216,
-0.0627582148,
0.0435347818,
-0.0337136202,
-0.0035324511,
0.0148607148,
0.0738350004,
-0.0198263656,
0.013306723,
-0.0615946166,
0.025926061,
0.0486323871,
0.0215572286,
0.0119028902,
0.0098087369,
0.0025807889,
0.0487603545,
0.0278541092,
0.0033777698,
-0.0310058594,
0.0323088281,
0.0527947433,
-0.0024558816,
0.0540362336,
0.002056414,
0.0285356548,
-0.0224639252,
-0.0184333343,
0.0546985045,
0.0478281379,
-0.0173045266,
0.0426988527,
-0.0121244844,
-0.0741816163,
-0.0000157707,
0.0283915531,
0.0562758744,
-0.0390191674,
0.004575274,
-0.0068219658,
-0.0259838514,
-0.0404898524,
-0.0358020626,
-0.0246339124,
0.0014227901,
0.0384632945,
-0.009762926,
0.0019882615,
0.0345599279,
-0.0127075911,
-0.031372156,
-0.0078161368,
-0.0081959758,
-0.0038017747,
0.0387494601,
0.006124706,
-0.0037503489,
-0.0092687439,
-0.012648128,
-0.0393954515,
-0.0062711523,
0.0058903121,
0.025483286,
0.0616880208,
0.0352555178,
-0.0004399162,
-0.0234193522,
-0.0136806816,
0.025898125,
-0.0144073404,
-0.0371882133,
-0.0355696864,
-0.0132675152,
0.0102807907,
-0.0035567409,
-0.0378928743,
-0.0222194847,
-0.0458459519,
0.0299472772,
0.0058225058,
-0.08681532,
0.0177031923,
-0.0035279018,
3.029e-7,
0.010465879,
0.0854315832,
0.0536065549,
-0.0312619768,
-0.0090909041,
0.0186140332,
0.0386689901,
0.0151846297,
0.0430942848,
0.0629949123,
0.0177218132,
0.0217597857,
0.0190203004,
0.0103561748,
-0.0441501476,
-0.0301432274,
-0.0203195103,
0.0361608937,
-0.0322749987,
0.0347782485,
0.051639013,
-0.0211202223,
-0.008584151,
-0.0322127827,
0.0500027612,
-0.0282260086,
-0.0091509186,
0.0274863206,
0.0357989557,
0.0008904745,
0.0210562646,
-0.0316269062,
0.0073408373,
0.0194414686,
-0.0196373891,
-0.0104316026,
0.011412642,
0.0280596111,
-0.0297312923,
0.0167088285,
0.0444139801,
0.0020848468,
-0.0346089713,
-0.0129767293,
0.0137447827,
0.0142251067,
-0.0222070646,
0.0541986823,
-0.0310691781,
-0.0342947394,
-0.0266459472,
-0.0104923956,
-0.0125540001,
0.0110782497,
-0.0058602397,
-0.0652052388,
0.0241014082,
-0.0551008284,
-0.034783788,
0.0065670982,
-0.0196526572,
0.0214468036,
-0.0754513815,
-0.0202394109,
0.0066670673,
-0.0541116521,
0.014761704,
2.669904452e-34,
0.0055532428,
-0.0168244783,
-0.0016545374,
0.001877315,
0.0187441949,
-0.0219045747,
0.0367148481,
-0.0056695784,
0.0118753845,
-0.0697084218,
-0.0324353874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14539v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14539v2 | Jailbreak in pieces: Compositional Adversarial Attacks on Multi-Modal Language Models | 2023-07-26T23:11:15 | 2023-10-10T22:17:17 | Erfan Shayegani, Yue Dong, Nael Abu-Ghazaleh | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | We introduce new jailbreak attacks on vision language models (VLMs), which
use aligned LLMs and are resilient to text-only jailbreak attacks.
Specifically, we develop cross-modality attacks on alignment where we pair
adversarial images going through the vision encoder with textual prompts to
break the alignment of the language model. Our attacks employ a novel
compositional strategy that combines an image, adversarially targeted towards
toxic embeddings, with generic prompts to accomplish the jailbreak. Thus, the
LLM draws the context to answer the generic prompt from the adversarial image.
The generation of benign-appearing adversarial images leverages a novel
embedding-space-based methodology, operating with no access to the LLM model.
Instead, the attacks require access only to the vision encoder and utilize one
of our four embedding space targeting strategies. By not requiring access to
the LLM, the attacks lower the entry barrier for attackers, particularly when
vision encoders such as CLIP are embedded in closed-source LLMs. The attacks
achieve a high success rate across different VLMs, highlighting the risk of
cross-modality alignment vulnerabilities, and the need for new alignment
approaches for multi-modal models. | [
0.0152148306,
0.0663287714,
-0.0179807637,
0.060973566,
-0.0295275208,
0.0075100414,
0.0205145311,
-0.0092953648,
0.004837601,
-0.0396738537,
-0.0186226461,
-0.0105865477,
0.0457051322,
0.0172949843,
0.0815827847,
-0.009879739,
0.0338352062,
-0.0217926502,
-0.0502881892,
0.0027434323,
0.0371572226,
-0.0101331091,
0.0176823102,
0.0411360189,
-0.0114700682,
-0.0256727412,
-0.0371727049,
0.0392891094,
0.0302657932,
-0.0017552061,
-0.0071358499,
0.0339011811,
0.0056103468,
0.0524398685,
0.000001971,
-0.0036903361,
-0.022959955,
0.0403101705,
0.0069087464,
0.0214399081,
-0.0100510567,
-0.0902652293,
-0.0278778151,
0.0062380224,
-0.0328546427,
0.0158267897,
0.0519005619,
0.0448769256,
0.0886430293,
0.0747220814,
-0.0046346448,
-0.0225228481,
0.0445938781,
-0.0263606645,
0.0145698572,
-0.0320762321,
0.0141282585,
-0.0369827226,
-0.0366429649,
0.0277531464,
-0.020025067,
0.0235713962,
0.0282846522,
-0.00410474,
-0.0508958548,
0.006245126,
0.0011129696,
-0.0461234786,
-0.0107214125,
0.052656211,
-0.037301369,
0.0125570185,
0.0013240506,
0.0213577859,
0.0271321367,
0.0113302041,
-0.0244891774,
0.0409358293,
0.0176645089,
0.0158586204,
-0.0295295417,
-0.0430357642,
0.0447198078,
-0.0182651561,
0.015503021,
-0.0223241784,
0.0452376306,
-0.0079307063,
-0.0223514903,
-0.0228594225,
-0.0048260121,
-0.0465261936,
-0.0172705557,
0.0022236663,
0.0275287442,
0.0138751743,
-0.123454906,
-0.0146413427,
0.020693155,
-0.0177421719,
0.045498006,
0.0158521421,
-0.0295851901,
0.0351721756,
-0.0233829357,
0.0299299322,
-0.0507816002,
0.0654917434,
-0.02098215,
0.0021455307,
0.0271523502,
-0.0374346636,
0.0311281458,
-0.0202323627,
-0.0285777021,
-0.0281527396,
-0.0203221664,
0.0449364819,
-0.0323245116,
0.0483954847,
-0.0555818975,
0.0218239781,
-0.0239886828,
0.0071819532,
0.0425860211,
-0.0137243913,
0.0452886298,
-0.0236645639,
-0.005226579,
-0.072694093,
-0.0499240607,
0.0472469106,
-0.064590998,
-0.0173568204,
-0.0327252969,
0.126064226,
0.0027611388,
-0.0146870036,
-0.0319028012,
-0.0614803955,
-0.0532593317,
-0.0211903397,
0.0440823883,
-0.0618689619,
-0.0013964085,
-0.0336129963,
-0.0244187862,
-0.0737532005,
0.0351664536,
0.019883642,
-0.028343007,
0.0985099897,
0.0321424603,
-0.0412041582,
0.0081378166,
0.0309123788,
0.0293366928,
0.0762006491,
0.0098612998,
0.0456814989,
0.0460687242,
-0.0137495771,
0.0146318348,
0.0631699935,
0.0129880244,
0.0267112702,
-0.0519478396,
-0.0274930745,
0.0553911254,
0.0179655626,
-0.0177991986,
0.0430149548,
-0.0001523655,
-0.0520827174,
0.0912426636,
0.0458673462,
-0.0259501096,
0.018318817,
-0.0304500684,
-0.0480589755,
-0.0083712442,
0.0299316198,
-0.0869287699,
0.0305180941,
-0.0756354108,
-0.0017840473,
-0.0031737338,
0.0543429554,
-0.0239280723,
-0.0010100012,
0.0051771901,
-0.0059699952,
-0.00522148,
-0.0101906052,
0.0057016588,
0.0155187286,
-0.0207334459,
0.0656143427,
-0.0007038563,
-0.0396569595,
-0.0147883352,
-0.0424627066,
-0.0278107133,
-0.0099884588,
0.0431183204,
0.0024945443,
0.0111617651,
-0.0232812893,
0.0022758623,
0.0356169306,
-0.0097187655,
0.0168487616,
0.0159307923,
-0.0222766921,
-0.0354189575,
-0.0750393644,
0.0081216646,
-0.0181703623,
-0.0229558051,
0.0089433147,
-0.0083417427,
-0.0231171045,
0.0289897788,
0.0362603031,
0.0246987268,
-0.0095653981,
-0.0303821769,
0.0684825927,
0.0029000407,
0.0052683218,
-0.0351565629,
0.0262460075,
0.0735215247,
-0.0359003134,
0.0366827361,
0.0101694446,
-0.03801677,
-0.0447177328,
0.0456497408,
-0.0831579342,
-0.0151798977,
0.0545448624,
-0.0400892794,
0.0051342328,
0.036034584,
-0.0360418446,
0.0295369364,
-0.0069541764,
0.0095033506,
-0.0037728664,
0.0330643132,
-0.0298256744,
0.0193523131,
-0.0490244664,
-0.0202016868,
0.0223388541,
0.0069827521,
0.0036980328,
0.0057921549,
-0.0527460761,
0.0230917968,
-0.0219248999,
0.0110813882,
-0.0148773845,
-0.0060335211,
-0.0021366668,
-0.0427344665,
-0.0494288914,
-0.0320260487,
-0.0159387682,
-0.0000586027,
0.030667631,
0.017795112,
-0.0006101648,
-0.014091948,
-0.0215526484,
0.0113665219,
-0.0050387089,
0.0207431875,
0.0110101104,
-0.0229240023,
-0.0328383595,
-0.0072939112,
-0.0203481503,
0.0170954466,
0.0823619068,
-0.0381179787,
-0.0241132956,
-0.0399619378,
-0.0088133402,
-0.0081719933,
0.0429207981,
-0.034120176,
-0.0356178507,
0.0465024896,
0.0240773819,
0.0082723266,
0.0925185159,
0.0137820523,
0.0726026744,
0.0507644415,
0.0223492812,
-0.0165740624,
-0.0295962095,
0.0517826229,
-0.0140647106,
-0.0304208435,
-0.0306780078,
0.010932833,
0.043611601,
0.0263775159,
0.02791287,
-0.0240217354,
0.063562125,
0.0139067834,
-0.0575741865,
-0.014707448,
-0.0016678751,
-0.0529329441,
-0.0063454616,
-0.0363676287,
-0.0795980543,
0.0355161801,
-0.063926734,
0.0117155565,
0.0612148717,
-0.0223554522,
0.0155945057,
0.0460016057,
0.0113024628,
0.0284691639,
0.0420595594,
-0.0274809115,
-0.0685412288,
-0.0141635202,
0.0231470112,
-0.0155148972,
0.0736487657,
-0.0308625214,
-0.0133132357,
-0.041618634,
-0.0235473644,
-0.0546128489,
-0.0454399586,
0.0096607916,
-0.0121688042,
0.0037086636,
-0.0185872745,
-0.0465709828,
-0.0226723962,
0.0375950262,
-0.0441671275,
-0.0254185814,
0.0271924902,
-0.0375950523,
0.0647588447,
0.0527954362,
-0.0127975708,
-0.008136726,
-0.0262082368,
0.0071270345,
0.0985616148,
-0.0060780793,
0.0416939929,
-0.0212556701,
0.0040920414,
0.0289380644,
0.061441496,
-0.0010943804,
-0.0035370691,
0.0706566125,
-0.0216852091,
0.0051402161,
0.0296250675,
-0.0079698134,
-0.0124561852,
0.0184856821,
0.0317333192,
0.0366062857,
0.0110160112,
-0.0004947635,
-0.0772910491,
-0.0383957513,
0.0286949053,
0.0147026153,
0.0069364547,
0.0217165425,
-0.0269904416,
-0.0923204422,
-0.015547093,
0.0272433963,
0.0023942175,
-0.0410100445,
0.0213354435,
-0.0090851597,
0.015164284,
0.0246179067,
-0.0207917821,
-0.0022425787,
-0.0082928352,
-0.0153649896,
0.043229226,
-0.0290576983,
-0.0357299186,
-0.0261588823,
0.041224543,
0.0748925656,
-0.0083165988,
-0.0248886235,
-0.0475970805,
0.0473947562,
-0.0132302102,
0.0101159774,
0.0300981272,
0.0214196276,
-0.0289138835,
-0.0264837034,
0.0180266239,
0.052429039,
0.0164967198,
-0.0260130558,
0.0046118191,
0.0239917655,
0.0166588444,
0.0123323509,
-0.0380729213,
0.0035967801,
0.0017910582,
0.0442985743,
0.0379044563,
-0.0430474766,
-0.0290047117,
-0.090119265,
-0.0042772712,
-0.0206461269,
-0.062055774,
0.0426093265,
0.0540942512,
-0.0142171839,
-0.0399428979,
-0.0021906076,
-0.0089298058,
0.055035416,
0.0112156225,
-0.0256429277,
-0.0577710718,
0.0097107142,
-0.039510712,
0.0043610432,
0.0070768907,
0.049909167,
-0.0339720398,
0.0511634313,
0.009628213,
-0.0392710529,
-0.0005648544,
-0.0129153663,
-0.1002821475,
-0.100959383,
-0.0205741134,
0.0619693696,
0.009103856,
0.052758012,
0.0006460409,
-0.0306400247,
0.0665722042,
0.0541603006,
0.0128181586,
0.0484944545,
0.0605277382,
-0.03558103,
0.0057161571,
0.0559788309,
-0.0363573618,
-0.0546906106,
0.0655371398,
-0.005565288,
-0.0289349537,
0.0033336408,
0.0191084519,
-0.0224566963,
0.0329824463,
-0.0134925023,
0.0265829209,
0.0229770206,
0.0338108875,
-0.0011568487,
-0.0264515374,
-0.0314933062,
-0.0081742704,
0.0028783544,
-0.0112043694,
0.0509590581,
0.0315848775,
0.0228435211,
-0.0027700078,
-0.0212439504,
0.0480940975,
0.0339327119,
-0.0050552399,
0.0200855788,
0.0572958887,
-0.0203593541,
0.0699069947,
-0.0442239717,
0.00821386,
-0.0170317385,
0.0663853213,
0.0090282494,
-0.0071619391,
-0.0217522718,
0.0566625334,
-0.0426967815,
-0.0056657996,
-0.0213546921,
0.0534532219,
0.0217905957,
-0.0039448957,
-0.002786651,
0.0141798323,
-0.0187979005,
-0.0137931053,
0.0022509908,
-0.0135129308,
-0.0419116095,
0.0672897324,
0.0041500372,
-0.0023835243,
0.0190377478,
0.0574409664,
0.0025594397,
0.0397585295,
0.0129316775,
-0.0059291637,
-0.0344774127,
-0.0191872139,
0.0883095935,
-0.0161399189,
-0.0230487641,
-0.0305724181,
-0.0215008818,
-0.0812583938,
-0.0083499122,
0.0241348371,
0.0069293906,
0.0167313498,
-0.0150285223,
0.0459589399,
0.0152179925,
0.033511024,
-0.0075118179,
0.0228099916,
0.0000172485,
-0.059900064,
0.0186770894,
-6.160762587e-33,
0.0120724291,
-0.0239251927,
-0.0447641574,
-0.0453124121,
-0.0154618239,
0.018593261,
-0.0122962231,
0.0104706055,
-0.0258800611,
-0.0279097985,
0.0040148268,
-0.0167753268,
-0.0186481271,
0.0345472768,
-0.0409060642,
-0.0312883183,
0.005291624,
-0.001253035,
-0.0233061034,
-0.0220078565,
0.0232230071,
0.0043552397,
0.0291687343,
-0.0250665843,
0.0303549543,
-0.0215849224,
-0.0733135939,
0.00820651,
-0.0181490835,
0.0641314536,
-0.0070587546,
-0.0021004095,
-0.0020504498,
0.0165829919,
-0.0012167479,
0.0867169946,
0.0072089271,
0.009398113,
0.0134857809,
0.0274334289,
-0.0564551875,
-0.0479568169,
0.0203468222,
-0.0372267105,
-0.0073685446,
-0.0456215478,
0.0022215398,
-0.004227465,
-0.0179637168,
0.0111118536,
-0.0385113806,
-0.006113681,
-0.0183559693,
-0.0374127738,
0.0120526357,
-0.0064069927,
0.0623401366,
0.0133151757,
-0.0569139048,
0.0273469798,
-0.0022038245,
0.0007830147,
0.0822821185,
0.0251596607,
0.0038037964,
0.0862516537,
-0.0038595011,
-0.0477879979,
-0.0098130619,
-0.0133430557,
0.0075819409,
0.057510905,
0.0620975755,
0.0940967649,
0.0283971876,
-0.0003538802,
-0.0421807095,
0.0073727393,
-0.0338414125,
0.0188207384,
0.0253950339,
0.0301410221,
-0.0143902879,
0.0187727679,
-0.0257745925,
-0.074856706,
-0.0347687565,
-0.0403072014,
0.0256980099,
0.0170334689,
-0.0358574316,
-0.0021836131,
0.0293101948,
-0.0558893271,
-0.0004132233,
0.0258596707,
-0.0035383569,
0.0132852187,
-0.0139681613,
0.0162188392,
0.0164768454,
0.0240447335,
0.0502276942,
-0.0437583886,
0.028539788,
0.0025409728,
0.0638514683,
0.0277521424,
-0.0465292744,
-0.0198279507,
-0.0329368673,
0.0180918369,
0.0179597717,
0.0086369934,
0.0632353798,
-0.0160306524,
-0.0336841606,
-0.0114999004,
0.0137666818,
0.0183180198,
-0.0406419337,
-0.0027536368,
-0.0528858453,
0.0237289611,
-0.0190239996,
-0.0013864626,
-0.0018335477,
0.0148002552,
0.0696377754,
-0.0680527315,
-0.003260552,
-0.022583751,
2.719e-7,
-0.0139786135,
-0.0235672481,
0.0316122249,
-0.0178751498,
0.0423198156,
0.0770352632,
-0.0252978206,
0.0753578246,
-0.0305777378,
-0.0822242796,
-0.049547825,
-0.0092524067,
0.0781852081,
0.0072869267,
-0.0097764852,
0.0706457123,
-0.0534917153,
0.0035604101,
-0.0321822837,
0.007951973,
0.022009749,
0.105702363,
-0.0019340231,
-0.0246962383,
0.0039962889,
-0.0484238937,
0.0222239941,
-0.017968677,
-0.0208992232,
-0.0608263426,
-0.0317630321,
0.0288409032,
-0.0019463311,
-0.0242338274,
-0.0367048495,
-0.0217930842,
0.0001007642,
0.0309732333,
-0.0030112604,
-0.0309168231,
-0.0506856553,
0.0072386544,
-0.0352953337,
-0.0228070393,
0.0791342705,
-0.0178047977,
-0.04553058,
-0.0676434636,
0.0049683172,
-0.0054698847,
0.0296320971,
-0.0437841639,
-0.0131352553,
0.0072067855,
0.0321329981,
-0.0121195717,
-0.0126829622,
-0.0694446638,
-0.0267180949,
-0.0244216658,
-0.0238768309,
0.0048087956,
-0.0300878715,
-0.003130486,
0.0565551482,
-0.0452055968,
-0.0454296507,
2.630670721e-34,
-0.0151737612,
-0.0557564497,
0.0292356554,
-0.0059308363,
0.0064639291,
-0.0075221723,
0.031038329,
-0.0019853872,
-0.0026256186,
-0.0520894304,
-0.0501191616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14522v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14522v2 | CliniDigest: A Case Study in Large Language Model Based Large-Scale Summarization of Clinical Trial Descriptions | 2023-07-26T21:49:14 | 2023-07-31T19:00:05 | Renee D. White, Tristan Peng, Pann Sripitak, Alexander Rosenberg Johansen, Michael Snyder | cs.CL | cs.CL | A clinical trial is a study that evaluates new biomedical interventions. To
design new trials, researchers draw inspiration from those current and
completed. In 2022, there were on average more than 100 clinical trials
submitted to ClinicalTrials.gov every day, with each trial having a mean of
approximately 1500 words [1]. This makes it nearly impossible to keep up to
date. To mitigate this issue, we have created a batch clinical trial summarizer
called CliniDigest using GPT-3.5. CliniDigest is, to our knowledge, the first
tool able to provide real-time, truthful, and comprehensive summaries of
clinical trials. CliniDigest can reduce up to 85 clinical trial descriptions
(approximately 10,500 words) into a concise 200-word summary with references
and limited hallucinations. We have tested CliniDigest on its ability to
summarize 457 trials divided across 27 medical subdomains. For each field,
CliniDigest generates summaries of $\mu=153,\ \sigma=69 $ words, each of which
utilizes $\mu=54\%,\ \sigma=30\% $ of the sources. A more comprehensive
evaluation is planned and outlined in this paper. | [
0.0307583939,
0.0519861318,
0.0074018706,
-0.0321948566,
-0.0147825144,
0.0129093127,
-0.0023202123,
0.0332774743,
-0.0305531863,
-0.0261672586,
-0.0034420425,
-0.0399026796,
0.0097018238,
0.0680674389,
0.0119646592,
-0.0857442021,
0.0252769087,
0.0197177026,
0.047644984,
0.0035075843,
0.0047728331,
0.0104289046,
-0.0211262386,
0.0384565182,
0.0468626544,
-0.0226981081,
0.0341628641,
-0.0135214143,
0.0253430288,
-0.0694821328,
-0.0180295054,
0.0334620327,
0.0043825163,
0.0233393833,
0.0000020963,
-0.0624846593,
-0.0328714214,
0.0579116493,
0.0016718722,
0.0490409099,
0.0854652524,
-0.0328840874,
0.0050351154,
0.0250690393,
0.0099982703,
-0.0536347255,
0.0453636944,
0.0400053859,
0.0466947109,
0.0318576545,
-0.0254181679,
-0.0059404825,
0.0222652145,
-0.041914843,
0.0151007157,
-0.0122152008,
0.0232577305,
0.0109779947,
0.0489375554,
-0.00231645,
0.0300380047,
0.0211677011,
-0.0258354228,
0.0088834958,
0.0072236317,
0.0487266742,
-0.0703404024,
-0.0079967994,
0.0230082162,
0.0379079059,
0.0286083687,
-0.0092354398,
0.0422577783,
0.0286630597,
-0.0124837002,
0.0208135284,
-0.0980780497,
0.0365970321,
-0.0214737393,
0.001912015,
-0.0098357145,
0.0121718422,
-0.0080496799,
-0.0056350315,
-0.026182143,
-0.0220898222,
0.0199766029,
-0.0206253212,
0.0108712334,
-0.0196579918,
-0.0203315224,
-0.0812052563,
0.0229559373,
0.0134691661,
-0.0282219704,
-0.0177316125,
0.0043756124,
-0.0737300813,
0.1111538038,
-0.0745103657,
-0.0044620964,
-0.0321705714,
0.0214028303,
0.0529431999,
0.0112019777,
0.0039143609,
0.0128864711,
0.010603454,
-0.037016768,
0.0346075483,
-0.0315997154,
-0.0155083425,
-0.0406835452,
0.0355919972,
-0.0466102846,
-0.0048498996,
-0.0939225182,
0.0092704277,
0.0005991776,
0.0246126875,
0.0045698439,
0.0090087298,
-0.0338660628,
0.0121710515,
0.0230213758,
0.0432778634,
-0.0070946119,
-0.0194551442,
-0.0219976064,
-0.0291349646,
-0.0012252604,
0.0034252566,
0.0074023581,
-0.0005228307,
0.0106105609,
0.0579318441,
0.017426705,
0.0085299509,
0.0012076255,
-0.0454268456,
-0.0454980992,
-0.0367982537,
-0.0196523853,
-0.072461918,
0.0424633622,
0.0158359837,
0.0085489079,
-0.0182035416,
-0.0084376261,
0.0134161031,
-0.0572669804,
0.0493443049,
-0.0656135157,
0.007528021,
0.0133181615,
0.0086242026,
0.0094327889,
0.0136760492,
0.0278579164,
0.0110775949,
0.0056969654,
-0.0196536984,
0.0038020574,
0.0027980518,
0.0141808856,
0.0037761254,
-0.0291486979,
0.005050547,
0.0183161683,
0.0221870355,
-0.0172628928,
0.0792032331,
-0.0192798749,
0.0471746959,
0.0769864172,
0.0564046875,
0.0091505405,
0.0226181224,
0.0048471345,
0.0028359648,
0.0313753635,
-0.0087793274,
-0.009400541,
0.0081976773,
-0.0039892299,
0.054230202,
0.0506742299,
0.0296929814,
-0.0245740693,
-0.0040296679,
-0.02231328,
-0.0205538943,
-0.0084134685,
0.0037028021,
0.0466633067,
-0.0323737189,
-0.0107705705,
0.0141683612,
0.0511923879,
-0.0370562114,
0.0179657433,
-0.0134914899,
-0.0232144427,
0.04023958,
0.0569735728,
-0.0386674032,
-0.0189230312,
-0.0361313187,
0.0109202173,
0.0396628417,
0.0265582856,
-0.0078828782,
-0.0326961726,
-0.0379496776,
-0.014402682,
-0.0041107908,
0.0192384496,
-0.0173800029,
-0.0054498906,
0.0112954751,
-0.0101679759,
-0.0531894192,
-0.0642709211,
0.0070326971,
-0.0201023221,
-0.006837354,
-0.0208517537,
-0.0728053004,
0.0307707377,
0.0285938419,
-0.0267751701,
0.0344639346,
0.0507457294,
-0.0256293211,
-0.0288597699,
0.0128333578,
0.0443995893,
0.0000346966,
0.0252185185,
-0.0533456989,
0.0198465697,
-0.020335529,
-0.0344350599,
-0.0366306342,
0.0010588077,
-0.0682949126,
0.0244149063,
0.0175510067,
0.0190394148,
0.0175242256,
-0.0009953048,
-0.0520795397,
0.0430542976,
0.0182339437,
-0.0088109449,
0.0622221977,
-0.0915117338,
0.0010238725,
-0.0339438766,
-0.0008390895,
0.0369060934,
0.0028598106,
-0.0167966243,
0.0053068604,
-0.0264378823,
-0.0207412746,
-0.0175750386,
-0.0897908956,
0.0227425545,
0.0488134064,
0.0305725615,
0.0501536466,
0.0339554064,
-0.0047315666,
0.0129385274,
-0.0342930593,
-0.0316422284,
0.044494804,
0.0208142456,
0.0286641493,
0.0396571346,
0.0006116921,
-0.0622759163,
-0.0098762047,
-0.0190370176,
0.0536083877,
0.0230096858,
-0.0663881898,
-0.03843325,
0.0346721001,
-0.0344471335,
-0.0137981316,
0.0209565368,
-0.0013897833,
-0.0074560968,
0.0035311901,
0.0462227128,
0.02214792,
0.0223243516,
-0.0068853023,
0.0683612451,
-0.01012043,
-0.0295609105,
-0.010906144,
-0.0243382901,
-0.0399485268,
0.021909399,
-0.0486797318,
0.0445535481,
0.053813573,
0.0497299619,
0.0077523906,
-0.0147002758,
-0.0101748928,
-0.0431153513,
0.0337625556,
-0.0410463847,
-0.0145546468,
-0.0273238271,
0.0058310884,
0.0022214658,
-0.0380027853,
0.0753255934,
-0.0339516215,
0.0308753885,
-0.0804886296,
0.0031797751,
-0.0493355691,
-0.0122274971,
0.0195716228,
0.0344798118,
0.016947316,
-0.0026810337,
0.0066170543,
0.0122652594,
0.0369079188,
-0.0412440002,
0.0938408151,
-0.0572870076,
0.0304772425,
-0.0345157571,
-0.0102489274,
0.0071995114,
-0.0130822333,
-0.0009234381,
-0.0158045739,
0.0618091896,
0.0003371437,
-0.0608090647,
0.0451679714,
0.0383841321,
0.0776090845,
-0.017308563,
-0.0132283196,
0.0184889138,
-0.010797346,
0.0500786826,
-0.0459675007,
0.0145634357,
-0.021546131,
0.0239031482,
0.0922801793,
0.0120429555,
0.0223680269,
-0.0098195961,
-0.0149199311,
-0.0306088906,
-0.0885730535,
-0.02365488,
0.0004622099,
0.0311902687,
-0.0311657265,
0.0268078782,
0.1212993041,
0.0349505767,
-0.0981140509,
-0.0137139605,
0.0133640068,
-0.0020189774,
-0.0190975685,
0.0055933688,
-0.0534199812,
-0.0002005947,
-0.0193127412,
0.0483091064,
-0.0083228163,
-0.0221584849,
-0.0198352747,
-0.0403839089,
0.0345210768,
0.0304021239,
-0.0594156012,
-0.0269777998,
-0.0610885024,
-0.0069640242,
-0.0290531646,
-0.0244371071,
0.0156432465,
-0.0419753306,
0.0233234446,
0.0084868353,
-0.0600886233,
-0.0693481714,
0.0050269943,
-0.0441583768,
0.0598034039,
0.0468605235,
0.0152357882,
-0.0279896427,
0.0176606905,
0.0397306681,
-0.0372032337,
-0.0438612029,
-0.0005340711,
0.1134169847,
0.0365043767,
0.0227640849,
-0.0406405814,
0.0486884452,
-0.0308699682,
-0.0239461213,
0.0200889595,
0.0736943334,
-0.0084541887,
-0.016666241,
-0.055259265,
0.0505639017,
-0.0105014667,
0.0505666174,
0.0276247896,
0.0013870025,
0.0094185779,
0.0072759395,
0.0090677617,
-0.0037613178,
-0.0069583785,
-0.0075407573,
-0.0642987341,
0.0093134595,
-0.0723877847,
-0.0313327461,
0.0812636316,
-0.0304045193,
0.0065994924,
0.0385815687,
0.0044385754,
-0.0200195815,
-0.0557138398,
0.0425823182,
0.0190218203,
0.0001976394,
-0.0285921544,
-0.0475427099,
0.0779284537,
0.0153088821,
0.004084575,
0.0744388029,
-0.0353055857,
-0.0240967087,
-0.037007615,
0.0121323476,
0.0389387496,
-0.0048774723,
0.0203690156,
0.0114147114,
0.0259098243,
0.002147668,
0.0227002818,
-0.0028690305,
-0.0592313558,
0.0072666015,
-0.0111254305,
-0.0324027129,
-0.0513221547,
0.0497705676,
-0.0290167686,
0.01459035,
-0.0104749454,
0.0068926322,
0.0571565293,
0.0625130832,
0.0356060788,
-0.0392618552,
0.0056046923,
-0.0406329557,
-0.0033131281,
-0.0609191619,
0.0027095655,
-0.0320157409,
0.0172784664,
0.0282621477,
-0.0037165133,
-0.0211647283,
0.0187722277,
-0.0744878128,
-0.0390245803,
-0.0472026728,
0.0116746873,
-0.0209291447,
-0.020273827,
0.0623339862,
-0.0357380882,
-0.0287498645,
-0.0093964804,
-0.0392155237,
-0.0026408439,
-0.0402482562,
0.0190940984,
-0.0057797926,
0.0173904132,
0.008122785,
0.0618338287,
-0.0574974455,
-0.0254248269,
-0.0384487696,
0.0045120148,
0.0292629376,
0.0082117599,
0.1047407612,
-0.0432263874,
0.0043186527,
-0.0664354786,
0.041723337,
0.0266163573,
0.0454937406,
-0.0085336147,
0.0114753749,
-0.0077032801,
-0.0417565294,
0.1129490733,
0.0138484268,
0.0157137662,
0.0055871359,
-0.0669312701,
-0.026842894,
-0.0333167054,
-0.0297425035,
0.0104499683,
-0.0481842123,
-0.0372453928,
-0.0726286247,
-0.011105963,
0.0337425061,
0.00026095,
0.0187983327,
-0.0244328249,
0.0205409471,
0.0107229287,
-0.0084134657,
-0.0164241996,
-0.0146033205,
0.0771275908,
-0.0020407843,
-0.0488661714,
-0.0099203596,
-5.741280815e-33,
0.0062403441,
-0.0261759572,
-0.0072639599,
-0.0059140064,
-0.031175172,
0.0259270538,
-0.0551174097,
-0.0216877349,
0.0455062389,
0.0368510485,
-0.0232534409,
0.0091989087,
0.0098908106,
0.0220532604,
0.0188420676,
0.0185267981,
0.03460012,
-0.0087482184,
-0.0077090692,
0.065286532,
-0.0178877637,
0.0094112167,
0.0463138744,
-0.056571573,
0.0326531865,
0.0278706495,
0.0049291984,
-0.0360600166,
0.0168049261,
0.0647356585,
-0.0157113057,
0.0204082131,
0.040130958,
-0.0196519587,
-0.0324173868,
-0.0485467762,
-0.0466530658,
0.0243322141,
0.0262108054,
-0.0610413738,
-0.0045625241,
-0.0002874394,
0.0312836878,
-0.0379955135,
0.0174333416,
-0.0217719413,
0.0284209438,
-0.0637290478,
-0.0475372635,
-0.039540723,
-0.0380714238,
0.0602748804,
-0.0158383679,
0.0288400464,
-0.0262785573,
0.0130717009,
-0.0308646727,
0.047316391,
0.0004189343,
0.0300931409,
0.0663034543,
0.030815579,
0.0135257998,
-0.05518407,
-0.0047112075,
0.0382719859,
-0.0193292927,
0.0047543785,
0.0018838217,
0.0262713265,
-0.0619327053,
-0.010321538,
0.0473864153,
0.0353995487,
0.0371043831,
0.0100904908,
-0.0700050965,
0.0679639354,
-0.0757373124,
0.0161539353,
0.0321761072,
-0.0215354227,
0.0048365998,
-0.0239173025,
-0.0136142038,
-0.0148906866,
-0.0300581958,
-0.0204242039,
0.0172248147,
-0.0038797469,
-0.0238555949,
-0.0051960605,
0.0132372295,
-0.0055868807,
0.0064826966,
-0.0092684152,
0.0260027014,
0.0422613584,
-0.025324082,
-0.0312512927,
-0.0166051835,
0.0032997867,
0.0153998556,
0.0110825216,
0.0158081334,
0.0175865088,
0.0152878547,
-0.0295506231,
-0.0422749855,
0.0175366309,
0.0085493494,
0.0074193412,
-0.0310148764,
0.0070532085,
0.0033736306,
-0.0020808643,
0.0403248556,
0.041749768,
0.0273116101,
-0.0242311247,
-0.0236156806,
-0.0103540849,
0.0226665679,
0.0025973611,
-0.0038291563,
0.0276695099,
-0.0183740463,
0.0249311272,
0.0621148162,
-0.0397828892,
-0.0083034169,
-0.047469262,
2.8e-7,
0.0898370072,
0.0516426675,
0.0172608867,
-0.001151938,
0.0343426056,
-0.0252860878,
-0.0045373109,
0.0129858758,
0.0078606242,
0.0268223584,
0.0419992507,
-0.0063106297,
0.0118765319,
0.0445955507,
-0.0645574629,
-0.0600539707,
-0.0659993738,
-0.0745086372,
-0.05797242,
-0.0095237456,
0.0389297418,
0.0545171835,
-0.0413409993,
-0.0028780093,
0.0122699179,
-0.056090381,
0.0175901521,
-0.0374091379,
-0.0336982347,
0.0668659061,
0.0152284047,
-0.0090637403,
0.0027502587,
0.0241172481,
-0.0358987525,
-0.0391892418,
-0.0034136013,
0.0923159719,
-0.0319546908,
0.0441151597,
0.0529370904,
-0.049265787,
0.0408653989,
-0.0270919465,
0.0137037234,
-0.0676795989,
-0.0223122668,
-0.0203800704,
-0.0334917307,
-0.0397112593,
0.06051296,
-0.0324837752,
-0.0208399314,
0.0388612375,
-0.0222509261,
0.0308629628,
-0.0368868634,
-0.0358882174,
0.0025117891,
0.06271635,
-0.0342701264,
-0.0551948287,
0.0254126899,
-0.0500638001,
-0.0065388144,
-0.0715417266,
0.0190914385,
3.010480522e-34,
0.0845649615,
-0.0093245246,
0.0020573284,
-0.0214957613,
0.0469786115,
-0.0269215889,
-0.010966979,
0.0102267396,
0.0063611493,
-0.0874723047,
-0.0118521852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14511v1 | Words That Stick: Predicting Decision Making and Synonym Engagement Using Cognitive Biases and Computational Linguistics | 2023-07-26T21:20:03 | 2023-07-26T21:20:03 | Nimrod Dvir, Elaine Friedman, Suraj Commuri, Fan Yang, Jennifer Romano | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, 03B65, H.5; I.7 | This research draws upon cognitive psychology and information systems studies
to anticipate user engagement and decision-making on digital platforms. By
employing natural language processing (NLP) techniques and insights from
cognitive bias research, we delve into user interactions with synonyms within
digital content. Our methodology synthesizes four cognitive
biasesRepresentativeness, Ease-of-use, Affect, and Distributioninto the READ
model. Through a comprehensive user survey, we assess the model's ability to
predict user engagement, discovering that synonyms that accurately represent
core ideas, are easy to understand, elicit emotional responses, and are
commonly encountered, promote greater user engagement. Crucially, our work
offers a fresh lens on human-computer interaction, digital behaviors, and
decision-making processes. Our results highlight the promise of cognitive
biases as potent indicators of user engagement, underscoring their significance
in designing effective digital content across fields like education and
marketing. | [
0.0566066578,
0.0137906745,
-0.0409648381,
-0.0237596203,
-0.0068768538,
-0.0023992718,
-0.0095213763,
-0.0192183219,
0.0597104058,
-0.0524523817,
-0.0289366078,
0.0242757741,
0.0468901582,
0.0301040486,
-0.0300681256,
-0.0330679826,
0.0266600531,
0.0443354957,
0.0267519224,
0.0229313895,
0.0184442606,
0.0545691773,
-0.0164096076,
0.0188694634,
-0.0033784087,
-0.0172391906,
0.0431863517,
0.0236573294,
-0.0033042391,
-0.0428230725,
0.0301938057,
0.05153374,
-0.0082758451,
0.0315519907,
0.0000021363,
-0.0715472251,
-0.0194917191,
-0.0403746739,
-0.0358533897,
0.0138060478,
0.111359328,
0.0481087081,
0.0040276097,
-0.0116069596,
-0.0281586722,
0.0612468831,
0.0693289787,
0.006729167,
0.0027375075,
-0.0190349184,
-0.0267682225,
-0.015737744,
-0.0594666637,
0.0188746955,
0.0392646529,
-0.0185069367,
-0.0120701808,
0.0034779452,
-0.0123591665,
-0.0621848144,
-0.0380903818,
0.0071580904,
-0.0272841193,
0.0101401228,
0.0471927598,
0.0475960374,
0.0582247488,
-0.0510562286,
0.0021404517,
0.0189128872,
0.0198324732,
0.0192259662,
-0.0009537775,
-0.0298888497,
0.0044209627,
0.0408908539,
-0.0329019204,
-0.0392603055,
-0.0011241328,
0.0032384854,
-0.0057565882,
0.0465889126,
0.0228223465,
0.0577573478,
0.0110135097,
0.0470222086,
0.0103186239,
-0.023912333,
0.0540276207,
0.0251014549,
0.0707440525,
-0.0311640222,
-0.0060850792,
-0.0485761985,
-0.0126248728,
0.0475836471,
-0.0306828711,
0.0121288151,
0.025158437,
-0.0691779256,
0.0107780723,
0.0306945015,
0.0305373743,
0.0487244129,
-0.0056933532,
-0.0261772648,
0.0204528905,
-0.0142129567,
0.0135447215,
0.0280196741,
-0.0287500545,
0.0112652127,
0.0211352929,
0.0441461392,
0.0160399172,
-0.0760038868,
-0.0730073601,
-0.0030892198,
-0.0285428725,
0.0373275168,
-0.0212026574,
0.0141235152,
-0.0111190621,
-0.014813412,
-0.0785916001,
0.0163667519,
-0.0672754571,
0.0156966913,
-0.027307542,
-0.045609083,
0.0473695807,
-0.0137970997,
0.0172496531,
-0.0393484682,
0.0260232221,
-0.0030198474,
0.0101417191,
-0.0416603871,
-0.0533228293,
-0.0806153566,
0.0048148218,
0.0070523708,
-0.0512148701,
-0.0431124754,
0.0069381404,
0.0587534979,
0.0228496902,
-0.0672921091,
-0.0125026703,
0.0426233932,
-0.0383168571,
0.0716185272,
-0.0406839885,
-0.0249671508,
0.0372473709,
0.0224949829,
0.002548181,
0.0264041405,
0.0043612062,
0.0439033769,
0.0739747584,
0.0017259923,
-0.0135052204,
-0.0101440521,
-0.0570949838,
-0.0653589666,
-0.0174137875,
-0.022599427,
-0.0253339875,
-0.0020378376,
0.013310099,
0.0341770835,
-0.028675044,
0.0345625393,
0.0754119754,
0.0694074631,
0.0102358451,
0.0165510532,
-0.0211162232,
0.0309828501,
-0.014203256,
-0.0058428748,
0.0080563398,
0.0280097984,
0.0397789888,
0.0163874626,
0.0612254739,
0.0166599527,
-0.0074587883,
-0.0659310371,
-0.0077586351,
-0.0068810126,
0.0709415376,
-0.0093543231,
0.0002531798,
-0.0334379412,
-0.0185504407,
0.0044494215,
0.0060172463,
-0.0314635858,
0.0304928254,
-0.0067023528,
0.0211279038,
0.1255307645,
0.0243879855,
-0.0057727345,
-0.0025914141,
-0.0150770918,
0.0104796141,
0.044460278,
0.0268415529,
0.0243933853,
-0.052433107,
-0.0495437533,
-0.0056032464,
-0.0231695808,
-0.0023833916,
0.0168371666,
0.0141546791,
0.040448945,
-0.0027759802,
-0.0142661976,
-0.0343755111,
0.0117007187,
0.0163458101,
-0.0290019363,
-0.0626294762,
0.0460667014,
0.0121260276,
0.0372731201,
0.0172747225,
-0.0030584752,
-0.0219154656,
0.0447641462,
-0.0338075571,
0.0249830429,
0.0432609804,
0.0777502581,
0.0285576768,
-0.0567354225,
-0.023079643,
-0.0335812382,
0.020392824,
0.0109231025,
0.0262990613,
-0.0561708063,
0.0792838559,
-0.0058180182,
-0.0227591507,
-0.0140719265,
0.0040037022,
-0.0060978313,
0.0382799692,
-0.0111231543,
0.0364583917,
0.0331562422,
-0.0278838165,
0.0177018121,
0.0427484326,
-0.0428715497,
-0.0136262141,
-0.0268569887,
0.012040806,
0.0491752625,
-0.0629777387,
-0.0841396749,
-0.0085596386,
-0.0673982576,
-0.0348848887,
0.0427804738,
0.0092095016,
0.0071436316,
0.0091554197,
-0.0364322364,
0.0013087727,
0.0128108552,
-0.0222575106,
-0.0335306525,
0.0368094631,
0.0356556028,
-0.0243001357,
0.0023789539,
-0.0263812076,
-0.0012356035,
-0.0051340316,
0.0270066243,
0.071585983,
-0.0491558388,
0.0047253827,
-0.0449038148,
-0.0537398979,
-0.0696411952,
-0.0094590029,
0.0038442446,
0.0268236529,
0.0337373614,
0.0255053956,
0.0335524529,
0.0364258252,
0.0257574674,
-0.0006413094,
-0.0357799456,
-0.0604686737,
-0.0208376702,
-0.0267536975,
-0.0422450677,
0.0090774801,
-0.0449188836,
0.0302872807,
0.0230088774,
0.0112811085,
0.0086769313,
-0.0056539308,
0.0380056091,
-0.0400363021,
-0.0176871885,
-0.027601514,
-0.0187878013,
-0.024084283,
0.0346275009,
0.0172157753,
-0.0318474099,
0.0585149974,
0.0445764735,
0.0316497497,
-0.0507169999,
0.0031270825,
-0.0102223791,
0.0212064534,
-0.0650444031,
0.038040746,
-0.0016272536,
-0.0667427108,
-0.0204930175,
-0.0556803346,
0.0449140184,
-0.0466823652,
0.023906406,
-0.0048198635,
-0.0203379616,
0.0492754765,
0.0170990061,
-0.0195964854,
-0.0117497761,
-0.0790445283,
-0.056420628,
0.0774406716,
-0.0140900612,
-0.0174957626,
-0.0410472192,
0.0073498697,
-0.021788111,
0.0312015265,
-0.0459219627,
0.0065768603,
-0.0178034715,
0.0546955019,
0.0142885037,
0.0110474164,
-0.0096920403,
-0.0181799624,
0.0634807721,
-0.0281386003,
-0.0386791751,
0.0008000189,
-0.0159714725,
0.0428413451,
-0.0833451375,
0.002567183,
0.0309879016,
-0.0157481004,
-0.0154222827,
0.0607080311,
0.0943881869,
0.0362514667,
-0.036292959,
-0.0202859435,
-0.0474687405,
-0.0162379779,
0.0283846036,
-0.0031712197,
-0.0821592733,
-0.0269548669,
-0.0114287408,
-0.0039570658,
-0.0046938024,
0.0063531506,
-0.0098395143,
-0.0868174434,
-0.0195197575,
-0.0076191234,
0.0857067704,
0.025894912,
-0.0233051367,
0.0031057959,
0.0065785614,
-0.0051604914,
-0.0337212086,
-0.046055533,
0.0146506103,
-0.0088245375,
-0.013178586,
-0.0128778452,
0.0177232139,
-0.024617834,
0.0310773291,
0.0152855106,
0.0620257482,
-0.0334972367,
-0.0655743852,
0.0322975777,
-0.0165290087,
-0.010219615,
-0.0047800918,
0.0387905762,
-0.0422825254,
0.0455853306,
-0.0371651128,
0.0217079017,
0.0236297604,
-0.0456207544,
-0.0099288058,
0.017016124,
0.047638163,
-0.0328139924,
-0.0548491441,
0.0393006094,
0.0217161067,
0.0594708063,
0.0052213361,
-0.0645285621,
0.0138170961,
-0.0184572395,
0.0437166803,
0.0355649889,
-0.0457525887,
-0.0368954167,
-0.0335189812,
-0.0236141291,
-0.046437148,
-0.0358609222,
0.020279089,
0.0094197122,
0.0390343405,
0.0193736833,
-0.0060155122,
-0.0129964659,
-0.0621792488,
0.0341178924,
0.0168206301,
0.036444556,
-0.055789724,
0.0075564948,
-0.0218483824,
-0.0201845728,
-0.0184912551,
0.0259651486,
0.0324981548,
-0.0231922567,
-0.0073636766,
0.0078460658,
0.0306089148,
-0.0250275154,
-0.0065726009,
-0.0377598479,
-0.0126696751,
0.041046977,
-0.0159335509,
-0.0448644757,
0.0167690311,
0.0325792618,
0.0020692588,
-0.0235065464,
0.0104955267,
-0.0129251471,
0.0063074594,
-0.007318269,
0.0067652888,
-0.0229277983,
0.0204767399,
-0.0032651231,
0.0254680943,
-0.0728798211,
0.039560955,
-0.0159984063,
-0.043967627,
0.0341744423,
-0.039345637,
0.031359002,
-0.0504273549,
0.008370216,
0.0261050481,
-0.0491393097,
0.0233622137,
-0.0331009664,
-0.00181779,
0.0158011001,
-0.0108942464,
-0.0267320853,
0.0202270616,
-0.0156751126,
-0.0145184631,
-0.0236820336,
0.0169472471,
0.0139086824,
0.024130309,
0.0079060234,
0.0519710518,
0.0200097337,
-0.0092315767,
-0.0290380307,
0.0202018134,
0.0205961522,
-0.0221026596,
0.0206482057,
-0.0166415069,
-0.0007638305,
-0.0449852608,
-0.0245158188,
-0.0399247706,
-0.0052323081,
0.0083869575,
0.0111678028,
-0.0216668155,
-0.0371592492,
-0.0140755046,
0.016162904,
-0.0258021131,
-0.0198171865,
0.0289823823,
-0.0927716568,
-0.0223365817,
-0.0273718126,
-0.077307649,
-0.0144068804,
-0.0052819024,
0.0015992916,
0.0767240003,
-0.017043449,
-0.0014879482,
-0.1152907386,
-0.0546262786,
0.0608230382,
-0.0064079436,
0.0171950124,
-0.0226307902,
0.053846363,
0.0436546206,
0.0106038442,
0.0036464122,
-0.0213611647,
0.0426633321,
-0.081224069,
-0.0166226402,
-0.0355578884,
-5.990086684e-33,
0.0287839361,
-0.0393999182,
-0.0067837448,
0.0143170608,
-0.0464307033,
0.0015794327,
-0.0132746343,
0.0489397645,
0.0187788643,
0.0139494538,
-0.0217453912,
-0.0107860146,
0.00903094,
-0.0146794477,
0.0446779691,
-0.0255173203,
0.0303854402,
0.0469958819,
-0.0287173893,
-0.0383657739,
-0.0013676727,
-0.007978755,
0.0068589109,
-0.04454799,
0.0475877747,
0.0577033311,
0.0073804948,
-0.0587754995,
0.0542762987,
0.0457022898,
-0.0042089061,
0.0368738957,
0.0177137963,
-0.0166423097,
0.014206727,
0.0844241306,
-0.0269420091,
-0.0304026064,
0.0768766403,
0.0120692551,
0.0216805767,
0.0040374105,
0.040570423,
-0.0168521013,
-0.0783541277,
0.0283818264,
0.0668211728,
-0.0152491285,
-0.0085461847,
0.0197401475,
-0.0829158351,
0.0030350555,
-0.018657146,
0.0308669079,
0.0155362478,
0.0075805234,
0.0262356848,
0.040347632,
-0.1177169532,
0.0523385666,
-0.0437633991,
0.0252740029,
0.0518376604,
-0.0065494943,
0.0107027125,
0.0882957801,
-0.0169494487,
0.0251103155,
-0.0213119723,
0.0423973016,
0.0302794576,
0.0339994952,
0.0213698093,
0.0687051713,
0.0416787378,
-0.0780189559,
0.0409670062,
0.0463564619,
0.0479436591,
0.0127582625,
0.0530292541,
0.0228358395,
-0.0749784112,
-0.0185539518,
-0.0035844538,
0.0148354359,
-0.0407438204,
-0.0578422062,
0.0218148474,
-0.0343382359,
-0.0503778085,
-0.001531505,
-0.0276867859,
-0.0210125335,
-0.0718601942,
-0.0258310903,
0.0107146427,
0.028039109,
-0.0113043105,
-0.0129131339,
0.0065066875,
0.0047496366,
-0.0783837438,
0.0361769423,
0.0215576664,
-0.0088591427,
-0.0529606678,
0.0041766544,
-0.0398369581,
-0.0263739731,
0.021326296,
-0.0199184921,
-0.0092458064,
-0.0542933755,
0.05787047,
0.0327219702,
-0.0238195881,
-0.0216419846,
0.0218864381,
0.0431938693,
0.0060541737,
-0.0447288677,
-0.0263795257,
0.0249641556,
0.0012404778,
-0.0072810301,
-0.0420192368,
-0.0087412558,
0.0109159043,
-0.0359062254,
-0.0246429686,
-0.0231245756,
2.934e-7,
0.012582561,
0.0646380633,
-0.0273413118,
0.0096170949,
0.0109930374,
0.0200673901,
0.0335657597,
-0.0002578957,
0.039419584,
-0.0422616936,
0.0215036925,
-0.0262433887,
0.0156616773,
0.0133375395,
-0.0988845229,
0.0014425919,
0.0023023007,
0.0684744567,
-0.0497455969,
0.0317947008,
0.0506034754,
-0.0177447218,
0.0585582927,
-0.0012335624,
-0.0269961879,
0.0154887857,
-0.01777073,
-0.0478840917,
0.0487231128,
0.0226982422,
0.0138226654,
0.0056899944,
0.0116983429,
0.0242884643,
-0.0329997726,
0.0101320986,
0.0768615901,
0.0087624351,
0.0434125103,
0.0184464846,
-0.0184368547,
-0.0062902821,
0.0032584355,
-0.0642807111,
0.0416776091,
-0.0555681959,
-0.0190251507,
-0.0248655751,
-0.054252848,
-0.0136412494,
0.0596844479,
-0.0281701703,
-0.0618352257,
-0.0166100636,
0.0266424008,
-0.0018624288,
-0.034671858,
-0.0679749399,
0.0326157138,
0.0075481604,
-0.0275880843,
-0.0224875547,
-0.0378245525,
0.0527313948,
0.0267680865,
-0.0187845509,
0.0198484641,
1.825016739e-34,
0.0070044538,
-0.0058531174,
0.0476193801,
-0.0040416438,
0.0537009463,
0.0388634019,
0.0172768924,
0.0078573991,
0.0657268465,
-0.0203972925,
0.0201396514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14500v1 | A Predictive Model of Digital Information Engagement: Forecasting User Engagement With English Words by Incorporating Cognitive Biases, Computational Linguistics and Natural Language Processing | 2023-07-26T20:58:47 | 2023-07-26T20:58:47 | Nimrod Dvir, Elaine Friedman, Suraj Commuri, Fan yang, Jennifer Romano | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68U15, H.5; H.5.1; H.5.2; D.3.2 | This study introduces and empirically tests a novel predictive model for
digital information engagement (IE) - the READ model, an acronym for the four
pivotal attributes of engaging information: Representativeness, Ease-of-use,
Affect, and Distribution. Conceptualized within the theoretical framework of
Cumulative Prospect Theory, the model integrates key cognitive biases with
computational linguistics and natural language processing to develop a
multidimensional perspective on information engagement. A rigorous testing
protocol was implemented, involving 50 randomly selected pairs of synonymous
words (100 words in total) from the WordNet database. These words' engagement
levels were evaluated through a large-scale online survey (n = 80,500) to
derive empirical IE metrics. The READ attributes for each word were then
computed and their predictive efficacy examined. The findings affirm the READ
model's robustness, accurately predicting a word's IE level and distinguishing
the more engaging word from a pair of synonyms with an 84% accuracy rate. The
READ model's potential extends across various domains, including business,
education, government, and healthcare, where it could enhance content
engagement and inform AI language model development and generative text work.
Future research should address the model's scalability and adaptability across
different domains and languages, thereby broadening its applicability and
efficacy. | [
0.0514043681,
0.0145071289,
-0.036519438,
-0.0402071141,
-0.0324447714,
0.0001617084,
-0.0222763307,
-0.0285322703,
0.0586496443,
-0.0139699336,
-0.026500348,
-0.0012888233,
0.0480268411,
0.058500085,
-0.0196318328,
-0.0221922938,
0.0250595193,
0.0470394343,
0.009640106,
0.0251642447,
0.024698833,
0.0466311127,
-0.0199734643,
-0.0025870055,
0.003891933,
-0.0053060655,
0.0056130299,
0.0189518239,
0.0182885733,
-0.0476133376,
0.0281517617,
0.0248387568,
0.013709438,
0.0423607863,
0.0000021893,
-0.0630069897,
-0.0243424326,
-0.004436302,
-0.0414636992,
-0.0029093139,
0.1056837142,
0.0454164259,
-0.0069815125,
0.0031611701,
-0.0211308803,
0.0902023837,
0.0688624904,
0.0113403685,
-0.0056367717,
-0.0025511798,
-0.028972026,
0.0005725641,
0.0292495918,
0.0257928669,
0.0365546197,
-0.003057041,
-0.0015208635,
0.0278894156,
-0.0149550354,
-0.0500281192,
-0.0167596024,
0.0134857446,
-0.0143519882,
0.005234716,
0.0445629135,
0.0574549511,
0.0554741994,
-0.0461500101,
-0.0017328708,
0.0093431454,
0.0360624343,
0.0063380473,
-0.0283632968,
-0.0374952406,
0.0071196482,
0.0087457336,
-0.0493498519,
-0.0516032502,
0.0226392169,
0.0359826051,
0.0415836163,
0.0483426638,
0.0300725475,
0.0659195557,
0.0155096082,
0.0556428581,
0.0077104582,
-0.0367801189,
0.0194371641,
0.0266376995,
0.0645679086,
-0.0130447391,
-0.0039029219,
-0.0254156943,
-0.0170395691,
0.0631252825,
-0.0145223513,
-0.0283489972,
0.0247220099,
-0.0603981353,
0.0158485528,
0.0251422357,
0.027002573,
0.0511667095,
0.0235625058,
-0.0270955432,
0.0233316515,
-0.0444288477,
0.0059634396,
0.033999227,
-0.0357807577,
-0.005884598,
0.0328983068,
0.0409629829,
0.0220476836,
-0.100947246,
-0.0353993252,
0.0142226536,
-0.0026594854,
0.0215957686,
0.0110894386,
0.0079110861,
-0.048060488,
-0.0109900897,
-0.0545570403,
0.0479800552,
-0.0539967753,
0.0120189935,
-0.0350352712,
-0.0640240759,
0.0541412644,
-0.0259476807,
0.015576683,
-0.0532228425,
0.0106442189,
-0.0158946719,
0.0098439204,
-0.069676809,
-0.0600847974,
-0.0799651816,
0.0164925288,
-0.0271593761,
-0.0156241888,
-0.0378927439,
0.008704016,
0.0160592478,
0.0106406352,
-0.0459320322,
-0.0081216153,
0.0262325797,
-0.0213972591,
0.060458675,
-0.0500002354,
-0.00957515,
0.0316796601,
0.017776709,
0.0542439222,
0.0481233336,
0.0276655536,
0.0320435092,
0.0795053393,
0.0043479661,
-0.027764814,
-0.0060635475,
-0.0475314148,
-0.0423650928,
0.0309312325,
-0.0116586536,
-0.0228109602,
0.0028900176,
0.0014441335,
0.0196653362,
-0.0172996931,
0.0557641834,
0.0815347359,
0.0379806422,
0.0233444497,
0.0056113387,
-0.0109244017,
0.0505215898,
-0.0108114332,
-0.0115300342,
0.0327773802,
0.0370137505,
0.0420466885,
0.0270565059,
0.0673666671,
0.0190483779,
-0.0138085848,
-0.0882689357,
0.0197786167,
-0.0135537637,
0.0772975907,
-0.0070573897,
0.0451630466,
-0.0452119187,
-0.0539090522,
-0.0387042537,
0.0229086988,
-0.0165815763,
0.0580227971,
0.0026191417,
0.0322459675,
0.1238256916,
0.0547764078,
-0.0188173205,
0.0014189328,
-0.0322843343,
0.0229909886,
0.0436107144,
0.0155112995,
-0.0002256254,
-0.0299284663,
-0.0253635831,
-0.0241432954,
-0.0231468398,
-0.0221349411,
0.0288717002,
0.0276739541,
0.0178093482,
-0.0165512245,
0.0009551817,
-0.0323978774,
0.0135439588,
-0.0333685204,
-0.0115133543,
-0.0424200743,
0.0398798138,
0.0372418799,
0.0612660311,
0.0141421407,
0.007052816,
0.0136366794,
0.0555783957,
-0.0192461312,
0.0169651061,
0.0595330857,
0.0823206156,
0.0125228567,
-0.0370518677,
0.0220088493,
-0.034629751,
0.0297021475,
-0.0056943139,
0.0079237875,
-0.029048061,
0.0743313655,
-0.0392586738,
-0.0141991004,
-0.0319656879,
0.0156862233,
-0.0218944829,
0.0445049144,
-0.0090759834,
0.0154583771,
0.0369301252,
-0.0422713757,
-0.0105039123,
0.0052620131,
-0.0519368462,
-0.011912317,
-0.033642929,
0.0140400995,
0.0463081785,
-0.0726162791,
-0.0855715945,
-0.013264114,
-0.0654580966,
-0.0353708714,
0.0351427868,
0.0357909128,
0.0190504584,
0.0230940208,
-0.0215460341,
0.0263294671,
0.0281726941,
-0.0349035189,
-0.0215989519,
0.0344825871,
0.0095337294,
-0.0135700935,
0.0202632472,
-0.0115119955,
0.0140713295,
-0.0107541624,
-0.000201838,
0.086798951,
-0.0580773912,
0.0075002965,
-0.0368668027,
-0.0283044819,
-0.0655997694,
-0.0371933915,
-0.0020115266,
-0.0058573247,
0.0269397441,
0.0107921464,
-0.0042315829,
0.0288309902,
0.0049070562,
0.0026128639,
-0.0267170817,
-0.0477042161,
-0.0053297719,
-0.0382723212,
-0.0168467052,
-0.0202153325,
-0.0678807572,
0.0298336055,
0.0013466482,
0.0219332892,
0.0231479798,
-0.0175276957,
-0.0013082639,
-0.0482146181,
-0.0330178216,
-0.0345566496,
-0.0253489874,
-0.0267200693,
0.0323543809,
-0.0082553616,
-0.0415609069,
0.0264544897,
0.028066583,
0.0428318456,
-0.0533979312,
0.0271292701,
0.0082015432,
0.0095435567,
-0.0345547199,
0.0275635216,
0.0196147729,
-0.0553244613,
0.0055890395,
-0.0279288031,
0.0098092724,
-0.0467312075,
0.0176970288,
0.0130311223,
-0.0389770046,
0.0636183247,
0.0078330077,
-0.0277713891,
-0.0009093524,
-0.0511725172,
-0.0374395624,
0.0577724092,
-0.0266134869,
-0.0302202329,
-0.024970483,
0.0011482657,
-0.0305508748,
0.0085281264,
-0.0678194761,
0.0222005751,
0.0065245428,
0.0674459934,
0.0101041645,
-0.0052154041,
0.0097981878,
-0.0087442528,
0.0360091142,
-0.0486764349,
-0.0290061645,
0.0018712059,
-0.0155167067,
0.0327840187,
-0.0655587837,
0.0012583444,
0.0411760472,
-0.0231798701,
-0.0060244938,
0.0227069724,
0.1070920974,
0.0239577126,
-0.0302303527,
-0.0175617039,
-0.0503065959,
-0.0266615637,
0.0139053762,
0.0139130019,
-0.0569388866,
0.0176627766,
0.0005770118,
-0.0081328908,
-0.0351349562,
0.0266002342,
-0.0299842879,
-0.0759855136,
0.0296891872,
-0.0103191994,
0.0867055133,
0.00955112,
-0.0459332056,
0.0098370174,
0.0058772839,
-0.0310909804,
-0.0156702418,
-0.0306605902,
-0.0082579264,
-0.0091565708,
-0.0100079104,
-0.0115146348,
0.0142516298,
-0.0046852971,
0.0327733345,
0.0646524355,
0.0707317814,
-0.057208579,
-0.0048799701,
-0.0290605463,
-0.0309503116,
-0.0070327171,
0.0055521457,
0.0635702461,
-0.0264170598,
0.0582272857,
-0.0490432419,
0.0436707735,
0.0178738087,
-0.0546887368,
-0.0177967716,
0.0436982848,
0.0159137715,
-0.0232512672,
-0.0501058027,
0.0086180633,
0.0316057317,
0.0503695905,
-0.0006767834,
-0.0377990417,
0.0353633985,
0.0027662504,
0.0520512387,
0.0107776653,
-0.0287715886,
-0.0289356224,
-0.0140291518,
-0.017628653,
-0.0495289192,
-0.0476611666,
-0.0048648436,
0.0307326987,
0.0215303041,
0.0574519634,
-0.0070457715,
-0.035807129,
-0.0602056198,
0.0018925336,
0.0109556625,
0.0436726399,
-0.0618679486,
-0.0245529637,
-0.0223746598,
-0.0761172995,
-0.0289584678,
-0.0270722322,
-0.0132891182,
-0.0114671299,
-0.0151179023,
-0.0119971279,
0.0256439857,
0.000552175,
-0.0271074679,
-0.0080800289,
0.029424632,
0.0015354757,
0.0028855423,
-0.0391152464,
0.0145153394,
0.0334782749,
-0.0027331926,
-0.0347827896,
0.0135671329,
-0.015960617,
0.0307664461,
-0.0147082619,
0.0132331252,
-0.0661125258,
0.011483009,
0.0203196853,
0.0309054628,
-0.0578924306,
-0.003938125,
-0.0427562334,
-0.0599295609,
0.0259298328,
-0.0286478624,
0.028492935,
-0.0457568951,
0.0157535728,
0.0008800808,
-0.0568081215,
0.0207631961,
-0.0603914522,
-0.0223931167,
-0.0622686632,
-0.0142472964,
-0.016731292,
0.0173999518,
-0.0192141104,
-0.0185345151,
-0.0083563849,
-0.0000778533,
0.002245869,
0.0187102593,
0.0120919803,
0.0628520697,
-0.0114002321,
-0.0073416494,
-0.0255836751,
0.02948061,
0.0031802959,
0.0326357707,
-0.0304806344,
0.0272971112,
0.0001105662,
-0.0220387913,
-0.009273407,
-0.0517142192,
-0.0023308755,
-0.0000386299,
0.0087167211,
-0.0182866119,
-0.0542477109,
0.021051839,
0.0233858023,
-0.0076934099,
-0.007918587,
0.0230154525,
-0.0927274525,
0.0062416615,
-0.0033692059,
-0.0458936915,
-0.0320334099,
-0.0296398979,
-0.0028615377,
0.097789064,
-0.0474517532,
0.0170542188,
-0.0390506685,
-0.0511428788,
0.0608483851,
-0.0116743948,
0.0010988071,
-0.0302370656,
0.0450414605,
0.0452779755,
-0.0162397958,
0.0014248514,
-0.0509310178,
0.0269003473,
-0.0670293197,
-0.026529273,
-0.0325753316,
-6.285003891e-33,
0.0462876186,
-0.0250299647,
0.0189375598,
0.0247852933,
-0.0633217618,
0.0203192756,
-0.0162778515,
0.0185370948,
0.0094768768,
0.0126283644,
-0.0145650618,
-0.0180698223,
0.0112637598,
-0.0221275724,
0.0208960809,
-0.0267710965,
0.0336393043,
0.0380415022,
-0.0154757211,
-0.0153316744,
-0.0159255415,
0.0036144834,
0.0218805932,
-0.0451795347,
0.0747004226,
0.0550821908,
-0.0346455723,
-0.0420585051,
0.0507723093,
0.0567428134,
-0.0024620697,
0.039995186,
0.0454450622,
-0.0325884707,
0.0139096593,
0.0873367637,
-0.0463768169,
-0.0242543835,
0.0576070584,
0.0170380231,
0.0212972946,
-0.0298659839,
0.0156348702,
-0.0298366304,
-0.0688074827,
0.0061276671,
0.0625406653,
-0.0078596314,
-0.0184078459,
-0.0132655296,
-0.1031113192,
0.0190454852,
-0.0210254136,
0.0052858479,
0.0017615907,
0.0606530011,
0.0465996973,
0.0634672791,
-0.1079974025,
0.0532000437,
-0.0325431712,
0.0276282988,
0.050104741,
-0.0289154816,
0.0411754996,
0.0806207433,
0.0097662695,
0.0023687973,
-0.0010642309,
0.0400007181,
0.0300452635,
0.0064467508,
0.0010065499,
0.0538130924,
0.0200679041,
-0.063547954,
0.0201933663,
0.0517844409,
0.0476617217,
0.0325822718,
0.0720484108,
0.0200150348,
-0.0899480954,
-0.0208570417,
-0.0037738932,
-0.0131823821,
-0.0426878817,
-0.0595007502,
0.0166440159,
-0.01983767,
-0.0297577456,
0.0041897227,
-0.0158896483,
-0.0355742536,
-0.0372891389,
0.0351755284,
-0.0000082836,
0.0616639331,
-0.0159233343,
0.003319443,
0.0032506431,
-0.0052207299,
-0.069034934,
0.0215241276,
0.0016924653,
-0.0067455322,
-0.0529501364,
0.0244101025,
-0.0152439196,
-0.0348373465,
0.0002776693,
-0.0195411723,
0.0327764601,
-0.020314265,
0.049306307,
0.0274071284,
-0.0219576191,
0.0054452028,
0.0367363803,
0.0260846447,
0.0022904198,
-0.0553221777,
-0.0301306751,
0.0101264967,
-0.0077071316,
-0.0009541617,
-0.0259124283,
-0.0337607786,
0.009072721,
-0.0325135142,
-0.0372259021,
0.0133261662,
3.013e-7,
0.0336440504,
0.0486005917,
-0.0353540704,
0.0335125029,
0.0161112212,
-0.000143034,
0.012274825,
-0.0171695258,
0.0374439247,
-0.0170315113,
0.0683750585,
-0.0287482459,
0.0162741076,
0.018527858,
-0.1071835831,
-0.010772327,
-0.0216786209,
0.0575162582,
-0.0611999854,
0.0533502735,
0.0341361947,
0.0205459744,
0.0408408344,
-0.0127020413,
-0.0179987364,
0.0398578756,
-0.0267174579,
-0.0471325777,
0.0133337518,
0.0406072512,
0.0066715325,
0.024722809,
0.0142283747,
0.0138400495,
-0.0619521402,
0.0056632985,
0.0469645001,
0.0356229991,
0.0438344777,
0.020827949,
0.0064961878,
-0.0262360852,
0.0195390116,
-0.0492908508,
0.071852468,
-0.0333565176,
-0.0459044836,
-0.0321982168,
-0.0539103486,
-0.0146469986,
0.0547659434,
-0.035504844,
-0.0557805449,
-0.0248547606,
0.0319094397,
-0.0070965402,
-0.0362345353,
-0.0367448181,
0.0311474856,
-0.042650342,
-0.0651508272,
-0.014698741,
-0.0390587039,
0.0212074798,
0.0048317714,
-0.0350118466,
0.0320660844,
2.080972139e-34,
0.0060198568,
-0.0176104866,
0.0398608185,
0.0076734438,
0.0234431829,
0.0410761163,
0.0081347143,
0.0014641365,
0.0364186503,
-0.0746594146,
-0.000012578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00109v1 | A Sentence is Worth a Thousand Pictures: Can Large Language Models Understand Human Language? | 2023-07-26T18:58:53 | 2023-07-26T18:58:53 | Gary Marcus, Evelina Leivada, Elliot Murphy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial Intelligence applications show great potential for
language-related tasks that rely on next-word prediction. The current
generation of large language models have been linked to claims about human-like
linguistic performance and their applications are hailed both as a key step
towards Artificial General Intelligence and as major advance in understanding
the cognitive, and even neural basis of human language. We analyze the
contribution of large language models as theoretically informative
representations of a target system vs. atheoretical powerful mechanistic tools,
and we identify the key abilities that are still missing from the current state
of development and exploitation of these models. | [
0.0446637198,
0.0640636832,
-0.0433740988,
0.0241045523,
-0.0431780107,
0.0395668447,
0.0167033803,
0.002624925,
0.0051047923,
-0.0664272234,
-0.0397733785,
-0.0790219828,
0.0024045832,
0.0283262637,
0.0622042082,
-0.0419734679,
0.0362529606,
-0.0686861351,
0.0065296986,
-0.0110493964,
-0.0183015876,
-0.0070390604,
0.0081531936,
0.0641173497,
0.0128659336,
-0.0178191382,
0.0030369607,
-0.0516163595,
-0.0404980592,
0.008735992,
-0.030996481,
0.0425047129,
0.0174531508,
0.0772687569,
0.0000015703,
-0.0432772413,
0.0589180663,
-0.0013794387,
-0.0619097427,
0.0173739865,
0.0527641587,
-0.0275422521,
-0.0149026727,
-0.0050368072,
-0.0363217182,
-0.0109431539,
0.0309853163,
0.0030111885,
-0.0045197988,
0.056183964,
0.0084320717,
-0.0610663965,
0.0640730485,
-0.0301122367,
0.0125354752,
-0.0385507196,
0.0446629524,
-0.0163093917,
0.0230039321,
-0.0266361311,
-0.0356700718,
0.0356527828,
-0.0151211862,
0.0171247814,
-0.0037565473,
0.0389124416,
0.0129432352,
-0.0536259897,
-0.0021810699,
0.0292803049,
-0.0303196665,
-0.0421078503,
-0.0129392194,
0.0153592154,
0.0008412572,
0.0349666886,
-0.0444464758,
0.0330649093,
0.0268706661,
0.0301236473,
0.0593453906,
-0.0301793423,
0.0559163578,
0.0331253856,
-0.0239573885,
0.0830965415,
0.0223485697,
-0.0159167219,
0.022958234,
0.0104870331,
-0.0300607942,
-0.0529102311,
-0.0033963809,
0.0193502922,
-0.0198583063,
0.0149831753,
-0.0216322616,
-0.0233236924,
0.0127531439,
-0.049206391,
0.051573813,
0.0122792553,
0.0068641021,
0.0092026815,
-0.0064212703,
0.0604254045,
-0.0482525006,
-0.0162757691,
-0.043865893,
-0.0006945017,
-0.0365838893,
-0.0519668795,
-0.0029629848,
0.0414885469,
-0.0425848886,
-0.050534606,
-0.0294207577,
0.0207090937,
0.0112957619,
-0.0392858051,
-0.0123087605,
0.0272297543,
-0.017756775,
-0.0103945481,
-0.0430915728,
-0.0041596685,
-0.0041727037,
0.0279564708,
-0.0340319946,
-0.0449251756,
0.0080530634,
0.0245996919,
-0.0066778939,
-0.0357177816,
0.009058021,
0.0946621299,
0.0049580703,
-0.0310894735,
-0.0086425226,
0.0097049326,
-0.0312217288,
-0.0696111694,
0.005495951,
-0.028088145,
-0.0101075387,
0.0372432917,
-0.0223578066,
-0.0423020944,
0.0106969513,
0.0171000864,
-0.0696819276,
0.0732953176,
0.0138546545,
0.0289560463,
0.0294104014,
-0.0193575211,
0.0309040993,
0.0240336377,
0.0199548863,
0.0283085816,
0.0182595775,
-0.0000293196,
0.0010852896,
0.0534812026,
-0.019230919,
-0.0446552224,
-0.0509270132,
-0.0402254313,
0.0202240683,
0.0365192294,
0.0099999011,
0.0606273152,
0.0123270154,
-0.0245553777,
0.0816303715,
0.0821629018,
0.010341865,
0.0760975182,
0.0885143653,
0.0098565212,
0.0080115218,
0.0127860112,
-0.0480385982,
-0.0102010733,
-0.0580801889,
0.00119913,
-0.0034127217,
0.0248300564,
-0.0212537535,
-0.0110891173,
-0.0213140082,
-0.0140236029,
0.0148582766,
0.0003450612,
0.0555994585,
-0.0277227815,
-0.0171534661,
0.030321287,
0.0422276817,
0.0072793402,
0.0195387267,
-0.0617741346,
0.0146935238,
0.0413444042,
0.0246738847,
-0.0130459508,
0.004441068,
0.0176492576,
-0.0147410864,
0.0699189007,
0.0396619216,
-0.0116046537,
-0.0033936433,
-0.0002651449,
0.0435227491,
0.0031821744,
0.0155148199,
0.0125370463,
-0.0187897459,
-0.0052930163,
-0.0099919336,
0.0140840616,
-0.0403729267,
0.0463732034,
-0.0271599889,
-0.0166615937,
-0.0284374543,
0.0057691331,
0.0355084799,
0.0014297639,
-0.0271757469,
0.0287945159,
0.0403565578,
-0.0635910481,
-0.0118675856,
-0.0042227819,
-0.0432891287,
0.015053547,
0.0418330655,
0.009699448,
0.0362996645,
0.0410382301,
0.0269611366,
-0.0257279761,
0.0490737259,
-0.059413109,
0.0803998783,
-0.043859113,
0.0279180035,
-0.0211320147,
0.0573214144,
-0.0116703678,
0.063865684,
0.0131360572,
0.0118805999,
0.0033714215,
-0.0028475339,
0.00819756,
-0.0276353732,
-0.0627482906,
0.0348495692,
0.0053470675,
-0.005670771,
0.0229797047,
-0.0235501807,
-0.0154851964,
-0.0209425949,
-0.0612745248,
-0.0421054885,
0.0022225142,
0.0148400441,
-0.0103413621,
-0.0220941976,
0.0119403508,
0.0187384021,
-0.0189065989,
0.0127407108,
0.0281362683,
0.0004874023,
0.0331619307,
0.008326347,
-0.0569150709,
-0.0481741875,
-0.0453099124,
-0.0431480147,
0.0752015039,
0.0196341947,
-0.0292791128,
-0.0722285211,
0.0164194982,
-0.0038932408,
0.0380221754,
0.0091462182,
-0.0649829954,
-0.0003635075,
-0.0248796027,
0.0484482758,
0.1002166122,
0.0187808946,
0.079253681,
0.0312933959,
-0.0027755161,
0.0029981018,
-0.0171839017,
-0.0398999415,
-0.0143938689,
-0.0903878137,
-0.0004782391,
-0.0551030897,
0.0849710256,
0.0196796618,
-0.0154076405,
-0.0309458543,
0.039995607,
-0.0208078343,
-0.0521729514,
-0.029765809,
-0.0140635632,
-0.0459157526,
0.0288419891,
-0.0303417239,
-0.0359854698,
0.0670523047,
-0.0318492763,
-0.0085860388,
-0.0048535946,
-0.027821973,
-0.0095369527,
0.0729567409,
0.0381484069,
0.0296483878,
-0.0007316967,
-0.0052721337,
-0.0156878792,
-0.0008830833,
-0.0445667692,
-0.0042256638,
0.0153831365,
-0.0622251108,
-0.0060006292,
0.0490567535,
-0.0383609869,
-0.0212718863,
-0.0463069268,
-0.0652057156,
0.0248073302,
0.0350957699,
-0.0154539905,
-0.0583320223,
0.0260633249,
0.033861693,
-0.0080275834,
-0.0252063144,
0.011283529,
-0.0269783903,
0.0413048528,
0.060210865,
-0.0093140537,
0.0474543236,
-0.0210068673,
0.042565912,
0.0200948585,
0.0262059756,
0.0395859219,
-0.0394865386,
0.0358986408,
0.0481727459,
-0.0238398127,
-0.0627679676,
0.0317816995,
0.0170116723,
-0.0567981899,
-0.0301350933,
0.1218337938,
0.0203965679,
-0.0245715268,
0.0439776331,
0.0172428656,
-0.0010122914,
0.034252286,
0.0307755955,
-0.0288863946,
-0.0280289557,
-0.0065118549,
-0.025516225,
-0.0328908376,
-0.0348838344,
-0.0005870663,
-0.0956188217,
0.0142151956,
0.0073375632,
-0.0277481303,
-0.0204292238,
-0.0268114582,
0.0033580267,
0.009907647,
0.0135304667,
0.0170321278,
0.000782335,
-0.0159139112,
0.0134957591,
-0.040257208,
-0.0317169167,
0.0473678708,
-0.0215808079,
0.0632897615,
0.0830399618,
0.051769767,
-0.0430598408,
-0.015387197,
0.0310651809,
-0.0287905168,
0.0343786404,
-0.0052869623,
0.0335719287,
0.0149049386,
-0.0127822831,
-0.0467910916,
0.0452089384,
-0.0249096584,
-0.0247932505,
-0.04425136,
0.0814986303,
-0.0322413854,
-0.0518249273,
0.0199979618,
0.0019726241,
-0.0205920059,
0.0765074566,
0.0311584212,
-0.0965482816,
-0.0539867729,
-0.0068328003,
-0.0008410895,
-0.0014389504,
-0.0678415671,
0.0172723178,
0.051057633,
-0.0500734523,
-0.0381451882,
-0.0392500237,
-0.0008025018,
0.0088007227,
0.036442671,
0.0337901451,
0.0437956788,
-0.0181211475,
0.0079889391,
0.0062277294,
-0.0197021589,
0.0064390246,
-0.0519202426,
-0.0224015918,
0.0487704054,
-0.0490920544,
-0.0304753259,
0.0054463111,
-0.0788034201,
-0.0785770118,
0.0334799476,
0.008566034,
0.0307089463,
-0.0003108103,
-0.0108777406,
-0.1057352275,
0.0311565381,
-0.015615386,
-0.0465789698,
0.0329861976,
-0.0036425998,
0.010010465,
0.0137536954,
0.0634352192,
0.0013671523,
0.0439680032,
0.0067626322,
0.0072358218,
0.0029763717,
-0.0352807343,
0.0282263476,
0.0157262776,
0.0468143597,
-0.0133916968,
-0.0000840246,
-0.0140201673,
-0.0217537582,
0.0020165495,
0.0015048154,
-0.0114850216,
-0.0214324445,
0.0423071049,
0.0171091724,
-0.0313209631,
-0.0607087426,
-0.0001544175,
0.028488636,
-0.0158935059,
0.0182469636,
0.0048426692,
0.0238462128,
0.010347628,
0.0222472083,
0.0001429054,
0.0376656912,
-0.0433148406,
0.039716959,
-0.0191241186,
0.0440200455,
-0.0028766398,
0.0079940232,
-0.0455688834,
-0.0013220176,
-0.0877003595,
-0.0643643439,
-0.0008776464,
0.0294324625,
0.0588902235,
-0.034120515,
0.0074102539,
-0.0345941223,
-0.0135733811,
-0.0179834608,
0.0117506105,
-0.0171267167,
-0.0220636725,
0.0224802177,
0.0154668996,
-0.0381282754,
-0.0038469087,
0.0577796176,
0.0407035612,
0.0397209339,
0.0199618507,
-0.0383343101,
-0.0235869326,
-0.043475084,
-0.0016605688,
0.0109301107,
-0.0256214235,
0.0418379791,
-0.0685161948,
-0.0702815875,
0.0285041425,
0.0167157277,
0.0286785737,
-0.0401689112,
0.0059805452,
0.0538399033,
-0.0084103001,
-0.0146696074,
-0.0528966412,
0.0137094157,
-0.0138587439,
-0.0166402515,
0.006165483,
-5.675373786e-33,
-0.013999843,
-0.0082606338,
0.0072064735,
0.0031137194,
0.0000657366,
-0.0361113288,
-0.036768198,
0.0159822237,
-0.0303309355,
0.0305628963,
-0.0263007618,
-0.002021532,
0.0064421976,
0.0337385237,
0.026536664,
0.0083807092,
0.022525087,
-0.0327112414,
0.0273918714,
-0.0027922948,
0.0182962753,
0.0432060361,
0.0182306487,
-0.0245774742,
0.0245570205,
-0.0217119697,
0.0240510758,
0.02790967,
-0.017516017,
0.0433628261,
-0.069993265,
0.0406941734,
0.0362055935,
-0.0402769074,
-0.0178004522,
0.0549018309,
-0.0484715477,
0.0071582817,
0.0563215837,
-0.0070932684,
0.0189436097,
-0.01626941,
0.0379155651,
-0.0342863463,
-0.0515800379,
0.0384931676,
0.0150659503,
-0.0352495387,
0.009125581,
0.0183009375,
-0.0876606628,
-0.015746912,
-0.0074734692,
0.0212271325,
0.0464273803,
-0.0037780863,
-0.0462235995,
0.0063490542,
-0.0263148006,
0.0161583852,
-0.0089014713,
0.0598709211,
0.0665553361,
0.0338042676,
0.0193516836,
0.0638901144,
0.071360372,
-0.0445520058,
-0.0083655305,
0.0000836163,
0.0538603216,
0.041838862,
0.0126180239,
0.0267344099,
0.012082234,
-0.0179218594,
-0.0432553254,
-0.0556590557,
0.0324507356,
0.0290165059,
0.0726705417,
-0.0076711117,
-0.0265526325,
-0.0386212841,
-0.036842674,
-0.0373603292,
-0.0131265502,
-0.0103905164,
0.0174318682,
-0.0263568405,
0.0214308128,
0.0135509204,
0.028280681,
-0.0605431125,
0.0041298778,
0.0260087159,
0.0046276287,
0.0082678571,
0.0042411783,
0.0390862375,
-0.0741149485,
-0.04504757,
-0.0343306921,
0.020259643,
0.0098897135,
0.0021837894,
-0.0181836132,
0.0165745486,
-0.0333833061,
-0.0122834491,
-0.044892747,
-0.0355243608,
0.0335361063,
-0.0182358883,
0.0601748824,
0.0073580644,
-0.0022828598,
0.0160595495,
0.0063107987,
-0.003922781,
-0.0007304903,
0.0038534405,
0.0201587975,
0.0115060704,
-0.0576242246,
-0.0268269405,
-0.0372890756,
0.0360219367,
0.0310228784,
-0.0594737269,
-0.0088207517,
0.0066972971,
2.391e-7,
0.0481403135,
0.0760360435,
0.0044750939,
0.019771073,
0.0451942421,
0.0251643583,
-0.0133947609,
-0.0058390703,
0.0015542754,
-0.0172278378,
0.0175849814,
0.0515303686,
0.0409181081,
-0.011833501,
-0.0498557091,
0.0136545254,
-0.0662692189,
0.0025364652,
-0.0628770441,
0.0075253458,
0.0106463144,
0.1232067645,
0.0304208715,
-0.0411832444,
-0.0089976629,
-0.0616189651,
0.0401917808,
-0.0406414047,
0.0096502807,
0.0053180023,
-0.0001752472,
-0.0000749399,
-0.0086751124,
0.0487241261,
0.0195619389,
0.0552417897,
-0.0035247193,
0.0334436037,
-0.0331121199,
-0.0002473339,
-0.0023134088,
-0.0038499616,
-0.0265655089,
-0.0507400408,
0.0630916357,
-0.0404794589,
-0.069061771,
-0.0155691076,
0.0268676411,
-0.0131148808,
-0.0451034829,
-0.025050737,
0.0342472419,
-0.0141087435,
0.0045710164,
-0.0176525936,
0.024634067,
-0.0679005235,
-0.0066739013,
0.038834095,
-0.0643857047,
-0.0237112977,
-0.0441584699,
-0.0190046784,
0.0577086024,
-0.0525674075,
0.0053234273,
2.029401916e-34,
0.0374174528,
0.0327190608,
-0.0043970281,
0.0151386363,
0.0579353161,
-0.0027254412,
0.0134974932,
0.0204310864,
0.0201108567,
-0.1193640009,
-0.0373010859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14440v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14440v1 | Controllable Generation of Dialogue Acts for Dialogue Systems via Few-Shot Response Generation and Ranking | 2023-07-26T18:16:45 | 2023-07-26T18:16:45 | Angela Ramirez, Karik Agarwal, Juraj Juraska, Utkarsh Garg, Marilyn A. Walker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems need to produce responses that realize multiple types of
dialogue acts (DAs) with high semantic fidelity. In the past, natural language
generators (NLGs) for dialogue were trained on large parallel corpora that map
from a domain-specific DA and its semantic attributes to an output utterance.
Recent work shows that pretrained language models (LLMs) offer new
possibilities for controllable NLG using prompt-based learning. Here we develop
a novel few-shot overgenerate-and-rank approach that achieves the controlled
generation of DAs. We compare eight few-shot prompt styles that include a novel
method of generating from textual pseudo-references using a textual style
transfer approach. We develop six automatic ranking functions that identify
outputs with both the correct DA and high semantic accuracy at generation time.
We test our approach on three domains and four LLMs. To our knowledge, this is
the first work on NLG for dialogue that automatically ranks outputs using both
DA and attribute accuracy. For completeness, we compare our results to
fine-tuned few-shot models trained with 5 to 100 instances per DA. Our results
show that several prompt settings achieve perfect DA accuracy, and near perfect
semantic accuracy (99.81%) and perform better than few-shot fine-tuning. | [
0.0400912315,
0.0254230835,
0.0008207401,
0.0134065542,
0.0041634678,
-0.0023540179,
0.0408453457,
0.0017281388,
0.0238444582,
-0.0659565404,
-0.0503253751,
-0.0318498127,
-0.0347880535,
0.0392184369,
0.0329126157,
-0.0498213917,
0.041136466,
-0.0057627005,
0.0370721705,
-0.0101950979,
0.0094980262,
0.0226973817,
-0.0314839259,
0.0552127175,
-0.0080502229,
-0.011323533,
-0.0137385195,
0.0085063092,
0.0335693955,
-0.0049814573,
0.0053805159,
0.0416022651,
-0.0070576021,
0.031360209,
0.0000019422,
-0.0536644608,
0.0064354069,
-0.0288387928,
-0.0089689167,
0.008419523,
0.011295855,
0.0347801,
-0.0165590085,
0.0146929976,
-0.0449968763,
-0.0348784514,
0.0445799716,
0.0229182355,
0.0998961478,
0.0924948528,
-0.0140958428,
-0.047864642,
0.0014474699,
-0.0450169817,
0.0057580103,
-0.0376609415,
-0.0307413172,
0.0044348435,
0.0303286184,
0.0363958962,
0.0003038164,
0.0151175773,
-0.0198480189,
-0.0589117184,
0.0037229883,
0.0099549452,
-0.0342440233,
0.0008669943,
-0.021044435,
0.1057311594,
-0.0005295742,
0.0164516978,
0.0212044735,
-0.0422327816,
0.0155253429,
-0.0199711658,
-0.0354338996,
0.0194301661,
0.0098030912,
-0.005276517,
-0.0262146071,
0.0435544662,
-0.0202941597,
-0.0069836862,
0.0029021965,
-0.0048206854,
0.0356694162,
-0.0217804722,
-0.0296311434,
-0.0141095733,
-0.0129828826,
-0.0689674839,
0.0024360528,
0.0280568097,
-0.0565543175,
0.0157981124,
-0.0721049756,
0.0037006079,
0.0229853746,
0.0127820307,
0.0699179322,
0.0324371122,
-0.0082651116,
0.0151613811,
-0.020441344,
0.0952089727,
-0.0132244229,
0.0308884401,
-0.0374395549,
0.0249959417,
-0.0415453166,
-0.0088948775,
-0.0529588871,
0.0274654645,
-0.0680485219,
-0.0252329074,
-0.0485691614,
0.0208355747,
-0.004635829,
0.0155116245,
0.0181639735,
0.0198551547,
-0.0392750986,
-0.0215390045,
-0.0261348672,
0.0229473431,
-0.0254758671,
0.0111971218,
0.0515559316,
-0.0261597037,
-0.0127497949,
0.0102400836,
0.0433150828,
-0.0087615876,
-0.0169027802,
0.0621635057,
-0.0539295115,
-0.0150197586,
0.0131948013,
-0.0333195068,
-0.0502085388,
-0.0328040086,
-0.036615625,
-0.0366288163,
0.0343065187,
-0.0076189465,
-0.020782508,
-0.0308474284,
0.0243209191,
0.0301395711,
-0.0232046675,
0.0320041552,
-0.001644823,
0.0002985853,
0.0141963717,
-0.0019543802,
-0.0113514299,
0.0132619301,
0.0332060866,
0.0429958627,
0.0285998918,
0.0014224104,
0.0355083458,
0.0255998187,
0.0194429327,
-0.0013181035,
0.0027233956,
-0.0014921991,
0.0148429247,
0.0224383455,
0.0449547879,
0.0401486568,
-0.0510062911,
-0.0129864682,
0.0539837405,
-0.0024187656,
0.0073306588,
-0.0190458763,
0.0892647654,
0.0605214536,
-0.0046632886,
-0.0010934174,
-0.007267884,
0.0312372558,
0.0073466985,
0.0224342886,
0.0607835501,
0.0035233439,
-0.0326831825,
-0.0365870893,
0.0288098622,
0.0043573859,
-0.0323267244,
-0.0159042366,
-0.0126248626,
0.0686839893,
-0.0799117982,
0.0222660247,
-0.0011642907,
-0.0582834557,
-0.0216567684,
-0.023009561,
0.0156230582,
0.0776114017,
0.0442573093,
0.002239594,
-0.0551945493,
-0.0288151633,
0.0225836411,
0.0609179474,
0.0380640477,
-0.0281209815,
0.0373770371,
-0.0555158108,
0.0201056153,
-0.0243445598,
-0.01439761,
0.0580451339,
-0.0553354174,
0.0037315746,
0.0183617789,
0.0475372709,
0.0035615682,
0.0161108095,
-0.0016604526,
-0.0461581461,
0.0661393851,
-0.001043616,
0.0409378968,
0.0009099873,
-0.0198489018,
0.0091943927,
0.0000850425,
-0.0176013093,
0.0073208995,
0.0279481765,
-0.0677443519,
-0.0995943993,
-0.0152799571,
0.0201266762,
-0.0144925462,
-0.0040224362,
-0.0459876359,
-0.072353296,
-0.0063478798,
-0.0198849104,
-0.0147276307,
-0.0635553971,
0.0145861581,
0.0725040361,
0.017549783,
-0.0526519939,
0.0393074192,
0.0072005382,
0.0058809859,
0.0810062513,
0.0765630528,
0.0227916446,
-0.0447272733,
-0.0024117799,
0.0115755051,
-0.033573579,
0.0011427371,
0.0220709741,
0.0483433977,
-0.0134039754,
-0.0299478862,
-0.0577721708,
0.0099621536,
-0.0095441332,
-0.0167845171,
0.0088786399,
0.0110760406,
-0.00871519,
-0.0096634347,
-0.0412022583,
0.0108217243,
0.0883469135,
-0.0113783255,
0.0469653271,
0.0223552268,
-0.0118223121,
-0.0593157485,
0.0191035643,
0.0162712056,
0.0383372866,
-0.0069152103,
0.0286548901,
-0.0584018864,
0.0278291292,
-0.0290940981,
0.0250095595,
0.0028814992,
-0.0833766088,
0.0358111002,
-0.0013811596,
0.0052947616,
0.0450375825,
0.0413176008,
0.007773906,
0.0081093945,
-0.0287778862,
-0.0737022907,
0.0364464708,
-0.0201608855,
-0.027763186,
-0.0013172047,
0.0068179499,
0.0350250341,
0.0468377173,
0.0689025447,
0.0324274823,
-0.0619463883,
0.0381867588,
0.0513225235,
-0.0634561777,
0.0017418558,
-0.0157947652,
-0.0496392474,
0.0230338257,
-0.0137771238,
-0.014180568,
0.0411322974,
-0.0360498391,
-0.0383096747,
-0.0277456883,
0.0265757889,
0.001239092,
0.0408289321,
0.0130892461,
0.0375338942,
0.0013806986,
-0.0259130783,
-0.0403187536,
0.0037346466,
0.0311416052,
-0.0149568971,
0.0119804498,
-0.0306047648,
0.0015912597,
-0.0225848332,
-0.0344598405,
-0.0622475222,
-0.080098398,
0.0083422204,
0.0048123035,
0.0034652224,
-0.0132483384,
0.0203410611,
0.001686394,
0.0079550399,
0.043440368,
-0.0034971652,
-0.0039148959,
-0.0476283021,
0.0851650015,
0.0469115153,
-0.0156940017,
-0.0436425731,
0.0250989888,
0.0623456575,
0.0152458996,
0.0074574989,
0.0225557853,
-0.0164964683,
-0.0081873275,
0.0261303522,
-0.0340965018,
-0.0154002467,
0.0137798954,
0.0496138483,
-0.0240744483,
-0.0256651267,
0.1273890883,
0.0380288251,
0.0006487674,
-0.0055306773,
0.0015837485,
0.0219931193,
0.0014907463,
0.0490563549,
-0.1129156575,
-0.0454802066,
-0.0276830476,
0.0115112877,
-0.0245351382,
-0.0102694957,
-0.0381578803,
-0.140663296,
0.0545311198,
0.0062796706,
-0.0422181673,
0.0098261693,
0.0187931061,
0.0155359982,
0.0118313218,
-0.0136962729,
0.0159161072,
0.0093951942,
0.0066903988,
0.0123938872,
0.0444964729,
-0.0178302862,
0.0235369187,
-0.0119707976,
0.0921805054,
0.0815998018,
0.0649453104,
0.0407678038,
-0.0084238863,
-0.0115821809,
-0.0383044742,
0.0186842661,
0.0132416645,
0.0174824297,
-0.0189391803,
-0.0276459046,
0.01399903,
0.017545091,
0.0281768441,
-0.0215498153,
0.0001850104,
0.0204954911,
-0.0406977385,
-0.0153316921,
-0.0132686719,
0.0487113073,
0.0419594944,
0.0534759946,
0.0355236344,
-0.0460007675,
-0.0328652859,
-0.0219738539,
0.0119906887,
-0.0838876367,
-0.0144879837,
-0.0091640353,
0.0090623247,
-0.005108668,
-0.1299934983,
-0.043959599,
0.0000442481,
0.0287882239,
-0.0165880416,
-0.0389684103,
-0.0139884781,
0.0019370377,
0.019906383,
-0.0341373011,
-0.0049853204,
0.0067467112,
-0.0578749217,
-0.0344882682,
0.082977213,
-0.0514742658,
-0.0198718496,
0.021863794,
-0.0111621367,
-0.0677311271,
-0.0277930759,
0.1106944457,
0.0130996611,
0.0252580233,
-0.0042072595,
-0.0460138023,
0.0170442127,
0.0626114979,
-0.0171904787,
-0.0115576377,
0.0609466545,
0.0478040203,
-0.0323862918,
0.0282075666,
-0.0323044471,
0.0712610781,
-0.002341653,
0.0403653383,
-0.0298516154,
-0.1016291827,
0.0021344516,
0.0103515042,
0.0204461198,
-0.027068885,
-0.0044440259,
-0.0160490666,
0.0308638383,
-0.0365167558,
-0.0200574771,
-0.0716408268,
0.0150082298,
-0.0021361222,
-0.01705667,
-0.012836447,
-0.0347722992,
-0.0536746308,
0.0615862571,
-0.0450190119,
-0.0262988377,
0.0177555848,
0.0173764229,
-0.0163164344,
0.0151458159,
-0.0347266123,
0.0320011601,
0.0176864564,
0.0263473243,
-0.0140600828,
0.0905267671,
0.0127655342,
-0.0374796204,
0.0000808864,
0.057831835,
-0.0445529781,
-0.0134329516,
-0.0290883929,
0.0082570547,
0.0433486141,
0.029562097,
0.0536853075,
-0.0160303265,
0.015450445,
-0.0053010825,
0.0437500589,
0.0295846034,
-0.0535280295,
0.0068371249,
0.0190402549,
-0.0027052423,
0.0231642462,
0.0723930001,
-0.0141016813,
-0.0020656968,
-0.0026737372,
0.0188604817,
-0.0615364648,
-0.0259759463,
-0.0202248804,
0.0195509251,
0.023392031,
-0.0055906395,
-0.0460689962,
-0.0192863215,
0.0254019927,
0.0086322222,
-0.0030491662,
-0.0079448018,
0.053967528,
0.0108121969,
-0.0082800984,
0.0177932587,
-0.0458695106,
-0.0066474564,
-0.0255406164,
-0.0239510071,
-0.061698962,
-5.598456048e-33,
-0.0537095033,
-0.0236812104,
0.0130128218,
-0.0239087995,
-0.015801616,
-0.037312258,
-0.0416650809,
-0.0123731028,
0.0060144882,
0.0220491327,
-0.0302052889,
-0.0273134466,
0.0023026229,
0.0325923227,
-0.0017061237,
-0.0134589411,
0.0447773896,
0.0032878059,
-0.0429396555,
0.0612207353,
0.0439274944,
0.0085821599,
0.0169549026,
-0.0480499566,
-0.033742141,
-0.0147064915,
-0.0381591432,
-0.0012036745,
0.0169934295,
0.0344109721,
-0.0029992524,
0.0329455659,
-0.0026395149,
-0.0604679324,
-0.0161719192,
0.0505609736,
-0.0290150866,
-0.034767855,
0.0236663036,
-0.0335575081,
0.0060889805,
-0.0398272201,
-0.01996281,
-0.0434356555,
-0.0177176688,
0.0168135799,
0.0079820883,
-0.0148177454,
-0.0251911543,
-0.0669655725,
-0.0647933707,
0.0056757419,
-0.0203723628,
-0.0731388256,
-0.0241016913,
0.0892571956,
-0.009949293,
0.0010522015,
-0.0147343669,
0.0328752957,
-0.0061210091,
0.0003579657,
0.0301197004,
0.0212664679,
-0.0109428745,
0.0665705055,
0.024041418,
0.0197939537,
-0.0019323446,
-0.0055192304,
-0.0380159989,
0.0687745288,
0.0107319942,
0.0998348966,
-0.0239802711,
-0.0054552425,
-0.0327146575,
0.0411775857,
0.0140203871,
0.0167037863,
0.0138147324,
0.0124151558,
-0.0111547979,
0.0015390908,
-0.0216719732,
-0.0133033227,
-0.0110919252,
-0.0319424607,
0.048316624,
0.011501383,
-0.0240693595,
0.0168654881,
0.0773359835,
-0.0067188237,
-0.0016067532,
0.0239830371,
-0.0528700203,
0.0276416186,
-0.0218967721,
-0.0070963688,
-0.0483964048,
-0.0301335137,
0.084985815,
0.0069547785,
-0.0025172324,
0.0321399719,
0.0081034629,
0.0011295701,
-0.0469319932,
0.0223058406,
-0.0032462978,
0.055843927,
-0.0573830344,
-0.0015410557,
-0.0155455396,
-0.0051395884,
-0.0369456075,
0.0641434789,
-0.0181147531,
-0.0339031518,
0.0017939744,
-0.023365166,
0.0122931264,
0.0098765735,
-0.0582073927,
0.0345440097,
0.0042559179,
0.0130549148,
-0.0143693117,
-0.0390292071,
-0.0112196757,
-0.0032252911,
2.71e-7,
-0.0298139099,
0.0076394142,
0.0028035152,
0.039558433,
0.0169963017,
0.0393015407,
0.0315053947,
0.0553000346,
0.048296079,
-0.0106336186,
0.0249350946,
-0.0277343113,
0.0361820236,
-0.008083621,
-0.1105054989,
-0.0124439094,
-0.0601685569,
-0.0034096555,
-0.0416067764,
-0.0316848494,
0.0654384866,
0.0458472893,
-0.0254979432,
0.008429422,
0.008046058,
-0.0166564677,
0.0527519286,
0.0073270057,
-0.0214336999,
0.0200997945,
0.0475974269,
-0.0496374033,
-0.024722008,
0.0113587631,
-0.0217054784,
0.0210786071,
0.0220374297,
0.0732297748,
0.008826457,
-0.0543876328,
-0.0141307032,
-0.0058067334,
0.024348842,
-0.022364242,
0.0454668514,
-0.0618565418,
0.0087480349,
0.005386638,
-0.0681411102,
0.0033710434,
-0.0055557922,
-0.0476149283,
-0.038494125,
0.0218703989,
0.0330019891,
0.0122481789,
0.0024956251,
-0.0800292864,
-0.0322399512,
-0.024555333,
-0.0311899371,
-0.0316322781,
-0.0008897276,
-0.0149679026,
0.0218296349,
-0.0527163818,
-0.0147340512,
2.294684589e-34,
0.020622205,
-0.005574923,
0.038012363,
0.0244829431,
0.0099837463,
0.0188628566,
0.0026418057,
0.0313947089,
0.0709475949,
-0.0709558204,
-0.0370036401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14430v1 | Skill-it! A Data-Driven Skills Framework for Understanding and Training Language Models | 2023-07-26T18:01:49 | 2023-07-26T18:01:49 | Mayee F. Chen, Nicholas Roberts, Kush Bhatia, Jue Wang, Ce Zhang, Frederic Sala, Christopher Ré | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The quality of training data impacts the performance of pre-trained large
language models (LMs). Given a fixed budget of tokens, we study how to best
select data that leads to good downstream model performance across tasks. We
develop a new framework based on a simple hypothesis: just as humans acquire
interdependent skills in a deliberate order, language models also follow a
natural order when learning a set of skills from their training data. If such
an order exists, it can be utilized for improved understanding of LMs and for
data-efficient training. Using this intuition, our framework formalizes the
notion of a skill and of an ordered set of skills in terms of the associated
data. First, using both synthetic and real data, we demonstrate that these
ordered skill sets exist, and that their existence enables more advanced skills
to be learned with less data when we train on their prerequisite skills.
Second, using our proposed framework, we introduce an online data sampling
algorithm, Skill-It, over mixtures of skills for both continual pre-training
and fine-tuning regimes, where the objective is to efficiently learn multiple
skills in the former and an individual skill in the latter. On the LEGO
synthetic in the continual pre-training setting, Skill-It obtains 36.5 points
higher accuracy than random sampling. On the Natural Instructions dataset in
the fine-tuning setting, Skill-It reduces the validation loss on the target
skill by 13.6% versus training on data associated with the target skill itself.
We apply our skills framework on the recent RedPajama dataset to continually
pre-train a 3B-parameter LM, achieving higher accuracy on the LM Evaluation
Harness with 1B tokens than the baseline approach of sampling uniformly over
data sources with 3B tokens. | [
0.0293036122,
0.0717728287,
-0.034324605,
-0.0074160057,
0.006249127,
0.029860964,
0.0057834671,
-0.0018774184,
-0.0280688088,
-0.0512707122,
-0.0712999329,
-0.0356056578,
0.0013707068,
0.0083428258,
0.0540735014,
-0.0521958135,
0.0264282245,
-0.0863117501,
-0.0138185471,
0.0045031621,
-0.010536165,
0.0278145336,
-0.030632928,
0.0452059209,
-0.0139902784,
0.0004257994,
0.0020221749,
-0.0159570035,
-0.0290223509,
-0.0365750976,
0.0232070126,
0.061861705,
0.0523107238,
-0.010323477,
0.0000023183,
-0.0334906392,
0.0087280767,
0.0049809488,
-0.05208271,
-0.0106752431,
0.0500688851,
-0.0030241604,
0.0013684011,
0.0343395025,
-0.0292623043,
-0.0618535988,
0.0362920947,
-0.014582688,
0.0364732631,
0.0701640025,
0.0085144686,
-0.0022411349,
0.0128606027,
-0.0339862965,
-0.0026767382,
-0.0154579962,
0.0285470095,
0.037841998,
0.0072336043,
0.0182198789,
-0.0042643091,
0.0001881721,
0.0300467759,
0.025725292,
0.0048882551,
0.0327816047,
-0.0086255809,
-0.0271735303,
-0.0057747755,
0.0411617458,
-0.0571160242,
-0.0244626291,
0.0145534426,
-0.0241179783,
-0.013961683,
0.0369230658,
-0.0544039905,
0.050107047,
0.0181934722,
0.0264018197,
0.0062924679,
-0.0226270761,
0.0191604439,
0.0183955096,
-0.0143873822,
0.0420620181,
-0.0061996141,
-0.0213113464,
0.0013017082,
-0.0048535066,
-0.0132155465,
-0.0378170758,
-0.0272765514,
0.0271526929,
-0.0344913788,
0.0109481514,
-0.0563750453,
-0.0059648314,
-0.0085969782,
-0.0006778144,
0.0648404434,
0.0003793717,
-0.0126472199,
0.0307803787,
0.0071263621,
0.0045760679,
0.0278825723,
0.0655395389,
-0.0507927351,
-0.0042657149,
-0.0643937588,
-0.0206805244,
-0.0217108969,
0.019083472,
-0.0265788734,
-0.0129899653,
-0.0102233272,
0.0224459618,
-0.0178555548,
-0.034326423,
0.0283404775,
-0.0302479751,
-0.0387465544,
0.0063655172,
-0.0269190855,
-0.0082838628,
-0.0071823699,
0.0610834807,
0.0018117859,
-0.0835013017,
-0.0047349157,
-0.0072825365,
-0.0123169469,
-0.0195291936,
0.0438853502,
0.0818850249,
-0.0208402369,
-0.0208770297,
-0.0295801088,
-0.00819025,
0.0274686906,
-0.0666702241,
0.0206899382,
-0.0653046593,
0.0403103083,
0.0016729246,
0.0110953934,
-0.0221068431,
-0.0114748906,
0.0043932758,
-0.0442546755,
0.0441085547,
0.0006195669,
0.0591568723,
-0.0113177923,
-0.0188880693,
0.0282835942,
0.069484733,
0.0256079193,
-0.0205316432,
0.01339579,
-0.0226857774,
0.0157850664,
0.038478639,
0.0089680711,
0.0013232222,
-0.0238148514,
0.0127764223,
0.0272191539,
0.0175490789,
0.0524297953,
-0.0044042901,
-0.0661937669,
0.0469851643,
0.0715842545,
0.0298611615,
0.0389438309,
-0.0038778896,
0.0442562141,
0.0449837744,
0.0375208668,
-0.0169234388,
-0.0666454285,
0.0015053402,
0.0307677742,
-0.0064644376,
-0.0106915468,
0.0301428884,
-0.0404633507,
-0.0297195725,
0.0057127415,
-0.000770637,
-0.0211637411,
0.041850213,
0.0573269129,
0.0045985393,
-0.0256676134,
0.0379691422,
0.0356432572,
-0.0270524435,
0.0146543914,
-0.0517295785,
0.0062741083,
0.0713822916,
0.0082580345,
-0.0457501002,
-0.0446448289,
0.0108597167,
0.0509243906,
-0.0206761044,
0.0238911193,
-0.0356078632,
0.0358725749,
-0.039547313,
-0.0443823524,
0.0026629139,
0.008528159,
0.0193973035,
-0.0038128896,
-0.0044464967,
-0.0070072631,
-0.014840438,
-0.0740782171,
0.0478843376,
-0.0304949302,
-0.016428547,
-0.0001755498,
0.0015658749,
0.0411430672,
-0.0148483068,
-0.0224454012,
0.0060507916,
0.0247415453,
-0.0222421139,
0.0303843617,
0.0145616243,
-0.0379204229,
-0.0018160334,
0.0235520415,
0.0015542809,
-0.0077064214,
0.0523613691,
-0.0487222746,
-0.0425431654,
-0.0099137845,
0.0028348553,
0.0446696244,
-0.0212769769,
0.0133985709,
-0.014067091,
0.0033774464,
-0.0223749112,
0.0305768698,
0.0034867499,
0.0138590755,
-0.0283170082,
0.0330940187,
-0.0101657696,
-0.044656761,
0.0001903924,
0.0075790635,
0.0000689387,
0.0641056597,
0.0006298858,
0.0411843285,
-0.0354786217,
-0.0073222145,
-0.0676555187,
0.0049007111,
-0.0210074298,
0.0108801322,
0.0259360261,
-0.0437075235,
-0.0339246914,
-0.016961718,
-0.0215754826,
-0.0375450477,
0.0103797484,
0.0159893762,
0.0023388034,
0.0123892985,
-0.0203236081,
-0.0048646666,
-0.0268147942,
-0.0114406291,
0.0378391296,
0.0035262203,
0.0428628363,
-0.0593089946,
0.0182792693,
-0.0023549059,
0.0367450975,
-0.0209580474,
-0.0481549762,
0.0006962026,
-0.0265595615,
-0.0013570875,
0.0563182309,
-0.0101877982,
0.0213975888,
0.0563113019,
-0.0033345409,
-0.0303310994,
-0.0059177373,
-0.0228670239,
-0.01126415,
-0.0342377573,
-0.0103769172,
-0.0104609532,
0.0605435185,
0.0169804189,
-0.0000537777,
-0.0425267071,
0.0089193452,
-0.0157170966,
-0.0199348405,
-0.026949469,
0.0090078982,
-0.0151173268,
0.0134657053,
-0.0487409197,
-0.0515782163,
0.0297351312,
-0.0288967267,
0.0041229245,
-0.0475236252,
-0.0183331054,
-0.0074928305,
0.0616601296,
0.0201580692,
-0.0010544632,
-0.0135225803,
-0.0273515563,
-0.0784069896,
0.0192293748,
0.0410509445,
-0.031495519,
-0.0126715917,
-0.0705145374,
0.0112982588,
0.0091199046,
-0.0279413369,
-0.0447054803,
-0.0190841481,
-0.0083451523,
0.0342612006,
0.0317416675,
0.0013020715,
0.0038658183,
-0.003123957,
0.0100843273,
0.0404168591,
-0.018697314,
0.0043469132,
-0.011664886,
0.0153314183,
0.0447175689,
0.0263167713,
-0.0092070941,
-0.0593000464,
-0.0073808599,
0.0213368032,
0.0715545416,
0.0065368563,
-0.033711262,
0.021300802,
0.0433685407,
-0.0150843505,
-0.012874309,
0.0348279551,
0.045448564,
-0.0536156744,
-0.0191196371,
0.1057744846,
0.0005411477,
-0.0300360993,
0.0152580952,
0.0678733289,
0.01382137,
0.0389883034,
0.0424076729,
-0.0794522464,
-0.0208718199,
-0.001679939,
0.051488474,
-0.0012387267,
-0.0221454389,
-0.003310855,
-0.139403984,
0.0358355902,
-0.0025756296,
-0.0921186209,
-0.0110186767,
-0.0479447022,
-0.0142360004,
-0.0275375396,
0.0389574915,
0.0108511355,
-0.0307723675,
0.0120285088,
0.0812062025,
-0.0063597653,
-0.1150277033,
0.0350761972,
-0.0415361337,
0.0869843662,
0.0356618501,
0.0036593357,
-0.01177401,
-0.0157754775,
0.0781626552,
-0.0046276492,
0.014753337,
0.0054420917,
0.0632932857,
-0.0229086187,
-0.0285932757,
0.0000966985,
0.0558408462,
-0.0118837692,
-0.0137925483,
-0.0197018497,
0.0674241111,
-0.0056964396,
0.0013620974,
0.009920584,
-0.0420454517,
0.0417931825,
0.0473830849,
0.0124891913,
-0.0568964407,
-0.0159983765,
0.0162827391,
-0.0021719222,
-0.0224140957,
-0.0399917699,
0.0382677764,
-0.0302254017,
-0.0257869847,
-0.0388666689,
-0.0243576504,
0.0415705331,
0.0765800476,
0.0156834703,
0.0105239134,
0.0207287222,
0.0066929329,
-0.0569751896,
0.066607967,
-0.0389227495,
0.0065763495,
-0.1020553038,
-0.0733997002,
0.0249470919,
-0.0486692972,
-0.0354272574,
-0.0287676901,
-0.1009272635,
-0.050598722,
0.0256946776,
0.0846084133,
0.0202268716,
0.0826858357,
-0.001523647,
-0.0884818658,
0.0507716052,
0.0283038616,
-0.1086760014,
0.008533976,
0.0293771327,
-0.050299108,
0.0116488431,
0.0149601353,
-0.0538580939,
0.0533489734,
0.0392736681,
0.0138944648,
0.0130339814,
0.0428390503,
0.0260839462,
0.0089134462,
0.0537013263,
0.0034996727,
0.0147382859,
-0.0767818242,
0.0137477703,
0.03311418,
-0.0098617915,
-0.0593018346,
0.0075954269,
0.0226471219,
0.0134883346,
0.0053874203,
-0.0121952053,
0.012302448,
0.0030890708,
-0.0514498539,
0.0111833112,
-0.0108845644,
0.0522914305,
0.0481769629,
0.0033288766,
0.0023150938,
0.0176022034,
-0.0232601613,
0.0111035192,
-0.0016885406,
0.0164122377,
0.0107310945,
0.0066547669,
-0.0280107576,
0.0289873648,
-0.0533753932,
-0.1002438143,
-0.0233267099,
0.0098688314,
0.0755480602,
-0.0753235966,
0.0371507965,
-0.0207879134,
0.018197272,
-0.0116207339,
0.0301484112,
-0.0174732953,
-0.018615894,
-0.0042731962,
0.0339502282,
-0.0211029183,
0.0023031761,
0.0952464417,
0.0246686805,
0.0619647466,
-0.0261713024,
-0.0049927062,
-0.013240655,
-0.0025266986,
0.0319933221,
0.0194290578,
-0.034884993,
0.0140168387,
-0.0166499354,
-0.0692037791,
-0.0569563583,
0.0303261448,
-0.0145420013,
-0.0290010963,
0.0650844499,
0.0644365251,
-0.0374331512,
0.0270645972,
-0.0368186869,
-0.0352982655,
0.0289603397,
-0.0080213398,
0.0101370206,
-6.812609836e-33,
-0.0109880529,
0.0158484317,
0.0320545807,
0.013483935,
-0.0043212832,
0.0297054537,
-0.0068217982,
-0.0090886373,
-0.0164563544,
-0.0035671643,
-0.0032037729,
0.0043155765,
0.0060405238,
0.0269505922,
0.0435549021,
-0.0075498628,
0.0455734394,
-0.0268402137,
-0.0151610505,
0.0246644206,
0.0338105038,
0.0209126715,
0.0904192328,
-0.0280438624,
-0.0231578574,
-0.0090189725,
0.000333747,
0.0167069752,
-0.0069509335,
0.0618076883,
0.0085156485,
0.0102270301,
0.0231289081,
-0.0731735602,
-0.04246369,
-0.0334523953,
-0.0743273869,
-0.0335378796,
0.0154991318,
0.0464036651,
-0.0111063179,
0.0030648429,
0.0542098098,
-0.0105789956,
-0.0305525847,
0.0115296841,
0.031967435,
-0.0311290007,
-0.0489282794,
-0.0206513926,
-0.0139500573,
0.0230220351,
-0.0122639826,
-0.0530220233,
0.0263325274,
0.0170448218,
-0.0175500959,
-0.0433158316,
-0.0537618771,
0.0365127921,
0.0401587524,
0.049059283,
0.046800103,
0.0528503172,
0.0428930409,
0.0511455312,
0.0494868159,
0.0005906157,
0.0356927887,
0.0331373736,
0.0680967122,
0.0723805279,
-0.0422808528,
-0.0095133213,
0.0516685471,
-0.0242729895,
-0.0903553739,
0.0113111399,
0.0124991424,
0.0240443796,
0.0260987151,
-0.0001356486,
-0.0159296673,
-0.0472198948,
-0.0434091091,
-0.0307603627,
-0.0061129001,
-0.0027238566,
0.0551050268,
0.0395059586,
-0.0234072804,
-0.0086245695,
0.0336413495,
-0.0273896996,
-0.059385661,
0.0167923253,
-0.0528651625,
0.0297368802,
-0.0173742138,
0.0175136402,
-0.1031112298,
-0.0825138763,
0.0112949945,
-0.0283142366,
0.0343500301,
0.0146532767,
0.0364310704,
0.0550141446,
-0.0579753369,
-0.0245316196,
-0.0306894984,
0.0265357047,
0.0248565488,
0.0129328258,
0.0755299106,
-0.005490934,
-0.0005088217,
0.0547843166,
-0.0114360591,
-0.0731299743,
-0.0422630645,
0.0319304988,
0.0002084684,
0.0141247353,
-0.0079316003,
-0.0104164295,
-0.057484813,
-0.0654397532,
0.0357175358,
-0.045378264,
-0.0209275149,
0.010400001,
2.952e-7,
0.0262950603,
0.032089211,
-0.0275062192,
0.025917273,
0.0068192999,
-0.0043895682,
-0.0501379408,
0.0005422771,
-0.0036665606,
0.0317992233,
0.0177103728,
0.0582568087,
0.0403707437,
0.0070196325,
-0.0521017537,
-0.0257418696,
-0.0373991132,
0.0437844433,
-0.0630567893,
-0.0364540294,
-0.0200605523,
0.085501574,
0.0124738328,
-0.0237678383,
-0.0125913424,
-0.0114351325,
0.0520560332,
-0.0254990906,
0.0154195148,
0.0352722704,
-0.0242629554,
0.0507133305,
-0.0240847841,
0.0431038551,
-0.0203024708,
0.0119939875,
0.0092713628,
0.074970074,
-0.0174001455,
0.0232677888,
0.0269144252,
0.0079092681,
-0.0258394908,
-0.0363211632,
0.0840004161,
-0.0738378167,
-0.0216801148,
-0.0382807106,
-0.0019575546,
-0.0236830451,
-0.0203728192,
-0.0031551081,
-0.0214852467,
0.0267798398,
0.0320177823,
-0.0246311668,
-0.0181957651,
-0.0508808084,
0.0038037095,
0.0463286191,
-0.0328718573,
-0.0597485602,
-0.0349400006,
-0.0368458182,
0.025515981,
-0.0310543552,
0.0087402714,
2.777593739e-34,
0.0223250054,
0.0112043079,
0.0461268947,
0.0266097076,
0.0162595212,
-0.0221145824,
0.0437181443,
0.0285517741,
0.0029795091,
-0.0543956272,
-0.0200364105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.00113v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.00113v2 | Three Bricks to Consolidate Watermarks for Large Language Models | 2023-07-26T17:56:36 | 2023-11-08T18:56:19 | Pierre Fernandez, Antoine Chaffin, Karim Tit, Vivien Chappelier, Teddy Furon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The task of discerning between generated and natural texts is increasingly
challenging. In this context, watermarking emerges as a promising technique for
ascribing generated text to a specific model. It alters the sampling generation
process so as to leave an invisible trace in the generated output, facilitating
later detection. This research consolidates watermarks for large language
models based on three theoretical and empirical considerations. First, we
introduce new statistical tests that offer robust theoretical guarantees which
remain valid even at low false-positive rates (less than 10$^{\text{-6}}$).
Second, we compare the effectiveness of watermarks using classical benchmarks
in the field of natural language processing, gaining insights into their
real-world applicability. Third, we develop advanced detection schemes for
scenarios where access to the LLM is available, as well as multi-bit
watermarking. | [
0.0109072085,
0.0815756693,
-0.0285747908,
0.0614295527,
-0.0552734882,
-0.0041641677,
0.0080516431,
0.0692943335,
0.0070272759,
-0.0622896291,
0.0087755676,
-0.0233124997,
0.0058968826,
0.0145554319,
0.0546095558,
-0.0014741063,
0.03556633,
-0.0256292094,
-0.0038656471,
0.0166733973,
-0.02097518,
-0.0010438456,
0.0773252472,
0.0119368052,
-0.0084491903,
-0.0003614472,
0.017885631,
0.0209526103,
-0.0042310921,
-0.0231047161,
-0.0566935986,
0.0626235157,
-0.0211709514,
0.114112936,
0.0000017562,
-0.0487848781,
-0.0486699492,
0.0425206982,
-0.0541010313,
0.0450435877,
0.0508634932,
0.000297423,
-0.0364707746,
0.0116654094,
-0.0044390094,
0.0545992814,
0.0472758897,
0.045186609,
0.0537010767,
0.0512313694,
-0.0163968448,
0.0102289338,
0.0418325439,
0.0179413445,
-0.0028462731,
0.0113024851,
0.0298332199,
0.0467508882,
-0.0135084465,
-0.0004634635,
0.0203025825,
0.0753140897,
-0.0059640817,
-0.0313449539,
-0.0591839887,
0.0106249955,
-0.0221451987,
0.0155014163,
0.0039448715,
0.022931328,
-0.0499811396,
-0.0444046445,
0.0260670763,
-0.036915902,
0.0031506582,
0.0373062305,
-0.0182227362,
0.0477846712,
-0.0079804426,
0.0398915745,
0.0345168188,
-0.0230454076,
0.0592235811,
-0.0055752499,
-0.0034191769,
0.0788580477,
0.0474142171,
-0.0039767404,
-0.0321654826,
-0.0056258584,
-0.0312983431,
-0.0784581155,
0.0303724222,
-0.0247069504,
0.0447799526,
-0.0009580564,
-0.0999386609,
-0.0357849076,
0.0072936811,
-0.0295943655,
0.0845498219,
0.0104178237,
-0.0197214801,
0.0410541557,
-0.0538850948,
0.0548101813,
-0.0596446544,
0.0220900401,
0.0234859679,
0.0152072124,
-0.0118775759,
-0.0367364548,
-0.0387774892,
0.0164181534,
-0.0379207507,
-0.0188149717,
0.006404323,
0.0304530319,
-0.0036502508,
0.0207118038,
-0.0307996012,
-0.0599691197,
-0.0001744568,
0.0134552969,
0.0274933074,
-0.0526162237,
0.0249131545,
0.0113374619,
-0.0246189907,
-0.0745221898,
-0.0108045656,
0.0413022116,
0.0288371854,
0.0040161447,
-0.0017960327,
0.0800300315,
0.028893996,
-0.0290221907,
-0.0265305657,
-0.0623675138,
-0.0165044945,
-0.0122440932,
0.0182541702,
-0.0672980547,
-0.0324311852,
-0.0239809416,
0.0131952958,
-0.0535147414,
0.0005771825,
0.0151451454,
-0.0117502213,
0.0528005064,
-0.0412792638,
-0.0163783971,
-0.0342794806,
-0.0150107732,
0.0072679925,
0.0814271569,
0.0583709739,
0.0062148347,
0.082447648,
-0.0069277599,
0.0166079774,
0.0755992159,
0.0098243328,
0.0250872225,
-0.0262487121,
-0.0407587849,
0.051636681,
-0.0334593952,
0.010992269,
0.0696959421,
-0.030470442,
-0.0432429723,
0.0440845713,
0.066978097,
-0.0243023932,
-0.002846946,
0.0156975016,
0.0114802672,
0.0496488027,
0.0398334712,
-0.0021297664,
-0.047562167,
-0.0435745195,
-0.0104577066,
0.035592027,
-0.0287226085,
0.0121232457,
0.0021245487,
-0.0575079024,
-0.0079341466,
-0.012297973,
-0.0416671894,
0.0148500185,
0.016674716,
-0.0360348597,
0.0472581275,
-0.0103315804,
-0.0213615149,
0.0242048353,
-0.0819711313,
0.0419953987,
0.0256796889,
0.0701011494,
-0.010383267,
0.0765268728,
-0.0003153946,
-0.0465820059,
0.066911228,
-0.0402906314,
-0.0156160956,
0.0316421352,
0.0095185908,
-0.014606026,
-0.0188747048,
0.0374692343,
0.0336002111,
0.0329639353,
0.0175730456,
0.0258048084,
-0.0557881035,
-0.0232856218,
0.0249984246,
-0.0174768306,
-0.023101544,
0.0047358377,
-0.0443480648,
0.042945914,
0.0169508513,
-0.054102473,
0.034102466,
-0.0032245799,
-0.0213524383,
-0.0263032131,
-0.0225659516,
0.0239523072,
-0.0038230557,
0.0415069684,
-0.0361568779,
-0.0074218116,
0.0411115475,
0.0102965524,
-0.0388208255,
-0.0027052851,
-0.0614108555,
0.0400458314,
-0.0391913876,
0.0503689237,
-0.0140555315,
0.0419122428,
-0.029054651,
0.0311945248,
-0.0075662145,
0.0251552016,
0.032431379,
-0.0063434704,
0.0297069289,
-0.0303453971,
-0.0249504745,
0.0016151584,
-0.0342702977,
-0.0017123633,
0.0122271487,
-0.0075781643,
-0.01867163,
-0.0266390443,
-0.0238800459,
0.0099554984,
-0.0117908129,
0.0495379902,
0.0092752557,
-0.0346999429,
-0.0023299907,
0.003412633,
-0.0070447177,
-0.0765193105,
0.048657462,
0.0282821991,
0.0472898595,
-0.0245951861,
-0.0351268426,
-0.0323038585,
-0.0255921576,
0.0018294207,
0.0778276101,
0.0086929277,
-0.0496225767,
-0.0981854349,
0.0410007052,
-0.0262534898,
0.0036446129,
0.01546429,
0.0130707491,
0.0038718465,
-0.0139031699,
-0.0023924957,
0.0299660936,
-0.0113019189,
-0.0244156048,
0.0420909859,
0.0177241061,
-0.0348456763,
-0.0444547869,
-0.0129555883,
0.0061415178,
-0.008522843,
-0.0439287126,
0.0378867611,
0.0385031477,
0.0013284204,
-0.0061062095,
0.0049318611,
0.035124559,
-0.0128399497,
-0.0184902307,
0.0078249341,
-0.0343597718,
-0.0268752594,
0.0575776175,
-0.0153772738,
-0.0680984557,
-0.0117233107,
-0.0806393027,
0.022974072,
-0.000949025,
-0.0049113887,
0.008691933,
0.0412223078,
0.0036690894,
0.0099361381,
0.0326190665,
-0.0234891027,
-0.007103242,
-0.0257522818,
0.0669977888,
-0.0522962771,
-0.0227065012,
-0.0418428034,
0.0356179625,
-0.0024439509,
0.011566842,
-0.0338855162,
-0.0471542329,
-0.0194791984,
0.0260706395,
0.0485984869,
-0.0266631022,
0.0170321632,
0.0200160667,
0.0175598208,
0.0370179079,
0.0135848299,
0.0026262514,
-0.0562628247,
0.0999369398,
0.0256876498,
-0.0543420762,
0.0559734106,
-0.0185220577,
-0.0156434458,
0.0515477359,
0.0166097395,
0.0570276156,
-0.002308415,
-0.0100984536,
0.0393817648,
-0.007524645,
-0.0224944279,
0.0323611759,
0.0132075604,
-0.0432979316,
0.0185433254,
0.0844913796,
0.0323146172,
0.0167441592,
0.0121628689,
0.018943524,
0.0165108778,
0.01352775,
-0.0207518432,
-0.0894133672,
-0.0153951198,
0.0615742467,
-0.0017076838,
-0.0440976694,
0.0085341502,
-0.0261877179,
-0.1047108769,
0.0255409498,
0.0079793949,
-0.0090600681,
0.0002347336,
-0.0615886897,
-0.0088975942,
0.0413768366,
0.0015574069,
-0.047252126,
0.0166396555,
-0.0198646318,
0.0212641899,
-0.0284738708,
-0.067103982,
0.0015351981,
-0.0370757319,
0.0238585137,
0.0678077713,
0.0444337912,
-0.0240557082,
-0.0179110561,
0.0216574576,
0.0086781541,
-0.0115687046,
-0.0041693882,
0.0479155369,
0.0180366039,
-0.0256781317,
-0.0162002705,
-0.0068692653,
0.0244499538,
-0.0171024874,
-0.0347570591,
0.0479197241,
0.0024341624,
-0.0395558998,
0.0045991647,
-0.0236659572,
0.0181875806,
0.0633371994,
0.0227995273,
0.0057275328,
-0.0253701899,
-0.039801091,
0.0435491689,
-0.0264048278,
-0.0495222658,
-0.0095593333,
-0.059163589,
-0.0203451924,
-0.0719999298,
0.0379991531,
-0.0399184562,
0.0512164943,
0.0424913205,
0.0200260933,
0.0283827409,
-0.0453662351,
-0.0353385769,
-0.0005354035,
-0.1199299544,
0.0268971846,
-0.0529254489,
0.008360533,
-0.0069187824,
-0.006894886,
-0.0337633006,
0.0445590727,
-0.1023912355,
-0.0796356127,
0.0014522363,
0.0041380492,
0.0312254708,
-0.00685971,
-0.0023515837,
-0.046540197,
0.0259346142,
0.0329269208,
-0.0025274784,
0.0306014009,
0.0362518057,
-0.0323151164,
-0.013507626,
0.0190908797,
-0.0469879843,
-0.0029785158,
0.0485800244,
-0.0050691473,
-0.0228063501,
-0.01765294,
0.0110205961,
0.0852344632,
0.02631611,
-0.0224020425,
0.0016313366,
0.0048837285,
0.0041226409,
-0.0439949371,
-0.0196003541,
-0.0418854915,
0.0264069848,
0.0107279196,
-0.0305699464,
-0.0217494257,
0.0255363826,
-0.018645972,
0.020819813,
-0.0177445877,
-0.0140115013,
-0.0215024408,
0.0155776646,
0.0041885958,
-0.008067322,
0.0128542166,
0.0409455486,
0.0219160877,
0.0370265916,
0.0003371869,
-0.0061047385,
0.0127772903,
0.0067591979,
-0.0148258582,
0.029004883,
-0.0680650324,
-0.0102293259,
-0.030499313,
0.0256724004,
0.0407774858,
0.0011468482,
0.0507737659,
-0.0513703749,
-0.0203325767,
-0.041741956,
0.0277905203,
0.0060353111,
-0.0528113842,
-0.0240137372,
-0.0188087709,
-0.0593124069,
0.0378953591,
0.0366467461,
0.0534882657,
0.0553175919,
-0.0164954104,
-0.0472721532,
-0.0107049132,
-0.02233487,
0.0181253329,
-0.0111007495,
-0.0166417286,
-0.0049500964,
-0.074142769,
-0.071120359,
0.0138064586,
0.0156208882,
0.0200900044,
0.0045105587,
-0.0473774374,
0.0297068581,
0.0250358339,
0.0049075144,
-0.0313608162,
-0.0037570482,
0.0149135953,
-0.0119405407,
-0.0146618467,
-5.431402505e-33,
-0.0325018205,
-0.0453147553,
-0.0524789765,
-0.0377245583,
0.0337565802,
0.0491842777,
-0.0246853363,
-0.0160406474,
0.0267278645,
-0.0213774908,
-0.0089524249,
0.0121364091,
0.0191025324,
-0.0164587721,
-0.0465942249,
-0.0011417433,
0.057728827,
0.0035209865,
-0.0480493903,
-0.0116351955,
0.0547146015,
-0.0446661785,
0.0335770324,
-0.0393191874,
0.029920347,
-0.0361463949,
-0.0271748919,
-0.0223744977,
-0.0331309773,
0.0622094162,
-0.0287748184,
0.001850973,
-0.0111615416,
-0.0178815965,
-0.0526752025,
-0.0192765817,
-0.0351025127,
-0.0122118844,
0.0256407838,
0.0196717493,
0.0088664582,
-0.0578599535,
0.0194209963,
-0.0129789095,
-0.0367342532,
0.0306649189,
-0.0025119148,
-0.0074134939,
-0.0247755256,
-0.0473760702,
-0.025828952,
0.0393363982,
-0.0146390572,
0.0358748883,
0.056677267,
0.0021533428,
0.0361022092,
0.0116867013,
-0.0478290543,
0.004570195,
0.0476787128,
0.0313755907,
0.0592047647,
0.0070655681,
0.0141267357,
0.0563136339,
0.0005266606,
-0.0085354922,
0.0267501958,
-0.0160045568,
0.0393800139,
0.0144161563,
0.0607206561,
0.0462704822,
0.0867653117,
0.0151940957,
-0.0015073339,
0.0270315427,
-0.0257667452,
-0.0366811007,
0.0371324383,
0.0127310865,
-0.0298956614,
-0.0169439651,
-0.0881957859,
-0.053974919,
-0.0077084647,
0.0148605229,
0.0416279212,
0.0061629764,
-0.0382828414,
-0.009585727,
0.0349874683,
-0.0657484233,
-0.0453282408,
-0.010051108,
-0.0154674491,
0.0343319774,
-0.0041707116,
0.0249016415,
0.0192895662,
-0.0137058562,
0.0413786843,
-0.0343802199,
0.0490656458,
-0.0143191414,
0.0236942191,
0.0295869429,
-0.0859884471,
0.0300042722,
-0.0109573137,
-0.0008019201,
0.0178047791,
-0.0006647662,
0.0335604213,
-0.0343025327,
0.0223308727,
-0.032394927,
0.0360232815,
-0.0073101707,
0.0040063267,
0.0283128303,
-0.0309131462,
0.0239355601,
-0.0045619542,
0.0164665431,
-0.0247928202,
0.0617388375,
0.0735858008,
-0.0001970189,
-0.008055333,
0.0008216728,
2.393e-7,
0.0256368406,
0.0212845746,
0.0604963973,
0.0253596995,
0.0306629241,
0.0308616273,
-0.0108295986,
-0.0007766507,
-0.0342460163,
-0.0157004651,
-0.0562849008,
-0.0247897319,
0.0665637255,
0.0083813285,
-0.0384886526,
0.0187882781,
-0.0324099883,
0.018668646,
-0.0539043359,
-0.0282733031,
0.0140216453,
0.0848384127,
0.0052085575,
-0.0172271729,
-0.0007701743,
-0.0691811591,
0.0423248336,
-0.035688512,
0.0126947984,
0.0115167825,
0.0298052188,
0.0104728909,
0.0318204239,
0.011568673,
-0.0306707546,
-0.008957915,
0.0167123619,
0.0481060557,
0.0132774897,
0.0475783683,
-0.0556560047,
-0.0512002259,
-0.0148605248,
-0.0122857224,
0.0596068762,
0.0840987563,
-0.0202235207,
-0.092435278,
-0.0199131183,
-0.0629300848,
0.0299700331,
-0.0044616507,
-0.0090543739,
0.0151422294,
-0.0224440098,
0.0377922691,
-0.0229565259,
-0.0376948565,
-0.0252604205,
-0.0598377697,
-0.0257201158,
-0.044363331,
-0.0365160033,
0.0007624331,
0.0515897088,
-0.0923325717,
0.0181573741,
2.646062809e-34,
0.003213759,
-0.0319464132,
0.0053242012,
0.0484438092,
0.0499006696,
0.0136163402,
0.0020931184,
0.0181898084,
-0.0063993377,
-0.066747874,
0.015622816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14334v1 | Towards Generalist Biomedical AI | 2023-07-26T17:52:22 | 2023-07-26T17:52:22 | Tao Tu, Shekoofeh Azizi, Danny Driess, Mike Schaekermann, Mohamed Amin, Pi-Chuan Chang, Andrew Carroll, Chuck Lau, Ryutaro Tanno, Ira Ktena, Basil Mustafa, Aakanksha Chowdhery, Yun Liu, Simon Kornblith, David Fleet, Philip Mansfield, Sushant Prakash, Renee Wong, Sunny Virmani, Christopher Semturs, S Sara Mahdavi, Bradley Green, Ewa Dominowska, Blaise Aguera y Arcas, Joelle Barral, Dale Webster, Greg S. Corrado, Yossi Matias, Karan Singhal, Pete Florence, Alan Karthikesalingam, Vivek Natarajan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Medicine is inherently multimodal, with rich data modalities spanning text,
imaging, genomics, and more. Generalist biomedical artificial intelligence (AI)
systems that flexibly encode, integrate, and interpret this data at scale can
potentially enable impactful applications ranging from scientific discovery to
care delivery. To enable the development of these models, we first curate
MultiMedBench, a new multimodal biomedical benchmark. MultiMedBench encompasses
14 diverse tasks such as medical question answering, mammography and
dermatology image interpretation, radiology report generation and
summarization, and genomic variant calling. We then introduce Med-PaLM
Multimodal (Med-PaLM M), our proof of concept for a generalist biomedical AI
system. Med-PaLM M is a large multimodal generative model that flexibly encodes
and interprets biomedical data including clinical language, imaging, and
genomics with the same set of model weights. Med-PaLM M reaches performance
competitive with or exceeding the state of the art on all MultiMedBench tasks,
often surpassing specialist models by a wide margin. We also report examples of
zero-shot generalization to novel medical concepts and tasks, positive transfer
learning across tasks, and emergent zero-shot medical reasoning. To further
probe the capabilities and limitations of Med-PaLM M, we conduct a radiologist
evaluation of model-generated (and human) chest X-ray reports and observe
encouraging performance across model scales. In a side-by-side ranking on 246
retrospective chest X-rays, clinicians express a pairwise preference for
Med-PaLM M reports over those produced by radiologists in up to 40.50% of
cases, suggesting potential clinical utility. While considerable work is needed
to validate these models in real-world use cases, our results represent a
milestone towards the development of generalist biomedical AI systems. | [
0.0090965107,
0.0644716397,
0.0043978514,
-0.034074191,
-0.0161425527,
0.0194287896,
0.014769339,
0.0216598734,
-0.0264639705,
0.0099050477,
-0.0165009797,
-0.0394096188,
0.003565042,
0.0765271708,
0.0311183631,
-0.074417606,
0.0461126976,
0.030822305,
0.0155088492,
-0.0114620561,
-0.0242519695,
-0.0062837084,
-0.016104592,
0.0567176528,
-0.0183351822,
-0.0071489052,
0.0007000179,
0.0101248324,
0.0457155183,
-0.0470180921,
-0.033593744,
0.0016626971,
0.0115022138,
0.0159473829,
0.0000019848,
-0.0454483889,
-0.0060435701,
0.0374614745,
-0.0120710488,
-0.0670156479,
0.0416450948,
-0.0579366647,
0.0012587532,
-0.0138879213,
-0.0376840346,
-0.0426343568,
0.0525245368,
0.006281124,
0.0600096658,
0.0479838103,
-0.0237668362,
-0.0013250737,
0.0487966277,
-0.0078987814,
0.0448569991,
-0.0378532559,
-0.0036282528,
0.0184805244,
0.0633786842,
-0.0016667416,
-0.0184812546,
0.0653477088,
0.0193918012,
0.0193726961,
0.046526473,
0.0822933167,
0.0105738267,
-0.0290102251,
-0.0131728761,
0.086531207,
-0.0177711137,
0.0098534422,
-0.0079987366,
0.0031674707,
-0.0091233645,
0.0098286895,
-0.067186594,
0.0219732933,
-0.0293076746,
-0.0073704906,
-0.0189584941,
-0.0337318331,
0.0353954881,
-0.0024033547,
-0.0291179772,
-0.004976016,
0.01512306,
0.0130813289,
0.0219944343,
0.0045602312,
-0.0054457802,
-0.04888447,
0.005842322,
0.0679368228,
-0.0630823225,
-0.0073316577,
-0.0181339141,
-0.0375549383,
0.0528105274,
-0.0113573549,
0.0568368882,
0.0124405157,
-0.0550738908,
0.0519379377,
-0.0202596616,
0.0000874362,
-0.061186526,
0.0753084198,
-0.0305766221,
-0.031965211,
-0.0696021467,
-0.0112305572,
0.0115368059,
0.0395533219,
-0.0082057388,
-0.0251843408,
-0.0614141561,
-0.001621554,
-0.0174580719,
0.0051781968,
0.0196260922,
0.0814598724,
-0.034008529,
0.017679736,
-0.0069636041,
0.0524268299,
-0.0367730148,
0.0044691628,
0.0100938436,
-0.0474813171,
-0.0036946684,
0.0062194639,
0.01117808,
-0.0069693751,
0.0115119452,
0.0807492957,
-0.0345152058,
-0.0095033068,
0.0190976188,
-0.054024104,
-0.0157738961,
-0.062370427,
0.0562167354,
-0.0543455966,
0.0456802361,
0.0130250594,
0.01232321,
-0.0145944078,
-0.01093583,
-0.0068531078,
-0.0219051205,
0.0741774738,
-0.0173162054,
-0.0083089834,
0.046594359,
0.0354952216,
-0.02183377,
0.0116743166,
0.0300176237,
-0.0142212324,
-0.0060841339,
-0.0225312021,
0.0153291952,
-0.0137138283,
0.0195870176,
-0.0584790744,
0.0093477182,
-0.0201749019,
-0.0248152018,
0.0809135064,
0.0079524191,
0.0352928787,
-0.0243654307,
-0.0315115899,
0.0498003289,
0.0518248156,
0.0123206666,
0.0200847052,
0.0650031045,
-0.0666035637,
-0.0324541926,
-0.0153799821,
-0.0151309762,
0.0555697456,
-0.0107066631,
0.003897117,
-0.0098519297,
0.0082522444,
-0.0240072217,
-0.0372789577,
-0.0120861847,
-0.0232995301,
-0.0247973818,
-0.0023156013,
0.0544192716,
-0.0052848873,
-0.0271892752,
-0.0146997925,
0.0248159617,
-0.0043781018,
-0.0209164452,
-0.0627782568,
-0.0032797621,
0.0523144901,
0.0411193557,
-0.0442894697,
-0.0514670685,
-0.0144566763,
-0.0025344261,
0.0120917698,
0.030114159,
-0.0224240664,
0.05139881,
-0.0272591058,
-0.0272167511,
-0.0003618084,
0.0113785481,
0.0149309281,
-0.007393931,
0.0116560608,
-0.0406395085,
-0.0312364437,
0.0298702754,
0.0318029672,
-0.0509002805,
-0.0155726708,
0.0217646565,
-0.0160169136,
0.0488905907,
0.0106840041,
-0.0207624063,
0.0185702592,
0.023304332,
-0.0418654643,
-0.0692661554,
0.0172407031,
-0.0377062373,
-0.0195296239,
0.0131324595,
-0.0973379686,
-0.009201372,
0.0042857723,
-0.053307116,
-0.0396733135,
0.0094802529,
-0.040189378,
-0.0133827012,
-0.0053333309,
-0.012604815,
0.0440626815,
0.0204066709,
-0.0095833102,
0.0339897387,
-0.0257767364,
-0.0368412063,
0.0268777311,
-0.0253270585,
0.0093116416,
-0.0451637655,
-0.0301448945,
0.0221431628,
0.0158134755,
0.0014907767,
-0.0051943678,
-0.003762743,
-0.0227913111,
0.0264724251,
-0.1171645001,
0.0185747389,
0.0546717718,
-0.0208214987,
0.0167646073,
0.0161987226,
0.0374080166,
-0.0206322633,
-0.0450811833,
0.0082616331,
0.0728136525,
0.0155662857,
0.0704820827,
0.0440544225,
0.0358991921,
-0.0449779369,
-0.0105440598,
-0.0376530997,
0.0516540818,
0.0212452915,
0.0339713469,
0.0132675786,
-0.0260284599,
-0.0723666698,
0.0214639194,
-0.0000970073,
-0.0079121701,
0.068346262,
-0.0447950438,
-0.029731689,
0.0852287486,
-0.0110601792,
0.0217364933,
0.017260449,
0.0053948527,
-0.0326408781,
0.0082565844,
-0.0080168694,
-0.0295716319,
0.0294538718,
-0.0381464884,
-0.0324394666,
0.071624063,
0.0257546157,
0.0018324866,
-0.0351790115,
0.0033530402,
0.0134723363,
-0.0423829779,
-0.0415784456,
0.0399622843,
-0.0062607965,
0.0400008447,
-0.0353674963,
-0.0408153348,
0.1052550748,
0.042247951,
0.0190040767,
-0.0089120269,
0.0137549089,
-0.010928289,
0.055961132,
-0.0043187505,
0.0546536855,
0.0138375284,
0.0191725343,
-0.0374950208,
0.0055469424,
-0.0167527646,
-0.0478175208,
0.0091555426,
-0.0322848856,
0.0062777069,
-0.0004235525,
-0.0554682575,
-0.0367915519,
0.0283148326,
-0.0043079793,
0.0304892268,
-0.0064365086,
-0.0009361934,
-0.0534634478,
-0.0138610769,
0.0261206962,
0.0288723838,
0.0036890635,
-0.0418538563,
-0.0098713823,
0.0353722349,
0.0425332971,
0.0319259576,
-0.0054524266,
-0.0285530668,
-0.0024995955,
0.0613142215,
-0.0231067184,
0.0163911507,
-0.035533566,
0.0250504706,
-0.0311685633,
0.0219513215,
-0.0204555281,
0.0109421518,
0.0362131335,
-0.0481479689,
0.0004810614,
0.0514017344,
0.0156615414,
-0.0205838718,
0.018177025,
0.0086223474,
-0.0195280705,
-0.0030568053,
0.0367761441,
-0.0787594989,
-0.0496091396,
-0.0264727231,
0.0164851733,
-0.0299703572,
-0.0454582572,
0.0195510983,
-0.0575507544,
0.0552016683,
-0.0100532509,
-0.0589531213,
-0.0086730104,
-0.0195649527,
0.0080388868,
-0.02180757,
-0.0553963967,
-0.0153802652,
0.025834607,
-0.0198801421,
0.0096414788,
0.0286329798,
-0.0712512508,
0.0229006112,
-0.0277436059,
-0.009792923,
0.0473652706,
0.0444112942,
-0.0063854558,
-0.0217684694,
-0.0110343909,
0.0861787125,
0.0232298318,
0.0026946617,
0.0738548338,
0.0163439848,
0.0009969041,
-0.0457050838,
0.054534398,
-0.0155231226,
-0.0017549838,
-0.0281252954,
0.0980344564,
-0.0142751765,
-0.042775996,
-0.0938076451,
0.0023998069,
0.0124310181,
0.0429151356,
-0.0097297663,
-0.011187084,
-0.0660671666,
-0.0202073678,
0.0767292455,
-0.0434653051,
-0.002962159,
0.0491524898,
-0.0198897887,
-0.0427198634,
-0.0871327296,
-0.0206534788,
0.0125881555,
0.0272773337,
0.0048690275,
-0.0342858844,
-0.0071930694,
-0.0077944417,
-0.063779898,
0.0112124579,
0.0160003789,
0.0041755969,
-0.0203180686,
-0.0434419885,
0.0537832677,
-0.042280864,
-0.0164119303,
0.0478214957,
-0.0377486795,
-0.0050385245,
-0.0592090711,
0.0900978446,
0.025529312,
-0.0243210364,
-0.0055945935,
-0.0341472067,
0.0801778808,
0.0568976961,
-0.025818238,
0.004054348,
0.017517304,
-0.0463872999,
-0.0219759587,
0.006411205,
-0.0039159888,
0.0379771516,
-0.0098178526,
0.0132723302,
-0.0147096543,
-0.0059950585,
0.0236406121,
0.0320797451,
0.0022209559,
-0.0276762918,
-0.0095053213,
-0.0086923037,
-0.0199228693,
0.0028537384,
0.0264069028,
-0.0426926427,
-0.0091068484,
0.0158383176,
0.0091377171,
0.0043411539,
0.0097129382,
-0.0235038269,
0.0085540386,
-0.0500283167,
0.0101163657,
0.0600522906,
-0.0003196622,
0.0183381103,
-0.0013733638,
-0.0103819482,
-0.002061157,
-0.0337278582,
0.014880036,
-0.0147737591,
0.0465060472,
0.0262476467,
0.0486384556,
-0.0166248437,
0.0390019864,
-0.0554905608,
-0.0279546287,
-0.0094455909,
0.0494465455,
0.0462967493,
0.0509663336,
0.0084895901,
-0.0025536835,
-0.0112584736,
-0.0179574881,
0.0565494522,
-0.0263666287,
-0.006378443,
0.0290516447,
0.0265251193,
0.0503485054,
-0.023966752,
0.0788258612,
-0.0250280201,
0.0722207129,
-0.0393117815,
-0.0461780094,
-0.0798586011,
-0.0233671926,
0.0501549393,
0.0346509553,
-0.0013998862,
0.0169131998,
-0.0590424128,
-0.0561007932,
0.0176528972,
0.0321361013,
0.0025166469,
-0.0149696385,
0.0562911853,
0.0335790664,
0.0042961719,
-0.0439063385,
-0.0183268301,
0.03440696,
-0.0197440684,
-0.0213966295,
0.010241284,
-6.213563956e-33,
0.0010137329,
-0.012084078,
0.0416331813,
-0.052910585,
-0.0001353473,
0.0328400508,
-0.0629886612,
-0.0108293528,
-0.0098548643,
0.0213066544,
-0.0291397367,
-0.0084849875,
-0.0121213961,
0.0310128927,
0.0219140649,
-0.0122579997,
0.0263312515,
-0.0158426985,
-0.0061562033,
0.035296388,
0.0149531476,
0.039236933,
0.0253966507,
-0.0672120005,
-0.0287823472,
0.0413494781,
-0.0110181812,
-0.0214590505,
-0.0315099657,
0.0362828188,
-0.0430037826,
0.0139257358,
0.0419746265,
-0.0279621016,
-0.0156811662,
-0.0057048919,
-0.0898004621,
-0.0029318912,
-0.0116961664,
-0.0260981247,
-0.0725615472,
-0.0254400354,
0.0610753521,
-0.0291301496,
0.0160053615,
-0.0596359596,
0.0454316363,
-0.0298208725,
-0.0082049016,
-0.0509259216,
-0.0579340421,
0.030018365,
-0.0215882398,
-0.0262837317,
-0.0388571993,
0.0042131809,
-0.0241974369,
0.0720710382,
0.0071714716,
0.0101821879,
0.0445446111,
-0.0361966379,
0.0392307304,
-0.0153162098,
-0.0057014697,
0.0401414074,
0.0560444444,
-0.0720319897,
-0.0402338393,
0.0300707594,
-0.0142396158,
0.0693200752,
0.0068392167,
0.0782890245,
0.0622834861,
0.0189178679,
-0.0964812487,
0.0515779965,
-0.0532514155,
0.0533695072,
0.0040649781,
0.0162334014,
-0.0078183655,
0.0208689738,
0.0052360171,
-0.0392647311,
-0.0304430705,
-0.0234359521,
0.0245765727,
-0.0142723862,
-0.0162338093,
0.0498587713,
0.0448416658,
-0.038709376,
0.0208175387,
-0.0091399616,
0.029474197,
0.0327096283,
-0.0149992583,
-0.0119066676,
-0.0179072041,
-0.0387528278,
0.0690857247,
0.009394329,
0.0724511668,
0.0240788721,
0.039768327,
0.0240664594,
-0.0171130858,
-0.0156691801,
-0.026283564,
-0.01032943,
-0.0063306238,
0.0378330275,
0.0312481597,
0.0155981863,
-0.0232195184,
0.0290405452,
-0.019012792,
0.0442002714,
-0.0554935299,
-0.0566553883,
-0.0003392888,
0.0063846866,
-0.0557577647,
-0.0020166396,
-0.0428081341,
-0.0152499322,
0.0389623195,
-0.082984522,
-0.0406238809,
0.0463141315,
2.872e-7,
0.0713726804,
0.0145600876,
0.0202813298,
-0.0229592472,
0.0292692687,
0.0288325902,
-0.0280652568,
0.0310313459,
-0.0264838506,
-0.0299183894,
0.0317421146,
0.0463943891,
-0.0067863683,
0.0434896685,
-0.0274649374,
-0.0373002887,
-0.0402111672,
0.0108687012,
-0.0071492284,
0.005168159,
0.0542316213,
0.0556118563,
-0.0143753327,
-0.0742644891,
0.0779189244,
0.0047850721,
0.068651408,
0.0042023119,
0.0458808169,
-0.0072149043,
0.0062074624,
0.0018542252,
0.0141280266,
0.0308167897,
0.0178133082,
-0.0587919727,
0.0401620381,
0.0752753913,
-0.0621206909,
-0.0184387285,
0.0349162184,
0.0144482832,
0.0124592986,
-0.0435052589,
0.0626699775,
-0.0409869589,
-0.0429378077,
-0.0494263768,
-0.0359431766,
0.0190993268,
0.0471545719,
-0.0567251407,
-0.0143644819,
0.038449429,
0.019999234,
0.0156038012,
-0.0305754356,
-0.0714647546,
-0.0145004764,
0.042911835,
-0.0426347815,
-0.0137521978,
0.0188039299,
-0.0370758623,
0.0149423741,
-0.0706581622,
-0.0366580188,
2.188315207e-34,
0.0157088581,
0.0078188758,
-0.0033957851,
-0.009119479,
0.0270084534,
-0.0169339515,
-0.0500863977,
-0.0182719845,
0.0182592329,
-0.0289247967,
-0.0364002511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.15717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.15717v1 | Utilizing Large Language Models for Natural Interface to Pharmacology Databases | 2023-07-26T17:50:11 | 2023-07-26T17:50:11 | Hong Lu, Chuan Li, Yinheng Li, Jie Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | The drug development process necessitates that pharmacologists undertake
various tasks, such as reviewing literature, formulating hypotheses, designing
experiments, and interpreting results. Each stage requires accessing and
querying vast amounts of information. In this abstract, we introduce a Large
Language Model (LLM)-based Natural Language Interface designed to interact with
structured information stored in databases. Our experiments demonstrate the
feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed framework. This framework can
generalize to query a wide range of pharmaceutical data and knowledge bases. | [
0.0360128209,
0.0545014404,
0.0072213467,
0.0324265361,
-0.0020050404,
0.0122362142,
0.0039835288,
0.0375193134,
0.0830095187,
-0.0345127322,
-0.013665027,
-0.0195070151,
-0.036992725,
0.0457161963,
0.0181782078,
-0.0147242006,
-0.0027959945,
-0.0164678246,
0.0335316621,
0.0234536249,
0.0037604214,
0.0270546321,
0.0127410721,
0.0037115139,
0.0349711031,
-0.0207064357,
0.0132306768,
-0.0237655248,
-0.0355494507,
-0.0848312601,
-0.0261881556,
0.0326172449,
0.0295866635,
-0.001537625,
0.0000016826,
-0.0686025098,
-0.0233287066,
0.0660776198,
-0.0353018418,
-0.0329230018,
0.0652128235,
-0.0322066322,
0.0150016546,
0.0029590726,
-0.0333399028,
-0.0398326628,
0.0454914384,
0.0471704341,
0.0203066971,
0.0324670114,
-0.0137848519,
-0.0601044446,
0.0272005033,
-0.0049871579,
0.0288446788,
-0.0234585758,
0.0694556609,
0.0466961041,
0.107285209,
0.046748165,
0.0342359655,
0.0051425355,
-0.0549823903,
-0.0332133137,
0.0408110134,
0.0209599975,
-0.0029690983,
-0.0101915579,
-0.0024143818,
0.0347930305,
0.0326304957,
-0.0008530113,
0.0048752045,
0.0210150629,
0.001976578,
0.0072216745,
-0.0429193154,
0.0086310217,
-0.0027197886,
0.004257869,
0.0358575918,
-0.0070338184,
0.0171837676,
0.0139287664,
-0.0406945497,
0.021610938,
0.0076560928,
-0.0102054048,
0.0268706083,
-0.0420303531,
0.0244828276,
-0.0154317105,
0.0289728791,
0.0285355225,
-0.0283485129,
0.0554887541,
-0.0007557349,
-0.010630128,
0.0770656615,
-0.079032816,
-0.0075377771,
-0.0270518921,
0.0069276812,
0.0797181576,
-0.0023516142,
-0.0004205562,
-0.013610254,
-0.031430237,
-0.0191884544,
-0.0273536257,
-0.0633937344,
-0.0157157574,
-0.0425156616,
0.027404245,
-0.0330241732,
-0.0247702543,
-0.043100059,
0.0358579308,
0.013009185,
0.0095172981,
0.0084483121,
0.0145143801,
-0.0292615127,
0.0062503773,
-0.0634445623,
0.0159850866,
0.0332109965,
-0.017111266,
-0.0345672816,
-0.0624250099,
0.0357326977,
-0.0034053342,
0.0192538947,
-0.0165368356,
0.0071919686,
0.0821096227,
0.0381219611,
0.0076872096,
-0.063165471,
-0.0571135879,
0.0209028833,
-0.0187433716,
-0.0026073998,
-0.0639674067,
0.0590771101,
0.0306174662,
-0.0248332899,
-0.0459132046,
0.0049115652,
0.0280456878,
-0.0628689229,
0.085370563,
-0.0651696399,
-0.0246719699,
0.0201300941,
-0.0215299167,
0.0367792584,
0.0103694927,
-0.0348055437,
-0.0273489151,
0.0033999619,
-0.0118727479,
-0.0017980146,
-0.0236693658,
-0.0127107762,
-0.0514282621,
-0.0221525747,
0.0683769211,
0.0005008067,
0.06390322,
-0.0835985914,
0.0345415697,
-0.0065347101,
0.0041474495,
0.030169094,
0.0851190388,
0.0457318053,
0.0201295298,
-0.0057119336,
0.016330149,
0.001155391,
-0.0435697883,
-0.0256973635,
0.024879938,
-0.0275377259,
0.0205049943,
0.0086860657,
-0.0005148065,
0.0094657661,
-0.0224761851,
-0.0342983082,
-0.0168924574,
-0.0098500215,
-0.0070323478,
0.0640315562,
-0.0223046467,
-0.0205329526,
0.023080999,
0.0423160195,
-0.0133956512,
0.0061079096,
0.0116513548,
-0.0054669706,
0.1062106863,
0.0228371229,
-0.0541041829,
0.007305535,
-0.0016371126,
0.0039036998,
0.0377409831,
0.0010528507,
-0.0315135829,
-0.0266757384,
-0.0046779993,
0.0067894906,
0.027985096,
0.0072004246,
-0.0112988455,
-0.0205695592,
0.0209504347,
-0.0228150804,
-0.0307195056,
-0.0322444849,
0.0213457663,
-0.0210548565,
-0.0544029623,
-0.0080415448,
-0.0015804309,
-0.0191770718,
0.0486733504,
0.0054527912,
0.044624839,
0.0696112588,
-0.0555816889,
-0.0134081999,
-0.0710368082,
0.0908326283,
0.0124340486,
0.0160885546,
-0.0180348568,
0.0046742037,
-0.0600298122,
-0.0437976159,
-0.0251996536,
0.0164843779,
0.0030308254,
0.0434023887,
-0.0009492905,
0.0032923901,
0.0178959481,
0.0100954724,
-0.0717023686,
0.0155068673,
0.0535090007,
0.0177265275,
0.0505916178,
-0.068681255,
0.0062825405,
-0.0399936959,
0.0061192852,
0.0556700639,
0.0218205154,
0.0136154247,
0.0167250019,
-0.0281942561,
-0.0275480691,
-0.0024650616,
-0.0484087728,
0.0005282926,
0.0218245368,
0.0506685711,
0.0257134065,
0.0345624685,
-0.0064462298,
-0.0282585528,
-0.0487461425,
-0.0547287017,
-0.0079535972,
0.0116594527,
0.0404703058,
0.0698440224,
-0.0225616023,
-0.0416991748,
-0.0306190029,
-0.0366604142,
0.0408598408,
-0.0016642956,
-0.0552431867,
-0.0179125797,
-0.0086604161,
-0.0266021937,
0.0254521556,
0.009427188,
0.0354238786,
0.0058152601,
-0.0414499119,
0.0046956274,
0.0357515216,
-0.0521324463,
0.0047247401,
0.0524340272,
-0.0153042683,
-0.0102970377,
-0.0079294918,
-0.0169484541,
-0.0023243125,
-0.0034271209,
-0.0178979058,
0.0204026345,
0.0364933126,
0.0125631141,
0.0098283924,
0.0001422785,
0.0046868189,
-0.0193716325,
0.035884168,
-0.0371787362,
0.0135869421,
0.0270533729,
0.0346314348,
0.0180393718,
-0.0222059451,
0.0855024755,
-0.0459637716,
0.0268452037,
-0.0658143759,
-0.0192218572,
-0.0145383626,
0.0154199135,
0.014903551,
0.0085837534,
0.0169960558,
-0.023432415,
0.0329526216,
-0.0139993653,
0.0058205617,
-0.0277596377,
0.0678131357,
-0.0564417802,
0.0513395965,
-0.0222929139,
-0.0129957097,
-0.0191539377,
0.0102763744,
-0.0279377103,
-0.0094273323,
0.0535603985,
-0.0117218103,
-0.0116377315,
0.0487902202,
-0.0062978175,
0.0082913889,
0.0213596039,
-0.0326162726,
0.0216719545,
-0.0254902467,
0.0383184589,
-0.0391988531,
0.0197044332,
0.0240816213,
0.0559365563,
0.0465151034,
-0.0193757415,
-0.0298940148,
-0.005968261,
0.0116825979,
-0.0050377836,
-0.0680353492,
-0.035310287,
0.0318522342,
-0.0520214662,
-0.0577789322,
0.0381376781,
0.1064484715,
0.0239814725,
-0.0237931702,
-0.0141094346,
-0.0094220629,
-0.072438851,
-0.0121834883,
0.0590124056,
-0.0940037519,
-0.0135279549,
-0.0459852368,
0.0014081057,
0.0001561793,
-0.041918207,
-0.009116211,
-0.0647461191,
0.0320254117,
-0.0058071525,
-0.0328318626,
-0.0299901906,
-0.0538524538,
-0.0086779688,
-0.0034238999,
-0.0241199788,
0.0393143669,
-0.0232095737,
-0.0341983996,
-0.0222499054,
-0.0388952158,
-0.0541275181,
0.0015536596,
-0.0313515551,
0.0322241411,
0.0324722417,
0.0327257812,
0.0143507728,
0.0119748572,
-0.0236603525,
0.0023288468,
0.0083910059,
-0.0304540917,
0.035699375,
0.0142916413,
-0.0031934236,
-0.0606590323,
0.0396997556,
-0.0494993851,
0.0187209193,
-0.0520168245,
0.1059587374,
-0.0293801092,
0.0208674371,
-0.0619736351,
-0.0187636651,
0.0233656447,
0.0426266305,
-0.0082833776,
0.0016950181,
-0.0600125156,
-0.0116671994,
-0.0301108342,
0.0278909355,
-0.0372488089,
0.0463116765,
-0.0366673358,
0.0045699147,
-0.0373396389,
-0.0205683634,
0.081296429,
-0.0208251309,
0.007104022,
0.0692786351,
0.0506224297,
-0.0501491055,
-0.0093965624,
0.0397006646,
0.0087180566,
0.0453159586,
-0.0201139245,
-0.042096246,
0.0568604134,
-0.019005226,
-0.0003261959,
-0.0016837924,
-0.0090040676,
-0.051286798,
-0.0300064255,
-0.0068388139,
0.0196867604,
-0.0012530891,
-0.0202872753,
-0.0429384038,
0.005357828,
0.0033864717,
-0.0295413677,
-0.052892331,
-0.069525905,
0.0245528854,
0.0029928284,
0.0098738791,
-0.0642893761,
-0.0108055398,
-0.0278891642,
0.0177941378,
0.0057748561,
-0.0431189388,
0.0699650422,
0.0398590639,
0.0246609729,
0.0333332457,
0.0075667696,
-0.0146060837,
0.0328881629,
-0.0581690148,
-0.013845792,
0.0066185095,
-0.0069957646,
0.0253766682,
-0.0192505028,
0.0051078675,
0.0063861338,
-0.0606081299,
0.0057623917,
-0.0225265604,
0.0564501882,
-0.0012080554,
-0.0331087187,
0.080216758,
-0.0177074615,
-0.0188069157,
0.0089230807,
-0.0228664801,
0.042977985,
-0.0434777364,
0.0430253334,
-0.0194157753,
0.0025806718,
-0.031878911,
0.0077696061,
-0.0078950729,
-0.0763016343,
0.0020664004,
0.0198442563,
0.0460852236,
-0.0167879462,
0.0399129689,
-0.0394684933,
0.0033617446,
-0.0405882187,
0.0105079534,
0.0520916618,
-0.0003432782,
0.0656586215,
0.0172395892,
-0.0107922927,
-0.0554399528,
0.0778797939,
0.0347200669,
0.0088818856,
0.0010635068,
-0.0689618662,
-0.0138830505,
-0.0177007653,
0.0296610072,
0.0080951285,
-0.0797421262,
0.013663657,
-0.0404760614,
-0.0321711116,
0.0085443063,
0.0109635592,
-0.043136701,
-0.0365374945,
0.0172519106,
0.0568177477,
0.0684898496,
-0.0495493934,
-0.0393020622,
0.0297691654,
-0.0360492803,
-0.0426707491,
-0.0306825563,
-5.32619025e-33,
0.0072347554,
-0.0430020392,
0.0019411762,
-0.0023835832,
0.0410783924,
-0.0415331237,
-0.0158900339,
0.0042688292,
-0.0074509848,
0.0519306026,
-0.0023427729,
-0.0132817151,
0.0049847881,
0.0115920594,
0.0073812813,
-0.0156898871,
0.0070029059,
0.0401736982,
0.0402215272,
0.0018130192,
0.0142089482,
0.0375688858,
0.0317663103,
-0.0559567697,
0.0396117494,
0.0099933585,
0.0838936269,
0.0048114071,
0.0078776609,
0.0650328249,
-0.0196884461,
0.0597489849,
0.0239520818,
-0.0306932274,
-0.0243374184,
0.0012973702,
-0.0496244878,
0.0047368133,
0.0186455604,
0.0111177657,
0.0089413226,
0.006850116,
0.0471753739,
-0.0311331376,
-0.0168858431,
0.0426651388,
0.0257765893,
-0.0450433865,
-0.0409832299,
-0.0379469879,
-0.0615260005,
0.0269705541,
0.0091655347,
0.039545387,
-0.002225019,
-0.0168881807,
-0.0117581207,
0.0171203576,
-0.0018713729,
0.0048562777,
0.0322121456,
0.0335299,
0.0179904439,
0.0258724689,
0.0289403815,
0.0162145514,
0.0114932926,
-0.0099519985,
0.0201892927,
0.0287444703,
-0.0396617949,
0.0463990383,
0.0015210155,
0.0157513414,
0.0075092753,
0.0360473618,
-0.082682848,
0.0214123689,
-0.0617677644,
0.0412005447,
-0.014424013,
0.0463699363,
-0.0055881506,
-0.0420761071,
-0.0307446029,
0.0529146194,
-0.0524287336,
-0.0294769462,
0.0100727519,
-0.0436220355,
-0.0067936978,
0.0111415684,
0.0291078705,
-0.0220359024,
-0.0883909389,
0.021736512,
0.0217085797,
-0.0115354648,
-0.0334092528,
-0.019282002,
-0.0649629384,
0.0112766186,
-0.0042687729,
-0.0514812507,
-0.0138543043,
0.0227198061,
-0.0434050225,
-0.0320262834,
-0.0437364951,
0.0126083447,
-0.0165661313,
-0.0175073761,
0.0089105535,
0.0440780185,
0.0361506641,
0.0315954648,
0.0540059693,
0.091793105,
-0.0007314142,
-0.0406413637,
-0.0276287813,
-0.0237014946,
0.0352233127,
-0.0385416001,
-0.0387873761,
0.0308661014,
-0.0480650738,
0.028021872,
0.0376819484,
-0.0246772058,
-0.0058257454,
0.022744203,
2.477e-7,
0.087709479,
0.0407555476,
0.0141537394,
0.0654803514,
0.0191675518,
-0.0117834937,
-0.0140921939,
0.0194099862,
-0.032561101,
-0.0472856425,
0.0152984308,
-0.0085771335,
0.0187149197,
0.0287914444,
-0.0625752881,
-0.0233560316,
-0.0121229822,
-0.0715861917,
-0.1194893196,
-0.0218643043,
0.0817520991,
0.06546662,
-0.0409759954,
0.0162097272,
0.0194279943,
-0.0641870722,
0.0148441354,
-0.0248870421,
0.0121364193,
0.0552025884,
0.0493636429,
-0.0036787051,
0.002903352,
0.0599164031,
0.0006591587,
-0.0115451645,
-0.0652053505,
0.0543070771,
-0.0676089525,
0.0499057882,
0.0324466787,
-0.0806067064,
0.0137661481,
0.0056647812,
0.021420408,
-0.0391041338,
-0.0228300262,
0.0211444627,
0.0097734369,
-0.05773592,
0.0129941106,
-0.0192013923,
-0.0104594128,
0.0135644851,
0.0267513953,
0.0006599502,
0.0082557434,
-0.0344348177,
0.0124977408,
0.0398595594,
-0.0195662919,
-0.0031580729,
-0.0020760195,
-0.0352129824,
0.0170955993,
-0.0211074911,
0.0159215257,
2.107559893e-34,
0.0370342359,
0.0107438248,
0.0182712022,
0.0454855561,
0.0815242752,
0.0082688462,
-0.0150039624,
0.0037088268,
0.0040475805,
-0.1338090301,
-0.0022778157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14324v1 | Evaluating the Moral Beliefs Encoded in LLMs | 2023-07-26T17:42:43 | 2023-07-26T17:42:43 | Nino Scherrer, Claudia Shi, Amir Feder, David M. Blei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | This paper presents a case study on the design, administration,
post-processing, and evaluation of surveys on large language models (LLMs). It
comprises two components: (1) A statistical method for eliciting beliefs
encoded in LLMs. We introduce statistical measures and evaluation metrics that
quantify the probability of an LLM "making a choice", the associated
uncertainty, and the consistency of that choice. (2) We apply this method to
study what moral beliefs are encoded in different LLMs, especially in ambiguous
cases where the right choice is not obvious. We design a large-scale survey
comprising 680 high-ambiguity moral scenarios (e.g., "Should I tell a white
lie?") and 687 low-ambiguity moral scenarios (e.g., "Should I stop for a
pedestrian on the road?"). Each scenario includes a description, two possible
actions, and auxiliary labels indicating violated rules (e.g., "do not kill").
We administer the survey to 28 open- and closed-source LLMs. We find that (a)
in unambiguous scenarios, most models "choose" actions that align with
commonsense. In ambiguous cases, most models express uncertainty. (b) Some
models are uncertain about choosing the commonsense action because their
responses are sensitive to the question-wording. (c) Some models reflect clear
preferences in ambiguous scenarios. Specifically, closed-source models tend to
agree with each other. | [
0.0794049948,
0.0905135497,
-0.0250656549,
0.0313282833,
-0.0840139836,
-0.0017886187,
0.0084607294,
-0.0054795491,
0.0177520178,
-0.0626387298,
0.0006412059,
-0.0454175957,
-0.0063122339,
-0.0385180525,
-0.0129551552,
-0.0007559768,
0.021586068,
-0.0001557737,
0.0801515281,
-0.0198750328,
0.0065423683,
0.0408103764,
0.0468038544,
0.0128528085,
0.0236219224,
0.002645279,
-0.0068446416,
-0.0213757958,
0.0191008188,
-0.0222550072,
-0.0059644082,
0.0316099338,
0.03845248,
0.0129296491,
0.0000019805,
-0.0737870708,
0.0213759765,
-0.0161833633,
0.0205586776,
0.0602815039,
0.0875331685,
0.0421013646,
-0.0045797573,
-0.0165421478,
-0.0179137681,
0.0483372472,
0.0275808349,
0.0364711471,
-0.0098402826,
0.021105025,
0.00772093,
-0.0330994166,
-0.0002501482,
-0.0006714186,
-0.012370565,
-0.0044776346,
0.0481232107,
0.0416452773,
-0.0110547049,
0.0183059033,
-0.0006357979,
0.0236968547,
0.0142570985,
-0.0162333995,
-0.071951203,
-0.0184086803,
-0.004427467,
-0.0483764224,
-0.0058233119,
0.0416477509,
0.0347618796,
-0.0215340313,
0.0201177988,
-0.0204854961,
0.0335395634,
0.0266506653,
0.000428532,
0.0620693341,
-0.0108210891,
0.0194443725,
0.0304787513,
0.0060542487,
0.0032520595,
0.0483028553,
0.0206048004,
0.0397233553,
-0.0343029052,
-0.0081754299,
0.0010219873,
-0.0066354144,
-0.079308264,
-0.043232277,
-0.0000998507,
0.0080123385,
-0.0054766685,
0.0470885076,
0.0137526179,
0.0404863432,
0.0707135648,
-0.0762052834,
0.0408296287,
0.0315735526,
0.0100867562,
0.0186991468,
0.0223789066,
0.0093152653,
-0.0023662341,
0.0274977796,
-0.0306445397,
0.0415053368,
-0.0033425936,
-0.0084715886,
0.0241713095,
0.0243632197,
0.0191743542,
0.0447356552,
-0.0496405512,
-0.0119874468,
-0.0446179733,
0.0029910675,
-0.0322401598,
-0.004218142,
0.0152873993,
-0.0135697499,
-0.0551521927,
0.0216171425,
-0.0391458981,
0.0556034259,
-0.0213429946,
-0.0069195768,
0.0665828735,
-0.0322277695,
-0.018644968,
0.0030076352,
0.0206607319,
0.0789732039,
-0.0095425919,
0.0269512534,
-0.0340782516,
-0.0133294007,
-0.0531263463,
-0.0400156192,
-0.0546835549,
-0.0722043514,
0.0128046498,
0.0093281353,
-0.0088379402,
-0.0353126377,
0.0352701209,
0.0120636905,
-0.0481347814,
0.0211633947,
0.0531995073,
0.0398408696,
0.001576381,
0.0231005996,
0.0180979799,
0.0510627814,
0.0218073372,
0.0235756766,
0.0331070237,
-0.0023476013,
0.0168076791,
0.0046122461,
-0.0182382092,
0.0250950549,
-0.0201072805,
0.035434328,
-0.0167291518,
0.0181070212,
0.0288951006,
0.0647655204,
-0.0228656866,
-0.0250015762,
0.0585719347,
0.1094120815,
-0.0077090524,
-0.0267747231,
0.0183837041,
0.0234372634,
0.028157426,
-0.0036699739,
-0.0503920279,
0.0001721939,
0.00128162,
-0.0230739936,
-0.0494930558,
0.0471537262,
-0.0082746996,
-0.0225795712,
-0.0202208254,
0.0013461757,
0.0452375486,
0.0361053087,
0.0120253358,
-0.0518103652,
0.0086149769,
-0.024051981,
0.0247758962,
-0.0477923565,
-0.0131125106,
-0.0426955819,
0.0854471475,
0.0496943481,
0.0289663654,
0.0351027064,
-0.0106944647,
-0.0293798838,
-0.0125266248,
0.0153799979,
0.0450152829,
-0.0146808652,
-0.0038048362,
-0.0416561253,
-0.0288862679,
0.007454047,
-0.0071075871,
-0.0051571014,
-0.0302526839,
-0.013179468,
0.0167021882,
-0.0350007378,
-0.0215760563,
0.0184512958,
0.0315911397,
0.0340726413,
-0.0695002899,
-0.005869431,
0.0496233962,
-0.0076823146,
0.010604932,
-0.0180252902,
-0.0072692977,
0.0318835974,
-0.0010178464,
0.0009897706,
-0.0264445152,
0.0379274599,
0.0252800789,
-0.0574576631,
-0.0206906833,
0.0066190944,
-0.0107356012,
0.0367516987,
-0.0513513684,
-0.0232491624,
0.0186727382,
-0.0409256741,
0.0091479281,
-0.0790379569,
-0.0739929304,
-0.0352385752,
0.0441140234,
-0.0308912825,
0.0235393755,
-0.0113080498,
-0.0513450652,
0.0421950407,
-0.0197108034,
-0.0349785425,
0.0179908313,
-0.0145366658,
0.0332678817,
0.0512299202,
0.0549986623,
-0.0276965108,
-0.0601967722,
-0.0491946675,
-0.0287468527,
0.0385203548,
-0.0041019903,
-0.025550656,
-0.0216148719,
-0.0029477531,
0.0409929156,
-0.0354154967,
-0.0015077248,
0.0160701536,
0.0349791273,
-0.0052106571,
-0.0262029544,
-0.0291510001,
0.0123123275,
0.0027557262,
-0.0241187587,
-0.0062666358,
0.0307581499,
0.0059274742,
-0.0321003534,
0.051255852,
-0.0914202407,
-0.018844828,
0.0038038504,
-0.0778559074,
-0.0002808586,
0.0373175777,
-0.0060724271,
0.0619818568,
0.0350487083,
-0.0055652838,
0.0510229208,
0.0145555316,
-0.0840752423,
-0.0425994359,
-0.0093884673,
-0.0228086002,
-0.0347537845,
-0.0856332108,
-0.0205188319,
0.0646182001,
0.026210865,
0.0028439492,
-0.0332221873,
0.0101032648,
-0.0735853314,
-0.0529634245,
-0.0240926668,
-0.0662645623,
-0.000253576,
0.0808261484,
0.005048559,
-0.0653266683,
0.07606785,
0.0519024022,
0.0322849378,
-0.0151961725,
0.0322432704,
-0.0056212801,
0.0374321714,
-0.0002166738,
0.0357678384,
0.0070722285,
-0.0288969819,
-0.0410949141,
-0.0288149305,
0.0314146467,
-0.0603799298,
0.0438378677,
-0.039123334,
0.007308939,
0.0068761199,
-0.0493656993,
-0.0215722211,
-0.0784669518,
-0.038349513,
-0.0450678729,
0.0349054635,
0.0150020486,
0.0466252528,
-0.0075212508,
0.0324499942,
-0.0515787899,
0.0188086778,
0.0092463149,
-0.0036233463,
-0.0497445427,
0.0298421606,
-0.0094130868,
0.0683235154,
-0.0037434073,
0.002044125,
0.0551981777,
-0.0115955342,
0.0255217105,
0.0255893376,
0.0135580283,
0.0361090712,
0.0416952483,
-0.0180536713,
0.0614563078,
0.0638124794,
0.0112912059,
0.0346844718,
0.0733127147,
0.0327368267,
-0.0246887468,
-0.0049922979,
-0.0408558249,
-0.0140666813,
-0.0008059483,
-0.0053964378,
-0.0997885242,
0.0016235627,
-0.0116682006,
-0.0087954812,
-0.1027372181,
-0.0362003148,
0.0281747896,
-0.0843427479,
0.0138031133,
0.039795015,
0.0077434769,
0.0060567227,
-0.0071324902,
0.0070181242,
-0.0186785404,
0.0422230549,
0.0193602424,
0.0105797676,
-0.0311940145,
-0.0013272777,
0.0142688174,
-0.0077408557,
0.0605255738,
-0.0226968303,
0.0690048859,
0.0469285399,
0.0404053852,
-0.0434891768,
-0.0419792235,
0.0165226664,
0.0344366655,
-0.0377890244,
0.010456603,
-0.0427225716,
-0.0104105035,
0.0124264881,
-0.0833826587,
0.0324840993,
0.0099293161,
-0.0351547189,
0.0125811715,
0.0583944917,
0.000040822,
-0.0694273412,
0.0066894437,
0.017322788,
-0.0084410589,
0.0875343829,
0.0017386151,
-0.0371488221,
0.0279727448,
-0.0345066153,
-0.0526937135,
0.0092349146,
-0.0603393055,
-0.0289560538,
0.0046647619,
0.0041743536,
-0.0331345499,
-0.0288841296,
-0.01600229,
-0.0195555389,
0.0537227988,
-0.0557399318,
0.07623633,
0.0102797719,
-0.0350314975,
-0.0164388884,
-0.0279198419,
-0.004366816,
-0.0132783502,
0.0607237481,
0.0311648473,
-0.0054066344,
-0.0073048868,
-0.0148486011,
-0.0130004929,
-0.0470378436,
0.042048607,
0.0356455557,
0.019488534,
-0.0245104488,
-0.0239568576,
-0.0246372651,
0.0123273581,
0.025027832,
-0.0494402945,
0.0458134487,
0.0413985699,
0.0687477365,
0.0061667403,
0.0293192174,
-0.0016559546,
0.0106607936,
0.0367509052,
-0.0060548284,
-0.0441001691,
-0.0456523485,
0.0381534621,
0.0295556094,
-0.0408474058,
-0.0087563638,
0.0312953629,
-0.0255835671,
-0.0564035065,
-0.0278243069,
-0.0447939895,
-0.0322728269,
0.0055540577,
0.0468363166,
-0.0136330491,
-0.0174863562,
0.014913152,
-0.0562613197,
0.0007615447,
0.0144755244,
-0.0011657069,
0.0250873175,
0.036509525,
0.0035963028,
-0.0145770349,
-0.0404231995,
0.0120548373,
-0.0299495291,
0.0369857401,
0.029062869,
0.0896162465,
0.0100869928,
-0.0345325321,
0.014749852,
-0.0007578064,
-0.0372150838,
-0.0465924405,
-0.0031678362,
0.0145165371,
-0.0277945716,
0.0338665247,
0.018620668,
-0.0193575863,
0.0046537295,
-0.0224400964,
0.0391196385,
0.0121013997,
-0.024655709,
0.0422606766,
0.0037766956,
-0.0434155725,
-0.0069233575,
0.0228322111,
-0.0535387844,
0.000210759,
-0.0189362746,
-0.0440976843,
-0.0061378204,
-0.023503786,
0.0238192547,
0.0053302008,
-0.0230300911,
-0.0142608173,
-0.1055951715,
-0.0163647886,
-0.0474625044,
0.015658211,
0.0176591258,
-0.0448755771,
-0.0523549765,
0.0644206852,
-0.0075748144,
0.0094143683,
-0.029327549,
0.0205868799,
-0.02768692,
0.0146893719,
-0.088221021,
-5.754025011e-33,
-0.0058399476,
-0.0192662459,
-0.0396881364,
-0.0469601788,
-0.0161036458,
-0.0329085216,
0.0158953331,
0.0425512604,
-0.0491144918,
0.0350998454,
0.0013612749,
0.020007899,
0.0047020456,
-0.0159728341,
0.0425725095,
-0.0524613261,
-0.0135800652,
0.0089426097,
-0.0331389382,
-0.0208758544,
0.0003363391,
-0.0631899685,
0.0450514741,
-0.0768741444,
0.0717955157,
0.0288756024,
-0.011384936,
0.0060232244,
-0.0626277253,
0.014653692,
-0.0076413183,
0.0422387235,
0.0080765076,
-0.0066804164,
0.0084837833,
0.0522615649,
0.0410881601,
0.0028323943,
0.0896296054,
-0.005166587,
-0.0007308741,
-0.0578395687,
-0.0064332797,
-0.0033197596,
-0.0651531294,
0.0191857535,
0.0269949548,
-0.023940539,
0.0323364176,
-0.0117682675,
-0.0289113168,
-0.023086885,
-0.0200050548,
-0.0214303154,
-0.0705918893,
0.0476143211,
-0.0388703309,
0.0454509705,
0.0063790088,
0.0373860933,
0.0282137003,
-0.0270759836,
0.039904952,
-0.0511682071,
0.0410336331,
0.078480877,
-0.0246590059,
0.0136701036,
-0.0422282964,
-0.0002044964,
0.0169029664,
0.0116455136,
0.0236786753,
0.0907296613,
-0.0177033488,
-0.0284211487,
-0.0364954844,
-0.0332857482,
0.0439463705,
-0.0032095753,
0.0448816381,
0.0148014985,
-0.048810605,
-0.0401721932,
-0.045121491,
-0.067667976,
-0.0157528259,
-0.0168068893,
0.0187134091,
-0.0325683244,
-0.047062587,
-0.0296913534,
0.0316769518,
-0.0278348327,
-0.014283807,
-0.0038288124,
-0.0080807945,
0.0330343321,
-0.0099106915,
0.0491788387,
-0.0494944453,
0.007087321,
0.0048288507,
-0.0150524974,
0.0173400789,
0.0130534749,
0.0098768314,
-0.0158071015,
-0.0106206993,
-0.0069887266,
-0.0063521205,
-0.0155806039,
0.0097288135,
-0.0510794595,
0.036901556,
0.0352451615,
0.0143617168,
-0.0085788798,
0.0073524504,
-0.0436586402,
-0.0295658931,
-0.0142892823,
-0.0237872824,
0.0347908176,
-0.0239929408,
0.0094044916,
-0.029039355,
0.0040351343,
0.0167933032,
0.0059289318,
-0.0287209377,
0.0319516696,
2.63e-7,
0.0230902862,
0.0010650791,
-0.0350281559,
0.0155371008,
-0.0250593517,
0.0662867129,
0.0423851795,
0.0276321936,
0.0787483454,
-0.0686394721,
0.0094933603,
-0.0119845681,
0.0452674404,
-0.0012653897,
0.0135760857,
0.0023264661,
-0.0047551454,
-0.0144772371,
-0.0101408372,
0.0627914071,
0.0499167629,
0.0517602004,
0.0262025837,
0.0157699157,
-0.0057837935,
0.0186562724,
0.0358102694,
-0.0959075689,
-0.0406568386,
0.0164571945,
-0.0291924514,
-0.0355794653,
0.0301746577,
0.0258042272,
0.0662575737,
-0.0326626673,
0.0098543661,
0.090610601,
0.0136451749,
-0.0039827572,
-0.0431667753,
-0.0623486713,
-0.0184291191,
-0.0456029885,
0.0534620173,
-0.0665585473,
-0.0251881629,
-0.0317395069,
0.0209684242,
-0.045579832,
0.0087318216,
-0.0189886242,
-0.0210062638,
0.01054308,
0.0175763033,
0.0174474809,
0.008091392,
-0.0123159708,
0.0023808267,
-0.0090941144,
0.0189333409,
-0.1246223301,
0.0298688114,
0.0502406769,
0.0246196017,
-0.0949456766,
0.0166540071,
2.116568725e-34,
0.0225063488,
-0.0166452974,
0.0131971547,
0.0021967199,
0.0442008264,
0.0504765548,
-0.0030336054,
0.0021774292,
0.0400314778,
-0.0286465213,
0.0091388291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14311v1 | Comparative Analysis of Libraries for the Sentimental Analysis | 2023-07-26T17:21:53 | 2023-07-26T17:21:53 | Wendy Ccoya, Edson Pinto | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study is main goal is to provide a comparative comparison of libraries
using machine learning methods. Experts in natural language processing (NLP)
are becoming more and more interested in sentiment analysis (SA) of text
changes. The objective of employing NLP text analysis techniques is to
recognize and categorize feelings related to twitter users utterances. In this
examination, issues with SA and the libraries utilized are also looked at.
provides a number of cooperative methods to classify emotional polarity. The
Naive Bayes Classifier, Decision Tree Classifier, Maxent Classifier, Sklearn
Classifier, Sklearn Classifier MultinomialNB, and other conjoint learning
algorithms, according to recent research, are very effective. In the project
will use Five Python and R libraries NLTK, TextBlob, Vader, Transformers (GPT
and BERT pretrained), and Tidytext will be used in the study to apply sentiment
analysis techniques. Four machine learning models Tree of Decisions (DT),
Support Vector Machine (SVM), Naive Bayes (NB), and K-Nearest Neighbor (KNN)
will also be used. To evaluate how well libraries for SA operate in the social
network environment, comparative study was also carried out. The measures to
assess the best algorithms in this experiment, which used a single data set for
each method, were precision, recall, and F1 score. We conclude that the BERT
transformer method with an Accuracy: 0.973 is recommended for sentiment
analysis. | [
0.0569886006,
0.0209485441,
-0.0052287574,
-0.0007025747,
-0.0614995062,
0.0232560113,
-0.0087730205,
0.0011912048,
0.0270532034,
-0.0759493038,
0.0179077517,
0.0083152559,
0.0001957747,
0.0173049346,
-0.0651579797,
-0.0514584705,
-0.0077092238,
0.0717277676,
0.0490416959,
-0.0206758156,
0.0098144803,
0.0306296181,
-0.0111718299,
0.0193604305,
-0.0070773205,
-0.0057912474,
0.0186295733,
-0.0114200506,
0.0410135724,
0.0046403012,
0.0513401628,
0.0273741055,
-0.0378972739,
0.0131766945,
0.0000023018,
-0.0292368494,
-0.0228070114,
-0.0078902906,
0.0595155321,
-0.0438160859,
0.1154282093,
-0.0076192925,
0.0075125005,
0.0429508574,
-0.0492725447,
0.0253254864,
0.0551722236,
0.0612275228,
0.073702611,
0.0775918961,
-0.0119528491,
-0.0441589281,
-0.0048458255,
0.0309519265,
0.0108431811,
0.0090549365,
0.024838144,
-0.0026944014,
-0.0130797848,
-0.0436990373,
-0.0056564505,
0.0013211897,
-0.0347127914,
0.0119833173,
0.0163319409,
0.0019166238,
-0.0608948432,
-0.0369692668,
-0.0157500263,
0.0042019347,
0.0045840889,
-0.016019268,
-0.0040197261,
0.0085816467,
-0.0302545149,
-0.0077479319,
0.026131561,
0.0144707812,
-0.032438904,
0.0232975204,
-0.0239056703,
0.0261696652,
-0.0309148934,
0.0596718602,
-0.001155087,
0.0430228077,
-0.0220815185,
-0.0322456658,
0.048209656,
0.0332151167,
0.016704727,
0.0083038183,
0.0292210057,
-0.0014294945,
0.0185962748,
0.0145930042,
-0.0051424014,
-0.041015368,
0.0077472492,
-0.1160391867,
-0.041478347,
0.0112582324,
-0.0156116216,
0.0060571288,
-0.0035897917,
-0.0049372674,
0.0553628094,
0.0156480838,
0.0169274732,
0.0084586423,
-0.0652889162,
0.0076910779,
0.0137852775,
0.0555895679,
-0.0144341579,
-0.0225531738,
-0.081742689,
0.0030096802,
-0.0049539274,
-0.0151608204,
0.0214198157,
0.0152932778,
0.0462877117,
0.0330799669,
-0.0206966344,
0.0611751601,
-0.0322957039,
0.0017823526,
-0.0708087161,
0.0210446175,
0.0605024397,
0.0259170663,
0.0115521718,
-0.0231985338,
0.0479050465,
0.0076962505,
0.0234197229,
-0.0389944352,
-0.0551512875,
0.0282201953,
0.0006064276,
-0.0647641197,
-0.0171348248,
-0.0287181884,
0.0035800557,
0.0408257507,
-0.0125402994,
0.0117694614,
0.019155927,
0.0064215902,
-0.0466615222,
0.03942113,
-0.0480925664,
-0.0136441439,
0.0251300279,
0.0023787094,
0.0263988618,
0.018527193,
-0.0226062294,
0.0553940609,
0.0328292251,
-0.0374825969,
0.019314453,
-0.0364482701,
-0.037051294,
-0.0687827244,
-0.0394620486,
0.003274099,
-0.0774426088,
-0.0184954964,
-0.044391498,
0.045008406,
-0.0053622364,
-0.0059394115,
-0.0062389532,
-0.0156817175,
0.0037618394,
0.0529323034,
-0.0314778462,
0.0493014753,
0.0728865266,
-0.013637092,
0.0053457064,
0.0393267721,
-0.0645461306,
-0.0206894819,
-0.0116276285,
0.0461867191,
-0.0074305264,
-0.0440511853,
-0.0360089429,
-0.0400539339,
0.0375756398,
-0.0323840603,
0.070001483,
-0.0322266221,
-0.0456291325,
0.0043629883,
0.068794325,
-0.0747800767,
-0.0637077987,
-0.0275670346,
0.0157508925,
0.0813167319,
-0.0194808915,
-0.0388365537,
-0.0301021002,
-0.0512965843,
-0.0488782823,
0.0069199251,
0.0121237934,
0.0186929703,
-0.0111968834,
-0.053327933,
0.0240890663,
0.014020334,
0.0052463184,
0.03150516,
-0.0270787254,
0.087975055,
-0.0056750793,
0.0139101353,
0.0125340363,
0.0096642198,
0.0370170213,
0.015711233,
0.0032447141,
0.0125675499,
0.036398083,
0.059553504,
-0.0212604664,
-0.0399552248,
0.020825142,
0.0465262607,
-0.0585354567,
0.0290135443,
0.020682713,
-0.04962264,
0.0324017555,
-0.0217130389,
-0.0113807265,
0.0568454526,
-0.0201903209,
0.004523709,
0.0607584044,
-0.0227960702,
-0.0064585498,
-0.0306572039,
0.0260173921,
-0.0842490345,
0.013056282,
-0.0090552149,
0.0528096668,
0.00223701,
0.0214766879,
-0.0497692786,
-0.0381846763,
0.0289913826,
0.0200890843,
-0.0474528484,
0.0237679165,
-0.0087008243,
0.0238730144,
0.029281335,
0.0117260059,
-0.0120365163,
-0.0586541183,
-0.0771054253,
-0.0173319299,
0.0063974792,
0.0009506819,
-0.0258459896,
0.0034849455,
-0.0109646311,
0.0355359092,
0.0113157369,
0.0231807716,
-0.0284487717,
-0.0144890388,
0.0182499252,
-0.0252828989,
0.0348954424,
-0.0339732654,
0.0094573488,
-0.0331285149,
0.0078323791,
0.0431113653,
-0.0811134875,
-0.00084046,
-0.015083205,
-0.0397940874,
0.0077984929,
0.0034235767,
-0.0435140803,
-0.0110669052,
-0.0220072642,
0.0266705249,
0.0267884396,
0.0456204675,
0.0485399552,
-0.0031612909,
0.0265897252,
-0.034190286,
0.044124946,
-0.0151876444,
0.0125580383,
-0.0127820233,
-0.032795731,
0.0013907262,
0.0214194302,
-0.0068403222,
-0.0070627085,
-0.0346335471,
-0.0140995765,
0.0017440891,
0.0220108218,
0.0180886872,
-0.0045095962,
0.0004906288,
-0.0358564071,
0.0678265095,
-0.022085391,
0.0386122763,
0.0161264986,
-0.0128324507,
-0.1340880394,
-0.0436080061,
-0.0205898769,
0.0423223749,
-0.004895356,
0.0081075476,
-0.0243397374,
0.017010361,
0.0385136083,
-0.0363667011,
0.0055199461,
-0.0222149268,
-0.0106052179,
0.0377498195,
-0.0185324214,
0.0081668682,
-0.0101104686,
0.0046414835,
-0.0416342765,
-0.074964948,
-0.0503319837,
0.0304819793,
-0.046553541,
-0.0046579977,
-0.0065188915,
-0.0083772903,
-0.0720330849,
-0.0078756576,
-0.0292187706,
0.0422522873,
-0.0171700176,
0.0225183647,
-0.0698601454,
0.0076589435,
0.0292625222,
0.011635772,
0.0297575742,
-0.0192855056,
-0.0242232122,
-0.0424325205,
-0.0265072156,
-0.0001092378,
-0.0313434638,
0.0010282282,
-0.0414239839,
0.0084938491,
0.0068805991,
0.0555396266,
0.1110023111,
0.0681033134,
-0.0372673459,
-0.0280103609,
-0.0322459117,
-0.0711550638,
0.017810015,
0.0297086611,
-0.0053828587,
-0.0296770222,
-0.0350185521,
0.0425389409,
-0.0278850757,
-0.044665359,
0.0346735865,
-0.078463383,
0.0058237119,
-0.0120875482,
-0.0168258529,
-0.0499939471,
-0.0230050795,
-0.0167616867,
-0.0378017239,
-0.0279846191,
-0.0221737418,
-0.0170391947,
0.0257408582,
0.013546668,
-0.0697808042,
0.0069503793,
0.0059454362,
-0.0115390429,
0.0063887606,
0.0060996884,
0.0901376158,
-0.0582584925,
-0.0268659294,
0.0177321341,
0.0081848782,
0.0247962251,
-0.0387937799,
0.0864433721,
-0.0124714011,
0.0102389967,
-0.0416300371,
-0.0162029322,
-0.0078339344,
0.0116723534,
0.0068544187,
0.0125245349,
-0.0410766266,
-0.0763645619,
-0.0274873711,
0.0756101906,
0.0267214812,
0.0308779813,
-0.0152587825,
-0.0369410962,
-0.0491289236,
-0.0069137164,
0.0048652799,
-0.0200209804,
-0.012042311,
-0.0203918796,
-0.0152510628,
-0.0404438376,
-0.0704104304,
-0.0353919342,
-0.0057512084,
0.0124299666,
-0.0462435558,
0.0143611366,
-0.0080827568,
0.0226077568,
-0.0502839498,
-0.0205364469,
0.077597484,
0.0249677282,
-0.0012325539,
-0.0378855057,
0.0685601309,
0.0037822095,
0.003510477,
-0.0360575356,
0.017278105,
-0.0379338041,
0.0189102869,
0.0468418524,
0.0129624028,
-0.0506043136,
-0.0001222166,
-0.0308818724,
-0.0162965693,
0.1070585996,
-0.025092721,
-0.0075987196,
0.0319139063,
0.0683702752,
-0.0063058976,
-0.010220645,
0.0003387776,
0.0224976037,
0.00773517,
-0.0420259945,
0.0045836605,
-0.0104169063,
-0.0217892937,
0.0287954956,
0.0542957149,
0.0213348418,
-0.0596796609,
0.0122056296,
-0.0361955985,
0.0155466683,
-0.0196360536,
-0.0023336904,
-0.0317355394,
-0.0151207093,
0.0381037891,
-0.0680299923,
-0.0288041234,
-0.0084854448,
-0.027271539,
0.0242443569,
0.1040952131,
0.0653786138,
0.0524804294,
0.0142179858,
0.0039611491,
-0.0203049891,
-0.0554710776,
0.0465132594,
-0.0126006762,
0.0105644055,
0.0427235961,
-0.0116431294,
-0.0208531246,
0.0098136021,
0.0341526829,
-0.0058382605,
0.01934034,
-0.0408243835,
0.0345980637,
0.0059373425,
-0.0132839335,
0.0356946401,
-0.0498163365,
0.011109245,
-0.0151800178,
0.0355268009,
-0.0137683433,
0.0107982457,
-0.0043165442,
-0.0363445394,
-0.0535692647,
-0.012529091,
0.0182062276,
-0.0811762214,
0.0057447972,
0.0319311842,
-0.0596150495,
-0.034579251,
0.0126183359,
0.0531549007,
-0.0204341076,
0.0068006027,
0.0241065379,
-0.0414226167,
-0.0005420021,
0.0940006748,
-0.0801903605,
0.0330811925,
-0.0054267412,
0.015131087,
0.0612237789,
0.0158100687,
0.0743164495,
-0.0592888445,
0.0295789856,
-0.0521872304,
-0.0118132913,
-0.0112069556,
-6.410195508e-33,
0.0204752963,
-0.0149108395,
-0.0613794923,
0.0580229908,
-0.001963045,
-0.0015038119,
0.0165772662,
0.0456130989,
0.0130229127,
0.0401856005,
-0.0179560501,
0.0201840103,
-0.0011257029,
-0.0094130635,
0.0163130183,
-0.002378687,
-0.0201752912,
0.0160012115,
0.0028265628,
-0.0059738155,
0.023738293,
0.0530978031,
0.06840574,
-0.1337376237,
0.0139538599,
0.021535622,
-0.0277513806,
-0.0277562235,
0.0025621071,
-0.0057115206,
0.0244989544,
0.0719047114,
0.0177538916,
0.0007334304,
0.0183711983,
0.0030056762,
0.0176663101,
-0.0353423357,
-0.0191084202,
0.035950873,
0.0176965836,
0.0148951607,
0.0108392509,
0.0089699775,
-0.0478852056,
0.0095102275,
0.0506745614,
-0.0132310325,
0.0159976296,
-0.0903052166,
-0.0359412804,
0.0466451049,
-0.0191375092,
0.0006105173,
0.0186085925,
0.0352207348,
-0.0019120068,
0.0149712777,
-0.0565228015,
0.0153010143,
-0.0107849138,
-0.0240790993,
-0.0310451556,
-0.0484367386,
-0.0029009867,
0.0341443419,
0.045807153,
-0.0134453224,
-0.0118533205,
0.0500092767,
-0.0109922085,
0.0336139426,
0.0593384095,
0.0327036716,
0.0117536727,
-0.0720107332,
-0.0149966041,
0.0635381788,
0.1132095382,
0.0024280781,
0.0422267057,
0.0002914613,
-0.0264748838,
0.0008439227,
0.0668442547,
-0.034327291,
-0.008822605,
-0.0288866851,
-0.0336909853,
-0.0231680125,
-0.0195260085,
0.0082515609,
-0.0335185155,
-0.0430808514,
-0.0017542454,
0.0462777652,
-0.0449330397,
0.0793502405,
0.0023522815,
0.0093789101,
-0.0136492066,
-0.0060353391,
-0.0055513703,
0.0317158066,
0.0308827609,
-0.0153908981,
0.0172822811,
0.0256721936,
-0.0680452734,
0.0000987442,
0.0184947401,
0.0223621279,
0.0049047563,
0.039638713,
-0.0708816275,
-0.003968609,
-0.004520887,
0.0169056766,
0.0041001886,
0.0692918599,
-0.0195822231,
-0.0190296564,
0.0288046841,
-0.0423976853,
-0.024898883,
-0.014937425,
0.012469138,
-0.0200574826,
-0.0249626767,
-0.0094822347,
-0.0003065001,
-0.0368877277,
3.067e-7,
0.057752233,
0.0893533006,
0.0020052232,
-0.0625437498,
-0.0003077005,
0.0599354953,
-0.004003068,
0.0191670619,
0.0172908865,
0.0339752734,
0.0264452975,
-0.0364261232,
0.024275288,
0.0423040055,
-0.0749793127,
-0.0079673389,
-0.0209839847,
-0.0303469822,
-0.0057326509,
0.0464023054,
0.0496857427,
0.0436294302,
0.0675383508,
-0.0208302587,
-0.0110204574,
0.0049438132,
0.0004510122,
-0.055465281,
0.0349587202,
0.0120713059,
0.0066390466,
-0.0316300094,
-0.0073940861,
-0.0223865993,
0.0028966975,
-0.002866972,
0.0369973816,
0.0310383141,
0.0077939136,
-0.0204672739,
0.0441550538,
0.022004595,
0.0066129421,
0.0090527507,
0.041340299,
-0.0398636349,
-0.0588255897,
-0.0443609357,
0.0082030119,
-0.0019466419,
0.0745495483,
-0.0055431258,
-0.0233544651,
0.0233704969,
-0.0265900474,
-0.0345038325,
-0.0364255607,
-0.0684370473,
-0.0067358608,
-0.0062746103,
-0.0112275193,
-0.023253154,
0.0175943486,
0.050590504,
0.0742413625,
0.0091124587,
0.0499304831,
2.324813289e-34,
0.0335894302,
-0.0219751839,
-0.0332371816,
0.0044728634,
0.0276365019,
0.0308909602,
0.0014486554,
-0.0092815934,
0.0025437283,
-0.019636035,
0.0369775631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14305v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14305v1 | Automatically Evaluating Opinion Prevalence in Opinion Summarization | 2023-07-26T17:13:00 | 2023-07-26T17:13:00 | Christopher Malon | cs.CL | cs.CL | When faced with a large number of product reviews, it is not clear that a
human can remember all of them and weight opinions representatively to write a
good reference summary. We propose an automatic metric to test the prevalence
of the opinions that a summary expresses, based on counting the number of
reviews that are consistent with each statement in the summary, while
discrediting trivial or redundant statements. To formulate this opinion
prevalence metric, we consider several existing methods to score the factual
consistency of a summary statement with respect to each individual source
review. On a corpus of Amazon product reviews, we gather multiple human
judgments of the opinion consistency, to determine which automatic metric best
expresses consistency in product reviews. Using the resulting opinion
prevalence metric, we show that a human authored summary has only slightly
better opinion prevalence than randomly selected extracts from the source
reviews, and previous extractive and abstractive unsupervised opinion
summarization methods perform worse than humans. We demonstrate room for
improvement with a greedy construction of extractive summaries with twice the
opinion prevalence achieved by humans. Finally, we show that preprocessing
source reviews by simplification can raise the opinion prevalence achieved by
existing abstractive opinion summarization systems to the level of human
performance. | [
0.0625773296,
0.0161738861,
0.003535344,
0.0082053998,
-0.0416603535,
0.0002154312,
-0.0266403686,
-0.0489740893,
-0.0492622703,
-0.0563878044,
0.0035415459,
-0.0148903932,
0.0473553389,
0.0237027481,
-0.019620683,
-0.0304091629,
0.0073910155,
0.0352207646,
0.046789974,
0.0119318999,
0.0388442129,
-0.0033182846,
-0.0045677917,
0.0183572639,
-0.0021940414,
0.0033908112,
0.0510634705,
-0.0416657589,
0.049968265,
-0.015410278,
0.0200969707,
0.0337420404,
-0.0129441274,
-0.0069247563,
0.0000015803,
-0.026482705,
-0.0063576009,
-0.0100917071,
0.051652316,
0.0281159505,
0.0701414421,
-0.0180389639,
0.0209021699,
0.0061964272,
-0.02658391,
-0.0076334761,
0.0053140405,
0.0699983984,
0.0914081484,
0.0237544142,
-0.0162353106,
-0.0285513327,
-0.019311998,
0.0130799431,
-0.0322069936,
0.0064967526,
-0.0069885035,
0.048871927,
-0.0299128164,
-0.0067451214,
0.0265318025,
0.0000747906,
-0.0227757152,
-0.0087659806,
0.017091902,
0.0011515458,
-0.0619688109,
-0.0113467928,
0.036709778,
0.0577015467,
0.0508846715,
-0.0172034148,
0.0246016085,
0.0217249338,
0.0234784167,
0.027517179,
-0.0314759277,
0.0372122563,
-0.000518556,
0.0274635516,
-0.0542352572,
0.0511796921,
0.0038124137,
0.0068800864,
0.0406842008,
0.039178431,
-0.0012929082,
-0.0120668281,
-0.0010192228,
0.0459343195,
-0.0198957156,
-0.0326011293,
0.0074349232,
-0.0120636979,
-0.0056378338,
-0.0036034645,
-0.0294822287,
-0.0180123504,
0.059777461,
-0.0640784577,
0.0354393944,
-0.0438238531,
0.0004291649,
0.0576757602,
-0.0118586188,
0.0030344557,
0.032474637,
-0.0275496934,
-0.0457714982,
0.0027035864,
-0.0547213219,
0.0347165801,
0.0307814702,
0.039837312,
-0.0068211793,
0.0137889907,
-0.0975451171,
-0.0129544577,
-0.0568150952,
-0.0092891119,
-0.0063938755,
0.0218703076,
0.0456648991,
-0.0056370576,
-0.0393065102,
0.0352812484,
-0.0441029742,
0.0270534828,
-0.0165278874,
0.0172937494,
0.0243388265,
0.0252449419,
0.0302514173,
0.0198391899,
-0.0007924032,
-0.015831681,
0.0129174329,
-0.0070120129,
-0.0166611951,
-0.0257069357,
-0.0371287204,
-0.0518250354,
-0.0203978531,
-0.0820550099,
0.0156283807,
0.0006321023,
-0.0239932947,
0.0531123392,
-0.0044626188,
0.0356300883,
-0.0203733966,
0.015291146,
-0.0334236287,
-0.0111397849,
0.0245743282,
-0.0190754756,
0.013283723,
0.0185761172,
0.010706312,
0.0361724123,
0.0531987101,
0.0383956432,
0.0233220123,
-0.0116465148,
-0.0070246984,
-0.0107208602,
0.0540211238,
-0.0091094514,
-0.0917260647,
-0.0476281829,
0.0205008555,
0.0846054927,
-0.0162750091,
-0.0101528969,
0.0478798859,
0.0235759486,
-0.0648873225,
0.0243413877,
0.0022895855,
0.0308069438,
0.0473553427,
0.062482968,
-0.0096347695,
0.0222047996,
-0.0077454541,
0.0361536704,
0.0262239594,
0.0393575542,
0.0009602237,
-0.0589460991,
-0.006218465,
-0.0206212979,
0.004097302,
-0.012139963,
0.0197749101,
0.0033049763,
-0.014227977,
0.0497029759,
0.0232114475,
-0.0308229849,
-0.0097360928,
0.0012954203,
0.0337554142,
0.0346680321,
0.0030707354,
0.0045982408,
0.0138443857,
-0.0061984779,
-0.025305355,
-0.0006006124,
0.0560776182,
-0.0327517986,
-0.0285976827,
-0.0082414523,
-0.0075234561,
-0.0136887953,
0.0347783975,
0.0013799641,
-0.0087255975,
-0.0320881791,
0.0326957181,
-0.0485356599,
-0.0493359156,
0.0022614305,
0.0468756929,
0.0118883001,
0.0152049577,
-0.0253766719,
0.0402429774,
0.0616033822,
-0.0411428325,
0.0072158701,
0.0313285738,
-0.0143159423,
-0.045205567,
0.0161729287,
-0.0086516142,
0.0093278382,
0.0352984555,
-0.0963305309,
-0.0505993403,
0.0293979868,
-0.0284441076,
-0.0329985023,
0.0058020591,
-0.0483529419,
0.0001019636,
-0.0312356707,
-0.0121704545,
-0.0016231727,
-0.0308738556,
-0.0041760984,
0.0581970736,
0.003678214,
-0.0034688951,
0.0115570277,
-0.1076088026,
0.0181488097,
0.0128702847,
-0.0307972543,
-0.0392476283,
0.0147292856,
0.0254019145,
0.0720288157,
-0.0203338116,
-0.0186085701,
-0.0036426114,
-0.123285301,
-0.0301103182,
-0.0016860226,
0.0149118677,
0.0597377531,
-0.0208024401,
0.0242862124,
0.035644602,
-0.0340443887,
-0.0270551052,
-0.0043436205,
0.0274396315,
0.0629125014,
0.0305141658,
0.0267074984,
-0.0716610402,
-0.0183383506,
-0.0103605911,
0.0315763429,
0.0383957066,
0.0017540507,
-0.0507087708,
0.001534951,
-0.0538054183,
-0.0308027621,
0.0165935289,
-0.0022939541,
-0.0092822798,
0.0206837486,
0.0237472598,
0.0174277686,
0.0256831516,
-0.021904787,
0.0813622773,
0.0263982862,
-0.0128961122,
-0.0472940281,
-0.0367785469,
0.0262293015,
0.0350828022,
-0.0450421087,
0.0623922423,
0.0286229439,
0.0228680763,
-0.0093906391,
0.0108727133,
0.0143048558,
-0.0240004379,
-0.0045541232,
-0.0340481438,
-0.0515765175,
-0.0088818064,
0.0365377851,
-0.0104526049,
0.0041708364,
0.0657506362,
-0.0225526411,
0.0476931296,
-0.0567977391,
0.0071372665,
-0.0325529128,
-0.0102509437,
0.0001662985,
0.0089093093,
-0.0072817188,
0.0325924009,
-0.0343957916,
-0.049452424,
0.0627145916,
-0.0104816342,
0.0584064387,
-0.0497371219,
0.0376652256,
0.0014223845,
-0.0302098449,
0.0114962449,
-0.0402767546,
-0.0224280134,
-0.0024714582,
0.0440715663,
-0.0104364036,
-0.0395150743,
0.0029615602,
0.0630803928,
0.0147794606,
0.0101996753,
-0.0185042024,
0.0360104144,
0.046547465,
0.0663058087,
0.0008802162,
0.0567198992,
-0.025283182,
-0.0317464694,
0.0877918527,
-0.0154327191,
-0.0027802519,
-0.0216284394,
-0.0554153323,
-0.0593776591,
-0.039933715,
0.0103538204,
-0.0295661502,
0.0250803921,
-0.0115885045,
0.0367727764,
0.0841589943,
0.0069727753,
-0.0361388363,
-0.0369572751,
0.0431173109,
-0.0137675274,
0.0090124076,
-0.017189594,
-0.0736957192,
0.0081287222,
-0.0375475101,
0.0323022418,
0.0022099207,
-0.0140003022,
0.0101864804,
-0.0912294313,
-0.0083456123,
-0.015920708,
0.0022267576,
-0.0542321317,
-0.0397133715,
0.0310647991,
-0.0190530084,
-0.0011940747,
-0.0043549179,
-0.0002519657,
0.0437297411,
-0.0309815016,
-0.0757102817,
0.0140371472,
0.0534174852,
-0.0383220688,
0.0097921817,
0.0495309345,
0.047093045,
0.0015593977,
0.0227485411,
0.0318806507,
-0.0580479316,
-0.0328951143,
0.0313246548,
0.0871579871,
-0.0009009332,
0.0222006943,
-0.0301735979,
0.0115529289,
-0.0155442767,
0.0155695789,
0.0256500766,
0.0110714491,
0.0492267199,
-0.037366461,
-0.055562824,
0.0389499553,
-0.0337452255,
0.0852602199,
-0.0063327835,
0.0075932075,
-0.015433548,
0.0140995001,
-0.0276671983,
-0.0621999949,
-0.0496074446,
0.0002913113,
-0.0235885698,
-0.016559761,
-0.1209761649,
-0.0464950725,
-0.0151333492,
-0.0055164602,
0.0032461181,
-0.0411525629,
0.0751236454,
0.0338113159,
-0.0177306496,
-0.0096890619,
0.0268184114,
-0.0166928824,
0.0036238213,
-0.0085392129,
0.0750975162,
0.0246591065,
-0.0022975907,
0.0244620219,
-0.0223130826,
-0.0248165913,
-0.0040004407,
0.0424083807,
0.018785201,
0.028353285,
0.0139154391,
0.0271741357,
0.0216966998,
0.0206219219,
-0.005725753,
0.0239591803,
0.0108714858,
0.0335358679,
-0.0028942937,
0.0064036148,
-0.0598462857,
0.0342325903,
-0.01850578,
0.0107701421,
-0.0568282828,
-0.0114329448,
0.0399939753,
0.0173373837,
0.0166237392,
-0.0149846161,
0.0722822621,
-0.023891408,
-0.024019897,
-0.0361046642,
-0.0294795316,
-0.0266690925,
0.0433238894,
-0.0423009023,
0.0087787928,
-0.0506974682,
0.0679715276,
-0.0054449732,
0.0366438739,
-0.0284457337,
0.0207572207,
-0.0249622725,
-0.0186364409,
-0.0555682555,
-0.0322610214,
-0.047818359,
-0.0295442957,
-0.0454757288,
-0.0020741469,
0.0179633908,
-0.0172244292,
0.0198696796,
-0.0094612874,
-0.0445033722,
0.0141672334,
-0.075938195,
0.0397553891,
-0.0382364877,
-0.0217008721,
-0.0130314287,
-0.0557311848,
0.0755114108,
-0.0270020366,
-0.0464868918,
-0.0043706815,
0.0186642576,
-0.0133766644,
0.0532362945,
-0.0374064893,
0.0268460326,
-0.0071467143,
0.0234557558,
0.0608608946,
-0.0681091398,
-0.020663958,
0.0052750083,
-0.0648871884,
-0.0462663695,
-0.028547423,
-0.0594602153,
0.0049604569,
0.0041085575,
-0.0322817527,
-0.0773694515,
-0.0270013567,
0.0537133478,
0.0303865056,
0.0688332543,
-0.0005447675,
0.0087323021,
0.0573621392,
0.0291239694,
0.0278771222,
-0.0353608616,
-0.010435258,
-0.0145406779,
0.0226539169,
-0.0410348438,
-5.756542038e-33,
0.0043722456,
-0.0390236452,
-0.0641067624,
0.0275601912,
0.0125363655,
0.0047655432,
-0.0533682927,
0.0182589125,
-0.0019914189,
0.0698368698,
0.0187219493,
0.0340683274,
0.0052714949,
0.003088173,
0.0356922187,
0.0302026737,
0.0529898964,
-0.0003916482,
-0.0320795365,
0.0173783284,
0.0396670178,
-0.0250012595,
0.0236980654,
-0.102816157,
0.0670667961,
-0.0002629151,
-0.0334177501,
-0.0167443175,
0.0348396339,
0.0249533392,
-0.0058957879,
0.0579411276,
0.0322702564,
-0.0373033285,
-0.0078451857,
0.0034399377,
-0.0645872951,
-0.0035252897,
0.0464221835,
-0.0586097278,
-0.0243734159,
0.012155937,
0.0441059843,
-0.0137736071,
-0.027360633,
-0.0011930317,
0.0696126744,
-0.0716204792,
0.0018453498,
-0.1269337088,
-0.0155263422,
0.0240134522,
-0.0274314024,
0.0328129716,
-0.0040476318,
0.0030684806,
-0.0045276289,
0.0301464051,
-0.0435925424,
0.0543128997,
-0.0151852267,
0.0249549132,
-0.0047752527,
-0.0528385043,
0.0091375494,
0.1086769775,
-0.0049984311,
0.0005969937,
-0.0167420413,
0.024345383,
-0.0410167016,
-0.0039458079,
0.0220983122,
0.0807315931,
0.0594156198,
0.0076863957,
-0.0475035422,
0.049828399,
0.0084074875,
0.0010478082,
0.0524838641,
-0.016738601,
-0.0317152292,
0.0026744755,
0.0279423762,
-0.0019526434,
-0.0177181661,
-0.0063602058,
-0.0391074084,
0.0119858338,
-0.0590486191,
-0.0351578258,
-0.0207930058,
-0.0281380694,
0.0024271368,
-0.004333342,
-0.0287542194,
0.0187360886,
0.0366315432,
-0.044736024,
-0.0237046964,
0.0632664263,
-0.0352754295,
0.0551256426,
0.0006991536,
-0.002966661,
0.0826135352,
-0.0229058377,
-0.0703856274,
0.0071027414,
0.0240307115,
-0.0037419344,
-0.0249273367,
0.0015948557,
-0.0172530673,
0.0327687189,
-0.003494102,
0.0358726196,
-0.0285801794,
0.0434015617,
-0.0132384207,
0.0425970219,
0.0128528392,
0.0118253306,
0.0021618207,
-0.0070651816,
-0.0035684926,
0.0079618664,
-0.0053637978,
-0.0302506145,
-0.0029370096,
-0.0012356673,
2.364e-7,
0.0594209358,
0.0319639668,
0.0132460864,
-0.0293995924,
-0.0028715041,
0.0445180833,
0.030118715,
0.0134615637,
0.0051689702,
-0.0833594948,
0.0317600965,
0.0139464522,
-0.0039092945,
0.06016903,
-0.0799021572,
0.0059184302,
-0.0486240909,
-0.0627889112,
0.0110285496,
0.0059150308,
0.0460491292,
0.0488768257,
-0.0057738046,
-0.0050524403,
-0.028985383,
-0.0184857734,
0.0414493121,
-0.0189564954,
-0.0469717309,
0.0065998863,
0.0644915774,
-0.0260748193,
-0.0069645555,
-0.0265360475,
-0.036516685,
-0.010218773,
0.0338388421,
0.0165311079,
0.0438396446,
-0.033781711,
0.0094816415,
-0.0119224889,
0.0423832387,
0.0383767784,
0.023619283,
-0.060466513,
-0.0198482927,
-0.0871465802,
-0.0496006906,
0.0134058306,
0.0026617292,
0.0056733224,
-0.0377975404,
0.0472201779,
-0.0464657508,
-0.0171344671,
-0.0127824824,
-0.0387571864,
-0.0198824313,
0.0504403487,
-0.0036427786,
-0.0705519319,
0.0535969026,
-0.018589491,
0.0004351652,
-0.0583599508,
0.0539429784,
1.78187667e-34,
0.1066372618,
-0.0151659958,
-0.0184579547,
-0.0327433422,
0.0486866646,
-0.0166445505,
-0.0556206033,
-0.0256374981,
0.0147115616,
-0.0236708187,
-0.0142823504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14298v1 | ChatGPT and Persuasive Technologies for the Management and Delivery of Personalized Recommendations in Hotel Hospitality | 2023-07-26T16:58:10 | 2023-07-26T16:58:10 | Manolis Remountakis, Konstantinos Kotis, Babis Kourtzis, George E. Tsekouras | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T01, I.2.1 | Recommender systems have become indispensable tools in the hotel hospitality
industry, enabling personalized and tailored experiences for guests. Recent
advancements in large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, and persuasive
technologies, have opened new avenues for enhancing the effectiveness of those
systems. This paper explores the potential of integrating ChatGPT and
persuasive technologies for automating and improving hotel hospitality
recommender systems. First, we delve into the capabilities of ChatGPT, which
can understand and generate human-like text, enabling more accurate and
context-aware recommendations. We discuss the integration of ChatGPT into
recommender systems, highlighting the ability to analyze user preferences,
extract valuable insights from online reviews, and generate personalized
recommendations based on guest profiles. Second, we investigate the role of
persuasive technology in influencing user behavior and enhancing the persuasive
impact of hotel recommendations. By incorporating persuasive techniques, such
as social proof, scarcity and personalization, recommender systems can
effectively influence user decision-making and encourage desired actions, such
as booking a specific hotel or upgrading their room. To investigate the
efficacy of ChatGPT and persuasive technologies, we present a pilot experi-ment
with a case study involving a hotel recommender system. We aim to study the
impact of integrating ChatGPT and persua-sive techniques on user engagement,
satisfaction, and conversion rates. The preliminary results demonstrate the
potential of these technologies in enhancing the overall guest experience and
business performance. Overall, this paper contributes to the field of hotel
hospitality by exploring the synergistic relationship between LLMs and
persuasive technology in recommender systems, ultimately influencing guest
satisfaction and hotel revenue. | [
0.0708786696,
0.0117858956,
-0.0288995355,
0.0386709012,
-0.0432320982,
-0.0095663015,
0.0096127735,
0.0066460525,
0.0562002063,
-0.0428358912,
-0.0601886958,
-0.0067744725,
0.0099851834,
0.0501349978,
0.0046374355,
-0.0074837608,
0.0071621193,
-0.0143784443,
0.0382578336,
0.013335783,
0.0429298393,
0.0166061409,
0.0248690527,
0.0435128622,
0.0229462814,
-0.0199173782,
0.0036113679,
-0.0134960013,
0.0171383508,
-0.0559251718,
0.0028289661,
0.0495167412,
0.0105292089,
0.0018879367,
0.0000020434,
-0.0480916537,
-0.0167560223,
0.0003775731,
-0.0366503708,
-0.0038246813,
0.09454339,
0.0549709015,
0.0048470581,
0.0206911378,
-0.0326680243,
0.016850112,
0.0346030444,
0.0723275691,
0.0024615841,
0.0149813257,
-0.0187674873,
-0.0484601595,
-0.0401039384,
0.0047535403,
0.0126579227,
-0.0027563155,
-0.0109075373,
-0.0150592104,
0.0154654551,
-0.0000741576,
0.0542896055,
0.0038943614,
-0.0328246765,
-0.0100576971,
0.0483296961,
0.0276117027,
-0.0509371161,
-0.021027891,
-0.0047462201,
0.0093442993,
0.0385071337,
0.0005138654,
-0.0085195107,
0.0257853772,
0.0205342751,
0.0299759153,
-0.0283447877,
-0.008893528,
0.0237320755,
0.0355799608,
-0.0161651,
0.043104589,
0.0394799709,
0.0110882223,
0.054016348,
0.0481633134,
-0.0075957556,
-0.0351784863,
0.0007162716,
0.0352319777,
0.0375471041,
-0.0338584036,
-0.0007871484,
-0.0108574759,
-0.0424201526,
-0.0123153459,
0.0632762387,
0.0390575081,
0.0137122218,
-0.0928206444,
0.0184225403,
0.0318355449,
-0.0174359325,
0.0233073775,
0.0041365325,
-0.0175582226,
0.0166431908,
-0.0362105109,
-0.0292485561,
0.033787597,
-0.041632954,
-0.0063526644,
-0.0061554643,
-0.0022242183,
-0.0161687583,
-0.0074438695,
-0.0791335255,
0.0186263043,
-0.0192156583,
0.049782753,
-0.0079655647,
0.0533867441,
0.0200835317,
0.0026080022,
-0.0591307916,
-0.0196866337,
-0.0388430059,
0.0053253286,
-0.0080738999,
-0.0017123049,
0.0706884414,
0.0487256423,
0.0404503793,
0.0219350532,
-0.0095802741,
0.020514667,
-0.0075541632,
-0.0259382296,
-0.067555733,
-0.049560789,
-0.0065840287,
-0.0387463272,
-0.0692528263,
-0.0740174726,
0.021766847,
0.0594038293,
-0.0108744865,
0.0113579798,
0.0267720744,
-0.0024985806,
-0.0346997194,
0.0385468863,
-0.0007743374,
-0.0007841989,
0.0424508639,
0.0296507441,
-0.0020875242,
0.0062069506,
0.0159689113,
0.0993329883,
0.0479215123,
0.0026870905,
0.0501906797,
0.0080346754,
-0.0528520681,
-0.0109433774,
0.0063273078,
0.0070287758,
-0.027746344,
-0.0373146534,
-0.0693567544,
0.0466189757,
-0.038917549,
0.0751339123,
0.0958592892,
0.0328779519,
-0.0134543767,
0.0703251734,
0.0239491109,
0.0050501623,
-0.0337349996,
-0.0315374807,
0.0215303525,
0.013834022,
-0.0117723951,
-0.0086026331,
0.0719161555,
-0.0108152926,
-0.0299626794,
-0.0455683358,
-0.0034350937,
-0.0395829342,
0.0716477707,
0.0232218876,
0.0142438402,
-0.0438903086,
-0.022621436,
-0.0154580474,
0.0376179628,
-0.0525484942,
-0.0022582526,
-0.0120708039,
0.0836620256,
0.1664462835,
0.013218659,
0.0216671061,
0.0932580233,
-0.0362549908,
-0.0212758649,
0.0190475676,
0.0693898275,
-0.0003850428,
-0.0333708376,
-0.029937787,
-0.0249249749,
0.0392910354,
0.0246054549,
0.0267625656,
-0.0047530178,
0.0309124216,
0.0153267914,
0.0357521102,
-0.0414449386,
-0.0490232632,
0.0298597664,
-0.0413548574,
-0.0437798575,
0.043758966,
0.027241407,
0.0530736782,
0.0249143243,
-0.0328203626,
0.0112004401,
-0.0147062056,
-0.0263329018,
0.0463691503,
0.0224890951,
0.0298642926,
-0.0010308042,
0.0288289692,
-0.0045404774,
0.000156068,
0.0361288525,
0.0149206081,
0.037800353,
0.0004894296,
0.1139014289,
-0.0251744613,
0.0107916892,
0.0113621568,
0.0053477236,
-0.0006651362,
0.0578491166,
0.0286790915,
-0.0120966695,
-0.0115432795,
-0.0650328025,
-0.0036808832,
-0.0012212772,
0.0004844755,
-0.0350488052,
0.0355193466,
0.0492775105,
0.0415843092,
-0.0021095811,
-0.0228347983,
-0.0055093318,
-0.1094412208,
-0.0526811369,
0.0155055122,
0.0108434334,
0.0009397659,
0.0330359824,
-0.0001650462,
0.0058570625,
-0.0513171107,
-0.0301643424,
0.0139178336,
0.0032195959,
0.0325111635,
0.01314006,
-0.0435172543,
-0.0211100541,
0.0287816115,
-0.0170572288,
0.0029591711,
0.0431446247,
-0.0097217383,
-0.0323907286,
-0.0563223138,
-0.0358630233,
-0.0551594719,
0.0152051467,
-0.0259185564,
-0.0012475146,
0.0118450355,
0.0645282045,
-0.0582734235,
0.0185519829,
0.037350364,
0.0263912007,
-0.0178943221,
-0.0674453378,
-0.0278325062,
-0.0527144037,
-0.0007078653,
-0.0070516439,
-0.0540684052,
0.0213069487,
-0.036578007,
0.0098094735,
0.0200456083,
-0.06519036,
0.0413405672,
0.02442104,
0.0095922472,
-0.025013024,
0.0071944953,
-0.0193677191,
0.093117699,
0.0309249703,
-0.0324773267,
0.0290531609,
-0.0306378286,
0.0064040334,
-0.0116899395,
-0.0444271863,
-0.0268573184,
-0.0068944916,
-0.0006422608,
0.0540921874,
-0.0125211747,
-0.0050257584,
0.0431336649,
-0.0599735975,
0.0238308981,
-0.0518137962,
-0.0129840244,
0.0224189069,
-0.0304201115,
0.0610205159,
-0.0326737687,
-0.0328878053,
-0.0376791991,
-0.0574686639,
-0.0300105177,
0.0442610867,
0.0103736706,
-0.0342724174,
0.0108881295,
0.0132068386,
0.0075460901,
0.0180818643,
-0.0445230566,
0.0026920163,
0.0037617672,
0.0001831228,
0.0055145402,
0.0059795445,
0.0068504922,
0.0021577636,
0.0349783041,
-0.0686788931,
-0.0617701635,
-0.031734921,
0.0064097536,
0.0155976629,
-0.0055616163,
0.0105991606,
0.0217798054,
-0.0164436772,
0.0040784287,
0.0589157417,
0.0443533435,
0.0121677909,
-0.0692194626,
-0.0131332669,
-0.048727084,
0.0061521176,
-0.0229589213,
0.0541544929,
-0.0692702457,
-0.0033365274,
-0.0217767991,
0.017770147,
-0.0109467218,
0.021133801,
-0.0283567607,
-0.0253932811,
0.0748223662,
0.0098465327,
0.0275863409,
0.0137414085,
0.001738889,
-0.0066109104,
-0.0079588499,
-0.02503605,
-0.0335107781,
-0.0196962077,
-0.0103719188,
-0.0241724215,
-0.0481258631,
-0.0155805489,
0.003357948,
-0.0666571707,
0.0028124552,
0.1092455015,
0.0484875999,
0.0031531383,
-0.0463564992,
0.0031949691,
0.073936291,
0.012685121,
-0.0065862765,
-0.0015021892,
0.006885625,
0.0294613596,
-0.0189777762,
0.0101507297,
-0.0302356444,
-0.0088292854,
0.0351912789,
0.0379281715,
0.0114401877,
-0.011069864,
-0.0108429631,
0.0760133639,
0.0380201079,
0.0538321994,
-0.0091529107,
-0.0510824993,
0.0153782126,
-0.0665729046,
-0.0188790578,
0.0526175462,
-0.0387356207,
-0.0395276099,
-0.0182700027,
-0.0465330705,
-0.0718532428,
-0.0361226238,
-0.0190730914,
-0.0137234079,
0.0134624653,
0.0304508451,
-0.0032158117,
0.0222093966,
0.0549698509,
-0.0021882073,
-0.0536132604,
-0.0035702763,
-0.0760485306,
-0.0115625365,
0.0004384594,
-0.1013837308,
0.0203307047,
-0.0511688814,
0.0077459277,
-0.023139393,
-0.0277151726,
0.0625566393,
0.0212813225,
0.0360980332,
0.0017903955,
-0.0387050025,
-0.0044608968,
0.0392649062,
-0.0331223458,
-0.0382349193,
0.0230448637,
0.0506964065,
0.009774291,
0.0067707966,
-0.005876116,
0.0224580821,
-0.0318731517,
-0.0133708222,
-0.0191839468,
-0.0154379634,
0.0488005914,
0.0179081559,
0.0028746226,
0.0024755688,
0.0304269623,
-0.0077594672,
-0.0173866674,
-0.0330743343,
-0.0254151504,
-0.0253695268,
-0.043127168,
0.0042484449,
0.0340681411,
-0.0135893375,
-0.0424022675,
-0.0469482541,
-0.0443414524,
-0.0165086947,
0.0242002588,
-0.0269752964,
-0.0195345953,
0.0271028057,
0.0105453609,
-0.008389554,
0.0247603506,
0.0117645795,
0.0267665684,
-0.0453151055,
0.0540903173,
-0.0037291737,
-0.0343129672,
-0.0151355145,
0.0520377047,
0.0227758698,
-0.0546782725,
0.0120938914,
0.0023876517,
-0.0033970485,
-0.0300742239,
0.008061789,
-0.0915658772,
-0.0146174207,
-0.0134583954,
0.0004668842,
0.0049549481,
-0.0262555741,
-0.0258882046,
0.0255362634,
-0.0281241126,
0.0204703454,
0.0246292092,
-0.0393985957,
-0.0460183322,
-0.0199889112,
-0.0823582262,
-0.038076032,
0.020738652,
0.0003761624,
0.0428811871,
-0.058362402,
-0.015060191,
-0.0345634893,
-0.0307471026,
-0.0116976108,
-0.0126051968,
-0.0041218502,
-0.0484226942,
0.0272048116,
0.0388928428,
-0.0332113132,
-0.0327136107,
-0.059707839,
0.0030990674,
0.0018132192,
0.0112762321,
-0.0202396307,
-6.535061661e-33,
0.0358910151,
-0.0337533914,
0.018301107,
0.0889489576,
0.0506185628,
-0.071746707,
0.0070025646,
0.0512967333,
0.0597691685,
0.0242184699,
-0.0242986437,
-0.0371580273,
0.0062939553,
-0.0075730314,
0.0120910974,
-0.0407185853,
0.0651860684,
-0.0052346759,
-0.0385916196,
0.0172838625,
0.0151208434,
0.0042906585,
-0.0002964468,
-0.108770363,
0.037795417,
-0.0606005453,
-0.030527724,
-0.0026665507,
0.0284066964,
0.0026912461,
-0.0170376915,
0.027780544,
0.0096078478,
-0.0335934274,
0.0544126593,
0.0323118642,
-0.0259361099,
0.0022037835,
0.0770634785,
0.0093109552,
0.0235926509,
-0.0084698936,
-0.0256558806,
-0.0343225971,
-0.0333753265,
0.0776977465,
0.0162329711,
-0.0381728262,
0.0006312174,
-0.0002294588,
-0.0481989123,
0.0149670225,
-0.0056169205,
0.0120518198,
0.017013967,
0.0719140396,
-0.048980318,
0.0558398701,
-0.0541914105,
0.0350225009,
0.0091761006,
-0.013197761,
0.0195418429,
-0.0494786128,
-0.0493199155,
0.0374938026,
0.0044327737,
0.0029578959,
-0.0078706797,
0.0281623472,
-0.0352507979,
0.0705847666,
0.0041447389,
0.0512755513,
-0.0193542764,
-0.0281160008,
0.0218652971,
0.03760482,
0.0742591619,
-0.0638909265,
0.0898308083,
0.0249749217,
-0.0487325639,
-0.0361857787,
0.0348352976,
-0.0183760822,
-0.0499028526,
-0.0990181491,
0.0075032567,
0.0485669374,
-0.0298065003,
0.0098858951,
-0.0088102613,
-0.0329423733,
-0.0628424287,
-0.0143636717,
0.0030428199,
-0.0163712874,
0.0047822376,
-0.0279306788,
-0.0191194452,
0.0163795575,
-0.0650381744,
-0.0090777678,
0.0008174093,
0.00715004,
0.0306345541,
0.0000468245,
-0.00768054,
0.0231496189,
0.0450913198,
0.0003565579,
-0.0097666234,
-0.0325033404,
0.0230828878,
0.010718747,
-0.0038838948,
0.0595064685,
0.0102402829,
0.0388656333,
-0.0206006467,
-0.0529471673,
-0.002186904,
-0.0071231732,
-0.0202385373,
-0.0133684706,
-0.046577096,
-0.0196274091,
0.0543899313,
-0.0419040509,
-0.0092927245,
-0.039723862,
2.814e-7,
-0.0119989403,
0.0700630993,
-0.0872686803,
-0.0578097478,
-0.0167382639,
0.0625420138,
0.0194283389,
-0.0093077635,
0.0594309494,
0.029649999,
0.026984321,
-0.0030136849,
0.0345767736,
0.0513009466,
-0.0479528755,
-0.0248821583,
-0.05255704,
-0.0287682712,
-0.0524181202,
0.0344810635,
0.0305934027,
0.0244513657,
0.0435879566,
0.0083882539,
0.0031486733,
-0.0053162663,
0.0333668254,
-0.1027348116,
-0.0391709358,
0.006828621,
0.0233204197,
0.0202630367,
-0.0122050382,
-0.0382505171,
-0.0385369472,
-0.0002116096,
0.0063481345,
0.0188726988,
0.021562878,
0.0187127031,
0.0245619752,
0.0004323692,
0.0162443742,
-0.0573237799,
0.0220248289,
-0.0246514156,
-0.0173042528,
-0.0606142618,
-0.009450946,
-0.0346072055,
0.0046645682,
-0.0223911051,
-0.0631714538,
0.0147373183,
0.007646881,
-0.0049308697,
-0.0226305369,
-0.0318326801,
0.0466888957,
0.011754781,
-0.0112186987,
-0.024473846,
-0.0272383559,
0.0169105995,
-0.0016367114,
-0.0093574263,
0.0430173315,
2.079033033e-34,
0.0411600098,
0.0164281651,
0.0012487535,
-0.0052921055,
0.0559959114,
0.0174487289,
0.0106741041,
-0.012493846,
0.0465603545,
-0.0180541128,
-0.0027632592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14291v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14291v2 | Founding a mathematical diffusion model in linguistics. The case study of German syntactic features in the North-Eastern Italian dialects | 2023-07-26T16:49:11 | 2023-09-16T19:19:01 | I. Lazzizzera | cs.CL | cs.CL | The initial motivation for this work was the linguistic case of the spread of
Germanic syntactic features into Romance dialects of North-Eastern Italy, which
occurred after the immigration of German people to Tyrol during the High Middle
Ages. To obtain a representation of the data over the territory suitable for a
mathematical formulation, an interactive map is produced as a first step, using
tools of what is called Geographic Data Science. A smooth two-dimensional
surface G is introduced, expressing locally which fraction of territory uses a
given German language feature: it is obtained by a piecewise cubic curvature
minimizing interpolant of the discrete function that says if at any surveyed
locality that feature is used or not. This surface G is thought of as the value
at the present time of a function describing a diffusion-convection phenomenon
in two dimensions (here said tidal mode), which is subjected in a very natural
way to the same equation used in physics, introducing a contextual diffusivity
concept: it is shown that with two different assumptions about diffusivity,
solutions of this equation, evaluated at the present time, fit well with the
data interpolated by G, thus providing two convincing different pictures of
diffusion-convection in the case under study, albeit simplifications and
approximations. Very importantly, it is shown that the linguistic diffusion
model known to linguists as Schmidt waves can be counted among the solutions of
the diffusion equation | [
-0.0298787709,
0.0060659535,
-0.0349092148,
0.0054593938,
-0.0501297936,
-0.0189367719,
0.0078923944,
-0.044061143,
0.0073797521,
-0.0179803297,
0.0413366184,
-0.053364791,
0.0438096523,
-0.0554313138,
0.034453176,
-0.0849692225,
0.0177004095,
-0.0298954342,
-0.0238599181,
-0.0104653658,
0.0112560205,
-0.0420181602,
-0.0018766605,
0.0025589075,
-0.0038008229,
0.013764943,
0.0089444676,
-0.0587741658,
0.024099201,
-0.0077340375,
-0.0250837859,
0.0183017999,
0.013911223,
-0.005362351,
0.0000019058,
0.0025892272,
0.0087196566,
0.0076161325,
0.033145044,
0.003506735,
0.0946542248,
0.0397828892,
-0.0216473732,
-0.0659683719,
0.009451394,
0.0736566782,
0.0113382246,
-0.0335004665,
0.0175537169,
-0.0178053882,
-0.0197662879,
-0.1018950492,
-0.000082462,
0.008354241,
0.0294973701,
0.0345998518,
0.0156634096,
0.0227290299,
0.0419025943,
-0.0132301077,
-0.0469569601,
0.0683060214,
-0.0386202857,
0.0101528764,
-0.0010992374,
0.0138958013,
0.0322957039,
0.007110476,
-0.001012167,
0.01416534,
0.034055762,
0.0113118747,
0.0121386023,
0.0399240777,
-0.0248339288,
0.1027370691,
-0.0188879073,
-0.0650827289,
-0.0211935136,
-0.0065004532,
0.021239372,
-0.062859036,
-0.0173399486,
-0.0032287687,
-0.069816038,
0.1372243911,
0.0445954762,
-0.0268883631,
-0.0139962751,
-0.014253661,
0.0228558294,
-0.0838013887,
-0.0130862975,
0.0671890974,
0.0241636876,
0.0108210919,
0.0405724831,
-0.0133976284,
0.0088186553,
-0.0580465123,
0.035722252,
-0.0567631982,
-0.0017855663,
0.0384282172,
0.010972538,
0.0088134892,
-0.0248210896,
-0.0090695331,
-0.0073814946,
-0.0024482752,
-0.0460316017,
-0.0052516805,
-0.0367500223,
-0.0223696548,
0.0380310044,
0.0557947382,
-0.0174547564,
-0.00874958,
0.0329143405,
-0.0586320497,
0.0042096432,
-0.0589510277,
0.0364412144,
0.0288451873,
-0.0408470333,
0.0101380553,
-0.0472968593,
0.0032205163,
-0.0440669134,
0.0341362022,
0.0340380073,
0.0164067205,
-0.0024990835,
-0.0124023817,
-0.0273160487,
-0.022559084,
0.0041779205,
0.0222264566,
-0.0102363452,
0.0176953673,
-0.069027096,
-0.0230863951,
-0.0117215253,
-0.0833877772,
-0.0202261992,
-0.0009237759,
-0.0139716957,
0.0028864138,
-0.0283657406,
-0.0051280004,
-0.0694751889,
-0.0401214212,
-0.0609511957,
0.0063034603,
0.0436963141,
-0.0157319922,
0.0758378431,
0.0297976807,
0.0227314159,
-0.0505513176,
-0.0216017831,
-0.0364743732,
-0.0098394565,
0.0011068031,
0.0473267399,
0.0661195889,
-0.1021144763,
-0.0357639939,
-0.0062491791,
-0.0019969656,
0.0554540567,
0.0637295395,
-0.0256781243,
-0.0396552347,
0.0303164497,
0.093973577,
0.0150954956,
0.017942328,
0.0119785666,
0.0445037074,
-0.027185956,
0.0391989611,
0.0757653341,
-0.0495221838,
0.0435815901,
-0.03551488,
0.017236596,
0.0403271317,
-0.0011482157,
-0.0370689407,
0.0133020077,
-0.0159919765,
0.088391684,
-0.0365760699,
0.0475485437,
-0.0010224103,
0.0499932989,
0.0207625721,
0.002921154,
-0.0058356435,
0.013159615,
0.0239525791,
0.0581295677,
0.0294302851,
-0.0197672788,
0.016674025,
0.0178057812,
0.037766397,
0.0097629474,
-0.0128513845,
0.0188302975,
0.043537572,
-0.0248304531,
-0.0101140169,
0.0058601648,
0.0542814769,
-0.0067563048,
0.0177256279,
-0.0869412869,
0.0633772612,
-0.0096729426,
-0.0352297127,
0.0188313928,
-0.0265172645,
0.0146856271,
0.04702406,
-0.0528622903,
-0.0001083618,
-0.0185014941,
0.0165687185,
-0.001324366,
0.0140044838,
-0.0105820829,
-0.0449757762,
-0.0211395249,
0.057923574,
0.0424117334,
0.0464573652,
0.0116847297,
0.0044825603,
0.0451994836,
-0.0841376558,
0.0212027691,
-0.0152238859,
0.056863606,
-0.074183844,
0.0929853022,
0.035222467,
0.0003992727,
-0.0145281358,
0.032538753,
-0.0169978645,
0.0483652949,
-0.0005019287,
0.057352338,
-0.07017643,
-0.0006481259,
0.0154557824,
0.0116687138,
-0.0149679072,
-0.022722533,
-0.0100948438,
-0.0195551198,
0.0029972475,
-0.0434603915,
0.0030794099,
-0.0024051422,
-0.0545188226,
-0.0380692706,
-0.0086562885,
0.0356654264,
-0.0239139479,
0.0089084394,
-0.0003945415,
0.0574059263,
-0.0027021023,
0.0005014865,
0.001412968,
-0.0198867116,
0.0146735432,
-0.0377553664,
-0.0390840322,
-0.0298588146,
-0.0134614389,
0.0114405118,
0.0336342677,
0.0066314177,
-0.0523560867,
-0.0246036202,
-0.0144548984,
-0.0723473281,
0.0265447572,
-0.0052521531,
-0.0308316946,
-0.000060647,
-0.0020835819,
0.043581035,
-0.0397723243,
-0.0128561724,
-0.0277855489,
-0.014119192,
-0.0991673023,
0.0131880734,
-0.0236966759,
-0.0317246057,
0.0629678741,
-0.0774801895,
-0.0564679541,
0.0438962877,
0.0592229776,
0.0258571561,
-0.0209879018,
0.0208175294,
0.0147934081,
-0.0837496817,
0.0168700647,
0.0118978797,
-0.0168717057,
-0.0237973705,
0.0446283706,
-0.0173989013,
-0.0324723162,
-0.0134469057,
-0.0213950705,
0.0233892631,
-0.0763450414,
-0.0312391873,
-0.0216615815,
-0.0009634826,
-0.013771357,
0.020267291,
0.0115970578,
-0.0138410972,
0.0226007476,
-0.0775169134,
0.0030023546,
-0.0053335032,
0.0283008069,
-0.0755741596,
0.0142135033,
0.038766861,
0.0201261528,
0.0375825912,
-0.0550334454,
0.03757523,
-0.0100351609,
0.0323947854,
-0.0549559034,
0.0934856236,
0.0400171317,
0.0332790352,
0.0103147989,
0.0267729685,
0.0233945362,
-0.0022577154,
0.0175081212,
0.0391006172,
0.1141739562,
-0.0380727425,
0.0395163521,
-0.0101529323,
-0.0141867697,
0.0084884651,
0.0510493331,
0.0074266521,
0.0254429467,
-0.0034732588,
0.0074302037,
-0.0630745292,
-0.0144248186,
0.0540922098,
-0.0019979179,
-0.0221612081,
0.0051501188,
0.0048602731,
-0.0042422945,
0.0203349963,
-0.0208368041,
0.0400788225,
-0.0009227638,
-0.0084684547,
-0.0133026233,
0.0859114602,
-0.0035467572,
-0.0420976356,
-0.0371795036,
0.003602871,
0.0193235744,
-0.0227622017,
0.0679091662,
0.0124522969,
-0.016806962,
0.0393550657,
-0.0681203529,
-0.018144168,
0.0600318722,
-0.0634685233,
-0.0671725348,
0.0356129818,
-0.0074012638,
0.0272729974,
-0.0357959494,
-0.0235210061,
-0.0145113114,
-0.0348622054,
-0.0009480887,
-0.0136701018,
0.0457803272,
-0.0729372278,
-0.0832371339,
0.0172887109,
0.0473188236,
0.0183743685,
-0.0014071991,
-0.0161806326,
0.1036314443,
0.0232040193,
-0.0538625531,
-0.0469003282,
-0.0223504137,
0.0116367191,
0.0302904043,
0.070854798,
-0.0061486554,
0.0160887167,
-0.0308640599,
0.0198569037,
0.0319614448,
0.0102421073,
0.0393705703,
-0.0210651942,
0.0047248253,
-0.038576927,
0.044439774,
0.0820108205,
-0.0972140282,
0.0184219759,
-0.0139461551,
-0.113424629,
-0.0574728437,
0.0432241522,
-0.0271176491,
0.0907763168,
0.0513166599,
0.006626369,
0.0685791522,
-0.0590575784,
-0.0153378025,
-0.0145909758,
0.0014949448,
0.0367497876,
-0.0051040738,
-0.0140128238,
0.0154143209,
0.0007313972,
-0.0427473523,
-0.0401302874,
-0.0173215084,
-0.0598787367,
0.0353946611,
0.020182427,
0.023052251,
-0.0013843778,
-0.0325393192,
-0.0236816425,
0.0446655564,
-0.028079249,
0.0119466139,
0.0380408429,
-0.0023560177,
-0.0483778641,
0.0588995852,
-0.0395909138,
0.0007713831,
0.0116751222,
-0.0380727574,
-0.0283239521,
-0.0598481856,
-0.0037880202,
-0.0204761494,
-0.0516379103,
0.0403736494,
0.0214728601,
0.0169360228,
0.0219948906,
-0.0057330197,
0.0240072347,
-0.0289906897,
0.0131181087,
0.0111932429,
0.0241212472,
0.0047678566,
-0.0286656972,
-0.0303206239,
-0.0220127869,
-0.0189608298,
0.0530823283,
0.0431939662,
0.0225498155,
0.047702264,
0.0065833898,
0.0586123317,
-0.0045163054,
0.0241807662,
-0.0511190705,
0.0344467387,
0.0335972235,
-0.0443900302,
-0.0133075882,
-0.0354290716,
-0.0011412913,
-0.0137110716,
-0.0249295328,
-0.0534385033,
-0.0089349868,
-0.0080673313,
0.0133646606,
0.0300571378,
0.0423019864,
-0.0157486796,
0.016729055,
0.0016216352,
-0.034584526,
-0.0253114197,
-0.0014524268,
0.0118948678,
0.0140617257,
0.0052696336,
0.0083996207,
-0.0232107621,
-0.0541860461,
0.0007178519,
-0.025633309,
-0.0433139019,
0.0028401874,
0.0099543706,
-0.0228175893,
-0.0226877388,
0.000165787,
-0.014039252,
-0.0635597855,
-0.0382108837,
-0.0039311042,
-0.0038456582,
-0.0166070908,
-0.0283941943,
0.0302976687,
0.0471975394,
-0.0467782654,
0.0302711949,
-0.0295854174,
0.0741772875,
-0.0780281723,
-0.0244785435,
0.0219097398,
-5.814252566e-33,
-0.0219256859,
0.0028221637,
0.0275844503,
-0.0004732053,
-0.0205816552,
-0.0348286852,
-0.00865616,
-0.0017062933,
-0.0578901432,
0.0242794454,
0.0208851732,
-0.0279523637,
-0.0003368119,
-0.0076283165,
-0.0034043193,
0.0166436043,
-0.0236631706,
-0.0004156397,
0.0209602248,
0.0130269667,
0.027347235,
-0.0346847437,
0.0221852195,
-0.0428867117,
0.0238283481,
-0.0006950508,
-0.0280202813,
0.0181267448,
-0.0029247322,
-0.0094687631,
-0.0238880459,
0.0158305019,
0.0271381736,
-0.0014010586,
-0.0147839086,
0.0029402135,
0.0395318232,
-0.0948823839,
0.0119327698,
0.0542277545,
0.0115649253,
-0.0512375683,
0.0127117084,
0.0127319023,
-0.0320064127,
0.0798272938,
0.0345842578,
0.0172940884,
-0.0465468131,
0.0548971966,
-0.0117085688,
0.0089153061,
-0.0224985145,
-0.0038178365,
0.0179871097,
-0.0154540157,
-0.0100543387,
-0.0104509015,
-0.0324706286,
0.0535109229,
0.065158844,
0.0451313891,
-0.0006447277,
-0.0146147981,
0.0390301198,
0.0172708984,
0.0848558024,
0.0107924631,
0.0165727604,
-0.0042431736,
0.0553331859,
0.0240499172,
-0.0346328132,
-0.0075978879,
0.0550398491,
-0.0129602337,
0.0059285974,
-0.0245586261,
-0.0279195011,
-0.0316963904,
-0.0440191962,
0.0038428211,
-0.0036402501,
-0.0122169144,
-0.0093655931,
-0.0460343435,
0.0242298134,
0.0105542941,
-0.0161244031,
-0.0785682574,
0.0975900143,
-0.0059559229,
-0.0004546238,
0.0143048363,
-0.0404854454,
-0.0475628339,
0.0092154266,
0.0377541818,
0.0023192395,
0.0349349342,
-0.001906329,
-0.0425098538,
-0.0686128661,
0.0590877049,
0.0061022858,
0.0418895595,
-0.0262535438,
0.0258971322,
0.010375645,
-0.0144923599,
0.0060703587,
-0.0594576001,
0.0099278297,
0.0417673513,
0.0317520462,
-0.0000101349,
-0.0024778694,
0.0387796834,
0.0689341277,
0.0150519973,
0.0296607111,
0.018939063,
-0.0153358504,
0.0343761742,
-0.0023624643,
0.0035293507,
0.0199787356,
0.0450376719,
0.0324921943,
-0.0265420768,
-0.0029232376,
0.0322313234,
2.841e-7,
0.0383661836,
0.0476581939,
0.0061504291,
-0.0046501602,
0.0351162478,
-0.0316205807,
-0.0083013857,
-0.0180017781,
-0.0050192517,
-0.0296711382,
0.0102311382,
0.0049407533,
0.0228910986,
0.0554491282,
-0.0619635321,
0.0228124689,
-0.0167352576,
-0.0572411083,
-0.0328971334,
0.0035054917,
0.026561955,
0.0091182822,
0.0390321426,
-0.0274965279,
-0.0133922575,
0.027438309,
0.0324119776,
-0.0201926492,
0.0204039365,
0.0268925577,
0.0094066113,
-0.0744303167,
0.0116529344,
-0.0030335616,
0.0156590659,
0.0090187117,
0.0278120227,
-0.0527455695,
-0.0162214842,
0.0100071169,
0.0032065853,
-0.0436629355,
-0.0269570649,
-0.036920432,
0.0070089637,
0.0235455632,
0.0244934279,
-0.0346760415,
-0.0293689631,
0.0383293964,
0.0592987202,
-0.0088676773,
-0.0308661163,
-0.0410397723,
0.0252216738,
-0.014807011,
-0.0066108103,
0.0212938543,
-0.0109731639,
0.0512978397,
-0.0385569148,
-0.0409142189,
0.0010278244,
0.0078256615,
0.0485641249,
0.0120805027,
0.007644501,
2.39072064e-34,
0.0133506488,
-0.020251587,
0.0036349955,
-0.0179483443,
-0.0371729471,
0.0209380705,
-0.0149240978,
0.0336797312,
0.0146140568,
-0.0286543239,
-0.0095713194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16819v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.16819v1 | The flow of ideas in word embeddings | 2023-07-26T15:51:31 | 2023-07-26T15:51:31 | Debayan Dasgupta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The flow of ideas has been extensively studied by physicists, psychologists,
and machine learning engineers. This paper adopts specific tools from
microrheology to investigate the similarity-based flow of ideas. We introduce a
random walker in word embeddings and study its behavior. Such
similarity-mediated random walks through the embedding space show signatures of
anomalous diffusion commonly observed in complex structured systems such as
biological cells and complex fluids. The paper concludes by proposing the
application of popular tools employed in the study of random walks and
diffusion of particles under Brownian motion to assess quantitatively the
incorporation of diverse ideas in a document. Overall, this paper presents a
self-referenced method combining microrheology and machine learning concepts to
explore the meandering tendencies of language models and their potential
association with creativity. | [
0.0140131498,
-0.0176943839,
-0.0349468887,
0.0385870375,
-0.0684136748,
0.0141893495,
-0.0378760956,
-0.0065137683,
-0.0054595298,
0.0076913736,
0.0485232994,
-0.0615611039,
0.0056446306,
0.0034909481,
0.0395556241,
-0.0585439391,
0.0098940022,
-0.0355169103,
-0.0032521365,
-0.012212649,
-0.0139222564,
-0.0559127741,
0.0137594296,
0.0170884039,
0.0450098254,
-0.0082270978,
-0.0165697113,
-0.0172986649,
0.019282151,
-0.0304860305,
-0.0807605013,
0.0282823145,
0.0173094478,
0.075223498,
0.0000016282,
-0.0333149992,
0.0153285256,
0.0108880028,
0.0503702909,
-0.038040258,
0.0430697724,
0.0247211196,
-0.0166232102,
-0.0140095539,
0.0064876648,
0.0266162902,
0.0502029732,
0.0608939305,
0.0088536255,
0.0133862803,
-0.0112871621,
-0.0454355143,
0.0394217931,
-0.0091658281,
0.0790866017,
0.0559464768,
0.0330077596,
0.0339618959,
-0.0117790131,
-0.0080094375,
-0.0686702654,
0.024608843,
-0.0143429907,
0.0275852308,
0.0584129468,
0.0351488627,
0.0307944883,
-0.0091300178,
0.0144851804,
0.062074177,
-0.0498354472,
0.0145854317,
-0.0004620739,
-0.0077281352,
-0.0300023668,
0.1044889838,
-0.0438209362,
-0.0111136418,
0.0122479806,
0.0039253319,
-0.0021213412,
-0.0095810713,
0.0446988083,
-0.0151534444,
-0.0295497607,
0.0273605809,
0.0437406786,
-0.0413049161,
-0.0145989293,
-0.0073780501,
0.0487212352,
-0.0434479788,
-0.017105449,
-0.0068069375,
0.1002507359,
0.019448407,
0.0128922155,
0.0518859513,
0.0231687427,
-0.0595920868,
0.0702909082,
-0.024348069,
0.0661321729,
0.0593747795,
-0.0036018169,
-0.0375264473,
-0.0647004023,
-0.0054667993,
-0.0254847631,
0.0391802043,
-0.0525552891,
0.0037160174,
-0.0039231977,
0.0234807879,
0.0324390866,
-0.1067456454,
-0.0434000008,
0.0429484248,
0.0280786902,
-0.0548299067,
-0.0413867198,
0.0092216516,
0.0550284833,
0.0277881883,
-0.0242174454,
-0.0230142325,
-0.0304749385,
0.0233732723,
0.0001818668,
0.0599974953,
-0.0301555824,
0.0049613896,
0.0011995281,
-0.0159672871,
-0.0380956978,
0.0340906791,
0.0430383794,
-0.0431445502,
-0.0297904219,
-0.0271957424,
-0.007257292,
0.0061254092,
0.0497706905,
-0.0755632147,
-0.0172137283,
0.0121945525,
0.0085830782,
0.0026067887,
-0.0069897384,
-0.0088568078,
-0.0818492472,
0.0378557332,
-0.0174284764,
-0.0020179586,
0.0293750688,
0.01196934,
0.0547692291,
0.0264353082,
0.0672820508,
-0.0130371805,
0.0106116096,
-0.0248640049,
0.0112025887,
-0.0044724913,
0.0076057338,
0.0009478355,
0.0252066944,
-0.0502415448,
-0.0060725524,
0.071605593,
0.0207132157,
0.0573116243,
-0.0353370793,
0.0102586616,
0.034814965,
0.1307728142,
0.0095670102,
0.0317391902,
0.0450800322,
-0.0293670259,
-0.0087356968,
0.0694930628,
0.0490680896,
0.0159684736,
0.0150468368,
0.0102997283,
0.0778269544,
0.0330472067,
-0.0197833292,
0.0408809744,
-0.0136068612,
0.0118239224,
0.033542417,
-0.0839447975,
0.0138664367,
0.0043612509,
0.0106716007,
0.0010658533,
0.0045753582,
-0.0156996865,
-0.0365629904,
0.0002508628,
0.0032670032,
0.0735436156,
0.0338035934,
0.0079985792,
0.0321837664,
-0.0172791034,
-0.0250003114,
0.0418941602,
-0.0015153029,
0.0123069594,
-0.0534385778,
-0.0120898047,
0.0140945502,
0.02329918,
-0.0012425223,
0.019972425,
-0.0799958482,
0.049173221,
-0.00434874,
-0.0106662558,
-0.0191379022,
0.0187603626,
-0.0324078538,
0.0108517092,
-0.0233903397,
-0.0082951318,
0.0134839602,
-0.0102845002,
-0.0551740266,
0.0397601314,
0.0237883572,
-0.0400540344,
-0.0601662397,
0.0475802347,
0.0074764783,
-0.0055895308,
-0.004216257,
-0.0499459058,
0.034234412,
-0.0287851784,
0.0591756105,
-0.0134975268,
0.0490815565,
-0.0475263223,
0.0685406774,
-0.0276891906,
0.0136608612,
-0.0206539258,
0.043992091,
-0.0111318026,
0.042233903,
0.0017634733,
0.0810771361,
-0.0446578488,
0.0021937503,
0.0361321643,
0.0077819456,
-0.0348648615,
0.0017421646,
0.0393127799,
0.0089022415,
0.0126969125,
-0.0486688316,
-0.0131123569,
-0.0240293387,
-0.0043315762,
-0.0504595563,
0.0193061158,
0.0261348467,
-0.0215869844,
-0.0002210404,
-0.0040113931,
0.0448985286,
0.025365673,
0.0078392224,
0.003068862,
0.0358708203,
0.04691796,
-0.0662490651,
-0.0357426964,
-0.0186431203,
-0.0034716588,
-0.0242888387,
0.0540009849,
0.0330212191,
-0.0067204093,
-0.0092587471,
0.0146577889,
-0.0568981767,
-0.0302377511,
-0.005108064,
-0.0138703501,
0.0328326263,
-0.0201254431,
0.0780773908,
0.0169275161,
0.0185311716,
0.0368001759,
0.0472806282,
-0.0320158973,
0.0236539207,
-0.0461044163,
-0.03765608,
0.1125847548,
-0.0479017012,
-0.0183971506,
-0.0013745179,
0.0607478544,
0.0326352157,
-0.000678086,
-0.0241370443,
0.0638171658,
-0.0435240082,
-0.0000510037,
0.0169754028,
0.0010886312,
-0.041760236,
0.0459219478,
0.0030201867,
-0.0230957102,
0.0742720515,
0.0004799383,
0.0256025176,
-0.0074025602,
-0.0191589128,
-0.0209375527,
0.060434863,
-0.0118612973,
0.0031065119,
-0.0123780388,
0.0075173578,
-0.0191778466,
-0.0104977917,
0.0220037382,
-0.0096385144,
-0.0045733866,
-0.00107177,
-0.0082941381,
0.0192992836,
0.0255749337,
0.0085460488,
-0.0810626596,
0.0117944805,
-0.0106457025,
0.1015724838,
-0.0719143748,
-0.0048004435,
0.0384796038,
0.0309509318,
-0.0112871723,
-0.0073354067,
-0.0266124047,
0.0210675262,
0.0851411372,
0.0527153946,
-0.0293763541,
0.0558618009,
-0.011475944,
0.0542787686,
0.0055851447,
-0.0118361525,
0.0070810914,
-0.0415475555,
0.0112861516,
-0.0305948257,
-0.0099899452,
-0.0224231165,
-0.0227745138,
0.0302300472,
-0.0201938432,
-0.0486651324,
0.0726851821,
0.0313017666,
0.0015550291,
0.0069867629,
-0.0223025866,
0.0260896068,
0.0008687046,
0.0059917872,
0.0124932006,
0.0242996272,
-0.0268562045,
-0.0350318179,
-0.0332013369,
-0.0436567105,
0.001758321,
-0.0648114458,
0.025601225,
0.0156223793,
-0.0188410096,
-0.0184084773,
-0.0562848262,
-0.0145564908,
0.0546431169,
-0.0585696958,
-0.0340531915,
-0.0005142072,
0.0231589787,
0.0000505114,
-0.0383407958,
-0.0123471953,
-0.0108331377,
-0.0481407009,
0.0447646193,
0.0285723396,
0.0484427474,
-0.046331469,
-0.0839827433,
-0.0335488841,
-0.0361078754,
0.0064407424,
-0.007970389,
0.0267976783,
0.0294993371,
0.0101553313,
-0.0377808549,
-0.0121650966,
-0.0304002501,
-0.0195986703,
-0.0254671331,
0.1212523431,
-0.0483257957,
-0.0867606699,
-0.0510866381,
-0.0012987751,
0.0112366332,
0.0573243238,
0.0201890208,
-0.0443793684,
-0.020904135,
-0.0355459563,
0.045516666,
0.0556867868,
-0.0561941899,
-0.060602393,
0.0270117614,
-0.0116761373,
-0.0892906785,
-0.0105319144,
-0.0181270633,
0.0984948725,
0.0211709067,
0.0635656342,
-0.0052887639,
-0.0537815914,
-0.0230682231,
-0.0363067724,
0.0230829176,
0.0053202882,
0.0222031176,
-0.0018965902,
0.0120698819,
-0.0142236967,
-0.043633271,
-0.0142047219,
-0.1134660766,
-0.0987202078,
-0.0028121858,
-0.0173861999,
0.0244542547,
-0.0027431278,
-0.0107200714,
-0.0382750109,
0.0499863699,
-0.0154745178,
0.0281373635,
0.0281433426,
-0.0116823567,
0.0230003949,
0.0181623176,
0.0076473025,
-0.0035490883,
0.0028493879,
0.0011613229,
0.0150036402,
-0.0607368276,
-0.0540848337,
-0.0207333863,
-0.0309958085,
0.0150376232,
0.022121463,
-0.0315687135,
-0.0038347081,
-0.0078215245,
0.023328973,
-0.0065533263,
-0.0184704307,
-0.0368429534,
0.0562459417,
-0.0107465191,
-0.0441583917,
0.0136318924,
-0.0247133952,
-0.0051816721,
0.0128236944,
-0.0110936053,
0.0143966647,
0.0080164727,
-0.0159199331,
0.0266716611,
0.021215979,
0.0294344705,
-0.0660089254,
0.0157990437,
0.0184975229,
0.0183221046,
0.0037914689,
0.0136344787,
-0.0284220744,
-0.0107694846,
-0.1168565005,
-0.0489413403,
0.0222860537,
0.0480414033,
0.0131696528,
-0.0106844334,
0.0357611068,
-0.0459537469,
0.010860553,
0.0175789557,
-0.0060911737,
-0.0376215279,
0.0359575115,
0.0329412706,
0.0304534528,
-0.0085232947,
0.0243432093,
0.0413913243,
-0.0445576571,
0.0149600003,
-0.0010810426,
-0.0354060829,
-0.0103579024,
0.0355975628,
0.0252422746,
0.0357950479,
0.0146501176,
0.0228313506,
-0.0733761489,
-0.0305743869,
0.0760600492,
0.0233267602,
0.019580137,
-0.0203214381,
0.0202072002,
0.0781316683,
-0.0020582357,
0.0343694836,
-0.0382861942,
0.0216928162,
-0.0444614403,
-0.0358072184,
-0.0390794203,
-5.915670545e-33,
0.0053052707,
-0.0338123143,
0.0102563938,
0.0176876485,
-0.0085636266,
-0.045897238,
-0.0351203755,
0.0049858629,
-0.016891133,
0.0608329922,
0.0218462758,
0.0129324384,
-0.0156234214,
-0.0109728482,
0.0402783975,
0.0184576046,
-0.0124904066,
-0.00140683,
0.0124737704,
-0.0055395807,
0.0249764454,
0.0158761498,
-0.0212663524,
-0.0328816846,
0.006808409,
-0.017895313,
0.056977842,
-0.0110126659,
0.0006469505,
0.0022480653,
-0.0527529977,
-0.0086185988,
0.0183044709,
0.012215592,
-0.0239311196,
-0.0249530599,
0.0377698764,
-0.0531635471,
-0.02174519,
-0.0248976853,
-0.0248137377,
-0.0250007678,
0.0513023809,
-0.0211536959,
-0.0202594493,
-0.0083248112,
0.0651154891,
0.0222320501,
-0.0609909557,
-0.0114259105,
-0.0637152269,
0.0244891029,
-0.022708945,
-0.0149947545,
0.0181555785,
-0.1080355644,
0.0174551364,
-0.0216161385,
-0.0259217247,
0.0435493588,
-0.0338259824,
0.0091813738,
-0.0195024665,
-0.0017651452,
0.0436158106,
0.0600738041,
0.0438418426,
0.0431096591,
0.0073583662,
0.0158617999,
0.0391118079,
0.0281637497,
0.0263653714,
0.0195038356,
0.038253881,
0.009645002,
-0.0051036081,
-0.0041079386,
-0.0267975442,
0.0001913199,
0.0453400649,
-0.0120970588,
-0.0310040768,
-0.0175078418,
0.0143377027,
-0.0766162053,
0.0032851116,
-0.0247851089,
-0.0311517604,
-0.0351174437,
0.0252372995,
-0.0116777318,
0.0240642242,
-0.0076688221,
-0.0424295999,
0.0013240512,
-0.0318689272,
0.0422077663,
0.0104450593,
0.0020083576,
-0.0220987257,
-0.0287865736,
-0.0443258695,
0.0482467562,
-0.0009909685,
-0.0154399611,
-0.0275805388,
0.0011391781,
-0.0512913726,
-0.0401957259,
-0.0070387013,
-0.0674101934,
0.0189966168,
-0.0426326804,
0.0266021937,
-0.0230414607,
-0.0192068554,
-0.0055270805,
0.0376254581,
0.0308777448,
0.0069652046,
0.0362758003,
-0.0433259383,
0.0025528683,
-0.0284766648,
-0.0225824676,
-0.0322879478,
0.0652967021,
0.0560922027,
-0.0786222443,
-0.0225430839,
0.0246667042,
2.547e-7,
0.0403768793,
0.0722168162,
0.0075504323,
0.0078870337,
0.0316150151,
-0.0149230212,
-0.0452568233,
-0.019106647,
-0.0102617042,
-0.0275013093,
0.0234379079,
0.0290257931,
0.016627213,
0.020277895,
-0.0875203237,
-0.0022626945,
-0.0607064292,
0.022301089,
0.0089237243,
-0.0284872521,
-0.0056403098,
0.0423046239,
0.0440010987,
-0.0203921273,
-0.0171597544,
-0.0545915477,
0.0495086014,
0.0079713203,
0.0557518676,
-0.0233534593,
-0.0338257626,
-0.0494188033,
-0.0095932316,
0.0004572866,
0.0010527049,
0.0073763202,
0.0212256555,
-0.0505702198,
-0.0247351974,
0.0424010828,
-0.0174970794,
-0.01930934,
0.0051016179,
-0.0303783789,
0.011456891,
0.0023654744,
-0.0272005349,
-0.0625060201,
0.007824624,
0.0072892415,
0.0796895996,
0.0225478858,
-0.0129303271,
-0.0211824235,
-0.0168582518,
-0.0032984298,
0.0268912781,
-0.0462532379,
0.0190036464,
-0.0079300757,
-0.0443010069,
-0.0444944128,
-0.0279975832,
-0.0218409672,
0.058767125,
-0.0126149924,
-0.0283002313,
2.372068621e-34,
0.0748285949,
-0.031735424,
0.0029889138,
0.0166665986,
-0.0053435233,
-0.003697119,
0.0336989462,
-0.0184943601,
0.0255732518,
-0.0711990446,
-0.0330875516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14236v1 | UnScientify: Detecting Scientific Uncertainty in Scholarly Full Text | 2023-07-26T15:04:24 | 2023-07-26T15:04:24 | Panggih Kusuma Ningrum, Philipp Mayr, Iana Atanassova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL | This demo paper presents UnScientify, an interactive system designed to
detect scientific uncertainty in scholarly full text. The system utilizes a
weakly supervised technique that employs a fine-grained annotation scheme to
identify verbally formulated uncertainty at the sentence level in scientific
texts. The pipeline for the system includes a combination of pattern matching,
complex sentence checking, and authorial reference checking. Our approach
automates labeling and annotation tasks for scientific uncertainty
identification, taking into account different types of scientific uncertainty,
that can serve various applications such as information retrieval, text mining,
and scholarly document processing. Additionally, UnScientify provides
interpretable results, aiding in the comprehension of identified instances of
scientific uncertainty in text. | [
0.0661761463,
0.0584475361,
-0.0063845338,
0.0196206868,
-0.0392272808,
0.0158266574,
0.0169262066,
0.0119330529,
-0.0015971176,
-0.0417839587,
-0.0033932352,
0.0276920646,
-0.0034209047,
0.0009025188,
-0.0001351565,
-0.0337449163,
0.0660791919,
0.0037711975,
0.1263603717,
0.0207113549,
0.0017299706,
-0.0089018131,
-0.0138263358,
0.0257975925,
0.0301700328,
-0.0543313958,
0.0346756727,
0.0047182776,
0.0252259932,
-0.077151604,
0.0089186337,
0.0327774398,
-0.0270710886,
0.0757417753,
0.0000017388,
-0.0452459194,
-0.0490456447,
0.0342760421,
-0.0175412707,
0.0436193161,
0.0724125803,
-0.0130210472,
-0.0000696053,
-0.028001314,
-0.0031456822,
-0.0061194375,
0.0335262977,
0.0185436979,
0.0011992388,
0.0077574234,
0.0051595964,
-0.0207517557,
0.0269015301,
0.027518373,
-0.0063054762,
-0.0190528501,
0.0456723012,
-0.0039165816,
0.0216326732,
0.0835897997,
0.0422227457,
0.0332209319,
-0.0602981709,
-0.0481848381,
0.0211996734,
-0.0230087209,
-0.0255796295,
-0.0252273995,
0.001889428,
-0.0001840638,
0.0601906106,
-0.0361903794,
0.0347259566,
-0.0049235909,
-0.0012075132,
0.0690722093,
-0.0062881429,
-0.0092407893,
-0.0145856002,
-0.0407841131,
-0.0034174484,
0.0111577231,
-0.0003814228,
0.0373243354,
0.0082120243,
0.0909212157,
-0.0062687113,
-0.0650023818,
-0.0064348918,
0.0188539084,
-0.0208285861,
-0.055412475,
0.0538994148,
0.0165678598,
0.010485216,
-0.0167104714,
-0.0193240326,
-0.0714647472,
0.0715274438,
-0.0130565464,
-0.0163027477,
-0.0155327572,
-0.0318173245,
0.0123870568,
0.0536592528,
-0.0142760938,
0.0027238526,
-0.0138747226,
0.022442149,
0.0351515263,
-0.0312847123,
-0.0489588343,
-0.0217381157,
-0.0358998477,
-0.0150759267,
0.0112719554,
-0.0646021888,
-0.0733216852,
-0.0201269612,
0.0219049938,
-0.0695005879,
-0.0104994699,
-0.0293985605,
0.0357766189,
-0.0338511765,
0.0370494723,
-0.0057233125,
0.0356735811,
-0.0264753886,
-0.0238432344,
-0.0009672053,
0.0278421137,
0.0255512819,
-0.0169228334,
-0.0115408935,
0.0189005453,
0.0105560729,
-0.0153555209,
0.0067660562,
-0.0659875423,
-0.0469452292,
-0.0080478545,
0.0041293269,
-0.0245410893,
0.0040023667,
0.0093997875,
0.0104307318,
-0.0250833388,
0.0112861348,
0.0019645453,
-0.0352125317,
0.074568063,
-0.0846272781,
-0.0425255373,
0.0462500304,
-0.0152945481,
0.0183515791,
-0.0399564579,
0.0251116417,
-0.0235199351,
0.0481385924,
0.004554119,
0.0174388532,
-0.0549568571,
0.0089923916,
-0.0410639569,
0.0198200233,
-0.0037886412,
-0.0174263828,
0.0228797495,
-0.0560026579,
0.0461005121,
-0.0301560275,
0.0168271419,
0.0108764423,
0.0284107737,
-0.0586154126,
-0.0130401514,
0.0179070663,
-0.0041533196,
0.0581163503,
0.0199713297,
-0.0050908322,
0.0168605242,
-0.0152582228,
0.0001864435,
-0.0103065576,
-0.0106041562,
0.0413017794,
-0.0652646124,
-0.0539617687,
0.0276650693,
-0.0228145253,
-0.0292651281,
0.0440751798,
-0.0220741816,
-0.0008263895,
-0.0159873329,
0.0172210243,
-0.0477130823,
0.0110009005,
0.0276993271,
0.0488262102,
0.0295638125,
0.0287886597,
-0.0743528679,
-0.0408981368,
-0.0088911569,
0.0070474483,
0.0492612459,
0.0043036551,
-0.0110907611,
-0.0207941979,
-0.0455639251,
-0.0139397727,
-0.0147307413,
0.0212164316,
-0.0318126529,
-0.0131636951,
0.0185673703,
-0.011039854,
-0.0358028561,
-0.0494481176,
0.0574655533,
0.0096747186,
-0.01546467,
-0.0248571765,
-0.023433499,
0.0497748554,
0.0163800884,
-0.0166317746,
0.0379279256,
0.0568920337,
-0.0042133452,
-0.0339295007,
-0.0031228939,
0.0579287596,
0.0249480717,
0.0407477953,
-0.0265825875,
-0.0339403301,
-0.0259208176,
-0.0207084175,
-0.0259356871,
0.00387489,
0.0032304367,
-0.0438747108,
0.0082655279,
0.0041100914,
-0.0152085051,
0.020859411,
-0.0821100101,
0.0415943488,
0.0449953452,
0.050740324,
0.0227409769,
-0.0633834228,
0.0205955878,
-0.0051428522,
-0.0431801602,
-0.0261561535,
0.0071411869,
-0.0464273579,
0.0554496758,
-0.0386561528,
0.0054463753,
-0.0450407714,
-0.0143210264,
0.0054149167,
0.0323857404,
0.008244846,
-0.0210076664,
-0.040742483,
0.0202046614,
-0.0021515982,
0.0786318034,
-0.00290716,
-0.006632675,
-0.0004906905,
0.0879506171,
0.0049898317,
0.0145566417,
-0.043227762,
-0.0090902206,
-0.0585578643,
0.0353258327,
0.079119347,
-0.0453524403,
-0.0922833309,
0.0225785002,
-0.0089920443,
-0.0073745614,
0.0248092338,
-0.0088131055,
0.0355275497,
0.0334094875,
-0.0315833129,
0.0699678361,
0.0136297727,
0.0245676674,
0.0517051294,
-0.0334898792,
-0.0032096112,
0.01883558,
0.0038514703,
0.0288677067,
0.0190297607,
-0.0143776899,
0.0344733261,
0.0147882821,
-0.033469107,
-0.0349169374,
-0.0056010014,
0.0253666397,
-0.0279422067,
-0.0036289787,
0.033020068,
-0.0124608586,
0.0061197383,
0.0557601452,
0.0182585977,
0.0007927681,
0.0574976802,
-0.0428471714,
0.0101803523,
-0.0853416398,
0.0047450108,
-0.0088777617,
-0.036612764,
-0.0035870373,
-0.0256978553,
0.0371532962,
-0.0097433133,
-0.0085392753,
-0.0076181684,
0.0261735767,
0.001807578,
-0.0258326512,
-0.0585825816,
0.0084521892,
-0.0091733066,
0.0071269353,
0.0319600254,
-0.0311596114,
-0.0409257896,
0.0011994017,
0.0694674104,
-0.0564450808,
-0.0568852425,
0.0044803871,
0.0344626941,
0.0089120641,
-0.0368169099,
-0.0249202754,
-0.0594531633,
-0.027371088,
0.0248367563,
-0.0000829956,
0.051718805,
-0.0205672085,
-0.0264549684,
0.0627650321,
-0.0644584447,
0.0123179574,
-0.0478657633,
-0.0580025688,
0.0216864832,
-0.0564488731,
-0.0172837302,
-0.0134073282,
0.0567660108,
-0.0291778632,
-0.0143824257,
0.0940885693,
0.0106270947,
-0.0146605354,
-0.0276195873,
-0.0608248487,
-0.0022575841,
0.0087229414,
0.022893481,
-0.0601375476,
-0.0108726602,
-0.0109348539,
0.0096027525,
-0.0167897586,
-0.0359174609,
0.0256976634,
-0.017277617,
0.0512152426,
-0.0069016204,
-0.0635076687,
0.0097459219,
-0.0502357073,
0.0149882641,
0.0108088516,
-0.0211013015,
0.0046922993,
0.0158429556,
0.0103795435,
0.0154455379,
-0.0476056263,
-0.0541580953,
-0.0337000452,
-0.0306766741,
0.0130347759,
0.01070836,
0.0624050573,
-0.0319503099,
0.0042876271,
0.0092235301,
-0.0255244337,
-0.0130991917,
-0.0066334927,
0.0827210918,
0.0362437665,
-0.0062231338,
-0.0104838414,
0.030865524,
-0.010547379,
-0.0500127114,
0.0403081924,
0.0500886552,
-0.018088812,
0.0370275229,
-0.0603761487,
0.0210676417,
0.0136197722,
0.0390265174,
-0.0206807051,
0.004495074,
-0.0608279854,
-0.0065702125,
0.0638146847,
0.0008798704,
-0.0006943979,
0.0168738458,
-0.046706304,
-0.0132602053,
-0.0625158474,
0.020239722,
0.0194260385,
0.0145672122,
0.0358784385,
0.015522955,
0.0718279332,
0.0019994581,
-0.0461682118,
0.0231734682,
0.006396445,
0.0455150194,
-0.0030545099,
0.0007299004,
0.0360263884,
0.0424508527,
-0.010845758,
0.0477290377,
0.0079443436,
-0.0370106585,
-0.0029513401,
0.0068301591,
0.0232487973,
-0.0109819034,
-0.0193601176,
-0.0581163801,
-0.001844167,
0.0585963577,
-0.0223757513,
0.0031851397,
-0.0097778682,
0.0040649469,
-0.0410394929,
-0.0481040813,
-0.0180938002,
0.0044440264,
-0.0388900675,
-0.0089534605,
-0.0562504679,
-0.0834338591,
0.0275415368,
0.0474649407,
0.1104174182,
-0.0363835245,
0.0334474854,
0.0007790567,
-0.0175657701,
-0.0005712695,
-0.0314423814,
0.0024990065,
0.0082146432,
0.0021167493,
-0.0061299191,
-0.0186533313,
0.0345923081,
-0.0168584567,
0.0360286757,
-0.0048771924,
0.0248841289,
-0.0008067667,
0.057291355,
-0.0018317513,
-0.0215442833,
0.0033451479,
-0.0248964094,
-0.0531397574,
0.0432306938,
0.0357582271,
-0.0173983779,
0.0461288095,
0.0100901462,
-0.0135013415,
-0.0225296598,
-0.1276235282,
0.0099980989,
-0.016020624,
0.014116114,
-0.0137993088,
0.0166463405,
0.0411606207,
-0.0520770438,
-0.0385457836,
-0.0143102072,
0.0203241855,
0.0370209888,
0.0594604313,
0.0399140753,
-0.0044593434,
-0.0277263708,
-0.0271954201,
0.0249620918,
0.0071293446,
0.03077038,
-0.0233654063,
-0.0945649222,
-0.0172241628,
-0.0371765755,
-0.0618248135,
0.0289108548,
0.0249501485,
-0.0038235572,
-0.0268603042,
0.025811173,
0.0949614123,
0.0454088636,
-0.0002632825,
-0.030636169,
-0.0289691444,
0.0302178226,
0.0027824435,
-0.0557295941,
-0.0276222043,
0.0472845584,
-0.0015680951,
-0.0246396139,
-0.0542041883,
-5.822749921e-33,
-0.0173945557,
-0.0710087568,
-0.0586664267,
0.0216007885,
0.0016984313,
0.0226932764,
-0.0284774732,
-0.0299766883,
0.0147257624,
0.0750326216,
0.0167410448,
0.0159353372,
0.0163316112,
-0.027344102,
0.0614675581,
0.0354420841,
0.0672249869,
0.0206893981,
-0.0094490182,
-0.036771141,
0.0625314191,
0.0192991551,
0.0476095937,
-0.1374720186,
0.0586730167,
0.0001893167,
-0.0125887999,
0.0229258481,
-0.0456195362,
0.0399690904,
-0.017204538,
-0.029114088,
-0.03698612,
0.0001425431,
-0.0049675559,
-0.0085604675,
-0.0637188777,
-0.0023709221,
0.0143009294,
0.0247512572,
-0.0295364056,
-0.0273277834,
0.0044194157,
-0.0093433801,
-0.0295439959,
0.0289390963,
0.0812792256,
-0.041768752,
-0.0050800517,
-0.0854315013,
-0.0622754022,
0.0286463797,
-0.0229368396,
0.0456898659,
-0.0099240923,
0.0373984277,
-0.00447754,
0.0505204238,
-0.0002084574,
0.0043523363,
0.0026136229,
0.02542511,
-0.0298308209,
-0.0253483616,
-0.0036300456,
0.0366200767,
0.00984676,
0.0179943852,
0.0273496471,
-0.0303884465,
-0.0189441647,
0.0153627507,
0.0645093247,
0.1000197828,
0.050646767,
0.0410152525,
-0.0647232458,
0.0034647249,
0.0170684848,
0.0390135311,
0.0022434364,
0.0276243463,
0.0117214136,
-0.0098745851,
0.0131902816,
-0.037936151,
-0.0203612801,
0.0209755115,
-0.0222256444,
-0.0336620063,
-0.0408700295,
0.0692928582,
0.0049221674,
-0.0027577085,
-0.0389727056,
-0.015435325,
0.0149994576,
0.0496297888,
-0.0143913189,
-0.0163255222,
-0.0370835215,
-0.0278354045,
0.0134124616,
0.0143860467,
0.0441388376,
0.0056572026,
0.0286671575,
-0.0306610502,
-0.0325178578,
0.0129826618,
0.0401745141,
-0.0040948545,
0.0080006393,
-0.0402776003,
-0.0015402411,
-0.0037582102,
0.030625239,
0.0473866463,
0.0290898122,
0.0493790321,
0.0105046798,
0.0205657594,
0.0107216025,
-0.0003797014,
0.0038414956,
-0.0424577147,
0.0180062167,
0.0074915169,
-0.0805299878,
-0.0577284768,
0.0437058695,
0.0077804262,
2.608e-7,
0.0776771456,
0.0829318836,
0.0490491576,
-0.0378628895,
0.0415429212,
0.0054769935,
-0.0036534562,
-0.0330308862,
-0.0156010892,
-0.0172437374,
0.014135411,
-0.0478872508,
0.0303398967,
0.0406285301,
-0.0361712426,
-0.0900580883,
-0.0472633578,
-0.0514485985,
-0.0326386355,
0.0254470408,
0.0577004775,
-0.0029204227,
0.0124968858,
0.0257281866,
-0.0372064412,
-0.0404226221,
0.0233829543,
0.0045680017,
0.0287166238,
0.0707459375,
0.0382279977,
-0.0435678624,
0.0112704849,
0.0714920759,
-0.0279853288,
-0.0096318694,
0.0121414503,
0.0184937809,
0.0151889352,
0.0648265556,
0.0153363161,
0.0245504063,
0.0538450219,
0.0080957506,
0.0132759167,
-0.0448893271,
-0.0296266098,
-0.0368330441,
-0.0425651707,
-0.0444071405,
0.0482383817,
0.0044310526,
0.0114545533,
0.0347399414,
-0.0415539555,
0.0344881974,
-0.0485209674,
-0.0580732264,
-0.0026415265,
0.040220242,
-0.0297295209,
-0.0099802967,
0.0209676512,
-0.0330327339,
0.0117852027,
-0.0681226477,
0.0066826916,
2.296197808e-34,
0.0791956112,
-0.0086882422,
-0.0211985372,
0.0062639751,
0.0198018942,
0.0030578515,
-0.0623349659,
0.0393068455,
0.0055966061,
0.0003954663,
0.0491282791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14142v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14142v1 | LOIS: Looking Out of Instance Semantics for Visual Question Answering | 2023-07-26T12:13:00 | 2023-07-26T12:13:00 | Siyu Zhang, Yeming Chen, Yaoru Sun, Fang Wang, Haibo Shi, Haoran Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Visual question answering (VQA) has been intensively studied as a multimodal
task that requires effort in bridging vision and language to infer answers
correctly. Recent attempts have developed various attention-based modules for
solving VQA tasks. However, the performance of model inference is largely
bottlenecked by visual processing for semantics understanding. Most existing
detection methods rely on bounding boxes, remaining a serious challenge for VQA
models to understand the causal nexus of object semantics in images and
correctly infer contextual information. To this end, we propose a finer model
framework without bounding boxes in this work, termed Looking Out of Instance
Semantics (LOIS) to tackle this important issue. LOIS enables more fine-grained
feature descriptions to produce visual facts. Furthermore, to overcome the
label ambiguity caused by instance masks, two types of relation attention
modules: 1) intra-modality and 2) inter-modality, are devised to infer the
correct answers from the different multi-view features. Specifically, we
implement a mutual relation attention module to model sophisticated and deeper
visual semantic relations between instance objects and background information.
In addition, our proposed attention model can further analyze salient image
regions by focusing on important word-related questions. Experimental results
on four benchmark VQA datasets prove that our proposed method has favorable
performance in improving visual reasoning capability. | [
0.0317995697,
0.0270712189,
-0.0121878535,
0.0872730836,
-0.0076585943,
0.0037628128,
0.0265557598,
-0.0032752072,
-0.0020674781,
-0.0684251562,
-0.0133510241,
0.0061259563,
-0.0193166547,
0.0458008423,
0.0491570793,
-0.0486164354,
0.0562265813,
-0.0153810792,
-0.010001651,
0.0184920225,
0.0566806607,
-0.0099659115,
0.0151762115,
0.0269996133,
-0.0539407767,
-0.0359823816,
0.001795897,
0.0128676714,
0.0350860357,
-0.0205397606,
-0.010136418,
0.0284194462,
0.0367251486,
-0.018625604,
0.0000018738,
0.0095408913,
0.0165892504,
-0.0028683408,
0.0025556886,
-0.0114697963,
-0.0269939043,
-0.0190161038,
0.0611522123,
-0.0170089025,
-0.0331301466,
-0.012204309,
0.0612975247,
0.0464083776,
0.0533681512,
0.0063332603,
-0.0187357422,
0.0043694153,
-0.0037810516,
-0.0241023619,
0.0437943116,
-0.0717347115,
-0.0083741117,
0.0225107875,
0.0088831019,
-0.000096363,
-0.0762779638,
0.0525824837,
0.0338176638,
0.0156504121,
0.0236889571,
0.0383172482,
-0.023145983,
-0.0170864295,
0.0007987545,
0.0995967984,
0.0181081481,
-0.0035592085,
-0.0485045016,
0.0111062052,
0.0235413145,
0.0289967284,
-0.0295176096,
0.0187654421,
-0.0376998447,
-0.021146344,
-0.0228702407,
0.0325796306,
-0.0181644652,
-0.0002689836,
-0.009581686,
-0.0152590349,
-0.0082471948,
0.0225478262,
-0.0184758604,
0.0231860671,
-0.068318814,
-0.0299315024,
-0.0088451821,
0.0712031722,
-0.0071395985,
0.009804355,
-0.0432180576,
0.0059251017,
-0.0156695563,
-0.0457559638,
0.0375110283,
0.0187961534,
-0.070595406,
0.0861129314,
-0.0196671635,
0.0328275114,
-0.0478155687,
0.0284183566,
-0.0393367112,
-0.0283731222,
-0.0010950796,
-0.0066894689,
-0.0692621619,
0.0176396575,
-0.0368577205,
-0.0485164598,
0.0155741815,
-0.00701886,
-0.0201009195,
-0.0403966308,
-0.0289778057,
0.0437276885,
-0.0107037909,
-0.0067321588,
-0.0407121964,
0.0294620674,
-0.0716865212,
0.025346892,
-0.0393126793,
-0.0376522355,
-0.0320149511,
0.0403461941,
0.0075378437,
-0.0337941572,
-0.0121900747,
0.0738036036,
-0.0220147949,
-0.0443814397,
0.0007798701,
-0.0503903069,
-0.0155659206,
-0.017042771,
0.0338380411,
-0.0382720828,
0.0076252716,
0.0068452251,
-0.0013111369,
-0.0046061743,
0.0117806345,
0.0138012115,
-0.0352606848,
0.0629068762,
0.0225339867,
-0.0055636708,
0.0123922601,
0.0250793565,
0.0270267986,
0.0418051258,
0.0121484837,
0.0032583217,
0.0167241041,
0.0059608361,
0.0513838716,
0.0195470303,
0.0282179285,
0.0058367532,
-0.0653859749,
0.0484641753,
-0.0057448666,
-0.0288148485,
0.0354486033,
-0.0012043959,
0.0051744105,
-0.075959675,
0.0573123507,
-0.0158957001,
-0.0536806732,
0.0003664881,
0.0085972026,
-0.0148789901,
0.0055985101,
0.014314401,
-0.0612162799,
0.1029446125,
-0.0009419192,
0.0033895089,
-0.0002823264,
0.0214081034,
-0.0525082834,
-0.0207781717,
0.0028869689,
0.0403262414,
-0.0088331318,
0.0757211298,
0.0292018447,
0.0409260392,
-0.0120475339,
0.0546177067,
0.0294100437,
0.0192879513,
-0.0199338086,
-0.0291263796,
0.0378027223,
0.0273021199,
0.0262902752,
-0.0248876214,
-0.0273104291,
0.0140459891,
0.0404918864,
0.0387102589,
-0.0154550569,
0.0245544016,
0.0302260052,
-0.0072767693,
-0.0352185257,
-0.0465431847,
-0.0130093032,
-0.0048401505,
0.0402032845,
-0.0199539941,
0.0078331474,
-0.050452292,
0.03513496,
0.0350712538,
0.0699990615,
0.0087119387,
-0.0431792662,
0.0418820754,
0.0124630602,
-0.0197162647,
0.0090518817,
-0.0134268384,
0.0039111967,
-0.0505888611,
0.0398558378,
0.0108574359,
-0.0271409452,
-0.0558893494,
-0.0055915317,
-0.0678407252,
-0.0416919477,
0.0275976155,
-0.0299325455,
0.019222565,
0.0035028241,
-0.0626785457,
-0.0111146336,
-0.0361627787,
-0.0393522829,
0.0420666076,
0.0513825193,
-0.0281555913,
0.0793262348,
-0.0470433086,
0.0084457742,
0.0048695323,
0.0166192763,
0.0264243428,
-0.0135763874,
-0.0064190584,
-0.0305370204,
-0.0149486195,
-0.0252639391,
-0.0034831981,
0.0003755764,
-0.0483456999,
0.0135585265,
-0.0536177121,
-0.0264636353,
0.0003113243,
-0.0416700281,
0.0129194139,
0.0056765447,
0.0099929431,
-0.0720007122,
-0.0283006988,
0.0271642674,
-0.0425917208,
0.0062112608,
0.0536121726,
0.0044841059,
0.0203638542,
-0.0243251584,
0.0040836926,
0.0098927841,
0.1017221063,
0.0268316045,
-0.0381550714,
-0.0147192534,
0.0081047788,
-0.0569087751,
0.0639960319,
0.0032558045,
-0.0185269378,
0.0072565442,
-0.0141286328,
0.0457705706,
0.1038752198,
-0.0007024838,
0.0206355918,
0.0099971853,
-0.0292557832,
-0.0339565538,
0.0413728841,
0.0114118531,
-0.0186223965,
0.0275395848,
-0.0398101956,
-0.0265104808,
0.0394414365,
-0.0318008289,
-0.029050963,
-0.0366382897,
0.0348852389,
0.0446356758,
-0.0433019511,
-0.0685775876,
0.0456059165,
0.0335642807,
0.0292157792,
-0.0722627044,
-0.0466259047,
0.0774607137,
0.005445532,
-0.0075467057,
0.0364521854,
0.0149838971,
-0.0512416922,
0.0949014425,
0.0284199994,
0.0143329846,
-0.036882326,
-0.0133934449,
-0.0569705926,
-0.0232708994,
0.0012727658,
0.0167519264,
0.0432601646,
-0.0213354304,
0.0165386759,
-0.019668797,
-0.0091516115,
-0.0258008298,
-0.0250758398,
-0.0238732733,
-0.0058638095,
-0.0656129345,
0.0260861553,
-0.0230660066,
0.0555740632,
0.0348281488,
0.001335738,
-0.0121587357,
-0.0059061293,
-0.0027749669,
0.0584182739,
0.0696618631,
0.0394266881,
-0.0057946211,
-0.0379763544,
0.0159095488,
0.0521193407,
-0.0149433073,
0.0132812886,
-0.0243745856,
0.008231204,
0.0194544867,
0.0340885893,
0.0005598771,
0.0186160114,
0.0567356832,
-0.0881238654,
-0.0363792367,
0.0510888323,
0.0091722542,
-0.0020550883,
-0.0119736046,
-0.0122177321,
0.0143643012,
0.0673765317,
0.063602455,
-0.0614346154,
-0.060395427,
-0.0465220325,
-0.0362593681,
0.0345491096,
0.0091677243,
-0.0042854771,
-0.0524282046,
0.0570296124,
-0.034614034,
-0.0861185938,
-0.033727698,
0.0239804089,
0.0309077445,
0.0237748716,
-0.0369084403,
-0.0241145361,
-0.0049258973,
0.0014557745,
-0.0132819638,
0.0509108193,
0.0336089283,
0.0381455421,
-0.0623766556,
-0.0283677299,
0.0255077146,
-0.0046283677,
-0.010277139,
-0.0374278426,
0.0064442018,
-0.008391208,
0.008600818,
-0.0052975439,
0.0603232756,
-0.0393318683,
-0.0644781664,
-0.0218306258,
-0.0132727483,
0.0077219866,
-0.0324525908,
-0.0185466129,
0.0469068885,
-0.0032957804,
-0.0181540027,
-0.0590806827,
0.0294326097,
-0.0223028809,
0.0479804166,
0.0444646627,
-0.0193983521,
-0.0343497917,
0.0157097131,
-0.0237112902,
-0.0431411155,
-0.0129576083,
0.0326252878,
0.0131266862,
-0.0093512274,
-0.0400889218,
-0.0307050366,
0.0651089177,
0.0356555358,
-0.020484766,
-0.0111750253,
-0.0070309266,
0.0221703127,
-0.0695368201,
0.0736848488,
-0.0378409773,
0.0286106151,
-0.0153094186,
0.0093145529,
0.0267192479,
-0.0524900481,
-0.030839026,
0.0425086021,
-0.0463303588,
0.0116225202,
-0.0287241321,
0.0598886609,
0.00364479,
0.0466425568,
0.0037591001,
-0.0437018611,
-0.0017553362,
0.0139152436,
-0.0088888109,
0.0216244701,
-0.0312969945,
-0.0377682559,
0.005980432,
0.0179321636,
-0.0479279459,
0.0338399373,
0.0402148701,
0.0002220543,
-0.0583259463,
-0.0275143571,
0.0336645581,
-0.0150260404,
0.0134469196,
0.0068838112,
0.0123998458,
-0.0082874242,
0.0236051772,
0.0419023111,
-0.0139905121,
-0.0917829573,
0.0206324495,
-0.0180718694,
-0.021604633,
0.0198846348,
0.0150582017,
0.0295940507,
0.0212239604,
-0.019038761,
-0.0104358634,
0.0125661939,
-0.0101414407,
-0.0261755474,
0.0290221237,
-0.0176288933,
-0.0279977061,
-0.0201826971,
0.0432411954,
0.016517235,
0.0858250409,
0.0398041084,
-0.0527915396,
-0.0538864471,
-0.0011873971,
-0.0342821889,
0.0011310597,
-0.0129652601,
0.0401744992,
0.0127808023,
-0.0143056754,
-0.0460061878,
0.0225281343,
-0.0293252692,
0.00484752,
0.0260188617,
0.0095514664,
-0.0354260355,
0.0689941645,
0.0488131903,
0.0202400014,
-0.0163722597,
0.0447825678,
0.006304998,
0.0147839878,
0.02545592,
-0.0246490072,
-0.0315826796,
-0.0171517599,
0.0483749546,
0.0185546353,
0.0162202138,
0.0778230652,
-0.045719523,
-0.0600486025,
-0.0343826562,
0.0280471854,
-0.0196775813,
0.0255384818,
0.0339582041,
0.0253734998,
0.0559043624,
-0.0708892569,
-0.0191843268,
0.0034808074,
-0.0213157497,
0.0223421846,
0.0057227421,
-6.114971939e-33,
-0.0713595301,
-0.0519610494,
0.022738032,
-0.0133723933,
-0.030714253,
0.0328222774,
-0.0394758433,
-0.0239096731,
-0.0589358062,
0.0290259551,
0.0213509984,
0.0270588677,
-0.0101874061,
0.0211815592,
-0.0159941223,
-0.0273812991,
0.0087926481,
0.0356143303,
-0.0049974886,
0.0037231622,
0.0048014773,
-0.001079065,
0.0505743697,
-0.0427250043,
-0.0260061957,
0.0069599696,
-0.0192484148,
0.0590788834,
-0.0348856039,
0.0728350654,
-0.0253623761,
-0.0074055963,
0.0370774344,
-0.0280312616,
-0.0095963674,
0.0271996688,
-0.0925270244,
-0.0160291437,
0.0605114549,
0.0201656502,
-0.0935793966,
-0.0081881667,
0.0514701679,
-0.004304715,
0.0858306289,
-0.065768078,
0.0429835916,
-0.0241267532,
-0.0053801602,
0.0012001479,
-0.0247914866,
-0.010250628,
-0.0193588603,
-0.0577685274,
0.0088066598,
0.0169364419,
0.0253503229,
0.0317469761,
-0.0036327958,
-0.0010425039,
-0.0050292131,
0.0251358226,
0.0565890856,
0.0798539594,
-0.0128108189,
0.0469732322,
0.0275803544,
-0.0284269117,
-0.0276978705,
-0.0281143207,
-0.0056360429,
0.0700546056,
0.0496399216,
0.0250603054,
0.0247224811,
0.0533911698,
-0.064730458,
-0.022106437,
-0.0757687762,
0.0665840432,
0.0025661069,
-0.0274759829,
-0.0020397177,
0.0092819547,
-0.0378328003,
0.0293745659,
-0.0830497518,
0.035964001,
0.0638012514,
0.0223198831,
-0.0250454396,
0.0689534694,
0.0385210849,
-0.0319154188,
0.0311486032,
-0.0080716498,
0.0112044364,
0.0445661359,
0.0229118615,
0.0359476469,
0.0086793629,
0.0258832872,
0.0385376886,
-0.0455971025,
-0.0176640712,
0.0178259853,
0.0624420308,
-0.0068186,
-0.0373803005,
-0.0208696723,
-0.0556701422,
-0.0169646069,
-0.0442737341,
-0.0125492485,
0.0165880583,
0.0242978707,
-0.0585717186,
0.0301552229,
-0.0079144584,
-0.0169743374,
-0.0135422545,
-0.0245931037,
-0.0220086854,
0.0517614521,
0.0063326475,
-0.0025536106,
-0.0396112353,
-0.0396940298,
-0.0099841692,
-0.057625033,
-0.0234959982,
0.0749920085,
2.493e-7,
0.0396753848,
0.014580762,
0.0063097794,
0.0551774763,
-0.0037017167,
0.0437328108,
0.0028052116,
0.0499467775,
0.0261971112,
-0.0465890691,
-0.0188891962,
0.0860506073,
0.0169957653,
-0.0173052829,
-0.0057532676,
0.0339698605,
-0.0005098239,
-0.0199669283,
-0.047491163,
-0.016748881,
0.0575849749,
0.0774987489,
-0.0081635322,
0.0041613504,
0.0344209038,
-0.0591426045,
0.066170916,
-0.0215704385,
0.0036080442,
-0.0258876011,
-0.0225024633,
-0.0044966331,
-0.0077223019,
0.0518654101,
0.0126954438,
-0.0214199498,
0.0553982444,
0.010132012,
-0.0225913972,
-0.0187660046,
-0.054628402,
0.0194438249,
-0.0013999887,
-0.0466217063,
0.0888674483,
-0.0483603217,
-0.0211270694,
-0.0176675059,
-0.0416803509,
0.0084023746,
0.0060970681,
0.0164557789,
-0.0200064573,
-0.0133719854,
0.0198275521,
-0.0579533353,
-0.0258359071,
-0.0741116554,
-0.0226884317,
-0.0123960664,
-0.0233065169,
0.0050626523,
-0.0648345798,
-0.0242631976,
0.0304670539,
-0.0286104996,
-0.0816424564,
1.732928925e-34,
0.0177542921,
-0.0078391861,
-0.0061478666,
0.0289295241,
0.0372992605,
-0.0503725,
-0.0665480345,
-0.0244492646,
0.0124683548,
-0.0434994958,
-0.0038635929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14134v1 | Developing and Evaluating Tiny to Medium-Sized Turkish BERT Models | 2023-07-26T12:02:30 | 2023-07-26T12:02:30 | Himmet Toprak Kesgin, Muzaffer Kaan Yuce, Mehmet Fatih Amasyali | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This study introduces and evaluates tiny, mini, small, and medium-sized
uncased Turkish BERT models, aiming to bridge the research gap in
less-resourced languages. We trained these models on a diverse dataset
encompassing over 75GB of text from multiple sources and tested them on several
tasks, including mask prediction, sentiment analysis, news classification, and,
zero-shot classification. Despite their smaller size, our models exhibited
robust performance, including zero-shot task, while ensuring computational
efficiency and faster execution times. Our findings provide valuable insights
into the development and application of smaller language models, especially in
the context of the Turkish language. | [
0.0208880436,
0.050168734,
-0.0125231063,
0.0160285607,
-0.0357501991,
0.025710661,
0.0620091707,
0.0365209021,
-0.0125630358,
-0.0432754233,
-0.0063360636,
-0.0854245648,
0.0082751038,
0.0072295722,
0.031679675,
-0.065743953,
0.0377819352,
-0.0349952467,
0.0341379791,
-0.0059073232,
0.0427171551,
0.0096900491,
-0.0207471661,
0.048667945,
-0.0147771575,
0.0067475378,
-0.0426090322,
0.0021957785,
-0.0275642145,
-0.0117399739,
0.0539610684,
0.0473804213,
0.0033712389,
0.0677382946,
0.0000018153,
-0.0239871833,
0.0214080457,
0.0102402782,
0.0277947504,
0.012115757,
0.0491954461,
-0.0480311215,
-0.0578852333,
0.0104066748,
-0.0168244131,
-0.0427965038,
0.0457760803,
0.0390487537,
0.0145151699,
0.085765332,
-0.0175394211,
-0.0482236892,
0.0063071861,
-0.0222746991,
0.0215735696,
-0.0090045538,
0.0186292622,
-0.0858177096,
-0.0476917922,
-0.0279874187,
0.0149096521,
0.0142228482,
-0.0171998441,
0.0179787576,
-0.0374979861,
0.0348315276,
-0.0788802952,
-0.0578810535,
0.0344295129,
0.0131239118,
-0.0390214026,
-0.0433397591,
0.012489466,
0.013040917,
-0.0103122797,
-0.0321839936,
-0.0288379882,
0.0025463463,
-0.0176190771,
0.0149137499,
0.0192533508,
0.0263493676,
0.0147502581,
0.0209665392,
-0.0502130985,
0.0111738732,
0.0204533152,
-0.043566037,
-0.0424723327,
0.0113008562,
-0.0052431789,
-0.0305503309,
0.018242063,
0.0223543551,
0.0587667711,
0.0001595149,
-0.0553177968,
-0.0747120604,
0.0126218721,
-0.0827875137,
0.0195120554,
0.0189904831,
0.0013471151,
0.0376468562,
-0.1063153818,
-0.0065860753,
0.0249129292,
-0.0072003952,
0.0077614165,
-0.0338369384,
-0.0148412678,
0.0097502526,
-0.0622382499,
0.0508686043,
-0.0393069983,
0.0233016275,
-0.0300646238,
0.0017985052,
-0.0029932072,
0.0406929143,
0.0054161786,
-0.0087233251,
-0.0207632706,
-0.0169644859,
0.0004606672,
-0.003111827,
-0.0358240232,
-0.014181558,
-0.0451260209,
-0.0586060025,
0.0108834123,
0.0098213637,
0.0249581505,
-0.0299497638,
0.0210160185,
0.0212854631,
-0.0010045653,
-0.0637793764,
-0.0271862112,
0.0509768799,
-0.0221248437,
-0.0430760197,
-0.0028472603,
-0.0556459427,
-0.0095018903,
0.0182929114,
0.004103845,
-0.0013081805,
0.0195731428,
0.0383871496,
-0.0059626051,
0.0860358253,
0.0124222711,
0.0068816431,
0.002081116,
-0.0126128923,
0.0473988354,
0.0793910772,
0.0502959676,
0.033205878,
0.0264153425,
-0.0205078069,
-0.0216308217,
0.0534965135,
0.0333558321,
-0.0017215295,
-0.0523875132,
0.0066980552,
-0.0326959528,
0.0193175152,
-0.0151102683,
0.0658742338,
0.0128235789,
-0.0195604004,
0.0801932439,
0.0579064228,
-0.0135949207,
0.100404799,
-0.0018031854,
0.0232624412,
0.0184883364,
-0.0422839448,
0.027353514,
-0.0062714852,
-0.0188204572,
0.0182588417,
-0.0020367019,
0.0405120701,
-0.0494394228,
-0.0296056345,
-0.0412532873,
-0.0247833263,
0.0175073706,
-0.0244449712,
0.0850997269,
-0.0119417906,
-0.0581367686,
0.0517789759,
0.0191727988,
-0.0499969758,
-0.0313702598,
-0.0689466372,
0.0424498096,
0.0212753732,
0.0334188789,
-0.0380028859,
-0.0225847457,
-0.0293801688,
-0.0069950656,
0.0401197076,
0.0599512197,
-0.0181790926,
0.0122688869,
-0.0491906032,
0.0581754632,
0.0384867489,
0.0353739634,
0.0058661741,
0.010334962,
0.0500281826,
0.0089467512,
-0.0376967117,
0.0271515064,
0.0145010734,
0.0024767043,
-0.0236369222,
-0.004622553,
0.0353731066,
0.0006618612,
0.0099006686,
-0.0278311633,
-0.0041110166,
0.0311386567,
-0.0774591565,
0.0064453715,
-0.0173909739,
-0.0220320337,
-0.0480332337,
0.0169543959,
0.0074374406,
0.011512056,
0.0846656859,
-0.0336462297,
-0.0449384525,
0.0406812839,
-0.0386553295,
0.0642904192,
-0.0512837619,
0.0082416972,
-0.0279555824,
0.0065879901,
-0.0150919426,
0.0243132487,
-0.0068894476,
0.0039005782,
-0.0095816301,
-0.0275332313,
0.0547132194,
0.0060789394,
-0.0572047718,
0.0022931674,
-0.0089831194,
0.0078656338,
0.0239618961,
0.0190195478,
0.0235916637,
-0.0467372686,
-0.1270053089,
-0.0144396229,
-0.0181982424,
0.0307834167,
-0.0076680947,
0.033453498,
-0.0213849414,
-0.0130180018,
-0.0266421642,
-0.0573061518,
-0.0228126515,
0.0065247887,
0.056862589,
-0.0166342836,
-0.0158117451,
-0.0391289853,
-0.0322041288,
-0.0103952494,
0.0502842031,
-0.0303981807,
-0.1063324735,
0.008914859,
0.0193380471,
-0.0035431425,
0.0469067879,
0.0186012238,
-0.0731130391,
0.0066198232,
-0.0160277039,
0.0469311625,
0.0391298458,
-0.0068307826,
0.0094105955,
0.0024234082,
0.0266820118,
-0.0469730385,
0.0132817505,
0.0031668907,
-0.0216092784,
-0.0010367591,
-0.0301005095,
-0.0315709896,
0.0852859169,
-0.044691056,
-0.0113533931,
-0.1031020656,
-0.013294572,
-0.0305520613,
0.0092270505,
-0.0354836136,
0.0315731205,
-0.0075644208,
0.0197808594,
0.0054899445,
-0.0097468346,
0.0307457112,
-0.0342189893,
-0.0017463516,
-0.0305288602,
-0.0081573902,
-0.0572782718,
0.0262964088,
-0.0076581007,
0.0208110958,
-0.017906392,
-0.0094735809,
-0.0517737046,
0.0173257645,
-0.0237797312,
-0.0227661505,
0.0271786731,
0.0074060517,
0.0105119729,
-0.0158742573,
-0.0633913204,
-0.0105348425,
-0.0945767313,
-0.0449255146,
0.0215488467,
0.03911395,
-0.0103829084,
-0.0446308143,
0.0516238585,
0.0141865937,
0.032311026,
-0.006851464,
0.0084158182,
0.0011056706,
0.0406126454,
0.0425910763,
-0.0529985502,
0.016573783,
-0.014856304,
0.040031869,
0.0474877991,
0.0618970692,
0.0230719857,
-0.0660221949,
-0.0365207978,
0.0431647412,
-0.0170807876,
-0.0336486921,
-0.0434028357,
0.0399913415,
-0.0475992262,
-0.005132711,
0.1088589132,
-0.0050275917,
0.003795306,
-0.0022319669,
-0.013049745,
0.0585593693,
0.018737141,
0.0038598008,
-0.0505433306,
-0.0165561698,
0.0278696828,
0.0323004797,
-0.0154813472,
-0.0022898368,
0.0569986627,
-0.1334893852,
-0.0119413864,
0.0199719779,
-0.0380972028,
-0.0111297481,
-0.0585513897,
-0.0088550104,
-0.0171796661,
-0.0369200893,
-0.0144969504,
-0.0119489664,
0.0106955795,
0.0510516725,
-0.0843484625,
-0.055658102,
0.0097027142,
-0.001947846,
0.0404583104,
0.0166228116,
0.0193553697,
-0.0314123929,
-0.0266948249,
-0.0009999266,
-0.029136911,
-0.0088591976,
-0.0082185008,
0.0492475219,
-0.0254562292,
-0.0556561463,
-0.0205601472,
-0.0099136848,
-0.0309190322,
0.0160621684,
-0.0395248123,
0.0289539825,
0.0338159129,
-0.017018564,
-0.0276125725,
-0.0066721812,
-0.0102406899,
0.0597046576,
0.0222534295,
-0.0513510928,
-0.0510981381,
0.0268325396,
-0.0335147008,
-0.1046973318,
-0.0026617767,
0.0065183397,
0.0029067539,
-0.0353592485,
-0.057230331,
-0.0174516924,
0.0365370847,
0.0270891953,
-0.0266188998,
-0.0015941052,
-0.0205441993,
0.0265572462,
-0.0661707744,
0.0193191376,
0.0248873793,
0.0111026494,
-0.0488187708,
-0.0187062211,
0.0400854945,
-0.0003919666,
-0.0113159912,
-0.0033971458,
-0.0886174217,
-0.0300797485,
0.0164480489,
0.0743463263,
0.01996441,
-0.0154970754,
0.0045894575,
-0.0676199049,
0.087252222,
0.0045030601,
-0.0130650084,
0.0038652911,
0.0149714779,
-0.0023286503,
-0.0061232932,
0.0454538576,
-0.0125315636,
0.034901347,
-0.0084877964,
-0.0085890479,
-0.0473105982,
0.0369799174,
-0.0083558084,
0.0021502608,
0.0345587209,
-0.0141872857,
-0.00138347,
-0.0241015796,
0.0438225828,
0.0068196636,
0.0274290778,
-0.0087399734,
0.0060446816,
0.0163306724,
0.0053169099,
-0.0473127589,
0.0109755294,
-0.0160794072,
0.0160393808,
-0.0638912991,
0.0257503036,
-0.0097363535,
0.0376024246,
0.0344984829,
0.0229465831,
-0.0463779829,
0.0128495153,
-0.018112665,
-0.0012104072,
-0.0424424857,
-0.0134175047,
-0.0121451858,
0.0191191509,
0.0151393674,
0.067916587,
-0.0049961903,
0.0161987264,
-0.033700794,
0.061332617,
0.0428167172,
-0.0206847768,
0.022248419,
-0.0185459796,
-0.0044475952,
-0.009254368,
0.0147820329,
-0.0248907432,
-0.0187576227,
0.00573155,
0.010736662,
-0.0219327901,
-0.0151834693,
0.0770766661,
0.02489274,
0.0557946227,
0.0236821473,
0.0162041243,
-0.0266890395,
0.0388618037,
0.0604266599,
0.0644021258,
-0.0142356595,
0.0049795448,
-0.0743306801,
-0.06612131,
0.0163817294,
-0.0083450647,
0.0164228603,
-0.0365787037,
0.0130778225,
0.0393596552,
0.0497639403,
0.0384184904,
-0.0264733806,
-0.000767522,
0.0008374373,
-0.0248175189,
-0.0095550027,
-5.672072851e-33,
0.0051835775,
0.0644755885,
-0.0190603212,
-0.0297416989,
0.0360456072,
0.0061874026,
-0.0121288393,
0.0060104276,
-0.0067200847,
0.0179564394,
-0.0316060334,
0.0096046831,
0.0090191867,
0.03398709,
0.0003198202,
0.0005254946,
0.0643853843,
-0.0217480082,
0.0199466832,
0.0116771022,
0.0347162858,
0.0515691303,
0.0491253622,
-0.0356775969,
-0.0315247737,
-0.0366816074,
-0.0205975305,
-0.0110833263,
0.0364333317,
0.0776662454,
-0.0073955837,
0.0643023252,
0.0284839831,
0.0078365514,
-0.0056597264,
0.0316733234,
-0.0656307116,
0.0065776906,
-0.0040869974,
0.0522087663,
-0.0154554537,
-0.0184154529,
-0.0180529431,
-0.0078615854,
-0.0260795373,
0.0313232653,
0.0211986732,
-0.0301624555,
-0.0334025659,
-0.0355829522,
-0.059969198,
0.0349040776,
-0.0066240923,
-0.027170958,
0.0737366155,
0.0598471649,
0.0089923413,
-0.0171538573,
-0.037770398,
-0.0025082477,
0.0113255884,
0.0328639373,
0.026462907,
-0.0182220098,
-0.0179075133,
0.0442814641,
0.025957115,
0.0387249626,
-0.0127628669,
0.0057404852,
0.0393824019,
0.02146638,
0.0457409807,
0.0436679721,
0.0122856498,
-0.0351404026,
-0.087242879,
0.02321098,
0.0443960093,
0.0349170379,
0.0268297028,
-0.0268615596,
-0.0625209585,
0.003543026,
0.0237361249,
-0.0460138284,
-0.008983071,
0.0083004665,
0.0161931049,
0.0040476513,
-0.0332700275,
0.0262294393,
0.0113077546,
-0.0245586168,
0.0258916244,
-0.0331657864,
0.0115280617,
0.0302440561,
-0.0137453983,
0.0403047502,
-0.0655537993,
-0.0429843739,
0.0013844661,
0.0137965623,
0.017926747,
0.0317744352,
0.0493850634,
0.0343610682,
-0.1068956628,
-0.0331381671,
-0.0180894602,
0.0419749692,
0.0059352522,
0.064955987,
0.0239826832,
0.008581344,
0.0138812074,
0.0294633396,
0.017366318,
-0.0216054879,
0.015740227,
-0.0202628281,
-0.0019950999,
-0.0118472259,
0.0034853185,
-0.0080516897,
-0.0324312896,
0.0436069779,
0.0501174405,
-0.035112001,
-0.0121019883,
0.0046021324,
2.561e-7,
0.0151915886,
0.0694990605,
-0.0062634982,
-0.0129384305,
0.0331590921,
0.0441167764,
-0.0124541428,
0.0493189953,
-0.0255691633,
0.0276872702,
0.0177913327,
-0.0325268544,
0.0728595257,
0.0047439313,
-0.0781497657,
-0.0176564865,
-0.0581947118,
0.0341031253,
-0.0404292792,
0.0566122718,
0.0434360318,
0.1243052706,
0.0059485352,
-0.0330016091,
0.0072509591,
-0.0336646587,
0.0759468973,
-0.0280716624,
-0.0175526738,
-0.0040708105,
0.034203507,
0.0382018648,
-0.0054696584,
-0.0090798493,
-0.0194767267,
0.0251183398,
0.0118402224,
0.0671813935,
-0.0418937542,
0.0231174659,
0.0488990173,
-0.0073691183,
-0.0371831283,
-0.0867148563,
0.0848012492,
-0.0190905761,
-0.018334372,
0.0069296109,
-0.0055566002,
0.0219427869,
0.0093424674,
-0.0201923884,
-0.0558974482,
0.0248463061,
0.0356014855,
-0.0449742675,
-0.0161072873,
-0.059118066,
0.0252368096,
-0.0087173888,
-0.0093936399,
-0.0259348936,
-0.0402620323,
-0.0041264812,
0.0227967184,
-0.0310883783,
-0.0017181736,
2.220392427e-34,
0.0177749153,
-0.0155840497,
-0.0328330025,
0.0328410156,
0.0089648273,
-0.0309507344,
0.0147719374,
-0.0052105733,
0.036048919,
-0.0462778769,
-0.02096547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14132v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14132v3 | CIF-T: A Novel CIF-based Transducer Architecture for Automatic Speech Recognition | 2023-07-26T11:59:14 | 2023-12-15T04:13:45 | Tian-Hao Zhang, Dinghao Zhou, Guiping Zhong, Jiaming Zhou, Baoxiang Li | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | RNN-T models are widely used in ASR, which rely on the RNN-T loss to achieve
length alignment between input audio and target sequence. However, the
implementation complexity and the alignment-based optimization target of RNN-T
loss lead to computational redundancy and a reduced role for predictor network,
respectively. In this paper, we propose a novel model named CIF-Transducer
(CIF-T) which incorporates the Continuous Integrate-and-Fire (CIF) mechanism
with the RNN-T model to achieve efficient alignment. In this way, the RNN-T
loss is abandoned, thus bringing a computational reduction and allowing the
predictor network a more significant role. We also introduce Funnel-CIF,
Context Blocks, Unified Gating and Bilinear Pooling joint network, and
auxiliary training strategy to further improve performance. Experiments on the
178-hour AISHELL-1 and 10000-hour WenetSpeech datasets show that CIF-T achieves
state-of-the-art results with lower computational overhead compared to RNN-T
models. | [
-0.0369969644,
0.0459191576,
0.0418496951,
0.0220855847,
-0.0225660149,
-0.0141801694,
0.0614161976,
-0.0396553949,
-0.0495584719,
0.0139717543,
-0.0528564937,
-0.0340424031,
0.0452419855,
0.0132151926,
0.0159617737,
-0.0043914416,
0.0092293629,
-0.0251335297,
-0.003596561,
-0.0159243271,
0.0333817787,
-0.0100219306,
-0.0563769005,
0.0410532504,
0.0110505586,
0.0095521621,
-0.0319664739,
-0.0186200757,
0.0276619215,
-0.0337475091,
-0.0019860298,
0.0006595418,
0.0386266373,
0.0713310018,
0.0000021244,
-0.0051175551,
-0.0184826162,
0.028585704,
-0.0869105384,
-0.040431723,
-0.0011976183,
0.0270057488,
-0.0386500061,
0.0555385202,
0.0207108557,
-0.0090664392,
0.0524336547,
0.0375941247,
0.0100075444,
0.0482138768,
0.0231881868,
-0.0684177056,
0.0323522724,
-0.0226022508,
-0.0380147696,
-0.068030864,
-0.0151313078,
-0.0101417666,
-0.0239818543,
-0.0396696478,
-0.0280347057,
0.0838428438,
0.0329860784,
-0.0029407095,
0.053711161,
-0.0195199512,
-0.0773142502,
-0.0468489639,
-0.0065187975,
0.0397814959,
-0.0096589085,
-0.0355663784,
0.0181993674,
0.0280750301,
-0.0456395373,
-0.0538511463,
-0.027491089,
0.0036487705,
-0.0054041944,
-0.0084356135,
-0.041889973,
0.0409440361,
0.0589094833,
-0.011385723,
-0.0491257608,
-0.0170789752,
0.0005566895,
-0.0135582276,
0.0301902443,
-0.0305639468,
0.0264594648,
-0.0110908598,
0.0477136746,
0.0141603444,
-0.0350418836,
-0.0161374714,
-0.0351208672,
-0.0400308631,
-0.0243313611,
-0.0358456634,
-0.0180971064,
0.0541572049,
-0.0180965215,
-0.0179446489,
-0.0300291013,
0.0830988511,
-0.0260567628,
-0.0070981537,
-0.0453965552,
-0.0167047922,
-0.0258320943,
-0.0184556823,
-0.0337294266,
0.021562418,
0.03773994,
-0.0611609519,
-0.0681118593,
0.0375003926,
0.0000553339,
0.0245057475,
0.0477894843,
0.0090548759,
-0.0710945278,
-0.0389914811,
0.0430214666,
0.0667437911,
0.0474691167,
0.0167518221,
0.0089431508,
-0.0191570781,
-0.0154730976,
0.0178813301,
0.0354599804,
-0.0055287611,
0.0040328931,
0.0521597974,
0.0104006538,
-0.0407284126,
-0.0427391417,
0.0265165437,
-0.0299506523,
-0.0271815527,
-0.0080993632,
-0.054589387,
0.0770098865,
-0.0378618874,
0.0003944606,
-0.0261585657,
0.0169157851,
-0.0033170718,
0.0521549396,
0.0521684028,
-0.0081237899,
-0.014842256,
0.0371643752,
-0.0228592772,
0.0512767993,
0.0554854274,
0.0541024134,
-0.0227219667,
-0.0215594228,
-0.0515575446,
-0.0340880379,
0.0369526558,
0.0199859962,
-0.0361975469,
-0.0308506396,
-0.0165586118,
0.0212057587,
0.066055499,
0.0460798033,
0.0118898805,
0.0115552256,
-0.0143223088,
0.0423165001,
0.0017674644,
0.0980060399,
0.0651666224,
0.0281576235,
-0.0113056535,
-0.0228406768,
-0.00250046,
-0.012618063,
0.0438732766,
-0.0252610631,
0.0268952306,
0.0652605891,
0.0468884744,
-0.0313819721,
-0.0020590902,
0.0165403653,
-0.0174707901,
-0.0292380694,
0.0239036139,
0.04050906,
0.0004906008,
-0.0376977772,
0.0027859518,
-0.0328220315,
-0.0164084099,
-0.0162254293,
-0.0087251784,
-0.0548938997,
-0.0047286111,
0.0133186392,
-0.0284642521,
-0.0632705092,
-0.0241888892,
-0.0196388699,
0.0264421105,
-0.0097263614,
0.0255637672,
0.0490320139,
-0.0540857986,
-0.0236976501,
0.0871863365,
-0.0218111239,
0.0670269281,
-0.0179088395,
0.0340612158,
0.0163749084,
-0.0136128403,
0.0138722891,
-0.024895085,
-0.0358005054,
-0.0380139425,
-0.0241827443,
0.0535314493,
0.0422733501,
0.0296142623,
-0.0205253828,
0.0094233584,
0.0117731011,
-0.0367934071,
-0.0110587906,
0.0518045425,
-0.0877487138,
-0.0193017013,
0.0488556363,
-0.0019276346,
-0.0016536893,
0.0294966716,
0.0226695333,
-0.0716693252,
0.0692167804,
-0.0044603697,
0.0595144369,
-0.0316513143,
0.053603638,
0.0555478297,
-0.0472651236,
0.0288987774,
-0.0136443358,
0.0232885145,
0.0327713676,
-0.0052012349,
-0.0283003598,
0.0105931666,
-0.080897674,
-0.0132136242,
0.0531222112,
-0.0435131118,
-0.0040060668,
0.0083470587,
-0.0299777556,
0.0038500768,
-0.0199703686,
-0.0227045659,
0.0077812974,
-0.00666204,
0.0522706546,
-0.034433309,
0.0434751138,
0.0258707069,
0.0237058792,
-0.0516489372,
-0.0417521,
-0.0262326561,
-0.0291791614,
-0.0284101143,
0.0088748811,
-0.0508898497,
-0.0211381707,
-0.0040532821,
0.0033412729,
0.0053351601,
-0.0405309163,
-0.0695975274,
-0.0107986843,
0.0163872018,
0.0530511029,
0.0381940007,
-0.0199112576,
-0.0227010567,
-0.0267920755,
0.0133125214,
-0.0263726115,
0.0186367892,
-0.0067979,
-0.0357052907,
-0.0070826439,
-0.0073588085,
-0.0288398098,
0.0332930498,
-0.0042129853,
0.0188563652,
0.0195541754,
0.0444501452,
-0.0431846976,
0.0260066576,
0.0127935605,
0.0274161305,
-0.0399731621,
-0.0405891128,
0.0147640305,
-0.0179545432,
-0.0354298577,
-0.0467029326,
-0.043254897,
-0.0410002619,
-0.020276878,
-0.0164298043,
-0.0201488137,
-0.0845439211,
-0.0356657431,
-0.0560801104,
-0.0443307348,
-0.0162186623,
0.0051182094,
0.0295058023,
0.00277621,
0.0154724745,
-0.0278753527,
-0.0185842495,
0.0191863738,
0.0093376869,
-0.0473520122,
0.0104830805,
0.0135496696,
0.0064980467,
-0.0116535109,
-0.0245756581,
-0.0209046975,
0.0155534726,
-0.0025111148,
0.027065238,
0.0159747135,
-0.0429716147,
0.0030988923,
0.0314565785,
0.0368557349,
0.0770284683,
-0.0138811218,
0.0184149612,
-0.033394061,
0.0752036721,
0.0266264845,
0.013774748,
0.0016311606,
0.0215869471,
0.0627265126,
0.0060461313,
0.0974935517,
0.0106595615,
-0.0892924741,
-0.0551589131,
0.0143361241,
0.0072930208,
0.0201136228,
-0.0059224232,
0.051954668,
-0.0404653884,
0.0261271428,
0.0729519576,
0.0075638192,
-0.0199621096,
-0.0362031013,
0.0243279189,
0.041570697,
0.0129002882,
-0.0408318974,
-0.0236528721,
-0.0068099559,
0.0760948956,
0.0448856317,
0.0177882947,
0.0284526516,
-0.0242341794,
-0.0627239123,
0.003246817,
0.0524871573,
-0.0422239192,
-0.0585326701,
-0.0171709098,
-0.0521353595,
-0.0067012487,
0.0369531289,
0.0273701251,
-0.0056596221,
-0.023763204,
0.077697143,
-0.1010181159,
-0.0199325718,
-0.046734836,
-0.0559449159,
0.0917777419,
0.0743580386,
0.0023288277,
0.0105502168,
0.0028061117,
0.0612835139,
-0.032493107,
0.024333369,
-0.0194133911,
0.0002206659,
0.001872002,
-0.0150610674,
0.0316726193,
0.0219520852,
-0.033026021,
0.0065964395,
-0.0151532134,
0.067870371,
-0.030133104,
0.0332569554,
0.0072754733,
0.0156930368,
-0.0033479258,
0.0552360378,
-0.009283131,
0.0088680917,
-0.0029043059,
0.0419278592,
0.0271429084,
-0.0830492675,
-0.0048814444,
0.0021636263,
0.0083928807,
-0.0872981325,
0.0037736581,
0.0097349761,
-0.0126495846,
0.0742444173,
0.0116244135,
-0.0012471613,
-0.0090030162,
0.0360337645,
0.0037539881,
-0.0181734953,
-0.0231443234,
0.0463909172,
-0.0438515656,
0.0372885019,
0.0062420205,
-0.0485950448,
0.0027534573,
0.0578442477,
-0.0818045288,
-0.0410896726,
0.0091140466,
-0.0441015251,
0.0142450221,
0.0714512616,
-0.0179084912,
0.0190654285,
0.0411773846,
-0.0036306097,
-0.0041370592,
0.0414724685,
0.0534654297,
-0.0177043155,
0.0155171687,
0.0082917977,
-0.0551216677,
0.0114270365,
-0.0490046181,
0.0234259572,
-0.0115304515,
-0.0186952986,
0.0252657942,
0.0196797978,
0.0501895249,
0.0345255584,
0.0696944371,
-0.01899473,
0.0727094412,
0.0216319803,
0.0416016728,
-0.0258674007,
0.0148787834,
0.0356974006,
0.0494148582,
-0.0143973678,
-0.0081812991,
0.0359287448,
-0.0366367996,
0.0100437924,
0.064808242,
0.0196581353,
-0.008468139,
-0.0234728102,
0.0102877775,
-0.0257552825,
0.0313142613,
0.0468704663,
0.02768071,
-0.0230418928,
0.0459712483,
0.023802733,
0.0060512205,
-0.0179712493,
0.0214308202,
-0.0180781577,
0.0066880491,
-0.0173664503,
-0.0032777211,
0.0242612883,
-0.0111416159,
0.0031440365,
0.0090476274,
0.0048811417,
-0.0301269814,
0.0036800366,
-0.0204720888,
0.0123252766,
0.0615422651,
0.0130643845,
0.0028800247,
-0.0164848827,
0.0133223981,
0.0004846225,
0.0449234918,
-0.0171978902,
0.0146033736,
-0.0111436192,
-0.0278813876,
-0.0383619256,
0.0182461068,
-0.0338932835,
-0.0435300656,
0.0114313969,
-0.0371438786,
0.053732831,
-0.015068721,
0.0400835872,
-0.0340951011,
0.0115774097,
-0.0256501231,
-0.0163719896,
0.0006457696,
0.0564448945,
-0.0333156399,
0.0201044492,
-0.015448695,
-0.0076978542,
-6.535617817e-33,
-0.0286639705,
0.0382842198,
0.0210231002,
-0.004641796,
-0.0897878408,
0.0129082259,
-0.0162689053,
0.0241552051,
-0.0064616464,
-0.0445857048,
0.0021325955,
-0.0131794102,
0.0364621766,
0.0065249968,
0.0020330695,
-0.005292661,
0.0652229637,
-0.0215402357,
0.0204185434,
-0.0390017778,
0.0377076603,
0.0284444634,
-0.0079794032,
-0.0607907735,
-0.0825426877,
0.0361009911,
0.0082197422,
0.0062071616,
0.0120868376,
0.0011649589,
0.0111533841,
0.0341967791,
-0.0253347959,
-0.0476759598,
0.0034971146,
0.0348784924,
-0.1113955975,
0.0024700633,
-0.0196909904,
0.0537300445,
-0.0143625299,
-0.0536401942,
0.0557727963,
-0.0004408671,
-0.0378605351,
-0.038397871,
-0.0070574451,
-0.0151259266,
-0.0357163362,
-0.0595123135,
-0.029597383,
0.0394917019,
-0.0152064804,
-0.0264686905,
0.0718628839,
0.0447497889,
-0.0246753059,
-0.035275653,
-0.1070546359,
-0.0025059127,
-0.0323506072,
0.0692728013,
0.0366508178,
0.0314536653,
0.0052848109,
0.0106853805,
0.0550458357,
-0.098015599,
0.0114772823,
-0.0165240709,
0.0013721013,
-0.0149817951,
0.037843693,
-0.0049929684,
0.0279102959,
-0.0410777405,
-0.0148183731,
-0.0064950716,
-0.0060778074,
0.0372336656,
0.0119108669,
0.0523638278,
-0.0534207001,
0.0079544317,
-0.0219998043,
-0.0400100835,
-0.0393818952,
0.0057744584,
0.0591281019,
0.0179519095,
0.0441776887,
0.0238951165,
0.0312623233,
-0.0176143572,
0.0502408557,
0.0317852087,
-0.0006755011,
0.0004536242,
-0.0019299849,
0.0283862185,
-0.0652846694,
-0.0253133159,
-0.0010121593,
0.0545232818,
0.0172442999,
-0.0509285405,
0.037047442,
0.089965798,
-0.0710337311,
-0.0351393968,
-0.0366369821,
-0.0095053045,
0.0160022303,
0.0019368961,
0.0395255722,
-0.0283024572,
0.0127153099,
0.0356464311,
-0.0275713094,
-0.0022710229,
-0.0312656797,
0.0098116957,
0.0288249198,
-0.001286648,
-0.0125751458,
0.0131400647,
0.0255805869,
-0.0025491158,
0.0276687406,
-0.0367825069,
-0.0185716301,
0.0024480261,
3.06e-7,
-0.0262442697,
-0.0159382503,
0.0875503197,
-0.039973285,
0.0271170102,
-0.0125002628,
-0.01326284,
0.0073041553,
0.0067750206,
0.0373336524,
0.0541665591,
-0.0121133365,
0.0525030345,
-0.0120910248,
-0.0821929276,
-0.0283480827,
-0.0483435392,
0.0509312786,
0.013596449,
-0.0125326756,
-0.0162719674,
0.0698939785,
-0.0094271665,
-0.0426723287,
0.0316919498,
-0.0470734313,
-0.004392399,
0.0235359129,
0.0421453752,
-0.033948034,
-0.0206469577,
-0.0175933931,
-0.0454175957,
0.0078481268,
-0.006011182,
0.0403431766,
0.023016382,
0.007856709,
-0.0269530844,
-0.0659419522,
0.0111459726,
0.0663415641,
-0.0208967943,
-0.0030727263,
0.0635275096,
-0.0331487507,
-0.0068591908,
-0.0483163111,
-0.0470199957,
0.0099167591,
-0.0062376182,
0.0460125767,
0.0415451676,
-0.0029405239,
0.0026765836,
0.0115990322,
-0.0286472552,
-0.0399666354,
0.0004262894,
0.0240540579,
-0.0722588524,
0.0074611199,
-0.0692457259,
-0.0069962237,
0.0296169911,
-0.0048110313,
-0.0439876169,
2.559189185e-34,
0.003061502,
-0.0456053279,
0.0477486365,
-0.0011575505,
-0.0240923185,
-0.0384520441,
0.0264742784,
0.0189205967,
-0.0136667592,
-0.0512437075,
-0.0618548319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14117v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14117v2 | Leveraging Implicit Feedback from Deployment Data in Dialogue | 2023-07-26T11:34:53 | 2024-02-01T04:30:38 | Richard Yuanzhe Pang, Stephen Roller, Kyunghyun Cho, He He, Jason Weston | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study improving social conversational agents by learning from natural
dialogue between users and a deployed model, without extra annotations. To
implicitly measure the quality of a machine-generated utterance, we leverage
signals like user response length, sentiment and reaction of the future human
utterances in the collected dialogue episodes. Our experiments use the publicly
released deployment data from BlenderBot (Xu et al., 2023). Human evaluation
indicates improvements in our new models over baseline responses; however, we
find that some proxy signals can lead to more generations with undesirable
properties as well. For example, optimizing for conversation length can lead to
more controversial or unfriendly generations compared to the baseline, whereas
optimizing for positive sentiment or reaction can decrease these behaviors. | [
0.0628346279,
0.0909743086,
-0.0236657057,
-0.0114722708,
-0.0117816608,
-0.0231262054,
-0.0143109597,
0.010486492,
0.0061738743,
-0.0309764799,
0.0063841818,
0.0056497399,
0.0041225841,
0.061445903,
0.002304761,
-0.0594869703,
0.0143055608,
-0.0201097354,
0.0084148822,
0.0074997321,
0.0302122682,
-0.0075253518,
-0.0171035435,
0.060962569,
-0.0559824333,
-0.0010681852,
-0.049620036,
0.0059990091,
0.012870172,
0.0023522491,
0.0142985256,
0.0564345606,
0.0059656021,
0.0253876224,
0.000001865,
-0.0168325938,
0.0148444083,
-0.0082140099,
-0.0006706143,
-0.0147111453,
0.0675456002,
0.0155980038,
-0.001661401,
0.0595060289,
-0.0631070957,
0.0412768237,
0.0218594279,
0.029727919,
0.0738252699,
0.0488633923,
-0.004925109,
0.0250662565,
-0.0313061513,
-0.0157185271,
0.0087497374,
-0.0455309898,
-0.0327010714,
-0.0043411823,
0.0058112149,
-0.0037896566,
0.0019983936,
0.0342012867,
0.0137600247,
-0.0463186316,
0.0868178681,
0.0157496501,
-0.0082623893,
-0.0654185638,
-0.0036715618,
0.1129280478,
0.068084456,
0.000809732,
-0.0086858431,
-0.0210175291,
0.0499537662,
-0.0090521136,
-0.0197550934,
-0.0454077274,
0.0153682875,
-0.0306547396,
-0.0701102987,
0.0060529383,
-0.0091428077,
-0.0125390943,
0.0267470255,
0.0494697206,
-0.041821707,
0.0005484333,
-0.0149200493,
-0.006529199,
0.0422492251,
-0.0496640839,
-0.0171835292,
0.0188294034,
-0.0544462763,
0.0071379323,
-0.0449298508,
0.0098339114,
0.0056692832,
-0.055098597,
0.020149447,
0.0306916479,
-0.0146346465,
0.0242643058,
0.0047439891,
0.0299681686,
0.0291731246,
-0.0381747298,
-0.0212701838,
-0.0002933214,
-0.04980997,
0.0018604113,
-0.0252348538,
0.0415795371,
-0.0256002713,
-0.0367275514,
-0.0069270111,
0.0528078042,
-0.0381574705,
0.0178383794,
-0.0087507796,
0.0437118672,
-0.0489602759,
0.0021235174,
-0.0887827277,
0.0066097258,
-0.0555970706,
0.0150323445,
0.0219231993,
-0.0667205527,
-0.0111250263,
0.0186267439,
0.03985212,
0.0401153713,
-0.008306995,
0.07445544,
-0.009489323,
-0.0217559654,
0.0267037228,
-0.0432636738,
-0.0328740291,
-0.0501670428,
-0.0404097028,
-0.0271720309,
0.0095970649,
-0.0102139907,
-0.0155737624,
-0.037417151,
0.0048466343,
-0.0049583209,
-0.021483507,
0.0682499483,
-0.0324151218,
0.0303136725,
0.0120263398,
0.0243965387,
-0.0180711094,
0.0612076782,
0.0283796936,
0.0327403955,
0.0230798814,
-0.0023312459,
0.0475958064,
0.0139854122,
0.0264725666,
0.0405914932,
-0.0077220197,
-0.0049541295,
-0.0351674296,
0.0343626179,
-0.002293888,
0.0466823094,
-0.0093304338,
-0.0369186699,
0.0707355663,
0.0349966176,
-0.0688835457,
0.0504533127,
0.0313254409,
0.057832595,
-0.0032568746,
-0.0020296101,
-0.0122866184,
0.0291927382,
-0.0261552986,
-0.0337280966,
0.0290126316,
-0.0185813047,
-0.0363161303,
-0.071355924,
0.0263719689,
-0.044340048,
0.0860265791,
0.0098147346,
-0.003118725,
0.0212956406,
-0.0621498637,
0.0068699238,
0.0011830812,
-0.0746070594,
-0.0382339992,
-0.0438852385,
0.0708949491,
0.0816981047,
0.0236693453,
-0.004076242,
-0.0561952107,
-0.0104702879,
-0.0142942565,
0.0366673246,
0.0687601939,
-0.0525684394,
0.0471407697,
-0.0019683037,
-0.011031935,
0.0267668068,
0.0017664677,
0.0189898238,
0.0351871252,
0.0145832142,
0.0178435259,
0.0139195798,
-0.0247105677,
-0.0033485114,
-0.0150901405,
0.0302369427,
0.0098656407,
-0.0088710831,
0.0719529837,
0.0255459938,
0.0055215238,
-0.0311735794,
0.0325123668,
0.0109994225,
-0.0633212104,
0.0471537411,
-0.0386370458,
-0.0022068722,
0.0576821677,
0.0080450047,
-0.0112914806,
0.0337348245,
-0.0289473142,
0.0155973397,
0.0376468673,
-0.0583131723,
0.0542530864,
0.0252433177,
0.012918273,
-0.0380737148,
-0.004561279,
0.0135619156,
-0.0257264692,
-0.0213199817,
-0.0636447743,
0.006332668,
-0.0186216328,
0.0022772348,
-0.0152602708,
0.0194977224,
0.0049532647,
0.0150041878,
0.0167794228,
0.0584239475,
-0.0155556845,
-0.0731180906,
-0.025408566,
-0.0841174871,
-0.0491271019,
0.0030530931,
-0.0401397385,
0.0028163232,
0.0148505857,
0.0112992292,
-0.0282565169,
-0.0265148096,
0.0484296903,
0.0264860541,
-0.0018524062,
0.0610121451,
0.0085769994,
-0.0191455763,
-0.0788891912,
0.0231656842,
0.0006684186,
0.0131117655,
0.0173120629,
-0.0055320896,
-0.0384146869,
0.0132913524,
-0.0794133618,
0.0383023247,
-0.0223407652,
-0.1021548584,
0.0328626372,
0.0012644947,
0.0437085144,
0.0880871713,
0.0479116328,
0.0612738431,
-0.0066899005,
0.021032216,
-0.0722864643,
0.011180073,
-0.0170773063,
-0.0143601894,
-0.042100247,
-0.0144516379,
0.010001299,
0.0264587384,
-0.0050128065,
0.0122111365,
-0.0934224203,
0.0604597442,
0.0134396451,
-0.0380932689,
0.0328728296,
-0.018666951,
-0.009858815,
0.0291494187,
0.0024334565,
-0.0657694489,
0.0943513289,
-0.0012623185,
-0.0084982058,
-0.0113900639,
-0.0203000493,
0.0081155458,
0.0505461954,
-0.0048923241,
0.0082269851,
-0.0023274128,
0.0219260845,
-0.0404600129,
-0.0390988849,
0.0311220866,
-0.0440269224,
0.0170354843,
-0.043508213,
-0.0106150443,
0.0394504517,
-0.0610835813,
-0.0153630162,
-0.0383366123,
-0.0332948714,
-0.0247241296,
0.0084302528,
-0.0590102896,
-0.0001639443,
-0.0078151356,
0.0033971283,
0.0108720111,
-0.0014533035,
-0.018273592,
0.0043315161,
-0.0367170312,
0.0519179069,
0.0433313102,
-0.0048808092,
-0.0182589758,
0.0587728024,
0.0386313759,
0.0487723872,
-0.0242200568,
-0.0607225522,
-0.0255553331,
-0.0237430837,
0.0313747823,
0.0105267558,
0.0327014141,
0.086841099,
-0.0221072417,
0.017666731,
0.0741920099,
0.0171141122,
-0.0051923408,
0.0332987271,
-0.0068880692,
0.0736891627,
0.0237568915,
0.0064763026,
-0.0398288183,
-0.0284829047,
0.0056382418,
0.0481258295,
-0.022254983,
-0.0296042226,
0.0185953714,
-0.1381198168,
-0.0066684443,
-0.0024206133,
-0.0237709321,
-0.0224326011,
-0.0232859123,
-0.0006203359,
-0.0333305039,
-0.0266052913,
-0.0105551099,
0.024440024,
0.0187433306,
-0.0001959012,
-0.0606749393,
-0.0196778346,
0.0333149619,
-0.0246410966,
0.0734093934,
0.0295537673,
0.0698014274,
0.0349487588,
-0.005681735,
0.0352130868,
0.0349943489,
0.0040193084,
0.0000856544,
0.0962834135,
-0.005136827,
0.0064772926,
-0.0175362453,
0.0186569672,
-0.0010872392,
0.001808858,
-0.0015326447,
-0.0098537039,
-0.0014687754,
-0.008025201,
-0.0271345098,
0.0682353079,
0.0374273695,
0.0307027008,
0.035070397,
-0.0677705109,
-0.0157009792,
-0.0189951118,
0.0064277956,
-0.0219887178,
-0.0359647833,
-0.0505898632,
-0.0058630323,
-0.0323240235,
-0.0936815664,
-0.0615334362,
-0.0006479276,
0.0382730626,
-0.0037695447,
-0.0303997286,
0.0039433963,
0.0370810665,
0.0133578246,
0.0196015928,
0.0043624919,
-0.0054933671,
-0.0255943928,
-0.0358218662,
0.0399218425,
-0.0147365807,
-0.0100044198,
0.0098124361,
-0.0506660566,
-0.0624951087,
-0.0178292058,
0.0986909196,
0.0281185023,
0.074746117,
-0.0267970338,
-0.0260445178,
0.0263991468,
0.0543728806,
-0.0285783,
0.0136828329,
0.0442366265,
0.0587357394,
-0.0129978927,
0.036859978,
-0.0479443185,
-0.0095569259,
-0.0404224023,
-0.0292026829,
-0.0488112606,
-0.0782925934,
-0.0003777323,
0.0129399523,
0.0227400176,
0.0089425994,
-0.019969672,
0.0224508513,
-0.0094128428,
-0.0070524719,
-0.0054339329,
-0.062165305,
0.0154836196,
-0.0286621898,
-0.0158151966,
0.0023680935,
-0.0124883298,
-0.0573666953,
0.069073692,
0.0108610746,
-0.0016373632,
0.0325006209,
0.0002871363,
0.0231748316,
0.0103049511,
0.0011067777,
0.0004751762,
-0.0173294116,
0.0299697872,
0.0007895406,
0.0455845594,
-0.0017345477,
0.0084344018,
0.0169291925,
0.0580719262,
-0.0679230466,
-0.0640842095,
-0.0244074259,
0.0394263826,
-0.0118012335,
0.0291546136,
0.0700404644,
-0.0100574968,
0.0302331727,
-0.015582595,
0.0525028035,
-0.0417667069,
-0.0516564474,
-0.0142833246,
0.0053483141,
-0.034108717,
0.0391772129,
0.0517116152,
-0.0116899377,
0.0411205404,
-0.0385672562,
-0.0031727371,
-0.042443376,
-0.0014441697,
0.0301516112,
0.0099712657,
0.0081509985,
0.0177365113,
-0.0540090241,
-0.0468541421,
0.0156900398,
0.0219264701,
0.0260825232,
-0.0445675813,
0.0251112729,
0.0373964198,
-0.0206176136,
0.0007388726,
-0.0784077048,
-0.0324624442,
-0.0189399868,
-0.0016085587,
-0.0122619644,
-5.870085609e-33,
-0.031708952,
-0.0242150761,
-0.030407669,
0.0237415563,
-0.0617792606,
-0.0217326507,
-0.0498270467,
0.0199937318,
-0.0102628656,
-0.0088274535,
-0.0134327002,
0.0495873503,
-0.0078378478,
-0.0147938738,
0.0197961032,
-0.035679657,
0.0644892231,
-0.0145657221,
-0.0384277552,
0.0658607185,
0.0065349853,
-0.0129808895,
-0.0215601064,
-0.0843450576,
0.0227874685,
0.010257666,
-0.0144064054,
0.0150387483,
0.039934542,
0.0647210851,
0.0063936156,
0.0415034965,
-0.00653528,
-0.0101876464,
0.0000180401,
-0.0182033721,
-0.0321156755,
0.0056760823,
-0.0326862969,
-0.0089871781,
-0.0398340821,
-0.021289913,
0.021550091,
-0.001213506,
-0.0507161841,
-0.0037553431,
0.035311237,
-0.0056948182,
0.0182493478,
0.0108708125,
-0.0465322733,
-0.0137758823,
-0.0545365848,
-0.0555381551,
-0.0130400378,
0.0828276947,
0.0271400791,
0.0281581506,
-0.0268351845,
0.0459531732,
-0.0136774685,
-0.0094623268,
0.0156517029,
-0.0021001645,
0.0346857607,
0.0442632399,
0.0340098105,
0.0621020719,
-0.0185789336,
-0.0501132905,
0.0125632547,
0.0373203196,
0.0422434881,
0.0622756742,
0.0202568583,
-0.0641200542,
0.0224280637,
0.0426349863,
0.0318419263,
0.0134615339,
-0.0033841531,
0.0147846462,
-0.0276940241,
-0.0016455946,
-0.0232402217,
-0.0304112975,
-0.0074002203,
-0.0313285403,
0.0078862058,
0.0428675115,
-0.0300494339,
-0.0596738532,
0.0254444089,
-0.0443117209,
0.0064378935,
0.0014067001,
-0.0698239282,
0.0011784589,
0.0030026829,
-0.020057153,
-0.0321503654,
0.0155043984,
0.0281721689,
0.0282310788,
0.0517691672,
0.0034738979,
-0.0204750691,
0.0623156242,
-0.069248423,
-0.0091566481,
-0.0118834712,
0.0333462432,
-0.0281046983,
0.0014094225,
0.0071800468,
0.0235164426,
-0.042246487,
0.0528962761,
-0.0288966671,
0.0449459665,
-0.030580692,
-0.01446582,
0.0167612806,
-0.0230838098,
-0.0481531024,
-0.0513186716,
-0.0293938164,
0.0033233543,
-0.0106916819,
-0.0511408821,
-0.0438630246,
-0.0457323715,
2.593e-7,
-0.05305022,
0.0631926507,
0.0270776115,
-0.0056686318,
0.0259206612,
0.0856282339,
-0.0023026671,
0.0137370741,
0.0045556757,
-0.0272428934,
0.0324821919,
0.0081968177,
0.049859982,
0.0206688829,
-0.0671252385,
-0.0400370695,
-0.0721157193,
-0.019762259,
-0.005458639,
0.0020974849,
0.0565240718,
0.0512718,
0.0388136953,
0.0083587626,
0.0328834429,
-0.0113567682,
0.0327637643,
-0.0347987972,
-0.0063339891,
0.0024716968,
0.0142462784,
-0.0241356231,
-0.0069594141,
-0.0125338994,
-0.0104907574,
-0.0129019124,
-0.0413224511,
0.0543150567,
-0.0185625572,
-0.0557105429,
-0.0091442969,
0.0537170768,
0.0009838311,
0.0182777904,
0.0279122014,
-0.0281273201,
-0.0337458625,
-0.0343395136,
-0.0060488107,
-0.025714647,
0.0150377061,
0.0111036655,
-0.0328784026,
0.0236334894,
-0.002924941,
0.0061932383,
0.0024252571,
-0.0618530065,
0.0082272161,
-0.0133291455,
-0.0520986207,
-0.0858059525,
-0.0098042013,
0.022096334,
-0.0108967219,
-0.0043998808,
0.0348509513,
1.926837509e-34,
0.0553736426,
-0.0077759572,
0.0076768873,
0.0142795388,
0.0669757202,
0.0035838161,
0.0232093502,
-0.0276136696,
0.098331213,
-0.0152537068,
-0.0002099581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.14107v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.14107v2 | Decoding ChatGPT: A Taxonomy of Existing Research, Current Challenges, and Possible Future Directions | 2023-07-26T11:10:04 | 2023-08-25T09:00:08 | Shahab Saquib Sohail, Faiza Farhat, Yassine Himeur, Mohammad Nadeem, Dag Øivind Madsen, Yashbir Singh, Shadi Atalla, Wathiq Mansoor | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Chat Generative Pre-trained Transformer (ChatGPT) has gained significant
interest and attention since its launch in November 2022. It has shown
impressive performance in various domains, including passing exams and creative
writing. However, challenges and concerns related to biases and trust persist.
In this work, we present a comprehensive review of over 100 Scopus-indexed
publications on ChatGPT, aiming to provide a taxonomy of ChatGPT research and
explore its applications. We critically analyze the existing literature,
identifying common approaches employed in the studies. Additionally, we
investigate diverse application areas where ChatGPT has found utility, such as
healthcare, marketing and financial services, software engineering, academic
and scientific writing, research and education, environmental science, and
natural language processing. Through examining these applications, we gain
valuable insights into the potential of ChatGPT in addressing real-world
challenges. We also discuss crucial issues related to ChatGPT, including biases
and trustworthiness, emphasizing the need for further research and development
in these areas. Furthermore, we identify potential future directions for
ChatGPT research, proposing solutions to current challenges and speculating on
expected advancements. By fully leveraging the capabilities of ChatGPT, we can
unlock its potential across various domains, leading to advancements in
conversational AI and transformative impacts in society. | [
0.0512985699,
0.0623127334,
-0.0125595704,
-0.0048359972,
-0.0305088498,
-0.0045726337,
0.0387668684,
0.0065925848,
0.0512080714,
-0.0595247485,
-0.0571196564,
-0.0136218956,
-0.022025384,
0.0504198335,
0.0225760229,
-0.0749427453,
0.0305416826,
0.0073206029,
0.0427524447,
0.0129657043,
0.0065013086,
0.0073903305,
-0.0260145012,
0.0890928507,
-0.0530163571,
-0.0395939872,
-0.0052298908,
0.0060974443,
0.0297317933,
-0.0104295621,
0.0137720555,
0.0606374107,
-0.0004412456,
0.0651463121,
0.0000022366,
-0.0328917988,
-0.0465985537,
-0.0088084256,
-0.0155570861,
-0.0376274884,
0.0138465734,
0.0148676429,
-0.0493058041,
0.0351061225,
-0.0810788572,
-0.0302888565,
0.0579674356,
0.0473835208,
0.0518843867,
0.1142711043,
-0.0307942051,
0.0211935658,
0.0424884781,
-0.0169423521,
0.0125562511,
-0.0345437601,
-0.004771628,
-0.0053262743,
-0.0651130453,
0.0192678273,
-0.0383231193,
0.0416583829,
0.0201039743,
-0.0478532948,
0.0147052612,
0.0295928307,
-0.0417172201,
-0.0249763727,
-0.0389262699,
0.047497537,
-0.0164369326,
-0.0081675434,
0.001630821,
-0.0011262675,
0.0141427061,
0.0053777285,
-0.0503454767,
0.0150962714,
-0.0018956087,
-0.0097903106,
-0.0582098849,
0.0384323113,
-0.0259432774,
-0.0181653518,
0.0064373109,
-0.0167419817,
0.022624027,
-0.0219759624,
0.0006027825,
0.0365625285,
-0.0021025792,
-0.0853663683,
0.0373051241,
0.0163446851,
-0.0264924597,
0.021413384,
-0.0256625637,
-0.007445259,
-0.013167697,
0.0098218098,
-0.000782156,
0.0393683389,
-0.0110476287,
0.0045783734,
0.0091823693,
0.0518284962,
-0.0103917187,
0.0453063138,
-0.0203468911,
0.0180619303,
-0.0508633889,
-0.0241083745,
-0.0559426211,
-0.0102684926,
-0.0016681069,
-0.0202381797,
-0.0614402108,
0.0125161922,
-0.0025156573,
0.0040969644,
0.0231440701,
0.026908556,
-0.05698587,
0.0046219374,
0.0086012231,
0.0354966335,
0.001106107,
-0.0056156996,
0.0366442464,
-0.0806865469,
-0.0096951853,
0.0236102026,
0.0188118313,
-0.0148023115,
-0.0250787847,
0.071552895,
-0.0406267196,
-0.0616817065,
0.0088281576,
-0.0111928117,
-0.0266281907,
-0.0453254431,
0.0346304141,
-0.0094955452,
0.0317385159,
-0.0167734846,
0.0226871483,
-0.0202201251,
-0.0006488495,
0.012050868,
0.0202645157,
0.05260114,
0.0081615541,
0.0017031521,
0.0058172047,
0.0374841653,
-0.0190136246,
0.004040204,
0.0590226129,
0.0541485175,
0.0610092767,
-0.0339082889,
0.0491241068,
0.0262354929,
0.008230648,
-0.0531160571,
0.0910726637,
-0.0211364292,
-0.0108702444,
0.0315955579,
-0.0065755113,
0.0649517402,
-0.0624859519,
0.0134325372,
0.1022798195,
0.068561919,
0.0239889454,
0.0535159782,
0.031844534,
0.0512629151,
0.0037315513,
0.0186134018,
-0.0523429848,
0.0263943821,
-0.0136455195,
-0.0070257057,
-0.0225615036,
0.0436024144,
-0.0181847475,
-0.0498938002,
0.0291157421,
-0.0243061204,
0.0087825935,
-0.024291208,
-0.0008138904,
0.0398653783,
-0.0706106052,
0.0005660976,
-0.006297823,
-0.0864567384,
-0.0196272936,
-0.0771533474,
-0.007699138,
0.0447016694,
0.0742080361,
0.0036817652,
-0.0263016988,
-0.0316401869,
0.0023192342,
0.0211723018,
0.0231999401,
0.0049803006,
-0.0078718867,
-0.0437549986,
-0.007952692,
0.0125320517,
-0.017264314,
0.0221558958,
0.0546884723,
0.0451824553,
-0.0072918995,
0.0052268491,
0.0170321688,
0.025502855,
-0.0043159546,
-0.0413017981,
0.0106998272,
0.0062787659,
0.0105046704,
0.0074571474,
-0.0183892455,
-0.0047048563,
0.0086856624,
0.0172077995,
-0.0414149016,
0.0805797949,
-0.0919443518,
-0.0414638668,
-0.0122390063,
-0.0915711448,
-0.0317676291,
0.0401268043,
-0.0194988754,
-0.0335284099,
-0.0007128806,
-0.0145676844,
0.0693828985,
-0.0310091618,
0.0117845377,
0.0188054852,
0.0177858267,
-0.0305989254,
0.0156812761,
0.0145303914,
-0.0447046757,
-0.0271896515,
0.019643018,
0.0017467961,
0.0020404325,
0.0083433697,
0.0231148377,
-0.020725267,
0.0068239095,
0.0136270355,
0.0397081301,
-0.0657298863,
-0.0542436242,
-0.1003467515,
0.0109585607,
-0.0160779264,
0.0050545665,
0.0325843059,
-0.0115321213,
-0.0160737447,
-0.0087357089,
-0.0712880939,
0.0336716548,
0.0154238036,
-0.0336825326,
0.0262540001,
-0.0228853766,
0.0143962717,
-0.0353351384,
0.0000173584,
-0.009713036,
0.0304483008,
0.0457068719,
-0.0423069373,
-0.028769305,
0.0437925607,
0.0059134276,
-0.0027051221,
-0.0084342957,
-0.0612653494,
0.0406294279,
0.0216101315,
0.0611014329,
0.0359794758,
0.0483710207,
0.0366861969,
-0.0157111175,
-0.0217689089,
-0.0465666801,
0.0024924211,
-0.0281249154,
-0.0355359986,
-0.0143164946,
-0.0110274153,
0.0144785764,
0.0389318801,
0.0231746603,
-0.0049273837,
-0.0593038835,
0.0115242489,
0.0138401715,
-0.0340547711,
0.0076844646,
-0.0117470426,
-0.0114472853,
0.0257018637,
-0.0077311099,
-0.0378256105,
0.0579738654,
-0.0322753899,
-0.0342950672,
-0.0429162271,
0.0154714659,
-0.0152650718,
0.0620312169,
-0.0069805821,
0.0121348444,
0.0256781001,
-0.0535696484,
-0.065125525,
0.0162773114,
0.0167782344,
-0.0242373943,
-0.0005160825,
0.0040543792,
-0.0149809401,
-0.008930536,
-0.0337625481,
-0.0589543656,
-0.0329900384,
0.0109146582,
-0.0164184328,
0.0699931458,
-0.0363379382,
-0.0297296997,
-0.0187249407,
-0.0196609143,
0.0378727205,
-0.0226101372,
-0.037945129,
-0.0367649794,
0.0320880376,
0.0282551255,
0.0163968001,
0.0362160318,
-0.0059760683,
0.0312925577,
0.0909112841,
0.0064315102,
-0.0336795487,
-0.0113347825,
-0.0447737835,
0.0111422902,
-0.0250916984,
0.0100732585,
-0.0089041032,
0.0738135204,
-0.0203103423,
-0.013100761,
0.1061101332,
0.0087809497,
-0.0441874266,
-0.0061166957,
0.01191842,
0.0165422224,
-0.0243996419,
0.0168861989,
-0.1107590795,
-0.0198232885,
-0.0003261875,
0.0149802538,
-0.0165229216,
-0.0298108216,
-0.0206411146,
-0.0694851428,
0.0818397403,
-0.0078462781,
-0.0132747227,
-0.0012851433,
-0.0018803962,
-0.0329143032,
-0.0122718634,
0.0222914834,
-0.0284753125,
-0.0154268574,
0.020594798,
-0.0042876564,
-0.0482893214,
-0.0126406802,
0.0307198707,
-0.0218567513,
0.0400672145,
0.0771385431,
0.0574445277,
0.027055148,
-0.0077489489,
-0.0011786625,
0.0474447943,
0.0173083879,
0.005588558,
0.0734162256,
-0.0465689041,
0.0048550274,
-0.0281057991,
0.0372424722,
-0.0206253882,
-0.0161456093,
0.0378663987,
0.0370913185,
-0.0293020289,
-0.039942164,
0.012988355,
0.0473767743,
0.045942273,
0.0587180518,
0.0303634796,
-0.0280540604,
-0.030084461,
-0.0175277311,
0.0586005226,
-0.013096855,
-0.0606731735,
-0.0222800542,
0.02753786,
-0.0239944216,
-0.0766901821,
-0.0518529676,
0.0224450286,
0.032816615,
0.0011567721,
-0.0575095937,
0.0539157093,
0.0226466022,
-0.0263932105,
0.0149798179,
-0.0348963663,
-0.006209584,
-0.0367083661,
-0.0405193828,
0.0050030001,
-0.0392486639,
0.0041164462,
-0.0034354257,
-0.0511919372,
-0.0320964269,
0.0250877496,
0.0690115541,
0.0189851858,
0.0330083072,
-0.0130152358,
-0.0235474687,
0.0564928018,
0.0471478552,
-0.0434717014,
0.0223000608,
0.0669315532,
0.0091364011,
-0.0083890595,
0.0068326881,
0.0149225043,
0.0324919634,
0.0051097274,
0.0019572652,
-0.0209779032,
-0.0369998328,
0.0141219925,
-0.0008524439,
0.0624737628,
-0.0131238038,
0.0415335484,
-0.0582943894,
0.0183805618,
-0.0336546227,
0.0178921428,
-0.0726006329,
-0.0260801353,
0.0169359948,
0.007637368,
-0.0178290848,
-0.0186556485,
-0.0745822564,
0.0091440538,
-0.047525052,
0.0277316328,
0.0220229868,
0.0219952166,
0.0181600302,
-0.0066300952,
0.0000450566,
0.0403843448,
-0.0005641402,
0.0407007486,
0.0107840784,
0.0693762377,
0.01113398,
-0.0217020195,
0.040778894,
0.0452149473,
-0.104183346,
-0.0510211512,
-0.0338329673,
0.0569037348,
0.0331175625,
0.03422153,
0.0582452267,
-0.0425362475,
0.0251328684,
0.0238964129,
0.0366072729,
-0.0079131322,
-0.0349958241,
-0.029104298,
-0.0276224371,
-0.0108624492,
0.0082786111,
0.0665407777,
-0.0864138976,
0.0251985434,
-0.0087327436,
-0.017716147,
-0.0622836687,
-0.0523303337,
-0.0014394087,
-0.0152858999,
0.0271861609,
-0.018360218,
-0.0339097492,
-0.0515417717,
-0.0103728883,
0.0113647813,
0.0056223529,
-0.0229431186,
0.0167156048,
0.0606928021,
-0.0185651928,
-0.0063978168,
-0.0173161253,
0.0023630299,
-0.0068869712,
-0.0127993003,
-0.0056781056,
-6.016200291e-33,
-0.0226270966,
-0.0366942585,
0.0179246385,
0.0336614139,
-0.0245804191,
0.0140205445,
-0.0369465686,
0.0204439089,
0.0213488601,
0.0267751478,
-0.0635332093,
0.0347482599,
0.0200883634,
0.0251510106,
-0.0055736373,
0.0034060692,
0.0700243711,
-0.0294651873,
-0.0289828032,
0.0565365255,
0.0353166498,
0.0328491665,
0.0779960603,
-0.0961188301,
0.0192261636,
-0.0166058764,
-0.0426442847,
-0.0385625996,
0.0060339384,
0.0301673934,
-0.0097437883,
0.0250282437,
-0.0018615182,
-0.0174601693,
-0.024996195,
0.0378184281,
-0.05879182,
-0.0280480199,
-0.0253703874,
0.0445614383,
-0.0078592263,
-0.0305632353,
-0.0018036469,
-0.0600353703,
-0.0217628274,
-0.0094832079,
0.0166755747,
0.0206206255,
0.0378436372,
-0.0319386981,
-0.0833279863,
0.0090044271,
-0.0448742919,
-0.0399121679,
-0.0195337888,
0.0633773208,
0.002176079,
-0.0234133117,
-0.0554432496,
0.0407116935,
0.0183073394,
0.0012567625,
0.0247313157,
-0.0246017054,
-0.0289577059,
0.0524750985,
0.0392005816,
0.0149131147,
-0.0202474631,
-0.0177603103,
0.0226292983,
0.0198094286,
0.0367452875,
0.075060159,
0.0148302084,
-0.0252737869,
-0.0300540775,
0.0267149936,
0.0309511833,
-0.0110932132,
0.0002633353,
-0.0029390485,
-0.0359422639,
-0.0063847592,
0.0093243159,
-0.0239683595,
0.0132807782,
-0.0555984117,
0.0434565581,
0.0104794167,
-0.0043040919,
0.0161117204,
0.0386342146,
-0.0610700957,
0.0236601699,
-0.0029458115,
-0.0447672904,
0.0301344898,
-0.0490827747,
0.0139591629,
-0.0452618338,
-0.0190669708,
0.0837090835,
0.0261691157,
0.0233562682,
0.0132164834,
0.0342427231,
0.0338634066,
-0.0413137227,
-0.0028461604,
0.0005530082,
0.0546886846,
0.0240311008,
-0.0369447321,
0.0059472728,
0.0021823768,
-0.0403657295,
0.0121288644,
0.022359103,
0.0402177647,
-0.0496638939,
0.0215848517,
-0.0146632213,
-0.0032305408,
-0.0410468951,
0.0099683255,
-0.0356868766,
-0.0371473543,
0.0402808562,
-0.0629501641,
-0.0053221178,
-0.0358768888,
2.904e-7,
0.0082277823,
0.0436901376,
0.0422845893,
-0.0053529656,
0.009919283,
0.0123183122,
0.0244705174,
0.0352069065,
0.031797491,
0.0334220156,
0.0333126523,
0.0293868389,
0.0379122272,
0.0312055759,
-0.0827782974,
-0.054305952,
-0.0780176446,
-0.0297822636,
-0.037660867,
0.0015238747,
0.0928757414,
0.0565250106,
-0.0109396745,
-0.018061718,
0.0137177873,
0.0207008962,
0.0522606187,
-0.0340018049,
-0.0020826629,
0.0314361453,
0.0426433831,
-0.02358458,
0.0098982453,
0.0162031725,
-0.0067858077,
-0.011743892,
0.0117516723,
0.0548727363,
0.015982775,
-0.0202445239,
0.0169111509,
0.0263921469,
-0.0083591407,
-0.0471130721,
0.0586939454,
-0.1059982628,
-0.0305743329,
-0.0346213356,
-0.0272251964,
-0.0392340496,
0.0237416793,
-0.0080707613,
-0.0128805917,
0.039120134,
0.0195978787,
0.0269401576,
0.0179926101,
-0.0680871606,
0.003762922,
-0.0401110686,
-0.0143088447,
-0.0516479723,
-0.0248057004,
-0.0415234827,
0.0112376409,
-0.0350109413,
-0.0017272462,
2.730591184e-34,
0.024778733,
0.0062154629,
0.0411468484,
0.0119272768,
0.0474698655,
0.0229012426,
0.0756874904,
0.0033344845,
0.0139550352,
-0.0512515604,
-0.0441841595
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.