id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09476v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09476v3 | Overthinking the Truth: Understanding how Language Models Process False Demonstrations | 2023-07-18T17:56:50 | 2024-03-12T07:00:02 | Danny Halawi, Jean-Stanislas Denain, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Modern language models can imitate complex patterns through few-shot
learning, enabling them to complete challenging tasks without fine-tuning.
However, imitation can also lead models to reproduce inaccuracies or harmful
content if present in the context. We study harmful imitation through the lens
of a model's internal representations, and identify two related phenomena:
"overthinking" and "false induction heads". The first phenomenon, overthinking,
appears when we decode predictions from intermediate layers, given correct vs.
incorrect few-shot demonstrations. At early layers, both demonstrations induce
similar model behavior, but the behavior diverges sharply at some "critical
layer", after which the accuracy given incorrect demonstrations progressively
decreases. The second phenomenon, false induction heads, are a possible
mechanistic cause of overthinking: these are heads in late layers that attend
to and copy false information from previous demonstrations, and whose ablation
reduces overthinking. Beyond scientific understanding, our results suggest that
studying intermediate model computations could be a promising avenue for
understanding and guarding against harmful model behaviors. | [
0.0121165728,
0.0220841579,
-0.0306166913,
0.0385319255,
-0.0360473096,
0.0339958631,
-0.0341602564,
-0.0001412494,
-0.0315111205,
-0.0038755911,
-0.0497607514,
-0.0143778352,
0.0442368798,
-0.0339597501,
0.0499891862,
-0.0024012006,
0.0801473409,
-0.054687079,
0.0022121451,
-0.0335682034,
0.0022944745,
-0.0174461231,
-0.0001764916,
0.0337216705,
0.0076040467,
0.0020531011,
-0.0324279703,
-0.0241458714,
-0.0242795385,
-0.0071333428,
-0.0165027697,
0.0228248853,
0.0365863703,
0.0971110463,
0.0000017375,
-0.0393781997,
-0.0002097076,
-0.0004372242,
-0.0685005635,
0.0273273475,
0.0334700271,
-0.008132332,
-0.0121645918,
-0.0135857929,
-0.0266766027,
-0.0203159358,
0.0223742761,
0.0704967231,
0.024124112,
0.0679144859,
0.0236172359,
-0.0070913169,
0.0066065635,
0.004991462,
0.028924752,
-0.0288013089,
0.0284870751,
-0.0114132334,
0.0081605883,
-0.0346323103,
-0.0551239252,
-0.0185907315,
0.0113074966,
0.0249237288,
-0.0482586324,
0.0384131819,
-0.0174002685,
-0.0477564298,
0.0062792953,
-0.0071452651,
-0.04795634,
-0.05932758,
0.0087299449,
-0.0145131741,
0.0203718748,
0.0200891141,
-0.0287070051,
0.042918358,
0.0299218222,
0.0075540496,
0.0064146481,
-0.0174104199,
0.0456049144,
0.0082394844,
0.0221290011,
0.0369061418,
-0.0188170485,
-0.0445833281,
-0.0021005042,
0.0069709849,
0.0214958154,
-0.0655388832,
-0.0236028302,
0.0004855599,
-0.0092863059,
0.0247792546,
-0.0185256805,
-0.0070501189,
0.0340245403,
-0.0287754219,
0.079240635,
0.0457459539,
-0.0051561072,
0.0247023981,
-0.0248311162,
0.0301257242,
-0.0416365303,
0.0867964998,
-0.0092111714,
0.0612975881,
-0.0124221724,
-0.0396999456,
-0.009993433,
0.0276199821,
0.0458590351,
-0.0230252799,
-0.005644761,
-0.0075970967,
-0.0342740305,
0.0157534778,
-0.0862590149,
0.0155877508,
-0.01514637,
-0.0024102561,
-0.033355318,
0.0208660029,
-0.0104797697,
0.0297267158,
0.0120815132,
-0.0561543256,
-0.0576246381,
-0.0276787486,
-0.0144803068,
0.0007658181,
-0.0155862533,
0.021221064,
-0.0048142821,
-0.048106432,
0.0076719406,
-0.0203924291,
0.0103381798,
-0.0550448969,
0.0299354419,
-0.0432313308,
0.0116078071,
-0.0326118991,
-0.0146994684,
-0.0253890138,
-0.0069256444,
-0.0114077916,
-0.048863396,
0.0479458757,
0.0011392398,
0.0169469435,
0.0229046158,
0.0329086594,
-0.0481273644,
0.0730202794,
0.0003441394,
0.0008748524,
-0.0224619135,
0.0107286945,
0.0566290393,
0.0290852226,
0.065009214,
0.0150904879,
-0.0475342311,
-0.0271238815,
0.0070851017,
0.0467456616,
0.0411407948,
0.0377572849,
-0.0721437559,
0.014493838,
0.053975191,
0.02362567,
-0.0318633839,
-0.0270921253,
0.0429688394,
-0.0206313841,
0.0328103304,
0.0603793599,
-0.0764043182,
0.0192027204,
-0.0491489619,
0.0209952127,
-0.0270279162,
0.0140655013,
0.0032523759,
0.003886404,
-0.0069188508,
0.0338212252,
0.0028360933,
-0.0008842738,
0.0161856636,
0.0540570207,
-0.0294211376,
-0.0014434984,
0.00421063,
-0.0161825959,
0.0166539773,
-0.083068192,
0.0248358157,
0.0181342568,
0.0238845032,
0.0037613043,
-0.0257119462,
-0.0149570573,
0.0113848401,
0.0347806439,
0.0385657363,
-0.017372014,
0.0037958848,
0.0125133172,
-0.0184600726,
-0.0097993212,
0.0560320541,
0.0010295896,
-0.0366894677,
-0.0156345293,
-0.0242922045,
-0.0041894112,
-0.0462014489,
0.04851982,
-0.0520965308,
-0.03222977,
-0.0654564574,
0.009776216,
-0.001918708,
-0.0308082402,
-0.0175895952,
0.03005323,
0.0295607951,
0.0344813429,
-0.0027938404,
0.0154766943,
-0.0540378988,
-0.0461604968,
0.0260127485,
-0.0298174378,
-0.016931152,
0.0083397105,
0.0101335403,
-0.0321338065,
0.0294714421,
-0.0499315038,
0.0967005044,
-0.0122134434,
0.0250142682,
-0.0440555885,
0.0120214932,
0.0066403965,
0.0427674912,
-0.0442063697,
0.0212186556,
0.0753269792,
-0.0350613184,
-0.0373680443,
-0.0378561392,
-0.016195789,
-0.0015426814,
0.0108356597,
0.0191488769,
0.0026905274,
-0.0158316176,
-0.058123529,
-0.0073316246,
-0.0179993995,
-0.0360169969,
0.0165935736,
0.0049130004,
0.0101971338,
-0.0417844765,
-0.0281535145,
-0.0108426288,
0.0367229171,
0.0051037101,
-0.0018906496,
0.0323330574,
0.0056348774,
0.0080039557,
-0.0288671795,
-0.0093682781,
0.0224913266,
-0.0277739558,
0.0614636317,
-0.0522368699,
0.0042845709,
-0.0746745914,
-0.0133816395,
-0.0182676837,
0.0370524041,
-0.0023138816,
-0.0349370353,
0.0625712723,
0.0070039295,
-0.0436424427,
0.0833340958,
0.00189798,
0.0637780502,
0.0648450851,
0.0085505722,
-0.0511728525,
-0.025084639,
-0.005947894,
-0.0116670141,
-0.0429580621,
-0.0259834696,
-0.0556378886,
0.1076058522,
0.0299494099,
0.0111865047,
-0.0440939069,
0.0769608244,
-0.0402086824,
-0.0732362345,
0.009877231,
-0.0600911379,
-0.0668804422,
0.0364487655,
-0.0249399561,
-0.0473438054,
0.0711400434,
-0.0079235854,
-0.0082574757,
0.0270619206,
0.054431092,
0.0555281527,
0.046867907,
0.0471710749,
0.0172307324,
0.0736299828,
-0.0169573724,
-0.078678757,
0.0148046929,
0.0460806042,
-0.0276024882,
-0.0047422498,
-0.0236116964,
-0.0276267231,
0.0093459543,
-0.0244481862,
-0.0479214303,
-0.0059853103,
-0.0164726153,
-0.0171320811,
-0.0854258239,
-0.0002238038,
-0.0088386033,
-0.0619263463,
0.0247393865,
0.0192598011,
-0.0207690168,
-0.0113746179,
-0.0283804927,
-0.0138584487,
0.067968674,
0.0284476113,
0.0507003181,
-0.0499269813,
0.0529751964,
0.0369131938,
0.0116893277,
0.0436938256,
-0.0410077013,
0.0304158572,
0.0307732467,
0.0127313528,
-0.0069360882,
0.0418363698,
0.0553593487,
-0.0528379567,
-0.0374907106,
0.0548916645,
0.0166533422,
-0.0134505956,
0.0529205762,
-0.0204541963,
0.0433460027,
0.0385755412,
0.0032184354,
-0.0585060827,
-0.0043288064,
0.0447195806,
0.0193350371,
-0.0646367669,
-0.0201892536,
0.0055117682,
-0.1453682631,
0.0336849056,
0.0229942873,
-0.0641569868,
0.0147354919,
0.0002841041,
0.0059359889,
-0.0000154379,
0.0534107685,
0.0379783399,
0.0173741151,
0.009951951,
0.0091595622,
0.019917164,
-0.0715031698,
0.032956589,
-0.030512996,
0.0906320959,
0.0351048186,
0.0072744833,
-0.0079520643,
-0.0304229315,
0.0403034985,
-0.0080343923,
0.0206922069,
0.0077716727,
0.0268707033,
0.0347948633,
-0.0081823338,
-0.000728478,
0.0422935672,
0.0414835289,
-0.0440892465,
-0.0588635579,
0.093171522,
-0.0102951527,
-0.0481310487,
-0.0020260729,
-0.0021255722,
-0.002070656,
0.0380227119,
0.056729693,
-0.0133042326,
-0.0062610223,
-0.0193993244,
-0.0078759128,
-0.0114454916,
-0.0669941232,
0.0446501486,
0.0738442689,
-0.0102662127,
-0.0627404898,
-0.0217632353,
-0.0026723898,
0.0123944534,
0.0118174925,
-0.0181344897,
-0.0296584647,
-0.0329291858,
-0.0094240317,
0.0107336156,
0.004288502,
0.0079509132,
-0.0111610442,
-0.0097578848,
-0.016503809,
-0.0483475253,
-0.0054058386,
-0.028965557,
-0.0679426491,
-0.0778184459,
0.0459335521,
0.0782075375,
0.0276579726,
0.0657753646,
0.0050843288,
-0.0336266309,
0.0609405823,
0.0041252044,
-0.0071723019,
0.043589741,
0.0432626158,
-0.0549994372,
-0.0078729531,
0.0438467003,
-0.0016418784,
-0.0078056697,
0.0403579809,
0.0065877899,
-0.0189088732,
0.0397644266,
0.066159308,
-0.0050655529,
0.0634459034,
-0.0324375108,
0.0124370847,
-0.0138822272,
-0.0124202585,
-0.0028799279,
-0.0153607866,
-0.0057701059,
-0.0255119093,
0.0389515124,
0.0564402267,
0.0085759116,
-0.0455054902,
0.0069591505,
0.0424366966,
-0.0167862903,
0.0107665053,
0.0447170734,
0.008964723,
0.0108500561,
0.0480054356,
-0.0059804274,
0.0527001247,
-0.0529304147,
0.0374202132,
0.0037683609,
0.0252049845,
0.033056289,
-0.0009311498,
-0.0199304316,
0.0111491038,
-0.068108134,
-0.0370033756,
-0.0247115511,
-0.0080116335,
0.017196836,
-0.04668805,
0.0327681378,
-0.0303732678,
0.0152549678,
0.0171359628,
-0.0058040316,
-0.067715317,
-0.0715536401,
0.0144570358,
0.023311168,
0.0038979759,
-0.0060101836,
0.0597593747,
-0.0106901964,
0.0972048566,
-0.0141820237,
0.0286299083,
-0.0021236758,
-0.0344344191,
0.0634499267,
0.0175985508,
-0.0405306369,
-0.016673144,
-0.0666827932,
-0.0683092028,
-0.0341446586,
0.0273624808,
0.026820926,
-0.0441822484,
0.0128839128,
0.0262890421,
-0.0174000878,
-0.0088339634,
-0.0164615158,
-0.037280634,
0.052866511,
0.0082379971,
0.0093714166,
-6.047450809e-33,
0.0010309976,
-0.0151633769,
0.0160767604,
-0.0356458426,
-0.0484016575,
0.0021797139,
-0.019562589,
0.0187822618,
-0.0136648733,
0.0244185552,
-0.0242081676,
0.0019042826,
0.0074422969,
-0.0200479422,
0.0648537204,
-0.0134610096,
0.0028919384,
-0.0455745496,
-0.0604831241,
-0.0294980649,
0.0133207142,
0.0126166688,
0.0777615309,
-0.0092846137,
0.0407496244,
0.0150101585,
-0.057381805,
-0.0040639793,
-0.0875961706,
0.033269126,
-0.0176699478,
-0.0030683794,
0.0048880605,
-0.0455144532,
-0.0445233807,
-0.0066223466,
0.0068557849,
-0.0315856598,
0.0244671609,
0.0294508152,
-0.0316616595,
0.023255391,
0.0518760793,
-0.0403650403,
-0.0485011674,
0.012531179,
-0.032569658,
-0.0262728594,
0.0036861713,
0.0469760634,
-0.0867249891,
-0.0119521013,
0.0216905046,
-0.0455744155,
0.0404502228,
0.0250822902,
-0.0267299134,
-0.0345168412,
-0.0909125432,
0.0212840568,
0.0205249544,
0.0011624672,
0.0494176969,
0.0167632513,
0.011124556,
0.0598100908,
0.0729393736,
0.0241312999,
0.0212904774,
-0.0115357991,
0.0614532381,
0.0240257066,
0.0250442736,
0.0138143115,
0.0965763256,
-0.003560836,
0.0358390175,
-0.0466519296,
0.0215332285,
0.0355194211,
0.0161055401,
0.0023339204,
-0.0049389186,
-0.039263662,
-0.0453207754,
-0.0227110684,
-0.0202483945,
-0.0036528092,
0.0078742011,
0.0373392254,
0.0021025625,
-0.0051490152,
0.0166514982,
-0.0383736417,
-0.0055432059,
-0.0446540825,
-0.02453449,
0.0260892399,
0.01706733,
-0.0005050537,
-0.0624687187,
-0.0454618037,
-0.0309833605,
0.0174733475,
0.0293752104,
0.0369689576,
0.0490457304,
0.0531927235,
-0.0376384221,
0.0096668284,
-0.0239312612,
-0.0042037754,
0.0566263311,
-0.0593884178,
0.0678697154,
-0.0103422347,
-0.0363094918,
-0.0383396298,
0.0272704326,
-0.0202604104,
-0.0502518602,
0.0859025642,
-0.0374063216,
0.0253283139,
-0.0194676686,
-0.0247698296,
-0.0425289348,
0.0416523777,
0.0290636532,
-0.0789644793,
-0.0217250101,
0.0014672638,
2.675e-7,
-0.0086318022,
0.0531288646,
-0.0049172998,
0.0339840204,
0.0425303131,
0.0508458726,
-0.0556963868,
0.0313826837,
-0.0084809726,
-0.0542446524,
0.0214796625,
0.0078375358,
0.0282301866,
0.0297738127,
-0.0367463157,
-0.020816844,
-0.0674428716,
0.0221534148,
-0.0055806586,
-0.014887196,
-0.0179750174,
0.0505699068,
0.0079416195,
-0.0212619714,
0.0021999492,
-0.0113111716,
0.0516096875,
0.0282511488,
0.0543080866,
-0.0345622487,
-0.0071804551,
-0.0023174582,
-0.0065205311,
0.0065824604,
-0.0014237519,
0.0242172517,
-0.0298256166,
-0.0220010523,
-0.0254833661,
0.0183844417,
-0.0180327557,
-0.0102747418,
-0.0291037224,
-0.0460264124,
0.0366263203,
-0.0751923025,
-0.0027338616,
-0.0490336716,
0.0345437415,
-0.0112308376,
0.0090277363,
-0.0063040215,
-0.0071251937,
0.0172023587,
0.0039255572,
0.0420389399,
-0.0221589152,
-0.0424153656,
-0.024425678,
-0.0094937785,
-0.0375191607,
-0.0432079546,
-0.0215370376,
0.0170831345,
-0.0181762669,
-0.056327913,
-0.0229785759,
2.167120263e-34,
0.0169898104,
-0.0361884609,
0.0497304909,
0.0187994055,
0.0125798155,
-0.0325393304,
0.0366610289,
0.0289669763,
0.0313152708,
0.0178529415,
-0.029977696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09474v1 | ChatSpot: Bootstrapping Multimodal LLMs via Precise Referring Instruction Tuning | 2023-07-18T17:56:06 | 2023-07-18T17:56:06 | Liang Zhao, En Yu, Zheng Ge, Jinrong Yang, Haoran Wei, Hongyu Zhou, Jianjian Sun, Yuang Peng, Runpei Dong, Chunrui Han, Xiangyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Human-AI interactivity is a critical aspect that reflects the usability of
multimodal large language models (MLLMs). However, existing end-to-end MLLMs
only allow users to interact with them through language instructions, leading
to the limitation of the interactive accuracy and efficiency. In this study, we
present precise referring instructions that utilize diverse reference
representations such as points and boxes as referring prompts to refer to the
special region. This enables MLLMs to focus on the region of interest and
achieve finer-grained interaction. Based on precise referring instruction, we
propose ChatSpot, a unified end-to-end multimodal large language model that
supports diverse forms of interactivity including mouse clicks, drag-and-drop,
and drawing boxes, which provides a more flexible and seamless interactive
experience. We also construct a multi-grained vision-language
instruction-following dataset based on existing datasets and GPT-4 generating.
Furthermore, we design a series of evaluation tasks to assess the effectiveness
of region recognition and interaction. Experimental results showcase ChatSpot's
promising performance. | [
0.0173794031,
-0.0086286897,
-0.0014222173,
0.0409273244,
-0.0371547043,
0.0142117357,
0.0281500071,
0.0119221704,
0.0481506139,
-0.0645892993,
-0.090816766,
-0.0207656417,
0.0123134647,
0.0082463892,
0.0424119495,
-0.0826224983,
0.0290749948,
-0.0739521831,
-0.0612672232,
-0.0053422661,
0.0035002935,
0.0059620957,
-0.0746824592,
0.0603261255,
-0.037011195,
-0.0107680541,
-0.0315518603,
0.0207987428,
-0.0041723889,
-0.0434572436,
-0.0209039133,
0.0312603191,
0.0455180034,
-0.0133867292,
0.0000020786,
-0.0267677158,
0.0502181575,
-0.0326271839,
0.0232429057,
-0.0109135509,
0.0286130887,
-0.0005894508,
-0.0038206014,
-0.0051194322,
-0.0043111942,
0.0037113922,
0.0782788545,
0.0293681826,
0.1052664518,
0.0240335707,
-0.0024727252,
0.0039423122,
0.0041356669,
0.0039638011,
0.0523022227,
-0.0375489481,
-0.012149713,
0.0411861278,
0.056610655,
0.0037420511,
-0.0375695266,
0.0538912192,
0.0231831446,
-0.0428820923,
-0.0138328215,
0.0383078977,
-0.0189561434,
-0.0332536995,
-0.0327974893,
0.1022842303,
-0.0023207013,
0.0018659668,
-0.0001211907,
0.0179427862,
0.0124557558,
0.0082058702,
-0.0741577744,
0.0168729685,
-0.0013704118,
-0.008062277,
-0.0407795236,
-0.016296735,
0.016866887,
0.0007209726,
0.010651906,
0.0451043211,
0.0101551628,
-0.0132721905,
0.005266943,
-0.0071706143,
-0.0064713969,
-0.0613585301,
0.0184586868,
0.052459754,
-0.0288275201,
0.0143728852,
-0.0668767691,
0.0397550836,
0.0005282192,
-0.0105861006,
0.0771019012,
0.0354989767,
-0.0640165955,
0.0598848015,
-0.0065934309,
0.0620126128,
-0.0142138833,
0.0314081125,
0.0026170642,
-0.0110025583,
-0.0443836637,
-0.0029377411,
-0.0462511219,
-0.0005444782,
-0.0559433736,
-0.0491141826,
-0.0216381121,
0.0497832112,
-0.0181548577,
0.0153378015,
-0.001189735,
-0.015469118,
-0.0083751362,
-0.0039996854,
-0.0182374045,
0.017027745,
-0.0280517116,
-0.0131386267,
-0.0096905362,
-0.0800669268,
0.0042172857,
0.0513375923,
0.0010277701,
-0.0265160445,
-0.017213637,
0.1241734028,
-0.0152499508,
-0.0397255272,
-0.0249173753,
-0.0139612667,
-0.0265952833,
-0.0422073305,
0.0249717999,
-0.0539632849,
0.0382905677,
-0.0040054126,
0.0009109945,
-0.0232894197,
0.018952148,
0.0303028729,
0.0063693123,
0.0620266646,
0.0012862575,
0.0226624198,
0.0363923609,
0.0081257913,
-0.0224937089,
0.0498232916,
0.0682859793,
0.0644760728,
0.0181541853,
-0.0047051841,
0.0188776609,
0.0847394317,
-0.0173547752,
-0.004111568,
-0.0301143061,
-0.0205193441,
-0.0136684179,
0.0546055138,
0.0371510871,
0.0422354229,
-0.0474627838,
-0.0049900054,
0.0856142044,
0.0801633373,
-0.0092566721,
-0.0180210676,
0.0338938199,
0.0168761592,
0.0110627599,
-0.0481620021,
-0.0776374862,
0.0710159913,
0.0100080688,
-0.0020081326,
0.0262631923,
0.0211294256,
-0.0120539814,
-0.0164867081,
-0.0219518319,
0.0034196766,
-0.0033702701,
0.0186862778,
0.0497898161,
-0.0165013745,
-0.0131979715,
0.0337143913,
0.0230604485,
-0.0433969274,
-0.0061009587,
-0.0312444996,
0.0063838065,
0.0670118406,
0.0113093555,
0.0109316809,
-0.0363241732,
-0.0265983734,
0.0662608147,
0.0399859399,
0.0332148001,
-0.0013097211,
0.0198091548,
-0.0437279977,
-0.0377872624,
-0.0060751545,
-0.0167101566,
0.0219507478,
0.0065964921,
-0.0200253092,
-0.0161945578,
-0.0197404046,
0.0382378884,
0.0264885612,
-0.0002426862,
0.0118500441,
-0.0488914661,
0.0086779064,
-0.0105428919,
0.0062830341,
-0.0186469425,
-0.0140864765,
0.0125841834,
-0.0287958942,
0.0451758988,
0.0124280127,
-0.0324791558,
0.0032735392,
0.0230541769,
-0.0164417326,
-0.035683699,
-0.0197023917,
-0.0139642674,
-0.009416759,
-0.0064112674,
-0.0198377967,
0.0154069932,
-0.0252211597,
-0.0078860177,
0.0246363189,
-0.0012071058,
-0.0517221279,
0.0201107319,
-0.0388399847,
0.0148586445,
0.0624180697,
0.0317676738,
0.0032617813,
-0.0424980596,
-0.0115379263,
0.0260048285,
0.0055827275,
0.0108531844,
-0.0012429653,
0.0417813659,
-0.037415076,
-0.0398812816,
-0.0744221807,
-0.0099594239,
-0.0221441239,
0.0043212473,
0.0173405819,
-0.0137088094,
-0.0311902612,
-0.0501057096,
-0.0107116103,
0.0221044943,
0.0004640508,
0.0203456581,
0.0230095573,
-0.0104799829,
0.0071144057,
-0.0303036738,
0.0177729707,
0.0101857418,
0.0234179553,
0.0108790928,
-0.0256254598,
-0.0703732595,
0.0023683598,
-0.026012769,
0.0428253934,
-0.0130982017,
-0.0163803175,
0.0387354046,
-0.0306600984,
0.0186218433,
0.0625283495,
-0.0326681435,
0.0506856814,
0.0498149469,
-0.0624398962,
-0.0705251917,
0.0348734073,
0.0339323916,
-0.0181883536,
-0.0480614342,
-0.0092946747,
-0.0083639836,
0.0462210774,
0.0102642728,
0.042604927,
-0.0251123458,
0.005665876,
-0.0032531819,
-0.0344340615,
-0.0523661561,
0.0293460879,
-0.0502295308,
0.0403081439,
-0.0664888248,
-0.0730650946,
0.0062738447,
-0.0704722106,
-0.0429302007,
0.0400621071,
-0.004143599,
0.0098268976,
0.1009479463,
0.0186254717,
0.0033106096,
-0.0338095762,
-0.0393968858,
-0.0268286075,
0.023816837,
-0.010826,
0.001185338,
0.053281337,
-0.0789707154,
0.0206975378,
-0.021995943,
-0.0106512019,
0.0040148636,
0.0531916507,
-0.0236487426,
-0.0147953322,
-0.0131833637,
-0.0453375466,
-0.0155659784,
0.0598821491,
0.0657230988,
0.0296384841,
-0.0168216284,
-0.0194474701,
-0.0300332811,
-0.0258457102,
0.0522357933,
0.0716451481,
-0.069297269,
-0.0363911539,
-0.0202387217,
0.0385539755,
0.0009190203,
-0.016299393,
-0.0501816459,
0.0329824239,
0.0598321594,
0.0013182737,
-0.0317735672,
0.040594738,
0.0710844547,
-0.0629072189,
0.003243471,
0.1014896408,
0.0133939171,
-0.053719908,
-0.0214384627,
-0.0053426209,
0.0469437689,
0.0345466211,
0.029520059,
-0.0895945728,
-0.0590833798,
0.0128180115,
-0.0167442244,
0.0552576669,
-0.040907532,
-0.0131303789,
-0.0979217291,
0.0575717092,
-0.0026839369,
-0.0524927191,
-0.0530488454,
0.0008980398,
0.0474486537,
0.0196059924,
0.0074357344,
0.0150181446,
-0.0228760019,
-0.016475508,
0.0158115402,
-0.0176141337,
-0.009044975,
-0.0021055036,
-0.0294489805,
0.0361691341,
0.0447115786,
0.0280944016,
0.0290919039,
-0.0320267603,
0.0395129733,
0.0360661112,
0.0081899688,
-0.0292221997,
0.0402690917,
-0.005152991,
-0.0281829685,
0.007374526,
-0.0046321619,
-0.02822976,
-0.0099551966,
-0.0115125021,
0.0675116181,
-0.0552946292,
0.0368706547,
-0.0125916479,
0.0125999488,
0.0180310346,
0.0385721847,
0.0339199863,
-0.0492635407,
-0.041393023,
-0.0367632508,
-0.0187430307,
-0.0192851778,
-0.0351585373,
0.0124062998,
-0.045652736,
-0.0200426802,
-0.0609581098,
-0.048604507,
0.0675133243,
0.051350072,
-0.0007712473,
-0.0096945213,
0.001551228,
0.0112412907,
0.0168023966,
0.0506725758,
-0.0445389636,
0.0223207008,
-0.0550707616,
-0.0282315239,
0.0250464622,
-0.0467154384,
0.0210361928,
0.0585908629,
-0.045545239,
-0.0503212325,
-0.0332356319,
0.063462548,
0.021777086,
0.0335227139,
0.0046320143,
-0.0792321786,
-0.006871908,
0.0067221778,
-0.0124261798,
0.0141223837,
-0.0115336031,
0.0331969894,
-0.0068782149,
0.0138164395,
-0.0472246297,
0.0088853054,
-0.0099855587,
0.0335999727,
-0.038600795,
-0.0746786296,
0.0010344409,
-0.0056589339,
0.0342778303,
-0.0219951309,
0.0042104032,
-0.0350253619,
-0.0047412319,
-0.0028511421,
-0.007126058,
-0.0902855843,
0.0335069485,
-0.0039373678,
-0.0217048414,
0.0249663386,
-0.0318616368,
0.0163157079,
0.0295610726,
-0.0214294046,
0.0254612453,
0.0066066976,
0.0148975626,
0.0088931201,
0.0535901412,
0.004437353,
0.032900285,
-0.0218452383,
0.0408888124,
-0.0009032753,
0.0933115557,
0.0001573485,
-0.056829527,
0.0059931767,
0.0475241877,
-0.0073820925,
-0.0497692376,
-0.0083256019,
0.0495532863,
0.0770108476,
0.0399412811,
0.0583533607,
-0.0357253104,
0.0024292062,
-0.0058469903,
0.0695998892,
0.028912602,
-0.0576482452,
0.0441699959,
0.0219501257,
0.0084323352,
-0.0246417597,
0.0198105089,
-0.0161250029,
0.0240723714,
0.0053731147,
-0.0094335089,
-0.0403262824,
-0.0430705696,
0.0492832549,
0.0185642522,
-0.0048505585,
0.0187738705,
-0.0176134314,
-0.0630968213,
-0.0151593983,
0.0583476201,
-0.0338585787,
-0.0109513914,
0.062220376,
0.0413030609,
0.0089842547,
-0.0162516236,
-0.0404785834,
-0.0240273438,
0.0030506598,
-0.0323175639,
-0.0458389074,
-5.778478967e-33,
-0.0649638847,
-0.049862612,
0.0613701157,
0.022046417,
-0.0403788909,
-0.0393403657,
-0.0320209116,
0.0373807065,
-0.0029830604,
-0.0129629215,
0.0079138372,
-0.0394586958,
0.0119168144,
0.026403714,
-0.0066314829,
0.0001921779,
0.012227416,
0.0035416193,
-0.027260486,
0.0302690584,
0.0410244726,
0.013868643,
0.0613787211,
-0.0515882038,
0.0129215298,
0.0049412209,
-0.0247029755,
0.0369944908,
0.0033470318,
0.0619882271,
-0.0394463018,
0.0503562391,
0.0188911799,
0.0117397048,
-0.0107466988,
0.0373621434,
-0.0520487167,
-0.0398183167,
0.0068158982,
0.0380265303,
-0.0434414782,
-0.0183480978,
0.0437986851,
-0.0246298779,
-0.011460077,
-0.0092279371,
0.0362613425,
-0.018227594,
-0.0445039198,
0.0179515127,
-0.0437699109,
0.0262584761,
-0.0072826394,
-0.0692865551,
0.0166489705,
0.0463638529,
0.0166598428,
-0.0150203574,
-0.0427733362,
0.031265948,
0.0005769672,
0.0244631395,
0.0971575752,
0.0434447564,
0.021777181,
0.0738481134,
0.0456257649,
-0.0233447589,
-0.0040605031,
-0.0104625188,
0.0478919782,
0.0462701321,
-0.03002958,
0.0475824587,
-0.0275695305,
0.0236320551,
-0.0076179695,
0.0229855012,
0.0196411423,
0.070822157,
-0.0026172097,
0.0256292094,
-0.0069984766,
0.0098917009,
-0.0294511151,
0.0265289862,
-0.0215086341,
-0.043440979,
0.0568610057,
-0.0022679036,
0.0343518108,
0.0089622848,
0.0826933309,
0.0013219044,
-0.0310993884,
-0.0316127092,
-0.0035486931,
0.0813864395,
-0.0015710365,
-0.0127865085,
-0.0236978922,
-0.0507130176,
-0.0001518135,
-0.0433812253,
0.0424530841,
0.0237733908,
-0.014490285,
0.0283817947,
-0.0616227947,
-0.0144812837,
-0.0398532487,
0.011772315,
-0.0048197871,
0.0156945493,
0.0410154723,
-0.0647639185,
-0.0525497496,
0.0644982383,
-0.0298941471,
-0.032409247,
-0.00752838,
-0.0460251383,
-0.0305695236,
-0.004592685,
-0.0355864093,
0.0167356953,
-0.047868412,
0.0086103817,
0.0153560499,
-0.0642779097,
0.0033356049,
0.0166443046,
2.816e-7,
0.0366934985,
0.0343412831,
-0.013968532,
0.0437397994,
0.0027452307,
0.0096061733,
-0.0288669914,
0.0120576676,
0.0035628413,
-0.0351662934,
-0.0177604426,
0.0424793698,
0.0283875689,
-0.0000911388,
-0.0972065106,
0.0199264288,
-0.0036114841,
0.0032155039,
-0.0364395119,
0.0196503177,
0.0470313765,
0.0413053818,
-0.0219522137,
-0.0106738815,
0.0305731818,
-0.0400874242,
0.0531392172,
-0.0726541281,
-0.0030358692,
-0.0024082935,
0.04730599,
0.0000613215,
-0.0339733288,
0.0215004012,
-0.0016698462,
-0.0295788515,
0.0175420586,
0.0502621531,
-0.0222123433,
-0.0221450664,
0.003318954,
-0.016191395,
-0.011264761,
-0.0326600112,
0.0362638198,
-0.0567379221,
0.0040482171,
-0.0269403011,
0.0256343,
-0.0376325771,
-0.0038993254,
-0.0464589968,
-0.0244798809,
0.0123206638,
0.0126753049,
-0.0387477316,
-0.0208930541,
-0.0492668599,
-0.0349907279,
-0.0112224333,
-0.0558872744,
-0.0440554656,
-0.0523942001,
-0.0464508384,
-0.0213068351,
-0.0324148946,
-0.0446154661,
2.221625778e-34,
-0.0024903368,
-0.0080824476,
0.0326521918,
0.0499089733,
0.0558846407,
0.0181683451,
0.0122133791,
0.0402550064,
0.002257114,
-0.0296998806,
-0.025749322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09456v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09456v2 | A comparative analysis of SRGAN models | 2023-07-18T17:35:45 | 2023-07-19T14:27:57 | Fatemeh Rezapoor Nikroo, Ajinkya Deshmukh, Anantha Sharma, Adrian Tam, Kaarthik Kumar, Cleo Norris, Aditya Dangi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, eess.IV | In this study, we evaluate the performance of multiple state-of-the-art SRGAN
(Super Resolution Generative Adversarial Network) models, ESRGAN, Real-ESRGAN
and EDSR, on a benchmark dataset of real-world images which undergo degradation
using a pipeline. Our results show that some models seem to significantly
increase the resolution of the input images while preserving their visual
quality, this is assessed using Tesseract OCR engine. We observe that EDSR-BASE
model from huggingface outperforms the remaining candidate models in terms of
both quantitative metrics and subjective visual quality assessments with least
compute overhead. Specifically, EDSR generates images with higher peak
signal-to-noise ratio (PSNR) and structural similarity index (SSIM) values and
are seen to return high quality OCR results with Tesseract OCR engine. These
findings suggest that EDSR is a robust and effective approach for single-image
super-resolution and may be particularly well-suited for applications where
high-quality visual fidelity is critical and optimized compute. | [
0.0093980404,
0.0879066065,
0.0254488196,
0.0465666279,
-0.0255322903,
-0.0196041614,
0.0074928473,
0.0008265176,
-0.0100689465,
0.0418731607,
0.0123058697,
-0.0269815437,
0.0038962383,
0.0306784157,
0.0192574337,
-0.0553094782,
-0.0075136763,
0.0162998289,
0.0117287654,
-0.0173979476,
-0.0128953829,
-0.0127711976,
0.0322563015,
0.0028760524,
-0.0497901328,
-0.005816299,
-0.0038483201,
0.0840467587,
0.0262560323,
-0.0125519689,
0.0056841685,
0.0375495888,
0.0503991358,
0.0185571015,
0.0000024232,
0.0184816848,
0.0402585901,
0.0196213387,
-0.0122031579,
0.0651739985,
0.0578868166,
-0.0151564861,
-0.0689083859,
-0.0086359316,
-0.028619498,
-0.0394331925,
0.0183053259,
0.0699922293,
0.0554517731,
0.0075344485,
-0.0152430451,
-0.0541745387,
0.0531770959,
-0.0572580658,
-0.049081523,
-0.0048261685,
0.0122424886,
0.0796613246,
-0.0251512937,
0.0084233582,
0.0082821744,
0.0407529734,
0.0897838026,
-0.041230388,
0.022794066,
0.0310866814,
0.0262622871,
0.020083474,
0.0079543637,
0.0208706539,
-0.1313894838,
0.0313734375,
-0.0479878038,
-0.0116750374,
-0.0004799142,
-0.0283231474,
-0.0338266753,
-0.0402885824,
-0.000332228,
0.0055845985,
-0.1331319064,
-0.0002664392,
0.011043747,
0.0016725026,
-0.0427354835,
-0.0794564486,
-0.0058390619,
0.0296312403,
-0.0375219397,
-0.0202139169,
-0.071918942,
-0.0014927766,
0.0254273955,
-0.0216725804,
-0.0119670462,
-0.0216041598,
-0.0580591038,
-0.0103853391,
0.0135137103,
-0.0020017815,
0.047500696,
-0.0199791789,
-0.020483911,
0.0156921353,
-0.0524387471,
0.0607170723,
-0.0545857362,
0.0838704258,
-0.0450749919,
-0.0273343902,
0.0032451621,
-0.0362005718,
0.0120169064,
0.0170063321,
-0.0411002748,
-0.0450557619,
-0.030823011,
-0.0161244217,
0.0161558241,
0.0162398573,
0.0197024271,
0.0474251248,
-0.0612851046,
-0.0415859446,
-0.0354430415,
-0.0184802916,
0.011358669,
0.0013634592,
0.0550736226,
-0.0466993637,
-0.0156391729,
-0.0091476645,
0.0129418885,
0.0114616612,
0.0114602735,
0.049797494,
-0.0523234792,
0.0270318724,
-0.0512113571,
0.02138092,
-0.027964199,
-0.0489582345,
-0.0094635189,
-0.0408658683,
0.0138288112,
-0.0662928447,
-0.0171264112,
-0.0621523038,
-0.0049282243,
-0.0189026389,
-0.0084352857,
0.0091030477,
0.004486403,
-0.018975962,
0.0281771217,
0.0056113182,
0.0273687374,
-0.0094708456,
0.0191279482,
0.0604288913,
-0.0002938132,
0.0061166971,
-0.0080435751,
0.0346315838,
0.027855752,
-0.0029073053,
-0.0014255544,
-0.0354210138,
0.0193485208,
0.0199720841,
0.0519509129,
0.0551159643,
-0.0461216457,
-0.0671776608,
0.0746444613,
-0.0052784691,
0.0343044475,
0.0557217151,
-0.0018716848,
0.0583695844,
0.0123360706,
0.0318800397,
-0.0185849816,
0.064965263,
0.0796699077,
0.0007251605,
0.0415782146,
0.0319438055,
-0.0643396452,
-0.0719031394,
0.0069201575,
-0.0063085905,
-0.0498152822,
-0.0230406802,
0.074775666,
0.0408134088,
-0.0508363955,
-0.1057972461,
0.0032328146,
0.014850189,
-0.0010013675,
-0.0628783256,
-0.0009890075,
0.0306513608,
0.1018679664,
-0.0187292453,
0.0158444121,
0.0105204089,
-0.0479142591,
0.006959558,
-0.0115823857,
0.0277677979,
0.0266673304,
-0.0275683012,
-0.0372231603,
0.0078417817,
-0.0122819971,
0.0613378473,
-0.0005769882,
-0.0028584229,
-0.0092930794,
-0.0762727484,
-0.0534694009,
0.0066172471,
-0.0443435796,
0.0324010849,
0.0494101495,
-0.0049372781,
0.0290482491,
-0.0184279773,
-0.0570451021,
-0.0161846578,
0.055213958,
-0.0545877405,
0.0026114015,
-0.0499514118,
-0.0668359101,
-0.0180468876,
-0.0051009771,
-0.0544209443,
0.0298544876,
0.0875545815,
-0.040592242,
0.018381631,
0.0121280318,
0.0207833983,
-0.0346678905,
-0.0762433186,
-0.0212568473,
-0.0157465599,
0.0224954244,
-0.0034698518,
0.076980494,
-0.0252584238,
-0.0422217026,
0.0352182202,
0.0011263394,
0.004705077,
-0.0417992584,
-0.0191843826,
0.0007507168,
-0.0240124874,
-0.0071007214,
0.0085921241,
-0.0068601449,
-0.0239646211,
-0.0107374135,
0.046573963,
0.0087634427,
-0.039018698,
0.0175401829,
0.0140036177,
0.0034042264,
0.0046093683,
-0.0036685036,
0.0015715571,
0.0189674422,
-0.0231872089,
-0.0466259271,
0.0402528681,
0.0011596174,
0.0349933244,
-0.0498992316,
-0.0237405188,
0.0736503974,
0.0377760977,
0.0030432472,
-0.0418445878,
-0.0360368714,
0.0302365478,
-0.0104231471,
0.0265058707,
-0.0367604382,
-0.0733184442,
-0.0128252329,
-0.020810904,
-0.0081700673,
0.0784821361,
-0.0122783566,
-0.0435419865,
-0.0422817282,
0.0376704708,
-0.015425479,
-0.0348312445,
0.0098588541,
-0.0163413733,
0.0335989557,
-0.0243726857,
-0.0492835976,
-0.0008291906,
0.0476516597,
0.0301148836,
-0.0154924691,
0.0037622438,
0.0196826588,
-0.0421751142,
-0.0033825492,
0.0348468013,
0.0274296794,
-0.0239276793,
-0.0628602952,
-0.0209274571,
0.0426728763,
-0.0013252437,
-0.0340909697,
0.0372740403,
0.0118424026,
0.0180982128,
-0.0106806085,
0.0579217002,
0.0352413543,
0.0067805443,
-0.0229044836,
-0.0371945389,
-0.024376221,
0.0430068411,
-0.0267676059,
-0.0265937056,
-0.0361065604,
0.0077145756,
-0.0314462297,
-0.0030803238,
-0.0201703068,
0.0002889389,
0.0557994097,
0.0300700944,
-0.007954143,
0.0241779126,
-0.0076497314,
0.018429067,
-0.0377182029,
0.0323087163,
0.0008607261,
-0.0251611508,
-0.0053817267,
0.0923243091,
-0.0239151325,
-0.0300729387,
0.0212983508,
-0.0089043081,
0.0579085127,
0.0519617759,
-0.0089465054,
0.0312981382,
-0.0716635659,
0.0040529892,
-0.0039772461,
0.0873532444,
-0.0066893194,
0.0008495691,
0.00205276,
-0.0133791119,
-0.0059405337,
-0.0101886541,
-0.0141900349,
0.047726132,
0.005683701,
0.0012364151,
0.0939216092,
-0.0279410016,
-0.039380528,
-0.0208802614,
-0.0096959723,
-0.0449592918,
0.006199528,
0.0298680421,
0.0048139212,
0.0133562172,
-0.0050231875,
0.0817977116,
0.0350203998,
-0.0517345667,
-0.0309759956,
0.0183844082,
0.017075086,
-0.0545970239,
0.0334031768,
-0.00194978,
0.0079359598,
-0.0081330575,
0.0214624219,
0.0634988621,
-0.0105683561,
-0.0288933553,
-0.0463261865,
-0.0323775411,
0.0583791584,
0.0028643571,
0.0205559414,
-0.0249804128,
0.0053584944,
0.0201205015,
0.0447492599,
-0.0105441604,
0.0741695985,
0.0336942188,
-0.0049345149,
-0.0176428966,
0.0446826704,
-0.0257478207,
0.0547821,
-0.0096140113,
-0.0542660989,
0.0290840175,
-0.004707851,
-0.0491865724,
-0.0199601576,
-0.022450706,
-0.0154576879,
0.028648844,
0.0104204351,
-0.0405439399,
0.0067405421,
0.0915306509,
-0.0471589752,
-0.0063147536,
0.0235647857,
-0.0143648237,
-0.0731047541,
-0.0154090477,
0.0077335639,
-0.0082737701,
-0.002236055,
-0.0332059339,
-0.0625461489,
0.0012295126,
-0.0119362092,
-0.0299089905,
-0.0327763855,
-0.0215737224,
-0.0095810713,
-0.0359768383,
0.0272083059,
0.0501744188,
-0.0253892224,
-0.0206479374,
-0.0058973916,
-0.0268380009,
0.0038713878,
0.0005734978,
0.0529526733,
-0.0014049558,
0.0340194069,
0.0034776041,
-0.0079203499,
0.0644229501,
0.0294010695,
0.0275802519,
-0.0125383222,
0.0496529005,
-0.0401944779,
-0.0201394949,
0.0442804582,
0.0078158025,
0.0707525983,
0.0084471107,
-0.0289742574,
0.0033008046,
0.0034262198,
0.0239320807,
-0.0217384398,
0.0143382316,
0.0116499811,
0.0156130008,
-0.0339637324,
0.0537945926,
0.0314612538,
0.0142557472,
-0.0409470238,
0.0131191369,
0.0051423917,
0.004175642,
0.0021879806,
0.1112572476,
0.0153554967,
0.0534376875,
-0.0388632044,
-0.0359287113,
-0.0176085569,
0.0122116134,
-0.0044461531,
0.0068587936,
-0.0122302929,
-0.0341549516,
0.0029346161,
0.0321050175,
-0.0177895185,
-0.004792524,
-0.0003926984,
0.0146156782,
0.019557517,
0.0628174767,
-0.0050512217,
-0.0597421229,
-0.0910649821,
0.0030706753,
0.1013041064,
0.0294502582,
0.0334680118,
0.0210302044,
0.0039397683,
-0.0684847757,
0.0089956569,
0.0772076398,
-0.0195151828,
-0.0141247921,
0.0043451018,
0.0601940416,
0.0065862364,
0.0617814548,
-0.0261426289,
0.0004184981,
-0.0295189489,
0.0225602128,
-0.0141861318,
-0.0210168436,
-0.0046870694,
-0.0228429046,
0.0249316096,
0.0066405176,
0.0425616391,
-0.0085334601,
-0.0594758317,
0.0147333853,
-0.0059064431,
-0.0082811061,
0.0321500786,
-0.0051515163,
-0.0162401237,
0.0169147737,
0.033471968,
-0.0061945962,
0.0034893055,
-0.0132765695,
0.0312942527,
-6.634740643e-33,
0.0024406824,
0.0007469647,
-0.010087043,
-0.0516647734,
-0.0159019921,
0.0049638483,
-0.0324972793,
-0.0321938433,
-0.0563909896,
0.0141483815,
-0.0347431153,
0.0407339633,
0.0031089915,
0.0437178873,
-0.0659042597,
0.0017794663,
0.0672558919,
0.0061012772,
-0.006017372,
0.0032733001,
-0.006211271,
-0.0057633598,
0.0291923024,
-0.0777013302,
-0.0532530397,
-0.0130574936,
-0.0315667205,
-0.0601239614,
0.0420544371,
0.0299488157,
0.0051360433,
0.0536543652,
-0.0121759577,
-0.0536919534,
-0.0178197231,
-0.02512981,
-0.0980396271,
0.0198565647,
-0.0629086569,
-0.010898944,
-0.0884505138,
-0.0217679963,
-0.0140130352,
-0.0023430036,
-0.0220923442,
-0.0164613687,
0.049347207,
-0.0519776382,
-0.0308002587,
0.0132392757,
-0.00057624,
0.0246699117,
-0.051833462,
-0.0244999304,
0.0293468982,
0.0295678303,
-0.0026103284,
0.0301557016,
-0.0461737774,
0.015108658,
-0.0042068744,
0.0246284977,
0.0427888706,
0.0210914873,
0.0052847196,
0.0052692569,
-0.025091216,
-0.0412209928,
0.0141626243,
-0.0383800678,
0.0006514108,
0.0176421329,
0.0604587682,
0.0354642943,
0.0564893484,
-0.028752286,
-0.0546853803,
0.0487449467,
-0.0129928291,
0.060477756,
0.0234012175,
0.0335929953,
0.0412695035,
-0.0224500056,
0.000555394,
-0.051007852,
-0.0143914698,
-0.0208032113,
0.0161092672,
0.0362716168,
-0.0155343488,
-0.0412557125,
-0.0116477609,
-0.0404599532,
0.0090743648,
0.0291919261,
-0.0099513615,
0.0143764326,
0.0042596464,
-0.0104877986,
-0.0007536703,
0.0352267176,
0.0524242334,
0.0713928118,
-0.0152533231,
-0.0170688853,
0.0159184933,
0.0066773822,
0.0290906057,
0.0037602277,
-0.038519036,
0.0368540809,
0.0239064842,
-0.0112970909,
-0.0144261606,
-0.0510874949,
-0.0058095101,
0.0640142336,
-0.0365882404,
0.0607194379,
-0.0209389944,
0.037601579,
0.0347431563,
0.0115194805,
-0.0227378011,
0.0311346799,
-0.0808318183,
-0.0841736123,
0.0506824665,
-0.0411282741,
-0.0564877018,
0.0198599454,
2.976e-7,
-0.0210378878,
0.0322259814,
0.0395334587,
-0.0046534026,
0.0036077646,
0.0263146088,
0.0119055277,
-0.0000476503,
-0.0280408822,
-0.0104608759,
0.0442290083,
0.0152059002,
0.0134997414,
0.0103404932,
-0.0044129076,
0.0236799251,
-0.0429816246,
0.0352624059,
0.0304872841,
0.0086018164,
0.0302306879,
0.05581652,
-0.0498564951,
-0.0331671648,
0.0624216758,
-0.0045309393,
-0.00294157,
-0.0002994102,
0.0531494953,
0.0336346216,
0.0100437934,
0.0790622607,
-0.000820663,
-0.0084812464,
0.0129146324,
-0.0571201965,
0.0810209587,
-0.0106480159,
-0.0275143888,
-0.0506046191,
-0.0067427801,
0.0294018798,
0.0092149489,
-0.0552122779,
0.0511253513,
-0.0178150553,
-0.0212955531,
0.0127674658,
-0.0623400658,
0.0087238215,
0.0413725898,
-0.0271457396,
-0.0244941134,
0.0132895252,
0.0341788642,
0.0173356757,
-0.0129621699,
-0.0013574809,
0.0270044375,
-0.0229564067,
-0.0130097913,
-0.0259421766,
-0.0424836837,
0.0195311029,
0.0572876744,
-0.0074500879,
-0.0202689879,
1.993994282e-34,
-0.0006135333,
0.0257032607,
0.0230619311,
-0.0444604866,
-0.0289890897,
0.0158083402,
-0.032092426,
-0.0210547559,
-0.0444021747,
-0.0033026098,
-0.0359617993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09455v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09455v2 | Pseudo Outlier Exposure for Out-of-Distribution Detection using Pretrained Transformers | 2023-07-18T17:29:23 | 2023-07-19T04:13:11 | Jaeyoung Kim, Kyuheon Jung, Dongbin Na, Sion Jang, Eunbin Park, Sungchul Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 | For real-world language applications, detecting an out-of-distribution (OOD)
sample is helpful to alert users or reject such unreliable samples. However,
modern over-parameterized language models often produce overconfident
predictions for both in-distribution (ID) and OOD samples. In particular,
language models suffer from OOD samples with a similar semantic representation
to ID samples since these OOD samples lie near the ID manifold. A rejection
network can be trained with ID and diverse outlier samples to detect test OOD
samples, but explicitly collecting auxiliary OOD datasets brings an additional
burden for data collection. In this paper, we propose a simple but effective
method called Pseudo Outlier Exposure (POE) that constructs a surrogate OOD
dataset by sequentially masking tokens related to ID classes. The surrogate OOD
sample introduced by POE shows a similar representation to ID data, which is
most effective in training a rejection network. Our method does not require any
external OOD data and can be easily implemented within off-the-shelf
Transformers. A comprehensive comparison with state-of-the-art algorithms
demonstrates POE's competitiveness on several text classification benchmarks. | [
0.0110483412,
0.0136282546,
0.0094418423,
0.023955306,
-0.0104988907,
0.0234583244,
-0.0260031372,
0.0385766439,
-0.0015274414,
-0.0373354293,
-0.0032116142,
-0.0026401887,
-0.0237159654,
0.0432173833,
0.0045706541,
-0.005505722,
0.0251396485,
0.0028434389,
0.0324939415,
0.0004440779,
-0.009594975,
0.02732943,
0.0079177851,
0.0287013017,
0.0018924205,
-0.0236717667,
0.0439535454,
0.0258809179,
0.0116373394,
-0.0161920004,
0.0456343181,
0.0238510557,
0.0074342932,
0.0630885661,
0.0000019295,
-0.0453089327,
-0.0282462295,
0.0177397281,
-0.0216757711,
0.0017216551,
0.0272983946,
-0.0279821809,
-0.012676293,
0.0292607713,
-0.0146783795,
-0.0244003199,
0.0446940511,
0.0834140033,
0.0195413996,
0.0819084942,
-0.0269126054,
0.0552592501,
-0.0026536949,
-0.0066761402,
-0.0235068537,
0.0199614856,
0.0453103632,
-0.0637745112,
-0.0318613127,
-0.0116309887,
-0.0195837244,
-0.0001416991,
0.0043066,
0.0289557111,
-0.0029174949,
0.0309688654,
-0.023493113,
-0.0004913399,
-0.0182468388,
0.0789127126,
-0.0917918161,
-0.0416091904,
0.0016689757,
-0.0499010384,
0.0103486925,
0.0214571618,
-0.0208437536,
-0.0079266112,
0.0255852938,
0.0406164974,
-0.0065417578,
0.0499973558,
0.0337522551,
0.0116317822,
-0.0292083547,
0.0214954838,
0.0043105772,
-0.0102498513,
-0.0045058471,
-0.013151749,
-0.0508881994,
-0.0305957869,
0.0166978575,
0.0097693605,
0.0028003543,
-0.0097686667,
-0.0573026314,
-0.0475969352,
0.0412220955,
-0.0378642306,
0.0593466535,
-0.0131423455,
-0.0716612265,
0.0263622906,
0.0076128459,
0.0184305627,
-0.0165248048,
0.1165460423,
-0.0246310141,
-0.0105337678,
-0.0063523757,
0.0226832535,
-0.0355382673,
0.0435492583,
-0.0220394693,
-0.0107970294,
-0.027130859,
0.0300201178,
-0.011627174,
-0.0133576915,
-0.0054349448,
0.0078553576,
-0.0331957154,
-0.0183718223,
0.002074637,
0.0177192222,
0.0134838074,
-0.0086050564,
-0.0254134424,
-0.0831388384,
-0.0517335534,
0.0652473271,
0.016501423,
-0.0236597098,
0.0284455437,
0.0434264503,
0.0318575203,
-0.0396858901,
-0.0076650498,
-0.0165277366,
-0.0028697955,
-0.0157110523,
-0.0172912516,
-0.0765018091,
-0.0567892641,
0.0168807171,
0.0005657937,
-0.0578798726,
-0.0059092543,
0.0422373079,
-0.0150007652,
-0.0091264928,
-0.0321227871,
-0.0212562717,
0.0276452582,
-0.0179363806,
-0.0001236502,
0.058668144,
-0.0235689189,
-0.012292101,
0.0581264161,
0.019381173,
0.1092166081,
0.0624450706,
0.0283698402,
0.0193689596,
-0.0049534007,
-0.0005888604,
0.0052230568,
-0.0238449741,
0.0433669873,
0.0131886899,
0.0016464831,
-0.0458791703,
0.0370582342,
-0.0274385307,
-0.0343954042,
-0.0267935209,
-0.0178080704,
0.0254664868,
-0.0548341908,
-0.0097029228,
-0.0381415822,
0.0112197343,
-0.0158145577,
-0.0367568061,
-0.0224685427,
0.0155198565,
-0.0449230857,
-0.0267393757,
-0.0233598761,
-0.0273658503,
-0.0199493952,
0.0104240421,
0.0820199177,
0.0210609753,
-0.0339069515,
0.0328671746,
0.0179766659,
0.0258057062,
0.0000522968,
-0.0485113934,
-0.0128187612,
-0.0123158246,
0.058182586,
-0.059505295,
0.0462917387,
-0.0390444025,
0.0235083327,
0.0242294203,
0.0064892885,
0.008930767,
0.0292721298,
-0.0323769785,
-0.0144286407,
0.0250525195,
0.0299105737,
-0.0039604092,
0.0055818064,
0.0103016049,
0.0349047147,
-0.1110989749,
-0.0426022895,
0.0564060323,
0.0153705319,
-0.0662188604,
0.0296600945,
0.0136393737,
0.021932276,
0.0015356109,
-0.0178661384,
-0.0098829977,
0.042236831,
-0.0148855653,
-0.0182066541,
-0.027256554,
-0.0201028436,
-0.0491344221,
0.0136033297,
-0.0337228999,
-0.0130202193,
0.0581608303,
-0.0424439572,
-0.001530341,
0.0165686607,
-0.0463589281,
0.0457421094,
-0.0683211014,
-0.026332844,
-0.0019457143,
0.0664870217,
-0.0010356501,
0.0541588515,
-0.0255325139,
0.0478533022,
-0.012978497,
-0.022269791,
0.0395415276,
-0.0159271155,
-0.0355239399,
-0.009078538,
-0.0524263047,
0.0185095631,
-0.005681213,
-0.0072247367,
-0.0126421405,
0.0030183261,
0.0105893295,
-0.0455476381,
-0.0507150218,
0.0039849337,
0.0294666942,
0.0056069298,
-0.0231242273,
-0.0272120461,
-0.0072025899,
-0.0445565432,
0.0372498706,
-0.0018266841,
0.0313638896,
-0.027043134,
-0.0273348428,
0.0340094678,
-0.0162814576,
-0.007490132,
0.0844973847,
-0.0271479785,
-0.0291711725,
-0.0650258884,
-0.0170585327,
-0.0289071649,
0.0396488048,
-0.0047601126,
-0.0389973037,
-0.0427811071,
-0.0005422567,
0.0268153977,
0.0158876497,
0.0122565022,
-0.0270882994,
0.0300140977,
0.0239904597,
-0.0333640762,
-0.0427140072,
-0.0419635288,
0.0120482175,
0.0073466585,
0.0039122039,
0.0372870043,
-0.0139678651,
0.0230882466,
-0.0386747308,
-0.0020144044,
0.0113705462,
0.005281609,
0.0131001798,
0.0161832273,
-0.0071426672,
-0.0256443545,
0.0242220033,
0.008291889,
-0.0145637682,
0.0616614148,
-0.0005549839,
-0.0062831691,
-0.0440734997,
-0.0189676899,
0.0024518205,
-0.0228095781,
0.004967107,
0.0201749522,
0.0021477612,
-0.046141196,
-0.0125935143,
-0.0235282704,
-0.0179090854,
-0.01542388,
0.0166369267,
-0.004980796,
0.0008863195,
0.0280392785,
-0.0178606976,
-0.0522791967,
-0.0982930809,
0.0160748977,
-0.0195461195,
-0.0516351759,
-0.0154075241,
-0.0405122079,
-0.0055909138,
-0.0435199514,
0.0963464156,
-0.0035840434,
0.0015152462,
0.0051595094,
0.0451792888,
0.0208387915,
-0.0306575689,
0.0471243002,
-0.0337350704,
-0.0029642947,
0.0487016514,
0.0337439366,
-0.0145292319,
0.009410887,
-0.0199093688,
0.0167084783,
-0.0257981364,
0.0166658089,
0.0495862737,
0.0065482142,
0.0152715007,
-0.053950347,
0.0804967284,
0.0291608907,
-0.0461478271,
0.0146386856,
0.0063715796,
0.0635322705,
0.0364315994,
-0.0103465896,
-0.0404901579,
0.0108480649,
0.0117194047,
0.0303693321,
-0.0486756787,
-0.0345636047,
0.0090508051,
-0.1162072793,
0.0423890688,
0.0126988692,
-0.0561111346,
-0.0681016967,
-0.045649536,
0.006284263,
0.0155173186,
0.0145556526,
-0.0161084831,
0.0331617333,
-0.0146123571,
0.0044056484,
-0.0340945646,
-0.0888030231,
0.0451773033,
-0.0245141014,
0.004998921,
0.0095514376,
0.0085070217,
-0.0265739765,
-0.0022205347,
0.0285801142,
-0.0815617368,
-0.0119414963,
-0.0124542015,
0.0924458504,
0.0097291423,
-0.0094469441,
-0.0114978896,
0.0382276438,
-0.0906661227,
0.0011147076,
-0.023960473,
0.0824590102,
-0.0273215026,
-0.0209981743,
-0.0158991478,
-0.007721541,
0.0658511072,
0.0520240217,
-0.0120564913,
-0.0452183075,
-0.0054280711,
-0.010352809,
0.0078974031,
0.0230104066,
0.0646504611,
0.0583487563,
0.0289819762,
-0.1258627027,
-0.0721007288,
-0.0107298521,
-0.0432425514,
0.048638992,
0.0088439034,
-0.0192121137,
-0.0532180183,
-0.0095709749,
-0.0292702131,
-0.0073948512,
-0.0225526243,
0.0102652153,
-0.0253645219,
0.0436066948,
0.0198773816,
-0.0112045445,
-0.0554988272,
0.0291404072,
-0.0623774491,
-0.067635864,
0.0481508523,
0.0058705066,
0.0202968847,
0.0209779348,
-0.0470501184,
-0.0585734248,
0.0877027735,
0.0804041326,
-0.0218950007,
-0.0015042113,
0.0297635458,
-0.0854129344,
0.0050958465,
0.0353606045,
-0.0311515406,
0.0467798933,
0.0376723483,
-0.0500009172,
-0.0372070521,
-0.0038636962,
0.0160511043,
0.0125696892,
0.0580780059,
-0.0159510411,
-0.0297449101,
-0.0289148875,
0.0159020554,
-0.0131644458,
-0.0130373919,
0.0046533789,
0.0313549116,
0.0480970629,
0.0114336805,
-0.0575714782,
0.0546992943,
-0.0359449424,
0.0459885597,
0.0017540377,
0.0026117393,
0.0438000113,
0.0158742182,
0.0327941999,
0.0034499012,
-0.0116150416,
-0.0345688611,
0.004177731,
0.0224137791,
-0.015811136,
0.0263298508,
0.0291105136,
0.0273541473,
-0.0191846173,
-0.0271942317,
-0.0596939139,
0.055899214,
-0.0729444772,
0.0349828713,
-0.0007406947,
-0.0168959349,
-0.0176443513,
-0.0221919678,
-0.0063217552,
-0.037606284,
0.020805439,
-0.0305357613,
-0.0232919212,
0.0173424426,
-0.004103228,
-0.0103875427,
0.0245311968,
0.0517738573,
0.0131055713,
0.0300753005,
0.0178910568,
-0.0032042805,
-0.0435829498,
0.0571897924,
0.0057984274,
0.0455984771,
0.0015542139,
-0.0072994586,
-0.0094171334,
-0.0598911494,
0.0316760279,
-0.013229249,
0.0019976012,
0.0264612641,
0.023656955,
0.0725376606,
-0.0239223689,
-0.0030094779,
-0.0011461572,
-0.0125239054,
0.0113180391,
-0.0433424637,
-0.0153938476,
-6.035865577e-33,
0.0252069253,
-0.0421827249,
-0.0595006905,
-0.0171496309,
0.0336602516,
-0.0161439572,
0.0227150749,
-0.0329648703,
-0.0144865038,
0.0178234354,
-0.0077916095,
0.0282751434,
0.0116721457,
0.0421867073,
-0.0409930684,
-0.0086157834,
0.0394373313,
-0.0250910688,
-0.0289444216,
0.0314368084,
0.0389953144,
0.0348132923,
0.087667495,
-0.1014693528,
0.0004960836,
-0.0324969105,
-0.0278678592,
0.0206476655,
0.0317884833,
0.0428536683,
0.0006981019,
0.1092691198,
0.0236283559,
0.0178421885,
-0.0023977472,
-0.0040856181,
-0.0363784581,
-0.041193001,
-0.0382291377,
0.0273583643,
0.0931762233,
-0.0022153859,
0.0600003116,
-0.0423821285,
-0.029590426,
-0.0169269945,
0.0589007661,
-0.0021271643,
-0.0218446217,
0.0202983394,
-0.0179083198,
0.0453776643,
-0.0023365726,
-0.0059724948,
-0.0033456995,
0.0447591767,
0.0258020218,
0.0206557699,
-0.05771235,
0.0066784187,
0.011151175,
-0.0162977856,
-0.0105738938,
0.0231343154,
-0.038366206,
0.0394302458,
-0.0176703315,
-0.0084738741,
-0.0062766355,
0.0043179831,
0.0686625093,
0.0244629197,
0.0162199177,
0.0663622245,
0.0649025738,
-0.0381696932,
-0.0880983174,
0.0311625451,
-0.0401341803,
-0.0771468803,
0.0498861633,
-0.0375409983,
-0.0716114864,
-0.0237847231,
0.0186750218,
-0.0552174039,
-0.0023349747,
-0.0072658844,
0.0177364685,
0.0059709232,
-0.0037444844,
0.0134520754,
0.0051910118,
-0.0556795374,
-0.0620133914,
0.0117540732,
-0.0133688925,
0.0263224486,
-0.0018052942,
0.0081468197,
-0.0257997494,
-0.023708012,
0.0379379652,
0.0280911475,
-0.0137902219,
-0.0368221886,
0.0866487101,
0.0511839055,
-0.0942459181,
0.0122852828,
0.009789818,
0.0475826152,
0.0133904107,
0.0805220231,
0.0136049464,
-0.0073090615,
-0.0178475678,
0.0070892004,
0.0176255926,
0.0167465173,
-0.013377714,
0.0349967033,
-0.0375883244,
-0.004105798,
-0.0300937593,
-0.0162308533,
0.0278218444,
-0.0070052338,
0.0540504195,
-0.056070853,
0.0235141907,
-0.0060284948,
2.615e-7,
0.0363498777,
0.0337467268,
0.0115050841,
-0.0261963569,
0.0188443027,
0.0142680164,
0.0086184628,
0.0330353007,
-0.0018665268,
-0.043952059,
0.0296587721,
-0.0171820428,
-0.0193331745,
0.0278564207,
-0.1001994982,
0.0344483517,
-0.0398666635,
0.0196455084,
-0.0425517708,
-0.0195804946,
0.0416730009,
0.1191706061,
0.0529471077,
-0.0447673388,
0.0097631626,
-0.040581122,
0.0484757349,
-0.0167628806,
0.0246045161,
-0.0058990694,
0.0596016161,
0.0238592308,
0.0707419887,
0.046270024,
-0.0245290343,
0.0468676053,
0.0121749714,
0.009359939,
-0.0328538381,
-0.0365943834,
-0.005461128,
0.0440429971,
-0.007110802,
-0.059440095,
0.0426829942,
-0.0491368696,
-0.0248098318,
-0.0256141275,
-0.0450632274,
-0.0312188342,
0.0449916944,
-0.0214563794,
0.0066487202,
0.0544758476,
0.0594843775,
-0.0113918977,
0.0224391911,
-0.0601724349,
-0.0234901328,
-0.007288456,
-0.0493137017,
-0.0371211767,
0.0048214155,
0.0194260869,
0.0253575016,
-0.0369038209,
0.0310769938,
2.57317045e-34,
0.0657960773,
-0.0003688047,
-0.0219529904,
-0.0178788397,
0.0090860343,
-0.0059598698,
0.0643677935,
0.0044566062,
-0.0020010341,
-0.0256804749,
0.0092880055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09416v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09416v2 | Let's ViCE! Mimicking Human Cognitive Behavior in Image Generation Evaluation | 2023-07-18T16:33:30 | 2023-07-19T08:27:50 | Federico Betti, Jacopo Staiano, Lorenzo Baraldi, Lorenzo Baraldi, Rita Cucchiara, Nicu Sebe | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Research in Image Generation has recently made significant progress,
particularly boosted by the introduction of Vision-Language models which are
able to produce high-quality visual content based on textual inputs. Despite
ongoing advancements in terms of generation quality and realism, no methodical
frameworks have been defined yet to quantitatively measure the quality of the
generated content and the adherence with the prompted requests: so far, only
human-based evaluations have been adopted for quality satisfaction and for
comparing different generative methods. We introduce a novel automated method
for Visual Concept Evaluation (ViCE), i.e. to assess consistency between a
generated/edited image and the corresponding prompt/instructions, with a
process inspired by the human cognitive behaviour. ViCE combines the strengths
of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Visual Question Answering (VQA) into a
unified pipeline, aiming to replicate the human cognitive process in quality
assessment. This method outlines visual concepts, formulates image-specific
verification questions, utilizes the Q&A system to investigate the image, and
scores the combined outcome. Although this brave new hypothesis of mimicking
humans in the image evaluation process is in its preliminary assessment stage,
results are promising and open the door to a new form of automatic evaluation
which could have significant impact as the image generation or the image target
editing tasks become more and more sophisticated. | [
0.0359854661,
0.0595619045,
0.0027550603,
0.021564696,
-0.0451196767,
0.0194893181,
0.0075002713,
0.0246473774,
-0.0235985871,
-0.0275750328,
-0.0285858642,
-0.0535595715,
0.0161211453,
0.0388268195,
0.0321588889,
-0.0725843757,
-0.0299400706,
-0.0122024575,
-0.0045351055,
-0.0019176148,
0.0148129342,
-0.032265611,
0.0210645776,
0.0280880351,
-0.0300799478,
-0.0183356125,
-0.022026984,
0.0374258012,
0.0296383947,
-0.0139395269,
-0.052974768,
0.064271681,
-0.0151256714,
0.0130368974,
0.0000019789,
-0.0477258638,
0.0441372879,
-0.0215608086,
0.0201590173,
0.0322042704,
0.0350703709,
-0.0081416443,
-0.0233523604,
-0.0464738682,
-0.0297878142,
0.0385698192,
0.0678470805,
0.0418576933,
0.1386510581,
-0.0005392783,
-0.0115394518,
-0.0206543524,
-0.0268040411,
0.0050004278,
0.0409233086,
-0.002028629,
-0.0152640911,
0.0324933231,
0.0160048492,
-0.0109160775,
0.0019929055,
0.0282052085,
0.0233791545,
-0.047773052,
0.0248107966,
0.0293776505,
-0.0204599854,
-0.0592080057,
-0.007963784,
0.0358115956,
-0.0284755174,
0.015292896,
-0.0258682054,
-0.0099007254,
-0.0104533993,
0.0318421572,
-0.0547750741,
0.0221125931,
-0.0063929665,
-0.0135985119,
-0.0662680492,
0.025295265,
-0.0125262821,
-0.022765629,
0.0357543416,
-0.0163341276,
0.0400413163,
-0.0012205013,
-0.0457958058,
0.0414575264,
-0.0726168454,
-0.0801798776,
0.0019606526,
0.0322380699,
0.0009307742,
-0.0257664453,
-0.0191614181,
-0.0175918844,
0.0287609771,
-0.031089196,
0.0919702128,
0.016891988,
-0.0453386419,
0.0658599734,
-0.0121278083,
0.1073045284,
-0.0034505718,
0.0219003689,
-0.0444933176,
0.0194692928,
-0.0414735116,
-0.0241761617,
-0.01298327,
-0.0209006332,
-0.0109448396,
-0.0303791184,
-0.0536859445,
0.0184704661,
-0.0499532744,
0.0345298164,
0.0139385862,
0.0530797802,
-0.0267730337,
-0.0163873732,
-0.0873211697,
-0.0060342383,
-0.0219274014,
0.0206123311,
-0.0115286512,
-0.0143159665,
0.0223207381,
0.0429411158,
0.0065297266,
0.0191499572,
-0.0043909787,
0.0538069271,
-0.0227909293,
0.0259642899,
-0.0240800828,
-0.0309783574,
-0.0042191157,
-0.0382784493,
0.0197568815,
-0.0571379624,
0.0071162689,
-0.0366678983,
-0.0308403391,
-0.0035023277,
-0.0147650111,
0.0410373621,
0.0118723726,
0.0473071113,
-0.0191554632,
0.0224388223,
0.0331869051,
0.0243839156,
-0.0051795528,
0.0109313615,
0.0196161997,
0.0787229836,
0.0351852216,
-0.0091286208,
0.0516319387,
0.0332941748,
-0.0068323896,
-0.0081742778,
-0.0588591583,
0.0017434203,
-0.0054252991,
0.0348001085,
0.0295895077,
0.0849186182,
-0.0360827856,
-0.0120212007,
0.0770409107,
0.0379382074,
0.0214389544,
-0.0047125113,
0.0824816823,
0.0057163178,
0.0147759253,
0.0583849773,
-0.0094138402,
0.0923887715,
0.0163143165,
0.0336067118,
0.0034217676,
0.0292671826,
-0.025152361,
-0.0475889705,
-0.0046178517,
-0.0014330166,
-0.0087732542,
-0.0214138739,
0.0078687379,
0.0268896539,
-0.0347202085,
-0.0623153001,
-0.0389132574,
-0.0455041938,
0.0134616429,
-0.0676818341,
0.0560246594,
0.0749415532,
0.0396153778,
0.0622024797,
0.0387075022,
0.0111796008,
0.0072286357,
0.0610427223,
-0.0111692902,
-0.0188316442,
-0.0050943978,
-0.0226850752,
-0.0286007971,
-0.0366239697,
-0.0151623515,
0.0030131368,
-0.0102884285,
0.0037217543,
-0.0074592507,
-0.0094393576,
-0.0332629196,
0.0369014405,
0.0555186123,
-0.0093799569,
-0.0130653437,
0.0430641063,
-0.004922241,
-0.0017886558,
-0.0351563878,
0.0336201228,
0.0095917871,
-0.02563034,
0.0031463176,
0.0064869211,
-0.0150150787,
0.0075554531,
0.0245301854,
-0.0652528107,
-0.0145694204,
-0.0060636098,
-0.0070577012,
-0.0107789915,
-0.0047756187,
-0.0453882627,
-0.027753802,
-0.0885967314,
0.0144492248,
0.0070081353,
-0.0137029886,
-0.0144749768,
0.0609224327,
-0.0187120382,
0.0124166124,
0.0310414117,
-0.0005879677,
-0.0018937265,
-0.0190249495,
-0.0340962447,
-0.0272662789,
0.0114614405,
0.0167167261,
0.0154482201,
0.0472703055,
-0.0778284743,
-0.003806897,
-0.0553552769,
-0.0429287627,
-0.0062412075,
-0.0199257992,
0.0109993545,
-0.0412525125,
-0.0015653557,
-0.0128137078,
-0.0300361738,
0.0137039293,
0.0167117696,
0.0109137297,
0.0634254664,
-0.0043967413,
0.0142641161,
-0.0354949608,
0.0111727798,
0.0587615408,
0.0809514746,
0.085153304,
0.0316517241,
-0.0456761196,
0.0177820195,
-0.0469770171,
-0.0180491395,
0.0361116081,
-0.0478229038,
0.0280161668,
0.01327434,
0.0148932952,
0.0800810754,
0.0453561917,
-0.0395421274,
0.0271288399,
0.0052288477,
-0.0187302101,
-0.0270271767,
0.0160347819,
-0.030688813,
0.0733147711,
-0.0520270355,
0.0032765151,
0.0009229647,
0.0050873579,
0.0550009347,
-0.060315039,
0.106646575,
0.001948518,
-0.0518614277,
-0.0501839519,
-0.0137411896,
-0.005318508,
0.0455302633,
-0.0534400679,
-0.0907032117,
0.0726937577,
-0.0480628125,
-0.013724016,
0.0514134094,
0.0314019918,
0.0261427909,
0.0653462559,
0.032388214,
0.048677057,
0.033630427,
0.0358840525,
-0.0760194734,
0.002341378,
0.0625733435,
-0.0303232949,
0.0014327337,
-0.072871767,
-0.0268566776,
-0.0140250744,
-0.0105740782,
-0.0566210262,
0.0419720411,
-0.0104535334,
-0.0169118363,
0.0144475922,
-0.0043565878,
0.0174586102,
0.0456988476,
0.0185413957,
-0.0150515409,
0.0184023082,
-0.0332030021,
0.015249759,
0.0645185634,
0.0656926408,
0.0192670003,
-0.0291245934,
-0.0366671532,
0.019625783,
0.0431729108,
-0.0366902389,
0.0191510096,
-0.0463016368,
0.0565622151,
0.0018318341,
0.0436709039,
0.0066255247,
0.0318780839,
0.0665927902,
-0.0289792512,
-0.0215894133,
0.0724099949,
0.0249291416,
-0.0276011471,
-0.0169182681,
-0.0036796839,
0.0076692384,
0.0276681259,
0.0241506938,
-0.0828929767,
-0.0063861613,
-0.0368747562,
-0.0078847567,
-0.0364391059,
-0.0006635207,
-0.0219212789,
-0.058313258,
0.1080624089,
0.013983598,
0.003003201,
-0.0246229749,
0.0043949033,
0.0193212051,
0.0123851169,
-0.0619963072,
0.0227968078,
0.0269568879,
0.0169463791,
-0.0174890459,
0.028112065,
-0.0182526279,
0.0215816889,
-0.0569197237,
0.0039802664,
0.0921539515,
0.0153461993,
0.0211043265,
-0.1192419603,
-0.02878334,
-0.0183730181,
0.0245504435,
0.0103163496,
0.0463743359,
0.0171790458,
-0.0138485776,
-0.0417909622,
-0.002812183,
0.0342931338,
-0.0382845961,
0.008355313,
0.0106587876,
-0.0120230597,
-0.0210287794,
-0.0732353106,
0.0184636358,
0.0048496779,
0.0213193055,
0.0691002607,
-0.0470403917,
-0.0309688523,
-0.00289171,
0.0141627965,
-0.0794979855,
-0.0626966506,
0.0040470175,
0.0196099598,
-0.00747093,
-0.0955771357,
0.0171832237,
0.0120766349,
0.0362568945,
-0.0151749924,
-0.0461079255,
-0.0367471687,
0.0095543331,
-0.0626113266,
0.0071651414,
0.0266059618,
0.0059249913,
-0.055852741,
-0.0095256157,
-0.0072661,
-0.0259333663,
-0.0235063806,
0.0261645615,
-0.0532006398,
-0.0084280213,
-0.0430938564,
0.0656938702,
0.0164255612,
-0.0176021382,
0.0278472938,
-0.0264777206,
0.0332546346,
0.0461399816,
0.0163115729,
0.0059440089,
-0.0142356837,
-0.0025591899,
-0.0108171087,
-0.0066025774,
-0.0301258154,
0.035877835,
0.0209923554,
0.011646213,
0.0047653788,
-0.0447782837,
0.0304827392,
0.0270214379,
0.009944533,
-0.0558155961,
0.0125018563,
0.0083626788,
-0.0369149372,
0.01242809,
-0.0277960487,
-0.06344717,
-0.0081245257,
-0.0120581686,
-0.0017344099,
0.0100600095,
0.0012913654,
-0.0391073748,
0.0250012167,
-0.0343694389,
-0.0161772557,
0.0115137314,
0.004525458,
-0.0115960054,
0.0027749029,
0.0216501113,
0.001854068,
-0.0364008434,
0.043952439,
0.0245802961,
0.0553468131,
0.0147545654,
-0.0059254947,
0.0100632841,
0.0590618402,
-0.0110784685,
-0.0504975282,
-0.0638381541,
0.0275163967,
0.0893003643,
-0.0040945988,
-0.0077594779,
-0.0038004981,
-0.0197016541,
-0.0311118737,
0.0306319557,
0.0173449274,
-0.046529185,
0.0339936949,
0.0165411346,
0.0077056042,
-0.0308818053,
0.0377285779,
-0.0419940986,
-0.0214663502,
-0.0335711092,
-0.0007055937,
-0.0318894722,
-0.0015952071,
-0.0027934152,
-0.0248148087,
0.0007398887,
0.0441055521,
-0.0395864695,
-0.0653057396,
0.0003098086,
0.0863924921,
0.0471542254,
0.0484584011,
0.0654893592,
0.0525854863,
-0.0107021509,
0.0121897366,
0.0024859649,
-0.0226657875,
-0.0356578305,
0.0061173667,
-0.0237887558,
-5.778135502e-33,
-0.0282675996,
-0.0756836981,
0.0208227597,
-0.021753449,
0.0023226966,
-0.0098390654,
-0.0370500386,
-0.0080097085,
0.0193758998,
0.0131061282,
0.0257819481,
-0.036247775,
-0.0125551624,
-0.010254343,
0.0125100985,
0.0235711876,
0.0572849549,
0.0014937007,
-0.0747896358,
-0.0015327079,
-0.0229697861,
-0.0207647681,
-0.0169292204,
-0.0260046124,
-0.0297129154,
-0.0108105307,
-0.0395127423,
-0.017568823,
0.0187791288,
0.0978377908,
-0.0104231024,
-0.0000713702,
0.0088238204,
-0.0302983858,
-0.013185163,
0.0102574211,
-0.0102859735,
-0.034334816,
-0.0109508736,
-0.0350089483,
-0.094419919,
-0.0015314401,
0.0403036773,
-0.0351070687,
-0.0223469567,
-0.027798783,
0.0565894246,
-0.0317851193,
0.0404803492,
-0.0148185147,
-0.0416464098,
0.0063362368,
-0.0223927684,
-0.0555014126,
0.0078380592,
0.0341139138,
0.0062948633,
0.0048396112,
-0.0678965449,
0.0596932732,
0.0062639001,
0.0031255519,
0.088636294,
0.0126396418,
0.0096885562,
0.0497506224,
0.0036537794,
-0.0317709409,
-0.0186800603,
0.0019087059,
-0.0075547718,
0.0594931804,
0.0580971986,
0.0644254833,
0.0295530837,
-0.0157212503,
-0.0175494868,
0.0709088519,
-0.0701355636,
0.0816273391,
-0.0052045533,
0.0059662643,
0.0165304188,
0.0337374583,
-0.026251765,
-0.0271159355,
-0.0730281845,
-0.0433940403,
0.0147201745,
0.0048646349,
-0.0144433379,
-0.0429771543,
0.0208005831,
-0.0101104742,
0.025955312,
-0.0354577936,
-0.0554333031,
0.0586837791,
0.0113233393,
-0.0184448548,
0.0156693403,
0.0253270827,
0.0534470081,
0.0576498061,
0.0152928559,
0.0250549428,
0.0164604727,
0.0251004454,
-0.0106857782,
0.0128211575,
-0.0229955856,
0.014228018,
-0.000909681,
-0.0419253632,
-0.0131996982,
-0.0260898247,
-0.0700859949,
-0.015307568,
-0.0432295129,
-0.0112423021,
-0.0342992023,
-0.0204945933,
0.0062091681,
0.0261299014,
-0.0589599833,
0.0134659475,
-0.0330266431,
-0.0078567481,
0.0095791155,
-0.0386047065,
-0.0419387482,
0.0140567161,
2.65e-7,
-0.0158769898,
0.0104553318,
-0.0084714526,
0.0398911647,
-0.0000702677,
0.0380875207,
-0.0461714566,
-0.0131966341,
0.0152178491,
-0.0428334735,
0.0232384317,
0.0297395717,
0.0189110134,
-0.0042705727,
-0.0167908575,
0.0285549592,
-0.0380752049,
0.0086698765,
-0.0015063706,
0.0029674468,
0.0908244029,
0.0168598108,
-0.0297116619,
-0.0451867469,
0.0434273109,
-0.0360032842,
0.0735977814,
-0.0142718013,
0.0012555679,
-0.0232099742,
0.0424084626,
0.0029988037,
0.0169288125,
0.0328612663,
-0.0161128528,
-0.0520155616,
0.0504457913,
0.0089622103,
-0.0099254539,
-0.0032348207,
-0.0064253756,
0.0161358025,
0.0342479646,
-0.0730317906,
0.0437825136,
-0.058658056,
-0.0233192835,
-0.0269992463,
-0.0336872041,
-0.0033043267,
0.048525434,
-0.0532380864,
-0.0403987579,
0.0064256028,
0.0386826992,
0.0337369442,
-0.0146565977,
-0.0060040806,
-0.0161436796,
-0.0073461994,
-0.0101692369,
-0.0340767317,
-0.0646087006,
-0.0272155907,
0.0056864996,
0.0009204627,
-0.0368821807,
1.889172443e-34,
0.0264107734,
0.0167635716,
0.0401300229,
-0.0163138825,
0.0288959537,
0.0146258585,
-0.0144716548,
0.0034213671,
-0.0001828509,
-0.0206286926,
-0.0129043842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09384v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09384v2 | Zero-shot Query Reformulation for Conversational Search | 2023-07-18T16:05:25 | 2023-10-23T17:24:02 | Dayu Yang, Yue Zhang, Hui Fang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | As the popularity of voice assistants continues to surge, conversational
search has gained increased attention in Information Retrieval. However, data
sparsity issues in conversational search significantly hinder the progress of
supervised conversational search methods. Consequently, researchers are
focusing more on zero-shot conversational search approaches. Nevertheless,
existing zero-shot methods face three primary limitations: they are not
universally applicable to all retrievers, their effectiveness lacks sufficient
explainability, and they struggle to resolve common conversational ambiguities
caused by omission. To address these limitations, we introduce a novel
Zero-shot Query Reformulation (ZeQR) framework that reformulates queries based
on previous dialogue contexts without requiring supervision from conversational
search data. Specifically, our framework utilizes language models designed for
machine reading comprehension tasks to explicitly resolve two common
ambiguities: coreference and omission, in raw queries. In comparison to
existing zero-shot methods, our approach is universally applicable to any
retriever without additional adaptation or indexing. It also provides greater
explainability and effectively enhances query intent understanding because
ambiguities are explicitly and proactively resolved. Through extensive
experiments on four TREC conversational datasets, we demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method, which consistently outperforms state-of-the-art
baselines. | [
0.0528992452,
0.0344424509,
-0.0289905891,
0.0297221132,
-0.0305687562,
-0.0102207204,
0.022002615,
0.0028851337,
-0.0117425844,
-0.0270393938,
-0.0353299044,
-0.00884292,
-0.0222038459,
0.0224776622,
-0.0157572236,
-0.0387308449,
0.0331976153,
0.0081418566,
0.0149982627,
0.051131241,
0.0131348316,
0.0204599127,
-0.0088627543,
0.0379744805,
0.0261909477,
-0.0014823021,
-0.0523338504,
0.0689412281,
-0.0244264528,
-0.0030503266,
-0.0024782692,
0.0275691599,
0.0103325387,
0.0570570566,
0.0000014333,
-0.0204237271,
-0.0352040976,
-0.0233516749,
-0.0328199863,
-0.0248420015,
0.0337649062,
-0.0053709149,
0.0277862456,
0.0438609049,
-0.0238169413,
0.0059736078,
0.0316612795,
0.0375078395,
0.0306695588,
0.0903652012,
-0.0086499015,
-0.0062010922,
-0.023797581,
-0.0116399387,
0.046455957,
-0.0851024836,
-0.0186978262,
-0.0089102061,
0.0345679596,
0.0577660017,
0.0123566538,
0.0721401349,
-0.0170994345,
-0.0521972217,
0.0070191603,
0.01128734,
-0.0663219914,
-0.0357334241,
0.0045652697,
0.0973788276,
0.0261593312,
-0.0077962852,
0.0098433821,
0.0201760679,
-0.0176539253,
-0.0137299784,
-0.0662523806,
-0.01765012,
-0.0091101723,
-0.0109459832,
-0.0580242537,
0.0085423738,
0.0235658865,
0.0161827393,
-0.0177435298,
0.0487505235,
0.0046033645,
-0.0316502266,
0.0011187174,
-0.0183200706,
0.0029140445,
-0.0282267686,
0.0148060862,
0.0310063194,
-0.0667412058,
0.0418696851,
-0.0165826716,
-0.0082975132,
0.0205062907,
0.0009388317,
-0.0049122456,
0.0610753596,
-0.0165373795,
0.0770149007,
0.0023290666,
0.0285029542,
0.0060637076,
0.0063257194,
-0.0678113922,
-0.0740897804,
-0.0431025065,
-0.012820431,
-0.0649621412,
0.0220583528,
-0.0684011206,
-0.0575410649,
-0.0062661916,
0.0440960228,
0.0405195206,
-0.0237204116,
-0.0176127423,
0.0151503878,
-0.0711410269,
0.0118915802,
0.0042457846,
0.0455952995,
-0.0171798952,
0.0299627427,
-0.0010121946,
-0.0802526921,
-0.0411154591,
0.0351643227,
0.0337265432,
-0.0223145261,
-0.037230894,
0.0025916498,
-0.0235264637,
-0.0939629599,
0.0034534677,
-0.0282094814,
-0.0257197935,
-0.0276469607,
-0.0170437079,
0.0150688607,
0.0376770943,
-0.0181337055,
-0.0062385611,
-0.0072002197,
0.0021101439,
0.0614417605,
-0.0196579639,
0.0864589661,
-0.0009420115,
0.029797852,
0.0267064553,
0.0296780486,
-0.0015967961,
0.0914851651,
0.005840241,
0.0057200151,
0.0546049885,
0.0159667786,
0.0018323541,
-0.0178647134,
0.0378820822,
0.011643311,
-0.0049962611,
0.0660384297,
-0.0565250628,
0.0285636596,
0.0112161366,
0.0338959508,
-0.0372545682,
-0.0293582976,
0.0197354164,
0.0537595712,
0.0206139181,
-0.0418953411,
-0.0042868243,
0.0500268824,
-0.013374405,
-0.0015337882,
-0.0375818945,
0.0089951381,
-0.0272287372,
-0.0098905507,
0.0457910188,
-0.0439732857,
-0.0489442237,
-0.0217529815,
0.0259709097,
0.0373441726,
-0.0113391383,
0.0261368174,
0.0182101876,
0.0212094467,
-0.0585807115,
0.0112918569,
-0.0273400359,
-0.0602739155,
-0.0065802662,
-0.0274933428,
0.0165913962,
0.0511632599,
0.0834781304,
-0.0249806102,
-0.0374921151,
0.0075574894,
0.0244702157,
0.0301395226,
-0.0046524364,
-0.0119106872,
0.0790220425,
-0.0476414599,
-0.0259306114,
0.0270584449,
0.0146517744,
-0.0125061441,
0.0090531539,
-0.000784408,
0.0415805317,
-0.0556623191,
0.0347060487,
-0.0000468082,
-0.0080838958,
-0.0366561562,
0.0450670533,
0.0184675977,
0.0087141506,
0.0463554151,
0.0104075428,
0.0077036931,
0.0218917578,
0.0278860666,
-0.0050146803,
0.0170630906,
-0.0390784219,
-0.0536001101,
0.0054462953,
-0.0334642939,
0.0071471049,
-0.0004599253,
-0.0183816571,
-0.071957089,
-0.005712064,
-0.0283559207,
0.0531472154,
-0.0610316023,
0.0102188634,
0.0105501916,
-0.0121806609,
-0.0527650304,
-0.0049389494,
0.0283568166,
-0.0223655086,
0.03676733,
0.0092572849,
0.0133690629,
-0.0848806426,
-0.0297348704,
0.001361988,
0.0137708951,
-0.0086992923,
0.0076644747,
-0.0002834004,
-0.0590041019,
0.0089448132,
-0.1378551275,
0.0286574028,
-0.0291809663,
-0.035028182,
0.0107293995,
0.0539228544,
0.0055637336,
-0.0334709436,
-0.0164036043,
-0.0163252279,
0.0186754614,
0.022001639,
0.0154390577,
0.0427849554,
-0.0406498052,
-0.0546149388,
-0.0164204035,
0.0044229836,
0.0169180706,
0.0029774916,
-0.0074779494,
-0.0122847687,
0.0249039065,
-0.0202730596,
0.0202187151,
-0.0250030216,
-0.0069819153,
0.0003254666,
-0.0351847932,
-0.0429892726,
0.0450455584,
0.0072008735,
0.0185734686,
-0.0253168251,
-0.0254349355,
-0.0780376568,
0.0381609686,
-0.014375018,
-0.0326537415,
-0.0104316529,
-0.0328880697,
0.0338318162,
0.0071443762,
0.0064033577,
0.0330946185,
-0.065193072,
-0.015023334,
0.0044992846,
-0.0407862626,
-0.0438800603,
0.0191720072,
0.0051497398,
0.0556248464,
-0.0280658007,
-0.0268891882,
0.0725100264,
-0.0272544399,
-0.0327130854,
-0.0665358007,
-0.0114376927,
-0.0423622243,
0.0468789451,
-0.049367439,
0.0090531697,
0.0404938534,
-0.0722026899,
-0.0292889867,
-0.0239593685,
0.0172393769,
-0.0057675452,
0.0699704438,
-0.0200902037,
0.0275797565,
0.0357941352,
-0.0179148205,
-0.0214543995,
-0.0296970494,
-0.0192221459,
0.0074113072,
0.0128732705,
-0.0261741038,
-0.0686034784,
0.0071948678,
0.0172503963,
0.0253096949,
-0.0050271978,
-0.0261920858,
-0.0074058892,
0.0231449157,
0.0568324104,
-0.0142263453,
-0.0346068963,
0.000092507,
0.0431596786,
0.0184224304,
0.0596249178,
-0.0365417637,
0.037076965,
-0.0535507016,
0.0411788598,
-0.0179927927,
0.0083838282,
-0.0076379655,
0.0494625233,
-0.0073143942,
-0.034186136,
0.1141943038,
0.034752246,
-0.0393539146,
-0.0426137261,
-0.0240004398,
0.0417659618,
0.0069619045,
0.0369486772,
-0.0689341128,
-0.0645036548,
0.0168807656,
0.0706865489,
-0.009081129,
-0.0290995687,
-0.0240462814,
-0.0837298632,
0.0237652343,
-0.0191064719,
-0.0486712493,
-0.0267245192,
-0.0406216048,
0.0294134058,
-0.0480922274,
0.02932976,
0.0282751434,
-0.0167789683,
-0.0050529214,
-0.0173293315,
0.0203402676,
-0.0301321857,
0.0119564785,
0.0067238873,
0.0116267297,
0.0531116463,
0.0478129573,
0.0581502579,
0.0333751068,
0.0013346756,
-0.0387956016,
-0.0071893972,
-0.0266521424,
0.0696219429,
-0.0448783636,
-0.0055142092,
-0.0209037624,
0.0136557007,
-0.0022770506,
0.0192717928,
-0.0043023406,
-0.0105761336,
-0.0384263694,
0.0445238538,
-0.0517744906,
0.0243303739,
0.0266685952,
0.0932149217,
0.0349297784,
0.0220198855,
-0.031602677,
-0.0064783022,
0.0103762243,
-0.0630864426,
0.0036741137,
-0.0212932322,
0.0233730599,
0.0220730193,
-0.0219351873,
-0.0915929377,
0.0104180211,
0.0188485943,
-0.0041246368,
0.0097952131,
0.0136913145,
0.0078679146,
-0.0265767965,
-0.0063820574,
-0.0345738977,
0.0187550243,
-0.0461451299,
0.0156408884,
0.034308888,
-0.0204553045,
-0.0016827168,
0.0102026574,
-0.0575451441,
-0.0214923304,
-0.0288358759,
0.0118307052,
0.0254870784,
0.0335764214,
-0.0308976192,
-0.0391425975,
-0.0005778775,
0.0270755216,
-0.0315638296,
-0.0104677416,
0.0349410251,
0.0380847789,
-0.0041948017,
0.0746691376,
-0.0484843887,
-0.0074679544,
-0.040713042,
0.0657060891,
-0.0745296329,
-0.0556134284,
0.0068420162,
0.0120252715,
0.0416513346,
0.0376420692,
0.0436088666,
-0.0183661357,
0.0595851764,
-0.055573862,
-0.0102620469,
-0.0429080725,
-0.0026761908,
0.0069328016,
-0.0484936722,
-0.0043014348,
0.0199449658,
-0.0935140699,
0.0595412552,
-0.0353639573,
0.0196142774,
0.0135450363,
-0.0372321047,
0.0159263778,
-0.0308817234,
-0.0008489942,
0.0606780462,
0.020289164,
0.0514537878,
0.0111877834,
0.0584045202,
0.030050138,
-0.0425135009,
0.0001934373,
0.0418702066,
-0.0892699212,
-0.0372171178,
0.0239334162,
0.006463822,
-0.0122116422,
-0.02782836,
0.0351863839,
0.013063848,
0.0171897188,
-0.0206884202,
0.0335844122,
-0.0021512825,
-0.0175216757,
0.0365075655,
0.0319227017,
-0.0011296757,
0.0315236561,
0.0748907849,
-0.0125236176,
0.0369219258,
-0.0266750678,
-0.0268761273,
-0.0258923229,
-0.0150602954,
0.0606091432,
0.065191552,
-0.0322605707,
0.0031083915,
-0.0402681939,
-0.015822269,
0.0313354731,
-0.0745205134,
-0.0032533172,
-0.0076206834,
0.041081056,
0.0733669847,
0.0161146428,
-0.0281100497,
-0.0393922701,
-0.0181189794,
-0.0187995285,
-0.0251823235,
-0.0155656906,
-5.780621305e-33,
-0.0203763526,
-0.0225172397,
0.0092993258,
-0.0390104651,
-0.00385915,
0.0136010731,
-0.0405842587,
-0.0241868049,
-0.0491049886,
-0.0111269383,
-0.0268051922,
0.0764568374,
0.0280949958,
0.031022381,
-0.0336537063,
-0.0204835143,
0.0624606721,
0.0107450373,
-0.0149646737,
0.0146300755,
0.0433040671,
0.0638755634,
-0.0112143205,
-0.0734379888,
0.031712506,
-0.0150016788,
-0.0098364605,
0.0878257751,
0.0557360351,
0.0440399088,
0.0145432912,
0.0282640923,
0.0143891284,
-0.0112804631,
0.0125434361,
0.0177740064,
-0.086008735,
-0.0069007049,
0.0355778374,
0.0197097119,
-0.0258433428,
0.0031319254,
0.0094234925,
-0.0254120491,
0.0472904965,
-0.0086067785,
0.0020810156,
0.0089881374,
-0.0478028953,
0.0160120949,
-0.0192930344,
0.0319502689,
-0.0306339078,
-0.0588623993,
0.018845303,
0.0970286876,
0.0227425657,
0.0497246347,
-0.0406412967,
0.0311365593,
-0.0279670544,
0.0171097852,
0.0332375802,
0.0272855703,
-0.0071025565,
0.0334839858,
0.0319037214,
-0.0065196631,
-0.027705811,
-0.0573606901,
0.0129216798,
0.0230937805,
-0.0368042067,
0.0354653038,
-0.0121974042,
0.0152276894,
-0.0299436245,
0.0154389935,
-0.0048572384,
0.0377724916,
-0.0158854704,
0.0447805375,
-0.1031254381,
-0.0058450908,
-0.0262606684,
-0.0090443986,
-0.0748059228,
-0.0058338395,
0.0530763119,
0.0184751414,
-0.0263804644,
-0.0101998653,
0.0425873958,
-0.0196182188,
0.0212345105,
0.0410418101,
-0.0099052461,
-0.0234222803,
-0.0085210623,
0.0310473666,
-0.0367484353,
0.0055231205,
0.0521146804,
0.0338358097,
-0.0125092464,
0.0028727236,
0.0035624108,
0.0108783506,
-0.0384674333,
-0.0322027393,
0.0060245954,
0.0074786711,
-0.0894272774,
0.0185695216,
-0.0037466965,
0.0551369525,
-0.0236423202,
0.063952826,
0.0169174317,
0.0323991105,
-0.0290635303,
-0.0704292804,
0.0156164337,
-0.0195277035,
-0.0039211526,
-0.0017195622,
0.038180206,
-0.0077179228,
0.0076926737,
-0.0377077796,
-0.0059515224,
0.0123095615,
2.388e-7,
0.0078639369,
0.0366156362,
0.0095173456,
0.0650685057,
-0.0219607372,
0.0469965003,
0.0057103275,
0.0210569333,
0.0299310144,
-0.0040570358,
0.0459121838,
0.0081440834,
0.0393786319,
-0.0085643735,
-0.0794703513,
-0.0518995337,
-0.0285022501,
-0.0388015881,
-0.0363319814,
-0.0268945433,
0.0835533366,
0.0984175503,
0.0034591109,
0.0004739978,
-0.0162332803,
-0.0412872508,
0.0189432707,
0.0062166532,
-0.027348021,
-0.001798826,
0.0449041501,
0.0179793108,
0.0057631424,
-0.0039077154,
-0.0144466897,
0.0231506228,
0.0493770987,
0.0716488659,
-0.0013717614,
-0.0886866152,
-0.0315760598,
0.0048458623,
0.0136694694,
-0.0400003977,
0.0653879568,
-0.0125430124,
-0.0095957834,
0.0317859128,
-0.0447207838,
0.0189414509,
0.0294039119,
-0.0021202154,
-0.0297942944,
0.0132584181,
0.0102280295,
0.0127083566,
0.0079831593,
-0.0971442461,
0.0091331275,
-0.0466055162,
-0.0069723157,
0.0040577594,
-0.0406476483,
-0.0310588293,
-0.0077724718,
-0.0305383652,
0.0120195691,
1.785321649e-34,
0.0433894284,
0.0163217578,
-0.0015876287,
0.0304259937,
0.0173343867,
0.0020606818,
0.0067051784,
0.0026797606,
0.0471398756,
-0.0937256664,
-0.013273512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09312v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09312v4 | Multi-Modal Discussion Transformer: Integrating Text, Images and Graph Transformers to Detect Hate Speech on Social Media | 2023-07-18T14:57:12 | 2024-02-22T06:17:39 | Liam Hebert, Gaurav Sahu, Yuxuan Guo, Nanda Kishore Sreenivas, Lukasz Golab, Robin Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM, cs.SI | We present the Multi-Modal Discussion Transformer (mDT), a novel methodfor
detecting hate speech in online social networks such as Reddit discussions. In
contrast to traditional comment-only methods, our approach to labelling a
comment as hate speech involves a holistic analysis of text and images grounded
in the discussion context. This is done by leveraging graph transformers to
capture the contextual relationships in the discussion surrounding a comment
and grounding the interwoven fusion layers that combine text and image
embeddings instead of processing modalities separately. To evaluate our work,
we present a new dataset, HatefulDiscussions, comprising complete multi-modal
discussions from multiple online communities on Reddit. We compare the
performance of our model to baselines that only process individual comments and
conduct extensive ablation studies. | [
0.0585915484,
0.0816627815,
0.017437797,
0.040075589,
0.0072782324,
0.0324904993,
0.0287464969,
0.0339901783,
-0.0208015479,
-0.0843069851,
-0.0248630904,
-0.0114236753,
-0.0085528083,
0.022588592,
-0.0147693902,
-0.0353107452,
-0.0136687765,
0.0389324985,
0.0055416655,
0.0035798857,
0.0780604929,
0.0133845257,
0.0112493895,
0.0577493235,
-0.0824476033,
0.0087707015,
0.0582476705,
0.013004275,
0.028400952,
-0.0109084034,
0.0168454945,
0.043006029,
0.0248556603,
0.0820550993,
0.0000015803,
0.0116284052,
0.0161225349,
0.0091554523,
0.0201832112,
-0.0491175279,
0.108965084,
-0.0654755831,
0.0255620349,
0.0329147242,
-0.0328426361,
0.0085752513,
0.0756157041,
0.096774146,
0.0878779888,
0.053598918,
-0.0295141675,
-0.0546261296,
0.0002382051,
0.0149686821,
-0.0181197003,
0.0218343772,
0.0218140446,
-0.0004071969,
-0.0374159291,
0.0109023713,
-0.0366286077,
0.0135623505,
0.0018366108,
-0.0146502098,
0.0507149696,
-0.0054187924,
-0.0012410581,
-0.0220580027,
-0.0013514785,
0.074279964,
-0.0314333662,
0.007210352,
-0.0088046649,
0.0077742096,
-0.0201717094,
0.0074255802,
-0.0543237813,
-0.001676651,
-0.0178508367,
0.0419418588,
-0.0529300384,
0.0078163445,
0.0522170886,
0.023582926,
0.0324274637,
-0.0006056157,
-0.0138884522,
-0.0209292434,
-0.0142337335,
0.0187693126,
-0.0230623037,
0.0190116968,
0.0187067222,
-0.0004147817,
-0.0034882161,
0.0051290058,
-0.0423805006,
-0.0494398922,
-0.009738015,
-0.0563750789,
0.0347741134,
-0.0250302684,
-0.0295062084,
0.0244399942,
0.009031523,
0.0123547446,
-0.0292208698,
0.0109113082,
-0.0208671913,
-0.0306970309,
-0.0365901142,
0.0051388391,
-0.0135901524,
-0.0240242388,
-0.0291075241,
-0.0291879363,
-0.021620376,
0.008138191,
-0.0477169454,
-0.0428081043,
0.0139650013,
0.0351910852,
0.0025060955,
0.0018377447,
0.0019810752,
0.0548207983,
0.007702528,
0.025082821,
-0.0268074051,
-0.0225295499,
0.0008827385,
0.0471523069,
0.0109872203,
-0.0072491062,
0.0051582796,
0.0714599267,
0.0165376347,
-0.0140078235,
0.0016170494,
-0.0378030799,
-0.0416398868,
-0.0199358482,
0.0586300306,
-0.0612583384,
0.0255321953,
-0.0098797549,
-0.0287695415,
-0.0207391661,
0.0125900088,
0.0173420403,
-0.0574455895,
0.0938014612,
-0.0008287181,
-0.0388573632,
0.0396113247,
0.0385855399,
-0.0083038053,
0.0568940341,
0.014915199,
0.0184591282,
0.0450018644,
-0.0023658439,
0.0054059313,
0.0383098461,
0.0286453776,
-0.0000645954,
-0.0299919955,
0.0066308803,
-0.0879783109,
-0.0315503366,
-0.0159349162,
0.0423410721,
-0.0430604555,
-0.0656309575,
0.0268307514,
0.0737271309,
-0.0587221198,
0.0237306729,
0.0191501379,
0.0321390852,
-0.0403556786,
-0.0357940607,
-0.0557982065,
0.0196634457,
-0.003990069,
-0.0552000888,
0.0135222543,
0.0509315133,
-0.0131351715,
-0.008302222,
-0.0105679464,
-0.0265230425,
0.0713598952,
-0.0401366502,
0.0177795179,
0.0198374297,
-0.0207455959,
0.0530904904,
0.0386607684,
-0.012947456,
-0.0357335135,
-0.0242119711,
-0.0103740133,
0.0228965487,
0.0013286447,
-0.0053307228,
-0.0123034231,
-0.05968187,
0.0222701486,
0.0460676961,
-0.0156224547,
0.0079924585,
-0.0029941669,
-0.0502506159,
-0.0414569341,
-0.0031944886,
0.004107405,
0.0002835786,
0.0356854275,
-0.0084425509,
0.016936617,
0.0318530872,
0.0115610063,
-0.0058522373,
0.0805869028,
0.0245837737,
-0.0119035905,
0.0105812559,
0.0338418148,
0.0291159954,
-0.0270505156,
-0.0331014916,
0.0257624444,
-0.0026626301,
-0.066671446,
0.0336696617,
-0.0413769856,
-0.025197234,
0.0327403322,
-0.1009581238,
-0.0351640433,
0.0493887439,
-0.0238196962,
0.0199861173,
0.0828875229,
-0.044744458,
0.0235316046,
0.0122294091,
-0.0591517463,
-0.0283839293,
0.0464881547,
-0.0012613063,
0.0422129221,
-0.0259175207,
-0.0244179461,
0.0267779306,
-0.043693684,
0.0311296619,
0.0435039289,
-0.0434247293,
-0.0097693512,
-0.0101777753,
0.0454670899,
0.0233098026,
0.0006020835,
-0.0382868685,
0.0067713549,
-0.1396291107,
-0.017933188,
-0.0251390692,
-0.0181642435,
0.0214485563,
0.0032472375,
0.0271208622,
-0.0280241221,
-0.0333261974,
0.0001480647,
0.0574409701,
0.0291151907,
0.0161172505,
-0.0488626882,
0.0162851624,
-0.027027851,
-0.0430720672,
0.0170334354,
0.0757539868,
0.0303053409,
-0.0423115492,
0.0317696631,
-0.0350054391,
-0.0518743992,
0.0324078985,
-0.0196400918,
-0.0340629928,
0.0371584147,
0.0250374805,
0.0082051139,
0.0320201367,
0.0451333411,
0.0989159048,
-0.0125812106,
-0.0034621975,
-0.0010091488,
-0.0083564613,
-0.0288000982,
0.0318814553,
-0.031292662,
-0.0171804689,
-0.0152560398,
0.050861109,
0.0167050231,
0.0089372629,
-0.0387082398,
0.0126362797,
-0.0405680463,
-0.0153012238,
-0.0122389011,
-0.0560900979,
0.0083591258,
-0.0346335545,
-0.0468629301,
-0.0496460982,
0.0538570993,
0.0021732736,
0.0077891462,
0.0339854509,
-0.0353670269,
-0.0176310129,
0.0409473814,
0.0304129068,
0.0336072221,
-0.0512512363,
0.0071675191,
0.0212758724,
-0.0276688337,
0.0392279252,
-0.020824641,
0.0168134477,
0.0033556146,
0.0062870835,
-0.0056008543,
-0.0468707122,
-0.0350145698,
-0.0560171194,
-0.0451908819,
-0.0375506058,
0.0061861021,
-0.031349849,
-0.045176018,
0.0034690083,
0.0163112488,
-0.0219547041,
0.013373754,
-0.0027795106,
0.0317921788,
0.0359422117,
0.0156264063,
0.0065170592,
0.0110660614,
-0.0062355408,
-0.0169321634,
0.0969265923,
-0.0086036744,
-0.0125529468,
-0.0278603639,
-0.0110988067,
-0.0092892284,
0.0751172006,
0.0160678141,
-0.0568830185,
0.049817007,
-0.0057157655,
0.005977497,
0.0796249285,
-0.0054582707,
-0.0343261659,
-0.0169733241,
0.0181001462,
-0.0033649891,
0.0082006911,
-0.0295417383,
-0.11108803,
-0.0346919559,
-0.0623398051,
0.0037506979,
-0.0178969689,
-0.02202872,
0.0079635791,
-0.0334570259,
0.0105427587,
-0.0092360219,
0.0114389928,
-0.0220051669,
0.0021590532,
0.0222753733,
-0.017056508,
0.036082048,
-0.0668254197,
0.0217620693,
-0.0213219412,
0.0035778261,
-0.015079299,
-0.0024153595,
0.0064749923,
-0.0156881176,
0.023857059,
-0.0120238727,
0.0512072779,
-0.0139503879,
-0.0282309707,
0.0487134345,
0.0427363142,
-0.0305066369,
-0.0356982574,
0.0815371498,
-0.0113777006,
-0.0252807438,
-0.0278585088,
0.0021671536,
-0.0040002102,
-0.0377409607,
-0.037957076,
0.0476533994,
0.0166763589,
-0.0194595307,
-0.0599234551,
0.043568112,
-0.0061823656,
0.0322079659,
0.0345449448,
-0.0425971821,
-0.0144424727,
-0.0591149777,
0.0037535648,
-0.0392166674,
-0.0679093897,
0.0028967343,
-0.0169270355,
-0.0085437214,
-0.0306863412,
-0.0170286614,
-0.0077501391,
-0.0046684942,
-0.0108204037,
-0.0384252816,
0.0295391344,
-0.0251468588,
-0.0644790605,
0.038925074,
-0.0147978375,
0.0376064889,
-0.0096639907,
0.0062795817,
0.0011963045,
0.0005016473,
-0.0342782699,
0.0198207255,
-0.0874952897,
-0.0350684635,
-0.0110473195,
0.0293368753,
0.0131643247,
0.0267108083,
-0.0115381815,
-0.0298254862,
0.0540652424,
0.0480219014,
0.0114833824,
-0.031719204,
0.0303010624,
-0.0312647969,
0.0124985762,
0.0161856059,
-0.0171854347,
0.0586579554,
0.0038685685,
-0.0556210577,
-0.0746114627,
-0.0209857561,
-0.0404004045,
-0.0255863555,
0.0714151636,
0.0409145765,
0.000535319,
-0.0424927287,
-0.0491456315,
-0.0213013571,
-0.0281311255,
-0.0390570574,
0.0095278108,
-0.003925994,
-0.0187554862,
-0.0384026021,
-0.0025582726,
-0.0121496338,
0.0343935229,
-0.0358077139,
0.0217288472,
0.0794461444,
-0.0240290537,
0.0352608599,
0.0215162877,
-0.0103126485,
0.0211935863,
0.031770125,
-0.0407970548,
-0.0059361421,
0.0476719514,
0.0160029698,
-0.0274496265,
0.0270195603,
0.0091187861,
-0.023893021,
0.0011806192,
-0.0361643024,
-0.0234609209,
-0.0073723486,
-0.0026289581,
0.0417425856,
0.0234642401,
-0.0230280589,
0.0155013492,
0.0298104808,
-0.0399248339,
-0.0422013253,
0.0325635672,
0.0200894866,
-0.0154279219,
0.0330692865,
0.0384171456,
-0.0179990772,
0.0175255388,
0.0324967653,
-0.0756116807,
-0.036032442,
0.0078073475,
0.0281149819,
0.0220649932,
0.0415804051,
0.0399567187,
-0.0221996009,
-0.0588080771,
0.0157657675,
-0.0501918234,
0.0248474237,
0.0423292778,
0.0146699594,
0.0421309993,
0.0265932772,
0.0195008852,
0.0060462803,
0.0109251477,
0.0041337069,
-0.055121664,
0.0039832788,
-5.798794448e-33,
0.0023508994,
-0.0665760338,
-0.019656444,
0.0062340791,
-0.0391772278,
0.0226200745,
0.0232155658,
0.0148873953,
-0.0021823386,
0.0370607302,
0.0315391608,
0.0296985097,
-0.0113799758,
0.0528335571,
-0.0219751168,
-0.0169987939,
0.0238185581,
-0.011544615,
0.0051630586,
0.0223411061,
0.0346483737,
-0.0114048868,
0.034277685,
-0.0630233362,
0.0120165106,
-0.0038921349,
-0.0207930915,
0.0296025537,
0.045097027,
0.0759083256,
-0.0247392673,
0.0916661397,
0.0420296639,
0.0046210201,
-0.0256238934,
0.0643289238,
-0.0470315441,
-0.0008445049,
0.0135550657,
0.0080885515,
-0.0259927306,
0.0190034974,
0.0588418357,
-0.0105925919,
0.001912459,
-0.0645826161,
0.045795422,
0.0120243672,
0.02365743,
-0.0150796119,
-0.064813368,
0.0297162645,
-0.0441771299,
-0.0146845644,
0.0131166093,
0.0243417025,
0.0607038513,
0.0203163009,
-0.0513261035,
0.0286182296,
-0.0596145391,
-0.0359161422,
0.0020931996,
0.023895666,
0.0094526224,
0.0601746142,
-0.0326544307,
0.0115153808,
-0.0445938073,
-0.0153793814,
-0.0065653222,
0.0815349147,
0.0516450778,
0.074176982,
0.0064450884,
-0.0621532984,
-0.0650910065,
-0.0362334177,
0.0162415635,
0.0012360472,
0.0109113809,
0.005000487,
-0.0005950834,
-0.004901838,
-0.0023804652,
-0.0539253652,
-0.0372125767,
-0.0185025185,
-0.0149848303,
0.0141034452,
-0.0149766663,
0.0467233136,
0.0327624902,
-0.057865005,
-0.0093237935,
0.0893072188,
-0.0326992348,
0.0195641536,
0.0237210635,
0.0172955971,
-0.021305196,
0.014681072,
0.0373854078,
-0.024795305,
0.0244364701,
-0.012560932,
0.0903171375,
0.021742411,
-0.0636033416,
0.0018237492,
-0.0497844853,
0.0266419239,
-0.0413071178,
0.0506349392,
0.0095591331,
0.0628795773,
-0.0472893678,
-0.0042655459,
0.0023228296,
0.0380302183,
-0.0204691775,
-0.0009047552,
-0.0259327423,
-0.0010676397,
-0.0177972037,
-0.0042849784,
-0.0167650878,
-0.0138106672,
0.0313591324,
-0.1031540185,
0.0085888328,
-0.0302442256,
2.315e-7,
0.0235939529,
0.0442791432,
0.0290222988,
-0.0409350097,
0.0386185981,
0.0535193421,
0.0287259147,
0.0359126963,
-0.0008387405,
-0.0103259012,
-0.0224000867,
0.0717696622,
-0.0060744551,
0.0616079085,
0.0138827795,
-0.040650893,
-0.0968872309,
-0.026282521,
-0.0190264694,
0.0101574324,
0.0313048176,
0.0906488895,
0.0403780341,
-0.0488907844,
-0.0276339762,
-0.0205098409,
0.0640067905,
-0.0353749171,
-0.0167935882,
-0.0512296632,
0.0223068651,
-0.0026579443,
0.0179619249,
-0.0240880847,
-0.0148169128,
-0.0021673078,
0.0511677302,
0.0313175954,
0.0141177308,
-0.0364972204,
0.0126316436,
0.0162067879,
-0.0028485958,
0.00018855,
0.016009694,
-0.0361593626,
-0.0218789373,
-0.1076589003,
-0.0324168466,
-0.0079088835,
0.0607052408,
-0.01674412,
-0.0169280469,
0.0112951472,
0.0404390767,
-0.0225685369,
-0.0027681256,
-0.0891209468,
0.0071650199,
0.0048665637,
-0.0689063966,
-0.0209484175,
-0.0095994379,
-0.0489456132,
0.0640290156,
0.0549197346,
0.0284273475,
1.528110973e-34,
0.0185411386,
-0.0238375496,
0.0036179498,
-0.0501056276,
0.0368490033,
-0.0007817008,
-0.039390374,
-0.0177016165,
0.0332444534,
-0.048889935,
0.0083699003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10292v1 | The Language Labyrinth: Constructive Critique on the Terminology Used in the AI Discourse | 2023-07-18T14:32:21 | 2023-07-18T14:32:21 | Rainer Rehak | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE, K.4.0; K.4.1; K.4.2; I.2.0; I.2.1; K.4.3 | In the interdisciplinary field of artificial intelligence (AI) the problem of
clear terminology is especially momentous. This paper claims, that AI debates
are still characterised by a lack of critical distance to metaphors like
'training', 'learning' or 'deciding'. As consequence, reflections regarding
responsibility or potential use-cases are greatly distorted. Yet, if relevant
decision-makers are convinced that AI can develop an 'understanding' or
properly 'interpret' issues, its regular use for sensitive tasks like deciding
about social benefits or judging court cases looms. The chapter argues its
claim by analysing central notions of the AI debate and tries to contribute by
proposing more fitting terminology and hereby enabling more fruitful debates.
It is a conceptual work at the intersection of critical computer science and
philosophy of language. | [
0.0480067022,
0.0048574158,
-0.0444420017,
-0.0018997948,
-0.0647059381,
0.0225958694,
0.0023522268,
0.0024946732,
0.0037005516,
-0.0456688255,
0.02483912,
0.0313703306,
-0.0212963466,
-0.0183887575,
0.0270401314,
-0.042742569,
0.0157933645,
-0.0251708832,
0.0361919738,
-0.0013520096,
-0.0027757103,
0.0024326325,
-0.0200908668,
0.0455045253,
-0.049714569,
-0.0013235799,
-0.0102643138,
-0.0476752892,
-0.0204654243,
-0.0115021262,
-0.0126093328,
-0.0131338052,
0.0484770238,
0.033161778,
0.0000018838,
-0.0422358811,
0.047582265,
0.0054959082,
-0.0520311072,
-0.0536594838,
0.0139401155,
0.0115687875,
0.0291105509,
-0.015669018,
-0.0658184662,
0.0592261739,
0.0397454686,
0.0044812295,
-0.029026486,
0.0217887387,
-0.001998096,
-0.0265899003,
0.0463893451,
0.0006721193,
-0.0283966698,
-0.0541476831,
0.0273634475,
0.0034342371,
0.0162457321,
-0.0263763927,
-0.023229802,
0.0348549262,
0.0512237921,
-0.0086117005,
-0.0212406386,
-0.001948734,
0.0025252495,
-0.0279248133,
0.003212943,
-0.0104783624,
0.0646765605,
-0.002839824,
-0.0095747244,
0.0159387272,
0.0261506159,
-0.0017956523,
-0.0030095715,
0.063630037,
-0.0245732088,
-0.0146542648,
0.0609007403,
-0.0174789708,
0.0093044806,
0.034358453,
-0.0439543538,
0.0499774888,
-0.057123404,
-0.0274754185,
0.0467305146,
-0.0002683595,
0.0451037772,
-0.0316473618,
0.0113899279,
0.0669808164,
-0.0028346963,
0.0275536887,
-0.0086781643,
0.0194972623,
0.0032137083,
-0.074435018,
0.0396634787,
-0.0149408346,
0.0300817639,
0.0047758729,
0.0378888063,
0.0146442316,
-0.0233561285,
0.0747894794,
-0.0367471129,
0.0064514577,
-0.072525017,
-0.0402272195,
-0.0674159303,
0.0316253789,
-0.0111217089,
0.0122900093,
0.0471567437,
0.0285185277,
-0.0686814487,
0.0184108596,
-0.0560243912,
-0.0055727586,
-0.0305271354,
0.0141740832,
-0.062607035,
-0.0592292361,
-0.0355354249,
0.0348940901,
-0.0257406011,
-0.0534769632,
0.0148229832,
0.0225692615,
-0.0510656722,
0.0092435088,
0.0132243838,
0.0994514674,
0.018200241,
-0.0247004312,
0.0143743763,
-0.0430515073,
-0.0110585392,
-0.0406696312,
0.0174429342,
-0.0067190169,
-0.0167248882,
-0.0039971699,
-0.0169449281,
-0.0789562166,
-0.0193160027,
0.0094128735,
-0.0287959892,
0.077434741,
-0.0433380343,
0.00896856,
0.0410537161,
0.0205512065,
-0.0030468628,
0.0051663457,
0.0222315211,
0.0158374403,
0.0269428585,
0.0012569586,
0.1006004512,
-0.0183813721,
-0.0281075332,
-0.0092572663,
-0.0083988402,
0.0115050245,
-0.0675484911,
0.0168439168,
-0.0219133776,
0.0432330668,
-0.0053891605,
0.0197845176,
0.0105165299,
0.0976327658,
0.0006566166,
0.0544395708,
0.0526897386,
-0.0517495908,
0.006846311,
0.0512542091,
-0.0151216611,
-0.013676404,
-0.0006624236,
-0.0140143745,
-0.0713483095,
-0.0361950248,
-0.0006259381,
-0.0725651234,
0.041757144,
-0.007705423,
0.0429289043,
0.0227263458,
0.0241564978,
-0.0054035974,
0.0147598702,
-0.0712640435,
-0.001201194,
0.0326615162,
-0.0195997898,
-0.1130739674,
0.0204349421,
0.0265510809,
-0.0067579495,
-0.0370994993,
-0.0168933496,
0.0075226356,
-0.0134887407,
0.0408221409,
0.041906286,
-0.0196925774,
-0.0446307026,
-0.0079241032,
-0.0101723736,
-0.0392209701,
0.0001651479,
0.0047752531,
-0.0891624168,
0.0012592182,
-0.0026405815,
0.0408188775,
-0.08420223,
0.0330049135,
-0.0069822115,
-0.0157760642,
-0.0475484431,
0.0157366581,
0.01610112,
0.0034377815,
-0.0335440151,
0.031212803,
0.0510813743,
-0.0165058356,
-0.004344292,
-0.0090578375,
0.028224932,
0.0927601382,
0.0022599187,
-0.09541177,
0.0037634384,
0.0000691,
0.0233181752,
0.0000014171,
0.0366319828,
-0.0548554733,
0.0156349074,
0.0119116073,
0.023345666,
-0.055933591,
-0.0234350376,
-0.0471154824,
0.0282258205,
-0.0012094378,
-0.0216709357,
-0.0400158912,
0.0266181063,
0.0290902667,
0.0018156918,
-0.0262706038,
0.0826176926,
0.0269807838,
0.0177156832,
0.066207841,
-0.01005504,
-0.0069127134,
0.0115676057,
-0.0701717809,
-0.0258186925,
0.0178482775,
-0.0039250348,
-0.0402194187,
-0.0537041649,
-0.0000139168,
-0.026105497,
0.0380454846,
-0.0304747727,
-0.0295907501,
-0.0038771657,
0.0232211947,
0.0166477021,
-0.0072087822,
0.0153263947,
0.0088097798,
-0.0310859736,
-0.0085687563,
0.0296259262,
-0.0176299736,
-0.000894594,
0.0055058971,
-0.0338911898,
-0.0261493679,
-0.0137490788,
0.0057295351,
0.0463430472,
0.0435194448,
-0.0490376689,
0.0358203128,
0.019302208,
0.0752623081,
0.0278379768,
0.0357163772,
0.0123789907,
0.0017061026,
0.0094877761,
-0.001597063,
-0.0266031846,
-0.0033912447,
0.0089398213,
0.0164786465,
0.0233240426,
0.0280476827,
-0.0186852925,
0.102187857,
-0.0527611747,
-0.0400027595,
-0.0334762782,
-0.0753472671,
-0.033323165,
0.0534061529,
-0.0207015648,
-0.0462325029,
0.076464422,
0.0279574823,
0.0316388234,
-0.0445084795,
-0.0663296282,
0.0130317044,
0.0934263468,
-0.0368239656,
0.025711095,
-0.0066319802,
-0.0139488708,
-0.0350722522,
-0.0323232152,
0.0244064555,
-0.0371327363,
0.0475533605,
-0.0393583328,
0.0290819108,
0.0166517477,
-0.0414852425,
-0.0170079321,
0.032399442,
-0.0586604513,
0.0297080241,
0.0496704802,
0.0022262728,
-0.0306948349,
-0.0333860628,
0.0512177125,
0.0254539233,
0.0452077724,
-0.0204393696,
-0.0276124105,
-0.0762846544,
-0.0168909002,
0.0380939655,
0.0380767174,
0.0303315558,
0.0306757931,
0.0010131837,
-0.002998553,
0.0057778452,
-0.0035221202,
-0.0004956947,
0.0036097497,
-0.0356188826,
-0.0100753643,
-0.0043687625,
0.0014135889,
-0.0505768582,
-0.047754351,
0.0439108051,
0.010041561,
-0.0459791161,
0.0323054977,
-0.0514516532,
-0.0804447457,
0.0261862595,
0.0210874658,
-0.0556377992,
0.0272324085,
-0.0022561785,
0.0263942573,
-0.0844921917,
-0.0137589192,
-0.0017526645,
-0.009765462,
0.0582128651,
-0.0094649196,
-0.024348475,
-0.0458210967,
0.0052498677,
-0.0269411821,
0.0230673477,
0.042656742,
0.0072134994,
0.0023240291,
0.0244522449,
0.0632631406,
0.0043788464,
0.0255350936,
-0.0308572985,
-0.0076756454,
0.0570176877,
0.046500694,
0.0545624681,
-0.0511282608,
0.001491963,
-0.0109613873,
-0.008461169,
0.0205877423,
-0.0001197325,
0.0122754006,
0.005856086,
-0.0056642126,
-0.0539720543,
-0.0294022001,
-0.0006056353,
-0.0110216504,
0.0806402266,
0.0587139577,
-0.0796585605,
-0.0321950503,
-0.0211616829,
-0.0419218838,
-0.019658789,
0.0352349244,
0.026612822,
-0.0041190265,
-0.0181318503,
-0.0341463089,
0.0224543978,
0.0179972686,
-0.050057143,
0.0174769759,
-0.0212842636,
-0.0341152102,
-0.0154918851,
-0.0747870281,
0.0021914602,
0.0703896284,
0.0591481626,
-0.0426960699,
0.0220145509,
0.0216173902,
-0.0652718171,
0.0245122481,
0.0070512984,
-0.0121810241,
0.0004330379,
-0.0280761812,
-0.0165258385,
-0.0101013714,
0.0007592955,
0.0082334802,
0.0984232053,
-0.0158618893,
0.0218352675,
0.0636412799,
0.0335829072,
-0.009087096,
0.0125610493,
-0.03985117,
0.0320418328,
0.0011925786,
-0.014974514,
0.0336775184,
0.034163598,
-0.0266618598,
-0.0035157944,
0.0288001131,
0.0177837983,
0.0102286404,
-0.0320015065,
-0.0207741875,
-0.0599063858,
0.0362720788,
0.047008872,
0.0194399133,
-0.0113371452,
-0.0275565665,
-0.0027955256,
0.0025567131,
-0.0422607735,
0.0281847399,
-0.045876991,
0.0041039004,
-0.0318665542,
-0.0075257733,
0.0243617315,
0.0186639484,
0.0027974197,
-0.0350059941,
-0.0154397078,
0.0267166123,
0.0133397644,
0.0663292855,
0.0822335109,
-0.0260919221,
0.0298054367,
0.0380993113,
0.0566864274,
-0.0222866237,
0.031857539,
-0.0002964964,
0.0412550494,
0.0454798453,
0.0173347183,
0.0179616101,
0.0294446722,
-0.0562811047,
-0.1186861023,
0.0517650321,
0.0324601084,
0.015899837,
-0.002629736,
-0.0543348752,
0.0099780411,
0.0130725261,
0.0434068963,
-0.012278066,
0.0150377303,
-0.0315305851,
-0.0169612821,
0.00921755,
-0.0238947887,
-0.0169409029,
0.0426565744,
-0.0793779418,
0.0709017739,
-0.02491468,
-0.0167999621,
0.0152029917,
-0.0727564245,
0.0033505661,
0.0074463999,
0.036750976,
0.0024421143,
-0.0736132562,
-0.0450709909,
-0.0486328043,
0.0151111735,
0.0453514345,
-0.0337648615,
0.0193740763,
0.0579115935,
0.0412750207,
-0.0351840258,
-0.048587542,
0.0512845591,
-0.0268223044,
0.0326867625,
-0.0189372841,
-5.486932858e-33,
-0.0321395658,
-0.0715384185,
0.0340544805,
0.0169205554,
-0.0562408268,
-0.0032200271,
0.0000906134,
0.0171703827,
-0.0531010032,
0.0559564978,
-0.012131229,
0.016024394,
-0.0241267905,
-0.0238455068,
0.0374252796,
-0.0121502113,
-0.0139196077,
-0.0074324668,
0.0069198492,
0.0057459963,
0.0073837684,
-0.0236551631,
0.0093520433,
-0.0647539273,
0.0652267411,
0.0240881965,
0.0095267752,
0.012415058,
-0.0013211078,
0.0090388283,
0.0171858091,
0.0700379238,
0.030936325,
-0.0105689606,
0.0178463887,
0.0387472473,
0.015344061,
-0.0207678154,
0.0438414253,
0.0124371639,
-0.0171500575,
-0.0666760132,
0.0422131941,
-0.0123746609,
-0.0610749982,
0.0709143057,
0.0258285273,
-0.0233386401,
0.0037034997,
-0.0449347682,
-0.0780963674,
-0.0081653995,
-0.0746260434,
-0.0416114107,
0.0241476148,
-0.01648576,
-0.0044370811,
-0.0136670331,
-0.0429057926,
0.0167451333,
-0.0417851619,
-0.0400316045,
0.0418478325,
0.0144920433,
0.011254278,
0.0270483252,
0.0282054637,
0.038409777,
-0.0278831143,
-0.0271518528,
0.0105745671,
0.04839091,
-0.0061264755,
-0.0419989489,
-0.0056935563,
-0.052636113,
-0.017316198,
-0.0311739091,
0.0160295498,
0.0386955366,
-0.0207491703,
-0.0257068761,
-0.066763632,
-0.0080288555,
-0.0396265052,
-0.0885032639,
-0.0244097151,
-0.0035098582,
-0.0080820909,
-0.0285474826,
0.0085514728,
0.0214781705,
-0.0518807098,
-0.0776967406,
0.0827122554,
-0.0272965077,
0.0066528232,
-0.0141936988,
0.0106410962,
0.0134975677,
0.0168848671,
-0.0478188582,
-0.0391852781,
0.047147084,
0.0386957973,
0.0168374572,
-0.0131346714,
0.0025705623,
0.0408160649,
-0.014681519,
-0.0271083843,
0.0123727191,
0.0373133011,
-0.0032824583,
0.0174318496,
0.0502373986,
0.0093326299,
-0.0150759779,
0.0279104505,
0.022444848,
-0.0337349027,
0.0072774692,
-0.077199474,
0.0059964871,
-0.0186470672,
-0.0293196402,
-0.0579857156,
0.0716184601,
0.0312239844,
-0.0437368378,
0.0008055699,
0.014313153,
2.723e-7,
-0.0007001028,
0.0685386956,
-0.0045944876,
-0.0348838419,
-0.0031840899,
0.02735129,
0.0011489796,
0.0187578648,
-0.0224469192,
0.0085906126,
0.0126597658,
0.0296465978,
-0.0309169982,
-0.0011630376,
-0.0033160266,
-0.0545722991,
-0.0232551154,
0.0049388525,
-0.0693456233,
0.0777471364,
0.0381709747,
0.0207294039,
0.031084545,
-0.0212314986,
-0.0640881509,
-0.0388065577,
-0.0268288702,
0.0033826986,
0.0691446289,
0.0306348056,
0.0435271487,
0.0684065297,
0.015863616,
0.0423315987,
0.043064855,
0.0199223943,
-0.009449061,
0.0396164283,
0.0083101029,
0.0148192737,
-0.0405776463,
-0.0284726061,
0.0248173624,
-0.0122838151,
0.028790636,
-0.0444258787,
-0.0570836924,
-0.0390267856,
0.0058041206,
-0.0018062112,
0.014568557,
-0.0000418167,
0.0003307212,
0.023664603,
0.0031536177,
-0.0384701379,
0.0422973447,
-0.0502482243,
0.0505536124,
0.0350175947,
-0.0078665251,
-0.0003093028,
0.0164388362,
0.0205925349,
0.0355126858,
-0.0257245377,
0.0423061773,
1.640277815e-34,
-0.0174283795,
-0.0268142372,
0.0194419939,
0.0272452086,
0.0362840034,
0.0577945411,
0.0154575789,
0.0122413784,
0.0275300052,
0.0113712624,
0.0005958154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09288v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09288v2 | Llama 2: Open Foundation and Fine-Tuned Chat Models | 2023-07-18T14:31:57 | 2023-07-19T17:08:59 | Hugo Touvron, Louis Martin, Kevin Stone, Peter Albert, Amjad Almahairi, Yasmine Babaei, Nikolay Bashlykov, Soumya Batra, Prajjwal Bhargava, Shruti Bhosale, Dan Bikel, Lukas Blecher, Cristian Canton Ferrer, Moya Chen, Guillem Cucurull, David Esiobu, Jude Fernandes, Jeremy Fu, Wenyin Fu, Brian Fuller, Cynthia Gao, Vedanuj Goswami, Naman Goyal, Anthony Hartshorn, Saghar Hosseini, Rui Hou, Hakan Inan, Marcin Kardas, Viktor Kerkez, Madian Khabsa, Isabel Kloumann, Artem Korenev, Punit Singh Koura, Marie-Anne Lachaux, Thibaut Lavril, Jenya Lee, Diana Liskovich, Yinghai Lu, Yuning Mao, Xavier Martinet, Todor Mihaylov, Pushkar Mishra, Igor Molybog, Yixin Nie, Andrew Poulton, Jeremy Reizenstein, Rashi Rungta, Kalyan Saladi, Alan Schelten, Ruan Silva, Eric Michael Smith, Ranjan Subramanian, Xiaoqing Ellen Tan, Binh Tang, Ross Taylor, Adina Williams, Jian Xiang Kuan, Puxin Xu, Zheng Yan, Iliyan Zarov, Yuchen Zhang, Angela Fan, Melanie Kambadur, Sharan Narang, Aurelien Rodriguez, Robert Stojnic, Sergey Edunov, Thomas Scialom | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we develop and release Llama 2, a collection of pretrained and
fine-tuned large language models (LLMs) ranging in scale from 7 billion to 70
billion parameters. Our fine-tuned LLMs, called Llama 2-Chat, are optimized for
dialogue use cases. Our models outperform open-source chat models on most
benchmarks we tested, and based on our human evaluations for helpfulness and
safety, may be a suitable substitute for closed-source models. We provide a
detailed description of our approach to fine-tuning and safety improvements of
Llama 2-Chat in order to enable the community to build on our work and
contribute to the responsible development of LLMs. | [
0.0469103679,
0.0512621142,
0.0042401338,
0.0558171347,
0.005255593,
0.0131591698,
-0.0094176298,
-0.0072213616,
0.04482162,
-0.0437211804,
-0.1088542342,
-0.0201116577,
0.0064727417,
0.036400158,
0.017416114,
-0.0649868622,
0.0314960927,
-0.0370257124,
0.0156874228,
0.0073087877,
0.0272788759,
0.0107788853,
-0.0306928605,
0.0543978475,
-0.0042236843,
-0.0260816403,
-0.016486736,
0.0061392216,
-0.0170772765,
-0.0095503042,
0.0358046666,
0.0426682122,
0.0128950356,
0.0296352655,
0.0000018303,
-0.0349294469,
0.0422833748,
-0.0359838977,
-0.0456017368,
0.0469954945,
0.0438552611,
0.0216123834,
-0.0262280274,
0.0633435622,
-0.0276701897,
-0.0297012664,
0.0305040292,
0.049115207,
0.0764522552,
0.0859811604,
-0.0068810903,
-0.0232995488,
0.0325992294,
-0.0470479615,
-0.015879238,
-0.072067678,
0.0172554106,
0.0092054252,
0.0107612843,
0.0258230679,
0.0164357014,
0.0330540538,
0.0140769994,
-0.045339141,
0.0033103437,
0.0303370766,
-0.0407483876,
-0.0226738714,
-0.0278496966,
0.1193660721,
-0.0126170451,
0.0027325028,
-0.0050502657,
-0.0011454958,
-0.0129682804,
-0.0758443996,
-0.0714655817,
-0.0021885897,
0.0258213636,
0.0086519299,
-0.0036814888,
0.0057562515,
0.0302642435,
0.0357438996,
0.0023170314,
0.0182408057,
0.0017785808,
0.0017969472,
-0.0043313634,
-0.0092140362,
-0.0089893071,
-0.0745302066,
0.0279158745,
0.0353718959,
-0.0408855602,
0.0096201319,
-0.0539079607,
0.0009684392,
0.0322784744,
-0.0794560239,
0.0213669743,
0.0271656048,
-0.0245134477,
0.0609529987,
0.0105857644,
0.0189116113,
-0.0300329067,
0.0206550043,
-0.0325370282,
-0.0074663996,
-0.0073069921,
0.0106740305,
-0.0442415662,
0.0114763072,
-0.0557971969,
-0.0702439472,
-0.022881154,
0.0431725457,
0.044879131,
0.009812858,
0.0305703823,
-0.0065158661,
-0.0239438042,
-0.0144102955,
-0.0051646912,
0.0137876542,
-0.0294018164,
0.0408573188,
0.018459864,
-0.0924032852,
-0.0065555885,
0.0464275926,
-0.004096292,
-0.0009119714,
0.0028118766,
0.0663503185,
-0.0201012958,
-0.0276498236,
-0.0136205824,
-0.0080871563,
0.0072174459,
-0.0569590256,
-0.0111651588,
-0.0450230762,
0.049657546,
-0.0256013349,
0.0154716354,
-0.0238581654,
0.0245070681,
0.0126877129,
-0.0271672662,
0.0511087924,
-0.0359637924,
0.0181755088,
0.0407157801,
0.0275033228,
-0.000857915,
0.0626525059,
0.0442236997,
0.0477635935,
0.0416533686,
0.0062659415,
0.0098578129,
0.0525476746,
-0.0104562137,
-0.0073122196,
0.016037453,
0.0333202668,
0.0067141405,
0.0587986074,
0.006082199,
0.0622329414,
-0.0539099425,
-0.0123206386,
0.0813210681,
0.041954048,
0.020279659,
0.0285557993,
0.0213295948,
0.0271098483,
0.038147673,
-0.0341157168,
-0.0604051091,
0.0288986955,
-0.002426045,
-0.0230811499,
0.0608639233,
0.0207201429,
-0.0627185181,
-0.0464258045,
0.0087377606,
-0.0397045165,
-0.0118632223,
0.0067341831,
0.008825412,
-0.005292668,
-0.0556019731,
0.0549670048,
0.0266229417,
-0.0277622174,
-0.034385819,
-0.0511586033,
0.038349703,
0.0894358978,
0.0480367579,
-0.0187578313,
-0.0704105124,
-0.0247370768,
0.0306730401,
0.0417336896,
0.0568710789,
-0.010875144,
0.0431911349,
-0.0809060633,
0.001662686,
-0.0041871928,
-0.0035152126,
0.0016693532,
0.0408201441,
-0.0009223007,
-0.0000229674,
0.0165396556,
-0.0103225568,
0.0232325699,
-0.0050333105,
-0.0114159863,
0.0135999462,
-0.0225910656,
0.0311266314,
0.0011338129,
-0.0100206006,
-0.0085144313,
0.0133206667,
-0.0128223356,
0.0013624285,
0.0187130496,
-0.0742439628,
-0.0537774563,
0.0307491031,
0.030809233,
-0.0021523256,
0.0340944156,
-0.0490914918,
-0.0386050977,
0.0160201881,
-0.0204904862,
0.0285176449,
-0.048476398,
0.0294244196,
0.019185748,
0.0386852138,
0.0087425699,
0.0054635722,
-0.0002083424,
-0.0296298731,
0.0059819324,
0.0286817737,
0.0130677186,
-0.0433460511,
-0.0354353562,
0.0332481526,
-0.0198576059,
0.0277514551,
-0.0266334638,
0.0485039838,
-0.0319859162,
-0.0438630953,
-0.1147408932,
0.0444063805,
-0.0228399504,
0.0054781898,
0.0081467694,
0.0164062213,
-0.0324545205,
-0.0393731035,
-0.019681545,
0.024551196,
0.0260214582,
-0.0116391936,
0.0173023641,
0.0055720862,
-0.026178211,
-0.09044265,
0.0012948235,
0.0299809314,
0.0169458296,
-0.0109017408,
-0.0459155664,
-0.0381287783,
0.0292181596,
-0.0269350447,
0.0616293699,
-0.0251101349,
-0.0847401321,
0.0114927394,
0.0080450699,
0.0235843975,
0.0650513619,
0.0174192209,
0.0185041968,
0.0113249458,
0.0016475193,
-0.0508893281,
0.0392853022,
-0.0088427896,
-0.0470657162,
-0.0317368433,
0.0237021595,
0.0143272737,
0.0505602732,
-0.0159934331,
0.0272851121,
-0.0466184057,
-0.0147204399,
0.0023182288,
-0.0204118844,
-0.0103715174,
-0.0066572148,
-0.0254136696,
0.0213280693,
-0.0273103323,
-0.0574624836,
0.0396523625,
-0.0667433068,
-0.0136978077,
-0.0257692579,
-0.0333975852,
-0.0424914919,
0.0162675213,
-0.0403181091,
-0.0018910193,
0.002479889,
-0.0371646844,
-0.0065684384,
-0.0149837304,
-0.013005822,
-0.0459346697,
0.0297628362,
-0.0454591401,
0.0028021836,
0.0096096871,
-0.0609067604,
-0.0412759297,
-0.054461509,
-0.0629183277,
-0.0006979536,
0.010696141,
-0.0254499074,
-0.0410674848,
0.0132003147,
-0.0165954344,
0.04216763,
-0.006922049,
0.0144697903,
-0.0362059139,
0.0133147659,
0.0618692823,
0.0088531151,
0.0110368552,
-0.0349815674,
0.0437557399,
0.0478848405,
0.0104864184,
0.0015407628,
-0.0277631078,
-0.0123306783,
0.0253231674,
0.0072430782,
-0.0321536027,
0.0029187743,
0.0632274076,
-0.0276101362,
0.005422378,
0.1270926446,
0.0098763639,
-0.0506491512,
-0.0071874447,
-0.0146468664,
0.0091930907,
0.0112481397,
0.0303455032,
-0.0820906311,
-0.0540518835,
0.0161479469,
-0.0008180758,
0.026395103,
0.0053626578,
0.0033822784,
-0.0874862373,
0.0129724564,
0.0053700502,
-0.0168910865,
-0.0197994262,
0.00098935,
0.0056769373,
-0.0093090246,
0.0338887013,
0.0030675295,
-0.0008039785,
-0.0500993654,
-0.0005762727,
-0.0104124499,
-0.0274802167,
0.0477464683,
-0.0235510841,
0.0935694426,
0.0422578231,
0.0367014073,
0.0296842288,
-0.0151317092,
0.0402037837,
-0.0025633464,
-0.0058300761,
-0.0205509122,
0.0265481677,
-0.0211405959,
-0.0297615845,
-0.0246210638,
0.0325531401,
-0.0076228501,
0.0042060879,
0.0042872312,
0.017379526,
-0.0176918674,
-0.0171816181,
-0.0010826292,
0.0407915041,
0.0251956005,
0.055914592,
0.0402409136,
-0.0230258573,
-0.0287004858,
-0.0077497172,
-0.0237837899,
-0.0097328704,
-0.0120627116,
-0.0132464692,
0.0015614671,
-0.0126236128,
-0.0719328374,
-0.0212455615,
0.0320467763,
0.0061694942,
-0.0007892301,
-0.0056206738,
-0.0057789776,
0.0022284759,
0.0205789004,
0.0363744348,
-0.0503111631,
0.0349618979,
-0.0750198439,
0.0166362021,
0.0625459328,
-0.0100373775,
-0.0063396683,
0.0446321182,
-0.100522913,
-0.0813754275,
-0.0191003233,
0.0751985982,
0.0193712767,
0.0265922155,
-0.0477240309,
-0.0877294019,
-0.0021737516,
-0.003695053,
-0.0360158272,
0.0135475667,
0.0437679067,
0.0355029032,
0.0140850944,
0.0562698133,
-0.0270616263,
0.0210533421,
-0.0085639311,
0.0112226522,
-0.0242109448,
-0.0895167887,
-0.032393001,
-0.0026746411,
0.0203502756,
0.0172826163,
-0.0284731314,
-0.0329024792,
0.0608364232,
-0.005313029,
-0.00262043,
-0.0526980124,
0.018691862,
0.0291302577,
-0.0109908292,
-0.0090851597,
-0.0059322929,
-0.0230944064,
0.0386052355,
-0.0179472715,
0.0145452777,
0.0035766507,
-0.020883875,
0.0158258975,
-0.005963244,
-0.0378249921,
0.0319463015,
0.0041358471,
0.0106890323,
-0.0231710635,
0.0686798319,
-0.0159159247,
-0.0403143875,
-0.0122660222,
0.0523409061,
-0.0296230596,
-0.0687172189,
-0.0126057686,
0.0914634988,
0.0500011034,
0.0395672917,
0.0493215807,
-0.0085190022,
0.0208934527,
-0.0249006804,
0.0774291456,
-0.0266482681,
-0.027540084,
0.0571520142,
0.0068049417,
-0.0195272993,
0.0191991888,
0.0794155449,
-0.0015084452,
0.0457536243,
0.0222608484,
0.0243768543,
-0.028370481,
-0.0241125077,
0.0382218063,
0.0301268455,
-0.0239336397,
0.000007461,
0.0210340302,
-0.0366003588,
0.0095542707,
-0.002510437,
-0.0408724807,
-0.0042603468,
0.0377609767,
0.0536817536,
0.0184888951,
-0.0036359718,
-0.0151346214,
-0.023940824,
-0.0210121032,
-0.0186902992,
-0.0154529726,
-6.530459601e-33,
-0.0247913469,
0.0110703884,
0.0224368423,
0.0209499691,
-0.0613225475,
-0.0402687378,
-0.0193415638,
0.0024526909,
-0.0491991118,
-0.0027186226,
-0.0343166851,
0.0659337193,
0.025440922,
0.0169922542,
-0.0312286783,
-0.0208887272,
0.0471884757,
-0.0047110314,
-0.0071719866,
0.0532098077,
0.0052676196,
0.0198148433,
0.0438351706,
-0.0585479513,
-0.0226421431,
-0.0219473802,
-0.0195310917,
0.0509343073,
0.0041869311,
0.0595637001,
-0.0470499545,
0.028659435,
-0.0001738387,
-0.0122809764,
-0.0201060325,
0.0555564947,
-0.034993954,
-0.0060755727,
0.0503029451,
0.021584034,
-0.0102432687,
-0.0410555601,
0.029630946,
-0.0168583728,
0.0210878886,
0.0047904723,
-0.0038250186,
-0.0112915589,
-0.013575606,
0.0133836502,
-0.0365459286,
0.0192545485,
-0.0183009971,
-0.075159952,
-0.0229303092,
0.0210563019,
-0.0011802464,
-0.0218884237,
-0.0235198848,
0.0118770842,
0.0100930119,
0.0220609028,
0.028863309,
0.008714431,
0.0157224257,
0.0550119802,
-0.0090792021,
0.0063378136,
-0.0295439661,
-0.0217598639,
0.0010718809,
0.065329656,
0.0083655221,
0.0431276597,
-0.0276363716,
-0.0276187249,
-0.0697007179,
-0.0035500962,
0.0533147939,
0.0639929324,
0.0033102212,
0.015814025,
-0.036054913,
-0.00798898,
-0.0310284197,
0.0303133037,
-0.0326282978,
-0.0241263118,
0.0369541906,
0.0328269936,
-0.0035917009,
-0.0261107907,
0.0371853039,
-0.0354924947,
0.0241106357,
0.0139426636,
-0.0016260835,
0.0312252268,
-0.0255246311,
0.0178658906,
-0.0576024279,
-0.0414129421,
0.0493039563,
-0.0132619627,
0.0046427217,
-0.0026722173,
0.013563863,
0.0343123116,
-0.0527441241,
-0.0038494803,
-0.0233706199,
0.0252067093,
0.0008840385,
0.0381939784,
0.0244407356,
0.0078535788,
-0.03110574,
0.0682394952,
-0.03262325,
0.0091704093,
-0.031570565,
-0.06023518,
0.0131570697,
0.0124820564,
-0.0442453362,
0.0204955712,
-0.0515874214,
-0.0248764027,
0.0072067212,
-0.0543557703,
-0.0196356867,
-0.0078546507,
2.463e-7,
-0.0035190706,
0.0488645062,
0.0251423158,
0.0386350974,
0.0243864376,
0.0287360698,
-0.00751979,
0.0483660363,
0.0124069061,
0.0009325375,
0.0136343073,
0.050933674,
0.0600811243,
-0.0103390887,
-0.1015416086,
-0.0373535603,
-0.0935621038,
-0.0158966873,
-0.0482812226,
-0.0993976295,
0.0415984914,
0.1215578318,
-0.0108631728,
-0.0000495172,
0.0037984157,
-0.039403595,
0.0616614632,
-0.0477078855,
-0.0366218537,
0.047798302,
0.0634457767,
0.0511643998,
-0.0243266411,
-0.0308473203,
0.0158391502,
0.028138008,
0.0021903329,
0.1324913949,
0.0055509917,
-0.039728038,
0.0221971627,
-0.0241813641,
-0.0099289268,
-0.034749411,
0.0647965595,
-0.0387992002,
-0.0145488959,
-0.0367297083,
0.0259551834,
-0.0138399415,
0.0170585085,
-0.0444059931,
-0.0079703555,
0.0308633614,
0.0149809057,
-0.0313153826,
-0.022493057,
-0.0861146078,
-0.0348973162,
-0.0241710916,
-0.0579669438,
-0.0339346044,
-0.0612565577,
-0.0317065753,
-0.0019601523,
-0.0220331866,
0.0308235679,
1.575052457e-34,
0.0297416952,
-0.0157518554,
0.0116598122,
0.0543759912,
0.0273708478,
0.0055853953,
0.0240803417,
0.007986024,
0.0156523623,
-0.0882238969,
0.0075158742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10291v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10291v2 | Mutual Reinforcement Effects in Japanese Sentence Classification and Named Entity Recognition Tasks | 2023-07-18T14:30:36 | 2023-07-21T02:34:58 | Chengguang Gan, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori | cs.CL | cs.CL | Information extraction(IE) is a crucial subfield within natural language
processing. However, for the traditionally segmented approach to sentence
classification and Named Entity Recognition, the intricate interactions between
these individual subtasks remain largely uninvestigated. In this study, we
propose an integrative analysis, converging sentence classification with Named
Entity Recognition, with the objective to unveil and comprehend the mutual
reinforcement effect within these two information extraction subtasks. To
achieve this, we introduce a Sentence Classification and Named Entity
Recognition Multi-task (SCNM) approach that combines Sentence Classification
(SC) and Named Entity Recognition (NER). We develop a Sentence-to-Label
Generation (SLG) framework for SCNM and construct a Wikipedia dataset
containing both SC and NER. Using a format converter, we unify input formats
and employ a generative model to generate SC-labels, NER-labels, and associated
text segments. We propose a Constraint Mechanism (CM) to improve generated
format accuracy. Our results show SC accuracy increased by 1.13 points and NER
by 1.06 points in SCNM compared to standalone tasks, with CM raising format
accuracy from 63.61 to 100. The findings indicate mutual reinforcement effects
between SC and NER, and integration enhances both tasks' performance. We
additionally implemented the SLG framework on single SC task. It yielded
superior accuracies compared to the baseline on two distinct Japanese SC
datasets. Notably, in the experiment of few-shot learning, SLG framework shows
much better performance than fine-tune method. These empirical findings
contribute additional evidence to affirm the efficacy of the SLG framework. | [
0.0587907769,
0.0113939494,
0.0064281235,
0.0058575375,
-0.0166192725,
0.0658302754,
0.0284656975,
0.0096030729,
-0.0188133772,
-0.0626225471,
-0.0427845791,
-0.0326297171,
0.0277690012,
-0.0316264033,
0.0251737889,
-0.0683892965,
0.0255386233,
-0.0022143568,
0.0483728424,
0.0314193815,
0.0294968244,
-0.0154208597,
-0.010049697,
0.0139706433,
-0.0218431652,
0.018559983,
0.0273696333,
-0.0034487818,
0.0315260477,
-0.0415791199,
0.0427006036,
0.0505121388,
-0.0182702858,
0.018132057,
0.0000021395,
-0.066872105,
-0.0288873427,
-0.0239659362,
-0.010966856,
-0.012391733,
0.0169927981,
-0.0436069816,
0.0057357089,
-0.0078706043,
-0.0068727457,
-0.0502727516,
0.0420330018,
0.1028077826,
0.05145026,
0.0975856408,
-0.0170217529,
-0.0449629202,
0.0252109114,
-0.0189343728,
0.0268041771,
0.0372320712,
0.028664941,
-0.0291951355,
-0.0343692973,
-0.0023639074,
0.0173288137,
0.0022324082,
0.0062620714,
0.0195519775,
0.0576294586,
0.0507652536,
-0.0147604141,
-0.0316573977,
-0.0020043056,
0.0305197444,
0.0003564175,
-0.006179966,
0.0319777131,
-0.0056738816,
-0.02065452,
-0.018627651,
-0.040599227,
0.0478687659,
-0.0316877291,
0.0075861551,
0.0338149108,
0.0151492879,
0.0040895045,
-0.0129146772,
-0.0043050558,
0.0191179253,
0.0346040465,
-0.077438347,
0.0006556651,
0.0513190739,
-0.0310730916,
-0.0509624705,
0.0126820859,
0.0236145053,
-0.0244935639,
0.0179517306,
-0.0522113629,
-0.0668458939,
0.0171509013,
-0.0498328879,
-0.0098575288,
0.0166778769,
0.0079177339,
-0.0252572112,
-0.0419454314,
0.0371793993,
0.0092456378,
0.0139164645,
-0.016258955,
0.0150853833,
-0.0834920183,
-0.0377869159,
-0.0350200534,
0.0707586929,
-0.0069268676,
-0.0272344239,
-0.0630542338,
-0.0031233451,
-0.0058946069,
0.0064241253,
0.038117379,
-0.0347624682,
-0.0456337556,
0.0500775054,
-0.0392138474,
0.0162923802,
-0.0345216393,
0.0228250306,
0.0249336641,
0.0313201435,
-0.0091415001,
0.0003933506,
0.0478545465,
-0.0465660281,
0.0139013911,
0.0249171164,
-0.0247482993,
-0.0607590005,
-0.0650459602,
-0.0365490578,
-0.0404415801,
-0.0400055088,
0.0253644604,
-0.0315949023,
0.0523706079,
0.0028952651,
0.0010815847,
-0.0116541749,
0.0381548852,
0.0038399103,
-0.0071808328,
0.062470194,
-0.0102161635,
-0.0217419565,
-0.0086479997,
0.0003605643,
0.0717668459,
0.0617650151,
0.0511898287,
0.0062790462,
0.0417262278,
0.0427933149,
-0.0047362787,
0.0221344065,
-0.0105473557,
-0.0127665205,
0.0260416623,
-0.0209785327,
0.0157364737,
0.0081961202,
0.034785226,
0.0015394958,
-0.0113873919,
0.0620539375,
0.0360506549,
0.0191384535,
0.0026450264,
-0.0014575529,
0.049155537,
-0.0264459215,
-0.0177071597,
0.0435514078,
-0.0445166118,
0.0028609501,
-0.0120341601,
0.0616732836,
0.0080367755,
0.0040578339,
-0.0229707845,
-0.0442819893,
0.0038860408,
-0.0249571316,
-0.007230896,
-0.0136216274,
0.0487810969,
0.0346083306,
-0.0515706353,
0.0895044804,
0.0474820733,
-0.0588159263,
0.024445856,
-0.0125942379,
0.0061371936,
0.0673347786,
0.0097346753,
-0.0370226838,
-0.0242248867,
-0.0090365345,
0.0067134011,
0.0897431523,
0.0152766099,
-0.0325908624,
0.0095445737,
-0.0268128663,
-0.0185317192,
-0.0295827873,
0.0117852138,
0.005357937,
0.0299710743,
0.0283895154,
0.0347651169,
-0.0261646751,
-0.0383667797,
0.0580285117,
0.0170934517,
-0.0405257232,
0.0122626089,
0.0598454066,
-0.015785696,
0.0304761045,
-0.0314364918,
0.0073123137,
0.0017510195,
-0.0609936826,
-0.0177458134,
-0.0035971471,
-0.0123771764,
-0.0847530812,
-0.0098951031,
0.0201999359,
-0.0151248612,
0.0079178335,
-0.0230648685,
-0.0518920682,
-0.0575106591,
0.0197938979,
0.0075793634,
-0.0320546404,
0.0179294739,
0.0232162979,
0.0235810298,
-0.0348484479,
0.0837097839,
0.0095903361,
-0.0026043677,
0.0089272335,
-0.0436229594,
0.0066779717,
-0.0361629091,
-0.0317721851,
0.016087858,
0.0012291266,
-0.0415453501,
0.0272613484,
0.0231715105,
-0.0432190485,
-0.0277437456,
-0.0965570733,
0.0257305373,
-0.0152050685,
0.0667099059,
0.0041596587,
0.0242813788,
-0.0349963456,
-0.0023667885,
0.0044693789,
0.0105027258,
0.0073513351,
0.0074623441,
0.0381367654,
0.0303821955,
0.0095280735,
-0.0166872721,
-0.0044262521,
-0.0328473337,
0.0270504896,
0.0439331941,
-0.082302317,
-0.0763176531,
0.0617462769,
-0.0199258644,
-0.0271146409,
0.0322269835,
-0.0128033198,
0.009918998,
-0.0057368898,
0.0696276426,
0.0485882051,
-0.0050971834,
0.0146214934,
0.0035665347,
-0.0300305076,
-0.0266953539,
0.0405148491,
-0.0235306434,
0.0392261855,
-0.0142803639,
-0.0205677748,
0.0440001898,
0.0911097154,
0.0086905723,
0.0124287205,
-0.0405266583,
-0.0136936493,
-0.0302255526,
-0.0182540901,
-0.0233143922,
0.0121127907,
-0.0265353769,
-0.0030617947,
-0.0315154716,
0.0005321371,
0.0660522655,
-0.0129830046,
-0.0153446337,
-0.0574819408,
0.0227681994,
-0.0262063909,
0.0486860909,
0.0158060566,
0.0088493302,
0.0951678976,
-0.0637592077,
-0.0214605201,
0.0478600189,
0.0061701471,
0.015406359,
0.0316244103,
-0.0140028307,
-0.0030321279,
-0.0432847887,
-0.0107554179,
-0.0340299457,
-0.0341417082,
-0.0069607361,
0.0165566597,
-0.001612796,
0.0224133227,
0.011527163,
0.0378391966,
0.0248909295,
0.0042131385,
-0.0356077142,
-0.017852217,
-0.035554111,
0.0572664849,
0.0494440608,
0.0058224425,
-0.0242612902,
-0.0108547863,
0.0307060424,
-0.001301653,
0.024301786,
0.0200826898,
0.0329407193,
-0.0069553773,
0.0110227419,
-0.0957256854,
-0.0106472,
-0.0069013676,
0.0491118282,
-0.0620473474,
-0.0301125757,
0.1350335777,
0.0212861132,
-0.0171710514,
-0.0319630206,
0.0169836748,
0.0201482885,
0.012129399,
0.0090616094,
-0.0632576421,
-0.0345050171,
0.0074266638,
0.0224279612,
-0.0134807052,
-0.0333496891,
0.0096149705,
-0.13514404,
-0.0090255132,
-0.0045663868,
-0.077809073,
0.0104413666,
-0.0529132523,
-0.0003142919,
0.0089657139,
0.0076210708,
-0.0349173956,
-0.0212987587,
0.0166778062,
0.0147739649,
-0.0053919447,
-0.0522512868,
-0.0028793628,
-0.0236247387,
0.0382158794,
0.030260507,
0.0323308706,
-0.0125907613,
0.0244512297,
0.0165166222,
-0.030512251,
-0.000761644,
-0.0342399366,
0.0545576476,
-0.0241067223,
0.0009962698,
-0.0192065556,
0.0013424535,
0.0103605883,
-0.0339607783,
0.0478220731,
0.0337386578,
0.0253129303,
-0.0098282387,
0.0030093931,
-0.0375629105,
0.0291156825,
0.0646653622,
0.0288804714,
-0.0559211746,
-0.0369271114,
0.0130335055,
-0.0173265338,
-0.1087732315,
-0.0016421435,
0.0059593618,
-0.0504786111,
0.0017085081,
-0.0842630789,
-0.072479479,
0.0099763004,
0.0240317285,
0.0256385915,
-0.0107132327,
0.0043134796,
0.0142907696,
-0.0367477164,
-0.0148109868,
-0.0206405725,
-0.0129184341,
-0.0348002426,
-0.0287354626,
-0.0180153511,
-0.0125708552,
0.0154609773,
-0.0334267505,
-0.0631660223,
-0.0357624292,
-0.0268750265,
0.061526034,
0.0004855785,
0.0109180603,
0.032485012,
-0.0047590043,
0.0304980408,
0.0704799742,
-0.0512626059,
0.0122368978,
0.0226181168,
0.0318790376,
-0.0170201827,
0.0140533876,
-0.0437475927,
0.0135686668,
0.0322594829,
0.0588206612,
0.0224809814,
-0.0060810866,
-0.0010478088,
0.037711639,
0.0732816458,
-0.0588778406,
-0.0181410406,
-0.074444741,
0.0131802866,
-0.0151439561,
-0.0280559752,
-0.0160300322,
-0.0209785197,
0.0081752688,
0.0342141278,
-0.027038971,
0.0755512342,
-0.0133538265,
0.0184464622,
-0.0744843185,
-0.0325304866,
0.0121415751,
0.0348979607,
-0.0052630519,
-0.0076464773,
-0.0095700482,
-0.0198484808,
0.0464996025,
-0.0019538892,
-0.0157764181,
0.044724416,
-0.0054364703,
-0.0112760039,
-0.0337910056,
0.0366916843,
-0.0500135496,
0.091793023,
-0.0157737751,
0.0029063229,
0.0503300168,
-0.0083282897,
0.0635738447,
-0.0243649334,
-0.0228247568,
0.0190218333,
0.0344788618,
-0.0000805468,
-0.0080511188,
-0.007793332,
-0.0064178528,
-0.0195968859,
-0.0499369763,
0.0866006762,
0.0227500405,
0.0325122885,
-0.0037278316,
-0.004742688,
-0.0395754464,
-0.0408943221,
0.0063747745,
-0.000806624,
-0.0241567604,
-0.0648308247,
-0.0030635712,
-0.0185766276,
0.0193492156,
-0.0232907124,
0.0127265463,
0.0296311155,
0.0069307024,
0.0074817729,
0.0083661322,
-0.0357265696,
-0.0294749252,
-0.0033277685,
0.0162622686,
0.0124731399,
-0.0074374406,
-6.387296878e-33,
-0.0675942004,
-0.0127134183,
0.0147244064,
0.025890382,
-0.0279257279,
0.0268315692,
-0.0377465226,
-0.0034007865,
0.051182501,
-0.0230766181,
0.0007596985,
-0.015261001,
0.0317028835,
0.0200039521,
0.0263013057,
-0.0205592401,
0.0564564951,
0.0104215816,
-0.0516973771,
0.0139189977,
0.0372418799,
0.0374046564,
0.047888767,
-0.0277213603,
0.0731121674,
0.0012992352,
0.0041220877,
-0.0028393569,
0.048201248,
0.0725309625,
-0.0108615197,
0.0819335878,
0.0291270874,
-0.0802504495,
-0.0163758025,
0.0880791545,
-0.1498834938,
-0.0374400243,
-0.0174654499,
0.0169467069,
-0.0149612771,
-0.0505323522,
-0.0031504291,
0.0009472575,
0.0468474813,
-0.0064322944,
0.0591357686,
-0.0150067164,
0.0234460644,
-0.0545449108,
-0.1030326635,
-0.0109831151,
0.0204002317,
0.0369208679,
0.0356145129,
0.0401761942,
0.0105450964,
-0.0158698373,
-0.0475621,
0.0260217506,
-0.0091253091,
0.0150755756,
-0.009225308,
0.0654151514,
-0.0171551481,
0.0250041764,
0.0204252489,
-0.0012648099,
-0.035570737,
0.0065155448,
0.0123885898,
-0.0031920813,
-0.009504606,
0.0588434078,
0.017213393,
-0.0433697365,
-0.0985788628,
0.0442351736,
0.0112128891,
0.0136732655,
0.0030647088,
-0.0251156129,
-0.0361884572,
-0.0331994407,
0.011221067,
-0.0194732565,
-0.0449625403,
-0.0112437438,
0.0489934236,
0.0528444052,
-0.0511058755,
0.0245920122,
0.0265393183,
-0.0283047128,
-0.0229536705,
0.0303323977,
-0.002261146,
0.032895647,
-0.0312447976,
-0.058391612,
-0.0769339651,
-0.0668444857,
0.019105725,
0.0147102131,
0.0151970005,
-0.0138973631,
0.0758970231,
-0.0022597595,
-0.0488368943,
0.026205238,
-0.0034675566,
0.0211807732,
0.0105226608,
0.0044221021,
-0.0045739249,
0.0067069959,
0.0036491491,
0.005887229,
0.0809066445,
-0.018247949,
-0.0351954587,
-0.0171729121,
0.0134266112,
0.0222981963,
-0.0020136132,
0.0130678704,
0.0113476943,
0.029217774,
-0.0236758012,
-0.0524174832,
-0.0143939555,
-0.0079728849,
2.859e-7,
0.0104296654,
0.0260533914,
0.0044242563,
-0.0054824683,
-0.0111615146,
0.0216166861,
0.0150601845,
0.0419354439,
0.0000775795,
0.0004933919,
0.0349381194,
-0.001289625,
0.0313926376,
0.0020509853,
-0.1014431119,
-0.0163325071,
0.0036140401,
0.0204581767,
-0.0763109848,
0.0401273295,
0.0794841349,
0.0171123203,
-0.0142678227,
-0.0001758652,
-0.0156250689,
-0.0293696038,
0.0626877919,
0.0255812537,
0.0155196125,
0.0542760827,
0.006914692,
0.0333436504,
-0.0127197187,
0.0331458785,
-0.0295770876,
0.0110190678,
0.0200219955,
0.062394876,
-0.0045868428,
-0.0309053361,
0.010084061,
0.0026039388,
0.0237127766,
-0.0386133716,
0.0833387822,
-0.0711567998,
0.0031806962,
0.0384876281,
0.0091288853,
-0.0022126799,
-0.0196968913,
0.0071604392,
-0.0474901721,
0.0091513367,
0.0354345478,
0.013311795,
-0.0372765064,
-0.0564961135,
-0.02199669,
0.0412550904,
-0.0029918498,
-0.0180229694,
-0.0427183807,
-0.00656329,
-0.0018167681,
-0.0726440772,
-0.0060338657,
2.662095679e-34,
-0.0450238064,
0.0148626342,
-0.0072810077,
0.0180515572,
0.0060502351,
-0.0296318904,
-0.0964863598,
0.0049936133,
-0.0064965351,
-0.0512488894,
-0.0039000555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09274v1 | Improving Text Semantic Similarity Modeling through a 3D Siamese Network | 2023-07-18T14:11:58 | 2023-07-18T14:11:58 | Jianxiang Zang, Hui Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Siamese networks have gained popularity as a method for modeling text
semantic similarity. Traditional methods rely on pooling operation to compress
the semantic representations from Transformer blocks in encoding, resulting in
two-dimensional semantic vectors and the loss of hierarchical semantic
information from Transformer blocks. Moreover, this limited structure of
semantic vectors is akin to a flattened landscape, which restricts the methods
that can be applied in downstream modeling, as they can only navigate this flat
terrain. To address this issue, we propose a novel 3D Siamese network for text
semantic similarity modeling, which maps semantic information to a
higher-dimensional space. The three-dimensional semantic tensors not only
retains more precise spatial and feature domain information but also provides
the necessary structural condition for comprehensive downstream modeling
strategies to capture them. Leveraging this structural advantage, we introduce
several modules to reinforce this 3D framework, focusing on three aspects:
feature extraction, attention, and feature fusion. Our extensive experiments on
four text semantic similarity benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness and
efficiency of our 3D Siamese Network. | [
0.031332925,
0.0234508887,
0.0028970216,
0.0480372012,
-0.0508306511,
0.0343703516,
0.0074898084,
-0.0406930074,
-0.0229297988,
-0.0448300056,
-0.0207405388,
-0.0011273186,
0.0029309355,
0.0476000048,
0.0240583457,
-0.0696971714,
0.0221843272,
0.0334220566,
-0.0459113754,
0.0269754939,
0.0269608423,
0.0378282554,
0.0404028296,
-0.0095881401,
-0.006376687,
0.0035136486,
-0.0097676162,
-0.0086081298,
0.0113708917,
-0.0376806632,
0.017114222,
0.0177844334,
0.0325669199,
-0.0075011686,
0.0000019481,
-0.0076793502,
-0.0037787128,
-0.0106934132,
0.0790367872,
-0.0177772772,
0.0170421693,
-0.0252013709,
0.0197865926,
-0.0267965961,
-0.0395441689,
-0.0118911937,
0.0293103755,
0.0698904693,
0.0389668606,
0.0322994143,
-0.0477219224,
-0.0394447707,
0.0511797182,
-0.00945751,
0.0251211822,
0.0068101636,
0.0091664102,
0.0278243013,
-0.0346884653,
0.0524424799,
-0.0022431179,
0.0212292951,
0.0282761455,
0.0485551544,
0.0532256663,
0.0494899116,
-0.0125617897,
0.0291031338,
-0.0036751328,
0.0764252394,
-0.0174983144,
-0.0303688571,
0.0038344339,
-0.0101988707,
-0.016617747,
0.0047000516,
-0.0337079614,
-0.0262995679,
-0.0335597508,
0.0233524702,
-0.0017028378,
0.0768760219,
-0.0230063368,
0.0093739852,
-0.0651932359,
-0.0314108394,
0.022493232,
-0.0263273213,
-0.0185933597,
0.0021417274,
0.0216481797,
0.010620771,
0.018878134,
-0.0267854352,
0.0278215334,
-0.0025315434,
-0.0214119069,
-0.038620241,
0.0159753636,
-0.0914788693,
0.0038646339,
0.0454712771,
-0.0307257865,
0.0730222836,
-0.0735234991,
0.02636455,
-0.052613847,
0.0763396621,
-0.0762463138,
-0.0403056815,
-0.0546967052,
0.030617781,
-0.0250958446,
0.053480193,
-0.0188515745,
-0.0651391521,
0.0077926344,
0.0236057937,
-0.0152782854,
-0.0319653414,
-0.0142291579,
0.0623709522,
0.0033203976,
-0.041450344,
-0.0055088373,
0.0227110572,
-0.0322286114,
0.0008684217,
-0.0430990383,
-0.0112398649,
-0.0056793289,
0.0473122634,
0.0288328864,
-0.040624667,
0.0101955794,
0.0293289497,
-0.0301088989,
-0.0582647808,
-0.0122398771,
-0.008137838,
-0.0016359448,
-0.0170033295,
0.0181164742,
-0.0853685141,
0.0490440689,
-0.0186642651,
-0.0382608846,
-0.0700987279,
-0.0151217105,
0.0194604807,
-0.0571863353,
0.0491040684,
0.0046746004,
-0.0369668379,
0.0333026573,
0.0103134429,
0.0075357012,
0.0013596094,
0.0020099368,
0.0633975789,
-0.0024453206,
0.0312091373,
-0.0521669909,
0.0043821977,
0.023362482,
0.0282702632,
-0.0432100482,
-0.0038685864,
-0.0044447342,
0.0433988869,
0.0453912057,
0.055789873,
-0.0388008766,
-0.0444553643,
0.0284805465,
0.0866249576,
-0.0124231484,
0.0406996571,
0.0371849462,
0.0087057836,
-0.0472298563,
0.0242400356,
-0.0118285455,
0.0491929241,
0.0134283034,
0.006902874,
0.0127146458,
0.0681637377,
-0.0562454015,
-0.0029923713,
0.024872791,
-0.0079046348,
0.0282095391,
-0.0394609906,
0.0621584021,
0.0346356034,
-0.0409337468,
0.0865791813,
0.0137405042,
-0.0573337898,
0.0016300008,
0.0341289975,
-0.0019181772,
0.0530757196,
0.0197894983,
-0.0062393751,
-0.0375392959,
0.0132706696,
0.0079994537,
0.0033977928,
0.0315119848,
0.0224643946,
-0.0328714512,
-0.0655339062,
-0.0636184588,
-0.0105168065,
-0.0206480883,
0.0422225446,
0.0281884242,
0.0156867485,
0.0310282409,
-0.0059392429,
0.0348817073,
0.0240593627,
-0.0480013937,
0.0065028877,
-0.0311322007,
0.025909299,
0.0281187985,
-0.0037807962,
0.0197373573,
0.0217586737,
0.0277997628,
-0.0668550655,
-0.0640163943,
0.0200913232,
-0.076719597,
-0.0103187468,
0.02622471,
-0.0708308145,
0.0030092346,
0.0383986533,
-0.0574172512,
-0.0079071382,
0.032449279,
-0.0430270098,
0.0054179709,
-0.0349197984,
0.0124570737,
0.0196319781,
0.0335590728,
-0.0519750379,
0.0836931393,
-0.0525067784,
0.0237491746,
-0.0017913504,
0.0099404864,
0.0336511247,
0.0324114338,
0.0140443621,
-0.0063453149,
0.0080117332,
0.0095043993,
0.002952816,
-0.0054893568,
-0.0373988636,
-0.0459953621,
-0.0156532694,
0.0268897973,
0.0201084446,
0.0149154188,
0.0203487147,
0.023841979,
0.0038042378,
-0.0383141786,
-0.0580474585,
0.0086857351,
-0.0392374024,
-0.0059494814,
0.0190662388,
-0.040984448,
-0.0018664954,
-0.0226624385,
-0.0215179101,
-0.0166512523,
0.0828639343,
0.0005789057,
-0.0524005108,
0.0015569335,
-0.015754981,
-0.0418483466,
0.0311802253,
-0.0016366324,
0.0172942113,
-0.0263785366,
-0.0543350279,
0.0022613327,
0.0218950175,
0.0342462622,
0.000658109,
0.0063681025,
0.0144459028,
-0.0685557947,
0.0094124703,
-0.0739329383,
0.0599585697,
0.01084013,
-0.0300283823,
0.0453812964,
0.0036640272,
0.0459727906,
0.0132159302,
-0.0248357113,
0.0187060516,
0.0617505759,
0.0054203961,
-0.0457051508,
-0.0030614864,
0.0144240726,
-0.0219264887,
-0.0425468348,
0.0046052923,
0.0668148324,
-0.0179509111,
0.0318738669,
-0.07163506,
0.0134471385,
-0.0654730424,
0.0759938434,
-0.0096439272,
0.0263902321,
-0.0150231374,
-0.0033263026,
-0.0083088679,
-0.006341652,
0.030980384,
0.0103906281,
0.022685295,
-0.0014552191,
0.0225612856,
-0.0024294748,
-0.019462822,
0.0017453891,
-0.0312899351,
-0.0311084688,
0.0009298854,
0.0152522232,
0.017558096,
-0.0577356741,
0.0112988949,
0.0039874171,
0.0570939742,
0.0059447316,
-0.0592077225,
-0.0372271314,
0.0810972527,
0.0220556594,
0.0116425762,
0.0100282775,
0.010606708,
0.0050558452,
0.0914710984,
-0.0021175307,
0.0202612709,
-0.0704773441,
0.0336052328,
0.0270095114,
-0.014812273,
0.0155654838,
-0.0398083404,
-0.0500557348,
-0.0257385224,
0.0087035121,
0.0571656041,
0.0293398723,
-0.0357455462,
-0.0235227011,
0.0018302392,
0.0163313877,
0.0242044516,
-0.0075030234,
-0.0288185794,
-0.0220159665,
-0.0383762829,
-0.0366142169,
0.0723479837,
-0.0130083924,
0.0044618188,
-0.0620822534,
0.0200823378,
-0.009994762,
-0.0468140841,
-0.0475236736,
-0.047069367,
0.0118547911,
0.0085386662,
-0.036957141,
-0.0550591201,
0.0086456453,
-0.0376666747,
-0.0071857804,
0.0390820019,
0.0092387702,
0.0164050236,
-0.0513306111,
-0.0252080597,
-0.0278351456,
0.0490723625,
-0.0003171395,
-0.0792061314,
-0.0211649928,
-0.0332452245,
0.0035424887,
0.0100719035,
0.047254853,
-0.0269398652,
0.0080721127,
-0.0417162143,
0.0077357139,
-0.034346614,
-0.0223880112,
-0.0310063753,
0.070078522,
-0.0291164052,
0.0019959125,
-0.0694313422,
0.0448748507,
-0.0429321267,
0.0438426696,
0.0207787398,
0.0001103438,
-0.0144972866,
0.0274822786,
0.012340107,
-0.0231928732,
-0.010600822,
0.0255696904,
0.0149820643,
-0.0328620374,
-0.0606108792,
0.0176110081,
-0.0349517949,
0.0096416017,
-0.0218549371,
-0.0029881403,
0.0526419096,
-0.0507863835,
-0.0499846861,
0.0269919988,
-0.0196732283,
0.0165500194,
0.0414714254,
0.0678578913,
0.0684029981,
-0.0422641598,
-0.0441678464,
-0.0334691331,
-0.051656533,
-0.0097594718,
-0.0521868244,
0.0130216852,
-0.0074893357,
0.03701704,
-0.0050684721,
0.0153708067,
0.0060979337,
0.0164377913,
-0.0210359283,
-0.0010332604,
-0.0125798192,
-0.020696545,
-0.0194923449,
-0.0048817536,
-0.0203370024,
0.0328308493,
0.0081453416,
-0.0350572839,
0.0096273106,
-0.0629902631,
-0.0155291092,
-0.0348431505,
0.0658429638,
0.0364446603,
0.0043702992,
-0.035464555,
0.0119835213,
0.0168801006,
0.0091830269,
-0.0328411348,
0.0059972061,
0.0208936241,
-0.0097887451,
-0.0369080305,
0.0432026051,
0.0376886241,
-0.0084154792,
-0.0115121957,
-0.0179608483,
-0.0166559126,
0.0092862481,
-0.0387978479,
-0.0099464776,
-0.0515185446,
-0.0382944271,
-0.0515724383,
0.0128863659,
-0.0532957502,
0.0378618948,
0.0497757308,
-0.0313261338,
-0.0406056494,
0.0752810091,
-0.0657262504,
-0.0419769622,
-0.0602152944,
-0.0345874093,
0.0342534333,
0.0029815463,
0.0190487131,
-0.0108198458,
-0.0042746724,
0.0351719074,
0.0103586782,
-0.0098974109,
-0.0286260303,
0.0125143658,
-0.0054053147,
0.0045029321,
-0.0151037443,
0.0230370071,
-0.0055096503,
0.0303539839,
0.0250840094,
-0.0624312647,
-0.0238588471,
-0.0166469384,
0.0074025188,
0.0825412348,
0.0012485334,
0.0006046937,
-0.0345006287,
-0.0241810307,
0.0228764247,
0.0073935837,
-0.0319685936,
0.0262661371,
0.0822681487,
0.0496122986,
0.0079393201,
0.0017237982,
0.0043292316,
0.0096950373,
-0.0418940075,
-0.0408615395,
-0.026042264,
-6.191114218e-33,
0.0079128854,
-0.019514285,
-0.0017555762,
0.0294872373,
-0.058079768,
-0.0110958535,
-0.0425068922,
-0.0520593636,
-0.0255858991,
0.0148748029,
0.0263086744,
0.0027185879,
-0.0074331718,
0.027667826,
-0.0032909531,
0.0165467728,
0.0000202475,
0.0304251574,
-0.0033085132,
0.0408836752,
0.0461875647,
0.018161146,
0.0690088049,
-0.0872910321,
-0.0496037155,
-0.0053405417,
0.0054538678,
-0.0064043025,
0.033107277,
0.055121053,
-0.0304051246,
0.0104599968,
0.0436953567,
-0.0497357994,
-0.0334314033,
0.0318415165,
-0.0765970945,
-0.0638633892,
-0.0156484675,
-0.0393507183,
0.0025589077,
0.0011794948,
0.0329349451,
0.0015708475,
0.0318024345,
-0.061713919,
0.0799964294,
0.0032411013,
-0.0521745235,
-0.0088776937,
-0.0513611287,
0.0417962,
-0.0208403524,
0.004153687,
-0.0071787625,
0.014520579,
0.0346389897,
0.0249822531,
-0.0423017107,
0.0013217553,
-0.0739693716,
0.0074973102,
0.0330691822,
-0.0005957774,
0.0038500661,
0.1026782468,
0.0504142381,
-0.0357382447,
-0.0191479549,
-0.0449554585,
0.0462758318,
0.0420482978,
0.0798779204,
0.042424798,
-0.0013220267,
0.0171343666,
-0.0288765412,
0.062060006,
-0.0892276987,
0.0466595031,
0.0312568918,
-0.0000592339,
-0.0145005034,
-0.0203397311,
-0.021721147,
0.0510951169,
-0.0454539433,
-0.0033264989,
0.0326965116,
-0.0101761604,
0.0187817812,
0.0684947446,
0.0088559883,
-0.013450997,
0.0240376741,
0.0901568383,
0.0114371786,
0.0509078614,
-0.0092638982,
0.0014704253,
-0.0313722454,
-0.0530678779,
-0.0419149995,
0.031733349,
0.0004339899,
0.0063163009,
0.063998431,
-0.0078217927,
-0.0651034936,
-0.0011706095,
-0.0165463034,
-0.0571436062,
-0.0434713438,
0.0175387245,
0.000367201,
0.0332773104,
-0.009735046,
0.0306327753,
0.0197182465,
0.0010303363,
-0.0561835282,
-0.0221763812,
0.0140316924,
0.0545303337,
0.0086766807,
0.0316698514,
-0.0822709203,
-0.0203439314,
0.0561271347,
-0.0481265746,
-0.0169477537,
0.0400858484,
2.717e-7,
0.0350774527,
0.0101405447,
0.0509467088,
-0.0412899591,
-0.0049837548,
0.0536472015,
0.0493691266,
0.0722387806,
-0.0018387149,
0.0370227955,
0.0201627258,
0.0406841896,
0.0065966593,
0.018794436,
-0.0743637457,
0.0675482526,
-0.1114985943,
-0.0316948257,
-0.0470559448,
0.0036149861,
0.1030651703,
0.0582132414,
0.0223255232,
-0.0080323247,
-0.0050519421,
0.0032098512,
0.0386299863,
-0.0106781125,
0.0319771841,
0.0350153185,
0.0125772702,
-0.0100994734,
-0.0055193314,
-0.0055496101,
-0.0066207121,
0.0243401937,
0.0271728672,
0.0327961855,
-0.0207018014,
0.0081518106,
0.001121184,
-0.0332753919,
-0.011328618,
-0.0626583397,
0.0460191816,
-0.0685291812,
0.0200452842,
-0.0084052086,
-0.0155418133,
0.0726313666,
0.0323783681,
0.0360155031,
-0.0189939067,
0.0319910049,
0.0350375548,
0.0018826952,
-0.010506154,
-0.0805821642,
0.0151509512,
0.005048472,
-0.030344788,
-0.0160020683,
-0.0545382276,
0.0055679581,
0.0709085763,
-0.0235421509,
-0.0002515145,
2.139930528e-34,
-0.005371111,
0.0406703539,
0.0117155798,
-0.0227474626,
0.01168394,
-0.028101692,
0.0347358547,
-0.0050362758,
0.0002638287,
-0.0503835641,
0.0185940024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09270v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09270v1 | Linearized Relative Positional Encoding | 2023-07-18T13:56:43 | 2023-07-18T13:56:43 | Zhen Qin, Weixuan Sun, Kaiyue Lu, Hui Deng, Dongxu Li, Xiaodong Han, Yuchao Dai, Lingpeng Kong, Yiran Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relative positional encoding is widely used in vanilla and linear
transformers to represent positional information. However, existing encoding
methods of a vanilla transformer are not always directly applicable to a linear
transformer, because the latter requires a decomposition of the query and key
representations into separate kernel functions. Nevertheless, principles for
designing encoding methods suitable for linear transformers remain
understudied. In this work, we put together a variety of existing linear
relative positional encoding approaches under a canonical form and further
propose a family of linear relative positional encoding algorithms via unitary
transformation. Our formulation leads to a principled framework that can be
used to develop new relative positional encoding methods that preserve linear
space-time complexity. Equipped with different models, the proposed linearized
relative positional encoding (LRPE) family derives effective encoding for
various applications. Experiments show that compared with existing methods,
LRPE achieves state-of-the-art performance in language modeling, text
classification, and image classification. Meanwhile, it emphasizes a general
paradigm for designing broadly more relative positional encoding methods that
are applicable to linear transformers. The code is available at
https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/Lrpe. | [
0.0355019979,
0.0594006665,
-0.0014711715,
0.0269409753,
0.0048131482,
0.0297874007,
-0.0269109085,
0.0501625724,
-0.0358748473,
-0.0710783005,
-0.0291269291,
-0.0230200309,
0.0069193454,
-0.0389956273,
0.0279056039,
-0.063217409,
0.0085522924,
0.0250300784,
-0.023485221,
-0.0337617844,
-0.0631115511,
-0.017951645,
0.0063351905,
0.010585878,
0.0215139836,
0.0063597159,
-0.0374538861,
-0.0087795788,
0.0280545577,
0.0030785599,
-0.0298955459,
0.0023262266,
0.0579334572,
-0.0169802997,
0.0000020522,
0.0404809043,
-0.0565917753,
-0.0043584034,
0.0025058754,
-0.0089091361,
-0.0067891129,
-0.0809636638,
-0.0022350349,
0.0194547065,
-0.0210487638,
-0.0624637865,
0.0862414688,
0.0690865815,
0.0135724405,
0.0733141452,
-0.0240929946,
-0.0904575437,
-0.0044774362,
0.0091717653,
0.0305239875,
0.0028713311,
0.0225899927,
-0.0062583066,
-0.0092947632,
0.0750053599,
-0.0762349516,
0.013703269,
0.0184952542,
0.0145589169,
0.0049588899,
0.0563015006,
0.0047550416,
0.0144293038,
-0.0083757155,
0.0373911485,
-0.0676661357,
-0.0423600823,
-0.0074082604,
0.0232384279,
0.0065215407,
-0.015487615,
-0.0310146436,
0.0268162079,
0.009267794,
0.0392604992,
-0.0536943227,
0.0588002168,
0.0063258074,
-0.0234590266,
-0.0335287377,
0.0272901952,
0.0026462965,
-0.0383602157,
-0.0423510298,
-0.0109620644,
-0.0365853012,
0.029347742,
-0.0104955388,
0.005315972,
-0.0012563479,
0.0167410001,
-0.024761783,
-0.0002908482,
-0.0092417384,
-0.1199255958,
0.060701061,
0.0668574572,
-0.0093894918,
0.0101695219,
-0.0459085964,
0.1314952523,
-0.0505818985,
0.0509202965,
-0.0279989243,
0.0129415253,
-0.0315723792,
-0.0071303854,
-0.0431656726,
0.0345960557,
-0.0196792278,
-0.0346152633,
-0.0225461926,
0.0676926672,
0.0353195742,
0.0398665108,
0.0255968422,
0.0229574256,
-0.0143081304,
0.0328472368,
0.0410361998,
0.0386791006,
0.0150315063,
-0.0357790068,
-0.0648549274,
0.0126296673,
-0.0180448499,
0.0369175002,
0.0302759372,
-0.0215320252,
-0.0167571083,
0.0264250804,
-0.0161235314,
-0.0343591049,
0.0009047939,
0.0245509669,
-0.0230467636,
0.0192289334,
0.0173297878,
-0.0231527835,
0.0272431299,
0.0326435491,
-0.0110815046,
-0.0192271899,
-0.0000994603,
0.0233514737,
-0.0490691215,
0.063558042,
0.0500669405,
0.017365519,
0.0119349193,
0.0045948625,
0.0310748611,
0.01668212,
0.0451704971,
0.0531616174,
0.0226890016,
-0.0412881151,
-0.0247389451,
0.0028844499,
-0.0044808793,
-0.0602890365,
-0.0414954126,
0.0133993933,
0.0083696144,
-0.0192083921,
0.0085017476,
0.0527520031,
-0.0249985438,
-0.0765278339,
0.0459637158,
0.0263924692,
0.0202004667,
0.0351561643,
-0.010301671,
0.055270575,
-0.0274281148,
-0.0236289669,
-0.0350144319,
0.0473566465,
0.0167193711,
-0.02081085,
-0.0429647043,
0.0100251166,
-0.0092152469,
-0.0092400024,
-0.0530576669,
-0.0570719577,
-0.0185865033,
-0.0208449122,
0.0283822082,
-0.0122354822,
-0.0420416743,
0.1327258795,
-0.0201980863,
-0.0482428931,
-0.0198319182,
0.0309964735,
-0.0114402594,
-0.0137869613,
0.0078639826,
-0.0285499562,
0.0125762066,
0.0026618952,
-0.0089979088,
-0.017775815,
0.0143253552,
-0.0085989442,
-0.0069775367,
-0.018922206,
-0.0841518119,
0.032200262,
0.0018450621,
0.0314356908,
0.0402356014,
-0.0166091733,
0.0289137736,
-0.0606876425,
0.0492115654,
-0.0053641289,
0.0477675162,
-0.0190301836,
0.0283395983,
0.0261558481,
0.0001733994,
0.0399816744,
0.0042711194,
0.0134447506,
0.0786120072,
-0.0371856913,
-0.0296600461,
0.0272317678,
0.0175126754,
0.0064286478,
0.0193865411,
0.0113181639,
0.023383338,
0.0857950673,
-0.041731853,
-0.0143359415,
0.0003907374,
-0.040836934,
0.0303930286,
0.0087570623,
-0.0140300719,
-0.0150491148,
0.0010037519,
-0.0381422937,
0.0895401239,
-0.024856139,
0.0138309989,
0.0291856173,
-0.0242181215,
0.0339668952,
-0.0212465301,
-0.0398265459,
0.0438336246,
-0.0082930718,
0.0203110594,
0.0445842035,
-0.0239325147,
0.0114375725,
-0.0724994987,
-0.0592022724,
-0.0263549369,
-0.0018582082,
0.022902254,
0.0229859818,
0.0038265381,
0.0500969775,
-0.0467722341,
-0.0566105023,
-0.0217240248,
-0.0252523776,
-0.0175949931,
0.023049606,
-0.0060670604,
-0.0297504012,
0.0267990939,
-0.0134993503,
-0.0100332545,
0.0701495409,
-0.0450826809,
-0.0270143636,
-0.0698681548,
0.0003354695,
0.0087088821,
0.0247462597,
-0.0115625905,
-0.0462102741,
-0.0300421529,
-0.0083776712,
-0.0432706624,
0.026710555,
0.0245748181,
0.0355635844,
0.0465618186,
0.0421753712,
-0.0193505157,
0.0061677629,
-0.0699374229,
-0.0137860393,
-0.0123277698,
-0.0070861448,
-0.0263392292,
0.021440383,
0.0070199878,
0.0145544372,
-0.0707381442,
-0.0158701167,
-0.0005041261,
0.0103412485,
-0.0505562797,
-0.0110929506,
-0.0031676299,
0.0049890531,
-0.0327513516,
0.0047956542,
-0.0047524031,
-0.0324373357,
0.0070205471,
-0.0144086778,
-0.003470622,
-0.043036662,
0.0517569222,
0.007563442,
0.0596987717,
-0.047272291,
-0.0305837225,
-0.0345119908,
0.0189347062,
-0.0162276365,
-0.040242862,
0.0138642751,
0.0249167383,
0.0171170104,
-0.0435860567,
-0.0634403452,
-0.0588361621,
-0.0410126522,
0.0804995075,
-0.0017673055,
-0.0181060173,
-0.0793742612,
-0.0263799373,
0.0682283938,
-0.0003830649,
0.0100250095,
0.0097262599,
-0.004049364,
-0.013051752,
0.0289178435,
0.002620494,
0.0508002341,
-0.020313777,
0.0165565796,
-0.0464164913,
0.0892891884,
0.0317035802,
-0.006562951,
-0.050283432,
0.0422809534,
0.0483841412,
0.0103049921,
-0.0347992443,
-0.0054425434,
-0.0323696621,
0.0073812162,
-0.0208621044,
0.105225645,
0.0462110452,
-0.066741012,
-0.0064360849,
0.029371446,
0.0092769396,
0.010576874,
0.0399820134,
-0.0540941581,
0.0189037491,
-0.0314403251,
0.0150394663,
0.0084605133,
-0.0045650322,
-0.0028929142,
-0.052957423,
0.0180497207,
0.0261694249,
-0.0082105156,
-0.0734955072,
-0.0282850154,
-0.0067297858,
0.0241538491,
-0.0138140162,
0.021488646,
-0.0135691604,
-0.0276414547,
0.0490761921,
-0.0323795639,
-0.0510252826,
-0.0306823365,
0.003569073,
-0.0201812405,
-0.0130557651,
0.0553740934,
0.0075699263,
-0.0647488832,
-0.0773118436,
-0.0040036542,
-0.0089130327,
-0.0086400183,
0.0064327721,
0.0043690223,
-0.0432807766,
0.0384791605,
-0.0024375524,
-0.0705188662,
-0.0165931266,
-0.0988590941,
0.0665927455,
-0.045432169,
0.0385511704,
-0.0085808327,
-0.0274972972,
-0.018320024,
0.0310571119,
-0.0227438416,
0.0099244928,
-0.0212643836,
0.0110618901,
0.0362874083,
0.0401219167,
-0.0354965478,
-0.0044312989,
-0.0216749124,
-0.0584920198,
-0.0557192825,
0.0265199263,
-0.0241434518,
0.0255489573,
-0.0052455836,
-0.0320834182,
0.0265432559,
-0.0403400324,
-0.1059945598,
-0.045966614,
-0.0069412924,
0.020166209,
0.0110516706,
-0.0027769909,
0.0554128997,
-0.0218504313,
-0.0376028381,
-0.0697930604,
-0.0369772166,
-0.0207624659,
0.03328095,
0.0400541909,
0.0130451396,
-0.0008121302,
-0.0010008862,
-0.0273275077,
0.0611202046,
0.023551207,
0.0298702586,
0.0482377224,
0.0424728505,
-0.0301590879,
0.0039243647,
0.0071926494,
-0.0610953346,
0.0068296026,
-0.0286165178,
-0.0000463225,
-0.0314867087,
-0.0169543996,
0.0329437815,
-0.027674824,
0.0659845173,
0.0123542026,
0.0152414218,
0.0207576714,
0.0290170219,
-0.0408145003,
-0.0065475181,
-0.0359474383,
-0.0006396712,
0.0403512195,
0.0351619162,
0.0024191029,
0.0257584285,
0.0519353002,
-0.0090210363,
0.0277357101,
0.00402265,
-0.0182848144,
-0.0210936815,
-0.0212646835,
0.0425476357,
-0.0222873297,
0.0072908173,
0.038494397,
0.0416702107,
-0.0285862796,
0.0485677719,
0.0311674159,
0.0073991907,
-0.0551302098,
0.0565852597,
-0.0683752,
0.001553964,
-0.0130095761,
-0.0345581919,
0.0330991969,
-0.0282354765,
0.0306101535,
-0.0522803888,
0.0155080017,
0.0070998287,
0.0211600866,
0.0249593295,
-0.0454311259,
0.0386917293,
0.0115976594,
0.0032276148,
0.0207290221,
0.052021049,
-0.0284679867,
-0.0010282017,
-0.0804595873,
-0.0380184762,
-0.0218519457,
-0.0040013483,
0.0166420694,
-0.026537884,
0.000759862,
-0.017412398,
-0.0386304297,
-0.0205492619,
0.0461552814,
-0.0338073038,
0.0072671822,
-0.034837231,
0.0261140261,
0.0179043468,
0.0345912687,
0.0187602602,
-0.0485455208,
-0.0565974712,
0.0105984434,
-0.0103641544,
-0.0158283506,
-5.862767789e-33,
-0.0054186936,
-0.0385384969,
-0.0275016874,
0.0447711907,
-0.0367664099,
0.0302551202,
0.031906236,
-0.008937004,
0.0068942346,
-0.0426832326,
0.006037517,
0.0075089512,
0.0076031261,
0.0066841422,
-0.0159135312,
-0.0254598875,
0.0218911804,
-0.0039986768,
-0.0101909172,
-0.0013330914,
0.0675801188,
0.0120507786,
0.0513827242,
-0.063197732,
-0.0197320562,
0.0174329951,
0.0134502826,
0.0260431152,
0.017019894,
0.050733421,
-0.01557214,
0.0080348272,
0.0145679014,
-0.0202153642,
0.0000028213,
0.0395358652,
-0.0655474812,
-0.0138212554,
-0.0314222649,
0.0930416882,
0.0352986827,
0.0048223804,
0.0243580882,
-0.012480353,
-0.0079842871,
-0.0557576008,
-0.0089693265,
-0.0179116931,
-0.0363021381,
-0.0245058909,
0.0172491521,
0.0108899679,
0.0022619641,
0.0306769907,
0.0739421248,
0.0551807806,
0.0294790845,
-0.017121831,
-0.0593577288,
-0.0026626447,
-0.0302461553,
0.0311244745,
0.0098082814,
-0.0033917262,
-0.017994456,
0.0403514951,
0.0859288499,
-0.0556461997,
-0.0515167005,
-0.0038053298,
-0.0162269156,
0.0012870056,
0.0287196133,
0.0091933636,
0.0410368778,
-0.0070800628,
-0.021710299,
0.0325876288,
-0.0252067503,
0.0317750312,
0.0337955877,
0.0679715648,
-0.0470283702,
-0.039520137,
-0.0053409622,
0.0067396769,
-0.0193296783,
-0.0321415626,
0.024366634,
0.0102956863,
-0.0427733473,
0.0290036555,
0.0287060905,
-0.0436054617,
-0.00014756,
0.000332757,
0.0137506118,
0.0696301311,
-0.0323384441,
-0.0257958621,
0.0458302982,
-0.0429922305,
0.0370480865,
-0.0683408305,
0.0141387004,
0.0010948732,
0.0209590979,
0.0986536518,
-0.0330018438,
-0.015095477,
-0.0009662212,
-0.056089785,
-0.0218241662,
0.0601411872,
0.0334892944,
0.0285058226,
0.0156198377,
0.0411549024,
0.0136408508,
0.0474574566,
0.0183974952,
-0.014710092,
0.033280883,
0.0027720365,
-0.0064465231,
0.0077493801,
-0.0098134857,
0.0684484467,
0.0158845354,
-0.0730654001,
-0.0154577633,
0.0092263417,
2.855e-7,
0.0635929704,
0.0310602542,
0.0844250992,
0.0141335391,
0.0189440399,
0.0113920784,
0.0102455942,
0.0752118751,
-0.0124031985,
0.0164800137,
0.0251432452,
-0.0276745427,
0.0045130537,
-0.0232069008,
-0.0637973547,
-0.0101282978,
-0.0592993125,
-0.0340909176,
-0.0013407652,
0.057324633,
0.0998547003,
0.0913582593,
-0.0075732851,
-0.0046523903,
-0.0194567069,
0.016387796,
0.0764669627,
-0.0219419766,
0.0547730215,
-0.0553137027,
0.0113886893,
-0.0226376466,
0.0110686533,
-0.0216139518,
-0.0218819007,
0.0341223888,
0.0152418604,
0.0631797686,
-0.0119379908,
-0.0463510007,
-0.011629588,
0.0047235391,
-0.0360867716,
-0.0314217247,
0.0431577191,
-0.0418113582,
0.0024043906,
0.0163820032,
-0.0407157317,
0.032618776,
-0.0181541331,
0.0252184197,
0.0159923695,
0.0189473722,
0.0253334213,
-0.021492729,
0.0202303343,
-0.0921425894,
-0.0254141353,
-0.0361852534,
-0.0286205076,
0.0373158827,
-0.0006770415,
-0.0165003389,
0.0310631674,
0.0382348485,
-0.0588561259,
2.831211205e-34,
-0.0057321177,
0.015332995,
-0.001228691,
0.0385617502,
-0.0268199127,
-0.0396135226,
0.015886765,
0.019758191,
0.0101956809,
-0.0671747625,
-0.0175679382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09255v1 | Text vectorization via transformer-based language models and n-gram perplexities | 2023-07-18T13:38:39 | 2023-07-18T13:38:39 | Mihailo Škorić | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 | As the probability (and thus perplexity) of a text is calculated based on the
product of the probabilities of individual tokens, it may happen that one
unlikely token significantly reduces the probability (i.e., increase the
perplexity) of some otherwise highly probable input, while potentially
representing a simple typographical error. Also, given that perplexity is a
scalar value that refers to the entire input, information about the probability
distribution within it is lost in the calculation (a relatively good text that
has one unlikely token and another text in which each token is equally likely
they can have the same perplexity value), especially for longer texts. As an
alternative to scalar perplexity this research proposes a simple algorithm used
to calculate vector values based on n-gram perplexities within the input. Such
representations consider the previously mentioned aspects, and instead of a
unique value, the relative perplexity of each text token is calculated, and
these values are combined into a single vector representing the input. | [
0.0228045024,
0.0131534077,
-0.0231578071,
0.0303874984,
-0.0644322261,
0.0251129642,
-0.0143257808,
0.0334469341,
-0.0557899699,
-0.0496696308,
0.046394676,
-0.0437897444,
0.0370563604,
-0.0060428451,
0.0150782429,
-0.0525820293,
0.0121235466,
-0.0187670048,
-0.014675823,
0.0260192584,
0.0209748261,
0.007487833,
0.0009618087,
0.0403263606,
-0.0155306719,
0.0076205749,
-0.0018142472,
0.0242814869,
0.0043893717,
-0.0091374191,
-0.0468552895,
0.0461398251,
-0.0133691914,
0.02209449,
0.0000019583,
-0.0102536939,
-0.0512302555,
0.0058271633,
0.054587476,
0.0212410558,
0.0807017982,
-0.023802951,
-0.0477815717,
0.0261298623,
-0.0029054219,
-0.0182960629,
0.0673423633,
0.0692609921,
0.0153695131,
0.0505895913,
-0.034232486,
-0.0458116904,
0.0334413201,
0.0186400041,
0.0246685334,
-0.0292460211,
0.0238643009,
0.0077317222,
-0.0379149988,
0.028324509,
-0.0193565339,
0.0168390684,
-0.0263212454,
-0.0240274556,
-0.0273148958,
0.0285720173,
0.0286245681,
0.0010522925,
-0.0172176398,
0.0089391479,
-0.0687098652,
-0.0367613509,
0.026891591,
-0.0035222359,
-0.0090655657,
0.006494829,
-0.0579832755,
0.001438293,
-0.0194148161,
0.0217781495,
0.0233209543,
0.0161351766,
-0.0075215288,
-0.0385315493,
-0.0778324604,
0.029601818,
0.0284582898,
-0.036179442,
-0.056872692,
-0.0241009332,
-0.0393814072,
-0.0307741202,
0.0701499283,
0.0057017915,
0.0399685688,
0.0220933259,
-0.0404070243,
-0.1423140168,
0.0200658683,
-0.0956849828,
0.0424824059,
0.0159722865,
0.0137034981,
0.0377813429,
-0.0328259654,
0.0546101034,
-0.0306276176,
0.0155043155,
-0.0452456661,
0.0341273658,
-0.0301724877,
-0.010775636,
-0.0418791845,
0.0290568322,
-0.0039590485,
-0.0352202281,
-0.0155610926,
0.0212721005,
0.0499875546,
-0.0276105478,
0.0168915112,
-0.031453196,
-0.0270677358,
-0.0229123197,
0.0202217139,
0.0165796019,
0.0058972142,
-0.0183919854,
-0.0352216884,
-0.0228083767,
0.0099389097,
0.0305001233,
0.0512418784,
-0.0333844535,
-0.0204936396,
0.0263820048,
-0.0241125375,
-0.0216574762,
0.0045313262,
-0.0041986667,
-0.032618314,
-0.0047029601,
-0.0327680111,
-0.0746579915,
-0.0010311513,
0.0331172235,
0.0097754924,
-0.0059834467,
0.0062720273,
0.0192780737,
-0.0439142399,
0.0567946248,
0.0246412661,
0.0153643992,
0.0417339876,
-0.0129055548,
0.0302195456,
0.0415676534,
0.0228444282,
0.0105763851,
0.0257936586,
-0.0466419496,
0.0323482081,
0.0476472005,
-0.0095817698,
-0.0121731684,
-0.0219774488,
-0.0390435047,
0.023295274,
-0.0369902477,
0.0242243465,
0.1153900698,
-0.0425997786,
0.0207597557,
0.0363665335,
0.0713212639,
0.0222408921,
0.0428961851,
0.0114018908,
0.0291805714,
-0.0107060764,
0.0454600565,
0.0116161192,
-0.0157163758,
-0.0136165386,
0.0082097249,
0.0263415575,
0.0393703505,
-0.011941582,
-0.0218515992,
0.0155719928,
-0.0485086143,
0.0969159603,
-0.0703990683,
0.0953094363,
0.0085870828,
-0.0826532692,
0.0370769352,
-0.02402707,
-0.0774977356,
0.0141766937,
-0.0382827744,
-0.0061530424,
0.0352224819,
0.1044381037,
0.0057891659,
0.0221495889,
0.0133862123,
-0.0280455146,
0.0328838527,
-0.0024277465,
0.0253900904,
-0.0124236178,
-0.0603933483,
0.0226282626,
0.0357402042,
0.0296122376,
0.0124409813,
-0.0192109942,
0.0111000035,
0.0182230305,
-0.0394081958,
0.0004599933,
0.0247763246,
0.0086275833,
0.0284046307,
-0.008491151,
-0.0150735378,
-0.0008483323,
0.0324039087,
-0.0152409393,
0.0507795028,
0.0298487935,
-0.0829210505,
-0.0127561269,
0.018700622,
0.0051735332,
-0.0185798425,
0.0521445796,
-0.0373950079,
0.0355992429,
0.0191560667,
0.0179037489,
-0.0173064247,
0.0279427208,
-0.092264615,
0.0349230543,
-0.040087238,
0.0722321793,
-0.0450913124,
0.0052008322,
-0.0420383625,
0.0590834729,
0.0167384297,
0.0609972402,
-0.0378539227,
-0.0247987602,
0.0572752319,
-0.0032864816,
-0.0252483524,
-0.0407259203,
-0.0255597215,
0.0029098797,
0.0274770223,
-0.015459355,
0.0389576592,
-0.0985885039,
-0.063587822,
-0.053194616,
-0.0056084977,
0.0284557678,
0.0093045738,
0.0253005475,
0.0310320128,
-0.0034137673,
-0.0149977347,
-0.0054902956,
0.0110802185,
-0.0041477587,
0.0410845093,
-0.0181235578,
-0.0475255102,
-0.0061626169,
-0.0213631447,
-0.0248061474,
0.067981571,
0.029397957,
-0.0264868755,
-0.114637658,
0.0559721403,
-0.0171047132,
0.004909033,
-0.0052782884,
-0.0491475463,
-0.020695515,
-0.0405780748,
0.073200129,
0.0221800711,
0.0223360769,
0.0081426864,
0.0139371995,
-0.0204527657,
-0.0059659076,
-0.0219771117,
-0.0382750034,
0.0306478925,
-0.0305150189,
-0.0447941534,
0.0216498915,
0.0106562739,
0.0144085223,
0.0162384864,
-0.0557152703,
0.0142279491,
-0.0246804617,
-0.0020637689,
0.0231614672,
-0.0192279872,
-0.0206359811,
0.046302475,
-0.0008533669,
-0.0230943915,
0.0512662753,
-0.0469452292,
0.0127739208,
-0.1111814007,
0.0157716908,
-0.0338470973,
0.0350739099,
-0.0192830563,
0.0441690832,
-0.0599615388,
-0.0538354069,
-0.0149652027,
0.0113511477,
-0.0008347359,
-0.0647128299,
0.0597028546,
-0.0061219851,
0.0167691931,
0.0027171914,
-0.0057605929,
-0.0070942836,
-0.0495197773,
-0.0038927989,
-0.0303384792,
0.0956519619,
-0.0216790978,
-0.0348383002,
0.1090505421,
0.018855609,
0.0171398949,
-0.0311221909,
-0.0002867892,
-0.0084699644,
0.0644722581,
0.0063705714,
-0.0317333564,
-0.0195520334,
-0.0061554145,
-0.0147614721,
0.0492065139,
0.025892619,
0.0009518611,
0.0075200675,
-0.0326810479,
0.01716993,
-0.0073097092,
-0.0408315472,
-0.0002235606,
-0.0065205274,
-0.0040541147,
-0.0433057882,
0.095819816,
0.0557803884,
-0.0531115457,
-0.0041967193,
-0.0324208923,
-0.0203909483,
-0.0319255404,
0.0525841266,
-0.039846763,
0.0341246948,
-0.0069981865,
-0.0347060561,
0.0152733987,
-0.0065290765,
0.0081678629,
-0.0637788549,
0.05056924,
0.0173156727,
-0.0048816269,
-0.0906349272,
-0.0434101671,
-0.0112718958,
0.0209696032,
-0.0059788255,
0.0291046724,
0.0122822141,
0.0030627581,
0.0213978477,
-0.0447442643,
-0.0259085428,
-0.04730298,
-0.0243424643,
-0.0167269185,
0.0627228245,
0.0260123238,
-0.0384248309,
-0.0911765993,
-0.0404095165,
-0.021684736,
0.0119743329,
-0.0122186719,
0.0148192374,
0.0425586812,
-0.0095119588,
-0.0374282598,
-0.0207016356,
0.0011113657,
-0.0423327088,
-0.025833996,
0.0140883876,
-0.0235330667,
-0.0096387491,
-0.0105866119,
0.0029209447,
-0.0019335391,
0.0373223759,
0.0052982564,
-0.0448954068,
-0.0413065478,
-0.0470526367,
0.0761809498,
-0.0567842163,
-0.019981714,
-0.0254553799,
0.0349665955,
-0.0944038555,
-0.0594023541,
0.0595109984,
0.0085513191,
0.0826275349,
0.0214639083,
0.0318224579,
0.0508055054,
0.0062418263,
-0.0412064865,
-0.062499471,
0.0226075985,
0.0261189137,
-0.0582262911,
0.0402443931,
0.0336163715,
0.0033179752,
-0.0144524425,
-0.0115718292,
-0.0610161833,
-0.0368837081,
0.0143573238,
0.0151925515,
0.0267302673,
-0.0212503392,
-0.0267597251,
-0.0448043421,
0.0328088589,
0.0432973094,
0.0005270361,
0.0331750326,
-0.0258380957,
0.0112709627,
-0.0148210023,
0.0013274315,
-0.0300030448,
-0.0094999429,
-0.0130665964,
0.0529950894,
-0.0362371653,
-0.0118231308,
0.012113261,
0.0002280125,
0.04086392,
-0.0063015521,
0.0436391905,
0.0141575569,
0.0145146772,
-0.0559412912,
0.000309485,
-0.0255900621,
0.0119467452,
0.0326524787,
-0.0074051078,
-0.0208664741,
-0.0149022704,
-0.0507942028,
0.0322288536,
0.0101418998,
0.0126176476,
-0.0412159972,
-0.0352259129,
0.0222698506,
-0.0144850276,
0.003177379,
-0.0470237695,
0.000923333,
0.0094973482,
-0.0254654214,
0.0056721293,
0.0117776562,
-0.0330531672,
-0.0435452126,
0.04968483,
-0.0311575066,
0.0206696559,
-0.0261428226,
-0.0242997687,
0.0128674768,
0.0292175338,
0.0751402378,
-0.026461836,
0.0074526039,
-0.036103867,
0.0148997968,
0.0475822315,
-0.0014206803,
0.0145157706,
0.0008791497,
0.0015804144,
-0.0350078829,
0.0838255659,
-0.0515305214,
-0.0217226855,
0.0266310722,
-0.036221303,
-0.0206515323,
0.0315443948,
0.0009779934,
0.0528072752,
-0.0270338599,
-0.0232080221,
-0.0375604369,
-0.0243718382,
0.0430500992,
0.0315650105,
0.010366152,
-0.015732538,
-0.0111960936,
0.0688275918,
-0.0080263298,
0.0068304492,
-0.0158821084,
0.0114210639,
-0.0234898627,
-0.0440885015,
-0.0127590122,
-5.77684356e-33,
0.0061487234,
-0.0355170555,
-0.0592427477,
0.0397958755,
0.0167779159,
-0.0191691797,
-0.0121962801,
0.025547469,
0.0330777876,
-0.0075212391,
-0.0102990279,
-0.004837628,
0.0261387136,
0.0044336179,
-0.0118860826,
0.0235168077,
0.0232534464,
-0.0153074851,
-0.0045339293,
0.0128184259,
-0.0119699519,
0.0399053767,
0.0433655381,
-0.1154147312,
-0.0048757764,
-0.03487188,
-0.0118638556,
0.0056438469,
0.0689899996,
0.056894999,
-0.0030750134,
0.0129882274,
0.0180932991,
-0.0387965925,
-0.0144733163,
0.0427934118,
-0.010442066,
-0.0251798984,
0.0271751955,
0.0330668353,
0.0099517014,
-0.0261374228,
0.0074330284,
-0.0268972982,
-0.026784109,
0.0284501947,
0.0257836692,
-0.0121123474,
-0.028698016,
-0.0104985218,
-0.0262703281,
0.0424599834,
-0.0007320982,
-0.014780934,
0.054092057,
-0.0290548783,
-0.0056965956,
0.0285347179,
-0.0332174264,
0.0452608429,
0.0127381878,
0.0411120541,
0.034095861,
0.0046955063,
0.0038187897,
0.028433051,
0.0563201532,
-0.0086790714,
-0.0488109849,
-0.0098048626,
0.0270462465,
-0.0153235029,
0.0468124151,
0.0438571684,
0.0555273816,
0.0099069672,
-0.032892663,
0.0524727628,
0.0103719234,
-0.0019026991,
0.0653639883,
0.0228850134,
-0.0678690299,
-0.0506365746,
0.0020820913,
-0.0184337962,
-0.0315574668,
-0.0500977039,
-0.0181185454,
0.0020249651,
-0.0350413732,
0.0241767596,
0.0187255368,
-0.0305117313,
-0.0644877851,
0.0158746708,
0.0009859089,
0.0737186223,
-0.0516317673,
0.0014793293,
0.0295507852,
-0.0360357799,
0.0480983146,
0.0257733297,
-0.0047085918,
-0.0081614731,
-0.0086036371,
0.0151087055,
-0.093061462,
-0.0175639596,
0.0220391843,
-0.0297984499,
0.0110835945,
0.0432548188,
0.0045927134,
-0.0027410248,
0.0204875153,
-0.0082146786,
0.0586805381,
-0.0174458362,
-0.0072944523,
0.0068656541,
0.0133959269,
0.010800763,
-0.0372768231,
-0.0337282717,
-0.0121303704,
0.020906318,
0.0526955277,
-0.0319599472,
-0.0307264216,
0.0424600132,
2.646e-7,
0.0779385343,
0.0912889317,
0.0461874306,
-0.0362685844,
0.0413656496,
0.0234523416,
-0.016310757,
0.0238254499,
-0.0058244034,
0.0396631695,
0.0178488456,
-0.0180177148,
0.0171534959,
0.0109529253,
-0.0601380281,
0.0224070698,
-0.0387277491,
0.0283720028,
-0.0297561381,
0.0177693423,
0.0636961088,
0.0915719196,
-0.0063856975,
0.0136149386,
-0.0013401053,
-0.0503621176,
0.0229542293,
-0.0120383603,
0.0011296314,
0.0160598941,
0.0225793999,
-0.0185153317,
0.0172380302,
0.0433968082,
0.0023463669,
0.0080489647,
0.0549068898,
0.05002065,
-0.0422450937,
0.0060931896,
0.0126321251,
-0.0295281783,
-0.011264151,
-0.0813822821,
0.0215742346,
-0.003842525,
-0.028310189,
-0.0129896002,
-0.0533696823,
0.0332542658,
0.0021736957,
0.0210449137,
-0.0586359315,
0.034870103,
0.0447056033,
0.0110367956,
0.0046393988,
-0.0439973511,
-0.0137505438,
-0.0417541899,
-0.0148048382,
-0.0494517274,
-0.025953237,
0.029339416,
0.0654385835,
-0.0268407688,
0.0401157923,
2.75989107e-34,
0.0436497182,
-0.0070490395,
-0.0318914838,
0.0391178988,
0.0063516372,
-0.0167330932,
0.0455536097,
0.033673387,
-0.0252422299,
-0.1011881381,
-0.0132338163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09254v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09254v1 | PAC Neural Prediction Set Learning to Quantify the Uncertainty of Generative Language Models | 2023-07-18T13:36:24 | 2023-07-18T13:36:24 | Sangdon Park, Taesoo Kim | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Uncertainty learning and quantification of models are crucial tasks to
enhance the trustworthiness of the models. Importantly, the recent surge of
generative language models (GLMs) emphasizes the need for reliable uncertainty
quantification due to the concerns on generating hallucinated facts. In this
paper, we propose to learn neural prediction set models that comes with the
probably approximately correct (PAC) guarantee for quantifying the uncertainty
of GLMs. Unlike existing prediction set models, which are parameterized by a
scalar value, we propose to parameterize prediction sets via neural networks,
which achieves more precise uncertainty quantification but still satisfies the
PAC guarantee. We demonstrate the efficacy of our method on four types of
language datasets and six types of models by showing that our method improves
the quantified uncertainty by $63\%$ on average, compared to a standard
baseline method. | [
0.0022252058,
0.1615832299,
-0.0039835745,
0.0059626214,
-0.0199110489,
0.0005321996,
-0.0135575561,
-0.0238040499,
-0.061744079,
0.0234048571,
0.0343604013,
-0.1239278242,
0.0148750972,
0.0141610447,
0.0624349155,
-0.0381707624,
0.0094531961,
-0.0209685564,
0.0348399244,
-0.0233974215,
-0.0116784349,
-0.0099577093,
0.011013384,
0.0440337807,
-0.043974977,
-0.0269939378,
0.0214309134,
-0.0064150239,
0.0199075099,
0.0020178093,
0.0361884125,
0.0693637505,
-0.0148266042,
0.026007358,
0.0000018212,
-0.029737832,
-0.0185426213,
-0.0144365178,
-0.0256410576,
0.0055680694,
0.0195991267,
0.0432025529,
-0.0404224098,
0.0247945562,
-0.0235096272,
-0.0433324091,
0.0697503313,
-0.0000810296,
0.008583989,
0.0519777462,
0.0015087115,
-0.0144567685,
0.0453949645,
-0.0264199618,
0.0347133353,
-0.0345146246,
0.0156925805,
-0.0048206709,
-0.0433140136,
0.0020230976,
-0.0128364963,
0.0461527333,
0.0134445978,
0.0115072187,
-0.0230537653,
0.0230133366,
-0.0112154987,
-0.048407454,
0.0189063307,
0.0039218608,
-0.0705694705,
-0.0644767657,
-0.0533605665,
-0.0306961425,
0.0044186558,
0.0304209758,
-0.0138426861,
0.0294282995,
-0.0139763821,
0.0520420447,
-0.0072855125,
0.0279122684,
0.051593978,
-0.0259348266,
-0.0142186033,
0.0748186633,
0.0076845149,
-0.0004754586,
-0.0209829397,
-0.0107155461,
-0.0527625233,
-0.0123041291,
-0.0207822304,
-0.0079949247,
0.0066795177,
0.0359862968,
-0.0294583403,
-0.0014165338,
0.023252992,
-0.0329937786,
0.0193376467,
0.0018879839,
-0.0122971339,
0.0018304561,
0.0022095484,
0.0540905967,
0.0393245183,
0.0031646292,
-0.0179985948,
-0.0228899233,
-0.0069294334,
0.0037326473,
-0.0257594232,
-0.0092789317,
0.0076117422,
0.0133874426,
-0.0606660396,
-0.0261435211,
-0.0445365608,
0.0770094767,
0.0335081778,
0.028988272,
-0.02292284,
-0.0472451746,
-0.0167160649,
-0.0060104188,
-0.0169645995,
0.0176617038,
0.0097480835,
-0.0967150405,
0.0079715131,
0.0013327226,
0.0072779064,
0.0200412534,
0.0013018235,
0.0589141324,
0.0160163548,
-0.0181525797,
-0.046944011,
-0.0010451883,
-0.0267712176,
-0.0429877862,
-0.0162889473,
-0.0703571886,
0.0053538331,
-0.0138663212,
-0.0006823469,
-0.090655908,
0.0117582139,
0.0121344291,
-0.0057614483,
0.0978715494,
-0.0032922199,
0.0239326693,
0.0161788724,
-0.0002715199,
-0.0278248135,
0.0684915185,
0.0522678159,
0.0516758002,
0.0522512868,
0.0284303278,
0.0422990434,
0.0189410932,
0.0479606763,
-0.0207728967,
-0.0371173806,
-0.0285436735,
0.00008684,
0.0125085358,
-0.004818304,
0.0765266791,
-0.0328162163,
-0.0391885154,
0.1034463719,
0.0008121795,
0.0022737177,
0.0264272057,
0.0459247045,
-0.034019012,
0.01831761,
-0.0090821823,
-0.0321506262,
-0.0065722279,
-0.0070412932,
0.0438626371,
0.0012454349,
0.0245237704,
-0.0282790791,
-0.0921870396,
-0.0404432118,
-0.0300920643,
-0.0208851323,
-0.0060482631,
0.0347976014,
0.0013681076,
-0.0361251347,
0.0384770297,
0.0290164426,
-0.0471034348,
0.0273252539,
-0.0426399447,
0.0575943999,
0.03338819,
0.0050816191,
-0.0176828429,
-0.0387537628,
-0.0258792732,
0.0007390702,
-0.0002941334,
0.0178008657,
-0.0086977547,
0.0338108391,
-0.0360313207,
0.000575308,
0.0027206675,
0.0481011793,
0.0075197192,
0.0400628559,
0.009127873,
-0.0035645405,
-0.0510647483,
-0.0326114856,
0.0164716262,
-0.0253737047,
-0.049716495,
0.0266831722,
-0.0034254789,
0.0336480066,
-0.006304719,
-0.028975876,
0.0341242775,
0.0128900409,
0.0090196226,
-0.0391621776,
-0.0037079591,
-0.0166865159,
0.02506084,
0.0517140627,
-0.0169888549,
0.0144410757,
-0.0259106979,
-0.0410446376,
-0.0109642269,
0.01042102,
-0.0281323567,
0.0093669239,
-0.0511234403,
0.0199881624,
-0.017133262,
0.0250123292,
-0.0219530612,
0.0380058736,
-0.04942628,
0.0388763063,
0.0027210941,
0.0575957559,
0.0205954555,
0.0045466991,
-0.0460568704,
-0.0082389889,
-0.029094046,
0.0271757822,
0.0344792232,
0.0042670132,
-0.0080547705,
-0.0193583705,
-0.0226086862,
-0.0205913801,
-0.0141775049,
-0.0054127225,
0.019185584,
-0.0379323885,
-0.0085322494,
0.0122824963,
-0.0521393716,
-0.0117611364,
-0.0148907462,
-0.0205102973,
0.0290002637,
-0.0020285749,
0.0049229478,
-0.0447515398,
-0.0151911564,
0.0108964378,
0.072346054,
0.0038338362,
0.0025691711,
-0.08048255,
0.0578158014,
-0.0492334217,
0.0208987575,
-0.0046250154,
-0.0524085872,
0.0100302743,
-0.033494316,
-0.0280293282,
0.0331212059,
0.0064962953,
-0.010589133,
0.0727592856,
0.0003173665,
-0.0175490566,
-0.0101865334,
-0.079913497,
-0.0562171414,
0.0238661095,
-0.0353510864,
-0.0290891025,
0.0408002064,
0.0284674615,
-0.0469944403,
-0.0601705275,
0.0569730699,
-0.0160084479,
-0.0001013008,
-0.0044737281,
0.0075900755,
-0.0084427977,
0.0680083856,
-0.031254705,
-0.0754443333,
0.0725673214,
-0.0557380244,
0.019557599,
0.0049672467,
0.0021216082,
0.0201156791,
0.0075204978,
0.0276396051,
0.023900006,
0.024659887,
0.0077681039,
-0.0620543398,
0.001392513,
0.0550999679,
-0.0421757922,
-0.0114661222,
-0.0526138432,
-0.0008776426,
0.023319643,
-0.0084386431,
-0.0582621135,
-0.0033522511,
0.0174398515,
0.0283865444,
0.0370122381,
-0.0578595102,
0.0294798836,
0.0066282591,
-0.0500879101,
0.0377366729,
-0.0264511444,
-0.0117915478,
-0.0160851423,
-0.0038321754,
0.0246701669,
-0.03191467,
0.085780032,
0.0012009637,
-0.033467181,
0.015673127,
0.0195530429,
0.0290386621,
-0.0632776022,
-0.0043752966,
0.0207310319,
0.0085642673,
0.0107592372,
0.0602551959,
0.0346757993,
0.0030092795,
-0.0410346128,
0.1233252063,
0.0110398429,
-0.0054946207,
0.0057131653,
-0.0051759277,
0.0362163223,
0.0117168669,
-0.001429987,
-0.0518854819,
0.006922313,
0.0061129178,
0.0281406511,
-0.0107281534,
-0.0278509352,
-0.0122681642,
-0.1067244709,
0.0287000593,
0.025423592,
-0.0266526416,
-0.0234534554,
-0.0183973145,
-0.000416487,
-0.0574969761,
0.0463285372,
-0.012011297,
0.0203386173,
0.0110751381,
0.0293061715,
0.0001700647,
-0.0751416013,
-0.007874989,
-0.0520932525,
0.0750268251,
0.0156763401,
0.0201266576,
-0.0099760676,
-0.0126701547,
-0.0009953061,
-0.0216046274,
-0.0515703633,
0.0514842123,
0.0448000394,
0.0270990301,
-0.0133535219,
0.0463535972,
0.0343731456,
-0.0319237635,
-0.0050069289,
-0.03111922,
0.0427244119,
0.005424052,
-0.0429970063,
0.0045392402,
-0.0000022965,
0.0342051685,
0.0522165075,
0.0200701747,
-0.0108280936,
0.0029562959,
-0.0626870245,
0.0617512241,
-0.0096519496,
0.0213191733,
0.032251291,
0.0289059691,
-0.0442584418,
-0.0844963416,
-0.0130532114,
-0.0197787732,
0.0153778689,
-0.0108289998,
-0.0070193894,
0.0824495628,
-0.0115341647,
-0.0463460051,
0.0023898729,
0.0116483774,
0.0158582591,
-0.0055731474,
0.00407751,
0.0494430363,
-0.002877437,
-0.0269316677,
0.0454471707,
-0.1229515225,
-0.100054875,
-0.0016880037,
0.0723846555,
0.0278736837,
0.0204138737,
-0.0393319726,
-0.1061306298,
0.0778424367,
0.0620009229,
0.0058281077,
-0.0255392324,
0.0325470455,
0.0280027594,
-0.0117120948,
0.0244249161,
-0.0285277907,
0.0236681774,
-0.0001547836,
0.0164438635,
-0.026914712,
-0.0619636402,
0.0189033337,
-0.0083645768,
0.0401559249,
-0.0484746508,
0.007851758,
-0.0571898147,
-0.0038758675,
-0.0116879139,
-0.0083853602,
-0.0301138703,
0.0234745108,
0.0355900265,
-0.0185487289,
-0.0419222377,
-0.0384875387,
0.0263975468,
0.0323174112,
-0.0107414834,
-0.0676985458,
0.0144997742,
0.0214972291,
0.0174351037,
-0.0031042469,
-0.0074227899,
0.0354439765,
-0.0310167689,
0.0083907042,
0.0329163224,
-0.0085193496,
0.0377574377,
0.0293848794,
-0.0136721507,
-0.005258244,
-0.0422360934,
-0.0992408544,
-0.0997380763,
0.0578350425,
0.0464368127,
0.0318095163,
0.0121997492,
-0.0593898632,
-0.0121932337,
-0.0161748137,
0.0341663435,
0.0233168732,
-0.0245255399,
0.049622383,
0.0057179774,
-0.0247235093,
-0.0165928919,
0.0832138062,
0.0191606637,
0.0512264483,
-0.0541170649,
-0.0563245341,
-0.0255225915,
-0.0486630239,
-0.0375512578,
-0.000841571,
-0.009837389,
0.0174598973,
-0.0123642134,
-0.0919400603,
0.0060786805,
0.061877396,
0.0338368863,
0.0003301155,
-0.0007656543,
0.0444209278,
-0.0085111037,
0.0125348642,
-0.0387598909,
-0.0287833437,
0.0213182569,
0.0271630157,
-0.0489582494,
-6.052372089e-33,
-0.0017923677,
-0.0223093927,
-0.0139037622,
-0.0163565893,
0.043938268,
-0.0197242741,
0.0160887856,
0.0085622407,
-0.0151040331,
0.0441518277,
0.0130883288,
0.0190476254,
0.0152566619,
0.0479697101,
0.005378949,
-0.0195159037,
0.0430513918,
-0.034075629,
0.004111011,
0.0062963255,
0.034832377,
0.004371305,
0.0607576109,
-0.0457182713,
0.0252001733,
-0.0175102055,
-0.0563060194,
0.0719467178,
-0.0190922432,
0.0392623432,
-0.0030650962,
0.051818639,
-0.0152997673,
0.0044316417,
-0.0128727406,
-0.060439121,
-0.0594355538,
-0.0440092571,
-0.0061404281,
0.0118737984,
-0.0015748502,
0.0069428715,
0.0279143397,
-0.0158270821,
-0.0393821821,
-0.0002068482,
0.0280109197,
-0.0371563956,
-0.0247045513,
-0.0835285559,
-0.0075597907,
0.0205001496,
0.0308485087,
0.0030308508,
0.0081415474,
0.0235868525,
-0.0136282416,
-0.0345794223,
-0.0455515869,
-0.0126810381,
0.0056981654,
0.0339214318,
0.0328336954,
0.0142932981,
0.0084223477,
0.0466030575,
0.001849684,
-0.0219527427,
-0.0251900647,
0.027462339,
0.0334187448,
0.0243152995,
0.0374364778,
0.0655471906,
0.0260704905,
-0.0124117453,
-0.047405947,
0.0125474092,
0.0071540424,
0.027227167,
0.0610210076,
0.0065381313,
-0.0464491844,
-0.0373247527,
-0.0601043254,
-0.0910900384,
-0.0261060949,
-0.0156819168,
-0.0102289012,
0.0087328572,
-0.006388166,
-0.0315340124,
-0.0005681723,
-0.0539537333,
-0.0296440795,
0.0470714606,
-0.0319766402,
0.005648701,
0.0141138118,
0.0426565632,
-0.0076211598,
-0.0060001048,
-0.004977921,
0.0163054336,
0.0056107892,
0.0252629723,
0.0719345883,
0.0388151482,
-0.0447834693,
0.0356414393,
-0.0634609908,
0.0188090578,
0.0288402364,
0.0065388456,
0.0408891849,
-0.0237455927,
-0.0088896407,
0.0145144938,
0.0368673801,
0.0648267791,
0.0197260436,
0.0418564044,
-0.0028727013,
0.0030563853,
-0.0483048782,
-0.0336741507,
-0.0242569037,
-0.018038936,
0.0580257215,
-0.0386618823,
-0.0153686376,
0.0055177971,
2.518e-7,
0.0258744881,
0.0213084053,
0.0149230519,
0.0571181327,
0.0205154289,
0.0144970389,
-0.0007392056,
-0.003983757,
-0.0040683886,
-0.0252479985,
0.0179319885,
-0.0215355456,
0.0377207212,
0.059434589,
-0.0460652001,
-0.0207982454,
-0.0660630688,
0.0117342938,
0.0040943148,
-0.0171415843,
0.0546255112,
0.123441726,
0.0338384844,
0.0173728969,
0.0353272036,
-0.0224331338,
0.0639192462,
-0.0252451636,
-0.0164503809,
0.0550917946,
0.0821284056,
0.033509776,
-0.0010913423,
-0.0034198302,
-0.0047483547,
0.007288896,
-0.0010479527,
0.0443679653,
0.0177211966,
-0.0173359178,
-0.0118092857,
-0.0238069743,
-0.0061443122,
-0.0762940571,
0.0398717523,
-0.0466555506,
-0.0108285444,
-0.0292469207,
0.020508118,
-0.0263993237,
0.064347662,
-0.0519843288,
-0.0075046401,
0.0132336142,
0.0058045969,
0.0247549973,
-0.013950468,
-0.0501654483,
-0.0469808988,
0.0249928106,
-0.0240444262,
-0.0299718436,
0.0276819803,
-0.0179332644,
0.0334763564,
-0.0640641674,
0.0350720584,
2.099758008e-34,
0.0622704588,
-0.0095643653,
-0.0242218301,
-0.0240075905,
0.044145178,
-0.0230725911,
0.0159507096,
0.0334503539,
0.0156322978,
-0.0072315666,
-0.0235578101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09249v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09249v2 | UniTabE: A Universal Pretraining Protocol for Tabular Foundation Model in Data Science | 2023-07-18T13:28:31 | 2024-03-13T08:20:34 | Yazheng Yang, Yuqi Wang, Guang Liu, Ledell Wu, Qi Liu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advancements in NLP have witnessed the groundbreaking impact of
pretrained models, yielding impressive outcomes across various tasks. This
study seeks to extend the power of pretraining methodologies to facilitating
the prediction over tables in data science, a domain traditionally overlooked,
yet inherently challenging due to the plethora of table schemas intrinsic to
different tasks. The primary research questions underpinning this work revolve
around the establishment of a universal pretraining protocol for tables with
varied structures, the generalizability and transferability of learned
knowledge across tasks, the adaptation to diverse downstream applications, and
the incorporation of incremental columns over time. In response to these
challenges, we introduce UniTabE, a straightforward yet effective method
designed to process tables in a uniform manner, devoid of constraints imposed
by specific table structures. UniTabE's core concept relies on representing
each basic table element with a module, termed TabUnit. This is subsequently
followed by a Transformer encoder to refine the representation. Moreover, our
model is designed to facilitate pretraining and finetuning through the
utilization of free-form prompts. In order to implement the pretraining phase,
we curated an expansive tabular dataset comprising approximately 13B samples,
meticulously gathered from the Kaggle platform. This research primarily centers
on classification and regression tasks involving tabular data, and conducts
rigorous experimental testing and analyses to validate the effectiveness of our
methodology. The experimental results demonstrate UniTabE's superior
performance against several baselines across massive benchmarks. This,
therefore, underscores UniTabE's potential to significantly enhance the
semantic representation of tabular data, thereby marking a significant stride
for tabular data analysis. | [
-0.0003246887,
0.072850965,
-0.008823107,
-0.034137968,
0.0167427324,
0.0529254749,
0.0087226415,
0.0127818473,
-0.0310966913,
-0.0185140874,
-0.0196038466,
-0.0035189248,
-0.0296364296,
0.0506409779,
0.0176240746,
-0.0096587278,
0.0448071584,
0.0283034369,
-0.065158315,
0.0505220443,
0.0049896706,
-0.0388048328,
-0.0176695231,
0.0162058845,
-0.0388708375,
-0.0086754337,
-0.0502001904,
-0.0120566571,
-0.0634726211,
-0.0171552822,
0.0183185488,
0.1046768576,
0.0366453789,
0.0049880184,
0.0000022735,
0.0108815199,
-0.072116442,
-0.0343555845,
-0.0190308951,
-0.0090079159,
0.0359754637,
-0.0762046278,
0.0041416874,
-0.0168882702,
-0.0517181829,
-0.0358627476,
0.0267263725,
0.0280011222,
0.0346454941,
0.0342188254,
-0.0141544817,
-0.0416022614,
0.0143504497,
-0.0038150239,
0.0362145267,
-0.0069130245,
-0.0156846698,
0.0006204764,
-0.0296321921,
-0.0153332306,
-0.0055946046,
0.0210347697,
0.0380686186,
-0.0021841738,
0.0564732961,
0.0408049151,
-0.0439499095,
-0.0189027824,
-0.0152634587,
0.089520745,
0.0103725586,
-0.0196446721,
0.0027170933,
0.0072686481,
0.0254960489,
0.0054774485,
-0.0575916879,
-0.0135720549,
0.0062322859,
-0.0224938691,
-0.0008475446,
0.009700384,
-0.0133505249,
-0.0133078275,
-0.0527613945,
0.0426353924,
-0.0503637455,
-0.0374075025,
0.0361449756,
-0.0164395086,
0.0353731848,
-0.0325662903,
-0.007006322,
0.0288030226,
-0.0422780439,
0.0062776525,
0.0082841516,
-0.0526118018,
0.0175021477,
-0.0309802014,
0.0671835244,
0.0401074067,
-0.0116383685,
0.0046866438,
-0.0340498313,
0.0432829,
-0.0079132868,
0.0434517749,
-0.0123865968,
0.0086893318,
-0.0686690956,
-0.0108242305,
-0.0531002693,
0.0174490586,
-0.0458308496,
0.0028648488,
0.0061235586,
0.0145086618,
-0.0176414344,
0.022345474,
0.0269078538,
0.0272699241,
-0.0104859704,
0.0315406509,
-0.0460980907,
0.0373617113,
-0.0273903366,
-0.0218033735,
-0.001279006,
-0.0844284669,
-0.0241473205,
-0.0249889772,
-0.0026353116,
-0.0260000881,
0.0475173369,
0.0420909747,
-0.0302149095,
-0.0011858603,
-0.0374470353,
-0.0337626338,
-0.0127722956,
-0.0277949534,
0.0446710028,
-0.0403820202,
0.0673435032,
0.0228488538,
0.0113937138,
-0.0705459416,
-0.0113273989,
0.0295597333,
-0.0083644772,
0.0876321942,
-0.0209905505,
0.0139401508,
-0.0222019106,
-0.0168741178,
-0.0365162715,
0.0576302931,
0.0238486305,
0.0427607335,
-0.00280562,
-0.0596603639,
-0.0134860408,
0.0277092531,
0.0313323848,
-0.0333892629,
-0.0131960139,
0.0452336706,
0.0317889154,
0.0160018764,
-0.0185830574,
-0.0393407829,
-0.0136311669,
0.0243845843,
0.0458469316,
0.0199360102,
0.0155495228,
0.0812564939,
-0.0072432701,
-0.0284326356,
0.0230270494,
0.0077152387,
-0.0068796962,
0.035768006,
0.0202671029,
-0.0013381159,
0.006833734,
0.0321701318,
-0.0325200483,
-0.063557066,
0.0199894868,
-0.0080940956,
0.0131831681,
-0.0243957881,
0.0475427024,
0.0346912853,
-0.0536522008,
0.0274311751,
0.0235561617,
-0.0648749247,
-0.0243126936,
0.0203266013,
0.026115777,
0.0440076925,
0.0437774137,
-0.0716142282,
-0.0152240302,
-0.0180006456,
0.0266495217,
-0.0126482807,
0.0384576209,
-0.0666806325,
-0.0113248089,
-0.0137605444,
-0.0252323002,
0.0419196598,
0.0207637884,
-0.011906378,
0.0070198104,
-0.0152834849,
-0.0011509365,
-0.0544579588,
-0.033720538,
0.0378827304,
0.0086856224,
-0.0102819838,
0.005943682,
-0.000453944,
0.0050742347,
0.0186128896,
0.0123511087,
0.0133640403,
0.0556214228,
-0.0093496423,
0.0078956038,
-0.0147960484,
-0.028014021,
-0.0000091764,
0.0015050124,
0.0236225221,
-0.036741633,
0.0064383238,
-0.0303326771,
-0.0095909145,
0.0082906745,
0.0218598507,
-0.0266724788,
-0.0167109929,
0.0123970034,
-0.0185134504,
0.0188346356,
-0.0216978062,
0.0681281909,
0.0122735221,
0.0028736235,
0.0100493245,
-0.1038705334,
0.0252844822,
-0.0070157107,
0.0247386694,
0.0180379078,
-0.0265990905,
0.0152071798,
0.0120272571,
-0.0016285066,
-0.0629172176,
-0.0120570976,
-0.101535365,
0.0484143123,
-0.0272357296,
0.0441772416,
0.0362723023,
-0.0035145481,
-0.0129369777,
-0.0453751832,
-0.0290535297,
-0.0124526359,
-0.0207304936,
0.0007467693,
0.0584061332,
-0.0180851258,
0.0018322779,
-0.0203984622,
-0.0238429829,
-0.0624713749,
0.0389902778,
-0.0136826551,
-0.0435700938,
0.0316121615,
-0.0310079828,
0.0239112955,
0.0061593601,
0.0194806959,
0.0148312198,
0.0013526324,
-0.0090832245,
0.0431304909,
0.0478261784,
-0.0168346614,
0.0969436094,
-0.0007763357,
0.002997142,
-0.0354664139,
0.0284895208,
-0.0198868681,
0.019423876,
0.0002351825,
-0.0363739952,
0.0657818317,
0.0642625764,
-0.0315087251,
0.0238221567,
-0.0412311219,
0.0278816391,
-0.0025175971,
-0.0041569602,
-0.0829339251,
0.0769312009,
0.0087700849,
-0.001327978,
-0.0056589111,
0.0037908484,
0.0000975474,
-0.0270493515,
0.0118895397,
-0.0279480927,
0.0019870347,
-0.0509550124,
0.0812637955,
0.0280330013,
-0.0272450056,
0.0263721943,
-0.0104035912,
-0.0321820714,
0.0352483802,
-0.009442294,
-0.0086875958,
0.0849211812,
-0.0346201956,
0.0051661828,
-0.023753291,
-0.0280489381,
-0.0274229664,
-0.0537815355,
0.0164633896,
0.0445802137,
-0.0041160788,
0.0119632427,
-0.0646552145,
-0.013205762,
0.0280955564,
0.0545218438,
-0.0048964429,
-0.037862733,
-0.04398489,
0.0578375012,
0.0103724599,
-0.0228705965,
-0.0306330677,
-0.009666129,
0.0068191779,
0.0524799675,
-0.0294578578,
0.014269135,
-0.0287092049,
0.0223564766,
-0.0027202442,
-0.0502575375,
-0.0025666947,
0.0339986384,
-0.0237372648,
-0.0571807586,
-0.0118170679,
0.0869729221,
0.0392952785,
0.010409141,
-0.015269585,
0.034733817,
0.0458786227,
0.028654296,
0.0172561333,
-0.0760118589,
-0.0299632587,
-0.019513173,
0.0080559961,
0.0310516357,
-0.061091803,
-0.0017868264,
-0.062621437,
0.0300393198,
-0.0083584841,
-0.0653269142,
-0.0750347748,
-0.0699151531,
-0.017766092,
-0.0488196313,
0.0298500527,
0.0494936556,
-0.0379594751,
0.0473369323,
0.0484515652,
-0.0608431175,
-0.0318468921,
-0.0212988928,
-0.0588415898,
0.0216075443,
0.0485215075,
0.0100956755,
-0.0380142219,
-0.0018018881,
-0.0103497319,
0.0201250557,
0.0290303398,
-0.0155078704,
0.0914393365,
0.01823337,
0.0059204604,
0.0187026542,
-0.0352985822,
-0.0570390671,
-0.005369659,
0.0215413757,
0.0793636292,
-0.0366417356,
-0.0018586428,
0.0094735185,
-0.0374148078,
-0.0003039241,
0.0644549429,
0.0396604128,
0.0075473287,
-0.0493152179,
-0.0198807418,
-0.0242013708,
-0.0512882397,
0.0247154925,
0.063544862,
-0.0355999172,
-0.0308020618,
-0.0534283929,
-0.0373426341,
0.0583655499,
0.0425971635,
0.0121987723,
0.0130066322,
-0.0028638793,
-0.0186478663,
-0.080062978,
0.0043419912,
-0.0206879266,
-0.0156621691,
-0.0120483665,
-0.0740140676,
0.0053910301,
-0.0061480775,
-0.0138343377,
-0.0007604441,
-0.0143541079,
0.0071633691,
-0.0019574002,
0.0086191101,
0.0240096264,
-0.0123215159,
0.045136299,
-0.0038765802,
-0.0084670298,
0.0117355995,
-0.0717512295,
-0.0434165709,
-0.0110782189,
-0.0770143494,
-0.0025489614,
0.0000638827,
0.0157530177,
0.0275570601,
-0.0467704721,
0.031729117,
0.0137532232,
0.0376452506,
0.0620030165,
0.0023012643,
0.0201009866,
0.0520267002,
-0.0519174896,
-0.02316886,
0.0096894046,
-0.0398474373,
-0.0302767493,
0.0077814842,
0.0049794875,
0.0069370973,
0.0308214705,
-0.0246577673,
0.0174453631,
0.0152638955,
0.0657675117,
-0.0625864863,
0.01068551,
0.0384089984,
-0.0093748663,
0.0212107878,
-0.0175244119,
-0.0039939368,
-0.0156200295,
0.027910281,
0.0246072505,
-0.0105908802,
0.030740194,
0.0326239653,
-0.0066720368,
-0.0381533988,
0.0635865107,
-0.0483605675,
-0.0389103554,
-0.0165295545,
-0.0158600602,
-0.0262119938,
0.0027480859,
-0.0139468443,
-0.0169365425,
-0.0126351714,
0.0298676435,
0.0254520271,
0.0557340793,
0.0079534221,
0.0292668547,
0.0043584052,
-0.0273074228,
-0.0732202232,
0.0701714531,
0.0307962783,
0.0108831823,
-0.0121623324,
-0.0285337456,
-0.0488438308,
0.0234491713,
0.0179944858,
-0.0107001886,
-0.0170221757,
-0.027648855,
-0.0299277771,
-0.0001852502,
0.043420177,
0.0301524512,
-0.0079391869,
0.0129569499,
0.0297904927,
0.0514017791,
0.0281116609,
0.0022407635,
-0.0229076874,
0.0203760322,
-0.031643752,
-0.033364132,
-0.0166500583,
-6.581566422e-33,
-0.0400794707,
0.00205832,
0.0183861256,
-0.0292248037,
0.0001697291,
-0.0247307438,
-0.0361249521,
-0.0115000866,
0.0168337766,
-0.001766588,
-0.0521425419,
0.012227213,
0.0257447548,
-0.0290319789,
0.0513850115,
-0.0731691942,
0.0494833477,
-0.0151866646,
-0.020627046,
0.0096142851,
-0.0003582042,
0.0509533845,
0.0562669113,
-0.026017582,
0.0349539109,
0.0210071802,
0.0084353685,
-0.0301483329,
0.0252459999,
0.0257930271,
-0.0253994484,
0.0285789892,
0.0465571769,
-0.0894243196,
-0.0467423089,
0.0461189598,
-0.162706852,
-0.0168083049,
-0.031448476,
0.0448203869,
-0.0161773469,
-0.0007474303,
0.0065136706,
-0.0247097928,
-0.0083022285,
-0.035911344,
0.0442730598,
-0.0281539485,
0.0002350577,
-0.0095873363,
-0.0190974828,
0.0055144844,
-0.0139713213,
0.0100821285,
0.0775617808,
0.0469684824,
0.0330390595,
-0.0291182995,
-0.0591969565,
0.0083487416,
0.0287608691,
0.030974932,
0.0482030883,
-0.0293629244,
0.0254927482,
0.038184125,
0.0433317572,
0.023066679,
-0.036685653,
-0.0009734098,
-0.0270657316,
0.0381643586,
0.0320354886,
-0.0219736807,
0.0794111192,
-0.0233521368,
-0.0541414022,
0.0825399607,
0.0418262593,
-0.0105422754,
-0.0448137969,
-0.0055013937,
-0.0081982287,
-0.0132946027,
-0.0135183586,
0.0034465897,
-0.0096506346,
-0.0306966025,
0.0230392702,
-0.0097702257,
0.0403949395,
0.0268426519,
0.0172894299,
0.003434913,
-0.0095106196,
0.0357844047,
0.0053777043,
0.0278191213,
0.007922736,
-0.0391997062,
-0.0138755469,
-0.0469647013,
0.0336959995,
0.001393275,
0.0696028695,
0.0411805548,
0.0745279491,
0.035622783,
-0.0530499145,
-0.0192214549,
-0.0202156845,
0.0246969108,
0.0480484888,
0.0194613952,
-0.0113631049,
0.0343043096,
-0.0114862835,
0.0426828898,
0.0474201217,
-0.0083204005,
-0.0279238969,
0.0203668512,
0.0184936095,
0.0033655837,
0.0292497426,
-0.0189829562,
-0.0612727068,
-0.0029462101,
0.026165437,
-0.036807172,
0.0038015593,
-0.0082840491,
2.725e-7,
0.0802604258,
0.0457447395,
0.0569394715,
0.0038706509,
0.0111728869,
-0.0029915632,
-0.0156274736,
0.0078770062,
-0.0544472821,
-0.0499788523,
0.0543113723,
-0.0283227637,
0.0509303026,
0.0566598512,
-0.0547050275,
-0.0719438419,
-0.0590071492,
-0.0158359502,
-0.079138428,
0.0038762346,
0.0451424159,
0.0602971837,
-0.0586926341,
-0.0081975935,
0.0006456358,
0.0284197237,
0.0141679235,
-0.0459050387,
0.0594810806,
0.0401094742,
0.0394829288,
-0.0261988342,
-0.0175265279,
0.0716644078,
-0.0322396345,
0.0086673275,
-0.0067260051,
0.0419643074,
-0.0306782573,
0.041409459,
0.018522799,
-0.0676854178,
0.0197259635,
-0.0818806589,
0.0756807551,
-0.0579069667,
-0.0025542134,
0.0850750282,
-0.0191857498,
0.0598350465,
0.0269365758,
0.0422582105,
0.0042004879,
0.0315994546,
0.0207239538,
0.0170822032,
-0.017634334,
-0.0566725284,
-0.0195196662,
0.0360104702,
-0.0018236227,
0.004030616,
-0.0232294742,
-0.0501316078,
-0.0077612326,
-0.0678348392,
-0.0098249819,
2.970208361e-34,
0.0225568637,
0.0222881883,
0.057817325,
0.0337471254,
0.0530182458,
-0.064808704,
0.0317228623,
-0.0037116483,
-0.0033306445,
-0.0820519254,
-0.0055174367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09209v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09209v1 | Automated Ableism: An Exploration of Explicit Disability Biases in Sentiment and Toxicity Analysis Models | 2023-07-18T12:45:54 | 2023-07-18T12:45:54 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Mukund Srinath, Shomir Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | We analyze sentiment analysis and toxicity detection models to detect the
presence of explicit bias against people with disability (PWD). We employ the
bias identification framework of Perturbation Sensitivity Analysis to examine
conversations related to PWD on social media platforms, specifically Twitter
and Reddit, in order to gain insight into how disability bias is disseminated
in real-world social settings. We then create the \textit{Bias Identification
Test in Sentiment} (BITS) corpus to quantify explicit disability bias in any
sentiment analysis and toxicity detection models. Our study utilizes BITS to
uncover significant biases in four open AIaaS (AI as a Service) sentiment
analysis tools, namely TextBlob, VADER, Google Cloud Natural Language API,
DistilBERT and two toxicity detection models, namely two versions of
Toxic-BERT. Our findings indicate that all of these models exhibit
statistically significant explicit bias against PWD. | [
0.0257959459,
0.0648212209,
-0.0422514454,
0.0135815749,
0.0098180873,
0.0143133802,
0.0508856252,
-0.0261130296,
0.0582559183,
-0.0653227121,
0.0044343388,
0.0470605381,
-0.0112479888,
0.0061518596,
-0.0124693718,
-0.0510921851,
0.0517595708,
0.0768518001,
0.0160975214,
-0.0303659979,
0.0394912362,
0.014516497,
-0.0182788316,
0.0302191991,
-0.0000589598,
-0.0147674344,
0.0741527975,
0.0234991927,
0.0189735405,
-0.0580599159,
0.0314678885,
0.0612323135,
0.0129891615,
0.016933063,
0.0000016996,
-0.0610366538,
0.0277202968,
0.0179279931,
0.0233829729,
-0.0484092869,
0.0475081913,
-0.0115251308,
0.0143110063,
0.060312517,
-0.0346017368,
-0.0131910797,
0.0712765828,
0.0143978689,
0.0417069867,
0.032160297,
-0.0257889796,
0.0249845311,
-0.0049184929,
0.0251756757,
0.0251367707,
-0.0149820726,
0.0439424738,
-0.0596851967,
-0.0591433793,
-0.034150172,
0.0012587352,
0.0029825752,
-0.0259574037,
0.0109149748,
0.0113588888,
-0.0355244316,
0.0024302735,
-0.0264583956,
0.0318094715,
0.0624066815,
0.0705772787,
0.0045488817,
-0.0183385722,
0.0271231029,
0.0284606777,
0.0126509592,
-0.0422918051,
0.0163353514,
0.0001538383,
-0.0165236443,
-0.0157415196,
0.0134368381,
0.0129062803,
0.0451711081,
0.0398637839,
0.0307798889,
-0.00011183,
-0.0241972618,
0.0017581369,
0.0247362442,
0.0429926924,
0.0015474071,
0.0204481948,
-0.0039847004,
-0.0014218002,
0.0154302213,
-0.0551074706,
-0.0478226878,
0.018842347,
-0.0811760426,
0.0173437949,
0.0231022518,
-0.0403905958,
0.0005332081,
0.0224639513,
-0.0056174509,
-0.0067515555,
0.0262154043,
0.0321387835,
0.050731048,
-0.0153865721,
0.0146681592,
0.0089304401,
-0.0118532693,
0.0129341986,
0.0328726098,
-0.0245222505,
0.0277607013,
-0.0733345225,
-0.0339395925,
-0.0173424743,
0.0257073175,
-0.0149765983,
0.0116284443,
-0.0161883608,
0.0161118135,
-0.0423494726,
0.0608388372,
-0.0582903326,
-0.0400535129,
-0.0018932028,
0.0322151072,
0.0258645732,
-0.054788705,
0.014319038,
0.08193703,
0.0595366508,
-0.0149065638,
-0.0499759614,
-0.0236051306,
-0.0188292414,
-0.0038309498,
-0.0170880016,
-0.0218401607,
-0.0010069907,
0.0177975986,
-0.0193251967,
-0.0889916047,
0.0160449073,
0.0083406474,
-0.0591732711,
0.0549493693,
-0.0326263793,
-0.018039722,
0.0280370563,
0.0224276744,
-0.022096524,
0.0517769046,
-0.0228460375,
-0.0022606712,
0.0494832881,
-0.0067694485,
-0.0154235009,
0.0119152972,
0.0311036278,
0.0251588076,
-0.0642048568,
0.0454822257,
-0.0594756976,
-0.048352588,
0.0205495805,
0.0312590301,
0.0256712846,
-0.0059280717,
0.0523102731,
0.0300920289,
-0.0129864272,
0.0328713283,
-0.0268845521,
-0.0025387187,
0.0058320547,
-0.0186587553,
-0.0595494285,
-0.0220064502,
-0.0285190213,
-0.070278585,
0.0160434879,
0.0424992591,
-0.0073417681,
-0.0313758031,
-0.0239795204,
-0.0020629431,
0.0507537872,
-0.0355863683,
0.026916787,
0.0132918656,
0.002416508,
-0.0217961837,
0.0283178631,
-0.0374473557,
-0.002406575,
-0.0636643916,
-0.0258938,
0.0645744875,
0.0271726009,
-0.0389230065,
0.0179817658,
-0.0274361018,
-0.0439311527,
0.0363948233,
0.0045665638,
-0.0031414016,
-0.0265599154,
0.017201934,
-0.0107817454,
0.0318372846,
0.0503279492,
0.0033236099,
0.0298706573,
0.0638007447,
-0.0282478053,
-0.0276769269,
0.0041186484,
0.0361797325,
0.0405827686,
-0.044632826,
-0.0035895249,
0.0040211636,
0.0493513681,
0.0170818418,
-0.0558502004,
-0.0038069452,
-0.0447155014,
-0.0019674227,
-0.0515469611,
0.0271760914,
-0.0021771991,
-0.0096174153,
0.005040613,
-0.0416952707,
0.004637213,
0.0937386826,
0.0117650945,
0.0250015687,
0.0793265253,
-0.0455303751,
-0.0206702352,
-0.0157860722,
-0.0284614712,
-0.059362065,
0.0509863459,
-0.0361863784,
0.047885213,
-0.0235091038,
-0.0275675096,
-0.0339429937,
-0.0567788929,
0.0267513283,
-0.0214005485,
-0.045298811,
-0.0320933945,
-0.0294228513,
0.0248091742,
0.0295460094,
-0.0440166742,
-0.0062631527,
0.0276653562,
-0.0810256228,
-0.0257767364,
-0.0145702809,
0.025990149,
0.0116107417,
0.0290429257,
-0.0069209225,
0.0129669383,
0.0080304295,
-0.0149320625,
0.0124350404,
0.0574688837,
0.0075602448,
-0.0469215512,
0.0041520093,
-0.0597667694,
0.0014206552,
-0.0574569777,
0.0323035493,
0.0554442964,
-0.0494852364,
0.0127915405,
-0.0317494348,
-0.0338012055,
0.0155482246,
0.0099290153,
-0.0337448865,
0.0184225459,
0.0504384376,
-0.0145190302,
0.0477187634,
0.0390136987,
0.0541061461,
0.0247259904,
0.0525855236,
-0.0153558571,
-0.0004647914,
-0.027740689,
0.0298109241,
-0.0208473932,
-0.0724470392,
0.0155642089,
0.035734307,
0.0412287116,
-0.0461209677,
-0.0379152857,
0.0715347901,
-0.0212851334,
-0.0178895891,
0.0367921814,
-0.0353605859,
-0.0261039659,
-0.0123856068,
0.0086912727,
-0.0726857856,
0.027396407,
0.0239034723,
0.0401872434,
-0.0244229753,
-0.0022539662,
-0.0019721519,
0.0434477478,
0.0025568698,
0.0402584076,
-0.0500535071,
0.0119823273,
-0.0011775527,
-0.0098533537,
0.0193590987,
-0.0118466783,
0.0078052059,
-0.0208674055,
0.0299039837,
0.0162294805,
-0.0207466912,
-0.0265918393,
-0.0245980825,
-0.0324180312,
-0.0217205249,
0.0320051424,
-0.0507915579,
-0.0161095448,
-0.0250400081,
0.0077539538,
0.0093172276,
0.0015230493,
-0.0169472974,
0.0454303883,
-0.0416316539,
0.0181241613,
-0.0434755161,
0.0483609103,
0.0300846864,
0.0174065754,
0.0477120392,
-0.0204780176,
0.0226392467,
0.0088935019,
-0.028877439,
0.0075196237,
-0.0172060523,
0.0532345064,
-0.0226095598,
0.0315294303,
0.0217391383,
0.0114665879,
0.0492435656,
0.0153354779,
-0.0698948279,
0.0478628352,
-0.0265186559,
-0.0235729497,
0.0226446688,
0.0054319715,
-0.1108532995,
-0.0183406863,
-0.0161825009,
0.0542857759,
-0.0904814079,
-0.060590867,
-0.0076260408,
-0.0799117684,
0.0124543533,
-0.0300735943,
0.023389576,
-0.0292007141,
-0.0264713354,
0.0334977955,
-0.0116374651,
0.0392378308,
-0.051267866,
0.0224832967,
0.0037124185,
-0.0175354127,
-0.090234004,
-0.0528459214,
0.0047618449,
0.0000613181,
0.0695205629,
0.0383561105,
0.0280635487,
-0.0318124071,
0.0139636463,
0.0528605767,
-0.0442313813,
-0.0154563347,
-0.0491751879,
0.083810173,
-0.0084101195,
-0.0175770335,
-0.0636886582,
0.0361850075,
-0.0213716961,
0.0279768966,
0.0088926917,
0.0005196036,
0.002646538,
-0.0482667051,
-0.0771674588,
-0.0041047926,
0.0535931997,
0.0500017293,
0.0088727018,
-0.0599338487,
-0.002511252,
-0.0661827549,
-0.002575848,
-0.0246064812,
-0.0579527132,
-0.02521763,
-0.0193156488,
-0.0729170591,
-0.0706605315,
0.0027019195,
-0.027290253,
-0.0036642388,
-0.0124523072,
-0.0421071239,
0.0010656472,
0.0161129273,
-0.0242489781,
0.023983255,
0.0290686786,
0.0324031748,
0.0125179822,
-0.0284486525,
-0.0303401798,
-0.0015986457,
-0.0362898968,
-0.039562244,
-0.0010793866,
-0.0518338978,
0.0903813392,
0.037312001,
0.0171423331,
0.0012962883,
-0.0181792509,
-0.0553879477,
0.0394171029,
0.0973067731,
0.0216291584,
0.0160056334,
0.0414599665,
-0.0165276472,
0.004627482,
0.0179755352,
-0.0070693456,
0.0593031608,
0.0093569215,
-0.0052708718,
-0.0228689276,
0.0218643248,
-0.0151550369,
0.0170108359,
0.035692513,
0.0257363059,
-0.0262784641,
-0.0263785869,
-0.037262585,
-0.0089037707,
-0.0378070623,
-0.0182058811,
-0.0219128598,
0.0324183144,
0.0226291604,
-0.0427859984,
-0.0213437267,
-0.0787449628,
-0.0115003185,
-0.032038413,
0.0777732432,
0.0225163307,
0.0539442934,
-0.0114224739,
-0.0047845468,
-0.0126849674,
0.0093851173,
-0.0094587002,
0.0156517942,
-0.0050322879,
0.0064224484,
0.009055024,
0.0102203656,
0.0307162441,
-0.0083578695,
0.0130001269,
-0.0146197081,
-0.0103094541,
0.0145677999,
-0.042940978,
0.0156770702,
0.0403793044,
0.0182554722,
0.0043605799,
-0.0056948839,
-0.0403029397,
0.0068335021,
0.0265535656,
0.0023436444,
-0.0099513456,
-0.0192370545,
0.0156023707,
0.0455012619,
-0.0128326146,
0.0712443665,
0.0004120525,
-0.0371757671,
0.0069056423,
-0.0584972128,
0.017726047,
0.0029961879,
0.0006200747,
0.0329322703,
-0.0322279222,
-0.0374781527,
0.0051106988,
-0.0551672205,
0.0320459045,
-0.0235439297,
-0.0267730374,
0.0299548134,
0.0085888971,
0.0106472764,
0.0122645246,
-0.0127816852,
-0.0911372676,
-0.0435133576,
-0.0081215659,
-5.688850829e-33,
-0.0008866237,
-0.0729356781,
-0.0621204823,
-0.0102620078,
-0.0011038468,
-0.0114817349,
0.0030298466,
0.034532126,
-0.0477877446,
0.0475522839,
0.0421762317,
0.0290407371,
-0.0020427464,
0.0126871848,
-0.014905245,
-0.0386829749,
0.0168172047,
-0.0089248307,
-0.0130989989,
0.0393086523,
0.0051615476,
-0.001850781,
-0.0028405883,
-0.1066617742,
0.0866534561,
-0.0172239468,
-0.0279809944,
0.0188575219,
0.0391282737,
0.017539721,
0.0128673483,
0.080254674,
0.0369404927,
0.0404095463,
0.0249324646,
0.1004065424,
-0.0137603655,
-0.0165404603,
0.0112499502,
0.0088268323,
0.0143707823,
-0.0021126869,
0.0115445377,
0.0121554406,
-0.0790887326,
-0.0161374751,
0.050937701,
-0.0129764769,
0.0521498136,
-0.0247391928,
-0.0549818575,
0.0094922464,
-0.0313283466,
0.0250049364,
-0.0515670963,
0.0461004712,
0.050528843,
0.0384563543,
-0.0045143007,
-0.0076637808,
-0.0678565726,
-0.0323902182,
-0.0204812977,
-0.044247251,
0.029062774,
0.0429864563,
0.0345228277,
0.0385998897,
-0.0586917773,
-0.037534833,
-0.0041219657,
-0.0293045342,
0.0347866006,
0.0553217344,
0.022828145,
-0.0477536768,
-0.0520516858,
-0.0069364794,
0.0565374903,
0.013137294,
0.0476695001,
-0.073837027,
-0.0953800231,
-0.0055013411,
-0.0171445217,
-0.0444846042,
-0.021286346,
-0.011358453,
0.0035697678,
-0.0208692625,
-0.0158741791,
-0.0134936571,
-0.0074972231,
-0.0367634185,
-0.008722729,
0.0266585238,
0.018596543,
-0.0057058143,
0.0271456111,
0.0113227973,
0.0049627004,
-0.0030025947,
-0.0011525727,
0.003170114,
0.0556687452,
0.0029131307,
0.0592829324,
0.0000449849,
-0.0753122419,
0.0115497634,
-0.0074226381,
0.0307038613,
-0.0172544885,
0.0676794797,
0.0047904523,
-0.0039815735,
0.0024056374,
0.0259547122,
0.0585584827,
0.0686518848,
-0.0121752983,
-0.0034665612,
-0.0455733351,
0.0166942831,
-0.0436484404,
-0.0448132008,
0.0071657039,
-0.0045277686,
-0.027418375,
-0.0943170264,
0.0098224981,
-0.0847570151,
2.565e-7,
0.052014295,
0.0887459591,
-0.0311173964,
0.0311066527,
0.0433678664,
0.0325786956,
0.0390954502,
0.0527037568,
-0.0194046292,
0.0491341799,
-0.0137066646,
0.0336920731,
-0.0077539911,
0.0261579771,
-0.004400311,
0.0052418876,
-0.0569549948,
0.0651853308,
-0.0118463067,
0.0249000136,
0.0188955124,
0.0298754051,
-0.0003900012,
0.0025370128,
-0.018285742,
-0.0719499514,
0.010076452,
-0.0232935697,
0.0492056422,
0.0234907009,
0.0341566429,
-0.0083809011,
0.0263405386,
-0.0037143843,
-0.0127544031,
0.0319656692,
-0.0260088276,
0.023767896,
-0.0577293299,
-0.0152861103,
0.022478994,
-0.0130492579,
0.0333292745,
-0.007203083,
0.038347356,
0.0159501117,
-0.0297354478,
-0.075619787,
-0.0466493964,
-0.0249979459,
0.0636055619,
0.0047082384,
-0.0100386348,
-0.0108288741,
0.0196580049,
0.0095694987,
-0.0020640064,
-0.0868699253,
-0.0264234859,
-0.0094154524,
-0.0299073607,
-0.0833779871,
0.0041553513,
0.0310686082,
0.0251110531,
0.0013293866,
0.0666080266,
1.952795271e-34,
0.0478904545,
0.0281370785,
-0.020863276,
-0.0443583801,
0.0466561504,
0.0271817613,
0.0533567071,
-0.0329287201,
0.018796226,
-0.0495287143,
0.0070371325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09162v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09162v3 | Unveiling Gender Bias in Terms of Profession Across LLMs: Analyzing and Addressing Sociological Implications | 2023-07-18T11:38:45 | 2023-08-31T20:02:47 | Vishesh Thakur | cs.CL | cs.CL | Gender bias in artificial intelligence (AI) and natural language processing
has garnered significant attention due to its potential impact on societal
perceptions and biases. This research paper aims to analyze gender bias in
Large Language Models (LLMs) with a focus on multiple comparisons between GPT-2
and GPT-3.5, some prominent language models, to better understand its
implications. Through a comprehensive literature review, the study examines
existing research on gender bias in AI language models and identifies gaps in
the current knowledge. The methodology involves collecting and preprocessing
data from GPT-2 and GPT-3.5, and employing in-depth quantitative analysis
techniques to evaluate gender bias in the generated text. The findings shed
light on gendered word associations, language usage, and biased narratives
present in the outputs of these Large Language Models. The discussion explores
the ethical implications of gender bias and its potential consequences on
social perceptions and marginalized communities. Additionally, the paper
presents strategies for reducing gender bias in LLMs, including algorithmic
approaches and data augmentation techniques. The research highlights the
importance of interdisciplinary collaborations and the role of sociological
studies in mitigating gender bias in AI models. By addressing these issues, we
can pave the way for more inclusive and unbiased AI systems that have a
positive impact on society. | [
0.0593659729,
0.078390196,
-0.0418129861,
0.0220745467,
-0.0394235849,
0.0124273542,
0.0538266897,
-0.0315123051,
0.027486166,
-0.0627260879,
0.0207276475,
-0.0045180172,
0.0359232649,
0.0180549901,
0.0283591114,
0.0073358752,
0.0008981936,
0.0478972308,
0.0317950286,
-0.0328270905,
0.0141218537,
0.0686383992,
0.0314730555,
0.0750754476,
0.0143782785,
-0.0329573601,
0.065959692,
0.0100275483,
-0.0185908768,
0.0115585262,
0.0408673957,
0.0364737995,
0.0015947036,
0.0354273245,
0.000002119,
-0.0862671211,
0.0083862646,
0.0297212303,
-0.0163986608,
-0.0136824343,
0.0472799055,
0.0072752144,
-0.0317738466,
0.0418757424,
-0.0451045968,
0.0268209111,
0.0310306456,
-0.0022240188,
0.0089181382,
0.0007692577,
-0.0100312876,
0.0087156519,
-0.0174095463,
-0.0014714674,
-0.0452726074,
0.0165495314,
0.0452008657,
-0.0157753173,
-0.0233113486,
-0.0125547722,
-0.0103256078,
0.0142345419,
-0.0172333363,
-0.0138775716,
-0.0047581312,
0.0362057947,
-0.0261740368,
-0.0464032441,
0.0111450339,
0.0081374859,
0.0308485031,
0.0026106129,
0.0179978497,
-0.0106857037,
0.0321680382,
0.0203264914,
-0.0362252519,
0.0485709496,
-0.0121953348,
-0.0074635856,
0.0165211577,
-0.0241542757,
0.0165468901,
0.0837819204,
-0.011074313,
0.0962261036,
0.0024284101,
-0.0399553142,
0.0166105963,
0.0102718119,
0.0231942534,
-0.0347810537,
0.0092344908,
-0.0123477131,
0.0102184936,
0.0244346317,
0.0113342199,
-0.0170867369,
0.0385201462,
-0.0661282092,
-0.0147103593,
0.0328945108,
0.0402629711,
-0.0032471451,
0.0172555652,
0.0025417379,
0.0077810236,
0.035524644,
-0.0049046609,
-0.0266029872,
-0.0363018252,
-0.0423406661,
-0.0024197446,
0.00709516,
-0.0054033347,
0.0346695893,
-0.022152584,
0.0030085761,
-0.0676642135,
0.0200138614,
0.0154087124,
0.032010328,
-0.0046252715,
0.0004984647,
-0.0232259408,
-0.0014100559,
-0.0376271307,
0.0468423702,
-0.0499106757,
-0.0885319039,
0.0301817544,
-0.0044602337,
-0.0079183197,
-0.0286159255,
0.0254747942,
0.0181912314,
0.0139167095,
-0.0305865556,
-0.0285463333,
-0.0091978144,
-0.0238871798,
-0.0487155207,
0.0039493553,
-0.0574055724,
0.0129209617,
0.0559337027,
-0.0006624809,
-0.0475074314,
-0.0020955002,
0.0290429369,
-0.0564652458,
0.0316765159,
0.0075877104,
0.0272363052,
0.1083534434,
0.0268119238,
-0.0091933208,
0.0674971864,
0.0857897475,
0.0188267566,
0.0275504757,
-0.0026591788,
0.0031763411,
0.0267263874,
-0.0087972507,
0.0358439684,
-0.0359342471,
0.036164403,
-0.0544949546,
0.0244110432,
0.0608652607,
0.0225668792,
0.021479493,
0.0019350421,
0.0411438234,
0.1027450189,
0.0139989797,
0.0830973759,
0.0309059974,
0.0099139344,
-0.0019967435,
-0.0160281993,
-0.0610813536,
-0.0117488531,
-0.0116418684,
-0.0406867079,
-0.0335929245,
0.042486079,
-0.0017798234,
-0.0484840497,
-0.0047148089,
0.0227132216,
0.0425151922,
0.0152383149,
0.0252404604,
-0.0062399716,
-0.012260206,
0.0042728377,
0.0189268608,
-0.0343709886,
-0.0112813655,
-0.0716669634,
0.0067050564,
0.0839267969,
0.0155399116,
-0.0110169519,
0.0021711835,
-0.042675484,
-0.0442848876,
0.0541315526,
0.0065375683,
0.0224762093,
-0.0394504331,
-0.0366962589,
-0.0096733263,
0.0334277228,
0.0049182172,
0.0370477922,
0.0276047606,
0.0533246025,
0.0169064328,
-0.0312629156,
-0.0743566304,
0.0145140737,
-0.0351864547,
-0.0049256552,
0.0004689233,
-0.0058357762,
0.0126240607,
0.0387263037,
-0.0356164537,
0.02302403,
-0.0150881428,
-0.0025779996,
-0.0112935966,
0.0048888577,
-0.0063941842,
0.0652461872,
-0.0011842898,
-0.076161392,
-0.0487762168,
0.0290434267,
0.0154104158,
0.0149691245,
0.0613675825,
-0.0181324724,
0.00294001,
-0.0281258002,
-0.0072551565,
-0.0354332738,
0.009652541,
-0.0422341861,
0.0060523218,
-0.04755098,
-0.0332708731,
0.0070749326,
-0.0152722858,
-0.0037033388,
-0.0361245312,
-0.0382359847,
0.0367688574,
0.012669052,
0.0245949086,
0.0420440249,
-0.0198360663,
-0.0155057451,
-0.0496454798,
-0.0879877508,
-0.0227921307,
0.0064762565,
-0.0139276292,
-0.0534166694,
-0.016001055,
-0.0511571206,
0.0149244079,
-0.0087928167,
-0.0384381227,
0.0016042819,
0.0389154665,
0.028378183,
-0.020354474,
-0.0038945079,
-0.0434962064,
-0.0368534587,
-0.040205285,
0.0252357982,
0.0709829554,
-0.0284277443,
-0.0382664688,
-0.001458326,
-0.0430105887,
-0.0128967138,
-0.0178086143,
-0.0033126145,
0.0104600266,
0.0389586687,
0.0334161557,
0.0589233935,
0.0264681652,
0.0312783867,
0.0540732555,
0.0212843232,
-0.0374221466,
-0.0210138783,
0.0449924543,
0.0170565415,
0.0139856292,
-0.0930474624,
-0.0156940725,
-0.0046086409,
0.0166584644,
-0.032321047,
-0.027037099,
0.0889067575,
-0.0567957088,
-0.0468962826,
-0.0089436946,
-0.0508970432,
-0.0113203535,
0.0232858639,
-0.0202859398,
-0.0612511039,
-0.0039539328,
0.0059214816,
0.0335936993,
-0.0222826414,
-0.037696287,
-0.0385307819,
0.0498993956,
-0.0135802748,
0.0331397057,
-0.0043739951,
-0.0197988413,
-0.0800240487,
-0.0420924984,
-0.0002607467,
-0.0546391383,
0.0283479188,
-0.0195337757,
0.0216577724,
0.0036556188,
-0.0260003451,
-0.0265411288,
-0.023469869,
-0.0243651439,
0.0187781621,
0.036259938,
0.0043656509,
-0.001903472,
-0.0005083461,
0.0109916758,
0.0141464705,
0.0061385166,
-0.0027409103,
-0.0248307735,
-0.0423712283,
0.0480003394,
-0.0040682335,
0.0384173132,
0.0039055075,
-0.0193423722,
-0.0061337873,
-0.0128692314,
0.0128063569,
-0.0064795008,
-0.014850934,
0.0577529185,
-0.0553487167,
-0.0304073635,
-0.0052857567,
-0.0288113784,
-0.0532352515,
0.0347259529,
0.0983311385,
0.0081814686,
-0.0699217096,
-0.0026718115,
-0.0220831931,
-0.0120696966,
0.0368480943,
0.0077554877,
-0.0632181317,
0.0397381447,
0.0304468237,
0.003236162,
-0.0825050846,
-0.0481318198,
-0.0336894579,
-0.1162037775,
0.0174368732,
0.0028822662,
-0.0015342258,
-0.0365101695,
-0.0186312757,
-0.0289331377,
-0.0028414873,
0.0388714559,
-0.0145317437,
-0.0195380375,
0.0131830703,
0.0185697693,
-0.0607394092,
-0.0215229448,
0.0408506505,
-0.0740588456,
0.0636196434,
0.05346274,
0.0636729226,
-0.075375706,
0.0096069342,
0.0186739862,
0.0139694735,
-0.0055236714,
-0.0078511098,
-0.0089947097,
-0.0602888763,
0.014616874,
-0.052072756,
0.0034244624,
0.0215817615,
0.0275480468,
0.0273072999,
0.0340264961,
-0.0021242865,
-0.0237244777,
-0.0834248587,
-0.021365881,
-0.0061143045,
0.069353357,
-0.0131521765,
-0.0349438936,
-0.0314570107,
-0.0251206718,
0.0070184744,
0.0878408775,
-0.0374663919,
0.002420682,
0.0175095014,
-0.0229406301,
0.0050747306,
-0.0773242116,
0.0157867819,
-0.02760965,
0.0259214528,
-0.0284516998,
0.0471112765,
-0.0001714148,
-0.0631451979,
0.0171218105,
-0.0082286149,
0.0391068682,
0.0273573007,
-0.0157330409,
-0.0062012286,
-0.0382931381,
-0.0053277677,
0.0079895202,
0.0015959681,
-0.0390250832,
0.0413171202,
0.0238089785,
0.023665823,
0.0320999175,
0.0190010946,
-0.042729158,
0.0361328609,
0.0360504985,
-0.0177692529,
0.0465105139,
0.0194141436,
0.0350806043,
0.0085682124,
0.0123996856,
-0.0368573926,
0.0149463555,
-0.0017631862,
-0.0127389934,
-0.0394972265,
-0.0230206922,
0.0185861122,
0.0170401298,
-0.0166883748,
-0.0513279699,
0.0347261801,
-0.0525262058,
-0.0308033191,
-0.0361598097,
-0.0440848358,
-0.0124423318,
-0.0251847506,
0.0535784699,
0.0331547707,
-0.0306312963,
-0.0117454221,
-0.0534195751,
-0.0124506503,
-0.0185449254,
0.0390891694,
-0.0150460238,
0.0570951737,
-0.0076927207,
-0.0164480209,
0.0091300439,
0.0114315152,
-0.0301008746,
0.0229947865,
0.0503169931,
0.0258458387,
0.0047392268,
0.0228889212,
-0.0164493266,
0.0352734849,
-0.0285808947,
-0.0549970157,
-0.0085241711,
0.0382408127,
0.0072628157,
-0.0185651779,
0.0429288708,
-0.0109582394,
0.0076781162,
0.0145897167,
-0.0285554342,
0.015817238,
0.0096458364,
0.0254335459,
-0.0004882273,
-0.036390055,
-0.0132148238,
0.0291513186,
0.0653092042,
0.0591911301,
-0.0278718043,
-0.0538293757,
0.0210760571,
-0.0540694334,
0.0292584579,
-0.0360139795,
-0.0079273339,
0.0000920216,
-0.1033895835,
-0.039398659,
-0.016568942,
-0.0413076617,
0.0296951439,
-0.0531374812,
-0.0127927512,
0.0649443641,
-0.0081063425,
-0.0482029542,
-0.0378328897,
0.0002282311,
-0.0218124092,
-0.0158627424,
-0.003099493,
-6.191756332e-33,
-0.0226119217,
-0.0730091333,
0.0226291101,
-0.0049655489,
-0.0284065697,
-0.0070720902,
0.0169082545,
0.0041168416,
-0.0213486943,
0.0234668292,
-0.0222420637,
0.0398813374,
0.0048737773,
-0.0143178971,
0.0382584296,
0.0075791362,
0.0303476602,
0.0164768454,
0.0055925706,
-0.0391713344,
-0.0484552495,
0.0059411004,
0.0126908049,
-0.0819006041,
0.1334262788,
-0.0068996372,
-0.0196987949,
-0.0142139895,
-0.025756754,
-0.0005604561,
-0.0009182843,
0.0711570531,
0.0209597666,
-0.0434124023,
0.0193187017,
0.0692419335,
-0.0281183571,
-0.0046536601,
0.0291268732,
0.0161001943,
0.0485628732,
-0.0384496264,
0.0588483438,
0.0300131235,
-0.0920954645,
0.0078932382,
0.0732690543,
0.0020447222,
0.0633360818,
0.0018000702,
-0.0711338371,
0.014207121,
-0.0549979992,
0.0357541963,
0.0034257725,
-0.0080397511,
-0.0034036043,
0.0329401493,
-0.0685124472,
0.0125845792,
0.0247486383,
-0.0326882191,
0.0629494637,
-0.0055443598,
0.0312717892,
0.0373753347,
0.08102981,
0.0452381819,
-0.0457008854,
-0.0843398198,
0.0214560684,
-0.0202151705,
0.0180658698,
0.0295431912,
0.0169217456,
-0.0155979712,
-0.0283262972,
-0.0612893291,
0.0232185461,
0.0152212391,
0.0344717056,
-0.0360754244,
-0.1008915007,
-0.0622058846,
-0.0210133623,
-0.0760939866,
-0.0043815314,
-0.0138161341,
0.0235148035,
-0.0133235389,
-0.0133654624,
0.0179070551,
-0.0346914455,
-0.0787909999,
-0.0106339408,
-0.0098516392,
-0.0148633402,
-0.0523422398,
0.0365145989,
0.0346682332,
-0.0759647489,
0.014551634,
-0.0276919082,
0.02661548,
0.0276715867,
0.039183341,
-0.0332131051,
0.0054012081,
-0.0584491827,
-0.025180947,
-0.0130709251,
-0.0062595117,
0.0138939451,
-0.0015216956,
0.0230796952,
0.0330894627,
0.0171262212,
-0.0205090083,
0.0665410459,
0.0450741425,
-0.0103533305,
-0.0253553055,
-0.0369199663,
0.0137141692,
-0.0288209021,
-0.0102231633,
0.0132836942,
0.0451932289,
0.0584836714,
-0.0248669796,
-0.0077213696,
-0.0466797017,
2.757e-7,
0.0282073766,
0.0882032663,
-0.0026805394,
0.0321338363,
-0.0009981398,
0.0095094657,
0.0367080569,
0.0587465689,
0.0525242426,
0.0115970587,
-0.0048359167,
0.0381232165,
-0.0103105279,
0.0127702774,
-0.0454558581,
0.0290150829,
-0.0796421915,
0.0116672898,
-0.0370370336,
0.0433339402,
-0.007604924,
0.042037461,
0.0369540192,
-0.0120381312,
-0.067629531,
-0.0198185332,
0.0068532294,
-0.0240433533,
0.0233982261,
0.0376748741,
0.025057273,
0.0297835656,
0.019480044,
0.0349557586,
0.0236692335,
0.0279693883,
0.0489458814,
0.0430720896,
-0.0461615361,
0.0609221011,
0.0094110379,
-0.0394808501,
-0.0128605627,
-0.0685662478,
0.0588004105,
0.0302648433,
-0.050230559,
-0.0406226628,
-0.0074912617,
-0.0299176089,
0.081409432,
-0.0227633473,
-0.020256184,
0.0014241344,
0.0167023707,
-0.009035632,
-0.0007373983,
-0.036521785,
0.0173422471,
-0.0373096168,
-0.000649283,
-0.0791953877,
0.003504012,
0.0548207983,
0.0331405811,
-0.0375396982,
0.03045086,
2.40759151e-34,
0.0095949695,
0.015837539,
0.0145218913,
0.0170955881,
0.0273267049,
0.0424481817,
-0.021541873,
-0.0047211926,
0.0378120989,
0.0144930845,
-0.0042737974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09084v1 | Attention over pre-trained Sentence Embeddings for Long Document Classification | 2023-07-18T09:06:35 | 2023-07-18T09:06:35 | Amine Abdaoui, Sourav Dutta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite being the current de-facto models in most NLP tasks, transformers are
often limited to short sequences due to their quadratic attention complexity on
the number of tokens. Several attempts to address this issue were studied,
either by reducing the cost of the self-attention computation or by modeling
smaller sequences and combining them through a recurrence mechanism or using a
new transformer model. In this paper, we suggest to take advantage of
pre-trained sentence transformers to start from semantically meaningful
embeddings of the individual sentences, and then combine them through a small
attention layer that scales linearly with the document length. We report the
results obtained by this simple architecture on three standard document
classification datasets. When compared with the current state-of-the-art models
using standard fine-tuning, the studied method obtains competitive results
(even if there is no clear best model in this configuration). We also showcase
that the studied architecture obtains better results when freezing the
underlying transformers. A configuration that is useful when we need to avoid
complete fine-tuning (e.g. when the same frozen transformer is shared by
different applications). Finally, two additional experiments are provided to
further evaluate the relevancy of the studied architecture over simpler
baselines. | [
0.0231392682,
0.0404663272,
0.011430853,
0.0197843798,
-0.0142749622,
0.0104093812,
0.008222783,
-0.036355447,
0.0235428438,
-0.0845901668,
-0.0121757379,
0.0039446373,
-0.0142754475,
0.0078315958,
0.0021097274,
-0.0439087525,
0.039720349,
0.0103595285,
0.0087017333,
0.0313760377,
0.0261477325,
-0.0186149348,
0.0382879637,
0.0236672964,
-0.0329464599,
-0.0176161565,
-0.0165866446,
-0.0321248025,
-0.0005784434,
-0.0155557841,
0.0230551921,
0.0457118675,
0.0274521392,
0.0449502543,
0.0000018309,
-0.0374833532,
0.0024262459,
-0.018164888,
-0.0190436356,
0.0221121404,
0.0357061028,
-0.0097992681,
0.0367568135,
0.0073145358,
-0.0061367946,
-0.0372965299,
0.0193913095,
0.1014687791,
0.0447361842,
0.0708311349,
-0.0187185053,
-0.0414342955,
0.0356812626,
-0.0273265354,
0.0022794972,
-0.0417701378,
0.0095641855,
-0.0486769937,
0.0249203239,
0.0322476439,
-0.0227678791,
0.0409542806,
0.0405210927,
-0.0014970652,
0.0582914427,
0.0275645088,
-0.0360632911,
0.000215387,
-0.0281567387,
0.0845902637,
-0.0615045875,
-0.0359942205,
-0.0272815377,
-0.0033837082,
0.0150331082,
-0.0382078215,
-0.0265361853,
0.0048377686,
0.0387252644,
0.0049203639,
0.0379516892,
0.0597685389,
0.0140038496,
-0.0088328887,
-0.0723827332,
0.0134534407,
0.0050852345,
-0.0519878343,
0.0225097053,
0.0184517819,
-0.0127600217,
-0.0393544957,
0.0133765349,
0.0356770642,
0.0099099679,
-0.0103168283,
-0.0605675876,
-0.0458008312,
0.020175213,
-0.0551009551,
0.0178331323,
0.0097992718,
-0.0091637466,
0.0496488847,
-0.0540319867,
0.0387977362,
-0.0167223625,
0.0361615494,
-0.0600528605,
0.026260918,
-0.0198972821,
-0.0072118789,
-0.0745480061,
0.049525205,
-0.0098617813,
-0.0526731648,
-0.0172516834,
0.0352128819,
0.0353868417,
-0.010539067,
0.000012965,
0.004698643,
-0.0042425054,
0.0038754242,
0.0085610822,
0.0186748318,
-0.0420820639,
0.0140347062,
-0.0022793233,
-0.0209391639,
-0.0418894999,
0.0239281338,
0.0151496511,
-0.0128692379,
0.0049284077,
0.0334723294,
0.015768189,
-0.1063307673,
0.0180828664,
0.0261463504,
-0.0272474587,
-0.0581078418,
0.0147457337,
-0.0354824327,
0.027952645,
0.0069371252,
0.0072433702,
0.0044879299,
-0.0003601961,
0.0286928564,
-0.0276466683,
0.0623427555,
0.0391216315,
-0.0353130549,
-0.0039079753,
0.0121278847,
0.0375637189,
0.0437182002,
0.0120323589,
0.0569055527,
0.0301813502,
-0.0274196714,
0.0418222994,
-0.0134910187,
0.0281231776,
-0.0196308549,
0.0265916213,
0.0377847664,
-0.0236232653,
0.0292317029,
0.0126619833,
0.0018029442,
-0.0034939486,
-0.0172488093,
0.0234074816,
0.0508217178,
0.0219539683,
0.0509602651,
0.0329783671,
0.0160348974,
-0.0263726208,
0.0152882235,
-0.0462833904,
0.0310462881,
0.0182588734,
0.0006855865,
0.0194210559,
0.0085253865,
-0.0611986294,
-0.0285980105,
0.013548865,
-0.0410508588,
0.0135973329,
-0.0061590532,
0.0296209473,
0.0180088226,
-0.0594238117,
0.0692876279,
-0.0060907723,
-0.0548013635,
-0.0149099072,
0.000826074,
0.0111322785,
0.0260417517,
0.0310513247,
-0.0638380125,
0.0029397153,
-0.0428641848,
0.0257380679,
-0.0014122617,
0.0414691791,
0.0367874354,
0.0012561587,
-0.0356572531,
-0.0271496885,
-0.054454729,
0.0214759074,
0.0088267028,
-0.0110087693,
0.0247834474,
0.0427074768,
-0.020721605,
0.0053717028,
0.045336742,
0.0030566338,
-0.0555345677,
0.0022684394,
0.0354320221,
0.0321657471,
0.0026555208,
0.0153763732,
0.0429337509,
0.031790223,
-0.047440365,
-0.0339998715,
-0.0058496115,
-0.0523554757,
-0.0474447981,
0.0007728465,
-0.0300229099,
-0.0095048593,
0.0503213815,
-0.0439292006,
-0.0235630516,
0.0171816833,
-0.0641158298,
0.050998129,
-0.0244409908,
-0.0074652596,
0.0193498749,
0.0685010105,
-0.0320909433,
0.0251040664,
-0.0069786329,
0.035064023,
-0.0272517651,
-0.0253031813,
0.0304225609,
-0.0099416859,
-0.0580825023,
-0.0115802633,
-0.0095419688,
0.0055304836,
0.0286370274,
-0.0304309931,
-0.0177662596,
-0.0301279649,
-0.0664432272,
0.0064810743,
-0.03595246,
0.0260833148,
-0.0091448957,
0.016789984,
0.0092625096,
-0.0276079532,
-0.0482215621,
-0.0189255327,
-0.0098296152,
0.0121951001,
0.0466332734,
-0.0180797558,
-0.0020451813,
-0.0055448487,
-0.027460441,
-0.0151599515,
0.087296769,
-0.0055566928,
-0.0041701496,
-0.0324141122,
0.0149345919,
-0.0041872994,
0.0084474729,
-0.0132326949,
-0.0624985509,
-0.0287980903,
-0.0192260928,
0.0692556724,
0.107666418,
0.0329788774,
0.0485242009,
0.0411441624,
0.0152812377,
0.0002824145,
0.0258782059,
-0.0344100967,
0.0463156775,
-0.0216534231,
0.0350204073,
0.0346985944,
0.0710865557,
-0.0442527905,
-0.0300029572,
-0.0301615875,
-0.0131593682,
0.0150296129,
0.0195623208,
-0.0025937546,
-0.0003221743,
-0.0130764302,
-0.0094516156,
-0.0045740246,
-0.0267487336,
0.0452002995,
-0.0158538576,
-0.0021813703,
-0.0680799708,
-0.0001455332,
-0.0511154979,
0.0631595775,
0.046744898,
-0.0118310712,
-0.0077771139,
-0.0285085067,
-0.0017248902,
0.0021877568,
-0.0110941958,
-0.0117512466,
0.0341489539,
0.0617841072,
0.0196880288,
-0.0452924259,
-0.0307862181,
-0.0274296813,
-0.0797248632,
-0.0317434818,
-0.0122018047,
0.0287289117,
0.0112563903,
-0.0799691528,
0.0304220635,
0.020353375,
0.0521244071,
-0.0187141802,
-0.0026908731,
-0.0188171733,
0.0537800603,
0.0218562149,
0.0174725428,
0.0184089504,
-0.0167702436,
0.0432768613,
0.0519610643,
0.0144495666,
0.0024912897,
-0.0617125034,
-0.0357842445,
0.0192766991,
-0.0674554706,
-0.0056102737,
0.0063162358,
0.008707962,
-0.0795005411,
-0.0177248809,
0.1058242694,
0.0202618521,
-0.0315426774,
-0.0123445848,
0.0293907356,
-0.0071540275,
0.0216601919,
0.0180911552,
-0.0575635992,
-0.0395964049,
0.0083522089,
-0.0270459503,
0.0340280496,
-0.0118914125,
-0.0197026674,
-0.0596862584,
0.0130588338,
0.001325253,
-0.028647,
-0.0275491737,
-0.056280151,
-0.0336429514,
0.0138396267,
-0.0159187578,
-0.0231401753,
-0.0308313854,
-0.0142775355,
-0.0199461542,
-0.0782720074,
-0.0188843235,
0.0303733964,
-0.0001120184,
-0.0079439748,
0.0220691785,
0.0265263654,
-0.0089421496,
-0.044462055,
0.0385466889,
-0.0401898548,
-0.0313815661,
0.0217468776,
0.0637119263,
-0.0512419082,
0.0151974782,
-0.0194416046,
0.0038518957,
-0.0390628204,
-0.0120510524,
-0.0161875803,
0.0989134833,
-0.0184479598,
-0.0350265652,
-0.0445998125,
-0.0057655023,
-0.0208211727,
0.0733125955,
0.0438218936,
-0.0660762936,
-0.0881545916,
0.004588163,
0.0158202611,
-0.0543652065,
-0.0199284535,
0.0227458626,
0.0250037573,
-0.0440540873,
-0.0362071842,
-0.0862030089,
0.0170904733,
0.0288695302,
-0.0365464427,
-0.003149044,
0.0037182022,
-0.0088516884,
-0.0370835364,
0.0379845425,
-0.0114361523,
0.0202900581,
-0.0639699623,
0.046721939,
0.0368747301,
-0.0019059194,
-0.0095685525,
-0.0343242362,
-0.0880308822,
-0.0255782902,
0.0054425816,
0.041212175,
-0.0052818619,
0.0199433547,
-0.0211964287,
-0.0487400331,
0.0909264609,
0.0425430797,
-0.0529176742,
-0.0159332417,
0.0672393888,
-0.0292461757,
0.0111468742,
0.0257129744,
-0.0302517563,
0.0447289906,
0.0118367774,
-0.002588592,
-0.0019381074,
-0.0292014629,
-0.0176225044,
-0.0103960866,
0.0591794029,
0.0105191376,
0.0474620089,
-0.0054462617,
0.0485464633,
-0.0012214743,
0.0027063945,
-0.045498047,
-0.0027378516,
0.0071216561,
-0.0044852239,
-0.0180730261,
0.0465040952,
-0.0218228586,
-0.0071950932,
-0.0050864969,
0.0456963666,
-0.0032868495,
-0.025748441,
-0.0036051187,
0.0273118652,
-0.0399823897,
-0.0521719977,
-0.0065085189,
0.005529739,
-0.0136458641,
0.0055669663,
0.0202335268,
0.0368378945,
-0.0289681721,
0.0341068171,
-0.098518908,
0.0378250964,
-0.0026815264,
-0.018567726,
0.0526545122,
-0.0721133873,
-0.0135707464,
-0.0069614286,
-0.0175125357,
-0.0264738575,
0.049317006,
-0.0081906617,
-0.0193292629,
0.0004354474,
0.015173696,
-0.0279017892,
-0.0159985404,
0.0628840774,
0.0096505396,
-0.0032731204,
0.0544143394,
-0.0212988127,
-0.0618436448,
-0.0275077615,
0.0055888738,
0.0262243412,
-0.0041872459,
0.0149452137,
-0.0097372355,
-0.0435737781,
0.0473604314,
-0.0379679799,
-0.0305966083,
-0.0027048069,
0.0351807363,
0.0286712646,
0.0184166022,
-0.0090839285,
-0.0219032373,
0.0421470143,
0.0027612306,
-0.0390089974,
0.0166236218,
-5.472277382e-33,
0.0235356428,
-0.0173512921,
-0.0103080338,
0.0062011513,
-0.0335805863,
0.0268045757,
-0.0038558212,
-0.0228449237,
-0.0037387174,
0.0238545667,
-0.0357742645,
0.0023494752,
-0.0122770099,
0.0519251861,
-0.008996034,
-0.0096420543,
0.0632898137,
0.0025843107,
-0.0207135286,
0.0264707059,
0.0152356606,
0.0539757237,
0.0357720964,
-0.0014249728,
-0.0183341354,
-0.0152029814,
0.0245997515,
-0.0144679286,
0.0187658444,
0.0586205311,
-0.0077455412,
0.0304951482,
0.0513418727,
-0.0268157087,
-0.0281537399,
0.0868473351,
-0.0993684754,
-0.0498902984,
-0.049704846,
0.0155876195,
-0.0234151762,
-0.0260454528,
0.0230170861,
-0.0028884397,
0.0370652974,
-0.0553811118,
0.0346004553,
0.008887751,
-0.0288033187,
-0.042089738,
-0.0467249453,
0.0151887452,
0.0024901254,
-0.0134654697,
0.0298413485,
0.0342241414,
0.0218196996,
0.0683045909,
-0.0697110817,
-0.0189836714,
-0.0127920443,
0.0478282459,
-0.0108809508,
-0.0104460558,
-0.0173702613,
0.0051878304,
-0.0202443823,
-0.0076208054,
-0.0604930855,
-0.0005644662,
0.0227019582,
0.0209382381,
0.0480340794,
0.0026429025,
0.0759744644,
-0.0190521255,
-0.0681137592,
-0.0129709421,
0.0026792902,
0.0634748489,
0.0413444526,
0.0100563793,
-0.026709808,
0.0044788811,
-0.0094259875,
0.0450877398,
-0.0136965103,
-0.011132462,
0.0390989259,
0.0431485102,
0.0289837606,
-0.0037731188,
0.039809607,
-0.0467854664,
-0.0067786071,
0.0296124481,
-0.0031040974,
-0.0095660919,
0.0102985594,
0.0105889859,
-0.0560323969,
0.0112111215,
0.00593817,
-0.006052596,
-0.0244536754,
-0.0216269307,
0.0749865621,
0.0091230581,
-0.0933825672,
-0.0207516085,
0.0092125088,
-0.01074092,
-0.0064352476,
0.0415082835,
0.0351513252,
0.0286746062,
-0.0092685316,
0.0957392678,
-0.0099492818,
0.0073446082,
-0.0231849849,
-0.0060424819,
0.031546548,
0.0337832458,
0.0012679689,
-0.0272588786,
-0.0542855337,
0.0697284713,
0.0056586121,
-0.0912307426,
0.0046600541,
-0.0009917449,
2.436e-7,
0.0412408561,
0.0322769396,
0.0354838707,
-0.0091376575,
0.0206760205,
0.0172987729,
0.0326613784,
0.0655075386,
-0.0420201123,
0.0306862947,
0.0147629278,
0.0131181013,
0.0340206437,
-0.0108024692,
-0.108829312,
-0.0099832714,
-0.0937478468,
0.0120051624,
-0.0565970652,
-0.0378642157,
0.0695725456,
0.1275040358,
0.0154374177,
0.0243284274,
-0.0039335261,
-0.0288279839,
0.065978542,
0.0008714334,
-0.0030712842,
0.0126977209,
0.037444517,
0.0286105201,
-0.0195310246,
-0.0104554631,
-0.0295852274,
0.0390591957,
0.0010591854,
0.0528238565,
0.0016076829,
-0.0533728935,
0.0057326052,
-0.0105529586,
-0.009704873,
-0.0280080717,
0.0656279624,
-0.1068578586,
-0.0217688903,
-0.0318552628,
-0.0384413935,
-0.0097658411,
0.0558595844,
0.0305256825,
0.0156804565,
0.0218673889,
0.0351085104,
-0.0202548597,
0.0097523071,
-0.1419413835,
0.0051255552,
0.0236693509,
-0.0236341543,
0.0379800834,
-0.0797856897,
-0.0231618918,
0.0949475244,
-0.0140920077,
-0.0038978055,
2.301430135e-34,
0.0488981977,
-0.0242245197,
0.02778483,
-0.0066470448,
0.0029982454,
-0.046262864,
0.0382525735,
-0.0204129443,
0.068716757,
-0.0774889067,
-0.004727948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09059v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09059v1 | Unleashing the Imagination of Text: A Novel Framework for Text-to-image Person Retrieval via Exploring the Power of Words | 2023-07-18T08:23:46 | 2023-07-18T08:23:46 | Delong Liu, Haiwen Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | The goal of Text-to-image person retrieval is to retrieve person images from
a large gallery that match the given textual descriptions. The main challenge
of this task lies in the significant differences in information representation
between the visual and textual modalities. The textual modality conveys
abstract and precise information through vocabulary and grammatical structures,
while the visual modality conveys concrete and intuitive information through
images. To fully leverage the expressive power of textual representations, it
is essential to accurately map abstract textual descriptions to specific
images.
To address this issue, we propose a novel framework to Unleash the
Imagination of Text (UIT) in text-to-image person retrieval, aiming to fully
explore the power of words in sentences. Specifically, the framework employs
the pre-trained full CLIP model as a dual encoder for the images and texts ,
taking advantage of prior cross-modal alignment knowledge. The Text-guided
Image Restoration auxiliary task is proposed with the aim of implicitly mapping
abstract textual entities to specific image regions, facilitating alignment
between textual and visual embeddings. Additionally, we introduce a cross-modal
triplet loss tailored for handling hard samples, enhancing the model's ability
to distinguish minor differences.
To focus the model on the key components within sentences, we propose a novel
text data augmentation technique. Our proposed methods achieve state-of-the-art
results on three popular benchmark datasets, and the source code will be made
publicly available shortly. | [
0.0118254283,
0.0742538646,
0.0220632944,
0.0508063883,
-0.0145127168,
0.001047024,
-0.0257628355,
0.0289489664,
-0.0251777787,
-0.0190575551,
-0.0153974453,
-0.022875037,
0.0027358891,
0.0114532774,
0.0343241282,
-0.0730261952,
0.0133434283,
0.0322426669,
-0.0383826159,
0.0142264348,
0.0520432182,
0.0401801132,
0.0329531729,
0.0068967398,
-0.0388829969,
0.004531018,
-0.0064151585,
0.0525054932,
0.0503639393,
-0.0008584505,
0.0028361597,
0.0048074219,
0.0676810071,
-0.0236229692,
0.0000019826,
-0.0043648737,
-0.0236336756,
0.040462099,
0.0094712554,
-0.0229706261,
0.0509893149,
-0.049936574,
0.0545805916,
-0.0283403527,
-0.0022047171,
0.0330503993,
0.0623065531,
0.0762836412,
0.0877824351,
0.104909867,
-0.0460347682,
-0.0393248349,
-0.0091231959,
-0.0265144296,
0.0480140336,
-0.0232172683,
0.014046655,
0.0027549253,
-0.0299998913,
0.0498655885,
0.0093929702,
0.0332865342,
0.0100798514,
0.0248907208,
0.0232311171,
0.0164615531,
-0.0177594814,
-0.0195126552,
0.0239098165,
0.0446607135,
-0.0095178876,
0.0089842072,
-0.0256019738,
-0.0055988901,
-0.0230804905,
0.0266584903,
-0.0164273269,
0.0128546394,
0.0129834376,
0.0122927967,
-0.0792672634,
0.0151643977,
0.0149634657,
0.0119708022,
-0.017934246,
-0.0461379178,
0.0151010919,
0.006887387,
-0.0223595947,
0.0285835583,
-0.0387571938,
-0.0104691181,
0.0255833473,
0.021759009,
0.0103219664,
-0.0120200189,
-0.0459909551,
-0.0396495126,
-0.0229794383,
-0.0099468306,
0.0098182969,
0.0270621721,
-0.0446630456,
0.0400333479,
0.006354508,
0.0233731344,
-0.0109192077,
0.0346429348,
-0.0325757973,
-0.030365428,
-0.0059629045,
-0.0299688708,
-0.0321599655,
-0.0268015321,
-0.0257331897,
-0.0336938947,
0.0003463403,
-0.0301553756,
-0.0120044332,
-0.0236582793,
0.0052156765,
0.026269732,
-0.0739169344,
-0.0252733342,
-0.0123930965,
0.0282159504,
0.0131512666,
0.0193292592,
-0.0140381344,
-0.0013483225,
-0.0312670246,
0.0201528464,
0.032846339,
-0.0449969396,
0.0190846939,
0.0458885096,
-0.0821733773,
-0.0576476827,
-0.023124557,
-0.0284598265,
-0.02867659,
-0.0740308091,
0.0246014223,
-0.0366371609,
0.0399984531,
-0.0396953151,
-0.0049905051,
-0.0500559099,
0.0009106431,
0.0205332767,
-0.006097428,
0.1040920243,
0.0111788614,
-0.0040844427,
0.021995848,
0.0263658129,
0.0068635242,
0.0253366549,
0.0182185359,
0.0559139773,
-0.0052029663,
0.0445960388,
0.0167332422,
0.0554096326,
0.0374399386,
-0.0053196205,
-0.03509349,
0.0244756099,
-0.0115172798,
0.0558740236,
0.0277107712,
0.0623696819,
-0.0466299169,
0.0093370127,
0.0602614395,
0.0158319231,
-0.0349504538,
0.0449223518,
0.0346664153,
0.0498144031,
-0.0098688435,
-0.0227502398,
-0.0306499414,
0.041772116,
0.0355809405,
-0.0125821317,
0.0141397584,
0.0387129821,
-0.0491506159,
0.0094559863,
0.0341954678,
-0.0193989035,
0.0313782804,
-0.0000705117,
0.0461788625,
0.0237385146,
-0.048999723,
0.0615197457,
0.0247627907,
-0.0415948592,
0.0072796009,
-0.0105735632,
-0.0221336372,
0.0328885801,
0.0192419253,
-0.0202587657,
0.0348929651,
0.0160092693,
-0.0013407581,
0.0402914844,
-0.0359156877,
0.0362904742,
0.0296268761,
-0.0441600159,
-0.0329549387,
-0.0231792685,
-0.0120866327,
0.0206299443,
0.0169374757,
0.0244368445,
0.0523253307,
-0.0187513232,
0.0042603938,
0.0445741005,
-0.0079497378,
-0.011609219,
-0.0274423789,
0.0546039641,
-0.0595531054,
0.009512593,
-0.0518523343,
-0.0201621708,
0.0091708312,
-0.0080244895,
-0.0239119679,
0.0112802926,
-0.0469562225,
-0.058656916,
0.0146988863,
-0.0550305098,
-0.0339342318,
0.0542682819,
-0.0057449723,
-0.054376781,
0.0161026362,
-0.0616232604,
0.0150954425,
-0.045331981,
-0.0080436654,
0.0290100258,
0.0224040616,
-0.0072118584,
0.0502962619,
0.0039229081,
-0.0149447909,
0.0064372886,
-0.0082467096,
-0.0139831603,
-0.0427319407,
-0.059195552,
-0.0468647927,
0.0078946557,
0.0619777627,
0.0158398487,
0.0197372902,
-0.0388749428,
-0.0112380069,
-0.082063213,
-0.0147202378,
-0.0084931059,
-0.0318914764,
-0.0315863639,
0.0214019883,
0.0144075146,
-0.039992664,
-0.0629786551,
0.0060902918,
-0.0193116423,
0.0085460013,
0.0362473838,
0.032202363,
0.012336133,
-0.0222618245,
-0.0024227921,
0.027704183,
0.0543466173,
-0.0063850977,
-0.0423490666,
-0.0147765605,
0.0591647737,
-0.0097462181,
0.0371959098,
-0.0394467078,
0.0079204571,
-0.0196760409,
-0.0047375467,
0.0330501497,
0.0434838012,
-0.0073351096,
-0.0203909148,
-0.064734824,
-0.0029962142,
-0.0480994917,
0.0213488005,
-0.0049698991,
-0.0257713497,
0.0103435721,
-0.018661093,
-0.0061842841,
-0.0216035563,
-0.025146706,
0.0059416583,
-0.0618524663,
-0.0126345204,
0.0356338806,
-0.0340999849,
-0.0381319821,
0.0051861871,
-0.0036595317,
-0.0013524933,
-0.0640962496,
-0.0441286452,
0.0194191486,
-0.043083027,
-0.0170732159,
0.0185569432,
0.0023209658,
-0.0334748998,
0.0817814544,
0.023274105,
0.046400141,
0.0136836208,
-0.0313165784,
-0.0464132614,
-0.0142493974,
0.0166843832,
-0.0287118945,
0.0334568731,
0.0313508995,
0.0249355827,
-0.0304642599,
-0.0569093823,
0.0171804596,
-0.0576302819,
0.0053554201,
-0.0112117417,
-0.0206709411,
-0.0376501232,
-0.0557271726,
-0.0174759831,
0.0327581316,
-0.0060565192,
-0.0225140322,
-0.0035773902,
-0.0167391337,
0.0633784458,
0.0317202881,
0.0160472486,
-0.0532529764,
-0.0556666628,
-0.0514866002,
0.0409595966,
-0.0255235992,
-0.0055694864,
-0.014476941,
-0.0029827838,
-0.006539369,
0.0615513325,
-0.0054948246,
0.0080618104,
0.0968491584,
-0.0379992537,
-0.032068152,
0.0349501036,
-0.0119890776,
-0.0680023283,
-0.0567706712,
0.0219092499,
0.0090467548,
0.0012284138,
0.0290787723,
-0.0660688281,
-0.0623323806,
0.0122392913,
-0.0077655604,
0.0218438171,
0.0096620666,
-0.0422816351,
-0.0712027997,
0.009156011,
0.0089021046,
-0.0316672921,
-0.0357528403,
0.0088902777,
0.0067885122,
-0.0109715778,
0.0141782705,
-0.0073736729,
0.0020648069,
-0.0022378042,
0.0016590299,
0.041223377,
-0.0447745323,
-0.0153647605,
-0.0256123766,
-0.0258697569,
0.0231913682,
0.065860182,
-0.0048282319,
-0.0560972206,
-0.008794222,
0.0262024868,
0.0023393733,
0.0385482535,
0.073185496,
-0.0530332923,
-0.0134802172,
-0.0119885635,
0.0375004821,
0.0397990197,
-0.0211832989,
-0.0389275551,
0.0140704224,
0.0178440921,
0.0425394215,
-0.0305809677,
0.0001873185,
0.0278231129,
0.0267555974,
-0.0077457819,
-0.0193350837,
-0.0082316231,
0.0150788249,
0.0412803702,
-0.0436453074,
-0.061694283,
0.0151823433,
-0.0260668006,
0.0140911778,
-0.0163036603,
-0.0139543079,
-0.009918387,
0.0387821198,
-0.019262353,
-0.0245701168,
-0.0595565736,
0.0122218579,
-0.0489372164,
0.0819519311,
-0.0748534948,
0.065194428,
0.0387577824,
0.0159972161,
-0.0035776049,
-0.0538357086,
-0.0068089743,
0.017461516,
-0.0828093886,
-0.0200875178,
-0.0462934226,
0.0301304031,
0.0076348456,
0.0712090284,
0.035647843,
-0.0685102791,
0.059468098,
0.0599523149,
-0.0100292983,
0.009715613,
0.0042775129,
-0.0028652186,
-0.0334101655,
0.0244972352,
-0.0143423034,
0.0166012403,
0.002562901,
-0.0251264516,
0.0244224425,
-0.0302088354,
-0.0017759471,
0.0118353684,
0.0111113768,
-0.0076201498,
0.054068964,
-0.0281908382,
-0.0304076131,
-0.017924577,
-0.0390426628,
-0.0547865964,
-0.0425725505,
0.0108770775,
0.0221697073,
-0.0009235752,
0.0111858472,
0.0511202253,
0.0422881357,
-0.0641632825,
-0.0302959569,
0.0217342786,
0.0077259648,
-0.0078489957,
0.0342641138,
0.006812192,
0.0244695153,
-0.0196172893,
0.0309265237,
-0.0188593771,
0.0471569002,
0.0237362329,
-0.0139173688,
-0.0425936021,
0.0045240009,
-0.0243562479,
-0.0335310511,
-0.0792933479,
-0.0205667969,
-0.0162046533,
-0.0178296827,
0.0589487255,
0.0127578108,
-0.0321247913,
0.018763246,
0.0108479131,
-0.0278922003,
-0.0049687419,
0.0226626005,
-0.002437575,
-0.0074858172,
-0.0041904757,
0.0203932133,
-0.0030267211,
0.0139592877,
-0.0374677479,
-0.046108827,
-0.0211221594,
-0.0078683877,
0.0767696798,
-0.012917513,
0.0153336059,
-0.0357752405,
-0.0070413407,
-0.0239201561,
0.0013703933,
0.0246528406,
-0.0396642201,
0.0577984937,
0.0435063764,
-0.0040400447,
0.0013687531,
-0.0154537233,
0.0063670706,
-0.0145948818,
-0.0114092436,
0.0044740653,
-0.0054825079,
-6.07417604e-33,
-0.042479869,
0.0357250236,
0.0366178714,
-0.0282974448,
-0.1024806723,
0.024425026,
-0.0170191973,
0.01289427,
-0.0092978552,
0.0182063896,
-0.0051097427,
0.0008197698,
0.0189753119,
0.0808357,
-0.0491959639,
0.0504922718,
0.0617095679,
0.0098736817,
-0.0251526441,
0.0378315225,
0.0331892706,
0.0141411163,
0.074428767,
-0.0673628226,
0.0039255591,
-0.0170850568,
-0.0623246469,
0.0105707757,
0.0697862059,
-0.0001555406,
-0.014538534,
-0.0007668079,
0.0014555687,
-0.0337700322,
-0.0262214914,
0.0383229069,
-0.0426602028,
0.0232650433,
-0.0440174453,
0.0313962065,
-0.0621314608,
-0.0137805967,
0.0273826513,
-0.042486947,
0.068700403,
-0.0447745323,
0.0490246229,
0.0047227666,
0.0558999479,
-0.0371645875,
-0.0319744945,
0.029673405,
-0.0397185385,
-0.0263626818,
0.0396167375,
0.02505113,
0.0152833806,
0.0077069891,
-0.0502415113,
-0.0165778846,
-0.0012946498,
0.0047677523,
-0.0104746688,
0.0766021907,
-0.0166538637,
0.0619536117,
0.0244738981,
-0.0182438307,
-0.0409592874,
-0.0118742343,
0.0412643403,
0.0627133325,
0.0311614238,
0.1097934023,
0.031939283,
-0.0138500128,
-0.0497896895,
0.0499127172,
-0.068045266,
0.0104723079,
0.0211033616,
0.0439433455,
0.0095445253,
0.005054309,
-0.0276211854,
-0.0456545204,
-0.0266577955,
-0.0184405167,
0.0183468685,
0.0467357226,
-0.0232485421,
0.0401858389,
0.0724242777,
-0.0205558334,
0.0211619884,
0.0007767511,
-0.0429488756,
0.034306597,
-0.034286432,
-0.0031360856,
-0.0207482912,
-0.0758301839,
0.0654930323,
0.0426450633,
0.0039136284,
-0.003776816,
0.0584697314,
0.0317953825,
-0.052661974,
-0.009955436,
-0.0428543091,
0.0063563175,
-0.0101525504,
0.0673621893,
0.0091134571,
0.0154010486,
-0.031707637,
0.0142122628,
0.0259905029,
0.011512775,
-0.0231882725,
-0.0377907306,
0.0582002476,
-0.0299781393,
0.0035493195,
0.0605227835,
-0.0370050035,
-0.0628538132,
0.0530520156,
-0.0655266717,
0.0052380422,
0.0540506393,
2.641e-7,
0.0285696369,
-0.0132872751,
0.0688549057,
-0.0051102554,
-0.0084678298,
0.0563158989,
-0.004437923,
0.0602555163,
-0.0134952115,
-0.0233220663,
0.0620781481,
0.0487683453,
0.0583036654,
-0.0087217735,
-0.0378917307,
0.0239292923,
-0.0604251698,
-0.0291916169,
-0.0504106022,
-0.0282390397,
0.054269854,
0.0756913573,
0.0041494342,
-0.0321029648,
0.0110714221,
-0.0567559302,
0.134937793,
-0.0334741101,
-0.0203351006,
0.0005254942,
-0.0074716653,
0.0535006672,
-0.0044038519,
0.0133254668,
0.0114614712,
0.0504220389,
0.0880455896,
0.0362268165,
-0.0251284447,
-0.0205091704,
-0.0233902447,
0.0472086892,
-0.0263020061,
-0.0152638434,
0.0536043942,
-0.058081273,
-0.026614977,
-0.0288209524,
-0.0458168164,
0.0276217982,
0.0371290334,
0.0013367002,
-0.0419510826,
0.0481417216,
0.0604402386,
0.0316790417,
-0.0345644318,
-0.1271158904,
-0.0200608335,
-0.0146537349,
-0.0607667826,
0.023139609,
-0.0546169989,
-0.008973158,
-0.0126729859,
-0.0600037128,
-0.0086018955,
2.040496103e-34,
-0.0132689793,
0.0021461507,
-0.0180532299,
-0.012947578,
0.0202154666,
0.005556169,
0.0087669212,
-0.0163853113,
-0.0365990363,
-0.073231414,
-0.0319591127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09021v1 | Towards a Neural Era in Dialogue Management for Collaboration: A Literature Survey | 2023-07-18T07:20:43 | 2023-07-18T07:20:43 | Amogh Mannekote | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue-based human-AI collaboration can revolutionize collaborative
problem-solving, creative exploration, and social support. To realize this
goal, the development of automated agents proficient in skills such as
negotiating, following instructions, establishing common ground, and
progressing shared tasks is essential. This survey begins by reviewing the
evolution of dialogue management paradigms in collaborative dialogue systems,
from traditional handcrafted and information-state based methods to AI
planning-inspired approaches. It then shifts focus to contemporary data-driven
dialogue management techniques, which seek to transfer deep learning successes
from form-filling and open-domain settings to collaborative contexts. The paper
proceeds to analyze a selected set of recent works that apply neural approaches
to collaborative dialogue management, spotlighting prevailing trends in the
field. This survey hopes to provide foundational background for future
advancements in collaborative dialogue management, particularly as the dialogue
systems community continues to embrace the potential of large language models. | [
0.0849430189,
0.0558394156,
-0.0160542466,
0.0178105012,
-0.0335241556,
-0.0095676202,
0.0343949534,
-0.0316587128,
-0.0123451063,
-0.006618876,
-0.0335808843,
-0.0600302294,
0.0000815299,
0.0603342429,
-0.030857984,
-0.0675620288,
0.0245464835,
-0.0148945469,
0.0373832323,
0.0049096975,
-0.0139517095,
-0.0099270344,
-0.0418319851,
0.068882741,
-0.0403986275,
-0.005202401,
-0.0711778551,
-0.0328545459,
0.0094204135,
-0.0014092386,
-0.0149241062,
0.0298903435,
0.0482815392,
0.0693306699,
0.0000017956,
-0.0316333137,
0.0258603059,
-0.0488225557,
-0.0250755455,
-0.0348977894,
-0.006897612,
-0.0066836015,
0.0001396309,
0.0217233431,
-0.0552009009,
0.0031911661,
0.0146568334,
0.0573112518,
0.0594708622,
0.0520859025,
0.0140124625,
-0.0049781022,
0.0412762053,
-0.0566867962,
-0.0127936695,
-0.079684861,
-0.0031327198,
-0.0154373609,
-0.002289698,
-0.0155242048,
0.0010339513,
0.024470659,
0.0488069132,
-0.0872751772,
-0.0371685214,
0.0380364768,
-0.0236199386,
-0.0393029377,
-0.0246573891,
0.0974325538,
0.0392039567,
0.0345123559,
0.0198426042,
-0.0256588347,
0.0228838865,
0.0170903206,
-0.0341487229,
0.0149517376,
0.0098059084,
-0.0193400718,
-0.0139063625,
-0.0068978034,
0.0030863592,
0.0060391463,
0.0112200594,
0.0601665787,
-0.0262403302,
-0.034262158,
0.0351733714,
-0.0275724567,
-0.0002883557,
-0.0930124521,
0.0345672294,
0.0608409159,
-0.0650540739,
0.0251605883,
0.0023612038,
0.0131759485,
-0.0034233781,
-0.0130823599,
0.0463402793,
0.0186082907,
0.0136810141,
0.0470165685,
0.0464024134,
0.0366033278,
-0.0033427272,
0.0034364283,
-0.0164190941,
-0.0004158941,
-0.0572762564,
-0.0125360042,
-0.0586229973,
0.0209193323,
-0.0766542554,
-0.0595553145,
0.0033158017,
0.064867422,
-0.0006254835,
0.0500937626,
0.0248832833,
0.0703680962,
-0.0337104164,
0.0105771609,
-0.0680473223,
0.0323772877,
-0.0416305065,
0.0210298132,
0.0355800875,
0.0013664009,
0.0053884778,
0.013936596,
-0.0002576131,
-0.0019500935,
-0.0105533255,
0.055586759,
-0.0281905364,
0.0126917763,
0.0079945819,
-0.0323186889,
-0.011966872,
-0.0384597071,
0.041837059,
-0.0133323846,
0.0802975446,
-0.0513041317,
-0.0516906865,
-0.0607434064,
0.0069161342,
0.0176414512,
0.005687207,
0.0319708101,
-0.0074802516,
0.0091083162,
0.0859816074,
0.0307201277,
-0.0094822133,
0.0344448015,
0.0819691047,
0.0430247299,
0.0122266971,
0.0331745744,
0.0382794291,
0.0258362666,
0.0040090815,
-0.0004436576,
0.0140780713,
-0.0125279352,
-0.0209308378,
0.0583567694,
-0.0212295596,
0.0580009781,
-0.0380061455,
-0.0436123237,
0.0459840633,
0.0646613613,
0.0042985654,
0.0417203866,
0.0508835651,
0.0351292565,
0.000773621,
-0.0123360688,
-0.0181026924,
0.0477819964,
0.0543925539,
-0.0398475714,
0.0136947744,
-0.0142352963,
-0.0316927359,
-0.0631408393,
0.0499823689,
-0.0019122246,
0.0428967215,
0.0040475433,
-0.004347574,
-0.0149262445,
-0.0584015846,
0.0134477634,
-0.0168021917,
-0.0158581436,
0.0056476253,
-0.0287270229,
0.0389934555,
0.0378636271,
0.0288581494,
-0.0270497184,
-0.0656321421,
-0.0245547723,
0.0320640206,
0.0505075194,
0.0288569964,
-0.0381971896,
0.0399464928,
-0.0384695716,
-0.0116564073,
-0.0193530936,
-0.0267960969,
0.0270561762,
-0.0275518801,
-0.0144235445,
-0.0112201804,
0.0512236357,
-0.000346467,
-0.0042071971,
-0.0189222619,
-0.0037589485,
0.0019544673,
0.03578813,
0.029682992,
0.0328703001,
-0.017869914,
-0.016077783,
0.033694353,
-0.0154958535,
-0.0404077172,
0.0373603664,
-0.0596215799,
-0.0366199352,
0.0266908947,
-0.0070236418,
-0.0163058043,
-0.0215649046,
-0.0352931283,
-0.0593430027,
0.0679600909,
-0.0233314596,
-0.0148797939,
-0.0342548788,
-0.0032754007,
0.0286289733,
-0.0043856893,
-0.022009952,
0.0124035785,
-0.0203940179,
-0.0590736084,
0.0369421467,
0.0333970636,
0.0440596528,
-0.066143021,
0.0246828888,
0.0532819852,
0.0089906212,
-0.0081945993,
0.0264732391,
0.0289908592,
-0.0429707207,
-0.0321128331,
-0.0868691429,
-0.0214914102,
-0.0305832084,
-0.0116040418,
-0.0054251808,
0.0090530729,
0.0053241015,
-0.0229044873,
-0.0357172117,
0.0240562223,
0.0561264679,
-0.0432674028,
0.0544601679,
0.0734702349,
-0.0258694608,
-0.0522045344,
0.0127259623,
-0.0028188091,
-0.0092663504,
0.0299270935,
-0.0294662789,
-0.0291764624,
-0.0016333674,
-0.0861022696,
0.0749543384,
-0.033595562,
-0.0476865768,
0.0378682949,
-0.0047779521,
-0.004615075,
0.068707779,
0.006714432,
0.0480866171,
0.0240455084,
-0.020888146,
-0.0528782606,
0.0896500275,
-0.0132658398,
0.018811617,
-0.0473288745,
0.0278739519,
0.0270538907,
0.0271897335,
0.0007943302,
0.0483829863,
-0.0357149988,
0.0153341247,
0.0467005596,
-0.0662386045,
0.001509044,
-0.037821237,
-0.0397186391,
0.0421717092,
-0.0269496255,
-0.0006642143,
0.0674167275,
0.0099726412,
-0.0288683232,
-0.0482580587,
-0.0328455195,
-0.0580543205,
0.0473988466,
-0.0341017023,
0.0181194264,
-0.0009229773,
-0.0347815305,
-0.0313601047,
-0.0031637205,
-0.0173330624,
-0.0115592312,
0.0133360317,
-0.0699080601,
-0.0142159928,
-0.000162164,
-0.0227103271,
-0.0506613404,
-0.0084093539,
-0.0184603687,
0.0131772486,
0.0190331861,
-0.0233252961,
-0.0052656755,
-0.014082185,
0.0024734852,
0.0473302454,
0.0351790451,
0.0011399233,
-0.0516345501,
0.0156743973,
0.024283329,
0.0580120571,
-0.0189118311,
0.0085836146,
0.0439440459,
0.0219923854,
0.045244284,
-0.0046495851,
-0.012400398,
0.0057329186,
0.0164457541,
0.012704839,
-0.006038276,
0.0236626919,
0.0308344401,
-0.0349314697,
-0.027205877,
0.0873766169,
0.0489020906,
-0.0619373247,
-0.0203386527,
-0.0410427116,
0.011553267,
-0.0129354903,
0.0263572652,
-0.0614067391,
0.0026355004,
-0.0250024274,
0.0003278176,
0.0060463925,
-0.0618235469,
-0.0085457684,
-0.1010226011,
0.0304144155,
-0.0232834052,
-0.0086051263,
0.0168291628,
0.0027759511,
0.0174272023,
0.0095609678,
0.0227310304,
-0.025938265,
0.0474497266,
-0.0332084745,
0.0205182172,
-0.0171446744,
0.0081464089,
-0.005541991,
-0.0573352911,
0.063893795,
0.0995938629,
0.076605618,
0.0222037099,
0.0104697933,
0.0077967886,
0.0500724465,
0.0298763607,
-0.0094935047,
0.0419688374,
-0.0144380871,
0.0037500146,
0.0194565114,
0.0345585831,
-0.0367538072,
-0.0071601011,
0.0406242795,
0.0368543118,
-0.0842755362,
0.0130576976,
-0.003951265,
0.0656954423,
0.0398048721,
0.0415939204,
0.0276355967,
-0.0511194728,
-0.0308089908,
-0.0253516957,
0.0022799128,
-0.0863899365,
0.0221754536,
-0.0289661046,
0.018819252,
0.0327690989,
-0.0577127561,
-0.0882424638,
0.0621976629,
0.0097557837,
0.0074749421,
-0.038284529,
0.0208688714,
0.0061551481,
0.0248099435,
-0.0171139799,
-0.0010076279,
-0.0074265492,
-0.0473781899,
-0.0221891645,
0.0185926929,
-0.0155990496,
0.0005799318,
0.0254912674,
-0.0776496902,
-0.0489426218,
-0.033377856,
0.0559932292,
0.0148635264,
0.0265152957,
0.0056325584,
-0.0735705793,
-0.0043849288,
0.0085631488,
-0.0057520042,
-0.0059308265,
0.0186499283,
0.0689633936,
-0.0307137668,
0.045994062,
-0.0207113251,
-0.0037665409,
0.001515053,
0.0294374321,
-0.0562927164,
-0.1022567153,
0.005375688,
-0.0639754757,
-0.0069477619,
0.0036884632,
-0.042027384,
-0.0302079432,
0.025774302,
-0.004845947,
-0.0241312962,
-0.0727806091,
0.0149095571,
-0.0152722504,
-0.0043108691,
0.0145388013,
0.026032595,
0.0176010784,
0.0546152256,
-0.0275421496,
-0.0084878653,
0.0350603648,
0.0049254824,
-0.0232884176,
0.0397412181,
0.0227209162,
0.0356057845,
0.0207020137,
0.0369942933,
0.0004177118,
0.1080392972,
0.0223858692,
-0.027985733,
0.0091245715,
0.0459733345,
-0.0854397863,
-0.0931280181,
0.0345203206,
0.0354295112,
0.0451669171,
0.0432288796,
-0.0096628331,
-0.0505221933,
0.0304636173,
0.0160316452,
0.0407626778,
-0.0235656872,
-0.0260797571,
0.0063607004,
0.0260348823,
-0.0040022461,
0.0118732359,
0.0343228281,
-0.0120899184,
0.0208659265,
-0.0184766427,
0.026218703,
-0.0481492244,
-0.0189722292,
-0.005148198,
0.047990188,
-0.0096171536,
0.0010524165,
-0.0350615047,
-0.0295687672,
0.0100354003,
0.02618769,
0.0039561582,
-0.0236138292,
0.0382756181,
0.0230059065,
-0.003165514,
-0.0087945377,
-0.0240151789,
0.0163637977,
-0.016165046,
-0.0294805299,
-0.0690587685,
-4.963413224e-33,
-0.0474149883,
-0.0456264466,
0.0474235229,
0.0176328123,
-0.0369746648,
-0.0587157384,
-0.0534632131,
0.0066246344,
-0.0152158597,
0.0134906033,
-0.0378515646,
0.0233295485,
0.0105925715,
0.0138975345,
0.0171044059,
-0.0323469974,
0.0431369729,
-0.0351301022,
-0.0217280965,
0.053038571,
0.0300083682,
0.0149403652,
-0.0078136399,
-0.0859219879,
-0.0208114423,
0.0399038307,
0.0153624015,
0.0540856048,
-0.0035105664,
0.0490563735,
0.008212286,
-0.0157315396,
0.0006451309,
-0.0206635445,
0.0179536566,
0.0321122557,
-0.0595278218,
-0.0275892857,
0.0024308134,
-0.0291558839,
-0.0684429854,
-0.0131492577,
-0.0081515983,
0.006393264,
0.0168878213,
0.018750364,
0.0067355679,
0.0237870123,
-0.0218540188,
-0.0038095699,
-0.0248147249,
-0.014525081,
-0.049472563,
-0.0731231347,
0.0098052556,
0.0171924103,
0.0265302975,
-0.0466057658,
-0.0553395487,
0.031225441,
-0.0259365086,
-0.0328013673,
0.0285843592,
0.0000987718,
-0.0069124862,
0.0659606978,
0.0563647896,
0.0457021296,
-0.0371184647,
-0.0178801268,
-0.017564673,
0.074861154,
-0.0047949967,
0.0353215858,
-0.0423350036,
0.0010043749,
-0.021112008,
0.042021621,
0.0345097594,
0.0404185429,
-0.0300087873,
0.028315451,
0.0059349257,
-0.0178338382,
-0.0360349603,
-0.0023748968,
-0.0120568555,
-0.02368645,
0.0264541693,
0.0373458005,
-0.0072821928,
0.009891632,
0.0585658401,
-0.0420790799,
0.0121162394,
0.0424508266,
-0.0009767822,
0.0461122952,
0.0035357147,
-0.0190368928,
-0.0686472058,
-0.0239620302,
0.0073219002,
0.0154932914,
0.0205815509,
-0.0022460876,
-0.0173893571,
0.0036636007,
0.0162700154,
0.0073056314,
-0.0336091816,
0.0536470599,
0.0041216016,
0.0258725025,
-0.0053849844,
-0.0143045634,
-0.0389481857,
0.0425183177,
0.0098084351,
-0.0234267507,
-0.0510266721,
-0.0459392481,
0.0215758532,
-0.0216349866,
-0.0476043932,
-0.0215101168,
-0.0172224045,
-0.017598277,
0.041146297,
-0.0135084176,
-0.0009707903,
-0.0243925136,
2.488e-7,
-0.0231539086,
0.020652961,
0.0741300136,
0.035749197,
0.0404394716,
0.0264051091,
-0.0125356363,
0.0163442362,
0.0145958858,
-0.0003456356,
0.0524806231,
0.0365467221,
0.0275793746,
0.0080788685,
-0.0841467604,
-0.0523349792,
-0.0652582124,
-0.0585619323,
-0.0462302901,
-0.0036047306,
0.0210396051,
0.0457383506,
0.0119135743,
-0.0184560902,
-0.0132855754,
-0.0231646076,
0.0411550254,
-0.0331988335,
0.0046978183,
0.0430590622,
0.0128835374,
-0.032392364,
-0.0252598617,
0.0080654426,
0.0153403524,
0.052546382,
-0.0093248775,
0.0611597821,
0.0202937201,
-0.080128178,
-0.0227312166,
0.0119506652,
0.0366474204,
-0.0119374739,
0.0135486238,
-0.0689774007,
-0.0176312383,
0.0189543255,
0.0313477702,
-0.0188231356,
0.0067061358,
-0.0057382612,
0.0165930539,
-0.0112885414,
-0.0089618228,
0.0017204398,
0.047021281,
-0.0788379312,
0.0068875742,
-0.0306246374,
-0.0653689429,
-0.012433487,
-0.03557707,
-0.023225097,
-0.0356102698,
-0.0048938142,
0.0142050497,
1.673124846e-34,
0.0085270572,
0.0045239381,
-0.01330336,
0.0523412339,
0.0419500247,
0.0204418562,
-0.009998587,
0.0148751289,
0.0417576097,
-0.0681621581,
-0.0381392874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09014v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09014v1 | Exploring acceptance of autonomous vehicle policies using KeyBERT and SNA: Targeting engineering students | 2023-07-18T07:03:29 | 2023-07-18T07:03:29 | Jinwoo Ha, Dongsoo Kim | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | This study aims to explore user acceptance of Autonomous Vehicle (AV)
policies with improved text-mining methods. Recently, South Korean policymakers
have viewed Autonomous Driving Car (ADC) and Autonomous Driving Robot (ADR) as
next-generation means of transportation that will reduce the cost of
transporting passengers and goods. They support the construction of V2I and V2V
communication infrastructures for ADC and recognize that ADR is equivalent to
pedestrians to promote its deployment into sidewalks. To fill the gap where
end-user acceptance of these policies is not well considered, this study
applied two text-mining methods to the comments of graduate students in the
fields of Industrial, Mechanical, and Electronics-Electrical-Computer. One is
the Co-occurrence Network Analysis (CNA) based on TF-IWF and Dice coefficient,
and the other is the Contextual Semantic Network Analysis (C-SNA) based on both
KeyBERT, which extracts keywords that contextually represent the comments, and
double cosine similarity. The reason for comparing these approaches is to
balance interest not only in the implications for the AV policies but also in
the need to apply quality text mining to this research domain. Significantly,
the limitation of frequency-based text mining, which does not reflect textual
context, and the trade-off of adjusting thresholds in Semantic Network Analysis
(SNA) were considered. As the results of comparing the two approaches, the
C-SNA provided the information necessary to understand users' voices using
fewer nodes and features than the CNA. The users who pre-emptively understood
the AV policies based on their engineering literacy and the given texts
revealed potential risks of the AV accident policies. This study adds
suggestions to manage these risks to support the successful deployment of AVs
on public roads. | [
0.0397589616,
-0.025037054,
-0.0366654769,
0.0317859761,
-0.0188493729,
-0.0271021295,
0.0228782576,
-0.017601205,
0.043537017,
-0.0586331673,
0.0638135597,
0.0579151921,
-0.0321559533,
0.0273642335,
-0.0232598614,
-0.0113291331,
-0.0147431185,
0.0079697296,
0.0273350701,
0.045391269,
0.0248776153,
0.0254279636,
-0.0131842345,
0.0638799742,
-0.0102222674,
0.006566748,
0.0203976799,
-0.0475079864,
0.0726300478,
-0.0807103142,
0.0007819466,
0.0391520783,
0.0439311676,
-0.0013179033,
0.0000022868,
-0.0372628234,
-0.0291659031,
0.0221857987,
0.0420549251,
-0.0104140909,
0.0787557364,
0.0871170089,
-0.0106943734,
0.0331666842,
-0.0444958173,
0.0093782153,
0.0169370398,
0.030460922,
0.0234210603,
0.0202417374,
-0.0339639373,
-0.032126613,
-0.0389549434,
0.0427597985,
-0.0225027166,
-0.0259200186,
0.054930754,
0.0257948115,
0.0118799657,
0.0039598714,
0.0076121464,
0.0167184044,
-0.0026295576,
-0.0191766787,
0.0484311879,
0.0563370176,
0.0214054491,
-0.0327486284,
0.045410309,
0.032328289,
0.0515434258,
-0.0410135351,
0.0403595157,
-0.0184928942,
-0.0144528449,
0.0626344234,
-0.0266126767,
-0.0491187349,
-0.0133287786,
0.0179174189,
-0.0592960194,
0.0132138357,
-0.0252877008,
-0.0001743147,
-0.0235373937,
0.0486047305,
-0.0292945802,
-0.045389697,
0.0510782413,
0.0041528214,
0.0066169817,
-0.0381518938,
0.0310920272,
0.0020707753,
0.0132195326,
0.016195409,
0.0432086848,
-0.0418546535,
0.04374272,
-0.1031451598,
-0.0081802486,
-0.0233136639,
-0.0046903035,
0.009861703,
-0.0123518677,
-0.0127824852,
0.046936769,
0.026455516,
-0.0171184205,
0.0255015939,
-0.0757835954,
0.0049907803,
-0.0461507961,
-0.0019636175,
0.0101849008,
-0.0007234103,
-0.0236050934,
0.0630110577,
0.0088358754,
0.0130422628,
-0.0731775537,
0.0514547639,
0.0512545258,
0.0331864394,
-0.0187863354,
-0.0422934815,
-0.0334517844,
0.0780417919,
-0.0286544655,
0.0627526641,
0.0716483593,
0.0237498358,
0.0656399876,
0.0046585109,
-0.0032953124,
0.0485843606,
0.00167588,
-0.0535382517,
-0.0633219704,
-0.0364828035,
-0.0166777819,
0.0240775049,
-0.0487228818,
-0.0935635194,
-0.0384949893,
0.0247830022,
-0.0281104129,
-0.006734089,
-0.0026788749,
0.0237695761,
-0.0217941273,
0.0100492416,
-0.047871016,
-0.0087101478,
0.0433144867,
0.0292968284,
0.0470563248,
0.0030703517,
0.0509354658,
0.0566940904,
0.0465923026,
0.0237874668,
-0.040586371,
-0.0271784384,
-0.0263171773,
0.0201825723,
0.0035967263,
0.0110591548,
-0.0544637442,
-0.0177461505,
-0.0253509898,
0.0192068405,
-0.0256867465,
0.0301242992,
0.0103763165,
0.0848413259,
-0.0134367524,
0.0138737326,
-0.0120979454,
0.056430079,
0.0100914324,
-0.0258562453,
0.0698821917,
-0.0242549852,
-0.0469245054,
-0.0188927185,
0.0237267129,
0.0040578688,
-0.0193484407,
-0.0564525649,
-0.005620155,
0.0066423081,
0.0885516852,
-0.0163467433,
0.0305632968,
-0.0617957301,
-0.0066791787,
-0.0386515372,
-0.0093723256,
-0.0081858234,
-0.0104061775,
-0.0189368054,
0.015568099,
0.0570432097,
0.0129182432,
-0.0183972474,
0.0080235293,
-0.012768778,
-0.0044662603,
-0.0187687408,
-0.0034248463,
-0.0022797799,
-0.0512417518,
-0.0229938962,
-0.0505000614,
0.0284338389,
-0.0108654117,
-0.0343990289,
-0.0187306236,
0.0767633915,
0.0272135828,
-0.0120715527,
-0.030627653,
0.017970724,
0.0320636332,
0.0326489657,
-0.0397411622,
0.0082293237,
-0.0116681419,
0.0593261272,
-0.00794941,
0.0295719113,
0.0498682559,
0.0023532752,
-0.03999101,
0.0422671884,
0.0236442368,
0.0779655352,
0.018221546,
-0.1061155796,
0.0186005216,
0.0202831421,
0.0336446092,
-0.003677401,
-0.022021817,
-0.0334330685,
0.0340724364,
-0.0066866325,
0.0011941816,
-0.0255823843,
-0.039593149,
-0.0285986811,
0.0277137421,
0.0254818182,
0.0136018284,
-0.0209812634,
-0.0177429616,
0.0642941296,
-0.00098427,
-0.0535800271,
-0.0039943717,
-0.0241119191,
0.0240758341,
0.0407993086,
-0.0124025652,
-0.0178375021,
0.0091685364,
-0.061073713,
-0.0277525187,
0.0041411784,
-0.0022832425,
-0.0010510188,
-0.0344903432,
0.0001205608,
0.0104867173,
0.0095351674,
0.0395251475,
-0.0276764464,
-0.0137019772,
0.0480495952,
0.0122824898,
-0.0474900566,
-0.0145634497,
-0.0165282059,
-0.0499846861,
0.0119319968,
0.115237467,
-0.0588869043,
-0.0477815941,
0.072692804,
-0.0125141423,
-0.0228109248,
-0.0061688754,
-0.0224013142,
0.0322459824,
0.0488146022,
-0.0010084505,
0.0187743735,
0.0370755531,
0.0382066295,
0.0434487835,
-0.0102462554,
-0.0351625979,
-0.0261315573,
-0.0392332375,
0.0144394571,
-0.0050586341,
-0.0281627327,
0.0596181713,
-0.0222899448,
0.0078196935,
0.0040953704,
0.0041247206,
-0.0291445944,
-0.0544392057,
-0.0170348044,
-0.0347485803,
-0.0399039686,
-0.0012890301,
0.0446373895,
0.0502192974,
0.0341143608,
0.025282532,
-0.0027602999,
0.0485840626,
-0.0818034336,
-0.0445497334,
-0.0201924946,
0.0275541879,
0.0073421006,
0.0193341188,
0.0513387546,
0.0260847863,
0.0296518579,
-0.0420478918,
-0.0081744753,
0.019215731,
0.047941789,
0.0020717802,
0.0079057682,
-0.0058213109,
-0.0133960051,
-0.0026318373,
-0.0584067218,
-0.0390346609,
-0.0011760059,
0.0411035195,
-0.039971672,
0.0504687354,
0.037405815,
0.0259161722,
0.0232136324,
0.0440411121,
-0.0306268632,
-0.0119792884,
0.0060168356,
0.0593556724,
-0.031459637,
0.0034186274,
0.011196983,
0.0044065518,
0.0692079812,
0.0142210806,
0.001113573,
-0.0709635615,
-0.045622237,
-0.0079726726,
-0.0260351226,
0.0190657172,
0.0371236056,
-0.0058917324,
-0.0038144332,
0.0263479445,
0.0234238468,
0.0423613675,
-0.0337187834,
0.0350312181,
0.0175767913,
-0.0085277986,
-0.0134366276,
0.0129022999,
-0.0940236226,
0.0094320541,
-0.0351754352,
0.0157382246,
-0.0657359511,
-0.0404587686,
0.0184468683,
-0.007665961,
0.0343001448,
-0.0342174359,
-0.0450760499,
0.0027390213,
-0.0789306387,
-0.0074039064,
-0.0142242275,
-0.0177302323,
-0.0311831441,
-0.0130246039,
-0.0036148492,
0.0688750669,
-0.0720716417,
-0.0630322918,
0.0071798856,
-0.0305234101,
0.0125520043,
0.0338533111,
0.0148500884,
-0.0492308363,
-0.0377909765,
0.0092010945,
0.0036768871,
0.0187605005,
-0.0026876922,
0.0040648733,
-0.0396919474,
0.0203069448,
-0.0323235169,
0.0022585511,
-0.0171655882,
-0.0459247194,
0.0372803733,
0.0787401795,
-0.0249442924,
-0.0250744931,
-0.0549812727,
0.0299734082,
-0.0049653761,
0.0141503401,
0.0124384761,
-0.0092288749,
0.0312693417,
0.0028168196,
-0.0062685739,
0.0164161362,
-0.054775428,
-0.0522579029,
-0.0103877932,
-0.0589798316,
-0.0199596714,
-0.0447533615,
0.0131777385,
-0.0055329632,
-0.0178482793,
0.0343499184,
0.0931278989,
0.0009294074,
-0.0524009094,
-0.0198635124,
0.0319383889,
0.0259511676,
-0.0034878664,
0.0191599019,
-0.0071776584,
0.0279575847,
-0.0488155484,
-0.0439748801,
0.0356021859,
-0.0440320596,
0.0332014374,
-0.031150654,
0.0192687288,
-0.0370021053,
-0.0245726295,
-0.0604767613,
0.0586159676,
0.0472390987,
0.0120180566,
-0.0038858696,
-0.0111506525,
0.001067694,
0.0199365821,
-0.0061065289,
-0.009063947,
0.0356130861,
-0.0118197799,
-0.0414993651,
-0.054067947,
-0.0586494021,
0.0037331155,
0.0388611965,
0.0261864997,
0.0131112961,
0.0446133427,
-0.0441162437,
0.0030419249,
0.017801147,
0.0071669025,
-0.0178180579,
0.007097831,
-0.049323868,
-0.0293567926,
-0.0346631035,
-0.0210243762,
-0.0200808365,
-0.016327396,
0.0423134677,
0.1022272706,
0.0446945168,
0.0810774043,
0.0066014603,
-0.0342658013,
-0.0132773463,
-0.0753007084,
-0.0064809918,
0.0212728139,
0.0201027337,
0.0249442048,
0.0138527472,
-0.0465546809,
0.0148030352,
0.052469369,
-0.0346252359,
-0.0414300673,
-0.0389270112,
0.0003200397,
0.0147977164,
0.0242636856,
0.0094284061,
-0.074257642,
0.0167886205,
-0.0066068289,
0.035949111,
0.0148797156,
-0.0182817895,
0.0349628665,
-0.0174307544,
-0.0477733463,
-0.0374182537,
0.0425407104,
0.0088262474,
-0.0167801101,
-0.0158794913,
-0.0696743801,
-0.0223649554,
-0.026907783,
0.0774350762,
0.0084850816,
-0.0340734906,
-0.0459762104,
-0.0649880841,
-0.0297152642,
-0.010510874,
0.0089138784,
0.0053569558,
-0.0086891791,
-0.0015126655,
0.0106678857,
0.0421246924,
-0.0045503899,
0.003934599,
-0.0306920689,
-0.06305971,
-0.0133054573,
0.0046124738,
-6.594349923e-33,
0.0033887115,
-0.0622732528,
0.0175051242,
0.0339404047,
-0.011220959,
-0.015304937,
-0.0147697357,
0.0299240127,
-0.0039829006,
0.0107806912,
0.0224436149,
0.0067092669,
0.0146093834,
-0.0248672273,
0.0408312343,
0.0091392146,
0.0145275146,
0.0294755232,
0.0029280628,
0.0137022315,
0.0390086919,
0.0072480896,
0.0205982141,
-0.1214182526,
0.074858658,
-0.014170669,
-0.0053086122,
-0.0171067137,
0.0349062085,
0.032241378,
-0.0089733899,
0.0424996801,
0.0408930406,
-0.0281236991,
-0.0107963439,
0.0755162165,
-0.0019160409,
-0.0530580729,
0.0046509318,
0.0020188785,
-0.0089411698,
-0.0220129192,
0.060647957,
-0.0257368926,
-0.0387159996,
0.0553428419,
0.1043738723,
0.0078844503,
-0.0173192024,
0.0041673537,
-0.0429884121,
0.0323723517,
-0.0233984049,
0.0547180586,
0.0136475191,
0.0270186514,
-0.0049511814,
-0.0070424308,
-0.0531197749,
0.0105830552,
-0.0155045586,
-0.0050837044,
0.0137695652,
-0.0330829918,
0.007784789,
0.0578968264,
-0.0306172799,
-0.0461768582,
-0.0050202892,
-0.0468430147,
0.0043266942,
0.052907601,
-0.0193768106,
0.0535604395,
0.0074665998,
-0.0721037984,
-0.0929346979,
0.0200705696,
-0.0187549368,
0.0010114153,
0.0729729459,
-0.0222188532,
-0.1122203395,
-0.0410873145,
0.0081531936,
0.0145688374,
-0.021208914,
-0.0743796229,
0.0008528318,
-0.0140434718,
-0.0433351099,
0.0214891154,
-0.0208034031,
-0.0402795263,
-0.0148720527,
-0.0163435489,
-0.043410413,
0.0044823214,
-0.0320358612,
0.0307889897,
-0.1226458773,
0.0098590925,
-0.0409194902,
-0.0026893015,
0.0392046236,
0.0198133178,
0.0009931085,
-0.0080345459,
-0.0282605737,
-0.0165986512,
0.0147037264,
-0.0673368871,
0.0039747404,
-0.0078885844,
-0.0045741452,
0.040420495,
0.0089997947,
-0.0147744725,
0.0125583764,
-0.0085989526,
-0.0220246259,
-0.0400753357,
-0.0325099938,
-0.018074302,
0.0255525652,
-0.003001353,
-0.0078975335,
0.0155710485,
0.0523520857,
-0.0398573987,
0.0102513423,
-0.0535160452,
3.033e-7,
0.0216950364,
0.0228387173,
-0.0488976464,
-0.0233585984,
0.0018621716,
0.080591619,
0.0201709419,
0.034363009,
0.0127416775,
0.0552882142,
0.0181116983,
0.0018234982,
-0.0495536774,
0.0577950887,
-0.0304671824,
-0.0156467799,
-0.0241308883,
0.0000490441,
-0.0457834005,
0.0640225634,
0.1041041836,
-0.0261367932,
-0.000241848,
0.0151035935,
-0.0281058811,
-0.0020146261,
-0.0076041697,
-0.0360766649,
0.0489715785,
0.0019462275,
0.0229109414,
0.0228046514,
0.016460523,
0.0525798611,
-0.012834182,
-0.0121934433,
-0.0138828298,
0.0274626054,
0.0048419023,
0.00483914,
0.0552410409,
-0.0575233623,
0.0145358779,
-0.0266689006,
0.0331231058,
-0.0526973717,
-0.0354509503,
-0.007266941,
-0.0023439587,
-0.0316317528,
-0.0120105827,
0.0407615304,
0.0104414597,
-0.0066916929,
-0.0286197085,
-0.03657322,
0.0089346822,
-0.0395921618,
0.0576334819,
-0.0191429127,
0.021320058,
-0.0673825815,
-0.0131242862,
0.0624797605,
0.0520883948,
0.0033475102,
0.0527567789,
2.200449431e-34,
-0.0169386137,
0.0383384116,
-0.0218353923,
-0.0163259394,
0.0019055471,
0.0508152284,
0.0190510452,
0.010044436,
0.0030548833,
-0.0327187665,
-0.0134448605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09009v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09009v3 | How is ChatGPT's behavior changing over time? | 2023-07-18T06:56:08 | 2023-10-31T16:13:44 | Lingjiao Chen, Matei Zaharia, James Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 are the two most widely used large language model (LLM)
services. However, when and how these models are updated over time is opaque.
Here, we evaluate the March 2023 and June 2023 versions of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 on
several diverse tasks: 1) math problems, 2) sensitive/dangerous questions, 3)
opinion surveys, 4) multi-hop knowledge-intensive questions, 5) generating
code, 6) US Medical License tests, and 7) visual reasoning. We find that the
performance and behavior of both GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 can vary greatly over time.
For example, GPT-4 (March 2023) was reasonable at identifying prime vs.
composite numbers (84% accuracy) but GPT-4 (June 2023) was poor on these same
questions (51% accuracy). This is partly explained by a drop in GPT-4's amenity
to follow chain-of-thought prompting. Interestingly, GPT-3.5 was much better in
June than in March in this task. GPT-4 became less willing to answer sensitive
questions and opinion survey questions in June than in March. GPT-4 performed
better at multi-hop questions in June than in March, while GPT-3.5's
performance dropped on this task. Both GPT-4 and GPT-3.5 had more formatting
mistakes in code generation in June than in March. We provide evidence that
GPT-4's ability to follow user instructions has decreased over time, which is
one common factor behind the many behavior drifts. Overall, our findings show
that the behavior of the "same" LLM service can change substantially in a
relatively short amount of time, highlighting the need for continuous
monitoring of LLMs. | [
0.0425674692,
0.0440516621,
-0.0205133073,
-0.0010700834,
-0.0503377654,
0.0116312001,
0.0222241655,
0.0270003472,
0.0427223183,
-0.0264211912,
0.0058146077,
-0.0429366902,
-0.0030401105,
0.0361774191,
0.0035108633,
-0.0377333127,
0.0600984283,
-0.0383280143,
0.0202924367,
-0.0238835216,
0.0100484379,
0.0123160696,
-0.0056448989,
0.0410861708,
0.0145517476,
-0.050271593,
-0.0075780102,
-0.034959767,
-0.0174046941,
-0.0563458018,
0.0125417905,
0.0616233833,
0.0080449898,
0.0408779904,
0.0000023773,
-0.0645757467,
0.0000968294,
0.0098989336,
-0.0313612558,
0.0691500455,
0.0392351709,
0.0657632723,
-0.018774692,
0.0557496622,
-0.0599367693,
-0.006586358,
0.0448564366,
0.0043380018,
0.0451386273,
0.0353803821,
-0.0007751116,
0.0196043868,
0.016393654,
-0.0186303202,
0.0252062902,
-0.0461519398,
-0.0038758938,
0.0165524501,
0.0123603744,
0.0151074771,
-0.0206513498,
0.0116635738,
0.0329131484,
-0.0186273828,
-0.0358819589,
0.0592655502,
-0.0540346988,
-0.0117955981,
-0.0098121352,
0.0266354196,
0.038941361,
0.0036818769,
0.0195658244,
0.004129706,
-0.021194702,
0.0097487094,
-0.0679067001,
-0.004343993,
0.0034451494,
-0.0228737071,
-0.0065234066,
-0.0414997339,
0.0155035658,
0.0042643929,
-0.0099733695,
0.0530622452,
0.0182162784,
-0.0306443647,
-0.0154647762,
0.0151943592,
-0.02025906,
-0.0562241375,
0.0033536521,
0.0151913278,
-0.0284592975,
0.0084441854,
0.0078246519,
0.0122514628,
0.0290765893,
-0.0362562351,
-0.0136277648,
0.077757813,
-0.0203121156,
0.0265069734,
0.0050562532,
0.0879209936,
-0.0096095996,
-0.0288003664,
-0.0079126833,
0.0403594002,
-0.0509373881,
-0.024285825,
-0.0229750425,
0.0538360588,
0.0094156871,
0.0018392964,
-0.0582660623,
0.0463674888,
0.0042883623,
0.013896835,
0.0063814525,
-0.0128925936,
-0.0168856867,
0.0054992894,
-0.041667141,
0.0561231524,
-0.0294743311,
-0.0209475849,
0.0189220887,
-0.0731359124,
0.018975243,
-0.0044508977,
-0.0194496736,
-0.0065341117,
0.0223300159,
0.0587590449,
-0.0178228021,
0.0069436994,
-0.0140411109,
-0.0397693664,
-0.0087101562,
-0.0623924397,
-0.0102991806,
-0.0662656948,
-0.0142251365,
0.0471978523,
-0.0165381879,
0.0172319356,
0.0005173656,
0.0439590029,
-0.0294199716,
0.0232164767,
-0.002795924,
0.0278320592,
0.0380310304,
0.0212982427,
-0.0034989233,
0.0510047376,
0.0081655402,
-0.0173774231,
0.0111293485,
-0.0659264028,
0.0158255771,
0.0631464794,
-0.0261722766,
0.0277081113,
0.0288849473,
0.0233297274,
0.0197525211,
0.0166770108,
-0.0062903143,
0.0575994477,
-0.0150061976,
0.0070106848,
0.0862156004,
0.0745915323,
-0.0353177637,
0.0517173856,
-0.0021844713,
0.0274509117,
0.0205595419,
-0.0079017226,
-0.0713051707,
0.0218288731,
-0.0292736571,
0.030505009,
-0.0052275113,
0.0384585783,
-0.0209943317,
-0.0300975181,
-0.0070136939,
0.0109818801,
0.0065328917,
0.042452272,
0.0355209,
-0.0611265376,
-0.0282219332,
0.0638268963,
0.009739073,
-0.0430848151,
-0.033267498,
-0.096494399,
0.0370814875,
0.0572882928,
0.0538035259,
0.0056471261,
-0.0538852885,
-0.0160904732,
0.0299750827,
0.0369362123,
0.0865605101,
0.0229537487,
-0.0445524454,
-0.0609556176,
-0.0052064876,
0.0114032542,
-0.0054403758,
0.015292136,
0.0451632179,
0.0266916379,
0.0057608322,
-0.0177443624,
0.003781263,
-0.0137941334,
-0.0336251855,
-0.0076512713,
-0.0293931514,
-0.0221835189,
0.0259646345,
0.0001620328,
0.0010415695,
0.0028039976,
0.0051768073,
0.0126695037,
0.0053470475,
0.0039632544,
-0.0673962235,
0.0279229693,
0.0529006012,
0.0160068087,
-0.0125202006,
0.0205780435,
-0.027604783,
-0.0226554126,
0.0310075786,
-0.0263647567,
0.0483207442,
-0.0287149418,
0.0109110847,
-0.032384906,
-0.0365188345,
-0.0348610468,
0.0645492598,
0.0015960006,
0.017152857,
-0.0020861658,
0.0241589937,
0.0104005197,
-0.0363336988,
-0.037212465,
0.0464092866,
-0.0017302419,
0.0205289833,
0.0171465315,
0.0461810566,
-0.0563704297,
-0.0134399533,
-0.1142304838,
0.0020150193,
-0.0033111547,
0.0370212868,
0.033526469,
0.0006399355,
-0.025418222,
0.0029932703,
-0.0498745181,
0.015454757,
0.028251512,
0.0711577684,
0.0144726522,
-0.0102034407,
-0.0113580842,
-0.0282331761,
-0.0169948693,
-0.0387762263,
-0.00010218,
0.0109429071,
-0.0038960245,
-0.0359401591,
0.0572518669,
-0.0601789914,
-0.0064086178,
-0.0214520935,
-0.0454137251,
0.0321051218,
-0.0299211014,
0.0623520352,
0.0513549447,
0.0107372683,
0.0206358936,
0.0147161875,
-0.0081959618,
-0.066837959,
0.0129518993,
-0.0037238533,
-0.0789334029,
-0.0046138242,
-0.0151641872,
0.0029614992,
0.071110867,
-0.0102887517,
0.0069584236,
-0.0429952927,
0.018407179,
-0.0530483611,
0.006457034,
-0.0271691605,
0.0320561714,
-0.0375839211,
0.0034087617,
-0.0083771711,
-0.0770188496,
0.0349834524,
-0.0029810374,
-0.0149891032,
-0.0550387986,
-0.0143584944,
-0.0125428103,
0.0811048746,
-0.0134615256,
0.0218427274,
0.008613484,
-0.0489137806,
-0.0653736666,
0.0130615365,
0.0186494701,
-0.0636194572,
0.0648249388,
-0.051183667,
0.0095220907,
-0.0175192617,
-0.05355433,
0.0019088917,
-0.0116478391,
-0.0413264148,
-0.0216440745,
0.0213199221,
-0.0370844826,
0.0266026221,
-0.0036222728,
0.0080064517,
0.0374581143,
-0.0325930715,
-0.0194913186,
-0.001534336,
-0.0403950214,
0.02101757,
-0.0004104823,
0.0199655686,
-0.0369440354,
0.0176026504,
0.0679775178,
0.0659840703,
-0.0306888912,
-0.0105496459,
-0.0089340555,
0.0401387438,
-0.0375265218,
-0.0593997799,
0.0659705848,
0.0528198406,
-0.0923428908,
-0.0127763283,
0.1185727417,
0.0113889789,
-0.0768969283,
-0.006982788,
-0.0333327018,
0.0408435762,
0.0372325405,
0.0342075266,
-0.0812777579,
-0.0002973671,
0.0167997107,
0.0184280612,
-0.0404111594,
-0.0355651602,
0.0013535293,
-0.1203755215,
0.0412009209,
-0.0110802809,
-0.0366557129,
0.03508991,
-0.0068120193,
-0.004131563,
0.0181991849,
0.0418657362,
0.0105873337,
-0.0127559407,
0.0135332607,
0.0113572152,
-0.114319317,
-0.0124914655,
0.0809594542,
0.0094260816,
0.0459884554,
0.0757598057,
0.0076210005,
-0.0342724659,
-0.0387731791,
0.1066734493,
0.0213739369,
-0.0010460416,
-0.0228504259,
0.0276331808,
0.0206522178,
0.0035812107,
-0.0366945527,
0.0241574869,
-0.0094606755,
0.0276404433,
0.0435972065,
0.0606287308,
-0.0255921166,
-0.0244597793,
0.010298742,
0.0010584833,
-0.0171632748,
0.0517644659,
-0.0056872671,
-0.0462814607,
-0.0417623781,
-0.0644353926,
0.0129292272,
0.0196208581,
-0.0324357599,
-0.0249177497,
0.0115378713,
0.0060354145,
-0.0287381206,
-0.0238786116,
0.0284805447,
0.0078218188,
0.0074214549,
0.0150964204,
0.0158168282,
0.027508134,
-0.0085940342,
0.0154438587,
-0.0244638678,
0.0092920419,
-0.0937820897,
0.0112168696,
0.0054786266,
-0.0019309645,
-0.0140436804,
0.0054492047,
-0.086738117,
-0.0472594053,
0.0230280198,
0.0308081023,
0.0432722792,
-0.0212887917,
-0.002597336,
-0.0171876308,
-0.0009491177,
0.0242960006,
-0.0404685326,
0.0321590863,
-0.0249451622,
0.0353866555,
0.0073365886,
0.0166362617,
-0.0217142571,
-0.0303075034,
0.0033614114,
0.0067095752,
-0.0156807024,
0.0082302494,
0.0100409826,
0.058454331,
0.0303396266,
0.01583739,
0.0191631187,
0.0137436101,
0.0041157375,
-0.0172015633,
0.0053105336,
-0.0217326805,
-0.0440467075,
0.0130500458,
-0.004500112,
0.005416207,
0.0069285892,
0.021274887,
0.0261892509,
-0.0495842546,
0.0227699336,
-0.0172329601,
0.0133069623,
0.0641810596,
-0.0197995044,
-0.0248156711,
-0.0009563883,
-0.0014753519,
0.0381322131,
-0.0028615203,
0.1051155552,
-0.013038177,
-0.0158715677,
0.0511258058,
0.0178311244,
-0.0647699311,
-0.1500685662,
0.0063744597,
0.0374524742,
0.0289200954,
0.0272844583,
0.035443496,
-0.0287641305,
0.0044289939,
-0.0367210917,
0.0052801999,
0.0394912809,
-0.0353818275,
0.0032565934,
0.0028566844,
-0.0204342399,
-0.0290061124,
0.0760411024,
0.0085306196,
0.0411049165,
0.0184527989,
-0.0189962909,
-0.0152387265,
-0.0235644188,
-0.0010276251,
0.0044319518,
-0.0073850085,
-0.0333019719,
-0.0692897364,
-0.0363557152,
-0.0399813019,
-0.011436577,
0.0085492898,
-0.0483843684,
0.0361360908,
0.0818179548,
-0.0244777184,
-0.0325356796,
-0.0174520351,
0.0111825019,
-0.0400873832,
-0.0026698203,
-0.0107592121,
-6.69586488e-33,
0.0001323645,
-0.0028922104,
0.0442886129,
0.0186087098,
-0.034419585,
0.0029864758,
-0.0276279207,
0.0266350433,
-0.0287296288,
-0.0216301214,
-0.0318187438,
0.0205540843,
0.0238323882,
0.0007165181,
0.0510715656,
-0.0412752181,
0.032978449,
-0.0097126188,
-0.041417338,
0.0450016148,
0.0099841217,
0.0092589846,
0.0802107155,
-0.0596584901,
0.0114527317,
-0.0044225575,
0.0359617434,
-0.0094260471,
-0.0290537886,
0.0370262377,
0.0034507022,
0.0555586852,
0.020765489,
-0.064243719,
-0.0163418837,
-0.0094722277,
-0.0082190763,
-0.0302650891,
0.0299763642,
-0.0130115114,
0.0163488463,
-0.0375786014,
0.0155285075,
-0.0090775704,
-0.0513250642,
-0.0307191033,
0.0106178373,
-0.0111606475,
-0.0119513804,
-0.0127978092,
-0.00248002,
0.0135427276,
0.0008630519,
0.0249681026,
-0.0772675723,
0.0328716151,
-0.0366739891,
0.0138636772,
-0.0376944318,
0.0217015855,
0.0170408189,
0.0418057181,
0.0572836623,
-0.0167522486,
0.0152146053,
0.0405202992,
0.0041888896,
0.0339089073,
-0.0230886303,
-0.0421954729,
0.0299626496,
0.0209353101,
0.0192006789,
0.0173583962,
0.0184675418,
-0.0454543196,
-0.0446348675,
0.0013160807,
0.0729325935,
0.0212886129,
0.0443791747,
-0.0105496114,
-0.0564457588,
-0.0453415401,
-0.0171337407,
0.0426008403,
-0.0291701462,
-0.0708470345,
0.0468571708,
-0.0231648833,
0.0156715717,
-0.0185822193,
0.0284525007,
-0.0215887297,
-0.030609265,
-0.0329562537,
-0.0340372697,
0.0415941477,
-0.0129532069,
0.0458378084,
-0.0852086991,
-0.0099234888,
-0.0466729179,
0.0218863375,
0.0206199046,
0.0356393978,
-0.0313359052,
0.0123683382,
-0.0847696587,
-0.0076276804,
-0.0282762889,
0.0226672497,
0.0115009351,
-0.0105421534,
0.0306641571,
-0.0324380025,
0.0354148746,
0.0344663039,
0.0223566331,
-0.0220503416,
-0.0695627332,
-0.0172468349,
0.0048535871,
-0.0257694572,
-0.0027081056,
-0.0005508606,
-0.0597850941,
0.0340896286,
0.0216365103,
-0.0189037994,
-0.0214492194,
-0.0019280878,
3.038e-7,
0.0237588733,
0.0603356026,
-0.0261786915,
0.019253226,
0.0243328568,
0.025742624,
0.0038235046,
0.0090751145,
0.0719947293,
0.0153504638,
-0.0148684802,
0.0092468821,
0.0259415377,
0.0380688757,
-0.0814001337,
-0.0202070531,
-0.0743613616,
-0.0160331391,
-0.091844365,
0.0435417816,
0.051485952,
0.0389756858,
0.0040190029,
-0.0041779676,
0.0051011494,
-0.0440643393,
0.0586240515,
-0.0554054417,
-0.0469839163,
0.0010883774,
0.0043686256,
0.0514164791,
0.0039927461,
0.0468516387,
-0.0049790223,
-0.0290329624,
-0.0247740969,
0.0636262149,
0.0161223784,
0.0185067803,
0.0160394385,
-0.0162821766,
0.0065666893,
-0.0922449008,
0.0770011172,
-0.0294401776,
-0.0366157554,
-0.01604289,
-0.0273490101,
-0.075451985,
0.0075438195,
-0.018579483,
-0.0162632819,
0.0265576113,
-0.0116748046,
-0.0203071292,
-0.0119459126,
-0.0199703407,
-0.0093109598,
-0.0029851738,
-0.0251252167,
-0.1191871837,
-0.0670748428,
0.0171314515,
0.002841437,
-0.0256640781,
0.0106728934,
3.033908216e-34,
0.0302917771,
0.0094581395,
0.0555299595,
0.0147398682,
0.0411003269,
0.0522849225,
0.057340607,
0.0220748447,
-0.0041096737,
-0.0317660235,
-0.0166195184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09007v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09007v2 | On the (In)Effectiveness of Large Language Models for Chinese Text Correction | 2023-07-18T06:48:52 | 2023-12-11T12:39:16 | Yinghui Li, Haojing Huang, Shirong Ma, Yong Jiang, Yangning Li, Feng Zhou, Hai-Tao Zheng, Qingyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, the development and progress of Large Language Models (LLMs) have
amazed the entire Artificial Intelligence community. Benefiting from their
emergent abilities, LLMs have attracted more and more researchers to study
their capabilities and performance on various downstream Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. While marveling at LLMs' incredible performance on all
kinds of tasks, we notice that they also have excellent multilingual processing
capabilities, such as Chinese. To explore the Chinese processing ability of
LLMs, we focus on Chinese Text Correction, a fundamental and challenging
Chinese NLP task. Specifically, we evaluate various representative LLMs on the
Chinese Grammatical Error Correction (CGEC) and Chinese Spelling Check (CSC)
tasks, which are two main Chinese Text Correction scenarios. Additionally, we
also fine-tune LLMs for Chinese Text Correction to better observe the potential
capabilities of LLMs. From extensive analyses and comparisons with previous
state-of-the-art small models, we empirically find that the LLMs currently have
both amazing performance and unsatisfactory behavior for Chinese Text
Correction. We believe our findings will promote the landing and application of
LLMs in the Chinese NLP community. | [
0.065421924,
0.0201014485,
0.0067478712,
0.0482723415,
-0.0419615507,
0.0014505384,
0.0126971202,
0.0123429708,
0.019181177,
-0.0585096851,
-0.0530322082,
-0.0627990887,
0.0329709128,
-0.032293994,
0.011152708,
-0.0327965654,
0.0519588441,
-0.0063820034,
-0.0083203167,
0.0183573421,
0.0163463913,
-0.0104408152,
0.0366262607,
0.0471965559,
0.0130057782,
-0.0560346432,
0.0328370854,
0.0471908115,
0.0255363155,
-0.0164651908,
0.0362397879,
0.0310435891,
-0.0522136129,
0.0620264485,
0.000001778,
-0.02766441,
-0.014829847,
0.0001169654,
0.0117367487,
0.0941445231,
0.0444697775,
-0.039303679,
-0.0726991147,
0.0268871766,
0.0144936563,
-0.0063544502,
0.044205334,
0.0818391517,
0.0480654985,
0.0825831518,
-0.0028870832,
-0.0017201308,
0.0364479646,
-0.011074651,
-0.0245894138,
-0.0190420114,
0.0480297878,
0.0339191332,
-0.0211317576,
-0.0272386186,
-0.0391145423,
0.0298589673,
-0.0172950905,
-0.0220214464,
-0.0192753635,
0.0018167075,
0.0113914162,
0.0168970861,
-0.0469560884,
0.0251285769,
-0.0405594222,
-0.0207733382,
-0.0347993858,
0.0034834517,
-0.0164472479,
-0.0134660313,
-0.0219604466,
0.0106569193,
-0.0086091626,
0.0260373224,
0.0427774042,
-0.0785381421,
0.0416229293,
0.0360779427,
-0.009890792,
0.0400774404,
0.0330601446,
-0.0733593106,
-0.0478268303,
0.0018866721,
0.008014339,
-0.057578966,
0.0588490069,
0.0268892385,
-0.0340170376,
-0.0097322194,
-0.0264300965,
-0.00855707,
-0.0098831933,
-0.0521602258,
0.041240491,
0.0312403105,
-0.0343373343,
0.0393008217,
-0.0412817895,
0.0551651046,
-0.0113906544,
0.0138429003,
-0.0277375001,
-0.0204159915,
-0.0299716834,
-0.0066348151,
-0.0453122146,
0.0084863063,
-0.0178799201,
-0.02941739,
-0.043315731,
-0.0162454545,
-0.0259999428,
0.0288566556,
0.0097958911,
-0.0255559273,
-0.0167356469,
-0.0418466628,
-0.0036675502,
0.0555210002,
0.0292255338,
0.0237178057,
-0.0057050758,
-0.0357946157,
-0.0015338259,
0.0063325884,
0.0319315046,
-0.0275531877,
0.024454454,
0.0387818404,
-0.0101149064,
-0.032205902,
-0.0481038466,
0.033279188,
-0.0180091485,
-0.0300250761,
-0.0467397533,
-0.0416820385,
-0.0383947492,
-0.026511915,
0.0580072552,
-0.0162366237,
0.0294679143,
0.0104516,
-0.0346547291,
0.0716783702,
-0.0007420348,
0.0315969102,
-0.0105319386,
-0.0407346748,
0.0197162069,
0.0220648758,
0.0355611704,
-0.0313573629,
0.0868523568,
0.0193111245,
0.0268872455,
0.0473024026,
-0.0760626867,
-0.0074726483,
-0.0224298351,
-0.0383439958,
-0.0020526173,
0.0235333126,
0.0272446107,
0.0741644949,
-0.0135043059,
0.0474335738,
0.0683408454,
0.018898014,
0.0124737127,
0.0175976474,
0.0305345226,
-0.0479158163,
0.0111969542,
0.0301249269,
-0.0525187925,
0.0037773512,
-0.0592057966,
0.0135757141,
0.0380971059,
0.0204482935,
-0.0344235562,
-0.0592224859,
-0.0542526245,
0.0043904483,
0.0178657845,
-0.0216282886,
0.0509066693,
-0.0070915576,
-0.0199919697,
0.0086411787,
0.0006421388,
-0.0278786961,
0.0165370442,
-0.0454601273,
0.0050821593,
0.1162054911,
0.0702946261,
0.0095223645,
-0.0148404678,
0.0072854636,
-0.0571669228,
0.0707250163,
0.0893606544,
-0.0203489885,
-0.0362072065,
-0.0511043854,
0.0124869784,
0.0274663698,
0.0151328566,
-0.013564351,
0.0582026467,
-0.0081495922,
0.009796245,
-0.0057206373,
-0.074380286,
0.0235917196,
-0.0344523713,
-0.0079780063,
0.0024367229,
-0.0016456868,
0.014381947,
0.0186243672,
-0.0519364849,
0.0158471242,
-0.0276405327,
-0.0289581995,
-0.0584471412,
-0.0078665121,
-0.009416976,
-0.0551863424,
0.0800464526,
-0.0173919145,
-0.031929113,
0.0516741127,
-0.040104568,
-0.0319349766,
-0.0183923151,
-0.0187520329,
-0.0113406507,
-0.091110006,
0.0768330544,
-0.0006804339,
-0.0009607306,
-0.0139963347,
0.0190515015,
0.0058588032,
0.0347085968,
0.0166972727,
0.0324741043,
-0.0058273333,
-0.0358965844,
-0.0615982786,
-0.0089774039,
0.0079032918,
0.0379897244,
0.0200789478,
0.0232324079,
0.0019285131,
-0.041213721,
-0.0553760529,
0.0244046506,
-0.0572510771,
0.0004154799,
0.0398869067,
-0.0066906339,
-0.0055585848,
-0.0164571647,
-0.0036697919,
0.0092166085,
0.0244018435,
0.0135471364,
0.0592782497,
-0.0424439833,
-0.0234048348,
-0.0475463159,
-0.0092587611,
-0.0123323398,
-0.0193262827,
-0.0094608208,
-0.0831700191,
-0.0856832117,
0.0351328105,
-0.0109199639,
0.0285689402,
0.03018119,
-0.0642944649,
-0.03976788,
-0.0167179387,
0.0777146146,
0.0258024596,
-0.0061661312,
-0.0067629605,
0.0307484344,
-0.0131762577,
0.016313646,
0.0200967491,
0.0193274971,
-0.0415744074,
-0.0435954891,
-0.0433407314,
-0.015187202,
0.0800340623,
0.0048685423,
-0.0269913059,
-0.013385741,
-0.0340277068,
-0.0374039635,
0.0146946022,
-0.0045194621,
0.0051413812,
-0.0220547207,
-0.0109821092,
-0.06580621,
-0.013823363,
0.0534596294,
-0.0122499689,
0.014189017,
-0.0499893688,
0.0032010362,
-0.0377525613,
0.0141771389,
-0.002335008,
0.0336455517,
-0.0176227652,
-0.0505180694,
-0.025414316,
0.0140283471,
0.0038238443,
-0.0260705296,
0.0456873551,
-0.0456490815,
0.0388252027,
-0.0285627767,
-0.0288611222,
0.0014833704,
-0.0055888859,
-0.0559140183,
0.0282679815,
0.0398395844,
-0.0086087855,
-0.0066999332,
0.0488274582,
0.0115448777,
0.0505665839,
0.0057310113,
0.0069749723,
-0.0183358416,
0.0090920022,
0.007249543,
0.058681,
0.0338151865,
-0.0130435871,
0.0652295128,
0.045950368,
0.0278883725,
0.0156026147,
0.0035640735,
-0.0071401196,
0.0335518606,
-0.048541937,
-0.006505202,
-0.0060927258,
0.0741842836,
-0.0788560063,
-0.0154362153,
0.1107734442,
0.0334640071,
-0.0130824251,
-0.0076983455,
0.0011224106,
-0.061994873,
0.0154287573,
-0.0146479541,
-0.0883138701,
-0.031101089,
0.0497879758,
-0.0289588962,
-0.0150361974,
0.0037690829,
0.0203698184,
-0.1464148313,
0.0593480133,
0.0319635086,
-0.0000870866,
-0.0632503033,
-0.0047850073,
0.023981167,
0.0036505701,
0.0531257205,
0.0361880697,
-0.0162666477,
-0.0578155555,
-0.014485145,
-0.0347566307,
-0.0689755231,
0.0095839584,
-0.0684425607,
0.0392097048,
0.0659612864,
0.0202667825,
0.0150837628,
0.020602487,
0.0390560664,
0.0001908204,
-0.0008091958,
0.0027880548,
0.0155499149,
0.0214064568,
-0.0219549965,
-0.0042561009,
0.0256703738,
-0.0189098511,
0.0083284536,
0.0241781622,
0.0331478082,
-0.0067072562,
-0.0105111422,
0.0087244241,
0.0083356006,
-0.0285324492,
0.0805233791,
0.0169770829,
-0.0479435734,
-0.0589497797,
-0.0501163602,
-0.0486101285,
-0.0535264798,
-0.0096389363,
0.064059332,
-0.0482832827,
0.0094744926,
-0.0630783141,
-0.0436692014,
0.0066073281,
-0.0465825647,
0.0274422672,
0.0108367102,
0.0258990247,
0.0156305209,
0.0104418518,
-0.0380683206,
-0.0361144431,
0.0324125029,
-0.0786597356,
0.0157509092,
0.0114684869,
-0.0092083169,
0.0203888863,
-0.008193423,
-0.0592946187,
-0.0371589102,
-0.0078120246,
-0.0094018709,
0.0041812696,
0.0156294256,
-0.0437039062,
-0.0394615829,
0.0028427804,
0.0245282277,
-0.0091082044,
0.042187877,
-0.0058680675,
-0.0198313314,
-0.0108834757,
0.0227967557,
-0.0255437195,
0.0319980755,
0.0335071646,
0.075079307,
-0.0109880101,
-0.0005521993,
0.041767478,
0.0501339808,
0.0282254256,
0.0163835883,
0.0378759056,
-0.062541388,
0.0417212062,
-0.0237490498,
-0.0512593612,
-0.0093755703,
-0.0203836225,
0.0582988746,
-0.0168695226,
-0.0498738885,
0.034727715,
0.0035809472,
0.0041774954,
-0.0326876082,
-0.0200762358,
-0.015696289,
0.0109505281,
0.0058422145,
-0.0294595473,
-0.0164596383,
0.0175517052,
0.0324815772,
-0.0027231439,
0.0131031591,
0.0195253491,
0.0095072966,
0.0156332385,
-0.0366686434,
0.0107461568,
-0.0661787987,
-0.013038476,
-0.0195737593,
0.047087308,
0.1198337376,
0.0044558197,
0.048112765,
-0.0459957942,
-0.0439879484,
-0.0634596571,
0.0062575904,
0.0495366417,
-0.009146696,
-0.0138451047,
-0.000538984,
-0.0098403674,
-0.0241231173,
0.0648414865,
0.0023343849,
0.0691248104,
0.0122090727,
-0.0443192087,
-0.0157307591,
-0.0366430096,
-0.0015689089,
-0.0417191871,
-0.0304744393,
0.0088206325,
-0.0356538929,
-0.056772586,
0.0105706686,
0.0228881147,
0.0104161417,
-0.021359209,
-0.0564666502,
0.048403684,
0.0222249087,
0.0143115669,
-0.0618148111,
-0.0203725323,
0.0194224492,
-0.0068341936,
-0.0143914279,
-5.811075425e-33,
-0.0309654307,
0.0214770492,
0.0085591776,
-0.0200771652,
0.0002232592,
0.0010613172,
-0.0442144163,
-0.0199458264,
-0.0202633552,
0.0160009414,
-0.0421964824,
0.0330220386,
0.0176904388,
0.0245802198,
0.0285598002,
0.0409049578,
0.0999523625,
0.0036755484,
0.0133347083,
-0.0400036164,
0.0318465754,
0.0471849181,
0.0480290465,
-0.0204709042,
0.0265774056,
0.0188292712,
-0.0222381707,
0.0235678591,
-0.0052955849,
0.0625693724,
-0.0022555701,
0.0460703969,
0.0507311933,
0.0063272719,
-0.0413256697,
-0.0081586335,
-0.1070311591,
0.0066019497,
-0.008834742,
0.0498009212,
-0.0079906732,
-0.0342271663,
0.0473265983,
-0.0121427048,
-0.0037379067,
-0.0009960502,
0.0121911829,
-0.0776486471,
0.0284436531,
0.0061771544,
-0.0535994768,
0.0320766382,
0.0238985717,
0.0007706719,
-0.0148711018,
0.0012387423,
-0.0365615599,
0.0461158492,
-0.0609657653,
-0.0109376907,
0.05576865,
0.0867721587,
0.0090275779,
-0.0066172616,
-0.0189013742,
0.0133937085,
0.0036362286,
0.0137898698,
-0.0033273066,
-0.017933419,
0.0187900588,
0.0104574338,
0.0450885296,
0.0624023527,
0.0310223829,
-0.0432092845,
-0.0595206507,
0.0145811234,
0.020970149,
0.0214061867,
0.021429861,
0.0137426313,
-0.0180227179,
-0.0100160381,
-0.0098150633,
0.012809122,
-0.0460792482,
-0.003837212,
0.0328556634,
0.04290618,
-0.0174955837,
-0.0033002673,
0.014296216,
-0.0617608763,
-0.0391918011,
0.004047839,
0.0251597818,
0.0257057846,
-0.0265140366,
0.0179169234,
-0.0614894889,
-0.0459040813,
-0.0290636271,
0.0104967048,
-0.0426511839,
-0.0075326408,
0.0440440103,
0.0202130675,
-0.0827588886,
0.0248613935,
-0.0052116401,
-0.0059491689,
0.0263467543,
0.0148676317,
0.0050728787,
-0.0099980319,
0.0189958476,
0.0131566338,
0.0306375362,
0.005124195,
-0.002242638,
-0.0279961172,
-0.0328393541,
0.0144214872,
-0.0100054778,
0.0225440096,
-0.058805611,
0.0074208085,
0.0080093415,
-0.0433848985,
-0.0041838014,
-0.0071068183,
2.409e-7,
0.028415123,
0.0300771538,
0.0425563231,
0.0416176245,
0.031568747,
0.0005640141,
-0.0480718501,
0.0216473974,
-0.0169628188,
0.0377958007,
0.0378660597,
0.0156897735,
0.0827258825,
-0.0106095569,
-0.027428437,
0.0214484949,
-0.0371753015,
0.0182290096,
-0.0231795721,
-0.0145099293,
-0.016780179,
0.075327374,
-0.0262470171,
0.0151535533,
-0.0038256247,
-0.0897923633,
0.0476592556,
0.0042113755,
-0.0350321084,
0.0638066679,
0.0486270152,
0.0472686924,
0.014873879,
-0.0122611411,
-0.0100597572,
0.0238213427,
0.0440942124,
0.0791686475,
-0.006455346,
0.0419828668,
-0.0186020415,
-0.0016027105,
-0.0115087368,
-0.0341319591,
0.0533652045,
-0.0008004403,
0.0285478048,
-0.025920745,
-0.0105305081,
-0.0055552856,
0.0086758705,
-0.0327167176,
-0.0408984125,
0.0359438397,
0.023409456,
0.0373717621,
-0.0263752658,
-0.0438483208,
-0.0324603915,
0.0057050078,
-0.0077893361,
-0.0402856059,
0.0049723997,
-0.0250684489,
0.0122606941,
-0.0509123914,
-0.0184094086,
1.955070954e-34,
0.0473669097,
-0.0250031389,
-0.0000591574,
0.043732807,
0.0597249977,
-0.024634501,
-0.0351967886,
0.0043516709,
-0.0396820232,
-0.0585161746,
-0.0280085858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10274v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10274v2 | Zero-shot Domain-sensitive Speech Recognition with Prompt-conditioning Fine-tuning | 2023-07-18T06:45:43 | 2023-10-06T03:41:30 | Feng-Ting Liao, Yung-Chieh Chan, Yi-Chang Chen, Chan-Jan Hsu, Da-shan Shiu | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work, we propose a method to create domain-sensitive speech
recognition models that utilize textual domain information by conditioning its
generation on a given text prompt. This is accomplished by fine-tuning a
pre-trained, end-to-end model (Whisper) to learn from demonstrations with
prompt examples. We show that this ability can be generalized to different
domains and even various prompt contexts, with our model gaining a Word Error
Rate (WER) reduction of up to 33% on unseen datasets from various domains, such
as medical conversation, air traffic control communication, and financial
meetings. Considering the limited availability of audio-transcript pair data,
we further extend our method to text-only fine-tuning to achieve domain
sensitivity as well as domain adaptation. We demonstrate that our text-only
fine-tuned model can also attend to various prompt contexts, with the model
reaching the most WER reduction of 29% on the medical conversation dataset. | [
-0.0307826642,
0.0310531016,
0.0175367035,
0.0063530304,
-0.0180835277,
-0.0073303431,
0.0796356425,
0.01057366,
-0.0059567424,
-0.0577447042,
-0.0845709369,
-0.0270402841,
0.0219150707,
0.040722765,
0.0266972426,
-0.0344055519,
0.0353346877,
-0.0338230021,
0.0035444966,
0.0017155815,
-0.017628761,
0.0090643726,
-0.0820493847,
0.0178858805,
-0.0023910052,
0.0063697803,
-0.0004512426,
0.0224339496,
0.0154049322,
-0.0386268422,
-0.0049754628,
0.0439317487,
0.0425277911,
0.011857966,
0.0000019056,
-0.0359989181,
-0.0281906147,
0.0027574769,
-0.066518724,
-0.0513365082,
0.0491895154,
-0.0147164008,
-0.0092251999,
0.0454337113,
-0.0155071942,
-0.0321559906,
0.0132707665,
0.0409812778,
0.0033958505,
0.0804359093,
-0.0190266222,
-0.002992946,
-0.0082775448,
-0.0339506418,
-0.0074449596,
-0.0700435564,
-0.0142651619,
-0.0718661696,
0.0184992831,
0.0047596497,
-0.0382090732,
0.0133628994,
-0.0225778949,
0.0219981186,
-0.0027282892,
0.0295698587,
-0.0140927527,
-0.0152598387,
-0.0265315268,
0.0776155591,
0.0359513983,
-0.0301159471,
0.0287371967,
-0.0229425058,
0.0040467223,
-0.0226758439,
-0.018609181,
-0.009932654,
0.0248037949,
-0.0211419407,
-0.041492071,
0.0443844348,
-0.0071503134,
-0.0080169654,
-0.0084468881,
-0.0017490844,
0.0047037941,
-0.0166749936,
-0.0164607242,
-0.0096034426,
-0.0102044167,
-0.0272976719,
0.0027836063,
0.012552009,
-0.0490936786,
-0.0108776381,
-0.0901706368,
-0.0487176254,
-0.0046298392,
0.0410895348,
0.0234315917,
0.0403824188,
-0.0414041616,
0.0069072638,
-0.0003283574,
0.0239162799,
0.0322183967,
-0.0121643795,
0.0029686007,
0.0181981195,
-0.0148278791,
0.0568726845,
-0.029332675,
0.004687102,
-0.0663866699,
-0.0210333988,
-0.0283809826,
0.0097960457,
0.0187560562,
0.0028688775,
-0.0197761692,
-0.0072959773,
-0.0764613524,
-0.0368923247,
0.0597030483,
0.0112670176,
0.0038629465,
0.0873067752,
0.0192391202,
-0.0666790754,
-0.0526310205,
0.0108037191,
0.0817204565,
0.0073611024,
-0.0069431299,
0.0795630515,
0.007955608,
-0.0796894133,
-0.0326295942,
-0.0383306034,
-0.0356761143,
-0.0479747318,
-0.0093045207,
-0.0390806198,
0.0216367226,
0.0044131926,
0.0154467709,
-0.0678253174,
-0.0029501449,
-0.0061920295,
-0.0204554833,
0.0750151277,
-0.0267634559,
-0.0187206175,
0.0268415101,
0.0143010262,
-0.0198760945,
0.0576127395,
0.0299681127,
-0.0388112925,
-0.0096412878,
0.0045531034,
0.0170492902,
0.0283846371,
0.0632206127,
0.0270885322,
0.0124081699,
-0.0019256131,
0.0471011959,
0.0135310832,
0.03470302,
-0.0028754834,
-0.0257103033,
0.004463315,
0.046024248,
0.0304674041,
0.0259077828,
-0.0183311142,
0.030839948,
0.0233014785,
-0.0374162532,
-0.0024829886,
-0.0291883275,
-0.0281350799,
-0.0207336787,
0.026792923,
0.030747151,
-0.0178087931,
-0.0473086499,
0.0026819604,
0.0175600909,
-0.0400405414,
-0.023988042,
0.0229980126,
0.045682095,
0.0288366862,
-0.079245992,
0.0299978871,
0.0160169993,
-0.0827937722,
0.0116624357,
-0.0147342756,
0.0164348166,
0.0233715624,
0.0243582614,
-0.043275483,
-0.0195167568,
-0.0671077967,
0.0659805089,
0.0489695258,
0.0174261797,
0.0111578023,
0.0700890198,
-0.0713322163,
-0.0073229335,
0.0251910277,
0.022611076,
0.039635811,
-0.0123978276,
0.0637211502,
0.0075205588,
0.0024919817,
0.0610733256,
0.001010163,
-0.0673852861,
-0.0622972175,
0.0361527763,
0.0123205418,
0.0491514131,
0.0419026017,
-0.0309784133,
-0.0027264475,
-0.0019408686,
-0.0141680203,
0.0223630387,
-0.0299130362,
-0.0768236592,
-0.0284269992,
0.0073742256,
0.0081382263,
0.0450483561,
0.0068228981,
0.0037734243,
-0.0638277456,
0.0007921642,
0.0296700876,
0.0130999712,
-0.04697451,
0.0331195667,
0.0203455854,
0.0189179331,
0.0007340056,
-0.0208161566,
0.0399267189,
0.0079019424,
0.0396592431,
0.0267961435,
-0.0017444694,
-0.0479747765,
-0.0142755993,
-0.0345526002,
-0.0326590501,
0.0496264659,
-0.0015047325,
0.0106102237,
-0.0251729097,
0.0131110149,
-0.0779652223,
0.0074484069,
-0.0274210982,
0.0145372385,
-0.0025880539,
0.0519234836,
-0.0330498554,
-0.0353598446,
-0.0080052502,
0.0009066448,
-0.0010408921,
0.0105277197,
-0.0167423449,
0.001550825,
0.0031038662,
-0.0083605945,
0.0487683676,
0.0089829797,
-0.0040788925,
-0.0320996866,
0.0114801107,
-0.027281234,
0.0922744349,
0.0347918831,
0.0358625837,
-0.0013988881,
0.0011188115,
0.000352892,
0.0190870538,
0.0038016427,
0.0499501489,
0.0131055359,
-0.0428438559,
-0.0115594743,
-0.0093698157,
-0.0408339575,
0.0116217313,
0.0109335864,
-0.0182621721,
0.0069815624,
0.0477659144,
-0.0094144791,
0.0496185049,
0.0284157414,
0.00359035,
-0.0608338006,
0.0131644178,
-0.0150896292,
-0.0251020957,
-0.0012690489,
-0.011611945,
-0.0432716757,
0.0253524967,
0.0188535377,
-0.0118523464,
0.0264181662,
-0.0751929954,
-0.0130197126,
-0.0524437539,
-0.0138635309,
-0.0073857857,
-0.0241788197,
-0.0372385941,
-0.0058868183,
0.074788928,
-0.0510247909,
-0.0368203968,
-0.0092832278,
0.0136447623,
-0.0381213762,
0.0505752191,
-0.0171941984,
-0.0002535785,
-0.0395400785,
-0.0554486066,
-0.051777754,
-0.0448208414,
-0.0336187966,
0.0117536755,
-0.0348873846,
-0.0158106033,
-0.0536091439,
-0.0101829609,
0.0060246442,
0.086790897,
0.0113012558,
0.0032144685,
-0.0435889401,
0.0482981429,
0.0293504521,
0.0316836908,
-0.0286968518,
-0.0027078823,
0.0588238128,
0.0187011678,
0.0455812216,
0.028671464,
-0.0157727469,
-0.015668299,
0.0265668165,
0.0179543495,
0.0041857827,
0.0656313449,
0.0735218152,
-0.0246374141,
-0.0121624693,
0.1254538894,
0.0103522195,
-0.0462803058,
-0.0282587353,
0.0170694366,
0.0071118381,
0.0008856365,
-0.0147894369,
-0.0822532624,
-0.0735162422,
0.0527546257,
0.0588091575,
-0.0125599774,
-0.0308118965,
-0.021054117,
-0.0933761597,
0.0127196237,
0.0313495845,
-0.0178101696,
-0.0221004784,
-0.0162102748,
0.0098596374,
-0.0144062927,
0.0272739846,
-0.0173884481,
-0.0216167439,
-0.0243127849,
0.0217551589,
-0.0035709809,
-0.1005404145,
0.0293037556,
-0.0242890269,
0.0624465868,
0.053936094,
0.0148601262,
0.0174350683,
0.0072932607,
0.0178272035,
0.0099612465,
-0.000799286,
-0.018498607,
0.0588972121,
-0.0279671699,
0.0145103587,
0.0455342792,
0.0871036798,
-0.0402112603,
-0.0221415963,
0.0545436703,
0.0371902175,
-0.0261488594,
0.0123710558,
-0.0165702514,
0.03814907,
0.0365544632,
0.0429802537,
0.0383122787,
-0.0366008505,
0.002799721,
0.0203984901,
0.0246311445,
-0.0431073904,
-0.0207645167,
-0.0407253094,
0.0042829444,
-0.0257053338,
-0.0375603996,
-0.0127424328,
0.0105937887,
0.0565514974,
0.0143764913,
-0.0265934281,
-0.0347745195,
0.0370695218,
-0.0270592608,
-0.0001397251,
-0.0294863433,
0.0365679562,
-0.1086540073,
0.019335743,
0.0708830506,
-0.0586881079,
-0.0208885986,
0.0229470395,
-0.046883177,
-0.0468477048,
-0.0080351019,
-0.0108076325,
0.0122187603,
0.0595316291,
-0.0218975693,
-0.0224567782,
0.0767250806,
0.0846979097,
-0.0772025138,
0.0496822707,
0.0849654153,
-0.0260072667,
-0.0463983305,
0.0239104219,
-0.0471462756,
0.0447589308,
0.0288096089,
-0.0186920892,
0.0103647662,
-0.053350538,
-0.0323413387,
-0.007810812,
0.096097976,
-0.0026791599,
-0.0010130432,
-0.0223329216,
0.0321714655,
-0.0153674325,
0.0527667403,
-0.0356649235,
-0.0192798562,
-0.0139494939,
-0.0223819893,
-0.0161790084,
-0.0035014739,
-0.0669591799,
0.0235348437,
-0.0506884605,
0.0673649237,
0.0319610797,
0.0071269223,
0.0195864122,
-0.0374060087,
-0.0152356504,
0.0155294165,
0.0316445902,
0.014749513,
-0.0147364866,
0.0678185746,
0.0029799466,
0.0345251001,
-0.0013255612,
0.0126410192,
-0.0477807038,
0.0128596332,
-0.0256441254,
0.0429894812,
0.0090790456,
-0.0093112178,
0.0025259533,
0.0127910431,
0.0171062667,
-0.0348417684,
0.0431990363,
-0.0210662652,
0.0142797604,
0.0175485834,
0.0073433979,
0.0041031144,
0.0258957446,
0.0804841816,
0.0217181481,
0.0374376401,
0.0082287062,
0.0620040447,
-0.0459875911,
-0.025681749,
0.0165108629,
0.0049108774,
0.0018928695,
0.0356152244,
-0.0636660606,
-0.0445058271,
0.0513619818,
-0.0274431482,
0.0065698186,
-0.0221443214,
0.0335000344,
-0.0135499379,
-0.0510796383,
0.0051953229,
-0.00148744,
-0.0009063169,
0.0210636389,
-0.029084947,
0.0141386455,
-5.827894545e-33,
-0.0305792615,
-0.0033844549,
0.0135662062,
0.0063198586,
-0.0107081076,
0.0120666111,
-0.0217267219,
0.0008906177,
-0.014449208,
-0.0186205581,
-0.0481068157,
0.0140586048,
0.0365865193,
0.0272175577,
-0.0274546705,
-0.0282122381,
0.0965419337,
-0.0323962681,
-0.0361614339,
0.0248205215,
0.0205886178,
0.0629443526,
-0.004372641,
-0.0475860089,
-0.0146131404,
-0.0127357598,
-0.0187808815,
-0.0406031013,
0.0703133866,
0.0256185774,
0.0126210796,
0.002691204,
0.0006732674,
-0.0665605888,
-0.0167331938,
0.0672027096,
-0.0993838906,
-0.0156997424,
-0.0391513295,
-0.0001844853,
0.0175388027,
-0.0282893758,
-0.0054077962,
-0.0032657604,
-0.0204240996,
-0.0502132326,
0.0053989193,
-0.0428638496,
-0.0111542232,
-0.0298667345,
-0.0080222636,
0.032819815,
-0.0062822294,
-0.08596766,
0.0466911495,
0.0698258504,
0.0067546968,
0.0166724455,
-0.0621492043,
0.0532870106,
0.0403028838,
0.0332611948,
0.0021840499,
0.0013024078,
-0.0479557849,
0.0277691875,
0.003943325,
-0.0303080138,
0.0337948985,
-0.0051668021,
0.0053411126,
0.0020178535,
-0.0102054095,
0.0693842992,
0.0053986362,
-0.0560104102,
-0.0517430939,
0.0024272031,
-0.0300314482,
-0.0266331732,
0.0293682981,
-0.0124915885,
-0.0600797907,
0.0047871796,
-0.0573145188,
0.0042064507,
-0.0254308842,
0.0119316662,
0.059358079,
0.0178370625,
-0.0083290935,
-0.0154747376,
0.0890365168,
-0.0215683319,
0.0241156537,
0.0244230945,
0.0272155181,
-0.0167493131,
-0.0293886382,
-0.0019407034,
-0.0423739292,
-0.0235530324,
0.0754727721,
0.0488810502,
0.0132870451,
-0.022934122,
0.0241491124,
0.0400126837,
-0.0715478286,
-0.0287094433,
0.0241330452,
0.0559487343,
0.02809011,
0.0528215766,
0.0211193636,
0.0177042,
0.0074678115,
0.0903549343,
-0.0196438525,
-0.0640907064,
-0.0044381511,
0.0126511967,
-0.0192717817,
0.0132306395,
-0.0541233681,
-0.0018612919,
0.0245881192,
0.0252087507,
0.0276571903,
-0.0095321452,
-0.0091034314,
-0.0027987328,
2.77e-7,
-0.0437291823,
-0.008504143,
-0.0113739083,
-0.0182177927,
0.022353325,
0.0738741234,
-0.0019376596,
0.0517871939,
-0.0321808159,
0.0252958275,
0.0225940067,
-0.0333223045,
0.0686319023,
-0.0137499291,
-0.137593776,
-0.011347129,
-0.0135482932,
0.0374736488,
-0.0180762634,
-0.0147052053,
0.0259041376,
0.0611512624,
-0.0170246568,
-0.0057525411,
0.0214334875,
0.0046079964,
0.0297465976,
0.006625114,
0.0057058083,
0.0002453871,
-0.0287689306,
-0.0254273228,
-0.0161310546,
0.0292304289,
-0.0585374683,
0.0394446738,
-0.0143388715,
0.0483139865,
-0.0057916502,
-0.0382513478,
0.0319131464,
0.0091352575,
-0.0010289024,
0.0347665027,
0.066766344,
-0.0582828037,
-0.0362912752,
0.0033271776,
-0.0369462781,
-0.0134066017,
0.0121152569,
-0.0101247933,
0.0073103849,
0.0204477292,
0.0228275098,
0.0188696347,
-0.0207521804,
-0.0667727888,
0.0241877101,
-0.0025457258,
-0.0306557044,
-0.0180317499,
0.0005422575,
-0.017469883,
0.0276588034,
-0.0510476083,
0.0231481474,
2.090950525e-34,
0.0228022784,
-0.023304116,
0.001417905,
0.0080334879,
-0.0244653337,
-0.0343028605,
0.0122467401,
0.0027241292,
0.0746682286,
-0.0552675277,
-0.0343260728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11772v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11772v3 | AutoAlign: Fully Automatic and Effective Knowledge Graph Alignment enabled by Large Language Models | 2023-07-18T04:43:24 | 2023-11-13T10:56:22 | Rui Zhang, Yixin Su, Bayu Distiawan Trisedya, Xiaoyan Zhao, Min Yang, Hong Cheng, Jianzhong Qi | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | The task of entity alignment between knowledge graphs (KGs) aims to identify
every pair of entities from two different KGs that represent the same entity.
Many machine learning-based methods have been proposed for this task. However,
to our best knowledge, existing methods all require manually crafted seed
alignments, which are expensive to obtain. In this paper, we propose the first
fully automatic alignment method named AutoAlign, which does not require any
manually crafted seed alignments. Specifically, for predicate embeddings,
AutoAlign constructs a predicate-proximity-graph with the help of large
language models to automatically capture the similarity between predicates
across two KGs. For entity embeddings, AutoAlign first computes the entity
embeddings of each KG independently using TransE, and then shifts the two KGs'
entity embeddings into the same vector space by computing the similarity
between entities based on their attributes. Thus, both predicate alignment and
entity alignment can be done without manually crafted seed alignments.
AutoAlign is not only fully automatic, but also highly effective. Experiments
using real-world KGs show that AutoAlign improves the performance of entity
alignment significantly compared to state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0114951711,
0.0306833945,
-0.0014932803,
0.0514051132,
-0.0311693121,
0.0120431148,
-0.0270469133,
-0.0168105252,
0.0300654341,
-0.0406007357,
-0.0020310392,
0.0255407766,
-0.0206722636,
-0.0044981828,
0.0296667349,
0.0102056181,
0.0528400131,
0.0617097877,
-0.0006285309,
0.0022178064,
0.0345891863,
0.0317174867,
-0.026005771,
-0.0043223742,
-0.0090613915,
-0.0308729559,
-0.0027278608,
-0.0152510507,
0.0717375875,
-0.0004654624,
-0.0181835722,
0.0294733942,
-0.0114599401,
0.027015157,
0.0000016587,
-0.0586344898,
-0.0388139598,
0.0083335871,
-0.0292406511,
-0.0141738495,
-0.0433375984,
-0.0285240319,
0.020868348,
0.0091761444,
-0.0277136397,
-0.0640932322,
0.0676289126,
0.0111682052,
0.0314434096,
0.0591411367,
-0.0283276215,
-0.0376554728,
0.0338191427,
0.0070842793,
-0.0379136913,
-0.0607174896,
0.02314681,
0.0210028458,
-0.0426379368,
-0.0029468329,
-0.016628461,
0.0441414341,
-0.0470386334,
-0.020198321,
0.0559060276,
0.0038944788,
-0.0268400423,
0.0183658004,
0.0044701118,
0.0993320048,
-0.03435269,
-0.0292439833,
0.0231264289,
-0.0039258446,
0.0008172744,
0.0128000462,
-0.0014665257,
-0.0148575837,
0.0092699779,
0.021931177,
0.0013007304,
-0.0321438648,
0.0498178713,
-0.0396141037,
-0.0345276073,
0.0482381694,
0.0421499349,
-0.0072325547,
-0.019378243,
-0.0020003859,
0.0019621945,
-0.0514173135,
-0.0035871004,
0.0390914567,
-0.0300233569,
0.0192754213,
-0.0785264596,
0.0150623219,
-0.010861082,
-0.0279803947,
0.0025392792,
0.030873077,
0.0239365529,
0.0764760226,
-0.0696407259,
0.0587761626,
-0.0129016358,
-0.0027667347,
-0.0394244902,
-0.0540861785,
-0.0532778949,
0.0143729411,
-0.0139310472,
-0.0098703597,
0.0150910476,
-0.0497171171,
-0.0441338196,
0.0557367764,
-0.0254129935,
0.0908848792,
0.002086373,
-0.0098702433,
0.0351430252,
-0.0213453472,
0.0002677317,
0.032704901,
-0.0259493049,
-0.0197599195,
-0.0529169925,
0.0026667614,
0.0127145685,
0.0143097127,
0.0448052697,
-0.0198584963,
-0.0447306633,
0.0364330076,
0.0369612128,
0.0181659162,
-0.0293502919,
-0.0298007708,
0.0385301486,
-0.0254490841,
-0.020671308,
-0.0567708239,
0.0982315764,
0.0210939273,
-0.023437215,
-0.0754255429,
0.0243945159,
-0.0363517739,
-0.0469566509,
0.0737792775,
-0.047052186,
0.0633504391,
0.0079239784,
-0.0377084948,
0.0182602555,
0.0188408718,
0.0166770574,
-0.0740499422,
0.0575928465,
-0.0282181036,
-0.0716821775,
0.0348894112,
0.0415063314,
-0.00710291,
0.0254059043,
0.0179996993,
0.0443096235,
0.0661622435,
0.0201927889,
0.0341143385,
0.0042652795,
-0.0002198938,
0.0177216921,
0.0157535579,
0.0191116352,
0.0156385172,
0.0275708102,
0.0185946524,
-0.0116252564,
-0.0217980109,
-0.0541485846,
-0.0146200694,
-0.0451736152,
0.0234018341,
0.0383459367,
0.0263634939,
-0.0104318438,
0.0388118923,
-0.0038564077,
-0.0156545546,
-0.0188021734,
-0.0242430121,
0.0346908122,
-0.0238633603,
-0.0227381457,
0.0818018839,
0.0201683901,
-0.0168095771,
-0.0004472387,
0.0373639315,
-0.0104672657,
0.0499469005,
0.0344887003,
-0.0095787151,
-0.0751742795,
0.0192288812,
-0.0429477543,
0.0199833196,
0.0407306626,
-0.0303829964,
-0.0339091867,
-0.0437631607,
-0.0584076382,
0.0210308358,
-0.0356773958,
-0.0136409812,
0.0430047661,
0.0554020777,
0.0439797081,
-0.0663210601,
0.021378329,
0.0322429761,
-0.044323463,
0.0207552053,
-0.0434298627,
0.0481469147,
-0.0002043358,
0.0219400283,
-0.0127570834,
0.0195687823,
0.0194843393,
-0.0129607162,
0.0217109956,
0.0111571373,
0.0058011739,
-0.0314236805,
0.0917073786,
-0.003358643,
-0.0298531856,
-0.0058582798,
-0.040768072,
-0.0311828759,
-0.0402148254,
0.025160823,
0.07064794,
0.0169767477,
0.0469284244,
-0.0295243748,
-0.0428368188,
-0.0106696086,
0.0521510988,
0.0417118147,
0.0303907301,
-0.0210820138,
-0.0221323818,
0.0475535169,
0.003923649,
-0.0189031847,
-0.0305123571,
0.0229830332,
0.0259751324,
0.0176631883,
-0.0581597202,
-0.0516179241,
0.0293233506,
-0.0826651454,
0.0472034216,
0.0273137186,
0.018457599,
0.0256135352,
0.0035006898,
0.0067629647,
0.0130304405,
-0.048768986,
0.0231561735,
0.0127823539,
-0.0041235648,
0.0356116816,
-0.0355210267,
-0.0263855215,
-0.0334263444,
0.0022609131,
-0.0574653931,
0.0386634618,
0.024611298,
0.0137960864,
-0.0486372672,
0.0549137667,
-0.060219299,
0.0311561469,
0.011618793,
0.0087028211,
-0.0376735963,
0.0131336907,
0.017660236,
0.0143207721,
-0.0203542951,
-0.0143794939,
0.016691681,
-0.0104740439,
-0.0446565375,
-0.018674748,
-0.0067701098,
0.0149926161,
-0.0347674415,
0.0039982796,
-0.0062209796,
0.0087246355,
-0.0056552277,
-0.030810751,
-0.0430356525,
0.0249170493,
0.0061063147,
0.0534170158,
-0.0012823251,
-0.0044498346,
0.0439600423,
0.0026678345,
-0.0351974703,
0.0233234279,
0.0604712851,
-0.0237804111,
0.0536315516,
0.0115616405,
0.0156945363,
-0.0215736758,
0.0448057577,
0.0032065748,
0.0490216911,
-0.0239828695,
-0.0018600636,
-0.0461794436,
0.018103525,
0.053705845,
-0.0155427912,
0.0339802317,
0.0150374575,
0.0387072451,
-0.0011527068,
-0.0089816386,
-0.0517936349,
0.004780455,
-0.031261228,
0.0296610743,
0.0402436368,
-0.02702309,
-0.0541717187,
0.0404664762,
-0.0332457386,
-0.0327659994,
0.023370035,
0.0203037187,
-0.0308976565,
0.0340388902,
0.0736104921,
-0.0256402194,
0.0058797281,
0.0250481032,
0.0076967306,
0.01598325,
0.005922894,
-0.0142065873,
-0.014976684,
-0.0362529457,
0.0003161192,
-0.1033070683,
-0.0056773396,
-0.028961312,
0.0185379907,
0.0200879481,
0.0417974889,
0.1325936168,
0.0334238783,
0.0001880143,
-0.0082818801,
0.0126842922,
-0.0198188238,
0.019576503,
0.0108383438,
-0.1046141461,
-0.0210821051,
-0.0103450883,
-0.0196030326,
0.0542359687,
-0.0576532148,
0.0115396632,
-0.1154842451,
-0.0266976822,
0.036473114,
-0.0336906388,
-0.0780728087,
-0.0234145019,
0.0304442365,
-0.0095892875,
-0.0356946327,
0.0046033729,
-0.003893916,
-0.0135080656,
-0.0342914909,
-0.0153085664,
-0.0435919277,
0.0030120101,
-0.1123667732,
0.0547752343,
0.014978609,
0.0626179129,
0.0323533416,
-0.0199658871,
-0.0400972851,
0.0063570747,
-0.0501414947,
0.0225184336,
0.0048459768,
-0.061562255,
-0.0218477342,
-0.0225326512,
0.0042805327,
-0.0439900905,
0.0101797115,
0.0218451824,
0.0914593339,
0.0195107926,
0.0042166496,
-0.003287856,
-0.0307427682,
0.0025667092,
0.0684923008,
-0.0156017607,
0.0098532923,
-0.0003593711,
0.0142795714,
0.0350935385,
0.0189847853,
-0.0114221703,
0.0199315362,
-0.0689971447,
0.0191555358,
-0.0578457974,
-0.0310843866,
0.0354885422,
-0.008230784,
0.0402716398,
0.0183306374,
0.0415636413,
-0.0464122072,
-0.0827137455,
0.0007405046,
-0.0486516766,
0.0123829832,
-0.0111760916,
0.0133776516,
0.0113381697,
0.036957901,
-0.0417374,
-0.0093968669,
-0.0443542525,
-0.0757809058,
-0.0299009196,
-0.0156061435,
-0.0002545405,
0.069830671,
-0.0298856553,
0.0338205658,
0.0407411829,
0.0129569033,
-0.0426836908,
-0.0284365341,
-0.0237296764,
-0.0422482863,
0.0001039385,
0.042929709,
-0.0563560165,
-0.0184801221,
0.0183869526,
0.0460120291,
-0.031785164,
-0.0885682032,
0.0198683087,
0.0534475707,
0.0055167582,
0.0236523282,
0.0171167981,
-0.0465961248,
-0.0050805425,
-0.0166948009,
-0.0412404127,
-0.0030057747,
0.006631976,
0.0388320275,
-0.0027946373,
0.0356296822,
0.0181814637,
0.017268721,
0.0011804907,
-0.0112530347,
-0.0218258463,
-0.011130441,
0.0286207758,
0.0518192276,
-0.0271252003,
-0.0289345589,
0.022145696,
0.0144971265,
0.0085778059,
-0.0724100173,
-0.0141967796,
0.0361559428,
0.0077169128,
-0.0365266129,
0.0086051011,
0.019801477,
-0.0290747099,
-0.0015637894,
0.0068098735,
0.1073879674,
-0.0189666748,
0.0567222573,
-0.0207000524,
-0.0299843922,
-0.0107995495,
0.0409514382,
-0.0168578122,
0.0188527964,
0.0103022419,
-0.0058818217,
-0.0071194144,
0.0105775381,
0.0456863642,
0.0024981722,
0.0595340095,
-0.0269698333,
-0.0667042807,
-0.041856572,
-0.0156955775,
0.0485882089,
-0.0013619418,
-0.0229051858,
-0.0005346021,
-0.0045194733,
-0.0602800064,
0.0374325141,
0.0216542594,
-0.0855270773,
0.0376734212,
0.0211755503,
0.0257244501,
0.0210303385,
-0.0460777953,
-0.008744956,
0.0159127321,
-0.0639479011,
-0.0292521007,
0.0114957634,
-5.130322402e-33,
-0.0330879986,
-0.0083412435,
0.0111155063,
-0.0224849172,
-0.0594164208,
-0.0164605957,
-0.0130918305,
-0.0081035718,
-0.0482531823,
0.0329630934,
0.0108248806,
0.0074254973,
0.0014881223,
-0.0281921066,
-0.0134016043,
-0.0075447233,
0.0154071571,
0.0098793665,
0.0051733172,
0.016058106,
-0.0012908116,
0.0321240164,
0.0285200905,
-0.0770962834,
0.0275902394,
-0.0235023517,
0.0183671229,
0.0195744261,
0.038297344,
0.0463712327,
-0.0228818674,
0.019083418,
-0.003872083,
0.0173302777,
-0.0100900773,
-0.005402836,
-0.0887450576,
-0.0513489023,
0.0230275374,
0.0293554775,
-0.0302562937,
-0.0129977958,
0.0304839592,
-0.0129342722,
0.0298878159,
-0.0349305384,
0.0571681932,
-0.0214995779,
-0.0223956816,
-0.0539691821,
-0.0673495457,
0.0284428857,
-0.0023662001,
0.0092386706,
0.018050978,
-0.0244021378,
0.0349255763,
-0.0163937863,
-0.0847127736,
0.0125208544,
-0.0033256807,
0.0035333957,
0.066713497,
0.0119500048,
0.0166218933,
0.0327090174,
-0.0359177366,
-0.0607206821,
0.0032091003,
0.0497388169,
-0.0006856046,
0.0520303063,
-0.0156001337,
0.0309309997,
-0.0328220651,
-0.0145137701,
-0.0890916437,
0.0353463888,
-0.0335739516,
-0.0051735779,
-0.0241130665,
-0.0039307931,
-0.0258495081,
-0.0080286888,
-0.0391224734,
-0.0160949863,
-0.0145475771,
-0.0316964947,
0.0239043981,
-0.0406869464,
-0.0116927754,
0.0323273987,
0.00128894,
-0.0754634663,
-0.0476354659,
0.0401497222,
0.008642924,
-0.0014062423,
-0.0343430825,
0.0458890758,
-0.0430242307,
-0.0768622681,
-0.013102741,
-0.04480334,
0.018896075,
0.031346418,
0.0265111923,
-0.0215216056,
-0.053132847,
0.0225578118,
0.008635697,
-0.0733993649,
-0.0464695357,
-0.046319928,
0.0468678214,
0.0332986191,
0.0478605069,
0.0087125823,
0.0911645964,
0.0128965229,
0.0087578734,
0.0278848726,
0.0302215796,
0.0261004604,
-0.0028448885,
0.0101751275,
-0.0515378118,
0.0051673208,
-0.0231877137,
-0.0399438776,
-0.004752378,
-0.0101339007,
2.42e-7,
0.0513197742,
0.0038393612,
0.0649033934,
0.0342790931,
-0.0112506719,
0.0193890277,
0.0261078663,
0.0418159366,
-0.0334992893,
0.0131857954,
0.0552182719,
0.0221905615,
-0.0202367827,
0.0150046013,
-0.0418385044,
0.0368455462,
-0.0268971194,
-0.0328104608,
-0.0700084418,
0.0327669792,
0.0406183153,
0.048956275,
0.0525728017,
0.0434075817,
-0.0092736371,
-0.0442798547,
0.0392361805,
0.0024188797,
0.0072038099,
0.0676669553,
0.0197597872,
0.0003800835,
-0.0237761624,
0.0581840724,
0.0076831789,
0.0624028295,
0.0229705479,
0.0351399519,
-0.0385222882,
0.0525922291,
-0.050519079,
-0.057162609,
0.0169619024,
-0.0573689789,
0.0598081052,
-0.0226383097,
-0.0059627518,
0.0041295355,
-0.0538990125,
0.0036540846,
-0.0097275982,
0.0348898433,
0.0160344709,
0.011545239,
0.050229989,
-0.000333381,
-0.0145961931,
-0.0756976306,
0.0027005102,
0.0387895629,
-0.0005800002,
-0.0176220555,
0.0347764567,
-0.0506506562,
0.0561989546,
-0.0271782652,
0.0347531773,
2.067402985e-34,
-0.0060283649,
0.0274789855,
0.0186185259,
0.0119864745,
0.0534204282,
-0.0533762649,
-0.0267080758,
0.022027988,
-0.0008938132,
-0.0616403595,
0.012795629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08945v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08945v2 | Mitigating Label Bias via Decoupled Confident Learning | 2023-07-18T03:28:03 | 2023-09-29T16:06:05 | Yunyi Li, Maria De-Arteaga, Maytal Saar-Tsechansky | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Growing concerns regarding algorithmic fairness have led to a surge in
methodologies to mitigate algorithmic bias. However, such methodologies largely
assume that observed labels in training data are correct. This is problematic
because bias in labels is pervasive across important domains, including
healthcare, hiring, and content moderation. In particular, human-generated
labels are prone to encoding societal biases. While the presence of labeling
bias has been discussed conceptually, there is a lack of methodologies to
address this problem. We propose a pruning method -- Decoupled Confident
Learning (DeCoLe) -- specifically designed to mitigate label bias. After
illustrating its performance on a synthetic dataset, we apply DeCoLe in the
context of hate speech detection, where label bias has been recognized as an
important challenge, and show that it successfully identifies biased labels and
outperforms competing approaches. | [
0.0553430244,
0.1087934151,
-0.0200130381,
0.0081693856,
0.0014413453,
0.0510783494,
0.0267567821,
0.0042894422,
0.0194357838,
-0.0325585157,
-0.0046051051,
0.021045113,
-0.0182042886,
0.0073602423,
-0.0431418344,
-0.0471434146,
0.0326977558,
0.064227201,
0.1202600598,
-0.0421642587,
0.0522085354,
-0.0071803168,
-0.0027223094,
0.0259101465,
-0.0749893188,
-0.0063951127,
0.0645539835,
-0.0123459976,
0.0151747148,
-0.0071482081,
0.0761583894,
0.0485930555,
-0.0101508386,
0.0392173007,
0.0000017114,
-0.0400636457,
-0.0098921526,
0.005757764,
0.0076417322,
-0.0353229381,
0.050243184,
-0.0092513897,
-0.0150403045,
0.0354379043,
-0.0185775552,
-0.0272123087,
0.0429103933,
0.0630828291,
0.016942516,
0.0125051215,
-0.0021666589,
-0.0203511678,
-0.042586904,
0.0016835449,
-0.0213495325,
-0.0320398174,
0.0733228698,
-0.0870282874,
-0.1098944247,
-0.0254415348,
-0.0190191921,
0.0055207084,
0.0211309399,
0.0379577428,
0.0330252089,
-0.002847363,
-0.0504064485,
-0.0581624843,
0.000443431,
0.0304141492,
0.0080086086,
-0.010267579,
0.015115899,
-0.0194581281,
0.046523802,
-0.0562753156,
-0.0115955621,
0.0259061176,
-0.0539765246,
0.0240299739,
-0.0424214453,
0.0305356253,
0.0258209668,
0.0479324535,
0.0404232517,
0.0703741536,
-0.0149625158,
-0.0207136739,
0.0377341844,
0.0360107869,
0.0375711992,
0.0384653918,
0.064947471,
-0.0211976822,
-0.0253536329,
-0.0012352653,
-0.0520782918,
-0.0119767226,
0.0040947879,
-0.0029459579,
-0.0234559812,
-0.0125915278,
-0.0206992943,
0.0011637717,
0.0431276448,
0.0032550248,
0.0374421068,
0.0534211807,
-0.0063637234,
0.013983991,
-0.0119312974,
0.025037704,
0.0035106915,
0.0170995221,
0.0068668853,
0.0530645922,
-0.0526096821,
-0.0427681506,
-0.0960313603,
0.0057324236,
-0.0220767576,
0.0334046297,
-0.0310206916,
0.0030845574,
-0.0294296704,
0.0128247635,
0.008690862,
0.0231286231,
-0.0384637155,
-0.0717488527,
-0.002994668,
0.0332067162,
-0.0290161557,
-0.0088318521,
0.0075579458,
0.0629060641,
0.0095743006,
-0.0332708135,
-0.0343128219,
-0.0292609241,
-0.0128350332,
-0.0219188966,
0.0108948508,
-0.043940492,
0.0017722581,
-0.0410400108,
0.0069323578,
-0.0984333009,
-0.0139476629,
-0.003889926,
-0.050444603,
0.064549461,
0.0031604506,
-0.0258488655,
0.0703103244,
0.0562702455,
-0.015955044,
0.0476491936,
-0.0062492522,
0.0346383154,
0.0705123991,
0.0079591498,
0.0438858904,
0.0247157738,
0.0556549355,
-0.0080337776,
-0.0265120994,
0.0100658126,
-0.0183680598,
-0.036557205,
0.0224494953,
0.0293669049,
0.0072562145,
-0.0491116457,
0.0466734767,
0.0026541888,
-0.037409395,
-0.0262297764,
0.0077392329,
0.0076124948,
-0.0147021189,
0.0153632024,
-0.0795172304,
-0.0343976431,
-0.0114389192,
-0.0538842008,
0.012513943,
0.0539267361,
-0.0347464122,
-0.0570936091,
-0.0185554717,
0.0036129071,
0.0107771,
-0.0116429487,
0.0047432096,
0.0400988534,
0.0001697351,
0.0106763886,
0.0821449235,
0.01109167,
0.0066345949,
-0.0413496047,
0.0051173046,
0.0207760166,
-0.0152807683,
-0.0395268127,
0.039546676,
-0.0539702363,
0.0300024934,
0.0254057981,
0.0466411598,
-0.0314578153,
0.0208338238,
-0.0327499062,
-0.0490257852,
0.0445265695,
0.0423003025,
0.0238553938,
0.0893810615,
0.0196745601,
-0.0027755604,
0.0090909945,
-0.0057756337,
0.0503916368,
0.0617130697,
-0.0480706468,
0.0267562885,
0.0091790482,
0.0407437198,
0.0095178587,
-0.0338508114,
-0.0356889628,
-0.0028231873,
0.0212331433,
-0.0554330312,
-0.0193649493,
-0.0350572728,
-0.0285090357,
0.0276535712,
-0.0751474649,
-0.0707443133,
0.0258967318,
-0.0498221405,
0.0356994197,
0.007243732,
-0.0113804396,
-0.06968043,
0.0009053574,
-0.0312002841,
-0.0260299258,
0.0277240146,
-0.0405297689,
0.0345142372,
-0.0238073003,
-0.0046106917,
0.0082502831,
-0.0591839701,
0.02030438,
0.00354739,
-0.0069659031,
-0.0139009682,
-0.043396268,
0.0215141233,
0.0196982231,
-0.0086463215,
-0.0153573127,
0.0083878562,
-0.0341099612,
-0.0269058254,
-0.0139203081,
-0.0391486213,
-0.0210679229,
-0.0151760597,
-0.0132875117,
-0.0396599136,
-0.0200434085,
-0.0431901924,
0.0170191992,
0.0361383483,
0.0055607487,
-0.060962256,
-0.0075083454,
-0.0057282066,
-0.009500931,
-0.0085956259,
0.0268847663,
0.0168321971,
-0.0155462651,
-0.0083854934,
-0.0354149044,
-0.03097599,
0.0086590992,
-0.0169069376,
-0.0089202533,
0.0235824417,
0.0309981816,
-0.0573033579,
0.0435183533,
0.0506545976,
0.0216666032,
0.05414306,
0.0180050991,
0.0173018705,
-0.0067421352,
-0.0392293818,
0.0084984219,
0.0141794113,
-0.0494002588,
-0.0371796191,
0.0751338974,
0.0568955727,
-0.0040170359,
-0.0542006604,
0.03052908,
-0.0580445714,
-0.0791013986,
-0.0515265577,
-0.0134235537,
-0.0223704204,
0.005695513,
-0.0487134941,
-0.0778955296,
0.0952253416,
0.0374174751,
0.0374685377,
-0.0313981548,
-0.0304432083,
0.013974268,
0.0038188298,
0.0132128615,
0.0275314432,
0.0079084709,
0.0123917488,
-0.0217453558,
-0.0503430963,
0.0556096546,
-0.0402645059,
-0.0454190597,
-0.0380772762,
-0.0205371957,
0.0082384963,
-0.078443259,
-0.0802452564,
-0.0128463758,
-0.0355961137,
-0.0199892558,
0.0048182067,
0.0086909663,
-0.0292574577,
-0.0323505923,
0.0174952149,
0.0277755409,
0.0092774872,
-0.0087174848,
0.0546430759,
0.0028517246,
0.0091033187,
-0.0335624926,
0.0327622816,
0.0019531064,
-0.0095212357,
0.0691725314,
0.0493818596,
0.050748419,
0.0212002844,
0.0301705934,
0.0033565636,
0.0152736837,
0.028334938,
-0.00322315,
0.0128355324,
0.0145487748,
0.0353609398,
0.0740704164,
-0.0090725096,
-0.0354314931,
0.0022004072,
0.0147458995,
0.0184852835,
0.0257751681,
-0.0366740003,
-0.0478986464,
-0.0117810769,
0.0115760788,
0.048949603,
-0.0513559505,
-0.0442611352,
0.0061195493,
-0.066798456,
0.0379051492,
-0.0025042749,
-0.0226466302,
-0.0317309238,
-0.0299666673,
0.0304466654,
-0.0400378369,
0.0095449034,
-0.0455257036,
0.032278277,
0.0122873578,
0.0242431946,
-0.0754055008,
-0.0308676083,
-0.0068803704,
-0.0393756293,
0.0474256612,
0.0009504373,
0.0172858089,
-0.0236569569,
0.0228760839,
0.0201622788,
-0.0030237178,
-0.0316495821,
-0.0321726725,
0.0858744904,
-0.0324812382,
-0.0311852787,
-0.0329855569,
0.034859065,
-0.0103907743,
-0.0090268664,
0.022884503,
0.0155069605,
0.0530972034,
-0.0556974113,
-0.0716561526,
0.0232061762,
0.0013586102,
0.0593959391,
0.0191992205,
-0.0278919134,
0.0101288352,
-0.0668630451,
0.0161938593,
0.0141838184,
-0.0514772795,
0.0613075756,
-0.0264873169,
-0.0725185946,
0.0067214607,
-0.038378071,
-0.0022272225,
0.005504143,
0.0081313392,
-0.0334763639,
0.0063896645,
0.0105642071,
-0.0782525465,
0.0105463555,
-0.0085060438,
0.0462278537,
0.0191903319,
-0.0041209799,
-0.0360400341,
-0.0029412175,
-0.0427108742,
0.0284971222,
-0.0255688094,
-0.0532793254,
0.0748547614,
0.0530980974,
0.0116662849,
0.0436287373,
-0.0085503878,
-0.0538756028,
0.0942334756,
0.108328186,
-0.0169180073,
-0.0016679976,
0.0684353709,
-0.037687622,
0.0165336523,
0.0157949589,
0.0114603648,
0.0595551878,
0.0575876273,
-0.0403338633,
-0.0214013886,
-0.0108755417,
-0.0207607914,
0.0009987541,
0.071271807,
-0.0207981542,
-0.0100106075,
-0.0312415082,
-0.0188971404,
0.0311386753,
-0.0633746907,
0.0156544577,
0.0067709554,
0.0250728913,
0.0199078619,
-0.0541404001,
0.0077512846,
-0.0236392152,
0.020968182,
-0.0073963804,
-0.0032014404,
0.0300676003,
0.0475327969,
0.0103050601,
-0.0166884493,
-0.0103544518,
0.0682159662,
0.028157955,
0.016713867,
0.0377870314,
-0.0131769935,
0.0472405888,
0.0364504568,
0.020956682,
-0.0447713882,
-0.0279695299,
-0.0211529452,
-0.0324827246,
-0.0024265803,
-0.008071146,
-0.0118131274,
-0.0226648431,
0.0270018205,
-0.0355053172,
0.006339069,
-0.0238249768,
-0.0019581793,
-0.0040043858,
0.0467444323,
-0.0000595634,
-0.0138086425,
0.0251991376,
0.0427497663,
0.0239363741,
0.0650862455,
-0.0472205654,
-0.0752318203,
-0.029593708,
-0.0072242608,
0.034042418,
0.0225180257,
0.018332202,
-0.0024769902,
-0.0249871351,
-0.0495335087,
0.0160807893,
-0.0368512571,
0.0772261992,
-0.0035572955,
0.0175386705,
0.049796775,
0.0064028963,
-0.0188735053,
0.0242220908,
-0.0179142244,
0.0271181129,
-0.03699518,
-0.0065732184,
-5.507299399e-33,
-0.0132557843,
-0.0232857186,
-0.0596510656,
-0.0103489077,
0.0013741613,
0.0008508501,
0.0358040631,
0.0122615816,
-0.0018108895,
0.076340057,
-0.0107762283,
0.0307254381,
0.0127607966,
0.012300116,
-0.0044053183,
-0.0522617735,
0.0489673093,
-0.0264225006,
-0.0351755619,
0.0103749456,
-0.0406732559,
0.0469895191,
0.0257226024,
-0.1320676953,
0.0273593701,
0.0225662198,
-0.0324646309,
0.0247695372,
0.0102057643,
0.0508781932,
-0.0010871718,
0.0857886523,
0.025330849,
-0.0009575954,
0.0273717884,
0.0326664709,
-0.0613332875,
-0.0081918994,
-0.012240733,
0.0432494171,
0.0353382304,
0.0046626786,
0.0217444468,
0.010307081,
-0.0503906906,
-0.0195520073,
0.0517943166,
-0.0327227786,
0.0151415244,
-0.0484692529,
-0.0133616263,
0.0134162353,
-0.019314602,
0.0293851532,
0.0023940175,
-0.0042002741,
0.0173255447,
0.0232606363,
-0.0505220965,
0.0059149424,
-0.007456216,
-0.0095319059,
-0.0056785662,
0.0145885618,
-0.0224698093,
0.0588405803,
0.069687739,
0.0414588973,
-0.0344914272,
-0.03005757,
-0.0032934805,
-0.0087271845,
0.0436529703,
0.0836793333,
0.0147864139,
-0.0657054186,
-0.0589306615,
-0.0049781324,
0.0150113823,
-0.0322662927,
-0.0019681882,
-0.0250922944,
-0.0488240831,
-0.0398759134,
-0.0251481179,
-0.0768990368,
-0.0132928994,
0.0254019015,
0.0051600737,
0.0194330215,
-0.0469265282,
0.0021362565,
-0.0332566649,
-0.0356874727,
-0.0163167007,
0.0246544983,
-0.0059574856,
-0.0346055813,
0.0149261802,
-0.0046452265,
-0.0754250586,
-0.0074460553,
0.0181215443,
0.0083903633,
0.019707812,
-0.0033625385,
0.0541795753,
0.0241116397,
-0.0472871251,
0.0219051335,
0.0014541909,
0.041690819,
0.0319866352,
0.0367432572,
0.0151726939,
0.0251424462,
-0.00216945,
-0.023015663,
0.0117214117,
0.0140921287,
-0.0244861916,
0.0269888639,
-0.0241061635,
0.0271548573,
0.001436809,
-0.0474000201,
0.0198099893,
-0.0203769542,
0.0217139851,
-0.0670787096,
0.0142244073,
-0.0529855601,
2.394e-7,
-0.0397378951,
0.0191008002,
-0.0246995408,
-0.0305144694,
0.0222964771,
0.059470281,
0.0341731757,
0.0328683183,
-0.0093481559,
-0.0512150228,
-0.0013340019,
0.0538048223,
0.0235147811,
0.0380272903,
-0.0218950752,
-0.0672872514,
-0.0265042298,
0.0069062081,
-0.0165532138,
-0.0009467792,
-0.0049816766,
0.0717854276,
0.0812219754,
-0.0548032969,
-0.0171101652,
0.0332992673,
-0.0039721513,
-0.0095364498,
0.0276357848,
-0.005724411,
0.0383872464,
0.0060077165,
-0.0027242454,
0.0164373908,
-0.0194404572,
-0.0064381473,
0.0071999016,
0.0617336519,
0.0123966131,
0.0384884626,
-0.0057361354,
0.0396401696,
-0.004949457,
0.0075286264,
0.0140642421,
-0.0100379586,
-0.0048596519,
-0.045134902,
-0.0188082345,
-0.0391006023,
0.0603209697,
0.0089923479,
-0.0172620602,
-0.0083185891,
0.0141328182,
0.0338408612,
-0.023044426,
-0.0746091604,
-0.0096835168,
-0.0580234081,
-0.0276992209,
-0.0454773679,
0.0406081453,
0.0377477892,
-0.0106024137,
-0.000572564,
0.0396714956,
1.694225544e-34,
0.021335559,
-0.0120491125,
-0.0149271591,
-0.0886348262,
0.0273212735,
0.0039170212,
0.0048371479,
-0.0280967467,
0.0163182598,
0.0249398295,
0.0149732493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08941v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08941v2 | NTK-approximating MLP Fusion for Efficient Language Model Fine-tuning | 2023-07-18T03:12:51 | 2023-08-05T01:10:06 | Tianxin Wei, Zeming Guo, Yifan Chen, Jingrui He | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Fine-tuning a pre-trained language model (PLM) emerges as the predominant
strategy in many natural language processing applications. However, even
fine-tuning the PLMs and doing inference are expensive, especially on edge
devices with low computing power. Some general approaches (e.g. quantization
and distillation) have been widely studied to reduce the compute/memory of PLM
fine-tuning, while very few one-shot compression techniques are explored. In
this paper, we investigate the neural tangent kernel (NTK)--which reveals the
gradient descent dynamics of neural networks--of the multilayer perceptrons
(MLP) modules in a PLM and propose to coin a lightweight PLM through
NTK-approximating MLP fusion. To achieve this, we reconsider the MLP as a
bundle of sub-MLPs, and cluster them into a given number of centroids, which
can then be restored as a compressed MLP and surprisingly shown to well
approximate the NTK of the original PLM. Extensive experiments of PLM
fine-tuning on both natural language understanding (NLU) and generation (NLG)
tasks are provided to verify the effectiveness of the proposed method MLP
fusion. Our code is available at https://github.com/weitianxin/MLP_Fusion. | [
0.0092744296,
0.0265558679,
-0.0042641042,
0.0530348197,
-0.0329325385,
-0.0034707284,
0.0315779559,
-0.0258277338,
-0.0246065482,
-0.0248621833,
-0.0175362378,
-0.0065947599,
0.0157490559,
-0.0083645005,
0.0536064841,
-0.0277447458,
0.0155376326,
0.012199956,
-0.0092609059,
-0.0088065248,
0.0022313492,
0.022829853,
-0.0051012821,
0.0512668006,
-0.0004311665,
-0.0104270997,
-0.0246024169,
0.0060690171,
0.0341678485,
-0.00869691,
-0.0027821499,
0.0148988618,
0.033557158,
0.0201255549,
0.0000021576,
-0.0157894883,
-0.020384185,
0.0031891773,
-0.0304568503,
-0.010551231,
0.0505999252,
-0.0180691816,
-0.0224071201,
0.0061774733,
-0.0401582494,
-0.0255953316,
0.0550307743,
0.0075852978,
0.0822185799,
0.0922893286,
0.0039731194,
-0.0538279079,
0.018947674,
-0.0069898842,
-0.0355351716,
-0.0236735828,
-0.0099448077,
-0.0125789037,
-0.0438596085,
-0.0364583395,
0.0092765223,
0.028176425,
0.0220740642,
0.0159566272,
0.0123772258,
0.0589114726,
-0.0233084206,
-0.0487268195,
-0.0298452135,
0.0616962872,
-0.1047816426,
-0.0417116545,
0.0099419849,
0.0058459151,
-0.0127424151,
-0.0638910607,
-0.0170787238,
0.0077513941,
0.0105552962,
0.0495129526,
0.0134766959,
-0.0361987166,
0.0598249324,
0.0143663418,
-0.0402175859,
0.0346128643,
0.0258941222,
0.0090066381,
-0.0435012318,
-0.0223297384,
-0.0199406035,
-0.0514671691,
0.0177102201,
0.0495848358,
0.0375035778,
0.0050728661,
-0.0867070183,
-0.0370514579,
-0.0393364057,
-0.0453565419,
0.0705856457,
0.0625755265,
0.034107998,
0.0228319,
-0.0587393194,
0.008920908,
0.0204877257,
0.0066761747,
-0.0531029515,
0.0039223135,
-0.0351650044,
-0.0046656155,
-0.0232546758,
0.037944641,
-0.0380967669,
-0.0264843851,
-0.0404415913,
0.0197455417,
0.0056159045,
-0.046893429,
-0.0264288709,
0.0119679114,
-0.009542129,
-0.0016839029,
0.0108461305,
0.0398214795,
-0.0151999192,
0.0218848549,
0.0001941748,
-0.0495764129,
-0.0160512403,
0.0358893573,
-0.0005703594,
0.013740588,
0.0620913729,
0.0121356994,
-0.0261785705,
-0.0401352905,
-0.0601826385,
0.0065921922,
0.0032765332,
-0.0405298732,
-0.0223534666,
-0.0754250288,
0.0888032168,
-0.0205340721,
-0.0145392632,
-0.0450163223,
0.0094636632,
0.0150866844,
-0.0363760106,
0.0478519052,
-0.0421731286,
0.0195048973,
0.0658849701,
-0.0184874851,
0.00330142,
0.0659752265,
0.0642329156,
0.0087938802,
-0.0124193253,
-0.0057780365,
-0.0635530129,
0.0247209352,
0.0532167889,
-0.0236667972,
-0.0647606105,
-0.0615043417,
-0.0631831661,
0.0202968866,
0.0562647507,
0.0652040616,
-0.0563726984,
-0.008385431,
0.0231972449,
0.0853539482,
0.0342782028,
0.0498019755,
0.0250018109,
-0.0078114411,
0.0002493809,
-0.0092066927,
-0.007517389,
0.0057935971,
-0.0466810539,
-0.0034832382,
0.0756813288,
0.0792436525,
-0.0439362116,
-0.0414299779,
0.0032139733,
-0.020524215,
0.0100253401,
0.0043038451,
0.0425867587,
0.0160680506,
-0.0166870765,
0.0960396826,
0.0160695333,
-0.0387130864,
0.0101968078,
-0.0556810275,
-0.0134173129,
0.0328591578,
0.0112708602,
-0.0054003014,
-0.0481959879,
0.0057754042,
0.00206804,
-0.0018178612,
0.0187449027,
-0.0076096356,
0.0509177037,
-0.0704739317,
0.0314862542,
-0.0104536191,
0.0064400495,
0.0264967214,
-0.016382277,
-0.0158530995,
0.0421605222,
-0.0196406599,
-0.0493927449,
0.0365033671,
0.0071456754,
-0.0254783295,
0.0408882163,
0.0279437806,
0.0035006881,
0.009261745,
0.007453965,
0.012024058,
0.038757097,
-0.0806772485,
0.0280654058,
-0.0252490845,
-0.0342777893,
-0.0673687384,
0.0700210258,
-0.0035825199,
0.0234273858,
0.0188525841,
-0.0522370748,
-0.0740572959,
0.0454826392,
-0.0204757396,
0.0332654603,
-0.0371243022,
0.0150838559,
0.0135930348,
0.0554474927,
-0.0329231583,
0.0441774391,
-0.022340294,
0.0144778462,
0.0312110633,
0.0403157473,
0.0102535142,
0.017438991,
-0.0051702792,
-0.0166148953,
-0.0140328305,
0.0503129736,
0.01292919,
0.0164208505,
-0.0068033226,
-0.0540909581,
-0.0971372649,
0.0098815383,
-0.0365353748,
0.0419834927,
0.0288709253,
0.0325768515,
0.0219131131,
-0.0197499134,
-0.0209862664,
0.0519318096,
0.0101578161,
-0.0011964439,
0.0163888801,
0.0094729662,
-0.0068155276,
-0.0178080071,
-0.0366465896,
0.0107297748,
0.064380832,
-0.0412220135,
0.0103652179,
-0.0421619974,
-0.007764359,
-0.0119155888,
0.0501485355,
0.0099840397,
-0.0126773193,
0.0176578257,
-0.019551279,
0.074207142,
0.0714063793,
0.0061548026,
0.0420154557,
0.0411589928,
0.0013967063,
-0.0495890975,
0.0379078165,
-0.0326314792,
-0.0132882679,
-0.0196244139,
0.0099653099,
-0.029361194,
0.0927566364,
-0.0070451857,
-0.0150803477,
-0.068594873,
-0.0120108984,
0.0015165197,
-0.0232132655,
-0.0150985103,
0.0086888,
-0.0331992805,
0.0362370051,
-0.0111048222,
-0.0543855764,
0.0572075807,
-0.0582385287,
0.003106701,
-0.0333049819,
-0.0754105598,
-0.0070527196,
0.0507667474,
0.0140837496,
0.0416067056,
-0.0451259725,
0.0114366785,
-0.0244651232,
0.0262070764,
-0.0287906192,
-0.0230694339,
0.0306119937,
-0.0269368161,
0.0168421566,
-0.0310673565,
-0.0214048643,
-0.017114507,
-0.0667553991,
-0.0153140044,
0.015545127,
-0.0076549621,
0.0022176674,
-0.013166287,
0.0336174034,
0.0020953191,
0.0483464412,
-0.0021963594,
-0.0018997446,
-0.0260266159,
0.00934109,
0.0374420658,
0.0114752343,
0.0086742109,
-0.0004766926,
0.0113461586,
0.0238563083,
0.0490658954,
0.0180726033,
-0.0974312425,
-0.0084734866,
0.0078179874,
0.02188012,
-0.034733545,
0.0282211173,
0.0257493667,
-0.055935584,
-0.019248154,
0.100901179,
-0.0037198311,
-0.0587136336,
0.0040712147,
0.0394709557,
0.0222605653,
0.0106465248,
0.0313163586,
-0.0038869027,
-0.0246812273,
-0.0014107043,
0.0383769125,
0.0115224216,
-0.0105858035,
-0.0481647439,
-0.0687079206,
-0.0216376483,
0.0488665141,
-0.0255169887,
-0.0159487743,
-0.0387631468,
-0.0247253086,
0.0181816909,
0.0193619095,
-0.0075609866,
0.0286722351,
0.0115131224,
0.0210398901,
-0.0275600404,
-0.0724155456,
0.0074528344,
-0.0119118616,
0.0217985623,
0.045252569,
0.0326299183,
0.0046359408,
-0.0544704087,
0.0805376768,
-0.0118578915,
0.0157302599,
-0.0037750495,
-0.0102283033,
0.0011070591,
-0.0203536768,
0.0335635245,
0.0239545852,
-0.0498915464,
-0.0063376948,
-0.0380585119,
0.0577402152,
-0.0315111317,
0.0216864534,
0.0113322958,
-0.0126416869,
-0.0130207473,
0.0187053382,
0.0401923358,
-0.0399143584,
-0.0164886918,
0.0006539834,
-0.0171376709,
-0.0207637902,
0.0022770122,
0.0056218482,
0.0214809142,
-0.0389157049,
-0.0147196194,
0.0000797595,
-0.0082493899,
0.0623533688,
-0.0067022592,
-0.0195831601,
0.0260280594,
-0.0180991758,
-0.0687385872,
0.0393336155,
-0.0064343326,
-0.0229930039,
-0.0323596485,
-0.0056617358,
0.0457386598,
-0.0216570366,
0.0097650038,
0.0172395166,
-0.1196538955,
-0.1065243408,
-0.0200049393,
0.0396487489,
0.0179241132,
0.0427849181,
-0.0113982884,
-0.061530076,
0.0466433614,
0.1039539948,
-0.0304817893,
0.0452962369,
-0.0059228614,
-0.0574903712,
-0.0121196862,
0.0252578855,
-0.0359284803,
0.0250313934,
-0.0109954709,
0.0116013093,
-0.0319217667,
-0.0682480708,
-0.0030163336,
0.0102727497,
0.0826466009,
-0.02495916,
0.0145596927,
-0.0242082682,
-0.0280960687,
0.0432359688,
0.0147895981,
-0.0328432284,
-0.0201707147,
0.0229250193,
-0.0154712405,
0.0042502438,
-0.02934842,
0.0819521472,
-0.0057819793,
-0.0112415459,
-0.0413176231,
-0.0231551323,
-0.0010797455,
0.0145288445,
0.0008338057,
-0.0342522077,
0.0214834027,
-0.0231540035,
0.0094199525,
-0.0436694212,
0.0036995604,
0.0295570847,
0.0388789698,
-0.0803518742,
0.0573802814,
-0.0567568876,
-0.0811486393,
-0.0278832503,
-0.0195301268,
0.0686948448,
0.0033579154,
0.0557906032,
-0.0194388274,
-0.0123462975,
-0.022541102,
0.0182110481,
0.0082585691,
-0.022726221,
0.0265237335,
0.0102289841,
-0.0121848686,
0.0142922392,
0.0619539656,
-0.025335893,
0.0343345366,
0.0144887865,
0.0511515625,
-0.0511318259,
-0.0102551877,
-0.0421742052,
0.0530765057,
0.0067992918,
0.0360973589,
-0.0071533429,
-0.0478361323,
0.0305249561,
-0.0157754831,
0.0131238066,
-0.0129280556,
0.0411851592,
0.0679317415,
-0.0195747055,
0.0171716921,
-0.022901034,
0.0205982346,
0.035315454,
-0.0010814025,
0.0177927371,
-7.099432662e-33,
-0.0338458344,
0.0179614108,
0.0090117641,
0.0585888773,
-0.0297927298,
0.0019049473,
-0.0343527533,
-0.0074110534,
-0.0012073633,
-0.0351785086,
-0.0410764553,
0.0125700189,
0.0104976883,
0.031431891,
-0.0220792145,
0.00650091,
0.0717190504,
-0.0197999272,
-0.0020556585,
0.0197085068,
0.0417600758,
0.0415902287,
0.0340358168,
-0.039716322,
-0.0575148612,
0.0171020627,
-0.0115303518,
0.0119870557,
-0.0137826288,
0.0133847743,
-0.0394689031,
0.0363679118,
0.0156291071,
-0.0135740247,
-0.0416929163,
-0.0242012814,
-0.0489421599,
-0.0196046364,
-0.0036055623,
0.0095788063,
-0.0663947761,
-0.032920409,
0.118294023,
0.0184221826,
-0.0186993442,
0.0043629906,
-0.0034295355,
-0.0370512307,
-0.0413257815,
-0.0448124222,
-0.0043037273,
0.0225319974,
0.0069051292,
-0.0333784819,
0.0662577823,
-0.0107171787,
-0.0533198752,
-0.0072549284,
-0.088434808,
-0.0148497103,
0.0060269469,
0.0769281387,
0.0782714188,
0.0414025486,
0.0268849432,
0.0578930005,
0.0354919769,
0.0208494645,
-0.0252128765,
0.0387481339,
0.0552390516,
0.0348784737,
0.0028285005,
0.0140036428,
0.0523631983,
-0.0453307517,
-0.0408415459,
0.0170471966,
0.0109982351,
0.0079847993,
0.0311536323,
0.0254921671,
0.0068537463,
-0.0423835851,
-0.0421377197,
-0.0560458526,
-0.0233173408,
-0.0118382657,
-0.0061409865,
0.0393926725,
-0.0333959535,
-0.0366149396,
0.017330857,
-0.0237966515,
0.0514492318,
-0.0217152424,
0.0136331804,
-0.0249957852,
0.0254124776,
0.0320114903,
-0.0506333746,
-0.0637460351,
-0.0315815806,
-0.0157572366,
0.0274146348,
0.013402191,
-0.0049651512,
0.060525734,
-0.0327206515,
-0.0010342046,
-0.0426419228,
-0.0125006288,
0.0251485873,
0.0638496503,
0.0476928763,
-0.0012070378,
-0.0120018963,
0.0566573776,
0.0030767207,
-0.0137648387,
0.0158866197,
-0.0000260636,
0.0570890494,
0.0380835459,
-0.036420349,
0.0017003643,
-0.0391071662,
0.0195325501,
0.0285153724,
-0.0513118207,
-0.0207005329,
0.0311759654,
3.047e-7,
-0.0001035785,
0.0125558302,
0.0128489789,
-0.0429525152,
0.0126526104,
0.0185893457,
0.0164959785,
0.0073819328,
-0.0122365076,
-0.0615726523,
0.0026842384,
0.0352520198,
0.0336148366,
0.009324288,
-0.0766093954,
0.0226990059,
-0.0269120764,
0.0531195328,
-0.0220784731,
0.0033849261,
0.0247352533,
0.1045914814,
0.0185460821,
-0.0361253843,
0.0467272252,
-0.0230017435,
0.0464596413,
0.0174087957,
0.015029192,
0.0062739868,
0.0312713496,
0.0162474848,
-0.0259996969,
0.0003706214,
0.0054680514,
0.0377700701,
-0.0086358655,
0.0656332672,
-0.0137480181,
-0.0011792076,
0.0466281511,
-0.0180129707,
-0.0346718803,
-0.053133931,
0.0344503075,
-0.020823691,
-0.0225175731,
-0.0543633811,
0.028703874,
-0.0130540244,
0.0400973037,
-0.0383544229,
0.0235956702,
0.0301582199,
-0.0088023702,
-0.0243551303,
-0.0255844258,
-0.0987542942,
-0.040180292,
0.0130922813,
-0.0448213406,
-0.011584525,
-0.0520472266,
0.0180501454,
0.0753253698,
-0.0017098581,
-0.0187481567,
2.630016393e-34,
-0.0016929962,
-0.0235416368,
0.0123224361,
0.0217556935,
0.0032046936,
-0.0250491686,
-0.0143059753,
-0.0071827266,
-0.0157375392,
-0.1024303213,
-0.0558978133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08931v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08931v1 | Teach model to answer questions after comprehending the document | 2023-07-18T02:38:02 | 2023-07-18T02:38:02 | Ruiqing Sun, Ping Jian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-choice Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC) is a challenging extension
of Natural Language Processing (NLP) that requires the ability to comprehend
the semantics and logical relationships between entities in a given text. The
MRC task has traditionally been viewed as a process of answering questions
based on the given text. This single-stage approach has often led the network
to concentrate on generating the correct answer, potentially neglecting the
comprehension of the text itself. As a result, many prevalent models have faced
challenges in performing well on this task when dealing with longer texts. In
this paper, we propose a two-stage knowledge distillation method that teaches
the model to better comprehend the document by dividing the MRC task into two
separate stages. Our experimental results show that the student model, when
equipped with our method, achieves significant improvements, demonstrating the
effectiveness of our method. | [
0.0238849185,
0.0066641164,
-0.0029569713,
0.0269059967,
-0.0381757244,
0.0429736823,
-0.0219222568,
-0.0442336239,
0.0291115176,
-0.0035655517,
0.0476817042,
0.0316331238,
-0.0402297229,
0.0250354894,
-0.0131335007,
-0.0597868338,
0.0250865594,
-0.0249836296,
0.0097148614,
0.0118208835,
-0.0094632925,
0.0348461457,
-0.0093980022,
-0.0315958709,
0.0491058789,
-0.0598261878,
-0.0456410833,
-0.0090698507,
0.0218707733,
-0.0233646221,
-0.0097086672,
0.0148967877,
0.0131643517,
0.0193192381,
0.0000020304,
-0.0475353599,
-0.0633391142,
0.0126212612,
-0.0504323877,
0.0075049023,
0.0269777905,
-0.0087400144,
0.0531077236,
-0.0002241835,
-0.0122310361,
0.0176266152,
-0.0212092623,
0.0684935004,
0.0553565882,
0.0378970429,
0.0160654671,
-0.0377334766,
0.0139090847,
0.0123603232,
0.0182553791,
-0.0543943755,
0.0005279432,
0.0399701409,
0.0205377713,
0.0399988964,
-0.0403633863,
0.0604842305,
0.0485322736,
0.0275054425,
0.0092423661,
0.0423316434,
0.0421735086,
-0.0298337881,
-0.0158925503,
0.0757560655,
-0.0052235615,
0.0018243465,
0.0045713591,
-0.0025296165,
0.0072261514,
0.0459268875,
-0.0321289524,
-0.0318706036,
-0.0630665049,
-0.0021858467,
-0.0196199082,
-0.0159258042,
0.0060345423,
0.0435885191,
-0.0403160751,
0.0493759774,
-0.0261144303,
-0.0330868773,
0.0439518616,
0.0220175963,
-0.0102573242,
-0.0018462837,
0.0705120191,
0.0690127164,
-0.0087540969,
0.0177925508,
-0.0167810582,
-0.0440904275,
0.0117788054,
-0.0326153375,
-0.0005455599,
0.0341212712,
-0.0034150211,
0.061439082,
-0.0539325401,
0.0136930346,
-0.0239088237,
0.0340722911,
-0.0679538772,
0.0035288853,
-0.0438733622,
-0.0311164819,
-0.042422872,
0.0352475233,
-0.0740631297,
-0.0321200639,
0.0081782378,
0.0331963338,
0.0295148734,
0.0116610024,
0.0129513629,
0.0346393324,
-0.0556171723,
-0.0288648456,
-0.0620005541,
0.0891495571,
-0.0875947401,
-0.0072015901,
0.005552595,
0.0112915654,
-0.0273349378,
-0.0339775048,
-0.0036356996,
-0.0281647108,
-0.0023159396,
0.048399549,
-0.056673307,
-0.0158884525,
-0.0336447433,
-0.0297795124,
0.0090833129,
-0.0771285519,
0.0197518896,
-0.0352614,
0.0379588753,
0.0075852554,
0.0125652943,
-0.0046445173,
-0.0039421674,
0.0027047787,
-0.0370333828,
0.1032693982,
-0.0012387999,
-0.0206520669,
0.0541760772,
0.0375415832,
-0.0200622752,
0.0705365017,
0.0131758032,
0.010802066,
0.0293146484,
0.0023392639,
-0.0264357869,
-0.0087613575,
0.0281249266,
-0.0047320956,
0.0059859827,
0.0268165041,
-0.0380520821,
0.0388811976,
0.0424244553,
0.0242291428,
-0.039181117,
-0.0015240378,
0.0434687436,
-0.0057592392,
0.0286281481,
0.011207765,
0.0255812015,
0.0484037958,
0.0142676672,
0.1012097672,
-0.0320901349,
0.0276873093,
-0.0163944196,
0.0348681472,
0.0103754262,
0.0471966788,
-0.0053582257,
-0.0457843207,
0.0456716157,
0.0143962391,
0.0216258597,
0.0384771787,
0.0609132536,
0.0501576588,
-0.0343470387,
0.0171963647,
0.0147307152,
-0.0156301837,
0.0288220942,
-0.030481169,
0.0482176542,
0.0481903963,
0.0710162073,
-0.0347862318,
-0.0323149264,
-0.0196046289,
-0.0040119933,
0.0017742633,
0.0399448462,
-0.0403969474,
0.0231879074,
-0.0444389582,
-0.0330219492,
-0.0000150031,
-0.0089119682,
0.0014606104,
-0.0009517035,
-0.0089655966,
0.011514469,
-0.0633795336,
-0.0140849622,
0.0402389206,
-0.0319585726,
-0.0571040064,
-0.0367022306,
0.0289368723,
0.024614539,
0.0313987173,
0.0143793672,
-0.028249776,
0.0300395414,
-0.0202040542,
0.0003346811,
-0.0194340162,
-0.0505841151,
-0.0758976117,
0.0197033696,
-0.0479842164,
-0.0235377792,
0.048263777,
-0.0401683375,
-0.0485918596,
-0.0216126889,
-0.0043180315,
0.0036517279,
-0.0260524675,
-0.006676429,
0.0141445249,
-0.0291392691,
-0.0534863286,
0.0597111508,
-0.0110978801,
0.0030762872,
-0.0095487656,
-0.0136119407,
-0.0191718396,
0.0316560082,
0.0036177852,
0.021219315,
0.0109677678,
0.0012367087,
-0.0055765817,
0.009419878,
-0.0726609752,
-0.0243920274,
-0.0356661975,
0.0351416022,
0.0026268456,
0.0035753327,
0.0348634683,
0.0262527857,
0.0080588665,
-0.0393183641,
-0.0168130007,
0.0074346932,
-0.0148931285,
-0.0005518213,
0.031481225,
0.0082283393,
0.0206844024,
0.0175005887,
-0.0260524601,
-0.0088516735,
0.0558266416,
0.0139424792,
0.0137910405,
-0.0432247594,
0.0193975344,
0.0020868578,
-0.0038134945,
-0.0014271523,
0.0090606948,
0.0168038886,
-0.0323452204,
0.0055248407,
0.0826884806,
0.0061581377,
0.0609809197,
0.0295705777,
0.011542554,
-0.0685014799,
0.0515931323,
-0.0300843772,
0.0268191416,
-0.0279572178,
-0.0303020459,
-0.0332591385,
0.0708072782,
-0.0161878131,
-0.0309258122,
0.0102729229,
0.0133352075,
-0.0074030752,
-0.0413389355,
-0.0721235126,
0.0053083729,
-0.0097311381,
0.0275353901,
-0.0330582522,
-0.0034924725,
0.0997831374,
-0.0177076012,
-0.0183229446,
-0.1139674261,
0.0240343288,
-0.0200567245,
0.0403570868,
0.0001654958,
0.0123757683,
-0.0070893876,
-0.0259324238,
-0.0604983829,
-0.027089959,
0.0496839657,
-0.0035714754,
0.0567127466,
-0.0389044061,
-0.032459043,
-0.0085737929,
0.0005399026,
-0.0258543026,
0.0178560466,
-0.0127843032,
0.0080323489,
0.0022533361,
0.0205701441,
-0.0570269562,
-0.0160220247,
0.05052872,
0.0494266264,
-0.0259201117,
-0.0289347898,
-0.052637957,
0.0955619887,
0.0276028421,
0.0504117087,
0.0394928195,
-0.036272496,
0.0704942942,
0.0667936802,
0.0065622721,
-0.0204180572,
-0.0014255927,
0.002537603,
0.0052689505,
-0.0773842037,
0.0533294715,
-0.025333846,
0.0514445007,
-0.086861752,
-0.0158181097,
0.0699259266,
0.025566088,
-0.0059010801,
-0.0311961696,
-0.0120320059,
0.0494172908,
0.0140995011,
0.0438516662,
-0.0535803214,
-0.0232114736,
0.0015139449,
0.0657063127,
0.0327646248,
-0.0139102414,
-0.0162303597,
-0.0537765659,
0.0012512085,
0.0115397414,
-0.0588308796,
-0.0404997021,
-0.0411947295,
-0.0274710245,
-0.0041872077,
0.0314153805,
0.0377223752,
-0.0021209463,
0.0057808533,
0.0059602228,
0.0391322039,
-0.0143175116,
-0.0291530974,
-0.0406241044,
-0.0183275174,
0.0444294065,
0.030196026,
0.0067979218,
0.0383416191,
-0.0194723848,
-0.0377618149,
0.0073381495,
-0.0018177006,
0.0686175972,
-0.0061757355,
0.0037388352,
-0.0180538949,
0.0542095639,
-0.0349892303,
-0.0099938763,
0.0284275711,
0.0378929563,
0.0218448229,
-0.0624759644,
-0.0419530198,
0.0016239855,
-0.0075401673,
0.0876396596,
0.0468401462,
-0.0352694131,
-0.0748909265,
-0.0477795526,
-0.0021012549,
-0.0897598565,
0.0232461877,
0.0203689523,
-0.0343813561,
0.0359398834,
-0.0302021466,
-0.0795550719,
0.0340650901,
0.0266744569,
0.0028008972,
0.0052553271,
0.0674610808,
0.0073185447,
-0.0410575047,
0.0004185107,
0.0072184606,
-0.0078184484,
0.004796504,
-0.0061533977,
-0.0148370555,
-0.0449621603,
-0.0301350858,
0.0120481933,
-0.0699670762,
-0.0164449178,
-0.0077794716,
0.0147826076,
0.0193374809,
0.0815530941,
-0.0312553979,
-0.04403935,
0.0656031817,
-0.03145108,
-0.0579523817,
-0.0004616691,
-0.0118834144,
0.0017205663,
-0.0172722079,
0.007692737,
0.0074142599,
0.0262015834,
-0.0279124565,
0.051722534,
-0.040660914,
-0.0141808232,
0.0324865319,
0.0277507268,
-0.0109906038,
0.0143313212,
0.0264808834,
-0.05964965,
0.0289588105,
0.0110827833,
-0.0185460765,
-0.0264322069,
0.0118913976,
0.0378511995,
-0.0368647017,
-0.0084750205,
-0.0048381332,
0.0215167981,
0.0284895636,
-0.0023177168,
0.0133655928,
0.0619928651,
0.0066121002,
0.0319726951,
-0.0270225741,
-0.0287648328,
0.0345074795,
-0.0282552168,
0.05087661,
0.0081450306,
0.0814709142,
0.0597021021,
-0.0030809112,
-0.0063287239,
0.000183895,
-0.0744390115,
-0.0170493983,
-0.0263356771,
0.0317445397,
-0.0118391383,
0.0119536817,
0.0363161601,
-0.0053587477,
-0.0215807613,
-0.0064988532,
0.0050359964,
-0.0033274512,
0.0103731668,
-0.0084923748,
0.037112359,
0.0304211508,
-0.0150473742,
0.066453211,
-0.0004236281,
0.0313764922,
-0.0062161954,
-0.0096238665,
-0.0650077611,
-0.0439667404,
-0.0343016945,
0.0374009721,
-0.0153013878,
0.0101322997,
-0.0309410598,
-0.0717532113,
0.0298050027,
0.0110509684,
0.0158428699,
-0.0278646853,
0.0040839841,
0.0579051822,
0.000711177,
-0.0704103112,
-0.0480196029,
0.0240206718,
-0.0294293649,
-0.0326799527,
0.0184940305,
-6.014490682e-33,
-0.0258704256,
-0.0354272611,
0.0151609695,
-0.0379786864,
-0.0105469842,
0.0036283617,
-0.0011939199,
-0.0458731018,
-0.0105095441,
0.0394920856,
-0.034727443,
0.0319889821,
0.0081101935,
0.0238883607,
-0.0169166084,
0.0093386238,
0.0711973831,
-0.0313772634,
-0.0288014002,
0.0373174399,
0.051949881,
0.0654021725,
0.0237259939,
-0.0195176471,
0.0365649946,
-0.0113211144,
-0.0117523065,
0.022370385,
-0.0167984385,
0.0273794886,
-0.0265124664,
0.0176548511,
0.0506127849,
-0.0431721583,
-0.0303924568,
0.0671175718,
-0.1682012379,
-0.0386275463,
0.0087968167,
0.0227100626,
-0.0721316412,
-0.0097456658,
0.0438128375,
-0.0079015754,
0.1013172343,
-0.0591742471,
0.043533951,
-0.0271382295,
-0.047399465,
-0.0160038136,
-0.0506402068,
0.0081727942,
-0.0472951159,
-0.0295400154,
0.0110403132,
0.0342109352,
-0.0018669544,
0.0287645813,
-0.0680881143,
-0.02054682,
0.0522232503,
0.0227102712,
0.0091000246,
0.0262170322,
-0.0432788357,
0.0196646675,
-0.0388717093,
-0.0412783846,
-0.0338735543,
-0.0079646176,
0.0404740572,
0.0257446263,
0.0121286549,
0.040109504,
0.0615112893,
0.0018361666,
-0.0428624898,
0.0475349315,
0.0041569993,
0.0385657884,
-0.0103453239,
-0.0221005734,
-0.0182670113,
-0.0023556205,
-0.0708040893,
-0.0361644439,
-0.044658158,
-0.002341866,
0.017530337,
-0.0054194871,
-0.0792919621,
-0.0070763044,
0.0252664648,
-0.0677796304,
0.0008774917,
0.0343105458,
-0.0031718735,
0.0230217203,
-0.0002148517,
0.0408854261,
-0.0348774754,
0.0139910718,
0.0032141278,
-0.013915753,
-0.0135125769,
0.0066630179,
0.0340931043,
-0.0381832123,
-0.0255972631,
0.0014229403,
-0.0296166576,
0.0028512422,
0.0177298859,
0.0502486676,
0.0257387124,
0.0181905162,
-0.0262182411,
0.0088453405,
0.00755401,
-0.0028426233,
-0.04528578,
0.0135060018,
0.0027802938,
0.0508555062,
-0.0213574059,
-0.0271855891,
-0.0141563574,
-0.0207839087,
0.0253275,
-0.0693405122,
0.0214762744,
0.0648156181,
2.617e-7,
0.0463378206,
0.0229007397,
0.0394998454,
0.0143748699,
-0.0021549952,
0.0145423496,
0.0226325113,
0.0239819717,
0.0372873619,
-0.0635470152,
0.0153398793,
0.0472972989,
0.0270873755,
0.0399235711,
-0.1069221124,
-0.0526470467,
0.0094676735,
0.0035078474,
-0.0259138085,
-0.0338873081,
0.0464436747,
0.0126709212,
0.0157959983,
-0.0189413559,
0.0162061471,
-0.0169912037,
0.0208523143,
0.0155595494,
0.024782829,
0.0461908504,
0.0343625993,
-0.0260815583,
-0.0102641433,
0.0411178395,
-0.0092241522,
0.0054474673,
0.0157027077,
0.0653789714,
0.0403083637,
-0.037854515,
-0.0044214521,
0.0166632105,
0.0267676543,
-0.0539928563,
0.0517325476,
-0.0684209242,
-0.003152481,
0.0076208333,
-0.0588413142,
-0.0552032329,
0.0194841418,
0.0133951921,
0.0133009618,
0.0535131805,
-0.0203782171,
-0.0254708845,
0.0089019705,
-0.0823586136,
0.0061913487,
0.006668862,
-0.013150027,
-0.0278685279,
-0.0129544912,
-0.070303306,
0.045329906,
-0.0607600845,
-0.0233998913,
1.968269552e-34,
0.0040245862,
-0.0148289846,
0.0109301442,
0.0253747795,
0.0048479936,
-0.0238375682,
-0.0451561995,
-0.0064885747,
0.0045516379,
-0.0857909545,
-0.0165444836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08925v1 | Federated Large Language Model: A Position Paper | 2023-07-18T02:09:14 | 2023-07-18T02:09:14 | Chaochao Chen, Xiaohua Feng, Jun Zhou, Jianwei Yin, Xiaolin Zheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large scale language models (LLM) have received significant attention and
found diverse applications across various domains, but their development
encounters challenges in real-world scenarios. These challenges arise due to
the scarcity of public domain data availability and the need to maintain
privacy with respect to private domain data. To address these issues, federated
learning (FL) has emerged as a promising technology that enables collaborative
training of shared models while preserving decentralized data. We propose the
concept of federated LLM, which comprises three key components, i.e., federated
LLM pre-training, federated LLM fine-tuning, and federated LLM prompt
engineering. For each component, we discuss its advantage over traditional LLM
training methods and propose specific engineering strategies for
implementation. Furthermore, we explore the novel challenges introduced by the
integration of FL and LLM. We analyze existing solutions and identify potential
obstacles faced by these solutions within the context of federated LLM. | [
0.0212535504,
0.0750355124,
-0.039182391,
0.0370366052,
-0.0375985466,
0.0100350352,
0.0883935466,
-0.0090476349,
0.047457397,
-0.0496647358,
-0.0821291432,
-0.0449643657,
-0.0114800297,
0.037558239,
-0.0006873585,
-0.0272470266,
0.0381497815,
-0.0578334369,
-0.041210793,
-0.0372910202,
-0.0258089248,
0.0112619353,
0.0299074315,
0.0179189984,
0.0119929425,
-0.0420022421,
-0.0159411654,
-0.0043742284,
-0.0131024579,
0.0130807487,
0.0336277634,
0.0602605529,
0.0455211401,
0.0857347399,
0.0000020973,
-0.0486512035,
-0.0413642004,
0.0235252716,
-0.0117617426,
0.0678796992,
0.0087259216,
0.0180857703,
-0.0197093263,
0.0352092572,
-0.0468391851,
-0.0302075632,
0.0344462916,
0.0068388884,
0.0705354661,
0.0582376309,
0.0109190885,
-0.066122219,
-0.0049842591,
-0.0263443142,
-0.1230393201,
-0.0061638756,
0.0426151045,
0.0132997558,
0.0144795114,
0.0081622144,
-0.0129400743,
0.0277111717,
0.0218153074,
0.0257664397,
-0.0045277267,
0.008333019,
-0.0249991622,
-0.0246054679,
-0.0537794232,
0.0373763032,
0.0311178435,
-0.0059697269,
0.0236151218,
-0.0121451719,
-0.0167692024,
0.0388733819,
-0.0143326977,
0.0370917208,
0.0163810048,
0.0369156264,
0.0002142236,
-0.0510052107,
0.014261717,
0.0180192124,
-0.002812482,
0.0749927387,
0.008382435,
-0.0201544855,
-0.0457452685,
-0.0300143231,
-0.0098626567,
-0.0663123429,
0.051444497,
0.0347623378,
-0.0164800733,
0.0043332018,
-0.0623202138,
-0.0627439395,
0.0262518488,
-0.0074671907,
0.0273766853,
-0.0344101936,
-0.0194967296,
0.0397327952,
-0.020814063,
0.0103644747,
-0.0164165478,
0.0237492733,
-0.0026039979,
0.0179562476,
-0.0677515641,
0.0168637652,
-0.0261306446,
0.0542871915,
-0.0400369018,
-0.000542094,
-0.0089917965,
0.0321930684,
-0.0124994153,
0.0369394086,
0.0235249512,
-0.0309094023,
-0.0139026176,
-0.0360916071,
0.0004027277,
0.0211587455,
-0.0023125997,
0.0105810957,
-0.0067626899,
-0.0306646582,
0.0196557846,
-0.0021806406,
-0.023942247,
0.0136396755,
-0.0009470894,
0.055004742,
0.0280801468,
0.0037472639,
-0.0324694254,
-0.0625409707,
0.0471671,
-0.066562131,
-0.0231209695,
-0.0707549006,
-0.0133756604,
0.0048164185,
0.0150817512,
-0.0409799255,
-0.0147873191,
-0.0169126354,
-0.0001083812,
0.0401957519,
-0.0363735184,
0.0214046948,
0.0233542491,
0.0168557204,
0.0080673108,
0.0997139961,
0.0039483234,
-0.0059312521,
0.0586348958,
-0.0179973189,
-0.0299592894,
0.0601765364,
0.0154313417,
0.0420619994,
-0.008787686,
0.008309437,
0.0158062428,
-0.0010031889,
-0.0197421666,
0.0317443572,
0.0059976643,
0.0173381586,
0.0632837191,
0.0769801959,
0.0547146723,
-0.0076171965,
-0.0090014683,
0.0547096804,
0.0171161834,
0.0214041993,
-0.0514239892,
-0.0295054633,
-0.0340371504,
-0.0232095923,
-0.0147376657,
0.1024229378,
-0.0283949114,
-0.0237773471,
0.0006626476,
-0.0543582253,
-0.0388725176,
0.0212882627,
0.0522024333,
0.0011225594,
-0.0086048776,
0.0548292212,
0.019319471,
-0.0256452523,
0.0122487051,
-0.0336377434,
0.0013817189,
0.0504279435,
0.0645638332,
-0.0273971036,
-0.0170394313,
-0.0294713806,
0.0276018288,
0.0313164033,
0.0159752797,
-0.0268800389,
0.0165016875,
-0.0490438491,
-0.0563488305,
0.0385677926,
0.0191528518,
0.0022940678,
-0.0295203496,
-0.0161687024,
-0.0171427969,
0.0205051228,
-0.0315663889,
0.0330433324,
-0.0244881772,
-0.0115214214,
-0.0037741018,
0.0314456671,
0.0413771346,
0.0205486454,
-0.0276777875,
-0.0214593802,
0.0305171572,
0.0163029637,
-0.0424494594,
-0.0359566063,
-0.0056663626,
0.0223645978,
0.0211417954,
0.0100451941,
0.0122197522,
0.0125264516,
-0.0581426024,
-0.0325535499,
-0.0233906228,
0.0173648782,
0.0504589006,
-0.0250177905,
0.0434148647,
-0.0372041836,
0.0024652523,
-0.0481108055,
0.0112933619,
-0.0178985354,
-0.0224424787,
-0.0027905072,
-0.0017718183,
0.0431479998,
-0.0154914418,
0.0059520779,
0.0154493218,
0.02120189,
0.033412192,
-0.0101323258,
0.028945893,
-0.0157583114,
0.0077815964,
-0.0109788477,
0.0136069823,
-0.0301959496,
0.0397077315,
0.027056545,
0.0049310625,
-0.0305836648,
-0.0262893438,
-0.0170248765,
0.030439334,
-0.0183216184,
0.0223485138,
-0.0163148139,
0.0187549703,
-0.0728040412,
0.0204133112,
-0.0251621976,
0.0118947849,
0.0232824795,
-0.0157597009,
-0.028440129,
-0.1123083606,
0.0415970385,
-0.0524607971,
0.0493034087,
0.0278643779,
-0.0170925334,
0.001759419,
0.0144375404,
0.0031553204,
0.0307303704,
-0.0206667483,
-0.0099940356,
0.0633649006,
0.0017948312,
-0.0499316119,
-0.0260768123,
-0.0177357458,
-0.0404762365,
-0.0678762645,
0.0361979939,
0.0251373593,
0.0301229842,
-0.0138374865,
-0.0273106787,
-0.0194431413,
0.0352805294,
-0.0391736776,
-0.0309052449,
-0.0478948727,
-0.0218868405,
-0.0052697556,
0.0483997054,
0.0337082185,
-0.0901039466,
0.0855642483,
-0.0312821344,
0.0249108467,
-0.0343585126,
-0.052424144,
-0.0670692846,
0.0555839315,
-0.0358290561,
0.0323468484,
0.0260016005,
-0.0617943518,
-0.0424219109,
0.0313521847,
0.0231526382,
-0.0327791274,
0.0184195042,
-0.0280513372,
-0.0198247079,
-0.0100140143,
-0.054240752,
-0.0019302794,
-0.0358896777,
-0.0642708689,
0.0259343758,
-0.0463541932,
-0.0179846287,
0.0092784185,
0.0378457308,
-0.0051280539,
0.0023856084,
-0.0066143293,
0.0260319058,
-0.0291142594,
0.0011552866,
0.0008497532,
-0.0470612459,
-0.0036038491,
-0.0344301686,
0.0085871331,
0.0248624943,
0.0729992017,
-0.0410114452,
0.0391258374,
-0.0364298932,
0.0571737699,
-0.0548558421,
-0.0103704073,
0.0112281973,
0.0360390656,
-0.0559566692,
0.0092662685,
0.0996062309,
0.0246768612,
-0.0578839332,
-0.0038228258,
-0.0261464175,
0.0519330055,
0.0162395965,
0.022319356,
-0.0984195992,
-0.0125381118,
0.0209320113,
0.0354491509,
0.0033722545,
-0.0100890957,
-0.0277625415,
-0.1024045646,
0.0335377567,
0.025560569,
-0.0103588263,
-0.0359467939,
-0.0419755392,
0.0141829262,
0.0247838423,
0.0226182267,
-0.0090965116,
-0.0147006679,
-0.0173761863,
0.0370148979,
-0.0169199482,
-0.0671279803,
-0.0169616695,
-0.0674674064,
0.0797241554,
0.0391078964,
-0.0188105069,
0.0062960614,
-0.0339485221,
0.0089767016,
0.0377063453,
-0.0048053828,
-0.0392711423,
0.0068308217,
-0.0216381736,
-0.0157730915,
0.0099669406,
0.0348772593,
0.0125116007,
-0.0061130882,
0.0435800105,
0.0985169485,
-0.0331437998,
0.0133509468,
0.0138405254,
-0.024714008,
0.0471360497,
0.0578757301,
0.0024564962,
-0.0423161127,
-0.0190448202,
0.0156839471,
-0.0095107192,
0.0230191145,
-0.0123249292,
0.0415097512,
-0.0334537663,
0.0032575042,
-0.0177982096,
0.014064597,
0.0207663793,
0.0210913848,
0.0559063032,
0.0329643153,
0.0717515275,
-0.0146372914,
-0.0027545707,
0.0300183091,
-0.0943453684,
0.0323862508,
-0.1083827168,
-0.0438982323,
0.0284728613,
-0.0063915025,
-0.0217936933,
0.0224861186,
-0.0678158477,
-0.0782887414,
0.0216311663,
0.0106113441,
0.0233744644,
0.0310968626,
-0.0179427043,
-0.0935331583,
0.0858015567,
0.0074399733,
-0.0695159659,
0.0193603449,
0.0456849635,
-0.0602146424,
0.0009920225,
0.0387202017,
-0.0538617,
0.0100515466,
0.0483432226,
-0.0238630362,
0.0173712689,
-0.0714511052,
-0.014499343,
0.0501658916,
0.0579606555,
-0.0145799397,
0.0097343093,
-0.0538848042,
0.054008428,
-0.0240787957,
-0.0082000485,
-0.0209816713,
0.0061470894,
0.002227409,
-0.0227974989,
0.0230804309,
-0.0078627234,
0.032515604,
0.0310285185,
-0.0246695541,
0.0532176457,
0.0026838449,
-0.024117142,
0.067810148,
-0.0007905383,
-0.0057238392,
0.0426861718,
0.0174286906,
0.0317904837,
-0.0209729113,
0.0661325008,
-0.0104966387,
0.029058747,
-0.032741908,
0.0303209741,
-0.0459760018,
-0.1320491582,
-0.0061712512,
0.0277398583,
0.0458116457,
0.0440065898,
0.0278298222,
-0.0454273224,
-0.0054804804,
-0.029290121,
0.0117946342,
-0.0101932399,
-0.05760796,
0.030165609,
-0.0062911673,
-0.019262068,
0.0669811592,
0.085644573,
0.0116825309,
0.0362440422,
-0.0211935341,
-0.0240073837,
-0.0415536575,
-0.0372973308,
0.0406518839,
0.0296330042,
-0.0779835507,
-0.0335288197,
-0.0507302396,
-0.0449560918,
-0.009232712,
0.0016655724,
-0.0363692641,
-0.0254735779,
0.0290146954,
0.0231968667,
-0.0016054814,
-0.0183745194,
-0.0605125055,
0.0245489236,
0.0108125303,
-0.0136425663,
0.0005598686,
-6.019698856e-33,
-0.0164252184,
-0.0056264433,
0.0144557385,
0.0189899411,
-0.0126761105,
0.0356071554,
0.0137853874,
-0.010707329,
0.0249573011,
-0.012878146,
-0.0216134079,
0.0017846307,
0.0241922699,
0.0293878671,
-0.0017050204,
0.0008094219,
0.0671462417,
-0.0546868928,
0.0039264867,
0.0439658947,
0.0415064581,
0.0556482188,
0.0443721525,
-0.0517597906,
0.0030929502,
-0.0265762229,
-0.0130316671,
0.0376463868,
-0.0443976037,
0.0486558303,
-0.0326448046,
0.0358734727,
0.00514118,
-0.0484830178,
-0.0451305322,
0.0202389993,
-0.0383031107,
0.0068989987,
0.0067416993,
0.0366449319,
0.0121745011,
-0.0135394884,
0.0293807965,
-0.0304952525,
-0.0185895525,
0.0110245207,
0.0155044245,
0.0053979759,
-0.024050707,
-0.0258361697,
-0.0246024933,
0.0084928544,
0.0127014061,
0.0167794563,
0.0496539101,
0.0036268909,
0.0125434902,
-0.0256988704,
-0.0316953771,
0.0333959498,
0.0346903466,
0.0189576969,
0.0754133835,
0.0506275818,
0.0153743401,
0.0413407348,
0.0352202468,
0.0104149524,
-0.0102201235,
0.0078013423,
0.0300953798,
0.0427909456,
-0.0065322993,
0.0349231586,
-0.0370484665,
-0.035567157,
-0.0327281952,
-0.0157630965,
0.0224921554,
-0.0083734216,
0.0130764404,
0.0288335234,
-0.0089787673,
-0.018721154,
-0.0500523709,
0.0050603873,
-0.0055215769,
-0.0063976445,
0.0013760503,
-0.0070761512,
-0.0273513757,
-0.0242513325,
0.0442287922,
-0.0503985137,
-0.0534217656,
0.0242752098,
0.0616691597,
0.0208640154,
-0.0003864197,
0.0355975516,
-0.0763635561,
-0.0411744006,
-0.0150142182,
-0.033668302,
0.0066199214,
-0.0122797284,
0.0482898876,
0.0173664615,
-0.0564153083,
0.0247109644,
-0.0173786879,
-0.0018190497,
0.043296963,
0.0279896464,
0.0495597199,
-0.0127193369,
0.0252460893,
0.0300315246,
0.0359245278,
-0.0377940312,
-0.0175697729,
0.0112642646,
-0.0026530945,
0.0159367807,
0.0073190392,
-0.0059240502,
-0.0538206957,
0.0128254676,
0.0716486797,
-0.0105546881,
0.0094078835,
-0.0386369638,
2.749e-7,
0.0198957007,
0.0257936884,
-0.013620724,
-0.0364926644,
0.0381527878,
0.0390211754,
-0.013922479,
0.0364978276,
0.0207969695,
0.0131728994,
-0.0007110765,
0.0095823584,
0.048610691,
0.0094817076,
-0.0584366135,
-0.0258284025,
-0.0187239256,
0.0451562852,
-0.0920274481,
-0.0090548117,
-0.0068186792,
0.0613416061,
0.038712915,
-0.0290814303,
-0.0198152568,
-0.0057460065,
0.0162492394,
-0.0238269717,
-0.0379516557,
0.0181738175,
-0.0018649371,
0.0773072615,
-0.0019785725,
0.0049256659,
-0.0116988085,
0.027892584,
-0.0499425121,
0.0746241584,
0.0266842544,
0.0573471785,
-0.0063787717,
-0.0424693525,
-0.0563494526,
-0.0122296996,
0.0585042574,
-0.05109936,
-0.0355730653,
-0.0309000835,
0.0202426482,
-0.0866071135,
0.0102283126,
-0.021835966,
-0.0015499488,
0.03328133,
0.0099175964,
-0.0215871725,
-0.0247902162,
-0.0694365576,
0.0102660349,
-0.0078846319,
-0.0286222603,
-0.0534652025,
-0.007547169,
0.0348547809,
-0.0070188851,
-0.0453796946,
0.017235186,
2.737758485e-34,
0.0185181461,
-0.0222595483,
0.0156254806,
0.035802789,
0.0000253848,
-0.0352007374,
-0.0065153418,
0.0176578127,
0.0062696063,
-0.0724519938,
0.0090419827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08922v1 | Large Language Models Perform Diagnostic Reasoning | 2023-07-18T01:43:00 | 2023-07-18T01:43:00 | Cheng-Kuang Wu, Wei-Lin Chen, Hsin-Hsi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore the extension of chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting to medical
reasoning for the task of automatic diagnosis. Motivated by doctors' underlying
reasoning process, we present Diagnostic-Reasoning CoT (DR-CoT). Empirical
results demonstrate that by simply prompting large language models trained only
on general text corpus with two DR-CoT exemplars, the diagnostic accuracy
improves by 15% comparing to standard prompting. Moreover, the gap reaches a
pronounced 18% in out-domain settings. Our findings suggest expert-knowledge
reasoning in large language models can be elicited through proper promptings. | [
0.0667468607,
0.0296212025,
-0.0004833192,
-0.0080668591,
-0.0297220573,
0.0480933785,
0.0459471978,
0.0695876405,
0.027826516,
-0.0408684574,
0.0141781149,
-0.0431191698,
-0.0063334862,
0.0241539404,
0.0164903514,
-0.0229160357,
0.0017733037,
-0.037643522,
0.0740377307,
-0.0057455017,
-0.0083287992,
0.030143844,
-0.045991309,
0.0317512155,
0.0076218103,
-0.0214860346,
0.0343106911,
-0.0324112698,
0.0369847007,
-0.0745812058,
-0.0189516023,
0.047257755,
-0.0057865586,
0.0038266629,
0.0000017518,
-0.0664132088,
0.0129493149,
0.00338249,
-0.0571644418,
-0.0349055566,
-0.0328655615,
-0.015586962,
0.0350143835,
0.0474975184,
-0.0226821154,
-0.0263563842,
-0.0151477885,
0.071711421,
0.0331049077,
0.0612701438,
-0.0164944381,
-0.0190855525,
0.0310647562,
-0.0190620981,
-0.0095004858,
-0.0362856835,
0.0648423433,
0.0245457832,
0.0477735922,
0.0083346348,
0.0194513835,
0.0219334103,
-0.0071375221,
-0.0054268874,
-0.0299644619,
0.0479723252,
0.0289878286,
-0.0236218069,
0.0123615209,
0.0523315035,
0.0239776,
-0.0125265829,
0.033148203,
0.0119884862,
0.0118758492,
0.0416407213,
-0.0100810071,
0.032577958,
-0.0473618545,
-0.0051526763,
0.0587094203,
0.0048055551,
0.0452746339,
0.0055522616,
-0.0310239475,
0.0398936681,
-0.0152046364,
-0.026870735,
0.0328130387,
0.0185482763,
-0.0174753889,
-0.070252277,
0.0248610117,
0.0429360718,
-0.0759717003,
0.0098607503,
0.0321862884,
-0.0128553566,
0.0500638671,
0.0005518161,
-0.016228037,
0.0019286226,
-0.0202074237,
0.0576005094,
-0.0416998826,
-0.0086385962,
-0.0537316874,
0.0212113969,
-0.041458454,
-0.0101958206,
-0.0631940067,
-0.0272307042,
0.0009274503,
-0.0037660059,
0.0409862474,
-0.0034060993,
-0.0331169218,
-0.005444495,
-0.0190727133,
0.0269657746,
-0.0035642916,
0.0283745378,
0.0231802296,
-0.0345721729,
-0.053309191,
0.0207546316,
-0.017897388,
0.0422705077,
0.0246005952,
0.0195271466,
0.0061470536,
-0.0063060429,
0.0022731393,
0.0036053204,
0.0488761142,
0.0233641379,
-0.0049000061,
0.0002314105,
0.0020562978,
-0.0635220781,
-0.0354206041,
-0.0388164036,
-0.019045705,
-0.0580680408,
-0.0032344249,
0.0690394044,
0.0141412206,
-0.0168276802,
0.0201743022,
-0.0004843608,
-0.0707865879,
0.052210059,
-0.0416750349,
0.0277538765,
0.0051462902,
0.0428280048,
-0.014388931,
0.0169874914,
-0.0043732547,
-0.0399227738,
-0.0211091712,
-0.0106042037,
0.0355746597,
-0.0216877032,
0.0001583757,
-0.0151056992,
0.0127015114,
0.0134638846,
-0.0065612928,
0.0885212421,
-0.0394635312,
0.0536423773,
-0.0053599761,
0.022300534,
0.0126068024,
0.0687103048,
0.0059305988,
-0.0018499957,
0.0516927876,
-0.0510979146,
-0.0002696059,
0.0158610232,
-0.0142199155,
0.0054065655,
-0.0190218054,
-0.0212173425,
-0.0209136382,
-0.0164885055,
-0.0181800518,
-0.0420437194,
-0.0721276402,
0.0290459562,
-0.0399149805,
0.0174293034,
0.0527732037,
-0.0052607856,
-0.0016784657,
0.0416722819,
0.0444254018,
0.002127043,
-0.0264447834,
-0.0815046132,
0.0103546316,
0.0746919289,
0.0290037338,
-0.0232288688,
-0.0223389473,
-0.0225030966,
0.0206046514,
-0.0087981969,
0.0214612335,
-0.0322263315,
-0.0203815047,
-0.0264515486,
-0.0054598451,
0.0494067967,
0.0157268438,
-0.0334685147,
-0.026165314,
0.0279677045,
-0.0089906091,
-0.0363103375,
-0.0188857466,
0.0267224666,
-0.0655005202,
-0.0026675367,
-0.004822487,
0.0168752559,
0.0051719085,
0.007987598,
-0.0168222059,
0.021237731,
-0.0126129407,
-0.0361609496,
-0.0513856262,
0.0140489433,
-0.045567207,
-0.0267395601,
-0.0022147913,
-0.0233139023,
-0.06339553,
-0.0540813766,
-0.0278908256,
-0.0388901979,
-0.0451355726,
-0.0289349966,
0.0194918104,
-0.0036886784,
0.007248973,
0.0239930041,
-0.0292797945,
-0.0172719155,
0.065939337,
-0.0211963896,
0.0177712198,
0.0315766968,
-0.0014099909,
0.005312108,
-0.0127115231,
-0.0305316132,
-0.0027702004,
0.0374319665,
-0.0128660724,
-0.0235467926,
-0.0033757624,
-0.0419892184,
-0.0298332479,
-0.1272978187,
-0.0365935676,
0.0005203959,
-0.0122183859,
0.0149172265,
-0.002743335,
0.0061766263,
0.0066643073,
-0.0605035685,
0.0076006115,
0.0349645019,
0.0363231748,
0.0496706478,
0.036622107,
0.0059262579,
-0.0010273487,
0.004444086,
-0.0751487762,
0.0398930348,
0.0473360233,
0.0139357531,
-0.0575871505,
0.0076178424,
-0.0495999008,
0.0057102609,
-0.0040337825,
-0.0212260671,
0.0168273747,
-0.0491305739,
-0.0020067219,
0.0752823502,
-0.0053318511,
-0.0236398987,
0.0721602887,
0.0096590826,
-0.0308639165,
0.0237442292,
-0.0262945071,
-0.0111428164,
0.0038585204,
-0.0379372984,
-0.0160553474,
0.0670844167,
0.0125548989,
-0.0230761915,
-0.047642529,
-0.0063855941,
-0.0074245087,
0.0134391254,
-0.0412399247,
-0.043933738,
0.0123703396,
0.1093355641,
0.0256806947,
-0.0094843926,
0.1129691973,
-0.0054791784,
0.024248559,
-0.052695334,
-0.0164134707,
-0.0347141661,
0.0361563377,
-0.0105130253,
0.018383665,
0.0404183902,
0.0041474458,
-0.0205975939,
0.0102988221,
-0.0034198912,
-0.0491797812,
0.0246195272,
-0.0418776348,
0.0294986553,
0.0395728052,
-0.0761405304,
-0.041856885,
-0.0254531018,
-0.067208156,
-0.029620368,
-0.0103226956,
-0.0073307194,
-0.025566414,
0.0204047896,
0.0128298374,
0.0650906637,
0.0338490233,
-0.0344216749,
0.0151029211,
0.0051568095,
0.0059035365,
-0.0165009927,
0.0144195659,
-0.0389092751,
0.0475399122,
0.0431132205,
-0.0068519763,
0.0201856606,
-0.0207135007,
0.0100499569,
-0.007270976,
0.0086078206,
-0.0276966076,
0.0134007996,
-0.0035095599,
-0.0494405702,
-0.0148899192,
0.1214909181,
0.0329062566,
-0.0827621669,
0.0037372336,
-0.0360887982,
-0.0032641201,
-0.0072351811,
-0.0001292075,
-0.0686529875,
-0.0401974805,
0.0165786073,
-0.0199424736,
-0.0335515998,
-0.0480234027,
0.0226485766,
-0.0509275757,
0.0226945784,
-0.0415556245,
0.0424727909,
-0.0206152592,
-0.0364119597,
0.0126268817,
0.0217803475,
-0.038619034,
0.0044296551,
0.0052102441,
-0.01440759,
0.0105544329,
-0.0559609458,
-0.0603609681,
0.0746688396,
-0.0092275189,
0.0376979746,
0.0559419543,
0.0262491964,
-0.0020189595,
-0.0413989723,
-0.0109024644,
0.0062273419,
0.0421559811,
0.004125928,
0.0796916261,
0.0213282481,
0.0062916558,
-0.0668851659,
0.0412906818,
-0.0431438051,
-0.0008265542,
0.0242325682,
0.1035007685,
-0.0399511009,
-0.0513710864,
-0.0355726928,
0.0357115455,
0.005028456,
0.0487456061,
-0.0203714799,
-0.0191320553,
0.0028850522,
0.0264551099,
-0.0116725415,
0.0465559922,
-0.0419210903,
0.0369164497,
0.0219591279,
-0.0053167706,
-0.0640589222,
-0.0121995639,
0.0434492864,
0.0365093276,
0.0246899147,
0.0122894049,
-0.0172624346,
0.0313921943,
-0.0257047322,
0.0632577762,
0.0355776735,
0.0180800669,
-0.0529356152,
0.0106413746,
0.0588512383,
-0.0063310401,
-0.021113161,
0.0023071161,
-0.0314900801,
-0.0192203186,
-0.0267579183,
0.0210061744,
0.0255178139,
0.0156506374,
-0.0345027186,
-0.0498486049,
0.0111221187,
0.0189133491,
-0.0340388492,
-0.0174402017,
0.0159294251,
-0.0166300684,
0.016700143,
0.0365380868,
-0.0238060337,
0.019092124,
0.0073476606,
0.0181050785,
-0.0333727263,
-0.0148221692,
0.031294208,
0.0233667996,
0.057522174,
-0.0115207611,
-0.0052537997,
-0.0172334518,
0.0197879374,
-0.0015765756,
-0.0380793698,
0.0043857517,
0.0446969494,
0.028557485,
-0.0173446927,
-0.00922006,
-0.0488404445,
-0.0208690241,
-0.0496164933,
-0.0075644818,
0.0367000028,
0.0265971571,
-0.0005871598,
0.0921982452,
-0.0395767651,
-0.0051488332,
-0.0189441685,
0.0227432624,
0.0510760881,
0.005346253,
0.1181096956,
0.0389118269,
0.0125557669,
-0.0099580456,
-0.0076736524,
-0.066364713,
-0.0904531181,
0.0342127457,
0.0119949058,
0.0286400504,
-0.011410458,
0.0036297529,
-0.048171632,
0.0197299421,
0.0196958743,
0.0091749886,
-0.001659637,
0.0065991352,
0.0478782244,
0.0035398756,
0.0008440911,
0.0064398451,
0.0680144802,
-0.0282434244,
0.023748951,
0.0104855942,
-0.0476808101,
-0.0284663681,
-0.0207924098,
-0.0399392284,
0.0134744709,
-0.0362235494,
0.0387411602,
-0.0821180716,
-0.0583612807,
-0.0256989747,
-0.031644959,
-0.0076203933,
-0.0050695478,
0.0134925852,
0.0854691938,
0.0158284269,
-0.0192484744,
-0.0278935786,
0.0616486929,
-0.0129479626,
-0.0068240967,
-0.0198213495,
-5.919409352e-33,
0.0357608199,
-0.0481454358,
0.0263184924,
-0.0402410328,
0.0349918678,
0.0356409214,
-0.0432767458,
0.0232633017,
-0.0128457602,
0.0794751495,
-0.0392494947,
0.0150353424,
0.0004375629,
0.0093963146,
0.0365688093,
-0.010829594,
0.0204055067,
0.0242174305,
-0.0267951246,
0.0259368345,
0.0251871105,
0.0276724827,
0.0007238701,
-0.0941779986,
0.0312476289,
-0.0205991268,
0.0352512673,
0.0389227085,
-0.0560601987,
0.0303347558,
-0.0164616015,
0.0231742598,
0.0533924289,
0.0011875911,
0.0248411801,
0.0153453033,
-0.0748883411,
-0.0149743566,
0.0352892019,
-0.0421750098,
-0.044358369,
-0.0092509845,
0.0158682577,
-0.0034025731,
-0.0027147899,
-0.009453251,
0.0311651193,
-0.0298482962,
0.0214936025,
-0.0331596024,
-0.0148701612,
0.0232826564,
-0.0098270811,
-0.0067708134,
0.0005351282,
0.0309104547,
-0.0471902341,
-0.0030550002,
0.0046576126,
-0.0028565391,
0.0247591734,
0.0072841011,
0.0123449033,
-0.025980616,
-0.0605064556,
0.0647460744,
0.0118832598,
-0.0084746685,
-0.0741468742,
0.0157306753,
-0.055729337,
0.0380844139,
0.0719360411,
0.0082963388,
0.0170247983,
-0.0004983259,
-0.0881223828,
-0.0200969763,
-0.0352902301,
0.0382639803,
0.0586023293,
-0.0617091954,
-0.0710891485,
-0.0291779488,
-0.039202217,
0.002768307,
-0.0465291664,
-0.017538894,
0.0358691663,
0.0115602864,
0.0313005932,
-0.0164389703,
0.0141567839,
0.0059392964,
-0.0010841847,
0.0122749191,
0.0107488856,
-0.0012001898,
-0.0367374793,
0.0223450102,
-0.0469128937,
-0.0113556199,
-0.0058574141,
0.013269417,
0.0459810905,
0.0250008665,
0.0471945293,
-0.0567712039,
-0.0471896902,
-0.0165128354,
-0.0201146509,
0.0179425161,
-0.0127476901,
0.0236316379,
0.0296490826,
0.0482444689,
-0.0103641516,
0.0321610868,
-0.0020871731,
-0.0007131212,
-0.0409237035,
-0.008169841,
-0.0318712555,
-0.0269342326,
-0.0751675293,
-0.0317339562,
-0.0192042086,
0.0186091643,
0.0355495885,
-0.0586125962,
-0.0021379294,
0.0071123592,
2.581e-7,
0.0682581961,
0.0789587349,
-0.0235721786,
-0.0274385959,
0.0303568728,
0.0276830755,
-0.0033007399,
-0.0109279668,
0.0435466655,
-0.0474168882,
0.0184969939,
0.0215007588,
0.0176362563,
0.0566173233,
-0.065714404,
-0.0400956273,
-0.0685280189,
-0.0367882289,
-0.0281080697,
-0.0270115603,
0.0660222769,
0.0508825071,
-0.006360536,
-0.0305871852,
0.0473267473,
-0.0480302535,
0.0350716822,
-0.0195528921,
0.0489014387,
0.0229012929,
0.0451789945,
0.0040642982,
0.0317566842,
0.1089002267,
0.0042656753,
-0.0076390845,
-0.0277784877,
0.0556389615,
-0.0371421576,
0.0427389741,
-0.0100500677,
-0.0126128122,
0.0412588567,
-0.0668429434,
0.0716608167,
-0.0513243414,
-0.0388067812,
-0.0069411751,
0.0300471913,
-0.0624179691,
0.0256816782,
0.0064467182,
-0.0106751947,
0.0448396578,
-0.0006672057,
0.0184235424,
0.0131460065,
-0.1062064171,
-0.0244787075,
0.0516426489,
-0.0128962304,
-0.0492554046,
0.032398019,
-0.0129134627,
0.0321695805,
-0.0915076956,
0.0185285453,
2.288435872e-34,
0.024310289,
0.024567157,
0.0073211142,
0.0212754365,
0.0404665917,
0.0175788924,
-0.0068223425,
0.0031485804,
0.0498858355,
-0.104189828,
-0.0053686225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11771v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11771v2 | An Integrated NPL Approach to Sentiment Analysis in Satisfaction Surveys | 2023-07-18T00:23:35 | 2023-08-02T00:33:22 | Edson B. Pinto-Luque | cs.CL | cs.CL | The research project aims to apply an integrated approach to natural language
processing NLP to satisfaction surveys. It will focus on understanding and
extracting relevant information from survey responses, analyzing feelings, and
identifying recurring word patterns. NLP techniques will be used to determine
emotional polarity, classify responses into positive, negative, or neutral
categories, and use opinion mining to highlight participants opinions. This
approach will help identify the most relevant aspects for participants and
understand their opinions in relation to those specific aspects. A key
component of the research project will be the analysis of word patterns in
satisfaction survey responses using NPL. This analysis will provide a deeper
understanding of feelings, opinions, and themes and trends present in
respondents responses. The results obtained from this approach can be used to
identify areas for improvement, understand respondents preferences, and make
strategic decisions based on analysis to improve respondent satisfaction. | [
0.0541325472,
0.0793019906,
-0.0158046558,
0.0262731817,
-0.0773351118,
0.0202279277,
-0.0417940579,
-0.0084951865,
0.0084201703,
-0.0486257449,
0.0351097882,
0.0195483025,
-0.0087739602,
0.0007057699,
-0.0351672657,
-0.0274018385,
0.0013082878,
0.0870188028,
0.0437265113,
0.0426254682,
0.0125745768,
0.0400099605,
0.0035744444,
0.0097936103,
-0.0319661424,
0.0040105935,
-0.0102853375,
-0.0104199564,
0.009979344,
-0.0324724317,
0.0307470318,
0.0236433912,
-0.0399426892,
-0.0293441191,
0.0000020095,
-0.0542894304,
-0.0269291475,
0.0063165696,
0.0544842631,
0.0062383437,
0.1242411882,
0.0091127288,
-0.0020624353,
0.0195879098,
-0.0024603985,
-0.0012999844,
0.0309201851,
0.0855122656,
0.0844347402,
0.0070330831,
-0.0154660046,
-0.044238165,
-0.0777601749,
0.0532959998,
-0.0137191759,
0.0216363259,
0.0237034187,
-0.0487401523,
0.0123322066,
-0.0698586553,
0.0094030052,
-0.0188201256,
-0.0381262824,
-0.0362032466,
0.0015933939,
0.0115704508,
-0.0101661803,
-0.0308535583,
0.0162133165,
-0.0253476277,
0.0154590532,
0.0339854583,
-0.0251305215,
-0.0306261927,
-0.0029983327,
-0.0153734572,
-0.0146971382,
-0.0074620359,
-0.0219406076,
-0.0060153753,
-0.0256094597,
0.0378838144,
-0.0250880104,
-0.0188567806,
-0.0175928697,
0.0456872843,
-0.0067383936,
-0.0391210653,
0.0197801441,
0.0013648091,
0.034005478,
0.020539429,
0.0167389661,
-0.0336181633,
0.0015630226,
0.0352886654,
0.0616602041,
0.0122928079,
0.0358256996,
-0.0752920881,
0.0036148448,
-0.0166776627,
0.0105804438,
-0.0115510933,
0.037088871,
-0.0038909421,
0.0583199114,
-0.0417606607,
-0.0477768928,
0.0295909308,
-0.0718553215,
-0.0095262509,
-0.008791591,
0.0656650662,
-0.0232776683,
0.0148307281,
-0.0496710204,
0.0026856798,
-0.0126077244,
-0.0117868036,
0.0107606174,
0.0363547802,
0.0625941679,
0.0324813128,
-0.0552384332,
0.0877783746,
-0.0382443666,
0.0128957415,
-0.0701482072,
-0.0148095805,
0.0736945495,
0.0015326955,
0.0022616088,
-0.0015815978,
0.0018315549,
0.0456381701,
0.0141329663,
-0.0293763392,
-0.0988653675,
-0.0143766198,
-0.0031253924,
-0.0136431241,
-0.0576785058,
-0.0413459241,
0.0056878412,
-0.0045008189,
-0.0108470358,
0.0335339829,
0.0000236405,
0.0592073612,
-0.0285006538,
0.0339234732,
-0.0239107814,
-0.0076036188,
-0.033438392,
-0.027088467,
0.1317464858,
-0.0359679163,
-0.0073085544,
0.0084063504,
0.0308023151,
-0.0232809335,
-0.0042970786,
-0.0519225597,
-0.0551995523,
-0.0618292987,
-0.0216346532,
0.0026762511,
-0.071346201,
-0.0360276215,
-0.0529844016,
0.067974247,
0.0172355808,
0.0063698278,
0.032366205,
0.0158890057,
-0.0110713132,
0.0059439894,
-0.0505449437,
0.0462613739,
0.0026707321,
-0.0187911354,
-0.0070253541,
0.0065163439,
0.0207910985,
0.0312241446,
-0.0020945028,
0.0237167794,
0.0140393805,
-0.1007806659,
-0.0232656784,
-0.0072438084,
0.0604992919,
0.0086848876,
0.0214348249,
-0.0098272823,
-0.0696826726,
-0.0604585297,
0.0271759927,
-0.0414829217,
0.0097735906,
-0.0069768857,
0.0382006131,
0.0903956667,
-0.0144671071,
0.0093313046,
-0.0400810018,
-0.0504124537,
-0.0883196965,
0.0334520675,
-0.0195987951,
0.0057089739,
-0.0251661111,
0.0019340427,
-0.0079995701,
0.0243526604,
-0.0055185584,
0.0191953983,
-0.0534389168,
0.0195420906,
-0.0096469298,
-0.0133383805,
-0.0096165612,
0.0129282968,
0.0683516264,
-0.0284172874,
0.0546117015,
0.0238033868,
0.0443638526,
0.0846584663,
-0.0193952564,
0.0428194329,
0.0196728576,
0.0113722915,
-0.0783123672,
0.0074598338,
0.0420860089,
0.0141206598,
-0.0071492372,
-0.0525014773,
0.0155374324,
0.0368546136,
-0.0014020213,
-0.005780472,
0.0155224521,
-0.0038152274,
0.0040414408,
-0.0169283841,
0.0152297784,
-0.0137321651,
-0.0063814041,
-0.0813312978,
0.0075740796,
-0.0035643156,
0.0008339393,
-0.0178872235,
-0.0513708964,
0.0324610919,
0.028261574,
-0.0624032058,
0.0456658415,
0.0126237255,
0.0023551008,
0.0746766999,
0.0402718224,
-0.0279322565,
-0.0331555679,
-0.0484537892,
-0.0188340843,
0.0334271006,
0.0273700282,
-0.0077104918,
0.0070334743,
-0.0278114788,
0.0184160098,
0.0092999069,
-0.0409752093,
0.0123258047,
-0.0113062998,
0.0407419652,
0.010704156,
-0.0030179247,
-0.0184219386,
-0.0164280999,
-0.0168086477,
-0.0335117467,
0.0686801597,
-0.0709064454,
-0.0385930315,
0.0120751038,
-0.0475146547,
-0.0151589131,
0.0193596538,
-0.0409342311,
0.0000941306,
-0.0246573389,
-0.0223715976,
0.0022944992,
0.0492331535,
0.0109791141,
0.0038924015,
-0.0370756909,
-0.0216143839,
0.014224167,
-0.0665909126,
0.0171848834,
0.0015504811,
-0.0297300033,
0.0876855254,
0.023628965,
0.0502868406,
-0.0290219747,
0.0116758002,
0.0020767997,
-0.021673983,
0.0126758488,
-0.0190755185,
0.0094181038,
0.008457236,
0.015876757,
0.0723515078,
-0.0466885492,
0.0123609565,
0.0337952599,
0.0136198988,
-0.133687079,
-0.012486266,
-0.0393648259,
0.0158408023,
-0.0238078237,
0.0200428329,
0.0393154658,
-0.046634879,
0.0379126258,
-0.0564574935,
-0.0262997728,
0.0147673124,
-0.0237225275,
-0.0125182625,
-0.0230995789,
0.0086908601,
-0.0016392688,
-0.0329677984,
-0.0299542565,
-0.0175714791,
0.0006536437,
0.0455413312,
0.0141734499,
0.0129205277,
0.005742196,
-0.0164532885,
-0.0776460841,
0.0164476018,
-0.0296582337,
-0.0022415509,
0.008798589,
0.0424465425,
-0.0134592038,
0.0453351103,
0.0490264818,
-0.0795924291,
0.0236904267,
-0.0014832183,
0.0445916168,
-0.0082614664,
-0.0031742197,
0.0031321212,
-0.0393042006,
-0.00377155,
0.0285295304,
-0.0612819269,
-0.0213014781,
0.0526160449,
0.0882114545,
0.0264117774,
0.0182318687,
-0.0148419151,
0.0288109221,
-0.035168387,
0.0132033136,
0.0502809845,
-0.020161666,
0.0410207994,
-0.0277556591,
0.0213574488,
-0.0268862396,
-0.0044353488,
-0.0202234592,
-0.110429123,
0.0375471488,
-0.0311036222,
-0.0059366212,
-0.0192432255,
-0.0140356878,
-0.0324643366,
-0.0225795414,
0.0162897594,
-0.0421488658,
-0.0077361474,
0.0199364834,
0.0274886321,
-0.049080357,
-0.0297019724,
0.0225307588,
0.0092031015,
0.0000848931,
0.0352160856,
0.074324958,
-0.0453826636,
-0.0217270106,
0.0605137721,
-0.0455357768,
-0.0076303366,
-0.0197044089,
0.002536892,
-0.0048221652,
-0.0182590913,
-0.0435262285,
-0.0023257309,
-0.0463062823,
0.0493577048,
0.0311138667,
0.0302944966,
-0.0068205232,
-0.0113475733,
-0.0401505269,
0.0730108544,
0.021630317,
0.0156914592,
-0.0416479744,
-0.0055890437,
-0.0329804979,
0.0300024897,
-0.0069946176,
0.053286273,
-0.0354012065,
0.0323529504,
-0.0382512398,
0.0061759353,
-0.0252571553,
-0.0699987561,
0.0145356907,
0.0707586631,
0.0145980082,
0.0338429138,
0.0545605905,
-0.0065373243,
-0.0238260645,
-0.0447820202,
0.0514861085,
0.0388215557,
-0.0113599608,
-0.0220073126,
0.0192725286,
0.0339597054,
-0.0074241729,
-0.0958638042,
-0.0082936278,
0.0075239805,
0.0059217145,
0.042791605,
0.0054659294,
-0.0149874287,
0.0164808258,
0.0059291893,
-0.0374994837,
0.0673412979,
-0.0181200076,
-0.0329964943,
-0.0270794407,
0.108974345,
-0.0011730174,
-0.0249430947,
0.040312387,
0.0051974412,
-0.0174069013,
-0.0129797664,
0.0150487171,
-0.0141965682,
0.0281689577,
0.0231430102,
0.0139911966,
0.0112281628,
-0.0092544267,
-0.0110563068,
-0.0328366235,
-0.0259652622,
-0.0508038104,
-0.0385331325,
-0.0317921527,
-0.0621381328,
0.0455052741,
-0.0566250533,
-0.0142600955,
-0.0389443412,
0.0204790588,
0.0185276195,
0.0538518578,
0.0476413146,
-0.0105738305,
-0.0479808971,
-0.0047090105,
0.0202784706,
-0.0475175716,
0.0101578021,
0.041299019,
0.0171760637,
0.0214610659,
-0.00276455,
0.0087491181,
-0.0560438558,
0.0230205506,
0.0188033096,
0.0027304196,
-0.0249142256,
-0.0241435189,
-0.0655130222,
-0.054105822,
0.0045802589,
-0.031692747,
0.0320913158,
-0.0101454286,
0.0028844767,
-0.003342235,
0.0069393273,
0.0478211977,
-0.0032999711,
-0.0333190523,
-0.0815897137,
-0.0084995758,
-0.0545135774,
-0.0377940424,
-0.0139027294,
-0.0332757346,
-0.0672373176,
0.0103177531,
0.0487302728,
0.0555036813,
0.0134189306,
0.0149755394,
-0.0747823417,
0.012282881,
0.0056470716,
-0.0122762928,
0.0659085065,
0.0040188096,
0.0225292444,
0.0205034669,
0.0378211364,
0.0291817654,
-0.0308808479,
-0.0292249806,
-0.0441148095,
0.0011248199,
0.0010605761,
-6.022838896e-33,
-0.0166198071,
-0.0499980785,
0.0005659231,
0.041714862,
-0.0295365937,
-0.0107652517,
0.0491593368,
0.0107968468,
0.0129729966,
0.0066807438,
-0.0084623853,
-0.0220056418,
0.0232687201,
0.016439354,
0.0629209131,
-0.0117595298,
0.0451882966,
-0.0016915302,
0.0018772493,
-0.0339433923,
0.026294088,
0.0294955745,
0.0841531977,
-0.1297888458,
0.0446106754,
0.0259414241,
-0.0162413158,
-0.0013106816,
0.074650988,
0.0109981578,
-0.011394199,
0.0254597254,
0.0280189086,
-0.0455971248,
-0.0064723827,
0.0263551921,
-0.0213814825,
-0.0312613808,
0.0107092299,
0.0350731052,
0.0111647658,
0.0222908985,
0.0287950188,
0.0085014738,
-0.0185605679,
0.0498845093,
0.0670763999,
-0.0087238634,
0.019196339,
-0.0171125345,
-0.0577808656,
0.0109923957,
-0.0270214733,
0.0432805084,
-0.0146765485,
0.0124712419,
-0.0342248306,
0.0032757213,
-0.0148361381,
0.0032091532,
0.0396429189,
0.0011275948,
0.0130224032,
-0.0429108478,
0.0126820989,
0.0331337154,
0.0697438568,
-0.0225486904,
0.0229304563,
0.0496548824,
0.0311378036,
-0.0089292824,
-0.0087299664,
0.039691329,
0.0005663148,
0.0012064556,
0.0356603377,
0.0282016285,
0.0954385847,
0.0159199033,
0.030878678,
0.0057855747,
-0.0093770241,
-0.0627750307,
0.0193291493,
-0.0363501348,
-0.0284860432,
-0.0183040332,
0.041956678,
-0.0076858578,
-0.0140539128,
-0.0218548253,
-0.0026842158,
-0.0047249342,
-0.054370448,
0.0225682091,
-0.011942476,
0.0178775676,
-0.0331044495,
-0.0303467661,
-0.0284509659,
0.03759747,
-0.0564239733,
0.024001319,
-0.0142170098,
-0.0044598863,
-0.0385651849,
-0.0045593274,
-0.0730364695,
-0.0094628027,
0.0207591914,
-0.0102956239,
0.0070348326,
-0.0043009897,
-0.0082610855,
-0.0082873246,
-0.0142466081,
0.0503151491,
-0.0161472633,
0.0143966815,
0.0032245873,
0.0196632147,
0.0089953011,
-0.0210209843,
0.0088753421,
-0.0227167495,
0.0305192061,
0.0021671446,
-0.0170409549,
0.024878107,
0.0081961006,
-0.0441251881,
2.662e-7,
0.0184632558,
0.0696048662,
0.0259390362,
0.0029608861,
0.0038718332,
0.024217587,
0.0121206138,
-0.014625404,
0.0203904137,
0.0447204113,
0.0387194157,
-0.0799588189,
-0.0406261981,
0.0410106778,
-0.0753382072,
0.017609043,
0.0346110016,
-0.0462477207,
-0.060994748,
0.0441824347,
0.1099545434,
0.0509402007,
0.0216137972,
-0.0282975584,
-0.027324548,
0.036243543,
-0.0349032916,
-0.0320710614,
-0.0212799106,
0.0000933996,
0.0172244199,
-0.0404597148,
0.0522863418,
-0.0135430982,
-0.0020619365,
-0.0054062982,
0.0193525869,
0.0116268164,
0.024305502,
-0.0151050016,
0.0452335887,
0.0242736433,
-0.0143784164,
0.0019565066,
0.0339430086,
-0.0757174417,
-0.0435234569,
-0.0482169129,
-0.0361017473,
-0.0426324643,
0.0500019565,
0.0092660291,
-0.0570418946,
0.0419177637,
-0.0046477281,
-0.0302076489,
-0.0356393903,
0.0046123504,
0.0445751101,
0.0323067456,
-0.0234669913,
0.0075188666,
0.0179505888,
0.057157971,
0.0197896473,
0.0378272124,
0.0157230701,
1.854213424e-34,
0.0268797502,
-0.0020053883,
0.011026877,
0.0147852367,
0.0156236915,
0.0391699374,
-0.07857427,
0.034734197,
0.0121840145,
-0.0341063365,
0.0088196527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08859v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08859v1 | Curriculum Learning for Graph Neural Networks: A Multiview Competence-based Approach | 2023-07-17T21:33:35 | 2023-07-17T21:33:35 | Nidhi Vakil, Hadi Amiri | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | A curriculum is a planned sequence of learning materials and an effective one
can make learning efficient and effective for both humans and machines. Recent
studies developed effective data-driven curriculum learning approaches for
training graph neural networks in language applications. However, existing
curriculum learning approaches often employ a single criterion of difficulty in
their training paradigms. In this paper, we propose a new perspective on
curriculum learning by introducing a novel approach that builds on graph
complexity formalisms (as difficulty criteria) and model competence during
training. The model consists of a scheduling scheme which derives effective
curricula by accounting for different views of sample difficulty and model
competence during training. The proposed solution advances existing research in
curriculum learning for graph neural networks with the ability to incorporate a
fine-grained spectrum of graph difficulty criteria in their training paradigms.
Experimental results on real-world link prediction and node classification
tasks illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach. | [
0.03701628,
-0.00132392,
-0.0221254751,
0.0252142902,
-0.0440802537,
0.0103196064,
-0.000292881,
-0.0738174543,
0.0670630932,
0.020406181,
0.0133752069,
-0.0048520039,
-0.0030989163,
-0.0027188577,
0.0251716785,
-0.038793467,
0.0197528787,
-0.0125359977,
0.0291298069,
-0.0437946059,
-0.0337809026,
0.0317403302,
0.0010795491,
0.0119747194,
-0.0076198783,
-0.0318735912,
-0.0072906208,
0.0144864824,
-0.0218056552,
-0.0256346446,
0.014689968,
0.0119333453,
0.014050669,
0.0230328105,
0.000002112,
-0.0149901714,
-0.0205576904,
-0.0177693479,
-0.0354760922,
-0.0383691266,
0.0465464108,
0.0331973061,
0.0324436501,
0.0138125001,
-0.0301205907,
0.0212332681,
0.0532980002,
-0.0300831962,
0.008735205,
0.0580539852,
-0.0307215713,
-0.0210760124,
-0.0080300765,
-0.0035532098,
-0.0300951414,
-0.0326677486,
0.0324615948,
0.0458208583,
0.0353860371,
-0.0246797223,
-0.0553506352,
0.0118512185,
0.051899042,
0.0042081545,
0.053291399,
-0.0018437188,
0.0127206445,
0.0174770169,
-0.0035799129,
0.0863395706,
-0.0407745354,
0.0039389925,
-0.005011525,
-0.0397036709,
0.0434490293,
-0.0043707229,
-0.0243688002,
-0.0305232015,
-0.0130518219,
0.0289925952,
-0.0179446209,
-0.0349119119,
0.040769428,
-0.0096999891,
0.0147146415,
0.0527545549,
-0.0167176016,
-0.0001940422,
0.0651572049,
0.0054217889,
-0.0029806918,
0.021187868,
0.0207655914,
0.046280399,
-0.0515386909,
-0.0054581915,
-0.0200557448,
0.0159121938,
-0.0112753268,
-0.0055679097,
0.0373521037,
-0.0228291359,
0.0090256054,
0.0312520452,
0.0019349649,
0.0709296763,
0.0027328967,
0.0588535145,
-0.0472675823,
-0.0035433199,
-0.0572596304,
0.016209783,
-0.0605310723,
0.0016162851,
0.0266327802,
-0.0223781224,
-0.0420501195,
0.036440976,
-0.0669473559,
0.0401719138,
0.0688978806,
0.0143349087,
-0.0111533804,
-0.0032454394,
-0.0121330665,
0.0124437995,
0.0117799593,
0.0170245133,
-0.0361077748,
0.0300458949,
0.0195668451,
-0.0116894813,
0.0494796596,
-0.0079637999,
0.0335602537,
0.0625730678,
-0.0016585704,
-0.0018188506,
-0.0408773683,
-0.0198875386,
-0.0311927889,
-0.0404929668,
0.0540144779,
-0.0855707973,
0.0092657395,
-0.0051772585,
-0.0113802729,
-0.0182245467,
-0.017544996,
-0.0144825531,
-0.0342866518,
0.0457565263,
-0.0070802588,
0.0014860961,
0.0178355705,
-0.0317248143,
-0.0020165413,
0.0159839243,
0.0103791552,
0.0265400633,
0.0214808937,
-0.0092127947,
-0.0238648448,
0.0293571409,
0.0240096226,
-0.0365282558,
0.0084936982,
-0.0152231008,
0.002403409,
0.0165245179,
-0.0125821773,
0.0496260077,
-0.0332640223,
-0.0352970064,
0.0142256981,
0.0044047534,
0.028397182,
-0.0221074782,
0.0792519674,
0.0403230265,
0.0039421939,
0.044963453,
-0.0593110807,
0.0061444282,
0.0299765971,
0.0090075443,
-0.0390335917,
-0.042391073,
-0.0159002915,
-0.0701102763,
0.0240419507,
-0.019111678,
0.0849466547,
0.0031015654,
0.0597299635,
0.0088868113,
-0.037800163,
-0.0473297015,
0.0428461134,
0.0265270807,
0.0157407448,
0.0060369824,
-0.0635826439,
0.0721527264,
0.0344660245,
-0.035007719,
-0.0789198279,
0.0280581973,
0.0284737274,
-0.0337286666,
0.0416315235,
-0.0703428164,
0.018696852,
-0.0457199141,
-0.0281261876,
-0.0163219143,
-0.0067739221,
0.0252887979,
0.0145756993,
-0.0419777706,
0.0071669556,
-0.0562848449,
-0.0833861381,
0.0144461151,
-0.0134597151,
-0.0253949426,
0.0195394047,
0.0427498296,
0.0190080032,
0.0236358084,
0.032374654,
-0.0090095196,
0.0009407256,
-0.0085122623,
0.0100112138,
-0.0171977859,
-0.0669839233,
-0.0403258242,
0.0597484,
-0.0467136204,
-0.0317244604,
0.0371464863,
-0.0331456028,
-0.044284761,
0.0533828251,
-0.0339359492,
0.0020796917,
0.0122176446,
0.0014944931,
-0.0283918064,
-0.012963864,
-0.0108987894,
0.0365244448,
0.0055617434,
0.0467893928,
0.0462795049,
0.0016356908,
-0.0100861518,
-0.0605978258,
-0.0277866311,
0.0090386579,
0.0089458441,
0.0170698687,
0.0065827579,
0.0126192616,
-0.0688705444,
-0.0043792888,
-0.0868485346,
-0.0144699849,
-0.001107795,
0.0080298046,
-0.0158066899,
-0.0442258604,
0.0234484393,
-0.053371191,
-0.0639522672,
0.0853327662,
-0.0237705782,
0.0104247546,
0.0298006907,
0.0317704901,
-0.0545102879,
-0.0184705704,
-0.068649292,
-0.0341749601,
0.0687002838,
0.0366645418,
0.0207860451,
0.0058526541,
0.0182822291,
-0.0101625873,
0.0063079437,
-0.0158611741,
-0.0068675415,
0.0099366447,
-0.0023115561,
0.0233766306,
0.0274902899,
-0.0432086438,
0.0175631326,
0.0524589382,
-0.0078077605,
-0.0110121947,
0.0158525836,
-0.073437877,
-0.0235830471,
-0.0676565915,
-0.000511367,
-0.0470687337,
0.0080781151,
-0.0105137918,
-0.0196072292,
-0.0558208413,
-0.0008131283,
-0.0134539036,
0.0173362214,
-0.0149397999,
-0.0170108024,
0.0170484465,
-0.0540788658,
-0.039166227,
-0.0124224816,
0.0657911226,
0.0277324822,
0.0174443237,
0.012829667,
-0.0426078252,
-0.0224966593,
0.0373438336,
0.0921933129,
0.0199513193,
0.0083698425,
-0.0502318889,
-0.0974222869,
-0.0021814147,
0.0738711655,
-0.0256565381,
-0.0159515496,
-0.0313062817,
-0.0228247866,
0.0111665763,
-0.0015406209,
-0.0248711426,
0.0777743161,
0.0111558065,
0.0647569001,
0.0351775177,
-0.023516722,
0.0464154109,
-0.0632422715,
-0.0663465858,
0.0189053826,
0.007069007,
0.0014493524,
-0.0060582105,
0.0194951333,
0.0000609066,
0.0206106026,
-0.0030502887,
-0.0381725244,
0.0035638351,
-0.0012285585,
0.0399829075,
-0.0397457518,
-0.0376532227,
0.0583643578,
-0.009597417,
-0.0095253652,
-0.0158753451,
0.0290291812,
-0.0186012834,
-0.0340924338,
0.0092149358,
0.0629458204,
-0.0043881149,
-0.0861888379,
0.0005955332,
0.0222033393,
-0.0113671403,
0.0632646456,
0.0285815094,
-0.0509974286,
0.03343549,
-0.0206232853,
0.0644374117,
-0.0054825777,
-0.0452153496,
-0.0395905152,
-0.0439572036,
-0.0030268559,
0.0365779176,
0.0055902405,
-0.0088034291,
-0.0646841228,
-0.0310750287,
-0.0317262411,
0.0120138181,
-0.0361142978,
-0.0135671804,
-0.0173776578,
0.0471650213,
-0.023981696,
-0.0508230627,
0.0276288465,
0.0068744705,
0.0489629358,
-0.066219613,
0.0317833312,
0.0061242515,
0.0124902166,
0.053588558,
0.0213402528,
-0.0320719294,
-0.0026879797,
0.0322955362,
0.0229310114,
-0.0132131213,
-0.0156181175,
0.0336784907,
0.0008998322,
-0.0088332407,
-0.0230521932,
0.1180295646,
0.0211442243,
-0.0414219461,
0.0171841253,
-0.0445554592,
0.0241060369,
0.0044900193,
0.0333710611,
-0.0446530767,
-0.0195848253,
-0.0200862568,
0.0191742592,
-0.0828507692,
-0.0226726551,
0.0384876803,
-0.032232739,
0.0200812183,
-0.0297202505,
-0.0078278482,
0.0296487864,
0.0632937774,
-0.0112352157,
-0.025463609,
0.0938933566,
0.0186831933,
-0.1061689928,
-0.024318913,
0.0010764981,
0.0232014898,
-0.0523819216,
-0.0174681116,
-0.0275690574,
-0.0292102434,
-0.0316352099,
-0.0280906279,
-0.0721633881,
-0.0588584095,
-0.017079087,
0.0106023382,
0.0117078219,
0.0804340914,
0.0055104131,
-0.0217539556,
0.0509463064,
0.0384222195,
0.0170326475,
-0.0223331098,
0.076384306,
-0.0279407129,
-0.0263983719,
0.0419523902,
-0.0620677285,
0.029323902,
0.0305595417,
0.0088616461,
0.0067528989,
0.0188394859,
0.0088651553,
0.0676656738,
0.0265186578,
0.0422066264,
-0.0083169555,
-0.0777420253,
-0.0176837929,
0.0113251153,
-0.0323040895,
-0.0190822519,
-0.0407297686,
0.0028627338,
0.0407083593,
-0.0098247351,
-0.0963459536,
0.0665590465,
-0.0060340902,
-0.0467879698,
-0.0172292292,
-0.0096095586,
0.0097363731,
0.0463966504,
0.0049074921,
-0.0399000272,
0.0255535878,
0.0255361106,
-0.0039165285,
-0.0245609973,
-0.0059493226,
0.0188077111,
0.0227465052,
-0.061740689,
-0.0218001213,
-0.0264612343,
0.0224439334,
-0.0437599048,
-0.0272544902,
0.0422878303,
-0.0141275832,
-0.0112224109,
-0.0493853688,
0.0196231157,
-0.0131052276,
0.0374282598,
-0.0002384904,
-0.0790387094,
0.0332117788,
0.0236517079,
0.0342993028,
0.0309012271,
0.0613261722,
0.0738535449,
0.0308236964,
-0.0088356286,
-0.0421207771,
-0.0456944667,
-0.0686448738,
-0.0237271208,
0.0560848601,
-0.002504708,
0.0328869,
-0.0202122889,
-0.087010473,
0.0355692841,
0.0232116133,
0.0290041845,
0.0072146342,
0.0290602334,
0.0408899598,
0.0045515629,
-0.0047957296,
-0.0221840963,
0.0256378558,
0.0329688452,
-0.0074609397,
0.0152439438,
-5.914294482e-33,
0.0085925227,
-0.0761302486,
0.0364447236,
0.0635801554,
-0.0195743237,
0.0525313802,
-0.0348114707,
0.01178593,
-0.0456979126,
0.0456272475,
-0.0041936962,
0.0056275288,
-0.0002932017,
0.0343417786,
-0.0074163633,
0.0060938271,
0.0468102433,
-0.0079135625,
0.029880872,
0.0294997673,
0.0372477695,
0.0028654682,
0.0304562245,
-0.0564564615,
0.0102557931,
-0.0105787981,
0.0360116139,
0.0230379291,
0.0529138483,
0.0320508517,
0.0154515021,
0.0728641748,
0.0388455987,
-0.0125656733,
-0.0113986777,
-0.0271151066,
-0.1075064093,
-0.0826551914,
-0.021922268,
0.0284711663,
-0.0311512984,
-0.0508095026,
0.0593777895,
0.0079138726,
-0.0081806565,
-0.0577970706,
0.0454255641,
-0.0007574029,
-0.0391739868,
0.0065962854,
-0.043904461,
0.005852011,
-0.0186811816,
0.0097197425,
0.0385861583,
-0.001032252,
-0.0032469141,
-0.0485594794,
-0.0469701514,
0.0480165221,
-0.0721414909,
-0.0087769553,
0.0154857365,
0.0368658416,
0.0184390955,
0.0317047983,
-0.0147104142,
0.0317354836,
0.0072903158,
0.0173143502,
0.0405195802,
0.0714668185,
-0.0047027799,
0.0050019454,
-0.00911659,
-0.0356894284,
-0.095488444,
-0.0351649113,
0.0282664299,
0.0200206023,
-0.0046081762,
-0.0207075495,
-0.0340899192,
-0.0695750862,
-0.0130104115,
-0.0121848676,
-0.0027746193,
0.0167619549,
-0.0207922738,
-0.0012394445,
-0.0411048718,
0.0316584557,
-0.0250514522,
-0.0692057014,
-0.0015403237,
0.1218107119,
-0.01628525,
0.0492772833,
0.0046200678,
0.0346393101,
-0.0667993203,
-0.0523200594,
-0.0095720459,
-0.0164707992,
0.0444449931,
0.0404705219,
0.060015589,
0.0477628298,
-0.01623624,
-0.0431761034,
-0.0534381643,
-0.0011931377,
0.0070281411,
0.0026155214,
0.0410515554,
0.0111971293,
-0.0261998642,
0.0321962573,
0.0292607732,
-0.004080758,
-0.0038101289,
0.0371232331,
0.0077044279,
0.0323762484,
-0.0393406749,
-0.0377888754,
-0.0114034209,
0.0297674518,
0.0090573365,
-0.0534548871,
-0.0194767751,
-0.0174113233,
2.707e-7,
0.0078984266,
0.0478760526,
0.017863078,
0.0366591737,
0.023788657,
-0.0216122139,
0.0014905062,
0.0221444722,
-0.025473386,
0.0196515545,
0.079241626,
0.0279827379,
-0.0046779383,
0.0297931731,
-0.0379046202,
0.0203507505,
-0.026970394,
-0.0105991429,
-0.0120584536,
0.030957792,
0.041662991,
0.0039412868,
0.050873559,
0.0206676386,
-0.0218678806,
-0.0483787879,
-0.002316118,
-0.0040568528,
0.058796145,
-0.0000052777,
-0.0030000848,
0.0360380672,
-0.0083902897,
0.0558352396,
-0.0161126219,
0.0398830548,
0.0237423349,
0.0291899778,
-0.010882047,
0.0199234579,
0.0180150643,
-0.0339858979,
-0.0108364169,
-0.0100183021,
0.0491774306,
-0.0747439489,
-0.016575478,
0.0141703915,
-0.0114442576,
-0.0208803862,
0.014330552,
0.0125322361,
0.0011708897,
-0.0273160953,
0.0259856954,
-0.0291427672,
0.0368706509,
-0.0618807897,
0.0477405153,
0.0291002393,
-0.0055853329,
-0.0420945697,
-0.0111041339,
0.0041893143,
0.0499142744,
-0.0062554469,
0.0553161167,
2.183784273e-34,
0.038545873,
-0.0018359299,
0.025513744,
-0.0631076917,
-0.0117292674,
-0.0365199521,
-0.0096987244,
0.0107744168,
0.0595750511,
-0.0849523991,
-0.0385462008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08813v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08813v2 | Comparative Performance Evaluation of Large Language Models for Extracting Molecular Interactions and Pathway Knowledge | 2023-07-17T20:01:11 | 2023-10-18T13:52:33 | Gilchan Park, Byung-Jun Yoon, Xihaier Luo, Vanessa López-Marrero, Shinjae Yoo, Shantenu Jha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Understanding protein interactions and pathway knowledge is crucial for
unraveling the complexities of living systems and investigating the underlying
mechanisms of biological functions and complex diseases. While existing
databases provide curated biological data from literature and other sources,
they are often incomplete and their maintenance is labor-intensive,
necessitating alternative approaches. In this study, we propose to harness the
capabilities of large language models to address these issues by automatically
extracting such knowledge from the relevant scientific literature. Toward this
goal, in this work, we investigate the effectiveness of different large
language models in tasks that involve recognizing protein interactions,
identifying genes associated with pathways affected by low-dose radiation, and
gene regulatory relations. We thoroughly evaluate the performance of various
models, highlight the significant findings, and discuss both the future
opportunities and the remaining challenges associated with this approach. The
code and data are available at: https://github.com/boxorange/BioIE-LLM | [
0.0127662634,
0.0873884112,
0.0206831452,
0.0388111658,
-0.0066911136,
0.0181127004,
0.0368412174,
0.0433803946,
0.0509007536,
-0.0229304861,
-0.0261749253,
-0.0088749044,
-0.0095912023,
0.0505967587,
-0.0113607235,
0.0005642328,
0.0093854824,
-0.0344640687,
0.0259852037,
-0.0185431149,
-0.0064117094,
0.0287432689,
0.0198931694,
-0.0038904832,
0.0337997712,
-0.0145970043,
0.0299631022,
-0.0199943576,
0.0425687693,
-0.0320017338,
-0.0482146367,
0.0082429582,
-0.0033510663,
0.0452858694,
0.0000017142,
-0.0697384775,
-0.0401514247,
0.0393910334,
-0.0020936506,
0.0194590017,
0.0387816243,
-0.0465927012,
-0.0052573723,
-0.0051344358,
0.0169919096,
-0.0285662487,
0.0730226636,
0.0298651531,
0.0191430859,
0.0343400128,
-0.0071151298,
-0.04309972,
0.0644639507,
-0.001285854,
0.0368558466,
-0.009779674,
0.1090094522,
0.0218291283,
0.0448045246,
-0.0104502253,
0.0226328913,
0.0527583584,
-0.0355655029,
-0.0445000418,
-0.0070866104,
0.0432259068,
0.0151570896,
-0.0094345277,
0.0210052524,
0.0655795634,
0.0043864781,
-0.0359772034,
0.0138542121,
0.0174391139,
-0.0145726167,
0.0466853902,
-0.0373545401,
0.0193748493,
-0.0181709547,
0.0100779533,
0.0178696588,
-0.038655974,
0.0454961434,
-0.0051359325,
-0.0105015012,
0.0801053271,
0.0051040598,
-0.0352044329,
-0.0205974393,
-0.0262263305,
-0.0184933972,
-0.052166909,
0.0163355358,
0.0131175919,
0.0037697379,
0.0182533134,
0.0055376883,
-0.0157537907,
0.0662150383,
-0.0326584876,
-0.0125517547,
-0.0025318856,
-0.0004620691,
0.061624106,
-0.0143558932,
-0.0233121086,
-0.0549650528,
-0.0078826724,
-0.0085498858,
0.0185267571,
-0.0604377612,
-0.0025227326,
-0.0046865903,
0.0335339792,
-0.003672614,
0.0146857304,
-0.0388626866,
0.0116213737,
0.005138773,
0.0325513817,
0.0330076441,
-0.0180791058,
-0.0446026474,
0.0476655737,
-0.0035743394,
0.0341374278,
-0.0065652002,
-0.0163364932,
-0.0433241725,
-0.0617249124,
-0.006999766,
-0.0092503158,
0.0304299034,
-0.0473544151,
-0.0116047282,
0.1025630236,
0.0301699918,
0.0046168398,
0.0455449671,
-0.0124511076,
-0.0374554694,
-0.0641937256,
-0.0096975444,
-0.074953042,
0.0429129414,
0.0349215753,
0.0181789529,
-0.0220700223,
0.0289471243,
-0.0226667728,
-0.0710869655,
0.044643119,
-0.0475646034,
-0.0171516296,
0.0244427957,
0.0052071023,
0.0172463022,
-0.0070994124,
0.0031689829,
-0.0551439747,
0.0068971762,
-0.0026100392,
-0.0263609029,
0.0041763983,
0.0004634725,
-0.0244388506,
-0.0003222236,
0.0174859539,
0.0264016092,
0.0437440127,
-0.0108222328,
0.0330994278,
-0.0134937046,
-0.0185581055,
0.0127228657,
0.056976635,
0.0255672783,
0.052275788,
0.0097398562,
0.0314916484,
0.0303383209,
-0.0261163078,
-0.0060992395,
0.0136129195,
-0.0464298017,
0.0387206525,
0.005929111,
0.04023486,
0.0229556784,
-0.0216971654,
-0.0478151105,
0.0032154249,
-0.0120001314,
-0.0367239006,
0.0685890317,
-0.034864299,
-0.0253753085,
0.0055160108,
0.0946197733,
-0.0333569832,
0.0278272107,
0.0022391004,
0.0010257524,
0.0449172258,
0.0467103086,
-0.0735272691,
0.0086370138,
-0.0096811159,
0.0048489603,
0.0247327127,
-0.0118069528,
-0.0148434257,
0.0026234556,
0.0243622102,
0.0137325209,
-0.0053275796,
0.0220358819,
-0.0139303394,
-0.0250513665,
-0.0186403375,
-0.03605593,
0.0021056789,
-0.0330698341,
0.0077589117,
-0.0317082033,
-0.0233675614,
-0.0363299698,
-0.0276451092,
0.0213002469,
-0.0043314928,
-0.0478360467,
0.0316704698,
0.0573752224,
-0.0588780642,
-0.028514836,
-0.0059031402,
0.0420644805,
-0.040428672,
0.0453509241,
-0.0071709538,
-0.0312823728,
0.0135014802,
-0.0309889279,
-0.0244844295,
0.0097509064,
-0.0070564267,
0.0411395542,
0.0201505329,
-0.0143884243,
-0.0119775943,
-0.0082308026,
-0.0396676958,
0.0650693923,
0.0226878878,
0.0206528641,
0.0140951807,
-0.0695572868,
0.0179500617,
-0.0211609714,
-0.0239811353,
0.028078096,
0.0169796683,
0.0064426647,
0.0245913547,
-0.0203011967,
-0.0159343835,
0.0041589201,
-0.0389430523,
-0.0089887278,
0.027271945,
0.02870702,
0.0215625335,
-0.0142647205,
0.0030136104,
0.0172617473,
-0.019051427,
0.0156143326,
-0.0118177878,
0.0141764982,
0.0353761166,
0.0245197359,
-0.0664575696,
-0.0800065175,
-0.0274710581,
-0.0664592832,
0.0936900452,
0.0358053856,
-0.0538206697,
0.0024859163,
0.0609905757,
-0.0328046642,
0.0261939466,
-0.0038347135,
-0.0490118042,
0.0198156554,
-0.0294644367,
0.0095009021,
0.0029106496,
-0.0270702895,
0.0110590421,
0.0731598362,
-0.0169817526,
-0.0174826868,
-0.0175739471,
-0.0615219846,
-0.0237708185,
-0.0241673496,
-0.0174987912,
-0.0331068151,
0.0274407193,
-0.0066873543,
-0.0093198167,
-0.0067766001,
0.0108757261,
-0.0323188081,
0.0069326297,
-0.0407670848,
-0.0241474025,
-0.0046415767,
0.02715181,
0.0427148715,
-0.0264864862,
0.0796020776,
-0.0387337208,
0.022159541,
-0.0517197214,
0.0085597476,
0.0005533805,
0.040478643,
0.0145413298,
0.0559301153,
0.0273954738,
-0.0039201663,
0.0168285519,
-0.0165061746,
0.0122917676,
-0.0139245968,
0.0310663134,
-0.0398854874,
0.0548617952,
0.016980473,
-0.0318023637,
0.0003625305,
0.0206758417,
-0.0295315851,
0.0387295075,
0.0281234272,
-0.0629097596,
-0.0520105995,
0.01737657,
0.0422830805,
-0.0109450538,
-0.0115374504,
-0.0246577486,
-0.0202590153,
0.0206758436,
0.0528199449,
-0.0827507079,
0.0095400522,
-0.0349877439,
0.0645616949,
0.0611649603,
-0.025491666,
0.0166520625,
-0.013553692,
-0.0097238151,
0.0022515079,
-0.0088574253,
0.0170851517,
0.0006650522,
0.0209588911,
-0.0243720505,
-0.0419390127,
0.1121178791,
0.0191823971,
-0.0490202457,
0.0140676433,
-0.0242870543,
-0.0246094242,
-0.0135117164,
0.0437293276,
-0.072507903,
-0.0074830488,
-0.0151508031,
-0.0171357822,
-0.0005605796,
-0.0403828137,
0.0321257822,
-0.0248627439,
0.0260292999,
0.0294120256,
-0.0544471778,
-0.0338548385,
-0.0925920978,
-0.0276865233,
-0.0596145242,
-0.0176024716,
0.010247617,
-0.0055338833,
-0.0251021087,
-0.0045398884,
0.0015148101,
-0.0717095286,
0.0394559503,
-0.0292498395,
0.0309049282,
0.037730664,
0.0420895517,
-0.0075144591,
0.0226968769,
0.0086604916,
0.019726662,
-0.0027386856,
-0.0264884178,
0.0352141671,
0.0636240095,
-0.0329525657,
-0.0583119579,
0.0395700224,
-0.0649581179,
-0.0184975136,
-0.0361438245,
0.0736410767,
-0.0121340733,
-0.0311506186,
-0.0275725797,
0.0027259456,
-0.0145998774,
0.0676951632,
0.0190502815,
0.0034953456,
-0.0405486636,
-0.0089087738,
0.0070838593,
-0.0059104464,
-0.0584733821,
-0.0035368633,
-0.0278250817,
-0.0434252322,
-0.0403642468,
0.0099802129,
0.0325603411,
-0.013416023,
-0.0006414688,
0.0326120891,
0.0336585492,
-0.0276560839,
-0.0118852528,
0.0670784414,
-0.0012851051,
0.0367552191,
-0.0311866272,
-0.0590381213,
0.0379738733,
0.0260087997,
-0.0321987644,
0.0461188182,
-0.0620231368,
-0.0694890022,
-0.029643856,
0.0384890996,
0.0286406949,
-0.008348926,
0.0036050971,
-0.0220547765,
0.000533259,
0.0452968627,
-0.011693283,
-0.0139956921,
-0.0263510142,
-0.0425452702,
-0.0034237558,
0.0028550848,
-0.0178800598,
0.0131748645,
-0.0033660044,
0.0368572287,
-0.0289529432,
-0.0197693873,
0.0671551898,
0.0534556992,
0.0496628098,
0.0211774949,
-0.07202553,
-0.0418055132,
0.0121502671,
-0.0664723143,
-0.0239493623,
-0.0154114105,
-0.0067932941,
0.0425970256,
0.0074884188,
-0.0028410396,
-0.0246581081,
-0.0132262595,
0.0096830036,
-0.0526214205,
0.049334161,
0.013635179,
-0.0099412557,
0.0880470723,
-0.0376422703,
-0.0177419856,
0.0038662842,
-0.0331745818,
0.0108993482,
-0.0006263701,
-0.0495391451,
0.0070989537,
0.0035152524,
-0.0147156306,
-0.0065033552,
-0.0186825525,
-0.0233101379,
-0.0241191369,
-0.0138503239,
0.0784445778,
-0.0082863932,
0.0548593327,
-0.0345159248,
-0.0186887514,
-0.0585013479,
0.0202737041,
-0.0068808794,
0.0035573593,
0.0652446151,
0.0311880093,
-0.0407619774,
-0.0428597145,
0.0661191046,
0.0576844104,
0.0764459372,
0.008054439,
-0.0601091087,
-0.0248110462,
-0.0216845274,
-0.0310386866,
0.0041873418,
-0.0716301724,
-0.0067349365,
-0.0389875434,
-0.0432732143,
0.0038383573,
0.0330092534,
-0.0141921686,
0.0230014622,
-0.0005024943,
0.0016909628,
0.0514017269,
-0.0378889553,
-0.0227194801,
0.0585227162,
-0.0271805506,
-0.0579423755,
-0.0019868694,
-5.771020455e-33,
-0.0040437416,
-0.0596389137,
0.0102513274,
0.0441079661,
0.0216853283,
0.0355382077,
-0.0802849457,
-0.0211046133,
0.0096072545,
0.0435384735,
0.0177910328,
-0.0075000604,
-0.0088129342,
-0.0300326012,
-0.0080418941,
-0.0125523619,
0.0137744499,
0.0164651182,
0.0272468068,
0.0060526086,
0.0538810566,
0.0646189451,
-0.0057312967,
-0.0601843558,
0.0042179702,
0.012792184,
-0.0100523224,
-0.0111392653,
-0.0432531685,
0.0748136118,
-0.0237418525,
0.026416596,
-0.0303564034,
0.0058043059,
-0.0022423554,
-0.0109730083,
-0.0532103218,
0.0486190356,
0.0099999718,
-0.0208983682,
-0.0143935187,
-0.0063075824,
0.0061813844,
0.0007856145,
-0.0179731473,
-0.0178224836,
0.0326749124,
-0.0555279925,
-0.053257335,
0.0070154173,
-0.0908570737,
0.0319471285,
-0.0011731774,
0.0412796065,
0.0335665047,
-0.030961046,
0.0083342427,
0.0720576718,
-0.0173492264,
-0.0001975188,
0.0656297207,
0.063668862,
0.0782529041,
-0.0397971272,
0.0461463965,
0.072238937,
-0.0159312021,
-0.0057862373,
0.0430770963,
0.009051865,
-0.0010937079,
0.0568774119,
0.024524631,
0.0060205348,
0.0042074043,
0.0221621618,
-0.1667952538,
0.029431019,
-0.0213806406,
0.0649439245,
-0.0185606536,
0.051456891,
0.0235784333,
0.0089259194,
-0.0368311256,
0.0450191274,
-0.0353159904,
-0.0111610508,
-0.0311137158,
-0.0549652018,
-0.0373383351,
0.0362144187,
0.0306232963,
-0.0452689454,
-0.0616063178,
0.060951177,
0.0262035467,
0.0034718348,
-0.0285125151,
0.0166984927,
-0.0541501231,
-0.0433481112,
-0.0064267186,
-0.0524110608,
0.0433875471,
-0.0067175273,
0.012448038,
0.0114982408,
-0.0236904044,
0.0054697054,
-0.0644881502,
-0.0240221713,
0.0093873506,
0.0454512574,
-0.0122791659,
0.0274962895,
0.0255797654,
0.0896503478,
0.0578564778,
0.0045900466,
0.0371798873,
0.0365647823,
0.0106670735,
-0.0329896174,
-0.0492277816,
-0.0458947569,
-0.0207773428,
0.0377941877,
0.0347398929,
-0.0284454133,
-0.0216207802,
0.018693978,
2.63e-7,
0.1031168774,
0.0777849481,
0.0251728185,
0.0379423201,
0.0129820118,
-0.0018390506,
-0.0356241167,
-0.0131995501,
-0.0215751007,
0.0040567173,
0.0191250835,
-0.0217045955,
0.0621457286,
0.0358714089,
-0.0176801253,
-0.0129053053,
-0.0617448166,
-0.0313327648,
-0.0624875315,
-0.0305864103,
0.0276539363,
0.0627924949,
-0.0179409273,
0.0033100327,
0.0180846341,
-0.0361295156,
0.0338927247,
-0.041319672,
0.0115866251,
0.0446997024,
-0.0171091873,
-0.0126832565,
0.0061708707,
0.0199552514,
-0.0324718729,
-0.0276466422,
-0.0115678795,
0.0637315959,
-0.0107992282,
0.044524923,
0.0771036372,
-0.0113977445,
0.0374117121,
-0.0580766946,
0.02313531,
-0.0605077669,
-0.0562062524,
-0.0019474765,
0.0043478147,
-0.0218481086,
0.0266419593,
-0.0272108857,
0.0012138984,
0.0223189052,
-0.0155753689,
0.0046434291,
-0.0244233739,
-0.0110749733,
-0.0129736764,
0.0508087389,
-0.0458152406,
-0.0256548449,
0.0009824809,
-0.0205288026,
-0.0223312303,
-0.0261962805,
0.0096300179,
2.566095903e-34,
0.031694755,
-0.0026726059,
-0.0316053145,
0.0185824577,
0.0856405497,
-0.0289394651,
-0.0422511995,
0.0361067466,
-0.0625710487,
-0.1186688915,
0.0067261988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08767v1 | A mixed policy to improve performance of language models on math problems | 2023-07-17T18:27:49 | 2023-07-17T18:27:49 | Gang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T10, I.2.6 | When to solve math problems, most language models take a sampling strategy to
predict next word according conditional probabilities. In the math reasoning
step, it may generate wrong answer. Considering math problems are
deterministic, we propose a mixed policy exploration approach to solve math
problems with reinforcement learning. In peculiar, we propose a two level token
exploration policy: the abstract level explores next token with probability and
the second level is deterministic. Specifically, the abstract level policy will
decide whether the token is operator or operand with probability sampling,
while the second level is deterministic to select next token with the highest
score in a greedy way. We test our method on GSM8K dataset with GPT-2 model,
and demonstrate more than $2\%$ performance gain. Our implementation is
available at https://github.com/vividitytech/math_lm_rl. | [
0.0276769996,
0.0962935835,
-0.0102523137,
0.0024820298,
-0.0692443475,
-0.006836758,
-0.0118880905,
0.0078365058,
-0.0531598292,
-0.0277551319,
0.0337684415,
-0.0485769138,
-0.0295227543,
0.0508961119,
0.0075145806,
-0.0581142306,
0.046889443,
-0.058826264,
0.0962466896,
-0.0092981504,
-0.0296551865,
-0.0084500909,
-0.0366191417,
0.0348044448,
-0.0303092599,
-0.0268075392,
-0.0071324049,
-0.0619153753,
0.0165484641,
-0.036997769,
-0.0012321146,
0.0279592425,
0.0192667004,
0.0583542101,
0.0000022299,
-0.0604355223,
-0.0300641954,
-0.0033879452,
0.0214866083,
-0.0146914702,
0.0223932676,
0.0209211614,
-0.0039540273,
0.0316381864,
-0.0695369318,
0.0161370095,
0.0346104316,
0.0402750224,
0.039930068,
0.0570408143,
0.0103613054,
-0.0601520352,
0.0043578278,
-0.0178716592,
0.0661648065,
-0.0597751811,
0.0210733451,
0.0131025268,
0.0355752334,
-0.0075741732,
-0.0461581796,
-0.0023788186,
0.0444509722,
0.0124902818,
-0.0246604979,
0.0364982709,
-0.0108313793,
-0.0068268417,
-0.0127683757,
0.0152822891,
-0.0647979081,
0.0095230695,
0.0218032524,
-0.0466690511,
-0.0244165063,
-0.0184596479,
-0.0471888073,
-0.0056777615,
0.0033692447,
0.0559553504,
0.0153958136,
-0.0032128626,
0.0220640879,
0.0184308868,
-0.065629743,
0.1308166683,
-0.0030775152,
-0.0237465035,
-0.0002664031,
0.0084290477,
-0.0396585129,
-0.0183942318,
0.0132757686,
0.0423552431,
-0.0377120823,
0.0283550955,
-0.0078684166,
-0.0317489319,
-0.0173549764,
0.0201861952,
0.0247658119,
0.0756286234,
0.0261731129,
0.0361472629,
-0.0057619787,
0.0077812718,
-0.0017011109,
0.0532930531,
-0.0035399951,
0.0422560908,
-0.0187679585,
-0.0248388462,
-0.0311635379,
0.0664514601,
0.027336536,
-0.0285778921,
-0.0510454252,
0.0060545639,
-0.0187019575,
-0.0025267426,
0.017803628,
-0.0313599817,
-0.0256637204,
-0.0018513389,
-0.0840536654,
-0.023539586,
-0.067105107,
0.0218349826,
0.0074652852,
-0.0108286785,
-0.0236642621,
-0.0168922618,
-0.0116231292,
-0.0252317563,
-0.0007705135,
0.1307837963,
-0.0115128066,
-0.0210545752,
-0.0108934473,
-0.0280516837,
0.0423074551,
-0.066353254,
0.0012272516,
-0.0840938613,
0.0175279751,
0.0053172056,
-0.0325386114,
-0.0229013674,
0.011775149,
0.0170650445,
0.0042955945,
0.0607838929,
0.037629813,
-0.0248412676,
0.0100585064,
-0.00985948,
-0.029334845,
0.0965894833,
0.0308082867,
-0.0116817933,
0.012073759,
0.028667517,
0.0207115244,
0.0419221558,
0.0325321816,
-0.0228620134,
0.0115096495,
-0.0206699409,
0.0019415957,
0.0407178178,
0.0347896665,
0.0386904366,
-0.0504782088,
-0.0032155795,
-0.0262430701,
0.0567142516,
-0.0073500974,
-0.0163970701,
0.0364904329,
-0.0083066719,
0.0107522747,
0.0208670422,
-0.059825521,
0.0210367125,
0.0246102978,
0.0244031642,
0.0248170644,
0.0160690527,
-0.0005926896,
-0.0661721155,
-0.0029429416,
-0.0089774327,
0.0199649613,
0.0019343275,
0.0858600363,
-0.0092201577,
-0.0273310374,
0.0415816084,
0.0192182269,
0.0202556122,
-0.0057690153,
-0.0807999894,
0.0410377644,
0.0063239853,
0.0531793684,
-0.0698235482,
-0.0126690827,
-0.0279233642,
-0.0472554639,
0.0108405007,
0.0243220162,
0.0008695928,
-0.0060330937,
-0.0329111964,
-0.0348219909,
0.002033483,
0.0301170722,
-0.0022554549,
0.0389838591,
0.0362112746,
0.0106671862,
-0.0383672789,
0.0206036046,
0.0360327102,
0.0143867973,
-0.0309271645,
0.0282336976,
-0.0187307782,
0.018266283,
-0.0228384156,
0.0280053783,
0.0346585773,
0.0043426459,
-0.0109688565,
-0.0226468481,
-0.0378428325,
-0.0834325925,
-0.0421909504,
0.0693519115,
-0.0342154466,
-0.0237796996,
-0.005066873,
-0.0591274574,
-0.0261383727,
0.0474769324,
-0.0414318144,
0.0599243008,
-0.024985088,
0.0119101787,
0.0251864456,
-0.0148436558,
-0.0416324511,
0.0738442764,
-0.0195923038,
0.0351708494,
-0.0054829,
0.0034031535,
0.0051617976,
-0.0523575209,
0.0380739868,
-0.0033344366,
-0.0251550395,
0.0235803686,
0.0184796676,
0.0396257788,
-0.0280636549,
-0.0183890294,
0.0188738685,
-0.0235102549,
-0.0220618453,
0.0416159295,
-0.0271297023,
0.013090251,
-0.0169030521,
-0.0398747437,
-0.0290295426,
-0.0101264119,
-0.0020300886,
-0.0183764398,
0.0349536873,
0.0319757164,
-0.0100241778,
-0.0393033884,
-0.0297227334,
-0.0360688157,
-0.0009682445,
-0.0113242539,
0.0697254986,
-0.0180238932,
-0.0126890009,
-0.032356564,
0.0058255768,
-0.0167788714,
0.0353012048,
0.0237245485,
-0.0686896294,
0.0099363849,
0.031464871,
0.0054066894,
0.0484778471,
-0.0058612996,
-0.0094570406,
-0.0743128732,
0.0176209807,
-0.02610204,
-0.0050411965,
-0.0131210303,
0.0055883955,
0.0116679538,
0.0892737657,
-0.0243304968,
-0.022246873,
-0.03235998,
0.0288036987,
-0.0139708836,
-0.0310746171,
-0.0121426918,
0.0536386333,
-0.0432601161,
0.0376804322,
0.0017763935,
-0.0410045423,
0.0937831402,
0.0262549985,
-0.0079398677,
-0.090862833,
0.0053383941,
-0.0467498675,
0.020291727,
0.0213709213,
-0.0065198839,
-0.0689431801,
-0.0471377373,
-0.0337925442,
-0.0061728605,
0.0341229439,
-0.0200899262,
0.0431448668,
-0.0179373305,
0.0326964706,
0.0017367945,
-0.0370105356,
-0.0329349078,
-0.0180367548,
-0.034519203,
0.0227941256,
-0.0109723769,
-0.0309224762,
-0.0132730631,
0.0060219159,
0.0110087898,
0.0395053774,
-0.0373158939,
-0.0245135669,
-0.0228136014,
-0.0193290431,
0.0544975922,
-0.0085869348,
-0.0076983399,
-0.0259695202,
-0.000376095,
-0.0085649034,
0.0659961626,
-0.0048370613,
0.006314544,
0.0374226421,
0.0206540469,
-0.0732489675,
-0.0359634571,
0.0494943038,
0.0035264655,
-0.0708185509,
-0.0173462201,
0.0870361626,
0.0456020944,
-0.0109818662,
0.0069741327,
-0.0600787997,
0.0441760756,
0.0107086655,
0.0521431714,
-0.0994775519,
-0.014023792,
0.0081883362,
0.0109565826,
-0.0116854627,
-0.0282209739,
0.0261560399,
-0.1221396253,
0.0058841626,
-0.0160246156,
-0.0890025124,
-0.0016429746,
-0.0314216651,
0.0004028514,
-0.0199077278,
-0.0025444506,
0.0292814448,
-0.0128027387,
0.0449987799,
0.0188133717,
0.0205279589,
-0.0296801124,
-0.0064130691,
-0.0186558701,
-0.0298470613,
0.0680043995,
-0.0124075068,
-0.0444742255,
-0.0471813343,
0.0225740224,
0.0753533915,
-0.0481128395,
-0.0237183049,
-0.0342314504,
-0.0198797192,
-0.01133689,
0.0007059503,
0.0749200657,
-0.0045358068,
-0.0307444111,
0.0093056737,
0.1280278414,
-0.0342419483,
-0.0195110589,
-0.0380571932,
-0.0149607817,
0.0267274473,
0.035786435,
-0.0128472392,
-0.0253878441,
-0.0774026811,
-0.0697516873,
-0.0180063881,
-0.0589588135,
-0.009468724,
-0.0558540002,
0.0355886482,
0.0083993962,
-0.0099980542,
-0.0401287936,
0.0453395098,
0.0554358587,
-0.0506845005,
0.008824572,
-0.0071872864,
0.0114582879,
-0.0351741984,
-0.0337638743,
-0.0029220402,
0.0575668216,
-0.0452658087,
0.0073505118,
-0.0143148908,
-0.0001764012,
-0.0593935288,
-0.0100898072,
-0.0706348941,
-0.0547785722,
0.0078307781,
0.0573441535,
0.0179949831,
0.0073774047,
-0.0147171561,
0.0064313998,
0.0471746139,
0.0452858768,
-0.0520267934,
-0.0005377251,
0.0235413983,
0.0090186382,
0.0164849386,
0.0056117345,
-0.0100844568,
-0.0196572747,
-0.0098460568,
0.0698849186,
-0.0300190859,
0.0091629131,
0.0048237075,
-0.0073600304,
0.0537032671,
-0.0038645708,
0.026595775,
-0.0112775015,
0.0215473808,
-0.0146714635,
0.0063776281,
-0.0056455838,
0.0257925093,
-0.0064979261,
-0.0050288364,
-0.0018767116,
-0.0159374475,
0.015590908,
0.0417367294,
0.0648936406,
0.047027003,
0.0291136652,
0.0207077973,
0.0332560688,
-0.0365948193,
0.0296861734,
-0.0217095669,
0.0185226463,
0.0568095706,
0.0005749019,
0.0350813493,
0.0337919779,
0.0268886313,
-0.0175687,
-0.0621949621,
-0.0351775885,
-0.0864004344,
-0.0237161275,
0.0332698673,
0.0213444941,
0.0012847303,
-0.0252724104,
-0.0557205863,
-0.0091663757,
0.0155289378,
-0.0040616146,
0.0042990088,
-0.0105768098,
0.0621325336,
0.0247728396,
0.0066932254,
-0.0505429469,
0.0671458021,
0.021808397,
0.0468502715,
-0.0386139043,
0.029398175,
-0.0176475402,
-0.0007838804,
0.0383342989,
0.0604056679,
0.0023034317,
-0.0013401483,
-0.0616575442,
-0.0572274663,
-0.046853777,
0.0208391547,
-0.0098046046,
-0.0110135563,
0.0703923702,
0.0736605972,
-0.0347263291,
-0.0041995705,
-0.0460528731,
0.023896914,
0.0198037978,
-0.0517841987,
-0.0252703782,
-6.488612002e-33,
-0.020142382,
-0.0248402692,
0.0337689631,
0.0049411636,
-0.0198682565,
-0.0526526235,
-0.0015225869,
0.0039712186,
0.023866646,
0.0061956788,
-0.0262913667,
0.0117962463,
0.0257856324,
0.0393690914,
0.0285293441,
-0.0027822286,
0.0162441935,
-0.0298418235,
-0.0385741517,
-0.0287139714,
0.0001398973,
0.0359193534,
0.0575600825,
-0.0190014094,
0.0051584383,
0.0420306064,
0.0062176581,
0.0180674382,
-0.0286867898,
0.0711203739,
-0.0059159026,
0.0135343634,
0.0103107346,
-0.0661174059,
-0.0300454926,
-0.0101131611,
-0.0362153277,
-0.0908205882,
0.0115674809,
0.0413313098,
-0.0603392981,
-0.0209243745,
0.0105551928,
0.0068743029,
-0.0495297126,
0.0053888005,
0.0344787017,
-0.000889651,
-0.0198259074,
0.0194543656,
-0.0343234614,
0.0401837155,
0.0222589821,
0.028792657,
0.0323214456,
-0.0325258896,
-0.0240365565,
0.000977146,
0.0368890129,
0.0193776749,
0.023150824,
0.0569556244,
0.0307172611,
0.0472946204,
0.0019384807,
0.0191533491,
0.0006014052,
-0.082091406,
-0.0120574934,
-0.0086846016,
0.0468331352,
0.0186509099,
-0.008092883,
-0.0011620745,
0.0653589517,
0.0194391906,
-0.0308956075,
0.0248468146,
0.0529236682,
0.0473918878,
0.001923437,
0.0212991685,
-0.0279098805,
-0.0084496224,
-0.0595173351,
-0.0075078523,
-0.0372613929,
-0.071898818,
0.0076096524,
0.0137346247,
-0.0060135806,
0.0137580065,
0.0289972741,
-0.0295098368,
-0.0641936064,
0.0019809064,
-0.0205926653,
0.0153822489,
-0.0143724419,
0.0284106303,
-0.0657548457,
-0.0252580009,
-0.0228989031,
-0.0040975469,
-0.0047391886,
0.0085710716,
-0.032437969,
0.013118322,
-0.0691253096,
0.0051402906,
-0.0256868377,
0.0073329764,
0.023250116,
0.0383375101,
0.0353102162,
-0.0090386793,
0.0001712133,
0.0356909074,
0.0009822159,
-0.0422445983,
-0.022793917,
0.0386016145,
-0.028528979,
0.0554328077,
-0.0298785549,
0.0078439759,
-0.0458121747,
0.0086832335,
-0.0267780554,
-0.0671607405,
-0.0023151785,
0.0423523895,
2.943e-7,
0.0543356016,
0.0508563891,
0.0076383087,
0.0506264679,
0.0182922371,
0.0196187254,
-0.0079896115,
0.0083290758,
-0.0148915835,
0.0190772377,
0.0274939816,
0.0083737914,
-0.0142650781,
0.0317254066,
-0.071370557,
0.0540573671,
-0.0473765582,
0.011043149,
-0.05678479,
-0.0108677028,
0.0451107584,
0.1118473709,
0.0408524387,
-0.0023968166,
0.0094324043,
-0.0120137297,
0.0404690877,
0.0228022039,
0.0072572911,
0.0103690559,
0.0005650365,
0.0379877649,
0.0536932833,
-0.0192931201,
-0.0065770177,
0.0468780436,
0.0199587271,
0.0665294975,
0.0271573123,
-0.0054980968,
0.0045419629,
-0.0076852264,
0.0049931062,
-0.0496339835,
0.0667461157,
-0.0297499709,
-0.0110134613,
0.0062132352,
-0.0004078233,
-0.033644557,
0.0171900857,
-0.0382518135,
-0.0320646502,
0.0290896054,
0.023569325,
0.018864112,
0.0121304048,
-0.0501806773,
-0.0097080162,
-0.0095083136,
-0.0414820276,
-0.0344117358,
-0.045679763,
0.0552808456,
0.0164093524,
-0.0098191835,
-0.0381084569,
2.928798128e-34,
0.0790108964,
-0.0254644081,
-0.0076841814,
0.0370789394,
-0.0000686448,
0.0232597589,
-0.0090443203,
0.0660769641,
0.0539354794,
-0.0268268418,
-0.0310050026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08701v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08701v5 | AlpaGasus: Training A Better Alpaca with Fewer Data | 2023-07-17T17:59:40 | 2024-02-13T18:37:25 | Lichang Chen, Shiyang Li, Jun Yan, Hai Wang, Kalpa Gunaratna, Vikas Yadav, Zheng Tang, Vijay Srinivasan, Tianyi Zhou, Heng Huang, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) strengthen instruction-following capability
through instruction-finetuning (IFT) on supervised instruction/response data.
However, widely used IFT datasets (e.g., Alpaca's 52k data) surprisingly
contain many low-quality instances with incorrect or irrelevant responses,
which are misleading and detrimental to IFT. In this paper, we propose a simple
and effective data selection strategy that automatically identifies and filters
out low-quality data using a strong LLM (e.g., ChatGPT). To this end, we
introduce AlpaGasus, which is finetuned on only 9k high-quality data filtered
from the 52k Alpaca data. AlpaGasus significantly outperforms the original
Alpaca as evaluated by GPT-4 on multiple test sets and the controlled human
evaluation. Its 13B variant matches $>90\%$ performance of its teacher LLM
(i.e., Text-Davinci-003 generating the 52k data) on test tasks. It also
provides 5.7x faster training, reducing the training time for a 7B variant from
80 minutes (for Alpaca) to 14 minutes. Moreover, the experiments prove the
efficacy of our method across diverse datasets, base models, and LLM filters.
Overall, AlpaGasus demonstrates a novel data-centric IFT paradigm that can be
generally applied to instruction-tuning data, leading to faster training and
better instruction-following models. Our project page is available at:
https://lichang-chen.github.io/AlpaGasus/ | [
0.0188557021,
0.0471441187,
-0.0277349036,
0.0305796936,
0.008475462,
0.0260687545,
0.0034401419,
0.0089077977,
-0.0189948976,
-0.0664667189,
-0.0580604263,
-0.0169649404,
-0.0084553603,
-0.0240084138,
0.0518132262,
-0.0422289371,
0.0684442073,
-0.0311414413,
-0.0062898262,
0.0016856317,
0.0059413882,
0.0105176205,
-0.008068555,
0.0366281569,
0.0594153926,
0.0058728349,
-0.0024925305,
-0.0067947167,
0.0038973705,
-0.0493625775,
0.0826416239,
0.0518762134,
-0.0028025489,
-0.0064560501,
0.0000023899,
-0.012591593,
-0.0046093077,
-0.0280137192,
-0.0135776866,
0.0263616648,
0.0180379096,
-0.0037013567,
-0.0206496492,
0.0283337943,
-0.0232606512,
-0.0086781951,
0.0123056769,
0.0405975319,
0.0769193843,
0.0674405098,
0.0072142063,
-0.0164592844,
0.0263148192,
-0.0252626222,
0.0350659229,
-0.0283113215,
0.0139669497,
-0.018013956,
0.0331503823,
0.0285789091,
-0.0293086357,
0.0211674776,
0.0140764983,
0.0145891327,
-0.0283007286,
0.0348941199,
-0.0457769223,
-0.0180512015,
-0.0176550858,
0.0702643245,
-0.0254248008,
-0.0071705692,
-0.0081236688,
-0.0099213002,
-0.0125553599,
-0.023923669,
-0.0555631705,
0.0087520992,
0.0052242638,
0.0494434237,
0.0425314941,
-0.0085971439,
-0.0070409877,
0.0209048837,
-0.0046973694,
0.0327156596,
0.0021795079,
-0.0433235355,
0.0276805498,
0.0078708334,
-0.0148007562,
-0.0338676088,
0.0063590682,
0.0514127351,
-0.0256171748,
-0.0032217491,
-0.0628536567,
0.0045068446,
0.0457549356,
0.0093210163,
0.0587921031,
0.0593121871,
-0.0196574293,
0.0196261387,
-0.0390521735,
0.0511083677,
0.0224134047,
0.0590416268,
-0.0242565293,
0.0448845699,
-0.057017494,
0.0173252001,
-0.0181960035,
0.0224624518,
-0.0365921669,
0.0192369632,
-0.0403222442,
-0.0010504524,
-0.02027197,
-0.0216855295,
0.0117202811,
-0.0503550284,
-0.0631781071,
0.0348453894,
-0.0209721588,
0.0378967449,
-0.0377429724,
0.0360778272,
-0.0079979803,
-0.0651146248,
-0.0014173313,
-0.0021517139,
-0.0139132319,
-0.0313613005,
0.0649941713,
0.0659985766,
-0.0324867405,
-0.0599258021,
-0.0740413368,
-0.0071439776,
0.0062794914,
-0.0712420568,
0.0101213316,
-0.0457350574,
0.0160439927,
-0.0101099098,
0.0202507693,
0.0138904117,
0.0162763931,
0.0528139248,
-0.0023856752,
0.0320405923,
-0.0202714559,
0.0273966528,
-0.0032132154,
0.0027228042,
0.0147579489,
0.0538094565,
0.0377771854,
-0.000412879,
0.0178842228,
-0.0282565448,
0.003735357,
0.0438839942,
0.0208941288,
0.0278771408,
0.0144866323,
-0.0114238271,
-0.0156400725,
-0.0005439972,
0.0567772798,
0.0455874279,
-0.0166391488,
0.0238430183,
0.0894047692,
0.0073449956,
0.0057036676,
-0.0115551064,
0.0397874042,
0.0503217392,
0.0203848649,
0.0304497555,
-0.0766844079,
0.020869717,
-0.0124194231,
0.012131528,
0.0178493094,
0.0311458781,
-0.038765125,
-0.0406102985,
0.0309355743,
-0.0030126886,
0.0234049484,
0.013345791,
0.0345039666,
-0.0013846955,
-0.0556172319,
-0.0210248437,
0.0573008806,
-0.0152721573,
-0.0054241917,
-0.0814474151,
0.0575309694,
0.0693159252,
0.0318182595,
-0.0278935283,
-0.0523051769,
-0.0221660081,
0.0425168537,
-0.0016958573,
0.0162160117,
-0.0002013893,
-0.0011874584,
-0.078077361,
-0.0076649738,
0.0098087918,
-0.0003318825,
-0.0010023615,
0.0166493226,
0.0132724475,
-0.0081504388,
0.0180918705,
-0.0779135153,
0.0682569444,
-0.0227177963,
-0.0632747188,
-0.0344737321,
0.0179313887,
0.0201075692,
-0.0076245316,
0.0083326446,
-0.0243440121,
0.037981119,
-0.0106550371,
0.0428975262,
-0.0528571978,
-0.0816746429,
-0.0268595349,
0.0157140773,
-0.0174921677,
-0.0451368988,
0.0354810469,
-0.0428518727,
-0.0434981845,
-0.0539857447,
-0.0458136089,
0.0096605448,
-0.0116067808,
0.0442187525,
0.0013903431,
-0.0015082937,
-0.0675850511,
0.0155622922,
0.0071943095,
0.0459544733,
0.0340433754,
0.0074908705,
0.0183480084,
-0.0491354726,
-0.0330917202,
0.0133390334,
-0.0280907433,
0.0215742458,
0.0185554065,
0.0981829166,
-0.0479349047,
-0.0342166945,
-0.0382427275,
0.0436149463,
-0.0252334606,
0.0253610145,
0.029408602,
-0.0333817899,
-0.0329121985,
0.0067349654,
-0.0292900633,
-0.0178860072,
0.0027334848,
0.0123214843,
0.0248759687,
0.0111070564,
-0.0303988419,
-0.0595001206,
-0.0150968432,
-0.0072499397,
-0.0343351401,
-0.0078025521,
-0.0270517319,
-0.0357792377,
0.0596441589,
0.0030008967,
0.0337775536,
-0.020749094,
-0.1008358598,
0.0238083359,
0.0167575888,
0.0296883117,
0.0830511302,
0.0038850612,
-0.0062180837,
0.042771183,
-0.0005245556,
-0.0683079436,
0.0278620888,
-0.034073703,
-0.0490465574,
-0.035104923,
-0.0304039959,
-0.0037434257,
0.0774653032,
0.0084637683,
-0.0025506136,
-0.0800947994,
0.0001338998,
-0.0278835613,
0.0203770492,
-0.0076985313,
0.0155873615,
-0.0281534195,
-0.0043958272,
-0.0474716425,
-0.0673618913,
0.0553117394,
-0.0196553525,
-0.0139561277,
-0.0586740188,
-0.0057764105,
-0.006392742,
0.0035349261,
0.0299671218,
0.0040163314,
-0.0115227904,
-0.0046524168,
-0.0661251396,
0.0295853503,
0.0152431186,
-0.0431924723,
0.0545326285,
-0.0682456121,
-0.0022183205,
-0.0215318538,
-0.0260383226,
-0.0205215774,
-0.0015435459,
0.0160382204,
-0.0169992559,
0.0268584471,
-0.0146923261,
-0.0326530337,
-0.0258408915,
0.0332937501,
0.0603274852,
-0.0497042984,
0.0068439743,
-0.0414930023,
-0.050975617,
0.043854326,
-0.0190489814,
-0.0192964803,
-0.0483143181,
0.0324944109,
0.0355231948,
0.03958226,
0.003402584,
0.000804692,
0.0210114159,
0.0428708605,
-0.0156703684,
-0.0330543593,
0.0323882736,
0.1165969148,
-0.0664722398,
-0.0057375464,
0.0960291028,
0.0120312441,
-0.0319874175,
-0.0084678503,
0.0352273583,
0.0365695246,
0.0231454596,
0.0227582697,
-0.0515288338,
-0.0534089692,
-0.0009969441,
0.0674397051,
-0.0253692288,
-0.0043900842,
0.005993892,
-0.1013651937,
0.0358564891,
0.0135459136,
-0.0502604544,
-0.0223957393,
-0.0472983234,
0.007353554,
-0.0215559658,
0.031999357,
0.005773955,
-0.0517287143,
0.0113042733,
0.0537757725,
-0.0085350526,
-0.0706163198,
0.0333373807,
-0.0187435076,
0.0763289109,
0.0689381361,
0.0300887134,
-0.0036795719,
-0.0352036133,
0.0357167199,
-0.0338476002,
-0.0174405091,
-0.0054046321,
0.0575592592,
-0.0223948974,
-0.0146069592,
-0.0117929615,
0.0643536001,
-0.0080495095,
0.0308966115,
0.0234972667,
0.0632454678,
-0.0097343922,
0.0122861108,
-0.0122802546,
-0.0176476128,
0.0044316472,
0.0800898075,
0.0336788483,
-0.0673619211,
-0.0177962463,
-0.0230400134,
-0.0496636555,
-0.0607525185,
-0.0267826766,
0.0564583279,
-0.0882026181,
-0.000616797,
-0.0646499023,
-0.0675321147,
0.0723264292,
-0.009135697,
0.0181176495,
0.006374503,
0.0162625313,
-0.019959908,
-0.0021455463,
0.0375607684,
-0.0248164237,
0.0362454206,
-0.125195995,
-0.0679775104,
0.0113628013,
0.0102257356,
-0.0053305309,
0.044140704,
-0.0532234013,
-0.0707812831,
0.0206240248,
0.0749463737,
0.0192573108,
0.0309010576,
0.0256115757,
-0.0354533158,
0.0349073485,
0.0384188034,
-0.0389334448,
0.0166827384,
0.0411734506,
-0.018443251,
0.0003861666,
0.0144445663,
-0.0252695475,
0.0640007406,
0.0252892133,
0.0360581838,
-0.0329682045,
0.0131929675,
0.0303376243,
0.0229613725,
0.0254352521,
-0.0210277587,
-0.0240375977,
-0.0437231772,
-0.0021043096,
0.0147114042,
0.0237681214,
-0.0451171771,
-0.000951968,
0.0094561651,
-0.0161470417,
-0.0122052496,
-0.0315914005,
-0.0251728166,
0.0233129505,
-0.0502082221,
0.0365744606,
-0.0320894383,
0.0341327302,
0.0336890258,
0.0097771315,
-0.0158955455,
0.0004948524,
0.0304086488,
0.041269429,
-0.0086359261,
0.0831523761,
0.0195260942,
0.025945412,
0.0025256129,
0.0403790623,
-0.024487434,
0.0052639809,
-0.055985976,
0.0026217641,
0.0121650659,
-0.0394583493,
0.0467006266,
-0.0174558368,
0.0022024908,
-0.0318728462,
0.0335040428,
-0.0020869062,
0.0096042762,
0.0123833911,
0.0236169118,
0.0018334194,
-0.0134187024,
0.0809611678,
-0.0164449159,
0.053617049,
-0.0001682736,
0.0314324573,
-0.0458847582,
0.0026516858,
0.0178819243,
0.003982658,
0.006109783,
0.0321847387,
0.0051561804,
-0.027055677,
-0.0684277117,
0.0061396467,
0.0051763635,
-0.0537171997,
0.0350005329,
0.0098021124,
-0.030956002,
-0.0100725591,
-0.0496488363,
-0.042068284,
0.0126942573,
-0.0041376874,
-0.0372744724,
-6.99862447e-33,
-0.0469379611,
-0.0026784015,
0.0254970565,
0.0227573924,
-0.018274622,
0.0050120759,
-0.0264371708,
-0.012338941,
-0.0211322177,
-0.007830129,
0.0090624103,
-0.0139806699,
0.0068256585,
0.0177913159,
0.0181777589,
0.0239802748,
0.036951974,
-0.0100679891,
-0.034512572,
0.0317024142,
0.0103282034,
0.0073432783,
0.0447002053,
-0.071461685,
0.0027825972,
-0.0131962951,
-0.0001772128,
-0.0071097235,
-0.0414611846,
0.0644378215,
0.0040878537,
0.0314506404,
0.0238336455,
-0.0367297009,
-0.0190891344,
0.006527714,
-0.0558051318,
-0.0531670637,
0.0103265243,
0.0131531861,
-0.0085626403,
-0.0349869691,
0.0421319455,
-0.028562868,
-0.0190388579,
-0.0137644289,
0.0195176657,
-0.0523201153,
-0.0304812081,
0.0216608234,
-0.0744768903,
0.0165000521,
-0.0055113807,
-0.0555895753,
-0.0023173948,
0.0613709539,
-0.0189896412,
0.0016090282,
-0.0446541421,
0.0353204645,
0.0790498182,
0.0702742785,
0.0367848389,
0.0043286635,
0.0072989692,
0.0389152728,
0.0185209494,
0.0140356896,
0.0456842594,
-0.0209472645,
0.038861908,
0.0565504916,
0.0427699164,
-0.0035158433,
0.0459903888,
-0.0269674752,
-0.0629764423,
0.0541875735,
0.0236018766,
0.0190247223,
0.0225208066,
-0.0089093447,
-0.0619018115,
-0.019660322,
-0.0240058973,
0.0248206332,
0.0008867186,
-0.0158876739,
0.0607467964,
0.0197909381,
-0.0177576877,
-0.0085952645,
0.0262548383,
0.002960762,
-0.0068522287,
-0.0413191393,
-0.0651289076,
0.0037805468,
0.0095565785,
-0.0144968368,
-0.0673328415,
-0.0921003222,
0.0186488144,
-0.0316173583,
0.0467236787,
0.0165213291,
0.0738003924,
0.0234316755,
-0.0746600479,
-0.0093235141,
-0.0326522402,
0.0491097309,
0.0112322597,
-0.0199370235,
0.0365365036,
-0.0018270874,
0.0045408066,
0.0914745927,
-0.0050930511,
-0.0235554799,
-0.0530664213,
-0.0639359429,
-0.011618657,
0.0377665348,
-0.0347086675,
0.0111906659,
-0.0517438091,
-0.0141772963,
-0.0220038574,
-0.0396545939,
-0.0093995128,
0.002742114,
3.032e-7,
-0.005564326,
0.0448218174,
-0.0120698661,
0.0221687555,
-0.0052728318,
0.0219883267,
-0.045811113,
-0.007118023,
0.0207567737,
0.0147702703,
0.0022022258,
0.0323163047,
0.0552167706,
0.0090560075,
-0.0577484854,
-0.0095362235,
-0.0253223069,
-0.0109217251,
-0.0595797971,
0.0052209292,
0.0452260002,
0.0952427536,
-0.0062368419,
0.0043434217,
0.0250350665,
-0.0071406625,
0.034225978,
-0.0130497599,
-0.0146455141,
0.0256683324,
0.0351734906,
0.023602182,
-0.0212636255,
0.02170581,
-0.0313244648,
0.0073635164,
-0.0365427285,
0.0626524314,
-0.0116171194,
0.0273643788,
0.0655810609,
-0.0136873331,
-0.0119923651,
-0.0281491354,
0.0689519718,
-0.0746662095,
-0.0009312342,
0.017496245,
-0.0135077238,
-0.0315015577,
0.014300786,
-0.0268236771,
0.008924989,
0.0218884982,
0.0066157822,
-0.015190796,
-0.0290876031,
-0.0643222556,
0.0293880887,
0.0234884955,
-0.0285115093,
-0.0625862256,
-0.0808828324,
0.0136214597,
-0.0053581069,
-0.0556541719,
-0.0086038718,
2.830950622e-34,
-0.0076749539,
-0.0524996258,
0.0591304451,
0.0114603266,
0.0183265675,
0.0188503023,
-0.0126286726,
0.0399829745,
0.0112433936,
-0.0433912314,
-0.0214058235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08689v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08689v1 | COLLIE: Systematic Construction of Constrained Text Generation Tasks | 2023-07-17T17:48:51 | 2023-07-17T17:48:51 | Shunyu Yao, Howard Chen, Austin W. Hanjie, Runzhe Yang, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Text generation under constraints have seen increasing interests in natural
language processing, especially with the rapidly improving capabilities of
large language models. However, existing benchmarks for constrained generation
usually focus on fixed constraint types (e.g.,generate a sentence containing
certain words) that have proved to be easy for state-of-the-art models like
GPT-4. We present COLLIE, a grammar-based framework that allows the
specification of rich, compositional constraints with diverse generation levels
(word, sentence, paragraph, passage) and modeling challenges (e.g.,language
understanding, logical reasoning, counting, semantic planning). We also develop
tools for automatic extraction of task instances given a constraint structure
and a raw text corpus. Using COLLIE, we compile the COLLIE-v1 dataset with 2080
instances comprising 13 constraint structures. We perform systematic
experiments across five state-of-the-art instruction-tuned language models and
analyze their performances to reveal shortcomings. COLLIE is designed to be
extensible and lightweight, and we hope the community finds it useful to
develop more complex constraints and evaluations in the future. | [
0.068791084,
0.0883243307,
0.0056410716,
-0.0015786054,
-0.0387311205,
-0.0253070444,
0.029570261,
-0.0273133907,
-0.0102691818,
-0.0294026323,
0.0217889491,
-0.050581146,
-0.0198170971,
0.0378255844,
0.02815759,
-0.0499915853,
0.0196218081,
-0.0135699268,
-0.001243735,
0.0276330784,
0.0253329314,
0.0514767133,
-0.0065062782,
0.0296671893,
-0.0417734683,
0.0017715079,
-0.0156545546,
0.009493486,
0.0225404967,
-0.0171163157,
0.0378922932,
0.0660927743,
0.024366634,
0.023997644,
0.0000019775,
-0.0401123986,
-0.0412259512,
-0.0254799761,
-0.0013798286,
0.0008365168,
0.0568798743,
-0.0429371074,
0.0023606226,
0.0304421876,
-0.0300013125,
0.0090607274,
0.0054942267,
0.0401947834,
0.085637331,
0.1023334786,
-0.0199213456,
-0.0045343693,
-0.0150154084,
-0.0297453292,
0.017024748,
-0.0153860915,
-0.0056350282,
-0.0146196513,
0.0344867893,
-0.019398341,
0.0174104925,
-0.0023779806,
0.0519924946,
-0.0080294749,
-0.0181218591,
0.0355797932,
-0.0765474364,
-0.0508362092,
-0.0441604741,
0.0470857844,
0.0286235213,
-0.0425825752,
0.0230498388,
-0.0187786259,
-0.0026729838,
-0.0293150228,
-0.0323788337,
0.0589820333,
0.0004633449,
0.0255446266,
0.0294950046,
0.0290207602,
-0.003314496,
0.003303919,
0.0184254888,
0.0221253,
0.0311157852,
-0.0365968235,
-0.0063134902,
0.0117386607,
-0.0368364677,
-0.0520458333,
0.025431646,
0.0353731066,
-0.0668806806,
-0.0029322195,
-0.1026901901,
-0.0260436311,
0.0252612606,
0.0141207017,
0.066153422,
0.0366404951,
0.0403347313,
0.0164366104,
0.0009975545,
0.0711433738,
0.0037094851,
-0.0278522149,
-0.0258292295,
0.0220183562,
-0.029052753,
-0.0205596015,
-0.0662348196,
0.0014107698,
-0.0492790639,
-0.0312212463,
-0.0286085717,
0.0248693973,
0.0110400924,
0.0292563681,
0.0185235087,
0.0336552709,
-0.0623131841,
-0.0233125798,
-0.0095568486,
-0.0369106829,
-0.0384547189,
0.0016122422,
0.0420640074,
-0.0305401571,
-0.0301697776,
0.0511253104,
0.0255755316,
-0.0502144881,
-0.0145238079,
0.0463101342,
-0.0266996305,
-0.0214449409,
-0.008490405,
-0.0623320565,
-0.0302899517,
-0.1009401307,
-0.0060467692,
-0.0617487319,
-0.0235752389,
-0.0166911613,
-0.0115356389,
-0.0363709629,
0.0235232152,
0.0231378283,
0.0224018302,
0.001895436,
0.0271091722,
-0.0213755239,
-0.0041258764,
0.0212248079,
0.0360632315,
0.0600594915,
0.050546892,
0.0423195958,
-0.0055671032,
0.0298963953,
0.0154015413,
0.0289202407,
0.0069074929,
-0.0126093198,
-0.0063348436,
-0.0124449069,
-0.016286185,
0.029569827,
0.0196116064,
0.076687552,
0.0029120413,
0.0042310753,
0.0504691415,
0.0094800219,
0.0036053329,
0.0224941671,
0.0797525793,
0.0110398866,
-0.0267620254,
0.0321481153,
-0.0358012021,
0.0185710452,
0.0210062936,
0.0100783221,
0.012635963,
0.0387271382,
-0.0067218449,
-0.041457925,
-0.0091808783,
0.0066822344,
0.0027497853,
-0.043062076,
0.0249781888,
0.0293762386,
-0.0674996972,
0.0435491502,
-0.0099867946,
-0.0927227214,
0.0136879236,
0.0118086757,
0.0114660887,
0.0479993448,
0.0777141601,
-0.0031502191,
-0.0444096215,
0.0012187151,
0.0400503427,
0.1071865112,
0.0544736423,
0.0148950787,
0.0142376926,
-0.0533266366,
0.0012687288,
-0.042146869,
0.0231748391,
-0.0013390094,
0.0390739255,
-0.0078628939,
0.0470098928,
-0.0042894692,
-0.0359990671,
0.0504667461,
-0.026474895,
-0.0423449352,
0.0033804004,
-0.0159726571,
-0.01048976,
0.001440197,
-0.0106318025,
0.0280634928,
0.0314176381,
-0.0433203019,
0.0105747283,
0.0120017603,
-0.059962634,
-0.0295363069,
0.0054927226,
-0.0560964048,
-0.002616571,
0.0149234012,
-0.0190198813,
-0.0685847476,
0.0398982242,
-0.040618401,
0.0098319063,
-0.048782479,
-0.0136744455,
0.0506303385,
-0.0227222964,
-0.0222494099,
0.0737535208,
0.0119290547,
-0.0083228527,
0.0325609334,
-0.0166015644,
-0.0083653908,
-0.0508826748,
0.0054821642,
-0.0421557091,
-0.0019541206,
0.0108898757,
0.0468042567,
0.0770382062,
-0.0333865397,
-0.0386385806,
-0.0447046645,
0.0512946397,
-0.0340355448,
0.0320722871,
0.027151553,
0.0137185287,
-0.0172389857,
0.0041185129,
-0.0629137307,
0.0056530237,
0.0438116565,
-0.0254442431,
0.0327809863,
0.0073750787,
-0.0089734457,
-0.0271846056,
0.0114599122,
-0.0000048799,
-0.0076954076,
0.0530206822,
0.0240310263,
-0.0173544716,
0.0623116344,
-0.0151489498,
0.0301375892,
0.0106407218,
-0.0015620671,
0.011229774,
-0.0123538598,
0.0752441436,
0.0035919778,
-0.0055766953,
0.0606040061,
0.0308046602,
-0.0118503524,
-0.0025659646,
0.043837253,
-0.0566157028,
0.0058779898,
0.0180578213,
-0.0175645668,
0.0179210622,
0.0721068308,
0.0112819653,
-0.0089359162,
-0.0635624379,
0.0413640961,
-0.007615671,
-0.0075627249,
0.0106499027,
0.013024807,
-0.01784214,
0.0068445257,
-0.0349040143,
-0.0399625935,
0.0378502347,
-0.0376789719,
-0.0009102899,
-0.0217624586,
0.0084477896,
-0.0396507084,
0.0522522479,
0.0556385219,
0.0201143585,
0.0424533039,
0.0138038266,
-0.0600682497,
0.0487763509,
0.029466413,
-0.0056136074,
0.0186588503,
-0.0678491667,
0.0032570849,
-0.042953033,
-0.0489227623,
-0.0615159757,
-0.0167024117,
0.01378504,
0.0167101566,
0.0537621491,
-0.0267644245,
-0.0170128066,
-0.0137489662,
-0.009982937,
0.0670639277,
-0.0289149452,
-0.0060874252,
-0.0617850535,
0.036796499,
0.0650314391,
0.0392193496,
-0.017436184,
-0.0343456902,
-0.0180024896,
0.02283049,
0.0110810017,
0.0216656476,
0.0063526831,
0.0335343443,
0.0073603108,
-0.015140661,
0.0117861414,
0.0377958938,
0.0816833228,
-0.0645564124,
-0.0677802563,
0.1129097417,
0.0459638648,
-0.024571225,
0.0163239595,
0.0064033587,
0.0983456001,
0.0256086197,
0.0257920399,
-0.0635202751,
-0.0399949141,
0.0193475746,
0.0341866873,
-0.0269546397,
-0.0273176413,
-0.0461273007,
-0.0938728824,
0.0352245867,
0.0177458003,
-0.0261455495,
0.0080979941,
-0.0053880736,
-0.0468141176,
-0.009138626,
-0.0122539774,
0.013578658,
-0.0133136055,
0.0355758369,
0.0379009806,
0.0106327096,
-0.0300222244,
-0.0155436192,
-0.010286361,
0.0298354123,
0.0397806056,
0.0037772844,
0.0114733791,
-0.0203647632,
0.0234108232,
0.0155186262,
-0.0175492354,
-0.0076619387,
0.0048917043,
0.0084968945,
-0.0147818485,
-0.0284254774,
0.0618618354,
-0.0692059025,
-0.0146978553,
0.023340255,
0.0557571054,
0.0126779284,
-0.0257883929,
-0.0303002018,
-0.0008961134,
0.0287882257,
0.0723702759,
0.0427133217,
-0.0285026841,
-0.0648703054,
-0.0466091298,
0.0172081403,
-0.1463615894,
0.0197479464,
0.0071005481,
0.0057232319,
0.0160218496,
-0.0888759568,
-0.0269197375,
0.038296327,
0.0539558344,
0.0014723042,
-0.045133058,
0.0187753662,
-0.0405063219,
-0.0716333538,
-0.0001381682,
-0.0091670798,
0.002645361,
-0.0574674867,
-0.0385152288,
-0.0295585506,
-0.0304478556,
-0.0011831125,
0.0678497031,
-0.0898148566,
-0.0687778443,
-0.0534666814,
0.0493678823,
0.0242958888,
0.0169539601,
-0.0101405988,
-0.0225518662,
-0.0352790467,
0.0460641161,
-0.0436447486,
0.0020603584,
-0.0138995349,
-0.0616583563,
-0.0030658885,
0.0307366755,
-0.0095951157,
0.0258219335,
-0.0041584508,
0.0796274543,
0.005154687,
0.0016538157,
0.0712593794,
-0.0075470582,
-0.0188329834,
-0.0650242344,
-0.0027752519,
-0.0370691754,
-0.0121504404,
-0.0564629957,
-0.0237244349,
-0.0570983402,
0.0306588598,
0.0001959077,
-0.0028098186,
0.0098255211,
-0.0037216861,
-0.01274883,
0.0484966412,
-0.0329104029,
-0.0032651529,
0.0248916708,
-0.0002560336,
0.0237729102,
-0.0329743735,
-0.0243960358,
0.0488715768,
-0.0541892275,
0.0392548628,
-0.0108562084,
0.035438396,
0.019001428,
0.0086174766,
0.0109108696,
-0.0074726031,
-0.0006007262,
0.0429970212,
-0.0479969643,
-0.0096277818,
0.0396492369,
-0.0145772425,
0.0736963898,
-0.0340598375,
0.0029884481,
-0.0276401471,
0.0504413061,
0.0145841148,
-0.0388433523,
-0.0149439266,
0.0202866811,
-0.0085270042,
-0.0320833512,
0.0834724233,
0.0610145219,
0.0366784781,
0.0383544639,
0.0033542169,
-0.0686148852,
-0.0369151197,
0.0036617131,
0.0090696346,
0.0164305102,
0.0136246551,
-0.0501488037,
-0.0490853116,
-0.0049677868,
0.033337716,
0.0349628143,
-0.0030650028,
0.0365702733,
0.0076714996,
-0.0588328131,
-0.0238354485,
-0.0437064283,
0.0108641125,
-0.0365726128,
-0.0247338414,
-0.0126159117,
-6.375062186e-33,
-0.0481629483,
-0.0603973456,
0.0404083133,
-0.0049669831,
-0.0081176665,
0.0017322554,
-0.0675584525,
-0.0072337179,
0.0621305332,
0.0012107143,
0.0066297939,
-0.0337083042,
-0.006387305,
0.0622634552,
-0.002852947,
0.0204289723,
0.0177975446,
-0.0115521392,
-0.074188903,
0.0524445586,
0.0569826551,
0.007626527,
0.0276874751,
0.0254216455,
-0.0141437324,
-0.0182963461,
-0.0403369777,
0.0053500673,
-0.0144303693,
0.0429648757,
-0.0357536599,
0.0173819065,
0.020952303,
-0.0260974392,
-0.0245427657,
0.0497144684,
-0.0480526425,
-0.0444629341,
0.0029946319,
-0.0388805009,
-0.0527402088,
-0.056356702,
0.0053057629,
-0.0285815895,
-0.0116497641,
0.0231070556,
0.013651236,
0.0048002708,
-0.0067452257,
-0.0406239405,
-0.0805265084,
0.0165025834,
-0.0225928854,
-0.0412552394,
-0.0038020189,
0.0544085316,
-0.0065844292,
-0.0342976116,
0.0138624301,
0.0287226047,
0.0266638286,
0.0645902231,
0.0383176729,
0.0011599936,
-0.0278062951,
0.0380355418,
-0.060684897,
-0.0228131376,
-0.0576134697,
0.06422925,
-0.0072596753,
0.0519918948,
0.02271064,
0.0416704416,
0.0186599866,
-0.0038105778,
-0.0757141411,
0.0238734223,
-0.0226398334,
0.0236705355,
0.0391198471,
-0.0066975169,
-0.0208805744,
-0.0046334295,
-0.0159227755,
0.009607641,
-0.01263134,
0.0192278102,
0.0584674701,
0.065693073,
-0.0337104201,
-0.0013827353,
0.0134545118,
0.0183095913,
0.0042386488,
0.0211667493,
-0.042478539,
-0.0076668453,
-0.0135334153,
0.0306537617,
-0.0602228977,
-0.0378692821,
0.0604610406,
0.0223636497,
0.0219707694,
0.0241486244,
0.021990044,
0.0226442702,
-0.0373687521,
0.0148017826,
-0.0846349224,
0.0823142901,
-0.0109646339,
0.0138262063,
0.0135296574,
-0.0260938015,
-0.0161514077,
0.008943703,
0.0153047862,
-0.0381035246,
-0.0387417004,
-0.000232329,
0.016717514,
0.0217662472,
-0.0178505778,
0.0142195299,
-0.0121607548,
0.0066465223,
0.0218955837,
-0.0325979777,
0.0023265455,
-0.0048825969,
2.614e-7,
0.0131425923,
0.0435534008,
0.0558885299,
0.0331359245,
0.0135078635,
0.0071498826,
0.0017528422,
0.0675773397,
-0.0408222862,
-0.0283628982,
0.0007656594,
0.0061898185,
0.0425836332,
0.0218325369,
-0.0365191437,
0.0515444279,
-0.0379439294,
0.0015298735,
-0.0494672246,
-0.0183886606,
0.0966778696,
0.0381497927,
-0.0279330891,
0.0004233244,
0.0038214212,
-0.0471392944,
0.0481516756,
0.0080631236,
-0.0049486994,
0.0008111024,
0.0209354199,
-0.0019149206,
-0.0373579077,
-0.0035176903,
-0.0190743841,
0.0096744094,
0.0083838506,
0.074456729,
0.0170390848,
-0.0097198868,
0.0336141214,
0.0010181241,
-0.0007715142,
-0.0414224193,
0.0487019904,
-0.0214519836,
-0.007669731,
-0.0071765739,
-0.0084437858,
0.004937428,
-0.032434091,
-0.0186930951,
-0.027221119,
-0.004073346,
0.0200932901,
-0.0046286425,
-0.0170567725,
-0.0358280391,
-0.0246160142,
0.0076197623,
-0.044158157,
0.0028701343,
-0.0771187171,
0.0256787296,
-0.0272923559,
-0.0565437302,
-0.0189751368,
2.76284404e-34,
0.0086664706,
-0.0010473115,
0.0009622747,
-0.0131635536,
0.0365634076,
0.0069864411,
-0.0718083531,
0.0189399328,
-0.0012828829,
-0.0772757828,
-0.0412747562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08678v1 | Do Models Explain Themselves? Counterfactual Simulatability of Natural Language Explanations | 2023-07-17T17:41:47 | 2023-07-17T17:41:47 | Yanda Chen, Ruiqi Zhong, Narutatsu Ri, Chen Zhao, He He, Jacob Steinhardt, Zhou Yu, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are trained to imitate humans to explain human
decisions. However, do LLMs explain themselves? Can they help humans build
mental models of how LLMs process different inputs? To answer these questions,
we propose to evaluate $\textbf{counterfactual simulatability}$ of natural
language explanations: whether an explanation can enable humans to precisely
infer the model's outputs on diverse counterfactuals of the explained input.
For example, if a model answers "yes" to the input question "Can eagles fly?"
with the explanation "all birds can fly", then humans would infer from the
explanation that it would also answer "yes" to the counterfactual input "Can
penguins fly?". If the explanation is precise, then the model's answer should
match humans' expectations.
We implemented two metrics based on counterfactual simulatability: precision
and generality. We generated diverse counterfactuals automatically using LLMs.
We then used these metrics to evaluate state-of-the-art LLMs (e.g., GPT-4) on
two tasks: multi-hop factual reasoning and reward modeling. We found that LLM's
explanations have low precision and that precision does not correlate with
plausibility. Therefore, naively optimizing human approvals (e.g., RLHF) may
not be a sufficient solution. | [
0.0410019644,
0.0253888629,
-0.0286954865,
0.0366505757,
-0.0550935492,
0.0227934476,
-0.0261460319,
-0.0033808297,
-0.0223815739,
-0.0404952578,
-0.0257043317,
-0.002502111,
0.007801184,
0.0156382937,
0.013392848,
-0.0414441787,
0.0603930838,
-0.0448832028,
0.0166710038,
-0.0356783606,
-0.0480217896,
0.0297579914,
-0.0259265825,
0.0421619155,
0.033402063,
-0.0246035978,
-0.0256212875,
-0.0199720655,
0.0307204816,
0.0010569661,
-0.0141353123,
0.0179741271,
0.0501586273,
0.0329423621,
0.0000020199,
-0.0319718942,
0.0100695863,
0.0200361554,
-0.0812468603,
0.001740833,
-0.0169150606,
-0.0019739396,
0.0120721934,
0.0064322543,
-0.0084885899,
0.0467079543,
0.042889405,
0.080679208,
0.0479637496,
0.0746533126,
0.027431434,
-0.0553508848,
0.0025649199,
-0.0086393626,
0.0223185197,
-0.011755269,
-0.0111779487,
0.0498475991,
-0.0025332915,
0.0102790156,
-0.027499754,
-0.01350787,
0.0489604175,
0.0187313389,
-0.0269060545,
0.0374976508,
0.0265134908,
-0.0381714813,
0.0101179462,
0.0439142995,
0.0089067202,
-0.042675171,
-0.0140459454,
-0.0343624949,
0.0255663674,
0.0516685285,
-0.0313519537,
0.0313693136,
-0.0017576504,
0.0248736963,
0.0066673174,
-0.0051222709,
0.0685869604,
0.0176732987,
0.0179345813,
0.0973125696,
-0.0094694141,
-0.0124078691,
-0.020584736,
0.0029954866,
-0.0104633151,
-0.0620065294,
-0.0121726133,
0.0428298786,
-0.05643709,
0.0165110733,
0.010780192,
0.0396221355,
0.0331023149,
-0.0357210711,
0.0480468385,
0.0436298586,
-0.0171792861,
0.047910776,
-0.0193005092,
0.0441266857,
-0.0586135797,
0.0318451077,
-0.0088502383,
-0.0066000619,
-0.073943004,
-0.0436524861,
0.0114299068,
0.032122992,
-0.0408500619,
0.0204209406,
-0.0270851515,
-0.0154587217,
-0.0860233381,
0.0255981479,
-0.0126153268,
0.0359841958,
-0.0183211956,
-0.044053372,
-0.1004033089,
0.0147721972,
-0.056553144,
0.051949244,
-0.0000771388,
-0.0190135688,
-0.0075220102,
-0.0184299964,
-0.0088122655,
-0.01386132,
0.0071777967,
0.0885780379,
0.0055429805,
0.0125812655,
-0.0212935824,
-0.0503735617,
-0.0004911404,
-0.0931478664,
-0.0013746353,
-0.0433321632,
0.0081003131,
-0.0014129988,
-0.0155534204,
-0.0149480635,
0.0088735726,
0.0014457651,
-0.0368864313,
0.0972568765,
0.0221632924,
0.0113615245,
0.0095445458,
0.0072288886,
-0.0533463471,
0.0513571166,
0.0244255532,
0.0173691325,
0.0235684216,
-0.0231815241,
0.0344011448,
-0.0198730752,
0.0316453874,
-0.0251062941,
-0.0099744564,
0.0192539599,
-0.0327164121,
0.0266390815,
0.0326030552,
0.0195011292,
-0.0193070117,
-0.0313532352,
0.05755895,
0.0250425711,
-0.0013662081,
0.0063786921,
0.0914889202,
0.0028757975,
-0.0073296409,
0.0608224571,
-0.1020744592,
0.0578154922,
-0.0532549508,
0.0106390547,
0.0076340246,
0.0151266083,
-0.0136735039,
-0.060743589,
-0.0047398498,
-0.0039781029,
0.0215517897,
0.0378205478,
0.0474444553,
-0.0313670449,
-0.0288731698,
0.0082427962,
0.0176956356,
0.0028400461,
0.0045700087,
-0.072951138,
0.0380183011,
0.0478540547,
0.0335116945,
-0.0308361407,
-0.0132191097,
-0.0238707494,
-0.0474323668,
0.0316487551,
0.0759794712,
-0.0113495933,
0.0094223926,
0.0098055126,
-0.0096107917,
-0.0416321531,
0.0515673533,
0.0179453809,
0.0132090319,
-0.0113507649,
0.0230286587,
-0.0137667051,
-0.0012791695,
0.0456629544,
-0.0154855708,
0.0005924348,
-0.0251870789,
0.0027649777,
0.042037271,
0.0282879677,
0.0141109051,
0.0285249669,
0.0313815325,
0.0294379517,
-0.052844394,
0.0295766853,
-0.0113145793,
-0.0251988024,
0.0164868031,
-0.0402253084,
-0.0507261157,
0.0558555163,
-0.0382478163,
-0.0406936631,
0.0329750963,
-0.0153939119,
0.0580500737,
-0.0225705225,
0.0208002534,
-0.0020794026,
-0.0246576518,
-0.0021036977,
0.0491187237,
0.021166319,
0.0218793396,
-0.042470891,
-0.0132207554,
0.0082642846,
-0.0435145386,
0.0225515943,
0.0118297292,
-0.0156746712,
-0.013230023,
0.0163568202,
-0.0174670164,
-0.0402360782,
0.0222396813,
-0.0355537534,
-0.0105342697,
-0.0049769236,
0.0175580643,
0.0241549574,
-0.0604340918,
0.0193736553,
-0.0079311635,
-0.0188310314,
0.0043663057,
0.012437962,
0.0301600993,
0.0403882749,
-0.0178188235,
-0.0346945636,
-0.0251756422,
-0.0044390899,
-0.0393464603,
0.0357755348,
0.0047843158,
0.0512245186,
-0.0557733402,
-0.0203756411,
-0.0537351631,
0.0086144684,
-0.0093805576,
-0.0279298984,
0.0578210093,
0.0480049625,
-0.0316692069,
0.0506860018,
0.0035519747,
0.036505755,
0.06854821,
0.0394090004,
-0.0506434925,
0.0012532243,
-0.0440367647,
-0.0224127863,
-0.0135253174,
-0.0598756447,
-0.0147826215,
0.0559665971,
0.0021186944,
-0.0100397086,
-0.0818209574,
0.0327475145,
0.0076729367,
-0.0512537695,
-0.0516553074,
-0.0428541414,
-0.0170509182,
0.0623766631,
-0.0108370632,
-0.046256572,
0.0859503374,
-0.0056535485,
0.0068692267,
-0.0023669286,
0.0124799935,
-0.0112739261,
0.089762032,
0.0032006926,
0.0036497249,
0.0324131027,
0.0307407267,
-0.0320127867,
-0.045561105,
0.0500471666,
-0.0074095302,
0.0461771004,
-0.0742729902,
-0.0117392614,
0.003406435,
-0.0115866615,
-0.0373159237,
-0.0350048505,
-0.0293514859,
0.0097434204,
-0.0506389029,
-0.0322525389,
-0.0140759507,
-0.01012873,
0.0526508279,
-0.0187321641,
-0.013462835,
-0.0163432509,
-0.0203411523,
-0.0201141536,
0.056626182,
0.0520071387,
0.0632294938,
-0.0237189848,
0.0246025641,
0.0261421055,
0.0042046471,
-0.0011420968,
0.005764924,
0.0192865636,
-0.0242804941,
-0.0181745347,
-0.0000967507,
0.0361732319,
0.0529829785,
-0.0540042408,
0.0118410364,
0.0826104507,
0.0405175462,
0.0113551067,
0.0364314541,
-0.0396593101,
0.000712293,
0.0101514691,
-0.0005667262,
-0.0385138728,
-0.0267641917,
0.0015678125,
-0.0016238271,
-0.031412743,
-0.0101890396,
-0.0033933886,
-0.0976671204,
0.0308564994,
-0.0036072521,
-0.0305062514,
-0.0563010871,
-0.0483038537,
-0.0103081912,
-0.0203313883,
-0.0241774432,
0.009794727,
0.0262003951,
0.0244410355,
-0.0074586296,
0.0063421903,
-0.0385376178,
0.0585485473,
-0.0191730969,
0.0642534494,
0.0578751676,
0.0209140684,
-0.0116308611,
-0.0361993983,
0.0107858824,
0.0034098013,
0.0016731881,
0.0097684879,
0.0216094423,
0.0091289449,
0.0079038469,
-0.0397149548,
0.0325477459,
0.0082878117,
-0.0492487736,
-0.0034448628,
0.0971411243,
-0.0253998805,
-0.0565092489,
-0.0087416377,
0.0123472009,
-0.0212635137,
0.1380358934,
0.0364112183,
-0.0077677746,
-0.0552476645,
-0.0492521152,
-0.0339351818,
-0.0460345708,
-0.036061503,
0.0123669719,
0.0477465168,
-0.0116437953,
-0.044643376,
-0.0494468138,
0.0064132023,
-0.0106122829,
-0.0250728093,
-0.0169367343,
0.0146822454,
0.008923999,
0.0054115774,
0.028467508,
-0.0317849964,
0.0202575959,
-0.0002545278,
-0.0118213436,
0.0155879417,
-0.0446592905,
-0.0197484288,
-0.0269519594,
-0.02444553,
-0.0452951193,
-0.0112795765,
0.0344475694,
0.0350452252,
0.0430144593,
0.0014470528,
-0.0241443943,
-0.0009807238,
0.0151741812,
-0.0457045846,
0.0074527557,
0.0690381378,
0.0158423074,
-0.0043491535,
0.0463142768,
-0.0303071532,
0.026600264,
0.0028720149,
0.0476591624,
0.0008274121,
-0.0085480185,
0.0518507548,
0.0005566748,
0.0276570693,
-0.016679531,
-0.0020304141,
-0.0127404202,
-0.0012781515,
-0.0263075605,
-0.0189454351,
-0.0121307001,
-0.0163835958,
0.0029794222,
-0.0063646263,
-0.0093582235,
-0.0792653039,
-0.0359582454,
0.0157335345,
0.0130785769,
-0.0133327143,
0.0058684833,
-0.0033754187,
-0.0233403295,
0.0018803924,
-0.0383798778,
0.0060995133,
-0.0460543074,
0.0371740498,
0.0152507294,
0.0682550967,
0.0319621526,
0.0103348801,
-0.0300520305,
-0.0140021965,
-0.0872578621,
-0.0285392199,
0.0264620632,
0.0309894811,
0.0356248021,
-0.015121012,
0.0201023463,
-0.0438800082,
-0.0159715116,
0.0138037615,
0.0213029664,
0.027913861,
-0.0045514875,
0.0529393442,
0.0279458016,
-0.0277179871,
-0.0147204949,
0.0408531055,
-0.0178144891,
0.0564508215,
-0.0288574398,
-0.0242106952,
-0.0028072563,
-0.0566522703,
-0.0209770463,
0.013635884,
-0.0075000138,
0.0108871097,
-0.1093875244,
-0.0789531618,
-0.0538099669,
0.0585874617,
-0.0031421022,
-0.0489964113,
-0.0160638634,
0.0430145562,
-0.0056384695,
-0.055249922,
-0.0219363272,
0.0238377731,
-0.0161724985,
0.0549846701,
-0.0731154755,
-6.39984675e-33,
-0.0292685833,
-0.0645006001,
0.0150930882,
-0.0556998104,
0.0240082704,
-0.0284577757,
-0.0299194753,
-0.0111571308,
-0.056047067,
0.0502263717,
0.018881632,
0.0036801924,
0.0073977285,
-0.0071998411,
0.0144331176,
-0.0340443626,
0.0272742808,
0.0075341146,
-0.0386296585,
0.0100772372,
0.0216664206,
-0.0475307219,
0.0317483209,
-0.0554164276,
0.0742304698,
-0.0008127491,
-0.0344329178,
0.0372572653,
-0.0980706513,
0.0388757586,
-0.0287929513,
0.0133001981,
0.0302958526,
-0.0600379147,
0.0204696022,
-0.0087706735,
-0.0205456149,
-0.038311258,
0.098475337,
-0.0300758258,
-0.0356551558,
-0.0212244038,
0.0486931838,
0.0013577986,
-0.0158213116,
0.0022857846,
0.0167276282,
-0.0219089258,
0.0399513021,
0.0415924489,
-0.0919776112,
0.0007728683,
-0.0116305538,
-0.0116297752,
-0.0287657753,
0.0820848867,
-0.011168723,
0.0198159423,
-0.0384783708,
0.0231913384,
0.052183006,
-0.0247878134,
0.0804529339,
-0.0055811559,
0.0140297385,
0.0660352334,
0.0196765885,
0.0069419639,
-0.0894841552,
-0.0153262978,
-0.018450724,
0.0580204129,
0.0984110534,
0.0683872253,
0.0637180805,
0.0226665046,
-0.0444955714,
0.0081564672,
-0.0344363563,
0.023940729,
0.0470539592,
0.0151010826,
-0.0248327982,
0.0007583394,
-0.0518015288,
0.0035512045,
-0.0228878185,
-0.0377168991,
0.0225486513,
-0.0180152338,
-0.0382759161,
0.002950765,
-0.0054068882,
-0.0426231511,
0.013970172,
-0.0050699739,
-0.0022472825,
-0.0056886836,
0.022564156,
0.0186393932,
-0.0252393093,
-0.0192010235,
0.0043631326,
-0.0011023487,
0.0388278514,
0.0111376448,
0.0262374077,
-0.0031366928,
-0.0018724216,
0.0162080992,
-0.0586107634,
-0.006893002,
-0.0066277902,
-0.0446048677,
0.0563720874,
0.0126117514,
-0.0323876888,
-0.0123232584,
0.0006953367,
-0.0310986768,
-0.0334132388,
0.0430658571,
-0.0576254614,
0.0366861969,
-0.0095865326,
-0.0014366325,
-0.0162809324,
-0.0049946764,
0.0082281819,
-0.0361243151,
-0.0270684008,
0.0102290176,
2.659e-7,
0.0248772036,
0.001134754,
0.016945608,
0.0284171179,
0.0400836356,
0.0910995826,
-0.0234862845,
-0.0076364265,
0.0159539748,
-0.0350683965,
0.0177559219,
0.0442790948,
0.0151884947,
0.0147835445,
0.0272721425,
0.0101964353,
-0.0548899136,
-0.0410096757,
-0.0063711484,
0.0163852964,
0.0704554766,
0.0296998713,
0.0523206033,
0.0152478833,
0.0011228179,
0.0077984626,
0.0404249914,
-0.0506511517,
0.0125933848,
-0.0306939185,
0.010012581,
-0.0095961131,
0.0171877798,
0.0289117265,
0.0216872152,
-0.0112313395,
-0.035981968,
0.0569040179,
-0.0423722193,
-0.041515626,
-0.0844869316,
-0.0442856364,
0.0193420444,
-0.1012712568,
0.0873066783,
-0.059440393,
-0.0469052382,
-0.0204612091,
0.0005847947,
-0.0023566426,
-0.0132127153,
-0.003139931,
-0.0152289923,
0.0043878243,
-0.0183792356,
0.0263158847,
0.0394823924,
-0.0694771186,
-0.039119184,
0.0403675325,
-0.0391791165,
-0.018967174,
-0.0396928191,
0.0298412107,
0.0539640374,
-0.0700781047,
-0.0384285972,
2.030206395e-34,
0.025879018,
0.035752926,
0.01908678,
-0.0122891786,
0.0347134918,
0.0355422758,
-0.018498145,
0.0080525503,
0.0678875297,
-0.0083455276,
-0.0338902697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08655v1 | Multilingual Speech-to-Speech Translation into Multiple Target Languages | 2023-07-17T17:12:44 | 2023-07-17T17:12:44 | Hongyu Gong, Ning Dong, Sravya Popuri, Vedanuj Goswami, Ann Lee, Juan Pino | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) enables spoken communication between
people talking in different languages. Despite a few studies on multilingual
S2ST, their focus is the multilinguality on the source side, i.e., the
translation from multiple source languages to one target language. We present
the first work on multilingual S2ST supporting multiple target languages.
Leveraging recent advance in direct S2ST with speech-to-unit and vocoder, we
equip these key components with multilingual capability. Speech-to-masked-unit
(S2MU) is the multilingual extension of S2U, which applies masking to units
which don't belong to the given target language to reduce the language
interference. We also propose multilingual vocoder which is trained with
language embedding and the auxiliary loss of language identification. On
benchmark translation testsets, our proposed multilingual model shows superior
performance than bilingual models in the translation from English into $16$
target languages. | [
-0.0126517471,
0.0272220634,
-0.0036431346,
0.0431340113,
-0.0073249466,
-0.0217876695,
0.0722988769,
0.0026682713,
-0.0510411114,
0.0113648139,
-0.0756155178,
-0.064530842,
0.0332115628,
0.0005431609,
0.0490304232,
-0.0468547717,
0.0435597375,
-0.0432508513,
-0.0562630668,
0.0050098081,
0.0025883312,
0.0268577002,
0.0255783666,
-0.0005604543,
-0.01970255,
0.038721323,
0.0056110825,
0.0186498873,
0.0496228375,
-0.0212291945,
-0.0079224901,
-0.0333263427,
0.0671552867,
0.0677588508,
0.0000019837,
-0.0186831802,
-0.0280532632,
0.0098647065,
-0.0261564814,
-0.023553744,
0.0365992039,
-0.0721721351,
0.0038555183,
0.0535075106,
0.0047935429,
-0.0206217859,
0.062231686,
0.0186980944,
0.0392695852,
0.0561842471,
-0.0342956595,
-0.0452410243,
-0.0328144543,
-0.0659020543,
-0.0479266159,
-0.0285436604,
-0.0398782827,
-0.0418287963,
-0.0465968922,
-0.0041306978,
-0.0363684483,
0.067644991,
-0.0027913519,
0.010466381,
-0.0306060556,
-0.008396796,
-0.0069195987,
-0.0507323481,
-0.0225007515,
0.0633693263,
-0.0549366958,
0.0241805688,
0.0078596352,
0.0219807439,
-0.032489039,
-0.0264846757,
-0.0216997769,
-0.0090699578,
0.0433820784,
-0.0181441642,
-0.0170742963,
0.0845113248,
0.0513748303,
-0.0613360368,
-0.0370160826,
-0.0021768936,
0.0213579908,
-0.0264682099,
0.0239276532,
-0.0101207569,
0.0069596819,
0.003238763,
0.0759181529,
-0.004145429,
-0.0488149114,
0.0253388789,
-0.0575143285,
-0.1029790416,
-0.0422138721,
-0.0537260137,
0.0365813896,
0.0494882949,
-0.0417673625,
0.0301622935,
-0.0164393242,
0.02972796,
-0.0202571489,
0.004834014,
-0.0567776114,
-0.0553691201,
0.0353557579,
0.0350676663,
-0.0379245356,
-0.0031149141,
-0.0409381837,
-0.0184247289,
0.0421355478,
-0.0248674266,
-0.0265289769,
0.0533305109,
-0.003577207,
-0.0338629186,
-0.077612482,
-0.0204877462,
0.0453549214,
0.0469239466,
-0.0147811882,
-0.0075293067,
-0.0178411119,
-0.057752233,
-0.0323518515,
0.036845807,
0.0129257571,
-0.0318125933,
0.0050063492,
0.0866736099,
-0.0348825604,
0.020069737,
0.0101825409,
-0.0069341632,
0.0071016555,
-0.0495133959,
0.0201323442,
-0.0487612188,
0.0853698775,
0.0029146532,
0.0295706242,
-0.0141824773,
0.0187547877,
-0.0496204384,
0.0158445276,
0.0841051638,
0.0194640215,
0.00842747,
0.0607020259,
0.0085657565,
-0.013493225,
0.0537377894,
0.0112782521,
-0.0254650563,
0.0391270481,
-0.0071539264,
-0.0471479185,
0.0761667937,
0.0333210379,
0.0318278894,
0.014750503,
-0.029848963,
0.0357812569,
0.0126325898,
0.0155779161,
0.0507887267,
-0.02466763,
-0.0213501491,
0.0313288532,
0.0141145363,
0.0329137407,
0.0457649976,
0.0487780906,
0.0314514264,
-0.0415401608,
0.0024274166,
0.0232369844,
0.0132353473,
0.0146553628,
-0.0349523984,
0.0369997956,
0.0342538245,
-0.0441129245,
0.0054094829,
0.0201518349,
-0.0463693999,
0.0290379636,
0.0050556366,
0.031362392,
0.0107397232,
-0.0534767434,
0.066384837,
-0.0219837055,
-0.0426460467,
0.0725822151,
0.0377237387,
-0.0445420966,
0.0110010793,
-0.0076471902,
0.0350014791,
0.0121274814,
-0.0536493734,
-0.0091162939,
0.028557336,
0.050995063,
-0.0060551148,
0.1080676988,
-0.0564776659,
0.0052828128,
-0.0023183725,
-0.03262816,
0.0529684834,
-0.0299369097,
0.0419487096,
0.0141993286,
-0.0053138062,
0.0387056097,
-0.0224536732,
-0.027658334,
0.0335953161,
0.0435661077,
0.0053982642,
0.0242753606,
0.0387356207,
-0.023108013,
0.001332473,
-0.0023824263,
-0.063882567,
-0.0158413425,
0.0570166074,
-0.0365899503,
-0.0443765335,
0.0110588577,
-0.0264854152,
0.0171195958,
0.0598527528,
-0.0165630355,
-0.087234661,
0.0270661861,
-0.0145688634,
-0.0064668041,
0.0014381137,
-0.0120131848,
0.0183882099,
0.049965959,
0.039971415,
-0.0253397599,
0.0244268216,
-0.0105103906,
0.0251325238,
0.0084745008,
0.0424385555,
-0.045699466,
-0.0246471781,
0.0536655523,
0.0064659198,
0.0126766097,
-0.003722728,
0.0137878843,
0.019738337,
-0.0093413638,
-0.0778833106,
0.0088373581,
-0.0238365289,
0.0245013013,
-0.0236007385,
0.0336639062,
0.0237399861,
-0.0173318163,
-0.0483567789,
-0.0609028116,
0.0135604003,
-0.0174032524,
-0.0319961272,
0.0155560048,
0.0051510399,
-0.0005813197,
-0.0137551269,
0.0578781106,
0.0055186511,
-0.0241778791,
-0.076743573,
-0.0558151715,
0.0216519665,
0.0068962211,
0.0272149984,
-0.0179494675,
-0.0147163281,
-0.0379481204,
0.0399449281,
0.055443909,
0.0337168314,
-0.0496408865,
0.0063127284,
0.0265072249,
-0.0137877697,
-0.0390219688,
0.0210920926,
0.0086380234,
-0.0104079787,
-0.0330179036,
-0.0009635899,
0.0210285541,
0.0153357312,
0.0193163678,
0.002585331,
-0.0526366867,
-0.0533501394,
0.0027207623,
-0.0419921502,
-0.0484862253,
0.0092852525,
0.0062692757,
0.0221880414,
-0.006898344,
0.0115529941,
0.0124470964,
-0.0743570402,
-0.0404893309,
-0.0507250652,
-0.0219193026,
-0.0244425703,
-0.0078139585,
-0.0123011991,
0.0452682041,
-0.0649586916,
-0.0240919236,
-0.0411249287,
0.0564147159,
0.0028747485,
-0.0231611896,
0.0197787005,
-0.0419450998,
-0.0182107259,
-0.0329097174,
-0.0486933626,
0.0055960664,
0.0455440283,
0.0008600702,
0.0190613065,
0.0220721569,
-0.0427929498,
-0.0361901559,
0.0068462975,
0.0437745936,
0.0579190254,
0.0252588838,
0.0431272797,
-0.0102535291,
0.0355664939,
0.0046274452,
0.0091155516,
-0.0013396847,
-0.0773713663,
0.0377363972,
-0.0125869615,
0.0464253277,
0.0002620792,
-0.0105808675,
-0.010867266,
0.0464103594,
0.0547988228,
-0.0690423176,
-0.0246601384,
0.0435085185,
-0.0199025329,
0.0066029937,
0.0863366723,
-0.0263692625,
-0.0212346613,
-0.0153385364,
-0.0486162864,
0.0165823027,
0.0104998089,
0.0044358075,
-0.0723779351,
-0.0142249651,
0.0163906664,
-0.0096051926,
0.03971209,
0.0382340029,
-0.028977124,
-0.0897443816,
0.0038818445,
0.068433024,
-0.0478638932,
-0.0444646068,
0.0121818548,
-0.0518357009,
-0.0128536532,
0.0289699566,
-0.0436685681,
0.0429478325,
-0.0553562865,
0.0176068246,
0.0131054539,
-0.0394349508,
0.0238002352,
-0.0145749589,
0.0625937805,
0.039532166,
0.0320499502,
-0.0190523267,
-0.0133874323,
0.0346401557,
0.0186510254,
-0.0211655591,
-0.005452035,
-0.0049596545,
-0.0150036532,
-0.0120821735,
0.0591043383,
0.0298299398,
0.0243407283,
0.0286163054,
0.0217674598,
0.0356214978,
0.0155181279,
0.001122599,
0.0229426678,
-0.0018561151,
0.0025800751,
0.0370730758,
-0.0091544157,
-0.04955763,
0.0027345091,
-0.0046899789,
0.0199108906,
-0.0353104956,
-0.0021970139,
0.0164238587,
-0.0147650372,
-0.0656552464,
-0.0295126066,
-0.0099987527,
0.0237089116,
0.0214973111,
0.0290607698,
0.015352672,
-0.0053425217,
0.0114576193,
0.0079554729,
-0.0096599562,
-0.0345206596,
0.0630590692,
-0.036409799,
0.0160782002,
-0.0124536771,
-0.0392100364,
0.0000712929,
0.0328132957,
-0.0855727717,
-0.0547095872,
-0.0418253019,
0.0337663069,
0.010815965,
0.0699409544,
-0.0347970612,
-0.032025516,
0.0009803517,
-0.0747880638,
-0.0106211808,
0.0124414517,
0.0779892728,
0.0204720851,
-0.0195983034,
0.0452196486,
-0.0306581166,
0.027249299,
-0.0258740876,
0.0176241975,
-0.0174576845,
-0.0341166556,
-0.0268686581,
0.0138212377,
0.0302628577,
-0.0146460012,
0.0341455564,
-0.0158854201,
0.0323495902,
-0.0347814374,
0.0086811157,
-0.0577771813,
0.0016173505,
0.0569724217,
0.0038502053,
0.0218325574,
-0.0022016694,
0.0565901212,
-0.0491204523,
0.0576224551,
0.0051152604,
0.0228844956,
0.0271862186,
0.0303873885,
0.0265907664,
-0.0157111287,
0.0308692139,
0.0274547655,
0.0043616146,
-0.0192285776,
0.0177006423,
-0.0038758288,
-0.0008360968,
0.0452401526,
0.0153809162,
0.0232195314,
-0.0244165082,
-0.0094899731,
-0.0367542021,
0.0094669834,
0.0237232689,
0.1132300273,
0.0143190874,
0.0189859681,
-0.0133359572,
0.0545756184,
-0.0410118327,
-0.0509344451,
0.0226222426,
-0.044931151,
-0.0067293448,
0.0584360659,
0.0289559774,
0.0091463523,
-0.0178238265,
-0.0288837999,
0.0241994672,
-0.0013339155,
-0.0118529797,
0.0106154755,
0.0185125098,
-0.0205810796,
-0.0179273132,
-0.0206373651,
-0.0552023388,
0.0083422642,
-0.0220222883,
0.0164916739,
-0.0183163341,
0.0070128618,
0.0370563902,
-0.0391949788,
0.0134605849,
-0.0159044191,
-0.0390671194,
0.04037809,
-0.0129158264,
0.0239214078,
-6.091475643e-33,
-0.0355004445,
-0.0033270726,
-0.0192869008,
-0.0217831675,
-0.0207764935,
-0.0489529297,
-0.0482262969,
-0.0092445379,
-0.0442245007,
-0.0265132841,
0.005257661,
0.025967814,
0.0237576142,
0.036064472,
-0.0059665116,
0.0086999424,
0.080569379,
0.0112070628,
0.0018114889,
0.0341409072,
0.0333279446,
0.0299130008,
0.0680566356,
-0.0824771747,
0.0081384648,
0.0073002726,
-0.0213808976,
0.01425613,
-0.0107360333,
-0.0100071598,
0.0065949345,
0.0428941064,
-0.0275225099,
-0.0530051216,
-0.0319663063,
0.0173551086,
-0.0579013862,
-0.0098965941,
-0.0082050441,
0.0439916998,
-0.0328924097,
-0.0301651359,
0.0047820043,
-0.0219429713,
0.021779675,
-0.0429599285,
-0.0064882305,
-0.0152175538,
0.0062176096,
-0.0202674586,
-0.0285054743,
0.0236954112,
-0.0004142077,
-0.0022438962,
0.0842309669,
0.1025642157,
0.0006995247,
-0.0704212785,
-0.0816424042,
0.0074619986,
-0.0439421535,
0.0181708299,
0.0708112866,
0.0213104226,
-0.0452276953,
-0.0083861379,
0.0408997685,
-0.0393751375,
0.0481493808,
0.018378498,
0.0277723707,
0.0219028518,
0.0592463575,
0.0277606063,
-0.003044826,
-0.0501873344,
-0.0383653119,
0.0044148904,
-0.0106797684,
-0.0396126732,
0.0151721351,
0.0316348076,
0.0039110612,
-0.0111956419,
-0.0673260912,
-0.0368826315,
0.0019001464,
-0.0458334535,
0.0372248478,
0.0151307704,
0.0226171203,
0.003819233,
0.102018103,
-0.0028008802,
-0.00284935,
-0.0195167195,
-0.0099793803,
0.024680946,
-0.045874957,
0.0577437021,
-0.0505664013,
-0.0536048524,
0.0326683484,
0.0015081459,
0.0232844055,
-0.0334096849,
0.0197925363,
0.0498293489,
-0.0420453064,
-0.014623574,
-0.020063011,
0.0199439283,
-0.0069322218,
0.0576241091,
0.0237764101,
-0.001560087,
-0.0239327867,
0.0276486408,
-0.0054490273,
-0.0272543598,
-0.0320905894,
-0.0036185815,
0.0102289272,
0.010223113,
-0.0586655997,
0.030197598,
-0.0342980921,
-0.0287388489,
0.0882581845,
-0.0144615676,
-0.0336306877,
-0.0279802699,
2.768e-7,
-0.0063988157,
-0.0139514646,
-0.0188610461,
-0.0158551857,
0.014588627,
0.0526262708,
-0.0447406471,
0.0619565696,
-0.0334422849,
0.0319908932,
-0.0178122241,
-0.0132152187,
0.0976137817,
0.0393386558,
-0.0618495457,
-0.0450931564,
-0.0218066946,
0.0290190317,
-0.0287938081,
-0.0032116636,
-0.0075964252,
0.0965750813,
-0.0041721985,
0.0109221106,
-0.0105308527,
0.0101474058,
0.0642236248,
-0.0285743922,
-0.0160773881,
-0.0149292918,
-0.0130540719,
0.0267840736,
-0.065582037,
-0.0071360306,
-0.0487276129,
0.0670782328,
0.0808741823,
0.0856776237,
0.0029363867,
-0.034673702,
-0.0003505136,
0.0323824696,
-0.0768143833,
0.0105718626,
0.0350140706,
0.0101657482,
-0.0272676367,
0.0152200572,
0.0256854445,
0.0504784547,
0.007897147,
-0.0163256265,
-0.0573608764,
0.0083994297,
0.0377088413,
0.0084388526,
-0.0077500124,
-0.0402534977,
-0.0334495232,
-0.0294066668,
-0.0333753005,
-0.01972536,
-0.0134740174,
-0.0000794015,
-0.0216500517,
-0.0032337406,
-0.012041484,
2.048524822e-34,
0.0360684581,
-0.0334723182,
0.0078726057,
-0.0037333374,
0.0286092162,
-0.0714672208,
-0.0405140184,
0.0376597941,
0.0030001253,
0.0007384226,
-0.0591296256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08621v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08621v4 | Retentive Network: A Successor to Transformer for Large Language Models | 2023-07-17T16:40:01 | 2023-08-09T08:53:08 | Yutao Sun, Li Dong, Shaohan Huang, Shuming Ma, Yuqing Xia, Jilong Xue, Jianyong Wang, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work, we propose Retentive Network (RetNet) as a foundation
architecture for large language models, simultaneously achieving training
parallelism, low-cost inference, and good performance. We theoretically derive
the connection between recurrence and attention. Then we propose the retention
mechanism for sequence modeling, which supports three computation paradigms,
i.e., parallel, recurrent, and chunkwise recurrent. Specifically, the parallel
representation allows for training parallelism. The recurrent representation
enables low-cost $O(1)$ inference, which improves decoding throughput, latency,
and GPU memory without sacrificing performance. The chunkwise recurrent
representation facilitates efficient long-sequence modeling with linear
complexity, where each chunk is encoded parallelly while recurrently
summarizing the chunks. Experimental results on language modeling show that
RetNet achieves favorable scaling results, parallel training, low-cost
deployment, and efficient inference. The intriguing properties make RetNet a
strong successor to Transformer for large language models. Code will be
available at https://aka.ms/retnet. | [
-0.0003737345,
0.0507986248,
0.0064771324,
0.0400856063,
-0.0191023052,
0.0094295442,
-0.0161251239,
-0.0492990054,
-0.0438173339,
-0.0362446755,
0.0221940707,
-0.0437156409,
0.0354248285,
0.0319708921,
-0.0030829899,
-0.0627672076,
0.016575519,
-0.0208102874,
0.0208997484,
-0.0009250057,
0.023619961,
0.0191047825,
0.0044732983,
0.0182445198,
0.0342262201,
-0.0081362724,
-0.0190204587,
-0.0214755014,
-0.0236902945,
-0.0495263636,
0.0045394585,
0.0259996951,
0.0484614149,
0.0646807775,
0.0000020406,
-0.022698991,
-0.0197267681,
-0.029192498,
0.0023007074,
0.0260417964,
0.028366005,
-0.0383633748,
-0.0116084693,
0.0120950537,
-0.0167288184,
-0.0288988445,
0.0602726415,
0.0245932564,
0.0341359004,
0.0659965426,
0.000932203,
-0.0711596981,
0.039078705,
-0.0747758448,
-0.0159174502,
-0.0193295181,
0.0020127019,
0.0009381822,
-0.0210401434,
-0.0125104198,
-0.051209081,
0.0419055857,
0.0603923686,
0.0232283324,
-0.0143327657,
0.0461165607,
0.0166801289,
-0.0097250557,
-0.0241013933,
0.0276135225,
-0.0698251203,
-0.0339504927,
-0.0074127708,
0.0104812384,
-0.0229969155,
0.0014904053,
-0.0595275313,
0.0685634166,
-0.0034702215,
0.0342898294,
0.0183261167,
0.009597728,
0.0433660708,
0.0047393828,
-0.0670209005,
-0.0054312567,
0.0190444607,
0.0211467594,
-0.0631293133,
0.017284425,
-0.0063115559,
-0.0618084669,
0.0130881509,
0.0534829609,
0.0070871431,
0.0222586878,
-0.0362077132,
-0.0510524996,
0.0023144665,
-0.0393397138,
0.0248815026,
0.0501194932,
0.0070165107,
0.0223524459,
-0.0454427712,
0.0597330779,
-0.0341449119,
-0.022969,
-0.0351613685,
0.0021309913,
-0.0157609358,
0.0078429468,
-0.0408352725,
0.031427823,
-0.0110595664,
-0.02019554,
-0.0356545523,
0.0274241548,
0.0157202948,
-0.0273839608,
0.0045358716,
0.00930769,
-0.0425985344,
-0.0032105038,
0.003448104,
0.0671686381,
-0.0249573719,
-0.0149299931,
0.0179315843,
-0.0703736916,
-0.0303647332,
0.0094991503,
0.014655753,
-0.0187122189,
-0.0224423558,
0.0323188268,
0.002032175,
-0.0441615991,
-0.0366176814,
-0.0272823256,
-0.0196058694,
-0.0612598769,
0.0142854173,
-0.0905179605,
0.0487394035,
-0.0142975906,
-0.016274292,
-0.0301747695,
0.0227937493,
0.0421441942,
-0.0225525014,
0.0389714353,
0.0081435675,
-0.0262220241,
0.0126604475,
0.0199138261,
0.0429913998,
0.0447888486,
0.0607894436,
0.051445391,
0.0114264991,
-0.0154944574,
0.0029871066,
0.0296236686,
0.0296640843,
-0.005620142,
-0.0383630469,
-0.008258895,
0.0042728116,
0.0334339105,
0.0492387637,
0.0622785725,
-0.0224039499,
-0.0368845612,
0.0528029539,
0.0380356088,
0.0201558713,
0.0597021468,
0.0402383283,
0.0133019229,
-0.0354577228,
0.0261574145,
-0.0385706872,
0.0804785714,
0.021761382,
0.0476005711,
0.0386192687,
0.0483998619,
-0.0322739817,
-0.011225177,
0.0016603441,
-0.0220124051,
0.0084274253,
-0.0146115115,
0.0751588941,
0.0292907953,
-0.0706366822,
0.0501375198,
0.0219242796,
-0.05462813,
-0.0321294367,
-0.0242457576,
0.0344185084,
0.0496461317,
0.0440235995,
-0.004408028,
-0.0274654441,
-0.0188693292,
-0.012024289,
0.015503088,
0.0284514017,
0.0191515591,
-0.0153920334,
-0.0838146806,
-0.0043004341,
0.0259041265,
-0.0117042474,
0.0501203611,
0.0339217484,
0.0248401817,
0.0288862046,
0.0160549935,
-0.0167859737,
0.0239059329,
-0.0237604193,
-0.0157654714,
0.000662063,
-0.0089358604,
0.0414730385,
-0.0008767936,
0.0043940111,
0.0242582448,
0.0584773012,
-0.0532313772,
0.0020206762,
0.0053081652,
-0.0948182344,
-0.0533206724,
0.0375958011,
-0.0187963247,
0.0201373696,
0.0455725789,
-0.0392782241,
-0.0550163239,
0.0699289516,
-0.0812623054,
0.0673931539,
-0.0412402786,
-0.0020956793,
0.020103246,
0.0647505224,
0.0010283524,
0.0461848862,
-0.0453230478,
0.0092615327,
0.0116927279,
-0.0111408578,
-0.0202622563,
-0.0340142474,
-0.0425888635,
0.0269406699,
-0.0145722022,
-0.0008194528,
0.0158879794,
-0.0291501395,
0.0221791398,
-0.0102266232,
-0.0517555028,
0.0162597671,
-0.0314766951,
0.0402114652,
0.0016245357,
0.0447318964,
0.0320851542,
-0.0150087876,
-0.0252149869,
-0.0086309686,
-0.0094251186,
0.0256485622,
0.0158222504,
-0.0292565878,
-0.0443612859,
-0.0162125211,
-0.0618007258,
0.0050671697,
0.0673624724,
-0.0103051169,
-0.0437765196,
-0.0198300481,
-0.0165962074,
-0.0121751269,
0.0374607705,
-0.0177686326,
-0.033386182,
-0.0227686428,
-0.0254086796,
0.07127361,
0.0421124883,
0.020322144,
0.0216847453,
0.0304204617,
-0.0184642561,
-0.0184281096,
0.0094553744,
-0.0404557921,
-0.002510584,
0.0116595067,
-0.0500706993,
-0.0154938595,
0.1007299721,
-0.0203483161,
-0.0055261767,
-0.0417841449,
-0.0319461226,
0.004258879,
0.0120727457,
-0.018119853,
-0.0024500573,
-0.022396924,
0.0051627224,
-0.023191331,
-0.0575267375,
0.0485189967,
-0.0538617261,
-0.0045625945,
-0.0385418758,
0.0003826382,
-0.0402866565,
0.0739378259,
0.0337676071,
0.0018088209,
-0.0159500577,
-0.0242250394,
-0.0031551258,
0.0234496836,
-0.0066780723,
-0.0341165885,
0.0537661463,
-0.0296143163,
0.0036530881,
-0.0501212217,
0.0219410583,
-0.0136705143,
0.0074821576,
-0.0414983407,
0.012560362,
0.0170432776,
-0.0251185708,
-0.0453465879,
0.0385146514,
0.03340571,
0.0725962371,
-0.0168806463,
0.0286054779,
-0.0057810973,
0.0550364219,
0.0431245752,
0.013170775,
0.030295901,
-0.0421373323,
0.010386711,
0.0684410483,
0.0256670602,
0.0146589708,
-0.073111631,
-0.0106807509,
0.0157768428,
-0.0156584345,
0.0048247315,
0.0493891314,
0.0126687791,
-0.1044485196,
-0.0075327232,
0.1095064878,
0.0063934457,
-0.0658091828,
-0.0058694673,
0.0449862108,
0.0490659438,
0.0115243066,
0.0029185617,
-0.0706628114,
-0.0441502631,
0.0172780603,
-0.022331845,
0.0178817753,
-0.029424211,
-0.0134841381,
-0.090890944,
0.0267916024,
-0.0006205423,
-0.0591445304,
-0.0401827842,
-0.0369157307,
-0.0483909138,
0.0198188927,
-0.0227674898,
0.0384218022,
-0.0097577004,
0.0029622281,
0.0123852659,
-0.0345776789,
0.0074701137,
0.0143677425,
-0.0380899757,
0.0256854594,
0.0649796724,
0.0050821891,
-0.0072227991,
-0.0402380526,
0.0027520219,
-0.0232213605,
-0.0145944189,
0.0160221756,
0.025018163,
-0.0219327454,
0.0020529646,
-0.0158288442,
0.0274840873,
-0.0724668205,
-0.0215549059,
0.0010926573,
0.0796036944,
0.0103946635,
-0.0374581181,
-0.0413589552,
-0.0075324904,
-0.025099095,
0.0696380958,
0.0385123938,
-0.0304269455,
-0.0654256791,
-0.0206529759,
-0.0147863496,
-0.0568858311,
-0.0122169219,
-0.0114976522,
0.0181900263,
-0.0598402172,
-0.0606430173,
-0.0100521958,
0.0155136166,
-0.0206188355,
-0.0163045134,
-0.0063446974,
0.0501043461,
-0.0018520817,
-0.0955506042,
0.0071059992,
-0.0284152906,
0.0338298492,
-0.0579629019,
0.0238661543,
0.0282585211,
-0.0280758552,
-0.0055249557,
0.0262854639,
-0.1306971014,
-0.0324336663,
0.0051981714,
0.0312788896,
0.0149470996,
0.0384316631,
0.0018218914,
-0.0138835059,
0.0136730196,
0.0025963774,
-0.0450259782,
0.0184104349,
0.002546835,
0.0193911716,
0.0091759032,
0.0316229612,
-0.0096937111,
0.0170419924,
-0.0233338494,
0.0107463915,
0.0079605682,
-0.0192093384,
-0.0063775387,
-0.0319642164,
0.0181347765,
0.0026553776,
0.0198212489,
-0.0136502367,
0.0228832047,
0.0105063962,
0.0265078414,
-0.044192072,
0.0365033932,
0.0235114824,
0.0032782338,
-0.001386593,
-0.0023604771,
0.0556740724,
-0.0539009757,
-0.0141633851,
0.0287395325,
-0.0180849619,
-0.0346005112,
0.037391182,
-0.0080545368,
-0.0131439315,
-0.0246458873,
-0.0296946988,
0.0346927457,
-0.0411451831,
0.0412307419,
0.0309751444,
0.0109454347,
-0.0159192644,
0.0059240088,
-0.0533628054,
-0.0029741062,
-0.0403154939,
0.000734916,
0.0510243028,
-0.0165083557,
0.0193429012,
0.0055686194,
0.0186493695,
-0.0329199582,
0.0385947302,
-0.0186526589,
-0.0175532475,
0.0245223138,
0.0360208303,
-0.0306729544,
0.0293482859,
0.0830906779,
0.0097248247,
0.013880345,
0.0234053563,
-0.0017697889,
-0.0167815834,
-0.0369709432,
-0.0370744318,
0.0387582146,
-0.0298608635,
-0.0254422128,
-0.0095144985,
-0.0560063496,
0.017322341,
0.0113436161,
0.0187282301,
-0.0182119906,
0.0274603199,
0.0264023431,
-0.0034439322,
-0.0020430412,
-0.0179088358,
0.0510823205,
-0.0341452695,
-0.0287252795,
-0.0093420465,
-6.392636561e-33,
0.0145564843,
-0.0122725321,
0.0124468356,
-0.0165843274,
-0.046096839,
0.0073300507,
-0.0602728873,
-0.0272390954,
-0.0043135355,
0.005647548,
0.0155355548,
0.0277865436,
0.0014539928,
0.0755904242,
0.0193711519,
-0.0009094878,
0.0573492013,
0.0057950229,
0.0037917672,
0.0449831672,
0.0148615465,
0.0369865857,
0.0454305299,
-0.0047668121,
-0.0321783498,
-0.0460760966,
0.0430899821,
0.005350776,
-0.0025299729,
0.0480889603,
-0.0380128585,
0.0200133137,
0.0372045673,
-0.076868467,
-0.0449656807,
0.0459691398,
-0.0957184955,
0.0061607147,
-0.0147195142,
0.010298837,
-0.0598805472,
-0.0281484611,
0.0466011837,
0.0183526576,
0.0487625487,
-0.0462033711,
0.0152287008,
-0.0062711155,
-0.0633385926,
-0.0028747995,
-0.0408548713,
0.0353417769,
0.0016039259,
-0.0206687152,
0.0634249598,
0.0042798747,
-0.0175832622,
0.0483968668,
-0.0513255559,
-0.0142230811,
0.0040932819,
0.0872056037,
0.0506372936,
0.0201778021,
0.0139853777,
0.0272828378,
0.0281243734,
-0.0324435942,
-0.0479561351,
0.0338165648,
0.0166500807,
0.0130095519,
0.0406986326,
-0.0134955188,
0.0642926916,
-0.0172966048,
-0.0697412938,
-0.0338840857,
0.0120739574,
0.0728877559,
0.0640317127,
0.0328004397,
-0.0016798887,
-0.025385825,
-0.006053959,
-0.006084173,
-0.033261843,
0.0078108362,
0.0220040027,
0.0331116617,
0.0099005783,
0.0183460936,
0.0404060632,
-0.0319373533,
0.0422287695,
0.0115165291,
0.009099694,
0.0078895129,
-0.0054220487,
0.032400392,
-0.0577709973,
0.0228071623,
-0.0154816015,
-0.0117498366,
-0.0207562931,
0.0085242763,
0.044902049,
0.0330416709,
-0.0625046343,
-0.0205033161,
-0.0615952685,
0.0217361618,
-0.0040743286,
0.0891895369,
0.04839468,
0.0121527761,
-0.0136512965,
0.0610986985,
-0.0101508247,
-0.0099856239,
-0.0235425979,
0.016973123,
0.0251481887,
0.0108560175,
-0.0376007743,
-0.0095897578,
-0.0524447113,
0.0420189388,
0.0318460539,
-0.0555700734,
-0.0364309698,
0.075268507,
2.676e-7,
0.0071975049,
0.030517716,
0.0793125778,
-0.0077234968,
0.0544865839,
0.0090619419,
0.0195870567,
0.0443203896,
0.0148309451,
-0.0087469518,
0.0078179762,
0.0129347574,
0.0650921538,
-0.0040401798,
-0.1103964671,
-0.0117012542,
-0.1104661599,
0.0066225925,
-0.0023298138,
-0.037366569,
0.0200572796,
0.125308603,
0.011565472,
0.0117218746,
0.0427233689,
0.0154449502,
0.0365614481,
-0.0025894949,
0.028329825,
-0.0086393291,
-0.0110482927,
0.0453356653,
-0.0503908992,
-0.041787874,
-0.0059098657,
0.0258867517,
-0.0125296032,
0.060465876,
0.012985629,
-0.013716734,
0.0343401283,
-0.0294869058,
-0.0357611701,
-0.0258357488,
0.0390221924,
-0.0553745069,
-0.0211480893,
-0.0291359425,
-0.0034874137,
0.0147471633,
-0.0116215106,
0.0151132466,
0.0170132555,
0.0295841582,
0.0308025535,
-0.0221478101,
-0.0253431667,
-0.1009046286,
-0.0312657394,
-0.0141788283,
-0.0633413419,
0.0142399259,
-0.0794923827,
-0.0449708663,
0.0478793271,
-0.0473601148,
-0.0133190993,
2.325022674e-34,
0.0379889086,
-0.0264731683,
-0.0146035375,
0.039290525,
0.0184153169,
-0.0433839783,
-0.0116298338,
0.0192039479,
-0.0056293006,
-0.0998966321,
-0.0562424101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08597v1 | Multimodal Diffusion Segmentation Model for Object Segmentation from Manipulation Instructions | 2023-07-17T16:07:07 | 2023-07-17T16:07:07 | Yui Iioka, Yu Yoshida, Yuiga Wada, Shumpei Hatanaka, Komei Sugiura | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.RO | In this study, we aim to develop a model that comprehends a natural language
instruction (e.g., "Go to the living room and get the nearest pillow to the
radio art on the wall") and generates a segmentation mask for the target
everyday object. The task is challenging because it requires (1) the
understanding of the referring expressions for multiple objects in the
instruction, (2) the prediction of the target phrase of the sentence among the
multiple phrases, and (3) the generation of pixel-wise segmentation masks
rather than bounding boxes. Studies have been conducted on languagebased
segmentation methods; however, they sometimes mask irrelevant regions for
complex sentences. In this paper, we propose the Multimodal Diffusion
Segmentation Model (MDSM), which generates a mask in the first stage and
refines it in the second stage. We introduce a crossmodal parallel feature
extraction mechanism and extend diffusion probabilistic models to handle
crossmodal features. To validate our model, we built a new dataset based on the
well-known Matterport3D and REVERIE datasets. This dataset consists of
instructions with complex referring expressions accompanied by real indoor
environmental images that feature various target objects, in addition to
pixel-wise segmentation masks. The performance of MDSM surpassed that of the
baseline method by a large margin of +10.13 mean IoU. | [
0.0448580571,
-0.0013997337,
0.0198545065,
0.0407390259,
-0.0549349077,
0.0080037499,
0.0518220626,
-0.0174635854,
-0.0434761904,
-0.0794390962,
-0.0097311884,
0.0073212986,
0.036323078,
-0.0225929189,
0.0108161066,
-0.0846397355,
0.0117004951,
-0.0441186093,
-0.0723143592,
-0.000629215,
0.0023414043,
0.0134650813,
-0.040279191,
-0.0059946431,
-0.0413974188,
-0.0019950124,
-0.0365109704,
0.0001061872,
0.0372751914,
-0.0437937118,
0.0023658522,
0.0077830534,
0.0507933274,
-0.0165500678,
0.0000022237,
-0.0312003195,
-0.0313204601,
0.0024754992,
0.0404299833,
-0.0666124597,
0.0713638291,
-0.0512389243,
-0.0149600664,
-0.051393386,
0.009937997,
0.0209672563,
0.0594589114,
0.0850378573,
0.0612798892,
0.0636446252,
-0.0200443473,
-0.0537447818,
0.0064048646,
0.0064127119,
0.05327769,
-0.0171702299,
0.0201915912,
0.0624883808,
-0.0084305601,
0.0029942326,
-0.0563482903,
0.0327434912,
0.0136203608,
0.0226960387,
0.0123107061,
0.0313966125,
0.023875108,
-0.069868125,
-0.0434074253,
0.0879533365,
-0.0676247627,
0.0430693142,
0.0170844141,
-0.0003605523,
-0.0137727819,
0.0145630557,
-0.0668977797,
0.0278475881,
0.0042393766,
0.0350355357,
-0.0481322519,
0.001220379,
0.0128521631,
-0.0384874716,
-0.011890389,
0.0322591141,
0.0090663293,
-0.0053024581,
0.0340643711,
-0.031712912,
-0.0102117639,
-0.0478804223,
0.0611365698,
-0.0074481484,
0.0007917271,
0.0164277088,
-0.0404828042,
-0.0354535617,
-0.0052584531,
-0.0190964788,
0.0075574717,
-0.0062568411,
-0.0185224358,
0.0983559862,
-0.0468328595,
0.0130889546,
-0.0350510105,
0.0351462662,
-0.0596508831,
0.0137101272,
-0.0478702635,
0.0277280249,
-0.0123548685,
0.004739603,
-0.0533927567,
-0.0405560285,
-0.0286756717,
-0.0257585645,
-0.0201565512,
0.0009614805,
0.0433735773,
0.0074963444,
-0.0252825245,
-0.0035734174,
0.0057341615,
-0.0214733947,
-0.0399016887,
0.0098594194,
-0.0147966333,
-0.011409577,
-0.0099118436,
0.0317287631,
0.0265891198,
-0.028885901,
0.0014923757,
0.0509317368,
-0.0591670386,
-0.0305650998,
-0.019750854,
-0.045278389,
-0.0158787668,
-0.018596705,
0.1217171997,
-0.0438529812,
0.00993683,
-0.0403846018,
0.0410546064,
0.0030740509,
-0.0031624211,
-0.0001022768,
0.0035330523,
0.0733922794,
0.0106021976,
0.0169678163,
0.0462896116,
0.0308024716,
0.0168613233,
0.0239839461,
0.0420770608,
0.0321673378,
0.0461115465,
0.0063317548,
0.0273517631,
0.057453651,
-0.0347055122,
-0.0109861642,
-0.0220809057,
-0.029889008,
0.003234324,
0.0133900596,
0.0432000309,
0.034320537,
-0.019310981,
-0.0306106918,
0.0387986153,
0.0323662981,
-0.0769773647,
-0.0125485947,
0.0320140794,
0.0468737595,
-0.0643799156,
0.0086805271,
0.0004525053,
0.0171588864,
0.019452123,
0.0007810458,
0.029995868,
0.0089440448,
-0.0111071663,
-0.0255235806,
0.0164587405,
-0.0364595614,
0.0767790228,
-0.0302253049,
0.067454882,
0.011924712,
-0.0619588569,
0.0361512601,
-0.0187186673,
-0.0440844037,
-0.0573385544,
-0.0519118793,
0.0173513386,
0.030772673,
-0.0046387063,
-0.0367167816,
0.0070021441,
0.0223144516,
0.0698117241,
0.0204503089,
-0.0041190484,
0.0037561874,
0.0142122526,
-0.0573855825,
-0.0557332002,
-0.0256225504,
-0.0073676114,
-0.0023147159,
0.0101237847,
-0.011853613,
0.0179769564,
-0.0316865407,
0.061024677,
0.0543307289,
0.0344335549,
0.030336054,
-0.0282899011,
0.0225624014,
0.0169593729,
-0.0086430386,
0.0068739424,
-0.0488361716,
0.0120040495,
-0.0369901918,
0.0382765494,
0.0014346685,
-0.0480469242,
-0.0491067879,
0.0105337491,
-0.0535494648,
-0.0249318257,
0.0240367837,
-0.0453751162,
-0.0145968599,
0.018110944,
-0.0031410025,
0.0324610956,
-0.0010243644,
-0.0212024823,
0.0449173152,
0.0329237171,
-0.0106867133,
0.0573706999,
-0.0562944226,
-0.016929239,
-0.0123339556,
0.0012699878,
-0.0058920109,
-0.0071155699,
-0.0057451427,
-0.0408813283,
-0.0298362765,
-0.0230181012,
0.0094916197,
0.0097923996,
-0.0665887818,
0.0137667861,
-0.067231901,
-0.0304226819,
-0.0410923958,
-0.0115069905,
0.0182929821,
-0.0007797953,
-0.0077820374,
-0.0245046988,
0.0316543877,
0.0375773124,
-0.053352356,
-0.0001240433,
-0.0008979419,
-0.000937379,
-0.0331791565,
-0.035807468,
-0.0048984303,
0.0084016426,
0.0407199785,
0.0212281682,
-0.0468159318,
-0.0200320892,
0.0431901813,
0.0047972789,
0.0155900801,
-0.0216187332,
-0.0150711304,
0.0037910517,
-0.0263826884,
0.0601633415,
0.1132172346,
-0.0205154587,
0.0231766328,
0.0398328304,
-0.0719555989,
0.0043744924,
0.0086299367,
-0.0192418415,
0.0269987993,
-0.0216772649,
-0.0594716333,
0.0042857989,
0.0328368843,
0.0412755981,
0.0258844737,
0.0012324414,
-0.015167335,
-0.0121496264,
-0.0413682014,
-0.0216295999,
0.0297019798,
-0.0252469797,
0.0027382243,
-0.0475743972,
-0.0421793014,
0.0169131923,
-0.0504253246,
-0.0151158879,
-0.0218235981,
-0.0127011482,
0.0574566573,
0.0496015586,
0.0317831263,
0.0339613631,
0.0170697328,
-0.0145308189,
-0.0205064658,
0.010397397,
-0.003368868,
0.0380670391,
-0.0130521767,
-0.0702921897,
0.0011563402,
0.007389375,
0.0162468683,
-0.0026059893,
-0.0336271226,
-0.0020796368,
0.0090464186,
-0.0270261634,
0.0014709049,
-0.0258192588,
0.0250204504,
0.0386871919,
0.0627949685,
-0.0043377364,
-0.0117440457,
-0.0253899246,
0.0242226068,
0.0608261004,
0.0157636181,
-0.1009189412,
-0.0487534404,
-0.012109017,
0.0452435017,
0.0314225592,
-0.0304199215,
-0.0831632763,
0.0256983694,
-0.0056831189,
0.016563056,
-0.0139710698,
0.0374329165,
0.0903318897,
-0.0449475236,
-0.0010141559,
0.0476788022,
0.0359439477,
-0.0107390815,
-0.009103274,
0.0274938717,
-0.0048280875,
0.024742553,
-0.0316642933,
-0.0627111271,
-0.0714943409,
0.0081450474,
-0.0198874213,
0.0183349084,
-0.0041846246,
-0.0024828629,
-0.0653913766,
0.0659801066,
-0.0000771409,
-0.0676644892,
-0.0218912233,
-0.0239454564,
0.0367638208,
0.0085970033,
-0.0196273904,
-0.0286537781,
-0.0125909839,
-0.0409722142,
0.0000654638,
-0.0167768057,
-0.0378939472,
0.0139262229,
-0.0232217386,
-0.0337442942,
0.0756002516,
-0.014574483,
0.0134762013,
-0.0417945758,
0.07216876,
0.0133488914,
0.0023667556,
-0.0189495869,
0.0226505827,
-0.0032568451,
0.0118245892,
0.0130826235,
0.0491371565,
0.0019397219,
-0.0535171404,
-0.0110762147,
0.0697028786,
0.0062176893,
-0.0085905939,
-0.0739392042,
0.016872067,
0.0489742681,
0.0626933053,
-0.0079768728,
-0.0181964599,
-0.0164287277,
-0.0121588456,
0.0098655671,
0.0045153252,
0.0092074964,
-0.0229355171,
-0.0726587102,
-0.0509154201,
-0.0633997992,
-0.0292838532,
0.0796276182,
0.034972474,
0.0096170055,
-0.0296708979,
0.0279988088,
0.0383744612,
-0.0490742251,
0.0405964963,
-0.0270029195,
0.0217601713,
-0.0226028804,
-0.0168204643,
0.0167446155,
-0.0048134173,
-0.0370061509,
0.0457818992,
-0.0763709545,
-0.039766781,
-0.0072526406,
0.0921004489,
0.0083591677,
0.0305924974,
0.0134058725,
-0.0180778429,
0.038552165,
-0.017971497,
-0.0097160758,
0.0163516216,
0.0322265066,
-0.0118589792,
0.004580331,
-0.020072829,
-0.0212620534,
0.0258695614,
0.0017128007,
0.0123909591,
-0.0812031254,
0.0359312817,
0.0001129126,
-0.0508741066,
0.054120034,
-0.0152922049,
0.0540767163,
-0.0545505732,
0.043110203,
0.029892128,
-0.0146231316,
-0.0585941598,
0.0336099491,
0.0131443702,
0.0080410987,
0.0247311536,
0.0308275614,
0.0087523097,
0.0054467176,
-0.0143736182,
-0.0126694916,
0.0288752411,
0.0205051415,
-0.0219439734,
0.0211221501,
0.0111801717,
-0.0193246994,
-0.0061696991,
0.0261940416,
0.0216514878,
0.0999346003,
0.0129125603,
-0.0654435009,
-0.0670430511,
0.055815585,
0.0294972174,
0.0459087752,
-0.0256768502,
0.0193967428,
0.0308440942,
-0.019992182,
0.0291393083,
-0.0044059348,
-0.0076955883,
-0.0111558111,
0.0544959866,
0.0116789527,
-0.03894132,
0.0535609126,
0.0090330932,
0.0021409667,
-0.0090969345,
0.0153920809,
-0.0650093406,
0.0002644823,
0.0312804431,
-0.0366580486,
-0.0835722685,
-0.0052823713,
0.0104798041,
0.0446988493,
-0.0203685518,
0.0139585109,
0.0267883167,
-0.0309837032,
-0.0204044264,
0.023565542,
-0.0110030361,
0.0391606651,
0.0579129644,
0.0519840829,
-0.0370819643,
-0.0709389597,
-0.0167916529,
-0.0116407452,
0.0015379547,
0.0088300277,
0.0124351075,
-6.264147682e-33,
-0.0243913103,
-0.0260617808,
0.0268965065,
-0.0275374614,
-0.0157888941,
-0.0328781381,
-0.0410180055,
0.025396321,
0.0175520107,
0.0315121226,
0.0268581025,
-0.0241815671,
0.0526019037,
0.0501604713,
-0.0115429116,
-0.0099516166,
0.0399435423,
-0.0273416564,
-0.0321078897,
0.000496385,
0.0192799307,
0.0335968919,
0.0808871835,
-0.0393450558,
0.0193183627,
0.0087933857,
-0.0168005154,
0.022668818,
0.0192094836,
0.0435226485,
-0.046647694,
-0.0012823517,
0.0200566538,
-0.0149186384,
-0.0194769185,
0.0351616554,
-0.0747382939,
0.0236031301,
0.016903352,
0.0488640666,
-0.0764240026,
-0.005330659,
0.0523208641,
0.005443743,
0.0270871781,
0.0063516698,
0.0479648337,
-0.0534719042,
0.0284382608,
0.0480747297,
-0.0431831442,
0.023238061,
-0.0107739475,
-0.0526407287,
0.0537152141,
-0.0118309399,
0.0624400601,
0.0071926326,
-0.0806916133,
0.0352227166,
0.0042633824,
0.0469582118,
0.0657573864,
0.0375509299,
0.0308599807,
0.0863508806,
0.042721957,
-0.0747076496,
0.0623536855,
0.0331261531,
0.0151505079,
0.0737156793,
-0.0224077813,
-0.0216115918,
0.0367257446,
0.0783601552,
-0.0682369322,
0.0156800803,
-0.0824313313,
0.0464792512,
0.0076296455,
0.0094701387,
0.0082020946,
0.0209055766,
0.0234705564,
0.0112524461,
-0.0099098179,
0.0043052421,
0.0352879241,
0.0320060104,
-0.0288518742,
0.0285387356,
0.0641539693,
0.0186167099,
-0.0185420923,
-0.0299927015,
-0.0230954979,
0.0553824008,
-0.0048830947,
-0.0424717776,
-0.0276621394,
-0.0298373085,
0.0193605609,
-0.0463204831,
0.0157106463,
0.0150875188,
-0.0113239689,
0.0188927334,
-0.0206278376,
-0.0127014387,
-0.0185634512,
-0.0078628901,
-0.0549519993,
0.0742102414,
0.0219957605,
0.0219225381,
-0.0516328625,
0.0662182868,
-0.0150191626,
-0.0316832028,
-0.0022826793,
-0.0149817197,
-0.0127321705,
0.0106201926,
-0.048843246,
-0.0218176451,
-0.0108950315,
-0.0160217527,
0.0736550912,
-0.0586808659,
-0.0011649696,
0.0503362305,
2.892e-7,
0.0217895936,
0.0258816481,
-0.0048386189,
0.0239350181,
-0.0295497663,
0.0389427058,
-0.0286366791,
0.0152298333,
-0.0239958949,
-0.0888302699,
0.0057654311,
0.0330652855,
0.0133141596,
-0.0102684693,
-0.0798401237,
0.0364053734,
0.0591048412,
-0.0320236199,
-0.0751091614,
0.0169849861,
0.0156064797,
0.0764583722,
-0.0050959927,
-0.0075177583,
-0.0045212093,
0.00096631,
-0.0034177098,
-0.0490762331,
-0.0007889897,
0.0037441438,
0.0047618775,
0.0080854446,
-0.0382198058,
0.0232444927,
-0.0135369934,
-0.0322786197,
0.0449440107,
0.047879003,
-0.0077120019,
-0.0279940423,
0.0058476906,
0.002719593,
-0.0278821625,
0.0074325241,
0.060254842,
-0.0340769701,
0.015948087,
-0.0118808281,
-0.0150533784,
0.0028599873,
0.0052793175,
-0.0180808511,
-0.0479067452,
0.0059930133,
0.0248304848,
-0.0065679536,
-0.0250521433,
-0.0598489009,
-0.0317106992,
-0.0149066346,
-0.0575426444,
-0.0184850711,
-0.013588706,
0.0042576483,
-0.0284055658,
-0.0357776545,
-0.0547975041,
2.334937923e-34,
0.0049585844,
0.0082078064,
-0.0295293741,
0.0316630714,
0.0395216048,
0.0137685286,
-0.0532650948,
-0.0020865011,
-0.0429773442,
-0.0425018296,
-0.0427723564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08586v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08586v2 | Syntax-Aware Complex-Valued Neural Machine Translation | 2023-07-17T15:58:05 | 2024-06-17T13:09:45 | Yang Liu, Yuexian Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Syntax has been proven to be remarkably effective in neural machine
translation (NMT). Previous models obtained syntax information from syntactic
parsing tools and integrated it into NMT models to improve translation
performance. In this work, we propose a method to incorporate syntax
information into a complex-valued Encoder-Decoder architecture. The proposed
model jointly learns word-level and syntax-level attention scores from the
source side to the target side using an attention mechanism. Importantly, it is
not dependent on specific network architectures and can be directly integrated
into any existing sequence-to-sequence (Seq2Seq) framework. The experimental
results demonstrate that the proposed method can bring significant improvements
in BLEU scores on two datasets. In particular, the proposed method achieves a
greater improvement in BLEU scores in translation tasks involving language
pairs with significant syntactic differences. | [
-0.0195349753,
0.0422757268,
-0.0116257668,
0.0138378004,
-0.0114150401,
0.0205711741,
-0.0180516988,
-0.0244161654,
-0.0287436768,
-0.0362231247,
-0.0076991529,
-0.0308604725,
0.016373666,
0.04786814,
0.0567538179,
-0.0522455871,
0.0271313079,
0.0165909734,
0.0329843462,
0.0320059061,
-0.0026518689,
-0.0079269707,
0.0327189304,
0.0302606393,
-0.0084015643,
0.0164370593,
-0.0109635517,
0.0256231334,
0.0495464727,
-0.0544595234,
0.0108109508,
0.0220792405,
-0.0040097502,
0.0254291203,
0.0000019487,
-0.0088573648,
-0.0372426212,
0.0072995382,
-0.0095811784,
0.01111825,
0.0273630116,
-0.0549844131,
-0.0127994642,
0.0272416007,
-0.0177510362,
-0.039452292,
0.0396604165,
-0.0093996357,
0.0387728065,
0.0940389186,
-0.015837403,
-0.0432049818,
0.0310473964,
-0.0483574532,
-0.0203802977,
-0.0347250812,
-0.0138549739,
-0.013399519,
-0.0418767557,
0.0081968727,
-0.0015942503,
0.0539353006,
0.0358328559,
-0.0106184222,
0.0518976226,
0.0262021255,
0.0038487422,
-0.0008765956,
-0.0102199642,
0.0706871301,
-0.0846297741,
0.0067849578,
-0.017890662,
-0.0161352195,
0.0108701214,
-0.0508118793,
-0.0542767905,
0.0133291939,
0.0172726177,
0.0108280946,
0.0383093432,
0.0279404912,
0.0322415866,
-0.0568089001,
-0.0197609887,
-0.0061961836,
0.0478944927,
0.0043829801,
-0.0144679928,
0.0145795904,
-0.0586342923,
-0.0371901616,
0.0335597992,
0.0162762925,
0.0087141469,
-0.01029047,
-0.0460852683,
-0.0686167628,
-0.0269656759,
-0.0596235804,
0.054434523,
0.0630609617,
0.0043148263,
0.0041482765,
-0.0406650379,
0.0396670848,
0.0124816773,
-0.0014458346,
-0.0437235199,
-0.0056031924,
-0.0242941305,
0.0399374627,
-0.0154723292,
0.0101255728,
-0.0336302556,
-0.0059239222,
-0.0035871316,
-0.0085179331,
0.0000343904,
0.0181909744,
0.0062832171,
-0.0271637514,
-0.0822421238,
0.0169579834,
0.0001375517,
0.0170437451,
-0.0239452589,
-0.0097844694,
0.0241276473,
-0.0652490109,
-0.0569543652,
0.0124040945,
0.0136116128,
-0.0431911945,
-0.0259186663,
0.0326717794,
-0.0147300083,
-0.0172596741,
-0.0228481665,
-0.0074191671,
-0.0168611817,
-0.0201672241,
0.0209414698,
-0.0566496775,
0.0420141146,
-0.0064646965,
-0.0235898383,
-0.0729994401,
-0.0033940978,
0.0488894843,
0.0312116947,
0.0369961411,
0.0148958173,
-0.0736637041,
-0.0018442622,
-0.0227124412,
-0.0246256683,
0.0272225738,
0.053676337,
-0.0014235267,
-0.0352389142,
-0.0061138561,
-0.0055367709,
0.0110515831,
0.011612067,
-0.0100934459,
-0.0376350805,
0.0087922225,
0.0489976257,
0.01380252,
0.0394776352,
0.0571639612,
-0.033673957,
0.0207025055,
0.0276066083,
0.0069870362,
0.017519258,
0.0813478604,
0.0556970015,
0.0053346464,
-0.0416118465,
-0.0022778031,
-0.0323272832,
0.0747641325,
-0.0205333456,
0.0182183832,
0.0181477182,
0.040678367,
-0.0077666906,
-0.0432953313,
-0.0031298518,
-0.0405058749,
0.0512477607,
-0.0444365516,
0.0130546838,
0.0009136177,
-0.0667694509,
0.035379637,
0.0123504996,
-0.0558664612,
0.0363176279,
-0.0058786916,
-0.0549140908,
0.0903551877,
0.0010514125,
-0.0021314442,
-0.0408750884,
-0.0169600453,
-0.0475326329,
0.0309259295,
0.0212785602,
0.0346761197,
0.0364873409,
-0.0603109226,
-0.0058061727,
-0.0827112123,
-0.001302205,
0.013752237,
-0.0150350835,
0.0079868622,
0.0317024812,
0.0027622287,
-0.0603341721,
0.024380153,
-0.0073054973,
-0.0059537948,
-0.0103017092,
0.003308,
0.0222161226,
0.0054093096,
0.0061424924,
0.0293984376,
0.0014747786,
-0.0532506518,
-0.0288522001,
-0.011865044,
-0.0791085809,
-0.0654982105,
0.0165429953,
-0.0568354353,
0.0099446215,
0.0211380757,
-0.0130097242,
-0.0393089801,
0.0266928859,
-0.0794452205,
0.0044007055,
-0.0157752987,
0.0110720489,
0.0452897362,
0.0457369126,
-0.0433252975,
0.0601927266,
-0.0258782469,
-0.032803148,
0.0027969626,
-0.0282905847,
-0.0256853402,
0.009816057,
0.0030211757,
0.0107441833,
0.0209133346,
0.0324231572,
0.0060238587,
0.0367864594,
-0.0078962175,
-0.0161821134,
-0.0497603826,
0.0135231297,
-0.0559207276,
0.0207766481,
0.0460333526,
0.0393815413,
0.0407205783,
0.0280528478,
-0.0437577069,
0.0447516926,
-0.0313173085,
-0.0356076807,
0.0534027405,
0.0024870583,
-0.0467065573,
-0.0455284379,
-0.0132673904,
-0.018041838,
0.0398138016,
0.0063128015,
-0.0156302098,
-0.0309876576,
0.0127638867,
0.0161134377,
0.0144789862,
0.0144677032,
-0.0400327593,
-0.0188139379,
-0.0237285327,
-0.0029365267,
0.1030065715,
-0.0198900253,
0.0146129644,
0.0348100811,
-0.0174229499,
-0.0642947778,
0.0353550836,
-0.0151592381,
0.0077649802,
-0.021728754,
-0.0456634574,
0.0276128035,
0.0489071943,
-0.0470313206,
0.0199626647,
-0.0747651309,
0.0268948916,
0.0189402755,
-0.0197747145,
0.0785103515,
0.0318073668,
0.000521602,
0.0151776895,
-0.022149289,
-0.0165245514,
0.0721345097,
-0.0362455137,
-0.0369949378,
-0.0635134056,
0.0159927942,
-0.0299045611,
0.0072447862,
-0.0009146791,
-0.0064821821,
-0.0085513853,
-0.0475604236,
-0.0075965552,
0.0074397591,
0.0080143763,
0.0087469444,
0.0396661498,
-0.0586270764,
-0.0000405937,
-0.0068840324,
-0.0181134753,
0.006384789,
0.0512000024,
-0.0124516739,
0.0391791947,
0.0519741401,
-0.0353681557,
0.0202136245,
0.0026008987,
-0.0008643072,
0.0713291243,
-0.0004188503,
0.0051182038,
-0.0481540784,
-0.008916216,
-0.0050432328,
0.0317906849,
0.0561504737,
-0.0231691469,
0.0014823667,
0.0227275677,
-0.0382903554,
-0.0000654857,
-0.0359703898,
-0.0007232236,
0.0493453033,
0.0049931998,
-0.0208490305,
0.0211937856,
0.0238550119,
-0.0607440397,
-0.0523967668,
0.1079362482,
0.0337977745,
-0.0342228599,
0.0027118907,
-0.0368411839,
0.0666983798,
0.0162187889,
0.0253736582,
-0.014615952,
-0.0460837781,
0.0016116971,
0.0257210415,
0.0201948844,
0.0046677585,
0.0036468147,
-0.081518501,
0.0026976475,
0.0595842749,
-0.0242481772,
-0.0486922562,
0.0163558293,
-0.0197069459,
-0.0059947828,
0.0189814605,
0.0038729748,
0.0273740925,
-0.0060658334,
0.0047571161,
0.0222589783,
-0.0674934909,
-0.0013461268,
-0.0726798251,
0.034612149,
0.098558791,
0.0005902448,
-0.0191324502,
-0.0000821552,
0.0103833107,
0.0139331687,
-0.0069280784,
-0.0015960548,
-0.0059177317,
0.002047227,
-0.0122446194,
0.0013965046,
0.0171749126,
-0.0326693878,
0.0357139446,
0.0028827686,
0.0688792616,
-0.0238014795,
-0.0081103984,
0.0195184778,
-0.0326023214,
-0.0280972421,
0.0306549948,
0.0662417561,
-0.0418131277,
-0.025183212,
-0.0522014797,
-0.0136697376,
-0.1087268814,
0.0065700132,
0.0185394492,
0.0147713544,
-0.0809680298,
-0.0869939551,
-0.0923632309,
0.018695442,
0.0159324855,
0.0007313385,
-0.0420554243,
0.0696627349,
-0.0190003887,
-0.0260269325,
0.0446089618,
0.0113362689,
0.0081005786,
-0.0433017723,
0.003551157,
-0.0166888107,
-0.0156324822,
-0.01562934,
-0.0079911966,
-0.0826585814,
-0.0537363403,
0.0001413647,
0.0889962167,
-0.000024666,
0.0464207418,
-0.0215998981,
-0.0266869459,
-0.0321672484,
-0.014101794,
-0.0605703928,
-0.0058642682,
0.0502126366,
-0.0085446537,
0.0181274191,
0.0554612279,
0.0114595089,
-0.0294761155,
0.0032318213,
0.0616727285,
-0.0190500822,
-0.040767882,
0.0361504517,
0.0011359605,
0.0552787334,
0.047078643,
-0.0419482738,
0.008379641,
0.0438963324,
-0.044215586,
0.0143173905,
-0.0850192159,
-0.0353818908,
0.031154966,
0.0659731254,
-0.0004657551,
0.0448022373,
0.0418363549,
-0.0442126654,
0.0156769529,
0.0262903664,
-0.007864017,
0.0246859137,
-0.0082716765,
0.0075317845,
-0.0315526873,
0.00841776,
-0.0008885674,
0.0299267657,
-0.0660480186,
0.0223185513,
0.0277446751,
0.0001691372,
-0.0102658169,
0.0254596174,
0.0058836266,
-0.0024977012,
-0.0217540376,
-0.0438622274,
0.066763632,
0.0156139201,
0.1060235426,
0.0236482564,
-0.0052156611,
-0.0297646299,
0.0276425499,
-0.0220405944,
-0.0338270366,
0.0276995469,
-0.007287201,
0.009644636,
-0.0404779837,
0.0470070057,
-0.0210984275,
-0.0398439765,
-0.0266934708,
0.0091525503,
-0.0067557902,
-0.0013709759,
-0.016079206,
-0.0178731624,
-0.0179867633,
0.0118420878,
0.0122632282,
-0.0304508191,
0.0645371005,
-0.010964443,
-0.0127817392,
-0.0135474065,
0.0502338521,
0.0374674983,
-0.0549514443,
-0.0646995753,
-0.0269169193,
0.0172497202,
0.0270283073,
-0.04338447,
-0.0280282404,
-6.661882808e-33,
-0.0495017655,
0.0055373721,
-0.0081038792,
-0.0202276092,
-0.0274027679,
-0.0035828452,
-0.0535650589,
0.0046603787,
-0.0085871909,
0.000912101,
0.0263357013,
0.02171975,
0.0092595555,
0.0466602556,
0.0361979008,
-0.029360136,
0.0474477783,
0.0241036285,
-0.0232267641,
0.0272119567,
0.0013437185,
0.0246978942,
0.0884014443,
0.0003474655,
-0.0096342731,
0.0171718393,
0.0428780429,
-0.0004051592,
-0.0227279365,
0.0070074457,
0.0126602091,
0.0005713622,
-0.0026480446,
-0.0166103672,
-0.0378705561,
-0.0270618219,
-0.0793728307,
-0.0305185206,
-0.0110995071,
0.0370858796,
-0.028666798,
-0.0655403063,
0.0913623124,
-0.0256771501,
0.0027908806,
-0.041856125,
-0.0028271512,
-0.0095601901,
0.0007268551,
0.014558468,
-0.0459901132,
0.0107691148,
-0.0149498032,
0.0098917149,
0.0468389094,
0.0627666265,
-0.0337776057,
0.0113572674,
-0.1080232859,
-0.0396596529,
-0.0507345386,
0.0684985742,
0.0582136139,
0.0156809296,
-0.0212079678,
0.017350873,
0.0401955061,
-0.0274116397,
-0.0127971768,
0.0526977815,
0.0338433459,
-0.024617793,
0.0779218376,
-0.0400837362,
-0.0252300724,
0.0252601523,
-0.0781841576,
-0.0011372895,
-0.0013219313,
0.0699082762,
-0.0051527945,
0.0196175892,
-0.0124140689,
-0.0264954697,
-0.0268044081,
-0.013440825,
-0.0348158553,
-0.0047944123,
0.0152496248,
-0.0122012096,
0.001679733,
-0.006653117,
0.0748886392,
0.0339277424,
0.0384185314,
-0.0234857984,
0.0166969839,
0.0398495011,
0.0126437489,
0.0593935214,
-0.0325953923,
0.0025952312,
0.033185143,
-0.0051121418,
0.0338261798,
-0.0064247977,
0.0434274301,
0.0239995141,
-0.026938742,
-0.0234534144,
-0.0685423762,
-0.0052928915,
0.005296181,
0.0473885462,
0.0352065973,
0.0248654,
-0.0026219839,
0.0735674948,
0.0049740169,
0.0196416769,
-0.0561112054,
-0.0008810497,
0.0335156433,
0.0246183593,
-0.0507584549,
0.0155326016,
-0.0456238948,
0.0146232387,
0.0085019227,
-0.0411807112,
-0.0439496785,
0.026284717,
2.813e-7,
0.0812842175,
0.0651554093,
0.0166094806,
0.0498139411,
-0.0040145935,
0.046769131,
-0.0150839947,
0.0356948599,
-0.0037780011,
0.0455451831,
-0.0005504855,
0.0124404952,
0.0303820353,
0.0139691681,
-0.0724797174,
-0.0243171379,
-0.0105522973,
0.0086348103,
-0.0180908404,
-0.0313524865,
0.0534354672,
0.0954533145,
-0.0321596824,
0.0581527166,
0.0315870568,
-0.0272729341,
0.0478017256,
0.0101512549,
-0.0351867974,
-0.0012786594,
0.011306962,
0.0253459942,
-0.0538112596,
0.0280851461,
-0.0121974312,
0.0193129983,
0.046751935,
0.1087285802,
-0.0298750717,
-0.0135445027,
0.017004054,
0.0135619622,
-0.0158245061,
-0.0095280474,
0.0425907299,
-0.0946165174,
-0.0399776734,
0.0211413652,
-0.0516628437,
0.0462079756,
0.0384915881,
-0.0123509588,
-0.0215587895,
-0.0022637898,
0.0566790029,
-0.0076086819,
-0.0090020448,
-0.0209940542,
-0.0269569997,
0.0148058739,
0.0070979181,
0.0165684558,
-0.0588870198,
-0.0019564559,
-0.0103092901,
0.0554559492,
-0.0186931174,
2.764580649e-34,
0.0483717397,
-0.0258393437,
0.0265930742,
0.0298227631,
0.0609125122,
-0.0294416156,
-0.0800859928,
0.0130023742,
-0.0065852068,
-0.0585871935,
-0.0443644933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08580v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08580v1 | The Resume Paradox: Greater Language Differences, Smaller Pay Gaps | 2023-07-17T15:49:35 | 2023-07-17T15:49:35 | Joshua R. Minot, Marc Maier, Bradford Demarest, Nicholas Cheney, Christopher M. Danforth, Peter Sheridan Dodds, Morgan R. Frank | physics.soc-ph | physics.soc-ph, cs.CL | Over the past decade, the gender pay gap has remained steady with women
earning 84 cents for every dollar earned by men on average. Many studies
explain this gap through demand-side bias in the labor market represented
through employers' job postings. However, few studies analyze potential bias
from the worker supply-side. Here, we analyze the language in millions of US
workers' resumes to investigate how differences in workers' self-representation
by gender compare to differences in earnings. Across US occupations, language
differences between male and female resumes correspond to 11% of the variation
in gender pay gap. This suggests that females' resumes that are semantically
similar to males' resumes may have greater wage parity. However, surprisingly,
occupations with greater language differences between male and female resumes
have lower gender pay gaps. A doubling of the language difference between
female and male resumes results in an annual wage increase of $2,797 for the
average female worker. This result holds with controls for gender-biases of
resume text and we find that per-word bias poorly describes the variance in
wage gap. The results demonstrate that textual data and self-representation are
valuable factors for improving worker representations and understanding
employment inequities. | [
0.0076848962,
0.1090425402,
-0.0241667293,
-0.0336983018,
-0.011640544,
0.0225273687,
0.0374089591,
0.0072933608,
-0.0167002585,
-0.0515483655,
0.047236912,
0.0131176803,
0.067440182,
-0.024907954,
0.0554967411,
0.0013353005,
-0.0234009922,
0.0498094372,
0.0422541313,
-0.0638344586,
0.0153365806,
0.0306070615,
-0.0005479542,
0.0788863376,
-0.0126703531,
-0.040235199,
0.0674945638,
-0.0031099259,
-0.0232229438,
0.0148886237,
0.0541662052,
0.0540412329,
-0.0198997706,
0.0010823114,
0.0000018831,
-0.0238534063,
0.0325453468,
-0.0038617409,
-0.0398143269,
0.0084188161,
0.0293346643,
-0.0337421186,
-0.0081106303,
0.0018841036,
-0.0046170093,
-0.0056573451,
0.0090528009,
-0.0009554653,
-0.0014227318,
-0.0292582698,
0.0005391779,
-0.0174240936,
-0.0828900263,
-0.0440691859,
0.0043018381,
0.0108119482,
0.0409461558,
-0.0692935139,
-0.0501994602,
-0.0275123175,
-0.0458992831,
-0.0010809322,
-0.0655126348,
-0.0394488946,
-0.0360031575,
0.0811530501,
-0.0115135433,
0.0021802087,
0.0133935995,
0.00570392,
0.0396200456,
-0.034085989,
-0.0033139307,
-0.0328362659,
0.0619433336,
0.0201372448,
-0.012698642,
0.0645652339,
-0.0420203805,
-0.0184690375,
-0.0100822272,
0.0074229622,
-0.0037341225,
-0.0010144495,
0.0160437431,
0.0810355321,
-0.0278534722,
-0.0400253758,
0.0028625003,
0.0113996575,
0.0736729279,
-0.0433822013,
0.0309373159,
-0.0135488641,
0.0131078446,
0.0048640026,
0.0053158519,
-0.0344032496,
0.0200910643,
-0.0570297539,
-0.0271051507,
0.0296045747,
-0.0200083572,
0.0291736852,
0.0104347682,
0.0136532104,
-0.0035922995,
-0.0178236179,
-0.022368703,
-0.0047279969,
-0.0433345847,
-0.0417360403,
-0.0437273756,
-0.0345512144,
-0.0213650223,
0.0940167233,
-0.0231114477,
-0.0316719562,
-0.0700309798,
0.0237623174,
-0.0201425701,
-0.0118745631,
-0.0175846443,
0.0327659845,
-0.0416413918,
-0.0206011701,
-0.0167912208,
0.0112649612,
-0.018194763,
-0.0651059598,
0.0272380188,
-0.0037642187,
0.0305647291,
0.0150964707,
-0.0028368765,
0.0067753261,
0.0286448169,
0.027575016,
0.0399199091,
-0.0237677563,
-0.0003690307,
0.0063603171,
-0.0364344828,
-0.0488969535,
0.023605274,
0.041655302,
0.0007597792,
-0.0642365366,
0.002190992,
0.0021802313,
-0.0201114789,
0.010100632,
0.0411932729,
-0.0020811548,
0.0737412348,
-0.0126116145,
-0.0251961779,
0.0350957364,
0.0714186803,
0.0240450352,
0.0398704149,
-0.0280107521,
0.0018980063,
0.0350211821,
-0.0207094848,
-0.0039612567,
-0.0396196395,
0.0480569266,
0.0177617408,
0.0247830413,
0.0562816709,
-0.0229907129,
-0.0139463888,
0.0266744997,
0.0075504808,
0.130316332,
0.0249915849,
0.022608377,
0.01371466,
0.0296377186,
-0.012224433,
-0.0376459397,
0.0038853469,
-0.0161909703,
0.0176861584,
-0.0416297913,
-0.0206537079,
-0.0271329153,
-0.0423487052,
-0.0313484743,
-0.0222058203,
0.0192194413,
0.001944107,
-0.0057228054,
-0.0139992265,
-0.0075121722,
-0.0150073133,
0.0390547924,
0.0290402155,
-0.0271077976,
0.0029975222,
0.006175213,
0.0036392473,
0.1014154106,
-0.0188421514,
0.0005563872,
0.0645194873,
-0.0551557243,
0.0252635144,
0.0653337613,
0.0555474423,
0.0369922854,
-0.0099992966,
-0.0219685845,
-0.0127965771,
0.0288259517,
0.0362181105,
0.0605370775,
0.0287201107,
0.0189469121,
0.0239326954,
-0.0392473303,
-0.0474074371,
0.0040448927,
0.0199257899,
-0.0316413455,
0.0359303914,
0.0093308426,
-0.0565560907,
-0.0082099615,
-0.0264501385,
0.0205554217,
-0.0705933049,
-0.0073318877,
-0.0013506101,
0.0318639129,
-0.0297689214,
0.046703361,
-0.0579646528,
-0.0295959972,
-0.0581606403,
-0.0225327611,
-0.0087713813,
0.0416188389,
0.0389391929,
0.0161201414,
0.0347090848,
-0.0027963885,
-0.0055062794,
-0.0185380895,
0.0369396918,
-0.0106251454,
-0.0140454415,
0.0200109165,
-0.0054176697,
-0.0450953916,
0.0000113121,
-0.0089046843,
-0.1168201715,
0.0307604298,
0.0355633982,
0.0257402156,
0.0289439373,
0.0106945066,
-0.0203218423,
-0.0106990915,
-0.0403518453,
-0.0202808492,
-0.0238915402,
0.0375701077,
-0.0194452088,
0.0086931409,
-0.0331652798,
-0.0072462219,
0.0044439738,
-0.0056484235,
-0.0442915484,
0.0391674899,
0.0110544199,
0.0504985079,
-0.0236897934,
0.0442193486,
-0.0428453684,
-0.0661970377,
-0.0417764075,
0.0289341453,
0.0526915826,
0.0031051161,
-0.0796271414,
-0.0499925017,
-0.008093521,
-0.0311527625,
-0.0064978921,
0.0126034971,
-0.0188624579,
0.0190297291,
0.0131140007,
0.0429225303,
0.0079158088,
0.0612007007,
0.0290676467,
-0.0242691543,
-0.0258885734,
-0.040709652,
0.0338467844,
0.0854720622,
-0.0023473199,
-0.0675491244,
-0.0136219896,
0.0076423199,
0.0059731756,
-0.0174037907,
0.0111036645,
0.0567677841,
-0.057121601,
-0.0206671096,
-0.0678086132,
0.0120067978,
-0.0295139253,
0.0408201218,
-0.0305913575,
-0.0181797966,
-0.0475587361,
0.0087060863,
0.0406167693,
-0.0010641167,
-0.0275076218,
-0.030468734,
0.0463576429,
-0.0265731048,
-0.0023456265,
-0.0001001212,
-0.0488188006,
-0.0346931145,
-0.0094596315,
0.0559614263,
-0.0075886282,
-0.0132986084,
-0.0122736515,
0.0156439915,
0.0045644585,
-0.0007593879,
-0.013415806,
-0.0643026233,
-0.029830616,
0.0214892551,
0.0440985523,
-0.0165404044,
-0.0573896877,
-0.0000877914,
0.0237690266,
0.0190244038,
-0.0028223442,
-0.0145944841,
-0.0152068427,
-0.0355979018,
-0.0129881371,
0.0344174169,
-0.0236081984,
-0.0722036958,
0.0022067286,
-0.0109122628,
0.0023153014,
0.046340853,
0.0439367369,
-0.0135662612,
0.0266479664,
-0.0589874573,
-0.0113128526,
-0.0021344111,
-0.0479520969,
-0.0302055161,
0.0212115422,
0.0681761727,
0.0098170228,
-0.0183559414,
-0.0126234526,
-0.0052140947,
-0.0087923231,
0.048516199,
0.0276407804,
-0.0246139932,
0.0442877151,
0.0029486727,
0.0144526763,
-0.0076004546,
-0.0239451751,
-0.0297044553,
-0.0675944239,
0.0134639107,
-0.0115225287,
-0.0148272328,
0.0315190665,
-0.0220735017,
-0.0357129797,
0.0195666775,
-0.0238721501,
0.0013126574,
-0.0255546235,
0.0173722953,
0.028155379,
-0.0359824114,
-0.00024758,
0.0367060713,
-0.0108366581,
-0.0445947237,
-0.0074297665,
0.0766580552,
-0.0460570417,
0.0118577946,
0.0000897861,
0.0108117769,
-0.0130750518,
0.0143106924,
0.0299380776,
-0.0365723968,
-0.0061374907,
-0.0338062644,
-0.0260323398,
0.0106743751,
0.0216412116,
0.0217352305,
-0.0143408244,
0.0522725135,
-0.0415301174,
-0.0000771409,
-0.0106351469,
-0.0423441753,
0.0525982864,
-0.0208831206,
-0.0465198308,
0.0125327716,
-0.0190407615,
0.0134618552,
0.0352009162,
-0.0400054716,
0.0124074351,
0.0218424704,
0.0418972671,
-0.0087700048,
-0.0677592382,
0.0111677535,
0.0202927571,
0.0243102536,
-0.0320003591,
0.0235264879,
-0.0162858032,
-0.0746694505,
-0.0150730386,
-0.0409362614,
0.0265382919,
0.0496370345,
-0.0316455476,
-0.0593279041,
-0.0352504328,
-0.0366979577,
-0.0305261556,
-0.0500999354,
0.0018610603,
0.0049130539,
-0.0288583804,
0.0169529505,
0.0164590366,
0.0225013662,
-0.0151811223,
0.0378581099,
0.086456731,
-0.0432427116,
0.049764879,
-0.0205509532,
0.0197464433,
-0.0036602479,
-0.0154276546,
-0.0563104078,
0.0185091253,
0.0017768702,
-0.041625835,
0.0485583581,
-0.0416379236,
-0.0046824305,
-0.0105709415,
-0.0503462851,
0.0005729562,
0.0058624684,
-0.0214159936,
-0.0029263292,
-0.0195441414,
-0.0274533667,
0.0241988599,
-0.039664641,
0.0628014058,
0.0026638035,
0.0141811706,
0.0411875211,
0.0182033926,
0.0377720483,
-0.0103843221,
0.0366990417,
-0.0739169493,
0.0589783266,
-0.0205811709,
-0.025791999,
0.0228634644,
-0.014326321,
-0.0328612626,
0.044543948,
0.0403555036,
0.0128965052,
0.0117691886,
0.0222556684,
-0.01429806,
0.011046554,
-0.0307806954,
-0.0887507871,
0.0315447561,
0.0102011804,
-0.0157529432,
-0.1024324074,
0.0607006475,
-0.0011885255,
0.0090584178,
0.0253448635,
-0.0159261078,
0.0119208358,
0.0067472341,
0.0359115899,
-0.0194954351,
-0.0049628559,
-0.0278147347,
0.0036430038,
0.0488376506,
0.0354655348,
-0.035830982,
-0.0131598609,
0.0039972565,
-0.0199395157,
0.000278105,
0.0080833994,
0.0029222611,
0.0140097234,
-0.087459743,
-0.0239426699,
-0.0073915836,
0.0006003107,
-0.004657133,
-0.0033271711,
-0.0179066043,
0.0269010421,
-0.007694453,
-0.0338783562,
-0.012879258,
0.0381389335,
-0.0356415138,
-0.0220478941,
-0.0272364207,
-5.010927073e-33,
-0.0085803317,
-0.0552381985,
-0.0129876053,
0.0178105347,
0.0308860373,
0.0530843139,
-0.0138214929,
0.005007091,
0.014312746,
-0.0087521942,
-0.0448869728,
0.0349828675,
0.0093327919,
0.0098352525,
0.0322050527,
0.0487784967,
0.0304064844,
0.0080259424,
-0.0107475007,
-0.0354350358,
-0.0408099368,
0.0229427293,
0.0995924398,
-0.0401055925,
0.0943617374,
-0.0279967338,
-0.0098604569,
-0.0144622251,
0.0471416637,
0.0358473696,
0.0061415881,
0.040613085,
0.0057693701,
-0.0281741433,
-0.0130632613,
0.0259087142,
-0.0367689617,
-0.0316693038,
0.0221339371,
0.0274540335,
0.0518953167,
-0.0228062738,
0.0000231313,
0.041261442,
-0.0569496192,
-0.0070698718,
0.0657499954,
0.04219684,
0.0930338278,
0.0734803826,
-0.022563234,
0.0275605079,
-0.0641366988,
0.0560195409,
0.0463423356,
0.0505984053,
0.0251800995,
0.0442269892,
-0.1004691124,
0.0205655284,
-0.0478357971,
0.0265008304,
0.0071057105,
-0.0204889476,
0.0473897979,
0.0374227166,
0.1028994843,
0.0638254508,
0.0082642315,
-0.0430457443,
0.045759216,
-0.0392977372,
-0.0406834744,
0.0627253205,
0.0805030242,
-0.0620814264,
0.0084473863,
-0.0676583871,
-0.0018453514,
-0.0064135734,
-0.00066797,
-0.0029600945,
-0.0489290804,
-0.0700578094,
-0.0286033638,
-0.0517642573,
-0.0106577883,
-0.0025726387,
0.0360405594,
-0.0056351554,
0.0579403229,
-0.0123205893,
-0.0414397493,
-0.0326672122,
-0.0789993331,
-0.0120644467,
-0.0539060161,
-0.0312560834,
0.0404131897,
-0.0257054176,
-0.1033918783,
0.0287313275,
-0.0310009755,
0.0651068315,
0.0315094106,
0.0864132792,
-0.0315875858,
-0.0215192493,
-0.0634246022,
-0.0150656793,
-0.006855845,
0.0007628137,
-0.0355918482,
-0.0490225293,
0.0516607575,
0.0290435497,
0.0324867144,
-0.0357570536,
0.0368789844,
-0.0210103374,
-0.0189161599,
-0.045648098,
-0.0003038838,
0.0386424996,
-0.0147257373,
-0.0155482916,
0.0172551759,
0.0464280546,
0.0653499961,
-0.0282552037,
0.0074854307,
-0.0592920221,
2.339e-7,
0.0198754724,
0.0526691303,
-0.0087121604,
0.008959109,
0.0254872385,
0.0172800217,
0.0122379148,
0.029929813,
0.0705297142,
0.017218966,
-0.0652877912,
0.0300322697,
-0.0101365503,
-0.0230478514,
-0.0475006476,
0.0208427906,
-0.0627497211,
-0.0076412163,
-0.0046064765,
0.006532501,
0.0540788174,
-0.0180767234,
0.0621444322,
-0.0023752241,
-0.0657595769,
0.0069207181,
0.0578159541,
-0.0339828953,
0.0167970322,
0.014094335,
-0.0073830476,
-0.013940623,
-0.0298990291,
0.0488410965,
-0.0209409185,
0.0223765988,
0.0412393212,
0.009055661,
-0.0083909808,
0.1034821048,
-0.0221488681,
-0.0087316912,
-0.0439317524,
-0.0509478711,
-0.0004336317,
0.0151047958,
-0.0280700326,
-0.0400857441,
-0.0428775288,
0.0349499844,
0.0558063649,
0.0329766832,
-0.0329019576,
-0.0192039702,
0.0136762206,
-0.0019787645,
0.0005477252,
0.0040214607,
-0.0217132214,
0.0007081257,
-0.0257713906,
-0.0366785415,
0.0015667684,
0.0726243183,
0.0175381191,
0.006953781,
0.0281197075,
1.586271081e-34,
0.0079036951,
0.0794734061,
-0.00219363,
-0.0247716997,
0.03083832,
0.0198901575,
0.0239547081,
0.0300094336,
0.0127104996,
0.0603259243,
0.0023513467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08541v1 | Discovering collective narratives shifts in online discussions | 2023-07-17T15:00:04 | 2023-07-17T15:00:04 | Wanying Zhao, Siyi Guo, Kristina Lerman, Yong-Yeol Ahn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Narrative is a foundation of human cognition and decision making. Because
narratives play a crucial role in societal discourses and spread of
misinformation and because of the pervasive use of social media, the narrative
dynamics on social media can have profound societal impact. Yet, systematic and
computational understanding of online narratives faces critical challenge of
the scale and dynamics; how can we reliably and automatically extract
narratives from massive amount of texts? How do narratives emerge, spread, and
die? Here, we propose a systematic narrative discovery framework that fill this
gap by combining change point detection, semantic role labeling (SRL), and
automatic aggregation of narrative fragments into narrative networks. We
evaluate our model with synthetic and empirical data two-Twitter corpora about
COVID-19 and 2017 French Election. Results demonstrate that our approach can
recover major narrative shifts that correspond to the major events. | [
0.0068067415,
0.061270684,
-0.0358128659,
-0.0194547754,
-0.0437821485,
-0.0186547711,
-0.0570170134,
-0.0209906194,
-0.0077912565,
-0.0264877249,
0.106693916,
-0.0196565669,
-0.0046480116,
0.1082890332,
-0.0268614329,
-0.0288726483,
0.0342061408,
0.0464930721,
0.0477296188,
-0.0028461507,
0.0290070232,
0.0445682369,
-0.0429501645,
0.0236359518,
-0.0118219312,
0.009747996,
-0.0030903856,
-0.0078592375,
0.0873565823,
-0.0064910371,
0.0199655164,
0.0202805921,
0.0556652285,
0.06326399,
0.0000017622,
-0.0341022536,
-0.0417174324,
-0.0369994901,
-0.007940447,
-0.0184764285,
0.048358269,
-0.0135335242,
0.0171075948,
0.0053110057,
-0.0447287261,
0.0158289559,
0.0175307691,
0.027216848,
0.0332390629,
0.0800648928,
-0.0275753401,
-0.0282112155,
-0.0259603281,
0.0064265761,
-0.0174459983,
-0.0137121994,
0.0155556016,
-0.0190684404,
-0.0201664399,
-0.0301205702,
0.0044913148,
0.0195305403,
-0.0052538398,
-0.0453717671,
-0.0249619819,
0.0663491935,
-0.002127819,
0.0067342343,
-0.0038017882,
0.0576789863,
0.0518067069,
-0.0323286802,
0.0699679554,
-0.0106035452,
0.0237726737,
0.0390768386,
-0.0310666021,
0.0168854333,
-0.0227798615,
0.0279147159,
0.0124715706,
0.0086818393,
0.009730109,
0.0135723706,
-0.0141861364,
0.0130034015,
-0.0064990181,
0.0006111694,
-0.0677368343,
-0.0058824206,
-0.0043956749,
-0.0235016141,
0.0205150414,
0.007418836,
-0.0279807243,
0.0429199859,
-0.0051841685,
0.040807303,
-0.0116950544,
-0.1071231589,
-0.016836727,
-0.0353721157,
0.0087262224,
0.0682663918,
0.0245445035,
-0.0391889028,
-0.0058511123,
-0.0272148084,
0.0022404559,
-0.0093223713,
-0.0867349356,
0.048174154,
0.0180514753,
-0.0041840505,
-0.0358925052,
0.0150133586,
0.0412529632,
-0.0109072002,
0.0067176106,
-0.0072044716,
-0.0544138812,
0.0272611026,
-0.016286822,
-0.0218553729,
-0.0125683537,
0.0864003673,
-0.0421016961,
-0.0110236192,
-0.0147470683,
0.0011110426,
-0.0055837543,
-0.0277204923,
0.070888795,
0.0160039589,
-0.047655344,
-0.0022636331,
-0.0143768284,
0.0207523275,
-0.0130293109,
-0.0462533645,
-0.0144726979,
-0.0244582798,
0.0011959191,
-0.0605432652,
0.0380207747,
-0.0012385958,
0.0075136949,
-0.004838808,
0.0224013142,
0.006658819,
-0.0724180713,
0.0116939778,
-0.039665807,
0.0090524517,
0.0647987351,
0.0034896475,
0.0424005203,
0.0557727478,
0.042950701,
0.0281880833,
0.0793218017,
0.0018003273,
-0.012861399,
-0.0006342449,
-0.0198018961,
0.0337701999,
0.0479675271,
-0.0226181317,
-0.0060285199,
-0.0009402286,
0.0002122383,
0.0089157205,
-0.020070916,
-0.0420184396,
0.052658353,
0.0344541334,
-0.0158860032,
-0.0280862711,
0.017205717,
0.038600564,
-0.0066916067,
0.0193173885,
0.0324344188,
-0.0097152032,
0.0221208762,
-0.0617163703,
-0.0040324954,
0.0269075334,
0.000028839,
-0.0031476615,
0.0160399098,
0.0024169192,
0.0130520677,
-0.0380897745,
-0.0208745841,
-0.0122366594,
-0.0007731324,
0.0235256366,
0.0830828696,
-0.0585199483,
0.0389743857,
0.0200062245,
0.0177455358,
0.0414643511,
0.0336132385,
-0.0113245342,
-0.0697297454,
-0.050398197,
0.055560872,
0.0125710554,
-0.0120608127,
-0.0431742072,
-0.0350259878,
0.008968682,
0.0007869494,
0.0270540174,
0.0111619355,
0.0138890445,
0.0168748125,
-0.0130772758,
-0.0402510166,
-0.0218563993,
-0.0398530662,
0.0161796827,
-0.0010233865,
0.0258963145,
0.0279824231,
0.0028266222,
-0.0111847464,
0.0399973392,
-0.0058540939,
-0.0334708728,
0.0319960192,
-0.0093305707,
-0.0730393976,
0.0886633098,
-0.0294606593,
-0.0194889158,
0.0149773611,
-0.0329956226,
-0.0486556217,
-0.0120523665,
-0.031258516,
-0.0307333749,
0.0874605924,
-0.058087904,
-0.0507243797,
0.0250584371,
-0.0493569449,
-0.0175445285,
-0.0341422074,
-0.0291095916,
0.0659843609,
-0.02529319,
-0.0141940005,
-0.0399803519,
-0.0293113366,
-0.0162965599,
0.0072405422,
0.0499034189,
0.0375510827,
-0.0074693225,
0.002620863,
0.0719738305,
-0.0736281797,
-0.0368865877,
-0.0078373961,
-0.0378532559,
0.0003599631,
-0.0315883532,
0.0113640856,
0.0847741738,
0.0002704754,
-0.0122777363,
-0.0132522127,
-0.0306669455,
-0.0068959123,
-0.026682999,
0.0121969255,
0.0140726827,
0.0096307648,
-0.0093538277,
-0.0373057872,
0.0230114553,
-0.0547429435,
0.0524088629,
0.0520457998,
-0.0580486283,
-0.0266521871,
-0.0614196993,
-0.0365889259,
0.0061849193,
-0.0491203405,
0.0083265854,
0.0030178917,
0.0087200906,
0.0539220273,
0.0160101485,
0.0451196469,
0.0948262215,
-0.0064775655,
-0.0117374733,
-0.0168501809,
-0.0002453394,
-0.0707981363,
0.0073246332,
-0.0664299503,
-0.0720820278,
0.0377250947,
0.0803442821,
-0.0057768575,
0.0176736694,
-0.0184333436,
-0.0408734344,
-0.0444505215,
-0.0165820215,
0.02448925,
-0.0083527882,
-0.0173111837,
-0.0054266192,
-0.032304395,
0.0049407077,
0.0147150941,
0.0388829783,
0.0693283379,
-0.0397986062,
-0.0559951439,
-0.0323124826,
0.0538725927,
0.0189736448,
0.0253875684,
0.0541790761,
-0.0178270265,
0.011240053,
-0.0268513653,
0.0636827722,
-0.0091310805,
0.0080609135,
-0.0653550699,
0.0267847423,
0.021631252,
0.0018133105,
-0.0038765997,
-0.0863717198,
0.0071723782,
0.0018145934,
0.0143484883,
-0.0489006378,
-0.0387042277,
-0.0211729519,
0.0126650305,
0.0232899226,
0.0163731463,
-0.0200128909,
0.0077095358,
0.0574683212,
0.0331902541,
-0.0008868449,
-0.0017328383,
-0.0183857363,
0.0183306895,
0.0630446747,
0.0233224928,
-0.0159448814,
-0.0096754208,
-0.0531031154,
-0.0166932326,
-0.0811259747,
0.0211877711,
-0.0175918061,
0.0471862704,
-0.039402891,
0.0066438541,
0.0841804221,
0.0392338485,
-0.0274896119,
0.034284655,
0.0447742604,
-0.0314215049,
0.0215429198,
-0.0176050626,
-0.0722210854,
0.0304426737,
-0.0161056556,
-0.0077267024,
-0.0200863089,
-0.0909943134,
-0.0026275716,
-0.047386352,
0.0381090939,
-0.0073626824,
0.0502042435,
0.0463249981,
-0.0639075562,
0.0385827199,
-0.0331067741,
-0.0583961718,
-0.0177594703,
-0.0048487186,
-0.0026731158,
0.0079962499,
-0.0831570327,
-0.0047848113,
-0.0073901545,
-0.0361009575,
0.0143802557,
0.0104679484,
0.0643564388,
0.0029352515,
0.040812958,
-0.002481784,
0.0194563791,
-0.018224448,
0.0056078718,
0.0918797255,
-0.0108182803,
0.0038503893,
0.002702917,
0.0428328775,
-0.0077600419,
-0.0487877354,
0.0076922788,
0.0416798145,
0.0253284667,
-0.0696766153,
0.0055074114,
0.0190777574,
0.0343880467,
0.003012592,
0.0303509664,
-0.0083263637,
0.0019946767,
-0.0095264083,
0.0527954623,
-0.0377144106,
-0.0421149358,
-0.0482596308,
0.0082600247,
-0.0225319993,
-0.0504912287,
-0.0138385696,
-0.0049712998,
-0.0038269339,
-0.0250878725,
-0.0046054129,
0.0781155154,
-0.0358895175,
-0.0917436853,
-0.0143761644,
-0.0553060547,
0.0189745482,
0.0233580191,
-0.0404919945,
0.0166034903,
0.0444344245,
0.0056320438,
-0.0017849598,
-0.0610781386,
-0.0523311235,
0.0234562848,
-0.0688184649,
0.0132695017,
0.0540422164,
-0.0231204573,
-0.0142618697,
0.0537998155,
0.0238921996,
-0.0497463495,
0.0023417321,
-0.0247781891,
0.0357924253,
-0.0241254065,
0.0041191783,
0.0223444123,
-0.004658903,
-0.0119110784,
0.0006977228,
-0.0786092132,
0.0290993191,
0.0169452988,
-0.0390026383,
0.0439663045,
0.0084751183,
-0.0613493063,
-0.0806324631,
-0.0461256057,
-0.0081780376,
-0.0071182954,
0.0268868897,
-0.0016346888,
0.0179589279,
-0.0098090954,
-0.0233071223,
0.0368690938,
-0.0091782389,
0.0082460074,
-0.0786182508,
-0.0108097252,
0.0352410115,
0.0203164425,
0.0065045934,
-0.0142257651,
0.027668355,
-0.0022467428,
0.0143071832,
0.0350844935,
0.0056959596,
-0.0213365965,
0.0093747806,
-0.0280238464,
0.0275448244,
-0.0021735425,
-0.0546738692,
-0.0149990441,
-0.0189996772,
0.0151226576,
0.0517112985,
-0.0072032269,
0.0596700124,
0.0098074041,
-0.0020700989,
-0.0202531386,
0.0001036827,
-0.0161530655,
-0.0132084759,
-0.0442821085,
0.0134524154,
-0.0468752496,
0.0610209033,
0.0545407832,
-0.0032282716,
0.0826997086,
0.0297020692,
-0.0262296535,
-0.0026439021,
-0.0374811888,
-0.0488755852,
0.0209135357,
3.998e-7,
0.003592015,
-0.0499053784,
0.0195276756,
0.0675868317,
-0.0401600152,
0.0212753229,
0.0113003934,
-0.0357863754,
0.037821468,
0.032856591,
0.0382315852,
-0.0648395792,
0.0177568197,
-0.0190910641,
-0.0262202937,
0.0216095336,
-6.647701203e-33,
0.0040641408,
-0.053703405,
-0.0141776521,
0.0226690117,
-0.0388697982,
0.0408552438,
-0.0425901823,
-0.009035347,
0.0397730954,
0.0724379197,
0.0545532778,
0.0419343524,
0.0178169254,
-0.0079750204,
0.0036025974,
-0.0031349848,
0.0494175553,
0.0124845449,
-0.0308366138,
0.0496989265,
0.0688117892,
0.011924969,
0.0618384331,
-0.0674981549,
0.016968606,
-0.0038139545,
0.0110008949,
0.0217585266,
0.0287996549,
-0.0055797999,
0.022650715,
0.0331617482,
0.0495733395,
-0.0268823616,
-0.0212617032,
0.0262146536,
-0.0550504476,
-0.0208263546,
0.0196759701,
-0.0084788939,
-0.0117148478,
-0.0307105053,
-0.0116562415,
0.020690212,
0.0062479009,
-0.0110400608,
0.042855151,
0.0166932661,
0.0271945056,
-0.0041639656,
-0.0670906976,
0.059881907,
-0.0454773493,
-0.0126175713,
-0.0691390261,
-0.0010039555,
0.0689327866,
-0.0154744554,
-0.0484081246,
0.047841873,
-0.0375942998,
0.0332651287,
-0.0174058359,
-0.0037729226,
-0.0402973741,
0.0745245442,
0.0176437367,
0.061476551,
-0.0501689799,
0.0418496579,
-0.0380273163,
0.0321078934,
0.0002554929,
0.0740009397,
-0.007722734,
-0.0108538903,
-0.0966692716,
0.0468718223,
0.0153145827,
0.0256911311,
0.0117345219,
0.0196635406,
0.0109536108,
-0.0212487653,
-0.0136363124,
-0.0251171384,
-0.0013391351,
0.0204490181,
-0.0496160239,
0.0121095823,
-0.0112603325,
0.0755287707,
0.0216816943,
-0.0263151713,
-0.0092982668,
-0.0215799939,
-0.0039995424,
0.0323974453,
0.002994091,
0.0249513574,
-0.0401494838,
0.0021341399,
-0.0001489233,
0.0211105123,
0.0280477814,
-0.0325621776,
0.0059528165,
-0.0017867298,
-0.0072343438,
0.0165055078,
-0.0054409737,
-0.0117317438,
-0.0519814566,
-0.0245224442,
0.0217662323,
0.0247671455,
-0.0089141512,
-0.0098391371,
0.0452659503,
0.0489564762,
0.0219705608,
-0.0034966299,
-0.0588740148,
0.0029230663,
-0.0024282895,
0.0012004201,
-0.0144877946,
0.0506276824,
0.0260010492,
-0.0060555907,
-0.0253878888,
-0.0483324751,
2.699e-7,
0.0472858027,
0.0590194128,
0.0640328676,
-0.0325419307,
0.041619584,
0.0285733137,
0.028646078,
0.0165050365,
-0.0236063097,
-0.078327544,
-0.0009964094,
0.0487452671,
0.0131649366,
0.0598424673,
-0.0478539355,
0.0015040092,
-0.0430844426,
-0.0012862193,
-0.0760910586,
-0.0119566871,
0.0251614489,
-0.025865633,
0.0325089954,
-0.0028976223,
-0.0128449947,
0.0038017062,
0.0496682711,
-0.0227249637,
-0.0702999905,
0.0597213656,
-0.0140668033,
-0.0331340842,
-0.0275131483,
-0.040579427,
-0.0221404321,
0.0051198001,
-0.0231500454,
-0.0121374754,
0.0152149098,
0.0137477908,
-0.0129477391,
-0.0418759398,
0.0143420678,
0.0155792637,
0.0534061827,
-0.0862127095,
-0.0581424907,
-0.0311575439,
-0.0393480919,
0.0385667607,
0.0196404215,
0.0025380738,
-0.0372917503,
0.0444498174,
-0.0469602607,
0.0391090438,
-0.0150364293,
-0.0795902461,
0.0076445569,
0.0233045202,
-0.0272980426,
-0.0151749076,
0.0266846754,
-0.0276340172,
-0.005664886,
-0.0172933154,
0.0770350173,
2.01981452e-34,
0.0247247629,
0.049710691,
-0.0466834605,
0.0230538119,
0.0563603789,
-0.0206902623,
-0.0533177629,
-0.0057502151,
0.0079028513,
-0.0288508479,
-0.0000912781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11770v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11770v1 | Large-Scale Evaluation of Topic Models and Dimensionality Reduction Methods for 2D Text Spatialization | 2023-07-17T14:08:25 | 2023-07-17T14:08:25 | Daniel Atzberger, Tim Cech, Willy Scheibel, Matthias Trapp, Rico Richter, Jürgen Döllner, Tobias Schreck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Topic models are a class of unsupervised learning algorithms for detecting
the semantic structure within a text corpus. Together with a subsequent
dimensionality reduction algorithm, topic models can be used for deriving
spatializations for text corpora as two-dimensional scatter plots, reflecting
semantic similarity between the documents and supporting corpus analysis.
Although the choice of the topic model, the dimensionality reduction, and their
underlying hyperparameters significantly impact the resulting layout, it is
unknown which particular combinations result in high-quality layouts with
respect to accuracy and perception metrics. To investigate the effectiveness of
topic models and dimensionality reduction methods for the spatialization of
corpora as two-dimensional scatter plots (or basis for landscape-type
visualizations), we present a large-scale, benchmark-based computational
evaluation. Our evaluation consists of (1) a set of corpora, (2) a set of
layout algorithms that are combinations of topic models and dimensionality
reductions, and (3) quality metrics for quantifying the resulting layout. The
corpora are given as document-term matrices, and each document is assigned to a
thematic class. The chosen metrics quantify the preservation of local and
global properties and the perceptual effectiveness of the two-dimensional
scatter plots. By evaluating the benchmark on a computing cluster, we derived a
multivariate dataset with over 45 000 individual layouts and corresponding
quality metrics. Based on the results, we propose guidelines for the effective
design of text spatializations that are based on topic models and
dimensionality reductions. As a main result, we show that interpretable topic
models are beneficial for capturing the structure of text corpora. We
furthermore recommend the use of t-SNE as a subsequent dimensionality
reduction. | [
-0.0007716487,
0.0020403105,
-0.0150409164,
0.0293435995,
-0.0235587172,
0.0123914266,
0.0339552276,
0.0071889912,
-0.0406097546,
-0.0139381345,
-0.015638968,
0.0012421503,
0.0330091007,
0.0181869771,
-0.0238921922,
-0.0831637308,
-0.0442646518,
-0.0099085923,
-0.0053723622,
0.0282445494,
0.0232713465,
-0.0214427747,
-0.0152911367,
-0.0072446717,
-0.0404452384,
-0.0337144509,
-0.022822056,
-0.0100912377,
0.0125808762,
-0.0298537314,
-0.0546136163,
-0.0029778103,
0.0512807816,
0.0113134943,
0.0000020992,
0.0053696432,
-0.0393388197,
-0.0056820377,
0.0943071172,
0.0552388839,
0.0903662741,
-0.0533854775,
0.0101106307,
-0.0464006923,
-0.0009598748,
0.0005575717,
0.0306999218,
0.0686247274,
0.0294839945,
0.0026848346,
-0.0427208543,
-0.0622634068,
0.0042595766,
0.0052048396,
0.0069586718,
0.0517443903,
-0.0250398386,
-0.0103853559,
-0.0267390963,
0.0916042104,
-0.0354321226,
-0.0019655589,
-0.0299409032,
-0.0093355542,
0.040615309,
0.0371873379,
-0.0068923361,
0.0084535647,
-0.0060315137,
0.0488126874,
0.0015017354,
-0.0016357475,
0.0552252978,
-0.0072489837,
-0.0481282733,
0.0689787716,
-0.0738479793,
-0.0147737581,
0.009575435,
0.0211042501,
-0.0304229911,
0.0099532502,
-0.010580129,
-0.0451909788,
-0.0383400097,
0.0468233414,
0.0125336796,
-0.0437645391,
-0.0620381273,
0.0102384118,
0.0251221787,
-0.0192911513,
0.0407299586,
-0.0081863729,
0.0488335751,
0.0119189955,
0.0237355828,
-0.0693338662,
0.0064237015,
-0.0605502725,
0.0143075166,
-0.0337050557,
0.0036918009,
0.0336822756,
0.0213278215,
0.0509256348,
-0.0247264449,
0.0124101555,
-0.056845665,
0.0192743186,
0.0184674915,
0.0433125943,
-0.0000512714,
-0.0104769263,
-0.0112500275,
-0.0143066812,
-0.0014954827,
0.0197688118,
0.0241609402,
-0.003147963,
-0.0426410399,
-0.0009406395,
-0.0054049068,
-0.0032948363,
-0.0149797797,
0.0246176086,
-0.063013643,
0.0118648475,
-0.0762631521,
0.0571087152,
0.0158172306,
0.0554267876,
0.057636641,
0.0016589812,
-0.0338264965,
0.0178119894,
0.0218922235,
-0.014531754,
-0.0394148938,
0.0161742847,
-0.0487365685,
0.01592502,
0.0329145156,
-0.0649889261,
0.0091184322,
-0.0191584118,
0.0059310235,
0.0246603098,
-0.0309155621,
-0.0031989273,
-0.0311149526,
0.0526552796,
-0.0048953025,
0.0259403642,
0.0868461356,
-0.021021273,
0.0270869136,
0.028816184,
0.0527290031,
0.0824539587,
0.0480272546,
-0.0483026989,
0.0048960932,
-0.0106347855,
-0.0007249282,
0.0359859802,
-0.0364354327,
-0.0113100056,
-0.0099019986,
0.0152313672,
0.0488518402,
0.0323167294,
-0.0301186796,
-0.0170973856,
0.0422782637,
0.1362354904,
0.0084350053,
0.0040931902,
0.0079175383,
0.0722280294,
-0.0407823287,
-0.0049800766,
0.0617442541,
-0.0335044004,
0.0228474028,
-0.0034270482,
0.0522153787,
-0.0095287217,
-0.0018972176,
-0.0454124026,
-0.0240640268,
-0.0083451169,
0.0469503999,
-0.0694456995,
0.085551165,
-0.0238967687,
-0.0045675975,
0.025266951,
0.0128561705,
-0.0621815212,
-0.019518204,
0.0450167917,
0.0357685722,
0.0542719178,
0.0193377584,
-0.0482997745,
0.0277240723,
0.0107079996,
0.0408530384,
0.0159805492,
-0.0133024044,
0.0032640838,
-0.0210897867,
-0.0462115109,
-0.0442769974,
-0.0261199642,
-0.0151270656,
0.020400852,
-0.0167848002,
0.040477436,
0.0045298133,
-0.1004488617,
0.0051089958,
0.0409198366,
0.0454700999,
0.0464789644,
-0.004964455,
0.0154584646,
0.0311392713,
0.0224323031,
-0.0233599991,
-0.0123999584,
0.0501442775,
-0.0387969762,
0.0276448224,
-0.0096098892,
-0.0050468715,
-0.020454444,
-0.0216376912,
-0.0617589653,
0.0239492096,
-0.0219296142,
-0.0054486147,
-0.0246203505,
0.0305730272,
-0.06592682,
-0.0211270917,
0.0206539109,
-0.0121121118,
-0.0509656742,
-0.0097556151,
-0.041771479,
0.0479605049,
-0.0350596309,
0.0343144648,
0.0088856919,
-0.0079571381,
0.0306505356,
-0.0036601443,
0.0333310999,
-0.0275492873,
0.0262331385,
0.0072222785,
0.0163420122,
0.0189003032,
0.0108872969,
-0.029135162,
-0.0639157742,
-0.0112249479,
-0.0251247101,
0.0099444948,
0.0519347042,
-0.0341682844,
-0.0131625747,
-0.014615017,
-0.0056320308,
0.0097866161,
-0.0523558334,
-0.0237188097,
0.0569724217,
-0.0572956987,
0.0190072656,
-0.0045622396,
-0.000703542,
-0.0040123393,
0.0248938967,
0.0381205119,
-0.0434222221,
-0.0319747329,
0.0466601588,
0.0270472914,
-0.0278557409,
0.0084390789,
0.0110183107,
0.0372211896,
-0.035057079,
0.0570116602,
0.0269112326,
0.0076961587,
0.050811816,
0.0597414449,
-0.0183807854,
-0.0333106667,
0.0227802955,
-0.0174979046,
0.096613951,
0.0230565164,
-0.0670229271,
0.0540370084,
0.0448147021,
0.0201111119,
0.0208115727,
-0.0187601168,
-0.0160769727,
-0.0682672858,
0.0426696651,
-0.074419111,
-0.0008012387,
-0.0010323472,
0.0484019667,
-0.0145678753,
-0.0142911077,
-0.0168967694,
-0.0672043934,
0.0205613803,
-0.0873058215,
0.0164731424,
-0.0287061371,
0.0523234122,
0.0234609172,
0.010085633,
-0.0185057279,
-0.0159947835,
0.0201481786,
0.0198035017,
-0.000478601,
0.0041587241,
-0.0221741535,
-0.0374149755,
-0.0052237073,
0.0016601699,
0.008424852,
0.0057525462,
-0.0297975112,
0.0478679426,
-0.0917603374,
0.0341139361,
-0.0370947756,
-0.0194418561,
0.0749793276,
0.0231897067,
0.0511966534,
0.0199983343,
-0.0127138421,
0.0001946393,
0.0966903269,
0.0169860274,
0.0132690873,
-0.045403216,
0.0132717015,
-0.018755611,
0.0199795607,
-0.0445793979,
0.0228492618,
-0.0107849333,
0.0382040776,
0.0014240406,
0.0061600045,
-0.0366239026,
-0.0132902749,
0.0650416538,
0.0042753583,
-0.0457377657,
0.0849543288,
0.0670975298,
-0.0468456559,
-0.0241036825,
-0.0340388678,
0.0070186541,
-0.0076576606,
-0.0165294707,
-0.0021564253,
0.0503039062,
-0.0337067172,
-0.0320190564,
0.0327511057,
-0.0098472517,
0.0163707566,
-0.0304348916,
0.0582150333,
0.0148076881,
-0.1010888442,
0.0150280921,
-0.1065721437,
-0.0220821202,
0.009173464,
-0.0527126715,
-0.0292939357,
0.0073149251,
0.0057366155,
0.0035297803,
-0.0820336342,
0.018417757,
-0.0521128066,
0.0013305091,
0.0028910441,
-0.0176618006,
0.0781020597,
-0.0396629572,
-0.0549763478,
-0.038401641,
0.0445906594,
0.0228764825,
-0.0123489872,
0.0345571637,
0.0337780192,
-0.0006567296,
-0.0436193869,
0.0025652277,
0.0077718594,
-0.0227998346,
0.0463720225,
0.0448265038,
-0.0248959605,
0.0025060673,
-0.0643148944,
0.0295184366,
-0.0019687752,
0.0056411019,
0.0635295436,
-0.0275920182,
-0.0378081053,
-0.0467813574,
0.0441211686,
0.006641217,
-0.0100690946,
-0.0103750015,
-0.0171843395,
-0.0493391864,
-0.0630544201,
-0.0142922215,
-0.0086466754,
0.0043463991,
-0.0183137618,
-0.0030358916,
-0.0138386739,
-0.0535734557,
-0.0396489277,
0.0117624886,
0.0155065469,
-0.0269012302,
0.0001736682,
0.0008310133,
0.0015769383,
0.0011109444,
-0.0086780209,
-0.0078342175,
-0.0513105616,
0.0188739281,
-0.0173784196,
-0.0294243954,
0.0024715816,
0.0083410172,
-0.0386537239,
-0.0270265937,
0.0933761075,
0.0099022957,
-0.0478785709,
-0.0077501941,
-0.0184510686,
0.039872881,
0.0105781592,
-0.0346840955,
-0.0096453791,
0.0528073274,
-0.0272995345,
-0.0111179156,
-0.0607618392,
0.0145811345,
-0.0383919701,
-0.016644042,
0.0789967775,
0.0115440236,
-0.0467005409,
-0.0213671979,
-0.0260389466,
-0.0602641851,
-0.0199413616,
0.0302809495,
0.0064757057,
0.0559572987,
-0.0133077176,
-0.0276690908,
0.0261038728,
-0.010716089,
-0.0037706539,
0.0063668536,
0.0059318668,
0.0379937328,
0.0037459433,
-0.0176812895,
0.0658837482,
-0.0076831263,
-0.0158677194,
-0.0465099439,
0.0051167025,
0.0277865957,
-0.009951951,
-0.0012615155,
-0.0071396148,
-0.0307059512,
0.0613301098,
-0.0452497713,
0.0094883963,
-0.0030428316,
0.0379415862,
0.0178833511,
0.0046509188,
0.0526188724,
-0.0081108063,
-0.0061674793,
0.0160032623,
0.0183111858,
0.0766371265,
0.0050797937,
-0.010795855,
0.0136296824,
-0.0230108015,
-0.0138031822,
0.0449093655,
0.0323476419,
-0.0603180528,
0.013198372,
-0.0449424051,
-0.039079424,
0.0656477883,
-0.0033010084,
0.0641595125,
-0.0146159353,
-0.0226293206,
-0.0413497351,
0.0038633768,
0.0482859612,
-0.0081426529,
-0.0297279432,
0.0226854123,
0.0457219109,
0.0551649071,
-0.0035597833,
0.0771949291,
-0.0332181975,
0.0217212457,
-0.0207276642,
-0.081934385,
-0.0251304414,
-5.695104826e-33,
0.0024374777,
-0.0564004667,
-0.0057535404,
-0.0133021325,
-0.0132722817,
-0.0003252509,
-0.0222636182,
-0.0036942139,
0.0275215227,
0.0131634176,
0.0013171326,
0.0064078914,
0.0073613944,
-0.005562346,
0.0100727146,
0.0461876318,
0.0094826762,
-0.0158059746,
-0.0657784343,
0.0398609191,
0.0537016168,
0.0155665465,
0.0075287898,
-0.0637454838,
0.0078252442,
-0.015495928,
0.0328814611,
-0.0258626025,
0.0675710961,
0.0329946466,
-0.0488287583,
0.0308809429,
0.0391116068,
-0.0268175527,
-0.0256750304,
0.0605316199,
-0.0019988022,
-0.0873284414,
-0.0260206982,
0.019434901,
-0.0097958846,
-0.0555507839,
0.0476743802,
0.0142407883,
-0.0209934283,
-0.0043526627,
0.071820572,
-0.0020768095,
-0.0317093022,
0.0129134841,
-0.0215962753,
0.0212270729,
-0.056672398,
-0.0101344371,
0.0349321552,
-0.0423519351,
0.0223342627,
0.0646629632,
-0.0483284704,
0.0732296109,
0.0293930434,
-0.0054320525,
0.0128088826,
-0.0152973225,
0.0227584485,
0.0809622556,
-0.0006106079,
0.0365932249,
-0.0073674056,
-0.0124351243,
0.0470298827,
0.0239006933,
0.0327877887,
0.0095188785,
0.0069632367,
0.0124986097,
-0.0500638001,
0.0860050321,
-0.0404728018,
-0.008619735,
0.0207293909,
0.0174565036,
-0.0440918393,
-0.0553197525,
0.0049986946,
-0.0190873668,
-0.0261681676,
-0.0046878513,
0.0056634685,
-0.0379007831,
-0.002009959,
-0.0198206846,
-0.0125455605,
-0.0146491667,
-0.0157596897,
0.0219617393,
-0.0360920057,
0.0546046197,
-0.0097077284,
-0.0365180075,
-0.01654437,
-0.0596444607,
0.003059963,
0.0504989624,
-0.0160157196,
-0.0309270918,
0.00970075,
-0.0175547339,
-0.0272817444,
-0.008351149,
0.0217020437,
-0.1011389494,
-0.0150994807,
0.002169288,
0.0007521642,
-0.0349367298,
0.0003190705,
0.0614044555,
0.0307802577,
0.0248228386,
0.029563548,
-0.0618791208,
-0.0444611795,
-0.0032342537,
0.0182767604,
-0.0169805977,
-0.0130383456,
-0.0079377256,
0.0670731664,
-0.0515735857,
-0.0437525883,
-0.0312681347,
2.703e-7,
0.065041177,
0.0856312364,
0.0251215063,
-0.065221332,
0.0489655025,
0.0117940381,
-0.0117912423,
0.0199886132,
-0.0793627575,
0.0162335318,
0.0333413519,
0.0223756433,
0.014891508,
0.0374008566,
-0.0790346339,
0.091543965,
-0.0725990012,
-0.0193538591,
-0.0703755543,
0.0699053407,
0.0463959649,
0.0055132187,
-0.0017643229,
-0.0001142286,
-0.0113381958,
-0.0064101862,
0.0185795445,
-0.0748673603,
0.0163084287,
0.0090111354,
-0.0006717242,
-0.0358129665,
-0.0175098106,
-0.0470904335,
0.0294458866,
-0.0133079709,
0.0330694467,
0.0229855292,
-0.0006530751,
0.0564871766,
0.0085457917,
-0.0394270197,
-0.0075032674,
-0.0678212121,
0.0181526504,
-0.0123490971,
-0.0297692437,
-0.0075615249,
0.0220498424,
0.0245523229,
0.0359433368,
0.016089879,
-0.0193812903,
0.000120845,
-0.0074447221,
-0.007328291,
0.0376421623,
-0.0059592263,
-0.0035437206,
0.024623137,
-0.0052298992,
-0.0069810608,
-0.036609102,
0.0306083485,
0.0132892942,
-0.0005598728,
0.017496625,
2.396469083e-34,
0.0191302821,
0.0111821061,
-0.0164828375,
-0.0114795454,
-0.0089016324,
-0.0340554789,
-0.0387917198,
-0.0075749704,
-0.0229248032,
-0.0417604521,
0.0363711901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08487v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08487v3 | Latent Jailbreak: A Benchmark for Evaluating Text Safety and Output Robustness of Large Language Models | 2023-07-17T13:49:52 | 2023-08-28T08:35:28 | Huachuan Qiu, Shuai Zhang, Anqi Li, Hongliang He, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Considerable research efforts have been devoted to ensuring that large
language models (LLMs) align with human values and generate safe text. However,
an excessive focus on sensitivity to certain topics can compromise the model's
robustness in following instructions, thereby impacting its overall performance
in completing tasks. Previous benchmarks for jailbreaking LLMs have primarily
focused on evaluating the safety of the models without considering their
robustness. In this paper, we propose a benchmark that assesses both the safety
and robustness of LLMs, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach. To
comprehensively study text safety and output robustness, we introduce a latent
jailbreak prompt dataset, each involving malicious instruction embedding.
Specifically, we instruct the model to complete a regular task, such as
translation, with the text to be translated containing malicious instructions.
To further analyze safety and robustness, we design a hierarchical annotation
framework. We present a systematic analysis of the safety and robustness of
LLMs regarding the position of explicit normal instructions, word replacements
(verbs in explicit normal instructions, target groups in malicious
instructions, cue words for explicit normal instructions), and instruction
replacements (different explicit normal instructions). Our results demonstrate
that current LLMs not only prioritize certain instruction verbs but also
exhibit varying jailbreak rates for different instruction verbs in explicit
normal instructions. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/qiuhuachuan/latent-jailbreak. | [
0.0331583396,
0.037218485,
-0.0284697488,
0.0364287198,
-0.0298152473,
0.0041945977,
0.0030468616,
-0.0064126253,
0.0277549159,
-0.0308857299,
-0.028183667,
-0.0411728397,
-0.0010157339,
0.0187640898,
0.0466933697,
-0.0272058137,
0.0615063384,
-0.0538235903,
-0.0177041329,
0.0240050144,
0.0187438317,
-0.0012541864,
0.0305560939,
0.0656070188,
-0.0004877084,
-0.0110243475,
-0.0075792624,
0.0309278984,
0.0430575162,
-0.0313215926,
0.0193946306,
0.054756403,
-0.0014312395,
0.0639935136,
0.0000020808,
-0.0106409146,
-0.0169573724,
0.0099854413,
0.0145388758,
0.0414417535,
0.0544262528,
-0.0544245951,
-0.048257459,
0.0282354094,
-0.0205670297,
0.0266036931,
0.0531495512,
0.0287857298,
0.0726993605,
0.0710391179,
0.0040968941,
0.0255507212,
0.0374482945,
-0.0135768894,
0.0226209909,
-0.0473023541,
0.0231661852,
0.0024665406,
0.0028056963,
0.0556565449,
0.0097330166,
0.0241814256,
0.0178535562,
-0.0393028706,
-0.0370885171,
0.0021623995,
0.009424584,
-0.039439708,
-0.0175773613,
0.0548418202,
-0.0474462695,
-0.0042709894,
0.0068049594,
-0.02360362,
0.0049447888,
-0.0074729896,
-0.018172333,
0.0642603114,
0.0053594797,
-0.0002921317,
0.0365353152,
-0.0021556569,
0.0564315096,
-0.0196832921,
0.0480347052,
0.0483472608,
0.0269868411,
-0.0372152291,
0.0058857501,
-0.0227628052,
-0.0534787998,
-0.0592406392,
0.0190446302,
-0.01037909,
-0.0255699269,
0.0453787819,
-0.1006996706,
-0.0527005531,
0.0453860015,
-0.0750309825,
0.0199318938,
0.0341984183,
-0.0127138598,
0.0180485435,
-0.0036928165,
0.0326697789,
-0.0338267237,
0.0312952437,
-0.010228361,
0.042024117,
0.0000261778,
-0.0150903435,
-0.0010521286,
0.0257923976,
-0.0216075238,
0.0005940559,
-0.0467205867,
0.0375732109,
-0.0191390794,
0.0048914352,
-0.0082778111,
-0.0077237645,
-0.0396829173,
0.0288920682,
0.0338172764,
-0.0414358415,
-0.0344893113,
0.0124891698,
0.0283908322,
-0.0418949425,
-0.0028016532,
0.0188807249,
-0.0512156561,
-0.0345341973,
-0.0279837772,
0.1056175232,
0.003563581,
-0.0168096051,
-0.0597130507,
-0.0618687086,
-0.0605617538,
-0.0291836299,
-0.0004126828,
-0.0701617673,
-0.013003367,
-0.0128235128,
0.0044769822,
-0.0507001095,
0.0431534685,
0.048168242,
-0.0456982143,
0.0469259098,
0.0105776787,
-0.0204107035,
-0.0081943618,
0.050037384,
-0.0021749954,
0.0589047559,
0.0290329922,
0.0809279755,
0.0504241623,
-0.0151409134,
0.0123030059,
0.0629852265,
-0.0114427544,
0.0486909188,
-0.0179193057,
-0.0217926893,
0.0540632345,
0.0064461729,
0.004086419,
0.0847737342,
-0.0070900852,
-0.0065716137,
0.0779994801,
0.0323885009,
-0.0569918975,
0.0081933141,
0.0539723113,
0.002893704,
-0.0066672615,
0.019679971,
-0.0849472508,
-0.0037032212,
-0.0551394932,
-0.0285787638,
-0.011280288,
0.0135369357,
-0.001302478,
0.0006031322,
-0.0302391741,
-0.0140429065,
0.0205332041,
-0.0372175798,
0.0216124263,
0.0186789092,
-0.0551179126,
0.0173342805,
0.0424264669,
-0.047023803,
-0.00514175,
-0.047028441,
0.0085344398,
0.0909833983,
0.0527259707,
0.0007185054,
-0.0068822042,
-0.0257905349,
0.0253755804,
0.0172376484,
-0.0121002011,
-0.0071446956,
0.0302223265,
-0.0238295551,
-0.0208717063,
-0.0046601593,
0.0326423384,
0.0187534243,
0.0404984728,
-0.014656459,
0.0200306606,
-0.0249089878,
-0.0636581481,
0.0584880412,
-0.0287717003,
-0.0047626351,
-0.0068795993,
-0.0013672885,
0.0207682643,
0.0035741066,
-0.0372493789,
0.0043000523,
0.0480360426,
-0.0106926849,
0.0081010927,
0.0043171803,
-0.0533119328,
-0.020216709,
0.010617462,
-0.0265174266,
-0.0216372553,
0.0606111102,
-0.0295994692,
-0.0121547934,
0.0023707903,
-0.0498484448,
-0.0089924783,
-0.0098064831,
0.0338625945,
-0.009766967,
-0.0110580437,
-0.025411794,
0.0291898027,
-0.0443322286,
0.0063768802,
-0.0041390327,
0.0058858423,
-0.0149149336,
0.0096490113,
-0.0659905598,
-0.013099554,
-0.0320087001,
0.0245822761,
0.0266985856,
0.0467242673,
-0.0075746509,
-0.0484386235,
-0.0645210221,
0.0076693981,
-0.037112128,
0.0132290851,
0.0537205413,
0.0127770789,
-0.0013256664,
-0.0005538951,
-0.006201725,
0.0165435225,
-0.0055171968,
0.032611981,
0.0058513596,
-0.0078529464,
-0.0279665794,
-0.0340106338,
-0.0012713164,
-0.0163156353,
0.0233881995,
-0.008223705,
-0.0043845214,
-0.0408749878,
0.0302937403,
0.0146025987,
0.0025735095,
-0.0162383188,
-0.0618075393,
0.0309585668,
0.029530786,
0.0605452023,
0.0712487847,
0.001694239,
0.0516545437,
0.082679674,
0.0096610487,
-0.0290700998,
-0.0192123745,
0.0051647592,
-0.0488222539,
-0.021215966,
-0.1057412177,
0.0108812535,
0.0750479475,
0.0427954681,
0.0084430119,
-0.0612586215,
-0.015151591,
-0.0527905338,
-0.0496067218,
-0.0142784687,
-0.0337978192,
-0.0604019836,
0.0168915335,
-0.0311693344,
-0.0749458373,
0.0689595863,
-0.0224052966,
0.034698192,
0.0068067932,
-0.0109417439,
-0.0059225932,
0.0451917574,
-0.0045287698,
0.0204415396,
0.0102314446,
-0.0388906337,
-0.0304180793,
0.0224991627,
0.0261986293,
-0.0097249905,
0.0503930971,
-0.0704549327,
-0.0214923341,
-0.0166144408,
-0.0380704291,
-0.0402448662,
-0.077701129,
0.0159483273,
-0.0108576501,
0.0708090737,
-0.0220191274,
-0.0148248402,
0.002334286,
0.0344054028,
0.0281123314,
-0.0401610956,
0.0042894403,
-0.03274066,
0.002450271,
0.0426039249,
-0.0912502557,
-0.0016833454,
-0.0411722399,
0.0347258486,
0.0880509466,
0.0087694125,
-0.0002196269,
-0.0297509972,
0.0114755128,
0.020969931,
0.0230600275,
-0.0385099277,
0.0477947518,
0.0930088758,
-0.0529756583,
-0.0272327699,
0.0706796274,
0.0352712497,
0.0062875459,
0.0334569402,
-0.0068264753,
0.0622165501,
0.0121261533,
0.0029453358,
-0.0695040077,
-0.0190639757,
0.0219006296,
0.0704601035,
-0.0088311937,
-0.0402394608,
0.0101424353,
-0.0723474845,
0.0183753502,
0.0204953831,
-0.0322124511,
-0.0185949467,
-0.0425493494,
-0.0081465486,
-0.008094091,
0.0183180906,
-0.0112032881,
-0.0049407603,
-0.0324610434,
0.0310271531,
-0.021664653,
-0.0425233394,
0.029639205,
-0.0323014855,
0.0650223717,
0.0938604921,
0.001438198,
-0.0215097424,
0.0146185253,
0.0522697605,
0.0057408689,
-0.0044274968,
0.0075493688,
0.0343277827,
-0.0048001381,
0.0023946443,
0.0030685172,
0.0303724892,
-0.0068922322,
-0.0509331748,
0.0415231921,
0.0599723011,
-0.0057571526,
-0.0247372631,
-0.0445065424,
0.0060164542,
0.0332556441,
0.0745213777,
0.0333156586,
-0.0582736246,
-0.0216460302,
-0.0536481626,
-0.0200497285,
-0.0426720232,
-0.0300208032,
-0.001324082,
-0.0377949886,
-0.0550196394,
-0.0880609676,
-0.0372840911,
0.0217950381,
0.0344461687,
0.0433572307,
-0.0141096478,
-0.0173461773,
0.0020723441,
-0.0025742594,
-0.0050575021,
-0.0092123942,
0.0412079655,
-0.0664230883,
0.0244883131,
-0.0172737706,
-0.0059600705,
-0.0057861665,
0.0287042502,
-0.1003797203,
-0.0904421434,
0.0306465756,
0.0827805325,
0.0217591356,
0.0017494271,
-0.0408706442,
-0.0669045821,
0.0173974037,
0.0397559553,
-0.052655004,
0.012403233,
0.0421867408,
-0.0159445442,
0.0091740815,
0.0154170897,
-0.0395958908,
-0.0173760783,
0.0357330814,
0.0282293428,
-0.0268908013,
-0.0269969869,
0.0142171215,
0.0198126137,
0.0204073861,
-0.0459069498,
-0.0062870779,
-0.0216210242,
0.0022342273,
-0.0309212599,
-0.0346709602,
-0.0247476958,
0.0429421403,
0.0543753989,
-0.0302925669,
-0.008888565,
0.0150628239,
-0.0222247895,
0.0322064534,
-0.0302316882,
0.0028732936,
0.0125484308,
0.0695532933,
0.0546254218,
0.0387692302,
-0.0422411636,
0.0401770622,
-0.0361520052,
0.0116058718,
-0.0058898698,
0.0315794647,
-0.0149882827,
-0.013374663,
0.0244986452,
0.0489618294,
-0.0594663024,
0.0010199775,
-0.0529268906,
0.0527211018,
0.0039141462,
0.007468563,
0.0704113394,
-0.0450189821,
-0.0007777811,
-0.0578971095,
0.0070647816,
0.0019714527,
-0.0718639866,
0.0173418168,
0.003698162,
-0.0134414369,
-0.0015630638,
0.0868320465,
0.0263861883,
0.040668644,
0.032316979,
-0.0241454132,
-0.0459369756,
0.0144259175,
0.067683354,
0.0207863208,
-0.0585070774,
-0.0207969733,
-0.0604052395,
-0.0723410472,
-0.0137772402,
0.0308214631,
0.0221163612,
0.0034446218,
-0.0049837949,
0.054450646,
-0.0177710783,
0.0110258516,
-0.0604443811,
-0.0005370364,
0.0138864908,
-0.0248751137,
-0.0314957239,
-6.104255838e-33,
-0.0154173942,
-0.0445604958,
-0.0267363731,
-0.01473678,
0.014706309,
-0.0049277041,
-0.0413316861,
0.0309749413,
0.0247146189,
-0.006951205,
-0.0071239499,
-0.0048902249,
0.0049848361,
0.0031831036,
-0.0020863335,
-0.0145164272,
0.0400653556,
-0.004668769,
-0.0444521978,
0.0421385281,
0.0430539176,
0.0041430523,
0.0272902846,
-0.0654573217,
0.0668367967,
-0.0242938492,
-0.0537739471,
0.005233421,
-0.0179431327,
0.0678455457,
-0.0039698966,
0.0255367924,
0.0010227702,
-0.01598767,
-0.0292479135,
0.053276591,
-0.0246274378,
-0.0077447067,
0.0166749023,
-0.0159640554,
-0.0552802645,
-0.073254481,
0.0252007432,
-0.026106786,
-0.0027710074,
-0.0025281115,
0.0118537499,
-0.0099529848,
-0.0273960363,
-0.0208290778,
-0.0742307901,
0.0151525801,
-0.0125979111,
-0.0203732718,
-0.0220081173,
0.0289781597,
0.0133356517,
-0.007430627,
-0.0259917472,
0.0226671342,
0.0379150845,
0.0189123023,
0.0498479642,
-0.0005584474,
-0.0167736746,
0.0688017532,
-0.0088394787,
0.0279869158,
0.0208842587,
-0.0205241665,
0.0195595436,
0.0439821966,
0.0506487153,
0.0559652634,
0.0362423025,
-0.0151924426,
-0.0689277425,
0.0278635435,
-0.0002858725,
0.0168042742,
0.0268000178,
0.0140663162,
-0.0505396053,
-0.0143714715,
-0.0412589349,
0.0013029464,
-0.0072693471,
-0.0463223383,
0.0504646562,
0.0057799118,
-0.0382219665,
-0.0347810462,
0.0076617855,
-0.0230671037,
0.0097588627,
0.0108462628,
-0.0310923997,
0.0107995588,
-0.0210194904,
0.0590579547,
-0.0445258208,
-0.0093580615,
0.0474493057,
-0.0487916544,
0.0417728983,
0.0060897772,
0.0597605072,
0.0341959409,
-0.075395979,
-0.0075783296,
-0.0368152522,
0.0459769815,
0.00469907,
-0.0086169662,
0.0458773598,
-0.037813697,
-0.0049375049,
0.0190672036,
0.0416480377,
-0.0006151407,
-0.0385752805,
0.0108851073,
-0.0243632812,
0.0112857344,
-0.0119005796,
0.0102723343,
-0.0073751886,
0.0291209817,
0.0260882117,
-0.0736951306,
-0.0127263386,
0.0188118741,
2.749e-7,
0.0338565744,
0.0426929444,
0.0130381295,
0.0169098638,
0.0017917301,
0.0435236618,
-0.0328680128,
0.0575587861,
0.0068500969,
-0.0207563937,
-0.0159550142,
-0.0170526356,
0.0683304369,
0.0731273368,
-0.0574738346,
0.0092130546,
-0.086450845,
0.0243393052,
-0.0515979305,
-0.0134503618,
0.0506392568,
0.0818817988,
0.0043296209,
-0.0050477171,
-0.0121973334,
-0.0409550071,
0.0312699638,
-0.0225820746,
-0.0196947046,
-0.0210264884,
0.0204422623,
0.0360123441,
0.0111796446,
0.0172021389,
-0.0294757131,
-0.040003553,
0.0048056841,
0.0816545263,
-0.0009738805,
-0.0019332647,
-0.0119907437,
-0.0527860075,
-0.0164391343,
-0.0475735329,
0.0572967269,
-0.0269933958,
-0.0119007211,
-0.0040428978,
0.0145395119,
-0.0001387285,
0.0259588435,
-0.0482998155,
-0.0085041942,
-0.0154189579,
0.0178826004,
0.022322746,
-0.0116165131,
-0.0305434726,
-0.0198653433,
0.0024965042,
-0.0195237361,
-0.0801889524,
-0.0621931702,
0.052833315,
0.003775801,
-0.0692776516,
0.0176580045,
2.990248473e-34,
0.0066941516,
-0.0638865605,
0.0197374392,
-0.0109554343,
0.044020202,
0.0170373973,
0.0100274337,
0.0198599938,
0.007785459,
-0.0374438018,
-0.0353396907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11769v1 | Domain Knowledge Distillation from Large Language Model: An Empirical Study in the Autonomous Driving Domain | 2023-07-17T13:34:31 | 2023-07-17T13:34:31 | Yun Tang, Antonio A. Bruto da Costa, Jason Zhang, Irvine Patrick, Siddartha Khastgir, Paul Jennings | cs.CL | cs.CL | Engineering knowledge-based (or expert) systems require extensive manual
effort and domain knowledge. As Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained using
an enormous amount of cross-domain knowledge, it becomes possible to automate
such engineering processes. This paper presents an empirical automation and
semi-automation framework for domain knowledge distillation using prompt
engineering and the LLM ChatGPT. We assess the framework empirically in the
autonomous driving domain and present our key observations. In our
implementation, we construct the domain knowledge ontology by "chatting" with
ChatGPT. The key finding is that while fully automated domain ontology
construction is possible, human supervision and early intervention typically
improve efficiency and output quality as they lessen the effects of response
randomness and the butterfly effect. We, therefore, also develop a web-based
distillation assistant enabling supervision and flexible intervention at
runtime. We hope our findings and tools could inspire future research toward
revolutionizing the engineering of knowledge-based systems across application
domains. | [
0.0148775084,
-0.0047013229,
-0.0375814922,
0.0604680367,
-0.030118268,
0.0062206313,
0.0138420425,
0.0140112704,
0.0444397517,
-0.0569216795,
-0.0029770671,
0.0206262339,
-0.0416569933,
0.0620913357,
-0.012916496,
-0.0625408962,
0.0034334259,
-0.1003370732,
-0.0003566456,
-0.0005216094,
-0.0084789526,
-0.0027434039,
-0.0247248169,
0.0334811248,
-0.0192127377,
-0.0285131223,
-0.0155667197,
-0.0217626747,
0.0146627435,
0.0157100186,
-0.0071975007,
0.0753017217,
0.054992944,
0.0084045744,
0.0000022162,
-0.0700826272,
0.0026089596,
0.0292461086,
-0.033853285,
-0.0178509019,
0.0006465586,
0.0455126017,
0.0129229976,
0.0226409175,
-0.0445609502,
0.0107499305,
0.0042834561,
0.0127926478,
0.0694097057,
0.0250818711,
-0.0001266188,
-0.0006325071,
0.0074232458,
0.0237890352,
-0.0117257228,
-0.0427207798,
0.0376212671,
0.0416978449,
0.0378858149,
0.0153452745,
-0.0326140709,
0.0258498695,
0.0225820653,
-0.0182291754,
-0.008554182,
0.0218443461,
0.0030467997,
-0.0430193432,
0.0004380348,
0.0462590419,
0.0239918828,
-0.0109691005,
0.0295643341,
0.0173855741,
0.0056157559,
0.0429474562,
-0.0145673333,
-0.0071856463,
-0.0162068196,
-0.0236485973,
-0.0419869572,
-0.0213826466,
-0.0321923643,
-0.0248595979,
-0.0389886349,
0.0924174264,
0.0056786276,
-0.0285347886,
0.0037540225,
0.0064503411,
-0.0133557236,
-0.0875610933,
-0.0277410261,
0.0568301566,
-0.031839788,
0.0180390179,
-0.0128724491,
0.015487073,
-0.0162054971,
-0.0066022333,
-0.0143470783,
0.0185745843,
-0.0454815328,
0.0200984143,
0.0173520949,
0.0725049525,
0.0632930845,
0.0310942158,
-0.0306308363,
-0.0249073803,
-0.1141839921,
-0.0017131845,
-0.0319761634,
0.0400219448,
-0.0132443737,
-0.0026322072,
-0.0307455268,
0.0669718906,
-0.0390650295,
0.0214672741,
0.0030446847,
0.0026457317,
0.0055959816,
-0.0196172055,
-0.0512228049,
0.0039931764,
-0.0028672058,
0.0220413785,
0.0163489878,
-0.0494772643,
0.0336994864,
0.0086585572,
-0.0236071013,
0.0116463033,
-0.0155364657,
0.1464198679,
-0.0155688385,
-0.0304625873,
-0.0447180532,
-0.0700764805,
-0.0085838214,
-0.0445412286,
-0.0039527752,
-0.0755717158,
0.0402600318,
0.0287265312,
-0.0079257553,
-0.0865962058,
-0.0013638393,
-0.0383180752,
-0.0171608645,
0.0638919771,
-0.0423440412,
0.0417591669,
0.044244688,
0.0295071304,
-0.0417835191,
0.0694825873,
-0.0046152235,
0.0378346518,
0.0310774427,
0.0299525466,
0.0047836374,
0.008260834,
-0.0097925477,
0.0206530727,
0.0144796567,
0.0116095711,
-0.0117032044,
0.0196366645,
0.0206416063,
0.0087655885,
-0.0068945424,
0.0585695542,
0.0458413959,
0.0249407459,
0.0253581293,
0.0212650374,
0.0584427528,
0.0456395671,
0.0148813957,
0.0093305875,
-0.0589852855,
0.0018699151,
-0.0201429706,
0.0180870406,
0.0039445683,
0.0530819893,
-0.0321311206,
-0.04570641,
0.0161154307,
0.007023795,
-0.0113944309,
0.0197662693,
0.0567447096,
0.0204904024,
0.0329082534,
0.0418125615,
0.017956648,
0.019328706,
0.0248413887,
-0.0771367103,
-0.0179179627,
0.0839041993,
0.0318146348,
-0.0545090996,
-0.0532769635,
0.0122368485,
0.0259969048,
0.0098808082,
0.0097741019,
-0.0382004417,
-0.0218696836,
-0.0068800589,
-0.08102604,
0.031079337,
0.0287633985,
-0.0053471513,
0.0351984315,
0.0242788605,
0.0302991718,
-0.0666975155,
-0.0207185112,
0.0200622845,
-0.0191295929,
-0.0356433988,
-0.0440292917,
0.0380940512,
0.0046394658,
0.0132153016,
-0.0414274111,
0.0012578822,
0.0270599574,
-0.0054925866,
-0.057335671,
-0.0090636797,
0.0243296903,
0.0219361335,
0.0576621592,
-0.0392863043,
0.0009004363,
0.0085979337,
-0.037412297,
-0.0320056751,
-0.0329897925,
0.0099974768,
0.0294098463,
0.0072472366,
0.0255541224,
0.0265639517,
-0.024309596,
-0.0187815577,
0.0417843536,
0.0285830535,
-0.0265311021,
0.0255470052,
0.0048324349,
0.0056919404,
0.013159262,
0.0117094871,
-0.020608427,
-0.0173708629,
0.023437513,
0.018759463,
0.0073315171,
-0.028545294,
0.009743494,
-0.0538404435,
-0.0233485233,
-0.0209435653,
-0.0097176312,
0.0141031565,
0.0253051799,
-0.0029952836,
-0.0170944761,
0.0142120114,
0.0242827442,
-0.0111723924,
0.0141094495,
0.0242510699,
0.0143443355,
-0.0402755179,
-0.0004695115,
-0.0022595604,
-0.013682697,
-0.0080323527,
0.0129543627,
-0.0007525187,
-0.0872459486,
0.0546796322,
-0.0590621233,
0.0538328439,
0.0069517093,
-0.0250043962,
0.0256703757,
0.0072589428,
0.0371963717,
0.0470811129,
0.0166820008,
0.0104959924,
0.0533259772,
-0.0216880459,
-0.0517264828,
-0.0147911152,
-0.0323985368,
-0.0446022339,
-0.0096918102,
0.0111696152,
0.0141482409,
0.0529130474,
-0.0109474771,
-0.0009209702,
-0.0409517996,
-0.0081141181,
-0.0486980714,
-0.0255260859,
-0.0680599883,
0.0056387857,
-0.0092738243,
0.0897537619,
0.0046764733,
-0.0395957939,
0.077555649,
-0.0106116664,
0.0342780575,
-0.0024003724,
-0.0084749339,
-0.0046424428,
0.0753233358,
-0.0090035331,
0.0209240112,
0.0645577982,
0.0027391976,
-0.0494349189,
0.0064787487,
0.0175705012,
-0.0085098417,
0.0380237997,
-0.1036818847,
0.0240784623,
0.0013557893,
-0.0523233861,
-0.0490790196,
0.0159607753,
-0.0355805755,
0.0271041896,
0.0255317707,
-0.0313712768,
0.0186019484,
-0.0012546729,
0.016661806,
0.0546796545,
0.0334166326,
-0.0321464539,
-0.0298193134,
-0.0004434589,
0.0395155661,
0.0136865592,
-0.0329972617,
-0.0062308242,
0.0531321205,
0.0301930066,
0.011017452,
-0.0491918586,
-0.021813808,
-0.0207565855,
0.0154866148,
-0.0601549633,
0.0188568011,
0.056422431,
-0.0198317729,
-0.0346296355,
-0.0172996391,
0.103756614,
0.0324448459,
0.0008129945,
0.0122749796,
0.0072177127,
0.0172757283,
0.0089842118,
0.0237834025,
-0.1138336286,
-0.0305176284,
-0.004875619,
0.018888846,
0.0221209358,
-0.0232479125,
0.0157331619,
-0.0697068647,
0.0459822305,
-0.0288963839,
-0.0412529968,
-0.0238823947,
-0.0138610275,
0.0240704529,
-0.0157974325,
-0.0269307271,
0.0135356691,
-0.0257706773,
-0.027802147,
0.032047119,
-0.011100186,
-0.066776298,
0.0451744422,
-0.033692196,
0.0454810709,
0.0440642945,
0.0065819509,
0.0090711694,
-0.035408508,
0.0370453969,
0.0300240237,
0.0346111581,
-0.0238390826,
0.0498107411,
-0.0204260387,
0.0019665244,
-0.0103522474,
0.020544244,
-0.0559953228,
0.0036271177,
0.0183517579,
0.0849148408,
-0.0319073759,
-0.0093615521,
-0.0284276027,
-0.022814272,
0.0184602309,
0.0402381755,
-0.0175464489,
-0.021031566,
-0.0152641051,
-0.0046416158,
-0.0529600531,
0.0355018117,
-0.0706880465,
-0.0255410299,
-0.0498407632,
-0.0405394472,
-0.045041535,
-0.0200880766,
0.0439031348,
-0.0014599438,
0.0171381608,
-0.0132934293,
0.0530398451,
0.0519994088,
-0.0564867221,
-0.0068374574,
-0.0490493998,
0.0119624278,
-0.0237753689,
-0.023044914,
0.0371949077,
-0.0486844033,
-0.0423505045,
0.0025880036,
-0.0230198149,
-0.059754014,
0.0662543848,
0.0302011464,
0.0326048732,
0.0374537297,
-0.0408451594,
-0.0395821072,
0.0740268826,
0.0264198724,
-0.0481319241,
0.0184912905,
-0.0177185722,
0.0293348823,
0.0137042375,
0.0395523421,
-0.0980857685,
0.0435316302,
-0.0157551896,
-0.0237886384,
-0.0136575131,
-0.0676978603,
0.0283686165,
0.0474687628,
0.0194213502,
0.0037945679,
0.0189793743,
-0.0318339467,
0.0109420596,
0.0113526816,
-0.0209570397,
-0.0560373664,
0.0519694649,
-0.0468891039,
-0.009372591,
0.0330957919,
0.0080179563,
0.0086460616,
-0.0066856151,
0.0130118094,
-0.0135373762,
0.0143494876,
0.0154235167,
0.0671623871,
-0.0148472805,
0.0164564643,
0.0096012512,
0.0093947556,
0.0312259439,
-0.0228120256,
0.0804769322,
0.0191490818,
0.0224381406,
-0.0367406942,
0.0255871788,
-0.0454296693,
-0.1240827739,
-0.0201356765,
0.0689450428,
0.048598025,
0.0409842171,
0.0242611114,
-0.1029996872,
0.0109612187,
-0.0240867939,
0.0231765863,
0.022498697,
0.034122359,
0.0192999151,
0.0178339705,
-0.002942845,
-0.0176117551,
0.1009242609,
-0.0082177958,
0.0293288585,
-0.0065331003,
-0.0377379805,
-0.0596368946,
-0.0447294489,
0.0472714677,
-0.008815757,
-0.0254756976,
-0.0495200604,
-0.0699306503,
-0.0675611347,
-0.0494751111,
0.0292578489,
-0.0304395966,
-0.0089464309,
0.0598430261,
0.0514431782,
0.0268170033,
-0.034783043,
-0.0112648355,
-0.0214826372,
-0.015033708,
-0.0290978476,
0.0171477869,
-6.377121505e-33,
-0.0362250879,
-0.0087239724,
0.034718208,
0.0127137331,
-0.0055162162,
-0.0365248136,
0.0140907168,
0.0210200902,
-0.0008500847,
0.0489030592,
0.0020155443,
0.0113602784,
0.01923557,
-0.0289571974,
0.0410997272,
-0.0237881951,
0.059173353,
-0.0262867231,
-0.0123299658,
0.0505039059,
0.0540431589,
0.0237299521,
-0.0219053142,
-0.0855942369,
0.0361731723,
-0.0098958062,
0.0097112842,
0.0314946584,
0.0305981133,
0.0229810178,
-0.0105948327,
0.0812337846,
0.0236403663,
-0.0491481349,
-0.0118360734,
0.0045512537,
-0.0707774609,
-0.0526877493,
0.0274742134,
-0.0156788547,
-0.0200385507,
-0.0122594442,
0.0355303101,
-0.0093687959,
0.0029266167,
0.0029549759,
0.0565857291,
-0.001346604,
0.0087385876,
-0.0447368771,
-0.0918190032,
0.0069900649,
0.013613062,
-0.0712291077,
0.0439289361,
-0.0026563334,
0.0248764865,
-0.0449311584,
-0.0116438717,
0.0100646587,
0.0172261149,
0.0358843394,
0.0754443258,
-0.0047966475,
-0.0252862424,
0.0210112873,
-0.0309031438,
0.0190214738,
0.0213503949,
-0.015432612,
-0.0061577088,
0.0980261564,
-0.0505271666,
0.0278058611,
-0.0044638566,
-0.0295865443,
-0.0196092278,
0.0265064817,
-0.0599415042,
0.024637593,
0.0015515496,
-0.0107255317,
-0.0465109125,
-0.0038844862,
-0.0087307515,
0.0583959818,
-0.0377955697,
-0.0495228618,
0.0374689251,
0.0059789838,
-0.0314640068,
-0.0730833039,
0.0029704277,
-0.0763903633,
0.0149191525,
-0.0331453495,
-0.0323015675,
-0.0011794379,
-0.0223370139,
-0.0249642599,
-0.0515420698,
-0.0259700511,
-0.0114610912,
0.020920638,
0.005858155,
0.0099042989,
-0.0366597287,
0.0341046825,
-0.0341807045,
0.0194097739,
-0.0570156686,
-0.0085254321,
0.0444498509,
0.0035967226,
0.0185679346,
0.0310558807,
-0.0119417496,
-0.0162946228,
0.0138883926,
-0.0576021746,
-0.0314758644,
0.0408933349,
0.0062425546,
-0.0079870978,
-0.0359122865,
-0.0154492166,
-0.0258332752,
-0.0164961964,
0.0217226762,
-0.0056815576,
-0.0006583229,
-0.0350460894,
2.948e-7,
0.0061987322,
0.0313421749,
-0.0135373008,
0.0375414491,
0.023455441,
0.0342757665,
0.0301142484,
0.0193383228,
0.0189793892,
-0.0185292047,
-0.0011631254,
0.0399626009,
0.0176260378,
0.0189230926,
-0.0748657882,
-0.0571290627,
0.0542356409,
-0.0544893295,
-0.0589777268,
0.0194179825,
0.0958196521,
0.029373996,
-0.0014457036,
-0.0089802537,
-0.000519564,
0.0024306886,
-0.0000039631,
-0.0028166773,
0.0424423032,
0.0536671206,
0.0189597402,
0.0208064206,
0.013609889,
0.0740196481,
-0.0111391572,
-0.0183627456,
-0.0189721771,
0.060063567,
0.004777133,
0.0240709428,
-0.0133914361,
-0.056052167,
0.0262916591,
-0.0448729359,
0.0258862507,
-0.0800227597,
0.0171627942,
-0.0284259934,
-0.0346684344,
-0.0537291616,
-0.0412382446,
0.0077051674,
0.0314671658,
0.025700137,
-0.0134404451,
0.0064167124,
-0.0012272305,
-0.0570849888,
0.0077274679,
0.0055107619,
-0.0273045711,
-0.0845266134,
0.0062993048,
-0.0119127668,
0.0278887935,
-0.0539900102,
0.0061152205,
2.443633728e-34,
0.007624913,
0.0307861175,
0.0027385217,
0.0339682549,
0.0053142379,
0.0173791479,
-0.0405652486,
0.0160262324,
-0.0054054516,
-0.0392987058,
-0.0081509221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08426v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08426v1 | Improving End-to-End Speech Translation by Imitation-Based Knowledge Distillation with Synthetic Transcripts | 2023-07-17T12:14:45 | 2023-07-17T12:14:45 | Rebekka Hubert, Artem Sokolov, Stefan Riezler | cs.CL | cs.CL | End-to-end automatic speech translation (AST) relies on data that combines
audio inputs with text translation outputs. Previous work used existing large
parallel corpora of transcriptions and translations in a knowledge distillation
(KD) setup to distill a neural machine translation (NMT) into an AST student
model. While KD allows using larger pretrained models, the reliance of previous
KD approaches on manual audio transcripts in the data pipeline restricts the
applicability of this framework to AST. We present an imitation learning
approach where a teacher NMT system corrects the errors of an AST student
without relying on manual transcripts. We show that the NMT teacher can recover
from errors in automatic transcriptions and is able to correct erroneous
translations of the AST student, leading to improvements of about 4 BLEU points
over the standard AST end-to-end baseline on the English-German CoVoST-2 and
MuST-C datasets, respectively. Code and data are publicly
available.\footnote{\url{https://github.com/HubReb/imitkd_ast/releases/tag/v1.1}} | [
0.012534189,
0.0214756578,
-0.0092879236,
0.0134480838,
0.0038075224,
0.0035757716,
0.0089246342,
-0.0114154229,
-0.0437450595,
-0.0017228032,
-0.0176099688,
-0.0207662098,
0.0213459581,
-0.0090134181,
0.0372418165,
-0.0218248423,
0.0127180964,
-0.0319575481,
-0.0111565264,
-0.0307716317,
-0.0099429004,
0.022049142,
-0.0235687904,
0.0160627272,
0.0117532033,
0.029161483,
-0.0225753784,
0.0308374893,
0.0195325911,
-0.0021294577,
0.0034634541,
-0.0224316996,
0.0336239971,
0.0608336367,
0.0000021295,
-0.0265245344,
0.0046197386,
-0.0145338317,
-0.0464312248,
0.0055386839,
0.0169768389,
-0.0026042948,
0.0067510032,
0.0672070086,
-0.0279183462,
-0.0142343352,
0.0152791031,
-0.0221159961,
0.0408451781,
0.082507737,
0.0015916371,
-0.0522915646,
0.0088986661,
-0.0388343595,
-0.000778951,
-0.0113179926,
-0.0279069971,
0.0026664173,
0.0070566935,
0.0021389232,
-0.0157202799,
0.0692699775,
0.0106811067,
-0.0315377302,
-0.0030224263,
-0.0040699178,
-0.0179621689,
-0.0730630681,
-0.018617142,
0.083818309,
-0.0130772125,
-0.0111267762,
0.0209919736,
0.0139450366,
0.0017084804,
-0.0311929304,
-0.0287375674,
0.0181391779,
0.0208970457,
-0.0080692405,
0.0025660784,
0.021879904,
0.0168068577,
-0.0403472669,
-0.04493412,
-0.0535407476,
0.0084496662,
-0.0340495855,
0.0172185991,
-0.003521777,
-0.0251723491,
-0.0177950673,
0.0477947854,
-0.0068394495,
0.0115775885,
0.0075077978,
-0.0343899503,
-0.055545982,
-0.0384799354,
0.0211639665,
0.0220206641,
0.079405576,
-0.0283126961,
-0.003264707,
-0.000590792,
0.0892133415,
0.0222087838,
0.0424414463,
-0.0473203249,
0.007017483,
-0.063676849,
0.0540662892,
-0.044193849,
0.0040720105,
-0.0623978227,
0.0056246677,
0.0012974308,
-0.0192944426,
-0.0290983133,
0.0322957039,
0.0505490042,
-0.0253615733,
-0.0843710452,
0.0100445691,
-0.0066907755,
0.0800565481,
0.0201534498,
0.0035881046,
0.018285146,
-0.0476864353,
-0.044333376,
-0.0073529622,
0.031453304,
-0.007851433,
0.0140789552,
0.0320866965,
-0.0097300103,
-0.0401117988,
0.0197235234,
-0.0000857301,
-0.0368519612,
-0.0800187886,
0.0272624865,
-0.0638635531,
0.0809616297,
-0.0204191487,
0.0105664833,
-0.026355477,
-0.0063088858,
-0.0444074981,
0.0224204026,
0.0421856716,
-0.0113234092,
0.0304987449,
0.0296510924,
0.0218150299,
-0.0179717671,
0.0483240224,
0.0584768541,
-0.0201027039,
-0.0327792056,
-0.003425915,
-0.0087110167,
0.037482623,
0.048720628,
0.0422592312,
-0.0045685847,
-0.0081097046,
-0.003098838,
0.0409722738,
0.0481014289,
0.0592700876,
-0.0459390283,
0.0320060886,
0.0587073527,
-0.0072534787,
0.0217071474,
0.0036485887,
0.0373104252,
0.0256800931,
-0.0111252852,
0.0044639325,
-0.0193007067,
0.0014150951,
0.0330918878,
0.0156286452,
0.0559472665,
0.0537878387,
0.001067301,
-0.0280163605,
0.0115888547,
-0.0056233504,
-0.0253694151,
0.0079811169,
-0.0048947739,
0.028848229,
-0.0504345298,
0.0220997892,
-0.0050047305,
-0.0612567998,
0.0532107465,
-0.0273605864,
-0.032414794,
0.0384586714,
0.0288516805,
-0.0178504512,
0.0046711829,
-0.0795463771,
-0.0532495305,
0.0484138057,
0.0248456001,
-0.0026490551,
0.0549186133,
-0.0589352995,
-0.0049883807,
0.0019227316,
0.0299020298,
0.0199916493,
-0.0341154188,
0.0615469888,
0.0217373222,
-0.0254605804,
-0.0187176373,
0.0065686023,
-0.0591600724,
-0.0331843048,
-0.0046689576,
0.0185263604,
0.0526428521,
0.0431966111,
-0.0332167931,
-0.0128970193,
0.0131763034,
-0.0200508051,
-0.0098700924,
0.0236349199,
-0.0790600702,
-0.1029263139,
0.0664326325,
-0.0707992464,
0.0121506443,
0.0349841453,
-0.0167082176,
-0.1101409048,
0.002491365,
-0.0156602692,
0.0698572099,
-0.0071699666,
0.0473976247,
0.0368618369,
-0.0270022489,
0.0085147331,
-0.0283875652,
0.0029717432,
-0.0117109055,
0.0020807111,
-0.0405736603,
0.0096986331,
-0.0301885512,
-0.0289968997,
0.0361172482,
0.0003755746,
0.0577403009,
0.0233656447,
0.0065996875,
-0.0064820587,
-0.0210597534,
-0.053358525,
0.0108680092,
-0.0193233881,
0.0086213872,
0.036211174,
0.0741791278,
0.0036351602,
-0.0110825617,
-0.0206796005,
-0.0012448585,
0.0126285357,
-0.0429677777,
-0.0476773083,
0.0008440134,
0.0066092857,
-0.010652028,
0.0144187249,
0.0185543839,
-0.0138048595,
-0.0512188412,
0.0152604328,
-0.0224617831,
0.030902043,
-0.0133912843,
0.0475433432,
-0.0053789313,
-0.0393818542,
0.0072274911,
-0.0376501009,
0.0251991339,
0.0098905545,
-0.0311087221,
-0.0369844958,
0.0113498894,
-0.0156373661,
-0.1054417118,
0.0344705954,
-0.0062508075,
0.0067719622,
-0.042529691,
0.0038733603,
-0.0441950373,
0.0430189334,
0.0346565917,
-0.0193763245,
-0.0674313456,
-0.0276462454,
0.014059619,
-0.0119862072,
-0.0194243845,
-0.023243269,
-0.0058039813,
-0.0040505752,
-0.0108341109,
-0.0115231657,
0.0333033502,
-0.0581081882,
-0.042669218,
-0.0692458972,
-0.007966469,
0.0166901145,
0.0226420574,
-0.0280949865,
-0.0032296635,
-0.0427356698,
-0.0054017203,
-0.0352290533,
0.0074050375,
0.014794996,
-0.0473595001,
0.0539872907,
-0.0533609129,
0.0064160177,
-0.0058752485,
-0.0474397615,
-0.030114593,
0.0228672177,
-0.011117612,
0.0005551585,
0.0014170847,
-0.0617456362,
-0.0363648236,
-0.0224513654,
0.014538696,
0.1191602647,
0.0046224236,
0.0080492236,
-0.0349143967,
0.0062362226,
-0.0061052227,
0.0181348287,
-0.0025468208,
-0.0294978991,
0.061243996,
-0.0119410148,
0.0578535348,
-0.0098794969,
-0.0319114849,
-0.0191522148,
0.0295972358,
0.0217663758,
-0.0121008903,
0.0067624534,
0.0474273749,
-0.033748433,
-0.0209945589,
0.0883854255,
-0.0044400566,
-0.0054518119,
-0.0110260481,
0.0390011556,
0.0574072525,
0.0169593822,
0.0144492872,
-0.1117374748,
-0.022190433,
0.0384693593,
0.0816315711,
0.0424278378,
0.0320861787,
-0.0353739187,
-0.1065734923,
0.0292958654,
0.0771470666,
-0.0872024223,
-0.0737555772,
0.0157103781,
-0.0443910919,
-0.0279929563,
0.0589512922,
0.0147954877,
0.0192667991,
0.0130849322,
0.024918735,
0.0090818023,
-0.0723427385,
-0.0059643462,
-0.0027157767,
0.1086245328,
0.0340011232,
0.0419392101,
0.0197795611,
-0.0307318158,
-0.0069636297,
-0.0177479256,
-0.0101042585,
0.0071661556,
0.023680672,
0.0201819874,
-0.0107952459,
0.0576910451,
0.0580789819,
-0.0249744039,
0.0439647809,
0.0137419375,
0.0560175739,
-0.0390783958,
-0.0193265583,
0.049599167,
-0.0255104825,
0.0438688919,
0.0476200096,
0.0243086908,
-0.0107300123,
0.0052846284,
0.0020571281,
-0.0100960368,
-0.0914809704,
0.0346434787,
0.0294128843,
-0.0311061144,
-0.0162976962,
-0.0693192706,
-0.0276012216,
-0.0030800602,
0.042102538,
0.0241406038,
-0.0236908663,
0.0329584777,
0.0017440502,
-0.0145196915,
0.030681584,
-0.0239994507,
0.0228978246,
-0.0248890445,
-0.0114465784,
0.0198077261,
-0.0712104142,
-0.0079866201,
0.0201053247,
-0.0967305079,
-0.0859378427,
0.0371281356,
0.0337038524,
0.0209185164,
0.1043361127,
-0.046344433,
0.0081179254,
0.0898515433,
-0.0031792547,
-0.0720904171,
0.0002239427,
0.0479094088,
-0.0213794243,
-0.0007650793,
0.014741201,
-0.0054572988,
0.0272057708,
-0.0224011689,
0.0387799144,
0.0157070849,
-0.0337517522,
0.0221255589,
0.0475149415,
0.0412692949,
0.0123064239,
0.020023698,
-0.052257847,
0.0262283385,
0.0295652784,
0.0396333076,
-0.0660032853,
-0.0183153152,
0.0621116683,
0.0270328633,
0.0005535728,
-0.0194822233,
-0.0096406834,
-0.0528420247,
-0.0054179183,
0.012260587,
-0.0017972102,
0.0239745993,
0.0384640209,
0.0117298476,
0.0126021225,
0.0707655996,
0.0254713856,
0.0359906293,
-0.0119002005,
0.0311514251,
0.0088223265,
0.0218598451,
0.0519454181,
-0.0105664739,
-0.0352885723,
-0.0237808991,
-0.0307700392,
0.0428011753,
0.0452318713,
0.0202635489,
0.107834585,
-0.0078594359,
0.0266937334,
0.0006257962,
0.0133461878,
-0.0447079614,
0.0137433801,
0.0107146334,
-0.0164814666,
0.0281724036,
0.0337881669,
0.0305835847,
-0.0346428305,
0.0547309257,
-0.0325545222,
0.072183609,
-0.0299984664,
-0.0426560342,
-0.0092996899,
-0.0246327948,
-0.0015248253,
-0.0187729597,
0.017946193,
-0.0695586801,
-0.0348100848,
0.0288748741,
-0.0243668593,
-0.0385161787,
0.0166211203,
0.0008019098,
-0.0600848086,
0.006024966,
-0.0172176082,
-0.036934562,
0.0095104435,
-0.0653849915,
0.0048813075,
-6.517904586e-33,
-0.0149541982,
0.0424578041,
0.0333188921,
-0.0353519954,
-0.0822220668,
-0.0286898781,
-0.0075871777,
-0.0377704389,
0.0025786494,
0.0031096058,
-0.0156521313,
0.0514073111,
0.0206609573,
0.0160878357,
-0.0017394997,
0.029004572,
0.0768644363,
-0.016813131,
-0.02433387,
0.0565986,
0.0436427109,
0.0264985301,
0.0675357431,
-0.0439747646,
-0.0107313218,
-0.0106494036,
-0.0008526078,
0.0041522132,
-0.0414429083,
-0.0051659234,
0.0237063169,
0.0174386445,
-0.0286139157,
-0.015181236,
-0.0512572452,
-0.0191274118,
-0.0800252184,
-0.0026935397,
0.0158527661,
0.0455457382,
-0.008915972,
-0.0060510994,
0.0703983828,
-0.0397072993,
-0.0038613367,
-0.0161841307,
-0.0190548226,
-0.0043244259,
-0.0071755676,
-0.0242765434,
-0.0164544061,
-0.0098298108,
-0.0359322913,
-0.0449202172,
0.0449760482,
0.0385392122,
-0.0147627611,
-0.0664619133,
-0.1047650874,
0.0378369689,
0.0124591161,
0.0438333452,
0.0414690115,
0.004405567,
-0.0237741247,
-0.0037940973,
0.0114851464,
-0.0364206247,
0.0520702489,
-0.026905071,
0.0575253107,
0.0075427759,
0.0183766074,
0.016005218,
0.0600023009,
-0.0310163312,
0.0086389622,
0.0090133818,
-0.0127903447,
-0.0149173737,
-0.0280372798,
0.0151440287,
-0.0035402759,
0.0144823026,
-0.0866316333,
-0.0143232765,
0.0052661914,
0.0050621037,
0.034625642,
0.0296616908,
-0.0166231431,
-0.0510095879,
0.0750551075,
-0.0375350378,
0.0340106599,
-0.0370011367,
-0.0437568054,
-0.0069059818,
-0.0464964546,
0.0222811438,
-0.0519337803,
-0.0612662844,
0.0544402786,
0.0580896959,
0.0046252413,
-0.0101500563,
0.020630125,
0.0747080892,
-0.0410488509,
0.0127438502,
-0.0339801535,
0.0526416525,
0.0039029601,
-0.02047088,
0.0365611687,
0.0009693861,
-0.0001800202,
-0.0110359779,
0.0187393744,
-0.0138846515,
-0.0131595777,
0.0224610027,
0.0282207839,
0.0132245934,
-0.0717476159,
0.0045687663,
0.0060629221,
-0.0217843354,
0.0049349377,
-0.0390292779,
0.0014926952,
0.0014976956,
2.947e-7,
-0.0156458393,
0.012289675,
0.0239522755,
-0.0175721124,
0.0230531823,
-0.0086277742,
-0.0317053087,
-0.0002692378,
0.0040226728,
-0.0099373944,
0.048623953,
0.0097001065,
0.1045797244,
0.0200468749,
-0.0969846472,
-0.0396619067,
-0.0434921943,
0.026467694,
-0.0269943755,
-0.0423913859,
-0.0032451528,
0.064293012,
0.0113873621,
-0.0150830392,
0.0003814939,
-0.0029848344,
0.0221443959,
0.0372724161,
0.0089814467,
-0.0280637741,
0.0434391461,
-0.0095073553,
-0.0402767435,
0.0274360739,
-0.0419127159,
0.0459682569,
-0.0057937633,
0.0502369665,
-0.0006323943,
-0.0227522906,
0.0012339181,
0.0377609022,
-0.0098096821,
-0.0334244967,
-0.0026061358,
-0.0322398953,
0.0473447554,
0.0130600771,
-0.0486010723,
-0.0123806354,
0.0274087824,
-0.0082601579,
0.0336904526,
0.0406375192,
0.0131168123,
0.0109869316,
0.0058371508,
-0.0369229838,
-0.0011095242,
0.0115884561,
-0.0373265333,
-0.0482528955,
-0.0187748615,
0.0029866851,
-0.0314675644,
0.0047642551,
-0.0166756269,
2.322007026e-34,
0.0307420045,
-0.0263909567,
0.0524186566,
-0.0453270711,
0.0253359657,
-0.0344022922,
-0.0300014243,
0.0170883723,
-0.00389751,
-0.0390998684,
-0.0608137771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08416v1 | Enhancing Supervised Learning with Contrastive Markings in Neural Machine Translation Training | 2023-07-17T11:56:32 | 2023-07-17T11:56:32 | Nathaniel Berger, Miriam Exel, Matthias Huck, Stefan Riezler | cs.CL | cs.CL | Supervised learning in Neural Machine Translation (NMT) typically follows a
teacher forcing paradigm where reference tokens constitute the conditioning
context in the model's prediction, instead of its own previous predictions. In
order to alleviate this lack of exploration in the space of translations, we
present a simple extension of standard maximum likelihood estimation by a
contrastive marking objective. The additional training signals are extracted
automatically from reference translations by comparing the system hypothesis
against the reference, and used for up/down-weighting correct/incorrect tokens.
The proposed new training procedure requires one additional translation pass
over the training set per epoch, and does not alter the standard inference
setup. We show that training with contrastive markings yields improvements on
top of supervised learning, and is especially useful when learning from
postedits where contrastive markings indicate human error corrections to the
original hypotheses. Code is publicly released. | [
0.0351187177,
0.0423540808,
0.0006552259,
0.0036335157,
-0.0092288107,
0.0151136117,
0.0291731656,
0.001415047,
-0.026413545,
-0.0267825387,
-0.0381205492,
-0.0395561755,
0.0038819057,
-0.0479000658,
0.0696972832,
-0.0753158554,
0.0120072225,
-0.0167390294,
-0.0238792785,
0.0099585494,
-0.0275520161,
-0.0031278243,
-0.0143156042,
0.0346844792,
-0.0743218139,
0.0035539998,
0.0239851624,
0.0549834333,
0.056200061,
-0.0649711713,
0.0145506822,
0.0603673756,
0.006700214,
0.0622686483,
0.0000021932,
-0.0149993375,
-0.0429727025,
0.0022829655,
0.0317603126,
0.0047817091,
0.0575042553,
-0.0681787655,
-0.0187425315,
0.0294770151,
-0.0205878597,
-0.0426828377,
0.07812953,
0.0332291201,
0.0509353355,
0.0764989406,
-0.0014318065,
-0.0153311789,
-0.0157627501,
-0.0459262505,
-0.0264629573,
-0.0105772913,
0.0088770483,
0.017116474,
-0.0566650257,
0.0231956542,
0.0026005125,
0.0531871468,
0.0597103573,
-0.0188070145,
-0.037675675,
0.0145051144,
0.0214723162,
0.0055414727,
-0.0179625284,
0.0339239128,
-0.0117694158,
-0.0037590221,
-0.0409291163,
-0.0198815037,
0.0122435866,
-0.0417440943,
-0.0209756717,
0.000578327,
-0.0085293297,
0.0345181078,
0.0641626641,
0.0383516401,
0.0271234736,
0.0161527339,
-0.0304760747,
0.0002262295,
0.0222066157,
-0.0356005207,
-0.0161583479,
0.0276467912,
-0.0331959277,
0.0005565007,
0.0545071438,
-0.0135169001,
-0.0097984578,
0.0212924294,
-0.0215988122,
-0.0827644467,
0.0085542705,
-0.0266067423,
0.0461577959,
0.0737278536,
-0.0512335822,
0.0262897387,
-0.0129050184,
0.054432828,
-0.0366630107,
0.0140624288,
-0.0485150851,
-0.0025903853,
0.0040835701,
0.020337183,
-0.0526150167,
-0.0207473096,
-0.0071297893,
0.0325741321,
-0.0412628502,
-0.0067106537,
-0.0105833504,
-0.0028422906,
-0.005331526,
-0.0503592938,
-0.0922293738,
0.0111196768,
0.0060191229,
0.0442559421,
-0.0293328948,
-0.0078126537,
0.0068208305,
-0.0591470487,
-0.0432999171,
0.0129073029,
-0.0231098495,
-0.0420910455,
-0.0079866275,
0.1000193506,
-0.005619782,
-0.0223586243,
-0.0583510548,
-0.0204107407,
-0.00663502,
-0.0000515305,
0.0394299813,
-0.0613392703,
0.0166712906,
-0.0082664043,
0.0226452779,
-0.0413665175,
-0.0108295931,
-0.0128185041,
0.0336217508,
0.0499672741,
-0.0272613037,
-0.0655832738,
0.0258047208,
-0.0043523177,
-0.0502145737,
0.058702752,
0.030169772,
0.0110881459,
0.0038545833,
0.0162470024,
0.009624565,
0.0555783324,
0.0347968303,
0.0147900842,
-0.0665106103,
-0.0314752273,
0.0749903023,
0.0192824323,
0.0411470123,
0.0379850343,
-0.0434610955,
0.0060774311,
0.046470847,
0.0253063198,
-0.008519792,
0.0360880755,
0.0527028888,
-0.0294895284,
-0.0015202714,
0.0584704988,
-0.0301334076,
0.0154985879,
-0.0144127812,
-0.0156670306,
0.0045664231,
-0.0103040971,
-0.0081617264,
-0.0829225928,
-0.0150357829,
-0.006627752,
-0.0261113029,
-0.0626203567,
0.0378341265,
0.0357976668,
-0.034436617,
0.0164917558,
0.0282336548,
-0.0117163043,
0.0341745131,
-0.0414381325,
-0.0400581248,
0.0321085639,
0.0181899406,
-0.0424473397,
-0.010145016,
-0.0222380366,
0.025978161,
0.0895688683,
0.0547771044,
0.0376201011,
0.0116698593,
-0.0367226042,
-0.0062391362,
0.0015952982,
0.0196587462,
0.0176271331,
0.0043161134,
0.0291211735,
0.0348043889,
-0.0221115686,
-0.0978822857,
0.0642011315,
0.0363214239,
-0.0430331677,
0.0460273065,
0.0133344252,
0.0345012061,
0.0097372821,
-0.0244864412,
-0.0166039821,
-0.0025246423,
-0.0404050201,
-0.0140543189,
0.0065854033,
-0.0717260987,
-0.0456508473,
0.0440632589,
-0.0892729759,
-0.0231121331,
0.0126494654,
-0.0470044389,
-0.0511498712,
-0.0165743865,
-0.037806388,
0.025953861,
-0.0175309405,
0.0012739857,
0.0308079123,
-0.0118332617,
-0.0293965247,
0.0393690877,
0.0001530557,
-0.001649406,
0.0235894341,
-0.0258574504,
-0.0029470974,
-0.0105708782,
-0.0185795426,
-0.0028097683,
0.0109970681,
0.0245362986,
0.0183190219,
0.0472765975,
-0.0447920933,
-0.0131699853,
-0.0212682523,
0.000780874,
-0.0185001474,
0.0427256748,
0.0459190309,
0.0138417529,
-0.0034212116,
-0.0330343805,
-0.0191158,
-0.0178933889,
-0.0417551696,
-0.0022260456,
0.0362779833,
0.0142153166,
0.0293410644,
-0.0426395647,
-0.0237009451,
-0.0146546448,
0.0269442499,
0.0354932994,
-0.0080965776,
-0.0967832357,
0.0603771396,
-0.010317116,
0.0252916664,
-0.0020420882,
-0.0735252872,
0.0554227419,
-0.0250167772,
0.0201930478,
0.043523822,
0.0118936412,
0.004614763,
0.0165336877,
0.0142771155,
-0.0644638464,
0.0191198606,
-0.0327757038,
0.0082548158,
0.0122023579,
-0.0494412109,
0.0090807127,
0.0279265158,
0.020228846,
0.0070751077,
-0.0518989302,
-0.0022731342,
-0.0152907167,
-0.0151017904,
0.0010540391,
0.0433979258,
0.0164148547,
0.008045949,
-0.0098246345,
-0.0563105457,
0.1006071121,
-0.0281322263,
-0.0048842337,
-0.041211728,
-0.0063620196,
-0.0141368825,
-0.0030076171,
-0.0257454515,
0.0102685569,
-0.0055668759,
-0.0261986237,
-0.022786703,
-0.0041872743,
-0.0048426366,
-0.0119090239,
-0.0194099322,
-0.0725397691,
-0.0289443787,
-0.0133975465,
-0.0081068128,
-0.0209556706,
0.0212667789,
-0.0092593012,
0.0176660493,
-0.0062125968,
-0.0214214344,
0.0031106831,
0.0003078074,
0.0068930527,
0.097091414,
-0.005812339,
-0.0056577288,
-0.0248678233,
-0.032829266,
-0.0289460886,
-0.0120082777,
0.0179405082,
-0.0698593035,
0.0229556188,
0.0375996418,
0.021275226,
-0.0114250202,
-0.0568243377,
-0.0109258825,
0.0341740213,
0.0090074353,
-0.0058791949,
-0.0059380978,
0.0171212871,
-0.0760307759,
0.0036266013,
0.1055784896,
0.0096341735,
-0.0621818528,
-0.0017618552,
-0.0090504969,
0.0176634472,
0.0117109371,
0.0165327806,
-0.0631447509,
-0.0287700761,
-0.0131128943,
0.0631248951,
0.0080255335,
0.0254208297,
-0.0150835123,
-0.0740214586,
0.0148690278,
0.0447489843,
-0.0994364619,
-0.0233493652,
-0.0154042346,
-0.0048787901,
-0.022097582,
0.0231360178,
-0.0268120971,
0.0319707915,
0.0026489261,
0.0520206168,
0.0729792193,
-0.0443595238,
-0.0588900894,
-0.0909237713,
0.0059252479,
0.0629383624,
0.0002231587,
-0.0011425841,
-0.0382988006,
0.0468723178,
-0.0628440008,
0.019235082,
-0.0453018732,
0.0343259275,
-0.0193659142,
-0.0209763478,
0.0016735101,
0.0225736946,
-0.0261064526,
0.0175534505,
0.0143565657,
0.0591087677,
-0.0007210669,
0.0155037371,
0.0053957612,
0.0094824396,
0.0336112529,
0.0195683353,
0.0286012255,
-0.0608110614,
0.0342139937,
-0.0367943756,
0.0266597643,
-0.0268889815,
0.0104458984,
-0.0148934433,
-0.0419950299,
-0.0085175708,
-0.0966498107,
-0.0481730439,
0.0105225118,
0.0819203556,
0.011863092,
-0.0072701634,
-0.0129105682,
-0.0575995706,
0.0064161024,
0.042773556,
-0.0263216496,
-0.0171227064,
-0.0534687825,
-0.0004484682,
0.0315572321,
-0.0359509848,
0.0057937624,
0.0460899659,
-0.0533127934,
-0.0688247085,
-0.0206764117,
0.0832987428,
0.017161306,
0.0622879192,
-0.0386615582,
-0.021729134,
0.0130402371,
0.0322889946,
0.018933421,
-0.0230899118,
0.0400906727,
-0.0286433231,
-0.0077768257,
0.0094189877,
0.0017676575,
0.0081871394,
0.0498057269,
0.0424856246,
-0.0325896069,
-0.0290780924,
0.0483533889,
-0.0139815928,
0.0803095177,
-0.0234794915,
-0.0394859053,
-0.0302561764,
0.0285683516,
-0.0044159601,
-0.0340320691,
-0.0406874642,
0.0210064594,
0.0064441846,
-0.0036243245,
-0.0219224095,
0.0020325268,
0.0030179187,
0.0012751403,
0.020325426,
-0.0209272131,
-0.0275038313,
0.039336551,
-0.0347447731,
0.0185295548,
-0.0017080907,
0.0353548713,
0.0285341442,
0.046751041,
-0.0065551405,
0.0514484644,
0.0254003387,
-0.0057728826,
0.0135324318,
0.0099266069,
-0.0575655364,
-0.0143766059,
-0.0519708917,
0.0038152658,
0.0647466108,
-0.0052283891,
0.0770777687,
-0.0342050418,
-0.0060095247,
0.0047016004,
0.0427983031,
0.0098558255,
-0.0052934894,
0.011744163,
-0.004563198,
0.0459537283,
0.0139138857,
0.0227823649,
-0.0291605387,
0.0400304832,
-0.0427179784,
0.0072166207,
-0.0093009723,
0.013457655,
0.017994225,
-0.0481771603,
0.0175442323,
-0.0012157742,
-0.0075059105,
-0.0564227886,
0.0049260017,
0.0453057885,
0.007422281,
0.010849,
0.0271285586,
0.0459298119,
-0.0475990959,
-0.0325009562,
-0.0193719417,
-0.0129936989,
0.0699754357,
-0.0442533642,
-0.0553071387,
-6.978930532e-33,
-0.0545888096,
-0.0326593965,
0.0125470283,
-0.0182446614,
-0.0013012971,
0.0125347059,
0.0022530344,
-0.0324364081,
0.0079487497,
0.028244501,
0.0189118069,
0.0367573276,
0.0308963396,
-0.0104595385,
-0.0044877301,
0.0171687361,
0.0818122551,
0.0062675341,
-0.0331322253,
-0.016491266,
0.0266977679,
0.010334244,
0.1290219724,
-0.0475934073,
0.0268429387,
0.0008961486,
-0.0332381316,
0.0378717892,
-0.0425791256,
0.0256227665,
0.0109589519,
-0.0219897628,
0.0079434942,
-0.0321122892,
-0.0242965147,
-0.0738549754,
-0.0780684948,
-0.0285553038,
0.004053765,
0.0537977442,
-0.0507290289,
-0.0584061518,
0.0790660679,
-0.0359796956,
-0.0253509823,
0.0113570383,
0.0098108323,
-0.0286783017,
0.0023969051,
0.0276280884,
-0.0403935499,
0.0273133069,
-0.0045476314,
0.0065903217,
-0.0022819911,
0.0807051435,
0.0010422233,
-0.0322859846,
-0.1178208888,
-0.017152587,
0.006991528,
0.0393774882,
0.0392753184,
0.0404165983,
-0.0214216262,
0.0048253434,
0.0262095723,
-0.0146408165,
0.062472146,
-0.0522833094,
0.02659861,
-0.037123844,
0.1020043269,
0.0091383206,
0.0553882606,
0.0099590095,
-0.0539612323,
0.0382147282,
-0.0402783044,
0.0155762872,
0.0138561577,
0.0156152388,
-0.03176184,
0.0100443847,
-0.0526118465,
-0.0882726535,
-0.0342785344,
-0.0311315097,
-0.0092564719,
0.0284305159,
-0.0519510247,
-0.020051524,
0.0511088893,
0.0239214301,
0.0419861972,
-0.0332760811,
-0.0182981435,
0.0201809201,
-0.0222559795,
0.0063049318,
-0.0085552977,
-0.024974877,
0.0327326059,
0.0366802253,
0.038998533,
-0.0105190603,
0.080619514,
0.0156622827,
-0.0360202603,
0.0310601853,
-0.0271752682,
0.008936055,
0.0184273999,
-0.0541209765,
0.0501605086,
-0.0364465639,
0.0027507127,
0.0448605604,
0.0546281673,
0.0056589036,
-0.0244171172,
0.0367515236,
0.0126964524,
0.0455496535,
-0.0518739745,
0.0046889768,
0.0194835383,
0.0260267667,
0.0175090395,
-0.0571701378,
-0.0401561409,
0.0234121624,
2.934e-7,
0.0631028339,
0.0364014469,
0.0289994907,
0.0305419043,
0.018077299,
0.02819179,
-0.0332420655,
0.0000472604,
0.0479448251,
0.0411745757,
0.0411366373,
0.0099497754,
0.0610605963,
0.0471726432,
-0.0668453723,
-0.0488460883,
-0.0137865283,
0.0204136986,
-0.0200830009,
-0.0039324234,
0.0910598487,
0.0721038729,
-0.0007718418,
-0.0070774723,
-0.0018795094,
-0.0245665424,
0.066775918,
-0.008885338,
0.010286021,
-0.0394988246,
0.0304926243,
0.034286648,
-0.015523117,
0.0085399803,
-0.0218045451,
-0.010837825,
0.0137795983,
0.0396621935,
-0.008413882,
0.0402247049,
0.0251952112,
0.0257787313,
0.0020121078,
-0.0075733862,
0.0235216152,
-0.0263347682,
0.0191807393,
-0.0069921431,
-0.0244957656,
-0.0145530943,
0.0350885689,
-0.0582408793,
-0.0516552292,
0.0137700858,
0.0141401719,
0.0326407254,
-0.0419960245,
-0.0047682235,
-0.0444879308,
-0.0230052136,
0.0048680906,
-0.0165892299,
-0.0205827262,
0.0024614946,
-0.0288651213,
-0.0308182389,
0.0030858361,
2.499931642e-34,
0.0478501022,
-0.0505561344,
0.0274938345,
0.0137236053,
0.0314706825,
0.0204435643,
-0.0415454134,
-0.0119658634,
0.0345596708,
-0.0130545637,
-0.0475934595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08393v1 | On the application of Large Language Models for language teaching and assessment technology | 2023-07-17T11:12:56 | 2023-07-17T11:12:56 | Andrew Caines, Luca Benedetto, Shiva Taslimipoor, Christopher Davis, Yuan Gao, Oeistein Andersen, Zheng Yuan, Mark Elliott, Russell Moore, Christopher Bryant, Marek Rei, Helen Yannakoudakis, Andrew Mullooly, Diane Nicholls, Paula Buttery | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The recent release of very large language models such as PaLM and GPT-4 has
made an unprecedented impact in the popular media and public consciousness,
giving rise to a mixture of excitement and fear as to their capabilities and
potential uses, and shining a light on natural language processing research
which had not previously received so much attention. The developments offer
great promise for education technology, and in this paper we look specifically
at the potential for incorporating large language models in AI-driven language
teaching and assessment systems. We consider several research areas and also
discuss the risks and ethical considerations surrounding generative AI in
education technology for language learners. Overall we find that larger
language models offer improvements over previous models in text generation,
opening up routes toward content generation which had not previously been
plausible. For text generation they must be prompted carefully and their
outputs may need to be reshaped before they are ready for use. For automated
grading and grammatical error correction, tasks whose progress is checked on
well-known benchmarks, early investigations indicate that large language models
on their own do not improve on state-of-the-art results according to standard
evaluation metrics. For grading it appears that linguistic features established
in the literature should still be used for best performance, and for error
correction it may be that the models can offer alternative feedback styles
which are not measured sensitively with existing methods. In all cases, there
is work to be done to experiment with the inclusion of large language models in
education technology for language learners, in order to properly understand and
report on their capacities and limitations, and to ensure that foreseeable
risks such as misinformation and harmful bias are mitigated. | [
0.0571902655,
0.0137487287,
-0.0414934158,
0.0116848797,
-0.0743825808,
-0.0021870907,
0.0443376675,
-0.0311240144,
0.0186476391,
-0.0933969393,
-0.012347579,
-0.0372078568,
0.0114071649,
0.0315429531,
0.0242403671,
-0.0714206696,
0.0125934146,
-0.0096001606,
0.0124599719,
0.0144319879,
0.0101924185,
0.0173972286,
-0.0149484482,
0.0634337887,
-0.0330557078,
-0.0190326963,
-0.0024892457,
-0.032830555,
-0.00063094,
-0.002320166,
0.0267091468,
0.0689089298,
-0.0042374353,
0.0610828251,
0.000002057,
-0.0447520427,
0.0166263003,
-0.0059481449,
0.0290835686,
0.0413092449,
0.064253442,
0.0244502649,
-0.0403850973,
0.0315390937,
-0.0446343273,
-0.0290946048,
0.0334826149,
-0.000119516,
0.0440176837,
0.0521232411,
0.0039398177,
-0.0115380641,
0.057799872,
0.0224847104,
-0.0140310097,
0.0300417896,
0.029947754,
0.0207814332,
0.0381260328,
0.0205159076,
-0.0288804546,
0.0203146953,
0.0215267092,
-0.0524547249,
0.004754005,
0.0180265587,
-0.0269911159,
-0.0219503902,
-0.0037754986,
0.0173113104,
0.0105641708,
-0.0248878356,
-0.0095391283,
0.0011521601,
0.0011406976,
0.0111257425,
-0.0457824729,
0.0592126884,
0.0046150577,
0.0127172656,
0.0755781084,
-0.0293295626,
-0.0088290209,
0.0372505747,
0.006262389,
0.0252949279,
0.0465362594,
-0.0567007326,
-0.0163246784,
0.0607447103,
-0.0218934733,
-0.0584984235,
0.0206195973,
0.0461067073,
-0.0088125831,
0.0388740227,
-0.0614525676,
-0.0419355445,
0.024590658,
-0.0424602441,
0.0540341809,
0.033274252,
0.0089742402,
-0.0123100653,
-0.0044668927,
0.087872237,
0.0336164944,
0.0137449633,
-0.036800798,
0.0250391215,
-0.0302117504,
-0.0321596898,
-0.0423711948,
0.0499795452,
-0.0172241554,
0.0066807508,
-0.0688669309,
0.0031493877,
-0.0300432574,
0.0272830855,
0.0293626618,
-0.0170880556,
-0.0358451381,
0.0182429645,
-0.0141851949,
0.0386659391,
-0.0051297266,
0.011309403,
0.0159937963,
-0.0520258211,
0.0278960578,
0.0057782368,
-0.0027368602,
-0.0219108183,
0.0081240153,
0.040990524,
-0.0043113292,
-0.0381898172,
-0.0141694285,
-0.0375109129,
-0.0276522245,
-0.0735971332,
-0.0162500907,
-0.0836277902,
-0.0278156027,
0.0036203524,
0.0071775145,
-0.010654673,
0.0165600255,
0.0346337892,
0.0156243835,
-0.0060055535,
-0.0103309434,
0.018090874,
0.0477564968,
-0.0038931502,
0.0162891001,
0.0226419568,
0.0566227399,
-0.0112926364,
0.01354477,
-0.0535094962,
0.0267240591,
0.0415055826,
-0.0239546318,
-0.0193622001,
-0.0226269253,
-0.0490223914,
-0.0018185478,
0.0322150141,
-0.0214842968,
0.0963939205,
-0.0000550195,
0.0412829518,
0.0663915277,
0.0509669781,
-0.0191021841,
0.0477004461,
0.0882499889,
-0.0087020714,
0.0339445621,
0.0427053683,
-0.0118707744,
-0.0249525141,
-0.0341742337,
0.0078660054,
0.0125275599,
0.0495571755,
-0.0017676266,
-0.0911106393,
-0.0165893994,
-0.0058604474,
0.0194500592,
-0.0008518876,
0.0710663572,
0.0001392346,
-0.0210628379,
-0.0357355885,
0.0442184098,
-0.0733372197,
0.0652228817,
-0.0822278261,
0.0380878001,
0.0970820189,
0.0838547051,
-0.0010593318,
-0.0073814932,
-0.0146975182,
-0.0251724143,
0.0750807375,
0.0637153015,
-0.028315099,
-0.0761921778,
-0.0341728218,
0.0181051306,
-0.0027433059,
0.01623719,
0.0045060753,
0.0113226725,
0.0291159023,
0.0103706382,
0.0195045974,
-0.0876374766,
0.0261113681,
-0.0402720347,
-0.0539471582,
-0.0280597508,
-0.0007186436,
0.0295320861,
0.0401513651,
-0.0232007559,
0.0110926172,
0.0166428033,
-0.009911987,
-0.0328768976,
-0.0363259763,
-0.0605584718,
-0.0142809898,
0.0445027724,
-0.041821707,
0.0184996799,
0.0265620332,
0.004369318,
-0.0453674905,
0.0294900928,
-0.0571164638,
0.0198219735,
-0.0324496292,
0.0505870171,
-0.0281804707,
-0.0396761,
-0.0406756364,
0.0456845835,
0.0240648575,
0.0386474356,
-0.021695938,
0.0265913233,
0.0023070693,
-0.0240250733,
-0.0465915948,
0.0267070569,
0.0129516385,
0.0502344519,
0.0379583985,
0.023678394,
-0.0392661765,
-0.050326962,
-0.0883907229,
-0.0069761244,
-0.0104469107,
0.014254367,
0.0218336489,
-0.0097481068,
-0.0010510422,
0.0310458001,
-0.0609412789,
-0.0218487028,
0.0552868098,
0.0074740462,
0.0139830709,
-0.0062224367,
-0.0159414988,
-0.0494525619,
-0.027475426,
-0.0392506532,
0.0173537135,
0.081307821,
0.0065829079,
-0.059422601,
0.0593982711,
-0.0349787064,
0.0078958729,
0.0502344668,
-0.0413507111,
0.0225446969,
-0.0235651322,
0.0590182208,
0.0610234551,
0.0111698583,
0.0727654621,
0.0422722213,
-0.0271823276,
-0.0422707573,
-0.0045068581,
-0.0316582657,
-0.0181741323,
-0.0176923834,
-0.0466306321,
-0.0322077014,
0.0568287857,
0.0431233533,
-0.0359332263,
-0.0557184517,
0.0343715809,
-0.0746902972,
-0.0081714978,
0.0058247214,
-0.0444435216,
-0.0151990447,
-0.005134949,
-0.0127364602,
-0.0422354564,
0.0724374354,
-0.015616118,
0.0209586602,
-0.0688273385,
0.0188408978,
-0.0245828331,
0.0367139429,
0.0355160981,
0.0270955358,
-0.0159942247,
-0.0002294561,
-0.0271424446,
0.0383840613,
0.0199318323,
-0.0513660163,
0.0385427438,
-0.0830769241,
-0.0119199483,
-0.0035799204,
-0.0376030207,
-0.0260157008,
0.0019680953,
0.000343479,
0.0182509832,
0.0282686241,
0.0021518678,
0.0005855446,
-0.0070774704,
0.025907049,
0.0296625942,
-0.037149854,
-0.0138515234,
-0.0133652398,
0.0278640855,
0.0253265649,
-0.0457211435,
0.0007845323,
-0.0239215791,
0.0287396275,
0.0376942605,
0.0130884722,
0.0188603941,
-0.0191285908,
0.0110462783,
0.0514939576,
-0.0427704714,
-0.0372429602,
0.0261014309,
0.0362611562,
-0.1055724025,
-0.0323819444,
0.1124315485,
0.0438843444,
-0.0288900603,
-0.0001643971,
-0.0042492175,
-0.016089987,
0.00257752,
0.0268016737,
-0.0510492325,
0.014391684,
-0.0132507402,
0.0277345832,
-0.0507405736,
-0.0270632226,
-0.003190272,
-0.1412964314,
0.0644021332,
0.0330332331,
-0.0215617456,
-0.012950059,
-0.0241592173,
-0.0133576086,
0.0270975791,
-0.001494173,
-0.0029680347,
-0.0121226842,
0.0193965752,
0.0472203046,
0.0132233091,
-0.0680190176,
0.016031336,
-0.0016264644,
0.0635185167,
0.0557303801,
0.0335830264,
-0.0354078598,
-0.0379962176,
0.0148179382,
-0.0082002636,
-0.0091836704,
-0.0092963753,
0.0036104363,
0.0113673015,
-0.0022254484,
-0.0489155203,
0.0382377468,
-0.0012901335,
0.0197465345,
0.0311063882,
0.0979837179,
0.0003100562,
-0.0218847618,
-0.0151413307,
-0.0083704637,
0.0019530627,
0.0538605601,
0.034983404,
-0.0891963542,
-0.0229230225,
-0.052423913,
-0.0065749632,
-0.0389534011,
-0.0254692528,
0.0174155943,
-0.003430998,
0.0014088211,
-0.0845991373,
-0.0798149109,
0.0307844263,
0.0114898169,
0.0334899016,
-0.0003674366,
0.0338063128,
-0.0088116257,
0.0025362072,
0.0092146415,
-0.0122120874,
0.0111072697,
-0.0955804139,
-0.0401251763,
-0.006287158,
-0.0387580432,
-0.0060894829,
0.0077701802,
-0.0525192656,
-0.0751118138,
0.0233277418,
0.0675712377,
0.0206416193,
-0.0026722027,
0.0074038892,
-0.0471537039,
0.0055071525,
-0.0095339837,
-0.0108184069,
0.0277166925,
-0.0289534777,
-0.0072901663,
0.0015576658,
-0.0015407759,
-0.0007448603,
0.0357344598,
0.00824391,
0.0314054042,
-0.011194312,
-0.058239229,
0.0420073271,
0.0473443829,
0.0272067655,
-0.0394419692,
0.0074955607,
-0.059618488,
-0.0222485438,
-0.0621613152,
-0.0283738039,
-0.0376115851,
-0.0194592159,
0.0188779235,
0.0150119904,
-0.0291693844,
0.0009047829,
-0.0335805826,
0.0410391092,
-0.0237988699,
0.041484613,
-0.019201424,
0.0429266654,
0.0236556735,
-0.0024427196,
-0.042810034,
-0.0076047229,
-0.0141019793,
0.0432406664,
-0.0000077858,
0.0761183947,
-0.0039270371,
0.0045609423,
0.0459811874,
0.0111995135,
-0.0192173496,
-0.0076386747,
-0.0470733419,
0.0260231495,
0.0405189097,
0.0167139247,
0.0578869842,
-0.0532678999,
-0.0107397521,
-0.0381742977,
0.0156984683,
0.023509251,
-0.0581163578,
0.0175483357,
-0.005290404,
0.0189542752,
-0.0320279114,
0.0514974855,
0.0023484298,
0.0382717215,
0.0026222176,
-0.0120441848,
-0.0225532502,
-0.0401280373,
0.006253134,
-0.0214594528,
0.0109728565,
0.0065302853,
-0.0660998225,
-0.0533531718,
-0.0189224109,
0.0523386486,
0.0339004435,
-0.05337549,
0.0347550921,
0.0318674743,
-0.0433997735,
0.015880039,
-0.068619445,
0.0201964825,
-0.0319143832,
-0.0244314559,
-0.0169722345,
-5.835683665e-33,
-0.0573693179,
-0.0565329082,
0.0398012064,
0.0289764144,
-0.0152270282,
-0.0043081217,
-0.0264647566,
0.0181547143,
0.0221582837,
0.0202965308,
0.0044040503,
-0.0291808974,
-0.0069147162,
0.0416569039,
0.0281323586,
0.0350439772,
0.0538415536,
-0.0273848996,
-0.0126611525,
0.0442108139,
0.0208492633,
-0.0179839674,
0.0599481873,
-0.0259096902,
0.042942144,
-0.0116072586,
-0.0150994044,
-0.0107601238,
-0.0659456477,
0.0581305809,
-0.0130917244,
0.0634795129,
0.0256080925,
-0.0163747575,
-0.0065835821,
0.0223178752,
-0.0263504647,
-0.0323079191,
0.0096378373,
0.0124331797,
-0.0104060955,
-0.0550884008,
0.029446641,
-0.0098172342,
-0.0710167065,
0.0088403337,
0.0436970182,
-0.0312510133,
0.0064022536,
-0.0316616073,
-0.0850290209,
0.0066371579,
-0.0110085504,
-0.0117935883,
-0.0251042787,
0.0380620062,
-0.0173384119,
-0.0153507292,
-0.0217042975,
0.0412730798,
0.072305657,
0.0327993222,
0.0593265221,
-0.0036436955,
-0.014876225,
0.0455302224,
0.0214309096,
0.006066835,
0.0030499033,
-0.0105248205,
0.0266086198,
-0.0054364265,
0.0842764601,
0.0635115057,
0.0002442801,
-0.0160268117,
-0.0443866588,
0.027277464,
0.0128553612,
-0.0068333806,
0.0281454287,
-0.0578715913,
-0.0626645684,
-0.0307010673,
-0.0377351791,
-0.0122328643,
-0.0244159773,
-0.0141244354,
0.0494955108,
-0.0211794022,
0.0046018106,
-0.0062272144,
0.0014310126,
-0.0343769751,
-0.0201728046,
-0.0042958218,
-0.04532196,
0.0531968661,
-0.0427347161,
0.0172987562,
-0.0435502715,
-0.0325390026,
0.0161907934,
0.0105643254,
-0.0067227143,
0.0294344611,
0.0177379847,
0.044627253,
-0.0384722203,
0.0325595029,
-0.0443147346,
0.0347627215,
0.0420146249,
-0.0215320755,
0.0313088708,
-0.0090590511,
-0.0018849751,
0.0408575423,
0.0307231545,
-0.013883587,
-0.0235198215,
-0.0324342288,
0.0071247937,
0.0104840724,
-0.0395019278,
0.0226090848,
-0.0294720773,
0.036741361,
0.0203900468,
-0.0320792235,
0.0001706483,
-0.0068131704,
2.671e-7,
0.0204725396,
0.0615920424,
0.007764372,
-0.0169688687,
0.0173722096,
0.0211202595,
0.0039091362,
0.014653475,
0.0356732979,
0.067224443,
-0.0041126739,
0.0105991596,
0.0462616831,
0.0273046102,
-0.0459822565,
0.0175753888,
-0.02489358,
0.0124407979,
-0.0664716959,
0.0208326243,
0.0860010535,
0.0313195884,
0.0198956411,
-0.0339178666,
-0.0290000606,
-0.0305522121,
0.0592130646,
-0.0005026044,
-0.0274995919,
0.0184885915,
0.0316603519,
0.0355453119,
0.0042361869,
0.0338574946,
-0.0135639478,
-0.00486418,
0.0103449374,
0.0586136729,
-0.0056444439,
0.044325579,
0.0577005073,
-0.026893748,
-0.0197464824,
-0.0728314444,
0.0409241356,
-0.0136060538,
0.0004094021,
0.0027741394,
-0.0274700839,
-0.0357570536,
-0.0124856215,
-0.077695258,
-0.012720705,
0.0157513879,
0.0019063773,
-0.0163561907,
0.0232174248,
-0.0009895478,
-0.0078918692,
-0.0015490104,
-0.023411138,
-0.0665051043,
-0.0334855095,
0.0079303682,
-0.02063936,
-0.0531843789,
0.0154154925,
2.556490599e-34,
0.0236633737,
-0.0322592482,
0.0325594507,
-0.0391225219,
0.0164395664,
0.0246455409,
-0.0031728786,
0.0108151771,
0.0130671058,
-0.0511462055,
-0.0513498336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08368v1 | Gender mobility in the labor market with skills-based matching models | 2023-07-17T10:06:21 | 2023-07-17T10:06:21 | Ajaya Adhikari, Steven Vethman, Daan Vos, Marc Lenz, Ioana Cocu, Ioannis Tolios, Cor J. Veenman | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Skills-based matching promises mobility of workers between different sectors
and occupations in the labor market. In this case, job seekers can look for
jobs they do not yet have experience in, but for which they do have relevant
skills. Currently, there are multiple occupations with a skewed gender
distribution. For skills-based matching, it is unclear if and how a shift in
the gender distribution, which we call gender mobility, between occupations
will be effected. It is expected that the skills-based matching approach will
likely be data-driven, including computational language models and supervised
learning methods.
This work, first, shows the presence of gender segregation in language
model-based skills representation of occupations. Second, we assess the use of
these representations in a potential application based on simulated data, and
show that the gender segregation is propagated by various data-driven
skills-based matching models.These models are based on different language
representations (bag of words, word2vec, and BERT), and distance metrics
(static and machine learning-based). Accordingly, we show how skills-based
matching approaches can be evaluated and compared on matching performance as
well as on the risk of gender segregation. Making the gender segregation bias
of models more explicit can help in generating healthy trust in the use of
these models in practice. | [
0.03138097,
0.0891377628,
-0.0162431803,
-0.0460620038,
-0.0013543916,
-0.0036073523,
0.0476918146,
-0.009024376,
-0.0055409009,
-0.0581011623,
0.0403266661,
-0.0068630823,
0.0488262847,
0.0040166113,
0.0366204269,
-0.0227688551,
0.0079776254,
0.0621808246,
-0.0375653654,
-0.0144035025,
-0.0106017832,
0.0425211675,
0.0003335613,
0.1085346043,
0.0033115812,
-0.0269174147,
0.0557991825,
0.0040286477,
0.0053451047,
0.046964962,
0.0611722618,
0.0082045039,
-0.0046483553,
-0.0126917781,
0.0000020289,
-0.0445891283,
-0.015773017,
0.0285296813,
-0.0057685664,
-0.0621629842,
0.014080382,
-0.0161696598,
0.0029150636,
0.0517163984,
-0.0228225291,
-0.0090120509,
0.0444240011,
-0.0356717259,
0.0485744253,
-0.0073838932,
-0.0097154761,
0.0085382573,
-0.0557362437,
-0.0215871502,
-0.0088709854,
-0.0143919252,
0.054892458,
-0.0287038628,
-0.0122463331,
-0.0146088833,
-0.0248103831,
-0.0165407974,
-0.0648809001,
-0.0310576502,
0.05292999,
0.0471168943,
-0.025256481,
-0.0019116814,
-0.0033487347,
-0.0112444451,
-0.0440328494,
-0.0046474021,
-0.0035702302,
-0.0171769559,
0.0244989898,
0.0790874511,
-0.0232707709,
-0.0128820986,
-0.0082864296,
-0.0028748638,
-0.0153202526,
0.0004880761,
0.0049613598,
0.015944656,
-0.0085885087,
0.1059168205,
-0.0188797824,
-0.0493131876,
0.0129858647,
-0.0045805494,
0.0363331735,
-0.0200463738,
0.064964436,
0.0044328254,
0.003281679,
-0.0176043604,
0.001610717,
0.000358069,
0.0046590678,
-0.0428966433,
-0.0146834021,
0.0415869057,
0.017704349,
0.0122081675,
0.018134214,
-0.006265454,
0.0334966518,
0.0056293728,
-0.0413756557,
-0.0622546673,
-0.0909975842,
-0.0303180423,
-0.033142291,
-0.038340684,
-0.0197990984,
0.053847488,
-0.0225431509,
0.0155058373,
-0.0587804541,
-0.0068167229,
0.0048325951,
-0.0222224016,
-0.006465042,
0.0431899764,
-0.0698277429,
-0.0383583717,
-0.014308936,
0.0367551185,
-0.0386081338,
-0.0068873679,
0.0213606879,
-0.0035463162,
0.0043950952,
-0.0399463549,
0.0163323618,
0.0167007148,
0.0464737564,
0.0233326387,
0.0059568202,
-0.0091908956,
-0.012097693,
0.0104903169,
-0.0058271945,
-0.0566135757,
0.0307726618,
0.0210960265,
-0.0099485423,
-0.048783958,
0.0012752922,
0.0138231441,
-0.0650497302,
0.0267428737,
0.0336455479,
0.0300427377,
0.0779927447,
-0.0111075714,
-0.0258746743,
0.009525897,
0.0309590623,
-0.0009818895,
0.0171978939,
-0.0393012837,
0.0188382789,
0.0540849753,
-0.0188907776,
0.0091174375,
-0.0112597551,
0.0364839733,
0.0189532191,
0.0065681036,
0.0809426829,
-0.0503337048,
-0.0063632466,
0.0048893327,
0.0214695521,
0.1349761635,
0.0624086931,
0.0339063331,
0.0370087735,
0.0440454036,
-0.0474187173,
-0.0291390028,
-0.008771766,
-0.0268807113,
-0.0087492289,
-0.049232129,
-0.0137094492,
0.0393941365,
-0.0420007706,
-0.0089613562,
0.0145081095,
0.0069342121,
0.0343506411,
-0.0009572674,
0.0272721425,
-0.0135271661,
0.0144552402,
0.0437150225,
0.0206391197,
-0.0082597658,
-0.0407640561,
-0.0416329913,
-0.0420479961,
0.0873723701,
0.0169244688,
-0.0112608848,
-0.0084316768,
-0.0462547205,
-0.0397888571,
0.0236588344,
0.0413595438,
0.0187442452,
-0.0005965221,
-0.0434693471,
-0.0276502948,
0.0745352879,
-0.0066153519,
-0.0074764248,
0.0411147662,
0.0255569834,
0.0244175699,
-0.0452654213,
-0.0424012393,
0.0368477665,
-0.0029034773,
0.0208433568,
0.039057944,
0.01741823,
-0.0317233391,
-0.0165050048,
-0.0068674171,
0.0219297148,
-0.0422285274,
0.0021179691,
-0.001166894,
0.0234619472,
0.0193649847,
0.0625798479,
-0.0115895085,
-0.0316968448,
-0.0487123802,
0.0065019117,
0.0073822765,
0.0327570029,
0.0247009378,
0.0224862844,
-0.0271281581,
0.0061768661,
0.0363520235,
-0.0146574629,
0.0243705064,
-0.0229497328,
0.0165173728,
-0.0042806878,
-0.0117831752,
-0.0520487987,
0.004188953,
0.0028231295,
-0.0949649289,
0.0042946022,
-0.028086165,
0.0168594383,
0.0475250408,
0.0099390754,
-0.0138121201,
0.0193792991,
-0.0300977994,
-0.0333721712,
0.029056171,
0.0475473143,
-0.0021384575,
0.0028589079,
-0.0137689011,
-0.0110986233,
0.0222647935,
-0.0274935346,
-0.0086396709,
0.0203758832,
-0.0065779234,
0.0396381505,
-0.0273032486,
-0.0015275102,
-0.0323642939,
-0.0683113486,
-0.0569920652,
0.0471840762,
0.015207489,
0.0180633347,
-0.0438599885,
-0.0113514103,
-0.039397832,
0.013984032,
-0.01250662,
0.0224800855,
-0.0390641987,
0.0290313382,
-0.0029642473,
0.0264865328,
-0.0063523808,
0.0221471805,
0.0726988316,
0.01928306,
-0.03566714,
0.0063772546,
0.025819432,
0.065730311,
0.0195856486,
-0.0805623829,
-0.0050968118,
-0.0123841334,
-0.0029519019,
-0.0399199203,
-0.0202151705,
0.0232791286,
-0.0141253956,
-0.0047944915,
-0.0810967833,
0.0202439185,
0.0223402493,
0.0254088044,
-0.0426839329,
-0.0234369263,
-0.0375967808,
0.0071835062,
0.0542848967,
-0.035885863,
-0.0772353336,
-0.0483291931,
0.0176147521,
-0.0317338556,
-0.0043331096,
-0.0375168696,
0.0168104135,
-0.0513510779,
-0.0344873779,
-0.0070944959,
-0.0286404956,
-0.0183024071,
-0.0012685036,
0.0119491033,
0.0336947516,
-0.013920188,
-0.0117099052,
-0.042900838,
0.0248761605,
0.0458796434,
0.0401807092,
0.0007682179,
-0.057390023,
0.0501502231,
-0.0146098109,
0.0357968807,
0.0229109135,
-0.0273346622,
-0.0296698511,
0.0170366634,
0.0348031297,
0.054106079,
-0.0340708978,
-0.0386785343,
-0.0522987247,
-0.0330634229,
-0.0166747272,
0.0135364057,
-0.0013877386,
0.0235338174,
0.0471781343,
-0.0752295777,
-0.0182237476,
0.0043292465,
-0.0392943211,
-0.0259037614,
0.0243197624,
0.0763810202,
0.0367960259,
-0.0214579012,
-0.0020936239,
-0.0271607209,
-0.0182425007,
0.0480989367,
0.0732720122,
-0.0414290279,
0.0553268604,
0.0162997972,
0.0264558643,
-0.0029816162,
-0.0088970689,
-0.0218174737,
-0.1188297719,
0.0424945876,
0.002810277,
-0.0200669412,
-0.0457062833,
-0.036407318,
-0.01525144,
-0.013380372,
-0.0213380456,
-0.0375709198,
-0.0190780945,
0.0133186895,
0.0483921356,
-0.0357355028,
-0.016122736,
0.0559514686,
-0.0951323658,
0.0265981704,
0.0159815233,
0.0815076455,
-0.0349852964,
0.0085584959,
-0.0149264252,
0.0071262349,
0.0008964844,
0.0258786716,
0.0122635737,
-0.0734569579,
-0.015271211,
-0.0271054562,
-0.0336002633,
0.0121669546,
0.0052617094,
0.0270200223,
0.0245970245,
0.0086473869,
-0.0267570224,
-0.0499010421,
0.0015541215,
-0.007875883,
0.0845487341,
-0.046466466,
-0.0655765608,
-0.0167768765,
-0.0339821056,
0.0156273004,
0.0862641558,
-0.0501613468,
0.0343290083,
-0.0046321061,
-0.0032149167,
0.0231802687,
-0.0481292047,
0.0352973342,
0.0175277069,
-0.0001883514,
0.0112545481,
0.0207906105,
-0.0173598621,
-0.0920707434,
0.044618737,
-0.0036407202,
0.0717570782,
0.0058365953,
-0.0215989221,
-0.0604918189,
-0.0309634022,
-0.071289055,
-0.0447918884,
-0.0473944433,
-0.0080023715,
-0.0250005182,
-0.023071859,
0.0236385278,
0.0324325785,
-0.027390657,
-0.0444763266,
0.010637912,
0.0742076561,
-0.0363973193,
0.0124899559,
-0.0123588275,
0.010906429,
-0.006112603,
-0.0174754132,
-0.0455229804,
0.0225294903,
-0.0138846822,
-0.0143854823,
-0.0257549696,
-0.0347498134,
-0.0147661176,
-0.0021132033,
-0.0025447763,
0.0202063695,
-0.0154021513,
-0.067888625,
-0.0075105652,
0.0330064967,
-0.0355822593,
-0.0163469352,
-0.0532407723,
0.0819370523,
0.0273742285,
0.0237260386,
0.01475213,
0.0250991676,
-0.012832731,
-0.048236981,
0.0367316008,
-0.0484119467,
0.069608219,
-0.0372437537,
-0.0114571108,
0.0274476688,
-0.0481792577,
-0.0014198126,
0.0337442979,
0.0365960263,
-0.013207512,
-0.0100903558,
0.0467099622,
-0.0240910854,
0.0132515151,
-0.0178138316,
-0.0653760433,
-0.0211551972,
0.0489390418,
-0.0013371641,
-0.08025489,
0.03518245,
0.0004910613,
-0.0165757835,
0.0002510999,
-0.0312243588,
0.0277577676,
0.0552770533,
0.0253360476,
-0.0033387737,
-0.010041385,
-0.0164505839,
0.0283545144,
0.0855166167,
0.0413364135,
-0.0691056922,
-0.0749192759,
-0.0057242191,
0.0110977618,
0.0782171786,
-0.0009290987,
-0.0079614827,
0.0152498093,
-0.0722946078,
-0.0604347959,
0.0060563916,
-0.0323044956,
-0.0059943865,
-0.0118945045,
-0.0098611536,
0.062145859,
-0.0012639774,
-0.0204760954,
-0.0370995067,
-0.0243914239,
0.0095822727,
-0.014354351,
-0.0449655876,
-5.838701746e-33,
-0.0254899412,
-0.0635173693,
0.0124069471,
0.0020319973,
0.0194804315,
0.0107073737,
0.0494336449,
-0.0255703647,
-0.0066270139,
-0.0287031345,
0.0032067543,
0.0284232497,
0.0033318414,
-0.0242515504,
-0.001821584,
0.0474054515,
0.0161870867,
0.0353001282,
0.0099661471,
-0.0843415931,
-0.0470703617,
0.031129444,
0.0174919702,
-0.0502878465,
0.0581349656,
-0.0172231384,
0.0103612514,
0.0123745874,
0.0163676478,
0.0430561192,
-0.0052385288,
0.0175913069,
0.0187724773,
-0.037257798,
0.0167400856,
0.0235503968,
-0.054397177,
-0.0087083718,
-0.0172590222,
0.0188594237,
0.0409491211,
-0.0163415857,
0.0221225228,
0.080492191,
-0.0550844073,
-0.0308719855,
0.0962687805,
0.0023765615,
0.0384850167,
0.0461961851,
-0.0107932268,
0.0154633662,
-0.0861804485,
-0.0036727961,
0.0245601051,
0.0151198069,
0.0265946034,
0.00625889,
-0.107051298,
0.0206841361,
-0.0351360813,
0.0199693069,
0.0135450009,
-0.0081349779,
0.0274206884,
0.0113151399,
0.0389872566,
-0.0043778461,
0.0494133458,
-0.060250815,
0.0266058296,
0.0142864184,
-0.0379676335,
-0.0230906866,
0.0713720769,
-0.0157493372,
-0.0451074727,
-0.0072600255,
0.0132260816,
-0.0110157523,
-0.0006827883,
0.0037771452,
-0.0768563077,
-0.0331894904,
-0.0262272768,
-0.0622288659,
-0.0154532865,
0.0143802026,
0.0544805117,
-0.0068999897,
0.0087126773,
0.0380658619,
-0.0496127196,
-0.0485194251,
-0.0227205716,
-0.0191610921,
-0.0568957925,
-0.0425899178,
0.0521244667,
0.0120364511,
-0.0704910085,
0.0020010842,
-0.0158128273,
0.0215686541,
0.0304361079,
0.0750756338,
-0.0297525451,
-0.0051387316,
-0.0733246058,
-0.0141410753,
-0.0032163418,
-0.0110848667,
-0.0560985431,
0.0144224279,
0.048210714,
0.0066921604,
0.0451462939,
-0.015651308,
0.0545576401,
-0.0029789957,
0.0231209733,
-0.0265874881,
-0.0074565327,
-0.0054735728,
0.0475225598,
0.0170844737,
0.0012627188,
-0.0010574292,
0.017044276,
-0.0330600515,
-0.0076203588,
-0.0398510136,
2.598e-7,
0.0585973114,
0.04834456,
-0.0031192184,
0.055910524,
0.0058178222,
-0.0116076823,
-0.0031617219,
0.0380282439,
0.0575611554,
0.0518848039,
-0.0273058675,
0.0358245075,
0.0130312173,
-0.0134812323,
-0.0013820435,
0.0440291725,
-0.059095446,
-0.0012624952,
-0.0470695756,
0.0134651102,
0.0324644856,
0.0516851172,
0.0654932708,
-0.0106005892,
-0.0203098785,
-0.01661551,
0.0244743042,
-0.0126376618,
0.0183222536,
0.0385171734,
0.0048757405,
0.0243926309,
-0.0073343748,
0.0656299219,
-0.0108561954,
0.0759283081,
0.0863228887,
0.0053325505,
-0.050721325,
0.061892353,
-0.0160139706,
-0.0149216643,
-0.0117745837,
-0.0408273079,
0.0474058613,
0.0229863413,
-0.0138734048,
-0.0628469884,
-0.0616228878,
0.0194381494,
0.0673802271,
0.0313699618,
-0.0395832807,
-0.0206495579,
0.0345954746,
-0.0033188954,
-0.0294794515,
-0.0005928188,
0.0197947323,
0.0029647383,
-0.0211520661,
-0.0422161482,
0.0238457732,
0.0578014478,
0.0529499948,
-0.0131861977,
0.0036700999,
2.278669167e-34,
-0.0010454351,
0.0877168179,
0.0051969462,
-0.0410057902,
0.0293866992,
0.001159617,
0.0097792717,
0.021013435,
0.0255267285,
0.034381561,
0.0026714527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.09390v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.09390v1 | How do software citation formats evolve over time? A longitudinal analysis of R programming language packages | 2023-07-17T09:18:57 | 2023-07-17T09:18:57 | Yuzhuo Wang, Kai Li | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL | Under the data-driven research paradigm, research software has come to play
crucial roles in nearly every stage of scientific inquiry. Scholars are
advocating for the formal citation of software in academic publications,
treating it on par with traditional research outputs. However, software is
hardly consistently cited: one software entity can be cited as different
objects, and the citations can change over time. These issues, however, are
largely overlooked in existing empirical research on software citation. To fill
the above gaps, the present study compares and analyzes a longitudinal dataset
of citation formats of all R packages collected in 2021 and 2022, in order to
understand the citation formats of R-language packages, important members in
the open-source software family, and how the citations evolve over time. In
particular, we investigate the different document types underlying the
citations and what metadata elements in the citation formats changed over time.
Furthermore, we offer an in-depth analysis of the disciplinarity of journal
articles cited as software (software papers). By undertaking this research, we
aim to contribute to a better understanding of the complexities associated with
software citation, shedding light on future software citation policies and
infrastructure. | [
0.027348049,
0.0112038441,
-0.0196204204,
-0.0469532572,
-0.01716608,
-0.0083367359,
0.0411384962,
0.0166353341,
0.013384684,
-0.0304553602,
0.0270585287,
0.0762116611,
0.0455613099,
0.0291909557,
0.0005361046,
0.0092272433,
0.0329607129,
0.0172136519,
0.0147810578,
0.0518525541,
-0.0087441625,
0.0433496833,
0.0078908429,
0.0431617349,
0.0646511614,
-0.0659636557,
0.0244539045,
-0.010916478,
0.0376775712,
-0.0393065363,
0.019242879,
0.0334473699,
-0.0024464675,
0.0608893037,
0.0000017426,
0.009214161,
0.0187671948,
0.093198739,
-0.0108999303,
0.0528239086,
0.0418572314,
0.0007517009,
0.0048025656,
-0.0207017269,
0.0160404108,
-0.0600171909,
0.0207658354,
-0.0295053292,
-0.0691124126,
-0.0542875528,
0.0214835778,
0.0210425109,
0.0354984738,
0.0112575963,
0.008058453,
0.0386047103,
-0.0100639286,
0.0727519765,
0.0314881317,
0.0959727839,
0.0298383012,
0.0320375487,
-0.0066358224,
0.0060307048,
0.0492266268,
0.0569157973,
-0.0058700726,
0.0326819345,
0.0093608629,
0.0084373327,
0.0818046853,
-0.0311056077,
0.0807007998,
0.0147436764,
-0.0536805689,
0.0240336191,
0.0018704975,
0.0141369263,
0.0199832693,
-0.0320881791,
-0.01347965,
0.0044424185,
-0.0064694779,
0.0134122428,
-0.0012989793,
0.0504435971,
-0.0128154904,
-0.0117095746,
0.0673842877,
-0.0338380858,
0.0151586924,
-0.0409674086,
-0.0031322497,
-0.0600761548,
0.0783063471,
-0.0161284208,
0.027138276,
-0.0051709688,
0.0939704999,
0.020864822,
-0.0269426405,
-0.0426625311,
-0.0001431942,
0.0015534632,
-0.0074375626,
-0.0024558899,
-0.04389368,
-0.0154631659,
0.0856681541,
0.0240640286,
-0.0492513962,
-0.0279929023,
0.0168101024,
-0.0220651962,
-0.012197637,
0.0000345501,
-0.0225810483,
0.0384867564,
0.0240284447,
-0.0044139284,
-0.0162303355,
0.0019597868,
-0.0655683056,
0.026769191,
0.0062863338,
0.0034257995,
-0.005915706,
0.0184027124,
-0.0203814656,
0.028223617,
0.0071147801,
0.0001857778,
0.0048402073,
-0.0528537221,
0.0335053615,
-0.0379282162,
0.0418363698,
0.0326248631,
0.0220567882,
-0.0341724195,
0.0174747724,
0.0036575443,
0.0199891273,
-0.0577075407,
-0.0135901598,
0.0689874887,
0.0129686464,
-0.013578984,
-0.0285223257,
0.0341377482,
-0.0302875265,
0.013907548,
-0.0872436538,
0.0012053967,
-0.0064318534,
-0.0074924091,
0.0452186093,
-0.0454894453,
-0.005113977,
-0.0627618879,
0.0119353496,
-0.0462500788,
0.0371739902,
-0.015840413,
-0.0308453515,
0.0197913237,
0.0195136219,
0.0637380183,
0.0104481485,
-0.0395129509,
-0.0025819654,
-0.010568562,
-0.0457046553,
-0.003348835,
0.0082104998,
0.0214859154,
-0.0252864491,
0.0289262235,
0.0015281375,
0.019917978,
0.0313753709,
-0.0884425715,
0.0059660622,
0.0274163038,
0.0328304842,
0.0399379842,
-0.068104431,
0.0166408196,
0.0003452503,
-0.0351310372,
-0.0245360993,
0.0134351635,
0.006796814,
-0.0453231707,
0.0333368145,
0.0075699072,
-0.0032474627,
0.0416512862,
0.0063223173,
0.0114712361,
-0.0470909253,
-0.0149467895,
0.041761525,
-0.0261970889,
0.0608972907,
-0.0470328517,
0.0279185213,
-0.0533186682,
-0.0005809318,
0.0371446684,
-0.0247427225,
0.0045049423,
-0.0041473778,
-0.0068784165,
0.0090616802,
-0.0199213997,
-0.0335968435,
0.0591687039,
-0.0102707939,
0.050932996,
-0.0403426029,
-0.0199060272,
-0.0152718313,
0.0095915115,
-0.0044147675,
0.0030872407,
-0.0211885553,
-0.0467771366,
0.0024590751,
-0.0059351493,
-0.0250071567,
0.0162617899,
0.0545711406,
0.0328155383,
-0.0009089021,
0.0255085286,
0.0666861087,
0.0954726636,
-0.0023365037,
-0.0105266944,
0.0463551208,
-0.0218132231,
-0.0364949964,
0.036993254,
0.0548828766,
0.0110211521,
0.0282152519,
0.0362404063,
-0.0380529054,
-0.0338010602,
-0.0095907431,
-0.0108887022,
0.0172902364,
0.0186441038,
0.0572333895,
0.0282739159,
-0.0413010679,
0.0310645774,
0.0480542481,
-0.0679274648,
0.0088790478,
-0.0531979613,
0.0043161437,
0.0445988141,
-0.0098515907,
-0.0268913768,
-0.0042556813,
0.014414575,
0.0110432459,
0.0373302102,
-0.007801638,
-0.014569927,
-0.0655378476,
0.0015014798,
-0.0006978669,
0.0507186726,
-0.1019863635,
-0.0338061117,
-0.0331045873,
0.069273971,
0.0030345148,
0.0143271675,
-0.0353637971,
-0.0244802367,
-0.0325397067,
0.0250569414,
0.0225828476,
0.0081159202,
-0.0713807493,
0.0215429813,
-0.0458797701,
-0.0193208866,
-0.0525127463,
0.0589404404,
0.0136704436,
0.0557050295,
0.0413212776,
0.0222380254,
-0.045051571,
-0.0017620109,
0.0155196972,
0.002818421,
-0.0515892133,
0.0196701195,
0.0085927788,
-0.0277347341,
0.0107686259,
-0.0654025599,
0.0560256056,
-0.0364703052,
-0.0446618274,
0.0208996907,
0.0173424929,
-0.0308913942,
-0.0162006728,
0.0063944696,
0.0237952955,
0.0026361609,
-0.0100324741,
0.0244635697,
0.0081635369,
-0.0286494363,
-0.0354192518,
-0.0360275246,
-0.0437626727,
-0.0672628656,
-0.0082123308,
-0.0369722433,
0.0381006561,
0.0178991295,
-0.0374331884,
0.0308111534,
0.0384028517,
-0.0135606546,
-0.0084478678,
0.005784201,
-0.0134393992,
0.0260876436,
0.0372450501,
0.0041958396,
-0.0030608275,
0.0288199354,
0.0428653657,
-0.0069113132,
0.0069920477,
0.0054528634,
0.0138237905,
-0.0264345184,
-0.0187052581,
0.035979446,
0.0668539032,
0.0096080359,
0.0205933955,
-0.0210555084,
-0.0143383136,
-0.033629857,
0.034581136,
-0.0637240261,
0.0203141775,
0.0495203957,
-0.0626109689,
0.0131369606,
0.0224044416,
-0.0128628379,
-0.0516894385,
-0.0621869676,
0.0097659528,
-0.0600319579,
-0.0281654671,
0.0385599323,
0.0274536237,
-0.0046131141,
0.0322999358,
0.0070111807,
0.0337892137,
-0.0487417951,
-0.0334119089,
-0.0401337966,
0.0252429061,
0.0578762405,
0.0092908936,
-0.0802567378,
0.0636020228,
-0.0174747445,
0.0044054734,
-0.0418361835,
-0.0150816236,
0.0226221066,
-0.0371761732,
0.0526086129,
-0.03600071,
-0.0618386008,
0.0236263797,
-0.0402101725,
0.012247568,
-0.0201861542,
-0.026088044,
0.0174039956,
-0.0254999325,
0.0229598191,
0.016609747,
-0.0670449287,
0.0205426365,
0.0142423799,
-0.0179852825,
0.0349509977,
0.0271131247,
0.0399754681,
-0.0501004532,
-0.0121370088,
-0.0089684343,
-0.020609824,
-0.0487590246,
-0.0237813704,
0.0524705164,
0.0420734212,
0.0033767223,
-0.0278949738,
0.0098867705,
0.0024663296,
-0.022461798,
-0.018162962,
0.0488019139,
0.0004122839,
-0.0082800547,
-0.0513324216,
-0.0060789082,
-0.0130202062,
0.0130354045,
0.0004820584,
0.0188273545,
-0.0424190164,
-0.0042305132,
0.058653757,
0.0199962724,
-0.0468684584,
-0.0619330667,
-0.062754482,
0.0126226302,
-0.0082040057,
-0.0366633609,
0.0165915769,
-0.0602321029,
0.013593453,
0.020345524,
0.0489692427,
-0.0524633117,
-0.0780310258,
-0.0163018275,
-0.0230457075,
0.0238445736,
0.0020382993,
-0.0236972198,
0.0168143101,
0.0679912269,
-0.0530952513,
0.0239392594,
0.0185789503,
0.0524055772,
-0.0252296999,
0.0444315709,
0.0248758383,
-0.0685805678,
-0.00527533,
0.0002693538,
-0.0005658752,
0.0591199808,
0.0187635142,
0.009585822,
-0.032681793,
-0.0140577639,
-0.0540588759,
-0.0517884493,
-0.0181961302,
-0.0395297557,
0.0022412976,
-0.040928971,
0.0194054842,
0.0170866661,
0.0017754075,
-0.0362830646,
0.0467702672,
-0.0043025413,
0.0679387823,
0.0352460295,
-0.0412728079,
-0.0082528843,
0.0310772061,
-0.0006354117,
-0.0126921283,
-0.0435775295,
0.0191926304,
-0.0274410807,
0.0631137937,
-0.028522471,
0.0495138168,
-0.0362813361,
0.0296721421,
0.040879719,
0.0650345609,
0.0255877338,
0.0197649114,
-0.0169123355,
-0.0304597653,
-0.0303104557,
0.0421555229,
0.0138686141,
0.0306145772,
-0.0196472928,
-0.019264007,
0.0217211768,
-0.0043867785,
-0.0689458475,
-0.0084279906,
0.0444939844,
-0.0508851781,
-0.0006602242,
0.0401379615,
0.0438215211,
-0.0154712182,
-0.021133827,
-0.0467905886,
0.0354363918,
0.0199036114,
0.046831321,
-0.0010217094,
-0.0103910416,
-0.0634891763,
-0.0207565483,
0.0410854071,
0.0470272042,
-0.0249787793,
0.0126444744,
-0.0494905412,
0.0143675702,
-0.0475324765,
-0.0762383118,
-0.0353890806,
-0.0030202868,
-0.0804248825,
-0.0359278359,
-0.0352918729,
0.0133471126,
-0.0149456933,
0.0095072286,
-0.03358927,
-0.0363171026,
-0.007592916,
0.0308669303,
-0.0707819909,
-0.001505947,
0.0632205978,
-0.0956876948,
-0.0582714938,
-0.031398464,
-4.962543726e-33,
0.0422275178,
0.0057684546,
-0.0209311098,
-0.0130389109,
-0.0174691528,
0.0285329465,
-0.0216907542,
0.0038707429,
-0.0184962656,
-0.008875845,
-0.0429075882,
-0.0193772316,
0.0078611029,
-0.0601757877,
0.0815134495,
0.0151379481,
0.0095258318,
-0.0081849014,
0.0129226493,
0.0184312221,
-0.0112050762,
-0.0374267995,
0.0370243192,
-0.0680567995,
0.0725208074,
-0.031800583,
0.0259944219,
-0.0415957645,
0.0354597382,
0.0993859172,
0.0171046238,
-0.0399134904,
-0.0061244033,
-0.0745488852,
-0.0081921862,
0.0056808013,
-0.0963400677,
0.04341878,
0.0514718294,
-0.0156188374,
0.0191899501,
0.0074456469,
0.0237636194,
0.0155005753,
-0.0146872643,
-0.0223548952,
0.062310826,
-0.0048804758,
-0.0288337469,
-0.0873797014,
0.0045759585,
-0.0000958944,
-0.0195319224,
0.0990862772,
-0.0166676491,
0.0346636362,
-0.0030447026,
0.1005615816,
-0.0552655458,
-0.0201025344,
-0.0143113341,
-0.0051131076,
0.0371543355,
-0.0035119988,
0.0363705121,
-0.0018017323,
-0.0110776098,
0.0007756968,
0.0050477022,
-0.0036477987,
0.0116874641,
0.0600778535,
0.0464332476,
0.0427541211,
0.0611020885,
-0.0144243427,
-0.0515871048,
-0.0241715517,
0.0045992625,
0.0272371601,
0.0262622479,
-0.0063507119,
-0.0248874109,
-0.013866568,
0.0019506648,
-0.0660225675,
-0.0154693676,
-0.0559845939,
-0.0060765427,
-0.0199425612,
0.0224180147,
0.0472499393,
0.0410259999,
-0.0410869382,
-0.0955111459,
0.0183027834,
-0.0582467169,
0.0594030991,
-0.0154222334,
0.0175179038,
-0.0597893707,
0.0090137245,
0.0039573698,
0.0179837979,
0.0619639903,
-0.0324163288,
0.0235123094,
-0.0139193181,
-0.0661991537,
0.0054499097,
0.0155273434,
0.0416211821,
-0.0358920395,
0.0089071244,
0.0002723517,
0.0222109687,
0.0383373834,
-0.0111198621,
0.0370565914,
0.0319786258,
-0.0299988911,
0.0345593877,
-0.0180764738,
-0.0101743946,
0.0309023578,
-0.0218581874,
-0.0234665051,
0.0651588961,
0.0257976633,
0.0180367175,
-0.0102768922,
-0.0268616602,
2.48e-7,
0.0356649011,
0.030670505,
0.0129691409,
-0.0284721497,
0.0073967427,
-0.0063243192,
0.000096774,
0.0546372309,
0.0316149294,
0.0339919142,
-0.0506001078,
-0.0477434993,
0.0240758751,
0.0166919921,
-0.0311352722,
-0.0593284257,
-0.0945161209,
-0.0282390788,
-0.0713796467,
-0.0067649721,
-0.0329162367,
-0.0125483684,
0.0050243256,
0.0430065803,
-0.0538781695,
-0.0239730421,
-0.014619912,
-0.0597002134,
0.0542416051,
0.0506401509,
-0.0337521397,
0.0228758492,
-0.0092321318,
-0.003189917,
-0.002313369,
-0.0496278405,
-0.0136287287,
0.025492236,
0.0494292006,
0.0218328573,
0.0386564657,
-0.0121790441,
0.0037879762,
-0.0400176235,
0.0404610187,
0.0094269235,
-0.0259686857,
-0.0166789442,
-0.0750215128,
-0.0216185581,
0.0276097562,
-0.0296646319,
0.0183796212,
0.0087493099,
-0.0462760553,
0.0084171239,
-0.030534422,
-0.010684724,
-0.0055913166,
0.0452296995,
-0.0062385537,
-0.0554014742,
-0.0349826254,
0.0037533673,
0.0321631655,
0.014854854,
0.0832795352,
2.201926375e-34,
0.0592271015,
-0.043669153,
-0.0063830083,
-0.0108260512,
0.0085951481,
-0.0078172917,
0.0064684502,
0.0118674543,
-0.0304023698,
-0.0148162702,
-0.0023607078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08321v1 | Legal Syllogism Prompting: Teaching Large Language Models for Legal Judgment Prediction | 2023-07-17T08:38:46 | 2023-07-17T08:38:46 | Cong Jiang, Xiaolei Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Legal syllogism is a form of deductive reasoning commonly used by legal
professionals to analyze cases. In this paper, we propose legal syllogism
prompting (LoT), a simple prompting method to teach large language models
(LLMs) for legal judgment prediction. LoT teaches only that in the legal
syllogism the major premise is law, the minor premise is the fact, and the
conclusion is judgment. Then the models can produce a syllogism reasoning of
the case and give the judgment without any learning, fine-tuning, or examples.
On CAIL2018, a Chinese criminal case dataset, we performed zero-shot judgment
prediction experiments with GPT-3 models. Our results show that LLMs with LoT
achieve better performance than the baseline and chain of thought prompting,
the state-of-art prompting method on diverse reasoning tasks. LoT enables the
model to concentrate on the key information relevant to the judgment and to
correctly understand the legal meaning of acts, as compared to other methods.
Our method enables LLMs to predict judgment along with law articles and
justification, which significantly enhances the explainability of models. | [
0.0470521078,
0.03571897,
0.0011664969,
0.0138763236,
-0.0624296702,
0.0413355865,
0.0429814048,
0.0081211301,
0.0198509675,
-0.0583388209,
-0.0196503513,
-0.0064446107,
-0.0189209022,
-0.0332180634,
-0.0182727519,
-0.0832806975,
0.0507127345,
0.0015976871,
0.0771850944,
-0.0148870014,
0.0413318053,
0.0209988188,
0.0109410817,
0.0082651153,
0.0087940311,
-0.0362295844,
-0.0454621911,
0.0025206367,
-0.0038686588,
-0.0425483435,
0.0019010754,
0.0948848054,
0.0431463048,
0.0381633788,
0.0000021461,
-0.0651563406,
0.0180265065,
-0.0267886296,
-0.0149370153,
0.0365024284,
0.0149638811,
-0.0247855131,
0.0028994004,
0.0226393212,
-0.0466711819,
0.0233790297,
-0.0238204934,
0.0629517883,
0.0511973165,
0.0878889039,
0.01675082,
-0.0722962692,
0.0218482874,
-0.0512980223,
0.0245542862,
-0.026424747,
0.00931348,
0.0446295217,
0.0143715283,
0.0070222472,
0.0112620685,
-0.0284411088,
0.0494870916,
-0.0053088097,
-0.0471442528,
0.0069862073,
-0.0364241526,
0.0007848685,
0.012832881,
0.0552279688,
0.0404793397,
-0.0478999354,
-0.0241629239,
0.0016965246,
0.0737236887,
0.0366656221,
-0.0397480801,
0.0725091323,
-0.0193726625,
0.0329506174,
0.0621754229,
0.0167683885,
-0.0003021075,
0.027847534,
-0.0089596007,
0.0605048425,
-0.0253682602,
-0.034196645,
0.0092375902,
0.0178038552,
0.0206379276,
-0.0384462178,
-0.016607197,
0.0364352837,
-0.0432062261,
0.0379656442,
-0.0003844724,
0.0051408936,
0.041837953,
-0.0402766839,
0.0115493573,
0.0290475637,
-0.0144540109,
0.0633706897,
-0.0692942888,
-0.0100825801,
0.0241060704,
0.041114673,
-0.008484073,
-0.0127235269,
-0.0485613644,
-0.0002778039,
-0.0245536342,
0.0376640335,
-0.0525099896,
0.0128285168,
-0.0128182881,
-0.0121040698,
-0.0412749089,
0.0290431138,
0.0097358767,
0.0029894824,
0.0098426351,
-0.0400185809,
-0.0829684138,
-0.0220885705,
-0.0659204349,
0.0561468527,
0.0107221166,
0.0150952376,
-0.0092744511,
-0.021671081,
-0.015542022,
0.0154651757,
0.0163127966,
0.0916246027,
-0.0168707892,
0.0125613995,
-0.0818447024,
-0.0596610755,
0.0017552901,
-0.0853446797,
-0.042265255,
-0.0798425004,
-0.0427059345,
-0.0171789061,
0.0103292651,
-0.0123104313,
0.0535020865,
0.0430714786,
-0.0142811304,
0.0893764421,
-0.0084490906,
-0.0320976749,
-0.0585092828,
0.0427980796,
0.0242498685,
0.0391450003,
-0.028206192,
0.0290897321,
-0.0097090229,
-0.0096992524,
0.0225932728,
-0.0239822082,
0.007193082,
0.0241302643,
-0.0353731215,
0.0139098028,
-0.0180875324,
0.0132211475,
0.0021485966,
0.027497638,
0.0060297842,
0.007764854,
0.0231682323,
0.0249482244,
0.0157594699,
0.0499459915,
0.0348741561,
-0.0248884819,
0.0127127646,
0.0075355456,
-0.0904570892,
0.0557774417,
-0.0313447751,
0.0046954858,
-0.0633398965,
0.0085572191,
-0.0442345254,
-0.039698977,
0.0277582258,
0.0221590716,
0.0096687851,
0.0260300729,
0.0179809257,
0.0284795854,
-0.0197614823,
0.0171799529,
0.0590645634,
-0.0472336262,
-0.0403889641,
-0.0411688872,
0.0673179552,
0.0557940118,
0.0331935547,
0.0007751044,
-0.0186494552,
-0.0381165966,
0.0191712286,
0.0281519201,
0.0255016442,
-0.0089684399,
-0.0448068976,
-0.0457934551,
-0.0522091091,
-0.0050748419,
0.0456536748,
0.0163009446,
0.0098090144,
0.0204575621,
0.0601785854,
-0.0488968566,
0.0330640972,
0.0405283161,
-0.0021108636,
-0.04151728,
-0.0064230491,
-0.0146959666,
0.0305862706,
0.0164139364,
0.0164233949,
-0.0196496844,
0.0253455061,
0.0185962953,
0.0111069512,
0.0173594207,
-0.0175720733,
-0.0585505292,
0.0326324031,
-0.0509796925,
0.0046007815,
-0.0186694469,
-0.0771545246,
-0.0044027846,
-0.0145218261,
0.0146568641,
-0.0074839522,
-0.064529486,
-0.0180001613,
-0.0039963364,
-0.0451049879,
-0.0105042197,
0.0561479554,
0.0210664961,
-0.0144004365,
0.0458118729,
0.0356719978,
0.0395108722,
0.002167779,
-0.0011320402,
-0.0407373756,
-0.0139598595,
0.0193095617,
0.0094330413,
0.0376825817,
-0.0566318743,
-0.0167063531,
-0.0729195476,
0.0017136032,
-0.037610393,
-0.0038641284,
0.0052073319,
-0.0444164351,
-0.0127083613,
-0.0280088093,
-0.0217308551,
-0.0036710245,
-0.0116600944,
-0.009941333,
0.0045477776,
-0.0398267433,
-0.0111749293,
0.0030210961,
0.0037357414,
-0.0208494198,
0.0233659465,
0.0401742533,
0.0291597191,
-0.0252394658,
0.0794884264,
-0.0173174459,
-0.0227241237,
-0.029461978,
-0.0202821773,
0.0009951179,
0.0183137786,
-0.0241832137,
0.041442465,
0.0455998108,
0.0108277509,
0.0470633432,
0.0034801564,
-0.0591435544,
-0.0041592582,
-0.005114466,
0.0247948878,
-0.0327035934,
-0.0247347075,
-0.0306343939,
0.0160270426,
-0.0007197181,
0.0023252456,
-0.0367653631,
0.0345173962,
0.0092211477,
0.0199520644,
-0.0345679261,
-0.016826123,
-0.0073407539,
0.0123860827,
0.010360376,
-0.0752521902,
0.0668636635,
0.0405054539,
0.0490462258,
-0.0676411241,
0.0007193086,
-0.0434657335,
0.0718094632,
-0.0067305886,
-0.0075910054,
-0.018182341,
-0.0170953702,
-0.0133381467,
-0.0044560581,
0.0623498894,
-0.0253548063,
0.0585245304,
-0.0406875126,
0.0076667024,
-0.010115643,
-0.0213586502,
-0.0538653769,
-0.0304825287,
-0.0577422529,
0.0097427955,
-0.027547719,
0.0123018622,
0.012303045,
-0.0243142024,
0.014405977,
-0.0001532312,
-0.008830403,
-0.0214922167,
-0.0248014648,
-0.0046590134,
-0.0091769751,
-0.048773773,
-0.0058675366,
-0.0321606398,
0.0532880872,
0.023061201,
0.0171045121,
0.0193915367,
-0.0096590128,
0.0335557871,
-0.0129132755,
-0.0153207052,
-0.0058358111,
0.0468767062,
0.0009340283,
-0.0622873306,
0.038802322,
0.1195112839,
0.0272060614,
-0.0421332344,
-0.0189308375,
-0.0101359375,
0.0233663078,
0.0399576537,
-0.0121892113,
-0.1163207218,
-0.0467491932,
0.0159282219,
-0.0047696792,
-0.0326133221,
-0.0191004034,
0.0146322045,
-0.102308847,
0.07619524,
0.0292001627,
0.0153463846,
-0.0246454868,
-0.0461455807,
0.0126910843,
-0.0183971245,
-0.0313149467,
0.0256999619,
-0.0185821112,
-0.0025714398,
0.0166721512,
-0.0169175155,
0.0077415947,
0.0568883978,
-0.0470832288,
0.0485468358,
0.0314060561,
0.0338390246,
-0.0193156097,
-0.0464628637,
0.0026957006,
-0.0119121242,
0.0170864556,
0.0025627422,
0.0452436134,
-0.0056238761,
0.0259699002,
-0.0602863692,
0.0735621378,
0.0043072775,
-0.0422984846,
0.0617894568,
0.0609815903,
-0.0490819998,
-0.0562023446,
-0.0324117392,
0.0164179094,
-0.0139279589,
0.0842815265,
0.0130313495,
-0.0074588475,
-0.0209157597,
-0.0454274304,
-0.0558286794,
-0.0211614035,
-0.0119765941,
0.0102991788,
0.0088132611,
0.0128279785,
-0.0008288208,
-0.0289080888,
0.0172553621,
0.0211397912,
0.0123669291,
0.0223059673,
-0.0169645324,
0.0322997533,
-0.0332531482,
0.0291368365,
-0.031414222,
0.0064812382,
-0.0151610356,
0.0260049179,
-0.0073759989,
-0.0057836208,
-0.0061046258,
-0.0144242244,
-0.0124984737,
-0.0013189527,
-0.025702944,
0.0298314057,
0.0185572039,
0.0230415687,
-0.0217395779,
-0.0093035586,
0.0550269186,
0.0389298685,
0.0176382866,
-0.0086790165,
0.0632104352,
-0.0353491157,
0.0163585059,
0.0049257153,
0.0240300633,
0.0343936644,
0.0474371202,
-0.0001623575,
-0.0713240132,
0.0130523564,
0.0548727363,
0.0316636488,
0.0455409698,
0.0224176496,
-0.0148881683,
-0.0298709534,
0.0031636651,
-0.0270870533,
-0.0143984109,
-0.029774189,
0.0091070617,
0.0410283394,
-0.0161841922,
-0.0153285582,
-0.0112434616,
-0.0391715653,
-0.0349256694,
-0.0118240286,
0.0258933455,
0.0532666147,
-0.0041608997,
0.01109464,
-0.0515021421,
-0.0075831972,
-0.0057435269,
-0.0334303603,
0.0234999135,
0.0002928101,
0.106179364,
0.0244990885,
0.0064334921,
-0.0017234924,
-0.0206226744,
-0.042782478,
-0.0116170896,
-0.0055126785,
0.0386243314,
0.0270897839,
-0.001057019,
-0.0280258637,
-0.0371601135,
0.0154286232,
0.0199991446,
0.0624939352,
-0.0198886357,
-0.0509393513,
0.0386207886,
0.0348465294,
-0.0170911234,
-0.0164494105,
0.03017818,
-0.0417946912,
0.0116291745,
0.0156154055,
-0.028122548,
-0.0177734885,
-0.0099382997,
-0.0012896301,
0.0245279856,
-0.0097652534,
-0.005139472,
-0.1041620374,
-0.0390790813,
-0.07347022,
0.0194376726,
0.0016286912,
0.0012742011,
0.0139753651,
0.0792360306,
-0.0073586819,
-0.0285887532,
-0.0305760875,
0.0082978513,
-0.0202516448,
-0.0310487039,
-0.0439973287,
-6.024044145e-33,
-0.0182358101,
-0.0401447192,
0.0119755361,
-0.0066005304,
0.003644956,
-0.0468944721,
-0.0136510739,
0.0160462148,
-0.0354771167,
0.0605972037,
0.0020654381,
0.0387402549,
0.0015269693,
-0.0206714962,
0.004109947,
-0.0283588916,
-0.0019660431,
0.0108786961,
0.0017336488,
0.0208104048,
-0.0042584832,
0.0118091181,
0.030613916,
-0.0704575181,
0.0440909304,
0.02250438,
-0.0420842059,
-0.0359779149,
-0.0983861908,
0.0144571252,
0.0153860748,
0.0182540119,
0.0203787349,
-0.050111074,
0.0146937631,
0.0691116601,
-0.0534324124,
-0.0090456121,
0.0380512327,
-0.046592705,
-0.0011635416,
-0.0364608727,
-0.0215102173,
-0.000965984,
0.0138909267,
-0.0034040145,
0.0378079936,
-0.0522949919,
-0.0253265426,
-0.0314312428,
-0.0532596,
0.0379495323,
-0.0300658103,
-0.0148390578,
-0.0149792023,
0.0427178629,
-0.0081004165,
0.0120934704,
-0.0360066555,
0.0305709243,
0.0280409772,
-0.0283347592,
0.0215470586,
-0.0522132441,
-0.0246069152,
0.0654634312,
-0.0068469397,
-0.0120439921,
-0.0750710964,
0.0001740645,
0.0201986246,
0.1013055593,
0.0647715256,
0.0401170515,
0.0379562713,
-0.0291050375,
-0.1013078019,
-0.0256225206,
0.0434053056,
0.0204386059,
0.0414781794,
-0.0299330894,
-0.0455320664,
-0.0249614585,
-0.0360745527,
-0.0526659861,
-0.0199578237,
-0.0183304977,
0.0048949006,
0.0272126906,
0.0232261587,
-0.0516140275,
-0.0192616284,
-0.0274802689,
0.0308169946,
0.0740329921,
-0.0192318726,
-0.0103589371,
-0.0245972294,
0.0286601279,
-0.0526629053,
-0.0277899727,
0.0288858172,
-0.0192353856,
0.0092759458,
-0.0140945204,
0.0856804401,
-0.0223182514,
-0.0507265143,
-0.024247624,
-0.0114294011,
0.0226981714,
0.013365359,
-0.0122888247,
0.0115129286,
0.0526616238,
0.0172470119,
-0.007837669,
0.000699723,
-0.0269501284,
-0.0338896103,
0.0021195898,
-0.0284688752,
-0.0024138018,
0.0060290759,
-0.0146984104,
-0.0098755909,
0.0017611338,
0.0316789672,
-0.0260371342,
-0.0005979686,
0.0789526924,
2.827e-7,
0.0317243002,
0.0298535265,
-0.0530719012,
0.0186326373,
-0.0142072542,
0.0752245337,
-0.0003590118,
0.0371828377,
0.0758195445,
-0.0539211407,
0.0291117895,
0.041314207,
0.0586409047,
0.0586854666,
-0.0816263855,
-0.0320247076,
-0.0416447818,
-0.0710577294,
-0.0474672504,
0.0445968732,
0.0361824781,
0.0891374797,
0.0361493379,
-0.001090155,
0.0389307067,
-0.0173472352,
0.0407515131,
-0.0111671463,
-0.0133119877,
-0.0155136846,
0.0699356422,
-0.0529008359,
-0.0016349087,
0.0614189357,
0.026915757,
0.0245858487,
-0.0541666448,
0.0385368802,
0.0042123818,
0.0458426178,
-0.0292686168,
-0.0354171209,
0.0249551255,
-0.045445621,
0.0716078207,
-0.020221414,
-0.0157461539,
0.0113429129,
-0.0238857102,
-0.0413824469,
0.0161583722,
0.0138248391,
-0.0307803079,
-0.0260609575,
0.0221342128,
-0.0310818385,
0.0262688417,
-0.0693126172,
-0.0371941887,
0.0372825414,
-0.0110272057,
-0.0249209292,
0.0245027859,
-0.0363043621,
0.0531801358,
-0.0749053806,
0.0343921706,
2.363572461e-34,
0.0308693144,
-0.0248525441,
0.013967786,
0.0288588274,
0.0396776795,
0.0326309055,
-0.0016109608,
-0.0130615085,
0.0169211756,
-0.0619813055,
0.0234056134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08315v1 | IterLara: A Turing Complete Algebra for Big Data, AI, Scientific Computing, and Database | 2023-07-17T08:23:09 | 2023-07-17T08:23:09 | Hongxiao Li, Wanling Gao, Lei Wang, Jianfeng Zhan | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.DS | \textsc{Lara} is a key-value algebra that aims at unifying linear and
relational algebra with three types of operation abstraction. The study of
\textsc{Lara}'s expressive ability reports that it can represent relational
algebra and most linear algebra operations. However, several essential
computations, such as matrix inversion and determinant, cannot be expressed in
\textsc{Lara}. \textsc{Lara} cannot represent global and iterative computation,
either. This article proposes \textsc{IterLara}, extending \textsc{Lara} with
iterative operators, to provide an algebraic model that unifies operations in
general-purpose computing, like big data, AI, scientific computing, and
database. We study the expressive ability of \textsc{Lara} and
\textsc{IterLara} and prove that \textsc{IterLara} with aggregation functions
can represent matrix inversion, determinant. Besides, we demonstrate that
\textsc{IterLara} with no limitation of function utility is Turing complete. We
also propose the Operation Count (OP) as a metric of computation amount for
\textsc{IterLara} and ensure that the OP metric is in accordance with the
existing computation metrics. | [
-0.0050187754,
0.0729524642,
-0.026065683,
0.0103646517,
-0.0141320899,
0.036651697,
-0.0124371499,
0.0008417569,
-0.0035151772,
0.0208399855,
-0.0388067141,
0.0167932678,
-0.0445130952,
0.0461676754,
0.0080200452,
-0.0481882989,
0.0306784175,
-0.0085900966,
-0.0771312192,
-0.0233755596,
-0.0457665659,
-0.014967205,
-0.0125537496,
-0.0553560592,
0.0474413447,
-0.0164104439,
0.0192287844,
-0.0803761557,
0.008346444,
0.0587953106,
-0.0449300036,
-0.0245012604,
-0.0283157546,
-0.0100806002,
0.0000020149,
0.0087471232,
-0.0150370533,
0.0620356277,
-0.0539389327,
0.0212943237,
-0.0111838132,
0.0242787935,
-0.0103950128,
0.0099525359,
0.0057078269,
0.0367942117,
0.0452074818,
-0.0445500724,
-0.0168350022,
-0.0045248894,
0.0111618154,
-0.0782570541,
0.0617991649,
0.0180950779,
0.0298118312,
-0.0256370418,
0.0005369378,
0.0290254802,
0.0098685808,
-0.0343099609,
0.0211045723,
0.007568955,
0.0253474787,
0.0009290625,
0.0473769642,
0.0069303433,
0.0262737758,
-0.0185182989,
-0.0400949083,
-0.0085127726,
0.0273666065,
-0.0404270403,
0.0094954129,
0.0576450489,
-0.0202505719,
-0.0407765396,
-0.0366705954,
0.0561927594,
0.0541232526,
-0.008183917,
-0.0027364662,
0.0155597115,
-0.0035964446,
-0.0185256116,
-0.0430043899,
0.0483134687,
0.0504527241,
0.0184791517,
-0.026270451,
-0.0174124893,
0.0376487412,
0.0055570323,
0.0239791516,
0.0306434743,
-0.0614478998,
-0.0198201947,
-0.0036681194,
-0.0161696374,
-0.0061619165,
-0.0734889507,
0.0638794452,
0.0122181037,
0.0767124593,
0.0338505358,
0.0102700507,
0.0784907937,
-0.0586457998,
0.0063934624,
-0.0169492736,
-0.0233153608,
0.0276022702,
-0.0078491671,
0.003654009,
0.0101735238,
0.0073864809,
0.0454246625,
-0.0327291936,
0.1046164706,
-0.04747862,
-0.003317649,
-0.0856071636,
-0.0538145639,
0.0467603058,
0.0137568563,
-0.0093487902,
-0.0276833531,
-0.0080198273,
-0.0114248218,
-0.0110524129,
-0.026894886,
0.0054235468,
0.0339881852,
0.0288653877,
-0.0086876471,
0.0408719294,
0.0394325741,
-0.0045557688,
-0.026948804,
0.0345456004,
0.0152819715,
0.0522859804,
-0.0830070749,
0.0132849002,
-0.0090376111,
0.096140407,
0.0248249266,
-0.0016913038,
-0.0140159521,
-0.0324473493,
-0.0032696067,
-0.0177573375,
0.0248598456,
-0.0050926413,
0.0263956543,
-0.0030353034,
-0.0074048201,
0.023922734,
-0.0112213092,
-0.0287542604,
0.012103539,
-0.005586178,
-0.0203270055,
0.0170011204,
-0.0096574575,
0.0277623236,
-0.0188987963,
-0.0629769489,
0.0369248725,
-0.0257509854,
-0.0138727296,
-0.0659539327,
0.1089199409,
-0.0218008794,
0.0378137641,
-0.0041376418,
-0.0184809752,
-0.0267419927,
0.0877646878,
-0.0129560111,
0.0033960543,
0.0601097345,
-0.0111118443,
-0.0078018443,
0.0492743328,
-0.0639990345,
-0.0236892905,
0.0067955614,
-0.028631622,
-0.0182971917,
-0.0367954262,
0.0339001827,
0.0203061122,
0.0107688736,
-0.0177233685,
0.0598072857,
-0.0062615648,
-0.0250203274,
-0.0427586176,
-0.0378681123,
-0.0524294935,
-0.022674365,
-0.0331603438,
0.0686546043,
0.0160431769,
0.0072150966,
-0.0494781919,
0.0028135665,
0.0054173665,
0.0058379932,
-0.0399491042,
-0.0170914251,
-0.0126106963,
-0.0610054992,
-0.0021241191,
-0.0014514364,
0.0554619245,
0.0148337167,
-0.0035650814,
0.0064054355,
-0.0134113468,
-0.0237035174,
0.0075997747,
-0.0163129345,
-0.0488621667,
0.019894341,
-0.0298859458,
0.0274025202,
0.036125686,
0.0542588755,
0.0337898917,
-0.0146341091,
0.0276875589,
0.0597105697,
0.0115083056,
-0.0511971079,
-0.0420876853,
0.0575263985,
0.0919549912,
0.0159011278,
-0.0096742902,
0.0033455377,
0.0398301668,
-0.0262887385,
0.0066739176,
0.0686968341,
-0.0146204978,
-0.0323680826,
0.0013149155,
0.0173236728,
-0.028853422,
-0.0126882745,
0.0207333472,
0.0315305665,
-0.0235405918,
0.0036748736,
-0.04308559,
-0.0476992093,
-0.0420831144,
0.0524162166,
-0.0521471575,
-0.0097784474,
-0.0066754101,
0.0545092635,
0.0307100844,
-0.041830048,
0.0285989791,
0.0297834612,
0.0014576289,
0.0387354456,
-0.0286989734,
0.0643157512,
0.0262932386,
0.0560736507,
0.0337717198,
0.0313582532,
0.0254994761,
0.0301162675,
-0.0130701521,
0.025968885,
0.0039225742,
0.0230171643,
-0.0457874723,
0.0114306612,
-0.02645237,
-0.0147440089,
0.041322019,
-0.0418169126,
-0.0122175096,
0.048064515,
-0.011518077,
-0.0007324721,
-0.0079142023,
-0.0451942533,
0.0051835012,
0.0079025598,
-0.0062719262,
0.0120896678,
0.013986066,
-0.0358230472,
0.0560031161,
-0.0134520167,
0.0247756895,
0.0351050757,
-0.0049989843,
-0.0254668891,
-0.0543863773,
0.0456614494,
0.0087906746,
-0.0040512518,
-0.0200908016,
-0.0439724587,
-0.0275866278,
0.0080830846,
-0.0389031246,
0.0311120152,
0.0177011061,
-0.0140402401,
-0.0372750647,
-0.0028936747,
0.0072747888,
0.0236793943,
0.0107686622,
-0.0290645082,
0.0378217883,
0.0023330215,
-0.0102865463,
-0.0403327495,
-0.018419506,
0.0565404631,
0.0113573261,
0.0209782198,
-0.096678704,
0.0156216165,
0.016892463,
-0.0285657644,
-0.0549512133,
-0.0488544144,
0.0603966229,
0.0059257937,
-0.0116528925,
0.0227480419,
0.0007635431,
-0.015159837,
0.0662146807,
0.0012406195,
-0.0133320261,
-0.0134097803,
-0.0180701148,
-0.0042060735,
-0.0069572479,
0.0331424065,
-0.0293674599,
0.0114742853,
0.0280718189,
0.0087750033,
-0.0828573704,
-0.0133486707,
-0.004302674,
-0.005493666,
0.0216956474,
0.020875575,
0.0641835183,
0.0104732607,
-0.016834721,
-0.0073417802,
-0.0129344333,
-0.0052741724,
-0.0381462164,
0.0350783318,
-0.0010069069,
-0.0718862191,
-0.01487948,
-0.0015637111,
-0.0068463725,
-0.0075731515,
-0.010932195,
0.0163089279,
0.0094764484,
-0.0141377393,
0.0308369081,
0.0520153493,
-0.1401603073,
0.0337882228,
-0.0189808514,
-0.0292362161,
-0.0385037139,
-0.0210411381,
0.0150608364,
-0.038803,
0.0021448592,
-0.0034909714,
-0.0826246142,
-0.0963121578,
-0.0365494154,
0.0498178154,
-0.0341547579,
-0.0209883358,
0.0283152238,
-0.0186838023,
0.0257411096,
0.0102470461,
0.0779355764,
0.0129208881,
-0.0145866517,
0.0118849715,
-0.0557114072,
0.0155260609,
0.0559426248,
-0.0712621808,
0.001876016,
0.0133655034,
0.0819418207,
-0.0369884148,
0.0193951316,
-0.0234039314,
0.0286391545,
-0.0424350016,
-0.0476585329,
0.0361740887,
0.0116701806,
0.014690035,
0.0063386681,
0.0773097053,
0.0050325859,
0.0013312083,
-0.0067573679,
-0.0640425682,
0.0206124503,
0.0581986979,
-0.0083644288,
0.0079152016,
-0.0149783194,
0.0036743889,
-0.0045072045,
-0.0107166208,
-0.0626409575,
-0.0500768609,
-0.0295088626,
-0.0262810513,
0.0056954492,
0.013952503,
0.0650175959,
-0.0005400404,
-0.0297402274,
-0.0564723574,
0.0699693263,
-0.0819260702,
-0.1306590438,
-0.0998223349,
-0.0315647535,
0.056932874,
0.0109168272,
-0.0001760654,
-0.0479340963,
0.0291071218,
-0.0602068305,
-0.0153521355,
0.0054534539,
0.0050804438,
0.0261053294,
0.0702635348,
0.0137672517,
-0.1059230417,
0.0102035059,
0.0003839699,
0.0616919808,
0.0622332767,
-0.038088046,
0.019971136,
-0.0227080528,
-0.0515170209,
0.0175208077,
0.0309996698,
-0.008586267,
0.0069358256,
-0.0137421936,
0.0025005108,
-0.0100323483,
0.0196592566,
-0.0285696313,
0.0590637773,
-0.02176366,
0.0578298084,
0.0227616541,
0.0177165382,
0.0074948301,
-0.0431545712,
-0.0101506189,
-0.0854541063,
0.0046322746,
-0.0181676038,
0.0078729158,
-0.036602091,
-0.0301679559,
0.0599325933,
-0.0117633296,
-0.0118394997,
-0.0061916737,
-0.0042694607,
0.0408405997,
0.0335317925,
0.0481003635,
0.0069292863,
-0.0218776558,
0.0587097779,
0.0109651983,
-0.0134044262,
-0.0370577462,
0.0252138246,
0.0130630424,
-0.0135525158,
0.0354720168,
-0.0138467969,
-0.0362298638,
0.0435285568,
0.0072717108,
-0.0118262731,
0.0492429882,
-0.0125527484,
-0.0292371698,
-0.0006496701,
-0.0400999747,
-0.0159453098,
-0.0268618986,
0.0113041317,
-0.0609772988,
0.0118104341,
0.0519766733,
0.0351935551,
0.0376618765,
-0.0572198518,
0.0423380062,
-0.0441516861,
-0.0080830315,
-0.0281357225,
-0.0468082875,
-0.029819658,
0.0240796451,
0.0676725358,
-0.0375754982,
-0.0157996919,
-0.0280395802,
-0.0197342522,
0.000963657,
0.0085488884,
-0.0453677364,
0.0410700329,
0.0142251095,
0.0155458767,
0.0231280327,
-0.0291270707,
-0.0002711978,
-0.0796098262,
-0.0555641837,
0.0339101963,
-5.818115902e-33,
-0.0345494077,
-0.0077247284,
0.0191796739,
0.0452560894,
-0.0338675827,
0.0204851553,
-0.0148270661,
-0.0049485755,
0.0051183654,
0.0173127241,
0.0016478181,
0.0335180052,
0.0146949906,
0.0024145157,
-0.0138608869,
0.0441250391,
0.0079651969,
-0.0292348545,
0.0140596004,
0.0050896034,
0.0026304524,
-0.0502575524,
0.0274919216,
-0.0379920229,
-0.0239379257,
0.0039174263,
-0.0431996323,
0.0152651723,
-0.0509637818,
0.034512341,
-0.0214202572,
-0.0111891683,
-0.0177711938,
-0.0058843801,
-0.0123985773,
0.0505596176,
-0.04466803,
-0.0150311505,
0.0275083408,
-0.0037920924,
0.0018036593,
-0.0053303242,
0.011071451,
-0.0149781862,
-0.0220071636,
-0.0138722761,
-0.047238864,
-0.005826626,
0.0049589798,
-0.0376792736,
0.0030334878,
0.0095228339,
-0.032089293,
0.0268228892,
0.037056949,
-0.0013363549,
-0.051511582,
-0.0497675873,
-0.0196759757,
0.0252485126,
-0.0102622332,
-0.0573619343,
-0.0496025197,
-0.0174530912,
0.0237693898,
-0.0230024084,
0.0691416189,
-0.0323687941,
-0.0321240239,
0.0431941636,
-0.0656593442,
0.0728648603,
-0.0122911325,
0.0117625603,
-0.0121132964,
0.0194854755,
-0.0749574527,
0.0588949993,
-0.0270256083,
0.0149248252,
0.0137568377,
-0.0233603623,
-0.0509002395,
-0.0369969867,
-0.0022225585,
0.023492828,
-0.0502297021,
0.035227973,
-0.0369396619,
-0.0188578591,
-0.0681931525,
0.1244706437,
0.014275847,
-0.0451940671,
-0.0014712343,
0.0537211969,
-0.0036877578,
0.0182910096,
0.0589040928,
0.0164582506,
-0.0258573312,
0.0025822155,
-0.0787345916,
0.0186146777,
0.0336214527,
0.0348503143,
-0.0014614457,
0.0626006648,
-0.0567251965,
0.0040864181,
-0.0097214747,
0.0045192721,
-0.0202083942,
-0.0027094393,
0.0056170095,
0.0193842724,
0.0521846823,
0.0774968415,
0.0034428886,
0.0505557619,
0.0162336025,
-0.0190681834,
0.0044777011,
0.0112391887,
0.0142668411,
-0.0371291861,
-0.0332706608,
-0.0097061954,
0.0132629685,
-0.0333127081,
-0.0029972454,
-0.0280948859,
2.933e-7,
-0.0033466259,
0.0075571937,
0.0296497717,
0.0419408157,
0.0054227281,
0.0184025206,
0.0764814094,
0.0306952875,
-0.0091132466,
0.1020008102,
0.0421807244,
0.024930723,
-0.0262893401,
-0.0596691445,
0.0515068658,
-0.0408066288,
-0.055707369,
-0.0316385627,
-0.0138694067,
-0.0023921893,
0.0485345423,
-0.0100628892,
0.0745140687,
-0.0027834068,
-0.0026751091,
-0.0052974266,
0.0319111906,
0.0285264626,
0.0240837391,
0.0189726092,
-0.0502085947,
0.0415384732,
0.0260155406,
-0.0197252147,
0.0343487151,
0.0480049774,
0.0221342109,
0.0588364229,
0.0038352166,
0.0498869829,
0.0291711744,
-0.0800722539,
-0.0155244702,
-0.0137678301,
0.087069571,
0.0682918951,
-0.0461778417,
-0.0270871092,
-0.0466007777,
0.0219793711,
0.0049440823,
0.0198581107,
0.0002307978,
-0.0243993327,
-0.0295734797,
-0.003490452,
-0.009510437,
0.0172084216,
0.0061983308,
0.0316576809,
-0.003931575,
0.0008487005,
-0.0060066953,
0.0263912287,
0.0156666916,
-0.0099957269,
0.0024678311,
2.7485301e-34,
0.035311047,
0.0328339264,
0.0493499003,
-0.0216890611,
0.0396494158,
-0.0053535085,
-0.02153855,
-0.0307640806,
-0.0007631963,
-0.0523392148,
-0.038322892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08303v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08303v5 | Soft Prompt Tuning for Augmenting Dense Retrieval with Large Language Models | 2023-07-17T07:55:47 | 2024-06-17T04:30:58 | Zhiyuan Peng, Xuyang Wu, Qifan Wang, Yi Fang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Dense retrieval (DR) converts queries and documents into dense embeddings and
measures the similarity between queries and documents in vector space. One of
the challenges in DR is the lack of domain-specific training data. While DR
models can learn from large-scale public datasets like MS MARCO through
transfer learning, evidence shows that not all DR models and domains can
benefit from transfer learning equally. Recently, some researchers have
resorted to large language models (LLMs) to improve the zero-shot and few-shot
DR models. However, the hard prompts or human-written prompts utilized in these
works cannot guarantee the good quality of generated weak queries. To tackle
this, we propose soft prompt tuning for augmenting DR (SPTAR): For each task,
we leverage soft prompt-tuning to optimize a task-specific soft prompt on
limited ground truth data and then prompt the LLMs to tag unlabeled documents
with weak queries, yielding enough weak document-query pairs to train
task-specific dense retrievers. We design a filter to select high-quality
example document-query pairs in the prompt to further improve the quality of
weak tagged queries. To the best of our knowledge, there is no prior work
utilizing soft prompt tuning to augment DR models. The experiments demonstrate
that SPTAR outperforms the unsupervised baselines BM25 and the recently
proposed LLMs-based augmentation method for DR. | [
0.0363888219,
0.0105750617,
0.0052625029,
0.019138284,
0.0109918257,
0.0065148999,
0.0170415267,
0.0081705898,
0.0236715749,
-0.0344271958,
-0.0753436014,
-0.0247417241,
-0.0430240817,
0.0503317639,
0.0172604229,
-0.0210983194,
0.0590738133,
-0.0143227922,
-0.014698022,
0.0116652856,
-0.0142636765,
0.0114468494,
0.022242384,
-0.0085851206,
0.0285692625,
-0.0002016928,
-0.0045741433,
0.0332589783,
-0.0191376861,
-0.0185848121,
0.0242083017,
0.0745986328,
0.053393282,
0.0366289541,
0.0000017424,
-0.0631833375,
-0.030959459,
-0.0054957131,
-0.0432392582,
-0.0040773936,
0.0064289863,
-0.0023008646,
0.0592708699,
-0.0013801835,
-0.0121228117,
-0.0316019282,
0.0079484126,
0.0577260926,
0.0536907129,
0.0810461566,
-0.0059768423,
0.0178704076,
0.0011655373,
-0.0500795804,
0.0419782028,
-0.0669146329,
0.0426270068,
-0.0304387603,
0.0307744499,
0.0865944102,
-0.0050657499,
0.0153718581,
-0.0219801962,
-0.0265042465,
0.053748589,
0.0053779958,
-0.0395604633,
0.0063059134,
0.0114397295,
0.0663515255,
0.0068447073,
-0.0038601512,
-0.0020219893,
0.0067965356,
0.0257608183,
0.0132747227,
-0.0609643869,
-0.0360969827,
0.0185902771,
-0.0021457036,
-0.0347993188,
-0.0032222697,
0.0223087147,
0.0204107668,
-0.002504274,
0.0312671885,
0.0267318394,
-0.0388456546,
0.0379137211,
0.0257761925,
-0.0370250233,
-0.0125606041,
-0.0086480044,
0.0165627711,
-0.0674675182,
-0.0131458258,
-0.0494704917,
-0.0213805959,
0.0312715285,
-0.0070292251,
0.0294878967,
0.0147474837,
-0.0424198359,
0.1021876782,
-0.0361151695,
0.0273102503,
0.0116473846,
0.0411640108,
-0.0458816253,
-0.0284717381,
-0.0402381793,
0.0001888269,
-0.0462741442,
0.0373329185,
-0.0222299807,
-0.0118118962,
-0.0152951051,
0.0241645407,
0.0121374363,
-0.0139277289,
-0.0009930751,
0.0155890835,
-0.0851504207,
-0.0150828762,
-0.0347174481,
0.0226317756,
-0.0062361425,
0.0402437188,
0.0279508382,
-0.0461573377,
-0.0245710071,
0.005457195,
0.0480731986,
-0.0790729076,
0.0068112896,
-0.0197354872,
-0.0390356444,
-0.0515269339,
-0.0318152495,
-0.0207868293,
0.0107100382,
-0.0089877201,
-0.0065849843,
-0.0293506216,
0.0311560836,
-0.0260441154,
-0.0003832104,
-0.028436875,
-0.0165183078,
0.0177532509,
-0.0376407541,
0.0677680671,
-0.0016065934,
0.0109789073,
0.0448482968,
0.0062033194,
-0.0238213427,
0.0459277295,
-0.0608059727,
0.0447365642,
0.0613250583,
0.0002609467,
0.003730336,
-0.0082521541,
0.0331261195,
0.0591371246,
0.002043487,
0.0241985526,
0.016134914,
0.014850636,
0.0411359817,
0.0236546453,
-0.0289702322,
-0.011485341,
0.0126042347,
0.0166428834,
0.0386602692,
-0.043221835,
0.0379325263,
0.0068090954,
-0.0388944522,
-0.0048716916,
-0.0328167155,
0.0164396428,
-0.0282311141,
-0.0244765095,
0.0584279485,
-0.0153399697,
-0.0577698201,
0.0100703258,
0.0321697108,
0.0185468588,
-0.0375939682,
0.0282935463,
0.0561471656,
0.01410452,
-0.0041140094,
0.0298726019,
0.0144749507,
-0.0064092823,
0.0188604854,
-0.0565159358,
0.0319529027,
0.0210846271,
0.0363951735,
-0.0283289701,
-0.012324064,
-0.0219549108,
0.0509854667,
0.0052553792,
0.0712644458,
-0.0252543949,
0.023283612,
-0.0461441688,
-0.0794155151,
-0.0114706289,
0.0212305039,
0.0041367062,
-0.0130297178,
0.0363219269,
0.0672040209,
-0.0705936179,
-0.010211939,
0.0303248819,
-0.0399378017,
-0.063354671,
0.0290779322,
0.0087118279,
-0.0182668623,
0.0027141452,
0.0087360023,
0.0166419093,
0.0293313973,
0.0025716212,
-0.0078332182,
-0.072506234,
-0.0494759567,
0.0126126902,
0.0051885606,
0.0060363007,
0.0208693855,
0.0143871279,
-0.035236761,
-0.0446098857,
-0.0370056406,
0.0018888783,
-0.0281124003,
-0.0632485375,
0.0118134748,
-0.0155545864,
0.0125709977,
-0.0673266277,
0.0304213334,
0.0506197251,
0.0462679081,
0.0152708469,
0.0272861309,
0.0140918931,
-0.0611362197,
-0.0432158634,
-0.0132316649,
-0.0166042652,
0.0269888248,
0.0333756506,
0.0144998906,
-0.0506399758,
0.0200469028,
-0.0802519545,
0.0042989263,
-0.0299575832,
-0.0240403116,
-0.0105229849,
0.0375732183,
-0.0150754098,
-0.018243501,
-0.0401960909,
-0.0194987934,
0.0295107458,
0.0489549264,
0.0160447638,
0.0256784894,
0.0163203925,
-0.0387110077,
-0.0334488377,
0.0124575654,
0.0196426176,
-0.0228316691,
-0.0301256999,
-0.0405386873,
0.0465834104,
-0.0077424413,
0.0125970198,
-0.0046523702,
0.0250138119,
-0.0066593308,
-0.0695510283,
0.0113607636,
0.0741925985,
0.0090460833,
-0.019242838,
-0.0021247175,
-0.0075358972,
-0.0926788896,
0.0191015732,
-0.0433393009,
-0.0304365754,
-0.0112165604,
-0.0081627639,
0.0557932705,
0.0169268586,
-0.0255846139,
-0.0188811459,
-0.0498582758,
-0.0019711764,
0.0244741347,
0.0000171681,
-0.0702856854,
0.0170469172,
0.0237461012,
0.0386498868,
-0.0271809492,
-0.0227589104,
0.0667941123,
-0.0265321229,
0.0003376215,
-0.0242355429,
-0.0181152634,
-0.0577874146,
0.0221243221,
-0.0277003199,
0.0075455061,
0.0071228254,
-0.0197993796,
-0.0406686924,
-0.0164199769,
0.012577665,
-0.0151380002,
0.0416109264,
0.0058470746,
0.028007092,
-0.0225119554,
-0.0558650158,
-0.0322992988,
-0.0363109559,
0.0005368893,
0.0302513372,
-0.0175495185,
-0.0080510583,
-0.0385867208,
0.0032309517,
0.0033843191,
0.0459965542,
-0.0228826907,
-0.0278226621,
-0.0104781464,
0.0077218227,
0.0829076543,
0.0225820076,
-0.0453016646,
-0.0172004085,
0.0070400084,
0.0119505031,
0.0186752751,
-0.0323777497,
0.0038488891,
0.0229030792,
0.068297863,
-0.0084158638,
-0.0277864076,
-0.0078573413,
0.0449941568,
0.0040184204,
-0.0533938855,
0.0804198831,
0.0012459139,
-0.0750114024,
-0.0330137052,
-0.0366733111,
0.0273724981,
0.0373578109,
0.0614611171,
-0.0446058474,
-0.0428882614,
0.0130972471,
0.0601749867,
0.0320388414,
-0.033675041,
0.0085967863,
-0.1490978301,
0.0367085412,
-0.0095141483,
0.0284982491,
-0.0228781514,
-0.0696826205,
0.0214861669,
0.0068436,
0.0105752796,
0.0097399075,
-0.0097281234,
-0.0071906177,
0.0410867482,
0.0854789913,
-0.0679675937,
0.0129999788,
-0.0380205102,
0.0322809443,
0.0476003923,
0.0120966109,
0.0203320514,
-0.0331118107,
0.041334264,
-0.0244985055,
-0.0152958026,
-0.011238914,
0.0356493071,
-0.0362403318,
-0.0017715506,
0.0131440451,
0.0164488647,
-0.0109975971,
-0.0165524911,
0.01036999,
0.0771552995,
-0.0402754769,
0.0101455105,
-0.0474265926,
-0.0490975939,
-0.0049290564,
0.0819621682,
0.0084464215,
0.0095014377,
-0.0048491801,
0.0063342936,
-0.0014442416,
-0.0043606786,
-0.0110724987,
0.0142342011,
-0.0572612062,
0.0149555644,
-0.0421036929,
-0.0229393058,
0.0436319634,
0.0475431085,
-0.0044225366,
0.0130103184,
-0.0490168408,
-0.0204023588,
-0.0164850298,
0.0594819635,
-0.0680327117,
0.0212783851,
-0.0956870615,
0.0141053898,
0.0411200374,
-0.035192322,
-0.0169220828,
-0.036767967,
-0.0270630624,
-0.0455047525,
-0.0189630296,
0.0261569116,
0.0130213071,
0.0294747222,
-0.0493365899,
-0.0770500079,
0.0506031178,
0.0702923238,
-0.0534170792,
-0.0066328426,
0.0076257554,
-0.0389641933,
-0.0365366004,
0.0347384177,
-0.0826725587,
0.0135732396,
0.0315462127,
0.0378456935,
0.008081154,
-0.0516924895,
0.0139928237,
0.0367488638,
0.10365282,
0.0282959882,
0.0208260249,
-0.0514970422,
0.0142165134,
-0.0002021878,
-0.0312762745,
-0.0321345106,
0.022609571,
0.0555332229,
-0.013857875,
0.0004003318,
0.0149841495,
-0.0259435028,
0.0968320742,
-0.0782267153,
-0.0288613085,
0.0160617307,
-0.0064382157,
0.023728352,
-0.004952448,
-0.0259357374,
0.0330112204,
0.0374669321,
0.0624090284,
-0.0334861353,
0.0129673351,
0.037169043,
0.0280170087,
-0.0254603904,
0.0178630091,
-0.0855309889,
-0.0451053865,
-0.025829412,
-0.0004920142,
0.0143964496,
-0.0526573472,
-0.0013477217,
0.0170435645,
-0.0173724517,
-0.0452710688,
-0.0104605798,
0.038639348,
0.0027277069,
0.0364162661,
0.0479510464,
-0.0027402793,
0.0556579493,
0.0567512438,
-0.0015212235,
0.0386291742,
-0.0259935148,
-0.0366153568,
-0.0108049624,
0.0074328482,
0.0947303325,
0.0444245525,
-0.0249347929,
0.0088277645,
0.01242733,
-0.028430175,
0.037401583,
-0.0656502917,
-0.0367618203,
0.01304908,
0.0583421662,
0.0844464004,
-0.0011426203,
-0.0125824055,
-0.0405970439,
0.0042829234,
0.0002457227,
-0.0280705485,
0.0098111778,
-6.346848118e-33,
-0.0159998164,
0.0234157685,
0.0063128807,
-0.0303815585,
-0.0126716662,
0.002866155,
-0.0045314627,
-0.0353244133,
-0.03514117,
0.0023701487,
-0.04853414,
0.0064250464,
0.0176908672,
0.0393834151,
-0.0039883032,
-0.0150706321,
0.0713697001,
0.0081197908,
-0.0245122965,
0.0430642143,
0.0336734876,
0.0706467107,
0.0010671683,
-0.0397076756,
0.0200844016,
-0.007861848,
-0.0118870903,
0.0543642528,
0.0328575149,
0.0489949137,
-0.010684317,
0.0187138412,
0.0123526901,
-0.042577561,
0.0045708991,
0.0459105074,
-0.0897606015,
-0.0192052238,
-0.0055535296,
-0.0288437009,
0.00305703,
-0.0151292393,
-0.0163862891,
-0.0241384897,
0.0228484143,
-0.0062167505,
0.0205309074,
-0.0131177548,
-0.0540238507,
-0.0374254808,
-0.0053552715,
0.0161365736,
0.0138336029,
-0.0056030061,
0.0212772246,
0.0485125631,
0.0018011276,
0.0674777776,
-0.0359111093,
0.0201179311,
-0.0255093854,
0.0692921802,
0.0232469216,
0.0259692855,
-0.0447025932,
0.0396857634,
-0.0022704203,
0.013629985,
0.0282988288,
0.0056008757,
0.0323492065,
0.0613020919,
0.0040551675,
0.0606657304,
0.0233982112,
-0.0131407492,
-0.0358847082,
0.0544821322,
-0.0182444863,
0.0298878048,
0.0161182508,
0.0270570628,
-0.0526839495,
-0.0448102206,
-0.0346067809,
0.0069798385,
-0.0523329228,
-0.0065721124,
0.0400759764,
0.0429493524,
-0.0351316705,
-0.0161251165,
0.0745068938,
-0.0102629764,
-0.0348101705,
-0.0045815539,
-0.0018246879,
-0.0229147561,
-0.008510327,
0.0025773647,
-0.029058136,
-0.0849264637,
0.0690270886,
-0.0062412024,
-0.0248383991,
0.0089967493,
0.0465264358,
0.0113922954,
-0.0577045269,
-0.0110079348,
-0.0057891109,
-0.0012729603,
-0.0108447811,
0.0601103008,
-0.0189686995,
0.0210253894,
-0.0027995456,
0.0807143822,
0.0295273997,
-0.011697528,
-0.0053792996,
-0.0626506433,
0.0122580398,
-0.0151484115,
0.0007091269,
0.0100454353,
-0.0262319949,
0.0030278354,
0.0259342063,
-0.0394449122,
-0.0144228386,
0.0026977691,
2.616e-7,
0.0098286709,
0.0221090317,
-0.0239560902,
0.0105813369,
-0.0388243943,
0.0612321831,
-0.006244733,
0.0670601726,
0.0441383198,
-0.0301681086,
0.0183236636,
0.0169650894,
0.0227617044,
-0.0009597599,
-0.0923594609,
-0.0223131962,
-0.0437820219,
-0.0244705547,
-0.0560117848,
-0.0476693511,
0.0304169618,
0.0955609381,
-0.0056428164,
-0.0203891005,
0.0325996615,
-0.076944001,
0.0480988808,
-0.0097107692,
-0.0280647874,
0.026811311,
0.0747437179,
0.005180663,
0.0122431805,
-0.0015614228,
-0.0242423341,
0.0422626697,
0.0478348732,
0.0622585788,
0.0052868798,
-0.0219037104,
-0.0143908355,
-0.010021558,
0.0327977352,
-0.0171704963,
0.0874372572,
-0.0243539084,
0.0057262597,
0.0013007914,
-0.0352238044,
-0.0266709831,
0.0358592533,
-0.0520007536,
-0.013264725,
-0.0008094558,
0.0421899781,
0.0338430405,
-0.0355689228,
-0.0838257596,
0.0211652238,
-0.0290597305,
-0.0399495065,
-0.0247739181,
-0.0286551286,
0.0426122248,
-0.0116445925,
-0.0322191343,
0.0234273225,
2.370551269e-34,
0.0362052806,
0.0351644084,
0.0219266377,
-0.0169140138,
0.0196546074,
-0.0044280388,
-0.0249714479,
0.0360791013,
0.0384582095,
-0.1104533747,
-0.0218392573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08290v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08290v1 | CoAD: Automatic Diagnosis through Symptom and Disease Collaborative Generation | 2023-07-17T07:24:55 | 2023-07-17T07:24:55 | Huimin Wang, Wai-Chung Kwan, Kam-Fai Wong, Yefeng Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic diagnosis (AD), a critical application of AI in healthcare, employs
machine learning techniques to assist doctors in gathering patient symptom
information for precise disease diagnosis. The Transformer-based method
utilizes an input symptom sequence, predicts itself through auto-regression,
and employs the hidden state of the final symptom to determine the disease.
Despite its simplicity and superior performance demonstrated, a decline in
disease diagnosis accuracy is observed caused by 1) a mismatch between symptoms
observed during training and generation, and 2) the effect of different symptom
orders on disease prediction. To address the above obstacles, we introduce the
CoAD, a novel disease and symptom collaborative generation framework, which
incorporates several key innovations to improve AD: 1) aligning sentence-level
disease labels with multiple possible symptom inquiry steps to bridge the gap
between training and generation; 2) expanding symptom labels for each
sub-sequence of symptoms to enhance annotation and eliminate the effect of
symptom order; 3) developing a repeated symptom input schema to effectively and
efficiently learn the expanded disease and symptom labels. We evaluate the CoAD
framework using four datasets, including three public and one private, and
demonstrate that it achieves an average 2.3% improvement over previous
state-of-the-art results in automatic disease diagnosis. For reproducibility,
we release the code and data at https://github.com/KwanWaiChung/coad. | [
0.0221814346,
0.0542539544,
-0.0186598115,
-0.047318697,
0.0148632405,
0.0201453101,
0.0234509297,
0.0130594959,
0.0364580192,
-0.0028838818,
0.0293299165,
0.019368045,
-0.0046928176,
0.049323082,
-0.0239063278,
-0.04829349,
0.038148012,
0.0329681262,
-0.0064284164,
0.012250849,
-0.0236092638,
-0.0013639504,
-0.0280959327,
0.0503672697,
-0.0600641035,
-0.0230714362,
0.0148155931,
-0.0150302015,
0.0722037777,
-0.0764270648,
0.024851948,
0.0111681847,
-0.0227750205,
-0.0447511375,
0.0000022877,
-0.0425811373,
-0.0269453563,
0.0032936714,
0.0193675309,
-0.0617954545,
-0.0259389803,
-0.040338736,
0.056144882,
0.0271127354,
-0.0684458464,
-0.0361867286,
0.0187912676,
0.0613130555,
0.0482485779,
0.069531709,
-0.0281786937,
-0.0114779649,
-0.0140369171,
-0.0117376745,
-0.0048901537,
-0.0192471724,
0.0248645749,
-0.0206584316,
0.0376964994,
-0.0506637469,
0.0058904584,
0.0175879598,
0.0224653184,
0.0266908817,
0.0140422601,
0.0760940462,
0.0310903993,
-0.0488038324,
-0.0157886539,
0.0543975309,
-0.0011119395,
0.0010099098,
0.0374516882,
-0.0106698573,
0.0333023965,
0.0180743933,
0.0116158668,
-0.0121277049,
-0.0400964208,
0.0358701646,
0.0430715941,
0.0303850863,
0.0308399443,
-0.0493606478,
-0.0220208354,
0.0563975759,
-0.0250097401,
-0.0170602538,
-0.0258303527,
-0.0352786407,
-0.0207274687,
-0.0318911895,
0.0101438472,
0.0185735337,
-0.0944342464,
-0.0324656703,
-0.0058465968,
-0.0588469245,
0.060463652,
-0.0085958876,
0.0287632737,
-0.0007000307,
-0.0072019314,
-0.014212138,
0.0069688628,
-0.0142813819,
0.0014106635,
0.0189038739,
-0.0439481735,
-0.0017279045,
-0.049303595,
0.0138611561,
-0.0567160584,
0.0261699855,
0.0293972921,
-0.0258506574,
-0.0679955259,
0.005879736,
-0.0240181573,
-0.0108505124,
0.0428204015,
0.071112141,
0.0233225524,
0.0653799921,
0.0299115106,
0.0267138146,
-0.0248771533,
0.0012887057,
0.0325082354,
0.014839991,
0.0166977234,
0.0004749998,
0.0038822382,
0.0025558749,
0.027887864,
0.0315487199,
0.0048199734,
-0.0061115809,
0.0041997433,
-0.0405529104,
-0.0442432798,
0.0004880926,
-0.0230412055,
-0.0568914488,
0.0241302028,
0.0374135301,
0.0221023634,
-0.0351480208,
0.0158803239,
-0.0235648844,
-0.0085294582,
0.0220981836,
-0.0690182298,
0.0207175352,
0.0204136558,
0.0264690444,
0.0156892501,
-0.009850949,
0.0473357327,
0.0342432521,
-0.0071008122,
-0.0446918756,
0.0366736501,
-0.0032981583,
0.0229075607,
-0.0316827781,
0.0410956256,
-0.0460201129,
-0.0105197085,
0.0585491396,
-0.0708491132,
0.0573526025,
0.0453530103,
0.0092765624,
0.0107035693,
0.0032388035,
0.0796983019,
0.0006116274,
0.0262748823,
-0.0115982238,
-0.0453208573,
-0.0051874244,
0.0126982927,
0.024942724,
-0.0160334874,
-0.0166750289,
-0.0174863376,
0.0287523903,
-0.016973367,
-0.0993982777,
-0.0470210537,
-0.0200563706,
-0.0190206654,
0.0092122294,
-0.0044212998,
0.0121608078,
0.0003541702,
0.0487052836,
0.0530358814,
-0.0417509302,
-0.0672446266,
-0.0430548228,
0.0114509901,
0.0551004335,
0.0146910893,
-0.0382503793,
-0.0612999201,
-0.0066573457,
0.0037386168,
-0.0391588621,
0.0358441621,
-0.0208474882,
0.0126245068,
-0.0167232975,
0.007074038,
0.0542573221,
0.0149357617,
-0.0438923836,
-0.0390575826,
-0.0105911633,
-0.0046370891,
-0.0111879483,
-0.0319211148,
0.036891073,
-0.0548419543,
-0.0256857853,
0.0493901484,
0.0183815379,
0.061147429,
-0.0034935095,
0.008178656,
0.0063949316,
0.026497392,
-0.0648061633,
-0.081234701,
0.0604811944,
-0.0498301424,
-0.0498282015,
-0.0060445121,
-0.0060933242,
-0.0099173514,
0.0131348735,
-0.0725081638,
-0.024451375,
0.0127771897,
-0.046997413,
-0.0039907992,
0.0153331803,
-0.0242752675,
0.0674487576,
0.0263495911,
-0.0178489499,
0.0097218687,
-0.0209603645,
-0.0402413979,
-0.0156989396,
-0.0414608009,
-0.0008858545,
-0.002984867,
-0.0190071575,
-0.0476434529,
-0.0199026745,
-0.0183343012,
-0.0098403115,
-0.0228135977,
0.0023914147,
-0.0223611873,
-0.110239327,
-0.0051363641,
0.0263128988,
-0.0473729745,
-0.012232909,
0.019518571,
-0.0120941484,
-0.0130587658,
-0.0547368154,
0.0381998904,
0.0450230576,
-0.005536261,
0.048091758,
0.0402513482,
-0.0130296331,
-0.0418519303,
0.0219816193,
-0.0874464735,
0.0045663025,
0.045424819,
-0.0075315367,
-0.0305665955,
-0.0137064736,
-0.0172826089,
0.0049960949,
0.0142912734,
-0.0280339327,
-0.0149972513,
-0.0360484757,
-0.0279832501,
0.0464606844,
0.0262763593,
0.0627395213,
0.0518052392,
0.0109494813,
-0.0550364107,
0.0435676612,
-0.071676828,
0.0039203628,
0.0126826521,
-0.0745119452,
0.0111805107,
0.0845373496,
0.0446111821,
0.001257011,
-0.0394592062,
0.0258375891,
-0.002454218,
0.0299035888,
-0.0005696649,
0.0035950227,
-0.0119574228,
0.0079647386,
-0.0085468255,
-0.0637828186,
0.0588445291,
-0.0091797616,
0.0332604349,
-0.0882506669,
-0.0330150314,
-0.0284031536,
0.0077632656,
0.0247824527,
0.0352466255,
0.0478358082,
0.0239338446,
0.0237183385,
0.0346974581,
0.0004557205,
-0.056012027,
0.0140333902,
0.0075105554,
-0.0078923926,
0.032198295,
-0.0603097044,
-0.0545884781,
-0.0116133941,
-0.0120045114,
0.0128107853,
-0.0188838169,
-0.0185478497,
-0.0460497998,
0.0123068793,
-0.0508428141,
0.0544444621,
0.0297806598,
-0.0294088032,
0.0257348828,
0.0081947157,
0.0387537703,
0.0175530091,
-0.00698468,
-0.0196417216,
0.02345456,
0.0514779873,
0.0103402836,
0.0492178686,
-0.0244618822,
-0.0072823623,
-0.0308889095,
-0.0050523481,
-0.0176827461,
0.0275280084,
-0.040446274,
-0.0250884015,
-0.0006368037,
0.0997440442,
0.039184764,
-0.0466293879,
0.0473634154,
-0.0130321169,
0.0155380527,
-0.0047304332,
-0.005936319,
-0.0797648877,
-0.0416775718,
0.005535366,
0.048217576,
-0.022875268,
-0.0110689746,
0.0226508174,
-0.0098460745,
0.0319430232,
-0.0165039562,
-0.0151014747,
-0.0189149175,
-0.0428177603,
-0.0397134051,
-0.0047770692,
-0.0306459051,
-0.0453051291,
0.0120429546,
0.0025904148,
0.0414939933,
-0.0846805871,
-0.0412259325,
0.0224923976,
-0.0167334788,
0.055575788,
0.0551942177,
0.0472694598,
0.0235665292,
-0.0348428413,
-0.0145515492,
0.0279840324,
0.054386314,
-0.0174475089,
0.0672109574,
-0.0095925666,
-0.0032794676,
-0.0547227077,
0.0618599765,
-0.0657591969,
0.0038556925,
0.0355458297,
0.1014174968,
-0.0283908416,
-0.0525244474,
-0.0727149323,
0.0357318632,
0.0571526736,
0.0302461758,
0.0005350343,
-0.0035038455,
-0.0276668388,
0.076040782,
0.055361744,
-0.0010661429,
-0.008464138,
0.0327859335,
0.003185842,
-0.0501372889,
-0.078811191,
-0.0338842645,
0.0157112144,
-0.0005530303,
0.0213481411,
-0.0191803724,
-0.0304593239,
0.0010214194,
-0.076859206,
0.0135288779,
0.0935124159,
0.0176935177,
-0.0475574806,
-0.0266368389,
0.0538392998,
0.0157880206,
0.0017855192,
0.0171342511,
-0.05776475,
-0.0131909763,
0.0455055833,
0.0609755851,
0.010500432,
0.0139135662,
-0.0019002302,
0.0126323104,
0.037379548,
0.0689041838,
-0.0143268565,
-0.0170487948,
0.0217219386,
-0.0289956033,
-0.0032992782,
0.0171827134,
-0.015225281,
0.0468422957,
-0.0084888889,
0.0390300564,
-0.0189321414,
0.0053984369,
0.0473193564,
0.019188676,
0.0593394227,
-0.0239779539,
-0.0262444802,
-0.0172246434,
0.0044296584,
0.009950215,
-0.0097767375,
-0.0200069025,
0.0231783446,
-0.0189056583,
0.0011403445,
0.0186965093,
0.029669039,
-0.0268375464,
-0.0452471599,
-0.0379527584,
0.0598348044,
0.0341263488,
-0.0042046309,
0.0436686017,
-0.0011913609,
0.0485308543,
0.0124338064,
0.0393342003,
0.0233057328,
0.0199163798,
0.0641885847,
0.0111546749,
0.0649150461,
-0.0196260177,
0.0550482832,
-0.0231226105,
-0.0413225889,
-0.0186900105,
-0.0101382351,
0.0304529388,
-0.0054276516,
0.0680169612,
-0.0325038657,
0.0290664416,
0.0027582736,
-0.000915992,
-0.0475700311,
-0.0262343585,
0.0233564321,
-0.0333823822,
-0.0167843718,
-0.03630374,
0.0878057331,
-0.0292497836,
0.0240995623,
0.0067975824,
-0.0209916178,
-0.0415989459,
0.006114162,
0.0325426981,
-0.0047576092,
-0.0642487407,
-0.0018707308,
-0.0436387733,
-0.0397198983,
0.0325532518,
-0.0539606027,
0.0127171222,
-0.0142186657,
0.0405163094,
0.0350352973,
-0.0071429308,
-0.0250648167,
-0.0229261946,
0.0244383812,
-0.0224296805,
-0.0478721261,
0.000535438,
-5.997044509e-33,
0.0010631918,
-0.0304388478,
0.0094321072,
0.0025480862,
0.0426503159,
0.0345283747,
-0.0304324664,
-0.0045385556,
0.0326033197,
0.0376905352,
-0.0115616648,
0.0029444243,
0.0026799608,
0.064252995,
0.0386169031,
-0.0247880202,
0.0634196177,
0.0076019685,
-0.0496228859,
0.0195752773,
0.0357782394,
0.0480247959,
-0.0057890201,
-0.0950149447,
-0.045706667,
-0.0226685144,
0.0042936918,
-0.0126050562,
-0.0129086273,
0.0190953407,
-0.0001159766,
0.0547353476,
0.051805485,
0.0153200086,
0.0079313228,
-0.0102552166,
-0.0647759363,
-0.0272548087,
-0.043537952,
-0.0531230606,
-0.0441600978,
-0.0181839485,
0.0288670678,
-0.0054860301,
-0.0119285276,
0.0078394087,
0.0606485866,
-0.0211701673,
0.0188725069,
-0.070778124,
-0.0190007091,
0.0255581513,
-0.0003873114,
-0.0306662396,
-0.0292200111,
0.0662682429,
-0.0224845801,
-0.0023988406,
-0.0288932566,
0.0020167658,
0.0267276429,
0.0158754364,
0.019986162,
-0.0338125154,
-0.0322674252,
0.0378818884,
0.0648656115,
-0.0612976477,
-0.0658916235,
0.0477941483,
-0.0637744665,
0.0390539765,
0.0554809645,
0.0116215395,
0.0226560179,
-0.0511031747,
-0.0655778423,
0.0712651908,
-0.0502169952,
-0.0041613765,
0.0346457362,
-0.0406182148,
-0.0256630257,
-0.0311527178,
-0.0135174999,
0.0163063388,
-0.0267625023,
-0.0282647498,
0.0630256906,
0.0228208303,
0.0049734879,
-0.0211676545,
-0.0155354161,
-0.0313722156,
0.0019087566,
-0.0183143336,
0.0503074154,
0.0058712699,
-0.0309277605,
-0.0030229567,
-0.0388492271,
-0.0279192664,
0.0288921706,
0.0060830559,
0.0623049624,
0.0334894247,
0.0460023843,
-0.0180548429,
-0.0074399761,
-0.0131255202,
0.0428763926,
0.0279589444,
-0.0229396485,
0.0196999386,
-0.0063668033,
0.0252933558,
-0.0275633484,
0.0366654657,
0.0126877222,
0.0404508263,
-0.0591148771,
-0.002936007,
-0.0076183234,
-0.008314698,
-0.0282845944,
-0.0125279678,
-0.043938145,
0.0083254203,
0.0427348241,
-0.0757404119,
-0.005329696,
-0.0167881344,
3.012e-7,
0.0744544789,
0.0421714038,
-0.0035332353,
-0.0646233857,
0.0070776432,
0.0216411799,
0.0231659878,
0.0442160964,
0.002423502,
0.0204975996,
0.0286940653,
-0.0060585891,
0.0162715726,
0.0735634863,
-0.0095833633,
-0.0247327816,
-0.0667677373,
0.0068316618,
-0.0181431063,
-0.0252336673,
0.0805949047,
0.0602607466,
-0.0173935592,
-0.0565109439,
0.080724664,
0.0292767677,
0.0114179058,
-0.0235252865,
0.0188205559,
0.0232209601,
-0.0003317751,
-0.017958099,
0.0385031514,
0.0212959982,
-0.0311655384,
-0.0144130671,
-0.0263396557,
0.0075028655,
-0.0125787687,
-0.0486036092,
0.0041154362,
0.0066941609,
0.0316836312,
-0.0437465757,
0.0590354688,
-0.1140388325,
-0.0342195854,
0.0177161824,
-0.0185247976,
0.0151634375,
0.029783994,
-0.0133037046,
-0.0427213162,
0.0369253494,
0.012792469,
0.0451250598,
-0.0104184682,
-0.0994648635,
-0.0414528027,
0.0041534789,
-0.0230486281,
0.0038576312,
0.0273613166,
-0.0299011171,
-0.0125567699,
-0.0535679609,
-0.0077211214,
2.768886586e-34,
0.009284324,
0.0325257778,
-0.0220740251,
-0.0044833743,
0.0056694564,
-0.0307755955,
-0.005712491,
0.0119016143,
0.0241976399,
-0.0486655645,
-0.0511303432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10247v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10247v1 | Automated Action Model Acquisition from Narrative Texts | 2023-07-17T07:04:31 | 2023-07-17T07:04:31 | Ruiqi Li, Leyang Cui, Songtuan Lin, Patrik Haslum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Action models, which take the form of precondition/effect axioms, facilitate
causal and motivational connections between actions for AI agents. Action model
acquisition has been identified as a bottleneck in the application of planning
technology, especially within narrative planning. Acquiring action models from
narrative texts in an automated way is essential, but challenging because of
the inherent complexities of such texts. We present NaRuto, a system that
extracts structured events from narrative text and subsequently generates
planning-language-style action models based on predictions of commonsense event
relations, as well as textual contradictions and similarities, in an
unsupervised manner. Experimental results in classical narrative planning
domains show that NaRuto can generate action models of significantly better
quality than existing fully automated methods, and even on par with those of
semi-automated methods. | [
0.017626008,
0.0592002571,
-0.0219116863,
0.021244023,
-0.056430459,
0.0118050566,
-0.0289392658,
-0.0132439928,
0.0482433401,
-0.0297075734,
0.0582869947,
0.0330440067,
-0.0214550663,
0.0726125315,
-0.0420042947,
-0.0408258736,
0.0244917013,
-0.0153736342,
0.0246668402,
0.0343861207,
0.0103095463,
0.0554766953,
-0.0547058731,
0.0358990319,
-0.0194647666,
-0.0233205184,
-0.0631772429,
-0.023417253,
0.0495274663,
-0.0410802513,
-0.0213866271,
-0.0027126793,
0.027485637,
-0.0072483788,
0.0000019663,
-0.0752919763,
-0.0228738431,
-0.0445306785,
0.0039348686,
0.004048672,
-0.0069692601,
0.001666995,
0.0039817807,
-0.0436739214,
-0.0451268256,
0.0318012312,
0.0120334905,
0.0790685192,
0.0304376278,
0.0895597264,
-0.0350843035,
-0.0248331707,
-0.0192565173,
0.021528285,
-0.0387522951,
0.0019830056,
-0.0014276549,
0.0425135158,
0.0645403415,
-0.0002452934,
-0.0069117816,
-0.0154612996,
0.0126831718,
0.0146361291,
-0.0673384443,
0.0426493585,
0.0072708111,
0.0158467665,
-0.0134006739,
0.0524174049,
0.0295528062,
-0.030228829,
0.0357549302,
-0.0327782966,
-0.0147511093,
0.0396727435,
-0.0279826578,
0.0462822206,
-0.0265853442,
0.0343877189,
0.057957232,
-0.0100698406,
0.031366121,
-0.0331402272,
0.0193315726,
0.0574106388,
-0.0031076195,
-0.0024260825,
-0.0369095653,
0.0102497935,
0.0070242104,
-0.0860530213,
0.0190614313,
0.064302288,
-0.0378577746,
0.0189730693,
-0.0292251259,
0.0761275068,
-0.0262761638,
-0.0446059145,
0.0618915968,
0.056322325,
0.0147921238,
0.0330435932,
0.0119506614,
0.0690662712,
0.0170951635,
0.0226491913,
-0.0507710129,
0.0716250166,
-0.0538663901,
0.0192836877,
-0.027960239,
0.0320865735,
-0.0730951577,
-0.0288024135,
0.007646007,
0.0246227197,
-0.0144133288,
0.0135859437,
-0.0006403138,
-0.0065690852,
-0.0129957283,
-0.0254636779,
-0.0811262354,
-0.0475517884,
-0.0719906986,
0.0090440819,
-0.0542866401,
0.0086616427,
-0.0172554273,
-0.022002684,
0.0623473488,
-0.0039697369,
0.0237151161,
0.0653885528,
-0.0021340279,
-0.0062379194,
-0.0862573311,
-0.0442671105,
0.0215743408,
-0.0260138009,
-0.0436397977,
-0.0395206288,
0.0497989766,
-0.0222900081,
-0.0202033073,
-0.0047942279,
0.0009213116,
0.0002071628,
-0.0159814898,
0.0242420305,
0.0304148775,
0.0258100946,
-0.0245669074,
-0.0036507517,
0.02297966,
0.0140680671,
0.0545531474,
0.0509972796,
0.0225463938,
0.0738064125,
0.0423010699,
0.0444506519,
-0.016630413,
0.008883235,
-0.0012706304,
0.0000848621,
0.0034762539,
0.0276829489,
-0.0015602827,
0.0018964618,
-0.0292307921,
-0.0142536703,
0.0444222763,
0.0742420405,
-0.015731303,
-0.0045568715,
0.0983528867,
-0.0156147126,
0.0187922996,
0.0055112792,
-0.006714005,
0.0098697338,
-0.0123030841,
-0.0029651236,
-0.056362398,
0.0073099672,
-0.0058689681,
-0.0556000285,
0.0177828558,
-0.018551711,
-0.0021199337,
-0.0167387966,
0.0079488773,
0.0227856878,
-0.0766259953,
-0.0338161141,
0.0124351066,
-0.0596644394,
0.0211456642,
0.0129009457,
0.039512109,
0.0867825672,
0.074090369,
-0.0702602565,
-0.0501895584,
-0.0047252318,
0.0118722348,
0.0082407249,
0.0149082607,
-0.0570396259,
0.006057627,
-0.0258150082,
-0.011870347,
-0.0512358211,
0.0069593918,
0.0299258176,
0.0013204889,
0.0118356505,
-0.0422171727,
0.0500153303,
-0.0388106741,
0.0690103248,
-0.0609324984,
-0.0450960509,
-0.0382485874,
0.0192456208,
0.0125423763,
0.0045339549,
-0.0143513652,
-0.0001015771,
0.0483556427,
-0.0116346404,
-0.0342340358,
0.0735694319,
-0.0085784839,
-0.032217741,
0.0264589246,
-0.0222900249,
-0.037182197,
-0.0023741818,
0.0042296732,
-0.0353064947,
0.0028463174,
-0.0016833552,
0.0011475153,
-0.0016714527,
0.0120377783,
0.0177841615,
-0.0494895913,
0.0005110807,
0.0530547276,
0.0101964409,
-0.0365536548,
0.0240776874,
-0.011922772,
0.0210634973,
-0.0242179185,
0.0322921649,
0.0133984387,
0.0295130871,
-0.0197936017,
0.0564309321,
-0.0161111839,
0.0000339469,
-0.0181241147,
-0.051119972,
0.0057867784,
-0.0061062621,
0.0078483969,
0.0284766201,
-0.0129321357,
-0.0404416099,
0.0293932743,
-0.0062686312,
-0.0265149884,
0.0217487607,
-0.0337692685,
0.01087745,
0.0193440802,
-0.0109339003,
-0.0368477255,
0.0207918659,
-0.0479467586,
0.0198670309,
0.0674386397,
0.0070023825,
-0.0270974971,
0.0138882464,
-0.0071109179,
0.0328701623,
-0.0376262106,
-0.0360245891,
0.036795225,
-0.0617448799,
0.0226876512,
0.0304122753,
-0.0175091047,
0.0572112538,
0.0668138042,
-0.0622796305,
-0.024562696,
0.032676395,
-0.0646894649,
0.0312910043,
-0.0542491227,
-0.0323167071,
0.033166606,
0.0597972982,
0.0208800472,
0.0340791866,
-0.0639300495,
-0.013282408,
0.0075523895,
-0.0018669531,
0.038931936,
-0.0574393235,
-0.0374131128,
0.067466706,
-0.0173975639,
0.0097618336,
0.0436668284,
-0.0053493362,
0.0062671718,
-0.0299700163,
0.0239158999,
-0.030827241,
0.1094343886,
0.0480848402,
0.0448040254,
0.0282750819,
0.02191405,
-0.0302794985,
-0.0125124101,
0.0496771485,
0.018954739,
0.0314402431,
-0.068485871,
0.0026484742,
0.0416396558,
0.0020245032,
-0.0494002439,
-0.0390191488,
-0.0169082675,
-0.020987995,
0.0008007599,
-0.0325703174,
-0.0309991445,
0.0076820534,
0.0043274304,
0.0228495523,
0.0378436409,
-0.0365605429,
-0.0400782935,
0.005535963,
0.0385785326,
-0.0495666079,
-0.0123301437,
-0.0057776528,
-0.0069410792,
0.0220738705,
-0.0023770337,
-0.007841168,
-0.0179182198,
0.0413472727,
-0.0017146108,
-0.0332640707,
0.0226958357,
0.0316311643,
0.0096252253,
-0.0025679518,
-0.010317158,
0.0786828399,
0.0441492796,
0.0428244658,
0.0411888473,
-0.0232948996,
-0.0049548466,
0.0127976788,
0.0164203476,
-0.0252351966,
0.0084866444,
-0.0093533695,
-0.019610012,
-0.0408694111,
-0.0627450049,
-0.0065763355,
-0.0793269947,
0.0344957709,
0.004317536,
-0.0086020995,
0.0217096899,
-0.02734836,
-0.0003682135,
-0.0285774581,
-0.0726337284,
0.0045461501,
-0.0082385931,
0.014777245,
-0.0421549827,
-0.0568366684,
0.0220257044,
0.0268177893,
-0.0302040949,
0.011258252,
0.043926049,
0.0626569986,
-0.0044980291,
0.0468817279,
-0.0349612013,
0.0430451892,
0.0134343822,
0.0046353908,
-0.0040890211,
-0.0146979522,
0.0155231683,
-0.0237578936,
0.0663798526,
-0.0259812232,
-0.1052697152,
0.0218980499,
0.0643182695,
0.0044608992,
-0.0369019546,
-0.0224857498,
0.0285459459,
0.0078911576,
0.0480861589,
-0.0409543812,
-0.0112241153,
-0.0528627858,
-0.0134318313,
-0.0184819549,
-0.0742172822,
-0.0589338616,
-0.0069855074,
-0.0022865681,
0.031104343,
-0.0800525472,
-0.0852022842,
-0.0068257903,
0.0404853486,
0.0483536534,
-0.0307904277,
0.0423262306,
0.0027085673,
-0.0177095849,
0.0206896905,
-0.0287134536,
-0.0055182674,
0.0302761234,
-0.0103136888,
-0.0062929899,
-0.0275418255,
-0.0125473877,
0.0260793213,
-0.0118764108,
-0.0302772988,
-0.0169456583,
0.0443918444,
0.010479711,
0.0570016317,
0.0083570369,
0.0159452986,
-0.0012327645,
-0.0191023201,
-0.0260674395,
0.0437366553,
0.0302190613,
0.0630368739,
0.0045564906,
0.01711406,
-0.0207232032,
0.022922568,
-0.030488465,
0.061046306,
-0.074551411,
-0.0135206124,
0.0350008495,
-0.0146230431,
-0.0184068996,
-0.0253991149,
-0.0429403707,
-0.0706456229,
-0.0139714368,
-0.0332018174,
-0.0184192043,
-0.0376185589,
0.0436488129,
0.0177823938,
0.0273805857,
-0.0197770838,
0.0030046329,
-0.0643143803,
-0.0000907479,
0.0051004426,
-0.0177858081,
0.0868724585,
0.011153616,
0.0205019191,
-0.027221512,
-0.0029648009,
-0.0034924888,
-0.0384617448,
0.0414687507,
-0.0186123755,
0.0438702181,
0.0397665985,
-0.0042843958,
-0.028552426,
-0.0208519977,
-0.0561451688,
-0.004389103,
0.0227855761,
0.0108466242,
0.0543303788,
-0.0460156985,
0.0495190918,
-0.0920937061,
0.0290956181,
0.019922182,
0.0151404887,
0.0372760929,
0.0138478382,
0.0101397345,
0.0351128876,
-0.0117734913,
0.0246399865,
0.0278446097,
-0.0419259816,
0.1143194735,
0.0168658532,
-0.0333499387,
-0.0372933969,
-0.088486366,
0.0129362065,
0.037228927,
-0.0034939521,
-0.0338058397,
-0.0920504406,
0.0089245904,
0.0311752725,
0.0319598578,
-0.0027712926,
-0.0423139632,
0.0071104895,
-0.0045041959,
0.0113964081,
0.0070530968,
-0.0248757005,
-0.0019782102,
-0.045986712,
-0.0235275608,
-0.0278460179,
-5.278622402e-33,
-0.0081756562,
-0.0392925777,
0.0545555428,
0.0013805084,
0.0047731334,
-0.0224796776,
-0.0487332791,
-0.0245264955,
0.0121889962,
0.0666460618,
0.0062552905,
0.0049513453,
0.0050758729,
-0.047191672,
0.0064130784,
-0.0001664934,
0.0236524045,
-0.0011593823,
-0.0490566753,
-0.0109749883,
0.058336027,
-0.0411344282,
-0.0066766725,
-0.05092711,
-0.0033104315,
-0.0602820888,
-0.0466925725,
0.0255338084,
0.0096547157,
0.0451457202,
-0.0078107193,
-0.0292711798,
0.019104844,
0.0098447334,
0.0093590645,
-0.0024738263,
-0.0426083617,
-0.0333284326,
0.032812532,
-0.0214135759,
-0.0121737076,
-0.0304022506,
-0.0537813716,
0.0135163264,
-0.0129027534,
-0.0065173362,
0.0394856222,
0.0054060821,
0.0421213768,
0.0252740029,
-0.1088162661,
0.0103163915,
-0.0535148345,
-0.0446894169,
0.0133961709,
0.0552268662,
0.0460117757,
-0.0284433644,
0.0279765334,
0.0345431566,
-0.0186601263,
-0.0271435119,
0.0102377087,
0.0022212937,
0.0031162908,
0.0816205144,
0.0108614964,
0.00277541,
-0.0699307248,
0.0735198185,
-0.0352186449,
0.0571773238,
-0.0075404756,
0.0658999309,
-0.0355051234,
0.0486110188,
-0.0838577449,
0.0583459847,
-0.0169374682,
0.0319977812,
0.0373181514,
0.0116296485,
-0.043330837,
-0.0045590056,
-0.0160443187,
-0.0252251793,
0.0021198438,
0.0121994922,
0.0178810433,
-0.0100318836,
0.0048067793,
0.0338858813,
-0.0001256293,
-0.0280132983,
0.0104240514,
0.0670539439,
-0.0573701896,
0.00461955,
-0.0228427891,
0.0158467256,
-0.0464001931,
-0.0197754893,
0.0217803512,
-0.0182545893,
0.0437538587,
0.0371628217,
-0.0221876744,
0.0497675762,
0.0255855061,
-0.0052082352,
-0.0194068365,
-0.0419557504,
-0.0048751445,
-0.0532228425,
0.0241998881,
0.0030278442,
-0.0048911548,
0.0106397113,
0.0146252699,
-0.0404378176,
-0.0173016265,
-0.022725014,
-0.0041981307,
-0.0059812604,
-0.000918107,
0.0065694377,
-0.0214605741,
0.0411480702,
0.0164305065,
-0.0357386582,
0.0100954659,
0.0324448645,
2.562e-7,
-0.0120458174,
0.00287043,
0.0403183065,
0.0284388792,
-0.0078806486,
0.0412237905,
-0.0108346147,
-0.003170847,
-0.0087570967,
-0.0174010713,
0.0735226721,
0.0359583162,
0.0085586635,
0.0194386896,
-0.0478613451,
0.0069152666,
-0.0091218809,
-0.0843360797,
-0.0826617852,
-0.023207454,
0.1117491201,
-0.009270777,
0.0661906973,
0.0079560699,
0.0050422018,
-0.0282990783,
0.0431469046,
-0.0125519391,
-0.0259954091,
0.0430170447,
-0.0414082743,
-0.0514173508,
-0.0479965918,
-0.0342365168,
-0.015102827,
0.0106806802,
-0.0133206164,
0.0747287795,
-0.0487980172,
-0.0171954762,
-0.0280848779,
-0.0443980955,
-0.0181060582,
-0.0058716168,
0.0616274774,
-0.0086661438,
-0.0032870597,
0.0165411755,
-0.0074232793,
0.0148043688,
-0.0572160482,
0.0286152698,
-0.0151126124,
0.0288404003,
0.0109355506,
0.0207385775,
0.0115706241,
-0.070465751,
0.0126599791,
0.0368137695,
-0.0005792633,
-0.01466507,
0.0165519956,
0.0213816408,
-0.0060818084,
-0.0558638871,
-0.0098539945,
2.368808461e-34,
-0.0318763256,
0.0272385012,
-0.011869519,
0.0189929381,
0.0413136072,
0.0039790925,
0.0101702651,
0.0356193222,
0.0531792231,
-0.0567973219,
-0.0409599394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10246v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10246v1 | Deep Neural Networks and Brain Alignment: Brain Encoding and Decoding (Survey) | 2023-07-17T06:54:36 | 2023-07-17T06:54:36 | Subba Reddy Oota, Manish Gupta, Raju S. Bapi, Gael Jobard, Frederic Alexandre, Xavier Hinaut | q-bio.NC | q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG | How does the brain represent different modes of information? Can we design a
system that automatically understands what the user is thinking? Such questions
can be answered by studying brain recordings like functional magnetic resonance
imaging (fMRI). As a first step, the neuroscience community has contributed
several large cognitive neuroscience datasets related to passive
reading/listening/viewing of concept words, narratives, pictures and movies.
Encoding and decoding models using these datasets have also been proposed in
the past two decades. These models serve as additional tools for basic research
in cognitive science and neuroscience. Encoding models aim at generating fMRI
brain representations given a stimulus automatically. They have several
practical applications in evaluating and diagnosing neurological conditions and
thus also help design therapies for brain damage. Decoding models solve the
inverse problem of reconstructing the stimuli given the fMRI. They are useful
for designing brain-machine or brain-computer interfaces. Inspired by the
effectiveness of deep learning models for natural language processing, computer
vision, and speech, recently several neural encoding and decoding models have
been proposed. In this survey, we will first discuss popular representations of
language, vision and speech stimuli, and present a summary of neuroscience
datasets. Further, we will review popular deep learning based encoding and
decoding architectures and note their benefits and limitations. Finally, we
will conclude with a brief summary and discussion about future trends. Given
the large amount of recently published work in the `computational cognitive
neuroscience' community, we believe that this survey nicely organizes the
plethora of work and presents it as a coherent story. | [
-0.0229257513,
0.0689506233,
-0.0293338075,
0.0237242896,
-0.0262239948,
0.0205141939,
0.0098624239,
0.0124743478,
-0.0242657699,
0.0352305248,
-0.0592842735,
-0.0573530868,
0.0718464851,
0.1055748239,
0.0311603565,
-0.0272296276,
0.0123279598,
0.0260342713,
0.0083654188,
0.0016355689,
0.0009274656,
0.0056329616,
-0.0601386502,
0.0389925539,
-0.0188413151,
-0.0369765721,
-0.0425010212,
0.0055230935,
0.0207436457,
0.0022927118,
-0.0305842143,
0.0358619988,
0.0482093394,
0.0504405349,
0.0000019244,
0.0219363365,
0.0160695706,
-0.0286723822,
-0.0388251506,
-0.0206445251,
-0.0146864392,
-0.0117377751,
0.0039613047,
-0.0341958404,
-0.0512117818,
-0.0453702472,
0.1012518033,
0.069782421,
0.0097507089,
0.0399525985,
-0.0183024593,
-0.0312052965,
0.080967024,
-0.0399269722,
-0.0017188068,
0.0207709149,
0.0340237133,
-0.0248701721,
-0.0702385753,
0.0141257448,
-0.0471169911,
0.0430154502,
0.0109306024,
0.025917273,
-0.0058002942,
0.0340668447,
0.0079505779,
-0.0428656712,
-0.0239374377,
0.067937769,
-0.0052407761,
-0.0324748643,
-0.0323903114,
-0.0106730545,
0.004775539,
-0.0142151779,
-0.0040065045,
0.0262464583,
0.0071780947,
0.0683707744,
-0.0105377324,
-0.0132844141,
0.0438603684,
-0.037633948,
0.0021181069,
-0.0070807105,
-0.0158255603,
-0.0102716358,
0.0263432134,
0.0186390821,
-0.0177410152,
-0.0080711637,
0.0117247719,
-0.0084335906,
-0.0085222051,
-0.0123481127,
-0.0509639643,
-0.0518510081,
-0.0080341585,
-0.0459944643,
-0.0099960519,
0.0492110699,
-0.0304166377,
0.0083317589,
-0.0215936154,
0.0766057372,
-0.0842963308,
0.0270029828,
-0.0269282013,
-0.0014081399,
-0.0398030244,
-0.0467787385,
0.0173139684,
0.0231984425,
-0.0012601159,
-0.0548826344,
-0.0454947464,
0.0265355036,
-0.0180548877,
0.0107265413,
-0.0365104601,
0.0578437224,
-0.0016437125,
0.0470479429,
-0.0290249679,
0.0646623373,
0.0209319126,
0.0400225557,
0.0221922249,
-0.04429942,
0.0132706072,
0.0350752249,
-0.0127771748,
-0.0258542635,
-0.0027136805,
0.0581590384,
-0.0124111278,
0.0005104243,
-0.0170500986,
0.0230081864,
0.0120182997,
0.0350851938,
0.0507481359,
-0.0373573713,
0.0813268572,
-0.0060160812,
-0.022559559,
-0.0850848779,
-0.0186722688,
-0.0134515548,
-0.0388393588,
0.071611464,
-0.0351278186,
-0.0236646086,
0.0631584302,
-0.0040722522,
-0.0055140769,
0.0058215223,
0.0407794975,
0.0197619442,
-0.0329210535,
-0.0325716585,
-0.0310936831,
0.0278565157,
0.0080292057,
-0.0556641743,
-0.0464983396,
-0.0529335253,
-0.0176164974,
0.0619868636,
0.031999439,
0.0330361426,
-0.0049100691,
-0.0433489643,
0.0687245876,
0.0729840174,
0.0049572764,
0.0303222463,
0.0097211162,
-0.0232340507,
0.0134795392,
0.0099809142,
-0.0104146414,
0.0694561899,
0.037418738,
-0.0169841181,
-0.0249464195,
-0.0145484051,
-0.0288097933,
-0.0135866283,
0.0132564176,
-0.0324544273,
0.0027736169,
0.0307317618,
0.0435166694,
-0.054836005,
-0.0310848206,
0.0068116863,
0.0066383658,
0.0364946201,
0.0144509291,
-0.0180581436,
-0.011530594,
0.0171565134,
-0.004574459,
-0.0250563323,
-0.0439538546,
0.0156470872,
-0.0226976629,
0.038951911,
0.0100168409,
0.0217076093,
0.047656633,
-0.0487537757,
-0.0281998497,
0.0148012806,
-0.0161129963,
0.0361505784,
-0.054836411,
-0.0019198513,
-0.0347789861,
0.0386767611,
-0.0283693988,
0.0383498147,
-0.013772957,
-0.005972547,
-0.0079026837,
0.0242431816,
0.0496361032,
0.0019003571,
-0.0269879121,
-0.0010405337,
0.037387114,
-0.0209962912,
0.023548184,
0.0139763551,
-0.0394696072,
0.0071787909,
-0.0056465198,
-0.0503940247,
-0.0129347807,
0.0867058784,
-0.0080446955,
-0.0319561735,
-0.0201092735,
-0.0286885649,
-0.0046331231,
-0.0279784109,
0.0145331686,
-0.0098539107,
0.0270456411,
-0.0301339757,
0.0157099608,
-0.0080302088,
-0.001472013,
0.0086794402,
-0.0483835526,
0.0340334214,
-0.0682852119,
-0.0510935634,
0.0296834912,
-0.0463232175,
-0.0310499202,
-0.0043404442,
-0.0288526639,
-0.0271005817,
0.025577182,
-0.0389703102,
0.0025860348,
0.0410699919,
-0.0174898077,
0.024018243,
-0.006022288,
0.0156737193,
0.0101295291,
-0.0677436888,
0.0623378195,
0.0431254581,
-0.0057909712,
0.0257726144,
0.0020422675,
-0.0026874258,
-0.0239713266,
-0.0264030863,
-0.0596882999,
0.0418589078,
-0.0270542596,
-0.0591839403,
-0.0595129356,
0.0444873758,
0.0004842195,
0.0430874899,
-0.0132310987,
-0.0380501486,
0.0333106853,
0.0061330353,
-0.0143797155,
0.1055595428,
0.0017409216,
0.036672771,
0.0479858443,
0.0473072827,
-0.0031321335,
-0.0260536205,
-0.0197925679,
0.0076969774,
-0.0164214056,
-0.0421916693,
0.0065322132,
0.0542091057,
0.0796150714,
0.0340168141,
-0.060893409,
-0.004012119,
0.0156061733,
-0.0365819782,
-0.0292942263,
-0.0174242295,
-0.0147728007,
0.0638354048,
-0.052148506,
-0.0288479347,
0.0571346655,
-0.01379201,
0.0051785349,
0.0396014825,
-0.0071174172,
0.0032271468,
0.0023736514,
0.0473427139,
0.044964049,
-0.0217831917,
-0.0483994409,
-0.0492365472,
-0.0012181923,
-0.0397128612,
-0.0429350846,
-0.0166906212,
-0.0008705083,
-0.0176370293,
-0.0170489531,
-0.0019196919,
-0.0667665303,
0.0184753314,
0.0118745016,
-0.0109300576,
0.0080354093,
0.028676264,
-0.0630596727,
-0.0096794544,
0.022927383,
0.0219215099,
-0.0257431772,
-0.0079336669,
-0.0439090282,
0.0683770776,
0.0241313558,
0.021084426,
-0.0059889765,
-0.0272980649,
-0.0089330943,
0.0563841797,
-0.0287126806,
0.0678609833,
-0.094359763,
0.0309740882,
0.0156765394,
0.0364425965,
0.0311619174,
0.0112783993,
0.0106964177,
0.0049203853,
0.0031677033,
0.1005823016,
0.0264906436,
-0.0985731557,
-0.0214755014,
-0.0018823418,
-0.0066413158,
-0.0139223542,
-0.0082923705,
-0.0646467656,
-0.0048653064,
-0.0233306866,
-0.0114908097,
0.0219037794,
0.0044466867,
0.0126463305,
-0.0159506984,
-0.0001257196,
0.0293013304,
-0.0195285343,
-0.0630693287,
-0.0043877852,
-0.0051860507,
-0.0004350021,
0.037789043,
-0.0301034432,
0.0386615656,
-0.0093275877,
0.0496195219,
0.0222218595,
-0.0232507382,
-0.0065526329,
-0.0483621433,
0.0844221115,
0.0629898757,
0.0291354172,
-0.0394843705,
-0.0240512807,
-0.0488303751,
0.0191224013,
0.0135852927,
0.0214023329,
0.0499610119,
-0.0096707959,
-0.0293326378,
-0.0197972171,
0.0443324484,
-0.0613359287,
-0.0354548842,
-0.0571878925,
0.0411969163,
-0.0412269235,
0.0155134499,
-0.0350403488,
0.0172644835,
-0.0057347924,
0.0527439229,
0.0383680277,
-0.0397972576,
0.0103718266,
0.0115542086,
0.0421983749,
-0.0232436843,
-0.0592241436,
0.0198833961,
0.0165350195,
-0.0049110274,
-0.017975945,
-0.0260861292,
0.0348576643,
-0.0017188553,
0.0476266965,
-0.0430702232,
0.0762415007,
-0.0501128994,
-0.0733691007,
0.0254448839,
0.0238512028,
-0.0092790714,
-0.033879593,
-0.0226866286,
0.0149066141,
-0.0262754168,
0.0086878221,
0.0443070978,
-0.0654315799,
-0.0523853116,
0.0492290966,
0.0200976189,
0.0206727572,
0.0291755591,
0.0174648277,
-0.0151080852,
0.0438647531,
0.0184474494,
0.0017994504,
0.0096099591,
-0.0299603567,
0.0043062521,
-0.0294526927,
-0.0126234852,
-0.0474767908,
0.0096700937,
-0.0067832191,
-0.0040545715,
-0.0120170331,
0.0101899989,
0.0682799518,
-0.0255471207,
0.077136524,
0.0053188838,
0.0083664758,
-0.0298389271,
-0.012630173,
0.0288054645,
0.0530938208,
-0.0002334484,
-0.0399026275,
0.0779495686,
0.0160119794,
-0.0158739518,
-0.0256192442,
0.0182047039,
-0.015217009,
-0.0010974801,
-0.0281497519,
-0.034533482,
-0.0018417171,
-0.0273295548,
0.0504813977,
-0.0166634694,
0.0437960029,
-0.043539416,
0.0199595969,
0.0197810512,
0.0479809195,
0.0434262827,
0.0523781739,
-0.0311390478,
0.0582128912,
-0.0184028,
-0.0533032157,
0.0143097751,
-0.0049293661,
0.0339282118,
-0.0300860256,
-0.0143672982,
0.0114116771,
0.0296043046,
-0.0257423706,
0.0203035083,
-0.0360196456,
-0.000590392,
0.0448453538,
0.0071670022,
0.0195699204,
-0.0583135597,
0.041037403,
0.0018797599,
-0.0148491077,
0.0035973524,
-0.0055710711,
-0.0277695619,
0.0131687848,
0.0197265428,
0.012103729,
-0.049030941,
-0.0286022201,
0.0334435739,
-0.0501677282,
0.0213191062,
0.0000501471,
0.0412035808,
-0.0193713643,
0.0018754534,
-0.0014987456,
-0.002312182,
0.0032248257,
0.0533514805,
0.0074844817,
-0.0421586782,
-0.0501517914,
-0.0652832165,
-5.555063408e-33,
-0.0350012593,
0.004995184,
-0.0078725182,
0.0383387059,
-0.0279307086,
0.0046029016,
-0.0241110511,
-0.002378108,
-0.0152445165,
-0.0206123963,
0.0012015748,
0.0120698046,
0.0142028062,
0.0386821888,
-0.0150014041,
-0.0198260471,
-0.0377873965,
-0.0602748953,
0.0055585066,
-0.0224566478,
0.0485107079,
0.0087825246,
0.0777182877,
-0.0717946663,
-0.0375123098,
0.0207445901,
0.0287509449,
0.011338681,
-0.0048544356,
0.0169008542,
-0.0675914511,
0.0256127287,
0.0509895794,
0.0046137199,
0.0231415778,
0.0395278446,
-0.0530185252,
0.0169845074,
-0.0100170234,
0.0377369896,
-0.0614988208,
-0.0250634868,
0.0815762728,
-0.0206629764,
0.0097860117,
0.0202182215,
0.0460841022,
-0.0249050446,
0.0116824489,
0.0102811418,
-0.0200685523,
-0.0666482002,
-0.0407626852,
-0.0009226578,
0.0510226414,
0.0486751869,
-0.0253011193,
0.0369109064,
-0.0913209468,
0.0267666932,
-0.0263378508,
0.0284254793,
0.0502739623,
0.0109712463,
0.0331534185,
0.0737018585,
0.0830969363,
-0.0437692516,
-0.078081958,
0.0198056456,
0.0178866386,
0.0372511707,
0.031887155,
0.0200003479,
0.0715041533,
-0.0335267968,
-0.0517408177,
0.017589353,
-0.0203003548,
0.0171650816,
0.0360771418,
0.003225259,
-0.013713059,
-0.0037279497,
-0.0110932998,
-0.0265651159,
-0.0393238477,
-0.0297655556,
0.029807657,
-0.0563968681,
0.0165926944,
-0.0068908022,
0.042061381,
-0.0398973487,
0.0664510652,
0.0007361304,
0.0078080972,
0.0637864545,
0.0186953619,
0.0168233383,
-0.0328706428,
-0.0352567732,
0.0261039734,
-0.0055263308,
0.0746044666,
0.0310424753,
-0.0294364579,
0.0185892154,
0.0394122712,
-0.0293389652,
-0.0147218453,
-0.054309532,
0.0141794635,
0.0230443347,
0.0345297307,
0.0061529255,
-0.0017482304,
-0.0531725027,
-0.0295914821,
-0.0046701077,
-0.026639428,
-0.0208987854,
0.0061099059,
0.0445979461,
-0.0136751859,
-0.0031162053,
-0.0484500974,
-0.0337483324,
0.0506907068,
-0.0743621141,
-0.0139684761,
0.0166394897,
2.649e-7,
0.0047171633,
0.0196072645,
0.0651053712,
0.0285430085,
0.0398610272,
0.018430585,
0.0016669171,
0.0600717254,
0.0233251099,
-0.0750027522,
0.0045947582,
0.0537716113,
-0.0147498483,
-0.0371223353,
-0.0488210358,
-0.0178608559,
-0.0388290249,
0.0433634184,
-0.0184898097,
0.033883132,
0.0431551933,
0.0512492992,
-0.0369521528,
-0.0364438817,
0.047948055,
0.0460941941,
0.0587338544,
-0.0356568247,
0.0393640324,
-0.0179478973,
-0.0238168966,
-0.057031516,
-0.0192504209,
0.0540676005,
0.0362955742,
-0.005580598,
0.0133067593,
-0.0133968098,
-0.039902363,
-0.0771757513,
-0.0365284905,
0.0287386291,
-0.023989303,
0.0029811834,
0.0050385538,
-0.0833176076,
-0.1043335646,
0.0073729521,
-0.0677854866,
0.0359102339,
0.0320107043,
0.0157660954,
0.0133403121,
-0.0098217195,
0.0025560211,
0.0050596842,
-0.0014710603,
-0.0210962202,
0.009984713,
0.0173865575,
-0.0730077177,
0.0267402157,
-0.0297947489,
-0.0195607003,
0.0621478073,
-0.0303691383,
-0.0077652601,
1.572515502e-34,
-0.0549554378,
0.036332801,
0.0657046735,
0.0260621291,
-0.0518367849,
-0.0401040539,
0.0031439678,
0.0251898766,
-0.0284910351,
-0.0660407022,
-0.044018805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08272v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08272v3 | ChatGPT is Good but Bing Chat is Better for Vietnamese Students | 2023-07-17T06:36:53 | 2023-07-30T01:04:05 | Xuan-Quy Dao, Ngoc-Bich Le | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study examines the efficacy of two SOTA large language models (LLMs),
namely ChatGPT and Microsoft Bing Chat (BingChat), in catering to the needs of
Vietnamese students. Although ChatGPT exhibits proficiency in multiple
disciplines, Bing Chat emerges as the more advantageous option. We conduct a
comparative analysis of their academic achievements in various disciplines,
encompassing mathematics, literature, English language, physics, chemistry,
biology, history, geography, and civic education. The results of our study
suggest that BingChat demonstrates superior performance compared to ChatGPT
across a wide range of subjects, with the exception of literature, where
ChatGPT exhibits better performance. Additionally, BingChat utilizes the more
advanced GPT-4 technology in contrast to ChatGPT, which is built upon GPT-3.5.
This allows BingChat to improve to comprehension, reasoning and generation of
creative and informative text. Moreover, the fact that BingChat is accessible
in Vietnam and its integration of hyperlinks and citations within responses
serve to reinforce its superiority. In our analysis, it is evident that while
ChatGPT exhibits praiseworthy qualities, BingChat presents a more apdated
solutions for Vietnamese students. | [
0.0631969944,
-0.0297913216,
-0.039259322,
-0.0042453688,
-0.0437469892,
-0.0078314384,
0.0347564295,
-0.0210732073,
0.1118855625,
-0.0453009717,
-0.0454042219,
-0.0299963355,
0.0048230323,
0.0085162828,
0.0042412993,
-0.0386438929,
0.0339830667,
-0.0135215716,
0.004702847,
-0.0237365477,
0.0085773291,
0.0318610072,
-0.0241347924,
0.0521321297,
0.0478286706,
-0.0560291931,
-0.0198453348,
-0.0037315225,
-0.0310885776,
-0.04137595,
0.051070936,
0.0634137839,
0.0106157195,
0.0526424795,
0.000002263,
-0.0550410971,
-0.0119741624,
-0.0005588762,
0.0271093119,
0.0751678869,
0.0762788355,
0.0511052758,
-0.0150199756,
0.0298520122,
-0.0372324996,
-0.0021546772,
0.0286985021,
-0.0188153032,
0.0255354028,
0.0221002121,
-0.0063554444,
-0.0218697134,
0.0170611795,
-0.0045884051,
0.026335584,
-0.0218317937,
0.0093718218,
0.0960189551,
0.0754223019,
0.0314931199,
-0.0307596233,
0.0205104481,
-0.0086475248,
-0.0474658087,
0.00444492,
0.0351985693,
-0.02222706,
-0.0478565283,
0.0189173482,
0.0361644328,
0.0331349634,
-0.0094101503,
0.0070215389,
0.044327382,
0.0082482621,
0.0495561436,
-0.0994779989,
0.0166881494,
0.0047902339,
0.0122311879,
0.0275662169,
-0.04603374,
-0.0106787728,
0.030172592,
0.0248003658,
-0.0320252143,
0.015343667,
-0.0240670536,
-0.0334579796,
0.0291706957,
-0.0149513427,
-0.0073648742,
0.0069890628,
0.0322088189,
-0.0208590161,
0.0195632242,
0.0178168193,
0.0277012754,
0.0148466462,
-0.063398838,
-0.0036637688,
0.0624156781,
0.0085433889,
0.0118808532,
0.0166980289,
0.0392856039,
0.023533307,
-0.0022721689,
-0.0046090786,
0.0241709575,
-0.0704926178,
-0.0427210219,
-0.0395441875,
0.0730095059,
-0.0164944064,
-0.0508132763,
-0.072588414,
0.0230357256,
0.0273809265,
-0.0103125544,
0.0079656597,
-0.0270609073,
-0.02462174,
0.0182956215,
-0.032633204,
0.0605609752,
-0.0015789759,
0.0053363857,
-0.0000299527,
-0.0542409644,
0.0565178767,
0.0159142986,
-0.028850399,
-0.0382665172,
-0.0067798384,
0.0333636217,
-0.0433098748,
-0.0133548677,
-0.032223478,
-0.0235847514,
0.0188441835,
-0.0416625626,
0.0203630663,
-0.0599222407,
-0.0083558438,
0.0470790789,
0.0173903573,
0.03980406,
0.0033273934,
0.0268818792,
0.006161049,
-0.0005077235,
-0.0219967943,
0.0200535078,
0.0790974349,
0.0276155137,
-0.0064763441,
0.0573418736,
0.0177316908,
0.0035088311,
0.0212088153,
-0.0599918887,
-0.0178079829,
0.0172603726,
-0.0172266327,
0.0031786524,
0.0260608792,
-0.012946195,
0.0086343894,
-0.0024834496,
-0.062517494,
0.0562519021,
-0.026798781,
0.0812525824,
0.089652963,
0.0661659315,
0.0390154272,
0.059417747,
-0.0186577309,
0.0424601845,
0.0490804426,
0.0138030397,
-0.010303136,
0.0349540897,
-0.0129967099,
0.0135748684,
0.0356576182,
0.0256935153,
-0.019717453,
-0.049835708,
-0.0159197319,
-0.0029211915,
-0.0028626199,
0.02470457,
0.0372248031,
-0.0574064925,
-0.008565967,
0.0622377247,
0.0303256828,
-0.0202905238,
0.0124147786,
-0.0666022971,
0.0295038819,
0.0866542459,
0.0577153936,
-0.0154203493,
0.0022686636,
-0.0037322398,
0.0166552626,
0.0680749789,
0.0529317409,
-0.005511173,
-0.0471415706,
-0.0226089135,
0.0418574773,
0.0000192437,
-0.0043183542,
-0.0073863869,
0.0444228351,
0.0543748438,
-0.0101733422,
0.0079241348,
-0.0392745659,
-0.0174837653,
-0.0418390967,
0.0174848791,
-0.0541038513,
-0.022220578,
-0.0093083549,
0.0620736964,
-0.0145073887,
-0.0051621674,
-0.0082318932,
0.0113826767,
-0.0347532146,
-0.0102830026,
-0.0208122395,
0.0107690282,
0.053879682,
-0.0439248458,
0.0335269086,
0.0223076288,
0.0128997974,
-0.0163524766,
0.0531566441,
-0.0082770009,
0.0641263947,
-0.002763028,
0.0291268677,
-0.0598868579,
-0.0006342363,
-0.0181022342,
0.0268167742,
0.0265453663,
0.0273190252,
0.0024470726,
0.0077965292,
0.0233577006,
-0.0000448503,
-0.0313189924,
0.0689737946,
-0.001317192,
0.0239892583,
0.0036324603,
0.0177907236,
-0.0611115396,
-0.0519720912,
-0.1106339917,
0.0066047232,
0.0067622662,
0.0271489229,
0.0697006807,
-0.0104391612,
-0.0311646555,
-0.0029350843,
-0.0292979535,
0.025954444,
0.0163908713,
0.0220396984,
0.0001177611,
-0.0379538126,
0.0178933963,
-0.0573762693,
-0.0458855852,
-0.0038845618,
-0.0066406894,
0.0547875799,
-0.0922017172,
0.0076725553,
0.0090897763,
-0.0456362665,
-0.0514825881,
-0.0136400405,
-0.0603730828,
0.0317777842,
-0.0159404911,
0.0340622813,
0.0596651994,
0.0361570008,
0.0318941846,
0.0244891662,
-0.0389826633,
-0.0224435087,
-0.0079776393,
-0.0235985443,
-0.0415404364,
-0.0281073991,
-0.0534895658,
-0.0447759777,
-0.0087316688,
0.0020270138,
-0.0022710599,
-0.0011883284,
-0.0062860386,
-0.0566031523,
0.0391891897,
-0.0278235134,
0.013976397,
-0.0211195722,
-0.0239157062,
0.0007698012,
-0.0269042011,
0.0318620466,
-0.0009745866,
0.017031204,
-0.0605989546,
-0.0218818914,
-0.0172649175,
0.0447730385,
-0.0509654693,
0.0012933476,
-0.0544137284,
-0.0563017353,
-0.033061333,
-0.0029173661,
0.0416195616,
-0.0622651428,
0.0276829172,
-0.0270562991,
-0.0137428865,
-0.0360670611,
0.0330271535,
-0.0001165553,
0.0107860016,
-0.034977112,
-0.0220639575,
0.0109253451,
-0.0076016863,
0.0065415609,
0.0120209828,
0.0180762317,
-0.0196611509,
-0.0416237228,
-0.0016143585,
-0.007921136,
0.020520784,
0.0304423869,
-0.0296333488,
-0.0147612151,
-0.032870844,
0.0744468048,
0.0514428876,
-0.0424951911,
-0.0306419972,
0.0222768821,
-0.0335044749,
0.0502960198,
-0.0107878596,
-0.054069601,
0.0043745218,
0.0427775607,
-0.0390754379,
0.0420091264,
0.108513318,
0.0134266522,
-0.0374015085,
-0.0394483656,
-0.0546094626,
0.0445091836,
-0.0091182739,
0.033148393,
-0.0970147923,
0.0191354156,
-0.0172084216,
-0.0105563095,
-0.0097351782,
0.0052528162,
-0.0010853426,
-0.0867729262,
0.0081532504,
0.0084284861,
-0.031216424,
0.0326070525,
-0.0320982933,
-0.0242758896,
0.0153152486,
0.0262002386,
-0.0095526064,
-0.0132123241,
0.0270608198,
0.0216473881,
-0.0575605519,
-0.0030897055,
0.0452894643,
0.0070241881,
0.0354125388,
-0.0086938338,
0.0371178836,
-0.015601147,
0.0060824258,
0.0691918209,
0.0197964739,
-0.0202771425,
0.0110757463,
0.0168769881,
-0.0042794412,
0.0295144916,
-0.0623774193,
-0.00304251,
-0.0135421818,
-0.0057040788,
0.0515448451,
0.0593380444,
0.001456528,
-0.0036369963,
-0.0146298967,
0.0396714211,
-0.0116876541,
0.0358255282,
-0.0045815147,
-0.036191076,
-0.0086097727,
-0.0344869308,
-0.0326587744,
0.0285229702,
-0.0530968346,
0.0268401951,
-0.0284300651,
-0.0685672909,
-0.0280164909,
-0.0541214198,
-0.0016799517,
0.0145906657,
0.0115865041,
0.0683479533,
0.0279582031,
0.0183138363,
0.0225352943,
0.0068534086,
-0.0173515454,
-0.0064932033,
-0.0737254769,
-0.0166488625,
0.0202662982,
-0.0442467891,
0.0384592861,
-0.0074699386,
-0.0355137773,
-0.0666875467,
-0.0092467852,
-0.0074749212,
0.0275966711,
-0.0139168873,
0.0205075592,
-0.0344424509,
0.0037635751,
0.0458151437,
0.0002734505,
0.0071968278,
-0.0169456117,
0.0057641123,
0.0225732457,
-0.0016106606,
0.0036618905,
-0.0015707604,
-0.0037465582,
0.0246158913,
0.0007721412,
-0.0079217497,
0.0269444026,
0.0609290898,
0.0081046866,
-0.0263973549,
0.0071727969,
-0.0308483131,
0.0105336932,
-0.0631461814,
-0.0038364776,
-0.0069518061,
-0.0673023388,
0.0405683294,
-0.0075719771,
0.0165063851,
0.0109164938,
-0.027002655,
0.008252183,
-0.0084160026,
0.0631373897,
-0.0538754202,
0.0166685991,
0.0190735869,
0.0108056823,
-0.0392307676,
-0.0372394733,
-0.0095310882,
0.0370519049,
-0.0188857764,
0.1055024043,
-0.027808914,
-0.0409340635,
0.1040708646,
0.0268348828,
-0.0340662971,
-0.065111801,
-0.0019502413,
0.0492024198,
0.0503732748,
0.0219087712,
0.0555141345,
-0.0597264841,
0.0176831912,
-0.0241014585,
0.0359547324,
-0.0008506668,
-0.0571725592,
0.0072316406,
-0.0079633351,
0.0208208971,
0.0076929876,
0.0443618968,
-0.028278714,
-0.0282987319,
0.0415303893,
-0.0316264704,
-0.008272009,
-0.0467609391,
0.0228066333,
0.0344698094,
-0.0010890645,
-0.0129032163,
-0.0492349789,
-0.0503080823,
-0.0308168549,
0.0030784924,
0.0082268156,
-0.0420853309,
0.0210804287,
0.0654539019,
0.0032233729,
0.0071684276,
-0.0704214498,
0.0351007544,
-0.0477352142,
0.0158331636,
0.0163542982,
-6.550902917e-33,
-0.0153026544,
-0.0264016837,
0.070563063,
-0.0029878858,
-0.0280514546,
-0.0216120966,
-0.0260700192,
0.048780147,
-0.0430273637,
-0.0278336704,
-0.0250498187,
0.030721793,
0.0146426708,
0.0202499013,
-0.0128291855,
0.001138842,
0.002922877,
0.0101754079,
0.013602552,
0.0198056996,
0.0119894985,
0.0004622608,
0.0618060492,
-0.0197175015,
0.0145050492,
-0.0373472348,
0.0245993454,
-0.0581566542,
0.0076604467,
0.0258966107,
-0.0178933963,
0.0688337535,
0.0190829616,
0.0000520368,
-0.0068547376,
0.0175689179,
-0.0449580066,
-0.0506471209,
0.0437177792,
0.0267166588,
0.0390694216,
-0.0310667958,
0.0066595459,
-0.0231390595,
-0.0232068188,
-0.0320649371,
0.0183152743,
-0.0104330173,
-0.0246268045,
0.0558619499,
-0.0765759051,
0.0044776839,
-0.0103752287,
0.0245925579,
-0.0479776002,
0.0438587293,
-0.0176414289,
-0.0101278862,
-0.0399114043,
0.0610397905,
0.0035501278,
0.0408806168,
0.0492431372,
-0.0099709975,
0.0163327642,
0.0300039928,
0.0375591516,
0.0332402959,
-0.0100665251,
-0.0151846809,
0.0533350334,
-0.0076447907,
0.0433428399,
0.0313760564,
-0.0161984041,
-0.0561421625,
-0.0869838223,
-0.0330423638,
0.0388845392,
-0.0526519977,
0.0095023215,
-0.0056926585,
-0.0251773093,
-0.0433078744,
-0.0006721189,
0.0274494607,
-0.0023202435,
-0.0863340348,
0.0062715481,
-0.0509613343,
-0.0169044845,
-0.050409276,
0.0481634177,
-0.0452841148,
-0.0260868073,
-0.0204567071,
-0.061129678,
0.061812371,
-0.0467322432,
0.0151787894,
-0.0603250377,
-0.0322091691,
-0.0194038451,
0.0161987916,
-0.0229836386,
0.0496560037,
-0.029546814,
-0.0004503526,
-0.0215387624,
-0.0095450999,
-0.0346673056,
-0.0107055055,
0.0504249893,
-0.0643048137,
0.024032088,
0.000458996,
0.0091620628,
0.0564024709,
0.0175422095,
-0.0088511957,
-0.0331480578,
-0.041301854,
-0.0368341319,
-0.0435254052,
-0.0098936697,
0.0448194668,
-0.0801096633,
0.0528594181,
-0.0024677524,
-0.064756006,
-0.0139877582,
-0.0275113098,
3.01e-7,
0.0118653784,
0.0218825247,
0.0084112799,
0.0194194634,
0.0144995358,
-0.0300228857,
0.0112892203,
0.018971337,
0.0689462796,
0.016155066,
0.000885211,
0.0226134248,
0.027243739,
0.0553885959,
-0.0875053182,
-0.0390397832,
-0.0820372105,
-0.0542257167,
-0.056985639,
0.0473430976,
0.0637922585,
0.0134832384,
0.0039506438,
0.0015864404,
-0.0606020279,
-0.0492326431,
0.0534728914,
-0.0153412661,
-0.0568205826,
0.0344642811,
-0.0062448569,
0.0125752743,
0.003741835,
0.031672556,
-0.0151000516,
-0.0462511703,
0.022218857,
0.0427950583,
0.0081014875,
0.0282875821,
0.0412932634,
-0.0325444452,
0.0134022795,
-0.0644014999,
0.0893560871,
-0.0158988014,
-0.0362909809,
0.0524513684,
-0.0194375068,
-0.0550922789,
0.0264002904,
-0.0342091247,
-0.019540539,
0.0318268985,
-0.0239932444,
-0.0007792342,
0.0160883591,
0.0177319534,
0.0057970164,
-0.0287543628,
-0.0054627792,
-0.1015503705,
-0.0316775888,
-0.0196610354,
-0.0018271728,
0.028182283,
0.0258142147,
2.254486585e-34,
0.0168262701,
-0.0104174605,
0.0423312597,
-0.0090119187,
0.0552218668,
0.0255963411,
0.048210375,
0.0125029795,
0.0239272937,
-0.0348982811,
-0.0270529184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08260v1 | Extending the Frontier of ChatGPT: Code Generation and Debugging | 2023-07-17T06:06:58 | 2023-07-17T06:06:58 | Fardin Ahsan Sakib, Saadat Hasan Khan, A. H. M. Rezaul Karim | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Large-scale language models (LLMs) have emerged as a groundbreaking
innovation in the realm of question-answering and conversational agents. These
models, leveraging different deep learning architectures such as Transformers,
are trained on vast corpora to predict sentences based on given queries. Among
these LLMs, ChatGPT, developed by OpenAI, has ushered in a new era by utilizing
artificial intelligence (AI) to tackle diverse problem domains, ranging from
composing essays and biographies to solving intricate mathematical integrals.
The versatile applications enabled by ChatGPT offer immense value to users.
However, assessing the performance of ChatGPT's output poses a challenge,
particularly in scenarios where queries lack clear objective criteria for
correctness. For instance, evaluating the quality of generated essays becomes
arduous and relies heavily on manual labor, in stark contrast to evaluating
solutions to well-defined, closed-ended questions such as mathematical
problems. This research paper delves into the efficacy of ChatGPT in solving
programming problems, examining both the correctness and the efficiency of its
solution in terms of time and memory complexity. The research reveals a
commendable overall success rate of 71.875\%, denoting the proportion of
problems for which ChatGPT was able to provide correct solutions that
successfully satisfied all the test cases present in Leetcode. It exhibits
strengths in structured problems and shows a linear correlation between its
success rate and problem acceptance rates. However, it struggles to improve
solutions based on feedback, pointing to potential shortcomings in debugging
tasks. These findings provide a compact yet insightful glimpse into ChatGPT's
capabilities and areas for improvement. | [
0.0354431756,
0.0431137383,
-0.0212331675,
0.0259404499,
-0.0383065082,
0.0059302431,
-0.0141002825,
-0.0219107307,
0.0211254377,
-0.046099104,
0.0037874919,
-0.0235485099,
-0.0234074574,
0.0555129647,
-0.0063350173,
-0.0265543703,
0.0123803765,
-0.031421978,
-0.0179037042,
0.0152227543,
0.0015477535,
0.0213516969,
-0.0274222568,
0.0859133452,
-0.0151199177,
-0.0463250391,
-0.0460268408,
-0.0278235208,
-0.024730891,
-0.0003331617,
0.0371096916,
0.032184761,
0.0055191731,
0.0576283447,
0.000002319,
-0.0489928573,
0.0072737387,
0.0102789011,
-0.0405359045,
0.0123286117,
0.0137007041,
0.0426257402,
-0.0006589085,
0.0524156615,
-0.066885978,
-0.0202473905,
0.041325219,
0.0110331466,
0.0883304626,
0.0725852773,
0.0033969311,
-0.0145553295,
0.0531549454,
0.0062920307,
0.0451440252,
-0.0706087723,
-0.010037329,
0.03778781,
0.0226696152,
0.0003184033,
-0.005579324,
0.0392805859,
0.0608958453,
-0.0332065858,
-0.0103442585,
0.0177561045,
-0.0531143434,
-0.0169808567,
-0.0044260724,
0.054602243,
-0.0272193439,
-0.012698967,
0.0077552083,
0.0028854322,
-0.0071897381,
-0.01459412,
-0.0332240388,
0.0380951203,
-0.026252415,
-0.0117645124,
-0.0026087195,
-0.0191617683,
0.0162836593,
0.0171243362,
-0.0267494451,
0.0417550765,
-0.0075854692,
-0.0270130467,
-0.0043686968,
0.0026248295,
-0.02828997,
-0.0766939223,
0.0239778794,
0.0844957083,
-0.0412903279,
0.0153318858,
-0.020630179,
-0.0308827646,
0.0070086643,
-0.0249972567,
-0.0019394006,
0.0487753302,
0.0031827481,
0.0065914807,
-0.0146543393,
0.0933461264,
-0.030196311,
0.0054498604,
-0.0394145921,
-0.0080143446,
-0.1024738848,
-0.0397295691,
-0.0464181975,
0.0688282028,
0.0216542073,
-0.0208525136,
-0.0351420864,
0.0484825335,
0.0166031439,
0.0319005325,
0.0123942737,
0.0166377071,
-0.0420320146,
-0.0017990763,
-0.0417762287,
0.0199134387,
-0.0324428938,
-0.0254613757,
0.0244938768,
-0.0856317952,
0.0092725735,
0.0290741902,
-0.0221851673,
-0.0174962375,
0.016038822,
0.0733318701,
-0.0130184917,
0.0011654758,
-0.028215969,
-0.0449724607,
-0.0070804562,
-0.0618736297,
0.0123383794,
-0.0915842578,
-0.0040392322,
0.0213018917,
-0.0404209085,
-0.0349339508,
0.0228810515,
0.035718631,
0.0208788719,
0.035876736,
0.0000739833,
0.0126158139,
0.0770021603,
0.0092457812,
-0.0104559697,
0.0503204986,
0.0767561048,
0.0395675451,
0.0072214734,
-0.020783579,
0.0747013688,
0.0230168961,
0.0058008311,
-0.0158988796,
0.0311340876,
0.0218415633,
0.0037998541,
0.040456146,
-0.0077563683,
0.07140176,
0.0005059668,
0.0301811304,
0.0244801026,
0.051431179,
0.0155681781,
0.0614675134,
0.0629362389,
0.0215298403,
0.0179575607,
-0.0063117091,
-0.0431457609,
0.0350317359,
-0.0039419956,
0.012105763,
-0.0046046483,
0.0161299147,
-0.0163392462,
-0.0699282587,
0.0021300488,
0.0054185623,
-0.0066794623,
0.012527572,
0.0463513136,
0.0007723718,
-0.0526722148,
0.0386446044,
-0.0093419021,
-0.0559434518,
-0.0102357781,
-0.0956429914,
0.0207206123,
0.0456501655,
0.0728619248,
-0.0304656196,
-0.0410240851,
-0.0071471422,
0.0076358006,
0.0112110088,
0.0690783411,
-0.0010605656,
-0.0325768776,
-0.0473694131,
0.0203904323,
-0.042683322,
-0.0094607994,
0.0092629893,
0.0526352003,
0.000069687,
0.0346002057,
0.0008999397,
-0.0433873609,
0.0333269313,
-0.0274369735,
-0.0271063838,
0.0180341583,
-0.0082229367,
0.006484502,
-0.0020943624,
-0.0189586394,
0.0426513217,
0.0028354069,
-0.0164891575,
-0.0591726974,
-0.0100403633,
-0.0492854193,
-0.0290629845,
0.0281692781,
-0.0641440749,
-0.0160257593,
0.0351930782,
-0.0302150007,
-0.0229028501,
0.0443317108,
-0.0710683465,
0.0018743395,
-0.0258137491,
-0.0132499784,
-0.0239404459,
-0.0295354351,
-0.0403742939,
0.0511640608,
0.040178284,
0.0061206841,
-0.0109396596,
0.0545988381,
0.0181392822,
-0.0393954366,
-0.0235048532,
0.0013517182,
-0.0178350341,
0.036278706,
0.0229051262,
0.0435611568,
-0.0321911797,
-0.0389314257,
-0.1192538217,
0.0436614491,
-0.006941196,
0.0244266093,
0.0130983749,
0.0025690617,
0.0037793699,
0.0060486048,
-0.0740917102,
0.0129586793,
0.0194944497,
-0.0114222365,
0.0573771335,
0.0156074641,
-0.0351124145,
-0.0557896271,
0.0039314986,
-0.052719932,
0.026689278,
0.0350553542,
-0.0095083378,
-0.021004701,
0.0805681422,
-0.0232434478,
0.017582288,
-0.0135137811,
-0.0580620393,
0.0325062312,
-0.0293717515,
0.0332479253,
0.0668689311,
0.004332575,
0.0336858518,
0.0186317358,
0.0009164268,
-0.0434022583,
0.0374009758,
0.0015574303,
-0.0581903532,
0.0124387667,
-0.0280938633,
0.0207773279,
0.0669779927,
0.0112149753,
-0.0175300147,
-0.0585596971,
0.0311755352,
-0.0124825062,
0.0200997945,
-0.0108167641,
-0.0008741532,
0.0033110469,
0.0422361419,
-0.0064291954,
-0.0579635985,
0.0620482042,
-0.013612723,
-0.0282648169,
-0.065726541,
-0.0286005773,
-0.0555511601,
0.08368361,
0.0038570585,
0.0143518662,
-0.023700282,
-0.0218145102,
-0.0562922917,
0.0149986576,
-0.0089898231,
-0.0451186039,
0.0326381959,
-0.0603123866,
-0.0028844289,
-0.0014211325,
-0.0369335376,
-0.0473052524,
-0.0156217339,
-0.0225124396,
0.0041313018,
0.0539639778,
-0.0035455213,
-0.0121515365,
-0.0030708031,
0.0125452727,
0.0288792755,
-0.0347116068,
-0.0366108567,
-0.0121344058,
-0.0069989501,
0.0395813137,
0.0081485175,
0.0132361483,
-0.0082406215,
0.0350785553,
0.0392947979,
0.0334762,
0.0459096543,
-0.0472407229,
-0.0219136961,
-0.0111376978,
-0.0308608804,
-0.0249586739,
0.047083199,
0.0309728198,
-0.0735828578,
-0.0497308895,
0.1055350453,
0.0579157025,
-0.0578187145,
-0.0130017512,
-0.0202441309,
0.0273260903,
0.0265212227,
0.0714907646,
-0.108797431,
-0.0416924171,
0.0117458068,
0.0165810939,
-0.028532818,
-0.0071377563,
-0.0258369688,
-0.1394919902,
0.021091152,
-0.0171332713,
-0.0190914664,
-0.0053289165,
-0.017782772,
-0.0480750315,
-0.0032403395,
-0.0077492241,
0.0215359107,
-0.0010591857,
0.0158634987,
0.035944216,
-0.0537854359,
-0.0007109695,
0.0516221412,
-0.0251359567,
0.035089884,
0.0900691971,
0.0218292736,
-0.0003878094,
0.006861012,
0.0285888445,
0.0239442755,
0.0184199922,
0.0128503824,
0.0503902249,
-0.0216783509,
-0.0203840714,
-0.0267851856,
0.0353288054,
-0.0720410347,
0.0148878982,
0.0641505495,
0.0637390018,
-0.015764527,
-0.0077026198,
-0.025485754,
0.0114652002,
-0.0145277949,
0.0586123727,
0.037801981,
-0.0547962002,
-0.0701566935,
-0.0428838059,
-0.0010112756,
-0.0785881355,
-0.0278516766,
0.0034908075,
0.0249928012,
0.0047490858,
-0.063036792,
-0.049118042,
0.0479210168,
0.0249345228,
0.0132184653,
-0.0619730093,
0.0255550835,
0.0358326063,
-0.0386159196,
0.0131392255,
-0.0078524901,
0.0196932591,
-0.0743856207,
0.0127207851,
0.0102895563,
-0.0398507789,
-0.0237337966,
0.0060935863,
-0.1279319525,
-0.043792896,
0.0007218816,
0.0496985987,
0.025486812,
-0.017498007,
-0.0192063786,
-0.0382823981,
-0.02913839,
0.0322865397,
-0.0423052199,
-0.0118093044,
0.0106240464,
0.0246514902,
0.0205445718,
0.0074129933,
-0.0533249155,
-0.0039304532,
-0.011439574,
0.0055483724,
-0.0038396423,
-0.0208969265,
0.0343803167,
0.0272396449,
-0.0085843075,
0.0307760537,
-0.0280993059,
-0.0053545102,
0.0223103277,
0.00607085,
-0.0260656495,
-0.0658401251,
-0.0052302424,
0.0191629175,
-0.0092786336,
0.038613189,
-0.0013645343,
-0.0283105932,
0.0155729232,
-0.0041478081,
0.0263668392,
0.0232651588,
0.0417226516,
0.0364397615,
-0.0118841743,
-0.0325736403,
0.0079365838,
-0.00383905,
0.0344653241,
-0.0076638167,
0.0760731623,
0.0070921634,
0.0232826825,
0.0290173981,
0.0213225707,
-0.0665161535,
-0.0865311176,
0.0091425562,
0.0454484932,
0.0435245745,
0.0399305709,
-0.0173332915,
-0.04148243,
0.0260200687,
-0.0131894192,
0.042603489,
0.0067009283,
-0.0197566431,
0.0127968676,
0.0189754032,
-0.0035508277,
-0.0499585569,
0.1000009626,
-0.0059473906,
0.0248189922,
0.0247936454,
-0.0093346192,
-0.0233472325,
-0.0171047077,
0.0191216227,
-0.0057673287,
0.008292282,
-0.0204079635,
-0.0152324121,
-0.0693915039,
-0.0191027429,
0.029853953,
0.0289107189,
-0.0070829852,
0.0418810435,
0.0894005373,
-0.0047117244,
-0.0153804207,
-0.0480217524,
0.0282440521,
-0.0530564822,
-0.0207242928,
-0.0375493579,
-5.86366741e-33,
-0.0293046869,
-0.0631683171,
0.0419912003,
0.0481402241,
-0.0275853332,
-0.0074730422,
-0.056331981,
0.0347745642,
-0.0142147299,
0.0034563271,
-0.0230308212,
0.0410145894,
-0.0040317676,
0.010904544,
0.023548441,
-0.0339187421,
0.0157995578,
-0.0067518181,
-0.0279628783,
0.0373608172,
0.0033711016,
0.0107482495,
-0.0059300927,
-0.0254627783,
-0.0018362389,
-0.0420993827,
0.0101141371,
0.018239269,
-0.0176182594,
0.070720084,
-0.0163190458,
0.0299975965,
0.0163183678,
-0.030499829,
-0.000906856,
0.0275159534,
0.0061603598,
-0.0348049961,
0.0030951547,
0.0192111861,
-0.0080074435,
-0.0510282256,
0.0393183529,
-0.0022561965,
-0.011650526,
-0.0102218445,
0.0416808464,
0.0172397569,
0.0145828547,
-0.0296521951,
-0.0521143749,
0.0096913297,
-0.0515932254,
-0.0567398258,
-0.0194582846,
0.0451310053,
-0.0202937052,
-0.0039916458,
0.0037471808,
0.0071615279,
0.0197350215,
0.0244536791,
0.0639564767,
-0.0149548166,
-0.0143707637,
0.0295050126,
0.0310701225,
0.0133856218,
-0.0470912196,
-0.0245620906,
0.034629561,
0.0219210107,
0.0550380088,
0.0322762206,
0.0389035754,
0.0050910078,
-0.0572080687,
0.0259223413,
0.0291789956,
0.0135971317,
0.0269443486,
-0.0044367886,
-0.0454895273,
-0.0243106652,
-0.0359411091,
0.0345727839,
-0.0416815616,
-0.0395365283,
0.0572504774,
-0.0277521499,
0.0072408314,
-0.0324009694,
0.0243163574,
-0.0551063307,
0.0206675138,
-0.0081382254,
-0.0399675742,
0.0540209748,
-0.0317662694,
0.0399534553,
-0.0332399867,
-0.0079408651,
0.0062123816,
0.0308484156,
0.0471963249,
0.0343168415,
0.0093982285,
0.0158421174,
-0.0316385441,
-0.0177141242,
-0.0525793396,
0.0214299895,
0.0114777209,
0.0559291095,
-0.006937624,
0.0140436245,
-0.0156394355,
0.0380277783,
-0.0166033469,
-0.0053088497,
-0.073475346,
-0.0230777692,
0.0186238866,
-0.0140324365,
-0.0489639156,
-0.0113671068,
-0.0501421764,
0.0333415903,
-0.0049170111,
-0.0658740923,
-0.0231737345,
0.0242581721,
2.948e-7,
0.0391893908,
0.0622543208,
0.0216781646,
0.0512342788,
0.0048416085,
0.0194388889,
0.0049313409,
-0.0096054366,
0.0282764025,
0.0202055983,
-0.0015303961,
0.0347386189,
0.0423866361,
0.0397643186,
-0.079010129,
-0.0306647439,
-0.0574495755,
-0.0161637459,
-0.0560867637,
0.0311192013,
0.0841178074,
0.0754757077,
-0.0064023603,
-0.0026912198,
0.0216428116,
-0.0336154737,
0.0418794751,
0.0133367293,
-0.0156865939,
0.0568188243,
-0.0130791692,
0.0400707237,
-0.0095915943,
0.0144395279,
0.0007694697,
-0.0215884857,
0.0190675873,
0.0552339181,
0.0077437209,
-0.0003309421,
0.0176604427,
-0.0160128232,
0.0107990196,
-0.0743689761,
0.0558555983,
-0.0567225032,
-0.0191053096,
-0.0160273388,
0.0269902833,
-0.0397095606,
0.0023023058,
-0.0180007052,
0.0238356814,
0.0082380595,
0.0015193748,
-0.0274431407,
0.00584178,
-0.0473275632,
-0.0075613447,
-0.0030424593,
-0.0350314341,
-0.0411421768,
-0.0684266686,
-0.0117745521,
0.0490282625,
-0.0257586166,
0.0138691282,
2.933507223e-34,
0.0205882825,
-0.0138668222,
0.0198345147,
0.0146240387,
0.0737220123,
0.0246411916,
0.0264379214,
0.0116118994,
0.0077930526,
-0.0534756333,
-0.0409375168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08247v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08247v1 | PAT: Parallel Attention Transformer for Visual Question Answering in Vietnamese | 2023-07-17T05:05:15 | 2023-07-17T05:05:15 | Nghia Hieu Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present in this paper a novel scheme for multimodal learning named the
Parallel Attention mechanism. In addition, to take into account the advantages
of grammar and context in Vietnamese, we propose the Hierarchical Linguistic
Features Extractor instead of using an LSTM network to extract linguistic
features. Based on these two novel modules, we introduce the Parallel Attention
Transformer (PAT), achieving the best accuracy compared to all baselines on the
benchmark ViVQA dataset and other SOTA methods including SAAA and MCAN. | [
0.0302090701,
0.0458864681,
-0.0071910773,
0.0655265227,
-0.0180744063,
0.0062888437,
0.0203772318,
-0.0021346558,
-0.022386346,
-0.0570040941,
-0.056974493,
-0.0681113377,
0.0274506472,
0.0101185916,
0.0312416051,
-0.0677440092,
0.0385620818,
-0.0069968253,
0.0053303312,
-0.0073373448,
0.0251546372,
-0.000782004,
0.0091744671,
0.0087143499,
-0.0031495213,
-0.0414211303,
-0.0145547166,
0.0140816085,
0.0320501253,
-0.0328950733,
-0.0034605609,
0.0064929239,
0.0003834856,
-0.0250081439,
0.0000020224,
0.0145831089,
0.0052219941,
-0.0146817314,
0.0545720421,
0.0118769128,
0.0311698597,
-0.0349648334,
0.0227960367,
0.0305184033,
-0.0419352949,
-0.0387011282,
0.0363845043,
0.0298508238,
0.0763025805,
0.0391460769,
-0.0199244637,
-0.0138732521,
0.0266944319,
-0.0411418118,
-0.0149114346,
-0.0280354954,
-0.0104844682,
-0.0002942338,
0.0158220343,
-0.0180921424,
-0.0663719103,
0.0784105062,
0.0595017634,
0.029830182,
-0.0053553404,
0.0273037069,
0.0024061461,
-0.0014770647,
-0.0249917582,
0.0966427922,
-0.0372931585,
0.0288402829,
-0.0360529311,
0.0251134355,
0.0040545911,
0.0017446253,
-0.0543310754,
0.0650385842,
-0.0172447823,
0.009649205,
0.020870544,
-0.0016094669,
-0.0201114994,
-0.0244493652,
0.0103839478,
-0.0432281457,
-0.0052864975,
-0.0234849341,
-0.021096997,
-0.0087116631,
-0.0840017125,
-0.0008588494,
-0.0101405233,
0.0510711297,
-0.0207159072,
0.0024273063,
0.0080478592,
-0.0200030301,
-0.0048704082,
-0.101398088,
0.0530153923,
0.0213678274,
-0.0969020948,
0.0303289555,
-0.0151204839,
0.0701035187,
-0.0590005629,
0.0223466344,
-0.0395429395,
-0.0326081552,
-0.0272638388,
-0.0077159819,
-0.0705381632,
0.0366704464,
-0.0400610752,
-0.070186317,
-0.0048149545,
0.0179870985,
-0.0115701761,
-0.0398250371,
0.0427410416,
0.0400554202,
-0.0413035266,
0.004390589,
-0.0074820705,
0.0803807601,
-0.036218971,
0.0316021219,
-0.0266137887,
-0.0440733396,
-0.0106430743,
0.0533030368,
0.0166157223,
-0.035134282,
-0.0015954914,
0.0695359632,
-0.0661816075,
-0.0042461809,
-0.0342633426,
0.0188993309,
0.0005417746,
-0.0359043479,
0.0715782493,
-0.0414669253,
0.0284693744,
-0.0116226124,
0.0135795623,
0.0267123822,
-0.0110915825,
0.0245604198,
0.0053572082,
0.0665318891,
-0.0011643901,
-0.0293904711,
0.0450134836,
0.0144286426,
-0.0003179542,
0.05102323,
0.0186333843,
0.04856034,
0.0243596993,
-0.0478398614,
0.0126071284,
0.0254438929,
-0.0161053557,
-0.0240852609,
-0.0273081157,
0.0372110829,
0.0023288098,
0.0009269728,
0.0534847826,
0.062494345,
-0.012543832,
-0.0476753339,
0.0336930193,
0.0084503563,
0.0172410235,
0.0130901383,
0.0388432629,
-0.0014748533,
0.0133996634,
0.025710037,
-0.0499087535,
0.1018473506,
-0.0070240954,
0.0214357097,
-0.0030243639,
0.0368799493,
-0.0454129726,
-0.0314857364,
0.0137002999,
-0.0058464902,
-0.0079163499,
0.0453456417,
0.0238204673,
0.0281067435,
-0.0234998707,
0.0287969504,
0.0159949511,
0.0307512917,
-0.0253526978,
-0.0374922901,
0.0151302116,
0.0213185586,
0.0027373291,
-0.0072520939,
-0.000029784,
-0.0144269001,
0.0382662639,
0.0500448011,
-0.0190172065,
0.0216286853,
0.0055017457,
-0.0477798022,
-0.0078980755,
-0.0335274115,
-0.0223554969,
0.0373329706,
0.0140812192,
0.0311138015,
-0.003691393,
0.0218407568,
0.0408679135,
0.0262439605,
0.0681425333,
0.0112367999,
0.0001365805,
0.0316945128,
0.043441385,
-0.0076612048,
0.0074500702,
-0.0112415161,
0.0200300552,
-0.0656015053,
0.0392037965,
-0.0135007482,
-0.0127676297,
-0.0910955966,
0.0216357037,
-0.0729442164,
-0.0004783421,
0.0633944273,
-0.023093136,
-0.014569385,
0.0389258116,
-0.0526718087,
0.0052229045,
-0.0587297976,
-0.0139174769,
0.0569808409,
0.0814298615,
-0.0091115888,
0.0561531223,
-0.0395704471,
0.0037741773,
0.0174822435,
0.0316694528,
0.0185089167,
-0.0316128545,
-0.025446102,
0.0529341362,
0.0019055711,
0.0116146915,
-0.027541304,
0.0297281612,
-0.0185766779,
-0.0402628258,
-0.1061171368,
0.0213613193,
-0.0327928513,
0.0025755877,
0.0177539885,
0.0082311807,
-0.0042388258,
-0.0706803501,
-0.0570709407,
0.0426109619,
-0.0014518988,
0.0052123046,
0.0275849197,
0.0093678934,
-0.0031424293,
-0.044822596,
-0.0304849744,
0.0442229286,
0.075602293,
-0.0316237845,
-0.0352640301,
0.0039107404,
-0.0543566309,
-0.0282750931,
0.0156916995,
0.0076722135,
-0.0690179691,
-0.0033541434,
-0.0378098451,
-0.0185556691,
0.0870368183,
0.038815774,
0.0280890502,
-0.0155583117,
-0.0232641529,
-0.0069771437,
0.0304247811,
0.0082056383,
-0.0184989888,
0.0146797393,
0.0051699048,
-0.0219546258,
0.0582404882,
0.0049614743,
0.0161392055,
-0.0368588679,
-0.0415872373,
0.0442825668,
0.0241810847,
-0.0157627016,
0.0595204905,
-0.0133446576,
-0.0315572172,
-0.0499606058,
-0.0456345491,
0.0488650426,
-0.0096458178,
-0.0436775833,
-0.0343271419,
-0.0000745861,
-0.0537107475,
0.0814379007,
0.0304414183,
0.0060973307,
-0.0612679087,
-0.0432546884,
-0.0327699073,
0.0273722541,
-0.010266399,
-0.0090948651,
0.06082993,
-0.0072596339,
0.0062757647,
-0.0358488709,
-0.018277755,
-0.0348544829,
-0.0412273705,
-0.0392688103,
0.0026393954,
-0.0413777418,
0.0163221024,
-0.001561289,
0.0289190244,
0.0192243531,
0.016608607,
-0.0011816797,
0.0223300457,
-0.0131566003,
0.0969109461,
0.0746792331,
0.0445646718,
-0.0344123021,
-0.0230546147,
0.048095718,
0.0499771573,
0.006774168,
-0.0213091243,
-0.0316916741,
0.0345361494,
0.0082407026,
0.0287028383,
-0.0272916611,
0.0120242899,
-0.0150159914,
-0.0760385171,
0.0215232447,
0.0649141967,
0.0089861825,
-0.0159164146,
-0.010109432,
0.018152019,
0.010127617,
0.0269871615,
0.0357317254,
-0.0905955583,
-0.0570211448,
-0.0596313961,
-0.0136178313,
0.045660343,
0.0350320637,
-0.0302716997,
-0.0575818233,
0.0392861255,
-0.0162722804,
-0.0840433091,
-0.0081661483,
0.0343425311,
-0.0051447232,
0.0173313096,
0.0186976604,
0.0211578123,
-0.0148067297,
-0.0184219219,
0.0057028551,
0.0006110693,
0.0023158537,
0.0573454387,
-0.0393519439,
-0.0296604913,
0.0232366193,
-0.0013428262,
-0.0302483495,
-0.0754085854,
0.0214716159,
-0.0129903313,
0.0264662113,
0.0306562725,
0.0127903707,
-0.0276996288,
-0.0525604561,
-0.001738608,
0.0111373933,
-0.0429132991,
0.0069139842,
0.0221826937,
0.0722336322,
-0.0188920628,
-0.0291073453,
-0.0112019572,
0.0059545431,
-0.0255193748,
0.0195546877,
0.0209965799,
-0.0761458501,
-0.0469836295,
-0.007682513,
-0.0413823165,
-0.0325021744,
0.0064098621,
0.0433134176,
-0.0128067406,
-0.0326723717,
-0.0817541555,
-0.0415371992,
0.0194292404,
0.0551113561,
-0.0314544328,
-0.0186203923,
0.004433617,
0.0307651386,
-0.0594166815,
0.0567334555,
-0.0074973325,
0.008733728,
-0.0392206088,
-0.0017375611,
0.0261042919,
-0.0470677987,
0.0085787429,
0.0029858528,
-0.0544381253,
0.0015885829,
-0.0065075592,
0.0373086929,
-0.0014097802,
0.0306601468,
0.0145516712,
-0.0352100581,
-0.0208133385,
0.0208122768,
-0.0166320186,
0.0079654511,
-0.0111870617,
-0.0478334427,
-0.0123238051,
0.0137518914,
-0.0020584324,
0.0201265253,
-0.0000107806,
0.0163279008,
-0.0145234149,
-0.0126300817,
0.0133771002,
0.0227238946,
0.0494006649,
-0.0124739883,
0.0000770036,
-0.0343545638,
0.0281250495,
0.0383573957,
-0.0068485448,
-0.0660382509,
0.0041639721,
-0.0165964086,
-0.0138425305,
-0.0047720703,
-0.0169733129,
0.0386767946,
-0.0471616648,
0.0307915583,
0.0292434637,
0.0199678484,
0.0116128614,
-0.0307689961,
0.0222559739,
-0.0020147096,
-0.0346237235,
0.0327998325,
0.0429578945,
-0.0011731175,
0.1026558205,
0.0189531799,
-0.0177568104,
-0.0302150249,
0.0377693251,
-0.0276607461,
-0.01722854,
-0.0446617641,
0.0213383473,
0.0784215704,
0.012637076,
-0.0056526321,
0.0109128645,
-0.0118609015,
-0.0067934361,
0.0287631862,
-0.0138688823,
-0.044090949,
0.0611189082,
0.0054719439,
-0.017793553,
-0.0114738019,
0.0676863268,
-0.0469899476,
-0.0004033063,
0.0084686289,
0.0139689725,
-0.0559842773,
-0.020562591,
0.0241418947,
0.0410931669,
0.0015710696,
0.0234311279,
0.018310234,
-0.066539064,
0.0124471318,
0.0138293151,
-0.0155108338,
0.0114482706,
0.0250371024,
0.0209853929,
0.0581042692,
-0.0418990999,
-0.0501105189,
0.0027892271,
-0.0318578258,
0.0223739054,
0.0197099671,
-6.299895935e-33,
-0.0647375137,
-0.0143384868,
0.0229088161,
-0.0035368633,
-0.043831639,
0.0184508841,
-0.013978431,
0.0118741216,
-0.0367004275,
-0.003789694,
0.0093397768,
-0.011302568,
0.0049629249,
0.0648588911,
0.0248526782,
-0.0220157336,
-0.0260834415,
-0.0015220622,
0.0123353694,
-0.0137353158,
0.0053826589,
0.0204806868,
0.0645524338,
0.0039675762,
-0.0397750586,
0.0129465498,
-0.0214440003,
0.0030842756,
-0.031883169,
0.0856006965,
-0.0287169907,
0.0545262545,
0.0297520515,
-0.0181831811,
-0.0186004806,
0.0217923317,
-0.0751650482,
-0.0340940356,
0.0310352016,
0.0589578673,
-0.1018946841,
-0.0069878148,
0.0226900131,
-0.0050137504,
0.0683092549,
-0.0490249954,
0.0128703974,
-0.0366436318,
0.0147395628,
0.0361425206,
-0.0374767222,
-0.0025957923,
-0.0176390633,
-0.0008909594,
-0.0086884415,
0.0337435529,
-0.0161659271,
0.0002188822,
-0.0586593822,
-0.019302994,
-0.032380756,
0.0171958227,
0.0474156775,
0.0635906458,
0.0062439367,
0.0102082025,
0.0736822337,
-0.0648004934,
-0.0240055602,
0.028400179,
0.0009089072,
0.0628228039,
0.068290703,
0.0283410531,
0.0371582136,
0.0162544865,
-0.0594687127,
-0.0264163129,
-0.0333692096,
0.069094196,
-0.0104846656,
-0.0002876516,
0.0063183601,
-0.0058402321,
0.0121667059,
0.0364247896,
-0.0436382219,
-0.0419493578,
0.03645356,
0.0332977436,
0.0055281129,
0.0465105027,
0.0678612143,
-0.0653526336,
0.0530709364,
-0.0034405489,
-0.0294111185,
0.0676278248,
0.0032064894,
0.0406838432,
-0.0355320349,
0.0213376042,
0.0316347778,
-0.0467154868,
-0.0237822849,
0.0238040239,
0.0368701331,
-0.0044746916,
-0.0650173351,
-0.0132671203,
-0.0233938824,
0.0149752069,
-0.0305769015,
0.0530014299,
0.010924235,
-0.0210871603,
-0.0437211059,
0.0557126477,
-0.0399605185,
-0.0200675484,
-0.0447747819,
-0.0056579774,
0.0053670965,
0.0173369031,
-0.0298956595,
0.0655430853,
-0.0500538312,
-0.0056021656,
-0.0542552099,
-0.0595412813,
0.0019718115,
0.0710440278,
2.699e-7,
0.0561567061,
-0.0052929185,
0.0381125435,
0.0004780934,
0.0243104491,
0.0056330943,
-0.0190829262,
0.0222769398,
0.0118913744,
0.0015072258,
0.0241116285,
0.0350312255,
0.0555609912,
-0.0024367699,
-0.0445294306,
0.0027474961,
-0.0502381064,
-0.0111773899,
-0.0219798554,
-0.0163898859,
0.0730001777,
0.101339303,
-0.0538966544,
-0.003441303,
0.0038679475,
-0.0393649936,
0.0682224855,
0.0501126312,
-0.0192859098,
-0.0130536724,
0.002577936,
-0.0234856699,
-0.0503973328,
0.0252363794,
-0.0003690574,
-0.004296456,
0.0429647937,
0.0240877531,
-0.0072211102,
-0.0758364052,
-0.0093233781,
0.032142818,
-0.0257848725,
-0.0334715843,
0.0957005545,
-0.0149224838,
-0.0438691266,
-0.026105836,
-0.0153051401,
0.019957969,
0.0312450565,
-0.0239410456,
-0.0239540152,
0.0164456312,
0.0532540344,
-0.0653118044,
-0.0379526056,
-0.0667338893,
-0.0323055238,
0.0020668055,
-0.0595188513,
0.0059863012,
-0.041737549,
0.0206427202,
0.0432013683,
-0.0031070558,
-0.0365515091,
1.572718573e-34,
0.0249982625,
-0.015926186,
0.0194867738,
0.03429031,
0.013191795,
-0.0378728062,
-0.0427112393,
-0.0186583009,
0.013776483,
-0.0581004806,
-0.0197966248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08720v1 | ivrit.ai: A Comprehensive Dataset of Hebrew Speech for AI Research and Development | 2023-07-17T04:19:30 | 2023-07-17T04:19:30 | Yanir Marmor, Kinneret Misgav, Yair Lifshitz | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We introduce "ivrit.ai", a comprehensive Hebrew speech dataset, addressing
the distinct lack of extensive, high-quality resources for advancing Automated
Speech Recognition (ASR) technology in Hebrew. With over 3,300 speech hours and
a over a thousand diverse speakers, ivrit.ai offers a substantial compilation
of Hebrew speech across various contexts. It is delivered in three forms to
cater to varying research needs: raw unprocessed audio; data post-Voice
Activity Detection, and partially transcribed data. The dataset stands out for
its legal accessibility, permitting use at no cost, thereby serving as a
crucial resource for researchers, developers, and commercial entities. ivrit.ai
opens up numerous applications, offering vast potential to enhance AI
capabilities in Hebrew. Future efforts aim to expand ivrit.ai further, thereby
advancing Hebrew's standing in AI research and technology. | [
-0.0475058705,
0.0723859966,
-0.0029408592,
0.0332110673,
-0.0068718977,
0.0412188955,
0.037401367,
0.0059484979,
-0.0124593657,
0.0074272351,
-0.0392046198,
-0.0503134429,
0.0553406999,
-0.000475916,
0.0356333926,
-0.0168867614,
-0.008408457,
-0.0788242668,
0.0081830351,
0.0109538306,
0.0356964841,
0.0489896536,
-0.0570627786,
0.0053811357,
-0.000364552,
0.0002087624,
-0.0019405594,
0.0024623042,
0.0414904095,
0.0114457188,
-0.070935227,
-0.0192531124,
-0.000204144,
0.0155315679,
0.0000016993,
-0.0108211813,
-0.0081156474,
-0.0145515883,
-0.0759166926,
-0.0118945315,
0.0506619811,
-0.0363851823,
-0.0403170399,
0.0281767081,
-0.0630436242,
-0.0103715863,
0.0481291153,
-0.0268249083,
0.0121558532,
0.0411127321,
-0.0116226366,
0.0075084176,
0.0519916192,
0.0186783206,
-0.0433824994,
-0.0252224635,
-0.0032852199,
-0.0409311876,
-0.0498237312,
-0.0236590244,
-0.0058853636,
0.027857,
0.0386896916,
0.0080783255,
-0.0467606448,
-0.0019530462,
-0.0757382289,
-0.0494805984,
0.0037796116,
0.0070422767,
0.0315638781,
-0.042182453,
0.0311440937,
0.0047719898,
-0.0554206371,
-0.0283858329,
-0.0042920057,
0.0504605286,
-0.0391449481,
-0.0244123805,
-0.003949964,
0.0052842782,
0.0037588135,
-0.0196091887,
-0.0177979153,
-0.0405720882,
0.0308757741,
-0.0164601356,
0.029483404,
-0.0310125872,
0.01548436,
0.0206672959,
0.035340704,
-0.017425023,
0.0406019092,
-0.0345260799,
-0.0510513708,
-0.0518180057,
-0.0350407362,
0.0041013476,
0.0173151717,
0.043659687,
-0.0620844997,
-0.0126310913,
0.0136300884,
0.0145331305,
0.0642127991,
0.0022906784,
-0.0067911302,
0.0231824741,
0.0171475448,
0.0221684854,
-0.0428489037,
0.0022214982,
-0.0531124435,
-0.023434246,
-0.0460514426,
0.0047482299,
0.0457903929,
-0.0115854479,
-0.00679261,
-0.0274769999,
-0.0087378602,
-0.0260511879,
0.0600308105,
-0.031773854,
-0.0185198896,
0.0671262667,
-0.0260115284,
-0.1120240763,
-0.0127124032,
0.0411481857,
0.0452372208,
0.0033727172,
0.0162760187,
0.0497098006,
0.0299892146,
-0.0696706176,
-0.0372876823,
0.0241303518,
-0.0246724356,
-0.0223623626,
0.0009669319,
-0.0489162616,
0.0824340582,
-0.0145233441,
-0.0363479033,
-0.0278352704,
-0.0405024998,
-0.0105220443,
0.0570995919,
0.073022224,
-0.0018281642,
0.0115587562,
0.0287951492,
-0.0159104299,
0.0329292938,
0.0276146159,
0.0129846651,
-0.0392325968,
0.0064340075,
-0.0430600755,
0.0154623454,
0.0482666306,
-0.0056170551,
0.0384385251,
-0.0519456714,
-0.0055528255,
0.0152025186,
-0.0206503775,
0.0291874614,
0.0124156084,
-0.0454366542,
-0.0505687296,
0.0949968174,
0.0863858461,
-0.0466244258,
0.0176426768,
-0.039545469,
0.0392960757,
0.071297951,
-0.0428065434,
0.0070862547,
0.0408677794,
0.032757856,
-0.0243257675,
-0.0035698665,
0.032476332,
-0.042986542,
-0.0483074598,
-0.0405685119,
-0.0193031486,
-0.041865766,
0.0565725118,
0.0365986787,
0.0003719893,
-0.0245115291,
0.015780637,
0.0128869358,
-0.0436975397,
0.0194578804,
-0.0240444075,
0.0136844562,
0.0124955568,
0.0447163545,
-0.0447339825,
-0.0423824936,
-0.0451114736,
0.018278813,
0.0578739122,
-0.0567703694,
0.03046274,
0.053576041,
-0.0589320213,
0.023213204,
0.0540109575,
-0.014343854,
0.0459073335,
-0.0306820869,
0.0306945406,
0.0331633128,
0.0242977366,
0.0241025854,
-0.0009632839,
-0.0102555901,
-0.0107410885,
0.0168729145,
0.0039858408,
0.0889489427,
0.0379203707,
-0.013538844,
-0.0281401575,
0.0272216816,
-0.0101387817,
0.0290964488,
0.035236232,
0.0097834915,
0.0202204473,
0.0316467248,
-0.0314895213,
0.0013956437,
0.0298602227,
0.0396089517,
-0.0486106873,
0.0590225644,
-0.0490274206,
0.0356745198,
-0.0312575847,
0.0486301109,
0.0604554974,
0.0559943356,
0.0432215817,
-0.0098161586,
0.0435143374,
-0.0280090254,
0.0660594255,
-0.02337333,
-0.0011330586,
-0.0293622296,
-0.0232495535,
0.0239386465,
-0.0629270002,
0.0109865637,
0.0033065174,
-0.0562674887,
0.0272798147,
0.0147326877,
-0.0713179857,
-0.02167801,
-0.0064329179,
0.050575491,
-0.0172889605,
0.0194693897,
0.025985647,
-0.0308431238,
-0.0167308748,
-0.0294090323,
0.006016124,
0.000747826,
-0.0356234349,
-0.0460744239,
-0.0265999176,
-0.0596209206,
0.014186251,
-0.0098815663,
-0.0113594541,
0.0047415271,
-0.014997961,
0.0165843237,
-0.0435793735,
0.0210475866,
0.0308686737,
-0.029326804,
-0.0129989851,
0.019742528,
0.0073099271,
0.0175718199,
0.0285150688,
-0.0417594649,
-0.036043711,
-0.046968963,
-0.0155655164,
-0.0499480665,
0.0034749671,
0.0362283513,
0.030812569,
-0.0436078086,
0.0000650536,
-0.0294043645,
0.0108197425,
0.0547290482,
0.0420407206,
-0.010035689,
0.034164913,
-0.0169648323,
-0.0086623533,
0.0171797685,
-0.0103743356,
-0.0404417031,
0.0473575369,
-0.0190652627,
-0.0293919425,
0.0108252792,
-0.0573601872,
-0.0533816814,
-0.0015169135,
-0.0231227875,
-0.0120029207,
0.0344322361,
-0.0332851186,
-0.0094479937,
-0.0656346083,
-0.0350613371,
-0.0400682315,
0.0194123946,
-0.0027302564,
-0.0273887496,
0.0186669566,
-0.0225382578,
0.0061896653,
-0.031076083,
-0.0277669821,
0.0131312488,
0.0120706987,
-0.0307133608,
-0.0246183332,
0.0421563648,
0.0006882306,
0.0107460422,
-0.0021177256,
-0.0588154905,
0.0364788584,
0.0530218557,
0.017094532,
-0.0295240656,
0.025918344,
0.0095612109,
-0.0078699132,
-0.0106027601,
0.0274700914,
0.0371657461,
-0.0225588828,
0.0133172125,
0.0022693784,
-0.0636869222,
-0.0000123136,
0.0561447851,
0.0139225181,
0.0097929593,
-0.0024723338,
-0.002874525,
-0.008013403,
0.0336702839,
0.0626502633,
-0.0053297812,
-0.0551663898,
0.0001659905,
-0.0150612732,
-0.0231240653,
-0.0041490658,
0.00228188,
-0.0999765024,
-0.0049619293,
0.0608425029,
0.0371368155,
-0.0003756599,
0.038206771,
0.0360914841,
-0.0615026839,
0.0165457781,
0.0330224819,
0.0028169481,
-0.0495708548,
-0.0484306477,
-0.0318598785,
-0.0300056506,
0.0333283655,
0.0010012672,
-0.0172637179,
-0.026190374,
0.0284500252,
-0.0288684778,
-0.0120048914,
0.0439494699,
-0.0042708199,
0.0855476931,
0.0482781939,
0.0485032983,
-0.0548047312,
-0.0161500964,
-0.0120628309,
-0.0432461947,
-0.0506030731,
-0.0126108844,
-0.0084430072,
0.0394181125,
-0.0249353852,
0.0107637793,
0.0498161167,
-0.0036378971,
0.0083610499,
0.0368972048,
0.032838244,
-0.0420678891,
0.0507410541,
0.0519495532,
0.0222563781,
-0.0297422968,
0.0345639549,
0.0156288333,
0.0185753182,
-0.0019807124,
0.0119540403,
0.012258756,
-0.0343091078,
-0.0495302305,
-0.0040430543,
0.0716727376,
-0.047285106,
-0.0738331825,
-0.0287845265,
0.0033595376,
0.0265345313,
0.0412053801,
0.0009518436,
-0.0026043751,
0.0584952347,
-0.055408448,
-0.0142788785,
0.0182871036,
0.0643177405,
-0.026423784,
-0.0589147843,
-0.0053052926,
-0.1071349159,
0.0217557382,
0.0633208752,
-0.0537420399,
-0.0358312018,
0.0404436961,
-0.0029141337,
0.0173996519,
0.0818285495,
-0.0476132222,
-0.024590509,
0.0382658355,
-0.025156023,
-0.0522530563,
0.0070993025,
0.0840270743,
-0.0042290846,
-0.019763479,
0.0002498996,
0.0101639079,
0.0475350246,
0.0259967577,
-0.0430167913,
-0.04049927,
-0.0409784876,
-0.0197646134,
-0.0236877501,
0.0274126846,
0.0291914195,
0.0088673504,
-0.0295607056,
-0.0008765919,
-0.0195508935,
0.0831234306,
-0.0617077537,
0.0054723253,
0.0369380265,
0.0401863083,
-0.0364366882,
0.0391961858,
-0.0060028634,
-0.0873496011,
-0.0048561632,
0.109101072,
0.0199567173,
0.0185622647,
-0.0278073251,
0.0265374798,
0.0106686866,
0.0401239842,
-0.0098253349,
0.046869792,
-0.0039165393,
-0.0194586068,
-0.0493679866,
-0.0157315601,
0.0527511947,
0.0273537692,
-0.0121802315,
-0.0226313807,
-0.0228257794,
0.0353282876,
0.0032433998,
0.0241603702,
0.0742830783,
0.0119128162,
-0.0023423391,
-0.0187689085,
0.0260155424,
-0.0324473977,
0.0194769111,
-0.0394930132,
0.0137439203,
-0.0403188951,
-0.0129808234,
0.0382792652,
-0.0085897082,
0.0321908221,
0.009936681,
0.0078052431,
-0.0255436655,
-0.0619686469,
0.0121781761,
-0.0453486145,
-0.0333969556,
0.005839596,
-0.0090400632,
-0.0461857133,
-0.0146627249,
0.0156925227,
0.0138809346,
-0.0353461094,
0.0159044936,
0.0323964953,
-0.0507425927,
0.0167373773,
-0.0148903541,
-0.0328061804,
-0.0074492567,
-0.0375918709,
-0.004280603,
-5.081383633e-33,
-0.0009200593,
0.0418936014,
0.0033123218,
0.0087407436,
-0.0386241376,
0.0349030495,
-0.0339108035,
-0.0222963858,
-0.0104482407,
-0.0360187404,
-0.0195960458,
0.031702105,
0.0310158394,
-0.0053552827,
0.0592064746,
0.0029728352,
0.0707098395,
0.0095760562,
-0.0189140104,
-0.0059444816,
-0.0061745211,
0.0316665284,
0.0745561868,
0.017771598,
-0.0215708129,
-0.0009516598,
0.0034613211,
-0.022318583,
0.0264899731,
0.067829445,
0.0185405109,
0.0229457207,
-0.004515531,
-0.0310816467,
-0.0047218264,
0.0060506524,
-0.0707369447,
0.0269638784,
0.0083628511,
0.1092840061,
-0.0444092341,
-0.0037031982,
-0.005077105,
-0.0235270951,
-0.0772531256,
0.0017128283,
0.0248347055,
-0.0407929234,
-0.0120897302,
-0.034799885,
-0.0461126156,
0.0634680167,
-0.0429900065,
-0.0286563635,
0.1047147885,
0.0368382074,
-0.0244280528,
-0.0140618533,
-0.0745101348,
-0.0145532303,
-0.0319044292,
0.0501228943,
0.0068049268,
0.0171058085,
-0.0442155227,
-0.0089084078,
0.0798615143,
-0.0713655502,
0.0725471303,
0.0350833274,
0.0043291254,
0.0212549828,
0.0143996915,
0.0373563282,
0.0121387178,
-0.0353599079,
-0.0121262837,
-0.0345359519,
0.0485328175,
-0.0122973537,
0.0100245085,
-0.0014260594,
-0.0570848286,
0.0202530827,
0.0168387387,
-0.0597467273,
-0.01506285,
0.0229701865,
0.0501306318,
0.0196120366,
-0.0000593533,
0.0429764166,
0.0390164107,
-0.0223969892,
0.0737705156,
0.0330700651,
0.0011750358,
-0.0279311333,
-0.0260652881,
0.006564477,
-0.0200411007,
-0.0507591702,
0.0234083813,
0.0032294921,
0.0082166353,
-0.0242262278,
0.0352604613,
0.0287895519,
-0.0117647182,
-0.0315409414,
-0.0132522536,
0.0206879098,
-0.0075937207,
0.0296514276,
0.0246620309,
0.0021037806,
0.0201057643,
0.0394460969,
0.0171419438,
-0.0310780052,
0.0108204447,
0.040352229,
-0.0096951295,
-0.0178565085,
-0.0344065726,
0.006884573,
0.0176147036,
-0.045927532,
-0.0000687245,
-0.0206527058,
0.0169247594,
-0.0046550496,
2.43e-7,
-0.0344017483,
0.0071203392,
0.0468740799,
-0.0233781524,
0.009309425,
-0.0263990276,
0.0186265353,
-0.0212979726,
-0.00204366,
0.0617453642,
0.0307719,
0.0057799052,
0.141106531,
-0.0101891588,
-0.0810248852,
-0.0565399006,
-0.0685846135,
0.0097973449,
-0.0733861476,
0.0265750308,
0.0436963215,
0.1215016097,
-0.0187889878,
-0.0449950583,
-0.0024437134,
0.0084340144,
-0.0241208803,
0.0097211953,
0.0294702668,
-0.0064093121,
-0.0230091084,
-0.0337320603,
-0.0070721037,
-0.043215692,
-0.0586408675,
0.0428727269,
0.0258992333,
0.05245471,
-0.03572613,
-0.0338990577,
-0.0082905134,
0.044276692,
-0.0497894324,
0.0090612965,
0.0679282993,
0.0246156342,
-0.018011108,
0.0375161655,
-0.0680602193,
-0.0242462251,
-0.0149833094,
0.0242887959,
0.0248368029,
0.0071079787,
0.0491718613,
-0.0202660523,
-0.0144362468,
-0.0523779988,
0.0387898162,
0.0033126036,
-0.0323976725,
-0.0172001608,
0.0054647359,
-0.0096965525,
-0.0095367795,
0.0259747151,
-0.0085032377,
1.710783599e-34,
0.0398426093,
-0.0031226331,
0.0471657775,
-0.0120532252,
-0.0016625263,
-0.0235467106,
0.0185011271,
0.0354148783,
-0.0039585386,
-0.0102542052,
-0.0268267393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08217v1 | BASS: Block-wise Adaptation for Speech Summarization | 2023-07-17T03:31:36 | 2023-07-17T03:31:36 | Roshan Sharma, Kenneth Zheng, Siddhant Arora, Shinji Watanabe, Rita Singh, Bhiksha Raj | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | End-to-end speech summarization has been shown to improve performance over
cascade baselines. However, such models are difficult to train on very large
inputs (dozens of minutes or hours) owing to compute restrictions and are hence
trained with truncated model inputs. Truncation leads to poorer models, and a
solution to this problem rests in block-wise modeling, i.e., processing a
portion of the input frames at a time. In this paper, we develop a method that
allows one to train summarization models on very long sequences in an
incremental manner. Speech summarization is realized as a streaming process,
where hypothesis summaries are updated every block based on new acoustic
information. We devise and test strategies to pass semantic context across the
blocks. Experiments on the How2 dataset demonstrate that the proposed
block-wise training method improves by 3 points absolute on ROUGE-L over a
truncated input baseline. | [
-0.0133754667,
0.0132785309,
0.0391603969,
-0.0149161853,
0.0079274839,
-0.0191462301,
-0.0091660088,
-0.0401797593,
-0.0422308519,
-0.0108837532,
-0.0105990963,
-0.0535717532,
0.0173041262,
0.0458140261,
-0.0038799462,
-0.1590952575,
0.0238429457,
-0.0392279699,
-0.0335007235,
-0.0048355414,
0.0173473731,
0.0011300662,
-0.0160473287,
0.0159243979,
0.0284922384,
0.0163922179,
-0.0149717601,
-0.0062102578,
0.0401387326,
-0.0334033556,
-0.0331388451,
-0.0001413312,
0.0710246339,
-0.0311333425,
0.0000017872,
-0.0371524878,
-0.0483883545,
0.0105988979,
-0.0379174314,
0.0055904612,
0.0160007309,
-0.0235519763,
-0.0071990979,
0.031097142,
0.0122956634,
-0.0273356289,
-0.005679206,
0.0292957667,
0.0516325086,
0.0534243397,
0.0038911661,
-0.0911194533,
0.0162312929,
-0.0479262434,
-0.0283822604,
-0.0441179201,
-0.0081590135,
-0.0143006956,
0.0228290912,
-0.0390510187,
-0.0280554239,
0.0459489934,
0.0079888031,
0.0254240818,
0.0260950793,
0.019003991,
-0.0001046644,
0.017567303,
0.0352043174,
0.058222115,
0.0241026506,
0.0147259189,
0.0305208657,
0.0217276458,
0.0185895991,
-0.0683441162,
-0.0811281055,
0.0685363114,
0.016236579,
0.008821412,
-0.0474383608,
0.058784537,
-0.0045735831,
-0.0021900702,
-0.0404504985,
-0.0002358323,
-0.0369262174,
-0.0279151034,
-0.0481984727,
-0.0358616449,
-0.0039546816,
-0.0274341553,
-0.0029612549,
0.0097433832,
-0.0248278733,
0.0076702815,
-0.0304979458,
0.0154518681,
-0.0410912186,
0.0142034339,
-0.0003487712,
0.0078545874,
-0.0026268638,
0.0507183596,
-0.0032620411,
0.0211138465,
0.0599696785,
-0.0063195061,
-0.0690911263,
-0.0128439246,
-0.0628229603,
0.0318510942,
-0.0602564886,
0.0230824146,
-0.0401165336,
-0.0149574168,
-0.0591882877,
0.0247640517,
-0.022507282,
-0.0027558426,
-0.0400688089,
-0.0079045519,
-0.0183453951,
-0.0188475251,
0.0462256521,
0.0574274026,
-0.0253538843,
-0.0010986193,
0.0517296195,
-0.0208815057,
-0.0317276083,
0.0061195181,
0.0516537502,
0.0311879981,
0.0153762372,
0.0162593778,
-0.0093502589,
-0.0186960418,
-0.0473983921,
-0.020188421,
-0.0373604633,
-0.0286397636,
-0.0240646247,
-0.0359308384,
0.0067009651,
-0.0434543453,
-0.0061454913,
-0.0062649716,
-0.0230885241,
-0.0070392252,
0.009852591,
0.0334450155,
-0.0023441855,
0.0125735337,
0.0298750252,
0.0146752102,
-0.0166631136,
0.0548151806,
0.0640452877,
0.0161116868,
0.0414870642,
-0.0029899043,
-0.0571013018,
0.0585369281,
0.0231311899,
0.0129378317,
-0.0303519424,
-0.0337544717,
-0.0146307945,
0.003995867,
0.0776067376,
0.0269018542,
-0.0350107625,
0.0172525197,
0.0365118645,
0.023405673,
0.0370452963,
0.0009126008,
0.0258043557,
0.0145440446,
0.0153177939,
0.0818245858,
-0.0099660382,
0.0338600017,
-0.0195264444,
0.074128598,
0.0863227472,
0.0348850191,
-0.0378785618,
-0.0255320463,
0.0245395154,
0.0048974468,
-0.0009294028,
0.0210421998,
0.0293849632,
0.0335864015,
-0.0351333283,
0.0543880425,
0.0049900459,
-0.0928042755,
0.0299736019,
-0.0196485519,
-0.0000697248,
0.0342607833,
0.0242743902,
-0.0662668571,
0.0092016747,
-0.0391792729,
0.0462625697,
0.006474792,
-0.0023763722,
-0.0273090061,
0.063121438,
-0.0405110046,
-0.0199248437,
0.0228085462,
0.0013433164,
0.0090558166,
-0.0291712098,
-0.0179087874,
0.015496037,
0.0120890448,
-0.0009747028,
0.001386574,
-0.0078699253,
0.0042636497,
0.0251956824,
-0.0047830413,
0.055737637,
0.0538324043,
-0.0328022875,
-0.0061044414,
0.0279058795,
-0.0595924668,
0.0035911673,
0.0500147194,
-0.0713488087,
-0.0354373939,
0.0341405086,
0.0063469061,
0.0349780284,
0.0492222123,
-0.0108237853,
-0.0839603171,
0.0605190545,
-0.039043095,
0.020530967,
-0.0173892491,
0.023984205,
-0.0065303338,
0.0340370201,
0.00261413,
-0.0015222023,
0.0195837021,
-0.0149005093,
0.0125766359,
0.0139007503,
-0.0322530493,
-0.0588814132,
0.0202606004,
0.0411362164,
-0.0125339292,
0.0133524332,
0.0131420186,
-0.0440806895,
-0.0228030123,
0.032177534,
-0.0553338528,
0.0304366127,
-0.0134096136,
0.0254137497,
0.0161268599,
0.0468222909,
-0.003777442,
-0.0235064551,
-0.0124114258,
-0.0391812809,
0.0220437627,
-0.0240188185,
-0.0539169386,
0.0264513008,
-0.0053203809,
-0.0349316821,
-0.004736851,
0.0322271511,
0.0117500545,
-0.0477678105,
-0.0579410009,
-0.0015927384,
-0.0138305333,
0.0129532926,
0.0135123348,
-0.0058494397,
0.0143342819,
-0.0558237061,
0.0052848551,
0.0223815851,
0.0398887619,
0.0518410318,
-0.0206890963,
0.0205920972,
-0.0292994305,
0.0080492171,
0.004885315,
0.0235678907,
0.0532834381,
0.0055826474,
-0.0166488886,
0.0091334498,
0.0353967249,
0.0411891714,
0.0201245565,
-0.0025695243,
-0.0276626386,
-0.0271662772,
0.0103595713,
-0.0300125368,
-0.0495233871,
-0.0390758067,
-0.0040055639,
-0.0269900039,
-0.0223407038,
0.045431599,
-0.0391876958,
-0.039548777,
-0.0821390748,
-0.0698334575,
-0.0503890477,
0.0404860936,
-0.0004779641,
0.0256891791,
-0.0152802868,
-0.0214389861,
-0.0445571169,
-0.0027851528,
0.0467465743,
-0.0147986757,
0.0538135506,
-0.0212500785,
-0.0051468052,
-0.021181982,
0.0010528953,
-0.0094158892,
-0.0264722798,
-0.0425657406,
0.0417719968,
0.0115934713,
0.0070319851,
-0.0697139502,
0.0511348359,
0.0503447242,
0.0892820656,
-0.0166542437,
0.0355913676,
-0.0190682989,
0.0599734858,
0.0232393052,
0.0479847156,
0.0178494249,
-0.0156233925,
0.0800867081,
0.0128144985,
0.0925349072,
-0.0002911151,
-0.0157007407,
-0.0120748011,
-0.0261173379,
-0.0504436083,
0.0181264933,
0.0060734157,
0.0400117189,
-0.0507846661,
0.0218812115,
0.0882768258,
0.0211456828,
0.0147689302,
-0.0268610697,
0.0171884559,
0.0427835137,
-0.0015409365,
-0.0246331654,
-0.0181049779,
-0.0465802997,
0.0370620564,
0.054243654,
0.0239554495,
0.0062837568,
-0.0403563753,
-0.0739664063,
0.0130357007,
0.0247945692,
-0.0815048963,
0.0239133034,
-0.0518301539,
-0.006438978,
-0.0096244523,
0.0518745221,
0.0366579518,
-0.0446903966,
0.0002034008,
0.0414358713,
-0.112587668,
-0.0104621835,
-0.0341800451,
-0.045395229,
0.0306237005,
0.0693182573,
0.0131309023,
-0.0179771651,
0.0590381473,
0.0635655299,
-0.0456579886,
-0.0132799381,
0.0128450831,
0.0691146329,
0.0300532337,
0.0261644386,
0.0178693905,
0.0373085402,
0.0252093766,
0.0065104724,
0.0402636565,
0.0111765666,
0.0369274355,
0.0094199646,
-0.0268071909,
0.0936275572,
-0.0354601853,
0.0452023856,
0.0243962277,
-0.0060335179,
0.0237687528,
0.0114028286,
-0.0332802385,
-0.0464328453,
0.017320076,
0.0065457071,
-0.0426025428,
-0.0054771933,
-0.057328362,
-0.0013861719,
-0.0176044144,
0.0112447403,
-0.017359795,
0.0270872209,
-0.002337758,
0.040523421,
-0.0602895208,
0.0146548022,
0.0155184129,
0.0240706317,
-0.0283598676,
-0.0030643758,
0.0644010678,
-0.0446387678,
-0.021462556,
0.0560799763,
-0.0302113928,
-0.0386297032,
-0.0074781207,
0.0000869938,
0.0192633811,
0.0857509896,
0.0193322208,
-0.0083614206,
0.0341310538,
-0.0077959732,
0.0038252764,
0.0706122518,
0.0377848484,
0.0121039096,
-0.0361658037,
0.0367116556,
-0.088457875,
0.0568264052,
-0.0575899556,
-0.0054764845,
-0.0225690249,
0.005187769,
-0.0158042721,
0.0033520139,
-0.0065165181,
0.0304099694,
-0.0290551241,
-0.0115597052,
-0.0044163684,
-0.0415031277,
0.0181433912,
-0.0354809724,
0.0223717634,
-0.0355417989,
-0.0112355594,
-0.0071882312,
0.0667148605,
-0.0307647139,
-0.0572604612,
-0.020886898,
0.034557011,
-0.0184263792,
-0.0340859294,
-0.0595330894,
-0.0184085425,
0.0002246146,
-0.0414437987,
0.0321536362,
-0.0124302218,
-0.0067917146,
-0.0065660272,
0.0107013462,
0.0002011512,
-0.0231208317,
0.0345047675,
-0.0904527828,
0.0356132649,
-0.0365671813,
-0.007760461,
0.0126731191,
-0.0240571424,
0.0524364002,
0.0554368161,
0.0161348153,
-0.0400540419,
0.0017385324,
-0.0261430815,
-0.0316632278,
-0.0274979025,
0.0140514979,
0.0191999488,
0.0296577681,
0.0507092662,
-0.0048193005,
0.0174827315,
-0.0089367582,
0.0141871097,
-0.0311416406,
-0.0291057006,
-0.0543005653,
0.0674093589,
-0.0081846509,
-0.0097949235,
-0.022131836,
-0.0301044416,
0.0558553785,
-0.0200785808,
0.0295998678,
-0.0398102775,
0.0533815883,
-0.0421360768,
-0.0022946345,
-0.0079647638,
0.0143492576,
-0.0447597578,
-0.0255969241,
0.0196382143,
0.0435364731,
-5.335467472e-33,
-0.0474624299,
0.036157392,
-0.0132359201,
-0.0338663273,
-0.073815003,
0.0167135317,
-0.0445937477,
0.0182682723,
0.0199207421,
-0.0413003415,
-0.0298078489,
0.0313183516,
0.0267496388,
0.0450945906,
-0.0064916201,
-0.0039011638,
0.0940979272,
-0.0249872804,
-0.050682582,
0.0605664328,
0.0262645446,
0.0325073414,
0.0286014248,
-0.0398224629,
-0.034169279,
0.0058082454,
-0.040617194,
-0.0115869977,
0.0549657345,
0.0125246141,
0.0182084795,
0.0047611389,
0.0116628874,
-0.0617818646,
-0.0763106644,
0.0148189561,
-0.0879869834,
0.0234783888,
0.0204330701,
0.017083887,
-0.0397512466,
0.0022376159,
0.0581429526,
0.0029484939,
0.0233174842,
-0.0671468005,
0.0377827287,
-0.095817171,
-0.0374892056,
-0.0130884405,
0.0028206878,
0.0400606096,
-0.0446625501,
-0.0388774239,
0.0410833731,
0.0460929573,
-0.0117790848,
-0.0363525301,
-0.0172959361,
0.0452413522,
0.0433410667,
0.0470931642,
0.0415741056,
0.0197577998,
-0.0011709072,
0.0370223448,
0.0655132383,
-0.060161382,
-0.0093214288,
-0.0145412115,
0.0146008115,
0.0068483655,
0.028797606,
0.0297602955,
0.0678407028,
0.0350548439,
-0.0553191006,
0.0312024672,
0.0247518811,
0.0061972463,
0.0168906841,
0.0282191839,
-0.0010853341,
-0.0031451029,
-0.0603189655,
-0.0318509042,
-0.0084806317,
-0.0005550447,
0.0082504256,
0.0367061235,
0.0113368323,
-0.0287454184,
0.0432036333,
0.0095998794,
0.0423638858,
-0.0090420507,
-0.0246261787,
-0.0117304884,
0.0270503946,
-0.016516231,
-0.0016490351,
0.0216507912,
0.0566898771,
0.0137005178,
-0.0203353483,
-0.0279987603,
0.0230528396,
0.0352702886,
-0.0201824326,
0.0079474431,
0.0304230005,
0.0345574282,
-0.0406031236,
0.0542638153,
0.0149982302,
-0.0108824717,
0.0261154566,
0.0611624345,
-0.039287027,
-0.0082633756,
-0.0204074606,
0.0027257891,
0.0133886458,
0.0456417799,
-0.0408272482,
0.0124467909,
0.0261227451,
-0.0277620275,
0.0485615395,
-0.0581386499,
-0.0312779061,
0.0001171334,
2.454e-7,
-0.0141787166,
-0.0095393369,
0.0352561288,
-0.0467417836,
0.0102396421,
0.0018137343,
-0.0425230265,
-0.0105141671,
0.0246227551,
0.0386688113,
0.0332789831,
0.0006568837,
0.0868892893,
0.0161859561,
-0.1325231045,
-0.0650170818,
-0.0607436746,
-0.010974816,
-0.0118322093,
-0.0286798738,
0.0073410873,
0.0994624123,
-0.0187828019,
-0.0381684378,
0.0272413362,
-0.0382639393,
-0.012643056,
0.0264157429,
0.0065052509,
-0.0349948853,
-0.0045261094,
-0.0085556591,
-0.0417934395,
-0.0077623944,
-0.0282929204,
0.0372380018,
0.0328370742,
0.0260626208,
0.0224274062,
-0.0184840336,
0.0243384708,
0.0530787036,
-0.0098983059,
0.0276055746,
0.0691404641,
-0.024505537,
0.0071279714,
-0.0274825785,
-0.0624260865,
0.0106757088,
-0.064276211,
0.0317581072,
-0.0144351954,
0.0238458961,
-0.0047269333,
0.0143462326,
0.0004145345,
-0.0710511655,
-0.0264193043,
0.0098322025,
-0.0432646163,
-0.0407688655,
-0.0184996445,
0.0265134424,
0.005812584,
-0.0524264425,
-0.0049443874,
2.16432525e-34,
0.0567065589,
-0.0292448346,
-0.0324476548,
-0.0276963469,
-0.0119761443,
-0.0443422534,
0.0094550876,
-0.0337890945,
0.0189061631,
-0.064625591,
-0.0263254307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08189v1 | Mini-Giants: "Small" Language Models and Open Source Win-Win | 2023-07-17T01:35:56 | 2023-07-17T01:35:56 | Zhengping Zhou, Lezhi Li, Xinxi Chen, Andy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | ChatGPT is phenomenal. However, it is prohibitively expensive to train and
refine such giant models. Fortunately, small language models are flourishing
and becoming more and more competent. We call them "mini-giants". We argue that
open source community like Kaggle and mini-giants will win-win in many ways,
technically, ethically and socially. In this article, we present a brief yet
rich background, discuss how to attain small language models, present a
comparative study of small language models and a brief discussion of evaluation
methods, discuss the application scenarios where small language models are most
needed in the real world, and conclude with discussion and outlook. | [
0.0305213649,
0.0715222508,
-0.0191396344,
0.0372596495,
-0.0769683123,
-0.0069490084,
0.0218959525,
0.0411070846,
0.0273192078,
-0.0398256779,
-0.0103480024,
-0.0274990797,
0.0021629825,
0.0385832712,
0.0061891587,
-0.0663700625,
0.0456461236,
-0.033703614,
-0.0383962989,
-0.0206811018,
0.0426482819,
-0.000317149,
0.0169459097,
0.0719806552,
0.0164365862,
-0.0231321491,
-0.0196834281,
0.0037664615,
-0.0241784267,
0.02563137,
0.0016007033,
0.0343211628,
-0.0196071956,
0.0980160162,
0.0000018214,
-0.0519181974,
-0.0274795536,
0.0330610983,
0.0120325694,
0.0228960291,
0.0636510104,
-0.0014289181,
-0.0582645573,
0.0428324491,
-0.0177197624,
-0.0406872667,
0.0734489113,
0.0123874284,
0.0532988831,
0.0647941902,
0.0067447899,
-0.0228309818,
-0.0266685709,
-0.001113672,
-0.0309253223,
-0.0083873253,
0.0138909882,
0.0106017748,
0.0432963632,
0.0126101896,
-0.006865886,
0.0272796731,
0.0060888515,
-0.0277338251,
-0.0300966166,
0.024891695,
-0.0927862599,
-0.0239869393,
-0.0182769615,
0.0212789997,
-0.0134495888,
-0.0627691448,
0.0319093987,
0.0078816405,
-0.0285531357,
-0.0136766834,
-0.0584412552,
0.0384691916,
-0.0062026507,
0.0246712044,
0.0162335243,
-0.0155754732,
-0.0017760517,
0.0043756561,
0.0059084925,
0.0427399985,
0.0264938325,
-0.0086237714,
-0.0400434174,
0.0037952177,
-0.0234796666,
-0.0492719524,
0.0083921086,
-0.0002702917,
0.0350427143,
0.013407846,
-0.0454947352,
0.0164181869,
0.0484560691,
-0.063267149,
0.0051450911,
0.0356226303,
-0.0079143085,
0.0323278122,
0.0098772431,
0.0317380726,
0.0047888071,
0.0210472476,
-0.0213979259,
0.0192152951,
-0.0430179499,
0.018575754,
-0.0842854083,
0.04942232,
-0.0454005301,
0.0094779367,
-0.0218257103,
0.0265464187,
0.0185558088,
0.025175333,
0.0301898662,
-0.0070061889,
-0.0138885221,
-0.0110493898,
0.0204546321,
0.0379996672,
-0.0144904237,
-0.0263782553,
-0.011608257,
-0.0986015126,
0.0149273286,
0.0221294034,
-0.0160275381,
-0.0147613296,
-0.0080415392,
0.0721755475,
0.0321417227,
-0.005742657,
-0.0119082415,
-0.016560914,
-0.0197648834,
-0.070460856,
-0.0494972356,
-0.0834678262,
-0.0473976322,
0.0206466075,
0.0075491155,
-0.0499685258,
-0.0111608207,
-0.007692547,
-0.0293266121,
0.0318261273,
-0.0483610407,
-0.0005139792,
-0.006223897,
0.0204549916,
0.0152246086,
0.0765615553,
0.0317089446,
0.0020740861,
0.0632850379,
-0.0432840362,
-0.0058652675,
0.0629147664,
-0.0043457081,
0.0281576198,
-0.006422915,
0.016616039,
0.0289858561,
0.0147404065,
-0.0272319932,
0.1161196828,
-0.0044820202,
-0.013833507,
0.0877321884,
0.0762107149,
0.026679989,
0.0337630473,
0.0142795192,
0.0495536104,
0.0152290547,
-0.0208245646,
-0.0087956432,
-0.0156288296,
-0.0504550859,
0.012005493,
-0.0224563833,
0.0636361316,
-0.012195454,
-0.0158676356,
-0.0317926854,
-0.0136067709,
0.0104613137,
-0.0141740544,
0.0764569715,
-0.019254934,
-0.0134532182,
0.0340959541,
0.0556466728,
-0.0691790059,
-0.0097732814,
-0.0921717063,
0.0030762425,
0.0130827278,
0.0777414963,
-0.0008312199,
0.0092183752,
-0.0313998871,
-0.0180718619,
0.041709125,
0.0743194073,
-0.0045788526,
-0.0315344408,
-0.0405980013,
0.0093461815,
0.0427732468,
0.0127468007,
-0.0130233755,
0.011239633,
0.0333634168,
-0.0070615234,
-0.0114001334,
-0.0210602898,
0.0019908412,
0.000733496,
0.0069293501,
-0.0348583721,
0.0005542015,
0.0290628858,
0.0258057564,
-0.0155277187,
0.0049820621,
0.0305013917,
0.0171876401,
0.0049444921,
0.0210340098,
0.0137317125,
-0.0030983486,
0.0606577434,
-0.0043467944,
0.0312698483,
0.0313250571,
-0.0232985746,
-0.0254948437,
0.0472378768,
-0.0380149819,
0.0598522276,
-0.0307560991,
0.0208514649,
-0.0502160527,
-0.015819408,
-0.0322451964,
0.0020631596,
0.0102183092,
0.0364440419,
-0.0250946153,
-0.015016228,
0.070777379,
-0.0333941765,
-0.0809126049,
0.0485707484,
-0.0289045721,
0.0745174512,
0.0390348323,
0.0434145145,
-0.0144618209,
-0.0326727517,
-0.0956181809,
-0.0067068692,
-0.0220936798,
0.0316186808,
0.0199333224,
0.0439301692,
-0.005715942,
-0.0032203121,
-0.0183793679,
0.01125044,
0.0118714673,
0.0005813969,
0.0080165444,
-0.0011773048,
-0.0653101876,
-0.0372550637,
-0.0264989194,
0.0078970911,
0.0395666361,
-0.0003822223,
-0.0285775885,
-0.048225008,
0.0125227394,
-0.045997344,
0.0560039021,
0.0041937521,
-0.0881051272,
0.0278140232,
-0.01865419,
0.0231897738,
0.0330767594,
-0.0183787625,
0.0180654861,
0.0183884893,
-0.0110230315,
-0.0587695502,
-0.0104124043,
-0.0028878949,
-0.0777185038,
-0.0265404042,
-0.021440722,
-0.0394582748,
0.0935334712,
-0.0107981674,
-0.0243210215,
-0.0800641477,
0.0138550662,
-0.0546756163,
-0.00035752,
-0.0283238851,
0.0196457766,
-0.0259644445,
0.0140745556,
-0.0034143736,
-0.058729656,
0.0561348982,
-0.0408332348,
-0.0095914621,
-0.0463350341,
-0.0379222967,
-0.0571471564,
0.0910988376,
-0.002107875,
0.036635723,
0.0278064143,
-0.0144945458,
-0.0344101712,
0.0284670312,
0.0315153375,
-0.0477801487,
0.0378236733,
-0.0397519693,
0.04542749,
-0.0219825543,
-0.0551408194,
-0.0136263305,
-0.0320363902,
-0.0515769683,
-0.0048866505,
0.0417433158,
-0.0085030543,
-0.0169815123,
0.0711227134,
0.0091316029,
0.0369494073,
0.004674152,
0.0042117755,
-0.005007118,
-0.0003407022,
0.016434988,
-0.0083032334,
0.0057793334,
0.0034359461,
0.0063139149,
0.0620164238,
0.0694757104,
-0.0225774497,
-0.0212099068,
0.0037246183,
0.0553309731,
-0.0423472524,
-0.0496517234,
0.0075807953,
0.051437363,
-0.0463666879,
-0.0255285203,
0.0940487385,
0.0103938729,
-0.0226146802,
0.0162143316,
-0.0491137691,
0.0716526583,
0.012889728,
0.0239915922,
-0.1165947095,
-0.0220961254,
0.0008670475,
0.0297381543,
-0.0119164186,
-0.0091600334,
-0.0160358399,
-0.0989695564,
0.0369897671,
0.0425791293,
-0.0530202612,
0.0014520846,
-0.0204799958,
-0.0233961847,
-0.0380671769,
-0.0010223315,
0.0350904204,
-0.0428388789,
0.000391937,
0.0245179646,
-0.0417009145,
-0.0104382951,
0.0175357126,
-0.0477465354,
0.0995326266,
0.0460667275,
-0.007856423,
-0.0025809987,
-0.01584181,
0.0305768792,
0.0078955041,
-0.0253801644,
-0.0052648988,
-0.0072588832,
0.0248731505,
-0.0380029716,
-0.0098457215,
-0.0050421474,
-0.0141522978,
0.0063578803,
-0.0141820796,
0.0671341568,
0.0001516175,
-0.0383278579,
0.011903978,
-0.0081342952,
0.0092988899,
0.0675890371,
-0.0027503115,
-0.0251315106,
-0.0614557154,
-0.0451511629,
-0.0340792574,
0.0151451174,
-0.0656534359,
0.0297257062,
0.0211624317,
-0.0844078213,
-0.0334378444,
-0.0118627222,
0.0249781683,
0.0179513432,
0.0152597185,
0.0275358036,
0.0439388864,
0.0233534444,
-0.039639473,
0.0086892685,
-0.0547754243,
0.0118825128,
-0.1003873944,
-0.0017582513,
0.0411591902,
0.0015097297,
-0.0233256519,
0.00313249,
-0.101914756,
-0.0766462833,
0.0113195907,
0.0514978357,
0.0415576771,
-0.0103308354,
-0.0344614983,
-0.0702533573,
-0.0092063919,
0.0384789109,
-0.0463648699,
0.0232998002,
0.0572704114,
-0.0345362835,
0.0090649333,
0.0441960245,
-0.0348953344,
0.0059788902,
-0.0354452208,
0.0070318999,
-0.0291974097,
-0.0238557421,
0.0163739994,
0.0549241044,
-0.0101167373,
-0.0280699525,
0.0036985376,
-0.0080744075,
0.0059272153,
-0.0044478155,
0.0028402943,
-0.0586513206,
-0.0182715897,
0.0129317287,
-0.0024611393,
-0.0003050209,
-0.0060969335,
-0.0440525748,
0.0318577811,
-0.0209810678,
0.0388295352,
0.0089779887,
0.0117222499,
0.0671099499,
0.0069242851,
-0.013993144,
0.014355409,
-0.006787674,
0.031815879,
-0.030279126,
0.0274592005,
0.0137336366,
-0.0070243203,
0.0420146435,
0.0344434306,
-0.0094944248,
-0.0566530414,
-0.0167748239,
0.0603206865,
0.06349314,
0.0694323778,
0.0699376538,
-0.0296023004,
0.0073633799,
-0.0517109223,
0.0441737995,
0.0009967329,
-0.0629497916,
0.006841565,
0.000676702,
-0.0357933119,
0.0131182075,
0.1016380861,
0.0208236352,
0.0312888175,
0.019874813,
0.0019981107,
-0.0417182334,
-0.0158773847,
-0.0127279842,
0.0161853898,
-0.0286530703,
-0.0131866792,
-0.0950579494,
-0.0626500845,
-0.0777838975,
0.0551121123,
0.0213022958,
-0.0057921936,
0.0406488664,
0.0260018669,
0.0147218462,
0.0012744081,
-0.057096526,
-0.0055299676,
-0.0323027261,
-0.0309143718,
0.0372154228,
-6.065240079e-33,
-0.01176487,
0.0002021427,
0.031050235,
0.0164834838,
0.0040399567,
-0.0150008621,
-0.0257630683,
0.0235726163,
-0.0302230008,
-0.0126028638,
-0.005563451,
-0.0144538656,
0.0233325753,
-0.0081728902,
0.0037063933,
0.0136114061,
0.0320241861,
0.0029934444,
-0.0160567313,
0.0356112905,
0.0033402529,
-0.0128245503,
0.0595812052,
-0.0517389625,
0.0139978137,
-0.0369749554,
-0.0258827657,
0.0120616173,
-0.01207201,
0.0610553697,
-0.0059419,
0.0357063077,
-0.0037434348,
-0.0063053388,
-0.008722974,
-0.0096826926,
-0.0537012108,
0.0012395338,
0.0206082892,
0.0249290448,
-0.0057631368,
0.0106150554,
0.0159496106,
-0.0211011339,
-0.0340819396,
0.0337087288,
-0.0084416214,
0.0110753374,
-0.0301807225,
0.0475114845,
-0.0208781213,
0.035324011,
-0.0068767252,
0.0039703189,
0.027061034,
-0.0226358157,
-0.0122815212,
-0.0269006751,
0.0097615011,
0.0377159938,
0.0264619123,
0.0250167064,
0.0772584081,
-0.0341610201,
-0.0037080508,
0.0394989215,
0.0093551753,
0.0010283194,
0.0003052347,
-0.0341286287,
0.0311732087,
0.0464178063,
0.0576075539,
0.0297949929,
-0.0157508049,
-0.0243489388,
-0.0406570062,
-0.0074484623,
0.0816378668,
0.0174283832,
-0.0215968583,
0.0170297436,
-0.074360773,
-0.027061237,
-0.0144901229,
-0.0446595438,
-0.0191076733,
-0.0538027398,
0.0205507968,
-0.0081182085,
-0.0192093756,
0.0112942411,
0.0408416055,
-0.076267004,
-0.0186252352,
-0.01133266,
-0.0137481503,
0.0470766574,
-0.0162675772,
0.0472859181,
-0.0508026928,
-0.0250789486,
-0.0173853617,
-0.0035919037,
0.0131651787,
0.0131969843,
-0.0050848802,
0.0220824014,
-0.0586442761,
0.0367713384,
-0.0409501381,
0.0538956709,
-0.0095600188,
-0.0228886735,
0.0239712037,
-0.0260731503,
0.0259068683,
0.0293349028,
0.0369794257,
-0.025001036,
-0.0333186612,
-0.0027608888,
0.0087894807,
-0.0145764221,
-0.0237992909,
0.0094967075,
-0.0401472859,
0.0660810396,
0.0596001893,
-0.0025715085,
-0.0183234382,
-0.0088398298,
2.65e-7,
0.0225684848,
0.0453813709,
0.0407427959,
0.00600731,
0.0057921153,
0.0483512171,
-0.0186379757,
0.0515309349,
-0.0317386575,
0.0215124916,
-0.0211225972,
-0.0133705148,
0.0657479987,
0.0162897836,
-0.0927358717,
-0.0039685946,
-0.0757968351,
-0.0022697244,
-0.0497966297,
0.00907584,
0.0184986219,
0.0760613531,
0.0421479084,
0.003969973,
-0.0259426367,
-0.0521412715,
0.0160066113,
-0.0274422094,
-0.0118918801,
0.0441953279,
0.0281969011,
0.0538123846,
0.0064991587,
-0.0281030461,
0.0042302329,
-0.0078787077,
-0.0094133969,
0.0740486607,
-0.0138357971,
0.0313547365,
0.0193429738,
-0.0771021321,
-0.0259619989,
-0.07669954,
0.0477981865,
-0.0013029394,
-0.0127111087,
-0.0098925317,
0.0160324965,
-0.0424263664,
-0.015048747,
-0.019408796,
-0.0384938791,
0.0114533631,
0.0196830872,
-0.0387632325,
-0.0129267164,
-0.0416403376,
-0.0174336471,
0.0038005421,
0.0023149487,
-0.0653985962,
-0.0044768518,
0.0264096092,
0.0082701268,
-0.0219656695,
0.0205866508,
2.36505216e-34,
0.0384347737,
-0.0294719711,
0.0013268387,
0.0253188778,
0.0194760785,
-0.0063548828,
0.0322365649,
-0.0134287849,
-0.0029494066,
-0.0294699278,
-0.0273017604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.13702v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.13702v1 | Measuring Faithfulness in Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2023-07-17T01:08:39 | 2023-07-17T01:08:39 | Tamera Lanham, Anna Chen, Ansh Radhakrishnan, Benoit Steiner, Carson Denison, Danny Hernandez, Dustin Li, Esin Durmus, Evan Hubinger, Jackson Kernion, Kamilė Lukošiūtė, Karina Nguyen, Newton Cheng, Nicholas Joseph, Nicholas Schiefer, Oliver Rausch, Robin Larson, Sam McCandlish, Sandipan Kundu, Saurav Kadavath, Shannon Yang, Thomas Henighan, Timothy Maxwell, Timothy Telleen-Lawton, Tristan Hume, Zac Hatfield-Dodds, Jared Kaplan, Jan Brauner, Samuel R. Bowman, Ethan Perez | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) perform better when they produce step-by-step,
"Chain-of-Thought" (CoT) reasoning before answering a question, but it is
unclear if the stated reasoning is a faithful explanation of the model's actual
reasoning (i.e., its process for answering the question). We investigate
hypotheses for how CoT reasoning may be unfaithful, by examining how the model
predictions change when we intervene on the CoT (e.g., by adding mistakes or
paraphrasing it). Models show large variation across tasks in how strongly they
condition on the CoT when predicting their answer, sometimes relying heavily on
the CoT and other times primarily ignoring it. CoT's performance boost does not
seem to come from CoT's added test-time compute alone or from information
encoded via the particular phrasing of the CoT. As models become larger and
more capable, they produce less faithful reasoning on most tasks we study.
Overall, our results suggest that CoT can be faithful if the circumstances such
as the model size and task are carefully chosen. | [
0.0525932238,
0.042739749,
-0.0229382254,
0.0117318854,
-0.0681462064,
0.0351562127,
0.007527227,
-0.0036147435,
0.0058825691,
-0.0537932143,
-0.0105708241,
-0.0314029381,
0.0252525117,
-0.0027815956,
0.0261080544,
-0.0475525409,
0.0434274413,
-0.0708631575,
-0.002501498,
-0.0248107947,
-0.0154427784,
-0.0035581386,
-0.0239964947,
0.0259744264,
0.0165584628,
-0.0280847475,
-0.0344753675,
-0.0268761404,
0.0096851885,
-0.002982243,
-0.0076627368,
0.0419202559,
0.0129796201,
0.0322190225,
0.0000019682,
-0.0758018792,
0.0140325921,
-0.0082864547,
-0.0454275906,
0.0339961238,
-0.0566567406,
0.0190725513,
0.0285780262,
0.043940939,
-0.0163078289,
0.0287495553,
0.0094968742,
0.0375721641,
0.0164978355,
0.0455423594,
0.0185057987,
0.0012141109,
0.0031654732,
-0.0082525332,
0.0173519365,
-0.0554852858,
0.0051098904,
0.0413606018,
-0.0000043121,
0.0202576518,
-0.0231933706,
0.019281894,
0.0165678561,
0.0158975534,
-0.0236057751,
0.044886671,
-0.0010425479,
-0.0291445199,
-0.0023919328,
0.0166870691,
-0.0076256599,
-0.0558836721,
0.0009982953,
-0.0119232796,
-0.0142301656,
0.0303762686,
-0.0396342389,
0.0533610992,
-0.029532304,
-0.0085168928,
0.0148907611,
-0.0156942438,
0.0317247994,
-0.0000167092,
-0.0543411449,
0.0918040723,
-0.019768035,
-0.0619535111,
0.0120674558,
0.0388189964,
-0.015285315,
-0.109648928,
-0.0120821651,
0.0284410771,
-0.0404729433,
0.0292713493,
-0.0062379353,
0.016647771,
0.0037687188,
-0.0156995002,
0.0368101522,
0.0561781675,
0.0030270007,
0.0299116634,
-0.0560749955,
0.0533880815,
-0.0390757099,
0.0236353688,
-0.0391152836,
-0.0183143392,
-0.0707882792,
-0.0391305909,
-0.0171090961,
0.0694707036,
0.0248753,
-0.013187781,
-0.0201269221,
0.0237386152,
-0.0084853107,
0.0086415457,
0.0140348962,
0.0194252525,
0.0190707389,
-0.0243838485,
-0.0851845592,
0.0335792378,
-0.0503133163,
0.0664540753,
0.0297250208,
-0.0275608245,
-0.0148063712,
-0.0264083054,
-0.0116530433,
-0.0165195577,
0.033590544,
0.0309945326,
-0.0267323796,
0.0065930532,
-0.0305359457,
-0.0588368066,
-0.0265916046,
-0.0808263943,
0.0122417631,
-0.0514866933,
0.0245244335,
0.0562585257,
-0.0041739349,
-0.0045938278,
-0.0076109925,
0.04467161,
-0.0701922402,
0.0637342036,
0.0418784842,
0.0316941254,
-0.0045458255,
0.0166477691,
-0.0536153689,
0.0168125946,
0.0402747132,
0.0202386603,
0.0004843215,
0.0014657842,
-0.0133512914,
0.0142447585,
0.0101781599,
-0.0263251476,
-0.0151391877,
0.0393048674,
-0.0120515861,
0.0423243232,
0.0422581509,
0.049994193,
-0.0295011178,
0.0299398322,
0.0661878362,
0.0568854995,
0.0128635094,
0.0213638432,
0.0522290505,
-0.0161375012,
0.0147627974,
0.0476991236,
-0.0873273686,
0.0376095213,
-0.0126739005,
0.013179224,
0.0183394738,
-0.0013593099,
-0.0310044643,
-0.0340343043,
-0.0206445288,
0.0322283842,
-0.0064460682,
0.0409914553,
0.0103718936,
-0.0004139252,
-0.0257257596,
0.076545082,
0.012820947,
-0.0123534193,
-0.0319659486,
-0.0679167956,
0.0316835977,
0.026319962,
0.0180097111,
0.017871784,
-0.0346458592,
0.0026030217,
0.030454196,
0.0037752194,
0.0493170507,
0.001639022,
-0.0172250662,
-0.0182858873,
-0.0186028983,
-0.0328776091,
0.0110080764,
-0.0009120716,
0.0045352769,
-0.0002515086,
0.0044040019,
-0.0124315824,
0.0130493073,
0.0198140182,
-0.0205645524,
0.0033024636,
-0.0230257306,
0.0194536932,
0.0134791257,
-0.018628696,
0.0006403179,
0.0360733531,
-0.0077471607,
-0.0067924303,
-0.036122445,
0.0111917211,
-0.0820039511,
-0.0110183246,
0.0148113361,
-0.0024109455,
-0.0351677164,
0.0189292412,
-0.0183246061,
-0.0400628671,
0.0028104577,
-0.027285954,
0.023198979,
-0.0148053057,
0.0521149039,
-0.0260632318,
-0.0135488808,
-0.0092041669,
0.0896542892,
-0.0218903515,
0.0289295632,
0.0161151495,
0.018356327,
0.0005217185,
0.0099184057,
0.0080976915,
0.0185282771,
0.0214603562,
-0.0154662328,
0.0121917492,
-0.0185606927,
-0.0686881989,
-0.0268074088,
-0.0881461427,
-0.0039641475,
-0.0102314642,
0.0258825496,
0.0300575085,
-0.0006354499,
0.004311868,
-0.0007790008,
-0.0390920714,
0.0146691762,
0.0156874657,
0.0355372354,
0.0242200028,
-0.0140018314,
0.0042952723,
-0.0183844008,
0.0064171171,
-0.0488842316,
0.0328655876,
-0.0222813636,
-0.015847398,
-0.0676490366,
0.0643251464,
-0.0731380582,
0.0175178722,
-0.0024000844,
-0.0152760055,
0.0412173718,
0.0266586449,
0.0371978655,
0.0920005515,
0.0039561521,
-0.0364336818,
0.0926001668,
0.0001409265,
-0.0480594561,
0.0303620994,
-0.0067407936,
-0.037483044,
-0.0132386712,
-0.0383899957,
-0.0282947551,
0.0886252373,
0.0254469048,
0.009076722,
-0.0478821918,
0.0067297663,
-0.0186452065,
-0.0262412969,
-0.0228459034,
-0.0467600673,
-0.0237292815,
0.0820705742,
-0.0095210206,
-0.0271738954,
0.0687825978,
-0.0195694733,
0.0174029786,
-0.0279060081,
0.0269449987,
-0.0124674542,
0.0780980885,
-0.0004562924,
0.0079701133,
0.0024653345,
0.0074087637,
-0.0842377618,
-0.0273853038,
0.0411659069,
-0.0311550107,
0.0625311062,
-0.0615327395,
-0.0030909737,
0.0000398781,
-0.0665166378,
-0.0546754263,
0.0061518303,
-0.0679771155,
0.008592153,
-0.020462459,
-0.0105555113,
-0.0091109509,
-0.0227617808,
0.0534121171,
0.0105408821,
-0.0046529681,
-0.0394310653,
-0.0074389251,
0.0188400038,
0.0546167754,
0.0159148201,
0.0557189323,
-0.0214271098,
0.0521218628,
0.0536044799,
0.0586858951,
0.0519582219,
-0.0281754062,
-0.0070865517,
-0.0148148946,
-0.0030985011,
-0.0668717474,
0.0380944535,
0.0433718227,
-0.0509685725,
-0.0283614211,
0.1125745475,
0.0439536385,
-0.0256470814,
0.014139493,
-0.0534911454,
0.0481191687,
0.0261987709,
0.005529514,
-0.0644444153,
-0.0314103551,
0.0548362024,
-0.0087955482,
-0.0445109867,
-0.0468318649,
-0.0142941568,
-0.1060011014,
0.0094565339,
-0.0236334261,
0.0142150009,
0.0014482969,
-0.0431748033,
0.022737382,
0.0431298614,
0.0222294349,
0.0383119881,
0.001770186,
0.0026725761,
0.0327916667,
-0.0351817161,
-0.0028786371,
0.0775737092,
-0.0198277216,
0.0297376364,
0.0334246047,
0.0111307697,
0.0228834655,
-0.0419390462,
0.0632243976,
-0.0162382517,
0.0268874709,
-0.0063549886,
-0.0030987135,
0.0240131356,
0.0078725927,
-0.0325685069,
0.0017377996,
0.0072387564,
0.0074141882,
0.034754023,
0.0881345719,
-0.0301892012,
-0.055229947,
-0.0049598417,
0.0149291949,
-0.0465635732,
0.0867791176,
0.0229749624,
-0.0347568952,
-0.0559437722,
-0.0089063952,
-0.0549725816,
-0.0113125034,
-0.0600592867,
0.0234262999,
0.0418555401,
0.0760132596,
-0.0645866096,
-0.0530267991,
0.0126316566,
0.0413530692,
-0.0084662894,
0.0361921117,
0.0113366432,
0.0092202993,
-0.0035723639,
0.001657851,
-0.0380670577,
0.0193448663,
-0.0133062433,
0.0263029374,
-0.0077807927,
-0.0134908389,
-0.0203884877,
0.0050876024,
-0.1088903248,
-0.030455092,
-0.0165289715,
0.0377810597,
0.0356432535,
0.0402325653,
0.012664495,
-0.0342168882,
-0.004498424,
-0.0381370448,
-0.0199395698,
0.0601716414,
0.0197461378,
0.0056914813,
0.0113453204,
0.0490770862,
-0.0353287496,
-0.0138946548,
0.0264213681,
0.0348361135,
-0.0023407722,
-0.0338598676,
0.0445704572,
-0.0005932861,
0.0340236872,
0.0253172275,
0.0039805728,
0.0018616526,
0.0530447625,
0.0004672323,
-0.0180658512,
-0.0138191078,
0.0059997202,
0.0362206362,
0.0196091011,
-0.0043122154,
-0.0436122194,
0.0007480535,
0.0061585261,
-0.0075917211,
-0.0407226011,
0.0026654738,
0.0385612138,
0.0443736725,
-0.001082589,
-0.0484975055,
-0.000251214,
0.0095501263,
0.0540103428,
-0.000019096,
0.0932459086,
0.0350646712,
-0.011266917,
-0.0530624017,
-0.019010758,
-0.1172728017,
-0.087839894,
0.0492550656,
-0.0172341429,
0.0206528027,
-0.0376897305,
0.0317528211,
-0.0628692061,
0.0036346358,
-0.0023351028,
0.0083955526,
0.0178547129,
-0.0137500893,
0.0157208145,
0.0098922914,
0.0069502797,
-0.0057493332,
0.0719448999,
0.0089896973,
0.0426110812,
-0.0034217862,
-0.0329741687,
-0.0074633434,
-0.0461699478,
-0.0455272496,
0.0054945694,
-0.0058796545,
0.0006615057,
-0.078927882,
-0.0795585737,
-0.0142017659,
-0.0092676701,
0.0303616915,
-0.0526742414,
0.0193288419,
0.0814567506,
0.0140091386,
-0.0244950708,
-0.0099156033,
0.0071305488,
0.0189232696,
0.0110916402,
-0.0510898829,
-6.163355654e-33,
0.0102045247,
-0.0098007424,
0.0409688838,
-0.0042461772,
-0.0023915276,
0.0024682507,
-0.0401964188,
0.0181841627,
-0.0415470861,
0.0158759374,
-0.0451793782,
0.0172307882,
0.0105436342,
0.0048506614,
0.0488419943,
-0.0205203798,
0.026572777,
-0.0120514175,
-0.0404183008,
-0.0200605225,
0.0473073758,
-0.0167683978,
0.0163863339,
-0.04751065,
0.0267477222,
-0.0070311404,
0.0063958624,
0.0147781344,
-0.0652622133,
0.0479561277,
-0.0037402164,
0.0205892567,
0.0454476476,
-0.0406760201,
-0.0104188789,
0.0121632684,
-0.0525910333,
-0.0318571217,
0.0598070174,
-0.0095737427,
-0.0659555048,
-0.0074621816,
0.0212873723,
0.0270326044,
-0.0179477781,
-0.0572225153,
0.0020710512,
-0.0079829888,
-0.0142916907,
0.004451171,
-0.0475179553,
-0.0172542874,
0.0048889075,
-0.0389232635,
-0.0001235002,
0.0452423841,
-0.0256796461,
-0.001690328,
-0.0311128311,
-0.0195898581,
-0.0155885303,
0.0155411931,
0.0703290477,
0.0056118853,
-0.0075080181,
0.0723433718,
0.0399117135,
0.0110993311,
-0.0582963414,
-0.0073356,
-0.0061382679,
0.0409775116,
0.0604328997,
-0.0086848233,
0.0316810347,
0.0305733532,
-0.0807231516,
-0.0353400335,
0.0067645521,
0.0533244833,
0.0406843759,
-0.0089238063,
-0.0287506431,
-0.0346878879,
-0.0723441616,
0.0151434699,
-0.0512744226,
-0.0230637826,
0.0424195416,
0.0110175787,
0.0014239021,
-0.0298954491,
0.033564318,
-0.0091031315,
-0.009726719,
0.0141021488,
-0.0448652357,
0.0094372686,
-0.0020258799,
0.0421667434,
-0.0495906621,
0.0086778011,
-0.0203508679,
0.0248983651,
0.0234024934,
0.0218224712,
0.038888786,
-0.0056181024,
-0.0513281636,
-0.0175752044,
-0.0870640054,
0.0110393185,
-0.0105248755,
-0.0142120859,
0.0780286714,
0.0222047288,
-0.010174809,
0.008850351,
-0.0094557367,
-0.0395446531,
-0.04805227,
0.0492003597,
-0.0202851444,
0.020933982,
-0.0214699227,
-0.0194453392,
-0.0551395826,
0.0172039513,
0.0083971862,
-0.0442096852,
-0.0305656195,
0.0494556092,
2.701e-7,
0.0087354397,
0.0493880622,
-0.0270258728,
0.0173600391,
0.0264972113,
0.0365784615,
-0.0223030485,
-0.0039920704,
0.0486084372,
-0.0536722131,
-0.0203395933,
0.0348902866,
0.0358890556,
0.0209338572,
-0.038397979,
-0.0250421893,
-0.0882430598,
0.0056108679,
-0.0227685217,
0.0022024652,
0.0330578685,
0.0496960767,
0.0142047536,
-0.0258845128,
-0.0011515253,
-0.0221712235,
0.0667031705,
-0.0070560421,
0.0218477435,
-0.0124912597,
0.0041435771,
0.0021889252,
0.0082665225,
0.0694494322,
0.0222203378,
0.0050660488,
-0.0146936718,
0.0268045608,
0.022599401,
0.0057100132,
-0.0610222369,
-0.0377357416,
0.0282811094,
-0.1040024385,
0.0983385742,
-0.0389719196,
-0.0101151494,
-0.0200107638,
0.0450009815,
-0.0154416347,
0.0091827251,
0.0332125239,
0.0036604558,
0.0161912162,
0.0143671092,
0.0219228305,
0.0054407711,
-0.0962272361,
-0.0576667041,
0.0317046642,
-0.0363078564,
-0.054547593,
-0.0353358425,
0.0159638487,
0.0650539026,
-0.0503875203,
-0.0141742388,
2.479741608e-34,
-0.0041148444,
-0.018808404,
0.0654945672,
0.0117127094,
0.0309489463,
-0.0191885345,
0.0167243648,
0.004185881,
0.0319576785,
-0.0825722888,
-0.0359467454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11768v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11768v2 | Question Decomposition Improves the Faithfulness of Model-Generated Reasoning | 2023-07-17T00:54:10 | 2023-07-25T04:01:43 | Ansh Radhakrishnan, Karina Nguyen, Anna Chen, Carol Chen, Carson Denison, Danny Hernandez, Esin Durmus, Evan Hubinger, Jackson Kernion, Kamilė Lukošiūtė, Newton Cheng, Nicholas Joseph, Nicholas Schiefer, Oliver Rausch, Sam McCandlish, Sheer El Showk, Tamera Lanham, Tim Maxwell, Venkatesa Chandrasekaran, Zac Hatfield-Dodds, Jared Kaplan, Jan Brauner, Samuel R. Bowman, Ethan Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | As large language models (LLMs) perform more difficult tasks, it becomes
harder to verify the correctness and safety of their behavior. One approach to
help with this issue is to prompt LLMs to externalize their reasoning, e.g., by
having them generate step-by-step reasoning as they answer a question
(Chain-of-Thought; CoT). The reasoning may enable us to check the process that
models use to perform tasks. However, this approach relies on the stated
reasoning faithfully reflecting the model's actual reasoning, which is not
always the case. To improve over the faithfulness of CoT reasoning, we have
models generate reasoning by decomposing questions into subquestions.
Decomposition-based methods achieve strong performance on question-answering
tasks, sometimes approaching that of CoT while improving the faithfulness of
the model's stated reasoning on several recently-proposed metrics. By forcing
the model to answer simpler subquestions in separate contexts, we greatly
increase the faithfulness of model-generated reasoning over CoT, while still
achieving some of the performance gains of CoT. Our results show it is possible
to improve the faithfulness of model-generated reasoning; continued
improvements may lead to reasoning that enables us to verify the correctness
and safety of LLM behavior. | [
0.0219553318,
0.0604042597,
-0.0084441444,
0.0349403732,
-0.0378579274,
0.0403841697,
-0.0052811881,
-0.0013246886,
0.0012478369,
-0.0368055552,
-0.0018575093,
-0.0166437645,
-0.0114141684,
0.0035127401,
0.0251399688,
-0.053122472,
0.0478930958,
-0.0657436475,
-0.0089233937,
-0.0006761127,
-0.0053196512,
0.0020726516,
0.0006838752,
0.0210211203,
0.0130086914,
-0.0454568565,
-0.0524611399,
0.0063210092,
0.0054703346,
-0.0068866531,
-0.0337211229,
0.0143379858,
0.0087058181,
0.0184146985,
0.000002065,
-0.047155112,
-0.0139805023,
0.0144126397,
-0.0604426004,
0.0085256211,
-0.0361678414,
0.0126888761,
0.0251227058,
0.049205672,
-0.0465337262,
0.0024008863,
0.0010702945,
0.0562787727,
0.0686087459,
0.0605813041,
0.0114216404,
-0.0324170627,
0.0082632219,
0.0204931516,
-0.0019139161,
-0.0372587927,
-0.0030412311,
0.0503510945,
0.0371308289,
0.04038487,
0.0059653502,
0.0399276167,
0.0707548559,
-0.0072559728,
-0.0245126355,
0.0306353588,
-0.0156177795,
-0.0267053843,
0.0013631985,
0.0244815554,
-0.0115005244,
-0.041971311,
0.0073546232,
0.002967272,
0.0141261453,
0.0071992516,
-0.0553241596,
0.0577494837,
-0.0242143739,
-0.0076639378,
0.0139729381,
0.0101265982,
0.0396551341,
-0.0043654474,
-0.0591737777,
0.0832133144,
0.0012247674,
-0.0555932447,
-0.007179176,
-0.0152791673,
-0.0306186154,
-0.086943239,
-0.0118463337,
0.077841565,
-0.0628332421,
0.0377224609,
-0.0133350436,
0.0131255165,
0.0148489941,
-0.0225893464,
0.02109975,
0.0429382548,
0.0138213364,
0.0419599265,
-0.0194535963,
0.0406354144,
-0.0559440479,
0.0045945081,
-0.0572951213,
-0.0185424909,
-0.0420345925,
-0.0413660072,
-0.02967491,
0.0699524581,
-0.0113779865,
0.0046304422,
-0.003056067,
0.0508156419,
0.0061765881,
0.0400387831,
0.024730036,
0.0137805445,
0.0158237778,
-0.0385956019,
-0.0523439236,
0.0036531647,
-0.0757696033,
0.0184674393,
0.0454065166,
-0.0315827802,
-0.007249976,
-0.002527135,
-0.0125183789,
-0.0198799353,
0.0096330307,
0.0519483052,
-0.0012553267,
0.0074075069,
-0.0496463068,
-0.0808173344,
-0.003385633,
-0.0799213424,
0.012911058,
-0.070590727,
0.0236581266,
0.0185169075,
-0.0207116101,
-0.0043528313,
-0.0025334759,
0.0116481092,
-0.0217078347,
0.0778250471,
0.0236422624,
0.0183484349,
0.0019101718,
0.0304311123,
-0.0046034972,
0.0425364636,
0.0374513566,
0.0142043037,
0.02341865,
0.0159590635,
0.0031489797,
0.0152170686,
0.0300794747,
-0.0196608789,
-0.0122850155,
0.0620809942,
-0.02800842,
0.0056377919,
-0.0185909923,
0.079714641,
-0.0187231619,
0.0146420682,
0.0217427351,
0.0384786762,
-0.0200500917,
0.0211206898,
0.05445382,
-0.0046795127,
0.0038902771,
0.0543483086,
-0.0614343882,
0.0341789499,
-0.0630628467,
0.010904409,
0.0051360531,
0.014747452,
-0.0539719909,
-0.075583607,
-0.0226824638,
0.0305967778,
0.0141670592,
0.0477484576,
0.0135895656,
0.0193300303,
0.002081237,
0.0734880567,
0.0085852547,
-0.0502847284,
-0.0140573066,
-0.0959812328,
0.0579502434,
0.0087343408,
0.0455082543,
0.002744731,
-0.0328198932,
0.0068643787,
0.0126098897,
0.0066320202,
0.0161847137,
-0.026554836,
-0.0141108111,
-0.0207804274,
-0.0151853347,
-0.0168975089,
0.0128809465,
-0.0420377068,
0.0316893198,
-0.0240087193,
0.0093233958,
-0.0392313264,
0.0118595287,
0.032637354,
-0.0344007686,
-0.0179237314,
-0.0105115874,
0.0271634627,
0.0071407496,
0.0137573816,
0.0115907388,
0.0413973965,
0.0227105469,
-0.0311102364,
-0.033600349,
0.0147122759,
-0.0414573215,
-0.0486167669,
0.0192460343,
0.0142150596,
-0.0284526628,
0.0265280921,
-0.0373325385,
-0.0389817171,
0.0092218872,
-0.0240097735,
0.0118834507,
-0.0413863063,
0.0262518991,
-0.0049150977,
-0.0490415916,
-0.0182570722,
0.0909258649,
-0.0261639543,
-0.0024303561,
0.0104037989,
0.0074301488,
0.0119786737,
-0.0261446014,
0.0024885992,
0.0421089642,
-0.0132766692,
0.0082451673,
0.010672559,
0.020905057,
-0.0698091462,
-0.0153708439,
-0.0654609427,
0.008036823,
-0.014238921,
0.0170783177,
0.0383252911,
0.0303685553,
0.0232949015,
-0.0037251136,
-0.0560131036,
-0.0114371218,
0.0465130471,
0.0038639288,
0.0397586823,
0.0013744076,
-0.0006063232,
-0.0064757783,
-0.0038388919,
-0.0294074323,
0.0400874168,
-0.0204922706,
0.0222061127,
-0.0586284399,
0.0487974286,
-0.0502249412,
0.0171126742,
0.0074363346,
-0.0253976732,
0.0501992926,
-0.0107562607,
0.0089921802,
0.0865406841,
-0.0107939951,
-0.0055449377,
0.0492284857,
0.0054034311,
-0.0426132493,
0.0396913737,
-0.0051441272,
-0.026594637,
-0.0065959962,
-0.0456255414,
-0.0020052365,
0.0709997863,
-0.0147307105,
-0.0116419885,
-0.0616150722,
0.0304336846,
-0.0227183066,
-0.012553351,
-0.037171822,
-0.0393368937,
-0.0107508898,
0.0804656968,
-0.0196461678,
-0.0220783316,
0.0736916587,
-0.0164249185,
-0.0022166125,
-0.0455240011,
0.0078451494,
-0.0172749255,
0.1002452746,
-0.0272757988,
0.0137954112,
0.0289332382,
0.0080777556,
-0.0705215409,
-0.0384887494,
0.0107303541,
-0.0324185714,
0.0522413366,
-0.0549794137,
-0.0064442712,
-0.0017061809,
-0.0582429096,
-0.0851513892,
0.0018954498,
-0.036488764,
0.0205337759,
-0.0383747295,
-0.0135088349,
0.0064064115,
0.0046446044,
0.0399107412,
-0.0088882167,
-0.0286136717,
-0.027808072,
-0.0209249817,
0.0527408272,
0.0558781885,
0.0131521123,
0.0323667116,
-0.0438861512,
0.0896285176,
0.0812901706,
0.0523849539,
0.0215811916,
-0.0244496968,
0.0039001608,
-0.0147750564,
0.0098181609,
-0.0121454624,
0.0201043915,
0.0530222356,
-0.0739091262,
-0.0482925065,
0.1258486509,
0.0569488965,
-0.0058265054,
-0.0046621514,
-0.0561786778,
0.056030523,
0.0219684746,
0.0404757708,
-0.0583011694,
-0.0251390357,
0.0401243642,
0.006012293,
-0.0165215656,
-0.025017295,
-0.0100968089,
-0.0985512435,
0.0501739047,
-0.0055409814,
-0.0071470477,
-0.0122336522,
-0.0450891033,
-0.0010446382,
0.0496706776,
0.0125888214,
0.0507361218,
0.0165767036,
-0.0225927774,
0.0229502525,
-0.0265004393,
-0.0104849245,
0.0417132601,
-0.0311422851,
0.0111838868,
0.0489594191,
0.0259721801,
0.029556118,
-0.0492650606,
0.0473385118,
-0.0144858239,
0.0010261906,
-0.0139061874,
-0.0035238441,
0.0014484422,
0.0085882731,
-0.0194247179,
0.0311426632,
-0.013904484,
-0.0055200332,
0.02640789,
0.1013615876,
-0.0403837636,
-0.0342508554,
-0.0363843478,
0.0086035691,
-0.0342169367,
0.0776261836,
0.0519922264,
-0.0214188155,
-0.0451852158,
-0.0284178331,
-0.0543144755,
-0.0262275282,
-0.0319020003,
0.0221047327,
0.0325559713,
0.0376891121,
-0.0620202795,
-0.049812641,
0.030902138,
0.0448542461,
-0.0310307518,
-0.0074650254,
0.0296242908,
-0.0023170004,
-0.0287348423,
-0.0102675026,
-0.0525752939,
0.0097986683,
-0.0096421223,
0.038211707,
0.0111730434,
-0.0145665202,
-0.0156190405,
0.0006498809,
-0.0934050456,
-0.0480511896,
-0.0337067805,
0.0382969454,
0.0343796015,
0.0345613882,
-0.0309508666,
-0.045257654,
0.0026463098,
-0.0066049201,
-0.0360584147,
0.010133761,
0.023412358,
-0.0163385477,
0.0064396197,
0.0488914922,
-0.0459135249,
0.0044460446,
0.005624976,
0.0512696989,
-0.0275307074,
-0.0315356702,
0.0512261614,
0.0525931418,
-0.0130671561,
0.0231637377,
0.0094832107,
-0.0048415218,
0.0402449295,
-0.0195371229,
-0.0466781966,
-0.0378230512,
0.048543416,
0.0186473634,
0.0019772581,
0.0030270293,
-0.0179049373,
-0.0075452104,
0.0231165029,
0.0140698934,
-0.0290640555,
-0.0043340544,
0.03522259,
0.032661546,
-0.0158786699,
-0.0201662406,
-0.0035684584,
0.0031819732,
0.040975064,
-0.0131228277,
0.0663133562,
0.0414826199,
0.0013834145,
-0.0723205879,
0.020261528,
-0.095052667,
-0.1079407707,
0.041993279,
0.0065434431,
0.0060773343,
0.0270695761,
0.0024803511,
-0.0258103143,
-0.018603906,
0.0124084549,
0.015034372,
0.0569188744,
-0.0372613855,
0.049454391,
0.037392199,
-0.0065050274,
-0.0338188075,
0.0391559042,
-0.0133208353,
0.0383989327,
-0.0051660766,
-0.0075112861,
-0.0530975126,
-0.0441527031,
-0.0334606133,
0.0020901733,
-0.0169317927,
0.0130569367,
-0.064340651,
-0.0950443372,
-0.0253265984,
0.0377514958,
-0.0029032959,
-0.0185929947,
0.0272226389,
0.060513258,
0.027168043,
-0.0366231948,
-0.0038962925,
0.0121119162,
-0.0206776671,
-0.0223393887,
-0.019200353,
-5.972356189e-33,
-0.0208275747,
-0.0280953292,
0.0557540767,
-0.0263491217,
-0.016342137,
-0.015701402,
-0.0516293645,
0.0162352454,
-0.0435230881,
0.0201683827,
-0.0452751555,
0.0385931805,
-0.002971353,
0.0175624602,
0.0061182892,
-0.0409097485,
0.027719235,
-0.025948232,
-0.0497239605,
0.0237997547,
0.0356181525,
-0.0264267549,
-0.0040113362,
-0.0109709231,
0.0176114459,
-0.032022763,
-0.0152148074,
0.0718150586,
-0.0522819646,
0.0715372786,
-0.0220185909,
-0.0079654073,
0.0349937789,
-0.0167381093,
0.0083562424,
0.0233120434,
-0.0622686855,
-0.0187930837,
0.051090017,
-0.0324122608,
-0.1083458215,
-0.0135147814,
0.0126459552,
0.0137443785,
0.0148565965,
-0.0274673924,
-0.006782616,
-0.019125836,
0.0177732389,
-0.0122134574,
-0.028827237,
-0.0038592985,
-0.0097411396,
-0.0533414409,
0.0201215781,
0.0566926077,
-0.0183273777,
0.0148653444,
0.0237815566,
-0.0171844698,
0.0379101485,
0.0034746046,
0.0565309301,
0.0172055997,
-0.0183298644,
0.0479871146,
-0.0063132844,
-0.0160175469,
-0.0599713549,
-0.0022281599,
-0.0006109336,
0.066145964,
0.0536183715,
0.0144522758,
0.0033239792,
0.0441175997,
-0.0759416595,
0.0290169958,
0.0053955112,
0.0639170408,
0.0344695598,
-0.0181788579,
-0.0288372077,
-0.0153134856,
-0.054191988,
0.0121701788,
-0.0570291951,
-0.0085881613,
0.0386315249,
0.0014998799,
-0.054835517,
-0.0462411717,
0.0305465497,
-0.0430670977,
0.0209870227,
0.0477309152,
-0.0157839116,
0.0034586387,
-0.0015555482,
0.0612450503,
-0.0223113392,
0.0188900754,
-0.0062470553,
-0.0139564881,
-0.0085494518,
0.0258328225,
0.0185987987,
0.0035037063,
-0.034313567,
0.0064182063,
-0.0732899383,
0.0424419418,
-0.0360793844,
0.002412613,
0.0330951586,
0.0376704559,
-0.0022101747,
0.0222510025,
-0.0120224198,
-0.0326712653,
-0.048320543,
0.0683150962,
0.0135136629,
0.0393637121,
-0.0100440253,
-0.0115843238,
-0.0518595204,
0.0341480114,
0.0068890154,
-0.0647462234,
-0.0161224529,
0.0341978073,
2.669e-7,
0.0150652155,
0.0152746988,
0.0075274869,
0.0548822507,
0.011741396,
0.0430521742,
-0.0161110498,
-0.0143658966,
0.0340542197,
-0.0664562508,
0.0008026747,
0.054742489,
0.0406453051,
0.0448149331,
-0.047500845,
0.0036430873,
-0.06682235,
-0.0383517779,
-0.0353317373,
-0.0039508054,
0.0724596232,
0.0639746934,
0.0084808934,
-0.0129616186,
0.0094200708,
-0.0252784733,
0.0449806787,
0.0019464928,
-0.007403668,
-0.000105589,
0.0056971856,
0.0449295416,
0.0241607111,
0.016542796,
0.0224679131,
0.00449477,
-0.0220902581,
0.0559098832,
0.0196964983,
-0.0300561339,
-0.0533792228,
-0.0508345403,
0.041373916,
-0.0863659233,
0.0949535817,
-0.0287767574,
-0.0107194968,
-0.0250719395,
0.0249522887,
-0.0075337584,
-0.0381078161,
-0.0011891288,
-0.0210951231,
0.0189954229,
0.0146526834,
-0.0114716981,
0.0324191898,
-0.0948560759,
-0.0489058457,
-0.0100975996,
-0.0194230899,
-0.0540307686,
-0.0136327837,
0.0165220052,
0.0280064102,
-0.0511908457,
-0.0217244308,
2.676699819e-34,
0.0308270492,
0.0095530991,
0.0322201811,
0.0372294821,
0.0377570502,
-0.0163947064,
-0.0030307767,
0.0046407925,
0.0380621776,
-0.0877670124,
-0.0326853469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08161v1 | Assessing the Quality of Multiple-Choice Questions Using GPT-4 and Rule-Based Methods | 2023-07-16T22:12:10 | 2023-07-16T22:12:10 | Steven Moore, Huy A. Nguyen, Tianying Chen, John Stamper | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Multiple-choice questions with item-writing flaws can negatively impact
student learning and skew analytics. These flaws are often present in
student-generated questions, making it difficult to assess their quality and
suitability for classroom usage. Existing methods for evaluating
multiple-choice questions often focus on machine readability metrics, without
considering their intended use within course materials and their pedagogical
implications. In this study, we compared the performance of a rule-based method
we developed to a machine-learning based method utilizing GPT-4 for the task of
automatically assessing multiple-choice questions based on 19 common
item-writing flaws. By analyzing 200 student-generated questions from four
different subject areas, we found that the rule-based method correctly detected
91% of the flaws identified by human annotators, as compared to 79% by GPT-4.
We demonstrated the effectiveness of the two methods in identifying common
item-writing flaws present in the student-generated questions across different
subject areas. The rule-based method can accurately and efficiently evaluate
multiple-choice questions from multiple domains, outperforming GPT-4 and going
beyond existing metrics that do not account for the educational use of such
questions. Finally, we discuss the potential for using these automated methods
to improve the quality of questions based on the identified flaws. | [
0.0065060193,
-0.0288206674,
-0.0485206395,
-0.0119577013,
-0.0523657091,
0.0515422486,
0.0183284506,
0.0026699535,
0.0342097431,
-0.0561050922,
0.0443620346,
-0.0123854438,
-0.015947897,
-0.0227840971,
0.033642862,
-0.0005965008,
0.000308913,
0.0340628475,
-0.0224922411,
0.0641892031,
-0.0021658824,
-0.0059340922,
-0.0184633266,
0.0083759455,
0.0167525001,
-0.0614515617,
-0.0150042307,
-0.0169762019,
0.018190898,
-0.0473231599,
0.0304868873,
0.0643061996,
-0.0678420514,
0.0123342862,
0.0000023291,
-0.0565428324,
-0.0397536978,
-0.0059064846,
-0.0154756261,
0.0417731777,
0.0279621612,
0.0687474981,
0.0158247501,
0.0342392959,
-0.0444798134,
-0.0411863476,
0.0236483905,
0.0231927373,
0.0551878884,
0.0443684086,
-0.0080163116,
0.0158629306,
0.026008768,
0.0232762694,
0.040132504,
0.0118456557,
0.0071485727,
0.0267652068,
0.0013476684,
0.026298387,
-0.0134552764,
-0.0144066494,
0.0150888804,
-0.0098295603,
0.0205811709,
-0.0147119379,
-0.0379843414,
-0.0059232581,
0.0095905298,
0.0663475618,
-0.0024186329,
-0.002568183,
-0.0220911186,
-0.0324968435,
0.0497933328,
0.0426179916,
-0.0007848816,
-0.0186481401,
-0.0390279926,
-0.0380973406,
-0.0022295306,
-0.0485020354,
-0.0128455227,
0.0204269886,
0.032779675,
0.013339296,
0.022551652,
-0.0587959923,
0.0002589825,
0.045379322,
-0.0184061285,
0.0060352329,
0.0532301962,
0.0200217124,
-0.0292183943,
0.0119715491,
-0.0231590495,
-0.0175211448,
0.0453197658,
0.0139820911,
0.0516668819,
0.0365383551,
-0.0278016292,
-0.0050716302,
0.013192893,
0.0815412328,
0.0458684601,
0.0211177487,
-0.0635780245,
0.0703711659,
-0.0445203111,
0.0023836531,
0.0163387023,
0.0369743854,
0.0271859057,
0.031770438,
-0.0508055389,
-0.0023731836,
-0.0088812103,
0.0213127509,
-0.0291414075,
-0.0303919613,
0.0096654473,
0.0272153262,
-0.0317775011,
0.063552171,
-0.0162493829,
0.0011859679,
-0.0016549539,
0.0091636153,
0.010523349,
0.0298875552,
0.0120040877,
-0.0038105645,
-0.0063078701,
0.0072980663,
-0.0118417051,
-0.0046392051,
-0.0065089338,
-0.0246270541,
-0.0255129524,
0.0185053907,
-0.0186703708,
-0.0313381292,
-0.0326004699,
0.0188268889,
-0.0281855259,
0.0185654443,
0.0000399135,
0.0604446307,
0.0320966095,
0.0274715926,
-0.0129058594,
-0.0003835579,
0.0505743064,
0.0157739446,
-0.0140506476,
-0.0338777974,
0.0326605327,
-0.0148525489,
0.0341409557,
-0.0766082928,
0.0410018228,
-0.0085535636,
-0.0182320997,
-0.0070611201,
0.0301267412,
0.0120843714,
0.0110767428,
0.0477984101,
-0.039142862,
0.0704739839,
0.0130923158,
0.0141354585,
0.0562144704,
0.0307478346,
0.0102081085,
0.0053103315,
0.0039677997,
0.0303051677,
0.0303583797,
0.0714545175,
-0.0093602333,
-0.0209650472,
0.0120359808,
-0.0024432107,
-0.0030108176,
0.0377252884,
0.0398268066,
-0.0959712192,
-0.0267289523,
0.0156778246,
0.0121261748,
0.0272275768,
0.0026698655,
-0.0151577005,
-0.0672546476,
-0.0250062589,
-0.0310406331,
-0.0733958706,
0.0258298777,
-0.0264002662,
0.0962729827,
0.0555941314,
0.0500731021,
-0.048147507,
-0.0782890022,
-0.0228501372,
0.0048245699,
0.0039858595,
0.0679559261,
-0.0418451056,
-0.015976131,
-0.063196294,
-0.0179922767,
0.03179029,
0.0079946266,
-0.0242583435,
-0.0324473381,
-0.0078377901,
0.0263791773,
-0.0359860323,
-0.0710982606,
0.0562138371,
0.0253809765,
-0.0623626225,
0.0030672546,
0.008203336,
0.0148356222,
0.0148265529,
0.0060376786,
0.0128485048,
-0.0384545103,
0.0089976257,
0.0044845245,
-0.0584819913,
-0.0433137417,
0.0146542294,
0.0553664304,
-0.0418032072,
-0.0426457599,
0.0478887297,
-0.0197820198,
-0.038902998,
-0.050625816,
-0.041307196,
-0.0416791812,
-0.0401458517,
0.0108396523,
-0.0156042222,
-0.0294924006,
-0.068194963,
0.0223993268,
0.0537886396,
0.0655765608,
-0.0284478348,
0.0110311359,
0.0551915802,
0.0167374648,
-0.0009423036,
-0.0003411826,
-0.030646529,
0.0328442119,
0.0312254447,
0.0306196455,
-0.1042312458,
0.0033893706,
-0.0262831673,
0.0118144909,
0.0112274634,
0.0204447042,
0.0068853311,
-0.0418395512,
-0.0179173443,
0.0156727228,
-0.0412504561,
-0.0259792972,
-0.0199137963,
-0.0014422522,
0.0506728552,
-0.0170760714,
0.0411989018,
-0.0228014812,
-0.0114747118,
-0.0676342398,
-0.0158948097,
0.0740327984,
0.0631702021,
-0.0459256694,
0.0528354682,
0.013639193,
-0.0819713473,
0.05908278,
-0.0375932977,
0.0171690583,
-0.0144070284,
0.0584253296,
0.0539442934,
-0.0015897702,
0.0263901297,
0.0307366494,
-0.0236514844,
0.0009785062,
-0.0049506044,
-0.004534984,
0.0339193754,
0.0165302306,
-0.0533211455,
0.0368493535,
-0.0021027755,
0.0390658192,
-0.0631965995,
0.0105411792,
0.0547723398,
-0.086567007,
0.0288666468,
-0.064742133,
-0.0226787254,
-0.0196977407,
0.0283618327,
0.0258710105,
-0.0202920008,
0.0728434026,
-0.0020698784,
0.0158732794,
-0.0923248306,
0.0309558809,
-0.0145991342,
0.0146659333,
0.0084704598,
0.0031283593,
0.0294606071,
-0.0371643156,
-0.0674576759,
0.0122420704,
0.0590688325,
-0.0285524148,
0.0563221648,
-0.0601660013,
-0.0518524945,
0.0049695224,
-0.0079539521,
0.0006661548,
0.0099024549,
0.0623792373,
-0.0519936495,
-0.023300264,
-0.0082263499,
0.0127389617,
-0.0210775081,
0.0091071976,
0.0165021215,
-0.0589692555,
-0.0225276574,
0.0037949381,
0.0839828849,
0.0155140124,
-0.0071941558,
0.0024385094,
-0.0185083263,
0.0478673093,
0.0486232825,
0.0368923843,
0.0298539754,
0.0277810115,
0.0401732326,
0.0046371897,
-0.076569818,
-0.0255149994,
0.0296419431,
0.0654007494,
-0.0903867185,
-0.0017509174,
0.0751175135,
0.0550332144,
0.0065577179,
-0.0086299749,
0.0035588306,
-0.0376912802,
-0.0067197345,
0.0573891811,
-0.0420159288,
0.0015889608,
-0.0124330129,
0.0631646961,
-0.0410307646,
-0.0295660794,
0.0338138677,
-0.0824065059,
0.0391389802,
-0.0008210129,
-0.0446731783,
-0.0243094359,
-0.019422248,
-0.0180677641,
-0.0098356791,
0.0433610938,
0.0037324014,
0.0207941104,
0.0385551117,
0.0449090488,
-0.060946323,
-0.0117875636,
-0.0059605422,
0.018770963,
0.0033437498,
0.020011995,
0.038050171,
-0.0348485447,
-0.0445422679,
0.0276741218,
-0.0613579974,
-0.030179603,
0.0008901803,
0.0337416157,
0.0271193124,
0.0097687207,
-0.0650591999,
0.0316593349,
0.0075134519,
-0.0206502154,
0.0620620996,
0.0606236048,
-0.0222294647,
-0.0247142669,
-0.027287066,
-0.0073124766,
0.0002523815,
0.0201692991,
0.0611004867,
-0.0467452332,
0.0088712787,
-0.0636462197,
0.0455104187,
-0.0705228448,
0.0090848263,
0.0214758106,
-0.0271445103,
-0.0088866912,
-0.0448410362,
-0.0911761671,
0.0788343847,
-0.0098112188,
0.0138407871,
0.0046448861,
0.0359592736,
0.0189550389,
-0.0308579635,
-0.0199084766,
0.0351999477,
-0.0169258807,
-0.0120307952,
-0.019349996,
-0.0394706242,
0.0216899347,
-0.0260481834,
0.0067273285,
-0.0091278143,
-0.0069160997,
0.0242999997,
0.0518265218,
0.0075781583,
-0.0758458301,
-0.0053959792,
0.0039583216,
-0.0239114352,
-0.001936238,
0.0048203613,
-0.0333536677,
-0.0479871631,
-0.040270336,
-0.0166647397,
-0.0289732292,
0.0359445699,
0.0042438405,
-0.0114084072,
0.0467373841,
-0.0336262286,
-0.0149279116,
0.0404683016,
0.065081127,
0.0227416698,
-0.008975435,
-0.0075328341,
-0.0211086348,
-0.0014180241,
-0.0185472742,
-0.0256702248,
0.002490269,
0.0061566276,
0.0308805034,
-0.0139780082,
-0.0247936659,
-0.0222526528,
-0.0628694668,
0.0387005769,
-0.0242614392,
0.0360158198,
-0.0067121577,
0.0334115066,
0.0114524169,
-0.0272141546,
-0.0399743095,
-0.0222835857,
0.0277356524,
0.0547566749,
0.0337155126,
0.0933855772,
-0.0097618429,
0.0292457007,
0.0667284131,
0.0188478641,
0.0026642396,
0.0128172254,
-0.0161913987,
0.0126393531,
-0.0507409237,
-0.0051318207,
0.0046149641,
0.0004461568,
-0.0127983876,
-0.02215432,
0.047556825,
-0.0095558306,
-0.0114601962,
0.0213045198,
0.0201369096,
-0.0009106999,
-0.0472999439,
0.0300211981,
-0.0154324071,
-0.0093479455,
0.0100597888,
-0.05250182,
-0.0543100722,
0.0040719043,
-0.009972061,
0.0301022585,
0.0008368198,
0.0011653421,
-0.0832290053,
-0.0478108861,
-0.002788272,
0.0335087255,
0.0602656528,
-0.0245237593,
-0.0344191119,
0.0476811528,
-0.0456775166,
-0.0060692732,
-0.0274446197,
-0.0080520492,
-0.082281135,
-0.0404488035,
0.0145098614,
-5.849132055e-33,
-0.0356952548,
-0.094281964,
0.0124037666,
0.0155428434,
0.0030467915,
-0.0278537013,
-0.0318830907,
0.0146394502,
0.0069842208,
0.0099412939,
0.0104382616,
0.0015237175,
-0.0190137662,
0.0380065963,
0.039952185,
-0.0403096303,
0.0126188239,
0.0132420352,
-0.0542806722,
0.0162850991,
-0.0196707882,
0.0120543335,
0.0593933724,
0.0097714011,
0.0461940989,
-0.0229522977,
-0.0057826876,
-0.0199954752,
-0.032870546,
0.0398105308,
-0.0028426098,
0.0405794159,
0.0274642333,
-0.0441050977,
0.0187435094,
0.0361244082,
-0.0031507944,
-0.0744839236,
-0.0154174063,
-0.0048114359,
0.021172097,
-0.0484829694,
0.023380341,
-0.0020759939,
-0.005329798,
-0.0269450303,
0.0627178103,
-0.0244862419,
0.0143767809,
-0.0199882761,
-0.0421227142,
0.0176300518,
-0.0445137247,
-0.0109742796,
-0.0551344231,
0.0787543878,
0.0034284578,
-0.0000043755,
-0.0449388511,
0.0329178423,
0.0166890118,
0.0139593445,
0.0047700261,
-0.0264254045,
-0.0503962412,
0.0210422147,
0.0106444182,
-0.0110035371,
-0.0047820397,
0.0231067855,
0.0204815734,
-0.0282793138,
0.1049585342,
0.0750917271,
0.0542809591,
-0.0140345395,
-0.0205806717,
0.0917283371,
0.0212794282,
-0.0133989416,
-0.0429453701,
-0.0598555245,
-0.0430810004,
-0.0371239409,
-0.032031104,
-0.0198840257,
-0.026451325,
-0.0241760239,
0.0612125583,
-0.0951743126,
-0.0209180918,
0.0264757816,
0.0004984648,
0.0194694996,
-0.0224059876,
-0.0501456074,
-0.0325386748,
0.0430191346,
-0.039680168,
-0.0009276049,
-0.0388565846,
0.0526763573,
0.0133969039,
0.0006635042,
0.0323937796,
-0.0095926858,
0.0163442716,
0.0109975245,
-0.0537067354,
-0.0181264598,
0.0178136826,
-0.0410658717,
0.0304826424,
0.0162407085,
-0.0030852887,
0.0282534305,
0.0068118088,
0.0162028074,
0.0271127131,
-0.0198709425,
-0.0541468114,
-0.0496806502,
-0.0114155309,
-0.0340440162,
0.0018063998,
-0.0360983163,
-0.0082006659,
-0.0067496337,
0.0100354534,
-0.0486071594,
0.0036682361,
-0.0267310329,
2.804e-7,
0.074247323,
0.0699878037,
0.0047146576,
-0.0249278545,
-0.0360506736,
0.0420511775,
0.0004642798,
-0.0262127798,
0.0633814186,
0.0520223491,
0.0591364764,
-0.0282780379,
0.0362314694,
0.0550729446,
-0.0478270017,
-0.0286241043,
0.0426857471,
-0.0071660774,
-0.0450587235,
0.0390776619,
0.1095923483,
-0.005272869,
0.0070346617,
-0.0390392691,
-0.0075852973,
-0.0064085,
-0.0074227112,
-0.021916071,
-0.0214083083,
0.0279835667,
0.034078069,
-0.0177945755,
0.0196251068,
0.0638674125,
-0.0176192988,
-0.0694453344,
0.0622368492,
0.0127522396,
0.0491250604,
-0.0047114743,
-0.0063201808,
0.0325486138,
0.0363066643,
-0.088649489,
0.0120233689,
-0.0271336548,
0.0113300588,
0.023301661,
-0.0616606697,
-0.0342521034,
0.0187948477,
-0.0047660787,
-0.0079929112,
0.0046545928,
-0.0111889597,
-0.0202813894,
0.0454579778,
0.031617716,
-0.0092184721,
0.0170986801,
0.0411046818,
-0.0241686106,
-0.0300063398,
-0.0611589439,
0.0222637057,
-0.0329448953,
-0.0330410339,
2.598231439e-34,
0.0233797766,
-0.0452938229,
0.0726969987,
-0.0082996041,
0.0021550863,
0.0240985323,
0.0186867304,
0.0016173548,
-0.0285022873,
-0.0345646739,
-0.0064302408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08153v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08153v4 | Analyzing Dataset Annotation Quality Management in the Wild | 2023-07-16T21:22:40 | 2024-03-09T14:18:41 | Jan-Christoph Klie, Richard Eckart de Castilho, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data quality is crucial for training accurate, unbiased, and trustworthy
machine learning models as well as for their correct evaluation. Recent works,
however, have shown that even popular datasets used to train and evaluate
state-of-the-art models contain a non-negligible amount of erroneous
annotations, biases, or artifacts. While practices and guidelines regarding
dataset creation projects exist, to our knowledge, large-scale analysis has yet
to be performed on how quality management is conducted when creating natural
language datasets and whether these recommendations are followed. Therefore, we
first survey and summarize recommended quality management practices for dataset
creation as described in the literature and provide suggestions for applying
them. Then, we compile a corpus of 591 scientific publications introducing text
datasets and annotate it for quality-related aspects, such as annotator
management, agreement, adjudication, or data validation. Using these
annotations, we then analyze how quality management is conducted in practice. A
majority of the annotated publications apply good or excellent quality
management. However, we deem the effort of 30\% of the works as only subpar.
Our analysis also shows common errors, especially when using inter-annotator
agreement and computing annotation error rates. | [
0.0707773939,
0.062204238,
-0.00920734,
0.0096787214,
-0.015694838,
0.0103353411,
0.016574882,
-0.04187667,
-0.0073397593,
-0.0622116514,
-0.0021967785,
0.0076968721,
0.0322033875,
-0.0108441543,
-0.0083504375,
-0.0299455374,
0.058149185,
0.0158609636,
0.0207895227,
0.0185785834,
0.016888259,
0.0091627268,
0.0361516811,
0.0432022884,
-0.0559720099,
-0.0142317535,
0.02618948,
-0.0132482769,
0.0033560863,
-0.041957397,
0.0185752679,
0.0642132312,
-0.0146506354,
0.0777323321,
0.0000016607,
-0.056476891,
0.0052357959,
0.0610529706,
-0.0420663916,
0.0044551864,
0.0423284881,
-0.0340092741,
0.0060473555,
0.011907964,
-0.0220962763,
-0.0271730032,
0.0565914623,
0.0284289978,
0.0838253051,
0.0655396655,
-0.006282595,
-0.0205654055,
0.0426333658,
-0.0014432326,
-0.0080868872,
0.0136695663,
0.0230952837,
0.0505043119,
-0.0403201357,
0.0137297343,
0.0150774335,
0.0283038337,
0.021644,
-0.0276668053,
0.0066930479,
-0.0112745296,
-0.0887880549,
-0.0616881996,
0.011807262,
0.0377359428,
0.0605038404,
-0.0163053013,
-0.0050285412,
-0.0299264789,
-0.0005168871,
0.0240630489,
0.0091928095,
0.0404991992,
-0.0066924454,
0.0071679223,
0.0022025083,
-0.0226765294,
0.0240454357,
0.001593215,
0.0185800977,
0.0328025818,
-0.0386003479,
-0.0428144559,
0.0162759144,
0.0204905551,
-0.0340550989,
-0.0550945252,
-0.0289206952,
-0.0438866429,
0.0035201777,
0.0281009823,
-0.0501501858,
-0.0444385,
0.0663804859,
-0.0256970804,
0.0043516778,
-0.0205937605,
-0.0384246372,
0.025816666,
0.0581354536,
-0.0052101077,
0.0553540327,
0.0215365216,
0.0052441228,
-0.0039849072,
-0.0220703389,
0.0339580961,
0.0041436213,
-0.003582723,
0.0170000326,
0.0176881701,
-0.0514345542,
-0.0107134515,
-0.03052352,
0.0602367781,
0.0338574946,
0.0028063543,
-0.0240154937,
0.0318638608,
-0.0590440668,
-0.0092186434,
0.0078457939,
0.0678112358,
-0.0125348177,
-0.0604569428,
0.0189813152,
0.0326914713,
-0.0054947892,
-0.016772477,
0.0171308573,
0.041322533,
0.0599303357,
-0.0382110365,
-0.056697581,
-0.044632148,
-0.040864516,
-0.0473845974,
0.0067673372,
-0.041575864,
0.036823567,
0.0032638742,
-0.0147827175,
-0.0462089963,
-0.0237831771,
0.0336902328,
-0.0251805075,
0.0569610037,
-0.1084248573,
0.0054450403,
0.0126734935,
-0.0103260493,
-0.0240837261,
0.0654991046,
0.0497851074,
-0.0135438424,
0.0492763743,
-0.0099664368,
0.0123002138,
0.0027979268,
0.018666476,
0.013633511,
0.0150640719,
0.0221066643,
-0.0317656957,
0.0129823098,
-0.0024928791,
0.0654984191,
-0.0416695103,
-0.0106498096,
0.0364222713,
0.0390516371,
0.006350663,
0.0083477078,
0.0048382669,
0.0013008711,
0.041567266,
-0.0304560121,
-0.0244092289,
-0.0162562672,
0.0124105057,
-0.0241036694,
0.0033745351,
0.0110575119,
0.0108867781,
-0.0876900107,
-0.0565418489,
-0.0038115932,
0.0208389536,
-0.0012213327,
0.0113747064,
0.0006820814,
0.0073244288,
-0.0062403469,
0.0109389834,
-0.0499396361,
-0.0166576933,
-0.0101518696,
0.0428071208,
0.0352209434,
0.0423377715,
-0.0077753966,
-0.0053432873,
-0.0429337509,
0.0249358229,
0.0013209272,
0.0366081409,
-0.0352065116,
0.0007414237,
-0.0353064984,
-0.0582296662,
0.0033747097,
0.019427307,
-0.0283909421,
-0.0024876848,
-0.0042513525,
0.0005015405,
-0.0331768692,
-0.1079078764,
0.0706072226,
-0.0140788695,
-0.0014277847,
-0.0140240304,
-0.0196310971,
0.0614797175,
0.0356233791,
-0.0313539542,
0.0023001521,
0.0336714014,
0.0410509519,
0.0116036935,
0.0018994685,
0.0430971645,
-0.0014393547,
0.0347687081,
-0.0740324482,
-0.0387725718,
-0.0044435416,
-0.0575754941,
-0.0327328928,
-0.0539088212,
-0.0398716368,
-0.0081651621,
-0.0295655448,
-0.0059142546,
-0.0149867097,
-0.0031394325,
-0.0180819631,
0.0374078527,
-0.0284835119,
0.0370278955,
-0.0072599379,
-0.0462967753,
0.0453218184,
-0.0194582064,
-0.0313920639,
0.0151205733,
-0.0137534803,
0.0506149083,
0.0640578344,
0.0022461456,
-0.0566470958,
0.0083305184,
-0.0552367866,
-0.0094762435,
-0.000777602,
0.0240063313,
-0.0018170057,
-0.0541849136,
-0.0011672693,
0.0132523598,
-0.0128815267,
-0.064091593,
0.0062255473,
0.0233957954,
0.0599876121,
-0.0028791637,
0.015085889,
-0.0449205041,
-0.0026173554,
0.0018196449,
0.0393924303,
0.0380458795,
-0.0215672571,
-0.0559565499,
0.0486033931,
-0.0307605714,
-0.0013218875,
0.0137234861,
-0.0019032998,
0.0423701666,
0.0583737008,
-0.071483694,
0.017086789,
-0.0229972079,
0.0136879263,
0.0527030975,
0.0215690881,
-0.0397313945,
-0.0117287254,
0.0030382334,
0.0131648481,
0.0211467296,
-0.0347647369,
0.0331218615,
0.0230936278,
-0.0190337617,
-0.0200075489,
-0.0110549899,
0.0311239474,
-0.0296509769,
-0.0271471757,
0.0289072655,
-0.0326322056,
0.0095497426,
0.0859885141,
-0.0323251858,
-0.051436305,
0.0373750478,
-0.0192473773,
0.0290578678,
-0.0623774715,
0.0193608683,
-0.0114649832,
0.0176175404,
-0.0012796832,
-0.0038917104,
0.0347633772,
0.0244342536,
-0.027897045,
-0.0003694788,
0.0629147589,
-0.0320302434,
0.0305625722,
-0.0335481316,
0.0374246091,
-0.0144061344,
-0.0019474104,
-0.0231690574,
-0.0355123989,
-0.032375142,
-0.00656308,
0.0332904384,
-0.0095701832,
-0.0241174642,
-0.0253519882,
0.0243858807,
0.0422497727,
0.0093744034,
-0.0232196748,
0.0248038247,
-0.0252879597,
0.0081560379,
0.0270677544,
0.0499879308,
-0.0031399461,
-0.0258774068,
0.0449151434,
-0.0180143528,
0.0427038334,
-0.0486322902,
-0.032158114,
0.0215261467,
-0.0110587757,
-0.0501915105,
-0.0042071682,
0.0347832814,
-0.0729239807,
0.0138359945,
0.0733865574,
0.0308882743,
-0.0192114469,
-0.005963874,
-0.0010487596,
0.0176557191,
0.008722364,
-0.023203468,
-0.1266295314,
-0.0228251107,
-0.0039623296,
0.0399883538,
-0.0397864953,
-0.0440238304,
-0.0091642793,
-0.0930288285,
0.0541682579,
-0.0042546927,
-0.0568311438,
-0.0015344409,
-0.0808244273,
-0.0196807254,
-0.0812230036,
0.0673065633,
-0.0284845326,
0.0227913968,
0.0210712496,
0.0413495824,
-0.068575345,
-0.1141672432,
0.0089263311,
-0.0545027927,
0.0786378458,
0.0663839653,
0.0579291508,
-0.0077957362,
-0.0230768528,
0.0101849288,
0.0071500689,
-0.0113933189,
0.0146206142,
0.1108148396,
-0.0159648657,
-0.0076514436,
-0.0181843992,
0.0231614783,
-0.0255110059,
-0.0110433828,
-0.015099695,
0.0424503013,
-0.025534695,
0.0198365469,
-0.0420419499,
-0.0245003495,
-0.0116728926,
0.0802628174,
0.006504768,
-0.0093573174,
0.0016839871,
-0.0085333865,
0.0438108705,
-0.0368622281,
0.0010260266,
0.0646226034,
-0.0574552119,
-0.0268278345,
-0.0505326539,
-0.0980565995,
0.036185354,
-0.0156128742,
0.024037946,
-0.0125786066,
-0.0035837756,
0.006415226,
-0.003840172,
0.0684926659,
-0.0080754291,
-0.0161428042,
-0.0100695677,
-0.027835412,
0.0082944948,
0.0304221585,
-0.000344369,
0.0404947139,
-0.0261098649,
-0.0393781178,
0.0280126203,
0.0422160029,
0.0210104249,
0.033168029,
0.0242237914,
-0.0610304177,
-0.030165432,
0.074312076,
-0.0290010069,
-0.0414161049,
0.0358830541,
-0.0120721543,
-0.0158928409,
-0.0136083625,
-0.0437035598,
0.0050014798,
-0.0100908754,
-0.0146834785,
-0.0404536612,
-0.0009912859,
0.0393216833,
0.0345289148,
0.0511886589,
-0.0543255396,
0.005915028,
-0.0465259738,
-0.0248457044,
-0.0285699144,
-0.0506583005,
-0.0423795022,
0.0385668203,
0.0011764843,
0.0005913244,
-0.0459296964,
0.0406765118,
-0.0421027206,
0.047885973,
-0.0569555722,
0.0511994325,
0.0579978637,
0.0238391478,
-0.0185274724,
0.001321506,
-0.0277965274,
-0.0049578203,
-0.0204762071,
0.0076296739,
0.0222827327,
-0.0086041847,
0.0267164838,
0.0318867974,
0.0426419601,
0.0247317087,
-0.0433576107,
0.0042267977,
-0.0518527329,
0.0049325358,
0.0308683794,
-0.0187614411,
0.0727438405,
-0.0057190172,
-0.0063277413,
-0.0314239636,
0.0400532261,
0.0242037009,
-0.003975586,
-0.0000143078,
0.0061693299,
-0.0722200871,
-0.0304005295,
0.063757278,
-0.0092311762,
0.0479217172,
-0.0531637669,
-0.046839308,
-0.0170824956,
0.0137262177,
-0.0032672533,
-0.0277309045,
-0.0045692348,
-0.0661932305,
-0.0672817454,
-0.0658028498,
-0.010087247,
0.0142274955,
0.0321730226,
0.0102797262,
0.0074058725,
0.0423010401,
0.0005686246,
-0.0120380381,
-0.0261143371,
-0.0603187121,
-0.0024671534,
-0.0108427107,
-0.0260356367,
-5.128037167e-33,
0.0051354324,
-0.0006700364,
-0.0115132052,
0.0032070032,
0.0059458734,
0.0228886399,
-0.0018532922,
-0.0230162162,
-0.0312336795,
0.0266410708,
0.0055481796,
0.0280383676,
0.010129407,
-0.0064006629,
0.0623366013,
-0.0207822435,
0.056996163,
-0.0240362361,
-0.0515668988,
-0.0266842972,
0.033980187,
-0.0091940649,
0.0724390745,
-0.0908547863,
0.0836724117,
0.0190037247,
-0.0327900015,
-0.0117593557,
-0.0232827794,
0.081189841,
0.012722102,
0.0612376332,
0.0209952444,
-0.0279336572,
-0.0176951624,
-0.028865518,
-0.0501392335,
-0.0246667098,
0.0074406969,
0.0211433936,
-0.0157623831,
-0.0020413578,
0.0719097108,
-0.0196023565,
-0.0466160998,
0.0232618134,
0.059877079,
-0.045180019,
-0.0385192744,
-0.04357481,
-0.0250118226,
0.0615442879,
-0.0151993111,
0.0029698664,
0.0288461,
0.0402341075,
0.0153153231,
0.0206611343,
-0.0728628784,
0.0100076264,
0.0397661887,
-0.0131041072,
0.0304846745,
-0.0124513367,
0.010886264,
0.0783303231,
0.0453540683,
0.0387730226,
0.0401338525,
0.0031227446,
0.0149024585,
0.039221596,
0.0257351641,
0.0848615319,
0.0312915407,
-0.034325812,
-0.0572069213,
0.0359650478,
-0.0363125019,
0.0123922173,
-0.028064752,
-0.028947819,
-0.0380194113,
-0.0368073508,
-0.0665872693,
-0.031823568,
-0.0012207956,
0.0126048652,
0.0099652028,
-0.0001559606,
-0.0134266801,
0.0513329953,
0.0039214501,
-0.033270169,
-0.044040218,
0.0096264975,
-0.0299889073,
0.0127190566,
0.0191209912,
-0.0150392102,
-0.0789471343,
0.003984489,
0.0108053507,
0.0206503719,
0.0605150089,
-0.0116491998,
0.0910201818,
0.0399378426,
-0.0445164517,
0.0094522787,
-0.0016041379,
0.0221350435,
-0.0067988005,
-0.0193329565,
0.021969622,
0.0006675099,
0.0009425215,
0.0325897858,
0.0413884036,
0.0429408848,
-0.044510629,
-0.0020459236,
-0.0104231415,
-0.0285417642,
0.0167388804,
-0.038376946,
0.0090955449,
-0.012628153,
0.0586780012,
-0.0227619745,
0.0019153594,
-0.0241021942,
2.345e-7,
0.0764096901,
0.0580120236,
0.0158593263,
-0.0065154778,
-0.0005120935,
0.0333928615,
-0.0080795418,
0.0153749585,
-0.0064165574,
-0.020628741,
0.0122973667,
-0.0476676673,
0.0400815308,
0.0740993991,
-0.0550474524,
-0.0327746347,
-0.0786759928,
-0.0170325581,
-0.0291157886,
0.0262191128,
0.0296708401,
0.0747905821,
0.0018840051,
-0.031224506,
-0.0226123817,
-0.0114543224,
0.0426488444,
-0.0374913588,
-0.0015715532,
0.0472621247,
0.0930522606,
0.0229427274,
0.0281264819,
0.0318633951,
-0.0304807518,
0.0068960791,
0.0043929876,
0.021792775,
-0.0106347548,
-0.0043691522,
0.0057415529,
-0.0057997741,
0.0023842186,
-0.0238017626,
0.0512256958,
-0.042400822,
-0.0583191998,
-0.0716180205,
-0.037237417,
-0.0147025045,
0.0816955194,
0.0039071785,
0.0271739624,
0.0232043397,
-0.0094888359,
0.0116480459,
-0.0259944573,
-0.0304979198,
-0.0050414051,
0.0147905946,
0.0056865779,
-0.0737654343,
0.0275801551,
-0.0127236182,
0.0155475941,
-0.0677961484,
0.0133014126,
1.822611682e-34,
0.0312727988,
-0.0548261628,
0.0253904201,
-0.0099764485,
0.0182169005,
0.0034756588,
0.0287951604,
-0.0019330077,
-0.0291894265,
0.0151940882,
0.0173867252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08152v1 | The Potential and Pitfalls of using a Large Language Model such as ChatGPT or GPT-4 as a Clinical Assistant | 2023-07-16T21:19:47 | 2023-07-16T21:19:47 | Jingqing Zhang, Kai Sun, Akshay Jagadeesh, Mahta Ghahfarokhi, Deepa Gupta, Ashok Gupta, Vibhor Gupta, Yike Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent studies have demonstrated promising performance of ChatGPT and GPT-4
on several medical domain tasks. However, none have assessed its performance
using a large-scale real-world electronic health record database, nor have
evaluated its utility in providing clinical diagnostic assistance for patients
across a full range of disease presentation. We performed two analyses using
ChatGPT and GPT-4, one to identify patients with specific medical diagnoses
using a real-world large electronic health record database and the other, in
providing diagnostic assistance to healthcare workers in the prospective
evaluation of hypothetical patients. Our results show that GPT-4 across disease
classification tasks with chain of thought and few-shot prompting can achieve
performance as high as 96% F1 scores. For patient assessment, GPT-4 can
accurately diagnose three out of four times. However, there were mentions of
factually incorrect statements, overlooking crucial medical findings,
recommendations for unnecessary investigations and overtreatment. These issues
coupled with privacy concerns, make these models currently inadequate for real
world clinical use. However, limited data and time needed for prompt
engineering in comparison to configuration of conventional machine learning
workflows highlight their potential for scalability across healthcare
applications. | [
0.0502266772,
0.0272918716,
-0.0171910841,
-0.0171176624,
-0.0561006106,
0.0270183478,
0.0319411047,
0.0159112606,
0.0514000431,
-0.0288625248,
0.0091199381,
-0.0427202322,
-0.021401532,
0.0476175807,
-0.0152302822,
-0.0571344234,
0.0339376144,
0.0031987247,
0.0366827324,
0.0172323827,
-0.0067295991,
0.0101839369,
-0.0356030054,
0.0710991323,
-0.0102271708,
-0.0150569379,
0.0017078283,
-0.047828842,
0.0284470841,
-0.0477352366,
-0.0127553744,
0.0497685596,
-0.0260345843,
0.0178226195,
0.0000020718,
-0.0616328716,
-0.0062174681,
0.0312783569,
-0.0565587431,
-0.0476087481,
0.0189894103,
-0.0158181489,
0.0174760576,
0.0441911854,
-0.0379096195,
-0.0583271123,
0.045425918,
0.0422851145,
0.0532741062,
0.0556814447,
-0.0271293838,
0.0046467758,
0.0329893082,
-0.0181341376,
0.0133577669,
-0.0854652449,
0.0550039895,
-0.0127640981,
0.0547434166,
0.001826575,
0.0393015966,
0.0334086791,
-0.0003231361,
0.0369034372,
-0.0200702827,
0.0528998859,
-0.0372847095,
-0.0260219797,
-0.0099898223,
0.0434390865,
0.00891627,
0.0037057321,
0.0076425024,
0.0095450217,
-0.0037251536,
-0.0080646044,
-0.0189903229,
-0.0038781054,
-0.0621617027,
-0.030659752,
0.0026540989,
-0.009494503,
0.0222556703,
-0.0086826952,
0.00440318,
-0.0110235158,
-0.0063331285,
-0.0194652081,
0.0241371263,
0.0037808691,
-0.0205915961,
-0.0582217723,
0.0516576618,
0.0441360474,
-0.0846419856,
-0.0004563358,
-0.0059538023,
0.0185497981,
0.0649759248,
-0.0553031191,
0.0037780476,
0.0170757417,
0.0070404247,
0.0247295108,
0.0099674705,
0.0140082343,
-0.0229513925,
0.0117128631,
-0.0275936686,
-0.0052964995,
-0.0873598829,
-0.0147444224,
-0.0379519425,
0.0111136446,
0.0142878676,
-0.0018787713,
-0.0863005817,
-0.0034020876,
-0.0015360879,
0.0144249089,
0.0258994307,
0.0200747065,
0.0102104889,
0.0341451354,
-0.0290174205,
0.0007105002,
0.0124531677,
0.0129581355,
0.0033637036,
-0.0545042865,
0.0358210243,
-0.0168838445,
-0.0015594416,
0.0077129463,
0.0404481068,
0.0527666323,
0.0193007886,
-0.0385356843,
-0.0104984874,
-0.0309546683,
-0.0337582529,
-0.058098238,
-0.0126380678,
-0.0467256717,
0.0092156492,
0.0537066273,
-0.0048972326,
-0.0024762356,
0.0029421004,
0.0101168612,
-0.0291163903,
0.0535141639,
-0.032460209,
0.0266310051,
0.0272468496,
0.0454271138,
-0.0428293012,
0.0153032569,
-0.0030562496,
-0.0193058252,
-0.010305794,
-0.0462874696,
0.0380995423,
0.0175297298,
-0.0026508532,
-0.0419279225,
0.0172177665,
0.0203301813,
-0.0121536655,
0.0622497238,
-0.0527271293,
0.0754000396,
0.0266689602,
0.0036382859,
0.0488838777,
0.0626158789,
0.0315797925,
0.0182335433,
0.0221527219,
-0.0082554063,
0.0030621463,
-0.0331071131,
-0.0065646241,
-0.0014705549,
-0.0058713262,
-0.0331676789,
-0.0343183018,
0.0062603448,
-0.0309746489,
-0.0323252045,
-0.0555663705,
-0.013856533,
-0.0185476281,
0.0205999576,
0.012485425,
-0.0479587279,
-0.0275982805,
0.0298275258,
0.0269169342,
-0.0108553357,
-0.0482522734,
-0.1105543897,
-0.0065108812,
0.0925474539,
0.0295305513,
-0.0182231646,
-0.0250585712,
-0.0277559012,
0.0061222557,
-0.0061886553,
0.0328301415,
-0.0070705418,
-0.0102566257,
-0.0275747553,
-0.0120506948,
0.0581838302,
0.0179896876,
-0.0193116441,
-0.0150263039,
0.038337741,
-0.0270645265,
-0.0037887001,
-0.0093036219,
0.018800661,
-0.0271759871,
-0.0298368614,
0.0083936732,
0.0176345278,
0.0624810196,
0.0265296064,
-0.000627039,
0.0122161154,
-0.0143930037,
-0.0022075796,
-0.0445565954,
0.0080673266,
-0.029848149,
-0.0034824125,
-0.016689375,
0.0087810485,
-0.0328923985,
-0.0008913652,
-0.0365335718,
-0.0256028324,
-0.0636606291,
-0.0732325017,
0.0097165955,
-0.017697094,
-0.0019410176,
0.0160373896,
-0.0100031719,
-0.0243477561,
0.031320475,
-0.0065659694,
-0.0061603268,
-0.0180188604,
-0.0158846974,
0.0248385612,
-0.0336307958,
-0.0172165614,
0.0020987755,
0.0144797852,
0.0371610783,
-0.0188426133,
0.0070067416,
-0.017008936,
-0.0041538402,
-0.1516565382,
-0.0001389571,
0.0048647183,
-0.0021200716,
0.0262808334,
0.0325280651,
-0.0205942448,
-0.0275273584,
-0.0588085465,
0.0266647507,
0.0539173782,
0.0583595484,
0.018356612,
0.044414781,
-0.0051361965,
-0.0021671974,
0.0090412088,
-0.0528382957,
0.0066920575,
0.0419178084,
-0.0259884764,
-0.0181212053,
0.0044215126,
-0.039672073,
0.0093303826,
0.0031390437,
-0.0128651578,
0.0068066013,
-0.0329899006,
-0.0097861867,
0.0361187682,
-0.0216301847,
0.0228626989,
0.0448028557,
0.0129078319,
-0.0023560827,
0.0191631373,
-0.0300871022,
-0.0454319976,
0.0320855528,
-0.022055313,
0.0022138171,
0.0487244651,
0.0445869081,
0.0085842218,
-0.0401510559,
0.0164087564,
-0.0192294028,
0.0322610848,
-0.0578635819,
-0.014581522,
-0.0241678674,
0.0557823367,
0.0012225523,
-0.0522108376,
0.0920788273,
0.003254819,
0.024386147,
-0.0939031392,
-0.0539229363,
-0.0355995782,
0.0395166203,
-0.009219517,
0.0280291587,
0.0082968213,
-0.0304350965,
0.013781175,
-0.0024700779,
-0.0241143145,
-0.0673477426,
0.0507352799,
-0.0390637033,
0.0344069563,
0.0007241752,
-0.0434050411,
-0.0598456711,
-0.0190847684,
-0.0420967154,
0.0177779905,
-0.0110130552,
0.0081783505,
-0.0554025285,
0.041353479,
0.001510721,
0.086983569,
0.0260991286,
-0.0321682319,
0.0266344156,
-0.0179099385,
0.002835256,
-0.0169245806,
-0.0038817336,
-0.0032529498,
0.0428159237,
0.0618053973,
-0.00612015,
0.0223918855,
-0.013564907,
-0.0092828153,
-0.0218915623,
-0.0386132002,
-0.02695526,
0.0352692939,
0.0107122483,
-0.0589326769,
-0.0077819508,
0.1141359061,
0.0309483372,
-0.0978774577,
0.0037551986,
-0.0141994935,
-0.0454239324,
-0.0298541281,
0.0123291807,
-0.0673492402,
-0.0400016345,
0.004351058,
0.0262296852,
-0.0309577789,
-0.0449904986,
0.020295376,
-0.0292048119,
0.0569392741,
-0.0154250804,
-0.0267354753,
-0.0273002516,
-0.0571012162,
0.017256761,
-0.0102652628,
0.0164266266,
-0.0402445458,
0.0003461454,
-0.0118744886,
-0.0046718298,
-0.0665197074,
-0.0692289695,
0.0862821862,
-0.0111212973,
0.0260472391,
0.0645439997,
0.0344459303,
-0.0092768157,
-0.0248261485,
-0.005967163,
0.0416168608,
0.0383282788,
-0.0132972915,
0.0849958733,
0.0165598374,
0.0052993107,
-0.0819149837,
0.0193601102,
-0.0257499572,
0.0154408645,
0.0389517546,
0.1240578666,
-0.0647862032,
-0.0428928472,
-0.0402647629,
0.0035577167,
0.0527556948,
0.0438031442,
-0.014155915,
-0.0313765481,
-0.0380787291,
0.0383136533,
0.0472029224,
0.0584757477,
-0.0218715761,
0.0276457015,
-0.0081407838,
-0.0315224789,
-0.0413598977,
-0.0367606133,
0.0398499854,
-0.0090613244,
0.0191170368,
0.0309495702,
0.0317914784,
0.0512084551,
-0.0471270941,
0.0479777567,
0.0537732169,
0.0341337435,
-0.0668803528,
-0.0250228886,
0.0755848885,
-0.0002831513,
0.0004708739,
0.0012559416,
0.0013812628,
0.0101523455,
0.0129427649,
0.0379482061,
0.0272085425,
-0.0201488473,
-0.0126160011,
-0.0284680389,
0.0065879123,
0.0328466818,
-0.0502759926,
-0.0160547886,
-0.0069605908,
0.0068147434,
-0.0048084124,
0.0098240227,
-0.0056730974,
0.0402301066,
-0.0130736176,
-0.0160296727,
-0.033043161,
-0.0223130528,
0.025372345,
0.0354793221,
0.0597340986,
0.0030438048,
-0.026150085,
-0.005333377,
0.0129540125,
-0.008491734,
0.0222886037,
-0.0194429047,
-0.0266899336,
0.0276843198,
-0.0087492391,
-0.0027542971,
-0.0421400666,
-0.0626608953,
-0.0735050589,
-0.0533672422,
0.0525065958,
0.0182525087,
0.0144763226,
0.0600038767,
-0.0166398864,
-0.0147369429,
-0.0118373781,
0.0299155712,
0.0089148441,
0.0019598978,
0.1198459566,
-0.0134141659,
0.0307332147,
0.0166215058,
0.0513278693,
-0.039927315,
-0.0781376362,
0.01620166,
0.0485920608,
0.0229633208,
0.0159081686,
0.0014306544,
-0.0485994853,
0.0113129308,
-0.0273955557,
0.0079839155,
-0.019927986,
-0.0017620286,
0.0466736332,
0.0073025278,
-0.0078008864,
-0.0158036351,
0.0631911084,
-0.019383017,
0.0454330407,
0.0073946444,
-0.0679015815,
-0.0550895967,
-0.0317480788,
0.0266166423,
-0.006078626,
-0.0677849352,
0.0164078847,
-0.0732001215,
-0.0448844805,
0.0004025472,
-0.0329137258,
-0.0149813239,
-0.0324922688,
0.0585814752,
0.0640080497,
0.016997749,
-0.0423839577,
-0.0319679789,
0.034376204,
-0.0338400565,
-0.0027940804,
0.0036204772,
-5.744629505e-33,
0.020901043,
-0.0283238515,
0.0452766791,
-0.0064713564,
0.0453027152,
0.0319739841,
-0.026304666,
0.0141580747,
-0.0076558385,
0.0374608859,
-0.03022331,
-0.0002579518,
0.0125791784,
0.0250880253,
0.0181771312,
-0.02466131,
0.0446553826,
0.0060012932,
-0.0116270678,
0.0558472946,
0.0064922809,
0.0347027071,
0.0265065189,
-0.0908756033,
0.0025466364,
0.0034590675,
0.0142694199,
0.0302875191,
-0.0621684082,
0.0426997691,
-0.0342435166,
0.0540229529,
0.0686622858,
0.0146754738,
0.0137786744,
0.0425902568,
-0.0354893282,
-0.0307641681,
0.0041747666,
-0.010668518,
-0.0094634052,
-0.0007039105,
0.0303857941,
-0.0280204043,
-0.0311089978,
-0.004028155,
0.0133349774,
-0.0296612903,
-0.0055166194,
-0.0208654981,
-0.0078869946,
0.0276276022,
0.0075628194,
-0.0172484312,
-0.009572166,
0.0234731399,
-0.0730829313,
-0.0292825121,
-0.0360952727,
-0.0126927672,
0.0328045338,
-0.0286716297,
-0.0040108436,
-0.0208397117,
-0.0432376936,
0.042929288,
0.0580734946,
-0.0283450224,
-0.0671958998,
0.0197833478,
-0.0641037226,
0.0364397578,
0.070569545,
0.0117686158,
-0.0006677306,
-0.0117550148,
-0.0820055678,
0.0240817405,
-0.027235074,
0.0424933732,
0.0474820621,
-0.042798277,
-0.0872891247,
-0.021272365,
-0.0177663192,
0.0340558141,
-0.03736718,
-0.0375406295,
0.053279385,
-0.0094861891,
0.0242812783,
-0.0003620441,
0.018490525,
-0.0013510128,
0.0064066164,
-0.0120309731,
0.0472645201,
0.0054838699,
-0.0235730968,
-0.0013447378,
-0.071725972,
-0.0079651065,
0.0065564015,
0.0187056977,
0.0422125868,
0.0014835509,
0.0202212427,
-0.0088493759,
-0.0440323837,
-0.0057144347,
0.0168773308,
0.0409945697,
-0.0081954226,
0.0253691152,
0.0362116098,
0.0103442483,
0.0030031113,
0.0760610998,
-0.0003271504,
-0.0062227044,
-0.0511275679,
-0.025248941,
-0.0390176103,
-0.0221716464,
-0.0323631875,
0.0009778787,
-0.0388213135,
0.0524389446,
0.0357452184,
-0.0468237698,
0.0118393712,
-0.0018259112,
2.844e-7,
0.071549423,
0.0565946549,
-0.0076471134,
-0.0121355159,
0.0265335478,
0.0212867986,
0.0033862882,
0.0159971062,
0.0347534642,
0.0112914965,
0.0327515863,
0.018401226,
0.0305582844,
0.0542384982,
-0.0466408804,
-0.0458625406,
-0.0667390004,
-0.0068142419,
-0.0469456911,
0.0168147907,
0.0749918446,
0.0692135096,
-0.0193899404,
-0.0522765368,
0.032861758,
-0.013881539,
0.0378507823,
-0.026906047,
0.009390736,
0.0151975229,
0.0322161056,
0.004121989,
0.0330849513,
0.0940351635,
-0.0049567954,
-0.0295146927,
-0.0238241684,
0.0973718911,
-0.0642880276,
0.0384193547,
0.0064770081,
-0.0104411561,
0.0332640931,
-0.0607158802,
0.0661260113,
-0.0654935911,
-0.0482796021,
0.0090724351,
0.0135708731,
-0.0527673177,
0.0662293658,
-0.0265980065,
-0.0436605439,
0.0289756395,
0.0051500234,
0.0160775296,
-0.0128767053,
-0.0614518821,
0.0142099215,
0.0244629346,
-0.0316663906,
-0.0349538252,
0.0429868326,
-0.0209784806,
0.0146047445,
-0.0746378079,
0.038906686,
2.459155993e-34,
0.0034313502,
0.0191825069,
0.0150381988,
0.0070207566,
0.0114623355,
0.0288877282,
0.0652856827,
0.0149834082,
0.0253926292,
-0.0516949184,
-0.0115996944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08139v1 | It's All Relative: Interpretable Models for Scoring Bias in Documents | 2023-07-16T19:35:38 | 2023-07-16T19:35:38 | Aswin Suresh, Chi-Hsuan Wu, Matthias Grossglauser | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose an interpretable model to score the bias present in web documents,
based only on their textual content. Our model incorporates assumptions
reminiscent of the Bradley-Terry axioms and is trained on pairs of revisions of
the same Wikipedia article, where one version is more biased than the other.
While prior approaches based on absolute bias classification have struggled to
obtain a high accuracy for the task, we are able to develop a useful model for
scoring bias by learning to perform pairwise comparisons of bias accurately. We
show that we can interpret the parameters of the trained model to discover the
words most indicative of bias. We also apply our model in three different
settings - studying the temporal evolution of bias in Wikipedia articles,
comparing news sources based on bias, and scoring bias in law amendments. In
each case, we demonstrate that the outputs of the model can be explained and
validated, even for the two domains that are outside the training-data domain.
We also use the model to compare the general level of bias between domains,
where we see that legal texts are the least biased and news media are the most
biased, with Wikipedia articles in between. Given its high performance,
simplicity, interpretability, and wide applicability, we hope the model will be
useful for a large community, including Wikipedia and news editors, political
and social scientists, and the general public. | [
0.0530011207,
0.0382382348,
-0.0151516246,
-0.0020326497,
-0.0423802584,
0.0578683428,
0.0201598909,
0.0269903336,
0.0337772593,
-0.0925739557,
0.0117102675,
0.0183529835,
0.0280293077,
-0.0132947033,
-0.0403257906,
-0.0382943787,
0.0371175446,
0.0323243216,
0.0947038978,
-0.0265986361,
0.0358012132,
0.0097383019,
-0.022520477,
0.0308277495,
-0.0273071807,
0.0126792667,
0.0405446701,
0.011862929,
-0.0020986099,
0.0211132392,
0.0058935289,
0.0689800307,
-0.0224732887,
0.0508761071,
0.0000016823,
-0.0307613816,
-0.0023793937,
0.0001086326,
-0.0034122274,
-0.0029538737,
0.0874576047,
-0.0333735049,
-0.0120472061,
0.0051479694,
-0.0053075496,
-0.0165409464,
0.0414647758,
0.0090396842,
0.056780573,
0.0618078709,
-0.0047172615,
-0.0535560139,
0.0009270339,
0.0132555999,
0.0500382669,
-0.034530703,
0.0449593589,
-0.0004098419,
-0.1006282344,
-0.0126330266,
-0.0062110377,
-0.018161932,
0.0081881881,
-0.0192418657,
0.0261276793,
-0.0096422676,
-0.0107582156,
-0.0312266368,
0.0253660921,
0.036282409,
0.031347774,
-0.0374626406,
0.026098555,
-0.0133500248,
0.0444815345,
0.0414320938,
-0.0219934937,
0.0183654148,
-0.0098861195,
0.0022373553,
0.039562691,
0.0059905662,
0.0206381362,
0.0788173154,
-0.0207564048,
0.020883074,
0.0025626998,
-0.0175596196,
0.0165057145,
0.0493611433,
0.0522915237,
-0.0203173906,
0.0169812366,
-0.000056889,
0.0225097258,
0.0141065158,
-0.0390908718,
-0.0042708525,
0.0517918281,
-0.0825269297,
-0.021227058,
-0.0350823998,
-0.0393728241,
0.0803595558,
0.0070225941,
-0.0374387354,
0.0181131363,
-0.0051246136,
0.0136251207,
0.0024748708,
-0.0291133169,
0.0248809792,
0.0298246052,
0.002987565,
0.0046797534,
0.0131003875,
-0.0261494666,
0.0037155687,
-0.03460503,
0.0303345919,
0.0077098887,
-0.0154683944,
-0.0316100083,
-0.0162585583,
-0.0474348739,
0.024089219,
-0.0281724874,
0.074820742,
-0.0534436516,
-0.0227798615,
0.0163589437,
0.0182826947,
0.008617864,
-0.0185128823,
-0.0059413277,
0.0424181335,
0.0301395599,
0.0129052643,
-0.0244312398,
-0.0412067436,
-0.0031938017,
-0.0280692391,
-0.0064814314,
-0.03022095,
0.0053807669,
0.0023158458,
-0.0013176905,
-0.0343220495,
-0.0366174504,
-0.0059373248,
-0.061850749,
0.0411172584,
0.0056129447,
-0.0221418403,
0.0483212806,
0.0131019764,
-0.027013259,
0.0834504366,
0.000869894,
0.0457461439,
0.064639613,
0.0271504056,
0.016018115,
0.0060873469,
0.0283534806,
0.0338265821,
0.0183110442,
0.0343020037,
-0.0082797892,
-0.0002195983,
0.0064834221,
0.0063919523,
-0.0151935667,
-0.0240281541,
0.0780895278,
-0.0255034845,
0.0150575899,
0.0108877886,
-0.0069542415,
0.0032829598,
0.0178087372,
0.0329406336,
-0.0742142648,
-0.0067567686,
-0.0112069044,
-0.0394884869,
-0.0091789309,
0.0053693969,
-0.0077483021,
-0.0279296841,
0.0088592032,
-0.0113376994,
-0.0236348696,
-0.0473359823,
0.043803405,
0.0147302449,
-0.033772938,
0.0683777258,
0.0310420077,
-0.0151932519,
0.055051744,
-0.0279119089,
-0.0050584232,
0.0193058439,
-0.0093178581,
-0.0548830144,
0.0305108335,
-0.042077858,
0.0096514104,
0.0057120384,
0.0649114475,
-0.0415470116,
-0.0257688779,
-0.0399104021,
-0.0373298489,
-0.0084621338,
0.0610687695,
0.0311065316,
-0.0009291122,
0.0446260124,
0.0149049871,
-0.0666757822,
-0.0330927297,
0.0431770869,
0.0626954734,
-0.0069818404,
-0.0170138702,
0.0249984358,
0.0055007283,
0.0358815081,
-0.0285065342,
-0.024383001,
-0.0013269325,
0.0289178845,
0.0010179466,
-0.0075239679,
0.0027555877,
-0.0054465942,
0.0015657588,
-0.0586003661,
-0.0071397023,
0.022522347,
-0.046389509,
0.0116710076,
0.017786881,
-0.0308948886,
0.0005313787,
-0.0011569933,
-0.0248798933,
-0.0521123931,
-0.0243153051,
-0.049510181,
0.0580359623,
-0.0018151032,
-0.0140007585,
0.0272760466,
-0.0817188025,
0.0033448732,
0.0099138338,
-0.0266977604,
-0.0154384971,
0.0036140147,
0.0272174142,
0.0456933528,
-0.0635251552,
-0.0345342308,
-0.0500383191,
-0.033551611,
-0.0171619598,
-0.0319974609,
0.0173681602,
0.0311662834,
-0.0480531491,
0.0073764008,
-0.0289798211,
-0.0211483389,
-0.0447180234,
-0.015003589,
0.0283209737,
0.0119694462,
0.0028096053,
0.0144551834,
-0.0293851402,
-0.0320890956,
-0.0365297534,
0.0760093629,
0.0816828534,
-0.0109839244,
-0.0565136038,
0.0077993656,
-0.0059901993,
-0.0431816466,
-0.0143754659,
0.0023628422,
0.002105145,
0.0124138333,
-0.0758658722,
0.058992371,
0.0546941236,
0.0325301513,
0.0142095406,
0.0037705014,
-0.0579502881,
-0.0737867206,
-0.0343267359,
0.0404550284,
-0.0431002006,
-0.0356134996,
0.0240608081,
0.0222702641,
0.0335777141,
0.0112682143,
-0.0287274104,
0.076780647,
-0.0273801498,
-0.0218978655,
0.0086975032,
-0.0342014991,
0.0207338557,
0.0274335705,
-0.0243320931,
-0.070868291,
0.0480220728,
0.0119422618,
0.0947971046,
-0.0414712019,
0.0455064364,
-0.017545281,
0.0004343004,
0.004222034,
0.0277063083,
-0.0014350391,
-0.0277220365,
-0.0296297111,
0.0036819321,
0.0944727361,
-0.0407690927,
0.0183776245,
-0.0271899235,
-0.0087620504,
-0.014340302,
-0.0223926194,
-0.0138858147,
-0.0436278246,
0.0316486098,
-0.0156130176,
0.0209213104,
0.0290485676,
-0.0368002057,
-0.0101907412,
-0.0199397895,
-0.012260328,
-0.0310122594,
0.0049656252,
0.0319530703,
0.0433660671,
0.0005405239,
-0.0477699675,
0.0294546671,
0.0212234389,
-0.0369972065,
0.0227338877,
0.0002716623,
0.0495063663,
-0.015909601,
-0.0077072321,
-0.0122585371,
-0.093706876,
-0.0115362285,
-0.0363802128,
-0.0104188398,
-0.0430385247,
0.0426799804,
0.0948181376,
0.0121280616,
-0.103083767,
-0.0401560478,
0.009410888,
-0.0541415736,
0.020705713,
-0.027535107,
-0.108278133,
0.0108144796,
0.0184788443,
0.0352002867,
-0.033139579,
-0.04807337,
0.0202696845,
-0.0684508234,
0.0135204261,
-0.0003292066,
0.0204653274,
-0.0004985991,
-0.0729291886,
0.0117732985,
-0.0671863258,
-0.0363805853,
0.0205730796,
0.0283688474,
0.0344160087,
0.0055292714,
-0.0300585497,
-0.0748507828,
-0.0187657103,
-0.027604118,
0.0492483974,
0.0258987658,
0.0538786277,
-0.0470265932,
0.015343098,
0.0429317169,
-0.0159003418,
-0.0140546439,
-0.0439582877,
0.1128226519,
-0.0403595343,
-0.0097760018,
-0.0135753732,
0.0374763981,
0.0643347502,
0.0188250393,
-0.0079018828,
0.0237507783,
0.0279989224,
-0.0299596339,
-0.0468203165,
-0.0603783876,
0.042386692,
0.0464966409,
0.0269713681,
0.0005218596,
-0.0219447054,
-0.0472418331,
0.0080649694,
0.0049304273,
-0.0235945899,
-0.0011842661,
0.0123241069,
-0.0347656012,
-0.059471149,
-0.0484130308,
-0.0562750921,
0.025614528,
0.0200767536,
-0.0255621038,
-0.0063231336,
-0.0324325971,
-0.0488152504,
0.0017225867,
-0.0045727552,
-0.012836379,
0.0135917608,
-0.0467117801,
0.0053008124,
-0.0210358016,
-0.0491025113,
-0.0348346643,
-0.0001384422,
-0.0204730127,
0.0547553748,
0.0384830423,
0.0227902532,
0.0330523178,
-0.02433745,
-0.0456498452,
0.0756618977,
0.0562525503,
-0.0516533926,
-0.0216170922,
0.032841146,
-0.0290456526,
0.0059253583,
0.0119739641,
-0.0537489541,
0.0233611614,
0.0064224177,
-0.0455117412,
-0.0301753841,
0.0168223064,
-0.0179035794,
-0.0038935954,
0.0575158857,
0.0127523644,
0.0151239587,
-0.0436434597,
-0.0145821515,
0.0247842558,
-0.0596520863,
0.0379164815,
0.0002987318,
0.0186267402,
0.0059719798,
-0.0580971912,
0.0539365821,
-0.0355550237,
-0.0011005505,
-0.0715446323,
0.0366396569,
0.056856472,
0.0563076101,
-0.0335499123,
-0.0213896222,
-0.046252694,
-0.0003545194,
-0.004985767,
0.0235725809,
0.0092722503,
-0.0071681258,
0.0251380298,
0.0079011116,
0.0198639035,
-0.0129440995,
-0.0743051916,
0.0248048287,
-0.0184009019,
-0.0127446987,
0.0378409103,
-0.0345310904,
0.0241737161,
0.0112095205,
-0.0282330923,
0.0218208469,
-0.0081680957,
0.0736629367,
-0.0085004894,
0.0345912464,
0.0125300689,
-0.0161297657,
0.0500546545,
0.0324519314,
-0.0080507686,
0.0592415221,
-0.0378267691,
-0.0741862878,
-0.0203933604,
-0.0227896869,
0.0143840918,
-0.0043188166,
-0.0167531781,
-0.0471723936,
-0.0446551219,
-0.0115387719,
0.0113578625,
-0.0037188488,
0.0616796985,
0.0118503245,
-0.0327106528,
0.0741553083,
0.0184162632,
-0.0066206623,
-0.0283100773,
0.0078663053,
-0.0701586753,
0.0007322454,
-0.0015727587,
-5.195232465e-33,
0.005119469,
-0.0115440059,
-0.0495630354,
0.0017098051,
0.0065843356,
0.0055047097,
-0.010295351,
-0.0314624123,
-0.057180699,
0.0351046957,
0.0277743377,
0.0378140248,
0.0216999445,
-0.0457681604,
-0.0002936521,
-0.0462722667,
0.0328183733,
0.000193386,
-0.025081085,
0.0116429767,
-0.0219896249,
-0.0088924291,
0.0520806052,
-0.0733179525,
0.0992725044,
0.0129260076,
-0.027868595,
-0.0218710639,
0.0124975611,
0.0535262153,
0.0184592959,
0.0584926903,
0.0459276661,
-0.0515392683,
0.0021063599,
0.0200087987,
-0.0181011911,
-0.0032502625,
0.0209108628,
0.0307088327,
0.0455649793,
-0.000266201,
0.0681558996,
0.0239230823,
-0.0533386059,
-0.0402213074,
0.0782267377,
-0.0449690633,
0.0258108899,
-0.0156478453,
-0.0304506272,
0.0437707938,
-0.0291999262,
0.0457167141,
-0.0199958291,
0.0025198774,
0.0576157905,
0.0569618195,
-0.0680242777,
0.0267331973,
0.0078202309,
0.0244347043,
0.0099932356,
-0.0468526073,
-0.0182593837,
0.0861591399,
0.071785152,
0.0357259586,
-0.0411957093,
-0.0260843486,
0.0134072723,
-0.0139721343,
0.038572941,
0.1086275727,
0.0393668339,
-0.0287416559,
-0.0802657977,
0.0071611539,
0.0434535742,
0.0464106537,
0.0392799266,
-0.0368972421,
-0.0450603813,
0.0131956488,
-0.0705729499,
-0.1074410528,
-0.0444646887,
0.0091541791,
-0.0011279865,
0.0211496055,
-0.0262517035,
0.0267358478,
-0.0183554851,
-0.0422077067,
-0.0164813548,
0.0665948093,
-0.0423741676,
0.0164613519,
-0.0053288112,
-0.0232264809,
-0.0473493598,
0.0005743004,
0.00728956,
0.0404293649,
0.0523933358,
-0.0161399301,
0.0279555302,
-0.0021107013,
-0.0293368679,
0.0053349524,
0.0000535732,
-0.0352474377,
0.008568164,
0.0322976261,
0.0414968543,
-0.0142366337,
-0.0002820292,
0.0012525226,
0.0086820433,
0.0260122623,
0.0027123813,
-0.0305934474,
-0.020839449,
0.0193813685,
-0.0271114074,
-0.0401615798,
0.0442336872,
0.0181751586,
-0.0355033912,
-0.0473646037,
0.0054050405,
-0.0060423673,
2.411e-7,
0.049195122,
0.0701231211,
-0.0034666543,
-0.0099928128,
0.0301403273,
0.0365899205,
0.0208674204,
0.0423081219,
-0.0045011775,
-0.0254142974,
-0.0065525663,
0.0006472165,
-0.0116616255,
0.0310516227,
-0.0504039712,
-0.0384128056,
-0.0510738939,
0.0529691875,
-0.0296213664,
0.0173450075,
0.0426222309,
0.0251806155,
0.0083620101,
-0.011455928,
-0.0083062416,
-0.0055634789,
0.0383400843,
-0.0190600418,
0.0135779474,
0.0258291215,
0.0635098591,
-0.0343328789,
0.02028789,
0.0365067534,
-0.022371918,
0.0048273094,
-0.0143969338,
0.0390054248,
0.0105214389,
0.0347526968,
-0.0097690327,
-0.0211461335,
0.0323853195,
-0.0750022605,
0.0724388957,
0.0374873504,
-0.0224645622,
-0.071671471,
-0.0674276128,
-0.0541984774,
0.0513182953,
0.0015556414,
-0.0181313772,
-0.0015835296,
-0.0209389236,
0.0388215445,
0.0104653258,
-0.059936095,
-0.0166634042,
-0.0331535563,
-0.0085571595,
-0.0390771478,
0.0218892377,
0.0350626446,
0.0135397175,
-0.0254447125,
0.0459664948,
1.59338397e-34,
0.0588072725,
-0.027091315,
0.0129776374,
-0.0297599547,
0.0171765015,
0.0266565979,
-0.016298065,
-0.037716601,
0.0045565525,
-0.0287693609,
0.0091693075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08074v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08074v2 | Disco-Bench: A Discourse-Aware Evaluation Benchmark for Language Modelling | 2023-07-16T15:18:25 | 2023-07-22T00:11:24 | Longyue Wang, Zefeng Du, Donghuai Liu, Deng Cai, Dian Yu, Haiyun Jiang, Yan Wang, Leyang Cui, Shuming Shi, Zhaopeng Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modeling discourse -- the linguistic phenomena that go beyond individual
sentences, is a fundamental yet challenging aspect of natural language
processing (NLP). However, existing evaluation benchmarks primarily focus on
the evaluation of inter-sentence properties and overlook critical discourse
phenomena that cross sentences. To bridge the gap, we propose Disco-Bench, a
benchmark that can evaluate intra-sentence discourse properties across a
diverse set of NLP tasks, covering understanding, translation, and generation.
Disco-Bench consists of 9 document-level testsets in the literature domain,
which contain rich discourse phenomena (e.g. cohesion and coherence) in Chinese
and/or English. For linguistic analysis, we also design a diagnostic test suite
that can examine whether the target models learn discourse knowledge. We
totally evaluate 20 general-, in-domain and commercial models based on
Transformer, advanced pretraining architectures and large language models
(LLMs). Our results show (1) the challenge and necessity of our evaluation
benchmark; (2) fine-grained pretraining based on literary document-level
training data consistently improves the modeling of discourse information. We
will release the datasets, pretrained models, and leaderboard, which we hope
can significantly facilitate research in this field:
https://github.com/longyuewangdcu/Disco-Bench. | [
0.0084453998,
0.0586049557,
0.0078229802,
0.049644351,
-0.0431163274,
-0.0150572201,
0.0143256197,
-0.0187605452,
-0.0129172094,
-0.0512300804,
-0.0441111699,
-0.0299572926,
0.0170528814,
-0.0011327057,
-0.0066254525,
-0.0300294589,
0.0254949853,
-0.0095542623,
0.0181620177,
-0.0029982277,
0.0155589236,
-0.0040561021,
-0.0005811509,
0.0200187881,
-0.0224157926,
-0.062951237,
-0.0073170848,
0.0265058577,
0.0355412737,
-0.0439834595,
0.0592351481,
0.0377727486,
-0.0142828533,
0.04354278,
0.0000020521,
-0.0378865637,
-0.011548127,
-0.0183304902,
-0.0006027066,
0.0513560809,
0.053522002,
0.0060976371,
0.0021734615,
0.0024172566,
-0.0524126254,
0.0146620125,
-0.0021527375,
0.0958648175,
0.0663809553,
0.0928055644,
-0.0153684048,
-0.0403517559,
0.0033966894,
-0.0211583469,
-0.0718443692,
-0.0668140277,
0.0000805192,
0.0385934561,
-0.0039692423,
0.033923503,
-0.0200530868,
0.0326371901,
0.0204755701,
-0.0054316721,
0.0059219557,
0.0382988676,
-0.0606884807,
-0.0032315666,
-0.0249351375,
0.0678904131,
0.0510968938,
-0.0208857246,
-0.0005409068,
0.0059811007,
-0.0128914006,
-0.0353627242,
-0.0012447271,
0.0136893187,
0.0000682297,
0.0598631799,
0.0464023799,
0.0258053653,
0.0051160315,
0.0186816752,
-0.0083082579,
0.0378852896,
0.0131446207,
-0.005918195,
0.0134684611,
0.0119221015,
-0.0570667572,
-0.0498220846,
-0.0024874466,
0.0180087425,
-0.0556274876,
-0.008924705,
-0.0408613756,
-0.0314916894,
0.024199985,
-0.0461307503,
0.0729094669,
0.0147460895,
-0.0272021983,
0.0205012485,
-0.0125746997,
0.0856259093,
-0.0022369782,
-0.0293300394,
-0.0371281132,
0.0009749628,
-0.029251013,
-0.0176226981,
-0.0372439735,
0.0343388394,
-0.0781504661,
-0.0472677238,
-0.0445002541,
-0.0152364373,
0.011089908,
-0.0061333496,
0.0242519453,
0.0297686215,
-0.0484106429,
0.0147768334,
-0.0139100272,
0.0287459269,
-0.0430946536,
0.0232024156,
0.0097961845,
-0.0417842679,
-0.0105465567,
0.028694937,
-0.0061877053,
-0.0140659055,
0.0055041597,
0.0422530733,
-0.0196190402,
-0.0188490599,
-0.0137783969,
-0.0258343685,
-0.028566571,
-0.0784353465,
0.0046269116,
-0.0602363721,
-0.0080573773,
-0.0137683181,
0.0176831111,
-0.0515879057,
0.0328289904,
0.0197725371,
0.0035555186,
0.0432989262,
0.0132648954,
0.0006239532,
0.0160991326,
0.0220257696,
0.0505571626,
0.066449739,
0.0493293963,
-0.0009831958,
0.0482782498,
0.0132099148,
-0.0131630395,
0.0217323843,
-0.0039101047,
-0.0203712806,
0.0148174474,
0.0224367883,
-0.0287394375,
0.0324867256,
0.0129480008,
0.0610534921,
-0.0257360786,
-0.0442291945,
0.0644637868,
0.033310812,
-0.0409437157,
-0.0048368559,
0.0575709939,
0.0225882512,
0.0213434026,
0.0412898548,
0.0023181953,
-0.0150292031,
0.0221820269,
0.0119898561,
0.0323562473,
0.0265364423,
-0.0293522552,
-0.056533806,
-0.0067277341,
-0.0012787805,
0.0048134667,
-0.0555044338,
0.0121663036,
0.0302073155,
-0.0512902029,
0.0451256484,
0.0333486907,
-0.0668523684,
-0.0214784294,
-0.0021787419,
-0.0193250049,
0.0210789591,
0.0382527113,
-0.0191987772,
-0.0411414094,
0.0052394141,
0.0444356427,
0.0702582076,
0.019531833,
-0.0032131888,
0.0250656232,
-0.0348783322,
0.0184691045,
-0.0736201108,
0.0411221646,
0.0331270359,
0.0106237307,
-0.009495886,
0.0080723632,
-0.0285903886,
-0.0593150295,
0.0347360559,
-0.05524721,
-0.0265557803,
0.0196922123,
-0.0185587183,
0.0312117953,
0.0147963874,
-0.0389992893,
0.0070479205,
0.0429537371,
-0.0458641686,
0.0009777716,
0.0616542287,
-0.0444309823,
-0.0553771369,
0.0489434786,
-0.08804214,
-0.0287486203,
0.0400847942,
-0.0408564806,
-0.0540463515,
0.0383301154,
-0.0110221971,
-0.0248268135,
-0.0434297435,
0.025721373,
-0.0058883931,
0.0241477378,
0.0034073326,
0.0528766401,
0.0053336001,
0.0183815211,
0.0132705336,
-0.0111397952,
0.0350212008,
-0.0136652319,
-0.0372067168,
-0.0175596122,
-0.000226231,
0.0256543681,
0.029918367,
0.0215413962,
-0.0412029102,
-0.0476610772,
-0.152289018,
0.042567607,
-0.0345019624,
0.0315633453,
0.0497674718,
-0.0236240085,
-0.0092352536,
-0.004112402,
-0.0168774407,
-0.0348830037,
0.0148602668,
-0.0145262619,
0.0581883043,
-0.0272869878,
0.0286964513,
-0.0445671529,
0.0191611052,
-0.0069503915,
0.051532086,
0.0038577551,
0.0333727077,
-0.0116634741,
0.0081871804,
-0.0230492875,
-0.0122143803,
-0.0124533083,
-0.0644836649,
0.0330751725,
0.0507509969,
0.1054854617,
0.0618850365,
0.0376187675,
0.0524568669,
0.0083158556,
-0.032083638,
-0.0190010555,
0.0306086466,
-0.0167312715,
0.0228011832,
-0.0531670712,
-0.0121171763,
-0.0065795612,
0.0874443352,
-0.0007934417,
-0.0150789609,
-0.0305628311,
0.0343598984,
-0.0344359539,
-0.0241612885,
0.0040983129,
-0.0005544836,
-0.0089845322,
0.0005501815,
-0.0545701869,
0.0110119935,
0.0420731492,
-0.075551413,
-0.0156729631,
-0.0638430864,
0.0006301464,
-0.0404007584,
0.0683916658,
0.0105705792,
-0.0045295036,
0.0212125219,
-0.0017714993,
-0.0090225572,
0.0105620138,
0.0260990541,
-0.0301665496,
0.0526410975,
-0.0463007167,
-0.0085514067,
-0.0089945998,
-0.0475505814,
-0.0433511958,
-0.0470069461,
-0.0226808432,
0.028829528,
0.0098437173,
-0.0099580185,
-0.0071944706,
-0.0059356336,
-0.0065864804,
0.0336655825,
-0.0348651037,
-0.0064711613,
-0.040451616,
0.0602817424,
0.0336791202,
0.0184955113,
0.0157808978,
-0.0516058616,
0.0364757143,
0.0457394458,
-0.0257326625,
0.0114252958,
-0.0652083904,
0.0046065049,
-0.0277727246,
-0.0416210927,
-0.0192758646,
-0.0184243321,
0.098415263,
-0.0454656444,
-0.0543412082,
0.1234212965,
0.0061809686,
0.0068333019,
0.00418719,
0.0023926804,
0.0420444235,
0.0256577246,
-0.0107412888,
-0.070200406,
-0.0200900063,
0.0067531047,
-0.001164631,
0.0008029575,
-0.0421858877,
-0.0062570679,
-0.0952237248,
0.0313436016,
-0.0157848299,
0.0229670852,
0.0239868108,
-0.0268350355,
0.0088501144,
0.0058719171,
0.0362905748,
-0.0164089985,
-0.0226979665,
0.004907581,
0.0107192229,
-0.0100874426,
-0.0368602499,
0.0184508581,
-0.038628187,
0.0306302346,
0.0087562744,
0.0863427222,
0.006776975,
0.0205292646,
0.0219992194,
-0.0546340235,
-0.023284385,
0.0199896079,
0.0531047955,
0.0109623568,
-0.011675355,
-0.0078715077,
0.0494135693,
-0.0363220498,
-0.0177427381,
0.0274000317,
-0.0001827255,
-0.0136449719,
-0.0354038328,
-0.0115681076,
0.0470788665,
0.0020147332,
0.0873245448,
0.0631254986,
-0.0267001819,
-0.0519903563,
-0.0156826805,
0.0145357829,
-0.0540458448,
-0.0216413774,
-0.0053406367,
0.0269917026,
0.0218502302,
-0.0976886675,
-0.0666740239,
-0.033417955,
0.0126153473,
0.0187043604,
0.0059273634,
0.0192966852,
-0.025350349,
-0.0341479182,
0.0236708522,
-0.0195514392,
-0.0126279574,
-0.0537437499,
0.0090945875,
0.0460663475,
-0.0228425469,
-0.0215488579,
-0.0148799941,
-0.0570314899,
-0.0770143569,
0.0012658642,
0.0248489641,
0.0102771018,
0.05024454,
-0.0371241197,
-0.0006360997,
0.0302793831,
0.0345465019,
-0.0432961695,
0.0649652481,
0.0622434914,
-0.0208353139,
-0.0127648916,
0.039985463,
0.022109054,
0.0510444231,
0.001494961,
0.0408189557,
0.0002862772,
-0.0469286777,
0.0130328909,
0.0023346569,
0.0370555595,
-0.014152484,
0.0160785411,
-0.0405615829,
0.0094323969,
-0.0517779626,
-0.0456817113,
-0.0403611362,
0.003352049,
0.0336533003,
0.0209076386,
-0.0491284095,
0.0256802738,
-0.0072188349,
0.0598231889,
-0.0198393762,
-0.0072785337,
0.0160412081,
-0.0054278444,
-0.0393531621,
-0.0103457617,
-0.0100909267,
-0.0174698681,
-0.0342973955,
0.0678754076,
-0.0092785256,
0.0603013299,
0.0236917958,
-0.000673435,
0.0267813858,
0.0215053037,
-0.0680198744,
0.0573882796,
-0.0101103196,
-0.0088090152,
0.0778646246,
-0.0302274209,
0.1002681628,
-0.0263816528,
0.012551453,
-0.0335983336,
0.076237306,
0.0090495348,
-0.0191214196,
-0.0288539901,
0.0063588289,
-0.0226128455,
0.0314308517,
0.0827800333,
0.0019014213,
0.0266050026,
0.0801397786,
0.0061651971,
-0.0516413264,
-0.0696874484,
-0.0246768147,
-0.0234986432,
0.0166480094,
0.0254632477,
-0.0369555801,
-0.0223147646,
0.075365074,
0.0133267185,
0.0219606441,
-0.0180879179,
0.0143950926,
0.0514659211,
0.0030964664,
0.016519811,
-0.0698065609,
-0.0205427203,
-0.0160304718,
0.0068907803,
-0.0492710844,
-6.653615409e-33,
-0.067223981,
-0.0076836515,
0.0149962772,
0.0175571963,
-0.043042697,
0.0298810564,
-0.0810684562,
-0.0077918414,
0.0189777371,
0.0581424721,
-0.0171906222,
0.0207048934,
0.007337783,
0.040995568,
-0.0267924387,
-0.0068691727,
0.067335248,
0.0048506246,
-0.0513034873,
0.0185813513,
0.0428787209,
0.0235029645,
0.0473443158,
-0.0128793959,
-0.0210957713,
-0.0251389015,
-0.0160635542,
0.013515234,
0.0054920977,
0.0442219712,
-0.0207059216,
0.0188543666,
0.034864258,
0.0013734234,
-0.0023490386,
0.000578717,
-0.0914649069,
-0.0418450274,
0.0256277435,
0.0032688086,
-0.0230643004,
-0.0230440386,
0.0135189481,
-0.0030943048,
0.0147134233,
-0.0204053205,
0.036505878,
-0.009215232,
0.0176873934,
-0.0375715718,
-0.0926283747,
0.0177529063,
-0.0357385278,
-0.017718114,
0.0102882423,
0.0265586227,
-0.0095484825,
-0.0188805312,
-0.0613681972,
-0.0110384226,
-0.0087228436,
0.0468755141,
-0.0161697995,
-0.0075386427,
-0.0077742455,
0.0917676389,
-0.0361826159,
0.0045723268,
-0.0317214057,
0.0314083956,
0.0312743485,
0.0427537374,
0.0201176461,
0.027263606,
-0.0002503413,
0.0259990431,
-0.0766760185,
0.0214907136,
-0.0011729451,
0.0281581171,
0.0360225029,
-0.0287231486,
0.0116722006,
0.0018442358,
-0.0584122874,
-0.0004956823,
0.0025725493,
-0.0019517558,
0.0192495752,
-0.0038597663,
-0.0350032225,
-0.0211609509,
0.0139352372,
-0.0416423641,
-0.023576159,
0.0371615402,
-0.0393335745,
0.0067250347,
0.0015654382,
0.058714062,
-0.0371928848,
-0.03671683,
0.0150124151,
0.0348385759,
0.0202267431,
-0.0352265462,
0.0390703231,
-0.0026496432,
-0.0340761319,
0.0121672228,
-0.0321927257,
0.0334646739,
-0.0480749831,
0.0571432598,
-0.0008232958,
0.0346313156,
-0.0254549254,
0.0458444878,
0.0137806255,
0.0198393092,
-0.0483964607,
0.002496311,
0.0010130758,
0.0498784147,
-0.0239797235,
0.0156860277,
-0.0368075855,
0.046143923,
0.003312211,
-0.0432216637,
-0.0103799598,
0.0182873365,
2.643e-7,
0.0257747471,
0.0330256559,
0.0522018895,
0.0300048217,
0.0162737947,
0.0155161591,
-0.0263558663,
0.0477057211,
-0.0029962938,
-0.0363569111,
0.0007051491,
0.0586594641,
0.0710735172,
0.0219903272,
-0.0922391564,
-0.025020577,
-0.0874668062,
-0.0346792378,
-0.0458312668,
-0.0277497321,
0.0182813164,
0.0382088833,
-0.0152524151,
0.0146513088,
0.001474691,
-0.0000689926,
0.0683387443,
-0.022608893,
-0.0098220576,
0.0716669932,
0.0340224318,
0.0149664152,
-0.0119485511,
-0.0035543612,
-0.0089074662,
0.0462762974,
-0.0239965208,
0.0689408928,
0.0374513976,
-0.0302710198,
-0.0006805309,
0.0053554825,
-0.0041469703,
-0.0042092809,
0.0467728041,
-0.0434896387,
-0.0461413674,
-0.0384777151,
-0.0453774855,
0.0013130638,
0.0397414193,
-0.0198894944,
-0.0253341068,
0.0314585082,
0.0117938938,
-0.0185096767,
-0.0002694543,
-0.0482309647,
-0.046193894,
0.0125751691,
-0.0357046612,
-0.0067824889,
-0.0171762407,
-0.0142732244,
-0.0266252514,
-0.0705287308,
-0.0005782432,
2.43178626e-34,
0.0776930526,
-0.043990165,
-0.0029069188,
0.0210843273,
0.0410596244,
-0.0325961001,
-0.0056187226,
-0.0200628173,
-0.0270299036,
-0.0602391176,
0.0221594423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08072v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08072v2 | Do Emergent Abilities Exist in Quantized Large Language Models: An Empirical Study | 2023-07-16T15:11:01 | 2023-07-26T04:15:48 | Peiyu Liu, Zikang Liu, Ze-Feng Gao, Dawei Gao, Wayne Xin Zhao, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the superior performance, Large Language Models~(LLMs) require
significant computational resources for deployment and use. To overcome this
issue, quantization methods have been widely applied to reduce the memory
footprint of LLMs as well as increasing the inference rate. However, a major
challenge is that low-bit quantization methods often lead to performance
degradation. It is important to understand how quantization impacts the
capacity of LLMs. Different from previous studies focused on overall
performance, this work aims to investigate the impact of quantization on
\emph{emergent abilities}, which are important characteristics that distinguish
LLMs from small language models. Specially, we examine the abilities of
in-context learning, chain-of-thought reasoning, and instruction-following in
quantized LLMs. Our empirical experiments show that these emergent abilities
still exist in 4-bit quantization models, while 2-bit models encounter severe
performance degradation on the test of these abilities. To improve the
performance of low-bit models, we conduct two special experiments: (1)
fine-gained impact analysis that studies which components (or substructures)
are more sensitive to quantization, and (2) performance compensation through
model fine-tuning. Our work derives a series of important findings to
understand the impact of quantization on emergent abilities, and sheds lights
on the possibilities of extremely low-bit quantization for LLMs. | [
-0.0142413108,
0.0743933246,
-0.0283326693,
0.0498333275,
-0.0411507078,
0.0153774619,
0.0215231106,
-0.0108834887,
-0.0149448281,
-0.042585209,
0.0065030204,
-0.0507570095,
-0.0366956182,
0.0192666426,
0.0427651368,
-0.0058556674,
0.0796863735,
-0.0875974149,
0.0052788639,
-0.0349288359,
-0.0466437675,
-0.0441936031,
0.0057796109,
0.0071695969,
0.0312903672,
-0.0011602193,
-0.0386330336,
0.0112255476,
-0.0259492639,
-0.0476130955,
-0.0317467786,
0.0388869196,
0.055601906,
0.0177451931,
0.0000019934,
-0.0383009687,
0.0003517972,
0.0100499131,
-0.0457879901,
0.038114395,
-0.0118041476,
-0.0163146202,
-0.0418953784,
0.0052693207,
-0.0089444881,
-0.0169363786,
0.0381621532,
-0.014872673,
0.016330447,
0.0314785242,
-0.0099443495,
-0.0271998402,
0.0471458882,
-0.0164342113,
0.0046538603,
-0.0186038595,
0.0126332762,
0.0239025876,
0.0322612152,
0.0121183842,
-0.0390408859,
0.0115421629,
0.0333391428,
0.0335683674,
-0.0326233618,
0.0482895561,
-0.0469438396,
-0.0191140026,
-0.0238467809,
0.0103579247,
-0.056080021,
-0.0193217956,
-0.0005671738,
0.0142550999,
-0.0163600929,
-0.0594839863,
-0.043004375,
0.0612596124,
-0.0122641996,
0.0130820144,
0.0231813621,
-0.0183637626,
0.0557859913,
0.0177185368,
-0.0532920137,
0.0912212729,
0.0095613897,
-0.0329774655,
-0.0287196003,
-0.0207252428,
-0.0863869637,
-0.0395391025,
-0.0469509996,
0.0259006955,
0.0139489388,
0.0240445379,
-0.0417038947,
0.0340620764,
0.0017468439,
-0.0150425322,
0.0138157308,
0.0605329908,
0.0128469141,
0.0590650216,
-0.0397769101,
0.0616041943,
-0.0404417552,
0.0218312349,
-0.0241065696,
0.0333549157,
-0.0317171291,
-0.0117475623,
-0.0483186916,
0.0720388666,
0.006025428,
-0.0254204534,
-0.0425278246,
0.0263140388,
0.0097741624,
0.0092732497,
-0.0260808747,
-0.0189157184,
0.0112428535,
0.0131555926,
-0.0243040547,
-0.0065361098,
-0.0317267515,
0.0143311406,
-0.002765239,
-0.0552585125,
-0.0163443927,
-0.008629675,
-0.0142583465,
-0.0546734929,
0.0325400643,
0.0283234008,
0.021397518,
-0.0598756224,
-0.0146935293,
-0.001162192,
-0.0110197989,
-0.101183109,
0.0138203399,
-0.070241496,
-0.0155976173,
0.031850554,
-0.0042242939,
-0.0099684298,
0.0204733945,
-0.0175958648,
-0.0138488356,
0.0565248206,
-0.0103220791,
-0.0032596348,
-0.0297461264,
0.0202437732,
0.0555361621,
0.0916561037,
0.0180425625,
0.0129757132,
-0.0038019943,
0.020810103,
-0.02158737,
0.0332806855,
0.0368085951,
0.0136997299,
-0.0214963201,
-0.004371474,
-0.0104205664,
0.0268112253,
0.0445187055,
0.0765945241,
-0.0505230129,
0.0000019594,
0.0405436978,
0.0565068237,
0.0431653373,
0.0198798534,
0.0113408258,
0.0075370613,
0.0074967411,
0.0092829177,
-0.0764517039,
0.0369009227,
0.0083025098,
0.0222376548,
0.0325401723,
0.0155284721,
-0.0378081165,
-0.0391620509,
-0.0351303294,
0.0165362135,
-0.0002841486,
0.0123425573,
0.0473207571,
0.0091308123,
-0.0112322057,
0.0557199642,
0.0258922931,
-0.0472772494,
-0.0316375308,
-0.1111910865,
0.0086035384,
0.0342617556,
0.0357775949,
-0.0069707269,
0.0059953015,
0.0331742316,
-0.0172788668,
0.0173398647,
-0.0114564756,
0.0171074998,
-0.0079029119,
-0.0315397978,
-0.0133142564,
-0.0432394743,
0.0159692708,
0.0031019414,
0.0253732279,
0.0037383093,
-0.0320480503,
-0.0029787223,
0.0102766734,
0.0080495728,
0.0273664594,
-0.0328037217,
-0.0115213031,
-0.0001468783,
0.0245039184,
-0.0121314973,
-0.0252187904,
0.012406636,
0.0281800628,
-0.0223925635,
0.0133405244,
-0.0097777592,
-0.0348609947,
-0.0516582429,
0.0289016776,
0.0390762351,
0.0531499945,
-0.0004971352,
-0.0236810017,
-0.0397643782,
0.0660280138,
-0.0262005702,
0.0475440398,
-0.0265740193,
0.0454132035,
-0.0259399693,
0.0114993481,
-0.0294153523,
0.0706372485,
-0.0412864648,
0.0092955176,
0.0326470435,
0.0482978188,
0.0024721555,
-0.0358228944,
-0.0531835221,
0.0108904839,
-0.0101325111,
0.0142061263,
-0.0148458108,
-0.0492270924,
-0.0058996202,
-0.0104912547,
-0.091317527,
0.0152683929,
-0.0322932824,
0.0352165028,
0.0018507565,
0.0063481214,
0.0071802358,
0.0130259078,
-0.0087689888,
-0.0113986433,
0.000457957,
0.0549276136,
-0.0034812642,
0.0039286655,
-0.0393248349,
-0.0398122706,
-0.0453862883,
-0.0263167471,
0.0419264473,
-0.0380570851,
-0.036980547,
-0.0468296446,
0.0403033867,
-0.0184978284,
0.0443672016,
-0.0439731404,
-0.0266081672,
0.0436096638,
-0.0340252295,
0.0652604401,
0.0779721811,
-0.01779861,
0.042233184,
0.0790787116,
-0.0056624268,
-0.017083779,
0.0456520356,
-0.0094228946,
-0.049541764,
-0.0347226039,
-0.0120687876,
-0.0420634523,
0.1086704507,
-0.0229068063,
-0.0259257387,
-0.0320292078,
0.0489702001,
-0.0199865997,
-0.0172274709,
-0.0464329235,
-0.0167308543,
-0.0043244385,
0.0672883168,
-0.0191340651,
-0.0623472333,
0.0490693338,
-0.0096178325,
-0.0025800068,
-0.0044868239,
-0.0027519604,
-0.0258055124,
0.0849881545,
0.0494153053,
0.020908976,
0.0038712316,
0.0004711987,
-0.0647267103,
-0.0100068254,
-0.0028342365,
-0.0217721183,
0.0172003061,
-0.0537548885,
0.019877715,
-0.0321912728,
-0.0472610965,
-0.0159476958,
0.0122306645,
-0.0118188784,
0.0542251468,
0.0312422905,
-0.0311712455,
0.0392417945,
0.0575962029,
0.0142370388,
0.0317303613,
-0.0161927808,
-0.0160368234,
-0.0203582756,
0.0129518323,
0.0279316604,
-0.0150188003,
0.049593959,
-0.0366235934,
0.0233537294,
0.0356299877,
0.0404456407,
0.0387563221,
-0.0409100652,
0.0296210051,
0.0190279596,
0.0044799508,
-0.0496419035,
0.0229346957,
0.0794747248,
-0.0726466626,
-0.0331655033,
0.0838129744,
0.0220668036,
-0.0140818227,
0.0150411837,
-0.0210357942,
0.0357729569,
0.0344744101,
0.0213696212,
-0.1074233875,
-0.008808339,
0.0120560825,
-0.002591429,
-0.0108513599,
-0.0181119777,
-0.011145018,
-0.0795523599,
0.0246272627,
0.0055994284,
-0.0130778411,
-0.0066856816,
-0.0155119058,
-0.0325465389,
0.0094463769,
0.0367725119,
0.0389502309,
-0.0124020083,
-0.007674831,
0.010592605,
-0.003843914,
-0.0387738384,
0.0517784618,
-0.0136543326,
0.0531767122,
0.0361256413,
0.0001209444,
-0.0093819937,
-0.0025372349,
0.0211661961,
-0.030049134,
0.008523101,
-0.001089623,
0.0047380049,
0.0215162653,
-0.0065790801,
-0.008773163,
-0.007856464,
0.0302179195,
-0.0128589282,
-0.0011718794,
0.0495781116,
-0.0250110384,
-0.0410833396,
-0.0072389538,
-0.0419820063,
-0.0228519384,
0.0586162247,
0.0154225379,
-0.0306374226,
-0.0864855722,
-0.0177918505,
-0.0359135829,
-0.0150746983,
-0.0644047782,
-0.0064483173,
0.0088498006,
-0.0438184962,
-0.0180251636,
0.0109979259,
0.004580887,
0.0287673194,
-0.0133600049,
0.0131624248,
0.0354264528,
0.0027621372,
-0.0564730689,
0.0017818864,
-0.023367567,
0.0175728742,
-0.0467152521,
-0.0213963129,
0.0200036336,
-0.0251871813,
-0.0210442301,
-0.0412070714,
-0.1226577386,
-0.0711765289,
0.0159358829,
0.0445668623,
0.0281268377,
0.0533372276,
0.0112843104,
-0.0664485469,
0.0609314851,
0.029313419,
0.0242037456,
0.04778523,
0.034000989,
0.0131440526,
0.0076636439,
0.0274580047,
-0.0082545597,
0.0460987799,
0.0138794938,
0.0398753919,
-0.0680240691,
-0.0024429674,
-0.0148802148,
-0.0068761585,
0.0524209253,
-0.0012647215,
-0.0133537948,
0.0170468427,
0.0412627235,
-0.0203783195,
0.0011323057,
-0.0466874316,
-0.0364360139,
0.0272100177,
0.0191073045,
-0.015128497,
-0.0281706285,
0.0401722342,
-0.0029538514,
0.0297605768,
0.0159678031,
-0.0241305344,
0.0437572561,
0.0622951277,
-0.000411423,
-0.0224162135,
0.0250307117,
-0.0148352766,
0.074576132,
-0.0313241743,
0.0637556687,
-0.0008201283,
-0.0148793077,
-0.0168280322,
0.0262957662,
-0.0640112832,
-0.0607095957,
0.0224633701,
0.0110870562,
0.03834543,
0.0164333116,
0.0291038342,
-0.0430538133,
-0.0035228701,
-0.0136871841,
-0.0016748926,
0.010028556,
-0.0377480984,
0.064864561,
0.0511119328,
-0.0070725544,
0.0111285131,
0.0480919927,
0.050525561,
0.0254761204,
0.0016808716,
0.0193688069,
-0.0045960387,
-0.0353768989,
-0.0648849532,
0.0200349819,
-0.002497361,
0.0357974581,
-0.0575168952,
-0.0396647677,
-0.0354561396,
0.0244203135,
0.0285627767,
-0.0493026674,
0.0247837342,
0.0536619984,
0.0102535179,
-0.0619098879,
-0.0252382774,
-0.0368699543,
0.0063344622,
0.0259618051,
-0.013283357,
-6.427966779e-33,
-0.0315134712,
0.0000239921,
0.0647316128,
-0.0198639464,
0.006102962,
0.0079672504,
-0.0428805426,
0.029550666,
-0.0554954484,
-0.0373950601,
-0.011797701,
0.0254152119,
0.0106721222,
0.0274458285,
-0.0068750731,
0.0125013543,
0.0509304479,
0.0044170055,
-0.0132939024,
0.0272207875,
-0.014388904,
-0.0237404238,
0.0218902435,
0.0240480117,
-0.0103801712,
-0.0276356023,
0.019840559,
0.0069927936,
-0.0312104262,
0.0415553749,
-0.0258142781,
0.0011826645,
0.0173777007,
0.0033072548,
-0.0077976352,
-0.0197279025,
-0.0451362357,
0.0064894715,
0.0253300089,
0.0194995757,
-0.0295263045,
-0.0421122313,
0.0290717874,
0.0373765677,
-0.0285791922,
-0.0413198359,
-0.0194918551,
-0.0219885819,
-0.0508295335,
-0.0541499704,
-0.0531519875,
0.026291756,
0.0334690586,
0.0178337973,
0.054056365,
-0.0183796901,
-0.0430632643,
-0.0072863298,
-0.0364605598,
0.0148858577,
0.0393853635,
0.0803809315,
0.072767809,
0.0362816602,
0.0188002884,
0.0333810635,
0.0598924421,
0.0291999951,
-0.0443554893,
0.0373266786,
0.0462194346,
0.0494929627,
0.0545218289,
-0.0030236603,
0.0886727273,
0.0318983644,
-0.0785091072,
-0.0605628975,
0.0372195914,
0.0440235287,
0.0730527714,
0.0346932895,
-0.0574698709,
-0.0449421667,
-0.0382656977,
0.0008402048,
-0.0463053435,
-0.0307540316,
0.005768788,
0.0078894012,
-0.0271262694,
-0.0210260917,
0.0419820696,
-0.0392112732,
-0.0410959385,
-0.0051945914,
-0.0189025048,
0.0252978168,
-0.0124314502,
0.060251072,
-0.0704657063,
-0.0555438884,
-0.0063751512,
0.0368669666,
0.0253024045,
0.0166209564,
0.0177953448,
0.0399979092,
-0.0845891014,
-0.0280025229,
-0.0540503971,
0.0131768007,
-0.0023435806,
0.01023609,
0.0416801423,
0.0108810421,
0.017458206,
0.0382929631,
-0.005381688,
-0.0087010218,
-0.0314249955,
0.0213130619,
-0.020384388,
0.0395911895,
-0.0172149129,
-0.0202723071,
-0.0707602948,
0.0764195174,
0.0254917964,
-0.0763272643,
-0.0411721654,
0.047447443,
2.823e-7,
0.0231603365,
0.0240874141,
0.0023379193,
0.0084372424,
0.0306877308,
0.0080464156,
-0.0166624803,
-0.0149845928,
0.033057116,
-0.0004554277,
0.0065369713,
0.0680704117,
0.0012682158,
0.0110621834,
-0.04640707,
0.039741043,
-0.0340521969,
-0.0031400148,
-0.0529474542,
-0.012685732,
0.0386075154,
0.0991382599,
-0.0134045174,
0.0120278373,
0.0303455722,
-0.0279614665,
0.0411840305,
0.0230931379,
0.0163238421,
0.0183891337,
-0.0367234014,
0.0597035773,
-0.019764822,
0.0050422717,
0.0280412175,
0.005898057,
-0.074446626,
0.0467444621,
0.0034515113,
0.0014250915,
0.0085810348,
-0.0211758297,
-0.0099690612,
-0.041162122,
0.1109587029,
-0.0891099945,
-0.0361884572,
-0.0466873199,
0.0175011978,
-0.0049210363,
-0.000446513,
0.0095321285,
-0.0113048516,
0.00476322,
0.0033449344,
-0.0195121709,
0.0165507253,
-0.0985046402,
-0.032620836,
0.0484092347,
-0.0121364202,
-0.0955930129,
-0.0573873818,
0.0075366618,
0.0198868215,
-0.0368521102,
-0.0030819217,
2.85691045e-34,
0.0332643278,
-0.0197667498,
0.0509995595,
0.0178237781,
0.0183070451,
-0.0300515629,
-0.0309533905,
0.0204426274,
0.0243492126,
-0.0593434796,
-0.0213324539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08070v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08070v1 | Automatic Identification of Alzheimer's Disease using Lexical Features extracted from Language Samples | 2023-07-16T15:05:05 | 2023-07-16T15:05:05 | M. Zakaria Kurdi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Objective: this study has a twofold goal. First, it aims to improve the
understanding of the impact of Dementia of type Alzheimer's Disease (AD) on
different aspects of the lexicon. Second, it aims to demonstrate that such
aspects of the lexicon, when used as features of a machine learning classifier,
can help achieve state-of-the-art performance in automatically identifying
language samples produced by patients with AD. Methods: data is derived from
the ADDreSS challenge, which is a part of the DementiaBank corpus. The used
dataset consists of transcripts of Cookie Theft picture descriptions, produced
by 54 subjects in the training part and 24 subjects in the test part. The
number of narrative samples is 108 in the training set and 48 in the test set.
First, the impact of AD on 99 selected lexical features is studied using both
the training and testing parts of the dataset. Then some machine learning
experiments were conducted on the task of classifying transcribed speech
samples with text samples that were produced by people with AD from those
produced by normal subjects. Several experiments were conducted to compare the
different areas of lexical complexity, identify the subset of features that
help achieve optimal performance, and study the impact of the size of the input
on the classification. To evaluate the generalization of the models built on
narrative speech, two generalization tests were conducted using written data
from two British authors, Iris Murdoch and Agatha Christie, and the
transcription of some speeches by former President Ronald Reagan. Results:
using lexical features only, state-of-the-art classification, F1 and
accuracies, of over 91% were achieved in categorizing language samples produced
by individuals with AD from the ones produced by healthy control subjects. This
confirms the substantial impact of AD on lexicon processing. | [
0.0215271283,
0.0450504944,
-0.0048683062,
0.0356977694,
-0.0475817248,
0.0397166722,
0.0183760207,
0.0473841392,
0.0801540241,
-0.0721195042,
0.0538136587,
-0.0024789057,
0.0325179286,
0.0214566961,
-0.0119275004,
-0.0366889276,
0.0495902114,
0.0077749891,
0.0752556399,
-0.0048543992,
-0.0352027155,
0.0018839915,
-0.034220729,
0.0416692384,
-0.0150971096,
-0.0216779429,
0.0680415705,
-0.0305291545,
0.0170945581,
0.0283597466,
-0.0270198099,
0.0131818969,
-0.0154786427,
-0.011515487,
0.0000020091,
-0.0781694353,
0.0213395525,
0.0079323752,
0.0041301604,
-0.0386718437,
0.0312022977,
0.0459553152,
0.030804975,
0.0066903378,
-0.0137627777,
-0.033985246,
0.0418204665,
0.0624953136,
0.0136707816,
0.0700286627,
-0.0215268526,
-0.050474409,
0.0480700582,
0.0326963589,
0.0299240388,
-0.0323797353,
0.0664435104,
-0.0171549581,
-0.0259916596,
-0.092379868,
0.0241228901,
0.0576565489,
-0.0645063147,
0.0263679326,
-0.0101868082,
0.0178969037,
0.0094983038,
0.0060003223,
0.0041919099,
-0.0050448659,
-0.0043525347,
0.0214591566,
0.0190811511,
0.0292286109,
0.0241443571,
0.0297565572,
-0.0059342887,
-0.004687815,
-0.0399603583,
-0.0043220166,
0.0207768138,
0.0188798178,
0.0035015179,
0.0080846893,
-0.003958914,
0.0196672305,
-0.0101493932,
-0.0148890866,
0.0376221091,
-0.034880057,
-0.044053413,
-0.0221257564,
0.0353920534,
0.0001193318,
-0.0133106662,
0.0098645557,
0.0055734836,
-0.0486320965,
0.0319396555,
-0.089520283,
0.0350840986,
-0.0200076476,
-0.0741544068,
0.0065132217,
-0.0182340126,
0.0486265495,
0.0205489807,
-0.0113819409,
-0.0400626995,
0.0338313431,
-0.0706739426,
0.0008796116,
-0.0405069888,
0.043171905,
0.0345505066,
-0.0175794251,
-0.104489997,
-0.0204629228,
0.0349803306,
-0.0310723037,
0.0153979687,
0.0365911275,
0.0183947831,
0.0474132374,
-0.0253297258,
-0.0256795324,
-0.0429094732,
0.0234185494,
-0.0033176739,
-0.0388832837,
0.0506329127,
0.0354411043,
-0.0046418281,
-0.050334245,
0.0158767477,
0.0604032539,
-0.0139730936,
-0.0510551818,
-0.0794343725,
-0.0264456496,
-0.0836810842,
-0.0164647643,
-0.010927842,
-0.0164022874,
0.0178531781,
0.0162794683,
0.0084600253,
-0.0314280167,
-0.0053705028,
0.0126982024,
-0.0634206012,
0.0513364896,
-0.0113454303,
-0.0008434416,
0.0743096918,
-0.021837119,
0.0334961601,
-0.0121528478,
0.048736833,
-0.0219308939,
0.0356966779,
-0.0232724994,
0.0207781289,
0.0280980375,
-0.0064063696,
-0.016072832,
-0.0056216386,
0.0063565923,
-0.0049927882,
0.0272037927,
0.0138204582,
0.0708263442,
0.0302441325,
-0.0418728106,
0.03785602,
0.0730637908,
-0.0104483934,
0.042363178,
0.0126567082,
-0.0040096776,
0.0387300625,
0.0012492578,
0.0237766635,
-0.0612391382,
-0.0314233229,
0.0052199117,
-0.0085757719,
0.0025501405,
0.0034522628,
-0.0173187684,
-0.0140655925,
-0.0242752694,
0.0396236256,
0.0002246209,
-0.0197783019,
0.0268553924,
-0.0229830761,
-0.0280012581,
0.0042521222,
-0.0312216356,
-0.0721686855,
-0.0738853142,
-0.0214351211,
0.0594855398,
0.0455048643,
-0.031266775,
0.0242993925,
-0.0453220196,
-0.0324977152,
-0.0078456281,
-0.0426014364,
0.0056724828,
0.0384548455,
-0.014238921,
0.0430208296,
0.0432604328,
-0.0008688433,
-0.0019656355,
-0.0250762999,
0.0209279712,
-0.0107848467,
0.0035744312,
-0.0291229915,
0.0397285298,
-0.0224033315,
-0.0582049862,
0.0154078808,
0.009090269,
0.0572424382,
0.0395219885,
-0.0091270814,
-0.0083630253,
-0.0063539743,
-0.0443990044,
-0.0193088371,
0.0258079469,
-0.065028809,
-0.0010339256,
-0.0027285267,
0.0008008992,
0.0397649221,
-0.0359069295,
0.0228010304,
-0.0160962678,
-0.017128719,
-0.0856538936,
0.0543002337,
-0.047540836,
0.0584962629,
-0.0384780914,
-0.0062146084,
-0.0206097718,
0.1152002588,
-0.0267791077,
-0.0158724897,
-0.0204548016,
-0.0744754598,
0.0206272341,
-0.010615428,
-0.036707066,
-0.0302887056,
-0.0141096674,
0.0112498058,
0.0217267163,
-0.0401404724,
-0.0053220326,
-0.0008673934,
-0.0863197446,
-0.0293003507,
0.0124014467,
0.0043966388,
-0.0243796892,
-0.0064244242,
-0.0278506037,
0.0092493668,
-0.0101275602,
0.0131054251,
-0.0049641076,
0.0217831787,
0.0049168165,
0.0285594556,
-0.0464429446,
-0.025175713,
0.0027411925,
-0.0330734253,
0.0532316305,
0.0241949726,
-0.0735902488,
-0.0312582701,
0.0293500889,
0.0117833391,
0.0298489146,
0.0006217075,
-0.003274651,
-0.0344514586,
0.0108417068,
-0.0058097774,
0.0415750332,
0.015525911,
0.0544339679,
0.0155089926,
-0.0109306127,
0.0270879474,
-0.0264312159,
0.0121706482,
0.0550698079,
-0.0618296526,
-0.0309650674,
0.0500385948,
0.0279915016,
0.0834655687,
0.020248536,
0.000899346,
-0.0104521131,
-0.0311211292,
-0.0011316828,
-0.005653095,
-0.0675122216,
-0.067877084,
-0.0132872229,
0.0153183406,
-0.0531221628,
0.0541492924,
-0.0538730249,
0.0222690254,
-0.06704586,
-0.0432127528,
-0.0191077422,
0.0489583947,
0.0005201054,
0.0555942133,
0.027379781,
-0.0771296993,
0.027977366,
-0.0498099737,
-0.0107646445,
-0.031196313,
0.0711902082,
-0.0124627817,
0.0180867165,
0.0501508713,
-0.0232565235,
-0.0322559997,
-0.0142363189,
-0.0050017862,
0.0250268653,
0.0260851365,
-0.0574557446,
-0.1141812801,
-0.016727753,
0.0064373594,
0.0535139702,
0.0002979202,
-0.0189136993,
0.0153150326,
0.0528301969,
0.0047911094,
-0.0202269889,
-0.0786745772,
-0.0042165061,
-0.0236602686,
-0.0284791663,
-0.044010438,
0.0347518697,
-0.0090522878,
0.0034395801,
-0.0039929822,
-0.0860828683,
-0.0203755051,
0.0432602279,
0.015196681,
0.0132447965,
-0.0088597117,
0.1077989489,
0.0466971025,
-0.0738169029,
0.0174875353,
-0.0204368457,
-0.0427696221,
0.0044136513,
0.0075446176,
-0.0251441281,
-0.0252827816,
-0.0147564868,
0.0273197033,
-0.0434099957,
-0.0162575077,
-0.0016804454,
-0.0097519122,
0.0043520029,
-0.0226987582,
-0.0413053632,
-0.0204553846,
0.0135339992,
-0.0380277559,
-0.005430785,
0.0176194664,
-0.0276897456,
-0.0517279357,
-0.0498108901,
0.0244093072,
-0.0846752375,
-0.050359644,
0.0427295752,
-0.0123408353,
0.067315653,
0.0896998122,
0.0418412127,
-0.0280708186,
-0.0452883504,
-0.0513616763,
-0.0305205155,
0.0477480963,
-0.0112296389,
0.0979667678,
-0.0022675954,
0.0164221171,
-0.0227647275,
0.0284043886,
0.0108676795,
0.0099409521,
0.0243260898,
0.0274797734,
-0.0557012782,
-0.0142788514,
-0.001560103,
-0.0148159582,
0.0210968126,
0.0425044708,
0.0063335332,
-0.0099501265,
-0.0032880439,
-0.0021032414,
0.0281377174,
0.01039775,
0.0037510316,
-0.0060417182,
-0.0406846069,
-0.0279809032,
-0.0930645317,
-0.0084646475,
0.0360295661,
0.0246091336,
0.0352684036,
0.0065049231,
0.0167147703,
0.0312398933,
-0.0726841465,
0.0139705511,
0.0244503785,
0.0280860551,
-0.0651659593,
-0.032374505,
0.0312292743,
0.0065861349,
-0.0333747342,
0.0271806438,
0.0104928957,
-0.0278140958,
0.1030833051,
-0.0079035293,
0.0182154085,
0.0155739067,
-0.0029902435,
-0.0765328631,
0.0460058078,
0.018718617,
0.0398230031,
0.00608001,
0.0060307742,
0.0048350412,
-0.018982688,
0.0030383146,
0.0050599356,
0.0107433023,
0.0003323847,
-0.0578702949,
-0.0477473512,
-0.0258393828,
0.0008655134,
0.037059214,
0.0150454482,
-0.0242831446,
0.0180608314,
-0.0235045291,
-0.003109873,
0.0119220819,
0.0083738025,
-0.0042653703,
-0.0191822872,
0.0244212337,
-0.0292647984,
-0.0098459339,
-0.0224818997,
-0.0889247432,
-0.0476854071,
-0.0078260032,
0.0537142716,
0.0051086522,
0.0614583865,
-0.0113047818,
-0.0082012899,
-0.0022881741,
0.0351181291,
0.0037285609,
0.0178449005,
0.0132626966,
0.0541196465,
-0.0265478026,
0.0085625136,
-0.0249833204,
0.0002530498,
-0.0028059415,
0.0111748343,
-0.0438876823,
0.0274430308,
0.0137008028,
-0.0517492481,
0.027973704,
-0.0218357164,
0.0379845761,
-0.0131838135,
-0.0410867631,
-0.0012621258,
-0.0050095511,
0.0116098458,
0.0221704878,
-0.0241886303,
0.0050883638,
0.0692063272,
-0.0085552307,
-0.0123900073,
-0.0174377263,
-0.0664517581,
-0.0477931984,
-0.0553891025,
0.0619271807,
0.0041317842,
-0.0395008065,
-0.0132005364,
-0.0258692279,
-0.0229947213,
0.0694339946,
-0.0539420284,
0.0902537853,
0.0270734392,
0.0251971632,
0.0182296634,
0.0169142429,
-0.0302266367,
-0.0477429256,
-0.0151198208,
-0.048049435,
-0.0032161728,
-0.018665228,
-5.802722068e-33,
-0.0006806952,
-0.0546487644,
0.0115902098,
0.0029327211,
0.0125526935,
0.0047828546,
0.0253881142,
0.0240585133,
-0.0086017912,
0.0355107412,
0.0077131316,
-0.0076751262,
0.0311039016,
0.0369274467,
-0.0181787647,
-0.0120712137,
0.0268336236,
0.0073105283,
-0.0183892678,
-0.0119538065,
0.0639792904,
0.0252176467,
0.037075568,
-0.0560185052,
0.0699047074,
0.017019745,
-0.0039577992,
0.0093383491,
0.0567319877,
0.0090303393,
-0.0387459323,
0.0480386652,
0.0129276421,
0.0165940989,
0.0041322852,
0.0602417141,
-0.0567370318,
-0.0218996592,
0.0655876622,
0.016354356,
0.0332150944,
-0.0367183648,
-0.006280541,
0.0079324674,
-0.0459362045,
0.027958978,
0.0587371811,
-0.0355459861,
-0.0153542338,
-0.0316385329,
-0.0504821241,
-0.0017983821,
0.0099720275,
0.0178649239,
0.0139871398,
-0.0100071589,
-0.0187360868,
-0.0364705324,
-0.0207607578,
0.0106094414,
-0.0141911115,
0.0152911749,
-0.0098697804,
-0.0177965891,
-0.0323967598,
0.0706838593,
0.0630442128,
-0.0311721787,
-0.0089529427,
0.017290527,
-0.0384336375,
0.0334423557,
0.0380051024,
-0.0235195886,
0.0358650126,
-0.0610309467,
0.0117333094,
-0.0282879453,
0.0468059406,
0.0120704416,
0.0586798266,
-0.0359031595,
-0.0682943389,
-0.0207717866,
-0.0280234683,
0.0509854145,
-0.0280612502,
-0.0018398822,
0.0024384793,
-0.030480165,
0.0201291926,
0.0165221505,
0.0057450957,
-0.0285595823,
0.0178986583,
-0.0268612523,
0.0262867622,
0.0357106216,
-0.0152027095,
-0.0133349635,
0.0177329946,
-0.0407273248,
0.0352165662,
0.0205009449,
0.0526600145,
0.0051843002,
0.0684577152,
-0.0073060994,
-0.057274431,
0.0092841741,
0.0516125709,
0.006564118,
-0.0098834392,
0.034967266,
-0.0423761159,
0.0188970584,
-0.0010359642,
0.0527769215,
-0.0093348166,
0.0022040315,
-0.0003276055,
-0.0279796012,
-0.0020844424,
0.0302932654,
-0.0361417904,
-0.0135040767,
-0.0004335535,
0.0073257093,
0.0031824047,
-0.0476606116,
0.0235187802,
0.0200217422,
2.781e-7,
0.0386127569,
0.100238204,
0.031520512,
0.0086752512,
0.0110413367,
-0.0027950329,
0.0246879999,
0.0067171692,
-0.0207862537,
0.0297736991,
0.0065401588,
-0.0088354284,
0.0312993191,
0.0226732623,
-0.0978794694,
0.02887013,
-0.1198783666,
-0.0164627302,
-0.0790092573,
0.0674194396,
0.0357788391,
0.0398026519,
-0.0098851826,
-0.0600007474,
0.018598415,
-0.0554142445,
-0.0355722345,
-0.0205895863,
-0.0142539116,
0.0058837985,
0.0488676056,
0.0153723974,
0.0549304858,
0.0718603507,
-0.0383162536,
0.001577094,
-0.0008489679,
0.0467837937,
-0.0549118556,
-0.0160672087,
0.0225768667,
0.0122866947,
-0.020720195,
0.0470004231,
0.0389200225,
0.031999059,
-0.0501257889,
-0.032373812,
0.0144000351,
0.0154804895,
0.0616222434,
-0.0052705174,
0.0096820481,
-0.004544599,
0.0420410298,
-0.0138746928,
-0.0019776244,
-0.0520123467,
0.009096561,
0.0433732644,
-0.0174680706,
0.0062487666,
0.0120727979,
-0.0156425219,
0.0167656448,
-0.0962365791,
0.0285167415,
2.603967943e-34,
0.0307320338,
0.0242980458,
0.0003825097,
0.012019108,
-0.0037638273,
-0.0025374391,
0.0531071126,
0.0241853539,
-0.0353732854,
-0.0444820188,
0.015473865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08036v1 | A Neural-Symbolic Approach Towards Identifying Grammatically Correct Sentences | 2023-07-16T13:21:44 | 2023-07-16T13:21:44 | Nicos Isaak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0; I.2.3; I.2.7; I.5.1 | Textual content around us is growing on a daily basis. Numerous articles are
being written as we speak on online newspapers, blogs, or social media.
Similarly, recent advances in the AI field, like language models or traditional
classic AI approaches, are utilizing all the above to improve their learned
representation to tackle NLP challenges with human-like accuracy. It is
commonly accepted that it is crucial to have access to well-written text from
valid sources to tackle challenges like text summarization, question-answering,
machine translation, or even pronoun resolution. For instance, to summarize
well, one needs to select the most important sentences in order to concatenate
them to form the summary. However, what happens if we do not have access to
well-formed English sentences or even non-valid sentences? Despite the
importance of having access to well-written sentences, figuring out ways to
validate them is still an open area of research. To address this problem, we
present a simplified way to validate English sentences through a novel
neural-symbolic approach. Lately, neural-symbolic approaches have triggered an
increasing interest towards tackling various NLP challenges, as they are
demonstrating their effectiveness as a central component in various AI systems.
Through combining Classic with Modern AI, which involves the blending of
grammatical and syntactical rules with language models, we effectively tackle
the Corpus of Linguistic Acceptability (COLA), a task that shows whether or not
a sequence of words is an English grammatical sentence. Among others,
undertaken experiments effectively show that blending symbolic and non-symbolic
systems helps the former provide insights about the latter's accuracy results. | [
0.0771539211,
0.0452420078,
-0.0041469499,
0.0296307076,
-0.0648676082,
0.0288222451,
-0.0122819059,
-0.0151752476,
0.0151574844,
-0.03767813,
0.0326887071,
-0.0091019087,
0.0219160058,
0.0148069737,
0.0150924521,
-0.0205794964,
0.0426394269,
0.0287468396,
0.0392074399,
0.0077728732,
0.03463462,
0.0150485514,
-0.0029808718,
0.0479997508,
-0.0471891165,
-0.030188892,
0.0242809225,
-0.0152529078,
0.0251098536,
0.017363213,
0.0426555946,
0.0349479392,
-0.0366858281,
0.0407571532,
0.000001593,
-0.026397055,
0.0018591273,
-0.0414452888,
-0.0058679944,
0.0094673205,
0.0418984629,
-0.0283011198,
-0.0132460212,
0.0185393523,
-0.0462016314,
0.0522987992,
0.0094804997,
0.0549802445,
0.0804703385,
0.0792515427,
-0.0071581784,
-0.0017831812,
0.0545003489,
0.0192286968,
-0.054638315,
0.0080862464,
0.0094684325,
-0.0247378815,
0.0088284304,
-0.0310104191,
0.0150335105,
0.0579636991,
0.0516948104,
-0.0446777567,
-0.0132222893,
-0.0072087697,
-0.0586783439,
-0.0096901134,
-0.0387060791,
0.0680118352,
-0.0347433798,
-0.0426283814,
0.0348833799,
0.0123523381,
0.0136218872,
-0.0286274105,
-0.0250372048,
0.0177245755,
-0.0210819356,
0.024345655,
0.0422510058,
-0.0154849114,
0.0075680944,
0.0540208071,
0.008440691,
0.0893765837,
-0.0080816001,
-0.0557886846,
0.0117921326,
0.0262539051,
-0.0463594832,
-0.0425267555,
0.0870817229,
0.0334299356,
-0.0099575734,
0.001390732,
-0.044404719,
-0.0602520257,
0.0088210395,
-0.0790003389,
0.0267661195,
0.0141749028,
0.0080253677,
0.0349451713,
-0.0126892086,
0.0495837033,
0.0308788475,
0.062636137,
-0.0261675641,
-0.0077743665,
-0.0518280379,
-0.0075592091,
-0.0366658084,
0.0654639527,
-0.0468902253,
-0.037117213,
-0.0272908937,
-0.0137984389,
-0.0117566241,
0.0288487505,
0.0112026092,
0.0259362943,
0.0325591639,
0.0286096279,
-0.0123841045,
-0.0059728911,
-0.030985089,
-0.0030948303,
0.001472884,
-0.0175869241,
-0.0046916348,
0.000557187,
0.0269967206,
-0.0147044975,
0.0173586663,
0.0050082929,
-0.0047461786,
-0.0445726439,
-0.0227239076,
-0.0271532405,
-0.0233304035,
-0.0467370339,
-0.0072042309,
-0.0428320505,
0.0170002226,
-0.04317322,
-0.0169349145,
-0.0466779582,
0.0097724507,
0.0596062616,
0.015491969,
0.0233996175,
0.0036948663,
-0.0059086294,
0.002966498,
-0.0037845727,
0.0286228135,
0.0131719867,
0.0732489824,
0.0349339955,
0.0438310355,
0.0482449941,
0.0064537753,
0.0098868879,
0.0091050975,
-0.0243742261,
-0.0299092364,
-0.0163857974,
-0.0682686418,
0.0209342428,
-0.0151459826,
0.1054350138,
0.0020606096,
-0.0255926885,
0.0555896014,
0.0254749842,
-0.0000132419,
0.0020743762,
0.0685654506,
-0.0050997734,
0.0600883402,
0.0272732992,
-0.0462867282,
-0.0065680593,
-0.0649550036,
-0.0097004892,
-0.00403935,
0.05005496,
-0.010185414,
-0.0872917175,
-0.0068824687,
-0.0078717945,
0.0174984746,
-0.014573318,
0.0130181005,
0.0173508152,
-0.0137998592,
0.0031980213,
0.0003450196,
-0.0606353171,
0.0110512972,
0.0119682383,
0.0449467897,
0.0179076828,
0.0394761674,
-0.018425405,
-0.0152286701,
-0.0145528605,
-0.0236629099,
0.078984879,
0.0490680896,
-0.008303877,
0.0004720403,
-0.0259284899,
0.0210130569,
0.0378902964,
0.0075996034,
-0.0230201688,
-0.0175316669,
0.0047096047,
0.0263661016,
-0.0018365392,
-0.0689856037,
0.0658215582,
0.0262192041,
-0.0096665425,
0.0353367142,
0.0291458536,
0.0380289666,
0.0465623625,
0.0136752622,
0.0190946888,
0.0144826928,
-0.0523322262,
-0.0731571913,
0.0045417594,
-0.0506898798,
-0.0689746663,
0.0573349893,
-0.0495943911,
-0.0194287542,
0.0933662206,
-0.0574276522,
-0.0699951798,
0.033066418,
-0.0771374255,
-0.0187041387,
-0.0509735979,
-0.0035906616,
0.0162710156,
0.0052540833,
-0.0189301427,
0.0477094501,
-0.0123675577,
-0.0040361295,
0.0183761138,
-0.0326689109,
0.0072686351,
-0.0244589541,
-0.0495934524,
0.0002487966,
-0.0110842763,
0.0509671196,
0.0445821062,
0.0040942039,
-0.0372439362,
-0.0224239789,
-0.079340145,
0.0100008156,
-0.0173834879,
0.0448527224,
0.0489062183,
-0.0276658013,
0.0074650464,
-0.016451709,
-0.034254089,
-0.0029769656,
0.032411471,
-0.0125333667,
0.0858521536,
-0.0137011055,
-0.0117384018,
-0.0540299676,
-0.0314457826,
-0.0671385005,
0.0570356026,
0.0375492424,
-0.0178368073,
-0.0295484588,
-0.0134202689,
-0.0336733162,
0.0304618236,
0.0545677617,
-0.0571515709,
-0.0152627295,
0.0087898634,
-0.0102126282,
0.0555193089,
-0.0002851252,
-0.008285326,
0.019694943,
0.0247488748,
-0.0155003583,
0.0178423803,
-0.0129723242,
0.0569233373,
0.0113386363,
-0.0108400946,
0.0401101373,
0.0783310458,
0.0233906116,
-0.0328414477,
-0.0177507102,
0.0423474088,
-0.0270774048,
0.0153598925,
-0.0488759726,
-0.0363013111,
-0.0135739334,
0.0200507622,
-0.0729414225,
0.0066240388,
0.0791446045,
-0.0183310602,
0.0087989205,
-0.0857158378,
-0.0414231457,
-0.056033805,
0.0185267758,
0.0357353687,
0.0240498465,
0.0484457649,
-0.0264853816,
-0.025699826,
-0.0150210829,
-0.0253761634,
-0.0143121695,
0.0445139781,
-0.0486837029,
0.0116887642,
0.017585611,
-0.0335509107,
-0.0279637109,
-0.0567897186,
-0.0308584161,
0.0133012477,
-0.0464937836,
0.0063210763,
-0.0084840879,
-0.0422455072,
0.0100748437,
0.0582009107,
-0.0189845469,
-0.0116996346,
-0.0508374199,
0.0620842129,
0.0466930866,
0.0408522338,
0.0358691141,
0.0145611269,
0.0175690539,
0.0327460431,
0.0010329908,
0.0318940096,
-0.0492516719,
0.0000402575,
0.0001975336,
-0.0633291155,
-0.0025066326,
0.0251959041,
0.0078994296,
-0.0668687299,
-0.0313749202,
0.0979798064,
0.0591722578,
-0.0457866341,
0.0081969546,
0.0325949937,
-0.0294602569,
0.0011487294,
0.0269437488,
-0.0532553308,
-0.0357936956,
0.0152383083,
-0.0137580512,
-0.0441355109,
-0.0114908684,
-0.0105261393,
-0.0793374553,
-0.0122467149,
0.0009275059,
-0.0414651781,
-0.0246629436,
0.0091456249,
0.0199530479,
-0.0027049107,
0.0324074402,
0.0198947527,
-0.0127882026,
-0.0056163743,
-0.0033150425,
-0.0467327572,
-0.036068771,
0.0122414595,
-0.0475395471,
-0.0035360984,
0.0549794175,
0.0531771071,
-0.0147458781,
-0.0159120262,
0.0467199646,
-0.0342420153,
-0.0176188964,
0.0129495915,
0.0446604788,
0.0111343144,
0.0056876629,
-0.0439703539,
0.0284598172,
-0.070938997,
0.001334627,
0.0002206062,
0.086641185,
0.0093428111,
-0.0285867266,
-0.0232249983,
0.0398875326,
-0.0209961999,
0.0591269322,
0.0537195094,
-0.051709976,
-0.0440814905,
-0.0415905379,
-0.0057213814,
-0.0652694777,
-0.0100168902,
0.0412624739,
0.0303295311,
-0.017991228,
-0.1317243725,
-0.0823758617,
-0.004632202,
0.0003051232,
0.0130405808,
-0.0149268107,
0.0312779322,
-0.0505711883,
-0.0091437111,
0.000874666,
-0.0139091704,
0.011670935,
-0.0370234847,
0.0636806488,
-0.0076565393,
0.0096480446,
-0.027636053,
-0.0182353873,
-0.0711348355,
-0.0502954237,
-0.0197280198,
0.0356338248,
0.0191622488,
-0.0277080685,
-0.05488782,
-0.057912793,
0.0342210233,
0.0548610836,
0.0137649216,
0.0070377165,
0.0272201635,
0.0017259429,
-0.0147722894,
0.0254942253,
-0.0172803719,
0.0146695664,
0.000034609,
0.0364869051,
-0.0283314679,
0.015234082,
0.0617718883,
0.0259526949,
0.0205881391,
0.0082080718,
-0.0301622432,
-0.0221680067,
-0.0215191636,
-0.002876787,
-0.0302379206,
-0.0157920271,
0.0302412137,
-0.0189457629,
0.0211406164,
-0.0368036032,
-0.0411845893,
-0.0211110245,
0.0325379521,
-0.0215384662,
-0.0303222295,
0.0381138287,
0.0178738646,
-0.0607169196,
-0.0046703722,
-0.0189603977,
0.0133736972,
-0.0131026646,
0.0274390206,
-0.0252514258,
-0.0030522083,
0.0543073267,
-0.0113803335,
-0.0223458875,
0.0252385437,
-0.0855584815,
0.0589032173,
-0.002408192,
-0.0083325906,
0.0979967788,
-0.0149279144,
0.0261853114,
0.0040798411,
0.0046942667,
-0.0194698498,
0.0256782994,
0.013454699,
-0.0254162736,
-0.0257001631,
0.0040266924,
0.0090438211,
-0.037623778,
0.0311559457,
-0.0518446602,
0.0195985232,
0.039487157,
-0.0074203173,
-0.0292982068,
-0.0044269874,
-0.0366945229,
0.0011182706,
-0.0387806036,
0.0138498731,
-0.0458145402,
-0.0469934717,
0.0658838525,
0.0527726077,
0.046015434,
-0.0047627361,
0.0083915219,
0.0034467652,
0.020724507,
-0.0045393123,
-0.0589618199,
-0.0185661241,
-0.0020826051,
-0.0426879898,
-0.0626716986,
-5.741677177e-33,
-0.023916427,
-0.0090829227,
-0.0288784672,
0.0148506192,
-0.0076077459,
-0.0023399717,
-0.0607965514,
-0.0350984186,
0.014741187,
0.0440401174,
-0.0429830477,
0.0301640388,
0.0020876017,
0.0398276672,
0.0101889735,
-0.0179341696,
0.0290677156,
-0.0060642157,
-0.025437301,
-0.0312162098,
0.051523149,
0.0249425452,
0.0246602502,
-0.0121876588,
0.0179524124,
0.0186693966,
-0.0180974863,
0.0341807343,
-0.0172145851,
0.0579429306,
0.0201160479,
0.0317036584,
0.040532928,
0.0314533003,
0.0042688064,
0.0652061999,
-0.0636731312,
-0.061536517,
0.0108435201,
-0.0143732503,
-0.0568460785,
-0.0650898218,
0.0733739436,
-0.0438158661,
0.0158361085,
0.014754626,
0.0524530597,
-0.0160951875,
0.0266193449,
-0.0748289376,
-0.0415719263,
0.0066721006,
-0.0250652079,
0.0056175259,
-0.0266705211,
0.0495087989,
-0.009974394,
-0.0097476682,
-0.0516547561,
-0.0142983766,
-0.0105570778,
0.0320296101,
0.0160923395,
-0.0507415235,
-0.0391494818,
0.0602711514,
-0.0323102884,
-0.0222448334,
-0.0357991792,
0.0362444893,
0.0320779942,
0.012907437,
0.0783935711,
0.0349657163,
0.0686486438,
-0.0036567359,
-0.0571951866,
0.035727445,
0.0538549796,
0.0355768986,
0.003520869,
-0.0285836495,
-0.0498190671,
0.0053796335,
-0.0226156283,
-0.0361355878,
-0.0589297637,
-0.0224181563,
0.0224866681,
-0.0071971552,
-0.0190227609,
-0.0347933695,
-0.0153745096,
-0.0540435202,
0.01554099,
0.0271657445,
0.0043976512,
0.0159362387,
0.024410665,
0.0385742076,
-0.0447527468,
-0.0039583775,
-0.0266767442,
0.0195651259,
0.0310341194,
0.0055279355,
0.0813691691,
0.0339007787,
-0.0187663697,
0.0267388504,
-0.0207148101,
0.0252260864,
-0.0152152143,
-0.021382302,
0.009888066,
0.0467538163,
-0.0166351926,
0.0269561522,
-0.0046811332,
0.0007100936,
-0.0263279621,
0.0143504897,
0.0205317866,
0.0448013321,
-0.0121035399,
-0.0251224581,
-0.0177502949,
0.0578357577,
0.0313994177,
-0.049074553,
0.0299302768,
-0.0138000604,
2.365e-7,
0.0269144252,
0.0514860004,
0.056030307,
0.0260872133,
0.0025287874,
0.0046494864,
0.0038460547,
0.0231862459,
-0.0302558616,
-0.0125259282,
0.0107954359,
0.0247596931,
0.056481611,
0.0215716902,
-0.0967884436,
-0.0095574167,
-0.0846496746,
-0.0389683582,
-0.0210919585,
0.0114699611,
0.0794679448,
0.058502771,
0.0442492925,
-0.036288064,
-0.058833532,
-0.0530317239,
0.0340017825,
0.0243078545,
-0.0067702923,
0.00525204,
0.0659918413,
-0.0275621973,
0.0243916903,
0.0050961091,
0.0102931429,
0.0374407582,
0.0174894296,
0.0604528934,
-0.0029196984,
0.0073474213,
-0.015925521,
-0.0129580796,
0.0200774577,
0.0070625185,
0.0495586395,
-0.0644486845,
-0.0005076156,
-0.0214249305,
-0.0084275352,
-0.0346034244,
0.011889725,
-0.0208761077,
-0.0175509732,
0.0401314721,
0.0026348848,
-0.041091118,
0.0311049689,
-0.0679087639,
-0.0429436229,
0.0242725424,
0.0059585166,
0.0448693782,
-0.0139880963,
-0.0043216501,
0.0132819703,
-0.0748754218,
-0.0067141661,
2.090946622e-34,
0.044902809,
-0.0285712685,
0.0150999753,
0.014347625,
0.0260039065,
0.0083013419,
-0.0639571846,
0.0000030983,
0.0215458032,
-0.0498667769,
0.0003537295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07994v1 | Facilitating Multi-turn Emotional Support Conversation with Positive Emotion Elicitation: A Reinforcement Learning Approach | 2023-07-16T09:58:44 | 2023-07-16T09:58:44 | Jinfeng Zhou, Zhuang Chen, Bo Wang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotional support conversation (ESC) aims to provide emotional support (ES)
to improve one's mental state. Existing works stay at fitting grounded
responses and responding strategies (e.g., question), which ignore the effect
on ES and lack explicit goals to guide emotional positive transition. To this
end, we introduce a new paradigm to formalize multi-turn ESC as a process of
positive emotion elicitation. Addressing this task requires finely adjusting
the elicitation intensity in ES as the conversation progresses while
maintaining conversational goals like coherence. In this paper, we propose
Supporter, a mixture-of-expert-based reinforcement learning model, and well
design ES and dialogue coherence rewards to guide policy's learning for
responding. Experiments verify the superiority of Supporter in achieving
positive emotion elicitation during responding while maintaining conversational
goals including coherence. | [
0.0801791996,
0.0142633915,
-0.0251088031,
-0.0128530068,
-0.0037480143,
-0.0065842224,
0.0080876937,
-0.0574174859,
0.0079214722,
0.0131723396,
0.020253066,
0.0129176006,
-0.020704478,
0.063276127,
0.0005476538,
-0.1154246926,
0.0165579785,
0.0226667114,
0.1350034475,
-0.0019557052,
0.0341100618,
0.0010471782,
-0.0282781757,
0.017409794,
-0.0490438007,
0.0293747745,
-0.0153076034,
0.0347811356,
0.0483931378,
-0.0549099669,
0.0339871049,
0.0197207704,
0.0013379601,
-0.0308004729,
0.0000022465,
-0.0482960939,
-0.0343242884,
-0.0362554379,
0.0281164646,
-0.0849599987,
0.0372843109,
-0.0299180876,
0.0141447531,
0.0003300096,
-0.0062103854,
0.0544317625,
0.0180177819,
0.12270464,
0.0845998004,
0.0783892125,
-0.0116040511,
0.0042986944,
0.0096616978,
-0.0179303158,
-0.0073445025,
-0.0120769693,
-0.0226840284,
0.0072278944,
0.0131153706,
-0.0672317371,
-0.0297620315,
-0.0034871553,
-0.0023326308,
-0.0059687681,
0.0228065923,
0.0112043303,
0.0020354742,
-0.0399660654,
-0.0210825205,
0.0719389096,
0.0104100192,
0.0598297343,
0.0076797106,
-0.0176682398,
0.0593316294,
0.0471862182,
-0.0097412998,
-0.0199869517,
-0.0064423718,
0.0001778615,
0.0068666753,
0.0291396212,
-0.0266664047,
0.0144942217,
-0.0135722253,
0.0472552814,
-0.0624313392,
-0.043343477,
0.0297530405,
0.03083249,
0.016787516,
-0.0261709467,
0.0137288067,
0.0173362792,
-0.064854987,
0.01243845,
0.0073555233,
0.0247855466,
-0.0354845673,
0.0057896054,
-0.0150273973,
0.034693338,
-0.0444904752,
0.0131290993,
0.0136134708,
-0.0129460357,
0.0227548294,
-0.0322314613,
0.0166078284,
0.0207518246,
-0.0451602153,
-0.0081450762,
-0.0290885232,
0.0372895636,
-0.0400119498,
-0.0497260764,
-0.0783730224,
0.0101130679,
-0.0628070086,
0.0566904098,
-0.0303914044,
0.0043636914,
-0.0032225798,
0.0163613111,
-0.0342186466,
0.0677570701,
-0.0558677576,
0.0204013623,
0.0538519956,
-0.0223034713,
-0.0007652667,
0.0075141736,
-0.0050173979,
-0.0026389796,
0.0229119491,
0.029996153,
-0.0175559223,
-0.0263599735,
-0.0218679458,
-0.0353394113,
-0.0220676325,
-0.0513419434,
0.0079846699,
-0.0070043621,
0.0346405655,
-0.0409118347,
0.0257816277,
-0.0243192669,
0.0316015445,
-0.0534246117,
-0.0184297469,
0.0379416049,
-0.0414812639,
-0.0246949308,
0.030842416,
0.0440176018,
-0.0126439389,
0.0441385731,
0.0106743816,
0.0082340464,
0.0415429026,
-0.0224637687,
0.0675053596,
-0.0154713634,
0.0060185133,
-0.0378284864,
0.0261652451,
-0.0331814215,
-0.0527027994,
0.0677219406,
0.0072447024,
-0.0225316733,
-0.0383057334,
0.0192954317,
0.0210730005,
0.0685967281,
-0.0342485979,
0.0438432135,
-0.0523814745,
0.0562289134,
-0.0219461042,
0.0121033322,
-0.0170772001,
0.0570893437,
-0.0294626467,
-0.001747368,
-0.0040560472,
-0.0116950823,
-0.0377382115,
-0.0382914916,
0.0391885191,
-0.0257150996,
0.0040229107,
0.0564615168,
0.0066432063,
-0.0387489684,
-0.015516595,
-0.0357709229,
0.0074407407,
-0.0298108533,
-0.0115680909,
-0.0439705178,
0.0337587111,
0.0972124711,
0.0015469963,
-0.0361632332,
-0.0444417894,
-0.0495465696,
-0.0163834505,
0.023578262,
0.0263723955,
-0.0030772535,
0.040480759,
-0.0240218733,
-0.0131275551,
-0.0166317727,
0.0072346344,
0.037883576,
-0.0365850627,
0.0173621513,
-0.0261799656,
0.0640702024,
0.0353573598,
-0.0022296631,
0.0330521986,
0.0417929292,
0.0253435299,
0.0027288208,
0.0311535355,
0.0255230349,
-0.0417549871,
-0.0146395266,
0.0102624008,
0.0087717259,
-0.0432536192,
0.057172168,
-0.0403318889,
-0.0112854671,
0.0003474929,
-0.0083122058,
-0.0304648429,
-0.0471054353,
-0.0227180943,
-0.0336318687,
0.0370234586,
0.0092688724,
0.0424892195,
0.0214709695,
0.0354005024,
0.0069026821,
-0.0104117598,
0.0050653578,
-0.0142976353,
-0.0118630733,
-0.0037579671,
-0.0215995666,
-0.0257659517,
-0.0206141118,
-0.0692228228,
0.0283376556,
0.0238239262,
0.021666212,
-0.0243792981,
0.019937152,
0.0276963264,
-0.082958512,
-0.0697284192,
-0.0723015517,
-0.0230899509,
-0.0156840105,
-0.0309100673,
-0.0049682921,
-0.0298096631,
-0.0307824481,
-0.0316849388,
-0.0396192856,
0.0170636829,
0.0408009589,
-0.0173390731,
0.0134744095,
0.0298090931,
0.0002818642,
-0.0609624125,
0.0035958651,
0.0068511404,
-0.0141933998,
-0.0025976053,
-0.0294934772,
-0.0470954627,
-0.0530398451,
-0.0633796528,
0.0301867127,
-0.0372092687,
-0.0413085632,
0.0150908707,
0.0106840199,
0.0392849669,
0.065294303,
0.0562575273,
0.0492269173,
-0.0121545624,
-0.0192849934,
-0.048059497,
0.0449240692,
-0.0252396595,
0.033640556,
-0.0597557463,
0.0126101272,
0.0090545202,
0.0025345981,
-0.0096433284,
0.0345617197,
-0.0590272434,
-0.0048737992,
0.0194158833,
-0.0445058234,
-0.0323401354,
-0.0238817539,
0.0064066108,
0.0100865597,
-0.0025853117,
-0.0383209139,
0.0718195438,
0.0506833345,
-0.0346275903,
-0.0366218463,
-0.0186128933,
-0.0032606462,
0.0380827636,
-0.0578793325,
0.0026430236,
-0.0001242224,
-0.0017119505,
-0.0021886961,
-0.0801315531,
-0.0045004799,
-0.0335696116,
-0.0087731332,
-0.0586546101,
-0.0321849287,
0.0460245982,
-0.0364495441,
-0.0287125912,
-0.0080385683,
-0.052972503,
-0.0034832638,
0.0137718488,
-0.0208140481,
-0.0190281607,
-0.0599649809,
0.0806274563,
0.0111972811,
-0.0005781247,
-0.0389177576,
0.0201445203,
-0.0041856971,
0.0516774729,
0.0422003306,
0.0202183984,
-0.0309147034,
0.0587082766,
0.0246753655,
0.0036603431,
-0.0306689534,
0.0356355831,
0.0015685422,
0.0002413608,
0.0243102331,
0.0016526892,
0.0310419258,
0.0536386743,
-0.0135766296,
-0.0041323397,
0.0869722292,
0.0264632888,
0.001476605,
-0.0047436492,
-0.0852178857,
0.0318587013,
0.0033099363,
0.0010259355,
-0.0272601396,
0.0235587116,
-0.0158410762,
0.0415787362,
-0.0005413759,
-0.0086094178,
0.0158259589,
-0.0627746284,
0.0351556987,
-0.0028077555,
-0.012798477,
-0.0014663187,
-0.0065138279,
0.0118641527,
0.0309650041,
-0.0285597611,
-0.0382373929,
0.0399993397,
-0.017593421,
0.0339003839,
0.0062879454,
-0.0213500094,
-0.0114357267,
-0.0200230125,
0.0862325355,
0.0677026659,
0.0546692051,
-0.0097951153,
0.0170677528,
-0.0158311613,
0.0681996718,
0.0246931165,
-0.0190158095,
0.0410410166,
-0.0339391194,
0.0288595501,
-0.0115662031,
0.0706206262,
0.0254270453,
-0.0004032645,
0.0652652979,
0.0354768522,
-0.0430486463,
-0.0489166416,
-0.0047327997,
0.0447278842,
0.0316694193,
0.012054258,
-0.008762625,
-0.0607511923,
0.0114468383,
0.0000207146,
0.0296985246,
-0.0061867167,
-0.034331169,
-0.05721692,
0.0186867286,
0.0682445541,
-0.0391416997,
-0.0716162249,
0.029542096,
0.0160300471,
-0.0534720309,
-0.0401004814,
0.0169508159,
0.0376293138,
0.0374272652,
0.0055417344,
0.0172379445,
0.0294134952,
-0.0290316045,
-0.0075564175,
-0.0113905389,
-0.0160883404,
-0.0087245237,
-0.0583797842,
0.1122436449,
-0.0186442938,
0.0075505017,
0.1057181805,
0.0125902118,
0.0260488708,
0.0412956066,
-0.0356994718,
0.0291223023,
0.0164191462,
-0.0608763881,
0.0058337315,
0.0665923506,
0.0730369091,
-0.016428737,
0.0139651978,
-0.0035027212,
0.0448689163,
0.0060359519,
0.0238529518,
0.0144539839,
-0.0514913611,
-0.0119210621,
-0.0053188382,
0.0410989113,
-0.0006144115,
-0.0101770302,
-0.0001807641,
0.0109038344,
-0.0093191601,
-0.0174609032,
-0.0407181196,
-0.010383293,
-0.0365430973,
-0.0370722562,
0.0108533744,
-0.0375779793,
-0.0235956591,
0.0154080745,
-0.0071712453,
0.0107263885,
0.0200293921,
-0.007587749,
-0.0381636843,
0.008696923,
0.0220157746,
0.0137988022,
0.0320730247,
0.0277980249,
-0.0002247512,
0.1221153811,
0.0318398178,
-0.0425827242,
0.0164252967,
0.0131610446,
-0.0499006957,
-0.0368050225,
0.0059544682,
0.0504667982,
0.0308822934,
0.053806413,
0.036186859,
-0.0279347803,
0.0000570977,
0.0189522039,
0.0277067702,
-0.0141134784,
-0.0249690469,
0.0412406065,
0.0061112586,
-0.0326126814,
-0.0147972368,
-0.0017410035,
-0.078792505,
0.0197034664,
-0.0293287002,
0.0160758849,
-0.0477279462,
-0.0221512914,
0.0262974408,
0.0086758872,
0.0014441921,
0.0548530407,
-0.0779035464,
0.0025659408,
-0.0035255698,
-0.0180215444,
0.0092391735,
-0.035230808,
0.0182849262,
0.009733743,
-0.0210762843,
0.0082903923,
-0.028375024,
0.0227422584,
-0.0262970496,
-0.0043744948,
-0.0536378026,
-6.040120132e-33,
-0.0115742432,
-0.0059375218,
-0.0045490414,
-0.0100164888,
-0.0460451506,
0.0073502222,
-0.0262723546,
0.0659277216,
0.0064000636,
0.0526561178,
-0.0059909062,
0.0494681261,
-0.0055000847,
-0.0002039788,
0.0053557684,
0.0056996574,
0.0155408541,
0.0186724812,
-0.0286117382,
0.0422070622,
-0.0048931157,
0.043966338,
0.0301768016,
-0.1437112689,
0.0530012436,
0.06426204,
-0.0165827218,
0.0187674444,
0.0377176888,
-0.0067329626,
0.0152595118,
0.0201686546,
-0.0023812472,
-0.0358706564,
0.0178113356,
0.0268153027,
-0.0086266194,
-0.0629988536,
-0.0014692044,
-0.0635839328,
-0.104360953,
-0.007142981,
-0.0391141251,
0.0291505288,
0.0213565007,
-0.0109143956,
0.0054119853,
0.020044785,
0.0127952956,
-0.0360664129,
-0.039691586,
0.0003477307,
-0.0511018783,
-0.0212320201,
-0.0147204502,
0.0717723295,
-0.0133340908,
-0.0325865559,
0.0212420989,
0.003136585,
-0.0189293679,
-0.019914601,
-0.0217729099,
-0.0137593467,
-0.023693461,
0.0439877771,
-0.0182806309,
0.0349792242,
-0.0403923132,
-0.0134114511,
0.015384566,
0.0307994224,
0.0578468889,
0.0334507301,
-0.0274267849,
-0.0393102057,
-0.0074328808,
0.0110653657,
0.0513337776,
0.0370477475,
0.0091244373,
0.0036041045,
-0.0314137489,
0.0037401458,
-0.0495330915,
-0.0053152647,
-0.000304581,
-0.0565904453,
0.0199243873,
0.0171531048,
-0.0207247622,
-0.0292468574,
-0.0339849442,
-0.013886977,
-0.0085351635,
0.0343535058,
-0.0399880931,
0.041034691,
-0.0022981488,
-0.0281252395,
-0.0412024409,
-0.0323549621,
-0.005614745,
-0.0229947064,
0.0340350643,
-0.0115815252,
0.0075513427,
0.0148503128,
-0.0516094752,
-0.0002758768,
0.0041041486,
0.0981231481,
0.0022081828,
-0.0333183706,
-0.0601423383,
0.0246161167,
-0.0093425475,
0.0138269961,
0.0025770722,
0.0356216691,
-0.0377947874,
-0.0214281902,
0.0047821957,
0.0450685024,
-0.0605500564,
-0.0038583586,
-0.0100267204,
-0.0444248915,
-0.0133712329,
-0.0204375871,
-0.0331486017,
-0.0218763482,
2.974e-7,
-0.0713795274,
0.0548034571,
0.0279644877,
-0.0054269433,
0.0103705544,
0.0325134024,
-0.010178363,
0.0251313411,
0.0502336323,
-0.0353739969,
0.0306205582,
0.0095111253,
0.0381928571,
0.0011890313,
-0.0173602775,
-0.0748425722,
-0.0164758097,
-0.0167903248,
-0.0082820337,
0.0191230644,
0.0746816695,
0.0228327774,
0.0408786573,
0.0087650958,
0.0206832737,
0.0920573473,
0.0359976329,
-0.0860531926,
0.0170516334,
0.0136988396,
0.0124449208,
-0.0387219191,
-0.0059860642,
0.0103718182,
0.0198198166,
0.0488299243,
-0.0495076105,
0.1017441601,
-0.009055363,
-0.0523590483,
0.0066481596,
0.0707715079,
-0.0038389096,
0.0044336296,
-0.006637916,
-0.1165230796,
-0.0367937535,
-0.0284951143,
-0.0270697065,
-0.0472034104,
0.0189101081,
-0.0189762078,
-0.0641769469,
0.0325578302,
0.0202254206,
0.0430708341,
0.0343077555,
-0.0391572639,
0.0075917747,
0.0381829776,
-0.014992252,
-0.0366605222,
-0.0202603396,
0.0427004546,
-0.0500255078,
-0.0393611491,
0.0100033861,
2.1487387e-34,
0.017423477,
0.0034984522,
-0.0006847512,
0.0370130353,
0.0300271008,
0.0276648141,
-0.0586259961,
-0.0051736697,
0.0381992981,
-0.0104205282,
0.000113085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07982v1 | A Survey of Techniques for Optimizing Transformer Inference | 2023-07-16T08:50:50 | 2023-07-16T08:50:50 | Krishna Teja Chitty-Venkata, Sparsh Mittal, Murali Emani, Venkatram Vishwanath, Arun K. Somani | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AR, cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent years have seen a phenomenal rise in performance and applications of
transformer neural networks. The family of transformer networks, including
Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformer (BERT), Generative
Pretrained Transformer (GPT) and Vision Transformer (ViT), have shown their
effectiveness across Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Computer Vision (CV)
domains. Transformer-based networks such as ChatGPT have impacted the lives of
common men. However, the quest for high predictive performance has led to an
exponential increase in transformers' memory and compute footprint. Researchers
have proposed techniques to optimize transformer inference at all levels of
abstraction. This paper presents a comprehensive survey of techniques for
optimizing the inference phase of transformer networks. We survey techniques
such as knowledge distillation, pruning, quantization, neural architecture
search and lightweight network design at the algorithmic level. We further
review hardware-level optimization techniques and the design of novel hardware
accelerators for transformers. We summarize the quantitative results on the
number of parameters/FLOPs and accuracy of several models/techniques to
showcase the tradeoff exercised by them. We also outline future directions in
this rapidly evolving field of research. We believe that this survey will
educate both novice and seasoned researchers and also spark a plethora of
research efforts in this field. | [
0.003308712,
0.0669721514,
-0.0019717047,
0.0609331429,
-0.00853601,
0.0007512218,
0.021039458,
-0.0025682391,
-0.017304942,
-0.0025769239,
-0.004128261,
-0.0337571502,
0.0083338525,
-0.0101775378,
0.0174897145,
-0.0251383539,
0.016012121,
0.0080551328,
-0.0440890715,
-0.015358991,
-0.0183480103,
-0.0006374833,
-0.011049713,
0.0494152494,
-0.0363386236,
-0.0043145842,
-0.0079228841,
0.0012703827,
0.0166277438,
0.0120551055,
0.0041747438,
0.0169634167,
0.0109082339,
0.0245342124,
0.000002339,
0.0266528353,
-0.0010224606,
-0.0099258944,
-0.0373845622,
-0.0342153944,
-0.0186013039,
-0.0438497141,
-0.0085490942,
0.0110177761,
-0.0168150663,
-0.0588189736,
0.0879058316,
0.0551404133,
0.0281343199,
0.0592916943,
-0.0132206567,
-0.052683752,
0.0319574326,
-0.0356758274,
-0.0173694044,
-0.001823058,
-0.0136752287,
-0.0507666618,
-0.0598082133,
-0.0219861791,
-0.0279205963,
0.0422205441,
0.0404724889,
0.034766987,
-0.0219155308,
0.0404342674,
-0.074242644,
-0.0286879148,
-0.0124319652,
0.0175039619,
-0.0541628413,
-0.0138204014,
-0.0082382392,
0.0041325479,
-0.0372478031,
0.0049972655,
0.0011381746,
0.035797663,
-0.0102955382,
0.0178826451,
-0.047382094,
0.0251163263,
0.0309940632,
0.0016477349,
-0.0428574085,
0.0358633958,
0.0201779548,
0.0296964999,
-0.0053395852,
0.0196294375,
-0.0314624794,
-0.0306025613,
0.0153965335,
0.0206919555,
0.0041049141,
-0.0015874816,
-0.0185998511,
-0.031758137,
-0.0439417288,
-0.0203487277,
0.0174328107,
0.0669953972,
-0.0043870229,
0.0114178415,
-0.0402788259,
0.0636752918,
-0.0632354394,
0.0228439029,
-0.0404572785,
-0.0282514803,
-0.0095970361,
-0.0268341098,
-0.0355322734,
0.0263150893,
-0.0067386008,
-0.0070657842,
-0.0572028905,
-0.0024227332,
0.006042562,
-0.0465452038,
0.0324408412,
0.0552234016,
-0.0406997129,
-0.0073021357,
-0.01796351,
0.0769178197,
0.0044313776,
-0.0140696652,
-0.029890636,
-0.0798488036,
-0.0218414739,
0.0155920489,
0.002962518,
-0.0241172388,
0.035299968,
0.0724973083,
-0.0114278449,
-0.083168976,
-0.0317607783,
0.0217544753,
0.0044573732,
-0.0382009633,
0.0618855581,
-0.0548698567,
0.0467390344,
0.003705773,
0.0071107936,
-0.0149143478,
0.0024132309,
0.0159401167,
-0.0075270385,
0.0503919087,
0.0167491809,
-0.0302413534,
0.0139734037,
0.0003701855,
-0.0055903667,
0.0598259084,
0.0455881618,
0.0516672768,
-0.0256015528,
-0.0282246079,
0.0151124327,
0.029651517,
0.0069577256,
-0.0438482575,
0.0106820948,
-0.0609690808,
-0.0528764948,
0.0053176871,
0.0206057951,
0.0616317093,
-0.038288895,
-0.0333751403,
0.0557285286,
0.0265203994,
0.0507398024,
0.0753010362,
0.0318860821,
-0.0027601339,
-0.0024845595,
-0.0199159086,
-0.0520054922,
0.0577191077,
-0.0024501986,
-0.0237106699,
-0.0648838058,
0.077823855,
-0.0400696695,
-0.0376297906,
0.0099748624,
-0.0246068202,
0.0155687984,
-0.011004121,
0.040959619,
0.0297437422,
-0.0494937375,
0.1410328597,
0.0022250898,
-0.0290299784,
-0.0382916071,
-0.0833021253,
-0.0267860107,
-0.004804878,
0.037438184,
-0.0086925244,
-0.0385038853,
0.0173527095,
-0.0384021737,
0.0156623945,
0.0001653803,
0.0216700695,
0.0173665639,
-0.0537515357,
-0.0196244773,
0.0125297075,
0.0125066657,
0.0310152695,
0.0491974205,
-0.0089032985,
0.0301846098,
-0.010717636,
0.0278151687,
0.0114112739,
0.0109096998,
-0.0165024176,
0.0489395522,
0.021755049,
0.0135233896,
-0.0168916062,
-0.0045146137,
-0.0207793489,
0.0267376062,
-0.057344716,
-0.030474022,
0.0166896638,
-0.0603310056,
-0.0115950527,
0.0163340699,
-0.0679624379,
0.0352873467,
0.0717680156,
-0.0432327986,
-0.027319435,
0.003174159,
-0.0815592483,
0.0538468175,
-0.0335489735,
0.0145025859,
0.0138716688,
0.0259942692,
0.0325798355,
0.0441420786,
-0.015249148,
-0.0069745155,
0.0097146621,
-0.0346014202,
-0.0098536117,
0.0066500977,
-0.0553814322,
-0.0150162522,
-0.0253444929,
-0.0113915363,
0.030856058,
-0.0159894545,
0.0274149701,
-0.0229676012,
-0.0663474575,
-0.0056239879,
-0.0318031237,
0.0181239899,
-0.009191284,
0.033074107,
0.0353982523,
-0.0088402145,
-0.0046750843,
0.0168647207,
-0.0175021607,
-0.0036035138,
0.004533567,
-0.0335584767,
-0.019324651,
0.0222159121,
-0.0577806197,
-0.0032907464,
0.0888617933,
-0.0077509833,
-0.0294449199,
-0.0263698194,
-0.0061160228,
0.0076470925,
0.0391346738,
-0.0399035364,
-0.0295946468,
-0.005048411,
-0.0006616377,
0.0513316169,
0.0523838662,
0.0357925966,
0.0133140441,
0.0061702998,
-0.0049002003,
-0.0342479162,
0.0295437481,
-0.060008388,
-0.0105542084,
-0.0107641611,
0.0095561231,
-0.0390828215,
0.0940762982,
-0.0379243232,
0.0039911829,
-0.049070511,
-0.0261782631,
0.0261336025,
-0.012245859,
0.0162161794,
-0.0130916964,
0.0014934035,
-0.0072579039,
0.0115277292,
-0.0201473646,
0.0581354797,
-0.0305973291,
0.0003741875,
-0.0145901497,
0.0223712288,
-0.0084700957,
0.0420146324,
0.041104354,
0.0320390537,
-0.0143525805,
0.0054599568,
-0.0454986468,
0.0255617481,
0.0184909049,
-0.03383049,
0.0682102367,
-0.0073292893,
0.0055626528,
-0.0189306978,
-0.0444455817,
-0.0418573096,
0.0132642221,
-0.0204023272,
0.0163544677,
0.0672255531,
-0.0331680104,
-0.0722696632,
0.037003275,
-0.0036287457,
0.0727354288,
0.0136428503,
-0.0265783146,
-0.0147106834,
0.0475566871,
0.0081147943,
0.0401894711,
0.0608883649,
0.0057610907,
-0.0148753598,
0.0558029301,
-0.0012450619,
-0.0008910485,
-0.0885932073,
0.0049610934,
0.0325366035,
-0.0154615091,
-0.0038611682,
0.0097445482,
0.0123158628,
-0.0492968969,
-0.0073823845,
0.0711594597,
0.0002995926,
-0.0395947658,
-0.000520781,
0.0657161474,
-0.0248155985,
0.0027406628,
0.0375299491,
-0.0792578533,
-0.0336831436,
-0.0000517913,
0.0110809421,
-0.0014215312,
-0.0213463921,
-0.003052447,
-0.0763290226,
0.0267441124,
-0.0321592838,
0.0492937528,
-0.0412516035,
-0.02701056,
-0.0211719982,
-0.0533960648,
-0.0090442626,
-0.0165812019,
-0.0194071233,
-0.0401762463,
0.0079583321,
-0.0307079814,
-0.01127866,
0.0141646927,
-0.029616341,
-0.0351312831,
0.0395286269,
-0.0015674591,
-0.0285670068,
-0.0624110363,
0.0028709914,
-0.015309413,
0.0244033337,
0.0065013478,
0.0572067648,
-0.0177243333,
-0.0334702209,
-0.0326775685,
0.0070505505,
-0.0159519762,
-0.0367060974,
-0.0637334213,
0.0451534875,
-0.0170030519,
-0.0277698375,
0.0003451417,
-0.0038173848,
-0.0458198152,
0.0347476751,
-0.0108554969,
-0.0167142227,
-0.0461590029,
0.0000230068,
0.0181121696,
-0.0236912612,
-0.0564264245,
0.0017522445,
0.0514656752,
-0.10368184,
-0.0149037726,
0.0270737913,
-0.0003868509,
0.0097191874,
-0.0070966142,
-0.1051805243,
0.0981439352,
0.0103557911,
-0.0722105578,
0.0321376026,
-0.0121585615,
0.0045133866,
-0.0460620709,
0.0291811042,
0.0604937337,
-0.0507526472,
-0.0167689417,
0.0347959772,
-0.1546035558,
-0.0261111017,
0.0317634046,
0.0754624903,
0.016896883,
0.0409990139,
0.003827486,
-0.0016160406,
0.0364337899,
0.0919582024,
-0.0307164863,
0.0100282449,
0.027052097,
-0.0305251218,
-0.019480804,
0.0181180555,
-0.0030314955,
0.0617338382,
0.0112035256,
0.0220162217,
-0.0435726829,
-0.0244665947,
0.0247843508,
-0.0074394378,
0.0761076063,
-0.0010400722,
0.0431048237,
-0.0151918298,
0.0404648036,
0.0358690545,
0.0350607596,
-0.0541529581,
-0.0079834284,
0.0178518947,
0.0293978434,
-0.0266687106,
0.022266699,
0.0476954915,
-0.0405039936,
-0.0225772858,
-0.0012799187,
-0.0017671894,
-0.0201093536,
-0.0037621318,
-0.0057703806,
-0.0000999978,
-0.0126988217,
0.0338255167,
0.0413816385,
-0.0200547166,
0.0519868061,
0.029970035,
0.0130837411,
-0.0684938729,
0.0249358136,
-0.0479651503,
-0.0496501476,
-0.0500999764,
0.0138869416,
0.0267620143,
-0.0194691066,
-0.0129806353,
-0.0392030105,
0.0089967698,
0.0057228794,
0.0136220763,
0.0190466475,
0.0205264073,
0.0413577966,
0.0226164814,
0.0155826714,
-0.0374608114,
0.0477365181,
-0.0539154783,
0.0321770161,
-0.0100073321,
-0.0141953267,
-0.0399769656,
-0.0545925051,
-0.0296553969,
-0.0351431929,
0.0238708649,
-0.0110689746,
-0.0433828942,
-0.0466512665,
0.0344087034,
-0.025934983,
0.0255116578,
-0.0384262875,
0.06213459,
0.0464502908,
0.0157732069,
-0.0401791818,
0.0296186227,
-0.0214098115,
-0.0214525256,
0.0414548554,
-0.0189796221,
-6.685887137e-33,
0.0031461497,
-0.0067687789,
0.0309400689,
0.036011599,
-0.0206684321,
0.0418821909,
-0.0119388308,
-0.0322386995,
-0.0569733158,
-0.0128304269,
-0.0160947684,
0.0319852158,
0.0218066834,
0.0374437012,
-0.0286765657,
-0.0408130772,
0.0564591028,
0.0229795147,
-0.0156903788,
0.0115335668,
0.0085822903,
0.0267460532,
0.0734769627,
-0.0312273651,
-0.0783232898,
0.002171281,
0.0250780694,
-0.0032890802,
0.0073335404,
0.0301183611,
-0.0572552271,
0.0259762537,
0.0194255505,
-0.0698693618,
0.0176210068,
0.0187268052,
-0.0924042612,
-0.0088021783,
-0.0354382508,
0.0523969345,
-0.0012780816,
-0.0149579374,
0.0579661839,
0.0434954837,
-0.0115720546,
-0.058349777,
0.0237268899,
0.02633553,
0.0115958052,
-0.0814009309,
-0.0203573965,
0.0217058696,
0.0074425004,
-0.0423518978,
0.04459171,
0.0559697188,
-0.0228306018,
0.0242437851,
-0.1017061695,
0.0080667362,
0.0213699974,
0.0463820659,
0.0637458339,
0.0344004445,
0.0024902921,
0.0385901779,
0.0269577298,
-0.0249367077,
-0.0575254373,
0.0034690972,
0.0382549316,
0.0509541258,
0.0503877923,
-0.0185528062,
0.0704109594,
0.0002839287,
-0.0503182448,
-0.0068533719,
-0.0064720232,
0.0733811334,
0.0314850584,
-0.0248136986,
-0.0008378277,
-0.020640444,
0.0030411775,
-0.0009376889,
-0.0195339378,
0.0021054156,
-0.0107202129,
0.0309446678,
-0.0369724706,
0.0460431278,
0.0295622386,
-0.0614003614,
0.0660933405,
0.0154077578,
0.0177905392,
0.0182029549,
0.013439524,
0.0222705137,
-0.0311738458,
-0.0290126391,
0.0251384247,
0.0161534622,
0.0183176678,
0.0103347497,
0.021551691,
0.0710838661,
-0.0484738126,
-0.0177015122,
-0.0445803143,
0.0110315513,
-0.0106100412,
0.0462048277,
0.0378507227,
0.0598473884,
-0.0220399406,
-0.0099001033,
-0.0172258336,
0.032543432,
-0.0059886328,
0.055879049,
0.038643349,
0.028427219,
-0.0129754087,
-0.0052942811,
-0.0403499231,
0.0333186872,
-0.0057744659,
-0.0970072001,
-0.0567059927,
0.0468171015,
3.087e-7,
0.049682267,
0.0385967493,
0.037143629,
0.0000426822,
-0.0079918392,
0.0112182312,
0.0697869658,
0.007188533,
0.0361637585,
-0.0013917636,
0.0453340299,
0.0325654112,
0.0210294127,
0.0147525938,
-0.0689272061,
-0.0142933559,
-0.058079809,
-0.0047933208,
0.0125505934,
-0.0180308484,
0.0487720408,
0.0864986479,
-0.0109794484,
-0.0127007933,
0.0273528975,
0.0212247688,
0.0500724576,
-0.0084668845,
0.0399563238,
0.0082254019,
0.0173181333,
0.010831601,
-0.0223214943,
0.0314928554,
0.0047692652,
0.0212865025,
-0.0041001751,
0.0264289491,
-0.0002579212,
-0.029962739,
0.0099471789,
0.0088664927,
-0.0304656606,
-0.0131425727,
0.0597889349,
-0.0974214524,
-0.0355781354,
0.0063099838,
-0.0293899421,
0.0033905695,
0.0073384233,
-0.0015385561,
0.0220142901,
0.0128512513,
0.0195754599,
-0.0130440705,
-0.0368485227,
-0.0578616858,
0.0046309722,
-0.0025703087,
-0.0659085214,
-0.032904543,
-0.0431432873,
-0.0605227053,
0.0633580685,
-0.0099608377,
-0.0313574113,
2.786377575e-34,
0.0071232091,
0.0140179414,
-0.015209957,
0.0310395211,
-0.005018048,
-0.001948145,
0.0362299457,
-0.0067920936,
-0.0316107236,
-0.0721955448,
-0.0402629152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10236v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10236v3 | Look Before You Leap: An Exploratory Study of Uncertainty Measurement for Large Language Models | 2023-07-16T08:28:04 | 2023-10-17T15:20:19 | Yuheng Huang, Jiayang Song, Zhijie Wang, Shengming Zhao, Huaming Chen, Felix Juefei-Xu, Lei Ma | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | The recent performance leap of Large Language Models (LLMs) opens up new
opportunities across numerous industrial applications and domains. However,
erroneous generations, such as false predictions, misinformation, and
hallucination made by LLMs, have also raised severe concerns for the
trustworthiness of LLMs', especially in safety-, security- and
reliability-sensitive scenarios, potentially hindering real-world adoptions.
While uncertainty estimation has shown its potential for interpreting the
prediction risks made by general machine learning (ML) models, little is known
about whether and to what extent it can help explore an LLM's capabilities and
counteract its undesired behavior. To bridge the gap, in this paper, we
initiate an exploratory study on the risk assessment of LLMs from the lens of
uncertainty. In particular, we experiment with twelve uncertainty estimation
methods and four LLMs on four prominent natural language processing (NLP) tasks
to investigate to what extent uncertainty estimation techniques could help
characterize the prediction risks of LLMs. Our findings validate the
effectiveness of uncertainty estimation for revealing LLMs'
uncertain/non-factual predictions. In addition to general NLP tasks, we
extensively conduct experiments with four LLMs for code generation on two
datasets. We find that uncertainty estimation can potentially uncover buggy
programs generated by LLMs. Insights from our study shed light on future design
and development for reliable LLMs, facilitating further research toward
enhancing the trustworthiness of LLMs. | [
0.0263132881,
0.0958712325,
-0.0120686861,
0.0482807495,
-0.0387102216,
-0.0238260832,
-0.0269095339,
-0.0182450619,
0.0035906448,
-0.0457940288,
0.0304409657,
-0.0652016103,
0.0194748268,
0.0272161812,
0.0263971444,
0.0027558308,
0.0564783774,
-0.0602747872,
-0.0086382916,
0.0251497291,
-0.0252418444,
-0.0025900712,
0.0289460737,
0.0861271471,
-0.0167117082,
-0.0256025866,
0.0038250699,
0.0244219806,
0.0156043163,
-0.0258436464,
0.0111550773,
0.0424793549,
0.011192061,
0.0469618253,
0.0000021735,
-0.0590402335,
-0.02176865,
0.03981236,
-0.0364314802,
0.0360248908,
0.0370191783,
0.022503905,
-0.0381497592,
0.0365696475,
-0.0164333172,
0.032264322,
0.0532974601,
0.0000356159,
0.019836219,
0.036104098,
0.011251091,
0.0091438079,
0.0102085704,
0.0114788329,
0.0175007079,
-0.0545552373,
0.0200669095,
0.0029381928,
-0.0105656898,
0.0200598668,
-0.000040156,
0.0199942347,
0.0142150298,
0.0075251856,
-0.032883849,
0.0145893097,
-0.0241667628,
-0.0336419828,
-0.0150107285,
0.0034981743,
-0.0465566851,
-0.0058540283,
-0.0180801507,
-0.0384646617,
-0.0087699406,
0.0141952345,
0.0137247266,
0.0408282131,
-0.0117393667,
0.0161141027,
-0.0021652458,
0.0100198137,
0.0453961641,
0.0154218702,
-0.0091111725,
0.1166894957,
-0.0251496341,
0.0082943598,
0.0146847954,
-0.0190798752,
-0.0108047677,
-0.031574212,
-0.0232401155,
0.0231306739,
-0.0325576626,
0.0467143618,
-0.051722683,
-0.0025412866,
0.0618597642,
-0.0724654198,
-0.0091110943,
0.0165663138,
-0.0128110815,
0.0082798302,
-0.0115935197,
0.050117746,
0.0052783177,
-0.0242995452,
-0.0180902798,
0.0026736734,
0.0063284519,
-0.0248771273,
-0.0101210158,
0.0202401634,
0.0049432013,
0.0056604482,
-0.0623227954,
0.0445784405,
-0.0438143648,
0.0726102069,
-0.0423804671,
-0.0046774661,
-0.0010052955,
-0.0089694262,
-0.0343025476,
-0.0250943117,
0.014191865,
0.0001557091,
-0.0174629781,
-0.1112570018,
0.0181792118,
0.0098057454,
-0.0549913272,
-0.0034981235,
0.00719239,
0.1045425311,
0.0294103157,
-0.01013932,
-0.0715274438,
-0.0430361219,
-0.036370825,
-0.0284990557,
-0.0492739975,
-0.0828618556,
-0.0731608272,
0.0274818875,
0.006075724,
-0.0585460253,
0.0300601274,
0.0002727631,
-0.0503022596,
0.0841300935,
-0.0551545843,
0.0210891031,
0.0073379865,
0.0249563195,
-0.0199683215,
0.0758308768,
0.0505996533,
0.0276786853,
0.0396225266,
0.0032656377,
0.0534575321,
0.0137487231,
-0.0375273302,
-0.0156013938,
-0.0292865634,
0.0056788092,
-0.0089602983,
-0.0240891837,
-0.0247990265,
0.0713767409,
0.0188842658,
-0.0066062808,
0.0541162156,
0.0243113227,
-0.0493837222,
-0.0040775426,
0.0363467596,
0.026888106,
0.0125092166,
-0.040216893,
-0.0446209237,
-0.0037209846,
-0.0514702983,
0.0093142418,
-0.0041830456,
0.023769388,
0.0163083952,
-0.0871295556,
-0.0598833673,
-0.0320361592,
0.0130901393,
-0.0054097148,
0.0459197126,
-0.0306221694,
-0.0482549258,
0.0131284222,
0.0045719692,
-0.0096349902,
-0.0333164595,
-0.0775577873,
-0.001776855,
0.0647537112,
0.042690251,
-0.0443796702,
-0.0393464603,
-0.0231879484,
-0.028779367,
-0.0381743647,
0.041066654,
0.0188250151,
0.0335755274,
-0.0305931307,
-0.0099163232,
0.0091788331,
0.0147372615,
0.0002888722,
0.0405615494,
0.0158434883,
0.0146662509,
-0.0243266989,
-0.0869444907,
0.0343476906,
0.012717098,
-0.0051649208,
0.0146750566,
-0.0127264289,
0.0353490114,
-0.0182438474,
-0.0267081521,
0.039637316,
0.0334056802,
0.0379731245,
-0.058618661,
0.0026784053,
-0.0046468391,
0.0576119572,
0.0376923308,
-0.0106414314,
-0.004379543,
-0.0133022266,
-0.0538026653,
0.0029249114,
0.0214239713,
-0.0535642132,
-0.0199778266,
0.0127504161,
0.0466888845,
-0.048976928,
-0.0028575952,
-0.062546134,
0.0220859665,
-0.0176755451,
0.0206793174,
-0.0144522684,
0.0473701209,
0.0150839938,
0.0131517537,
-0.0665845871,
-0.0029544386,
-0.0163758006,
0.0581218377,
0.0369962417,
0.0136337541,
-0.013703418,
-0.0078860149,
-0.0481867902,
0.007535717,
-0.0053029037,
0.030439565,
0.0079465406,
-0.0196517203,
-0.0288046952,
-0.0194915496,
0.0089579141,
-0.0101406975,
-0.0183244161,
0.0186390784,
0.0372461006,
0.0018418124,
-0.0276594143,
-0.011098952,
-0.0082748719,
-0.0197409652,
0.0817799792,
0.0060064862,
-0.0249188505,
-0.1054753289,
0.079939805,
-0.0202778876,
0.0173151512,
-0.0201126561,
-0.0192048475,
0.0176813155,
0.0092075476,
0.0159051735,
0.0255631078,
-0.0020256783,
0.0307493508,
0.076804921,
0.0010791704,
-0.0318101905,
-0.0036839615,
0.0010528608,
-0.0592986085,
0.0104051428,
-0.0345981754,
0.0218048729,
0.0375511721,
0.0098466948,
-0.0453396253,
-0.0114880586,
0.0277866498,
-0.0349837579,
-0.0051195617,
0.0026277753,
-0.0487514324,
0.0018874337,
0.0678334236,
0.0155572975,
-0.105927363,
0.0807367787,
-0.0454913042,
0.0160204694,
-0.0259688497,
-0.0437862054,
0.0130765038,
0.047609482,
-0.0008858315,
0.0254087094,
0.0266925246,
-0.0169896521,
-0.038421575,
0.0083388742,
0.0213261377,
-0.0490081981,
0.0479872115,
-0.0716312155,
0.0119966017,
-0.0002060844,
-0.0024694493,
-0.056051448,
-0.0363106467,
-0.0518496111,
-0.0112356488,
0.0312203374,
-0.0265814234,
0.0036969273,
-0.0011775803,
-0.0020884455,
0.0038615847,
0.0202631038,
-0.0417928211,
-0.0110446215,
-0.0458657555,
0.0130715948,
-0.0486505292,
0.098599419,
-0.0014397742,
0.0006810642,
0.0504410863,
0.0410767682,
0.0143099604,
-0.078722313,
-0.040742971,
0.0149033358,
-0.005292064,
-0.0196891557,
0.090747945,
0.0689933449,
-0.0577939972,
-0.0038492589,
0.0788667202,
0.0290899761,
0.0084743099,
0.0324553996,
-0.0115784407,
0.0365309156,
0.0537645854,
0.0219925642,
-0.0820603967,
-0.0299090408,
0.0267760586,
0.0472837798,
-0.0460355729,
-0.035358537,
-0.0087382207,
-0.1259191483,
0.0474273451,
-0.0084505556,
-0.0241466481,
-0.0463793352,
-0.0468780212,
-0.0241101272,
-0.0179605596,
0.049733825,
0.006107389,
0.0132951159,
0.0004855178,
0.0240972936,
-0.0795988441,
-0.0563514046,
0.0269738957,
-0.0447147153,
0.062989682,
0.0476432033,
-0.0114272842,
-0.0179754272,
0.0077689774,
0.0295391865,
-0.0021100023,
0.0195525121,
-0.0064683924,
0.0438209027,
0.0374725088,
-0.0204707291,
0.006873162,
-0.0192736071,
-0.0285280943,
-0.0218106974,
0.0018167198,
0.044087328,
-0.039123565,
-0.0340543315,
-0.0119424174,
-0.0083760303,
0.0179688018,
0.0564837642,
-0.014206267,
-0.0183626711,
-0.0515584163,
-0.0567174144,
0.0294278804,
-0.009212466,
-0.0090384111,
0.0283958856,
0.0038719124,
-0.0318098776,
-0.0373802185,
0.0037741547,
-0.0241151657,
-0.0102774175,
0.0171339214,
-0.003179695,
0.0475475341,
0.0211256202,
-0.0652487874,
0.0080000162,
-0.0073182052,
0.0730348155,
-0.0312184487,
0.0597545952,
0.0245319009,
0.0249247532,
-0.0142612215,
0.0466173217,
-0.1063210145,
-0.1014218479,
-0.009860212,
0.0836251974,
0.0298084095,
0.0060412167,
-0.0402117334,
-0.0846571475,
0.0403275229,
0.047648143,
-0.025004819,
-0.0065669166,
0.0229472406,
0.0152829904,
0.0161376279,
-0.0014774189,
-0.0321750529,
-0.0343638547,
0.0089635011,
-0.0255750194,
-0.0283541437,
-0.048118595,
-0.0156011758,
0.0369991846,
0.0239704121,
-0.0319793299,
0.0334568694,
0.0236564148,
-0.0063534589,
0.0066564372,
-0.0347495079,
-0.0345361605,
0.0234975498,
0.0070174839,
-0.0255630072,
-0.0053062784,
-0.0135843661,
0.010880596,
0.0322017893,
0.012956406,
0.0170570742,
0.0214820914,
0.0555044338,
0.071900107,
-0.0077495952,
-0.0114630759,
0.0269096233,
-0.0050009298,
0.0291811693,
0.0398826487,
0.0228832532,
-0.0047156024,
0.0043755737,
0.0036592949,
0.0155179463,
-0.0469069369,
-0.1056809127,
-0.0271029975,
0.0412433259,
0.0200116653,
0.0397828221,
0.037405327,
-0.0552297831,
0.0276025068,
-0.0496443808,
0.034453664,
0.0058857398,
-0.022881845,
0.0449578315,
0.002547862,
-0.0623643398,
0.0099867173,
0.0954092741,
0.0153579209,
0.0268906076,
-0.0311016794,
-0.1032748893,
-0.0213397685,
-0.0061481944,
-0.0024823598,
-0.012893036,
-0.0382959619,
-0.0199586283,
-0.078266114,
-0.0749164075,
0.0044662082,
0.0138062527,
0.0624900684,
-0.0298730247,
-0.0234815311,
0.0912602395,
0.0378336199,
0.0271534082,
-0.0432274789,
-0.0258708801,
0.0170980785,
0.0236139242,
-0.0314922035,
-6.011034361e-33,
0.0120424377,
-0.0728262886,
-0.0315627158,
-0.0257692933,
0.0257201176,
0.0091633769,
-0.0124689285,
0.0369181149,
-0.000086428,
-0.0127721736,
0.0389713608,
0.0118512055,
0.0133354934,
-0.0165729467,
0.0434727184,
-0.0171254557,
0.0241528284,
0.0172157139,
-0.0183232538,
-0.0142738586,
0.0270899273,
0.0116065219,
0.0514306724,
-0.0712625608,
0.0342611559,
0.0047092061,
-0.014664202,
0.0132595347,
-0.0179650597,
0.0302574243,
0.0052343933,
0.0428008437,
-0.0085615041,
-0.0445171446,
-0.037057884,
-0.0362783745,
0.0198125336,
-0.0160776656,
-0.0158153996,
0.0517293364,
0.0322900824,
-0.0243245922,
0.0579534061,
0.0061986013,
-0.0398142152,
0.0312541537,
0.0147860944,
-0.0225906633,
-0.0091672149,
-0.0467269719,
-0.0102524403,
0.0361729972,
-0.0139068644,
0.0056348527,
0.007837222,
0.0321166366,
-0.0132635413,
-0.001224673,
-0.0357869752,
-0.0176279526,
0.03833583,
0.0134277223,
0.1014622673,
0.0053513828,
-0.0176091269,
0.0242437851,
-0.0090141837,
0.0032700866,
-0.0220558941,
-0.0062548551,
0.0209675245,
0.0421272703,
0.0267509818,
0.0460918322,
0.040653266,
-0.0038726851,
-0.0722433478,
0.0319442153,
-0.0030933369,
0.0395589359,
0.0546593778,
0.0252230559,
-0.0723756254,
-0.0332351588,
-0.0385957807,
0.0054918565,
-0.0210959539,
-0.0046045445,
0.0086742006,
-0.0121502727,
-0.0182525013,
0.018548118,
0.0085454909,
-0.0461185798,
-0.0310739167,
0.0034033044,
-0.0401876308,
-0.0097405128,
-0.0047068079,
0.0432442203,
-0.002841492,
0.0067466167,
-0.003788488,
-0.0115506845,
0.0382678956,
0.0040003527,
0.0141409589,
0.0285600126,
-0.0891853794,
0.0266973637,
-0.0262408908,
0.0190618038,
0.0151094776,
-0.0010150683,
0.0431447588,
-0.0432896577,
-0.0077493,
0.0349781625,
0.0193434842,
0.0150545752,
-0.0086964956,
0.0232387614,
-0.0189961046,
-0.0145849204,
-0.0243544299,
-0.0442507453,
-0.0182045456,
0.0141750947,
0.0366845466,
-0.0364597216,
-0.0369450152,
-0.0104321707,
2.941e-7,
0.0326078758,
0.0475326851,
0.0014315759,
0.050632488,
0.0179747976,
0.0773865357,
-0.0017565982,
-0.0172946565,
0.0012543361,
-0.0087190224,
-0.0199089926,
-0.0085771075,
0.0567457937,
0.0630984977,
-0.0043278448,
-0.0299590919,
-0.0392575301,
0.0236940961,
-0.051582735,
0.0098233866,
0.0701013431,
0.0902073756,
0.0013636859,
-0.0045258743,
0.0102358852,
-0.03041845,
0.0165552869,
-0.0360142291,
0.0012788614,
0.0250046458,
0.0496096797,
0.0499033481,
0.0122015756,
0.0447208621,
-0.0126047302,
-0.0270881057,
-0.017777361,
0.0343765244,
0.017110277,
0.0347233266,
0.0031829567,
-0.0403668173,
0.0052010603,
-0.0647056848,
0.0460898876,
-0.0313016325,
-0.0333854668,
-0.0468450189,
0.0105618294,
-0.0254846103,
0.0429366156,
-0.0134894289,
-0.007460712,
0.0102121048,
-0.0152019989,
-0.0013505556,
-0.0186462961,
-0.030259721,
-0.050792437,
0.020866584,
-0.0261186063,
-0.0535901114,
-0.0198943131,
0.0145755075,
0.0184259098,
-0.0424734615,
0.032372538,
2.990544413e-34,
0.0271300785,
-0.0156125296,
-0.0143407546,
0.0265063848,
0.0582753308,
0.0251810905,
-0.0086085228,
0.0235365592,
-0.0158999804,
0.0101850871,
-0.0194778536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07951v1 | MinT: Boosting Generalization in Mathematical Reasoning via Multi-View Fine-Tuning | 2023-07-16T05:41:53 | 2023-07-16T05:41:53 | Zhenwen Liang, Dian Yu, Xiaoman Pan, Wenlin Yao, Qingkai Zeng, Xiangliang Zhang, Dong Yu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Reasoning in mathematical domains remains a significant challenge for
relatively small language models (LMs). Many current methods focus on
specializing LMs in mathematical reasoning and rely heavily on knowledge
distillation from powerful but inefficient large LMs (LLMs). In this work, we
explore a new direction that avoids over-reliance on LLM teachers, introducing
a multi-view fine-tuning method that efficiently exploits existing mathematical
problem datasets with diverse annotation styles. Our approach uniquely
considers the various annotation formats as different "views" and leverages
them in training the model. By postpending distinct instructions to input
questions, models can learn to generate solutions in diverse formats in a
flexible manner. Experimental results show that our strategy enables a LLaMA-7B
model to outperform prior approaches that utilize knowledge distillation, as
well as carefully established baselines. Additionally, the proposed method
grants the models promising generalization ability across various views and
datasets, and the capability to learn from inaccurate or incomplete noisy data.
We hope our multi-view training paradigm could inspire future studies in other
machine reasoning domains. | [
-0.0064349985,
0.0603658333,
0.0056443783,
0.06849318,
-0.0004606557,
0.038712848,
-0.0195454676,
-0.0083027873,
-0.0316666476,
-0.0378788523,
-0.0277415998,
-0.0108131561,
-0.0470611006,
0.0077823978,
0.0557699092,
-0.0577506647,
0.010128689,
-0.0690098852,
0.0352775268,
-0.011104892,
0.0003475418,
-0.004598347,
-0.015370965,
-0.0093565704,
-0.0344499536,
-0.0588274449,
0.023831673,
-0.0265775304,
0.0261066556,
-0.0128274364,
-0.022121191,
0.0406121835,
0.0267030895,
0.002863165,
0.0000022629,
-0.0561676547,
-0.016780939,
-0.0051009255,
-0.0288663339,
-0.0054260441,
-0.0141725177,
-0.0282199737,
0.0593340844,
0.0050147162,
-0.079476811,
0.0181966536,
0.0128036728,
0.0550049655,
0.1044496894,
0.0765902996,
0.0030399882,
-0.0687556043,
0.015369623,
-0.0379221365,
0.083793126,
-0.0538264625,
0.0163159296,
0.0389779583,
0.0061528576,
0.0248840451,
-0.036688108,
0.0507831387,
0.0491914637,
-0.0022812809,
-0.0204680786,
0.0148863448,
-0.0393643379,
0.0086819995,
0.0114524374,
0.0726736933,
-0.0221624486,
-0.0094059762,
-0.0207692832,
-0.0039092479,
0.0256685223,
0.0235591512,
-0.0719867349,
0.0167575367,
-0.0039297505,
0.0144981183,
-0.0183329489,
-0.0031765986,
0.0324798971,
0.0038486619,
-0.0517137796,
0.0609524176,
-0.0154489288,
-0.0134819504,
0.0130201299,
0.0011441028,
-0.0805782005,
-0.0226018075,
-0.0043404372,
0.0688183904,
0.03397521,
0.0251467507,
-0.0464552455,
0.0038196989,
-0.0077081821,
-0.0437436141,
0.0699722767,
0.0619145967,
-0.0047093281,
0.0314131938,
-0.0345361903,
0.0167543925,
-0.0048525021,
0.0450610369,
-0.0524520352,
-0.0002628801,
-0.0330960751,
-0.0182046574,
-0.0202542022,
0.0698512867,
0.0012760133,
0.0059614768,
-0.0532513484,
0.0230779238,
-0.0341008231,
0.0219636112,
0.0514930114,
-0.0102609396,
-0.0147804739,
-0.035041146,
-0.0270813983,
0.013243421,
-0.0728794336,
0.0275660045,
-0.0009800037,
-0.0477802642,
-0.0354326479,
0.0176034905,
-0.0079612033,
-0.030163629,
0.0176471546,
0.0470968299,
-0.0003537922,
-0.0025447505,
-0.0436790101,
-0.0337557234,
0.0077325003,
-0.0663017258,
0.0360663608,
-0.0820774063,
0.049238544,
0.013838632,
-0.007788843,
-0.0329176039,
0.0150328744,
0.0098192645,
0.0142547973,
0.0817918405,
0.0249621756,
-0.0178054851,
0.0331089459,
0.0142205087,
0.0012036033,
0.0906660557,
0.0370396525,
-0.040307492,
0.0216874424,
-0.0100396732,
0.0057282676,
0.0468561426,
0.0280915666,
-0.0049165101,
-0.0067478018,
0.0096986564,
-0.0056956019,
0.0174443759,
-0.0238841251,
0.0215604044,
-0.0563846268,
-0.0093518356,
-0.0017112043,
0.0385266468,
0.0060796207,
-0.0016090426,
0.0325908102,
-0.0305022225,
0.0470018461,
0.0039542797,
-0.0489009358,
0.0241706613,
-0.0210749265,
0.0046355664,
0.0171410497,
0.009951463,
-0.0333995447,
-0.0786558166,
-0.0112982737,
-0.0042864713,
-0.0694693774,
0.0204623975,
0.0474145859,
0.0310269315,
0.0338817984,
0.0754559115,
0.012496735,
-0.0267043952,
-0.0192165449,
-0.0238014683,
0.0121310204,
-0.0289940145,
0.0200468004,
-0.063633725,
-0.072112143,
-0.003942688,
0.0171692632,
0.0057291128,
0.078126885,
-0.0342588499,
-0.0292938352,
-0.0716841295,
-0.000405149,
-0.0421797968,
0.0300724208,
-0.0084204208,
0.0130944755,
-0.0349244289,
0.0338554867,
-0.0696083158,
0.0066694464,
0.0292760897,
-0.0383485109,
-0.0499814525,
-0.0122823473,
-0.0023895102,
0.0101425499,
-0.0037028866,
0.022782797,
0.0354585536,
0.0146326153,
-0.0624865368,
0.0307968166,
-0.0076501397,
-0.0576879941,
-0.070543997,
0.0570958294,
-0.0460572429,
-0.0120690661,
0.0088010402,
-0.0836835802,
-0.0378527828,
0.0026936505,
-0.0010546525,
0.0090212468,
-0.0206537992,
-0.0149241751,
0.0254912544,
-0.0010587167,
-0.0251598172,
0.0677972585,
-0.009590772,
0.0007691023,
0.0069946796,
-0.0222412553,
0.032928519,
0.0055028717,
-0.006444247,
-0.0231020637,
-0.0252609253,
0.009102053,
-0.0172734596,
0.0144988513,
-0.0416705608,
-0.0159955584,
-0.0276018679,
0.0011640444,
0.0116797537,
0.0397220291,
0.0111712832,
-0.0360199548,
0.0112144733,
-0.0255091209,
-0.0484580509,
-0.0082213245,
-0.0102251889,
-0.0102933785,
0.0408393405,
0.0095973872,
0.0120535884,
-0.0219474584,
-0.020983411,
-0.0554315783,
0.0497925729,
0.0179271977,
0.0288870502,
-0.0128651159,
0.0066432473,
-0.0541508198,
0.0044785026,
-0.020786047,
0.044326406,
0.0291721672,
-0.0481537469,
0.0085402513,
0.0690192357,
-0.0336767547,
0.0128264492,
0.0231024642,
0.0055976426,
-0.0705083907,
0.0398804694,
0.0008122634,
0.0152944541,
-0.0273822881,
-0.0215354674,
-0.0334626995,
0.06147312,
-0.0569839254,
-0.0251529198,
-0.0602488369,
0.0500880219,
-0.002696116,
-0.0151647916,
-0.0524052158,
0.0383372568,
0.0103441076,
0.0472059362,
-0.0005556502,
-0.0342320763,
0.050741706,
-0.014891943,
-0.0061782296,
-0.0170338731,
0.0327682421,
-0.0843351707,
0.0211113654,
-0.0131696006,
-0.0221909489,
-0.0212937184,
0.0117203873,
-0.0507030301,
0.0026642445,
0.0322724134,
-0.0223342236,
0.0858600959,
-0.0486442968,
-0.0105255693,
-0.0248859767,
-0.038225621,
-0.0295387208,
0.0137856351,
-0.005668256,
0.0291941743,
-0.0090685431,
-0.0027633989,
-0.026594352,
-0.0101728402,
-0.0053626252,
0.030669475,
-0.0441671424,
-0.0203603636,
-0.0246796329,
0.0047104838,
0.0367737114,
0.0425955094,
0.026969675,
-0.0738690495,
-0.0042218259,
0.0089314776,
0.0386513323,
-0.0089992024,
0.0019447544,
0.0346693434,
0.0088143004,
-0.0041792351,
-0.022465907,
0.0179745834,
0.0419588909,
-0.0725644976,
-0.0317528173,
0.116380237,
0.0305455495,
0.0017171188,
-0.013224856,
-0.0725632086,
0.0425042398,
0.0508568697,
0.0496227294,
-0.0672439411,
-0.0294904877,
-0.0085624261,
0.0314816535,
0.0425651483,
-0.0309140552,
-0.0067243851,
-0.1136475801,
0.00370553,
0.0100116422,
-0.0134269688,
0.0099336617,
-0.0105774943,
-0.0038305735,
0.0115284463,
-0.0433769003,
-0.005722153,
-0.014000359,
0.0131663224,
0.0428046174,
-0.0141320284,
-0.0432681926,
0.0141913034,
-0.0065827821,
-0.0204659887,
0.0003025475,
0.0123343226,
-0.0200014412,
-0.0624289699,
0.0333975591,
0.0617929697,
-0.0074452581,
-0.0182257928,
0.0256287102,
-0.0113364467,
-0.011227753,
0.0485042818,
0.0892841816,
-0.0573973693,
-0.0282322783,
0.0312300883,
0.0957747176,
-0.0165388975,
-0.0000614531,
-0.0230110455,
-0.0144959213,
-0.0592069104,
0.0470890403,
0.0429046564,
0.0027450754,
-0.0360181183,
-0.0606716834,
-0.0150359673,
-0.064628616,
-0.0175150614,
0.0052145054,
0.0192051567,
0.0013376508,
-0.0434441902,
-0.0222041234,
0.0562826321,
0.0662493855,
0.0115808081,
-0.0511974655,
0.0177295469,
-0.0077269278,
-0.016970044,
0.0282295812,
-0.0412026867,
-0.0099793309,
-0.0264016911,
0.028167706,
0.0257144943,
-0.032431677,
-0.0492328182,
0.00501914,
-0.1090465859,
-0.054863669,
-0.00578957,
0.0844233111,
0.0198781248,
0.0467617065,
-0.0074100145,
-0.038727954,
0.055496458,
0.0295074545,
0.033235345,
0.0116969906,
0.0554873794,
-0.0097584035,
0.0108762737,
0.0211632103,
-0.0312035028,
0.0171377826,
0.0194743276,
0.0444294736,
-0.0417159162,
0.0144792963,
0.0184426755,
0.0292418115,
0.0010033629,
0.0472617559,
0.0009303267,
-0.027427787,
0.0290724803,
-0.0113876835,
-0.0142405173,
-0.05318591,
0.023928348,
0.0133460918,
-0.047395613,
0.0127638541,
-0.0149194477,
0.023293145,
0.0418143533,
-0.0151796071,
0.0408772156,
0.0235307161,
-0.014562157,
0.0089429412,
-0.0258662533,
0.0196267702,
0.0266835243,
-0.0123659279,
0.0264498051,
-0.0196137894,
0.0410003029,
0.0271787662,
0.0527256019,
-0.0487325266,
-0.0178565476,
-0.0404727198,
-0.0830802694,
-0.0348236635,
0.0635563657,
0.0237193983,
0.0076352446,
-0.0037657735,
-0.0408351459,
-0.0025682866,
0.0125792446,
0.019207567,
0.0117801139,
0.0069135646,
0.0616136007,
0.0378376767,
0.0270987395,
-0.0636020228,
0.0913836136,
-0.0739052296,
0.0494767949,
-0.024491664,
0.0391576774,
-0.0567381307,
-0.0273423158,
0.0357395001,
0.0296180993,
0.0218974482,
0.0062875967,
-0.0543563254,
-0.0859494954,
-0.0027501059,
-0.0070982799,
-0.0380141661,
0.0163710192,
0.0328709483,
0.077441223,
-0.0234794114,
-0.0193070676,
0.0098601924,
-0.0239951555,
0.0058786324,
-0.0079219518,
0.0080217021,
-6.446845953e-33,
-0.0122473435,
-0.0015683764,
0.048319459,
0.0237036943,
0.0192833785,
-0.0160221905,
0.0016100071,
0.0112606566,
-0.0360376425,
0.0022850195,
-0.0026718623,
0.0194184929,
0.0027197711,
0.0244275853,
0.0334366076,
0.0061010476,
0.026239844,
-0.0080688093,
-0.035561882,
-0.011856514,
0.0225672685,
0.0029958268,
0.0624288693,
-0.0325328149,
0.0212153159,
-0.0006360431,
-0.0230702311,
0.0462939292,
-0.0633182526,
0.0680791363,
-0.0112054748,
0.0077874353,
0.024339607,
-0.0364950374,
-0.0335084721,
0.0112718483,
-0.0427196063,
-0.0748867616,
0.0184587147,
-0.0011186954,
-0.0563553385,
-0.045031026,
0.0376322493,
-0.0004062728,
0.0004038909,
-0.0350145102,
0.0148911104,
-0.0314561464,
0.0045955474,
-0.0113488017,
-0.0129058454,
0.0179314632,
-0.0250346232,
-0.043142207,
0.0202417113,
0.0345249474,
-0.0072438759,
0.0354300775,
-0.0028076882,
0.0320120119,
0.0548801683,
0.029785702,
0.0490371883,
0.0104881581,
-0.0147869345,
0.0173379388,
-0.0125140902,
-0.0382945724,
-0.0038177227,
-0.0275824368,
0.018712014,
0.0895833224,
0.0462865904,
0.0245434176,
0.0460755676,
0.0335631818,
-0.0484953597,
0.0103430822,
-0.0091191242,
0.0555339679,
0.0127198771,
-0.0218925532,
-0.0004291408,
-0.0037143687,
-0.0646054447,
0.0139366686,
-0.0405037813,
0.0157111678,
0.0259870607,
-0.0009579395,
-0.0231294855,
0.0616246462,
0.0254501496,
-0.0398595668,
-0.0266582631,
0.0197613593,
0.0124254962,
0.0188994259,
0.0081347553,
0.0135487076,
-0.0444808267,
-0.0167489816,
0.0154095832,
-0.0393764079,
0.0335474759,
0.011688211,
0.0733853504,
-0.0052651865,
-0.0398695171,
-0.0237502102,
-0.022516815,
-0.0363250971,
0.0414363816,
0.0577564202,
0.0238207672,
0.0503448993,
-0.01931886,
0.0368508324,
-0.0066826306,
-0.0220998842,
-0.0221451931,
0.0098433457,
-0.0228183586,
0.0218016654,
-0.0033920736,
-0.011999947,
-0.0039510746,
-0.0322966687,
0.0362877659,
-0.0579442419,
-0.0020611726,
0.0493134037,
2.877e-7,
0.098484084,
0.0648834184,
-0.0020317724,
0.0489856489,
0.0110540679,
0.0292886235,
-0.0308370888,
-0.0158649441,
0.0360965841,
-0.0323354192,
-0.0043822573,
0.0555815883,
0.0258137379,
0.0665818751,
-0.0544493683,
0.0011919275,
-0.0314492919,
-0.0113453483,
-0.0331423059,
-0.0063859005,
0.0702178627,
0.1045715734,
0.0114571638,
-0.0229258668,
-0.0017635047,
-0.0386569984,
0.0664613768,
-0.0121172396,
-0.0076764449,
0.0580495298,
0.0028816091,
-0.0144348079,
0.0207823105,
0.0116344867,
-0.0029266083,
0.028907001,
0.0141755892,
0.0609390438,
0.0128555102,
-0.0116579495,
-0.0168775227,
0.0199870951,
0.00021821,
-0.0577995852,
0.0664285123,
-0.0824619234,
-0.0204577968,
0.0118442252,
0.0065831356,
-0.0092842467,
0.04028669,
-0.0104833227,
0.036661651,
0.0024988197,
0.0044956566,
-0.0200567544,
-0.0286344662,
-0.054576084,
-0.0189636629,
-0.0083854385,
-0.0419009253,
-0.0326993167,
-0.0366223902,
-0.048463963,
0.0165543538,
-0.0409043655,
-0.0126594082,
2.798875008e-34,
0.0449706875,
-0.0277389437,
0.0202641934,
0.0659591779,
0.0164803714,
-0.0315095708,
-0.06251017,
0.0316107124,
0.0231706388,
-0.0930235684,
-0.0221330225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10234v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10234v2 | SentimentGPT: Exploiting GPT for Advanced Sentiment Analysis and its Departure from Current Machine Learning | 2023-07-16T05:33:35 | 2023-07-23T13:48:15 | Kiana Kheiri, Hamid Karimi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI | This study presents a thorough examination of various Generative Pretrained
Transformer (GPT) methodologies in sentiment analysis, specifically in the
context of Task 4 on the SemEval 2017 dataset. Three primary strategies are
employed: 1) prompt engineering using the advanced GPT-3.5 Turbo, 2)
fine-tuning GPT models, and 3) an inventive approach to embedding
classification. The research yields detailed comparative insights among these
strategies and individual GPT models, revealing their unique strengths and
potential limitations. Additionally, the study compares these GPT-based
methodologies with other current, high-performing models previously used with
the same dataset. The results illustrate the significant superiority of the GPT
approaches in terms of predictive performance, more than 22\% in F1-score
compared to the state-of-the-art. Further, the paper sheds light on common
challenges in sentiment analysis tasks, such as understanding context and
detecting sarcasm. It underscores the enhanced capabilities of the GPT models
to effectively handle these complexities. Taken together, these findings
highlight the promising potential of GPT models in sentiment analysis, setting
the stage for future research in this field. The code can be found at
https://github.com/DSAatUSU/SentimentGPT | [
0.0243988298,
0.0418923534,
-0.0167604946,
0.0398428515,
-0.0167096294,
0.0257761497,
-0.0430341288,
0.0199503377,
-0.0106889969,
-0.0495756306,
-0.0217061508,
0.0190352276,
-0.0471281856,
0.0291937664,
-0.009097877,
-0.0498096757,
0.0075280839,
0.0644605756,
0.007995965,
-0.0161913112,
0.0100290077,
0.012424551,
0.0114122014,
0.0485733673,
-0.0272873975,
-0.0020059543,
0.0111045456,
0.0394691415,
0.0465735011,
-0.0253687277,
0.0342603773,
0.0478435419,
0.0196507275,
0.0527055524,
0.0000021745,
0.0050780424,
0.0036975855,
-0.017079521,
0.0091916891,
-0.0084336689,
0.0764764175,
-0.0390941575,
-0.0161714684,
0.0292365011,
-0.069699429,
-0.0613184832,
0.0482167713,
0.0638433546,
0.0673823729,
0.0908844098,
-0.0423365571,
-0.035092134,
0.0119227879,
-0.0260999855,
0.0160604436,
-0.0338950567,
-0.0022199417,
-0.0215592608,
-0.0479679592,
0.0436022617,
-0.0471428111,
0.0182760265,
0.0055924067,
0.0278600976,
0.0016868851,
0.0228646714,
-0.0084374854,
0.0080203237,
-0.048455283,
0.0340492725,
0.001700042,
-0.0214451924,
-0.0456304252,
-0.0108429296,
-0.0250621904,
-0.0500258319,
-0.0254705008,
-0.0047549214,
0.0131313661,
0.0572578236,
0.0046294397,
0.0669123754,
0.0277373232,
-0.0074459631,
-0.0012061835,
0.0114780599,
0.0043277522,
-0.0413321778,
-0.0067304848,
0.0580087528,
-0.0479701906,
0.0136193708,
-0.0116158593,
-0.0009616411,
0.0162640065,
0.0238089077,
-0.0150357187,
-0.0269742869,
0.0122305509,
-0.0175730754,
-0.0080847768,
0.0360493213,
-0.0146607654,
0.0329679921,
-0.0230673961,
0.0037280577,
-0.0301714111,
0.0031859346,
-0.0213079341,
-0.0075798659,
-0.0670277998,
-0.0132675506,
-0.0281590801,
-0.0160443597,
-0.0236299783,
0.0004541759,
-0.0748611167,
0.020062305,
-0.0104710441,
-0.0193744414,
0.037037883,
-0.003524516,
-0.0194579456,
-0.0000501643,
-0.0183922909,
0.0339441709,
-0.0594787598,
0.0343679674,
-0.031562712,
-0.0566045754,
-0.0189908184,
0.0254325457,
0.0060595134,
-0.0149001926,
0.0329453871,
0.016335832,
0.0318749733,
-0.0642377213,
-0.0385194346,
0.0098930439,
-0.024064647,
-0.0530638583,
0.0103498707,
-0.0142732859,
0.0295350999,
-0.0123684332,
-0.0025189037,
0.031322781,
-0.0138482125,
0.002387895,
-0.0110275578,
0.0740301684,
-0.0303517077,
-0.0148853539,
0.0002399463,
0.0280460995,
-0.0337238908,
0.0452540405,
-0.0133087579,
0.0546261892,
0.026815664,
-0.0306855254,
0.0116028329,
0.0003836595,
0.0354067944,
-0.0081986841,
0.0085833445,
0.021666998,
-0.0577927269,
-0.0205598883,
0.0015597688,
0.0111510437,
-0.0177165251,
-0.0093960185,
0.0319529325,
0.0119320052,
-0.0215208586,
0.0856818929,
0.0413414948,
0.0059258733,
-0.0184083562,
-0.0230843686,
-0.0103598731,
-0.0044258162,
-0.0419596024,
-0.0177266151,
-0.0294197444,
0.0594656281,
-0.0250677802,
-0.0539533198,
0.0037008033,
-0.0427847281,
0.0260687694,
-0.0056256717,
0.0493477099,
0.0213168785,
-0.1003633291,
-0.0198021531,
0.0144253112,
-0.0712495968,
-0.0576351397,
-0.0512557998,
0.0058747437,
0.0353876203,
0.0309922285,
-0.0133377519,
-0.0259327199,
-0.0362508409,
-0.0238861497,
0.0089314179,
0.0151802059,
0.0358763896,
-0.0128890304,
-0.0467751734,
-0.0008043549,
-0.0179488305,
0.0319606028,
0.0288257692,
0.0400846787,
0.0623764917,
0.0067698373,
0.0112880664,
0.0658827275,
0.0176039655,
0.0258687343,
-0.0455380306,
0.0075065484,
0.0075399252,
0.0607605651,
0.0254268236,
-0.0123979915,
-0.0339865088,
0.0332357027,
-0.018828826,
-0.0724503845,
0.0468202457,
-0.0625470132,
-0.0738230795,
-0.0180896781,
-0.0380503498,
-0.0276468899,
0.0564942285,
-0.0710798278,
-0.0080892053,
0.0101521499,
-0.0067643938,
0.0416303873,
-0.0724510849,
-0.0309130028,
-0.0273576044,
0.0398270376,
-0.0041985242,
0.0624035522,
0.0195148177,
-0.02640309,
-0.0148906158,
0.035498213,
0.0544709153,
0.0206671078,
-0.0424957052,
0.0257436559,
0.0185641758,
0.0028194576,
0.0109421238,
0.0247537717,
-0.0090191504,
-0.0500403978,
-0.1379298419,
0.0040574726,
-0.0142835081,
0.0136240656,
0.0348364748,
-0.0002708006,
-0.0197278839,
0.0271222405,
-0.0243993197,
0.0009841811,
0.0019378146,
-0.0004321657,
0.0290520862,
-0.027824875,
0.0054829358,
-0.0153785786,
0.0078288475,
-0.0196273606,
0.0203538425,
0.0284126699,
0.0263,
-0.0086778533,
0.0201961324,
-0.0159557555,
0.0082442798,
-0.0172265731,
-0.0623577461,
-0.0059555587,
-0.0104619497,
0.0665941685,
0.0128466655,
0.0217307396,
0.0711420476,
-0.044615142,
0.0087257754,
-0.0040090452,
0.0446475446,
-0.0555671751,
-0.020297315,
-0.0327837616,
0.0098119769,
0.0072755385,
0.0699261352,
0.0249438081,
-0.0194887146,
-0.0907380134,
0.0183807071,
-0.0004485567,
0.0180322882,
0.029109329,
0.0033587478,
-0.0072272895,
-0.0209209304,
0.0272843689,
-0.0430339463,
0.0643691123,
-0.0105737727,
-0.0271178801,
-0.0580614284,
-0.029877793,
-0.0325884968,
0.0793575719,
0.0006299414,
-0.0032040046,
0.0156212365,
0.0306841359,
-0.0102772806,
-0.0079639051,
-0.0113271074,
-0.021886602,
0.0254740566,
0.0517005101,
-0.0123728001,
-0.0095120566,
-0.0344585702,
-0.0069108647,
-0.0560772456,
-0.0562576689,
-0.0314878859,
0.0485237055,
-0.0037344804,
0.0189583357,
0.0041113989,
-0.0503950641,
0.0050768703,
-0.0043653063,
-0.0410920084,
0.0072125597,
0.0047321199,
0.0065649762,
-0.0370160118,
0.0414068513,
0.0296251345,
-0.0025279357,
0.0596519299,
-0.0124969948,
-0.0044265548,
-0.0592835061,
-0.0226794425,
0.0071150069,
-0.0080234781,
-0.002870098,
-0.0377437286,
0.0216279086,
-0.0437869802,
0.0171299465,
0.1130657792,
0.022094015,
-0.0355284885,
-0.000377908,
0.0504010245,
-0.0121781593,
0.0177505556,
0.003038245,
-0.0759909451,
-0.055559434,
-0.0335939303,
0.0097474121,
-0.013274313,
0.0086089186,
-0.0123431515,
-0.0722269118,
0.058435481,
-0.0051063728,
-0.0013470266,
-0.0177378077,
-0.0085535925,
-0.0216317065,
-0.0150206406,
-0.009461971,
-0.0702965036,
0.0100076394,
0.022197064,
-0.0480409861,
-0.0418294594,
-0.0321017802,
0.0490799472,
0.0089892754,
0.0109152831,
0.059934482,
0.0549188554,
0.001862118,
-0.0236461703,
0.0176422112,
-0.049149096,
-0.0002576654,
-0.0343482308,
0.0782311559,
-0.0430145003,
-0.0053241248,
-0.0035032011,
-0.024565449,
-0.0659438148,
0.0173082184,
0.0043463153,
0.0909162983,
-0.0077800793,
-0.0514813699,
-0.0405664034,
0.0336143039,
0.028960688,
0.0605671629,
0.001929878,
-0.0322914645,
-0.0312959738,
-0.0072052013,
0.0464658625,
-0.0449644737,
-0.0476794057,
-0.0254402328,
0.0484292842,
-0.0208830144,
-0.0437545367,
-0.0577317998,
0.0066014058,
0.0262010936,
-0.0467821695,
-0.0089507867,
-0.028409142,
0.0118084708,
-0.0483419858,
0.0088837333,
0.0068954476,
-0.0029876253,
-0.013031981,
-0.0245396495,
0.0809617788,
-0.0076101115,
-0.0301585831,
-0.0028701811,
-0.0536883436,
-0.0243206173,
-0.0220792983,
0.0601441301,
0.0144150974,
-0.0049384614,
-0.0048295856,
-0.001628286,
0.0630471855,
0.0600341186,
-0.0279279128,
0.0202513766,
0.0607811548,
0.0486058518,
0.0128116552,
0.0181560125,
0.0240506567,
0.0759797618,
-0.0074701263,
-0.026325589,
-0.0110110333,
-0.0132147716,
-0.0006981445,
-0.033322379,
0.1029763296,
0.0068641114,
-0.0345236398,
-0.000389653,
-0.0072081136,
-0.0247270931,
0.0107039185,
-0.068388626,
-0.0387254432,
0.0169761106,
0.0038423371,
-0.0881169215,
-0.0065587517,
-0.0294826739,
0.0273146834,
-0.0366488583,
0.0585737638,
0.0455509387,
-0.0008846058,
-0.0054076579,
0.0372019485,
-0.0097595649,
-0.0539266467,
0.0254537333,
-0.03233115,
0.0026714269,
0.0783154443,
0.010470869,
0.0205047838,
0.0113516981,
0.0431454591,
-0.049603045,
0.0201099478,
-0.0138974255,
0.0016686084,
0.0354810096,
-0.0000012586,
0.053531941,
-0.0469762757,
-0.0161846727,
0.0176914595,
0.0411079414,
-0.0370923989,
-0.0181590952,
0.040207725,
-0.0070653297,
-0.0386761613,
-0.0327746756,
0.039923314,
-0.0607187115,
0.0402438939,
0.0450499132,
-0.0098345261,
-0.0517589599,
-0.0228753518,
0.0357929654,
-0.0528893918,
0.0244385619,
0.0198134538,
-0.0382037759,
-0.0574201047,
0.0498530343,
-0.0421073176,
0.0072759558,
-0.0064825281,
0.0258631837,
0.0524804294,
-0.0166883077,
0.0052334531,
-0.011191505,
0.0029727239,
-0.0338993743,
-0.0234231353,
-0.0009542915,
-6.523880506e-33,
-0.0111975605,
-0.0059452755,
-0.0122825075,
0.029582737,
-0.0284892805,
0.0191187616,
-0.0361394323,
-0.0080098193,
-0.0072020292,
0.0377707668,
-0.0166062154,
0.0282497965,
-0.0116828587,
0.0263278056,
-0.0033233592,
-0.0076761921,
0.061894808,
0.0002983009,
0.0046761553,
0.0361080542,
-0.0077875112,
0.0432961769,
0.0707506388,
-0.1007819548,
-0.0038011719,
-0.0183802284,
-0.0688169003,
0.0115353279,
0.0121583249,
0.0323416851,
-0.0124033783,
0.0859641507,
0.0317860357,
-0.0399936289,
0.0082860999,
0.0503252521,
-0.0135442642,
-0.0252672173,
-0.0429225527,
0.0010805457,
-0.011839767,
-0.0072517553,
0.0145831471,
-0.0084022796,
-0.0163368676,
-0.0323663726,
0.0128763672,
0.0100716129,
0.062424358,
-0.0727524385,
-0.0700975135,
0.0128345592,
0.0008408,
0.01745167,
0.0296346899,
0.0300304517,
0.0481970087,
0.0755998641,
-0.0461045913,
0.024294639,
-0.0298772249,
-0.0172632486,
-0.0260113049,
-0.0445589647,
0.0158223566,
0.0236109812,
0.0148558356,
0.0050545661,
-0.0432825461,
0.0255799759,
0.0192989632,
0.019070752,
0.0661964491,
0.0997761041,
0.0531754419,
-0.0513156094,
-0.0324611403,
0.00279552,
0.037234433,
-0.0095566157,
0.04360478,
-0.0004137994,
-0.0404490642,
0.0074500409,
0.0280237943,
-0.0128588593,
0.0118336519,
-0.0483689345,
0.0195548702,
0.031231679,
-0.0036004651,
0.0267112274,
0.003310866,
-0.0736787394,
0.0238529686,
0.0274958182,
-0.0561170802,
0.0212016776,
0.0003091571,
0.0206559487,
-0.0131977061,
-0.0226568002,
0.0291267317,
0.0309440382,
0.0056611304,
-0.0220760796,
0.0391129255,
0.0654409602,
-0.087019369,
0.0042769043,
-0.0082355952,
0.0394763947,
-0.0321357772,
0.0366304554,
-0.0147843072,
0.0236114264,
-0.0012293366,
0.0359728076,
0.0272045024,
0.0447528884,
-0.0266633835,
-0.0031618821,
0.0202446543,
0.020022383,
-0.0265375394,
-0.0326416753,
0.0120805223,
-0.0551459678,
0.0021308465,
-0.0948753878,
-0.0164749883,
-0.0269004628,
2.922e-7,
0.0626592934,
0.059096653,
-0.0033478455,
-0.0057494976,
0.0099434741,
0.0710914955,
0.0153433178,
0.0102176862,
-0.0031013924,
0.0132465623,
0.0593836121,
0.0274097733,
0.0006969658,
0.0328627713,
-0.1013907045,
0.0154781174,
-0.0562373288,
0.0225814544,
-0.0107445829,
0.0370425172,
0.1062468365,
0.1130912155,
0.0244401097,
-0.0118694464,
0.0110839633,
0.0036560749,
0.0739652589,
-0.0433487818,
0.0248628259,
0.0129211461,
-0.0203578789,
0.0218083281,
-0.0230132323,
-0.0173054431,
-0.0121879922,
0.0115930615,
-0.0217493903,
0.0696282908,
0.0069893952,
-0.0421029069,
0.0206271708,
0.0231923684,
0.0149680907,
-0.0481309071,
0.0326688066,
-0.0817518234,
-0.0340494812,
-0.031283997,
-0.0554674044,
-0.0101368176,
0.0670298785,
-0.0023699158,
-0.0214180481,
0.0234385487,
0.0072347689,
0.0054458394,
-0.0338633917,
-0.1089231446,
0.0254798215,
0.0076159309,
-0.0650483444,
-0.0119495429,
-0.0090952963,
0.0309162736,
0.0718615502,
-0.0091246013,
0.0129613495,
2.820758489e-34,
0.0463187397,
-0.0217458438,
0.0374065563,
-0.012764127,
0.022866847,
0.0182361994,
0.0190687589,
-0.0271883942,
0.0317774303,
-0.0171047393,
-0.0200679954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07948v1 | Model Adaptation for ASR in low-resource Indian Languages | 2023-07-16T05:25:51 | 2023-07-16T05:25:51 | Abhayjeet Singh, Arjun Singh Mehta, Ashish Khuraishi K S, Deekshitha G, Gauri Date, Jai Nanavati, Jesuraja Bandekar, Karnalius Basumatary, Karthika P, Sandhya Badiger, Sathvik Udupa, Saurabh Kumar, Savitha, Prasanta Kumar Ghosh, Prashanthi V, Priyanka Pai, Raoul Nanavati, Rohan Saxena, Sai Praneeth Reddy Mora, Srinivasa Raghavan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) performance has improved drastically in
recent years, mainly enabled by self-supervised learning (SSL) based acoustic
models such as wav2vec2 and large-scale multi-lingual training like Whisper. A
huge challenge still exists for low-resource languages where the availability
of both audio and text is limited. This is further complicated by the presence
of multiple dialects like in Indian languages. However, many Indian languages
can be grouped into the same families and share the same script and grammatical
structure. This is where a lot of adaptation and fine-tuning techniques can be
applied to overcome the low-resource nature of the data by utilising
well-resourced similar languages.
In such scenarios, it is important to understand the extent to which each
modality, like acoustics and text, is important in building a reliable ASR. It
could be the case that an abundance of acoustic data in a language reduces the
need for large text-only corpora. Or, due to the availability of various
pretrained acoustic models, the vice-versa could also be true. In this proposed
special session, we encourage the community to explore these ideas with the
data in two low-resource Indian languages of Bengali and Bhojpuri. These
approaches are not limited to Indian languages, the solutions are potentially
applicable to various languages spoken around the world. | [
0.0206340682,
0.0443021618,
-0.0095040035,
0.0439444706,
-0.0639427155,
0.0054963641,
0.0310257543,
0.0142740635,
0.0041754232,
-0.0186341051,
-0.0666736737,
-0.0130687254,
0.0243712347,
0.0315774493,
-0.0138926432,
-0.0402201936,
0.0143819284,
-0.0771074444,
0.0201289449,
-0.0198564809,
0.0172302481,
0.0265905317,
-0.0545134097,
-0.0121387625,
-0.0219378639,
0.0218338184,
0.0153494319,
0.0142348809,
0.0002674519,
-0.0075102174,
-0.021464048,
0.0395905413,
0.0116967494,
0.0198388826,
0.0000016685,
-0.068133913,
-0.0306873713,
0.0053605405,
-0.0303710941,
0.0025518662,
0.0454159975,
0.0136104953,
-0.014483043,
0.0479473844,
0.0059302473,
0.0283508096,
0.0833377987,
-0.0027554359,
-0.0010413594,
0.0821846873,
-0.0337052643,
-0.044815354,
-0.0033621376,
0.030789189,
-0.0198931638,
-0.0113026677,
-0.0186749753,
-0.036429137,
0.0030263725,
-0.0232256986,
-0.0150408912,
0.0393506102,
-0.0325524546,
-0.0399610028,
0.0072991452,
-0.0194400251,
-0.0502999946,
-0.0441585109,
0.0024660504,
0.0110651292,
-0.0227526892,
-0.0510330275,
0.0356576107,
-0.0075718947,
-0.0718027651,
-0.0098043326,
-0.0074560344,
-0.0026444225,
-0.0187647268,
0.0237820428,
0.0435533896,
0.0396248959,
-0.0089495825,
-0.0388346724,
0.0467211083,
-0.0061076805,
-0.0061749048,
-0.0152351391,
-0.0101145897,
-0.0208059177,
0.0225052163,
0.0358637087,
0.055305481,
0.0083405636,
0.0060978527,
0.0191299599,
-0.0192005225,
-0.052772101,
-0.0026982948,
-0.0532073192,
0.0490406714,
0.0525143296,
-0.0584696382,
0.0111738266,
-0.0091244923,
0.012252247,
0.0158675034,
-0.00100902,
-0.0147987949,
0.0208667163,
0.0157512762,
-0.0110442117,
-0.0332106315,
-0.0064644404,
-0.0444265231,
0.011862929,
-0.0291374102,
0.0216839146,
0.0059208018,
-0.0245447811,
0.0529302508,
-0.0507483147,
-0.0477661602,
-0.0526621379,
0.0395647101,
0.0192501582,
0.0272310227,
0.0480844676,
-0.0296034403,
-0.0849493667,
0.0070491699,
0.0391198993,
0.0283727255,
0.0232365392,
-0.0076421942,
0.0517645031,
-0.0111888442,
-0.0284718536,
-0.0813126862,
0.0748116001,
-0.0629824251,
-0.0635723397,
-0.0257233474,
-0.0318315998,
0.05781997,
0.0303618927,
-0.0015710095,
-0.0090600187,
-0.0197788458,
-0.0361088216,
0.0249504317,
0.0693988949,
-0.0161186419,
0.0174407493,
0.0695498139,
0.0097753592,
0.0516217723,
0.0498914197,
0.0272043087,
-0.0315303691,
0.0229517855,
-0.0631790236,
0.0056674755,
0.0451186411,
-0.0249803364,
0.008621525,
-0.0127144344,
0.0125062512,
0.0031860182,
-0.0077412971,
0.0076705697,
0.0503530428,
0.0189581905,
-0.0160345025,
0.0382970236,
0.0469934009,
0.0409135334,
0.03871575,
0.0121191628,
0.0078851292,
0.0385680534,
0.0228693206,
0.0224790033,
-0.0237608626,
-0.0305924453,
-0.0067233266,
0.0367508642,
0.0318856612,
-0.016604159,
-0.0027912213,
-0.0506414846,
-0.023277916,
-0.0369476825,
0.0203979854,
0.0825331137,
0.0113636078,
-0.0307458621,
-0.0148222828,
0.0724384859,
-0.0635440573,
0.0210196767,
-0.0498524569,
0.0234533846,
-0.0160651784,
-0.0003591736,
-0.0650453642,
-0.0004034563,
0.0236103386,
-0.0355297886,
0.0488885939,
0.0243104845,
0.0202047639,
0.0439374894,
-0.0674612671,
0.0236659255,
0.0679083019,
-0.0162722059,
0.0308129359,
-0.060747344,
0.0200151484,
-0.0085056657,
-0.0245983899,
-0.0152412606,
0.0014812014,
-0.0087195057,
-0.0006629404,
0.0445928052,
0.0216173716,
0.1058761403,
0.0335061811,
-0.0155668296,
-0.0398744233,
0.0364638604,
-0.0017799331,
0.0344592258,
0.0255084485,
-0.0611638874,
-0.033224456,
0.0158780254,
0.0058965753,
0.0757514387,
0.0017554571,
0.0309128761,
-0.0945072919,
0.0552348867,
-0.0303670093,
0.053086929,
-0.0112326974,
0.0737319216,
-0.0073578963,
0.0291312449,
0.0121068908,
-0.0070257434,
0.0644593313,
-0.0411112159,
-0.044283662,
0.0224831831,
0.0564143993,
-0.0839081183,
-0.0118473647,
0.0280657001,
-0.01335409,
0.0377219841,
0.0393811576,
-0.0064214235,
-0.0348345041,
-0.0178756248,
-0.0948270261,
-0.0461772196,
-0.0241386425,
0.0170246791,
-0.0311732963,
0.0587386265,
-0.0195442401,
-0.0541263744,
0.0055655614,
0.008013824,
0.0216017291,
-0.0134509858,
-0.0164377652,
-0.0084287794,
-0.0066430541,
0.0075709643,
-0.023812389,
0.0098640164,
0.006654195,
-0.007183257,
-0.0432895087,
-0.0520821288,
0.0118151912,
0.0207096301,
0.0237161387,
-0.0039112009,
-0.0349728018,
-0.0531310476,
-0.0144301848,
0.0215387866,
0.0234057195,
-0.0222775694,
-0.0102240751,
-0.0058275331,
0.0000410741,
-0.0195734836,
-0.0081916749,
0.036745362,
0.0038338241,
-0.0226604007,
0.0383711718,
-0.0215558987,
0.0201548822,
0.0039346139,
0.0129609648,
-0.0361058339,
-0.0600717776,
-0.0425619036,
-0.0144401947,
0.0013441308,
-0.0121822013,
-0.0433149524,
0.0478463136,
0.0288028661,
-0.0473321266,
0.0147584016,
-0.0867283195,
-0.0297207162,
-0.0942687467,
-0.0530077033,
-0.0372570343,
0.0054176198,
0.0015628716,
0.0062497491,
-0.0083196508,
-0.0496256873,
-0.0250876956,
0.0063661817,
0.0423948132,
-0.0234999955,
-0.0135721974,
-0.0325483531,
0.0589266717,
-0.0238294285,
-0.0443850979,
0.0088969143,
-0.0257211421,
-0.0102732833,
0.0050957594,
0.0199028756,
-0.0295405257,
-0.0096806679,
0.0829344466,
-0.0143050365,
0.0495878533,
0.0017828216,
0.0364570357,
-0.0037005199,
0.030845141,
0.0332479849,
0.0218099356,
-0.021282034,
0.0162701756,
0.0333770774,
-0.073435612,
0.0815569162,
-0.0240249503,
-0.0415003523,
0.0286401995,
0.0494467802,
0.000295153,
0.0277132224,
0.0153024187,
0.0574904531,
0.0209178533,
-0.0064658774,
0.0617357194,
-0.0115857841,
-0.0146478377,
-0.0279045124,
-0.0647220165,
0.0122100599,
-0.0216311216,
0.0108002191,
-0.0064159981,
0.0111140274,
0.0530727841,
0.0291425418,
0.0218760893,
0.0273295082,
-0.0095182722,
-0.0752909482,
0.0214354247,
0.0090172198,
-0.0411743596,
-0.0230947714,
-0.0607432276,
-0.0142307933,
-0.0492819622,
0.050041832,
0.0303575527,
-0.0476723872,
-0.0721584037,
0.0606562793,
-0.0804877207,
-0.0340773575,
-0.0141880708,
-0.0104652904,
0.0689939857,
0.0105260722,
-0.0417305231,
-0.0357960053,
0.0112756062,
0.0094867079,
-0.0155578125,
-0.0143522946,
-0.0211906862,
0.0312590711,
0.0097536491,
-0.019799903,
0.0221747532,
0.035717573,
-0.0017553051,
0.0066324766,
0.01103462,
0.0187041815,
0.0017919414,
-0.0189970098,
0.0066380752,
0.01805708,
-0.0049004192,
0.0157696363,
0.018210873,
-0.0194506608,
0.0027658974,
0.0425286107,
0.0260063987,
0.0121281939,
-0.0009437621,
0.0191005599,
-0.0374599099,
-0.0596533045,
0.0147452001,
-0.0090864329,
0.0088155959,
0.0617121868,
0.0537976511,
0.0611320287,
0.0032461749,
0.0485463776,
-0.0063837259,
-0.0336570479,
-0.0387673825,
0.003464838,
-0.0675908849,
-0.0230447073,
0.0423450358,
-0.042397581,
-0.0217334181,
-0.0603066497,
-0.0386189781,
-0.0575929992,
0.0550026,
0.0100213727,
0.0213824827,
0.0399112031,
-0.0329073556,
-0.0822909921,
0.0920519605,
-0.0020966395,
-0.0853530467,
0.0152967544,
0.0423355065,
0.0212823786,
-0.0285786036,
0.0143109979,
-0.0393595397,
0.022643337,
-0.022331506,
-0.0095233545,
-0.0102621485,
-0.0515504703,
0.0042001591,
0.0284265764,
0.0358653404,
-0.0452543497,
-0.0175865721,
-0.0417274125,
0.0222571325,
0.0256251264,
0.0437773541,
-0.0140567496,
-0.0132553456,
0.0207532905,
0.0396613739,
-0.020824058,
-0.018249549,
-0.039116323,
-0.0131624434,
0.0236036684,
0.1106310785,
0.0571026802,
0.0541008599,
0.0138888275,
0.0049547786,
-0.0056197383,
0.0362475179,
0.0327015705,
0.0214479584,
0.0102482559,
0.0154523663,
-0.0095714564,
0.0345404409,
0.0421561114,
0.0385531746,
0.0166650638,
0.0068008928,
-0.0228534713,
0.0385723785,
0.0248648301,
-0.0223242231,
0.0697192699,
-0.0054501998,
0.0265901685,
-0.0721328631,
0.0112575497,
-0.0360214151,
0.055868309,
0.0112476237,
-0.0244787596,
-0.0435801409,
0.064701803,
0.0101275193,
0.0223436877,
-0.008770531,
0.0368817858,
0.0324293226,
-0.0355854779,
-0.037436448,
-0.0088995388,
0.0024282166,
-0.0101206601,
0.0082420073,
-0.0244943798,
-0.0730946884,
0.0152324801,
-0.0279394891,
0.0409222096,
-0.0341400541,
-0.0104249921,
0.0304412358,
0.0100622512,
0.03741768,
-0.0019914042,
-0.0219174773,
-0.0079857158,
-0.0108804787,
0.0506742299,
-5.737646701e-33,
-0.0072917086,
0.0242522899,
-0.0310367402,
0.0050108875,
0.0154005773,
0.0099817449,
-0.0074050813,
-0.0044490611,
-0.0032884986,
-0.0180910043,
-0.0408009961,
-0.0265687238,
0.0457613431,
0.0051534213,
0.0178413857,
0.0188460145,
0.05083289,
0.0041781585,
0.0053131445,
-0.0199597646,
0.0225704815,
0.0222185794,
0.0524277873,
-0.0534049682,
-0.0404310338,
-0.036924731,
-0.00762907,
-0.0069903214,
0.0261790883,
0.057346642,
-0.0108434269,
0.0603166744,
-0.0006981201,
0.0339388177,
-0.0242803339,
0.0125565324,
-0.0961908773,
0.0246983059,
-0.0069455886,
0.098633267,
0.0004746509,
0.005718092,
0.0203058179,
0.0017678426,
-0.0662511215,
0.0125280647,
-0.0089914007,
0.0106079001,
-0.017037211,
-0.0238009878,
-0.0476115942,
0.0716967732,
-0.0115941642,
0.0007629358,
0.0644667745,
0.0369462334,
-0.0147835752,
-0.0737046003,
-0.0464368984,
0.0127118295,
0.0208896678,
0.0821787789,
0.0447828993,
0.0300671291,
-0.069751665,
-0.0247146562,
0.0566126741,
-0.1107271388,
0.0563371554,
-0.0213796627,
0.0368066095,
0.0036055676,
-0.0430186205,
0.010045453,
0.0284148976,
-0.0696601048,
-0.0289571472,
-0.0324075408,
0.046677988,
0.0265523512,
0.0155367488,
0.0277768299,
-0.0559578352,
-0.0138468621,
-0.0060400204,
-0.0361390449,
-0.0347275734,
-0.0210037045,
0.0731777698,
-0.0221765265,
0.0029852446,
0.0277479608,
0.0608831458,
-0.0108175334,
0.0212626364,
-0.0159610379,
-0.0111532276,
0.0002664705,
-0.0085114781,
0.0635841638,
-0.0376529545,
-0.0647478476,
0.0115798796,
0.042853944,
0.0004910799,
-0.0400403365,
0.0026998401,
0.0419626795,
-0.0666399226,
-0.0000107271,
0.0241582096,
0.0024052944,
-0.0048924298,
0.0587632768,
0.0157736093,
-0.0247462988,
-0.0056548081,
0.0228902642,
0.0246436186,
0.0153033379,
0.0057066428,
0.0252686478,
-0.007138459,
0.005302934,
-0.0187789779,
0.02346926,
-0.0038134996,
-0.0298884585,
0.0142444829,
0.0077417125,
0.016492635,
0.0144389281,
2.547e-7,
-0.0394480228,
0.0203234851,
0.0333599746,
-0.0964073688,
-0.0239874143,
0.0049084877,
-0.0373871513,
-0.0183229521,
-0.0214790199,
0.0428933203,
0.0260049924,
-0.0050098309,
0.0852232873,
0.0030189797,
-0.0619222485,
-0.0048203734,
-0.0873047784,
0.0329458639,
-0.0249349363,
0.0256942529,
-0.0413686112,
0.0727278888,
0.0060923942,
-0.0544442981,
-0.0199579652,
-0.0195783824,
0.0127399554,
-0.0125960605,
-0.0067557297,
0.018685976,
0.0017897665,
-0.0222228523,
-0.0515371338,
-0.0081311166,
-0.0376094319,
0.0628725365,
0.0101094292,
0.0236602053,
-0.0329483859,
-0.0121301729,
0.0380873345,
0.0818728358,
-0.03715875,
-0.0292634778,
0.03277798,
0.0527591594,
-0.0659888238,
-0.0240248851,
-0.0277566332,
-0.0015569315,
0.0234363973,
0.0127126975,
-0.002566728,
0.0146322213,
0.0233932119,
-0.0615128651,
-0.0472536087,
-0.0215315074,
0.0246202443,
0.0280655399,
-0.0209391657,
-0.0307751838,
-0.0128968861,
0.0303086098,
0.0548011437,
-0.0265280623,
0.0361459702,
1.87189853e-34,
0.0556513518,
-0.0347478203,
0.0020544375,
-0.0048034852,
0.0088681597,
-0.0434596874,
-0.0023953069,
0.0529966876,
0.0036306249,
-0.0690357909,
-0.0397417173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07946v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07946v2 | Unifying Token and Span Level Supervisions for Few-Shot Sequence Labeling | 2023-07-16T04:50:52 | 2023-07-20T02:01:34 | Zifeng Cheng, Qingyu Zhou, Zhiwei Jiang, Xuemin Zhao, Yunbo Cao, Qing Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot sequence labeling aims to identify novel classes based on only a few
labeled samples. Existing methods solve the data scarcity problem mainly by
designing token-level or span-level labeling models based on metric learning.
However, these methods are only trained at a single granularity (i.e., either
token level or span level) and have some weaknesses of the corresponding
granularity. In this paper, we first unify token and span level supervisions
and propose a Consistent Dual Adaptive Prototypical (CDAP) network for few-shot
sequence labeling. CDAP contains the token-level and span-level networks,
jointly trained at different granularities. To align the outputs of two
networks, we further propose a consistent loss to enable them to learn from
each other. During the inference phase, we propose a consistent greedy
inference algorithm that first adjusts the predicted probability and then
greedily selects non-overlapping spans with maximum probability. Extensive
experiments show that our model achieves new state-of-the-art results on three
benchmark datasets. | [
0.0429224372,
0.0365296975,
0.0087395953,
0.0014033845,
-0.0164250042,
0.0409615338,
0.0295231938,
-0.0083768889,
-0.0175424758,
-0.0183846448,
-0.0158313252,
-0.0359136425,
-0.0265383516,
0.0123667903,
0.0419771634,
-0.057215713,
0.0532140508,
0.0398354568,
0.0708981231,
0.0033944154,
-0.0073923375,
-0.0133974804,
-0.0188776031,
0.0189808626,
-0.0359504819,
0.0239918735,
0.0000364226,
-0.0102096172,
0.0102034509,
-0.0693404749,
0.0622097664,
0.0749518722,
0.0259318501,
0.0685901716,
0.0000020888,
-0.0274523664,
-0.0307238791,
0.00627098,
0.0007231286,
-0.00647004,
-0.0116780642,
0.0288071204,
0.0373402648,
-0.0304606613,
-0.0099622719,
-0.0484092012,
0.0702959299,
0.0601197556,
0.0318942778,
0.0424527302,
-0.0091583356,
-0.067038238,
-0.0022811473,
-0.0719474778,
0.0579159372,
-0.0795386732,
0.0341641717,
-0.0308192577,
-0.0063656047,
-0.0097704334,
-0.0150787057,
0.0367544442,
0.0057027354,
0.0064087952,
0.0322450921,
0.0611355603,
-0.0732621104,
-0.0677042976,
0.0149072977,
0.0715747401,
-0.0302038155,
-0.0094862562,
0.0360840037,
-0.0352451764,
0.0308380425,
-0.0754094124,
-0.0133588677,
0.0004310491,
-0.0195262954,
0.0392222479,
-0.0550096519,
0.0521604121,
0.0305519532,
0.0054434263,
-0.0335963145,
0.0072360253,
-0.0089885034,
-0.0184839964,
-0.0190406013,
0.0043354714,
-0.0154487211,
-0.0479745828,
0.0192426518,
0.0186871178,
-0.0240958594,
0.0178585611,
-0.0179566219,
-0.0641170815,
0.022672262,
0.012636086,
-0.0115427244,
0.0040620016,
-0.0448865965,
0.0512390397,
-0.0460322537,
0.0208228882,
0.0262214784,
0.0780653283,
-0.0011237548,
-0.0049145231,
-0.0456825495,
-0.008583352,
-0.0291775558,
0.0604457483,
0.0313916355,
0.0021442473,
-0.0859665051,
-0.0237157363,
-0.0157141965,
0.0551063865,
-0.0237315241,
0.0059141056,
-0.0356223807,
0.009891117,
0.0095433369,
0.0182330906,
-0.0585492626,
0.007410862,
0.0284157582,
-0.049748484,
-0.0339041501,
0.0446219444,
0.0055797542,
-0.009787376,
0.0110063283,
0.0989531726,
0.0021482764,
-0.0616416931,
-0.0589572601,
-0.0247731637,
-0.0556038655,
-0.0287208837,
-0.0088473111,
-0.0571027659,
0.02372225,
-0.0082678618,
-0.005007775,
-0.0146150636,
0.0055221254,
-0.017350167,
-0.0200413484,
0.0746369138,
-0.0152216917,
-0.0462083891,
0.0223964415,
0.0100259585,
0.0101152975,
0.0488697216,
0.0255554188,
0.0655590817,
0.0453743227,
0.017990116,
0.026012212,
0.020727288,
0.0510110259,
-0.0616095625,
-0.0397312716,
-0.0274603069,
0.0612813458,
0.0255454518,
0.0229078308,
-0.0009191792,
-0.0318470821,
-0.0280098878,
0.0331344083,
0.0323699601,
0.0083551146,
-0.0287515037,
0.021075787,
-0.0297535788,
-0.0398728624,
0.0222521126,
-0.0064374092,
0.0340308845,
0.050140921,
0.0108962767,
0.0525847636,
-0.0215223748,
-0.0425560884,
-0.0392626971,
-0.0004942117,
-0.0138859143,
-0.0853523612,
-0.0337550268,
0.0768708736,
0.0183734894,
-0.0344834998,
0.0521365963,
0.0352826044,
-0.0134005575,
-0.004967887,
-0.0068425545,
0.0306122806,
-0.0044470043,
0.0138106914,
-0.0838149861,
-0.057659965,
-0.0144724958,
0.0259410795,
0.0083542233,
0.0181782786,
-0.0169476867,
0.0192532632,
-0.0630408823,
-0.0255130678,
-0.0063966759,
0.0194628835,
0.0499763414,
-0.0053920327,
-0.018372884,
0.0302055776,
-0.0666449666,
-0.0236257277,
0.0294857975,
0.0099596409,
-0.0271019507,
0.0507385246,
0.0333942063,
0.050483197,
0.0000796902,
-0.0093591157,
0.0117424708,
0.0323299579,
-0.0395885073,
-0.0421078876,
-0.030098252,
-0.0656734928,
-0.0841620415,
0.0330605917,
-0.0213457178,
-0.0340671465,
-0.0571240596,
-0.0712437332,
-0.0359670632,
0.0075926436,
-0.0214556679,
-0.0038807553,
-0.0429553129,
-0.0050450959,
0.0078698751,
0.004441129,
-0.0754505545,
0.0873489305,
-0.0002080772,
0.0427092463,
-0.0091607636,
-0.0184988063,
0.0050668013,
-0.0282483213,
-0.0184271801,
0.0141780488,
-0.0153994998,
-0.0399378389,
0.0135044577,
-0.0117141409,
-0.0410156138,
-0.026610693,
0.0083751734,
-0.027152976,
0.0049726353,
0.0446008816,
-0.0103621632,
-0.0090818135,
0.022684522,
-0.0571529604,
-0.0481686704,
0.0146394204,
-0.0443579108,
-0.0051135747,
0.0714851171,
0.0370417945,
-0.0090926327,
-0.0034544631,
-0.0083732996,
-0.0115906466,
0.0260699932,
-0.0072660078,
-0.0719747692,
-0.0099700894,
-0.0499855205,
-0.0104556428,
0.0049955822,
-0.0097721079,
0.0064748875,
-0.0024719622,
-0.017943494,
-0.0237912014,
-0.0082577588,
0.0015362842,
0.0077425377,
-0.0055900207,
0.0001355586,
-0.020707747,
0.005094219,
-0.0401411057,
0.0152788246,
0.0150509737,
-0.0204083361,
0.0061577479,
0.0906627402,
-0.0172102787,
0.0387627073,
-0.0606337041,
-0.02853534,
0.0154127339,
-0.0400781184,
-0.0342988931,
0.0096819028,
-0.0232678019,
-0.0207628831,
-0.033965677,
-0.0430363081,
0.0776639059,
0.0018759076,
-0.0346040577,
-0.0000583566,
-0.0110457055,
-0.0279245768,
0.0241030958,
0.0377138555,
0.0182265136,
0.0257539414,
-0.0682758912,
-0.0441798605,
0.0026101691,
-0.0015757901,
-0.0201125722,
-0.0216671694,
-0.0229207613,
0.0097967051,
-0.0424494483,
-0.0137094101,
-0.0083202953,
-0.0063731507,
0.0031287756,
0.0097116828,
-0.0497554243,
0.0013918617,
-0.0895812064,
0.0271771029,
0.0279018227,
0.0823420063,
-0.0138302483,
0.0299283247,
-0.0135189965,
0.058029931,
0.0128107704,
-0.0227860324,
0.0002337099,
-0.0285902303,
0.0139547298,
0.0348889194,
0.0235309359,
0.0372667611,
0.0200261157,
0.0084664868,
0.0242399946,
-0.0104458034,
-0.0049898443,
0.0216668751,
0.0161011089,
-0.0141707314,
0.0041769044,
0.0898233205,
0.0190509874,
-0.0615366735,
0.0166735128,
0.0441200398,
0.0131664705,
0.0273901317,
-0.0171737652,
-0.0769343078,
-0.0472024009,
-0.0046236818,
0.0486725271,
-0.0118753836,
-0.0552286953,
-0.0120834233,
-0.0648905486,
-0.0030423985,
0.0101931011,
-0.1095318496,
-0.0032863512,
-0.0127095906,
0.0141711636,
-0.0246408544,
-0.011105001,
-0.01064952,
0.0315866508,
0.0073964032,
0.0650436729,
0.0011463461,
-0.0507430062,
-0.0310205854,
-0.0501215532,
0.0360598378,
0.0295762401,
-0.006597586,
0.0008120233,
0.0015241837,
0.027396014,
-0.0308444835,
-0.0111971861,
-0.00273952,
0.0757249892,
-0.0126380743,
-0.0493062735,
0.0118431654,
0.023041917,
-0.0170468837,
-0.0193519257,
-0.0022016179,
0.053705316,
0.0205496959,
-0.0132314954,
-0.009526669,
-0.011479225,
-0.0064053843,
0.0422975905,
0.0527326502,
-0.0191227198,
0.0143681765,
0.0185253303,
0.0362467766,
-0.0862513632,
0.0431450792,
0.0424219444,
-0.0617863648,
-0.1283152997,
-0.0400211103,
0.0037257546,
0.0408883393,
0.0602603778,
0.0002772203,
-0.0005794075,
-0.0056425226,
-0.0285986643,
-0.0349372216,
-0.0167959612,
-0.0072881584,
-0.0136727076,
-0.0614935644,
-0.0068100714,
0.0320642143,
-0.0082300957,
-0.0327944383,
0.0224896986,
-0.056186527,
-0.0576508567,
0.0002601043,
0.0103135668,
0.0072965324,
-0.0129808905,
-0.0076732142,
-0.0638576671,
0.0699006468,
0.130585745,
0.018045431,
-0.0131340828,
0.0244770832,
-0.0241897218,
-0.0424920917,
0.0097730868,
-0.0577002913,
0.0524144843,
0.0471425056,
0.029203428,
-0.0288767572,
0.0335009322,
0.0104988245,
-0.0030730648,
0.0858192891,
-0.0345321409,
-0.0110858241,
-0.0464604236,
0.0449153893,
0.037279103,
-0.0285190493,
0.0017518962,
-0.0142578529,
-0.0043593273,
0.0050429339,
-0.0333820432,
0.0230909344,
0.0250629783,
0.0429146215,
-0.0604269952,
-0.0215753391,
-0.0159951821,
0.0330187753,
-0.0262724739,
0.0096939802,
-0.0172257051,
0.0071854377,
0.0307818688,
0.0180485584,
-0.0367561169,
0.0003397032,
0.0666954592,
0.0602405369,
0.0008596837,
0.0254944861,
-0.0250829663,
0.056655962,
-0.041873578,
0.0370485149,
0.0430465527,
-0.0094286418,
-0.0405961089,
0.0135408156,
-0.0182463229,
-0.0173077043,
0.0274003111,
-0.0193311684,
-0.0440082029,
0.0375318341,
0.015677331,
-0.0151919397,
-0.0163085088,
0.0901772454,
-0.0043800124,
0.0614328012,
-0.0451178253,
-0.0105126947,
-0.0244593062,
0.0088924402,
0.048406098,
0.0184652805,
-0.0087169511,
-0.0147068566,
-0.0371532366,
-0.0113137262,
0.0038938082,
-0.015004484,
0.0144391032,
0.0524347872,
0.0434997566,
0.0206100866,
0.0037006312,
-0.0120019689,
-0.0014520126,
0.0067427461,
0.0661815554,
-0.0252442118,
0.0259953979,
-6.807074727e-33,
-0.0103804674,
-0.0434766412,
-0.0299533885,
-0.0133899031,
0.0006392967,
0.0054554255,
-0.0200697947,
-0.0173103288,
0.0049819606,
0.00518829,
0.0121233938,
-0.0260314457,
0.0194374081,
0.0190273467,
0.0411390141,
-0.0341653787,
0.04535532,
0.0169974957,
-0.0271557681,
0.0410000868,
0.0291620977,
0.0307943989,
0.0982925594,
-0.0401614755,
-0.0179063324,
0.0292545669,
0.0067160279,
-0.000733042,
0.0270016976,
0.0188484062,
0.012418787,
0.0371869504,
0.0408383384,
-0.0255723894,
-0.0162593517,
-0.0065848357,
-0.0877301842,
-0.0507295951,
-0.0400116928,
0.0228386838,
-0.0023155781,
-0.0447316393,
0.0454321876,
-0.021241745,
0.0126139708,
0.007861238,
0.0612810627,
-0.0062105046,
-0.0413557589,
-0.0403824784,
0.0039150533,
0.0504348353,
-0.0061739734,
0.0260545854,
0.0307516214,
0.0373070352,
0.0254245289,
0.0712106377,
-0.0149740018,
0.0317406878,
-0.00367656,
0.0566218384,
0.0216658935,
0.0544570722,
-0.0208957884,
0.0585332289,
0.0444974378,
-0.0328947268,
0.0319273844,
-0.0279961191,
-0.0206540823,
0.0195286702,
0.0428221785,
0.0110125169,
0.0333527029,
-0.0031042364,
-0.0669822916,
0.0278335586,
0.0087054344,
0.0214109439,
0.0019621658,
0.0459632948,
0.0089520374,
-0.0074243005,
0.0000637383,
-0.0365459286,
-0.0485652909,
0.0224482343,
0.0062744385,
0.0223599412,
-0.0264447108,
0.0742375925,
0.0081651332,
0.0173760597,
-0.037491478,
-0.0378157683,
0.0319543332,
0.0144737046,
0.0001568821,
-0.0124922823,
-0.067867294,
-0.0370232016,
0.0592168644,
0.0216877572,
0.0236860737,
-0.0029961937,
0.1042356864,
-0.0167491548,
-0.052732788,
0.0082367426,
-0.0262698438,
-0.0171836577,
0.0155693181,
-0.0134750959,
0.022259675,
-0.0038026578,
-0.0265936535,
0.0534773916,
0.0263691992,
-0.031295184,
0.0223705899,
0.0126162991,
0.0021201479,
0.0340585746,
-0.0359916165,
-0.0101355519,
0.0029110138,
-0.0009974224,
0.0236067101,
-0.0381282642,
-0.0157284159,
0.0318735167,
3.048e-7,
0.0108870799,
0.0129572833,
0.0286176186,
-0.0526837595,
0.0302213021,
0.0510562807,
-0.0388936214,
0.0456949584,
-0.0591514297,
-0.0216163602,
0.0321943723,
-0.0479747392,
0.0171399489,
0.0261484813,
-0.0872876048,
0.044026155,
-0.079953596,
0.0445873104,
-0.0435761623,
0.0325939544,
0.0763527527,
0.0847739205,
0.0377713963,
-0.007465994,
0.0147170797,
-0.0505432859,
-0.0045188917,
0.0300753769,
0.0273298696,
0.0089233154,
0.016113922,
0.0384520516,
-0.0196235906,
0.0470390618,
-0.0366538242,
-0.0046606222,
0.0285921767,
0.0065345601,
-0.0073983595,
-0.0046378034,
0.008260252,
0.0425315872,
0.0149757145,
-0.0306550153,
0.0513001718,
-0.0674034432,
-0.0404245369,
0.0243805964,
-0.0395665057,
0.0163895506,
-0.00332823,
0.0173451304,
-0.0201773252,
0.0417304449,
0.0292748716,
-0.002382675,
-0.0294072088,
-0.0766094998,
0.036427848,
-0.0049188621,
-0.0206155758,
0.0190156866,
-0.0530786663,
0.021161411,
-0.0008762727,
-0.0725403354,
-0.0129257953,
2.812831937e-34,
0.0164033622,
-0.0396341123,
-0.0383230522,
-0.0004448302,
-0.0104940264,
-0.0172229055,
-0.0686176941,
0.0272391308,
-0.0049643987,
-0.0256686006,
-0.0185164139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07940v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07940v2 | Deduplicating and Ranking Solution Programs for Suggesting Reference Solutions | 2023-07-16T04:20:26 | 2023-09-11T09:42:37 | Atsushi Shirafuji, Yutaka Watanobe | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.PL | Referring to solution programs written by other users is helpful for learners
in programming education. However, current online judge systems just list all
solution programs submitted by users for references, and the programs are
sorted based on the submission date and time, execution time, or user rating,
ignoring to what extent the programs can be helpful to be referenced. In
addition, users struggle to refer to a variety of solution approaches since
there are too many duplicated and near-duplicated programs. To motivate
learners to refer to various solutions to learn better solution approaches, in
this paper, we propose an approach to deduplicate and rank common solution
programs in each programming problem. Inspired by the nature that the
many-duplicated program adopts a more common approach and can be a general
reference, we remove the near-duplicated solution programs and rank the unique
programs based on the duplicate count. The experiments on the solution programs
submitted to a real-world online judge system demonstrate that the number of
programs is reduced by 60.20%, whereas the baseline only reduces by 29.59%
after the deduplication, meaning that users only need to refer to 39.80% of
programs on average. Furthermore, our analysis shows that top-10 ranked
programs cover 29.95% of programs on average, indicating that users can grasp
29.95% of solution approaches by referring to only 10 programs. The proposed
approach shows the potential of reducing the learners' burden of referring to
too many solutions and motivating them to learn a variety of solution
approaches. | [
0.0448795073,
0.0036268176,
-0.0279976837,
-0.0203252286,
0.0081138099,
-0.0024038521,
0.0178254824,
-0.0046528107,
0.0042800354,
-0.0144460117,
-0.0271970388,
0.0987593755,
0.0199398827,
-0.0212566033,
-0.0241384413,
-0.0873611718,
-0.0034406595,
-0.0006789484,
0.039122045,
-0.0048983139,
0.0532195307,
-0.0045562573,
-0.0316178054,
0.0554292649,
0.0094448933,
-0.0387470238,
0.0234286152,
-0.0439459048,
-0.017541388,
-0.0556943193,
-0.027261151,
0.0485647507,
-0.0178004168,
-0.0061058616,
0.0000023457,
-0.0439988934,
-0.0357895046,
-0.0242325924,
-0.0445530564,
0.0645015389,
-0.013243828,
0.0951102972,
0.037765827,
-0.0023896343,
-0.0142247425,
-0.0095883301,
0.0138286995,
0.0255542491,
0.0850725323,
-0.0402921923,
0.0360484384,
0.0192180499,
-0.0228421055,
0.0395742357,
0.0406789444,
-0.0142580429,
-0.0233749896,
0.080846861,
0.0639436319,
0.0068792375,
0.0021698116,
0.0057692411,
-0.0200042948,
-0.0015703331,
0.0687315762,
0.0187945645,
-0.0450000614,
0.0061966786,
0.0343887284,
0.0420121476,
-0.0190012213,
-0.0369607285,
0.0128814084,
-0.0191473272,
0.0357147828,
0.0753214657,
-0.0678692907,
-0.009807175,
0.000538358,
-0.0282837171,
-0.0193445608,
0.0092440378,
-0.0249380935,
-0.0058945292,
0.0593240708,
0.0122861881,
-0.0194413867,
-0.013857957,
0.0369852483,
0.0602247566,
0.0346571729,
-0.0236332156,
0.0329590887,
0.0143031692,
-0.0513190776,
-0.0001378881,
0.0303860065,
-0.0042341566,
0.0040937518,
-0.0207719188,
0.0828802064,
0.0093181273,
0.043922022,
0.0266003627,
-0.0312873498,
0.037464764,
0.0064038089,
-0.0453433134,
-0.0192372054,
0.0344772898,
-0.0883377045,
-0.0223624781,
-0.0533881746,
0.0973614156,
0.0772166848,
0.0169261321,
-0.0369597487,
0.0137980487,
-0.0585012846,
0.0016407893,
-0.0242998544,
0.0391035005,
0.0152907111,
0.0380855091,
-0.0477585457,
-0.0041716541,
-0.0629478768,
-0.0165240709,
-0.0621396266,
-0.0001846944,
0.0201844964,
-0.0173366889,
-0.0165904053,
0.0056552268,
0.0173228458,
-0.0069834455,
0.0012469286,
0.0318938047,
-0.0219185073,
-0.0507158376,
0.0427863039,
0.0451270789,
-0.0665449202,
-0.0910148621,
-0.0385648683,
0.036808379,
0.0350496061,
0.0204501357,
0.0047665848,
0.017317906,
-0.0097728288,
0.0241529103,
-0.0202444717,
0.0295185223,
0.0773279145,
0.0604263321,
-0.0178220309,
-0.0239961222,
-0.0287234746,
-0.0059431563,
-0.0056840754,
-0.0322747044,
0.0742505789,
-0.0373898633,
-0.0165929012,
-0.0205737613,
0.0484119169,
0.0294156987,
-0.0083074365,
0.0227403287,
-0.0715612918,
-0.0139611196,
-0.0468889959,
0.0866012126,
0.0018523061,
0.0033890207,
0.0068499246,
0.0352391228,
-0.0195028204,
0.0627432764,
0.0435006954,
-0.0159409624,
-0.0130412746,
0.1162917987,
0.0080814203,
-0.0017079418,
0.0135687711,
-0.0134108467,
-0.0249701794,
-0.0338807739,
-0.0064658946,
0.0457540229,
-0.027643159,
0.0087408721,
0.0206880979,
0.0191463102,
0.0181319099,
0.059333168,
-0.0099416627,
-0.0378638431,
-0.0326010771,
-0.0398952216,
0.0471046418,
0.0616137497,
0.0447553992,
-0.0231472552,
0.0068908995,
0.0023060364,
0.0292375349,
-0.0719875395,
0.0525412969,
-0.0354971066,
-0.0297051668,
-0.0115395356,
-0.0538083725,
-0.0178991985,
-0.02532457,
0.0187002849,
0.0406187512,
0.0020809018,
-0.0058130664,
-0.0364217237,
-0.0067067295,
0.0209689401,
0.0329942182,
-0.0158593711,
-0.0109297326,
0.0003297658,
0.0114599047,
0.0207966883,
0.0289040264,
0.010763932,
0.0277140383,
-0.0025568323,
-0.021448765,
-0.0476580262,
-0.011400993,
0.0608510189,
0.0164952017,
-0.1014619023,
0.0048437463,
-0.0161958393,
0.0026443824,
0.0148022482,
0.046580486,
-0.0162596405,
0.0263026748,
0.0396759696,
0.0248280484,
-0.0343098342,
-0.0762726516,
-0.0022200115,
0.0624528453,
0.0591195859,
0.0402650908,
0.0611704364,
-0.0239969585,
0.0294729024,
-0.0114214346,
-0.0231936742,
-0.0465975292,
-0.0215087123,
0.0240341164,
0.0075531122,
0.0135975219,
-0.0295421891,
0.0213847756,
-0.0123141427,
-0.0462215059,
0.0471931957,
0.008852412,
-0.0268479045,
-0.0308680553,
-0.0040739118,
-0.0470702872,
-0.0176212359,
-0.0327635929,
-0.006246205,
0.005303273,
0.0206932724,
0.0221085697,
-0.0007653754,
-0.0410407931,
-0.0090365941,
-0.0209342595,
0.0353428721,
0.0313279703,
-0.0091605913,
-0.0754895657,
0.0649095774,
-0.0138437701,
-0.0434584804,
0.0352866687,
0.0371941924,
0.0200831667,
0.0006694235,
0.0309766177,
0.0046982151,
-0.0173764434,
0.0161112584,
0.0789418072,
-0.0197495017,
-0.1161314845,
-0.0019640923,
0.0468653962,
-0.0369808786,
0.0824510157,
-0.0525155254,
0.0203358699,
-0.0396462232,
0.0064543993,
-0.0032206387,
0.0346249305,
0.0560524091,
-0.005700842,
0.0068572648,
-0.0849763229,
-0.0533427037,
0.0183105748,
-0.0464545153,
0.018051656,
-0.0461693741,
0.0765227005,
0.008205547,
0.014011885,
-0.0386754535,
0.0108530577,
-0.0174496341,
0.010765275,
-0.0451131724,
0.0249013826,
-0.0203989036,
-0.0114750406,
-0.0184226073,
0.0092723956,
0.0846788436,
-0.0358654708,
0.0408745185,
-0.0156561825,
-0.0241694078,
0.019545,
-0.0215854403,
-0.0438100062,
0.0022596698,
-0.0104130497,
-0.0600198954,
0.0065488503,
0.0253191963,
-0.0144017609,
-0.0056853131,
0.0785276964,
-0.0351327807,
0.0421300717,
-0.0651467517,
0.0494872592,
-0.006993202,
-0.0264962278,
-0.0293108523,
0.0014656893,
-0.0375306234,
-0.0268840007,
0.0453916639,
0.0733409896,
-0.0233117044,
-0.0015055577,
-0.0297468379,
0.0319471993,
-0.0695307329,
-0.0095463702,
0.0177621953,
-0.0294736754,
-0.0290038008,
0.0211834572,
0.0508536473,
0.0693491399,
-0.0514383987,
-0.007899751,
-0.0330049694,
0.0181964636,
0.0464969985,
0.0455378555,
-0.0883441344,
-0.008368725,
-0.0349583104,
0.0305944849,
-0.0223874189,
-0.0070107798,
-0.0105844075,
-0.0786771849,
-0.037220072,
-0.0005847855,
-0.0084541915,
0.0154990349,
-0.0004232212,
-0.0184503067,
0.0022640391,
-0.0713550672,
0.0335335098,
-0.0352453999,
0.0646213591,
0.0270352233,
-0.0237939656,
0.0281600002,
0.018180158,
-0.0095211398,
0.0032422682,
0.0161370486,
-0.0072033624,
-0.0042492119,
-0.022661943,
0.0056938813,
-0.0416302979,
0.006672598,
-0.0129784122,
0.0247486364,
-0.0075447531,
0.0080046142,
-0.0503077507,
-0.018229207,
-0.0062283999,
-0.0147645045,
0.0720470324,
0.0133446828,
0.0199910495,
-0.0115751652,
-0.043544475,
-0.0137790889,
-0.0247764178,
0.015975086,
0.0250606537,
0.0125425141,
0.0511084646,
-0.0589829721,
-0.0064628823,
0.0320249945,
-0.0210754648,
-0.0593943819,
-0.0518305004,
0.0375396125,
-0.0463694111,
0.0378444232,
0.047348801,
0.0327909999,
0.0025357725,
0.011725001,
-0.0003043568,
0.0412427932,
-0.0073877284,
0.0103012649,
0.005285948,
-0.017188089,
-0.0424819514,
-0.0226686299,
-0.0171286296,
-0.0158047061,
-0.016851183,
0.0372414067,
-0.0004810657,
0.0110941101,
-0.0569820292,
0.0372135676,
0.0212395322,
-0.0648219809,
-0.0119838612,
-0.0212228317,
-0.0508550107,
0.0064791082,
0.0507463925,
-0.002424448,
-0.0512730107,
-0.0267076027,
0.0377948247,
-0.0417664088,
-0.0503823124,
-0.0156405121,
0.0103723705,
0.010796546,
-0.0215091091,
0.0263703689,
0.034858007,
0.0580753237,
0.0104497606,
0.0294661988,
0.0400943719,
0.0066405623,
0.0109507963,
0.0128140301,
-0.0412616469,
0.0240369346,
0.0562895499,
-0.0265317596,
0.0077793729,
0.0159763303,
0.0374052562,
0.0165601,
0.0366808586,
0.0039888076,
0.0162967946,
0.0434180647,
-0.0007444771,
-0.0058028139,
-0.0154871363,
-0.0229486935,
-0.0246487204,
0.024824854,
0.0431834236,
-0.0200672932,
0.0351551659,
-0.0153382029,
0.0333183743,
0.0129141537,
0.0164602865,
-0.0163226742,
-0.0949331522,
-0.0013490504,
0.019090822,
0.0049810396,
0.0617928095,
0.0036197631,
0.0144592654,
0.0016569474,
-0.0065221079,
0.0075243586,
-0.0427538045,
-0.0081926277,
-0.0275914185,
0.0449149907,
0.0276761297,
-0.0102915075,
0.0612417459,
-0.0615282506,
-0.0585850924,
-0.0508853905,
-0.0595255494,
-0.0112957284,
0.039103251,
-0.019516129,
0.057009615,
-0.0111914929,
-0.0681926161,
-0.038736973,
-0.0306908917,
-0.0455902629,
0.0205577947,
0.028675925,
0.037026044,
0.0772596672,
0.0473398529,
0.005172811,
-0.0301898122,
0.0230219141,
0.0109919859,
-0.0339771472,
-0.0256225001,
-0.0177737735,
-5.586592738e-33,
-0.0035643391,
-0.0197813287,
-0.0212455411,
-0.017651258,
0.0468121991,
-0.0369453803,
-0.0080702808,
0.0665168688,
-0.0112144863,
-0.0139958793,
0.0086693568,
-0.0216516461,
0.0112143066,
-0.0646555722,
0.0762092993,
0.0249140915,
0.0350829177,
0.0368877761,
-0.0420019552,
0.035610836,
-0.0131199099,
-0.0146327391,
0.0130767412,
-0.0788605511,
-0.0195548292,
-0.0134053342,
0.018657865,
-0.0573671684,
0.0040529617,
0.0406613499,
0.014041163,
0.0273830332,
-0.0193594638,
-0.0290979166,
-0.0387536287,
-0.025979761,
-0.0499705896,
-0.0587659255,
0.0284434725,
-0.0666605011,
0.0374782681,
-0.0166670363,
0.0396581553,
0.0111181745,
-0.0347095542,
0.0545591228,
0.0502701551,
-0.0052182572,
0.000895269,
0.012285158,
-0.0191691238,
-0.0173579026,
-0.0371535905,
0.0387014858,
-0.0355270468,
0.0547444671,
-0.0467472114,
0.0047017122,
-0.0234395266,
0.0782105476,
-0.0044399714,
0.0441027656,
0.0910287052,
-0.0584543981,
-0.0339123495,
-0.0104286522,
0.0174388699,
-0.0527745858,
0.0239717867,
-0.0561004654,
0.0030713896,
0.0052913139,
0.0809368864,
0.0332109593,
0.063784793,
-0.0020875873,
0.0020653221,
0.0328791067,
0.0155106476,
-0.0272944849,
0.0116415117,
0.0057830983,
-0.0851657093,
-0.0292681456,
-0.0029561862,
0.0274692755,
-0.0374675728,
-0.0435982421,
0.0635089278,
0.0063650305,
-0.0060847141,
-0.0091996463,
-0.056628447,
0.0022331472,
-0.0728362277,
0.0164402928,
0.0074618515,
0.0273445975,
-0.0145681296,
-0.0295936614,
-0.0683962777,
0.0084513891,
-0.0213465262,
0.0085777529,
0.0505304374,
0.0219497699,
-0.0022315022,
-0.0505382121,
-0.0676470399,
0.017106764,
0.0061067995,
-0.0625417456,
-0.0059815929,
-0.0171073414,
0.0024970961,
-0.0046829409,
0.0190437455,
-0.0001685158,
-0.0213574599,
-0.0335593484,
-0.0569223017,
-0.0117038256,
0.0008322521,
-0.0400772057,
0.0330315791,
-0.0022095942,
-0.0439884849,
0.0239971001,
0.0142596811,
-0.001759198,
-0.0463424176,
-0.0083404919,
2.848e-7,
-0.0117540723,
0.0115890652,
-0.0163716972,
-0.0117048407,
-0.0223661792,
0.0146043459,
-0.0029582083,
0.0296792053,
0.0593705028,
0.0471121669,
-0.0144538777,
-0.0152053731,
-0.0124578709,
0.0409169309,
-0.0421818569,
-0.0760597959,
-0.0138966357,
-0.0266968217,
-0.0537123755,
-0.0056974278,
0.069126077,
-0.0162962321,
0.0575254746,
0.0479481593,
-0.0198979098,
-0.050842084,
-0.0107746441,
-0.0149498247,
0.0534101725,
-0.0042415629,
-0.0130975312,
-0.0016065589,
-0.0070113596,
0.0150072556,
0.008618461,
-0.0518141165,
0.0434101522,
-0.002326044,
0.0195879489,
0.0028366502,
0.0373306051,
-0.0113723194,
-0.0025658086,
-0.0390580446,
-0.0094073983,
-0.0250549037,
0.0315986536,
0.0490022041,
-0.0335455984,
-0.039494928,
-0.0069823372,
0.0127873234,
-0.0087649273,
-0.0273575503,
-0.0249778256,
-0.0314985663,
-0.0437908396,
0.0038394621,
-0.0168647747,
0.0083318613,
0.0182794686,
-0.0345216841,
-0.0208944902,
-0.0206252616,
0.0100037949,
0.0115346806,
0.0124039929,
2.159703628e-34,
-0.025230661,
-0.0028221582,
0.0899668485,
-0.0156902913,
0.0169409793,
0.0373418555,
-0.055027537,
-0.0095135327,
0.0201884806,
0.0409553796,
-0.028937187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07930v1 | GeoGPT: Understanding and Processing Geospatial Tasks through An Autonomous GPT | 2023-07-16T03:03:59 | 2023-07-16T03:03:59 | Yifan Zhang, Cheng Wei, Shangyou Wu, Zhengting He, Wenhao Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Decision-makers in GIS need to combine a series of spatial algorithms and
operations to solve geospatial tasks. For example, in the task of facility
siting, the Buffer tool is usually first used to locate areas close or away
from some specific entities; then, the Intersect or Erase tool is used to
select candidate areas satisfied multiple requirements. Though professionals
can easily understand and solve these geospatial tasks by sequentially
utilizing relevant tools, it is difficult for non-professionals to handle these
problems. Recently, Generative Pre-trained Transformer (e.g., ChatGPT) presents
strong performance in semantic understanding and reasoning. Especially, AutoGPT
can further extend the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) by
automatically reasoning and calling externally defined tools. Inspired by these
studies, we attempt to lower the threshold of non-professional users to solve
geospatial tasks by integrating the semantic understanding ability inherent in
LLMs with mature tools within the GIS community. Specifically, we develop a new
framework called GeoGPT that can conduct geospatial data collection,
processing, and analysis in an autonomous manner with the instruction of only
natural language. In other words, GeoGPT is used to understand the demands of
non-professional users merely based on input natural language descriptions, and
then think, plan, and execute defined GIS tools to output final effective
results. Several cases including geospatial data crawling, spatial query,
facility siting, and mapping validate the effectiveness of our framework.
Though limited cases are presented in this paper, GeoGPT can be further
extended to various tasks by equipping with more GIS tools, and we think the
paradigm of "foundational plus professional" implied in GeoGPT provides an
effective way to develop next-generation GIS in this era of large foundation
models. | [
0.04501158,
0.0641373321,
-0.0085835354,
0.0017216678,
-0.0532377586,
-0.004588264,
-0.0028398617,
-0.049652122,
0.0046152109,
-0.037620984,
-0.0202721227,
0.0344347544,
0.0026029155,
0.0359770618,
-0.003380592,
-0.1114045829,
0.0129352259,
-0.0288010631,
0.0005637763,
0.0226217136,
-0.0119436923,
0.0214435924,
-0.0124355871,
0.0245518591,
-0.0152481981,
0.0185269862,
-0.0304962974,
-0.0034642681,
0.0060898983,
-0.0189261679,
0.0024928798,
0.023983499,
0.035695605,
0.0296644606,
0.0000021751,
-0.010857394,
-0.0508545041,
0.0364786424,
0.0328839533,
-0.0266323183,
0.0073870812,
0.0075763944,
-0.0029034861,
-0.0047206352,
-0.0587618016,
-0.0188418869,
0.0545117185,
0.0410789438,
0.0955408663,
0.0463714525,
-0.0234960951,
-0.0735159293,
-0.0029529445,
0.0096013444,
0.0047857016,
-0.010836577,
-0.0009100003,
0.0189915691,
0.0257763769,
0.0846713781,
-0.0178021081,
-0.004992621,
0.0138528952,
0.0103073781,
-0.0063155643,
0.0495434105,
-0.0286590979,
0.0106525924,
-0.0199865494,
0.0084033068,
-0.0469047725,
-0.0199862868,
0.0567420013,
0.0123636015,
-0.0289999042,
0.0417585522,
-0.0656145588,
0.0235052276,
-0.0198888183,
0.0313251987,
-0.0486831926,
0.0033882526,
-0.0026068969,
0.0112289228,
-0.0394085646,
0.0943258032,
-0.014482256,
-0.0218486413,
-0.0543604232,
0.0153346397,
-0.0031855456,
-0.0852141678,
-0.0057707336,
0.0564569719,
-0.0182851143,
0.0022784311,
0.010210772,
0.052031178,
0.0012318991,
-0.000092652,
-0.013369699,
0.0354789831,
-0.022504583,
0.0669660866,
-0.0235600565,
0.0390233658,
-0.0213900451,
0.0796972439,
0.0152029861,
-0.023872111,
-0.0467095263,
-0.034945149,
-0.0716195107,
0.0220682789,
-0.047880806,
0.0072642667,
0.0186086893,
0.038241189,
-0.0136669585,
0.0012064389,
-0.0174781885,
0.0276984349,
-0.0296620615,
-0.0485909507,
-0.0433963165,
-0.0221233312,
-0.0130423466,
-0.0056195152,
-0.0095324507,
-0.0315288305,
0.0280905366,
0.0342012085,
0.0286652669,
0.0007901269,
-0.0240783133,
0.0593319312,
0.0146110319,
0.013176675,
-0.0901616141,
-0.0089874221,
0.0193323586,
-0.0520439819,
0.0096759712,
-0.0559776798,
-0.0144742178,
0.0191815645,
-0.0251683313,
-0.0183065347,
-0.0304259658,
0.0207249951,
-0.0151232043,
0.063110292,
-0.0468452424,
0.0370499939,
0.0631251931,
0.0118718259,
0.0353880264,
0.0789082646,
0.0100277374,
0.0846615061,
0.0067321691,
-0.0117618116,
0.0328324623,
0.0145374062,
-0.0226547066,
0.0023979968,
-0.0005449647,
0.0312299188,
-0.0340225622,
0.0159955155,
0.0158683956,
0.0672089309,
-0.021633165,
0.032756649,
0.0396674275,
0.0644095838,
0.0265987404,
0.0449576601,
0.0907530263,
0.1141218022,
-0.0665236861,
-0.0038615395,
-0.0470527112,
0.0029785046,
-0.0332220271,
-0.0087179895,
-0.0283838958,
0.0358357951,
0.0022761363,
-0.0447945483,
-0.0014684757,
0.0176635738,
0.0342020392,
-0.0159386639,
0.0744517297,
0.0143899051,
-0.0092003224,
0.0299671609,
-0.0211281236,
-0.0112164272,
0.0010446031,
-0.0582686849,
-0.0256638918,
-0.0001630557,
0.0062623508,
-0.0142495809,
-0.0079778582,
-0.0032357522,
0.0172448009,
0.0251508486,
0.0342906304,
0.0103166774,
-0.0622274838,
-0.0505581349,
-0.0467907749,
0.0091069769,
0.012688431,
0.0093868701,
0.0672965795,
0.0314857513,
0.0581388436,
-0.0376000479,
0.0020761851,
0.0143642146,
0.0137855234,
-0.0460032523,
-0.0338611789,
0.0278328154,
-0.0169516727,
-0.0299321786,
-0.0023490961,
0.0023683435,
0.0040894486,
0.0260849912,
-0.0460337102,
0.0222241003,
-0.0010191121,
0.0318727642,
-0.0216873288,
-0.0316764228,
-0.0166361202,
-0.0055617187,
-0.0682184845,
-0.0488573126,
-0.0010255215,
-0.0367414169,
0.0333884619,
-0.0353705473,
0.002651165,
0.0041232607,
-0.0479262918,
-0.0681321546,
0.0365817472,
0.0405126251,
-0.0154172098,
-0.0027472866,
0.0208303984,
0.0729863644,
-0.0084290672,
-0.0147462748,
-0.0335852504,
-0.0287100095,
0.018909907,
0.0168350805,
0.0498797521,
-0.0213483013,
-0.0497931167,
-0.0850690603,
0.013404157,
-0.0057172915,
0.0253517423,
0.0349340662,
-0.0261689313,
-0.0387432836,
-0.0208996795,
-0.0315047354,
0.0162782259,
0.0136805624,
-0.0067189741,
0.0295940842,
-0.0071407161,
0.0294790585,
0.0212636255,
0.0090948483,
-0.0210896339,
-0.0018031251,
0.0628419742,
-0.0393780842,
-0.0204250626,
0.0140627939,
-0.018008275,
0.0091450168,
-0.0042792466,
-0.0604961999,
0.029052943,
-0.0332841277,
0.0233645421,
-0.0016420304,
-0.0002723157,
0.0159388259,
0.021006709,
-0.0489372499,
-0.0557230338,
0.0283839088,
-0.0396916606,
-0.0349248089,
-0.005707812,
-0.0033061903,
0.0490431935,
0.0337293521,
-0.0048461482,
-0.0181776565,
-0.0381612666,
0.0331815854,
-0.0319979154,
0.0205618255,
-0.0002533603,
0.0164027214,
0.0173639301,
0.0523606315,
-0.0244976673,
-0.0579206459,
0.0293684229,
-0.0397834145,
-0.022259118,
-0.0371938832,
0.0056050355,
-0.0730850324,
0.0854047239,
0.0254844278,
0.0356285311,
0.0109075727,
-0.0305491406,
-0.0121831698,
-0.0222365912,
-0.0218942519,
0.0016507081,
-0.0095094787,
-0.0739835873,
0.0239856336,
0.0012822259,
-0.038241975,
-0.0331361294,
0.0216528866,
-0.017146511,
-0.0072318395,
0.0368960239,
-0.0411189683,
0.0426284596,
0.0752220675,
0.014762694,
0.0746183023,
-0.0357132778,
-0.0340183079,
-0.0306723882,
-0.004136845,
0.0336131714,
0.077897273,
-0.0570555143,
0.0668898597,
-0.0675314814,
0.046079535,
-0.0145468861,
-0.0155180898,
-0.0388378911,
0.0163159743,
0.031235639,
-0.039785333,
-0.0111138327,
-0.0143860606,
0.02782318,
-0.0797393098,
-0.0237319507,
0.0752072558,
0.0303500779,
-0.007628384,
-0.0137571143,
-0.019054627,
-0.0116151748,
0.0259982683,
0.0338121355,
-0.0676627308,
0.0002540391,
0.0096228765,
-0.0415203162,
0.0026839112,
-0.0085864924,
-0.0339762121,
-0.099910371,
0.1198349297,
-0.0039706598,
-0.0542112589,
0.0028013487,
-0.0441652872,
-0.023159219,
-0.0231079981,
-0.0900067464,
-0.0289323553,
0.0034245884,
0.0272485409,
0.0164893642,
-0.0644892454,
-0.0233320892,
-0.0287857428,
-0.0525284,
0.0183300208,
0.0478908196,
0.0408785716,
0.0025662333,
-0.0406978503,
0.0329661593,
0.0742327943,
0.0467396639,
-0.029785905,
0.026160378,
-0.0023660457,
-0.0045134565,
0.0049472884,
-0.0208632201,
-0.0305078216,
-0.0240533426,
0.0082675498,
0.0829000622,
-0.0281461813,
0.0251679383,
-0.0367702022,
0.0205589272,
0.0558907799,
0.0145842042,
-0.011260204,
0.0264275055,
-0.0686796755,
-0.0659907907,
-0.0092472406,
-0.0299584549,
-0.0772945285,
0.0259824619,
0.0315089151,
-0.0734873712,
-0.0159619022,
-0.003854692,
0.0363963433,
0.0422626622,
0.0119714979,
-0.0477523543,
0.0521093421,
-0.0236089546,
-0.0621283986,
0.0481875166,
-0.0408336893,
-0.007333857,
-0.0479739457,
-0.0225916822,
0.0420613177,
-0.0191575699,
-0.0364703648,
0.001191498,
-0.0223827753,
-0.0272032656,
0.0080458419,
0.0622376166,
0.0261858013,
-0.0172813348,
-0.0478524789,
-0.0037948824,
0.0202489644,
0.0235874895,
-0.0670938566,
-0.0577866025,
0.0024781695,
0.019601902,
0.0202434734,
-0.0227668714,
0.0077836658,
0.0362933315,
-0.0088163223,
-0.0061232345,
-0.0467969514,
0.0155689465,
0.0214798283,
0.0371128954,
0.0972875282,
0.0271123294,
0.0486280844,
-0.0191049818,
-0.0470390506,
-0.0027800375,
-0.0037617907,
-0.0370485969,
0.0326967202,
0.0101129459,
0.0222239755,
0.0278606918,
0.0173460692,
-0.0269524213,
-0.0351557843,
0.0070304708,
-0.0239239614,
-0.0034819245,
-0.0120653221,
0.0276715495,
0.0215896126,
-0.0032657592,
-0.037784446,
0.0162642244,
0.0184913259,
-0.0076069296,
0.0137334792,
0.0460221842,
0.0141339423,
-0.0135713071,
0.0246088784,
-0.0172796305,
-0.1057460234,
-0.0288843401,
0.0356671438,
0.0434463359,
0.0308285616,
-0.0141491117,
-0.0437109396,
0.009704764,
0.0029800087,
0.0079203229,
0.0565955564,
-0.0638753623,
0.0052415249,
-0.005973679,
-0.0574316196,
-0.0535287522,
0.0173615795,
0.0106134005,
0.0080592278,
-0.0046545449,
-0.0521921366,
-0.0295475125,
-0.0237008594,
-0.0094410302,
-0.0046046497,
0.014400553,
0.0135574313,
-0.0359922424,
-0.0123521816,
-0.0390288569,
0.0422031321,
-0.028440604,
-0.0023666976,
0.0398524851,
0.0697974563,
-0.0346668251,
-0.0345944427,
-0.0449848212,
0.015206933,
-0.0301294662,
-0.0043809507,
-0.0043279668,
-6.07310781e-33,
-0.0192952845,
-0.0732962862,
0.0944792852,
-0.0035417674,
0.0052198838,
-0.0404187478,
-0.0205670968,
-0.0252752751,
0.0209398903,
-0.013247503,
-0.018168373,
-0.0135310646,
0.0111418357,
0.0287469048,
0.0199431386,
0.0356838331,
0.0564411134,
0.0226898883,
-0.0221011024,
0.0187018216,
0.0064674499,
-0.014052527,
0.0351136513,
-0.0951106921,
-0.0460388288,
0.0335643664,
-0.0216349792,
0.0230126604,
-0.0026229464,
0.0320625082,
-0.0074869096,
0.0123077231,
0.0276072323,
-0.0347349457,
-0.040944919,
0.042686671,
-0.0598090254,
-0.0199191105,
-0.0164569262,
0.0483909473,
-0.0305619575,
-0.0192287453,
0.0199764874,
-0.0028555703,
0.026696004,
0.0066391043,
0.0312143825,
0.0238512717,
-0.0086714868,
0.0077439179,
-0.0445492044,
0.0468636975,
0.0093542142,
-0.027089132,
0.0256699566,
-0.0334448107,
0.0153307812,
0.0335771404,
-0.0069032931,
0.0344075896,
0.067520164,
0.0053034942,
0.02842981,
-0.0028266239,
0.0161895566,
0.0333289914,
-0.0137945106,
-0.0480661131,
-0.0421559177,
-0.0242368858,
0.011945813,
0.0657602251,
-0.0422458611,
0.0011843238,
0.0247491114,
0.0128020681,
0.0206185859,
0.0447415076,
-0.0854206979,
0.0668033063,
0.00032745,
0.0071057263,
-0.0158070438,
-0.0292477738,
0.0064121382,
-0.025243111,
0.0087548038,
-0.0196676496,
0.0324100815,
0.0125394994,
-0.0008515987,
0.0708484575,
-0.008376156,
-0.0345070772,
-0.0221485775,
0.0045430637,
-0.0245284215,
0.0113436934,
-0.0200633295,
0.0706854686,
-0.0333804451,
-0.0343256891,
-0.003689375,
0.0245123487,
-0.01185288,
0.0507488996,
-0.0352981798,
0.0621581934,
-0.0470832922,
0.0024882916,
-0.0339153707,
0.0099193836,
-0.0262019802,
-0.0078620138,
-0.0030832058,
-0.015639903,
-0.0021974468,
0.0305599608,
0.0138313547,
-0.028036207,
-0.0124665434,
0.0367339849,
-0.0288991015,
0.0119751506,
-0.0029881208,
0.0131941792,
-0.0150336288,
-0.0188837294,
0.0053618932,
-0.0246867314,
0.010172952,
0.0302798897,
3.01e-7,
0.0326855741,
0.0660449341,
0.0155278016,
0.0133444527,
-0.0035589267,
0.0140019758,
0.0310740862,
-0.0158545673,
-0.0240869503,
0.070576258,
0.0350271836,
0.0481451079,
-0.0027230855,
0.0366826281,
-0.0973908231,
0.0649472922,
-0.0181574859,
-0.0330098681,
-0.0880769417,
0.0172562487,
0.0832547322,
0.0184244439,
-0.0037147754,
0.0207309537,
0.0220071077,
-0.0466817096,
-0.010704143,
-0.0197325405,
0.035095308,
0.0727749541,
0.0598921403,
0.0339678302,
0.0153421639,
-0.0261318833,
0.0041693798,
-0.0238860883,
0.0161661617,
0.0662025511,
-0.0206735786,
0.0191251133,
0.0206852127,
-0.0881554559,
-0.0058009205,
-0.0795235038,
0.035862837,
-0.107903026,
0.0035174058,
0.0292374529,
0.001799006,
-0.0154977264,
-0.0352140032,
0.0145985689,
-0.0415407643,
-0.0183935594,
0.0299357474,
0.0152238747,
-0.0240150336,
-0.0506116264,
0.0414371863,
0.0435286947,
-0.0351130962,
-0.0061108568,
-0.0341243744,
0.0173867643,
0.0221913327,
0.0325486138,
-0.0086773839,
2.388306515e-34,
-0.0036557387,
0.0394828953,
-0.0031945473,
-0.0203567054,
0.0272732116,
0.0561396517,
0.0174987968,
0.0171212293,
-0.0318282917,
0.0066347318,
-0.00182354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07924v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07924v5 | ChatDev: Communicative Agents for Software Development | 2023-07-16T02:11:34 | 2024-06-05T13:23:49 | Chen Qian, Wei Liu, Hongzhang Liu, Nuo Chen, Yufan Dang, Jiahao Li, Cheng Yang, Weize Chen, Yusheng Su, Xin Cong, Juyuan Xu, Dahai Li, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.MA | Software development is a complex task that necessitates cooperation among
multiple members with diverse skills. Numerous studies used deep learning to
improve specific phases in a waterfall model, such as design, coding, and
testing. However, the deep learning model in each phase requires unique
designs, leading to technical inconsistencies across various phases, which
results in a fragmented and ineffective development process. In this paper, we
introduce ChatDev, a chat-powered software development framework in which
specialized agents driven by large language models (LLMs) are guided in what to
communicate (via chat chain) and how to communicate (via communicative
dehallucination). These agents actively contribute to the design, coding, and
testing phases through unified language-based communication, with solutions
derived from their multi-turn dialogues. We found their utilization of natural
language is advantageous for system design, and communicating in programming
language proves helpful in debugging. This paradigm demonstrates how linguistic
communication facilitates multi-agent collaboration, establishing language as a
unifying bridge for autonomous task-solving among LLM agents. The code and data
are available at https://github.com/OpenBMB/ChatDev. | [
0.0339448638,
0.0346664786,
-0.0459390469,
0.0312174931,
-0.0198731087,
-0.0174856726,
0.0027093163,
-0.0372732878,
0.0109715965,
-0.0027337151,
0.0026857711,
0.0148113603,
0.0057748095,
0.0545088612,
-0.0026465859,
-0.0602826364,
0.0311300233,
-0.0231452752,
-0.0075205201,
0.0224312227,
0.0251574181,
0.0160465948,
-0.0408994965,
0.0946649015,
-0.0094593093,
-0.0410089567,
-0.0524748527,
0.0068330476,
-0.0177491922,
0.0220095608,
0.0183537062,
0.0391932316,
0.0228382088,
0.020311052,
0.0000023709,
-0.038789615,
0.0287999325,
-0.0194858741,
-0.0315025896,
-0.0384565033,
0.0143035594,
-0.0027487727,
-0.0293489154,
0.0281069931,
-0.0478299856,
-0.0488910116,
0.0502642803,
0.0232547577,
0.0892620459,
0.022418905,
0.0192929432,
-0.0061000288,
0.0030154437,
0.0159391556,
0.0008392084,
-0.0388120413,
-0.028149195,
0.0550903715,
0.0595881082,
0.0259633288,
0.0073475796,
0.0286284443,
0.0415902473,
-0.0302251987,
-0.003092621,
0.0362674184,
-0.0343591645,
-0.0521502234,
0.0090139033,
0.07092347,
-0.0268958248,
0.0099094948,
0.0114116697,
0.0185473114,
0.0074429018,
-0.0178765841,
-0.0232208595,
0.0107484935,
-0.0045162193,
-0.0381284058,
-0.0300921742,
-0.0530046709,
-0.02883582,
-0.0167149995,
-0.0103586605,
0.0482021943,
-0.0299285837,
0.0446336009,
-0.0483562052,
-0.0219150223,
0.0327227339,
-0.0625483021,
0.0178142693,
0.0580182299,
-0.0658338442,
0.0179790873,
-0.0078381523,
-0.0061692991,
0.0179382227,
-0.0567339472,
-0.048049096,
-0.0120307384,
-0.0135179497,
0.0162342209,
0.0047676913,
0.0270077679,
-0.0011337155,
0.0011688897,
-0.0052901362,
-0.0144043984,
-0.0905403867,
-0.0111693991,
-0.0481043756,
0.0425303578,
-0.0043383171,
-0.0139282867,
-0.0085162846,
0.0946322978,
0.0068412283,
0.043854598,
-0.0269898791,
0.0185818337,
-0.0521068461,
0.0081087342,
-0.0043007713,
0.0330631845,
-0.0307748374,
-0.0228667501,
0.0163828209,
-0.0567026511,
0.0291725732,
0.0077804024,
-0.0503996611,
0.0009511198,
-0.0076677012,
0.1164436117,
-0.0061591971,
0.0669052005,
0.0166055057,
-0.0274853371,
0.048644647,
-0.0070464802,
-0.0225202348,
-0.0732302368,
-0.0103028873,
0.0188229643,
-0.0120124212,
-0.0729428455,
0.013159018,
-0.0084416913,
0.0162496362,
0.0486378968,
-0.0458266735,
0.0235406402,
0.1121190488,
0.0538417362,
0.0051911068,
0.0667533651,
0.0588568859,
0.0356375128,
0.0407728329,
-0.00329287,
0.0511094183,
0.0297553539,
-0.0355336405,
-0.012862185,
0.0464842096,
0.0016790929,
0.0053121028,
0.0189182833,
-0.0094223889,
0.0212586671,
-0.0179650746,
-0.0181236695,
0.0389677212,
0.0328769088,
0.0461839139,
0.0312430151,
0.0110162795,
0.0814294815,
-0.0280961096,
-0.0278849099,
-0.0152727654,
0.0839871317,
0.0255293809,
-0.0082334047,
0.0010110949,
0.024023341,
-0.0392057784,
-0.0502732731,
0.0291504096,
-0.0298677944,
0.0267077908,
0.035875354,
0.0163540673,
0.017804144,
-0.0349882767,
0.0505883284,
0.0151517028,
-0.0370819382,
-0.0343788005,
-0.0405967645,
0.0139372135,
0.0684284791,
0.070023872,
-0.0406433046,
-0.069897823,
-0.0050937631,
0.0255360249,
0.0129072899,
0.0182783529,
-0.0274214335,
-0.0285364781,
-0.026401639,
-0.0333363228,
-0.0251911543,
-0.0274914112,
0.0158100557,
-0.00974569,
-0.0047811125,
-0.014168581,
0.0332007594,
-0.0600126609,
0.0290077049,
-0.0157625675,
0.0185255073,
0.0018909388,
0.00061103,
0.0054228101,
-0.006620537,
-0.0291754585,
0.0070339739,
0.0396451429,
-0.030602688,
-0.0683670044,
0.0338676944,
-0.0117101958,
-0.0537647456,
0.0130857974,
-0.0609162003,
-0.0099537317,
-0.0002550975,
-0.0432347618,
0.0038680451,
0.1092785448,
-0.0223126635,
-0.0084440252,
0.0219666101,
0.0007735578,
-0.0115527054,
-0.0023487941,
-0.025441546,
0.0074465727,
0.0502050817,
-0.0350153446,
-0.0435668901,
0.0704187378,
0.01408384,
-0.0082759056,
0.0169314388,
0.0707899183,
-0.0017046982,
0.046445094,
0.0355854593,
0.0626504868,
-0.0179254152,
-0.0257181935,
-0.1074341312,
0.0000103927,
-0.015932411,
0.0059442003,
-0.0026156369,
0.0367655605,
0.0374537073,
-0.017382348,
-0.0403321609,
0.0482003391,
-0.0047660326,
-0.0000852377,
0.0409288108,
0.0081726601,
-0.049309779,
-0.041428525,
-0.0048003201,
-0.0192480814,
0.0236605667,
0.0099067343,
-0.0458301418,
-0.0533693917,
0.0369354114,
-0.0421157405,
0.0270842388,
-0.0162262991,
-0.0497467145,
0.033637058,
0.0130889295,
0.018122565,
0.0416365676,
0.0041647973,
0.0588774458,
0.0113438116,
-0.0189902522,
-0.0672507137,
0.03239654,
0.0290773064,
-0.0171097089,
-0.0299727209,
-0.0128259631,
0.0200500265,
0.0713678747,
-0.0144969281,
-0.0165979229,
-0.0135289254,
0.0136741214,
0.0037348927,
0.0115943588,
0.0405655019,
-0.0265616365,
0.0249619745,
0.0155171538,
-0.0328157954,
-0.0535608456,
0.0864161104,
0.0055858484,
-0.0539864413,
-0.067218937,
-0.0565572605,
-0.0636199713,
0.0802022889,
-0.0439277962,
0.0042354786,
-0.0309401676,
-0.0197679661,
-0.0501197465,
-0.000220703,
0.0112222144,
-0.012023421,
0.0233543497,
-0.0772027671,
0.0068943771,
-0.00975205,
-0.0297116935,
-0.0323638208,
0.0263611134,
-0.0398459695,
0.0222748723,
0.0094045354,
0.0102058677,
-0.0441302843,
0.0373964682,
0.0169690065,
0.0170650836,
0.0461421199,
-0.0204554703,
-0.0355009288,
-0.0759112462,
0.0116428128,
-0.0122250523,
-0.0313082151,
-0.0206751563,
0.0413374528,
0.0397429802,
0.0480385125,
0.016624948,
-0.0384034738,
-0.0443891883,
0.0097776875,
-0.014255573,
0.0030896252,
0.0049598068,
0.0195987448,
-0.0486841276,
-0.0176352039,
0.0777322575,
0.0257275868,
-0.0609328747,
0.0151713109,
-0.008291645,
0.0328031927,
0.0498220995,
0.0317118987,
-0.0902550071,
-0.0521019846,
-0.009158954,
-0.0329701453,
0.0002270758,
0.0050648293,
-0.0087521113,
-0.0473162048,
0.0005354983,
-0.0081857117,
-0.0259700138,
0.0309353732,
-0.0300566927,
0.0008556094,
0.0118178865,
0.0152986767,
0.0204198342,
0.0440237336,
-0.0127821015,
0.0080046561,
-0.0750849247,
-0.0203408599,
0.0481437631,
-0.0735873953,
0.0557385124,
0.1059775874,
0.0377220288,
0.014734922,
0.0201010983,
0.049851954,
0.018095836,
0.025875425,
-0.0124630807,
0.02871917,
0.0070045558,
-0.037761163,
0.0234782174,
-0.0176636707,
-0.0960864872,
0.0263921116,
0.0454998016,
0.0316713378,
-0.0464523025,
-0.0211821049,
-0.0401279815,
0.0445110798,
0.0246025212,
0.0061368458,
0.0036594742,
-0.0599651858,
-0.0556736067,
-0.0539288297,
-0.0276829209,
-0.0032518951,
-0.0515413396,
-0.0117501309,
0.0182915535,
-0.0303581376,
-0.0487975143,
-0.0515785664,
0.0494640693,
0.0115887215,
0.0303132832,
-0.0192063078,
0.0493328236,
0.0432549454,
-0.0017267745,
0.0165483113,
0.0125572318,
0.018759232,
-0.0165141262,
-0.0254913457,
-0.0021673131,
-0.0229408927,
0.0021812147,
0.0475714691,
-0.0582795665,
-0.0369863473,
-0.0226776954,
0.0459913425,
0.0116166286,
-0.0165755115,
-0.040071249,
-0.0966982618,
-0.061603006,
0.0244342051,
-0.0241851397,
-0.0238503236,
0.0200386699,
0.0254977699,
-0.0009037725,
0.0055450755,
-0.0638973042,
0.016521953,
-0.0098375734,
-0.0152086234,
-0.0285223834,
-0.0287433527,
0.0080422964,
-0.0346557572,
-0.0430689603,
0.0587445833,
-0.0318955146,
-0.0133574065,
0.0075621665,
0.0047666519,
-0.0244198125,
-0.0730150342,
0.0382063724,
-0.0435919687,
-0.0351527929,
0.0883233324,
0.0155729968,
-0.0166582428,
0.0285007544,
0.040847376,
0.0660417303,
0.0242360607,
0.0317324027,
0.0003682003,
0.0104595795,
0.0043101967,
0.0155206379,
-0.0137831308,
0.0452630557,
-0.0076325606,
0.0287299212,
0.0092979725,
0.0141962143,
0.0039242203,
0.0272979327,
-0.0187656451,
-0.1062295064,
0.0410179235,
0.0421439596,
0.0257033836,
0.1059485078,
-0.005613897,
-0.0446567498,
0.0441265851,
-0.026235329,
0.0458907075,
-0.0308167916,
-0.0457572266,
-0.0139133045,
0.0138512813,
-0.0072730915,
-0.0504623502,
0.082823582,
-0.0001188669,
-0.0151110496,
-0.0297713391,
-0.028113341,
-0.0284434855,
0.0115517657,
0.0321456231,
-0.0336331874,
-0.0268672053,
0.0176912639,
-0.0043942258,
-0.0415587388,
-0.0103688547,
0.0115472488,
0.0188733116,
-0.0160973612,
0.0329076089,
0.0898531154,
-0.00305585,
-0.0295721646,
-0.0187525004,
-0.0215738788,
-0.022488568,
-0.0123187993,
-0.0555929691,
-5.567080634e-33,
-0.015792463,
-0.0469412878,
0.0579610877,
0.0319641568,
0.0059122569,
-0.0277240518,
-0.0385169983,
0.0343777388,
-0.0292706024,
0.0230372809,
0.0071437629,
0.0478126816,
-0.005175312,
-0.0237022974,
0.0579962693,
0.0024245584,
0.0638467818,
0.0168300644,
-0.0087330388,
0.0929210111,
-0.0161906369,
0.0273064822,
0.016384121,
-0.0642520636,
-0.0033895245,
0.0071798349,
0.0184319559,
0.0277534742,
0.0124149928,
0.0181897581,
-0.0016571373,
0.0026292964,
-0.0075794333,
-0.0290645733,
-0.0401774757,
-0.0324102752,
-0.0144243259,
-0.0287606567,
0.0022321148,
0.0071200687,
-0.0580463447,
-0.0176600162,
0.0539326109,
0.0014964782,
-0.0094986921,
0.0127648525,
0.0439406559,
0.022153059,
-0.0084334807,
-0.0174191482,
-0.0649479777,
0.0222219843,
-0.0545923226,
-0.0550031401,
-0.0127112074,
0.0129819717,
-0.0157961026,
-0.0538654961,
0.0025027648,
0.0245046373,
-0.0067727612,
0.0235327948,
0.0504479408,
0.0075582243,
-0.0124877151,
0.0281555708,
0.061089132,
0.0699665844,
-0.0220339336,
-0.0146162044,
0.0394003391,
0.068751201,
0.0240124483,
0.0041250181,
-0.055007685,
-0.0070585939,
-0.0186315421,
0.0048737219,
0.0219968297,
0.0553310104,
0.0160297006,
0.0486411266,
-0.0427425094,
-0.0238159783,
-0.0449024476,
0.0237112157,
-0.000607127,
-0.0373257324,
0.0005998624,
0.014396104,
0.0088462224,
-0.0170334633,
0.0209609512,
-0.049194973,
-0.0305165183,
0.0026694327,
-0.029270811,
0.003225812,
-0.0277716573,
0.0026625597,
-0.0102971764,
-0.0207655933,
-0.0091251675,
0.0270379335,
0.0569549538,
0.0147983143,
-0.0192922913,
0.0015896667,
-0.0049823709,
0.0095191272,
-0.0655528605,
0.0214279313,
-0.0019992085,
0.0420707464,
-0.0276321936,
-0.0060806731,
-0.0119619789,
0.0241602007,
-0.025423862,
-0.0688144118,
-0.0663389415,
0.0311204754,
-0.0208180975,
-0.0049959524,
-0.0564865842,
-0.0509119257,
-0.0800903514,
0.0204192735,
0.0261866301,
-0.0534693897,
-0.0313813016,
0.0049622706,
3.023e-7,
-0.0362758525,
0.0559325479,
0.0139763253,
0.044782754,
0.0466152728,
0.0470997281,
-0.0010198379,
0.0099204751,
0.0278465655,
0.002153733,
-0.0324979313,
0.0648516566,
0.048693385,
0.036126826,
-0.0779136121,
-0.0324699245,
-0.0087371897,
-0.0003326369,
-0.067193076,
-0.0248327665,
0.0277455058,
0.0410598814,
0.0191307664,
-0.0033923383,
0.0182833187,
-0.0424646884,
-0.0234810598,
0.0011703729,
0.0309612472,
0.096897684,
-0.0084136287,
-0.0246915631,
-0.0037234686,
0.0160896908,
0.0282266159,
-0.0474590771,
-0.0094264476,
0.0161879454,
-0.0202379171,
-0.0027154339,
-0.0049066041,
-0.0130588477,
-0.0133804344,
-0.0122879911,
-0.0000998833,
-0.0571906902,
-0.016486967,
-0.0119503336,
0.0593480133,
-0.0375954174,
0.0121316211,
-0.0090454295,
0.0098078595,
0.003087522,
-0.0025729714,
-0.0380064249,
-0.0072904518,
-0.0571017303,
0.004302436,
0.0211092848,
-0.0526360236,
-0.0351123065,
-0.0246962756,
0.0174636431,
0.0074422448,
0.0466054082,
0.0389582999,
2.551194675e-34,
0.0003320052,
0.0006785778,
-0.0017506288,
0.054479003,
0.0607216284,
-0.004575572,
0.0055557131,
0.0276502725,
0.0119961593,
0.0018625844,
-0.0340022333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11767v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11767v1 | Recognition of Mental Adjectives in An Efficient and Automatic Style | 2023-07-16T01:27:08 | 2023-07-16T01:27:08 | Fei Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, commonsense reasoning has received more and more attention
from academic community. We propose a new lexical inference task, Mental and
Physical Classification (MPC), to handle commonsense reasoning in a reasoning
graph. Mental words relate to mental activities, which fall into six
categories: Emotion, Need, Perceiving, Reasoning, Planning and Personality.
Physical words describe physical attributes of an object, like color, hardness,
speed and malleability. A BERT model is fine-tuned for this task and active
learning algorithm is adopted in the training framework to reduce the required
annotation resources. The model using ENTROPY strategy achieves satisfactory
accuracy and requires only about 300 labeled words. We also compare our result
with SentiWordNet to check the difference between MPC and subjectivity
classification task in sentiment analysis. | [
0.0403737687,
0.0221124105,
0.0085909171,
0.0315640084,
0.0048453356,
0.0259144679,
-0.0241074096,
0.0144731384,
0.0383487381,
-0.0943614617,
-0.0316406712,
0.0009899586,
-0.0223361589,
-0.0717341676,
0.0365379639,
-0.0630682632,
0.0106653236,
0.0437756777,
0.0511957258,
0.003310994,
-0.0033456418,
0.0287036598,
-0.0332089663,
-0.0022051258,
-0.0011562093,
-0.0011517822,
0.0240103509,
-0.0122209135,
0.0221187752,
-0.0518903844,
-0.0054513891,
0.0788086578,
-0.0326411799,
-0.0242438503,
0.0000021128,
-0.0600195862,
0.0018441905,
-0.0196602829,
0.0556316264,
-0.0104697691,
0.0531845056,
-0.0053568208,
0.0147767439,
-0.0019807396,
-0.0248571336,
-0.0221611299,
0.0776089728,
0.080143258,
0.0299082045,
0.031357795,
-0.0182507299,
-0.0321444348,
-0.0107466737,
0.015345173,
0.0439698882,
0.0069213025,
0.0418687612,
-0.0200565942,
-0.0067647505,
-0.0421847031,
0.0072097583,
-0.0236543119,
-0.0233731978,
0.0306655318,
-0.0026338289,
0.008113415,
-0.0354879349,
0.0252013784,
0.0036168909,
0.0740628839,
0.0329514891,
-0.0077597406,
0.022978358,
-0.0061156219,
-0.0041203299,
0.0140487915,
0.0024004211,
0.0198176298,
-0.0318304412,
0.0230880864,
-0.0098282862,
-0.0032074954,
-0.0132676186,
0.0677646175,
0.0141816009,
0.0842000619,
-0.015750045,
-0.0317825899,
0.0488054119,
0.0197251197,
-0.0452592894,
-0.0259603038,
-0.0035805602,
0.0111631118,
0.0552017242,
0.0266061276,
0.0022160735,
-0.0493644588,
0.0273772608,
-0.0896595418,
-0.0091369711,
-0.0046508466,
0.0104705524,
-0.0008973512,
-0.0326684117,
0.0311397873,
0.0048378976,
0.0797909424,
-0.0355861112,
0.0173543282,
-0.1069786549,
-0.0100815035,
-0.0372376963,
0.0537812822,
0.0754784867,
-0.0321222059,
-0.0649683028,
-0.0150390444,
-0.0678067729,
-0.0306172185,
0.0529210642,
0.0221131723,
0.0124899093,
-0.0071587567,
-0.0516319536,
-0.0148364687,
-0.043993827,
0.057916835,
-0.0628001615,
0.0383486077,
0.0229839161,
0.0124888709,
0.0419518091,
-0.0272364635,
0.0233877897,
0.0207976624,
0.0314379595,
-0.0351464041,
-0.085187383,
-0.0242511425,
-0.0050507537,
-0.0149752069,
0.0021418862,
-0.0501702242,
-0.0351219364,
-0.025099542,
-0.0074192076,
-0.0112399366,
0.0378409699,
-0.0092508458,
-0.0355863348,
0.0748102963,
-0.0561916269,
-0.0577783734,
-0.0283095371,
-0.0030989058,
0.030685924,
0.0494160391,
0.0278842635,
0.0028895552,
0.0493861251,
0.0082494831,
0.0004838331,
0.003789559,
0.0001343514,
-0.0392783321,
-0.020877881,
-0.0514899008,
-0.0550058112,
0.0242327284,
0.0062749805,
0.0188265219,
-0.0078856535,
0.008382434,
0.0117265163,
0.0541960932,
-0.0339704938,
0.0416386612,
-0.0278282445,
0.0284090117,
0.0491366424,
0.0299879871,
-0.0207988378,
0.0269864779,
-0.0226511508,
-0.0147974687,
-0.0174591299,
-0.0235868432,
-0.0212673713,
-0.0417326279,
-0.0688233152,
-0.0528000221,
0.0671337396,
-0.041119393,
0.0415082946,
0.0100927278,
-0.0126253609,
0.0487279408,
0.0649764836,
-0.0389487222,
-0.0397359952,
-0.0580643602,
-0.0263125673,
0.0895374417,
0.0051904935,
-0.0387449898,
-0.0567881018,
-0.0036306712,
-0.027737733,
0.0280125104,
0.0287888143,
-0.0070649739,
-0.0486581735,
-0.0633125454,
-0.0154522052,
-0.0017254048,
0.0232675858,
-0.0064535909,
-0.03163087,
0.039869491,
0.000377365,
-0.0104973717,
-0.0066572349,
0.0260960236,
0.0616574176,
-0.0359742045,
0.0016748313,
0.0095130829,
0.0436914004,
0.0020203958,
-0.0086120367,
0.0089913663,
-0.0064635114,
-0.0254066177,
-0.0592019185,
0.0496079624,
0.0610912926,
-0.0302998964,
0.0277140122,
-0.0194973592,
0.0090571325,
0.00024884,
-0.0093096318,
-0.0213337988,
-0.0029200066,
-0.0485626459,
0.0585001633,
-0.053620223,
-0.0131579787,
-0.0107826674,
-0.0024637752,
-0.0167069398,
0.0900528803,
-0.0185100324,
0.0409822427,
0.0046213213,
-0.0523744598,
0.0049033985,
-0.0088352412,
-0.005832314,
0.0149758253,
0.0340196006,
0.023004951,
0.0100701554,
0.0139930276,
-0.016167881,
-0.0166177042,
-0.0970858857,
-0.0198974088,
0.0200907048,
0.026005052,
0.016524788,
-0.0512610227,
-0.0007564547,
0.0372894779,
0.0112555819,
0.069774963,
-0.0353165381,
-0.0051984303,
0.0458137579,
-0.0491216779,
0.0028156664,
-0.0040193796,
0.0066546882,
-0.0689856336,
0.0169885363,
0.0392877199,
0.0116750589,
-0.0060225045,
0.0311686452,
-0.0708956495,
0.0343991145,
0.0446641222,
-0.1065177768,
-0.0156464186,
-0.0123744048,
0.0138680721,
0.0560817048,
0.0422999561,
0.008594905,
0.018272331,
0.000806109,
-0.0173765905,
0.0082473233,
-0.0109330779,
0.0702031106,
0.0165162981,
-0.0307081565,
0.0085819075,
0.0463679209,
0.0342869796,
-0.0012636206,
-0.0354839303,
0.0121395281,
-0.0054744352,
0.003917011,
-0.0036590053,
0.0546456799,
-0.0058303345,
0.0140658636,
0.0113303894,
-0.003870385,
0.0692483708,
0.0095947543,
0.0395159163,
-0.0670816228,
-0.0075403014,
-0.0102633163,
0.0508342348,
0.0310352352,
0.0138015812,
-0.0056434618,
0.0079948939,
-0.0043157702,
-0.0719768777,
0.0046873074,
-0.0174023602,
-0.0294517316,
-0.0278648492,
0.0107618729,
0.02751619,
-0.0178878959,
0.0173555445,
0.0026727067,
-0.0567389466,
-0.0061068218,
0.0075859129,
-0.0435594954,
0.0014780459,
0.0102316001,
-0.0038859572,
0.0002980209,
-0.0099872556,
-0.0088774934,
0.0035547463,
0.0298646055,
0.0556481257,
-0.0133386133,
0.0126016336,
0.0208889022,
-0.0253875293,
0.0846031383,
-0.0250678211,
0.0118699959,
0.0102094961,
-0.0098498296,
0.0254814476,
-0.0337143689,
-0.0224450119,
-0.0258748159,
0.0197716933,
-0.0535716191,
-0.0015931368,
0.1053140163,
0.0560142696,
-0.009536243,
0.0106239552,
0.0153023209,
-0.0303819384,
-0.0084160399,
0.0098259784,
-0.0127703799,
-0.0519032702,
-0.024704935,
0.0046586408,
-0.0475631468,
-0.0329395831,
0.0275957193,
-0.0682104677,
0.0002033374,
-0.0073993434,
0.0248993114,
-0.0478703789,
-0.0326301157,
0.0183758065,
-0.0074254363,
-0.0537231043,
-0.0482951999,
0.0192897189,
0.0211370569,
0.0196737517,
-0.0429477729,
-0.0211184435,
0.0548216105,
-0.0230512284,
0.0323611684,
0.0226782802,
0.0945392773,
-0.0605496652,
-0.144446373,
0.0182204414,
-0.0140979253,
-0.0425917879,
-0.0281558819,
0.0541982241,
0.0087824222,
-0.0062098326,
-0.0488187969,
0.026467815,
-0.0271947961,
-0.0352562293,
0.0018944707,
0.0656655356,
-0.028099101,
-0.0280612949,
-0.0244426597,
0.0158669408,
0.0135813542,
0.0683770701,
-0.0130606899,
-0.0444730483,
-0.0568460561,
-0.0351767577,
0.0044035157,
-0.0505840741,
-0.0563432202,
-0.0061958041,
-0.0313319601,
-0.0386703722,
-0.0783106685,
-0.015887456,
0.0147807961,
0.0637091324,
-0.0169344656,
-0.0134066325,
0.0442634746,
0.0259567052,
-0.085419409,
0.0304525048,
0.0468987711,
-0.0062136594,
0.0005906526,
-0.0703836009,
0.0673976988,
-0.0129789971,
-0.0275456887,
0.0060001202,
0.0205314271,
-0.0248187389,
-0.00634589,
0.0302279796,
0.0155245177,
-0.0355036482,
-0.0091565205,
-0.0422837548,
0.0362011977,
0.0105518913,
-0.0144446446,
-0.0212223679,
0.0309934057,
0.056553632,
0.0219540354,
0.0417490415,
0.0266026501,
0.0630536303,
-0.0124043599,
0.0073389322,
-0.0033023041,
-0.0389603674,
0.0015340747,
0.0370011255,
0.0402298011,
0.0075967223,
-0.0323526859,
-0.0339491405,
-0.046004042,
-0.009546998,
-0.0317103304,
-0.0163297784,
0.0200227741,
-0.0066760289,
0.0188567769,
-0.0953502059,
-0.0341865979,
-0.0137807252,
-0.0161542296,
0.0298170485,
0.0276985858,
-0.0072176447,
0.0171042271,
-0.0377298035,
-0.02424068,
-0.0114536807,
-0.0111074662,
-0.0145548303,
0.0036501349,
0.0068633789,
0.0489709526,
0.0227142256,
-0.0287921764,
-0.045668792,
0.0206398387,
-0.0156669132,
0.0247244667,
-0.0322245993,
0.0846842453,
-0.002845394,
-0.0082291178,
0.0007225602,
-0.0416967161,
-0.0148702618,
0.0194884185,
0.037343245,
-0.0039216527,
-0.0161620062,
0.055427637,
0.0127247619,
-0.0215903576,
-0.0754290372,
0.0321068801,
-0.0604896843,
0.0234619416,
-0.0026165326,
-0.0663746148,
-0.0349384323,
0.0259674098,
-0.0055227173,
0.0177190881,
0.0372285508,
0.0595642887,
-0.0512406491,
-0.0271852203,
0.0464964136,
-0.0026596759,
-0.0077724867,
-0.0012665769,
0.0505685844,
0.0463091694,
0.0086667379,
-0.0343987122,
-0.0223866198,
-0.0004764694,
-0.0243142229,
0.0065219239,
-0.0339424089,
-6.341191786e-33,
-0.0005577729,
-0.0531224161,
-0.0215643495,
0.0671797991,
-0.0245872904,
-0.0009988709,
0.0061957301,
0.006570986,
-0.0089238761,
0.0610275902,
0.0373396128,
0.019419251,
-0.0116026253,
0.0046950146,
0.0286904406,
-0.0085605793,
-0.0082034944,
-0.0147375725,
-0.0081462041,
-0.0012132929,
0.0458280444,
-0.0107705314,
0.1067851335,
-0.0615733191,
0.0248786155,
0.0659250244,
-0.00508057,
0.0252698343,
0.0362935252,
0.0120351855,
-0.0089958142,
0.0683058798,
0.030331295,
-0.0283927862,
0.0359560736,
0.0491782129,
-0.0308952741,
-0.0656630173,
-0.0091153597,
0.0269744489,
-0.016206732,
-0.0385037176,
0.0268817488,
-0.0103687122,
-0.0450318083,
-0.0049640397,
0.0668311119,
-0.0034178358,
0.0328930467,
-0.0634512976,
-0.0425352715,
0.0368403532,
0.0029896782,
0.0058874371,
-0.0009999032,
-0.0312531739,
-0.0286369566,
0.0144990645,
-0.0900170431,
-0.0034301537,
-0.0407128669,
0.0057936939,
-0.0289718378,
-0.0334542394,
0.0169913825,
0.0630859509,
0.0311212558,
-0.0051803794,
-0.0615947209,
0.0540805385,
0.039480526,
0.0510534756,
0.0450119674,
0.0123732286,
0.0636168867,
-0.034105096,
-0.0186610427,
0.0119751645,
0.0765732452,
0.0510429889,
0.0225453675,
-0.0123202689,
-0.0629804581,
-0.0070556835,
0.0482335761,
-0.0225752089,
-0.0265962277,
0.0071629779,
-0.0245478507,
-0.0415860303,
-0.0283981692,
-0.026130544,
-0.0398585163,
-0.0086946674,
-0.0154617736,
0.0665226206,
-0.0132170068,
0.0293958895,
-0.0071138404,
-0.0095591927,
-0.0172238648,
-0.0171638243,
-0.0085291788,
0.0593868382,
0.0267033353,
0.016639743,
0.0147345355,
-0.0066236472,
-0.0438898169,
-0.0200981405,
-0.0136952614,
-0.0219446737,
0.0107838036,
0.0226606485,
0.0137132257,
0.0113493791,
0.0099043082,
-0.0016504184,
0.0229653828,
0.0067298575,
-0.0169509295,
0.0287823509,
0.0078784162,
0.016873261,
0.0060255164,
-0.0106437132,
-0.0179992206,
-0.076025039,
-0.0335697904,
-0.0739263296,
0.0166694596,
0.0195289701,
3.03e-7,
0.0366687067,
0.0624796301,
-0.0351100639,
-0.0393182747,
0.0259779021,
0.0380935185,
-0.0078436257,
0.0060377,
0.0142102949,
-0.0173631869,
0.0170997083,
0.036539305,
-0.0033357635,
0.0564034134,
-0.0686331689,
-0.0107383002,
0.0030012415,
-0.0028652085,
0.0055188648,
0.0293408427,
0.0984721109,
0.0413631611,
0.0541028567,
0.0071780165,
-0.0063451845,
-0.0756434426,
0.0103066182,
-0.0093080634,
0.0549363978,
0.0273278002,
0.081083186,
-0.0111363279,
0.0033501547,
0.0360244028,
-0.019531738,
0.0056366292,
0.0083355596,
0.0284765568,
-0.0199128632,
-0.0269567352,
0.0147878807,
-0.0590625443,
0.0200390276,
0.0275696851,
0.0504624806,
-0.0656489357,
-0.0548273139,
-0.0328826383,
-0.0043842215,
0.0205312464,
0.0323493332,
-0.0037092916,
-0.0040084408,
0.0205010362,
0.0209212545,
-0.0803710669,
-0.0190432463,
-0.0836264119,
-0.0130284997,
0.0124028102,
-0.0201006662,
-0.0194371939,
0.0130761657,
0.0192166492,
0.029688878,
-0.0722008944,
0.0294560082,
2.572184366e-34,
0.0146060167,
-0.0059454218,
0.0126840826,
-0.0287937131,
0.0128622418,
0.0068681431,
0.014830499,
-0.0023568205,
0.0198015925,
-0.0651104152,
0.0161218867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.08714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.08714v1 | Cross-Lingual NER for Financial Transaction Data in Low-Resource Languages | 2023-07-16T00:45:42 | 2023-07-16T00:45:42 | Sunisth Kumar, Davide Liu, Alexandre Boulenger | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose an efficient modeling framework for cross-lingual named entity
recognition in semi-structured text data. Our approach relies on both knowledge
distillation and consistency training. The modeling framework leverages
knowledge from a large language model (XLMRoBERTa) pre-trained on the source
language, with a student-teacher relationship (knowledge distillation). The
student model incorporates unsupervised consistency training (with KL
divergence loss) on the low-resource target language.
We employ two independent datasets of SMSs in English and Arabic, each
carrying semi-structured banking transaction information, and focus on
exhibiting the transfer of knowledge from English to Arabic. With access to
only 30 labeled samples, our model can generalize the recognition of merchants,
amounts, and other fields from English to Arabic. We show that our modeling
approach, while efficient, performs best overall when compared to
state-of-the-art approaches like DistilBERT pre-trained on the target language
or a supervised model directly trained on labeled data in the target language.
Our experiments show that it is enough to learn to recognize entities in
English to reach reasonable performance in a low-resource language in the
presence of a few labeled samples of semi-structured data. The proposed
framework has implications for developing multi-lingual applications,
especially in geographies where digital endeavors rely on both English and one
or more low-resource language(s), sometimes mixed with English or employed
singly. | [
0.0187964365,
0.0613464266,
0.015562688,
0.0517096333,
0.0142684523,
0.0558163859,
0.0377888009,
0.0219245777,
-0.0042773536,
0.0066904444,
-0.0426178128,
-0.0486253574,
0.0120341927,
0.0046411459,
0.0441719145,
-0.0224991497,
0.0172948819,
-0.0257367436,
0.0143310577,
0.0005617072,
0.0241606943,
0.0144903986,
0.01633396,
-0.0232345276,
-0.0118464669,
-0.001527803,
-0.0180296618,
-0.0179827735,
0.0299388375,
-0.0154480971,
0.0174068045,
0.0143887233,
-0.001601461,
0.0116048548,
0.0000021769,
-0.0643305108,
-0.0704261884,
0.0074863997,
-0.0510902554,
-0.0043399939,
-0.0053819944,
-0.0870525837,
0.0116111431,
-0.0167059116,
-0.0212956797,
-0.0164528787,
0.0349821709,
0.0933396146,
0.0434366241,
0.0814712867,
-0.0137419151,
-0.0690207109,
-0.0195449758,
-0.0359104127,
0.0044112536,
-0.0343864895,
0.035753686,
0.0161445327,
-0.0423975512,
0.0289378967,
-0.0156419966,
0.0276056044,
0.0135266129,
-0.011030402,
-0.022091696,
0.025477238,
-0.033324115,
0.0219085664,
-0.0113323694,
0.0471860133,
-0.0097563565,
0.0330321528,
0.0676545501,
-0.0175781902,
-0.0399636663,
-0.0171305165,
-0.0277345851,
0.0193118043,
-0.036491584,
-0.0056166435,
0.0177334808,
0.0121246725,
0.0440926664,
0.0017674459,
-0.0692666322,
-0.0020578876,
0.0159299877,
-0.0512607954,
0.0087987222,
0.0071614245,
-0.0132176355,
-0.0222853515,
0.0337548219,
-0.0062003937,
0.0585385971,
0.0243103318,
-0.0023221939,
-0.0045870738,
-0.0034868345,
-0.0532395318,
-0.019572217,
0.0323341228,
-0.0157395825,
0.0498077832,
-0.0709940642,
0.0361036733,
-0.0042882399,
-0.0073503521,
0.0066776183,
-0.0130012613,
-0.0682412088,
0.0230145883,
-0.0318031982,
0.0604971461,
-0.0363046713,
0.0265193116,
-0.0535101071,
-0.024253644,
-0.0119830128,
0.0258563459,
0.0365394019,
-0.0523477159,
0.0175120085,
-0.0321247615,
-0.0182045959,
0.0428055078,
-0.0204150528,
-0.0281968452,
-0.0268231891,
-0.0160897225,
0.0119544128,
-0.0005228657,
0.0169136021,
-0.0343758762,
0.0110865189,
0.0734840035,
0.0280335117,
-0.0743453726,
-0.0912652612,
0.0028038637,
-0.0094162654,
-0.0513217412,
0.0092131561,
-0.0275685545,
0.0646451935,
0.0094512152,
0.00372723,
-0.0227955412,
0.0078985933,
-0.0258932561,
-0.0123168221,
0.0848056301,
0.0085962312,
-0.023555031,
0.0310360529,
-0.0125260437,
0.0645397604,
0.0373377502,
0.0158520583,
-0.0334966145,
0.0249994304,
0.0066974908,
-0.0408026762,
0.0573165976,
0.0197141208,
-0.0336485654,
0.0020270296,
-0.0081118895,
0.0074605639,
-0.0171994045,
0.0487009473,
0.020778073,
-0.0354386792,
0.0013801605,
0.0417990163,
0.0082254084,
0.0367182307,
0.0085831825,
-0.0023933898,
0.0267681163,
-0.0031399063,
0.0016140568,
0.0140854055,
-0.0025859789,
0.0143138738,
0.0241555348,
-0.0077632796,
0.0367782451,
-0.05470201,
-0.0052873776,
0.011643921,
-0.0312541313,
0.0012177662,
0.0183981471,
0.0782895759,
0.0042785807,
-0.0325294323,
0.0869105309,
0.0318662077,
-0.0066125565,
0.0410070755,
-0.0020482955,
0.0260134917,
0.0674302131,
0.0067649572,
-0.0007478476,
0.0305384248,
-0.0361970067,
-0.020591069,
0.0682576299,
-0.0099129612,
-0.0190865155,
0.0465869717,
-0.0484042689,
-0.0280807149,
0.0442943871,
0.0095373662,
0.0341141298,
0.0010945422,
0.0737811401,
0.0317518339,
-0.0378279984,
-0.013547889,
0.0194185339,
-0.0449163578,
-0.0430080332,
0.0265543982,
0.0517038777,
-0.021976864,
0.0563963279,
-0.0180832166,
-0.0306184329,
-0.0071127634,
-0.0238320213,
0.0009363365,
-0.0154950591,
-0.0142948907,
-0.0398067012,
0.0153459478,
-0.01379064,
-0.0129806492,
-0.0245036557,
-0.0374237262,
-0.0563843474,
-0.0214395151,
0.0256817155,
0.0211061817,
-0.0700418279,
0.0289335046,
0.0304219164,
0.0164841954,
-0.0104359388,
0.0297535229,
-0.0223348048,
0.0355851576,
-0.038734667,
-0.0432351269,
0.0355863608,
0.007562988,
-0.0325472504,
0.0274753552,
-0.0224057026,
0.0184322875,
0.0638289303,
0.0061817379,
-0.0039415499,
-0.0095866118,
-0.0343782976,
-0.0302130636,
-0.0131762493,
0.0671425015,
-0.0056395628,
0.0639285222,
-0.0066099963,
-0.0308592655,
-0.0152624473,
-0.0086865537,
-0.0117431115,
-0.0051131444,
0.0535380132,
0.0109099867,
-0.0070644789,
-0.0006079476,
0.007717134,
0.0082883146,
0.0320256613,
0.0108079035,
-0.0649031848,
-0.0495908409,
-0.0152994301,
-0.0228830893,
-0.0087207602,
-0.0079072602,
0.0314705819,
-0.004386635,
0.0409015827,
0.006007269,
0.0058577126,
-0.0492304936,
-0.0023319118,
-0.0310628805,
-0.0406138487,
-0.0553875901,
0.0134938527,
-0.0024330239,
0.0409373194,
-0.0311208181,
-0.053096462,
0.0186571423,
0.0928590894,
-0.0521759838,
0.0086543681,
-0.0350568295,
-0.0608959608,
-0.0074949483,
-0.008247993,
-0.0551212914,
0.0430479124,
-0.0040085465,
0.039799951,
-0.0215106327,
0.0027898608,
0.0454523042,
-0.0169605035,
-0.0066450983,
0.0061566038,
-0.0295074955,
-0.0394914746,
0.0256017633,
-0.0366181135,
0.0316017307,
0.026384322,
-0.0754458383,
-0.0066869627,
0.001803947,
0.0567729436,
0.0202199966,
0.0524139553,
-0.0050591538,
0.0243449751,
-0.0078901723,
-0.023158757,
-0.0232588295,
-0.0139864134,
-0.0063130185,
0.0206270218,
0.0204267949,
-0.0342148989,
-0.0425629765,
0.0673529282,
0.0050254925,
0.0432284959,
0.015805738,
-0.0135982055,
-0.0035060663,
0.0369716026,
0.0212096423,
-0.0338108055,
-0.0028050232,
-0.0632658973,
0.0116581274,
-0.010369217,
-0.0483565368,
-0.0348235779,
0.0202713646,
-0.0105797816,
-0.0093657169,
-0.0634527206,
-0.0143987024,
-0.0248629041,
-0.0050489758,
-0.0319108255,
0.0018660702,
0.0859769061,
-0.0013278053,
0.0146121001,
-0.042773962,
-0.0054854983,
0.0070182187,
-0.0093007395,
0.0245397817,
-0.1299644858,
-0.0131484037,
-0.0110364966,
-0.0048809028,
0.0518872924,
-0.0691459179,
-0.0140971281,
-0.1007824168,
-0.0027429848,
-0.0212799199,
-0.063784577,
-0.0284587406,
-0.0653477311,
-0.0214506518,
-0.0519361719,
-0.000423358,
-0.0422562584,
-0.0245211031,
-0.0150185097,
0.0208971351,
-0.014338091,
-0.0372326635,
-0.023349287,
-0.0550721139,
-0.0383757204,
0.0032877128,
0.0350213386,
-0.0080027422,
-0.0171099771,
-0.0435649455,
-0.0509352051,
-0.0461595021,
0.0069676382,
0.0423683412,
-0.0224474184,
-0.0428914838,
0.0117907766,
-0.0283899307,
-0.0283350665,
0.0024539763,
0.0020210198,
0.0142871663,
0.0245827567,
0.0234432369,
0.0423736498,
-0.0410412662,
0.015944954,
0.0659989864,
0.0000561322,
-0.0290819574,
-0.0118028633,
0.0114967264,
-0.0145693421,
0.0081221592,
0.0206729546,
0.0127303684,
-0.0425685905,
-0.0523467362,
-0.0496732891,
-0.0686282516,
0.0184810739,
0.0338808484,
0.0208221562,
0.018542042,
0.0733431429,
-0.0317123905,
-0.0390174426,
-0.0081366217,
-0.0771279559,
0.0199548956,
-0.0291308314,
0.0339090228,
-0.0294620935,
-0.005526152,
-0.0431069098,
-0.0176104754,
-0.084633261,
-0.0517489947,
-0.0221341457,
0.0031380798,
0.0064406567,
0.0344175175,
-0.0229286179,
-0.0107054329,
0.0300674066,
0.038234964,
-0.0356214568,
-0.0484780185,
0.0427949168,
0.0155574288,
-0.0274975765,
0.017653821,
-0.0186686385,
0.0336855799,
0.0269154999,
0.0316691622,
-0.0604317114,
-0.0137820439,
0.0014237971,
0.0156409908,
0.0223629232,
-0.0201829132,
-0.0116918199,
-0.0691261366,
0.0098781632,
0.0144160856,
0.0283824559,
-0.0046342299,
-0.0520415641,
0.041026853,
0.0210101511,
0.0116775446,
0.0674093664,
-0.0052295621,
-0.0049987915,
-0.0305448566,
0.0210934095,
-0.0003047744,
0.0571761131,
-0.0001896177,
-0.0136695234,
0.0557959862,
0.0343895592,
0.0612290613,
0.0310057942,
-0.0290371589,
0.0123751787,
-0.0076758754,
0.0346673355,
0.0210533924,
-0.013670289,
-0.0005398368,
-0.0022208993,
-0.0127893547,
0.0464962833,
0.0639193058,
-0.047318995,
0.032983426,
-0.0365619771,
0.0078208679,
-0.0079536065,
0.0145808784,
-0.0140151912,
-0.0119207883,
0.0094522396,
0.0113236811,
-0.015442105,
0.0099045178,
0.0757830441,
-0.007243102,
0.0206827149,
-0.0148212984,
0.0090121543,
-0.0393019654,
-0.0155518427,
0.0766037926,
-0.0306744762,
-0.0388333164,
0.0205664542,
-0.0374607071,
-0.0639343262,
0.0083600674,
-0.0467324443,
-0.030009985,
0.005649928,
0.0285927579,
0.0198387783,
0.0120423902,
0.0500834323,
-0.0172559414,
-0.0118246898,
0.0047721416,
-0.0302993674,
-0.0181611627,
-6.063360023e-33,
0.0083451895,
-0.0047645918,
0.0250275135,
-0.0089031439,
0.029542055,
0.0522982106,
-0.0131052742,
-0.0268354602,
0.0232703388,
-0.0069686756,
-0.021821849,
0.011084537,
0.0391156115,
0.0273814686,
0.0002681173,
-0.0026410588,
0.0694777593,
0.0251307506,
0.0007735583,
0.0164789129,
0.0229743253,
0.0840396285,
0.1276628971,
-0.0760529339,
0.0692249537,
-0.0091058807,
-0.0324547365,
-0.000215918,
0.1191913262,
0.0497208498,
-0.0506971814,
-0.0034982942,
0.0029608589,
-0.1170962229,
-0.0050987052,
-0.017385276,
-0.1300029308,
-0.0086125499,
-0.0252685361,
0.0539031252,
0.0119028725,
-0.0153619787,
-0.0073519694,
-0.0285291784,
-0.0064803208,
0.051359646,
0.0099479826,
0.0157872308,
-0.0070897765,
-0.0168874152,
-0.069771409,
0.0639048889,
0.0055854036,
0.0508183911,
0.0991014913,
0.0311952922,
0.0177199692,
-0.0423359722,
-0.0819285959,
0.0106019964,
0.0201528873,
-0.0199977104,
0.0411973074,
0.0270968415,
-0.0404599309,
0.0316233672,
0.0391889513,
0.0056641367,
0.0551250242,
-0.0177061837,
0.0260697417,
0.0002733512,
-0.0229975712,
0.0778755322,
0.0324579552,
-0.051390212,
-0.0641068891,
0.0510031693,
-0.0279736351,
0.0196951944,
-0.0079852985,
-0.0033403982,
-0.0559252352,
-0.04224943,
-0.0029725395,
-0.0547090471,
-0.0204742532,
-0.0063447841,
0.0198035557,
0.0288884509,
-0.0286664981,
0.040209841,
0.0187399965,
-0.0297668129,
-0.1108656451,
0.0054532634,
0.0247956794,
-0.000427174,
0.0188279487,
0.0162227843,
-0.0750055537,
-0.0803141743,
-0.0149153769,
-0.0046492903,
-0.0014667745,
-0.0008714042,
0.0762320459,
-0.0071316618,
-0.0814538077,
0.0215044674,
0.0111921029,
0.0207308587,
-0.0150050195,
0.0753119513,
0.0015907618,
-0.0201823991,
-0.0079770209,
-0.0041787503,
0.0608645789,
-0.0275473148,
0.0311695654,
0.0111751072,
0.0201009419,
0.0738530755,
0.0150356786,
0.0073192213,
-0.0200282298,
-0.0056273541,
0.0249675624,
-0.0293649491,
-0.0046148929,
0.0251463857,
2.794e-7,
0.0040197112,
0.0110155037,
-0.004397132,
-0.0094009181,
-0.0214848723,
0.0213020928,
-0.0097107003,
0.0301864259,
-0.0483654104,
-0.0239669457,
-0.0108295325,
0.0165711846,
0.0781726092,
-0.0069631869,
-0.1323919445,
-0.0265037343,
-0.0055311141,
-0.0034732712,
-0.0621341988,
0.0437699668,
-0.007296449,
0.0837135613,
-0.0222075339,
-0.0349640623,
-0.0272339936,
-0.0453034118,
0.0539527647,
-0.0137995966,
0.0061792089,
-0.0078969738,
0.0251665618,
0.0388126709,
-0.0168101452,
0.0449617468,
-0.0162108522,
0.016080711,
0.0296611488,
0.0683276057,
0.045041088,
0.0713916421,
0.0062214816,
-0.0095920982,
-0.0260752402,
-0.0429835767,
0.0435754471,
-0.0300591495,
-0.0152678061,
0.0299328733,
-0.0134662744,
0.0051234127,
0.0496636368,
0.0269095413,
-0.0132119637,
0.0271810181,
0.0573133864,
-0.0185512844,
-0.0055665132,
-0.0077884928,
0.0561194904,
0.0293094646,
0.0314980596,
0.0148164378,
-0.0231214035,
-0.0249474328,
0.0258379914,
-0.0080934698,
0.029285457,
2.55519434e-34,
0.0262308773,
0.0010249348,
-0.0200991631,
0.0558188073,
0.0337128565,
-0.0310325846,
-0.0407648347,
0.0072246278,
-0.0121363197,
-0.0406407192,
0.0306061916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07544v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07544v1 | A Dialogue System for Assessing Activities of Daily Living: Improving Consistency with Grounded Knowledge | 2023-07-15T22:41:59 | 2023-07-15T22:41:59 | Zhecheng Sheng, Raymond Finzel, Michael Lucke, Sheena Dufresne, Maria Gini, Serguei Pakhomov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In healthcare, the ability to care for oneself is reflected in the
"Activities of Daily Living (ADL)," which serve as a measure of functional
ability (functioning). A lack of functioning may lead to poor living conditions
requiring personal care and assistance. To accurately identify those in need of
support, assistance programs continuously evaluate participants' functioning
across various domains. However, the assessment process may encounter
consistency issues when multiple assessors with varying levels of expertise are
involved. Novice assessors, in particular, may lack the necessary preparation
for real-world interactions with participants. To address this issue, we
developed a dialogue system that simulates interactions between assessors and
individuals of varying functioning in a natural and reproducible way. The
dialogue system consists of two major modules, one for natural language
understanding (NLU) and one for natural language generation (NLG),
respectively. In order to generate responses consistent with the underlying
knowledge base, the dialogue system requires both an understanding of the
user's query and of biographical details of an individual being simulated. To
fulfill this requirement, we experimented with query classification and
generated responses based on those biographical details using some recently
released InstructGPT-like models. | [
0.0670722499,
0.0267641619,
-0.0243191849,
0.0056331451,
-0.024208989,
0.018990403,
0.0201936234,
-0.0062061013,
0.0698135346,
-0.0179492589,
0.0238803141,
-0.0347026512,
-0.0121200169,
0.0225134753,
0.0089764353,
-0.0516619161,
0.026712507,
0.0291985106,
0.0164875016,
0.0250526927,
-0.0093037495,
0.0520443879,
-0.0663179457,
0.0421307124,
0.0130845504,
-0.0079703443,
-0.0206694193,
-0.0183145422,
0.0372187831,
-0.0198028442,
0.0259892624,
0.0452234186,
0.0245483667,
-0.0230439734,
0.000002038,
-0.0406791605,
-0.0041094781,
0.0097943656,
-0.0177648719,
-0.0805449262,
0.0319256447,
0.0399603099,
0.0520854741,
0.0320156775,
-0.0522564203,
0.0015140284,
0.0208409782,
0.0424072817,
0.0615392774,
0.0291550905,
-0.0055138511,
0.0024523379,
-0.0444420576,
0.0073223887,
0.0184696261,
-0.010383809,
0.005450788,
0.0491195619,
0.0474163331,
-0.0272061266,
0.036436446,
0.0171377491,
-0.0121451262,
0.0047023124,
0.0304718707,
0.0201241635,
0.0091753555,
0.0005285426,
0.0262515452,
0.0637170374,
0.0602837317,
0.0587990545,
0.0251461957,
0.0042679124,
0.026046304,
0.0349733867,
-0.0439646542,
-0.0191278942,
-0.0144778853,
-0.0350477584,
-0.0235918071,
0.0568737499,
-0.0286376849,
-0.0144957751,
0.0103013664,
-0.0137608992,
-0.0002048297,
-0.0416191705,
0.0188203026,
-0.0151892425,
0.0102375746,
-0.0717196688,
0.0356458463,
0.0265308078,
-0.0743627846,
0.0144894663,
-0.0225336254,
0.0298735835,
0.0385687947,
-0.0178137626,
0.0124570495,
0.051879514,
0.0259939879,
-0.0026410343,
0.0524085648,
0.0476136655,
0.0327047184,
-0.0088818204,
-0.0558307059,
0.0506606624,
-0.1088291779,
-0.0349452496,
-0.0509734973,
0.0581947304,
-0.0612448826,
0.0043388978,
-0.0777781308,
0.0199184455,
-0.0155587038,
-0.0198452156,
-0.003544338,
0.0488005131,
-0.0103320312,
0.0638071969,
-0.0650343299,
-0.0014701569,
-0.0402208865,
0.0059020394,
0.0039632497,
-0.0420698859,
0.0348815173,
0.017780818,
0.0025372086,
-0.0455027632,
0.0069453241,
0.0110869966,
-0.0188495182,
-0.0197969731,
0.0036020379,
-0.0601775795,
-0.0271998309,
-0.044754073,
-0.0056217946,
-0.0302583687,
0.0388670415,
-0.0114922505,
-0.0110847605,
-0.0321356542,
0.0324570239,
0.0465908423,
-0.0199629255,
0.0859965608,
-0.0116598699,
0.0173247494,
0.0702869743,
0.0224191938,
0.0675956234,
0.0033608002,
-0.0064754644,
-0.0522050932,
-0.0001906341,
-0.0074564521,
0.007093675,
-0.013815226,
-0.0053590164,
-0.0251419675,
0.0451567248,
0.0546673946,
-0.0541806519,
0.0611776151,
-0.0385232866,
0.0535393395,
-0.0211534463,
0.0362212099,
0.0290762093,
0.0712517649,
0.0109877195,
0.0411690585,
0.0278934818,
0.0505891331,
0.0053876787,
0.0031346804,
-0.0176720209,
-0.002814261,
0.0119341575,
-0.0197736342,
-0.0206588134,
0.0042563416,
-0.0325135179,
-0.0720482096,
-0.0019196684,
0.0108190421,
0.0325167179,
0.0070813061,
-0.0107715661,
-0.0114278272,
-0.0199375227,
0.0100893835,
-0.0248018242,
-0.0724768639,
0.0120956432,
-0.080474861,
-0.0178768579,
0.1058888733,
0.0650405064,
-0.0136366133,
-0.0427555516,
-0.0135849463,
0.0138102323,
0.0094784889,
-0.0174387693,
-0.0228208043,
-0.009565589,
-0.0317243263,
-0.0345523395,
0.01637589,
-0.0010256558,
-0.0079630567,
-0.0326750986,
0.0007049249,
0.0210518297,
0.0065261349,
-0.0201312061,
0.0245261714,
-0.0323853418,
-0.0279192515,
0.0188442301,
0.0089113414,
0.0217145886,
0.072900489,
0.0146106258,
0.0335754119,
0.000219785,
-0.0052118897,
-0.0284510981,
0.0550030172,
-0.0285366885,
-0.0282375664,
-0.0110448264,
0.0009466171,
0.0180690009,
0.001731743,
0.0039520166,
-0.0508644059,
-0.016400937,
-0.0478994139,
-0.0107937427,
-0.0678947121,
-0.0256818924,
0.0442436077,
-0.0448915139,
-0.0775071234,
0.0576132834,
-0.0032730235,
0.0328257568,
0.0104499701,
-0.0051579578,
-0.0017997132,
-0.1144113839,
-0.0250905119,
-0.0218601041,
-0.0327474102,
0.0297030862,
0.0107594496,
0.0639632344,
-0.0412319899,
0.0092017753,
-0.1274553835,
-0.0073134801,
-0.026115194,
0.0017629017,
0.0090561332,
0.016811939,
-0.0246987008,
-0.0274375919,
-0.0736499578,
0.003421095,
0.0533463694,
0.0058324379,
0.0553398989,
0.0325621963,
-0.0111278007,
-0.0010841645,
0.0139159905,
-0.0140232351,
0.0205757357,
0.0514848083,
-0.0257512834,
-0.0201591123,
-0.0313576572,
-0.032450024,
-0.0046703508,
0.0042476705,
-0.0229686797,
0.0276489779,
0.0068987808,
0.0210263561,
-0.0102368109,
0.0367233008,
0.0301971678,
-0.0024355354,
-0.0157636814,
-0.0473876037,
0.0222027153,
-0.0384092629,
0.0189223122,
-0.0296162479,
-0.0651548356,
0.0381876379,
0.0287805572,
0.062675707,
0.0187053476,
-0.0394231305,
0.0304645263,
-0.0198011883,
0.0090091387,
-0.056396354,
0.0259144176,
-0.0185304079,
0.0352506228,
0.0100954082,
0.0049287942,
0.0623715706,
0.0153721049,
-0.023741927,
-0.0757462531,
-0.0049923882,
-0.0285317786,
0.0459159166,
-0.0129620666,
0.0339177586,
0.034536764,
-0.0527830422,
-0.0128167523,
-0.0324066989,
-0.0150594143,
-0.0481794849,
0.026444748,
-0.0839300677,
0.038074661,
-0.0052711833,
-0.0334931873,
-0.0660444573,
-0.0249133781,
0.0056334897,
0.01504777,
-0.0190554168,
-0.0003311948,
-0.0118106939,
0.0050546937,
-0.0004518966,
0.0508517064,
-0.0117955394,
-0.0215086415,
-0.0109359818,
0.0305358209,
0.0461396538,
0.0567929,
-0.059823703,
0.0189920943,
0.0160762612,
0.0420446955,
-0.0066319974,
0.0256613977,
0.0455546975,
-0.0069300188,
0.0000451577,
-0.0387653299,
0.024218848,
0.0295645278,
0.0312067363,
-0.0059013944,
-0.060056787,
0.1287308484,
0.0432625189,
-0.0081011374,
0.0133659979,
-0.0189418811,
-0.0341793671,
0.0064067934,
0.035876859,
-0.0593704022,
0.0042123781,
-0.0501385406,
0.0778966919,
-0.0435685292,
-0.0421743728,
0.0088673979,
-0.064537026,
0.0470160432,
-0.0250305887,
-0.0362546481,
-0.048384808,
0.0139610237,
-0.004215966,
-0.0112536959,
-0.0132734245,
0.0062713083,
0.0140358396,
0.0335635692,
0.0152246244,
-0.0408421233,
-0.0835829228,
0.0444348864,
0.0132162841,
0.0631311834,
0.0670521036,
0.0685322732,
0.051691968,
-0.0323657952,
-0.0117609696,
-0.0230045803,
0.0384335481,
-0.0347809754,
0.0505860001,
0.0048626279,
0.0102702267,
-0.0626162291,
0.0352218859,
-0.0394809917,
0.0078694848,
0.0338761434,
0.02916402,
-0.0838191584,
0.0220461693,
-0.0170259234,
0.0481381044,
0.0918388218,
0.0633027181,
0.0016208017,
-0.0160452388,
-0.0042557828,
0.0066385055,
0.0306991283,
-0.0305190459,
-0.0362694822,
-0.0136911748,
-0.0228891373,
0.0280478019,
-0.0539367683,
-0.0416435823,
0.0589328259,
0.0346448272,
-0.0194904078,
-0.0069679101,
0.0555861145,
0.0529586114,
-0.0342041105,
0.0051423553,
-0.001946972,
0.0269948263,
-0.0123105673,
-0.0674852654,
0.0445833877,
-0.0162896328,
-0.0468922257,
-0.0366000719,
-0.0114429398,
0.0054654819,
0.0065568266,
0.0447055958,
0.0246651284,
-0.0104166511,
-0.0159533937,
0.0158158895,
-0.0430991389,
-0.0027916944,
-0.0282692574,
-0.0166397691,
-0.0166425575,
0.058953695,
-0.0166584682,
0.0213130862,
0.008137323,
0.0042507341,
-0.0447152331,
0.0347416662,
-0.0833122432,
-0.0734023228,
0.0195985045,
0.0158374961,
0.0102359354,
0.0118608996,
-0.0171418581,
-0.0399477184,
0.0149618248,
-0.0208494086,
-0.0391807333,
-0.0572629981,
-0.0001974652,
0.0160666965,
-0.0222063661,
0.0204386879,
-0.0186780263,
-0.0986329243,
0.0259331223,
-0.0533586033,
-0.0026848505,
0.019987328,
0.0250216797,
-0.0268247463,
-0.035163179,
-0.0132179987,
0.0002277284,
0.0222901646,
0.0444426276,
0.0133451875,
0.0964085236,
-0.0217124913,
-0.0158773065,
0.0169376489,
0.0145625584,
-0.0268742181,
-0.0198457204,
-0.0362552255,
0.0371634364,
-0.0064795804,
0.0266936515,
-0.0222633462,
-0.00116747,
0.0143691525,
-0.0036033383,
0.001820931,
0.0202168263,
-0.0104123643,
0.0334567577,
0.0077703702,
-0.0152928866,
-0.0649684593,
0.0387556404,
0.0049392311,
-0.022147337,
-0.0130551085,
-0.0457384102,
-0.0612861402,
-0.0372323357,
-0.012274934,
0.0425526239,
-0.0455928892,
0.0024975983,
-0.0544721037,
-0.008587705,
0.0083027491,
0.001479546,
0.0082338406,
-0.0043504061,
0.0776423141,
0.0212422572,
-0.0217098407,
-0.0260360036,
-0.0575158224,
0.0175594464,
-0.0715104043,
-0.0103236344,
-0.0353636071,
-5.593234649e-33,
-0.0600762516,
-0.0723660961,
0.0523580015,
-0.0399976894,
-0.0125354035,
-0.03088695,
-0.0253362078,
0.0073930579,
-0.0151577182,
-0.0186870694,
0.0372745432,
0.0019584617,
0.0067231739,
0.0383272134,
0.0134256957,
-0.0506254323,
0.0446965136,
0.0118497713,
-0.0086505301,
0.0446205772,
-0.0069278125,
0.0169214383,
0.0287158191,
-0.0871698037,
0.0626955777,
-0.0087793563,
-0.0106990682,
0.0323574953,
0.0029455367,
0.0228298567,
-0.0400422588,
0.0513926148,
0.0473296978,
0.0340278111,
0.0137031404,
0.0461316928,
-0.0731579363,
-0.0452511273,
0.0321602114,
-0.0084186131,
-0.0385228358,
-0.0009241129,
0.0055749337,
0.0014076346,
-0.0185092408,
-0.0035708593,
0.0448279083,
-0.0192548055,
0.0529679768,
-0.0031918902,
-0.0179949254,
0.0163891278,
-0.0066425325,
-0.0305959471,
-0.081573613,
0.0557623841,
-0.0240012892,
-0.0297449008,
-0.0217319727,
0.0064278077,
-0.0047389339,
0.0232746322,
0.018679468,
-0.0025569121,
-0.0215261448,
0.0259895492,
-0.0230977181,
-0.0156727824,
-0.0665732622,
0.0102011738,
-0.0263482947,
0.0202147961,
0.0259112474,
0.0801938698,
0.003524937,
0.0143287275,
-0.0254503954,
0.0415475108,
0.0177290216,
0.0308753122,
0.0105170151,
-0.0064710709,
-0.0219540279,
-0.0109895095,
-0.0472888872,
0.0251596943,
-0.0290910453,
-0.0288952459,
0.0343898386,
0.0119464165,
-0.025865972,
0.0142460633,
-0.0230547078,
0.0042520561,
-0.0075775366,
-0.020615859,
0.0331548899,
-0.0248912834,
-0.0277784895,
-0.0173150003,
-0.0169337671,
-0.0155819841,
0.0186005775,
0.0247004479,
0.0150690321,
0.0239326637,
-0.0127118779,
-0.0324084535,
-0.0245382152,
-0.021129461,
0.0178856347,
0.0565178059,
-0.0305912849,
0.0659196302,
-0.0031731131,
0.0114685372,
-0.0316074863,
0.0909256786,
-0.0253264792,
-0.0262034107,
-0.0773043856,
-0.0371244512,
-0.0012413434,
0.0134071894,
-0.0227425229,
0.0186851248,
-0.0102683529,
0.021165695,
0.0117755635,
-0.0136071257,
0.0346386693,
0.0008589429,
2.765e-7,
0.0331542715,
0.0329810195,
-0.0012594718,
-0.0128522189,
0.0057961629,
-0.0005401214,
0.037782684,
0.0366553105,
0.016207628,
-0.0138849616,
0.0614546947,
0.0050637731,
0.0335933492,
0.0250381622,
-0.0511031784,
-0.0500825122,
-0.0213329978,
-0.0194756649,
-0.0633893311,
0.0383410901,
0.1138718873,
0.0087955203,
-0.0290040039,
-0.0051920819,
-0.0070785275,
-0.047953859,
0.0107681863,
0.0183290578,
-0.0263541322,
0.0120844273,
0.0412191488,
-0.0351561569,
0.0472189412,
0.052718889,
-0.0228863265,
0.0067604012,
0.0268998314,
0.1005035862,
-0.0483956523,
-0.0180085078,
-0.0128383916,
0.004735915,
0.0167096704,
-0.0019111278,
0.0393367037,
-0.0736207664,
0.0115226144,
0.0133758038,
-0.0159873813,
-0.0409840643,
0.0316720307,
-0.0134635447,
-0.0607310981,
0.0184888374,
0.0319166258,
0.0115793552,
0.0308998041,
-0.025271479,
0.0191284735,
0.005268414,
-0.0883805752,
-0.0525556915,
-0.0069530657,
-0.0258620903,
-0.0276062619,
-0.0478750281,
-0.0200390574,
2.363118334e-34,
-0.0066026538,
0.1084657237,
0.0125745321,
-0.0018169874,
0.036180798,
0.0157730039,
-0.0004322999,
0.0428445823,
0.0305334684,
-0.0449588411,
-0.0306092016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07889v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07889v3 | LLM Comparative Assessment: Zero-shot NLG Evaluation through Pairwise Comparisons using Large Language Models | 2023-07-15T22:02:12 | 2024-02-06T17:05:58 | Adian Liusie, Potsawee Manakul, Mark J. F. Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current developments in large language models (LLMs) have enabled impressive
zero-shot capabilities across various natural language tasks. An interesting
application of these systems is in the automated assessment of natural language
generation (NLG), a highly challenging area with great practical benefit. In
this paper, we explore two options for exploiting the emergent abilities of
LLMs for zero-shot NLG assessment: absolute score prediction, and comparative
assessment which uses relative comparisons between pairs of candidates. Though
comparative assessment has not been extensively studied in NLG assessment, we
note that humans often find it more intuitive to compare two options rather
than scoring each one independently. This work examines comparative assessment
from multiple perspectives: performance compared to absolute grading;
positional biases in the prompt; and efficient ranking in terms of the number
of comparisons. We illustrate that LLM comparative assessment is a simple,
general and effective approach for NLG assessment. For moderate-sized
open-source LLMs, such as FlanT5 and Llama2-chat, comparative assessment is
superior to prompt scoring, and in many cases can achieve performance
competitive with state-of-the-art methods. Additionally, we demonstrate that
LLMs often exhibit strong positional biases when making pairwise comparisons,
and we propose debiasing methods that can further improve performance. | [
0.0101163341,
0.0266989972,
0.0050812992,
0.0269778222,
-0.0384116359,
0.0027052497,
0.0429593883,
-0.0140421074,
0.017658066,
-0.0759969205,
-0.0511710085,
-0.0530738682,
0.0036636065,
0.0149448784,
0.0362290964,
-0.0389648862,
-0.0056202146,
-0.0160306524,
0.0256018098,
-0.0163870733,
0.002311198,
0.0215796009,
-0.01404656,
0.0338539816,
0.053871382,
0.0155842099,
0.0059541278,
0.0094279516,
0.0341334231,
-0.0657489672,
-0.0199500043,
0.0712307841,
0.0008462038,
0.0148992818,
0.0000019705,
-0.0575379692,
0.00239888,
-0.0253002364,
-0.0052152416,
0.0227281153,
0.0589817204,
0.030614594,
0.0194219481,
0.0051333969,
-0.0416246392,
-0.0356608406,
0.0258854181,
-0.0094077829,
0.0656071827,
0.0508893207,
0.0045697936,
0.0006822243,
-0.0163113866,
-0.0322619677,
0.0092324028,
-0.0371540673,
0.0015331799,
0.0004725194,
0.0238127932,
0.0307321399,
0.004232306,
0.0093053654,
0.0084754704,
-0.0204661526,
0.0346510224,
0.060504701,
-0.0354711041,
-0.0159397032,
0.0059898957,
0.0871594623,
-0.0231084321,
-0.0213018544,
0.0099175321,
-0.0188950431,
0.008469766,
-0.0208956543,
-0.0476187207,
0.0546366945,
0.0004769108,
0.0197914187,
0.037962012,
0.0322451964,
0.0074090664,
0.0469818562,
0.0056098411,
0.0317114741,
0.0256749988,
-0.0254308041,
0.0101865139,
0.0187970474,
-0.0240459554,
-0.0902460814,
-0.0050464179,
0.0343457609,
-0.070998475,
0.006015528,
-0.0453629568,
0.0068744328,
0.0294882674,
-0.0316038951,
0.0649539456,
0.0204913095,
0.0127972066,
0.0186825953,
-0.0406489596,
0.0796105042,
0.0494107269,
-0.0155204581,
-0.0710993484,
0.0306904633,
-0.045852568,
-0.0115125095,
-0.0203460027,
0.0388584584,
-0.0362997614,
-0.0186572019,
-0.0863904878,
-0.0338411368,
-0.0183361638,
-0.0107667437,
0.0265370235,
0.042008318,
-0.0385914259,
0.0156309139,
-0.0294061638,
0.0154210869,
-0.0499737523,
0.0022211436,
0.0313289799,
-0.051397372,
-0.0016149561,
0.0240471046,
0.0143023096,
-0.0225768164,
-0.0061291186,
0.0589921549,
-0.0085138297,
-0.0257636551,
0.004585545,
-0.043317534,
-0.0188582987,
-0.0709337518,
-0.0042199399,
-0.0724685788,
0.0158036482,
-0.0005974107,
-0.0130722011,
-0.0011908191,
0.0270872749,
0.038727589,
0.0047495081,
0.0274650641,
0.0184323471,
-0.0029612307,
0.0120138396,
0.0118843177,
-0.0052544936,
0.0596212707,
0.0151522243,
0.0288754199,
0.0120527735,
-0.0000552001,
0.0270978436,
0.0161135942,
-0.0074638482,
-0.0177120343,
0.0004302427,
-0.0016616068,
-0.0089761009,
0.0650867447,
0.0375485383,
0.0513197333,
-0.0405670628,
0.0014688672,
0.0650132522,
0.0168320127,
0.0416666456,
-0.0200341418,
0.1046684235,
0.0159302633,
-0.0229649916,
0.0350027792,
-0.0206121802,
0.0331509411,
-0.0330876745,
0.0132581303,
0.0522497073,
0.0490777232,
-0.007597507,
-0.0449235663,
-0.0016970671,
0.0089045558,
0.00053476,
-0.0213983152,
0.0161639191,
0.0239034239,
-0.0652170181,
0.0260744374,
0.0273707174,
-0.0667372569,
0.0177337341,
-0.0402711667,
0.0275187045,
0.0727210417,
0.0542533137,
0.0379349515,
-0.051904697,
0.0126798842,
-0.0493727028,
0.0665074438,
0.0435418561,
-0.0205060337,
-0.0032838385,
-0.0665920004,
-0.0026852307,
-0.02791797,
0.0219981261,
0.0199596398,
0.0048250533,
0.0146317333,
0.0381006375,
-0.0075662737,
-0.0445891172,
0.0205283668,
-0.0211729184,
-0.0516122468,
0.0219414514,
-0.015514032,
0.012597614,
0.0037794244,
-0.0204757638,
0.0306451581,
0.013924499,
-0.0377078801,
-0.0267177783,
0.003251571,
-0.0476699211,
-0.0733546615,
0.0070675882,
-0.0317894593,
0.0228694342,
0.0004193597,
-0.0572996326,
-0.024368763,
0.0129723502,
-0.0107778404,
-0.0083189989,
-0.026430903,
0.0369157866,
0.0282722674,
-0.0099276816,
-0.0643541962,
0.0793042704,
0.0196163096,
0.0337847099,
0.0437395126,
0.0068508158,
0.0029788984,
-0.0556656942,
-0.0319222957,
0.0265094079,
0.0014376323,
-0.0027933714,
0.0184364785,
0.0482756197,
-0.0666210279,
-0.0396724045,
-0.1177556366,
0.0453258865,
-0.0084390091,
0.0284960419,
0.0516589843,
-0.0280195177,
0.0068272604,
0.0322733521,
-0.0526769161,
-0.0274764858,
0.0600382499,
0.016609244,
0.0438861586,
0.0067761741,
-0.0220173988,
-0.0456632785,
0.005896097,
0.0022087793,
0.0553484149,
0.0485271439,
0.03293401,
-0.0197233837,
0.079382427,
-0.0615279414,
-0.0550633296,
0.0272548366,
-0.0528207459,
0.0091803893,
0.0144337649,
0.0184722599,
0.0350988172,
0.0183507968,
0.0192776769,
0.0606442392,
-0.0218360107,
-0.0379594117,
-0.0422959328,
-0.0046868199,
-0.0136228222,
0.0101548694,
-0.0357390381,
-0.0069558797,
0.051533822,
0.0273132436,
-0.0014257478,
-0.0391589105,
0.0787274241,
-0.0493350998,
-0.0367795415,
-0.0363809168,
-0.0182519574,
0.0081427898,
0.0303705055,
-0.0485797822,
-0.0555350408,
0.0720235854,
-0.0480955727,
0.0142804151,
-0.0450851433,
0.0219875723,
-0.0493309088,
0.0413150936,
0.0207936466,
0.031274315,
-0.0076344768,
-0.003883159,
-0.0597109646,
-0.0094534848,
0.0126619916,
-0.0373712815,
0.0168785118,
-0.0587464757,
-0.0045767678,
-0.0072480985,
-0.0327215269,
-0.0400317945,
-0.0403562896,
-0.0217930581,
0.0274145827,
0.0148505103,
0.0155945718,
0.0036417663,
0.0132297464,
-0.0028066032,
-0.0066602724,
-0.0294511393,
-0.0075077959,
0.0075078337,
0.0778325275,
0.0241195112,
-0.0274468791,
-0.0116855996,
-0.0132318018,
0.0212067179,
0.0213552676,
0.0125381267,
0.0555600785,
-0.0120528778,
-0.001484254,
0.0078175934,
-0.0510214306,
-0.040564239,
0.0078653712,
0.0429961458,
-0.0524496995,
-0.0098837158,
0.1386650652,
0.0345428064,
0.0168237928,
0.0175850894,
0.0038519786,
0.0304658003,
0.0051803025,
0.0257651005,
-0.0883627832,
-0.0276550353,
-0.0176034123,
0.0215797406,
-0.0520090088,
-0.0156722143,
-0.0215722062,
-0.1777234674,
0.0303238127,
0.0241073258,
-0.0264347401,
0.0202755611,
-0.0165161099,
-0.0204974208,
-0.0194848701,
-0.0251998585,
0.019237522,
-0.0230980236,
0.0457293317,
0.0127670113,
-0.004367406,
-0.0681955889,
0.0309579857,
-0.0479856431,
0.0764901266,
0.0602330156,
0.0530603193,
0.0206955727,
-0.0093325255,
0.0014817461,
-0.0503198244,
0.029842047,
-0.0244518127,
0.0267700143,
0.0036329201,
0.0199270267,
-0.0382768549,
0.0061158389,
0.022698367,
-0.0039214627,
-0.010336685,
0.0315453149,
0.0099018393,
-0.031591855,
-0.002825967,
0.0668050796,
-0.0073621641,
0.0788697302,
0.0398538485,
-0.0429190211,
-0.0337034129,
-0.0201178454,
-0.0102528222,
-0.0705704316,
-0.043122258,
0.0106157586,
-0.001461005,
-0.0011053636,
-0.1196867824,
-0.049731344,
0.0242718253,
0.0167057086,
-0.0057554115,
0.0034045817,
-0.0462248623,
0.0034419179,
0.0071909395,
0.0154624311,
-0.0121133467,
0.004450833,
-0.0364856943,
-0.0030666089,
0.037353836,
-0.0451566912,
-0.0379032381,
0.0216706563,
-0.0724888444,
-0.0594983622,
-0.0303689241,
0.0455733798,
0.0265332013,
-0.0140792802,
-0.0021868413,
-0.054609403,
0.0459776372,
0.0689515024,
-0.0117524127,
0.0397038683,
-0.0035901291,
0.0276735164,
0.0024890623,
0.0262813922,
-0.0173844062,
0.0293650795,
0.0086204382,
0.0458994769,
0.0231298544,
-0.0363147743,
0.0144664822,
0.0451390445,
0.0149644809,
-0.0568217002,
-0.0101838969,
-0.0279051699,
-0.023120299,
-0.0452052169,
-0.0464028753,
-0.0174189974,
-0.0146153225,
0.0205288362,
0.0108927814,
-0.0102964407,
-0.0040474404,
-0.053266611,
0.0506150909,
-0.0354183279,
0.0280514471,
0.02793286,
-0.0253636707,
0.0070078331,
-0.004118016,
-0.0416597389,
-0.0069687134,
-0.0217417628,
0.0426328108,
-0.0342804529,
0.0568076521,
-0.0086346073,
0.0100742551,
0.0017448987,
0.0593135357,
-0.0420713536,
-0.0046303989,
-0.0358792357,
0.0430958457,
0.0758827403,
0.013933979,
0.0807605311,
-0.0042673624,
0.0192346126,
-0.0144244833,
0.0279263929,
0.0084161172,
-0.0623834804,
0.0340503789,
0.016976187,
-0.0029116443,
0.0086860117,
0.1007112488,
-0.0165120922,
0.0374443382,
0.0040704217,
-0.0055512786,
-0.0302417055,
-0.0312702507,
0.0070439326,
-0.0057506398,
0.0119263884,
0.0031850175,
-0.0638648421,
-0.0362383574,
0.0123986676,
0.0413806066,
0.0292093568,
-0.0292980745,
0.0552784577,
0.0353244878,
-0.0337062888,
0.0138823697,
-0.0471146926,
-0.0079679443,
-0.0379943624,
-0.017070597,
-0.0594524071,
-6.415164176e-33,
-0.0472200662,
-0.0583750717,
0.0309854373,
-0.0384849422,
-0.0391516872,
0.0020125867,
-0.0253241789,
0.025963312,
0.0171282589,
0.0042009391,
0.0118355351,
-0.048114758,
0.0054200748,
0.0100396872,
0.0063177012,
-0.0458738208,
0.0501646176,
0.0099720322,
-0.0586367175,
0.0319242105,
0.0081064291,
0.0030196288,
0.0064754691,
0.0067120343,
0.0180437807,
-0.0286167338,
-0.0306872707,
-0.0077153048,
-0.0015046794,
0.0646250173,
-0.0115458546,
0.0329177193,
0.0489778109,
-0.0335049257,
0.0006086488,
0.0151334414,
0.005581853,
-0.0126857096,
0.0281359218,
-0.0416734517,
0.0052876715,
-0.0376859568,
0.0122024817,
-0.013446087,
-0.0577487536,
0.0041876775,
0.0225865208,
-0.0231077876,
-0.001912114,
-0.0215469431,
-0.046225138,
0.0237399563,
-0.0214910749,
-0.0366782881,
-0.0262808856,
0.0730744675,
-0.0425413102,
0.028771136,
-0.0202681758,
0.0568050928,
0.0339756384,
0.0500723086,
0.0753838196,
0.010355196,
-0.0269682612,
0.0667813942,
0.0139457025,
-0.0160280243,
-0.017990144,
-0.0239594579,
-0.0125129549,
0.0254979376,
0.0387441665,
0.0769223049,
0.0681850314,
0.034382157,
-0.0611314662,
0.0493654422,
0.0195407569,
0.0077506471,
0.0259316172,
-0.0155460211,
-0.0163037907,
-0.034051396,
-0.0810401514,
-0.0472893752,
-0.0574561022,
-0.0441858359,
0.0588769801,
0.0131240524,
-0.0180027913,
-0.0444479361,
0.027198825,
-0.014042018,
-0.0031833036,
0.008021947,
-0.0450802967,
0.0308826007,
-0.0173995402,
0.0030717596,
-0.0468349196,
0.0065800715,
0.0381867029,
0.0515404269,
0.0188118871,
0.0144926589,
0.0125389332,
-0.0181700122,
-0.0420641191,
0.0262065902,
-0.0487219803,
0.0082713654,
-0.0338764377,
-0.007460421,
0.0128188683,
-0.0147447037,
-0.0245479457,
0.0561021306,
0.0174869802,
0.0036361646,
-0.0101145059,
0.00019736,
-0.0070860409,
0.0080827493,
-0.0324748792,
0.0528471954,
0.0064302981,
-0.0005032317,
0.0109309182,
-0.0332728773,
-0.0289347284,
0.004239162,
2.696e-7,
0.0144700063,
0.0595468059,
-0.0206126198,
0.0204553697,
-0.0030820833,
0.0355805457,
-0.0023916583,
0.0289934184,
0.0303899683,
0.0093553131,
-0.0093576452,
0.0216979068,
0.0293943565,
0.0283251926,
-0.0456697345,
0.0030936585,
-0.0917784274,
-0.0114500886,
-0.0609345809,
-0.0447425507,
0.0963698551,
0.0462815017,
-0.0223477557,
-0.0080644945,
0.0036807456,
-0.0463951714,
0.0662526116,
-0.0029671744,
-0.0357343405,
0.0166253336,
0.044954434,
-0.0109204091,
-0.0044913492,
0.0335197598,
-0.0010932647,
-0.0158040393,
0.0196566619,
0.0584148802,
0.0286788549,
-0.0138992313,
0.0393934175,
0.0174055211,
-0.0041473126,
-0.0653586984,
0.0840741694,
-0.0681517422,
-0.0307485368,
-0.0105989492,
-0.0257305168,
0.0129341073,
0.0170872323,
-0.0516434647,
-0.051078029,
0.0256112032,
0.0185833387,
0.0158301722,
-0.0291406084,
-0.0227765273,
-0.0428959951,
-0.0008475562,
-0.0147844702,
-0.0411354564,
-0.0251408927,
-0.0122904321,
-0.0084187696,
-0.0609577261,
-0.0033783265,
2.300194948e-34,
0.031132618,
-0.0032836169,
0.0257976092,
-0.0400035679,
0.039179951,
0.0291601457,
-0.0320060663,
-0.0159176439,
0.0159105565,
-0.0754305571,
0.0004271293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07880v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07880v1 | Is Prompt-Based Finetuning Always Better than Vanilla Finetuning? Insights from Cross-Lingual Language Understanding | 2023-07-15T20:33:33 | 2023-07-15T20:33:33 | Bolei Ma, Ercong Nie, Helmut Schmid, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual pretrained language models (MPLMs) have demonstrated substantial
performance improvements in zero-shot cross-lingual transfer across various
natural language understanding tasks by finetuning MPLMs on task-specific
labelled data of a source language (e.g. English) and evaluating on a wide
range of target languages. Recent studies show that prompt-based finetuning
surpasses regular finetuning in few-shot scenarios. However, the exploration of
prompt-based learning in multilingual tasks remains limited. In this study, we
propose the ProFiT pipeline to investigate the cross-lingual capabilities of
Prompt-based Finetuning. We conduct comprehensive experiments on diverse
cross-lingual language understanding tasks (sentiment classification,
paraphrase identification, and natural language inference) and empirically
analyze the variation trends of prompt-based finetuning performance in
cross-lingual transfer across different few-shot and full-data settings. Our
results reveal the effectiveness and versatility of prompt-based finetuning in
cross-lingual language understanding. Our findings indicate that prompt-based
finetuning outperforms vanilla finetuning in full-data scenarios and exhibits
greater advantages in few-shot scenarios, with different performance patterns
dependent on task types. Additionally, we analyze underlying factors such as
language similarity and pretraining data size that impact the cross-lingual
performance of prompt-based finetuning. Overall, our work provides valuable
insights into the cross-lingual prowess of prompt-based finetuning. | [
0.0083481446,
-0.0140861813,
-0.0115154162,
0.0639495254,
-0.0575137176,
0.0234784354,
0.0323574916,
-0.0478665344,
-0.0352680236,
-0.060764432,
-0.0604816079,
-0.0160357449,
-0.008427049,
-0.0261052158,
0.0190250613,
-0.0380933322,
0.0662361756,
-0.0279688202,
0.0150490096,
-0.0081532057,
0.0116354134,
0.0149691505,
-0.0083544329,
0.0085484376,
0.0400560163,
-0.0004128336,
0.0131413136,
-0.0013917638,
0.0452164151,
-0.0048205531,
0.022710545,
0.0276265293,
0.0237300079,
0.0189236309,
0.0000017191,
-0.078935571,
-0.0250866003,
-0.0142812049,
-0.0152747585,
-0.0138316602,
0.0678126812,
-0.0545933768,
0.0138661889,
-0.0183879491,
-0.0209588502,
-0.0155322701,
0.0496373363,
0.0354532637,
0.0398931541,
0.0355760232,
-0.0110806357,
-0.0312176179,
-0.0215723179,
-0.0404144078,
-0.0019179853,
-0.0724584609,
0.014185789,
-0.025403481,
-0.0036948652,
-0.0156240379,
-0.034290541,
0.056879729,
-0.0117069725,
0.0341224745,
-0.0446868576,
0.0125710089,
-0.0271164514,
-0.0189123116,
-0.0256267805,
0.0913859531,
-0.0443553887,
-0.010618533,
-0.0129037313,
-0.0380390696,
0.0057100765,
-0.0307468325,
-0.047845345,
0.0151439598,
0.001266993,
0.0210157782,
0.0209041052,
-0.0049254806,
0.014317954,
0.0283110756,
-0.02200347,
0.0681674033,
-0.0035581144,
-0.0211715512,
0.0339738391,
0.0419518165,
0.002003557,
-0.0124402354,
-0.0056147794,
-0.0047582011,
-0.0168006979,
0.0182893369,
-0.0536237843,
-0.032143902,
0.0276107341,
0.0205795001,
0.0417736396,
0.0303556584,
-0.0526833683,
0.0717802271,
-0.0480034538,
0.0223219749,
-0.0198552851,
0.0434284732,
-0.0386611521,
-0.0280113406,
-0.0572833419,
0.0108645204,
-0.0328985453,
0.0347740538,
-0.0228068624,
0.0079705808,
-0.0282959715,
-0.0178750791,
-0.0040908693,
-0.0107610971,
-0.0181791894,
-0.0544805638,
-0.0467081368,
-0.0117596872,
0.0058759297,
0.0703643635,
-0.0562421754,
0.0461691804,
-0.0042806724,
-0.0748280659,
-0.0306889974,
0.0110826092,
0.0241386518,
-0.0631275773,
0.01944522,
0.0214410108,
-0.0271609165,
-0.0501189232,
-0.0463233925,
-0.0311522447,
-0.0429154336,
-0.0736244991,
-0.0072992663,
-0.0657087788,
0.0630353317,
0.0103681041,
0.0066694822,
0.0124496445,
-0.0089006163,
0.0053300932,
-0.0585915893,
0.0853814036,
-0.010902972,
-0.0135506671,
-0.0365229324,
-0.0328256413,
-0.003433675,
0.0880489647,
-0.019676758,
0.0152037395,
0.0601110011,
0.0015532403,
-0.0505051427,
0.0419196673,
0.021448398,
0.0006697834,
-0.0256483089,
0.0109817609,
0.030689491,
-0.0024833234,
0.0191524923,
0.0058913343,
-0.0376833789,
0.0136602279,
0.0419240072,
0.0245929509,
0.0023768989,
-0.0125261564,
0.0776524097,
0.0216535684,
-0.0275097582,
0.0385398939,
-0.0381442606,
0.018275125,
-0.0274459533,
0.0161084905,
0.0045524156,
0.0303142872,
-0.0294368584,
-0.0154204899,
0.0227075685,
-0.0347109102,
0.003874914,
0.0337236486,
0.0541536622,
0.0399911851,
-0.0453055501,
0.035201855,
0.0577425733,
-0.0286488924,
0.0124165947,
-0.0243644379,
0.0218792204,
0.0618086495,
-0.0337246656,
-0.0232591424,
-0.039363537,
-0.0295788851,
0.0635489523,
0.0070813266,
0.0985830352,
-0.0190310702,
0.0588840917,
-0.0422056615,
-0.0196000952,
-0.0400623269,
0.0001405012,
0.0344422013,
-0.0318824016,
0.0370945409,
0.0103524504,
-0.0188285448,
-0.0111971591,
0.0061868508,
-0.0276177004,
-0.0359647311,
0.0068626888,
0.0222322419,
0.0049553858,
0.0052819466,
-0.0090984181,
-0.0046794568,
-0.0123467147,
-0.0389292873,
0.0109628486,
0.012223552,
-0.0303101819,
-0.0599239841,
0.0173781421,
-0.0075313677,
-0.0439273156,
-0.0002185239,
-0.0642748103,
-0.0272289217,
-0.0157017801,
0.0278617106,
-0.0119069889,
-0.0490077212,
0.0011525397,
-0.0369671248,
0.0512305871,
-0.0176507998,
0.0172564518,
0.0329769142,
0.0423762165,
0.0151202986,
-0.0267764125,
0.0584389493,
-0.0027047107,
-0.0416220836,
0.0309372973,
-0.0240352601,
-0.0019075773,
0.0411625654,
0.0194357093,
-0.0590363964,
-0.0155172395,
-0.0861912295,
0.0195254032,
-0.0197112728,
0.0328447148,
0.0290536638,
0.0224166382,
-0.0200333409,
-0.0355922543,
-0.0094681596,
0.0021892271,
0.0067175645,
0.0544482507,
0.0564378053,
0.0393639952,
0.0226807687,
-0.0478014201,
-0.0041039945,
-0.0037190949,
0.0161304679,
-0.0117911184,
-0.0298591442,
-0.0388815999,
0.0130750751,
-0.0315652788,
0.0138886357,
-0.0014400405,
-0.0399311781,
-0.0149418246,
-0.0222516414,
0.0265325438,
0.0685157701,
-0.0216351543,
-0.0097172009,
0.0317376107,
-0.0333316475,
-0.0478782989,
0.0312921144,
0.0076281615,
-0.0509737805,
-0.0449466556,
-0.0022120834,
0.0090165846,
0.0783636495,
-0.0046509025,
-0.0236348622,
-0.0731375739,
0.0308822542,
-0.0158408452,
-0.0106736254,
-0.0112473648,
0.0534115843,
0.0174838677,
0.0478139855,
-0.0217330158,
-0.0068543507,
0.0892382711,
-0.0280499719,
-0.0073860586,
-0.0404398106,
0.000854192,
-0.0209074002,
0.0298155583,
-0.0176289771,
0.0252411701,
0.0118815154,
-0.013941668,
-0.0721361339,
-0.034839537,
0.0427369475,
-0.0060169986,
0.027603196,
-0.0363480039,
0.0054786243,
-0.0370672382,
-0.0376258716,
0.006103409,
-0.092299886,
-0.0394301899,
0.0049480326,
-0.0100488998,
0.0396945216,
0.0085983118,
-0.0128763355,
0.0229181349,
0.0005229472,
-0.0370466225,
0.009658535,
-0.0216489621,
0.0206209291,
0.0445409007,
0.0149920564,
0.0211995393,
-0.0337028131,
0.0355076194,
-0.0135065122,
0.0093132062,
0.0258112475,
0.0023226927,
0.0036932209,
0.0458264835,
-0.0231777634,
-0.0458759405,
-0.0126474435,
0.0937892795,
-0.0477059856,
0.0106644984,
0.0851013064,
-0.008415916,
-0.0345968194,
-0.0332662128,
-0.0160705931,
0.000844611,
0.0316482,
0.0286420714,
-0.064007856,
-0.0624568574,
-0.0102235815,
0.0039382712,
0.0193943735,
-0.0322072394,
-0.029129371,
-0.1303239614,
0.0113751693,
-0.0268040895,
-0.077543214,
-0.0359033383,
-0.0031881339,
0.0100376159,
0.0226739757,
0.0348624103,
-0.0427117869,
-0.0202657524,
0.0191948786,
0.0021270351,
0.0215647779,
-0.0912643969,
0.0456214137,
-0.0514917299,
0.0083985878,
0.0555832274,
0.0489928648,
-0.0004602434,
-0.0205682982,
0.0506756715,
-0.0697916001,
-0.009292325,
-0.0097220559,
0.0720562339,
0.008514991,
-0.0421599634,
0.0524356402,
-0.0097657451,
0.0134409517,
0.0170284435,
-0.0010421091,
0.0605914593,
0.0383690633,
-0.0269259084,
0.0435727723,
0.0292102192,
0.0263436642,
0.0804206207,
0.0163119994,
-0.0373329371,
-0.0329266973,
0.0133757805,
-0.0077938871,
-0.0790363401,
-0.0120861661,
0.0393991619,
-0.0501893535,
-0.0136926286,
-0.046304483,
-0.083458893,
0.0345741622,
0.0371792801,
0.0163948853,
0.0359497257,
-0.0195184741,
0.0053709601,
-0.0146850729,
0.0275994111,
-0.0428799689,
0.0416073538,
-0.0260597151,
0.0039431253,
0.0492631309,
-0.0331531018,
-0.0112138288,
-0.0185767692,
-0.0865556225,
-0.0505629741,
-0.0212575085,
0.0626749247,
0.0087540979,
0.0500966236,
-0.0071508209,
-0.0345485061,
0.0000340198,
0.0467240736,
-0.0411885828,
0.0033683004,
0.064078398,
0.0302807074,
-0.0181465242,
0.077872254,
-0.0409042425,
0.0170813948,
0.0456905998,
0.0147171617,
0.0069499514,
-0.0480091535,
0.0162068196,
0.0277727265,
0.0633234158,
-0.0022313728,
-0.0199163668,
-0.0301911682,
0.0129188411,
0.0160853863,
-0.0307520386,
-0.0276803672,
-0.0319178179,
0.0270972457,
-0.0412672274,
-0.0033238756,
0.0238011423,
-0.0032910209,
0.00990324,
-0.0536834002,
0.004977698,
0.0374119356,
0.0200946685,
0.0200970508,
0.0168889444,
-0.0265433043,
0.0073893969,
0.0089775138,
0.0351298861,
-0.0479255579,
0.0399551578,
0.0277977958,
0.0117130661,
-0.0068790102,
0.0236001294,
-0.014134353,
-0.0354779027,
0.0433914624,
-0.006432259,
0.0517196842,
-0.0550576188,
0.0526686125,
0.023367893,
-0.0338816345,
-0.0036767258,
0.0405428857,
-0.0173733346,
0.0067288685,
0.0477788597,
0.0028954386,
-0.0088886041,
0.0198833812,
0.0597796626,
-0.0496573597,
0.0233032424,
0.0222789291,
0.0192426797,
-0.0307288859,
-0.0018793587,
0.0178733114,
-0.0036388999,
0.0157554969,
0.036602322,
-0.0475002266,
-0.0487513579,
0.0135704167,
-0.0110256001,
-0.0180834252,
0.0132887131,
0.0238645896,
0.0877121612,
-0.0102622258,
0.0015050033,
-0.0412683748,
0.0148738427,
0.0553398617,
0.0102140633,
-0.0155256391,
-6.039832871e-33,
-0.0388756841,
0.0567193851,
0.0007247599,
0.0414635725,
-0.011160275,
-0.0239686556,
-0.0274454821,
-0.0108534228,
-0.0540907048,
0.0251786206,
0.0082401466,
-0.0163562186,
0.0278850701,
0.0218789317,
0.0137944818,
-0.0513100401,
0.0565214418,
0.0004245758,
-0.0271838717,
0.0137819368,
0.0327395648,
0.048237849,
0.0922628492,
-0.0282245297,
0.0386722833,
0.0035107159,
0.0096556544,
0.0310386773,
0.0331132822,
0.0108451918,
0.0239350181,
0.0243537258,
0.033265464,
-0.0378714763,
-0.0276504122,
0.0353535376,
-0.1111615673,
-0.053617809,
0.0493309796,
0.0221607517,
0.0058801887,
-0.0310818311,
0.0093599688,
-0.0409910716,
0.0235942211,
-0.010904884,
0.019299861,
-0.0265935268,
0.005676399,
-0.0339294374,
-0.0788773298,
0.0034261269,
-0.0012989213,
-0.0320598297,
0.0641390085,
0.0994077176,
0.0089885378,
0.0717960075,
-0.0438889265,
0.0033048517,
-0.0353695974,
0.0236763563,
0.0508964136,
-0.0156554244,
-0.0179554578,
0.0200212449,
0.0045101908,
0.0212476365,
0.0350248218,
0.0201311503,
0.0406952836,
0.0146145662,
0.0008453954,
0.0935909525,
0.0422925614,
0.0061382758,
-0.0574437156,
-0.0044753095,
0.0345112197,
0.0046906727,
0.0221351814,
-0.0107602803,
0.0044903113,
-0.0406930223,
-0.0517070629,
-0.0357796177,
-0.0301837921,
-0.0030676315,
0.0189312845,
-0.0059186453,
-0.0138044041,
0.0098916944,
0.0775633827,
-0.0332932323,
-0.0441583022,
-0.0004558229,
-0.0233651735,
-0.0039368868,
0.0113500934,
0.033585418,
-0.0661476627,
-0.0354569331,
-0.019237211,
0.0105205337,
0.0379915982,
0.0063884878,
0.0902944654,
0.0002989608,
-0.0684581995,
0.0019286864,
-0.0383360237,
0.0353322625,
-0.019043345,
0.038890224,
0.011755052,
0.0497072786,
-0.0320406482,
0.0601335764,
0.0454969853,
-0.0599727482,
0.0136531834,
-0.0018868434,
-0.0087902844,
0.0164001063,
-0.0149921002,
-0.0330935717,
-0.0193158053,
0.0340399593,
0.0013821592,
-0.0449917354,
-0.015976401,
0.0329084583,
2.581e-7,
0.0460967049,
0.0108599225,
-0.0128053948,
-0.0065069268,
0.0049706697,
0.0503659211,
-0.0435639732,
0.0069000949,
0.0179385133,
-0.015417682,
-0.0170955155,
0.0256397221,
0.0361008793,
0.0233035274,
-0.098137863,
0.0071569784,
-0.0048193168,
0.0424772538,
-0.0127731347,
0.0079149399,
0.059706077,
0.0653797388,
0.0052858107,
-0.0002528764,
-0.0036259028,
-0.0664570257,
0.0662126765,
-0.0421534888,
-0.0047759754,
0.0335193723,
0.00450296,
-0.0075950958,
-0.0205597207,
0.0554688387,
-0.0071694711,
0.0320167132,
0.0168414805,
0.029775003,
0.0343027972,
-0.0066779689,
-0.0165669825,
-0.0222912952,
-0.0062909927,
-0.0613663271,
0.0933903158,
-0.1195563972,
-0.0074207364,
-0.0568309575,
0.0006617685,
0.0087918648,
0.0408511348,
-0.0064749438,
-0.0136724161,
0.0419046804,
0.0386360101,
0.008096925,
-0.0624418966,
-0.0520808175,
-0.0029043683,
0.0558922254,
-0.0042701578,
-0.0125494665,
0.0051486902,
-0.0306822658,
0.008116072,
-0.0731280372,
0.0374522507,
1.873192952e-34,
0.0230084136,
-0.0322612375,
0.0274081957,
-0.0251793955,
0.0187317804,
-0.0186066367,
-0.0470455661,
0.0082935775,
0.0139338998,
-0.0107784532,
0.0035242091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07870v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07870v3 | Large Language Models as Superpositions of Cultural Perspectives | 2023-07-15T19:04:33 | 2023-11-07T16:28:33 | Grgur Kovač, Masataka Sawayama, Rémy Portelas, Cédric Colas, Peter Ford Dominey, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T07, I.2.7 | Large Language Models (LLMs) are often misleadingly recognized as having a
personality or a set of values. We argue that an LLM can be seen as a
superposition of perspectives with different values and personality traits.
LLMs exhibit context-dependent values and personality traits that change based
on the induced perspective (as opposed to humans, who tend to have more
coherent values and personality traits across contexts). We introduce the
concept of perspective controllability, which refers to a model's affordance to
adopt various perspectives with differing values and personality traits. In our
experiments, we use questionnaires from psychology (PVQ, VSM, IPIP) to study
how exhibited values and personality traits change based on different
perspectives. Through qualitative experiments, we show that LLMs express
different values when those are (implicitly or explicitly) implied in the
prompt, and that LLMs express different values even when those are not
obviously implied (demonstrating their context-dependent nature). We then
conduct quantitative experiments to study the controllability of different
models (GPT-4, GPT-3.5, OpenAssistant, StableVicuna, StableLM), the
effectiveness of various methods for inducing perspectives, and the smoothness
of the models' drivability. We conclude by examining the broader implications
of our work and outline a variety of associated scientific questions. The
project website is available at
https://sites.google.com/view/llm-superpositions . | [
0.0196374897,
0.0671917722,
-0.0719401836,
0.0122408513,
-0.0454166941,
0.0028251412,
0.0121001704,
-0.0287617687,
-0.0133635644,
0.0126304114,
-0.047548227,
-0.0668872446,
-0.0017386909,
0.0316192061,
0.0351135209,
-0.069165051,
0.045046106,
-0.0315728262,
0.03183797,
-0.0313562751,
0.0015310567,
0.0051787258,
0.0252772644,
0.0178195816,
0.0235445146,
0.0036586116,
-0.0037101021,
-0.039338842,
0.0424475484,
-0.0074811936,
0.0067390017,
0.0228274595,
0.0188810341,
-0.0099139493,
0.000002267,
-0.0422975309,
0.0050382558,
-0.0407222994,
0.0356501639,
0.0454568863,
0.0618967488,
0.0108428663,
-0.0088559883,
-0.0061755059,
-0.0441926494,
-0.0258746631,
0.0036971911,
0.0404409133,
0.0081318691,
0.0177721698,
-0.0046899985,
-0.0481489226,
-0.0178929921,
-0.0259665269,
-0.000526345,
-0.0139442943,
0.0365413986,
0.0186599959,
-0.0415286832,
0.0399266332,
-0.0508503579,
-0.0109775066,
0.0056619761,
-0.0019492677,
-0.0320844352,
-0.0226087123,
0.0350612476,
-0.0592048503,
0.0067127654,
0.0449179485,
0.0395118482,
-0.0220959373,
-0.0092647253,
-0.0440379046,
0.0265062805,
0.0225365609,
-0.0170273688,
0.0452817641,
0.0147536742,
0.0128563447,
0.0617788285,
0.0114611806,
-0.0056717307,
0.0085230405,
-0.0335526541,
0.0877502412,
0.0111981099,
-0.0263882745,
-0.0048640184,
-0.002074962,
-0.0242022146,
-0.0667430907,
-0.0248314291,
0.0199367926,
-0.0121586332,
0.0497464798,
-0.0058536921,
0.0261833481,
0.0025941506,
-0.0413908251,
0.0211527869,
0.0538459606,
-0.0287403334,
0.0041907728,
0.0325146131,
0.0553510524,
-0.0418133549,
-0.0080674253,
-0.0294533335,
0.0086260755,
-0.0402703546,
-0.029801853,
0.02377069,
-0.0143977273,
0.0086337421,
0.0178996548,
-0.0469810031,
0.0252051391,
-0.0385767445,
-0.018023666,
-0.0769882128,
-0.0435084589,
0.0105988532,
0.0263925921,
-0.0370415151,
0.079898797,
-0.0589190461,
-0.0036481798,
-0.0245397557,
-0.0622577891,
0.0528137609,
-0.0188449174,
-0.0120706344,
-0.0160992462,
-0.0073247859,
-0.0060785259,
0.0086706923,
-0.0087244846,
-0.0053064534,
-0.0201701708,
-0.0270067882,
-0.056488499,
0.0182151776,
-0.0377826355,
-0.0030359384,
0.0320724696,
0.0001463252,
-0.0997254103,
0.0012680922,
0.0111852782,
-0.0265003797,
0.0349305682,
0.0441334732,
0.0298134163,
0.0193980075,
0.016901426,
-0.0036519747,
0.0641851798,
0.0082882252,
-0.0297230054,
0.0111239674,
-0.0385683104,
0.0066331839,
0.0351128764,
-0.0085184164,
0.0235266406,
-0.0531149618,
-0.0116854059,
0.0579946116,
0.0067887399,
0.0312215984,
0.0689499229,
-0.0082202787,
0.0126820486,
0.0993641317,
0.0348503515,
-0.0174384601,
0.0281660017,
0.022515377,
0.0084683197,
0.0139132384,
0.0449266955,
-0.033084631,
0.0114471754,
0.0331255347,
-0.0025417819,
-0.039931193,
0.0298461542,
-0.0228733011,
-0.0304864272,
-0.022464294,
0.0191722475,
0.0340715498,
0.0171810575,
0.0053373245,
-0.0213090405,
0.0207707584,
-0.0159881227,
0.0394144207,
-0.0583486333,
-0.0385245271,
-0.0448270291,
0.0742562413,
0.0352268554,
-0.0278146379,
0.0003054508,
-0.0004230581,
-0.0083958264,
-0.0280483179,
0.0597947873,
0.1082885787,
-0.0048604179,
-0.0254240893,
-0.0041912873,
0.0225975122,
-0.0138396667,
-0.0118056973,
0.0252199806,
-0.0589995347,
0.0277516339,
-0.0200429913,
0.0289059039,
0.0001803235,
-0.0148974722,
-0.0805279762,
-0.0031890969,
-0.0603908375,
0.0046834513,
0.0423938446,
0.0146052465,
0.0003867656,
0.0129095651,
-0.0137551455,
-0.0084081367,
0.0095302919,
0.0692107156,
-0.0713110343,
0.0367083885,
0.0165298097,
-0.0194506831,
0.0135270972,
-0.0029859918,
0.0427808017,
-0.0063955337,
0.0297743473,
-0.006957117,
0.0395227596,
-0.0092176022,
0.0193559099,
-0.0707209334,
0.0398655534,
-0.0196798723,
0.0388843752,
-0.0013308321,
0.003611557,
0.011379471,
0.0144393258,
0.0187301375,
-0.0275273584,
-0.0239944495,
0.0253087617,
0.0310465544,
-0.0054786298,
0.0432771444,
-0.029421119,
-0.0474194065,
-0.026152188,
-0.0711472332,
-0.0382406525,
0.0024146861,
-0.0172606334,
0.0233113673,
-0.0143652456,
-0.0309510641,
0.0457991622,
-0.0782113373,
0.0057384791,
0.0499157757,
0.0636032149,
0.0073181628,
-0.0122751622,
-0.0251752865,
-0.0234037265,
-0.0112943631,
-0.0199166518,
0.0117558381,
-0.0196828395,
0.0028379408,
-0.0494056419,
-0.0096737416,
-0.0809578225,
-0.0080999127,
-0.0360158645,
-0.0280153006,
0.0283061694,
0.0153687233,
0.0575825274,
0.0545916036,
0.0158138145,
0.0394057147,
0.0582560971,
0.0085788257,
-0.0461602695,
-0.0331708379,
-0.00132563,
-0.0037394785,
-0.0190418847,
-0.0637773871,
-0.0332813077,
0.0751767009,
0.0226215515,
-0.0050796247,
-0.0504938662,
0.0956106111,
-0.0459498316,
-0.0543001108,
0.038836576,
-0.025788635,
-0.0326817073,
0.0779568404,
0.0014233104,
-0.0376997478,
0.0509849004,
0.0223601144,
-0.0020235989,
-0.0007207043,
0.0178676844,
-0.0342835635,
0.0585634373,
0.0022896542,
-0.0012254864,
0.0807579607,
0.0039655943,
-0.0461696498,
-0.0229702722,
0.0036342822,
-0.0379130021,
0.0538221113,
-0.0314804204,
-0.0505682901,
0.0038642825,
-0.0410290584,
-0.0256213304,
-0.005135464,
-0.0372973904,
0.0351919681,
0.0488703661,
0.0121421181,
0.0442758985,
-0.0226450209,
0.0694686547,
-0.0102047436,
-0.0376414321,
0.0160861611,
-0.0046823528,
-0.0601198152,
0.0479103178,
0.0267451834,
0.0590996258,
-0.0562595986,
0.0286955144,
0.0003158943,
0.0111138038,
0.0163136963,
0.0137584256,
0.0421271026,
0.0424998552,
0.0184053499,
-0.0506373607,
0.0073881708,
0.0700423494,
-0.0107939588,
-0.0148433195,
0.0818333179,
0.0096892174,
-0.0062834038,
0.0380780585,
-0.0480726659,
0.0130436094,
0.0423506759,
0.0248173364,
-0.0629449636,
0.0475788191,
-0.0042005959,
-0.0017951205,
-0.0720365942,
-0.0281878952,
-0.0257304609,
-0.1047496647,
0.0100430958,
0.018020032,
-0.0268836096,
0.0063431649,
0.0313767269,
0.0286845863,
0.0159939304,
0.0315922014,
0.0177131798,
-0.0001600214,
-0.0098935254,
-0.0101695079,
-0.0009147686,
-0.0153537644,
0.0272342693,
-0.006403402,
0.0331418179,
0.0138700474,
0.0203219466,
-0.0123597197,
-0.0831053704,
0.0045036301,
-0.035154555,
0.0033565089,
0.0164874587,
-0.0381938107,
-0.0003188956,
-0.0124708274,
-0.0433390141,
0.0285736546,
0.025085967,
-0.0147900358,
-0.0073041366,
0.05896971,
-0.0033000605,
-0.0727694258,
-0.0126979994,
-0.0022919201,
-0.0054260846,
0.0505765863,
0.0340727121,
-0.1053432077,
0.0148931453,
-0.0230487324,
-0.0422987789,
0.0483122766,
-0.1072963551,
-0.0003412603,
0.0306723621,
-0.0038932478,
-0.0556803308,
-0.0505892597,
-0.0260963868,
-0.0036357834,
0.0320512801,
-0.0412595905,
0.0338591337,
-0.0328312963,
0.0074497061,
-0.0093269898,
-0.0145981302,
0.0295964368,
-0.0195263233,
-0.0117570832,
0.0467151143,
-0.100552544,
0.0102076316,
-0.031707786,
-0.0031807895,
-0.0829258412,
0.0700992942,
0.0111976089,
0.0280369017,
0.0074153682,
0.0329447016,
-0.0480694436,
0.016696373,
-0.0399051458,
0.0387693495,
0.0895638838,
-0.0139862597,
0.0658283681,
0.0062562888,
0.0319731273,
-0.0125854369,
0.0459478535,
0.0307284761,
-0.0203692541,
-0.0057721608,
-0.0618151128,
0.0345580019,
0.0090122605,
-0.0002397965,
-0.0049865334,
-0.0211743135,
-0.0270423684,
-0.0349579677,
-0.0466277078,
-0.0418067984,
-0.0109013487,
-0.029136559,
0.0433128439,
0.0320564136,
-0.0085500563,
-0.0225456432,
-0.0129694939,
0.0251340941,
-0.0507315509,
0.018808078,
-0.0070611793,
0.0280582495,
-0.0062275375,
0.0438467786,
-0.0254062973,
0.023708839,
-0.0481036454,
0.0443431437,
0.0088096634,
0.1199670658,
0.03224843,
-0.013543833,
-0.0014214949,
0.0071763075,
-0.0617589615,
-0.0503883511,
0.0557624176,
0.0148437377,
0.0397322178,
-0.0307264999,
0.0546330698,
-0.0549619906,
0.0105826128,
-0.032077264,
0.0124766137,
0.0429199934,
-0.057384856,
0.0219257604,
0.0057769124,
0.0029466064,
-0.0005815179,
0.0187990982,
0.0040074657,
0.0057068164,
-0.0016101066,
-0.0081859296,
-0.0137277944,
0.0449156351,
0.0076413197,
0.0066688983,
-0.0331854783,
0.0085036373,
-0.0977713317,
-0.0581559576,
0.0028407616,
0.0001441584,
0.0172685143,
-0.0822420344,
-0.0036438487,
0.0567653365,
-0.0142362211,
-0.0366435908,
-0.0434248857,
0.0292743817,
-0.0363314264,
0.0440238416,
0.0048170565,
-6.910315457e-33,
-0.0307695139,
0.0044192169,
-0.0085599441,
0.0165471639,
-0.0442586802,
-0.0448930636,
-0.0315408409,
0.05008002,
-0.0429501645,
0.0098536341,
-0.0219056718,
-0.010891282,
0.0061785392,
-0.0100955451,
0.0353264809,
0.0107299061,
0.0236186814,
-0.0044603446,
-0.0342318527,
-0.0246170387,
0.0392846391,
-0.0246559121,
0.0705330595,
-0.0984123722,
0.0484489873,
-0.0186793581,
0.0200106129,
-0.0011439411,
-0.0418790989,
0.0467497855,
-0.0104164192,
0.0312599242,
0.0420514904,
-0.0558641329,
-0.0262224656,
0.057285402,
0.0146279847,
-0.0463462025,
0.0617789142,
0.0076689469,
0.0175647866,
-0.061559584,
0.0087599754,
-0.0425279886,
-0.046531979,
0.0052889851,
0.0090758698,
-0.034986455,
0.03402403,
0.0307358578,
-0.0695879534,
-0.0236259736,
0.0001507577,
0.015503794,
-0.0051622111,
0.0137326624,
-0.030780619,
-0.0137930717,
-0.0162227377,
0.0335680954,
0.0126452865,
-0.001203093,
0.0450265519,
0.0404536352,
0.0400265753,
0.035673134,
0.050740771,
0.0709981248,
-0.0284050312,
-0.0588693917,
0.0463880859,
0.0126474043,
0.0243018791,
0.0476980135,
-0.0157267526,
-0.0536879413,
0.0151112359,
-0.0680767521,
0.083071813,
-0.0293612871,
0.0283649173,
0.0380315855,
-0.0184278935,
-0.0425907522,
-0.0485261455,
-0.0497941226,
-0.0139822494,
-0.0306218024,
0.0177058019,
-0.0197070558,
-0.0019041398,
-0.0034166812,
0.0620068535,
-0.0313999988,
-0.0446871929,
0.0050691003,
-0.0627259091,
0.0477481596,
0.0143120866,
0.005125788,
-0.0428733416,
0.0152006606,
-0.0394337401,
0.0208895635,
0.0067814677,
0.0558584444,
-0.0217652023,
0.0119731519,
-0.026546225,
-0.0191918556,
-0.0224072319,
-0.0212584883,
-0.0141047081,
-0.0114723854,
0.0574691333,
0.0255100727,
-0.0021415923,
0.0025868178,
0.059399005,
-0.0003483417,
-0.0759985372,
-0.0250191223,
-0.0177260172,
0.0334443934,
-0.0311358813,
-0.0179232899,
-0.0444096774,
0.05169563,
0.0583991632,
-0.0172355156,
-0.0219767168,
0.0052061011,
3.061e-7,
-0.0075439969,
0.0525544547,
-0.024774069,
0.0580561869,
0.064370282,
0.0433239117,
-0.0159099959,
0.0111783929,
0.0466396473,
-0.0505049452,
-0.0152704576,
-0.0032521947,
0.0437172912,
0.0173445158,
-0.0377963558,
-0.0005871085,
0.0013573273,
0.0271980558,
-0.0235141441,
0.0317124985,
0.0442377888,
0.0420085788,
0.0081123989,
0.0178263523,
-0.0179052167,
0.056802053,
0.0597518645,
-0.0283686314,
0.0105603086,
-0.004239236,
-0.0328892395,
-0.0107383234,
0.0131293889,
0.0125427786,
0.0431519561,
0.0362798832,
-0.0042508906,
0.068189308,
0.0264877323,
0.0062000505,
0.0037174043,
0.0261667948,
-0.0365196168,
-0.0932406187,
0.0608321689,
-0.0423546247,
-0.0372733884,
-0.0115886768,
-0.0140825231,
-0.0212470517,
0.0378514044,
0.0077875722,
-0.0258496888,
0.0233255494,
0.0000634883,
-0.0023083137,
-0.0100174574,
-0.0259908959,
-0.0177791063,
-0.0280899163,
-0.0228989366,
-0.0551408902,
-0.0216712672,
0.0075465078,
-0.0212669596,
-0.0326085091,
-0.0028237046,
2.692309558e-34,
0.0145225907,
0.0145442113,
0.0400686674,
-0.045704104,
0.0319849364,
0.0020476533,
-0.0041999603,
0.0531020835,
0.0574105568,
-0.0443745442,
-0.0261138454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07864v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07864v2 | CIDER: Context sensitive sentiment analysis for short-form text | 2023-07-15T18:25:56 | 2023-10-12T16:06:19 | James C. Young, Rudy Arthur, Hywel T. P. Williams | cs.CL | cs.CL | Researchers commonly perform sentiment analysis on large collections of short
texts like tweets, Reddit posts or newspaper headlines that are all focused on
a specific topic, theme or event. Usually, general purpose sentiment analysis
methods are used which perform well on average but miss the variation in
meaning that happens across different contexts, for example, the word "active"
has a very different intention and valence in the phrase "active lifestyle"
versus "active volcano". This work presents a new approach, CIDER (Context
Informed Dictionary and sEntiment Reasoner), which performs context sensitive
sentiment analysis, where the valence of sentiment laden terms is inferred from
the whole corpus before being used to score the individual texts. In this paper
we detail the CIDER algorithm and demonstrate that it outperforms
state-of-the-art generalist sentiment analysis on a large collection of tweets
about the weather. We have made our implementation of CIDER available as a
python package: https://pypi.org/project/ciderpolarity/. | [
0.0212066155,
0.0678181797,
0.0122093009,
0.0254225694,
-0.0504103266,
0.0336759947,
-0.0230034217,
-0.0046494631,
0.0299688485,
-0.030865835,
0.0197311845,
-0.0218782909,
0.0004700301,
0.0273782909,
-0.0571479946,
-0.0483046472,
0.0244385041,
0.0365452617,
0.0598951131,
0.0019533229,
0.0437812507,
0.0242825449,
0.0006046362,
-0.0029871804,
-0.0017921309,
-0.0033028326,
-0.0166479535,
0.0027294301,
0.0181831233,
-0.0545562617,
0.054160893,
0.0023327742,
-0.0068313512,
0.0033110438,
0.0000019737,
-0.0157232862,
-0.0330678113,
-0.020870002,
0.0489714071,
-0.036268793,
0.1278181374,
-0.0218184255,
0.024528211,
0.0195308626,
-0.0539470986,
0.0230400842,
0.0471314937,
0.0306373481,
0.0416534655,
0.0718057826,
-0.0301235188,
-0.0296027027,
-0.0565186031,
0.0240915511,
0.0396201536,
-0.0278450698,
0.0061099138,
-0.0183069687,
-0.0216727834,
-0.0231182501,
0.0015489549,
-0.0034615265,
-0.0282464512,
-0.0025987367,
-0.0127758104,
0.0044911122,
-0.0050775525,
-0.0249257404,
0.0016876362,
0.0030132378,
0.0561291985,
-0.0434004627,
-0.0035757027,
0.001247791,
-0.0086472854,
-0.006725851,
-0.0240331404,
0.0077538649,
-0.0206405222,
0.0447653085,
0.0429078937,
0.0670281798,
0.0017894006,
0.0633545145,
-0.0332524516,
0.0540410727,
-0.0203048624,
-0.0410249904,
-0.0385850854,
0.0323700234,
-0.01768074,
-0.0193807371,
-0.0090009691,
0.0157477129,
-0.0039442061,
0.0052352743,
-0.0016590244,
-0.0431141183,
0.0063362974,
-0.0827046931,
-0.0668023527,
0.000689894,
0.0004867449,
0.0318570323,
0.02965918,
-0.0324570499,
0.0446905717,
-0.0144878067,
-0.0077934987,
-0.0526658222,
-0.0503605418,
0.0267198943,
0.0253074244,
0.0040943706,
-0.0237213876,
0.0195372533,
-0.0610217638,
0.0188289974,
-0.0434477478,
-0.0155225229,
0.0019120803,
0.0423174351,
0.0177171249,
0.0047305152,
-0.0054694456,
0.0318720601,
-0.0505822338,
0.0477840938,
-0.0333922803,
0.00561111,
0.0136472657,
0.0245591886,
0.0809315741,
-0.0086620757,
0.0014656194,
-0.0062079951,
0.065829739,
-0.0416017435,
-0.0322521031,
-0.0219419468,
-0.040460214,
-0.0402134918,
-0.0400448442,
-0.0577881671,
-0.0133577511,
0.0422185995,
0.0162625443,
-0.0262942947,
0.0102123823,
-0.0032198455,
-0.0224281736,
0.0679679066,
-0.0438387692,
-0.0207763687,
-0.0241271015,
0.0165645536,
0.0328874215,
0.0478075184,
0.0184399635,
0.0673343912,
0.0529933535,
0.0104006035,
-0.0037908638,
-0.0729432106,
-0.0013057358,
0.0040750657,
-0.044050049,
0.0046079559,
-0.0535622127,
-0.0121527901,
-0.0478577018,
0.0324676633,
0.0280347019,
0.0343821198,
0.0290348865,
0.0079313312,
0.010792831,
-0.0160815287,
-0.0083446978,
0.0187249202,
-0.0175306406,
-0.0087058591,
-0.026197806,
0.0343403481,
-0.041344922,
-0.0218873154,
0.0307689048,
0.0132852541,
-0.0104431231,
-0.0656180009,
-0.024544036,
-0.0269411374,
0.0452665947,
-0.0279904064,
0.0405621566,
-0.0175919626,
-0.0337460414,
-0.0312464722,
0.0476709828,
-0.0968690291,
0.0004587827,
-0.0358633846,
0.0517749414,
0.0769893304,
-0.0161022525,
-0.0151071148,
-0.0187409651,
-0.0132295787,
0.0262416657,
-0.0098126987,
0.001698791,
0.0253426526,
0.0119510209,
-0.0537191667,
-0.0183925666,
-0.0197760295,
0.0343988575,
-0.0323498324,
0.006525855,
0.0655892119,
0.0053616748,
-0.0090178549,
-0.0136288116,
-0.0075495271,
0.0400731489,
-0.0332460143,
0.0296587646,
0.0182249621,
0.0218274575,
0.04778805,
-0.0183178242,
0.0003549988,
0.0234244969,
-0.0001405306,
-0.048689194,
0.0574811846,
-0.0192483962,
-0.0399042815,
0.0136338733,
-0.0154404659,
-0.0020859023,
0.0035077489,
-0.0344406143,
-0.020289667,
0.0233221781,
-0.0115791792,
0.0567619577,
-0.0225730706,
-0.0321169235,
-0.030381538,
0.0161509179,
0.0039092046,
0.0604895428,
0.0150159709,
-0.0271180235,
-0.0200705249,
-0.0089782393,
0.0038162542,
0.0365124084,
-0.0255568773,
-0.0154563561,
0.0130816652,
-0.0028016646,
0.0486971959,
-0.0112137999,
-0.0342772268,
-0.0331841223,
-0.0971867815,
-0.0150873791,
-0.033136446,
-0.0069348323,
0.025319485,
0.055369392,
0.0199469067,
0.0386463888,
-0.0169429444,
0.017951319,
-0.0140456632,
0.0332196914,
0.0302665513,
-0.0199745651,
0.0475918502,
-0.0365694687,
0.0283610988,
-0.0355668738,
0.0297825597,
0.0561677665,
-0.0128230369,
0.0193678159,
0.044807408,
-0.0277888123,
-0.0259730201,
0.0042376253,
-0.0403676555,
-0.0068970616,
-0.0441921502,
0.0081303464,
0.011673782,
0.0558920652,
0.0093859835,
0.0154711632,
-0.01696009,
-0.0452133268,
0.005077438,
-0.0672616959,
0.0147842765,
-0.0064812684,
-0.0273100194,
-0.0034967095,
0.0210590288,
-0.009241974,
0.0131911403,
-0.0596635714,
0.030379951,
-0.0264135115,
0.0394910648,
-0.0223095175,
0.0080319708,
0.0017832539,
0.0252537187,
0.0218690503,
-0.0427464917,
0.0570647605,
0.0251265727,
0.0263629537,
-0.0725163147,
-0.0469940789,
-0.0554911457,
0.0532914251,
-0.034699019,
0.0096529406,
0.00998036,
0.0535807349,
0.0370221585,
-0.0532823652,
-0.0105940644,
-0.0235588234,
0.0483506434,
-0.0172251724,
-0.004268466,
0.0239977334,
-0.0174557175,
0.0048198975,
-0.0296414513,
-0.0546619557,
-0.0198003966,
0.0376267619,
-0.0365440957,
0.0385708846,
0.0041592414,
0.0011400983,
-0.0422545522,
0.0017791258,
-0.0367393345,
0.0502183437,
-0.0009669165,
0.0189381596,
-0.0062638363,
0.0324327275,
0.0239066277,
-0.0052129854,
0.0324835368,
-0.010788233,
-0.0131234899,
-0.0267114062,
-0.0199167412,
-0.0011001478,
0.0038459471,
0.0396948978,
-0.0519253463,
0.0613050275,
-0.039222315,
0.0082132751,
0.1154894903,
0.0316696055,
-0.0714616179,
-0.0019731387,
-0.0275386684,
0.0025938414,
0.0246767215,
-0.0119166188,
-0.0607977733,
-0.0466554388,
-0.039279636,
0.047059983,
-0.0286377314,
-0.0149146896,
-0.0203204583,
-0.0657416284,
0.006951421,
-0.0197988898,
0.0121324193,
-0.003283255,
-0.0865044892,
0.0022922882,
-0.0557774268,
-0.0482235812,
-0.0549380668,
0.0077942093,
0.017623527,
-0.0038445746,
-0.0590121523,
-0.041669745,
0.0261698142,
-0.0192125924,
0.0140537117,
0.0268571079,
0.0825681984,
-0.0203127228,
-0.0164635573,
-0.0169449542,
-0.0356358103,
0.0036164746,
-0.0296932478,
0.0590081103,
-0.00148729,
-0.0187747125,
-0.0327147022,
0.0071853353,
-0.0593397468,
-0.0255232845,
0.0044356785,
0.0286467988,
-0.025506461,
-0.0154533228,
-0.0362679325,
0.0252451878,
0.06821163,
0.0536106266,
0.0152275413,
-0.0246100351,
-0.0313306786,
-0.0284871012,
-0.0134541569,
-0.0592369288,
-0.0326199085,
-0.0530758388,
0.0176726244,
-0.0651956871,
-0.0596617572,
-0.0115598831,
0.0362512469,
0.020474093,
-0.0517976508,
-0.0100120921,
-0.0076885554,
-0.0211599972,
-0.0690541565,
0.0106411017,
0.051368352,
0.0334577821,
0.0093878219,
-0.017089203,
0.0831277817,
-0.0030257886,
0.0002557432,
-0.0273110736,
-0.0374251232,
-0.0190365389,
0.0391345359,
0.0271782912,
0.0118283825,
0.0076022111,
-0.0162286833,
0.0097617172,
0.0243645143,
0.1200674251,
-0.01861329,
-0.0004915535,
0.0537949204,
0.0576708466,
0.0313502923,
0.0296271238,
-0.033610478,
0.0135217179,
-0.0086875483,
-0.0138544971,
-0.0271519702,
-0.0059008352,
0.003532978,
-0.0181657895,
0.0538183488,
0.0053078732,
-0.0637727976,
-0.0070265294,
-0.0201840904,
0.0067546852,
-0.0305936057,
-0.0081332494,
0.002870287,
-0.0272129681,
0.0143175796,
-0.0776526704,
0.0460332818,
-0.0486937128,
0.004213742,
-0.0379175805,
0.0983669013,
0.0550344028,
0.0198717229,
0.0086046401,
0.0045351842,
-0.0020044011,
-0.0140587939,
-0.0097576585,
-0.0051173898,
-0.0278439,
-0.0041983165,
-0.012061337,
-0.0033156574,
-0.0175686944,
0.0180718042,
-0.0571947508,
0.0138158044,
0.001841791,
0.000856401,
-0.0013382521,
-0.0334363542,
0.0488912463,
-0.026506722,
0.0207175519,
0.0025748448,
0.0306811314,
0.0005044721,
-0.0116453785,
-0.0126777552,
-0.0047349264,
-0.0373869129,
-0.0035945673,
0.0259933081,
-0.0955799967,
0.062484391,
0.061723154,
-0.0152810793,
-0.0120578324,
-0.002695661,
0.0093640629,
0.0409888476,
0.0250134878,
0.0449551903,
-0.0696152747,
-0.0225843918,
0.0965152904,
-0.066222243,
0.0307134297,
-0.0173581503,
-0.0000931445,
0.0348992944,
-0.0066681136,
0.0478166416,
-0.0685246512,
0.0103309778,
-0.0525678769,
-0.0231716633,
-0.0377886631,
-6.642788371e-33,
0.0159176532,
-0.0619927309,
-0.0446448959,
0.0047376892,
0.0043779556,
0.0290986039,
-0.0220081229,
0.0098869018,
-0.0000198093,
0.060144797,
-0.0108072385,
0.0510847047,
0.0020276937,
0.0069441022,
0.0379219018,
-0.0040919506,
0.0086152544,
0.0245755091,
0.0094265006,
0.0409131199,
0.0711677819,
0.0146581251,
0.0517633781,
-0.1423509568,
0.0641825423,
0.0218899418,
-0.0446186364,
-0.0000016613,
0.0385234021,
0.0240024608,
0.0022590421,
0.0667130202,
0.0288255829,
0.0104275709,
0.0168249551,
0.0205044281,
0.0023628215,
-0.0368411876,
-0.0107944291,
-0.0396880843,
-0.0136859911,
-0.0163664985,
0.009920503,
0.0360111967,
-0.0442674831,
0.0210901182,
0.034307301,
-0.0095884278,
0.0240154807,
-0.0713432431,
-0.0242216177,
0.0572662167,
-0.0094337203,
-0.0096259117,
0.0227548722,
0.0081299255,
0.0265045296,
0.0980960503,
-0.0416290127,
0.0408428237,
-0.0501069762,
0.0050738412,
-0.0145277102,
-0.030084243,
-0.0003042185,
0.0700254217,
0.0194289908,
0.0225767996,
-0.0381782539,
0.0418765731,
-0.0317354836,
0.0300767384,
0.0538189299,
0.1248597875,
0.0445658155,
-0.0537037775,
-0.0470663346,
0.0340182893,
0.0284322537,
0.0030129345,
0.0318189561,
-0.0073649529,
-0.0220721662,
-0.0022541143,
0.0280262697,
-0.0008832818,
-0.0414489284,
0.0132262697,
-0.0319166556,
-0.0142480638,
-0.0326429345,
-0.0022223559,
-0.0341936126,
-0.0518871285,
-0.0305505283,
0.0756132603,
-0.0267964192,
0.0177247915,
0.0211870372,
0.0143345762,
0.0029622049,
-0.0046507819,
-0.0273541827,
0.0704274029,
0.0302601401,
0.0026825331,
0.037443202,
0.0433136933,
-0.0442101434,
-0.0196568593,
-0.0293387286,
-0.0079266997,
-0.0508667678,
0.0061771977,
-0.0214370918,
0.0515215546,
-0.0002975425,
0.0625543445,
0.030690467,
0.0623420142,
0.018841045,
-0.0684040189,
-0.0113399755,
0.0176123753,
-0.0170732141,
-0.0647822693,
0.0266930442,
-0.036305584,
-0.0215078294,
-0.0138990199,
-0.0098751867,
-0.0324783586,
2.87e-7,
0.0516051203,
0.0847951174,
-0.0133235827,
-0.0044867191,
-0.0065167411,
0.0674799383,
0.0019692676,
-0.0057212105,
-0.0437936746,
0.0174421724,
0.0002267663,
0.0039798757,
0.0084235147,
0.0552071929,
-0.0697667897,
0.0332455337,
-0.0333284661,
-0.0372703783,
-0.0136605017,
0.0538204685,
0.1133663505,
0.0631603375,
0.056846045,
0.0016765181,
0.007578169,
-0.0016562628,
0.0042895293,
-0.0468111299,
-0.0045082597,
0.0214924496,
-0.0199887659,
-0.0409845598,
0.0064798207,
-0.0664981902,
-0.014912108,
-0.0186784118,
-0.0313530415,
0.0427047722,
-0.0154564334,
-0.0423939601,
0.0077600102,
0.0012659525,
0.027176179,
-0.0087650726,
0.0442089811,
-0.0438492149,
-0.0453109816,
-0.1011425257,
-0.0096308049,
0.0277355947,
0.0357017145,
0.006031794,
-0.0188115295,
0.0060241739,
-0.0249148589,
-0.0218583457,
-0.0519843735,
-0.094551526,
0.0048084054,
0.0030048052,
0.0162758119,
-0.0103256963,
-0.0018411461,
0.051325161,
0.063700214,
0.0066279597,
0.0459385365,
2.187051321e-34,
0.0466046184,
-0.0061257393,
-0.0459575094,
-0.0185460821,
0.0264402777,
0.0091820173,
-0.0045946795,
-0.0229165126,
0.0551806092,
-0.0169467404,
0.018648725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07851v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07851v5 | AspectCSE: Sentence Embeddings for Aspect-based Semantic Textual Similarity Using Contrastive Learning and Structured Knowledge | 2023-07-15T17:01:56 | 2023-09-24T20:35:52 | Tim Schopf, Emanuel Gerber, Malte Ostendorff, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Generic sentence embeddings provide a coarse-grained approximation of
semantic textual similarity but ignore specific aspects that make texts
similar. Conversely, aspect-based sentence embeddings provide similarities
between texts based on certain predefined aspects. Thus, similarity predictions
of texts are more targeted to specific requirements and more easily
explainable. In this paper, we present AspectCSE, an approach for aspect-based
contrastive learning of sentence embeddings. Results indicate that AspectCSE
achieves an average improvement of 3.97% on information retrieval tasks across
multiple aspects compared to the previous best results. We also propose using
Wikidata knowledge graph properties to train models of multi-aspect sentence
embeddings in which multiple specific aspects are simultaneously considered
during similarity predictions. We demonstrate that multi-aspect embeddings
outperform single-aspect embeddings on aspect-specific information retrieval
tasks. Finally, we examine the aspect-based sentence embedding space and
demonstrate that embeddings of semantically similar aspect labels are often
close, even without explicit similarity training between different aspect
labels. | [
0.0293722991,
-0.0129363257,
0.0021137025,
0.0431603268,
-0.0371277444,
0.0185330808,
0.0327514112,
0.0020219728,
-0.0006346908,
-0.0277903937,
-0.0245837606,
0.0024991345,
-0.0276936945,
0.001909354,
0.0060742227,
-0.0351628102,
0.0217644684,
0.0379492454,
-0.030837629,
0.006284276,
0.0508644693,
0.0434431545,
0.0193806402,
0.0185554512,
0.0002323373,
-0.0196133349,
0.0256052632,
-0.0230245106,
0.039726954,
-0.0035801616,
0.0578217581,
-0.0174980816,
0.0525416732,
-0.0433922932,
0.0000018609,
-0.0125179142,
-0.0167184211,
-0.0219166372,
0.0398346223,
0.0100303246,
0.0333558805,
-0.0207684878,
0.0690542534,
-0.0149634397,
-0.0001190067,
-0.0312531963,
-0.0104378732,
0.0880969986,
0.0273232702,
0.0629745647,
-0.0306075513,
-0.0288102683,
0.0028376628,
0.0012287702,
-0.0114716412,
-0.0106776673,
-0.0161065347,
0.0134377899,
-0.0040612258,
0.1120516285,
0.015992213,
0.0096759386,
0.0381399877,
0.0286784321,
0.0261104554,
0.0461095273,
0.0466412418,
0.0749178529,
0.0139463153,
0.0304463096,
0.034420561,
-0.0470179878,
0.0053918008,
-0.0353319757,
-0.0158533417,
0.0305972006,
-0.0046898951,
-0.0105002197,
-0.0251254272,
0.0395579524,
0.0501558334,
0.0406185277,
0.005992231,
-0.003353399,
0.0120459376,
0.0538408235,
0.0169321205,
-0.0477543101,
-0.0138733629,
0.0274400339,
0.004342454,
-0.0131586576,
0.0045829709,
-0.0055746119,
-0.0272168778,
-0.0146730626,
-0.0490737483,
0.0154618071,
0.0195339564,
-0.0423361808,
-0.0112895044,
0.0263912529,
-0.0084995739,
0.0342911296,
-0.0013033116,
0.0134681407,
-0.0076083029,
-0.0105517358,
-0.0773399398,
-0.0047006886,
-0.1122953892,
0.0083393417,
-0.0026949518,
0.0551188327,
-0.0004203917,
-0.0259502176,
-0.0001239135,
0.0107744141,
0.0362859443,
0.0048824809,
0.0610904582,
-0.0034888268,
-0.0120838489,
-0.008526314,
-0.0135770524,
0.0116790999,
-0.0633748174,
0.0284146983,
-0.0317915492,
0.0758645386,
0.0096461037,
0.0027943323,
0.0185680017,
-0.0401376188,
-0.0199079216,
-0.0405039378,
0.0265532732,
-0.0351168774,
-0.0202516895,
-0.0298019424,
0.001373186,
-0.0136052463,
-0.0285500381,
-0.0550440177,
0.0096662734,
0.0154343899,
-0.0180883445,
-0.0251036957,
0.0087892059,
0.0549729951,
-0.0594451278,
0.0539596453,
0.0101700919,
-0.03779836,
-0.0386737511,
0.0332654007,
0.0862277672,
0.020948926,
-0.0436671972,
-0.0039736275,
0.0426045991,
0.0629377067,
-0.0640709326,
-0.0488770306,
-0.0170263052,
0.0363617055,
0.0519438237,
0.0195746236,
0.0002820984,
0.0222062785,
0.0102743208,
0.0385530964,
-0.0223913305,
-0.0387312658,
0.0345893092,
0.0100792693,
0.0383018516,
0.0443141237,
0.0632404014,
0.0506360084,
-0.0637563467,
0.0459032767,
-0.0303965341,
0.0252759606,
-0.0192229375,
0.0185321439,
0.04419199,
-0.0030184139,
-0.0538329817,
-0.0330424383,
0.0003088553,
-0.0118662436,
-0.0396555439,
-0.024163181,
0.0256885514,
-0.006219049,
-0.0537953712,
0.0304418057,
0.0707285628,
-0.0560856089,
-0.0397695266,
0.0554576404,
0.0191289615,
0.0746525973,
0.0224799924,
-0.0308754593,
-0.0057028034,
0.0136705646,
-0.0408120453,
0.0041567851,
0.0339782909,
-0.0301568452,
-0.0204336122,
-0.0486841947,
-0.035646759,
-0.0550784171,
0.0034837432,
-0.0256587397,
0.0185630172,
0.0425765067,
0.0233033169,
-0.0672498569,
0.0024867172,
0.0265524443,
-0.0324096046,
-0.019608926,
0.003250672,
0.0340264961,
-0.0194534715,
0.047072947,
0.0235109981,
0.016933145,
0.0111620193,
-0.0716916099,
-0.04472927,
-0.0173237864,
-0.0760273039,
-0.0709439293,
0.041718483,
-0.0106588667,
0.0176577549,
-0.0162064508,
-0.0257093832,
-0.0090195462,
-0.0213566516,
0.0082452102,
0.0308515653,
-0.0262371749,
-0.0038900834,
0.0378510542,
-0.0242072307,
-0.0182124283,
0.0806215852,
-0.0337576531,
0.0489472076,
-0.0328535661,
-0.0085415859,
0.0451737605,
0.0282094572,
-0.038767077,
-0.0658335537,
0.0359379277,
-0.0114138285,
0.030999409,
-0.0011699059,
-0.0268705711,
0.0117712636,
-0.0887655392,
0.0239563901,
0.0010304019,
0.0283036139,
0.0228746943,
0.0014273894,
0.0414907001,
0.0029792921,
-0.0488158651,
0.0081545794,
-0.0529815257,
0.0226908643,
0.0287133344,
0.021723859,
0.0083190342,
-0.0409541167,
-0.0224669632,
-0.0353487991,
0.0616594814,
-0.023403028,
-0.0091603603,
-0.0533997007,
0.09192238,
-0.0147468103,
-0.0163180772,
-0.0023824878,
0.0179820806,
-0.0209515505,
-0.0159059726,
0.0121103898,
0.0296400115,
-0.0034825059,
0.0268890392,
0.0252552871,
0.0129955318,
-0.029447766,
0.0166191328,
-0.0543955676,
0.0375199728,
-0.0419187061,
-0.0308583491,
0.0228348654,
0.0210148469,
0.0181833934,
-0.0219194833,
-0.0396955982,
0.0228750091,
-0.0032712081,
0.0461482815,
-0.0237959828,
-0.0164925884,
0.0260090511,
-0.020177871,
-0.0316366144,
0.0216252469,
0.0867615119,
-0.00143319,
0.0467058085,
-0.0387676358,
-0.0474539474,
-0.0288597867,
0.0900659487,
-0.0356670134,
0.0222488046,
0.0554503053,
0.0436903685,
-0.0314271078,
-0.010553753,
0.0263318066,
0.0095623881,
0.0361145549,
0.0200422928,
0.0065321722,
0.0244540591,
-0.0654535294,
0.0010964656,
-0.0427021347,
-0.0434421785,
0.0409865528,
-0.008930333,
0.0002260403,
-0.0016223302,
-0.025088504,
-0.0066253883,
-0.0144115137,
-0.0044296151,
-0.0238246918,
0.0030608247,
0.0682885796,
0.0725265518,
-0.0453659557,
-0.036118228,
-0.0172264688,
0.0269671474,
0.032947965,
-0.0092482306,
-0.0062076026,
-0.005032992,
-0.0240292251,
0.0119407019,
-0.0642774701,
-0.0522589013,
-0.0054846471,
0.0577299185,
-0.0244473349,
-0.0566588938,
0.0969690755,
0.0606857203,
-0.035930302,
-0.005867207,
0.0146091254,
0.0139098242,
0.0263181739,
0.0094792945,
-0.0653756857,
-0.0208501052,
-0.0233972128,
-0.0091752764,
0.0460353456,
0.0005819297,
0.0009155633,
-0.0711993128,
-0.0184267927,
-0.0161249917,
-0.0299098846,
-0.0763116255,
-0.0281699393,
0.0090849549,
-0.0100271096,
-0.0164026096,
0.0002720575,
-0.0026438287,
0.0022092671,
-0.0157290194,
-0.0001902904,
0.016750358,
0.0443787165,
-0.0458779559,
0.011245193,
-0.0027820882,
0.0377872065,
0.0366569944,
-0.0765873492,
-0.0077349297,
-0.0907283872,
-0.0106373206,
-0.0148605732,
0.0586736165,
-0.04665149,
0.015094093,
-0.0399803407,
0.0211031511,
-0.0316789709,
-0.0335713476,
0.0029089276,
0.0569354109,
0.0098072598,
-0.001777767,
-0.0389126688,
-0.0072227647,
0.0081520556,
0.0725342333,
0.0319144018,
-0.0135278078,
-0.012169023,
-0.0043583391,
0.0000103293,
-0.0379137471,
-0.0625147969,
-0.0222588573,
0.0064224806,
0.0283469874,
-0.0653482229,
-0.0511456951,
-0.0316916071,
0.0034346033,
-0.0337488428,
0.0065624253,
-0.0005857644,
-0.0498670638,
-0.0548489131,
-0.0153211923,
-0.0282104537,
0.02535473,
0.036355637,
0.0114849508,
0.0693669915,
-0.029909879,
-0.0484731942,
-0.0582002997,
-0.0731611475,
-0.0297133178,
-0.048982501,
0.0025386661,
-0.0177291632,
0.0445497595,
-0.0234496426,
0.0147683555,
0.0220442209,
0.0119111342,
-0.0197599418,
0.0006046504,
0.031309586,
0.0121327285,
0.0392026454,
0.0698154718,
-0.0527921692,
0.0198049098,
0.0134974821,
0.0278426073,
-0.0276232362,
-0.1056624278,
0.0297673307,
-0.0014997087,
0.0333028845,
0.0256546363,
-0.0148838637,
-0.0434778668,
0.0190554634,
0.0124028465,
-0.0252476279,
-0.000298542,
0.0147547191,
-0.0031099876,
-0.0027121215,
-0.0336332805,
0.0768906251,
0.0018109285,
0.0626543909,
-0.0491102785,
0.0047599529,
0.0112671293,
0.0105379848,
-0.0496770665,
-0.005374847,
-0.0359555483,
-0.052260153,
0.0097303158,
0.0186075047,
-0.0294888262,
0.0283127297,
0.0060196579,
0.0034399144,
-0.0341419354,
0.0352760591,
-0.0569379143,
0.0132370787,
-0.0437866785,
-0.0662269965,
-0.005869234,
-0.0799770653,
0.0270775948,
-0.0404903628,
-0.0149493525,
-0.0153289838,
0.0334293358,
-0.0117360204,
0.0128427316,
0.0334281698,
0.0227107182,
-0.0192378853,
0.0369446799,
0.0603017025,
-0.0649796426,
0.0541261956,
0.0218080822,
-0.0585266314,
-0.012199102,
-0.0167369004,
-0.0053264862,
0.08126726,
0.0017174487,
0.0102044363,
-0.0270647444,
-0.0250004046,
0.0156340133,
0.0132470429,
-0.0335362777,
0.0336967744,
0.0341721699,
0.0208308194,
0.0132424608,
0.0056353635,
-0.0241227299,
-0.0320970826,
0.0122668315,
-0.0432945527,
-0.013428783,
-6.138388521e-33,
-0.0242202375,
0.015245025,
0.004022032,
0.0039327811,
-0.0428234786,
0.0111117922,
-0.0180758405,
-0.0236062203,
-0.0346979238,
0.0472220108,
0.0306765847,
0.0078057735,
-0.0171126667,
0.0182162728,
-0.0045755659,
0.0063736327,
0.0216828417,
0.0343672708,
0.0126524912,
0.0276255365,
0.0570622347,
0.0265248269,
0.0627504587,
-0.0992407054,
0.0041010701,
-0.0150862904,
0.0108120702,
0.0210320689,
0.0346681066,
0.0728892162,
-0.0021137693,
0.055971358,
0.0340633988,
-0.0286155753,
0.0113477493,
0.0019890291,
-0.0743429437,
-0.0624461286,
0.0245586429,
-0.0757625774,
-0.0008453241,
-0.058743678,
-0.0158025082,
-0.0072582415,
0.0398083553,
-0.0685717687,
0.0602932572,
-0.0132418266,
0.0007677932,
-0.05776513,
-0.022098314,
0.0221313853,
0.0048432723,
-0.0044705556,
-0.0070274831,
0.0372764803,
0.0391451456,
0.0339609049,
-0.0117339985,
0.023996735,
-0.0584040135,
0.0665977597,
-0.0162676536,
-0.0636358336,
0.0095683997,
0.065067254,
-0.0257930737,
-0.0410378315,
-0.0171151124,
-0.0275638197,
-0.0143784992,
0.0081642214,
-0.0002561397,
0.0309298951,
-0.036792174,
-0.0166306198,
-0.0448056757,
0.0468373671,
-0.0283264704,
-0.0110469321,
0.0272152722,
0.0442590415,
-0.0757266358,
-0.0318022445,
-0.0226872787,
-0.0275390092,
-0.0364576168,
-0.0104236435,
0.0197945945,
0.0124918818,
0.0119710751,
0.0367887914,
-0.0109874029,
-0.0486354791,
0.018447658,
0.0388367958,
-0.022933254,
0.0104454039,
0.0067652063,
-0.0080193933,
-0.0597170293,
-0.0047208825,
-0.009636797,
-0.0111221587,
-0.0035331112,
-0.0142425355,
0.1100931019,
-0.0162798241,
-0.0786904991,
-0.0002448644,
-0.0096732918,
-0.0809257552,
-0.0325815193,
0.0094904592,
0.005660444,
0.0605317838,
-0.0189605355,
0.0939820781,
0.0274768043,
-0.0234232005,
-0.0381237753,
-0.0596547537,
0.0233535953,
0.0340575501,
0.0243439805,
0.0159458611,
-0.0247133356,
0.0447075032,
-0.0347400717,
-0.0057273307,
-0.0257347319,
0.0416335613,
2.435e-7,
0.0288434308,
-0.0084303105,
0.0047936263,
0.0200606566,
0.0004840486,
0.0492650084,
0.0452809371,
0.0390137471,
-0.0368699618,
-0.0301383808,
0.0490528084,
0.0501177087,
0.0144272763,
0.0202819221,
-0.0570324697,
0.0867265761,
-0.0209214408,
-0.0840947181,
-0.0573140644,
-0.0468100831,
0.0692842901,
0.0607189722,
0.061108131,
0.026193032,
0.0308878031,
0.019155588,
0.0077529657,
-0.0340000987,
-0.0248182584,
-0.0209802911,
-0.0546122529,
0.0349496342,
-0.0054498538,
-0.005917415,
-0.0324908346,
0.0241611134,
0.0214936249,
0.0276729893,
0.0217350405,
-0.0641615465,
-0.0013139441,
-0.0328827538,
0.0188766681,
-0.0157758296,
0.0611532666,
0.0033325751,
0.0374034196,
-0.0235643964,
-0.0132054379,
0.0492437519,
0.0129399244,
0.0462743379,
-0.0336709544,
0.024555251,
0.0046894778,
-0.0017499378,
0.0121657522,
-0.055147253,
-0.0018867218,
0.0853621215,
-0.0041381195,
-0.0159474555,
-0.0041828067,
-0.0108960588,
0.0284912791,
-0.057909511,
0.0180123486,
2.151181524e-34,
0.009877773,
0.0471399166,
0.0044260509,
0.0337392017,
0.008204137,
-0.0254562162,
-0.0355564691,
-0.03963615,
0.06016187,
-0.0302494671,
0.0047879652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07843v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07843v1 | Transformers are Universal Predictors | 2023-07-15T16:19:37 | 2023-07-15T16:19:37 | Sourya Basu, Moulik Choraria, Lav R. Varshney | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We find limits to the Transformer architecture for language modeling and show
it has a universal prediction property in an information-theoretic sense. We
further analyze performance in non-asymptotic data regimes to understand the
role of various components of the Transformer architecture, especially in the
context of data-efficient training. We validate our theoretical analysis with
experiments on both synthetic and real datasets. | [
0.0219020788,
0.0934005231,
0.0013310703,
0.0283467993,
-0.0143543137,
0.0283668265,
0.0089834044,
0.0351780206,
-0.0550348423,
-0.0152064506,
-0.0682086051,
-0.0550481118,
0.0130539238,
-0.0132259727,
0.032320939,
-0.0346169323,
0.0240035951,
-0.0580610707,
-0.0495017208,
-0.0250181612,
-0.0154207349,
-0.0303249341,
0.0053730267,
0.0348488651,
-0.0147153633,
0.0309105702,
0.0186947919,
-0.0523901619,
-0.0327357277,
0.0114607429,
-0.0112577491,
0.0400902182,
0.0116804726,
0.0226435829,
0.0000016489,
-0.0010679221,
0.0213058274,
-0.0160928406,
-0.0549470298,
-0.0196762402,
0.0073980358,
-0.081761986,
-0.0118087102,
0.0264925826,
-0.0067454181,
-0.0738680214,
0.0688742548,
0.0607859716,
-0.0097238356,
0.0735411495,
-0.0182300322,
-0.0668201968,
0.0218311157,
-0.0596789569,
-0.0035563784,
0.0167099517,
0.0294668637,
-0.0504712686,
-0.0376537256,
-0.0002730047,
-0.0670622364,
0.0270945672,
-0.0066583087,
0.0500106812,
0.0134228272,
0.0523809344,
-0.0177545883,
-0.0445255414,
-0.0092219505,
0.0113305142,
-0.0185108427,
-0.0374090821,
-0.018617712,
0.0182182621,
-0.0223586503,
0.0270080511,
-0.0190459769,
0.0309851244,
0.0100010363,
0.0409190655,
0.0258462876,
0.0301539283,
0.0312554799,
-0.0235424396,
-0.0437006131,
0.0564891323,
0.0114608761,
-0.0187954083,
0.003851847,
0.0252511464,
-0.007614485,
-0.0034520146,
-0.0383905061,
0.0213457011,
-0.00998531,
0.0053600343,
-0.0287415683,
-0.030508168,
-0.0039024684,
-0.0551779978,
0.0333709233,
0.0189745631,
0.0237420294,
-0.0050531179,
0.0057208585,
0.0763552934,
-0.0219365284,
0.0451923683,
-0.0269371103,
-0.0044751661,
-0.0339361243,
0.0074438271,
-0.0369720943,
0.0316445455,
0.0161863044,
-0.0200344175,
-0.0545566753,
0.0110884998,
0.0131213535,
-0.0339014642,
0.045200713,
-0.0132160047,
-0.0562065318,
0.0202296656,
-0.0280478802,
0.0323195234,
0.0190874133,
0.0159996897,
-0.0254319608,
-0.0650466084,
-0.0154469358,
0.0423449203,
0.0154700326,
-0.0152851371,
0.0172919631,
0.0982071459,
-0.0065982067,
-0.0545452721,
-0.0205719322,
0.0340917371,
-0.0345920585,
-0.0521673709,
0.0293136556,
-0.0384875983,
0.0254732128,
0.0426198766,
0.005987959,
-0.0229909979,
-0.0121170022,
-0.0033751519,
-0.0209000222,
0.0653657019,
0.0198755823,
0.0157787781,
-0.0181670487,
-0.0125646153,
0.0223025996,
0.071540162,
0.0234987363,
0.0053129601,
0.0129968403,
-0.0460244417,
0.016440805,
0.0574621484,
0.0073109739,
0.0132863903,
0.0160181224,
-0.0254496615,
0.0205839761,
-0.0146827269,
0.0079535563,
0.0738776922,
-0.0152418045,
-0.0281947684,
0.0545540787,
-0.0002694424,
0.0820371211,
0.0809378251,
0.0121917007,
-0.0075294944,
-0.0094382558,
0.0530358925,
-0.0289338995,
-0.0078945216,
0.0090599582,
-0.0066306619,
-0.0068237507,
0.0183944572,
-0.0704033226,
-0.026117133,
-0.0159550551,
-0.0378490724,
-0.0099830329,
-0.0288311187,
0.0541384704,
0.0380297862,
-0.0304970182,
0.1226105839,
0.0244771373,
-0.0356771201,
0.0092689125,
-0.0322702378,
-0.0002263799,
0.0033559892,
0.011969801,
-0.0121521382,
0.0412367098,
0.0100754024,
0.0053827851,
0.0196723286,
0.016583113,
-0.0061087967,
0.0444281176,
-0.0257921237,
-0.0004197045,
0.0616948567,
0.000327014,
-0.0050688218,
0.009609282,
-0.0162529405,
0.0028989776,
-0.0215257201,
0.0097287828,
0.0313692875,
-0.0222419538,
-0.0451888107,
0.0025369346,
-0.0023431964,
0.0534342229,
-0.0177464355,
-0.0275967754,
0.0160901956,
0.0414056443,
-0.0486623384,
-0.0487993732,
0.0332076922,
-0.0601251386,
-0.0232997146,
0.0120211467,
-0.0374724083,
0.0591337606,
0.0602446944,
-0.0055650971,
-0.0599485189,
0.0453730598,
-0.0546049923,
0.0877727047,
-0.0414276682,
0.0119822985,
-0.0113563091,
0.0612804294,
0.0047457265,
0.0364696309,
-0.0120371571,
0.0501290113,
0.0003550337,
-0.0311849676,
0.0003514491,
0.0024927414,
-0.037102405,
0.0024708896,
-0.0325831398,
0.0221758634,
0.0232489202,
-0.0408458784,
0.038672965,
-0.0659282058,
-0.0541210622,
-0.0253262315,
-0.0510904975,
0.0318912156,
0.0050676572,
0.0318334512,
0.0254719835,
-0.0073936097,
-0.0253688656,
-0.0036521659,
0.0189334713,
0.0245831087,
0.0293399785,
0.0184100308,
-0.0441283025,
-0.0070249178,
-0.0456452407,
0.0032652959,
0.0793200284,
-0.0128877209,
-0.0301844254,
-0.0410257988,
0.0039648796,
0.0044871755,
0.0729590431,
-0.0312877744,
-0.0453446321,
-0.01292649,
-0.0128764417,
0.0317742005,
0.0017423155,
0.029541431,
-0.0007981636,
0.0284746662,
0.0287389383,
0.0094498973,
-0.0188511498,
-0.0721894801,
-0.0284256823,
-0.0579562001,
-0.0242558364,
0.0028489416,
0.124633655,
-0.0057189595,
-0.0302843284,
-0.0560919344,
-0.0234942958,
-0.0121491542,
-0.0014789135,
0.0234320015,
-0.0060937321,
-0.0185777433,
0.0129007492,
-0.0094867451,
-0.0402928479,
0.0205996204,
-0.0380846113,
-0.0141486041,
-0.0082077421,
-0.024997117,
-0.0500711836,
0.0319135748,
0.0547417626,
-0.0104915798,
0.0338982455,
-0.0262271669,
-0.0322075449,
0.0067155277,
0.0141543867,
-0.0241544694,
0.0766279176,
-0.0111823231,
0.0308490675,
-0.0033572307,
-0.0676314905,
-0.0204518475,
-0.0442812443,
0.0002671955,
0.0091503235,
0.0610992052,
-0.0560310893,
-0.0534244031,
0.005978934,
-0.0021957667,
0.0432504453,
0.0058635725,
-0.034783341,
0.0145159261,
0.0370972529,
0.0336969793,
0.0243936088,
0.0044451603,
-0.0475500561,
0.0162383523,
0.0080432296,
0.0350182317,
0.0762253776,
-0.0385117531,
-0.0298267882,
0.0419947989,
0.0123232184,
-0.0492089093,
0.0074253646,
0.007723046,
0.0213708859,
-0.0186976399,
0.1106654778,
-0.0165786799,
-0.0356195755,
0.0159553736,
0.0516382642,
0.0593097806,
0.0278143808,
0.007266806,
-0.0591516271,
-0.0243612416,
-0.0230739694,
0.0086945612,
-0.0064607942,
-0.0345355123,
0.0153935142,
-0.0572561771,
-0.0026533881,
-0.0064636641,
-0.0226183925,
-0.0481734499,
-0.0463622473,
0.001220173,
-0.0681628287,
0.0140564544,
-0.017455386,
-0.0545925573,
-0.0132442787,
0.054851912,
-0.0634089932,
-0.022060724,
-0.0125052864,
-0.0233505312,
-0.0013483914,
0.051183138,
0.0077846316,
-0.0435127281,
-0.0443245061,
-0.0251231883,
-0.0093730539,
0.0085431766,
0.0171864741,
0.0788607672,
0.0058248225,
-0.022848295,
-0.0062934086,
0.0077465158,
-0.028488772,
0.0321882889,
-0.0201114789,
0.0538878776,
-0.0088910377,
-0.0529815629,
0.0287782196,
-0.0067808144,
0.0099481698,
0.068887122,
0.0212893412,
-0.0536947027,
-0.0066308379,
0.0115384031,
0.0524905622,
-0.0142569942,
-0.0720518306,
0.0422594771,
0.0223502032,
-0.1049902514,
-0.0618011802,
-0.0085614659,
-0.0030467336,
0.0550002009,
0.0194832329,
-0.0149503127,
0.0044759726,
-0.0080814324,
-0.0081107067,
-0.0404526107,
-0.0232737586,
-0.0075416705,
-0.040393807,
0.0056593153,
0.0566960722,
-0.0125642167,
-0.0163076334,
-0.0077863885,
-0.1211671233,
-0.037566971,
0.0497560129,
0.0116530126,
0.0251871366,
0.0413058363,
0.0283729415,
-0.0450666398,
0.0693436712,
0.0294421352,
-0.0249899905,
0.0493940227,
0.0534794703,
-0.0480583645,
0.0220464952,
0.0454294197,
-0.0186088551,
0.0440164655,
0.0133624002,
-0.0121507393,
-0.0394637659,
-0.0136032905,
0.0395099707,
0.0004810302,
0.053814061,
-0.0049026469,
0.0120224664,
0.0066540134,
0.0216174889,
0.0331780985,
0.0241077412,
-0.0514184274,
-0.0021540143,
0.0489490889,
0.052341897,
-0.0199040454,
0.0175663866,
0.0047943769,
0.011182311,
-0.0127559854,
0.0239892863,
0.0072894669,
-0.0312627777,
0.0455514714,
0.048519291,
0.0137232654,
0.0108550861,
0.0405346602,
0.0189508032,
0.0125835277,
0.037100371,
0.0263025425,
0.0507984571,
-0.018098034,
-0.0422143526,
-0.0996933356,
-0.0286149736,
-0.0177356545,
0.009522181,
0.0035458358,
-0.0303399228,
0.0150769772,
-0.0489397049,
0.0145908445,
-0.0249552242,
0.0276945885,
-0.0401586369,
-0.0407274775,
0.0561617725,
-0.0081320582,
-0.0298225787,
-0.0054493141,
0.0854224935,
-0.0000828379,
0.0350924879,
-0.0206973013,
0.0148828281,
-0.0538442731,
-0.0270365719,
-0.0160270929,
-0.0213104896,
0.0094100628,
-0.0056513594,
-0.0306930803,
-0.0716192871,
0.0111375516,
-0.0271845777,
0.0490155593,
-0.0549796596,
0.0130904,
0.0453813113,
0.0031512505,
0.0035163029,
-0.0303214658,
-0.0030324128,
0.0029175528,
0.0108453566,
-0.0314070471,
-5.860665491e-33,
-0.0204189569,
0.0257817749,
-0.0099613592,
0.0495529547,
0.0111941295,
0.0178067423,
0.007143639,
0.0083147902,
-0.0550975986,
-0.0174106769,
-0.0293374881,
0.0134140747,
0.0140029732,
0.0761127248,
-0.0014014652,
-0.0316461734,
0.0670658723,
-0.0295350142,
-0.0082366886,
-0.0082286624,
0.0273735859,
0.0145519646,
0.0661617294,
-0.029041227,
-0.0326637514,
-0.0212619752,
-0.0309899747,
0.0433127247,
0.0025251594,
0.0562662333,
-0.0310755968,
0.0611977279,
0.0312160552,
-0.0774610415,
-0.0139660826,
0.029239174,
-0.0769085139,
-0.0169779658,
0.0085822148,
0.0540664122,
-0.0077351429,
0.0019367241,
0.0481568575,
-0.033664003,
-0.0255854372,
-0.034808144,
0.0151061835,
0.0207420997,
-0.026620131,
-0.0469302461,
-0.039092835,
0.015235221,
0.0234315693,
0.0075633642,
0.0425845832,
0.0659004524,
-0.0077883885,
0.0033598677,
-0.0572680496,
0.016483685,
0.0354950242,
0.0839409158,
-0.0029169247,
0.0421347171,
-0.0253595617,
0.0426797196,
0.0686313063,
-0.0242924355,
-0.0379424244,
-0.0372481048,
0.0329551436,
0.0104459003,
0.0394845717,
-0.0010334194,
0.0391179584,
-0.0332703814,
-0.0450794362,
-0.0082873711,
0.0171407405,
0.0115176961,
0.0169967581,
0.006714765,
-0.0352634117,
-0.0689818636,
-0.0386913233,
-0.0011833756,
-0.0067026252,
-0.0091128144,
-0.0063581918,
0.0404657722,
0.0084890984,
0.0116402283,
0.0009636936,
-0.0688867867,
-0.0116476724,
0.029568838,
-0.0150580416,
0.046989426,
-0.0232525263,
-0.0199909136,
-0.0722888261,
-0.0276685767,
-0.0018121386,
0.0519328788,
0.0145153683,
-0.0199121144,
0.0540675707,
0.0827977061,
-0.0917647481,
-0.0542088374,
-0.0473985933,
0.0255973376,
0.0096528018,
0.0079379361,
0.0437232479,
0.00834799,
-0.0201325994,
-0.0023820156,
-0.0030780311,
0.0019638131,
-0.0086812312,
0.0263385549,
0.0344121866,
0.0355751403,
-0.0172166005,
-0.0409721173,
-0.0475560687,
-0.0012405002,
0.0586609803,
-0.0576530769,
-0.0238787364,
0.0274686776,
2.323e-7,
0.0480108783,
0.0056327609,
0.0172022358,
0.0110678812,
0.0425491929,
0.0184640866,
0.0255616177,
0.0487305745,
-0.003950736,
-0.0024450489,
0.0294228755,
0.0009590659,
0.03956398,
0.0016329784,
-0.1089514419,
-0.0331512764,
-0.0813467279,
0.0179712009,
0.0008275009,
0.0202750713,
0.0210478436,
0.1219301298,
-0.0164153725,
-0.0331379659,
-0.0108219348,
-0.0040464238,
0.0589955151,
-0.0514513962,
0.0342360623,
0.0210052188,
0.020061668,
-0.0020457366,
-0.0140119428,
0.0440219827,
-0.0284761302,
0.0285501834,
-0.0293112025,
0.0257681217,
0.0181158278,
-0.0136519615,
0.0313011184,
-0.0014339698,
-0.0473164506,
-0.0131868646,
0.0518795401,
-0.0566904694,
-0.0269389898,
-0.0368117057,
0.0073171481,
0.056200698,
-0.0329308435,
0.0004568261,
0.0033541725,
0.0277888011,
0.0275090262,
-0.0176410861,
-0.0008593983,
-0.0360839702,
-0.0046152757,
0.0118485922,
-0.0535000935,
-0.0259975661,
-0.0323746167,
-0.0386203341,
0.0246797092,
-0.0048355889,
0.0019248519,
1.836310783e-34,
0.0355614834,
0.0151399039,
0.0323800519,
-0.0059557119,
0.0162646659,
-0.0614444166,
0.0408859365,
0.001013734,
-0.006465557,
-0.0828792155,
-0.0177444331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.11766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.11766v1 | Three-way Decisions with Evaluative Linguistic Expressions | 2023-07-15T14:45:33 | 2023-07-15T14:45:33 | Stefania Boffa, Davide Ciucci | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a linguistic interpretation of three-way decisions, where the
regions of acceptance, rejection, and non-commitment are constructed by using
the so-called evaluative linguistic expressions, which are expressions of
natural language such as small, medium, very short, quite roughly strong,
extremely good, etc. Our results highlight new connections between two
different research areas: three-way decisions and the theory of evaluative
linguistic expressions. | [
0.0619035065,
0.0014577052,
-0.0152267879,
-0.0226765163,
-0.0673265606,
-0.0246054288,
-0.0135906041,
0.0295114201,
-0.0397496112,
-0.0379403606,
-0.0045724991,
0.0074657192,
0.006858062,
0.0277523175,
-0.0114692459,
-0.0150400614,
0.0325133987,
0.0256184191,
0.0880225673,
-0.0114026284,
0.0232226923,
-0.0300879646,
-0.0163217243,
0.0106276618,
0.0433811322,
0.0125875371,
0.0021418757,
-0.0599934757,
-0.0166437514,
-0.0540048592,
-0.0676305518,
0.0100962007,
-0.0324959084,
-0.027375536,
0.0000018328,
-0.0772192329,
-0.0163581427,
-0.0452199019,
0.0016415751,
-0.0071229693,
0.0493879393,
0.0054553468,
-0.0073367069,
-0.0289537068,
-0.0789641216,
0.012016437,
0.0239443202,
0.0649735183,
0.0177911315,
0.0306773428,
0.0076512513,
-0.0007227744,
-0.0501583964,
-0.0194458216,
0.006613242,
0.0079463944,
0.0235939547,
-0.0167382527,
-0.013766082,
0.0078919688,
-0.012497467,
-0.022871783,
-0.0034203581,
0.0179662537,
-0.0513428971,
-0.0015920927,
-0.012342684,
-0.0428036712,
-0.0081105661,
-0.0090557784,
0.0401553139,
0.0239212085,
-0.0379658304,
-0.0643257275,
0.0370953605,
-0.0091214208,
-0.000486029,
-0.0239094254,
-0.010119509,
0.0055761845,
-0.0474345051,
0.101681754,
-0.0411723107,
-0.0066514453,
-0.0382471271,
0.122226879,
-0.0244671013,
-0.0242367424,
0.0248644631,
-0.0257459525,
0.0244721752,
-0.0308914911,
-0.0271215886,
-0.0199165214,
0.0333756171,
-0.0119565669,
0.0145529574,
0.056689959,
0.062765412,
-0.0854165852,
-0.034468554,
-0.0067939423,
-0.0081877895,
0.0171504654,
-0.0026002466,
0.0418521091,
0.0102581792,
-0.041271165,
-0.0553962663,
0.0484388545,
0.0126608573,
-0.0065143108,
-0.0219778661,
0.0326031111,
0.0220968574,
0.0192298796,
-0.098323524,
-0.0355064608,
-0.0521261021,
0.0202016085,
-0.0387431122,
0.0232597068,
0.0152272834,
0.0315850005,
-0.1068533137,
0.0291045904,
-0.0798814297,
0.044557713,
-0.038019605,
-0.031516768,
0.0388278291,
0.0070338915,
0.0166875031,
-0.053965874,
0.017931927,
0.0781940222,
0.0050009047,
-0.0359367095,
0.0438827723,
-0.0107174022,
-0.0214855503,
-0.0577464998,
-0.0179638732,
-0.0327341333,
-0.0084610581,
0.0138060395,
0.0031184333,
-0.0865594745,
0.0019402253,
-0.0218174215,
0.0309858266,
0.0299038589,
0.0632133558,
-0.0316654928,
-0.0807419345,
-0.0051106848,
-0.0029312568,
0.0366630182,
0.0356809869,
0.0526583306,
0.0262418799,
-0.033135768,
0.0316627882,
0.00276532,
0.021986736,
0.0278995465,
-0.035189908,
0.022233082,
-0.0028495451,
-0.0049941405,
-0.0266281813,
0.0595123842,
-0.0219588783,
-0.0121212332,
0.0492573716,
0.064191781,
0.0426728912,
0.0214957837,
-0.0109604225,
0.0419298299,
-0.0271192845,
0.0291851778,
-0.0074559413,
0.0209063999,
0.0069063632,
0.0000941889,
0.0116353994,
0.0237843394,
0.0142832994,
-0.0647355691,
0.0190532841,
0.0007464422,
0.052461274,
-0.0013649382,
0.0043301377,
-0.0421625376,
0.0262813717,
-0.037070848,
-0.0054152831,
-0.0444223098,
-0.0008459709,
-0.0848344713,
0.0309614129,
0.0140029509,
-0.0252806675,
0.0231828056,
0.0575597361,
0.0178670436,
-0.0251298398,
-0.0218150169,
0.0509537011,
0.0515481457,
-0.0246778447,
-0.0104313204,
0.01426291,
0.0380008295,
0.0193200503,
-0.0019649467,
-0.0754163414,
0.0672686249,
-0.0347444788,
0.0198657811,
0.0501273349,
-0.0172985774,
0.0985665247,
-0.0230072699,
-0.023143867,
0.0191448722,
0.0101617146,
0.0224648509,
0.0007146603,
0.0476858802,
0.0247831047,
0.0134414127,
-0.0339844152,
0.0283948071,
0.0066978224,
0.0263833124,
-0.0120262168,
-0.0420774631,
0.0022915527,
-0.054805737,
0.0171614401,
-0.0212308504,
0.0572781339,
-0.0270358473,
0.0449437313,
0.0013042805,
0.0315796286,
-0.0284875613,
0.0074501862,
-0.0326214656,
0.0290936772,
-0.0222656094,
0.0509097613,
-0.1046063378,
-0.0272320844,
0.0385911874,
-0.0243815258,
-0.0099404436,
0.0294098556,
-0.0023496489,
0.0007050188,
0.0507142842,
0.0390674174,
-0.0120398626,
-0.0370365754,
-0.026721945,
-0.0546687432,
0.046577543,
-0.0005566526,
-0.036397405,
-0.0138694402,
0.0210292134,
0.0159025956,
-0.0231564585,
0.0029732499,
0.0542491525,
0.0158240683,
0.0096887192,
0.0138761392,
-0.0556722954,
0.01008444,
-0.0291407369,
-0.0416333042,
0.0141519811,
0.0116678001,
-0.0443784818,
0.0015137099,
0.022867823,
-0.0727560893,
-0.0099175805,
-0.0215409696,
-0.0419249237,
0.0121944044,
-0.0136935655,
-0.0155225154,
0.0132684708,
-0.0136187142,
0.0636224747,
0.0485931896,
-0.0196002703,
-0.0569789931,
-0.0125386063,
-0.0308277067,
0.0306926798,
0.0076726554,
-0.0441174842,
-0.0240369104,
-0.0172825381,
0.0523655154,
-0.0064208168,
-0.0372554474,
0.0611587428,
-0.0249639302,
-0.0196465869,
0.0236702859,
0.0035016618,
0.0001091448,
0.1244151071,
0.0432587266,
-0.00371097,
0.0835261717,
-0.0262572821,
-0.0299613625,
-0.0357216969,
-0.0022356256,
-0.0194280073,
0.0776789263,
-0.0527927801,
-0.0030116984,
0.0245755855,
-0.0097462228,
-0.0010550705,
-0.0995126143,
-0.0003457571,
-0.0068988199,
0.049782373,
0.0099813454,
0.0195680838,
-0.0252732132,
-0.0229867883,
0.031707231,
-0.0484326519,
-0.0175127909,
0.0056014294,
0.0218941811,
0.0012031312,
-0.040739309,
0.0027906571,
0.0149114933,
-0.0316016562,
0.0019439462,
-0.0166242123,
-0.0410817452,
-0.0595205203,
-0.0052758558,
0.0460700504,
0.0481515303,
0.030249944,
-0.0061723045,
0.0868479162,
0.0050997697,
0.0272891372,
0.0028958914,
0.0418850295,
0.0200752504,
0.0052539613,
0.0007621653,
0.0188594516,
-0.037970379,
-0.011298568,
0.0117961736,
-0.0040677106,
-0.0021775614,
0.0084418589,
0.0355015472,
-0.051780697,
0.0124991732,
0.0213949569,
-0.0114266826,
-0.1050127521,
-0.0039355722,
-0.0586039461,
-0.0161192119,
-0.0687274709,
-0.0259301811,
-0.0035743453,
-0.0769234374,
0.0035377287,
0.0006162747,
-0.0014818836,
-0.0384916104,
-0.0289140306,
0.0042756032,
0.0143639594,
-0.0491729043,
0.0143803619,
-0.0266294666,
0.0120584769,
0.0143885668,
0.0366572328,
0.016242167,
0.0161543991,
-0.0131304218,
-0.0025109001,
-0.0253694095,
0.0408877172,
-0.0621648096,
-0.0546533912,
-0.023404954,
0.0097879954,
-0.0294693168,
0.0212455075,
-0.0542198345,
0.0138151087,
0.0236065518,
-0.0368019864,
-0.0274449829,
0.0337473117,
-0.0073872707,
0.0598608628,
0.0521046482,
-0.0359039046,
-0.0590522252,
0.0054443926,
0.0398240611,
0.0273641273,
0.0445197113,
0.0104067735,
-0.0472071618,
-0.0186886843,
0.0053321286,
-0.0217065345,
0.0404787548,
-0.0888545662,
0.0061395853,
0.0155235771,
-0.0490727834,
-0.0198131893,
-0.0382750332,
0.0095787663,
0.0641830117,
0.0162512809,
0.0075955396,
0.0380062163,
0.0161091685,
0.0127525693,
0.0116726207,
0.0447159596,
-0.0025119802,
-0.0044402708,
0.060691487,
0.0435271449,
-0.0116078453,
-0.0168811437,
-0.0411473177,
0.0630381331,
-0.0044507403,
-0.0018908236,
0.0644066334,
0.0458644107,
-0.0852280557,
0.009556192,
-0.0226941686,
-0.0342712812,
0.0207950491,
0.0233977269,
0.0548672415,
0.0620068647,
0.0432197489,
0.0054462664,
0.0197880976,
0.0203187708,
0.0267052986,
-0.0182457455,
0.0047776583,
-0.0544155054,
-0.0216284469,
0.0025911552,
-0.0059279287,
-0.0050272481,
-0.005479577,
0.0300053135,
0.0112043051,
-0.0027869281,
-0.0172903948,
-0.0495117009,
-0.0266857613,
-0.0348793194,
-0.0085999584,
0.0219348501,
-0.0171170179,
-0.0492420346,
-0.0538832769,
-0.0151663693,
0.0291591119,
0.049596604,
0.0653378218,
0.0031459674,
0.0228745099,
0.0020080577,
-0.0083803926,
0.0130141247,
-0.0161376242,
0.0128592318,
0.001401394,
0.0141215315,
0.051403746,
-0.0149797453,
-0.0588942356,
0.0356729813,
0.0176295936,
-0.0493819229,
0.0453144349,
-0.0201944541,
-0.0412849747,
0.0258962661,
0.0210912991,
0.0056130956,
0.023015976,
-0.0033190616,
0.0109626018,
-0.0075120921,
-0.0482329801,
0.0371150561,
0.011383947,
-0.0135724023,
0.0013608413,
-0.0168327186,
-0.0522111058,
-0.0003172626,
-0.0703472719,
0.0112837516,
-0.0201339759,
-0.0530379526,
-0.010696088,
-0.0093465336,
0.0157276727,
0.0035936588,
-0.1427574456,
-0.0459098518,
-0.0334899686,
0.0325972214,
0.0387459919,
-0.0296442583,
0.0246116519,
0.0448143072,
0.0440278351,
-0.0095788855,
-0.0361832194,
-0.0214700438,
0.0116608413,
0.0207524691,
-0.0358546898,
-6.020522804e-33,
-0.0021729344,
-0.0250159986,
0.0224882197,
-0.0060745031,
0.0282428544,
-0.0856190771,
0.0208769031,
0.0639935806,
0.010178037,
-0.0190783646,
-0.0285824351,
-0.0032017631,
0.0186428986,
-0.0075229825,
0.0566148758,
0.0321019441,
-0.0213911086,
-0.0096266549,
-0.0705004632,
-0.0469640195,
0.0592428669,
-0.0615826063,
0.0448522158,
-0.0590748116,
0.0623079501,
0.0285732225,
-0.0503069349,
0.0163789876,
-0.0299899541,
0.0285078529,
0.0271552354,
0.0026389502,
0.0165964495,
-0.0292577222,
0.0027799606,
0.0405311324,
0.0293360408,
-0.0779708102,
0.0514909588,
-0.0066962074,
-0.0026697309,
0.0175341293,
-0.0121713672,
-0.0321376137,
-0.0704102442,
0.0723891035,
0.0134114362,
-0.0016122402,
0.0039406028,
-0.0149393454,
-0.016788369,
0.0122116487,
-0.0282941386,
0.0388633013,
0.0358205959,
0.0123581355,
-0.0332223997,
-0.0305689182,
0.0075526154,
0.0434582941,
-0.0169244744,
-0.0175311398,
-0.0139936022,
-0.0458664745,
-0.0216368232,
0.068772465,
0.0271574166,
0.0181746352,
0.0594364591,
-0.0485910885,
0.0424005166,
0.0569702126,
0.0223690961,
0.0419101603,
-0.023720745,
0.008496291,
-0.0251909997,
-0.0059241112,
0.0550086647,
0.0390573256,
0.0109079918,
0.0206862763,
-0.0518701486,
-0.0479234233,
-0.0129587175,
-0.0421284996,
-0.0578050502,
-0.0267979112,
-0.0008267731,
-0.0417420901,
-0.0340682305,
0.0237941574,
0.064657487,
0.0014202271,
-0.0773467049,
-0.00337834,
-0.0080223018,
0.0303920247,
-0.0106240083,
0.0037640936,
0.0121307122,
-0.0251712184,
-0.045510713,
0.0024965107,
0.0440585911,
0.0025207468,
-0.0207539666,
-0.021083951,
-0.0491125695,
0.0030034829,
0.0226748548,
-0.0340518728,
0.0197401401,
-0.0368625186,
0.0222519226,
0.0112430444,
0.0094662672,
-0.0061776154,
0.0020130281,
-0.016994359,
-0.0739022121,
0.0100386124,
-0.0037839985,
0.0524496175,
-0.0260792021,
-0.0128362384,
-0.0445797332,
0.035879273,
0.0286553632,
-0.0070513152,
0.0057190876,
-0.0056997309,
2.816e-7,
0.0002906588,
0.0332015082,
-0.0027684227,
0.0396782868,
-0.0092475312,
0.0741577968,
0.0039367718,
0.0214373954,
0.0170376804,
0.0144854141,
0.0321169123,
-0.0178167876,
-0.0222045332,
0.018664252,
0.0196855012,
0.0600399189,
-0.0146763166,
-0.0490058064,
0.0127692111,
0.0195230786,
0.0779433623,
0.017039571,
0.0569292791,
0.0287579373,
-0.0397736244,
-0.0352408215,
-0.0019299516,
-0.020957116,
0.0425968021,
0.0359542146,
0.0215117484,
-0.0433129668,
0.0194945838,
0.0440681465,
0.0704934075,
0.0202028882,
0.0180503149,
0.0474349521,
0.0142529234,
-0.0273850076,
-0.0111383181,
-0.0232800134,
-0.0173707306,
0.0102645075,
0.0545895994,
-0.0523509867,
-0.0571250208,
0.0216065794,
0.0250186231,
-0.0231707934,
0.0455811359,
0.0079947738,
-0.0424637385,
-0.0013025802,
0.0010931568,
-0.0054105916,
0.0164487455,
-0.0211116169,
0.0167177655,
0.0146110747,
0.0238400958,
-0.0883284509,
0.0214763414,
0.0880589411,
0.0165870246,
-0.0489746518,
-0.0197910927,
2.088017529e-34,
0.0669929013,
-0.0140033243,
0.017591387,
-0.0079318425,
0.0319769494,
0.0301459357,
0.0030645994,
0.0156004047,
0.0972485766,
-0.0161396712,
-0.0240265075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07798v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07798v1 | Opinion mining using Double Channel CNN for Recommender System | 2023-07-15T13:11:18 | 2023-07-15T13:11:18 | Minoo Sayyadpour, Ali Nazarizadeh | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Much unstructured data has been produced with the growth of the Internet and
social media. A significant volume of textual data includes users' opinions
about products in online stores and social media. By exploring and categorizing
them, helpful information can be acquired, including customer satisfaction,
user feedback about a particular event, predicting the sale of a specific
product, and other similar cases. In this paper, we present an approach for
sentiment analysis with a deep learning model and use it to recommend products.
A two-channel convolutional neural network model has been used for opinion
mining, which has five layers and extracts essential features from the data. We
increased the number of comments by applying the SMOTE algorithm to the initial
dataset and balanced the data. Then we proceed to cluster the aspects. We also
assign a weight to each cluster using tensor decomposition algorithms that
improve the recommender system's performance. Our proposed method has reached
91.6% accuracy, significantly improved compared to previous aspect-based
approaches. | [
-0.0013968046,
0.0211167131,
0.007577478,
0.0356365331,
-0.0117279291,
0.0029305941,
0.0268568285,
0.0088195298,
0.0057299025,
-0.0438351184,
-0.0669809654,
-0.0131892618,
-0.0238215793,
0.0497085787,
-0.0611668974,
0.0170968138,
0.0079418765,
0.0327166058,
0.0284554251,
0.0084465435,
0.0150079262,
0.0517227761,
-0.0061009224,
-0.0004851811,
-0.0253968053,
-0.009462662,
0.0317715667,
-0.0119265746,
-0.0042177918,
0.0182527304,
0.034849003,
-0.0159803443,
-0.0000022607,
-0.0048989835,
0.000002324,
0.0255884938,
-0.0256196577,
-0.0417698883,
0.0383770764,
0.0187458806,
0.0807537735,
0.0068918737,
-0.0158857442,
0.0067580789,
-0.065723598,
-0.0008863808,
-0.0035246979,
0.1323548853,
0.0516558029,
0.0305756945,
-0.0492311642,
-0.0459089018,
0.0353351869,
0.0204438418,
-0.0377586074,
-0.019923741,
-0.0025394203,
-0.0343849137,
-0.0554373898,
0.0006063665,
0.0135023585,
-0.0131714307,
0.0293745585,
-0.0006670488,
0.0194898453,
0.022564074,
-0.0072062733,
0.0120994356,
-0.0150912059,
0.0853016302,
-0.0122514516,
-0.0190086868,
-0.0205658376,
-0.0306346752,
0.0017713566,
-0.0302851032,
0.0073429681,
-0.0220129788,
0.0105852354,
0.051314313,
-0.0215533953,
0.0153746195,
0.0146115366,
0.0015413485,
0.0093107251,
0.0485280193,
-0.0317601822,
-0.019266367,
0.0043113795,
0.0271272659,
0.0096853953,
0.0168464668,
0.0383350737,
-0.0237439722,
0.0089990525,
-0.0363727175,
-0.0208078045,
-0.0187021568,
-0.0026560493,
-0.1064722389,
0.0027508964,
-0.0231292024,
-0.0481057353,
0.0569377095,
-0.0199226998,
-0.0453970395,
0.0107378019,
-0.0167051479,
-0.0339317471,
0.0025731681,
-0.0386074148,
0.0009829944,
0.0168404449,
0.0468451865,
0.0072839018,
-0.0368577316,
-0.0439482108,
-0.018786788,
-0.0368525796,
-0.0184303708,
0.0227241348,
0.0534918755,
0.0502867736,
0.0182394218,
-0.0403459556,
0.0254485123,
-0.0597046055,
0.0729362965,
-0.0533001572,
0.0041471631,
0.0580876917,
0.0565511212,
0.0430338643,
-0.0049671978,
0.0185686108,
0.0050435611,
-0.0004927166,
-0.0747919381,
-0.0764960349,
-0.030243339,
-0.0137565769,
-0.0327005945,
-0.0253004525,
-0.0737223551,
0.0421404056,
-0.045459915,
-0.0230580531,
-0.0024279479,
-0.0145450849,
-0.0077256719,
-0.0093395934,
0.0292234607,
-0.0104129491,
-0.0299771689,
0.0376443677,
0.0010547844,
0.0510785058,
-0.0035850089,
0.0103894146,
0.0550165176,
0.0526699685,
0.0013829889,
0.0015995309,
-0.0217785109,
-0.021103939,
-0.0358231664,
0.0083175795,
-0.0096019302,
-0.0907657668,
-0.0340202749,
0.0006161214,
0.0500592962,
-0.0433328748,
-0.0138903577,
0.0279969238,
-0.0409529693,
0.0212242696,
0.0969718546,
0.0065634917,
0.0180577934,
-0.0279670171,
-0.0453206673,
0.0055269953,
0.0493542142,
0.0113263326,
-0.0570905693,
0.0652872846,
-0.0118296146,
-0.0545421876,
-0.0758524016,
0.0420595706,
-0.0502173454,
0.0879551247,
-0.0007469107,
0.0419197902,
0.0023890617,
-0.0293352623,
0.0242813826,
0.0322728269,
-0.0362379365,
-0.0054753921,
0.0199539363,
0.0651295409,
0.0709489807,
-0.0051240823,
0.0108375503,
0.0241000522,
-0.0395017117,
-0.008314454,
-0.0425957106,
0.0341851674,
-0.0025722184,
-0.0043086936,
-0.0782239959,
-0.0130841602,
-0.0345937572,
-0.0109301722,
-0.0232596043,
-0.0480597503,
0.0473524295,
0.0170247089,
0.0138704637,
0.0059644887,
-0.0211960431,
0.058245901,
0.0000472836,
0.0736360103,
0.0384157151,
0.0053660981,
0.0701686516,
0.001985016,
-0.0188405123,
0.053369049,
-0.0366884097,
-0.0811408088,
-0.0354298614,
-0.0233669449,
-0.0205954947,
0.0288259648,
-0.0672982708,
0.0412807688,
0.0411345586,
-0.0087162005,
-0.0279060341,
0.0578028969,
0.0092811948,
0.0211321507,
-0.0042208023,
-0.0457822159,
0.0110769412,
0.0360500962,
0.0155064836,
0.0595654771,
-0.0084818713,
-0.0301243216,
-0.0665897503,
-0.0573831499,
0.0152966194,
0.0187768415,
-0.0257637911,
0.0008280266,
0.0098755918,
0.0013448173,
0.0192287192,
-0.0094037103,
0.0040905657,
-0.0191889443,
-0.111219354,
0.0024383178,
-0.0059926673,
-0.004321408,
-0.0152566619,
0.0058570425,
0.0243727863,
0.0084057394,
-0.0728612691,
0.0313241668,
-0.0302135199,
-0.0109955715,
0.0328651331,
0.03877661,
0.0248907004,
-0.0023863262,
-0.0316842794,
0.0022686529,
-0.0158470105,
0.0297090653,
-0.0318998769,
0.0120827714,
0.0082523357,
-0.0320691131,
0.0047750361,
-0.0043510324,
0.0120306034,
-0.0364563726,
-0.0270998664,
-0.0257832073,
0.0280917846,
0.0207426157,
0.0424337275,
0.0423666723,
0.0329746269,
-0.0137212873,
0.0252169948,
-0.0459046587,
0.0385725237,
-0.0058829677,
0.0288103353,
-0.0151376035,
0.0045672324,
0.0282964893,
-0.0029763842,
-0.0200465117,
-0.0232452527,
-0.0062490795,
0.021053385,
0.0226094462,
-0.0012446294,
0.0230471231,
0.0247713644,
0.0265943781,
-0.0059847287,
0.0474630073,
0.0199968647,
-0.0019059172,
-0.0672029555,
-0.0729803666,
-0.0569075719,
-0.0357873812,
-0.0251783952,
0.0145805227,
-0.0324152224,
0.0415583551,
0.0284187105,
-0.0126604792,
0.0001426592,
-0.0048124068,
0.0068886499,
0.0305716544,
-0.0069463965,
0.0017976178,
-0.0302940961,
0.0033237368,
-0.0363430716,
-0.0195677001,
-0.0210350771,
0.0085173193,
-0.0098607903,
-0.0095201116,
-0.0445870459,
-0.0424304828,
0.013654327,
0.0071023065,
-0.0120892068,
0.0193917844,
0.043863982,
0.0468144268,
-0.0452131219,
0.0188335199,
-0.0053089457,
0.0149043603,
0.0831856057,
-0.0421064943,
0.0244808309,
-0.0517882146,
-0.0106164692,
0.0172362681,
0.0118864598,
0.0007707096,
-0.0081887357,
-0.002694427,
-0.0025203016,
0.0340042301,
0.1071046665,
0.0447090641,
-0.1028436273,
0.0198825523,
0.0383767113,
-0.0684059113,
-0.0004488342,
-0.0268356632,
-0.0495013148,
-0.0344341621,
-0.0443409644,
-0.009036175,
0.0217744336,
-0.0001726378,
0.0271793455,
-0.0709495172,
0.0319751911,
-0.0064118803,
0.0110390512,
-0.0666160733,
-0.0317664556,
-0.0042081811,
-0.0415269285,
0.0412884392,
-0.0476204231,
0.0345092565,
-0.0183456391,
-0.0287215412,
-0.0115251811,
-0.0109176058,
0.0456160046,
-0.0222680327,
0.0008113334,
0.0247901157,
0.0557237193,
-0.0433242731,
-0.0348088592,
0.0199461672,
-0.0092174476,
-0.0160861704,
-0.0117763076,
0.0520574562,
-0.05086907,
0.0033513117,
-0.0160310343,
0.0290033333,
-0.0785221085,
0.0268726721,
-0.0068817413,
0.0131025044,
-0.012544075,
-0.0412696227,
-0.0340030752,
0.0153975645,
-0.0164236818,
0.0537784845,
-0.0077903876,
-0.0750540867,
0.0233855192,
-0.0050690807,
-0.0126141645,
0.0106658079,
-0.0256301835,
-0.0272686128,
0.0369898826,
-0.0084034214,
-0.0558172315,
-0.0259264596,
0.0085403677,
0.0022320279,
-0.0404709876,
0.0051167179,
0.0120092481,
-0.0208630897,
-0.0139991045,
0.0144264773,
0.0348738246,
0.0396829471,
-0.0276680868,
0.0141481729,
0.0428562351,
-0.044592645,
-0.0219715498,
-0.0023408851,
-0.0395826995,
-0.0006792167,
-0.0665652826,
0.0513331778,
-0.0065924781,
0.0288928635,
-0.0323749073,
-0.047154896,
-0.0109761888,
0.0541415252,
-0.0725539029,
-0.0164964031,
0.0318299122,
0.0036890253,
0.0114998985,
0.0354272388,
-0.0277538877,
0.0316866189,
0.0150067797,
-0.0515493043,
-0.0346299969,
-0.0342415124,
0.0080842804,
-0.0371110849,
0.0928007737,
0.0182265826,
0.0425586961,
-0.0390446894,
0.01966873,
0.0303727984,
-0.0183055177,
-0.0512433983,
0.0266104955,
0.0274257846,
0.0025166727,
-0.0408324488,
0.0117608542,
0.0590495691,
-0.0042585898,
0.0194885395,
0.0669079572,
0.0198450722,
0.0303090885,
-0.0380837917,
0.0202275254,
-0.0120961312,
0.0083582923,
0.0228423625,
-0.0093444232,
-0.0050013866,
0.0112179182,
-0.000114849,
0.0048987977,
-0.0251852423,
0.0652213246,
-0.0052460101,
-0.0142704304,
-0.0364727601,
-0.0091629839,
0.0074366303,
-0.0615235902,
0.0332759283,
-0.0214530826,
0.0037330168,
-0.0463523641,
0.0162371267,
-0.0265750084,
0.0106940512,
0.002590202,
0.0085186251,
-0.0126170618,
0.007850646,
0.0632608756,
-0.0663791075,
-0.0089345975,
0.0262730345,
-0.0186431147,
-0.0479758419,
0.0263516866,
0.0005190261,
0.0812883601,
-0.0179263968,
0.0299964026,
0.0199694745,
-0.0012010812,
0.002273283,
-0.0327629447,
0.0255081523,
0.0046795453,
0.064606525,
0.0579556786,
0.0081851864,
0.063450247,
-0.0679246932,
-0.0167940129,
0.0083435234,
-0.0147306826,
-0.0247428901,
-6.930940975e-33,
0.0499083139,
-0.0001198381,
-0.0331661403,
0.0474598035,
0.0023656769,
0.0020527868,
-0.015917426,
0.0329755023,
-0.0092463968,
0.048244033,
0.0214089826,
0.0222551636,
0.003654171,
0.0142059475,
0.0000634569,
-0.0230859388,
0.0187555067,
0.0196587536,
0.0202342626,
0.0752931163,
0.0518682301,
0.0414817035,
0.0758617371,
-0.1039808914,
-0.0027342532,
-0.0193892084,
-0.0220093559,
-0.0130746774,
-0.0075158495,
0.0791971236,
-0.0152563984,
0.0757468343,
0.0216660611,
-0.0306175221,
0.0217049848,
-0.0067860908,
-0.0549218096,
-0.0116772857,
-0.0463314876,
0.0103808204,
-0.0400520824,
-0.0008621422,
0.0356015787,
0.0365262814,
-0.0053777499,
0.0084419148,
0.0676987171,
-0.0114348186,
-0.0009212331,
-0.0657793656,
0.0100546824,
0.0251722652,
-0.0356379561,
-0.0212378539,
0.0259763375,
0.0443387218,
-0.0006542358,
0.0366563909,
-0.0881944448,
0.0391273163,
-0.0691861361,
0.0021633587,
-0.0275924895,
-0.0882524401,
-0.0415536128,
0.068444401,
-0.008040322,
0.0162347946,
-0.0223865733,
0.0304370616,
0.0150946686,
0.0626857355,
0.0205555558,
0.0259391926,
0.0243791379,
-0.0384957902,
-0.0494629927,
0.0279799867,
0.0643936619,
-0.0065823859,
0.01071213,
0.0355839618,
-0.0396720581,
-0.006419797,
0.0490733795,
-0.0632732809,
-0.0390632898,
-0.0278436095,
-0.0459809564,
0.0404507108,
-0.0412402451,
0.0107842842,
-0.0177434273,
-0.0883433893,
-0.0086886352,
0.041454792,
-0.0376578607,
0.0146108586,
0.0258451588,
-0.0251093227,
-0.0481322855,
-0.0020187143,
-0.0262161735,
-0.0404693708,
-0.02172116,
0.003247211,
0.0427876115,
0.0293380804,
-0.0234493203,
-0.0111813685,
0.0317988433,
-0.0366141908,
0.0128599619,
0.0720734298,
-0.0329857171,
0.0238491017,
-0.0183835048,
0.1009384692,
-0.0339091308,
0.0795691684,
-0.0207489841,
-0.0458137207,
0.0355177,
-0.0114049762,
-0.0232052412,
-0.0675771087,
-0.0186882932,
-0.0169546511,
0.0488857105,
-0.0999671221,
-0.0253730975,
-0.0205724016,
2.938e-7,
0.0365397707,
0.0094341701,
-0.0195532218,
-0.0295127295,
0.0242295787,
0.0720010698,
0.0449832007,
0.0464303754,
-0.0128211668,
0.0364556983,
0.0485887565,
0.0301665105,
-0.0246663298,
0.0206661932,
-0.058388669,
0.0366923288,
-0.0311280228,
-0.0072323717,
-0.0101273153,
0.0047742631,
0.018828731,
0.111519672,
0.0642787963,
-0.0437617786,
0.0151548823,
0.0234749801,
0.0308770966,
-0.0203799922,
0.0164641403,
-0.0003592295,
0.0146721769,
0.0016479074,
-0.0360922515,
-0.0011303558,
-0.0286770388,
0.0209209323,
0.0166759305,
0.0232755896,
0.0332552306,
-0.0441238694,
0.0487988852,
0.0328683518,
0.0091768326,
-0.0007089858,
0.0801758617,
0.0023560347,
-0.0574341901,
-0.0754542947,
-0.0067030867,
0.0356463268,
0.0764124244,
-0.0034485923,
-0.0099928789,
0.0184938852,
0.018973643,
-0.0542201512,
-0.0179605093,
-0.0601171516,
0.0315140337,
0.015296693,
-0.0208027288,
0.0116908075,
0.0147774601,
0.0068030087,
0.0533922762,
0.0042155799,
0.0189042669,
2.051566872e-34,
0.0378825776,
0.0006139695,
0.0083113378,
0.010606085,
-0.0324023291,
-0.0093068155,
-0.0557317995,
-0.0489898659,
0.0204119254,
-0.0274044778,
-0.0089614689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07740v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07740v2 | Political Sentiment Analysis of Persian Tweets Using CNN-LSTM Model | 2023-07-15T08:08:38 | 2023-08-29T16:55:11 | Mohammad Dehghani, Zahra Yazdanparast | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Sentiment analysis is the process of identifying and categorizing people's
emotions or opinions regarding various topics. The analysis of Twitter
sentiment has become an increasingly popular topic in recent years. In this
paper, we present several machine learning and a deep learning model to
analysis sentiment of Persian political tweets. Our analysis was conducted
using Bag of Words and ParsBERT for word representation. We applied Gaussian
Naive Bayes, Gradient Boosting, Logistic Regression, Decision Trees, Random
Forests, as well as a combination of CNN and LSTM to classify the polarities of
tweets. The results of this study indicate that deep learning with ParsBERT
embedding performs better than machine learning. The CNN-LSTM model had the
highest classification accuracy with 89 percent on the first dataset and 71
percent on the second dataset. Due to the complexity of Persian, it was a
difficult task to achieve this level of efficiency. The main objective of our
research was to reduce the training time while maintaining the model's
performance. As a result, several adjustments were made to the model
architecture and parameters. In addition to achieving the objective, the
performance was slightly improved as well. | [
0.0178938638,
0.0352035314,
0.0141049381,
0.0058492324,
-0.0440727882,
0.0289675966,
-0.0115791298,
-0.0178124718,
0.0264879148,
-0.0493692867,
0.0261503439,
-0.0670677498,
-0.0251075327,
0.0606772378,
-0.0426035002,
-0.0519246794,
0.0289864335,
0.044557292,
0.0662773252,
-0.0421984345,
0.0212249663,
0.0375798084,
-0.0121995145,
0.0152471345,
-0.0463851243,
0.0156333558,
-0.0105250664,
0.0050875191,
0.0084603513,
0.0003671312,
0.027582759,
0.0066169929,
0.0198925976,
0.0300058369,
0.0000021416,
-0.0084576653,
-0.0352360234,
-0.0389663577,
0.0206080619,
-0.0308443122,
0.1093822345,
-0.0249982458,
-0.0253602602,
0.0437614657,
-0.0503266603,
-0.0460470617,
0.0686393231,
0.0921492353,
0.053440243,
0.0884978324,
-0.0169298518,
-0.0435401946,
-0.0130803296,
-0.0114657953,
-0.0126950918,
-0.0207531564,
0.0194281433,
-0.0804207847,
-0.0643586144,
0.0078131221,
-0.0228102691,
0.0056456719,
0.0177074503,
0.0006179659,
-0.0033155028,
-0.0249671526,
-0.0178056285,
-0.0056651882,
0.0326367244,
0.0153934807,
-0.0489637405,
-0.0442368463,
-0.0139036933,
-0.002271702,
-0.0287994761,
-0.0024270944,
-0.0205659736,
0.0245281067,
0.0044747354,
0.0778963044,
0.0279326029,
0.0076407231,
0.0230572708,
0.0537469983,
-0.0357357562,
0.0434400588,
-0.0229059309,
-0.0411107652,
0.0028649964,
0.0089729698,
-0.0122755058,
-0.0106741441,
0.0265498981,
-0.0166876949,
-0.0181468409,
0.0132823242,
-0.0242481325,
-0.0152547611,
-0.002965718,
-0.0847524628,
-0.0449859425,
0.0170553625,
-0.0102196587,
0.0573334806,
-0.0157339927,
-0.0419482253,
0.0080410354,
0.0107295876,
0.0134574883,
-0.027235372,
-0.0579003356,
-0.0033465105,
0.0238307193,
0.0399275236,
0.0131432489,
-0.0200720113,
-0.0622150823,
-0.0137266526,
-0.0012352738,
0.0130005646,
-0.0030413438,
0.036093723,
0.003763295,
0.0144566968,
-0.025456341,
0.0552778356,
-0.0281397309,
0.0301950518,
-0.0409576222,
-0.0357046537,
0.0298085585,
0.0468239225,
0.0448199622,
0.0012704675,
0.0253908224,
0.0237148944,
0.0190422777,
-0.032209117,
-0.0557185709,
-0.0174223725,
0.0007966988,
-0.0249555074,
0.0278916247,
-0.0789997429,
0.0199678987,
-0.0094770519,
-0.0126615446,
0.0181637853,
0.0171757564,
0.0292315781,
-0.0100706983,
0.0812191889,
-0.0009442015,
-0.010385382,
0.0352003314,
0.0084144408,
0.0363411345,
0.059019886,
0.0220549945,
0.0803561807,
0.0105766142,
-0.0309161525,
-0.0138935437,
-0.0236285925,
-0.0060583903,
-0.0430209674,
-0.0393859595,
-0.0114868386,
-0.0898846537,
0.0050048591,
-0.0076322784,
0.0157378856,
0.0282377619,
0.025002623,
0.0228305329,
0.0329848491,
0.020055078,
0.0602157004,
-0.052112598,
0.0492471457,
0.0151276384,
-0.0394691974,
0.0011337509,
0.0184721928,
0.0382873081,
-0.0078258337,
-0.0088377269,
0.0265303515,
-0.0236803256,
-0.0252747834,
0.003197151,
-0.066624932,
0.0331553854,
-0.0321750566,
0.0766874626,
-0.0545217879,
-0.0500041805,
0.0336070023,
0.0357784815,
-0.0658491328,
-0.0247024279,
-0.0469189286,
0.0302836355,
0.0416399576,
-0.023416575,
-0.0177365877,
-0.0113744764,
-0.0522083677,
0.0331371352,
0.0333402269,
0.0351274535,
0.0325978547,
-0.0355191715,
-0.0492035672,
-0.0329883993,
-0.0051582633,
0.0095286258,
0.0244853906,
-0.017808469,
0.079418771,
0.0121209044,
0.019943431,
-0.0060509229,
0.0096330149,
0.0601607747,
0.0036581827,
0.010697566,
0.0339624919,
0.0277534425,
0.0514943451,
-0.0309269,
-0.0354777798,
0.029036345,
-0.0155064156,
-0.0681326389,
-0.0007432377,
-0.0380627476,
-0.0028407641,
0.0234574657,
-0.0608263798,
-0.0101106139,
0.067378886,
-0.0510033779,
-0.0456126295,
0.1064714789,
0.0004184114,
0.0027037819,
-0.0472163484,
-0.0017873923,
-0.0548757017,
0.0156801715,
-0.0093380772,
0.0546178631,
-0.0049064066,
-0.0039662016,
-0.0567579605,
-0.0131087685,
0.0587299243,
0.0263945423,
-0.0304074045,
0.0462083034,
-0.0015048287,
-0.0068457117,
0.0351202898,
0.0056629125,
-0.0124227172,
-0.0300035644,
-0.0550312437,
0.0024754712,
-0.0226441678,
0.026775673,
-0.0220242869,
0.0223644469,
0.0038157881,
0.0216465257,
-0.0367341563,
-0.0092513254,
0.0025684799,
-0.0186430756,
0.0333003961,
-0.0440344661,
0.014162967,
-0.0148178628,
-0.0011131265,
-0.0336332843,
-0.0224494766,
0.0110809449,
-0.0674269646,
0.0625826195,
0.0135845505,
0.0222433321,
0.0248297863,
0.0000647031,
-0.0596831217,
-0.0004797236,
-0.0204079319,
0.0174284708,
0.0468212701,
0.045164708,
0.0136132874,
-0.0081013469,
0.0451021977,
-0.0271122549,
0.0186898038,
-0.0296102036,
0.0286498889,
-0.0185444113,
-0.0209327526,
-0.0286773313,
0.0194770675,
-0.0080714244,
0.0161983352,
-0.0315031633,
-0.00793189,
-0.0231761541,
0.0245189406,
0.0016560114,
0.0157217626,
0.0089002587,
-0.0070988867,
0.0152258128,
-0.0352980457,
0.024981536,
0.0144174779,
0.0316316746,
-0.0642418489,
-0.0404489078,
-0.0449244268,
0.0249097198,
0.0025303075,
-0.011602954,
-0.0565743558,
0.0179779455,
0.0013510702,
-0.0338009745,
-0.033860039,
-0.0318353362,
0.0075386581,
0.0242621712,
-0.003510691,
-0.0437275358,
0.0137513913,
-0.0080622314,
-0.0415310413,
-0.0331905037,
-0.0104936538,
0.0442018434,
-0.0491989963,
0.0163985956,
0.0012113131,
-0.0107411714,
-0.0627391115,
-0.0041063991,
0.0178351589,
0.0145127997,
-0.0101259537,
0.0440579951,
-0.0229606815,
0.0081074685,
0.0399757437,
0.011525115,
0.0298678633,
0.0085614342,
0.0335847065,
-0.0746023506,
-0.0413139127,
0.003234955,
-0.0304753631,
-0.005060337,
-0.0520663373,
0.0026320571,
-0.0439002961,
0.0367285721,
0.1307517737,
0.0209613759,
-0.0471091159,
-0.0210944396,
0.0012597861,
-0.0765161663,
-0.0076422389,
-0.0162867606,
-0.059132956,
-0.0191873349,
-0.0123512503,
-0.019015694,
-0.0098907063,
-0.0238223895,
0.0244321767,
-0.0903423652,
-0.0171090737,
-0.0222455729,
0.0056311404,
-0.0480928682,
-0.0181472767,
-0.0282185264,
-0.0221023038,
-0.0106533812,
-0.068049483,
0.0065725856,
0.0285963397,
0.0291601103,
-0.0859997869,
-0.0416831151,
0.024078723,
-0.0399565734,
0.0015042499,
0.0385291427,
0.0445372164,
-0.0691082701,
-0.0233045463,
0.0266387109,
0.0153253051,
-0.025709942,
-0.0278701298,
0.02044704,
-0.0365682319,
-0.0275817979,
0.0189087633,
-0.0106116878,
-0.0679268911,
0.018929176,
-0.0435809754,
0.0355344117,
-0.0579759032,
-0.0291934237,
-0.0286030285,
0.0224828608,
0.0225093272,
0.0485205241,
-0.0030998758,
-0.0178511925,
-0.0493151098,
-0.0057751075,
-0.0208789259,
-0.0816463009,
0.0180821493,
0.0075286594,
0.0139977802,
-0.0448021516,
-0.024669297,
-0.0369250216,
0.000213085,
0.0121660186,
-0.0612639822,
0.0313673839,
0.0193045307,
0.0162619315,
-0.0557828508,
0.0208567642,
0.04453649,
0.0311693139,
0.0239467975,
-0.0470741205,
0.0393981636,
0.009634926,
0.0019609639,
-0.0281648152,
-0.0373683423,
0.0002430077,
0.0269722287,
-0.0072317049,
0.0101150442,
-0.052004803,
-0.0177199021,
-0.0491111614,
0.0006529835,
0.0795360208,
0.0058365357,
-0.0320786051,
0.0328437649,
0.0808628649,
0.0163406916,
0.0403038636,
-0.0022105312,
0.0271774456,
-0.0070148716,
-0.0645105764,
-0.0277494676,
-0.0066701081,
-0.0169953424,
0.0010797152,
0.0670402497,
0.0366316624,
-0.0708305091,
-0.026049668,
-0.0370821021,
0.0065469081,
0.0118385078,
-0.0130883977,
-0.0096710678,
0.0271576997,
-0.0073819365,
-0.0582142547,
0.0059240418,
0.0076458212,
-0.0321691111,
0.0091343224,
0.079938516,
0.0155335525,
0.0349362418,
-0.0405786484,
0.0164494682,
-0.0297921672,
-0.0487557761,
0.012597586,
-0.0473968796,
0.0090390323,
-0.0088698966,
-0.0126515301,
0.0129052168,
0.0158954822,
0.0265154168,
-0.003220815,
-0.0245122556,
-0.0144534335,
0.0218649656,
0.0472769551,
-0.0552472211,
0.0222311839,
-0.0346737802,
0.0190057606,
0.0113020642,
0.0297909025,
-0.0126401288,
0.003674669,
0.052011963,
-0.0152044697,
-0.0508458205,
-0.0311918538,
0.0271148849,
0.0076876259,
0.0060620075,
0.0393156782,
-0.0285151806,
-0.0015462241,
0.0051068384,
0.0388361514,
0.0304229409,
-0.0005257911,
0.0233895257,
0.0143679036,
-0.0394821353,
0.071856901,
-0.0502519161,
0.046472799,
0.0015646112,
0.0369902737,
0.0749629438,
0.0008753749,
0.052766487,
-0.0446033925,
0.0226153377,
0.0016905258,
-0.0396285355,
-0.0397630371,
-7.01013256e-33,
0.0306195635,
-0.0062896251,
-0.0342721641,
0.0155701032,
-0.0132658947,
-0.0290259682,
-0.0241186135,
0.0103736436,
-0.0488292351,
0.0211148933,
0.0114812097,
0.0585764274,
0.0117551833,
0.0532253981,
0.0550347082,
-0.0396586917,
0.0070487242,
-0.0090423087,
0.0312169939,
0.0379768573,
0.0445487164,
0.0479570702,
0.1079461053,
-0.0948667824,
-0.0099135647,
-0.0143301087,
-0.0132540967,
-0.0062843519,
0.0254014507,
0.0150355045,
-0.0071086227,
0.0775001124,
0.0547630377,
-0.048427809,
0.0192291625,
0.0469609275,
0.020092044,
-0.0325321741,
-0.0438543521,
0.0409895629,
-0.0221871976,
-0.0110695455,
0.0349863507,
0.0434305929,
-0.025996767,
0.0328884833,
0.0392271951,
-0.0018502258,
0.0104952892,
-0.0384759158,
-0.0219789352,
0.0461187772,
0.0117762219,
0.0027227886,
0.0245641991,
0.0130649889,
0.0440347679,
0.0576268546,
-0.045825094,
-0.0043541086,
-0.0447492823,
0.0295417141,
0.0086055342,
-0.040783301,
-0.0253577791,
0.040814463,
0.0161709264,
0.0044444404,
-0.0401248001,
0.0222518258,
0.0171176288,
0.0034390478,
0.0427612886,
0.0645454079,
0.0598667786,
-0.0678976029,
-0.0890392587,
0.0218847208,
0.0846780613,
0.081182614,
0.0149347652,
-0.0122438716,
-0.0042503015,
0.0098259132,
0.0494830012,
-0.0304839183,
-0.0090475306,
-0.0151645737,
-0.036395777,
-0.0002348497,
-0.0023994423,
0.0274736974,
0.0034357049,
-0.057856489,
0.0274115894,
0.0040104385,
-0.0163696297,
0.0283730552,
0.0083733844,
0.0262505282,
-0.0405092314,
-0.0539394841,
-0.0371326581,
0.0331212245,
0.0025510071,
0.001619637,
0.0124856103,
0.0421799049,
-0.0644825548,
0.015550267,
-0.0035968586,
0.0101911481,
0.013931565,
0.0866405889,
-0.0292919334,
0.0003638637,
0.0145583767,
0.0385499224,
0.0214864723,
0.0227590092,
0.0226989817,
-0.0560520701,
-0.0160840563,
-0.056191165,
-0.0047362037,
-0.022178065,
-0.0350846648,
-0.0022506251,
-0.0344269164,
-0.0745355338,
-0.0024784082,
-0.0315320231,
3.013e-7,
0.0618526079,
0.0463378765,
-0.0061440691,
-0.0020187041,
0.0069028116,
0.0373042822,
0.029392289,
0.056762103,
-0.0816016272,
-0.0075073563,
0.0156079475,
0.0021267172,
0.0452632755,
0.0243053939,
-0.1110374182,
-0.0049572368,
-0.0721811578,
0.0315699466,
-0.0156387426,
0.0546702631,
0.0491581,
0.1162222549,
0.0337381177,
-0.0392679051,
0.0048756269,
-0.0163777098,
0.0187750217,
-0.0308042653,
0.0053259083,
0.0089963935,
0.0131102521,
-0.0023041023,
-0.0022068466,
-0.0138390018,
-0.0268439353,
0.0403050818,
0.0075348127,
0.0471345447,
-0.0006777468,
-0.0083533181,
0.0258916374,
-0.0199398864,
0.0259412508,
-0.007507755,
0.0622675829,
-0.0396149158,
-0.052975975,
-0.0839791,
0.014855884,
0.0188328866,
0.0897709876,
0.0166432299,
-0.0082840938,
-0.0078298189,
-0.0098904129,
-0.0571816303,
-0.0119798705,
-0.1021125093,
0.0302340705,
-0.0010369284,
-0.0229511224,
0.0263418835,
0.0419988632,
0.0269426648,
0.0812360942,
0.0368746966,
0.0067055435,
2.359154714e-34,
0.0460900366,
-0.0231821276,
-0.0243737027,
0.0096879741,
0.0050938795,
0.0179460105,
-0.0310290921,
-0.0043246225,
0.0003436837,
-0.0276813842,
-0.0127481446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07705v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07705v2 | CPET: Effective Parameter-Efficient Tuning for Compressed Large Language Models | 2023-07-15T04:37:11 | 2023-11-15T17:02:17 | Weilin Zhao, Yuxiang Huang, Xu Han, Zhiyuan Liu, Zhengyan Zhang, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Parameter-efficient tuning (PET) has been widely explored in recent years
because it tunes much fewer parameters (PET modules) than full-parameter
fine-tuning (FT) while still stimulating sufficient knowledge from large
language models (LLMs) for downstream tasks. Moreover, when PET is employed to
serve multiple tasks, different task-specific PET modules can be built on a
frozen LLM, avoiding redundant LLM deployments. Although PET significantly
reduces the cost of tuning and deploying LLMs, its inference still suffers from
the computational bottleneck of LLMs. To address the above issue, we propose an
effective PET framework based on compressed LLMs, named "CPET". In CPET, we
evaluate the impact of mainstream LLM compression techniques on PET performance
and then introduce knowledge inheritance and recovery strategies to restore the
knowledge loss caused by these compression techniques. Our experimental results
demonstrate that, owing to the restoring strategies of CPET, collaborating
task-specific PET modules with a compressed LLM can achieve comparable
performance to collaborating PET modules with the original version of the
compressed LLM and outperform directly applying vanilla PET methods to the
compressed LLM. | [
0.0036094352,
0.0879560485,
-0.02699182,
0.0398834683,
-0.022744244,
0.0186082218,
-0.0201872811,
0.014538696,
-0.0568783283,
-0.008985701,
-0.0285778604,
0.0002882301,
0.0143945133,
-0.0164736491,
0.0303324796,
-0.0281159543,
0.044972863,
-0.0362568013,
-0.0365736783,
0.0026386601,
-0.011904249,
0.0127438521,
0.0377292372,
0.0488617048,
0.0097584184,
-0.0063442178,
-0.0116610304,
0.0259023346,
-0.0059348778,
0.0562590398,
0.0021314614,
0.0529106371,
0.0379555933,
0.0244243164,
0.0000021252,
-0.0221115313,
-0.044811029,
0.0160241332,
-0.038265761,
0.0774083436,
0.0822408646,
0.0019914065,
-0.0029007567,
0.0255929399,
-0.010642102,
-0.02286781,
0.0657204241,
0.0147352377,
0.038796369,
0.0671996623,
0.0176422074,
0.0033923923,
-0.0297525264,
-0.0346270166,
-0.0503790863,
-0.0424723104,
0.0038264801,
-0.0076363953,
0.0045538433,
0.0155060021,
0.0010671178,
0.031413544,
0.013378907,
0.020527672,
-0.0509791709,
0.0017246829,
-0.0624258593,
-0.0101331566,
0.0055132792,
0.0127669415,
-0.0511845425,
-0.0808219835,
0.0138119254,
0.0078608599,
-0.0070711873,
-0.0048178947,
-0.0509263314,
0.0378113985,
0.01408152,
0.0111613357,
0.0342169814,
-0.0527381673,
0.0424674861,
0.0043690666,
-0.0079139974,
0.0536202639,
0.0378626473,
0.0106673473,
-0.0558480397,
-0.0208703671,
-0.0576781742,
-0.0330854654,
-0.0091023073,
-0.0045718853,
-0.0038468025,
0.0021513491,
-0.0671284273,
-0.0274983812,
0.0090769017,
-0.0166968536,
0.0659828037,
0.0522649549,
0.0281649008,
0.0201049391,
-0.0320401639,
0.0408446863,
-0.023816593,
-0.0107326992,
-0.0431715064,
-0.0278668217,
-0.052696839,
0.0153305046,
-0.0589089282,
0.025971882,
-0.0133558856,
0.0174230207,
-0.0033430776,
0.0527077019,
0.0216214582,
0.0163412094,
0.0309344865,
-0.0262528211,
-0.0485654585,
-0.0251317341,
0.0332792886,
0.057684999,
-0.0058767935,
-0.001356352,
-0.0187707897,
-0.050846383,
-0.0388587154,
0.0121410945,
0.0144010829,
-0.0202273913,
0.0300708301,
0.0238435604,
-0.000617911,
-0.017782351,
-0.0225707963,
-0.0287073273,
0.0171540827,
-0.0693531558,
-0.025006419,
-0.078884922,
0.0238719173,
0.014144606,
-0.002467873,
-0.0507123582,
-0.0195913594,
-0.0225884952,
-0.0628198534,
0.0389859192,
0.0169860572,
0.0278205555,
-0.0085377283,
0.0262991302,
0.0029559247,
0.1069790497,
0.0108538261,
0.0201976802,
0.0206470564,
-0.0136625832,
-0.0477168374,
0.052766595,
0.0148120513,
0.0277630426,
-0.0217587594,
-0.0005533093,
0.043734245,
-0.0092476625,
0.0413195789,
0.0251884609,
-0.0233550537,
-0.0188830681,
0.0616863035,
0.0161275603,
0.0373418406,
0.0540011041,
0.0222438667,
0.0170681793,
0.013482403,
-0.0030112849,
-0.0586362146,
0.0083686039,
-0.0475244448,
0.0008796463,
0.0144949602,
0.0443756729,
-0.0245646797,
-0.0132715227,
-0.0352824032,
-0.0246015042,
-0.0011067308,
0.023878444,
0.0564777479,
-0.0151897045,
-0.0223349798,
0.0989068821,
0.0337180607,
-0.05186579,
-0.0330406129,
-0.0469404124,
-0.0027863891,
0.0308934618,
0.0488823317,
-0.0383113548,
-0.0473207198,
0.0352046266,
0.0218788777,
-0.0101071894,
0.0363457203,
-0.001303555,
0.0429532342,
-0.0390860811,
-0.0234597493,
-0.0180981904,
0.0322885588,
0.0265134592,
0.051000569,
-0.0044236141,
0.0224063639,
-0.0330981798,
-0.0058219796,
0.0063396199,
-0.0110707451,
0.0051018842,
0.0052543082,
-0.0130259953,
0.0280392915,
-0.0349738002,
-0.0382119827,
-0.009948276,
0.0504162572,
-0.0386107415,
0.0221515913,
-0.004317313,
0.0021892255,
-0.0327429473,
0.0333612561,
0.0177774262,
0.0239637308,
0.0324880145,
-0.0544773936,
-0.0415837988,
0.0595196374,
-0.0147446562,
0.0820042565,
-0.0355254151,
0.0322150625,
-0.0554916337,
0.0108242193,
-0.0175623279,
0.0243624076,
-0.0069502373,
-0.0165692065,
0.0267304126,
-0.011654987,
0.0016910351,
-0.0030208833,
-0.0371237323,
0.0079626152,
0.0105400803,
0.016765194,
0.0201540496,
-0.0046688318,
0.0231194962,
-0.037848752,
-0.0841370523,
0.0502806306,
-0.0263567325,
0.0346776545,
0.0388666764,
0.0318712406,
-0.0131938355,
0.0094857896,
0.0110882409,
0.029100148,
-0.0095685283,
0.0371247269,
-0.0175533053,
0.0014672971,
-0.0294085462,
-0.0266543645,
-0.0271851663,
0.0107345916,
0.0263402686,
-0.063069433,
-0.0194365215,
-0.0923712552,
0.0547836684,
-0.0283226296,
0.0559392497,
-0.016244065,
-0.0513852462,
-0.0231943075,
-0.0396818481,
0.0340006426,
0.0603098534,
-0.0599410161,
-0.0273428112,
0.0666496679,
-0.0075555015,
-0.038183704,
0.0130535439,
-0.0355763845,
-0.0731885731,
-0.0302593466,
-0.008064853,
-0.035606999,
0.0758445412,
-0.0262854025,
-0.0479422957,
-0.0524278954,
-0.0060514668,
-0.0165230632,
-0.0156100551,
-0.0058572339,
-0.0114790564,
0.0247195736,
0.0243687741,
-0.0180371441,
-0.0715204477,
0.0487643667,
-0.0454674214,
-0.0149569446,
-0.0244448818,
-0.0335618667,
-0.0573593304,
0.0676201805,
0.0369249359,
0.0250360388,
0.0151790762,
0.009285124,
-0.0696429014,
0.0437223241,
0.0154043557,
-0.0204751026,
0.041041743,
-0.0492252,
0.0065464093,
-0.031116182,
-0.0419748425,
0.0026590307,
0.008622732,
-0.0109866578,
0.038389843,
0.0499112979,
-0.0400162041,
-0.0213153977,
0.0129036345,
0.0033600817,
0.0374298915,
0.0141185354,
0.0113927359,
-0.0263099223,
-0.0237096399,
0.0235930979,
0.0331821479,
0.0308814328,
-0.0225398876,
-0.0101211118,
0.0407688394,
0.0338497385,
-0.0271716565,
-0.0267231651,
0.0008940343,
0.0424683616,
-0.0248971768,
-0.0437367745,
0.0214457437,
0.0390129089,
-0.0913216844,
0.000753205,
0.1001425385,
0.0285347756,
-0.0334241688,
0.0113113206,
-0.0093599921,
0.0707174987,
0.0196544211,
0.0587074198,
-0.0735360831,
-0.0235466678,
0.0284491535,
0.0009086755,
0.0060878075,
-0.0031122579,
-0.0100977719,
-0.0853178576,
0.0461655855,
0.0275628921,
0.0095110396,
-0.0087753059,
-0.0537365973,
-0.0009867295,
-0.0212698877,
0.0048110578,
0.0294712726,
-0.0121386386,
0.0126115652,
-0.0035590627,
-0.0219138656,
-0.0538885146,
0.0211136434,
-0.0118305003,
0.0534041002,
-0.002694743,
-0.0029303639,
0.0169331804,
-0.0105958953,
0.0067410632,
-0.0039105094,
-0.0064005791,
-0.0528550036,
-0.0171214286,
0.0248889253,
-0.0153878964,
0.0468349829,
0.0089106653,
-0.0354461111,
0.0055502467,
-0.0064613018,
0.0887378156,
-0.0322257727,
-0.0127447536,
-0.0002203377,
-0.049988132,
-0.0198187325,
0.0838409141,
0.0197205152,
0.0110233407,
-0.0274377372,
-0.0003773984,
-0.0838907287,
-0.0034236494,
-0.0251180716,
0.0071573011,
-0.0268968251,
-0.0188768096,
-0.0247848891,
0.0529548749,
0.0299209207,
0.0161899123,
0.0010173733,
0.0457661562,
0.0133892456,
0.0001543705,
-0.1097857654,
0.0078632114,
-0.0521475039,
-0.016668357,
-0.0309504922,
-0.0156766791,
0.0214722622,
0.0009373642,
-0.0013182941,
0.0263333172,
-0.1334769875,
-0.0772466063,
-0.0305813421,
0.0497930273,
0.0228241459,
0.0784832835,
-0.0200840272,
-0.07105048,
0.0072342982,
0.0197801646,
-0.0284591746,
0.0699003711,
0.0129209403,
-0.0547031946,
0.0157659613,
0.0713556856,
-0.0478785373,
-0.0025846136,
0.0132030156,
0.0126456274,
-0.0042086239,
-0.0586780906,
-0.0052812048,
0.0300657954,
-0.0035648672,
-0.0055870642,
-0.01348178,
0.0002375287,
0.0533290617,
-0.0375128798,
-0.0132132778,
-0.0562630035,
0.0211592615,
-0.007535839,
0.0116101597,
0.0128040882,
0.0035066628,
0.0501429439,
0.0448932387,
-0.0205225348,
0.0250254218,
-0.0255678892,
-0.0328532271,
0.0657625273,
0.0078895399,
0.0013107988,
0.0121475412,
0.0009467415,
0.0383174904,
-0.0651840866,
0.0189040452,
0.0071078506,
0.0280172545,
-0.0750554204,
0.0276229493,
-0.0274855364,
-0.0861770213,
-0.0149577549,
0.0367246047,
0.058347486,
-0.0129504772,
0.0727932677,
-0.0443814807,
-0.0310648531,
-0.0328322165,
0.0299940333,
0.0167611409,
0.0167365838,
0.0122595383,
0.0061172871,
-0.0337316953,
0.0298372917,
0.0887763649,
0.0419301912,
0.0630801171,
-0.0166556928,
-0.0278227292,
-0.0100636035,
-0.0339960828,
-0.0075632026,
0.0147443516,
-0.0220434703,
0.0006730893,
-0.0234025139,
-0.0425879732,
-0.0306100901,
0.0054703061,
-0.0169404168,
-0.0212187152,
0.0180914886,
0.0648655295,
0.0059326589,
-0.0384381711,
-0.0344916731,
-0.0092342282,
0.0115302894,
-0.0283759031,
0.0223155227,
-6.788881013e-33,
-0.0370895937,
0.049052652,
0.0122643523,
0.0160116926,
-0.0250032227,
0.019642625,
-0.0300969966,
-0.0045792726,
0.0032180585,
-0.0268443786,
-0.001672939,
-0.009541302,
0.0055670342,
-0.0131059214,
0.0118178101,
0.0156795885,
0.0480025448,
0.0003847058,
-0.0231413115,
0.0283347014,
0.0379554406,
0.0186321475,
0.0766375735,
-0.0152018266,
-0.04879307,
0.0195239652,
0.0264155325,
0.005258562,
0.0002553296,
0.0481400862,
0.011671708,
0.0212169979,
0.0102685085,
-0.0395682901,
-0.0343503878,
-0.0185678694,
-0.063180618,
-0.0132877864,
0.0582049899,
-0.0029859142,
-0.0166445449,
-0.0583873056,
0.0440903455,
0.0234788042,
-0.0089887381,
-0.0191643126,
-0.0192413274,
-0.0366717093,
-0.0166845657,
-0.0220260378,
-0.0392233059,
0.0056205564,
0.0087718023,
0.0020530934,
0.0491191074,
-0.0265167169,
-0.0204063952,
0.028853232,
-0.022821812,
-0.0090954164,
0.025156742,
0.1250213385,
0.0764150992,
0.0047167256,
0.0165739171,
-0.0013567464,
-0.0269745067,
0.0246783309,
-0.0297988653,
0.0406042635,
0.0679647103,
0.0609961562,
0.0238606799,
0.0313042328,
0.012398188,
-0.0080117006,
-0.0712898523,
-0.0026433335,
0.0653905496,
0.0515220948,
0.0150069306,
0.0450689457,
-0.0050290343,
-0.0256280787,
-0.0586082377,
0.0184181426,
-0.0327467695,
-0.0207380764,
0.0096050054,
0.0157508347,
-0.0441907868,
-0.0007789714,
0.0641078651,
-0.0601478592,
0.0026370538,
0.0058674389,
-0.0293991435,
0.0042828703,
0.0132361222,
0.0431369916,
-0.0682379454,
-0.0539311431,
0.0229969919,
-0.0368861072,
0.0245825406,
-0.0168976616,
0.0333888121,
0.0728219599,
-0.0419818126,
0.0050739353,
-0.0504389443,
-0.0013946717,
0.0010559559,
0.0350525975,
0.0293647572,
0.0134844854,
0.0291901715,
-0.0186680164,
0.0235208068,
-0.008840207,
-0.030888794,
0.0047886879,
0.0440854467,
-0.0009067495,
0.0019271951,
0.0069298707,
-0.0538224913,
-0.0236871522,
0.034135811,
-0.0431039408,
-0.0423168838,
0.0141690029,
2.92e-7,
0.0389325768,
0.04793147,
-0.0189361759,
0.010887403,
0.0520273484,
0.004371779,
-0.0175898466,
0.014068054,
0.0140167391,
-0.0116712311,
0.0320809446,
0.0387940183,
0.0644430071,
0.0131504601,
-0.0702779144,
0.0147640156,
-0.0192240607,
-0.000600406,
-0.0543839633,
-0.0392351523,
-0.0009615842,
0.1247067824,
0.0386382453,
-0.0069490839,
0.002497379,
-0.0147628607,
0.0406309366,
-0.0308307428,
-0.0240741856,
0.0327412076,
0.008292607,
0.0450156517,
-0.0146419061,
-0.0001730545,
-0.0242288969,
0.0218567047,
-0.0321110785,
0.095002681,
0.0019031644,
0.0005977892,
0.0359702408,
-0.0572701879,
-0.0328172781,
-0.0624788292,
0.0901901424,
-0.0165439155,
-0.0177253429,
-0.039704334,
0.0168088246,
-0.0110365218,
-0.0290643964,
-0.0012422756,
0.0081105363,
0.0411551222,
0.0185080245,
-0.0209650099,
-0.0337951481,
-0.072292909,
-0.0407627597,
0.0301593915,
-0.046569556,
-0.0708284304,
-0.03183759,
-0.0295912083,
0.012415044,
-0.055754181,
-0.0037293292,
3.42625494e-34,
0.0270072259,
-0.0170703102,
0.0293350592,
0.0205464195,
0.031447079,
-0.0302926768,
-0.0364270546,
0.0185850486,
-0.0190786943,
-0.0904395506,
-0.0263314489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07699v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07699v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models to Generate Answer Set Programs | 2023-07-15T03:40:55 | 2023-07-15T03:40:55 | Adam Ishay, Zhun Yang, Joohyung Lee | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SC | Large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-3 and GPT-4, have demonstrated
exceptional performance in various natural language processing tasks and have
shown the ability to solve certain reasoning problems. However, their reasoning
capabilities are limited and relatively shallow, despite the application of
various prompting techniques. In contrast, formal logic is adept at handling
complex reasoning, but translating natural language descriptions into formal
logic is a challenging task that non-experts struggle with. This paper proposes
a neuro-symbolic method that combines the strengths of large language models
and answer set programming. Specifically, we employ an LLM to transform natural
language descriptions of logic puzzles into answer set programs. We carefully
design prompts for an LLM to convert natural language descriptions into answer
set programs in a step by step manner. Surprisingly, with just a few in-context
learning examples, LLMs can generate reasonably complex answer set programs.
The majority of errors made are relatively simple and can be easily corrected
by humans, thus enabling LLMs to effectively assist in the creation of answer
set programs. | [
0.0434466749,
0.0766069368,
-0.0383707061,
0.036434453,
-0.071004957,
0.0151020223,
-0.0014630598,
0.0087976241,
0.0222539399,
-0.0350105464,
0.0459704809,
0.016369788,
-0.0299463794,
0.0690991879,
0.0105254538,
-0.0291408505,
0.04989665,
-0.0484403223,
0.0377361812,
-0.0161010418,
-0.0335296988,
0.0484369025,
-0.004360762,
0.0074869916,
-0.0092981765,
-0.0366662629,
-0.0491147637,
-0.0263226405,
-0.0109413881,
-0.0305688586,
-0.0372034349,
0.0436065309,
0.0193463974,
0.0124278804,
0.0000020141,
-0.0390579775,
0.0191118531,
0.0020240012,
-0.0229357369,
-0.0169176254,
-0.0187650919,
0.0124376779,
0.0241886247,
0.0313875638,
-0.0355710238,
-0.004440282,
0.0438489318,
0.0431721136,
0.0943869874,
0.0698791668,
0.0031342714,
-0.0411696248,
0.0491776578,
-0.0006205671,
0.0592304245,
-0.0350551605,
0.0235844646,
0.0102142114,
0.0448780917,
-0.0149789024,
-0.0043722591,
0.0102987979,
0.0653985888,
-0.0085311821,
-0.0347993039,
0.0120476931,
-0.0199366882,
0.0204963814,
-0.0320507437,
0.0419426374,
-0.0055148238,
-0.0159918703,
-0.0353561118,
-0.0114454078,
0.0275636781,
0.0148384413,
-0.0324678682,
0.0627522096,
-0.0364560746,
-0.0003553985,
0.0240257271,
-0.0129294973,
0.0060988986,
0.002240258,
-0.0346675962,
0.0821062699,
0.0271264762,
-0.0108716143,
0.0158385485,
-0.0230600033,
-0.0511437133,
-0.0564850494,
0.0385329314,
0.076209709,
-0.0448951013,
0.0310884733,
-0.0256318506,
0.0028558909,
0.0130063128,
-0.0039453427,
0.0451418795,
0.0632811338,
0.0305419937,
0.0368365757,
-0.0367766283,
0.0393243842,
-0.0187926963,
0.0365754627,
-0.0760575011,
-0.028353449,
-0.0638449937,
-0.0331017151,
-0.0521654412,
0.05509381,
-0.0290106516,
-0.007042822,
-0.0092054205,
0.020225171,
-0.0078548966,
0.0163051784,
-0.0000140754,
0.0403732732,
0.0012564402,
-0.0243421942,
-0.0731116384,
0.0227666851,
-0.0782769769,
0.0178742651,
0.0031921086,
-0.0198340379,
-0.0113362409,
-0.0051556421,
0.0050272467,
-0.0401311144,
0.047236044,
0.0882508084,
-0.0040158252,
0.0060367077,
-0.0368978605,
-0.0334445722,
0.0158396177,
-0.0754936188,
0.018352259,
-0.0840510949,
0.0444430709,
0.0104431966,
-0.0291383825,
-0.0517517366,
0.013145905,
0.0503037237,
0.0123205055,
0.0693290681,
-0.0053661414,
0.0039139786,
0.0341068879,
-0.008799362,
0.0105645284,
0.0327823833,
0.0409166925,
0.0204227567,
-0.0042905095,
-0.0224732086,
0.0021755162,
0.0262385048,
0.0331986994,
-0.0003420588,
-0.0376061425,
0.043887198,
0.0038229665,
0.0406337231,
-0.0378419831,
0.0506099947,
0.0125482827,
-0.0421732105,
0.0218071509,
0.0670604631,
0.0039800755,
0.00808952,
0.0110597685,
-0.0579067506,
0.0284629669,
-0.0278987437,
-0.0575968921,
0.0582335144,
-0.0443199612,
0.0149101829,
-0.0361834317,
0.0446822755,
-0.0240085255,
-0.0308627319,
0.0145136099,
0.0282080974,
0.0207739118,
0.0303913578,
0.0262801237,
0.0114397779,
-0.0160841234,
0.0359587222,
-0.0126964236,
-0.0128211137,
-0.0073481523,
-0.0686215311,
0.0683588013,
0.0303124692,
0.041168604,
-0.0402985662,
-0.0076792939,
-0.0307113081,
-0.0017635914,
0.0497790985,
-0.0041867513,
0.0014445818,
-0.0317225568,
-0.0046956125,
-0.0011676911,
-0.0274958424,
-0.0008862767,
0.0329868868,
0.0419429019,
0.0014955365,
-0.009894127,
-0.0166125055,
0.0102002453,
0.036276035,
-0.0174199101,
-0.0217202939,
0.0104200635,
-0.0031009149,
0.0300902631,
0.0272058733,
0.0197116286,
0.049940154,
0.0100447433,
-0.0297577381,
-0.0592297241,
-0.0323424861,
-0.0374775939,
-0.0163675472,
0.0749733523,
-0.045711074,
-0.0357876234,
0.0373022929,
-0.0656864271,
-0.0480070226,
0.0280813985,
-0.0586406253,
-0.0151624177,
-0.0246659033,
-0.0411196947,
0.0473989137,
-0.0368687697,
-0.0334302783,
0.0805526823,
0.0275902301,
-0.0011150684,
0.0067937742,
0.0051368666,
0.0334458835,
-0.058744885,
0.0067794947,
0.0368998609,
-0.0129885618,
-0.0070045209,
0.0135283209,
0.0337543003,
-0.0353285372,
-0.019538682,
-0.0346568339,
0.0185284372,
0.0240130462,
0.0209093001,
0.0099699153,
-0.0057266094,
-0.0070944335,
-0.0115726795,
-0.0772061944,
0.0105117904,
0.0417999327,
0.0106335692,
0.0134564368,
0.0047187177,
-0.0232976489,
0.0106228963,
-0.039591033,
-0.0566286221,
0.0285130609,
0.0195814334,
0.0329101235,
-0.0606011935,
0.0247714128,
-0.0373444371,
0.0321029387,
0.0375676788,
-0.0131608509,
0.0496025495,
-0.0275605749,
-0.0294542797,
0.0720603541,
-0.001631854,
0.018107228,
0.0503865965,
-0.0245742314,
-0.0244276784,
0.0375822708,
-0.0234353337,
-0.0295428187,
0.0096177179,
-0.0605294742,
-0.035948623,
0.0308964755,
0.0457382128,
0.0010448126,
-0.0481471457,
0.0792622641,
0.0365550332,
-0.0095943986,
-0.073085092,
-0.0224606879,
0.006598189,
0.0671216026,
-0.0008133318,
-0.023054149,
0.1018954962,
0.0194413457,
0.0146824894,
-0.0579519644,
-0.0164637323,
-0.0487621538,
0.1008296609,
0.0014002234,
0.0175309442,
0.0241815485,
-0.0210106038,
-0.0457036868,
-0.0432592593,
0.0126448162,
-0.0304022096,
0.0278089475,
-0.0601633079,
0.0010045961,
-0.01483176,
-0.0150186028,
-0.0289569497,
-0.0121500203,
-0.0541847423,
0.0185343586,
-0.0240504313,
-0.02707888,
-0.0130720511,
0.0026895585,
0.0182402451,
0.0030948259,
-0.0123922694,
-0.0101286126,
-0.0416725986,
0.0147403143,
0.0470283628,
0.0570457987,
-0.0031361254,
-0.0046003181,
-0.0000326712,
0.0335186198,
0.015355505,
0.0171347149,
-0.0334045961,
0.0360847972,
-0.0105075808,
-0.0453916043,
0.0331346802,
0.0379685648,
-0.0081935208,
-0.0649076551,
-0.0114407614,
0.0797860697,
0.0480304174,
0.011508367,
-0.0012709377,
-0.0401547514,
-0.0013176556,
0.0231972951,
0.0625504404,
-0.0971554592,
-0.0438705757,
-0.0024333217,
-0.0158948377,
-0.0022448986,
-0.0295981392,
-0.0229883641,
-0.1331141442,
0.0428972431,
0.0172382183,
-0.0618778355,
-0.0322173014,
-0.0159565266,
-0.0179784279,
0.0062597948,
-0.032845851,
0.0134388097,
-0.0113737658,
0.0104345512,
-0.026469769,
0.0381433107,
0.0312710516,
0.0763816684,
-0.0035086679,
0.036303442,
0.047139924,
-0.0002477349,
-0.0311752688,
-0.0150562925,
0.0236764681,
-0.0180897005,
0.015510398,
-0.0268317815,
0.0085154921,
0.0176725835,
-0.0133361146,
-0.0291884113,
0.0345638879,
-0.0655132309,
-0.0452147834,
0.0493689254,
0.107797727,
-0.0195806269,
0.0019017142,
-0.0512638129,
0.0053057726,
-0.0139260665,
0.0588706918,
0.0090561006,
-0.0210122634,
-0.0414583646,
-0.0612762384,
-0.0305933766,
-0.028196454,
-0.0200584978,
0.0146130407,
0.0190757923,
0.0292132273,
-0.0200987607,
-0.0182071701,
0.0586891845,
0.0136839831,
0.0164681971,
-0.0104213208,
0.0174924303,
0.0066694771,
-0.0182494018,
0.0216698386,
-0.0307833552,
0.0383396856,
-0.0082270345,
0.0071900026,
-0.0219885446,
-0.0413847454,
-0.0331258588,
0.0127153518,
-0.0161170978,
-0.0350091904,
-0.030432051,
0.0514980331,
0.0314689167,
-0.0188230425,
-0.0094495863,
-0.0000530492,
-0.0033945483,
0.0371418744,
-0.0133102369,
-0.0120956022,
-0.0121010887,
0.0256988071,
-0.0032612598,
0.003329796,
-0.0194024034,
0.0110823093,
0.0056692716,
0.0647577494,
-0.0210171062,
-0.0327096432,
0.0533958673,
0.0586584881,
-0.029976733,
0.0107827038,
-0.0067295115,
-0.0134378122,
0.0049298778,
-0.0494348966,
-0.0203724187,
-0.0217539128,
-0.0111465789,
0.0172275938,
-0.0378888622,
0.0214030705,
-0.0505115241,
0.0000941597,
-0.0085190171,
0.0096925478,
-0.0049133399,
0.0361994915,
0.0074142655,
-0.0149859991,
-0.0160785466,
-0.015999997,
-0.0013080228,
-0.0175907519,
0.0489445031,
-0.0105723608,
0.0664844587,
0.0422896408,
-0.0154037494,
-0.059628401,
-0.0126075996,
-0.047990188,
-0.0601216927,
0.0090882732,
0.019126026,
0.0446860865,
0.0323359519,
-0.0264600236,
-0.0521905981,
-0.0208458919,
0.0111421775,
0.0136781111,
0.0309575573,
-0.0074659986,
0.0778769031,
0.0374833904,
0.0253562015,
-0.0908863842,
0.0195052978,
0.0069343965,
0.0247578621,
0.0245592427,
-0.0141830547,
-0.0335414298,
-0.0211438034,
-0.0151109044,
-0.0111435624,
-0.011839442,
0.012578507,
-0.0496695153,
-0.0740227103,
-0.0096199522,
0.0650223196,
0.0189080462,
0.0145217143,
0.0376634337,
0.0242009871,
0.0334212258,
-0.0937473625,
0.0008503702,
0.056413196,
-0.0547326207,
-0.0485605635,
-0.0420034677,
-5.777614611e-33,
-0.0648696795,
-0.0657833368,
0.0401478894,
0.007106992,
0.0262852944,
-0.0641275719,
-0.0407837182,
-0.0052091298,
-0.0153397238,
0.0099143181,
-0.0240774937,
0.0156987011,
-0.0015217289,
0.0101161525,
0.030093519,
-0.0262562186,
-0.0102433804,
-0.0184838008,
-0.0219818633,
0.0043084403,
0.0132400626,
-0.0472386554,
0.0339150392,
-0.0546949059,
-0.0177110638,
0.0139150834,
-0.0104498854,
0.0592178926,
-0.1015730575,
0.0237858351,
-0.0188229252,
0.0430286191,
0.016745301,
-0.0201036353,
0.0219869278,
0.0377986282,
-0.0452226326,
-0.0773156434,
0.0678646788,
-0.0327406563,
-0.0472151339,
-0.0478253327,
0.0223502796,
-0.0099438969,
0.0143026924,
-0.0269038212,
0.031298019,
-0.0426447652,
0.0305183921,
0.0033185973,
-0.0538326204,
-0.0272583291,
-0.0120216012,
-0.014187187,
-0.039086476,
0.0044649774,
-0.0173950847,
-0.013444961,
0.0052132313,
-0.004470699,
0.0721391365,
-0.0046116835,
0.0228315145,
-0.0039758389,
-0.011903381,
0.0203694571,
0.0279679,
-0.0380390994,
-0.0450549312,
0.0236866344,
-0.0066921655,
0.0619005151,
0.0848992616,
0.0371875763,
0.0411192961,
0.0400811359,
-0.0765138939,
0.0296559408,
-0.0109607466,
0.0907966867,
0.0399718583,
-0.0005840326,
0.009473566,
-0.0018249158,
-0.0476357713,
0.0335545987,
-0.0586913414,
-0.0239916015,
0.0320921466,
-0.038782604,
-0.0162544549,
-0.0337490737,
0.0145156141,
-0.0363482013,
0.0056273122,
0.0365981162,
0.0266739167,
0.0143389646,
-0.0068085957,
0.0267385542,
-0.0193702076,
-0.0097126085,
0.0043933154,
-0.0129692601,
0.0268830936,
-0.0017559467,
-0.0101234578,
0.0377491973,
-0.0445317924,
0.0091067916,
-0.0453116074,
0.0227564778,
-0.0017605654,
-0.0301394686,
0.0016586406,
0.0163686145,
0.001734562,
-0.0170638226,
-0.032164868,
-0.0484892018,
-0.0338364244,
0.0171172936,
0.0383031294,
0.0200555921,
-0.0017025158,
0.0262609962,
-0.0412652679,
0.0092645995,
0.0162217375,
-0.0197493508,
0.0069568995,
0.0337218307,
2.661e-7,
0.0495807342,
0.0206717905,
0.0528554879,
0.1212386265,
0.0296945367,
0.0309789535,
-0.0019935051,
0.0071338746,
0.0451012366,
-0.0292941406,
-0.0162156578,
0.0602676421,
0.013240586,
0.0547246151,
-0.0234221499,
0.0320359282,
-0.0271620341,
-0.0157676004,
-0.0666610673,
0.0433939397,
0.121303007,
0.0580187775,
0.0280517191,
-0.013879166,
-0.0166188851,
-0.0480601043,
0.0256790929,
-0.0188090671,
0.0091509344,
-0.0123297293,
-0.0144835021,
0.0034207406,
0.0269961599,
0.067402713,
0.0415968075,
-0.0105698192,
0.0085582798,
0.0450690202,
-0.0207499806,
-0.0178657509,
-0.0568136275,
-0.0288401786,
-0.0079434989,
-0.0557184219,
0.0580654703,
-0.074018009,
-0.0368477106,
-0.0232495591,
-0.016365828,
-0.0494166054,
0.0043220823,
-0.0206121039,
0.0060381778,
-0.0168544836,
0.002109762,
0.0104771014,
0.007981129,
-0.031514015,
-0.0127966385,
0.0330142975,
-0.0399597436,
-0.0036281261,
-0.0380955748,
0.0206087194,
0.0254928172,
-0.0691715032,
-0.016592972,
2.329782278e-34,
0.0368054695,
-0.0052204011,
0.0179547369,
0.0198618639,
0.0529634394,
0.0038990795,
-0.0365866385,
0.0077590179,
0.0207413714,
-0.0966961607,
-0.0434919633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07697v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07697v6 | Think-on-Graph: Deep and Responsible Reasoning of Large Language Model on Knowledge Graph | 2023-07-15T03:31:38 | 2024-03-24T06:42:47 | Jiashuo Sun, Chengjin Xu, Lumingyuan Tang, Saizhuo Wang, Chen Lin, Yeyun Gong, Lionel M. Ni, Heung-Yeung Shum, Jian Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although large language models (LLMs) have achieved significant success in
various tasks, they often struggle with hallucination problems, especially in
scenarios requiring deep and responsible reasoning. These issues could be
partially addressed by introducing external knowledge graphs (KG) in LLM
reasoning. In this paper, we propose a new LLM-KG integrating paradigm
``$\hbox{LLM}\otimes\hbox{KG}$'' which treats the LLM as an agent to
interactively explore related entities and relations on KGs and perform
reasoning based on the retrieved knowledge. We further implement this paradigm
by introducing a new approach called Think-on-Graph (ToG), in which the LLM
agent iteratively executes beam search on KG, discovers the most promising
reasoning paths, and returns the most likely reasoning results. We use a number
of well-designed experiments to examine and illustrate the following advantages
of ToG: 1) compared with LLMs, ToG has better deep reasoning power; 2) ToG has
the ability of knowledge traceability and knowledge correctability by
leveraging LLMs reasoning and expert feedback; 3) ToG provides a flexible
plug-and-play framework for different LLMs, KGs and prompting strategies
without any additional training cost; 4) the performance of ToG with small LLM
models could exceed large LLM such as GPT-4 in certain scenarios and this
reduces the cost of LLM deployment and application. As a training-free method
with lower computational cost and better generality, ToG achieves overall SOTA
in 6 out of 9 datasets where most previous SOTAs rely on additional training. | [
0.0519431122,
0.0013178176,
0.0081545943,
0.0606741011,
-0.0589895472,
0.0187939126,
-0.0003980917,
-0.0067168656,
0.0896162018,
-0.0241932273,
-0.0006423275,
0.0101372553,
-0.0445499569,
0.045561444,
0.0079294248,
-0.0047379551,
0.0264191926,
-0.0564315394,
0.0349573903,
-0.0293617826,
-0.0169505998,
0.0398117639,
-0.025280105,
0.008779631,
-0.0376903899,
-0.016164884,
-0.0265152678,
0.0073291562,
0.0094624972,
-0.0292232241,
-0.0210098792,
0.0036498362,
0.0269330423,
0.062981084,
0.0000022528,
-0.0530406609,
-0.04586998,
0.0062808651,
-0.0466026701,
-0.0340363905,
-0.016173495,
0.0162824057,
0.0026823287,
0.0211457089,
-0.0430600606,
0.011082625,
0.017449623,
0.0706306323,
0.0616571009,
0.0618598983,
-0.0009325867,
-0.0618386157,
0.0250683986,
-0.0010010845,
0.0309495423,
-0.0383061506,
0.031877622,
0.0286318995,
0.0087019373,
-0.0135224825,
-0.0231754482,
0.0610917173,
0.0249721818,
-0.0167353917,
-0.0000629168,
0.0315987803,
-0.0455460809,
0.0054643843,
0.0123989237,
0.0995230079,
-0.0119507266,
-0.0249250457,
0.0023449487,
-0.0061617191,
-0.0068901209,
0.0336510018,
-0.030843474,
0.0055118832,
-0.0276153572,
0.0143989902,
0.0253497697,
-0.0382802635,
0.0527749397,
0.017113721,
-0.0509458818,
0.1389903128,
-0.0008032983,
-0.0141536351,
0.0409982689,
0.0097117489,
-0.0312269125,
-0.0424545221,
0.0331169777,
0.0591186769,
-0.0446433946,
0.0495983548,
0.0061928597,
0.026361065,
-0.0154010216,
-0.038709037,
-0.0108703924,
0.0297710374,
-0.0113034658,
0.0815738738,
-0.0510555357,
0.0241995044,
-0.0485159308,
0.0666573122,
-0.0278634112,
-0.0568463616,
-0.071335122,
-0.0207201093,
-0.0327464901,
0.0578926019,
0.0057812836,
-0.0470689423,
0.0012945386,
0.0352613628,
-0.017995147,
0.035427358,
0.0290211141,
0.0248991735,
0.054697901,
-0.0387259796,
-0.0685154945,
0.0401123464,
-0.0218190905,
-0.0049344143,
-0.0063261571,
-0.0208939668,
0.0020607861,
0.0076045305,
0.0176003724,
-0.0107650422,
0.0279468969,
0.0553885885,
0.0304853395,
-0.0081829084,
-0.0333405174,
-0.0552722961,
-0.0026327719,
-0.0845989808,
0.0406943858,
-0.0970906392,
0.0270653106,
0.0187941752,
-0.0182960853,
-0.0397107378,
0.0409005359,
0.0078525292,
-0.0523052365,
0.0784505755,
-0.0372100621,
0.0222586244,
0.0180341918,
0.0056601525,
-0.0356938839,
0.0453207269,
0.0122997742,
0.0131839626,
0.0222252924,
0.0103288284,
0.0081645111,
0.0328030922,
0.0319231078,
-0.0064109261,
-0.0101295281,
0.0101922462,
-0.035470549,
0.0312186349,
-0.0148027735,
0.0640458092,
-0.0140386084,
0.0205709822,
0.0225094464,
0.0547861569,
0.0092445165,
-0.0177014675,
0.0343197733,
0.0244674124,
-0.0042294739,
-0.0097602401,
-0.0539610907,
0.0506896973,
-0.0314647444,
-0.0005837367,
-0.0009320621,
-0.0128990207,
-0.0159845781,
-0.0122729708,
-0.0208610892,
0.0095600728,
0.0164192338,
0.0494972803,
0.0595823154,
0.0018721924,
-0.0507694371,
0.0853640884,
0.0228158105,
0.0010252781,
-0.015976835,
-0.0408605151,
0.0155217871,
0.0895753652,
0.0714590624,
-0.0183046386,
-0.0345420465,
0.0019321642,
-0.0277093071,
0.0318017006,
0.0312687941,
-0.0049126609,
-0.0440702811,
-0.0561419986,
-0.0254962761,
-0.0107610337,
0.0024131774,
0.0224428773,
0.010581159,
0.0082288757,
0.0007200123,
-0.0265726112,
-0.0239237677,
0.0083014304,
0.0146089764,
0.0222094953,
-0.0241899416,
0.0181871299,
-0.0011059468,
0.0354041643,
0.018505957,
0.0188212022,
0.0153670637,
-0.0099686533,
-0.053282313,
0.0100927586,
-0.0407717638,
-0.0683911815,
0.0510687418,
-0.0115936426,
-0.0118632372,
-0.0267899074,
-0.0346810669,
-0.0582315587,
0.0204027593,
-0.0404023081,
0.0593667813,
-0.0406981893,
-0.001581109,
0.0125390301,
-0.0223108865,
0.0065869112,
0.1035317257,
0.0006573703,
-0.0077512139,
0.0051553156,
0.0134400101,
0.0218130313,
-0.0258872043,
-0.0295002013,
0.0210362095,
0.0017261567,
-0.0119106667,
-0.0041551311,
-0.0110360729,
-0.0634786859,
0.0138445264,
-0.0916139185,
0.0174694695,
0.0068602101,
-0.0008111299,
-0.0092291711,
-0.0124909235,
0.0086327456,
-0.0144919418,
-0.0438439138,
0.0391805544,
0.0183889307,
0.0039608097,
-0.0004053743,
-0.0083122272,
-0.0122176306,
0.0007254392,
-0.0122851739,
-0.0359671451,
0.018365711,
0.0149578433,
-0.0426500626,
-0.0435699895,
0.0683981255,
-0.0912533477,
0.0484449081,
-0.0080415932,
-0.015802661,
0.0335528851,
-0.0365272239,
0.0081584137,
0.0640895367,
-0.029123215,
-0.015168325,
0.0595015995,
-0.0374704301,
-0.060803365,
0.0283460673,
-0.0150178848,
0.00603397,
-0.021051392,
0.0152310021,
-0.0555346608,
0.0132807577,
0.0043893368,
-0.0092196707,
-0.0550847091,
-0.0075090178,
-0.0057116146,
0.0122544784,
-0.0249963496,
-0.0200872142,
0.005288213,
0.0343621597,
-0.0231691413,
0.0020798687,
0.0948453099,
-0.0085995272,
-0.0044585406,
-0.0058948798,
0.0096243657,
-0.0447308384,
0.073075816,
0.0039578993,
0.0105048502,
-0.0351631902,
-0.0219074823,
-0.0353298485,
-0.007873401,
0.0213567335,
-0.0432417765,
0.0443507433,
-0.0316174217,
0.0411868095,
0.0189735405,
0.0057286774,
-0.0497197099,
0.0246333778,
-0.061877273,
0.0160267949,
-0.022116486,
-0.0057922932,
-0.0054622255,
0.0125983348,
0.0210907627,
0.0154359825,
0.0006262801,
0.0063952478,
-0.0416817218,
0.0112227844,
0.0474869572,
-0.0132644465,
0.0277470592,
0.0114335082,
0.0580115765,
0.0525464453,
0.0041920603,
-0.0434958674,
-0.0236203577,
-0.0020188275,
-0.0125210127,
-0.0077740676,
-0.0361452438,
-0.0297785457,
0.0588873662,
-0.0819578394,
0.0125272973,
0.1005678251,
0.0307016429,
-0.0359138474,
-0.017366549,
-0.0077607334,
-0.009285423,
0.0380714312,
0.0216047578,
-0.106117554,
-0.0374599211,
0.0137943486,
-0.007022582,
0.0094157588,
-0.0739665255,
-0.0234503858,
-0.1219267324,
0.0245404057,
0.0014722117,
0.0243601725,
-0.0263291467,
-0.0170191377,
-0.0031207632,
0.0255527198,
-0.0371663198,
0.0003988945,
0.0224430449,
-0.0178335514,
-0.0096322093,
-0.0016858161,
-0.0162933059,
0.0600890107,
-0.0395074785,
0.048636321,
0.017806083,
0.0316407792,
0.0287303161,
-0.0192474965,
0.014259439,
0.0259466693,
0.0155095253,
-0.023821909,
0.0245071761,
0.0104619768,
-0.0137428641,
-0.0360037945,
0.0134230331,
-0.0503521189,
0.0010837023,
-0.0188280419,
0.1204673648,
-0.0353830084,
-0.0312160999,
0.0074378941,
-0.006288473,
-0.0136063201,
0.0734830201,
-0.0085087018,
0.0447013527,
-0.0457194075,
-0.0474613383,
-0.0037047048,
-0.0316853337,
-0.0483338423,
0.0401595831,
0.0195122994,
0.024449829,
-0.043554049,
-0.0197653361,
0.049319353,
0.015792165,
-0.0086173322,
0.0346717685,
0.0029935017,
0.0065384666,
-0.0444322899,
0.0302088298,
-0.0589327402,
0.0394608527,
0.0169268101,
-0.0035202384,
0.0342290439,
-0.0137564689,
-0.0139019471,
0.0297416598,
-0.061660111,
-0.0726052225,
-0.0318730325,
0.0056836917,
0.0227029845,
0.0589420684,
-0.0507834181,
-0.0159275178,
0.0706416816,
0.0278385654,
-0.0707812607,
-0.0265170746,
0.0145851457,
0.0084400233,
0.0027116218,
0.0416503027,
-0.0601639524,
-0.0145411361,
0.0069038509,
0.0534967668,
-0.0334878005,
-0.007999341,
0.0201731138,
0.0501136556,
-0.0173426066,
0.0148744574,
-0.010216238,
-0.0470163897,
0.0175378714,
-0.0101586096,
-0.0338239707,
-0.0379999317,
0.0329164341,
0.0034571425,
-0.0229306724,
0.0133365067,
-0.049377054,
0.0199281536,
0.0019097428,
0.0175695475,
-0.0180573259,
0.0222476497,
-0.0060331444,
0.0545037501,
0.0021020027,
-0.0141411116,
0.0351673961,
0.0157159958,
0.0386552066,
-0.0265086815,
0.0700272173,
0.0342471972,
-0.0375114121,
-0.0243649986,
-0.0054343692,
-0.0311297141,
-0.1107563749,
0.0362090208,
0.0597892106,
0.0751712844,
0.0313220546,
0.0031171946,
-0.0351962559,
0.0043548974,
0.0215095636,
0.0056366804,
0.0057474626,
-0.0482477881,
0.042093724,
0.0402356982,
0.007806933,
0.0000419455,
0.0369844027,
-0.009052177,
0.0469981283,
0.0031809607,
-0.031844303,
-0.040079236,
-0.0417741351,
-0.0254224483,
0.0309853349,
-0.0265799426,
0.0218804106,
-0.0289387517,
-0.0939784274,
-0.0291490741,
-0.0172550846,
-0.0499557145,
0.0063496865,
0.0376576222,
0.043638289,
0.0241969861,
-0.0456300899,
-0.025917707,
0.0060980828,
-0.0279624909,
-0.0089886477,
0.0105487928,
-6.567409062e-33,
-0.0180739872,
-0.0526282564,
0.0575642027,
0.0106803738,
-0.0372984745,
-0.016774958,
-0.053121727,
0.0038906608,
-0.0539998449,
0.0122033283,
-0.0086779809,
0.0350355916,
0.0059599536,
0.0061649308,
-0.01033678,
-0.0329037309,
-0.0099562332,
0.0137043912,
0.0079338159,
0.0312716775,
0.0514180027,
0.0192649607,
0.0614680052,
-0.0418216139,
0.0242289789,
0.0017133701,
0.004928153,
0.0518897772,
-0.0499286465,
0.0417909585,
-0.0247073006,
0.0330329612,
0.0271798354,
-0.0131295472,
0.0070248544,
-0.0024848932,
-0.0718357638,
-0.0530422479,
0.0256706569,
0.033300776,
-0.0247028656,
-0.0257601775,
0.0355811678,
-0.0078291586,
0.0404310711,
-0.0150994202,
0.0312586874,
-0.0087690577,
0.0014207851,
0.0252791066,
-0.0254749134,
0.0222057309,
0.0008668876,
-0.0048384345,
0.0297516715,
-0.0116336644,
0.0141888326,
-0.0267801546,
-0.0958505347,
0.0249128118,
-0.0277994405,
-0.0223609544,
0.0511582866,
-0.0104499608,
0.0093307681,
0.0319343247,
-0.0046950737,
-0.0244107563,
-0.0556972995,
-0.0178033113,
0.0226236824,
0.0888179615,
0.033753071,
-0.0187230352,
-0.0114774751,
0.012570573,
-0.071089603,
-0.0171901677,
0.0236873273,
0.0547938943,
0.0313797966,
0.0237800237,
-0.0417061262,
-0.0361879356,
-0.0223382227,
-0.0039864918,
-0.0444133766,
-0.0378907844,
0.0158346631,
-0.0164907761,
-0.0070023318,
-0.0065478329,
0.0196586493,
-0.0731131807,
-0.0007842063,
0.0638117567,
-0.0044543943,
0.017504815,
-0.0173521731,
0.056831453,
-0.0640006065,
-0.0128614921,
0.0000796071,
-0.0391107053,
-0.00422495,
0.0251207035,
0.0140216025,
0.0227535218,
-0.0313131437,
0.0006292161,
-0.0762637779,
0.0003199428,
-0.0184865855,
-0.0260238275,
0.0390694216,
0.0438725911,
-0.0003716686,
0.0306863952,
0.0388623103,
0.0264824349,
-0.0060382895,
0.0294209365,
-0.0136247883,
0.0067210416,
-0.0321293101,
-0.0021175675,
-0.0522749051,
-0.0197787695,
0.005567519,
-0.0473497212,
-0.0019280601,
0.0295136794,
3.055e-7,
0.0218411516,
0.0312230419,
0.0048429375,
0.063318722,
0.0170323718,
0.0250814017,
0.0030779787,
-0.0246992186,
0.0206969809,
-0.0531627946,
0.020366028,
0.0775410533,
0.0022007085,
0.0384477675,
-0.0887456164,
0.013898016,
-0.017454654,
-0.057469558,
-0.0672277287,
-0.0142911831,
0.0393929593,
0.0638578236,
0.0593634509,
-0.0287300237,
-0.0071799513,
-0.0748012364,
0.0384893455,
0.0245530382,
0.0033449016,
0.0036776951,
0.0200518984,
0.0446993783,
-0.0340664238,
0.0713140443,
0.032977663,
0.0108622964,
-0.0066357339,
-0.0059107435,
-0.001217511,
-0.045816496,
-0.0250964202,
-0.060470026,
0.0056116292,
-0.0799874514,
0.0997463688,
-0.0127261924,
-0.0276406985,
0.0319155306,
0.0016006349,
-0.05471633,
-0.0330585279,
-0.000366816,
0.011820673,
0.0118151065,
0.0094526615,
-0.0288460534,
-0.004112436,
-0.0854435563,
0.0187988486,
-0.0286336821,
-0.0274832938,
-0.0318921134,
-0.0083394917,
-0.0007247656,
0.007071197,
-0.0392497256,
0.0169836245,
2.929675846e-34,
0.028885765,
0.0221735369,
0.0008225056,
0.0089796921,
0.0477969311,
-0.0034323053,
-0.0278790817,
0.0105718318,
0.0251995753,
-0.1089314967,
-0.0353608131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07696v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07696v1 | Coupling Large Language Models with Logic Programming for Robust and General Reasoning from Text | 2023-07-15T03:29:59 | 2023-07-15T03:29:59 | Zhun Yang, Adam Ishay, Joohyung Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SC | While large language models (LLMs), such as GPT-3, appear to be robust and
general, their reasoning ability is not at a level to compete with the best
models trained for specific natural language reasoning problems. In this study,
we observe that a large language model can serve as a highly effective few-shot
semantic parser. It can convert natural language sentences into a logical form
that serves as input for answer set programs, a logic-based declarative
knowledge representation formalism. The combination results in a robust and
general system that can handle multiple question-answering tasks without
requiring retraining for each new task. It only needs a few examples to guide
the LLM's adaptation to a specific task, along with reusable ASP knowledge
modules that can be applied to multiple tasks. We demonstrate that this method
achieves state-of-the-art performance on several NLP benchmarks, including
bAbI, StepGame, CLUTRR, and gSCAN. Additionally, it successfully tackles robot
planning tasks that an LLM alone fails to solve. | [
0.034951847,
0.0243268982,
-0.0102000069,
0.0104212631,
-0.0414446704,
0.0190485884,
0.0186607577,
-0.024631314,
0.0400867239,
-0.0794589818,
0.0417937711,
0.0442756638,
-0.0500655435,
0.056099873,
-0.0111410925,
-0.0355285257,
0.0640437528,
-0.0407481641,
0.0361695699,
-0.0019244078,
0.0160805322,
0.051624462,
-0.0146557428,
0.0297700893,
-0.0098493053,
-0.0175627545,
-0.0127673,
-0.0340584666,
0.0042108139,
-0.0376977548,
-0.0117346318,
-0.0015499041,
0.0681702867,
-0.0045318245,
0.0000018159,
-0.050643716,
-0.0434198454,
0.0165199395,
-0.0329390988,
-0.038877327,
-0.0134786945,
0.0010245482,
0.0304051526,
0.0296851955,
-0.0491183586,
-0.0199582707,
0.0152680902,
0.0683864728,
0.0766010731,
0.0639625415,
-0.0077477996,
-0.0754161924,
0.0079538571,
0.0102538709,
0.0277509131,
-0.0619369447,
0.0228090771,
0.0475830249,
0.0439475439,
-0.0088890269,
0.0281220246,
-0.0040659164,
0.0298712626,
0.0094171492,
-0.0314568393,
0.0393853299,
-0.0512452312,
0.0060478644,
-0.0109751429,
0.0542839915,
0.0021892318,
-0.0247697048,
-0.0029600447,
0.0053628683,
-0.000463055,
0.0057498212,
-0.022375863,
0.0542057231,
-0.0171959046,
0.0171765797,
0.0050685876,
-0.0309636239,
-0.0070850658,
0.0165758282,
-0.0583227165,
0.113198176,
-0.0012982229,
-0.0313276015,
0.0241851546,
0.0036394338,
-0.0312278029,
-0.0687486306,
0.0070504206,
0.0849056244,
-0.0315905362,
0.0256593246,
-0.0404419005,
0.0337256454,
0.0162428916,
-0.0289271343,
0.0016278879,
0.0697426498,
0.0214729309,
0.0736417174,
-0.0386638641,
0.068697378,
0.0031707939,
0.0308953747,
-0.0474846177,
-0.0376465209,
-0.0842946917,
-0.0243274588,
-0.0591127314,
0.0730621889,
-0.0311720911,
-0.0285706576,
-0.0023516514,
0.0534867719,
0.0248122532,
0.0445483215,
0.0238329507,
0.0159073994,
-0.0014127023,
-0.0267600641,
-0.0709076747,
0.0406828932,
-0.0693729296,
0.0117382361,
0.0024288965,
-0.0252602864,
-0.0208531786,
-0.0051806248,
0.0116627803,
-0.045872137,
0.0329343267,
0.0791249499,
-0.0049716886,
-0.0166400038,
-0.0371505544,
-0.0483292714,
-0.0106935157,
-0.087973088,
0.001223015,
-0.0683749914,
0.0335651748,
0.0254163928,
-0.0293328967,
-0.0193114486,
0.0182699598,
0.0392197408,
-0.0086477911,
0.0716177002,
0.0091909394,
-0.0064170389,
0.0141860191,
-0.0175345093,
-0.0147271883,
0.0570281669,
0.0368671864,
0.0126523077,
-0.0007230145,
0.0278109647,
-0.028851239,
0.0176075883,
-0.015921684,
-0.0321791731,
-0.002936689,
0.0602495782,
0.0184242986,
0.0196841676,
-0.0151400445,
0.0356663577,
-0.0231670383,
0.0081510255,
0.004205727,
0.0301181637,
-0.0326207317,
0.0045509404,
0.0192273688,
0.0131474249,
-0.0001111368,
-0.0502017289,
-0.0702700019,
0.0201047398,
-0.0381378233,
0.0073679485,
-0.0474251397,
0.0344919376,
-0.0087204557,
-0.0143834259,
-0.0202352684,
0.0210473798,
0.0266346745,
0.0406183414,
0.0480894037,
-0.0021332093,
-0.0351539217,
0.0344800279,
-0.0207591765,
-0.0209981725,
-0.0305225216,
-0.0361828357,
0.0251891222,
0.0420469232,
0.0268447734,
-0.0490002893,
-0.0577575937,
-0.0190360416,
0.0212378949,
0.0317534469,
0.0230150651,
-0.0077306363,
-0.0034676893,
-0.0263221469,
-0.0126447817,
-0.0231792443,
-0.0067692888,
0.0434429608,
0.0372289605,
-0.002751821,
-0.0055302344,
-0.024837276,
0.0537627302,
0.0352267846,
0.004264859,
-0.0034414995,
-0.012044563,
-0.0099688536,
0.056640923,
0.0107053621,
-0.0192893408,
0.0110245496,
0.019109657,
-0.026746368,
-0.0510260537,
-0.0014673468,
-0.0217377096,
-0.050082624,
0.0818644613,
0.0015241138,
-0.052893918,
0.0037700427,
-0.0628892854,
-0.0374089405,
-0.0018698452,
-0.020252848,
0.0181529745,
-0.0253970195,
-0.0160699412,
0.0482849032,
-0.0357006341,
-0.0593168959,
0.091318123,
0.0238146167,
-0.0196091868,
-0.0157956611,
0.0004657252,
0.0463530906,
-0.0388397127,
0.0067821313,
0.040199101,
-0.0060146605,
-0.0234482381,
0.020120848,
0.0312392674,
-0.0275535863,
-0.021688791,
-0.0509764962,
0.0330971107,
0.0087086596,
0.0067453557,
0.0110195689,
-0.0074358056,
0.0152468858,
0.0008761112,
-0.0525530279,
0.0100255162,
0.0410405435,
0.0094827032,
0.0140635837,
0.0015794587,
-0.019987518,
0.0049750791,
-0.0033910272,
-0.0465582907,
-0.0038642155,
0.0230275262,
0.0019182137,
-0.0063956114,
0.0228820238,
-0.0491934083,
0.0619600452,
0.0236727353,
-0.0251784269,
0.0420843475,
-0.052795738,
-0.0030638764,
0.0809490681,
-0.0386003256,
-0.0116103292,
0.0495117791,
-0.029743176,
-0.0471386649,
0.056773968,
-0.0152556645,
-0.0219079088,
-0.0445833169,
-0.0101838559,
-0.0492042936,
0.0156883448,
0.028684888,
0.0112279402,
-0.0572919361,
0.0177686643,
0.023739066,
-0.0080777528,
-0.0314291976,
0.0052867336,
0.0095940214,
0.0378671847,
-0.0109256245,
0.0286506601,
0.0700711459,
-0.0046357685,
-0.0187792145,
-0.0384327881,
-0.0151385376,
-0.0313477851,
0.0662085637,
0.0156259649,
0.0232637059,
0.0087526897,
-0.0030756122,
-0.0352887027,
-0.0398891866,
0.0227321442,
-0.0307779592,
0.0396689959,
-0.0727543533,
0.038395118,
-0.0090005137,
-0.0553573631,
-0.0264889579,
-0.003739797,
-0.0704703405,
0.0501538925,
-0.05949663,
-0.0181505233,
-0.0332074761,
-0.0127361612,
0.0199044291,
0.0104764896,
-0.0064240708,
-0.0128989667,
-0.0428161249,
0.012520276,
0.0671720877,
0.0375071056,
-0.0153921796,
0.008722391,
0.051651109,
0.0426284522,
0.0189857166,
-0.0149583053,
-0.0296180528,
0.030059712,
0.0104627404,
-0.0392278582,
0.0186031684,
0.0295867324,
0.0502159521,
-0.065268591,
-0.0229233038,
0.1167886034,
0.0437107086,
0.0379296839,
-0.0253696758,
-0.0071314122,
0.0255247522,
0.0363912173,
0.0480737239,
-0.0549428239,
-0.0608398765,
0.0052144518,
-0.0127169937,
0.004780862,
-0.0464582518,
-0.0057352562,
-0.1163280979,
0.0217892639,
-0.0151224956,
-0.0503057614,
-0.0202277843,
-0.0201367512,
-0.0212335587,
-0.0196175873,
-0.0316148438,
0.0150898863,
-0.0090122167,
0.0152618093,
-0.0146824419,
0.012878634,
0.0205524731,
0.057880111,
-0.0010608045,
0.0341810174,
0.0803005099,
0.0073881727,
-0.016346667,
0.0209910125,
0.0202713069,
0.0090655768,
0.00155987,
-0.0414662696,
0.01209029,
-0.0249727294,
0.014882002,
-0.0049778698,
0.0213695839,
-0.0559719019,
-0.0293707903,
0.033616174,
0.0747601688,
-0.0319110379,
0.0066835359,
-0.0130214067,
-0.0098897023,
-0.0481492057,
0.0842637271,
-0.0302741546,
0.0225210153,
-0.0858918428,
-0.075929381,
-0.053815417,
-0.0430568196,
-0.0045121815,
0.0236324538,
-0.000996977,
0.0276992023,
-0.03320577,
-0.0213644877,
0.081101045,
0.0043302537,
-0.0209281389,
-0.0252082068,
0.024281973,
0.0345834829,
-0.0206333231,
-0.0011514929,
-0.0339172632,
0.0138077894,
0.0144576048,
0.0153334504,
0.0202852469,
-0.0381655693,
-0.0517584346,
0.0108149331,
-0.0392025597,
-0.0540682413,
-0.0103799272,
0.04915471,
0.0234555583,
0.0099679064,
-0.0282106753,
-0.0116916914,
0.0068237716,
0.0095967362,
-0.0005981324,
0.000961117,
-0.0008178916,
0.050764747,
0.0318480879,
0.0160180144,
-0.0632038489,
0.0223092269,
-0.0077016768,
0.0630279928,
-0.0411218256,
-0.0141500561,
0.0664880425,
0.0490121543,
-0.0184442736,
0.0088899266,
0.0046048602,
0.0046880902,
-0.0030761489,
-0.0645414069,
-0.026723979,
-0.0495663732,
0.0146130146,
0.0256948154,
-0.0367202647,
0.0242849272,
-0.0227246862,
-0.005480479,
0.0331598148,
-0.0072624302,
-0.0321872607,
0.0406553559,
-0.016114166,
0.0076486664,
-0.034148261,
-0.0282704532,
-0.0119153941,
-0.0084406938,
0.0121525023,
-0.0297528058,
0.0635027364,
0.0459158048,
-0.0184707325,
-0.0315860994,
-0.0104148621,
-0.0805754289,
-0.0819160864,
0.037214227,
0.0420348458,
0.0463734604,
0.0294488724,
0.0125190336,
-0.049650304,
-0.0144778574,
0.0042306022,
0.0065557733,
0.054046385,
-0.0212900154,
0.0470176004,
0.0260086674,
-0.0207678527,
-0.0456414446,
0.0372898206,
0.0093774544,
0.0604911298,
0.0155463535,
-0.0358620659,
-0.0610661395,
-0.0613545738,
-0.0322124101,
0.0260773189,
0.0149556957,
0.0078314757,
-0.0451325029,
-0.0389893539,
-0.0184072964,
0.019929409,
-0.0073730308,
0.0133258766,
0.0403768457,
0.0357705578,
0.0313463993,
-0.0985024869,
-0.0228443015,
0.0121194543,
-0.0396161154,
-0.0187640805,
-0.02331011,
-5.560063667e-33,
-0.041339051,
-0.0092974361,
0.0657813773,
-0.0392534658,
-0.0120471045,
-0.0434061363,
-0.0235985704,
-0.0233499352,
-0.0566678606,
-0.0019885444,
-0.0066863955,
0.0151720112,
0.0070662978,
0.0223279893,
0.014826173,
-0.026568139,
0.0262278598,
-0.0078210579,
-0.0066857305,
-0.0054211132,
0.0459612533,
-0.0148450416,
0.0169233568,
-0.0212358423,
-0.050470598,
0.0184409264,
-0.02302742,
0.0514177643,
-0.041633945,
0.0434549637,
-0.009403429,
0.0039762282,
0.02432115,
-0.0101933833,
0.0048960093,
0.0450360999,
-0.1010169387,
-0.043361187,
0.0323358253,
-0.0100044385,
-0.0109379729,
-0.0230837762,
0.0144409938,
-0.0238348339,
0.0354475565,
-0.0323422626,
0.0234435145,
-0.018207442,
0.0224719942,
-0.0214225855,
-0.019477807,
0.0077987313,
-0.0087456712,
-0.0088167302,
-0.0054014949,
0.0407988802,
0.0138739105,
0.0462299287,
0.0139042521,
-0.0061280206,
0.0075247171,
0.0112586785,
0.0281916466,
-0.0064700539,
0.0019208791,
0.0338474736,
-0.0011397362,
-0.0448199064,
-0.0252325535,
0.0122696273,
-0.0135709224,
0.0630810186,
0.0126879951,
0.047002092,
0.0094514173,
0.0416272245,
-0.1079556048,
0.0107623534,
0.0132589061,
0.0978625342,
0.0266645364,
0.008317139,
-0.0116967009,
0.0172807854,
-0.0321915671,
0.0538262799,
-0.0273624789,
-0.0224881563,
0.0504868217,
-0.0210314412,
0.0180083923,
0.0003865384,
0.051551763,
-0.0380002782,
0.0006673543,
0.0536292903,
0.0059942589,
0.0010962937,
-0.0095660947,
0.0687916204,
-0.0332511254,
-0.0202328712,
0.0139273703,
-0.0122953197,
-0.0049059349,
0.0153992502,
-0.0064554689,
0.0175259393,
-0.0346539058,
0.0096837282,
-0.0515319481,
-0.0045076855,
-0.0127225323,
0.0232453998,
0.0282160714,
0.0236178134,
0.002245927,
0.0098139253,
-0.0234186631,
-0.0431824401,
-0.0177700333,
-0.0189937297,
0.0296769422,
-0.0005275183,
-0.0096586999,
0.0156279095,
-0.0298400596,
-0.0147230551,
-0.0217346624,
-0.0268428177,
-0.0008518982,
0.0384980962,
2.568e-7,
0.0338815339,
0.0454370715,
0.00020443,
0.098827228,
0.0121465027,
0.0362014063,
0.0308242682,
0.0335894227,
0.0158244874,
-0.0119077535,
-0.0089299819,
0.056580279,
-0.0013967135,
0.0485657677,
-0.0548608191,
0.0148261953,
0.0151945911,
-0.0702206716,
-0.0565977804,
0.0256180093,
0.1292156279,
0.082673341,
0.0076122144,
0.0067925258,
0.0074058468,
-0.0815880299,
0.0146099878,
0.0102589736,
0.005829846,
-0.0089823306,
-0.0092239501,
0.0109472368,
-0.005607368,
0.0366911851,
0.0239792597,
0.0215189196,
-0.0080350479,
0.0810929239,
-0.0298046898,
-0.020446416,
-0.0185277369,
-0.0564633496,
-0.0013211586,
-0.0563452058,
0.1039335579,
-0.0746235326,
-0.0088764178,
0.008560502,
-0.053879071,
-0.0554923229,
-0.0542335697,
0.007639579,
0.0153359706,
-0.0075645233,
0.0020286369,
-0.0150302434,
0.0015661763,
-0.0588072874,
0.0026490015,
0.0379563756,
-0.0463133454,
-0.0191872828,
-0.0023499641,
0.0119270775,
0.0246059299,
-0.0669850335,
-0.0479444824,
2.379010696e-34,
0.0181427952,
-0.0032483789,
-0.000725699,
0.0447117202,
0.0543947816,
0.0273570549,
-0.0359226763,
0.0115101906,
0.0214981735,
-0.1199833825,
-0.0205948856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.07683v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.07683v2 | Single and Multi-Speaker Cloned Voice Detection: From Perceptual to Learned Features | 2023-07-15T02:20:26 | 2023-09-27T16:50:15 | Sarah Barrington, Romit Barua, Gautham Koorma, Hany Farid | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Synthetic-voice cloning technologies have seen significant advances in recent
years, giving rise to a range of potential harms. From small- and large-scale
financial fraud to disinformation campaigns, the need for reliable methods to
differentiate real and synthesized voices is imperative. We describe three
techniques for differentiating a real from a cloned voice designed to
impersonate a specific person. These three approaches differ in their feature
extraction stage with low-dimensional perceptual features offering high
interpretability but lower accuracy, to generic spectral features, and
end-to-end learned features offering less interpretability but higher accuracy.
We show the efficacy of these approaches when trained on a single speaker's
voice and when trained on multiple voices. The learned features consistently
yield an equal error rate between 0% and 4%, and are reasonably robust to
adversarial laundering. | [
-0.0055728345,
0.0695457384,
0.0038889295,
0.034080226,
-0.0236761589,
-0.0336677916,
0.0638292357,
0.0106945736,
-0.0325573869,
0.0071418597,
-0.0519344807,
-0.0327852815,
0.0102263605,
0.0112514505,
0.0518911257,
-0.0257179178,
0.0073100687,
-0.0171962734,
0.0246176142,
-0.0253621396,
0.0088035716,
-0.0084096268,
-0.0411235727,
0.0364713557,
-0.0466063842,
0.0042895298,
-0.0003556875,
0.011110873,
0.0296475869,
0.0561214946,
-0.008372928,
-0.0026138076,
0.0411880836,
0.0879194662,
0.000001913,
-0.0155526651,
-0.0562847592,
-0.0212228931,
-0.06979388,
0.0035148407,
0.033319179,
0.0386679657,
-0.0310108699,
0.021095369,
-0.0620290078,
-0.0187230445,
-0.0044939946,
0.0414329022,
0.0634360313,
0.034699358,
-0.0081213247,
-0.0317159742,
0.0083047813,
0.0081648044,
-0.0047896989,
-0.0170324743,
-0.0188503414,
-0.0280436035,
0.0248586591,
-0.0045535187,
0.0708288625,
0.0247709211,
-0.0282892026,
-0.0135047743,
-0.0181680005,
-0.0274679586,
-0.0480183922,
-0.0313193537,
0.0314469263,
0.0565923341,
-0.0353006572,
-0.0096625183,
0.0318229087,
0.0404844433,
0.0087997979,
0.0081077116,
0.0455119051,
-0.0130575076,
0.0131503353,
-0.0051013553,
-0.092658408,
0.0278768018,
0.0249810945,
-0.036756482,
0.0250299461,
-0.0842211843,
0.0029218022,
-0.000463567,
-0.0134741524,
-0.0436204337,
-0.0154264122,
0.0455176421,
-0.0021368074,
-0.0218016449,
-0.0008152426,
-0.0271189623,
-0.0987315252,
-0.0656319857,
-0.0110315429,
0.0131970644,
0.0745096356,
-0.0075854012,
-0.0591680035,
-0.0134835616,
-0.0343966112,
0.0162266735,
-0.0490302257,
0.0218264442,
-0.017376544,
-0.0012964706,
-0.0286935493,
0.0004176706,
-0.0007959084,
0.0259426963,
0.0268327445,
-0.0173049048,
-0.0449829288,
-0.0336259305,
-0.0516814291,
0.0382076912,
-0.0583137423,
-0.0075351321,
-0.0211886819,
-0.0107412664,
0.0358760953,
-0.0330523513,
0.0339532495,
0.0289243031,
-0.0395368934,
-0.0742935389,
-0.0359376557,
0.0463148654,
0.0400091037,
0.011653644,
0.0151965134,
0.0139186177,
0.0067697354,
0.0125283161,
0.0073212534,
-0.0280568842,
0.0002945788,
-0.0202948377,
0.0007045542,
-0.039347019,
-0.0230848659,
-0.069233194,
-0.0121511994,
-0.0216473211,
0.0144521026,
-0.0505738929,
0.0320752785,
0.0204784311,
0.0068662772,
0.0483957082,
0.0118652983,
0.0032341606,
-0.0464370176,
-0.0122765871,
0.012944757,
-0.0147070931,
0.025299754,
-0.0389454998,
0.0460059419,
0.0325192697,
0.0489378907,
0.0166623909,
-0.0198406857,
-0.0419822037,
-0.0167893786,
0.0068297531,
0.0492991544,
-0.0402526297,
-0.0182919167,
-0.0476694964,
0.0657069162,
0.0450807475,
-0.0074120066,
0.0081558367,
0.0603072681,
0.0616311356,
0.0106275771,
0.0109073203,
0.0070233895,
-0.03259198,
-0.0183210168,
0.0030640878,
-0.0352735966,
0.004432667,
-0.0307390336,
0.0407390706,
0.034943454,
-0.0464965031,
-0.0636233538,
-0.0157915279,
-0.0283572767,
0.0071960101,
0.0176128112,
0.0435534418,
-0.0345198736,
-0.0343060903,
-0.0221625268,
-0.0461431369,
0.0066818059,
0.020319324,
-0.0233535897,
-0.0075789648,
0.0581641831,
-0.0564020798,
-0.0459317006,
0.0283010304,
-0.0358137116,
-0.0190954655,
0.0553803742,
-0.0038428681,
-0.0064526587,
-0.0248868819,
-0.0194554701,
0.0637653619,
0.0009917163,
0.0050657559,
0.0201436747,
-0.0332622416,
0.0378924385,
-0.0348229893,
-0.0149767241,
-0.0520541593,
0.0324649848,
0.0234438609,
0.0436838903,
0.0018955683,
-0.0303832106,
0.0095803021,
0.022825148,
-0.0446631089,
-0.0209064633,
0.0187138375,
0.0105137024,
0.0085682748,
0.0220229719,
-0.0490692928,
0.021348834,
0.0978133902,
-0.000256736,
-0.0180701688,
0.056609977,
-0.0600374639,
-0.0032964519,
-0.0668667778,
0.0155901453,
-0.0237397011,
0.0311000887,
0.0377245992,
0.0071404385,
0.0216660369,
-0.0337145403,
0.0391258746,
0.0150437495,
0.0212317854,
-0.0774951801,
-0.0213677511,
-0.0371086113,
0.0030124234,
0.0290484745,
-0.0524853244,
-0.0308516081,
-0.0137278689,
-0.0003388108,
-0.0104547031,
-0.0390088968,
-0.0245300736,
0.0024193116,
0.0067343027,
-0.0172876548,
0.0027385096,
-0.0274526812,
-0.0441314168,
-0.03996085,
-0.0220091604,
-0.0578398369,
-0.0355750248,
-0.0359496996,
-0.0335066915,
-0.0003286709,
0.0358590484,
0.0044511217,
0.0155863501,
-0.0200554095,
0.0025863913,
-0.0404829942,
-0.0392109193,
0.0459806696,
0.0496743619,
0.0024490154,
0.0246981177,
-0.009658942,
0.0012243076,
-0.0006837198,
0.0518048741,
0.0301945172,
-0.0299551096,
-0.0005519192,
0.0836718157,
-0.0359860919,
-0.0156130008,
0.0251580589,
0.0304238964,
-0.0522736125,
0.0342262983,
-0.015243574,
-0.0380921699,
0.0642502233,
0.023365235,
0.0013551459,
0.0347364023,
0.0086418604,
-0.0707186684,
0.0468722917,
-0.0320054628,
-0.0172573682,
-0.0211322233,
-0.018233275,
-0.006912502,
0.0428786501,
-0.0610532016,
0.0006550165,
-0.0047759954,
-0.0661018714,
0.0128828408,
0.0243142173,
-0.011203343,
0.0353239886,
-0.0074168015,
-0.0243782569,
-0.0016835167,
0.0220338814,
0.0557843447,
-0.0477660224,
-0.0190853179,
-0.0260621384,
0.017913809,
-0.0043250122,
-0.0011271937,
-0.0453408174,
-0.066414535,
0.0164167713,
-0.0142510757,
0.004364613,
-0.0476815514,
0.0045662303,
-0.0064131776,
0.0466265231,
0.0637538433,
0.0183992572,
0.0424181521,
-0.0333556235,
0.080885157,
0.0066628638,
0.0419223532,
-0.0056715901,
-0.0091660451,
0.0301251858,
-0.008523711,
0.0155087207,
0.0284374449,
-0.0386376679,
-0.011601232,
0.0024742254,
-0.0020487823,
0.0083870711,
-0.0174664818,
0.0219928715,
-0.0087367287,
0.013418748,
0.0678781122,
-0.0062784618,
-0.0494477563,
0.0107096946,
-0.0055275671,
-0.0028870741,
-0.0052570105,
-0.0379724279,
-0.0363693126,
-0.0176165309,
0.049873326,
0.0463283174,
-0.0460173823,
0.0293067526,
-0.0307653379,
-0.0849414021,
0.0138895521,
0.0212758146,
-0.060441833,
-0.0786562487,
-0.0012599119,
-0.0293165874,
-0.0225701053,
0.0156835746,
-0.0123710316,
-0.0181101151,
0.0054690107,
0.0080425423,
-0.0373874009,
-0.0221469253,
-0.0008954573,
-0.0151199345,
0.055845324,
0.0320473053,
0.0052450085,
-0.0047450843,
-0.0695133954,
-0.0445815325,
-0.0025531054,
0.009195894,
0.0245989561,
0.0730128363,
0.0524138398,
-0.0162804704,
0.0179266073,
0.0641520396,
-0.0018826051,
0.027041385,
0.0078292545,
0.0182425696,
-0.0033100797,
-0.0506811403,
0.0329680517,
0.0200742241,
0.0636580363,
0.0390336812,
0.0451223105,
-0.0282161627,
-0.0041052368,
0.0686383843,
0.058242783,
-0.027654022,
-0.0844423994,
0.0615809709,
0.0314731225,
-0.0486745723,
-0.026543254,
0.0123708565,
-0.0603204109,
0.0706331804,
0.0247562099,
0.0041313372,
-0.0196021982,
-0.0017820507,
-0.0170217771,
0.0071427356,
-0.0413377136,
0.0692287385,
0.0135159427,
-0.0032623417,
0.0114014624,
-0.0306083113,
-0.0161510929,
-0.0146455793,
-0.0532154888,
0.000063465,
0.005584293,
-0.0412209891,
0.0244413223,
0.0564759448,
-0.0505501926,
-0.0114596905,
0.0386477187,
-0.0424489975,
-0.0207257848,
0.0166707803,
0.112611711,
-0.0444303751,
-0.0026308731,
0.0317428745,
-0.0071443594,
0.0839854032,
0.0154882036,
-0.0310509447,
-0.0768172517,
0.0010139794,
0.014160865,
0.0446298011,
0.0123155769,
0.0038061088,
0.1050337851,
0.0221845657,
0.0202631559,
0.031948138,
0.0261270292,
-0.0240637809,
-0.0221015476,
0.0324824788,
0.0391072556,
0.0440436639,
-0.0036087087,
0.0044684624,
0.0113451704,
0.0133435009,
0.0080033103,
-0.0125783365,
0.0264822021,
-0.0131990798,
0.0339017026,
-0.006725512,
0.1191367656,
0.0369398594,
0.026841348,
0.016396625,
0.0194100738,
0.0013328221,
-0.0399319492,
-0.003125624,
0.0284441635,
-0.0412118137,
-0.0558049977,
0.0179549586,
0.0405931659,
0.0045828847,
0.0082928911,
0.0511562973,
0.0132039106,
0.0248019081,
0.0113458512,
0.026416352,
-0.0540501177,
0.0081020268,
-0.0409894548,
-0.00124147,
-0.0195178445,
0.0171298087,
0.047498595,
-0.0184987038,
0.0005827004,
-0.0908471942,
0.0331705809,
-0.0363351889,
-0.0381115936,
0.0006158022,
-0.0193122737,
-0.0206017997,
0.0075072385,
-0.0261139497,
-0.0220229197,
0.0080801491,
-0.0207772404,
-0.0127706537,
0.0039257095,
0.0249297433,
0.0055241566,
-0.0381914638,
0.0529894568,
0.0107619707,
-0.0260856859,
0.0550797954,
-0.0377597474,
0.036194846,
-5.505147877e-33,
0.0270084981,
0.014385676,
-0.0324026905,
0.0006052671,
-0.0168003533,
0.0315115079,
0.0075501818,
0.0333612077,
0.0078456914,
-0.0261800457,
-0.0055201161,
-0.0018880705,
-0.0007554489,
0.0184860341,
-0.050857503,
-0.0091174608,
0.0816036612,
0.0043183486,
0.0182807203,
0.0259367228,
0.102526322,
0.0315917432,
0.0035343575,
-0.0638322011,
-0.0206067972,
-0.0050840536,
-0.0136947967,
-0.0303674974,
-0.0111232512,
-0.011770037,
0.0151334414,
0.0155365737,
-0.0079106065,
-0.0555878617,
-0.0331695341,
-0.0168805886,
-0.0159464683,
-0.0131346676,
-0.0238927156,
0.0385206193,
-0.003541538,
-0.0239005852,
0.0321227759,
-0.0094240131,
-0.0462724194,
0.0195913259,
0.0348592699,
-0.0384484902,
-0.000263802,
-0.0138032297,
-0.0175228063,
0.0075392569,
-0.0096104266,
0.0191257428,
0.0735311657,
0.1020616814,
-0.0315260515,
0.0115670618,
-0.1031009629,
0.0161184948,
-0.0432616547,
-0.0189198516,
-0.0007068929,
0.0252401736,
-0.0153180761,
0.0723394528,
0.0603535585,
-0.0876068547,
-0.0054241046,
-0.0178859886,
0.0379604436,
0.0557063557,
0.0663785934,
0.0822312087,
0.0448912792,
-0.0652813092,
-0.0225932207,
0.01951693,
0.0430906899,
-0.0590730868,
0.0140682608,
0.0303473659,
-0.0178634282,
0.0300580841,
-0.040427357,
-0.0648222417,
-0.0153797828,
-0.0264918134,
-0.0045810631,
-0.0188684333,
-0.0650360286,
0.0117307678,
0.0234883334,
-0.043251995,
0.0132266618,
-0.0497500226,
0.0063378904,
-0.003724064,
0.0113242771,
0.0131967198,
0.01975023,
-0.0462232977,
0.0860366076,
0.0143089741,
0.0497432649,
-0.0364139378,
0.0688869879,
0.0503618903,
-0.0408939086,
0.0077044033,
0.0350816585,
0.0464665145,
0.002170383,
0.047414545,
-0.0019189084,
0.0048436844,
-0.0023336837,
-0.0328292623,
0.0076842415,
0.0459047072,
0.0374270268,
0.0446339361,
0.0063988292,
0.0299600288,
-0.0386410244,
0.0033221939,
-0.0393330567,
-0.0070970068,
0.0158209167,
-0.0409702063,
0.0184370596,
-0.0427002311,
2.73e-7,
-0.0798259526,
-0.0622474961,
0.0253079105,
-0.103069827,
0.0341163538,
0.0707966164,
0.0285780784,
0.021781968,
-0.0509356298,
-0.0934393704,
-0.0031172237,
-0.0024568143,
0.0805440843,
0.0019363039,
-0.1105530262,
-0.0397171229,
-0.0204032585,
-0.0043236222,
-0.0412979126,
0.0243684929,
0.0364579409,
0.0614924617,
0.0428183042,
-0.065503411,
0.042859219,
-0.0294037089,
-0.0066261697,
0.0284407753,
-0.0082110073,
-0.0288236309,
0.0587248094,
-0.0299481321,
-0.0085930349,
0.0478036776,
-0.0037076401,
0.0309981816,
-0.0064188386,
0.0364564955,
-0.0045001442,
-0.0265419092,
-0.0553625189,
0.0245324429,
0.0110335164,
0.046478685,
0.0129361181,
0.016975645,
-0.0490409024,
-0.0801540166,
-0.0415480547,
0.0266034789,
-0.0258842595,
-0.000657527,
0.0295913201,
0.0186616741,
0.0028834385,
0.0044773198,
-0.0042599114,
-0.0239312556,
0.0122991614,
0.0075570662,
-0.0533145964,
-0.0240558051,
-0.012802178,
-0.0040093758,
0.0515248924,
0.0397822522,
0.0139907645,
1.715123974e-34,
-0.0314289704,
0.0168728642,
0.0297698285,
-0.0132108126,
-0.0237230547,
0.0032538362,
0.0094680618,
-0.0158669557,
-0.0030524288,
-0.0027865749,
-0.0183780193
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.