id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13628v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13628v2 | Improving Self-training for Cross-lingual Named Entity Recognition with Contrastive and Prototype Learning | 2023-05-23T02:52:16 | 2023-06-04T16:32:41 | Ran Zhou, Xin Li, Lidong Bing, Erik Cambria, Chunyan Miao | cs.CL | cs.CL | In cross-lingual named entity recognition (NER), self-training is commonly
used to bridge the linguistic gap by training on pseudo-labeled target-language
data. However, due to sub-optimal performance on target languages, the pseudo
labels are often noisy and limit the overall performance. In this work, we aim
to improve self-training for cross-lingual NER by combining representation
learning and pseudo label refinement in one coherent framework. Our proposed
method, namely ContProto mainly comprises two components: (1) contrastive
self-training and (2) prototype-based pseudo-labeling. Our contrastive
self-training facilitates span classification by separating clusters of
different classes, and enhances cross-lingual transferability by producing
closely-aligned representations between the source and target language.
Meanwhile, prototype-based pseudo-labeling effectively improves the accuracy of
pseudo labels during training. We evaluate ContProto on multiple transfer
pairs, and experimental results show our method brings in substantial
improvements over current state-of-the-art methods. | [
-0.4621742964,
-0.13769117,
-0.0582011677,
0.3161323071,
-0.4996249974,
0.3425765336,
-0.1380241215,
-0.8908617496,
0.6397297978,
0.1809794754,
-0.3728066385,
-0.0856541991,
-0.5652269125,
0.4854174852,
-0.1732167602,
1.0097837448,
-0.047084935,
0.3037103713,
0.1833824366,
-0.1742999703,
-0.4069570303,
-0.3228247464,
-0.7281614542,
-0.5107111931,
0.4854052365,
0.5981651545,
0.2247995287,
0.3446443975,
0.1666906625,
0.3587778211,
0.4287629426,
0.0224187393,
-0.5084980726,
0.0673587099,
-0.3766829669,
-0.3935912549,
-0.1809681952,
-0.2212055624,
0.8377597928,
0.723429203,
0.1041566953,
-0.0967780501,
0.133403793,
0.494892776,
-0.6309299469,
0.2324600965,
-0.6138250828,
0.2575481832,
-0.3819205165,
-0.0190510619,
-0.456087172,
0.0007046054,
0.3960784376,
-1.058865428,
0.23501499,
0.3013810515,
0.8760140538,
-0.0354149267,
-0.1854783893,
-0.1196163222,
-0.5684411526,
0.7493209839,
-0.3964143991,
0.9081314206,
0.1662935764,
0.2736413777,
0.0086210389,
-0.9048739672,
-0.6328843832,
-0.1385767758,
-0.4107946455,
0.2665286362,
-0.3026826978,
0.0460571349,
-0.1494039744,
0.373942256,
-0.7352112532,
0.3964288831,
-0.4168820977,
-0.4476860762,
0.4392878115,
-0.3723157644,
0.3731423616,
0.0356476381,
-0.6988981962,
-0.234946683,
-0.7647224665,
-0.0955629572,
0.2320821285,
0.2432245761,
-0.1388088167,
0.2175856978,
-0.3517587781,
0.4757321775,
0.7408054471,
-0.0839066952,
0.5682755113,
-0.205982402,
-0.1667293459,
0.551055491,
0.8055917621,
0.2404955328,
0.3124354482,
-0.5791236162,
-0.0950049311,
-0.2863717973,
-0.0588659644,
-0.8027653098,
-0.7513555288,
-0.0616373718,
-0.3516520858,
0.0387854092,
0.0000629262,
-0.6544001102,
0.1248236895,
-0.3546343744,
0.467783004,
-0.4824707508,
-0.4884973168,
-0.0189099927,
-0.0096004475,
0.2071923912,
0.27996701,
-1.2074723244,
0.5236679316,
0.2090585381,
0.5723435283,
-0.3511308134,
-0.4904390872,
-0.6180235744,
0.4931175411,
-0.3113438487,
0.8783217072,
-0.2700948119,
-0.2373375744,
-0.2349448204,
-0.0148971016,
-0.1977237761,
-0.7057242393,
-0.1653708816,
-0.4818866253,
0.4022181332,
0.0603115037,
-0.6814858317,
-0.0431147218,
0.3336817324,
-0.8150145411,
1.0055195093,
0.1012759954,
-0.9819146395,
0.3460027575,
-0.1791258156,
-0.5903103948,
0.273843348,
-0.1827072352,
-0.5252579451,
0.0052942149,
0.2697942257,
0.4088268578,
-0.1001751944,
0.1611464322,
-0.1404478848,
-0.2357706577,
0.0524760708,
0.1209589243,
0.4699326158,
-0.0186310764,
-0.4495103061,
-0.0456990376,
-0.7850062847,
0.031307172,
-0.0404199548,
-0.0314354673,
-0.6193181276,
-0.6730527878,
0.0758819506,
0.1434117407,
0.3450546563,
-0.5258009434,
0.030846037,
-0.6127404571,
0.0043413402,
0.4077313542,
-0.1688753068,
0.7421879768,
-0.0844817981,
0.4372057021,
0.1950269789,
-0.0705267787,
0.0764471516,
-0.0912212133,
-0.9994766116,
-0.3204955161,
0.7863715291,
0.3945269585,
-1.0661697388,
0.4036270976,
-0.2206687778,
-0.4794648886,
-0.3334489465,
0.1402203143,
0.6831052303,
0.7331249714,
0.7976871133,
-0.4057495892,
-0.8334443569,
-1.0672250986,
0.0243388768,
-0.2216316909,
0.2195344865,
-0.000093023,
0.451264888,
-0.1163837239,
0.8953601718,
-0.1303901374,
-0.5886018276,
-0.6017485261,
0.4934670925,
-0.1059966907,
0.7818255424,
0.5936130881,
-0.7765066028,
-0.9206132293,
0.127435118,
-0.4281664491,
-0.1758565605,
-0.1774520129,
0.0074039409,
0.1160495952,
0.6720708609,
-0.3010355532,
-0.1590176374,
0.5613704324,
0.200261727,
0.6482716203,
-0.244981423,
-0.0669560209,
-1.03513515,
0.0951469094,
0.0279252175,
-0.2813345194,
-0.6119725108,
-0.2903402746,
-0.0226612575,
0.105808273,
-0.6517519355,
1.0148922205,
-0.9150474072,
0.0878014937,
-0.1929086447,
0.174233228,
-0.0573980622,
0.4138864279,
0.4514013827,
0.7690387964,
0.7020561099,
-0.462685287,
0.1373672187,
0.0549532548,
-0.1026167572,
0.8835660219,
-0.6170319915,
0.1149066836,
0.045341149,
0.4579849839,
-0.9580372572,
0.0117639452,
0.5915228128,
-0.2388419509,
0.8008255959,
-0.2575235665,
-0.4432279766,
0.023975661,
-0.1579230726,
0.6781614423,
0.1181714684,
-0.7620865703,
0.5475533009,
0.4838394225,
0.0790236145,
-0.5850586891,
-0.6798026562,
-0.006623148,
-0.225977838,
-0.23695077,
1.040353775,
0.2528749704,
0.2974498272,
-0.032771375,
-0.424528718,
-0.0788815618,
-0.3979869187,
-0.182962656,
0.0336130224,
-0.0870108455,
0.3828473091,
0.1980535686,
-0.4441010654,
-0.1285901964,
-0.4305525422,
0.5131703615,
-0.1251515895,
0.1376865059,
-0.4762880504,
0.2212519944,
-0.0560997091,
-0.3922734261,
0.3751147985,
0.6568525434,
-0.3374952972,
-0.483324945,
-0.4888601601,
-0.2608008683,
-0.4581802189,
0.3767295778,
-0.816850543,
-0.9038994908,
0.3608204126,
-0.5702922344,
-0.5140852928,
0.3738981485,
0.1982934922,
-0.3460716903,
0.3110461831,
0.7409735918,
-0.127885595,
0.6368371844,
-0.4680092931,
0.1511899233,
-0.883086741,
-0.4767743051,
-0.2710130513,
-0.35947299,
-0.6558965445,
-0.3527989984,
0.0257839672,
0.1331358105,
-0.0020483569,
0.7078457475,
-0.4682908952,
0.38069731,
0.4615455568,
0.0332919993,
0.1961777359,
0.0500780754,
-0.3431228995,
-0.4264138341,
-0.9417489767,
-0.0474092588,
0.8015473485,
0.1336176246,
0.815061152,
-0.1582983285,
1.1840229034,
0.2539859116,
0.2910972536,
-0.519982934,
0.4383926392,
-0.2893054485,
-0.4533778727,
-0.2526834607,
-0.5129164457,
-1.101369977,
0.4392566383,
-0.1751834452,
-0.679566741,
0.5759467483,
0.3421036899,
-0.0096345255,
0.0879149139,
-0.6649048924,
1.1550209522,
-0.5158374906,
-0.2046356499,
-0.1690191329,
-0.934073925,
0.1299386322,
-0.0789023116,
-0.0901381522,
0.0578639619,
-0.0523691662,
0.8827763796,
-0.2351446003,
0.9465461373,
0.0294899009,
0.1111140847,
0.1578315645,
0.1693218946,
0.4442578554,
0.0532212816,
0.2333137542,
0.3138714135,
-0.1598868668,
-0.1819456071,
-0.665183723,
0.5974423289,
-0.6223497391,
-0.2951880693,
-0.7090486288,
-0.221025914,
-0.2247032374,
0.4412434995,
0.5033164024,
0.1957310438,
-0.4669463634,
-0.0286924914,
0.7253120542,
0.1845257133,
0.3472612798,
0.3995084763,
-0.1623305231,
-0.7929763198,
1.0990110636,
0.3240974545,
0.1536636055,
0.8824266195,
0.1212834939,
-0.7556101084,
-0.5622178316,
-0.5076139569,
0.5960215926,
-0.5848307014,
-0.3756985664,
-0.4454331398,
-0.116257526,
-0.2640003562,
-0.0805400014,
-0.679264009,
-0.5209181309,
-0.3955217302,
0.0769386142,
-0.0881621838,
0.322104007,
-0.2617451549,
0.4985545278,
-0.4548566639,
0.3848971426,
0.2709449232,
0.2071316093,
-0.1151263639,
-0.5574476719,
-0.2958410978,
-0.2031395435,
-0.0124593545,
-0.8927896619,
0.2644598782,
0.4505435824,
0.6827408075,
0.2734062076,
0.2938859761,
0.8902679086,
-0.4776933789,
0.0613504909,
0.6721334457,
-1.0972918272,
0.6019511223,
0.2009841204,
0.1482648253,
0.7590226531,
0.6563981771,
-0.439570576,
-0.2530162632,
-0.670714438,
-0.7049864531,
0.6509434581,
0.1916340888,
0.0513855927,
0.0399519168,
0.0814067349,
0.2954941392,
0.0681007951,
-1.1213921309,
-0.2561751902,
-0.466083616,
-0.0745957643,
0.1868195236,
0.0351343155,
0.103951484,
-0.2089690119,
0.7993982434,
-0.4233116806,
0.0201560371,
0.4094257951,
-0.429371506,
0.0325257741,
0.209496215,
0.0960872993,
0.361417532,
0.0246383585,
0.4809531868,
0.3786360323,
-0.1870524436,
0.3404373527,
0.4587335885,
-0.1815518588,
0.2766950428,
0.4209217429,
0.5230845213,
0.6688588858,
-0.3250719309,
0.3654693663,
0.2811073959,
0.114735879,
-0.1533904076,
-0.0520585217,
-0.0404285379,
0.2187590897,
0.2054234296,
-0.1459529251,
0.3657291532,
-0.5451594591,
0.3346605599,
0.3329031467,
-0.1823773682,
-0.4122647941,
0.3970863223,
0.2842911482,
-0.0694460794,
0.6162467003,
-0.3828600049,
-0.6614367962,
0.3955107033,
1.0031330585,
0.7434228659,
-0.5429391265,
0.4513669014,
0.5675851107,
0.1247836649,
-0.1212157384,
0.0513010286,
-0.4344143867,
-0.7782253623,
-0.2722966075,
-0.3356938362,
-0.5413448811,
0.0562610626,
-0.4726667404,
0.4189093113,
-0.404068619,
-0.0174350105,
0.0214266814,
0.1463885307,
-0.4304485619,
0.6047455072,
0.1885237098,
0.5649476647,
-0.8462463617,
1.0828285217,
0.8285967112,
-0.4721232057,
-0.7987413406,
0.0106092254,
-0.4757282138,
-0.5913556814,
0.891381979,
0.3923346102,
-0.4375248551,
0.1183742285,
-0.0685724616,
-1.0502653122,
0.8951483965,
0.3979307115,
-1.0287930965,
0.0872272253,
0.2654859424,
0.7988519669,
-0.4833924472,
0.1005388275,
0.1394555569,
0.4274556041,
0.2101971507,
-1.0874202251,
0.0937009305,
-0.0985259339,
0.102423206,
0.1957899928,
-0.7805358171,
0.3622685075,
-0.0434168428,
-0.3581715226,
-0.0590167083,
0.9910129905,
0.3362559676,
0.371527046,
0.6169354916,
0.6514475346,
0.6014224291,
-0.0565575324,
0.5380656719,
-0.3070483804,
0.31084463,
1.4884892702,
-0.2705585063,
0.7635423541,
0.7574656606,
-0.1316449195,
0.5270971656,
0.6660932302,
-0.2236321867,
0.7780142426,
0.331256032,
0.0143949846,
-0.3575693071,
-0.1226704493,
-0.5005373955,
0.459225297,
0.1186101735,
-0.2234172076,
-0.3683226705,
0.0635953769,
0.0646803528,
-0.0735916421,
-0.1722847819,
0.7044553161,
0.2847495079,
-0.6331671476,
0.5726688504,
-0.115182355,
0.6861469746,
-0.6305726767,
-0.0918864533,
-0.3749049902,
0.1416747421,
-0.2739765644,
-0.6632580757,
0.2660852671,
-0.4103081524,
0.0748519376,
-0.3171689212,
0.714795351,
-0.6883329153,
-0.4329568446,
0.772090435,
0.5047357678,
0.1796189547,
0.1265717596,
-0.8061387539,
-0.2419061363,
-0.1932786256,
0.175074175,
0.4228877723,
0.5051890612,
-0.1790527999,
0.5137729049,
0.4451415837,
0.0836800486,
0.1650198549,
0.1798544377,
0.7505369186,
-0.3773457408,
-0.5743284225,
-0.5333099961,
0.2412253171,
-0.0480629615,
-0.6098994017,
0.6325904131,
0.8706861138,
1.4720695019,
-0.1661792547,
0.3482962251,
-0.083642371,
0.2647064328,
-0.4927634895,
0.6064376235,
-0.6595370173,
0.0681267753,
-0.2277833372,
-0.9874812961,
-0.5487038493,
0.6359019279,
-0.2131953537,
0.0866315961,
0.622551024,
0.5236523151,
-0.4326076806,
-0.4411573112,
0.2398227751,
0.1072792187,
-0.0448669195,
0.4621602893,
0.8297536373,
-0.5439726114,
0.6735883951,
-0.6958584189,
0.0530256443,
-0.282189101,
-0.6170446277,
-0.9124983549,
-0.503110528,
-0.6173164845,
-0.0279046353,
0.4456713498,
0.6625981331,
1.059803009,
-0.9556925297,
-0.3331143558,
-0.1685557961,
0.0142957224,
-0.3173659742,
-0.1570726186,
0.5681377053,
-0.4546883702,
-0.8444251418,
0.4249280691,
0.2704770565,
0.2079998851,
-0.2062195987,
-0.2283792347,
-0.2165801525,
-0.4404275417,
0.3892036974,
0.609751761,
-0.6020874977,
-0.1963047683,
-0.027420219,
-0.0749805644,
0.3417314589,
0.6992340088,
-0.9358860254,
0.732000649,
0.4864801764,
0.4701119065,
0.9215666056,
-0.1438889951,
0.4323657155,
-0.8909143806,
0.1300052553,
0.2245572507,
0.4601319134,
0.5161331296,
-0.2312780917,
0.5025299191,
0.3715285063,
-0.11498072,
-0.5172686577,
0.1726966649,
-1.1353722811,
-0.1594612747,
0.662545085,
-0.2797570527,
0.0144075435,
-0.1974788457,
-0.0884727389,
0.4063079655,
-0.3678719699,
0.8178961873,
0.3146278858,
-0.4875726402,
-0.5715122223,
0.2484084517,
0.4218962491,
0.5421873927,
-0.8221555352,
-0.3414587677,
0.1161473244,
0.5550516248,
0.2722364068,
0.6160525084,
-0.0247977674,
0.3306318521,
-0.0554998517,
0.1633060426,
0.0501287356,
-0.6365866661,
-0.1533509791,
0.019522313,
-0.1769164056,
-0.4601920247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13627v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13627v2 | InstructAlign: High-and-Low Resource Language Alignment via Continual Crosslingual Instruction Tuning | 2023-05-23T02:51:34 | 2023-10-24T08:08:33 | Samuel Cahyawijaya, Holy Lovenia, Tiezheng Yu, Willy Chung, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) that are tuned with instructions have
demonstrated remarkable capabilities in various tasks and languages. However,
their ability to generalize to underrepresented languages is limited due to the
scarcity of available data. Additionally, directly adapting new languages to
instruction-tuned LLMs can result in catastrophic forgetting, which leads to
the loss of multitasking ability. To address this issue, we propose
InstructAlign which uses continual crosslingual instruction tuning to enable
LLMs to align new unseen languages with previously learned high-resource
languages. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of InstructAlign in
enabling the model to understand low-resource languages with limited parallel
data while preventing catastrophic forgetting. Our work contributes to the
advancement of language adaptation methods, particularly for adapting
instruction-tuned LLMs to underrepresented languages. Our code is released on
https://github.com/HLTCHKUST/InstructAlign | [
0.0672487542,
-0.4787982106,
0.285513401,
0.2494398206,
-0.0910801813,
0.5437291861,
-0.7339583039,
-0.0250498876,
-0.1076349467,
0.4610189497,
-0.6567825079,
-0.4888750017,
-0.4240927994,
-0.2031088918,
0.0961721167,
0.8844943643,
-0.2766550779,
0.3754037023,
-0.5262114406,
-0.3792386055,
-0.9317361712,
0.176955685,
-0.5059099793,
-0.509578228,
0.1906469315,
1.0094403028,
0.7762367725,
0.8109425902,
0.2492250353,
0.2690856755,
0.3702634573,
0.16883865,
-0.7550280094,
-0.0223377272,
-0.5403683186,
-0.5112196207,
-0.1846040785,
-0.2086928487,
1.0174759626,
0.9290861487,
-0.393795073,
0.3006263375,
0.5265245438,
0.6411121488,
-0.7445700169,
-0.0172718931,
-0.7682108879,
-0.0836278647,
-0.5333310962,
-0.1112830937,
-0.4261318743,
-0.3414348066,
-0.1244782805,
-0.7783515453,
0.046565026,
0.3127196133,
0.5067092776,
0.6963094473,
-0.0084947525,
-0.0308448933,
-0.5725679398,
0.8562185764,
-0.5561208129,
0.6782711148,
0.2938760817,
0.1666142046,
-0.089742355,
-0.2837541401,
-0.3483596146,
-0.0790857971,
0.0944706053,
0.225620091,
-0.1695939898,
-0.0698063895,
0.1064194813,
0.2929290831,
-0.9294717312,
0.7929142714,
0.057177823,
-0.1640667617,
0.1314818114,
0.2081329674,
0.5332254171,
0.295999527,
-0.442730546,
0.0968625322,
-1.0597691536,
-0.129220292,
0.2836018801,
0.4373656213,
-0.3750531077,
0.3476569057,
0.116042532,
0.6962943673,
0.5376075506,
-0.2971072197,
0.0631152317,
-0.2263580412,
-0.3098492622,
0.7147199512,
0.6755771637,
0.1999175102,
0.1799588054,
-0.3758048713,
-0.0400883667,
-0.0784412995,
-0.0436017141,
-0.5212301612,
-0.0534389354,
-0.2198552489,
-0.2811406553,
0.2650517523,
-0.3992472887,
-0.5574476123,
-0.2824760973,
-0.3432491422,
0.4175847173,
-0.4801315367,
-0.2303238064,
0.2675868869,
0.3191982508,
0.0420815125,
0.1022555381,
-1.2757722139,
0.240358904,
0.5812061429,
0.7260030508,
-0.0908190683,
-0.539525032,
-0.6459109783,
0.560379684,
-0.2808715701,
0.5508805513,
-0.8143445849,
-0.11969506,
0.1310344934,
0.3918916881,
-0.400270015,
-0.7350492477,
0.1123427078,
-0.2775266171,
0.3322401047,
-0.2042483389,
-0.5784489512,
-0.0245839152,
0.0721425265,
-0.5228408575,
0.9788131118,
0.3762002289,
-0.4242097437,
0.2675311863,
-0.3551641405,
-0.5815576315,
0.3941623867,
0.0628879815,
-0.466773212,
-0.0321580432,
0.3068380654,
0.1989029795,
-0.5312293768,
0.1867427677,
-0.2612371147,
-0.4622444212,
-0.0460507497,
-0.4177452922,
0.7419311404,
-0.163769871,
-0.4296744466,
0.0813180953,
-0.3643430769,
-0.0100120204,
-0.0324381068,
-0.450825125,
-0.422634691,
-0.2579038441,
-0.1014009714,
-0.0358970203,
0.5340335965,
-0.5063425303,
0.2068413049,
-0.3493177593,
0.2486442924,
0.7569842339,
-0.2806356847,
0.7414526343,
-0.3223257065,
0.9278066158,
-0.0704350993,
0.091034852,
-0.1866796911,
-0.166497916,
-0.8281676173,
0.0704397708,
0.2319763452,
0.8021941781,
-1.011613965,
0.212801367,
-0.4938154817,
-0.2009545565,
-0.9138230681,
0.6264973283,
0.9561240673,
0.5496641397,
0.3336761296,
-0.202433005,
-0.4697741568,
-0.6679549813,
-0.2643511593,
0.174036935,
0.2815561295,
-0.0709621832,
0.146893546,
-0.044288002,
0.2101637274,
-0.040579766,
-0.2738541961,
-0.0958202034,
-0.0945334136,
0.0124755371,
0.7010509372,
0.4865492284,
-0.2093736827,
-0.8626586795,
0.3025580347,
-0.6907594204,
0.0216375552,
-0.2530142665,
-0.438169688,
0.3907585144,
0.8719753623,
-0.3232803047,
-0.101092793,
0.8989530802,
-0.0337672643,
0.1739793867,
-0.2800711989,
-0.2111176699,
-1.0745666027,
-0.1820658445,
-0.0469741188,
-0.2548853755,
-0.1024625748,
-0.3715077341,
0.3007987142,
-0.3492184281,
-0.3188561797,
0.4614372849,
-0.8152616024,
0.164333418,
-0.1740085781,
0.0473637991,
-0.2547679543,
0.546742022,
-0.235325247,
0.9018626213,
0.7268506289,
-0.3984144032,
0.3526089489,
0.1203130037,
-0.6234727502,
0.7338852882,
-0.2819394171,
0.0550899059,
-0.1675336659,
-0.0290610064,
-0.6735169888,
-0.2843720019,
0.4899562895,
0.0811535567,
0.9103631973,
-0.3379299939,
-0.4267039001,
-0.0957023129,
0.0714577213,
0.6462566257,
0.2168987691,
-0.8716894984,
0.3326267302,
0.5868848562,
-0.2446914017,
-0.7208111286,
-0.5601184368,
-0.0259790458,
-0.2070795149,
-0.2952784896,
0.669031322,
-0.1201780811,
0.0087781306,
0.2782527208,
-0.1149793342,
0.2125510126,
-0.2032644749,
0.2194675505,
0.155785799,
-0.6634463668,
0.5689190626,
0.4524805546,
-0.3150333762,
-0.1572487503,
-0.6912197471,
0.6024626493,
-0.0629303753,
-0.6181486845,
-0.5714645982,
0.3744289279,
0.7201461792,
-0.3757342696,
0.6439799666,
0.6721178293,
-0.3067287207,
-0.3025084436,
-0.4380735457,
0.132849589,
-0.4708646238,
0.5826511383,
0.0535780787,
-1.0322440863,
0.2126173228,
-0.3320030272,
-0.0393836126,
0.1300932765,
0.6355788112,
-0.124176383,
0.8818001151,
0.9872905016,
-0.4059155285,
0.7334359884,
0.2063405067,
0.1034645215,
-0.7157305479,
-0.2545232475,
-0.3093857765,
-0.4768235385,
-0.6443785429,
-0.219444707,
0.3356897235,
0.109364748,
-0.430862844,
0.3253612816,
-0.49340716,
0.8615503907,
0.6008304358,
0.2305506915,
-0.0491179377,
0.0363685228,
-0.0708987266,
-0.2938470542,
-1.0736870766,
-0.2645895481,
0.8436896205,
0.0572248213,
1.1001904011,
0.1049484611,
0.6745740771,
-0.1492807567,
0.3061323762,
-0.6147693396,
0.2323927879,
-0.6171864867,
-0.3387286961,
-0.3908465505,
-0.1759764105,
-0.9464499354,
-0.1270627826,
-0.180180952,
-0.6706326008,
0.0382391401,
0.4432314932,
-0.5241200328,
0.2607558072,
-0.7517232299,
1.1660329103,
-0.7824324965,
-0.5723872185,
-0.5214322805,
-0.4029488266,
0.3041172624,
-0.1844246984,
0.044985719,
-0.2464657426,
0.0047178189,
0.6666594148,
-0.2551887333,
1.2345876694,
-0.0204087906,
-0.1048037931,
-0.1121575758,
0.0312838629,
0.5209614635,
0.1590700597,
0.0356982835,
-0.1443473101,
-0.3255267739,
-0.4680239856,
-0.6243085265,
1.1185661554,
-0.5341590643,
-0.6901860237,
-0.1796843857,
-0.8806601763,
-0.1969939321,
0.283851862,
0.3079233468,
0.3062603772,
-0.1968837231,
0.0207758676,
0.9109177589,
-0.331828177,
0.6476935744,
0.5525233746,
0.0814256072,
-0.5926839709,
1.1123517752,
0.0900003687,
0.3762497306,
0.6115584373,
0.102071166,
-0.1951147169,
-0.3259315789,
-0.8040061593,
0.4640416801,
-0.5563221574,
-0.4712042809,
-0.0282097124,
0.1032546014,
-0.2737220824,
-0.3483181894,
-0.4895638525,
-0.2237583399,
-0.2987305522,
0.2324804813,
0.337592721,
0.634062171,
-0.0825712755,
0.5003094077,
-0.8508834243,
0.0449968316,
0.2070789486,
0.588157475,
-0.0541507788,
-0.5516539216,
-0.8478078246,
0.0662572607,
-0.303024292,
-0.3334685564,
0.0688234791,
0.5108534694,
0.7987896204,
0.3465317488,
-0.0500097349,
1.0747663975,
-0.561406374,
0.2598217428,
0.3974058926,
-1.0657564402,
0.3789190054,
-0.060806755,
0.9979560375,
0.6789181232,
0.5778102875,
-0.7528896332,
-0.2069746554,
-0.0731204972,
-0.5433712602,
0.8556708097,
-0.4466301799,
0.1014904454,
0.188062042,
0.1631313711,
0.3517054617,
-0.0772471726,
-0.5745874047,
0.0462714657,
-0.1687243432,
-0.5556898713,
-0.0458070673,
-0.1089155748,
-0.1979691535,
-0.2662850916,
0.7826004624,
-0.2602655888,
-0.0169432648,
-0.6382671595,
-0.4143397212,
-0.6353759766,
0.0321719646,
0.6125942469,
0.7489898801,
0.2522133887,
0.0039457474,
0.3271304667,
-0.4679425657,
0.1242238134,
0.1315928102,
-0.0396330729,
-0.134926796,
0.4919623137,
0.9444938302,
0.9380196333,
-0.3636624217,
0.2115546912,
0.0516533144,
0.1347633898,
-0.2963718772,
0.0598686486,
0.3842740059,
0.4336356521,
-0.2689036429,
0.1943047494,
-0.6558164954,
-0.414064914,
-0.0462386869,
0.5213536024,
-0.6096169949,
-0.2620186806,
0.7536191344,
0.2221452296,
-0.3376497626,
0.9223851562,
-0.0386760384,
-0.2665297389,
0.2354245186,
0.9246736169,
0.8410770297,
-0.6030273438,
0.1557520181,
0.372974962,
0.3856413066,
-0.2045422196,
0.2107165754,
-0.0390039645,
-0.7388988137,
-0.6511252522,
-0.4728565812,
-0.2901322544,
0.1025380194,
-0.6661543846,
0.1262181699,
-0.4640306234,
0.1608153135,
-0.0634717718,
-0.4143503606,
-0.6363089085,
-0.1588205248,
0.167940408,
0.4152777791,
-0.8671962023,
1.1216542721,
0.6941432953,
-0.4638680518,
-0.589348495,
0.1796037853,
0.2431338131,
-1.0470930338,
0.5068876743,
0.1293726265,
-0.4277167916,
0.1709800065,
-0.5929088593,
-1.1614305973,
0.9794698954,
1.0492523909,
-0.8763402104,
0.050100185,
0.2910192907,
0.1700870544,
-0.3876416087,
-0.2889933288,
0.3748819828,
0.3910675049,
-0.0941877887,
-1.0141055584,
0.1998338103,
-0.0050879805,
-0.0769339204,
0.4805408418,
-0.7171737552,
0.5963683724,
-0.3403854966,
-0.5004805923,
0.0604806691,
0.4803123772,
-0.1071185917,
0.0244315732,
0.3364539444,
0.8412547112,
0.8510310054,
-0.1108175591,
0.5351675153,
-0.596501112,
0.0219601206,
1.3981583118,
-0.187064454,
0.5568951964,
0.4242969453,
0.1446071118,
0.439581871,
0.5424824357,
0.1428850591,
0.5130882859,
-0.0825554132,
-0.3862785399,
-0.6001423001,
-0.4520029128,
-0.3363673985,
0.5758224726,
0.5472376347,
-0.1058357954,
-0.2918779254,
0.2448117435,
0.2089685053,
0.2498663813,
-0.4080083966,
0.5889365673,
0.1451665163,
-0.7400892973,
1.0221480131,
-0.3391315639,
0.5468164086,
-0.5204011202,
-0.1254745871,
-0.2589422762,
0.5152714252,
-0.1933104992,
-0.6221934557,
0.0392531417,
-0.3233754635,
-0.3279987276,
-0.4857179523,
0.1740517318,
-0.9733701348,
-0.4836521447,
0.3714160323,
0.2773313224,
-0.1882320791,
0.393720746,
-0.7135269046,
0.0432283729,
0.033134304,
0.3309813738,
0.5331970453,
0.6834269166,
-0.3329473734,
0.7102969289,
0.3189632297,
-0.0912813097,
0.0825884268,
0.2706776261,
0.6971050501,
-0.4598605335,
-0.3246920109,
-0.7334244847,
0.4000807106,
0.2220382541,
-0.5702572465,
0.7929956913,
0.5974208713,
1.3484350443,
-0.125423789,
0.6325206161,
0.2941029966,
0.2929050326,
-0.9553830028,
0.7489709854,
-0.6747998595,
0.0942820758,
-0.1696278155,
-0.785522759,
-0.4294159114,
0.1377316266,
-0.1525443792,
-0.2847160399,
0.8120073676,
1.0648272038,
-0.4286090732,
-0.3828781843,
0.2709108591,
-0.0682539269,
-0.2793640494,
0.7970013618,
0.6981208324,
-0.1130764484,
0.6796384454,
-0.3478467762,
-0.1835275143,
-0.1373695284,
-0.5794901848,
-0.8532777429,
-0.5321605206,
-0.5531448722,
-0.0290317386,
0.1916607767,
0.8577091098,
0.6664649844,
-0.873631537,
-0.5400856137,
0.0371722095,
0.2614176869,
-0.394980669,
-0.1211533919,
0.3788646758,
-0.6738947034,
-0.8388592005,
0.6891943812,
0.5948027968,
0.0792955384,
-0.1662870049,
-0.3421435058,
-0.1760700643,
-0.5308679342,
0.2915276885,
0.6706926823,
-0.7102947235,
-0.231305182,
0.0057704733,
-0.1085614786,
0.1193854287,
0.8702504039,
-0.5683082342,
0.6832115054,
0.3057283759,
0.7905327082,
0.3148901165,
-0.3072148263,
0.8115027547,
-0.7059543133,
0.2584983706,
0.0865399912,
0.4622423351,
0.5275859237,
-0.4509756565,
0.080967091,
0.0401556343,
-0.5331549048,
-0.5943670273,
0.2723911405,
-0.5755839944,
-0.1184387803,
0.6011324525,
-0.0353086181,
-0.2942056358,
-0.1190873086,
0.0466097854,
0.5179407597,
-0.2448404282,
0.6663583517,
0.465084821,
0.0471226387,
-0.5146763325,
-0.2840130627,
0.4217336476,
0.6120064259,
-0.5911042094,
0.2188990563,
0.2744934857,
0.2432840317,
-0.1523684859,
0.2268403023,
0.047077205,
0.4182973206,
-0.0602377728,
0.2432479858,
0.0429715142,
-0.305588901,
-0.3814050853,
-0.2831446826,
0.1188634709,
-0.4417946935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13626v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13626v2 | Prompting and Evaluating Large Language Models for Proactive Dialogues: Clarification, Target-guided, and Non-collaboration | 2023-05-23T02:49:35 | 2023-10-14T06:36:05 | Yang Deng, Lizi Liao, Liang Chen, Hongru Wang, Wenqiang Lei, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational systems based on Large Language Models (LLMs), such as
ChatGPT, show exceptional proficiency in context understanding and response
generation. However, despite their impressive capabilities, they still possess
limitations, such as providing randomly-guessed answers to ambiguous queries or
failing to refuse users' requests, both of which are considered aspects of a
conversational agent's proactivity. This raises the question of whether
LLM-based conversational systems are equipped to handle proactive dialogue
problems. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of LLM-based
conversational systems, specifically focusing on three aspects of proactive
dialogue systems: clarification, target-guided, and non-collaborative
dialogues. To trigger the proactivity of LLMs, we propose the Proactive
Chain-of-Thought prompting scheme, which augments LLMs with the goal planning
capability over descriptive reasoning chains. Empirical findings are discussed
to promote future studies on LLM-based proactive dialogue systems. | [
-0.35890764,
-1.1557189226,
0.9344028234,
0.2602232397,
-0.1869703829,
0.135185644,
-0.3571532667,
-0.2883490026,
0.2486732751,
0.6429969072,
-0.8963467479,
-0.2031501979,
-0.2495531142,
0.0304410905,
-0.3295892179,
1.0434515476,
-0.0126863504,
0.0329174772,
-0.0521853194,
0.0210417006,
-0.8653210402,
-0.4705564678,
-0.7189281583,
-0.3572661877,
0.3851890564,
0.4053712785,
0.9144366384,
-0.1682520211,
0.5124951601,
0.3173128664,
-0.0960209519,
0.365506649,
-0.4420075715,
0.4579675496,
-0.1959771663,
-0.3222940862,
-0.5982983708,
-0.2799266875,
0.6932185292,
0.6511128545,
-0.1181632429,
-0.0044731796,
0.1641399562,
0.3753755391,
-0.4315813482,
0.4040275216,
-0.5357578993,
-0.2338031679,
0.2371296138,
-0.024508059,
-0.4907975793,
-0.369551003,
0.3163217604,
-0.4442043006,
-0.2560007274,
-0.1517916471,
0.3607105613,
0.046296306,
-0.2432505935,
-0.5838407874,
-0.8646989465,
0.6020018458,
-0.6580891609,
0.0693563372,
0.3819901049,
0.2013083696,
-0.6368855834,
-0.3592762351,
-0.5300890803,
-0.5192304254,
-0.0032431383,
0.1660007685,
-0.3704450428,
0.2926817536,
0.1348101497,
0.2281852514,
-0.5442913175,
-0.0294715557,
0.0575276017,
0.0508498549,
0.4134306312,
0.1274292767,
0.0903849453,
0.1242068931,
-0.1667679995,
0.3249125779,
-0.7793010473,
-0.086612843,
0.1961348206,
0.315715313,
0.201658085,
0.5956230164,
-0.3173523545,
0.8777805567,
0.0682824701,
0.0060236305,
-0.3464565277,
-0.4757384956,
-0.284432143,
-0.1389514953,
0.8908938766,
0.3479375243,
0.6425634027,
-0.0145892566,
-0.3194870651,
-0.0322188959,
0.1144791618,
-0.4940569103,
-0.1454139054,
0.3940603733,
-0.1655800641,
-0.1861942261,
-0.2357403785,
-0.1285245121,
-0.1618180126,
-0.1936618537,
0.6033902764,
-0.3218101859,
-0.4741687775,
0.1900188178,
0.1410811245,
0.0468728505,
0.3460505903,
-0.7684773207,
0.372852385,
0.6444977522,
0.6988581419,
0.2102536112,
0.0399975367,
-0.5096548796,
0.1171550155,
-0.4461811483,
0.8014431,
-0.7329519391,
-0.5973232985,
0.1287720352,
0.0342246182,
-0.2257517725,
-0.7889556289,
0.3817396462,
-0.6136716008,
0.0556938611,
-0.5711943507,
-0.3402173519,
-0.1393186301,
0.6593914032,
-0.4550469518,
0.647127986,
-0.0323273875,
-0.559217155,
-0.1136839762,
-0.6155022979,
-0.3676337302,
0.3274464607,
-0.1566975117,
0.0135644386,
0.1108131483,
0.1163018346,
0.3754882216,
-0.3298532963,
0.829246819,
0.0663583055,
-0.2818641663,
0.5329108834,
-0.3766717613,
0.3323223591,
0.1095723286,
-0.2522684932,
0.4120084941,
-0.4424266219,
0.155661732,
0.1442704201,
-0.3344911039,
-0.0056253029,
0.2176850885,
-0.3338693976,
0.1369813383,
0.3265120089,
-0.1931255311,
0.3112215102,
-0.2723149657,
0.5718732476,
0.6835449934,
0.23394081,
0.1174890772,
-0.4166199267,
0.6276041865,
-0.1346456259,
0.2268482447,
-0.470623821,
-0.6565189362,
-0.8283149004,
-0.1846980602,
-0.0705277026,
0.7469047904,
-0.9664562941,
0.4323938191,
0.015985474,
-0.3749355972,
-0.0125818402,
-0.0704410002,
0.68646878,
0.375913471,
0.1763279736,
-0.4630877078,
-0.4360562861,
-0.9028388262,
-0.1142879352,
-0.6748477817,
0.0495986864,
0.294295162,
0.3221250176,
-0.0619506538,
1.033488512,
-0.3100747466,
-0.0763798207,
-0.6406669617,
0.069581233,
0.3464389443,
0.2374081761,
-0.0036770774,
-0.4714033306,
-0.514606297,
-0.1780167967,
-0.6148997545,
-0.3096438944,
-0.3012638688,
0.0276693609,
-0.146421954,
0.3918211162,
-1.0116477013,
0.2570517361,
0.6040582657,
0.0035607412,
0.8955053687,
-0.199057892,
-0.1908278316,
-0.7570835948,
0.0683087558,
-0.141240865,
-0.2266620845,
-1.0219761133,
-0.2568641305,
-0.3570492566,
-0.0490040965,
-0.4347123504,
0.4729988873,
-0.2521243989,
-0.1266818792,
-0.4115729332,
0.2589586377,
-0.2094888985,
0.5099676251,
0.5207923651,
0.8173624277,
0.5027263761,
-0.9163116217,
0.273676157,
0.4249007404,
-0.4244794846,
0.5236430764,
-0.7390984893,
0.1946068853,
0.0839409158,
0.6170653105,
-0.9160069227,
-0.2279940993,
0.3796944618,
-0.1316296905,
-0.1463069022,
-0.0329075269,
-0.4489139915,
-0.2885780334,
0.1093869358,
0.2331189215,
0.3097027838,
-0.223601222,
0.3873117268,
0.0658483878,
-0.3647230566,
-0.3100678623,
-0.1411078274,
0.2502380311,
-0.0109531451,
-0.5329041481,
0.0872829631,
-0.1020516828,
-0.5772901773,
-0.2736062706,
-0.1005087644,
0.2571036518,
0.0150052821,
0.207528621,
0.2944431901,
0.0346096978,
0.0929302499,
-0.4403788149,
-0.0546024218,
0.1375991106,
-0.4615930915,
0.7562138438,
-0.269115746,
-0.5642570257,
-0.5940967202,
0.3738691509,
0.4900892675,
-0.3102844656,
0.6541844606,
0.2677482665,
-0.1065406203,
0.061420314,
-0.5656852126,
-0.4032880366,
-0.4996599555,
0.2243836075,
-0.3888601363,
-1.1339148283,
0.5808207393,
-0.2760403752,
0.088416256,
-0.0159745179,
0.8180011511,
-0.0513054132,
1.1774140596,
0.1054510698,
0.2173722535,
0.717980504,
-0.1351959407,
0.6844816208,
-0.8324121237,
-0.2654965818,
-0.2680018544,
-0.1395097971,
-0.4930664599,
-0.4781325161,
0.3460125625,
0.0827552602,
-0.1835746914,
0.4057222009,
-0.1923793405,
0.3902728856,
0.4474332631,
-0.0659084842,
0.2000176162,
-0.3181393445,
-0.2240791619,
0.3523180485,
-0.7344766259,
-0.797542274,
0.567191422,
0.3446694314,
0.6693781614,
0.2540788352,
0.4420854151,
-0.0119511699,
0.2196713388,
-0.9270353317,
1.0320355892,
0.3359186947,
-0.6720152497,
-0.3256856501,
-0.1294872016,
-1.008020401,
0.1642188281,
-0.1319895089,
-1.05656147,
0.1603384763,
0.0375444591,
-0.5728930235,
0.0859062895,
-0.7115787864,
0.6066477895,
-0.2188413292,
-0.395573765,
-0.2167714983,
-0.4090042114,
0.2645489275,
-0.0595056824,
0.2433950454,
-0.1379199475,
0.2514477372,
0.4802164435,
-0.3453836441,
1.050709486,
-0.2014344037,
-0.3927501142,
0.8428451419,
0.4910419285,
0.9325639009,
-0.0634291917,
0.0545376725,
-0.2887471616,
-0.1014278457,
-0.1358759105,
-0.6050963998,
0.5460673571,
-0.3596860766,
-1.1308435202,
0.0101880925,
-0.5442756414,
-0.5781755447,
0.1532796323,
-0.1448489279,
0.4152305424,
-0.3615155816,
0.1417069137,
0.6307093501,
-0.2174841464,
0.4358477294,
0.7241351008,
-0.3778749406,
-0.2022628486,
0.8095373511,
0.0360769443,
0.6935423613,
0.3044314682,
0.1452509314,
-0.4058022797,
-0.7309288383,
-0.1550407708,
0.2494488209,
-0.7069403529,
0.0404842161,
-0.5778657198,
-0.1743340194,
-0.3005920947,
-0.0345909372,
-0.15170452,
-0.2970166802,
-0.1588277072,
-0.0835789964,
0.0610435903,
0.9763711095,
0.115737319,
0.4991255403,
-0.9126948714,
0.0243858956,
0.5376645327,
0.1313249171,
0.013765092,
-0.2829746008,
-0.1280615628,
0.0525159165,
-0.4882567823,
-1.0066282749,
0.2926011682,
0.0407681577,
0.6023655534,
0.5426736474,
0.1576246321,
0.5087465644,
-0.3634929061,
0.9658412933,
0.1701679677,
-0.7464720011,
0.8601347804,
-0.7426019311,
0.5027054548,
0.3448096812,
0.2191394567,
-0.6093448997,
-0.558023572,
-0.5244095922,
-0.5382685065,
0.6006811261,
0.4100650847,
0.2114326954,
-0.460401386,
0.1837788969,
-0.2897584438,
0.2315460294,
-0.5816744566,
0.3045631051,
0.1691965908,
0.0041329628,
0.0462299697,
-0.3265585899,
-0.2000540197,
0.2811355591,
0.5086647868,
-0.3091915548,
0.2721456885,
0.3198026121,
-0.0099903867,
-0.0394884646,
0.6885121465,
0.6063105464,
0.6204205155,
-0.0999699757,
-0.0338291824,
0.2852047086,
-0.2481734008,
0.1883303821,
-0.4192124307,
-0.0255521275,
-0.2652152479,
0.3013271689,
0.8891577125,
0.1907242537,
-0.988681674,
0.3045797646,
-0.0944394991,
-0.2613231242,
-0.0718638822,
0.2975957692,
0.1341470778,
0.4865432382,
0.1602951586,
-0.1892725378,
0.0279039182,
-0.7895325422,
-0.2406993657,
0.786673665,
-0.5268723369,
-0.4006157815,
0.1568209827,
0.3283934593,
-0.6627983451,
0.6566630602,
-0.1841510981,
-0.7213152051,
0.4551630914,
0.6206023097,
0.8518791795,
-0.2643430233,
0.4335179329,
0.1532405466,
0.1819625944,
-0.2496020496,
0.3629454672,
-0.3705968857,
-0.9114344716,
-0.7436323762,
-0.2904680073,
-0.7446079254,
0.237333253,
-0.4082432687,
0.1075766608,
-0.5661743283,
-0.4790810943,
-0.2701308131,
-0.0850937739,
-0.3436961472,
0.1141076311,
0.0788710788,
0.7865689397,
-0.6353284717,
0.8459841013,
0.6577884555,
-0.0834171399,
-0.789988637,
0.0652209744,
-0.1144201979,
-0.7349115014,
0.7439143062,
0.1164588556,
-0.4079455733,
0.0250190143,
-0.3301113546,
-0.5731427073,
0.8371590972,
0.2668746114,
-0.8673666716,
0.0065571694,
0.1948529035,
0.6244224906,
-0.4171001911,
0.3860630989,
0.7213711143,
0.5760345459,
0.3475500643,
-1.3540761471,
0.1023120359,
-0.0866291001,
-0.1125375181,
0.082240887,
-0.7564360499,
0.4567112923,
-0.279125154,
-0.112675786,
0.2348929197,
0.1897559315,
0.454011023,
0.0427900925,
0.6125255823,
0.2505012155,
0.5910215378,
-0.16479972,
0.9120104909,
-0.2179439068,
-0.0889716372,
1.114343524,
-0.635115087,
0.8755315542,
0.3968088925,
-0.1740835607,
0.480240196,
0.5393744707,
0.3068823516,
0.343690455,
0.2594554126,
-0.6826475263,
-0.5479797721,
-0.3996650279,
-0.0601562038,
0.4776029587,
0.6943563819,
-0.1175552011,
-0.0611803718,
-0.1151154563,
0.0294626895,
-0.2157796472,
-0.1208703369,
1.0399380922,
0.0525863804,
-1.3556730747,
0.5352925062,
-0.1702422053,
0.1906432062,
-0.6205863953,
0.2032309622,
-0.075551115,
0.1145060733,
-0.0803846791,
-0.9272603989,
0.2732166946,
0.03085755,
0.1213547662,
-0.4423922896,
0.7495247126,
-0.2847597301,
-0.1095786616,
0.1268437803,
0.6308841705,
0.1889389604,
-0.1333338767,
-0.7339330912,
0.2068952322,
0.0074310401,
-0.3797318935,
0.3033281863,
0.2447219193,
-0.4657904804,
0.9267948866,
0.7409338355,
-0.0066729751,
-0.4081825614,
0.3351982534,
0.9756539464,
-0.3472030461,
-0.3718504906,
-0.8201450706,
0.3430632949,
0.1772104949,
0.2228996307,
0.7044206262,
0.1449582279,
0.4303134382,
0.1426752657,
0.7609070539,
0.0790201351,
0.2593215406,
-0.469409436,
0.064069964,
0.0105284126,
0.4928837419,
-0.1547151059,
-1.0110499859,
-0.1942604333,
0.7166830301,
-0.7823842168,
0.1280277818,
0.5530825853,
0.9250999689,
0.4287868142,
0.3044576049,
0.3739244342,
0.0731539726,
0.6906190515,
0.6238261461,
1.3643120527,
0.1241284758,
0.5246307254,
0.4848562777,
-0.2472772896,
-0.3733070493,
-0.8086566925,
-0.9359261394,
-0.3755372167,
-0.3693254888,
-0.224901706,
0.1634649485,
0.8708538413,
0.6715394258,
-0.8002613783,
-0.261569947,
-0.4387138188,
0.09402363,
-0.1568721384,
-0.1730226725,
0.0290640872,
-0.4332826734,
-0.6463301778,
0.662029922,
0.5335288644,
0.1169890985,
-0.5151306987,
-0.2056940347,
-0.274210006,
0.4831801355,
0.6654704213,
0.291193068,
-0.7965980172,
-0.165332526,
0.1231219769,
0.3152682185,
-0.2206385285,
1.0776816607,
-0.7220152617,
0.3962234855,
0.4836176336,
0.1498887539,
0.1912026852,
-0.0220963452,
0.6753320098,
-0.5432730317,
0.0301499981,
0.3252325952,
0.1455171555,
0.1962665468,
-0.19375135,
0.2508755326,
-0.0639597625,
-0.7361529469,
-0.7279196978,
0.6291401982,
-0.6169147491,
-0.2339595556,
1.3085969687,
-0.2923036516,
0.0622286126,
-0.3597766757,
-0.653745234,
0.0033673751,
-0.2571510971,
0.2974486947,
0.9813638926,
-0.4677239358,
-0.3245804012,
-0.6202719808,
0.4044775963,
0.5114403367,
-0.5731601715,
0.35602808,
0.4768211544,
-0.0680260956,
0.2135748118,
1.0666491985,
0.0794046745,
0.0232864413,
-0.2990291715,
-0.3442938626,
0.1667977571,
-0.4149871767,
0.0171363335,
-0.0552647449,
0.4701607525,
0.1026255861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13623v1 | Validating Multimedia Content Moderation Software via Semantic Fusion | 2023-05-23T02:44:15 | 2023-05-23T02:44:15 | Wenxuan Wang, Jingyuan Huang, Chang Chen, Jiazhen Gu, Jianping Zhang, Weibin Wu, Pinjia He, Michael Lyu | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | The exponential growth of social media platforms, such as Facebook and
TikTok, has revolutionized communication and content publication in human
society. Users on these platforms can publish multimedia content that delivers
information via the combination of text, audio, images, and video. Meanwhile,
the multimedia content release facility has been increasingly exploited to
propagate toxic content, such as hate speech, malicious advertisements, and
pornography. To this end, content moderation software has been widely deployed
on these platforms to detect and blocks toxic content. However, due to the
complexity of content moderation models and the difficulty of understanding
information across multiple modalities, existing content moderation software
can fail to detect toxic content, which often leads to extremely negative
impacts.
We introduce Semantic Fusion, a general, effective methodology for validating
multimedia content moderation software. Our key idea is to fuse two or more
existing single-modal inputs (e.g., a textual sentence and an image) into a new
input that combines the semantics of its ancestors in a novel manner and has
toxic nature by construction. This fused input is then used for validating
multimedia content moderation software. We realized Semantic Fusion as DUO, a
practical content moderation software testing tool. In our evaluation, we
employ DUO to test five commercial content moderation software and two
state-of-the-art models against three kinds of toxic content. The results show
that DUO achieves up to 100% error finding rate (EFR) when testing moderation
software. In addition, we leverage the test cases generated by DUO to retrain
the two models we explored, which largely improves model robustness while
maintaining the accuracy on the original test set. | [
-0.4234626889,
-0.8995100856,
0.3046525419,
0.2268660814,
-0.5217084885,
-0.0635622218,
-0.1297629029,
-0.2677182853,
-0.0444238521,
0.690402329,
-0.6160006523,
-0.7388228774,
-0.5936823487,
0.0523381978,
-0.6636414528,
0.943919301,
-0.1170438677,
-0.0286690518,
-0.3918347061,
-0.3983676732,
-0.8725028634,
0.3594975471,
-0.5170000196,
-0.2615522146,
0.4076431692,
0.3459951878,
0.7193675637,
0.2257851064,
0.5852828622,
0.383135289,
0.1586037725,
0.503428936,
-0.7014093995,
0.2593204081,
-0.3000585139,
0.033547923,
-0.0351794958,
0.0047199945,
0.4266479015,
0.2937683165,
0.1721112132,
0.2442994714,
-0.0350693688,
0.4277453125,
-0.753636837,
-0.0508051291,
-0.6923564672,
0.0876534507,
0.1643953174,
-0.4595829844,
-0.4585933089,
-0.2289000601,
-0.2032239437,
-0.7294322252,
-0.2045174241,
0.0705184788,
0.9551042914,
0.5155082941,
-0.9089929461,
-0.1305238158,
-0.9706587195,
0.7934048176,
-0.4063260257,
0.4453596771,
0.3150504827,
0.293212682,
-0.2529614568,
-0.5388461947,
-0.9913598895,
-0.0667422488,
0.1025540605,
0.2306168526,
-0.0190537963,
-0.0629502013,
-0.0172660984,
0.3566973507,
-0.6623850465,
0.1921904832,
-0.2962388098,
-0.591416955,
0.6737605333,
0.2131317109,
0.9275299907,
-0.4752374291,
-0.7810271978,
-0.2376425117,
-0.4969956875,
-0.1415192634,
0.5360722542,
-0.1343663335,
-0.1330815405,
0.7496162057,
-0.0405799672,
0.8378967047,
-0.217106849,
-0.2454302907,
0.0828174576,
-0.723092854,
0.0017650985,
0.0436387397,
0.9121557474,
0.9948815703,
-0.4723291993,
-0.177503854,
-0.0911698788,
0.6850810051,
0.1831099987,
-0.4975718558,
-0.3354042172,
0.4833529294,
-0.3999768198,
-0.3287867904,
0.2128924131,
-0.6705227494,
-0.5467579961,
-0.0850266293,
0.9960482121,
-0.5047214031,
-0.5284124613,
0.2452566028,
-0.5189900994,
0.3728501201,
0.2705000937,
-0.4392961264,
0.0856268927,
1.0767278671,
0.6440168023,
-0.4023635387,
-0.1781026721,
-0.722672224,
0.4330976307,
-0.0865509361,
0.9710561633,
-0.2961380184,
-0.2675332129,
-0.097486183,
-0.1871538013,
0.263332814,
-0.5384124517,
0.7275942564,
-0.8533417583,
0.119356446,
-0.3466548324,
-0.5839734674,
-0.1859545857,
0.4767597318,
-0.8851271272,
0.877384901,
0.1953980327,
-0.9179165959,
0.7667524815,
-0.4720911384,
-0.3810662329,
0.1463425159,
-0.0894460604,
-0.3373359144,
-0.4113674164,
-0.3013857305,
0.0744060874,
-0.2003273666,
0.222143203,
-0.462809056,
-0.5274317861,
0.2505289912,
-0.1602761894,
0.8548024893,
0.249968648,
-0.2910231352,
0.4294634163,
-0.4316619039,
0.0087197842,
-0.0036480061,
-0.3495966792,
-0.5192162395,
0.1520434618,
0.3153533936,
0.5522993207,
-0.1448138952,
-0.9412693381,
-0.3016489744,
-0.0368191376,
0.2334646583,
0.6908438802,
0.2085418254,
0.209706381,
-0.534517467,
-0.049448546,
0.3529545367,
0.3072064221,
-0.0198785327,
-0.5067431927,
-0.5940969586,
0.0154436314,
0.2537503541,
0.627140224,
-1.1849001646,
0.8741809726,
-0.3859857321,
-0.6774820089,
-0.4141491652,
0.6526067853,
0.2380167991,
0.6187183261,
0.1592244804,
-0.506878674,
-0.4245197475,
-0.6998791695,
-0.0337504409,
-0.3364230394,
-0.1188502908,
0.2072392553,
0.3745476305,
-0.4569538236,
1.0079529285,
-0.2373043448,
-0.3877242506,
-0.1842158288,
0.2536107898,
-0.2441143841,
0.6129594445,
0.2482638359,
-1.3754942417,
-0.3229799569,
-0.2470395714,
-0.6940909028,
-0.1766701639,
0.0079692816,
-0.3641830385,
0.0007311535,
0.0665432215,
-0.1851002276,
0.1649614871,
0.8954893351,
-0.5474475026,
0.4478724003,
-0.0257693157,
0.5309411883,
-0.980040133,
-0.0649924055,
0.0746215582,
-0.283981055,
-0.3307009935,
0.277656287,
-0.1291119754,
-0.0874622986,
-0.5801463723,
0.1927767545,
0.2091907561,
0.0052417447,
-0.3180423379,
0.4029699564,
0.1284342706,
0.0972756073,
-0.1027991027,
0.2928248048,
0.2868455648,
-0.6365990043,
1.0122549534,
0.1354681402,
-0.2427395582,
0.8248367906,
-0.7385768294,
-0.14765203,
-0.3028057814,
0.4482865334,
-1.3324644566,
-0.3770129085,
0.2493192554,
-0.2220684886,
-0.2188080996,
-0.0730214715,
-0.9849383831,
-0.3207262158,
-0.5733016133,
0.3462290168,
0.5088573694,
-0.2971169651,
0.5565079451,
0.6144657731,
0.3193091452,
-0.1162569672,
-0.6732678413,
-0.0437990502,
-0.1323913485,
-1.3489394188,
0.4783697426,
-0.1964849383,
-0.1947169751,
0.4177801907,
-0.1113474071,
-0.146788314,
0.1173369512,
0.4521734715,
0.3749680519,
-0.0660472959,
0.0619066954,
0.2827219367,
-0.3578739762,
-0.0599373393,
0.019801138,
0.5672694445,
-0.0535524487,
-0.5455003381,
-0.4541010857,
0.5456473231,
0.5185182691,
-0.2607932091,
0.5665450692,
1.3378480673,
-0.2367544323,
-0.0724154115,
-0.7599208355,
-0.2563100457,
-0.4639555216,
0.1038487479,
0.3062795699,
-0.9624649286,
0.532171309,
-0.106864132,
0.2220580578,
0.5281100273,
0.4662942886,
0.1716488153,
1.1523941755,
0.4598594308,
0.3145401478,
0.2122915238,
-0.3015425205,
0.1018069685,
-0.5290825367,
-0.2540008426,
-0.1445414126,
-0.4260010719,
-0.6278982162,
-0.3038758337,
0.8381771445,
-0.5845099092,
0.0031571374,
0.3359574378,
-0.2173801959,
0.6344686747,
0.6188597679,
0.385092169,
0.6057528853,
-0.2085653245,
-0.0885430574,
-0.1041321456,
-0.4272344112,
-0.3511146009,
0.500428617,
0.1319759935,
0.6278635263,
0.5253976583,
0.5745800734,
0.539537549,
0.1425346881,
-0.7187253833,
0.6130409241,
-0.3624879718,
-0.7556949258,
-0.1521163881,
-0.3898682892,
-0.4161988199,
0.1259038746,
-0.5558739305,
-0.2415308505,
-0.2556755543,
0.081506215,
-0.5617725253,
0.3778019547,
-0.7437218428,
1.071632266,
0.0508621335,
-0.6726695895,
-0.4356848896,
-0.7732937932,
0.6577454805,
-0.1080550477,
0.2102978081,
-0.2413239628,
-0.2684834898,
0.5424160957,
-0.3477295935,
0.6586403847,
-0.0466850996,
-0.0964945257,
0.4074934721,
0.4666223228,
0.0307285301,
0.1194048226,
0.1962333918,
-0.0874425471,
0.3302236199,
-0.189932555,
-0.6438721418,
0.8961828351,
-0.7446910143,
-0.297662586,
-0.1038003564,
-0.4708980024,
-0.1823401898,
0.3514605165,
0.1765324771,
0.2540893853,
0.0905972645,
0.2941529155,
0.8064915538,
-0.4062011838,
0.1631929427,
0.4938224554,
-0.2113137096,
-0.235597536,
1.0933107138,
-0.3167092502,
0.3448156416,
-0.0364230275,
0.3708230257,
-0.0476705059,
-0.2543520331,
-0.5128991008,
0.0512235761,
-0.7636848092,
-0.3129366934,
-0.6347057819,
-0.1503647864,
-0.4007126391,
-0.0431522466,
-0.3028276265,
0.0417485535,
0.160659194,
0.2424808145,
0.1146845818,
0.4068914354,
-0.1015498117,
-0.0042095878,
-1.1762074232,
0.47476843,
0.3391900659,
0.5516139269,
-0.3893555999,
-0.1314951032,
0.4164846241,
0.1465262324,
-0.3369942904,
-1.05643332,
-0.1428322941,
-0.0230091661,
0.3808900118,
0.4057629406,
0.2550118566,
0.3876139224,
0.044925034,
1.0033222437,
0.0683955029,
-0.8259844184,
0.6791886091,
-0.5367156863,
0.0671816468,
0.7662338018,
0.4313265681,
-0.8699734211,
-0.4232252836,
-0.3922394812,
-0.6536461711,
0.2861404419,
0.1083977297,
0.4784810841,
0.0825871527,
0.0310213361,
0.1966481954,
-0.1023326293,
-0.6886774898,
-0.1241909564,
-0.2316453755,
-0.1909565777,
0.239273414,
-0.3915560842,
-0.2626807988,
-0.1806576401,
0.7221147418,
0.1235943288,
-0.0941416919,
-0.0134112872,
-0.2390971333,
-0.3140284419,
0.1201380789,
0.2916041315,
0.2560460269,
-0.1064638197,
0.3859331012,
-0.1935338527,
-0.3464809656,
0.1389825493,
-0.2059881538,
-0.4199190438,
-0.0282089021,
0.1251123697,
0.2600924671,
0.4939477444,
-0.9732658267,
0.8776966929,
-0.1499708742,
-0.0594491921,
-0.1545633376,
0.323359549,
-0.0439206809,
-0.072877124,
-0.0954213068,
-0.0339794718,
0.4137702286,
-0.5017638803,
0.5097076297,
0.3387892842,
-0.4830060601,
-0.0619482733,
0.4349138439,
0.4199144542,
0.3545866609,
0.6479998231,
-0.4274682701,
-0.5506535172,
0.2940354347,
0.5680411458,
0.6037414074,
0.0935563296,
0.5206837058,
0.2732414603,
0.2406799793,
0.1950433403,
0.205361262,
-0.2829101682,
-0.9027014375,
-0.543526113,
-0.6159040332,
-0.2777818441,
-0.1507675499,
-0.1860945523,
0.5551951528,
-0.3936383128,
-0.1220868379,
0.1339078844,
0.0058014425,
-0.1744724065,
-0.1150623411,
0.1053356305,
0.8750071526,
-1.3269079924,
0.2205298245,
0.6994712353,
-0.5236580968,
-0.7830036879,
-0.3917293549,
0.4715730548,
-0.4271158278,
0.4671996236,
0.2310520709,
-0.0883497521,
-0.0764977634,
-0.5027287006,
-0.5040763617,
1.0370397568,
0.1019149125,
0.3132629693,
0.1978316456,
0.1682059616,
0.3555996716,
0.0359402746,
-0.1370675713,
0.1427120268,
0.6283100843,
0.8764475584,
-0.6993688345,
0.1219707578,
-0.4655479193,
0.0216655154,
0.219044283,
-0.3645505309,
0.6678670645,
-0.0045974771,
-0.3653394878,
-0.1717063636,
0.5462726355,
0.1545785367,
0.4454536736,
1.0008161068,
0.656773448,
0.1022554338,
-0.1335983723,
0.8095129132,
-0.2274451107,
0.2603988349,
0.7920523286,
-0.4269425869,
0.6599087715,
0.5316063762,
0.2122951895,
0.7935535312,
0.5585401058,
-0.3534120917,
0.3318832517,
-0.1398938596,
-0.573189497,
-0.6263021231,
-0.7080495954,
-0.1270712763,
0.6994745135,
0.2254238725,
-0.1602874249,
-0.5956140757,
0.0330217592,
0.1355288178,
0.2208493948,
-0.0929034427,
0.911046207,
-0.3160730898,
-0.7938956022,
-0.0957022756,
0.3719305396,
0.6900514364,
-0.5002320409,
-0.1211207584,
0.2532748878,
0.0959730521,
-0.4842030406,
-0.9393129945,
0.6698763371,
-0.1837898046,
0.3166157305,
0.0272430796,
1.2621901035,
-0.5008695126,
-0.1821586788,
0.0872995257,
0.2664945424,
-0.3160089552,
-0.0042821835,
-0.5059743524,
0.6832131743,
-0.4379639924,
0.5014002919,
0.0119159669,
-0.0303787049,
0.1632842124,
0.4716003537,
0.9074985981,
-0.1302753091,
0.0536092594,
-0.1578088403,
0.8867660165,
-0.0791901276,
-0.5989190936,
-0.7465401888,
0.4791488349,
-0.2946036756,
0.0816909596,
0.9108391404,
0.513980031,
0.994797349,
0.1605985612,
0.4468820691,
-0.367051661,
-0.0219002683,
-0.3328609169,
0.7661529779,
-0.4354815781,
0.0887274146,
-0.436514467,
-0.7083775401,
-0.5041917562,
0.0749057308,
-0.1366294473,
-0.0123171108,
0.4004133046,
0.8806907535,
-0.2597380877,
0.3965599835,
0.1994879544,
0.0084388321,
0.3781161606,
0.6457276344,
0.8215098381,
-0.4657167196,
0.5378540754,
-0.6389241815,
-0.4114913642,
-0.1840581894,
-0.9571977854,
-0.5543929338,
-0.858710587,
-0.415768683,
-0.8845673203,
-0.2049824148,
0.9729170203,
0.6068168879,
-0.4465637207,
0.0922014043,
0.1884836704,
0.4944621921,
-0.1281962991,
-0.2487958223,
-0.0530732721,
0.0987299457,
-0.3615111411,
-0.250009805,
0.5324140191,
-0.0767649636,
-0.7123572826,
0.0050848071,
-0.1480581313,
-0.1279443949,
0.6455813646,
0.0999368057,
-0.6627405882,
-0.4076280892,
-0.0648657009,
-0.2006628364,
-0.3281293213,
0.8233405352,
-0.5616366267,
0.6413245201,
0.8250082731,
0.5963924527,
-0.0074293232,
-0.08617118,
0.3074704707,
-0.4946095347,
-0.1141197532,
0.0720550418,
0.1286247224,
0.4376392961,
-0.1465235502,
0.2268738598,
0.5351479053,
-0.2944299281,
-0.7365093231,
0.3424852192,
-1.4213167429,
0.0485118106,
1.2974300385,
0.0167443734,
-0.4248896241,
-0.1144846678,
-0.2588261068,
0.378993094,
0.0458644964,
0.9477655888,
0.6502133608,
0.1653441787,
0.1102967039,
-0.2420138568,
0.1807364374,
0.2947642803,
-0.6591343284,
-0.2508987784,
0.8559725285,
0.672794044,
0.2988586426,
0.3114331961,
-0.4788308144,
0.6823354363,
0.0898731872,
-0.3205911815,
-0.2499441803,
-0.0317762494,
-0.0015596634,
0.1650097519,
-0.3046635985,
0.0374694243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13617v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13617v3 | SPEECH: Structured Prediction with Energy-Based Event-Centric Hyperspheres | 2023-05-23T02:28:09 | 2023-09-18T10:19:10 | Shumin Deng, Shengyu Mao, Ningyu Zhang, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Event-centric structured prediction involves predicting structured outputs of
events. In most NLP cases, event structures are complex with manifold
dependency, and it is challenging to effectively represent these complicated
structured events. To address these issues, we propose Structured Prediction
with Energy-based Event-Centric Hyperspheres (SPEECH). SPEECH models complex
dependency among event structured components with energy-based modeling, and
represents event classes with simple but effective hyperspheres. Experiments on
two unified-annotated event datasets indicate that SPEECH is predominant in
event detection and event-relation extraction tasks. | [
-0.0758323669,
-0.7398844361,
0.5486800075,
0.2888052166,
0.0415637791,
-0.0057266285,
-0.3274727464,
-0.6936029196,
0.6072235107,
0.4278233051,
-0.6628369093,
-0.4821254611,
-0.2685181797,
-0.1764747798,
-0.1183579937,
0.9950306416,
0.502227366,
0.0092109814,
-0.4740295112,
0.1367837191,
-0.5184977055,
-0.8286190033,
-0.3459804058,
-0.7613582611,
0.4861656427,
0.1585916877,
0.5905057192,
0.8472232819,
0.2637695074,
0.2502851486,
-0.2747845948,
-0.1855098158,
-0.1718974113,
0.3756169677,
-0.1786295772,
-0.4830884933,
-0.4932014644,
0.1634839773,
0.4866796434,
1.1254743338,
-0.4717045724,
0.2256670147,
-0.1107088104,
0.4897735417,
-0.7068576813,
0.7858954668,
-0.9728556275,
0.3958545029,
-0.4472526312,
-0.3636808693,
-0.556211412,
0.4997831881,
-0.042013403,
-0.5729857683,
0.1721691638,
0.3791861534,
0.3408850431,
0.2343530506,
-0.2998806536,
0.0603288971,
-1.0952293873,
1.0505689383,
-0.2760074735,
0.6980087757,
0.5605506897,
0.1450487971,
-0.4225594699,
-0.8606308699,
-0.5504016876,
0.0252686441,
-0.2184111178,
0.3001720905,
-0.0686153397,
0.3577464521,
0.4244107008,
-0.0834009498,
-0.5072786808,
0.0857110545,
-0.1455422044,
0.0143026365,
0.453050971,
0.330028832,
0.1155479252,
-0.8201701045,
-0.2437580675,
0.4328222275,
-0.381798476,
-0.0051691676,
0.1702328622,
0.880934298,
0.0097720465,
0.6658692956,
-0.4303566217,
0.777602613,
0.067658022,
-0.2914085388,
0.1676753908,
-0.0520154759,
-0.3699550927,
0.7841244936,
0.4559496343,
0.2261690944,
0.1101414114,
-0.3132708967,
0.2033168674,
0.2051275522,
0.0287310239,
-0.8701124191,
-0.3081165254,
0.5930423141,
-0.4706763029,
-0.2160144448,
-0.2598498464,
-0.7078357339,
-0.2713576257,
-0.5637993813,
0.0602684654,
-0.1167998686,
-0.1800214201,
0.2366290689,
-0.3026852906,
-0.045420818,
0.1514445394,
-1.0887922049,
0.4042525887,
1.0079648495,
0.7354984283,
0.0052934787,
0.0873928815,
-0.8377552629,
0.673588872,
0.2415551096,
1.0248367786,
-0.9529513717,
-0.360198468,
0.0292925145,
-0.1496729255,
0.0687515438,
-0.1542640328,
0.8207622766,
-0.2136101425,
0.469938755,
0.0195465274,
-0.9698034525,
-0.1490647346,
-0.1587793231,
-0.5291546583,
0.7657997608,
-0.2478080243,
-0.9328996539,
0.4668871164,
-0.6993048191,
-0.5047830343,
0.6350454688,
-0.4369785488,
-0.4174948037,
0.0199444704,
-0.0294401329,
0.4536287785,
0.0751530677,
0.305462271,
-0.4403774738,
0.071260646,
-0.1752431393,
-0.0907352343,
0.4440199137,
-0.0760325566,
-0.2880576551,
0.0991249532,
-1.5632181168,
-0.0024909049,
-0.1122935936,
-0.2728765011,
-0.4404599965,
0.7374072671,
0.3862808049,
0.0527329147,
0.1679788381,
-0.9763646126,
0.2411580384,
-0.5207009315,
0.160462603,
0.7058777213,
-0.0189780612,
0.409617126,
0.1752775013,
0.3973818123,
0.1038538441,
0.0228043348,
-0.1872886568,
-0.5957551599,
-0.1424540877,
-0.0719909891,
-0.2040561885,
0.5334767103,
-0.52310884,
0.4231546521,
0.1151512414,
-0.7214585543,
0.1417555511,
-0.2558679283,
0.3824456632,
0.8627592921,
0.4299773574,
0.1755799502,
-1.1525660753,
-0.5867586732,
-0.4097781777,
-0.5072683096,
0.0283085145,
0.1705119908,
0.2406562716,
-0.0933967531,
0.903988421,
-0.6433520913,
-0.3554065526,
-0.1691140383,
0.0888322145,
0.3203894794,
0.6559863687,
0.4169689715,
-0.9143816829,
-0.2603675723,
0.0483483113,
-0.6613759995,
0.1014226899,
0.2099045962,
0.0888955146,
-0.006063981,
0.4923148155,
-0.4507050514,
0.4916959107,
0.5954298377,
-0.5848346353,
0.8173734546,
0.3427685499,
-0.3975850046,
-1.1121983528,
-0.1009901837,
-0.0755298734,
-0.4059886634,
-0.8077507019,
-0.7701188326,
-0.3302033842,
-0.3076714575,
-0.5470520258,
0.3046303391,
-0.2909983695,
-0.4479595721,
-0.3405655622,
-0.1065212563,
0.2417092323,
0.5425686836,
0.4277316928,
0.2795577943,
0.6309859157,
-0.6279049516,
0.6133925319,
0.5144051909,
-0.5245395899,
0.4822016358,
-0.8547652364,
0.1995911598,
-0.1474090368,
0.5300273299,
-0.6109399199,
-0.4780362248,
-0.1622221619,
-0.4242079556,
0.338519007,
-0.3075005114,
-0.2769024074,
-0.0881471187,
0.0571187437,
0.2877293825,
0.1166962311,
-0.3415535986,
0.8918260932,
0.6908507943,
-0.2665260136,
-0.6106263399,
-0.4170042276,
-0.1321870387,
-0.0064372569,
-0.5114067197,
0.4886893034,
0.1843854487,
-0.3144831657,
0.366963923,
0.0282002557,
0.1430768669,
0.1400583088,
1.1174098253,
0.2467675507,
-0.3026838303,
0.3691391349,
-0.368155241,
-0.2043284923,
0.0634869039,
-0.8078546524,
0.5187821984,
-0.2313379794,
-0.2338809371,
-0.7505518198,
0.6075308323,
0.5921797156,
0.0420877486,
1.0096995831,
0.6572514772,
-0.766361773,
0.1676083952,
-0.3905083239,
-0.0647745952,
-0.4030506015,
0.5770456195,
-0.4794823825,
-0.8000583649,
0.501716733,
0.0400336459,
0.1384714097,
0.5891438127,
0.7072474957,
-0.3723065257,
1.5397564173,
0.8374771476,
-0.0164324064,
0.7998167276,
0.0580170117,
0.0202869084,
-1.0535054207,
-0.5182267427,
-0.7967832685,
-0.2338393927,
-0.7045041919,
0.018559292,
0.4582005143,
-0.2166785747,
-0.0877480805,
0.3486747146,
-0.3347685039,
0.3297009468,
0.4735758007,
-0.3790588677,
0.108935751,
-0.0910346359,
0.1684711576,
-0.0485486574,
-0.7372336388,
-0.3216592073,
0.7154579759,
0.0021927678,
0.4234994948,
-0.2119256705,
0.3715225756,
0.1221162602,
-0.0673711672,
-0.9232637286,
0.2145062238,
0.0226314962,
-0.8221209645,
-0.3494570553,
-0.3918643594,
-1.2299410105,
0.1062111035,
-0.4515267909,
-0.9661975503,
0.2788434029,
-0.1020698547,
-0.5394128561,
0.3248965442,
-0.3568383455,
0.6341811419,
0.308771342,
-0.305577904,
-0.361770004,
-0.4385871291,
-0.0657489374,
0.4013952613,
0.4530095458,
-0.493398577,
0.4340236783,
1.2170795202,
-0.2587885857,
0.7252197266,
-0.2564975023,
0.4863392711,
0.3017932177,
0.0743783712,
0.4759119451,
0.1300176978,
-0.5057685971,
-0.0122842854,
0.0502051339,
-0.6067401171,
-0.7566175461,
0.5363618135,
-0.6624571681,
-0.6279987097,
-0.3086183667,
-0.3050865531,
-0.5204966664,
-0.0326107591,
0.3114728332,
1.0423228741,
-0.4025064111,
0.2621482313,
0.3065942228,
0.1493960172,
0.5422772169,
0.3399446905,
-0.4032474458,
-0.3647166491,
0.510681808,
0.1447094828,
-0.1016079634,
0.39991045,
0.3399685025,
-0.2607269287,
-0.294947058,
-0.2972607911,
-0.0623559952,
-0.4192195535,
-0.3900342584,
-0.9853086472,
-0.163429901,
-0.5007206798,
-0.2762066424,
-0.5767992139,
-0.8184019327,
-0.3053431511,
-0.7533271909,
0.2062328607,
0.7336260676,
-0.268573761,
0.2205444127,
-0.8173758984,
0.0994519964,
0.3630469739,
0.3158556819,
-0.3229666948,
-0.2336431742,
-0.5369507074,
-0.2530221641,
-0.1755520254,
-0.7012588978,
0.419459343,
0.5698467493,
0.3654228747,
0.3979978561,
-0.1951479614,
0.4341321588,
-0.669295609,
0.9521183968,
0.588504076,
-0.887625277,
1.1544169188,
-0.3579551876,
-0.0322029442,
0.2372516394,
0.2450685948,
-0.6610910296,
-0.2302674204,
-1.0299912691,
-0.8293383718,
0.6918970346,
0.2153106779,
-0.1336122453,
-0.1275135577,
0.4556503892,
0.0229134634,
0.3792442083,
-0.5996100307,
-0.2621443868,
-0.1946201324,
0.0847657025,
0.0006469978,
-0.3809910417,
-0.044486586,
-0.1620426327,
0.6961455345,
-0.0177014079,
-0.0007037129,
0.3123940229,
0.3239720762,
-0.4709825516,
0.0918475911,
0.3277764916,
0.4351637661,
-0.6132860184,
0.3038386405,
-0.1741953641,
-0.5430108905,
0.051623214,
-0.1389181465,
0.0113782529,
0.3255055249,
0.7532682419,
1.062590003,
0.3348425627,
-0.3993978798,
0.1983662844,
0.0212547779,
0.266269654,
-0.5355126858,
0.0193930101,
0.0916278288,
0.1767219454,
0.3230472505,
0.0541184917,
0.4423703849,
-0.9858628511,
0.2716264725,
0.2027039528,
-0.97572124,
-0.8272486329,
0.755933702,
0.4970073402,
-0.3508357108,
0.4330923557,
-0.2168941796,
-0.7805243731,
0.6239303946,
0.6166587472,
0.8700404763,
-0.2069422156,
-0.0807738528,
0.4670309126,
-0.2013962269,
0.3517435789,
0.4627725482,
0.0704268664,
-0.7005497217,
-0.7838344574,
-1.1283296347,
-0.6300789714,
-0.1048265249,
-0.9260675311,
0.1535367817,
-0.5570348501,
-0.3616007566,
0.6286495924,
0.3606978953,
-0.5145639181,
0.15227817,
0.6312975287,
0.7241306305,
-0.8580514789,
0.6987533569,
0.8344710469,
-0.1586625576,
-0.7830455303,
-0.4062324166,
0.1989990473,
-0.3472522497,
0.9002297521,
0.0779949874,
-0.0293179657,
-0.0084477486,
-0.6179119349,
-0.9898982048,
0.7727772593,
0.1298933029,
-0.7632263899,
0.0335739069,
-0.0058219503,
0.4176555872,
-0.4735236168,
-0.009777749,
0.4203141332,
0.5734893084,
0.0995223895,
-0.9628710151,
-0.3197232187,
0.0479786061,
-0.070333086,
0.1748110056,
-0.5981332064,
0.7121189237,
0.031571582,
-0.3544094563,
-0.4882465899,
1.4307955503,
0.1614683717,
0.7897261381,
0.5148486495,
0.4486019015,
1.0841757059,
0.1785422862,
0.9530901313,
-0.2914719582,
0.4284103513,
1.2198493481,
-0.5075915456,
0.920114696,
0.1238317341,
-0.2874985337,
0.787071228,
0.3105863333,
0.4535720646,
0.4641423225,
0.0401850604,
-0.431991756,
-0.4208840728,
-0.7049711347,
-0.3762368858,
1.045784831,
0.7825018764,
0.2107670456,
-0.0124204336,
0.1565766931,
0.1021281406,
0.0665252879,
-0.5667570829,
0.8942026496,
0.1356516331,
-0.3843593597,
0.0266408678,
-0.1439677328,
0.254630208,
-0.3346007168,
0.1444470286,
0.2225485146,
0.0066120429,
-0.5921437144,
-0.6796396375,
0.7534649968,
-0.1450005472,
-0.7195227146,
-0.0866829157,
0.9787777662,
-0.4426848888,
-0.4414020181,
0.3012620211,
0.3536767066,
0.0087627759,
-0.4013677239,
-0.4042114019,
0.0934771374,
-0.0875923559,
-0.5738759637,
0.3770406544,
0.6341906786,
0.2778697312,
0.3790258765,
0.6495335102,
0.2501843572,
-0.0783096403,
0.0914509222,
0.5935695767,
-0.7886458039,
-0.5116236806,
-0.777916193,
0.0866978616,
-0.0825884342,
-0.1725961268,
0.4438360333,
0.8351788521,
0.4076776505,
0.1949502826,
0.7580431104,
0.1806126535,
0.5621148348,
-0.5429823995,
0.3564431965,
-0.2459595501,
-0.3360537887,
-0.1436927915,
-0.9441980124,
-0.1539915055,
0.3334622681,
-0.137887001,
-0.4185321331,
0.4741910696,
0.2701227069,
0.0662094727,
0.3954131007,
0.5952067971,
0.5047290921,
0.5867586136,
0.4764636755,
0.8264880776,
-0.1083538681,
0.0867329165,
-0.3100194931,
-0.2733448148,
-0.5602217913,
-0.8658084273,
-0.4061846435,
-1.0950590372,
-0.7326163054,
-0.3531394005,
-0.1475684941,
1.1555607319,
0.9443913102,
-0.907319665,
-0.1056735069,
-0.0367938653,
0.1605786532,
-0.1428115219,
-0.2603465319,
0.4985843599,
-0.3135546744,
-0.8071193695,
0.7442705631,
0.8415777683,
-0.2270633429,
-0.0540129542,
0.6104018688,
-0.1394644231,
0.3137492239,
1.0539314747,
0.4133758843,
-0.2799058855,
-0.6010885835,
-0.3089654148,
-0.0322851762,
-0.0892203003,
0.6708914638,
-1.0529277325,
0.167631194,
0.4831766784,
0.2147429436,
0.6286920309,
-0.0193867888,
0.5450953245,
-0.9930628538,
0.6242463589,
0.5346050262,
0.6800040007,
0.22838597,
-0.5952111483,
0.3900532126,
0.6606143713,
-0.6385955811,
-0.8076376915,
0.5716295838,
-1.3902692795,
-0.1259078979,
1.2556318045,
-0.1076460481,
-0.6182169318,
-0.3694697917,
0.0295598786,
0.3320901692,
-0.0849145129,
0.5892038941,
0.650668323,
-0.6114260554,
0.4840109646,
-0.5058280826,
0.7226365209,
0.3867011666,
-0.5145961642,
0.2608636618,
0.6347213387,
-0.255638808,
0.643091321,
0.3370529413,
0.2421233356,
-0.1540424228,
0.0745537579,
0.2776561081,
-0.1344595104,
-0.6853505969,
0.1535495967,
0.6048145294,
-0.4217305481,
-0.2980620265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13614v1 | LLM-empowered Chatbots for Psychiatrist and Patient Simulation: Application and Evaluation | 2023-05-23T02:25:01 | 2023-05-23T02:25:01 | Siyuan Chen, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Q. Zhu, Kunyao Lan, Zhiling Zhang, Lyuchun Cui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empowering chatbots in the field of mental health is receiving increasing
amount of attention, while there still lacks exploration in developing and
evaluating chatbots in psychiatric outpatient scenarios. In this work, we focus
on exploring the potential of ChatGPT in powering chatbots for psychiatrist and
patient simulation. We collaborate with psychiatrists to identify objectives
and iteratively develop the dialogue system to closely align with real-world
scenarios. In the evaluation experiments, we recruit real psychiatrists and
patients to engage in diagnostic conversations with the chatbots, collecting
their ratings for assessment. Our findings demonstrate the feasibility of using
ChatGPT-powered chatbots in psychiatric scenarios and explore the impact of
prompt designs on chatbot behavior and user experience. | [
-0.5348229408,
-0.9519344568,
0.9906408191,
0.3117671907,
-0.2842509747,
0.4450831413,
-0.1722552627,
-0.3227646053,
0.4743023217,
0.48218593,
-1.0082468987,
-0.1078282446,
-0.4486733079,
0.0618598498,
-0.2253408134,
0.7570443749,
0.2621892691,
0.3970843256,
-0.3107897341,
0.4506921768,
-0.5817967057,
-0.8561685681,
-0.9184113741,
-0.4254958928,
0.3303317428,
0.2023491114,
1.0104010105,
-0.1825371683,
0.7836512923,
0.3117124736,
0.240670383,
-0.0806554109,
-0.6187300086,
0.4065992534,
-0.0705104396,
-0.3918059468,
-0.6498715878,
-0.0667134598,
0.2656021714,
0.342494458,
-0.5054082274,
-0.0375714488,
-0.1309052259,
0.0885956362,
-0.1416015625,
0.2193042189,
-0.336628288,
0.3265248239,
0.2804191113,
-0.3654452264,
-0.1811979115,
-0.3431409597,
0.1054131985,
-0.3782700896,
0.0631605908,
0.2591351271,
0.3925241828,
0.4385639727,
-0.184968248,
-0.217955336,
-0.8047389984,
0.4307052791,
-0.7787291408,
0.2771432102,
0.2762076259,
0.7218241096,
-0.4654217362,
-0.8668608665,
-0.5647817254,
-0.5001546741,
0.0388414003,
0.5942420959,
-0.5026029348,
0.4937438071,
0.4840523899,
0.2038611472,
-0.4014460146,
0.3912967145,
-0.3562545776,
-0.1759305,
0.5467996597,
0.5684515834,
0.5475882292,
-0.2332367301,
-0.230677098,
0.080585584,
-0.2499634475,
-0.1576304138,
0.2663608491,
0.0404715873,
-0.0767236203,
0.9103078246,
0.0864927173,
0.3354867995,
0.055484429,
-0.2473229766,
-0.0680868998,
-0.1863914728,
-0.1984215528,
0.2507504523,
1.0198231936,
0.777811408,
0.0966489464,
-0.1574749053,
-0.013616899,
0.1638992429,
0.7548620105,
-0.962641418,
-0.5540866852,
0.5691803098,
-0.4215387404,
-0.2153379172,
-0.3381863236,
-1.0075819492,
-0.8383262753,
-0.0474818125,
0.6106302738,
-0.4893881679,
-0.5028668642,
0.2296521515,
-0.4181539714,
0.2094115317,
0.5241283178,
-0.8587922454,
0.543994844,
0.794947505,
0.86373806,
-0.2232222855,
0.0448150188,
-0.0667928085,
-0.2795457244,
-0.0710870102,
0.8220930696,
-0.4313860238,
-0.7459616065,
-0.1998309195,
-0.184078306,
-0.1323338449,
-0.5459126234,
0.590062201,
-0.1112718135,
0.3773297071,
0.3180460632,
-0.7575516701,
0.1625494361,
0.3468218148,
-0.2778980732,
0.6109864712,
0.328148365,
-0.6437827349,
0.1336612552,
-0.7941107154,
0.0299391001,
0.4063358009,
-0.252174139,
-0.203257367,
0.0507661551,
0.2681375444,
0.5975639224,
-0.2316807657,
0.1025539935,
-0.1591181755,
-0.4900891483,
0.6919611096,
-0.5226861238,
0.6842464805,
0.0241983924,
0.08189971,
0.3030743897,
-0.3613533676,
0.1464308202,
0.0275012702,
0.1499938071,
0.2275495678,
0.018734511,
-0.0229389146,
0.2399671823,
0.0872453973,
-0.6632404923,
0.2569137514,
-0.2947282791,
0.4380676746,
0.5148282647,
0.5084124804,
0.209821105,
-0.5188335776,
1.0960143805,
-0.3184818625,
0.5615804791,
0.0457248054,
-0.9066515565,
-0.451956898,
-0.7913081646,
0.1065524518,
0.9519982934,
-0.6551189423,
0.6000910401,
-0.091612637,
-0.7487154603,
-0.7086331248,
-0.2965035141,
-0.0148508428,
0.5752164125,
-0.0026746467,
-0.6351507902,
-0.4663315713,
-0.8088064194,
-0.0301292595,
-0.2734729052,
-0.5031560063,
0.5931592584,
0.0999840125,
-0.5170977116,
1.0003647804,
-0.3493004441,
-0.2218431979,
-0.5963212848,
-0.331243962,
0.3118313551,
0.4248668551,
0.2567762136,
-0.5044330359,
-0.2239359617,
-0.3947604299,
-0.7312774062,
-0.2810427845,
-0.1710883826,
-0.0024175937,
-0.4900182486,
0.4736962914,
-0.763341248,
0.5113549232,
0.4651842415,
-0.1555042714,
0.6968826652,
-0.3371647298,
0.3853280544,
-1.0928184986,
-0.3900590241,
-0.2263956368,
-0.3648293018,
-0.835624814,
-0.2950869203,
-0.2205574661,
-0.7102405429,
-0.5287678838,
0.3675077558,
0.0282614976,
0.004214799,
-0.2489984781,
0.5725133419,
-0.3273118138,
0.434464395,
-0.0506343208,
0.7107400894,
0.7178468108,
-0.324880898,
0.7933697104,
0.2501813173,
-0.3316215277,
0.7818492651,
-0.8035995364,
0.2144352645,
0.1724000126,
0.3712110817,
-1.0108152628,
-0.4291947484,
0.6953617334,
-0.4852390885,
0.0146229239,
-0.0554857738,
-0.8129941225,
-0.3244567215,
-0.0742980689,
0.1605640948,
0.9732034802,
-0.1728576124,
0.3154254258,
0.6989424825,
-0.3634306192,
0.151012674,
-0.3428559601,
0.3730522096,
-0.4654419124,
-0.5001081824,
0.1511370242,
0.010166306,
-0.4896822274,
-0.3188633323,
0.2426535934,
0.0878317431,
0.0710541308,
0.6933902502,
0.2459951788,
0.1641526222,
0.1614669263,
0.1091437787,
-0.2650126815,
0.2733282447,
0.1171744093,
1.05014956,
-0.1172164381,
-0.8586059213,
-0.8273051977,
0.3964466155,
0.2665595114,
0.209820047,
0.5078493953,
0.5464336872,
-0.3225994706,
0.2844257653,
-0.4946085513,
-0.6859699488,
-0.5138009191,
0.4510852695,
-0.1571138501,
-1.006940484,
0.3777185678,
-0.6092261076,
0.0082269879,
-0.0148202693,
0.9064320922,
-0.1828904897,
1.3251057863,
0.4260289669,
0.4191045761,
0.3796131015,
0.1367381066,
0.5608750582,
-0.7411960959,
-0.2378790528,
-0.2414160371,
-0.4520364106,
-0.761091888,
-0.5021008849,
0.7992688417,
0.0362533182,
-0.1369194984,
0.2104277462,
-0.6126804352,
0.2236888558,
0.3056184351,
0.561840117,
0.1741279513,
-0.1338114738,
-0.1093292683,
-0.4955103695,
-0.7667153478,
-0.4003860652,
0.6786521077,
0.3587372005,
0.8491540551,
0.1064724773,
0.6886671782,
0.3135963976,
0.2038067877,
-1.190977931,
0.7862417102,
0.4763192534,
-0.426269263,
-0.1927954406,
-0.3481167257,
-0.9342945218,
0.0976471379,
-0.1438251287,
-1.2946251631,
-0.1280110627,
-0.2134673446,
-0.5885748267,
0.0938171446,
-0.7556592226,
0.5453005433,
-0.2529508173,
0.0321599059,
-0.5159778595,
-0.6309229732,
0.2720018327,
-0.1815726906,
-0.0613402724,
-0.2856311798,
-0.1572264582,
0.5671506524,
-0.2932924032,
1.0043852329,
0.0639051422,
-0.1170472875,
0.0932761654,
0.2151376158,
-0.1853055656,
0.5093585253,
-0.0818804055,
0.1726600528,
0.1081361175,
-0.0510493964,
-1.045178771,
0.4760540724,
-0.6197224259,
-0.8410103917,
-0.3656038046,
-0.5142441988,
-0.6150758266,
0.080339931,
0.0470679998,
0.3330965042,
-0.4342268407,
-0.1042447835,
0.4102871716,
-0.3571315706,
0.1049262136,
0.4204555154,
-0.8539108634,
-0.464962393,
0.5946192145,
-0.1958937645,
0.304269135,
0.0434130095,
0.1501597613,
-0.2535075545,
-0.0001369192,
-0.52886796,
0.1380024403,
-0.4798347652,
-0.0783480182,
-0.6863399744,
-0.6300447583,
-0.2996988893,
-0.2776106,
-0.235979557,
-0.5753288865,
-0.0068674427,
0.0114169633,
0.5519035459,
0.7166938782,
-0.1597655267,
0.8031973839,
-0.6034408212,
0.4025814533,
0.3239064515,
0.1980477124,
-0.3081195951,
-0.1927750409,
0.1555346251,
0.0116954222,
-0.4467982948,
-1.0836123228,
0.486928761,
0.0032230085,
0.6566765904,
0.5428515077,
-0.0452246368,
0.5508042574,
-0.4561648071,
0.9936249256,
0.3885226846,
-0.5665262341,
0.671888113,
-0.2326844335,
0.1450193375,
0.4652637541,
0.2740882933,
-0.7673015594,
-0.4637317955,
-0.9703911543,
-0.4513686299,
0.6223506927,
0.3222706318,
0.4130564928,
0.1725279093,
0.4116249681,
0.0919316038,
0.2448428869,
-0.1166331097,
-0.262681216,
0.0254221968,
-0.0869622156,
-0.0660988614,
-0.1665019095,
-0.3395452499,
-0.1793824583,
0.3108375967,
0.0690099448,
0.7380552888,
0.2386965603,
0.3649004102,
0.1681581885,
0.1622806191,
0.1808916926,
0.5214529037,
-0.2891386449,
-0.1016941518,
0.242279008,
-0.6452457905,
0.0514731482,
0.1658176333,
0.1877813488,
0.0413926728,
-0.2018103004,
0.6556940675,
0.2764084935,
-0.9105046391,
0.3527459502,
-0.704565227,
-0.0099695278,
-0.2914946377,
0.454582274,
0.1353431493,
0.5433459282,
-0.0700704306,
0.0905584842,
0.2425884455,
-0.4805300534,
0.3400446177,
0.4754842222,
-0.780192554,
-0.1086781323,
0.3712954819,
0.0356071666,
-1.0954220295,
0.9604241848,
0.0412509106,
-0.7544955015,
0.4414306581,
0.8150324225,
0.7934158444,
-0.0777606815,
0.2502938509,
0.0907916948,
0.1413178742,
0.2059937268,
0.3943200409,
-0.0820973143,
-0.6524845362,
-0.1240325943,
-0.2540731728,
-1.2574908733,
-0.1345452368,
-0.453312993,
0.4050845504,
-0.5759557486,
-0.6457791924,
-0.275316596,
0.1325846463,
-0.3610335886,
-0.2153121531,
0.1885395348,
0.7002568245,
-0.2309732288,
0.56231004,
0.5985891819,
-0.0752498507,
-0.5395157933,
-0.019086929,
0.0470135994,
-1.0060255527,
0.0252550598,
0.2104472816,
-0.020228453,
0.2629056871,
-0.5910127759,
-0.2481333464,
0.9726922512,
0.3706733584,
-0.3967698514,
0.293959558,
0.2102872133,
0.7747963667,
-0.2180262506,
0.6329429746,
0.5012221336,
0.2570122182,
0.1090214849,
-1.3533779383,
-0.2176192701,
-0.2418137044,
-0.2237555832,
0.0028508026,
-0.6159162521,
0.5353091359,
-0.2270515561,
-0.2409379929,
0.1685179323,
0.4759576619,
0.4811791182,
0.0711479411,
0.2986040115,
0.324790895,
0.8715298772,
-0.0087162331,
1.0098671913,
-0.3559750617,
0.2549959719,
0.7579589486,
-0.4163649678,
0.4702351987,
0.4776941836,
-0.2381367087,
0.3022859693,
0.5805943012,
-0.0610224418,
0.2425225824,
0.5100682378,
-0.7476136088,
-0.3329667449,
-0.3373456597,
-0.3035947978,
0.3706431091,
0.7953506112,
-0.0422236845,
-0.2247564048,
0.2522061765,
0.1893229187,
-0.306971997,
-0.2196266949,
0.863129437,
0.4883011281,
-0.4113729894,
0.1496049315,
-0.1661304832,
0.4562782943,
-0.5963395834,
-0.0486625023,
0.1259742379,
0.3175559938,
0.0059122127,
-0.915571332,
0.0107453642,
0.0203440525,
0.3908527195,
-0.4107794464,
1.2073738575,
0.1284716874,
-0.5359542966,
0.0790425763,
0.9904111028,
0.7030487061,
-0.1558918357,
-0.8740659952,
-0.1432925314,
-0.2168038934,
-0.1498352438,
0.5919337273,
0.3707678616,
0.1090149581,
1.1013971567,
0.5516832471,
0.1754367948,
-0.1370143443,
0.2739878893,
0.8483461142,
-0.437798202,
-0.2995560169,
-1.032269001,
0.021833241,
-0.1791632622,
-0.2498304993,
0.8202147484,
0.4474981725,
0.1651879549,
-0.0820975453,
0.7837996483,
-0.3416108787,
0.4995505214,
-0.1860640794,
0.8980364203,
-0.2181518674,
-0.0489962958,
-0.1455120295,
-0.6289101839,
-0.4085884988,
0.6098719835,
-0.2170576602,
-0.0845708847,
0.3575468063,
0.8748613596,
0.0400567129,
0.2983057797,
0.5799758434,
-0.0625937209,
0.5855895877,
0.5459955931,
1.2972091436,
-0.1498230994,
0.1199325547,
-0.5468060374,
-0.4908357859,
-0.1225120202,
-0.7614155412,
-1.08720541,
-0.3464853168,
-0.235789597,
-0.4320366979,
0.1378614902,
1.1742008924,
0.4789847434,
-0.4369489551,
-0.2746858597,
0.1811014712,
-0.1726300269,
-0.2250941694,
-0.2764841616,
0.0304758046,
-0.2635118067,
-0.7441228628,
0.4402626455,
0.4487976134,
0.1967941076,
-0.557957232,
0.1028494686,
0.3607397974,
0.1044388264,
0.3424125016,
0.0819124877,
-0.3800046444,
-0.0986016393,
0.0860175416,
-0.2970123589,
0.1254550815,
1.0124334097,
-1.2197579145,
0.3420871198,
0.2805615664,
0.4121504426,
0.1734569222,
0.377733767,
0.871121347,
-0.2405541241,
0.2285395563,
0.5947433114,
0.2223967761,
0.1749413162,
-0.4328068495,
0.3882771134,
-0.0131871141,
-0.8361022472,
-0.7214064598,
0.1960542053,
-1.3506342173,
0.241729781,
1.0386875868,
-0.1626223177,
0.1579052955,
-0.2379353791,
-0.9489213228,
0.1840742677,
-0.5668573976,
0.8675373197,
0.5089318752,
-0.9327710867,
-0.4277535081,
-0.9968401194,
0.6092017293,
0.147875458,
-0.7594208717,
-0.3103905618,
0.3495687246,
-0.0720057487,
0.0552409664,
0.796007514,
-0.1271975785,
0.1353190392,
0.0306479726,
-0.0488316789,
0.2328307778,
0.2544749677,
-0.3144133687,
-0.0024313072,
-0.1362653971,
0.038413614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13602v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13602v2 | ReSee: Responding through Seeing Fine-grained Visual Knowledge in Open-domain Dialogue | 2023-05-23T02:08:56 | 2023-10-20T04:59:10 | Haoqin Tu, Yitong Li, Fei Mi, Zhongliang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incorporating visual knowledge into text-only dialogue systems has become a
potential direction to imitate the way humans think, imagine, and communicate.
However, existing multimodal dialogue systems are either confined by the scale
and quality of available datasets or the coarse concept of visual knowledge. To
address these issues, we provide a new paradigm of constructing multimodal
dialogues as well as two datasets extended from text-only dialogues under such
paradigm (ReSee-WoW, ReSee-DD). We propose to explicitly split the visual
knowledge into finer granularity (``turn-level'' and ``entity-level''). To
further boost the accuracy and diversity of augmented visual information, we
retrieve them from the Internet or a large image dataset. To demonstrate the
superiority and universality of the provided visual knowledge, we propose a
simple but effective framework ReSee to add visual representation into vanilla
dialogue models by modality concatenations. We also conduct extensive
experiments and ablations w.r.t. different model configurations and visual
knowledge settings. Empirical, encouraging results not only demonstrate the
effectiveness of introducing visual knowledge at both entity and turn level but
also verify the proposed model ReSee outperforms several state-of-the-art
methods on automatic and human evaluations. By leveraging text and vision
knowledge, ReSee can produce informative responses with real-world visual
concepts. Our code is available at https://github.com/ImKeTT/ReSee. | [
-0.6163507104,
-0.9691665173,
0.6534239054,
-0.0840174779,
-0.1147591919,
-0.1415218562,
-0.2873198688,
-0.5343027711,
0.309092164,
0.8177443743,
-0.4693246186,
-0.2993046343,
-0.2975197732,
-0.0339509323,
-0.2423374504,
0.7158455253,
0.1019302532,
0.1322211474,
-0.4667467475,
-0.216319561,
-0.4559757411,
-0.1492887437,
-0.481272459,
0.0106539745,
0.5908000469,
0.5075234175,
0.6994642615,
0.2047989815,
0.6411449909,
0.3965756595,
0.2483412027,
0.4390538633,
-0.6051723957,
0.2141104937,
-0.3274181187,
-0.5469169617,
-0.2543059289,
-0.168562606,
0.3469862044,
0.5418498516,
-0.0765117779,
0.1900376827,
-0.1098389477,
0.431319207,
-0.6719513535,
0.3297738731,
-0.6282705069,
0.0215466637,
0.1668470353,
-0.2237740159,
-0.449385047,
-0.0693976954,
0.6573616862,
-0.9522096515,
-0.0474382937,
0.2048833817,
0.8012838364,
0.2951877117,
-0.4635436237,
0.0609417707,
-0.6746374369,
0.6489447355,
-0.424739182,
0.5274369717,
0.2225591838,
0.6009664536,
0.1208866686,
-1.1318924427,
-0.8641883731,
-0.1427700669,
0.0005605899,
0.2875801325,
-0.2784353793,
0.049533762,
0.2767697275,
0.4336875081,
-0.1636928618,
-0.394944787,
-0.2875032425,
-0.1130845398,
0.2403681129,
0.1294599921,
0.4167841673,
-0.0707115009,
-0.5690517426,
-0.226868093,
-0.0857639387,
0.0757620335,
-0.2176143676,
0.2331074476,
-0.2300415784,
0.6279902458,
-0.3551947773,
0.8539116979,
0.0344323292,
-0.3089424372,
0.1013936996,
-0.6083500981,
-0.5416947603,
-0.441233933,
0.6606173515,
0.9453927875,
0.4512618482,
0.0783384815,
-0.1583779901,
0.0660595521,
0.4794334471,
-0.9044577479,
-0.2027699947,
-0.1889729351,
-0.678135097,
-0.140767321,
-0.2256466001,
-1.0815775394,
-0.5834184289,
-0.5259459019,
0.5126802921,
-0.4604690969,
-0.2394506484,
0.0862848908,
-0.2966610491,
0.1469904184,
0.9514784217,
-0.6354147196,
0.3134785295,
0.2750597,
0.536452055,
0.337308079,
-0.1124261245,
-0.5523018241,
0.1764246225,
-0.1704546511,
0.9060034156,
-0.8770870566,
-0.2551611066,
0.1301672906,
-0.091064088,
-0.0006081847,
-0.4419922829,
0.3168027997,
-0.371337384,
0.2961559594,
-0.1049702018,
-0.1907787323,
-0.3924488723,
0.4965232313,
-0.4346598089,
0.4188826382,
0.0014942921,
-0.8305482268,
0.3189924657,
-0.5986692309,
-0.0306388959,
-0.0551968738,
-0.5000608563,
0.0141066611,
0.1823773831,
0.4166026413,
0.151253432,
-0.4088015854,
-0.0700612441,
-0.433937788,
0.0420836769,
0.3335557878,
-0.7947544456,
0.1036067083,
0.2215474844,
0.0342478678,
0.113372311,
-0.7468112111,
0.3083958924,
0.0628118217,
0.0431330167,
-0.4280777276,
-0.3181395829,
0.0890791118,
0.0873507708,
0.0605871342,
-0.5473970175,
0.3546385765,
-0.3061885536,
0.3319944441,
0.5314356685,
0.1331095099,
0.5898380876,
-0.1181786805,
0.2470035851,
0.2422424704,
0.2370629758,
-0.4173101485,
-0.5361568928,
-0.9489008784,
-0.3147287071,
0.1893924624,
0.6295461655,
-1.3705229759,
-0.2670597732,
-0.4215046763,
-0.1621349454,
-0.4539033473,
-0.1902577877,
0.5688908696,
0.6522983909,
0.4868065119,
-0.6346484423,
-0.3363410234,
-1.1500928402,
-0.1581115872,
-0.4108057618,
-0.1408588886,
0.6999668479,
0.4280181825,
-0.3005361855,
0.8943533897,
-0.6958756447,
-0.2047017217,
-0.0920999348,
0.1733465642,
-0.2824128866,
0.2875714898,
0.3663735092,
-0.8855230808,
-0.1998733431,
0.2446622699,
-0.9899207354,
0.200206697,
-0.1765816063,
-0.2891327143,
-0.1008686647,
0.4149809182,
-0.4009350836,
0.7616270781,
0.2583667338,
-0.2969996333,
0.3171123266,
0.0257807095,
0.6569857597,
-1.1737556458,
-0.2522698343,
0.2020546049,
-0.3154706061,
-0.740702033,
-0.0760431811,
-0.2802534103,
-0.3833516836,
-0.4448836744,
0.6896369457,
-0.2198734283,
-0.0364248455,
-0.0603048354,
0.3006999195,
0.1957082301,
0.7456352711,
0.3597366214,
0.7501990795,
0.5677108765,
-0.367839992,
0.488729775,
0.6263272762,
-0.6651850343,
0.9873425961,
-0.4255150855,
-0.1022639498,
-0.2256839275,
0.2742528021,
-0.8375062346,
-0.4807322621,
0.2025023699,
-0.3668583035,
0.2014621943,
-0.2703153789,
-0.0186196528,
0.0235081967,
-0.0364184231,
0.5620054007,
0.1727677733,
-0.4244003892,
0.9196335077,
0.3479309678,
-0.380017668,
-0.4835678339,
-0.7575884461,
0.3962974548,
-0.0127373617,
-1.043322444,
-0.0069749304,
0.0309572723,
-0.4905093014,
-0.1338336319,
-0.1111237854,
-0.4217927456,
-0.3737982213,
0.1085087582,
0.1477553844,
-0.2120988518,
0.0988154784,
-0.1714395583,
-0.0856418312,
-0.2302997112,
-0.2900395989,
0.1911658198,
-0.2570294142,
-0.55609411,
-0.6078390479,
0.6138506532,
0.8306873441,
-0.3380281031,
0.4935837388,
0.5380516648,
-0.3093619347,
0.2268824726,
-0.5999845266,
-0.251327455,
-0.3535204232,
0.3217798471,
-0.5325467587,
-0.8864665627,
0.3078528941,
-0.3162445724,
0.0994063467,
-0.1451165676,
0.3988259137,
-0.0276764855,
0.8963137865,
0.7872335911,
0.5571305752,
0.7339156866,
-0.2066735476,
0.3844898343,
-0.8850861192,
-0.4357602298,
-0.148601234,
-0.2340126336,
-0.3727749586,
-0.6570550203,
0.5483134389,
0.1253195554,
-0.2796700895,
0.0204350296,
-0.2631862462,
0.3084400892,
0.6779215932,
0.4277266264,
0.5132446885,
0.2134577632,
0.0051704501,
-0.1916726977,
-0.5851528049,
-0.5987818837,
0.7965996861,
0.348095566,
1.1430511475,
0.0952463672,
0.4578698874,
0.1748742163,
0.1864628047,
-0.9276432991,
0.7111085653,
0.1096420288,
-0.2502539754,
-0.2801899016,
-0.3770489395,
-0.5134551525,
0.3508092463,
-0.4543681145,
-0.8088623285,
0.626016438,
0.0807805881,
-0.4074544609,
0.2197090685,
-1.0154554844,
0.9289087057,
0.0610193536,
-0.4567026496,
-0.254152745,
-0.7320810556,
0.3945251703,
0.2922550738,
0.2755040526,
0.179929167,
-0.0065266453,
0.3887762427,
-0.6676379442,
1.0421664715,
-0.1235515475,
-0.1638067961,
0.458892554,
0.0955829546,
0.3522582054,
0.3947121203,
0.5274023414,
0.0435602181,
-0.0171333812,
-0.3071857989,
-1.0099636316,
0.5953251123,
-0.5014764071,
-0.7148275375,
-0.1608858407,
-0.4198984504,
-0.3709204793,
0.2070564032,
-0.0043891608,
0.9889335036,
-0.3098114133,
0.2749375105,
0.8492868543,
-0.1968548447,
0.1214505807,
0.5002971292,
-0.5370186567,
-0.7523691654,
0.9534861445,
-0.1014719754,
0.5921962261,
0.5214049816,
-0.104452081,
-0.185309127,
-0.1147458851,
-0.6337713599,
-0.1339045465,
-0.8139669895,
-0.3258892,
-0.6548122764,
0.0041591977,
-0.1340406686,
-0.134236142,
-0.2262348384,
-0.595970571,
-0.0037469147,
0.0912213475,
0.3511773348,
0.5058880448,
0.0268381238,
0.0256393589,
-0.9364256263,
0.5861658454,
0.980001092,
0.3691763282,
0.1022534147,
-0.2564325035,
-0.2149285376,
0.4958007038,
-0.2419932932,
-0.6057884693,
0.1579590291,
0.1916765869,
0.3138068616,
0.3457762599,
-0.0337414742,
0.9244644046,
-0.6795592904,
0.9318335056,
0.5168036819,
-0.6683120728,
0.5291200876,
-0.2218411416,
0.2182090431,
0.5968056917,
-0.1439414471,
-0.5615086555,
-0.304474026,
-0.4294563234,
-0.4865867198,
0.5482486486,
0.2700231373,
0.1771346331,
-0.1629922837,
-0.0682379231,
-0.0857793018,
0.3763145506,
-0.5131995678,
-0.0336629823,
-0.6076546311,
-0.0161357019,
0.2871009707,
-0.1517588943,
-0.5353207588,
-0.0473005176,
0.3458951712,
-0.4181465507,
0.410081774,
0.5651432276,
-0.1537373811,
0.0448086821,
0.486569196,
0.5302910805,
0.6126466393,
-0.0047857743,
0.0951905474,
0.0690636933,
-0.4210154712,
-0.1823332459,
-0.2226538658,
-0.1196821481,
-0.2232749313,
0.4595987499,
1.0555286407,
0.2501546443,
-0.7375949025,
0.6108286381,
-0.4773728549,
0.0045247823,
-0.0249819309,
-0.1859234869,
-0.1871808171,
0.5220134854,
0.0498153865,
0.5206151009,
0.271559,
-0.879615128,
0.2064258903,
0.47148332,
-0.6039244533,
-0.1271641999,
0.5087810159,
0.6597948074,
-0.1262989342,
0.4841002524,
0.2302840352,
-0.2189344317,
0.2131332755,
0.3028855026,
0.7884717584,
0.1989883035,
0.3048980832,
0.1636512429,
0.0364082418,
0.1343218535,
0.3272971511,
-0.2008740008,
-0.76326859,
-0.478918761,
-0.5032790899,
-0.4389435649,
-0.1488559097,
-0.7953224182,
-0.0467636846,
-0.3449157476,
-0.2495192736,
0.0329071023,
-0.4822653532,
-0.7003855705,
0.2716274559,
0.1810952723,
1.0718345642,
-0.5992202759,
0.3398014009,
0.7697820067,
-0.7573385835,
-0.4007036984,
0.1770184785,
-0.096244514,
-0.9486085773,
0.6143270135,
0.0032976549,
-0.330834657,
-0.0963338614,
-0.8167942762,
-0.55159688,
0.8508855104,
0.270688802,
-0.4467413723,
0.0362808332,
-0.1659351736,
0.5372719765,
-0.5034468174,
0.6313124895,
0.4294131696,
0.5471578836,
0.3968116641,
-1.1064925194,
-0.234695062,
-0.3445727527,
0.2480942309,
0.1773313284,
-0.6703642607,
0.2805991471,
-0.3413147926,
-0.3289711773,
0.1975944191,
0.8603788018,
-0.2222606242,
0.4107662141,
0.42817384,
0.744874835,
0.5600681901,
-0.162927568,
0.9685413241,
-0.0989248678,
0.0164970029,
1.1071360111,
-0.1374010891,
0.7787775397,
0.5497409701,
0.0353874527,
0.6491739154,
0.2069980502,
0.3946592808,
0.6004455686,
-0.1516540647,
-0.6134057641,
-0.7139599323,
-0.6901910901,
-0.3426772058,
0.3964507878,
0.3085682094,
-0.1257258356,
-0.2916890681,
0.2733905911,
-0.4022212923,
0.3095871508,
-0.4051136672,
1.3044396639,
0.1076805964,
-0.4219009578,
0.6548259258,
-0.451895535,
0.3674036562,
-0.4322535396,
-0.5284938812,
-0.1713322848,
-0.1096335128,
-0.1431590021,
-1.043554306,
-0.01520677,
0.0143479574,
-0.5211933851,
-0.0621351674,
0.6558526158,
-0.6756888628,
-0.4571766555,
-0.1311553419,
0.5985492468,
0.0431189127,
-0.0036111753,
-0.4561375678,
-0.020272281,
0.2752120495,
-0.0078717973,
0.2709571421,
0.8863739967,
-0.2672207654,
0.9520186186,
0.5085280538,
-0.4403059483,
-0.156120494,
0.3007091582,
1.0763250589,
-0.4561553299,
-0.1613288671,
-0.3194928765,
0.7741494179,
-0.3630068302,
-0.1464376897,
0.4135567546,
0.3483291864,
0.7242856026,
-0.2219204903,
0.8712758422,
-0.0307543948,
0.3096372783,
-0.5529920459,
0.2838329673,
-0.645373404,
0.0517818891,
-0.3264777958,
-0.893140316,
-0.0850387886,
0.5507786274,
-0.1694674343,
-0.1240804493,
0.5923377275,
0.7636245489,
-0.2512788773,
0.1692146063,
0.5127344728,
0.3166171014,
0.1930617839,
0.4481475651,
0.9791406393,
-0.3981404006,
0.6167803407,
0.0552790575,
-0.5517101884,
-0.0418947898,
-0.61114645,
-0.8786993623,
-0.5876058936,
-0.1736652702,
-0.2335391492,
-0.0427953191,
0.6939908862,
0.5877774954,
-0.4147921801,
0.1085143834,
0.0360988416,
-0.0684962794,
0.0571077801,
-0.2381957173,
-0.1290017217,
-0.2907942533,
-0.8293188214,
0.5043408275,
0.5328879952,
0.2312408537,
-0.1953672171,
0.1045996547,
-0.0127901407,
0.3601923883,
0.8815581203,
0.2147805989,
-0.8989197016,
-0.5093234181,
-0.1126847342,
0.0905304104,
0.0267416257,
0.8726209402,
-0.9650295377,
1.005459547,
0.5193827152,
0.5198959708,
0.4892683029,
0.1202021837,
0.8797562718,
-0.5003871918,
0.2151504159,
0.040539287,
0.4633717239,
0.3637476861,
0.0331680998,
0.465390861,
0.2181222141,
-0.415920794,
-0.640011549,
0.7716789842,
-1.1106475592,
-0.1146703586,
0.7873830199,
-0.1655679941,
-0.1262902766,
-0.052050624,
-0.7449707389,
-0.10530103,
-0.66569978,
0.4254963696,
0.6536012888,
-0.1059890762,
-0.3643875718,
-0.4187117219,
0.4252619445,
0.1593967229,
-0.8716109395,
0.2644073367,
0.8502124548,
-0.0414301492,
0.4992187619,
0.5415967703,
0.0119675277,
0.2258707285,
0.348746866,
0.0592394471,
-0.0536984615,
-0.5505212545,
0.1888225228,
0.0325195082,
-0.1957033426,
-0.0893300325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13599v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13599v3 | Decoupled Rationalization with Asymmetric Learning Rates: A Flexible Lipschitz Restraint | 2023-05-23T02:01:13 | 2023-06-24T08:54:12 | Wei Liu, Jun Wang, Haozhao Wang, Ruixuan Li, Yang Qiu, YuanKai Zhang, Jie Han, Yixiong Zou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | A self-explaining rationalization model is generally constructed by a
cooperative game where a generator selects the most human-intelligible pieces
from the input text as rationales, followed by a predictor that makes
predictions based on the selected rationales. However, such a cooperative game
may incur the degeneration problem where the predictor overfits to the
uninformative pieces generated by a not yet well-trained generator and in turn,
leads the generator to converge to a sub-optimal model that tends to select
senseless pieces. In this paper, we theoretically bridge degeneration with the
predictor's Lipschitz continuity. Then, we empirically propose a simple but
effective method named DR, which can naturally and flexibly restrain the
Lipschitz constant of the predictor, to address the problem of degeneration.
The main idea of DR is to decouple the generator and predictor to allocate them
with asymmetric learning rates. A series of experiments conducted on two widely
used benchmarks have verified the effectiveness of the proposed method. Codes:
\href{https://github.com/jugechengzi/Rationalization-DR}{https://github.com/jugechengzi/Rationalization-DR}. | [
-0.5400434732,
-0.6352107525,
0.3095830977,
0.0190080758,
-0.3418394923,
0.0506179258,
-0.5900142193,
-0.3400975466,
-0.0145315388,
0.1911362857,
-0.8620074987,
-0.1546897143,
-0.2348210812,
0.1151859611,
0.1842537522,
0.8463885188,
-0.0526064821,
0.2398624867,
-0.2432466,
-0.1165063232,
-0.3698569238,
-0.2776531279,
-0.6260399222,
-0.5728212595,
0.078597039,
0.448954612,
0.4631613791,
0.8757287264,
0.3945423067,
0.4021887481,
-0.0194075163,
-0.3478620052,
-0.6181818247,
0.5298184156,
-0.1134370491,
-0.4062924385,
0.0002131379,
0.2380520999,
0.5933744907,
0.7199828625,
-0.5543549061,
-0.0436374545,
0.266407311,
1.0079952478,
-0.450171411,
0.0927229151,
-0.6259063482,
-0.0141911991,
0.3329693675,
-0.2632066905,
-0.1801707596,
-0.452363342,
0.2415368408,
-0.5700950027,
0.4728970826,
-0.6555143595,
0.6051464081,
0.5242868662,
-0.1357130408,
-0.0753934085,
-0.9392766356,
1.1369791031,
-0.4276000857,
0.3182730973,
0.4601637423,
0.5763177872,
0.0092849135,
-0.5739154816,
-0.5009643435,
-0.3611432016,
0.2598695159,
0.3755676746,
-0.0284199882,
0.0799153894,
0.511922121,
0.3113801181,
-0.299128592,
0.2217479795,
-0.5739241838,
-0.0759528801,
0.6559217572,
0.1756106019,
0.2816084623,
-0.0044829668,
-0.9753825665,
-0.1845626086,
-0.4221637845,
0.4020942152,
0.4698635042,
0.0740069523,
0.0268039946,
0.4102056324,
-0.2475309521,
0.3664255142,
0.4377376437,
-0.3319106102,
0.0658968538,
-0.1492882222,
-0.1635512114,
-0.0645992234,
0.7729816437,
0.6536935568,
0.3680379391,
-0.2082315385,
-0.4039368629,
0.3632245064,
0.2078733146,
-0.999073565,
-0.4425222278,
0.185044691,
-0.5051745772,
-0.226539582,
-0.2242760807,
-1.0984742641,
-0.1867334992,
-0.4468176961,
0.0331682824,
-0.7472836971,
-0.3030957282,
0.0638520271,
-0.3642458618,
0.1833381951,
0.1754721999,
-1.1778320074,
0.3501339853,
0.3349612355,
0.7344433069,
-0.0657397509,
-0.3264911473,
-0.072419703,
0.1134793311,
0.0214893296,
0.6320284605,
-0.4335821867,
-0.4363936782,
-0.2641371191,
-0.2601813972,
-0.0799920782,
-0.5671400428,
0.4344236851,
-0.3442619145,
0.2677028179,
-0.3475872576,
-0.4950946867,
-0.1485437453,
0.435637027,
-0.8273302913,
0.3333367109,
0.0800984949,
-0.7025079131,
0.5936145186,
-0.5643311739,
-0.2650942206,
-0.0633882135,
-0.4398592412,
-0.6788716912,
-0.0397467986,
-0.0040365341,
-0.1523821503,
-0.3163289428,
0.353017956,
-0.4910396636,
0.014508429,
0.4610210955,
-0.6266706586,
1.0848459005,
0.4584173858,
-0.3958001733,
0.3432513773,
-0.7903572917,
0.0789072141,
0.2744393051,
-0.5119743347,
-0.2321510613,
0.0961392969,
-0.193762511,
0.189189136,
0.0743019506,
-0.4820291996,
0.2524501979,
-0.547390461,
0.7200033069,
0.8284824491,
0.1679884195,
0.80869627,
-0.5739662647,
0.6677340269,
-0.1315816343,
0.2460240424,
0.0631305501,
0.0483279712,
-0.6647964716,
-0.6238928437,
0.3837869763,
0.41655159,
-0.4940997064,
0.5411221981,
0.0827110335,
-0.2681024075,
-0.3214564323,
-0.0645288751,
0.3149560392,
0.7269620299,
0.5694002509,
-0.2569860816,
-0.4888631105,
-0.7403704524,
-0.1501149386,
0.0528906435,
-0.3075260222,
-0.1459572762,
0.2442691028,
-0.1757614315,
0.9811524153,
-0.4308038056,
-0.3926617205,
-0.3313195705,
0.2572343647,
-0.2653756738,
0.9397495389,
0.3104439676,
-0.6679834723,
-0.5269294977,
-0.4607111812,
-0.5240202546,
0.1869805306,
-0.2367172241,
0.0684849769,
0.4203161001,
0.3854386806,
-0.8663215637,
0.406172365,
0.0143854199,
-0.0775410607,
0.8191791773,
-0.4067744017,
-0.1130642816,
-0.8846080899,
0.247451514,
0.0844122991,
-0.1437329948,
-0.5576107502,
0.1952978373,
-0.1165493131,
-0.2647502422,
0.0711256415,
0.0072543006,
-0.713182807,
0.3055155277,
-0.256491214,
0.1375510097,
-0.1185426414,
0.4022258818,
0.1209197789,
0.3755977154,
0.6275324821,
-0.605630219,
0.11524643,
0.0239736456,
-0.2151145041,
0.2030909806,
-0.9704155326,
-0.133060351,
-0.2228056043,
0.3292696774,
-0.7162020802,
-0.1270697266,
0.324844569,
-0.3195947111,
0.4316082597,
-0.1348187625,
0.0399894528,
-0.0852268562,
-0.6892193556,
0.4818446636,
0.8425627947,
-0.4896088243,
0.5417485237,
0.464307785,
0.0732233375,
-0.8880902529,
-0.5149264932,
-0.540186584,
-0.5149341822,
-0.5387983322,
0.4721576571,
-0.5009127259,
-0.3725070953,
-0.0333464257,
-0.5292740464,
-0.1205355376,
0.3060131073,
0.2329796702,
0.3055734038,
-0.075527586,
0.1039346606,
0.3111013472,
-0.356641829,
0.168413341,
-0.1747654676,
0.6399413347,
-0.0296911355,
-0.0369300246,
-0.6380113959,
0.2652914524,
0.6909015179,
-0.2685768902,
0.6396381855,
0.2748193741,
-0.4012521207,
-0.5384274721,
-0.4048333764,
-0.5954390764,
-0.5044586658,
-0.0862629563,
-0.5955104828,
-0.6529588699,
0.8279913664,
-0.2372333854,
-0.1660838574,
0.3910155892,
0.5770432353,
0.1426033676,
0.9228562713,
0.7857236266,
0.0814228728,
0.4194805026,
-0.5917469263,
-0.0100904163,
-0.4720095098,
-0.3911707699,
-0.3789984286,
-0.4511986077,
-0.6464644074,
-0.2299322337,
-0.0208720826,
0.7175604701,
-0.1219713688,
0.1302423179,
-0.6810457706,
0.8157889843,
0.4939829111,
0.2491585761,
0.363510102,
-0.0274726693,
-0.1306075454,
-0.0886572525,
-0.6761721373,
-0.1566868126,
0.7321586609,
0.5712957978,
1.1462430954,
0.1282815635,
0.9315422177,
-0.0600618087,
0.2374291271,
-0.9417518377,
0.4508951902,
0.1537674516,
-0.5599235296,
-0.7206090093,
-0.7464624643,
-1.0005437136,
0.1449691355,
-0.1716419011,
-0.5266658664,
0.5500922799,
0.3594232798,
-0.3516450524,
-0.062457785,
-0.487565577,
0.9852079153,
-0.0958667397,
-0.3607087731,
-0.5576263666,
-0.6827822328,
0.4914570451,
0.0318595171,
-0.1736134291,
-0.2718411982,
0.0256839506,
0.5357915759,
-0.3909296691,
0.8752931356,
-0.634000659,
0.1875382811,
0.3248653412,
0.1583808213,
0.2804862857,
0.426425308,
0.110974215,
-0.0800302401,
-0.1096402258,
-0.3805156648,
-0.5846017003,
0.9250353575,
-0.8406124115,
-0.7331174016,
-0.4892758429,
-0.6120443344,
0.145255819,
0.4855076671,
0.5561369061,
0.5436850786,
-0.4095458984,
0.0645397082,
0.7178477049,
-0.0501616001,
0.4390372038,
0.6835114956,
0.10647019,
-0.6368029714,
0.817963779,
0.2433166504,
0.3648911715,
-0.0226141009,
0.5110605955,
-0.4986802638,
-0.5109933615,
-0.3571432233,
0.0961786956,
-0.6588793397,
-0.3707500994,
-0.4318298101,
-0.0586936325,
-0.35916996,
-0.3422684073,
-0.3370204568,
-0.70430094,
-0.2499771118,
-0.1045670286,
0.1039392129,
0.270947665,
-0.3706666231,
-0.1843736619,
-0.3828561008,
0.3862200081,
0.3325463235,
0.4074626863,
-0.0157104917,
-0.353610158,
0.1639335304,
0.1230194643,
-0.3633405566,
-0.7846958041,
0.4788786769,
0.1743797511,
0.7968347669,
0.6377117634,
0.6848062873,
0.6027356386,
-0.4915288091,
0.3167871237,
0.7653572559,
-0.9524732232,
0.4190109372,
-0.1872319281,
0.1616232842,
0.9255183339,
0.6664392352,
-0.0383676365,
-0.2988473177,
-0.5394456983,
-0.8773032427,
0.6207155585,
-0.10238906,
0.000911756,
0.0385373272,
0.2748291492,
0.4346707165,
-0.1021983176,
-0.7869848609,
-0.0842757747,
-0.5238392353,
-0.1846009642,
-0.010076859,
-0.3230673969,
-0.5746361017,
-0.3579254746,
0.4234001935,
-0.1109115705,
-0.0354886502,
0.405970484,
-0.3160610199,
-0.4674612582,
0.2729465365,
0.6200974584,
0.7992011905,
-0.3805705905,
0.1613654792,
-0.0910174921,
-0.0974182412,
0.2613452971,
0.4033810496,
-0.5060361028,
-0.3816512525,
-0.0795860663,
0.5745029449,
-0.1491182148,
-0.7411354184,
0.3839387596,
-0.1813236177,
-0.4113772511,
-0.5569663048,
0.0782723352,
-0.1797466874,
0.3725222349,
0.1671345383,
0.5226328373,
0.1100532189,
-0.5978386998,
0.4272190034,
0.7603731155,
-0.3869261444,
-0.4114448726,
0.7790457606,
0.4670294523,
-0.2018577904,
0.6043071747,
-0.2421138138,
-0.6790929437,
0.5518183112,
0.8504732847,
1.1440507174,
-0.3746245205,
0.2502844334,
0.5995019674,
0.3265313506,
-0.3074026704,
0.0204210766,
-0.520657599,
-0.8234587908,
-0.3412106335,
-0.5172773004,
-0.1696264297,
0.0963431969,
-0.8619704247,
0.0743113831,
-0.7190364003,
-0.2410499752,
0.0315348357,
0.0373300202,
-0.2070310563,
-0.014149949,
-0.1161587313,
0.8571421504,
-0.7330935001,
0.9181482196,
0.3623889387,
-0.7596883774,
-0.5381402969,
0.414657861,
-0.3099602759,
-0.4821742177,
0.4940473139,
0.4199056625,
-0.2471123338,
0.1391993314,
-0.3786377907,
-0.6523522735,
1.245033741,
0.5479093194,
-0.4801855087,
0.0232523903,
-0.2203852683,
0.530401051,
-0.1676087677,
-0.1180611476,
0.6431386471,
0.3217307031,
-0.0216891281,
-0.5356140733,
0.2909328938,
-0.117164202,
-0.0792401582,
0.2376266718,
-0.6830725074,
0.8258396387,
-0.581884861,
-0.8171165586,
0.1682081372,
0.5755809546,
0.1690518558,
0.4256341457,
0.6310635209,
0.6409294605,
0.638481915,
0.2233643234,
0.7628981471,
-0.5466221571,
0.6065329313,
0.9084098935,
-0.1383037418,
0.5590065718,
0.5817934871,
-0.0213544965,
0.4750968516,
0.2565466166,
-0.1002098471,
0.7064635754,
0.3745029271,
-0.4025085568,
-0.1668640375,
0.0423188731,
-0.335791409,
0.3477208316,
0.1178924292,
-0.3237270117,
-0.30490762,
0.1547999233,
-0.200826332,
0.3461775482,
-0.0200039148,
0.7086402774,
0.1100489721,
-0.8269530535,
1.0313570499,
0.0199838858,
0.4943518341,
-0.6539029479,
0.1966042966,
-0.2748556733,
0.5330116153,
-0.0361086987,
-0.3591242433,
0.3131773174,
-0.1841100007,
-0.4842986465,
-0.2898755074,
1.0364458561,
-0.8956452608,
-0.1432058215,
0.2793459594,
0.3671926856,
-0.2001755834,
0.2948937714,
-0.8653537631,
0.0446858443,
0.1534708738,
-0.3568637371,
0.4459748566,
0.3270966113,
0.3029360771,
0.9771378636,
0.5803056359,
-0.2854328156,
-0.3558678329,
0.0392592847,
1.1510226727,
-0.6323252916,
-0.5304225087,
-0.9652805924,
0.5075742006,
-0.1121361628,
-0.2538771629,
0.8193068504,
0.4617905021,
0.8213075995,
-0.2839813828,
0.605718255,
-0.0683314726,
0.3504361808,
-0.4730943143,
0.7382270098,
-0.2815286815,
0.3464961648,
0.1545467824,
-0.8938401341,
-0.1946738958,
0.918613553,
-0.2314400375,
0.0273238607,
0.6356437206,
0.5592182279,
0.0222778935,
-0.1867803484,
0.1766009182,
-0.1022135094,
0.1741380543,
0.2645128071,
0.9505314231,
0.1808900535,
0.5099952817,
-0.8778678775,
-0.6220074892,
-0.0897137821,
-0.5828635693,
-1.0676480532,
-0.5399560332,
-0.4197666049,
-0.4573668242,
-0.1444031745,
0.9716240168,
0.4298591912,
-0.5979627967,
-0.2531174421,
-0.6500377059,
0.0070860446,
-0.4889745712,
-0.2923300266,
0.1179142669,
-0.560533762,
-0.5876703858,
0.4346044958,
0.0549410097,
0.208926931,
-0.5207982659,
-0.1574612111,
0.2536457479,
0.0150898155,
0.3392305672,
0.5848686099,
-0.5161983371,
-0.1243700311,
-0.0978608131,
-0.0280453004,
-0.0363265723,
0.9998887181,
-0.8845508099,
0.6342157722,
0.585234046,
0.3452950716,
0.4113241434,
0.5478436947,
0.6701453924,
-0.4127025306,
0.2714597285,
0.5924392343,
0.1584642529,
0.0939070582,
-0.2020780295,
0.3124118745,
0.4793133438,
-0.8585338593,
-1.0222284794,
0.6531817913,
-1.0601576567,
-0.583030045,
0.8532834649,
-0.2308309525,
-0.1536910683,
-0.0602043606,
-0.1228413209,
0.4406113029,
-0.5851665735,
1.3243124485,
0.1358772963,
-0.1832954884,
-0.1545048505,
-0.0722722933,
0.9326452613,
0.5230659246,
-0.5180957317,
0.4502328634,
0.7120335102,
0.5837105513,
0.2854145169,
0.5863959789,
0.0384216905,
0.1695544869,
0.332436502,
0.1679069698,
-0.1265755147,
-0.2884919047,
-0.6575939655,
0.1057409793,
0.1713281423,
-0.2211673707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13592v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13592v2 | Understanding Programs by Exploiting (Fuzzing) Test Cases | 2023-05-23T01:51:46 | 2023-06-12T00:56:21 | Jianyu Zhao, Yuyang Rong, Yiwen Guo, Yifeng He, Hao Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.SE | Semantic understanding of programs has attracted great attention in the
community. Inspired by recent successes of large language models (LLMs) in
natural language understanding, tremendous progress has been made by treating
programming language as another sort of natural language and training LLMs on
corpora of program code. However, programs are essentially different from texts
after all, in a sense that they are normally heavily structured and
syntax-strict. In particular, programs and their basic units (i.e., functions
and subroutines) are designed to demonstrate a variety of behaviors and/or
provide possible outputs, given different inputs. The relationship between
inputs and possible outputs/behaviors represents the functions/subroutines and
profiles the program as a whole. Therefore, we propose to incorporate such a
relationship into learning, for achieving a deeper semantic understanding of
programs. To obtain inputs that are representative enough to trigger the
execution of most part of the code, we resort to fuzz testing and propose fuzz
tuning to boost the performance of program understanding and code
representation learning, given a pre-trained LLM. The effectiveness of the
proposed method is verified on two program understanding tasks including code
clone detection and code classification, and it outperforms current
state-of-the-arts by large margins. Code is available at
https://github.com/rabbitjy/FuzzTuning. | [
-0.340774864,
-0.9080892205,
0.4406992495,
0.1192579791,
0.0720853359,
0.2820483148,
-0.277402699,
-0.1486616582,
-0.1197423488,
0.7832760215,
-0.8558148146,
-0.4962450862,
-0.4227521122,
-0.0577095449,
-0.5439700484,
1.321090579,
0.1673202962,
-0.0248149168,
-0.2982521355,
0.1379064173,
-0.4899677932,
-0.306322664,
-0.2515297532,
-0.4865503609,
0.2391333878,
0.4539265335,
0.6150741577,
0.3035835326,
0.3318406045,
0.2997639179,
0.3103419542,
-0.1096161008,
-0.7597117424,
-0.2935895026,
-0.0691091269,
-0.793079257,
0.1460114121,
-0.1086827666,
0.2167459577,
0.6480761766,
-0.0293041859,
0.0970088094,
-0.344398737,
0.4902707636,
-0.5763434172,
0.3112187386,
-0.8222192526,
-0.0504832827,
-0.0946133882,
-0.4405924082,
-0.568102181,
-0.2239863873,
-0.2156788111,
-0.6298809648,
0.3345539272,
-0.1138010994,
1.0758721828,
0.4546760023,
-0.2066114247,
-0.3553285897,
-0.5657394528,
0.6316417456,
-0.7534335852,
0.3165502548,
0.2838136852,
0.3090991378,
-0.5668778419,
-0.5721687078,
-0.5486165881,
-0.3430192471,
-0.0607220642,
0.003973268,
-0.1149171367,
0.226277858,
0.6757605076,
0.6557640433,
-0.6440474987,
-0.0033449053,
-0.5727813244,
-0.405921489,
0.6164089441,
0.0697186589,
0.6005589962,
0.1993966699,
-0.3047569394,
-0.1645792276,
-0.5093635917,
0.0457891859,
0.4495426416,
0.1363408267,
0.1532633603,
0.45562011,
-0.2603987753,
0.8004100323,
-0.115955919,
0.0417054333,
0.4346548915,
-0.2749689817,
-0.4260010719,
-0.2311799377,
0.3203401268,
-0.0953764915,
0.7282428741,
-0.335160464,
-0.1272225082,
0.4140556753,
0.6414653063,
-0.5906953812,
-0.7047188282,
0.142245695,
-0.0624507889,
-0.3278690279,
0.346550107,
-0.5502953529,
-0.2995343804,
-0.3503060937,
0.6275542974,
-0.9189515114,
-0.1674924195,
0.3390212953,
-0.4395121038,
0.8182059526,
-0.1200228557,
-0.8753422499,
0.3704459667,
1.0826357603,
0.4591507912,
0.0759987161,
-0.5088204741,
-0.8311218619,
0.1140854806,
-0.1597146839,
0.9686257243,
-0.593293786,
-0.4173792303,
-0.1817643791,
-0.0950766429,
0.020833388,
-0.4466419518,
-0.0314918235,
-0.6137276292,
-0.016984215,
0.0370908044,
-0.7920462489,
-0.1481399983,
0.0948866308,
-0.3761267662,
1.0383609533,
0.5296698809,
-0.5781583786,
0.3683020175,
-0.7291502357,
-0.7603760958,
0.028593814,
-0.2712739408,
-0.3051126897,
0.3833684623,
0.1387971193,
0.2149936855,
0.3770190775,
-0.1320088208,
-0.3755138218,
-0.8622034192,
0.2320352644,
0.1620907038,
0.7638309002,
0.1236628145,
-0.4025047123,
0.2037721574,
-0.315235436,
0.3619183302,
0.0574576855,
-0.2824490666,
-0.2133907229,
-0.1363217533,
-0.2977521122,
0.0336392671,
-0.0642175823,
-0.3692354262,
0.3103387654,
-0.9917176962,
0.3970467746,
0.6782513261,
0.0680563077,
0.3091295362,
-0.1405530721,
0.4950026572,
0.0068394728,
0.2388580441,
-0.3878528476,
-0.2842442393,
-0.9378013015,
-0.132646367,
0.2038409561,
0.5949105024,
-0.6678371429,
0.2886362374,
-0.1640901417,
-0.2195612788,
-0.4529547989,
0.6183565259,
0.3393494785,
0.0627438799,
0.1799605191,
-0.2172260284,
-0.400313586,
-0.7245520353,
-0.5081026554,
-0.2150583267,
-0.0819156542,
0.1998758316,
0.6462352872,
-0.3267500699,
0.858458519,
-0.9072021246,
-0.055127684,
-0.5072597265,
0.0670591518,
0.3330604136,
0.3373441994,
0.4097021222,
-0.7532324791,
-0.2494868636,
-0.0283998381,
-0.1133804992,
-0.4306586683,
-0.1526399106,
-0.3492912054,
0.1056198403,
0.7474917769,
-0.1161472276,
0.4375552237,
0.5411730409,
-0.506364882,
0.522521019,
-0.129376784,
0.2042046487,
-0.7238680124,
-0.051643759,
-0.372051686,
-0.3039350212,
-0.3361128867,
0.513862431,
0.1554024071,
-0.0729206353,
-0.5358865857,
0.2029289454,
-0.4116087854,
-0.1487345546,
-0.2248378396,
-0.0053332942,
0.0432538763,
0.5655485988,
-0.2708536386,
0.8944948316,
0.3696148098,
-0.4728469551,
0.4782744646,
-0.2074547261,
-0.3713115752,
0.1544752419,
-0.5353722572,
0.1742798388,
0.0555332601,
-0.0753616467,
-0.8969907165,
-0.2800642848,
-0.0897273421,
-0.5555846691,
0.2945145369,
-0.3220615983,
-0.6405293345,
-0.2935009301,
-0.3491990268,
-0.0133563234,
0.8344438076,
-0.4794894159,
0.3240949512,
0.4018850625,
0.3241016865,
-0.230874911,
-0.6276521683,
-0.3558824062,
-0.1571023464,
-0.526958406,
0.1374381483,
-0.0250375886,
-0.1687185913,
-0.1687442958,
-0.1735283583,
-0.3143885136,
0.4854979217,
0.3959494233,
0.1845482737,
-0.2036475986,
0.3302194774,
0.1381971836,
-0.3150947094,
0.0719413236,
-0.3431678712,
0.4382425249,
-0.2645810544,
-0.5537929535,
0.0714169741,
0.4211230576,
0.4571667314,
-0.3181066215,
0.4567331672,
0.7499304414,
-0.2356145084,
-0.6177323461,
-0.4317456782,
-0.3217403889,
-0.4794560671,
0.51301682,
-0.3809818029,
-0.885769546,
0.1379491985,
-0.4596075118,
0.1665149331,
0.1666023582,
0.6599131823,
-0.054311797,
0.8896067739,
1.0195493698,
-0.2122384608,
0.6153030396,
-0.3536869287,
0.4440137744,
-0.3934576809,
-0.1125798598,
-0.6094312668,
-0.102411814,
-0.2403196543,
-0.5390788317,
0.1731643081,
0.0039330497,
0.023412453,
0.3821667731,
-0.2188970447,
1.1497449875,
0.3764573336,
0.0687697381,
0.2553199232,
-0.1108326092,
-0.214450404,
0.0960768536,
-0.5415346622,
-0.3129320145,
0.7755776048,
0.1255062073,
0.8208323717,
0.1083680913,
0.8640099764,
0.4053098559,
0.3145186305,
-0.8460723758,
0.2789348364,
-0.2688072324,
-0.3948469758,
0.047293894,
-0.5139721036,
-0.8322877884,
-0.0371689461,
0.0591628738,
-0.8717884421,
-0.4989776015,
0.1436088681,
-0.3316189349,
0.0995341986,
-1.2131797075,
1.119284749,
-0.2781678736,
-0.0401203297,
-0.3839440942,
-0.4659188986,
0.475571245,
0.2554281056,
0.2790112197,
-0.1456863284,
0.1640603989,
0.3246043622,
-0.5220735073,
0.6685042381,
0.0341166817,
0.0172362812,
0.0973009467,
0.3666716814,
0.0584855638,
0.1585877091,
-0.0453770757,
-0.0058106994,
0.5600365996,
-0.6933222413,
-0.9070503712,
0.8369116783,
-0.5593572855,
-0.5973267555,
-0.2809435427,
-0.6630560756,
-0.3089424372,
0.1559363753,
-0.0193187408,
0.3590952754,
-0.0907940269,
-0.1556951404,
0.8293010592,
-0.2690475285,
0.0385507084,
0.3923587799,
-0.4261286855,
0.1854005456,
1.0197134018,
-0.4370076358,
0.4192358553,
0.3497751355,
0.1429793239,
0.0258476846,
-0.4547501802,
-0.1912502944,
0.2150481641,
-0.5951251984,
-0.2391645312,
-0.4500003457,
-0.0524037853,
-0.4402057827,
-0.3118944168,
-0.0544991829,
-0.1129364967,
-0.0561879091,
0.0646541864,
0.5580557585,
0.7157828212,
0.3352160454,
0.1827433407,
-0.7970695496,
0.2636394501,
0.0493461825,
0.4416146278,
-0.2735702693,
-0.2326271087,
-0.3116720915,
0.0221242253,
-0.3383389413,
-1.0576524734,
0.1395647526,
0.3413795531,
0.6639537811,
0.2401489019,
-0.0394163653,
0.8661797047,
-0.1723339856,
0.7014026642,
-0.3079012036,
-1.1629961729,
1.0279128551,
-0.0424072333,
0.4596580267,
0.8407429457,
0.1051719934,
-0.358802706,
-0.777535975,
-0.5726366639,
-0.5262945294,
0.7152999043,
0.1437476277,
0.3781503439,
0.1123299599,
0.446444273,
0.2309979796,
0.0752903894,
-0.4868373871,
0.0401380919,
0.0890630484,
-0.4403910935,
-0.0953340605,
0.1997066438,
0.0442007408,
-0.3823532164,
0.6194608808,
-0.3425889611,
0.0449075326,
-0.092117019,
-0.4263398051,
0.4736665785,
0.191024676,
0.2631198764,
0.4034627974,
0.0051440578,
0.2490884513,
0.2240161449,
-0.461522162,
-0.230340749,
-0.3207451403,
0.0833632573,
-0.1974542141,
0.48375085,
0.3942778111,
0.381973058,
-1.2078845501,
0.5258688331,
-0.052437745,
0.0226845071,
-0.0070803133,
0.9314364195,
0.0203694385,
0.0998263955,
-0.1809396893,
-0.196381852,
0.3193937838,
-0.8636930585,
0.4259071052,
0.3857736588,
-0.2644272447,
-0.0585234202,
0.0161548536,
0.1891369373,
-0.2581130564,
0.9424437284,
-0.2880589962,
-0.8344817758,
0.843937099,
0.6937840581,
0.592636168,
0.4198672771,
0.1764725298,
0.0378176086,
0.2482469976,
0.3595611453,
0.324763149,
-0.4897680581,
-0.4711858928,
-0.4892745912,
-0.6873483062,
-0.3223654032,
0.0226673763,
-0.441337347,
0.4568373859,
-0.5223834515,
0.1250431091,
0.0545606725,
0.2832137048,
-0.4607845545,
-0.1404145807,
0.1087319404,
1.1760505438,
-0.9696006179,
0.9376883507,
0.7295693755,
-0.4179329872,
-0.88954705,
0.1881874651,
0.0069194306,
-0.6163169742,
0.3952162266,
0.2623494864,
-0.0719528198,
0.0349874459,
-0.5594962835,
-0.5372716188,
0.6546912193,
0.6083031297,
-0.1430849284,
0.1749431044,
-0.0798906311,
0.478441596,
-0.1546452641,
0.2657548189,
0.9101706147,
0.3273133337,
0.1097201854,
-0.513255775,
-0.1561775059,
-0.4229787886,
-0.0052940631,
0.5836785436,
-0.2735773027,
0.528698504,
-0.6968285441,
-0.2458671033,
-0.0350470208,
0.4552405775,
0.1582479328,
0.3472057283,
0.425245136,
0.3865892887,
0.6088268161,
-0.2944407761,
1.3035535812,
-0.1049616411,
0.4441244602,
1.0823751688,
-0.0510584787,
0.6487007737,
0.8066495657,
-0.4572675824,
0.7665022612,
0.6278340816,
-0.1581634283,
0.3761490881,
0.7556172013,
0.0552832894,
-0.4485430717,
0.2834871709,
-0.2577981055,
0.4634837806,
0.5525273085,
-0.2068700045,
-0.3309716582,
-0.190578416,
0.0094719613,
0.1555732787,
0.005116872,
0.8146561384,
-0.0444992743,
-0.626614511,
0.2361509502,
0.0141348951,
0.5599171519,
-0.8099101186,
-0.2643515468,
-0.1065831631,
0.2677657306,
-0.4064799845,
-0.7994357347,
0.7148031592,
0.0460102707,
-0.1603891999,
-0.0282655247,
0.7122338414,
-0.0728630871,
-0.5459523201,
0.3361220956,
0.2601258457,
0.4290262759,
-0.0082419496,
-0.6744446158,
0.3415194452,
0.110378176,
0.1654338241,
0.2746660113,
0.3321564198,
0.2452986687,
0.4913588166,
0.7998782396,
0.0658432469,
0.2704055607,
0.2878216505,
0.8494277596,
-0.4813464582,
-0.5408334136,
-0.9586007595,
0.1408145279,
-0.1375462562,
-0.2088808417,
0.6348350644,
0.5177732706,
1.1888484955,
-0.2238647342,
0.4478479624,
-0.1264421195,
-0.1195539236,
-0.7451213002,
0.5241975784,
-0.3294783235,
0.3902531266,
-0.3373782337,
-0.5250473022,
-0.3252921104,
0.6561625004,
-0.3074821532,
0.0812147185,
0.524946034,
1.1169034243,
-0.0971942097,
0.0773166269,
0.2818315625,
0.1847901791,
0.2903045416,
1.2785686255,
0.7611341476,
-0.278146863,
0.4409058988,
-0.3144758344,
-0.5003841519,
-0.1710756272,
-0.7023184299,
-0.9051722288,
-0.4582701623,
-0.4173721671,
-0.3343169093,
0.0074494109,
0.6367191672,
0.8421851993,
-0.7797544003,
-0.1754701883,
-0.2802844048,
0.5967622399,
-0.3246695697,
-0.3335774839,
-0.1637945473,
-0.7263766527,
-0.5011582971,
0.1678374708,
0.4828202724,
-0.3213470578,
-0.3596924543,
-0.1185637563,
-0.1651083529,
0.2584949434,
0.3741813004,
0.3569611311,
-0.5491976142,
-0.3453543186,
0.069764033,
0.0087879617,
-0.1557092369,
1.2310318947,
-1.1637545824,
0.3493289351,
0.5784584284,
0.6596590281,
0.3744928539,
-0.1917997152,
0.5860981345,
-0.6741748452,
-0.0592658035,
-0.0434882753,
0.1841849834,
0.0360899046,
-0.6091828346,
0.308057785,
0.0800143406,
-0.3184736073,
-0.7279535532,
0.4306159914,
-0.8742120862,
-0.4085396826,
0.9390845895,
-0.2514226735,
-0.4378879368,
-0.2542932928,
-0.4271165133,
0.2661682665,
-0.1775671691,
0.8209779263,
0.5992233753,
-0.5822876096,
0.1145440042,
-0.4732236564,
0.3263894022,
0.3620663285,
-1.0340989828,
0.1344246864,
0.3593574464,
0.6530986428,
-0.0265511014,
0.3938125968,
-0.4033325315,
0.493414402,
-0.0342441425,
-0.2147018313,
-0.2502090037,
-0.0786329657,
-0.3364133239,
0.0263656843,
0.0247402154,
-0.1670817286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13589v1 | BiasX: "Thinking Slow" in Toxic Content Moderation with Explanations of Implied Social Biases | 2023-05-23T01:45:18 | 2023-05-23T01:45:18 | Yiming Zhang, Sravani Nanduri, Liwei Jiang, Tongshuang Wu, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL | Toxicity annotators and content moderators often default to mental shortcuts
when making decisions. This can lead to subtle toxicity being missed, and
seemingly toxic but harmless content being over-detected. We introduce BiasX, a
framework that enhances content moderation setups with free-text explanations
of statements' implied social biases, and explore its effectiveness through a
large-scale crowdsourced user study. We show that indeed, participants
substantially benefit from explanations for correctly identifying subtly
(non-)toxic content. The quality of explanations is critical: imperfect
machine-generated explanations (+2.4% on hard toxic examples) help less
compared to expert-written human explanations (+7.2%). Our results showcase the
promise of using free-text explanations to encourage more thoughtful toxicity
moderation. | [
-0.3811154068,
-0.8371686339,
1.0227147341,
0.5363679528,
-0.5317102075,
-0.3246003091,
-0.1509038955,
-0.3412649035,
0.319219768,
0.5427104235,
-0.8826978207,
-0.2945324481,
-0.7092037201,
0.1306493133,
-0.3160068691,
1.4441279173,
0.0012269525,
-0.1862290204,
-0.0446885675,
-0.1568029821,
-0.4841315746,
0.2018209696,
-1.0644556284,
-0.2343282253,
1.1490507126,
0.5199497938,
1.2094526291,
0.8577109575,
0.0636700839,
0.169509992,
-0.294898659,
-0.1925810128,
-0.7301090956,
0.1273298264,
-0.6144449115,
-0.4405111372,
-0.250715524,
0.3233155608,
0.0600497685,
0.685123086,
0.2051824629,
0.1854600459,
0.0619001277,
0.6933479905,
-0.865008235,
-0.1527236253,
-0.378138423,
0.3496170342,
-0.1125594527,
-0.1425082833,
-0.4089863002,
-0.6215289831,
0.1834933013,
-0.973223567,
0.059571337,
0.1578387022,
0.3545489907,
0.5334026217,
-0.6453085542,
-0.3250105381,
-0.7121220231,
0.8131055236,
-0.4572328031,
0.1749755144,
0.3835929334,
0.2032196671,
0.1381277889,
-0.5901483297,
-0.4619798362,
0.3292958438,
-0.0866269544,
0.1894392371,
-0.0757047534,
0.0256499704,
0.6425205469,
0.1940695345,
-0.4155617058,
-0.2258132398,
-0.1240218803,
-0.6313660145,
0.7116742134,
0.2573493719,
0.2007935941,
0.0478313267,
-0.3776169121,
0.2036887407,
-0.5114498138,
-0.1962464005,
0.3498721421,
-0.1066325679,
-0.1588602364,
0.4869868159,
0.0972954631,
0.2627268732,
0.2084376365,
0.2904533744,
-0.1058376953,
-0.4463324249,
-0.0271436889,
0.1448868662,
0.7454379797,
0.8785473108,
0.2189122885,
-0.0433386937,
-0.0509387478,
0.2896499932,
0.0930437744,
-0.9099578857,
-0.4361905754,
0.5571957231,
-1.0030595064,
-0.3713645041,
-0.3216223121,
-1.1267870665,
-0.7734578848,
-0.0629338995,
0.3756235242,
-0.0537872836,
-0.4554041028,
0.108989574,
-0.6181578636,
-0.116087921,
0.3923154771,
-0.3646683395,
0.1703308821,
0.2496201545,
0.8184850216,
-0.2179863304,
0.2576008737,
-0.7699989676,
0.0900791213,
-0.4140902758,
0.8546681404,
-0.6270141006,
-0.5245348811,
0.0491024144,
0.0345591418,
0.5924053192,
-0.4243592918,
0.9304080009,
-0.3639058769,
0.4455158114,
-1.0622535944,
-0.1810628623,
-0.087621212,
-0.0892590135,
-0.7500864863,
0.822923243,
0.0042554922,
-1.192910552,
0.8798345327,
-0.4833545685,
-0.4054321647,
-0.0281762891,
0.4352596104,
-0.1482340842,
-0.0397287197,
0.2129398435,
0.2750599086,
-0.0136406757,
0.0004144878,
-0.6845798492,
-0.6145137548,
0.3779861927,
-0.5448362231,
1.0349446535,
0.5819468498,
-0.6165146232,
0.3496380746,
-0.2495826632,
0.0693291798,
-0.2020014673,
-0.1227529794,
-0.6825742126,
0.3303198218,
0.2305017561,
0.5009979606,
-0.2264036238,
-0.2167214155,
-0.2505741417,
0.0129071483,
0.4709623456,
1.0292857885,
0.2258513719,
0.6827751398,
-0.5695358515,
0.3142828047,
0.1162129194,
0.8241221309,
-0.0027300403,
-0.6361485124,
-0.565739274,
-0.0764414147,
-0.1049252898,
0.3062758744,
-0.926997304,
-0.2110781074,
0.0987584293,
-0.2494203299,
-0.207922399,
0.1321432739,
0.5585669875,
0.3067842424,
0.4210734665,
-0.4526363015,
-0.0954436511,
-0.7759984732,
-0.6494623423,
-0.0014782859,
-0.174811244,
0.4664200544,
0.3413013518,
-0.4212622344,
0.6179448962,
-0.402012378,
0.0350199714,
0.0497999229,
0.4050438106,
-0.084159635,
0.0216122158,
0.3516328931,
-0.8089542985,
-0.5790227056,
-0.6501119733,
-0.3520167768,
-0.4625144899,
-0.3362243176,
-0.6510148048,
-0.3154245615,
0.3944615126,
-0.3902196586,
0.2755585015,
0.0064046709,
-0.5506616235,
0.6407184005,
0.1842233837,
0.1220008805,
-0.5661175251,
-0.2249252349,
0.2665580213,
-0.2314674109,
-0.4252566099,
-0.047922913,
-0.0705047473,
0.0565968268,
-0.6224770546,
0.6303240657,
-0.4871994853,
0.4569483697,
-0.267963022,
0.3899469674,
-0.0008366905,
0.183374688,
-0.0208504032,
0.6986035109,
0.3083980083,
-0.7406226397,
-0.0357188135,
-0.0290569738,
-0.0196151305,
0.6342591047,
-0.5177521706,
0.2619555891,
-0.3710047603,
0.4466131926,
-0.8441348076,
-0.4136968553,
0.5222802162,
-0.0381272472,
-0.3225132823,
-0.1781745106,
-0.2969279885,
-0.6025128961,
-0.772466898,
0.615618825,
0.3660415113,
-0.3971412182,
0.1532979608,
0.3210410178,
0.0020838794,
-0.5724798441,
-0.6352310777,
-0.0740215182,
-0.3683335781,
-0.3914653957,
0.1779924929,
-0.4875833392,
-0.7203519344,
0.0397365242,
-0.3191421032,
-0.2601448894,
0.072130397,
0.2764671445,
-0.1161882356,
0.115000017,
0.1112255231,
0.4587782025,
-0.0773007572,
0.6539161801,
0.0004298013,
0.0484103784,
0.2761394382,
0.068197228,
-0.3472112715,
0.6759851575,
0.6335725784,
0.1769136339,
0.3821228743,
0.5844886303,
-0.2179252803,
-0.5359407663,
-0.4587635696,
-0.4237535596,
-0.4857487082,
-0.1834938824,
0.3278183639,
-0.8032006621,
0.6799066663,
-0.0772237778,
0.0135288546,
0.3414380848,
0.4082765281,
0.085872516,
1.5760879517,
0.6054170728,
0.0809476599,
0.4439058602,
0.2371554822,
0.0816690475,
-0.4427718818,
-0.0698885694,
-0.3142621517,
-0.1998756677,
-0.5310829282,
-0.6152957678,
0.2864182591,
-0.6352801323,
-0.4052942097,
-0.2627529204,
-0.6344117522,
0.8302775025,
0.4779553711,
0.5038925409,
0.3058210313,
-0.3074243367,
0.0274788812,
-0.2041571289,
-0.5328727961,
-0.385250926,
0.8760868311,
0.2767946124,
0.9476222396,
-0.0833948925,
0.3421656489,
0.7261734009,
0.7686558366,
-0.7344101667,
0.3250337839,
0.1698571444,
-1.187735796,
-0.0535351709,
-0.3942138851,
-0.3638022542,
-0.083959572,
-0.43346259,
-0.227550596,
0.1431908309,
0.3449088931,
-0.7171878219,
0.1049032733,
-0.8546566367,
0.4625439048,
-0.1426402032,
-1.0755311251,
-0.2770279646,
-0.8161106706,
0.5996390581,
-0.0339499228,
0.7371471524,
-0.0932843164,
-0.1108558699,
0.8675782681,
-0.4225822091,
0.8776637912,
-0.4275030196,
-0.1170969978,
0.5291225314,
0.26588431,
0.3592862785,
0.5455947518,
-0.1306133717,
0.1165091917,
-0.1693160832,
-0.3420887291,
-0.568502605,
0.658947587,
-0.4745998383,
-0.4814518988,
-0.2507875264,
-0.3440944552,
-0.041910056,
0.2599706352,
0.2129762024,
-0.0893870667,
-0.0370129012,
-0.1679182947,
1.2344119549,
-0.4943115413,
0.2291142493,
0.2778742313,
-0.0413429439,
-0.387727499,
0.5924577117,
-0.0656695813,
0.1793452352,
0.0039257952,
0.3343277872,
-0.1777469218,
-0.1765155345,
-0.4149715602,
0.163356632,
-0.5733636618,
-0.0395125113,
-0.4831106067,
0.2462849021,
-0.122752063,
-0.4715599418,
-0.1945153475,
-0.2163336724,
-0.2254465818,
-0.2347005159,
0.2417473942,
0.7217611074,
-0.2608057857,
0.3547064662,
-0.479452461,
0.2378580719,
0.5810511112,
0.6985589862,
0.0715497658,
-0.0011923417,
-0.0766657367,
0.2185201049,
-0.3723530471,
-1.4471777678,
0.1268636733,
-0.1503859311,
0.2921896875,
1.0559004545,
0.19558011,
0.4289687276,
-0.3931103051,
0.7582992911,
-0.0686390623,
-0.9859676957,
0.6695429087,
-0.5650780201,
0.1608137637,
0.6416879892,
0.8238682151,
-0.8298367858,
-0.5608212948,
-0.2021051049,
-0.813357234,
0.5130082965,
0.1032358259,
0.3944777548,
-0.5722327828,
0.7017574906,
0.6432734728,
0.0004590238,
-0.9576892257,
-0.4918974936,
-0.5002599955,
0.0313522257,
0.1865894347,
-0.8676711321,
-0.4750458598,
-0.1363441795,
0.6364513636,
-0.1299904585,
0.401234597,
0.291608572,
-0.1657628864,
-0.6489645839,
0.3991133571,
0.4149077833,
0.6574227214,
-0.0407828428,
0.4455633461,
0.0266665369,
-0.4839390516,
0.0872152597,
-0.1299116313,
-0.3104013801,
-0.0620760769,
0.133047536,
0.3468871415,
0.334056139,
-0.5149463415,
0.7201209664,
-0.295473814,
-0.3177924156,
0.0411626995,
0.2195625752,
-0.0244884212,
0.1268149912,
0.143134892,
-0.0799104869,
0.5379189849,
-0.4993610084,
0.1623218507,
0.424018681,
-0.8914805055,
-0.3140234947,
1.3292845488,
0.428960681,
0.1019999683,
0.5571914315,
-0.04318754,
-0.3286434114,
0.4122631252,
0.2902389169,
0.8572335243,
0.0683777258,
0.74189955,
0.3421656191,
0.4114921391,
-0.0097101694,
0.343978703,
-0.4323176444,
-0.4888516665,
-0.6732329726,
-0.2846744061,
-0.4638524652,
0.0000273618,
-0.5357944369,
0.1938275099,
-0.7096527815,
-0.3834068775,
0.1833741516,
-0.167665273,
-0.5036484599,
0.2269089371,
0.0824335068,
1.2915946245,
-1.3486747742,
0.0849439874,
0.35872522,
-0.5149927735,
-0.7404516339,
0.3938197196,
0.3528556526,
-0.5303890705,
0.2795934975,
0.2131101787,
-0.0311113615,
-0.375934273,
-1.0443353653,
-0.5830135942,
0.7393836975,
0.1167461425,
-0.2509542406,
-0.0771774799,
-0.0393670164,
0.4817534685,
0.3277201355,
0.7742094994,
0.0654492602,
0.7913606167,
-0.043480061,
-0.4999480546,
0.7154542804,
-0.3325716853,
-0.0940125436,
0.0385841094,
-0.8025788665,
0.5462725163,
-0.3973082602,
-0.2662258148,
-0.4003327489,
0.4565949738,
-0.2520290613,
0.7795274258,
0.8521558642,
0.3184718192,
0.5444047451,
-0.1205455735,
1.0129311085,
-0.08398249,
-0.002853099,
0.7743454576,
-0.1469838321,
0.1565837413,
0.5094692111,
0.1243612468,
0.9066280723,
0.9749684334,
0.3340432644,
0.7251623273,
-0.0722426027,
-0.6102106571,
-0.5014799237,
-0.3670121133,
-0.3088337779,
-0.2042806298,
0.4005052447,
-0.7212414742,
-0.2780017853,
0.0603774376,
0.5288727283,
-0.1516230255,
-0.4756046832,
0.670159936,
0.1148676053,
-0.9427090287,
0.0093303965,
-0.1814620048,
0.6599091887,
-0.1940215826,
0.0720633119,
-0.3821184635,
-0.0208932348,
-0.3105360866,
-1.020015955,
0.4746679962,
-0.1413096935,
-0.4009751081,
-0.7518395185,
0.9219654202,
-0.0659103394,
0.0752907544,
0.2833430171,
0.6694904566,
0.1386435479,
-0.3708944619,
-0.8013619184,
0.0122642396,
-0.201510638,
-0.1557809263,
0.0976890773,
0.6923474669,
-0.3902199864,
0.5414351821,
0.5643808842,
-0.1065948978,
-0.1153031141,
0.0576875508,
0.9821941257,
-0.4382546544,
-0.3412182629,
-0.8053452969,
0.5963387489,
-0.194066003,
-0.2459032983,
0.7147055864,
0.3916513324,
0.8018891811,
-0.0406907499,
0.8501266837,
0.0207553487,
0.2284707129,
-0.2117774636,
1.0237630606,
-0.564904213,
0.0031719583,
-0.3890827,
-0.8536925912,
-0.2304020375,
0.3735153377,
-0.3066439033,
0.1031271443,
0.8581652641,
0.6820596457,
-0.0527847856,
0.2350760102,
-0.1711401045,
0.5889424086,
0.1155307814,
0.4000308812,
0.806871891,
0.2085916251,
0.6985693574,
-0.5638610721,
-0.5146430135,
-0.0890065208,
-1.0319806337,
-1.0168197155,
-0.3452955484,
-0.3032765687,
-0.7177516222,
0.2551864088,
0.6621581912,
0.7707622647,
-0.4133344293,
0.3669451773,
-0.0788311213,
0.7906566858,
-0.2927522659,
-0.3582122922,
-0.1778685153,
0.078457199,
-0.5281414986,
-0.1460787505,
0.2249458581,
-0.3741652071,
-0.1863651723,
0.1833976656,
0.0776174814,
0.5830506682,
0.6586817503,
0.1213031039,
-0.4328342974,
-0.6172522902,
0.0576025955,
0.0427823104,
-0.2129695714,
0.9742064476,
-0.7036427855,
0.6201608181,
0.4576914907,
-0.1142135635,
0.3119854927,
-0.1274714917,
0.3952651322,
-0.3910164535,
-0.0519424714,
0.2374717742,
0.0265478436,
0.2714757621,
-0.6797961593,
0.2123505622,
0.3757288456,
-0.6045332551,
-0.57360816,
0.1991747618,
-1.0182783604,
-0.3476639688,
1.5121047497,
0.1550623477,
-0.4142105281,
-0.3846740425,
-0.5275861621,
0.3338117898,
-0.5178447962,
1.2819535732,
0.7668367624,
-0.021495318,
-0.0137996851,
-0.786647737,
0.8628191948,
0.3975297213,
-0.7598178983,
0.2249263674,
0.888876617,
0.6261624694,
-0.0838784575,
0.9171112776,
-0.2222175151,
0.5694035888,
-0.0357644297,
-0.4059278965,
0.3374376595,
-0.1818438023,
0.2024838477,
0.0536781028,
-0.2320571989,
0.3581554592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13585v1 | Query Structure Modeling for Inductive Logical Reasoning Over Knowledge Graphs | 2023-05-23T01:25:29 | 2023-05-23T01:25:29 | Siyuan Wang, Zhongyu Wei, Meng Han, Zhihao Fan, Haijun Shan, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Logical reasoning over incomplete knowledge graphs to answer complex logical
queries is a challenging task. With the emergence of new entities and relations
in constantly evolving KGs, inductive logical reasoning over KGs has become a
crucial problem. However, previous PLMs-based methods struggle to model the
logical structures of complex queries, which limits their ability to generalize
within the same structure. In this paper, we propose a structure-modeled
textual encoding framework for inductive logical reasoning over KGs. It encodes
linearized query structures and entities using pre-trained language models to
find answers. For structure modeling of complex queries, we design stepwise
instructions that implicitly prompt PLMs on the execution order of geometric
operations in each query. We further separately model different geometric
operations (i.e., projection, intersection, and union) on the representation
space using a pre-trained encoder with additional attention and maxout layers
to enhance structured modeling. We conduct experiments on two inductive logical
reasoning datasets and three transductive datasets. The results demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method on logical reasoning over KGs in both inductive and
transductive settings. | [
-0.0555020906,
-0.8553275466,
0.8838880658,
0.1280562431,
-0.1438877434,
-0.2306583375,
-0.0498642027,
-0.0103627136,
-0.038189061,
0.8236227036,
-0.644698441,
-0.8656308651,
-0.4630792439,
0.2710400522,
-0.2268935293,
0.6106585264,
-0.1794816554,
0.2437893599,
-0.6194563508,
-0.1409415454,
-0.3041059077,
-0.6135841012,
-0.2800624371,
-0.4761722982,
0.1872571856,
-0.0155202299,
0.6693048477,
0.4476233721,
0.297021687,
0.3007439971,
-0.1516963392,
0.6204687357,
-0.4055629373,
0.1301913559,
-0.2811800539,
-0.6813486814,
-0.1677458882,
-0.1015269682,
0.4330837429,
1.1571981907,
-0.2208010703,
-0.0324120782,
-0.0418063067,
0.4513587356,
-0.3896972537,
0.5987087488,
-0.6213459373,
0.1813373864,
0.1227369457,
-0.3057791889,
-0.7951077223,
-0.6902335286,
0.0318910144,
-0.8109954596,
-0.0951341167,
0.0778952539,
0.593241334,
0.3188896179,
-0.6328347921,
-0.6232261658,
-0.5403481126,
0.2684041262,
-0.5976464748,
0.6279765368,
0.4274213314,
0.3167030215,
-0.6656766534,
-0.8549941778,
-0.5012159348,
-0.2854095995,
-0.616196692,
0.0269707069,
0.3186416626,
0.2602716684,
0.3565019965,
0.1177679747,
-0.605101347,
-0.3996304274,
-0.1775149256,
0.0771251246,
0.4811435044,
0.2495778948,
0.2662819028,
-0.3787796795,
-0.4270354509,
0.158045724,
-0.7038831115,
0.0941180587,
0.2081785649,
0.2518340945,
0.1572497785,
0.9131959677,
-0.449873656,
1.0418105125,
-0.0441600457,
-0.1476083845,
-0.0530009344,
-0.2546043098,
-0.4071559608,
0.1274543703,
0.7088591456,
0.1254052371,
0.3682121038,
-0.4213307202,
-0.0228701513,
0.0480331779,
0.1385619789,
-0.8703994155,
-0.4641062021,
0.1888917238,
-0.4244644642,
-0.0358007699,
0.0660860911,
-0.1442707926,
-0.4210551381,
-0.354596734,
0.5569254756,
-0.7630575299,
-0.1264308244,
0.746167779,
-0.0111016007,
0.1875351965,
0.2470878065,
-0.4488769472,
0.2821457386,
0.4369060695,
0.138727814,
0.3734901845,
0.088357456,
-0.4537405074,
0.555953145,
-0.2372143716,
0.6441186666,
-0.8804042935,
-0.2249486148,
0.0049437634,
0.1172901317,
-0.3382356763,
-0.4286804199,
0.8780030608,
-0.9442304373,
0.4149805605,
-0.5017219186,
-1.0618680716,
-0.393081665,
0.4851666093,
-0.4468637407,
0.8060537577,
0.1709408462,
-0.7827709317,
0.086219497,
-0.7428000569,
-0.6947249174,
0.2690536976,
-0.3268263042,
-0.2905115485,
-0.1724600047,
0.4610848129,
0.3279176056,
-0.3541849256,
0.3452447057,
-0.4374963641,
-0.0313066728,
0.2285276502,
0.2220136821,
0.9150750041,
0.1033925116,
0.0153712127,
0.1590000391,
-0.8654720783,
0.3577396274,
0.2141775936,
-0.4741764665,
-0.4194472134,
0.2620357275,
-0.7692528963,
0.1667375267,
0.0191914849,
-0.6637993455,
0.3327097595,
-0.4514769316,
0.5415174961,
0.2221066505,
0.0649710149,
0.5341229439,
0.2640649974,
0.3043347895,
0.1682675779,
0.1629097015,
-0.048249919,
-0.4201892316,
-0.6501238346,
-0.0787418932,
0.1036270037,
0.6186913848,
-1.1633096933,
0.4400548041,
-0.2824578285,
-0.1940469295,
-0.3351057172,
-0.1316577941,
0.4092531502,
0.9822071791,
0.4545720518,
0.2173178792,
-0.1798027009,
-0.7345198393,
-0.4660280645,
-0.1864522249,
-0.2054829299,
0.3207416236,
0.4497871995,
0.0624569394,
0.9877222776,
-0.7659476399,
-0.1640748382,
-0.3386587799,
0.0373156071,
0.2127045542,
0.2906289995,
0.2840466499,
-0.8289495707,
-0.1337833107,
0.0340883918,
-1.1293615103,
-0.1762129217,
0.0420965627,
-0.5258367658,
-0.101804994,
0.4935774505,
-1.1050289869,
0.4719097316,
-0.2103544027,
-0.4350425005,
0.4052614272,
-0.0178308673,
0.0779414847,
-0.8393774033,
-0.2546901703,
-0.1894730181,
-0.1111251637,
-0.5287081003,
0.1245633811,
0.2908968925,
-0.2920546234,
-0.0648827553,
0.1313753575,
-0.3307388425,
-0.1157305688,
0.0885960385,
0.0659721643,
0.4968690276,
0.7253036499,
0.1212669536,
0.2856263518,
0.3148297966,
-0.7356148362,
0.5375854969,
0.4862387776,
-0.5063639283,
0.4180835187,
-0.7228709459,
0.0975999832,
-0.4549179673,
0.4797414839,
-0.8625468016,
-0.212474674,
0.4396013618,
-0.3507024944,
0.1998207718,
-0.426833123,
-0.9015119076,
-0.4729141295,
0.0934958234,
0.2561418116,
0.066056259,
-0.5413178802,
1.0930551291,
0.038542226,
0.0396933109,
-0.228465125,
-0.3520611227,
-0.3077499866,
-0.0165874232,
-1.0604567528,
0.348426342,
0.1509927064,
-0.0640728846,
0.4725769758,
-0.2326555401,
-0.0400339253,
-0.110924311,
-0.0128993783,
0.1457131952,
-0.3170166016,
0.2320341915,
0.2356957644,
0.1306916475,
0.4022675157,
-0.8760910034,
0.6065664291,
-0.0989562348,
-0.635373652,
-0.4333488941,
0.1852872968,
0.4732824564,
-0.5912619233,
0.893787086,
0.2830506563,
-0.4291314781,
-0.3947648406,
-0.4197610915,
-0.2393697798,
-0.4488609433,
0.3716130555,
-0.8133800626,
-0.6959270835,
0.5584152341,
-0.2384377718,
-0.2447020262,
0.3063802123,
0.3138978779,
-0.2891731262,
1.0179163218,
0.2571168244,
0.6124888062,
-0.0479797907,
-0.2916550338,
0.3472366333,
-0.5333587527,
-0.9696464539,
-0.3445954621,
-0.1287167221,
-0.2055177838,
-0.3912372291,
0.635671854,
0.3309211731,
-0.5057429671,
0.2281663567,
-0.5402643085,
0.4895439744,
0.4363543093,
0.1662899852,
0.3341964781,
0.1229742616,
-0.3914896548,
0.0692537427,
-0.9442427158,
-0.1201195791,
0.7024816871,
0.0343549028,
1.1112793684,
0.0112830764,
0.2029505223,
-0.1227005497,
0.1369608492,
-0.6212679148,
0.6277464032,
-0.0478670746,
-0.4662078023,
-0.2496543378,
-0.8030774593,
-0.5097863078,
0.418533504,
0.0068183751,
-0.2344312519,
0.1433601975,
-0.2864946127,
-0.1903837621,
0.4530783296,
-0.8842416406,
0.9758107066,
-0.2986995876,
-0.054488305,
0.2197864503,
-0.8664255142,
0.4498919547,
0.5001577735,
-0.0413376167,
0.0858323053,
0.4259602427,
0.377661407,
-0.7747796178,
0.5892025232,
-0.366997987,
0.0653894618,
0.4806782007,
0.3089681566,
0.7137805223,
0.0808837861,
-0.2061442733,
-0.3335856497,
-0.1285515726,
-0.2861262858,
-0.9912907481,
0.2684272826,
-0.655431211,
-0.6962477565,
-0.0221439991,
-0.8125985861,
-0.2983960211,
0.2209735811,
0.2300630361,
0.6717833281,
0.4120421708,
0.2363372594,
0.9486017227,
-0.3045992255,
-0.1954597235,
0.4479537904,
-0.0948781073,
-0.2781652808,
0.4345352948,
0.1406524926,
0.270430088,
0.8301615119,
0.0379222892,
-0.6757993102,
-0.4453139901,
-0.5691239834,
0.40667063,
-0.9765919447,
-0.374130547,
-0.880451858,
-0.4111897647,
-0.5524139404,
0.1014029756,
-0.1167051047,
-0.4377914667,
0.059898559,
-0.2109138519,
0.3099510372,
0.5258190632,
0.683605969,
0.0987909883,
-0.5874023438,
0.4959627688,
0.3982975185,
0.5511468649,
-0.1798151433,
-0.4437478185,
0.0637990683,
-0.1354739964,
0.0124862399,
-0.8144907951,
0.1883521974,
0.0032176664,
0.5962715149,
0.2375689745,
0.5241348147,
0.6903442144,
-0.5154610872,
0.1991056353,
-0.1314067096,
-0.6364139318,
0.781504035,
-0.2633594275,
0.1348708272,
0.3638786972,
0.5635196567,
-0.0938723162,
-0.1608006209,
-0.1390153915,
-0.5157155991,
0.8820547462,
0.4075669646,
-0.2883585095,
-0.0840710178,
0.6219865084,
-0.0141672781,
0.1921870559,
-0.7850516438,
-0.1760540307,
-0.4826288521,
-0.3664411902,
0.825614512,
-0.3002968132,
-0.3539625406,
-0.3917121291,
0.5438919663,
-0.0662357509,
0.0985484645,
0.3725047112,
-0.265812099,
0.1871702969,
0.2272752374,
0.1286677718,
0.653657794,
-0.3477088809,
0.1968447119,
-0.0558452383,
-0.0997790471,
-0.0931157768,
0.555655539,
-0.255477339,
-0.1107804254,
0.2866823077,
0.8425201774,
0.025422208,
-0.4541799724,
0.3519436121,
-0.0790872797,
-0.1689027846,
-0.169085443,
-0.0792826712,
0.367785275,
0.2816827297,
0.2122110277,
-0.2456230521,
-0.0213984791,
-0.3201966584,
-0.1504968852,
0.4249637127,
-0.0604218841,
-0.0638228357,
0.9631080031,
0.3105179369,
-0.0286217649,
0.9248455763,
-0.5543702245,
-0.6875697374,
0.5292357802,
0.7020134926,
0.3916265666,
0.0688891485,
0.1727041453,
0.3099248409,
0.5234170556,
0.2519062161,
0.3736978173,
-0.2768850029,
-0.8034073114,
-0.5539845228,
-0.922162354,
-0.1836652011,
0.0242699888,
-0.3971478343,
0.1439362764,
-0.3456760645,
0.2392825782,
-0.0857526213,
-0.1559875906,
-0.4705245197,
0.3365429342,
0.1060297862,
0.9925900698,
-0.521119535,
0.9025169015,
0.7607594132,
-0.4721754789,
-1.0496913195,
-0.4281854033,
-0.2919211686,
-0.6307953,
0.8358182907,
0.1206747666,
-0.1987346262,
-0.146378085,
-0.5162689686,
-0.818144083,
1.21269238,
0.6446064711,
-0.1610571295,
-0.2198896855,
0.560900867,
0.2955397666,
-0.5317875743,
-0.0219174754,
0.4408463836,
0.3126234114,
0.4303986728,
-0.3884682357,
0.2031772584,
-0.243161276,
0.0351038277,
0.2392012328,
-0.1593982428,
0.7877956629,
-0.0674324483,
-0.352086097,
-0.0148937646,
0.7188953161,
0.518422544,
0.2465183437,
0.5730185509,
1.0488780737,
0.8057180643,
-0.2221341282,
1.3343242407,
-0.2847054601,
0.1385757923,
1.1252948046,
-0.4636763334,
0.2120734006,
-0.1274630725,
-0.2479260713,
0.6708328128,
0.4583538473,
0.2022954226,
0.543920815,
0.0643711686,
-0.2025400698,
-0.5382735133,
-0.2472397536,
-0.5388833284,
0.1627399176,
0.7144658566,
-0.3099270761,
-0.3702581525,
0.0009437553,
0.0625390187,
0.144239977,
-0.3539168239,
0.6379802823,
-0.0355998501,
-0.5821258426,
0.4342887998,
0.168588385,
0.0629826188,
-0.8111798763,
-0.0226536002,
-0.2526840866,
0.0520058274,
-0.3456482589,
-0.8903210163,
0.1765155047,
-0.2636139393,
-0.2222359926,
-0.2434799224,
0.9646165967,
-0.6746531129,
-0.6912284493,
0.3309849203,
0.3147931397,
-0.0123619754,
-0.2271469533,
-0.3952821791,
-0.1995475739,
-0.1227442324,
-0.2655304074,
-0.0237989314,
1.0272064209,
-0.2011510879,
0.6907343864,
0.6384599805,
-0.2942359149,
0.3188059628,
0.4907953143,
1.0625338554,
-0.6133767366,
-0.571729362,
-0.6101312637,
0.2575328648,
-0.1813469529,
0.2467629164,
0.6008277535,
0.5234410763,
0.8566927314,
-0.1135083139,
0.480214268,
-0.1498301327,
0.2981846929,
-0.7252345085,
0.6882206202,
-0.314676255,
0.2795964181,
0.1150941476,
-0.792992413,
-0.3320474923,
0.5117453337,
-0.4701235592,
-0.031275183,
0.6377308965,
0.7278131843,
-0.1163902283,
0.3174805343,
-0.0337832645,
0.5317946672,
0.2772638798,
0.5199748874,
0.9289895892,
-0.1503234357,
0.8270944953,
-0.2739130855,
0.0606135651,
0.0492794029,
-0.4986300766,
-0.8063314557,
-0.3560515642,
-0.1350060701,
-0.4259048402,
-0.1029579192,
0.6079109311,
0.5723306537,
-0.6107337475,
0.1023289785,
-0.2929305434,
0.3769726157,
0.0132543463,
-0.2979972363,
0.7012315392,
-0.519212842,
-0.3436706066,
0.4393155873,
0.4722723663,
-0.4003590345,
0.0655957982,
0.0780652985,
-0.3900445998,
-0.0565707795,
0.9948077798,
-0.0199620798,
-0.6850508451,
-0.2046158463,
0.1575938016,
-0.0817601904,
-0.0300732944,
0.7988059521,
-0.9262720942,
0.4756855965,
0.6484475732,
0.8582669497,
0.6963398457,
0.1786856353,
0.4476830363,
-0.8471080065,
0.0519160926,
0.386698693,
0.3890073299,
0.4505816996,
-0.3461356759,
0.7103392482,
0.4512369037,
-0.2217411101,
-0.6109997034,
0.4965759814,
-0.9623001814,
-0.4191960692,
0.937605679,
-0.2337435037,
-0.2071109116,
-0.106005013,
0.1524923742,
0.2657835782,
0.0280014779,
0.4527338445,
0.6519598961,
-0.478823483,
0.0615764037,
-0.3060210049,
0.2181466669,
0.3877895772,
-0.8831669092,
-0.1065742075,
0.4911755919,
0.2301988155,
0.0464054197,
0.4502099752,
-0.4366963208,
0.0038406397,
-0.0906411558,
-0.1586681604,
-0.4354157448,
-0.3507652879,
0.3221073747,
0.6388431191,
-0.469268769,
-0.1799901873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13583v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13583v4 | Cross-Attention is Not Enough: Incongruity-Aware Dynamic Hierarchical Fusion for Multimodal Affect Recognition | 2023-05-23T01:24:15 | 2023-11-13T00:09:47 | Yaoting Wang, Yuanchao Li, Paul Pu Liang, Louis-Philippe Morency, Peter Bell, Catherine Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS, eess.IV | Fusing multiple modalities has proven effective for multimodal information
processing. However, the incongruity between modalities poses a challenge for
multimodal fusion, especially in affect recognition. In this study, we first
analyze how the salient affective information in one modality can be affected
by the other, and demonstrate that inter-modal incongruity exists latently in
crossmodal attention. Based on this finding, we propose the Hierarchical
Crossmodal Transformer with Dynamic Modality Gating (HCT-DMG), a lightweight
incongruity-aware model, which dynamically chooses the primary modality in each
training batch and reduces fusion times by leveraging the learned hierarchy in
the latent space to alleviate incongruity. The experimental evaluation on five
benchmark datasets: CMU-MOSI, CMU-MOSEI, and IEMOCAP (sentiment and emotion),
where incongruity implicitly lies in hard samples, as well as UR-FUNNY (humour)
and MUStaRD (sarcasm), where incongruity is common, verifies the efficacy of
our approach, showing that HCT-DMG: 1) outperforms previous multimodal models
with a reduced size of approximately 0.8M parameters; 2) recognizes hard
samples where incongruity makes affect recognition difficult; 3) mitigates the
incongruity at the latent level in crossmodal attention. | [
-0.3537842929,
-0.7379620075,
0.3749121726,
0.3442213535,
-0.2343607694,
0.1184657887,
-0.0616526268,
-0.5640676618,
0.3459995389,
-0.3670530617,
-0.8450627923,
-0.0310235061,
-0.6500152946,
-0.010646401,
-0.0048028547,
0.9548484087,
-0.224732399,
-0.050632149,
0.0139660547,
-0.241485104,
-0.3460664749,
-0.2259457856,
-0.3136557341,
-0.2940178514,
0.8478772044,
0.2859256566,
1.1018753052,
0.2807661295,
0.6709811091,
0.318416059,
0.0622537248,
0.1550077498,
-0.4754852057,
0.1142567396,
-0.0928408056,
-0.2974285185,
-0.543910861,
0.0184561033,
0.4572996795,
0.2930865586,
0.3637465835,
-0.0505645722,
-0.2562080026,
0.2639768422,
-0.592843473,
0.1287883967,
-0.637770474,
0.6533010006,
-0.292491138,
-0.3983716071,
-0.1024224684,
0.0378861427,
-0.0931072235,
-0.3084958792,
-0.0334590077,
0.054084111,
0.783554554,
0.5867140889,
-0.7305908203,
-0.0091562429,
-0.5893138051,
0.6347801089,
-0.4151006937,
0.7023504376,
0.2590859532,
0.2429655343,
0.1578622013,
-0.4255440235,
-0.7342354059,
-0.3040113747,
-0.2998118401,
0.4052940905,
-0.2552575767,
0.0940217823,
0.3585877717,
0.7323243022,
-0.7016768456,
-0.0152800307,
0.0234734565,
-0.2865809202,
0.2917384803,
0.383915484,
0.5575170517,
-0.4502590299,
-0.8078469038,
-0.2193690538,
-0.3122406006,
0.2989611328,
0.2121638209,
-0.0137354787,
-0.4135334492,
0.3948791027,
0.0832353383,
0.0361519866,
0.7109541297,
-0.363740176,
0.4929822087,
-0.5445688367,
-0.4148058891,
-0.0638627931,
0.739517808,
-0.0096151773,
-0.5142940283,
-0.3374199271,
-0.0267916191,
0.3429445326,
0.2709559202,
-0.5325645804,
-0.2188533992,
0.2415600568,
-0.5778595209,
-0.070473358,
-0.1251753867,
-0.9005215764,
-0.4063217938,
-0.2847768366,
0.699020803,
-0.5090668201,
-0.3624550402,
-0.3733030856,
-0.0327444822,
0.0085798986,
0.3273246884,
-1.021042347,
-0.1781588793,
0.1729172021,
0.6531221271,
-0.1701668799,
-0.4494829178,
-0.2936684191,
0.1453000605,
0.1487171203,
0.5392445922,
-0.7058290243,
-0.0453688167,
-0.3962759078,
0.208092317,
-0.4788351357,
-0.3228036463,
0.4679582715,
-0.3017902374,
0.2189482301,
-0.0750284195,
0.1566081792,
-0.1782441884,
0.3871284425,
-0.8546996117,
0.9137170911,
0.4963951409,
-0.8054369688,
0.376221031,
-0.3611857891,
-0.4890419841,
0.0641002804,
-0.200855881,
-0.6089186668,
0.1598414034,
0.1349547356,
0.3707983196,
-0.2381187826,
0.1622741073,
-0.3620798886,
-0.3306283355,
0.1323512495,
-0.60173738,
0.3851383924,
0.047121305,
-0.8609643579,
0.3942141831,
-0.5909746885,
-0.0697856992,
-0.0299048871,
-0.356475234,
-0.153374508,
-0.3318475187,
0.1914072633,
0.8444747329,
0.179831624,
-0.3794806004,
0.181773752,
0.0881166607,
0.2000833452,
0.6566342711,
-0.3368822336,
0.3727468848,
-0.358566016,
0.6804497838,
0.3527917564,
0.4322390854,
-0.0971480384,
-0.0695558935,
-0.7943919301,
-0.5927744508,
-0.1250401139,
0.3931491077,
-1.017826438,
0.2542739213,
-0.0628166571,
-0.5951423645,
-0.6047827601,
-0.1086268947,
0.5200865269,
0.3301301003,
0.4300075471,
-0.3354509175,
-0.5268389583,
-0.9565016031,
-0.1536975652,
-0.1102930084,
0.250346899,
0.5473538041,
0.1892959327,
-0.7331867814,
0.3295252025,
0.0880882367,
-0.4286684394,
0.0441871248,
0.4287535846,
-0.1357210726,
0.2124456167,
0.5084500313,
-1.1191517115,
-0.3829541206,
0.1218146086,
-0.6990916729,
-0.0491244085,
-0.3355594873,
0.0277537517,
0.1872537285,
0.1312938184,
-0.5952094197,
0.3252916932,
0.782580018,
-0.4663185179,
0.3493805826,
0.1443597227,
0.7768047452,
-0.678992033,
-0.0043400181,
-0.1062002555,
-0.0632781535,
-0.5749363899,
-0.1469590068,
0.2343090922,
-0.1538375914,
-0.4730575681,
0.2967083752,
-0.5436194539,
0.064721629,
-0.0783593208,
-0.1586402208,
-0.1560840905,
0.939624548,
-0.1431762576,
0.3810603023,
0.3711825013,
-0.3024386466,
0.623073101,
0.2072918266,
-0.1824564338,
0.7506543398,
-0.1844356805,
0.0667600334,
-0.0231485683,
0.2780531347,
-1.2589519024,
-0.3772208989,
0.3464999199,
-0.1812274456,
0.3988061547,
0.1099301204,
-0.3609963059,
-0.2533289492,
-0.4994346797,
0.9944006801,
0.2622786164,
-0.5642186999,
1.0331021547,
0.2218269408,
-0.2666205466,
-0.2909520864,
-0.7970457673,
-0.055216141,
-0.3667464554,
-0.8453302383,
0.346226275,
-0.2089676112,
0.0941975564,
-0.2180503458,
-0.2032245994,
0.006101721,
-0.1902598888,
0.5223158598,
0.1266542822,
0.0538320653,
0.4272074401,
0.1147682071,
-0.0428819172,
-0.0977405831,
0.4716932178,
0.5618110895,
-0.0661331117,
-0.5355455279,
-0.6093946099,
0.4892514348,
1.0036770105,
-0.0861923099,
0.1815644205,
1.1712493896,
-0.1603425145,
0.1103545576,
-0.49560377,
-0.1644786298,
-0.462472558,
0.4584415555,
-0.4143275023,
-0.8688656092,
0.5415178537,
-0.0483738594,
-0.3797020614,
0.3161668777,
0.8412485719,
0.1621505022,
1.2023354769,
0.6488066316,
-0.0352019779,
0.9293004274,
0.1917453855,
0.517084837,
-0.8817809224,
-0.5177416801,
-0.0025418431,
-0.7719572783,
-0.5228906274,
-0.4608718753,
0.6913768649,
-0.527782917,
0.009038181,
0.1953940541,
-0.217446357,
-0.0909098983,
0.1258247942,
0.4294429719,
0.1587032527,
-0.049191013,
0.125986889,
-0.3873613179,
-0.676659286,
0.1884188205,
0.191603303,
0.4503278732,
1.033708334,
0.1772895902,
0.1798728555,
0.212404117,
-0.0229499247,
-0.9038650393,
0.4348274767,
-0.0182836652,
-0.3229190409,
-0.1401218772,
-0.5477404594,
-0.6937754154,
0.3986414671,
-0.4298993349,
-0.4439123869,
0.6555674672,
0.2776157856,
-0.1398648918,
0.3932434618,
-0.616584897,
0.804545939,
-0.3807913363,
-0.5266916752,
-0.2950286269,
-0.8951944113,
0.5325772166,
-0.1060651988,
0.2274074256,
-0.1198793873,
0.0228123628,
0.2748945951,
-0.0812471807,
0.7901875377,
0.056263648,
-0.2767801285,
-0.2653481066,
0.2064358294,
0.5503554344,
-0.0269755591,
0.1726251841,
0.1867500991,
-0.4453997612,
-0.1488429159,
-0.6223919988,
0.6762744188,
-0.6815832257,
-0.4480100274,
-0.2968016565,
-1.1634668112,
-0.2574484348,
-0.0680290386,
0.1929764748,
0.3040391207,
0.0936306417,
0.1571307629,
0.6102960706,
0.1699830145,
0.5270606875,
0.240563184,
0.1609564126,
-0.5151431561,
0.8705135584,
0.0936045125,
0.4367875159,
0.3924749494,
0.1916517913,
0.0458117016,
0.0059014242,
-0.2271359265,
0.1335119307,
-0.6880688071,
-0.1922859251,
-1.0180361271,
0.0030124141,
-0.4944710732,
-0.1176192164,
-0.1882196665,
-0.2863943279,
-0.0867597535,
0.218164742,
0.2327978164,
0.3652634323,
-0.1152636409,
0.0687777847,
-0.7684144378,
0.5840687156,
0.6815382242,
0.2851445973,
0.1325131953,
-0.573489964,
-0.231551379,
0.0058889091,
-0.2103271782,
-0.6687226295,
0.3621560633,
0.2700725496,
0.332272619,
0.3554616272,
-0.0242982153,
0.8850561976,
-0.1658515483,
0.6345787048,
0.4753458202,
-1.0474816561,
0.3472495377,
-0.2917146683,
0.5883936882,
0.4153710902,
0.6988067627,
-0.6506205201,
-0.3869527578,
-0.555508554,
-0.9878153205,
0.8297376633,
0.1774835885,
0.0490528718,
0.1641504467,
-0.220987618,
0.4082329273,
0.2270013541,
-0.9722642899,
-0.0707023442,
-0.3174229264,
-0.2118536085,
0.3157847524,
-0.2182147205,
-0.1168362424,
-0.3783908784,
0.3970427811,
-0.0573648661,
0.3848669529,
0.1706875712,
-0.2900515795,
-0.6129977703,
0.2340136617,
0.3419788182,
0.226321727,
-0.1566063464,
0.4289357364,
0.1267977655,
-0.3987676799,
0.1628728956,
0.0836541131,
0.2594941854,
0.0096049802,
0.3314429522,
1.1074975729,
0.5559989214,
-0.5141574144,
0.5311171412,
-0.0719504431,
0.1724874526,
0.1304914355,
-0.0564978719,
-0.2726780772,
0.6759646535,
0.291097343,
0.1459343284,
0.1521731168,
-0.9557608366,
0.1260575354,
0.389959842,
-0.5873084664,
-0.5131877065,
0.5353859663,
0.0231746156,
-0.0081822751,
0.2327344865,
0.2231758982,
-0.7219810486,
0.5215654373,
0.5178883672,
0.7550408244,
-0.6177150011,
0.0474005565,
-0.0261061415,
0.0780034661,
0.3658990562,
0.3349637091,
-0.5024292469,
-0.3694359958,
0.0845589191,
-0.2635428011,
-0.526743412,
-0.1441274732,
-0.2547658384,
0.3258348405,
-0.3555981517,
-0.2246990055,
0.0806569532,
-0.2907062173,
-0.557416141,
0.5879244208,
0.2574771941,
0.2358263582,
-1.0574095249,
0.5233771205,
0.7478527427,
-0.5773462653,
-0.6723267436,
0.1340578645,
0.1946889609,
-0.6338781118,
0.59478122,
0.1312911659,
-0.2355022281,
-0.2789687812,
-0.2431102097,
-0.8740193248,
1.2616964579,
0.2488077134,
-0.3450845182,
-0.0164151844,
0.0598008148,
0.352073431,
-0.2453525215,
0.5547785759,
0.2184931338,
0.6177476048,
0.3165375888,
-1.2211540937,
0.2069873661,
-0.6008786559,
-0.1828585863,
0.37415874,
-1.122600317,
1.3510583639,
-0.0836084485,
-0.4486448169,
-0.3733386993,
0.3286606073,
0.0026852647,
0.40234676,
0.7928338647,
0.5429894328,
0.5417086482,
-0.1059197858,
0.9388450384,
0.0292878244,
0.2972491682,
0.7697281837,
-0.2103267014,
0.2787698805,
0.5818253756,
-0.0715623647,
0.5057188272,
0.5672076344,
-0.0468956828,
0.6272701025,
-0.2107208818,
-0.2636831999,
-0.326816678,
-0.3137148619,
-0.484801501,
0.5458180308,
0.0824654102,
-0.3155067861,
-0.2342507243,
0.5686869025,
0.0504919402,
-0.4485664666,
-0.3344107568,
0.6774732471,
-0.0310976952,
-0.4121615291,
0.7176776528,
-0.4417995214,
1.0122708082,
-0.8022161126,
0.0520966873,
-0.1444349587,
0.0990936682,
-0.6209061146,
-0.4107372165,
0.225708589,
-0.3918328285,
-0.5205624104,
-0.1313695163,
0.7102748156,
-0.8269520402,
-0.0500398837,
0.5154274702,
0.1260440052,
-0.0347789861,
-0.0345398672,
-0.4453982413,
0.3650688231,
-0.207296595,
-0.3336820602,
0.4937045276,
0.6727372408,
-0.1569183171,
0.4970947802,
0.4204435647,
-0.3240529895,
0.0596325658,
0.0843278691,
1.0638151169,
-0.6730797887,
-0.4500110447,
-0.658728838,
0.7004295588,
0.2459617555,
-0.3129349351,
0.6955471635,
0.0897928104,
0.6119875312,
-0.095230788,
0.6075316072,
-0.339669317,
-0.1388493329,
-0.3949088752,
0.3811879456,
-0.9746884108,
-0.24890773,
-0.4742672145,
-0.797393322,
-0.3118120432,
0.2869974971,
-0.1583533287,
0.2637687325,
1.0600912571,
0.5793898106,
-0.3302388191,
-0.0052757072,
0.5746533871,
0.2504962981,
0.0875601321,
1.0344116688,
0.887421608,
-0.4886918366,
0.4757993817,
-0.2729005814,
-0.3754702508,
-0.4238994718,
-0.748382926,
-0.6342407465,
-0.5134170651,
-0.3101444244,
-0.1836342663,
-0.1813193858,
0.9489882588,
0.6225759387,
-0.537771523,
0.164922148,
0.4282488823,
0.1084528044,
-0.2071772218,
-0.2316301018,
0.3140177727,
-0.2508231103,
-0.8083260059,
0.4814075828,
0.7382190824,
0.0893166363,
-0.3415742815,
0.1145123914,
-0.4011418521,
-0.0010185363,
0.7539334893,
0.0529763028,
-0.6074866652,
-0.3983723521,
-0.2243580669,
-0.4073551893,
0.3763678074,
0.9157336354,
-0.5794707537,
0.4738937616,
0.7842391133,
0.5594601035,
0.3041074872,
-0.1774871498,
0.2053827643,
-0.6409612298,
0.4478861392,
0.3848748207,
0.5037764907,
0.2358242273,
-0.7544137239,
0.3348836601,
0.4350393116,
-0.5693622231,
-0.6071113348,
0.3609220386,
-1.4703228474,
-0.0233597234,
0.9877253771,
-0.0765433311,
-0.1885437965,
-0.0066111232,
-0.4289810061,
0.3672709465,
-0.2520240545,
0.9456250072,
0.471916914,
-0.3648534715,
-0.4578407109,
0.0862947702,
0.2580749094,
0.7512301803,
-0.8363483548,
-0.0645965636,
0.5513316989,
-0.025356682,
0.4004100859,
0.3404220343,
-0.2510829568,
0.5669988394,
0.0868108347,
0.281514883,
-0.0900001153,
-0.4306784868,
-0.4940868914,
0.3741464913,
-0.5225410461,
0.0474837832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13582v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13582v3 | Translation and Fusion Improves Zero-shot Cross-lingual Information Extraction | 2023-05-23T01:23:22 | 2024-06-20T14:42:34 | Yang Chen, Vedaant Shah, Alan Ritter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) combined with instruction tuning have shown
significant progress in information extraction (IE) tasks, exhibiting strong
generalization capabilities to unseen datasets by following annotation
guidelines. However, their applicability to low-resource languages remains
limited due to lack of both labeled data for fine-tuning, and unlabeled text
for pre-training. In this paper, we propose TransFusion, a framework in which
models are fine-tuned to use English translations of low-resource language
data, enabling more precise predictions through annotation fusion. Based on
TransFusion, we introduce GoLLIE-TF, a cross-lingual instruction-tuned LLM for
IE tasks, designed to close the performance gap between high and low-resource
languages. Our experiments across twelve multilingual IE datasets spanning 50
languages demonstrate that GoLLIE-TF achieves better zero-shot cross-lingual
transfer over the base model. In addition, we show that TransFusion
significantly improves low-resource language named entity recognition when
applied to proprietary models such as GPT-4 (+5 F1) with a prompting approach,
or fine-tuning different language models including decoder-only (+14 F1) and
encoder-only (+13 F1) architectures. | [
0.0752808377,
-0.5567330718,
0.2298668772,
-0.0401368141,
-0.4747354984,
0.1267852783,
-0.343236059,
-0.8298118114,
0.2366226465,
0.5042444468,
-0.3369221687,
-0.3335165977,
-0.6981988549,
0.3220803738,
-0.4084161818,
1.0413124561,
-0.0907539949,
0.1775892228,
0.0800195634,
-0.1861089766,
-0.3891969323,
-0.15214701,
-0.3483424187,
-0.4112463892,
0.5188631415,
0.5357139111,
0.6720710397,
1.0463665724,
0.3642297387,
0.1890063733,
0.3589361608,
-0.0406613648,
-0.4830036163,
0.0669353604,
-0.5079857111,
-0.3941739798,
-0.1598779112,
-0.0181545746,
0.7171390653,
0.7818152905,
0.0782675967,
0.3106188178,
-0.0606967248,
0.1620520502,
-0.8083722591,
0.0421759821,
-0.6185540557,
0.188005507,
-0.3517300785,
-0.2751404047,
-0.5371451378,
-0.0078034871,
0.4396284223,
-0.6811750531,
0.3093556166,
0.1180324107,
1.1646014452,
0.2869155705,
-0.137252599,
0.1276673824,
-0.8791537881,
1.1234170198,
-0.542427361,
0.6452905536,
0.3607126772,
0.1496995986,
0.1914283186,
-0.5439728498,
-0.440834105,
0.2201907635,
-0.2975543141,
-0.0674381927,
-0.1169867218,
-0.0410424024,
0.1241409779,
0.3484824896,
-0.7058338523,
0.213563174,
-0.4351995885,
-0.342592746,
0.4852948189,
-0.0044079479,
0.5574740171,
-0.0453241691,
-0.2883358896,
-0.1385173351,
-0.8950927854,
-0.3467690349,
-0.2488870472,
0.4792323411,
-0.2610598207,
0.4955691397,
-0.0392448194,
1.0481158495,
0.0843371749,
-0.2265127599,
0.2490861267,
-0.6028856039,
-0.6308648586,
0.3257712722,
0.6694929004,
0.0362250656,
0.375092268,
-0.5735315681,
0.0493918285,
-0.2778146267,
-0.1296928972,
-0.9325502515,
-0.0430613384,
0.1155966893,
-0.3006424904,
-0.2928177118,
-0.122936137,
-0.7714340687,
-0.2129818797,
-0.0154560125,
0.3285148144,
-0.5345454812,
-0.4244984388,
0.1302009076,
-0.2729646564,
0.3417571783,
0.2133441269,
-1.0484139919,
-0.3207540214,
0.3674957454,
0.7519019842,
-0.4198884368,
-0.2887447476,
-0.9945123196,
0.7589176297,
-0.2187894434,
0.7801449895,
-1.1418331861,
-0.3700428009,
0.0636768937,
0.2462792695,
-0.1421549171,
-0.5867823958,
0.1402627975,
-0.4254596531,
0.4981639981,
0.0227051787,
-0.4070879221,
-0.1464755088,
0.1947065741,
-0.7797819376,
0.7316570282,
0.3840693235,
-0.4503698647,
0.5840243101,
-0.5484104156,
-0.6695030928,
0.3737823665,
-0.0903737843,
-0.1125654429,
0.1985280365,
0.1912686229,
0.3940905333,
-0.6573799253,
0.1389264464,
-0.3409740031,
-0.2062366456,
-0.1194981635,
-0.3053304851,
0.7463625669,
-0.1049206108,
-0.3393807113,
-0.1126511693,
-0.7400092483,
0.1736679375,
0.0066118832,
-0.4570416212,
-0.3118041754,
-0.5098441243,
0.0526067801,
0.2124703526,
0.0604063347,
-0.7543570995,
0.1375720352,
-0.5483398438,
0.4155605435,
0.2307305634,
-0.028638754,
0.873824656,
-0.0125828711,
0.453779161,
0.2873113155,
-0.0829642639,
-0.0966936424,
-0.1234616339,
-0.7095060349,
-0.3419012725,
0.8485938311,
0.8511514068,
-1.2226113081,
0.1140615493,
-0.4749400318,
-0.3965335488,
-1.1057105064,
0.3069217503,
0.4653864205,
0.9058995843,
0.6659117937,
-0.0048451647,
-0.3709868789,
-1.0479739904,
-0.235476464,
-0.115410246,
-0.1359109432,
0.1551570147,
0.0866020024,
-0.1354975253,
0.6012498736,
-0.132950455,
-0.2805824578,
-0.5279851556,
0.3172653913,
0.0607684031,
0.5221091509,
0.3804394901,
-0.6928224564,
-0.4787708521,
0.3251785636,
-0.8265619874,
-0.1420497,
-0.2167621851,
-0.3615328968,
0.4229017496,
-0.0124332821,
-0.615716517,
0.4063979685,
0.4488923848,
-0.1443064511,
-0.053623721,
-0.0567006655,
0.1093368083,
-0.9751917124,
0.1882535815,
0.0438116938,
-0.3713361919,
-0.7475221753,
-0.1425347328,
0.4242662489,
-0.2366154939,
-0.834849596,
0.8878762722,
-0.546266973,
-0.0569257475,
-0.1298161298,
0.313975662,
0.1832544953,
0.2665421665,
0.6131877303,
0.6355928779,
0.5656033158,
-0.5402620435,
0.4417128563,
0.112183772,
-0.0812085718,
0.5700126886,
-0.4893642962,
0.0850571319,
0.0204390157,
0.024878826,
-0.4157170057,
-0.3738978803,
0.4069957435,
-0.2015708834,
0.7966235876,
0.0683390275,
-0.1645131409,
0.1022260338,
-0.2876641452,
0.4527333081,
0.3732065856,
-0.4911909699,
0.9200444221,
0.4413784146,
-0.1556987613,
-0.7160137296,
-1.0098333359,
0.0209885612,
-0.0136288395,
-0.5998136401,
0.5523685217,
0.1842172146,
-0.0338712595,
0.1910802871,
0.0181586035,
-0.2519138455,
0.0543838479,
-0.1664225012,
0.6061957479,
-0.2174827456,
0.3031589985,
0.1719138771,
-0.1680810004,
-0.5132184029,
-0.5034310222,
0.2754814625,
0.3908145428,
-0.1291550547,
-0.1440152973,
0.4883891642,
0.1805962175,
-0.2872566283,
0.6629273891,
0.7672913671,
-0.3966668844,
-0.1598081142,
-0.5047416687,
-0.1258305013,
-0.3284355402,
0.3759549558,
-0.1914882809,
-0.900890708,
0.1541024745,
0.1068548709,
0.2852221429,
0.5165238976,
0.4009381831,
0.1417844146,
0.7070149779,
0.7889277935,
-0.2182088941,
0.4903906286,
-0.0809548572,
0.1595722884,
-0.5977066159,
-0.2519390583,
-0.5269645452,
-0.4502559602,
-0.4525280893,
-0.2993591726,
0.2243713886,
-0.0425638743,
0.2233041227,
0.3245120049,
-0.4062209129,
0.528038919,
0.4872444272,
-0.1273831725,
0.2296190113,
0.2040556967,
0.1652109176,
0.0424741693,
-0.8346606493,
-0.2291248292,
0.9574831128,
-0.0110834679,
0.6459428668,
-0.1022904888,
0.8183040619,
-0.0833703652,
0.3428575397,
-0.511482954,
0.428271234,
-0.2650395334,
-0.6710793376,
-0.4253482521,
-0.4575338662,
-0.8403681517,
0.0302177947,
-0.4109380841,
-0.7399653196,
0.3418702185,
0.1420204639,
-0.5325124264,
0.2013551444,
-0.807156086,
0.8386064172,
-0.2640521824,
-0.6378620863,
-0.0331333466,
-0.6882088184,
0.1944298744,
-0.3040983081,
-0.0081559392,
0.0767292902,
-0.3114683032,
0.6118007302,
-0.2296257168,
0.4734079838,
-0.0757715479,
-0.1583576202,
0.0631646216,
0.1586584151,
0.5576277375,
-0.1916642189,
-0.1485579461,
0.5077741742,
0.0233618449,
-0.4195653796,
-0.5703151226,
0.7891343832,
-0.5605591536,
-0.5746830106,
-0.1664479971,
-0.6120686531,
-0.3110002875,
0.2152218074,
0.6210077405,
0.279984206,
-0.0216501337,
0.191916436,
0.7258117199,
-0.2565316856,
0.775288105,
0.7714933753,
0.075040102,
-0.3128348291,
1.1542955637,
0.1800987422,
0.325568229,
0.6775221825,
-0.1265041679,
-0.2494814247,
-0.3245438337,
-1.122035861,
0.4617396295,
-0.4412336648,
-0.4733779132,
-0.7083027959,
-0.1153127551,
-0.5226632357,
0.0314920396,
-0.1185703576,
-0.6378586292,
-0.5399064422,
-0.0211463142,
0.0445131548,
0.374851495,
-0.0530699529,
0.1185970455,
-1.299390316,
0.2777157426,
0.0302694067,
0.1428602785,
-0.356387794,
-0.6076894403,
-0.4880071878,
-0.0403145663,
0.0212625377,
-0.9804509878,
0.3891930878,
0.5229076147,
0.3804717064,
0.1204304025,
-0.040535979,
0.9008713961,
-0.4046542346,
0.8867740035,
0.1665879637,
-0.8849573731,
0.4755993783,
0.1310172528,
0.4084443152,
0.4695983529,
0.3986551762,
-0.5488960147,
-0.3344727159,
-0.4939337075,
-0.5997907519,
0.9427022338,
-0.1755772829,
-0.0506164655,
0.0843859091,
0.0260545611,
0.3303685486,
0.1761730462,
-0.623562634,
0.0648315176,
0.0045791771,
-0.4270532727,
0.0315658934,
-0.1806759387,
0.0511621796,
-0.0371875539,
0.8935936689,
-0.0486790575,
-0.0335377157,
0.0981153175,
-0.5993419886,
-0.6200854778,
0.2861336768,
0.3032437265,
0.4583573639,
0.0347292945,
0.0339850001,
0.2766526341,
-0.3992699683,
0.1580771506,
0.3726495504,
-0.3949092031,
0.2438881993,
0.7527819276,
0.7281803489,
0.4484701753,
-0.6141240597,
0.2421570867,
-0.0390024669,
0.0502433926,
0.2695023715,
0.2892381549,
-0.0348251909,
0.2339492291,
0.1611593813,
-0.4236098528,
-0.0012329497,
-0.4476379752,
-0.0014403432,
0.5665988326,
-0.2267487645,
-0.3520659208,
0.3781592846,
0.4275372326,
-0.2345196903,
0.6520710588,
0.1309423596,
-0.0418208018,
0.1186433136,
0.6155828238,
0.996917069,
-0.4446652234,
0.2737216651,
0.2149092108,
0.2470886409,
0.0499115884,
0.207886368,
-0.1953392178,
-0.5758085251,
-0.6531739831,
-0.7768437266,
-0.2196160257,
0.2358592749,
-0.4549027979,
0.4123980701,
-0.1585655659,
0.1550209671,
0.2353014201,
-0.0835783929,
-0.8911283612,
0.1765795648,
0.3541780114,
1.0346027613,
-0.7248644233,
1.0591759682,
0.7444295287,
-0.3510350287,
-0.861420393,
-0.2033616155,
-0.2015148699,
-0.7935941219,
0.7947496772,
-0.0892209932,
0.1305364221,
0.0377868004,
-0.3056607544,
-1.0440399647,
1.1332360506,
0.7940914631,
-0.8190714717,
-0.271805644,
0.453350246,
0.3424306214,
-0.5584104061,
0.3849716485,
0.7431789637,
0.5504935384,
0.2169692814,
-1.0419350863,
-0.1223238111,
-0.0789686814,
-0.1132801473,
0.3607568443,
-0.3213445544,
0.6221939921,
-0.1524260789,
-0.4990006089,
-0.2453309745,
0.4872063696,
-0.1651192009,
0.045554515,
0.2995949686,
0.5200188756,
0.7178637981,
-0.0717515796,
1.0774226189,
-0.4311261475,
0.0298167579,
1.0610781908,
-0.4648289382,
0.6385899782,
0.5823992491,
0.3700247109,
0.382312268,
0.6852229238,
0.2147106677,
0.6358790994,
-0.3077434301,
-0.1929190159,
-0.4556362927,
-0.6823397279,
-0.2370391935,
0.5193838477,
0.2249974459,
-0.63059479,
-0.5330663323,
0.2756258845,
0.0314802229,
-0.5742285848,
-0.419008106,
0.9881130457,
-0.1151129901,
-0.7595469356,
0.7761887312,
-0.1265355051,
0.3404066265,
-0.5305963159,
-0.2557276487,
-0.2934334278,
-0.0010224418,
-0.2093585432,
-0.6476142406,
0.2059690654,
0.166611284,
-0.1748020053,
-0.2079692036,
1.0562653542,
-1.002478838,
-0.4454697967,
0.4372053444,
0.6935379505,
0.1740855426,
0.2663556933,
-0.5692647696,
0.1727733463,
0.2323776335,
-0.2796864808,
0.4429340363,
0.5716446638,
-0.0283485353,
0.2871197462,
0.3939169049,
0.5726632476,
-0.1342859566,
-0.1792030036,
0.747313261,
-0.8335046172,
-0.1825148463,
-1.1584531069,
0.421536386,
-0.2196219862,
-0.2184361666,
0.2573138177,
0.3392395377,
1.0245335102,
-0.0446429774,
0.9548416734,
-0.0534266569,
0.4847472608,
-0.4955010712,
0.4329551756,
-0.6788276434,
-0.0597838387,
0.0968016908,
-0.9498315454,
-0.3296205699,
0.1652441472,
-0.4123295248,
-0.3228399754,
0.5732291937,
0.6983571053,
-0.1698562056,
0.069506824,
0.5490553379,
-0.0694734603,
0.1830468774,
0.9133555889,
0.3321953714,
-0.3221312463,
0.7566220164,
-0.2647849321,
-0.2080212831,
-0.2802900076,
-0.9176876545,
-0.8702425361,
-0.3463717103,
-0.2811615169,
-0.1950852722,
-0.0515016988,
0.9089846015,
0.7598519325,
-0.8507288098,
0.0346937142,
0.4035964012,
0.1466751695,
0.132295236,
-0.1342262924,
0.1339312047,
-0.3244929016,
-0.8462030292,
0.4260044694,
0.7402697802,
0.0846028328,
-0.1557252258,
0.0190837476,
-0.2819449604,
-0.0187452808,
0.2957082391,
0.4530597031,
-0.4538826048,
-0.5160887241,
0.0211753473,
-0.1076574177,
-0.00149559,
0.6055211425,
-0.9391415715,
0.5047840476,
0.4794220328,
1.0068036318,
0.3621696532,
-0.2127127051,
0.7675631642,
-0.7371739149,
0.262545377,
0.1940100044,
0.3231645226,
0.5544317961,
-0.5240950584,
0.7285387516,
0.3894439638,
-0.1265661567,
-0.8567633033,
0.1874989867,
-0.4309557974,
-0.0287085678,
1.1572350264,
-0.300997138,
-0.6893668175,
0.0468809269,
0.1231999025,
0.5317443013,
-0.3426282108,
0.507896781,
0.8041299582,
0.0001356756,
-0.2387163788,
-0.2837559581,
0.4859114289,
0.5534247756,
-0.8744122386,
0.1669537872,
0.4160759747,
0.1984801292,
0.4237915277,
0.33375898,
-0.0831151307,
0.3411897719,
-0.4589384198,
-0.0748936161,
-0.247354582,
-0.3426812291,
-0.43853122,
0.1508187801,
-0.2621356845,
-0.2401579916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13571v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13571v1 | Latent Positional Information is in the Self-Attention Variance of Transformer Language Models Without Positional Embeddings | 2023-05-23T01:03:40 | 2023-05-23T01:03:40 | Ta-Chung Chi, Ting-Han Fan, Li-Wei Chen, Alexander I. Rudnicky, Peter J. Ramadge | cs.CL | cs.CL | The use of positional embeddings in transformer language models is widely
accepted. However, recent research has called into question the necessity of
such embeddings. We further extend this inquiry by demonstrating that a
randomly initialized and frozen transformer language model, devoid of
positional embeddings, inherently encodes strong positional information through
the shrinkage of self-attention variance. To quantify this variance, we derive
the underlying distribution of each step within a transformer layer. Through
empirical validation using a fully pretrained model, we show that the variance
shrinkage effect still persists after extensive gradient updates. Our findings
serve to justify the decision to discard positional embeddings and thus
facilitate more efficient pretraining of transformer language models. | [
-0.1672758013,
-0.3205640614,
0.4159094691,
0.3359395862,
-0.0896620825,
-0.095643647,
-0.0130493073,
0.0767237619,
0.2668838203,
0.2708620727,
-0.2470757812,
-0.174436897,
-0.6037018895,
-0.4568616748,
-0.5838142037,
0.938613534,
-0.0123051228,
-0.1731113791,
-0.2742030025,
0.22898525,
-0.1173815951,
-0.423170507,
-0.0985949636,
-0.1635502428,
0.4265991151,
0.3108136952,
0.9469433427,
0.6360076666,
0.3921880424,
0.2604080141,
-0.0164465662,
-0.6896904707,
-0.6427929997,
0.2479991466,
-0.0302654915,
-0.7800337076,
0.0146196187,
0.1083538607,
0.8884789944,
0.6548265219,
-0.3690060675,
0.0631809011,
-0.1694939584,
0.3927256465,
-0.7506673932,
-0.0577957258,
-0.3118031919,
0.5646324158,
-0.2498377562,
-0.011289252,
-0.351867348,
-0.1657599211,
0.4489796162,
-0.4228618145,
0.7074122429,
-0.3180962801,
0.8785101771,
0.695653975,
-0.1796753854,
0.1250875592,
-0.9693160057,
0.7054110169,
-0.3901888728,
0.6991410255,
0.6041418314,
0.083712332,
0.1519145966,
-0.5070871115,
-0.3414161801,
-0.0120392544,
-0.1850022227,
0.1720961183,
-0.3602327704,
-0.1679659337,
0.0816990063,
0.4879186749,
-0.2581964433,
0.1598511338,
-0.2712347507,
0.1273744255,
0.2911005914,
-0.2483956665,
0.1590068042,
-0.0815608576,
-0.1816326082,
-0.4169443846,
-0.6396325827,
0.1231091544,
0.6309188604,
-0.1532123089,
-0.3192777932,
0.658967495,
0.5093744397,
0.2103386819,
0.7293561697,
0.0624464527,
0.5127970576,
0.1550824493,
-0.3312222362,
-0.1183934435,
0.9834475517,
-0.2591328919,
0.0332299434,
-0.5332300067,
-0.2119748443,
-0.4357736707,
0.7183717489,
-0.5613244176,
-0.2803398967,
0.0524309315,
-0.3761375546,
-0.2461129427,
0.1798807681,
-0.3924020827,
-0.1192159355,
0.1489378363,
0.0769625977,
-0.1788919717,
-0.3255531192,
-0.1860096604,
-0.051896695,
0.4920845926,
0.1034791023,
-1.2249820232,
0.0181699395,
0.3522452414,
0.5699239373,
-0.4276161194,
-0.3489865065,
0.0814242885,
0.0845542699,
-0.7436878085,
0.5316593051,
-0.789691031,
-0.4269697666,
0.0480540954,
0.2598053813,
-0.1862033159,
-0.5965787768,
0.3194308877,
-0.7489379644,
0.3429393768,
-0.1287630498,
-0.399517566,
0.1609891653,
-0.1516580731,
-0.752391398,
1.0595074892,
0.2380978614,
-0.7702867389,
0.3661525548,
-0.3074772358,
-0.3495153785,
-0.2700913548,
-0.2698638439,
-0.6394996047,
0.534186542,
0.1159582064,
0.5823898911,
0.0343702398,
0.2664708197,
-0.1809523553,
-0.3543717861,
0.4156349897,
-0.6439909935,
0.1757025123,
0.1611014307,
-0.6111220121,
-0.2759929299,
-0.6991602182,
-0.408798039,
0.2467728853,
-0.1691964865,
-0.4138269722,
-0.0033824691,
-0.285568893,
0.2826204896,
0.1989416033,
-0.403150171,
0.0968952775,
-0.5467799306,
0.0183659531,
0.5982257724,
-0.0589976981,
1.2226227522,
0.242582202,
0.7262588143,
0.3992779255,
0.0235114228,
-0.1697119921,
-0.2444220036,
-0.9414611459,
0.0188254416,
0.2551983297,
0.31746912,
-0.2547756732,
0.407350719,
-0.1917089373,
-0.3750706911,
-0.6031504869,
-0.157712236,
0.1740233004,
0.0612028055,
0.314717412,
0.0502079464,
-0.2404407412,
-1.2063653469,
0.0140276011,
0.1595870554,
-0.2524122596,
0.1288226396,
0.3211712539,
-0.2008617669,
0.9047312737,
-0.4177848101,
0.0229761247,
0.027027104,
0.288146764,
0.0730261281,
0.6293364167,
0.5678515434,
-0.5434182286,
-0.2560673058,
-0.2840914428,
-0.7527486682,
0.1637268066,
-0.2953528464,
0.0674845427,
-0.2069338858,
0.5664793253,
-0.738748312,
0.6734421253,
0.6927627325,
-0.2165076286,
0.1302197129,
-0.4201557338,
-0.0581371151,
-0.820017755,
-0.0619250648,
0.0183499306,
-0.1800708771,
-0.6926959753,
-0.3543233871,
0.2358211428,
-0.2654185593,
-0.1639407873,
0.4946917593,
-0.4727626145,
-0.1703314632,
-0.1955439597,
0.0146123925,
-0.0565180257,
0.4144367576,
0.2462600172,
0.8563452959,
0.4781275094,
-0.5359485745,
-0.2664171159,
0.2018114179,
0.1015588939,
0.1680312455,
-0.7797697186,
0.054512199,
-0.3833862841,
0.0863531902,
-1.0595971346,
-0.1176155955,
0.2457129061,
-0.1444987357,
0.7832997441,
-0.2552392781,
0.0571938343,
-0.5846191645,
-0.1452103704,
0.4787650406,
0.5295900702,
-0.4529368877,
0.3338316977,
0.5947219729,
0.0220150705,
-0.8019480705,
-0.9040083885,
-0.305740118,
-0.1495355517,
-0.2723597586,
0.4990071058,
0.1555670649,
-0.1052556261,
0.0193395764,
-0.3348027468,
-0.2902063429,
0.0694125518,
0.4702892303,
-0.1936701536,
-0.3656944335,
0.5454856157,
-0.1289378703,
-0.2632214129,
0.238882333,
-0.3259283602,
0.2959782481,
-0.0010130625,
-0.7167932391,
-0.4579526186,
0.1726401746,
0.5428305268,
-0.1655620337,
0.929254353,
0.774535358,
-0.1948495954,
-0.001687278,
-0.6637511253,
-0.1930534542,
-0.4705484211,
0.3056733906,
-0.2060578614,
-0.9431405067,
0.6840854883,
0.2132077068,
-0.3844350278,
0.7322712541,
0.349090755,
-0.2755807042,
0.7488843799,
0.9692278504,
-0.0157899261,
0.8257960677,
-0.3569277525,
0.4927477539,
-0.791457653,
-0.2650661767,
-0.4919140935,
-0.2024729401,
-0.7222262025,
-0.7891926169,
-0.0474823005,
-0.0608255602,
-0.3464152813,
-0.1169028506,
-0.3945758343,
0.5885567665,
0.4011588991,
-0.0069640093,
-0.4907737076,
-0.1706296951,
0.0498235002,
-0.4618887603,
-0.7256618738,
-0.2607669234,
1.0491731167,
0.6937299967,
1.1872073412,
-0.0903872177,
0.6461137533,
0.0277757309,
0.0753533617,
-0.7354041338,
-0.1282091588,
0.0740310997,
-0.4474599957,
-0.6619158983,
-0.2635857463,
-1.1717751026,
0.1159338653,
0.0813034028,
-0.6936668754,
0.5974308252,
0.1888305843,
-0.4670148194,
0.1727780104,
-0.7093861699,
0.9193363786,
-0.1134917438,
-0.3015902042,
-0.0982763171,
-0.5498648286,
0.1088145301,
-0.3413476944,
0.0372017846,
0.0975401402,
0.0841782168,
1.1116336584,
-0.5979027748,
0.9220971465,
-0.3907241523,
-0.3768466413,
0.254159838,
0.0580042824,
0.7250827551,
0.1464499533,
0.2774179578,
-0.0126813492,
-0.4216442406,
-0.3776221573,
-0.7186288238,
0.4993549883,
-1.12406528,
-0.7432284951,
-0.3023521304,
-0.2327177078,
-0.2252804488,
0.0359715857,
0.2818773985,
0.248406291,
-0.2789169252,
0.5997095108,
1.1633321047,
-0.3873630166,
0.4670663178,
0.2095430046,
-0.0152264638,
0.2051598877,
0.5563660264,
0.1718208641,
0.1320469826,
0.6439598203,
0.3005354702,
-0.3334164917,
-0.4352972507,
0.1123218536,
0.4688826799,
-0.7003144026,
0.0736987442,
-0.7455406189,
-0.3523800969,
-0.3598884046,
-0.2913402021,
-1.0574997663,
-0.4185140729,
-0.5526983142,
-0.2524901628,
-0.073762387,
0.9899814725,
-0.1563558429,
0.7132787108,
-0.543694973,
0.2903112173,
0.6136852503,
0.57151407,
0.2005854249,
-0.8759125471,
-0.6055916548,
-0.0276202224,
-0.1412340701,
-0.762526691,
0.4180437028,
0.0376569442,
1.0411064625,
0.6160830259,
-0.181735158,
0.4903305173,
-0.6300169826,
0.9524487257,
0.297655493,
-0.983192265,
0.5701213479,
-0.1812812537,
0.7556468248,
0.2002608329,
0.4984402955,
-0.2181838453,
-0.6338545084,
-0.9633482099,
-0.8871771693,
0.819685638,
0.1650847197,
0.4881057441,
-0.1823616028,
0.2037036866,
0.0867577046,
0.1909856945,
-0.8564069271,
-0.5592029095,
-0.721137166,
-0.0126844123,
-0.2071433663,
-0.6284372211,
-0.0031675918,
-0.1175022647,
0.3647041619,
0.215509668,
0.7670095563,
0.071264483,
-0.3909218907,
-0.1166923121,
0.1686304808,
0.5217077136,
0.4190838933,
-0.1367149055,
0.3938020766,
0.1032461673,
-0.6440900564,
0.3567451835,
-0.0354205072,
-0.0533356927,
0.0353121795,
0.1996471584,
0.9955195785,
0.8950449228,
-0.0297047626,
1.005081296,
-0.1226486862,
0.1153591648,
-0.300188452,
-0.141287744,
0.0814200416,
0.2141973674,
0.5567263961,
0.193456769,
-0.0250492971,
0.0043636728,
0.2949604094,
0.2574238479,
-0.7287927866,
-0.7463969588,
0.598826766,
-0.1417500377,
-0.0485848151,
0.3661441505,
0.0977582708,
-0.3672367632,
0.3731614053,
0.7120224237,
0.895852685,
-0.9114920497,
0.6066823602,
0.2881664336,
0.3868965507,
-0.0826529041,
-0.3010492623,
-0.214237377,
-0.7743601799,
-0.157021746,
-0.5139001608,
0.0081215575,
0.1200895756,
-0.5512084961,
-0.1359046549,
-0.3838798702,
-0.1353928298,
-0.1832861304,
-0.5794157386,
-1.0807627439,
0.3835648298,
0.3467434049,
0.3555637896,
-0.8449395895,
0.6559072137,
0.2927337587,
-0.2487014681,
-0.9145653844,
0.3271842301,
-0.4102437496,
-0.9020604491,
0.742192328,
0.0152079333,
-0.19451873,
-0.1331882477,
-0.592939496,
-1.6203241348,
0.8236868382,
0.4338974357,
-0.287917316,
-0.1072719842,
0.1917925775,
0.6159177423,
-0.2160794884,
0.5532239079,
0.1528582722,
0.1696433723,
0.229054451,
-0.5251355171,
-0.1180171147,
-0.1379967034,
0.1581805944,
0.0384039953,
-0.6017535329,
1.0866897106,
-0.1356524229,
-0.3115894794,
-0.5986838341,
0.7793059349,
-0.5345602632,
-0.365382731,
0.2697229385,
0.5457590222,
0.8110940456,
-0.0265947338,
1.1664243937,
-0.2515333295,
0.4519090354,
1.1218662262,
0.0563729182,
0.6696573496,
0.524856329,
-0.2092328221,
0.4919264317,
0.5242989659,
0.0754589736,
0.7986004949,
0.0894384831,
0.2729249001,
-0.2174421847,
0.2410293221,
-0.6393637657,
0.6371654272,
0.2119446248,
-0.6552713513,
-0.1570007652,
-0.0525085926,
0.0495780744,
-0.3819786608,
0.1291772127,
0.5066313744,
0.0332851633,
-0.5245007277,
0.6473110914,
-0.2221043408,
0.3875978589,
-0.5954669714,
0.3259645998,
-0.3574874997,
-0.0509270988,
-0.1005414799,
-0.7693786025,
0.2870746553,
-0.3427548409,
-0.331191361,
-0.4640240073,
0.6070253849,
-0.382707268,
-0.2190561295,
0.2176737636,
0.6774883866,
0.0643848628,
0.0302957185,
-0.3233720958,
-0.3058514297,
-0.1813663244,
-0.9168192148,
0.3545177579,
0.7505198121,
0.2378705889,
0.6059736013,
0.4318263829,
-0.1481768042,
0.2419265509,
0.4118039012,
0.9081538916,
-0.6128546596,
-0.7517482638,
-0.6383408904,
0.4731709063,
0.0566243492,
-0.1890846938,
0.799233377,
0.3286888599,
0.4005651772,
-0.2154137194,
0.8205994368,
0.2752827704,
0.1423273981,
-0.2944087088,
0.7639045715,
-0.4415557981,
0.2121777683,
-0.3112665117,
-0.9910266995,
-0.2849862576,
0.991007328,
-0.7697292566,
0.1586875767,
0.8173604012,
0.4104877114,
-0.2927211821,
-0.1322348267,
0.6253268123,
0.1914236397,
0.1466108561,
0.0109785469,
0.9119289517,
-0.5462228656,
0.217816636,
-0.115162909,
-0.1135810167,
-0.3485322893,
-0.6825174093,
-0.8949180245,
-0.6670219302,
-0.2281740457,
-0.1876505613,
-0.2039006203,
0.5937417746,
0.848534286,
-0.8299285173,
0.0222707391,
0.0832312182,
0.2023739219,
0.0936050862,
-0.2166703045,
0.4376758933,
-0.3639094234,
-0.365344435,
0.3858675063,
0.2786008716,
0.6146748662,
-0.4320810437,
-0.0274394676,
-0.1498069912,
0.0628742427,
0.2337539494,
0.2515507042,
-0.5119448304,
-0.4493629932,
0.1427977532,
-0.3109839857,
0.4557429552,
0.8247269392,
-0.7763752341,
0.3816280365,
0.2322490066,
0.6630446315,
0.7956174612,
-0.0741110072,
0.7258121371,
-1.1173175573,
0.534748435,
0.2155245841,
0.3136408329,
0.4275074899,
-0.460114032,
0.151319623,
0.070395492,
-0.5006786585,
-0.5309615135,
0.015195922,
-0.4790168405,
-0.0242158361,
1.0896281004,
-0.3571615517,
-0.4838189185,
0.0486593395,
0.2362543643,
0.3477190733,
-0.3625742495,
0.6886823177,
0.7979124188,
0.1455071867,
-0.3665665388,
-0.1493617743,
0.5574609637,
0.3180686235,
-0.4602969587,
-0.0485215597,
0.115558669,
0.1540598571,
0.4806834459,
0.6210088134,
-0.003830994,
-0.0872019082,
0.3003218174,
0.108475931,
0.4510483444,
-0.4913707376,
-0.5045019388,
0.3434558213,
-0.0297330413,
-0.178175509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18323v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18323v1 | ReWOO: Decoupling Reasoning from Observations for Efficient Augmented Language Models | 2023-05-23T00:16:48 | 2023-05-23T00:16:48 | Binfeng Xu, Zhiyuan Peng, Bowen Lei, Subhabrata Mukherjee, Yuchen Liu, Dongkuan Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Augmented Language Models (ALMs) blend the reasoning capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with tools that allow for knowledge retrieval and action
execution. Existing ALM systems trigger LLM thought processes while pulling
observations from these tools in an interleaved fashion. Specifically, an LLM
reasons to call an external tool, gets halted to fetch the tool's response, and
then decides the next action based on all preceding response tokens. Such a
paradigm, though straightforward and easy to implement, often leads to huge
computation complexity from redundant prompts and repeated execution. This
study addresses such challenges for the first time, proposing a modular
paradigm ReWOO (Reasoning WithOut Observation) that detaches the reasoning
process from external observations, thus significantly reducing token
consumption. Comprehensive evaluations across six public NLP benchmarks and a
curated dataset reveal consistent performance enhancements with our proposed
methodology. Notably, ReWOO achieves 5x token efficiency and 4% accuracy
improvement on HotpotQA, a multi-step reasoning benchmark. Furthermore, ReWOO
demonstrates robustness under tool-failure scenarios. Beyond prompt efficiency,
decoupling parametric modules from non-parametric tool calls enables
instruction fine-tuning to offload LLMs into smaller language models, thus
substantially reducing model parameters. Our illustrative work offloads
reasoning ability from 175B GPT3.5 into 7B LLaMA, demonstrating the significant
potential for truly efficient and scalable ALM systems. | [
-0.2126105279,
-0.7652071118,
0.6066577435,
-0.0696906522,
-0.429104507,
-0.0096549354,
-0.2872412503,
-0.4176824391,
0.3011188507,
0.8454460502,
-0.5333533883,
-0.5093383789,
-0.4479203522,
0.134880662,
-0.4670494795,
0.518063128,
-0.0624171644,
-0.4509070218,
-0.5302121043,
-0.1711084098,
-0.1826551706,
-0.143899709,
-0.7138520479,
-0.4817434847,
0.5101857185,
0.4083386958,
0.6583321095,
0.7296683192,
0.2922554314,
0.3955681324,
0.0820596367,
0.7707886696,
-0.1438530385,
-0.0171412956,
-0.2696477175,
-0.650485754,
-0.5007290244,
-0.1208007485,
0.4538748264,
0.7539318204,
-0.4388502538,
0.2045791,
-0.1459074318,
0.5421853065,
-0.767151773,
0.1645475328,
-0.7995494008,
-0.1615872234,
0.0992877409,
-0.0969954878,
-0.5595485568,
-0.1830028296,
0.125388518,
-0.7217776775,
0.0745960623,
0.26634413,
0.4786018431,
0.4032938778,
-0.342443049,
-0.1539571434,
-0.4925475419,
1.0513238907,
-0.9594575763,
0.6084741354,
0.5724244118,
-0.1035634875,
-0.2889382541,
-0.7335765958,
-0.6313353181,
-0.0479364917,
-0.0738864914,
-0.0935431346,
-0.4369351268,
-0.0290262084,
0.0201189928,
0.3100948334,
-0.2761953175,
-0.0311481096,
-0.1300037354,
-0.1442192942,
0.4811353385,
0.1211051717,
0.0671555996,
-0.2571774721,
-0.2711718976,
0.2232601941,
-0.7600831985,
-0.2596362233,
0.1766397059,
0.1826706231,
-0.0201940406,
0.5488300323,
-0.3237865865,
0.6656640768,
-0.0706531107,
-0.2979750335,
0.2164183706,
-0.1541793495,
-0.3689293265,
-0.3096420467,
0.7626830935,
0.250662297,
-0.2414256781,
-0.4678138793,
-0.4597499967,
-0.3802877069,
0.1882171631,
-0.4100800455,
-0.1827807277,
0.3420680761,
-0.5304139256,
-0.1921823919,
-0.4260099232,
-0.5104746222,
-0.1397752166,
-0.5120114088,
0.3550280333,
-0.3161248565,
-0.4055490792,
0.0200047828,
0.0094760545,
0.0929354131,
0.4008017778,
-0.7294079065,
0.2530803084,
0.9087112546,
0.7853512168,
-0.1514625251,
-0.2843638957,
-0.6924262643,
0.2566546798,
-0.4358348846,
0.8839303851,
-0.590367496,
-0.4019932151,
-0.1269092709,
-0.0723283514,
0.0406641699,
-0.7501879334,
0.6163073778,
-0.5816560984,
0.1871625334,
-0.1319924593,
-0.4818538129,
-0.3979723155,
0.3913747072,
-0.6180029511,
0.912017405,
-0.1420067251,
-0.5868548751,
0.3712245822,
-0.5412815213,
-0.4233088493,
-0.0691370964,
-0.1209885925,
-0.1878902614,
0.3100217581,
0.4434583187,
0.1452541053,
-0.7818872929,
0.2233366221,
-0.2935660183,
-0.3002251685,
-0.1856797785,
-0.3879540861,
0.5316346288,
0.2615613937,
-0.1945485473,
0.346214205,
-0.9408162236,
0.1597109437,
-0.0186125059,
-0.5597358942,
-0.4745584428,
0.1673791856,
-0.4818143547,
0.0619904697,
0.2364780605,
-0.5109149218,
0.2053485513,
-0.5662633777,
0.4577334821,
0.6364579201,
-0.2733147144,
0.432716161,
-0.1079080775,
0.3652789295,
-0.2433328331,
0.1372627169,
-0.1185279265,
-0.3860315084,
-0.9166121483,
-0.6041141152,
0.1062773839,
0.6899210215,
-1.0489448309,
0.4803094566,
-0.1178955883,
-0.3970482647,
-0.6577575803,
0.3252700865,
0.6245495081,
0.7206660509,
0.3803632259,
0.1865265667,
-0.6057071686,
-1.074888587,
-0.4547406733,
-0.3094273508,
-0.1278701276,
0.2343933731,
0.2730419934,
-0.4340848625,
0.8607265949,
-0.3574944735,
0.261048615,
-0.4060625732,
0.1492938399,
0.2470625788,
0.349989444,
0.0430213846,
-0.5144899487,
0.2311203033,
0.0968579575,
-1.0249918699,
-0.3114053011,
0.0593391359,
-0.2478419989,
0.3077906966,
0.6472853422,
-0.7850570679,
0.3988379538,
0.4246328473,
-0.0572393015,
0.5766290426,
-0.2763872147,
0.1509435177,
-0.9673883915,
0.1182332635,
-0.3819241822,
-0.2032958716,
-0.4439974725,
0.2188442498,
-0.0979979038,
-0.0820147917,
-0.3956315517,
0.5896460414,
-0.5740029216,
-0.0348594375,
-0.5708217621,
0.1018650159,
0.2437826693,
0.6051792502,
0.106997408,
0.5544471741,
0.3015495241,
-0.602668643,
0.4311859608,
0.0901641324,
-0.3804165125,
0.0274777114,
-0.7853562236,
0.3230633438,
0.0605369508,
0.0354184285,
-0.6177901626,
0.0338604227,
0.2421319038,
-0.1639605314,
0.0529048294,
-0.2545966208,
-0.5462391973,
0.0062748925,
-0.3129639328,
0.4669846594,
0.252848357,
-0.6907621026,
1.1432719231,
0.3413613737,
-0.0107101798,
-0.7060036659,
-0.5726212263,
0.0690531433,
-0.2243121266,
-0.6372518539,
0.0259538479,
0.3514747322,
-0.5520189404,
0.0486159064,
-0.2417527288,
0.221214056,
0.0031288813,
0.2019097954,
0.3124528229,
-0.0466024391,
0.3294315636,
0.3093778193,
-0.1908230036,
0.1986515224,
-0.3303630948,
0.4399876595,
0.0071679726,
-0.6150664091,
-0.4859424233,
0.647962749,
0.6011180282,
-0.1193743795,
0.8024633527,
0.1776449084,
-0.3515369892,
-0.1319169402,
-0.6935218573,
-0.0421336666,
-0.4614422023,
0.2010733485,
-0.5137827396,
-0.6804379821,
0.5831793547,
-0.2977930009,
0.571585238,
0.2341452241,
0.5111692548,
0.0945876017,
0.8692304492,
0.4140684903,
0.1603773981,
0.5533781648,
-0.1207963228,
0.4329071641,
-0.8654715419,
-0.4410617054,
-0.1852269471,
-0.1157938465,
-0.2669822276,
-0.6755053401,
0.0945674405,
0.2860233188,
-0.1621697247,
0.1465708911,
-0.1595102847,
0.411981672,
0.684241116,
0.122956492,
0.5465472937,
-0.087347284,
0.051531177,
0.2823645771,
-0.7540464997,
-0.6168301105,
1.1524883509,
0.055387903,
0.8985447884,
0.1890737265,
0.7793881297,
0.3388351798,
0.3336209953,
-0.7916647792,
0.7920814157,
0.0736300871,
-0.2677578032,
-0.2496032715,
-0.6112133861,
-0.7641574144,
0.6004501581,
-0.1914517581,
-0.5079031587,
0.2740419805,
0.3431984484,
-0.1558086425,
0.3893138766,
-1.021115303,
0.4844467342,
0.0338635482,
-0.4552195966,
-0.3128675222,
-0.433044225,
0.5561593175,
0.0209519453,
0.4183401167,
-0.1606131792,
-0.1821749806,
0.7016220689,
-0.7146857977,
0.6999086142,
0.0102215791,
-0.3129170537,
0.5464081764,
0.1643636674,
0.7327387929,
0.1047730893,
-0.184786275,
0.2287897468,
-0.1373660117,
-0.3754831254,
-0.8774820566,
0.8153768182,
-0.6342713237,
-0.8589327931,
0.0186821707,
-0.7158530951,
-0.1430102289,
0.1875894666,
0.1285715997,
0.6096643209,
0.3364539742,
-0.0290787574,
0.4735004008,
-0.1618575156,
0.267370522,
0.461412549,
-0.5565136075,
-0.5709453225,
0.7832342982,
-0.1165629551,
0.4583811164,
0.5303336978,
0.1476434618,
-0.3391109407,
-0.5197677612,
-0.2984347343,
0.2547754347,
-0.8776038885,
-0.1940106899,
-0.6309788227,
0.4583739638,
-0.3839353919,
0.0468019135,
-0.5713765621,
-0.5752271414,
0.032230705,
-0.1901367754,
0.3140688241,
0.3948997259,
-0.253092587,
0.0059613865,
-0.7819200754,
0.3862306774,
0.4060271084,
0.1275369376,
0.1751441956,
-0.4212674797,
-0.1974976659,
-0.0619649515,
0.0880770236,
-0.4826467633,
0.3311835229,
0.0737552419,
0.6449454427,
0.4411390722,
0.114730984,
0.7315171361,
-0.3872009218,
0.4405933917,
0.0050280429,
-1.1405968666,
0.7951311469,
-0.2473047823,
0.1233583093,
0.2939302027,
-0.0637794808,
-0.2646979094,
-0.2701189518,
-0.4279232025,
-1.1146842241,
0.5812573433,
0.0124923633,
-0.2090852559,
-0.331917882,
0.5749356151,
0.2687048018,
0.2867535055,
-0.3346046507,
-0.0590342321,
-0.1203345433,
-0.0008764332,
0.1883654594,
-0.1806395054,
-0.3606968522,
-0.3351433277,
0.6740090847,
-0.2177736312,
0.1122323573,
0.1174715608,
-0.287121743,
0.132024467,
0.2953181565,
0.4029528499,
0.7551792264,
-0.0194828045,
0.4028307796,
0.3525408208,
-0.186378032,
-0.0985194147,
-0.2371932566,
-0.1303208917,
-0.1494674385,
0.8095601201,
0.6923234463,
0.4567906559,
-1.023968339,
0.0138944183,
-0.0398992263,
-0.1503144503,
-0.0913650915,
0.0755629465,
0.1169759408,
0.4110963047,
0.2156140208,
0.0229827669,
0.2252703905,
-0.6885470748,
0.1492669284,
0.3584616184,
0.0647043362,
-0.3363652825,
0.476821214,
0.4999017417,
-0.3909411132,
0.7763704658,
-0.2073656619,
-0.2223901898,
0.3132966757,
0.6453959346,
0.735016048,
0.1600870937,
-0.0922785103,
0.0654501021,
0.3675252795,
-0.1261924356,
0.2405442595,
-0.2719309032,
-0.8645108938,
-0.7417522073,
-0.4311278462,
-0.4718456864,
-0.0743654221,
-0.8088504672,
0.0490131788,
-0.5684010983,
0.0491133146,
-0.4395671189,
-0.1556172967,
-0.2748953402,
0.0206463803,
0.0731216744,
0.9534379244,
-0.8443816304,
0.7689647079,
0.6307832599,
-0.1168041825,
-0.73763448,
-0.1352591068,
0.0123820286,
-0.8849399686,
0.4459376335,
-0.0478845574,
-0.6886740327,
-0.1430516541,
-0.4673202038,
-0.757591784,
0.9402641058,
0.6635449529,
-0.4804070294,
0.1818767786,
-0.2624760568,
0.2275706679,
-0.2937811613,
0.0837833732,
0.8322165012,
0.2364837676,
0.2230263501,
-0.8037372828,
0.1646254659,
-0.2722790539,
-0.1968886554,
0.5941498876,
-0.5616257787,
0.82740134,
-0.3943893313,
-0.1973106712,
0.0127781834,
0.8390906453,
0.5662190914,
0.3705509007,
0.5662856102,
0.8820825815,
0.8166932464,
0.052154772,
1.101955533,
-0.0670177788,
0.2488029152,
1.0773202181,
-0.2576995194,
0.9447670579,
0.7612447739,
-0.080544129,
0.5951668024,
0.2561323345,
0.6011561751,
0.6571043134,
-0.0988628268,
-0.4642813206,
-0.7251620293,
-0.0204431992,
-0.1203902811,
0.4875586331,
0.2794530094,
-0.0407265909,
-0.1746383905,
0.0286601279,
0.1143270209,
0.0662108287,
-0.3386101127,
0.685489893,
0.0279015098,
-0.6683021784,
0.4806981087,
-0.1072868407,
0.6314067245,
-0.5545826554,
-0.1738763005,
-0.2848983109,
0.3345633447,
-0.3282213509,
-0.4526270032,
0.6035472155,
-0.062495742,
-0.5160753727,
-0.118187584,
0.6615009904,
-0.2532394826,
-0.551982522,
0.2901538312,
0.6186879277,
0.2358307987,
-0.0003030915,
-0.4950243831,
0.2083811611,
0.1134363636,
-0.3634698093,
0.2076218426,
0.6323229671,
-0.1808837801,
1.1583570242,
0.8582133651,
-0.0322709531,
0.0991096348,
0.1722798944,
0.9028486609,
-0.6349751949,
-0.1339407712,
-0.8149938583,
0.2460594475,
-0.0045819841,
-0.2367718518,
0.7279304266,
0.5643523335,
0.5469245911,
0.1953130215,
0.6097427011,
0.0414486229,
0.6604418755,
-0.7614716291,
0.3764324784,
-0.5684803724,
0.6777259111,
-0.0040167458,
-0.5075978041,
-0.2225563675,
0.4732663035,
-0.4275403917,
-0.1267246753,
0.4915390015,
0.5922566056,
0.1502331495,
0.0407639295,
0.1853626966,
-0.1196616739,
0.5824822783,
0.2965559363,
0.8111087084,
-0.3096380532,
0.5535341501,
-0.1172276661,
-0.2196889967,
-0.1057242379,
-0.86580652,
-0.8118182421,
-0.1762402952,
-0.2821384966,
0.0260313116,
-0.1058304906,
1.0959888697,
0.5564071536,
-0.6040661335,
-0.0047648828,
-0.0825399533,
0.5603591204,
-0.3379541039,
-0.191246748,
0.445482105,
-0.2723770738,
-0.6708293557,
0.7271171808,
0.4466811121,
-0.5354399681,
-0.1000988111,
-0.0404663272,
-0.2634225786,
0.2009491026,
0.9178982973,
0.3699058592,
-1.0443949699,
-0.3893480599,
-0.1008932665,
0.3687694967,
-0.2524867654,
0.9449896216,
-1.0375756025,
0.4060546458,
0.6236920357,
0.6229996681,
0.1877656728,
0.0231933556,
0.6724318266,
-0.6932560802,
0.3367439806,
0.0712873638,
0.5299274325,
0.1841600537,
-0.0842263773,
0.4226346314,
0.3208593726,
-0.4546248317,
-1.0667444468,
0.291624397,
-0.7349100113,
-0.2862302959,
0.937217772,
-0.2762902379,
-0.2657294273,
-0.2611684799,
-0.1127244011,
0.1457557976,
-0.4037639499,
0.7872856855,
0.5215010643,
-0.4425505996,
-0.5361734629,
-0.3575917184,
0.0976784602,
0.4565963745,
-0.9701068401,
0.3542106748,
0.3521690965,
0.2297707796,
0.2515805066,
0.4044572413,
-0.0792988241,
0.118433997,
0.1563083977,
0.2062299252,
-0.3774121404,
-0.253447324,
-0.0196386855,
0.099138543,
-0.0559965409,
-0.3345103264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13551v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13551v3 | How Fragile is Relation Extraction under Entity Replacements? | 2023-05-22T23:53:32 | 2024-05-07T16:22:07 | Yiwei Wang, Bryan Hooi, Fei Wang, Yujun Cai, Yuxuan Liang, Wenxuan Zhou, Jing Tang, Manjuan Duan, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Relation extraction (RE) aims to extract the relations between entity names
from the textual context. In principle, textual context determines the
ground-truth relation and the RE models should be able to correctly identify
the relations reflected by the textual context. However, existing work has
found that the RE models memorize the entity name patterns to make RE
predictions while ignoring the textual context. This motivates us to raise the
question: ``are RE models robust to the entity replacements?'' In this work, we
operate the random and type-constrained entity replacements over the RE
instances in TACRED and evaluate the state-of-the-art RE models under the
entity replacements. We observe the 30\% - 50\% F1 score drops on the
state-of-the-art RE models under entity replacements. These results suggest
that we need more efforts to develop effective RE models robust to entity
replacements. We release the source code at
https://github.com/wangywUST/RobustRE. | [
-0.0859586969,
-1.0088490248,
0.597415626,
0.1773291081,
-0.4106355906,
-0.2008183599,
0.0637918636,
-0.7529423237,
-0.0369037651,
0.3879230022,
-0.4852719009,
-0.3920563757,
-0.4780364037,
0.3298968971,
-0.4487575293,
1.1058795452,
-0.2057540864,
-0.1609871089,
-0.3237247169,
-0.2400921583,
-0.4780688286,
-0.2697776556,
-0.6380773187,
-0.213039577,
0.3736638725,
0.1745043844,
0.6458157301,
0.6163536906,
0.7797480226,
0.2553099394,
-0.2663767636,
-0.1044051349,
-0.4435818493,
0.7221192122,
-0.4369325042,
-0.4404913485,
-0.3983097374,
0.0344487019,
0.4821823835,
0.5735890865,
-0.3128036857,
0.2076410055,
-0.0294592492,
0.2063446343,
-0.7286168933,
0.3117502332,
-1.0639761686,
-0.0363408178,
-0.2101218551,
-0.1807817668,
-0.615062952,
-0.0956356525,
0.3583557606,
-0.6338179111,
0.391746968,
0.1699014902,
1.3380360603,
0.3373815417,
-0.3629281819,
-0.0388703905,
-0.8784068823,
0.6730379462,
-0.2408739924,
0.5122345686,
0.3617073894,
0.1509103626,
-0.3063569665,
-0.9431297183,
-0.066566661,
-0.064310886,
0.009816085,
-0.1357112974,
-0.0842483863,
-0.0521775819,
0.274769783,
0.6663295031,
-0.0894606113,
-0.0358847529,
-0.0476349071,
-0.3088668883,
0.2574855387,
0.2883829176,
0.508310914,
-0.3460395336,
-0.64991045,
0.1640102565,
-0.6777796745,
-0.0808325559,
0.015811529,
0.251081109,
0.2086597979,
0.4865880609,
0.1254552603,
0.3696831465,
0.1578952819,
-0.295671314,
-0.0531735756,
-0.3922567368,
-0.4652664959,
-0.2785984576,
0.794193387,
0.0869313553,
0.5800040364,
-0.4823061228,
-0.4806371927,
-0.1209012941,
0.4327552915,
-0.5996513963,
-0.3381425142,
0.1184366867,
-0.5419952869,
-0.6262743473,
0.1157585904,
-0.5606067181,
-0.0657258183,
0.165028885,
0.3483890891,
-0.8331215978,
-0.5356225967,
-0.082713306,
-0.0165047031,
0.080670923,
0.425403893,
-0.6596805453,
0.2847793698,
0.6229047179,
0.7419728041,
-0.255443275,
-0.4368952811,
-0.4012720883,
0.171472922,
-0.0728553236,
0.7688387632,
-0.4497699738,
-0.6275706291,
-0.0735824406,
0.1184045374,
-0.2756328583,
-0.574882865,
0.83316046,
-0.8071805239,
0.0549136885,
-0.4801574647,
-0.592425704,
-0.0012542905,
0.1780825704,
-1.0629818439,
0.8370919228,
0.4184322357,
-1.125649929,
0.5266100168,
-0.0208446328,
-0.5276886821,
-0.3421609998,
0.15987055,
-0.8878442645,
0.009264281,
0.1791261584,
0.1862015575,
-0.3309273422,
0.2733044922,
-0.6977095604,
-0.3911375105,
0.4921333492,
-0.2587280869,
0.96546942,
0.3678610325,
-0.1484410912,
-0.3089677691,
-0.6171024442,
-0.1210617945,
0.1041736752,
-0.252698034,
-0.6489163637,
-0.0697081015,
0.3778410256,
0.1639550626,
-0.2617272437,
-0.3632889092,
0.207569927,
-0.1854987442,
0.4836285412,
0.7315458655,
0.6863074899,
0.7001068592,
-0.2818233669,
0.6841508746,
0.2139375806,
-0.0735105351,
-0.1790143251,
-0.4344317913,
-0.2291730195,
-0.2681514919,
0.7978723049,
0.3886725903,
-0.8953244686,
0.0422988236,
-0.3863409758,
-0.4866971076,
-0.3384387493,
0.0296691824,
0.5125126243,
0.6956365705,
0.3632876575,
-0.1660739779,
-0.5550701022,
-0.7540743351,
-0.729719162,
-0.4099547863,
0.2176266909,
-0.204862237,
0.6577190757,
-0.2020918429,
1.1429845095,
-0.2921853065,
-0.2957167625,
-0.0812380314,
-0.1367886066,
-0.2358964682,
0.64970541,
0.7261527777,
-1.0441991091,
-0.2704222798,
-0.4840626419,
-0.7150306702,
0.1168011203,
-0.2619068623,
-0.1753634065,
0.226629585,
0.2871850431,
-0.9687159061,
0.5344334245,
0.0763038769,
-0.3093850315,
0.5952709317,
0.3726994097,
0.1150177121,
-1.1566592455,
0.1429670006,
0.2885715067,
-0.4964521527,
-0.5062991977,
0.4398108423,
0.0770811811,
-0.0643248037,
-0.480902642,
0.3062773049,
-0.7709832788,
-0.0385270007,
0.3125717342,
-0.0398247279,
0.0851311982,
0.1708312184,
-0.0756735355,
0.7813660502,
0.4300929904,
-0.5557576418,
-0.1289619356,
0.4460339546,
-0.4542727768,
0.5270271897,
-0.6741712093,
0.0050013345,
0.1639628112,
0.2128151804,
-0.6169970632,
-0.3925128281,
0.339520812,
-0.2972995043,
0.6642979383,
-0.2874714136,
-0.3547952473,
0.1355022639,
-0.3129339218,
0.3561111689,
0.1306543648,
-0.4242808223,
0.6435700059,
0.5498513579,
0.0649834499,
-0.7383435369,
-0.8166670799,
-0.0534954853,
-0.2365363687,
-0.6318116188,
0.4550073445,
0.2806352973,
-0.4962307215,
0.5316759944,
-0.5164749622,
-0.3252602816,
0.3325752318,
0.3579120636,
0.2244593352,
-0.1699202061,
0.1705073714,
0.0176413096,
-0.113467291,
0.1485443413,
0.2950946391,
0.1554861814,
0.0265761074,
-0.1822326779,
-0.5725342631,
0.2487149239,
0.8149639964,
-0.3204165995,
0.9352931976,
0.4168585241,
-0.7292388082,
-0.0468871556,
-0.4057869613,
-0.0887093619,
-0.3795368075,
0.4146597683,
-0.8080732822,
-0.6660265923,
0.8327254057,
0.0242267158,
-0.0097746579,
0.746198833,
0.1304848641,
-0.1186821386,
0.4555065036,
0.6195548773,
-0.1096117496,
0.4412036538,
-0.0998467132,
0.00962325,
-0.7718560696,
-0.183507055,
-0.4951740503,
0.0876415297,
-0.5823788047,
0.1059750468,
0.0009542435,
0.195429191,
0.0140326079,
0.5433512926,
-0.3421763182,
0.2136673182,
0.4141325355,
0.2156050056,
0.3788040578,
0.0190306306,
0.0511834957,
-0.4536248147,
-0.3934628665,
-0.464595139,
0.9453350306,
0.4044935405,
0.8184783459,
0.1038394794,
0.9088948965,
0.16965653,
0.62021029,
-0.6733720899,
0.3213828802,
0.2407746166,
-0.7590311766,
-0.154129684,
-0.656876266,
-0.9440600872,
-0.0664309412,
-0.4495566487,
-0.7507414222,
0.3132832348,
0.056891188,
-0.1272429377,
0.5635880232,
-0.6728973985,
0.886270225,
0.251299113,
-0.284879595,
0.1848986447,
-0.5253905654,
0.7208775878,
-0.1846261919,
-0.0594919138,
0.2288646847,
-0.0367144831,
0.4701352417,
-0.4813264012,
0.4563003182,
-0.1010630205,
-0.0950449035,
0.4938507378,
0.5496596098,
0.5361716747,
0.3500696719,
-0.4351114631,
-0.1257114708,
0.0887284353,
-0.2359201163,
-0.5326850414,
0.7081902027,
-0.6402158737,
-0.591740191,
-0.4333561361,
-0.3174388409,
-0.041962374,
0.2080408633,
0.4991192818,
0.4604538679,
-0.5926651955,
0.0926063657,
0.7281013131,
-0.1718378365,
0.40957883,
0.0658606291,
-0.0261513647,
-0.5316814184,
0.4964290857,
0.1011416316,
0.3064520657,
0.4373125732,
-0.3951959312,
-0.3202247918,
-0.3810228705,
-0.3486568332,
0.1810985804,
-0.6369211078,
-0.4077839553,
-0.6549432278,
-0.0350736007,
-0.2207813114,
0.2505458593,
-0.4233333766,
-0.4862968326,
-0.3928035498,
-0.121685192,
0.1049255282,
0.3960708678,
0.3874259293,
-0.0571681447,
-0.867241621,
0.2793477774,
0.1181988493,
0.3458899558,
-0.1892390102,
-0.3230107725,
-0.0518913306,
-0.1740249246,
-0.1945070177,
-1.2237604856,
0.1130008996,
0.136497587,
0.3669552207,
0.3947582245,
0.2961775959,
0.7357885242,
-0.366432935,
0.4720935822,
-0.1035307944,
-0.8291025758,
0.5057322383,
-0.3627170622,
0.0129751377,
0.8400214911,
0.1966550946,
-0.1409999132,
-0.5998166203,
-0.9818080068,
-0.5707471371,
0.421246618,
0.3670309186,
-0.1570233107,
-0.1201492772,
0.9109559655,
0.0377897359,
0.0977365375,
-0.6883285642,
-0.349159956,
0.0464265272,
-0.0399976596,
0.3091131747,
-0.472417444,
0.2770845592,
0.0552425236,
0.5857585669,
0.4932537079,
0.2650518715,
0.3242991567,
-0.3724677563,
-0.3110989928,
0.0173465796,
0.3951718509,
0.5384634733,
-0.4321032465,
0.0618776493,
-0.0246818122,
-0.6306105852,
0.0919076428,
0.0215332229,
-0.4088920951,
0.2841672003,
0.4981693327,
0.4744947553,
0.6183274984,
-0.2553808689,
0.3553736508,
-0.2787324488,
0.0098634642,
-0.3839522004,
0.0670169368,
0.0680097267,
-0.1076926365,
0.1610044539,
0.5969275832,
0.0039759977,
-0.7359024882,
0.5011278391,
0.248575449,
-0.3405454159,
-0.3859821558,
1.1359142065,
0.0475313477,
-0.485332638,
0.9064825177,
-0.1498051286,
-0.5340500474,
0.4835917354,
0.5132548213,
0.8820160031,
-0.3704338372,
0.0860870257,
0.313870281,
0.4488235116,
-0.3193243444,
0.0366641432,
0.2279176861,
-0.7863880396,
-0.4647003114,
-0.4032535553,
-0.4117929339,
0.080511488,
-0.9459815025,
0.2557493746,
-0.3312310874,
-0.4937983155,
-0.1937682033,
-0.0320123993,
-0.4767145216,
0.3237003684,
-0.5955596566,
0.9882493019,
-0.6958782673,
0.9592075348,
0.8806006908,
-0.6947605014,
-1.0567035675,
0.2244928628,
-0.0817097351,
-0.2105655372,
0.4039322138,
-0.0182921626,
-0.0258068889,
-0.1880726218,
-0.3381076157,
-0.6459222436,
0.976539731,
0.6703217626,
-0.1996192187,
-0.152980715,
-0.2936764657,
0.4581163526,
-0.2136538774,
0.120735012,
0.2647304833,
0.31872347,
-0.3172744513,
-0.7185280323,
0.353579253,
-0.2916515768,
0.0229802746,
0.3806852698,
-0.493722707,
0.7777370811,
-0.3564019203,
-0.5274095535,
0.4643814266,
0.5517805219,
0.3113023639,
0.3837110698,
0.7102572322,
0.8513325453,
0.5511387587,
-0.214580968,
1.0916954279,
-0.1399770528,
0.6914974451,
1.1554141045,
-0.1304612011,
0.8987642527,
0.6036199927,
-0.1259375364,
0.6222474575,
0.8575438261,
-0.0326415375,
0.4890727997,
-0.3342584074,
-0.0610940196,
-0.2841363549,
0.189161703,
-0.2469702661,
0.4825253785,
0.2684876621,
-0.4536111057,
0.0274970029,
-0.4357761145,
0.1194963083,
0.1583848894,
0.0825036913,
0.3245997131,
0.3101519346,
-0.6786185503,
0.2695206404,
0.092029117,
0.3029345572,
-0.1262268722,
-0.1043872833,
-0.2152342945,
0.1344785541,
-0.1512145251,
-0.4500119686,
0.373056531,
-0.1883938462,
-0.3577267826,
-0.0927314386,
1.0074800253,
-0.3078186512,
-0.1599010229,
0.0882245451,
0.698676765,
-0.0885575488,
-0.1235980168,
-0.6042934656,
-0.0616088361,
0.08261922,
-0.5270056129,
0.3829118013,
0.7658733726,
-0.1483446807,
0.8179653287,
0.4329450428,
-0.0180559214,
-0.157861203,
-0.07935258,
0.6887607574,
-0.5405586958,
-0.141978398,
-0.8269609213,
0.4517660439,
-0.0976083279,
-0.5621265173,
0.6569448113,
0.3141843677,
0.603659749,
-0.1969770491,
0.2568761706,
-0.0351919979,
0.3683553934,
-0.457973659,
0.8220559359,
-0.5097962022,
0.4622727633,
-0.7906489372,
-1.1965800524,
-0.3606627882,
0.3661297262,
0.0283576883,
0.1449389309,
0.8474914432,
0.5657029748,
-0.2852692604,
0.1758565605,
0.0195187293,
0.132494837,
0.1976731867,
0.3457325995,
0.7499561906,
-0.7389870882,
0.8375197649,
-0.3516563475,
0.1490888447,
0.0183990672,
-0.602283895,
-0.6266893148,
-0.6095742583,
-0.5117482543,
-0.5509192944,
0.031073017,
0.487965107,
0.2883914709,
-0.6138533354,
0.2503288984,
-0.1785698533,
0.4350046813,
-0.2711184323,
-0.3451940417,
0.4491109252,
-0.2558548152,
-0.7814121246,
0.0917095765,
0.0334309824,
0.094029583,
-0.0110261301,
0.1035551056,
-0.384480387,
-0.4113174975,
0.1392690837,
0.3102682233,
-0.6136419177,
-0.6970127821,
0.1917127073,
-0.3611044586,
-0.0353719369,
0.7080653906,
-0.6765476465,
0.2245094925,
0.3134317994,
0.7368578315,
0.2948266268,
0.1913384497,
0.7793241143,
-0.5857618451,
-0.0264345109,
-0.0144783538,
0.7375706434,
0.402657181,
-0.3405536115,
0.9240987897,
0.4815354645,
-0.5259357691,
-1.1089318991,
0.3138521314,
-0.9450076222,
-0.0768733993,
1.1325149536,
-0.4857049286,
-0.3077022135,
-0.1759566963,
0.0888678133,
0.5061812997,
-0.3973588049,
0.8918219209,
0.6218582392,
0.1648045927,
-0.4067279696,
-0.2269647121,
0.3360084891,
0.4451355934,
-0.3642016947,
-0.2874444723,
0.1913361847,
0.7526343465,
0.2165182084,
0.6382413507,
-0.2344210595,
0.4119266868,
0.1823857278,
0.0305755362,
-0.0387391746,
-0.0563752428,
-0.0485248566,
0.25279966,
0.2908614278,
-0.2190216631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13547v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13547v3 | Self-Evolution Learning for Mixup: Enhance Data Augmentation on Few-Shot Text Classification Tasks | 2023-05-22T23:43:23 | 2023-11-27T15:10:00 | Haoqi Zheng, Qihuang Zhong, Liang Ding, Zhiliang Tian, Xin Niu, Dongsheng Li, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.NI | Text classification tasks often encounter few shot scenarios with limited
labeled data, and addressing data scarcity is crucial. Data augmentation with
mixup has shown to be effective on various text classification tasks. However,
most of the mixup methods do not consider the varying degree of learning
difficulty in different stages of training and generate new samples with one
hot labels, resulting in the model over confidence. In this paper, we propose a
self evolution learning (SE) based mixup approach for data augmentation in text
classification, which can generate more adaptive and model friendly pesudo
samples for the model training. SE focuses on the variation of the model's
learning ability. To alleviate the model confidence, we introduce a novel
instance specific label smoothing approach, which linearly interpolates the
model's output and one hot labels of the original samples to generate new soft
for label mixing up. Through experimental analysis, in addition to improving
classification accuracy, we demonstrate that SE also enhances the model's
generalize ability. | [
-0.2833810449,
-0.5200748444,
0.3386545777,
0.0070712464,
-0.3863517344,
0.0422088169,
0.0230976902,
-0.5036655068,
0.2661311328,
0.480004549,
-0.6935014129,
-0.3216933906,
-0.4823432267,
0.215908289,
-0.2823135555,
1.2845221758,
0.1502591819,
-0.2266951054,
-0.2111238092,
-0.1179301813,
-0.4384661615,
-0.467782557,
-0.4968796372,
-0.4424641132,
0.2760071754,
0.5723571777,
0.4368538558,
0.584536314,
0.211602807,
0.3279431164,
-0.0296844169,
0.3752949238,
-0.4934820533,
0.3546003103,
-0.3221468031,
-0.0067384285,
-0.5252737403,
-0.0756498128,
0.4644861221,
0.3844045401,
-0.0237772241,
-0.0554603525,
0.3474746943,
0.3061904013,
-0.6651107669,
-0.2021423578,
-0.9383136034,
0.0789052173,
-0.0853154659,
-0.3864100873,
-0.1845996678,
0.1221321672,
0.2646699846,
-0.7163513899,
0.4577923715,
-0.1843312085,
0.5669127703,
0.5064768195,
-0.2610290051,
-0.1033735797,
-0.6400709748,
0.6848308444,
-0.9487854242,
0.0786940157,
0.2170601636,
0.1683156341,
-0.109254688,
-0.6236775517,
-0.6239928007,
0.208004415,
0.1523710787,
0.3833511174,
0.143302083,
-0.0738127977,
-0.0077873934,
0.3140977025,
-0.3078427613,
0.3033071756,
-0.2068609595,
0.0613048673,
0.687859416,
0.1525208801,
0.3340412974,
-0.2208964527,
-0.6440560222,
-0.2997971177,
-0.278214097,
-0.1155519709,
0.4139045179,
0.3888791502,
0.142505303,
0.204259038,
-0.1852208078,
0.6721720695,
0.3225418329,
-0.0480419248,
0.5842188001,
-0.2194657773,
-0.4370701313,
0.0996128842,
0.708094418,
0.0240385719,
-0.2943623662,
-0.0211060084,
-0.1360467523,
-0.4499122202,
0.3109385669,
-0.8992359042,
-0.5076094866,
0.1914127618,
-0.2173354626,
-0.5912903547,
-0.0619194806,
-0.9328845739,
-0.3674997687,
-0.1095122397,
0.7382330298,
-0.3338368833,
-0.0794809982,
0.0732297227,
-0.0318225361,
-0.0863830298,
0.4722372293,
-0.9354090095,
0.2315868139,
0.2485074252,
0.6332519054,
-0.2720097005,
-0.4759124815,
-0.4582875371,
0.1694603115,
-0.0860476717,
0.9359584451,
-0.6112573743,
-0.5136473179,
-0.3332866132,
-0.3231805563,
-0.0364046171,
-0.4699960947,
0.5471319556,
-0.1229930446,
0.5526721478,
0.2907682359,
-0.8429940939,
-0.1970651746,
0.2358625233,
-0.485678941,
1.4660925865,
0.1687806547,
-0.7381336689,
0.5995656848,
-0.3692702651,
-0.3310250342,
0.39898175,
-0.2658762038,
-0.9558548331,
0.0723762363,
0.4735434651,
0.8024945259,
0.2047776431,
0.1158025637,
-0.6568006873,
-0.1967768818,
0.157296285,
-0.2237792611,
0.3944042623,
0.1490069628,
-0.1746557951,
-0.2094385326,
-0.9283679724,
0.124112457,
-0.0002910157,
-0.4495941103,
-0.6902762055,
-0.0843522921,
0.0487062372,
0.2656258047,
0.1236715242,
-0.230035305,
0.6338871121,
-0.36749354,
-0.0271768626,
0.7284683585,
0.4014709592,
0.5223807693,
-0.3638872206,
0.3370317519,
0.1972720772,
-0.1102508157,
-0.6254200935,
-0.5249717236,
-0.9312196374,
-0.1910368055,
0.7080695033,
0.6635590792,
-0.8467007279,
0.6548753381,
-0.0335521773,
-0.5269774795,
-0.4416474998,
0.6418735385,
0.1910844445,
0.6014521122,
0.7402899861,
-0.232003808,
-0.4658284187,
-0.5238124132,
-0.4126792848,
0.2387191057,
-0.0193890277,
0.3200438917,
0.3778875172,
-0.4673551023,
0.9378846288,
-0.4126707017,
-0.4351865649,
-0.3488934934,
0.5095466375,
-0.0001017224,
0.7749073505,
0.62105757,
-0.6807413697,
-0.3539628685,
0.0485799983,
-0.5944181681,
-0.2104966789,
-0.5941640139,
0.1222877875,
-0.197404772,
0.3716743886,
0.1336867213,
0.2849246562,
0.3230739236,
-0.1345819235,
0.119481191,
-0.6115138531,
0.1578671634,
-1.2571834326,
-0.5119228363,
0.3971616328,
-0.351343751,
-0.9327615499,
-0.1212532222,
0.3510158956,
-0.0691111088,
-0.5202618241,
0.4888078868,
-0.230443567,
0.1925841123,
-0.626835227,
-0.1503129601,
-0.0533536486,
0.3783157468,
0.1524810493,
0.4711407125,
0.5624423027,
-0.9189561009,
0.0032664395,
0.083464697,
0.0221563317,
0.3820594549,
-0.363768667,
0.3575088978,
-0.1322662681,
0.1375162452,
-0.9891793132,
-0.3753013909,
0.1895041615,
-0.3878157735,
0.5654861927,
-0.0697494447,
-0.0564019941,
-0.2429531366,
-0.2371295542,
0.4145275354,
0.5196115375,
-0.8260053992,
0.6592988372,
0.1142164245,
-0.2335731983,
-0.440895617,
-0.6028936505,
-0.0752479061,
-0.3493619561,
-0.3941195905,
0.6710186005,
-0.3059361875,
0.1683635861,
-0.1354554743,
-0.2422799319,
-0.3784433603,
-0.0289354697,
-0.0477843955,
0.1993628442,
0.2258045971,
0.3564278483,
0.6099416614,
-0.0964593962,
-0.4715248644,
-0.1736928374,
0.1424112618,
0.1949106753,
0.1002806276,
-0.4025645852,
0.0968396887,
0.0258919578,
0.2592190206,
0.3656332493,
0.6000204682,
-0.3702374995,
-0.5392506123,
-0.4391244054,
-0.1778281033,
-0.5059453845,
0.2039137036,
-0.6691671014,
-0.5951499343,
0.2884765863,
-0.3359662592,
0.0273197219,
0.6010092497,
0.3609057665,
-0.4351232052,
0.7752200365,
0.5658076406,
-0.0733912736,
0.610563159,
-0.2132612318,
-0.0951158479,
-0.5838907957,
-0.1462770551,
-0.4290128946,
-0.3382825553,
-0.4734382629,
-0.3990078568,
0.2100981921,
0.0389730074,
0.0942367464,
0.3470873535,
-0.5891389847,
0.7587069869,
0.4244879782,
0.615876615,
0.3382736444,
0.1768565327,
0.0480754226,
-0.2686413825,
-0.896946609,
0.0575552806,
1.16703403,
0.3018729389,
0.9582468867,
-0.351139009,
1.2346072197,
0.6063183546,
0.0140592,
-0.3987136781,
0.2398847193,
-0.220835492,
-0.3749027848,
-0.2169349492,
-0.5768173337,
-0.7310053706,
0.4333491623,
-0.7118577361,
-0.3947526515,
0.5232040286,
0.3368715644,
-0.1328930706,
0.1904440969,
-0.6332841516,
0.5633446574,
-0.3648478687,
-0.2998836935,
0.1253873706,
-0.3440922201,
0.275215894,
-0.3956195414,
0.2419807017,
0.1525015086,
-0.0453776233,
0.7525649667,
-0.4246777594,
0.8304585218,
0.0092287445,
-0.0159971975,
0.3146136701,
0.0629412308,
0.6079682112,
-0.1393074095,
-0.0136608602,
-0.0232201219,
-0.3548726439,
-0.5564998388,
-0.7607123256,
0.5382757783,
-0.724164784,
-0.3171413839,
-0.4996770918,
-0.3937606514,
-0.2688420117,
0.0236951727,
0.6723712683,
0.394037962,
0.1448569149,
0.1163749024,
0.7307627797,
-0.1071659029,
0.4183234274,
0.2849967778,
0.0481545255,
-0.5661184192,
0.9878582954,
0.0521414578,
0.2629290223,
0.1237980798,
0.3900492191,
-0.2600418329,
-0.6180176735,
-0.4944258928,
-0.108071655,
-0.6135523915,
-0.4137455523,
-0.7693240643,
-0.2040328681,
-0.508692801,
-0.3895873725,
-0.2487357706,
-0.5054278374,
-0.568256855,
-0.0183765087,
0.370261699,
0.7751656175,
0.0148575623,
0.5823099613,
-0.6429396272,
0.3009488285,
0.5209230781,
0.2751566172,
-0.2382239997,
-0.9003005028,
-0.0704315677,
-0.0771443546,
-0.4184873998,
-1.27133286,
0.5987736583,
0.4210584164,
0.5705929399,
0.3430030942,
0.0348597094,
0.7659707069,
-0.2363362312,
0.4513729513,
0.4854827225,
-1.0547306538,
0.8123716712,
-0.4376517832,
0.325416714,
0.768853128,
0.364279002,
-0.1827571839,
-0.3655586541,
-0.9499439001,
-0.8649555445,
0.7724515796,
0.3206329346,
0.2475316226,
0.3615805805,
0.5662714243,
0.4104860127,
-0.0468058325,
-1.1611298323,
-0.2761147618,
-0.3966560662,
-0.4391246438,
-0.0244663935,
-0.094910495,
0.321705848,
-0.4916818738,
0.9484128952,
-0.2359678596,
-0.1493234783,
0.2094168067,
-0.2081570178,
0.0709247738,
0.5191168785,
0.2388213873,
0.0928620398,
-0.2913537621,
0.0617039092,
0.630867362,
-0.4601175189,
0.2142094374,
0.0641202778,
-0.4032594562,
-0.0774915814,
-0.0697188973,
0.6856989861,
0.3460828364,
-0.3461782336,
0.3160519898,
0.0866907835,
-0.3740023971,
0.3516369164,
0.5167866349,
-0.4690538347,
0.25579983,
0.6596138477,
0.1054482833,
0.5838739276,
-0.3488859534,
0.3017630875,
0.1202216372,
-0.2296498418,
0.1510670632,
0.4739145935,
0.3305804729,
-0.2562339008,
0.0980687439,
-0.490499109,
-0.6015446782,
0.5350802541,
0.9278671145,
0.9764606357,
-0.4323854744,
0.2413094491,
0.2843638659,
0.1808169782,
-0.0007929485,
-0.0575714745,
-0.2069154382,
-0.6207885742,
-0.2295886725,
-0.3449441791,
-0.7228990197,
0.4694297314,
-0.3978364766,
0.4808033705,
-0.4325394034,
0.0628624856,
-0.019740995,
-0.0059129116,
-0.6421504617,
0.6441235542,
0.0850823,
0.528290689,
-0.9598372579,
0.8653456569,
0.7809273601,
-0.2618061602,
-0.4200228155,
0.2437528968,
-0.3219785988,
-0.2297927737,
0.4022677243,
0.3002708852,
0.0135645848,
0.1005135402,
-0.5311623812,
-0.5781648159,
0.8432160616,
-0.1882459521,
-0.5413789749,
0.0252730232,
-0.090213269,
0.5323745012,
-0.6064438224,
0.3331644833,
0.3318215907,
0.1810438037,
0.3074233532,
-0.4435224235,
-0.1745222956,
-0.2927600443,
0.1315765083,
0.1446876824,
-0.3438825309,
0.6696435213,
-0.1008459479,
-0.0317113586,
-0.1814462394,
0.8676199317,
0.0345621221,
0.7238764167,
0.5130259991,
0.724032104,
0.8193228245,
0.0763508379,
0.6969664097,
0.1508421451,
0.7541915178,
1.5046821833,
-0.1508133858,
0.660787046,
-0.0051366878,
-0.0953258052,
0.6163154244,
0.8314738274,
-0.1331281364,
0.5023545623,
-0.2047075927,
-0.2672125995,
-0.5273026228,
0.4530393779,
-0.4295592904,
0.4510598779,
0.440198034,
-0.2477882206,
-0.447507143,
0.2534066737,
-0.2267368585,
0.04815403,
-0.4507114589,
0.8974203467,
-0.3735013306,
-0.3541374505,
0.3789336383,
-0.0341181718,
0.9251510501,
-0.2650893331,
-0.008459853,
-0.1994554251,
0.087407358,
-0.3304568827,
-0.708201766,
-0.1273611635,
-0.1203203872,
-0.106231302,
-0.0584433749,
1.2080830336,
-0.7172890902,
-0.6038147211,
0.0975477025,
0.3507658243,
0.085536398,
0.0175309498,
-0.974594295,
-0.1392459571,
0.0446964204,
-0.165520817,
0.429880619,
0.2665071487,
0.3679250777,
0.5506919026,
0.5597577095,
-0.1554732025,
0.1429040283,
-0.1117449328,
0.782337904,
-0.6480671167,
-0.7721419334,
-0.749530375,
0.3928668499,
-0.4497903585,
-0.4106681347,
0.7081366181,
0.5106847882,
0.7065153122,
-0.1260637343,
0.9458727837,
0.2295348644,
0.6092706323,
-0.5125098228,
0.3219779134,
-0.7209558487,
0.2157342285,
-0.5013090372,
-0.9685018063,
-0.2123378962,
0.5695878267,
-0.2841757238,
0.3289674819,
0.4694848657,
0.276398927,
-0.4137474597,
0.0819987729,
0.3880959451,
-0.0019400943,
-0.0119394269,
0.4144945443,
0.5536187291,
-0.6598036885,
0.452450633,
-0.4209966063,
-0.369436413,
-0.4288027585,
-0.915522337,
-1.0689843893,
-0.5080206394,
-0.5838073492,
-0.3232271373,
-0.011326286,
0.8582959175,
0.8385536671,
-0.6807994843,
0.2345198244,
-0.1771198064,
-0.0768634006,
-0.0967186391,
-0.2468761057,
0.0702955797,
-0.6948969364,
-0.9625319839,
0.533283174,
0.3086177409,
0.6640245318,
0.0552031063,
0.1126894429,
-0.1752657592,
0.2781483531,
0.3279887438,
0.5031619072,
-0.2523466945,
0.0354127437,
-0.3007471561,
0.0707092732,
0.2477024198,
0.7499532104,
-1.185495615,
0.8934229016,
0.4658244848,
0.998128891,
0.888292551,
0.2595874965,
0.1415142864,
-1.1262488365,
0.1354967207,
-0.0113162603,
0.2723550797,
0.2747057974,
-0.6834569573,
0.4465824962,
0.2419867516,
-0.5501464605,
-0.5426960588,
0.0708102584,
-1.1302928925,
-0.5670503378,
0.9337133765,
0.1368141472,
-0.0897777006,
-0.0373841971,
-0.2110483348,
0.146251604,
-0.4703741074,
0.9841451645,
0.4220730364,
-0.3113174438,
-0.2270230055,
-0.0672092065,
0.4741356671,
0.4821421206,
-1.3107588291,
-0.3577208519,
0.3780862987,
0.4991134107,
-0.0554922335,
0.5633863211,
0.317070514,
0.3416777551,
-0.0917194933,
-0.0173415784,
0.0265458412,
-0.5264008641,
-0.5821196437,
0.006421471,
-0.3974719048,
-0.1551806033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13535v1 | Improving Classifier Robustness through Active Generation of Pairwise Counterfactuals | 2023-05-22T23:19:01 | 2023-05-22T23:19:01 | Ananth Balashankar, Xuezhi Wang, Yao Qin, Ben Packer, Nithum Thain, Jilin Chen, Ed H. Chi, Alex Beutel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Counterfactual Data Augmentation (CDA) is a commonly used technique for
improving robustness in natural language classifiers. However, one fundamental
challenge is how to discover meaningful counterfactuals and efficiently label
them, with minimal human labeling cost. Most existing methods either completely
rely on human-annotated labels, an expensive process which limits the scale of
counterfactual data, or implicitly assume label invariance, which may mislead
the model with incorrect labels. In this paper, we present a novel framework
that utilizes counterfactual generative models to generate a large number of
diverse counterfactuals by actively sampling from regions of uncertainty, and
then automatically label them with a learned pairwise classifier. Our key
insight is that we can more correctly label the generated counterfactuals by
training a pairwise classifier that interpolates the relationship between the
original example and the counterfactual. We demonstrate that with a small
amount of human-annotated counterfactual data (10%), we can generate a
counterfactual augmentation dataset with learned labels, that provides an
18-20% improvement in robustness and a 14-21% reduction in errors on 6
out-of-domain datasets, comparable to that of a fully human-annotated
counterfactual dataset for both sentiment classification and question
paraphrase tasks. | [
-0.4402732849,
-1.0054306984,
0.439964354,
-0.0952832699,
-0.2983280718,
0.0694491491,
-0.0007880144,
-0.2437046766,
0.0101761157,
0.2493282408,
-0.3779450059,
-0.2583545148,
-0.5472499132,
-0.1787801832,
-0.3077894151,
1.1623811722,
0.078227669,
-0.0693430901,
-0.5291830301,
-0.4338388741,
-0.2128914148,
-0.6145871282,
-0.4341083765,
-0.425619334,
0.2272835076,
0.326633215,
0.9720956683,
0.2116646767,
0.0723432228,
0.2723126709,
0.228939876,
0.3132932782,
-0.4123598933,
0.1610566825,
-0.0851705968,
-0.5066882372,
-0.277515471,
0.183842063,
0.2405575812,
0.583835721,
-0.0217173845,
0.0244031493,
-0.080002889,
0.4501476288,
-0.5264227986,
0.3231857121,
-0.6194123626,
-0.0927868783,
-0.0715382323,
0.0299612582,
-0.3167353868,
-0.267028749,
0.205149129,
-0.9119992852,
0.4606307447,
-0.0686468408,
0.7753632665,
0.5000978112,
-0.2609867752,
-0.048754897,
-0.5454987884,
0.60390836,
-0.6408387423,
0.3099706173,
0.5415789485,
0.0063791741,
-0.0628381446,
-0.4735822678,
-0.8542296886,
0.105152145,
-0.2869757414,
0.2359015346,
-0.497995168,
-0.1309432089,
0.2854123414,
0.0957521424,
-0.6740871072,
0.1371244639,
-0.0680990368,
-0.2625290751,
0.6076338291,
-0.0765917525,
0.3413594365,
0.0666727051,
-0.4185730219,
-0.4571922719,
-0.6240278482,
0.0072747595,
0.48555547,
0.324067682,
-0.181719929,
0.2412317693,
-0.0523612574,
0.735421896,
0.2807487547,
0.0262003765,
0.48633039,
-0.2532329559,
-0.2089930028,
0.2094310969,
0.739274621,
0.4177961349,
0.0645086467,
-0.2322517186,
-0.2180343568,
0.6111202836,
0.5036664009,
-0.7485610843,
-0.5835707784,
0.3246649802,
-0.0886701569,
-0.7473112345,
-0.0943820104,
-0.7437451482,
-0.2571001351,
-0.202650696,
0.7377378345,
-0.252840668,
-0.2011434585,
-0.2880520821,
0.0748502612,
-0.1145680696,
0.25866732,
-0.6645573378,
-0.1121803969,
0.4844501615,
0.6352801919,
0.0095270555,
0.0439914949,
-0.8588451147,
0.1022556797,
-0.5630787611,
0.8167501092,
-0.6944016814,
-0.4119736254,
-0.0773601606,
-0.0642368272,
0.0828289911,
-0.4847123623,
0.3682479262,
-0.5721331835,
0.2394994497,
-0.2931801081,
-0.413428396,
-0.1539200693,
0.5122511983,
-0.6004360914,
1.1137421131,
0.0683711767,
-0.8633726835,
0.6390240788,
-0.3855057359,
-0.556827724,
0.0556898937,
-0.3000840545,
-0.994374752,
-0.1468974352,
0.3068375885,
0.4037415981,
-0.1660320908,
0.776807487,
-0.4421344399,
-0.1951598525,
0.4681685865,
-0.6506823301,
0.7056595087,
0.0422067977,
-0.3150300682,
0.1118377969,
-0.8786705732,
-0.3400135636,
-0.0901927426,
-0.2669143975,
-0.6387732625,
-0.2247415781,
-0.1291099638,
0.239715457,
-0.0134526221,
-0.6678842306,
-0.0239297841,
-0.3411619961,
0.1377562881,
0.7171321511,
0.0243383907,
0.4140380621,
-0.3852593601,
0.3792793453,
0.4951419234,
0.0099272607,
-0.1127076223,
-0.5357437134,
-0.7085548639,
-0.3564055264,
0.1999455839,
0.5967423916,
-1.2705774307,
0.5699023008,
-0.0876019374,
-0.5431064963,
-0.2958683074,
0.2806419134,
0.6583137512,
1.0482796431,
0.5461824536,
-0.2837004364,
-0.5359945297,
-0.886456728,
-0.0674570203,
-0.5911129713,
0.076040484,
-0.0821763277,
0.3439974487,
-0.2732698321,
0.9532849193,
-0.5119510889,
-0.1296730787,
0.0076166643,
0.7874369025,
0.0344235487,
0.6292000413,
0.5975559354,
-1.0921800137,
-0.272180289,
-0.3076702058,
-0.859650135,
-0.2411324382,
-0.4849660695,
-0.1055316031,
0.4442489445,
0.5652835965,
-0.4810878932,
0.5573520064,
0.2880034745,
-0.2806095779,
0.1313709915,
-0.2537707388,
-0.1489861608,
-0.9404535294,
0.0061037852,
0.211461544,
-0.0870594308,
-0.720961988,
-0.1083123907,
0.0537913702,
0.1701438576,
-0.2520362437,
0.307932049,
-0.1011228934,
0.2509345114,
-0.0370739736,
0.0678964183,
0.0636936426,
0.6230636835,
0.2566945851,
0.6905590892,
0.4989022613,
-0.4219090641,
0.4346866906,
0.3452444375,
-0.0930585712,
0.9587663412,
-0.316269964,
0.0204907022,
-0.4936467111,
0.4460681677,
-1.0932246447,
-0.0462294035,
0.3535450697,
-0.418364197,
0.4167782068,
-0.1359247714,
-0.3874536753,
-0.0372973308,
-0.3923944831,
0.3464542031,
0.3852900565,
-0.7493314743,
0.6513523459,
0.2852278352,
0.0459337197,
-0.409511894,
-0.8532640338,
0.1442684382,
-0.2808581889,
-0.1747327149,
0.1072357744,
-0.1658293456,
-0.3304260969,
-0.0757799894,
-0.2117088288,
0.0180282593,
0.0917220265,
0.3720891178,
0.4341555834,
0.0354630612,
0.5833538175,
0.1797911525,
-0.1817861497,
0.1334920526,
-0.2107027322,
0.1253177226,
-0.0325761251,
-0.1800204515,
-0.0564841963,
0.3318850994,
0.1085318327,
-0.0411498174,
0.6803532243,
0.8900638223,
-0.3925735652,
-0.2211500704,
-0.4292180538,
-0.1241329461,
-0.440115571,
0.3381550312,
-0.3260205984,
-0.4222551882,
0.2507754564,
0.2368827611,
0.1092223004,
0.3023985326,
0.3111132979,
-0.0228864942,
0.8287210464,
0.1937425137,
0.1278037876,
0.3561526835,
-0.177015081,
0.2373388857,
-0.3650856018,
-0.251131475,
-0.2300257981,
-0.0333704352,
-0.5259467959,
-0.5136360526,
0.5343324542,
-0.0300684366,
-0.1736756861,
0.1584461629,
-0.3602066636,
0.1555777043,
0.7411324382,
0.5382900238,
0.1828821898,
-0.0084275063,
-0.0390886031,
-0.0817942023,
-0.7114909291,
-0.5772371888,
1.1291850805,
0.0632404536,
0.5842669606,
0.3288152814,
0.5660070181,
0.3477493823,
0.7170845866,
-0.5511541367,
0.4044505954,
-0.4109146297,
-0.5342578888,
-0.2728567719,
-0.4017119408,
-0.5995218158,
0.1528454274,
-0.5801509619,
-0.4003785551,
0.5107386112,
0.5495554209,
-0.4587114751,
0.2785736322,
-0.7775123715,
0.7956871986,
-0.1724425852,
-0.5958578587,
-0.0036607455,
-0.8450645208,
0.1945682317,
-0.3931897283,
0.2371864021,
0.3390198648,
0.1275764406,
0.7336505055,
-0.5398208499,
1.23389709,
-0.3419133723,
-0.3652985692,
0.3790250719,
0.076448068,
0.6237725019,
0.2875400782,
0.0412702896,
-0.024563048,
-0.2029694617,
-0.4732233286,
-0.6694779396,
0.617334187,
-0.7813623548,
-0.5734814405,
-0.4164170623,
-0.5929639935,
-0.6915478706,
-0.0354791433,
0.21750094,
0.7441013455,
-0.4051415622,
0.0382883176,
0.998281002,
-0.3677448034,
0.5029521585,
0.4046003819,
0.1577957571,
-0.4652595222,
1.1870075464,
0.1791461259,
0.2907598615,
0.5822939277,
0.1400289088,
-0.364818126,
-0.348416388,
-0.6720787883,
-0.2075671703,
-0.698759973,
-0.3843636811,
-0.7907546163,
0.1437354386,
-0.4233360589,
-0.1735917032,
-0.1166608855,
-0.525968492,
-0.482367903,
-0.3839257061,
0.4387053549,
0.5660959482,
-0.3622249365,
0.3084922731,
-0.4749085605,
0.6512290239,
1.0011411905,
0.0475870222,
-0.1199270934,
-0.4121821821,
0.0549185909,
0.2379193604,
-0.2358738482,
-0.721411109,
0.3571892977,
0.2201440185,
0.5028897524,
0.4840815067,
0.6150625348,
0.5415687561,
0.0406143516,
0.6659561396,
0.2348452806,
-0.8586015701,
0.5073209405,
-0.292176038,
0.2445377409,
0.4523133039,
0.3617578745,
-0.0872738734,
-0.3697012961,
-0.6697087288,
-0.9357125163,
0.7064948082,
0.2045044452,
0.0215042159,
-0.0263705663,
0.0844302997,
0.3240193427,
0.0871400461,
-0.6123533845,
-0.2408790886,
-0.857424438,
-0.4875648618,
-0.2757894099,
-0.1759768128,
-0.4028291702,
0.0019020183,
0.9863640666,
-0.3780099154,
-0.1624186784,
0.2638745904,
-0.2351613641,
-0.2549198866,
0.320648551,
0.4936875701,
0.2729471624,
-0.2840643823,
0.5295842886,
0.3011772335,
-0.2940259874,
0.2203016877,
0.4971238971,
-0.5556853414,
-0.1361234784,
0.3494622707,
0.8629620671,
-0.0123878503,
-0.6357075572,
0.5734667182,
-0.0792548954,
-0.0621578135,
-0.0908054858,
-0.0315928273,
0.0087962179,
0.2067055702,
0.4124789238,
0.3356985748,
0.0819388032,
-0.5976952314,
0.2837498486,
0.4454578161,
-0.5500685573,
-0.373048991,
0.7065297365,
0.3069665432,
-0.0221888665,
0.3676380515,
-0.3515259624,
-0.5806738734,
0.4877406061,
0.4922135472,
0.6577813625,
-0.0465633199,
0.5576274991,
0.396381706,
0.2459418923,
-0.073184073,
0.077319175,
-0.3673924804,
-0.8952103853,
0.048689954,
-0.3886179924,
-0.5089340806,
0.083345063,
-0.6471153498,
-0.035216596,
-0.3418138027,
-0.0566654764,
-0.0510102846,
-0.2086022943,
-0.5196871758,
0.7245472074,
0.1127976552,
0.3287065923,
-1.2147986889,
0.8295029998,
1.0019203424,
-0.5759704113,
-0.3321157992,
0.0087352041,
-0.0712921172,
-0.6026818156,
0.5358552933,
0.1850903481,
-0.1893646866,
-0.3989181221,
-0.5974734426,
-0.434928,
0.7121938467,
0.3019989729,
-0.651940465,
0.2658865452,
0.1545643955,
0.7372277379,
-0.192676425,
0.116339609,
0.3225179315,
0.4405359626,
0.0855541751,
-0.5206948519,
0.4087710381,
-0.4602328539,
-0.007740024,
0.0151436701,
-0.5985662937,
0.4913926721,
-0.2523206472,
-0.0821390525,
-0.1808700562,
0.66310215,
0.2041840702,
0.5929905772,
0.9357154369,
0.7373651862,
0.4928518236,
-0.2295133322,
0.631782949,
-0.1016033366,
0.0214374103,
1.1869728565,
-0.0618140735,
0.5332550406,
0.4803932011,
-0.1622690707,
0.3779839873,
0.4806122482,
-0.0089966003,
0.4913414419,
-0.0358684696,
-0.39516747,
-0.8965322375,
-0.2407909781,
-0.1715904772,
0.2142246217,
0.466049552,
-0.272639811,
0.0352546088,
0.029040318,
0.2064828128,
0.3934217691,
0.071311377,
0.8339532614,
-0.1036679447,
-0.7298519611,
0.4803208709,
-0.3769651055,
0.8701663613,
-0.2416229695,
-0.2096057832,
-0.2629708648,
0.1551980972,
-0.2268411517,
-0.6322039962,
0.1376078874,
-0.0861689746,
-0.1265999824,
-0.2536058426,
0.4468556941,
-0.5828589797,
-0.6178599,
0.0801233724,
0.3182187378,
-0.2071191519,
0.2017235011,
-0.3652898967,
-0.0590102077,
-0.0144712441,
-0.017595401,
0.2220137417,
0.2697630227,
-0.2745977938,
0.4175013602,
0.6440351009,
-0.1449725479,
-0.2009186894,
0.0842081755,
1.0250601768,
-0.3982069492,
-0.5033340454,
-0.46242854,
0.294472307,
-0.1638846546,
-0.3747000396,
0.4086700678,
0.3622711599,
0.9562337995,
0.0794529319,
0.9584017992,
-0.088495031,
0.5476224422,
-0.3103673458,
0.5424989462,
-0.4911635518,
0.4170872867,
-0.346973598,
-0.4734675586,
-0.4003878534,
0.534732163,
-0.3629517257,
-0.063011311,
0.0363941975,
1.0159611702,
-0.0848066583,
0.0649352819,
0.324305594,
0.395280689,
0.4600461125,
0.354924649,
0.6232278943,
-0.5853321552,
0.7304314971,
-0.5688619614,
-0.1787032038,
0.0249422044,
-0.7233405113,
-1.0190718174,
-0.6603605747,
-0.7966020107,
-0.2822254896,
0.2864045799,
0.8394259214,
0.6079233289,
-0.9719842672,
0.4030697346,
-0.1484783888,
0.0614540428,
-0.1696344167,
-0.2623487711,
0.3131187856,
-0.2578827441,
-0.7038564682,
0.3582681119,
0.0972587913,
0.3101772666,
-0.1937204897,
-0.0758819953,
-0.4456695914,
0.1921281666,
0.5654582381,
0.2294040024,
-0.5477709174,
-0.3720204532,
-0.5613407493,
0.1074701175,
0.0072491597,
0.5412435532,
-1.1387366056,
0.8030884266,
0.4731840789,
0.4170527458,
0.3691011667,
0.1637870073,
0.6943563223,
-1.0068918467,
0.095774129,
-0.0341425277,
0.1505931318,
0.6008574367,
-0.3878802657,
0.5515363216,
0.3197879493,
-0.1168083102,
-0.9653053284,
0.2591142058,
-0.9416190982,
-0.4009462595,
0.8659242988,
-0.4088892341,
0.1625455022,
-0.5402979255,
-0.0831027105,
0.5287332535,
-0.5229127407,
0.8955250978,
0.2365032285,
-0.044616431,
-0.0628795922,
0.0456117839,
0.3410062492,
0.5983077288,
-0.9035261869,
-0.0198164508,
0.6140141487,
0.1653007865,
0.2814379632,
0.223947823,
0.1200757772,
0.2002094686,
0.1638469696,
-0.0605462864,
-0.1718841642,
-0.0097976569,
-0.2116186768,
0.227883637,
-0.1511699557,
-0.2283345014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13534v1 | How Language Model Hallucinations Can Snowball | 2023-05-22T23:14:28 | 2023-05-22T23:14:28 | Muru Zhang, Ofir Press, William Merrill, Alisa Liu, Noah A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL | A major risk of using language models in practical applications is their
tendency to hallucinate incorrect statements. Hallucinations are often
attributed to knowledge gaps in LMs, but we hypothesize that in some cases,
when justifying previously generated hallucinations, LMs output false claims
that they can separately recognize as incorrect. We construct three
question-answering datasets where ChatGPT and GPT-4 often state an incorrect
answer and offer an explanation with at least one incorrect claim. Crucially,
we find that ChatGPT and GPT-4 can identify 67% and 87% of their own mistakes,
respectively. We refer to this phenomenon as hallucination snowballing: an LM
over-commits to early mistakes, leading to more mistakes that it otherwise
would not make. | [
-0.0841603503,
-0.9690724611,
0.7175661325,
0.0687109083,
0.1326321959,
-0.1201237366,
0.1039330587,
-0.5253013968,
-0.1787963361,
0.6348291039,
-0.6059868932,
-0.2433650494,
-0.6171578169,
-0.1664011478,
-0.7306204438,
0.9256696701,
-0.0230509434,
-0.0870169401,
-0.144672662,
0.0717259943,
-0.7746257782,
-0.9686413407,
-0.4698450565,
-0.3052237332,
0.3687478304,
0.2262340933,
1.1260381937,
0.2919229865,
0.5563457608,
0.2292339653,
0.1414552033,
-0.1287388206,
-0.4583561122,
0.0499471165,
0.0758801252,
-0.6666950583,
-0.2874481678,
-0.1073903292,
0.2392698377,
0.7294130325,
-0.6568707824,
-0.2616840601,
-0.0620999262,
0.6193625927,
-0.3787634373,
0.1847889125,
-0.9886775613,
0.3027717173,
-0.3167245686,
-0.1360040456,
-0.4208156765,
-0.3247658312,
0.2137242854,
-0.267239511,
0.6784763932,
-0.0080227181,
0.9578288794,
0.3790074885,
0.108207278,
-0.7789087892,
-0.8790166378,
0.5408238173,
-0.9021815658,
0.2779106498,
0.6654065847,
0.5019133687,
-0.0525050238,
-0.3804312646,
-0.4825442433,
-0.2617687881,
-0.1922888905,
-0.1696961671,
-0.0870733187,
0.1429270059,
0.5043231845,
0.2021690607,
-0.8457027078,
-0.0413554236,
-0.4917549491,
-0.4070339203,
0.3816190958,
0.4161614478,
0.5124376416,
-0.0526251607,
0.0308436304,
-0.0200278368,
-0.7058864236,
-0.3998052478,
0.4746368825,
0.4231530726,
0.2115208805,
0.6389284134,
0.3493473232,
0.7060959339,
-0.0955635533,
0.0247214865,
0.2058742791,
-0.1450543553,
-0.3748596311,
0.3865585625,
0.5608711243,
0.3460160494,
0.5167677999,
-0.4519920051,
-0.2192356586,
0.1998030692,
0.4668853283,
-0.6428118348,
-0.3840663731,
0.4088580906,
-0.1290190667,
-0.2783730626,
0.0545908995,
-0.8492043018,
-0.8314988613,
0.1240456477,
0.491671592,
-0.4531409144,
-0.3128439784,
0.4992367923,
-0.1093110144,
0.0641644448,
0.3502598703,
-0.7832690477,
0.6369473338,
0.5339407921,
0.8472365141,
-0.086587593,
-0.5980978012,
-0.2663253546,
-0.1475752741,
-0.632181406,
0.8015946746,
-0.1313055009,
-0.1747383326,
0.2010226399,
-0.0427163765,
-0.2578975558,
-0.8731640577,
0.2414505482,
-0.3398849666,
0.3880051076,
-0.2200624496,
-0.6289811134,
-0.3413306475,
0.1309619397,
-0.5985996723,
0.7991061211,
0.0258454345,
-0.8265814185,
0.1232222617,
-0.2610159814,
-0.2238098085,
-0.0298114549,
-0.3405883014,
-0.4968511462,
0.1396445781,
-0.1624636203,
0.4735831916,
-0.1007639021,
0.4133819938,
-0.0717857778,
-0.4173875153,
0.5803621411,
-0.3192054629,
0.6876305938,
0.1330135316,
-0.6060195565,
-0.1681351066,
-0.6091521978,
-0.1984701902,
0.3630002141,
-0.0788151473,
-0.1560129821,
0.1708201319,
-0.3387964368,
0.2558971345,
-0.0689304918,
-0.1609245688,
0.0262681525,
-0.3779592812,
0.2453486472,
0.5519038439,
-0.0535597242,
0.19899261,
-0.7035893202,
0.514193356,
0.5670110583,
-0.0164069794,
-0.0852120444,
-0.6691621542,
-0.7527671456,
0.5693795681,
-0.0290447157,
0.8444641232,
-0.650244832,
-0.0442695692,
0.0958918557,
-0.4722925723,
-0.5526688695,
0.1558061838,
0.138910234,
0.3321192861,
0.2326085716,
0.014842418,
-0.5205854774,
-0.7557789087,
-0.4360424876,
-0.5217211843,
0.2624188364,
0.2896466553,
0.4547012448,
-0.2512104511,
0.7664724588,
-0.4191854894,
-0.3485601842,
-0.2310536802,
0.2941991389,
0.2474074811,
0.3345274925,
0.5326870084,
-0.6501472592,
-0.1258039176,
-0.3437692225,
-0.8150493503,
-0.145320788,
-0.3949810863,
0.2642550766,
0.4587915838,
0.2399673909,
-0.901740551,
0.4359800518,
0.6759045124,
-0.4842988849,
0.7162727714,
-0.0492392406,
0.0812427849,
-0.9386467338,
-0.4253819585,
-0.1389422119,
0.0485159829,
-0.8078320026,
-0.2094541043,
-0.1081113294,
0.1334688812,
-0.4517122209,
0.1050563678,
-0.3837608695,
-0.0254568979,
-0.1416428536,
0.3648903072,
-0.2312783003,
0.2033670098,
-0.0573839694,
0.4444467723,
0.8383470774,
-0.565410614,
0.3448527455,
-0.0571305081,
-0.5391697288,
-0.0244708601,
-0.4727328122,
0.2111427933,
-0.3028530478,
-0.2151602209,
-0.8816716671,
-0.3365440965,
0.4198035598,
-0.3713223636,
0.0013522352,
-0.0527913012,
-0.6884347796,
-0.2010345459,
-0.0364839546,
0.2613368332,
0.6372392774,
-0.2640751898,
0.2357078046,
0.3826399744,
-0.0229384396,
-0.661914587,
-0.9932029247,
0.0813471749,
-0.2684302032,
-0.4838657975,
0.1220285445,
-0.2725561857,
-0.6078542471,
0.0356547162,
0.0672745332,
-0.1478275657,
0.1053381562,
0.5046417117,
0.0155697251,
-0.3223673403,
0.2147251666,
-0.5473065972,
0.1422321498,
0.2444232106,
0.3033705354,
0.8509507775,
-0.2368120849,
-0.6810264587,
-0.257609874,
0.1746837795,
0.5373786092,
0.5612763762,
0.8225477934,
0.2312099785,
-0.6975278854,
-0.1182841286,
-0.7114428282,
-0.4816286862,
-0.3670192957,
0.4218633175,
-0.4286596775,
-0.5759556293,
0.7504606247,
0.3846946359,
0.1172918603,
0.3061209321,
0.4559994936,
-0.046218317,
1.3261022568,
0.3832375705,
0.0193622783,
0.0793357417,
-0.0658390522,
0.3347745538,
-0.201727733,
-0.2386637628,
-0.599922061,
0.1881205738,
-0.6732857823,
-0.4592838883,
-0.1099621803,
0.0745889172,
-0.0648165047,
0.1958025098,
-0.3773368597,
0.5886084437,
0.3524465561,
-0.140329361,
0.2276051342,
-0.0771432742,
0.0962061882,
-0.3107324541,
-0.9054096341,
-0.5506854057,
0.691362977,
0.4791719615,
0.9963951111,
0.1784763485,
0.6478030086,
0.1667312384,
0.190369457,
-0.7001673579,
0.4843604267,
0.3018338084,
-0.9218312502,
-0.4301667213,
-0.466899842,
-0.7683255672,
0.2057189494,
-0.017834207,
-0.8644275069,
0.0269417949,
0.2278972119,
-0.2936551273,
0.4694912136,
-0.6471630335,
0.8744617701,
-0.1931311488,
0.1257356107,
0.0270046238,
-0.4576765299,
0.666693151,
-0.2116277814,
0.5643475056,
-0.2968477905,
0.4467321634,
0.7888637781,
-0.2317030579,
1.1805279255,
-0.2024680674,
-0.2808846235,
0.4986740947,
0.5200150609,
0.5271257758,
-0.2107598931,
-0.0571164265,
0.3202423751,
0.0647770017,
-0.1920823008,
-0.7270012498,
0.4752914906,
-0.8901814222,
-0.886508882,
-0.7871563435,
-0.5398469567,
0.0215586126,
-0.1480049193,
0.4668835402,
0.2956170738,
-0.208812654,
-0.1757563055,
0.5567496419,
-0.2639181614,
0.3949956894,
0.4793908596,
-0.6614733338,
-0.0324509107,
0.833578229,
0.4114791453,
0.3787566721,
-0.2447189838,
0.1841137707,
0.0075705098,
-0.7749578953,
-0.2169776261,
0.4768295586,
-0.9652462602,
-0.1049706414,
-0.7340795994,
-0.6231044531,
-0.4985347986,
0.0896780863,
-0.4213655293,
-0.3104291558,
-0.1964102834,
-0.2422779202,
0.0981616974,
0.8635175228,
-0.0318237431,
0.2723104954,
-0.7938338518,
0.1545448899,
0.4051336348,
0.177142188,
-0.0726793706,
-0.6086120605,
-0.226812914,
0.1488868445,
-0.2796302736,
-1.3249590397,
0.4529539347,
0.0019950594,
0.4945446849,
0.3760025501,
-0.1220828369,
0.832574904,
-0.6761847734,
1.1444762945,
0.1572774798,
-0.8910745382,
0.4923355579,
-0.0609478801,
0.2378056794,
0.154194206,
0.4102191627,
-0.8584327698,
-0.8709869981,
-1.0952187777,
-0.4536194801,
0.7660028338,
0.2596362829,
0.2240192145,
-0.1441703737,
0.3314085305,
0.3368866444,
0.0954922512,
-0.978309691,
-0.3348314762,
-0.3322160542,
0.0634870604,
-0.2468901277,
-0.5383934379,
-0.2617870569,
-0.0561953299,
0.6664226055,
0.0432624854,
0.29059425,
0.0162510537,
-0.3566215634,
-0.4372051954,
0.2380104214,
0.8867946863,
1.0295778513,
-0.2842697501,
0.6121883988,
0.3380310535,
-0.30006212,
0.0630267337,
-0.0875262693,
0.0200887918,
0.385296315,
0.4442566931,
0.9026670456,
0.0772202089,
-0.7728719711,
0.4986179769,
-0.1087013781,
-0.3027018011,
-0.5261349678,
0.1367835999,
0.1562929899,
0.1330574006,
0.2663794458,
0.1036414355,
0.1330630928,
-0.8720932603,
0.1538995802,
0.2492090762,
-0.4697028399,
-0.5379405022,
0.5527874231,
-0.3781204522,
-0.616132915,
0.7159085274,
0.0448036902,
-0.6132932901,
0.4993882477,
0.7830162048,
0.8670481443,
-0.5197408199,
0.4951620996,
0.159129411,
0.5592750907,
-0.3787718117,
0.2652027309,
0.5295713544,
-1.2508504391,
-0.312700808,
-0.35592857,
-0.4502132833,
0.4666385651,
-0.4839881659,
0.2691946328,
-0.1405781358,
-0.2588508725,
-0.100239411,
-0.5024715066,
-0.4672906399,
0.0942111239,
0.3593929708,
0.5257353783,
-1.0355576277,
0.5640868545,
0.4223245978,
-0.3642490208,
-0.6801711917,
0.0708852038,
0.1161763892,
-0.8877045512,
0.736094594,
0.1177656353,
0.0579782538,
-0.0921005458,
-0.4824021757,
-0.6104709506,
0.6964176893,
0.3049038351,
-0.6583846807,
-0.3174980283,
0.6064558029,
0.4428108335,
-0.4039079845,
0.1730745733,
0.6634420156,
0.2770853043,
0.1941816956,
-1.0105880499,
0.1719164848,
0.2628900707,
-0.0881786346,
0.2499562502,
-0.277729094,
0.9514003396,
-0.5801891088,
-0.429890573,
-0.2252584845,
0.0966343135,
0.4249064922,
0.3651805222,
0.4972601831,
0.5074880719,
0.8121055961,
-0.2175839394,
0.9604225159,
-0.173450008,
0.3088618815,
1.0135103464,
-0.2868552208,
0.6929302812,
0.5161496401,
0.0039138277,
0.3913877606,
0.7024037242,
0.0941471756,
0.5830837488,
0.3848737776,
-0.0396767482,
-0.1641187519,
0.3739622831,
-0.3982772827,
0.144043088,
0.712315917,
-0.2563816309,
-0.2989589274,
0.1652968973,
0.2190550715,
-0.3055116534,
0.0674370602,
0.9203088284,
0.1927848607,
-0.7460377812,
0.7336633205,
-0.2746880651,
0.2954957783,
-0.2155624777,
-0.2367073745,
-0.2505835295,
0.1252311766,
-0.2572993636,
-0.7756732106,
0.5663050413,
-0.1646896303,
0.0072846278,
-0.1647423953,
0.7778045535,
-0.4555085599,
-0.2557061315,
0.1736587286,
0.8381651044,
0.7781493068,
-0.2472520173,
-0.9293242693,
0.1295824796,
0.029944649,
-0.129541859,
0.2308090627,
0.5848033428,
0.123983413,
0.7586954236,
0.1991659105,
0.4217724502,
0.4639980495,
0.3087822199,
0.5009006858,
-0.9052581191,
-0.1749031246,
-1.2513228655,
0.5108759999,
0.0417064726,
-0.0902809724,
0.7516389489,
0.4316846132,
0.6298038363,
-0.1590345502,
0.9430555105,
0.0763626695,
0.4955910742,
-0.6926934123,
0.633621335,
-0.2197075039,
0.5057622194,
-0.3025518656,
-1.0145124197,
-0.3660324514,
0.7784312367,
-0.3347159624,
0.0535370633,
1.1237062216,
1.0070374012,
0.2323070168,
0.1480088383,
0.8560323715,
0.626681447,
0.2649342716,
0.5714808106,
1.2351024151,
-0.5337387323,
0.6610241532,
-0.3768813312,
0.1037773862,
-0.479305774,
-0.716303587,
-1.1234945059,
-0.839538753,
-0.7186697721,
-0.8148602247,
0.1296087801,
0.4632908106,
0.5491470098,
-0.9766898751,
-0.3294897377,
-0.2800225914,
0.2081611902,
-0.1881371886,
-0.3375622034,
0.2088468224,
-0.5510681868,
-0.5240000486,
0.0715521127,
0.0555552579,
0.5349146128,
-0.3167873621,
-0.0948696062,
0.2272642553,
0.186567381,
0.3060765564,
0.0419430658,
-0.9622506499,
-0.4339000583,
-0.0189224388,
-0.2000180036,
0.2547174692,
0.886916697,
-0.581294179,
0.2090256661,
0.2444180101,
0.3649963737,
0.3626210392,
-0.2588522136,
0.5466268659,
-0.4411205947,
0.0152504677,
0.3994271457,
0.2931507528,
0.4990741014,
-0.4467100203,
0.4227502346,
0.393381685,
-0.6811694503,
-1.1290268898,
0.1579877287,
-0.66729182,
-0.4527543485,
1.1179176569,
0.0757829174,
-0.0233553015,
-0.17671974,
-0.2494219989,
0.1274605691,
0.0009071987,
1.340793252,
1.3570376635,
-0.2937733531,
-0.4330167472,
-1.2092235088,
1.0334661007,
0.3722441792,
-0.8270183206,
0.3183144033,
0.4126667678,
0.3173519373,
0.4657270014,
0.5209638476,
-0.0292512998,
0.2944995463,
0.219818458,
0.0194431394,
0.3725962043,
-0.3046138287,
-0.2652488351,
0.3185247481,
0.34247756,
-0.0636034906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13533v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13533v2 | Open-world Semi-supervised Generalized Relation Discovery Aligned in a Real-world Setting | 2023-05-22T23:12:57 | 2023-11-01T18:36:28 | William Hogan, Jiacheng Li, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Open-world Relation Extraction (OpenRE) has recently garnered significant
attention. However, existing approaches tend to oversimplify the problem by
assuming that all unlabeled texts belong to novel classes, thereby limiting the
practicality of these methods. We argue that the OpenRE setting should be more
aligned with the characteristics of real-world data. Specifically, we propose
two key improvements: (a) unlabeled data should encompass known and novel
classes, including hard-negative instances; and (b) the set of novel classes
should represent long-tail relation types. Furthermore, we observe that popular
relations such as titles and locations can often be implicitly inferred through
specific patterns, while long-tail relations tend to be explicitly expressed in
sentences. Motivated by these insights, we present a novel method called KNoRD
(Known and Novel Relation Discovery), which effectively classifies explicitly
and implicitly expressed relations from known and novel classes within
unlabeled data. Experimental evaluations on several Open-world RE benchmarks
demonstrate that KNoRD consistently outperforms other existing methods,
achieving significant performance gains. | [
-0.3103789389,
-0.6743937731,
0.7242203951,
-0.1697200835,
-0.0929305404,
-0.2103136033,
-0.3817655742,
-1.0306164026,
-0.1974544823,
0.3800770044,
-0.2898138463,
-0.7039116621,
-0.1201100498,
-0.0400629677,
-0.0209260415,
0.9488431215,
-0.1895650774,
-0.4069674015,
-0.4861252606,
-0.6181764603,
-0.0722736865,
-0.7180834413,
-0.0594992377,
-0.47758919,
0.7333319783,
0.5130216479,
1.0263727903,
0.536960423,
0.3352396488,
0.1174957678,
-0.0471634269,
0.4620209038,
-0.6042267084,
0.3952206373,
-0.3908289671,
-0.1690444052,
-0.2027374655,
-0.0690588728,
0.3123196363,
0.7857394814,
0.0611166358,
0.1689171195,
-0.2032449692,
0.6900290251,
-0.8816146851,
0.3529852331,
-0.0944825187,
0.1622469574,
-0.2410508096,
0.0440911502,
-0.4058292508,
-0.3566401899,
0.5871327519,
-1.0107227564,
0.5080590844,
0.2296175659,
1.2008084059,
-0.3968501091,
-0.7285057902,
-0.3338408172,
-1.3554773331,
0.7727483511,
-0.4790419936,
0.6715456247,
0.1430765837,
0.6106524467,
-0.4322434962,
-0.6790215969,
-0.2754392922,
-0.1134161353,
-0.451046735,
0.1852143705,
-0.14431867,
-0.0407259241,
0.2897803783,
0.5403987169,
-0.3441784978,
0.1196231395,
-0.117933318,
-0.2407250553,
0.5375543833,
-0.1121861264,
0.2504825294,
-0.0605334714,
-0.4715334177,
0.0164120346,
-0.6973276734,
0.1784580648,
0.4112612307,
0.7680539489,
-0.0101200715,
0.7829545736,
-0.3195137382,
0.7640852928,
-0.4345057607,
-0.1015657336,
0.1136350855,
-0.0904620588,
0.0095259575,
0.045259241,
0.7669517398,
0.5124413371,
0.668497622,
-0.6523364186,
-0.0731059909,
0.0740745068,
-0.024497997,
-0.5682696104,
-0.3978210986,
-0.0741328597,
-0.4048329294,
-0.3687548637,
0.3252651095,
-0.9775152802,
-0.31652987,
-0.4079128802,
0.3381280303,
-0.1841329485,
-0.3911845088,
-0.3241622746,
-0.3050763905,
0.0647576302,
0.1063579321,
-0.574207902,
0.3260671794,
0.5127782822,
0.7993085384,
0.0665847436,
0.1454874575,
-0.4673470855,
0.5366958976,
-0.3783706129,
0.7461512089,
-0.7270109057,
-0.2974471152,
0.2640452385,
-0.0146340244,
0.4814189374,
-0.5239350796,
0.7027420402,
-0.6298944354,
0.5407432318,
-0.3054276109,
-0.3040647805,
0.0700973868,
0.3068813682,
-0.8079763651,
1.2091456652,
0.4813192189,
-0.9532361031,
0.5009795427,
-0.5463106632,
-0.5695670843,
-0.2411186248,
-0.2599627078,
-0.4483484924,
0.0704529211,
0.4373578429,
0.35697034,
-0.2500444353,
0.2770033777,
-0.5057630539,
-0.1534193009,
0.0483504757,
0.2968642712,
0.461671114,
0.031586349,
0.1412889957,
-0.062621586,
-1.0163000822,
-0.0336527936,
0.1780482531,
0.0893356055,
-1.4288549423,
-0.133619383,
-0.3412790895,
0.1319165826,
-0.0014618516,
-1.0350573063,
0.3951613307,
-0.5806695223,
0.2562766075,
0.6147917509,
0.4783864915,
0.8827147484,
-0.032726001,
0.3677331209,
0.0552289039,
0.1239278987,
0.0809185728,
-0.2699479163,
-0.4310981035,
-0.1151941791,
0.610652864,
0.281142205,
-0.5164831877,
0.2809357643,
-0.3135538697,
-0.3658203781,
-0.4540311992,
-0.3000740409,
0.5427241325,
0.8652066588,
0.4800784886,
0.1322925389,
-0.643268764,
-1.1695346832,
-0.5008306503,
0.0782196298,
-0.0106070554,
0.6090490222,
0.1167732403,
-0.0649777427,
1.3852802515,
-0.9502328634,
-0.5965005159,
0.1554492563,
0.1311500221,
0.1660857648,
0.1988816708,
0.3988324404,
-1.0627408028,
-0.5663728118,
0.4022491574,
-1.0531436205,
0.1367430836,
0.2274016738,
-0.5210230947,
0.0331879705,
0.3513344824,
-0.2632082403,
0.6161391139,
0.0660272241,
0.073872827,
0.2914470434,
-0.2674970627,
-0.0782182962,
-0.8395572305,
0.0994183868,
0.3251504898,
-0.1683360338,
-0.6588581204,
0.1154015362,
0.2798723578,
-0.0591989793,
-0.2785544991,
0.6790723801,
-0.7765995264,
-0.1246683523,
0.2999248803,
0.2970183194,
-0.185133338,
0.3700560629,
0.1439473331,
0.5228073001,
0.3262172043,
-0.874088645,
0.0471631736,
0.5869463086,
-0.4119304121,
0.3833749592,
-0.3067536354,
0.0623104386,
-0.1952574849,
0.2293681502,
-0.8506376743,
-0.2639288306,
0.1277665347,
-0.4981701374,
0.2127971202,
-0.5861161947,
-0.4109398425,
-0.3426272869,
-0.1996080726,
0.4237989187,
0.4696997702,
-0.9666942358,
0.6378291845,
0.3285266459,
0.1118453294,
-0.7906321287,
-0.3850509524,
-0.2093598694,
-0.1446670294,
-0.5428192616,
0.4675053656,
0.5227639079,
-0.3733153045,
0.2603763938,
-0.5488039255,
-0.2542081773,
-0.2849444449,
0.466874212,
0.2832987905,
0.0169372261,
0.2220404148,
-0.0438051932,
-0.2741503417,
-0.0485279933,
-0.0970913768,
0.2370802611,
0.3080916703,
0.2312054336,
0.0281998776,
0.2526843846,
0.3150606453,
-0.2622900009,
0.4728818834,
0.1888768226,
-0.4588792622,
-0.3558817506,
-0.0727512017,
0.051937364,
-0.4450767636,
0.0278580878,
-0.469450891,
-0.9067488313,
0.6455801129,
-0.4057159424,
0.3674695492,
0.315358609,
-0.1009325534,
-0.1766717583,
0.9409412146,
1.0081244707,
-0.0421215743,
0.0980463549,
-0.3469119072,
0.8432914615,
-0.933539629,
-0.6016975641,
-0.5430689454,
-0.4781439304,
-0.5991263986,
0.1160857454,
0.4463943839,
0.197968632,
-0.1223854497,
0.4677800536,
-0.4834303558,
0.4434813559,
0.5082317591,
0.057832703,
0.586004436,
0.0069976524,
-0.3840740025,
-0.4264273345,
-0.5767766833,
-0.4308901131,
1.2214020491,
-0.038771756,
0.8541070819,
0.2075235695,
0.9654240012,
0.2912519276,
0.6188322306,
-0.7240260243,
0.4784545898,
-0.1814864874,
-0.6272481084,
-0.2603348494,
-0.6423791051,
-1.3618444204,
0.1144384518,
-0.2273020744,
-0.7005799413,
0.3351781964,
0.215874508,
-0.1585684121,
0.2480534315,
-0.4573335648,
0.5502194762,
-0.0134301959,
-0.3800355792,
0.3819106221,
-0.8794944286,
0.7915309072,
0.104925707,
0.4228512645,
-0.0606818832,
-0.0478963628,
0.6587260962,
-0.4207599163,
0.4277665317,
-0.443244487,
-0.3275349736,
0.0949460045,
0.1814327985,
0.5379790068,
0.0763731226,
0.0401120633,
-0.135239929,
-0.0785073787,
-0.1438878477,
-0.9565689564,
0.989312768,
-0.6940363646,
0.0641727298,
-0.6363828182,
-0.7511556745,
-0.5489958525,
0.3648725152,
0.2180382311,
0.7886577845,
-0.5888668299,
-0.1148020253,
0.5670549273,
-0.0298477542,
0.1310369372,
0.6602571011,
-0.5631030202,
-0.5125544071,
0.7458420396,
0.2786732316,
0.2620486617,
0.5997697711,
0.3261162043,
-0.6201505661,
-0.0926669911,
-0.1758242846,
0.3120388091,
-0.4530415833,
-0.380222559,
-0.6889160275,
-0.0203920305,
-0.5322629213,
-0.0177943297,
-0.0281951483,
-0.6019803882,
-0.0186331272,
-0.0871908367,
0.3763911426,
0.5908039212,
-0.0244413167,
0.1764016598,
-0.8849955797,
0.7823091745,
0.1046836972,
0.2632605433,
0.1784861833,
-0.1599407345,
-0.1099139079,
0.0837608203,
-0.0220921934,
-0.6372379065,
0.2364387214,
0.2561227083,
0.5998749733,
0.5065437555,
0.8493593931,
0.8747329116,
-0.3650839925,
0.3696229756,
0.0714694858,
-0.2153288126,
0.637496829,
-0.3704183996,
-0.0493569747,
0.5586262345,
0.8735116124,
-0.4431326985,
-0.337045908,
-1.1076053381,
-1.0031055212,
0.5518725514,
0.2551856637,
-0.2638089061,
-0.0000756644,
0.4885682762,
0.2614536583,
0.1723684222,
-0.602579236,
-0.3516985774,
0.4515264332,
-0.2211923152,
0.0022597944,
-0.1397543997,
-0.3294944763,
-0.2009064853,
0.5554714799,
0.1757302433,
0.2985180318,
0.456048578,
-0.1329997629,
-0.3349532783,
0.3536734581,
0.0965453684,
0.8001239896,
-0.5415107012,
0.2930753827,
-0.2941393554,
-0.1630120724,
0.3057729602,
0.1793333292,
-0.4428289831,
0.2006874084,
0.3965789676,
0.2156360149,
0.4788420498,
-0.4832727611,
0.5355803967,
0.1538510472,
-0.4381728172,
-0.2743856907,
0.0468972176,
-0.1887608021,
0.2378034294,
0.2962528467,
0.0530820973,
-0.0094696218,
-0.9203456044,
0.3173758984,
0.346128732,
-0.4085846543,
-0.3756098449,
0.3741123378,
0.1412136257,
-0.3102232814,
0.7544538975,
-0.1393786222,
-0.611019671,
0.2258389741,
0.6108737588,
0.4273516536,
0.0892144069,
0.0897268727,
0.5319336653,
0.0376624763,
-0.1776257306,
0.2401649505,
-0.2558173239,
-0.7794830203,
-0.296721518,
-0.4201815128,
-0.4430092573,
0.225223273,
-1.2213308811,
0.2749229074,
-0.3087488115,
-0.0500047691,
0.0909952894,
-0.0066850074,
-0.4939627945,
0.1165254116,
-0.4037671089,
0.797070086,
-1.0235739946,
0.7137715816,
0.7914094329,
-0.1803185791,
-0.592900455,
0.0058027264,
-0.1562615186,
-0.5986516476,
0.5698719025,
0.1813296229,
0.1101237163,
0.0907181054,
-0.4741494656,
-0.6768647432,
0.9554611444,
0.0092625841,
-0.7642447948,
-0.2723168433,
-0.0548475683,
0.4769396782,
-0.2728820741,
-0.1401471496,
0.4546531439,
0.5024042726,
0.0419597887,
-0.5917848945,
-0.0889891759,
0.0640072301,
-0.1774172485,
1.2473856211,
-0.3095018268,
0.2278004289,
-0.4844878316,
-0.5453520417,
0.1810043901,
1.0306081772,
0.0663192421,
0.7413700223,
0.5086327791,
0.8815473914,
0.8676536679,
-0.2017410994,
0.7042511106,
0.317746073,
0.3149704933,
1.5532286167,
-0.5917547941,
0.7422705889,
0.3437254131,
-0.3302842975,
0.6264984012,
0.5057693124,
0.0479727723,
0.9172109962,
0.0831456333,
-0.1893009692,
-0.2061776519,
-0.1222005337,
-0.4497274458,
0.1002904847,
0.1097339541,
-0.3497509956,
-0.6509537101,
0.1867811829,
0.0323296301,
0.4453090429,
-0.0878364593,
0.7070961595,
-0.0043606916,
-0.5247849226,
0.2801302969,
-0.2362512052,
0.4418882132,
-0.6543543339,
-0.2222878337,
-0.0275442842,
0.4151502848,
-0.3170819283,
-0.7622902989,
-0.0979057476,
-0.1274653226,
-0.3635692894,
0.1475701183,
1.0237845182,
-0.4522480071,
-0.3279066384,
0.3835552931,
0.5569104552,
0.0334798284,
-0.0155689325,
-0.0340658315,
-0.2798066437,
0.0924885273,
0.0999617204,
0.559186697,
0.8524259329,
-0.4753032625,
0.4248067737,
0.8633404374,
-0.0521238409,
-0.1712313592,
0.1561638713,
0.9686780572,
-0.8039233685,
-0.3819984794,
-0.4490259886,
0.361308217,
-0.4861061573,
-0.4149208963,
0.8729397058,
0.9501392245,
0.9263070822,
0.2131997943,
0.8619242311,
-0.2053083777,
0.9824585319,
-0.17593503,
-0.0135159595,
-0.3390082419,
-0.0322627984,
-0.2828748226,
-1.2278798819,
-0.5783448219,
0.4760539532,
-0.2479398698,
-0.2360801697,
0.5917593241,
0.5842194557,
-0.5132513642,
0.1969562471,
0.0846833363,
0.0443264358,
0.6194825768,
0.3598531783,
0.9921865463,
-0.3910802603,
0.696647346,
-0.7130972147,
-0.4162021875,
0.0680260509,
-0.9662854075,
-0.8458075523,
-0.4740998149,
-0.2341921777,
-0.2525881231,
0.1906244904,
0.5348416567,
0.3933303654,
-0.4478047788,
0.0140458662,
-0.05826924,
-0.1771092713,
-0.3696932197,
-0.3106154203,
0.349891454,
-0.0339945592,
-0.3902150989,
0.4303818345,
0.0929284394,
0.1211235374,
-0.0340483785,
-0.1293412298,
-0.3658383787,
-0.3525654674,
0.6568012238,
0.6708952188,
-0.4520267546,
-0.4552146792,
0.0083235651,
0.2393628061,
0.0013924572,
1.1169937849,
-0.9584026933,
0.5025689602,
0.3482007682,
0.183764264,
0.5801581144,
0.4702704549,
0.7898033857,
-1.0374763012,
0.0330906101,
0.6096288562,
0.021870587,
0.1242742911,
-0.3551693559,
0.9863818288,
0.0914971009,
-0.7175236344,
-1.1823115349,
0.2178232819,
-1.1426906586,
-0.1899918765,
0.9251173735,
-0.0799579769,
-0.0737973079,
-0.3793329895,
-0.0969656855,
0.2323474139,
-0.4734350145,
0.3756232858,
0.4896374941,
-0.4589568973,
0.2641984224,
-0.6344531178,
0.2950966358,
-0.1761762798,
-0.5444847345,
0.4694309831,
0.6729255915,
0.0387802534,
0.2920411229,
0.2544023395,
-0.3071408272,
-0.0687270015,
-0.5727398992,
-0.0824984014,
-0.4153051972,
-0.6230478883,
0.3466738164,
0.1346577257,
-0.1530255526,
-0.2219990343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13530v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13530v1 | The Grammar and Syntax Based Corpus Analysis Tool For The Ukrainian Language | 2023-05-22T22:52:47 | 2023-05-22T22:52:47 | Daria Stetsenko, Inez Okulska | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper provides an overview of a text mining tool the StyloMetrix
developed initially for the Polish language and further extended for English
and recently for Ukrainian. The StyloMetrix is built upon various metrics
crafted manually by computational linguists and researchers from literary
studies to analyze grammatical, stylistic, and syntactic patterns. The idea of
constructing the statistical evaluation of syntactic and grammar features is
straightforward and familiar for the languages like English, Spanish, German,
and others; it is yet to be developed for low-resource languages like
Ukrainian. We describe the StyloMetrix pipeline and provide some experiments
with this tool for the text classification task. We also describe our package's
main limitations and the metrics' evaluation procedure. | [
0.085887149,
-0.8415197134,
0.6230445504,
0.2211564183,
-0.3689951301,
0.1755068898,
-0.0580293871,
-0.3908172846,
0.7548191547,
0.4624067545,
-0.5149716139,
-1.1102650166,
-0.366907239,
0.2088029981,
-0.4647977352,
0.883498311,
-0.0015941266,
0.4091984034,
-0.2185194045,
0.0549721271,
-0.3753461242,
-0.7092953324,
-0.2496068925,
0.3050839305,
0.2905147076,
0.5897579193,
0.6386612058,
0.902123034,
0.6206845045,
0.418897301,
-0.0029121586,
-0.2969691157,
-0.1449243575,
0.2062962949,
-0.2269830704,
-0.7041694522,
-0.2292752415,
-0.5021737218,
0.6721660495,
0.8779819012,
-0.2587808073,
0.4618757367,
-0.1398781091,
0.5025794506,
-0.3164540529,
0.1569236964,
-0.1144997552,
0.3289598227,
-0.7954644561,
0.0800566524,
-0.2690869272,
-0.5003512502,
-0.1813761294,
-0.344832927,
0.1450764388,
-0.1764447689,
0.7648229599,
0.1637241393,
-0.3791115582,
-0.6436828971,
-0.3552739322,
0.7693461776,
-0.2540334165,
0.6516034007,
0.0849477723,
0.2951271534,
-0.0884175375,
-0.9533962607,
-0.1862194389,
-0.3131749034,
-0.2530489564,
0.1176430136,
-0.3306081593,
0.0106618712,
-0.0942457393,
0.4547398686,
-0.7203814983,
0.152232185,
-0.6437787414,
-0.5160998702,
0.2267309278,
0.2538450658,
0.4978449941,
-0.7634344101,
-0.2494055182,
0.1356714815,
-0.1787234396,
0.3510018587,
0.7541220784,
0.2541441619,
-0.0985866413,
0.6184707284,
0.0742492825,
0.4945272505,
-0.35579741,
0.0581094287,
0.2235182822,
-0.6838960052,
-0.3007221818,
-0.0381936505,
0.9154093266,
0.2730291188,
-0.0037127689,
-0.1695223153,
0.1569929123,
0.657469511,
0.2869302928,
-0.4678811729,
-0.3016860187,
-0.0026024778,
-0.7194766402,
-0.6028856039,
0.1645119339,
-1.3818144798,
0.0179308355,
0.0026475249,
-0.039933715,
-0.4006617367,
-0.3715545237,
0.0246313717,
-0.2385511547,
-0.3868919909,
-0.0244627837,
-0.9503291845,
0.5600386858,
0.6553454399,
0.9172676206,
-0.130939126,
-0.3957192004,
-0.6683961153,
-0.6200050116,
-0.6191768646,
0.8620584607,
-0.6539471149,
-0.3565899432,
0.3440165222,
0.1754974127,
0.0308083706,
-0.4121038616,
0.6010189652,
-0.0733547881,
0.2195120454,
-0.0230855793,
-0.3681505322,
-0.0464930087,
-0.1108610928,
-0.7578705549,
1.4817690849,
0.577342093,
-0.8181798458,
0.5173975229,
-0.3739265501,
-0.1803559661,
0.1402844936,
-0.1203228086,
-0.1032739058,
0.2218617648,
-0.4490352571,
0.2184899449,
-0.1171936169,
0.2501202822,
-0.0732707009,
-0.3666742742,
0.0511998944,
0.4942782223,
0.9804923534,
0.3163721859,
-0.1682643145,
0.6754829288,
-0.8925765157,
0.1074610651,
-0.3447652161,
-0.5330170989,
-0.3915761113,
-0.070745647,
0.5713617802,
0.2879818678,
0.3337710202,
-0.6167122126,
0.2473642081,
-0.8052234054,
0.4008583128,
0.466352582,
-0.2567059696,
0.7414783239,
-0.0126978476,
1.01851964,
-0.2009906918,
0.0931542143,
0.0779967979,
-0.3379953504,
-1.0390862226,
-0.3048825562,
0.5502245426,
0.7916173935,
-0.860293448,
0.5675417781,
-0.270095259,
-1.0507386923,
-0.6485956311,
0.4104372859,
0.5347889066,
-0.0262892898,
0.140111208,
-0.2212889493,
-1.134934783,
-1.2468117476,
-0.1871517152,
-0.3867892325,
0.0251115728,
-0.1677458733,
0.5846116543,
-0.0539678447,
0.720944643,
-0.1867492795,
-0.0681188256,
-0.4929954708,
-0.0701669231,
0.4277022779,
0.2061568201,
0.8001579642,
-0.2828889787,
-0.5624888539,
0.0594684333,
-0.6348814964,
-0.4509147108,
0.4518486857,
-0.2895787358,
0.3549769521,
0.79181844,
-0.6451786757,
0.3312867582,
0.4968535006,
-0.8985925317,
0.8179505467,
0.1300775558,
-0.02292349,
-1.1720945835,
0.3690858483,
-0.1285399497,
-0.3005677164,
-0.8258671761,
0.1859372556,
0.1788866073,
-0.0812751874,
-0.4681690037,
0.4626956284,
0.0585814528,
-0.1819533855,
0.2011276931,
-0.1419313997,
-0.2961174548,
0.235731855,
-0.0244255364,
0.5617666245,
0.4301115572,
-0.3274575472,
0.393511802,
0.1678916067,
-0.5540489554,
0.3105960786,
-0.1860687435,
-0.0099556325,
-0.0497474894,
-0.5444284678,
-0.890348196,
0.0509039387,
0.3097036183,
-0.4501930177,
-0.1277462244,
-0.2722901702,
-0.6032287478,
-0.0900206864,
-0.5486469269,
-0.2366850227,
0.3218022585,
-0.2206545621,
0.5378413796,
0.3437686265,
-0.5765377879,
-0.6304669976,
-0.4023969173,
0.2380732,
-0.5232099891,
-0.8097618222,
0.1440726221,
0.0030182644,
-0.7945804,
0.029173661,
0.1284485608,
-0.1289456934,
0.1806401461,
0.3157047629,
0.5015859604,
-0.2441394776,
0.4692623317,
-0.2004264593,
-0.1021555662,
0.0348127969,
-0.2879216969,
0.7015101314,
-0.0737429857,
0.3114770949,
-0.1706454903,
0.4719389379,
0.5427284241,
0.079844445,
0.2890219092,
0.532074213,
-0.147580713,
-0.4808107018,
-0.148374632,
-0.0044396096,
-0.3712007701,
0.4176175296,
-0.4722511768,
-0.6539340615,
0.5936947465,
0.3776241839,
-0.1700757146,
0.5429640412,
0.5739290118,
0.1203450188,
0.4215793312,
1.0418432951,
-0.1008177772,
0.5749713182,
0.0754558817,
-0.1340306997,
-0.1142248958,
0.0469157845,
-0.7974947095,
-0.3037871718,
-0.5511571765,
-0.1698866785,
-0.0918603241,
0.194437027,
0.1273099929,
0.6405982375,
-0.4842435718,
0.1483052671,
0.6454341412,
-0.4350270331,
0.277209729,
0.0947582349,
-0.6813057065,
-0.4862708747,
-0.6416923404,
-0.8649024963,
0.8931444883,
0.3318111598,
0.4342382252,
0.3257541358,
0.5485662222,
0.2113809139,
0.0538675226,
-1.0313494205,
0.6364944577,
-0.3838770986,
-0.5548128486,
-0.0850178376,
-0.2843850851,
-0.7695111036,
0.1623072177,
-0.4163892269,
-1.0121440887,
0.2308287621,
-0.131493777,
-0.1774987131,
-0.0873261988,
-0.8381790519,
1.3120615482,
-0.0470005348,
-0.3907556236,
0.0043989546,
-0.2938905358,
0.2429036349,
-0.0863231719,
0.27279374,
0.0717240572,
-0.1784930378,
1.1958978176,
-0.5701562762,
0.6852787733,
-0.2287115157,
0.1580347419,
0.1002797708,
0.3603966236,
0.0874549672,
0.0018249626,
-0.1197281033,
0.2719787061,
0.6338754892,
-0.1654717326,
-0.3201445937,
0.5114468336,
-0.3084555864,
-0.1362640113,
-0.7641426325,
-0.1323167235,
0.015758628,
0.2984052896,
0.3511295021,
0.1882032752,
-0.4791005254,
0.1665696055,
-0.2052727491,
-0.3227868676,
0.4337739646,
0.6141679287,
-0.765196383,
-0.5009514093,
0.4348548055,
0.2938754857,
-0.0934389159,
0.2945326865,
0.1948118955,
-0.3062119186,
-0.7059522271,
-0.6468260288,
0.0939772502,
-0.8561286926,
-0.050419502,
-0.47742486,
-0.0024906511,
-0.152495265,
-0.1312763989,
-0.1018421873,
-0.5668521523,
-0.1515577585,
-0.3690294623,
0.357437551,
0.8690843582,
0.1522571445,
0.3827543557,
-0.7025577426,
-0.3215491772,
-0.0365217887,
0.2617511749,
-0.4259721339,
0.1206246093,
-0.4205762148,
-0.6445608139,
-0.0918015763,
-1.0933521986,
0.6825925112,
0.0583039783,
0.2336883098,
0.1584206969,
-0.3561764657,
0.5622599721,
-0.5587932467,
0.646259129,
0.121270068,
-1.1435801983,
0.668336153,
-0.3990477622,
0.0653314814,
0.6309546232,
0.0655590668,
-0.7538325191,
-0.4858696163,
-0.7488946915,
-0.6374096274,
0.65392977,
0.382873863,
-0.2476100773,
0.0494542718,
0.2469081283,
0.255322367,
0.2427080572,
-0.4417739213,
-0.0978552252,
-0.2296019495,
-0.8613941073,
-0.193878755,
-0.374730736,
0.261921376,
-0.111953713,
0.1684331894,
0.0375451706,
0.0258478336,
0.1242097244,
-0.4684609175,
-0.070136264,
0.5516571999,
0.3017167449,
0.7140457034,
-0.2582237124,
0.2148546129,
0.2062727362,
-0.8330471516,
-0.0154273231,
0.2706844211,
-0.1783749312,
0.6609982252,
0.5424496531,
0.3235768974,
0.6100173593,
-0.9145465493,
0.3683296144,
-0.0316589102,
-0.2909065187,
-0.6961189508,
-0.0461369716,
0.1615955383,
0.0538949147,
0.1394219846,
-0.0976127088,
0.3782814443,
-0.8598700166,
0.3521715999,
0.2852798998,
-0.5649988055,
-0.5080618858,
0.0666460767,
0.0235085748,
-0.4814728796,
0.1338188052,
-0.210621953,
-0.6099643707,
0.7188466191,
0.3327604532,
0.3573590517,
-0.4233905673,
0.2950643897,
0.3829741776,
0.3170513809,
0.31358248,
0.802615881,
0.1622211486,
-0.5886406898,
-0.2204592228,
-1.2736203671,
-0.0238711666,
0.1012954563,
-0.4991716743,
0.7113516331,
-0.6316998005,
-0.2818899453,
0.5463470221,
0.2053554207,
-0.4311589897,
-0.2856732607,
-0.3948171437,
0.9476333261,
-0.7727078199,
0.8574747443,
0.9418460131,
-0.2594842911,
-0.344637394,
-0.7719627023,
0.4216180444,
-0.4995348752,
1.1356753111,
0.0780303627,
-0.0906784162,
0.0211391635,
0.1168155819,
-0.8353434205,
0.6840240955,
0.3838993907,
-0.491858691,
-0.0916847661,
-0.0101781441,
0.7368531227,
-0.2390473187,
0.0654046983,
0.7985894084,
0.4588489234,
-0.3971613348,
-1.2936335802,
-0.1651480645,
-1.0187525749,
-0.2147705406,
0.6873773932,
0.1243651807,
0.9426752329,
0.5920306444,
-0.7146202326,
0.4713096321,
0.0342960544,
-0.1552851796,
0.0099954959,
0.4584827423,
0.7327173948,
0.6788511872,
-0.2538472116,
0.7942218184,
-0.2557549179,
0.1825912744,
0.709967196,
-0.0130043384,
1.0052902699,
0.3372884989,
-0.3917071819,
0.7315410376,
0.6750445962,
-0.312520057,
0.1677906811,
0.2616195381,
-0.1756523699,
-0.0241447445,
-0.2433854342,
-0.113700211,
0.8126629591,
0.3895431161,
-0.6433185935,
-0.2555909455,
0.1107149422,
0.3435877562,
0.273484081,
-0.3791159093,
0.8748770952,
-0.0940557569,
-0.575915575,
0.1503119916,
0.1707693636,
0.5628874898,
-0.7738854885,
0.1026728004,
0.0783158019,
0.4060172737,
-0.3593716323,
-0.5708994269,
0.6656732559,
0.3057354987,
0.0092062978,
-0.0434461012,
0.8398023844,
-0.3386129439,
-0.8375403285,
0.5017984509,
0.7594537139,
0.2563505471,
0.3531004488,
-0.317155838,
0.0413538814,
-0.1683181524,
0.3101066053,
0.0167021174,
0.2757885754,
0.0367067382,
0.3872883022,
0.8438417315,
0.5255489349,
0.0456000008,
-0.0485358052,
0.572703898,
-1.0627549887,
-0.9786585569,
-1.1390706301,
0.4667606354,
-0.1287040859,
-0.4030557573,
1.2069878578,
0.8408332467,
0.49253124,
-0.2836007476,
0.6973727345,
0.0033346736,
0.6560305357,
-0.7466865778,
0.8368330002,
-0.2042298168,
-0.2021153271,
-0.3930511475,
-0.9563127756,
-0.4483292401,
0.6926035285,
-0.1412959248,
-0.4116377234,
1.1896715164,
0.7226458192,
0.1098366827,
-0.1014560834,
0.2396046966,
0.2120452374,
-0.0596620627,
0.409006834,
1.0516196489,
-0.1002905071,
0.73895818,
-0.1981777102,
-0.1532995701,
-0.2987097502,
-0.4899513721,
-0.9861343503,
-0.592335403,
0.2387500554,
-0.447650969,
0.0597294234,
0.9320755601,
0.6190168858,
-0.6998277903,
-0.688739121,
-0.2145093381,
0.0430508181,
0.0211277734,
-0.2126532197,
0.4861692786,
-0.490270704,
-0.788018167,
0.3923096955,
0.5192429423,
-0.0156907123,
-0.3033369482,
0.1899797022,
-0.1709354669,
-0.3571336567,
0.4501706064,
0.012058951,
-0.51367414,
-0.0860993415,
0.3576633036,
-0.0596239716,
0.2501761913,
0.7642123699,
-0.6700212359,
0.6112805009,
0.6021858454,
0.0174271967,
0.2368950844,
-0.2373502702,
0.5338203907,
-0.7098777294,
0.4277962148,
0.2263693959,
0.650437057,
0.3214586675,
-0.2270258367,
0.5739875436,
0.2710671127,
-0.1624428034,
-0.7119033933,
0.2850881815,
-0.7613713741,
-0.3818809986,
0.7995931506,
0.2110274881,
-0.4854422808,
-0.6820076704,
-0.3586623669,
-0.0294599421,
-0.3533250988,
0.6152837276,
1.1971796751,
0.2728918493,
-0.1031071916,
-1.0107079744,
0.9889848232,
0.1608888358,
-0.8459858298,
-0.0761033595,
0.5612878203,
0.3268797398,
0.6633992195,
0.6227182746,
-0.1100522354,
0.3508038521,
0.2113328725,
0.0907279775,
0.1371171325,
-0.3423563242,
-0.5482731462,
0.3178270161,
0.0272563566,
0.1279442906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13528v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13528v2 | Transfer-Free Data-Efficient Multilingual Slot Labeling | 2023-05-22T22:47:32 | 2023-11-12T10:17:53 | Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Slot labeling (SL) is a core component of task-oriented dialogue (ToD)
systems, where slots and corresponding values are usually language-, task- and
domain-specific. Therefore, extending the system to any new
language-domain-task configuration requires (re)running an expensive and
resource-intensive data annotation process. To mitigate the inherent data
scarcity issue, current research on multilingual ToD assumes that sufficient
English-language annotated data are always available for particular tasks and
domains, and thus operates in a standard cross-lingual transfer setup. In this
work, we depart from this often unrealistic assumption. We examine challenging
scenarios where such transfer-enabling English annotated data cannot be
guaranteed, and focus on bootstrapping multilingual data-efficient slot
labelers in transfer-free scenarios directly in the target languages without
any English-ready data. We propose a two-stage slot labeling approach (termed
TWOSL) which transforms standard multilingual sentence encoders into effective
slot labelers. In Stage 1, relying on SL-adapted contrastive learning with only
a handful of SL-annotated examples, we turn sentence encoders into
task-specific span encoders. In Stage 2, we recast SL from a token
classification into a simpler, less data-intensive span classification task.
Our results on two standard multilingual TOD datasets and across diverse
languages confirm the effectiveness and robustness of TWOSL. It is especially
effective for the most challenging transfer-free few-shot setups, paving the
way for quick and data-efficient bootstrapping of multilingual slot labelers
for ToD. | [
-0.2011833042,
-0.4523640573,
0.3050609827,
0.3399295509,
-0.3833377063,
0.0574436821,
-0.2181759775,
-0.7730621696,
0.2488485724,
0.2783218026,
-0.5306007266,
-0.2980774641,
-0.5316428542,
0.0649027526,
-0.2384193838,
1.2301604748,
-0.1819870621,
-0.1058100685,
-0.2089378387,
-0.2534738779,
-0.3919224441,
-0.399548173,
-0.8064386249,
-0.1981882602,
0.5215550065,
0.2738922834,
0.4460632205,
0.6516891122,
-0.0019901902,
0.1217374131,
-0.0236057937,
0.2878330648,
-0.2620141208,
0.1609361321,
-0.1717419177,
-0.3605837524,
-0.2347695827,
-0.0826109424,
0.6023421288,
0.7282323837,
0.1773517281,
0.0281316862,
0.1594972759,
0.3952988684,
-0.4189472497,
0.3980436325,
-0.7039085031,
0.1677306741,
-0.4256714582,
0.0674017146,
-0.5827776194,
-0.1062789708,
0.1761918515,
-0.9727292657,
0.0160746798,
0.1546544582,
0.8056558967,
0.2183236182,
-0.45554474,
-0.1408720464,
-0.6099737287,
0.8418834805,
-0.2247664779,
0.457647115,
0.5559785962,
0.2001232058,
0.3185657561,
-0.6364079118,
-0.4593794048,
0.1505355388,
-0.3592963517,
-0.0060055912,
-0.1480618566,
-0.1673791111,
0.0343356766,
-0.1337741315,
-0.6743504405,
0.381703645,
-0.3436490297,
-0.3615436554,
0.4867157042,
-0.1245512068,
0.1747056395,
-0.0855941102,
-0.8650312424,
0.0236722883,
-0.7160413861,
0.0165909287,
-0.066294454,
0.5232197642,
-0.1777964532,
0.2231134027,
0.294929713,
0.7425490022,
-0.1264911294,
-0.2732984722,
0.283319205,
-0.6279656887,
0.1507301033,
0.0336190462,
0.6956208944,
0.363740921,
0.0786322802,
-0.4314328432,
-0.231743902,
0.0419868082,
0.1201069057,
-0.5329544544,
-0.0361182839,
0.2523026466,
0.0164308138,
0.0146476924,
-0.382150054,
-0.7165952325,
-0.3211190403,
0.040023908,
0.3591737449,
-0.3806725442,
-0.118106626,
-0.128178969,
-0.0521107465,
0.1462960243,
0.3958281279,
-0.703641355,
-0.0128503768,
0.6563745141,
0.9848937392,
-0.4485017657,
-0.2814326584,
-0.6560486555,
0.5779210925,
-0.4913896322,
0.8974995017,
-0.4003972113,
-0.2348407209,
0.1581801772,
0.2700811625,
-0.4834205508,
-0.3081587851,
0.3876367807,
-0.2866889238,
0.2025061995,
-0.1670715213,
-0.4164742529,
0.054468248,
0.2299458981,
-0.5645363927,
1.1958016157,
0.2493589073,
-0.6188861728,
0.3199689686,
-0.5010322928,
-0.7875082493,
0.2330216318,
-0.156902656,
-0.1411517113,
-0.2129626423,
0.1207670048,
0.3831309378,
-0.1848190427,
0.3540883362,
-0.0346441194,
-0.3118408918,
0.369038552,
-0.268856734,
0.6363127828,
0.2135413587,
-0.4331058562,
-0.0508793928,
-0.6891231537,
-0.0588240884,
-0.1750031114,
-0.0894595087,
-0.5437816381,
-0.2085356563,
0.2879293561,
0.5467512608,
0.001598541,
-0.7562053204,
0.2568071485,
-0.2509134114,
0.4157203436,
0.718865633,
-0.3272124231,
0.5372976661,
-0.1944926828,
0.540731132,
0.2058963329,
-0.0862209052,
-0.1993227154,
-0.5491074324,
-0.942478776,
-0.5128085017,
0.5500679612,
0.8863940835,
-1.3702312708,
0.2172624022,
-0.1397676319,
-0.2129050195,
-0.9163122773,
-0.2372653633,
0.6258807778,
0.5441260338,
0.4737784564,
-0.3568062782,
-0.4263816178,
-1.0920048952,
0.0004489449,
-0.1115693599,
0.1610749811,
0.2990370095,
0.3055170178,
0.0461412407,
0.6427447796,
-0.3763498962,
-0.5486881733,
-0.5200142264,
0.1817345917,
-0.1689871699,
0.6581721902,
0.5201348066,
-0.4409430325,
-0.6778683662,
0.1197947711,
-0.5288725495,
-0.1308944076,
-0.5511871576,
-0.3280965984,
0.6173175573,
0.2696103752,
-0.6030240655,
0.4558694959,
0.448585391,
-0.2139644623,
0.4035306275,
-0.0652151555,
-0.0624074936,
-0.9568886161,
0.1652118713,
0.0788561627,
-0.4233990908,
-1.0225932598,
-0.3325259686,
0.1320913434,
-0.1510152668,
-0.5129860044,
0.8483152986,
-0.4118738174,
-0.2280742973,
-0.1075568199,
0.3556625545,
0.1212795451,
0.651504159,
0.2285066992,
0.9281656146,
0.621588707,
-0.534271121,
-0.1543515921,
0.4004847705,
-0.3852088749,
0.7045333385,
-0.2856664956,
0.179357484,
-0.3179361224,
0.452750206,
-1.1959735155,
0.1634947807,
0.5444225669,
-0.1366516501,
0.5027475357,
-0.3933475614,
-0.296710968,
-0.1001421958,
-0.2948465049,
0.3743306398,
0.2058908939,
-0.5542674661,
0.1321901828,
0.5322151184,
-0.4394734204,
-0.6211217642,
-0.9688852429,
-0.0854266807,
-0.2115326524,
-0.3528529108,
0.4447893202,
0.091055043,
0.1230783463,
0.0145518659,
-0.2049778998,
-0.4856305122,
0.0032291831,
0.0278651435,
0.3865938485,
0.1516437083,
0.2364214957,
0.3024778366,
-0.4612306356,
-0.2535464466,
-0.514328897,
0.2992917299,
0.1659085602,
-0.1031818688,
-0.5822665691,
0.6521795392,
0.393415004,
-0.2528729141,
0.7644405365,
1.021209836,
-0.3523186743,
-0.1861334294,
-0.3378702104,
0.1649637967,
-0.3480529487,
0.340808779,
-0.5654607415,
-1.0749531984,
0.2509163916,
0.1049099863,
0.4523362219,
0.4497259259,
0.1393970102,
-0.203092441,
0.7065708637,
0.5112560391,
0.0494758524,
0.2980196774,
-0.0030495205,
0.3148394525,
-0.9417447448,
-0.3400941193,
-0.6647594571,
-0.3135689497,
-0.2819469273,
-0.8840564489,
0.5106059313,
-0.0127283633,
0.224268347,
0.4342832863,
-0.4144968688,
0.3467885554,
0.4003196061,
-0.2421782166,
0.1518074423,
0.1537305713,
-0.0550184511,
-0.307841152,
-0.811427176,
-0.3252479732,
0.8388745785,
0.1401821226,
0.4788241684,
0.077201575,
0.5082221031,
0.2524680793,
0.1231806949,
-0.6739652157,
0.4753634632,
-0.3716295362,
-0.4853251278,
-0.3565528989,
-0.2368119657,
-1.1576834917,
0.5752593875,
-0.090692468,
-1.0216888189,
0.3376164734,
0.0046319957,
-0.3997671008,
0.3343537152,
-0.7590682507,
0.8886970878,
-0.1578150988,
-0.4119603932,
-0.0691970512,
-0.9671564102,
0.2289323211,
-0.215029195,
0.496301949,
-0.2892245054,
-0.1643023938,
0.9190279245,
-0.2386837155,
0.9856638312,
-0.3799574971,
-0.2343732715,
0.2867763937,
0.0529837385,
0.6361218095,
0.0273811407,
0.0730004683,
0.0680508316,
0.1433353275,
-0.3973352313,
-0.4865972698,
0.4640907943,
-0.6191860437,
-0.2710733712,
-0.4667659998,
-0.6897756457,
-0.4177388847,
0.0232129861,
0.1516622156,
0.4610367119,
0.0222497731,
-0.2290762514,
0.6863698959,
-0.2606643438,
0.5738688707,
0.5100396872,
-0.0897616372,
-0.3735443354,
1.1680686474,
0.3556472361,
0.167404145,
0.4591421783,
-0.1863297969,
-0.5130981207,
-0.3167005479,
-1.1289232969,
0.2012126297,
-0.4487538636,
-0.2407765239,
-0.753113687,
-0.066585876,
-0.3148189187,
-0.2902106941,
-0.6137388349,
-1.0930969715,
-0.2833881378,
-0.1162009686,
0.2909439802,
0.4994209111,
-0.1114007235,
0.1998586059,
-0.6587562561,
0.1986735016,
0.1154869795,
0.4093777835,
-0.0908429399,
-0.3672550321,
-0.4470937848,
-0.1515435576,
-0.0008762394,
-0.9435004592,
0.2934582829,
0.3908755481,
0.6282701492,
0.126363039,
0.1642027795,
0.8315748572,
-0.5207344294,
0.8691253066,
0.2455014735,
-0.8838970661,
0.4296798408,
-0.0850153863,
0.1180224344,
0.5646395087,
0.5238705277,
-0.8432558179,
-0.3551355302,
-0.3322717249,
-1.2104049921,
1.0685989857,
-0.0071245609,
-0.1106411144,
-0.0703027323,
0.0961702168,
0.6212592721,
0.1645002365,
-0.8126314282,
-0.3687196076,
-0.1078406498,
-0.0297980718,
-0.1093735024,
-0.2393606603,
-0.1400400251,
-0.1851685196,
0.8189268112,
-0.1108369604,
0.4082758725,
0.1462025046,
-0.5213490129,
0.0908501521,
0.76989609,
0.505864501,
0.4324482083,
0.132449463,
0.2971331775,
-0.0127311293,
-0.0574805513,
0.3553745747,
0.4490041733,
-0.5238220692,
0.30923751,
0.0317487456,
1.1382508278,
0.2831254303,
-0.6779285073,
0.4997537732,
0.1887899786,
-0.0935733765,
-0.0851011053,
-0.405510813,
-0.0671193823,
0.1808922142,
0.260124743,
-0.061245814,
0.0141754206,
-0.3079504073,
0.3347875774,
0.3758378923,
-0.5220811367,
-0.4343187511,
0.4737769365,
0.303019315,
-0.0374695547,
0.5227158666,
-0.5401611924,
-0.3599385023,
0.1107573956,
0.9600747824,
0.7603969574,
-0.2299085259,
0.5920923948,
0.2951113284,
0.399564445,
0.1026883349,
0.1601479053,
-0.1196638644,
-0.6535499096,
-0.5432621241,
-0.5121850967,
-0.2774329185,
0.0009504096,
-0.8677888513,
-0.2154300064,
-0.1939695925,
-0.0319777988,
-0.0343849324,
-0.3282665014,
-0.6024124622,
-0.0885006562,
0.3092339337,
0.7277591228,
-1.0519112349,
1.0419687033,
0.8206871152,
0.0962386802,
-0.5340362191,
-0.4206371307,
0.0146371536,
-0.9258554578,
0.347709775,
0.338956058,
0.1340867132,
-0.123052001,
-0.0533336028,
-0.9047803879,
0.9329643846,
0.1882381886,
-0.5556129217,
0.0013562624,
0.2603929937,
0.4196787775,
-0.3969801068,
0.0651418865,
0.7759985328,
0.4856642485,
0.1306591183,
-1.1643310785,
0.0504330546,
-0.2294996828,
0.1433482021,
0.3735797107,
-0.7131727338,
0.6270225644,
-0.0046161171,
-0.2724798024,
0.0352686271,
0.5337777734,
0.0972415283,
0.3492798209,
0.5941566229,
0.5832824111,
0.89407444,
-0.3154103756,
0.7774078846,
-0.2277339399,
0.011321458,
1.0109111071,
-0.5086709261,
0.7927742004,
0.6202358007,
-0.1781627089,
0.3531495929,
0.4905482233,
0.1274837106,
0.5433037281,
0.0979484618,
-0.3170220554,
-0.188771069,
-0.6675233245,
-0.2915506661,
0.4084564447,
0.4613181055,
0.0370260105,
-0.2064548582,
0.2387846112,
0.3897489309,
-0.3175963759,
-0.1936213374,
0.8395965099,
-0.1617957205,
-0.7904347777,
0.5978457928,
0.0021030896,
0.8449949026,
-0.6918230653,
0.1091543138,
-0.3617065251,
-0.0482048132,
-0.0609435663,
-0.7439712286,
0.5123161674,
0.208714053,
0.0437319912,
-0.7212266922,
0.7233917117,
-1.0536754131,
-0.4141362906,
0.1038748249,
0.799595058,
0.5184049606,
0.4235957265,
-0.5940795541,
0.0520456322,
0.2649104297,
0.015212669,
0.7759720087,
0.2675970793,
-0.3027662933,
0.5120434165,
0.334582597,
0.1242305487,
0.1243713126,
0.0009787279,
0.6593865752,
-0.5392841697,
-0.7189651728,
-0.3300844431,
0.7758492827,
0.0522131175,
-0.3440894485,
0.6580134034,
0.7103069425,
0.9827018976,
-0.0306888707,
1.02321136,
-0.1564627588,
0.4998179376,
-0.5189289451,
0.4914256036,
-0.576644659,
0.2185712457,
-0.2797779739,
-0.6698442101,
-0.2934651077,
0.7913681269,
0.0710910484,
-0.3901017904,
0.8458165526,
0.5708064437,
0.1734191775,
-0.0212596767,
0.2059032321,
-0.0411226712,
0.1077545658,
0.8740995526,
0.7447553277,
-0.3658079803,
0.7662439942,
-0.3948642612,
-0.2633892894,
0.162727654,
-0.6706448197,
-0.7198211551,
-0.6366711259,
-0.6604323387,
-0.3790254295,
0.2316749692,
0.9301790595,
0.6347215176,
-0.7758206725,
-0.315654248,
0.5227528214,
0.2604003251,
-0.4725396931,
-0.2146841437,
0.5052204728,
-0.5596940517,
-0.7195489407,
0.6453979611,
0.4743517935,
0.1260965019,
0.092691943,
0.0966973975,
-0.1774783731,
-0.2488446385,
0.7272008061,
0.3286984265,
-0.6266302466,
-0.3384726346,
-0.2581039369,
-0.0890095755,
0.1320570856,
0.8356660604,
-0.7031106949,
0.4825893641,
0.0401656888,
0.8509069085,
0.6793838143,
-0.1746847034,
0.4256854355,
-1.2829757929,
0.4730577767,
0.1417623162,
0.2402679026,
0.3062207401,
-0.1117973328,
0.6512803435,
0.3567433059,
-0.1705779582,
-0.9109661579,
0.2442280352,
-1.0751694441,
-0.2843869328,
1.2378964424,
-0.479755789,
0.0275015645,
-0.4470415115,
-0.0587344542,
0.2334903777,
-0.2995022535,
0.4379558861,
0.5664163232,
-0.3279809952,
-0.1959496886,
-0.4002089798,
0.6455768943,
0.4819569886,
-0.8605020046,
0.2128764987,
0.5018854141,
0.1120041907,
0.1517708749,
1.0068290234,
-0.0029055306,
0.10212183,
-0.0768284276,
-0.1057617962,
-0.0738388598,
-0.5841483474,
-0.3115645349,
0.2148393989,
-0.0417627692,
-0.4122284949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13527v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13527v2 | Aligning the Norwegian UD Treebank with Entity and Coreference Information | 2023-05-22T22:44:53 | 2023-05-25T22:36:36 | Tollef Emil Jørgensen, Andre Kåsen | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | This paper presents a merged collection of entity and coreference annotated
data grounded in the Universal Dependencies (UD) treebanks for the two written
forms of Norwegian: Bokm{\aa}l and Nynorsk. The aligned and converted corpora
are the Norwegian Named Entities (NorNE) and Norwegian Anaphora Resolution
Corpus (NARC). While NorNE is aligned with an older version of the treebank,
NARC is misaligned and requires extensive transformation from the original
annotations to the UD structure and CoNLL-U format. We here demonstrate the
conversion and alignment processes, along with an analysis of discovered issues
and errors in the data - some of which include data split overlaps in the
original treebank. These procedures and the developed system may prove helpful
for future corpus alignment and coreference annotation endeavors. The merged
corpora comprise the first Norwegian UD treebank enriched with named entities
and coreference information. | [
-0.4625275731,
-0.2997623086,
0.2161048353,
-0.4364928007,
-0.2789357007,
-0.0010616034,
-0.3222339749,
-0.9946526885,
0.2470989078,
0.6548724771,
-0.3229614496,
-0.603088975,
-0.2299116999,
0.3119989634,
-0.1167000979,
1.2215640545,
-0.149143368,
-0.0332305171,
0.0123713398,
-0.4145455658,
-0.3623351753,
-0.6743403077,
-0.2370413691,
-0.2397664338,
0.6411896944,
0.6301066279,
0.6590157151,
0.3939593434,
0.56978935,
0.1249658912,
-0.2757044137,
0.1631192118,
-0.2190616876,
0.3416439891,
-0.4714345336,
0.0188976638,
-0.7818464041,
0.0135636227,
0.6387968063,
0.8221386671,
-0.0619655214,
0.347147584,
0.2358774543,
0.4641504288,
-0.581178546,
0.0414646305,
-0.4555762708,
-0.1915411055,
-0.5046363473,
0.2699686885,
-0.238494873,
-0.3103080392,
0.4767724574,
-0.7483266592,
0.2007571012,
0.1984646916,
1.0073984861,
0.2562758625,
-0.570479095,
-0.4424751699,
-0.5128263831,
0.8818823695,
-0.5203842521,
0.4585185647,
-0.0166112315,
0.1425105929,
-0.2055572867,
-0.2823854387,
-0.3432978988,
0.1361430585,
-0.3804186583,
0.0300416555,
-0.2027031779,
0.1253328025,
-0.0514934435,
0.4538437128,
-0.6124937534,
0.4279584289,
-0.5439354181,
-0.4788783789,
0.7613080144,
-0.2733582258,
0.1243056133,
-0.6096867323,
-0.4012069702,
-0.3344189227,
-0.6932581663,
-0.2202890813,
0.2923159301,
0.6145511866,
-0.0961867422,
0.7038292289,
0.1499886513,
0.6848269105,
0.3165537119,
-0.2435804456,
0.2240453511,
-0.4900723696,
-0.4002889991,
0.8403752446,
0.5622275472,
0.5404233932,
0.2104412615,
-0.1898338646,
-0.1682794243,
0.1679300517,
0.0528455377,
-0.4013630152,
-0.2204287201,
0.1969854683,
-0.2880853415,
-0.0944039673,
0.2194841504,
-0.6334030628,
-0.2019047141,
-0.5717644095,
-0.0117421448,
-0.3176746964,
-0.5534054041,
0.0624726638,
0.1205905378,
-0.025750326,
0.2692347169,
-0.6861701608,
0.0724188164,
0.7054534554,
0.5141589046,
-0.2717336118,
0.1105626673,
-0.3158822656,
0.3851158023,
-0.2997136116,
0.7377532721,
-0.2501116395,
-0.3485448956,
0.0965867564,
-0.1077442989,
0.0679160804,
-0.465995729,
0.9146172404,
-0.4494789541,
0.5290235877,
-0.1414126605,
-0.6033453345,
-0.4743963778,
0.3125446737,
-0.7707388997,
1.0789481401,
0.460062921,
-1.0359454155,
0.2185807824,
-0.7828187346,
-0.0304842722,
0.1816291064,
-0.1025476083,
0.2502935529,
0.1758637279,
-0.0360029191,
0.4160918891,
-0.2112347037,
0.5118309259,
-0.0875187591,
0.2770138383,
-0.2213058621,
0.3371768594,
1.2599337101,
0.097870037,
0.0652632862,
0.0072919503,
-0.8805704713,
-0.1181254536,
-0.3161135316,
-0.3260161281,
-0.8832778931,
-0.4349550903,
0.2142375559,
-0.0655553788,
0.6214505434,
-0.9156623483,
0.5539019704,
-0.1337365061,
0.0195588171,
0.5331805944,
-0.149480328,
0.6903226376,
0.0593113638,
0.4322262406,
0.1181304455,
-0.1203836128,
0.2370987982,
-0.4242144823,
-0.3778531849,
0.1099011973,
0.7931767106,
0.5704132915,
-0.426028192,
0.6982222199,
-0.5130978227,
-0.4064331651,
-0.4247041941,
-0.1046573967,
0.3718106151,
0.8643130064,
0.4017317891,
-0.4204359651,
-1.2430129051,
-0.9515770674,
0.2141419947,
-0.5808215141,
0.0284763686,
0.0274953414,
0.3884387016,
-0.309199065,
1.0096125603,
-0.1170829833,
-0.458029747,
0.3246583343,
0.1413303614,
0.4608731866,
0.8945022225,
0.5957276225,
-0.6063417196,
-0.4017388523,
0.4691369236,
-0.4779140055,
-0.3262774348,
0.1018849909,
-0.1838814616,
0.5139890909,
0.4859045148,
-0.5155917406,
0.4482318163,
0.8726708293,
-0.6030107737,
1.0422278643,
0.25839293,
-0.0499483347,
-0.9492202401,
0.3502636552,
-0.4550548792,
-0.2775816917,
-0.4246064425,
-0.2362950742,
-0.0928116739,
0.3124839962,
-0.1615633368,
0.671454668,
-0.5750938654,
0.0601070896,
0.1760877967,
0.1599707603,
0.0509373359,
0.0206828099,
-0.0551569797,
0.4307331741,
0.5557563305,
-0.6807402372,
0.4659825861,
0.7048912048,
-0.3724059761,
1.2757142782,
-0.2196107209,
0.1732198298,
-0.1189576089,
0.1788942963,
-0.852409482,
-0.2264677733,
0.2724435031,
-0.4128319025,
0.3536110222,
-0.3605761826,
-0.5301363468,
0.0692087337,
-0.0254014209,
0.4507697821,
0.0421448387,
-0.5514878035,
0.7887367606,
0.332311213,
-0.2227882296,
-0.7406083345,
-0.6973077059,
0.2090228349,
-0.2500429451,
-0.7015928626,
0.6843505502,
0.1569586396,
-0.3855711222,
0.6392357349,
-0.396443069,
0.0690374598,
-0.2483560443,
0.4240969419,
0.5289224386,
-0.6565991044,
0.2720914781,
-0.0374750271,
-0.0603272878,
-0.2448665053,
-0.5294220448,
0.1906010956,
-0.0129650971,
0.0290586725,
-0.1976997107,
0.5558335781,
0.391869247,
0.0469214581,
0.6054146886,
0.0924038589,
-0.5363748074,
0.3529628217,
-0.7471454144,
0.0692654252,
-0.2654746771,
-0.1083002836,
-0.41050753,
-0.9889790416,
0.3673551977,
0.1443835199,
0.7075104117,
0.6936438084,
0.0742136538,
-0.3337581754,
0.4251970053,
0.6325016022,
0.1717981696,
0.2473466396,
-0.0701186731,
0.0184258297,
-1.214902997,
-0.3508055806,
-0.6228039265,
-0.6901993155,
-0.4322902858,
0.0130924694,
0.0631025806,
0.5256332755,
-0.4097003639,
0.776176393,
-0.6560239196,
0.051114317,
0.4282391369,
-0.4849774241,
0.5014578104,
0.1441198289,
-0.5220841765,
-0.1689885557,
-0.5850635171,
-0.797991693,
0.9032836556,
0.018159505,
0.3845679164,
0.3001113832,
0.7366580367,
-0.017052386,
0.4141512513,
-0.2884328961,
0.3987844586,
-0.3872464895,
-0.9296156168,
-0.1910878718,
-0.0977018178,
-1.0639833212,
-0.0386294872,
-0.3422502279,
-1.0893809795,
0.6861610413,
0.1676092148,
-0.4511297345,
0.3379856348,
-0.6660919189,
0.8961921334,
-0.2005833834,
0.1994149834,
0.0564210266,
-0.7006866932,
0.3511226475,
0.0392175913,
-0.0060139117,
-0.1733050346,
-0.0781013817,
1.0519779921,
-0.2801664174,
0.7861763835,
-0.03891645,
-0.3629317284,
0.2106036842,
0.3273419738,
0.1976312846,
-0.0807582214,
-0.1062275842,
0.3242716193,
0.3890506923,
-0.1448217034,
-0.3205337226,
0.7265580893,
-0.4509340525,
-0.3647152185,
-0.5967689157,
-0.6163380146,
-0.0734573677,
0.2909713984,
0.0954791233,
0.2157759666,
-0.4311845601,
0.2185755074,
0.3298882842,
0.3640295565,
0.2168117315,
0.4360413253,
-0.6527629495,
-0.7995189428,
0.0881429985,
0.2127803862,
-0.0169044863,
0.1415807307,
-0.060573224,
-0.5130406618,
-0.276011467,
-0.371180743,
0.4224455953,
-0.6702486873,
-0.6229735017,
-0.3418981731,
-0.0712846816,
-0.6770612001,
-0.2198396772,
-0.2426988035,
-0.6282345057,
-0.3442261517,
-0.2974164188,
0.6509433389,
0.8406357169,
-0.4590206742,
0.4714223444,
-0.9042999744,
-0.182673201,
0.0383119658,
0.1632315964,
-0.2979999185,
-0.2856629193,
-0.1172484607,
-0.0330481976,
-0.049712006,
-1.1299716234,
-0.1652306765,
0.1814688593,
0.2717493176,
0.5636735559,
0.0438306965,
0.7384774089,
-0.3396146595,
0.4518544972,
0.3601171672,
-0.778200984,
0.2022258341,
-0.1137430742,
0.1379276365,
0.8565933704,
0.2552392185,
-0.9482468963,
-0.0090082455,
-0.951120019,
-0.631039381,
0.5465096235,
0.0894413292,
-0.487692982,
0.2752709985,
0.470251739,
0.4167394042,
0.0044411318,
-0.2997397184,
-0.090602532,
0.117740646,
-0.3237812221,
-0.0795015991,
-0.3520380855,
-0.3165950775,
-0.2039522082,
0.7038371563,
0.0275332127,
-0.3769769073,
0.3771661222,
-0.1738019288,
-0.0528054312,
0.1818024516,
0.2897922695,
0.6572888494,
-0.3541895747,
0.7094739676,
0.0328275152,
-0.4938045144,
0.0456710868,
0.0558021069,
-0.3081685305,
0.5361565948,
0.4085581899,
0.4265311956,
0.3899838328,
-0.4573890865,
-0.1848151088,
0.3594124615,
-0.1019089073,
-0.3075813651,
-0.212622419,
0.3844611943,
0.2018082142,
0.3697381318,
0.0531146154,
-0.2151036412,
-0.2929072678,
0.2636110485,
0.3294157684,
-0.2444692403,
-0.5088193417,
0.3454029262,
0.2754926383,
-0.0117095429,
0.5863710642,
-0.0855282843,
-0.656134665,
0.151558727,
0.321323812,
0.6585149765,
-0.4734425247,
0.0957283229,
0.7447947264,
0.3083534241,
0.1189485267,
0.2696178555,
-0.0941381305,
-0.7646582127,
-0.5936992168,
-0.6370836496,
-0.1536993086,
-0.0477061644,
-0.8890006542,
0.2771719992,
-0.1400547922,
-0.3110952973,
0.1701770127,
0.083155185,
-0.6237043142,
0.1342408061,
0.2520369291,
0.8978964686,
-0.894290328,
0.8089454174,
1.2623182535,
-0.0126612037,
-0.6555244923,
-0.4496387839,
0.0183515735,
-0.4224249721,
1.0196987391,
0.0585398301,
0.0995407999,
-0.101762481,
-0.4513943791,
-1.0368230343,
0.8320473433,
0.4412865937,
-0.7194343209,
-0.1494926661,
0.0220692754,
0.3470447958,
-0.65434587,
-0.1542481482,
0.7719452381,
0.8920112252,
-0.2285202444,
-1.3514462709,
0.1119256765,
0.0410071425,
-0.0815848038,
0.5584159493,
0.0641071275,
0.7516376972,
0.2407807261,
-0.7486937642,
-0.1825058609,
0.8186839819,
0.1987993866,
-0.1023780257,
0.7451395392,
0.930939734,
0.9658850431,
-0.045366928,
0.436068058,
-0.0893019289,
0.3213643432,
1.3663183451,
-0.2927899063,
0.7678592205,
0.8484963775,
-0.0146754002,
0.753878653,
0.7077077627,
0.2169802338,
0.1993952543,
-0.0846333876,
-0.1939959675,
-0.1294468939,
-0.5247094035,
-0.40473032,
0.3729799092,
0.4364809394,
0.0872367099,
-0.7832772136,
-0.1132131517,
0.2531011999,
-0.0087177986,
-0.1831335723,
0.6633535028,
-0.0081044799,
-0.6645949483,
0.6344207525,
-0.3175060451,
0.6558176875,
-0.2591347694,
-0.0431930833,
0.1296004355,
-0.0419812575,
-0.63530159,
-0.9096778631,
0.632592082,
0.0145876594,
-0.2595224082,
-0.3290829659,
0.5325350165,
-0.6065181494,
-0.3735982776,
0.4296485484,
0.1872614324,
0.4721055329,
0.0738684461,
-0.4727182388,
-0.0809428766,
0.095467411,
0.1516579688,
-0.1274043322,
0.3882603943,
-0.296171844,
-0.1640388668,
0.6340590715,
0.1135519743,
0.156671375,
-0.4542474747,
0.5840862989,
-0.5373366475,
-0.1469277591,
-0.6689684391,
0.6035783887,
-0.1364268214,
-0.6357195973,
0.5580610633,
0.7404645681,
0.8740618825,
0.0004264357,
0.4832296669,
-0.7007662058,
0.7121127844,
-0.4815864563,
0.3346140981,
-0.4302129745,
-0.0898717269,
0.0982691124,
-1.2817080021,
-0.4365255237,
0.4030532837,
-0.1124782488,
-0.5065698028,
0.7941802144,
0.3495523632,
-0.2418969572,
-0.0841995552,
0.0785662755,
0.3133512735,
0.0001118412,
0.7313824892,
0.4204601049,
-0.3073740602,
0.4656937718,
-0.4242911041,
-0.0751945674,
-0.3392524123,
-1.215783,
-0.5421816707,
-0.8872209787,
-0.6419287324,
-0.4876977503,
-0.0054015908,
0.8508452177,
0.4643769562,
-1.3073354959,
-0.1686925292,
0.1286989301,
0.1223996058,
0.0357872099,
-0.2022422999,
0.6809511185,
0.0930703953,
-0.7125597,
0.2476307452,
0.3567065597,
0.2570799589,
-0.2338184565,
0.0218679979,
-0.3693473637,
-0.4976034164,
0.0571955629,
0.44265908,
-0.8357104659,
-0.6026756167,
0.0142724728,
-0.2540429533,
0.4012447596,
0.7934264541,
-0.686981082,
0.4416965842,
0.629168272,
0.3447392583,
0.044091858,
0.2763352394,
0.5642083883,
-0.8314962983,
0.2776413262,
0.523040235,
0.3683637381,
0.4407162368,
-0.2991795242,
0.690312326,
-0.0211020298,
-0.4705432653,
-0.9980780482,
0.3745676875,
-1.2246530056,
0.0091017894,
0.8613506556,
-0.0775003955,
-0.3069832027,
-0.4872508645,
-0.3921482861,
0.297832638,
-0.2570793927,
0.3526691198,
1.0433183908,
-0.0941099674,
0.0370951556,
-0.3877902329,
0.4830316305,
0.359616071,
-0.4669988453,
0.0891398862,
0.5811457038,
-0.030602973,
0.9900346994,
0.0523883477,
-0.1373665482,
0.2698403001,
-0.2597559988,
0.8872680068,
0.128824532,
-0.1117700338,
-0.2123041451,
-0.1407261044,
-0.2329079956,
-0.2476687431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18322v1 | REFinD: Relation Extraction Financial Dataset | 2023-05-22T22:40:11 | 2023-05-22T22:40:11 | Simerjot Kaur, Charese Smiley, Akshat Gupta, Joy Sain, Dongsheng Wang, Suchetha Siddagangappa, Toyin Aguda, Sameena Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A number of datasets for Relation Extraction (RE) have been created to aide
downstream tasks such as information retrieval, semantic search, question
answering and textual entailment. However, these datasets fail to capture
financial-domain specific challenges since most of these datasets are compiled
using general knowledge sources such as Wikipedia, web-based text and news
articles, hindering real-life progress and adoption within the financial world.
To address this limitation, we propose REFinD, the first large-scale annotated
dataset of relations, with $\sim$29K instances and 22 relations amongst 8 types
of entity pairs, generated entirely over financial documents. We also provide
an empirical evaluation with various state-of-the-art models as benchmarks for
the RE task and highlight the challenges posed by our dataset. We observed that
various state-of-the-art deep learning models struggle with numeric inference,
relational and directional ambiguity. | [
-0.2960879803,
-0.5416686535,
0.0839148089,
0.1491979957,
-0.0938864648,
-0.1195338964,
-0.1141991168,
-0.7586024404,
0.1937925369,
0.5655606389,
-0.8355003595,
-0.2089213282,
-0.4489474595,
0.3111637533,
-0.4625782967,
1.184417367,
-0.0046718912,
-0.2216469496,
-0.3359180391,
0.0135299722,
-0.3500739932,
-0.1952435374,
-0.7074642181,
-0.31854707,
0.5871244669,
0.5387843251,
0.3811059296,
0.2753502131,
1.1515548229,
0.2868645489,
0.3640211821,
0.2267223001,
-0.5517027974,
0.2024312913,
-0.3072378039,
-0.1615663022,
-0.2602605522,
0.2524805665,
0.3210247159,
0.7474030256,
-0.0806176066,
0.4984512329,
-0.452268064,
1.0248247385,
-0.7687916756,
0.7806706429,
-0.5439198017,
-0.0967478827,
-0.3826898932,
0.0559270903,
-0.2968581915,
-0.3207867146,
0.8802682161,
-1.0127383471,
0.2914920151,
0.1112140343,
1.3376711607,
0.3937372267,
-0.4216679931,
-0.3699238598,
-0.6537824273,
0.5318644643,
-0.4214354753,
0.6123204827,
0.4249098599,
0.5122954249,
0.000230172,
-1.146574378,
-0.2462577671,
0.1639469713,
-0.2005978227,
0.0382571258,
-0.270444572,
-0.2364764214,
0.3714526594,
0.5183340311,
-0.0766521022,
-0.0892082527,
-0.5223553777,
-0.0020116398,
0.8109217882,
0.1122322679,
-0.0186418667,
-0.2761563957,
-0.529227972,
-0.1815539449,
-0.8250212073,
-0.2051195055,
0.246609956,
0.2847154438,
-0.0827843398,
0.4058012068,
-0.1757413149,
0.6060653925,
0.1290373057,
-0.1348119676,
0.4174811542,
-0.5324704051,
-0.3497694731,
-0.153648302,
0.7146639228,
0.3710304499,
0.8520885706,
-0.1502228975,
-0.1954280138,
-0.4671480656,
0.217308417,
-0.6267598271,
-0.2130234241,
0.1458941251,
-0.4956539273,
-0.1378004998,
0.2662658989,
-1.0069280863,
-0.2389118522,
-0.5297784805,
-0.1085656285,
-0.2967478931,
-0.5090732574,
-0.0384714417,
-0.5100690126,
0.617076993,
0.14880009,
-0.8516721129,
0.3016812205,
0.8469528556,
0.3502376676,
0.1594483554,
0.0378854983,
-0.2932889462,
0.1640933901,
-0.0044084089,
0.7541742325,
-0.6403506994,
-0.3268854022,
0.0697012171,
-0.1431864649,
-0.0904383734,
-0.7389521599,
0.2970264256,
-0.807962656,
0.0339099206,
-0.4296357334,
-0.5668241978,
-0.1841118783,
0.0451933108,
-0.9695157409,
0.5625069737,
0.4552285373,
-1.096876502,
0.5561185479,
-0.5428318977,
-0.3966077268,
0.0440956093,
-0.4081498086,
-0.4659295976,
-0.0622597113,
0.2448587418,
0.367081672,
-1.090914011,
0.5096984506,
-0.3975684345,
-0.2630117238,
0.34629637,
-0.2106555104,
0.5749089122,
0.2244933993,
-0.0046029654,
-0.1958167851,
-0.9605977535,
-0.4616232514,
0.2961460054,
0.1721465439,
-0.7976816893,
-0.1531386822,
0.1395807862,
0.0160492659,
0.4151910245,
-0.6238723993,
0.3390874863,
-0.252925694,
0.5054479241,
0.6187101603,
0.2926716506,
0.2158439159,
-0.1086465269,
0.4172734618,
0.1262906045,
-0.1187469438,
-0.1831984669,
-0.1391671449,
-0.407512486,
-0.1767610461,
0.7827165723,
0.5829365849,
-0.6813892126,
0.0994668528,
-0.5353739262,
-0.31103158,
-0.5464202166,
0.2208562344,
0.3704819083,
0.77618891,
0.1157255769,
-0.1786030531,
-0.659340322,
-1.4753124714,
-0.2275924683,
0.0182896592,
-0.0872638598,
0.4196008742,
0.5675670505,
-0.1397481412,
1.0901786089,
-0.8983454704,
-0.5071535707,
0.1154005304,
0.3428170979,
0.2628418505,
0.3102062345,
0.516379118,
-1.2068372965,
-0.2876754403,
0.0492013209,
-1.001278758,
0.1376088709,
-0.2857807577,
0.0847516656,
-0.173207432,
0.5648066998,
-0.6077716947,
0.6036182642,
-0.0345818028,
-0.1407773197,
0.4487437308,
-0.0495310053,
-0.2929524481,
-0.926094234,
0.4746792018,
0.4863855541,
0.0196203385,
-0.4305486083,
-0.0532278679,
0.1230768114,
-0.1340805888,
0.0112795522,
0.5375814438,
-0.4824033976,
-0.3117861748,
0.1029602215,
0.3747842014,
-0.004571971,
0.456474334,
0.1118866056,
0.7847880125,
0.1259078085,
-0.3299798071,
0.6963449121,
0.5929046273,
-0.3631946445,
0.6673549414,
-0.61133039,
0.0397839844,
-0.092581071,
0.2246164382,
-0.9454351068,
-0.2822747529,
0.1888067722,
-0.2094285637,
0.6575574279,
0.0906719342,
-0.35432899,
-0.2352947146,
-0.1672357321,
0.4310522079,
0.0599666834,
-0.4869466424,
0.5754630566,
0.2295773327,
-0.5180166364,
-0.9557932019,
-0.5007454753,
0.0041264175,
-0.1600837111,
-0.6775621176,
0.2673781812,
0.5729062557,
-0.6278643608,
0.4310190082,
-0.3120057881,
-0.1501787156,
0.0576575845,
0.3742785454,
0.5863370299,
-0.1423278004,
0.2598791718,
-0.2295631319,
-0.4763076901,
0.3085990548,
0.1721556187,
-0.0323407687,
0.206494391,
-0.1472663283,
-0.4366043806,
0.3125145435,
0.5443048477,
-0.5551453829,
0.6020014882,
0.1859558523,
-0.4923747778,
0.05549879,
-0.7071204185,
0.0131503353,
-0.4261776805,
0.3603034317,
-0.5977979898,
-0.6869087219,
0.7014679313,
-0.3404247761,
0.4341430962,
0.8735460639,
-0.1027580425,
0.308657378,
0.1312404573,
0.6308715343,
-0.4263615012,
0.4164011478,
-0.293918252,
0.3459076285,
-0.8444622159,
-0.5208889246,
-0.66227144,
-0.3905215561,
-0.5227326751,
0.1717892289,
-0.1827678233,
-0.0784846321,
-0.4330156446,
0.5259721279,
-0.1190904975,
0.1158245057,
0.4385614693,
-0.0480643213,
0.4316993952,
0.1137096211,
0.1623374671,
-0.3334561288,
-0.25593701,
0.0924154967,
1.3745814562,
0.3664033711,
0.8934044838,
-0.1846442074,
0.695197165,
0.1767045259,
0.8082119226,
-0.4848667383,
0.1228960901,
-0.2845719159,
-0.6460163593,
-0.3057252467,
-0.9575026035,
-0.9341564178,
-0.1716125906,
-0.0159280431,
-0.4346371293,
0.7550569177,
-0.3855761886,
-0.374453038,
-0.0439023189,
-0.793594718,
0.732103169,
-0.1023823991,
-0.4394503534,
0.1533262283,
-0.6498329043,
0.7527028322,
-0.5705752969,
0.2860566676,
-0.0195850991,
-0.0165160485,
0.7962747216,
-0.4930719137,
0.6490286589,
-0.1626196802,
-0.247104302,
0.3343682587,
-0.1617920101,
0.4718258083,
0.2635656595,
-0.1793340296,
0.0091699036,
-0.0569597334,
-0.1726070046,
-0.6295241117,
0.666615665,
-0.4734418094,
-0.45852983,
-0.4199976921,
-0.6190033555,
-0.4074015021,
0.1483894587,
-0.1361840516,
0.3185124099,
-0.2032557577,
0.2984871566,
0.2210449129,
-0.0455774665,
0.3954520524,
0.4651151001,
-0.3290887177,
-0.8243889809,
0.9815915227,
0.1779565513,
-0.0062759509,
0.1691327989,
-0.4028111398,
-0.5073156953,
0.0354227535,
-0.0760481879,
0.5191314816,
-0.5231724381,
-0.4580411911,
-0.0852980688,
-0.3295741379,
-0.4638440013,
0.0971796587,
-0.3349191546,
-0.3172584772,
-0.2204619944,
-0.3888193369,
0.5784653425,
0.853775382,
-0.169948712,
-0.1879422218,
-0.89795959,
0.5453258157,
0.5002354383,
0.4101466238,
0.1306607276,
-0.1853593737,
-0.2630831003,
-0.1787473559,
0.0475174151,
-0.6202396154,
0.3467256129,
0.2187139243,
0.241264388,
0.9596725106,
0.2248080373,
0.9705991149,
-0.1275344938,
0.1074984893,
0.1670917422,
-0.4370407462,
0.2327221483,
-0.1606567204,
-0.0757513419,
0.9493352771,
0.5137322545,
-0.4495397508,
0.1789356917,
-0.8799924254,
-0.9703876972,
0.5069003701,
0.1475548744,
-0.2109989524,
-0.0033446751,
0.9634013176,
0.1628167033,
0.5687913299,
-0.2161158472,
-0.5007946491,
0.1047526747,
-0.121957697,
0.1065007672,
-0.2727721035,
0.0469415784,
-0.3132103086,
0.5112859607,
0.2675023973,
0.0454818755,
0.4553889334,
0.2138154507,
-0.2217597067,
-0.2291046679,
0.290969044,
0.8934695721,
-0.6181023121,
-0.1028062403,
-0.2126925588,
-0.4409844577,
-0.0509301908,
0.7465286851,
-0.2056566775,
0.0542780682,
0.5913854837,
0.4078484476,
0.7401895523,
-0.7434096932,
0.4402385652,
-0.2779851854,
-0.4271041155,
-0.6798538566,
-0.3736219704,
0.2466045022,
0.215744406,
0.6622380614,
-0.2387879789,
-0.0139505696,
-0.5097151399,
0.6325980425,
0.3682758212,
-0.4736016989,
-0.110319376,
0.735861361,
0.4843980074,
-0.0865485668,
1.4601911306,
0.1456198394,
-0.229677096,
0.6539378762,
0.2431333065,
0.9896193147,
0.1571922302,
-0.1416431069,
0.3680610955,
0.1460800916,
0.012984016,
0.12870574,
0.0830887109,
-0.6947205067,
-0.715952456,
-0.5195900798,
-0.5061286092,
0.3420259953,
-1.012845993,
0.0961415917,
-0.4669713378,
-0.1408233792,
0.2927066684,
0.2856339514,
-0.8280254602,
0.116698727,
-0.127575025,
1.3398994207,
-0.6456356049,
0.6669109464,
0.4602763355,
-0.8620437384,
-0.5615305305,
-0.3678630888,
-0.1507667303,
-0.6070703268,
1.1642638445,
0.1892218441,
0.2995431721,
-0.1158733591,
-0.5548932552,
-0.666087389,
0.9997036457,
0.3551725149,
-0.9430060983,
-0.3546842039,
0.1555258632,
0.2573798001,
-0.5229895711,
-0.0808686689,
0.7713714838,
0.7917588949,
0.1012093499,
-0.7245150208,
-0.0058672219,
-0.4945569038,
-0.3301106691,
0.4082090259,
-0.7907552719,
0.7581461668,
-0.0044549541,
-0.1311607212,
-0.1463868022,
0.9326053262,
-0.0234177355,
0.5401240587,
0.3799004853,
0.8284494281,
0.7146492004,
-0.2812238932,
0.9976432323,
-0.2900350392,
0.4118462205,
1.3377925158,
-0.6507119536,
0.862447679,
0.4802847505,
-0.1770452112,
0.3610423505,
0.7047024369,
-0.3817260563,
0.3852804303,
0.2564461827,
-0.1740624756,
-0.2623715699,
-0.0997139812,
-0.5262331367,
0.2744690478,
0.5041207075,
-0.4851867259,
-0.2682605684,
-0.4952385128,
-0.1437269747,
-0.061913874,
-0.0726376697,
0.7872447968,
0.5771732926,
-0.4767816067,
-0.1113157123,
-0.2414233536,
0.3481092155,
-0.8062586188,
-0.42247352,
-0.3604947031,
0.1578738093,
-0.1493038237,
-0.4240077436,
0.1537909955,
-0.0719269365,
-0.2140994966,
-0.048165407,
0.9762610793,
-0.297875911,
-0.3886079192,
0.3253034651,
0.4313643575,
-0.073212184,
-0.2703544497,
-0.4565779865,
-0.3452922702,
0.0519128628,
-0.4858246744,
0.4289693832,
0.803948462,
0.1132627502,
0.645804286,
0.8391308784,
-0.1667037308,
-0.4001299441,
-0.1624451578,
0.8509139419,
-1.0622485876,
0.1268535852,
-0.6127874255,
0.1974801868,
-0.3685407937,
-0.5186264515,
0.6295868158,
0.5770533681,
0.6860572696,
-0.0391152054,
0.7365866899,
0.1355549544,
0.4176313579,
-0.1098342165,
0.4082563519,
-0.3914103806,
0.2567953169,
-0.3185059726,
-0.93079108,
-0.2338403761,
0.5991058946,
-0.4888160229,
-0.1173813343,
0.5099701881,
0.2627537549,
-0.0023776188,
0.4505837262,
-0.2153220922,
-0.0178024974,
0.076654546,
0.5406666994,
0.3266393244,
-0.580137074,
0.5278187394,
-0.4124394655,
0.0635032356,
-0.2444954365,
-0.8239281774,
-0.670231998,
-0.4567625225,
-0.3889190257,
-0.0786457509,
-0.2235991955,
0.6893417835,
0.2505007088,
-0.647849679,
-0.1857759804,
0.0959191546,
0.2015052736,
-0.125654608,
-0.2545397282,
0.5544641018,
-0.2548032403,
-0.548753202,
0.2395424098,
0.2123514712,
-0.0315056406,
-0.3855696023,
0.2733985186,
-0.3697302043,
-0.164276436,
0.1700523198,
0.5490846634,
-0.0616117306,
-0.2816100419,
-0.0800984949,
0.019538343,
-0.2024346143,
0.8520171642,
-0.5246143341,
0.2659124732,
0.4052191675,
0.9686206579,
0.6021668315,
0.325904429,
0.8350083828,
-0.6023706794,
0.0872565806,
-0.219539091,
0.3305125833,
0.0306136925,
-0.2796567976,
1.0205614567,
0.3609910309,
-0.5189792514,
-0.4969525039,
0.0323918089,
-0.7836726308,
-0.1410876662,
0.7236789465,
-0.3263311088,
-0.4929976761,
-0.241421029,
-0.0008297824,
0.0369520746,
-0.5918192267,
0.5469155908,
0.7323611379,
-0.0151063483,
-0.060410969,
-0.6670739055,
0.4191378057,
0.0936624408,
-0.6107623577,
0.5081247687,
0.5209037066,
0.304047823,
0.4278657734,
0.3916090131,
-0.1491244584,
0.2674487531,
0.2600682378,
0.0903479308,
-0.4753814936,
-0.247228682,
0.0226369631,
0.3908385932,
-0.1049984321,
-0.0119801322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13523v1 | A Study of Generative Large Language Model for Medical Research and Healthcare | 2023-05-22T22:37:24 | 2023-05-22T22:37:24 | Cheng Peng, Xi Yang, Aokun Chen, Kaleb E Smith, Nima PourNejatian, Anthony B Costa, Cheryl Martin, Mona G Flores, Ying Zhang, Tanja Magoc, Gloria Lipori, Duane A Mitchell, Naykky S Ospina, Mustafa M Ahmed, William R Hogan, Elizabeth A Shenkman, Yi Guo, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is enormous enthusiasm and concerns in using large language models
(LLMs) in healthcare, yet current assumptions are all based on general-purpose
LLMs such as ChatGPT. This study develops a clinical generative LLM,
GatorTronGPT, using 277 billion words of mixed clinical and English text with a
GPT-3 architecture of 20 billion parameters. GatorTronGPT improves biomedical
natural language processing for medical research. Synthetic NLP models trained
using GatorTronGPT generated text outperform NLP models trained using
real-world clinical text. Physicians Turing test using 1 (worst) to 9 (best)
scale shows that there is no significant difference in linguistic readability
(p = 0.22; 6.57 of GatorTronGPT compared with 6.93 of human) and clinical
relevance (p = 0.91; 7.0 of GatorTronGPT compared with 6.97 of human) and that
physicians cannot differentiate them (p < 0.001). This study provides insights
on the opportunities and challenges of LLMs for medical research and
healthcare. | [
0.0939215273,
-0.7667691708,
0.704025805,
0.1725372225,
-0.3342685401,
-0.0031578846,
-0.219114989,
-0.7269310355,
0.3570577204,
0.4659233093,
-0.1447894275,
-0.3538030088,
-0.6602702141,
0.4038826823,
-0.3907671571,
0.8494330645,
0.1874028444,
0.6439623833,
-0.1241561398,
-0.1807194054,
0.1095387861,
-0.830673337,
-0.7614585161,
-0.600069344,
0.5064203739,
-0.008176337,
0.9206621051,
0.5636383891,
0.711912632,
0.2734549344,
-0.3179736435,
-0.1114084721,
-0.325986892,
0.2712931037,
-0.1067747101,
-0.4537972212,
-0.4491966963,
-0.1418167949,
0.4917877614,
0.7809410691,
-0.4579259157,
-0.23596479,
-0.0825003758,
0.4798034132,
-0.0238795411,
0.0530208051,
-0.2956134677,
0.2462515235,
-0.2747851014,
-0.2023928016,
-0.3502471149,
-0.2498062402,
0.3807108104,
-0.4234362841,
0.5526618361,
0.3974751532,
0.8084639907,
-0.0658839568,
-0.2748648524,
-0.6137759089,
-0.7181258202,
0.5664899945,
-1.053088069,
0.3789852858,
0.1719070673,
0.3098343313,
-0.3371207118,
-1.0873254538,
-0.6497415304,
-0.6435061097,
0.0467455462,
0.1306132227,
-0.1290335804,
0.3029994369,
0.0662788972,
0.8161162138,
-0.9918965101,
0.2737678885,
-0.4547880888,
-0.0536180884,
0.4680119455,
0.4486379921,
0.7485721707,
-0.3947806656,
-0.263549298,
0.1842911988,
-0.9396877289,
-0.5714151859,
-0.0885101855,
0.1949912608,
-0.1376927644,
0.7658184767,
-0.1428142637,
0.534907043,
-0.236995548,
-0.1998096257,
0.4062440991,
-0.1343185753,
-0.6674714684,
-0.1271454841,
0.9286276102,
0.2454058379,
-0.0115562724,
-0.4213111997,
0.1462328434,
0.0301613454,
0.6074752212,
-0.9052657485,
-0.1545034498,
0.4940710366,
-0.5531012416,
-0.3084750473,
-0.4899173379,
-0.7155880928,
-0.7557160258,
-0.21973674,
0.0842112079,
-0.7590241432,
-0.1230690926,
0.6609525681,
0.1767006218,
0.2962793708,
0.2142578661,
-1.1503442526,
0.2617565691,
0.7970461249,
1.0657048225,
-0.2395384759,
-0.0199669152,
-0.0336138085,
0.0017764099,
-0.2073106915,
0.6780422926,
-0.3823203743,
-0.6680150628,
0.2329051048,
-0.015060585,
-0.2171459645,
-0.8087645769,
0.9752246737,
-0.2709616423,
0.2832151651,
0.1671259403,
-0.7278735042,
-0.1056880802,
0.4044127166,
-0.6103162169,
0.5784181952,
0.1691995114,
-0.679679215,
0.3125826716,
-0.5359812975,
-0.583183527,
0.5793502927,
-0.4761987031,
-0.5522657037,
0.4048500657,
0.2478547692,
0.5454088449,
-0.5690895319,
0.4672798812,
-0.1532438546,
-0.0715046003,
0.238692075,
-0.227610752,
0.5999571681,
0.3045049906,
-0.2147894204,
0.1232661679,
-0.6648073196,
-0.0559765249,
0.2603075206,
-0.4979415536,
-0.2176119089,
0.030609481,
0.1669932157,
0.2436238974,
-0.2834850848,
-0.6696282625,
0.224937588,
-0.8167591691,
0.8036713004,
0.199027881,
0.0330435894,
0.2231615484,
-0.5391969681,
0.8937200308,
-0.2248338461,
0.0601205714,
0.2994526923,
-0.6699537039,
-0.5856144428,
-0.5196719766,
0.2007893324,
0.3596693277,
-0.6109173298,
0.0334068015,
-0.2912091315,
-0.5213052034,
-0.6498788595,
-0.228152439,
0.2098617256,
0.6079090834,
0.4271653891,
0.1255214214,
-0.5244035125,
-0.9617266655,
-0.1714673936,
-0.1396114975,
-0.430588603,
0.4094341993,
0.5877042413,
-0.6453713775,
0.2384426743,
-0.4753921032,
-0.2800925374,
-0.5223575234,
0.1252183467,
0.1941889971,
0.2434821427,
0.5106189847,
-0.6749054193,
-0.3322975039,
0.1900313646,
-0.7481834292,
-0.000124857,
-0.0224648621,
0.0665929168,
0.0903659463,
0.4268043637,
-0.8940140009,
0.0722427517,
0.7731386423,
-0.0550540127,
0.7367160916,
-0.3716600835,
0.0857048035,
-1.2658495903,
0.2096860707,
0.0911140665,
-0.055685088,
-0.7977413535,
0.4220332801,
0.1394393444,
-0.1937843412,
-0.3711521029,
0.6019506454,
-0.4575863183,
0.5044769049,
-0.1801850945,
0.0074861324,
-0.2001555413,
-0.0404009335,
0.0206421372,
0.8539447188,
0.3916168511,
-0.4174527824,
0.517735064,
0.4607283771,
-0.5121690035,
0.5054363608,
-1.0180003643,
-0.0229310784,
0.0099864108,
0.2943504453,
-0.8160211444,
-0.6265633106,
0.031987574,
-0.5348269939,
0.3012315929,
0.1698878109,
-0.5799005032,
-0.6153145432,
-0.0832864344,
0.3043170869,
0.5814470649,
-0.3309503794,
0.435336411,
0.4698238671,
-0.6746531725,
-0.0705593452,
-0.7451327443,
0.2856412828,
-0.26308918,
-0.6893670559,
0.4228544831,
0.1451374441,
-0.0988111421,
-0.2993907332,
0.0903802589,
0.0360965468,
-0.3518711925,
0.2130006701,
0.3890935481,
-0.387013495,
0.4746072292,
-0.1952795088,
0.0620036125,
0.1606959254,
-0.0844383463,
0.7597864866,
-0.0162999351,
-0.2857984304,
-0.2146162242,
0.5378550887,
0.6888615489,
0.1986865252,
0.6452781558,
0.2101161331,
-0.3803552389,
-0.1625196636,
-0.5156233311,
0.0670503601,
-0.4449791908,
0.6953276396,
0.0325424336,
-1.0593481064,
0.3114944994,
-0.1487350911,
-0.0615805127,
0.5341668129,
1.0217761993,
0.0475930311,
1.048713088,
0.4125851393,
-0.1113013625,
-0.1183268428,
0.0466760322,
0.3387477994,
-0.973932147,
-0.3832345605,
-0.7136271596,
-0.1189566627,
-0.5552908778,
-0.5142256021,
0.5529654026,
-0.3004893661,
-0.0860414505,
-0.0646053031,
-0.6190204024,
0.0998327658,
0.2942288518,
0.220246762,
0.3397589922,
0.0100856358,
-0.4934053123,
-0.1546446979,
-0.5204167962,
-0.5706312656,
1.0777854919,
0.460580349,
0.9051430225,
0.2393951714,
0.4694475234,
0.0146616055,
0.4285327792,
-0.9426962137,
0.494335711,
-0.2583727241,
-0.6785154343,
-0.179327175,
-0.4258696139,
-1.1595129967,
0.4385352731,
-0.1993287504,
-0.49379614,
-0.3743401468,
0.0753106996,
-0.4494294524,
0.2413865179,
-0.4854719639,
0.3527193666,
-0.0892771855,
-0.0168626588,
-0.0795821175,
-0.6085840464,
0.417661041,
0.0086237406,
0.1299690306,
0.0653593019,
0.0579172298,
0.4848166704,
-0.3309375942,
0.6721376777,
0.2532408834,
-0.0786416605,
-0.2093101293,
-0.0732043684,
0.4160516262,
0.1221917793,
-0.1196670458,
0.0608594976,
-0.0141748264,
-0.3368353546,
-0.3137490153,
0.7091595531,
-0.5642725825,
-0.6725286245,
-0.7530938983,
-0.540158987,
-0.557752192,
-0.0156111671,
0.4552079141,
0.3579857945,
-0.5409155488,
0.3338829875,
0.5743429065,
-0.5564950705,
-0.1007639244,
0.413426578,
-0.2480279952,
-0.5054226518,
0.42588377,
-0.2312202901,
0.4589955807,
0.3244074583,
0.4752512276,
-0.4599943459,
-0.9679119587,
-0.4024916291,
0.5628237128,
-0.2532254159,
0.0252333786,
-0.7825890183,
-0.5983476043,
-0.6101616025,
-0.2333251089,
0.0469033346,
-0.1266396493,
-0.3682904243,
-0.11855039,
0.1642245799,
0.7482222915,
0.1695946306,
0.2578350604,
-0.8103427887,
0.4734829068,
0.1367674321,
0.229543373,
-0.0690658987,
-0.622533679,
-0.0011265818,
-0.0369790606,
-0.2434640527,
-0.6487196088,
0.8565849066,
0.1043973938,
0.6039548516,
0.4437321126,
-0.308039546,
0.5024437308,
-0.9001501203,
0.9371632338,
0.4342110455,
-0.4724625945,
0.3621646762,
-0.5360951424,
0.3497729599,
0.3035713732,
0.4881997705,
-0.866219759,
-0.504947722,
-0.5964028239,
-0.9588289857,
0.2192091644,
0.1054301858,
0.3442119956,
-0.1995889395,
0.3422307372,
0.0941217244,
0.0908790231,
-0.535802424,
0.0713593736,
0.2508085966,
-0.2341718823,
-0.276414603,
-0.523040235,
-0.2991186976,
-0.3870505393,
0.5750622749,
-0.0163532309,
0.4310738444,
0.373801589,
0.1014418229,
0.1476835161,
0.5818892717,
0.8883873224,
0.413405627,
-0.0838997513,
0.1588808,
-0.0104916235,
-1.1014164686,
0.108156465,
0.2190576196,
-0.1638001204,
0.0314935185,
0.4827257395,
0.4994405508,
0.1372662038,
-0.8262065649,
0.2925257087,
0.0082285088,
-0.6080735922,
-0.1088010743,
-0.0308645405,
0.5099847317,
0.1337299943,
0.0870585665,
-0.2349291444,
0.3172967136,
-0.4137252271,
0.1193816513,
0.4231058657,
-0.1222185045,
-0.2525090277,
0.8229011893,
0.3151039183,
-0.1693806797,
0.804679215,
0.1077083051,
-0.3764063716,
0.4189092815,
0.8762826324,
0.7504182458,
-0.3104631603,
0.4378510714,
0.2531200051,
0.0974018574,
-0.3316060305,
0.2570186555,
0.5177454352,
-0.5443574786,
-0.4460410178,
-0.9266276956,
-0.6384770274,
0.6108348966,
-0.4812663496,
-0.0103070093,
-0.4238798022,
-0.177168563,
0.363527596,
-0.1312042922,
-0.4251912534,
0.3110322356,
0.0196968112,
0.7176092863,
-0.4825031757,
0.795170784,
0.7311796546,
-0.2198608667,
-0.7712578177,
-0.1112041473,
0.1561312228,
-1.1447314024,
0.3445247114,
-0.0152465133,
0.2181060314,
-0.2243489027,
-0.5412720442,
-0.4112316668,
0.8163217306,
0.3138081431,
-0.6795769334,
-0.442576021,
0.5090361834,
0.8979240656,
-0.1852947474,
-0.1216210723,
0.5539371967,
-0.0018908096,
0.4646773934,
-1.0175088644,
0.0379292257,
-0.3673348129,
0.0903913975,
0.1428396404,
-0.4208294451,
0.9511306882,
-0.321100533,
-0.2409756333,
0.4336712956,
0.2139911354,
0.425532639,
0.0920645446,
0.0337290801,
0.6880685091,
0.8149319887,
0.0215412751,
1.2897200584,
0.004603541,
0.4847925603,
0.989390552,
-0.5667532682,
0.6902802587,
0.4736292362,
-0.4061433971,
0.2559194863,
0.3283062279,
-0.0257996358,
0.2400545627,
0.6070453525,
-0.7795553207,
-0.0610612519,
0.066374965,
-0.6193410754,
0.2021120638,
0.5851134062,
-0.7760220766,
-0.1139670387,
0.1911700964,
0.3466854393,
-0.0193105992,
-0.0903129056,
0.5952046514,
0.4633465707,
-0.4249153733,
0.5813723803,
0.0408454686,
0.557841599,
-0.7533216476,
0.1264475286,
-0.0317183957,
0.3560555577,
-0.0935954228,
-0.565785408,
0.3175312579,
-0.1151918173,
0.0633396953,
0.0498337559,
0.6636860967,
-0.1939636916,
-0.7097277641,
0.114186652,
0.3333134353,
0.1706571877,
-0.0300348401,
-0.4380782247,
-0.1051487103,
-0.1318790019,
-0.235012427,
0.4541784525,
0.3905034065,
0.1875320673,
0.8791146278,
0.6098588705,
0.7292875051,
-0.0961645991,
0.2431084216,
0.789943099,
-0.8412303925,
-0.4375109673,
-0.9649063945,
0.0667154789,
-0.144226104,
-0.5452076197,
0.4611825347,
0.5463653207,
0.2394601405,
-0.2547497749,
0.8485498428,
0.0005260818,
0.7530593276,
-0.6046648622,
0.8892259598,
-0.4937710464,
-0.0913275704,
-0.1180354357,
-0.2055902332,
-0.865967989,
0.4662512243,
-0.2226489186,
-0.0256412327,
0.8022677898,
0.6214011312,
0.1018549353,
0.3240274191,
0.5762317181,
0.435044378,
0.5607720613,
0.6760365367,
0.6820107698,
-0.0276859235,
0.2571438253,
0.0712277666,
-0.2264575809,
-0.4518773854,
-0.6216046214,
-0.9182839394,
-0.2579889596,
-0.0321203806,
-0.460331589,
0.0052989256,
0.7465515137,
0.5409978032,
-0.7258546352,
0.1526478231,
-0.2098413259,
-0.5710673332,
-0.1701153219,
-0.1944187731,
0.5556628704,
-0.2707617283,
-0.5331716537,
0.2446930856,
0.5041831136,
0.2357640713,
-0.2376224846,
-0.0321181044,
-0.0593638085,
0.216087386,
0.7696569562,
0.3081351817,
-0.7640684843,
-0.2010971457,
0.0889786109,
-0.5657690167,
0.1331112087,
0.8745157719,
-0.4075914919,
0.4923508465,
0.3491739631,
0.7132430673,
0.446072191,
-0.0897313654,
0.6901296377,
-0.1924308985,
0.0213070996,
0.7841057181,
0.4300609529,
0.3505529165,
-0.3572639525,
0.5560135841,
0.1876399368,
-0.978205204,
-0.6029254794,
0.1701878607,
-1.1685657501,
-0.0341170616,
1.4253017902,
0.031461224,
0.0276226792,
-0.2485673726,
-0.4799141288,
0.0445544757,
-0.0462502092,
0.9354633689,
0.6030362844,
-0.3960744739,
-0.0300352871,
-1.0872038603,
0.564083755,
0.4257701635,
-0.9538401961,
-0.1392384022,
0.4733793139,
0.3446694613,
-0.0114064831,
0.8652338386,
-0.5619168878,
0.0549101308,
-0.0637950748,
0.0286765695,
0.1319937706,
0.2102696449,
-0.381067574,
0.2042806894,
0.012126754,
-0.1450827718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13521v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13521v2 | CEO: Corpus-based Open-Domain Event Ontology Induction | 2023-05-22T22:26:47 | 2024-01-27T21:06:23 | Nan Xu, Hongming Zhang, Jianshu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing event-centric NLP models often only apply to the pre-defined
ontology, which significantly restricts their generalization capabilities. This
paper presents CEO, a novel Corpus-based Event Ontology induction model to
relax the restriction imposed by pre-defined event ontologies. Without direct
supervision, CEO leverages distant supervision from available summary datasets
to detect corpus-wise salient events and exploits external event knowledge to
force events within a short distance to have close embeddings. Experiments on
three popular event datasets show that the schema induced by CEO has better
coverage and higher accuracy than previous methods. Moreover, CEO is the first
event ontology induction model that can induce a hierarchical event ontology
with meaningful names on eleven open-domain corpora, making the induced schema
more trustworthy and easier to be further curated. | [
-0.2164503783,
-0.2926295102,
0.4644468427,
0.0189897157,
-0.0690887794,
-0.2090747058,
-0.484017849,
-0.5486635566,
0.4513382912,
0.6222431064,
-0.6999393106,
-0.9041612148,
-0.6293391585,
-0.0025405509,
-0.6344782114,
1.1453202963,
0.5075362921,
-0.3279332817,
-0.0657211542,
0.1975378692,
-0.0052231685,
-0.7360467911,
-0.599953711,
0.0390714891,
0.4765876234,
0.4990460277,
0.8160497546,
0.5171320438,
0.6474016905,
0.0729164407,
-0.1605934203,
0.4486358166,
-0.589590013,
-0.2414463162,
-0.3325828612,
-0.5500926375,
-0.4949778914,
-0.1168819517,
0.4284169078,
0.9105389714,
-0.289458096,
-0.0005240105,
0.1385513693,
0.244129613,
-1.1231632233,
0.2354699671,
-1.0779136419,
0.2239024043,
-0.30735147,
-0.333132416,
-0.551060617,
0.0094805928,
-0.0125677781,
-1.0334146023,
0.2912929058,
0.0930948704,
0.6164537668,
0.1624815315,
0.0202864837,
-0.5191798806,
-0.8102354407,
1.0798106194,
-0.1310167611,
0.5811167955,
0.3141587973,
0.0444177426,
-0.1644246727,
-1.1230232716,
-0.7744125724,
-0.0567687936,
-0.0236249175,
0.0267615262,
-0.1680679768,
-0.0602664948,
-0.1291827857,
0.18258591,
-0.1049818918,
0.4121887982,
-0.1842112839,
0.2410179973,
0.2350205034,
0.1587641388,
0.3248314559,
-0.2557549477,
-0.5260934234,
0.1960926503,
-0.9202263951,
-0.0956485718,
0.0155057982,
0.5343734622,
0.0200637449,
0.3778603673,
-0.3560789824,
0.155139029,
0.5035284162,
0.0678718016,
0.1146061644,
-0.4695587456,
-0.2276657522,
0.6157929897,
0.687857151,
0.2438259572,
0.2179903239,
-0.7239384651,
0.2299151719,
0.2620232701,
0.1579335332,
-0.6177377105,
-0.0866156369,
0.6161589622,
-0.2885486782,
-0.5628559589,
0.0157090463,
-0.682605803,
-0.3557197452,
-0.000460182,
0.0332513712,
-0.3332922161,
-0.2276923358,
0.1024946645,
-0.1656749696,
0.2882170081,
0.1994905174,
-1.2036669254,
0.1586156934,
1.0143768787,
0.5227225423,
-0.3980641961,
-0.2498577237,
-0.8466371298,
0.4812912047,
-0.5108575821,
0.7487220764,
-0.7442947626,
-0.1808494776,
0.3154932261,
-0.0362433568,
0.1183586344,
-0.4280229807,
1.0676145554,
-0.6313294172,
0.0473816432,
0.0776499584,
-0.3791942596,
0.263402611,
0.1101363525,
-0.2961317301,
0.9479989409,
-0.0593012832,
-0.7572733164,
0.7678605914,
-0.7772926688,
-0.0254195835,
0.2740097046,
-0.474817425,
-0.1455974281,
-0.1597781032,
0.300996244,
0.5027755499,
-0.0054710503,
0.3902232349,
-0.3218739927,
-0.0425108112,
0.0581225529,
0.4289608598,
0.7181248665,
-0.0633109733,
-0.0101475222,
0.2093499899,
-0.9746992588,
0.0041303933,
-0.0201881621,
0.2379643172,
-0.7042481303,
-0.0259186849,
-0.1359692365,
0.1166454852,
0.2190121561,
-0.6568005681,
0.272698015,
-0.6610920429,
0.2184090465,
0.3832644522,
0.1200284287,
0.9767084718,
-0.0166007336,
0.3825504482,
0.203382045,
0.2893407643,
-0.3275852203,
-0.6732838154,
-0.3882297277,
-0.4869493544,
0.3474519849,
0.6262844801,
-0.3231376708,
0.8963696361,
-0.3545539677,
-0.4174597561,
-0.2582919896,
-0.0376536176,
0.1857259423,
0.4674144089,
0.362195313,
-0.3920977712,
-0.8991490602,
-0.5802984834,
-0.1811237186,
-0.0148058068,
-0.2627913952,
-0.1332188398,
0.3086087406,
-0.3714036345,
0.824487865,
-0.3989833593,
-0.7685731649,
-0.1056552753,
0.0746052489,
0.1170219928,
0.4604238272,
0.4164924324,
-0.7901670933,
-0.1519732773,
0.1565478444,
-0.8835696578,
-0.1604142338,
-0.1174833328,
-0.6419955492,
0.0959125608,
0.6935114861,
-0.6286230087,
0.6778509021,
0.4856512547,
-0.3928001523,
0.6095256805,
0.114988625,
0.0121277096,
-0.9668436646,
-0.033544153,
-0.6565569639,
-0.0139434235,
-0.693908751,
0.058955878,
0.1867289394,
-0.085429512,
-0.3890509903,
0.1337749213,
-0.216984272,
-0.1963919103,
-0.402680099,
0.5543350577,
0.1039943397,
0.3914298713,
0.337590307,
0.1104396507,
0.7094951868,
-1.0476249456,
0.1561624706,
1.3808083534,
-0.5038281679,
0.4982462823,
-0.1362894177,
-0.0316574387,
-0.0194361471,
0.301681757,
-0.6132535338,
-0.0652429014,
0.1441773027,
-0.5584155321,
-0.0703436807,
-0.2274979949,
-0.6225459576,
0.0376827978,
-0.0837330595,
0.0851772428,
0.5710294247,
-1.0532827377,
0.6027197242,
0.2883223593,
-0.1878862679,
-0.6856940389,
-0.8363927603,
0.3090192676,
-0.0443115011,
-0.8055970669,
1.1481204033,
0.0876581743,
-0.3924919367,
0.2360056341,
0.1249304935,
-0.2631351948,
-0.2311553955,
0.5451990962,
0.1879874915,
-0.2178390771,
0.2796214223,
0.3127811253,
-0.1721315235,
-0.1230877563,
-0.6604047418,
0.1399224699,
0.2071393579,
-0.2117679864,
-0.9780128002,
0.6069396734,
0.4072008431,
-0.2907063365,
0.9448280931,
0.2826845348,
-0.4296154976,
-0.4358537495,
-0.1189055368,
-0.3702325821,
-0.4235550463,
0.1891649663,
-0.285403192,
-0.8159970641,
0.5075743198,
-0.2667452693,
0.1103139073,
0.6524194479,
0.7685329318,
0.3133044243,
0.83803159,
0.7988272905,
0.416354984,
0.4306228161,
-0.0728765503,
0.2659632862,
-0.6559922695,
-0.3268977106,
-0.6447992921,
0.0660913512,
-0.510185957,
-0.3616529405,
0.2215739638,
0.3092502058,
0.0199507549,
0.1731468886,
-0.5922085047,
0.2794311047,
0.5965164304,
-0.1834464669,
0.6374863386,
-0.2049777955,
-0.0756846368,
0.1015598997,
-0.9740686417,
-0.4233315587,
0.9091637731,
-0.2348672748,
0.3931568563,
-0.1725683212,
0.7720707059,
0.1948270202,
0.1409457177,
-0.3144667745,
0.2708759308,
-0.2256434709,
-0.6175097823,
-0.326035887,
-0.0075548152,
-0.9575307369,
-0.0651331246,
-0.4451525807,
-0.7359618545,
0.5798439384,
0.0277826879,
-0.6628364325,
0.3050352037,
-0.4390765131,
0.72267735,
0.2189572304,
-0.1716316044,
-0.1424733549,
-0.3506218493,
0.4275999367,
-0.4022102952,
0.495018959,
-0.2637263834,
-0.1388011873,
0.7344635725,
-0.598315239,
1.019402504,
0.0713640228,
-0.0277612396,
0.554905653,
0.0030042287,
0.8354922533,
0.1565604359,
-0.1458587795,
0.3266290128,
0.1012254357,
-0.2193191051,
-0.5513496399,
0.9643101096,
-0.575956285,
-0.2392568886,
0.1063195691,
-0.2076220065,
-0.3491937518,
-0.0777985901,
0.597192049,
0.1032578573,
-0.3353477418,
0.2644151151,
0.4323214889,
-0.184538871,
0.1237428114,
0.4792402983,
-0.316044122,
-0.0823509768,
0.2446553856,
-0.0463019647,
0.0818592682,
0.5724177957,
0.1378231347,
-0.0504456498,
-0.35526824,
-0.311247915,
-0.3574337661,
-0.5959804058,
-0.0901380405,
-1.141702652,
0.0224076658,
-0.7850752473,
-0.5683259964,
-0.5193451047,
-0.9625340104,
-0.3282062709,
-0.2810296118,
0.3943317235,
0.2133594006,
-0.3892941773,
0.6003489494,
-0.6712585688,
0.4758701622,
0.069654122,
0.3284707069,
-0.0664789379,
-0.6668046117,
-0.1534733921,
-0.3898507655,
-0.3308475912,
-0.5631141663,
0.3308444321,
0.6731521487,
0.3539247811,
0.9872478843,
0.4539521039,
0.3404892087,
-0.5633097291,
0.8140202761,
0.3606873453,
-0.8912600279,
0.6976261735,
-0.4130234122,
0.0399694741,
0.3420426548,
0.6089945436,
-0.414642036,
-0.6888998747,
-0.9762598276,
-0.8226672411,
0.6545577645,
0.3527626097,
0.0029839186,
-0.1862831116,
0.4698652923,
0.5185911655,
0.1595495343,
-0.3397696018,
-0.0569090135,
-0.0261165928,
-0.0333873183,
0.2749099731,
-0.3141993582,
0.0763405338,
0.0750175118,
0.6103870869,
0.045847889,
0.2914910614,
0.275813967,
0.1880065054,
-0.2158613801,
0.2218908221,
0.1015556231,
0.6709353924,
-0.0843439549,
0.2070584744,
0.4276167154,
-0.2505360544,
-0.6728867292,
-0.0143749909,
-0.0458366647,
0.0605905168,
0.4056981206,
0.2452895343,
0.5740483999,
-0.6064736247,
0.65330863,
0.090193063,
-0.1472595781,
-0.7257176638,
0.1016070768,
-0.1129261851,
0.2172533423,
0.5119981766,
-0.2630341351,
0.0519341342,
-0.4009575844,
0.5370585322,
0.1787391305,
-0.5397507548,
-0.4156984389,
0.9874763489,
0.1612566113,
-0.0081357397,
0.4917655289,
-0.2437439859,
-0.3864630163,
0.4776452184,
0.3702160716,
0.5900777578,
-0.2620343566,
-0.2256827205,
0.4979466498,
0.2878507376,
0.278801471,
0.4197641611,
0.0306268129,
-0.9786682129,
-0.7574673295,
-0.8516613245,
-0.7904108167,
-0.0151625825,
-0.6813570857,
0.6347550154,
-0.3499113023,
0.0447004884,
0.4549047649,
-0.4199643433,
-0.5053224564,
0.1432582885,
0.27505216,
1.1200264692,
-0.6041722298,
0.811171174,
0.2152376771,
-0.2824229002,
-0.2207192779,
-0.1575126648,
-0.3346609473,
-0.7098659873,
0.8672685027,
0.0115967542,
-0.0534691699,
0.0475478731,
-0.6851031184,
-0.6910425425,
0.7530472279,
-0.0219328552,
-0.4811862111,
-0.251437366,
0.2205000222,
0.4170033634,
-0.7525542378,
-0.2319372594,
0.2968318164,
0.4653433263,
0.0289615635,
-0.7186080813,
-0.0735373795,
0.2011953443,
-0.5251752734,
0.319062233,
-0.2410075814,
0.457698375,
-0.4416539669,
-0.1486767381,
0.2251797169,
1.1239972115,
0.1373280138,
0.6647353172,
0.4709843695,
0.4366934597,
0.9276509285,
0.1703491211,
0.9790440202,
-0.6839846373,
0.0488943271,
1.2569657564,
-0.4668168426,
0.9001383185,
0.2416946888,
0.1248772889,
1.0537772179,
0.0900796205,
0.0653074235,
0.7252501845,
-0.0220551081,
-0.4591782093,
-0.493781507,
-0.555046618,
-0.4135245681,
0.7526410222,
0.5907951593,
-0.5933173299,
-0.2088979334,
0.1540652663,
-0.0368188508,
0.2298501879,
-0.6684960127,
0.5400887132,
0.2167581469,
-0.6622779369,
0.3853705227,
0.3631637096,
0.4711874425,
-0.7854687572,
0.2655505538,
0.2557754815,
0.3940626085,
-0.4344640672,
-0.4508111179,
0.7917964458,
0.0812811255,
-0.3133080006,
-0.1277646869,
0.8730039597,
-0.332069397,
-0.1297773868,
0.4702695608,
0.2646540999,
0.0833029076,
-0.5700862408,
0.0123470537,
-0.0091474513,
-0.4776175916,
-0.0823574141,
0.3408060968,
0.7796247602,
-0.231299445,
0.185424149,
0.838994205,
-0.372053653,
0.1202982068,
-0.1428365707,
0.6230267286,
-0.7981750369,
-1.0377726555,
-0.5895169973,
0.1776173413,
-0.0632120296,
-0.4969267249,
0.5713655353,
0.6409793496,
0.5948292017,
-0.1196762919,
0.9541950822,
0.0461574048,
0.6462742686,
-0.2517186999,
0.5043689609,
-0.2550620735,
-0.2790554166,
0.0503130741,
-0.2698589861,
-0.5802630186,
0.0843759254,
-0.3200197816,
-0.3371543288,
0.777797699,
0.6483152509,
-0.1005562618,
0.6007403135,
0.6778885126,
0.2939080596,
-0.2164773047,
0.6418716908,
0.9593600035,
-0.0279117916,
0.9190554023,
-0.1142122447,
-0.5985741019,
-0.5876370668,
-1.0064022541,
-0.9190048575,
-0.7710483074,
-0.485349834,
-0.3699944615,
0.1422964185,
0.7361245751,
0.9075223207,
-0.9732736945,
0.449940443,
-0.2363160402,
-0.1277795732,
-0.388674885,
-0.1802440733,
0.5635086298,
-0.5938513875,
-0.7572265863,
0.6642848253,
0.3057432771,
-0.5451384187,
-0.051959075,
0.3978838623,
0.0708875731,
0.2749608755,
0.8433021903,
0.2405404747,
-0.4383859038,
-0.2931658626,
-0.2050058246,
-0.0750548989,
0.0131738689,
0.6448013783,
-0.8734754324,
-0.0545215197,
0.4086070657,
0.4433402419,
0.2989697158,
-0.2848821282,
0.2373006046,
-0.9649083614,
0.2662101984,
0.0985955447,
0.2069994509,
-0.0218919478,
-0.8066749573,
0.592615068,
0.2905889452,
-0.5085567236,
-0.7385644913,
0.5140879154,
-1.3279237747,
-0.0957000181,
1.1922397614,
0.1755028963,
-0.2756890655,
-0.2801243961,
0.0849141628,
0.2547634244,
-0.1375727654,
0.8718184233,
0.3084514737,
-0.3583129942,
0.3526632786,
-0.3693459928,
0.6903887987,
0.253564775,
-0.6415892839,
0.3227082491,
0.0964786708,
-0.1576665938,
0.4963810146,
0.5145493746,
-0.3485091627,
0.4761478007,
0.0340173542,
0.579649806,
-0.1098335236,
-0.536947906,
-0.0054050754,
0.7660135031,
-0.2092413008,
-0.2954421341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13516v1 | Scaling Speech Technology to 1,000+ Languages | 2023-05-22T22:09:41 | 2023-05-22T22:09:41 | Vineel Pratap, Andros Tjandra, Bowen Shi, Paden Tomasello, Arun Babu, Sayani Kundu, Ali Elkahky, Zhaoheng Ni, Apoorv Vyas, Maryam Fazel-Zarandi, Alexei Baevski, Yossi Adi, Xiaohui Zhang, Wei-Ning Hsu, Alexis Conneau, Michael Auli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Expanding the language coverage of speech technology has the potential to
improve access to information for many more people. However, current speech
technology is restricted to about one hundred languages which is a small
fraction of the over 7,000 languages spoken around the world. The Massively
Multilingual Speech (MMS) project increases the number of supported languages
by 10-40x, depending on the task. The main ingredients are a new dataset based
on readings of publicly available religious texts and effectively leveraging
self-supervised learning. We built pre-trained wav2vec 2.0 models covering
1,406 languages, a single multilingual automatic speech recognition model for
1,107 languages, speech synthesis models for the same number of languages, as
well as a language identification model for 4,017 languages. Experiments show
that our multilingual speech recognition model more than halves the word error
rate of Whisper on 54 languages of the FLEURS benchmark while being trained on
a small fraction of the labeled data. | [
-0.4203774333,
-0.3442180455,
0.0410016626,
0.4893915057,
0.0149778426,
0.0437558554,
-0.2767195702,
-0.6205748916,
-0.0321884155,
0.5200141668,
-0.4222008586,
-0.1699658632,
-0.7936071157,
0.1352283806,
-0.2779432535,
0.7980129123,
0.3743908703,
0.1972014159,
0.2624249756,
-0.358730197,
-0.2711932361,
-0.3698697686,
-0.7647176981,
-0.0168866348,
0.5814019442,
0.6411168575,
0.6720375419,
0.7357591391,
0.4773249328,
0.3186979592,
-0.0977913216,
0.0368169174,
-0.3963259161,
-0.0797883347,
0.0997790769,
-0.3687660694,
-0.5168002844,
0.0476136133,
0.9220048189,
0.7294282317,
-0.1638110131,
0.5490865707,
0.0454148427,
0.6029476523,
-0.1900602281,
0.1715236902,
-0.5742237568,
-0.1761714965,
-0.3812501729,
-0.0393269248,
-0.4051003158,
-0.1613921821,
0.4871121347,
-0.6306014061,
-0.0350541659,
-0.3397060037,
0.1913515031,
0.0631778911,
-0.5221495628,
-0.371306479,
-0.8076803684,
0.8961269259,
-0.5041463375,
0.7087677717,
0.6300945878,
0.3546560705,
0.1625055671,
-0.642324388,
-0.3253269494,
-0.1292840242,
0.442116648,
-0.0316145979,
-0.2582849264,
-0.1484028697,
0.3669859171,
-0.0094173308,
-0.6016490459,
0.2713826597,
-0.776851058,
-0.3735920489,
0.4866507649,
-0.2038475424,
0.1047748923,
0.1157040298,
-0.1358519346,
-0.2586227953,
-0.5805669427,
0.1353578717,
0.2449876517,
0.5744193792,
-0.1533277929,
0.4967619181,
0.0351542234,
0.7940680981,
-0.3925063908,
-0.6074151993,
0.4559035897,
-0.4023062587,
-0.2852078974,
0.1792454571,
0.5711073875,
0.2305001169,
0.4072675705,
0.1441200972,
0.2976819277,
0.0986426547,
0.2669997811,
-0.8555762768,
0.2242247313,
0.0703485757,
-0.2563440204,
0.0381728858,
-0.1908016354,
-0.4067175984,
-0.4531267881,
-0.2127979845,
0.3861744106,
-0.4921183288,
-0.741904974,
0.2633047104,
-0.2079894096,
0.1295851469,
0.1881310493,
-0.9013479948,
0.2187947035,
0.5750961304,
1.0183769464,
0.2027030885,
-0.4967397451,
-0.4949838519,
-0.119550325,
-0.637475431,
0.630450666,
-0.5105600953,
-0.7177737355,
0.0986951515,
-0.0215539578,
0.1089505851,
-0.6322947145,
0.483074069,
-0.2105564475,
0.0339021422,
-0.4093369246,
-0.4357508719,
-0.0677041039,
-0.2449268848,
-0.5677033663,
0.9351252913,
0.1875924468,
-0.4786478877,
0.4098289609,
-0.4089893401,
-0.6643590927,
0.1899173409,
-0.0787529126,
-0.2994151711,
0.270208776,
-0.0218201354,
0.1986385286,
-0.1723306179,
0.1209113523,
-0.0486207381,
-0.2101281434,
0.059093263,
-0.5058498979,
0.7243843675,
0.6034418344,
-0.2437468171,
0.0387577526,
-0.9230545759,
0.0784146488,
-0.225232929,
-0.4897433817,
-0.1256249249,
0.0132467858,
0.1455987841,
0.4881842434,
0.0478540771,
-0.82586658,
0.087412931,
-0.6443149447,
0.7046855092,
0.4199003875,
-0.412247926,
0.5003800988,
-0.1408729851,
0.5880240798,
-0.0918195471,
0.1643950492,
-0.5279925466,
-0.7971373796,
-0.7445750237,
-0.3172368705,
0.2167634666,
0.6260506511,
-0.5894553661,
0.1497773826,
-0.4617045522,
-0.6397138834,
-1.0083765984,
0.0462217405,
0.4202731848,
0.3836468756,
0.2384290248,
-0.1129257903,
-0.6338569522,
-1.0173420906,
-0.1425720602,
-0.3129283786,
-0.4137275219,
0.0988419726,
0.1593696922,
-0.0654426962,
0.7588298321,
0.0312324185,
-0.5125307441,
-0.0588743128,
0.0493488982,
0.095891729,
0.4204254746,
0.2710705101,
-0.9019905925,
-0.4361021817,
0.2340370566,
-0.4186843038,
0.1078833714,
0.0835957825,
0.3049223721,
0.2106022686,
0.5308318734,
-0.0151717775,
0.1443902254,
0.9250469208,
-0.1471598744,
0.2186041921,
-0.5349254608,
0.115536809,
-1.2786859274,
-0.3480435014,
0.1359234452,
-0.1617862731,
-0.794613421,
-0.260984689,
0.2247085869,
-0.2991708517,
-0.6917817593,
0.4400976896,
-0.4449030161,
-0.0685406923,
-0.4256685674,
0.0386376604,
-0.4525444508,
0.1067133099,
0.1015725508,
0.9630007148,
1.0247666836,
-0.5677819848,
0.3543840349,
0.1121752188,
-0.4692766368,
0.5388576388,
-0.6074331403,
-0.1002782583,
0.0746964216,
0.3624247015,
-1.065690279,
-0.108824864,
-0.4994540215,
-0.7352567315,
0.163264662,
-0.1647948474,
-0.4094492197,
-0.5097278953,
-0.0486565866,
0.367698729,
0.5521088839,
-0.6160151362,
0.6346324086,
0.8656459451,
-0.4292984605,
-0.3440986574,
-0.9039286971,
0.3284469247,
-0.0635096058,
-0.784016192,
-0.1258428544,
-0.1692311317,
-0.2030864954,
-0.4031933546,
-0.0760440826,
-0.1512153149,
-0.1208100542,
0.4309400618,
-0.1685089022,
-0.1468679458,
0.4635888338,
-0.0489606708,
-0.2281513214,
-0.0821849406,
-0.7134334445,
0.5535417795,
-0.2457893342,
-0.3232171535,
-0.5503305197,
0.6343798637,
0.5756676197,
-0.4187719822,
0.5333942175,
0.6206265688,
-0.4151177704,
0.0320015065,
-0.6540011168,
0.1492632329,
-0.5210247636,
0.5999335051,
-0.8687918186,
-1.1912647486,
0.4086678326,
-0.110367246,
0.1888231635,
0.6545568705,
0.7024914026,
0.1154487655,
1.1161708832,
0.7845687866,
-0.3770047724,
0.4480828047,
-0.0066400333,
-0.1880801171,
-0.3369202614,
-0.177519083,
-0.649557054,
0.0999993682,
-1.0691511631,
-0.7543488741,
0.5069053173,
-0.1874782592,
0.0469425321,
0.5558412075,
-0.5416894555,
0.3821616471,
0.7722508311,
-0.1638737917,
0.1405082941,
0.4790519178,
0.0071287355,
-0.1597742438,
-0.6020871997,
-0.3960466385,
1.0510714054,
0.5915281177,
0.5462281704,
0.2932792008,
0.3790915608,
0.2063846588,
0.178901881,
-0.73447299,
0.2410103232,
-0.3561588228,
-0.8095478415,
-0.5760188103,
-0.4721871018,
-0.7920024991,
0.2563061118,
0.0196526013,
-0.4404396713,
0.0711106434,
0.0316584334,
-0.2280666679,
0.1831634045,
-0.8966917396,
0.4088184536,
0.0000379821,
0.036812216,
-0.5231485367,
-0.7169237137,
-0.0697719902,
-0.4235065579,
0.6503240466,
-0.0622558072,
0.0252806526,
0.9092124701,
-0.2699562907,
0.7025875449,
-0.0807161927,
-0.4731178284,
0.3653212786,
-0.1311429143,
0.2340166718,
-0.1901451647,
-0.3046148121,
0.3757187724,
0.0045099123,
-0.5987955928,
-0.0735461861,
0.6845503449,
-0.6493160725,
-0.3256563544,
-0.2889358699,
-0.4655665457,
-0.4178812504,
0.11544431,
0.3213191628,
0.707087636,
-0.2932001054,
0.2692566216,
0.6135863662,
-0.3052679896,
0.3868873119,
0.8714396954,
-0.1908805668,
-0.5372043252,
1.1479256153,
0.603051722,
0.5076207519,
0.2060537934,
0.2762815356,
-0.3136487603,
-0.4632800817,
-0.6567564011,
0.3203894496,
-0.5329099298,
0.2975450456,
-0.7170994878,
-0.1648142487,
-0.8038275838,
0.1028978825,
-0.4985633492,
-0.5629358292,
-0.1460074335,
-0.1541674584,
0.2265800387,
0.8790051937,
-0.3087746203,
0.5154094696,
-0.6419566274,
0.2833396196,
0.4027406275,
0.4822792709,
-0.2937172055,
-1.1300144196,
-0.3553775251,
0.065894939,
0.0761430562,
-0.6389780641,
0.3192420304,
0.4936903119,
0.2436547428,
0.3635315895,
-0.4057690203,
1.0356146097,
-1.0601862669,
0.6187043786,
0.4543975294,
-0.8470711112,
0.5598535538,
-0.4594728649,
0.5845115185,
0.3057124913,
0.3996371031,
-0.8752709627,
-0.483884573,
-0.5481724143,
-0.5197352171,
0.5954307318,
0.0356985182,
0.461512059,
-0.0297236014,
0.2328624874,
0.1042082086,
-0.1051741615,
-0.3007856011,
-0.3289239407,
-0.1947316378,
-0.0954154804,
-0.3694443405,
-0.4505954981,
-0.0581444725,
-0.378917098,
0.6838873625,
-0.1177625805,
0.0341977142,
0.0484162234,
0.0357022807,
-0.1629423946,
0.2708929479,
0.8345165849,
0.7286993265,
0.0031897898,
0.0601671897,
0.2643048167,
-0.7700898647,
0.203806445,
0.2691824138,
0.0429804437,
-0.048710756,
0.4399526119,
0.898876965,
-0.0816690475,
-0.7196421623,
0.2412286848,
-0.0727608204,
-0.3443876505,
-0.4156084061,
-0.0791463405,
0.3888527751,
0.3234329522,
0.5467939973,
-0.0423211791,
0.0484315306,
-0.3884036243,
0.4302619398,
0.4177000523,
-0.585740447,
-0.3456316888,
0.6982650161,
0.3897345066,
-0.5202465057,
0.3104016781,
-0.0217749458,
-0.2024321854,
0.4424583316,
0.5547495484,
0.4186943173,
-0.7922441959,
0.2175896317,
0.6659168601,
0.5969254971,
-0.3172586858,
0.3192916512,
-0.0434463955,
-0.4000421464,
-0.5615693927,
-0.7062596679,
-0.4418816864,
-0.0846129432,
-0.6504486799,
0.1929347962,
-0.0757139251,
-0.3702940643,
0.3668124378,
0.0190450009,
-0.4782086015,
0.3357535303,
0.469874233,
1.0944113731,
-0.8937340379,
1.3417526484,
0.4069586396,
-0.1332384646,
-0.7330778837,
-0.5116400123,
0.1702027321,
-0.8538401723,
0.6409350038,
0.2106886506,
-0.3183902502,
0.3556429446,
-0.2199936211,
-1.0246663094,
0.6821562052,
0.3944992721,
-0.9659020901,
0.1990490556,
0.5162905455,
0.6443165541,
-0.3360781372,
0.1186199635,
0.5249583721,
0.3563099205,
0.0953656435,
-1.5167329311,
-0.5196518302,
-0.0663974509,
-0.0272377804,
0.1122405529,
-0.3758298159,
0.5857310295,
-0.3707173467,
-0.2818107605,
0.0202813298,
0.6998106837,
-0.0860890597,
0.0669531226,
0.6381821632,
0.4091657102,
0.8094370365,
0.0627804771,
0.9692190289,
-0.0800825432,
0.1714211255,
1.2323204279,
-0.1275143474,
0.9534444213,
0.1785069704,
-0.4133487344,
0.0278646294,
0.6236798763,
0.0778616592,
0.1171597615,
0.1303596646,
-0.6019575,
-0.2198620886,
-0.4847353697,
-0.5256491899,
0.5587425828,
0.4574804902,
-0.2956879139,
0.0445408747,
0.5800920129,
0.1121710986,
-0.0426978618,
-0.2806322277,
0.7810595036,
-0.0155361416,
-0.5884998441,
0.5987932682,
-0.0451659039,
0.5873258114,
-0.7655835152,
0.1349228173,
0.0392085798,
0.2664310634,
-0.075299345,
-0.7324271798,
0.0439020246,
0.2170364559,
-0.0740059838,
-0.4028495252,
0.5494588017,
-0.6214625239,
-0.9575607181,
0.4862497151,
0.5675590634,
0.3778497577,
-0.2876506746,
-0.3749337196,
0.1520527154,
0.1592609733,
-0.1102889031,
0.332621485,
0.3081117868,
-0.0500946753,
0.7506444454,
0.6967790723,
0.381729275,
0.4917367101,
0.3989633918,
0.6418836117,
-0.6031044722,
-0.5247343779,
-0.6707388759,
0.2092480063,
0.0451806635,
-0.3881100118,
0.9970394373,
0.6591714621,
0.9013410211,
0.183125928,
0.892077744,
0.0981111601,
0.833345592,
0.04118881,
0.3433941603,
-0.4525975883,
-0.0295684785,
-0.0215896461,
-0.6336145401,
-0.2590025663,
0.5622954369,
0.01605279,
-0.1436814517,
0.301034987,
0.6654955149,
0.2246403247,
0.1151909009,
0.6678281426,
0.226001814,
0.4109704792,
0.1860697865,
0.4746622741,
-0.3875001073,
0.8031036258,
-0.2114229947,
-0.5980081558,
0.1785875112,
-0.5910303593,
-0.5196514726,
-0.7449727058,
-0.1948816329,
-0.3947586715,
-0.2611771524,
0.7228435874,
1.0490807295,
-0.6694957614,
-0.5486931205,
0.2608482838,
-0.4196419418,
-0.2854305208,
-0.0722076669,
0.1005404815,
-0.1994431466,
-0.8366572857,
0.8254573941,
0.5455277562,
-0.0702370182,
-0.4849785864,
-0.1628921181,
-0.1015484706,
0.1896526963,
0.7873513699,
0.3288039863,
-0.6301226616,
-0.0577492006,
0.1101485267,
-0.0507092737,
0.1133114323,
0.8314881921,
-0.640771687,
0.98791641,
0.2131703049,
0.4761192501,
0.5619322658,
-0.2043356448,
0.2990331352,
-0.7459356189,
0.4439953864,
0.0744798779,
0.1268111914,
0.3827489614,
0.1963166445,
0.4466463029,
0.0218681134,
-0.5783378482,
-0.6807786226,
0.4419800341,
-0.9182124138,
-0.2747337222,
1.218824029,
-0.0146697499,
0.1061672121,
-0.0872404128,
-0.2057049423,
0.3587845862,
-0.2910902202,
0.2733770013,
0.8109404445,
0.0167566855,
-0.0252927803,
-0.9362883568,
0.4672694206,
0.3010259867,
-0.5433433056,
0.1689525098,
0.4984311163,
0.5069266558,
0.3941369057,
0.88573277,
-0.1994544715,
0.1650215536,
0.212247014,
0.0587905645,
0.1372018456,
-0.4623516202,
-0.6480005383,
0.0929132998,
0.1746535301,
-0.2350210994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13514v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13514v2 | Small Language Models Improve Giants by Rewriting Their Outputs | 2023-05-22T22:07:50 | 2024-02-01T11:47:57 | Giorgos Vernikos, Arthur Bražinskas, Jakub Adamek, Jonathan Mallinson, Aliaksei Severyn, Eric Malmi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the impressive performance of large language models (LLMs), they
often lag behind specialized models in various tasks. LLMs only use a fraction
of the existing training data for in-context learning, while task-specific
models harness the full dataset for fine-tuning. In this work, we tackle the
problem of leveraging training data to improve the performance of LLMs without
fine-tuning. Our approach directly targets LLM predictions without requiring
access to their weights. We create a pool of candidates from the LLM through
few-shot prompting and we employ a compact model, the LM-corrector (LMCor),
specifically trained to merge these candidates to produce an enhanced output.
Our experiments on four natural language generation tasks demonstrate that even
a small LMCor model (250M) substantially improves the few-shot performance of
LLMs (62B), matching and even outperforming standard fine-tuning. Furthermore,
we illustrate the robustness of LMCor against different prompts, thereby
minimizing the need for extensive prompt engineering. Finally, we show that
LMCor can be seamlessly integrated with different LLMs at inference, serving as
a plug-and-play module to improve their performance. | [
-0.2873323262,
-0.5930282474,
0.53636235,
-0.3506019413,
-0.2334730029,
-0.0481301732,
-0.709821701,
-0.3758745193,
0.0135479663,
0.5317858458,
-0.5098706484,
-0.1984814554,
-0.5649172068,
0.2088550478,
-0.0203986447,
0.9107657075,
0.3419831097,
-0.0595229678,
0.0232288446,
0.057685513,
-0.5371029973,
-0.0665122643,
-0.936329782,
-0.4497253597,
0.8868393302,
0.7934259176,
0.6211982965,
0.7891173959,
0.1793003082,
0.2741909623,
-0.2110399306,
0.6329020262,
-0.7502575517,
-0.1019098088,
-0.0571034141,
-0.7258501649,
-0.285433054,
-0.2840814888,
0.7443253398,
0.7471510768,
0.0589438565,
0.0598955341,
0.3714323342,
0.6599326134,
-0.6344547272,
0.1780307591,
-0.9903765321,
-0.2252672017,
-0.2407812029,
-0.1777772605,
-0.4713275731,
-0.2940232456,
-0.0401130915,
-0.3838775456,
0.5089185238,
0.2733504772,
0.6090607643,
0.3921991885,
-0.0000103191,
-0.1704298407,
-0.6381020546,
0.8130357265,
-0.9264540076,
0.126773119,
0.1629252732,
0.4397650063,
-0.403447479,
-0.4239909947,
-0.6623788476,
-0.2512066066,
-0.3649080694,
-0.1980991066,
-0.1762783378,
0.1275169849,
0.3969479501,
0.2185645103,
-0.2905381322,
0.5077030659,
-0.3910795748,
-0.07530763,
0.5620797276,
0.2880827487,
0.0477346405,
-0.1917276233,
0.2526875734,
-0.0933859497,
-0.9472498894,
0.1729865372,
0.215906769,
0.9674940109,
-0.055672396,
0.7174887061,
-0.1658991575,
0.8994570971,
0.3770498931,
-0.3228517473,
-0.2019398659,
-0.2479716837,
-0.2538630962,
-0.0614063069,
0.7572955489,
0.0555935092,
0.1561755389,
-0.2232267708,
-0.4032579362,
0.0243924987,
0.0389650278,
-0.8694258332,
-0.2523839772,
0.0899673402,
-0.0360144824,
-0.1297725737,
-0.2508281767,
-0.5030575395,
-0.4272869825,
-0.456312418,
0.3937541842,
-0.3678572476,
0.2246647477,
0.0309933815,
0.0632456765,
0.0374636427,
0.3996262848,
-1.0571718216,
0.1326045692,
0.7024900317,
0.7500321269,
-0.0799508095,
-0.1106712222,
-1.0787204504,
0.1095006242,
-0.408667326,
0.8425045609,
-0.4456921816,
-0.3207777441,
0.0747892261,
0.0086660422,
-0.1140698418,
-0.8673027158,
0.4751217067,
-0.4280537069,
0.1197660044,
-0.1920696199,
-0.5903661251,
0.2686431706,
0.2075932771,
-0.6638046503,
0.8929489851,
-0.0647513792,
-0.7509371042,
0.4799980521,
-0.5278013349,
-0.2922174633,
-0.0117899403,
-0.2861689627,
-0.4085215926,
0.3723967373,
0.4906738698,
0.6664751768,
-0.1998898685,
0.2199702412,
-0.1470719427,
-0.5499812961,
-0.0784517229,
-0.1646521986,
0.3078053892,
0.0125993723,
-0.0829522908,
0.200696066,
-0.8450126648,
-0.0385267213,
0.1024632752,
-0.7243686318,
-0.1293881536,
-0.1689548641,
-0.1073489785,
0.0925219133,
0.0725009814,
-0.4251456857,
0.4609529376,
-0.7368344069,
0.2257259041,
0.5768966675,
-0.2186703533,
0.923137486,
-0.4998519421,
0.5203634501,
-0.0456332453,
-0.3983817995,
-0.1718836725,
-0.2934101522,
-1.0343688726,
-0.5378606915,
0.3310690522,
0.3284292519,
-1.0129421949,
0.2604835927,
-0.4107830226,
-0.5157006383,
-0.7802963257,
0.6332361102,
0.3120368421,
0.5343641639,
0.2517155409,
0.0787607655,
-0.6083566546,
-0.8392655849,
-0.4543675184,
0.0654952005,
-0.2993812263,
0.3330088556,
0.1728285849,
-0.1242150441,
1.0942525864,
-0.3675083816,
-0.3233196437,
-0.7695733905,
0.0108021433,
0.41913113,
0.4841558337,
0.2750010192,
-0.2450799346,
-0.5482993722,
0.0187818985,
-0.3793970346,
-0.2228831649,
-0.0683484823,
0.0722519755,
0.1003465801,
0.5086739659,
-0.6068738699,
-0.0143555989,
0.5202398896,
0.0732426047,
0.3035958707,
-0.2248079181,
-0.2128422409,
-0.926568985,
-0.1561291963,
-0.0779941529,
-0.3480812907,
-0.6822132468,
-0.1835659742,
0.0815569311,
-0.2045611143,
-0.4888032973,
0.8457972407,
-0.3508913219,
0.0628746897,
-0.5251279473,
0.4689247906,
-0.1047936827,
0.3719395995,
-0.0210485719,
0.6987517476,
0.5004806519,
-0.6814165711,
-0.1341366768,
0.1482878029,
-0.3802337945,
0.2148913592,
-0.6198897362,
0.1931589246,
-0.4484050572,
0.1661265194,
-0.9421727061,
-0.5073680282,
0.096299015,
-0.2482273728,
0.6048074365,
-0.2938812077,
-0.6405544281,
-0.2793055773,
-0.1738679856,
0.0922550485,
0.6002886295,
-0.8279544115,
0.4710050523,
-0.1815935224,
-0.0971454903,
-0.3395632803,
-0.6922361255,
-0.1283560395,
-0.2716445625,
-0.5009327531,
0.2355804294,
0.049215503,
-0.0993256792,
-0.241704464,
0.0851764008,
0.1203676835,
-0.0582187772,
0.0735998154,
0.1643996686,
-0.3187895715,
0.3264266849,
0.1237460524,
-0.1889597923,
-0.4155425727,
-0.1601921171,
0.340249896,
0.0184146725,
-0.1806643754,
-0.4572247863,
0.1137198359,
0.1829677522,
-0.0455940887,
0.8821251392,
0.4574531019,
-0.3146599531,
-0.523345232,
-0.5678698421,
-0.4682037532,
-0.5047590137,
0.2180143893,
-0.367015183,
-1.3243272305,
0.126348123,
-0.1297339797,
0.2274105847,
0.2812516689,
0.4957716465,
-0.0012018173,
1.016551137,
0.9116833806,
-0.2036436498,
0.6202256083,
-0.1469425261,
0.2481998652,
-0.7115569711,
0.0715441108,
-0.542260766,
-0.4044112563,
-0.5647607446,
-0.5014286637,
0.2312964797,
0.4084904194,
-0.0973747149,
0.4825437069,
-0.3522142172,
0.7680146694,
0.4401203394,
0.0963135362,
0.3607028723,
-0.0058232513,
-0.0971493796,
-0.1980130374,
-1.2833408117,
-0.8118221164,
0.8819761276,
0.2262554467,
0.8877099156,
0.0171063859,
0.8417230844,
-0.0336910225,
0.4719917476,
-0.9650643468,
0.5182692409,
-0.2414636016,
-0.3140146136,
-0.2433976978,
-0.5174428821,
-0.9230952859,
0.3228968978,
-0.2355044782,
-0.7920543551,
0.1010127068,
0.4838233292,
-0.7784366608,
0.2524950802,
-0.7132004499,
0.7099997997,
-0.0473276675,
-0.4344326854,
-0.0486220457,
-0.3358796835,
0.4999840558,
-0.2765690982,
0.1662907004,
-0.1427192241,
-0.0037324256,
0.4959152937,
-0.4550742209,
1.1701773405,
-0.1070209146,
-0.1331599653,
0.3370088935,
0.1449752003,
0.7871246934,
-0.0062541375,
-0.1181936264,
-0.1635448486,
-0.3575082123,
-0.4519718587,
-0.6221698523,
0.7952409983,
-0.5838099718,
-0.5655167103,
0.0930532739,
-0.6454151869,
-0.3941733241,
0.1352921426,
0.3680381179,
0.3207936585,
-0.0563039929,
0.1377374679,
0.5077409148,
-0.0887372568,
0.6044412255,
0.4037685394,
-0.0439197943,
-0.2380356193,
0.6463615894,
-0.0429940373,
0.4974240959,
0.4667066038,
0.4209188521,
-0.1910378337,
-0.4453011453,
-0.3911298811,
0.3597671986,
-0.6037862897,
-0.3187804818,
-0.6753008962,
0.1308506131,
-0.2887064815,
-0.3694586456,
-0.5178576112,
-0.2856393754,
-0.4413137734,
0.0285367165,
0.2485276759,
0.5521516204,
-0.1138474643,
0.908342123,
-0.758271575,
0.1574932933,
0.4737386703,
-0.010689606,
-0.0151657807,
-0.7474237084,
-0.3716803193,
0.0633764789,
-0.1958263665,
-0.278034389,
0.3978705406,
0.4585669041,
0.3335045278,
0.3557720184,
-0.1177469715,
0.9432458878,
-0.7979680896,
0.6740653515,
0.2345667779,
-0.8096238375,
0.7487776875,
-0.2842354178,
0.5326495767,
0.6234382391,
0.0428798534,
-0.2465688586,
-0.4260939062,
-0.5156107545,
-0.4597005546,
0.7414295673,
0.1105621457,
0.1503317058,
-0.1551460922,
0.3453389704,
0.0584960133,
0.1180669516,
-0.5077872872,
0.0811396986,
0.2817540765,
-0.2985289395,
-0.3699332178,
-0.1505316049,
-0.0347294882,
-0.146789819,
0.6737372279,
-0.6505041122,
-0.0676763728,
-0.0022756627,
-0.2040638924,
-0.3213614821,
0.4486217499,
0.4717036188,
0.4174514711,
-0.0188327841,
0.2032146007,
0.4922139645,
0.0564364456,
-0.0324385352,
0.0078959903,
-0.2035247982,
0.1375537217,
0.4428374469,
0.728985548,
0.5591669679,
-0.7981194854,
0.2969526947,
0.0262912121,
0.1906011552,
0.1594380736,
0.3916453123,
0.1972162575,
0.5405980349,
0.1172404066,
0.1245794371,
-0.1695730388,
-0.4495919049,
0.1976247877,
0.3971179426,
-0.2860775292,
-0.2500978112,
0.6834508777,
0.0817889795,
-0.2894100249,
0.3486712277,
-0.198647365,
-0.2799449265,
0.4191437364,
0.662242949,
0.5506280065,
0.0188864935,
-0.0615957342,
0.5067158937,
0.3744264543,
-0.3417209983,
0.0328132398,
-0.0303614289,
-0.8012543321,
-0.5783416033,
-0.5817889571,
-0.3538472056,
0.1316353828,
-0.3288268447,
0.5235872269,
-0.6100129485,
-0.1412605941,
-0.0048349658,
0.1485581696,
-0.9297300577,
0.1164122075,
0.2473583221,
0.8825454116,
-0.672652185,
0.9953717589,
0.4951252043,
-0.274091661,
-0.9407932758,
-0.0635039434,
-0.091921173,
-0.7200175524,
0.6024690866,
0.3403438628,
-0.1428974867,
0.0401825905,
-0.6999562383,
-0.6428993344,
0.950031817,
0.5275034904,
-1.1473145485,
0.0269522034,
0.2093872577,
0.4562828839,
-0.5831186771,
0.0010692606,
0.7310196757,
0.1977979839,
0.2017451525,
-0.9052654505,
-0.1566204131,
0.2538357079,
0.1662689298,
0.1546123773,
-0.452996105,
0.6850474477,
-0.4994622767,
-0.3242845535,
0.3189840019,
0.7312812209,
0.5815116167,
0.0433398634,
0.4247913957,
0.4254058301,
0.9623950124,
-0.1063725576,
1.1187951565,
-0.0796730369,
0.3460736275,
1.5200959444,
-0.1703836024,
0.9739742875,
0.6209665537,
0.0895875543,
0.1558037847,
0.4326477945,
0.1487707347,
0.4926201403,
0.3666334152,
-0.259088248,
-0.4341975152,
-0.1701051891,
-0.0035113394,
0.3233367503,
0.1754591912,
-0.3206265271,
-0.3474921286,
-0.0021496606,
0.0945529267,
0.2219841182,
-0.4742581248,
0.7686673403,
0.2263476402,
-0.5135862231,
0.616797328,
0.0005985757,
1.0438629389,
-0.5031040311,
0.1860985756,
-0.4063181579,
0.3871070147,
-0.2108472586,
-0.302521646,
0.2421614081,
0.2295287997,
-0.2633325458,
-0.0600564852,
0.9500437975,
-0.769026041,
-0.574362278,
0.0421914347,
0.5940228105,
0.0149753522,
0.0018132956,
-0.3837829828,
0.0408233367,
-0.1138908118,
-0.0330868438,
0.2768431604,
0.5041325688,
0.206287697,
0.5846580267,
0.7130681872,
0.238291204,
0.1123686358,
0.1616818011,
0.8829129934,
-0.6173434258,
-0.2292582244,
-0.9487141371,
0.5232866406,
0.0584319271,
-0.1562025398,
0.5908618569,
0.4704198539,
0.8717598915,
-0.2359763086,
0.6909974813,
0.0710555688,
0.617926538,
-0.5492187142,
0.5894242525,
-0.5350334644,
0.398499161,
0.0095680403,
-0.9668374658,
-0.4468456507,
0.4021115601,
-0.4014334381,
-0.0619239807,
0.3199172318,
1.1017720699,
-0.1848428696,
-0.2854040861,
0.6657394171,
0.1938949078,
0.3750964403,
0.5810325146,
0.7944092155,
-0.3971126974,
0.481672436,
-0.2966510952,
-0.0078088013,
-0.2498540878,
-0.8797524571,
-1.2716600895,
0.0161963813,
-0.2891597152,
-0.2136137635,
0.0004811831,
1.1150461435,
0.7367444038,
-0.8030790091,
-0.1159843504,
-0.0257448182,
0.079608947,
0.0316115171,
-0.1838822216,
0.1346614957,
-0.6130340695,
-0.9279409051,
0.7333942652,
0.1374542713,
0.0699215606,
-0.0479574651,
-0.1691991985,
0.1734514534,
0.1424867511,
0.6888161898,
0.2611929774,
-0.8525034189,
-0.4194299281,
-0.1445406973,
-0.1881658584,
0.0492464788,
0.8257762194,
-0.932585597,
0.3653244078,
0.3836704791,
0.9036365151,
0.3435561955,
-0.157822758,
0.5291175842,
-1.1503838301,
0.1896258742,
0.1483085603,
0.435678184,
0.6004419923,
-0.2947234511,
0.3213710487,
-0.0332094431,
-0.4522481263,
-0.6480552554,
0.2142966688,
-0.7767868638,
-0.0400578827,
1.1233757734,
0.0543415211,
-0.2269997597,
0.243378967,
-0.3967617452,
0.2258009166,
-0.4424962997,
0.718964994,
0.3753366172,
-0.0985982493,
-0.3502277136,
-0.4929710329,
0.5929961205,
0.469201684,
-0.7655718327,
0.1138381734,
0.4582116008,
0.3982926011,
-0.0155690396,
0.4997214079,
0.251832664,
0.0044742683,
-0.0862196162,
-0.1685790122,
-0.0332139172,
-0.3407788575,
-0.6104261279,
0.0603043884,
0.296872735,
-0.048521474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13512v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13512v2 | Can ChatGPT Detect Intent? Evaluating Large Language Models for Spoken Language Understanding | 2023-05-22T21:59:26 | 2023-08-17T19:23:20 | Mutian He, Philip N. Garner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recently, large pretrained language models have demonstrated strong language
understanding capabilities. This is particularly reflected in their zero-shot
and in-context learning abilities on downstream tasks through prompting. To
assess their impact on spoken language understanding (SLU), we evaluate several
such models like ChatGPT and OPT of different sizes on multiple benchmarks. We
verify the emergent ability unique to the largest models as they can reach
intent classification accuracy close to that of supervised models with zero or
few shots on various languages given oracle transcripts. By contrast, the
results for smaller models fitting a single GPU fall far behind. We note that
the error cases often arise from the annotation scheme of the dataset;
responses from ChatGPT are still reasonable. We show, however, that the model
is worse at slot filling, and its performance is sensitive to ASR errors,
suggesting serious challenges for the application of those textual models on
SLU. | [
0.0296511874,
-0.8645145297,
0.8770180345,
0.141575858,
-0.1621055454,
-0.3822996318,
-0.4712333679,
-0.4387643337,
-0.3711024821,
0.4372012317,
-0.3394424319,
-0.2806786895,
-0.6925542355,
-0.327989012,
-0.5112558603,
0.9028838277,
0.1583387107,
0.0665492713,
-0.1546307504,
-0.0789620206,
-0.7007186413,
-0.3717142045,
-1.034271121,
-0.3785876632,
0.250349611,
0.2885383666,
0.5829834342,
0.1911554039,
0.3786906302,
0.2429075837,
-0.207127288,
-0.2405046672,
-0.4459019005,
0.0127536599,
0.2565938234,
-0.40078336,
-0.3892171085,
0.1508694887,
0.8805422187,
0.7295183539,
-0.2321723849,
0.0165928546,
0.0791791901,
0.3315118551,
-0.4967801869,
0.4570945799,
-0.7274562716,
-0.2419594675,
0.015552179,
0.123377122,
-0.9920131564,
-0.0350895077,
0.5003377199,
-0.6169336438,
0.137205869,
-0.1390611976,
0.699334383,
0.5184087753,
-0.3231509328,
-0.4297653735,
-0.8758674264,
0.5648465157,
-0.9446806908,
0.5667607784,
0.3021380603,
0.2692234814,
-0.0557603091,
-0.6844867468,
-0.4868463278,
-0.4724746644,
-0.2561230361,
0.0893615857,
-0.2773026824,
0.3017659485,
0.5763890743,
0.3086531162,
-0.742908597,
0.2169163227,
-0.3042697012,
0.0364257395,
0.5415859222,
-0.1407704651,
0.4473218918,
-0.1019662097,
-0.260130316,
-0.0152300978,
-0.663721323,
0.2685097754,
0.1030545086,
0.382298708,
0.0605476908,
0.6527661085,
-0.0004729553,
0.9388184547,
-0.1406591833,
0.222370699,
-0.1870100647,
-0.2340401709,
-0.4456814229,
0.2389150411,
0.7641240358,
-0.1282943785,
0.3756140471,
-0.1269043535,
-0.074832119,
-0.0841928497,
0.1894590259,
-0.6006394029,
-0.3086609244,
0.2973490357,
-0.1807943583,
0.157754913,
-0.0687672868,
0.0083624925,
-0.4135355055,
-0.199029997,
0.5120998621,
-0.5922733545,
-0.3131690621,
0.4646413028,
-0.020855261,
0.7305939198,
0.5693395138,
-0.8700557351,
0.2654078305,
0.9168832898,
0.7236577868,
-0.174053967,
-0.2883857191,
-0.6097820401,
-0.0417348482,
-0.1626580954,
0.83221066,
-0.6852984428,
-0.2796960771,
-0.1002282426,
-0.3049318194,
-0.6937545538,
-0.1543087661,
0.7796438932,
-0.521058023,
0.1626933068,
-0.1438602209,
-0.7424288392,
-0.4268423915,
0.0674310252,
-0.570718348,
0.7480808496,
-0.1018432528,
-0.5566658378,
0.5579794645,
-1.0213612318,
-0.4346293509,
0.3845230341,
-0.2119126618,
-0.2229150087,
0.2709075809,
0.0869495869,
0.4450579286,
0.1307698339,
0.3537365198,
-0.139867574,
-0.392087847,
0.4421420097,
-0.7093724608,
0.7595496178,
-0.0364492722,
-0.375149101,
0.2203343809,
-0.4274353385,
0.0545418486,
0.0447017513,
-0.1821072251,
-0.2857404053,
0.2088101208,
0.0370272584,
0.1333979517,
0.0751928017,
-0.5040087104,
0.2138235569,
-0.0649836212,
0.5498725176,
0.622007966,
-0.2121225744,
0.3421209455,
0.1948035657,
0.394747287,
-0.2389576435,
0.2002108991,
-0.2274584025,
-0.7297061086,
-0.8184983134,
-0.0432977714,
0.1917175353,
0.4396190345,
-0.4281672239,
0.0636888817,
-0.3954859376,
-0.3790240586,
-0.3133454323,
-0.1981978118,
0.4630329907,
0.2333477885,
0.0994313061,
-0.2495793104,
-0.1380339116,
-0.5618034005,
-0.2558326125,
-0.4613848925,
0.0025600658,
0.8942064643,
0.3140041828,
-0.0783485696,
0.8031007051,
-0.4806875587,
-0.0125247017,
-0.5335567594,
0.247972846,
0.3172941506,
0.1945294738,
0.3144900203,
-0.6903475523,
-0.563334167,
0.3432021737,
-0.6823789477,
-0.1079062,
-0.0889894143,
0.3135178983,
0.0426489189,
0.460870862,
-0.8450629115,
0.4756395519,
0.5868143439,
-0.3279321194,
0.5461815,
-0.2536151707,
0.0561502427,
-0.559735775,
-0.0113870967,
0.0171316303,
-0.2014598697,
-1.115760684,
-0.2378203869,
0.0446371064,
-0.2561781108,
-0.5227594972,
0.5046670437,
-0.3279924095,
-0.2637736797,
-0.2906112373,
0.2793188095,
-0.1920760125,
0.2757592201,
0.5295404196,
0.8166217804,
0.4421852529,
-0.5475307703,
-0.0449580215,
0.307151556,
-0.5730597973,
0.1524435878,
-0.8628767729,
0.3526673913,
-0.1300212741,
0.2954230309,
-1.2330828905,
-0.4233504236,
0.145024538,
-0.466270119,
0.3824447393,
-0.4292928576,
-0.1065896079,
-0.1018096805,
0.2319394052,
0.3336978555,
0.4036339223,
-0.4860942066,
0.6021084785,
0.3238439858,
-0.2376538366,
-0.7147567868,
-0.3671095669,
-0.1353217661,
-0.1515344381,
-0.6490262747,
-0.2043370306,
0.0744281858,
-0.2154099941,
-0.2363391668,
0.0597942024,
-0.1248018965,
0.0427553579,
0.3766000271,
0.1630571932,
-0.5203925371,
0.1807201356,
-0.34395051,
-0.0578874461,
0.0160884447,
-0.2912195027,
0.7956354618,
-0.3133690357,
-0.6418408155,
-0.5373055339,
0.0327878781,
0.7223424911,
-0.309283793,
0.6751865745,
0.5515887737,
-0.0869892389,
-0.0334614217,
-0.6034944654,
-0.0670127198,
-0.400603354,
0.3016095459,
-0.307433635,
-0.8945010304,
0.5331689119,
0.3227640688,
0.2783624828,
0.3105772734,
0.348934114,
0.0223466009,
0.8991607428,
0.5670822859,
-0.0575305708,
0.6955358386,
-0.2096738964,
0.4316192269,
-0.800293684,
0.0925354809,
-0.4779732823,
0.0121003613,
-0.5159394145,
-0.4201913774,
0.176380679,
-0.1706970483,
0.04104257,
0.2889660001,
-0.1925116032,
0.5438201427,
0.3023607135,
0.1154592633,
0.3843902946,
-0.250870198,
0.3423660398,
0.1580394655,
-0.755099237,
-0.4972808361,
0.9297550321,
0.4285110235,
0.8541088104,
0.0411989838,
0.1911538392,
-0.0270101707,
0.3332378864,
-1.0360586643,
0.4475740194,
-0.2093142867,
-0.635835886,
-0.6005657315,
-0.3150646389,
-0.8535904884,
0.300680846,
0.1877498478,
-0.9374557137,
0.10241092,
0.1727183014,
-0.4694678187,
0.2115413547,
-1.2839818001,
1.1958818436,
-0.2519284189,
-0.0866190717,
-0.1412872225,
-0.4010896385,
0.3954400718,
0.0413495637,
-0.019368235,
-0.2344718277,
0.2166231275,
0.7204297781,
0.0254957024,
0.7220391035,
-0.3332057595,
-0.0402350873,
0.3329084516,
-0.1916582733,
0.4689114094,
-0.0122718792,
-0.0723504499,
0.1119147614,
-0.2764670849,
-0.3766562939,
-0.5484657288,
0.3553728163,
-0.5739747286,
-0.5452613235,
-0.299000591,
-0.5625149608,
-0.1124906018,
0.0353000462,
0.3431673646,
0.559330225,
-0.3525578082,
0.2699725926,
0.7633551359,
-0.1867072433,
0.4278701544,
0.5987542868,
-0.1793554723,
0.3834733069,
0.7413250208,
-0.0066636587,
0.5965056419,
0.050968498,
0.1619128883,
-0.4253083766,
-0.9629455805,
-0.4563418031,
0.2309154421,
-0.6429561973,
0.2794751227,
-0.6041200757,
-0.42345348,
-0.3962546289,
0.0494532511,
-0.4905189574,
-0.1668387055,
-0.023433527,
0.0268193316,
0.3083973527,
1.1089917421,
0.2853422463,
0.7875251174,
-0.5998791456,
-0.1422052085,
0.3795794249,
0.4488193095,
-0.0828729644,
-0.7438821197,
0.060576655,
0.1124405339,
0.1323914081,
-0.6884995103,
0.2536334395,
0.4068639874,
0.6500801444,
0.577976644,
-0.2008140534,
0.5085971951,
-0.4889774621,
0.8465051651,
-0.1366344243,
-0.9132611156,
0.6604601145,
-0.4522470236,
0.4620598257,
0.5622912645,
0.4122137427,
-0.8301434517,
-0.3084232509,
-0.7786117792,
-0.4731011689,
1.0063405037,
0.2928038239,
-0.0236917809,
0.1533810794,
0.3364998102,
0.0813900828,
-0.192981571,
-0.9902847409,
0.0503030531,
0.1803338826,
0.0339933075,
-0.3480989039,
-0.2271942198,
0.3680123985,
-0.0717944354,
0.6603791118,
-0.0661182553,
0.2189908773,
0.0959767029,
-0.4983516932,
0.2324196398,
0.5234171748,
0.6079735756,
0.5774319172,
-0.216736272,
-0.0886262134,
0.1541358978,
-0.8433874846,
-0.0619622096,
0.0918384641,
-0.2431446612,
-0.0085323034,
0.3275707066,
1.1023510695,
0.2931540906,
-0.740588367,
0.6575177312,
-0.5969562531,
0.0792776197,
-0.2867694795,
0.2189658582,
-0.1494762599,
0.0185703449,
0.1348975599,
-0.1845504194,
0.1789186597,
-0.4201465249,
0.0424245074,
0.6722149849,
-0.8877058029,
-0.3008132577,
0.3673080802,
0.0009952032,
-0.234792158,
0.8384288549,
-0.2094011754,
-0.65232265,
0.4801940322,
0.5121604204,
0.7819448113,
-0.4726351798,
0.1437877417,
0.2860141098,
0.3206444979,
-0.0647916645,
-0.0646845698,
-0.2013649195,
-0.9113852382,
-0.7813336253,
-0.4806462228,
-0.5806335211,
0.3710559011,
-0.5450055003,
0.2198306769,
-0.1463955194,
0.0568350442,
0.3549941778,
-0.2092444003,
-0.4678620398,
0.0007414112,
0.249267906,
0.6290282011,
-1.1264431477,
0.918995142,
0.6809954643,
-0.1489192098,
-0.9907483459,
0.0102921389,
-0.1246117353,
-0.8432030678,
0.5360335112,
0.3908169866,
-0.0816933587,
0.1022478119,
-0.5303408504,
-0.6570234299,
0.6236138344,
0.1639675796,
-0.2940483689,
0.0778740719,
0.1621411741,
0.3805179894,
-0.2688366175,
0.6607242227,
0.7733832002,
0.2600594163,
0.317664057,
-1.1358348131,
-0.3415707052,
-0.0998814628,
-0.4741238952,
0.2676679492,
-0.2863761485,
0.750172019,
-0.2393990308,
-0.4155384302,
-0.2167906165,
0.3310554326,
0.1080948934,
0.4112356901,
0.6586791873,
0.4454527795,
0.6668539047,
-0.339204669,
1.062025547,
0.18017371,
0.3667350411,
1.2216876745,
-0.3299362659,
1.0934590101,
0.1683245897,
-0.2095507234,
0.1526185423,
0.6073423028,
0.4356784225,
0.2140210718,
-0.1399942786,
-0.4171728194,
-0.2609662414,
-0.0980269536,
-0.1670699269,
0.760269165,
0.8888602853,
-0.0728132203,
-0.1362373829,
0.0703370273,
-0.0664246306,
-0.3741146326,
-0.409750998,
1.0063945055,
0.0626117885,
-0.8104519844,
0.3459394276,
-0.5727066398,
0.4328645766,
-0.5029796958,
0.1496664435,
-0.0504620895,
0.231830433,
-0.1730267107,
-0.9935880303,
0.1066246554,
0.0142849647,
0.1940921694,
-0.1309531927,
0.9530507326,
-0.3784197569,
-0.1409805417,
0.0301104244,
0.3857829869,
0.5001737475,
-0.3834791481,
-0.527108252,
0.0521736294,
0.0664846152,
-0.0746325031,
0.0446552634,
0.3043587208,
0.0639818683,
0.6489940882,
0.5791654587,
-0.1320532709,
0.379729718,
0.303791821,
0.4572486579,
-0.3134930134,
-0.3144755661,
-0.8613941073,
0.2958591282,
-0.1879338175,
-0.1610631496,
0.7715722322,
0.5275287628,
0.640950501,
-0.0304693803,
0.7171261907,
-0.0146643883,
0.1879840642,
-0.4462161362,
0.6561444998,
-0.2135760039,
0.1318634301,
-0.1129882932,
-0.7642014623,
-0.2068707943,
0.7711930275,
-0.9459915757,
0.0602498874,
0.5711867809,
0.4932588041,
-0.235058412,
0.4892550111,
0.4350917041,
0.3362182975,
0.358479619,
0.6337009072,
1.1456947327,
-0.3414030075,
0.4344223142,
0.1212780103,
-0.3559876084,
-0.263902545,
-0.6307915449,
-0.7868764997,
-0.5476889014,
-0.2663933337,
-0.0908850729,
-0.0386790223,
0.5259114504,
0.7783406377,
-0.7536785603,
-0.2606112361,
-0.2513235211,
0.0935208276,
-0.0399798714,
-0.1743254066,
0.4355208874,
-0.5411142111,
-0.6897380948,
0.3075219989,
0.4368294179,
0.0202052407,
-0.0612283275,
-0.0957173631,
-0.2768987715,
-0.0400958769,
0.7910293937,
0.3911853433,
-0.7913517356,
-0.5301088095,
0.153418988,
-0.11485257,
0.1201795861,
0.9906290174,
-0.4989837706,
0.425414294,
0.4813300073,
0.6408704519,
0.7352138758,
-0.0807745457,
0.5113405585,
-0.5634297729,
0.1356137097,
0.265458703,
0.4824877679,
0.2440302819,
-0.3838453591,
0.4232709706,
-0.2170101255,
-0.8362259865,
-0.6723164916,
0.1706824005,
-1.3641943932,
-0.0344402753,
1.352640152,
-0.2836596072,
-0.2465379536,
-0.3107019067,
-0.2770645618,
0.1521850079,
-0.3089985847,
0.4330328703,
0.8281143308,
-0.3882225156,
-0.327673763,
-1.1730567217,
0.5301659703,
0.4872897565,
-0.7613012791,
0.5869859457,
0.3643749952,
-0.0004992833,
0.0275360178,
0.7021682858,
0.0545385294,
0.4965768456,
-0.0972905755,
-0.1156313643,
0.4233538806,
-0.1280259192,
-0.5165116787,
-0.1961546242,
0.4146990478,
-0.1055132002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13507v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13507v3 | Multimodal Automated Fact-Checking: A Survey | 2023-05-22T21:52:24 | 2023-10-25T18:43:02 | Mubashara Akhtar, Michael Schlichtkrull, Zhijiang Guo, Oana Cocarascu, Elena Simperl, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Misinformation is often conveyed in multiple modalities, e.g. a miscaptioned
image. Multimodal misinformation is perceived as more credible by humans, and
spreads faster than its text-only counterparts. While an increasing body of
research investigates automated fact-checking (AFC), previous surveys mostly
focus on text. In this survey, we conceptualise a framework for AFC including
subtasks unique to multimodal misinformation. Furthermore, we discuss related
terms used in different communities and map them to our framework. We focus on
four modalities prevalent in real-world fact-checking: text, image, audio, and
video. We survey benchmarks and models, and discuss limitations and promising
directions for future research | [
-0.6373568773,
-0.7418882251,
0.6164662242,
0.3519896865,
-0.2881605029,
0.2178783268,
0.1354159713,
-0.7763959765,
0.2058669627,
0.1513202488,
-0.627756238,
-0.3984880149,
-0.8112137914,
0.4955106378,
-0.3727876544,
0.8377358317,
-0.2597225904,
-0.0770541877,
-0.583427906,
-0.4549778998,
-0.2946603596,
-0.5347807407,
-0.380815208,
-0.2321179956,
0.5491909981,
0.6692191362,
0.8626023531,
0.4266070426,
0.6687746048,
0.3294824362,
0.4847096503,
0.5979864597,
0.167624563,
-0.0016870314,
-0.0333491638,
-0.3058405817,
-0.1790440232,
0.4898773134,
0.2954908013,
0.1615574807,
0.1057364494,
0.2310137302,
-0.3749962449,
0.4248334765,
-0.9785349965,
0.2973136306,
-0.1762866825,
0.1720372885,
-0.028460348,
-0.167433247,
-0.1379266828,
-0.347092241,
0.0461223498,
-0.6535716057,
0.2825887501,
0.283269465,
0.9024564028,
0.4277330935,
-0.9109866023,
-0.6006985307,
-0.7582539916,
0.5701560974,
-0.3243376315,
0.8179420829,
0.8286878467,
0.157772094,
0.61775738,
-0.4966432452,
-0.9945350885,
-0.1402906477,
-0.4118970335,
0.1280878037,
-0.2439864874,
0.1161434725,
0.1770733744,
0.2131982148,
-0.28498739,
-0.2272133231,
-0.0139669133,
-0.6990574598,
0.3321377933,
-0.0519432612,
0.4188774824,
-0.4619362652,
-0.4560386539,
-0.1313935071,
-0.253774941,
-0.150134474,
0.1776911467,
-0.3110628724,
-0.2886415422,
0.7435723543,
-0.2382532209,
0.4480246902,
0.2176415026,
-0.706946671,
0.3073152006,
-1.2560696602,
0.0445438214,
0.0472665466,
0.664953649,
0.8477203846,
-0.1952822059,
-0.0617835224,
-0.3196143508,
0.2935958803,
0.0816872045,
-0.5111481547,
0.0843576118,
-0.0464892201,
-0.521979332,
-0.073118329,
0.2444295436,
-0.7141333222,
-0.6384370327,
-0.4057914019,
0.5079178214,
-0.5056852102,
-0.1426746547,
-0.1903479695,
-0.2847309113,
-0.1160886139,
0.6690495014,
-0.4680342078,
-0.0366201214,
0.193834573,
0.9537409544,
0.0391950719,
-0.4103116691,
-0.1976194978,
0.0597603507,
-0.3409857154,
1.3537802696,
-0.4257557988,
0.0144683355,
0.1706715375,
0.1509151906,
-0.1497095078,
-0.3054196239,
0.6515443325,
-0.5703819394,
0.3699944615,
-0.6104722023,
-0.2840770781,
-0.6148112416,
0.7643865943,
-1.1244418621,
0.6691069603,
-0.2196953595,
-0.8085467815,
0.9257379174,
-0.6657762527,
-0.5908260942,
-0.3772828281,
-0.2473806441,
-0.4953450561,
-0.3648994267,
0.3784476519,
0.2316794544,
-0.3458104432,
0.1660998017,
-0.0385124609,
0.0735753477,
0.4716508985,
-0.8081800938,
0.1758803874,
0.3468700051,
-0.4861977398,
-0.0678856224,
-0.6762835979,
-0.3669984043,
-0.4132413566,
-0.5407024026,
-0.3351903558,
0.0177811384,
0.1281824559,
0.3762376606,
0.1619672477,
-0.6963251829,
-0.0009749314,
0.4193953872,
0.0815481022,
0.2120836228,
0.1108431816,
0.4033996165,
-0.7190856338,
0.2705285549,
0.5198539495,
0.2204301357,
-0.4531826675,
-0.3748453856,
-0.5349316001,
-0.4682185352,
0.5001935959,
0.5592344403,
-1.1576946974,
0.0832785442,
0.0632122084,
-0.3810252249,
-0.4508253932,
-0.1096327901,
0.2812259793,
0.419044733,
0.3231228888,
-0.3175682127,
-0.7131904364,
-1.0765249729,
-0.2437486202,
-0.4260597527,
0.3389971256,
0.2852340043,
0.6700737476,
-0.4607288539,
0.9800201058,
-0.0803524628,
-0.6040136814,
-0.1445494741,
0.941057384,
-0.3258933425,
0.2698354721,
0.7696273923,
-1.0298788548,
-0.2251936644,
-0.2068671733,
-0.7616177201,
0.0665511861,
-0.5418661237,
0.4957074821,
0.6256368756,
0.2817150652,
-0.8288419843,
0.5163151026,
0.5234466195,
-0.3016545475,
0.4845678806,
-0.057133656,
1.2137413025,
-0.5189932585,
-0.0570694692,
0.1381203681,
-0.3729052842,
-0.2446507215,
-0.1350672394,
0.1847976893,
0.450928092,
-0.4195295274,
0.1979452074,
-0.5936747193,
-0.0890917033,
-0.2104847431,
-0.1472023576,
-0.0938838795,
0.2298681587,
0.0515311733,
0.8774203658,
0.3539676368,
-0.5401499867,
0.7033436894,
0.0706426799,
-0.5162745714,
0.743098557,
-0.2764510512,
-0.1407239735,
-0.318536967,
0.6245154738,
-1.0992629528,
-0.6603136659,
0.2220305204,
-0.3836108446,
-0.2872757912,
-0.0728520453,
-1.0005215406,
-0.1363218725,
-0.3564466834,
0.6147784591,
-0.1462257057,
-0.3056524098,
0.7465909123,
0.5193703771,
-0.0208470896,
-0.6785604358,
-0.6684532166,
0.2782894671,
0.1530932784,
-0.5564368963,
0.1569931358,
0.0134917274,
-0.526979804,
0.1033105031,
-0.199911356,
-0.5586916804,
-0.2795008421,
0.3262136877,
-0.0337807499,
-0.0910661742,
0.325107336,
-0.2053522319,
0.041124519,
-0.2903451025,
0.159554705,
0.0916523337,
-0.1392992735,
-0.7082545757,
-0.7222046852,
0.6011256576,
1.007245779,
-0.1762213856,
0.6037412882,
0.8854011893,
-0.4491973817,
0.3365736604,
-0.9482070804,
-0.3393638432,
-0.3381751478,
0.2194326669,
0.0345349982,
-0.6132889986,
0.4529360533,
0.0004423379,
0.2792490423,
0.341140449,
0.4262150824,
-0.3301180899,
0.9086300135,
0.8203148842,
0.0682263896,
0.3613580167,
-0.0588468574,
0.1691304445,
0.0948032439,
-0.3961814344,
-0.4235608578,
-0.3355480731,
-0.156933248,
-0.5949531794,
0.6117627025,
-0.4281562269,
0.2904398441,
0.0871847719,
0.1515083313,
0.3632208109,
0.5059891939,
-0.0790972486,
0.6902233362,
-0.0718035176,
-0.0432806052,
-0.086548157,
-0.7002063394,
-0.3644945025,
0.6619964838,
0.3795039952,
0.9639109373,
0.3067421913,
0.0754129067,
0.8786199093,
0.5181283951,
-0.870010078,
0.3268497884,
0.0546151921,
-1.0241235495,
-0.1892086118,
-0.1044682935,
-0.5093792081,
0.1829292625,
-0.6200791597,
0.1235470101,
0.417989403,
0.3588630259,
-0.409204632,
0.3886328936,
-0.6311758757,
0.4872120321,
-0.4069688022,
-0.0566291995,
-0.4859497547,
-0.6891476512,
0.3881668746,
-0.0278990082,
0.8399673104,
-0.0730157048,
-0.2462301701,
0.5941554308,
-0.0215918627,
0.9068884254,
-0.00959705,
-0.1566904336,
0.4130057096,
0.0596763641,
0.336340934,
0.1313342154,
0.2983288765,
0.1111063808,
0.1551510543,
-0.0278568044,
-0.4865897298,
0.1634747833,
-0.6590605378,
-0.2296739221,
-0.8238993287,
-0.6532238126,
-0.2714157999,
0.2498923689,
0.2597971559,
0.6427961588,
-0.1495639086,
0.3030607402,
0.6674250364,
0.0635298565,
0.6263363957,
0.7649037838,
0.0830581486,
-0.3016613722,
0.7799612284,
0.3736097515,
-0.0475813523,
0.4388168156,
-0.144778356,
-0.5761887431,
-0.2791780829,
-0.6373057365,
0.1123942435,
-0.8131640553,
-0.2863838971,
-0.7192574739,
0.0546709634,
-0.3868795633,
0.1244594753,
-0.5352415442,
-0.57695508,
-0.1148522645,
-0.2541039884,
0.216261819,
0.8706099391,
-0.5364546776,
0.1586533487,
-0.8279277086,
0.8693714142,
0.5127853751,
0.4960263073,
-0.4514978826,
-0.1910476238,
-0.3533633053,
0.3036099672,
-0.2545576394,
-0.9956701398,
-0.0212408993,
0.2043648511,
0.6349309683,
0.515597403,
0.0796429962,
0.5163547397,
-0.2548008859,
0.9043922424,
0.3584285975,
-0.5752466917,
0.1865680516,
-0.1499906033,
0.1720454395,
0.7109234333,
0.755540669,
-0.7362384796,
-0.2261407077,
-0.3584132493,
-0.4397191405,
0.4656738341,
0.0705400407,
-0.1664459854,
0.0137607036,
-0.1211986691,
0.3106913865,
0.3501473963,
-0.7696593404,
-0.376044631,
-0.6532016993,
-0.1872680783,
0.0007424768,
-0.3044183254,
-0.5499910116,
-0.104834415,
0.3752946258,
-0.3131343722,
0.3549361229,
0.4769330025,
-0.6471321583,
-0.240613997,
0.4568472207,
0.9526091218,
0.70538342,
-0.0951454565,
0.6951677203,
-0.04189042,
-0.5658236742,
0.4090616703,
-0.1478695422,
-0.2131778449,
0.3369966745,
0.6161379218,
0.3886692226,
0.2467624694,
-0.5830098391,
0.6161146164,
-0.0926329717,
-0.5847035646,
-0.1473933905,
-0.3050208986,
-0.2275856584,
0.0483664609,
0.4772818983,
0.6632964611,
0.2908165455,
-0.9600026011,
0.3863235712,
0.2662523091,
-0.1442673802,
-0.3864690959,
0.3392243981,
0.482486397,
0.315743506,
0.3028811216,
-0.1257117838,
-0.3589504957,
0.4630316198,
0.1052369773,
0.6169217825,
0.1755146533,
0.4289399087,
0.2079151571,
0.7793495059,
-0.2289350182,
0.0811460316,
-0.2446846217,
-0.8570324779,
-0.3417201936,
-0.3097971678,
-0.5633919835,
0.1209276244,
-0.1633842885,
-0.0959905088,
-0.4362286925,
-0.5045391917,
0.2754114568,
-0.3553464711,
-0.6885948777,
0.583280921,
0.2556615174,
0.7506415248,
-0.8438099623,
0.356484592,
1.1007165909,
-0.5476231575,
-0.3569493592,
0.1741336882,
0.6303150058,
-0.5177556276,
0.6956312656,
-0.0894431174,
-0.5238549709,
-0.493265748,
-0.8095535636,
-1.00090909,
0.9678421617,
0.1818726808,
-0.1901150048,
-0.0024756258,
0.1814393401,
0.1898281127,
-0.2870308757,
0.4564622939,
0.4770483971,
0.9459536672,
0.0410343669,
-1.2299739122,
-0.2048368901,
0.0139328493,
-0.5820804834,
-0.3228943646,
-0.7732569575,
0.8421433568,
-0.1178329065,
-0.4187715352,
-0.2469199449,
0.578122139,
-0.0974908695,
0.5539758801,
0.9171471596,
0.428887099,
0.3640547693,
-0.1278784424,
0.7944301367,
-0.3367349803,
0.2021572292,
0.7441564202,
0.02477777,
0.2093236297,
0.5063135624,
0.1055972651,
0.6510317922,
0.6631817818,
0.0982564837,
0.4520502985,
-0.6531370282,
-0.2049795389,
-0.5428968668,
-0.3587117493,
-0.1805914789,
0.7308198214,
0.3793238103,
-0.0826353803,
-0.3973059654,
0.1968198717,
-0.117374979,
-0.0378480889,
-0.1328032315,
0.9611365199,
-0.4098098576,
-0.7648656964,
0.2256317139,
0.2251277417,
0.8450348377,
-0.4985200763,
-0.3126986921,
-0.134675175,
-0.2300933599,
-0.3893508911,
-0.9693720341,
0.3481875062,
0.0458942652,
-0.626971662,
-0.3153400123,
0.7618231177,
-0.3983440697,
-0.2171689719,
-0.1882193685,
0.7668327093,
-0.0941599905,
-0.0550241359,
-0.6118819118,
0.1625334173,
-0.1749218702,
0.0877818838,
-0.1225265712,
0.5060024858,
-0.3405037224,
0.8601552248,
0.4182017446,
-0.3557463884,
0.094474487,
0.0320564844,
0.5827968121,
-0.5435118079,
-0.4919601381,
-0.5016491413,
0.288490057,
-0.0549983345,
-0.2008770406,
1.0155550241,
0.5545861721,
0.6734657884,
-0.1833431125,
1.1144109964,
-0.3438543379,
0.4612163603,
-0.4515060186,
0.8013946414,
-0.5613682866,
-0.2686934769,
-0.2961173952,
-0.4337611496,
-0.2882021964,
0.5920321345,
0.042015437,
-0.1949581504,
0.8937869668,
0.700879693,
-0.1442725956,
0.3101803362,
0.2100332975,
0.1552723199,
0.0112655656,
-0.2655172348,
1.0387291908,
-0.2114263773,
0.5186687112,
-0.4475503266,
-0.3206151724,
-0.3941791952,
-0.8583788872,
-0.7243754864,
-0.7931893468,
-0.4409110248,
0.0522998422,
-0.2595370114,
0.8387716413,
1.0143405199,
-0.7075018883,
0.1535671502,
0.3948223591,
0.4908067584,
-0.2789573967,
-0.1504916996,
-0.0537127927,
-0.1595680118,
-0.4094957411,
0.1319017112,
0.3216059208,
0.1584894955,
-0.1609719992,
0.1984587312,
-0.5378679037,
0.3615086675,
0.8284044266,
0.2068192661,
-0.8148660064,
-0.5032876134,
0.0650812015,
-0.3300386369,
0.1386269927,
1.2667777538,
-0.6096969247,
0.4840047657,
0.4099038541,
0.4997072518,
0.051814016,
0.2421308458,
0.2580594718,
-0.7858301997,
0.0111073703,
0.0939848647,
0.3545519412,
0.341035068,
-0.2608157992,
0.2096152902,
0.7611015439,
-0.4239352942,
-0.4785708189,
0.2047730386,
-1.0036693811,
-0.2898437679,
1.0574499369,
0.1715375185,
-0.0640114322,
-0.6865745783,
-0.3690258563,
0.1547931582,
-0.5031455159,
0.93100214,
0.8790537119,
-0.2974615693,
-0.3346161544,
-0.379968524,
0.74550879,
0.1651669145,
-0.9131476879,
-0.0953050852,
1.0302243233,
0.3522316813,
0.597581625,
0.629907012,
-0.0460100472,
0.8895458579,
0.2296556979,
0.0523030385,
-0.2374368757,
-0.6737647653,
0.1491132677,
0.3292531669,
-0.3777145445,
-0.0984902158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13504v1 | Neural Machine Translation for Code Generation | 2023-05-22T21:43:12 | 2023-05-22T21:43:12 | Dharma KC, Clayton T. Morrison | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, A.1 | Neural machine translation (NMT) methods developed for natural language
processing have been shown to be highly successful in automating translation
from one natural language to another. Recently, these NMT methods have been
adapted to the generation of program code. In NMT for code generation, the task
is to generate output source code that satisfies constraints expressed in the
input. In the literature, a variety of different input scenarios have been
explored, including generating code based on natural language description,
lower-level representations such as binary or assembly (neural decompilation),
partial representations of source code (code completion and repair), and source
code in another language (code translation). In this paper we survey the NMT
for code generation literature, cataloging the variety of methods that have
been explored according to input and output representations, model
architectures, optimization techniques used, data sets, and evaluation methods.
We discuss the limitations of existing methods and future research directions | [
-0.3850109875,
-0.4991572201,
0.4448706508,
0.2909705043,
-0.2153498232,
0.1219755486,
-0.2902204096,
-0.1954011917,
0.1110362336,
0.4419460297,
-0.4848262668,
-0.3240036666,
-0.3129108548,
0.5124233365,
-0.4658170938,
0.9271302819,
-0.3106184602,
0.3027741909,
-0.1535865068,
0.3218226731,
-1.0284833908,
-0.7320671678,
-0.5469915867,
-0.4594580531,
0.1397484839,
0.2275928706,
0.4362781942,
0.7338581681,
0.720879972,
0.2719691098,
0.2400521785,
0.1810282767,
0.0222355463,
0.3271319866,
-0.0330466926,
-0.2655255497,
-0.1111868024,
-0.2835386395,
0.7005819678,
0.5951350927,
0.1152642742,
0.3180329204,
-0.0311214514,
0.7389166355,
-0.2819500268,
0.1505819261,
-0.5809258223,
0.4248392582,
0.0192225911,
-0.4465039372,
-0.4240061045,
-0.6051241159,
-0.2290434241,
-0.2274216712,
0.1519341022,
-0.0913136303,
0.4860922098,
0.5265282989,
-0.5209991932,
-0.6676776409,
-0.9237077832,
0.735932529,
-0.9654738903,
-0.0492961295,
0.2622310519,
0.4393755794,
-0.2033343315,
-0.7106131911,
-0.2407034636,
-0.4914729595,
-0.029996397,
0.1175877601,
-0.1709595472,
0.0685371384,
0.270229578,
0.5433049798,
-0.6719740033,
-0.051771868,
-0.3551985919,
-0.1856064945,
0.4200657904,
0.2699687779,
0.5477415323,
-0.5660045743,
-0.3804403245,
0.0167788882,
-0.6287439466,
-0.4161193967,
0.4097092152,
0.2047154605,
0.1326287389,
0.7641295791,
-0.2782727182,
0.8298954964,
-0.3116084933,
0.2798991501,
0.0154861584,
-0.7471310496,
-0.2122845799,
-0.0174273178,
0.578612864,
0.2458522171,
-0.094992362,
-0.4121490419,
-0.6053218842,
-0.1577722579,
0.4908319116,
-0.7925245166,
0.143568188,
-0.1224144474,
-0.6287340522,
-0.5517552495,
-0.0222565122,
-0.6293917894,
-0.1544768065,
-0.4896150827,
0.2298287749,
-0.4778859019,
-0.3903359473,
0.0463036187,
-0.1581442803,
0.3859497309,
-0.1946171969,
-0.7054638863,
0.1256632507,
0.4100680649,
0.9539524913,
-0.2097799331,
-0.1288792789,
-0.2134413868,
-0.2162947506,
-0.531034112,
0.2671855092,
0.0163233206,
-0.1214755997,
0.0432287902,
-0.3982015848,
-0.1987454593,
-0.3618752956,
0.1119481251,
-0.7263203263,
0.1136815771,
-0.1471316218,
-0.2729892731,
-0.3592499793,
0.366173476,
-0.4969733357,
0.6027733684,
0.3634953201,
-0.4860645235,
-0.1190953255,
-0.9384089708,
-0.6859892011,
-0.0534899682,
-0.1499247402,
-0.1946972609,
0.5069725513,
0.0228578337,
0.3118389249,
-0.6415470243,
0.459081769,
0.4649415612,
-0.1145355254,
0.3361420333,
-0.531319499,
0.715749681,
0.6373040676,
-0.6515372396,
0.0373007171,
-0.6470014453,
0.1774660647,
0.3696249723,
-0.5052704811,
0.1754956692,
0.0225763377,
0.0003041679,
0.4231227934,
0.3991153836,
-0.4101935625,
0.1604013443,
-0.5592210293,
0.9126160145,
0.3545563817,
0.3214455843,
0.4824938476,
-0.0614125617,
0.9518784285,
-0.1206887662,
-0.1417763531,
-0.33071509,
-0.4942913055,
-0.5728291273,
0.5485889912,
0.5738155246,
0.5354425907,
-1.3405102491,
0.172448352,
-0.0660330653,
-0.165828228,
-0.326510936,
0.1036358178,
0.6479763985,
0.3976948559,
0.3952898383,
-0.2331832945,
-0.7931818366,
-1.0302785635,
0.0169153418,
0.0607040636,
-0.0078460705,
-0.1231995374,
0.3812071681,
-0.1786705405,
0.6100147963,
-0.2623788714,
0.0380486809,
-0.1546111256,
0.3346065581,
0.252627939,
0.676784277,
0.4163184464,
-0.7228930593,
-0.3656167686,
0.3885629177,
-0.7631449103,
0.1015193015,
-0.372277081,
-0.0196620803,
0.4288273752,
0.5596520901,
-0.3090470433,
0.4367895424,
0.6901311278,
0.1417459548,
0.3762808144,
-0.255484879,
0.2363878191,
-1.4639914036,
0.221950233,
-0.475579232,
-0.2027205974,
-0.6113334894,
0.5286847949,
0.0841628462,
-0.2825027108,
-0.3703358471,
-0.0112814466,
-0.7907948494,
-0.2321276069,
-0.4422478378,
-0.1284228712,
-0.2440581173,
0.4584870934,
-0.0144604901,
0.8194893003,
0.1497270763,
-0.3990628123,
0.4324452579,
0.0138017079,
-0.0297275893,
-0.0419671871,
-0.5800705552,
0.5428770185,
0.1848773509,
-0.1373129338,
-0.7715684772,
-0.2243096232,
0.2849161029,
-0.7075329423,
0.3970316648,
-0.3448415995,
-0.6360374689,
-0.326556474,
0.0107534407,
0.3251482844,
0.636040926,
-0.2615890801,
0.1099719256,
-0.0830702856,
-0.0160714798,
-0.515365839,
-1.0684393644,
0.4473060668,
-0.0232239198,
-0.4786740839,
0.3589234054,
0.1412588358,
0.0545264035,
0.052941788,
-0.0887113363,
-0.1500238478,
0.046501983,
-0.0078813164,
0.1177586243,
-0.832018137,
-0.0204460621,
0.1724843234,
-0.2484455258,
0.2433688492,
-0.662160635,
0.7016401887,
-0.284078151,
-0.2861835361,
0.2066104114,
0.6817283034,
0.3114212155,
-0.3893661499,
0.4785594046,
0.6845350862,
-0.4948891401,
-0.3125057518,
-0.0593918078,
-0.0401049666,
-0.4132135808,
0.4845887721,
-0.3764502704,
-0.5319447517,
0.3391317129,
-0.0695553571,
0.0772694051,
0.4087256193,
0.793200016,
0.2311876863,
1.0425214767,
0.5279260278,
0.2427011132,
0.2966034412,
-0.2429837734,
0.3823617697,
-0.7607298493,
0.1138193682,
-0.5762283802,
-0.4808711708,
-0.5234435797,
-0.464856267,
-0.0322365612,
0.2067289501,
0.0253809448,
0.8913443685,
-1.0588641167,
0.5974146128,
0.874258101,
-0.1770270467,
0.1699583083,
-0.0290398113,
-0.2528553903,
-0.0655843243,
-0.7379404306,
-0.5788946748,
0.9191272259,
0.2167102098,
0.1867927164,
0.0977507383,
0.9305202961,
0.1882492006,
0.2978252769,
-0.7256942987,
0.3845302463,
-0.1427706331,
-0.6389999986,
-0.1566142291,
-0.6445844769,
-0.9139721394,
-0.1586573571,
0.1297313124,
-0.2258374095,
0.032144893,
0.1294745803,
-0.1497313082,
0.1753475964,
-0.7848997712,
0.8252464533,
-0.430223763,
0.1053179577,
0.1686921716,
-0.7598877549,
0.4112950265,
-0.1101832166,
-0.2386108041,
0.298004806,
-0.061495509,
0.3233715892,
-0.2842113972,
0.6349241734,
-0.1270267814,
-0.0510163307,
0.366363287,
0.2444584817,
0.2194980234,
0.0320644863,
-0.1814642102,
0.105302006,
-0.0602228343,
-0.155827269,
-0.3096868992,
0.558536768,
-0.4610379934,
-0.2784946859,
-0.2134381533,
-0.7770335674,
-0.1200095713,
0.5608415008,
0.7955111861,
0.2923094332,
-0.0475294739,
0.0997401774,
0.3555449247,
-0.5859184265,
0.6297593713,
0.0650317445,
-0.4212684929,
-0.63470155,
1.2505133152,
0.0757459402,
0.2638756931,
0.4573057592,
0.0874076188,
-0.0840788856,
-1.0621893406,
-0.7108886242,
-0.1742356867,
-0.6670268774,
-0.8426564932,
-0.211123392,
-0.5197547078,
-0.4401427209,
-0.2019410282,
-0.3306120634,
-0.6798080206,
-0.1443737,
0.0619074628,
0.1664208472,
1.0704692602,
0.0475296788,
0.3127931654,
-0.7375833392,
0.4931549132,
0.0310744755,
0.2261219174,
-0.1433333755,
0.0415910482,
-0.4899373651,
0.156597808,
-0.5432181358,
-1.1515082121,
0.6005824804,
-0.2072830647,
0.4030506015,
-0.2445385009,
0.0423692688,
0.2477065623,
-0.527748704,
0.689263463,
0.4276811182,
-0.8376031518,
0.699211061,
-0.3962020874,
0.2458207011,
0.3441614509,
0.1057538316,
-0.5294774175,
-0.2920342386,
-0.3262533545,
-0.8664389253,
0.5408297777,
0.5025749803,
0.3829354942,
-0.2055477202,
0.4260582328,
-0.0262282342,
0.346154213,
-0.6929574609,
-0.0258470718,
-0.3338979483,
-0.3660491109,
0.2308885604,
0.2664006054,
0.2606253028,
0.0453880541,
0.4599353671,
-0.2516180277,
0.5533592105,
0.1679765284,
-0.2203779966,
-0.0727275908,
0.1946456283,
0.9402795434,
0.4305853248,
-0.0094624804,
-0.119400233,
-0.0756384805,
-0.3482815623,
0.0979413986,
0.0066695199,
-0.5981812477,
0.2221257538,
0.0140503766,
0.6092041731,
-0.0498528667,
-0.280869931,
0.3382712603,
-0.0445035212,
-0.537060678,
-0.3459857106,
0.0114102541,
0.3483598828,
0.018217735,
0.0796834603,
0.5296311378,
0.3110149503,
-0.2987876534,
0.1856699437,
0.2406709641,
-0.3240846992,
-0.2362463027,
0.7494775653,
0.1378634274,
-0.5806895494,
0.8448586464,
-0.3185797036,
-0.4916387796,
0.844204843,
0.8605044484,
1.3065167665,
0.0728705451,
0.0707229227,
0.4117651284,
0.6797726154,
0.0938415527,
0.182806775,
-0.0632159859,
-0.5214759707,
-0.8082357645,
-0.5871455669,
-0.2653983235,
-0.0347410776,
-0.6218184829,
0.1154373586,
-0.3983128667,
-0.4019712806,
-0.2664885819,
-0.180672124,
-0.516397953,
-0.2180410028,
0.3033542335,
0.8191372752,
-0.361297518,
0.8678835034,
1.0645984411,
-0.8140190244,
-0.6725714207,
-0.0228646062,
-0.1426264495,
-0.6073790193,
0.6421775818,
-0.0930112079,
-0.0729094148,
0.2010098994,
-0.3730522096,
-0.5694828629,
0.9222246408,
0.7010345459,
-0.0400195345,
-0.4874288142,
0.4810534716,
0.4825492501,
-0.4474654496,
-0.2219576389,
0.4558840096,
0.4899157584,
-0.184630394,
-0.6603614092,
0.1314885765,
-0.4651533067,
0.623888135,
0.2065985054,
-0.2582789958,
0.6142330766,
0.0536346063,
-0.0293591898,
0.3567222655,
0.4092936814,
-0.0480043143,
0.1603398174,
-0.0786312371,
0.0412394442,
0.1576574147,
-0.1406577975,
1.124724865,
-0.3066157401,
0.2679440975,
1.0619243383,
0.0627197549,
0.5361402631,
0.5852946639,
0.0834210515,
0.1153887585,
0.5683008432,
-0.160731703,
0.3366678655,
0.6138999462,
0.0954242125,
0.1665517986,
0.1287273169,
-0.4850058854,
0.3009208441,
0.2070262879,
-0.7722881436,
-0.1911899149,
0.1072895899,
-0.2653864026,
0.1915546358,
-0.0457309261,
0.7970213294,
0.175752908,
-0.8007073998,
0.7816143036,
0.4161803424,
0.6263875365,
-0.3207978308,
-0.3820261359,
-0.3803471625,
0.0382354259,
-0.1331642866,
-0.4169253409,
0.8208565712,
0.0920759365,
-0.3802464306,
-0.6542018652,
0.9357922077,
-0.1231246218,
-0.3725034297,
0.0539743714,
0.4678660929,
0.1964704394,
-0.1025294587,
-0.635027945,
-0.2278819978,
0.2804697156,
-0.3419738114,
0.1470473558,
0.4813278317,
0.0857366621,
0.3144766092,
0.5029348731,
0.1897833198,
0.6952834129,
-0.2523112595,
0.5561538935,
-0.7862429619,
-0.1608072221,
-0.611794889,
0.3526763618,
0.07480295,
-0.5268893242,
0.6440566778,
0.5817285776,
0.703458786,
-0.4136761427,
0.6985841393,
-0.348733902,
0.0823468491,
-0.7140951753,
0.678760469,
-0.2157579362,
0.1313200593,
-0.1515610218,
-1.1117178202,
-0.4119218588,
0.480494678,
0.0506603867,
0.0147278933,
0.9530372024,
0.6047697663,
0.132839337,
-0.03990281,
0.4279453158,
-0.2303877324,
0.1007508263,
0.7138411999,
0.9617806077,
-0.625716269,
0.7680423856,
-0.3755045235,
0.2378809899,
-0.0789850578,
-1.0113493204,
-0.5309676528,
-0.5699501038,
-0.3870099783,
-0.3701438904,
-0.1992604136,
0.8339112997,
0.782951355,
-0.7778098583,
-0.266220212,
-0.6260688901,
0.1638541222,
-0.4135491252,
-0.1791838109,
0.0295898151,
-0.7923243642,
-0.658264339,
0.5278137326,
0.1795482188,
0.0659041628,
-0.3759800792,
-0.3313616216,
0.047889661,
-0.183328107,
0.5940126181,
0.330185622,
-0.421344161,
0.0846802965,
0.4792773724,
-0.2398218662,
0.1433563232,
1.0700585842,
-0.3214613199,
0.2182849944,
0.7473569512,
1.2515547276,
0.398614645,
-0.2880218625,
1.0507754087,
-1.0551786423,
-0.2197227031,
0.6459726095,
0.1415964663,
0.2326748818,
-0.3847090006,
0.6837669611,
-0.0482656918,
-0.5161649585,
-0.7724167705,
0.3944589198,
-0.585629344,
-0.2522313595,
0.9167944193,
0.1996737272,
-0.1329777241,
-0.1267622709,
-0.1346860826,
0.4898082018,
0.0167171136,
0.2366611063,
0.5964050889,
-0.065686129,
-0.0156278685,
-1.1870652437,
0.2765859365,
0.3626925349,
-0.7306275964,
-0.0958135575,
0.4545111954,
0.0303712171,
0.4181845188,
0.3869405985,
-0.4965892434,
0.3926286697,
0.10893628,
0.3648789227,
-0.2710122168,
0.0036254788,
-0.4987006485,
0.1519401371,
0.2647486925,
-0.3968525827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13499v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13499v2 | Learning Easily Updated General Purpose Text Representations with Adaptable Task-Specific Prefixes | 2023-05-22T21:31:03 | 2023-10-14T15:35:07 | Kuan-Hao Huang, Liang Tan, Rui Hou, Sinong Wang, Amjad Almahairi, Ruty Rinott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many real-world applications require making multiple predictions from the
same text. Fine-tuning a large pre-trained language model for each downstream
task causes computational burdens in the inference time due to several times of
forward passes. To amortize the computational cost, freezing the language model
and building lightweight models for downstream tasks based on fixed text
representations are common solutions. Accordingly, how to learn fixed but
general text representations that can generalize well to unseen downstream
tasks becomes a challenge. Previous works have shown that the generalizability
of representations can be improved by fine-tuning the pre-trained language
model with some source tasks in a multi-tasking way. In this work, we propose a
prefix-based method to learn the fixed text representations with source tasks.
We learn a task-specific prefix for each source task independently and combine
them to get the final representations. Our experimental results show that
prefix-based training performs better than multi-tasking training and can
update the text representations at a smaller computational cost than
multi-tasking training. | [
-0.1018986627,
-0.3572047055,
0.606975615,
0.1753619164,
-0.5705268383,
0.0377744585,
-0.5877060294,
-0.346888572,
0.3496167958,
0.5031017065,
-0.692994535,
-0.2650274038,
-0.7979286909,
0.2973205745,
-0.0067430194,
0.9200960398,
-0.1676016152,
-0.1322170049,
0.0307779461,
-0.244580254,
-0.9630568027,
-0.488399148,
-0.6760698557,
-0.2177802324,
0.5691077113,
0.4220137596,
0.5249333382,
0.6952176094,
0.2413762212,
0.2891876996,
0.2820208967,
0.302923888,
-0.3805741966,
0.3264533579,
-0.493519485,
-0.2659178078,
-0.0767855421,
-0.1457115561,
0.62423563,
0.5887722969,
0.0302245524,
0.0136023555,
0.2470341921,
0.3975917101,
-0.7963014841,
0.2519313991,
-0.9323661327,
-0.3929383159,
-0.1101541519,
-0.1626689583,
-0.5317010283,
0.1929496229,
-0.0554370917,
-0.8774836659,
0.3532783389,
-0.1455629617,
0.8740683198,
0.4206887186,
-0.3487848341,
-0.3607572317,
-0.6162106395,
1.0780605078,
-0.4151223898,
0.4815635383,
0.4828763306,
0.1038630828,
0.057238698,
-0.7827963829,
-0.1501599252,
-0.1334070116,
-0.3356579542,
-0.0007851799,
0.0911034793,
0.0557466485,
0.0817051455,
0.0669644028,
-0.209200263,
-0.0463162996,
-0.0598781034,
-0.0861670747,
0.4001401067,
0.007099486,
0.2721303105,
-0.0010315665,
-0.2343192101,
-0.1044856533,
-0.4204366207,
-0.0786418319,
-0.0636809021,
0.7290437222,
0.0552840792,
0.0255827587,
-0.1413988471,
0.6886698008,
0.2099077553,
0.1884884089,
0.2546536028,
-0.2418509275,
-0.3602280021,
-0.0936937928,
0.5429052114,
-0.1551249921,
0.3256137073,
-0.543300271,
-0.0578982234,
-0.2797755897,
0.7370463014,
-0.7480945587,
0.0105645256,
-0.0429815203,
-0.0248446893,
0.1577271521,
-0.069159776,
-0.2892084718,
-0.22674568,
-0.5485066772,
0.4301605821,
-0.5001852512,
0.0554964766,
0.1050676331,
-0.0048944117,
-0.1475008726,
0.5279449821,
-1.1804964542,
0.1948281974,
0.3827819824,
0.755946219,
-0.1704708934,
-0.3788256943,
-0.9353570342,
0.4028047621,
-0.2556761205,
0.7779679894,
-0.5538227558,
-0.2993605733,
-0.2307518125,
0.1832906306,
-0.2421068698,
-0.2423882782,
0.3818955123,
-0.536658287,
-0.1200749576,
-0.0241763573,
-0.4215619266,
-0.223126635,
0.1483105719,
-0.8107600212,
1.0850695372,
0.1368053854,
-0.7515684962,
0.2064733058,
-0.4522947371,
-0.3767671883,
0.015224915,
-0.0005075436,
-0.3438270986,
0.2559582889,
0.4688954353,
0.7195051312,
-0.3126334846,
0.4717969596,
0.1926860511,
-0.4553133845,
-0.4038769603,
-0.2026461065,
0.2407734692,
-0.0790460631,
-0.3127065301,
0.3196361065,
-0.575989306,
-0.0790578276,
-0.1709756404,
-0.3471411169,
-0.8308385611,
0.1469393671,
-0.0970919281,
-0.2192329466,
0.1797715873,
-0.3819712996,
0.4319290519,
-0.3619788587,
0.0847093984,
0.6604152322,
-0.0971513391,
0.6325783134,
-0.0124986358,
0.2322124392,
0.0517395027,
-0.2696255147,
-0.4805316627,
-0.4472780228,
-0.8030511737,
-0.4085450768,
0.6173755527,
0.4624259174,
-1.0043344498,
0.0527275465,
-0.525349617,
-0.5685658455,
-0.3519206047,
0.279260546,
0.4116274118,
0.2446334511,
0.7350645065,
-0.2080212981,
-0.3743360341,
-0.6746180654,
-0.6718156338,
0.2281225026,
-0.1883683354,
0.0719479248,
0.367593199,
-0.4224698842,
1.0136543512,
-0.7754026651,
-0.2481835634,
-0.2238502055,
0.7964427471,
0.1168663055,
0.5459057689,
0.3305974901,
-0.9964354038,
-0.6328280568,
-0.0482694395,
-0.2013406307,
-0.081725806,
-0.5003519654,
0.0119030531,
-0.0624190718,
0.6281566024,
-0.4035252333,
0.1748614907,
0.5665607452,
-0.4469729364,
0.5991219282,
-0.4489155114,
0.0853102356,
-1.2412080765,
0.0127294883,
0.0691260844,
-0.5239582658,
-0.8054937124,
0.1577402353,
0.3664239645,
-0.1745271534,
-0.3752614856,
0.7687847614,
-0.9236732125,
0.2681542337,
-0.362201333,
-0.2336090058,
-0.0626101121,
0.7454863787,
0.3752386272,
0.8735021949,
0.6855527759,
-0.9012334943,
0.0136104077,
-0.0317943171,
0.0037149489,
0.1669806242,
-0.4054547846,
0.2210385203,
-0.412999928,
-0.0319272801,
-0.5054265857,
-0.0817743987,
0.1162040681,
-0.2182652056,
0.4618763924,
-0.1759417653,
-0.2262032926,
0.0433490947,
-0.0859312192,
0.4141540825,
0.2545637786,
-0.4598431289,
0.9942703843,
0.0704157576,
-0.2198542356,
-0.6075168252,
-0.6090294719,
0.0073175221,
0.1571298093,
-0.074930802,
0.8660961986,
0.0407468379,
0.3439364731,
0.2335031033,
-0.3004844487,
-0.444260329,
0.0795033947,
0.3627290726,
-0.0862090215,
0.0181771461,
0.5183763504,
0.0692984834,
-0.4197744131,
-0.5359891057,
-0.3326343894,
0.3314172626,
0.220768705,
-0.264442116,
-0.0026498334,
0.5485762954,
0.3879501522,
-0.3622794747,
0.6333504915,
0.5422662497,
-0.4899394512,
-0.4293828011,
-0.2995325327,
-0.060251195,
-0.4927496314,
0.4706143439,
-0.5894796848,
-1.090493679,
0.257509619,
-0.3742426634,
0.1730957329,
0.4620920122,
0.3515482843,
0.1723614633,
0.6605949998,
1.0719172955,
-0.1086340398,
0.4578209817,
-0.0306759216,
0.0154946167,
-0.49800089,
0.031221047,
-0.5124741197,
-0.1636045873,
-0.1975816637,
-0.8642494678,
0.0027688646,
0.4003686905,
-0.3201025128,
0.6320953369,
-0.5446758866,
0.525472939,
0.546790719,
0.0778859034,
0.3185196519,
0.2164927423,
-0.1746769845,
-0.0574673153,
-0.4139972925,
-0.2494679689,
0.8022382855,
0.1918691844,
0.5829473734,
-0.141861394,
0.7524468303,
0.4360595345,
0.5466074944,
-0.7399201393,
0.348315537,
-0.4856615663,
-0.2225245535,
-0.2474728078,
-0.4800350964,
-0.9127028584,
0.3339971006,
-0.1739055216,
-0.8395348787,
0.1233848482,
0.2294398546,
-0.0570304319,
0.3666325212,
-0.6697250009,
0.8900590539,
0.0317717865,
-0.1784174889,
-0.3816487491,
-0.3332743347,
-0.0869916528,
-0.342708081,
0.2237907052,
-0.0216412451,
-0.3116239905,
0.6258696318,
-0.3234087825,
1.0119174719,
-0.1622206718,
-0.0190126617,
0.3284043372,
-0.2283677012,
0.6303537488,
0.083147943,
-0.2328864932,
0.0962629765,
-0.437558502,
-0.4790320694,
-0.7092730999,
0.515910089,
-0.6248261929,
-0.6044676304,
-0.5843383074,
-0.5402007103,
-0.5271293521,
0.3463646173,
0.2062799335,
0.6926242113,
-0.2423993647,
-0.1355961263,
0.407158494,
-0.0160180219,
0.6324578524,
0.3859934807,
0.1523756534,
-0.5099562407,
0.7836951017,
-0.1562271863,
-0.0305097569,
0.7100383043,
-0.0602220781,
-0.1331570446,
-0.5003439784,
-0.5855656266,
0.188683778,
-0.5691720247,
-0.4274185002,
-0.5164256096,
0.0490464643,
0.049377095,
-0.3163360655,
-0.3313330114,
-0.151606068,
-0.664521277,
0.1036790609,
0.4992697239,
0.6121641397,
0.121684283,
0.5419173241,
-1.0526206493,
0.6509157419,
0.587967813,
0.6453197002,
0.0308030304,
-0.233912915,
-0.6513386965,
0.1257359087,
-0.3049226701,
-1.0684945583,
0.2236223519,
0.5730423331,
0.2288763374,
0.0403011702,
0.0321246423,
0.8293491006,
-0.8490536213,
0.8111186028,
0.4587855339,
-1.2750583887,
0.3739751577,
-0.234997645,
0.5820627213,
0.641615212,
0.6966602206,
-0.6215361953,
-0.3363596201,
-0.3208165765,
-0.7169340849,
0.774748385,
0.1512307972,
0.5128602386,
0.0208950844,
0.5378316641,
0.2567927837,
0.037737269,
-0.6079054475,
-0.1967697144,
-0.3172989488,
-0.1678212881,
-0.3716126978,
-0.2117159963,
0.4464099407,
-0.3134314716,
0.7556957006,
-0.4689119458,
0.2390584648,
0.2963079214,
-0.4130952656,
0.3108658791,
0.4832942784,
0.3538531959,
0.4031938314,
-0.0934321955,
0.3340841234,
0.2955103517,
-0.8451468945,
0.4076386094,
0.144883424,
-0.0558048896,
0.4648516476,
0.3104020655,
1.019438982,
0.5568673015,
-0.6077138782,
0.2764773369,
0.0210066177,
-0.0319937132,
0.3116360009,
-0.0321196057,
0.330257982,
-0.0332212001,
0.5897570848,
0.2809809148,
-0.1609356105,
-0.4852226079,
0.244974792,
0.1220485866,
-0.5196989775,
-0.2929081619,
0.4864178002,
0.2809814811,
-0.0341532603,
0.3145650625,
-0.5752516985,
-0.4910004139,
0.4178042412,
0.6393395066,
1.1436591148,
-0.4218961,
0.2537051141,
0.4309028983,
0.0303628631,
-0.3522596061,
0.2069761455,
-0.0619138591,
-0.5571605563,
-1.0074057579,
-0.6432289481,
-0.5368244052,
-0.0120351957,
-0.314733386,
0.3991396725,
-0.1234326139,
-0.285142988,
-0.1072276309,
-0.2719263136,
-0.5513621569,
0.4442061782,
-0.0013089528,
0.8991264701,
-0.6601243615,
0.9207499027,
1.1086996794,
-0.1929898858,
-0.9083482623,
0.2568235695,
-0.5344886184,
-0.2732273638,
0.7725301385,
0.2752038538,
-0.1527033448,
0.2683459222,
-0.1784307063,
-1.0410398245,
0.7302405834,
0.7030155659,
-0.4791045785,
-0.2894375324,
0.1766294241,
0.2976893187,
-0.254068017,
0.2984754145,
-0.0351936109,
0.3067789078,
-0.2191753238,
-0.9725443721,
0.2923208177,
-0.3070622087,
0.2145673335,
0.5563204885,
-0.3000099659,
0.8966308832,
0.0512675308,
-0.5141485333,
-0.226308465,
0.7627007365,
-0.0989721045,
0.0786585361,
0.5530006886,
0.5510784388,
0.7159053683,
-0.090054132,
0.8873689175,
-0.1868686378,
0.4388875961,
1.1588895321,
0.0610804521,
0.7619188428,
0.2563416064,
0.198058024,
0.6858292222,
0.3873695433,
0.077338025,
0.8248152137,
0.1828380376,
-0.2592747808,
-0.4294413328,
-0.0077672862,
-0.0615111366,
0.2807122171,
0.3218549192,
-0.1297595501,
-0.6834543347,
0.3085764349,
0.0205917992,
0.1599534303,
-0.6895908117,
0.6846155524,
0.1204056218,
-0.8988291025,
0.8394337296,
0.3864356875,
0.9519049525,
-0.9420064688,
-0.1032169312,
0.1843963712,
0.0870541111,
-0.0378651991,
-0.3145945966,
0.5785216093,
0.104056634,
-0.4794352055,
-0.6516376734,
1.0650984049,
-0.4847266972,
-0.3251321316,
0.2808519602,
0.3647873998,
-0.1940108389,
-0.5533339381,
-0.4063217938,
-0.1153523922,
0.0007096774,
-0.1571046114,
0.3118409216,
0.192521587,
-0.2502602637,
0.6298037767,
0.4229514301,
0.1139141172,
0.0224787071,
-0.1331455112,
0.8960018754,
-0.8212709427,
-0.8073826432,
-0.7182742953,
0.644558847,
0.0575044602,
-0.1971189827,
0.4313773811,
0.297657311,
0.4930460751,
-0.4740538597,
0.7619849443,
0.1096621156,
0.3342467844,
-0.6721165776,
0.5381880999,
-0.5485650301,
-0.2231210023,
-0.0650486425,
-0.9603142738,
-0.3451078832,
0.2453915477,
-0.1682982594,
-0.2116035074,
0.8616377115,
0.459792614,
-0.3873030841,
0.0224462189,
0.0631483272,
-0.1897766888,
-0.0927373618,
0.7037007213,
0.2309070975,
-0.308865428,
0.2891342938,
-0.110404551,
-0.1268472075,
-0.0045587691,
-1.2818479538,
-0.734913528,
-0.9394061565,
-0.5307320356,
0.1951330453,
0.3502631485,
0.733039856,
0.7886270881,
-0.7819555998,
-0.0184048545,
-0.2504090071,
0.1808454096,
-0.5825858116,
-0.1573617011,
0.5989629626,
-0.9016763568,
-0.8075179458,
0.3458959758,
0.0590407178,
-0.1553322375,
0.2617303729,
-0.0003850376,
-0.1471942812,
0.1290698051,
0.5653633475,
0.3817000985,
-0.3863047659,
-0.3774892986,
-0.191366151,
-0.1023970842,
0.0811223835,
1.0897519588,
-1.0028995275,
0.3565833867,
0.4286236167,
1.010982275,
0.5944432616,
0.0775877908,
0.614233613,
-1.3735853434,
0.1884395629,
0.0816273093,
0.3340349793,
0.3536704481,
-0.2950598001,
0.3837758303,
0.1765746325,
-0.2206602246,
-0.4011306167,
0.298315376,
-0.9158753157,
-0.6216729283,
0.9116324186,
-0.2373115569,
0.0543293022,
-0.2080246061,
-0.1313084662,
0.503685832,
-0.3729380369,
0.288449347,
0.4646683633,
0.20350416,
-0.0160082225,
-0.3208215237,
0.6604552865,
0.3445765376,
-0.7498982549,
0.2053642571,
0.2487620115,
0.1336012632,
0.4198049009,
0.632840693,
0.3774012625,
0.0031852997,
-0.2611982822,
0.1529866159,
-0.2305762023,
-0.3110150397,
-0.2673568726,
0.1545800567,
-0.0980867743,
-0.2606883049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13484v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13484v3 | Flover: A Temporal Fusion Framework for Efficient Autoregressive Model Parallel Inference | 2023-05-22T20:58:09 | 2023-11-03T03:37:20 | Jinghan Yao, Nawras Alnaasan, Tian Chen, Aamir Shafi, Hari Subramoni, Dhabaleswar K., Panda | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Autoregressive models, despite their commendable performance in a myriad of
generative tasks, face challenges stemming from their inherently sequential
structure. Inference on these models, by design, harnesses a temporal
dependency, where the current token's probability distribution is conditioned
on preceding tokens. This inherent characteristic severely impedes
computational efficiency during inference as a typical inference request can
require more than thousands of tokens, where generating each token requires a
load of entire model weights, making the inference more memory-bound. The large
overhead becomes profound in real deployment where requests arrive randomly,
necessitating various generation lengths. Existing solutions, such as dynamic
batching and concurrent instances, introduce significant response delays and
bandwidth contention, falling short of achieving optimal latency and
throughput. To address these shortcomings, we propose Flover -- a temporal
fusion framework for efficiently inferring multiple requests in parallel. We
deconstruct the general generation pipeline into pre-processing and token
generation, and equip the framework with a dedicated work scheduler for fusing
the generation process temporally across all requests. By orchestrating the
token-level parallelism, Flover exhibits optimal hardware efficiency and
significantly spares the system resources. By further employing a fast buffer
reordering algorithm that allows memory eviction of finished tasks, it brings
over 11x inference speedup on GPT and 16x on LLAMA compared to the cutting-edge
solutions provided by NVIDIA FasterTransformer. Crucially, by leveraging the
advanced tensor parallel technique, Flover proves efficacious across diverse
computational landscapes, from single-GPU setups to distributed scenarios,
thereby offering robust performance optimization that adapts to variable use
cases. | [
-0.4544856846,
-0.8691753149,
0.4420705736,
0.4669180214,
-0.0458468348,
0.2735300362,
0.2489119768,
-0.5434626937,
0.1227020398,
0.1496028602,
-0.7287162542,
0.1231810078,
-0.4078733921,
-0.0273141917,
-0.8205052018,
0.4264040291,
-0.2103361934,
-0.2981600463,
-0.2873035073,
-0.0892450213,
-0.1381893158,
-0.2485055476,
-0.6711013317,
-0.356810689,
0.5065203905,
0.1968735158,
0.89913553,
0.8677872419,
0.4993806183,
0.3812373281,
0.3453662097,
0.068835713,
-0.3027146161,
0.2689186931,
-0.115125224,
-0.403732866,
-0.2521769404,
-0.4023909271,
0.7521420121,
0.5908654332,
-0.2424264997,
0.1509197205,
-0.2301902324,
0.4329145551,
-1.0486510992,
0.0710195452,
-0.4273006618,
0.4311209619,
-0.4996308982,
0.16891931,
-0.2354471236,
-0.2281842083,
0.1411062479,
-0.6244322062,
0.6681288481,
0.4131599963,
0.8640084267,
0.3182610869,
-0.2818446457,
0.5150982738,
-0.9699937701,
0.7471097708,
-0.5057271123,
0.5937709212,
-0.0861527622,
0.611502707,
-0.168775171,
-1.1734063625,
-0.5941108465,
0.2253312171,
-0.0198592655,
-0.0441754162,
-0.2320988923,
0.1693900526,
0.280846417,
0.7493789792,
-0.7317634225,
0.0192354266,
0.1848812252,
-0.1908458471,
0.4095665514,
0.3480208814,
0.1587717086,
0.1489957124,
-0.649354279,
-0.2942635417,
-0.4153360426,
-0.3395839036,
0.2582455873,
0.0393306687,
-0.0517123453,
0.2530445755,
-0.284661144,
0.7888092399,
0.0998117626,
0.2570667863,
0.2288152426,
-0.3009213507,
-0.4197062552,
-0.0815154091,
0.7780637145,
-0.0478471667,
-0.1433070004,
-0.3201305866,
-0.2602373958,
0.0068703257,
0.2139762342,
-0.7994738221,
-0.1175719574,
0.49906075,
-0.3769011199,
-0.1995359957,
0.2845633626,
-1.198438406,
-0.0426595211,
-0.0929577649,
0.5374823809,
-0.2753584385,
-0.6650045514,
-0.0794465095,
-0.3347583115,
0.2648758292,
0.0352950096,
-0.8200776577,
0.2113459557,
0.7748093605,
1.0938147306,
-0.2404291928,
-0.4860740304,
-0.8693600297,
0.3244057298,
-0.3129098713,
0.8288696408,
-0.5379877687,
-0.3537304103,
-0.1228641868,
-0.1196693107,
-0.3782042265,
-0.3016031981,
-0.0862518549,
-0.5240310431,
0.0318605453,
-0.2310551703,
-0.5135774016,
-0.0058342069,
-0.394230634,
-0.6821498275,
0.7423089743,
0.0959076583,
-0.6507988572,
0.6135175824,
-0.6181574464,
-0.5908069015,
-0.0471327715,
-0.2398326248,
-0.3017069995,
0.2212868333,
0.3696927726,
0.3303290308,
-0.4573440552,
0.2187137157,
-0.495303452,
-0.2592961788,
-0.3383904397,
-0.2840128243,
0.3932581842,
0.8558207154,
-0.646751225,
0.4095323086,
-0.552205801,
-0.1922836304,
0.2113547176,
0.4324596524,
0.036545407,
0.158737272,
0.1306334138,
-0.0977198333,
-0.1622266769,
-0.4722157419,
-0.047003828,
-0.4447055459,
0.6405676007,
0.5753872991,
0.0816432387,
0.5573757887,
-0.5320685506,
0.5276028514,
0.2642597854,
0.4455071688,
-0.209387213,
-0.1486981362,
-0.693659246,
-0.4686079919,
0.1801540554,
0.4971216917,
-0.877433598,
-0.0460877009,
-0.2400303334,
-0.3585599065,
-0.2599129379,
0.0341086388,
0.2543192208,
0.3577427268,
0.254118681,
-0.1343726963,
-0.4844154716,
-0.9889079332,
-0.315151006,
-0.0302232839,
-0.0142632984,
-0.1316771507,
0.3780783713,
-0.1261286288,
0.9412437081,
-0.4152197242,
0.0099734077,
-0.0102993874,
0.5555888414,
0.0121407947,
0.5832089782,
0.7069564462,
-0.8775903583,
-0.1535857469,
-0.1694706827,
-0.7849668264,
-0.0535861738,
-0.3892539442,
-0.5528407097,
0.2522181571,
0.4021236897,
-0.5690595508,
0.3906432986,
0.2776034772,
-0.3154335022,
0.3294863999,
-0.1444558948,
0.3043017387,
-0.6546635032,
0.0688690841,
-0.4827856719,
-0.2974429727,
-0.5164707303,
-0.0851231441,
-0.1248784289,
-0.0754824728,
-0.3470448256,
0.7264817357,
-0.4762328565,
-0.1697017848,
-0.1684902608,
-0.427898109,
0.2518084049,
0.1328806877,
0.1413678527,
0.8208563328,
0.4146670401,
-0.5923878551,
0.1110597625,
0.0573189035,
-0.3525699973,
0.4208633304,
-0.5662707686,
0.0204638988,
-0.1155803204,
0.326798439,
-0.8630716801,
-0.4192213416,
-0.0275817253,
-0.0148420958,
0.27129969,
0.0697952658,
-0.7830460668,
-0.4083251953,
0.1392453015,
0.7169672847,
0.5497341156,
-0.8214399815,
1.1487383842,
0.25159356,
0.1776448786,
-0.6315194964,
-0.8645936847,
-0.1725134403,
-0.1677715629,
-0.8295714259,
0.6600376368,
0.3132906556,
-0.4259291887,
0.1086155325,
-0.2897884846,
-0.1119153425,
-0.1619039625,
0.3791925907,
0.0023668162,
-0.2434450388,
-0.123558186,
0.1155690551,
-0.1583877206,
-0.165384382,
-0.5421840549,
0.5218278766,
-0.1476521045,
-0.6253523827,
-0.3298017085,
0.5097178817,
0.9503442645,
-0.26669541,
0.8506080508,
1.0419629812,
-0.350607425,
-0.1753518283,
-1.0613096952,
-0.3175606132,
-0.4465579093,
-0.1399563551,
-0.4773250222,
-0.5545829535,
0.7245903015,
0.1594237089,
0.6467092633,
0.6186679602,
0.3915092349,
0.0065556057,
0.8994659185,
0.1682444066,
0.0074881548,
0.8696331978,
-0.3935391903,
0.0141836843,
-0.1272574514,
-0.089358665,
0.0484092943,
-0.302470088,
-0.0654183403,
-0.4618922174,
0.2153767347,
-0.0997505188,
-0.4709214866,
0.2087979466,
-0.3162451386,
-0.0375850759,
0.5721728206,
-0.0573000871,
0.2130614519,
0.2516114712,
-0.2310703248,
0.3286152184,
-1.1157723665,
0.2526355088,
0.5672066808,
0.2296718061,
0.5521153808,
0.003778717,
0.6415703893,
0.5321529508,
0.1431801617,
0.0128626702,
0.3082016706,
-0.0210696999,
-0.6963136792,
-0.0019161274,
-0.5762937665,
-0.7259332538,
0.4489922822,
-0.1730570495,
-0.5040030479,
0.4877850115,
0.4906509519,
-0.5744930506,
0.7384100556,
-0.8166719675,
0.8714523315,
-0.1718410552,
-0.8988192081,
-0.5638558865,
-0.6899317503,
0.5908952951,
-0.071002461,
0.1771382242,
-0.2550297976,
-0.0115777608,
0.4606468678,
-1.053891778,
0.6150835156,
-0.4594560564,
0.4266570508,
0.468554467,
0.0325008743,
0.5210217834,
-0.1182409376,
0.0270893313,
0.2638990581,
0.3541463912,
-0.5991587639,
-0.5514137149,
0.6953065991,
-0.4835849404,
-0.3884491324,
-0.6241679788,
-0.6089693308,
-0.0687120482,
0.1853871495,
0.3167135417,
0.6054689288,
-0.0430416502,
-0.2155520469,
0.2992387712,
-0.1263079494,
0.5978446603,
0.0738488436,
-0.3712017238,
-0.5136085153,
0.9759705663,
-0.0958871618,
0.4178560376,
0.5042328835,
0.0819082856,
-0.5350759029,
-0.3495478034,
-0.410500735,
0.3239450753,
-0.4282843471,
-0.1612177044,
-0.7380752563,
-0.0569007285,
-0.3224574327,
-0.3443032503,
-0.5081335306,
-0.3428505659,
-0.2067610323,
0.1130393595,
0.6633921862,
0.5038250685,
-0.4078631997,
0.5992842913,
-0.6975182295,
0.5476307869,
0.1703268141,
0.2432884127,
0.2893877327,
-0.0698931962,
0.256696254,
-0.1643371135,
-0.0004659457,
-0.4165066481,
0.0781975985,
0.3354681134,
0.7620067596,
0.6202676296,
0.0822435841,
1.1101745367,
-0.3374882042,
0.606749177,
0.169787541,
-0.8424224854,
0.3744217455,
-0.1880848855,
0.5031095743,
0.5521085858,
0.094421342,
-0.0967462286,
-0.3113305569,
-0.765381217,
-1.1270256042,
0.3866940439,
0.3187614083,
-0.3480247855,
-0.2942743003,
0.3364882767,
0.2123910487,
0.2612349689,
0.1744653732,
-0.1904270798,
-0.4403615594,
-0.0690497831,
0.1329678297,
-0.1714940816,
0.0622877143,
-0.1855626255,
0.4372424185,
0.1133724898,
0.5045984983,
0.3187999427,
-0.2928445935,
-0.0202400442,
-0.1652276069,
0.437602073,
0.6369552016,
-0.1464984566,
0.0187949482,
0.2505863905,
-0.3030648828,
0.1244586483,
0.4267747402,
-0.0066085937,
0.0292371623,
0.4045332968,
0.8465871215,
0.450576961,
-0.4862831831,
0.2325396389,
-0.187150836,
-0.2605262101,
-0.3022516668,
0.1534968913,
-0.2352065146,
0.5487008095,
0.4272179902,
0.1115420833,
-0.0730396584,
-0.0644797236,
0.5844379067,
0.3941586614,
-0.0059969453,
-0.0331261195,
1.2377077341,
0.1993673593,
0.0094708307,
0.798586309,
0.0738821849,
-0.142294988,
0.5211450458,
0.2081304789,
1.1904364824,
-0.1300780922,
-0.1509951502,
0.3466862142,
-0.2350448519,
-0.4522890151,
0.2687444389,
-0.4868220389,
-0.3288956881,
-0.4525678456,
-1.0831412077,
-0.1498013586,
-0.2893610001,
-0.5606825352,
-0.1546977013,
-0.6666877866,
-0.4137915671,
-0.0653614923,
-0.3908103406,
-0.8643699288,
-0.2195373178,
0.0755344406,
1.0945222378,
-0.6820114255,
0.5469380021,
0.2517957687,
-0.2936736941,
-0.2599048913,
-0.1798226982,
0.3738966286,
-0.7445164323,
0.5933009982,
-0.008550168,
-0.3147827089,
0.3143964112,
0.0829558596,
-0.8515890241,
1.1785085201,
0.3326437175,
-0.6983317733,
-0.3014321923,
0.0249108318,
0.027657276,
-0.3210515678,
0.4404707253,
0.5689635873,
0.4956053495,
0.4091521204,
-0.7249694467,
-0.0416292921,
0.0252340753,
0.2924285531,
0.447273016,
-0.6262276173,
0.6482651234,
-0.2774338126,
-0.4060022533,
0.1435003281,
1.2861646414,
0.2230061591,
0.1767183393,
1.0693253279,
0.4524405003,
0.4682245255,
-0.265155226,
1.1631119251,
-0.4709476829,
0.12160559,
0.9187192321,
-0.1806364059,
0.6609506011,
0.5141078234,
-0.2102266401,
0.3915788531,
0.646001637,
-0.013324582,
0.5456269979,
-0.0938220844,
-0.5907077789,
-0.3170830607,
0.025156036,
-0.2899951041,
0.1834426075,
0.308393836,
-0.3076429069,
-0.5088024735,
0.2274162471,
-0.2538259625,
-0.3481814861,
-0.1904508919,
0.4098666608,
0.1195229217,
-0.7127954364,
0.4031937122,
-0.4498408735,
0.5384720564,
-0.7800058126,
-0.0494419821,
-0.2338093519,
0.5090155602,
-0.3178322911,
-0.2273174226,
0.574195683,
-0.337613076,
-0.2836122513,
-0.4082684219,
0.4266121089,
-0.2636425197,
-0.5524741411,
0.2293421477,
0.3331331313,
-0.0139435036,
-0.1201706529,
-0.5677572489,
0.3756232858,
-0.2821829021,
-0.214361921,
0.296808362,
0.0328575671,
-0.0916761085,
0.6919913888,
0.7373669744,
-0.1211245582,
0.3152408302,
0.2307889909,
0.4243707359,
-0.5128054023,
-0.4522148669,
-0.8211093545,
0.3271773756,
0.0285407975,
-0.0852271616,
0.440415889,
0.541272819,
0.58871454,
0.0244203396,
0.585983336,
-0.2584730089,
0.1233696342,
-0.408123523,
0.6271510124,
-0.7620856166,
0.0301330239,
-0.1058161706,
-0.7800956964,
-0.2080801725,
0.4040336609,
-0.4191945195,
0.1088779941,
0.5228584409,
0.6805480123,
-0.2808487415,
0.3222631216,
0.1373830736,
0.0051393476,
0.4733089507,
0.5932309628,
0.6275550127,
-0.3287184238,
0.5042716861,
-0.5227347016,
-0.2249487936,
-0.2108613998,
-0.9544866681,
-0.5098068118,
-0.6357575059,
-0.3984329104,
-0.2157367617,
0.267688334,
0.8554801941,
0.8024582863,
-0.8366580606,
-0.1303063631,
-0.5843792558,
-0.1365586966,
-0.6433597803,
-0.3270374238,
0.2705295086,
-0.6534435153,
-0.7318291664,
0.3419402242,
0.2102108449,
0.1193316281,
-0.3603812456,
0.3525084555,
-0.3034149706,
-0.2783828676,
0.5268951058,
0.6843386889,
-0.8486751318,
-0.2994322181,
-0.1473461837,
0.2013259977,
-0.1389847696,
1.0498443842,
-0.847661078,
0.6313791871,
0.8382475376,
0.7882393599,
1.0479601622,
0.1616333425,
1.1153099537,
-0.3822642565,
0.3586069942,
0.1145674884,
0.4268859029,
0.08818838,
-0.2986431122,
0.3457001746,
0.5702501535,
-0.544610858,
-0.9782137871,
0.1470240653,
-0.6540609002,
-0.3167422712,
0.8139741421,
0.1279556006,
-0.3249171674,
-0.1428433061,
0.4984619319,
0.3004537523,
-0.3657814562,
0.2797496915,
0.4324213564,
-0.5617744327,
-0.3012669086,
-0.7257510424,
0.452162534,
0.6877159476,
-0.3910396099,
0.2628399432,
0.4149646759,
0.2798463106,
-0.0614774227,
0.5260349512,
-0.0431291461,
0.2638007998,
0.5689525008,
-0.112981841,
-0.3184944391,
-0.4220835268,
-0.0640357807,
0.3538673222,
-0.2264023721,
-0.475120306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13478v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13478v2 | Automatic Readability Assessment for Closely Related Languages | 2023-05-22T20:42:53 | 2023-05-25T10:41:50 | Joseph Marvin Imperial, Ekaterina Kochmar | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, the main focus of research on automatic readability
assessment (ARA) has shifted towards using expensive deep learning-based
methods with the primary goal of increasing models' accuracy. This, however, is
rarely applicable for low-resource languages where traditional handcrafted
features are still widely used due to the lack of existing NLP tools to extract
deeper linguistic representations. In this work, we take a step back from the
technical component and focus on how linguistic aspects such as mutual
intelligibility or degree of language relatedness can improve ARA in a
low-resource setting. We collect short stories written in three languages in
the Philippines-Tagalog, Bikol, and Cebuano-to train readability assessment
models and explore the interaction of data and features in various
cross-lingual setups. Our results show that the inclusion of CrossNGO, a novel
specialized feature exploiting n-gram overlap applied to languages with high
mutual intelligibility, significantly improves the performance of ARA models
compared to the use of off-the-shelf large multilingual language models alone.
Consequently, when both linguistic representations are combined, we achieve
state-of-the-art results for Tagalog and Cebuano, and baseline scores for ARA
in Bikol. | [
-0.5048879385,
-0.4438528121,
0.2703529596,
0.346031785,
-0.5388997793,
0.4347965717,
-0.3602373898,
-1.2533887625,
0.5367050171,
0.4129708409,
-0.1169953793,
-0.2888214588,
-0.6264962554,
0.4969666004,
-0.0623763949,
0.7462041378,
-0.3728536665,
-0.3478244841,
0.0898035243,
-0.6746507883,
-0.3587296903,
-0.2421058863,
-0.2515003979,
-0.3262969851,
0.5467602015,
0.4820942879,
0.8796252012,
0.556406796,
0.5597884655,
0.1933090687,
-0.1382495612,
0.2655033171,
-0.0726650879,
-0.1846216619,
-0.1026313752,
-0.3779751658,
-0.4290995598,
0.092260249,
0.4248513877,
0.8467720747,
-0.011940226,
-0.0466930382,
0.3875092864,
0.7465056777,
-0.4861642122,
0.2843678296,
-0.2257663608,
0.2402025461,
-0.2154389918,
-0.072177358,
-0.1485565752,
-0.5321667194,
0.4643296301,
-0.6075063944,
0.0798635185,
0.0880124345,
0.8910522461,
0.2939012647,
-0.2455041707,
-0.7027482986,
-0.5448250175,
0.5865268111,
-0.8130433559,
0.5072256923,
0.7665766478,
0.3071733713,
0.4693930447,
-0.2428581715,
-0.6759250164,
-0.6553532481,
-0.4590189755,
-0.118204996,
-0.1487863958,
0.0316830575,
0.09987133,
0.4733536541,
-0.5914793611,
0.2607638538,
-0.4146278203,
-0.258872211,
0.6363535523,
-0.0478703417,
0.4790357053,
-0.3968930542,
-0.2381260544,
0.0465436019,
-0.4724110067,
0.2190732062,
0.7132602334,
0.3559257388,
-0.191532895,
0.6660069227,
-0.2229082435,
0.6785145998,
-0.1796411872,
-0.1672927886,
0.4699535668,
-0.6848512292,
-0.1424236596,
0.1474255174,
0.9622892737,
0.2517020106,
0.5539845824,
-0.2981076837,
0.0018534076,
-0.2055797428,
-0.1298174709,
-0.4127544761,
-0.0933680981,
-0.0054668076,
-0.5651337504,
-0.1394697577,
-0.2807782292,
-0.874987781,
-0.4758268893,
-0.1769259423,
0.2664076686,
-0.3533768058,
-0.2167561203,
0.0341569446,
0.1760480255,
0.0443576351,
-0.0271016676,
-1.1018680334,
0.1704454869,
0.4850097001,
0.9688623548,
-0.108988069,
-0.5514434576,
-0.4617938697,
0.0139553519,
-0.2699776888,
0.663441956,
-0.7267574668,
-0.2066036016,
-0.2123655677,
0.016372133,
-0.1830692738,
-0.5917806029,
0.3710078299,
-0.2894670665,
-0.0613821931,
-0.0860731527,
-0.256175369,
-0.4797413051,
0.4364202917,
-0.9737139344,
1.1382267475,
0.1929518729,
-0.7546297312,
0.6480661631,
-0.3374557197,
-0.640350461,
-0.1699049622,
0.1372400522,
-0.2374517322,
-0.034472879,
0.2901555896,
0.4006356299,
-0.189752534,
0.0292429551,
-0.3894263506,
-0.4787781537,
0.0227648746,
-0.431528151,
0.4672988653,
-0.040361248,
-0.4100719094,
-0.1401533633,
-0.9066653252,
-0.0747166723,
-0.344016999,
-0.3067621589,
-0.613627851,
-0.2361083776,
0.0416767523,
0.1643427163,
0.4250926375,
-0.5057933331,
0.0940837115,
-0.7804886699,
0.2518099546,
0.1884006709,
-0.3383543491,
0.5271167755,
-0.1691073477,
0.8683479428,
-0.0595992617,
0.0584704354,
-0.0327738039,
-0.5578873754,
-0.6760524511,
-0.2066147178,
0.4789918959,
0.8517548442,
-0.9193302989,
0.3831755221,
-0.0019982762,
-0.8275291324,
-0.8582527041,
0.5775624514,
0.7314550877,
0.4430390894,
0.2427179068,
-0.6114885211,
-0.3738915324,
-0.6145771146,
-0.4547772706,
-0.4096472859,
0.2154099345,
0.484497875,
0.248820588,
-0.2619511187,
0.7084079981,
-0.1780332625,
-0.0947356597,
-0.4620794058,
0.0743211359,
0.3513659537,
0.1885052323,
0.6909199357,
-0.5842468739,
-0.8740155697,
0.4429499507,
-0.7590453029,
-0.2326683253,
0.2938393652,
0.3204171956,
0.2719145715,
0.4325763881,
-0.1360488832,
0.5153787732,
0.7759031057,
-0.2054169625,
0.5353282094,
-0.5323562622,
0.2592292428,
-0.9219067097,
0.1717966646,
-0.1739013642,
-0.1620914489,
-0.3428890407,
0.0255397391,
-0.1445560008,
-0.1799317449,
-0.3102754056,
0.8408565521,
-0.5696326494,
-0.478490144,
-0.278767705,
0.242024824,
0.134593904,
0.3400420547,
0.1756652594,
0.7860853672,
0.4356365204,
-0.5502645373,
0.3901174963,
-0.0559866764,
-0.5276616216,
0.340418905,
-0.7845757604,
-0.1893024147,
0.183594346,
-0.0936436132,
-0.6551320553,
-0.109391734,
0.4529452622,
-0.2213670313,
0.14476569,
-0.1885732263,
-0.6193070412,
0.0085280947,
-0.1104177013,
0.5278385878,
0.2500655353,
-0.669636786,
0.7174129486,
0.3030917346,
-0.3815662861,
-0.919706881,
-0.8984320164,
0.0400703251,
-0.3168432415,
-0.6416685581,
-0.1379271895,
-0.0821933225,
-0.1932526082,
0.0825461894,
0.2363739759,
-0.4130142629,
0.1528476328,
0.0969895944,
-0.0284829568,
-0.3026505411,
0.2806438506,
0.0385259166,
-0.2066072673,
-0.3550625741,
-0.0246050414,
0.4997276366,
-0.4705063701,
-0.1262994558,
-0.2260893583,
0.3158468306,
0.3180924952,
-0.5482538342,
0.7792624235,
0.8040315509,
-0.157994017,
-0.1007290781,
-0.1818351001,
0.4103877544,
-0.420496136,
0.1712642163,
-0.5056059957,
-0.8714954853,
0.8178693652,
0.0576143004,
-0.0557371192,
0.3186200857,
0.4209605157,
-0.2120177299,
0.449845016,
1.0866109133,
-0.0605921,
0.4754389226,
0.019540105,
0.4919888973,
-0.6768140197,
-0.2381590903,
-0.5614326,
-0.2290767729,
-0.878230989,
-0.6249793172,
0.0884092003,
0.5101752877,
0.4879660308,
0.7078778744,
-0.2066547126,
0.7088256478,
0.2766006589,
0.0479080714,
0.7815839052,
-0.0182992388,
-0.4793477058,
-0.0610509776,
-0.6533299088,
-0.6030115485,
0.8700305223,
0.2368015945,
0.70876652,
0.0790885761,
0.773417592,
0.1773326397,
0.0863527358,
-0.8673493862,
0.2623232007,
-0.5556389689,
-0.2170971632,
-0.4765523374,
-0.376843214,
-0.8844684362,
0.1484563947,
-0.0193623137,
-0.711458385,
0.5074088573,
0.112479195,
-0.3400705159,
0.2051894516,
-0.824791491,
0.8298161626,
-0.2384319454,
0.0003035435,
-0.2003754675,
-0.593875289,
0.2545019686,
-0.2619786263,
0.1268627793,
-0.2575565279,
-0.2945086658,
0.593572855,
-0.2924180627,
0.8536356091,
0.3193938434,
-0.198149845,
0.3650299013,
0.068329826,
0.0435048789,
0.1619780362,
-0.3930152953,
0.416954726,
0.0636621416,
-0.4971898794,
-0.668659091,
0.4733991921,
-0.5918169618,
-0.14024885,
-0.4665850103,
-0.6478165388,
-0.3108134866,
0.3510498405,
0.1252843589,
0.2957689166,
-0.4082768261,
-0.1962230057,
0.5019249916,
-0.3658335209,
0.6387421489,
0.6307243705,
-0.1599921882,
-0.3537392616,
0.9873963594,
0.1534685493,
0.3005985022,
0.3953329027,
0.3203991354,
-0.2235891223,
-0.4241377115,
-0.6376073956,
0.2479151487,
-0.5379073024,
0.3379327059,
-0.5118438005,
-0.1125599742,
-0.0929130614,
-0.2051846832,
-0.1638168991,
-0.554926455,
-0.2657495737,
-0.0923484266,
0.2447591424,
0.6866086125,
-0.3497541845,
0.2200752646,
-1.0391334295,
0.3015107512,
0.1513345242,
0.6485589743,
0.0410702676,
-0.431920886,
-0.4460114539,
-0.3043980896,
0.2601974905,
-0.6944231391,
0.3379278779,
0.3423818648,
0.3219810724,
0.203893587,
-0.0561482869,
0.6088205576,
-0.4001134038,
0.3930490315,
0.0420437865,
-1.0182703733,
0.5611752272,
-0.093462877,
0.1941767782,
0.8937401175,
0.59363693,
-0.6680051684,
-0.3107335865,
-0.4138764739,
-0.4526771307,
0.4309540093,
0.0837824792,
-0.1404663026,
0.2868880033,
0.2147419155,
0.4502219558,
0.0484634675,
-0.6893998384,
0.1651071012,
-0.0543300621,
-0.3002747595,
-0.517947495,
-0.1059121266,
0.2524342835,
-0.0304868892,
0.4243772328,
-0.2178089917,
-0.2597958148,
0.0866288319,
-0.2705240548,
0.0574668124,
0.3334326446,
0.1894766092,
0.6449019313,
-0.2109219581,
0.0374200456,
-0.0068379384,
-0.6821448207,
0.1698373556,
0.5412320495,
-0.1784689277,
0.2592533529,
0.8289449811,
0.7551671267,
0.203835234,
-1.0074473619,
0.3026193082,
-0.1827346832,
0.4351918697,
0.1675793082,
0.0433295295,
-0.0139817065,
0.3215185106,
-0.1965390891,
0.2017203569,
0.2127901614,
-0.7882106304,
0.0614920631,
-0.1318235695,
-0.537612319,
-0.2128614485,
0.1533706486,
0.4878673851,
-0.0986080989,
0.418415755,
-0.3660196662,
-0.4338368475,
0.9298357964,
0.0367908776,
0.7688678503,
-0.1477568597,
0.3672201335,
0.2807872295,
0.8543539047,
0.1999436319,
0.2331703305,
-0.2686248422,
-0.6123614311,
-0.3538593352,
-0.7482185364,
-0.5791133642,
-0.4536818862,
-0.5645638704,
0.1677444726,
-0.2477589846,
0.2384786606,
-0.1004518494,
0.6054894328,
-0.5696021318,
0.2988117039,
-0.1725379229,
0.6787004471,
-1.1413673162,
0.8556339145,
0.5064674616,
-0.6222611666,
-0.80876863,
0.2034644037,
-0.3990575671,
-0.8250772357,
0.4530109763,
0.2991912067,
0.002972492,
-0.4847607017,
0.3023722172,
-0.7627741098,
0.9239321351,
0.5263137221,
-0.8424563408,
-0.1257475019,
0.4504478574,
0.9787608981,
-0.0645789132,
0.413202554,
0.6647510529,
0.3994503617,
-0.235687077,
-1.5077453852,
-0.1054996103,
-0.2509638369,
-0.2173650861,
0.308285892,
-0.7697952986,
0.4428839386,
-0.2672920823,
0.0869775116,
0.1755565107,
0.776384294,
0.2341566831,
0.7747287154,
0.6715818048,
0.6427934766,
0.946382463,
0.1367678791,
0.999794364,
-0.1341782063,
0.2272214741,
1.1950296164,
-0.2089689523,
0.8375043869,
0.2866981328,
-0.0653878823,
0.4299921095,
0.7832421064,
0.0052836575,
0.4439206719,
-0.0637764409,
-0.2131303698,
-0.0108158262,
-0.416195482,
-0.3921585679,
0.6630956531,
0.1587771624,
-0.4789485931,
-0.137771666,
0.355719775,
-0.185882777,
0.2342377454,
-0.3012367785,
0.4529199004,
0.2583496869,
-0.5136653781,
0.3536205888,
-0.0874590799,
0.7341218591,
-0.4007698596,
-0.0916651785,
-0.438615948,
0.0811999813,
-0.2577859163,
-1.0857847929,
0.60687989,
0.3285151422,
-0.3464900255,
0.0723273158,
0.6907571554,
-0.6840076447,
-0.5850185156,
0.793317914,
0.5195732117,
0.3559125364,
0.4042521417,
-0.7263587117,
-0.0153150111,
-0.1231343523,
0.2065141946,
0.1550965756,
0.5252197385,
-0.1090808064,
0.7167277932,
0.3357602954,
0.2780498862,
0.1716675162,
0.1358624846,
0.5546433926,
-0.5397360325,
-0.717648685,
-0.4954910576,
-0.0502570793,
0.1931474954,
-0.7032142878,
0.6439049244,
0.3779655695,
0.9075447917,
0.2279859632,
0.6835821271,
-0.1811064482,
0.5542775989,
-0.6162012219,
0.7968531251,
-0.6172963381,
0.3150680959,
-0.4397337139,
-1.005543828,
-0.0651461929,
0.3251343071,
-0.2844844162,
0.1250236183,
0.661768198,
0.5186274648,
-0.2456957698,
-0.0667290241,
0.337102443,
0.1388160586,
0.0210657772,
0.7486527562,
0.7078900933,
-0.4377301931,
0.7792249322,
-0.6717187762,
-0.2743518949,
-0.2014268935,
-0.8657795191,
-1.2088122368,
-0.5153196454,
-0.1926418692,
-0.3231210113,
0.1740401238,
0.2932384908,
0.4191870987,
-0.5578929782,
-0.2218309492,
0.2156781107,
0.271749258,
-0.2265357226,
-0.1981378943,
0.5596061945,
0.018033538,
-0.7208859324,
0.3325969577,
0.4207682908,
-0.2019204199,
-0.404412359,
-0.1229649261,
-0.233224079,
0.0556357726,
0.4133745134,
0.7042329907,
-0.5824358463,
-0.052303616,
-0.1589375436,
-0.309088558,
0.1311786473,
0.6190235615,
-0.9737573862,
0.8172553778,
0.8562851548,
0.7954474092,
0.3169875145,
-0.2985374629,
0.5311582088,
-0.4882947803,
0.3465933502,
0.304017663,
0.4109699428,
0.3947055638,
-0.3895002306,
0.9158284068,
0.1051698476,
-0.3016061485,
-0.6127958298,
0.1118687019,
-1.1398210526,
0.0879893973,
0.6230641603,
-0.6083467007,
-0.2348168492,
-0.1895021051,
-0.0578989387,
0.3897844553,
0.0064233593,
0.7469678521,
0.9742413163,
-0.1614124924,
-0.3444249928,
-0.3803838193,
0.2942400873,
0.6274689436,
-1.077711463,
-0.1932128668,
-0.0150611717,
0.2637212574,
0.2997828424,
0.434081912,
0.003760183,
0.5339594483,
-0.0451263972,
-0.0754974484,
0.0005061082,
-0.425049603,
-0.4969620705,
-0.1608236581,
-0.0594762862,
0.2045686543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13477v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13477v2 | Look-back Decoding for Open-Ended Text Generation | 2023-05-22T20:42:37 | 2023-10-23T00:58:02 | Nan Xu, Chunting Zhou, Asli Celikyilmaz, Xuezhe Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given a prefix (context), open-ended generation aims to decode texts that are
coherent, which do not abruptly drift from previous topics, and informative,
which do not suffer from undesired repetitions. In this paper, we propose
Look-back, an improved decoding algorithm that leverages the Kullback-Leibler
divergence to track the distribution distance between current and historical
decoding steps. Thus Look-back can automatically predict potential repetitive
phrase and topic drift, and remove tokens that may cause the failure modes,
restricting the next token probability distribution within a plausible distance
to the history. We perform decoding experiments on document continuation and
story generation, and demonstrate that Look-back is able to generate more
fluent and coherent text, outperforming other strong decoding methods
significantly in both automatic and human evaluations. | [
-0.3486391902,
-0.5363336205,
0.5366156101,
0.1843895018,
-0.52772367,
0.0396971665,
-0.2684412003,
-0.0903689042,
0.1937015504,
0.5554147363,
-0.923437655,
-0.6642394066,
-0.4598491788,
0.1967918724,
-0.5522421598,
1.0390250683,
-0.3141728938,
-0.2757099569,
-0.0933536291,
-0.204880923,
-0.500315547,
-0.2160557657,
-0.5828322768,
-0.3001098931,
0.4067284465,
0.2201545984,
0.5359013677,
0.5487031937,
0.2505817413,
0.0772137493,
-0.3079615235,
0.2952809036,
-0.8493977785,
0.5596837997,
-0.2665827572,
-0.3412303627,
-0.1928435415,
-0.2932180166,
0.8655600548,
0.7248129845,
0.0078667756,
-0.0549315996,
0.1751483828,
0.8133966923,
-0.9804516435,
-0.024572771,
-0.1797783077,
0.1916927546,
-0.2167272866,
-0.9238117933,
-0.7947206497,
-0.4441989362,
-0.1038250327,
-0.6024918556,
0.5151718259,
-0.1796336323,
0.7050648928,
0.1223289892,
-0.0809383392,
-0.5612431765,
-0.7632769942,
0.8037086129,
-0.7009174228,
0.7918820977,
0.131874457,
-0.082607232,
-0.4084384143,
-0.8196674585,
-0.6398845911,
0.0001613791,
0.0811751112,
0.4891801775,
-0.2216896564,
-0.5275161862,
-0.0145311905,
0.4029956162,
-0.56261307,
-0.1467139423,
-0.22285074,
-0.056156043,
0.2849460542,
0.3714302778,
0.0015950724,
0.029152343,
-0.1193326414,
-0.4600926936,
-0.7317605019,
-0.1568797231,
0.4906000793,
0.2156386226,
0.0082240226,
0.5520469546,
-0.5479176044,
0.3753730059,
0.131467998,
0.0055333278,
0.3473044932,
-0.4135540724,
0.0602029264,
0.2327821255,
0.4240755737,
0.6962310672,
0.0644688457,
-0.1487757713,
-0.0041294857,
-0.3651486635,
0.2376808822,
-0.8323739767,
-0.0863009766,
0.1167028174,
-0.9219670296,
-0.3739340901,
0.2307157516,
-0.9237971306,
-0.037667729,
-0.0252567381,
0.0472314022,
-0.7247412801,
-0.2550621927,
0.1827081591,
-0.4919557869,
0.4370854795,
0.2290212065,
-0.6123371124,
0.1562073827,
0.7577539086,
1.3413575888,
-0.161592409,
-0.3760251701,
-0.7333442569,
0.1912138015,
-0.5557495356,
0.6899579763,
-0.3371012807,
-0.6450610757,
0.0656152219,
-0.0545073748,
0.290725112,
-0.2751587331,
0.3677037656,
-0.596462667,
0.6410884261,
0.0781432465,
-0.3599073589,
-0.0388479903,
-0.003778728,
-0.6484453082,
0.9275501966,
0.236910671,
-1.0794793367,
0.761467278,
-0.4007664323,
-0.6281380057,
0.1481853127,
-0.0744158328,
-0.7084853649,
0.5179221034,
0.2506349385,
0.1118818745,
0.0277472436,
-0.0569309033,
-0.1623636186,
-0.4148396254,
-0.1131841317,
-0.4660632908,
0.7049819827,
0.1744591296,
-0.3962861001,
-0.1292740107,
-0.8215863109,
0.104136005,
0.276831001,
-0.4781746864,
-0.7663967609,
0.309586376,
-0.1469078809,
-0.3194063902,
-0.0171094611,
-0.5350263715,
0.165169239,
-0.6362639666,
0.1568178535,
0.5812588334,
0.2871558666,
0.3762978315,
-0.23736839,
0.5461167693,
0.3757764101,
-0.3333880305,
-0.9451985359,
-0.495012641,
-0.6699970365,
0.0268557351,
0.2868091464,
0.3057707548,
-0.6189085245,
0.4668865204,
-0.27794227,
-0.0560472533,
-0.3559759557,
-0.3692209125,
0.2882447839,
0.5941695571,
0.3821047544,
-0.4898828864,
-0.5135179758,
-0.5336152911,
-0.2839487493,
-0.0818986818,
-0.1414801627,
0.250851661,
0.3117648065,
-0.23562406,
1.2274101973,
-0.8785177469,
0.1018973142,
-0.0837682411,
0.3011085093,
0.0199020077,
0.4049801826,
0.1183580458,
-0.8039486408,
-0.3149016798,
0.2002590597,
-0.6898264885,
-0.0569599122,
-0.2496269941,
-0.2808308005,
0.6603425145,
0.6660556197,
-0.5197697878,
0.6239637733,
0.2106517553,
-0.5239169598,
0.5139122009,
-0.2649845183,
0.0089714667,
-1.3030040264,
0.317037642,
-0.5440322757,
-0.0049918648,
-0.3544286489,
0.0864765421,
0.0835484266,
-0.1039753035,
-0.2164783329,
0.6562128663,
-0.6191702485,
-0.1483191997,
-0.1498012096,
0.0790942386,
-0.0120984074,
-0.0365112089,
0.3740467727,
0.6791502237,
0.2399321645,
-0.5223292112,
0.083301276,
0.2929547727,
-0.2435122281,
0.7824146152,
-0.1139243916,
0.2321364433,
-0.6136238575,
0.3923861086,
-0.6734675765,
-0.312294364,
0.0970943198,
-0.6648842096,
0.3601631224,
0.1315381229,
-0.0881342739,
-0.25443995,
-0.5657315254,
0.3750464916,
0.7519625425,
-0.9353821874,
0.3504659534,
-0.3489446938,
-0.2117382884,
-0.7553907037,
-0.6062170863,
0.1968026012,
-0.0831106454,
-0.6074430346,
0.1557312608,
-0.1163312644,
-0.1634728909,
0.1171575487,
-0.0581575818,
0.0987129807,
-0.0989555717,
0.0173902232,
-0.0779061764,
-0.403595984,
0.0708622038,
0.2911452353,
-0.2319015115,
-0.167033717,
-0.6970773339,
0.7703347206,
0.1950480193,
-0.0243975315,
0.0332549699,
0.7538071871,
0.4325667024,
-0.3376945257,
0.8447075486,
0.5295769572,
-0.2390488535,
-0.7236963511,
-0.0901863426,
-0.0768991709,
-0.4691554904,
0.346180737,
-0.3291106224,
-0.6523594856,
0.3709841371,
0.0366385505,
0.0986492559,
0.299616009,
0.8418257833,
-0.1402899027,
0.6640963554,
0.8268321753,
0.39795205,
0.24567388,
-0.0517841093,
0.2856399715,
-0.558591783,
-0.507984519,
-0.2148127705,
-0.0221955292,
-0.2996440828,
-0.0676715374,
-0.0087524895,
0.5876569748,
0.214682579,
0.2770493031,
-0.5486510396,
0.4596175253,
0.7185482979,
0.1545273066,
0.4470505416,
0.1364004761,
-0.0824892148,
0.1862477511,
-0.5296187997,
-0.2918036282,
1.0511564016,
0.2305583656,
0.8732408285,
-0.0088608097,
1.4016108513,
0.270611912,
0.333856374,
-0.7393110394,
0.4476023316,
-0.0337561592,
0.053607095,
-0.3196216822,
-0.5372570157,
-1.075778842,
-0.1361731887,
0.2628662884,
-0.4226319492,
0.2202227712,
0.2155879885,
-0.0408691652,
0.2541621327,
-0.2268433273,
0.6903492808,
0.4552286267,
-0.0271643307,
0.1310587376,
-0.3567168117,
0.4033494592,
-0.2896437049,
-0.0627709702,
0.4361430109,
-0.1127090901,
0.5961201191,
-0.5420399904,
0.405793488,
0.0762121081,
-0.3917853236,
0.4533815682,
0.1058728695,
0.4533678889,
0.0713844374,
0.174063161,
0.0327106863,
-0.2079784274,
-0.2432295829,
-0.3913435042,
0.7567007542,
-0.2165267169,
-0.138091892,
-0.1612532437,
-0.5247392654,
0.1839925647,
0.6407851577,
0.908172965,
0.6126568317,
-0.4004517794,
0.2864932716,
0.6158647537,
-0.2262027562,
0.8291971087,
0.4204402566,
-0.0792616233,
-0.5312362909,
0.8874726295,
-0.0762895718,
0.147312969,
0.4524772167,
0.199131757,
-0.4111146331,
-0.6897210479,
-0.3667797148,
0.0726954862,
-0.7510392666,
-0.2423950732,
-0.6795412302,
-0.0890586004,
-0.3834958076,
-0.5457884073,
-0.2851982415,
-0.2373696268,
-0.2697484493,
0.1002470553,
0.1621611565,
0.5490093827,
-0.1725328416,
0.3026452065,
-0.7293462753,
0.1734952927,
-0.2253167629,
0.6919517517,
0.0903173536,
-0.2087324411,
-0.3502318263,
-0.2090567648,
-0.2905055285,
-0.9047698379,
0.5114507675,
0.1764535755,
0.1023982838,
0.2903826535,
0.251937896,
0.3395991623,
-0.7070176601,
0.6430714726,
0.2337750494,
-0.7746028304,
0.5859665871,
-0.3797515631,
0.8738405704,
0.2845534384,
0.2996042073,
-0.689152956,
-0.5310867429,
-0.5143480301,
-0.8475147486,
0.7758381367,
0.5445261598,
0.0084775006,
-0.5331274867,
0.3242727518,
0.4522199035,
0.081393145,
-0.4989084899,
-0.0719336495,
-0.4922801256,
-0.3162149191,
-0.141404748,
-0.1421377063,
0.1961761266,
0.5559474826,
0.4702227712,
-0.2406253666,
0.338467896,
0.3429583907,
-0.023545336,
-0.4097288847,
0.4704113007,
0.7240698338,
0.7146318555,
-0.4767175615,
-0.0120165441,
0.0222199969,
-0.9544392824,
-0.0194729399,
0.0633788109,
-0.6961777806,
0.4347299337,
0.6434593797,
0.6575232148,
-0.0770929903,
-0.7964299321,
0.4535102248,
-0.0499215573,
-0.2121097744,
-0.3653517365,
-0.1698009074,
-0.1154280975,
0.2730360925,
0.5131682158,
-0.2716214061,
0.0885215476,
-0.7577533126,
0.5682625771,
0.2820815146,
-0.1031150371,
-0.1491487175,
0.6017276049,
0.0585528575,
-0.7343049049,
0.7148301005,
-0.1265433133,
-0.3492878079,
0.6020181775,
0.7410251498,
1.3448592424,
-0.2720405757,
0.1619174033,
0.3443934619,
0.0387502387,
-0.2344424129,
0.4598461986,
-0.1805986464,
-0.3722377419,
-0.3695669472,
-0.7898956537,
-0.3881790042,
0.0928685516,
-1.0793825388,
0.1574087888,
-0.2117292434,
0.0402986594,
-0.1519327462,
-0.5238867402,
-0.3036458492,
0.2381220609,
0.0739824697,
0.9422505498,
-0.1483716518,
0.4905622303,
0.2813161612,
-0.1721093506,
0.0396258123,
0.5547164083,
-0.1314367652,
-0.384414494,
0.7903128862,
0.5458392501,
-0.4295737147,
0.2191341519,
-0.3936063945,
-0.8423447013,
1.2954058647,
-0.2563432753,
-0.6029167175,
-0.4195290506,
-0.1885183305,
0.3635388613,
-0.4031552672,
0.028463304,
0.6174762249,
0.0232849438,
0.0776681975,
-0.6819432974,
0.11340826,
0.0873660594,
-0.0839488059,
0.9066305757,
-0.3787800074,
0.8444792628,
-0.3705199063,
-0.6657252908,
0.4165742695,
0.7554536462,
0.1058129668,
0.8252601624,
0.1934987456,
0.7265568376,
0.2189524323,
0.0244318563,
0.9539241195,
-0.1769235134,
0.5278691649,
1.1604840755,
-0.0927957445,
1.0252034664,
0.298140049,
0.0829820782,
0.5027430058,
0.2353568524,
0.0801341385,
0.9658755064,
-0.1121636704,
-0.3169055879,
0.1901887357,
0.2248400748,
-0.4924726188,
0.2866033316,
0.1093003079,
-0.6065038443,
-0.5975174904,
0.0371264666,
0.1734482348,
-0.0407151617,
-0.4510026574,
0.6181496978,
0.0797455236,
-0.908393383,
0.673332274,
0.1071133986,
0.4371725917,
-0.4909354448,
-0.1498986483,
-0.6235251427,
0.4613722563,
-0.066331245,
-1.0127187967,
0.4086723924,
-0.151305303,
-0.4093454182,
-0.0393418372,
0.6465998292,
-0.4841883779,
-0.1011435315,
0.2955512702,
0.3186652064,
0.0268520284,
0.1684571207,
-0.1560215354,
0.1965735108,
0.0678825751,
-0.5097369552,
0.0774336979,
0.2802833617,
-0.0192968789,
0.4465444684,
0.622018218,
-0.2296254933,
0.1367547512,
0.0108623793,
0.828263998,
-0.9721918106,
-1.0667319298,
-0.8635966778,
0.358681947,
-0.1173372045,
-0.5882374644,
0.6465054154,
0.6432276368,
1.0615622997,
-0.0445253849,
0.75804919,
0.0630329549,
0.6573871374,
-0.7830542326,
0.5947085619,
-0.4850409627,
-0.0577380806,
-0.2758087516,
-1.1669665575,
-0.188014403,
0.4087384343,
0.0752140433,
-0.0238333065,
0.86603719,
0.416012615,
-0.0418833159,
0.0662096068,
0.178368032,
-0.0061316341,
0.2692561746,
0.493136555,
0.7817873359,
-0.2113534063,
0.7103975415,
-0.157472834,
-0.3102020919,
-0.2145587057,
-0.9273535013,
-0.9156923294,
-0.4838337302,
-0.0517831184,
-0.634118557,
0.3753437698,
0.1696913093,
0.3572309017,
-0.6574329138,
0.0362368375,
-0.4338577688,
-0.3186496496,
-0.3036053479,
-0.2853572965,
0.4937480688,
-0.4345876575,
-0.6655910611,
0.5214895606,
0.5749185085,
0.0626165047,
-0.3880660236,
-0.3770715296,
0.1204950735,
0.3937888741,
0.7706388831,
0.50687325,
-0.5983054638,
-0.2479149848,
-0.107166037,
0.1292888969,
0.0932154953,
1.1218229532,
-0.891097188,
0.6432461739,
0.5526519418,
0.4827008247,
0.6112035513,
0.3017882407,
0.7958767414,
-0.7542555928,
0.1696675271,
0.3426858187,
0.1482040137,
0.0915824175,
-0.4014834166,
0.4646804333,
0.31010741,
-0.2294176817,
-0.9798532128,
0.4042946994,
-0.8272870779,
-0.5174357295,
0.8464202881,
-0.226647526,
-0.1881481707,
-0.0400001667,
-0.0909684673,
0.1083660424,
-0.4123186767,
0.449457556,
0.6118015647,
-0.0658137426,
-0.5757042766,
-0.1638319939,
0.5160326362,
0.3548985124,
-0.7366836667,
0.3243668079,
0.6762573719,
0.1283389181,
0.2988129556,
0.6930555105,
-0.1099196076,
0.4680586457,
0.5109805465,
-0.2368976027,
-0.2052539736,
-0.6099568605,
-0.4644567668,
0.3557372391,
-0.3988505602,
-0.2173044533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13469v2 | MAILEX: Email Event and Argument Extraction | 2023-05-22T20:28:23 | 2023-10-21T02:15:22 | Saurabh Srivastava, Gaurav Singh, Shou Matsumoto, Ali Raz, Paulo Costa, Joshua Poore, Ziyu Yao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we present the first dataset, MailEx, for performing event
extraction from conversational email threads. To this end, we first proposed a
new taxonomy covering 10 event types and 76 arguments in the email domain. Our
final dataset includes 1.5K email threads and ~4K emails, which are annotated
with totally ~8K event instances. To understand the task challenges, we
conducted a series of experiments comparing three types of approaches, i.e.,
fine-tuned sequence labeling, fine-tuned generative extraction, and few-shot
in-context learning. Our results showed that the task of email event extraction
is far from being addressed, due to challenges lying in, e.g., extracting
non-continuous, shared trigger spans, extracting non-named entity arguments,
and modeling the email conversational history. Our work thus suggests more
future investigations in this domain-specific event extraction task. | [
-0.4749299586,
-0.7978749275,
0.322865665,
-0.2107805908,
-0.3000596762,
-0.1013081521,
-0.0320740752,
-0.4285293519,
0.1378996819,
0.4013799727,
-0.964476645,
-0.3475666642,
-0.7739188075,
0.2666667402,
-0.4557073712,
1.2688404322,
-0.1053706706,
-0.5765072107,
-0.3514386117,
-0.1751422733,
-0.0710597411,
-0.5330697298,
-0.6482168436,
0.057259433,
0.6379367113,
0.8668267727,
-0.2931714356,
0.341361165,
0.6405883431,
0.1411545575,
0.0409403928,
0.0786021873,
-0.3222873509,
0.1812201738,
0.0800652131,
-0.2089173794,
-0.3787582815,
0.3150182366,
0.5278992653,
0.6304060221,
-0.2138555795,
0.5195428729,
-0.1534599811,
0.5009418726,
-0.7883165479,
0.2055257857,
-0.5362862945,
-0.0334903598,
-0.65940696,
-0.343545258,
-0.3739161193,
-0.119047828,
0.4129832387,
-0.3511456251,
0.1670905799,
0.2070995867,
0.7104536891,
-0.2676944733,
-0.5177817941,
-0.3724341691,
-0.4504660666,
0.6096208692,
-0.5799904466,
0.0845735669,
0.2542133331,
0.3836823404,
-0.0973543301,
-1.0178581476,
-0.4475620091,
0.6186629534,
-0.0251116119,
0.1972018182,
-0.3786000907,
-0.0735581741,
0.6111599803,
0.2634036243,
-0.6067970991,
0.1087336913,
-0.2015185952,
0.1451493353,
0.5285671949,
0.4361869395,
0.1688068509,
0.0183886848,
-0.0924158394,
-0.0413317233,
-0.5026788712,
0.2435153127,
0.4872737527,
0.0089819571,
-0.11537797,
0.4267433584,
-0.1445150822,
0.2365515381,
-0.0200023409,
0.2516414523,
-0.2894632518,
-0.1564706415,
-0.4689971805,
-0.2086459249,
0.8943301439,
-0.0410547666,
0.0636257306,
-0.3442939222,
0.2166191787,
-0.0440813527,
0.2303161174,
-1.1366431713,
-0.2287328094,
0.5490799546,
-0.7219897509,
-0.3290031254,
0.2715179324,
-1.2137912512,
-0.2223571539,
-0.1779313684,
0.0002695482,
-0.1616475433,
-0.3820163906,
0.077274479,
-0.335092485,
0.0827188343,
0.5229738355,
-0.8970959187,
0.549505949,
1.0043652058,
0.34908548,
-0.5306733251,
-0.0575200841,
-0.7145795822,
-0.1370443851,
-0.1108934581,
1.204282999,
-1.2172119617,
-0.0287291761,
0.1996365488,
0.322306633,
-0.2623867095,
-0.6962205768,
0.369045347,
-0.6876115799,
0.6809716821,
-0.1828018874,
-0.9389619827,
-0.2551752627,
0.1507559717,
-0.4747475684,
0.7715886831,
0.1707629114,
-0.6420333385,
0.6019750237,
-1.0419282913,
-0.3455823958,
0.3621858358,
-0.0831667781,
-0.4243227541,
0.2153488249,
0.0337162502,
0.6342994571,
-0.4330830872,
-0.1840221286,
-0.403308332,
0.0867948979,
0.1761341393,
-0.1180272102,
0.5761607289,
0.0552759133,
-0.4846094549,
-0.2497754842,
-0.8881134987,
-0.1835705936,
0.0081810756,
-0.0925721228,
0.0385026895,
0.1028999984,
-0.0694340095,
0.2824199796,
-0.0380608179,
-0.6463911533,
0.5144039989,
-0.3828528821,
0.1531286985,
0.7863675356,
0.4472278655,
0.2802191079,
-0.0396306626,
0.7909556627,
0.5624043345,
0.1420797259,
-0.5413817763,
-0.5629310012,
-0.5748348832,
-0.1287349612,
0.0239744354,
0.4798256457,
-0.5749709606,
0.0080667222,
-0.2541685402,
-0.2216913998,
0.0017054686,
0.0606025904,
0.2641310096,
0.2100427002,
-0.075843893,
-0.2017123401,
-0.6932925582,
-0.7185465693,
-0.4026114345,
-0.3496025503,
0.1150954217,
0.4473505318,
0.7268950343,
0.0994196087,
0.858792007,
-0.5455130935,
0.0024255081,
-0.0801178366,
0.7177171111,
0.4531649053,
0.1953288913,
0.4023052752,
-0.4150041342,
-0.5930259824,
0.1535031945,
-0.6622883677,
-0.0669934303,
-0.1918632239,
-0.1116365045,
0.3622196317,
0.2202933729,
-0.5269239545,
0.5860313177,
0.2242416441,
-0.3509389162,
0.5290371776,
0.464033246,
0.2051448524,
-0.9114655256,
-0.0237129815,
0.1752679795,
-0.1727049351,
-0.7463160753,
-0.4312736094,
-0.1079303473,
-0.0707175285,
-0.5256271958,
0.6098601818,
-0.5037558079,
0.0999074876,
-0.544285953,
-0.1861166507,
-0.1479673386,
0.607378304,
0.1730458289,
0.537235558,
0.5393767953,
-0.4324353635,
0.515922904,
0.5401086807,
-0.4148105681,
0.7812847495,
-0.29513219,
0.6553944945,
-0.0428593084,
0.1656607687,
-0.7830840349,
-0.2868836522,
0.5207217932,
-0.3135271668,
0.146663934,
-0.4187880158,
-0.5912177563,
-0.3438838422,
-0.0410935618,
0.1703165472,
0.5330885649,
-0.5961892009,
0.3957528174,
0.455593437,
-0.338973552,
-0.0410557128,
-0.1430865824,
0.2912562788,
-0.5039855242,
-0.4447472692,
-0.0376593396,
-0.1756422818,
-0.2174192071,
-0.3559645712,
-0.1956219673,
-0.2250363529,
0.0706206411,
0.3654546142,
0.0410877392,
-0.3829633892,
-0.1581163555,
-0.1002091542,
-0.0452173427,
0.3307338357,
-0.1820718497,
0.1598523706,
0.1540831625,
-0.3664381504,
-0.6439946294,
1.1278918982,
0.3764886558,
0.06680049,
0.8419991136,
0.4041230381,
-0.6548841596,
-0.209564209,
-0.6909882426,
-0.7312428951,
-0.4029841125,
0.0296983607,
-0.4797205031,
-0.8207333684,
0.5705561638,
-0.4222967923,
0.5216305256,
0.3035249114,
0.2463960797,
-0.3291855156,
1.1452995539,
0.4722197354,
0.0271842536,
0.5121087432,
-0.075074017,
0.1610825509,
-0.7933632731,
-0.2616975605,
-0.6411594152,
-0.3950445056,
0.0746403784,
0.0454473831,
-0.0271177627,
-0.0117731802,
-0.0684656054,
0.5366197824,
-0.1457071006,
0.1386638731,
0.4487255216,
-0.3080637157,
-0.2046720237,
0.0562425852,
0.1591582596,
-0.1628726572,
-0.677647531,
-0.6600370407,
0.9827997684,
0.0346195064,
0.1947268248,
0.2909531593,
0.5400338173,
0.2184056491,
0.4058049023,
-0.3763234019,
0.415876925,
-0.1933084726,
-0.5432000756,
0.1687887609,
-0.2711581588,
-1.1161396503,
-0.0233623646,
-0.0132799223,
-1.4244889021,
0.3673503697,
-0.1836554259,
-0.2270566672,
0.3396508396,
-0.6460821629,
1.1066895723,
0.394864887,
-0.1821290255,
0.3667083979,
-0.6457242966,
0.1715119779,
-0.0273927841,
0.2005372494,
-0.1715510935,
0.2642044425,
1.1276688576,
-0.2447330207,
0.9122463465,
-0.0305317882,
-0.0154103544,
0.2082667202,
0.1121920422,
0.8943636417,
0.0019854098,
0.1042353883,
-0.1000420228,
0.358851105,
-0.249861449,
-0.564625442,
0.1475226581,
-0.2933188975,
-0.6202448606,
-0.2267157137,
-0.1624314934,
-0.1995940506,
-0.1815636158,
0.0988057852,
0.6976930499,
-0.0827271268,
0.3152936697,
0.4581898153,
0.0220731813,
0.9011449218,
0.8112829924,
0.3665158451,
-0.4135922492,
0.7917641401,
-0.1593253613,
-0.0221860744,
0.2704417408,
0.1173197776,
-0.1348911375,
-0.445458889,
-0.3452281654,
-0.0444843322,
-0.7665283084,
-0.204078123,
-1.1478987932,
0.0434638113,
-0.6538342237,
0.0936528593,
-0.3010476828,
-0.3939338326,
-0.9462337494,
0.0489562787,
0.0567625761,
0.5872847438,
0.3026178181,
0.50611341,
-1.0904917717,
-0.0335684307,
0.0108722094,
0.1140554622,
-0.3329975605,
-0.4066525102,
-0.310010165,
-0.2821858823,
-0.47437343,
-1.0169043541,
0.4567410946,
0.6221434474,
0.6591017842,
0.685847044,
0.175845623,
0.7777984738,
-0.4055253863,
1.1958419085,
-0.0595315024,
-0.6916852593,
0.8686894774,
-0.2105903774,
0.1317437142,
0.2861333787,
0.3362908959,
-0.7489548922,
-0.3472106457,
-1.2772444487,
-0.4322528839,
0.9845947623,
0.3604725301,
-0.0740708709,
-0.4377973974,
0.6185259223,
0.7272684574,
0.1710164398,
-0.2752736807,
-0.4127669036,
0.4983810484,
-0.0395874865,
0.0321707837,
-0.5191224217,
-0.4330025613,
0.0178608056,
0.4058048725,
-0.2290374637,
0.4316661358,
-0.1542478949,
-0.2215626538,
-0.201730296,
0.2525302768,
0.7833659053,
0.6774305105,
-0.0486172177,
0.1275412738,
0.1205744967,
-0.4120328426,
-0.1283753514,
0.0119885923,
0.4624113142,
0.0129948063,
0.5466686487,
0.9264582396,
-0.0106659429,
-0.4277865291,
0.645241797,
-0.2771229148,
-0.5150104165,
-0.266209811,
-0.085739024,
-0.3344688714,
0.3686569333,
0.3010416925,
-0.3008095026,
0.1226018444,
-0.4556879103,
0.5452008843,
0.5054898262,
-0.4750548899,
-0.7597974539,
0.7299165726,
0.2248767763,
-0.232657209,
0.5324032307,
-0.114778243,
-0.5057218075,
0.6956223249,
0.5857746601,
1.0059924126,
0.2182094902,
0.3202871382,
0.3040407598,
-0.0070805941,
0.1205358207,
0.1649402529,
-0.2372769266,
-0.6012004018,
-0.1490089893,
-0.284964174,
-0.6695259809,
0.1544168442,
-0.6645971537,
0.2348080575,
0.002924243,
0.0992411748,
0.3275380433,
0.3544568121,
-0.6689354181,
-0.0317050554,
0.1635829806,
0.9697088003,
-0.9780356884,
0.7324124575,
0.8979333043,
-0.0832360983,
-0.3822994232,
-0.432533443,
0.3378144503,
-0.2724893689,
0.8876858354,
0.1872207522,
0.4614871144,
-0.0529167019,
-0.5029329658,
-0.344266057,
0.8734721541,
0.1422436386,
-0.4099292159,
0.3237369359,
0.322384119,
0.1769723445,
-0.6906527281,
0.6064177155,
0.6169615984,
0.4173182845,
0.3425627053,
-0.4069417417,
-0.0226600319,
-0.5919374824,
-0.3577149808,
0.2597481608,
-0.3158362806,
0.5430704951,
0.4463476539,
-0.6116890311,
-0.0429373644,
0.7172613144,
-0.1691444218,
0.4640644491,
0.3153951466,
0.5476961136,
0.5544574857,
-0.1445401758,
1.0549439192,
0.0852049738,
0.3877542317,
0.817569077,
-0.472579807,
0.5885390639,
0.6253893375,
-0.2037880719,
0.4086870849,
1.0012655258,
0.3483507931,
0.4063239396,
-0.1893795282,
-0.6270201802,
-0.2900738418,
0.1303529739,
-0.2324860245,
0.3105158508,
0.4920063615,
-0.1444222033,
-0.2636592686,
0.0891534612,
0.1191390604,
-0.6382119656,
0.1142652109,
1.3673034906,
-0.0643044934,
-0.8447548151,
0.1021593735,
-0.4021230042,
0.3481626809,
-0.1550635695,
-0.2067592144,
-0.3804254532,
0.0407363512,
-0.0357406288,
-0.6885231137,
0.3651849627,
0.0987216234,
0.0367452838,
-0.3145785034,
0.8159742951,
-0.2515212297,
-0.1013968736,
-0.286458075,
0.3705264926,
0.495287925,
-0.3505085111,
-0.4687925577,
0.0668130592,
-0.2072742134,
-0.6828607321,
0.3894236088,
0.6839450598,
0.1954495609,
0.3093701601,
0.6631962657,
0.0794735998,
0.2240720838,
0.0041929046,
0.6396561861,
-0.5310222507,
-0.0354743935,
-1.0009328127,
0.7305051684,
-0.5299985409,
-0.4612897336,
0.3553211093,
0.622448504,
0.2974334955,
-0.1239075437,
0.6798378825,
-0.0822948888,
0.4576710463,
-0.2479429543,
0.1461308002,
-0.5351322889,
0.1246606037,
-0.3255001009,
-0.8574915528,
-0.2684115767,
0.140526101,
-0.0102580041,
-0.2495869994,
1.0735988617,
0.4281054139,
-0.0591278821,
0.7597720027,
0.2770681679,
-0.148061499,
0.7885805964,
0.7143202424,
0.7986530662,
-0.6885726452,
0.3989380002,
-0.3299675882,
-0.3060841262,
-0.3489971757,
-1.1357955933,
-1.057404995,
-0.946316421,
-0.9099093676,
-0.0946161672,
0.0712355301,
0.839456439,
0.8920853138,
-1.112082243,
0.0148380613,
-0.132874459,
-0.0530050062,
-0.2774553895,
-0.2314483076,
0.1124975979,
-0.5637568235,
-0.8293229342,
0.2577683032,
0.439094156,
-0.0427457504,
0.5450382233,
0.4528315961,
-0.1718994081,
0.1393778771,
0.6815238595,
0.6233346462,
-0.2632063925,
-0.8713817596,
-0.0347457193,
0.0422135331,
0.2262406796,
0.8850072622,
-0.4449939728,
0.0929576829,
0.4626900554,
0.717033565,
0.6566454172,
-0.061026141,
0.5684404969,
-0.8644652963,
0.0389387943,
-0.0024650805,
0.2299562395,
-0.2352655828,
-0.3674121797,
0.4869408309,
0.3923645318,
-0.6436185241,
-0.88468045,
0.0451409295,
-1.2127375603,
0.0334460028,
1.2551043034,
-0.3157028854,
-0.2299753428,
-0.2516492307,
-0.1050103232,
-0.0053774421,
-0.075388819,
0.7160549164,
1.0800132751,
-0.3228208721,
-0.9479689002,
-0.6443089843,
0.5446372628,
0.2053779364,
-1.383969903,
0.1247925609,
0.404655695,
0.16339688,
-0.2128461748,
0.4951631427,
-0.0440342948,
0.3068047166,
-0.151997596,
-0.0770075396,
0.2296935916,
-0.3390064836,
-0.0935600251,
0.5028824806,
-0.5245854855,
-0.4370582402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13455v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13455v3 | Clembench: Using Game Play to Evaluate Chat-Optimized Language Models as Conversational Agents | 2023-05-22T19:56:10 | 2023-11-23T15:47:52 | Kranti Chalamalasetti, Jana Götze, Sherzod Hakimov, Brielen Madureira, Philipp Sadler, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has proposed a methodology for the systematic evaluation of
"Situated Language Understanding Agents"-agents that operate in rich linguistic
and non-linguistic contexts-through testing them in carefully constructed
interactive settings. Other recent work has argued that Large Language Models
(LLMs), if suitably set up, can be understood as (simulators of) such agents. A
connection suggests itself, which this paper explores: Can LLMs be evaluated
meaningfully by exposing them to constrained game-like settings that are built
to challenge specific capabilities? As a proof of concept, this paper
investigates five interaction settings, showing that current chat-optimised
LLMs are, to an extent, capable to follow game-play instructions. Both this
capability and the quality of the game play, measured by how well the
objectives of the different games are met, follows the development cycle, with
newer models performing better. The metrics even for the comparatively simple
example games are far from being saturated, suggesting that the proposed
instrument will remain to have diagnostic value. Our general framework for
implementing and evaluating games with LLMs is available at
https://github.com/clembench . | [
-0.562705338,
-0.9356147051,
0.6178815961,
0.2376938462,
-0.1956001073,
0.1032807529,
-0.5951483846,
-0.485802412,
0.0696016252,
0.6719963551,
-0.6674282551,
-0.5405063033,
-0.3269934952,
-0.120228596,
-0.2266333848,
0.5660723448,
0.0461780764,
-0.0197666492,
-0.5496811867,
-0.2867607176,
-0.8358607292,
-0.5230760574,
-0.5994619727,
-0.6311156154,
0.0405717529,
0.4626280963,
0.9963571429,
0.4680655301,
0.5630204678,
0.4215336442,
-0.1560358703,
0.0408642702,
-0.9851768613,
0.444296658,
-0.1693753451,
-0.6956996918,
-0.1018792689,
-0.0107181501,
0.5072299242,
0.6123041511,
-0.1320076585,
0.2431313545,
0.2093287557,
0.2199072093,
-0.3982477188,
0.4341360033,
-0.3768589795,
0.0853436813,
0.3207780719,
-0.1199327707,
-0.619312048,
-0.114677079,
0.2187781781,
-0.5765194893,
-0.110688746,
0.1203293204,
0.7289196253,
0.0462347269,
-0.3092731237,
-0.5684196949,
-0.8918005228,
0.7758745551,
-0.8015562296,
0.151987955,
0.0193432681,
0.4723816514,
-0.4958626628,
-0.3743552268,
-0.2393226027,
-0.7492863536,
-0.1297750324,
0.2005618364,
-0.1950209141,
0.3585774302,
0.5225317478,
0.2379119992,
-0.4766523242,
0.1303820014,
-0.3155035377,
-0.1594019383,
0.7500548959,
0.31686005,
0.3221583664,
0.239348799,
-0.3713991344,
0.1047187075,
-0.4918221235,
0.2239443511,
0.3383684456,
0.1427650005,
-0.1914502382,
0.5366485715,
0.08019007,
0.7037890553,
0.0154840657,
-0.2142426372,
0.0996041894,
-0.0816504434,
0.1130881757,
-0.0909577459,
0.5000320077,
0.5831102729,
0.4020359516,
-0.1432388723,
-0.2295000255,
0.286046356,
0.2204369009,
-0.7799397707,
-0.09982007,
0.4443433881,
-0.339561224,
-0.2368060797,
-0.2956118286,
-0.5689966679,
-0.5135996342,
-0.2634967268,
0.4474018216,
-0.408069104,
-0.2259017676,
0.1297846735,
-0.1808197945,
0.3341734409,
0.2079630941,
-0.5130341649,
0.4462805986,
0.7708544135,
0.8317265511,
-0.2683579624,
-0.2004708648,
-0.379098326,
0.0054522762,
-0.5276480913,
0.5958297849,
-0.5752920508,
-0.9045664668,
0.2644615471,
-0.1197356433,
0.159835428,
-0.6269729733,
0.4344092607,
-0.5074031353,
0.1134896278,
0.0091242166,
-0.8252686262,
0.0929310024,
0.6674947143,
-0.7050370574,
0.7977799773,
-0.0344519913,
-0.2549082339,
0.2412047982,
-0.8809394836,
-0.5147019029,
0.1283768415,
0.1060205176,
-0.0411343947,
0.1886708289,
-0.0643304884,
0.1158915609,
-0.2287006229,
0.1818951219,
-0.6556037068,
-0.6760525703,
0.4640875459,
-0.1884537041,
0.4431075454,
0.3065625429,
-0.3418623805,
0.2312594056,
-0.3069969714,
0.352145344,
0.1078553647,
-0.1725200862,
-0.052916985,
0.3028904498,
-0.3684916794,
0.2298473716,
0.2415823936,
-0.3154322803,
-0.0494641811,
-0.5963670611,
0.5121937394,
0.3416624367,
0.0404696763,
0.6153527498,
-0.2900116742,
0.7939793468,
-0.3428446651,
0.3826200068,
-0.087219812,
-0.2740301192,
-0.7487120032,
-0.41644907,
0.4236373305,
0.5115963817,
-0.7159191966,
0.3283127844,
-0.1964866817,
-0.6477003098,
-0.3081507981,
0.0118940733,
0.3850098252,
0.1060180664,
-0.1985511035,
-0.6361663342,
-0.3782822788,
-0.7378355265,
-0.0554937907,
-0.2732254863,
0.0986065418,
0.8861951828,
0.4820128381,
0.0071512219,
0.9097707868,
-0.2354278266,
0.0294082183,
-0.6300127506,
0.0194402989,
0.0780120939,
0.2541253269,
0.6063528061,
-0.3758650124,
-0.3646698594,
-0.1177051663,
-0.7056607008,
-0.3145781457,
-0.0052900044,
0.0086525204,
-0.1234670356,
0.5836328268,
-0.6112920046,
0.3377934396,
0.867000401,
-0.1717892438,
0.5221372843,
-0.2177971601,
0.1732779741,
-0.5969694257,
0.1217802167,
-0.4562814534,
-0.4992648065,
-0.6891006827,
0.3746906221,
-0.4728107452,
-0.3486611545,
-0.5658041835,
0.7709046602,
-0.6447715759,
-0.4147880673,
-0.529609859,
0.9245433807,
0.0697481409,
0.1921820939,
0.0981626511,
0.8027096391,
0.4320109785,
-0.6628402472,
0.4705385268,
0.2380838841,
-0.6620845795,
0.5443766713,
-0.7884966135,
0.2087976187,
0.1204355359,
0.2754521966,
-0.8886398077,
-0.0864490271,
0.063950561,
-0.3837503791,
-0.080516547,
-0.1153172776,
-0.5087209344,
-0.4308948517,
-0.1488181055,
0.2139305025,
0.6421630979,
-0.3017633259,
0.6047605872,
0.7120454311,
0.098101154,
-0.3037605286,
-0.5274001956,
-0.050454542,
-0.3876339793,
-0.7698405981,
0.005151792,
-0.2838935256,
-0.5508868694,
-0.2264435291,
0.1489893794,
-0.0140979337,
0.4387363195,
0.3669595718,
-0.0680261925,
-0.311974436,
0.1863535196,
-0.3146626651,
0.0320159942,
0.0902040973,
0.1496727467,
0.7761501074,
-0.2663984597,
-0.5240262151,
-0.1270435899,
0.1628389657,
0.2759802043,
-0.2921925783,
0.6211622357,
0.2648706138,
-0.0384833664,
-0.4204529822,
-0.4275079072,
-0.3702181876,
-0.4881547987,
0.307705611,
-0.4099788368,
-1.2081842422,
0.9173329473,
-0.547239542,
0.1514904648,
0.1051332876,
0.6529022455,
-0.0741996914,
1.1270990372,
0.485516876,
0.1728754938,
0.4493800104,
0.0186387803,
0.1315674186,
-0.5172600746,
0.1898285002,
-0.3565532565,
-0.454513073,
-0.5086303353,
-0.531249702,
0.3142179847,
0.0158183835,
-0.1922556013,
0.2287065685,
-0.0520277321,
0.9278388619,
0.3265502453,
0.156036213,
0.0607177652,
-0.5265013576,
-0.1595007926,
0.1320515722,
-0.870408535,
-0.7638046145,
0.656750679,
0.4556342959,
0.4923539758,
0.2867800593,
0.6846179962,
0.2892280519,
0.530757308,
-0.8489469886,
0.6898524165,
0.3977743089,
-1.154599309,
-0.4247620404,
-0.1951666772,
-1.1420170069,
0.4252468944,
-0.3227725625,
-1.0030062199,
-0.0526258163,
0.0661833733,
-0.4355810583,
0.0120051512,
-0.8787189126,
1.1693605185,
-0.2537302971,
-0.5219131112,
-0.4597533643,
-0.4814252853,
0.5309339762,
0.2957929969,
0.4249083698,
-0.2377358377,
0.0199040901,
0.3184205294,
-0.1544272006,
0.8854436278,
-0.1408469677,
-0.0721056685,
0.7751616836,
0.7386929989,
0.2730488777,
0.055656407,
-0.0324967317,
-0.0701100156,
0.4319066405,
-0.4864402711,
-0.7380292416,
0.6098896861,
-0.7323640585,
-0.8527674079,
-0.2827064991,
-0.7809990048,
-0.4775395095,
0.0688909665,
-0.3348509967,
0.3270158768,
-0.9889892936,
0.3434420824,
0.4724768102,
-0.3246316314,
0.1930658817,
0.662630558,
-0.4623524845,
0.0079051452,
0.6124352813,
-0.3101251423,
0.5559711456,
0.0006215618,
0.0599945746,
-0.1821663827,
-0.4548151493,
-0.1280656606,
0.0542341955,
-0.7343984842,
0.0209027994,
0.0878635496,
-0.135144636,
0.1694671363,
-0.2602744102,
-0.2835220695,
0.0018216778,
-0.131054461,
-0.1324479133,
-0.083131671,
0.756735146,
-0.2318335623,
0.7377508879,
-0.7552188635,
-0.1736804694,
-0.0202274658,
0.381432116,
-0.1082258299,
-0.472745508,
-0.1934185773,
0.2391545475,
-0.1532201171,
-0.9314541817,
0.2592063844,
0.0699688047,
0.5758963227,
0.4494274557,
-0.0418745279,
0.6251345873,
-0.5038564205,
0.8887481689,
-0.2416842133,
-1.0935877562,
0.3778246045,
-0.3887506425,
0.1975363791,
0.717630744,
-0.0783273354,
-0.4915174544,
-0.4022759497,
-0.8295931816,
-0.4540635347,
0.8422466516,
0.2140790075,
0.4631536305,
0.0537055396,
0.3263063431,
-0.0507879481,
0.3949339986,
-0.5320467949,
-0.0029303769,
0.3837429881,
-0.0845703334,
-0.4152902365,
-0.503557086,
-0.313824296,
0.2311442345,
0.4039346576,
0.090577893,
0.1918433607,
-0.0776856169,
-0.3585215807,
0.1302659363,
0.2793630362,
0.5256243944,
0.7673826218,
-0.1072500795,
-0.0992580727,
0.3739234805,
-0.0599558838,
0.0241272617,
-0.1914986819,
-0.035177622,
-0.0464363918,
0.46634233,
0.832218349,
0.5222336054,
-1.1488056183,
0.5881253481,
-0.0300341006,
-0.2057002187,
-0.1570246816,
0.4037351608,
0.1685542166,
0.6077605486,
-0.4885193706,
-0.5154046416,
0.1873443425,
-0.8281926513,
0.3138290644,
0.7162806988,
-0.6036748886,
-0.1305175424,
0.3307701647,
0.5177998543,
-0.4779565334,
0.3705891967,
-0.326805234,
-0.5330507755,
0.6845735908,
0.5740372539,
0.5420560837,
-0.2012045532,
0.340644896,
0.1904386729,
0.4186466932,
-0.0329625607,
0.3257203102,
0.0586796254,
-0.8741692901,
-0.3917480409,
-0.1875020117,
-0.7654213905,
-0.0395292826,
-0.3497409225,
0.2772783935,
-0.3091302216,
-0.4934759438,
-0.2808848917,
0.1335912645,
-0.5817500949,
-0.2076408863,
0.3475802541,
0.7352549434,
-0.5790210366,
0.3465105891,
0.3818805218,
-0.1925634146,
-0.4870636761,
-0.2761658728,
-0.0084225452,
-0.7870304585,
0.2499024719,
-0.0406512059,
-0.1407474577,
-0.0063210097,
-0.707515955,
-0.7644661069,
0.9930489659,
0.5544259548,
-0.44634372,
0.2586412728,
0.325740695,
0.9142363667,
-0.5542881489,
0.6958553195,
0.7002335191,
0.4971015453,
0.1027764454,
-1.0460005999,
-0.2652330399,
-0.0386970155,
-0.1642110348,
0.0093938019,
-0.8107188344,
0.3248019516,
-0.1306125224,
-0.4064105749,
0.2833062112,
0.6170428395,
0.2698358893,
0.2779617608,
0.6544665098,
0.1260871738,
0.5267984867,
-0.275264591,
1.0949749947,
-0.6744374037,
0.3999434412,
0.9923877716,
-0.6662397385,
0.738293469,
0.1925047636,
0.0115369419,
0.3274097443,
0.5875748992,
0.0676024556,
0.2917459905,
0.7246810794,
-0.0345688984,
-0.4390569925,
-0.2722020149,
0.0222765878,
0.590526402,
0.5774658918,
-0.0797215402,
-0.2691501379,
-0.0664613396,
0.148905322,
0.1856873035,
-0.2663546801,
0.7979285717,
0.1061914563,
-0.7755412459,
0.3222190142,
-0.1458865553,
0.149114266,
-0.5818114877,
0.0323285758,
-0.1969283223,
0.2623140812,
0.2036954463,
-0.8858345747,
-0.0190798137,
-0.0977545753,
0.3151268363,
0.0426441692,
0.6930089593,
-0.3939475715,
-0.1800266206,
0.3599105179,
0.8995139003,
0.3889847398,
0.1488447487,
-0.8866347671,
0.4193891883,
-0.1353202313,
-0.2974062264,
0.2604847252,
0.5469722152,
0.10522677,
0.6963313818,
0.3544357419,
-0.1113051623,
-0.2997124791,
-0.0123866918,
0.5879858732,
-0.3974797428,
-0.5167328715,
-0.8056613207,
0.4000063539,
-0.2002043426,
-0.2555779517,
0.7062590718,
0.5668002367,
0.5557794571,
0.0493792929,
0.6179456711,
0.0807699114,
0.2604212761,
-0.3501786888,
0.4741249382,
-0.2920752466,
0.2117977291,
-0.0576649234,
-0.881498456,
-0.1491977274,
0.5046795011,
-0.5304757953,
0.0969031453,
0.5497847199,
0.7736996412,
-0.0828100592,
-0.010608647,
0.6559557915,
0.2052277923,
0.3386977315,
0.6381459832,
1.144795537,
0.1409275085,
0.5043712258,
-0.0812048689,
-0.3229307532,
-0.2839720249,
-0.7567397356,
-1.3647012711,
-0.4087606966,
-0.0934148952,
-0.4684494138,
0.255523622,
0.8816085458,
0.4751602709,
-0.573441267,
-0.665175736,
0.3353821635,
0.1285255104,
-0.185362637,
-0.1862454414,
0.0811058134,
-0.4489842355,
-0.8220084906,
0.4600063562,
0.0473442525,
-0.2179893106,
-0.5461325645,
-0.0932394639,
0.1062382385,
0.6156510115,
0.7072966695,
0.3263419569,
-0.567769587,
-0.4644517601,
0.1160444096,
-0.1102409586,
-0.0089735705,
0.8002217412,
-0.5870212913,
0.5723971128,
0.3031097054,
0.4411404729,
0.3938163519,
0.0471514501,
0.7961466908,
-0.4157680869,
0.4132967293,
0.3575858176,
0.2730611265,
0.1219594926,
0.0741516426,
0.5599229336,
-0.1569446027,
-0.582444191,
-0.9100137353,
0.2986348569,
-0.7293812633,
-0.1427520365,
1.4267911911,
-0.2059739083,
-0.3849128783,
0.0322837494,
-0.5023155808,
0.0174964126,
-0.2923707664,
0.6789182425,
1.0602989197,
-0.0792264119,
0.0639725998,
-0.8865100741,
0.3971595168,
0.2508056462,
-0.5913460851,
0.154830128,
0.673186183,
0.0196147822,
0.1456357688,
0.4714184403,
0.0368933342,
0.1725035459,
0.056420438,
0.1663669497,
0.1422758698,
0.0313996486,
-0.1760604531,
0.0717869699,
0.4554118216,
-0.014462485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13417v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13417v2 | VISIT: Visualizing and Interpreting the Semantic Information Flow of Transformers | 2023-05-22T19:04:56 | 2023-11-24T12:02:13 | Shahar Katz, Yonatan Belinkov | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Recent advances in interpretability suggest we can project weights and hidden
states of transformer-based language models (LMs) to their vocabulary, a
transformation that makes them more human interpretable. In this paper, we
investigate LM attention heads and memory values, the vectors the models
dynamically create and recall while processing a given input. By analyzing the
tokens they represent through this projection, we identify patterns in the
information flow inside the attention mechanism. Based on our discoveries, we
create a tool to visualize a forward pass of Generative Pre-trained
Transformers (GPTs) as an interactive flow graph, with nodes representing
neurons or hidden states and edges representing the interactions between them.
Our visualization simplifies huge amounts of data into easy-to-read plots that
can reflect the models' internal processing, uncovering the contribution of
each component to the models' final prediction. Our visualization also unveils
new insights about the role of layer norms as semantic filters that influence
the models' output, and about neurons that are always activated during forward
passes and act as regularization vectors. | [
-0.3504585326,
-0.5210242271,
0.62855196,
-0.0934583768,
-0.2688254714,
-0.0747900084,
-0.0601813272,
-0.1956435293,
-0.0100088036,
0.9518460035,
-0.8447270393,
-0.5330183506,
-0.8668099046,
-0.2804417312,
-0.760931015,
1.0832823515,
-0.0682443231,
-0.2533912957,
-0.1188323945,
0.0885843784,
-0.4160859883,
-0.2918552458,
-0.5811601281,
-0.4939605892,
0.5712019801,
0.1078364626,
1.0044058561,
0.7555110455,
0.5141886473,
0.3375666142,
-0.0690026134,
-0.602197051,
-0.7159791589,
0.2605902553,
-0.2411258668,
-0.6618233919,
-0.3135412037,
0.0118020987,
0.7673188448,
0.6238687634,
0.1057974473,
0.2129293531,
0.2336957604,
0.5500093102,
-0.1937900335,
0.8584074378,
-0.5609233975,
0.1980801076,
-0.2892707884,
-0.4570418894,
-0.6078908443,
-0.0769631937,
0.2527952492,
-0.5444220304,
0.2367592454,
-0.1257108301,
0.9842284918,
0.6923396587,
-0.2178771198,
-0.2206675857,
-0.827767849,
0.5534746051,
-0.2743038237,
0.507648766,
0.0054352847,
0.6650516987,
0.0540401004,
-1.2589324713,
-0.5870321989,
-0.0030155436,
-0.531159699,
0.282497555,
-0.4801052213,
0.0204772241,
0.2664982975,
0.2255135626,
-0.3884419203,
-0.082730256,
-0.4697572291,
-0.2388763726,
0.2496066689,
0.241493687,
0.4625402391,
0.0436234437,
-0.3774826825,
-0.5125697851,
-0.3939171135,
-0.0380620509,
0.0910005793,
0.2916775048,
-0.3318819106,
0.5252891183,
0.0282302555,
1.0249481201,
-0.1035067737,
0.096916616,
0.2099843621,
-0.1114872396,
-0.3470851183,
-0.2497719526,
0.6457770467,
0.2079933435,
0.7349382043,
-0.2381868064,
-0.0355027765,
-0.1305214316,
0.6110411882,
-0.9378252029,
-0.5219227672,
-0.0631965622,
-0.6319870949,
-0.2831232548,
0.1474056095,
-0.6982306838,
-0.3417041898,
-0.5682685971,
0.4904187322,
-0.4394827187,
-0.4025126696,
0.073441267,
-0.2503163815,
0.4327755272,
0.364575088,
-0.695453465,
0.2863976061,
0.5205266476,
0.7951897383,
-0.2234934568,
-0.2204848677,
-0.2299049944,
0.2513987124,
0.0419151708,
0.8355813026,
-0.5884085894,
-0.1682759523,
-0.1266428679,
0.1228346303,
-0.3589354753,
-0.4133268595,
0.5055980682,
-0.8585713506,
-0.3114574552,
-0.0485990718,
-0.5070351958,
-0.284946233,
-0.0652854592,
-0.8803030252,
0.5784038305,
0.1949892342,
-0.8571676016,
0.27636379,
-0.7034052014,
-0.0657538846,
0.2700855136,
-0.3899475634,
-0.1843283772,
-0.0086666541,
0.0433425605,
0.7038454413,
0.004710258,
-0.0199281443,
0.0705879629,
-0.3094689846,
0.3447090089,
-0.4123905003,
0.5260391831,
0.2658561766,
-0.2805491686,
0.5708341599,
-0.7650863528,
-0.145261243,
0.2620000541,
0.0567540675,
0.0349426009,
0.129734382,
-0.2126116604,
0.4421577156,
-0.0273677278,
-0.1874644905,
0.0213139411,
-0.0124942828,
0.3807046413,
0.8967831731,
0.02344588,
0.4451209605,
0.1906581223,
0.5786368847,
0.5246577859,
0.2059701085,
-0.456435442,
-0.7965948582,
-1.0022872686,
-0.0393893532,
-0.0030786658,
0.3523538113,
-0.7797890902,
0.1073361263,
-0.5664010048,
-0.3414318264,
-0.592621088,
-0.0901386216,
-0.2009861618,
0.7572441697,
0.2917938232,
-0.0632268712,
-0.186984852,
-1.0541335344,
-0.2895771861,
-0.0427354649,
-0.1923104078,
0.0219620205,
0.4742286503,
-0.219973281,
1.0201109648,
-0.6699192524,
-0.259703815,
-0.477181524,
0.2784579098,
0.4138137996,
0.3247718513,
0.4284711778,
-0.809684813,
-0.2543857396,
0.0667051449,
-0.5897922516,
-0.0433597118,
-0.2839171588,
-0.5607976913,
-0.4088199437,
0.7178968191,
-0.5595539808,
0.6933774948,
0.4313412607,
-0.7484484315,
0.198564142,
0.0253632814,
-0.1918867528,
-0.4563297331,
0.1415994465,
-0.18836613,
-0.2572521269,
-0.7021920085,
0.0093115848,
0.146912083,
-0.2416521013,
-0.2817633748,
0.4461729228,
-0.4467681348,
-0.2169904262,
-0.214854151,
0.178016901,
-0.0334047228,
0.6530739665,
0.0914015472,
0.6745709181,
0.7507250905,
-0.5568073988,
0.3339588344,
0.1778726131,
-0.3614622056,
0.4258866012,
-0.6059651375,
0.1642907262,
-0.5982680321,
0.1161864847,
-0.9473271966,
-0.0837580413,
0.3997629881,
-0.3775309324,
0.4887207747,
-0.294062227,
-0.5097703934,
-0.2187445909,
0.1000884026,
0.1418163329,
0.5873969793,
-0.4025769234,
0.9028193951,
0.4268019497,
0.0568951704,
-0.3248543143,
-0.7304806113,
-0.1041481793,
0.0412955172,
-0.75895679,
0.3377425969,
0.2198804766,
-0.2331846952,
0.3597911596,
0.1394481212,
-0.0877353325,
0.0497606769,
0.4703217745,
0.3169392049,
-0.2369931638,
0.1202603802,
-0.112238124,
-0.2847069502,
0.3340646029,
-0.4043019414,
0.6018255353,
-0.2352655977,
-0.3492214382,
-0.6388959885,
0.130570218,
0.6788134575,
-0.2765436172,
1.0262969732,
0.9325698614,
-0.2230354697,
-0.1627803147,
-0.110162735,
-0.2798390985,
-0.4622142613,
0.3850123882,
-0.5770845413,
-0.6438646913,
0.6542555094,
0.1378165036,
0.0434074961,
0.8823213577,
0.6184476018,
0.0097799404,
1.058347702,
0.6888821721,
0.1069788337,
0.4707499444,
-0.5238797069,
0.2193427086,
-0.6730307341,
-0.4812772572,
-0.185020119,
-0.4969816804,
-0.4289768934,
-0.673330307,
0.3239515126,
0.1910868883,
0.0096654175,
0.1928277314,
-0.4764403999,
0.3894401193,
0.3166331649,
-0.0790133849,
0.3122413456,
-0.1242801249,
-0.2264477611,
-0.061155349,
-0.7020115256,
-0.5321264863,
0.7796387076,
0.6150604486,
0.9382685423,
-0.2019326836,
0.1990066916,
0.1593805552,
0.598202765,
-1.0503236055,
0.5790740252,
0.0442929305,
-0.3143854141,
-0.2781190276,
-0.3570368886,
-1.0235564709,
0.3654842675,
-0.0403692685,
-0.6706727147,
-0.0341871977,
0.2272403538,
-0.2621600926,
0.6066687703,
-0.9321749806,
1.2009037733,
0.0829492211,
-0.11180453,
-0.3442780674,
-0.6202332973,
0.2138487399,
0.2418879718,
-0.0386094637,
0.0324207246,
0.1584376991,
0.6341924667,
-0.3067352474,
0.8705429435,
-0.1771752387,
-0.080545865,
0.4420180917,
0.0654225498,
0.4905782938,
-0.3291166723,
0.2078692764,
0.1803341508,
-0.3656547666,
-0.21410878,
-0.734272778,
0.5943927169,
-0.6431446075,
-0.5730364919,
-0.1038191393,
-0.6778680086,
0.1082797796,
0.2132072896,
0.0863893107,
0.3730414212,
0.1992740929,
0.1085765064,
0.4356396794,
-0.2979376912,
0.1301344782,
0.0808003321,
-0.4546405077,
0.4057139158,
0.9050774574,
0.1191242561,
0.3155434132,
0.4312996566,
0.0472776257,
-0.3407560885,
-0.5002912283,
-0.5743014812,
0.3602690697,
-1.1135383844,
0.1354673654,
-0.763710618,
-0.5146842599,
-0.2371396869,
0.2792890072,
-0.1639357656,
-0.4042961001,
-0.2942804396,
-0.1287059635,
0.3531807661,
1.0219496489,
0.3578695357,
0.4759489,
-0.6573756337,
0.289260745,
0.5125383735,
0.4817497134,
0.2274822295,
-0.4511705339,
-0.4021068811,
-0.3191276491,
-0.4506429136,
-0.8713856339,
0.3676407635,
-0.0250313357,
0.5777770281,
0.5336705446,
-0.4176159203,
0.6081225872,
-0.5601911545,
0.5767983794,
-0.0644613504,
-0.9418902993,
0.4769429266,
-0.0884102061,
0.4927409589,
-0.0171138979,
0.1385452747,
-0.6115583181,
-0.6115489006,
-0.5325266123,
-0.705154717,
0.8184869289,
0.4221919775,
0.0232185796,
0.2173423022,
0.2111029923,
0.065392375,
-0.0175737478,
-0.4725917876,
-0.4558995664,
-0.6070988178,
-0.3725486398,
-0.072167635,
-0.1132708341,
0.1669486165,
-0.2032491416,
0.1606188416,
-0.041161295,
0.6044206619,
-0.0428475365,
-0.2778278887,
0.0560018979,
0.1050511599,
0.5251853466,
0.6081677079,
-0.1868717521,
0.4115909636,
-0.1012028605,
-0.5571914911,
-0.3689234853,
-0.0677780434,
-0.1121997312,
0.2087693959,
0.4164785445,
1.3913965225,
0.0982785374,
-0.3941012621,
0.5221813917,
-0.0604151711,
0.2104445547,
-0.3655879498,
0.1832093745,
0.2797875106,
0.2610568106,
0.2798586488,
0.403362751,
0.2166772932,
-0.5498151779,
0.2867423296,
0.3042548597,
-0.7322955132,
-0.8150509596,
0.800255537,
0.0117862877,
0.0034639107,
0.5722815394,
0.1376398802,
-0.4731743932,
0.3825039268,
0.2563099861,
0.8609172106,
-0.0623087287,
0.1580805629,
0.2144967765,
0.3133640885,
0.1868516654,
0.0975064412,
-0.2295742333,
-0.79392308,
-0.6046930552,
-0.5346686244,
-0.1269433647,
0.2376968414,
-0.7942311764,
0.3057302833,
-0.1450866014,
-0.2306171954,
0.2089932114,
-0.769567132,
-1.166505456,
0.3291074932,
0.4205549061,
0.795168519,
-0.7267201543,
1.0687185526,
0.4870712161,
-0.3100755513,
-0.5847857594,
0.0853288919,
-0.2499564141,
-1.11967659,
1.1088237762,
0.1578083783,
-0.4917626679,
0.1935881227,
-0.3617442846,
-0.9281228781,
0.9689983726,
0.3870402873,
-0.1938327849,
-0.3451683223,
0.2386446297,
0.576601088,
-0.2564693391,
0.4532140791,
0.6498336196,
0.5740801692,
0.1223659888,
-0.5085891485,
0.0251469407,
-0.2328304648,
0.074528642,
0.3741094768,
-0.2936793864,
1.0087049007,
-0.1456686705,
-0.7414599061,
-0.4175244272,
0.7619177699,
-0.2324838489,
-0.1763174981,
0.5872266889,
0.399956882,
0.2939668894,
-0.2870135903,
1.3168407679,
-0.4114449024,
0.2679665983,
0.8883208632,
0.1522665471,
0.625310421,
0.5727983117,
0.0485084765,
0.72354877,
-0.0189093556,
-0.0067906748,
0.5072699785,
0.3980528116,
0.2842831314,
-0.1665783674,
-0.0905807391,
-0.0189111214,
0.3966972828,
0.4757250845,
-0.5617784858,
-0.350202024,
0.0522275642,
-0.1167920232,
-0.2360784411,
-0.4391024411,
0.4517512619,
0.0384696499,
-0.5257115364,
0.3966498673,
-0.2605277896,
0.3961480856,
-0.5662307739,
-0.2061340511,
0.2241299301,
0.3149872124,
-0.1407314241,
-1.47194767,
0.604385376,
0.017886728,
-0.0305393822,
-0.692745626,
0.9008937478,
-0.259386003,
-0.4228371084,
0.5293134451,
0.4993437827,
0.3316526711,
-0.2301720232,
-0.6167299747,
0.1890733242,
-0.0295767132,
-0.5320087075,
0.003464411,
0.4425067008,
-0.1269029826,
0.7388931513,
0.2967143357,
0.1631408781,
0.4814856052,
0.5636918545,
0.8545435667,
-0.804905057,
-0.4626973569,
-0.9240948558,
0.8325634599,
-0.1781337708,
-0.2160250843,
0.5946959257,
0.2170191407,
0.8952408433,
-0.3519608676,
0.4824299216,
0.2814546227,
0.4644263685,
-0.5950644612,
1.0793988705,
-0.2430330962,
0.0119454768,
0.0006543459,
-0.6518144011,
-0.1889573187,
0.4917936027,
-0.0959031582,
-0.104271695,
0.5252451301,
0.508872509,
-0.1342988312,
-0.0048700892,
0.3838152885,
0.5439008474,
0.2377173305,
0.3857657313,
1.0737992525,
-0.2570703328,
0.635858953,
-0.3287471533,
-0.0638590679,
-0.020838812,
-0.612255156,
-0.867046237,
-0.7564175725,
-0.2983325422,
-0.0348275341,
-0.5351527929,
0.3008537292,
0.6792340279,
-0.7044090033,
-0.3382643163,
-0.2384149283,
0.0083245533,
-0.1938035935,
-0.3116814196,
0.3954233527,
-0.3207816184,
-0.6989358664,
0.1914659292,
0.3647576571,
0.2360607088,
-0.3877813816,
0.0782789141,
0.4005329609,
0.0498944186,
0.702452302,
-0.1674045324,
-0.7114422321,
-0.3606422544,
-0.0593046285,
0.030931199,
0.2703826725,
1.1178814173,
-0.9917738438,
0.5430563688,
0.6139526367,
0.343265444,
0.8646252751,
-0.1550526917,
0.5942021608,
-0.5704596639,
0.3150227964,
0.1696166992,
0.4140890539,
0.2306269854,
-0.1877488941,
0.240338549,
0.0712789446,
-0.1616167277,
-0.5893609524,
0.4197583795,
-1.0564782619,
-0.1399189234,
0.7648590803,
-0.2107059509,
-0.3397142887,
-0.0320619754,
-0.1352973282,
0.5973890424,
-0.1505774856,
0.3819124699,
0.6669863462,
-0.2890181541,
-0.3959850073,
-0.9184468389,
0.5940675735,
0.206785664,
-0.6981918216,
-0.1414296925,
0.1058155447,
0.1052090898,
0.219794482,
0.260191083,
-0.3183799088,
-0.2708023489,
-0.0978168771,
-0.0402506329,
-0.038111899,
-0.4045090377,
-0.3810711205,
0.1197712049,
-0.0533725545,
-0.2612366974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13413v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13413v1 | Syntactic Knowledge via Graph Attention with BERT in Machine Translation | 2023-05-22T18:56:14 | 2023-05-22T18:56:14 | Yuqian Dai, Serge Sharoff, Marc de Kamps | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although the Transformer model can effectively acquire context features via a
self-attention mechanism, deeper syntactic knowledge is still not effectively
modeled. To alleviate the above problem, we propose Syntactic knowledge via
Graph attention with BERT (SGB) in Machine Translation (MT) scenarios. Graph
Attention Network (GAT) and BERT jointly represent syntactic dependency feature
as explicit knowledge of the source language to enrich source language
representations and guide target language generation. Our experiments use gold
syntax-annotation sentences and Quality Estimation (QE) model to obtain
interpretability of translation quality improvement regarding syntactic
knowledge without being limited to a BLEU score. Experiments show that the
proposed SGB engines improve translation quality across the three MT tasks
without sacrificing BLEU scores. We investigate what length of source sentences
benefits the most and what dependencies are better identified by the SGB
engines. We also find that learning of specific dependency relations by GAT can
be reflected in the translation quality containing such relations and that
syntax on the graph leads to new modeling of syntactic aspects of source
sentences in the middle and bottom layers of BERT. | [
-0.2783545256,
-0.6599965692,
0.7453909516,
0.2208171338,
-0.27226156,
0.0708175302,
-0.2045340836,
-0.6209157705,
0.3480885923,
0.625118494,
-0.5279037952,
-0.325022012,
-0.7888090611,
-0.0518200994,
-0.2836399674,
1.1169885397,
-0.1223922521,
0.0747052655,
-0.0395467728,
-0.0092275701,
-0.4999362528,
-0.6391823888,
-0.3423409164,
-0.0969458148,
0.7736165524,
-0.1231826246,
0.7256190777,
0.5874885917,
0.7128454447,
0.2203219533,
-0.1139719337,
0.1703174859,
-0.5407227874,
0.0812415406,
-0.2224035114,
-0.4465140402,
-0.2376933545,
-0.1750457138,
0.7172487974,
0.6864575744,
0.2198714018,
0.1938200891,
0.1343985349,
0.7354392409,
-0.1296243817,
0.6149724722,
-0.6140654683,
-0.0334492028,
-0.0137406616,
-0.0720039234,
-0.5242882371,
-0.1845982224,
0.24376899,
-0.3421633542,
0.3482586741,
-0.0287062395,
1.2561455965,
0.7242937684,
-0.4686341584,
-0.0546261407,
-0.6152435541,
0.4419220984,
-0.7201090455,
0.6061557531,
0.173047021,
0.3532795608,
-0.2130825073,
-0.9683579803,
-0.4696084261,
-0.0601747781,
-0.5460067391,
0.2550578415,
-0.2014286518,
0.1723453254,
0.155621767,
0.3526525199,
-0.5128199458,
-0.3223448992,
-0.3753210008,
-0.252825439,
0.2764038146,
-0.2108924091,
0.4557747841,
-0.5355124474,
-0.3558967412,
-0.0083229952,
-0.583712697,
0.1094422117,
0.1263709962,
0.4283919632,
0.2320169955,
0.3807484508,
0.0349259041,
0.812974453,
0.1021819338,
0.1961579174,
0.3395895362,
-0.5466622114,
-0.2462171912,
-0.1632182151,
0.6297854185,
-0.0522186235,
0.0755131319,
-0.6063210368,
-0.0906085521,
-0.1533626318,
0.407833308,
-0.6258412004,
-0.2461063713,
-0.0259188674,
-0.4948370159,
0.162559852,
-0.0157997105,
-0.1993242949,
0.1255654246,
-0.3024414778,
0.4481080472,
-0.6653431058,
-0.0215492919,
-0.3603213727,
-0.178230688,
-0.0106640421,
0.1474704891,
-1.0121030807,
-0.0910633653,
0.3187345266,
0.6864503622,
0.274843365,
-0.2791894674,
-0.5968868732,
0.541477263,
-0.2062376291,
0.7187128067,
-0.2560971081,
0.1175074279,
-0.3047199845,
0.1074460372,
-0.2487628609,
-0.1319912523,
0.3010088503,
-0.5814157724,
0.2121511996,
-0.4540731311,
-0.5306613445,
-0.658161819,
-0.0346068181,
-0.6568948627,
0.881585598,
0.5132694244,
-0.6549945474,
0.4358221591,
-0.6169472337,
-0.8300253749,
0.2815806568,
-0.0608447008,
-0.1496642232,
0.1842490882,
0.571503818,
0.5029185414,
0.2660729289,
0.2523905635,
-0.204070434,
0.0292665828,
0.0188450515,
-0.004050687,
0.6106089354,
0.0694094896,
-0.1173351184,
0.2526783049,
-0.3285339475,
0.1439688206,
0.2145563513,
-0.3716498613,
-0.1669473499,
-0.0890230462,
-0.2366259694,
0.3930152953,
0.4497339129,
-0.3327155411,
0.0658936054,
-0.6602395773,
0.7817339301,
0.6378797889,
0.2834407985,
0.3776784241,
0.3214789927,
0.4244150817,
-0.1563046128,
-0.0701749623,
-0.1242782325,
-0.4192023575,
-0.6657834053,
0.0491828732,
0.6264590025,
0.27497226,
-0.8725133538,
0.3773843348,
-0.2305714339,
0.0526315868,
-0.8610472679,
0.4309387207,
0.442019254,
0.4710929692,
0.556569159,
-0.3245008588,
-0.4153361917,
-0.9572193027,
-0.2121838033,
-0.1663978547,
0.0501935706,
0.4525095522,
0.1234668493,
-0.0257752538,
0.847460866,
-0.425733,
-0.5586359501,
-0.7052440047,
0.0347231068,
0.1917959899,
0.1679264903,
0.7841659188,
-0.5749087334,
-0.5914226174,
0.1451098025,
-0.657769084,
-0.0921932682,
0.0801994652,
-0.457058847,
0.2230388522,
0.3141486943,
-0.6156474948,
0.0774623826,
0.8066591024,
-0.1011733413,
0.1055212617,
-0.113910161,
-0.1067797095,
-1.1450666189,
0.168614015,
-0.0957284868,
-0.4282612205,
-0.5264172554,
0.2423524559,
0.1671481878,
-0.1798401773,
-0.3836058378,
0.4281291068,
-0.4964594543,
-0.3025593162,
-0.1367652714,
0.4170710742,
0.2228064239,
0.7924674153,
-0.1059266254,
0.8593161106,
0.0853518695,
-0.2711673975,
0.1375539899,
0.4857507348,
-0.1379817575,
0.0420991071,
-0.6473994255,
0.2704183757,
-0.0286203977,
0.3136216402,
-1.0944393873,
-0.2660201192,
0.3695224226,
-0.6752305627,
0.6496172547,
-0.411305815,
-0.7745162845,
-0.4470931888,
0.4225564897,
-0.1202175617,
0.4662517309,
-0.4139131308,
0.5206208229,
0.3017939031,
-0.3405942321,
-0.5587393641,
-0.7057834864,
0.183229804,
0.2400003076,
-0.864475131,
0.1158822253,
0.3039393127,
0.2867575586,
0.3677720726,
-0.2688457668,
-0.06427297,
0.1124571338,
-0.0175349917,
0.0146496473,
-0.2281663716,
0.3780665994,
0.226452902,
-0.2795996666,
0.1118829772,
-0.6300326586,
0.5740959644,
0.0228830278,
-0.0531649664,
-0.1567367166,
0.2635064721,
0.2336845398,
-0.6640958786,
0.6496322751,
0.793828845,
-0.0967112631,
-0.2510362267,
-0.3093877733,
-0.2802040279,
-0.3628085554,
0.4696908295,
-0.3603363633,
-0.9010006189,
0.526959002,
0.0289644208,
-0.2475063354,
0.6395432949,
0.4602038264,
-0.3923933506,
1.0912207365,
0.6137642264,
-0.2746457756,
0.7500452399,
-0.3235328794,
0.4512693286,
-0.9135738611,
0.1511716247,
-0.2283203602,
-0.4898045361,
-0.2849467099,
-0.1669982821,
0.3732450008,
0.178761363,
0.1317604333,
0.6905219555,
-0.4612274766,
0.3465167284,
0.6821493506,
0.3729650974,
0.0143755041,
-0.0499424003,
-0.2386340499,
-0.0885909498,
-0.8067991734,
-0.2537840009,
0.9149532914,
0.1984044164,
0.2292899489,
-0.0544464998,
0.676727891,
0.1310057789,
0.2070727646,
-0.5383733511,
0.393441081,
-0.3065957427,
-0.6250453591,
-0.4283568859,
-0.5618787408,
-0.7428068519,
0.1636965126,
0.2563551962,
-0.659781754,
-0.1965166479,
0.2299792916,
-0.1340683401,
-0.0803768039,
-1.0276119709,
1.2823084593,
-0.3277583718,
-0.2370584309,
-0.2111298144,
-1.110367775,
-0.002814529,
0.1548864096,
-0.1800679713,
-0.0613523871,
0.4202081561,
0.4547751844,
-0.413243413,
0.9478681684,
-0.2679946423,
-0.079152137,
0.3828013241,
-0.0280043017,
0.7791001797,
-0.1171021536,
0.2323235273,
0.3034055829,
-0.4461426139,
-0.4058977962,
-0.8473027945,
0.4535267055,
-0.6688174605,
-0.6230862141,
0.0939152986,
-0.9359505773,
-0.1947401166,
0.6151818633,
0.1181915477,
-0.0140515715,
0.1094414294,
0.0129715428,
0.3078811765,
0.1022318229,
0.3387901485,
0.2688018084,
-0.2101235986,
-0.3850229383,
0.913433373,
0.364456296,
0.4623891413,
0.507891953,
-0.103987284,
-0.3887935281,
-0.5283423662,
-0.6783054471,
0.488779515,
-0.8376905322,
-0.2749038041,
-0.8265317082,
-0.5146083236,
-0.3926305771,
0.013161066,
-0.014066807,
-0.6061671972,
-0.0566967279,
-0.2542058825,
0.339100033,
0.6048980951,
0.1624582857,
0.4155036211,
-0.9497582912,
0.1014825478,
0.1203754693,
0.183927089,
-0.0318728834,
-0.4290077984,
-0.7281191945,
-0.0154798273,
-0.4543301463,
-0.8663794994,
0.4684961736,
0.0002477315,
0.7269020677,
0.1878348738,
-0.1937656254,
0.4866025448,
-0.5628923774,
0.6276240349,
0.0005363119,
-1.1178574562,
0.7494928837,
-0.4123086631,
0.2531282604,
0.2865353227,
0.1810022593,
-0.4049044549,
-0.9860190749,
-0.6978752613,
-0.7658013701,
0.7186763287,
0.3597911298,
0.0043447781,
-0.1296172589,
0.2521341741,
-0.0111248856,
0.4099737704,
-0.7762730122,
0.0215787664,
-0.2902680039,
-0.2397246957,
-0.2246825397,
-0.0548372827,
0.0465485901,
-0.0307544917,
0.6188108921,
-0.1686075479,
0.3679655194,
0.1313132644,
-0.4162926376,
-0.2482390404,
0.1031161994,
0.2895108163,
0.6703830361,
-0.3044776022,
0.0882846639,
0.0358183049,
-0.1307831407,
-0.1818578392,
0.1869171113,
-0.3263274729,
0.1855773926,
0.3576859236,
0.8038790226,
0.1480749249,
-0.0108135333,
0.2717775106,
0.416467607,
0.0507088117,
0.1852099895,
0.013771316,
0.4843278527,
0.2337186337,
0.0754794553,
0.1225793213,
0.1465073377,
-0.3009541035,
0.264534235,
0.3936974406,
-0.5750144124,
-0.318413645,
0.7216905355,
0.2720209956,
-0.052310627,
0.4799745083,
-0.1392273158,
-0.8722029924,
0.6120467186,
0.7317461371,
0.6699917316,
-0.3019133806,
0.1757555753,
0.2687422037,
0.4118508399,
0.2794363797,
0.2242847234,
-0.0480673946,
-0.5853869319,
-0.8186885715,
-0.4292983115,
-0.3255655468,
-0.0897660479,
-0.4687632024,
0.0809579566,
-0.2880167663,
-0.1229606867,
0.103073895,
-0.0970797017,
-0.6601133347,
0.0888186172,
-0.1045765132,
0.3549195528,
-0.6805184484,
0.994905293,
0.7865685821,
-1.0192186832,
-1.1414449215,
0.0777186826,
-0.4919177592,
-1.036323905,
1.0079865456,
0.1650510281,
0.0951873288,
0.5053587556,
-0.5154159665,
-0.9822869301,
0.9234662652,
0.6480436325,
-0.3948155344,
-0.1249435246,
-0.0190650672,
0.7752498388,
-0.1675665379,
-0.0813086778,
0.2943413556,
0.4791101515,
-0.0465385467,
-0.7314838767,
0.1492327899,
-0.0839321762,
0.0682067722,
0.7311999202,
-0.8285995722,
0.4785287678,
-0.3459780216,
-0.4593708217,
-0.3530127108,
0.723407805,
-0.3803252578,
0.030830238,
0.175556004,
0.5970005393,
0.5183734894,
-0.1020787805,
1.1009230614,
-0.6293118596,
0.5225896835,
1.123290658,
-0.1040500551,
0.6940557957,
0.5746067762,
-0.2482600212,
0.5887627602,
0.6212927699,
-0.1429123878,
0.6686857939,
-0.0195970219,
0.2319007814,
-0.3023414314,
-0.2434802204,
-0.4186391234,
0.0832891837,
0.2034141868,
-0.8977937698,
-0.2929968536,
-0.0749212652,
-0.0811809897,
-0.0488869958,
0.0591256209,
0.9744785428,
0.1614022106,
-0.5187616348,
0.4565785825,
-0.2255219221,
-0.2357186824,
-0.5955786705,
-0.1619011462,
-0.3216102421,
0.0487534292,
-0.0919576213,
-0.9110354185,
0.3573506176,
-0.3785222769,
-0.5471035838,
-0.3608393669,
0.7772716284,
-0.5616335273,
-0.4488644004,
0.484826386,
0.6002748609,
0.2254430205,
-0.2201806307,
-0.4858474731,
-0.3262170553,
0.092398338,
-0.0663813651,
0.3670135736,
0.831813395,
0.1256691217,
0.6072402,
0.6869863868,
0.1435236484,
0.0651348233,
0.2065251023,
0.9491892457,
-0.5431346893,
-0.7827375531,
-0.6498836279,
0.351402998,
-0.0363451093,
0.1174854562,
0.8185427785,
0.2969326973,
0.8596705794,
-0.1652873904,
0.9534101486,
-0.0638661385,
0.4422547817,
-0.4371923506,
0.7648599744,
-0.4008075893,
-0.0661099255,
-0.3059346378,
-1.0348488092,
-0.3947990239,
0.5276858807,
-0.5468143821,
-0.0819879845,
1.0257014036,
0.3872683644,
-0.0413262658,
-0.278298229,
0.2268970758,
0.2996401191,
0.3486244678,
0.7937666774,
0.5232905149,
-0.363345623,
0.9047051668,
-0.0046574539,
0.0435127467,
-0.2140842676,
-0.6688671708,
-0.9476681948,
-0.4901858568,
0.0415440165,
-0.419344902,
0.2020361722,
0.6381569505,
0.5762235522,
-0.6655623913,
0.2189794034,
-0.2325765043,
0.307975769,
-0.5131194592,
-0.271017164,
0.6307858229,
-0.9920431972,
-0.4560256302,
0.3503549993,
0.4486474395,
0.0974984616,
-0.1597035676,
-0.0804945752,
-0.1326719075,
-0.2772496641,
0.5197933316,
0.0603693128,
-0.924369514,
-0.5244247317,
0.0795736089,
-0.2047719806,
0.2715107501,
0.6892228723,
-0.6238398552,
0.5485337377,
0.5839189887,
0.8791418076,
0.6605781913,
0.2070920169,
0.7575573325,
-0.914152801,
-0.0677241012,
0.0773410872,
0.4613099694,
0.218736127,
-0.6594111919,
0.7025175095,
0.3075493276,
-0.5816342831,
-0.3659518361,
0.3527562618,
-1.0044180155,
-0.0907614455,
0.9555631876,
-0.6008383632,
-0.2927946448,
0.1181147769,
-0.283241868,
0.5329883695,
-0.5133600831,
0.8281992078,
0.887797296,
-0.0608693399,
-0.3251170218,
-0.5883753896,
0.2662443817,
0.4490657151,
-0.6715413928,
0.126660198,
0.4176915586,
0.1276936829,
0.2983820736,
0.3198721111,
0.0669145361,
0.2238674313,
-0.10710942,
0.3083437979,
-0.2128362507,
-0.3374790847,
0.1072694063,
0.0813805833,
-0.0644630492,
-0.129678756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13412v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13412v1 | Element-aware Summarization with Large Language Models: Expert-aligned Evaluation and Chain-of-Thought Method | 2023-05-22T18:54:35 | 2023-05-22T18:54:35 | Yiming Wang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic summarization generates concise summaries that contain key ideas of
source documents. As the most mainstream datasets for the news sub-domain,
CNN/DailyMail and BBC XSum have been widely used for performance benchmarking.
However, the reference summaries of those datasets turn out to be noisy, mainly
in terms of factual hallucination and information redundancy. To address this
challenge, we first annotate new expert-writing Element-aware test sets
following the "Lasswell Communication Model" proposed by Lasswell (1948),
allowing reference summaries to focus on more fine-grained news elements
objectively and comprehensively. Utilizing the new test sets, we observe the
surprising zero-shot summary ability of LLMs, which addresses the issue of the
inconsistent results between human preference and automatic evaluation metrics
of LLMs' zero-shot summaries in prior work. Further, we propose a Summary
Chain-of-Thought (SumCoT) technique to elicit LLMs to generate summaries step
by step, which helps them integrate more fine-grained details of source
documents into the final summaries that correlate with the human writing
mindset. Experimental results show our method outperforms state-of-the-art
fine-tuned PLMs and zero-shot LLMs by +4.33/+4.77 in ROUGE-L on the two
datasets, respectively. Dataset and code are publicly available at
https://github.com/Alsace08/SumCoT. | [
-0.5077651143,
-0.498934567,
0.4752039313,
-0.0504537597,
-0.4046671391,
0.1765029132,
-0.149989143,
-0.6262018085,
0.4312924445,
0.3294299245,
-0.5072966814,
-0.634950161,
-0.4368609488,
0.4096012115,
-0.8000376225,
1.1790852547,
-0.1365791261,
-0.1650462002,
-0.3136925697,
-0.1537869126,
-0.0970029905,
-0.238638714,
-0.2357194871,
-0.2524110079,
0.6474403739,
0.3215783834,
0.6744165421,
0.7401931882,
0.5915108323,
0.1951693445,
-0.0571904257,
0.3891933262,
-0.5999712348,
0.0933624655,
-0.207995683,
-0.3572586179,
-0.7011060715,
0.1239480898,
0.5292400718,
0.6319167018,
0.2707905471,
0.226316154,
-0.0638357177,
0.6215699911,
-0.7012137175,
-0.0041441261,
-0.7087878585,
0.141769439,
0.1493587941,
-0.2855944037,
-0.2315481603,
-0.3305236399,
0.0476011708,
-0.4133061171,
0.354480952,
0.1751380265,
0.5613023639,
0.2921560109,
-0.4202089608,
-0.2241926044,
-0.560274601,
0.647364974,
-0.9124885798,
0.2001041621,
0.2744015753,
0.0075034611,
0.0732633024,
-0.4484513104,
-0.5236095786,
-0.1470488608,
-0.1550536454,
0.4341278076,
-0.0323151201,
-0.0704830959,
0.047980655,
0.5041165352,
-0.7003961205,
0.0940999165,
-0.3695748746,
-0.111927487,
0.9047980309,
0.2610263824,
-0.0412361994,
-0.1034429893,
-0.0861013234,
0.2900135815,
-0.745141685,
-0.5039422512,
0.0921941847,
0.2092242837,
-0.2271516323,
0.5790150166,
-0.5495857,
0.5730653405,
-0.0715123788,
-0.0088252071,
0.1676867008,
-0.5528734922,
-0.3442743421,
0.2494701594,
0.7306485772,
0.6859747171,
0.4844026566,
-0.2477080226,
-0.1849152446,
0.0821035281,
0.015789723,
-0.8428331614,
-0.2535181642,
0.3822742105,
-0.2348566055,
-0.6058936119,
0.0084075248,
-0.3702355921,
-0.4969096184,
-0.2685641646,
0.323640734,
-0.2160501182,
-0.0363042578,
-0.0062992554,
-0.2643306553,
0.004693883,
0.5355170369,
-0.8150133491,
0.3041814566,
0.5490630269,
0.7997517586,
-0.2319523394,
-0.3954020143,
-0.4724071622,
0.1758127809,
-0.5254206061,
1.0911564827,
-0.2336185724,
-0.2770851851,
-0.2612857521,
-0.4630402029,
0.0954439491,
-0.4163752198,
0.2961249948,
-0.3474574089,
0.355068326,
-0.5336555243,
-0.5839628577,
-0.0114375781,
0.2236656696,
-0.5133192539,
0.8542901278,
0.1486453712,
-0.9523163438,
0.3340504467,
-0.3317681849,
-0.6248682141,
-0.3479703963,
-0.3550225794,
-0.3284926116,
0.2101021856,
0.3690699637,
0.5864910483,
-0.1581749618,
0.0114921294,
-0.1639470756,
-0.5475170016,
0.3012855947,
-0.3324458003,
0.3897162974,
0.114504464,
-0.2969223261,
0.2954706848,
-0.7145264745,
-0.2349776626,
0.033766225,
-0.0327535421,
-0.2674160898,
-0.0790567771,
-0.3110288382,
0.2807939053,
0.0446482189,
-0.2073656172,
0.0657858625,
-0.3255203366,
0.2328589112,
0.6512752175,
0.1534592956,
0.3440300822,
-0.6894134879,
0.2059118301,
-0.0504706874,
-0.1148278266,
-0.5850574374,
-0.0500816703,
-0.9033853412,
-0.1849471927,
0.2447959185,
0.4372124672,
-0.5683423281,
0.4316185713,
-0.3782873452,
-0.3651858568,
-0.4989616573,
0.2036431432,
0.3856385052,
0.6129913926,
0.2980085909,
-0.4059133232,
-0.5236779451,
-0.7640208006,
-0.189290151,
-0.0960707664,
-0.0382242091,
-0.0448905788,
0.6435883641,
0.109732382,
0.9035006762,
-0.6122210026,
-0.0524970368,
-0.4164719284,
0.4015420079,
0.1547774225,
0.106392853,
0.36480546,
-0.4515085518,
-0.3760179281,
-0.2096713483,
-0.7967407703,
-0.3760438263,
-0.2673888803,
-0.0291047785,
0.2003511041,
0.3200229406,
-0.6094104648,
0.2549259961,
0.131199941,
-0.2936680019,
0.7445193529,
0.0128751406,
0.1493538618,
-1.2194048166,
0.1623794138,
-0.0916209966,
-0.508716166,
-0.3675290048,
0.0484811962,
0.0585012101,
0.0474736579,
-0.4184392989,
0.4778682292,
-0.499861449,
-0.3015028536,
-0.4802027345,
0.4956688881,
0.1163174734,
0.5419608951,
0.0035269109,
0.7856720686,
0.156778872,
-0.550599575,
0.3483456373,
0.2899161875,
-0.2900366485,
0.4416752756,
-0.5478499532,
-0.1297522932,
-0.4243654907,
0.3216728568,
-0.8525053859,
-0.2627648413,
0.0718013197,
-0.4326167107,
0.1594893783,
0.4376175702,
-0.3081488311,
-0.0888020396,
-0.8977569342,
0.0955123976,
0.3297040761,
-0.0852023959,
0.2732142806,
0.1738647074,
-0.4163593352,
-0.5828306079,
-0.7873290777,
0.2831492722,
0.0445838682,
-0.3043604493,
0.2957431674,
-0.1398746669,
-0.4630090296,
0.1588355005,
-0.4643780589,
0.091841571,
0.1158647835,
-0.0816251338,
0.2447325438,
0.0167289544,
0.1147248596,
0.0742506981,
-0.1765101999,
0.0327501148,
-0.0747074932,
0.1834823787,
0.0399163179,
-0.355530411,
-0.3855398595,
0.5505003333,
0.7653889656,
-0.2077264339,
0.293035239,
0.5169231296,
-0.2488337606,
-0.3322156668,
-0.479308337,
-0.3304222822,
-0.3102640808,
0.447139442,
-0.0699475557,
-0.6790711284,
0.5834072232,
0.1423325688,
0.3377074003,
0.6023881435,
0.5009183288,
-0.2291450351,
0.7511193752,
0.5255832672,
-0.4552799165,
0.2776354253,
-0.507891953,
0.0743941069,
-0.6928313375,
0.1120072752,
-0.258995682,
-0.3352631629,
-0.1788530499,
-0.137719363,
0.4349567294,
-0.0802983493,
-0.0875714943,
0.1792093515,
-0.2528094649,
0.5686516166,
0.5401679277,
-0.0805688277,
0.6788406968,
-0.0550597198,
-0.0779528543,
0.2065020651,
-0.7150714993,
-0.376730293,
1.0312210321,
0.1158636361,
0.9025200605,
-0.0751914456,
0.6260784268,
0.6721861362,
0.2955768704,
-0.7399424911,
0.6314381361,
0.014364576,
-0.1723451763,
-0.1993891746,
-0.3456771374,
-0.5009850264,
0.3737601042,
-0.3094747365,
-0.5102869868,
-0.0182039943,
0.1746148318,
-0.6747244596,
0.1066877544,
-0.4251765311,
0.3635187149,
-0.1534704417,
-0.4023152292,
-0.3735103607,
-0.7246652246,
0.4640218914,
-0.0955842212,
0.0511622354,
-0.2299178392,
0.0350660756,
0.5979366899,
-0.3218216896,
0.8126638532,
0.4273590744,
-0.1435356289,
0.2907925248,
-0.0039542182,
0.6360691786,
-0.0767060146,
-0.0558828004,
0.0420418121,
-0.2730565667,
-0.1592486352,
-0.5918087959,
0.5949977636,
-0.7592725754,
-0.4676367342,
-0.5182792544,
-0.7825343609,
-0.0599100254,
0.286529839,
0.3001745641,
0.6913055182,
-0.0869835317,
-0.0401000418,
0.7260473967,
0.1763373613,
0.4823331535,
0.7570031881,
-0.2419695258,
-0.5740613341,
0.8436331153,
0.3493159413,
0.185954541,
0.6284062266,
-0.0360924378,
-0.0724912137,
-0.6374712586,
-0.4172970951,
0.2847049534,
-0.5900566578,
-0.2962735891,
-0.6839853525,
-0.4098131359,
-0.5138756037,
-0.5054931045,
-0.2221941054,
-0.692804873,
-0.1695396751,
-0.4022646248,
0.0825508311,
0.7241948247,
0.0920603871,
0.0375446118,
-0.7317954302,
0.3680715263,
0.2934408784,
0.1948046088,
0.0779509321,
-0.3461409211,
-0.5857899189,
0.0050159823,
-0.3924375772,
-0.8934211731,
0.3025991321,
-0.0052682683,
0.4918079376,
0.5137068033,
0.3241433203,
0.4381535649,
-0.2208019346,
0.7398382425,
-0.0730067864,
-0.8920238018,
0.3927641809,
-0.5357673168,
0.525075078,
0.5661881566,
0.2591345012,
-0.5328981876,
-0.8788632154,
-0.4133318365,
-0.8683975935,
0.3831667304,
0.3773660064,
-0.2395883054,
-0.0559223853,
0.0855301246,
0.2284819782,
0.499294579,
-0.346585393,
-0.0845083967,
0.0092281187,
-0.3903649747,
-0.0326842368,
-0.4365578294,
-0.1666472703,
-0.1739034057,
0.7943931818,
-0.0776288435,
0.2619814575,
0.5071825385,
-0.4142324626,
-0.1893151402,
0.3316162229,
1.0598599911,
1.0446314812,
-0.4368157387,
0.4777073562,
0.3690079451,
-0.3190031052,
-0.0499295294,
0.0592877381,
-0.3990431726,
0.1394049972,
0.8376577497,
0.6730577946,
0.3639319241,
-0.6862512827,
0.4155808687,
0.0317487866,
-0.3481972814,
-0.3459763825,
0.2300465554,
0.0664163455,
0.1089760959,
0.4850546718,
0.0991588235,
0.2015335709,
-0.4760807455,
0.2398823202,
0.2436883301,
-0.202076003,
-0.4324791133,
0.7036970854,
0.5141109228,
0.1334183514,
0.3514354527,
-0.243919149,
-0.4120076299,
0.5138992667,
0.4528843462,
1.0904536247,
0.1302273571,
0.1930399984,
0.0330258012,
0.4679971933,
0.0627725273,
0.3029142916,
-0.2414454371,
-0.7417013645,
-0.5970793366,
-0.2046045363,
-0.6148030162,
0.0362769589,
-0.4208819568,
0.2215442359,
-0.2538962662,
0.0312575139,
-0.0605222285,
0.2490032762,
-0.3011130691,
0.1933452189,
0.1944183111,
1.130620122,
-1.0584048033,
0.3533587456,
0.4639140368,
-0.3606603444,
-0.3407232165,
0.1261255145,
0.1777471602,
-0.5984919071,
0.0644859225,
0.1575897187,
-0.2051378638,
0.031965591,
-0.2651313841,
-0.7895992994,
1.4155220985,
0.3034697473,
-0.448869735,
-0.0232089926,
-0.0665674284,
0.3157649338,
-0.3444715738,
0.603007257,
0.3890149891,
0.3094586134,
0.180883795,
-0.9147064686,
0.0648721829,
-0.3320721388,
-0.2594673336,
0.2158660889,
-0.9639479518,
0.7294570208,
-0.4474724531,
-0.1461747289,
-0.2540873587,
0.8112912774,
-0.029549202,
0.4533702731,
0.0981193259,
0.6822872162,
0.8231424093,
0.2773990631,
0.9556361437,
-0.5288357139,
0.1201900393,
1.4250713587,
-0.3616267443,
0.7059733272,
0.1606660485,
-0.0485409684,
0.2974611819,
0.4496425986,
0.0097442297,
0.4744358063,
0.0549947359,
-0.3813985586,
-0.0387844443,
-0.2592249513,
-0.3265151978,
0.333137989,
0.0565006621,
-0.5750448704,
-0.533197403,
-0.323828578,
0.2666409016,
-0.0240460001,
-0.4420486093,
0.8369159102,
0.1750441492,
-0.5145589113,
0.4203202724,
0.0607680455,
0.5568887591,
-0.5727199912,
0.0647592843,
-0.4311339855,
-0.0621391982,
-0.3143633902,
-0.6205075383,
0.3657112122,
0.1443546265,
-0.3152576387,
-0.0947369263,
0.900975585,
-0.5414923429,
-0.5219787955,
-0.1756194383,
0.6867490411,
0.1757016033,
-0.0426509343,
-0.1918580532,
0.0721305013,
-0.0995208845,
-0.3132569492,
0.2341382056,
0.1461940855,
-0.1253756881,
0.6360247135,
0.390145421,
0.2945004404,
-0.4165047407,
0.078204453,
0.9948123693,
-0.6449272037,
-0.5540361404,
-1.1114770174,
0.4507735074,
-0.3101152778,
-0.248849377,
0.8389646411,
0.8159925938,
0.7893242836,
0.0548922978,
1.2067480087,
0.2379807234,
0.4231073558,
-0.5050042868,
0.8828222156,
-0.2315545529,
0.2292017639,
-0.3333054781,
-0.7977066636,
-0.3277424276,
0.458968848,
-0.3015556633,
0.0112098446,
0.8853904605,
0.6619510651,
0.0954989195,
0.0663634762,
0.335816592,
0.2862128019,
0.112973839,
0.469955802,
0.5749332309,
-0.2641861439,
0.3571290374,
-0.2311579287,
-0.2033743262,
-0.3766250908,
-1.0473483801,
-1.0618999004,
-0.3892861903,
-0.362652868,
-0.0180423036,
0.232454285,
1.1144672632,
0.4728434682,
-0.7503718734,
-0.1076916084,
-0.1021875143,
0.3948217034,
-0.2676047385,
-0.2133670151,
0.547865212,
-0.23241283,
-0.5269336104,
0.1435405463,
0.4948031902,
0.1327867657,
-0.3869697154,
0.1154723987,
0.0212816503,
0.285575062,
0.7117797136,
-0.0181647651,
-0.3498688936,
-0.1815807968,
-0.0626082793,
-0.1490013748,
-0.1335133612,
0.8463125825,
-0.8050542474,
0.2849619389,
0.6310840249,
0.4359244108,
0.2005625814,
0.3412831128,
0.6722348332,
-0.668861866,
-0.0508362763,
0.1997903883,
0.2911240458,
0.280126065,
-0.4509739578,
0.4303065538,
0.2946633697,
-0.420810163,
-0.5741032362,
0.0655802563,
-0.8339369297,
-0.25749138,
1.018996954,
0.0141880969,
-0.1833102256,
-0.0085045546,
-0.1592954546,
0.276597172,
-0.3959340751,
1.060510993,
0.6071729064,
-0.1943529546,
-0.2841845453,
-0.2965455949,
0.3587653041,
0.2770831287,
-0.8240152001,
0.1883529723,
0.6017898917,
0.17716299,
-0.0737359896,
0.977208674,
0.1377475858,
0.2143434286,
0.00329742,
0.0740095899,
-0.5968288183,
-0.3927465975,
-0.0762794837,
0.1351614892,
-0.0757958293,
-0.0758811459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13408v1 | Modular Domain Adaptation for Conformer-Based Streaming ASR | 2023-05-22T18:49:35 | 2023-05-22T18:49:35 | Qiujia Li, Bo Li, Dongseong Hwang, Tara N. Sainath, Pedro M. Mengibar | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Speech data from different domains has distinct acoustic and linguistic
characteristics. It is common to train a single multidomain model such as a
Conformer transducer for speech recognition on a mixture of data from all
domains. However, changing data in one domain or adding a new domain would
require the multidomain model to be retrained. To this end, we propose a
framework called modular domain adaptation (MDA) that enables a single model to
process multidomain data while keeping all parameters domain-specific, i.e.,
each parameter is only trained by data from one domain. On a streaming
Conformer transducer trained only on video caption data, experimental results
show that an MDA-based model can reach similar performance as the multidomain
model on other domains such as voice search and dictation by adding per-domain
adapters and per-domain feed-forward networks in the Conformer encoder. | [
-0.4068568945,
-0.3025260866,
0.3724378347,
-0.0458097793,
-0.4707452059,
0.038498003,
-0.077904284,
-0.119561851,
0.161978215,
0.6192891002,
-0.5944588184,
-0.1774737388,
-0.8416277766,
0.0466277674,
-0.2692897022,
0.5924654603,
0.0935685784,
0.2549575567,
-0.3398830295,
-0.4517071247,
-0.5508059859,
-0.6968878508,
-0.698356092,
-0.2334236801,
0.3361599147,
0.3628326952,
0.2110567391,
0.4821244478,
0.3670549691,
0.3004735708,
0.1365695894,
0.069286108,
-0.273542136,
0.0408004411,
-0.3530322313,
-0.2895362675,
-0.6319939494,
-0.2649666667,
1.0373977423,
0.5244662166,
-0.3790783584,
0.1961152405,
-0.1813270748,
0.8808549643,
-0.496344924,
0.3089004159,
-0.765704155,
-0.2093732804,
-0.176203236,
-0.3604569435,
-0.4363927245,
-0.2941288948,
0.4700992107,
-0.5706580877,
0.4872110188,
-0.2813230753,
0.3787434101,
0.3262642622,
-0.6095086932,
-0.0564684123,
-0.9597049356,
0.4709662199,
-0.851370275,
0.7500230074,
0.1348962039,
0.6128991246,
0.0637105256,
-0.733487606,
-0.7657120228,
0.3214584887,
0.2577978671,
0.0307520758,
-0.1763539761,
-0.1753039062,
0.0308646187,
0.1855003089,
-0.5059651136,
-0.1251629591,
-0.8291179538,
0.003640139,
0.7692592144,
-0.081890218,
0.068366766,
0.1618097574,
-0.3357815444,
-0.139420256,
-0.5901699066,
0.2073221803,
0.2120607048,
0.7099727392,
-0.1466812789,
0.2414589822,
0.0348385647,
0.7200929523,
0.4984779954,
-0.2997633815,
0.4940529764,
0.2368343323,
-0.3448627591,
0.3352701664,
0.4003603458,
-0.1755910665,
0.2974840403,
0.0466588438,
-0.2865493596,
0.038322296,
0.7525218129,
-0.6398895979,
-0.3897566795,
0.3312056661,
-0.3700485528,
0.2448686659,
0.2807068229,
-0.5392241478,
-0.2286994457,
-0.5867977738,
0.7607756853,
-0.2939465642,
-0.3905457854,
0.2128901035,
-0.2029823512,
0.3086808622,
0.2093402296,
-1.0200600624,
0.7500765324,
0.5753025413,
0.7219344974,
-0.5256361365,
-0.3727187812,
-0.6689448357,
0.3865585625,
0.2259071767,
1.1944673061,
-0.8015957475,
-0.4996374846,
-0.0627614856,
0.2525259256,
-0.7387601137,
-0.9119570851,
0.300883323,
-0.7979822755,
-0.1418879628,
0.1337272525,
-0.713891983,
-0.6071897745,
-0.3382645547,
-0.9387494326,
0.1665935814,
0.148797214,
-0.1781757921,
0.4618808329,
-0.7228860855,
-0.614716351,
-0.0946468934,
0.0115547935,
-0.6645896435,
0.2030021846,
0.2144611776,
0.3350428939,
-0.1729559749,
0.0575811416,
-0.0497692004,
-0.0881037861,
0.3889952302,
-0.2769337296,
0.3813194036,
0.0362722576,
-0.0692748427,
0.224105984,
-0.873634398,
-0.034343116,
-0.207100302,
-0.6986168027,
0.1138068065,
0.4609150887,
0.2624853253,
0.1860417724,
-0.2408581376,
-0.4554601312,
-0.0281076729,
0.0520210378,
0.3280554712,
0.7854706049,
0.0982005298,
0.5075494051,
-0.6707391143,
0.5033424497,
0.6401243806,
0.0350876451,
0.0518442169,
-0.6004491448,
-0.5508244634,
-0.5834434032,
0.3265163898,
0.2634811401,
-0.441090554,
0.337443471,
-0.5080640912,
-0.350351572,
-0.5569429994,
0.1545494199,
0.1773741394,
0.1929727197,
0.5355426073,
-0.8235747218,
-0.6175181866,
-0.6135931611,
0.0338308625,
0.1027699932,
-0.1016015708,
0.2423941642,
0.1690696776,
-0.2392361611,
0.8860340118,
-0.5566349626,
-0.6194084287,
-0.2364497185,
-0.1191062108,
0.173831135,
0.6235398054,
0.3529714942,
-1.1902941465,
-0.6838999987,
0.098521851,
-0.2734642029,
0.1053541973,
-0.1589330882,
0.3472024202,
-0.0610048361,
0.1062527448,
-0.3469178081,
0.1952300817,
0.9729571342,
-0.0873898268,
0.3340965509,
-0.0118044689,
0.0585247576,
-0.9852392077,
-0.1583639681,
0.0109718535,
-0.4538705647,
-1.1718178988,
-0.191289857,
-0.0507875606,
-0.1763035655,
-0.5103588104,
0.2341735363,
-0.3627515435,
-0.0588705018,
-0.4405064583,
0.0762988403,
-0.0366085023,
0.6769555211,
0.3958978653,
0.9226025939,
0.8783586621,
-0.9705085754,
0.2073978335,
0.6257941127,
-0.0727527067,
0.6409552097,
-0.4482587278,
0.386826247,
-0.2291733474,
0.3241562843,
-0.8718920946,
-0.034970101,
-0.0821034089,
-0.4918159544,
0.4914867282,
-0.5062949061,
0.1857874244,
-0.0668876916,
0.0466858,
0.4755126536,
0.4496900439,
-0.6081442833,
1.2172451019,
0.7763994932,
-0.4065284133,
-0.012604258,
-0.3323171139,
-0.2539942265,
-0.0591394454,
-0.5147031546,
0.2093682438,
-0.3977534175,
0.2905130684,
-0.3302749097,
-0.5893111229,
-0.7474089861,
-0.2302232385,
0.5025547743,
0.1454384774,
-0.5800716877,
-0.3877446949,
0.2340179533,
-0.0930695385,
0.1042586192,
-0.7307572365,
0.3350466192,
0.238158077,
-0.5021565557,
-0.8023455143,
0.4100010991,
0.7597948909,
-0.1518081725,
0.5683883429,
0.2672415972,
-0.3040074408,
-0.4475829899,
-0.6076036692,
-0.1358446181,
-0.5147294402,
0.0753502771,
-0.7067992687,
-0.7797459364,
0.4976884723,
-0.1032252535,
-0.1758904308,
0.3688478172,
0.5254449248,
0.0714012608,
0.6522570252,
0.5707072616,
0.0783411637,
0.5052099228,
-0.2529049516,
-0.0070652715,
-1.086866498,
-0.2536739409,
-0.477486372,
-0.263952136,
-0.2284699976,
-0.5536830425,
0.2807272971,
-0.463480562,
-0.0366700739,
0.514570415,
-0.3105526567,
0.4110469818,
0.3893425167,
0.2343853116,
0.3942450583,
0.070913583,
0.2495017648,
0.0046657086,
-0.6299846172,
-0.342988342,
1.1288386583,
0.1402911246,
0.6496824026,
0.4248104393,
0.1929434091,
0.6121058464,
0.2542728782,
-0.7110788226,
0.3205331862,
-0.6300851107,
-0.6397323012,
-0.1862048805,
-0.3318408132,
-0.5873605013,
0.3545136154,
0.0638261735,
-0.4029087126,
0.7864617705,
0.1518854946,
-0.2265393138,
0.4472574294,
-0.527545929,
0.4512166381,
0.3537435532,
0.3473915756,
-0.1799686998,
-0.4793239534,
-0.0019750588,
-0.7009452581,
0.1718863547,
-0.1413469613,
0.2552523613,
0.7038587928,
-0.1733448803,
0.8647250533,
-0.5808258057,
-0.0500407554,
0.3418464065,
-0.0777891204,
0.2971048951,
-0.1138229817,
-0.0243607089,
0.2858404815,
0.168939203,
-0.4135169089,
-0.566637814,
0.4001267254,
-1.0621761084,
-0.6914856434,
-0.2244887203,
-0.4129063785,
-0.6201499104,
-0.0091613522,
-0.1336871535,
0.7746608257,
-0.1807870418,
0.1605421156,
0.8888422251,
0.2771510482,
0.1157062352,
0.9220566154,
0.2557528615,
-0.5688541532,
1.0160002708,
-0.0177352391,
0.6365828514,
0.4451835454,
-0.023487363,
-0.1972418875,
-0.8894102573,
-0.5108483434,
0.208367452,
-0.7020298839,
-0.2511614859,
-0.6455472708,
-0.6183848381,
-0.5651090145,
-0.144453764,
-0.3732816875,
-0.5027784705,
-0.4429273307,
0.0205750447,
0.2434457093,
0.8131714463,
-0.0218855999,
0.4564946294,
-0.9324068427,
0.6754058599,
0.7594604492,
0.4271497726,
-0.0035805351,
-1.2637341022,
-0.2516437471,
0.1146111339,
-0.2340041846,
-0.4870302975,
0.3459380865,
0.8841664195,
0.5974661112,
0.4537409544,
-0.1520313323,
0.7002190948,
-1.0193767548,
0.6083595157,
0.1027675346,
-1.0418245792,
0.2124916464,
-0.2672896683,
0.3881263137,
0.401830703,
0.2964249551,
-0.4400021434,
-0.2054745108,
-0.1088336483,
-0.398224175,
0.8825728893,
-0.0534032136,
0.3027277887,
0.4918770194,
0.4920872748,
0.4255076051,
0.0727549866,
-0.3154112697,
-0.2694298923,
-0.6025010943,
-0.0477215014,
-0.0768916979,
-0.0545750596,
-0.2831374407,
-0.4010769725,
0.8016642928,
-0.4899901152,
0.3287753463,
0.236711517,
-0.3427305222,
-0.3351798952,
0.2022656947,
0.7270787358,
0.8888628483,
-0.2123342454,
-0.0726190656,
0.2292510122,
-0.8114643097,
0.4275857806,
0.0106455171,
0.0694757923,
0.0239549112,
0.1366056204,
0.9070112705,
0.1450990885,
-0.5589517951,
0.4264832437,
-0.0446831658,
-0.5465559363,
-0.4009535611,
0.3068625927,
0.1285710335,
0.3710990846,
0.7426341176,
0.4622330666,
0.118126601,
-0.3964567482,
0.4873458743,
0.0280457679,
-0.5274506211,
-0.7264557481,
0.866399169,
0.116930522,
-0.3089382946,
0.2798124552,
0.4041493237,
-0.392583698,
0.3647056222,
0.8968230486,
1.2242083549,
-0.6871051788,
0.1870030761,
0.1010356322,
-0.1010273397,
0.0667578205,
0.3273334205,
-0.0270293988,
-0.7895257473,
-0.3193014264,
-0.6492808461,
-0.5112930536,
-0.2240310758,
-0.9746630192,
0.0366868936,
-0.6043224335,
-0.090503335,
0.4885314107,
-0.3655212522,
-0.446734339,
0.4041332901,
0.3143679798,
0.9303635359,
-0.8140016198,
1.352504015,
0.8091622591,
-0.2463431954,
-0.5066120625,
-0.0119724441,
0.2080737948,
-0.5353673697,
0.4495038688,
-0.233770594,
-0.3699837029,
0.1314495951,
-0.194675386,
-0.9772363901,
1.1617933512,
0.2614518702,
-0.5835562348,
0.2294107825,
0.201447323,
0.4108843207,
-0.8864314556,
-0.5700947642,
0.5553455949,
0.2839541435,
0.3128774464,
-1.1237248182,
0.0387034453,
-0.0742882118,
0.1014005169,
-0.0568470731,
-0.6191903353,
0.7561955452,
-0.0820116103,
-0.2758722603,
-0.2897430062,
0.7987400293,
0.1142653003,
0.2477813512,
0.6668323874,
0.0069400943,
0.552303195,
0.1158745363,
0.6777746677,
0.0074033877,
0.2979855835,
1.0654832125,
-0.6206952333,
1.1245163679,
0.3851054609,
-0.2451155782,
0.739802599,
0.0625599474,
0.0161060002,
0.8214258552,
-0.0907191783,
-0.5624642968,
-0.179587245,
0.2502361238,
-0.172028929,
0.4838083982,
0.3464156687,
-0.0189352967,
0.2408520132,
0.2278820276,
-0.4013302922,
0.0775143728,
-0.3230527639,
1.1880848408,
0.0762584582,
-0.2142543346,
0.6361198425,
-0.0947517976,
0.4514940381,
-0.9308238626,
0.2920042574,
-0.0614284724,
0.3249544799,
-0.4018405974,
-0.2002293617,
0.5381682515,
-0.2049998641,
-0.699947238,
0.0823723748,
0.4647488296,
-0.411444068,
-0.2705130279,
0.2287348807,
0.4257153273,
-0.1148170382,
-0.2191747725,
-0.4413405657,
0.0124247735,
-0.0259636845,
-0.0429124422,
0.3454796672,
0.2318477482,
0.20227696,
0.7035596967,
0.9812677503,
0.1745796353,
0.37251544,
0.3684773445,
1.2695670128,
-0.5842376947,
-0.4011426568,
-0.2650213838,
0.636356473,
0.3075118363,
0.0785053223,
0.4571970701,
0.5112806559,
0.8565346599,
-0.3896996379,
0.8904824853,
0.0725181624,
0.4779202342,
-0.472830385,
0.6611770988,
-0.3828635514,
0.1055411175,
0.0254323855,
-1.0338962078,
-0.3220091164,
0.4510510862,
0.1511959136,
-0.0345836654,
0.780667007,
0.6941608191,
-0.5253408551,
0.2314076871,
0.5508960485,
0.2629041672,
0.4114058614,
0.3134977221,
0.3732465208,
-0.6083570719,
0.2346720248,
0.2329673022,
-0.028184494,
0.0436909497,
-0.3366552591,
-0.8741180897,
-1.0633692741,
-0.4946994781,
-0.1456173807,
0.0797164515,
0.7955413461,
1.0398155451,
-1.4992041588,
-0.5477127433,
0.5866142511,
-0.226460427,
-0.5659524202,
-0.1980675757,
0.1369594634,
-0.083155863,
-0.7658572793,
0.8053560257,
0.3926414251,
-0.0435633957,
-0.199669227,
-0.0475132726,
-0.3644892573,
0.5912234783,
0.4625946283,
0.2880761921,
-0.4946450591,
-0.5298071504,
-0.370696485,
0.2136230618,
0.5532169342,
1.2808918953,
-0.7246217132,
0.5689929724,
0.2096482068,
0.582336247,
0.7370196581,
0.2252480388,
0.8807693124,
-0.7692271471,
-0.0828557685,
-0.0017953424,
0.3377187848,
0.3937678635,
-0.1595305204,
0.0629165694,
0.3319178224,
-0.6387649179,
-0.526427567,
0.1075917855,
-1.3071471453,
-0.0963124782,
1.0424004793,
-0.2476764619,
-0.1180911958,
-0.596752882,
-0.083068192,
-0.0220515318,
-0.5451676846,
0.5989009142,
0.2026202232,
0.0049481085,
-0.1184694842,
-0.3617170453,
0.4198467731,
-0.1963511109,
-0.6551052928,
0.1145154536,
0.3368321657,
0.9147008061,
0.0922587067,
0.7405909896,
0.0023395957,
0.4300311506,
0.0003813452,
-0.079762809,
-0.1658985168,
-0.5514026284,
-0.8506852984,
0.2456195205,
-0.0512028225,
-0.2862014771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.16333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.16333v1 | Text Generation with Speech Synthesis for ASR Data Augmentation | 2023-05-22T18:45:20 | 2023-05-22T18:45:20 | Zhuangqun Huang, Gil Keren, Ziran Jiang, Shashank Jain, David Goss-Grubbs, Nelson Cheng, Farnaz Abtahi, Duc Le, David Zhang, Antony D'Avirro, Ethan Campbell-Taylor, Jessie Salas, Irina-Elena Veliche, Xi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | Aiming at reducing the reliance on expensive human annotations, data
synthesis for Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) has remained an active area of
research. While prior work mainly focuses on synthetic speech generation for
ASR data augmentation, its combination with text generation methods is
considerably less explored. In this work, we explore text augmentation for ASR
using large-scale pre-trained neural networks, and systematically compare those
to traditional text augmentation methods. The generated synthetic texts are
then converted to synthetic speech using a text-to-speech (TTS) system and
added to the ASR training data. In experiments conducted on three datasets, we
find that neural models achieve 9%-15% relative WER improvement and outperform
traditional methods. We conclude that text augmentation, particularly through
modern neural approaches, is a viable tool for improving the accuracy of ASR
systems. | [
-0.3476918936,
-0.5132860541,
0.2966008782,
0.0138405897,
-0.3298752606,
0.3141919374,
-0.5086526871,
-0.7079691887,
0.2010666877,
0.4386167526,
-0.4119022191,
-0.3130019605,
-0.3228312135,
0.5505030751,
-0.6849147081,
0.7623523474,
0.1299608797,
0.2360738814,
-0.0436967127,
0.1090764105,
-0.4711375833,
-0.7940930724,
-0.7874493003,
-0.5192181468,
0.3955188096,
0.1131841615,
0.442878902,
0.6666969061,
0.4241919219,
0.4113794565,
-0.1452359259,
0.3096820116,
-0.007470292,
0.1748335809,
0.089609988,
-0.1020118818,
-0.3324598968,
-0.1859690845,
0.8441130519,
0.5809328556,
0.1956035942,
-0.0026763878,
0.0746216923,
0.6695619226,
-0.4722318649,
-0.164560914,
-0.5699198246,
0.1959787756,
-0.1909981966,
-0.3211284876,
-0.3417772651,
-0.5106941462,
0.4335219562,
-0.53412503,
0.361800462,
-0.0877278596,
0.3298478425,
0.2929624319,
-0.231118679,
-0.4570693672,
-1.1173930168,
0.5904853344,
-0.8286976218,
0.432146281,
0.1459524632,
0.1982464045,
0.0428727046,
-1.0101565123,
-0.8755090237,
-0.5714900494,
-0.0512010343,
0.059384834,
-0.1162479222,
0.1527066082,
0.3565054536,
0.3886783123,
-0.505826354,
0.0927344486,
-0.5752724409,
-0.2534953058,
0.8966748118,
-0.0418613665,
0.3199360967,
-0.2004047185,
-0.2030836791,
-0.5032454729,
-0.6220990419,
-0.1923214495,
0.4778367877,
0.4573177993,
0.3398732543,
0.6940491796,
-0.0972734913,
0.9141271114,
0.0112871248,
0.1450846493,
0.2988881171,
-0.6011911035,
-0.1981938481,
0.6027510762,
0.9327623248,
0.2712298632,
0.5365315676,
-0.2150108367,
-0.3750272393,
0.2569569945,
0.3653509319,
-0.8567678332,
-0.1445835084,
-0.0935114771,
-0.2617097199,
-0.3818595111,
0.0363099836,
-0.4857545793,
-0.3425717056,
-0.6031211615,
0.5550014377,
-0.4667927027,
-0.0882148743,
0.0333660133,
-0.3474040627,
-0.0812859312,
0.1677427739,
-0.7176656127,
0.2791355252,
0.2765903473,
0.6606595516,
-0.1132785082,
-0.3186154962,
-0.4724223316,
0.0590531789,
-0.6646403074,
0.8323164582,
-0.2556428015,
-0.5127604604,
-0.0558892265,
-0.5017089248,
0.1380020082,
-0.6567644477,
0.5608594418,
-0.2932623327,
0.2402213067,
0.0987423137,
-0.4640487432,
-0.020608956,
-0.0239125695,
-0.6795713305,
0.9025785327,
-0.277205646,
-0.4764760733,
0.3365174234,
-0.9589781165,
-0.9140295982,
-0.171212092,
-0.0867336988,
-0.3656941056,
0.2090170979,
0.3892496228,
0.2188619971,
-0.5358313322,
0.2244729698,
0.4154905379,
-0.4650243819,
0.7426909804,
-0.6514284015,
0.3264342248,
0.2574866712,
-0.3947133422,
0.1789612174,
-0.9761275053,
0.1297044307,
-0.0574042387,
-0.4260169566,
-0.1446609497,
0.0176661965,
0.4770692885,
0.0047955513,
0.1141503006,
-0.6140345931,
-0.2194119394,
-0.8736242056,
0.6938524842,
0.4225470722,
-0.0553905331,
0.4822769463,
-0.347746402,
0.2023173869,
-0.1816042215,
-0.230713129,
-0.4618023038,
-0.2745790482,
-0.6447541118,
0.0515818037,
0.6840623617,
0.3709291518,
-0.9067534804,
0.7375138998,
-0.4441965818,
-0.2963994145,
-0.391113162,
-0.206085667,
0.4641106427,
0.553858459,
0.5425797105,
-0.209953621,
-0.8321886659,
-0.6727785468,
-0.4594539106,
-0.1896948516,
-0.5051888227,
-0.1101862043,
0.0816178843,
-0.2039221823,
0.9923075438,
-0.3083611429,
-0.2890633047,
-0.1456575692,
0.2708255053,
-0.1335057318,
0.7653679252,
0.1484911442,
-0.8066154718,
-0.4864092171,
0.0721609443,
-0.3768283725,
-0.0067223185,
-0.1365878433,
0.493897289,
0.3875648081,
0.8222084641,
-0.3283031881,
0.5694473386,
0.3375529647,
-0.0480443873,
0.4263951182,
-0.5183133483,
0.3394377232,
-1.2132927179,
0.2219410986,
0.0756246373,
-0.2969802618,
-1.1381003857,
-0.1455013156,
-0.0349273868,
-0.4064929485,
-0.1639636457,
0.3566492796,
-0.4697787762,
-0.2724132836,
-0.4645200968,
0.1609499902,
-0.041635029,
0.0675631613,
0.1695430428,
1.0573297739,
0.290632695,
-0.4926905632,
0.4140688181,
0.3977891207,
-0.3448747396,
0.1569510102,
-0.8202640414,
0.3502943516,
-0.1907240003,
0.447550714,
-1.0027230978,
-0.3270890415,
-0.0730851144,
-0.7390464544,
0.3075481355,
0.1380402446,
-0.5903860927,
-0.4792576432,
-0.192953229,
0.3693567216,
0.7277822495,
-0.6292427778,
0.6733965278,
0.2320776433,
-0.3488180041,
-0.2420787364,
-1.1008023024,
0.4044905901,
-0.0359318182,
-0.6015834212,
0.7343941331,
-0.0544831678,
-0.1016670838,
-0.2022185922,
0.0457683131,
-0.1506002545,
-0.2834272683,
0.0780122504,
0.0953921378,
-0.3045954108,
0.2422525287,
0.0771583691,
-0.1780735105,
-0.0789531097,
-0.4613899291,
0.6146053672,
0.2698922455,
-0.2223510891,
-0.8135955334,
0.3417729437,
0.4496551454,
-0.4243558943,
0.321331948,
0.4893039763,
-0.4656134546,
0.0574275404,
-0.5943830609,
-0.4365320802,
-0.522221446,
0.2889752388,
-0.2845503986,
-0.6549340487,
0.1791819334,
-0.0206162352,
0.0172014385,
0.3980927467,
0.1735075563,
-0.0339210145,
1.2172162533,
0.1663407236,
0.1060356125,
0.755708158,
-0.1251246035,
-0.0444122255,
-0.7325278521,
-0.0932425857,
-0.6776945591,
-0.4592813849,
-0.6005545855,
-0.3420120478,
0.2787489295,
-0.3327469826,
-0.210973978,
0.3082426488,
-0.858001411,
0.3985233903,
0.6478673816,
0.1851599813,
0.3549110591,
0.3419720531,
0.2763881385,
0.0185362436,
-0.5434626341,
-0.3878996372,
1.173822403,
0.1347890198,
0.4644048214,
-0.2901199758,
0.6841313839,
0.1917698532,
0.2827084959,
-0.7492642403,
0.4916934967,
-0.5659418702,
-0.4255327582,
-0.4860656261,
-0.5967959762,
-0.8009069562,
-0.1801775396,
-0.6362270713,
-0.4322436154,
-0.0191849228,
0.2378552109,
-0.487500757,
-0.0157576278,
-0.8002243638,
0.3007563353,
-0.0503040105,
0.091860503,
-0.0452984348,
-0.7362838387,
-0.1540367156,
-0.2838384211,
-0.1241119877,
0.5086153746,
0.1595679671,
0.8787236214,
-0.4696119428,
0.4945714474,
-0.1215724051,
0.0019621425,
0.40706864,
-0.442742914,
0.5580297112,
-0.2088018954,
-0.274477452,
0.0410971604,
-0.450084269,
0.0831367075,
-0.6340596676,
0.5445964336,
-0.609416008,
-0.351775378,
-0.2208776325,
-0.7014110684,
-0.3210588694,
0.2043879479,
0.5618963242,
0.9340454936,
-0.1223943308,
0.3063362539,
0.5009755492,
-0.3457280993,
0.6227755547,
-0.009561942,
-0.1897149384,
-0.9730473757,
0.841222167,
0.3194432557,
0.3313601315,
0.33791399,
0.1958214641,
-0.6204790473,
-0.8115634322,
-0.7059426904,
-0.1034482196,
-0.3145617247,
-0.1624642015,
-0.5856960416,
-0.5664464235,
-0.5645407438,
-0.2109599262,
-0.3602238297,
-0.7387843132,
-0.3735677004,
-0.0483967289,
0.5259508491,
0.7474780679,
0.0450139269,
0.6663283706,
-0.9132036567,
0.5084691644,
0.3834352791,
-0.0057359789,
-0.0997627601,
-0.4496499896,
-0.1174362749,
0.3982724845,
-0.1929206997,
-0.6703330278,
0.5503027439,
0.3700352013,
0.0560983196,
0.0157440864,
-0.0468044765,
0.734274447,
-0.8870634437,
0.7810179591,
0.5234169364,
-1.0453819036,
0.5870382786,
-0.2216725349,
0.4254877567,
0.4940041006,
-0.0904367194,
-0.2444864661,
-0.2699752748,
-0.5113836527,
-0.7956295013,
0.6000846624,
0.5997808576,
0.3529005945,
0.3555159569,
0.4630196691,
-0.1313033104,
0.2825807929,
-0.4456399083,
-0.2635270953,
-0.2212230116,
-0.534960866,
-0.4762166142,
0.1726685762,
0.1338747144,
-0.1930125654,
0.4694888592,
-0.0540986508,
0.2830031812,
0.3575041592,
-0.0136406738,
-0.0994502604,
0.2119958997,
0.670141995,
0.4843347371,
0.0918873847,
0.1181650683,
0.3073238134,
-0.6734527946,
0.278357327,
0.644502461,
-0.3185714185,
0.1785070896,
0.1697735041,
0.9232972264,
-0.0507018194,
-0.587443471,
0.314332664,
-0.1567749232,
-0.293556869,
-0.4104835093,
0.097438328,
0.0810644403,
0.2273313403,
0.6944397092,
0.4431104958,
0.326415211,
-0.4389795959,
0.3475882411,
0.2810094059,
-0.314274013,
-0.1780210435,
0.6659977436,
0.1528605223,
-0.8380100727,
0.4543979168,
0.2672300935,
-0.5072033405,
0.4399959445,
0.8552553058,
0.9257629514,
-0.5033281446,
0.0653535649,
0.3411350846,
0.1299775988,
-0.2796587348,
0.2416799664,
-0.0862745568,
-0.5382754207,
-0.7751120925,
-0.5850237608,
-0.4309465885,
0.1352351606,
-0.53534168,
0.2323208749,
-0.3995041847,
-0.3752686977,
0.3033696115,
-0.0909310058,
-0.2147929817,
0.7267801762,
0.0720196143,
0.6746740341,
-0.5490817428,
0.6666852832,
0.7634675503,
-0.2501764297,
-0.7806277275,
0.4568561912,
-0.5442901254,
-0.2398727387,
0.628205359,
0.3789604604,
-0.2207742333,
0.4208516479,
-0.2486650497,
-0.583925128,
0.7883302569,
0.4065684676,
-0.5499048233,
-0.1028920487,
0.4987753034,
0.8914005756,
-0.2222311348,
-0.0030624105,
0.4065227211,
0.4361613691,
0.2643586695,
-0.9857097268,
-0.1449613571,
-0.3047386706,
0.2952517867,
0.1380891204,
-0.1896265149,
0.716709733,
0.1368526667,
-0.1463603228,
0.2165273279,
0.8097986579,
0.348120749,
0.3504485786,
0.6696658134,
0.2023481727,
0.5650904179,
0.0320970938,
0.8703408837,
-0.0442834944,
-0.1857672036,
0.9555408955,
-0.1813273728,
0.8343086243,
0.4313051105,
0.056353759,
0.2962159216,
0.3049086928,
0.3550743759,
0.3791523576,
0.3971725702,
-0.5127829313,
-0.0170237161,
-0.0090584094,
-0.4205288291,
0.5416228175,
0.2495407015,
-0.6013140082,
0.1812911779,
0.3675109446,
-0.3049392998,
0.2668305337,
-0.3147371411,
1.0121278763,
-0.0626248568,
-0.6766124964,
0.6926133037,
-0.1082325056,
0.7072666883,
-0.3803560734,
0.0125233149,
0.142759636,
0.1817612797,
-0.0642023459,
-0.5370609164,
0.4007341266,
0.4117255807,
-0.2117294073,
-0.3650545478,
1.0211827755,
-0.5610076189,
-0.5894531608,
-0.0676806942,
0.2032302469,
-0.0486005582,
-0.2705668509,
-0.2242818177,
-0.0246185698,
0.1333842427,
-0.1418067813,
0.1292584836,
0.2049912959,
0.0745962039,
0.335830003,
1.0085748434,
0.4171406031,
0.0860170349,
0.0231224298,
0.9732223153,
-0.5861003399,
-0.612070024,
-0.7780612111,
0.6742323041,
-0.31335783,
-0.1131018624,
0.5489034653,
0.5419229865,
0.6165526509,
-0.1011499688,
1.0744074583,
0.1275922954,
0.756962955,
-0.6864780188,
0.9536229372,
-0.4130855203,
0.0175063964,
-0.3477472663,
-1.042350769,
-0.5990152359,
0.8321604729,
-0.2396965921,
0.0895976722,
0.4187689424,
0.7956508994,
0.0322542042,
0.4223822057,
0.2717902958,
-0.0091129635,
0.2486435175,
0.0216679387,
1.0455341339,
-0.7400075197,
0.6638478041,
-0.1155803725,
-0.0315400735,
0.0308092665,
-0.6929491162,
-0.7596020103,
-0.7455359101,
-0.2234319746,
-0.2476926446,
0.2363170832,
1.1350991726,
0.6089177728,
-0.8128886819,
-0.2261993736,
-0.5588123202,
-0.4692464173,
0.0740771145,
-0.1097810492,
0.3127322793,
-0.2701829374,
-0.9573436975,
0.8312289119,
-0.0605157167,
0.3701753616,
-0.0270080417,
-0.0452752709,
0.0738403499,
0.1881525815,
0.5791675448,
0.1365878731,
-0.3166634142,
-0.2773990035,
0.1055690646,
0.0302983131,
0.1276509911,
0.8658980131,
-0.9135790467,
0.5489796996,
0.5625639558,
0.892087698,
0.6935536265,
0.2140247375,
0.8006581068,
-1.0064427853,
0.1205231845,
0.390799433,
-0.0282846875,
0.5824279189,
-0.1677799076,
0.2245087177,
-0.1197739094,
-0.5602564216,
-0.9769559503,
0.1196238399,
-0.6516659856,
-0.0229125246,
1.0766401291,
0.1805270761,
0.0013520173,
0.0530493893,
-0.5075724721,
0.5874266624,
-0.3401984572,
0.6128976345,
0.1567352563,
-0.1053877026,
0.1977867037,
-0.1367416531,
0.7396641374,
0.209704712,
-0.9863245487,
0.0926031619,
0.8004065752,
-0.1094095707,
0.6120918989,
0.5006112456,
0.0766997263,
0.2528481781,
-0.0232896265,
0.1170099899,
-0.1970570385,
-0.3902157545,
-0.4530744851,
0.0243902542,
-0.1282407641,
-0.219118461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13406v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13406v3 | DADA: Dialect Adaptation via Dynamic Aggregation of Linguistic Rules | 2023-05-22T18:43:31 | 2023-12-06T00:19:24 | Yanchen Liu, William Held, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing large language models (LLMs) that mainly focus on Standard American
English (SAE) often lead to significantly worse performance when being applied
to other English dialects. While existing mitigations tackle discrepancies for
individual target dialects, they assume access to high-accuracy dialect
identification systems. The boundaries between dialects are inherently
flexible, making it difficult to categorize language into discrete predefined
categories. In this paper, we propose DADA (Dialect Adaptation via Dynamic
Aggregation), a modular approach to imbue SAE-trained models with
multi-dialectal robustness by composing adapters which handle specific
linguistic features. The compositional architecture of DADA allows for both
targeted adaptation to specific dialect variants and simultaneous adaptation to
various dialects. We show that DADA is effective for both single task and
instruction finetuned language models, offering an extensible and interpretable
framework for adapting existing LLMs to different English dialects. | [
-0.2897975445,
-0.839954555,
0.4286828339,
0.2393305749,
-0.5472555757,
0.0176427308,
-0.4116175175,
-0.2365170866,
0.4359760284,
0.4770834148,
-0.4178331792,
-0.1238466948,
-0.5843673348,
0.0876920223,
-0.0066051679,
0.5335063338,
0.4254797995,
0.0159532446,
-0.090364337,
-0.3992200494,
-0.9307004213,
-0.3606698811,
-0.7586512566,
-0.1807473898,
0.1858763844,
0.3608391583,
0.5443831086,
0.3610605299,
0.2126843631,
0.4744624197,
-0.1582094729,
0.3287951946,
-0.3029456139,
0.3204001486,
-0.5424151421,
-0.977379024,
-0.8801794052,
-0.3252314925,
0.5345491171,
0.4861725271,
-0.4299753606,
-0.0384168774,
-0.0750334784,
0.5131385922,
-0.6443839073,
0.4321748614,
-1.0891538858,
-0.2600084245,
-0.0477484353,
0.0400998853,
-0.3658539355,
-0.0853744,
0.0252883304,
-0.4603265524,
-0.2601038814,
-0.2399741262,
0.4863598347,
0.0657590777,
-0.6447097063,
-0.372982502,
-0.6244754791,
0.6739211082,
-0.8781786561,
0.2671765685,
-0.05581991,
0.4183855355,
-0.2060253024,
-0.3768830001,
-0.6399434805,
-0.0449061319,
0.067821905,
0.223974064,
0.0508235916,
-0.0962808952,
-0.437838465,
0.2498491406,
-0.0447243564,
0.3403619528,
-0.2334989756,
0.3553352654,
0.6158436537,
0.1620786339,
0.3715759814,
-0.1521279812,
-0.3341552913,
0.012301988,
-0.4974981844,
0.044302173,
0.1329889446,
0.781478703,
-0.4659255743,
-0.0039672377,
0.0998519659,
0.6201413274,
0.4207567573,
-0.386626929,
0.0834486187,
-0.1094139144,
-0.083021462,
-0.2188800722,
0.4712767303,
0.1365468055,
0.2573774457,
-0.0805508345,
-0.2940346897,
-0.2459812313,
0.3469496071,
-0.4956878424,
0.132911101,
0.100448899,
-0.2992990315,
-0.1844777018,
0.0966249108,
-1.0220811367,
-0.2498371899,
-0.3953622282,
0.6227311492,
-0.5075099468,
-0.2841304243,
0.1052295491,
-0.052920863,
0.1748400927,
0.3237837553,
-1.2364656925,
0.4662808478,
0.7788025141,
0.7318210602,
-0.2249539047,
-0.6016389728,
-0.4182134867,
0.3599287271,
-0.2696489692,
0.7284212112,
-0.6703407168,
-0.1841283739,
-0.0608449019,
0.2474470139,
-0.5390263796,
-0.7465357184,
0.2313070744,
-0.6038446426,
0.1959889233,
0.2781091034,
-0.3310125172,
-0.481759578,
0.1200524345,
-0.5656904578,
0.6922984719,
0.3009867072,
-0.0536410324,
0.1656527221,
-0.4103528559,
-0.65334481,
-0.1554385126,
0.0589310676,
-0.1880562305,
0.5442586541,
0.2615252733,
0.5922005773,
-0.3575221598,
0.5032679439,
-0.2872297168,
-0.2458748519,
0.1589332521,
-0.4064844549,
1.0741506815,
0.1875359714,
-0.1077458635,
0.1697589904,
-0.9382785559,
-0.2597298324,
0.0461939164,
-0.3895932734,
-0.4823566377,
0.3471567631,
-0.2943692803,
-0.0145666506,
0.0781029686,
0.0794248059,
0.1227902249,
-0.2779255807,
0.3367847502,
0.9488617182,
-0.0296117589,
0.3529018164,
-0.4821688533,
0.6680541635,
0.1188243777,
-0.1181031391,
-0.1930797249,
-0.1007566527,
-0.7947108746,
-0.7393750548,
0.2890851498,
0.8908237219,
-0.5594579577,
1.0378153324,
-0.4613654315,
-0.4994670749,
-0.0983077288,
0.1433861405,
-0.0627176613,
0.2668060064,
0.2061509341,
-0.8697645068,
-0.4010421634,
-0.7393030524,
0.0858606398,
-0.3177415133,
-0.1369494051,
0.1802245229,
0.1306102127,
0.0551666021,
0.5741733313,
-0.2727576494,
-0.2008616328,
-0.4579284787,
-0.1485162228,
0.261195302,
0.2102428079,
1.0235378742,
-0.3841212988,
-0.5485700965,
0.0604357161,
-0.5122058392,
-0.4537580013,
-0.2826937139,
-0.1527625471,
-0.1123735979,
0.3712131083,
-0.4013765454,
-0.3132711947,
0.713712275,
-0.2758216262,
0.5353110433,
-0.0184923112,
0.0758316591,
-1.689869523,
-0.507240057,
-0.3225382566,
-0.3367582858,
-0.6109207273,
0.5504289269,
-0.0696387142,
-0.1050922424,
-0.3070868552,
0.47469455,
-0.4652585983,
0.2410631478,
-0.2408687025,
0.1718097925,
-0.0057945428,
0.4005617797,
-0.2566078305,
0.906727016,
0.8444392681,
-0.6230987906,
0.4507897794,
0.2201264799,
-0.2117252797,
0.9365642071,
-0.122297436,
0.1081815884,
-0.2240838856,
0.2633221745,
-0.7388335466,
-0.2465933859,
-0.1395072937,
0.0548158363,
0.5071388483,
-0.1739960611,
0.251663208,
0.1923453212,
-0.4000664055,
0.168173328,
0.5521893501,
-0.601975739,
1.2738782167,
0.5448569655,
-0.6051145792,
-0.2700917423,
-0.4262444377,
0.2553578615,
-0.4004884064,
-0.5968452692,
0.1377830654,
0.1124683097,
-0.5029379725,
-0.0348642394,
0.015356184,
-0.3585034907,
0.3710058928,
-0.0971202403,
-0.0400820635,
-0.7128687501,
0.0326455273,
0.1149785817,
0.1903930455,
-0.1855092347,
-0.1127519384,
0.5351311564,
0.0304421894,
-0.1847595274,
-0.3826142848,
0.5804524422,
1.0334042311,
-0.3036678433,
0.858322084,
0.2625865042,
-0.2472474724,
-0.8260993958,
-0.4008069634,
-0.2547873259,
-0.5215357542,
0.5185493827,
-0.754594028,
-0.6568401456,
0.7806070447,
-0.2503365278,
-0.1682425439,
0.3205028176,
0.6476828456,
-0.0822622627,
0.3401693702,
0.6480330825,
-0.1931527108,
0.7568854094,
0.2192703784,
0.2773236334,
-0.5629718304,
0.102444604,
-0.5079359412,
-0.2258150578,
-0.5710837245,
-0.593509078,
0.4031572044,
0.145608604,
0.0993032008,
0.3527753055,
0.1355571449,
0.5489610434,
0.5673125386,
0.0981261507,
0.1512808651,
-0.0311658978,
0.0999988839,
0.1820839047,
-0.8163512945,
-0.4168985784,
0.7138043642,
0.0947744399,
0.7163057923,
0.7110846639,
0.3920190334,
0.2930723727,
0.070756197,
-0.9166110158,
0.8030737042,
-0.9494398832,
-0.4575235248,
-0.0206710882,
-0.1650334597,
-0.6534267664,
0.4918123186,
-0.4369341433,
-0.6157228947,
0.4000947773,
0.1162059009,
-0.2583960593,
0.3954368532,
-0.9106683731,
0.513695538,
-0.1925128847,
-0.2931298316,
-0.4594252408,
-0.4062265158,
0.3799675107,
-0.5216944814,
0.3571569622,
-0.2454803586,
0.0359266363,
0.2622998953,
-0.3220428228,
1.1047912836,
-0.0609323047,
-0.0263748448,
0.2675278187,
0.1324887872,
0.5670912862,
-0.1062673181,
-0.4342207909,
0.1703766733,
0.1469035149,
-0.5825251937,
-0.6467400789,
0.5671136975,
-0.6710819006,
-0.8089158535,
-0.2273361087,
-0.7281427979,
-0.5519833565,
0.1352990866,
-0.391777277,
0.5077010393,
-0.2643779218,
0.2832633257,
0.2500431538,
0.0096142571,
0.4120658636,
0.7011299133,
0.1630906612,
-0.5007211566,
0.663171947,
0.1337246895,
0.4684905112,
0.3967116773,
0.2450787425,
-0.0338675752,
-0.9559785724,
-0.5868166685,
0.1525345594,
-0.6634996533,
0.0328211635,
-0.1265750974,
-0.0466586538,
-0.5032832026,
-0.4137978852,
-0.3748128712,
-0.5577114224,
-0.2903172672,
0.0029597306,
0.1079122201,
0.6540429592,
0.1807194948,
0.5083096623,
-0.8658339977,
0.1625773609,
0.6819688678,
0.3111240864,
-0.1860044748,
-0.8103266358,
-0.1088728011,
-0.3942931294,
-0.014931757,
-0.9848892689,
0.0026505275,
0.7524881363,
0.5906708241,
0.3201068044,
0.0291746408,
0.758974731,
-0.7076307535,
0.9236240387,
-0.0438341424,
-0.9899875522,
0.1244196892,
-0.4369103312,
0.294074297,
0.5934565663,
0.0176247358,
-0.3130732477,
-0.3876516521,
-0.0850225389,
-0.8525274992,
0.6162158847,
-0.520080924,
0.8176736236,
0.0685774162,
0.4169456661,
0.310126245,
0.0858740211,
-0.5198281407,
0.2253788561,
-0.1144010574,
-0.6950011849,
0.0323561952,
-0.4359998405,
-0.2637897432,
-0.0707966834,
0.9194597602,
-0.494120717,
0.0748929456,
-0.3573780954,
-0.2796864212,
0.1470391005,
0.5011307001,
0.4282399416,
0.74834162,
-0.1598760039,
0.3271480501,
0.4445229471,
-0.3340810537,
0.4445200562,
0.0812305361,
-0.2877072394,
-0.2930593789,
0.7515765429,
0.9918717742,
0.0919641405,
-0.6491010189,
0.2870708406,
0.169976145,
0.0511391647,
-0.1294525564,
0.5619917512,
0.3357486129,
0.3722907901,
0.1281367242,
0.1069680601,
-0.2900333107,
-0.8416975141,
0.3526844382,
0.4178890288,
-0.0984071419,
-0.6248267293,
0.5114468336,
0.5369524956,
-0.4567159712,
-0.0337388068,
-0.0271934271,
-0.3543184102,
0.6512632966,
0.8449272513,
1.0033118725,
-0.6446576118,
-0.1055817977,
0.1748908609,
0.3225542307,
0.2217474431,
0.2171612233,
0.3863659799,
-0.9425352216,
-0.3198965192,
-0.6733294725,
-0.4129153192,
0.0255640484,
-0.6048954725,
0.3795260787,
-0.5916545987,
0.1426989883,
-0.0641921014,
-0.4965738058,
-0.2400908023,
0.2093738168,
0.0532727204,
0.9792063832,
-1.1448216438,
0.9095218182,
0.9588922858,
0.0205225348,
-0.6901962161,
0.37521106,
0.2602410614,
-0.6703935266,
-0.1156858429,
-0.2685376108,
-0.4733941853,
-0.0555931441,
-0.037794549,
-0.6268828511,
0.9315723181,
0.6731287837,
-0.316878438,
0.3773137331,
-0.1319259107,
0.4688689113,
-0.621663332,
0.0427196734,
0.605260253,
0.1879077554,
-0.0825012103,
-0.8328660727,
-0.0007470875,
-0.0637214109,
-0.1364646107,
-0.0200915392,
-1.2715351582,
0.8614752889,
0.1797797829,
0.1304694712,
-0.0952244624,
0.5325499177,
-0.1001489758,
0.0530472659,
0.8663292527,
0.3879854679,
0.7830682993,
-0.0333791301,
0.6044864058,
-0.3645986617,
0.0745959431,
1.3057768345,
-0.4467321336,
1.035811305,
0.2702390254,
-0.4859431982,
0.7609426379,
0.2186715007,
0.3225264549,
0.5684403181,
-0.2364417017,
-0.6208723187,
-0.2645166218,
0.0491618365,
-0.0289580896,
1.0291604996,
0.471616596,
-0.053387139,
-0.0966176167,
-0.1709101796,
0.193940267,
0.4137761891,
-0.217729792,
0.9162790179,
-0.1043417975,
-0.7206881046,
0.7282280326,
0.1622974426,
0.723629415,
-0.9222233891,
0.2720637321,
-0.5447403193,
0.1720261276,
0.0124798436,
-0.0751164407,
0.4127581418,
-0.256360054,
-0.2664633393,
0.1698475033,
0.6467453241,
-0.5558120012,
-0.6181079745,
0.2999365628,
0.6789291501,
-0.1909052283,
0.4363868833,
-0.465105325,
0.0057311929,
0.00709813,
-0.1861867607,
0.3713428378,
0.5448026657,
-0.2131992429,
0.5579465032,
0.3545643091,
0.3063871264,
0.3131023347,
-0.0830281749,
0.7289262414,
-0.6181520224,
-0.634031415,
-0.5915218592,
0.4886352122,
0.122185871,
-0.0834286511,
0.4735295475,
0.1641263366,
0.6226368546,
-0.3164500594,
0.7831922174,
-0.2231736034,
0.3590843678,
-0.8291402459,
0.4444327652,
-0.803308785,
0.4901762605,
0.1626704335,
-0.9067299962,
-0.362993598,
0.4523373246,
0.0992237926,
0.0060669784,
0.7820397615,
0.9704679847,
-0.6906531453,
-0.0576067939,
0.3091031313,
0.6166670322,
0.3320780694,
0.2444096506,
0.4027593434,
0.0719041005,
0.0128360391,
-0.141800791,
-0.3063537776,
-0.2101791501,
-1.0415862799,
-0.6952425241,
-0.414489001,
-0.1484619826,
-0.0197713301,
0.3097711802,
1.1375305653,
1.047814846,
-1.2999582291,
-0.4864569902,
0.3351766169,
0.0984457508,
-0.6489329934,
-0.2147010416,
0.2979856133,
-0.5360931754,
-1.1411608458,
1.1461535692,
0.2822873592,
-0.0953893811,
-0.1579311043,
0.1733416617,
-0.2801856697,
0.7448198795,
0.7544609308,
-0.1214895844,
-0.5629360676,
-0.5797642469,
-0.5719742179,
0.1772328764,
0.179369092,
0.7562412024,
-0.4893542528,
0.6118837595,
0.5833499432,
0.8423681259,
0.0573012009,
0.1604912728,
0.6895760894,
-0.843912065,
0.6189880371,
-0.0415425338,
0.3857342899,
0.2104397863,
-0.1372615695,
0.4479775727,
0.4222352803,
-0.22145693,
-0.6937077045,
0.3049143851,
-1.094422102,
-0.5012835264,
0.9811750054,
-0.3332315683,
-0.2031291723,
-0.2351750284,
-0.1102036163,
-0.0653107464,
-0.1659145504,
0.9527403116,
0.8651936054,
-0.0674456432,
-0.1177689657,
-0.553468883,
-0.0690166429,
0.6228708625,
-0.8979893327,
-0.0072651613,
0.6299821138,
0.4662341177,
-0.1215666384,
0.5168505311,
0.159526512,
0.0096082464,
0.0524354838,
-0.137954101,
-0.0802095085,
-0.3614081144,
-0.6850379705,
0.4894196391,
0.3933511972,
-0.1885376126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13403v1 | GATology for Linguistics: What Syntactic Dependencies It Knows | 2023-05-22T18:34:12 | 2023-05-22T18:34:12 | Yuqian Dai, Serge Sharoff, Marc de Kamps | cs.CL | cs.CL | Graph Attention Network (GAT) is a graph neural network which is one of the
strategies for modeling and representing explicit syntactic knowledge and can
work with pre-trained models, such as BERT, in downstream tasks. Currently,
there is still a lack of investigation into how GAT learns syntactic knowledge
from the perspective of model structure. As one of the strategies for modeling
explicit syntactic knowledge, GAT and BERT have never been applied and
discussed in Machine Translation (MT) scenarios. We design a dependency
relation prediction task to study how GAT learns syntactic knowledge of three
languages as a function of the number of attention heads and layers. We also
use a paired t-test and F1-score to clarify the differences in syntactic
dependency prediction between GAT and BERT fine-tuned by the MT task (MT-B).
The experiments show that better performance can be achieved by appropriately
increasing the number of attention heads with two GAT layers. With more than
two layers, learning suffers. Moreover, GAT is more competitive in training
speed and syntactic dependency prediction than MT-B, which may reveal a better
incorporation of modeling explicit syntactic knowledge and the possibility of
combining GAT and BERT in the MT tasks. | [
-0.3657155037,
-0.7986481786,
0.8194128871,
0.1315218657,
-0.0624532402,
0.0025392557,
-0.1859014779,
-0.8312580585,
0.3792962134,
0.422457397,
-0.5359060764,
-0.3605593443,
-0.6376178861,
-0.0280610099,
-0.1507443339,
1.2769627571,
0.1712530106,
0.2202235162,
-0.0758514404,
-0.0651214123,
-0.629257679,
-0.6456378102,
-0.4992635846,
-0.3085086942,
0.7487844825,
0.1208186969,
0.7697592974,
0.6008093357,
0.5377039909,
0.2679851949,
-0.2667171359,
-0.1678779125,
-0.2879245579,
0.2343825698,
-0.1800736189,
-0.5601432323,
-0.2469691038,
-0.0464126877,
0.4486098886,
0.7612375617,
-0.0084672431,
0.0818152428,
0.1368187517,
0.7180313468,
-0.237849474,
0.7528178692,
-0.4904806912,
0.084457688,
-0.3033618033,
-0.0501391254,
-0.4024950266,
-0.0670975819,
0.7588885427,
-0.3928743601,
0.3858165443,
-0.0173540432,
0.9734044075,
0.1799988598,
-0.3847868741,
-0.1353754699,
-0.5651310086,
0.4535812736,
-0.4963880479,
0.4123080373,
0.5719219446,
0.3589302599,
0.0968746543,
-0.7486616969,
-0.1867537946,
-0.3500131071,
-0.4037466347,
0.2071096152,
0.0363137461,
0.2092257887,
0.1799983084,
0.4296361506,
-0.6745726466,
-0.320805788,
-0.4231905043,
-0.0356315859,
0.1179305539,
-0.0009661866,
0.6324866414,
-0.2163528353,
-0.4064930379,
0.2489713132,
-0.54311198,
-0.1760030389,
0.1472509205,
0.517642796,
-0.0312208775,
0.163980484,
-0.0174399316,
0.7013521194,
0.1948293597,
0.0921415463,
0.3088636398,
-0.2358073294,
-0.2437916398,
-0.2059249282,
0.6746943593,
-0.250601083,
0.3386206627,
-0.5556031466,
0.0965774134,
0.0437725931,
0.4731719792,
-0.4795516431,
-0.3803283274,
-0.1048983708,
-0.0279576294,
-0.1036835238,
-0.2633312941,
-0.4931636751,
-0.0433177873,
-0.3377794921,
0.4934768677,
-0.6794261336,
-0.0953397602,
-0.1529915333,
0.1662601978,
-0.140302524,
0.2329286486,
-1.2552870512,
0.3930645883,
0.3884443641,
0.8870549202,
0.2030566186,
-0.5997578502,
-0.4575659037,
0.3482997417,
0.0603886917,
0.6775465608,
-0.3355216384,
0.2764558196,
-0.1098775566,
-0.0128576756,
-0.3644763827,
-0.020891346,
0.1642083973,
-0.6014919281,
0.2521240711,
-0.4418243468,
-0.3678897321,
-0.9600840211,
0.1609722078,
-0.7517232895,
0.8398374915,
0.5178156495,
-0.9750951529,
0.3765854239,
-0.3611133695,
-0.9173948169,
0.4151424468,
-0.1449704617,
-0.1034320667,
-0.1582139432,
0.1283259094,
0.3987669647,
-0.1016882285,
0.1798329204,
-0.2255153656,
-0.0809882879,
-0.4044956863,
0.3550763726,
0.8569529653,
-0.1632377058,
-0.4334748387,
0.1165115163,
-0.5794736743,
0.1250485182,
0.0112651773,
-0.2247385085,
-0.1629551351,
0.0329289213,
-0.1660872549,
0.4780556858,
0.0393568054,
-0.364770323,
0.0776109099,
-0.6346421242,
0.6400511861,
0.538913846,
0.0194560457,
0.3687230051,
-0.0207277648,
0.6911302209,
-0.1100865081,
-0.2549029887,
0.1775108576,
-0.7113530636,
-0.7327747345,
0.379945457,
0.4183085561,
0.5282530785,
-0.7835069299,
-0.0822964534,
-0.0984052345,
-0.2682738304,
-0.3061261475,
0.1815962195,
0.6151643991,
0.4252662063,
0.4039171636,
-0.364113301,
-0.609189868,
-0.8548621535,
-0.0929556489,
-0.3278976977,
0.3706735075,
0.278609544,
0.3793120384,
0.201385051,
0.5544105172,
-0.3315164745,
-0.7410633564,
-0.5223299265,
0.0432089902,
0.0978130251,
0.0914334506,
0.8391284943,
-0.432485044,
-0.8349485397,
0.4699882567,
-0.6585529447,
0.1452222764,
0.409776777,
-0.0409152806,
0.2576345205,
0.0466510765,
-0.7298588753,
0.1550173759,
0.7762188315,
-0.0783141255,
0.5586796999,
-0.2102443427,
-0.3084460497,
-0.8397841454,
0.0314104855,
-0.0824274346,
-0.2431298792,
-0.9248657227,
0.2999999225,
0.0557725467,
-0.1101800278,
-0.3611741662,
0.3779242933,
-0.5684767962,
-0.1919985861,
0.0304967184,
0.0283605587,
-0.0639380962,
0.9430065155,
0.060796041,
0.8540344238,
0.6258534789,
-0.4645554125,
0.0739238486,
0.4658649266,
-0.2597249746,
-0.0188942607,
-0.6022410393,
0.5717174411,
0.2677797377,
0.0128242141,
-0.9056019783,
-0.340352267,
0.3579437435,
-0.5482017398,
0.4504822791,
-0.5075782537,
-0.6552190185,
-0.1693595201,
0.386490494,
0.3087387979,
0.2692425549,
-0.2032342851,
0.6128900051,
0.4951094985,
-0.4479198158,
-0.5475606322,
-0.9040821791,
0.0319020338,
0.0738213658,
-0.9184077978,
-0.0422114953,
0.4095439911,
-0.0204578117,
0.1161815897,
-0.1175334752,
-0.0767936781,
0.0433537588,
0.0811735839,
-0.0567029491,
-0.2502035499,
0.3980243802,
-0.4088307321,
-0.1996341348,
0.0660508126,
-0.7908957601,
0.6723384857,
-0.2943886817,
0.0196777713,
0.0497672446,
0.2620449364,
0.3828965724,
-0.4789991379,
0.6650090814,
0.6070813537,
-0.1447845846,
-0.2100656182,
-0.3611479402,
0.0716789961,
-0.3550088108,
0.5349978805,
-0.4274663031,
-0.739056766,
0.6933088303,
0.5759609938,
-0.2951538861,
0.4223411083,
0.8182119131,
-0.0058304798,
1.0618169308,
0.636351943,
-0.1798503548,
0.611774981,
-0.2337762713,
0.0618958175,
-0.6021149755,
0.0523589402,
-0.3329311907,
-0.2521821856,
-0.4322681427,
0.012309676,
0.3643868864,
-0.3126971722,
0.0277519263,
0.6446442604,
-0.2685646713,
0.3290032744,
0.711614728,
0.2364788353,
0.0050632111,
-0.0135069191,
-0.3246375918,
0.1063684672,
-0.5781629086,
-0.0361930467,
0.9349891543,
0.0699061379,
0.3813358247,
0.1566061378,
0.3841973543,
-0.1179592162,
-0.1892199963,
-0.8805074096,
0.4101438224,
-0.3772358596,
-0.7411801815,
-0.1722191423,
-0.349789083,
-0.8398793936,
0.1407688558,
0.3326637447,
-0.8905448318,
-0.1095877513,
0.1288973242,
-0.2531183064,
-0.0025428254,
-0.921397984,
0.8289600015,
-0.265414238,
-0.3673933148,
-0.172893092,
-1.1687961817,
0.0070028831,
0.18711178,
-0.0361479782,
0.0034784016,
0.4146545231,
0.620890379,
-0.2466860563,
0.9574831128,
-0.111927852,
-0.0176488012,
0.1042117774,
0.3078610003,
0.5120283961,
-0.1004636809,
-0.0045072678,
0.0206278395,
-0.2027579993,
-0.3290103078,
-0.5910759568,
0.3661360145,
-0.6595311165,
-0.7972207069,
-0.3083081245,
-1.0556602478,
-0.6428655982,
0.654974401,
0.2606134415,
0.3429938555,
0.0896789804,
-0.111740455,
0.2340047956,
0.3119616807,
0.0350393429,
0.2048932761,
-0.3802904785,
-0.3746226728,
0.7866829038,
0.4404358268,
0.6455922723,
0.4354370236,
0.1011947915,
-0.1428412497,
-0.6718402505,
-0.436578244,
0.2772270441,
-0.8274329901,
-0.0232840516,
-0.8312280178,
-0.503921628,
-0.4468488395,
0.2051500678,
0.1449030638,
-0.5663903356,
0.0424376465,
-0.2593617737,
0.4604473412,
0.9833939075,
0.2690663338,
0.3715915382,
-0.7290183902,
-0.0609159693,
0.2717734575,
0.3535142243,
0.0518606603,
-0.2689830661,
-0.7572345138,
-0.1088575348,
-0.4788087904,
-0.8603266478,
0.4846088886,
0.3190069795,
0.4966625273,
0.2790374756,
-0.4037028551,
0.437748909,
-0.6113446355,
0.5082945228,
-0.0208687931,
-0.8353589177,
0.5271318555,
-0.7341786623,
0.2762871981,
0.429333657,
0.1800138354,
-0.5333024263,
-0.8657396436,
-0.8652135134,
-0.5946893096,
0.9877963662,
0.2007873058,
-0.2069185227,
-0.0818185806,
-0.0019386188,
0.2702329457,
0.1493350863,
-0.6369952559,
-0.0874558315,
0.0289412513,
0.0453895293,
-0.3099212646,
-0.1683514118,
0.0110129481,
-0.2368459553,
0.5515268445,
-0.0377009958,
0.2672155499,
-0.1118255258,
-0.4021278918,
-0.1982308179,
0.0535578839,
0.3974177241,
0.6329277754,
-0.4261671603,
0.2408219576,
0.0546733327,
-0.6970462799,
0.0575007722,
0.0217559338,
-0.3283440173,
0.0772379115,
0.397462368,
1.0490521193,
0.2675487697,
0.0525721759,
0.1987823993,
0.5103321075,
-0.3601174057,
-0.0300900266,
-0.0830807537,
0.4893148541,
0.1729145348,
-0.0845445767,
0.2832606137,
0.2283088416,
-0.5351455808,
0.3105549514,
0.1598560065,
-0.6451384425,
-0.6425546408,
0.5842269063,
0.0480869934,
-0.125557214,
0.4733682871,
-0.1293592006,
-1.0852251053,
0.663774848,
0.7347377539,
0.9169207215,
-0.2426259667,
0.2463605255,
0.2752770483,
0.1282427311,
0.0616945215,
0.3603899479,
0.1399825364,
-0.5249244571,
-0.5129288435,
-0.4333817661,
-0.2765410542,
-0.0231462698,
-0.6428644061,
0.3045429885,
-0.6301987767,
-0.2050022036,
0.3138895929,
0.1617160589,
-0.7389685512,
0.2105160952,
-0.0928781033,
0.3147009611,
-0.644577682,
1.0418689251,
0.9628940225,
-0.8738408089,
-1.1857856512,
0.1304385364,
0.2025744915,
-1.0857473612,
0.9556347132,
0.3177129626,
-0.0803123564,
0.3212797344,
-0.0715756714,
-0.9616107941,
0.873701632,
0.5741645694,
-0.3149833679,
-0.4510494471,
-0.0426948778,
0.7419289351,
-0.2440513521,
0.1837886125,
0.4939747155,
0.3742886484,
-0.0370721482,
-1.1030455828,
0.0727040842,
-0.2833094895,
0.0122827813,
0.589836359,
-0.6589221954,
1.0199044943,
-0.40326038,
-0.5316817164,
-0.0318270214,
0.2880534232,
-0.372351408,
-0.1599723697,
0.3116599023,
0.6304897666,
0.5033063293,
-0.0867788121,
1.1301032305,
-0.355560571,
0.6241964698,
1.1632398367,
-0.1621761322,
0.4757566452,
0.4038531482,
-0.450592339,
0.5253779888,
0.6899946332,
-0.1357944608,
0.5531141162,
0.0660495609,
0.0110210227,
-0.0713805407,
-0.0740774572,
-0.5923498869,
0.3041526377,
0.2872086763,
-0.578509748,
-0.3226714432,
-0.003645018,
-0.0403377078,
-0.2632274032,
0.0239349566,
0.9902603626,
0.1149145514,
-0.5952951312,
0.5357641578,
-0.5090023279,
-0.1165722609,
-0.6165249348,
0.0721357465,
-0.0724223554,
0.2996201217,
-0.2211203575,
-0.9292128086,
0.2807889283,
-0.4886606634,
-0.3958879709,
0.0578688718,
0.7352412343,
-0.629090488,
-0.3694963157,
0.7627754807,
0.6427819133,
0.1466555297,
-0.1052136645,
-0.4122762084,
-0.465305537,
0.0627851039,
-0.2051892579,
0.6112349629,
0.6828957796,
0.0333834551,
0.7651355863,
0.4203059673,
0.4304478168,
-0.0331484452,
0.345107168,
0.6670073271,
-0.371189326,
-0.8242325783,
-0.7451218963,
0.1266394407,
0.3605311811,
-0.1668293178,
0.7151712179,
0.1698123068,
0.776674509,
-0.2237919122,
0.9646679163,
-0.3187443614,
0.48652637,
-0.5223505497,
0.6949844956,
-0.5248699784,
0.0432011113,
-0.3142451346,
-0.9032453895,
-0.436186552,
0.3251986802,
-0.5968280435,
0.0872777849,
1.2672703266,
0.4956660569,
0.0147746876,
0.2508095205,
0.3644382656,
0.2517828941,
0.0921530426,
0.8991774917,
0.6277821064,
-0.1342632771,
0.7174196243,
-0.4985816181,
0.0944611207,
-0.070467025,
-0.483899653,
-0.8556708694,
-0.6774574518,
0.0736334771,
-0.3920957148,
0.371807307,
0.599214375,
0.6418074965,
-0.9134994149,
-0.0805106685,
-0.2392457426,
-0.0612227805,
-0.5151417255,
-0.2286746353,
0.6640646458,
-0.8319738507,
-0.5315328836,
0.1195356324,
0.3876135051,
-0.056864772,
-0.0168759208,
0.1107041016,
-0.5368917584,
-0.686778307,
0.4885625243,
0.1854009181,
-0.8575331569,
-0.6982610822,
0.0423173197,
-0.1582853794,
0.3426042795,
0.7532757521,
-0.5883393288,
0.4780699313,
0.6157030463,
0.6846078634,
0.4995654523,
-0.1747739911,
0.9000948668,
-0.8268016577,
0.143774122,
0.2327700853,
0.4183035195,
0.0444917604,
-0.6231110692,
0.8786431551,
0.3559347689,
-0.6421275139,
-0.3511715829,
0.4033763409,
-1.0981724262,
0.1490740925,
1.210344553,
-0.5346614718,
-0.0342688635,
-0.4419834018,
-0.1976502836,
0.3504900634,
-0.3025898635,
0.577677846,
1.0576634407,
-0.0624148659,
-0.3503814042,
-0.9616436362,
0.3740294278,
0.6194143295,
-0.4916991591,
0.1536250859,
0.1926689744,
0.3558579087,
0.3626902401,
0.4188701808,
0.1484007537,
0.3936023414,
0.0090177096,
0.0713070929,
-0.1804945022,
-0.4164765477,
0.0046492219,
0.0493920222,
0.0232516006,
-0.1075277478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13401v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13401v1 | A study of conceptual language similarity: comparison and evaluation | 2023-05-22T18:28:02 | 2023-05-22T18:28:02 | Haotian Ye, Yihong Liu, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | An interesting line of research in natural language processing (NLP) aims to
incorporate linguistic typology to bridge linguistic diversity and assist the
research of low-resource languages. While most works construct linguistic
similarity measures based on lexical or typological features, such as word
order and verbal inflection, recent work has introduced a novel approach to
defining language similarity based on how they represent basic concepts, which
is complementary to existing similarity measures. In this work, we study the
conceptual similarity in detail and evaluate it extensively on a binary
classification task. | [
-0.4792684913,
-0.6079660058,
0.2137851864,
0.3135688603,
-0.4612353444,
0.4485342205,
-0.2205895185,
-0.7760731578,
0.2982946634,
0.4868882298,
-0.016370656,
-0.4352337718,
-0.2654907703,
0.3291018605,
-0.6317305565,
0.8062183857,
-0.0268797949,
-0.1131852269,
-0.3389002681,
-0.267275244,
-0.3546944559,
-0.4441345632,
-1.0654101372,
-0.561075151,
0.069922559,
0.0174517091,
0.8490493298,
0.2524620593,
0.838270247,
0.4795841873,
-0.2744352221,
-0.1522106826,
-0.3310310245,
-0.0249835029,
-0.4848081172,
-0.4395750761,
0.1362097263,
-0.066700168,
0.8565517068,
1.0157417059,
0.0168028604,
0.3016574383,
0.2571142316,
0.757260561,
-0.4140633643,
0.1336912513,
-0.7924126983,
0.2128440738,
-0.0699855462,
-0.2480465919,
0.00852169,
-0.6371507645,
0.2904471755,
-0.220494315,
0.5249330997,
0.3720726967,
0.9664441943,
0.0885455981,
-0.0624009445,
-0.4135325551,
-0.4934941232,
0.541415751,
-0.8001372814,
0.3470768034,
0.1292106509,
0.1317671388,
0.0606139936,
-0.4610992074,
-1.0607203245,
-0.5012792349,
-0.3017695546,
-0.0127290217,
-0.0669288933,
-0.0798414424,
0.1359845251,
0.5343396664,
-0.7417531013,
-0.0023612136,
-0.3939639032,
0.055987671,
0.5865732431,
0.1290596575,
0.2263409942,
-0.5696433783,
-0.4454265535,
-0.0177006256,
-0.3090671599,
0.0320248008,
0.3150542974,
0.3671843112,
-0.3650744259,
0.5215522647,
-0.5567390919,
0.83114326,
-0.1398706585,
-0.1420792341,
0.6436105371,
-0.5193382502,
-0.2479404956,
0.1551529318,
0.6841225624,
0.6113830805,
0.6135775447,
-0.4071404636,
-0.1442429423,
0.1928587407,
0.5078356862,
-0.3474479318,
0.031064963,
-0.3311603665,
-0.4850428402,
-0.5096077323,
0.0975288451,
-0.417101115,
-0.0211140718,
-0.5628249645,
0.2900575399,
-0.7702513933,
-0.2766566873,
0.1072793901,
-0.2231350243,
0.5495626926,
-0.1521357596,
-0.9189311862,
0.8593482375,
1.343517065,
1.096606493,
-0.6292415857,
-0.1466956288,
0.1958566308,
-0.2765386701,
-0.5254865885,
0.7673550844,
-0.7368780375,
-0.2956934273,
-0.188696593,
-0.4287705421,
-0.1920324564,
-0.873631835,
0.3363701105,
-0.5083593726,
0.2022033036,
0.1573758721,
-0.6179007888,
-0.4059920907,
0.5637250543,
-0.3945845664,
1.1889815331,
0.4373568892,
-1.0961533785,
0.6213662028,
-0.5745399594,
-0.2103555053,
0.4462008774,
-0.2356099337,
-0.0627663583,
0.2704533339,
-0.809169054,
0.1650240272,
-0.3962387741,
-0.2321342528,
-0.3304064274,
-0.4620166123,
0.3439358175,
0.1130319089,
0.589910388,
0.17157121,
-0.1842347085,
0.0360744037,
-0.8460536003,
0.4685820043,
-0.0298618916,
-0.0080022896,
-1.1629084349,
-0.2372461855,
0.067452617,
0.3291961253,
0.2542119622,
-0.6378870606,
-0.0257524662,
-0.8745143414,
0.2748920619,
0.2702325284,
0.1378474832,
0.4490678012,
-0.3371086121,
0.3713220656,
-0.3854750991,
-0.2117342651,
0.6531917453,
-0.5499313474,
-0.645602107,
-0.0686524585,
0.8697143793,
0.549481988,
-0.6632753611,
0.4369823933,
-0.5957987309,
-0.5158790946,
-0.5421208739,
0.1484682709,
0.7835943699,
0.3628048003,
0.070660904,
-1.0001088381,
-0.4221185744,
-1.0694479942,
-0.1339033544,
-0.4376345277,
-0.0830536038,
0.0055104559,
0.3875383437,
0.0366947427,
0.8955420256,
-0.4219562411,
-0.1256780922,
-0.0573749915,
0.2715581656,
0.1859381348,
0.4104438126,
0.8885248303,
-0.6088057756,
-0.6301303506,
0.2518078983,
-0.5443889499,
-0.0366819277,
0.2547547519,
-0.1136834696,
0.339235574,
0.6251071692,
-0.3356463909,
0.2710729539,
0.2268894911,
-0.5700353384,
0.4564551711,
-0.0354731679,
0.3044424355,
-0.9570569992,
0.0103730317,
-0.3464908004,
-0.022215385,
-0.4741618335,
0.4714885056,
-0.2994045317,
0.1242074519,
-0.3923997283,
0.5354983211,
0.1564046741,
-0.4324156344,
-0.3359635472,
0.273781389,
-0.3424194753,
0.2748116553,
0.2679213583,
0.5381643772,
0.4256393015,
-0.5425451398,
0.4504186809,
0.0821296424,
-0.5950611234,
0.9266355038,
-0.5013982058,
0.1939589679,
-0.0339623131,
-0.4683892727,
-1.0172772408,
0.4271112084,
0.1956158876,
-0.7154114246,
0.2573767006,
0.0965755731,
-0.7380517721,
-0.2763966918,
-0.5707185268,
0.5159161091,
0.3779606521,
0.0603454337,
0.2144399285,
0.0986434743,
-0.4169924855,
-0.3973655403,
-0.4590960741,
0.0173826981,
-0.4631631672,
-0.2768485546,
0.5926411152,
0.0821970254,
-0.7979585528,
0.3643527031,
-0.1768700331,
-0.166816771,
0.1764631271,
0.0848124623,
0.1686619818,
-0.4810651541,
0.2466342747,
-0.1871913821,
0.0356755219,
0.2597084939,
-0.2360662669,
0.7414085269,
-0.2976343036,
-0.0683284253,
0.0624095052,
0.2505006492,
-0.017382754,
0.0821435302,
0.5444265604,
0.5050898194,
-0.3846485615,
0.0411477052,
-0.4550713599,
0.1427313536,
-0.3885740936,
0.3408147395,
-0.6688751578,
-0.6919662952,
0.1519708633,
0.3165711462,
0.0105512263,
0.4796402156,
0.5050014853,
-0.2591502964,
0.1544916183,
0.8088281155,
-0.0683352277,
0.3187566698,
-0.0694850311,
0.183246091,
-0.6597568989,
-0.2454736382,
-0.8494874239,
-0.3574173748,
-0.7750127912,
-0.5347598791,
-0.3344591856,
0.1017594859,
-0.3355813622,
0.7103890181,
-0.3496550322,
0.4367049336,
0.398237437,
-0.3136999905,
0.4683962762,
0.1417885125,
-0.5573473573,
-0.2095936388,
-0.3722941279,
-0.7150921226,
0.8659744263,
-0.0952219442,
0.3301602304,
0.1462602615,
0.9352880716,
0.4834285975,
0.0691164583,
-0.826644659,
0.6691957116,
-0.253462553,
-0.385186702,
-0.3902695477,
-0.3423355222,
-0.9488005042,
0.3950660229,
-0.5874990225,
-0.8220773935,
-0.2506820858,
-0.3309021592,
0.0348328762,
0.0862536356,
-0.6785957217,
0.653444469,
-0.1008090004,
0.090879336,
-0.6418176293,
-0.4258615375,
0.2766105235,
-0.274487108,
0.1479529142,
-0.1447979212,
-0.2551710606,
0.9587048292,
-0.0822293833,
0.4073849022,
0.3290216923,
0.0615770333,
0.2245092839,
0.2144373357,
-0.6281894445,
-0.1442123652,
-0.1093110442,
0.2267176509,
0.3396743536,
-0.3908396363,
-0.8544183373,
0.7775995135,
-0.4933667481,
-0.2497331053,
-0.5527479649,
-0.3534706235,
-0.1868460625,
0.2406874746,
-0.053001944,
0.2071427256,
-0.4142169356,
-0.0434095412,
0.2442903072,
-0.1069681495,
0.4598250389,
0.6118128896,
-0.4300566614,
0.0400060825,
0.9044582248,
-0.2386374176,
0.4375507832,
0.8974244595,
-0.0227571391,
-0.3934696913,
-0.5770146251,
0.0223771203,
0.3156823814,
-0.5631897449,
-0.1407924443,
-0.4174857736,
-0.4661427736,
-0.1592827737,
-0.0697465315,
-0.229322508,
-0.6608221531,
0.320664078,
0.0103111481,
0.3976940215,
0.864010632,
0.1779273897,
0.1264523119,
-0.4198534191,
0.5254479051,
0.2946057022,
0.5989688635,
0.1315011978,
-0.5495761037,
0.0015918075,
-0.3590449989,
-0.3946007192,
-0.5331568718,
0.1675558984,
0.3375901282,
0.602483511,
0.3508986831,
-0.0941312835,
0.5289013386,
-0.5889194012,
0.5478491783,
0.3839205801,
-1.2308295965,
0.1885357499,
0.3337022364,
0.0753917918,
0.7365686297,
0.4680869877,
-0.6305251718,
-0.5733196735,
-0.9105457067,
-0.7583972812,
0.303270638,
0.7100514174,
0.1033356264,
-0.102103509,
0.3059184551,
0.1840464473,
0.4068617821,
-0.52552706,
-0.4320864081,
0.0608193427,
-0.216114074,
-0.1673094332,
-0.0701792836,
0.1756342649,
-0.196545884,
0.308821708,
0.0614581071,
0.5257924795,
-0.2258217186,
-0.010848077,
0.228306666,
0.6354312301,
0.4040723145,
0.5794907808,
-0.2886252105,
0.351765573,
0.6237664819,
-0.4909401536,
0.0056485133,
0.0556439981,
-0.131959945,
0.3549739718,
0.7002613544,
0.3971810937,
0.5520728827,
-0.5105940104,
0.2368573993,
-0.0027593041,
-0.1594826728,
-0.1538300663,
0.0428140908,
0.3120499849,
0.0583581477,
-0.0554315671,
0.0958538577,
0.4379338026,
-0.9858047366,
0.236027047,
0.5106090903,
-0.4458200037,
-0.1245320588,
-0.1161918491,
0.037012849,
-0.7146109343,
0.6032865644,
-0.6529955268,
-0.709847331,
0.6343809366,
0.4600823224,
0.4869098961,
-0.0047696037,
0.1140667275,
0.4260507226,
0.245812282,
0.314869374,
0.4678122401,
-0.2403776199,
-0.9553034902,
-0.3589700758,
-0.9119709134,
-0.2756440938,
-0.0961777493,
-0.7164571881,
0.4329732656,
-0.5368977785,
-0.0920536965,
0.3626231849,
0.1970579922,
-0.7633363605,
0.3283316195,
0.5000190139,
0.7527067661,
-0.6971340775,
0.8042325377,
0.8134025335,
-0.2158731818,
-0.5993286371,
-0.0765946805,
-0.1802504808,
-0.7243508101,
0.8957616091,
0.1286461055,
-0.3385448158,
-0.3525178134,
-0.0950735733,
-0.6986748576,
0.688377738,
-0.0059698997,
-0.2603943646,
-0.1731173992,
0.3271596432,
1.1478786469,
-0.5684939623,
0.3886230886,
0.913300097,
0.1413048953,
0.053226199,
-1.4476748705,
0.0977023244,
-0.4022267759,
0.396140039,
0.267381072,
-0.1925643831,
0.4407924712,
-0.060294725,
-0.3209109008,
-0.0126898438,
0.6439269185,
0.1514766514,
0.2324557006,
0.6341078877,
0.6934387088,
0.4318014383,
0.036823824,
0.7899525762,
-0.2202189118,
0.4709368944,
1.1689293385,
-0.3255771995,
0.9708327055,
0.4110836685,
-0.6147608757,
0.7325171828,
0.3885630071,
-0.0510173328,
0.5328825116,
0.5497744679,
0.0827014744,
0.2166703492,
-0.1521366984,
-0.4652858078,
0.6193251014,
0.3940196335,
-0.167539686,
-0.2861818373,
-0.2965719402,
-0.409529537,
0.4411720037,
-0.4721546471,
1.0447278023,
0.3787043393,
-0.4167074561,
0.7564045787,
0.1047969833,
0.9194667339,
-0.5282761455,
-0.0711769983,
0.1234500632,
-0.1246633753,
-0.1648919731,
-1.0925092697,
0.9030585885,
-0.054265514,
-0.0990681201,
0.159205988,
0.3434492052,
-0.202066198,
-0.328166157,
0.7066327929,
0.2418639064,
0.38993752,
0.1731106788,
-0.9180706739,
-0.2951160371,
-0.1734906435,
0.5286855698,
0.0665160492,
0.4669830501,
-0.1958808601,
0.7990933657,
0.1193046123,
0.4161143005,
0.2604292929,
0.1855756789,
0.3164081872,
-1.0855720043,
-0.5994384289,
-0.7219182253,
-0.2825677693,
-0.2379099727,
-0.5008582473,
0.4928908348,
0.7495583296,
1.3980389833,
-0.3246015906,
0.467980504,
-0.4243355691,
0.7013890147,
-0.5770717263,
0.4160993099,
-0.2823180854,
0.0967469439,
-0.6835647225,
-1.2544487715,
-0.220620811,
0.795273006,
-0.1976427436,
-0.256735146,
1.1503503323,
0.576648891,
-0.0769214034,
0.0618975051,
0.4201028645,
0.0764276758,
-0.3968597651,
0.4862261415,
0.9912384748,
-0.1117376536,
0.317676276,
-0.3936141729,
-0.0031359293,
0.048349686,
-0.6823198795,
-0.972612083,
-0.8166866899,
-0.3808981478,
-0.2667508423,
-0.0048658638,
1.3196760416,
0.3560580313,
-1.0337911844,
-0.4796011448,
0.1738545895,
0.3367314637,
-0.4426466525,
-0.302167356,
0.3122959435,
-0.3801109493,
-0.6024545431,
-0.2177198976,
0.3403269351,
0.0720306933,
-0.0030227704,
0.1988135278,
-0.2463697791,
-0.0288108774,
0.7593821287,
0.0771018788,
-0.8280858397,
-0.4194651842,
-0.5198648572,
-0.2260724008,
0.0818829387,
0.8951671124,
-0.7920776606,
0.2613425553,
0.7367122769,
0.602773726,
0.3704296052,
-0.1100943834,
0.4112674594,
-0.6732480526,
0.2386212796,
0.2775847614,
0.2467928231,
0.5647369623,
0.1151931062,
0.7740930319,
0.1121382043,
0.0309482906,
-0.4867422581,
0.3608086705,
-1.3787395954,
-0.0861174241,
0.9421753883,
-0.052795738,
0.0998869017,
-0.4884773195,
-0.1420494467,
0.1264839172,
-0.2753567398,
0.9801676869,
0.7295911908,
-0.0055084503,
0.1099889353,
-0.228871271,
0.5385135412,
0.2045337856,
-0.5038032532,
-0.5372681022,
-0.3414151073,
0.536211133,
0.6011353135,
0.4114765227,
-0.2006421387,
-0.0384724513,
-0.0857490599,
0.0226226375,
0.4460477233,
0.176202774,
-0.3801518381,
0.2663128972,
0.2349636257,
-0.2602061629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13395v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13395v2 | BioDEX: Large-Scale Biomedical Adverse Drug Event Extraction for Real-World Pharmacovigilance | 2023-05-22T18:15:57 | 2023-10-20T15:51:45 | Karel D'Oosterlinck, François Remy, Johannes Deleu, Thomas Demeester, Chris Develder, Klim Zaporojets, Aneiss Ghodsi, Simon Ellershaw, Jack Collins, Christopher Potts | cs.CL | cs.CL | Timely and accurate extraction of Adverse Drug Events (ADE) from biomedical
literature is paramount for public safety, but involves slow and costly manual
labor. We set out to improve drug safety monitoring (pharmacovigilance, PV)
through the use of Natural Language Processing (NLP). We introduce BioDEX, a
large-scale resource for Biomedical adverse Drug Event Extraction, rooted in
the historical output of drug safety reporting in the U.S. BioDEX consists of
65k abstracts and 19k full-text biomedical papers with 256k associated
document-level safety reports created by medical experts. The core features of
these reports include the reported weight, age, and biological sex of a
patient, a set of drugs taken by the patient, the drug dosages, the reactions
experienced, and whether the reaction was life threatening. In this work, we
consider the task of predicting the core information of the report given its
originating paper. We estimate human performance to be 72.0% F1, whereas our
best model achieves 62.3% F1, indicating significant headroom on this task. We
also begin to explore ways in which these models could help professional PV
reviewers. Our code and data are available: https://github.com/KarelDO/BioDEX. | [
0.0275675226,
-0.5879428387,
0.8531413078,
0.110139817,
-0.3018068969,
0.028337108,
0.0953015685,
-1.0508767366,
0.1484953016,
0.6022460461,
-0.2871626914,
-0.7825220823,
-0.5921747088,
0.238834247,
-0.2548643649,
1.1420243979,
0.0672057644,
-0.0512722805,
-0.2415789664,
-0.0136507871,
-0.2351387143,
-0.5405062437,
-0.7200098634,
-0.1681747884,
0.6298814416,
0.0863757133,
0.3462869525,
0.5530243516,
0.7578732371,
0.2303029299,
-0.2151271701,
0.0980915129,
-0.0956858024,
0.1376686096,
-0.4026561379,
-0.1698233932,
-0.962738812,
0.0493103229,
0.3798774779,
0.6179105043,
-0.1374605745,
0.1136592254,
-0.0587514862,
0.6982655525,
-0.7716915011,
0.0577395037,
-0.1445821524,
0.1926604509,
0.0566023923,
-0.1049923301,
-0.312060833,
-0.6135850549,
0.4925150871,
-0.5343744755,
-0.0420376509,
-0.2382007688,
0.7350188494,
0.1317505538,
-0.4780349731,
-0.0222286843,
-0.6990665793,
0.5872299671,
-0.6454790831,
0.1559427828,
0.2925349474,
0.2049205452,
-0.2382255495,
-0.6743558645,
-0.2552554309,
0.1168895513,
0.0219866913,
0.0273777116,
-0.0855487064,
0.1860838681,
0.2831125855,
0.2524433732,
-0.5986479521,
0.1529496014,
-0.3246863782,
-0.3757174611,
0.7007909417,
0.3141621649,
0.3729908466,
-0.2264617234,
-0.4489542246,
-0.0109638805,
-0.543271482,
-0.0005031132,
-0.100944154,
0.0921974331,
-0.1065325215,
0.396191299,
-0.0435613878,
0.5347906947,
-0.1835608035,
0.0517920852,
0.266386807,
-0.8866946101,
-0.07788793,
0.2736272812,
1.0495029688,
0.5736865997,
-0.0082356744,
-0.0851223543,
-0.0047300812,
0.0740724429,
0.4031187594,
-1.213390708,
-0.351039499,
0.7626036406,
-0.6419176459,
-0.4613565207,
0.0847361758,
-1.2956374884,
-0.7857039571,
-0.2224753648,
0.2945527434,
-0.587898314,
-0.217268005,
0.2773400843,
-0.2665953338,
0.1681730896,
0.2944577634,
-0.5185679197,
0.4439679682,
0.7560554147,
0.9028861523,
-0.3812460601,
0.1224085018,
-0.9753840566,
-0.1246567816,
-0.2040652782,
1.0969458818,
-0.2675230801,
-0.5000311732,
-0.1924416274,
0.1504744142,
-0.0459776148,
-0.6318311095,
0.6549354196,
-0.2368466109,
-0.0981296971,
-0.1467731595,
-0.4113680422,
-0.0199483577,
-0.0724458247,
-0.4827799797,
0.3022620082,
-0.2018136531,
-0.705632925,
0.5656743646,
-0.5641209483,
-0.4653922021,
0.1093426421,
0.1458395869,
-0.6706045866,
0.0788413584,
0.1698728353,
0.3159374893,
-0.2102069706,
0.40980497,
-0.3184906542,
-0.2197408527,
0.2554168105,
-0.1286529154,
0.8475030661,
0.1230082363,
-0.1389784664,
0.0667113215,
-1.1558779478,
-0.2003192604,
-0.0371063948,
-0.5726282001,
-0.5376113057,
0.1128909737,
0.3766483366,
0.3652304411,
0.1620978415,
-1.0048336983,
-0.1024287865,
-0.7142215371,
0.0980596989,
0.6851513982,
0.4862627685,
0.3293807805,
0.0757756755,
0.4147851169,
-0.0795692503,
0.4990965426,
-0.1253022701,
-0.4495861828,
0.0840841383,
-0.288210839,
0.590611279,
0.795569241,
-0.1610377133,
0.8359593153,
-0.1340516806,
-0.2220381945,
-0.1121265739,
0.0568290912,
0.3839583993,
0.510509491,
0.3149540424,
-0.5224999189,
-0.62533921,
-0.6828198433,
-0.3180541992,
-0.2726053596,
-0.3475494087,
0.0178141985,
0.5264549255,
-0.791087389,
0.8429026604,
-0.9501575232,
-0.3173614144,
-0.0145362141,
0.3306727707,
0.0940038264,
0.2681229115,
0.5251457095,
-0.4933972061,
-0.3141374886,
0.2436680794,
-0.8360595703,
-0.2794848979,
0.0076128752,
-0.2588835061,
0.0838478059,
0.4851541519,
-0.5244145989,
0.4571951628,
0.2468313724,
-0.5292055607,
0.52360636,
-0.352403909,
-0.1039310917,
-0.9990354776,
0.448486656,
0.4440869391,
-0.1668667197,
-0.4974833727,
-0.4491152465,
0.1276022494,
-0.3015343547,
-0.3153621554,
0.5025891662,
-0.1689475924,
0.1493661106,
-0.1864067912,
-0.1030058861,
0.2598142326,
0.0433483794,
0.2890074849,
0.3532629013,
0.2128877044,
-0.61991781,
0.3758917153,
0.2404056638,
-0.4086369276,
0.4055291116,
-0.6496050358,
-0.1362768561,
-0.173753798,
0.2642919719,
-0.583494544,
-0.4926616549,
0.0745305344,
-0.2612010837,
0.2409065813,
-0.3376916349,
-0.2546861768,
-0.3290366828,
-0.4955410063,
-0.2229916304,
0.4387829006,
-0.232944116,
0.5018131137,
1.0079426765,
-0.68402493,
-0.5005425811,
-0.3062497675,
0.2512417436,
0.0566137359,
-0.144129172,
0.1368930191,
0.0376238935,
-0.4341282547,
-0.0664081275,
-0.3421203792,
-0.2809301317,
0.0006778824,
0.3330793381,
0.6549730897,
0.0634905845,
0.1895238161,
0.0052134856,
-0.3585800231,
0.7282623649,
0.0440677442,
-0.1232088655,
-0.0108132921,
0.2507174015,
-0.5449330807,
0.4807943702,
0.6991134286,
-0.2148829401,
0.7324249744,
0.4246951342,
-0.5931767225,
0.0248793568,
-0.0459999107,
-0.3447871804,
-0.3396914303,
0.2682343423,
0.3424396217,
-0.1596017331,
0.4348936677,
-0.183007285,
0.2017982304,
0.4162670076,
0.2267947942,
-0.0914279893,
1.1526557207,
0.6025909185,
0.1707632393,
0.4345853925,
-0.0757230669,
0.1637625545,
-0.5845944285,
-0.2601989806,
-0.3315092921,
-0.0022358561,
-0.2480546385,
-0.3348902166,
0.709749043,
-0.5724899769,
-0.1835534722,
0.2839488983,
-0.4287052751,
0.3953525126,
0.1822566837,
0.1616215259,
0.285545975,
0.0484212227,
0.0487849228,
-0.1576497853,
-0.4374260008,
-0.4390729368,
1.2243955135,
0.4293730557,
0.6224001646,
-0.0369400494,
0.5806324482,
0.2552625537,
0.2149482071,
-0.5878219008,
0.5105440617,
-0.4233595431,
-0.4766908586,
-0.0286420546,
-0.5293778181,
-0.9263321757,
-0.1253299117,
-0.6475268006,
-0.5707755089,
0.6477589607,
-0.1497195512,
-1.0669753551,
0.1370503604,
-0.9183518291,
0.9912946224,
-0.231257081,
-0.3626881242,
-0.1920283139,
-0.8474000692,
0.3061816692,
-0.3949584961,
0.4668715596,
-0.0418561734,
-0.0115872398,
0.7043445706,
-0.5665321946,
1.0518687963,
-0.1396448165,
-0.1538983285,
0.2308304459,
-0.0967470333,
0.3520287871,
0.3721450567,
0.1608363092,
0.2166025192,
0.3031357229,
-0.1630159318,
-0.2420786917,
0.7529745102,
-0.5553199649,
0.0360557251,
-0.707695365,
-0.1739004403,
-0.0029769503,
0.1619601697,
0.1081816554,
0.7032792568,
-0.4178890884,
-0.0111657074,
0.8236094713,
-0.7496525049,
0.2407620251,
0.7941176295,
0.0722077116,
-0.4869603515,
0.870549798,
0.217721954,
0.0024299689,
0.501398921,
0.3272165656,
-0.3779191673,
-0.416709125,
-0.1291094869,
0.2112634778,
-0.5759103894,
-0.2591198087,
-1.0049850941,
-0.1307748854,
-0.5579185486,
0.1805589348,
-0.5350728035,
-0.3521719575,
-0.1835843474,
-0.2140265852,
0.4744398296,
0.7483894229,
-0.2330549806,
-0.085877493,
-1.2967942953,
0.5269230604,
0.4824384153,
0.5941426158,
-0.5198107958,
0.0456571728,
-0.3359202743,
-0.1733741462,
-0.1648982316,
-0.8503481746,
0.5729901195,
0.2559489906,
0.4439463317,
0.445705384,
0.2441471368,
0.255048573,
-0.4411902726,
0.4757460356,
0.1516903937,
-0.5316259265,
0.9912278056,
-0.3618587554,
0.155537039,
0.6085654497,
0.252164185,
-0.4694162607,
-0.1493172795,
-0.4332634509,
-1.2209345102,
0.542462945,
0.0990065262,
-0.4864695072,
-0.2576649785,
0.5021346211,
0.1845704168,
-0.138064757,
-0.4218358397,
0.0195783526,
0.2376907915,
-0.1346222013,
0.0423803926,
-0.2539775968,
-0.2518970072,
-0.2077012211,
0.4527942538,
-0.1956946403,
0.2440837026,
0.5055279136,
-0.1095576808,
-0.2469775826,
0.4124271572,
0.3283303678,
0.6412659883,
-0.7902887464,
0.1893846542,
-0.1169791594,
-1.1183458567,
-0.0561689101,
0.5608798862,
0.1284918934,
-0.2129710913,
0.4218212068,
0.2425536066,
0.1328187138,
-1.2753059864,
0.4152445495,
-0.4620397687,
0.0274678841,
-0.2831718624,
0.0542797521,
-0.4318891466,
0.1382926255,
0.4140890241,
0.2860162854,
0.4921875,
-0.4136046767,
0.5207800269,
0.1800652146,
-0.5834369063,
-0.3670580089,
0.8354429007,
0.5847067237,
0.0128573785,
0.2724592388,
0.1114403754,
-0.0205024891,
0.8115180731,
0.1534841508,
0.94284302,
-0.1172774807,
0.317602545,
0.7134158015,
0.0649305284,
0.081939429,
0.0898285583,
0.2801722884,
-0.3424624503,
-0.7767935395,
-0.8255802989,
-0.4894206524,
0.0313662812,
-0.4451328814,
0.2115678489,
-0.6132296324,
-0.3925811946,
0.4648412466,
0.105439499,
0.0625108182,
0.1586027145,
0.1497450769,
0.5325816274,
-1.0092867613,
0.3865347505,
0.8702679276,
-0.1494168192,
-0.0505996309,
-0.1299765259,
0.1195431128,
-0.0137087563,
0.4106278718,
0.2189480066,
0.1006971523,
-0.4230118692,
-0.3865975142,
-0.4130017161,
0.8465387225,
0.0788044184,
-0.6357705593,
-0.0050135776,
-0.0206557512,
0.8365911841,
-0.1586392224,
-0.1178570613,
0.7308155298,
0.1906160861,
-0.2271175534,
-0.7281131744,
0.0037305593,
-0.532933116,
-0.3025773466,
0.2980168462,
-0.1126802638,
0.6104433537,
-0.3733948469,
-0.0961113498,
-0.3938791752,
0.131333068,
0.2459530085,
0.5785442591,
0.404749155,
0.3709219098,
0.6762143373,
0.0779770166,
1.2686203718,
-0.0023034115,
0.0425724089,
0.6665631533,
-0.4099567533,
0.8144833446,
0.3023427427,
-0.3122725487,
0.6029459238,
0.5198481679,
0.2567226589,
0.5322867632,
-0.3746224642,
-0.4890764058,
-0.3885875046,
-0.0648329556,
-0.2134904712,
0.0656993985,
0.6907737255,
-0.3670097589,
-0.2000893056,
0.2402888685,
-0.1882517636,
-0.0418679006,
-0.2044769675,
1.0539983511,
0.2230087817,
-0.5997806191,
0.3080376685,
-0.2174571306,
0.3000364602,
-0.5046362877,
-0.2177570015,
0.0056953779,
0.7090365887,
-0.1368569583,
-0.9294726253,
0.6239614487,
0.08983244,
-0.3140935302,
0.0162930004,
0.860842824,
-0.2122056037,
-0.3799290657,
0.4580348134,
0.1853880435,
-0.0054745334,
-0.1987929195,
-0.6937583685,
-0.1463753283,
-0.2600678205,
-0.0917727128,
0.5182035565,
0.2274673581,
-0.0789008811,
0.4598608017,
0.7771584988,
0.4737089872,
-0.3099453449,
-0.1136849523,
0.5124860406,
-0.6400698423,
-0.4451993704,
-0.6962117553,
0.4431628287,
-0.5395304561,
-0.1391557753,
0.3094698489,
0.5688720942,
-0.1083984151,
-0.0746672601,
0.7028186321,
0.214230299,
0.7880959511,
-0.2730321288,
0.8049903512,
-0.2542279065,
0.344463408,
-0.2010060549,
-0.7129144073,
-0.479232192,
0.4711610973,
-0.2507371902,
-0.5228548646,
0.71390903,
0.2827678621,
0.1974705756,
-0.0394663326,
-0.2496064752,
0.4446956217,
0.5209245086,
0.6135576963,
0.3707129657,
-0.6833395958,
0.608707726,
-0.2029141784,
-0.4611673951,
-0.3085659742,
-0.7980698347,
-0.8533443213,
-0.1123789772,
-0.6943473816,
-0.5471529365,
0.1088539585,
0.9839134216,
0.4379297495,
-0.9637625217,
0.1352860779,
-0.1466895342,
0.3039910495,
-0.4965514541,
-0.2200910598,
0.3777045608,
-0.1330850571,
-0.571229279,
0.3572995961,
0.7245727181,
0.071864374,
0.1400835067,
0.2121155262,
-0.3350766301,
-0.0595676713,
0.8130628467,
0.5604090095,
-0.1405849159,
-0.0568154417,
0.0505954251,
-0.4105799496,
-0.1744568795,
0.5257839561,
-0.810254097,
0.7440046668,
0.7343494892,
0.581662178,
0.3554479182,
-0.1009288281,
0.9556389451,
-0.5368351936,
-0.0355044194,
0.2826323509,
0.1962765753,
0.104713358,
-0.5632073283,
0.6447780132,
0.4827554226,
-0.6263954043,
-0.8155975938,
-0.1576099396,
-0.9921345711,
-0.4256888032,
0.9766945839,
0.1711940318,
-0.6869847775,
-0.6838648915,
-0.3368374109,
0.0450831875,
-0.3386659026,
0.8366086483,
0.310038954,
-0.0708294213,
0.0244334228,
-0.9127750993,
0.7057110071,
-0.1142171025,
-0.9671307802,
0.375307411,
0.596543014,
0.3011829555,
0.2130535394,
0.7863002419,
-0.413290292,
0.5806388855,
-0.1039037034,
0.355432719,
0.3975855708,
-0.1836644709,
-0.4169704914,
0.0951888934,
-0.4077399671,
0.0167278741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13388v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13388v2 | The neural dynamics of auditory word recognition and integration | 2023-05-22T18:06:32 | 2023-12-05T21:20:16 | Jon Gauthier, Roger Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Listeners recognize and integrate words in rapid and noisy everyday speech by
combining expectations about upcoming content with incremental sensory
evidence. We present a computational model of word recognition which formalizes
this perceptual process in Bayesian decision theory. We fit this model to
explain scalp EEG signals recorded as subjects passively listened to a
fictional story, revealing both the dynamics of the online auditory word
recognition process and the neural correlates of the recognition and
integration of words.
The model reveals distinct neural processing of words depending on whether or
not they can be quickly recognized. While all words trigger a neural response
characteristic of probabilistic integration -- voltage modulations predicted by
a word's surprisal in context -- these modulations are amplified for words
which require more than roughly 150 ms of input to be recognized. We observe no
difference in the latency of these neural responses according to words'
recognition times. Our results are consistent with a two-part model of speech
comprehension, combining an eager and rapid process of word recognition with a
temporally independent process of word integration. However, we also developed
alternative models of the scalp EEG signal not incorporating word recognition
dynamics which showed similar performance improvements. We discuss potential
future modeling steps which may help to separate these hypotheses. | [
-0.4393057525,
-0.9083393216,
0.9976834059,
0.3833964467,
-0.1744618118,
-0.2328082323,
-0.36213395,
-0.7339813113,
0.4426383078,
0.0932615474,
-0.6469121575,
-0.2801816463,
-0.680609107,
-0.1451926827,
-0.8024493456,
0.1289478838,
0.148360908,
-0.0870563015,
-0.0661911964,
-0.0054453225,
-0.5858918428,
-0.2523881793,
-0.6006052494,
-0.4532230794,
0.420935601,
-0.1968873441,
0.4172045887,
0.5703642368,
0.4213961661,
0.3106918335,
-0.4387541115,
-0.3336599767,
0.079381153,
0.1829791665,
-0.1056753099,
-0.5298863053,
-0.2316195667,
0.3346244991,
0.3971309066,
1.108341217,
-0.3760330379,
-0.0405139588,
0.212659061,
-0.0086849984,
-0.3778948486,
0.2986170948,
-0.5289239287,
0.2999428213,
0.0375179946,
-0.5077781677,
-0.2511024475,
-0.1999361366,
0.6803956032,
-0.3858677149,
-0.0595249236,
-0.2999815345,
0.4768815637,
-0.0744974464,
-0.2541325688,
-0.4347725511,
-0.8512423038,
0.4315473437,
-0.4683451056,
0.8100634813,
0.4295239449,
-0.0343052559,
-0.1054264084,
-0.7702729702,
-0.9703781605,
-0.3847348094,
0.0985295549,
0.1734160185,
-0.5004636049,
0.2996056974,
0.2153519243,
-0.1704125106,
-0.3315936625,
-0.1442528665,
-0.2731380761,
-0.1294105947,
0.3155435324,
0.0718565211,
0.2989265025,
-0.035403695,
-0.1593486369,
-0.0165536795,
0.0261640083,
0.1729602218,
0.1421774477,
0.2909438312,
-0.1673492491,
0.44793576,
0.2472992539,
0.5283811092,
0.1650356501,
-0.4575371146,
0.2751502395,
0.1627464592,
0.0370745137,
0.5850014091,
0.660588026,
0.1342340708,
0.1643610448,
-0.4780367315,
-0.2294168919,
0.4979150891,
0.2669546604,
-0.3683982193,
0.0081656389,
0.376378119,
-0.6515931487,
-0.092412129,
-0.2539480627,
-0.478018254,
-0.5103344917,
-0.8563584089,
0.9149956703,
-0.7903838158,
-0.4974962473,
0.4084976614,
-0.5334611535,
-0.029905051,
0.2095110714,
-0.8179693222,
0.4114133418,
0.5892119408,
0.9528722763,
-0.2123195529,
-0.3937823772,
-0.2912770808,
0.0309190787,
-0.4146306515,
0.9704138637,
-0.6046100259,
-0.4634630084,
0.1229550987,
-0.0451050103,
-0.0919025391,
-0.4065635502,
0.2605758011,
-0.7595250607,
-0.1701458693,
-0.2322831899,
-0.5400077701,
-0.3601277769,
-0.239262417,
-0.3613394797,
0.1183043197,
-0.0896908492,
-0.6948996782,
0.4367331564,
-0.5241729617,
-0.2599647343,
0.3029449284,
-0.0849369317,
0.2674417794,
0.4807022214,
-0.3608730435,
0.2284144014,
0.2345407754,
0.0799618587,
-0.4395606816,
-0.5738008022,
0.6477761865,
-0.3981627524,
0.7386127114,
0.2405532897,
-0.1656605154,
-0.1380491704,
-1.1177506447,
-0.1643983275,
-0.2376810461,
-0.4443341494,
-0.3786206543,
0.5416813493,
-0.03682537,
-0.1001152173,
0.1820218116,
-0.6239008307,
-0.0331007354,
-0.3700998127,
0.5385125279,
0.4204814136,
0.1362208426,
0.3835153878,
-0.0472979173,
0.1941585541,
0.1915743202,
-0.1278057247,
-0.135221228,
-0.38719666,
-0.6178474426,
-0.1603762358,
0.603770256,
0.6508386135,
-0.2502208054,
0.4770022333,
-0.2001518458,
-0.1763321161,
-0.2849798203,
-0.4417792261,
-0.3043271303,
0.4824721813,
0.2667109072,
-0.2126165032,
-0.4887317717,
-0.6993200183,
-0.1293560117,
-0.49580881,
-0.4886194766,
0.1299014837,
0.0084993262,
-0.5966935754,
1.0081214905,
-0.1639524549,
-0.177706033,
0.0487300381,
0.9225514531,
0.5357270241,
0.2906115055,
0.3637605309,
-0.3886550367,
0.088543959,
0.1043345705,
-0.7266834378,
-0.4760145843,
-0.2153773308,
0.1716017723,
-0.5278255343,
0.6523618102,
-0.5600756407,
0.5456715822,
0.4363625348,
-0.3580090702,
0.3522232473,
-0.3015380204,
0.0132065304,
-0.476596415,
-0.4040831923,
0.0996001437,
0.0687813461,
-0.5636279583,
-0.2202068716,
0.1741709411,
0.1728755832,
-0.3354022205,
0.132745102,
-0.5422911644,
-0.1290521622,
-0.7605568171,
0.2181543708,
-0.4228643477,
0.5814480782,
0.1790017486,
0.5876321197,
0.6184076667,
-1.0037702322,
0.304564625,
0.2207210064,
-0.6031082869,
0.4750552773,
-0.6679581404,
-0.0711086467,
-0.3465904593,
-0.1349821538,
-0.9540802836,
-0.0729988813,
-0.1038166359,
-0.5282582641,
0.2486779392,
0.1303373426,
-0.358645916,
-0.0469207093,
0.2434905469,
0.4797436893,
0.6123315692,
-0.5089806914,
1.0797868967,
0.7318042517,
-0.2877789736,
0.1338811815,
-1.035733223,
0.098133564,
-0.0862310603,
-0.3683453798,
0.6942480206,
0.129732728,
-0.5540210009,
-0.0734847635,
-0.0027261416,
-0.0833936781,
-0.2983756065,
0.3942545056,
0.0628985539,
-0.0510378033,
0.1562359333,
0.2413094193,
0.1460695565,
0.3734904528,
-0.3774274588,
0.4218838215,
0.2394534349,
-0.3008502126,
-0.6566178799,
0.4631686211,
0.6277000904,
0.0202929843,
0.4593897462,
0.7603667974,
-0.5218036771,
0.1590284556,
-0.5367276669,
-0.1112253293,
-0.413643837,
0.234003216,
-0.3938597143,
-0.5143854618,
0.6912747622,
-0.0928615928,
-0.2083961517,
0.2856779993,
0.3581038713,
-0.3745595813,
1.310382843,
0.5607569814,
0.5135739446,
0.7516584396,
-0.0854045227,
0.2992749214,
-1.0496678352,
-0.2487708777,
-0.208931759,
-0.6315736175,
-0.6389372945,
-0.1988440603,
0.3319635987,
0.1875443012,
0.1825814992,
0.3922817111,
-0.3182948232,
0.2012573183,
0.4660357833,
0.2799449563,
-0.0036504476,
-0.012626837,
-0.7571056485,
-0.2377777696,
-0.4452485144,
-0.1982744485,
0.6516479254,
0.4996868074,
0.7072454095,
-0.0640479028,
0.3820722699,
0.404170841,
-0.0188751891,
-0.8231058121,
0.7473871708,
0.0988351181,
-0.1651518047,
0.0366792344,
-0.0576791763,
-1.0359262228,
0.2496720552,
-0.460767746,
-1.2610146999,
0.9568637609,
-0.383508414,
-0.7049893141,
0.0446149968,
-0.6961023211,
0.2602155805,
-0.1723220199,
-0.3371016979,
-0.4963257909,
-0.2319336087,
0.2434260547,
0.0004793397,
0.3514398038,
-0.1300686747,
-0.127236858,
0.8497276306,
-0.0175514054,
0.5109028816,
-0.1530907452,
0.1285044551,
0.3341187835,
0.2483993322,
0.2126637846,
-0.0305616092,
0.1547839344,
0.5298808217,
0.2287409157,
0.1575538665,
-0.353675127,
0.6329945922,
-0.6825965643,
-0.4283499718,
-0.5622057915,
-0.6784927845,
-0.3628090322,
0.0740969628,
0.3973172903,
0.4605728388,
-0.1542432159,
-0.0604005456,
0.6982771158,
-0.2248166651,
0.7348442078,
0.5066843629,
-0.5230819583,
-0.5825417042,
0.6519758701,
0.5689840913,
-0.2747550607,
0.231463477,
0.1500804424,
-0.321080178,
-0.7709031105,
0.2247169465,
0.2306413054,
-0.4490637183,
0.2299676389,
-1.0160181522,
-0.2475039661,
-0.2682153881,
0.1948808283,
0.1268052906,
-0.3111099899,
-0.362465024,
-0.1184071824,
0.1381448805,
0.7447413206,
-0.5237710476,
0.7019132376,
-0.8560992479,
0.4418419898,
0.7327995896,
0.3970630765,
0.1256614476,
-0.7725349069,
-0.3569729328,
0.0853975564,
-0.2635269165,
-1.4546105862,
0.6870138049,
0.1689997613,
0.6271952391,
0.7244231105,
-0.3943091929,
0.6529823542,
-0.7390267849,
0.6191775799,
0.2997916937,
-1.0363502502,
0.3102770746,
-0.42928949,
0.4006025195,
0.379581064,
0.4076135159,
-0.5567948222,
-0.2657676041,
-0.5078756809,
-0.7954683304,
0.4713665545,
-0.1563212872,
0.0955655798,
-0.1915477365,
0.234235853,
0.0925095007,
0.3153176904,
-0.2827384174,
0.2446267009,
0.227324605,
0.0596458353,
0.3000948131,
-0.4058895409,
0.095577091,
-0.6057558656,
0.1457303464,
0.2282537371,
0.8255462646,
0.2160957605,
-0.0887987092,
-0.0991775766,
-0.0445945673,
0.5044993758,
0.5000674129,
-0.500363946,
0.0715599284,
0.2404964864,
-0.5828630924,
-0.0412827954,
0.0211087726,
0.1121719331,
0.5109531879,
0.6192876697,
0.8978151679,
0.4378543794,
-0.4579537511,
0.4824924171,
-0.4054206312,
-0.4849230647,
-0.6576673985,
0.0799087137,
0.2313651592,
0.7046269774,
0.4654854536,
0.4365876317,
0.4151979983,
-0.6004975438,
0.1674704999,
0.3949889541,
-0.3578206003,
-0.4324663579,
0.7760472894,
-0.3086679578,
-0.6496244669,
0.574652195,
-0.1806458533,
-0.4944725335,
0.3023374975,
0.4995651841,
1.1371951103,
-0.147962749,
-0.1908404529,
0.3785476685,
-0.178413257,
-0.1250897646,
0.4718464613,
-0.4197390974,
-0.7817889452,
-0.4151543379,
-0.9890131354,
-0.3327732682,
0.1738810092,
-0.5379257798,
0.337725848,
-0.4966504276,
-0.727270484,
0.2983877063,
-0.4469201565,
-0.7006555796,
0.0728654638,
0.5676409602,
0.9950317144,
-0.6870122552,
0.6710622311,
0.4397749305,
-0.308744967,
-0.6993023753,
0.3980726898,
-0.1671225727,
-0.4892753363,
0.5704100728,
0.0790293217,
-0.1174465045,
0.0142817153,
-0.4082660675,
-0.9777573347,
0.7398499846,
0.3159218729,
-0.6694194674,
-0.1255225837,
-0.1487138569,
0.6908839941,
-0.4803809226,
0.4994216263,
0.8299875259,
0.5178092718,
0.1547688842,
-0.8050252199,
-0.555113256,
0.0136465104,
0.0471385121,
-0.1483549625,
-0.0320445821,
0.9831610918,
-0.0522024743,
-0.5019959807,
-0.1118303686,
0.8757280111,
0.1073667482,
0.2667821348,
0.563393712,
0.443779856,
0.4326828718,
-0.1494293064,
0.7204976678,
-0.5912458897,
-0.0104574971,
0.6396998763,
-0.1625321358,
1.1496498585,
0.4857710004,
-0.6794090271,
0.6674777269,
0.6407396197,
0.2695453763,
0.8002141714,
0.0232302584,
-0.4622670412,
-0.2638447285,
-0.2194320261,
-0.2592877448,
0.6907011867,
0.5508819818,
-0.4255099893,
0.1682385951,
0.390445292,
-0.5466241837,
-0.2384244502,
-0.4590581954,
0.8785806298,
0.2778188586,
-0.5990473032,
0.3339538574,
-0.1594860852,
0.850317359,
-0.6286092997,
0.0831881091,
0.2400402427,
0.2317354083,
-0.1403569579,
-0.4684621096,
0.3740630746,
-0.3695216179,
-0.2908626199,
-0.1666830778,
0.4757967293,
-0.6391045451,
-0.4723392725,
0.7069989443,
0.3470285535,
0.1562398076,
-0.0683213547,
-0.2636085749,
0.291797787,
-0.4881076515,
-0.1265414357,
0.4414333701,
0.5415753126,
0.4219095707,
0.1615374982,
0.6797686815,
0.6541822553,
0.3086992502,
0.1110856384,
0.2111937553,
-0.4710257947,
-0.9455021024,
-0.7757223845,
0.1433920413,
0.0465539284,
-0.061720714,
0.3383850157,
-0.0382353105,
0.5591369271,
-0.0325372629,
0.5861238837,
0.1808821261,
0.7373222113,
-0.3603419065,
0.7197397947,
-0.5784364343,
0.208367303,
-0.1375712007,
-0.8074474335,
-0.0178935751,
1.0197528601,
-0.3103034198,
-0.1457621753,
0.952784121,
0.4321466982,
-0.1468199044,
0.4851124585,
0.5110573173,
0.4261015058,
-0.1118742526,
0.2952572405,
0.721903801,
-0.2639001012,
0.0767026991,
-0.1702053994,
-0.3918476701,
-0.171533823,
-0.7677004337,
-0.3024566174,
-0.878354311,
-0.3728215992,
-0.286259234,
-0.159704268,
1.1671674252,
0.5692456961,
-0.7236528397,
-0.5330992341,
-0.2934230864,
-0.2663968801,
-0.6779099107,
-0.2432026863,
-0.0050776033,
-0.3026687801,
-0.5695626736,
0.6796630621,
0.5436967015,
0.0611215867,
-0.1606889218,
0.1666261703,
-0.2474145442,
0.684010148,
0.6796056032,
0.2467354983,
-0.593906641,
-0.049534224,
-0.2566123903,
0.0070999949,
0.0792210028,
0.7374058366,
-0.93906039,
0.557653904,
0.9220923781,
0.5235489607,
0.3864523768,
-0.4430377185,
0.6348446608,
-0.1161085814,
0.1534415632,
0.315982908,
0.6996347308,
-0.1351130158,
-0.0804689601,
0.0942128524,
0.4578113258,
-0.533675313,
-0.8066112995,
0.1292627752,
-1.1372102499,
-0.2301433235,
0.9586424828,
0.1019236147,
-0.6381579041,
-0.0580499507,
-0.0728038922,
0.3604370952,
-0.0918722004,
0.8368313313,
1.1375027895,
-0.5147727132,
-0.1631853282,
-0.5284793377,
0.1546499133,
0.0862195641,
-0.0840564743,
-0.0813881606,
0.4293447435,
0.0588061623,
0.5865164399,
0.4061174393,
0.0446702056,
0.4508102834,
0.4808682501,
0.0158537365,
0.2078901231,
-0.3204688728,
-0.5260500312,
0.5569213629,
-0.1198221818,
-0.43809852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13386v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13386v2 | Can LLMs facilitate interpretation of pre-trained language models? | 2023-05-22T18:03:13 | 2023-10-20T13:24:00 | Basel Mousi, Nadir Durrani, Fahim Dalvi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Work done to uncover the knowledge encoded within pre-trained language models
rely on annotated corpora or human-in-the-loop methods. However, these
approaches are limited in terms of scalability and the scope of interpretation.
We propose using a large language model, ChatGPT, as an annotator to enable
fine-grained interpretation analysis of pre-trained language models. We
discover latent concepts within pre-trained language models by applying
agglomerative hierarchical clustering over contextualized representations and
then annotate these concepts using ChatGPT. Our findings demonstrate that
ChatGPT produces accurate and semantically richer annotations compared to
human-annotated concepts. Additionally, we showcase how GPT-based annotations
empower interpretation analysis methodologies of which we demonstrate two:
probing frameworks and neuron interpretation. To facilitate further exploration
and experimentation in the field, we make available a substantial ConceptNet
dataset (TCN) comprising 39,000 annotated concepts. | [
-0.208697781,
-0.806978941,
0.6713362336,
0.016383104,
-0.5036492944,
0.189419657,
-0.4169810116,
-0.4553671181,
0.1952880472,
0.4341927171,
-0.4735606015,
-0.4769100249,
-0.7361903787,
-0.287086457,
-0.5138700604,
1.1181205511,
0.0923235193,
0.1156664789,
-0.2169185579,
0.1933930069,
-0.2162375301,
-0.746432364,
-0.5819247365,
-0.6216514111,
0.5239889622,
0.0425505973,
0.7801433802,
0.4915361702,
0.7073075175,
0.1874911934,
-0.3010567129,
-0.0070697633,
-0.4635877311,
-0.2637985349,
-0.02383673,
-0.6017640829,
-0.647777915,
0.4095304012,
0.6157650352,
1.0177208185,
-0.1408924162,
0.0118667008,
0.0611609295,
0.0879335627,
-0.1744485795,
0.4483353794,
-0.8215040565,
0.0961903557,
-0.1874763519,
-0.3761171401,
-0.2567417622,
-0.0892042145,
0.5162906051,
-0.6211887598,
0.0726454854,
0.006366008,
0.8803460002,
0.4423876703,
-0.2033914179,
-0.3594891727,
-0.4261739254,
0.5691205263,
-0.775596261,
0.1967516094,
0.3919407725,
0.3853946328,
-0.1069219932,
-0.9440956712,
-0.6680464745,
-0.5059390068,
-0.4683484733,
0.0665814057,
-0.0242779292,
0.1343832612,
0.1635542214,
0.5381144881,
-0.4529514015,
0.3725736439,
-0.32741943,
-0.2583921254,
0.4255712926,
-0.0414622836,
0.5363935232,
-0.2366079688,
-0.2344043702,
0.2488018572,
-0.8395891786,
-0.2914668024,
0.0800992101,
0.3660140634,
-0.3738355339,
0.5553643703,
0.0271527413,
0.702380836,
-0.3176995814,
0.2751848996,
0.2216414362,
-0.2523348629,
-0.3043425083,
-0.1651486456,
0.9500337243,
0.2181569934,
0.7115944624,
-0.4591476023,
-0.0534163304,
0.0812603682,
0.2438973188,
-0.8570244312,
-0.4531824589,
0.0095433258,
-0.3101625144,
-0.4934056401,
-0.2320377678,
-0.4530333579,
-0.3315154314,
-0.4927943051,
0.1822271198,
-0.2704773843,
-0.4172305167,
0.18208538,
0.1721469909,
0.3605151474,
0.4212867618,
-1.0543659925,
0.2034648955,
0.7152354717,
1.0287441015,
-0.3279693127,
-0.3109957576,
-0.1408404261,
0.0382783487,
-0.4490839243,
0.9286743999,
-0.7745772004,
-0.29744187,
-0.1809514016,
-0.0842768252,
-0.1036786884,
-0.4639173746,
0.1706213802,
-0.719378829,
0.0142944874,
0.1610099375,
-0.6853684783,
-0.0318085402,
0.4141991735,
-0.5220834017,
0.8211435676,
0.0643373132,
-0.74856323,
0.3117425442,
-0.8140437603,
-0.152675733,
0.188403666,
-0.6910964847,
0.1368213892,
0.3050791025,
0.2232796699,
0.8427398801,
-0.198726669,
0.495644033,
-0.2036039382,
-0.3397057652,
0.4391591847,
-0.4792981148,
0.3636368811,
0.1889606118,
-0.1692759842,
0.1900820881,
-0.5807156563,
-0.1391428709,
0.075715065,
-0.1279193312,
-0.0961797535,
0.0218862109,
-0.1638753563,
0.238010928,
0.3227133751,
-0.1608700156,
0.2550650835,
-0.4059533477,
0.6772843599,
0.6960360408,
-0.1359030008,
0.4631819427,
0.0873932764,
0.5503978133,
0.2098691463,
-0.1329554468,
-0.2918897569,
-0.324714452,
-0.689765811,
-0.1624625474,
0.2807504237,
0.3602134287,
-0.5683445334,
0.2931199372,
-0.6151508093,
-0.3703228235,
-0.4717902541,
-0.1218940765,
0.0633594915,
0.3270234466,
0.3981622159,
-0.4056169689,
-0.3341012299,
-0.9491083026,
-0.0170626249,
-0.1281331629,
-0.2319957018,
0.2199697047,
0.5186337233,
-0.4548121393,
1.1247096062,
-0.4931311905,
-0.1365299523,
-0.1658665687,
0.3855286539,
0.1763809919,
0.4736924469,
0.2610985637,
-0.7403461337,
-0.1677780151,
0.4082842469,
-0.818770051,
-0.0530323647,
-0.0537006631,
0.0024302406,
-0.4764302373,
0.9092079401,
-0.5456915498,
0.2738738954,
0.6444951892,
-0.2026204914,
0.6443213224,
-0.1425865591,
-0.1131259426,
-1.0623705387,
-0.0164182168,
-0.1945209205,
-0.3569787741,
-0.5874912143,
-0.0359377451,
-0.1570292413,
-0.0012005502,
-0.4127184749,
0.5930139422,
-0.2941853702,
-0.3590944409,
-0.3798025548,
0.5343750715,
0.0133928675,
0.3178856671,
0.4268727303,
0.9643612504,
0.6157078147,
-0.410010457,
0.2533659637,
0.1515056938,
-0.5213506818,
0.1516919285,
-0.7561978698,
0.2222431153,
-0.0471331775,
0.1774120033,
-0.8570915461,
-0.2544585466,
0.2536975145,
-0.5930943489,
0.284026593,
-0.2778601944,
-0.5794365406,
0.0738925859,
0.1648190618,
0.2270710021,
0.342130214,
-0.4425517023,
0.4830160737,
0.3475080729,
-0.1974024624,
-0.3536828458,
-0.7944877148,
0.0454758294,
-0.2491597831,
-0.3331074417,
0.033863645,
0.0124242902,
-0.3326767087,
8.014e-7,
-0.0261969157,
-0.3407268822,
0.3507998288,
0.2170272768,
0.2986630499,
-0.4514428973,
0.3931759298,
-0.2826751471,
-0.1989420801,
0.1558042169,
-0.4757580459,
0.6925984025,
-0.375341177,
-0.4078039825,
-0.187431246,
0.0220026132,
0.3452271223,
-0.3159404993,
0.6965752244,
0.7522601485,
-0.3366709948,
0.0247765165,
-0.3582045436,
-0.2528668344,
-0.4143281877,
0.4603349268,
-0.5461428761,
-1.3156257868,
0.51372087,
-0.2969305813,
-0.1839827746,
0.4207092226,
0.4829817712,
-0.3298764229,
0.686540246,
0.6318029165,
-0.169702813,
0.6101620197,
-0.2124262303,
0.22411111,
-0.8530209661,
0.0108411098,
-0.2067515403,
0.0336018875,
-0.5007791519,
-0.7810215354,
-0.0182168484,
0.4162201583,
-0.0788625032,
-0.0695281625,
-0.2968370616,
0.6328231692,
0.2638025284,
0.038000036,
0.3569220901,
0.1083685681,
-0.1199687719,
-0.0019784775,
-0.506221354,
-0.989261806,
1.0578790903,
0.5151751637,
0.5529319644,
-0.143339172,
0.5082449913,
0.1105567962,
0.7350586653,
-0.8827326894,
0.4436687827,
-0.0406058058,
-0.7376897931,
-0.3088498116,
-0.3846761584,
-0.8093172908,
0.5079781413,
-0.1068204194,
-1.0438996553,
-0.1677260548,
-0.0077380273,
-0.5123170614,
0.2548289895,
-0.8049077988,
1.1207137108,
-0.2691852152,
-0.0068703787,
-0.2836573422,
-0.415573746,
0.3304716349,
-0.3598562777,
0.2230030447,
-0.2321136892,
0.0523660481,
0.7079129815,
-0.2488375157,
1.0584017038,
0.0265180748,
-0.2659238875,
0.3763391674,
-0.08947891,
0.3691524267,
-0.0282112639,
0.0559745021,
0.45602265,
0.0531073734,
-0.4512502551,
-0.6810817122,
0.3882958293,
-0.7043792605,
-0.6411383748,
-0.3420059085,
-0.6032645702,
-0.2538100183,
0.0749269649,
0.0856944397,
0.3019513786,
-0.179853335,
0.0919423848,
0.4348170459,
-0.1590451002,
0.1806111038,
0.4037103355,
-0.4525600076,
0.2712615132,
0.7364895344,
-0.1346527338,
0.4200660586,
0.341429621,
0.1479949653,
-0.2468476743,
-1.0100613832,
-0.2098567933,
0.1755017489,
-0.8051047325,
0.2658801079,
-0.6206921935,
-0.186371699,
-0.1811555922,
-0.0439808108,
-0.2454975545,
-0.2235618979,
-0.3746525943,
-0.2916765511,
0.306175828,
0.8646601439,
-0.0354838297,
1.1325355768,
-0.7074384093,
0.1990548223,
0.334988445,
0.4152103066,
-0.0920409933,
-0.5320283771,
-0.3920904994,
0.2029836029,
0.1490973234,
-0.6531462073,
0.2284781337,
0.1398013383,
0.4880543053,
0.3787828982,
-0.5886654854,
0.6691262126,
-0.6256031394,
0.8003929853,
0.1611223072,
-0.856308043,
0.6614041328,
-0.548719883,
0.1299920231,
0.3937186599,
0.398306489,
-0.6232689619,
-0.2013757527,
-0.6942671537,
-0.6411051154,
0.6236919165,
0.1342984587,
0.2414578199,
-0.0748018473,
0.5745514631,
0.0720438808,
0.2442420423,
-0.9503656626,
-0.042647969,
-0.0145532284,
-0.2170345485,
-0.4267348647,
-0.3463450372,
0.0386293754,
0.000880414,
0.4029400945,
-0.3453672528,
0.1992146522,
-0.2283631563,
-0.5238474011,
0.2511979043,
0.3133843839,
0.3086579442,
0.8518817425,
-0.2824361026,
0.3112734854,
0.2012577951,
-0.6040798426,
-0.1093845218,
0.2433916628,
-0.02451423,
-0.0146889118,
0.7741755843,
0.8763334155,
0.3100734949,
-0.5720813274,
0.5337959528,
-0.13406308,
0.2092394531,
-0.269321084,
0.0222266074,
0.4357829094,
0.3846531808,
0.1457432508,
-0.2344221771,
-0.0776795372,
-0.4864659607,
0.4532665014,
0.3489971757,
-0.605719924,
-0.4608213007,
0.4674948156,
-0.0817640647,
0.1892065406,
0.4505482316,
-0.2653644979,
-0.5331667662,
0.4510202706,
0.2430468351,
0.5578579307,
-0.0810244679,
0.1822948605,
-0.0246744864,
0.3318283856,
-0.0559484065,
-0.0210116096,
-0.0767600164,
-1.0723268986,
-0.9806220531,
-0.9075667858,
-0.4071801603,
0.27714926,
-0.6172655821,
-0.0517388694,
-0.1825553179,
0.036914669,
0.1800892949,
-0.0343991891,
-0.7269082069,
0.4446430802,
0.3817476332,
0.5985081196,
-0.8183470964,
1.2037192583,
0.7649788857,
-0.5789144039,
-0.851497829,
0.008235882,
-0.2501034141,
-1.1744645834,
1.1662131548,
0.1536906511,
0.0090404404,
0.2292702049,
-0.6474968791,
-0.7515822053,
0.9253032207,
0.2422278523,
-0.6264026165,
-0.0384342968,
0.433991164,
0.7208938599,
-0.5775372386,
0.6427058578,
0.9077139497,
0.2586185038,
0.152703926,
-0.9396318793,
-0.1437312067,
-0.0729497224,
-0.3105894327,
-0.1469891667,
-0.0887701586,
0.9345316291,
-0.0255893283,
-0.2990894914,
-0.2766302228,
0.6912506223,
0.112655811,
0.0644245818,
0.388009727,
0.3520568609,
0.8583108783,
-0.1535185575,
1.0509570837,
-0.1570398659,
0.4258978963,
1.4559366703,
-0.0754088983,
0.7716423273,
0.4620049596,
-0.3338929713,
0.278763473,
1.0635480881,
0.2575404644,
0.4156599939,
0.5771219134,
-0.2319657207,
-0.4060206711,
-0.2311342061,
-0.3161641657,
0.4405650795,
0.7275230885,
-0.2615647018,
-0.3446328342,
-0.080510281,
0.0430845916,
-0.231091857,
-0.4131560624,
0.7141773701,
0.5165228248,
-0.2586335838,
0.4169694781,
-0.4246585369,
0.8254230618,
-0.5189775825,
0.0086777993,
-0.162647143,
0.0272648502,
-0.1690400839,
-0.7559356093,
0.2305546701,
0.01662408,
0.2461501509,
-0.2232165188,
0.8478999734,
-0.4472636878,
-0.369369328,
0.3654354811,
0.9591366649,
0.6686422229,
-0.5092771649,
-0.5798677802,
0.0052438607,
-0.2272237539,
-0.43177706,
0.2124149203,
0.7682009339,
-0.0723855197,
0.6799400449,
0.5401388407,
0.3101531863,
0.1014276072,
0.2848840654,
1.0369411707,
-0.7683491707,
-0.3337857425,
-1.1081490517,
0.4137078822,
0.0450438038,
-0.0511682853,
0.4094997644,
0.2456913292,
0.9055776,
0.0931611136,
1.0215221643,
0.0458554365,
0.3709903955,
-0.6930642128,
0.7297536731,
-0.4078466892,
0.3007345796,
-0.0044177128,
-0.7775064707,
-0.4072471559,
0.929253161,
-0.9184273481,
-0.118222855,
0.6582306623,
0.6260227561,
-0.2091450393,
0.1951758415,
0.5306446552,
0.2692675889,
0.4145302474,
0.3051166832,
1.4216704369,
-0.0812848732,
0.2449010164,
0.108275272,
-0.0891151279,
-0.1479690671,
-0.934956789,
-1.2303680182,
-0.3443998098,
-0.2311894894,
0.0653097257,
-0.0931444019,
0.8361278176,
0.8644376397,
-0.7578574419,
-0.1556556076,
-0.1794101745,
-0.1882800609,
0.2635582685,
-0.1503801495,
0.5393317342,
-0.6979446411,
-0.6138960123,
0.4002223313,
0.153677851,
0.2961518168,
-0.3445259035,
0.0308395661,
-0.1337525249,
-0.2985590994,
0.799323678,
-0.2946858406,
-0.6478276849,
-0.5053693652,
-0.2389870435,
-0.0430100337,
0.2389818579,
0.8459548354,
-0.6478691697,
0.193454951,
0.0044044908,
0.7684618831,
0.6578671336,
-0.1655091792,
0.6001072526,
-0.7602966428,
0.3906441331,
0.3543087244,
0.3992059529,
0.286588788,
-0.1111328006,
0.6810342669,
0.0364085473,
-0.1868263483,
-0.5938495398,
0.3406045735,
-0.8929556608,
-0.3010965586,
1.2026866674,
-0.6096864343,
-0.1532246172,
-0.0099964645,
-0.0430110507,
0.3777156174,
0.0003949198,
0.4599047899,
1.0656037331,
-0.0166297052,
-0.3370567262,
-1.1610366106,
0.5434427857,
0.3873159289,
-1.0672097206,
0.0518796146,
0.4155180752,
0.1060431823,
0.2206022143,
0.7348806262,
-0.1248137727,
-0.2145704925,
-0.1579240561,
0.1494185776,
0.1661434323,
0.0146760605,
-0.4091706276,
-0.1822990775,
0.4194423556,
-0.1129509062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13309v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13309v1 | Evaluating Factual Consistency of Texts with Semantic Role Labeling | 2023-05-22T17:59:42 | 2023-05-22T17:59:42 | Jing Fan, Dennis Aumiller, Michael Gertz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated evaluation of text generation systems has recently seen increasing
attention, particularly checking whether generated text stays truthful to input
sources. Existing methods frequently rely on an evaluation using task-specific
language models, which in turn allows for little interpretability of generated
scores. We introduce SRLScore, a reference-free evaluation metric designed with
text summarization in mind. Our approach generates fact tuples constructed from
Semantic Role Labels, applied to both input and summary texts. A final
factuality score is computed by an adjustable scoring mechanism, which allows
for easy adaption of the method across domains. Correlation with human
judgments on English summarization datasets shows that SRLScore is competitive
with state-of-the-art methods and exhibits stable generalization across
datasets without requiring further training or hyperparameter tuning. We
experiment with an optional co-reference resolution step, but find that the
performance boost is mostly outweighed by the additional compute required. Our
metric is available online at https://github.com/heyjing/SRLScore. | [
0.0523759015,
-0.3199068606,
0.4891231358,
0.1532147527,
-0.3175593317,
-0.0063402569,
-0.3955477476,
-0.4140726328,
0.1298005581,
0.4622392356,
-0.4590695202,
-0.7639201283,
-0.7530864477,
0.4991904199,
-0.4027341902,
1.6288384199,
-0.045827195,
-0.2767899632,
-0.9715322256,
-0.3405076563,
-0.2836201191,
-0.2495804578,
-0.2540973425,
-0.3563364446,
0.4151453972,
0.4920122921,
0.7292322516,
0.7414530516,
0.7115929723,
0.3581030369,
0.1205739453,
0.6361294389,
-0.573654592,
0.4759888649,
-0.5246408582,
-0.2342613041,
-0.4675274193,
0.3335943222,
0.7580396533,
0.3344990015,
-0.0085685356,
0.581052959,
0.0908120275,
0.5854907036,
-0.6012212038,
0.2259042263,
-0.4966939092,
0.039711602,
0.1020982042,
-0.2955003977,
-0.6436211467,
-0.6439483762,
0.211673975,
-0.6084404588,
0.6442123055,
0.060463246,
1.0713355541,
0.3138800561,
-0.4064630866,
-0.5779373646,
-0.5640315413,
0.9916107059,
-0.4238163829,
0.4654838443,
0.2061704844,
0.0747607052,
0.1048695222,
-0.7445221543,
-0.2369262427,
-0.4978954494,
-0.4603606462,
0.6535794139,
-0.0928861126,
-0.1221264675,
0.1277689934,
0.3639472127,
-0.6003435254,
-0.4173474014,
-0.4402401447,
-0.4626400471,
0.7867515087,
0.0038911896,
0.3953458369,
-0.3812097907,
-0.5346900225,
0.1708799005,
-0.4053838849,
-0.0676856488,
0.2876010239,
0.2625760734,
-0.3287348151,
0.7607518435,
-0.0148965009,
0.4687974453,
-0.004174029,
-0.2598566115,
0.0780133083,
-0.7119344473,
-0.113391757,
0.1100237519,
0.7644227743,
0.5887999535,
0.1936603338,
-0.4824252427,
-0.1267276406,
0.2565628588,
0.4471177757,
-0.6551221609,
-0.0210309122,
0.1123772711,
-0.2950419188,
-0.3558775187,
0.2468836159,
-0.3458702862,
-0.1560257822,
-0.3413818479,
0.2526004016,
-0.4927684963,
0.0788036808,
-0.2194582224,
-0.4720359445,
-0.0826146007,
0.3368668258,
-0.5193440318,
0.3781119883,
0.639523685,
0.9144302607,
-0.4634713233,
-0.2773790359,
-0.7696724534,
0.2269353122,
-0.4560631514,
1.11396873,
-0.2786447704,
-0.5432518721,
-0.2534390986,
-0.1832117736,
-0.1843864471,
-0.5774872899,
0.9571710825,
-0.4939796627,
0.3323077261,
-0.244784832,
-0.614010632,
0.1265550256,
0.5063578486,
-0.588209331,
1.2458047867,
-0.2131352276,
-0.7252457738,
0.5150857568,
-0.3000231385,
-0.536182344,
-0.1286374778,
-0.1381095648,
-0.4195231795,
0.2846288681,
-0.2212942243,
0.1147017032,
-0.3033882678,
0.4778620601,
0.1572682709,
-0.2842827141,
0.1389349848,
-0.1490653455,
0.4703723192,
0.1635118723,
-0.0669878721,
0.3597757816,
-0.683580637,
0.1080251634,
-0.3299401402,
-0.4263006449,
-0.3161217272,
0.1448890269,
-0.3434240222,
0.0822681487,
0.2429630607,
-0.5159077048,
-0.2520819902,
-0.1925462037,
-0.2358959466,
0.556450963,
0.069882609,
0.2198656648,
-0.4775831699,
0.2418760508,
-0.0039261864,
-0.0350096636,
-0.0962294489,
-0.3993243277,
-0.869161427,
-0.2958763838,
0.5346147418,
0.6091476679,
-0.6375230551,
0.9045825005,
-0.4636343122,
-0.84297961,
-0.2881320119,
0.0555176176,
0.7605414987,
0.8098458052,
0.4870827198,
-0.4538391829,
-0.6154381633,
-1.0405372381,
-0.692671299,
-0.3738715947,
0.011143459,
0.0734731257,
0.479190737,
-0.0707628429,
1.2775142193,
-0.494277209,
-0.3834311664,
-0.3341732323,
0.4171438217,
-0.0101124002,
0.4842185676,
0.1695258319,
-0.5871719718,
-0.3862904012,
-0.2429482341,
-1.0394054651,
-0.4568517506,
-0.1471010894,
-0.0496907793,
0.1776717752,
0.2050107718,
-0.5481230617,
0.2263959348,
0.6639009118,
-0.4317670763,
0.9545378685,
-0.4910045266,
0.4813297987,
-0.7809163332,
0.3279708028,
0.2143951505,
-0.4413445294,
-0.3560786247,
0.0063388953,
0.0164056998,
-0.0915355831,
-0.0434596464,
0.279746294,
-0.3638797104,
-0.3521601558,
-0.0473675951,
0.7813913822,
0.4190231562,
0.0112142032,
0.1013602838,
0.9186441302,
0.0412719622,
-0.7927714586,
0.2374594063,
0.1669168323,
-0.5331149101,
0.6511110067,
-0.770721972,
-0.0435164273,
-0.2427922487,
0.4584183097,
-0.9649096727,
-0.0217723083,
-0.035060823,
-0.5819174647,
-0.1643193215,
0.0255391784,
-0.5099900961,
0.1237577945,
-0.33388713,
0.0495827273,
0.3302355409,
-0.1739657223,
0.5313332677,
0.3840527833,
-0.083077535,
-0.5833220482,
-0.6439825296,
0.0906254351,
0.2454367876,
-0.6104931831,
0.49429968,
-0.2128476351,
-0.3365705311,
0.3406332433,
-0.522082746,
0.0085387118,
-0.047663521,
0.0772608444,
0.3716726303,
-0.2242678404,
0.2663618922,
0.2644553185,
-0.4319145679,
-0.0441954099,
-0.0110473614,
-0.1014200225,
-0.1411747187,
-0.1658861488,
-0.2707204819,
0.2808803916,
0.4925349951,
-0.2363791615,
0.5343427658,
0.3355291188,
-0.1945358366,
-0.2741810083,
-0.3260090351,
0.087266162,
-0.3426315188,
0.2232333124,
-0.3035131097,
-0.6368660927,
0.3094770014,
0.0106166275,
0.3620401919,
0.7614466548,
0.4184959829,
-0.0574006028,
0.6434157491,
0.4137202501,
0.6109503508,
-0.0134091526,
-0.0230886079,
0.1249511689,
-0.439607203,
-0.1300163716,
-0.6289803982,
-0.0341351256,
-0.4004420638,
-0.5064047575,
0.5517559052,
-0.049909737,
0.1997457594,
0.3715664446,
-0.2984560728,
0.6812548637,
0.3083599806,
-0.0726610944,
0.7838277817,
-0.1273004264,
-0.156912148,
-0.2705611587,
-0.6008662581,
-0.7575182915,
0.5681940913,
0.1093529388,
0.3146308064,
0.2820588648,
0.7209500074,
0.8808470368,
0.6446390152,
-0.6967290044,
0.736418128,
-0.4328208566,
-0.5676232576,
-0.1013207361,
-0.6066238284,
-0.481453687,
0.508026123,
-0.5391203761,
-0.2315528691,
-0.2327369452,
0.2511542439,
-0.2823188603,
-0.1454743296,
-0.863691926,
0.7049424052,
-0.0343489945,
-0.5246806145,
-0.3548737168,
-0.6301547885,
0.4765202999,
0.173228845,
0.3329865336,
-0.2066652775,
-0.132850945,
0.9343646765,
-0.3991482556,
0.7920256853,
0.0015398185,
-0.1897345632,
0.532574892,
0.0232965462,
0.3590489328,
0.0396378115,
-0.3583500981,
0.0925066099,
0.2236290425,
-0.2227909118,
-0.5996899605,
0.8118753433,
-0.7168613076,
-0.4278437495,
-0.7498835921,
-0.4601269662,
-0.3825251758,
0.4318609238,
0.3954901099,
0.4936773181,
-0.5844424963,
0.246999532,
0.6037778854,
-0.0995113254,
0.0212069601,
0.4879610837,
-0.0545386449,
-0.4728294015,
0.778636694,
0.3014042377,
0.2493938357,
0.2643867135,
0.4222697318,
-0.3814435303,
-0.1121277884,
-0.7380579114,
0.2043268979,
-0.708298564,
-0.3722093403,
-0.5666235089,
-0.2673546672,
-0.5167751312,
-0.1039784998,
-0.4815688729,
-0.5013750196,
0.0968929157,
-0.3537640572,
0.0633644983,
0.6081892848,
-0.1055376679,
-0.018814411,
-1.1239318848,
0.4722696245,
0.1248413548,
0.5308614373,
-0.268963784,
-0.4580353498,
-0.3906250596,
-0.2512971759,
-0.077497445,
-0.6613500118,
-0.1572310179,
0.356346935,
0.5724967122,
-0.0124690756,
0.3841819763,
0.4841662943,
-0.4088928103,
0.9661107659,
0.2864804566,
-1.1905236244,
0.3851493597,
-0.0192065109,
0.3164878786,
0.892595768,
0.1776533425,
-0.6214574575,
-0.5568245649,
-0.6552528739,
-0.6311117411,
0.5487609506,
0.3336361945,
-0.0285390578,
0.0024220068,
0.1256022602,
0.3566558361,
0.1716246605,
-0.4379636645,
-0.339841187,
-0.2141627818,
-0.5358745456,
-0.0714854822,
-0.4091100097,
-0.2878394723,
0.0753580481,
0.888659358,
0.0399602577,
-0.1593568921,
0.6240132451,
-0.430573523,
-0.0926877484,
0.3869387805,
0.7872561812,
0.7950692177,
-0.2543251812,
0.5133817792,
0.0768301561,
-0.6420363784,
0.0573650561,
-0.1996869296,
-0.5339462161,
0.4127983749,
0.7029179931,
0.489798218,
0.4564453959,
-0.8105784655,
0.5295094252,
-0.1250810176,
-0.2163052112,
-0.1091036648,
0.2045690864,
-0.2719169855,
-0.0634735823,
0.1946388036,
0.4325345755,
0.119366318,
-0.4545625448,
0.5558601022,
-0.0318074599,
-0.6044818163,
-0.4020171463,
0.2752244771,
0.4897962511,
-0.0336910337,
0.283860743,
-0.2004031688,
-0.3370424807,
0.4739560187,
0.6616510749,
0.9618358612,
-0.0945671201,
0.5352320075,
0.5153955817,
0.4447057247,
0.1256356388,
-0.0455885306,
-0.190330267,
-0.8784303069,
-0.516066432,
-0.5077646971,
-0.7557321787,
-0.3384206295,
-0.6099217534,
0.2347073108,
-0.3128218055,
-0.1988314688,
-0.173919946,
0.0838861018,
-0.1701779217,
0.6920516491,
-0.2395637929,
1.0299112797,
-0.9495449066,
0.6206945777,
0.7560259104,
-0.3057169616,
-0.2562699318,
0.1476612985,
0.0313037895,
-0.3260498047,
0.5305759311,
0.078944847,
-0.7083140612,
-0.1061636806,
-0.1846466511,
-0.7783008814,
0.9993148446,
0.2401038855,
-0.0619441345,
0.0741348267,
-0.2098582089,
0.6545311809,
-0.3090088367,
0.2461584657,
0.4481317103,
0.4971494377,
-0.0225586761,
-0.7464311719,
0.0452795252,
-0.3096162975,
-0.2723829448,
-0.1328776777,
-0.6339433789,
0.2659530938,
-0.2384163886,
-0.5997950435,
-0.0835181326,
0.9358842969,
0.5704230666,
0.4832798541,
0.6844106317,
0.5129917264,
0.8832058311,
-0.0256598815,
0.8829358816,
-0.3750238419,
0.4894849956,
1.2763614655,
-0.3594368994,
0.5270624161,
0.2529724538,
0.0229793843,
0.685857594,
0.0817670003,
0.0137594761,
0.3584627211,
0.0179973785,
-0.1932470649,
-0.344366163,
-0.453561157,
-0.1905507892,
0.4881088138,
0.1074663922,
-0.3246576786,
-0.6322499514,
-0.5090215206,
0.024299005,
0.6172576547,
-0.0442447923,
0.6665847898,
-0.0262623783,
-1.0143851042,
0.1568306088,
0.196259737,
0.4092615247,
-0.8270721436,
-0.0302534699,
-0.0769298375,
0.1196913272,
-0.4573895037,
-0.7672240734,
0.8020635247,
0.5135356188,
-0.5672205091,
-0.2733843327,
0.8878370523,
-0.408690393,
-0.4700548947,
0.0963473693,
0.4949827194,
0.1221438944,
0.6243052483,
-0.4221187234,
0.1985041499,
-0.1979968101,
-0.1371895969,
0.0578521192,
0.3253215551,
-0.0184032414,
0.3206231594,
0.5974500775,
0.1539139599,
-0.2607886791,
-0.0399804413,
0.4853287339,
-0.578275919,
-0.5030350685,
-0.6123412848,
0.5681646466,
-0.4602182508,
-0.5232389569,
0.9917767048,
1.016280055,
0.5593914986,
-0.1462964118,
1.0477850437,
-0.1772751212,
0.7569246292,
-0.4590140283,
0.6510735154,
-0.2758119404,
0.0594256967,
-0.1252629906,
-0.7152959704,
-0.4476648569,
0.4059662819,
-0.4539707899,
-0.2391883731,
0.7589620352,
0.5501243472,
-0.113488242,
0.1376676708,
0.2803187668,
0.0033165745,
0.1611849368,
-0.0775855109,
0.5726929903,
-0.534452796,
0.4652198851,
-0.0442054197,
-0.5169913173,
-0.0502486899,
-1.1755114794,
-0.5159350634,
-0.4485532939,
-0.5331181288,
-0.5789967775,
0.1663050354,
0.8491655588,
0.5535634756,
-0.8262076378,
-0.331390053,
0.1634513736,
0.4685012102,
-0.4165844917,
-0.2593286335,
0.3836268485,
-0.6375157833,
-0.6587596536,
0.4246889353,
0.4656929672,
-0.4068014324,
-0.0286402255,
0.0351675302,
-0.0909617469,
0.4073332846,
0.7968937159,
0.0418856628,
-0.4064692557,
-0.5528535843,
-0.0794586018,
-0.4229093492,
-0.1800549924,
0.969370544,
-0.615365684,
0.3753069639,
0.7516776323,
0.5516342521,
0.191912353,
0.5492839217,
0.585462153,
-0.9662525654,
-0.2298831791,
0.0217101164,
0.0747299045,
0.3696288764,
-0.2523202598,
0.5611758828,
0.5809326172,
-0.4445370436,
-0.7116215825,
0.3378046155,
-0.986274004,
-0.07956402,
0.8907796741,
-0.3225573599,
-0.1554619819,
-0.1086668223,
-0.0379823595,
0.4583735764,
-0.2845086753,
0.7876070142,
0.6160641313,
-0.2638734877,
0.1271500736,
-0.2005151659,
0.5489613414,
0.3121070564,
-0.733058691,
0.2446028739,
0.7690884471,
0.2514111996,
0.5215054154,
0.6884388924,
-0.204526037,
0.2093415558,
0.0062409975,
0.062181741,
-0.0642436221,
-0.4664034545,
0.2780960798,
0.2905237675,
-0.146295011,
-0.0044160835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13304v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13304v1 | RecurrentGPT: Interactive Generation of (Arbitrarily) Long Text | 2023-05-22T17:58:10 | 2023-05-22T17:58:10 | Wangchunshu Zhou, Yuchen Eleanor Jiang, Peng Cui, Tiannan Wang, Zhenxin Xiao, Yifan Hou, Ryan Cotterell, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The fixed-size context of Transformer makes GPT models incapable of
generating arbitrarily long text. In this paper, we introduce RecurrentGPT, a
language-based simulacrum of the recurrence mechanism in RNNs. RecurrentGPT is
built upon a large language model (LLM) such as ChatGPT and uses natural
language to simulate the Long Short-Term Memory mechanism in an LSTM. At each
timestep, RecurrentGPT generates a paragraph of text and updates its
language-based long-short term memory stored on the hard drive and the prompt,
respectively. This recurrence mechanism enables RecurrentGPT to generate texts
of arbitrary length without forgetting. Since human users can easily observe
and edit the natural language memories, RecurrentGPT is interpretable and
enables interactive generation of long text. RecurrentGPT is an initial step
towards next-generation computer-assisted writing systems beyond local editing
suggestions. In addition to producing AI-generated content (AIGC), we also
demonstrate the possibility of using RecurrentGPT as an interactive fiction
that directly interacts with consumers. We call this usage of generative models
by ``AI As Contents'' (AIAC), which we believe is the next form of conventional
AIGC. We further demonstrate the possibility of using RecurrentGPT to create
personalized interactive fiction that directly interacts with readers instead
of interacting with writers. More broadly, RecurrentGPT demonstrates the
utility of borrowing ideas from popular model designs in cognitive science and
deep learning for prompting LLMs. Our code is available at
https://github.com/aiwaves-cn/RecurrentGPT and an online demo is available at
https://www.aiwaves.org/recurrentgpt. | [
-0.4089324176,
-1.1667206287,
0.7223116755,
0.2951527834,
-0.2659231424,
0.194091633,
-0.4759994447,
-0.3523032367,
0.2190617621,
0.5121273398,
-0.8907817602,
-0.1322072744,
-0.2427695692,
0.2425775975,
-0.5025097728,
1.3261826038,
-0.2667956054,
-0.4107036889,
-0.2781756818,
0.1599468887,
-0.4389846027,
-0.5417299271,
-0.8643655181,
-0.4401634932,
0.8124542832,
-0.0639484972,
0.9011932015,
0.4688406885,
0.4887345433,
0.3020594418,
0.1658849418,
0.3442768455,
-0.6293305159,
0.4358437657,
0.0752351135,
-0.0863588825,
-0.2221450806,
-0.2711952925,
0.6467136741,
0.3329077959,
-0.3247669935,
-0.197034657,
0.1708454788,
0.5114951134,
-0.0969851762,
0.0974540785,
-0.2512770593,
0.1100049615,
-0.1700227112,
-0.2319349349,
-0.4884732068,
-0.4984375238,
0.1086098924,
-0.469945848,
0.1262132525,
0.217100367,
0.4427403808,
0.1734611243,
-0.2001035661,
-0.7411751747,
-1.0593503714,
0.6389501691,
-0.5610278845,
0.0877868831,
-0.0487681963,
0.1479767114,
-0.3451448679,
-1.2703639269,
-0.9359910488,
-0.9496510029,
-0.0970956236,
0.22522448,
-0.3300194144,
0.0952953771,
0.529908061,
0.3932976127,
-0.5919806957,
-0.2264715731,
-0.1378460228,
0.2459967285,
0.3436250389,
0.4793115258,
0.5423135161,
-0.1201389208,
-0.4693077207,
0.1832584739,
-0.6509343982,
-0.1961800605,
0.4207009673,
-0.0008692846,
-0.0677385628,
0.6590889692,
0.0943213031,
0.7020818591,
0.09755373,
0.0525036193,
-0.0989925489,
-0.0970805138,
-0.088551797,
0.1354818344,
0.9650608897,
0.0977969989,
0.5077297688,
-0.0689542964,
-0.037760295,
-0.1278697401,
0.4545080662,
-0.7811185122,
-0.2593024373,
-0.0073720068,
-0.2971236408,
-0.3736142814,
0.0937639549,
-0.5661670566,
-0.2298156172,
-0.4212243259,
0.3196783662,
-0.599168539,
-0.0806501806,
0.1477964967,
0.0845960304,
-0.084273763,
0.2397680581,
-0.8427571058,
0.2882345021,
0.457901895,
0.9187197685,
-0.5792595744,
-0.5722723603,
-0.2026600987,
0.411292851,
0.1451529264,
0.6999601126,
-0.3693355024,
-0.4568691552,
-0.091837354,
-0.2385284901,
0.0111460891,
-0.1112352014,
0.058750838,
-0.4386467934,
0.394220531,
0.0937630162,
-0.6115278006,
-0.0345343091,
0.3113862276,
-0.8449560404,
0.8856506944,
0.155758366,
-0.8067296147,
0.0403696261,
-0.7210481763,
-0.5173894167,
0.1378522962,
-0.2352756411,
-0.483587414,
-0.2632557154,
0.0469578654,
0.2157096118,
-0.2533587813,
0.595497489,
0.0179235488,
-0.3671213686,
0.5893516541,
-1.1052001715,
0.1542246044,
0.3455162644,
-0.4070207775,
0.1328224242,
-0.4605382681,
-0.1691436172,
0.1974962652,
-0.634101212,
0.2285207808,
-0.0132616088,
0.2225993723,
-0.1419962943,
0.3949654102,
-0.5247449279,
0.531014204,
0.0233085826,
0.714081347,
0.5284184813,
0.3417322338,
0.226595372,
-0.7618480325,
0.7233393192,
-0.3213933408,
-0.0474240668,
-0.59812814,
-0.5302197933,
-0.7967847586,
-0.1527764946,
0.2363026887,
0.6119829416,
-1.0016485453,
0.1164667979,
-0.3409613371,
-0.2723447382,
-0.0883489549,
-0.1311531961,
0.0798131004,
0.0943863615,
0.2540137172,
-0.1009676903,
-0.355663985,
-0.6316999197,
-0.2788408399,
0.0525352992,
-0.1211897656,
0.350907445,
0.1945607364,
-0.2051507682,
0.9968544245,
-0.6181926727,
-0.0686783567,
-0.6716293097,
0.4856981635,
0.206362918,
0.4073987901,
0.2757788301,
-0.7038626075,
-0.5358423591,
0.0998615995,
-0.7722364068,
-0.0038653004,
-0.6782266498,
0.1681567132,
0.344922483,
0.6839743257,
-1.0194964409,
0.4296443462,
0.4010865688,
-0.0527386852,
0.3495595455,
-0.4520240128,
0.1467661858,
-1.118573308,
0.1348415613,
-0.2794500589,
-0.435503453,
-0.4441188574,
0.0554346815,
-0.3484110832,
-0.3975774646,
-0.2886970639,
0.5889915228,
-0.4578676522,
0.2294888198,
-0.4743575156,
0.0880097076,
-0.1672846526,
0.5905769467,
0.35586375,
0.7485513687,
-0.0839504749,
-0.4222610593,
0.5184102058,
0.0397490188,
-0.4429191351,
0.114470996,
-0.6165088415,
0.1297560483,
-0.2632358968,
0.5147185922,
-0.6108602285,
-0.2995303869,
0.3327851593,
-0.1700040698,
0.2449628115,
0.0790177062,
-0.4656744599,
-0.3206528723,
0.176704213,
0.5539892316,
0.6839889288,
-0.4200741351,
0.66295439,
-0.1828265488,
-0.7054644227,
-0.1792003214,
-0.714345336,
0.2719311416,
-0.1664715707,
-0.60736835,
0.2237552404,
-0.3446343839,
0.0536715388,
0.038807027,
0.5605302453,
0.2476510853,
-0.4009547234,
0.2595925331,
-0.0450075231,
-0.2254274338,
0.2060224265,
0.2146450728,
-0.1764441282,
-0.1444023997,
-0.2105775774,
0.881922245,
-0.2676547766,
-0.5996337533,
-0.4309201241,
0.684263587,
0.3833750784,
-0.0613721535,
0.4509249628,
0.6688255668,
-0.012777322,
-0.3300457895,
-0.4243215919,
-0.0998666659,
-0.5074906349,
0.258972466,
-0.2578043044,
-1.0844122171,
0.3149304092,
-0.1558158994,
0.0076769893,
0.2022445351,
0.7634299397,
-0.0123224361,
0.5517888069,
0.3911394179,
0.1089328602,
0.5730313659,
-0.036905393,
0.3417781889,
-0.5369555354,
-0.1042116135,
0.073936373,
-0.3218615651,
-0.5487003922,
-0.3853507042,
0.2920005322,
-0.1173152998,
-0.5244220495,
0.2237997502,
-0.5304268599,
0.5026807785,
0.6747761369,
0.1296790689,
0.5256327391,
0.1587854922,
0.0849003345,
-0.1434528828,
-0.6925516129,
-0.346119225,
0.5622699261,
0.4150458574,
1.0846604109,
0.1482521743,
0.8067606688,
0.6568358541,
0.5180237293,
-0.750518322,
0.4084316492,
0.0117160641,
-0.2025337666,
-0.2818662822,
-0.3332381845,
-1.0011655092,
-0.2693073153,
-0.0584990606,
-0.4817992151,
-0.0559273399,
0.1317575723,
-0.4713594615,
0.451371938,
-0.4597154558,
0.4503269196,
-0.1935365647,
-0.4299940765,
-0.0152119417,
-0.2907186151,
0.1130584851,
0.0762083977,
-0.1720263362,
0.3162236214,
0.1111614555,
0.2450814992,
-0.272701323,
1.0549640656,
0.2782017291,
-0.0520848371,
0.6884233952,
0.4612705112,
0.7181269526,
0.2350323796,
0.0970252752,
0.0305860396,
-0.4177038968,
-0.0146605317,
-0.5189731121,
0.9427569509,
-0.3690026999,
-0.6232523322,
-0.7224766016,
-0.7150514722,
0.2335855514,
0.4029871225,
0.4379233122,
0.4046424925,
-0.494348377,
0.1873377264,
0.5337795615,
-0.2726545334,
0.6374476552,
0.1102619693,
-0.4153780937,
-0.4729641676,
1.0110840797,
-0.1108762249,
0.4319084287,
0.3730425239,
-0.0449738801,
-0.1099528819,
-0.4431873262,
-0.5177331567,
0.0597647689,
-0.3191191852,
-0.1595024467,
-0.7538886666,
-0.674274683,
0.1180255339,
-0.4291969836,
-0.0968434662,
-0.2638739347,
-0.307879895,
-0.1591891348,
0.6935362816,
1.1132620573,
-0.0865148604,
0.5410789251,
-0.6822908521,
0.43694821,
0.3028498292,
0.2684450448,
0.2227395475,
-0.1741266698,
0.0004360063,
0.1428960562,
-0.4740059376,
-0.4963101149,
0.5178123713,
-0.1193290651,
0.1508946419,
0.1453840882,
-0.1316383779,
0.3178311586,
-0.7722947001,
0.9103726745,
0.2078146636,
-0.8061820269,
0.1101874039,
-0.811745286,
0.4953273237,
0.2428617477,
0.276979357,
-0.8326892257,
-0.4485734105,
-0.5457566977,
-0.7985365391,
0.3922615647,
0.5679165721,
0.4445648491,
-0.5087373853,
0.4696115851,
0.1419341862,
0.3842370212,
-1.0166927576,
-0.1062287167,
-0.3419961929,
-0.3593128026,
0.1066989079,
-0.465370357,
0.2202932239,
0.2985442281,
0.4665204585,
-0.0399100184,
0.4449656606,
0.4756603837,
0.1228220761,
0.0344144143,
0.2044326663,
0.8332304358,
0.4800953865,
-0.1437378526,
-0.1557834148,
-0.0710647926,
-0.6752247214,
-0.0353960544,
0.0450311191,
-0.4669867158,
-0.0824477896,
0.4382600486,
0.9280359149,
0.2151881456,
-0.5125479698,
0.3169435859,
-0.1252509803,
-0.1005349234,
-1.0114015341,
0.0234337524,
0.3638378978,
0.1865967065,
0.128366217,
-0.0002869604,
-0.0898224339,
-0.4790034294,
0.418399483,
0.226893723,
-0.5287854671,
0.1559823751,
0.7644744515,
0.278321445,
-0.5899863243,
0.9790689945,
-0.0902759954,
-0.1635159254,
0.5633360744,
0.7956004143,
0.8237425685,
-0.0665965155,
0.2995174825,
0.2242691517,
0.1839720458,
-0.1138719916,
0.1568899006,
0.0740335137,
-0.5268146992,
-0.4051368833,
-0.6543636918,
-0.2903695405,
0.3276305199,
-0.51728338,
0.2528157234,
-0.6369365454,
-0.0733143017,
-0.1833270788,
-0.3228162527,
-0.2474448979,
-0.0521899238,
0.1123444363,
0.7682228088,
-0.2830686867,
0.8589913845,
0.2507938147,
-0.5403145552,
-0.5000719428,
0.165026471,
-0.2462883294,
-0.5506058931,
0.3422217667,
0.0648998395,
-0.0642410144,
0.3151703179,
-0.4002083838,
-0.6266898513,
1.2889424562,
0.0976566896,
-0.6795110703,
-0.1283651888,
0.4470149875,
0.6745095253,
-0.6568787694,
0.1452584267,
0.3448102176,
0.5954625607,
0.0348282382,
-0.5855308771,
0.1635744274,
-0.0992030725,
0.1287168413,
0.4789743721,
-0.6490795612,
0.8987121582,
-0.2939860225,
-0.1827313304,
0.7505865693,
0.8692715764,
0.3513179421,
0.2569372356,
0.1845842749,
0.389637053,
0.4030783176,
-0.0216887575,
1.4423072338,
-0.0752604082,
0.3430055678,
1.2182139158,
-0.136516124,
0.6452126503,
0.5008416772,
-0.0213863999,
0.7672985196,
0.3246785402,
-0.3214108646,
0.2969947159,
0.478146106,
-0.8111405969,
-0.2270865589,
-0.017611092,
-0.403822124,
0.0335618444,
0.3527710438,
-0.4648597836,
-0.2665900886,
0.2011537701,
0.0756020546,
0.2483003885,
-0.0092058787,
0.9091042876,
0.44732669,
-0.6717882156,
0.2248127162,
-0.0259681735,
0.5157251954,
-0.8668292165,
-0.320610553,
-0.2412748039,
0.100614123,
0.0741110295,
-1.0455272198,
0.1741369516,
-0.0898843706,
-0.4619517624,
-0.1836981922,
0.6929385662,
-0.7543446422,
-0.617536068,
0.0123553704,
0.3023456037,
0.0569379739,
-0.0592836998,
-0.498498708,
-0.0007260085,
0.2815380991,
-0.543497026,
0.3530757427,
0.4446313083,
-0.2367881238,
0.8707700372,
0.8292259574,
0.007317523,
-0.0899831057,
0.0989337936,
0.7388337255,
-0.892852366,
-0.612891674,
-0.7544654608,
0.3565112054,
0.0970884115,
-0.1230809242,
0.4349842072,
0.3338481486,
0.4771507382,
-0.4098470807,
1.0875095129,
-0.2539761364,
0.3739404678,
-0.7084702253,
0.9639850259,
-0.2143944204,
0.2298358083,
0.0480270572,
-1.0578993559,
-0.1511245966,
0.2813775241,
-0.2041092515,
0.2995066643,
0.7163749933,
0.5094621181,
-0.3767309487,
0.1865331233,
0.2157214284,
0.1135204285,
0.3517649174,
0.4711506069,
0.9428405762,
-0.0963823274,
0.6183274984,
-0.2176039815,
-0.0223131031,
-0.0574689433,
-1.1598445177,
-0.9551969171,
-0.5204765201,
0.00530115,
-0.2406541705,
0.122470364,
0.7972478867,
0.0848822147,
-0.5392288566,
-0.0718863159,
-0.4591379762,
-0.0468094051,
-0.0209860038,
-0.3015423417,
0.4569834769,
-0.1203733981,
-0.8160461783,
0.1866706461,
0.1895993054,
0.3724882901,
-0.3108907938,
-0.0087560033,
0.029312443,
0.1126346961,
0.7223483324,
0.4410091341,
-0.5479533672,
-0.2856081724,
-0.2133410871,
0.0508336276,
-0.0598439351,
1.1756155491,
-0.8248617649,
0.1524047405,
0.3397641182,
0.5669974089,
0.6841515303,
0.2083075345,
0.9034318924,
-0.5525433421,
0.1821502447,
0.2655494511,
0.1039105505,
0.185642153,
-0.7792027593,
0.1580671072,
-0.0143954773,
-0.7582253218,
-0.4293836653,
0.6573956609,
-1.1673521996,
-0.2549782395,
1.2985390425,
-0.1480869651,
-0.0924908966,
-0.0972050503,
-0.5147640109,
-0.010178145,
-0.5200414658,
0.7235305309,
0.5696223378,
-0.3123714924,
-0.3292907178,
-0.5161506534,
0.7125159502,
0.1091966629,
-0.8013920784,
0.2461721003,
0.4539437294,
0.2581790984,
0.196868971,
0.636762619,
-0.0322797038,
0.2597945333,
-0.030867124,
0.1724862158,
-0.5443798304,
-0.3473961949,
-0.1217480227,
0.137490049,
-0.0526942685,
0.3952378631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13303v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13303v3 | Towards Unsupervised Recognition of Token-level Semantic Differences in Related Documents | 2023-05-22T17:58:04 | 2023-10-20T12:27:41 | Jannis Vamvas, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatically highlighting words that cause semantic differences between two
documents could be useful for a wide range of applications. We formulate
recognizing semantic differences (RSD) as a token-level regression task and
study three unsupervised approaches that rely on a masked language model. To
assess the approaches, we begin with basic English sentences and gradually move
to more complex, cross-lingual document pairs. Our results show that an
approach based on word alignment and sentence-level contrastive learning has a
robust correlation to gold labels. However, all unsupervised approaches still
leave a large margin of improvement. Code to reproduce our experiments is
available at https://github.com/ZurichNLP/recognizing-semantic-differences | [
-0.1581313014,
-0.4796373844,
0.1970900744,
-0.0649163276,
-0.2139283568,
0.353636831,
-0.1176693887,
-0.5943363905,
0.3296411932,
0.4464704692,
-0.5027484894,
-0.6807612777,
-0.9121983647,
0.2590380907,
-0.5524300337,
0.8816546798,
-0.0536341369,
0.2526046932,
-0.2374492288,
-0.2512429953,
-0.5292755961,
-0.2101373225,
-0.4032847583,
-0.2798066735,
0.4647692442,
0.1628568619,
0.3181331456,
0.7411615252,
0.6030708551,
0.3132482767,
-0.2476507574,
0.3317846954,
0.189022392,
0.3128199279,
-0.5795997381,
-0.2470503449,
0.0674473345,
-0.07922066,
0.3959450126,
0.74316746,
0.3764414191,
-0.1905153543,
0.2046021372,
0.6425156593,
-0.7213137746,
0.4475491941,
-0.8159071803,
0.1752116084,
-0.4792369902,
0.0914542526,
-0.168028906,
0.4017609954,
0.0233286321,
-0.7307485938,
0.4946836829,
-0.0118664633,
1.1125737429,
0.0660030767,
-0.4433097243,
-0.3829915822,
-0.3990071118,
0.7341915369,
-0.5411467552,
0.679677546,
0.4198205769,
-0.0865750238,
-0.0387754552,
-0.9456138611,
-0.4631173909,
0.098969005,
-0.3557587862,
0.1323055178,
-0.3614122272,
-0.0576011688,
0.253131628,
0.2021217048,
-0.6073971391,
0.2819829285,
-0.3051167428,
-0.6643235087,
0.2801640034,
0.1316431761,
0.2884721458,
-0.5355732441,
-0.0839162096,
-0.2212370038,
-0.5301703811,
0.0575745925,
0.2333396375,
0.5944361091,
-0.0524301119,
0.4437333643,
-0.5031227469,
0.5890449286,
0.0178279988,
-0.1913758963,
0.3381331265,
-0.2871285975,
-0.0903175622,
-0.0394346267,
0.3542866409,
0.4746433794,
0.0195750985,
-0.5202076435,
-0.4592653513,
0.5440343022,
-0.1801910549,
-0.5333914161,
-0.4600561559,
-0.0944981351,
-0.5091760159,
-0.2418937981,
0.3884878457,
-0.5260310769,
-0.7352927327,
-0.3393367529,
0.7475387454,
-0.163538307,
-0.2225887775,
0.4018310308,
-0.6551448107,
0.1117207184,
0.3793932498,
-0.8345475793,
0.4082415998,
0.9386051893,
0.8289247751,
-0.3911938369,
-0.1973170191,
-0.7484657764,
0.1423875242,
-0.4716914594,
0.9975409508,
-0.5183186531,
-0.4273362756,
0.1245875582,
0.2448226511,
-0.1559467465,
-0.6199318171,
0.4203714728,
-0.5080932975,
0.3377210498,
-0.1369755119,
-0.6155304313,
-0.0139527582,
0.1919894814,
-0.7550996542,
1.2811596394,
0.1836253703,
-1.3323334455,
0.6724433303,
-0.6126357913,
-0.6185133457,
0.1414182782,
-0.1687827408,
-0.414519161,
0.0873818472,
0.1723277569,
0.40929088,
0.0111181308,
0.0734288543,
0.0409609675,
-0.1901364177,
0.2969119549,
-0.1818126142,
0.7627187371,
0.2664806247,
-0.314561367,
0.3751657903,
-1.1327137947,
-0.3788919747,
-0.1163534299,
-0.105344601,
-0.9409824014,
0.070365563,
0.2246696502,
0.0902164727,
0.3172238767,
-0.864394486,
-0.0610789284,
-0.2757724524,
0.4760485291,
0.7312533855,
-0.1003814414,
0.4556603432,
0.0362007134,
0.2201511115,
0.4849864542,
0.1001813486,
-0.1525859386,
-0.2322799712,
-0.9140422344,
-0.4894412756,
0.8311585784,
0.351978004,
-0.594052434,
0.6017411351,
0.1939444244,
-0.0241493862,
-0.5561231971,
0.0908878222,
0.4458444118,
0.7134167552,
0.3267156184,
-0.4139958322,
-0.6048588753,
-0.7724170685,
-0.3085850179,
-0.2049462944,
-0.1192888245,
-0.0581401996,
0.6579922438,
-0.2843247354,
1.0216062069,
-0.6690167189,
-0.66195786,
-0.0569447391,
0.4704123735,
-0.3877235055,
0.5034890771,
0.2976279259,
-1.0430585146,
-0.4857042432,
0.1455258429,
-0.5135134459,
-0.3930478692,
0.1288889349,
-0.1419311613,
0.3985984921,
1.2169036865,
-0.4605821073,
0.5673886538,
0.1562073976,
-0.5521915555,
0.0863274634,
-0.3346507251,
-0.1505988985,
-1.1801491976,
-0.2103597373,
0.053780321,
-0.2634395063,
-0.4103850424,
-0.1557034403,
0.2480255812,
0.0491741188,
-0.3146694303,
0.6245338917,
-0.5047358871,
-0.4782852829,
-0.1887072325,
0.342433989,
0.3557201922,
0.1872967035,
0.4043546319,
0.4572665393,
0.6200059652,
-0.166553542,
0.2112206966,
0.3078816831,
-0.5150104165,
0.5422232747,
-0.434116751,
-0.2349369675,
-0.1551827341,
0.0759048089,
-1.3175410032,
-0.0991328806,
0.2240781784,
-0.5907075405,
0.179107368,
-0.0845575407,
-0.645306766,
-0.071585834,
-0.4753948748,
0.1987777054,
0.258533895,
-0.5616360307,
0.6826134324,
0.3465534747,
-0.0612873845,
-0.5646694303,
-0.7214039564,
0.1309648156,
-0.2899987102,
-0.4224854112,
0.5359405279,
0.3141894639,
-0.5123462677,
0.1977948695,
-0.2289953828,
-0.1154382527,
0.2976913452,
0.403695941,
0.1735267341,
-0.129335463,
0.3565489948,
-0.0278681703,
-0.3826885223,
-0.2575953901,
-0.3217602968,
0.3482048512,
0.0406764299,
-0.3371545672,
-0.3538650274,
0.5170637369,
0.1759544015,
-0.5560613275,
0.5169409513,
0.9265047312,
-0.5208811164,
-0.0983422995,
-0.3674862385,
-0.0032398466,
-0.4112747014,
0.2638371885,
-0.3689772487,
-0.9414902925,
0.8458003402,
0.1396934092,
-0.001892868,
0.7996124625,
0.1473361105,
-0.1239475086,
1.0844445229,
0.9959972501,
0.1594471782,
0.7314898968,
0.0748789012,
0.0943638235,
-0.8853811026,
-0.4102838933,
-0.9418656826,
0.0868014246,
-0.8680025339,
-0.2612457275,
0.1124061793,
0.3140866756,
-0.0230749901,
0.274243623,
-0.4624865949,
0.622647047,
0.4836375117,
-0.078176342,
0.4842345715,
-0.1061372906,
-0.3085096776,
-0.1800516993,
-0.4493156075,
-0.2740003765,
0.7574968934,
0.0703212172,
0.5505595207,
-0.1336592436,
0.8331485987,
0.7626324296,
0.1149695814,
-0.6082398295,
0.5120674372,
-0.3914450109,
-0.1554928869,
-0.3535965383,
-0.0979560018,
-1.195882678,
0.5244984627,
-0.4909204841,
-0.7948470712,
0.1054425985,
-0.2966024578,
0.1563977152,
0.0880563557,
-0.8003408313,
1.06840837,
0.161267668,
-0.0513572022,
0.0844412073,
-0.8885236979,
-0.2098675966,
-0.2043717951,
0.0767229348,
0.0392579362,
0.0279529765,
1.1381716728,
-0.4935491085,
0.7415268421,
0.0819412619,
0.0976606011,
-0.0020211264,
0.0852424875,
0.4010182917,
-0.3222401142,
0.2136077434,
0.0515074022,
0.1237053573,
-0.4452242851,
-0.5900632143,
0.6859524846,
-0.6809924245,
-0.4286670387,
-0.5358586311,
-0.6342856288,
-0.1286848336,
0.463504076,
0.0976130813,
0.7123273611,
-0.0681544691,
-0.0712898597,
0.6196928024,
-0.1760037988,
0.6828061342,
0.9191553593,
-0.1630769521,
-0.2197211981,
0.7861477733,
0.1459410936,
0.1126650721,
0.664516449,
0.4065094888,
-0.686886251,
-0.619636178,
-0.2219630778,
0.1811518073,
-1.1141639948,
-0.1926159412,
-0.705761373,
0.0125104636,
-0.8265815973,
-0.3229454756,
-0.01867426,
-0.6601217389,
-0.3741116524,
-0.2430609465,
0.4805664718,
1.0265978575,
-0.4738221765,
-0.0937925428,
-0.5702032447,
0.2157176286,
0.249819681,
0.1062026098,
-0.2125565708,
-0.4695127606,
-0.1934785694,
-0.3401891887,
0.0517681837,
-0.4904337823,
0.316092819,
-0.0926357508,
0.5509500504,
0.5461775661,
0.4338472188,
0.5665237308,
-0.2392760366,
0.829603374,
0.3205824494,
-1.0255842209,
0.4755142927,
-0.2175928056,
0.1338680536,
0.3925511837,
0.2310448587,
-0.7057904005,
-0.4649870098,
-0.7801085114,
-0.9290902019,
0.5422932506,
-0.0784835815,
-0.1064874902,
-0.2976553142,
-0.0151654379,
0.1152007133,
0.0036166324,
-0.6458764076,
0.1045200527,
-0.1143127009,
-0.1669158489,
0.03099012,
0.0193665791,
-0.0796813145,
0.0128341103,
0.4213908315,
-0.008771738,
-0.1309403926,
0.2034157217,
-0.4780321717,
0.1524383575,
0.2334388644,
0.4808697402,
0.5685749054,
-0.1634262353,
0.6213366389,
-0.0068062865,
-0.2567544281,
-0.293156743,
0.1645479649,
-0.1788904667,
0.3441714048,
0.6358439922,
0.6480889916,
0.0665422529,
-0.6678163409,
0.8283360004,
0.0109767988,
-0.216484502,
0.0952609256,
-0.2629942298,
0.1311493665,
0.3466971517,
0.1032116562,
-0.1529647261,
0.077646032,
-0.5044374466,
0.395600915,
0.5002612472,
-0.5256239176,
-0.0009816329,
0.4455875754,
0.2764730453,
-0.5004265308,
0.4351679087,
-0.1972914338,
-0.737452507,
0.6440364122,
0.4991500378,
0.8183277845,
0.0598082952,
0.3791367412,
-0.0679716542,
-0.0753680393,
-0.116760619,
-0.1757480204,
-0.5711714029,
-0.8536818027,
-0.1111963466,
-0.4898175001,
-0.3523808718,
0.0188329555,
-0.9439016581,
0.3467397988,
-0.1613282561,
0.2294958383,
0.5819252133,
0.0965617746,
-0.3493487537,
0.2174244523,
-0.1682778597,
0.7453434467,
-1.2430644035,
0.6703830361,
0.6955685019,
-0.5331333876,
-0.5265908837,
0.096457839,
-0.0404827222,
-0.6658011675,
1.1387557983,
0.1416897476,
-0.299982816,
-0.2446103841,
-0.120090127,
-0.4332734942,
0.8077363968,
-0.17001836,
-0.305908829,
0.238017872,
0.3034698665,
0.6637577415,
-0.2595485151,
0.1020573378,
0.3265493214,
0.1714808047,
-0.0266461857,
-0.7985443473,
-0.174463734,
-0.0218335651,
0.1518154442,
0.3357490599,
-0.3701640368,
0.9533184171,
0.0633823648,
-0.4323193133,
0.0573406778,
0.6627476215,
-0.2994653583,
0.5192792416,
0.5089034438,
0.4764440954,
0.7092892528,
-0.0752464011,
0.5108558536,
-0.4194279313,
0.3804973364,
0.7891520262,
-0.4033763111,
0.8501210213,
0.378464967,
-0.0031630951,
0.3720779419,
0.7745344639,
0.0533181392,
0.7268104553,
0.2433475852,
-0.2861112356,
-0.3221377432,
-0.3889775574,
-0.1580456942,
0.2521412671,
0.2913239002,
-0.3368406594,
-0.6150824428,
0.308329612,
0.1096009612,
0.3566425145,
-0.5019419193,
1.0068995953,
-0.2019697875,
-0.4360602498,
0.2189698815,
0.2992915809,
0.9129282236,
-0.6058712602,
-0.1279219389,
-0.3575163186,
0.3425567448,
-0.3999181986,
-0.8294933438,
0.3353133798,
0.0005668423,
-0.2951630056,
-0.282263428,
1.0859045982,
-0.56411165,
-0.4230736792,
0.3920805156,
0.448717773,
0.1339612305,
0.158468008,
-0.705585897,
0.2096250355,
-0.2096821219,
0.2150494754,
0.8376169801,
0.7675256729,
-0.5785443783,
0.2894651592,
0.5202659369,
0.0026456809,
-0.0354234762,
0.3944277167,
0.7887133956,
-0.5952742696,
-0.7899166942,
-0.5673230886,
0.1418204904,
-0.1975050122,
-0.3345019221,
0.7750974894,
0.6847720146,
1.2679913044,
-0.0686212331,
0.6714664698,
0.1490758061,
0.8455099463,
-0.7462860942,
0.2606390417,
-0.6836804748,
0.2942436337,
-0.5515841842,
-0.6531948447,
-0.714392364,
0.8467661142,
-0.0678089634,
-0.4790900648,
0.8314093947,
1.2023255825,
0.053801056,
-0.2615261972,
0.3741830289,
-0.2589564025,
0.1850204766,
0.2325486988,
0.9331957698,
-0.3329527974,
0.2879061699,
0.0079259053,
-0.0398628153,
0.045734521,
-0.9559813142,
-0.9708855748,
-1.0550210476,
-0.7071937919,
-0.6268749237,
0.3504434228,
0.852568388,
0.375434339,
-0.7153587937,
0.1285266876,
-0.2855431437,
0.3087388575,
-0.2026512474,
-0.2207786888,
0.8428772092,
-0.3417311013,
-0.6149746776,
0.0489784852,
0.4749780595,
0.1181350872,
-0.2256599963,
0.1993104666,
-0.0469065383,
0.1216811091,
0.5654622912,
0.3080158234,
-0.7548334599,
-0.5322195888,
-0.2945556641,
-0.2511761487,
0.0595152043,
1.1287786961,
-0.6296287775,
0.3827125728,
0.8258401155,
0.6237190962,
0.552051723,
0.0583185554,
0.0859490633,
-0.7087073922,
0.2642290592,
-0.0977792442,
0.3603722453,
0.5741140246,
-0.0580451302,
0.5330198407,
0.6974134445,
-0.0606094636,
-0.8650735617,
0.2818158865,
-1.0995371342,
-0.6374691129,
1.3005590439,
-0.3251193762,
-0.0625404567,
-0.5168340802,
-0.2243558615,
0.2479535788,
-0.2603348494,
0.7977594733,
0.7957909107,
-0.1991074681,
-0.0450506769,
0.0418988131,
0.6165919304,
0.2786836326,
-0.7209902406,
0.1974376291,
0.5551066995,
0.5759751797,
0.1579778343,
0.6614336371,
-0.4614933133,
0.0398728363,
0.2642399669,
-0.1193346009,
-0.1398500204,
-0.3349348605,
-0.497933656,
-0.1111978889,
-0.0171831828,
-0.4924762249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13302v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13302v2 | Language-Agnostic Bias Detection in Language Models with Bias Probing | 2023-05-22T17:58:01 | 2023-11-20T14:31:26 | Abdullatif Köksal, Omer Faruk Yalcin, Ahmet Akbiyik, M. Tahir Kilavuz, Anna Korhonen, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models (PLMs) are key components in NLP, but they contain
strong social biases. Quantifying these biases is challenging because current
methods focusing on fill-the-mask objectives are sensitive to slight changes in
input. To address this, we propose a bias probing technique called LABDet, for
evaluating social bias in PLMs with a robust and language-agnostic method. For
nationality as a case study, we show that LABDet `surfaces' nationality bias by
training a classifier on top of a frozen PLM on non-nationality sentiment
detection. We find consistent patterns of nationality bias across monolingual
PLMs in six languages that align with historical and political context. We also
show for English BERT that bias surfaced by LABDet correlates well with bias in
the pretraining data; thus, our work is one of the few studies that directly
links pretraining data to PLM behavior. Finally, we verify LABDet's reliability
and applicability to different templates and languages through an extensive set
of robustness checks. We publicly share our code and dataset in
https://github.com/akoksal/LABDet. | [
-0.662107408,
-0.7697097063,
0.4207772911,
0.3605917394,
-0.339469552,
0.4023532271,
-0.3686606884,
0.1465071887,
0.3384593725,
0.6003654599,
-0.6451888084,
-0.5189626813,
-0.5520752072,
-0.102357246,
-0.3970555663,
1.1226910353,
-0.129609555,
0.1271644682,
-0.1621887684,
-0.5963491201,
-0.1556183249,
-0.7973136306,
-0.5785096884,
-0.4884732962,
0.1948374808,
0.02510456,
0.55031389,
0.2191603482,
-0.0916696116,
0.1798224598,
-0.0258143116,
-0.0951807424,
-0.2952352166,
0.009329631,
-0.3950434327,
-0.3190587759,
-0.3644881546,
0.2393985391,
0.5602369905,
0.5751936436,
0.1009013504,
0.2557908595,
0.1326131225,
0.8248455524,
-0.5644111633,
-0.0000145517,
-0.8270751238,
0.0582031123,
-0.4871495366,
-0.1354863942,
-0.441247046,
-0.5611014366,
0.2108725905,
-0.1103400066,
0.6180729866,
-0.1847813874,
0.7099055648,
0.281109184,
-0.6480301023,
-0.0774144977,
-0.4691013396,
0.7932814956,
-0.5027099848,
0.5336086154,
0.346487999,
0.1017746702,
0.0638712198,
-0.3015190363,
-0.6601610184,
-0.269903779,
0.1299908459,
0.2583963871,
0.1572181433,
-0.0867663249,
0.2795932293,
0.4128212929,
-0.5809670091,
-0.0996668711,
0.0201146081,
-0.4197954834,
0.4256689847,
-0.4876526892,
0.4280046523,
-0.0683135837,
-0.4680252969,
-0.2595101595,
-0.7055954933,
-0.0023016704,
0.8349322081,
0.0426880233,
-0.346480757,
0.3449396193,
0.0463515259,
0.5682207942,
-0.0507989749,
0.554497242,
0.3548420668,
-0.1820212454,
0.2476232797,
0.1452390105,
0.8011550903,
0.2010163814,
0.6720404625,
-0.016298268,
-0.1757353842,
0.484146446,
-0.0301621184,
-0.4813707471,
-0.4334349632,
0.2263854295,
-0.1636050045,
-0.3328189254,
-0.0744230449,
-0.6331623793,
-0.5500358343,
-0.1071939319,
0.1714035124,
-0.4376507103,
-0.6845962405,
0.0459318571,
-0.0469090417,
0.4334227145,
-0.0084745809,
-0.6602129936,
0.2488265187,
0.5867439508,
0.8273025751,
-0.2674502432,
-0.2565639019,
-0.7671991587,
-0.3077084124,
-0.3193899989,
0.7717704177,
-0.277802676,
-0.3439039886,
0.0988720283,
-0.153800413,
0.1104185879,
-0.4355001748,
0.6123023033,
-0.5651896,
0.221102953,
-0.5327778459,
-0.6013687849,
0.2126425058,
0.4357261658,
-0.6651315093,
1.0469238758,
0.0942823887,
-1.1167525053,
0.5943536758,
-0.6237893701,
-0.5098629594,
-0.176611498,
-0.3973083198,
-0.4370082021,
0.0632314384,
0.2665465176,
0.1977013946,
0.0370683484,
0.5112926364,
-0.50858742,
0.0027334685,
0.3460999429,
-0.4681636095,
1.2173682451,
-0.0576326028,
-0.3200173378,
0.0883996189,
-0.7012541294,
-0.0947378725,
0.0549801439,
-0.175350666,
-0.5447701216,
0.1367263943,
0.0328884162,
0.2790619135,
0.2241975069,
-0.8126247525,
-0.0008212315,
-0.3413292468,
0.2106258869,
1.0147371292,
-0.2987825572,
0.4117524028,
-0.1432481557,
0.5576603413,
-0.0752483606,
0.0495147035,
0.0511126071,
-0.321401149,
-0.7282010317,
-0.2136756331,
0.5134164691,
0.5954864621,
-0.9192949533,
0.5787301064,
-0.0385286883,
-0.1313771456,
-0.6507245898,
0.1099840328,
0.32285887,
0.5814741254,
0.2736019194,
-0.5995216966,
-0.5130247474,
-1.0355986357,
-0.6496798992,
-0.262701273,
-0.2068235427,
0.2168251276,
0.4587138295,
-0.2472586036,
1.1670453548,
-0.2254026234,
-0.0852725878,
-0.1058736965,
0.4029659331,
0.0801338553,
0.3766023815,
0.6312388778,
-0.5995554924,
-0.8427398801,
-0.0997874588,
-0.4108864069,
-0.6060726643,
0.1445986629,
-0.0979408473,
0.3397784233,
0.3853116333,
-0.3936507702,
0.1896747202,
0.7406486869,
-0.3375939727,
0.6831070781,
0.0312349666,
-0.2431877404,
-0.9741974473,
0.0402441248,
0.0871131495,
-0.4166150689,
-0.7701900005,
-0.2451594174,
0.3414782286,
0.2737132609,
-0.5039345622,
0.8453916311,
-0.3522177637,
0.0266121626,
-0.3050537705,
-0.0000186048,
0.0175340753,
0.0727541,
0.3967003822,
0.5995214581,
0.5773662329,
-0.3259266317,
-0.0244469624,
-0.0174696464,
-0.3614516854,
0.5296074748,
-0.4463356733,
0.5490015745,
-0.2360648662,
0.4239794016,
-0.8787978888,
0.0844318792,
0.0228832308,
-0.6879290342,
0.1439931542,
-0.2629101574,
-0.5407590866,
-0.2353823036,
-0.5170351267,
0.3790780604,
0.4602212012,
-0.523878634,
0.5073792338,
0.4090766907,
-0.1482733637,
-0.8358567357,
-0.4382223785,
-0.3255965114,
-0.114595145,
-0.4767160118,
0.0795717835,
-0.106558606,
-0.2861334085,
-0.2910428345,
-0.362924546,
0.0034468465,
0.1473233998,
-0.2140886784,
0.229133606,
-0.0472455919,
-0.1894183904,
0.1486260593,
0.0906746015,
0.3369557559,
-0.1724692881,
1.0359675884,
-0.320656687,
-0.3576416671,
0.1358687729,
0.0617667586,
0.4465997517,
-0.4081448317,
0.5804401636,
0.8641720414,
-0.0700614974,
-0.4664986432,
-0.9004412889,
-0.475076884,
-0.4451884627,
0.1812601984,
-0.1821859032,
-0.8750073314,
0.9699148536,
0.1113783494,
-0.0994192809,
0.1722293198,
0.5849596858,
0.2033764273,
1.0342592001,
0.5638210177,
-0.3628998399,
0.3357948959,
-0.0390737988,
0.181115061,
-0.7451617122,
0.2669190168,
-0.4902683794,
0.0476162098,
-0.6992149949,
-0.2783733308,
0.1206420958,
-0.2725128531,
-0.1991187483,
-0.1443161517,
-0.3714300096,
0.6272040606,
0.5891424417,
-0.1010869965,
0.0014980701,
-0.1549227983,
-0.3761704266,
-0.0459813811,
-0.5046396255,
-0.4281454384,
1.1545085907,
0.3870694339,
0.5180209875,
-0.1356476992,
0.8048473597,
0.1935707033,
0.6492131948,
-0.5721470118,
0.4659371376,
-0.2200221568,
-1.0143936872,
-0.1092425957,
-0.4503039718,
-0.5336383581,
0.3078224659,
0.1443753242,
-0.6134208441,
0.2865799069,
0.4038786292,
-0.1172135547,
0.2458046973,
-0.6754732728,
0.8776071072,
-0.3852741718,
-0.5798914433,
0.2033762932,
-0.6831754446,
0.4915906191,
-0.3201139867,
0.3434399366,
-0.2535438538,
0.2600129545,
0.7601286173,
-0.3482982814,
0.8479536176,
-0.3428361118,
-0.1705625653,
-0.0316397287,
0.1745077819,
0.4063809514,
0.2015838921,
-0.1162486374,
0.2903725207,
0.023308659,
-0.5463607907,
-0.2125566006,
0.6329740882,
-0.8409030437,
-0.5882717967,
-0.7406536341,
-0.6282761693,
-0.4003576636,
0.2479580492,
0.3343892694,
-0.0403931327,
-0.404050976,
0.1684862822,
0.8904488683,
-0.4399136603,
0.053436432,
0.8747743368,
-0.2869798243,
0.032462161,
0.7021593451,
0.141959995,
0.4173804224,
0.0770662874,
0.3479318917,
-0.4672816694,
-0.2648514807,
-0.3764441013,
0.2278480232,
-0.593282342,
0.1625095904,
-0.5745866895,
-0.1817581952,
-0.4022738934,
-0.232815817,
-0.7780842781,
-0.154590711,
0.1510010511,
-0.0994354486,
0.2690529525,
0.2043793201,
-0.1219187677,
0.2074051499,
-0.2747008801,
0.3598800004,
0.3123733103,
0.4930499494,
-0.325103879,
-0.331520915,
0.1417475343,
0.0538600087,
-0.2105982006,
-1.0271135569,
0.4456590414,
0.0927369297,
0.5576270819,
0.3666160107,
0.3999703825,
-0.0132350167,
-0.5777516365,
0.7805748582,
-0.0926802382,
-1.184441328,
0.6847278476,
-0.540312767,
0.4912220836,
0.7236976027,
0.395668298,
-0.3847102225,
-0.7182754874,
-0.5734450221,
-0.9398183823,
0.7624309063,
0.0961489528,
0.2500194311,
-0.1843815148,
0.1742658466,
0.4063504338,
0.3339276016,
-1.1425567865,
-0.4448218048,
-0.5625829697,
-0.0930485427,
-0.2099321932,
-0.1842550486,
-0.1586040556,
-0.2428427637,
0.6273515821,
-0.1811250001,
-0.0123346057,
0.0914016515,
-0.3325523436,
0.1148500144,
0.4066675603,
0.3635804355,
0.5972424746,
-0.6162047386,
0.4408661127,
0.0853542089,
-0.5803908706,
0.2526319027,
0.3610377014,
-0.4074427485,
0.2508332431,
0.0238604303,
0.6755660772,
-0.3166790605,
-0.3672733009,
0.6795148253,
-0.1463075429,
-0.2032125443,
-0.366763562,
-0.2331028879,
-0.0499913245,
-0.1286024898,
0.2383005768,
-0.0897113979,
0.0873598009,
-0.5604067445,
0.2912654579,
0.7999592423,
-0.51505512,
-0.5133928061,
0.6394769549,
0.1761221141,
-0.1438659579,
0.2583778799,
-0.3438448012,
-0.9595193267,
0.556474328,
0.3924688697,
0.9833090901,
-0.6636368632,
0.4958845377,
-0.05781167,
0.6137536168,
-0.0752562955,
0.2771633267,
-0.1756446809,
-1.208782196,
-0.4933281839,
-0.5714477301,
-0.5063237548,
0.5070930123,
-0.7186050415,
0.2986420989,
-0.3372238278,
-0.2247395068,
-0.0696407855,
0.0262891836,
-0.7505375743,
-0.0386932418,
0.1440329552,
0.7733579278,
-1.2837033272,
1.0892322063,
0.9425474405,
-0.0687760487,
-0.2853321731,
0.1897732764,
0.1794118881,
-0.8089582324,
0.5324588418,
0.2490563393,
-0.1540810764,
0.122432813,
-0.3616521657,
-0.490657568,
0.5291617513,
0.5893608332,
-0.261097163,
0.4063024521,
0.2949974239,
0.4906483293,
-0.1292737126,
0.150366351,
0.6502839923,
0.353427887,
-0.4819046557,
-0.827657342,
-0.0253919698,
-0.2554344535,
-0.106658794,
0.1401428282,
-0.6477090716,
0.8866680264,
0.4412717521,
0.0176719651,
-0.5385414362,
0.3294917345,
0.5262230635,
0.3378381431,
0.7125740051,
0.400190413,
0.7338013649,
-0.1625041664,
0.9983166456,
-0.5736273527,
0.3139348626,
1.0073330402,
-0.7108141184,
0.4066509604,
0.5329968333,
-0.0319268331,
0.3323072195,
0.5802960396,
0.3239882886,
0.6569089293,
0.3877908885,
-0.5410829186,
-0.0088109206,
-0.0884595737,
-0.4760562479,
0.0741808042,
0.3287436366,
-0.2818844318,
-0.2206635773,
0.1532958448,
0.4328469932,
0.1250425875,
-0.2593159974,
0.5419749022,
0.1933455318,
-0.747844696,
0.4578754902,
-0.2093736976,
0.945199132,
-0.6718064547,
0.3972257078,
-0.4971619844,
0.2402139306,
0.0319198929,
-0.7154049873,
0.1438099444,
0.0262178704,
-0.0355341956,
-0.3973329365,
0.9169393182,
-0.4440708756,
-0.3374029994,
0.4793348312,
0.8416363597,
-0.0365548022,
-0.2131613642,
-0.7140932679,
0.2666103542,
0.1398573816,
-0.3963808715,
0.4309700429,
0.3437472582,
-0.1321255416,
0.5373085737,
0.3842734098,
0.194256559,
0.1275400668,
0.4029639661,
0.7229251266,
-0.115676187,
-0.4765086174,
-1.1327614784,
0.4410983026,
-0.1665937752,
-0.066641517,
0.960573256,
0.6187392473,
1.0751882792,
-0.1112334803,
1.1835672855,
0.2484937608,
0.5607794523,
-0.428494364,
1.0476180315,
-0.1914510727,
0.2268516868,
-0.3166189492,
-1.0675559044,
-0.2084576786,
0.8466254473,
-0.7504934669,
-0.0278061945,
0.5581563115,
0.7032165527,
-0.2969572246,
-0.0829696506,
-0.0232397597,
0.2511763871,
0.3410007954,
-0.0542689264,
0.7988545895,
0.0814344734,
0.1692629606,
-0.3494689167,
-0.4373600483,
0.0070368522,
-0.9565004706,
-1.1229981184,
-0.4954195917,
-0.493785888,
-0.4426681995,
0.1139932796,
0.8300306797,
0.6206685305,
-0.9147799611,
-0.372262001,
-0.1528659165,
0.2219199389,
0.1405318528,
-0.3005563617,
0.4946065247,
-0.3796678782,
-0.5198159814,
0.0842622966,
-0.0508296452,
-0.0940206647,
-0.5104210973,
0.0263593327,
-0.2570911646,
0.3172422945,
0.6748992205,
0.357313782,
-0.5483129025,
-0.3363436759,
0.0191595163,
0.3476722538,
-0.0458496213,
0.7744107842,
-0.7125433683,
0.6938055158,
0.4183330834,
0.5103679895,
0.5202081203,
-0.063666001,
0.7061713934,
-1.3593444824,
0.237260133,
0.3684434593,
0.3713921309,
0.6033061743,
-0.0127987042,
0.4096732438,
0.1556753516,
-0.5863834023,
-1.1585538387,
0.4150691032,
-0.8628246188,
-0.0859507248,
1.1235567331,
-0.0357072577,
-0.1331532449,
-0.3231939077,
-0.1685707718,
0.3430933356,
-0.3808167279,
0.9703553915,
1.0925543308,
0.1165375188,
-0.296770215,
-0.8587361574,
0.7238353491,
0.6620680094,
-0.4701592326,
-0.0293345936,
0.271969229,
0.4094513059,
0.1219606996,
1.0174776316,
-0.0938138142,
0.2012269497,
-0.4272035062,
0.3149664104,
0.3800741434,
0.1731705815,
-0.2291057706,
-0.0543251559,
0.1930414587,
-0.0239784736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13300v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13300v4 | Adaptive Chameleon or Stubborn Sloth: Revealing the Behavior of Large Language Models in Knowledge Conflicts | 2023-05-22T17:57:41 | 2024-02-27T17:08:49 | Jian Xie, Kai Zhang, Jiangjie Chen, Renze Lou, Yu Su | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | By providing external information to large language models (LLMs), tool
augmentation (including retrieval augmentation) has emerged as a promising
solution for addressing the limitations of LLMs' static parametric memory.
However, how receptive are LLMs to such external evidence, especially when the
evidence conflicts with their parametric memory? We present the first
comprehensive and controlled investigation into the behavior of LLMs when
encountering knowledge conflicts. We propose a systematic framework to elicit
high-quality parametric memory from LLMs and construct the corresponding
counter-memory, which enables us to conduct a series of controlled experiments.
Our investigation reveals seemingly contradicting behaviors of LLMs. On the one
hand, different from prior wisdom, we find that LLMs can be highly receptive to
external evidence even when that conflicts with their parametric memory, given
that the external evidence is coherent and convincing. On the other hand, LLMs
also demonstrate a strong confirmation bias when the external evidence contains
some information that is consistent with their parametric memory, despite being
presented with conflicting evidence at the same time. These results pose
important implications that are worth careful consideration for the further
development and deployment of tool- and retrieval-augmented LLMs. Resources are
available at https://github.com/OSU-NLP-Group/LLM-Knowledge-Conflict. | [
-0.2804282904,
-0.7812098861,
0.741560936,
0.0864887014,
-0.2766295373,
0.0905915722,
-0.3478690684,
-0.4139049947,
0.2429646105,
0.6938460469,
-0.2391342968,
-0.2115289122,
-0.7058202624,
-0.0426666439,
-0.559133172,
0.6884095073,
-0.0721970797,
-0.2926464975,
-0.329349786,
-0.5309764147,
-0.581191659,
-0.5984139442,
-0.4351838231,
-0.511952877,
0.638487339,
0.1042024419,
0.907728076,
0.813010633,
0.3775264323,
0.4163979292,
-0.1090180874,
0.1986404657,
-0.4620303512,
0.3974678814,
-0.4878763556,
-0.600051105,
-0.0247489307,
-0.1478027552,
0.5204607248,
0.4384075105,
-0.3527945876,
-0.0350398645,
0.1441503763,
0.4210017323,
-0.6435962915,
0.1103613675,
-1.2434484959,
-0.1915415674,
-0.4282180071,
-0.3117836416,
-0.390922159,
-0.0905286595,
0.3456032872,
-0.6485924721,
0.2069948167,
0.0209476501,
0.6670228839,
0.3443753421,
-0.3482737541,
-0.4794954062,
-0.6108284593,
0.6211072206,
-0.8420216441,
0.1848586798,
0.4016107917,
0.0636444315,
-0.4106965661,
-0.6893066168,
-0.6857338548,
-0.3529284894,
0.0094328215,
-0.0483188927,
-0.3636684418,
-0.1851923466,
0.4777774513,
0.0766578689,
-0.4903225601,
0.1260611266,
-0.3022032678,
-0.3090175986,
0.4790346324,
0.2197734714,
0.2558181584,
0.0576259755,
-0.2358649373,
0.19048509,
-0.7939652205,
-0.1677222252,
0.320952028,
0.1896855235,
0.1512048692,
0.7515628338,
0.1416089535,
0.9185443521,
0.0555320345,
0.142753914,
-0.0935014933,
0.048419632,
-0.0562641211,
0.3832402527,
0.7088741064,
0.2813198864,
0.0695140213,
-0.0721677393,
-0.3679341972,
0.0860854313,
0.4811249673,
-0.297755301,
-0.1754797995,
0.1652592272,
-0.1771159917,
-0.1120791137,
-0.3696855903,
-0.7679774761,
-0.8330457211,
-0.2214308977,
0.6186139584,
-0.6268128753,
-0.3175413013,
0.0428509973,
-0.2306904495,
0.2408175915,
0.4355272055,
-0.7255477905,
0.1086475179,
0.8255948424,
0.8567907214,
-0.2216856629,
-0.5414946079,
-0.4464523196,
0.5495987535,
-0.4142897129,
0.7857546806,
-0.9179712534,
-0.3579230309,
0.1709460765,
0.0776325613,
-0.0292110313,
-0.9051938057,
0.4817959964,
-0.7835515141,
0.0998137295,
-0.7491409779,
-0.5178941488,
-0.1586116254,
0.1742350906,
-0.625931859,
0.8882363439,
0.2103327066,
-0.8312508464,
0.1346057504,
-0.0672584027,
-0.2991052568,
0.079693526,
-0.38763237,
-0.1150572672,
0.2607307732,
-0.0568863563,
-0.0069381567,
-0.4283403456,
0.3247883022,
-0.5436567068,
-0.3221373856,
0.3416271806,
-0.0862105414,
0.6445864439,
0.0238600709,
-0.2722736001,
0.1608573943,
-0.6305194497,
-0.5036761761,
0.3639924526,
-0.3294499815,
-0.8825596571,
0.2861382067,
-0.7310436368,
0.1749125421,
0.3788050711,
-0.4159159362,
0.1116996408,
-0.0444146357,
0.5774544477,
0.9882689118,
0.096357666,
0.1682156622,
-0.6288582683,
0.2449195534,
0.3204953372,
-0.1935987622,
-0.2526522577,
-0.3405289054,
-0.9322570562,
0.4419121146,
-0.1258903891,
0.2990735173,
-1.0408221483,
0.1468756199,
-0.1577073932,
-0.2997758389,
-0.495503217,
0.275636375,
0.0598130301,
0.7571080923,
0.2855007052,
-0.3539433777,
-0.4354432225,
-0.8790141344,
-0.5143508911,
-0.3020522892,
0.0347447805,
0.4397701025,
0.2014853358,
-0.0820438862,
0.677339673,
-0.221139133,
0.0645402446,
0.0734264404,
0.2111290246,
0.076066941,
0.4469687343,
0.6120163202,
-0.5980390906,
-0.3000716567,
0.0000461223,
-0.650588274,
-0.1590037346,
-0.1055657044,
-0.0082362443,
0.1399079412,
0.531891346,
-0.8463094234,
0.018307656,
0.3849440813,
-0.0851384178,
0.5489153266,
-0.0927877799,
-0.0970806926,
-0.6256701946,
0.0111490982,
0.3109146953,
-0.0527910925,
-0.6027480364,
0.096510306,
0.1474319398,
0.1209494919,
-0.341370672,
0.4245924652,
-0.3500012457,
0.0214227587,
-0.4679573774,
0.4520936012,
-0.2418333143,
0.4227263331,
0.2427613288,
0.9664674997,
0.4210512042,
-0.8611426353,
0.4814945459,
0.0502157956,
-0.3875004649,
0.6158618927,
-0.6610283852,
0.3001535535,
-0.2942562699,
-0.0527767353,
-0.7554836273,
-0.2599076927,
0.2364423275,
-0.1802849919,
0.3461726606,
-0.0949739516,
-0.2213536203,
-0.1941272765,
-0.2277230918,
0.2271834612,
0.4625523388,
-0.4654019177,
0.5387256742,
0.5936683416,
-0.5502707362,
-0.5290505886,
-0.5563489795,
0.1086640805,
-0.3884260654,
-0.2491793334,
0.2632305622,
0.057800293,
-0.3312351406,
-0.0229647718,
-0.4257996976,
0.0551854298,
-0.3413508534,
-0.1519065797,
0.26926139,
-0.387501657,
0.2102646381,
-0.1678392738,
0.0888728276,
0.3019664288,
-0.3178305626,
0.6539782882,
0.0975787416,
-0.6529403329,
0.0480651818,
-0.1211773381,
0.6479051709,
-0.0216930937,
0.6493142247,
0.4500385821,
-0.3884015679,
0.1560602933,
-1.072619915,
0.0072000851,
-0.5448073745,
0.4760500193,
-0.1692559719,
-0.9057061672,
0.6997504234,
-0.3226617873,
0.0335434675,
0.5079182386,
0.5742509365,
0.1366858035,
0.9474551678,
0.2692134976,
-0.3862689137,
0.4731514752,
0.1923722774,
-0.153657034,
-1.160397768,
-0.4004655182,
-0.5891805887,
-0.342759639,
-0.5299876928,
-0.4178028703,
0.2271550298,
-0.0133193517,
-0.4163839221,
0.4928386211,
-0.3007732928,
0.3094344437,
0.2862229645,
0.2164712995,
0.2427667081,
-0.1535477489,
-0.3031930625,
-0.3113750815,
-0.8088610768,
-0.3995016813,
0.9327015877,
0.2807650268,
0.9645857215,
0.1668498665,
0.2089700103,
0.2038323134,
0.1906323433,
-0.4810536504,
0.6858444214,
0.0652132854,
-0.2031399459,
-0.1499643922,
-0.390340358,
-1.1445304155,
0.327370137,
0.0423033647,
-0.9194420576,
0.361281544,
0.0729840398,
-0.2020641863,
0.318577975,
-0.53362602,
0.5113719106,
-0.4997962117,
-0.6944155693,
-0.420194149,
-0.4980619848,
0.6855334044,
-0.2371882051,
0.0033129503,
0.000910898,
-0.4412794709,
0.6771206856,
-0.2080176622,
0.7525626421,
-0.1910208464,
-0.293028146,
0.3852091134,
0.4000434577,
0.8467299342,
0.0350856632,
-0.3381454051,
-0.1293621957,
-0.0160619318,
-0.5672623515,
-0.6533307433,
1.063701272,
-0.7526876926,
-1.3216221333,
-0.5576796532,
-0.8630341887,
-0.3064199388,
0.2815247476,
-0.071181193,
0.1142413914,
-0.0564850233,
0.3446506262,
1.066398859,
-0.5187169909,
0.2498521656,
0.9335415959,
-0.1342854202,
-0.1268432587,
1.1312303543,
0.1492959708,
0.2919968963,
0.3045328557,
0.2445481122,
-0.1407997012,
-0.7779600024,
-0.2566380501,
0.1856104136,
-0.5054139495,
-0.1446233392,
-0.4954713583,
-0.3169363439,
-0.3188108206,
0.2519384623,
-0.090409711,
-0.2606221735,
-0.0989833027,
0.2913054824,
0.3297913671,
0.8358158469,
0.2425197512,
0.3050242364,
-0.9030222893,
0.1212796196,
0.4960884154,
0.1044417322,
0.0738530159,
-0.7955316305,
-0.0333906449,
0.0405271053,
-0.3386551142,
-1.0712444782,
0.3545339704,
-0.0478539951,
0.8917811513,
0.5338225961,
0.1375384033,
0.7371291518,
-0.2049056739,
0.7521324158,
-0.1576637775,
-0.7891198993,
0.4929507971,
-0.572979629,
0.3618628085,
0.1322562844,
0.4593749344,
-0.6489858627,
-0.594157517,
-0.6194319129,
-0.7455582023,
0.7504429221,
-0.1999880224,
0.2755983472,
0.0419301949,
0.6511819363,
0.0910907835,
0.5066902637,
-0.6618121266,
-0.0369170085,
-0.0717975199,
0.0238101799,
0.0817308873,
-0.4290370941,
-0.4378379285,
-0.093164809,
0.5962663293,
0.0025418985,
0.0579098985,
0.0405560061,
-0.3237818778,
-0.3176154792,
0.2202791572,
0.7583078146,
0.7640518546,
0.055100508,
0.4705141187,
0.4194972217,
-0.4311762452,
0.1349757761,
0.0381984375,
-0.2996152639,
-0.0033456828,
0.4831196964,
0.7780342102,
0.2905503809,
-0.7550877333,
0.3238026798,
0.1675418615,
0.1135174781,
-0.134343043,
0.1939211786,
0.1998596489,
0.3208257556,
0.1865256727,
0.0556337908,
-0.1593205631,
-0.58673352,
0.0940414667,
0.6685863137,
-0.3830922246,
-0.3045684695,
0.3456445038,
0.0125503186,
-0.3069854379,
0.5660642385,
-0.1897725761,
-0.610054493,
0.3828278184,
0.7327203155,
0.4536779821,
-0.5358375311,
-0.0218863208,
0.1387855709,
0.5163803697,
0.0050735157,
0.0808667317,
-0.0062166192,
-0.7932262421,
-0.1410352737,
-0.281442821,
-0.3441890478,
0.6174737215,
-0.6187855601,
0.0937038958,
-0.4435377121,
-0.1496558487,
-0.1799473166,
-0.0421712399,
-0.3646974266,
-0.3915218115,
-0.2107127011,
1.1233352423,
-0.6591345072,
1.0158056021,
0.6787726879,
-0.2729665935,
-0.3993321955,
0.2025226951,
0.2548726797,
-1.2392691374,
0.2053345442,
-0.2956268787,
0.0440975577,
-0.1668785214,
-0.4738068581,
-0.8367173672,
1.0776172876,
0.7308190465,
-0.719268918,
0.0961292386,
0.1199224666,
0.4471846819,
-0.1085672677,
-0.023698708,
0.7640054822,
0.5563536286,
0.2087245136,
-0.6720724702,
0.3551049531,
-0.1061710566,
0.1076336578,
0.3085767031,
-0.9415703416,
0.7643872499,
-0.0189130716,
-0.1582361311,
0.0030470316,
0.6860009432,
0.4092720151,
0.3172703087,
0.4374321401,
0.5400746465,
0.701025784,
-0.0227449648,
0.6598460078,
-0.5732964873,
-0.1306951046,
1.2347859144,
-0.6229969859,
0.821685791,
0.7231397629,
-0.3633595109,
0.5242824554,
0.6154485345,
-0.0020412642,
0.3501050472,
0.1710900962,
-0.3949932754,
-0.1264160722,
-0.3744127154,
-0.4061566889,
0.1174317077,
0.7141217589,
-0.2429623157,
-0.2870474458,
-0.1940741241,
-0.2342865467,
0.1142867878,
-0.2665778399,
0.8039253354,
0.0838778466,
-0.9450137615,
0.3351342678,
-0.0454604924,
0.559233129,
-0.8452246785,
0.1080422327,
-0.0000438367,
0.1104822159,
-0.1433891803,
-0.8856880665,
0.369872719,
-0.2673685849,
0.1782819629,
0.2591977417,
1.1151688099,
-0.6373684406,
-0.0462514237,
0.3488398194,
0.5556904674,
-0.1463724524,
-0.0307292324,
-0.7330026627,
0.3360133171,
-0.1003934443,
-0.2372917831,
0.7468956709,
0.6380012035,
-0.1546516865,
0.7985900044,
0.5262012482,
0.278167665,
0.1008119732,
-0.0613125935,
1.096685648,
-0.4649258852,
-0.2301598191,
-1.0363382101,
-0.1197375506,
-0.0667389035,
0.0979556441,
0.8942667246,
0.4790624678,
0.7625681758,
0.1002183557,
0.7813120484,
0.1048201472,
0.4284018278,
-0.5577555895,
0.3906734586,
-0.3675379455,
0.559922576,
-0.0765320659,
-0.6894893646,
0.3924928904,
0.4024195373,
-0.3991529047,
0.1292966455,
0.6179991364,
0.8034037352,
-0.1047896966,
0.2323502302,
0.1566428244,
0.4600544572,
0.1049909964,
0.6899901032,
1.124458313,
0.0725159422,
0.60667032,
-0.1959941536,
-0.0611951202,
0.0860009789,
-0.7865527272,
-0.6445412636,
-0.6462152004,
-0.2345732152,
-0.441157192,
0.1731720418,
0.9420932531,
0.2469565123,
-0.7544822693,
-0.3475391865,
-0.1105622873,
0.3408166468,
-0.1231275499,
-0.20587942,
0.1443225443,
-0.3631051183,
-0.528729856,
0.3543887436,
0.4429311454,
0.1522240043,
-0.4019233882,
-0.180119589,
-0.3156826496,
0.1938712895,
0.4853703976,
0.5788526535,
-0.8438478708,
-0.4299876392,
-0.2063962072,
-0.0930192098,
-0.0165716689,
1.2951823473,
-0.8006026745,
0.4701218307,
0.4669885039,
0.8217002153,
0.3787909448,
-0.1028640866,
0.8424341679,
-0.6345666051,
0.2992961705,
0.2275457382,
0.4477345049,
0.1536809504,
-0.3121568859,
0.1145156994,
0.2970155478,
-0.6367416978,
-0.8230147958,
0.2791928947,
-0.6570342779,
-0.2527115345,
0.9973061681,
-0.2146596164,
-0.1717620641,
-0.2881780565,
-0.2395029664,
0.2280455232,
-0.3542504907,
1.1271311045,
0.9860519171,
-0.2036359608,
-0.3099145293,
-0.6727061868,
0.5315654278,
0.456034869,
-0.6032921076,
0.1297912151,
0.4130645394,
0.2483520955,
0.2933128178,
0.4164715409,
0.02874602,
0.1984214932,
-0.0414370336,
-0.5604807138,
-0.0277955011,
-0.0289930794,
-0.432394892,
-0.0308370907,
0.3991656899,
0.2106463015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13299v1 | Measuring Inductive Biases of In-Context Learning with Underspecified Demonstrations | 2023-05-22T17:56:31 | 2023-05-22T17:56:31 | Chenglei Si, Dan Friedman, Nitish Joshi, Shi Feng, Danqi Chen, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In-context learning (ICL) is an important paradigm for adapting large
language models (LLMs) to new tasks, but the generalization behavior of ICL
remains poorly understood. We investigate the inductive biases of ICL from the
perspective of feature bias: which feature ICL is more likely to use given a
set of underspecified demonstrations in which two features are equally
predictive of the labels. First, we characterize the feature biases of GPT-3
models by constructing underspecified demonstrations from a range of NLP
datasets and feature combinations. We find that LLMs exhibit clear feature
biases - for example, demonstrating a strong bias to predict labels according
to sentiment rather than shallow lexical features, like punctuation. Second, we
evaluate the effect of different interventions that are designed to impose an
inductive bias in favor of a particular feature, such as adding a natural
language instruction or using semantically relevant label words. We find that,
while many interventions can influence the learner to prefer a particular
feature, it can be difficult to overcome strong prior biases. Overall, our
results provide a broader picture of the types of features that ICL may be more
likely to exploit and how to impose inductive biases that are better aligned
with the intended task. | [
-0.7053046823,
-0.5350050926,
0.5070592761,
0.1049649566,
-0.2415569872,
-0.1946582347,
-0.4089010656,
-0.2735978067,
-0.2203963548,
0.2797094285,
-0.3472923338,
-0.4765051603,
-0.5736865401,
-0.1634515971,
-0.5660859942,
1.4815998077,
-0.0960723981,
0.1835776716,
-0.4301511943,
-0.1616656184,
-0.4026589394,
-0.6171640158,
-0.0521934703,
-0.8637186289,
0.2537352145,
0.3850736618,
0.5142167807,
-0.00597012,
0.0694610998,
0.0796308666,
-0.1239556521,
-0.1016881019,
-0.2832432687,
-0.2215971053,
-0.2667722106,
-0.2810862958,
0.0384487957,
0.3502704203,
0.5552093983,
0.7892363071,
0.2512041032,
0.1361602247,
0.757373035,
0.2984635532,
-0.74487257,
-0.0007539846,
-0.7953594923,
0.0203373674,
-0.1026651338,
-0.1514536589,
-0.343421787,
-0.3418228626,
0.5101747513,
-0.253985852,
0.3981128633,
-0.2041487098,
0.6319078803,
0.3663926423,
-0.4063335359,
-0.7190534472,
-0.6398515105,
0.8620591164,
-0.6586318612,
0.233059302,
0.4634675384,
-0.0964503214,
-0.1255397797,
-0.5642638206,
-0.4732634127,
-0.5927091837,
-0.5157564878,
0.0209693015,
0.2176419795,
0.0860576928,
0.5367659926,
0.310364455,
-0.1541603506,
0.3827688098,
0.0198225304,
0.0297347978,
0.3748914301,
-0.1116011739,
0.3165619075,
-0.0132531207,
-0.6183206439,
0.0003564058,
-0.931873858,
0.3580536246,
0.2806471288,
0.3482283354,
-0.1758393943,
0.462418884,
-0.0679470152,
0.2967509627,
0.1067769751,
0.0069301189,
0.2307100892,
-0.053216435,
-0.3594251871,
0.4218957424,
0.6834433079,
0.1554454863,
0.2472893745,
-0.1159243286,
-0.3006133735,
-0.003639007,
-0.0299842544,
-0.7097328305,
-0.142862305,
0.0943008214,
-0.2163663208,
-0.1528083682,
0.1943129748,
-0.5213625431,
-0.5769324899,
-0.3094615936,
0.5336621404,
-0.47999686,
0.0136614852,
-0.0400919877,
-0.0442727879,
0.1698969007,
0.2896285653,
-1.1424524784,
0.3695122898,
0.7100203633,
0.7104739547,
-0.3850949705,
-0.449005872,
-0.3552362919,
0.0638974607,
-0.1926809996,
0.8010793924,
-0.5585831404,
-0.2501222789,
0.2921851277,
-0.0953482166,
-0.1918311268,
-0.6827326417,
0.4245221913,
-0.1947179735,
0.3402368724,
-0.5405606627,
-0.7188701034,
-0.1174215004,
0.2137215286,
-0.3668259382,
0.9294149876,
0.1476325244,
-1.1242073774,
1.101911664,
-0.9610542059,
-0.4961657822,
-0.0579472668,
-0.5170312524,
-0.4252004325,
0.0491435453,
0.4107572138,
0.5658484697,
-0.1539659053,
0.3428589702,
-0.4196237922,
-0.7638872862,
0.7107092142,
-0.3513334095,
0.7380205989,
-0.232253328,
-1.0234031677,
0.0740051419,
-0.3589398861,
-0.3198383451,
-0.1647328138,
-0.3788030148,
-0.6225166917,
0.214555487,
-0.2528589964,
0.2481085509,
-0.1400106698,
-0.5830665231,
0.2065906674,
-0.4787668586,
0.2137196213,
0.6660220027,
0.0763859227,
0.5776383281,
0.0134350564,
0.3014281094,
0.1414987892,
0.1387116164,
0.0891325921,
-0.2197124213,
-0.7674616575,
-0.1269832999,
0.1184048802,
0.1546345949,
-0.5690157413,
0.1180645451,
0.0226132013,
0.0116387196,
-0.4121029377,
0.2530073822,
0.6139245033,
0.5337674022,
0.4374441504,
-0.2251428515,
-0.1375616193,
-1.0348081589,
-0.2125452161,
-0.0303109847,
-0.3525901139,
0.2866950035,
0.5746875405,
-0.1053562313,
0.8345116973,
-0.0676491857,
-0.444234997,
-0.3701822162,
0.2063872367,
-0.03264983,
0.3380988836,
0.6695027351,
-0.5698043704,
-0.5253837705,
0.0681694224,
-0.6159334183,
-0.1476412863,
-0.2600796521,
0.2771372199,
0.1865912676,
0.4291882813,
-0.3553581834,
0.5982973576,
0.1936896294,
-0.1836958677,
0.307122618,
0.1493212432,
0.0072237896,
-0.5650833249,
-0.3095615506,
0.268031776,
0.3396142125,
-0.4655894041,
-0.047165446,
0.1531334966,
0.3879300654,
-0.542013526,
0.4131978154,
-0.4298332036,
-0.3675642312,
-0.3197754025,
0.1757200509,
-0.1272709668,
0.3764319122,
0.1158764437,
1.0823295116,
0.4137659073,
-0.587870419,
-0.2260030806,
0.1247133613,
-0.6254758239,
0.2702628076,
-0.3878752887,
0.1318598539,
0.0069305333,
0.3721946478,
-0.8867509961,
-0.1670335233,
0.184705928,
-0.242994085,
0.2303658873,
-0.1325246841,
-0.4488217533,
-0.1486956924,
-0.3402321339,
0.1551876664,
0.3483525217,
-0.8234893084,
0.285277456,
0.1085928306,
0.3141284883,
-0.7462944388,
-0.7746086121,
-0.3496342897,
-0.5999105573,
-0.0227167234,
0.3285573423,
0.1073154062,
-0.3529218733,
-0.2575035989,
0.1346398741,
0.3581369221,
0.2635089755,
0.5372185111,
-0.0068277027,
-0.1815882474,
0.2237728238,
0.1315645278,
0.2314591855,
0.2111018449,
-0.2257126272,
0.5119290948,
-0.1647921503,
-0.7458002567,
-0.4483974576,
0.1486321241,
0.5061099529,
-0.01825458,
0.4756148458,
0.5140398741,
-0.143746838,
-0.4951741099,
-0.4691457152,
-0.5432152152,
-0.3950591385,
0.3696286082,
-0.2101364136,
-0.8756814003,
0.4076510072,
-0.0444048606,
-0.0157652646,
0.1729949415,
0.6389787793,
-0.1421455294,
1.1185212135,
0.5868929625,
-0.2121857107,
0.5606524944,
-0.3540282547,
0.2266638726,
-1.2373498678,
-0.2983495593,
-0.4061730206,
-0.4427021444,
-0.5435656905,
-0.0759992525,
0.2730590701,
0.0424787961,
-0.3248819411,
0.000262984,
-0.4066809118,
0.3777411878,
0.7604578137,
0.1663202345,
-0.0815841407,
0.0164342709,
-0.5139638782,
-0.1879020035,
-0.5312228203,
-0.4802586436,
1.0323215723,
0.4190720022,
0.9262825251,
-0.2221822143,
0.4667429924,
0.1958023608,
0.7432599068,
-0.6549586058,
0.2674502432,
-0.1680475473,
-0.4775618911,
-0.2006646544,
0.3244893551,
-0.4895917475,
0.22977072,
-0.2370654792,
-0.835001111,
0.3287402689,
0.3938177526,
-0.225111708,
0.3985489607,
-0.7830162644,
0.72991997,
-0.3647753,
-0.3432809711,
-0.0348079838,
-0.4525477886,
0.5126532912,
0.0918420553,
-0.0381696261,
0.0693188831,
0.1903982162,
0.3461081386,
-0.1592521518,
1.1379328966,
-0.406244278,
-0.069543086,
0.1546615958,
-0.071303308,
0.4553926885,
0.1548218876,
0.0124793043,
-0.1706282049,
-0.5893890858,
-0.2070968747,
-0.748156786,
0.8145291805,
-0.9166748524,
-0.616514504,
-0.2114234865,
-0.4375461638,
-0.402082175,
-0.388273716,
0.5549639463,
0.5221796632,
-0.166610375,
0.1858490855,
0.9047762752,
-0.2963326871,
0.5066146851,
0.3779222071,
-0.0840588585,
0.0925484747,
0.6915544868,
0.1713228226,
0.622456789,
0.3397739232,
0.3816134632,
-0.1901382208,
-1.0070201159,
-0.3931327164,
-0.0788017586,
-0.8679620624,
-0.0208690464,
-0.730594039,
-0.2409377694,
-0.3517780006,
-0.3139131963,
-0.063495189,
-0.2293193191,
-0.4597283304,
-0.2809067965,
0.1207223535,
0.8737133145,
0.2494041026,
0.4404031634,
0.0446898304,
-0.0429238826,
0.6575414538,
0.2136913389,
0.1578684151,
-0.8035676479,
-0.3859192729,
-0.2031853497,
-0.4087602198,
-0.6044917703,
0.1364841908,
0.2643714845,
0.6455873847,
0.6468092799,
-0.010622574,
0.5090824366,
-0.3010237515,
0.9862318635,
-0.1803079098,
-0.8888355494,
0.641802907,
-0.1863608956,
0.3632606268,
0.4954788089,
0.6015591025,
-0.2830677629,
-0.7024023533,
-0.5024784207,
-0.7305895686,
0.6581529975,
-0.212602675,
0.2295588851,
-0.2683137059,
0.2449167222,
0.3127559721,
0.1573831737,
-0.976051271,
-0.2211629748,
-0.5446175337,
0.0203049798,
0.1432427317,
-0.536259234,
-0.2416443527,
-0.2013963759,
0.7821212411,
-0.4737218022,
0.0280607566,
0.1870392561,
-0.335857302,
0.1665762514,
0.4879663587,
0.8371086121,
0.6806732416,
-0.3186172247,
0.1986121088,
0.407286644,
-0.3346771002,
-0.0197837558,
0.1854151487,
-0.536025703,
-0.1507493705,
0.6063452363,
1.0457247496,
0.3972619176,
-0.41636163,
0.812278688,
0.2113312632,
-0.0127959289,
-0.2973763645,
0.1833080947,
-0.2264605165,
0.3023684323,
0.5049343109,
-0.2268758714,
0.3974978626,
-0.5091301799,
0.2744198143,
0.7419386506,
-0.8616238236,
-0.3639287651,
0.5091374516,
-0.033572264,
0.0064024581,
0.5057873726,
-0.0478438288,
-0.5693906546,
0.4952081144,
0.7573840022,
1.0956856012,
-0.0918876007,
0.2075269222,
0.2458420396,
0.3073011935,
0.1872630864,
-0.1996320486,
-0.1919118613,
-0.8320505619,
-0.4128316045,
-0.4441233277,
-0.3446704447,
0.3373751044,
-0.6954078674,
0.2736891508,
-0.4464402497,
0.1070393026,
-0.0070221522,
-0.2101400942,
-0.7412574887,
0.2112684101,
0.3527805507,
0.8197553158,
-1.1811486483,
1.1125086546,
0.7645715475,
-0.4150503278,
-0.6038188934,
0.4135662615,
0.2078270614,
-0.8144108653,
0.9289774895,
0.330450058,
-0.0567035265,
-0.4081655741,
-0.7485335469,
-0.6304766536,
0.9712296128,
0.264090091,
-0.2611407042,
0.0094404565,
0.3389007449,
0.3803106844,
-0.8932397366,
0.4745735228,
0.668487668,
0.1026537865,
-0.2127167732,
-0.8067378402,
0.0707289577,
0.2041532099,
0.0753266364,
0.0726581737,
-0.447326988,
0.6936938167,
-0.2477641106,
-0.0912350044,
-0.3053791523,
0.6770495176,
0.0959900022,
0.2857649028,
0.5268716812,
0.3840508759,
0.3567213714,
-0.0737086087,
1.081402421,
0.122524485,
0.2041174173,
1.2904390097,
-0.3201999664,
0.6197972894,
0.7069129944,
-0.0871212184,
0.7309845686,
0.6046836376,
0.2154141963,
0.6923119426,
0.1952308416,
-0.4446500838,
-0.0515117198,
-0.3517980874,
-0.1382164061,
0.3117634058,
0.7295190692,
-0.610309422,
-0.1852950305,
0.4922811985,
0.0530656204,
0.2277537733,
-0.2989809811,
0.8989405036,
-0.0621158294,
-0.6052107215,
0.4140048921,
-0.5430073738,
0.9677924514,
-0.4977611303,
-0.065044418,
-0.3541194201,
0.1040614843,
-0.238326177,
-0.9526954293,
-0.0861032829,
-0.1607923955,
-0.2091199011,
-0.2040089369,
0.4791521132,
-0.4860238135,
-0.1890100837,
0.511579752,
0.0390665531,
0.032115832,
-0.0704875588,
-0.60124892,
-0.0158964787,
0.2220950127,
-0.1443231553,
0.6939328909,
0.4291211069,
-0.2759248316,
0.6299687624,
0.2103732973,
-0.0569936037,
0.1190472022,
0.4413727522,
0.9968970418,
-0.446278125,
-0.1723992079,
-0.8137265444,
0.6027643681,
-0.018782476,
-0.4836466908,
0.7518302798,
0.4212435186,
1.3218202591,
0.0000010283,
0.995018065,
0.1598012596,
0.5989204645,
-0.6912979484,
0.4324884117,
-0.3214311004,
0.3364807963,
-0.4210897088,
-0.6626900434,
-0.21115686,
0.3876580596,
-0.5593277812,
-0.0989687294,
0.7736256123,
0.5911393166,
-0.2460685074,
0.0507782772,
0.1737366915,
0.0569322146,
0.3782064617,
0.4350472987,
1.0633437634,
-0.0702582523,
0.204213202,
-0.6155133247,
-0.2778876126,
-0.2376736999,
-0.9140091538,
-1.2591781616,
-0.5852988958,
-0.2867267132,
-0.234193787,
0.0041059661,
1.2002140284,
0.5459145904,
-1.0498276949,
-0.2218145281,
0.0894042179,
0.2256323546,
-0.2013788521,
-0.2723003924,
0.5945305228,
-0.7122497559,
-0.7014034986,
0.2672263384,
0.2209656388,
0.177825287,
-0.4722203612,
0.0353224911,
-0.1054736748,
-0.2781754732,
0.6303164363,
0.1797043979,
-1.1202214956,
-0.5621491075,
-0.2430131584,
0.0287802164,
0.1634764373,
1.1218914986,
-0.9511477351,
0.2765063047,
0.0344482102,
0.577559948,
0.4189344049,
-0.1098554283,
0.539803803,
-0.7149665952,
0.2906048298,
0.1943432838,
0.3190381825,
0.5499666929,
-0.3067059815,
0.2314323485,
-0.0401066989,
-0.6737917662,
-0.6897441745,
0.2201041579,
-0.392013669,
-0.2817626894,
1.114972949,
-0.0216447152,
0.1374094337,
-0.1744698733,
-0.0582751147,
-0.0105979545,
-0.2856462896,
0.9494044185,
0.6311255693,
-0.3767147362,
-0.0828746855,
-0.7767364383,
0.9935436249,
0.3417107761,
-0.4402962625,
0.0454770252,
0.3811219633,
0.2567352653,
0.039935071,
0.2424741685,
-0.0373761468,
0.1707589477,
-0.4593429565,
0.0644742325,
0.3385646939,
-0.3410156369,
-0.5133234859,
0.1173280999,
0.4587413073,
-0.0695585757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13298v1 | DiffusionNER: Boundary Diffusion for Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-22T17:56:12 | 2023-05-22T17:56:12 | Yongliang Shen, Kaitao Song, Xu Tan, Dongsheng Li, Weiming Lu, Yueting Zhuang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose DiffusionNER, which formulates the named entity
recognition task as a boundary-denoising diffusion process and thus generates
named entities from noisy spans. During training, DiffusionNER gradually adds
noises to the golden entity boundaries by a fixed forward diffusion process and
learns a reverse diffusion process to recover the entity boundaries. In
inference, DiffusionNER first randomly samples some noisy spans from a standard
Gaussian distribution and then generates the named entities by denoising them
with the learned reverse diffusion process. The proposed boundary-denoising
diffusion process allows progressive refinement and dynamic sampling of
entities, empowering DiffusionNER with efficient and flexible entity generation
capability. Experiments on multiple flat and nested NER datasets demonstrate
that DiffusionNER achieves comparable or even better performance than previous
state-of-the-art models. | [
-0.7535668015,
-0.9642196894,
0.4778407216,
0.110343501,
-0.0331821814,
-0.1799524128,
0.0184406005,
-0.4329700768,
0.2923930287,
0.5663219094,
-0.577645123,
-0.2158888131,
-0.850229919,
-0.0387002416,
-0.5724467039,
1.2068901062,
0.017164845,
0.0055024214,
0.1464912891,
0.3919972777,
-0.2112611979,
-0.0351688266,
-1.4920464754,
-0.6042512059,
0.5292108655,
0.0052054725,
0.28714028,
0.4267283678,
0.2251180857,
0.3103814721,
-0.323800385,
-0.1490490735,
-0.6064394712,
0.5075901151,
-0.1214422509,
-0.1008448079,
-0.255638659,
-0.3913783729,
0.9304891229,
0.7679612041,
-0.3916300833,
-0.0407751948,
-0.1997207254,
0.6928505898,
-0.6566051841,
-0.2384136021,
-0.4753918052,
0.3652811646,
-0.4306488335,
0.0807852969,
-0.2711935341,
-0.5592181683,
0.3309247196,
-0.4616770446,
0.7232477665,
-0.2360543311,
0.9766772985,
0.3402436674,
-0.2715797126,
-0.2839794457,
-1.2473349571,
0.6744906306,
-0.2146365494,
0.9502090216,
0.0626187027,
0.3515858948,
-0.2028923482,
-1.0008404255,
-0.68274194,
0.3513753712,
0.2477168888,
0.0968942419,
-0.4762338102,
-0.1194050461,
0.354411602,
0.2491451204,
-0.1969982088,
-0.1124293432,
-0.6848159432,
-0.1175952926,
0.5985780358,
0.0075824843,
0.1737686843,
0.354121089,
-0.3765636981,
0.2277676463,
-0.380540967,
-0.1983399689,
0.5642238259,
-0.1586797237,
0.1486066431,
0.1181929186,
-0.1654940248,
0.7528793216,
0.656216085,
-0.2932746112,
0.4516031444,
0.4022600055,
-0.3425195515,
0.1938686222,
0.56924963,
0.2655813694,
0.1841665059,
-0.5578173995,
-0.4303413332,
-0.2108801901,
0.2737395465,
-1.1333371401,
-0.7739235163,
0.0174632594,
-0.3988606632,
-0.0649528801,
-0.0331993103,
-1.08657372,
-0.3600521088,
-0.1348101497,
0.2008477598,
-0.2635175884,
-0.777410388,
-0.0922361612,
-0.5582653284,
0.1506450325,
0.5075190663,
-0.6087254286,
0.55008775,
0.2381510139,
0.7642711997,
-0.4642448425,
-0.0827284381,
-0.4292185009,
0.1521130949,
-0.1342085451,
1.1646652222,
-0.5272637606,
-0.6648894548,
-0.4134087563,
0.177901879,
-0.1689865738,
-0.8651117682,
0.117122978,
-0.9091279507,
-0.0465636291,
-0.0146511206,
-0.7750599384,
-0.2195054442,
-0.0109282229,
-0.9541097879,
1.0595065355,
0.0882447511,
-0.7990493178,
0.7285169959,
-0.7330337763,
-0.2874278128,
0.3348452449,
0.0460060276,
-0.7492736578,
-0.0272685774,
-0.1685516387,
0.5211054683,
0.3880315423,
0.0589693077,
0.1306129545,
0.0356070437,
0.0979044735,
-0.277192831,
0.487159133,
0.2873723209,
-0.2393023968,
-0.2372037917,
-0.993893683,
-0.3343520164,
0.0372895375,
-0.4126396179,
-0.4897441566,
-0.0853752866,
0.1875953674,
-0.0772886202,
-0.2645362616,
-0.6554324627,
-0.1240222901,
-0.3282621503,
0.3147285581,
0.5421916246,
0.8999518752,
0.8275126219,
-0.2265878916,
0.6698282957,
0.4361538291,
-0.3612016439,
0.3908095956,
-0.6498238444,
-0.8312039971,
-0.4205275774,
0.6350197792,
0.4222099185,
-0.3338377178,
0.1642347723,
-0.1450379193,
-0.5875207782,
-0.3037222922,
0.1659011245,
-0.0057011447,
0.7461583614,
0.351010561,
-0.3959946632,
-0.7498186827,
-0.7907769084,
0.0147839598,
0.3554134071,
0.1318220496,
0.1077940613,
0.6008020639,
-0.4910154641,
0.9059891701,
-0.5791063309,
-0.2499004304,
0.0065606954,
0.2346140295,
-0.1544882059,
0.4736658633,
0.343767345,
-1.3332957029,
-0.6153190732,
-0.4344192445,
-0.3340613544,
-0.0587470904,
-0.234093532,
-0.4279878438,
-0.0934613124,
0.6856072545,
-0.53964746,
0.4393867552,
0.2820606232,
0.000913265,
0.5461580753,
0.0243392438,
-0.2525250614,
-1.0662155151,
-0.1405318081,
0.275996834,
-0.1951318532,
-0.8123182654,
-0.2148847729,
-0.3654012084,
0.0383027568,
-0.5192233324,
0.6746702194,
-1.0811527967,
0.2215322703,
-0.1327150613,
0.2900313735,
-0.2307119966,
-0.1077290103,
0.278668642,
0.549416244,
0.8063816428,
-1.1757315397,
0.1846041828,
0.1843605936,
-0.1147771925,
1.0327522755,
-0.4508766532,
-0.0009178016,
-0.6015869379,
0.2370437235,
-1.0524281263,
-0.1143478006,
0.2775417864,
-0.0713817626,
0.3830181956,
-0.5001878738,
-0.0802859738,
-0.3872642219,
0.2130015194,
0.3113650084,
0.6981626153,
-0.4771563113,
0.8302317262,
0.639064908,
-0.1834151447,
-0.2481789887,
-0.8194071651,
-0.0397119112,
-0.483596772,
-0.3269098401,
0.6234406233,
-0.1446452737,
-0.1728511304,
0.2792005837,
-0.2182030529,
-0.5605314374,
0.03093981,
0.6854920387,
-0.1400131434,
-0.0519792549,
0.171082437,
0.358756721,
-0.1183074713,
0.1648989171,
-0.1423766464,
0.2604685128,
0.340603292,
-0.0003712697,
-0.3425812125,
0.1602609903,
0.1633306891,
0.0095302677,
0.664501667,
0.7581064701,
-0.6287914515,
-0.3366141915,
-0.6287375689,
-0.0611900873,
-0.4014867246,
0.0184077639,
-0.8515546918,
-0.6696907282,
0.6520393491,
-0.6755805016,
0.1084293574,
0.4217950702,
0.4735097289,
0.2294455171,
0.5815711021,
0.6836150289,
0.1661764085,
0.6696797609,
-0.4921331704,
0.1999600679,
-1.194630146,
-0.4598165154,
-0.1922778189,
-0.5046415329,
-0.2658342719,
-0.3457234502,
0.0496407188,
0.2557411492,
-0.0126321828,
0.2310708314,
-0.8598498702,
0.6272378564,
0.4934962094,
0.0593156815,
0.2842359245,
0.1657718718,
-0.191893518,
-0.0623293333,
-0.134134829,
-0.3551608324,
0.4375674725,
0.1729972512,
0.8871746659,
0.2027769983,
1.4031006098,
0.3750495911,
0.3937373757,
-0.6006447077,
0.4951132834,
0.3632777631,
-0.726960659,
-0.3676091135,
-0.2730179131,
-1.3774577379,
0.1602084041,
-0.1154916957,
-0.9959002733,
0.4893499613,
-0.0792321041,
-0.3337382078,
0.4844967425,
-0.4937945604,
0.3953310549,
0.5020483732,
0.0380543694,
0.123047024,
-0.4205725789,
0.3055920899,
-0.0968563929,
0.0260544699,
0.0583042838,
-0.0184753072,
1.0620212555,
-0.0000414477,
0.7402313948,
-0.7433158755,
-0.1686579883,
0.5582053065,
0.3344968855,
0.3487497568,
0.1639314145,
-0.0773471445,
0.0939008147,
-0.4551933706,
0.0189453699,
-0.2931788564,
0.7429543138,
-0.478087604,
-0.3354395926,
-0.1109639034,
-0.2550159097,
0.3469112813,
0.6610718369,
0.6423966885,
-0.0830086544,
-0.538662672,
-0.2219699919,
0.997079134,
0.2552414238,
0.5224608779,
0.5639178157,
-0.1072924808,
-0.6065199971,
0.7918030024,
0.5261707902,
-0.2189810276,
0.2355415821,
-0.3198430836,
-0.1534804106,
-0.6218096614,
-0.6176741123,
0.26139009,
-0.4683459103,
-0.0784477666,
-1.2472064495,
-0.6315077543,
0.0330777466,
-0.2041978836,
-0.3066280484,
-0.2496407032,
-0.4040132165,
-0.2443853319,
0.3009854555,
0.8359656334,
-0.2626374662,
0.6148426533,
-0.5025973916,
0.4659275413,
0.3608128726,
0.3460422158,
0.131378606,
-0.41147843,
-0.097858049,
-0.115222849,
-0.305672884,
-1.0624353886,
0.2929745913,
0.4024628103,
0.7334299088,
0.5336768627,
-0.1729658395,
0.8225300908,
-0.8094085455,
0.6870869398,
0.1402447969,
-0.7026717067,
0.6875187159,
0.1131135076,
-0.1098883003,
0.1934771687,
0.4689704776,
-0.3209871948,
-0.4986106157,
-0.9295775294,
-0.9684799314,
0.1796669364,
0.1991923451,
0.1437479258,
-0.192740798,
0.4508541226,
0.3364338279,
0.1365540326,
-0.5963189602,
-0.4534287453,
0.053231664,
0.1388299167,
0.2661684155,
-0.2152553946,
-0.0453053489,
-0.1583566666,
0.8820010424,
0.4819819927,
0.4738043845,
0.4043626487,
-0.3352282643,
-0.2163534015,
0.3714622557,
0.3422188759,
0.3157358766,
0.0305759385,
0.1155184656,
0.3636582792,
-0.6761884689,
0.3315958977,
0.3735022545,
-0.6354302168,
0.2808066607,
-0.2074546814,
0.7437412739,
-0.087435253,
-0.0866539031,
0.2079998851,
-0.1084082276,
-0.5510962009,
-0.5899530649,
0.4532891214,
0.2868963182,
0.5186251998,
0.5311617255,
0.3569430113,
0.5624954104,
0.2660341859,
0.4200298786,
0.2862689197,
-0.5138664842,
-0.4708896279,
0.8710312843,
-0.0908483714,
-0.3826167285,
0.6879262924,
-0.5850599408,
-0.2495096624,
0.4332990944,
0.7039310336,
0.8903166056,
-0.3500796556,
0.2738220394,
0.3233038485,
-0.1965477467,
-0.4776930809,
0.3716447949,
-0.3670037687,
-0.8560863137,
-0.0956133083,
-0.7336266637,
-0.3099520504,
0.1022523642,
-0.7552486658,
-0.0325607918,
-0.4880309999,
-0.8573014736,
0.6341685653,
-0.2547811866,
-0.7150131464,
0.3433710635,
0.3089109659,
0.7181649804,
-0.725032568,
0.5095786452,
1.0015386343,
-0.312468946,
-0.4788117409,
0.1175422892,
-0.0468255207,
-0.3363162875,
0.9720201492,
0.053558208,
-0.2648699582,
0.4719934165,
-0.2351961732,
-0.8355745673,
1.0431782007,
0.081182301,
-0.5927885175,
-0.070457235,
-0.544721961,
0.3757122457,
-0.3169488311,
0.1565945894,
0.3688416481,
0.6389274597,
0.1855300516,
-0.3740248084,
0.0804305822,
-0.2583505809,
0.3500256538,
0.6748361588,
-0.5583799481,
0.8723365664,
-0.4952329099,
-0.5847558975,
0.0106726596,
0.8502568603,
0.1774950027,
0.385648638,
0.6702939272,
0.9215878248,
1.153306365,
-0.0289149098,
0.3501247764,
0.0698398799,
0.3875624835,
1.011803031,
-0.3558537662,
0.5570881367,
0.5234652758,
-0.1814531684,
1.2638950348,
0.4846601188,
-0.5554025173,
0.7720757127,
0.3824461699,
-0.4611972272,
0.1367015243,
0.1830289662,
-0.2923404872,
-0.0153533407,
0.3655560911,
-0.5135520101,
-0.422735244,
0.1971799582,
0.0728956759,
-0.3620309532,
-0.1500817984,
0.8844307661,
0.0058209226,
-0.3102400303,
0.1884245276,
-0.0591746531,
0.7278747559,
-0.0590699501,
-0.2529693246,
-0.0118900221,
0.1831487864,
-0.432097286,
-0.7627187371,
0.4522699118,
-0.1795472205,
-0.5921078324,
-0.0116812838,
0.8757508993,
-0.6286584735,
-0.4363704622,
0.2652395964,
0.6238493323,
0.6707045436,
-0.021294497,
-0.5406574011,
-0.3393285573,
-0.2674828768,
-0.5773175359,
0.1210771352,
0.7266687751,
0.136271432,
0.6377949715,
0.5282008648,
0.3887246549,
0.476339817,
0.1807132065,
0.567677021,
-0.5682373643,
-0.6071996689,
-0.8679677248,
0.471901536,
-0.2031946331,
-0.2615893185,
0.7089518905,
0.7682592869,
0.8951980472,
-0.310102433,
0.7481729984,
-0.2425565124,
0.4294948876,
-0.2537195385,
0.7011922002,
-0.2510230839,
0.0184453055,
-0.3237823844,
-1.1136120558,
-0.3036040962,
0.7091385126,
-0.3200520575,
0.3660598397,
0.2572633624,
0.7610939741,
-0.3947270215,
-0.2584293783,
0.3256171048,
0.0638637394,
0.0951122418,
0.3638213277,
0.7570452094,
-0.6142668128,
0.2875904441,
-0.3123441935,
0.0227511674,
-0.0639861748,
-0.499630481,
-0.8538824916,
-0.4749787748,
-0.6933154464,
-0.3623033166,
0.2123631835,
0.2352937907,
1.0825214386,
-0.7528476119,
0.1533395201,
-0.4894529581,
0.3116649985,
-0.3567228019,
-0.4204848707,
0.0203360748,
-0.0105426963,
-0.9039586186,
0.2074494958,
-0.0671806559,
0.4668884575,
-0.14391087,
-0.1293731034,
-0.0215529706,
0.0517461188,
0.2224880904,
0.3194375932,
-0.5188866258,
0.1541006565,
-0.3168591261,
0.0717378929,
0.0560368486,
0.4900677204,
-0.789951086,
0.3344384134,
0.3681561053,
0.4042316973,
1.0150151253,
0.089396067,
0.1418855041,
-0.8429445028,
-0.1365237385,
-0.0012316022,
0.2740378082,
0.3065904379,
-0.6925561428,
0.4635271728,
0.4070604444,
-0.5198755264,
-0.7143910527,
0.1836268157,
-0.6891798973,
0.0246702749,
0.956754446,
0.0381600261,
-0.1403457969,
-0.3376948535,
-0.0444203019,
0.3576662242,
-0.7959586382,
0.3958516717,
0.4315778911,
-0.4611221254,
-0.5087284446,
-0.3626294434,
0.4504728019,
-0.3342332542,
-0.3724146485,
-0.2119071931,
0.368039459,
1.085056901,
0.4539193511,
0.8951177001,
-0.0552651547,
0.0453236476,
0.4057290256,
0.362474829,
0.0391030014,
-0.3267506063,
-0.2033840567,
0.3466443419,
-0.1958719492,
-0.0699528307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13297v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13297v2 | Investigating the Role of Feed-Forward Networks in Transformers Using Parallel Attention and Feed-Forward Net Design | 2023-05-22T17:56:09 | 2023-05-25T17:01:13 | Shashank Sonkar, Richard G. Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the key role of Feed-Forward Networks (FFNs) in
transformer models by utilizing the Parallel Attention and Feed-Forward Net
Design (PAF) architecture, and comparing it to their Series Attention and
Feed-Forward Net Design (SAF) counterparts. Central to the effectiveness of PAF
are two main assumptions regarding the FFN block and the attention block within
a layer: 1) the primary function of the FFN block is to maintain isotropy among
token embeddings and prevent their degeneration, and 2) the residual norm
computed in the attention block is substantially smaller than the input token
embedding norm. To empirically validate these assumptions, we train PAF
variants of two large language models (RoBERTa-large and bert-large-uncased).
Our results demonstrate that both assumptions hold true in the PAF design. This
study contributes to a deeper understanding of the roles and interactions
between FFNs and self-attention mechanisms in transformer architectures. | [
-0.6968539357,
-0.2612749636,
0.1883045137,
0.9831818342,
0.1488825828,
-0.4048014283,
0.0318268277,
-0.1789213121,
0.2343776375,
0.74196136,
-0.7033319473,
0.4356352389,
-0.5029541254,
0.566213429,
-0.7117430568,
0.7157965899,
-0.1901151687,
-0.0500862524,
-0.2446760833,
0.0482695512,
-0.2761357725,
-0.1503940523,
-0.8787895441,
-0.5269135833,
0.7051071525,
0.0226324219,
0.8095650077,
0.7900477648,
0.8701912761,
0.3286243081,
0.1592654735,
-0.2639924586,
-0.5017065406,
0.2613844275,
-0.2917839587,
-0.140414983,
-0.162228927,
-0.1541821212,
0.8309526443,
0.5726256967,
0.075254187,
0.1303307116,
0.3102469444,
0.7645096779,
-0.5435300469,
0.4992710054,
0.0432038121,
0.3713035882,
-0.0886546448,
0.0040512034,
-0.7623671889,
0.0824190527,
0.1207888648,
-0.393602103,
0.2945347428,
0.0364781544,
0.9186555147,
0.5758199096,
-0.3235127032,
0.0989696309,
-1.0472835302,
0.4583874047,
-0.6018584967,
0.6967154741,
0.1390397549,
0.1654057503,
-0.0286871158,
-0.8972767591,
-0.4084592462,
0.1444126368,
-0.5761104226,
0.4219796658,
-0.1578218937,
0.1458481252,
0.2726204693,
0.5919733047,
-0.3599546254,
0.2210713923,
-0.5945086479,
0.0164804664,
0.275049746,
0.2486434728,
-0.1231571063,
0.0247725938,
-0.8509300947,
-0.2994421124,
-0.8726956248,
0.1509579271,
0.3673997521,
0.3895006478,
-0.1313535124,
0.3334793448,
-0.1838581264,
0.7410598397,
0.4263151586,
0.1204665378,
0.1145820767,
-0.2385163605,
-0.5639465451,
-0.015059622,
0.9187934995,
0.1421681345,
0.3014001846,
-0.5157409906,
-0.2978084087,
-0.3226260543,
0.7537607551,
-0.7369040847,
-0.072235398,
-0.1899059862,
-0.7749319673,
-0.5672315359,
0.3797820508,
-0.5910640955,
-0.1743981838,
-0.3761127889,
0.5760959387,
0.1312232763,
-0.2633837163,
-0.1556584537,
-0.1908391267,
0.6027866602,
-0.1457838714,
-0.9266542792,
0.6880054474,
0.8055611849,
0.5206242204,
-0.16352503,
-0.5418378115,
-0.3062990606,
0.0242255237,
-0.1447416097,
0.8082029223,
-0.4109733105,
-0.198295325,
-0.0939273909,
0.4059613645,
-0.5358490944,
-0.5089324713,
0.635378778,
-0.8293999434,
-0.0929921269,
-0.4559105337,
-0.240993008,
-0.0599407218,
-0.0835244656,
-1.0162398815,
0.6061611772,
0.1832603067,
-0.9856743813,
0.0360463075,
-0.5063784719,
-0.8392708898,
-0.1636672318,
-0.0558318682,
-0.3491123021,
0.1151318774,
0.1868806928,
0.5240073204,
-0.4833894372,
0.0702690482,
-0.3411445022,
-0.4177999198,
0.2902753055,
-0.6106311083,
0.478382796,
0.0672517866,
-0.4386523664,
0.0041806209,
-0.399438709,
-0.4491987824,
0.2320943177,
-0.059900783,
0.0388555601,
0.1641079038,
-0.0387212373,
0.4916740954,
-0.4579351544,
-0.5875353217,
-0.2559432387,
-0.6228866577,
0.5181445479,
0.6737535596,
-0.0229582973,
0.6633473635,
-0.3425062001,
0.5819383264,
-0.0373513997,
0.3571088016,
-0.5624596477,
-0.2580901086,
-0.8327613473,
0.0523959734,
0.5164450407,
0.2644581199,
-0.4921271503,
0.1759536266,
0.0402226672,
-0.0902555361,
-0.5268538594,
-0.0092402752,
0.3055118024,
0.7291417718,
0.1222306415,
-0.2532546818,
-0.4032342136,
-1.2701307535,
-0.0897983387,
0.1570331603,
0.0569544248,
0.4284585118,
0.1025635526,
0.1240511388,
0.9511448145,
-0.3146989942,
-0.5388656855,
-0.2004172057,
-0.1284895241,
0.1845287532,
0.3812784553,
0.6515641809,
-0.8218976259,
-0.5231475234,
-0.1879626364,
-0.6106764078,
-0.2803670764,
-0.3640771806,
-0.0631598309,
-0.1489021033,
0.6086474657,
-0.5649777055,
0.6963108778,
0.564727366,
-0.1514269561,
0.3784767091,
0.2442604303,
-0.1196796522,
-0.7780938745,
-0.0274498854,
0.1946809292,
-0.0297748577,
-0.5983350873,
0.1276019812,
0.1210912615,
-0.3427252471,
-0.5288062692,
0.4222607315,
-0.4001387656,
-0.3849332035,
-0.5610798597,
-0.2426444739,
0.3531269729,
0.6377795339,
-0.1551787853,
0.9250475168,
0.5629197359,
-0.4953561723,
0.1355031133,
0.2770332694,
0.0742856264,
0.2616221607,
-1.0860849619,
-0.0197989382,
-0.2468612194,
0.3375289738,
-1.0724636316,
0.0040002805,
0.456045121,
-0.0860943571,
0.5657306314,
0.149922058,
-0.4053895175,
-0.7974137068,
-0.024281485,
0.3623474538,
0.2244585007,
-0.7039813399,
0.8302844763,
0.0798177198,
-0.0427931584,
-0.5909115672,
-0.8377824426,
-0.1961453408,
0.1024522856,
-0.951759994,
0.4806268811,
0.5278900862,
-0.2131641656,
0.1993026882,
-0.3131506145,
0.1875646561,
0.0324894786,
0.4597817957,
0.0005366132,
-0.6941637397,
0.0790664554,
-0.1102806702,
-0.3946239352,
0.3994918168,
-0.4862692654,
0.6217971444,
-0.1981950551,
-0.3278704286,
-0.6101544499,
0.5783300996,
0.6520928741,
-0.6635664105,
0.9634166956,
0.4528293014,
0.0193476379,
-0.2414935976,
-0.6782871485,
-0.4298940301,
-0.5495408773,
0.0073354566,
-0.2957480252,
-0.7385072708,
0.4855616391,
0.1366987973,
0.0188534465,
0.7147445679,
0.5327671766,
-0.2344150692,
0.5110782385,
0.6773374677,
0.0467638001,
0.329431206,
-0.1290436834,
0.2133131325,
-1.1912075281,
-0.0896913484,
-0.4009051919,
-0.7877528071,
-0.2821947038,
-0.1752443612,
-0.049287077,
-0.031987112,
-0.5599037409,
0.6195778251,
-0.4069388807,
0.432090342,
0.3375093937,
-0.0628385022,
-0.0860842839,
-0.2508193552,
0.0326772183,
0.2489674389,
-0.673261106,
-0.1918753833,
0.851105988,
0.7077916265,
0.9150663018,
-0.1585297883,
0.5585902333,
0.086520873,
0.4630559087,
-0.7726747394,
0.1673830599,
-0.302677691,
-0.4864136875,
-0.3195077479,
-0.1735168695,
-0.6885222197,
0.3440292776,
0.1655727476,
-0.3709633648,
0.6898161173,
0.1887752265,
-0.3267756104,
0.3155013621,
-0.8531631827,
0.8928739429,
-0.0641435683,
-0.2349917889,
0.0518641211,
-0.8276816607,
0.2521284223,
0.0936583281,
-0.1818176359,
0.2556371987,
0.2666540444,
0.5770872831,
-0.3880505562,
1.0133469105,
0.0156515948,
0.0505811162,
0.4868812561,
-0.1197094396,
0.548976481,
-0.0059832158,
-0.0022132818,
0.0326409154,
-0.6320697665,
-0.1597433835,
-0.4491931498,
0.7490010262,
-0.9487965703,
-0.8995212913,
-0.0828503892,
-0.3324434757,
-0.1911949366,
0.2783547044,
0.2268231213,
0.7813825011,
0.0096094655,
0.7403566241,
0.7706717253,
0.2828682959,
0.8870729208,
0.0426232144,
-0.1113128811,
-0.0880301073,
0.4523927867,
-0.076891236,
0.5232211947,
0.6599020362,
0.289309293,
-0.2144019604,
-0.052608043,
-0.4162941575,
0.3298294842,
-0.7018101811,
-0.380938381,
-0.8591399789,
-0.5707920194,
-0.5270897746,
0.0918765888,
-0.5056061745,
-0.2103855312,
-0.2256639749,
-0.0186430383,
0.0945741087,
0.9407239556,
0.1430387795,
0.6220883727,
-0.6141682267,
0.2576068342,
0.5009517074,
0.7152331471,
0.6303108931,
-0.4864251316,
-0.166681245,
-0.3475088477,
-0.4674966633,
-0.8620252609,
0.0683759078,
0.1182953566,
0.7108620405,
0.5127152801,
-0.0327709243,
0.137748614,
-0.8505233526,
0.3084630668,
0.2619223595,
-0.6316276193,
-0.114938207,
-0.3614738882,
0.3373406231,
0.2797258794,
0.2168872654,
-0.5169743299,
-0.0993776172,
-0.3773590624,
-0.5109921098,
1.193238616,
0.4954395294,
0.0590187982,
0.0418059751,
0.1612139642,
0.0707396865,
0.0151421502,
-0.520078063,
-0.4440325201,
-0.646404922,
0.0496070646,
0.052010268,
-0.2017556429,
-0.114676401,
0.1578569114,
0.2704103291,
0.0156574342,
0.698520124,
0.3776543736,
0.3087449372,
-0.1412379742,
-0.0484986492,
0.6598038077,
0.4329438806,
0.1695403308,
-0.0628370941,
-0.1065961942,
-0.4596221447,
0.0252395701,
0.1229939312,
-0.1739262193,
-0.2345920354,
0.2213314772,
1.0247653723,
0.3365561962,
0.2287926227,
0.606574595,
-0.3357270658,
-0.2976942658,
-0.2739759386,
-0.1409409344,
0.5801762342,
0.4540348053,
0.3733970225,
0.5002588034,
0.1214918047,
-0.0669146702,
0.4108433127,
0.0232864302,
-0.4979773164,
-0.3524263799,
0.6647759676,
0.3961942494,
-0.7466791868,
0.5713505149,
0.3240818977,
-0.4921080172,
1.0002090931,
0.8688477278,
1.2029901743,
-0.2079824358,
0.1819170564,
-0.010092916,
0.3237805665,
-0.0451016687,
-0.2416296154,
-0.1719699353,
-0.6244263053,
-0.6616348624,
-0.7772189379,
-0.0575803779,
0.0341233686,
-0.7513719201,
0.2271512598,
-0.4283806384,
-0.1037254483,
0.2529830039,
-0.8102957606,
-1.0421273708,
0.3462664783,
0.2385225594,
0.9306279421,
-0.8472735286,
0.6929660439,
0.4336642623,
-0.2961983979,
-1.1880781651,
0.4298913479,
-0.2485147417,
-0.6603752971,
1.1205208302,
0.2601691782,
-0.2921175063,
0.0456111841,
-0.0178541131,
-1.1403950453,
1.0004013777,
0.1181096584,
-0.5769451857,
-0.1439127922,
0.3034999073,
0.3408789337,
-0.5848506093,
0.1227403283,
0.1459883898,
0.4330332577,
0.2055552751,
-0.7672285438,
-0.0179632138,
-0.1601014882,
0.2593936622,
0.4646438956,
-1.1647285223,
0.9764248133,
0.2562179565,
-0.1724708378,
-0.2432227433,
0.8028308153,
-0.3720899522,
-0.1391758025,
0.564253509,
0.535664618,
-0.3054563701,
-0.331632942,
1.0698908567,
-0.3235107064,
0.2815438211,
0.9433227181,
-0.3532955945,
0.5134879947,
0.6066737771,
-0.142047897,
0.2675773203,
0.2410512716,
-0.2219055146,
0.7247205973,
0.251010716,
0.3184196055,
-0.0677601695,
0.0287063178,
-0.3781023324,
0.4985201061,
0.1044287831,
-0.6637086868,
-0.4504731596,
0.2961789668,
-0.2488185465,
-0.0664545223,
-0.2833151519,
0.6133557558,
0.3358720839,
-0.6294623613,
0.1224046201,
-0.0743056908,
0.4037835598,
-0.2056146115,
0.2618073821,
-0.3351039588,
0.5597296953,
-0.1036052257,
-0.8131037951,
0.7224770188,
-0.3966366947,
-0.4923584759,
-0.4853120446,
0.9629893303,
0.015075569,
-0.4265114665,
0.5217257142,
0.0003646899,
-0.4500735402,
-0.0327161588,
-0.4728169143,
0.3470235169,
-0.2191965133,
-0.4377336502,
0.217213437,
0.2703923285,
0.1678078622,
0.4931275547,
0.1775948256,
-0.2387644798,
0.1284366697,
0.216669932,
0.9811740518,
-0.4563856721,
-0.5759202838,
-0.6660556197,
0.3282384872,
0.0517922044,
-0.2244160473,
0.6129966378,
0.1154787689,
0.7745814919,
-0.3434819877,
0.334674865,
0.1200128794,
0.2717084587,
-0.1815468967,
0.8126031756,
-0.3358323872,
-0.0578958169,
-0.1504800171,
-1.1350107193,
-0.1462018937,
0.3406343162,
-0.2600720525,
-0.0201828815,
0.7015034556,
0.5710813403,
-0.112525776,
0.5085867643,
0.0814956278,
0.1026046276,
0.2462882698,
0.3371660709,
0.8570111394,
-0.664799273,
0.6240981221,
-0.5313316584,
0.1107004881,
-0.0481709167,
-0.6750613451,
-1.0000509024,
-0.4822667539,
-0.0472394526,
-0.0916308835,
-0.2399062365,
0.446030885,
0.6831592917,
-0.890522778,
-0.2029926628,
-0.2241825312,
-0.133000657,
-0.3512974381,
-0.2422915399,
0.3891487122,
-0.3695368171,
-0.409822315,
0.2277907282,
0.5468939543,
-0.1315104812,
-0.556104064,
0.1356346458,
-0.2034300268,
0.0930351689,
0.4758778214,
0.2559662163,
-0.7601085305,
-0.2894896865,
0.5587173104,
-0.2170942873,
0.1702026278,
1.033605814,
-0.9227003455,
0.2173244506,
0.5794300437,
1.0510015488,
0.5055508614,
0.1224006042,
0.8324323297,
-0.7241976857,
0.1712727994,
0.1721354723,
0.3411250412,
0.3026497662,
-0.5987517238,
0.3299898505,
0.1956315786,
-0.5922140479,
-0.4856665432,
0.2195992172,
-0.6716815233,
-0.0536779501,
0.8198096156,
-0.2239036709,
-0.3899267316,
-0.0003250704,
-0.0188197363,
0.0832956806,
-0.1372586638,
0.2987423539,
0.7003725767,
-0.0799722075,
-0.3992220461,
-0.2154656649,
0.3374111652,
0.3971610367,
-0.2453298867,
0.1212942526,
-0.3106349111,
0.0445026942,
0.3570251465,
0.136527434,
-0.2222250402,
0.1434000283,
0.0158929434,
-0.338263005,
-0.4271482825,
-0.6005772352,
-0.3768255711,
0.2954230607,
-0.4521273971,
-0.2506855428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14387v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14387v4 | AlpacaFarm: A Simulation Framework for Methods that Learn from Human Feedback | 2023-05-22T17:55:50 | 2024-01-08T04:46:56 | Yann Dubois, Xuechen Li, Rohan Taori, Tianyi Zhang, Ishaan Gulrajani, Jimmy Ba, Carlos Guestrin, Percy Liang, Tatsunori B. Hashimoto | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have seen widespread adoption
due to their strong instruction-following abilities. Developing these LLMs
involves a complex yet poorly understood workflow requiring training with human
feedback. Replicating and understanding this instruction-following requires
tackling three major challenges: the high cost of data collection, the lack of
trustworthy evaluation, and the absence of reference method implementations. We
address these challenges with AlpacaFarm, a simulator that enables research and
development for learning from feedback at a low cost. First, we design LLM
prompts to simulate human feedback that are 50x cheaper than crowdworkers and
display high agreement with humans. Second, we propose an automatic evaluation
and validate it against human instructions obtained on real-world interactions.
Third, we contribute reference implementations for several methods (PPO, DPO,
best-of-n, expert iteration, and more) that learn from pairwise feedback.
Finally, as an end-to-end validation of AlpacaFarm, we train and evaluate
eleven models on 10k pairs of real human feedback and show that rankings of
models trained in AlpacaFarm match rankings of models trained on human data. As
a demonstration of the research possible in AlpacaFarm, we find that methods
that use a reward model can substantially improve over supervised fine-tuning
and that our reference PPO implementation leads to a +10% improvement in
win-rate against Davinci003. We release all components of AlpacaFarm at
https://github.com/tatsu-lab/alpaca_farm. | [
-0.2507203519,
-0.6967875361,
0.4607343674,
0.1747585535,
-0.12128371,
0.1125655323,
-0.2462811917,
-0.4847224057,
0.1480004191,
0.5317289829,
-0.5477912426,
-0.3976626098,
-0.5861552358,
-0.0888557807,
-0.3269523382,
1.0402809381,
-0.2809011042,
0.087222226,
0.0342367403,
-0.038268473,
-0.1082169265,
-0.794659853,
-0.8042516112,
-0.6271188259,
0.7406360507,
0.5877755284,
0.5004352331,
0.6333019137,
0.3979313374,
0.2808018923,
0.1313401461,
0.2145970017,
-0.4161367118,
-0.1462617517,
0.0613636523,
-0.5857943892,
-0.3880072534,
0.2676852047,
0.4352207482,
0.5544292331,
-0.6749047637,
0.1580356508,
0.2237639278,
0.5407173634,
-0.6600365043,
0.3644303679,
-0.2256570607,
0.0838113278,
0.0010180252,
0.0633545667,
-0.4987142682,
-0.6019833088,
0.1793471724,
-0.6464406848,
0.2166766226,
0.1032079756,
0.6502574682,
0.2899506092,
-0.2088887095,
-0.6037871242,
-0.6917649508,
0.7005873322,
-0.7359192371,
0.383808881,
0.565203011,
0.5463220477,
-0.6051051021,
-0.769931674,
-0.6764481068,
-0.5511883497,
0.1995112151,
0.1398111135,
-0.0492881238,
0.0595441312,
0.03053689,
0.1155918092,
-0.1385738254,
0.2130694836,
-0.4831928313,
-0.0915999189,
0.4190765917,
0.0542723723,
-0.0523335785,
0.0618706755,
-0.5358553529,
-0.5350657105,
-0.6528850198,
0.0947737545,
0.5078697205,
0.1432394832,
-0.2117347568,
0.3353286982,
-0.1992426068,
0.5117858648,
-0.070867002,
-0.3570753038,
0.3285175264,
0.2450734526,
-0.1077263728,
-0.079415597,
0.8994711041,
0.2073370963,
-0.0165348351,
-0.2508024871,
-0.2204717249,
0.2002962381,
0.3304371834,
-0.8326144218,
-0.3573475182,
0.0635954514,
-0.4156178832,
-0.4717116952,
-0.0777179599,
-0.8853220344,
-0.4541879892,
-0.2845057249,
0.4250560403,
-0.3567127883,
-0.0280087218,
0.1757427454,
0.0387112424,
0.3394954205,
0.6307373643,
-0.7816514969,
0.5336808562,
0.8159455061,
0.7262686491,
-0.405767113,
-0.7362840772,
-0.6492807865,
0.1335224658,
-0.3059140742,
0.9812222123,
-0.3753329217,
-0.4381927848,
-0.0645675957,
-0.0912160352,
0.1073501557,
-0.6302446127,
0.6116614938,
-0.4485322833,
0.2942255139,
-0.3144711554,
-0.6445451379,
-0.1495185345,
0.3039832711,
-0.5072757602,
0.7559825182,
-0.0927638859,
-0.4373958111,
0.1448028535,
-0.9316052198,
-0.0820236653,
-0.1024477109,
-0.1624408513,
-0.2644887269,
-0.1234500855,
0.0706828982,
0.208377257,
-0.5447614789,
0.0917005241,
-0.3706705868,
-0.6455513239,
0.320614934,
-0.5469365716,
0.5633716583,
0.1414087266,
-0.6230365634,
0.1166635454,
-0.6212694049,
-0.0517475419,
0.1650962234,
-0.3896281719,
0.0962686315,
0.0469837338,
-0.1868341267,
0.0091877263,
-0.2945164442,
-0.5077519417,
0.3807314634,
-0.2072294354,
0.3943992853,
0.6990109086,
0.1349419951,
0.3132993281,
-0.402119875,
0.7287639976,
-0.290769875,
0.3091888726,
-0.0305364802,
-0.4344103932,
-0.8079497218,
-0.3257744014,
0.4354181588,
0.4771582484,
-0.7478787899,
0.1004004627,
0.0571022592,
-0.5224019885,
-0.627737999,
0.3123028874,
0.4116802812,
0.5664157867,
0.295119226,
-0.5260193944,
-0.1915186346,
-0.8429974318,
0.1129180789,
-0.5305112004,
-0.2161515802,
0.0607629642,
0.3345723152,
-0.4043163359,
0.6164249778,
-0.5331215262,
-0.356010288,
-0.1115251705,
0.5339585543,
-0.1557902843,
0.3373469114,
0.5199194551,
-0.2683466375,
0.0887973979,
-0.2158913016,
-0.4862254262,
-0.1591045856,
0.2228975594,
-0.3004893959,
-0.0358405337,
0.2974392772,
-0.4870498478,
0.3107967675,
0.6648911238,
-0.0457806177,
0.4386394918,
-0.2236102521,
0.3380121887,
-0.6953554749,
0.0409729816,
-0.209773168,
-0.1242912859,
-0.2850876451,
0.282568872,
-0.1264050752,
-0.2059987783,
-0.553165257,
0.5759738684,
-0.1248722598,
0.099740535,
-0.6271916032,
-0.0560365878,
0.1423059255,
0.864495337,
-0.036115177,
0.8046116829,
-0.1328022182,
-0.4826158285,
0.5704091191,
0.0725625679,
-0.3283088207,
0.2828519642,
-0.8765895963,
0.431075424,
-0.0180463605,
0.6050382257,
-0.70544976,
-0.5240619779,
0.6562623978,
-0.3219747245,
0.0247959476,
-0.2777126133,
-0.7529006004,
-0.3474715054,
-0.2910873592,
0.1659879535,
0.6734009981,
-0.7120326161,
0.5507270098,
0.4761403501,
0.0495327115,
-0.6941739917,
-0.3418762088,
-0.1635130942,
-0.01510954,
0.0530820005,
-0.0446957536,
-0.068708688,
-0.1588770449,
-0.2201576084,
0.2702211738,
-0.1263054758,
0.1969799697,
0.5423969626,
0.2790172994,
0.3789631724,
0.3033397794,
-0.0144415079,
-0.0486029126,
0.1758090854,
-0.1855324954,
0.5850652456,
-0.3085276186,
-0.8046710491,
-0.5326617956,
0.205776915,
0.2791973054,
-0.0896711275,
0.3568252027,
0.4829626083,
-0.3017161787,
-0.2081959546,
-0.6925461292,
-0.2734821141,
-0.4866824448,
0.3349077702,
-0.0260195229,
-0.517347455,
0.3437420726,
-0.2821315229,
0.3164475262,
0.0276997909,
0.8217223287,
-0.2206362486,
0.91778332,
0.5247067809,
-0.0094901994,
0.3561966717,
-0.2587222159,
-0.3934524655,
-0.5384340286,
-0.3027217686,
-0.4836882353,
-0.3626368046,
-0.0522998758,
-0.7332448959,
0.1840633601,
0.141791597,
-0.2595889866,
0.0928416178,
-0.363712132,
0.6501216888,
0.7853872776,
0.2683020234,
0.3510948718,
0.0141554512,
-0.2273228765,
0.1546880901,
-0.7387948632,
-0.6409476399,
0.8571543694,
0.4939335883,
1.007361412,
-0.0528538041,
0.9032024741,
0.4031507373,
0.9399546981,
-0.9850426912,
0.4052360952,
0.3104137778,
-0.2624014616,
-0.0308273751,
-0.4870330393,
-0.9547402263,
0.1312405318,
-0.1868474036,
-0.5317164063,
0.0748535618,
0.4708122015,
-0.2975828648,
0.2718698084,
-0.8218416572,
0.6265844107,
-0.1486930847,
-0.4577834904,
-0.2633816302,
-0.5021288991,
0.2351912111,
0.0916417465,
0.3606812954,
-0.1726032048,
-0.053774517,
0.8785844445,
-0.6901472807,
1.0644142628,
-0.2722772658,
-0.3464201689,
0.5642538071,
0.0657116622,
0.3929400146,
-0.0543789081,
-0.1583378017,
0.0625398085,
-0.0270978678,
-0.5494562984,
-0.7819510102,
0.7435836792,
-1.0329421759,
-0.4540420175,
-0.3321103752,
-0.4806105494,
-0.3851001263,
-0.1021538973,
0.1652095914,
0.2643656731,
-0.2236157358,
-0.1962618679,
0.279686749,
-0.1520596445,
0.0931083709,
0.4561095238,
-0.4516587555,
-0.6979591846,
0.6599208117,
-0.146113947,
0.1355894208,
0.1094034836,
0.1694032103,
-0.1029356793,
-0.1524767131,
-0.8051799536,
0.2665972412,
-0.7375987768,
-0.2516771257,
-0.3565995097,
0.081906423,
-0.0617257617,
-0.0909680799,
-0.539917171,
-0.4217561185,
0.0547039211,
-0.0709417164,
0.3941944838,
0.7985591888,
0.0014844615,
0.6486943364,
-0.7791834474,
0.0445429087,
0.6315973401,
0.437577039,
0.489102006,
-0.3628591001,
-0.3097634912,
0.3010541499,
-0.6006878614,
-0.9514841437,
0.2569614351,
-0.0765278861,
0.4872982204,
0.3259298205,
0.0432023406,
0.6507778168,
-0.5703150034,
0.5617037416,
0.1835658401,
-0.8792462945,
0.4433178008,
-0.1669559926,
0.1589872986,
0.8121911287,
0.3871189356,
-0.3525995314,
-0.3255129755,
-0.5403016806,
-0.5065575242,
0.4881884456,
0.0315757915,
0.113566719,
-0.1172095463,
0.7587829828,
0.1944939643,
0.1854961067,
-0.4518056214,
-0.0069070831,
-0.0952734873,
-0.2739716768,
0.1750956029,
-0.0323748738,
-0.4162934721,
-0.0765052587,
0.7189428806,
-0.2869102657,
0.349653244,
0.0941922143,
-0.0231266506,
-0.0556478202,
0.1516765356,
0.3885539174,
0.6501405835,
-0.2114893645,
-0.0155629916,
0.3144944608,
-0.5176212192,
0.4164313674,
0.1202492416,
-0.0834552571,
-0.0652615726,
0.3929194808,
0.7931808829,
0.3531138599,
-1.0202394724,
0.5903680325,
-0.2645917237,
-0.3171321452,
-0.2999811471,
0.2550419271,
0.1512145996,
0.3974941671,
0.3494674861,
-0.0702178106,
0.3578166962,
-0.5957306623,
0.1146280468,
0.1130079404,
-0.6264438629,
-0.386194557,
0.6479347944,
0.2097254694,
-0.3763572276,
0.4819890559,
-0.2191403657,
-0.5645138025,
0.5673343539,
0.3367027938,
0.4873129129,
-0.204358235,
0.2718001306,
0.0579743609,
0.0840624794,
-0.4449677765,
-0.0000217545,
-0.2349354625,
-0.367384553,
-0.5182963014,
-0.4798800647,
-1.2003542185,
-0.1888041645,
-0.7275180817,
0.4409879744,
-0.6245058179,
-0.2716345191,
-0.1528555453,
0.0400352962,
-0.5838512182,
-0.1880365759,
0.1092006713,
0.8923999667,
-0.6877273321,
1.0545668602,
0.7356823683,
-0.3080933094,
-0.9299612641,
-0.0005171776,
0.0176582597,
-0.8736261129,
0.5391148329,
0.186691016,
-0.3621634543,
-0.2872864306,
-0.7087212205,
-0.4205299318,
1.1293882132,
0.560854733,
-0.4521789551,
-0.1310123056,
-0.0897834301,
0.6099497676,
-0.2394826263,
0.4021375477,
0.4403960705,
0.0966451094,
0.3604641557,
-0.7981547713,
-0.236294955,
-0.1644397825,
-0.1144549921,
0.1353306919,
-0.9863079786,
0.6413769126,
-0.3387424648,
0.0328338221,
0.1988818645,
0.736849606,
0.7190901041,
0.2190798521,
0.5870085955,
0.4568158686,
0.7797250152,
0.1472229511,
1.1857768297,
-0.1138677821,
0.3242108524,
1.3865637779,
-0.4703553915,
1.1629830599,
0.5333670974,
-0.1375969201,
0.8189151287,
0.4098510444,
0.064207986,
0.4458197653,
0.384922713,
-0.1887737513,
0.0084829731,
-0.1308073997,
-0.3472901285,
0.5609763861,
0.1007349566,
-0.3118725419,
-0.0381591953,
0.1032281741,
0.1096692532,
-0.0086688958,
-0.1138666794,
0.7942528129,
0.1452742368,
-0.5881302953,
0.6406463981,
0.109564364,
0.5874223113,
-0.8076184392,
-0.420878619,
-0.2289302498,
0.4256365895,
0.1555654407,
-0.2869589031,
0.0272759926,
0.129860267,
0.0846128017,
0.1114272401,
0.381415844,
-0.2662060559,
-0.395157218,
0.3661566973,
0.3996311724,
0.0602668822,
0.2422667146,
-0.5448003411,
0.268255949,
-0.2321121246,
-0.3206886947,
0.5150213242,
0.2379401326,
0.0327387862,
0.827331543,
0.7806014419,
0.1309848726,
-0.1213829368,
0.1044005454,
0.8771965504,
-0.3595504463,
-0.346075207,
-0.7156524062,
-0.1862630695,
-0.0428199619,
-0.2193955332,
0.4252153039,
0.3733754158,
0.7028102875,
-0.0081216255,
0.5724500418,
0.3665584922,
0.6953632832,
-0.3655483127,
0.658421278,
-0.2948099673,
0.3911304474,
-0.0893697515,
-0.7992830873,
-0.2388267219,
0.7252318263,
-0.2020291537,
-0.1710309237,
0.3051471114,
0.6101347208,
-0.0326441266,
0.2485132217,
-0.0959312096,
-0.0437108129,
0.3928720355,
0.5107380152,
1.0024998188,
-0.4058423936,
0.7378790379,
-0.5224928856,
-0.5498718023,
-0.1659332663,
-0.821752131,
-0.8241248727,
-0.1927105635,
-0.0697161034,
-0.4338323474,
0.3172638118,
1.5752032995,
0.8228816986,
-0.6956264377,
-0.6068364382,
0.1771779954,
-0.0440473296,
-0.3652349412,
-0.1964841485,
0.3089842498,
-0.2561932206,
-0.8509386182,
0.1965501904,
-0.0227713957,
0.1161925495,
-0.3308590055,
-0.3085600436,
0.0522785075,
0.0819428563,
0.5507621169,
0.4976459146,
-0.733828485,
-0.2736379802,
-0.105511196,
-0.1537701786,
-0.0171485711,
0.8637536168,
-1.0468599796,
0.2035827488,
0.1055949777,
0.802051127,
0.5622879267,
0.0397392809,
0.7386566401,
-0.5123439431,
0.3853159547,
0.1125048846,
0.4246560335,
0.2699528933,
-0.0875335783,
0.6298103929,
0.0268861465,
-0.6324335337,
-0.7823283076,
0.1383224279,
-0.7713217735,
-0.0174863208,
0.95192343,
-0.4162077606,
-0.30807212,
0.1320152283,
-0.5561273098,
0.2192299217,
-0.5999991298,
1.2103641033,
0.5705298185,
-0.2031452507,
-0.2532081008,
-0.5958691239,
0.3831832707,
0.3661934137,
-0.9966728687,
0.1764752418,
0.4851133525,
0.2110523134,
0.0948236585,
0.7145835757,
-0.1062994376,
0.3464189172,
-0.064643912,
0.4382537305,
-0.2253217101,
-0.1344873756,
-0.1798373759,
0.2254418433,
0.4204839766,
-0.1844343543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18569v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18569v2 | Fairness of ChatGPT | 2023-05-22T17:51:56 | 2024-05-05T19:15:30 | Yunqi Li, Lanjing Zhang, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Understanding and addressing unfairness in LLMs are crucial for responsible
AI deployment. However, there is a limited number of quantitative analyses and
in-depth studies regarding fairness evaluations in LLMs, especially when
applying LLMs to high-stakes fields. This work aims to fill this gap by
providing a systematic evaluation of the effectiveness and fairness of LLMs
using ChatGPT as a study case. We focus on assessing ChatGPT's performance in
high-takes fields including education, criminology, finance and healthcare. To
conduct a thorough evaluation, we consider both group fairness and individual
fairness metrics. We also observe the disparities in ChatGPT's outputs under a
set of biased or unbiased prompts. This work contributes to a deeper
understanding of LLMs' fairness performance, facilitates bias mitigation and
fosters the development of responsible AI systems. | [
-0.1821799874,
-0.6758493185,
0.5247539878,
0.4646096826,
0.1558181047,
0.1484043598,
-0.0495688021,
-0.2340481132,
-0.3095239401,
0.2099183351,
-0.3629536033,
-0.3621676862,
-0.9393606782,
-0.1225840524,
-0.2147493213,
1.2354711294,
0.3246318102,
0.5273560286,
-0.4669380486,
-0.1913521737,
-0.6991847754,
-0.7653710842,
-1.0793302059,
-0.6494064927,
0.3053384721,
0.3672961295,
0.7364506721,
0.3615205288,
0.9490343332,
0.3610475361,
-0.2237836421,
-0.1786849797,
-0.7775989771,
-0.2459793091,
-0.2157117575,
-0.7175918221,
-0.5640731454,
0.3251572847,
0.6706195474,
0.5530812144,
-0.4636077583,
0.3302807212,
0.2835291922,
0.6685535312,
-0.5686553717,
0.1963574588,
-0.63166219,
0.4517152309,
-0.4227332175,
-0.1225309968,
-0.2444635928,
-0.8019654751,
0.1223452613,
-0.4344337285,
0.3351843953,
0.182578668,
0.5334120989,
0.370316714,
-0.4892841876,
-0.3360466063,
-0.3801528811,
0.8110714555,
-0.6449084282,
-0.1157847494,
-0.0553907827,
0.7425482273,
-0.3082547486,
-0.7150947452,
-0.4286103547,
0.0745666474,
0.0140228113,
0.5563440919,
0.0313031077,
0.3017090261,
0.336576283,
0.3495794237,
-0.4503316581,
0.2731930614,
-0.3481688797,
-0.4059197009,
0.7093857527,
0.3323878348,
0.0898597986,
-0.1360642463,
-0.4372215569,
0.0877105221,
-0.5480547547,
0.2364519536,
0.7459632158,
0.1445612758,
-0.3348531425,
0.6725555658,
-0.2302490175,
0.1619586796,
-0.17786403,
-0.0189607721,
0.2469142973,
-0.1206072494,
-0.202769652,
0.1097261384,
0.6806773543,
0.7369253635,
0.5226810575,
-0.1557857245,
-0.3672179282,
0.1620490104,
0.2706837952,
-0.69154948,
0.2064509541,
0.0025928486,
-0.718829751,
-0.4786562026,
-0.2280843109,
-0.8895513415,
-0.7692021728,
-0.2577326894,
0.4822553694,
0.0265067462,
-0.084592022,
0.0365865119,
-0.2278430164,
0.6017548442,
0.4355245531,
-0.4901117384,
0.2135984004,
0.9133954048,
0.7034674287,
-0.3006270528,
-0.2346675694,
-0.5465598702,
-0.0240569264,
0.1849854887,
0.7320581675,
-0.3565222621,
-0.4276676178,
0.1174878851,
-0.418004781,
-0.0852517188,
-0.70373559,
0.92305094,
-0.3443652689,
0.232718423,
-0.1987967491,
-0.6347372532,
-0.0216464419,
0.4941953123,
-0.2078038901,
0.6522551179,
0.1186753139,
-0.7560753226,
0.7300781608,
-1.0455306768,
-0.3393820524,
0.2227071226,
-0.455698669,
-0.5706422329,
-0.1019506007,
0.081752643,
0.3701548278,
-0.1700337976,
0.488261342,
-0.2181582302,
-0.8706101179,
0.195267573,
-0.9962735176,
0.8563244939,
0.1927960217,
-0.474447906,
-0.0145239793,
-0.2505150139,
0.0318458378,
0.0716382191,
-0.3494162261,
0.1913999915,
0.1432459652,
-0.0771982893,
0.0639067292,
0.2271905094,
-0.3603369594,
-0.0624289401,
-0.2676080167,
0.3916270137,
1.199349165,
-0.3440347314,
0.5000751615,
-0.5758247375,
0.5201150179,
-0.086407572,
0.7308250666,
0.4715602696,
-0.5342654586,
-0.5788008571,
-0.3499380946,
0.3446316421,
0.6747152209,
-0.5184420943,
-0.0223341715,
-0.1889716685,
-0.1434234232,
-0.777030468,
-0.2413454503,
0.3178623915,
0.703981638,
-0.0500547476,
-0.5068026185,
-0.0296705049,
-1.0550961494,
-0.4897874892,
-0.1333925575,
0.0142181283,
0.7283508182,
0.2973647416,
-0.1319218576,
0.9272545576,
-0.0388127826,
-0.5041068792,
0.1665709019,
-0.0513843037,
0.3243421614,
0.4239731729,
0.5724109411,
-0.8140688539,
-0.1801505238,
-0.3046621382,
-0.8964502215,
-0.2690267861,
0.1590665281,
-0.3292789757,
-0.1035638303,
0.2621439695,
-0.3841986358,
0.7026667595,
0.2829402387,
-0.5079451203,
0.4515674412,
-0.0457638502,
0.699988246,
-0.5165798068,
-0.0100589236,
-0.2866156399,
-0.3071867526,
-0.1826105118,
-0.0587427393,
-0.3196173012,
-0.0633052513,
-0.7797142267,
0.3985356987,
0.1401251107,
-0.4787975848,
-0.0957187787,
0.5888322592,
-0.3095841706,
0.3357360959,
-0.5205465555,
0.9047821164,
0.4634285271,
-0.2789646089,
0.2840664089,
-0.0088742534,
-0.1647353023,
1.105068922,
-0.7889262438,
-0.051503621,
-0.2345247269,
0.1628546268,
-0.6456757188,
-0.0766811818,
0.5049215555,
-0.609447062,
-0.1707863808,
-0.4470334351,
-0.3234352767,
-0.0867699981,
-0.1077734083,
0.7894005179,
0.8000596166,
-0.3234994411,
0.3219686449,
0.5437374115,
-0.1923793256,
-0.9370623231,
-0.4412272871,
-0.0025006391,
-0.560826838,
-0.6343482137,
0.120144926,
0.1022211388,
-0.4997690916,
-0.093101427,
0.0021955916,
-0.0329368263,
0.2690294981,
0.3489603698,
0.0124773309,
-0.0914739594,
-0.2840725482,
-0.2549039125,
-0.1704219282,
0.2670752704,
0.0267819632,
0.4973939955,
-0.2827421725,
-0.8563381433,
-0.2322091609,
0.1494195312,
0.1813615859,
-0.0336486921,
0.4466692805,
0.7486345768,
-0.2659081221,
0.0165282544,
-0.5802099705,
0.0417745635,
-0.5045072436,
0.3225781322,
0.0284645204,
-0.9805825353,
0.6529124975,
-0.0320040956,
0.3347721696,
0.4293317497,
0.6217673421,
-0.2088076621,
0.7104864717,
0.485427767,
-0.2698366046,
0.3072724044,
0.0712760463,
0.3901516497,
-0.4982940853,
-0.6102002859,
-0.5260239244,
-0.379774332,
-0.8975120783,
-0.4313561916,
0.5619559288,
-0.0095965192,
-0.4844635725,
-0.5722075701,
-0.5135192871,
0.5513744354,
0.6809676886,
0.2941112518,
0.4678715467,
-0.0572567098,
0.1545469612,
0.0663073659,
-0.7274002433,
-0.9303581119,
1.0319290161,
0.5682846308,
0.6356288791,
0.2496658862,
0.6939847469,
0.9075033665,
0.7292000055,
-0.6768069267,
0.4528564811,
-0.2187851667,
-0.5331526995,
-0.4945295453,
-0.7614671588,
-1.0292942524,
0.3614307046,
-0.0536801107,
-0.4853153527,
-0.28374511,
0.0486267693,
-0.3246512115,
0.226007551,
-0.817902267,
0.8156920075,
-0.1208282784,
-0.2744050622,
-0.4485359192,
-0.501095295,
0.3998049796,
0.1069496423,
0.4306923449,
-0.5498274565,
0.1747206002,
0.8027083278,
-0.3187530637,
0.6032083035,
-0.5575084686,
0.0117757544,
0.3826692104,
-0.1908529103,
0.1278805286,
0.5108786225,
-0.3298615515,
0.6052282453,
-0.1515994072,
-0.7574948668,
-0.5365942121,
0.6326331496,
-0.7932762504,
-0.7024402022,
-0.6238214374,
-0.5533825159,
-0.141874522,
0.1630533487,
0.0153156994,
0.0810218602,
-0.3813992441,
-0.1988146603,
0.6840487123,
-0.5286934376,
0.4513227344,
0.444852531,
-0.0844753236,
0.0683110133,
0.6954997778,
-0.110785827,
0.1856361479,
-0.0860462785,
0.0081951441,
-0.2507175505,
-0.5630173683,
-0.4859374464,
-0.2506782711,
-0.5499460101,
-0.1885122061,
-0.1702159196,
-0.4832007885,
-0.3349457681,
-0.2434414625,
-0.3688666821,
-0.2387615293,
0.2141159475,
0.287097007,
0.2735441327,
0.7663067579,
-0.1505601257,
0.6533290744,
-0.1583852768,
0.2195234448,
0.2478841692,
0.6352435946,
-0.1191528663,
-0.6274440885,
0.096127674,
0.2252011448,
-0.507355094,
-0.1086142361,
-0.1172265708,
-0.1652940512,
0.9143377542,
0.1076150164,
-0.135667488,
0.4204069972,
-0.551258564,
0.8149748445,
0.1338113695,
-0.7148097754,
0.3698218763,
-0.3906050622,
-0.0570270196,
0.5959476233,
-0.0511889085,
-0.4581254125,
-0.4997994304,
-0.6226261258,
-0.8924348354,
0.6421126723,
0.6277065277,
0.1267646104,
0.3002819121,
0.4814509451,
-0.0280617028,
0.2792753279,
-0.9870601892,
-0.3933362663,
0.0104708169,
-0.2238098681,
0.1633612961,
0.0114887832,
-0.2718755007,
0.2396699637,
0.4723562598,
0.1691586971,
0.4022230506,
0.0176359918,
-0.0905237198,
0.3064007759,
0.3244484961,
0.4010097682,
0.5849463344,
-0.0943578407,
-0.0556082577,
0.3643981814,
-0.4999101162,
0.1621693969,
0.1266225576,
-0.1392783225,
-0.2891026437,
0.4091352522,
0.2435970902,
-0.2907848656,
-0.6773172617,
1.060090065,
-0.3580066562,
-0.1036846936,
-0.187037155,
0.2599711716,
-0.2864198387,
0.5734996796,
0.2055919915,
0.2115707844,
0.4566999972,
-0.414532423,
0.2993930876,
0.5347885489,
-0.3984729648,
0.426168263,
0.6020544171,
0.4479721785,
-0.4738275409,
0.9573321342,
-0.1549452394,
-0.4151643813,
1.0215878487,
0.0921661928,
0.5520164371,
0.015138668,
0.1873987019,
-0.1773226708,
0.3586004376,
0.0768025443,
0.1288173795,
0.1201032475,
-0.5924757123,
-0.3486159742,
-0.5144518614,
-0.5718346834,
-0.2886162102,
-0.5610103607,
0.1592133939,
-0.3114269078,
-0.3806576431,
-0.404189229,
-0.0100730257,
-1.0946785212,
0.1663519144,
-0.0544512123,
0.5573372245,
-0.5379023552,
0.180163756,
0.3213968575,
-0.1771103442,
-0.4532852471,
0.0046526049,
-0.1063362733,
-1.4032224417,
0.5992583632,
0.1129152477,
-0.1042159945,
-0.3209327757,
-0.4011282027,
-0.3877332807,
1.1793233156,
0.677703321,
-0.542481482,
0.2242303044,
0.6577922702,
0.4025728106,
0.1154040992,
0.8433101773,
0.4677760005,
0.4933530986,
-0.3210549653,
-1.1816356182,
-0.2859885097,
0.1245818213,
-0.2802501619,
-0.1431144625,
-1.1682863235,
0.4766667485,
-0.1338422745,
-0.0612846576,
-0.2679766119,
0.3578421474,
0.4444929957,
0.8445888758,
0.429733187,
0.3795762956,
0.9117514491,
-0.3225595951,
0.854427278,
0.0725465044,
0.4641163945,
0.7987783551,
-0.3475041687,
0.0670248717,
0.4412578046,
-0.4389617443,
-0.1472802609,
0.7970954776,
0.1123316213,
0.4522747397,
0.9407641292,
-0.4546792507,
0.1547746807,
-0.3865107298,
-0.4239431322,
0.4684272408,
0.0269530434,
-0.058017835,
-0.3096257448,
-0.0315978937,
0.053468395,
0.0043501453,
-0.7542905211,
0.526688993,
0.2353670299,
-0.3683946729,
-0.2304296494,
0.2092784941,
0.9495174289,
-0.2198013812,
-0.1794997901,
-0.5756960511,
0.1892426908,
-0.2597461641,
-1.149633646,
0.2126386464,
0.139350161,
-0.1125386283,
-0.2345471531,
0.5184413791,
0.0545343272,
-0.3628621399,
0.2186030298,
0.5950424075,
0.4776144326,
0.1297888458,
-0.6437678933,
-0.146582067,
-0.1604760438,
-0.0375958085,
0.3162947297,
0.8537287712,
-0.1197483838,
0.914614141,
0.1711604297,
0.0909399539,
0.1398476511,
0.3770139813,
0.4898167551,
-0.4956196547,
-0.2775913179,
-1.1786215305,
0.3876049519,
-0.2492692769,
-0.4413695931,
0.6766213179,
0.6952294111,
0.8348022699,
0.2547996044,
0.8438699245,
-0.0729705021,
0.1858868152,
-0.5299991369,
0.9932224154,
-0.3202198148,
0.5009827018,
-0.3756462932,
-0.7216252685,
-0.045384869,
0.5561199784,
-0.2402120233,
0.3885159194,
0.0188433733,
0.6919569969,
0.0175323337,
-0.0258727986,
0.4048340917,
-0.1402957737,
0.4312412441,
0.6215826273,
1.2879071236,
-0.4003904462,
0.488602668,
0.1851267666,
-0.456702441,
-0.1135934442,
-1.0306743383,
-0.8131601214,
0.1896606088,
-0.1192776039,
-0.3133618832,
0.4713454545,
0.5859894753,
0.6468178034,
-0.5198013186,
-0.3104123473,
0.3260035217,
0.4947304428,
0.0880532041,
-0.3433188498,
0.2725431323,
-0.3214331567,
-0.5793099403,
-0.0560188815,
0.1436391473,
-0.094807066,
-0.0470195971,
-0.2569108903,
0.3942013681,
0.0013356247,
0.6421977878,
-0.2999219596,
-0.3397781551,
-0.4267205,
-0.3983589709,
-0.2811152339,
0.1599586308,
0.8982175589,
-0.6521009207,
-0.1255143732,
0.0557293408,
0.7490899563,
0.2549445629,
0.0080667762,
0.5472056866,
-0.5121874809,
0.0902968049,
0.4845252633,
0.1684305519,
0.1086164787,
-0.6399764419,
0.7552415729,
0.2281889021,
-1.0363595486,
-0.7615188956,
-0.0950053483,
-0.815217495,
0.1376111358,
0.9112095833,
-0.1569953859,
0.3275001049,
0.0129399989,
-0.3578440547,
0.4552470446,
-0.5451176763,
1.0776973963,
0.6591998339,
-0.384116739,
0.2214165777,
-0.9166969061,
0.3326034546,
0.6061995029,
-0.7983022928,
-0.0998370573,
0.4147597551,
0.2801494598,
-0.5622064471,
0.996709466,
-0.3709487915,
0.2003239393,
-0.2802940905,
0.0885851309,
0.2382525355,
0.1236934438,
-0.3014985323,
0.1581876129,
0.139636606,
-0.1546532661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13286v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13286v2 | How do languages influence each other? Studying cross-lingual data sharing during LM fine-tuning | 2023-05-22T17:47:41 | 2024-05-21T11:47:13 | Rochelle Choenni, Dan Garrette, Ekaterina Shutova | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual large language models (MLLMs) are jointly trained on data from
many different languages such that representation of individual languages can
benefit from other languages' data. Impressive performance on zero-shot
cross-lingual transfer shows that these models are capable of exploiting data
from other languages. Yet, it remains unclear to what extent, and under which
conditions, languages rely on each other's data. In this study, we use TracIn
(Pruthi et al., 2020), a training data attribution (TDA) method, to retrieve
the most influential training samples seen during multilingual fine-tuning for
a particular test language. This allows us to analyse cross-lingual sharing
mechanisms of MLLMs from a new perspective. While previous work studied
cross-lingual sharing at the level of model parameters, we present the first
approach to study cross-lingual sharing at the data level. We find that MLLMs
rely on data from multiple languages from the early stages of fine-tuning and
that this reliance gradually increases as fine-tuning progresses. We further
study how different fine-tuning languages influence model performance on a
given test language and find that they can both reinforce and complement the
knowledge acquired from data of the test language itself. | [
-0.5550806522,
-0.5843901038,
0.3759796023,
0.2670463622,
-0.1376684606,
-0.0405582376,
-0.1690958142,
-1.0409384966,
0.0977509767,
0.3842265606,
-0.4020677209,
-0.2240252495,
-0.6001056433,
0.0160805639,
-0.1028800532,
0.9954301715,
-0.1926207393,
0.3461398184,
0.1256929785,
-0.5435746312,
-0.4003692269,
-0.8576020598,
-0.5462487936,
-0.6100955606,
1.108450532,
0.4086688757,
0.8196030259,
0.461668998,
0.2474273443,
0.2513008118,
0.0080268746,
-0.0011123181,
-0.7367722392,
-0.0423161536,
-0.4409567714,
-0.6550990343,
-0.094385922,
-0.1872524321,
0.7975783944,
0.7211941481,
0.0980261266,
0.3438310623,
0.2098717093,
0.4841312468,
-0.7004089952,
0.2573052049,
-0.7014487982,
0.1393781006,
-0.4587454498,
-0.2917685807,
-0.340923816,
-0.2901570499,
0.0397919305,
-0.4434465468,
0.0643184707,
-0.1459670961,
0.7804080844,
-0.0202447642,
-0.5278992057,
-0.2073967159,
-0.6901000142,
0.913030982,
-0.4951733351,
0.6407046914,
0.4805595875,
-0.0096887574,
0.1582556367,
-0.315190047,
-0.3189425766,
-0.1462283134,
-0.4647247195,
-0.3842027187,
-0.0854515433,
-0.1881441474,
0.1505087912,
0.0323232152,
-0.4026360512,
0.3275095522,
-0.6287777424,
-0.019266285,
0.6684775949,
0.0014578872,
0.4661708176,
0.1318388134,
-0.1888587624,
-0.1695714444,
-0.91583395,
0.0603002235,
0.1774512976,
0.6355304122,
-0.3094587028,
0.4629268348,
0.0078173401,
0.6483728886,
-0.1750361025,
0.3808992803,
0.2010141909,
-0.5044640303,
-0.2700214386,
0.1544945836,
0.7453431487,
0.1628357768,
0.7807174921,
-0.2978871465,
-0.1723868996,
-0.1852286309,
-0.0480061546,
-0.5511519313,
-0.0031843632,
-0.4245659113,
-0.2048014253,
-0.1829575747,
-0.0612784065,
-0.5346633792,
-0.3735918403,
-0.482534945,
0.5548822284,
-0.1481652111,
-0.3263500035,
0.0236179847,
0.2079996318,
0.3368148804,
0.065361768,
-1.1193115711,
0.2850419879,
0.7461423874,
0.718008101,
-0.1795604527,
-0.8489877582,
-0.6550624967,
0.2792570293,
-0.5343837738,
0.4840778708,
-0.5771842003,
-0.234167859,
0.1543208808,
0.2413747907,
-0.2831302583,
-0.4300079942,
0.0517990105,
-0.6528311372,
0.1899364144,
-0.5922549367,
-0.4471000731,
-0.3367170095,
0.1155013517,
-0.9926156998,
0.9039642811,
-0.1481229961,
-0.7725246549,
0.5761409402,
-0.4407181442,
-0.6270960569,
-0.0994643643,
-0.3143279552,
-0.2392947078,
0.1953986585,
0.0623017326,
0.5510370135,
-0.2689439058,
0.1014156938,
-0.5097192526,
-0.2412217706,
0.3003490567,
-0.3594795763,
0.932207346,
0.04431431,
-0.1757283807,
0.0996438563,
-0.6425403357,
0.0734595954,
-0.0128149781,
-0.0872198865,
-0.7559958696,
-0.3121497035,
0.0837037265,
0.5864391923,
0.0372130312,
-0.3484480977,
0.0615225136,
-0.1175175756,
0.0985621512,
0.6772382259,
0.1988740861,
0.3035554588,
-0.4870215654,
0.571203351,
0.0872356072,
0.1142792106,
0.1382199377,
-0.3932905197,
-0.5344037414,
0.2297797352,
0.5112102032,
0.4980348349,
-0.5383117795,
-0.443982929,
-0.0766442046,
-0.5276358128,
-0.7680447102,
0.5302073359,
0.4760108888,
-0.0303213391,
0.1271055937,
-0.4197703302,
-0.4493431151,
-1.0048226118,
-0.3801223636,
-0.103505753,
0.2823618352,
0.1946905255,
0.3535082936,
0.1394483149,
0.4679527283,
-0.1963849217,
-0.2535688579,
-0.5357083082,
0.0635922626,
-0.0175645705,
0.6779280901,
1.0066378117,
-0.6536560059,
-1.0483173132,
0.4876526594,
-0.6207626462,
-0.1459201127,
-0.1792051941,
-0.3314519525,
0.4384815097,
0.382594794,
-0.3456251621,
0.2271853685,
0.9408842921,
-0.4818761349,
0.4828808308,
-0.3294155896,
0.1510436088,
-0.8405368924,
0.0695395842,
0.061013855,
-0.2015997767,
-0.8653695583,
0.0397568829,
0.0449762568,
0.2706784308,
-0.7338873744,
0.805003643,
-0.4640115201,
-0.1860285848,
0.049263455,
0.0231587123,
0.1282843947,
0.6062857509,
0.1122205928,
0.6206545234,
0.8100865483,
-0.5520076156,
-0.0299788024,
-0.0059977644,
-0.3554478288,
0.276209712,
-0.7417578697,
0.0594949163,
0.1512263566,
-0.2994303107,
-0.6207790971,
0.0952727571,
0.1779866815,
-0.2316178083,
0.3400618732,
-0.3595615923,
-0.6896241307,
0.2691856325,
-0.0027191588,
0.5879536271,
0.0051797531,
-0.5460871458,
0.400403142,
0.5093111992,
-0.0640106723,
-0.6797494292,
-0.9917798042,
-0.1090970859,
-0.3345334828,
-0.4903618693,
-0.0827007666,
0.061062213,
-0.5447704792,
-0.1744669378,
0.1284201741,
-0.3698132038,
0.0244955551,
0.1755814403,
0.1597377062,
-0.1245467737,
0.234038949,
-0.118066065,
0.1873296499,
0.1308255941,
-0.210226953,
0.6130063534,
-0.0337507129,
-0.2809382975,
-0.5325340033,
0.4287031889,
0.5546380877,
-0.4495221972,
1.2706301212,
0.5009232163,
-0.0808374435,
-0.1895172298,
-0.3732053339,
-0.1673592329,
-0.4574988484,
0.3482308388,
-0.6546955705,
-0.6441787481,
0.9028265476,
0.4558881521,
0.0810042247,
0.3481387794,
0.7409793139,
0.0743719935,
1.0101644993,
0.9827113152,
-0.5355246663,
0.8781037927,
-0.1935066432,
-0.3776005208,
-0.325488627,
-0.0531044416,
-0.523462832,
-0.4621500671,
-0.9988946319,
-0.368824631,
0.0194917452,
-0.0099368198,
-0.085008271,
0.1405318975,
0.2297732234,
0.6577185392,
0.6104263067,
0.0984369069,
0.4857834876,
0.1327985674,
-0.2178197205,
0.1212693751,
-0.8362486959,
-0.0137552759,
1.1667054892,
0.2173407227,
0.8736746311,
0.0830954313,
0.3767646849,
0.2410865575,
0.0517268293,
-0.4488332272,
0.2581770718,
-0.2603746057,
-0.6499539018,
-0.1558479816,
-0.4188265204,
-1.1437602043,
0.3641681075,
-0.0449976474,
-0.7208764553,
0.2982884347,
-0.0346997045,
0.0162647683,
0.4146958292,
-0.7083432674,
0.9974522591,
-0.3272443414,
-0.6602637768,
-0.5467489362,
-0.6481484175,
0.268564254,
-0.2666165829,
0.1985070407,
0.211068958,
0.3461890817,
0.7488869429,
0.0504285134,
1.0803616047,
-0.1273243278,
-0.7150181532,
0.0686912686,
0.188698113,
0.3749052286,
0.134369269,
-0.2075363398,
0.4655379355,
0.0719804168,
-0.6152327657,
-0.6178765893,
0.8053292632,
-0.979727447,
-0.4407096803,
-0.0839563757,
-0.7316177487,
-0.3401645422,
0.3230988681,
0.1071832627,
0.5244192481,
-0.0558728613,
0.129843086,
0.474106431,
-0.0284711625,
0.2775696218,
0.7050483823,
-0.6047672629,
0.1152184531,
0.8075224757,
0.1812389046,
0.7591730356,
0.5179180503,
0.1895937324,
-0.1222333014,
-0.29232499,
-0.5694789886,
0.4740555584,
-0.7278658152,
0.2554419339,
-0.3607230484,
-0.1168439314,
-0.2192751318,
-0.0215873215,
-0.4611890912,
-0.6265227795,
-0.1002992839,
-0.1139823422,
0.3540002704,
0.9814418554,
-0.258074522,
0.3668991625,
-1.0234520435,
0.0275926273,
0.1204187796,
0.5420500636,
0.116608046,
-0.2327046841,
-0.7747134566,
0.1715008318,
0.0946408436,
-0.8717349768,
0.1389591098,
0.2684727907,
0.7775357366,
0.2928462029,
-0.1894098669,
0.5820736885,
-0.2603139579,
0.6162130833,
-0.1571299732,
-0.877106607,
0.1881344318,
-0.1007514969,
0.3843237162,
0.565273881,
0.3654200733,
-0.8951756358,
-0.6298627853,
-0.3725579083,
-0.3095968366,
0.9292567968,
0.0078288009,
-0.0068484116,
0.5297529697,
0.1686712652,
0.3121350408,
0.0521420836,
-0.8389958143,
-0.32667467,
0.144764632,
0.0607437454,
-0.3864043355,
0.0764432177,
-0.1703078002,
-0.2790314853,
0.379127562,
-0.0745953172,
-0.2514503896,
-0.1601678431,
-0.4004659355,
-0.3524842262,
0.2408266962,
0.6327052116,
0.6688870192,
0.1185569912,
0.2295268923,
0.3596258163,
-0.4046751857,
0.0577278882,
-0.0458609313,
-0.2423142642,
0.1386394501,
0.4771391749,
1.1920170784,
0.1603543758,
-0.4085554481,
-0.0684159696,
-0.2628232539,
-0.0791168809,
0.2352998406,
0.0427422933,
-0.0809679627,
0.3755803704,
0.0886728168,
-0.042852968,
-0.2876993716,
-0.7236696482,
0.3851198554,
0.5524337888,
-0.4962391555,
-0.7370747328,
0.3166585267,
-0.2057006806,
0.0356967524,
0.3345293701,
-0.0463296324,
-0.8390260339,
0.5610784888,
0.4239265621,
0.6436613202,
-0.4278807342,
0.1983077228,
0.148556903,
0.3149337471,
0.1421776563,
0.3495283127,
-0.0812776089,
-0.6770300269,
-0.6009187102,
-0.4348680377,
-0.210188821,
0.0468136072,
-0.6830574274,
0.3227906823,
-0.0069002858,
0.1699124277,
-0.0945288464,
0.34063676,
-0.931391716,
0.1238594577,
0.3822865188,
0.6643347144,
-0.8761464357,
1.2732561827,
0.7902756929,
-0.1922160983,
-0.9442527294,
0.0569389537,
-0.0021519507,
-0.9712154865,
0.9767823219,
-0.0661501735,
-0.1696329117,
-0.0353299528,
-0.0856789052,
-0.9027897716,
0.5334547758,
0.2962770462,
-0.5151282549,
-0.0090908511,
0.7712979913,
0.6876293421,
-0.3123738468,
-0.003166189,
0.56374681,
0.5525308251,
-0.0549429543,
-1.3045128584,
0.04125572,
-0.1511265934,
-0.3212293983,
0.3742190599,
-0.6631225944,
0.8567159176,
-0.3593218327,
-0.175937444,
-0.335113734,
0.3969306946,
0.042088151,
0.1854699254,
0.5336351395,
0.2149843425,
0.5916261077,
0.4137705863,
0.9755902886,
-0.6354006529,
0.340710938,
1.3854718208,
-0.2275901735,
0.8935759664,
0.6230678558,
-0.0420413353,
0.4104430676,
0.4540832341,
-0.0085324738,
0.5628825426,
0.1346991807,
0.0173020791,
0.0520247594,
-0.2859044671,
-0.3617233336,
0.664702177,
0.2569235861,
-0.4932859838,
-0.2489880919,
0.1754437089,
0.0094930548,
-0.2810030282,
-0.4438169897,
0.7572946548,
0.0247939099,
-0.6637692451,
0.7898900509,
-0.2843605578,
0.3212495446,
-0.7483690977,
0.3376280069,
-0.3181018233,
0.3735651076,
-0.1044540703,
-0.9841746092,
0.3535369933,
-0.0084516956,
-0.1215954721,
-0.2651531398,
0.4825636148,
-0.8414920568,
-0.499327749,
0.8024232984,
0.8761509061,
-0.0348991975,
-0.0085739372,
-0.5924948454,
0.150433585,
0.1940914094,
-0.2685352564,
0.577490747,
0.6346398592,
-0.2861720622,
0.5838225484,
0.3884145916,
0.5384957194,
0.3964388072,
0.3848663867,
0.6624881625,
-0.6199105382,
-0.2375859171,
-0.9613468051,
0.2617968321,
0.2380913496,
-0.258695662,
0.9964582324,
0.4659684896,
1.1800701618,
0.0293018036,
0.6792704463,
0.0881265253,
0.2507772446,
-0.4823257029,
1.0299142599,
-1.0131369829,
0.1244406402,
-0.1273700297,
-0.7916948795,
-0.2632143497,
0.082689859,
-0.1930228919,
-0.0285825972,
0.557101965,
0.7293771505,
-0.134369269,
0.0313436352,
0.3486367762,
0.2551337183,
0.2993524671,
0.6343720555,
0.6457675099,
-0.2171320021,
0.5620553493,
-0.583029747,
0.0932778865,
-0.029173553,
-0.5184467435,
-0.9800165296,
-0.7098300457,
-0.1124856994,
-0.0615656972,
0.0096613048,
0.7261148095,
0.6377457976,
-1.0213527679,
-0.5566805005,
0.0073059821,
0.3602431715,
-0.3042160869,
-0.2094425261,
0.2609187663,
-0.3595274389,
-0.8687931895,
0.1623911709,
-0.1265173554,
0.1739570498,
-0.5508518815,
-0.0887237117,
-0.3594743013,
-0.0646259487,
0.5302641988,
0.2951125801,
-0.4436232746,
-0.1626968384,
0.0646550283,
-0.3005190492,
0.0777966529,
1.1560596228,
-0.6888080239,
0.2912674844,
0.5993914008,
0.4188610911,
0.3708804548,
-0.2546167672,
0.9772024751,
-0.957729876,
0.3174152672,
-0.2131366134,
0.3292750418,
0.2061349154,
-0.2366557866,
0.4368558824,
0.0658568218,
-0.5677006841,
-0.7903865576,
0.0638621897,
-0.597731173,
-0.2605548501,
1.1635417938,
-0.1272901148,
-0.0544386134,
-0.1287304014,
-0.0652839169,
0.4773014784,
-0.2674369514,
0.8379792571,
0.887172699,
0.027153926,
-0.3588560522,
-0.7157636285,
0.6299601197,
0.5602009296,
-0.5866554976,
0.4301640987,
0.0870409012,
0.1714213192,
0.0952593833,
0.2765713036,
0.2492777854,
0.0421801545,
-0.1843676567,
-0.2932049632,
0.2563288808,
-0.3386292458,
-0.409711659,
0.0081895441,
0.1137191355,
0.0065893247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13282v1 | Is Fine-tuning Needed? Pre-trained Language Models Are Near Perfect for Out-of-Domain Detection | 2023-05-22T17:42:44 | 2023-05-22T17:42:44 | Rheeya Uppaal, Junjie Hu, Yixuan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is a critical task for reliable
predictions over text. Fine-tuning with pre-trained language models has been a
de facto procedure to derive OOD detectors with respect to in-distribution (ID)
data. Despite its common use, the understanding of the role of fine-tuning and
its necessity for OOD detection is largely unexplored. In this paper, we raise
the question: is fine-tuning necessary for OOD detection? We present a study
investigating the efficacy of directly leveraging pre-trained language models
for OOD detection, without any model fine-tuning on the ID data. We compare the
approach with several competitive fine-tuning objectives, and offer new
insights under various types of distributional shifts. Extensive evaluations on
8 diverse ID-OOD dataset pairs demonstrate near-perfect OOD detection
performance (with 0% FPR95 in many cases), strongly outperforming its
fine-tuned counterparts. We show that using distance-based detection methods,
pre-trained language models are near-perfect OOD detectors when the
distribution shift involves a domain change. Furthermore, we study the effect
of fine-tuning on OOD detection and identify how to balance ID accuracy with
OOD detection performance. Our code is publically available at
https://github.com/Uppaal/lm-ood. | [
-0.6341406107,
-0.6769942641,
0.5173330903,
-0.4184293747,
-0.4636278152,
-0.3774935603,
-0.3443045318,
-0.7586582303,
-0.3617824018,
0.7323539257,
-0.5320318341,
-0.446880281,
-0.6497630477,
-0.0162074715,
-0.2408262193,
0.926879108,
0.008675321,
-0.3670349121,
0.0756952092,
-0.2130025923,
-0.5004085302,
-0.3133624196,
-0.479203254,
-0.3644010723,
-0.0879328623,
0.5638270378,
0.7218956947,
0.9243392944,
0.6797217131,
0.1837126315,
-0.0422560275,
0.5537061691,
-0.7470293641,
-0.0034090059,
-0.4310638607,
-0.6073300242,
-0.5874448419,
-0.2189013511,
0.5863921046,
0.6879563928,
-0.0658425316,
0.1588182002,
-0.1302336454,
0.7345955968,
-0.8882412314,
-0.1310433,
-0.8849434853,
-0.106256932,
-0.7241591215,
-0.4263387322,
-0.4264177978,
-0.1392553896,
0.0075112381,
-0.5618286729,
0.2621278763,
0.3305258751,
0.9603456855,
0.3662290573,
-0.2664360404,
-0.3229338527,
-0.8389191031,
0.7917795777,
-0.7299240828,
0.3894807994,
0.6893143058,
0.1985812932,
-0.4437327087,
-0.3130784035,
-0.668518126,
-0.0232807174,
0.1708559245,
-0.1399710774,
-0.2949614823,
0.1377171427,
0.118924439,
0.5271017551,
-0.2346845865,
0.5049090981,
-0.1568878442,
0.245339632,
0.5667338371,
0.0876856074,
0.3042266965,
0.3549777269,
-0.09516716,
-0.0517827086,
-0.7533546686,
-0.1900403202,
0.6346154809,
0.3901923895,
-0.1450012177,
0.3912794888,
-0.31705001,
0.8181372881,
0.3070569932,
-0.0289388876,
0.1411236078,
-0.3844470382,
-0.1969790608,
-0.0218999721,
0.569309473,
0.268854171,
0.6769480705,
0.0050431592,
-0.5965822935,
-0.0453619845,
0.1158298403,
-0.7954522371,
-0.3896497488,
-0.0079752281,
-0.6106464267,
-0.2911204696,
-0.0815985426,
-0.4596508145,
-0.3962618709,
-0.2664154768,
0.3797895908,
-0.4538749456,
-0.6491312385,
0.7130787969,
-0.1060632765,
-0.1920299828,
0.0970296115,
-1.1111252308,
0.0549675897,
0.5445227623,
0.6697050929,
-0.2077561766,
-0.3121404648,
-0.6123259664,
0.0373145677,
-0.5084172487,
1.0738043785,
-0.6101020575,
-0.0127812205,
0.1147739962,
-0.1018170714,
-0.154282704,
-0.9173959494,
0.382568121,
-0.5544370413,
-0.1818748415,
0.1085740402,
-0.7414871454,
0.3382426798,
-0.0440805368,
-0.5071926117,
1.0422898531,
0.1343158484,
-0.7593591213,
0.6736088991,
-0.7278963327,
-0.471227169,
-0.0399494283,
0.2305286527,
-0.5291756988,
0.4642364681,
0.2251439244,
0.4866994917,
0.0153228436,
0.0270858407,
-0.6775300503,
-0.5061941147,
0.0518181175,
-0.4122182727,
0.5453925729,
0.3956198692,
-0.3644014895,
-0.2093291134,
-0.9632653594,
0.0383947678,
-0.1375962794,
-0.104010269,
-0.6282121539,
0.1538585871,
-0.0871526897,
-0.0308537725,
0.0890283734,
-0.4567701519,
0.0284179412,
-0.7518840432,
0.4884058535,
0.6033986211,
-0.1367601901,
0.831358254,
-0.2189306021,
0.4652991295,
0.1289074123,
0.2527661026,
-0.1990683675,
-0.3619538248,
-0.3198248744,
-0.3671320379,
0.1111703813,
0.2630215883,
-0.6674998999,
0.7861170769,
-0.0824209154,
-0.3349633515,
-0.4986854792,
0.1150761619,
0.3859547675,
0.4230856001,
0.40839836,
-0.2698788941,
-0.2561461627,
-0.3715717793,
-0.4629684985,
0.0683766082,
0.3274042308,
-0.0147977313,
0.4659572542,
-0.4843279421,
1.1587772369,
-0.6746673584,
-0.7730845809,
-0.4142216742,
-0.1241242513,
-0.0217766557,
0.3526119888,
0.8643686771,
-0.6376774907,
-0.429348439,
0.3617279828,
-0.5339684486,
-0.2440838963,
0.261788249,
-0.1658360064,
0.2255111784,
0.9362632632,
-0.4090151489,
0.5886176229,
0.5187420249,
-0.1608393639,
0.3323635757,
-0.6836000681,
-0.2442712635,
-0.9989961982,
-0.0124735218,
-0.1020668,
-0.3323179185,
-0.7998335361,
0.3064449728,
0.1720355153,
0.0329753645,
-0.3981784582,
0.5735912323,
-0.4016090333,
0.1118639186,
-0.5172331333,
0.1174130142,
0.0050634728,
-0.0553059131,
0.0376384333,
0.6606923938,
0.5512913465,
-0.8535438776,
-0.0149338199,
-0.0510045923,
-0.834005475,
0.6390841603,
-0.3266242445,
-0.040483661,
-0.3207721412,
-0.0143239545,
-0.9985054135,
-0.0902107432,
0.2163198143,
-0.0898792744,
0.3440233767,
-0.3328508139,
-0.5890848637,
-0.1245657429,
-0.2318057716,
0.6186137795,
0.4881568551,
-0.7665064335,
0.0072684428,
0.4842619002,
0.3906516433,
-0.2798840106,
-0.5752220154,
-0.6036210656,
-0.3266271651,
-0.4129272699,
0.3055905998,
-0.1162084639,
-0.1170181409,
-0.0525172465,
-0.1387544572,
-0.3779895008,
0.1926144063,
0.0256492589,
-0.3784921765,
-0.310693562,
0.3544504344,
0.0988377035,
-0.1083830073,
-0.1954061389,
-0.4634969234,
0.599229753,
0.0693238974,
-0.3001800776,
-0.4654062986,
0.1385419816,
0.4634450376,
-0.4336170256,
0.6609679461,
0.5790002942,
-0.4333351552,
-0.438562572,
-0.2844600976,
-0.1663989872,
-0.521369338,
0.3849335611,
-0.3022571504,
-0.5172396302,
0.4542486072,
-0.257067591,
-0.3869381249,
0.2366650999,
0.2545899153,
-0.1819804609,
1.0756942034,
1.0579297543,
-0.1048560664,
1.0013298988,
-0.1034675613,
0.4728629887,
-0.4381644428,
0.2293885946,
-0.5673468709,
-0.0388777852,
-0.4829178751,
-0.070496656,
0.1855080575,
0.3740603328,
0.0035751748,
0.1148071885,
-0.3894557953,
0.932294488,
0.3164508343,
0.1075156108,
0.4457556903,
0.197715342,
0.3849439621,
0.2479813546,
-0.4431254268,
-0.2837506533,
1.1424872875,
0.314973563,
0.9717441201,
-0.1165244207,
0.7914156318,
0.3419932723,
-0.0722152442,
-0.4985639751,
0.2603656054,
-0.5091981292,
-0.5098862052,
-0.5551433563,
-0.3194297254,
-1.0933490992,
-0.0224908832,
0.0134389047,
-0.5542313457,
0.4497880936,
0.5507104397,
-0.6575924754,
0.3291298449,
-0.8937831521,
1.0597202778,
0.0866505429,
0.2925948501,
-0.2122770101,
-0.395508796,
0.2072678208,
-0.0874922127,
0.254866302,
-0.5321708918,
0.4194984436,
0.2475164384,
-0.6324766278,
0.7709850073,
-0.177989617,
-0.4220592082,
0.1137389168,
-0.0693968087,
0.6125568748,
0.050669305,
-0.0935195312,
0.1537611783,
0.2376665324,
-0.2712183893,
-0.2922550142,
0.5867218375,
-0.7022325993,
-0.2553670704,
-0.1676241457,
-0.4571902752,
0.0771431625,
0.5455408692,
0.9204136133,
0.6698856354,
0.0900473967,
-0.1274569482,
0.965654254,
-0.0159855746,
0.3331272602,
0.4783336222,
-0.2512004375,
0.0898641497,
1.0728684664,
0.1301688105,
0.6374101639,
0.493224442,
0.2922271192,
-0.3400076628,
-1.0471417904,
-0.5318775773,
0.1436078697,
-0.6682687998,
-0.2868287861,
-0.3014541566,
0.1204533279,
-0.3068879545,
0.0103374803,
-0.6194180846,
0.1272448897,
-0.5774162412,
0.1157349646,
0.477519244,
0.6875492334,
-0.017920021,
0.5858424306,
-0.4189124703,
0.5738944411,
-0.1487419754,
0.6552419066,
-0.3119727373,
-0.7888507843,
-0.4766424596,
0.3869043291,
-0.1002310291,
-0.4118151367,
0.4238733649,
0.7359884977,
0.2273567021,
0.6096230149,
0.5022624731,
0.9920827746,
-0.4946328104,
0.3656837046,
-0.1553274244,
-0.962773025,
0.7136849761,
-0.2994098365,
0.3863738775,
0.6815515757,
0.2094297558,
-0.1484153867,
-0.5804706216,
-0.2091188729,
-0.6035310626,
1.1087026596,
-0.0943202823,
0.1699048877,
-0.1304762661,
0.2821767926,
0.3513097167,
0.2019105256,
-0.3058784008,
-0.1742604524,
0.1736232191,
-0.1354918331,
-0.2763585746,
-0.0814675763,
0.1968799531,
-0.1653138995,
0.247052297,
-0.2150936574,
0.0634260625,
-0.056940686,
-0.4294724762,
-0.5522908568,
0.0583487749,
0.7405381799,
0.8688384295,
-0.5775358081,
0.043803487,
-0.1565307826,
-0.6449507475,
-0.0899838507,
0.0523197427,
-0.095613353,
0.0098989392,
0.1927019209,
0.9193386436,
0.0379087105,
-0.8397012949,
0.6917215586,
0.0238249265,
0.0640949085,
-0.1711526662,
0.2002232969,
-0.4346961379,
0.2041445971,
0.1170577034,
0.4798386395,
0.1865958869,
-0.7192677259,
0.0111533254,
0.5668315887,
-0.230000779,
-0.5089614391,
0.4945545793,
-0.0179611035,
-0.172991097,
0.4573458433,
-0.3900378942,
-0.1631169915,
0.6152411699,
0.6033833623,
0.5870022178,
-0.1534591466,
0.1199627668,
-0.4043350816,
0.3444521129,
-0.5033961535,
0.3627029061,
-0.03287182,
-1.093809247,
-0.2160794139,
-0.5422545671,
-0.0137882354,
0.2465897352,
-0.7034373879,
0.4999370873,
-0.2383764684,
-0.0546136014,
0.1511649936,
-0.2766765356,
-0.7624204159,
0.2395069003,
0.1527531147,
0.8509865403,
-0.7329980731,
1.1378145218,
0.6988385916,
-0.0414251052,
-0.4778733253,
0.3079594672,
-0.4998492002,
-0.695196867,
0.4855200052,
0.2070676535,
-0.2330976278,
0.2530328929,
-0.3189275563,
-0.7944387794,
0.6896947622,
0.7755339146,
-0.6657587886,
0.1073962152,
0.40596807,
0.7784039378,
-0.3049514592,
0.332936734,
0.7758206725,
0.0730782449,
-0.3683383167,
-1.1597818136,
-0.2694108784,
0.2027602345,
0.035909988,
0.8677595854,
-0.3175151348,
0.9334486127,
-0.3060733378,
-0.2992483377,
0.0905867592,
0.2887270451,
-0.0622211359,
0.6281063557,
0.391307503,
0.6353447437,
0.7645263672,
0.175838396,
1.0310600996,
-0.215642333,
0.4886722863,
0.9496147633,
-0.4464754462,
1.0837007761,
0.2530396581,
0.0290637892,
0.0095513323,
0.6100013256,
0.5828527212,
0.9578851461,
0.0469325893,
-0.029500572,
-0.4557883441,
0.0196615811,
-0.7892712355,
0.2923113704,
0.4449286461,
-0.29121539,
-0.4122609794,
0.3508547544,
-0.2510100603,
0.1813777387,
-0.6043916345,
0.5585744381,
-0.0281169638,
-0.4809603989,
0.9654499292,
-0.0629529729,
0.7991943955,
-0.3342536688,
0.2132616341,
-0.5693797469,
0.8386824131,
-0.1458049119,
-0.6820753217,
0.3057493269,
-0.3213408291,
-0.3949460089,
-0.3193839788,
0.8963033557,
-0.6245489717,
0.0098662516,
0.3412560821,
0.2361086011,
0.1318185776,
-0.5156105161,
-0.2688144743,
0.0317892954,
-0.2151181847,
-0.0023820966,
0.6302143931,
1.0005114079,
-0.2572666109,
0.5421405435,
0.6330768466,
0.0923409164,
0.3050076365,
0.1225706413,
0.7104728818,
-0.3168140054,
-0.6525693536,
-1.0504566431,
0.0763544887,
0.1253860593,
-0.6717329025,
0.519859612,
0.2600635886,
1.3818224669,
-0.4762145281,
0.6161054373,
0.2325677723,
0.4344272912,
-0.5556055307,
0.6585735083,
-0.7866438627,
0.1704694927,
-0.0858688578,
-0.8373619318,
-0.3191503882,
0.4119481444,
-0.4079658687,
-0.1563245356,
0.4685829878,
0.8507375121,
-0.4430347681,
-0.2075996697,
0.6346418858,
-0.0900018737,
0.2432820201,
0.3541406393,
0.8402941823,
-0.4760255814,
0.532802999,
-0.2138718218,
-0.1125037447,
-0.6257150769,
-0.848505199,
-1.2055443525,
-0.4795325696,
-0.4062404037,
-0.0280207191,
0.4280785024,
0.8481527567,
0.7704460025,
-0.8519263268,
-0.0773694664,
-0.5467315316,
0.0999423042,
-0.3682596684,
-0.1722380221,
0.0647661611,
-0.6479656696,
-0.6753541231,
0.3530269563,
0.46463269,
0.0681336299,
0.077529721,
-0.0124048013,
0.0524519123,
0.0558521226,
0.6372883916,
0.3862090707,
-0.4578032494,
-0.2972873151,
-0.2655660808,
-0.0418507382,
0.0217109956,
0.7079499364,
-0.4794054925,
0.6443315744,
0.6299337149,
0.35606879,
0.138940379,
-0.0067860694,
0.5881701112,
-0.9860037565,
0.4197826684,
-0.0245920159,
0.1185177863,
-0.0067175566,
-0.3875179589,
0.2580851316,
0.1119599193,
-0.6693698764,
-1.4499557018,
0.4259455204,
-0.4178647101,
-0.2009969503,
1.1476290226,
-0.0224681031,
-0.1116248444,
-0.5047585368,
-0.3009763956,
0.026112197,
-0.4902413189,
0.6159029007,
0.4768970013,
0.0366615392,
-0.0274013355,
-0.4386258423,
0.9785447717,
0.3150115013,
-0.8307532668,
0.1645468026,
-0.0118523557,
0.2485994399,
-0.0084848264,
0.7255774736,
0.3173642457,
0.1328677088,
-0.3546484411,
-0.0823032558,
0.0402976088,
-0.4098665714,
-0.4092259705,
-0.0037363523,
0.4035091102,
-0.5314776897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13281v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13281v1 | LM vs LM: Detecting Factual Errors via Cross Examination | 2023-05-22T17:42:14 | 2023-05-22T17:42:14 | Roi Cohen, May Hamri, Mor Geva, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | A prominent weakness of modern language models (LMs) is their tendency to
generate factually incorrect text, which hinders their usability. A natural
question is whether such factual errors can be detected automatically. Inspired
by truth-seeking mechanisms in law, we propose a factuality evaluation
framework for LMs that is based on cross-examination. Our key idea is that an
incorrect claim is likely to result in inconsistency with other claims that the
model generates. To discover such inconsistencies, we facilitate a multi-turn
interaction between the LM that generated the claim and another LM (acting as
an examiner) which introduces questions to discover inconsistencies. We
empirically evaluate our method on factual claims made by multiple recent LMs
on four benchmarks, finding that it outperforms existing methods and baselines,
often by a large gap. Our results demonstrate the potential of using
interacting LMs for capturing factual errors. | [
-0.1528501958,
-0.944414258,
1.0351577997,
-0.0555988029,
0.0920837447,
0.0220821388,
-0.1686924994,
-0.6741964817,
0.0662184954,
0.4130991995,
-0.4241989851,
-0.2845016718,
-0.540170908,
0.166708827,
-0.5007622838,
0.8174172044,
-0.1632011384,
0.2718645632,
-0.5827865005,
-0.4437389076,
-0.4631626606,
-0.4761083126,
-0.3999944329,
-0.2507095635,
0.6048819423,
0.2649436593,
0.9560913444,
0.3635584414,
0.4462042153,
0.3693456352,
0.1890399456,
0.5153927803,
-0.2889495492,
0.0545660742,
-0.3714535236,
-0.6545003057,
-0.1340919733,
0.159872368,
0.6293613315,
0.5504968762,
-0.0279472824,
0.1738421917,
-0.261120826,
0.6576905251,
-0.9269688725,
-0.0931675956,
-0.6176229715,
0.2133731842,
-0.2692572176,
-0.2440043986,
-0.5846177936,
-0.5623396039,
0.0755011961,
-0.0554899685,
0.3333902657,
0.2568979859,
1.0418958664,
0.1866430342,
-0.6130864024,
-0.6675582528,
-0.8350962996,
0.7637765408,
-0.9559344053,
0.7379742265,
0.0465296656,
0.3816514909,
-0.0104541564,
-0.7029620409,
-0.9229954481,
-0.7753087878,
-0.295081228,
0.0564930141,
-0.2233576328,
-0.0369770303,
0.2770272493,
0.2322668731,
-0.5065643787,
0.053523466,
-0.1593196392,
-0.5524582863,
0.7273441553,
0.232725203,
0.6374217868,
-0.221690461,
-0.3756897151,
0.0522636212,
-0.8689229488,
0.0503440499,
0.5248832107,
0.2753282487,
0.071097225,
0.7580161095,
0.1050891504,
0.6104040742,
0.1097439229,
-0.2712311149,
0.1210456714,
-0.6926592588,
-0.3016689122,
0.3658544421,
0.8535869718,
0.4800207019,
-0.0127377007,
-0.0438720584,
-0.3429521024,
0.0837916732,
0.1980255693,
-0.4213068485,
0.0403483696,
0.4155489504,
-0.319627732,
-0.2208158523,
0.1798365563,
-0.7001805902,
-0.6013638973,
-0.3650508821,
0.4944393039,
-0.1337421834,
-0.23174344,
0.0400123708,
0.0804314688,
0.0421051309,
0.4058761895,
-0.3379779756,
0.2258388698,
0.4973473549,
0.4090799093,
-0.1019706726,
-0.2862475216,
-0.7991631627,
-0.0182830431,
-0.5380146503,
0.8680903316,
-0.3146765828,
-0.2120032161,
0.195635736,
0.0659077689,
-0.1361186951,
-0.6591458917,
0.7074362636,
-0.5307500958,
0.3940350413,
-0.3596913815,
-0.6432541609,
-0.1009365693,
0.5441619158,
-0.8705881834,
1.1010866165,
-0.1447376162,
-0.9879966378,
0.6344730854,
-0.4734411836,
-0.2202370614,
-0.201015234,
-0.5116968751,
-0.8256803155,
-0.0694324225,
-0.0699191689,
0.3149200082,
-0.2167211771,
0.4793763161,
-0.3920350075,
-0.2210194767,
0.5881587863,
-0.5275611281,
0.7960665226,
-0.1249661073,
-0.5739285946,
0.1222426742,
-0.9658737183,
-0.0707702413,
0.2422946543,
-0.5652316213,
-0.3076290488,
0.2839684486,
-0.2991633713,
0.1588041335,
0.1044941545,
-0.7160384059,
-0.1889512539,
-0.1062335223,
-0.4095736146,
0.4077833593,
-0.0733053014,
0.0949183702,
-0.4065791368,
0.2324959189,
0.0363140665,
0.0497792736,
0.0368403569,
-0.3774822354,
-1.0764787197,
0.1255009472,
0.3404970467,
0.7326419353,
-0.5841975808,
0.1852367818,
-0.1076673493,
-0.264321208,
-0.71555686,
0.3329279423,
0.522081852,
0.5176411271,
0.3217113614,
-0.021505639,
-0.7370499372,
-0.8451051712,
-0.8843180537,
-0.3254441321,
0.3545465171,
0.1716907322,
0.4706059694,
-0.2451898009,
1.0775105953,
-0.0064117652,
0.1264047027,
-0.3198366761,
0.2932591438,
-0.090013586,
0.2648168802,
0.5847972631,
-0.8032464981,
-0.5085621476,
0.1301912069,
-1.1231033802,
-0.1883558184,
-0.25313434,
0.2438220233,
0.6671628952,
0.5184789896,
-0.52096349,
0.610829711,
0.3462963402,
-0.3359321058,
0.8225278854,
-0.2130279541,
0.311596632,
-0.5272089839,
-0.1143996865,
0.1244708225,
-0.4997048378,
-0.6552863717,
0.1272362471,
0.3191692829,
0.3286156654,
-0.4652508795,
0.4362823665,
-0.6473719478,
-0.1584215164,
-0.1603204459,
0.4125711918,
0.081317544,
0.0673827678,
-0.040150024,
0.4786821008,
0.201294288,
-0.598107934,
0.4494657815,
-0.1482424587,
-0.4649218321,
0.8284556866,
-0.2505211532,
0.0162610319,
-0.257614553,
0.0527977273,
-1.0005934238,
-0.1026897803,
0.3761294186,
-0.4060193598,
0.2828638554,
-0.041852504,
-0.558159709,
-0.1728169322,
-0.3921255171,
0.0551607125,
0.1181465983,
-0.6505361795,
0.7291998863,
0.1739272326,
-0.0969961733,
-0.9390205145,
-0.6488001943,
0.2021477222,
0.0471751355,
-0.665684998,
-0.311157614,
0.1133528203,
-0.771656394,
0.2030888498,
-0.084900409,
0.0254618227,
-0.0296276994,
0.0308973212,
0.3021546602,
-0.4566905499,
0.1121589541,
-0.108411245,
0.1399695128,
0.3874771297,
0.1661052555,
0.2040599436,
0.0242995564,
-0.9681484103,
-0.4998521209,
0.2436385006,
0.6385212541,
-0.1703034341,
0.5040599108,
0.3479718268,
-0.3815532625,
-0.1969528049,
-1.039731741,
0.1773995459,
-0.4128908515,
0.2895639837,
-0.3164709806,
-0.6125470996,
0.2898049951,
0.0327931978,
0.1988427639,
0.605468452,
0.5011304617,
-0.1998356879,
0.916750133,
0.6433262825,
0.0663074702,
0.112599805,
0.2976802289,
0.4651222229,
-0.2713541389,
-0.4041446745,
-0.6313737631,
0.0350211374,
-0.574862957,
-0.4006216824,
0.3549737334,
-0.2170088887,
0.1398825198,
0.118526496,
0.0636518672,
0.4630213976,
0.333555311,
0.0539199971,
0.6543064713,
-0.3227483034,
-0.4981479645,
-0.2879985273,
-0.7214866877,
-0.6072266698,
0.9256232977,
0.3627924919,
0.6804546118,
0.2335501164,
0.6703699827,
0.4207057059,
0.683477819,
-0.7267385125,
0.5605547428,
0.3579860628,
-0.8361750841,
-0.320597738,
-0.5568480492,
-0.6299270988,
0.3783622384,
-0.5437474847,
-0.5309363604,
0.2403853238,
0.3455684185,
-0.2962183356,
0.6135450006,
-0.5032873154,
0.8951948285,
-0.565318346,
-0.6948693395,
-0.218509078,
-0.6740149856,
0.8504195809,
-0.0325650498,
0.4851261079,
0.082315661,
0.2382920533,
0.4278563559,
-0.5019050241,
0.9943355322,
-0.1262984723,
-0.564751029,
0.5170198083,
0.3933138847,
0.6072629094,
-0.0286575668,
0.0754593462,
-0.3347449601,
0.0680843964,
-0.1651662588,
-0.6631031632,
0.5130403638,
-0.3713701367,
-0.5658742785,
-0.7050634623,
-0.4049685597,
-0.2565103769,
0.1130115017,
0.0564071238,
0.4356231689,
-0.6008145213,
-0.2271306813,
0.6194861531,
-0.2515786886,
0.3610266745,
0.8517363071,
-0.4165709317,
-0.0474573337,
1.0520640612,
0.1688083261,
0.4251407683,
0.2233797312,
0.241834566,
-0.51477319,
-0.3679481447,
-0.4820093513,
0.2959471345,
-0.9984852076,
0.0122311814,
-0.6571736336,
-0.0739034563,
-0.2258763611,
0.2446132153,
-0.4808406532,
-0.1750092208,
0.1964808851,
-0.1808715761,
-0.0588854849,
0.9918731451,
-0.246876359,
-0.1067232415,
-1.0191534758,
0.1764731854,
0.4898614585,
0.0935032964,
-0.0666874498,
-0.3981380165,
-0.2079327106,
0.0421393588,
-0.2937073112,
-0.8933091164,
-0.0724333227,
-0.2212512791,
0.6356204152,
0.5167826414,
-0.0623229668,
0.5245680213,
-0.6825045347,
0.7072633505,
0.2705385387,
-1.0321059227,
0.2676673532,
0.1457477361,
-0.2413497567,
0.4960936606,
0.5815577507,
-0.6723670363,
-0.5662098527,
-0.7056701779,
-0.2875489593,
0.2782565653,
-0.0033313972,
-0.1213810518,
0.1198972166,
0.1036234722,
0.1449386626,
0.1185843423,
-1.0014865398,
-0.2199958563,
0.0761645436,
-0.1609563679,
0.2736106813,
-0.4328190684,
-0.314561218,
-0.0078327367,
0.5915934443,
-0.1034045517,
-0.0208588894,
0.5286399126,
-0.4750106037,
-0.2506893873,
0.3657827973,
0.7880014181,
1.0561771393,
-0.2222799808,
0.4334586263,
0.3935874999,
-0.0403708257,
0.0594241656,
-0.0991624743,
-0.2328499556,
0.6876756549,
0.6710022092,
0.6475092769,
0.3997573555,
-0.8132472038,
0.7251458168,
0.0199769344,
-0.0923876688,
-0.1942963004,
-0.1814563274,
0.2439915836,
0.25771299,
0.2277731448,
0.0290342662,
0.1613595933,
-1.0066127777,
0.3837293684,
0.5868462324,
-0.3542471528,
-0.2579904199,
0.5660946369,
0.1763241142,
-0.3846244812,
0.0150811253,
-0.2257874012,
-0.6839293838,
0.4789691269,
0.3159893155,
0.6316096187,
-0.3224066496,
0.2228390127,
0.2133891135,
0.604208529,
-0.1777260303,
0.2590646744,
0.1103603914,
-0.9767930508,
-0.451728642,
-0.0437642187,
-0.8241479993,
0.119827494,
-0.4401607513,
0.2754233181,
-0.3594916761,
0.0045554405,
-0.1455786675,
-0.1025215536,
-0.358204931,
0.534013927,
0.2515493333,
0.7564713955,
-0.8294671774,
0.4272710383,
0.4729884267,
-0.5291224718,
-0.5224971175,
0.1551834047,
0.3085485995,
-0.8859956264,
0.7189415693,
-0.013685043,
-0.4151030779,
-0.6430277824,
-0.7835065126,
-0.4499672055,
0.7521234155,
0.2938676775,
-0.7216244936,
0.15597184,
0.4425468147,
0.4119328558,
-0.242072463,
0.2798123062,
0.5780889392,
0.5853351355,
-0.2517290413,
-1.099445343,
0.2278518081,
0.1363681853,
-0.4262379408,
0.0545761436,
-0.605461657,
0.9028248787,
-0.3584183455,
-0.489898771,
-0.0811869875,
0.7661626339,
0.3437185585,
0.7859086394,
0.6715566516,
0.4508793354,
1.0602371693,
0.0089010354,
1.1501638889,
-0.1736839563,
0.5642344356,
1.2325158119,
-0.7420839071,
0.7393760681,
0.6666887403,
-0.2264676392,
0.5387576818,
0.3873274922,
0.0734964013,
0.0719066858,
0.2694232464,
-0.3797903359,
-0.4147755504,
0.0393176675,
-0.24172768,
0.2368950695,
0.1725656241,
-0.2039317936,
-0.5549355149,
-0.322286278,
0.2505893409,
0.4209974408,
-0.115954645,
0.4228921533,
-0.0311521087,
-0.6834646463,
0.4424935877,
0.0556676239,
0.4849371016,
-0.4097561836,
-0.2631748915,
-0.2857055664,
0.272557497,
-0.3822533786,
-0.6326448321,
0.2505797148,
0.1342601329,
0.0752817914,
0.1188871562,
0.9363776445,
-0.532933712,
-0.5291222334,
0.530901134,
0.8432690501,
0.1643817723,
0.1726861447,
-0.6181465387,
0.2512588799,
-0.0671329722,
-0.0479635336,
0.156742081,
0.6065559983,
-0.0762105584,
0.645152986,
0.5701270103,
-0.0021112787,
0.2980908155,
0.0283533987,
0.5963629484,
-0.7012086511,
-0.1088766977,
-0.9573107958,
0.5722618699,
-0.3173364699,
-0.0968274102,
0.8457089663,
0.637257576,
1.0420314074,
0.0329130255,
1.1247774363,
0.071179159,
0.8949097991,
-0.883508563,
0.5820025802,
-0.6464492083,
0.2734039426,
-0.0513997041,
-0.6950483918,
-0.1982817352,
0.4060356319,
-0.2487519234,
-0.0969012603,
1.0708465576,
0.832447052,
-0.346313715,
-0.0206094403,
0.5073544383,
0.3055297732,
0.1308610886,
0.2868911922,
1.1412090063,
-0.5193872452,
0.5369104743,
0.04609368,
0.0180666391,
-0.4554418027,
-1.0010117292,
-0.979909122,
-0.176728934,
-0.5277000666,
-0.724263072,
0.1494638771,
0.8177027702,
0.2089598179,
-0.948638916,
-0.3513837755,
0.1754903346,
0.4245346785,
0.0311530624,
-0.2010815144,
0.1688209474,
-0.5328086019,
-0.7477514744,
0.5939260721,
0.1941477656,
-0.0569251142,
-0.462028265,
-0.0970823616,
-0.5742970705,
0.4666952193,
0.4670900702,
0.5123933554,
-0.7323466539,
-0.6292715669,
-0.2277784348,
-0.3719090521,
0.256375879,
0.9570096135,
-0.3639163971,
0.5084998608,
0.4551950991,
1.0332963467,
0.3541519046,
-0.1586684734,
0.5439659357,
-0.510984242,
-0.1829563975,
-0.0425468571,
0.5098779798,
0.4359493554,
-0.3577004373,
0.3368917108,
0.5775196552,
-0.3579230905,
-1.095921278,
0.2251076996,
-0.7979471684,
-0.1612327099,
0.8553271294,
-0.2518450022,
-0.2465418428,
-0.2655709684,
-0.1608095765,
0.2236682475,
0.1355996132,
0.7332767248,
0.9186510444,
-0.086144045,
-0.0181292463,
-0.8510386348,
0.5267396569,
0.7148797512,
-0.875944674,
-0.1298507601,
0.4370849431,
0.6633505821,
0.5003048182,
0.4259110689,
-0.1173393652,
0.4903668463,
0.0047100238,
0.2266622633,
0.2093887776,
-0.2535502911,
-0.1842266917,
-0.0088863177,
-0.0998886079,
-0.1761282682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13276v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13276v2 | Evaluating ChatGPT's Performance for Multilingual and Emoji-based Hate Speech Detection | 2023-05-22T17:36:58 | 2023-05-23T03:39:44 | Mithun Das, Saurabh Kumar Pandey, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Hate speech is a severe issue that affects many online platforms. So far,
several studies have been performed to develop robust hate speech detection
systems. Large language models like ChatGPT have recently shown a great promise
in performing several tasks, including hate speech detection. However, it is
crucial to comprehend the limitations of these models to build robust hate
speech detection systems. To bridge this gap, our study aims to evaluate the
strengths and weaknesses of the ChatGPT model in detecting hate speech at a
granular level across 11 languages. Our evaluation employs a series of
functionality tests that reveals various intricate failures of the model which
the aggregate metrics like macro F1 or accuracy are not able to unfold. In
addition, we investigate the influence of complex emotions, such as the use of
emojis in hate speech, on the performance of the ChatGPT model. Our analysis
highlights the shortcomings of the generative models in detecting certain types
of hate speech and highlighting the need for further research and improvements
in the workings of these models. | [
-0.5583307743,
-1.1848862171,
0.1015237421,
0.2392697036,
-0.1576443315,
0.2963401377,
-0.3177830875,
-0.5265610218,
0.1410393417,
0.1023495346,
-0.4148387313,
-0.3229854703,
-0.8903384209,
0.1336732656,
-0.414929837,
1.256831646,
0.1583895385,
0.0873791128,
0.2677694857,
-0.1914814413,
-0.354428947,
-0.7781529427,
-0.7667956352,
-0.0891121402,
0.5149980187,
0.3029172719,
0.7285345793,
-0.0871512741,
0.6223679781,
0.2095882744,
-0.291139096,
-0.0515137017,
-0.6446977854,
0.3672934175,
0.2380029112,
-0.2641206682,
-0.2322758436,
-0.303719908,
0.4571347237,
0.0733073577,
-0.2197443694,
-0.0959569216,
0.0606177747,
0.090584591,
-0.4608542323,
0.0975535065,
-0.6995882392,
0.2566052675,
-0.3484768569,
0.326595217,
-0.1984694749,
-0.3406033218,
0.0658766478,
-0.0921517313,
0.1294682771,
0.0245321002,
0.5157752633,
0.004318621,
-0.3335639238,
-0.4762344956,
-0.7141055465,
0.5765526891,
-0.7521219254,
0.5237038136,
0.0901711807,
0.3836577535,
0.1457554698,
-0.3898525536,
-0.5850239992,
-0.6509420872,
0.1864567995,
0.2731424868,
-0.5669768453,
-0.0145039409,
0.3185633719,
0.404604733,
-0.7897780538,
0.3425958157,
-0.1002798229,
-0.2035737187,
0.3733328879,
0.1233904809,
0.5176222324,
-0.2226857096,
-0.2940605879,
0.0611642972,
-0.3667295277,
-0.2455199361,
0.7295908928,
0.5257812142,
-0.0941231772,
0.6130834222,
0.0168414507,
0.4756653011,
-0.2599467039,
-0.0835678652,
0.2152864486,
-0.0580389164,
0.1125191227,
-0.1195029691,
0.89817518,
0.2808116674,
0.4282213151,
-0.2571720183,
-0.2456062734,
0.5562436581,
0.2641800046,
-0.9509913325,
-0.1976048946,
0.1407827735,
-0.1806069314,
-0.3883960247,
-0.4969013035,
-0.8709161878,
-0.7500042915,
0.1877441704,
0.3911912441,
-0.7720675468,
-0.5099382401,
-0.2344397902,
-0.3498747945,
0.076181747,
0.2806792259,
-0.7573295832,
0.0888071209,
0.639336586,
0.9541709423,
-0.2842938304,
-0.2089775354,
-0.3722740412,
-0.3610603213,
0.1596456766,
0.6998737454,
-0.9393776059,
-0.2706692815,
0.122573331,
-0.4118573964,
-0.2198867947,
-0.4625311792,
0.9591613412,
-0.3525160551,
-0.1389448643,
-0.0082448684,
-0.6682363153,
-0.0499008261,
0.5409610868,
-0.4959412217,
0.8014007211,
0.0843955353,
-0.9320137501,
0.3056556284,
-0.747149229,
-0.4276578724,
0.2357544005,
-0.14188914,
-0.801448226,
0.1349107325,
0.0293577258,
0.3924197853,
-0.1310977489,
0.1958102733,
-0.6419852972,
-0.1703636497,
0.3830622435,
-0.6007761359,
0.639947176,
0.5040923357,
-0.4631900191,
0.1172322556,
-0.6797269583,
-0.2569720149,
0.270260334,
-0.1499423981,
-0.1140179336,
0.0658608377,
0.6627988815,
0.2865470052,
-0.1666375846,
-0.9085714817,
-0.063404724,
-0.1040178463,
0.4762754738,
0.5768384337,
-0.326008141,
-0.0947076902,
-0.1487578005,
0.8562346101,
0.0947971344,
0.0634437725,
0.0705540329,
-0.7891464233,
-0.4670586288,
-0.1914636344,
0.2500617504,
0.6870628595,
-0.5168560743,
0.0375321284,
-0.1903046668,
-0.6147518754,
-0.2369288951,
-0.1853200495,
0.418089211,
0.0987665281,
-0.013403547,
-0.4045957625,
-0.5832034945,
-0.8794042468,
-0.5441136956,
-0.1922483891,
0.0830672383,
0.4031253755,
0.6647094488,
-0.1736670434,
0.6529448628,
-0.0519626513,
-0.1756881922,
-0.478281945,
0.2607476711,
-0.3265205622,
0.0863816813,
0.7176910639,
-1.0961376429,
-0.6561021209,
0.0010809856,
-0.3822888136,
-0.2471047491,
0.3105281293,
0.2787695825,
0.0353907496,
-0.0714881271,
-0.2308697999,
0.3595994711,
0.8549109101,
-0.6167960167,
0.6914684772,
0.5247324705,
0.5629172325,
-0.8353561163,
-0.2120800018,
0.069804661,
-0.1466461271,
-1.005117774,
0.0910869166,
-0.2097148895,
-0.715221405,
-0.6206707954,
0.1140648276,
0.1062469259,
0.1539652497,
-0.2426821887,
0.2637275457,
-0.4236035943,
0.3624013364,
-0.0682937279,
0.698487401,
0.2742395699,
-0.3858444393,
0.5087323189,
0.1267731339,
-0.333961308,
0.8848749995,
-0.4882016182,
0.011092307,
0.0736560822,
0.0091419341,
-1.0799822807,
-0.292509526,
0.4495254755,
-0.6000557542,
0.0249734055,
-0.5491027236,
-0.6149698496,
-0.1368655711,
-0.0987947732,
0.4805702865,
0.3463453948,
-0.3502400815,
0.6116528511,
0.6579486728,
-0.1539575309,
-0.3305514157,
-0.7091745734,
0.2058811039,
-0.5254298449,
-0.8404747844,
0.1670112163,
-0.0034886117,
-0.2732722759,
-0.2414095849,
0.2396258265,
-0.254878521,
0.169400394,
0.2913087606,
-0.3427984118,
-0.0725973547,
0.1315433979,
-0.2700440288,
0.3371428549,
0.0193428602,
0.0901502147,
0.8796564937,
-0.3825382292,
-0.4753217399,
-0.1851666123,
0.3381673694,
0.863394022,
-0.2469778508,
0.8076973557,
1.1100640297,
-0.2930471897,
-0.0250658076,
-0.5519607663,
0.0885486305,
-0.3308686912,
0.6216022968,
-0.360886544,
-1.2669196129,
0.8355291486,
0.1670169979,
-0.2121106535,
0.4194746614,
0.6309456229,
0.3831087649,
1.0506438017,
0.2356141508,
-0.0608282089,
0.7124863863,
0.1878727227,
0.4340554476,
-0.5050658584,
-0.138870731,
-0.6210623384,
0.1424929947,
-0.8027528524,
-0.2500798404,
0.5089330673,
-0.235567376,
-0.2973669171,
0.2597906291,
-0.3477208912,
0.2735312879,
0.1494809389,
0.0098393029,
0.1518118382,
0.363558054,
0.0959482193,
-0.1701875925,
-0.6953511834,
-0.4164091647,
0.8747124672,
0.390298456,
0.7017489076,
0.4900226891,
0.2838046551,
0.4448818862,
0.1515410244,
-0.8131845593,
0.2158433795,
-0.2567831576,
-0.7964093685,
-0.2482036501,
-0.4911714494,
-0.7390975952,
0.5267089009,
-0.0610902943,
-0.9265511036,
-0.2614184916,
0.1726667732,
-0.1871066839,
0.7036027908,
-0.7347455025,
1.1168488264,
-0.1588426679,
-0.1461973488,
-0.3105678856,
-0.1323388219,
0.3712877631,
-0.1404620558,
0.3667230904,
-0.3525159657,
0.3322889209,
0.7768074274,
-0.2266401947,
1.0702463388,
-0.145600304,
-0.1866103858,
0.2526590824,
0.2103272825,
0.5037777424,
-0.1851825416,
-0.10034924,
0.4689313769,
-0.1983140111,
-0.2646415532,
-0.4296886325,
0.5544935465,
-0.3779786229,
-0.2736583054,
-0.2652667761,
-0.4217512012,
-0.144683376,
-0.0189144816,
0.3429485261,
0.3651436269,
-0.7469847798,
0.0363963395,
0.5106423497,
-0.3858941197,
0.1514943987,
0.3239469826,
-0.6532880664,
-0.2589861453,
1.0378448963,
0.2367577851,
0.2854760289,
0.0735966563,
0.2521232069,
-0.1961402595,
-0.5274803042,
-0.7592236996,
-0.2332729846,
-0.5051100254,
0.0391664095,
-0.8329942226,
-0.0719416961,
-0.5564004183,
0.1653827876,
-0.4788205326,
-0.4722549617,
0.3044368625,
0.2648184896,
0.4458911717,
0.8517130613,
-0.0737139061,
0.4459893405,
-0.504607141,
0.2483778149,
0.2788642347,
0.5014213324,
-0.0457010344,
-0.8878631592,
-0.1349390149,
0.1218971089,
-0.5057570934,
-1.0544134378,
0.4162320495,
0.0744120851,
0.2200187147,
0.2972707152,
-0.0184211731,
0.566349566,
-0.5040074587,
0.7087346315,
0.0039182589,
-0.8952433467,
0.6651624441,
-0.5513456464,
-0.0310938749,
0.1119331867,
0.37225914,
-0.9318531156,
-0.7479858994,
-0.6932399273,
-0.6343913674,
0.6328428984,
0.8294638395,
0.1670030653,
-0.0012240284,
-0.1282633096,
0.0292504039,
0.1364122182,
-0.9039288163,
-0.4279619753,
-0.1428221613,
0.0394668728,
0.1536252946,
-0.366523385,
-0.0022471268,
-0.0147181898,
0.6393749714,
0.2133287489,
0.4502815008,
-0.2753953934,
-0.2377486676,
0.2637032568,
0.6034557819,
0.4860111177,
0.384077251,
-0.0350298733,
-0.1357934326,
0.3689742386,
-0.4244352877,
-0.0290713981,
0.208414644,
-0.1781270951,
0.1602516323,
0.219193235,
0.9456564784,
0.055247549,
-0.6689950228,
0.7371013761,
-0.2382972389,
0.2253391892,
-0.4593695998,
-0.0835758373,
-0.1082611233,
0.214925766,
0.0131696779,
0.1225675121,
0.3033669889,
-0.4151191115,
0.2197494209,
0.5529144406,
-0.5230277181,
-0.3198392093,
0.5554097891,
0.1853018254,
-0.4848476946,
0.567535758,
-0.3471669555,
-1.1371372938,
0.7573101521,
0.637001276,
0.7980402708,
-0.4305345714,
0.3893267214,
0.2589029074,
0.4799767435,
0.2978517413,
0.1020855308,
-0.0078662001,
-0.9976148605,
-0.1933071166,
-0.6682381034,
-0.5422357321,
0.114893958,
-0.4543778002,
-0.0482387878,
-0.3106298149,
-0.1680495441,
0.1441902816,
-0.3290751874,
-0.6928879619,
0.1145051271,
0.5439609885,
0.4098699093,
-1.1206510067,
0.3048245907,
0.5001513362,
-0.4085082114,
-0.5246634483,
-0.0765498057,
0.2764797211,
-0.8362699747,
0.546577096,
0.3785704374,
-0.24695988,
-0.1881453842,
-0.3260599077,
-0.4620472491,
0.1783433259,
0.3427582383,
-0.5734131336,
0.4866601229,
0.4870371819,
0.7783567905,
-0.3575660586,
0.5972966552,
0.4826760888,
0.3816614747,
-0.1274895519,
-1.0662808418,
-0.1567564905,
-0.1590330452,
-0.0361544043,
0.3115340173,
-0.7886201143,
0.7523178458,
0.0671631768,
-0.3876183033,
-0.1668506116,
0.1644462496,
0.0111779254,
0.2202212363,
0.5219682455,
0.8988701701,
0.4898282886,
-0.2144407779,
1.1902649403,
-0.1313215494,
0.5853559375,
0.7158952951,
-0.0670341328,
0.693166256,
-0.0712135881,
-0.3299537897,
0.3281774819,
0.4431827366,
-0.1708256602,
0.0825729519,
0.3556949496,
-0.6340854168,
-0.3569832742,
-0.4213729203,
-0.2565279305,
0.6340118051,
0.4228654802,
-0.2804679275,
-0.3216167986,
0.4330841005,
0.1974171996,
-0.1693807691,
-0.2468414009,
0.5545791388,
-0.1431874037,
-0.3524613678,
0.4028880596,
0.1140866503,
0.8426684737,
-0.3496882021,
0.0188793633,
-0.0234492831,
0.1644502878,
-0.1602595747,
-0.6658505797,
0.3854448497,
0.5067468882,
0.1536828429,
0.0470654294,
0.590182662,
-0.3980172276,
-0.4647304416,
0.4253679514,
0.3205103874,
0.4344811141,
-0.5061926842,
-1.010568738,
0.451610297,
0.1193460897,
-0.2052909434,
0.3551196754,
0.5086352825,
0.1498838365,
0.743928194,
0.3863402903,
-0.1666064709,
0.1849689633,
0.4301013947,
0.6402758956,
-0.4975998104,
-0.3808919787,
-1.1791553497,
0.2235592008,
-0.0796573013,
-0.5120013952,
0.9051169753,
0.6913195252,
1.1038136482,
-0.0574535057,
0.9628890157,
-0.407255888,
0.5447134972,
-0.2366957068,
0.6075368524,
-0.3927917182,
0.0874899849,
-0.5709131956,
-0.8485248089,
-0.5451925397,
0.5646002293,
-0.3648428619,
0.2051928341,
0.4506382048,
0.8886883259,
-0.1849443763,
0.333155185,
0.7171930075,
0.4098583758,
0.4864622355,
0.3603180945,
1.1475243568,
-0.5189790726,
0.8803963065,
-0.3819286823,
-0.0104058124,
-0.1207639948,
-0.5493599176,
-0.9193514585,
-0.3648665547,
-0.3963556886,
-0.537430048,
0.2288127691,
0.6713435054,
0.4484269917,
-0.9836059213,
-0.1644453406,
0.1581734568,
0.0824550837,
0.109349221,
-0.2449867129,
0.206859082,
-0.2729315162,
-0.8996011019,
0.2011874914,
0.3141557872,
-0.0911183953,
0.0523968004,
-0.0760697573,
0.0285392273,
-0.1107617244,
0.8475382328,
0.2214851677,
-0.9227190614,
-0.3244130313,
-0.4352770746,
0.0472253263,
0.0966864899,
0.9132585526,
-0.2831192911,
0.4854708612,
0.3033700287,
0.6865850687,
0.3896351159,
-0.0862247497,
0.2661653459,
-0.4662015438,
0.0810887218,
0.3571281731,
0.4315593839,
0.438408345,
-0.074001871,
0.4164081812,
0.3199519217,
-0.7004600763,
-0.7561977506,
0.5658301711,
-0.7246857285,
-0.0460925922,
1.1937716007,
-0.1950555146,
0.1425200105,
-0.2930060625,
-0.3227809668,
0.2672673464,
-0.5704694986,
0.8168243766,
0.8418092728,
-0.1965649873,
-0.0866722986,
-0.4634888768,
0.3584100902,
0.518787384,
-0.4629658163,
0.190216437,
0.5956357121,
0.2546124458,
0.1327737123,
0.3855370283,
-0.0993705541,
0.1697696447,
0.2801519334,
0.1741912067,
0.2663279474,
-0.0297746491,
-0.5300322175,
0.4811205864,
-0.0091575263,
-0.0343421623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.14386v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.14386v1 | Let GPT be a Math Tutor: Teaching Math Word Problem Solvers with Customized Exercise Generation | 2023-05-22T17:36:14 | 2023-05-22T17:36:14 | Zhenwen Liang, Wenhao Yu, Tanmay Rajpurohit, Peter Clark, Xiangliang Zhang, Ashwin Kaylan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we present a novel approach for distilling math word problem
solving capabilities from large language models (LLMs) into smaller, more
efficient student models. Our approach is designed to consider the student
model's weaknesses and foster a tailored learning experience by generating
targeted exercises aligned with educational science principles, such as
knowledge tracing and personalized learning. Concretely, we let GPT-3 be a math
tutor and run two steps iteratively: 1) assessing the student model's current
learning status on a GPT-generated exercise book, and 2) improving the student
model by training it with tailored exercise samples generated by GPT-3.
Experimental results reveal that our approach outperforms LLMs (e.g., GPT-3 and
PaLM) in accuracy across three distinct benchmarks while employing
significantly fewer parameters. Furthermore, we provide a comprehensive
analysis of the various components within our methodology to substantiate their
efficacy. | [
-0.1351530552,
-0.7514101267,
0.5909397602,
-0.2024863511,
-0.1286416501,
0.3594625294,
-0.1449927539,
0.2779896557,
0.0660944954,
0.1843033582,
-0.7018212676,
-0.2626165748,
-0.5304874182,
0.0009033781,
-0.1022172645,
1.1388856173,
-0.2708478272,
0.3848651946,
-0.4683571756,
0.1502679437,
-0.661893189,
-0.3624618649,
-0.4650940597,
-0.5080956221,
0.1629599333,
0.5106889009,
0.6262921691,
0.4802414477,
0.626157105,
0.264436841,
0.0285888277,
0.0564452633,
-0.3831452429,
-0.1826142073,
-0.1168809608,
-0.5818113089,
-0.2842564583,
0.1938112974,
0.2746400237,
1.0094089508,
-0.4565488398,
0.109362714,
0.2069574445,
0.5571557283,
-0.2858344913,
0.1194848344,
-0.6965527534,
0.0172259007,
-0.0692360103,
0.1692856401,
-0.1112086177,
-0.5382760167,
0.2597363889,
-0.9010388851,
0.7508794069,
-0.2616125941,
0.4349300265,
0.2725100815,
-0.1655641943,
-0.641992569,
-0.6019562483,
0.8905132413,
-0.690156579,
0.2229398489,
0.2205749601,
0.6320432425,
-0.0618704632,
-0.5900803208,
-0.5095469356,
-0.1806450039,
0.1297160685,
0.2012042403,
0.0423522629,
-0.1980846971,
0.3475946486,
0.4936764836,
-0.4822506011,
-0.1847430468,
-0.531437695,
-0.095787771,
0.5091304183,
0.1559403241,
0.4202647209,
0.0454444438,
0.0327964909,
0.0251417421,
-0.8211532235,
-0.1358494312,
0.4584525526,
0.3764776886,
0.0668311492,
0.9052013755,
0.3555691838,
0.5583853722,
-0.2774223089,
-0.5685558915,
-0.0991336852,
0.0082793701,
-0.0076051611,
-0.0770053566,
0.3572744429,
-0.2205916941,
0.3401296437,
-0.217070505,
-0.3380805254,
0.1079372168,
0.1610190868,
-0.9335205555,
-0.6771109104,
-0.1339340955,
0.1626948267,
-0.2092717141,
-0.1153004244,
-0.6554608345,
-0.3798291087,
-0.702542901,
0.8341107368,
-0.7865176201,
-0.2168295085,
0.3024810553,
-0.1941689551,
-0.3236198723,
0.272829473,
-0.9598900676,
0.4634525478,
0.7962298393,
0.8989928365,
-0.2092207074,
-0.0452839769,
-0.7053524852,
0.1686827838,
-0.2694749534,
0.6069290638,
-0.6358429193,
-0.598803103,
-0.0185827184,
-0.4857240021,
-0.2106451094,
-0.6138781905,
-0.0033386503,
-0.2611145675,
0.4177008867,
-0.3218454123,
-0.8925749063,
0.0100638168,
0.4409137368,
-0.3970648944,
0.8919789195,
0.6366393566,
-0.5974165797,
-0.0053672655,
-0.8649565578,
-0.1449041367,
0.1603183001,
-0.1416183263,
-0.4390293062,
0.4935683012,
0.5105750561,
0.2227703184,
-0.2757389843,
-0.1107498482,
-0.1491295546,
-0.2365754247,
-0.0373819657,
-0.0184099339,
0.255763799,
0.0682425946,
-0.2989675105,
-0.0898012146,
-0.8684606552,
0.1479824334,
0.5340173841,
-0.176008299,
-0.4417713583,
-0.0802233517,
-0.3644394279,
-0.0752515122,
0.2009789348,
-0.7071911693,
0.5644740462,
-0.5255419016,
0.4958524108,
0.904848218,
-0.2076504529,
0.216903612,
-0.2662082016,
0.9518852234,
-0.345916748,
-0.2242198884,
-0.1250471175,
-0.3091475666,
-0.6722781658,
-0.4573846161,
0.3368716538,
0.4671034813,
-0.9623397589,
-0.0743898079,
-0.3528261781,
-0.6599045396,
-0.2602640688,
0.4096082151,
0.3906187713,
0.7123003602,
0.4324944615,
-0.0594046786,
-0.0077372682,
-0.4605920911,
-0.6295176148,
0.0969197601,
-0.2974155545,
0.336340934,
0.60393399,
-0.0225890484,
1.0784020424,
-0.9831024408,
-0.5029130578,
-0.4285174012,
0.1041113958,
0.1000751406,
0.3932133317,
0.4693653882,
-0.4253505766,
-0.724811852,
-0.0063351984,
-0.3393978179,
-0.2670307457,
0.1172443256,
-0.005953819,
-0.1576946825,
0.2202955037,
-0.2818971872,
0.5078632236,
0.3763208091,
-0.3782022595,
0.6320391297,
-0.3810735345,
-0.3878893852,
-1.1927542686,
-0.3688338697,
0.1550673693,
0.0934541672,
-0.2732534409,
0.0576852895,
-0.1012748554,
-0.6313763261,
-0.0497685,
0.4706151485,
-0.379625231,
-0.023964135,
-0.2576708496,
0.0864814445,
-0.1784162074,
0.403005451,
-0.3427392244,
1.0253565311,
0.3254039288,
-0.3564943075,
0.3636769652,
0.1892671585,
-0.1845492274,
0.6258343458,
-0.8761749864,
0.4711380005,
-0.0873302519,
-0.1758738458,
-1.2230602503,
-0.1924707144,
-0.180087164,
-0.2819498181,
0.2383464426,
-0.2683963776,
-0.6372745037,
-0.5382789969,
-0.1508329809,
0.2895130217,
0.6432645321,
-0.7049942613,
0.7751538157,
0.0067649446,
-0.4075803161,
-0.0853386447,
-0.3473350406,
-0.3223912716,
-0.258407861,
-0.5392208695,
0.3960894644,
-0.2889246941,
-0.0908543393,
0.0505088307,
-0.3493010104,
-0.2133672684,
0.1047744006,
-0.0271458514,
0.2418795973,
0.0276765954,
0.2780282795,
0.0786610693,
-0.1918959171,
-0.0387693755,
-0.3382143676,
0.5246346593,
-0.1182119548,
-0.7018133402,
-0.1874343157,
0.3277498484,
0.3051456511,
-0.4864120781,
0.3494206071,
0.5385766029,
-0.3896493316,
-0.3235484064,
-0.3380440772,
-0.2474216968,
-0.529284358,
0.4876122177,
-0.4350631833,
-0.8592064977,
0.285734266,
-0.3551965058,
0.3999609351,
0.0432177708,
0.4636290073,
0.2274840772,
1.2083517313,
0.7434574962,
-0.0922282934,
0.3868145347,
-0.5645338893,
0.443738699,
-0.7143787742,
-0.1441176087,
-0.3488091528,
-0.3462877572,
-0.1590631306,
-0.3293431103,
0.5763210058,
0.2161989659,
-0.4653005898,
0.286152631,
-0.7055897713,
0.6657409668,
0.3553183973,
-0.1000040993,
0.1632834971,
0.3382117152,
-0.6526639462,
-0.5216864347,
-0.6009210348,
-0.3950383067,
1.3985170126,
0.0844138935,
0.7669915557,
0.529322207,
0.9287329912,
-0.3733774126,
1.0574179888,
-0.8911218643,
0.4187198579,
0.0211181231,
-0.6827073097,
-0.2897418439,
-0.5451604724,
-0.8600484729,
0.4201821089,
0.1491882652,
-0.8026217818,
-0.7810376883,
0.2059180737,
-0.2805868983,
0.4375745654,
-0.9383967519,
0.726460278,
-0.2327770144,
-0.3733426929,
-0.2104092091,
0.286012888,
0.4095852971,
-0.2855324447,
0.4583104849,
-0.0600517765,
-0.2345225066,
0.5322673917,
-1.005766511,
0.6032720804,
-0.4317334294,
-0.2697850168,
0.3033132553,
0.5704349279,
0.5653582215,
-0.0362876393,
-0.0496404693,
-0.5186659694,
0.0384426527,
-0.4718346298,
-0.9963770509,
0.6889098287,
-0.6008255482,
-0.8656642437,
-0.1681125462,
-0.8782227039,
-0.6157993078,
0.1465843618,
-0.0244918652,
0.5131049156,
0.1013121381,
-0.01420506,
0.3882832527,
-0.1060989425,
0.4737422168,
0.4695566297,
-0.1851555854,
-0.6499106288,
1.4133245945,
0.3751302958,
0.1640755385,
-0.0264714155,
0.6989603043,
-0.3173676133,
-0.5801283717,
-0.1647150964,
0.4369797111,
-0.6977859735,
-0.0295280125,
-0.1008763537,
0.1720492989,
-0.3424628973,
-0.3712234795,
-0.5435472727,
-0.2571311593,
-0.3735030591,
0.0425335951,
0.299839437,
0.6432964802,
0.055144228,
0.8054128885,
-0.645788908,
0.3227884471,
0.6747875214,
0.283156842,
-0.1188437119,
-0.6667072177,
0.0630536973,
-0.0188288577,
-0.7779086828,
-0.6652709246,
0.6938929558,
0.2963220775,
0.3522647023,
0.2617039084,
-0.2000629753,
0.8876215219,
-0.8670582771,
0.798145473,
0.4922896326,
-1.0073200464,
0.5351643562,
-0.283562988,
-0.0245252475,
0.2768110931,
0.3960879445,
-0.1508632898,
-0.0714030266,
-0.7543525696,
-0.6456095576,
0.3490370512,
0.1788381487,
0.4272904992,
0.2471319884,
0.7636668086,
0.1141377389,
0.1243660823,
-0.5793508887,
-0.0170089956,
-0.2729332745,
-0.547968328,
-0.1498219818,
-0.0030795548,
-0.2352262139,
-0.586075604,
0.6118072271,
-0.4546739459,
0.0740456358,
-0.0583822802,
-0.1307579577,
0.1667238325,
0.0448739231,
0.4096566439,
0.9017965794,
0.1665564775,
-0.0312593058,
0.2452493459,
-0.6338713169,
0.2336225957,
0.3116116822,
0.1715182066,
0.0502778925,
0.346215874,
0.3309747875,
0.1740169674,
-0.6887325048,
0.6047350168,
0.0350538976,
-0.6035987139,
-0.378865242,
0.4094981253,
0.28580755,
0.0870235935,
0.4184751511,
-0.367398113,
-0.2083174288,
-0.0658953413,
0.0630834401,
0.5998862386,
-0.3433518708,
-0.4718874395,
0.7742919922,
-0.1192359924,
-0.5929228663,
0.5098865628,
-0.1893889308,
-0.6627931595,
0.6431317329,
0.9303890467,
0.6203970909,
-0.3190470934,
0.1784885377,
0.487716347,
0.0942580923,
-0.0868260562,
0.3091705143,
0.0517198853,
-0.4682955444,
-0.3966474235,
-0.2963798642,
-0.4983566999,
0.2613902688,
-0.6266687512,
0.1521052718,
-0.6533781886,
0.1600510329,
0.1988105923,
0.3154090643,
-0.7334236503,
0.0838622153,
-0.1546278298,
0.5216977,
-0.5533284545,
0.5224379897,
0.8766973615,
-0.0579419695,
-1.1943651438,
-0.0313690156,
0.1553896219,
-0.9762541652,
0.6343448162,
0.1837814748,
0.2791349292,
0.3222246468,
-0.5402308106,
-0.6959779859,
1.1492551565,
0.5664098263,
-0.4682991803,
-0.0051071583,
0.3720495999,
0.2971771955,
-0.2017838806,
0.0700930506,
0.509606421,
0.085291788,
0.426022619,
-0.8095583916,
-0.170062229,
-0.1909154654,
0.2537253201,
0.0424814746,
-0.4698131979,
0.914111793,
-0.5428305268,
0.0190191362,
0.0441231206,
0.6003811359,
0.5471212268,
0.1242265329,
0.587408483,
0.8265100121,
0.9302054644,
-0.0347989313,
1.1147681475,
-0.0877434015,
0.4675472677,
0.9716265202,
-0.0451379977,
0.3776158392,
0.6133044362,
-0.4946839511,
0.2430396974,
0.4538058341,
0.011196035,
0.5142105818,
0.9022710919,
-0.3707128763,
-0.312803328,
0.2536462843,
-0.4173750579,
0.1952712834,
0.3142193854,
0.0255617667,
-0.7067153454,
0.1645797193,
0.1391226053,
0.3463924229,
-0.356030792,
0.2269138247,
0.0556741953,
-0.5242447257,
0.4770860374,
0.0096918307,
0.4450928867,
-0.5783187747,
-0.1649866253,
-0.2849752307,
0.4213587344,
-0.0149813322,
-0.2853473723,
0.1352911294,
0.2141264379,
0.1370289624,
-0.0812954083,
0.3501615822,
-0.3782796264,
-0.9894846678,
-0.4176007509,
0.6483114362,
0.1781607568,
-0.1642611474,
-0.6379520893,
-0.1870969981,
-0.0041261413,
-0.3765846193,
0.4673506618,
0.6194389462,
0.1787972897,
0.777412653,
0.8690440655,
0.047459919,
-0.0814561248,
0.1077480391,
1.0172184706,
-0.4645124674,
-0.4285643995,
-0.9379116297,
0.3940753341,
0.1099151,
-0.4772976339,
0.749068439,
0.6202528477,
0.6571608186,
-0.0445479527,
0.9073063135,
0.2546105683,
0.7209888101,
-0.2766249478,
0.2981024981,
-0.6297817826,
0.5628667474,
-0.4418606162,
-0.8720266223,
-0.2577188015,
0.8141674995,
-0.5236746073,
0.1042954996,
0.652862072,
0.6891869307,
-0.0963004529,
0.0291924328,
0.0619384795,
-0.4631972015,
1.0137156248,
0.8642320037,
0.7057994008,
-0.2609058022,
0.6472054124,
-0.4012070298,
-0.2607111931,
0.0598034114,
-0.8098301888,
-1.2479990721,
-0.215747565,
-0.5466077328,
-0.4041973352,
-0.4444394112,
0.7984696627,
0.4656895101,
-0.4496622682,
0.047297027,
-0.3926946819,
0.1102653667,
-0.1352356225,
-0.2333036363,
0.6713796258,
-0.5990924835,
-0.8610264659,
0.1498461217,
-0.2039155513,
0.3785484135,
-0.3067098558,
0.015579327,
0.7281284928,
0.1737632453,
0.4281411469,
0.0706729293,
-0.5161800385,
-0.3537847698,
0.1893258095,
0.0689737946,
-0.1811252981,
1.1302410364,
-0.5678069592,
0.4263479114,
-0.0042215418,
0.9936454892,
0.5845685601,
-0.1733368337,
0.4114623368,
-0.6454627514,
0.1736221015,
0.2845388353,
0.1682440341,
0.2906148434,
-0.2166433632,
0.6653161645,
0.6792212725,
-0.1338203549,
-0.9523371458,
0.1647266299,
-0.6684311032,
-0.3209890723,
1.1428762674,
-0.2271273136,
-0.1800725162,
0.1862119585,
-0.3769535422,
0.0296919383,
0.1122247949,
1.045396924,
0.9623305798,
-0.2004587352,
0.05404507,
-0.7720117569,
0.3454268873,
0.5859281421,
-0.6386685967,
0.0007660842,
0.2902326584,
0.6761215329,
0.0400999263,
0.2911004722,
-0.1297072172,
-0.0062312293,
-0.136513263,
-0.1001517251,
-0.5906162262,
0.0238634255,
-0.007356056,
0.2237244546,
-0.1039333194,
-0.0992828906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13272v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13272v2 | CLASS: A Design Framework for building Intelligent Tutoring Systems based on Learning Science principles | 2023-05-22T17:35:05 | 2023-10-26T01:25:23 | Shashank Sonkar, Naiming Liu, Debshila Basu Mallick, Richard G. Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a design framework called Conversational Learning with Analytical
Step-by-Step Strategies (CLASS) for building advanced Intelligent Tutoring
Systems (ITS) powered by high-performance Large Language Models (LLMs). The
CLASS framework empowers ITS with two key capabilities. First, through a
carefully curated scaffolding dataset, CLASS equips ITS with essential
problem-solving strategies, enabling it to provide tutor-like, step-by-step
guidance to students. Second, by using a dynamic conversational dataset, CLASS
assists ITS in facilitating natural language interactions, fostering engaging
student-tutor conversations. The CLASS framework also provides valuable
insights into ITS' internal decision-making process which allows seamless
integration of user feedback, thus enabling continuous refinement and
improvement. We also present a proof-of-concept ITS, referred to as SPOCK,
which is trained using the CLASS framework with a focus on introductory
college-level biology content. A carefully constructed protocol was developed
for SPOCK's preliminary evaluation, examining aspects such as the factual
accuracy and relevance of its responses. Experts in the field of biology
offered favorable remarks, particularly highlighting SPOCK's capability to
break down questions into manageable subproblems and provide encouraging
responses to students. Code and models are available at
https://github.com/luffycodes/Tutorbot-Spock. | [
-0.0379228219,
-0.8215718865,
0.4074559212,
0.0807532147,
0.0116424384,
0.7674241066,
-0.1947942376,
-0.3251481056,
0.2830503285,
0.2819888592,
-0.4710579515,
-0.4872260094,
-0.0311295111,
0.1181052253,
-0.5375651717,
1.0976741314,
0.4853149354,
0.5173038244,
-0.7671283484,
0.2783014178,
-0.3040602505,
-0.2625917196,
-0.6528642774,
-0.3131794631,
0.5314500332,
0.9745526314,
0.4560964406,
1.0245923996,
0.4930581152,
0.234173879,
-0.2196489871,
-0.1483951658,
-0.334261328,
0.2360735238,
-0.2545768321,
-0.5320693851,
-0.3658476472,
-0.175904572,
0.3370181322,
1.0665407181,
-0.1864324063,
0.3483248353,
0.0838434249,
0.7339116931,
-0.2044898719,
0.6866032481,
-0.3861285448,
0.3006156087,
-0.1664213985,
-0.2475646734,
-0.7615205646,
-0.3687820137,
0.4868277907,
-0.5782935619,
0.0680168048,
0.1140948161,
0.3378672004,
0.0090029603,
-0.4315323234,
-0.4498824775,
-0.3233554661,
0.6069049239,
-0.4960314929,
0.3773792684,
0.1784028262,
0.5361236334,
-0.2470282614,
-0.6972080469,
-0.4242358208,
-0.3437947631,
-0.0119376648,
0.1790142059,
0.3209195733,
0.2692865431,
0.0089005437,
0.526011467,
-0.4445390105,
0.0662219077,
-0.8603060246,
-0.1207411811,
0.6947647333,
0.1538442075,
0.0174866971,
-0.1034789234,
-0.3788510561,
-0.0827847198,
-0.5379614234,
0.3586577773,
0.5243422985,
0.6649545431,
0.0536750853,
0.4186044037,
0.0095428945,
0.5332943201,
-0.0022670082,
-0.0562008768,
0.0333107673,
0.1698634624,
0.0108338427,
0.3656932712,
0.4231759906,
0.2999476194,
0.1482245177,
-0.1079488993,
0.1152917221,
-0.0035797262,
0.3153946698,
-1.0430538654,
-0.473680079,
0.2942460477,
-0.1630318314,
-0.6173327565,
-0.242261976,
-1.184423089,
-0.4718729556,
-0.4620435834,
0.340962857,
-0.5178270936,
-0.1072010919,
0.2233524173,
0.1319939792,
0.172693491,
0.2308749706,
-1.0702904463,
0.5130097866,
0.6157228351,
0.5541369319,
-0.4101873636,
-0.1608746052,
-0.2237832546,
0.1883069575,
-0.260556072,
0.9172312021,
-0.7551745176,
-0.6879090667,
0.146281749,
-0.1267563999,
0.0543539003,
-0.3722204566,
0.2038846463,
-0.4144072533,
0.3843574822,
-0.0902812406,
-0.933131814,
-0.3993954957,
0.1274293214,
-0.1592244208,
0.7521231771,
-0.0579383411,
-0.2624439895,
0.1305149496,
-1.1706590652,
-0.5483973622,
0.5156570077,
-0.3684455454,
-0.2428970635,
-0.3242971599,
-0.3741542399,
0.5943686962,
-0.1227546334,
0.3797281981,
-0.1798026413,
-0.2150218785,
0.1402148306,
0.0948903933,
0.6641502976,
0.3058586121,
-0.3067101836,
0.4131837785,
-1.1167408228,
0.3292967081,
0.1534062326,
-0.3696106672,
0.0366920792,
0.2369625568,
-0.0966479331,
-0.3497271538,
-0.0138701033,
-0.4292919934,
0.5044302344,
-0.3507229984,
0.7211280465,
0.9695250988,
-0.1730926484,
0.5678621531,
-0.2779830396,
0.2658399045,
-0.0930749699,
0.1382979602,
-0.791154325,
-0.3592607975,
-1.0199862719,
-0.3048427701,
0.0492858067,
0.5407405496,
-0.4149006903,
0.3373809159,
0.0109073408,
-0.567612052,
-0.1010178328,
0.028179951,
0.3356554508,
0.5543574095,
0.562498033,
-0.2344955355,
-0.3864619732,
-0.6826460958,
-0.1743678153,
-0.3760277629,
0.0097229816,
0.172622323,
0.5627741218,
-0.0724815428,
0.9967859387,
-0.6125028729,
0.0145109342,
-0.3355161846,
-0.1846068203,
0.0129104508,
0.699667275,
0.4176278114,
-0.4824150801,
-0.3088656962,
-0.1544875354,
-0.7833696604,
0.1361518204,
-0.0226101056,
-0.2652457356,
0.0918194726,
0.4888471067,
-0.2348965108,
0.5596059561,
-0.1236548424,
-0.359813571,
0.6478393674,
0.0920995995,
-0.0083871521,
-0.9738815427,
-0.0985512808,
0.0516043454,
0.1181683987,
-0.7415034771,
0.189956978,
0.0549172238,
-0.4708690345,
-0.4380351305,
0.4912427962,
-0.064498134,
-0.0865398422,
-0.1282201856,
-0.2107166946,
-0.1285663992,
0.7520935535,
-0.0190837532,
0.661786437,
0.6390700936,
-0.7698717117,
0.532155931,
0.3196475208,
-0.2077537179,
0.8009290695,
-0.790923059,
0.1474210769,
0.0402374193,
0.1782783121,
-0.8378267288,
-0.4198141992,
0.1873766184,
-0.2937544882,
0.2979208529,
-0.0311568584,
-0.3648767769,
-0.3839804828,
-0.0911212787,
0.1539666355,
0.1271776706,
-0.6343868971,
0.5674507022,
0.1489560157,
-0.365635246,
-0.270203203,
-0.3285322785,
0.0644835383,
-0.084423922,
-0.5491530895,
0.2763493061,
-0.5233626366,
-0.1798253655,
-0.2198755294,
-0.1902007908,
-0.1305727959,
0.0235196892,
0.2209899276,
0.5041022897,
-0.0926441625,
0.4312438369,
0.0391916297,
-0.1364616007,
0.2429042011,
-0.3366826773,
0.4837578237,
-0.2893714607,
-0.5502820611,
-0.5705943704,
0.3388633728,
0.8784124851,
-0.0694311485,
0.2599548995,
0.1046056449,
-0.1509904861,
-0.3874591589,
-0.2648506165,
-0.7179914713,
-0.5219435692,
0.5431081653,
-0.1090808958,
-0.6134377718,
0.5750077367,
0.0737310499,
0.4470730126,
-0.3326820731,
0.1249077618,
-0.1739407778,
0.9070277214,
0.9257555008,
0.0883638412,
0.7155812979,
-0.359616071,
0.3993962109,
-0.164530009,
-0.7487481833,
-0.4522061646,
-0.2336846739,
-0.2530036867,
-0.0819169208,
0.219212532,
-0.1915311962,
-0.7998170853,
0.1292439997,
-0.7135965824,
0.6599924564,
0.7860699892,
0.2939245999,
0.1305456311,
0.2496794164,
-0.2468376607,
-0.0060823602,
-0.7036576271,
-0.6794762611,
0.9712295532,
0.3526281416,
0.6981450319,
0.0440041237,
0.4394206703,
0.1257687062,
0.212001726,
-1.1861237288,
1.0832779408,
0.1619270593,
-0.6587957144,
-0.0483445339,
-0.1382493228,
-0.5787484646,
0.0736175999,
-0.1667132676,
-0.6352326274,
-0.2939475775,
0.0588244572,
-0.3143667579,
0.49365592,
-0.6713781357,
0.7666599154,
-0.3264569342,
-0.8267499804,
-0.3713486493,
-0.9189497232,
0.0631175339,
0.2629009187,
0.0741070509,
0.1768915802,
0.423636049,
0.7825388908,
-0.4668473005,
1.2237432003,
-0.1308717728,
0.000431005,
0.3662573397,
0.2689313591,
-0.0528001264,
0.0614651702,
-0.1260878146,
-0.2649306357,
0.347758472,
-0.6510869265,
-0.5250338912,
0.2972486019,
-0.5301421285,
-0.7885476947,
-0.5413111448,
-0.5782375932,
-0.237859875,
0.1919385493,
-0.2123143822,
0.5388198495,
0.1606424153,
0.4173389971,
0.8843825459,
-0.2091006637,
0.3865937293,
0.7315987349,
-0.5146448612,
-0.3218947053,
1.0903706551,
0.0240995288,
0.4297981858,
0.1096402407,
0.4305950105,
-0.1629271209,
-0.3444568217,
-0.6862492561,
-0.028295137,
-0.8816677332,
-0.3030320108,
-0.3640685081,
-0.3641251922,
-0.5559635162,
-0.4173619449,
-0.2415527552,
-0.3185023069,
-0.3740928769,
-0.3250648975,
0.4925529957,
0.6950753927,
0.2385916263,
0.4130707681,
-0.6190467477,
-0.227401942,
0.5663881898,
0.2907682955,
-0.0871983394,
-0.4447270632,
-0.1905556023,
0.0310431197,
-0.6950929165,
-0.7043674588,
0.2179759294,
0.4557997882,
0.6258487105,
0.5131511092,
-0.0697669238,
0.5290272236,
-0.5262342691,
0.9014041424,
0.1724574566,
-0.8838043809,
0.7974542975,
-0.3192341328,
-0.0453687161,
0.4534480274,
0.4052878916,
-0.355060637,
-0.3441401124,
-0.5617787242,
-0.8081098199,
0.5190520287,
-0.4492587149,
0.2111941129,
0.1403185278,
0.6639629602,
0.3225658536,
0.4846389294,
-0.6786839962,
-0.3988367617,
-0.4893705845,
-0.5609710813,
0.3123755455,
-0.0177017301,
-0.3149205446,
-0.4160292149,
0.6961448789,
-0.5342153907,
0.0951465741,
-0.1713066697,
0.1668641269,
-0.0359911025,
0.2809666097,
0.5572788119,
0.5786058307,
-0.1475254893,
0.0358966254,
0.0009550697,
-0.7855145931,
0.0121513885,
-0.0809845179,
-0.023957517,
-0.4061743915,
0.2347703576,
0.3604638278,
0.4126728475,
-0.7776449919,
0.4177667499,
0.1499896049,
-0.2130031735,
-0.1361298114,
0.4574742019,
-0.1656676829,
0.3941389322,
0.7819782495,
0.1209052354,
0.0468735583,
-0.675295949,
0.2623437345,
0.1432049274,
-0.3133185506,
-0.4982192516,
0.529020071,
0.437948972,
-0.4662415981,
0.2898007035,
-0.1001347899,
-0.655480206,
0.7897084951,
0.7429017425,
0.4862012565,
-0.2494003177,
0.5290825367,
0.3245649636,
-0.3352980614,
0.0095573254,
0.2208039612,
-0.4511122108,
-0.3808530867,
-0.1212350875,
-0.5660309196,
-0.9287654161,
-0.1156450361,
-0.6686999202,
0.4588774741,
-0.8836269975,
0.3017247021,
0.0654658005,
0.2494159788,
-0.2026137412,
0.1181679145,
-0.2350119203,
1.0028584003,
-0.6407331228,
0.5586936474,
1.0583851337,
-0.4094848335,
-0.7383204103,
-0.3609506488,
0.2883035243,
-0.8142063618,
0.9622600675,
0.3147976398,
-0.1461733878,
0.197025463,
-1.0075196028,
-0.6731029153,
1.0443429947,
0.2507923245,
-0.4011605084,
-0.0592940412,
0.1475709826,
0.6174538732,
-0.4228023291,
0.1676450521,
0.1714343876,
0.0650400296,
0.55667454,
-0.5727071166,
-0.2197833061,
-0.336040169,
-0.5272119045,
-0.3323532045,
-0.8137059808,
0.4835472107,
-0.4722300172,
-0.2205418944,
0.2827324867,
0.7650984526,
0.3245143592,
0.7416496277,
0.3398916721,
0.2809044719,
0.8839395046,
-0.0850194842,
0.218337968,
-0.5837063193,
0.0906170458,
0.7944617867,
-0.2681399286,
0.7065214515,
0.5763117671,
-0.4616653323,
0.6705901623,
0.7650056481,
0.0552490205,
0.4350712001,
0.6887741685,
-0.4299583733,
-0.1482720524,
-0.0125399185,
-0.5015898943,
0.4383099973,
0.6347107887,
-0.0895948857,
0.1089763567,
0.230030939,
0.0392754897,
0.3455991745,
-0.4347941279,
0.6352594495,
-0.1662191451,
-0.45996508,
0.1863161922,
-0.6053802371,
0.5585091114,
-0.4702624679,
-0.0793141574,
-0.3250918388,
0.1620227396,
-0.4509441555,
-0.7591541409,
-0.1184041724,
-0.1428105086,
-0.206465885,
-0.3624775112,
0.3098329604,
-0.5500509739,
-0.516276896,
-0.2166552544,
0.333270669,
0.2127210647,
0.7550025582,
-0.4676958621,
0.0195479002,
0.0011668412,
-0.0542717092,
0.2260074168,
0.2815219164,
0.1800463796,
1.2167221308,
0.6754634976,
-0.0419108458,
-0.1683284491,
-0.0763520151,
0.9534459114,
-0.6294541359,
-0.467906177,
-0.4625948966,
0.5030788779,
-0.1463156193,
-0.0430995375,
0.6480795741,
0.6921239495,
0.9387741685,
0.0316156223,
0.7106420994,
0.1755845994,
0.6874406934,
-0.3098032176,
0.5610397458,
-0.2623682022,
0.6479139328,
-0.2099800259,
-0.7077265978,
-0.5393558145,
0.9281895757,
-0.1904092282,
0.0336595252,
0.6882385015,
0.7851102352,
0.1916444004,
0.8048466444,
0.091402635,
-0.0681492761,
0.7645127177,
0.1900207996,
0.907921195,
-0.1944306791,
0.4992506206,
-0.350266993,
-0.3241682351,
-0.3282560408,
-0.8010487556,
-1.0717926025,
-0.6087947488,
-0.5497695208,
-0.2776368856,
0.2807451785,
1.2890559435,
0.8775362372,
-0.8559585214,
-0.5085744262,
-0.3895247877,
-0.0035590264,
0.0498886444,
-0.3079154789,
0.312166661,
-0.7066127658,
-0.6860925555,
0.5332173109,
0.2631716132,
0.2435019016,
-0.3894329071,
0.2343596369,
0.0527213663,
-0.0108476384,
0.7199497819,
0.4821040332,
-0.4357701838,
-0.5046340823,
0.5418255925,
-0.078561753,
0.0705940798,
0.7964501977,
-0.798682332,
0.4195432365,
0.2165644765,
0.7055622339,
0.2377931774,
-0.3856436014,
0.3935988247,
-0.4262864888,
0.0445725434,
0.2953468561,
0.1358928978,
0.348670274,
-0.3521097898,
0.5313522816,
0.4022682309,
-0.8400244117,
-1.0674574375,
0.1707699597,
-0.9683852196,
-0.335292697,
0.8306716084,
-0.0331464671,
-0.2511624992,
-0.0880442709,
-0.4544425607,
0.0104604866,
-0.5182700157,
1.0035318136,
0.5791157484,
-0.48581025,
0.0716071203,
-0.6272727847,
0.490329504,
0.5899500251,
-0.9013719559,
0.05699002,
0.4369445145,
0.1908247918,
0.3525858819,
0.0384876542,
0.0027966811,
0.1288701743,
-0.2153807133,
0.0220049843,
-0.1935201734,
-0.6073145866,
0.1457996964,
0.2287545353,
-0.3486539721,
-0.2143016607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13269v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13269v4 | Chain-of-Knowledge: Grounding Large Language Models via Dynamic Knowledge Adapting over Heterogeneous Sources | 2023-05-22T17:34:23 | 2024-02-21T07:44:48 | Xingxuan Li, Ruochen Zhao, Yew Ken Chia, Bosheng Ding, Shafiq Joty, Soujanya Poria, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present chain-of-knowledge (CoK), a novel framework that augments large
language models (LLMs) by dynamically incorporating grounding information from
heterogeneous sources. It results in more factual rationales and reduced
hallucination in generation. Specifically, CoK consists of three stages:
reasoning preparation, dynamic knowledge adapting, and answer consolidation.
Given a knowledge-intensive question, CoK first prepares several preliminary
rationales and answers while identifying the relevant knowledge domains. If
there is no majority consensus among the answers from samples, CoK corrects the
rationales step by step by adapting knowledge from the identified domains.
These corrected rationales can plausibly serve as a better foundation for the
final answer consolidation. Unlike prior studies that primarily use
unstructured data, CoK also leverages structured knowledge sources such as
Wikidata and tables that provide more reliable factual information. To access
both unstructured and structured knowledge sources in the dynamic knowledge
adapting stage, we propose an adaptive query generator that allows the
generation of queries for various types of query languages, including SPARQL,
SQL, and natural sentences. Moreover, to minimize error propagation between
rationales, CoK corrects the rationales progressively using preceding corrected
rationales to generate and correct subsequent rationales. Extensive experiments
show that CoK consistently improves the performance of LLMs on
knowledge-intensive tasks across different domains. | [
-0.2528226376,
-1.1393283606,
0.6337817311,
0.299405247,
0.0028628418,
0.4679124057,
-0.3356978893,
-0.2504630685,
0.0480823182,
0.599607408,
-0.5753513575,
-0.4869457185,
-0.121289432,
-0.0721548051,
-0.31148386,
0.8370219469,
0.0017896155,
-0.2616067827,
-0.4366567433,
-0.20114173,
-0.3855494857,
-0.5427311063,
-0.5254864097,
-0.401637882,
0.4916878939,
0.5072388649,
0.7116088271,
0.5937767029,
0.1362330168,
0.2894030809,
0.0243324246,
0.4334159195,
-0.7270855904,
0.4322446287,
-0.5944288969,
-0.4806269109,
-0.5552411079,
-0.1613657027,
0.5843339562,
1.1455507278,
-0.4362244606,
-0.0616790317,
-0.0451494865,
0.8048003316,
-0.7912687063,
0.0432097167,
-1.0941518545,
-0.0293107387,
0.1653258204,
-0.4541971385,
-0.4915176928,
-0.3455226421,
0.3264986575,
-0.9733855128,
-0.1121310219,
0.314602375,
0.6476219893,
0.3637158275,
-0.4827352166,
-0.5858413577,
-0.7659729123,
0.7025734186,
-0.4242613912,
0.5369109511,
0.4447166622,
0.3515148163,
-0.5979420543,
-0.5906934142,
-0.5959378481,
-0.2853243351,
0.0026324529,
0.2569395304,
0.1317455769,
0.0308664497,
0.3835141659,
0.4071407914,
-0.2342708707,
-0.0367777012,
0.0254347026,
-0.0462049097,
0.5120431185,
0.0532550737,
0.3653151095,
0.0976225436,
-0.2567305267,
-0.0037975211,
-0.8820365667,
-0.0748395249,
0.4448104501,
0.1641447544,
-0.0003796882,
0.4847510457,
-0.5920335054,
1.0090355873,
0.5398981571,
-0.360127151,
-0.1470251679,
-0.3177735806,
-0.1394843012,
0.3472118676,
0.4537797868,
0.1590999216,
-0.1037661135,
-0.3466272652,
-0.0445016921,
-0.283031106,
0.187849313,
-0.4338673055,
-0.2934472859,
0.0096073346,
-0.0751340687,
-0.254938215,
0.0270089582,
-0.7593333125,
-0.3786318302,
-0.337936759,
0.2743379474,
-0.2267959863,
-0.2300978601,
0.2158406973,
-0.0744331032,
0.0669028461,
0.4912821054,
-0.713237226,
0.6202870011,
0.4085767865,
0.601572454,
-0.0595108233,
-0.2268362939,
-0.6226936579,
0.5928602219,
-0.4577907622,
0.6141452789,
-0.4746479988,
0.0880704001,
0.0453475527,
-0.0198632274,
0.078098312,
-0.5068843365,
0.2126142532,
-0.9492760897,
0.2551118135,
-0.5490971208,
-0.5408533216,
-0.1899138391,
0.5432995558,
-0.6869095564,
1.0937329531,
0.2050363719,
-0.7950227857,
0.2679772973,
-0.5500628352,
-0.5599352121,
-0.0883781984,
-0.189464286,
-0.0499037281,
-0.0751776397,
0.1005243883,
0.3451090753,
-0.4634459913,
0.4796928465,
-0.497148186,
-0.0273004808,
0.1102932096,
-0.0595491007,
0.6216303706,
0.212070629,
-0.2954621911,
-0.0132794799,
-1.1737875938,
-0.1180956066,
0.0191870071,
-0.6219086051,
-0.7752722502,
0.3581410944,
-0.5373080373,
0.2991998792,
0.0922511965,
-0.2131319791,
0.3764338493,
-0.3019413054,
0.3101583123,
0.6862686872,
0.1455350071,
0.5948577523,
-0.0681649595,
0.3909502029,
-0.0445332937,
-0.2244105637,
-0.1291943491,
-0.1920999587,
-0.9407593012,
0.1190597191,
-0.001349262,
0.5524401069,
-1.1017885208,
0.6847696304,
-0.3548418581,
-0.430603385,
0.0548340194,
0.0289477501,
0.0827717334,
0.8212679029,
0.4379114509,
-0.0077383984,
-0.8540446758,
-0.4805926681,
-0.4142320752,
-0.3161135912,
0.1209211051,
0.2261622697,
0.3551174104,
-0.1137163863,
0.8901848197,
-0.6906440854,
0.1178189516,
0.1066845357,
0.0825056508,
0.2535361648,
0.3725268245,
0.1717181802,
-0.6587336659,
-0.5881147981,
0.3884986043,
-0.8856484294,
-0.0994593874,
-0.1708095819,
-0.4125286639,
0.1082068607,
0.6496326327,
-0.3619719446,
-0.0340653658,
0.6619252563,
-0.4761690497,
0.6073815227,
-0.2536505163,
0.0743869692,
-1.1649245024,
0.1069813743,
-0.4362687469,
-0.3596135378,
-0.505992353,
-0.028378332,
-0.1976051927,
-0.0029203931,
0.039804142,
0.3241267502,
-0.4696032107,
0.0136952326,
-0.0442872867,
0.1031258777,
0.0723332688,
0.3439570665,
-0.0696128979,
0.6266207099,
0.3950577378,
-0.8158870339,
0.6580420136,
0.1611972302,
-0.4370437264,
0.4924891889,
-0.3504419625,
0.4283680916,
0.1313585192,
0.4309271872,
-0.7900323868,
-0.4377385676,
0.0667475685,
-0.0537437536,
-0.1117768437,
-0.3136332631,
-0.4313490689,
-0.3399398327,
-0.0390696153,
0.2564307153,
0.4052243531,
-0.7379921079,
0.7963202596,
0.4185676575,
-0.206945464,
-0.7050468922,
-0.5222227573,
-0.0146322045,
0.022682298,
-0.7324769497,
0.4103619754,
0.0188745707,
-0.3823052943,
0.1849827915,
-0.4187951088,
-0.3024904132,
0.1265424341,
0.0335921608,
0.0598701127,
-0.2395531982,
0.2376221865,
0.397926867,
0.1917609572,
-0.0325919613,
-0.7574933171,
0.6532489061,
-0.0135106454,
-0.3587774336,
-0.0226686336,
0.2022283822,
0.7411848307,
-0.0259326529,
0.9363695383,
0.2327821702,
-0.4862098396,
-0.3488797843,
-0.7004288435,
-0.0822488889,
-0.4575240612,
0.3538565636,
-0.6185977459,
-1.1571911573,
0.6863392591,
-0.3998059034,
-0.1958970726,
0.5027036667,
0.8296348453,
-0.0654415935,
0.75980407,
0.5422783494,
0.0132927662,
0.3668952286,
-0.0540798567,
0.387276262,
-0.4625440836,
-0.342115581,
-0.4139378071,
0.0540825725,
-0.4634928107,
-0.5144346952,
0.2510413826,
0.4744462371,
-0.2457657903,
0.0810273141,
-0.1358457655,
0.4891757965,
0.2171173543,
0.1230746359,
0.5458062887,
0.2414600551,
-0.3792711794,
0.4398062229,
-1.0724123716,
-0.2959424257,
0.8004745841,
0.2493460029,
0.9841342568,
0.0057821819,
0.314491868,
0.157984525,
0.0698587224,
-0.5734989643,
0.4275898337,
-0.0744941011,
-0.6146679521,
-0.3471558988,
-0.5401986837,
-0.5635409951,
0.0574407354,
-0.2550825477,
-0.4375213683,
0.3004564047,
0.4566454589,
-0.5090987086,
0.3317306936,
-0.6609789133,
0.5187485814,
-0.1959262341,
-0.7017664313,
-0.3794694841,
-0.4915281534,
0.4453204572,
-0.1487768292,
0.2576240897,
-0.008401189,
0.0566376485,
0.7954342365,
-0.4983094037,
0.6612665057,
-0.2289804965,
-0.2745028436,
0.4564650357,
0.1044084728,
0.9005490541,
0.1481967568,
-0.2855374813,
-0.2393136024,
0.0107502956,
-0.3644867539,
-0.9420961142,
0.7809667587,
-0.6925037503,
-0.5428729653,
-0.2683128417,
-0.7877666354,
-0.4273557961,
0.3185326755,
-0.1187358722,
0.1522264183,
-0.1669255793,
0.4583388269,
0.677609086,
-0.418631345,
-0.081330061,
0.5554820895,
-0.268709749,
-0.4907073379,
0.7215032578,
0.294172585,
0.4538970888,
0.5057159066,
0.4097736776,
-0.2773322463,
-0.5013560057,
-0.1549090594,
-0.054380741,
-0.7995713949,
-0.1175879538,
-0.9503097534,
-0.0627958104,
-0.3257834613,
-0.1356163472,
-0.4035983086,
-0.4317790866,
0.2628763914,
-0.1427638084,
0.5909170508,
0.5928056836,
0.0255186874,
0.1682718694,
-0.5520329475,
0.4271938205,
0.6752812862,
0.5145687461,
-0.0107796052,
-0.3692653477,
-0.5108608007,
-0.0157520249,
-0.0227466393,
-0.7360869646,
0.0167960227,
0.1850279719,
0.4573301673,
0.1467225701,
0.2124985456,
1.0995109081,
-0.5525898337,
0.6006909609,
0.3170306683,
-0.9147672653,
0.5848249793,
-0.6399914026,
0.1696769595,
0.6322814226,
0.4696262479,
-0.5665009618,
-0.1879202425,
-0.4735476077,
-0.8937361836,
0.5706152916,
0.0694690049,
-0.0451834053,
0.1334574372,
0.6644713283,
0.2634078264,
0.2881361246,
-0.5142785311,
0.0194622725,
-0.2368719727,
-0.2439701408,
0.2431622446,
-0.3680765927,
-0.276786536,
-0.5094004869,
0.8196364641,
-0.4257044196,
0.1524222791,
0.21059376,
-0.4443490505,
-0.3962301314,
0.1902349889,
0.5306487083,
0.9422529936,
-0.3406946063,
0.4682219625,
0.3001276255,
-0.4256286621,
0.1293406039,
-0.1073493585,
-0.1628174037,
-0.2723394036,
0.4083528221,
0.8916504979,
0.0766275004,
-0.6088886857,
0.0511981323,
0.1110887527,
-0.1037951782,
-0.2422636002,
0.1429342926,
0.1395641267,
0.1891530752,
0.4642659128,
0.0386141352,
-0.0957418531,
-0.8164926767,
0.3556561768,
0.0641950592,
-0.0992324874,
-0.4345543087,
0.3217392266,
0.2402915806,
-0.0776619688,
0.55380404,
-0.0925766528,
-0.5812323093,
0.2799535096,
0.6986836195,
0.5579991937,
-0.2339958698,
-0.0739388615,
0.442556411,
0.0332908854,
-0.3105303347,
0.2567189336,
0.0173615627,
-0.9722949862,
-0.7116259933,
-0.5891617537,
-0.3991851211,
0.2469528466,
-0.4730851948,
0.2249156237,
-0.7313203216,
0.2268369049,
-0.281875968,
0.1272470504,
-0.4390069842,
0.2910663784,
-0.1467309743,
0.9432522058,
-0.8475734591,
1.0450799465,
0.7413451672,
-0.3292408288,
-0.9986680746,
0.1486991793,
-0.2064787,
-0.695930481,
0.5939288139,
-0.3247641027,
-0.1623439044,
0.2918249071,
-0.6555023789,
-0.8637025356,
1.1725358963,
0.5063382387,
-0.6833778024,
-0.0367911197,
0.1300875694,
0.480055511,
-0.5481159687,
-0.1948305517,
0.5322706699,
0.4366596639,
0.2721580863,
-0.6107932925,
0.2222996056,
-0.0320275761,
-0.1761830002,
-0.0979936123,
-0.3941083848,
0.7973716855,
0.1016188785,
0.1125852838,
-0.1318736523,
0.6275393963,
0.4500191212,
0.1584005803,
0.7495023608,
0.6823148131,
1.1575311422,
0.019370934,
0.9442741275,
-0.3981630802,
0.3541416228,
1.3967394829,
-0.4205620587,
0.6549138427,
0.7246463299,
-0.2853579819,
0.9352914095,
0.4539918303,
0.2267329991,
0.5933693051,
0.3205992877,
-0.2776226699,
-0.2536402047,
-0.1641139239,
-0.3365634978,
0.2989305258,
0.2524144948,
0.0137751671,
-0.1558275223,
-0.1419064105,
-0.0864837319,
0.263073653,
-0.1686664969,
0.726929009,
-0.0725980625,
-0.9036903977,
0.7565965652,
-0.0053252443,
0.2831923962,
-0.6966036558,
-0.128529802,
-0.1319210082,
0.149777472,
-0.3332593441,
-0.5192967057,
0.4930161536,
-0.0186106861,
-0.5482290983,
-0.2184362262,
1.1778399944,
-0.7116626501,
-0.3464339077,
0.3465093672,
0.5045200586,
-0.2650564015,
-0.2325279862,
-0.608946383,
0.133182168,
-0.2082732618,
-0.1807041913,
0.1151581034,
0.8255006671,
-0.1332172006,
0.6843441725,
1.0001652241,
-0.1018691659,
0.3888724446,
0.067928344,
1.1045113802,
-0.6456025243,
-0.6557613611,
-0.724814415,
0.5233027935,
-0.2273206711,
0.2741396427,
0.7680220008,
0.5231102705,
0.8723571897,
-0.1583131403,
0.9082285762,
-0.3208472431,
0.2743052244,
-0.7712957263,
0.6731948853,
-0.4993617237,
0.2897992134,
-0.2500363588,
-0.8362749815,
-0.3018516898,
0.6197760105,
-0.4662319422,
-0.1561170518,
0.9200807214,
0.6389559507,
-0.0431013517,
-0.1947613657,
0.2838099003,
0.5604298711,
0.3473932445,
0.3597936332,
1.0778639317,
-0.3716803789,
0.2622923255,
-0.1898108125,
-0.1847002655,
-0.1677937657,
-0.9592761397,
-0.8376531601,
-0.4796732664,
-0.3479041159,
-0.5958058834,
0.2823306918,
1.0719028711,
0.7271074653,
-0.9088445902,
-0.4214370251,
-0.5400551558,
0.5079781413,
-0.1662664115,
-0.1989912391,
0.2910224795,
-0.5401863456,
-0.2137852311,
0.4983243048,
0.4673932195,
-0.4208598733,
-0.1705134362,
-0.3417373896,
-0.7346666455,
0.0019458547,
0.9470207095,
0.1001900658,
-0.5726237893,
-0.4607023001,
0.1879565269,
0.0946360007,
0.0431509204,
0.9764732122,
-0.8214289546,
0.5037644506,
0.6558514237,
0.7795519233,
0.303089112,
-0.1312652528,
0.7450926304,
-0.630174458,
0.2582715154,
0.1367367655,
0.0726625994,
0.1442218423,
-0.4370239377,
0.4642069638,
0.6508689523,
-0.2564029396,
-0.9181537628,
0.2570992708,
-1.1249785423,
-0.1426566094,
1.1587389708,
-0.2025798261,
-0.2882146835,
-0.3990174234,
0.0771333575,
0.4971571565,
-0.1926718652,
0.8041215539,
0.8965836763,
0.140097037,
-0.1308763772,
-0.2783860266,
0.4304952621,
0.263915211,
-0.9573785663,
0.1272306442,
0.3862698972,
0.4092324674,
0.1644731015,
0.5915101171,
-0.0524363145,
0.0115952287,
-0.0342303999,
0.0012840561,
0.0526291057,
-0.332141161,
-0.0059739351,
0.3361845315,
0.1493042707,
0.345148325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13267v1 | Enhance Reasoning Ability of Visual-Language Models via Large Language Models | 2023-05-22T17:33:44 | 2023-05-22T17:33:44 | Yueting Yang, Xintong Zhang, Wenjuan Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained visual language models (VLM) have shown excellent performance in
image caption tasks. However, it sometimes shows insufficient reasoning
ability. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) emerge with powerful
reasoning capabilities. Therefore, we propose a method called TReE, which
transfers the reasoning ability of a large language model to a visual language
model in zero-shot scenarios. TReE contains three stages: observation,
thinking, and re-thinking. Observation stage indicates that VLM obtains the
overall information of the relative image. Thinking stage combines the image
information and task description as the prompt of the LLM, inference with the
rationals. Re-Thinking stage learns from rationale and then inference the final
result through VLM. | [
-0.3115974963,
-0.9507732391,
0.8397622705,
-0.2296257764,
-0.5502843261,
0.1334837079,
-0.0062996452,
-0.563160181,
-0.2011195421,
0.7896168828,
-0.458022356,
-0.4794736207,
-0.3854292035,
-0.0330611877,
-0.4664080739,
0.8052769899,
-0.2668945193,
-0.1130816266,
-0.3226496875,
0.03617635,
-0.6580703855,
-0.3349256814,
-0.5996904373,
-0.0976227596,
0.4151036441,
0.3852376044,
0.6253352165,
0.744563818,
0.4120774269,
0.4181393385,
0.0778942034,
-0.0143038379,
-0.4297851324,
0.308091104,
-0.4359844029,
-0.87849617,
-0.2530779839,
-0.1706837416,
0.7567449808,
0.4188562334,
0.22074534,
0.0941837952,
-0.338958919,
0.5088587403,
-0.4795855284,
0.4566580355,
-0.8871380091,
0.0462366268,
0.1426245868,
-0.508146286,
-0.6230599284,
-0.109222509,
0.1457303911,
-0.5743752718,
0.109303087,
0.2029967755,
1.0209105015,
0.2920404375,
-0.2925898731,
0.3500176072,
-0.8693318963,
0.7675895691,
-0.7380381227,
0.1959621757,
0.3104890287,
0.6533023715,
0.1387634873,
-0.6354517341,
-0.7296157479,
-0.3968908191,
-0.0678650364,
0.0302010551,
-0.1339215189,
0.0659248009,
0.7411570549,
0.0268263724,
-0.3230697513,
-0.1577335149,
-0.382463038,
0.0021727588,
0.6185070276,
0.1512074918,
0.3772491217,
-0.3002333045,
-0.1591082215,
-0.2497730851,
-0.6388689876,
0.040120773,
-0.2356752604,
0.2013894022,
0.1083449125,
0.7738270164,
-0.3223472834,
0.9791955352,
-0.2438503504,
-0.387365222,
0.1526642442,
-0.4927904606,
-0.6192548275,
-0.126425609,
0.3566528857,
0.4615756273,
0.515417695,
0.2445349842,
-0.2373998016,
0.1567723304,
0.1154515296,
-0.7365269661,
-0.1013841927,
0.0670645013,
-0.3899354041,
-0.1793078333,
-0.2630613744,
-0.4781327248,
-0.2674540281,
-0.5754064918,
0.558373034,
-0.6128896475,
-0.2851580083,
0.0331268795,
-0.1944384426,
0.6098847985,
0.9481570721,
-0.3906903565,
0.1200718284,
0.4768689573,
0.5705108047,
0.1890804768,
-0.445299089,
-0.7152351737,
0.257753849,
-0.5108626485,
0.9326894879,
-0.8110724688,
-0.1238268167,
-0.0897638872,
0.1809596866,
-0.1772682667,
-0.1843209118,
0.3464039862,
-0.50747931,
0.2430182248,
-0.0739570558,
-0.4089574516,
-0.6606634259,
0.3221731782,
-0.4247811735,
0.72198385,
0.2591536939,
-0.8143280149,
0.4967673123,
-0.497041136,
-0.5116741061,
0.4055712223,
-0.3734836578,
-0.2978570759,
0.0518500209,
0.5848855376,
0.5273610353,
-0.0612822957,
0.099990584,
-0.4511700869,
-0.228705585,
0.0323383734,
-0.3245029449,
0.7714546919,
0.2075400501,
-0.3322393894,
0.4216260314,
-0.4330712557,
0.2106099874,
0.4206958115,
-0.0349510312,
-0.2432395071,
0.1218247861,
-0.2184485197,
0.288205266,
-0.050107602,
-0.3435137868,
0.4378581941,
-0.3454709351,
0.4716159999,
0.3916586637,
0.1246350557,
0.4327053428,
-0.1197201759,
0.6473628283,
0.1423319727,
0.0974299982,
-0.6326050162,
-0.4249548018,
-1.0924627781,
-0.0475857109,
0.1366774738,
0.7587575316,
-1.3173737526,
0.1472937465,
-0.2169260085,
-0.313952297,
-0.4164771438,
0.1152392924,
0.5642461181,
0.4397428036,
0.2507672906,
-0.2088145912,
-0.5577100515,
-0.7094776034,
0.1437646598,
-0.3996292949,
0.1472313255,
0.3280279636,
0.7314429283,
0.1632521898,
0.6567320228,
-0.4877801836,
-0.0791491494,
-0.5276213288,
0.0595182702,
0.269064188,
0.3715153933,
0.4668617845,
-0.6423018575,
-0.4715588391,
0.2039057314,
-0.8679139614,
0.040598236,
-0.4333500862,
-0.2556121647,
0.5726206303,
0.7625251412,
-0.7036355734,
0.7882689238,
0.1421126127,
-0.475286603,
0.6277187467,
-0.1819951385,
0.1908188164,
-0.7681922317,
-0.1148893237,
-0.0443214588,
-0.4851006866,
-0.4685361385,
0.2886241078,
-0.1597837657,
-0.0091347415,
-0.3850397766,
0.4567469358,
-0.8568452597,
-0.4256986678,
-0.3336749673,
0.1791486144,
0.0027100448,
0.4837788641,
0.3858494461,
0.472977072,
1.1052808762,
-0.2740162313,
0.355747968,
0.004441503,
-0.4718529284,
0.8163580298,
-0.4941798151,
-0.0628956854,
-0.5272088051,
0.1263932735,
-1.0823537111,
-0.1930595338,
0.1771306992,
-0.4115797579,
0.3412232995,
-0.2833505571,
-0.3290077746,
-0.7612823844,
-0.1582186967,
0.1544230431,
0.4829222858,
-0.292660296,
0.7867754102,
-0.0119095622,
-0.1650844663,
-0.3646430373,
-0.5480428934,
0.3076398075,
-0.1391519606,
-0.4678901136,
-0.1051999778,
0.0032146911,
-0.3677003384,
0.3250226676,
0.0814722925,
-0.0522128046,
-0.0674851686,
0.2598978281,
0.4646914899,
-0.4007670581,
0.0842028782,
-0.2283578217,
-0.002667554,
-0.0597714297,
-0.1774845719,
0.3212351501,
-0.3098253012,
-0.5017784834,
-0.5999953747,
0.2414250821,
0.779792726,
-0.4600930214,
0.5060543418,
0.239116624,
-0.2873881161,
-0.1889969409,
-0.4254751205,
-0.0250101555,
-0.3341262639,
0.5036374331,
-0.7289406657,
-0.7578192949,
0.1147910282,
0.2149385661,
0.1022474393,
0.2991034985,
0.3973626196,
-0.2495064288,
1.332682848,
0.6149237752,
0.1647613496,
0.6462712288,
-0.4410654306,
0.2347669452,
-0.7105203271,
-0.2413377464,
-0.309171021,
-0.006616083,
-0.1042139158,
-0.8550288081,
0.0961452574,
0.5480750203,
-0.500926435,
0.3270431757,
-0.3764681518,
0.6731637716,
0.6534888148,
0.1259473264,
0.4367050231,
0.3228251636,
0.0513527617,
0.0767969638,
-0.6889163256,
-0.5094301105,
0.7899615169,
0.3548229933,
0.6018471122,
-0.1529302597,
0.414517045,
-0.1569425017,
0.5403735638,
-0.9378872514,
0.8288411498,
0.1477684528,
-0.543674469,
-0.6462697387,
-0.194304958,
-0.753542304,
0.5325500369,
-0.3491428792,
-0.9160541296,
-0.1789148897,
0.0926006213,
-0.2439085245,
0.4071173668,
-0.7756304145,
0.7743934989,
-0.425278604,
-0.3011613786,
-0.3279881477,
-0.5296529531,
0.6951155663,
-0.0157546345,
0.1452856511,
0.0542148091,
0.1021374613,
0.4835397601,
-0.3894156814,
0.8370355368,
-0.2556309104,
0.1423353404,
0.6951808929,
0.4522998929,
0.4522548616,
-0.2993968129,
0.2121846527,
-0.1761910766,
0.0683134794,
-0.2815392017,
-0.8416196704,
0.297213763,
-0.6303127408,
-1.0453941822,
-0.321978122,
-0.6181158423,
-0.2146775126,
0.4135565758,
-0.2304482311,
0.101699926,
0.1523696631,
0.3022147715,
0.1570063531,
-0.3336789012,
0.5414426923,
0.4875969887,
-0.8594563007,
-0.3275464475,
0.565695703,
0.2144281417,
0.5608990192,
0.3802567124,
0.1071380228,
-0.1899365932,
-0.6792716384,
-0.4586051702,
0.2863636315,
-0.83672297,
-0.2818082869,
-0.6610976458,
-0.491445601,
-0.0934978947,
-0.2840811312,
-0.0782027617,
-0.2749167383,
0.0472410508,
-0.3239853084,
0.4975244701,
0.5896434188,
0.1758839339,
0.3104338944,
-0.6674823165,
0.3422617018,
0.5108885765,
0.1961041391,
0.2565048933,
-0.5976116657,
0.0225242265,
-0.0577317886,
-0.0699059591,
-0.8082991838,
0.4412713945,
-0.0180918872,
0.7150176764,
0.4946628809,
-0.4588638246,
0.8683891296,
-0.482725352,
0.6329057813,
0.4307305515,
-0.9508769512,
0.8351883292,
-0.3245502114,
0.5072699189,
0.1373757124,
0.1280291826,
-0.1443321109,
-0.3842981756,
-0.6909915805,
-0.4495124221,
0.7914735079,
0.2429021001,
-0.0668169484,
0.1762358546,
0.0725865364,
-0.2315138876,
0.0721342415,
-0.9479819536,
0.2513643503,
-0.3790565133,
0.2856422663,
-0.1240707636,
-0.240093872,
-0.0665014014,
-0.8941182494,
0.4692452848,
-0.3178610206,
-0.070562236,
0.2166439593,
0.0050991504,
-0.3280864358,
0.1162761524,
0.378613919,
0.7779565454,
-0.1285583824,
0.4337289035,
0.3468716443,
0.109455958,
0.0255341977,
-0.2708401382,
-0.2616793215,
-0.1553403288,
0.9674389958,
1.1464095116,
0.0835740566,
-0.6498155594,
0.5763881207,
0.132170856,
-0.5273495317,
-0.0558863468,
0.1687985957,
0.3699611425,
0.3900629878,
0.0516474359,
-0.0320347138,
-0.1615205407,
-0.9014979601,
0.1670970917,
0.5148460269,
-0.2357137501,
-0.0976774916,
0.4868929386,
-0.0865745693,
-0.3268768191,
0.646520853,
0.0236690436,
-0.6419686079,
0.8067170382,
0.7338424921,
0.6972726583,
-0.2329817116,
0.528439045,
0.6336971521,
0.4711607993,
0.0070167105,
0.522338748,
-0.095828481,
-0.7479493022,
-1.0530161858,
-0.5699336529,
-0.0751023963,
0.1533091068,
-0.1781423986,
0.2059807181,
-0.4908693731,
0.0856242999,
0.1599380374,
-0.1675818861,
-0.8053548932,
0.3057049513,
0.3490615785,
0.9521772265,
-0.8660619259,
1.0909157991,
0.4700842798,
-0.6667836905,
-1.0691107512,
-0.2282730788,
-0.2335543931,
-1.0096943378,
1.1173686981,
0.2418036908,
-0.21419774,
-0.0875968188,
-0.9720337391,
-0.996432662,
0.9586433768,
0.3863066137,
-0.8260094523,
0.1655200869,
-0.2095851749,
0.7450844646,
-0.6988128424,
0.2173833847,
0.4762296081,
0.5852248073,
0.7824890614,
-0.8755484819,
0.0728752092,
-0.0439845361,
0.2224575132,
0.0414409675,
-0.0420403257,
0.8429908752,
-0.6836681366,
-0.5488383174,
0.045824565,
0.526014924,
0.1800114363,
0.0403176136,
0.8601546288,
0.6982395053,
0.5619393587,
0.123880282,
1.2537503242,
-0.100448966,
0.0723095164,
1.2273886204,
-0.3928484023,
1.1971489191,
0.5139557123,
-0.1919188201,
0.6208745837,
0.4735183716,
-0.080689989,
0.3713442385,
0.3080384433,
-0.1093704179,
-0.7550113201,
-0.192164287,
-0.1789389849,
0.5389187932,
0.2526864111,
-0.4240818918,
-0.3607797325,
0.0846279785,
-0.0009728448,
0.1052432358,
-0.5894647241,
0.6889598966,
0.0542361923,
-1.045861125,
0.7272368073,
-0.3032521307,
-0.0032230089,
-0.2147771269,
-0.4984604716,
-0.0412239507,
0.034789592,
-0.1801004857,
-1.3095678091,
0.3701808751,
-0.0350779481,
-0.0329357646,
-0.2569514513,
0.8037950993,
-0.4465278983,
-0.8469052315,
0.2784752548,
0.7766256332,
0.4352428913,
-0.0743870735,
-0.7100407481,
0.0507085584,
0.2136093825,
-0.1815489531,
-0.1098235846,
0.5861378312,
-0.4593217671,
0.7356642485,
0.6429753304,
0.1621615887,
-0.0917946622,
0.3591938615,
0.8026376963,
-0.8131145239,
-0.1674644053,
-0.9411085844,
0.5264153481,
-0.3454712927,
0.1547244489,
0.6529733539,
0.2753638923,
0.7949631214,
-0.2729317844,
0.7906174064,
-0.0769886672,
0.2747116685,
-0.6422393322,
0.2488141209,
-0.5044811368,
-0.0521607138,
-0.4156972766,
-1.0441305637,
-0.5983567834,
0.8045503497,
-0.6832073331,
-0.0167813078,
0.9957455397,
0.7341669798,
0.1220178679,
-0.2231092304,
0.6088430285,
0.4670472741,
0.2881300151,
0.8311427236,
1.0596805811,
0.0278289244,
0.5055346489,
-0.0389297046,
-0.3275443017,
0.040349938,
-1.0681561232,
-1.1391288042,
-0.4699817002,
-0.366075784,
-0.2206477225,
-0.0770498961,
0.4509996772,
0.8782947659,
-0.6205156446,
-0.1145768017,
-0.3305918574,
0.3167647421,
-0.2404091358,
-0.2334660292,
0.3432609737,
-0.1701962501,
-0.5354809761,
0.1867644191,
0.523073256,
0.1073597595,
-0.482337147,
0.0218571946,
-0.31846717,
0.0495260321,
0.9287922382,
0.1683696061,
-0.9369924068,
-0.5992982388,
-0.3294373453,
0.1285500824,
0.0974579602,
0.5393336415,
-0.8757032156,
0.7480123043,
0.5566613674,
0.3481565714,
0.76792413,
-0.0182288084,
0.548148632,
-0.146868512,
0.1137488931,
0.1214664206,
0.6783067584,
0.3938634992,
-0.1656116247,
0.6121490002,
0.3149467111,
-0.1647089422,
-0.7049946785,
0.3612719178,
-1.0176311731,
-0.6605139971,
1.1250423193,
-0.0679620132,
-0.4012600482,
0.0649575144,
-0.7365813851,
0.1532552391,
0.1075279266,
0.3993607163,
0.681765914,
-0.1951289028,
-0.8531680107,
-0.6701651812,
0.3559193909,
0.2578270733,
-1.1100848913,
0.0297204014,
0.7191239595,
0.152733162,
0.2763235867,
0.7263257504,
-0.1093046889,
0.1893953383,
0.2426969111,
0.0099745374,
-0.136299178,
-0.568585813,
-0.062879324,
0.2488704771,
0.3551031649,
-0.1260450184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13264v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13264v2 | Prompting is not a substitute for probability measurements in large language models | 2023-05-22T17:33:17 | 2023-10-23T14:12:59 | Jennifer Hu, Roger Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompting is now a dominant method for evaluating the linguistic knowledge of
large language models (LLMs). While other methods directly read out models'
probability distributions over strings, prompting requires models to access
this internal information by processing linguistic input, thereby implicitly
testing a new type of emergent ability: metalinguistic judgment. In this study,
we compare metalinguistic prompting and direct probability measurements as ways
of measuring models' linguistic knowledge. Broadly, we find that LLMs'
metalinguistic judgments are inferior to quantities directly derived from
representations. Furthermore, consistency gets worse as the prompt query
diverges from direct measurements of next-word probabilities. Our findings
suggest that negative results relying on metalinguistic prompts cannot be taken
as conclusive evidence that an LLM lacks a particular linguistic
generalization. Our results also highlight the value that is lost with the move
to closed APIs where access to probability distributions is limited. | [
-0.2246987969,
-0.6549639106,
1.0018954277,
0.315092057,
-0.0756838173,
-0.1684907675,
-0.5182968974,
0.0128962463,
-0.1725154221,
0.1037208289,
-0.7532901168,
-0.4294904172,
-0.4407194853,
0.3824655414,
-0.1577747911,
0.7499502301,
0.3093113005,
-0.0375735275,
-0.3613721728,
0.2686739266,
-0.6081883311,
-0.2960265279,
-0.7777920365,
-0.728302598,
0.9029016495,
0.1528397053,
0.5003752708,
0.1344198585,
0.1430270374,
0.2615168691,
-0.1952477396,
-0.0292448029,
0.0543728545,
0.0277370308,
-0.4152258635,
-1.0241184235,
0.071826309,
0.2827295363,
0.4401397705,
1.0606002808,
0.0476203449,
0.1555372924,
-0.0346289948,
0.7467234135,
-0.6424301267,
0.093061693,
-0.5940942764,
0.2508491278,
-0.2152266055,
-0.4039421976,
-0.8292092681,
-0.1910854429,
0.3725530803,
-0.2195559293,
0.130410552,
-0.005007226,
0.560100615,
0.1993813962,
-0.2898520529,
-0.5187140107,
-0.6923885345,
0.6688805223,
-0.6208850145,
0.4530321062,
0.8584344387,
0.128379181,
-0.1865147948,
-0.3391088843,
-0.5450524688,
-0.8242475986,
0.2928333282,
0.1657001078,
-0.3036652505,
-0.0199346803,
0.415785104,
0.1044940278,
-0.4137792587,
0.2934300601,
-0.1643443555,
-0.1373904198,
0.3116047382,
-0.0356680155,
0.2582484782,
-0.4006199539,
-0.2011500001,
-0.3353782892,
-0.7090185285,
0.2408313453,
0.7569484115,
0.5915434361,
-0.1677018702,
0.5024908185,
0.0686794072,
0.7090004683,
0.2218625844,
0.0344415568,
0.1936086714,
-0.0752144679,
-0.1825097799,
-0.1905035079,
0.9808465242,
0.4613601565,
0.4286090136,
-0.1536021084,
0.0111864107,
0.1084194854,
-0.1488706023,
-0.2050391287,
-0.3931544721,
0.4591147006,
-0.2028317451,
-0.0611857809,
0.2378052771,
-0.4008572996,
-0.5807389617,
-0.1030726805,
0.2363032401,
-0.5102040172,
-0.4249610305,
0.1359425932,
-0.5626377463,
-0.0226416308,
0.1213022619,
-1.0663012266,
-0.1789616048,
0.7034987807,
0.9332797527,
-0.0723626167,
-0.1884081811,
-0.6060208082,
-0.318171531,
-0.6808825135,
1.0035010576,
-0.5416991711,
-0.4839403629,
-0.0237585083,
0.0287214126,
-0.081482403,
-0.8126270175,
0.6335480213,
-0.4785530567,
0.1156967431,
-0.6040571332,
-0.3515686691,
-0.3300411701,
-0.0143524511,
-0.4680437744,
0.6005042195,
-0.0697886422,
-0.6703727245,
0.8624269366,
-0.4331818819,
-0.1184834316,
0.0411258936,
-0.2106508464,
0.1148478687,
0.3620541096,
0.2293393016,
0.3848333359,
0.0160772894,
0.403812021,
-0.6691209078,
-0.2552313507,
0.6675727963,
-0.7567794323,
0.8115298748,
0.1004021615,
-0.2007318884,
-0.0831797197,
-0.42068398,
-0.108915031,
-0.2454641908,
-0.3168325126,
-0.4313846827,
0.2907091677,
-0.4361433089,
0.2174830735,
0.0431472063,
-0.4533299804,
0.0588261783,
-0.8239168525,
0.1847930998,
1.068130374,
-0.1996733248,
0.525375247,
-0.5866387486,
0.5347672701,
-0.0255208462,
-0.3221769929,
-0.0703151897,
-0.4522474706,
-0.6584015489,
-0.0141624492,
0.4643023014,
0.746604383,
-0.4659749568,
0.4871577322,
-0.1378518045,
-0.4582361579,
-0.1755961329,
0.1230650619,
0.1142805889,
0.1879944056,
-0.1672794521,
-0.067508705,
-0.4631167352,
-0.5172724724,
-0.5133655071,
-0.4494308829,
-0.3725036383,
0.3544511795,
0.242079556,
0.1084167883,
0.8741164804,
-0.0155256661,
-0.0265961867,
-0.2349329442,
0.1937946379,
0.64842695,
0.0825863704,
0.5665175319,
-0.3872196674,
-0.3540627956,
0.061238382,
-0.9101535678,
-0.3892264664,
-0.042732548,
0.1930564046,
0.1832535863,
0.32762447,
-0.6626451015,
0.2232860625,
0.7651618123,
-0.3419003785,
0.8276681304,
-0.1068913117,
0.032894101,
-0.5866793394,
0.0424394496,
-0.0532473139,
0.1081603095,
-0.5132640004,
-0.0493912064,
0.1228496209,
0.1441584975,
-0.3712061346,
0.7489511371,
-0.6469776034,
-0.1436209232,
-0.4683296382,
0.1777510047,
-0.1929544955,
-0.0593478121,
0.1136221886,
1.0127384663,
0.5840757489,
-1.207567215,
0.4718822539,
0.2649533749,
-0.5131435394,
0.4868080914,
-0.4678255916,
0.0992809907,
-0.1824225187,
0.2338998318,
-1.1235096455,
-0.3418524861,
0.2258130461,
-0.7198898196,
0.0418321975,
-0.2263620943,
-0.46743384,
-0.6709905267,
-0.2220605165,
-0.0733623132,
0.6598285437,
-0.4913890958,
0.2987340987,
-0.2441476882,
-0.463370651,
-0.6270289421,
-0.9249792695,
0.0301015135,
-0.2145123035,
-0.6368074417,
-0.3356879354,
-0.1661136448,
-0.6331726313,
-0.3797205389,
-0.0163264666,
0.2580373287,
0.023356095,
0.2148671448,
0.2125127465,
-0.1882668883,
0.5738254786,
0.031406913,
-0.1811717749,
0.5057885051,
-0.3726647794,
0.8580178022,
0.4358386695,
-0.68797791,
-0.6047344208,
0.0433728434,
0.1805561781,
-0.1650067419,
0.5801690221,
0.1190043464,
-0.0421530642,
-0.1164513752,
-0.7189577818,
-0.4640669525,
-0.4984943867,
-0.1196015477,
-0.5546569228,
-0.668435514,
0.6088469625,
-0.0892669857,
0.0642189905,
0.4797033966,
0.4523055255,
-0.2443560958,
1.0793607235,
0.192794919,
0.2086702883,
0.6602984667,
0.1371809244,
0.1054575294,
-0.8258512616,
0.0818877742,
-0.6137331724,
-0.0726578012,
-0.2356044352,
-0.1543953866,
0.2484676242,
-0.1442033499,
0.0290572066,
0.0174480043,
-0.1412272602,
0.38695997,
0.4245589375,
0.223018989,
0.3181925416,
0.2094550133,
-0.3851079047,
-0.1949950308,
-0.6814854741,
-0.6562733054,
1.1162474155,
0.1279142946,
0.7019875646,
0.0576369017,
0.547422111,
0.0807594433,
0.1067374498,
-0.9719552398,
0.4548665285,
-0.1160497218,
-0.6927481294,
-0.2059622854,
-0.7094041109,
-1.0933744907,
0.086465545,
-0.0603280701,
-0.8734174371,
0.4146096408,
0.0706725866,
-0.7010138035,
0.4892060161,
-0.6386986375,
0.3872388601,
-0.1294478923,
0.0147757446,
0.1829421371,
-0.1509141773,
0.4996790886,
-0.1143470034,
0.4673185349,
-0.4096360207,
-0.0831787959,
0.6400353909,
-0.2072772533,
0.9136226177,
-0.2558155954,
-0.5462670922,
0.2951142192,
0.2445238978,
0.5025339723,
-0.1095073372,
-0.5254109502,
-0.3525862992,
-0.2065783888,
0.006767631,
-0.8130901456,
0.4657059014,
-0.3858556747,
-0.6122784019,
-0.4846746027,
-0.6113424897,
-0.2863639593,
-0.0265377872,
0.6373742223,
0.4749568999,
-0.010490749,
0.079945907,
0.7379114032,
-0.3588594794,
0.4135083854,
0.4185914993,
-0.2795057297,
-0.1567540765,
0.7056444883,
0.4161913395,
0.5963276625,
0.0469494909,
0.5083662868,
-0.6411687732,
-0.3603638411,
-0.424359113,
0.3336174488,
-0.6928809881,
0.0365405902,
-0.6072856784,
0.2038081437,
-0.4333298504,
-0.062991783,
0.2179923654,
-0.1226294786,
-0.3602979183,
-0.4199808836,
0.5736095309,
0.6567115784,
-0.4956504703,
0.2366742045,
-0.7390943766,
-0.0793614164,
0.2817937434,
0.2566466331,
0.1894893348,
-0.8116503358,
0.2732439041,
0.1410548091,
0.0031762945,
-1.0875612497,
0.1308065653,
0.1800471097,
0.4777466655,
0.7095170617,
0.2309773564,
0.4751263559,
-0.5488370657,
0.9308979511,
0.2007179409,
-0.7512170672,
0.7262000442,
-0.6581683755,
0.6793346405,
0.5079777241,
0.4345080256,
-0.6608237028,
-0.6082302332,
-0.707342267,
-0.5176631212,
0.7037529349,
-0.3450854123,
0.5305331349,
-0.5123455524,
0.1453988552,
0.260825485,
0.1026667058,
-0.582877636,
-0.1919197887,
0.3369526863,
0.1158194318,
-0.2274328023,
-0.168846041,
-0.033413168,
-0.179697156,
0.5430344939,
-0.054126706,
0.394661516,
0.1675648093,
-0.0115561206,
-0.1348215044,
0.4442777634,
0.4713035524,
0.964681685,
0.0197072364,
0.2356425524,
0.3678862453,
-0.2245780528,
0.3557724953,
-0.1708900183,
-0.4885460138,
0.2697765827,
0.3618173897,
0.786321044,
0.2012171596,
-0.6429370642,
0.4735702872,
0.26285097,
-0.4468283951,
-0.3696372509,
0.2238725573,
0.1482427567,
0.1210570112,
0.4196854532,
-0.1244763657,
0.130258441,
-0.7967388034,
0.2460794002,
0.4901266992,
-0.4667279422,
-0.308041364,
0.5058693886,
-0.079482086,
-0.3168150187,
0.6747338772,
-0.3060133755,
-0.3124834597,
0.4488321543,
0.5822775364,
0.7302536368,
-0.336907208,
0.4567752182,
0.5012956262,
0.2985400558,
-0.189019382,
0.4875831008,
-0.0030522346,
-0.5894618034,
-0.6458005309,
-0.402305603,
-0.3628347218,
-0.0338565558,
-0.5422480702,
0.1799176782,
-0.6323004365,
-0.5687685609,
-0.1127073169,
-0.2380844802,
-0.4479206204,
0.0848025605,
-0.0081897201,
1.2116446495,
-0.8418644667,
0.1163244396,
0.4669422209,
-0.4222148955,
-0.9930209517,
-0.0956184939,
-0.0033543485,
-0.5129070282,
0.6803857684,
0.2983666956,
0.1548749208,
-0.0897174627,
-0.7115233541,
-0.5405465961,
0.5749353766,
0.5523340702,
-0.3757760525,
-0.1128032133,
-0.0986575633,
0.1770636886,
0.0897379369,
0.6090288758,
0.5196788311,
0.797121048,
0.0815725625,
-1.0858150721,
-0.0651542246,
0.0981999263,
-0.1124425083,
0.1500516981,
-0.303001374,
0.9863120914,
-0.3524876833,
-0.6800152063,
0.1352894753,
0.7261227965,
0.4249713421,
0.3020279408,
0.6976115704,
0.3615603745,
0.9867204428,
-0.2787968814,
1.0925102234,
0.2383400649,
0.0624921657,
0.8495597839,
-0.3406446576,
1.0851635933,
0.4157479703,
-0.5932863951,
0.7928856015,
0.8340064883,
0.0873327181,
0.2635925114,
0.2452817708,
-0.5457716584,
-0.4532532394,
-0.0056182505,
-0.3102510273,
0.3338886499,
0.3966195285,
-0.4166940153,
-0.4068222344,
0.2603864968,
-0.0305083282,
0.1514409035,
-0.169992581,
0.8759148717,
0.5098873973,
-0.8870509863,
0.4942547381,
-0.3084686399,
0.8428564668,
-0.6317185163,
0.3332976997,
-0.0308359191,
-0.2264456153,
-0.3500903547,
-0.9327248335,
0.198266536,
0.0761343166,
-0.2836161256,
0.0726114735,
0.4623214602,
-0.1133657545,
-0.3597579598,
0.1895274669,
0.6644169688,
0.5349042416,
-0.305437088,
-0.4360904098,
-0.1262328923,
-0.2121906579,
-0.1348905265,
0.1420205235,
0.5832193494,
0.0421674475,
0.874886632,
1.0404243469,
0.3202530444,
0.1644327343,
0.3739207089,
0.2616531849,
-0.4784267545,
-0.4685376585,
-1.0284006596,
0.2859831452,
0.1291410178,
-0.1635996997,
0.9306028485,
0.081080243,
0.640678525,
-0.2462234944,
0.9552044868,
-0.0081653129,
0.4770379364,
-0.691930294,
0.6604874134,
-0.2785319388,
0.0646311939,
-0.1473816633,
-0.8757613897,
-0.106961444,
0.7933129668,
-0.8389565349,
0.2613044977,
0.6979560852,
0.6610991359,
0.0728442892,
0.0339543968,
0.4649865031,
0.0453052372,
-0.0595502704,
0.4087194204,
1.2901098728,
-0.0022071265,
0.325211525,
0.3188481331,
-0.3969572484,
-0.0261515044,
-0.8361114264,
-1.1452549696,
-0.4284113348,
0.0292531513,
-0.2377355099,
-0.0476540476,
1.0407570601,
0.3109983206,
-0.6321014166,
-0.2542665601,
-0.1585052162,
0.1219593212,
-0.2583070993,
-0.2291981429,
0.0886531398,
-0.5879905224,
-0.6982730031,
0.571840167,
0.0119562028,
0.0846682563,
-0.4133034945,
0.0796926543,
-0.1268715858,
0.1308678836,
0.5133028626,
0.3806692064,
-0.9640683532,
-0.3092397749,
0.178539291,
0.1669314504,
-0.0685570985,
0.4509072006,
-0.7554656267,
0.3653771579,
0.7739183307,
0.3882066309,
-0.1923037022,
-0.1637845337,
0.9040656686,
-0.6014305353,
0.0713274032,
0.0615320913,
0.233417809,
0.3615417182,
-0.2646304369,
0.2186831832,
0.1702184677,
-0.4161400199,
-0.7697644234,
0.6291020513,
-0.580471158,
0.0518086106,
1.2144398689,
-0.0463955961,
-0.4145452678,
-0.1122234538,
-0.2371843904,
-0.0311464164,
-0.4633487165,
0.32759431,
1.2302271128,
0.092225045,
-0.3734973073,
-0.8551524282,
0.3253448904,
0.5026472807,
-0.3481771648,
0.2346457541,
0.3699144721,
0.3493050933,
0.2631170452,
0.7653383017,
0.0963551253,
0.4691442251,
0.1038278118,
-0.2847650945,
0.1577529013,
-0.3081443608,
-0.5593938828,
-0.0701442286,
0.2929272056,
0.1956415772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13256v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13256v2 | TaskWeb: Selecting Better Source Tasks for Multi-task NLP | 2023-05-22T17:27:57 | 2023-12-04T04:35:55 | Joongwon Kim, Akari Asai, Gabriel Ilharco, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent work in NLP has shown promising results in training models on large
amounts of tasks to achieve better generalization. However, it is not
well-understood how tasks are related, and how helpful training tasks can be
chosen for a new task. In this work, we investigate whether knowing task
relationships via pairwise task transfer improves choosing one or more source
tasks that help to learn a new target task. We provide TaskWeb, a large-scale
benchmark of pairwise task transfers for 22 NLP tasks using three different
model types, sizes, and adaptation methods, spanning about 25,000 experiments.
Then, we design a new method TaskShop based on our analysis of TaskWeb.
TaskShop uses TaskWeb to estimate the benefit of using a source task for
learning a new target task, and to choose a subset of helpful training tasks
for multi-task training. Our method improves overall rankings and top-k
precision of source tasks by 10% and 38%, respectively. We also use TaskShop to
build much smaller multi-task training sets that improve zero-shot performances
across 11 different target tasks by at least 4.3%. | [
-0.1946939826,
-0.1703170091,
0.2618601918,
0.5726277828,
-0.1385251582,
-0.1147157475,
-0.3956973553,
-0.6268115044,
0.1583172232,
0.3009417057,
-0.4375599325,
-0.1468650252,
-0.9362006783,
0.1004855111,
-0.4137375355,
1.0106645823,
0.1015634686,
-0.1765253693,
-0.496434927,
-0.1374960244,
-0.6841446757,
-0.2674769759,
-0.9266514778,
-0.4001983404,
0.4942497015,
0.5262665153,
0.3182534873,
0.1572253108,
0.7926808,
0.259454906,
0.3548904657,
0.2088692337,
-0.48706159,
0.3669801056,
-0.4944591522,
-0.4950231016,
-0.3270651102,
0.1089948118,
0.0470946282,
0.7352698445,
0.0803809166,
0.6821529865,
0.3261475861,
0.7106361985,
-0.8867996931,
0.2794840336,
-0.5893283486,
-0.0992585123,
-0.271269083,
-0.1850419492,
-0.3943124712,
0.3730246127,
0.1045755595,
-0.8594487309,
0.5081955194,
0.1465646923,
0.4484876692,
0.341340065,
-0.470482558,
0.0567298308,
-0.5344356894,
0.8385541439,
-0.3320839405,
0.6566449404,
0.7297766805,
0.1609141976,
0.018624464,
-0.6146509647,
-0.2663968205,
-0.3569872975,
-0.0386899598,
0.2000000924,
-0.2827861309,
-0.1908785999,
0.3822671473,
-0.1157406047,
-0.550940752,
-0.2176602483,
-0.2144278586,
-0.2673738301,
0.5918613672,
-0.2716196477,
0.302518338,
-0.4011902213,
-0.2334167361,
-0.2210967392,
-0.2873980701,
0.1221633032,
0.1082788259,
0.4740044475,
-0.0533493981,
0.4243907332,
-0.3496767282,
0.9933248758,
0.1902947873,
-0.3997904658,
0.2364560068,
-0.5913367271,
0.029639205,
-0.4037885368,
0.4655304551,
0.6384621859,
0.0887949318,
-0.8545742631,
0.161620751,
-0.0164110325,
0.6144955754,
-0.4154193401,
-0.4504950643,
0.2154116482,
-0.5285360813,
-0.006669533,
-0.1376172602,
-0.2345586717,
-0.1756349206,
-0.5760689974,
0.4201354384,
-0.4319299757,
-0.228830114,
-0.0917307585,
-0.6369094849,
-0.0889774486,
0.338904649,
-0.8188482523,
0.4283917248,
0.4776480794,
0.9016240239,
-0.6169508696,
-0.617985189,
-1.0569695234,
0.3802548349,
-0.1026895866,
0.9852207303,
-0.1882801354,
0.1007482782,
-0.1665015072,
-0.0808556825,
-0.2690781653,
-0.4069691896,
0.2885728478,
-0.3851241171,
-0.0825114548,
-0.5365925431,
-0.2963317037,
-0.0873803198,
0.2925269902,
-0.7510794997,
1.2070317268,
0.063467592,
-0.8312273622,
0.543561101,
-0.4269977212,
-0.9315162897,
-0.0621891133,
0.2992938161,
0.1220184639,
0.0037526514,
0.4094893336,
0.9350978732,
-0.0897084773,
0.0938457698,
-0.4116676152,
-0.0648205355,
-0.2009065598,
0.1718838364,
0.8790362477,
0.0954516158,
-0.4044865966,
0.0355862826,
-0.6121539474,
-0.0646288693,
0.039970763,
-0.1466150284,
-0.748005271,
-0.205553934,
0.1892816126,
0.5095017552,
0.1686884314,
-0.5520020723,
0.1808837652,
-0.0998429134,
0.2884930968,
0.3541190326,
-0.0971606895,
0.5911356807,
-0.570754528,
0.5170225501,
-0.2031885386,
0.0860139504,
0.3935156167,
-0.5783007145,
-0.661452949,
0.1659183353,
0.1695025712,
0.5493244529,
-1.0145391226,
0.1790708601,
-0.1093167365,
-0.5914910436,
-0.2128470391,
0.3959958553,
0.5639951229,
0.5059711933,
0.6388357878,
-0.4807662368,
-0.4620830119,
-0.7069939375,
-0.375374347,
0.0924696997,
-0.0417909548,
0.1811959147,
0.4322454333,
0.4133425951,
0.7003270388,
-0.4594203234,
-0.5350307226,
-0.3428167403,
0.1248907149,
-0.0522799678,
0.4210072756,
0.6151463389,
-0.6331446171,
-0.7399984002,
-0.2814649045,
-0.5084763765,
0.0079912078,
-0.359062314,
-0.5853813291,
-0.2363468856,
0.4181002975,
-0.6437365413,
-0.0857104361,
0.7398002744,
-0.1979059726,
0.3901292086,
-0.0134415915,
0.1466849297,
-1.4336495399,
0.3453604877,
0.3134518862,
-0.471819669,
-0.564324677,
0.1020992398,
0.2391641736,
0.1395552307,
-0.4403930902,
0.6790189147,
-0.6029739976,
-0.346228987,
-0.3366207778,
0.2704380751,
-0.0080132494,
0.8037666678,
-0.0333090052,
0.7226772904,
0.6094496846,
-0.5506597757,
0.3684287667,
0.6769223213,
-0.0431305096,
0.7937861681,
-0.2350972146,
0.4280198216,
0.2043827474,
0.2647198737,
-0.8425246477,
0.0041679838,
0.1713064313,
-0.4665893614,
0.2470893562,
-0.3057617545,
-0.3392457068,
-0.2912886143,
-0.2284677923,
0.1178176627,
0.1922602206,
-0.4963799119,
0.2051351368,
0.4088398218,
-0.1539157033,
-0.7833958268,
-0.5600072742,
0.1487263292,
0.0314203836,
-0.2768110335,
0.8570389748,
-0.017935602,
-0.0670564994,
0.0403541327,
-0.7050883174,
-0.1942935139,
0.1569810659,
0.4182976782,
0.0977706611,
0.3524465263,
0.2375757843,
0.0079198154,
-0.0587667413,
0.051127933,
-0.3738029003,
0.3006938696,
0.4891345799,
-0.2239923775,
-0.2135387361,
0.2976288497,
0.0465434827,
-0.3794996738,
0.5940873027,
0.880094409,
-0.2098822743,
-0.5477033854,
-0.5203815103,
-0.3146917224,
-0.3825792968,
0.3543693423,
-0.4147758782,
-0.7400719523,
0.0044054003,
0.0122695537,
0.2569712698,
0.3516372144,
0.2274469584,
-0.2758262753,
0.5354743004,
0.6704329252,
-0.3307795227,
0.606449306,
-0.3542524278,
-0.1002869308,
-1.1042760611,
-0.1560602784,
-0.5761032104,
-0.5623992085,
-0.1301046759,
-0.5752932429,
0.1911694258,
0.2130777985,
0.0764776692,
0.9569060802,
-0.4857386649,
0.2691907287,
1.1815727949,
0.5530766845,
0.2816441953,
0.0377804153,
0.2508300841,
0.2236694247,
-0.800660193,
0.1158512309,
1.5149371624,
-0.3855341077,
0.0823915377,
0.0296138395,
0.8633421659,
0.3719243705,
0.0825782791,
-0.7194760442,
0.5619683862,
-0.5155044198,
-0.5671772957,
-0.3184613287,
-0.2502818406,
-1.0582876205,
0.1869096011,
-0.5606229901,
-0.6435521841,
-0.0086521311,
0.3846735358,
-0.3557700813,
0.0931747779,
-0.5537189841,
0.7688103914,
-0.1453334391,
-0.5632303953,
-0.4444842935,
-0.6914536953,
0.0688858703,
0.1623593569,
0.0831522271,
-0.2605823278,
-0.0137512144,
1.11495924,
0.0367475972,
0.7278706431,
-0.2113591135,
0.293945998,
-0.0472813956,
0.1673451215,
0.586783886,
-0.1804871261,
-0.0052164369,
0.1996696442,
-0.1463672966,
-0.5243623853,
-0.5174681544,
0.5852757692,
-0.5718981624,
-0.437584132,
-0.2559280694,
-0.8192514181,
-0.8200042248,
0.3436704278,
0.2216909826,
0.4825268388,
0.1932461411,
0.3037620485,
0.1286207885,
0.2611044049,
0.5076400638,
0.1320318878,
0.3051487207,
-0.0410943404,
0.7259749174,
-0.1474889666,
0.3185292482,
0.6534334421,
-0.0595120862,
-0.1487122476,
-0.8870133758,
-0.205379948,
0.0589815639,
-0.5696626306,
-0.3941209316,
-0.6165331006,
0.149113223,
-0.6202722788,
-0.0359607972,
-0.2151224762,
-0.5810772181,
0.0148554733,
0.0277001299,
0.4029484093,
0.272406131,
-0.0718900412,
0.0747367367,
-0.8779385686,
0.7156003118,
0.6664649844,
0.2175317705,
0.0032883778,
-0.4933049083,
-0.2181707323,
-0.235442847,
-0.2263704091,
-0.9987746477,
0.2160253525,
0.2278356254,
0.8261154294,
-0.1627386659,
0.2004425675,
0.7957502604,
-0.5368155241,
0.5557905436,
0.4402683675,
-0.8552828431,
0.4390237927,
-0.3508983552,
0.3217629492,
0.7056643367,
0.602843523,
-0.5839871764,
-0.2874950767,
-0.5130317211,
-0.6621522307,
0.9732829332,
0.4193519056,
-0.0164281409,
0.1702588499,
0.3357479274,
0.1948150992,
0.3454066217,
-0.617728591,
-0.3541446924,
-0.0555566065,
-0.0296073277,
-0.2479574084,
0.2219392359,
-0.2122064382,
-0.310305953,
0.6665036678,
-0.4109075069,
0.4295636415,
0.1574666798,
-0.5191635489,
-0.162983194,
0.052817408,
0.0348230116,
0.6947960258,
0.0413754098,
0.2507680655,
0.2102171183,
-0.4565579295,
0.0182609539,
0.2871557772,
0.1773545593,
-0.1567962766,
0.8038390279,
0.8921694756,
0.485255897,
-0.396254003,
0.667538166,
0.3419586718,
-0.3459529579,
0.2468391061,
0.3176425397,
0.3463365734,
0.5462220907,
0.1569290161,
0.5417110324,
0.5496784449,
-0.3971192241,
0.2592900693,
0.5609121919,
-0.0052074147,
-0.2456120104,
0.5389012694,
0.3327077329,
-0.3475781977,
0.4819902182,
-0.3840690255,
-0.3079636991,
0.5845534205,
0.6460518837,
0.6805490851,
-0.0714400783,
0.5165237188,
0.6061074734,
0.1742648333,
-0.3415638506,
0.191253379,
-0.4852003753,
-0.7267662883,
-0.7972044349,
-0.4807195961,
-0.5244081616,
-0.0004198109,
-0.7686692476,
0.0299243778,
0.1196366847,
-0.2177815884,
0.162976265,
0.0031062874,
-0.9869235754,
0.1971053034,
0.048872035,
0.5397064686,
-0.8366541862,
0.9209704399,
0.8603160381,
-0.2996779084,
-0.9275036454,
0.0674928725,
-0.1116929352,
-0.8110617399,
0.7466110587,
0.0810370967,
0.126455009,
0.0880865231,
-0.1367820054,
-1.2439149618,
1.0677349567,
0.4989483654,
-0.7018275261,
-0.3378117085,
-0.1819179952,
0.2168547958,
0.1847364008,
0.0402415544,
0.144177869,
0.2594958246,
-0.071236819,
-1.3530374765,
0.2486799061,
-0.268268466,
-0.0610573739,
0.3242665231,
-0.499330014,
0.5202990174,
-0.228050366,
0.1732251942,
-0.3265480399,
0.3782089353,
0.1352794617,
0.291815877,
0.8579831719,
0.3682381511,
0.4071727693,
0.2169616818,
0.8189499378,
-0.2826237381,
0.1392963529,
1.4353289604,
-0.0120562157,
1.1591035128,
0.6697529554,
-0.4462066889,
0.205238685,
0.3287041187,
-0.1435584575,
0.5748438835,
-0.0089809587,
0.2420921922,
-0.452627182,
0.0907565206,
-0.0042494745,
0.4103685319,
-0.1064001098,
0.0230566263,
-0.2847647071,
0.4855763614,
-0.055075556,
-0.097567603,
-0.2659393251,
0.6868400574,
0.0716452226,
-1.1656452417,
0.2112254202,
-0.26283288,
0.8230820894,
-0.5672383308,
-0.0331333466,
-0.1176486462,
-0.0308978129,
-0.3758762181,
-0.5746101737,
0.3700000346,
-0.2000774294,
-0.0465943106,
-0.5448206067,
1.01711905,
-0.4266489446,
-0.1975956857,
0.4965468347,
0.8265895247,
-0.0527800545,
-0.6130763888,
-0.9517200589,
-0.3553329408,
-0.0086156707,
-0.2479535937,
0.718403697,
-0.2430564314,
-0.1401633918,
0.4782176316,
0.9144274592,
0.2641851008,
0.1336325556,
-0.0568306297,
0.4386462867,
-0.3740238547,
-0.3067391217,
-0.310216099,
0.2303237319,
-0.3333409727,
-0.3629184365,
0.9691440463,
0.2812917233,
1.110863924,
-0.0919455811,
0.7546491027,
-0.3784306049,
0.4462825358,
-0.3775459528,
0.3233098388,
-0.6160416007,
-0.2808781266,
-0.4165641963,
-1.0385878086,
-0.3426884115,
0.5635557771,
-0.1691713929,
0.0113363173,
1.0280152559,
0.305628866,
-0.2219955623,
-0.2266931683,
0.1611104608,
-0.2754202187,
-0.0601418652,
0.6690459847,
0.2811489403,
-0.2773432434,
0.817363143,
-1.0461283922,
-0.1202072501,
-0.0864499658,
-0.9399988651,
-0.9687202573,
-0.9485743046,
-0.5473715067,
-0.1754786819,
0.362965703,
0.8900001645,
1.2570761442,
-0.7004044056,
-0.3544194102,
-0.1361819208,
-0.3313572109,
-1.0456422567,
-0.1160403863,
0.4450482428,
-0.7198446393,
-0.6326701045,
0.4688512087,
-0.0185915586,
-0.6153228879,
0.2279006839,
0.1901914626,
-0.4591397345,
-0.5000583529,
0.7887072563,
0.070813261,
-0.4651435316,
-0.2129372358,
0.1212001666,
0.1019418687,
-0.2519319654,
0.8968093395,
-0.5807558298,
0.2656508386,
0.551948905,
0.7075235844,
0.8027973771,
-0.2515206337,
0.4075822532,
-0.9165941477,
0.1275391281,
0.0439011231,
0.4253835082,
0.2049607337,
-0.3329980373,
0.7270229459,
0.2709510028,
-0.4478918612,
-0.4840525985,
0.000142693,
-1.3933939934,
-0.5166785121,
1.3250043392,
-0.151181668,
0.0852054656,
-0.3033016026,
-0.1808656901,
0.5672052503,
-0.3598797917,
0.6486364007,
0.679782331,
-0.4525145888,
-0.0130211627,
-0.7293567061,
0.5897345543,
0.6223771572,
-1.0685584545,
-0.0518754646,
0.3925079107,
0.3999232948,
0.2505313754,
0.598297596,
0.5434564352,
0.4005415142,
-0.1376428306,
0.1105902717,
-0.3473911285,
-0.4798294306,
0.2517133355,
0.3914813697,
0.0906936452,
-0.4736241102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13252v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13252v2 | "According to ...": Prompting Language Models Improves Quoting from Pre-Training Data | 2023-05-22T17:25:24 | 2024-02-26T20:50:33 | Orion Weller, Marc Marone, Nathaniel Weir, Dawn Lawrie, Daniel Khashabi, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) may hallucinate and generate fake information,
despite pre-training on factual data. Inspired by the journalistic device of
"according to sources", we propose according-to prompting: directing LLMs to
ground responses against previously observed text. To quantify this grounding,
we propose a novel evaluation metric (QUIP-Score) that measures the extent to
which model-produced answers are directly found in underlying text corpora. We
illustrate with experiments on three corpora (Wikipedia, PubMed, and the U.S.
legal tax code) that these prompts improve grounding under our metrics, with
the additional benefit of often improving end-task performance. Furthermore,
prompts that ask the model to decrease grounding (or to ground to other
corpora) indeed decrease QUIP-Score, indicating the ability of LLMs to increase
or decrease grounded generations on request. | [
-0.2827650607,
-0.7114111781,
1.1789765358,
0.3648331761,
-0.2213873267,
-0.1239244342,
-0.2468411177,
0.0516929701,
0.0422731265,
0.3967902958,
-0.5177465081,
-0.4736680984,
-0.4029452503,
0.0659790635,
-0.4144154191,
0.9999181032,
0.3712204397,
0.2512545586,
-0.6371129751,
0.0571114607,
-0.564114213,
-0.6915598512,
-0.3848025799,
-0.3076591194,
0.8586060405,
0.4852866828,
0.7052205801,
0.3714539409,
0.1418737173,
0.2451627851,
0.073185049,
0.0101119485,
-0.4963738322,
0.1448032558,
-0.4284921288,
-0.9049600959,
-0.1415064782,
0.4761240184,
0.7032812834,
0.9333814383,
0.1019808128,
0.2523387372,
0.0577655099,
0.6727698445,
-0.5830948353,
-0.1858280897,
-0.7873702049,
-0.127927199,
0.0761831403,
-0.7933071256,
-0.6526631713,
-0.5673763156,
0.0606227703,
-0.365665555,
0.4604247212,
0.220045656,
0.8269312382,
0.1509229094,
-0.0836235583,
-0.4551555216,
-0.319455117,
0.4297382534,
-0.5778767467,
0.3461637795,
0.3568837345,
0.022665333,
-0.0254182927,
-0.6238913536,
-0.6078816652,
-0.5166950226,
-0.1972968429,
0.279502362,
-0.148034811,
-0.2003867179,
0.4552705288,
0.217773065,
-0.4263050258,
-0.1944716722,
-0.3500183523,
-0.0215066578,
0.2047002465,
-0.1532783657,
0.312794894,
-0.2387657464,
-0.1129539832,
-0.1219731793,
-1.0435355902,
0.1252816916,
0.5445722342,
0.3043031693,
0.1355558187,
0.7568261623,
-0.2986755669,
0.4266786575,
0.5154412985,
0.4143243134,
0.3168666959,
0.0988572314,
-0.297206074,
0.2237277925,
0.6098552346,
0.661385417,
0.3189532757,
-0.3799448907,
-0.202816084,
0.2202355713,
0.3118435442,
-0.5750962496,
-0.3740417957,
0.1408645213,
-0.2163723111,
-0.5519807339,
0.1255135685,
-0.5755358934,
-0.558897078,
-0.4044523537,
0.5736717582,
-0.3475066721,
-0.1002406552,
-0.0329676084,
-0.352547884,
0.1678869426,
0.2498996258,
-0.4999161065,
0.1008271575,
0.5437767506,
0.913921535,
0.114007473,
-0.2077792287,
-1.1003592014,
-0.0106865391,
-0.687900722,
1.2788815498,
-0.6899563074,
-0.4400258064,
0.0748058558,
-0.0129999695,
-0.0630978271,
-0.7270458937,
0.652793467,
-0.5391035676,
0.6694504023,
-0.8764268756,
-0.4941337705,
0.0039650803,
0.3894568384,
-0.428765893,
1.141279459,
-0.0269100554,
-0.8321542144,
0.4234079421,
-0.4961236715,
-0.127848208,
-0.0109507972,
-0.2976897061,
0.0605720654,
0.4851156771,
0.4143810272,
0.5459095836,
-0.5283733606,
0.4777000546,
-0.3292188644,
-0.2493135035,
0.2682899237,
-0.335257411,
0.7850303054,
0.0622879677,
-0.1501577944,
0.2969584465,
-0.7065506577,
0.1032618433,
0.1795738041,
-0.2410638779,
-0.4753027856,
0.0095937774,
-0.3333595395,
0.4456661046,
0.0154636968,
-0.3163115382,
0.034810774,
-0.6043538451,
0.1409070641,
0.7993836403,
0.0965358838,
0.4415499866,
-0.6913502812,
0.5419538021,
-0.0383307636,
-0.3661796153,
-0.4249618948,
-0.413218677,
-0.9738741517,
0.0801740587,
0.0426699631,
0.61297822,
-0.4903848171,
0.4953230619,
-0.4588944614,
-0.4766059816,
-0.6062908173,
-0.0226022583,
0.3329442739,
1.0079313517,
0.4065066874,
0.1683575362,
-0.4583701491,
-0.6068156362,
-0.4772117436,
-0.4817029238,
-0.3152281344,
0.1991847008,
0.1151216999,
0.2534148395,
1.0432591438,
-0.366451472,
0.2616596818,
-0.1054072306,
0.3591234088,
0.1225209981,
0.3395185769,
0.4922996759,
-0.571870923,
-0.4738872349,
-0.314678967,
-0.6656998992,
-0.6827377677,
-0.2179224193,
-0.1760299057,
-0.0553941205,
0.7311156988,
-0.6705362201,
0.1092520356,
0.2850749791,
-0.4931139052,
0.8287833333,
-0.1072863117,
0.4460994899,
-0.9260690212,
0.2014055997,
-0.2470158339,
-0.2755705714,
-0.3277653456,
0.042820964,
0.0881069824,
-0.0601581112,
-0.4036920071,
0.3949443102,
-0.3918268681,
-0.0874222815,
-0.1345244497,
0.3854811192,
0.2166435868,
0.1497537941,
0.0710452348,
1.2082829475,
0.5308889151,
-0.8039331436,
0.3144604266,
0.2499317825,
-0.286438942,
0.8498383164,
-0.809954226,
0.4052474499,
-0.3789094388,
0.124807395,
-1.2271361351,
-0.1201210842,
0.0322305523,
-0.725949049,
-0.0130579108,
-0.1541364193,
-0.5416117311,
-0.1997791231,
-0.5262605548,
-0.0902286619,
0.6207229495,
-0.6244721413,
0.37595281,
0.114254199,
-0.2085476965,
-0.3512626886,
-0.5241925716,
0.1568210572,
-0.4581799805,
-0.6171809435,
0.2812862396,
-0.3906897604,
-0.3494397402,
-0.0816458166,
-0.0722995177,
0.2435459644,
-0.0799461752,
0.2667326629,
0.1833860427,
-0.561735034,
0.4254290462,
-0.0122123836,
0.0555647053,
0.7342893481,
-0.2712562084,
0.7873756886,
0.0042473841,
-0.254691422,
-0.2873220444,
0.272361815,
0.2489206046,
-0.0577725992,
0.8115538359,
0.0774786398,
-0.0490389988,
-0.197786212,
-0.8578504324,
-0.2605254948,
-0.4912568629,
0.0455568098,
-0.5248458982,
-0.5998029709,
0.291424334,
-0.3051966727,
-0.1733720005,
0.6909803152,
0.6170355678,
-0.255980283,
1.0915207863,
0.5228722692,
-0.0654415339,
0.2765258849,
0.1011755466,
0.1016646996,
-0.5583613515,
-0.313646853,
-0.7696073055,
0.1328025609,
-0.2181789279,
-0.3930239677,
0.1502443105,
0.4192282259,
-0.0762258545,
0.007093132,
-0.3964370787,
0.6492334604,
0.4481116235,
0.0221946277,
0.1002787873,
0.0353046618,
-0.3879657984,
0.0282129701,
-0.7680537701,
-0.8148121834,
1.0197886229,
0.2494192421,
0.3902206421,
-0.0982858911,
0.4525912106,
0.2735680342,
0.4477149844,
-0.7067340612,
0.5636190772,
0.3076912761,
-0.5112675428,
-0.0723767877,
-0.3624695837,
-0.5453799963,
0.0347067118,
-0.1430613399,
-0.5540514588,
0.0058279806,
0.1764484346,
-0.487444818,
-0.1275749058,
-0.6536262035,
0.6576211452,
-0.0082142372,
-0.2209509909,
-0.2935687006,
-0.533169508,
0.2199688852,
-0.1182436943,
0.1313359588,
-0.1968221366,
-0.055499658,
0.76936692,
-0.2464511991,
0.6728289127,
-0.2200467139,
-0.0499096103,
0.4463687837,
-0.046095904,
0.4417956173,
0.2184998989,
-0.2817656398,
-0.2879371941,
-0.1101576835,
-0.2452514619,
-0.8812112808,
0.8085054159,
-0.5172355175,
-0.830529213,
-0.335588038,
-0.3922459185,
-0.5270872712,
0.0415608399,
0.665589869,
0.2271272987,
-0.2628023326,
0.2490891218,
0.8703845739,
-0.3554520011,
0.2218783349,
0.6379378438,
-0.2139267027,
-0.1854875833,
0.5627891421,
-0.0343584977,
0.309987694,
0.3757744431,
0.5228164792,
-0.580955565,
-0.2246120572,
-0.3063235581,
0.3182709515,
-1.0448396206,
-0.2616682351,
-0.830840826,
-0.1142447889,
-0.7039977908,
-0.2355953008,
0.0490289405,
-0.254193604,
-0.4689268172,
-0.3969486952,
0.3339648247,
0.4687355459,
0.0079838093,
0.4239689112,
-0.843909502,
0.2578612864,
0.3037260771,
0.1350298226,
-0.1879997253,
-1.0756657124,
0.179330036,
0.0532480106,
-0.0479772277,
-1.0371608734,
0.1098976508,
0.1348447651,
0.6272757053,
0.2024099082,
0.2809619904,
0.943661809,
-0.8897171617,
0.7821614146,
0.2623155117,
-1.0454990864,
0.6923558712,
-0.4477748275,
0.3562485874,
0.5946077704,
0.5896182656,
-0.6046292186,
-0.670178771,
-0.7667503357,
-0.5076363683,
0.4925617874,
-0.0515197441,
0.7155916691,
-0.3164477944,
0.3409917355,
-0.0823707581,
0.3191476166,
-0.7327959538,
0.0013902734,
-0.180158928,
-0.1372144371,
-0.0256896801,
-0.5169068575,
-0.0610978156,
-0.2076174319,
0.712808907,
-0.1149658561,
0.1341820061,
0.311055541,
-0.2861408591,
-0.3078106344,
0.1901462227,
0.5075048804,
0.8105162382,
-0.0819883645,
0.2917732894,
0.1239720061,
-0.2094026953,
0.0127217574,
-0.1583292931,
-0.2927136421,
0.1518477052,
0.3008726239,
0.5743200183,
0.1367248297,
-0.6962044835,
0.5937814713,
0.29816553,
-0.043816328,
-0.2555539906,
0.2265225649,
0.1526285261,
0.2453385293,
0.5639731884,
-0.1094264686,
0.0649218559,
-0.7484026551,
0.4976904988,
0.237276271,
-0.4016390145,
-0.4213213623,
0.5848374367,
0.0320434906,
-0.2990108728,
0.4282811284,
-0.0784402266,
-0.5874590278,
0.3057641089,
0.7208378315,
0.7046310902,
-0.4127562344,
0.4063067138,
0.4412218332,
0.2930760682,
-0.3215386868,
0.2474647313,
0.083133705,
-0.7250165343,
-0.5036526322,
-0.4601174593,
-0.098512046,
0.4152457118,
-0.6118818521,
0.4772803187,
-0.6807087064,
0.0132498601,
0.1454168111,
-0.1714513302,
-0.5682473779,
0.5714333057,
0.2062306851,
0.9316773415,
-1.0010666847,
0.792978406,
0.7494434118,
-0.7155573964,
-0.8475452065,
0.3201962411,
-0.1321735978,
-0.665402472,
0.640871942,
0.4728326499,
-0.2498372942,
0.1049505845,
-0.9353256822,
-0.6341285706,
0.5594832897,
0.6252629161,
-0.4494477808,
-0.1635127068,
-0.038977176,
0.3736267388,
-0.4637666941,
0.3101195693,
0.5644314885,
0.3857025206,
0.0526174121,
-0.5293921232,
0.1905178577,
-0.3034357131,
-0.2418631166,
-0.112295866,
-0.2381011248,
0.7631419301,
-0.109431833,
-0.2663296461,
-0.0447007343,
0.7457286716,
0.381172061,
0.4245934486,
0.6350377798,
0.3311065733,
0.9383572936,
0.0929881558,
0.8057911992,
-0.1524257362,
-0.0095981769,
1.2276966572,
-0.2626964748,
0.8079797029,
0.6127792597,
-0.0716461018,
0.6522243619,
0.5017986298,
-0.0157680791,
0.6186527014,
0.1878199875,
-0.1219298765,
-0.1634343266,
-0.1766764969,
-0.2264653444,
0.0947512165,
0.2784112394,
-0.3681457639,
-0.2952399552,
-0.0536275506,
0.1048366949,
0.5900011063,
-0.2895011306,
0.5935553312,
0.0501686931,
-0.9582439065,
0.6176653504,
-0.0994971395,
0.410291642,
-0.4242888689,
0.0169525221,
-0.2967452109,
-0.3718169928,
-0.1832762808,
-0.6620346904,
0.3388677835,
0.2690241933,
-0.4481574893,
-0.1916008592,
0.4628294408,
-0.3838182688,
-0.37736094,
0.2142694443,
0.53932482,
0.3286361098,
-0.5865852833,
-0.6913841963,
-0.1804358661,
-0.1510048211,
-0.4424316287,
0.1714060903,
0.776856482,
-0.0831224546,
0.5024323463,
0.9203863144,
0.0532026887,
0.1220631599,
0.3423888385,
1.0523860455,
-0.7023736835,
-0.6207762361,
-0.811175406,
0.5877048373,
-0.3562231064,
-0.3939391673,
0.9228788614,
0.5991474986,
0.7213385105,
-0.0708759204,
0.6671812534,
-0.0354656801,
0.8612981439,
-0.8629078865,
0.7138659954,
-0.4951741695,
0.4383390546,
-0.2705559134,
-1.1343182325,
-0.1671501845,
0.6773364544,
-0.5654184222,
-0.0649932772,
0.8767105937,
0.7855495811,
-0.0188681539,
-0.194016844,
0.5693410039,
0.1579091698,
0.155865863,
0.0734579116,
1.0766824484,
-0.1176416501,
0.3550460339,
0.0295695495,
-0.0477116145,
-0.1177292764,
-0.9453520775,
-1.0773909092,
-0.5382419825,
-0.2354934365,
-0.4750882089,
0.063064158,
0.9533961415,
0.3775748909,
-0.8651105165,
-0.0181752034,
-0.3050762415,
-0.1681132764,
0.0646749511,
-0.1833033115,
0.4061287344,
-0.920845449,
-0.4572599232,
0.7093061209,
0.0365018323,
-0.1366770118,
-0.1994470805,
0.0027473827,
-0.2202593535,
0.4336372614,
0.4174710214,
-0.0225958079,
-0.7299971581,
-0.4112119675,
0.1494584084,
-0.2931221426,
0.2125670612,
0.9669782519,
-1.143730402,
0.2100990862,
0.5401635766,
0.5070987344,
0.0046376684,
0.350656569,
0.80907166,
-0.8623143435,
0.3875956535,
0.4204239249,
0.1078956947,
0.580739677,
-0.5590885282,
0.4016122818,
0.2623055577,
-0.3528751135,
-0.9542815685,
-0.014284418,
-0.5286614299,
-0.3096489012,
1.1385897398,
-0.2461428195,
-0.1321441233,
0.0275527667,
-0.1532040536,
0.2606855929,
-0.2658116519,
0.9007235169,
0.9459844828,
0.4841062129,
-0.3094235659,
-0.6330766082,
0.68658638,
0.7760357857,
-0.8098282218,
0.0365019217,
0.7144383788,
0.4017149806,
0.2174527645,
0.7654500604,
0.0435703509,
0.3196849823,
-0.027606206,
-0.2830048203,
0.1335643977,
-0.5329098105,
-0.3623669147,
0.190104261,
0.1677462459,
0.0314303525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13246v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13246v1 | Interactive Natural Language Processing | 2023-05-22T17:18:29 | 2023-05-22T17:18:29 | Zekun Wang, Ge Zhang, Kexin Yang, Ning Shi, Wangchunshu Zhou, Shaochun Hao, Guangzheng Xiong, Yizhi Li, Mong Yuan Sim, Xiuying Chen, Qingqing Zhu, Zhenzhu Yang, Adam Nik, Qi Liu, Chenghua Lin, Shi Wang, Ruibo Liu, Wenhu Chen, Ke Xu, Dayiheng Liu, Yike Guo, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Interactive Natural Language Processing (iNLP) has emerged as a novel
paradigm within the field of NLP, aimed at addressing limitations in existing
frameworks while aligning with the ultimate goals of artificial intelligence.
This paradigm considers language models as agents capable of observing, acting,
and receiving feedback iteratively from external entities. Specifically,
language models in this context can: (1) interact with humans for better
understanding and addressing user needs, personalizing responses, aligning with
human values, and improving the overall user experience; (2) interact with
knowledge bases for enriching language representations with factual knowledge,
enhancing the contextual relevance of responses, and dynamically leveraging
external information to generate more accurate and informed responses; (3)
interact with models and tools for effectively decomposing and addressing
complex tasks, leveraging specialized expertise for specific subtasks, and
fostering the simulation of social behaviors; and (4) interact with
environments for learning grounded representations of language, and effectively
tackling embodied tasks such as reasoning, planning, and decision-making in
response to environmental observations. This paper offers a comprehensive
survey of iNLP, starting by proposing a unified definition and framework of the
concept. We then provide a systematic classification of iNLP, dissecting its
various components, including interactive objects, interaction interfaces, and
interaction methods. We proceed to delve into the evaluation methodologies used
in the field, explore its diverse applications, scrutinize its ethical and
safety issues, and discuss prospective research directions. This survey serves
as an entry point for researchers who are interested in this rapidly evolving
area and offers a broad view of the current landscape and future trajectory of
iNLP. | [
-0.6023544073,
-0.9318706393,
0.7239625454,
0.2409567386,
0.1866494268,
0.4027417302,
-0.3464909494,
-1.0283637047,
-0.2885902226,
0.446523428,
-0.3970873654,
-0.1499782801,
-0.3829542994,
0.0718152225,
-0.2701988518,
0.646689415,
0.2263186723,
0.0885535702,
-0.2388716787,
-0.0624820702,
-0.3061529696,
-0.5844904184,
-0.8678186536,
-0.501814425,
0.065021202,
0.3032719493,
0.8720577359,
0.19588615,
0.507621944,
0.4098674059,
-0.3110080659,
0.2683747113,
-0.1327064484,
0.2911947072,
-0.2486903816,
-0.1135400906,
-0.3440032005,
0.0827068165,
0.6980195642,
1.0345003605,
-0.0351838768,
0.0999824032,
0.3009439707,
0.5193662643,
-0.3773465455,
0.3012323976,
-0.2781438828,
0.2183974236,
-0.2904994488,
-0.2515129745,
-0.4572899938,
-0.2253514379,
0.2078468353,
-0.4401715696,
-0.207805872,
0.2801178992,
0.4438820183,
0.3040225506,
-0.1979923099,
-0.6801553369,
-0.9134620428,
0.6675575972,
-1.0850659609,
0.5178667903,
0.4948711693,
0.2522293627,
-0.5540183187,
-0.7828888297,
-0.8715468049,
-0.5317676663,
-0.1677963287,
0.0394464806,
-0.2071505338,
0.4691399932,
0.3683786094,
0.4631038904,
-0.4180853665,
0.3262969255,
-0.0815668851,
0.2636595666,
0.6489828825,
0.3669595122,
0.6207751632,
-0.1554671377,
-0.177226752,
0.1551026702,
-0.3342365623,
0.6186157465,
0.5406997204,
0.4604341686,
-0.035123162,
0.6228035092,
-0.1813770682,
1.0007288456,
0.0395521745,
-0.0064132498,
-0.1158735454,
-0.4462202787,
-0.3900693357,
-0.0584750548,
0.7657059431,
0.2338277847,
-0.107233502,
-0.0821073353,
-0.2053520679,
-0.2244198918,
0.3177366257,
-0.2743397057,
-0.1440659165,
0.2284435481,
-0.4706854522,
-0.2357326746,
0.0158283617,
-0.9560080171,
-0.4151237309,
-0.7582598329,
0.0731657594,
-0.3210243583,
-0.2133473009,
0.1279519945,
-0.0443440638,
0.1310759485,
0.4729461372,
-0.8757625222,
0.8955855966,
0.7054047585,
0.7007057071,
-0.1870588958,
-0.1111379489,
-0.4254163802,
0.2283213586,
0.0223795623,
0.8062106967,
-1.0324190855,
-0.3043346107,
0.0133892363,
-0.3020368516,
-0.1303563714,
-0.4840682149,
0.4959900081,
-0.5621548295,
0.4572686851,
-0.1804843247,
-0.8273226023,
-0.4525954127,
0.2803224325,
-0.5340332985,
1.1653603315,
0.0604130141,
-0.7161699533,
0.3613420427,
-1.2122286558,
-0.1690781862,
0.4122874737,
-0.0391169302,
0.0975658372,
-0.2016682923,
-0.0282344259,
0.2401458174,
-0.3087880015,
0.2284329683,
-0.2669854164,
-0.2161910683,
0.1253081709,
-0.0025528811,
0.9304368496,
0.2595216036,
-0.2017974406,
0.4407471418,
-0.704595983,
0.1093783379,
-0.2465055883,
-0.6296234727,
-0.2767249644,
0.144807741,
0.3865773082,
0.2496948242,
-0.0258317459,
-0.5601246953,
0.1244392619,
-0.5001302958,
0.4078193903,
0.557420969,
0.0983139649,
0.762439549,
-0.1129550934,
0.5094915628,
-0.548620224,
0.3361715972,
-0.1633522063,
-0.7553450465,
-0.4992187619,
-0.1212062612,
-0.1866119802,
0.4664160311,
-0.5747352242,
0.361866653,
0.1120002046,
-0.4547361434,
-0.5659970045,
0.0121163623,
0.2073832303,
0.6419302225,
0.3129729629,
-0.1726629287,
-0.5294454694,
-0.4618637264,
-0.3999608457,
-0.4087649882,
-0.1149829403,
0.0970098898,
0.3066305518,
-0.1538818479,
1.1471623182,
-0.1068728715,
-0.2390400171,
-0.5065012574,
0.2675957978,
0.2669098973,
0.3997061551,
0.4061214924,
-0.8596369624,
-0.7610430717,
0.3249494135,
-0.8876303434,
0.0068620658,
0.1062691659,
0.2136460394,
0.1133286804,
0.5921413302,
-0.6099444628,
0.3365689218,
0.2802801728,
-0.3295497298,
0.2054187655,
-0.2521912754,
0.0605547614,
-0.3400864601,
0.1693651229,
-0.1175709739,
-0.2670339644,
-1.0773496628,
0.4344321787,
-0.3303286135,
-0.1747854352,
-0.4706538618,
0.7839987278,
-0.4118114412,
0.0044781421,
-0.3883931637,
-0.0955011919,
-0.1734286994,
0.3747078478,
0.1871072501,
0.3318218887,
0.3262521923,
-0.6073028445,
0.4236729145,
0.2133747339,
-0.2659319937,
0.2943124175,
-0.4560154676,
0.4249947965,
-0.3819533587,
0.0597318411,
-0.7896333933,
-0.3764075637,
0.5843392611,
-0.2719091177,
0.3365544677,
-0.051406078,
-0.9079540968,
-0.1514490396,
-0.2359717786,
0.0806565508,
0.2419860512,
-0.2500307262,
0.7597695589,
0.882489562,
-0.3076702356,
-0.0349142961,
-0.4353198111,
0.1941428185,
-0.2912423611,
-0.5126065016,
0.1613033563,
-0.2118114382,
-0.8173470497,
0.0906395614,
0.2916931212,
-0.2221222818,
-0.0139784757,
0.2700845003,
0.0654672161,
0.1686707437,
0.0934882388,
-0.2769115865,
-0.0181737915,
0.195159778,
0.180940479,
0.5423407555,
-0.4433135092,
-0.4235441089,
-0.3010115027,
0.4930186272,
0.4821739793,
-0.2028450072,
0.5420693755,
0.414821595,
-0.6224893332,
0.0696776509,
-0.2668657005,
0.0429493263,
-0.4565514922,
-0.0305406395,
0.0500439331,
-0.7512833476,
0.286097616,
-0.0155651579,
0.3616235256,
-0.0383164771,
0.4630299211,
-0.5251528025,
0.9712699056,
1.0320276022,
0.192282334,
0.4523764849,
0.0138837779,
0.6270949841,
-0.8480370045,
-0.5190985799,
-0.4107774794,
-0.129266724,
-0.4631027281,
-0.3508237302,
0.2751788497,
-0.1521483362,
-0.3693875074,
0.1294639707,
-0.4233115911,
0.2083415389,
0.4898064137,
-0.1553294361,
0.4487080574,
-0.3612363636,
0.0491443425,
-0.201194182,
-0.5397627354,
-0.9372515082,
0.6048125625,
0.5901511312,
0.6387522817,
0.0588731803,
0.2028515935,
0.4522402883,
0.4028143585,
-0.8048880696,
0.6646103263,
0.2832550406,
-0.5011492968,
-0.47505638,
0.0866178125,
-0.7301774025,
0.2501674592,
-0.3508979082,
-1.0009276867,
-0.0392881632,
0.1722631007,
-0.4760216177,
0.502696991,
-0.4929824769,
0.5799004436,
-0.3408347964,
-0.499188602,
-0.2265407741,
-0.8730185032,
0.3793251216,
0.0386881232,
0.5396648049,
-0.1421648264,
0.0131668476,
0.3622891307,
-0.1652741581,
0.8290944099,
-0.2214350998,
0.0402360559,
0.2184644938,
-0.0363395587,
0.2958052456,
0.0022903094,
-0.3349167109,
0.0862606093,
-0.0280277189,
0.0772006139,
-0.525564611,
0.3761296868,
-0.411236912,
-0.3693930209,
-0.7232690454,
-0.6439866424,
-0.3494689167,
0.1953400224,
0.0514150709,
-0.0103512099,
-0.2240180969,
-0.1745683104,
0.6201467514,
-0.3558179736,
0.7828142643,
0.5421087146,
-0.5720565319,
-0.036493022,
0.5491039157,
-0.0415470935,
0.183158353,
0.5363307595,
0.2116426229,
-0.373824507,
-0.6512213945,
-0.112687327,
-0.0280814692,
-0.8482662439,
0.0831884742,
-0.9711855054,
-0.2989632487,
-0.0935137719,
-0.1561656147,
-0.1142379269,
0.0345082022,
-0.1926194131,
-0.1321287602,
0.176334843,
1.1590795517,
0.1248793676,
0.2026588023,
-0.6778910756,
0.3049979806,
0.1603394002,
0.33032763,
0.1640097499,
-0.1875549406,
-0.1178755313,
0.0241434705,
-0.1856780201,
-0.8213281631,
0.4190867543,
0.320725143,
0.9117652774,
0.3517152667,
0.0628742352,
0.6603043675,
-0.3713001311,
0.8101553321,
-0.1502943635,
-0.8946917057,
0.4815976322,
-0.3047325313,
0.2557532191,
0.529075563,
0.4146054685,
-0.6924539208,
-0.6020180583,
-0.4901117682,
-1.0015853643,
0.6877340674,
0.25658077,
0.035007026,
0.0747025385,
-0.0034658322,
0.2605352104,
0.3481779993,
-0.7607280016,
-0.0127488691,
0.1291216463,
0.1140258536,
0.2975811362,
-0.1065459028,
-0.0183695331,
-0.5214757323,
0.4720723927,
-0.1341838241,
0.0712918788,
-0.0699441284,
-0.2032095492,
-0.3832000494,
0.1522156596,
0.2246385366,
0.676843226,
-0.3389899135,
0.1619534642,
0.2097127438,
-0.2027404308,
-0.1451171935,
0.0048289723,
-0.2556519806,
-0.1120406389,
0.4430469573,
0.4484824836,
0.4270885885,
-1.001761198,
0.1804449111,
-0.2257807702,
0.5692018867,
-0.5504956841,
-0.0327445641,
0.0210809484,
0.1878879219,
0.3708079755,
0.3734773695,
0.604603529,
-0.9663669467,
0.0116744693,
0.5094889998,
-0.5264576674,
-0.376278162,
0.6912510991,
0.1422977746,
-0.4278625548,
0.8513535261,
-0.1987820417,
-0.2056986094,
0.2809685171,
0.2920086086,
0.8135914803,
-0.0393249355,
-0.0623297058,
0.364410609,
0.2473890334,
0.2835240066,
0.430437088,
-0.2151674628,
-0.7320960164,
-0.3407342434,
-0.7683389187,
-0.6822457314,
0.1914697886,
-0.6077139974,
0.129012078,
-0.5340521932,
-0.1792979389,
0.0982442573,
-0.1510433406,
-0.6752071381,
0.0891388208,
0.4543791115,
0.9591242671,
-0.767267406,
0.7021589875,
1.1298048496,
-0.463180244,
-0.3345580101,
0.1491108835,
0.2036244422,
-0.2200535387,
0.5939804316,
0.2176611871,
-0.11098703,
-0.2237603664,
-0.5758203268,
-0.8854632378,
0.6130999923,
0.3428344727,
-0.021660028,
0.0377602652,
0.2716356218,
0.8312240243,
-0.2633925974,
0.4191392958,
0.7779821157,
0.7806383967,
-0.26676175,
-1.1478419304,
-0.0885696635,
-0.6290509105,
0.0816057101,
-0.0341004953,
-0.3918109834,
0.5429513454,
-0.0227145161,
-0.4206129014,
-0.1076163948,
0.5834835172,
0.3277761936,
0.314493984,
0.5279713273,
0.3633015454,
0.7762998939,
-0.0500890948,
1.1627801657,
-0.0900304615,
-0.0142801227,
1.1334283352,
-0.4205112457,
0.8225533366,
0.74061203,
-0.4508387744,
0.3272290826,
0.7705727816,
0.213208586,
0.458563298,
-0.029367324,
-0.4363233745,
0.0295527335,
-0.501188159,
0.0361008234,
0.4808490276,
0.5710847378,
0.1186467633,
-0.3507530093,
0.1927501857,
-0.1341695637,
0.5036472082,
-0.2621122301,
0.8426123857,
0.0171937812,
-0.6558443308,
-0.2923607826,
-0.0843548328,
0.5395776629,
-0.7348521948,
-0.6014754772,
0.1793716103,
-0.0936038569,
-0.4206834733,
-1.3527810574,
0.6157982945,
-0.0139187109,
-0.1520106345,
-0.7792690992,
0.7903945446,
-0.2259853035,
-0.0652487054,
0.5656334758,
0.3106544316,
0.1186746061,
-0.0132336812,
-0.5248195529,
0.1910517216,
-0.166960001,
-0.2771550417,
0.3268432021,
0.1366590261,
-0.2295351028,
1.0733759403,
0.8513926268,
0.0958121791,
0.3867434263,
-0.0289159622,
0.9194655418,
-0.572558403,
-0.5291060805,
-0.6776612997,
0.7156874537,
-0.13797988,
-0.0889547616,
0.7594829202,
0.5130243301,
1.0637928247,
-0.0474976338,
0.9721974134,
-0.4629252851,
0.5017761588,
-0.4394592941,
0.525290072,
-0.1705447584,
0.3038926125,
-0.3423364162,
-0.7848466039,
-0.3493304253,
0.5794188976,
-0.1097371727,
-0.0801445022,
0.3342801034,
0.320243001,
-0.0444960594,
0.0950971916,
0.0752691627,
-0.1172652021,
0.5352450609,
-0.0829364806,
1.0495188236,
0.0293981712,
-0.0627696589,
-0.5375585556,
-0.1810222119,
-0.0992252976,
-1.0741131306,
-0.6462127566,
-0.5465145707,
-0.1038925573,
0.2776443362,
-0.161495164,
1.3716757298,
0.5590820909,
-0.8019414544,
-0.6050916314,
-0.1886873692,
0.0166783798,
-0.3884471059,
-0.3244334459,
0.0099639902,
-0.5698676109,
-0.998131454,
0.8103557229,
0.77399683,
-0.0926641151,
-0.2053788602,
-0.17240569,
-0.4351783097,
-0.2742145061,
0.7271846533,
0.6932193637,
-0.8254913092,
-0.0678019151,
-0.0987060517,
0.1126471981,
0.0836012736,
0.6914455295,
-0.6870267987,
0.9479962587,
0.5895200968,
0.5784652233,
0.2520892024,
-0.1165512577,
0.8111115098,
-0.4524821341,
0.1931298226,
0.7177296877,
0.3718197942,
0.5428632498,
-0.565778017,
0.5942671895,
-0.2188358456,
-0.5532978177,
-0.9455072284,
0.2073387504,
-0.8958877921,
-0.1461095363,
0.8693087101,
-0.0041219415,
0.159417063,
-0.6387138367,
-0.275544107,
0.1726817787,
-0.3589345515,
0.5521013141,
0.6691104174,
-0.9737855792,
-0.4370378256,
-0.8831321597,
0.787324965,
-0.1445043087,
-0.9549976587,
-0.0650347695,
0.2628885508,
0.0751451254,
0.1837946326,
0.7618664503,
-0.1098482683,
-0.0520637482,
-0.3857111037,
0.201467678,
0.063623637,
-0.1422823966,
-0.4136767387,
0.1126084477,
0.3663926125,
0.1848885119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13245v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13245v3 | GQA: Training Generalized Multi-Query Transformer Models from Multi-Head Checkpoints | 2023-05-22T17:16:38 | 2023-12-23T17:55:11 | Joshua Ainslie, James Lee-Thorp, Michiel de Jong, Yury Zemlyanskiy, Federico Lebrón, Sumit Sanghai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Multi-query attention (MQA), which only uses a single key-value head,
drastically speeds up decoder inference. However, MQA can lead to quality
degradation, and moreover it may not be desirable to train a separate model
just for faster inference. We (1) propose a recipe for uptraining existing
multi-head language model checkpoints into models with MQA using 5% of original
pre-training compute, and (2) introduce grouped-query attention (GQA), a
generalization of multi-query attention which uses an intermediate (more than
one, less than number of query heads) number of key-value heads. We show that
uptrained GQA achieves quality close to multi-head attention with comparable
speed to MQA. | [
-0.5006366968,
-0.2990855873,
0.5795010328,
0.0122140739,
-0.2111775726,
0.1139347479,
0.1992850751,
-0.1858868748,
0.2319533378,
0.675149858,
-0.8999533057,
-0.1632696688,
-0.6647538543,
-0.1506611407,
-0.5495817661,
0.8200843334,
0.5041541457,
0.2514479756,
0.1358211488,
-0.4327226877,
-0.3762364686,
-0.8966156244,
-0.8151642084,
-0.1162839606,
0.6797065735,
0.1015726626,
0.8358466625,
0.4576668739,
0.3727337122,
0.2871241868,
-0.080884479,
0.0718945935,
-0.5074622631,
0.1445926279,
-0.1046484634,
-0.5467548966,
-0.3976215124,
-0.0221383944,
0.7136829495,
0.652477324,
-0.0481131189,
0.1134908199,
0.0495011248,
0.9176061153,
-0.7711057067,
-0.0319690816,
-0.8762980103,
-0.0843342021,
0.022132773,
0.0549109839,
-0.5690510273,
-0.2374106348,
0.0795325488,
-0.6341084242,
0.604567647,
0.0297546685,
0.8656640649,
0.4493689835,
-0.6882721186,
0.0377393477,
-0.5415946245,
1.0708810091,
-0.3250990212,
0.784314394,
0.1790188402,
0.6402871609,
-0.0684166253,
-1.0321934223,
-0.5233922601,
0.0189027861,
-0.0633424595,
0.217352435,
-0.1591096073,
0.2239400446,
0.288318634,
0.6152245998,
-0.390655607,
-0.3272773027,
-0.2353833318,
-0.1816814244,
0.3340446949,
0.3644917607,
0.1607859433,
0.1779373139,
-0.2109451145,
-0.2391208708,
-0.7996801138,
0.2573349178,
0.078634955,
0.3033862114,
0.3988351822,
0.2139383256,
-0.632756114,
0.8907145858,
0.4927634001,
-0.282351017,
0.152221486,
-0.7177790403,
-0.2961016595,
-0.419762522,
0.5912783742,
0.1691534072,
0.1477552503,
-0.5705586076,
0.0468072779,
0.069880046,
0.711677134,
-0.9069900513,
-0.2656699121,
0.4073835313,
-0.3048941791,
-0.0150985364,
-0.0809404403,
-0.6350429058,
0.2929884791,
-0.5796505213,
0.6772733927,
-0.1938307136,
0.1375144869,
0.1910436153,
-0.3140496612,
0.4940275848,
0.3147730529,
-1.1627140045,
0.1829298586,
0.4576538205,
0.7386340499,
-0.0306379627,
-0.488491565,
-0.8221124411,
0.2579975426,
-0.2376506478,
0.8657103181,
-0.5946426988,
-0.1337399334,
-0.255512327,
0.2698400915,
-0.5808085203,
-0.4390221536,
0.5699375272,
-0.9574590325,
0.30079934,
-0.5563845038,
-0.1769210249,
-0.3577415049,
0.2145995647,
-0.7822383642,
0.9052394629,
0.3987725079,
-0.6212430596,
0.6001055241,
-0.4178414643,
-0.3858945966,
-0.1069415361,
-0.2422103435,
-0.2643428743,
0.1287806034,
0.8386976123,
0.3017909825,
-0.4030192196,
0.1282976717,
-0.1508070081,
-0.5748960376,
-0.1029191315,
-0.1800145507,
0.7811594605,
0.0280815233,
-0.3081607819,
0.2776485682,
-0.5819256306,
0.3869661093,
-0.1768525988,
-0.6946683526,
-0.0736477301,
-0.0004820194,
-0.2263011932,
0.4013547897,
-0.2963368297,
-0.2428106368,
0.3673601151,
-0.4390813708,
0.6168106198,
0.3840728998,
0.1162464842,
0.44316414,
-0.4198167026,
0.4970973134,
0.1175120547,
0.1597423702,
-0.3283167183,
-0.5474476218,
-1.1372416019,
-0.455514431,
0.4049335718,
0.3148537874,
-0.9289309978,
0.3090534508,
-0.3360540569,
-0.4103360474,
-0.7941531539,
-0.1782462299,
0.5219699144,
0.3562903404,
0.6992874742,
-0.4931927025,
-0.1866367906,
-0.8858283758,
-0.5303370953,
0.0673103109,
-0.5875077844,
0.1496480107,
0.4277202487,
-0.241818279,
0.6814807057,
-0.4204236269,
-0.3624570966,
-0.1813255697,
0.1605601162,
0.1967000067,
0.3059614003,
0.5409715772,
-0.7382058501,
-0.3462088406,
-0.4263118505,
-0.4162092209,
0.3050663173,
-0.1442078054,
-0.5416973233,
-0.2357429117,
0.5715289116,
-0.6649891138,
0.1860280931,
0.6065103412,
-0.0708939731,
0.6562827229,
0.1988767236,
0.5723059773,
-1.0274649858,
-0.1113676727,
-0.2424630225,
-0.1120575219,
-0.9225218296,
0.4570519626,
0.353923589,
-0.1151658595,
-0.6544828415,
0.3274374306,
-0.6344134212,
-0.1016837582,
-0.3025056124,
-0.3504625261,
0.3372629285,
1.0665792227,
-0.0413380042,
1.0220553875,
0.7209476829,
-1.034129858,
0.1718147695,
0.3261325955,
-0.2306576818,
0.6427509189,
-0.810565412,
0.5833532214,
-0.029762648,
0.3436707556,
-1.1028198004,
-0.4535951912,
0.121866487,
-0.42228356,
0.2934375107,
-0.5234878659,
-0.2645793259,
-0.4213791788,
-0.3850424588,
0.6627243161,
0.1537633538,
-0.8356954455,
0.9120011926,
0.3559720218,
0.1908421665,
-0.7324130535,
-0.7827020288,
-0.129540205,
-0.282738179,
-0.6337940693,
0.5240316987,
0.1352555007,
0.323859334,
-0.1742202193,
-0.1470074803,
-0.4770203531,
-0.1129656956,
-0.0080426298,
-0.2706629932,
-0.1956786662,
0.2186511457,
0.1664974689,
-0.1628054678,
0.0122505194,
-0.5650734305,
0.5782729983,
-0.0940616131,
-0.5105914474,
-0.3074186146,
0.5302637815,
0.808955431,
-0.4992180169,
0.8899253607,
0.5180462599,
-0.3237239718,
0.1736806929,
-0.6616684198,
-0.3761996329,
-0.4843985438,
0.3345549107,
-0.6491000652,
-1.0002944469,
0.5199370384,
0.1112768576,
-0.1339374483,
0.6052711606,
0.7505019903,
0.1085327566,
1.2262778282,
0.6714572906,
-0.37954548,
0.4342645407,
-0.1823226959,
-0.0087713636,
-1.1296836138,
-0.181139648,
-0.7692680359,
-0.2261819392,
-0.3557105362,
-0.4962041676,
0.6390560269,
0.1056818515,
-0.5031991601,
0.257643342,
-0.5100999475,
0.6302176118,
0.8881483674,
0.3961898088,
0.3803445697,
-0.041992452,
-0.0627684519,
0.023865493,
-0.7075784802,
-0.0908683017,
1.3399949074,
0.0881859809,
0.7991914153,
0.1220315993,
0.3559069335,
-0.0008786351,
0.0114809573,
-0.9399701953,
0.1783798933,
0.0546928048,
-0.9579134583,
-0.4197424948,
-0.4331355393,
-0.9421738982,
0.8010343909,
0.2532356083,
-0.7349010706,
0.2864941359,
0.3044089377,
-0.6226713061,
0.0745302364,
-0.6044015288,
1.0464135408,
-0.0232494157,
-0.0302823968,
-0.2531218827,
-0.8139154315,
0.7121032476,
-0.1988675594,
0.0319256,
0.0573635735,
0.242214933,
0.6431263685,
-0.1798096597,
0.4621935189,
-0.217746079,
0.3750593066,
0.2938292325,
-0.2840386331,
0.344466567,
0.0762236416,
0.2647066712,
0.0586379282,
-0.1380793303,
-0.6823804379,
-0.5509511828,
0.1877001375,
-0.6336877942,
-0.5681493282,
-0.2157812268,
-0.5053773522,
-0.4788272083,
0.1081789285,
0.5356907248,
0.5136981606,
-0.0091977799,
0.2806542218,
0.6624982357,
0.1343627423,
0.2992750704,
0.293099761,
0.0730973557,
-0.52190727,
0.5070022941,
0.0557892807,
0.6488847733,
0.3970177472,
-0.1890562922,
-0.3610573709,
-0.4482892752,
-0.6397105455,
0.055335924,
-0.730660677,
-0.2760819495,
-1.0239062309,
-0.1837643683,
-0.4428336024,
0.2540051937,
-0.5195972323,
-0.5164698958,
0.09761291,
0.3215864003,
0.0463144332,
0.2015470862,
0.1297496706,
0.9461606741,
-0.9751634002,
0.8439773917,
0.8114395142,
0.1347775459,
0.1556025594,
-0.9226569533,
-0.4749273956,
0.0509661324,
-0.5587988496,
-0.9078395963,
0.2795015275,
0.5652301908,
0.8364592195,
0.4560272992,
-0.1007574871,
0.6795628667,
-0.6157898307,
0.7400698066,
0.1291093826,
-1.0071452856,
0.3457647264,
-0.2513979673,
0.7008744478,
0.7793693542,
0.6812509894,
-0.6780464649,
-0.5640285611,
-0.2420963794,
-0.8579058051,
0.7925935388,
0.0059834588,
0.1537451148,
0.1181043312,
0.2967469394,
-0.1056395993,
0.3159164488,
-0.6210707426,
-0.3208979368,
-0.344736129,
0.157795012,
-0.044832956,
-0.323176831,
-0.1290137917,
-0.5517494678,
0.5702246428,
-0.5038356781,
0.6381207108,
0.0379958004,
-0.3730220497,
0.1128713861,
0.2763642073,
0.2910046875,
0.6146321893,
-0.2339847535,
-0.0236146133,
0.2197573632,
-0.5737751126,
0.4984070957,
-0.1715809405,
-0.0974884257,
-0.2036076039,
0.1314493418,
0.8226623535,
0.314642638,
0.0150057487,
0.3542791605,
-0.4465968907,
-0.3530406654,
0.1941397339,
0.1668536514,
0.1722597778,
0.2504213452,
0.5692874789,
-0.0291402563,
0.5112886429,
-0.4801915884,
0.4191932976,
0.5047206283,
-0.3505071402,
-0.2351400405,
0.9185717106,
0.0659648404,
0.208359465,
0.7524278164,
-0.2199962288,
-0.7701661587,
0.4023398459,
0.1496525258,
1.0318177938,
-0.4380131662,
-0.0953514799,
0.5501235127,
0.4599352777,
-0.1880142689,
0.1553124785,
-0.1076584309,
-0.7390987873,
-0.7973644733,
-0.6371762753,
-0.69294101,
0.2045396417,
-0.9347274303,
0.066222243,
-0.0492083281,
-0.212561354,
0.082297042,
-0.2500970364,
-0.7817705274,
0.5685850382,
-0.1018512174,
0.495229125,
-0.6513319016,
0.993825376,
0.4006414711,
-0.396484673,
-0.7935737371,
0.2393816561,
-0.0943163112,
-0.7614153028,
0.2825518548,
0.4555613697,
-0.2444027364,
0.1670542806,
-0.3566508591,
-1.0588129759,
1.0055096149,
0.4024370313,
-0.4376065433,
-0.3494914174,
0.1672811806,
0.3032322824,
-0.3287383914,
0.5462560654,
0.905842185,
0.1734369844,
0.1290538907,
-0.806245625,
-0.1227982044,
0.0685401186,
-0.0695246533,
0.1593160182,
-0.8633258343,
1.1821751595,
-0.1031866819,
-0.3726165891,
-0.2362225205,
0.733377099,
0.1085498631,
0.0145735107,
0.4676571786,
0.7969663143,
0.7681073546,
-0.2959697545,
1.107155323,
-0.4006085098,
0.4942111969,
1.1538727283,
0.2034489959,
0.6028285027,
0.3063405156,
-0.3374791443,
0.2628292143,
0.6416350007,
0.1838381886,
0.9542281628,
-0.0120909512,
-0.22473149,
-0.3803091943,
0.3756657541,
-0.6033743024,
0.3805500865,
0.2000409961,
-0.2639251649,
-0.3241040409,
-0.0298515502,
-0.229270637,
-0.5052075386,
-0.4805291295,
0.764267683,
-0.0737008527,
-0.7996525168,
1.0243285894,
-0.0122251352,
0.5403392315,
-0.4300084114,
0.3974428177,
-0.4629225433,
0.2477225214,
0.0981043279,
-0.3026651144,
0.4016298354,
-0.3326812387,
-0.4134719074,
0.1391102374,
0.5671380758,
-0.381832242,
-0.3920408487,
0.2699557245,
0.6409294009,
0.2912552059,
-1.0099591017,
-0.651063025,
-0.2392304987,
-0.0275339205,
-0.49936077,
0.5481984615,
0.5230856538,
0.1007642001,
0.5898852944,
0.5850805044,
-0.6038262844,
0.5514461994,
0.4058820903,
1.2574719191,
-0.9137294292,
-0.5208100677,
-0.7154672742,
0.5622547865,
0.244702816,
-0.2203264683,
0.478646785,
0.3813670874,
0.8984358311,
-0.2734765708,
0.7347524762,
0.4209645391,
0.5336870551,
-0.7763302326,
0.661257267,
-0.6303738952,
-0.2415182739,
-0.0333937295,
-1.2352124453,
-0.1489478946,
0.2875328362,
0.1573607773,
0.2090438008,
0.9189099669,
0.7068138719,
-0.2771890461,
-0.1591261625,
0.4185571969,
-0.3091780543,
0.4748053551,
0.9443523884,
0.9436529279,
-0.666437149,
0.7305528522,
-0.1550433785,
-0.1341267228,
-0.1316875815,
-0.5696640015,
-1.0187597275,
-0.3684138358,
-0.1388527751,
-0.1966713071,
0.0425830111,
0.2270777822,
0.9151206613,
-0.9696504474,
0.0417430066,
-0.0283084791,
-0.1158097908,
-0.3895963728,
-0.1530027241,
0.3442812562,
-0.7978166938,
-0.8588572145,
0.5402241349,
0.1276553571,
-0.1329661757,
-0.1453942806,
0.0732020959,
-0.1505201906,
0.1355032474,
0.5401872993,
0.1187179536,
-0.8246583343,
-0.369907558,
0.0811242387,
-0.2091440111,
0.4093481004,
0.9073083997,
-0.8703756332,
0.2264917046,
0.1797462702,
0.7613856792,
0.9029846191,
0.3546305597,
0.5465170145,
-0.9015716314,
0.214462176,
0.0851919949,
0.2272312641,
0.0904051587,
-0.2011142224,
0.5048635006,
0.2122283578,
-0.8395730853,
-0.4580304921,
0.3746757805,
-0.7742128968,
0.0139880599,
0.8280818462,
-0.1741061807,
-0.2166881561,
-0.2253902107,
-0.1559329629,
0.2458647788,
-0.3596141934,
0.6041247845,
0.6872079372,
-0.2139113098,
-0.1180246323,
-0.4993701279,
0.5715340972,
0.5995745063,
-0.7545549273,
0.0143403057,
0.4059396088,
0.0656575933,
0.302434355,
0.7075300813,
-0.0355234109,
0.3902518153,
0.2247143239,
0.0567600131,
0.2510793209,
-0.7878627777,
-0.4349762797,
0.3143053353,
0.0219101217,
-0.6064261198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13242v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13242v3 | MAGE: Machine-generated Text Detection in the Wild | 2023-05-22T17:13:29 | 2024-05-21T04:21:53 | Yafu Li, Qintong Li, Leyang Cui, Wei Bi, Zhilin Wang, Longyue Wang, Linyi Yang, Shuming Shi, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved human-level text generation,
emphasizing the need for effective AI-generated text detection to mitigate
risks like the spread of fake news and plagiarism. Existing research has been
constrained by evaluating detection methods on specific domains or particular
language models. In practical scenarios, however, the detector faces texts from
various domains or LLMs without knowing their sources. To this end, we build a
comprehensive testbed by gathering texts from diverse human writings and texts
generated by different LLMs. Empirical results show challenges in
distinguishing machine-generated texts from human-authored ones across various
scenarios, especially out-of-distribution. These challenges are due to the
decreasing linguistic distinctions between the two sources. Despite challenges,
the top-performing detector can identify 86.54% out-of-domain texts generated
by a new LLM, indicating the feasibility for application scenarios. We release
our resources at https://github.com/yafuly/MAGE. | [
-0.3119178414,
-0.7664731145,
0.4300509095,
0.1187538654,
-0.2613205612,
0.2270674855,
-0.309278965,
-0.467923373,
-0.0394766107,
0.8957290649,
-0.7174876928,
-0.7480267286,
-0.5724565983,
0.5186832547,
-0.6101566553,
0.8406329155,
-0.0088285143,
-0.4442326427,
-0.2000361383,
0.0731197372,
-0.3350122273,
-0.5299808383,
-0.4835672975,
-0.2882143557,
0.5691095591,
0.5569805503,
0.4385797977,
0.5114358068,
0.6431972384,
0.2525278926,
-0.0198633168,
0.7337218523,
-0.4938645363,
0.4286863804,
-0.1259693652,
-0.4247010648,
-0.3758659959,
0.089760907,
0.7631030083,
0.1584271193,
-0.136844784,
0.1442696154,
-0.1370548606,
0.684325695,
-0.7387529612,
-0.2308216691,
-1.1012620926,
0.1464194208,
-0.7473730445,
-0.1845628619,
-0.6716068387,
-0.0884745792,
-0.0277765635,
-0.6581441164,
0.2806977034,
0.3236964345,
0.7555316091,
0.0818738118,
-0.6494566202,
-0.5544350147,
-0.8123049736,
0.7306244969,
-0.6152332425,
0.1580066979,
0.5119029284,
0.4797199667,
-0.4775674939,
-0.8165559769,
-0.9918267727,
-0.0324910544,
-0.123543255,
-0.0316852033,
-0.5063234568,
-0.3817076087,
0.0569950938,
0.4894818962,
-0.7556029558,
0.2674509585,
-0.0354753546,
-0.326366961,
0.7919225693,
0.3442459702,
0.5451467037,
-0.0911689326,
-0.1602745801,
-0.2109036297,
-0.7738188505,
-0.4296386242,
0.7282803655,
0.055277653,
0.2397232354,
0.6770192981,
0.0637080148,
0.5983424783,
-0.1695686579,
-0.4060569704,
0.1783109009,
-0.1752972752,
-0.3183481395,
-0.2585454583,
1.1953338385,
0.1793452501,
0.3666405678,
-0.0993998572,
-0.2149117738,
-0.1403346509,
0.168799594,
-0.6593141556,
-0.2493706495,
-0.2247116715,
-0.4687213302,
-0.6843909621,
-0.0494743735,
-0.8101764321,
-0.8142059445,
0.1060817987,
0.1461908817,
-0.1797247231,
-0.4273890257,
0.099187687,
-0.0844911262,
-0.0283600166,
0.156470716,
-0.7350689769,
0.1451697797,
0.4626492858,
0.5073839426,
-0.5660818815,
-0.2483693212,
-0.4994328916,
0.1119808704,
-0.3763051331,
0.9922442436,
-0.2319779247,
-0.4015253186,
0.0606038049,
0.0724892691,
-0.1853984296,
-0.8564997315,
1.1336252689,
-0.6568683982,
0.4569554627,
0.1337469518,
-0.5543673038,
-0.1462876797,
0.4173174798,
-0.7721621394,
1.116418004,
-0.074759081,
-0.8370028138,
0.3783723712,
-0.5572379231,
-0.6273697019,
0.000976792,
0.2362705469,
-0.9457476735,
0.0009991189,
0.2219581455,
0.5285801291,
-0.3713621199,
0.4535813332,
-0.1688069105,
-0.1743851453,
0.6081299782,
-0.7511146069,
0.6789883375,
0.4918741286,
-0.1887091398,
-0.0193314347,
-0.9823720455,
-0.1369224042,
0.2852469385,
-0.3812008202,
-0.3477433026,
0.1803175658,
0.3187938333,
0.0877672881,
0.0558050126,
-0.4136147499,
0.2029384077,
-0.3005861044,
0.2228998691,
0.5208195448,
-0.0165044367,
0.4212427735,
-0.1848854721,
0.5000430346,
0.0252256375,
-0.0695769414,
-0.5566232204,
-0.6844911575,
-0.6041565537,
-0.5001558065,
0.2306836396,
0.6431724429,
-0.7778121829,
0.5457231998,
0.0243664291,
-0.5091454387,
-0.3656141758,
0.4524362087,
0.391490072,
0.4153693616,
0.2032763213,
0.0742869377,
-0.4931997657,
-0.8506464958,
-0.7544493079,
-0.2250960022,
-0.1890382618,
0.1589057893,
0.7309671044,
-0.4318920374,
1.0661693811,
-0.520640552,
-0.4568556547,
-0.4288170636,
0.1641678065,
0.0171032678,
0.1818325818,
0.5288256407,
-1.0158692598,
-0.8254912496,
0.2096336335,
-0.8430438042,
-0.4800243974,
-0.0785177723,
-0.2640598714,
0.2041848004,
0.412260741,
-0.711874187,
0.5424963832,
0.4898807108,
-0.2624846399,
0.4934264719,
-0.1772272587,
-0.0396723077,
-1.1687332392,
0.1923468262,
-0.1395340562,
-0.3713191152,
-0.7873319387,
0.1305845529,
0.09544608,
-0.0665110126,
-0.3163249493,
0.770501852,
-0.5021799207,
-0.0000412228,
-0.5397902131,
0.1545045674,
0.2682272792,
0.2502562404,
-0.0697986931,
0.7400728464,
0.2681275904,
-0.4801787734,
0.3903701007,
-0.0217205603,
-0.2738106251,
0.6550841331,
-0.33228001,
0.0901401788,
0.0138491876,
0.4482411146,
-0.9380401969,
-0.4612843394,
0.6374851465,
-0.460757643,
0.2720735073,
-0.0137098953,
-1.1277235746,
-0.3800884783,
-0.2046275884,
0.0399382599,
0.6310625076,
-0.5421256423,
0.5572794676,
0.4626590014,
0.2306599468,
-0.4994804561,
-0.7004636526,
0.438991338,
-0.3396250308,
-0.698995173,
0.1174193248,
-0.0873546973,
-0.4303035736,
-0.0981526822,
0.211183995,
-0.076968357,
0.3972491622,
0.1465058923,
0.1267742962,
-0.274317652,
0.1436775476,
0.1841222942,
-0.0355007686,
-0.0023023903,
-0.5686525106,
0.2902500629,
0.3704890609,
-0.6192092896,
-0.5380105972,
0.3761219382,
0.6310191751,
-0.3060859144,
0.7998062968,
0.8509936333,
-0.4861817956,
-0.445189774,
-0.4590068758,
0.0449694283,
-0.4946972728,
0.0490058474,
-0.028577188,
-0.6114330888,
0.4498552382,
-0.1240779534,
0.1004983783,
0.6525220871,
0.6804952025,
-0.0355756655,
0.9512639046,
0.6062858105,
0.0108291777,
0.223775655,
-0.0390054137,
0.1559006274,
-0.5246821642,
-0.0678875372,
-0.5441319346,
-0.3151803315,
-0.6100285649,
-0.2919949889,
0.1143997833,
0.0519062094,
0.0699919015,
0.2372937799,
-0.5611481667,
0.6905723214,
0.6133564115,
-0.1407431066,
0.7137326002,
0.1319013238,
-0.0391450189,
-0.0562678874,
-0.3686966896,
-0.7289223075,
1.2225055695,
0.156557098,
0.4382068813,
0.0598217063,
0.5287401676,
0.4622139931,
0.8168827295,
-0.5072364807,
0.4639538527,
-0.2178051025,
-1.0359816551,
0.0011943452,
-0.3476106226,
-1.0406640768,
0.4453284442,
-0.4289564192,
-0.4436236024,
-0.277493,
-0.0488577895,
0.066904828,
0.6385777593,
-0.5968876481,
0.8820265532,
-0.0259033591,
-0.0007712088,
0.1417575181,
-0.4460334182,
0.6694792509,
-0.5041396022,
0.3627679348,
-0.1902963221,
0.0340519585,
0.4558686018,
-0.3579652905,
0.9551491141,
0.1610936224,
-0.3604336381,
0.7112275362,
0.1556696296,
0.6898804903,
0.0553599857,
-0.0631442815,
-0.0390665382,
-0.5904582143,
-0.293960005,
-0.2669095099,
0.5548220873,
-0.5839326382,
-0.39662233,
-0.3307762742,
-0.5808452964,
0.0807985961,
0.4673291445,
0.716283679,
0.0957186893,
-0.3960961699,
-0.1548460126,
0.8449562192,
-0.5459475517,
0.4053311348,
0.623883307,
-0.5379179716,
-0.3671337366,
0.9175266027,
-0.3542667627,
0.0586399846,
0.4119932055,
0.2057257891,
-0.0933942944,
-0.7321977615,
-0.9223204851,
0.0676829815,
-0.6245962381,
-0.3547230959,
-0.7247980237,
-0.1928597242,
-0.1410268247,
-0.1037958413,
-0.1644037366,
-0.0554004498,
-0.6559278965,
0.0595146567,
0.3991094232,
0.7754092216,
0.1081046164,
0.5212797523,
-0.8630212545,
0.3648898005,
0.1452193409,
-0.1188350916,
-0.1258192956,
-0.4931895137,
-0.0754719302,
0.0028475372,
-0.470174551,
-0.7841058373,
0.8505427241,
0.2694185972,
0.3909130394,
0.5322608352,
0.192481488,
0.1404736936,
-0.499345243,
0.7249729037,
0.0772778913,
-0.6856421828,
0.4302820861,
-0.5751555562,
0.1087038293,
0.2855159938,
0.0857118368,
-0.4385955632,
-0.6840867996,
-0.3508816957,
-0.4682320654,
0.5682246685,
0.4952200353,
0.2417992353,
0.039668642,
0.3395729661,
0.3295650184,
0.1257077008,
-0.7723128796,
-0.3510859609,
0.2916077971,
-0.3079162538,
-0.1885149926,
-0.0025476846,
0.04779635,
0.1723254174,
0.3988468349,
0.0287489705,
0.0253333468,
-0.0279638879,
-0.3853882551,
-0.3104890287,
0.0928616673,
0.8489937782,
0.1874822825,
0.1970124692,
0.2563991845,
0.2201835662,
-0.8829990625,
0.0289049037,
-0.0500389189,
-0.3382724822,
0.2173331529,
0.5597507358,
0.5352006555,
-0.1009920985,
-0.7522954345,
0.5650421977,
-0.1137215272,
-0.3131523728,
-0.4102933407,
0.1166845411,
0.1168343872,
0.2213479877,
0.5492038131,
0.3712979555,
0.1198398098,
-0.4175346792,
0.1274419874,
0.4593969285,
-0.0757822692,
-0.511869669,
0.7506300211,
0.1449528784,
-0.5016385317,
0.5156208277,
-0.6146250367,
-0.8668600321,
0.5824414492,
0.5710040927,
0.9017390013,
0.1177394465,
0.2418220937,
-0.0605353452,
0.3786614537,
-0.2229148,
-0.0352201425,
0.1082822531,
-0.7567312717,
-0.46192047,
-0.4951447546,
-0.4292328954,
0.0920564458,
-0.1803774536,
0.5318923593,
-0.0604103915,
-0.0948704481,
-0.0944252163,
0.1666083783,
-0.4390653968,
-0.1250680685,
0.4154183865,
0.8489747643,
-0.7378528714,
0.8561003208,
0.5365297198,
0.0072879042,
-0.3915079236,
0.1415257007,
0.2999589741,
-0.7199110389,
0.6732518673,
0.0787231103,
-0.1349647492,
0.0720496476,
-0.6693724394,
-0.4936034977,
1.1647088528,
0.3456986547,
-0.3158417344,
0.1971130222,
0.2662962973,
0.7787917256,
-0.2745282948,
0.0566671304,
0.2916379571,
0.6707388759,
0.0911289454,
-0.7614125609,
-0.2039057314,
-0.2058363706,
-0.3537625968,
0.3667533398,
-0.3841975927,
0.9006814957,
-0.0836789533,
-0.4211063385,
0.2963019907,
0.5496773124,
0.425935626,
0.9175223112,
0.2433734983,
0.6225033402,
0.7957932353,
0.1535295993,
0.9912559986,
0.1284139752,
0.1267507374,
0.6425722241,
-0.4548331201,
0.7393139005,
0.1354321986,
-0.0093135834,
0.5659059286,
0.6167692542,
-0.1162445843,
0.3459807634,
0.4434887469,
-0.5132421255,
-0.1905814111,
-0.0159512535,
-0.2634603381,
0.374808073,
0.3712810278,
-0.5153572559,
-0.1387215704,
0.0600632317,
0.2366953045,
0.3078279197,
-0.2761714458,
0.4498232305,
0.0236957837,
-0.7027719021,
0.341116637,
0.3011695445,
0.8732025027,
-0.3578382432,
0.1260357052,
-0.2287522107,
0.5229230523,
-0.2200947702,
-0.7444767356,
0.3006622791,
0.4378377795,
-0.158449173,
-0.3981193006,
1.3815655708,
-0.4577996731,
-0.5435991287,
0.031401746,
0.8231110573,
0.2950809896,
-0.2799885273,
-0.3620777428,
0.0316077061,
-0.2281832993,
-0.4609845579,
0.4437065125,
0.933345437,
-0.2176764905,
0.6135895848,
1.0138113499,
-0.1974464208,
0.1943729818,
-0.1189758405,
0.7900291085,
-0.3560034931,
-0.2080895454,
-1.1999866962,
0.3117685914,
-0.2751483619,
-0.4324612021,
0.9158672094,
0.506490469,
0.5964027047,
-0.1472884864,
0.6290998459,
0.2549079359,
0.547185123,
-0.3135319948,
1.0831371546,
-0.5282124281,
0.452688545,
-0.2628829181,
-0.9388468862,
-0.7407690287,
0.3010075092,
0.0073280605,
-0.37082991,
0.4949308336,
0.5269094706,
-0.094075717,
0.0873048529,
0.4193840325,
-0.2214756757,
0.3504347801,
0.4308849573,
1.1913665533,
-0.4379357994,
0.9522950053,
0.1682941318,
0.072776705,
-0.3438357711,
-1.0571616888,
-1.3822938204,
-0.4087118506,
-0.08615008,
-0.0684529915,
-0.1855852306,
0.3771710694,
0.6193811893,
-0.7092350721,
-0.1074087024,
-0.1989376843,
0.4518534243,
0.0737439692,
-0.1915736943,
0.1403013319,
-0.0545488074,
-0.7161534429,
0.3697102368,
0.2366059124,
0.0982400179,
-0.5126954317,
-0.0572036095,
-0.1097994745,
0.1656889319,
0.5612566471,
0.2357067466,
-0.4577481747,
0.0637259409,
0.486851275,
-0.4930361211,
-0.1783729792,
0.8734819889,
-0.704390645,
0.1254384816,
0.6466132402,
0.5439293981,
0.4441684484,
-0.2942522168,
0.4942356348,
-0.8014592528,
-0.0877854079,
0.1281841695,
0.1646039784,
0.3792873025,
-0.3529246449,
0.4823130369,
0.5719140768,
-0.6125993729,
-1.1654071808,
0.3615525067,
-0.5700956583,
-0.2819022536,
1.1740870476,
-0.1994018555,
-0.1060655713,
-0.1888017356,
-0.3715027273,
0.1340889335,
-0.163985312,
0.4481668174,
0.7579814196,
0.2254247367,
-0.0031824219,
-0.5988097191,
0.4345919192,
0.0129173025,
-0.9766235352,
0.1092319936,
0.3872741759,
0.1635447145,
0.1595975012,
0.5944244266,
0.0233837329,
0.0376421288,
-0.0921673402,
0.0609832853,
-0.0638831779,
-0.1982115209,
-0.0397533253,
0.1395674795,
-0.0955120325,
0.0292835087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13235v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13235v2 | SPARSEFIT: Few-shot Prompting with Sparse Fine-tuning for Jointly Generating Predictions and Natural Language Explanations | 2023-05-22T17:06:41 | 2023-05-23T09:26:37 | Jesus Solano, Oana-Maria Camburu, Pasquale Minervini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Explaining the decisions of neural models is crucial for ensuring their
trustworthiness at deployment time. Using Natural Language Explanations (NLEs)
to justify a model's predictions has recently gained increasing interest.
However, this approach usually demands large datasets of human-written NLEs for
the ground-truth answers, which are expensive and potentially infeasible for
some applications. For models to generate high-quality NLEs when only a few
NLEs are available, the fine-tuning of Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) in
conjunction with prompt-based learning recently emerged. However, PLMs
typically have billions of parameters, making fine-tuning expensive. We propose
SparseFit, a sparse few-shot fine-tuning strategy that leverages discrete
prompts to jointly generate predictions and NLEs. We experiment with SparseFit
on the T5 model and four datasets and compare it against state-of-the-art
parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques. We perform automatic and human
evaluations to assess the quality of the model-generated NLEs, finding that
fine-tuning only 6.8% of the model parameters leads to competitive results for
both the task performance and the quality of the NLEs. | [
-0.6734389663,
-0.8251749873,
0.6718778014,
0.3117184937,
-0.3735450804,
-0.3709723353,
-0.5143358707,
-0.2113718987,
-0.1027134508,
0.2353345305,
-1.0746953487,
-0.334878087,
-0.3734689951,
0.3526681662,
-0.0740968212,
1.0319490433,
0.1920890063,
-0.085858658,
-0.1941015869,
0.0150522888,
-0.9894835949,
0.3413672149,
-0.8801144361,
-0.36696437,
0.8151844144,
0.5177822709,
0.8878347874,
0.6170405149,
0.0244365353,
0.3282298446,
0.069797121,
0.5057751536,
-0.5231095552,
0.0985888243,
-0.0937329531,
-0.2189984769,
-0.1701723486,
-0.068524614,
0.4040344059,
0.8851661086,
0.0891556144,
0.1264502108,
0.4732698202,
0.3257681429,
-0.4389484227,
-0.088096112,
-0.726092577,
-0.2999009192,
0.1852997243,
-0.2704724073,
-0.284219116,
-0.4228715599,
0.3538195789,
-0.874982655,
0.4827744067,
0.2692039311,
0.980273962,
0.6466270089,
0.0389905535,
0.0659857765,
-0.421358496,
0.9126042128,
-0.7054695487,
0.1950626224,
0.5896522999,
0.2530063689,
-0.409273535,
-0.4954864979,
-0.407972455,
-0.3000530899,
-0.3030260503,
-0.1166595519,
-0.1736794561,
0.261153996,
0.315361619,
-0.1332014054,
-0.9894724488,
0.299988538,
-0.0032568462,
-0.2545261681,
0.5539101362,
0.2252185792,
0.0641673431,
-0.2342921942,
-0.3010568023,
0.125635922,
-0.5984102488,
-0.1034050882,
0.2169872075,
0.6632486582,
-0.2167031169,
0.1951129884,
-0.2083323598,
1.0812535286,
0.2772280276,
-0.0780090094,
-0.3491599262,
-0.418943435,
-0.4193896949,
-0.1380231827,
0.9251784682,
0.1639581323,
0.5078566074,
-0.3195075095,
-0.2838497758,
0.04560671,
0.1851459891,
-0.7674477696,
-0.1164233238,
0.2702147365,
-0.4669044316,
-0.3392152488,
-0.4444755614,
-0.9333117604,
-0.5958119035,
-0.4455326498,
0.7494788766,
-0.5588933229,
0.0081403349,
0.2199231237,
-0.102376923,
-0.1750626862,
0.5697545409,
-1.1624913216,
0.3571463227,
0.4984931052,
0.8504989743,
-0.1520832032,
-0.5115964413,
-0.6903207302,
-0.1810207069,
-0.2785589993,
1.0124878883,
-0.1991323233,
-0.1425949931,
0.0012230705,
-0.2920469642,
-0.1354277879,
-0.4385733306,
0.5469657779,
-0.1416412443,
0.1838323325,
-0.4553805292,
-0.417821914,
0.004126647,
0.2789500058,
-0.5287182927,
0.9449356198,
-0.0355190113,
-0.5128290057,
0.6833075881,
-0.7125944495,
-0.175105527,
0.2907826602,
-0.115630202,
-0.2771505117,
0.1078744233,
0.5081110597,
0.689553082,
-0.4570043385,
0.3596828282,
-0.3034973145,
-0.487375468,
0.1551980227,
-0.6370602846,
0.6215063334,
0.1759204566,
-0.213914454,
0.2239749283,
-0.6254813075,
-0.05992743,
0.0511691161,
-0.0038036804,
-0.1780597121,
0.0473507792,
-0.0973801836,
0.0374660157,
0.1347099543,
-0.3101762235,
0.0584360957,
-0.709420383,
0.3267944455,
0.6585224867,
0.1858237386,
0.6570477486,
-0.6208615303,
0.5047360063,
-0.209296152,
0.2273829579,
-0.5131229758,
-0.5458700657,
-0.6069256067,
-0.2232884318,
0.3691807687,
0.2033374757,
-0.5202879906,
0.188333258,
-0.1333396882,
-0.1754418761,
-0.5950503349,
0.3616652191,
0.0764375478,
0.5797913074,
0.3309458494,
0.397361517,
-0.5507901311,
-0.7553921342,
-0.340351969,
0.0562874712,
-0.161062181,
0.3433297873,
0.4467086792,
0.0652831718,
1.1621009111,
-0.326484412,
-0.1648586243,
-0.2692161798,
0.5617384315,
0.0832822025,
0.4534106851,
0.678049922,
-0.5167639852,
-0.3845956028,
-0.2298037559,
-0.3402409852,
-0.1646391004,
-0.5014106631,
0.0224821679,
0.0812293366,
0.2123297304,
-0.7263843417,
0.1922218055,
0.4986577928,
-0.1967157274,
0.4140166938,
-0.2228305787,
-0.0750211328,
-0.9057307243,
-0.0606682003,
0.063703686,
-0.2900565863,
-0.3459817171,
-0.1823274642,
-0.2894948125,
-0.1960200965,
-0.1573057324,
0.6765059233,
-0.3040843308,
0.0697594583,
-0.1516448408,
0.2286293209,
0.1362885237,
0.5253996253,
-0.0110901287,
0.7396679521,
0.4115175903,
-0.510183394,
0.1550295502,
0.1810518205,
-0.1324105114,
0.2836540341,
-0.9232343435,
0.0749442205,
-0.1706480682,
-0.0042838138,
-1.2529084682,
-0.4559946358,
-0.0852656364,
-0.5592713952,
0.165107742,
-0.3561502099,
-0.5473725796,
-0.117441453,
-0.2408086061,
0.1991310269,
0.4351757765,
-0.6263098717,
0.3734077811,
-0.1504920572,
-0.2500837743,
-0.376131922,
-0.4860529006,
-0.044694718,
-0.173189193,
-0.8974345922,
0.2474307269,
-0.3104512393,
-0.0729694292,
-0.0189346615,
-0.0102217291,
-0.2817393839,
0.3513357043,
0.3018435836,
0.2487459928,
-0.5271478295,
0.1921088248,
0.2291847914,
-0.3243773282,
-0.0907982811,
-0.4821429253,
0.3498238921,
-0.1392290443,
-0.1002605334,
-0.4161383212,
0.4419783652,
0.263920188,
-0.0386654884,
0.7657487392,
0.7207134962,
-0.5734897256,
-0.6085813046,
-0.5171915889,
-0.631626904,
-0.5009278655,
0.0135432361,
-0.1845867038,
-0.9501449466,
0.3769612312,
-0.2531360388,
0.1260500103,
0.419701606,
0.5244150758,
-0.1747796088,
1.3691183329,
0.6135537624,
0.1257316172,
0.2785414457,
-0.129694894,
0.0640519336,
0.0148354927,
-0.0771034211,
-0.7775161862,
-0.3310901523,
-0.4387262464,
-0.0945204422,
0.4492890239,
0.098409757,
-0.1234003603,
0.2534553409,
-0.5183833838,
0.8055295944,
0.5601901412,
-0.0922634751,
0.0702993497,
-0.0449417569,
-0.2919377685,
-0.1545769423,
-1.0602718592,
-0.5075263381,
0.4651160538,
0.2067582607,
0.7034782171,
-0.1727419347,
0.8055816293,
-0.0272931214,
-0.1622484773,
-0.8410297632,
0.2975346744,
-0.1750068218,
-0.460472703,
-0.5050477982,
-0.3436044753,
-0.9834099412,
0.0464404672,
-0.5738784671,
-0.7166292667,
0.2404837459,
0.4262322783,
-1.2198572159,
-0.1958433837,
-0.9633777738,
1.155428648,
0.0460904539,
-0.6839528084,
-0.2633371055,
-0.5982473493,
0.4080334902,
0.0234183874,
-0.0105767008,
-0.1886771321,
0.0676141009,
0.5693674088,
-0.4041285515,
1.0023447275,
-0.2576431036,
0.1758017987,
0.0745992064,
0.2808465362,
0.5528358221,
0.4342145622,
-0.2139848024,
-0.0964877829,
0.0762015358,
-0.3502169549,
-0.7384540439,
0.8728126287,
-0.6018147469,
-0.2555264831,
-0.2008218914,
-0.6672843695,
-0.3939987123,
0.2767116427,
0.5585148931,
0.5930602551,
-0.1088761687,
-0.0478805937,
0.8947428465,
-0.3830441833,
0.5957093239,
0.3917419314,
0.3000647724,
-0.2163636386,
0.8432281613,
-0.0449246913,
0.0809440687,
0.1189818308,
0.4503818452,
-0.3693045378,
-0.7556394935,
-0.5229603648,
0.2309226245,
-0.2129927278,
-0.5551214218,
-0.2574464083,
0.0438804217,
-0.3105090857,
-0.523799181,
-0.2259471118,
-0.2314235866,
-0.5543981791,
0.1813256741,
0.6134323478,
0.8598514795,
-0.0765241459,
0.5682272911,
-0.8605895042,
0.6184722781,
0.4738910198,
0.6113238931,
-0.1042309701,
-0.4146756232,
-0.2536186278,
0.2443138808,
-0.1170959771,
-0.7711143494,
0.4793689847,
0.3469695449,
0.3588576615,
0.3338178098,
0.0947812423,
1.0910804272,
-0.4630047083,
0.8879806399,
-0.0090723634,
-0.8327104449,
0.7011908889,
-0.6341217756,
0.3891716897,
0.6951121688,
0.2916463912,
-0.2087344378,
-0.2703297436,
-0.5900889039,
-0.507134974,
0.9709105492,
0.089501515,
0.080513604,
0.0659154579,
0.4271832705,
0.3131945729,
-0.0518053398,
-0.3500939012,
-0.0851033926,
-0.2510429621,
-0.3240424693,
0.0842572749,
-0.2434319109,
-0.0183097832,
-0.1476081312,
0.5215594172,
-0.5061062574,
0.1293430924,
0.0143406522,
-0.1218135208,
-0.5835751295,
0.2245505154,
0.9141728878,
0.3134188652,
-0.2137885839,
0.0293648634,
0.3095482886,
-0.0656647608,
-0.1757984608,
0.201022163,
-0.1698760092,
0.2252689302,
0.4355434775,
1.0235327482,
0.4430802464,
-0.499794811,
0.5909500122,
-0.2739538252,
-0.3943174481,
0.0022751396,
0.0485386439,
0.0535774305,
0.0913524032,
0.1752874404,
0.4654262066,
0.0560572296,
0.048652906,
0.2036500275,
0.4632555544,
-0.0648836941,
-0.4922671616,
0.7454590797,
0.2206576467,
-0.0607963912,
0.3566911817,
-0.3241695464,
-0.1041915938,
0.4078356326,
0.4492718875,
0.8323072791,
0.0218968522,
0.4260014594,
0.5940155387,
0.3647548854,
-0.2840194404,
0.1871135682,
-0.1581089497,
-0.5789014697,
-0.837793529,
-0.7346112132,
-0.1880672574,
0.337320596,
-0.3167583942,
0.4133568704,
-0.6412783861,
0.0303030331,
0.3081337214,
0.2020223886,
-0.6825125813,
0.0817043856,
0.2486938238,
1.0603245497,
-1.0418014526,
0.6625153422,
0.4195462465,
-0.599815309,
-1.1018278599,
-0.0039063608,
0.0035965452,
-0.650967896,
0.5057919025,
-0.0028052947,
-0.0938719437,
0.1724811494,
-0.8234854341,
-0.7389339209,
0.8311007619,
0.9477683306,
-0.4301171899,
-0.1098638698,
0.069670029,
0.4538365901,
-0.0727684796,
0.249560535,
0.4915651083,
0.6487318873,
0.0533444136,
-0.8737570047,
0.0355751589,
0.1725895405,
-0.0669817999,
0.0865561292,
-0.3457883596,
0.6772134304,
-0.2950994968,
-0.1873488128,
0.2721584439,
0.6008191705,
0.2480051816,
0.2001619935,
0.6693547368,
0.1932457536,
0.7737958431,
-0.1119293869,
1.0113860369,
-0.062539354,
0.1733722985,
1.0308494568,
-0.0178823117,
0.6573557854,
0.4482216835,
0.1644662321,
0.4070264995,
0.7306810021,
0.0818209797,
0.3692680001,
-0.1396671832,
-0.1849359274,
-0.6520159245,
-0.410597235,
0.0970825925,
0.3400136232,
0.4380995333,
-0.099069275,
-0.6642814279,
-0.0374634676,
-0.2608533204,
0.1972292513,
-0.2145000398,
0.960618794,
0.1604016572,
-0.9983993769,
0.9745440483,
-0.0400364734,
0.5958648324,
-0.6924907565,
-0.1812959164,
-0.2562461495,
-0.0982497856,
-0.3508863151,
-0.4698954225,
0.3419954181,
0.1587389261,
-0.2960867584,
-0.5956034064,
0.8147922158,
-0.5214970708,
-0.0353949629,
-0.0072369766,
0.3756514192,
-0.171673581,
-0.181970939,
-0.8662074208,
-0.0208600555,
-0.1759173572,
-0.0299044847,
0.3901214004,
0.4656766057,
-0.0196382515,
0.5130406022,
0.674467802,
0.0906507447,
0.0866652057,
0.1582823247,
0.6534072757,
-0.2899208665,
-0.4472307861,
-0.8756970167,
0.5681846738,
0.1157587692,
-0.4364922643,
0.5606256723,
0.1411217898,
0.3236370683,
-0.0972400382,
0.7365851998,
0.1858907044,
0.59448421,
-0.6296390891,
0.6742733717,
-0.524995029,
0.1498097777,
-0.0993252173,
-0.5786262751,
-0.4400930405,
0.7118862271,
0.005980629,
-0.007248024,
0.6480756998,
1.0248452425,
-0.237264961,
0.0913982019,
0.5150113702,
0.3645280898,
-0.2241292894,
0.4555772841,
0.7393399477,
-0.2864856422,
0.5585474968,
-0.3150919676,
0.0152086932,
-0.1347835511,
-1.1639264822,
-0.9155215025,
-0.5357462168,
-0.283470124,
-0.0007023943,
0.0822813436,
1.2098836899,
1.0052354336,
-0.9307249784,
0.0194067396,
-0.3941931427,
0.2354143411,
-0.2340745777,
-0.2112351507,
0.0846522152,
-0.7917512059,
-0.5845733285,
0.7012266517,
0.0686974004,
0.0724353492,
-0.2023557872,
-0.267131567,
0.0167771801,
0.098954536,
0.3039720953,
0.1915037036,
-0.7365435362,
-0.2326663285,
0.1249955967,
0.0440841801,
-0.2396855652,
0.7472019196,
-1.1288017035,
0.2444476932,
0.7491281629,
0.7614374757,
0.1246676445,
-0.0089890957,
0.8085423708,
-1.2711275816,
0.0947607532,
0.2792442441,
0.2846513689,
0.2736774087,
-0.3546639085,
0.0935525298,
0.0467118882,
-0.6138194799,
-0.8760999441,
-0.0421433896,
-1.0667854548,
-0.2597070634,
1.1110972166,
-0.047758095,
-0.0732377917,
-0.3015569448,
-0.3187935948,
0.1991366297,
-0.5649598837,
0.5875871181,
0.5432158709,
0.0339545906,
-0.3173361421,
-0.5368556976,
0.9612163305,
0.6533471346,
-0.6787990928,
0.2409804761,
0.5477306843,
0.230367884,
-0.1376842707,
0.4174728692,
0.4828934968,
0.5364916921,
-0.0113791097,
-0.3363466263,
-0.1749464571,
-0.3680997491,
-0.7699953914,
0.1619952172,
0.3699930906,
-0.0325097963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13230v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13230v2 | To Repeat or Not To Repeat: Insights from Scaling LLM under Token-Crisis | 2023-05-22T17:02:15 | 2023-10-05T14:58:02 | Fuzhao Xue, Yao Fu, Wangchunshu Zhou, Zangwei Zheng, Yang You | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent research has highlighted the importance of dataset size in scaling
language models. However, large language models (LLMs) are notoriously
token-hungry during pre-training, and high-quality text data on the web is
approaching its scaling limit for LLMs. To further enhance LLMs, a
straightforward approach is to repeat the pre-training data for additional
epochs. In this study, we empirically investigate three key aspects under this
approach. First, we explore the consequences of repeating pre-training data,
revealing that the model is susceptible to overfitting, leading to multi-epoch
degradation. Second, we examine the key factors contributing to multi-epoch
degradation, finding that significant factors include dataset size, model
parameters, and training objectives, while less influential factors consist of
dataset quality and model FLOPs. Finally, we explore whether widely used
regularization can alleviate multi-epoch degradation. Most regularization
techniques do not yield significant improvements, except for dropout, which
demonstrates remarkable effectiveness but requires careful tuning when scaling
up the model size. Additionally, we discover that leveraging mixture-of-experts
(MoE) enables cost-effective and efficient hyper-parameter tuning for
computationally intensive dense LLMs with comparable trainable parameters,
potentially impacting efficient LLM development on a broader scale. | [
-0.4781540036,
-0.7117492557,
0.2296963036,
0.2629446983,
-0.2728251815,
0.1944856942,
-0.5708710551,
-0.4211715758,
0.1208392009,
0.5628450513,
-0.3804373741,
0.02207724,
-0.6620266438,
0.2549180984,
-0.4318646193,
0.9982015491,
0.1537875831,
0.1502990425,
-0.1593127102,
-0.2118723392,
-0.678866446,
-0.5499609709,
-1.0990896225,
-0.2624353468,
0.5307583213,
0.623965919,
0.6997238994,
1.097419858,
0.5558305979,
0.2984779775,
-0.1019788533,
0.1565330774,
-1.0006929636,
0.0734825656,
0.2940480709,
-0.7592738271,
-0.5096693635,
0.0754217282,
1.0741049051,
0.9200927615,
-0.3063086271,
0.1856383532,
0.2568360865,
0.7251653671,
-0.5061133504,
-0.0345654488,
-0.8322199583,
-0.1806832999,
-0.1827584058,
-0.1778389215,
-0.4146444499,
-0.0528507307,
0.0248945411,
-0.6874437332,
0.1024352312,
0.3397648931,
0.7012752891,
0.2957370877,
-0.3757120371,
0.0084138419,
-0.8248720169,
1.0688029528,
-0.8010223508,
0.5175205469,
0.2900763452,
-0.0297880415,
-0.0676673204,
-0.7229633331,
-0.4984200001,
-0.1017996222,
0.0970883667,
-0.1437377632,
-0.0680341646,
-0.1637146622,
0.1795056611,
0.6001357436,
-0.3838767409,
0.5807993412,
-0.4085050225,
-0.278839618,
0.3611138165,
0.3370029926,
0.1893445253,
0.1411606669,
-0.56887573,
-0.049869515,
-1.0056210756,
-0.1285787821,
0.4953638315,
0.5008891225,
0.2218560427,
0.1614723355,
0.0321432464,
0.5441109538,
0.0830101669,
-0.2631615698,
0.2840611041,
-0.4920342565,
-0.0769267529,
-0.1640833318,
0.634657681,
0.4749553204,
0.3228789866,
-0.1986055076,
-0.275329113,
-0.5283483267,
0.4058913291,
-0.9365131855,
0.0393292159,
0.2105914205,
-0.5388906002,
-0.1900335848,
-0.2281305641,
-0.8017473221,
-0.2348964214,
-0.5163946152,
0.4285247922,
-0.2999206483,
-0.3602780402,
0.224744007,
-0.1949527711,
-0.0373732895,
0.2559855282,
-0.8986800909,
0.1855796576,
0.7748085856,
0.8799302578,
-0.2406571805,
-0.5061805844,
-0.2613903582,
-0.0940835923,
-0.5545510054,
0.3483784497,
-0.3365013003,
-0.5794255137,
-0.1291463822,
-0.1008261293,
0.0170679465,
-0.8204998374,
0.4033059478,
-0.511044383,
0.0326694921,
-0.3612894416,
-0.4101793468,
-0.0056693554,
0.4783754647,
-0.6681932807,
1.0797518492,
-0.1158299148,
-0.7170114517,
0.7729547024,
-0.3002804816,
-0.2939755917,
-0.0237080436,
0.0135577302,
-0.6076237559,
0.4491307437,
0.3134524226,
0.4594210982,
-0.4108279049,
0.2574085593,
-0.3518726528,
-0.3059969246,
0.0935191289,
-0.6874253154,
0.4607987404,
0.1401039213,
-0.1138433293,
0.0322165675,
-0.9770603776,
-0.1276660413,
0.1125575453,
-0.5258775949,
-0.2416783422,
0.0095467111,
0.0668773651,
0.1950075924,
0.3934720457,
-0.4820436239,
0.2079710513,
-0.2285685986,
0.6606040597,
0.9607481956,
0.0891461298,
0.2910830677,
-0.5944280028,
0.488931179,
0.1901877671,
0.3457965851,
-0.405020088,
-0.2767133117,
-1.0429669619,
-0.2226583958,
0.2233019173,
0.3429552317,
-0.3719890118,
0.150515005,
-0.6995540261,
-0.5027037263,
-0.5248282552,
0.2666697502,
0.1444871128,
0.5682804585,
0.5535193086,
-0.4627098143,
-0.6075115204,
-0.9352155328,
-0.1533435881,
-0.1510027349,
-0.0311003029,
0.458673209,
0.3471518159,
-0.2822702825,
1.0216889381,
-0.1819632351,
-0.2218918651,
-0.2036317587,
0.1816165149,
0.0514570028,
0.5747579336,
0.4562277198,
-0.6695782542,
-0.2379757762,
-0.1208742037,
-0.3358156979,
0.0754839405,
-0.3850251734,
0.3109947443,
0.0998673439,
0.613122642,
-0.2691192925,
0.0769642889,
0.6069026589,
0.0852797627,
0.7550790906,
-0.3498746455,
0.1504460424,
-1.1138085127,
0.01023605,
-0.1902520806,
-0.2331595272,
-0.5914047956,
0.0753717273,
0.0267886389,
-0.1269194186,
-0.3031954765,
0.4855211973,
-0.397251755,
0.0448836461,
-0.2061311454,
-0.1089913473,
-0.1158285663,
0.3361832201,
-0.2549141049,
1.01555264,
0.5501129031,
-0.4349166155,
0.1591570377,
-0.1917801648,
-0.268610239,
0.2834486961,
-0.7288289666,
0.1201906502,
-0.1442670077,
0.1163154021,
-1.0485883951,
-0.0253061671,
-0.3554545343,
-0.3557567596,
0.6979947686,
-0.135582298,
-0.6652694941,
-0.2355474979,
-0.5726360679,
0.4718792439,
0.4517130852,
-0.5525520444,
0.4741818607,
0.1035786495,
-0.2998765707,
-0.7235637307,
-0.6318972707,
0.4203026891,
-0.5637783408,
-0.602018714,
0.1056915149,
-0.1400576681,
-0.2409031987,
-0.2880989313,
-0.100278452,
0.104137212,
0.3559154272,
0.2323025018,
0.0641604662,
-0.428896606,
0.1590748578,
-0.1733682156,
-0.2353326529,
0.0251379218,
-0.6072489023,
0.8153189421,
-0.0117627038,
-0.0968745351,
-0.590493381,
0.3677369356,
0.7740908265,
-0.1434575617,
1.0578866005,
0.4656230807,
-0.155732289,
0.092275992,
-0.9219831228,
-0.2424609065,
-0.4954789281,
0.5279583335,
-0.15931952,
-0.9235595465,
0.7124508619,
-0.3810087442,
0.2487473041,
0.6040040255,
0.7515671253,
0.0207697898,
0.7524696589,
0.9110761881,
-0.6652004719,
0.6432034969,
-0.2100521177,
-0.01468293,
-0.7296946049,
-0.1032802835,
-0.4252508879,
-0.3935371339,
-0.4801124036,
-0.3277387321,
0.2936228216,
0.362837255,
-0.2706576586,
0.0103745349,
-0.0722177699,
0.4579672813,
0.3389723599,
-0.0585932471,
0.5049600601,
0.0643025041,
0.287042737,
0.0100561399,
-0.6942825913,
-0.4535650611,
1.4349066019,
0.5740430951,
0.7540467381,
-0.0651468039,
0.6970916986,
0.0219691694,
0.3422403634,
-0.7849093676,
0.275354594,
-0.0571289659,
-0.7394524813,
-0.6436688304,
-0.6512326002,
-1.0991721153,
0.0615827292,
-0.0986739621,
-0.6178716421,
0.2303858101,
0.2712106407,
-0.387406379,
0.3373944759,
-0.5252972841,
0.7040771246,
-0.0808545426,
-0.1251796484,
-0.4827124476,
-0.5828860402,
0.0988544822,
-0.4885319173,
0.5248063207,
0.1237576231,
-0.289850384,
0.7898139954,
-0.5685240626,
0.942345202,
0.1349813342,
-0.1199437007,
0.0800293833,
-0.0749030411,
0.5557860136,
0.1785576344,
0.0290009771,
0.3585742414,
-0.3607905805,
-0.6006422043,
-0.5462267995,
0.7863653898,
-1.0471121073,
-0.5981195569,
0.1827415526,
-0.5351591706,
-0.2973122299,
0.2168478519,
0.3824383914,
0.6901780367,
0.0606108196,
0.5448775291,
0.6118991375,
0.0360333584,
0.5817269683,
0.2064281404,
-0.2671282887,
-0.4822105467,
1.0385634899,
0.5184039474,
0.6490407586,
0.0887711421,
0.272310406,
0.0339194648,
-0.9631517529,
-0.3874361515,
0.1181405038,
-0.57864815,
-0.1288182437,
-0.6775185466,
0.1739765704,
-0.4855104089,
-0.0766804442,
-0.6050550342,
-0.4364080429,
-0.4648302495,
-0.2060659379,
0.4167690277,
0.5218300223,
-0.1730048656,
0.5944973826,
-0.6450821757,
-0.0577500053,
0.2444393188,
0.3152111769,
0.2965793014,
-0.7608009577,
-0.4477127492,
-0.0096285688,
-0.0703914464,
-0.4011295736,
0.2628642321,
0.4818123281,
0.3659397662,
0.6645484567,
-0.3952531815,
0.9052079916,
-0.6139487028,
0.9303591251,
0.1375352293,
-0.7064528465,
0.1566712856,
-0.4212312996,
0.1551830769,
0.4807852507,
0.5656803846,
-0.7012554407,
-0.3256914318,
-0.5952289104,
-1.3181278706,
0.394277066,
-0.070811227,
0.4971811473,
0.0110834586,
0.7794987559,
0.2811243236,
0.1766501516,
-0.5236330032,
-0.5055239201,
-0.2011996657,
0.150447771,
-0.3781415522,
-0.6143556833,
0.060965959,
-0.1275197566,
0.6088774204,
-0.0086762961,
-0.2347332835,
-0.2279584259,
-0.2704666257,
0.0171817001,
0.241282925,
0.5701354146,
0.8693174124,
0.036363665,
-0.1005596966,
0.3694514334,
-0.6375529766,
-0.0081591969,
-0.1884812713,
0.0431771725,
-0.2791110873,
0.7445350885,
0.7960806489,
0.2408194989,
-0.6373422146,
0.3189838529,
-0.0073504532,
0.0080216574,
-0.2689454556,
-0.1329077333,
-0.0457997061,
-0.0339338407,
0.7071732879,
-0.0277851112,
-0.0660533905,
-0.6952214837,
0.3565365374,
0.074516803,
-0.1895011961,
-0.3074565232,
0.505060792,
0.1276797652,
-0.2293158919,
0.8795112967,
0.1294617206,
-0.3642676175,
0.6163327694,
0.5669202805,
0.3846790195,
-0.1807035953,
-0.2194247395,
0.2787683904,
0.3805653751,
-0.4066586494,
0.1970968992,
0.1607045084,
-0.7645475268,
-0.6488780975,
-0.5605763197,
-0.1864713132,
0.2162474394,
-0.9587773085,
0.1772599369,
-0.7730214,
-0.3833603561,
-0.3733421564,
0.0007376794,
-0.7192753553,
0.2537134588,
-0.021278372,
0.7464305162,
-0.7407675385,
0.6074748635,
0.2927114666,
-0.3890294135,
-0.7729729414,
-0.052601289,
0.1104040965,
-1.0343799591,
0.5569005013,
0.1060493588,
0.2145239115,
0.2734360099,
-0.5127491355,
-1.011113286,
0.8815562725,
0.2953544557,
-0.8480974436,
-0.0817426592,
0.2092392892,
0.5902136564,
-0.1965973079,
0.0798550919,
0.6813921332,
0.3560937047,
-0.0555507913,
-1.1041420698,
-0.1232856736,
0.1018125266,
-0.0109753748,
0.4376189709,
-0.761913836,
1.0255627632,
-0.3339013457,
-0.1066586599,
0.0293804035,
0.6128103137,
-0.1116203591,
-0.1788164675,
0.6055471301,
0.8730357289,
0.7105214596,
0.1234624833,
1.0223430395,
-0.4343466759,
0.5415956974,
1.1083734035,
0.1331727654,
0.9422391653,
0.6076769233,
-0.2526408136,
0.1400557905,
0.8213536143,
-0.0278203283,
0.1420632899,
0.2911013067,
0.0222579818,
-0.3925439715,
-0.1724766046,
-0.4313314259,
0.4198631942,
0.3475471735,
-0.2212442309,
-0.2173261046,
0.2629280686,
0.1569307894,
-0.2624767423,
-0.5198703408,
0.7801166177,
0.0883065611,
-0.1292332262,
0.4522106349,
-0.0784448087,
0.7882520556,
-0.3739072978,
0.3845592141,
-0.44751665,
0.0927852392,
-0.0823462605,
-0.2106673419,
0.1911539286,
-0.2336954921,
-0.3628413975,
-0.4038659632,
0.1918524951,
-0.4071294069,
-0.6451184154,
0.0780724958,
0.5723122954,
0.1947490275,
-0.1340453774,
-0.4320698082,
0.242770955,
-0.2636026144,
-0.458827436,
0.5793421865,
0.6077727675,
0.0171147529,
0.9778832793,
0.642511785,
0.3603923619,
0.2391582727,
0.1160654649,
0.8557879925,
-0.5897429585,
-0.2192412764,
-1.0927804708,
0.4333058,
-0.0058869934,
-0.5247240067,
0.8643388748,
0.7336472869,
0.883846283,
0.3157686293,
0.4590589702,
0.4252088368,
0.284571439,
-0.4621602595,
0.6873366833,
-0.7594112754,
0.2499166429,
-0.0086612888,
-0.6886243224,
-0.3267940581,
0.0621968135,
-0.0123643829,
0.1778176427,
0.4106860757,
0.647449255,
0.2634344399,
-0.2782307267,
0.3200880587,
0.2842388749,
0.4828702509,
0.1009397134,
0.7394243479,
-0.2177118808,
0.6521440744,
0.0518897586,
-0.1683149785,
-0.2995095551,
-0.7740995288,
-0.6975209713,
-0.5371258259,
-0.3259146512,
-0.0479792207,
-0.1259877384,
0.9152892828,
0.8003232479,
-0.5496717095,
-0.0887534842,
0.2086942792,
-0.0910770446,
-0.1861300021,
-0.143367961,
0.2751392424,
-0.7387697101,
-0.5984601974,
0.2887671888,
0.4354038537,
0.1400436461,
-0.5283242464,
0.2835613787,
0.2160021067,
0.0628651753,
0.5318003893,
0.1020678207,
-0.6254346371,
-0.4663007557,
-0.0558959246,
0.0926619396,
0.2920951247,
1.1286787987,
-0.6399951577,
0.4843347967,
0.2511673272,
0.8662263751,
0.3128702343,
-0.0499060564,
0.7688866854,
-0.7983931303,
0.1462095976,
0.1248704344,
0.5016385317,
0.2507967353,
-0.3076806068,
0.1729719043,
0.2261456996,
-0.6139310002,
-0.96737957,
0.0175145958,
-0.5457524061,
-0.2627433538,
1.0517133474,
-0.2048550695,
0.1487044096,
-0.2050043494,
0.0014468423,
-0.0094732493,
-0.3997435272,
0.8406782746,
1.0243128538,
0.0069797072,
-0.1394197941,
-0.4777715504,
0.4449833333,
0.4921683073,
-0.5185497999,
0.3822053671,
0.2971291542,
0.4367467463,
0.2215988636,
0.5003510714,
-0.1098162904,
-0.1800925136,
0.1107427329,
-0.2368301898,
-0.1936134845,
-0.5456698537,
-0.5658579469,
0.1659465134,
0.3441485465,
0.0416323543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.01753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.01753v1 | Preconditioned Visual Language Inference with Weak Supervision | 2023-05-22T16:57:52 | 2023-05-22T16:57:52 | Ehsan Qasemi, Amani R. Maina-Kilaas, Devadutta Dash, Khalid Alsaggaf, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Humans can infer the affordance of objects by extracting related contextual
preconditions for each scenario. For example, upon seeing an image of a broken
cup, we can infer that this precondition prevents the cup from being used for
drinking. Reasoning with preconditions of commonsense is studied in NLP where
the model explicitly gets the contextual precondition. However, it is unclear
if SOTA visual language models (VLMs) can extract such preconditions and infer
the affordance of objects with them. In this work, we introduce the task of
preconditioned visual language inference and rationalization (PVLIR). We
propose a learning resource based on three strategies to retrieve weak
supervision signals for the task and develop a human-verified test set for
evaluation. Our results reveal the shortcomings of SOTA VLM models in the task
and draw a road map to address the challenges ahead in improving them. | [
-0.3387981951,
-0.9025464058,
0.5526100993,
0.1795185804,
-0.2821316421,
-0.3797269464,
-0.086680308,
-0.3125388324,
-0.450468123,
0.7391697764,
-0.6659296155,
-0.2928575873,
-0.3844637275,
0.1865266711,
-0.0885366872,
0.8626560569,
-0.1420242935,
0.2739048004,
-0.7349526882,
-0.293849647,
-0.4667797983,
-0.6187208295,
-0.2660159469,
0.1085741222,
0.3492489457,
0.649741888,
0.5424332023,
0.1615277678,
0.7447171807,
0.4273293316,
-0.0152901728,
0.0730828941,
-0.5029199123,
-0.167571947,
-0.3307940364,
-0.3549551964,
-0.1843790263,
-0.0968225598,
0.2995876968,
0.5855424404,
0.0192057136,
0.2863569856,
0.0512927808,
0.5574593544,
-1.1075159311,
0.2581267059,
-0.4156571925,
-0.0196151044,
-0.0543616824,
-0.2469217181,
-0.4380428493,
-0.1202017665,
0.4245417714,
-0.8670217991,
0.1568529904,
0.433292985,
1.2654715776,
0.5290312767,
-0.2548441291,
0.0484159738,
-0.7218188643,
1.0058056116,
-0.4651912749,
0.3852006197,
0.8408756256,
0.400196135,
0.0134931812,
-1.0479381084,
-0.7314301133,
-0.2609615922,
-0.4978882968,
0.170715183,
-0.0936378315,
0.1808637083,
0.5641934276,
-0.0158668887,
-0.3806423247,
-0.2927154601,
-0.4924268126,
-0.0139991827,
0.3894205689,
-0.0012997662,
0.5435452461,
-0.479105711,
-0.7628104687,
-0.0554971248,
-0.5908703804,
-0.0038140037,
0.0971385762,
0.243598178,
-0.0117876688,
0.60623312,
-0.2012514174,
0.8073948026,
-0.3207502663,
-0.3069693148,
0.1771653593,
-0.8266427517,
-0.4865269363,
-0.2942655683,
0.6020864844,
0.3419550359,
0.4422874749,
0.022750739,
-0.3137767613,
0.0362521596,
0.3212108612,
-0.7205463052,
-0.2670074403,
-0.0780716017,
-0.4024630487,
-0.1108009666,
-0.2605084777,
-0.6291947365,
-0.1906037033,
-0.5782884955,
0.7457873821,
-0.2642593682,
-0.3238363564,
0.0805980191,
-0.0767358392,
0.379843533,
0.2429530621,
-0.847525835,
0.4633720517,
0.304933697,
0.4718722701,
-0.0892101824,
-0.4745637178,
-0.5778363347,
-0.0812971368,
-0.0709243566,
1.104165554,
-0.3425628841,
-0.1993926018,
-0.2203921378,
0.0661007315,
-0.0008210585,
-0.5181050897,
0.7168768644,
-0.4354048669,
0.093966715,
-0.6022741199,
-0.2992521524,
-0.0456096902,
0.1521650106,
-0.6394857764,
0.4783298671,
0.2071465999,
-1.1817803383,
0.6870269179,
-0.390720427,
-0.4818826616,
0.1604554802,
-0.2606505156,
-0.7260001898,
-0.1073071063,
0.3881706297,
0.4430215359,
-0.2527611256,
0.2672005892,
-0.5628759861,
-0.1897596866,
-0.064676933,
-0.2615755796,
0.9351359606,
0.1619388759,
-0.2106910199,
0.5798720121,
-0.6751323342,
-0.0626590773,
0.138032645,
0.0702428818,
-0.6460862756,
0.2553521097,
0.3881371617,
-0.046202071,
-0.1149938107,
-0.0554720312,
-0.1212766394,
-0.2482138872,
0.3359576464,
0.7387506962,
0.1107341275,
0.6144891977,
0.1657663435,
0.4301022887,
-0.0153810019,
0.4738306999,
0.1957381815,
-0.0408845879,
-0.9008948803,
-0.4402381778,
0.0025661681,
0.562528491,
-1.354782939,
0.0605171695,
0.0556166209,
-0.0529837497,
-0.3119844198,
0.3179209828,
0.852455318,
0.8114114404,
0.5479232073,
-0.0428099893,
-0.8610469103,
-0.8578933477,
-0.2721805573,
0.0133103393,
0.0413065813,
0.3707779944,
0.5911864042,
-0.1367964298,
0.9057884216,
-0.3487941325,
-0.5089863539,
-0.4660305679,
0.0480906479,
-0.0343132354,
0.5630145073,
0.5078883767,
-1.2833594084,
-0.1778743267,
-0.3093589544,
-0.9498060942,
-0.0889258161,
0.0559846796,
-0.0695310086,
0.044861991,
1.009655118,
-0.4188003838,
0.7486485839,
0.3583928049,
-0.66970402,
0.8056037426,
-0.1534089297,
-0.0638583973,
-0.7073720098,
0.1558107138,
0.2476266772,
-0.4648557901,
-0.5380873084,
0.1523809582,
-0.1341904998,
-0.0755644068,
-0.743481338,
0.5660655499,
-0.6034775972,
-0.1815287769,
0.0195192751,
0.0921138451,
0.0398460329,
0.5860037804,
0.3723839819,
0.6348952651,
0.663987577,
-0.5227710605,
0.170217663,
0.0820178986,
-0.5695876479,
0.791688323,
-0.9667308927,
-0.2878229916,
-0.5222908854,
-0.0371815339,
-0.7722418308,
-0.1358805597,
0.1970427483,
0.0360848196,
0.0810318142,
-0.3665713668,
-0.3421062529,
-0.1757268459,
0.2760253847,
0.6021131277,
0.4072577357,
-0.5805427432,
0.5003011227,
0.3959708214,
0.0181612559,
-0.8411549926,
-0.4145907164,
-0.2644216716,
-0.303278029,
-0.3516507447,
0.0153886462,
-0.1152756363,
-0.8395857215,
0.2143503278,
-0.0953438953,
-0.295876503,
0.2185628116,
0.4843560159,
0.4523285627,
-0.2749053538,
-0.0230250563,
-0.4054349363,
-0.3266096413,
-0.1015896574,
-0.0380758494,
0.0818282515,
-0.6707071066,
-0.4602019787,
-0.6405510902,
0.0401570536,
0.2684963644,
-0.3827364147,
0.4522886872,
0.5380733013,
-0.3614650071,
-0.1371167451,
-0.5402866006,
-0.17478019,
-0.498191148,
0.3558187187,
-0.4039018154,
-0.5910772085,
0.1293222457,
0.1221056655,
-0.2495025694,
0.1472635865,
0.4053453505,
-0.213727504,
0.8156026006,
0.6804955006,
0.2386198938,
0.5223034024,
-0.3448533416,
0.1922467649,
-0.4249800444,
-0.221470952,
-0.3677923679,
0.0989993066,
-0.2125864029,
-0.4957694709,
0.1347302496,
0.5125479102,
-0.0414816849,
0.2153874487,
-0.2027829736,
0.8887445927,
0.6475403905,
0.2711580992,
0.2184216827,
-0.1630860418,
0.0095183607,
-0.1046911702,
-0.5458968878,
-0.4839287698,
0.5785570145,
0.075883545,
0.6115061045,
0.0382311232,
0.4409787953,
0.0534174033,
0.4606650174,
-0.9173102379,
0.5221509933,
0.0016670888,
-0.5929442644,
-0.5606249571,
-0.5019541383,
-0.8501522541,
0.2703942358,
-0.3914358616,
-0.7525852323,
0.3283202946,
0.4047812819,
-0.3412070274,
-0.0611387491,
-1.0225304365,
1.5193554163,
-0.2617034316,
-0.7585266829,
0.072549805,
-0.6182338595,
0.6434388757,
0.1469914913,
0.3917600214,
-0.1070237234,
0.366206497,
0.5060369968,
-0.7319456339,
0.9006598592,
-0.5024838448,
0.3788269758,
0.5406152606,
-0.1815777719,
0.3934594095,
0.2064031512,
0.3362668753,
-0.2533210516,
0.1396211535,
-0.7295591831,
-0.7037927508,
0.2823270559,
-0.6734981537,
-0.5739989281,
-0.1073624641,
-0.1730104685,
-0.284709543,
0.4957340062,
0.3822958767,
0.3476914465,
-0.2252837718,
0.2737899721,
0.5626587868,
-0.1715695858,
0.4770714343,
0.2989654839,
-0.3074355423,
-0.1664842814,
0.9047585726,
0.091873236,
0.1944448799,
0.2193604261,
0.3403092623,
-0.3206968904,
-0.6890105605,
-0.2361515015,
-0.0839148685,
-0.8508476019,
-0.1108853221,
-0.2477484196,
0.0049316757,
-0.1926219463,
-0.1374780983,
-0.4536440969,
0.0442395359,
-0.4470253587,
-0.1336042434,
0.1968942434,
0.5135942698,
0.1059849784,
-0.0004883457,
-0.4072577953,
0.7838031054,
0.7821998596,
0.1915718466,
-0.1424902529,
-0.2805213034,
0.0604408495,
-0.2069690228,
0.2332638502,
-0.4917655885,
0.3368441463,
-0.0574760437,
0.6318099499,
0.5478553772,
0.476660192,
0.8967285752,
-0.5188231468,
0.4488652349,
0.449840337,
-0.9355527759,
0.6456571221,
-0.0857138932,
-0.1143454611,
0.7324815392,
0.5045750737,
0.1916885972,
-0.0215206053,
-0.6522024274,
-0.895249784,
0.3609787822,
0.2870571315,
-0.191573292,
0.1253295541,
0.1161350459,
-0.1777885109,
-0.1872481555,
-0.8911375403,
0.0435241684,
-0.5504891872,
0.1181868687,
-0.3645709157,
-0.4763362408,
-0.1029478759,
-0.4079765081,
0.3264517784,
-0.0654676259,
-0.3279617429,
0.4614934921,
-0.4115003049,
0.0952439159,
0.1037932485,
0.5759010911,
0.9242305756,
-0.3627358675,
0.3996839821,
0.2871775925,
-0.2758692205,
0.0413830876,
-0.1346063316,
-0.0946571678,
-0.2603484988,
0.6150996089,
1.0329613686,
0.3626458347,
-1.0054152012,
1.0858278275,
-0.3859552741,
-0.2184131891,
-0.5401644707,
0.0060679098,
-0.0310401674,
0.3685870469,
0.0538602136,
0.2333690822,
0.0816640779,
-0.4569908679,
0.4111840725,
0.359158814,
-0.536002636,
-0.3297286332,
0.551658392,
0.0128241209,
-0.2086951584,
0.5826846957,
-0.3819037676,
-0.2953421175,
0.3894068599,
0.5426287651,
0.6033542156,
0.1147762388,
0.114142634,
0.3827942908,
0.3036831319,
-0.2532598972,
0.4398100972,
-0.2883142233,
-0.9226091504,
-0.6588791013,
-0.6843038797,
-0.3639761508,
-0.0126034589,
-0.8011410236,
0.3703059852,
-0.5725457668,
-0.0213368572,
-0.0260164682,
-0.2568889856,
-0.8788631558,
0.3488966525,
-0.2097962499,
0.4125680029,
-1.0836724043,
0.928096354,
0.4761201441,
-0.8796093464,
-0.8688716888,
-0.0929605588,
-0.1541327536,
-0.7665364146,
1.1118962765,
-0.0973314419,
-0.2736171782,
-0.0987494066,
-0.8399752975,
-0.7834147215,
0.6652316451,
0.348330617,
-0.3613786101,
-0.05114232,
-0.4356324077,
0.5495125055,
0.1610048711,
0.0370495245,
0.5476593971,
0.5422155857,
0.2499894202,
-0.6350215673,
0.1601616144,
-0.376273632,
-0.0802991986,
-0.2974225283,
-0.4185956717,
0.6009537578,
-0.5760504603,
-0.3042163849,
-0.0068770773,
0.7417038679,
0.4065865278,
0.4048718214,
0.7874159813,
0.659006238,
0.3965118229,
0.1721385419,
1.0998214483,
0.4508089125,
0.3291597962,
1.2493584156,
-0.1937421411,
1.1541591883,
0.8419870138,
-0.2380989045,
0.2104702145,
0.3314415514,
0.0399021879,
0.6483190656,
0.2811958194,
-0.0860720277,
-0.4124892652,
-0.4198721945,
-0.1247755811,
0.7062827945,
0.3828451335,
-0.2048866749,
0.0535664819,
0.1906230897,
-0.1598480195,
0.2242618501,
-0.3529475331,
0.7713097334,
0.1327822357,
-0.6933435798,
0.8719013929,
-0.3722972572,
0.3658545017,
-0.2648393512,
0.0613324232,
-0.1328531504,
0.2911845446,
-0.2983458936,
-0.4269740582,
0.5107136965,
0.0288947895,
-0.116410248,
-0.5124922991,
1.0299931765,
-0.0343578085,
-0.6394402981,
0.2179176807,
0.4160411656,
0.115364112,
-0.0492141396,
-0.3802145123,
-0.1140424386,
-0.0511932299,
-0.4676992297,
0.319740653,
0.5640546679,
0.0290250368,
0.7479332685,
0.6358512044,
0.0096328566,
-0.1238309294,
0.3302529752,
0.7683874369,
-0.573754847,
-0.0798279047,
-0.9132069349,
0.6072267294,
-0.0285768434,
-0.2305040061,
0.8136197925,
0.1513639241,
0.8714362979,
-0.1751639992,
0.6567758322,
0.1553986222,
0.1761572212,
-0.8621265292,
0.7446959019,
-0.7949817181,
0.1104068458,
-0.698573947,
-0.708193779,
-0.6133345366,
0.780652225,
-0.4850966036,
-0.1786826253,
0.672537744,
0.8261309862,
-0.1849993467,
-0.2728154063,
0.4700844288,
0.1399669796,
0.0076725474,
0.4351347685,
1.0865211487,
-0.12909168,
0.8793097138,
-0.4137143493,
-0.2233590186,
-0.2199003398,
-1.1075818539,
-1.1186813116,
-0.6639104486,
-0.2490541488,
-0.3335627615,
0.0369550064,
0.5834530592,
0.915499866,
-0.6576837301,
0.0122334771,
-0.4974641502,
0.4472045302,
-0.1743241102,
-0.1863406301,
0.548776865,
-0.3548875153,
-0.551325798,
0.2186524272,
0.2770843506,
0.1972636133,
-0.2893351018,
-0.1205226108,
-0.1441934258,
-0.2849268317,
0.6715140939,
0.4472216964,
-0.7109327316,
-0.2629608512,
-0.1900449991,
-0.0211917162,
-0.1075009033,
0.7302772403,
-0.8255038261,
0.5938029885,
0.7051134109,
0.4936822355,
0.5353819132,
0.1009115726,
0.4606296122,
-0.8369851708,
0.4746387899,
0.3439955711,
0.6719981432,
0.2266074866,
0.0104859229,
0.3704039752,
0.5464439392,
-0.4095648825,
-0.9901990294,
0.424259901,
-0.9351754189,
-0.501973927,
1.0976749659,
-0.3506221473,
-0.5622905493,
-0.3691863418,
-0.2497343272,
0.0466039479,
0.2145195603,
0.6162042022,
0.2807509005,
0.1469680518,
-0.6340922713,
-0.4768673182,
0.8163924217,
0.4795436561,
-0.9393966794,
0.1521752924,
0.4317941666,
0.2067223936,
0.0820213929,
0.8238813877,
0.1641060561,
0.2725042701,
0.3196222186,
0.0786140561,
0.0544609986,
-0.370467186,
0.2431099266,
0.1901085377,
0.1759404838,
-0.1608010083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13225v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13225v2 | Multi-Task Instruction Tuning of LLaMa for Specific Scenarios: A Preliminary Study on Writing Assistance | 2023-05-22T16:56:44 | 2023-10-09T07:55:26 | Yue Zhang, Leyang Cui, Deng Cai, Xinting Huang, Tao Fang, Wei Bi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Proprietary Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have garnered
significant attention due to their exceptional capabilities in handling a
diverse range of tasks. Recent studies demonstrate that open-sourced smaller
foundational models, such as 7B-size LLaMA, can also display remarkable
proficiency in tackling diverse tasks when fine-tuned using instruction-driven
data. In this work, we investigate a practical problem setting where the
primary focus is on one or a few particular tasks rather than general-purpose
instruction following, and explore whether LLMs can be beneficial and further
improved for such targeted scenarios. We choose the writing-assistant scenario
as the testbed, which includes seven writing tasks. We collect training data
for these tasks, reframe them in an instruction-following format, and
subsequently refine the LLM, specifically LLaMA, via instruction tuning.
Experimental results show that fine-tuning LLaMA on writing instruction data
significantly improves its ability on writing tasks. We also conduct more
experiments and analyses to offer insights for future work on effectively
fine-tuning LLaMA for specific scenarios. Finally, we initiate a discussion
regarding the necessity of employing LLMs for only one targeted task, taking
into account the efforts required for tuning and the resources consumed during
deployment. | [
-0.0111042783,
-1.0098437071,
0.5987795591,
0.3836137354,
-0.2456475645,
0.1511826217,
-0.6009371281,
-0.4367396533,
0.116495274,
0.6403258443,
-0.6861664057,
-0.6882566214,
-0.7414242029,
0.2377798408,
-0.2872772217,
1.2262859344,
-0.21579355,
-0.3139696121,
-0.311678648,
0.0727662444,
-1.0245879889,
-0.4323628247,
-0.7269183397,
-0.1472565383,
0.7326605916,
1.0641479492,
0.2992471755,
0.9395084381,
0.6235787272,
0.2792274356,
0.1706817597,
0.5526217222,
-0.6239441037,
0.1184175834,
0.2585842013,
-0.530343771,
-0.5443519354,
-0.1760177165,
0.6007634401,
0.5620097518,
-0.3307126462,
0.4559893012,
0.2783800066,
0.5093509555,
-0.5939102769,
0.166782245,
-0.7182863355,
-0.0260180794,
-0.272092998,
-0.2032552958,
-0.4715997577,
-0.3391676545,
-0.018681448,
-0.7880573273,
0.4203351438,
0.2516626418,
0.4789717197,
0.4872552156,
-0.2882272601,
-0.4419487119,
-0.6037507653,
0.8181515932,
-0.7813756466,
-0.0220935903,
0.4883410633,
0.0532535166,
-0.208978042,
-0.4375584722,
-0.5449811816,
-0.4083101749,
0.086570017,
0.0549758375,
0.0131070865,
0.0738240853,
0.3228461146,
0.35004884,
-0.4077953696,
0.4624373615,
-0.3034914136,
-0.0387794673,
0.4489599168,
0.3716638684,
0.1176226959,
0.2445922792,
-0.0975301713,
0.0434162766,
-0.8164638281,
0.0121358717,
0.579900682,
0.4667150676,
-0.2033704072,
0.7380868196,
-0.2513638735,
0.7361474633,
-0.0033349763,
-0.2539233863,
-0.01139443,
-0.1877921075,
-0.1412292868,
-0.0152608333,
0.5082173944,
0.4245737791,
0.367996037,
-0.2191316783,
-0.1986604929,
0.187514782,
0.4911720157,
-0.6213951707,
-0.1700262725,
-0.1408629119,
-0.2913244963,
-0.2631829679,
-0.3937930465,
-0.6283897161,
-0.6908130646,
-0.4207456112,
0.4350836277,
-0.2207352966,
-0.0853432864,
0.1439661831,
0.124919951,
0.2132443041,
0.378133595,
-1.2288905382,
0.3608139753,
0.6381683946,
0.8068611026,
-0.3276664615,
-0.5655192137,
-0.7029805183,
0.2739160955,
-0.2209216356,
1.0258764029,
-0.7827382684,
-0.5617960691,
0.0014839339,
-0.1043265983,
-0.345579505,
-0.5052210689,
0.4738197327,
-0.0295012426,
-0.0475580804,
-0.2625122666,
-0.472982645,
0.0802788734,
0.3306635022,
-0.6002749205,
0.9997681975,
-0.0790292397,
-0.4248513281,
0.1800554395,
-0.679433167,
-0.7605302334,
-0.3004613221,
-0.080603905,
-0.4299865365,
0.1403757483,
0.2983353138,
0.6433452368,
-0.3246774673,
-0.1368856132,
-0.0570792854,
-0.6012141705,
0.1278484613,
-0.4648143947,
0.0107331015,
-0.140516609,
-0.3342363536,
0.2246091366,
-0.8720635772,
-0.1629193872,
0.0496429354,
-0.6833315492,
0.0195422135,
0.0759530663,
-0.0974823609,
-0.3702421188,
0.4253883064,
-0.621450901,
0.5622087121,
-0.0128207905,
0.3140377104,
0.7734331489,
-0.0993803516,
0.3218019605,
-0.6020749211,
0.7566635609,
-0.2936343849,
0.0677661076,
-0.3551404178,
-0.5959721804,
-0.9471302032,
-0.2706602216,
0.0936858952,
0.6923938394,
-0.4694772065,
-0.0749382675,
0.0312302951,
-0.3932801783,
-0.7630708218,
0.4678617418,
0.5997442007,
0.7058122158,
0.3415121734,
-0.0879498646,
-0.5252050161,
-0.884644568,
-0.1540381163,
0.1283382475,
0.2538085878,
0.3371769488,
0.179398343,
-0.0799303204,
0.4979824126,
-0.7820504904,
-0.4833559096,
-0.3759909272,
0.0840154514,
0.1461613029,
0.397990346,
0.286336571,
-0.3321856856,
-0.5589494705,
0.1197908893,
-0.4103565216,
-0.3131181598,
-0.3206136227,
-0.1254568696,
0.2102214694,
0.4686556458,
-0.4720433056,
0.3054394126,
0.6427451968,
0.0265528485,
0.6389348507,
-0.5319415927,
0.1048070267,
-0.9676195979,
-0.1083780453,
-0.0133002056,
-0.0225136094,
-0.6119017601,
-0.1091903299,
0.0198488384,
-0.0619642176,
-0.000616511,
0.2379195839,
-0.5150262117,
0.0997906327,
-0.626200974,
-0.0703852773,
-0.1198774651,
0.6669142246,
0.1051061153,
0.9473228455,
0.3787928224,
-0.468152225,
0.059359327,
0.1831050366,
-0.2041200399,
0.3528650403,
-0.6498037577,
0.5438671112,
-0.0256902464,
0.0564916171,
-0.9100776911,
-0.1915751845,
0.1701395959,
-0.0962311402,
0.2672999501,
0.0908106342,
-0.5704398155,
-0.0406870358,
-0.1940261722,
-0.0047988296,
0.3166711926,
-0.3912793994,
0.5405273438,
0.2013895512,
-0.2728425562,
-0.660178721,
-0.5819287896,
-0.0458401553,
-0.4047289789,
-0.3454495966,
0.3424137533,
-0.1500307769,
0.1150880828,
-0.2285565883,
-0.1508985758,
-0.0075633288,
0.2105392814,
0.5563434362,
0.2690135837,
-0.30061993,
0.1221657619,
0.284266144,
-0.0402840599,
-0.1593596041,
0.1370658875,
0.3521842957,
-0.0179901496,
-0.4802903533,
-0.4243366718,
0.5328000188,
0.2492649406,
-0.3186092675,
0.7148016095,
0.5696852207,
-0.1530018151,
-0.4469884336,
-0.7782137394,
-0.0220285896,
-0.485018611,
0.2917924225,
-0.216024816,
-1.0489143133,
0.4161224365,
-0.1815318465,
0.4254226685,
-0.04037055,
0.5570627451,
-0.244944483,
0.7774803042,
1.0754297972,
-0.1729834974,
0.7168474793,
-0.1388357729,
0.1302121133,
-1.012447834,
-0.1557599157,
-0.5296794772,
-0.4361617267,
-0.303956598,
-0.3370834291,
0.307415247,
-0.1294441223,
-0.1843270063,
0.4170000851,
-0.5832878351,
0.7930321693,
0.7316983342,
0.1457865983,
0.4423651397,
-0.1250253916,
0.1786313653,
0.2771735787,
-0.7988299131,
-0.8557037115,
1.3028329611,
0.0718170777,
0.7349429131,
-0.0830644146,
0.6497687101,
0.174672693,
0.4869602919,
-0.6635977626,
0.5842745304,
-0.3451088965,
-0.244956851,
-0.3031100333,
-0.1102019027,
-1.0460499525,
0.1965062767,
-0.2854024172,
-0.8144898415,
-0.2974007428,
0.4264807701,
-0.3982339203,
0.0401965789,
-1.1474403143,
0.9546567202,
-0.1687245816,
-0.1996779144,
-0.3851760328,
-0.5073329806,
0.2596404552,
-0.0851039961,
0.0301485453,
-0.2901604772,
-0.1521392912,
0.548478961,
-0.1091979966,
1.3343572617,
0.1172712892,
-0.2917019427,
0.208375603,
-0.122297734,
0.4956951141,
-0.0520096458,
-0.2186944634,
-0.1779907048,
0.0321245193,
-0.2612528503,
-0.5389803648,
0.8562831283,
-0.8941082954,
-0.8637921214,
-0.1199941635,
-0.9356392026,
-0.4610123932,
0.0345970131,
0.10625799,
0.3619932234,
-0.1016758755,
0.0411529541,
0.5869439244,
-0.0746347085,
0.4541945755,
0.5851137042,
0.2315089107,
-0.0319699943,
1.0365499258,
0.0613684021,
0.2836124897,
0.4169586897,
0.1468144655,
-0.0548519827,
-0.7211902738,
-0.7053246498,
0.0954367742,
-0.6470610499,
-0.1980747432,
-0.1597174853,
0.1378109753,
-0.1528661102,
-0.2395953834,
-0.2764348984,
-0.2729023099,
-0.7287012935,
0.0978757665,
0.4315648079,
0.8125393987,
0.3342062831,
0.7603626847,
-0.7345114946,
0.3087581098,
0.1037288308,
0.3511323035,
0.0191616919,
-0.4939584136,
-0.3815033436,
-0.0982661843,
-0.5072705746,
-0.6577973962,
0.0520965308,
0.3655263186,
0.64106673,
0.0200475939,
-0.1779095083,
0.9086962938,
-0.6881759763,
0.5497815013,
-0.2130521536,
-0.7924804688,
0.5954006314,
-0.3540651202,
0.4534481764,
0.5040555596,
0.179707408,
-0.5178905725,
-0.479978323,
-0.1711832732,
-0.670135498,
0.6644282937,
0.0376385897,
0.4110402167,
0.1502891779,
0.6080815792,
0.4352917969,
0.340958029,
-0.4862766266,
0.0112916715,
0.0040774257,
-0.3851542175,
-0.1698925346,
-0.0510119721,
-0.1406223923,
0.0080191111,
0.5670005679,
-0.2611774504,
0.1495058388,
-0.1452584267,
-0.1753286868,
-0.0303011965,
0.2932701409,
0.8399584889,
0.5461277962,
0.1602190137,
-0.0592651032,
0.4856337309,
-0.7002594471,
0.0510656498,
0.1114803776,
0.0641041771,
-0.4430263042,
0.5999903679,
0.8925355077,
0.3168772757,
-0.7968133092,
0.157151103,
-0.0600756891,
-0.0550002754,
0.0450161658,
0.5714444518,
0.1973921359,
0.3841945529,
0.1461964548,
-0.0852718949,
-0.0979974046,
-0.3189464509,
-0.4124616086,
0.4015544951,
0.1866755784,
-0.1954307109,
0.4165784121,
0.2484645247,
-0.4969191849,
0.6428413391,
-0.0485475026,
-0.1198470592,
0.8702067733,
0.9038501978,
0.5118339658,
-0.1265068948,
0.192827031,
-0.0219728108,
0.4951180816,
-0.0686252937,
0.3229601383,
-0.211099267,
-0.6066655517,
-0.5756530762,
-0.4486801624,
-0.8176147342,
0.0283141453,
-0.565730691,
0.2050197124,
-0.4947821796,
0.005888816,
-0.1441551298,
0.0347808488,
-0.5765106678,
0.0447644703,
0.1340412796,
0.5565645695,
-0.7781748176,
0.8444515467,
0.9009146094,
-0.1821615845,
-0.982621789,
-0.0118596395,
-0.0760321692,
-0.9303061366,
0.173434943,
0.2887919843,
-0.3460026681,
0.0892836377,
-0.2952893674,
-0.8579620123,
1.1915209293,
0.6155941486,
-0.8673568368,
0.0580756105,
0.2960959673,
0.5975986719,
-0.5100790858,
-0.0428562313,
0.7424723506,
0.1749627143,
-0.1039167121,
-1.1596192122,
0.053702835,
-0.1858383268,
0.0912502259,
0.120623529,
-0.8557275534,
0.6661342978,
-0.421810627,
0.053668227,
0.2948871851,
0.6385464072,
0.2995326221,
0.2517574728,
0.4746997356,
0.3926762342,
0.9088745117,
0.199552834,
0.9493507147,
-0.1393644959,
-0.1675558984,
1.2747879028,
-0.403221488,
0.8949716687,
0.5089437962,
0.1060586944,
0.5230389833,
0.5381509066,
0.0465767533,
0.4239167571,
0.36260885,
-0.3542597294,
-0.1086766124,
-0.1945297569,
-0.2620651126,
0.5302596688,
0.3072096407,
-0.0962847695,
-0.0065748054,
0.301155597,
0.0851321369,
0.1699580252,
-0.4026933312,
0.7529425025,
0.0281495769,
-0.7726684213,
0.2898220122,
0.0088576777,
0.6028519869,
-0.6004924774,
-0.2089759111,
-0.2784164548,
0.2665110826,
-0.2103746682,
-0.7175402045,
0.2228414416,
0.4259673059,
-0.2466667145,
-0.2940295041,
0.6758800149,
-0.4116747975,
-0.4811675251,
-0.2375766486,
0.3703418076,
0.0586073026,
0.0337365493,
-0.3165511489,
0.4602063298,
-0.1810483634,
-0.3275698423,
0.5607897639,
0.4050246477,
-0.0352603383,
0.8085154295,
0.621142447,
0.1160562634,
0.1432020813,
0.1682320237,
0.991631031,
-0.3566731811,
-0.2985703647,
-0.7489515543,
0.3797504306,
0.1372450441,
-0.7681808472,
0.8295803666,
0.4752651155,
0.6659772396,
-0.1175789535,
0.7248026729,
0.230446592,
0.4845005572,
-0.6668715477,
0.3916099966,
-0.3452926874,
0.3492037356,
-0.1381894946,
-0.8571385741,
-0.2709158957,
0.6423239708,
-0.4537604153,
-0.0677142963,
0.6355425119,
0.9222716093,
-0.0155294081,
0.2368045449,
0.1067172363,
-0.2575773895,
0.1396624297,
0.6663249135,
0.7653889656,
-0.0276660603,
0.7623201013,
-0.3286192417,
-0.1091000289,
0.0021654447,
-1.0235893726,
-1.0376195908,
-0.4051276445,
-0.2849058807,
0.1926204264,
0.1710256785,
0.8165907264,
0.5799794197,
-0.457108438,
-0.4368017912,
0.0806970298,
0.0118612545,
-0.2785740197,
-0.0789090469,
0.2759897709,
-0.4221676886,
-0.678091526,
0.5871742368,
0.1713462472,
-0.0593789108,
-0.0818161964,
0.094022572,
0.0194283687,
-0.0139259892,
0.5603383183,
0.1816484183,
-0.5376078486,
-0.4292861819,
0.2020816207,
-0.0751843005,
0.0379078165,
0.8475135565,
-0.552116394,
0.1072707623,
0.0348104537,
0.9180268645,
0.6263195276,
-0.0040961434,
0.5399377346,
-0.8866989017,
-0.0090880534,
0.0813779384,
0.1105974317,
0.4010234177,
-0.5811433196,
0.3168362379,
-0.2297807634,
-0.8046622276,
-0.7703303099,
-0.0721723437,
-1.0824745893,
-0.0339936279,
1.1699198484,
-0.1739558578,
0.0073642712,
0.1543108225,
-0.7058603764,
0.3090217412,
-0.3628166914,
0.9203226566,
0.8210359216,
-0.5043689609,
-0.3901589811,
-0.7287404537,
0.2796139717,
0.6320881248,
-1.1210372448,
0.0821614861,
0.5058206916,
0.2198525071,
-0.1894808859,
0.7357386351,
0.5436480045,
0.3201241195,
-0.0221231934,
-0.1758490801,
-0.3513612747,
-0.4015977085,
-0.1883051544,
0.0845175907,
0.3394177556,
-0.4461651444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13214v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13214v1 | Logical Reasoning for Natural Language Inference Using Generated Facts as Atoms | 2023-05-22T16:45:50 | 2023-05-22T16:45:50 | Joe Stacey, Pasquale Minervini, Haim Dubossarsky, Oana-Maria Camburu, Marek Rei | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | State-of-the-art neural models can now reach human performance levels across
various natural language understanding tasks. However, despite this impressive
performance, models are known to learn from annotation artefacts at the expense
of the underlying task. While interpretability methods can identify influential
features for each prediction, there are no guarantees that these features are
responsible for the model decisions. Instead, we introduce a model-agnostic
logical framework to determine the specific information in an input responsible
for each model decision. This method creates interpretable Natural Language
Inference (NLI) models that maintain their predictive power. We achieve this by
generating facts that decompose complex NLI observations into individual
logical atoms. Our model makes predictions for each atom and uses logical rules
to decide the class of the observation based on the predictions for each atom.
We apply our method to the highly challenging ANLI dataset, where our framework
improves the performance of both a DeBERTa-base and BERT baseline. Our method
performs best on the most challenging examples, achieving a new
state-of-the-art for the ANLI round 3 test set. We outperform every baseline in
a reduced-data setting, and despite using no annotations for the generated
facts, our model predictions for individual facts align with human
expectations. | [
-0.0958242342,
-0.9588544965,
0.8909249306,
0.059804678,
0.0438874029,
-0.2399490476,
-0.1043972,
-0.6016904116,
-0.2170987874,
0.6426515579,
-0.6777186394,
-0.4398964643,
-0.3213989437,
0.4348984361,
-0.3685713112,
0.7537344098,
0.4929039478,
-0.18056871,
-0.3069380224,
-0.0465792008,
-0.3074848354,
-0.3101066053,
-0.5611858368,
-0.4611532688,
0.0753454864,
0.3575203717,
0.9389907718,
0.9928665161,
0.3232584596,
0.3797608614,
-0.266988039,
0.2349603623,
-0.0055789775,
-0.1551889479,
-0.3363569677,
-0.6321014166,
-0.2062613815,
0.0396361016,
0.4179053009,
0.7111192346,
-0.1657075584,
-0.0329473242,
-0.5165513158,
0.4987814128,
-0.61933285,
0.2004148513,
-0.7740638256,
0.2059191614,
-0.0494483151,
-0.0158885028,
-0.6790543199,
-0.4929693937,
0.3527954817,
-0.9876992702,
0.1231678426,
0.2130379826,
0.9956995845,
0.4055607319,
-0.5199636221,
-0.3825386763,
-0.6758729219,
1.0203512907,
-1.1453734636,
0.3676210642,
0.4278826118,
0.4135645032,
-0.1332417727,
-0.5936765671,
-0.8241900802,
-0.4100495875,
-0.327437222,
-0.0035190708,
-0.2790358663,
0.0746657923,
0.3679825068,
0.2224720269,
-0.475379467,
-0.0929611102,
-0.0578705333,
-0.1408840567,
0.6977922916,
-0.0031471143,
0.5054729581,
-0.4823261797,
-0.4596929252,
0.188334316,
-0.5895268321,
-0.1327582449,
0.3645675778,
0.3461685777,
0.0985696167,
0.4778604507,
-0.2946383357,
0.8918409944,
-0.2017801553,
-0.1558078527,
0.2460564971,
-0.3845721781,
-0.3047604263,
0.4159355164,
0.5654163957,
0.1300706416,
0.5989307761,
-0.3669309914,
-0.085356243,
0.3582214713,
0.2507804334,
-0.7934213877,
-0.3186244965,
0.1186843812,
-0.2180829495,
-0.4721302986,
-0.023642309,
-0.4767430425,
-0.5007113814,
-0.7432152629,
0.4303880036,
-0.6725318432,
-0.2849668562,
0.2723185122,
-0.2913784087,
-0.0522258878,
0.4142926633,
-0.9242426157,
0.3593226671,
0.5707268715,
0.4493879974,
0.2625573277,
-0.2148744315,
-0.3460514545,
0.2109410465,
-0.3697857857,
0.8668760657,
-0.6369644403,
0.0544945486,
-0.287458837,
-0.4368722141,
-0.1114955768,
-0.5709118247,
0.5393542051,
-0.3670458496,
0.2907666266,
-0.3898269236,
-0.8360916376,
-0.611675024,
0.2920350134,
-0.5185302496,
0.5926975012,
-0.0607480146,
-0.7912528515,
0.4510385692,
-0.7995384336,
-0.474830091,
0.0412057489,
-0.2272229642,
-0.0735048354,
0.0887293443,
0.2588347197,
0.1227285936,
-0.4349509776,
0.6556087732,
-0.4378648102,
-0.0531679541,
0.4201167822,
-0.5565018654,
0.8801555634,
0.3311132491,
-0.3914628923,
0.2554539144,
-1.1821621656,
0.0071068997,
-0.0474311002,
-0.1537128836,
-0.228328228,
0.5196371078,
-0.1524584889,
0.151450634,
-0.1846443415,
-0.7605930567,
0.0162832625,
-0.6232382059,
0.7134110928,
0.6588765383,
0.1904214472,
0.4885658622,
-0.1508830637,
-0.0187029745,
0.0852862373,
0.1014427319,
0.1294493079,
-0.5137560368,
-0.7879037261,
-0.3843142092,
0.2144693732,
0.6971376538,
-0.7122558951,
0.6399235725,
-0.2507393956,
-0.322067976,
-0.580793798,
0.1616977006,
0.2416219711,
0.8826793432,
0.4321986437,
0.3286797404,
-0.7445225716,
-1.211283803,
-0.341053158,
-0.4073785841,
-0.0949899107,
-0.0564971901,
0.5175619125,
-0.3020581901,
1.2621854544,
-0.4314437807,
-0.1116024405,
-0.3778533936,
0.4264392257,
0.4319595397,
0.3380039334,
0.3511978686,
-0.8886803985,
0.0533750728,
0.0583233498,
-1.1008933783,
-0.1859580725,
-0.378639251,
-0.2915374935,
0.1700793058,
0.1874961704,
-0.6382818818,
0.7109875679,
0.119524613,
-0.6520919204,
0.2532666028,
0.0314205661,
-0.0229043644,
-0.7441725135,
0.2249595374,
0.0506699495,
-0.2436906248,
-0.8875946999,
-0.3864707947,
-0.0345153362,
0.113487795,
-0.3147037625,
0.6468314528,
0.0107546784,
-0.0346298777,
-0.3558341861,
-0.0313566029,
0.3939237297,
0.3188568652,
0.3645341992,
0.5015209317,
0.3357664645,
-0.6568364501,
0.040582601,
0.4009922445,
-0.4466219246,
0.1719991714,
-0.5900388956,
-0.2742578983,
-0.203584671,
0.052535519,
-0.5717720985,
-0.1344100386,
0.2001322955,
-0.4986056983,
-0.0905683562,
0.2666557133,
-0.4947225153,
0.1366866678,
0.1257228404,
0.0567964949,
0.3459703922,
-0.5261086226,
0.9522505999,
0.1676552296,
0.0831556022,
-0.5166472793,
-0.8261381984,
0.0540097319,
-0.1556495279,
-0.6276640892,
0.2555912137,
-0.0501128659,
-0.6586633921,
0.5029515028,
-0.1551835686,
-0.2079072744,
0.3914738297,
0.2123764753,
0.2736933827,
-0.2498136461,
0.101103045,
-0.0841296166,
-0.2032763809,
0.361459136,
-0.1999978274,
-0.0515614189,
-0.3986302316,
-0.1264618039,
-0.6091020703,
0.32810992,
0.4969964325,
-0.1984479576,
0.7030769587,
0.4152608514,
-0.6891236305,
-0.3997021019,
-0.5162149072,
-0.1650317311,
-0.3801016212,
0.111058034,
-0.2676322162,
-0.4889892042,
0.4223709702,
0.2556244135,
0.094390139,
0.51115942,
0.367421478,
0.1431688517,
1.2796696424,
0.2829968631,
0.1500489712,
0.0823488384,
-0.0938182697,
0.4573960602,
-0.3601920307,
-0.1379672587,
-0.2519055009,
0.0984376892,
-0.2496470362,
-0.0715509281,
0.17716223,
0.2505617142,
-0.3992162347,
0.1514758617,
-0.2515909672,
0.4614515007,
0.6775299311,
0.0829565004,
0.4270317256,
-0.3293211758,
0.0314816758,
0.179063037,
-0.5559310913,
-0.5986002088,
0.6923263669,
0.2648477256,
0.36238572,
0.367477417,
0.3649824262,
0.3366625011,
0.5063849092,
-0.703800559,
0.567884028,
-0.0006841557,
-0.9883158803,
-0.1412646025,
-0.7672836781,
-0.4417098463,
0.3244072795,
-0.4853235185,
-0.7681034207,
0.0900535285,
0.2432375103,
-0.4467760026,
0.3068098426,
-0.8117421865,
0.8921474814,
-0.213572681,
-0.242104724,
-0.2224425375,
-0.6369162798,
0.4833082259,
0.0894829333,
0.3541533649,
-0.4863730669,
0.2873600423,
0.4912509024,
-0.4905803502,
0.7489628792,
-0.2242677361,
0.1850459427,
0.4891465902,
0.0627394766,
0.1092465743,
0.3366492391,
-0.5399506688,
0.1066688448,
-0.0802445188,
-0.2366031706,
-1.0088125467,
0.355984956,
-0.6501145959,
-0.6662957668,
-0.442889303,
-0.6586532593,
-0.0375296846,
0.3714930415,
0.1981813163,
0.6084162593,
0.1463738978,
0.0371820219,
0.4282176197,
-0.0865529776,
0.3442651033,
0.3522574604,
-0.1977146119,
-0.4709856212,
0.9350181222,
-0.050867781,
0.199128598,
0.5273655653,
0.5363382101,
-0.5684422255,
-0.5969156623,
-0.5971933603,
0.0678913444,
-0.905151248,
-0.2080149353,
-0.4109558165,
-0.2038414925,
-0.4768075347,
-0.0743003786,
-0.2505624294,
-0.5202736259,
-0.1933014393,
-0.32885921,
0.2897430956,
0.792242229,
-0.0288090184,
-0.0036846045,
-0.7491208315,
0.4636487663,
0.3396104872,
0.0324642584,
-0.132758528,
-0.3441910148,
0.1201558113,
0.0432447344,
-0.0191560164,
-0.9033938646,
0.3971271813,
0.3725862801,
0.5701719522,
0.4377960563,
0.2573645413,
0.5808674097,
-0.4931018054,
0.483107239,
-0.0500883311,
-1.2956564426,
0.7709469199,
-0.2310342491,
0.253934592,
0.7450194955,
0.1837743819,
-0.1802319884,
-0.3178408146,
-0.6830122471,
-0.771214664,
0.6866835356,
0.4905901253,
-0.3699119687,
-0.1933746934,
0.3366786838,
-0.03207637,
0.3473773301,
-0.8401024342,
-0.0463192873,
-0.3402091265,
-0.482596606,
0.0572415702,
0.0403784029,
0.023072172,
-0.3720340729,
0.8515512347,
-0.1722823083,
-0.0363570638,
0.2889653742,
-0.2524366975,
0.0464043692,
0.3243740499,
0.434743464,
0.8557266593,
-0.5153283477,
0.3006946146,
0.3009833992,
-0.0166220888,
-0.0455826223,
0.0924014449,
-0.3771588206,
-0.0758984312,
0.6423261762,
1.0447882414,
0.148755759,
-0.9038403034,
0.353702575,
-0.2136719227,
-0.2929802239,
-0.4571647644,
0.2331746072,
-0.0046827006,
0.2092023343,
0.2261471003,
0.3889747858,
0.4793196917,
-0.5823768973,
0.3454980552,
0.1623799354,
-0.2112802267,
-0.3991630375,
0.6408153772,
0.1485486478,
-0.094192259,
0.8062860966,
-0.47318694,
-0.538864255,
0.6002671123,
0.6145636439,
0.6941739321,
0.1120460033,
0.1419032663,
0.3929386437,
0.2798045576,
0.0952039659,
0.212535888,
-0.0172729883,
-0.987372458,
-0.58966434,
-0.7552175522,
-0.4646729827,
0.1043441445,
-0.820720613,
0.08289022,
-0.5563246608,
0.1344958693,
0.3801047504,
-0.134403348,
-0.4455043674,
0.5343430042,
0.4508224726,
0.9567462206,
-1.1804500818,
0.7412875891,
0.7022739649,
-0.2736531496,
-0.7288113236,
-0.1262288988,
0.3010455072,
-0.4819432199,
0.6775046587,
0.517865777,
-0.0679691434,
0.0867741033,
-0.2100226581,
-0.8015059829,
0.8090466857,
0.6565032005,
-0.0239070132,
-0.0685758367,
0.0854922459,
0.3529329002,
-0.337941587,
0.5500558615,
0.7923153043,
0.6994234324,
0.2004122883,
-0.289137274,
0.1183257997,
-0.4860071838,
0.1312151402,
0.0642271936,
0.0140910977,
0.7090340853,
-0.2523566782,
-0.3409570754,
-0.0652061626,
0.8911734223,
0.4154102802,
0.2925873995,
0.8600125909,
0.8566426039,
0.8733979464,
0.0275351722,
1.1163967848,
-0.0590016693,
0.1172169298,
1.0217890739,
-0.4417987168,
0.892796874,
0.3034399748,
0.1837826371,
0.6858316064,
0.3938004673,
0.134920463,
0.3850777447,
0.2062879801,
-0.3907399774,
-0.6138166785,
-0.3913549185,
0.0969879478,
0.7907557487,
0.4298172891,
-0.0538786687,
-0.5037404895,
-0.1344934851,
0.0461207554,
0.4130268693,
0.0224488117,
0.7351408601,
-0.2035454512,
-0.7614367008,
0.4043900967,
-0.0609694533,
0.2395440936,
-0.5599833727,
-0.4092096388,
0.0659677312,
0.2562425137,
-0.3249435127,
-0.5285861492,
0.526941359,
0.107473135,
-0.4110228717,
-0.1934824735,
0.6297766566,
-0.2702635527,
-0.6309682131,
0.2311857939,
0.1934638172,
-0.145628199,
0.1319287419,
-0.6246182323,
-0.0960370824,
0.2145916373,
-0.4551489353,
0.019759601,
0.4268531203,
0.0305223614,
0.7651856542,
0.702732563,
0.0182529241,
-0.1100419462,
0.0373429656,
0.6495019197,
-0.6604943871,
-0.4070495665,
-1.0263850689,
0.6102682352,
-0.2605393231,
-0.3720013797,
0.7026129961,
0.4301916659,
0.5570657253,
0.1364705861,
0.914886117,
-0.0849224702,
0.6101311445,
-0.8361011744,
0.6192877293,
-0.3555829823,
0.3200862408,
0.1395016909,
-0.586745739,
-0.5156790018,
0.8551087976,
-0.3792808652,
-0.2503912747,
0.671762228,
0.6504206061,
0.0978137925,
0.614695251,
0.1209037974,
0.3258518875,
0.4051348865,
0.5314904451,
0.9868819118,
-0.1740465611,
0.1889095008,
-0.5544003844,
-0.0240401626,
0.1529920101,
-1.2721487284,
-0.7887901664,
-0.108550027,
-0.4860987365,
-0.0961245745,
0.0373200886,
0.9405642748,
0.8361642957,
-1.0102081299,
-0.0361237638,
-0.6952379346,
0.2449451238,
-0.2013006508,
-0.274733156,
0.2200630307,
-0.5492883325,
-0.5480554104,
0.6675320864,
0.1371765584,
-0.3279825747,
0.1653705686,
0.0234464891,
-0.6147172451,
0.1918450892,
0.3977946937,
0.2891479731,
-0.9313160181,
-0.6152412295,
-0.2122983336,
0.1418180466,
-0.0519966707,
0.3027141392,
-0.9123575091,
0.5177779794,
0.5629298091,
0.9272096753,
0.0155269671,
0.2003625035,
0.639349401,
-0.6929191351,
0.1164608598,
0.3737346232,
0.2938229442,
0.2983410656,
-0.3013912439,
0.517465055,
0.3129789233,
-0.3576335907,
-0.8747311831,
0.3103270531,
-0.7362501621,
-0.4937762022,
0.9561235309,
-0.1536363959,
-0.4464840889,
0.0196250547,
0.1413849145,
0.297039777,
-0.2189826816,
0.4618056417,
0.4952907264,
-0.3231615424,
-0.0268486217,
-0.7567825317,
0.4844706953,
0.6822628379,
-1.0526832342,
0.0436956473,
0.5285682082,
0.0910725743,
0.3389562368,
0.1801467985,
0.1636148393,
0.1429390162,
0.0295313038,
0.1544944048,
-0.2631470263,
-0.5691413283,
-0.1573056281,
0.0128021669,
0.0862255543,
0.0300465748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13204v1 | Improving Isochronous Machine Translation with Target Factors and Auxiliary Counters | 2023-05-22T16:36:04 | 2023-05-22T16:36:04 | Proyag Pal, Brian Thompson, Yogesh Virkar, Prashant Mathur, Alexandra Chronopoulou, Marcello Federico | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | To translate speech for automatic dubbing, machine translation needs to be
isochronous, i.e. translated speech needs to be aligned with the source in
terms of speech durations. We introduce target factors in a transformer model
to predict durations jointly with target language phoneme sequences. We also
introduce auxiliary counters to help the decoder to keep track of the timing
information while generating target phonemes. We show that our model improves
translation quality and isochrony compared to previous work where the
translation model is instead trained to predict interleaved sequences of
phonemes and durations. | [
-0.3443863988,
-0.4666987062,
0.4630862176,
0.3823493123,
-0.7490817308,
0.0674981177,
-0.1444183886,
-0.4834480584,
0.0217549037,
0.5067477226,
-0.4970613122,
-0.0838648751,
-0.7645727992,
0.4692803323,
-0.7077801824,
0.7213948369,
-0.1312405914,
0.4975568354,
0.0378669128,
-0.2356485426,
-0.5587249398,
-0.561647892,
-0.6098157763,
-0.6711791158,
0.0349711068,
0.6982890964,
1.0632098913,
0.9710319042,
0.7135935426,
0.2149808407,
0.2420233786,
0.0316745266,
-0.0701687485,
0.3430912495,
0.268228054,
-0.6450118423,
-0.2900274694,
-0.0709846616,
0.7767161131,
0.5693114996,
-0.031778153,
0.0806948096,
-0.0627883971,
0.3667898178,
-0.16237095,
0.1836140603,
-0.3822311461,
0.1489775777,
-0.2277294844,
-0.4106106758,
-0.6730799079,
-0.0869873092,
-0.4681848586,
-0.3996134996,
0.2418479025,
0.0844075233,
0.6949068308,
0.8273512125,
-0.4459555149,
0.0701422691,
-1.1824069023,
0.6368963122,
-0.875624299,
0.8574594259,
0.5027341843,
0.1827430278,
-0.0545012951,
-0.7177172899,
-0.3755283356,
-0.3583025336,
-0.2302806675,
0.1110004336,
-0.2952586412,
0.0647819415,
0.3882481158,
0.2688646317,
-0.4304383099,
0.3000206351,
-0.4738791883,
-0.3007484376,
0.603002131,
0.4680808783,
0.4227142334,
-0.1351084113,
-0.2455178648,
-0.0730945468,
-0.3443301022,
0.0653259233,
0.5590922236,
0.1019069254,
-0.0431174599,
0.7862844467,
-0.2082787901,
0.6927179694,
0.3998663425,
-0.0748614296,
0.2289032191,
-0.5517007113,
0.217108801,
0.54703933,
0.7302775383,
0.3763103783,
0.2341775447,
-0.1564502567,
-0.2054730505,
0.0393507443,
0.4906978011,
-1.05184865,
-0.0578698814,
0.1599916518,
-0.2648389041,
-0.0338052586,
0.169490248,
-0.1030563489,
0.4150243402,
-0.5434846282,
0.0094688283,
-0.7739653587,
0.3319682479,
-0.3856193721,
-0.1245849878,
0.084592618,
0.1002958491,
-0.6539084911,
0.4553789496,
0.3958680928,
0.7303692102,
-0.1125871241,
-0.2146518975,
-0.9130476117,
0.0165886022,
-0.7975431681,
0.612847805,
-0.6350364685,
-0.6112605333,
-0.2255001515,
0.1638639867,
0.0080130976,
-0.3286204934,
0.610784471,
-0.5508207679,
0.2006436735,
0.1247815043,
-0.5145416856,
-0.128007248,
-0.4109304547,
-0.7691960931,
0.7692083716,
0.1327459514,
-0.2635309994,
0.2056264579,
-0.314966172,
-0.8221494555,
0.1733603328,
0.2545672655,
-0.443249315,
0.3504922092,
0.3602666855,
0.2780207992,
-0.3351906836,
0.3360946178,
0.1937304735,
-0.3174707294,
0.3620234132,
-0.3662355244,
0.5389477611,
0.5901448131,
-0.1831870228,
0.3067727983,
-0.4634769261,
-0.0665549636,
-0.2353477776,
-0.3128376603,
0.003595734,
0.2374738306,
0.1023465246,
0.2355667353,
-0.0362529196,
-0.3197120428,
-0.1597771198,
-0.3726851046,
0.3755914867,
0.2257005423,
0.1744824797,
0.7393172979,
-0.3116303682,
0.8354480267,
0.0179275945,
0.0488077886,
-0.3208816648,
-0.5804730654,
-0.6736077666,
-0.1365870684,
0.2873345315,
0.7349282503,
-0.6769499779,
0.5215867758,
-0.3631706834,
-0.5660967827,
-0.7526959777,
0.1983484179,
0.393979609,
0.4623690546,
0.6597626805,
-0.7582702041,
-0.7329698801,
-1.0464135408,
0.0313509107,
-0.2880382538,
-0.3514278531,
-0.0859366134,
0.0091016963,
-0.2300994545,
0.6040548682,
-0.2295769453,
-0.3807881773,
-0.2622990012,
0.3303245902,
0.1148180738,
0.402210325,
0.2177839726,
-0.748480618,
-0.5743183494,
-0.1546363831,
-0.4135859907,
-0.5465818048,
0.0547832139,
0.0895977989,
0.1487710625,
0.9789659381,
-0.4904580712,
0.1771164834,
0.6079357862,
-0.1662115306,
0.3470487893,
0.1496504396,
0.5880461931,
-1.1369308233,
0.1395017058,
-0.3156445622,
-0.5702369809,
-0.6564041972,
-0.1273647696,
0.1825192571,
-0.518193543,
-0.5996837616,
0.299131155,
-0.4254176021,
-0.0904181898,
-0.6368272305,
0.0076651433,
-0.1521308422,
0.0376126058,
0.2283159196,
0.9486029744,
-0.0555244349,
-0.6353930235,
0.2038070709,
0.2360031605,
-0.4081948996,
0.5553889871,
-0.7150505781,
0.0038127194,
0.2183746994,
0.3857483566,
-0.8722953796,
-0.1038783267,
0.1555708498,
-0.76704669,
0.5152328014,
-0.1611258686,
-0.3870474398,
-0.317163527,
0.2587347031,
0.4528521001,
0.6635336876,
-0.1096110567,
0.4257593453,
0.1228633747,
-0.1964377016,
-0.3453006744,
-0.5038779974,
0.1944026947,
-0.0913370848,
-0.455707103,
0.8128340244,
-0.0517533682,
-0.178712219,
0.2747325301,
-0.0794771016,
-0.104777962,
0.045505248,
0.0830943063,
0.0849761367,
-0.3032505214,
0.2105326355,
0.0189590659,
-0.5176867247,
0.1128949672,
-0.3488087356,
0.6950344443,
0.3051292002,
-0.2118481398,
-0.4985365272,
0.5377331376,
0.7992936969,
-0.332857132,
0.6030258536,
1.0473386049,
-0.4000913203,
0.1014267355,
-0.5163732767,
-0.5485723615,
-0.3367474079,
0.661403954,
-0.4768024087,
-0.3537158668,
0.4615653157,
0.2564083636,
-0.156585753,
0.6701870561,
0.3015868068,
-0.0794207305,
1.3678283691,
0.8373857141,
-0.2498310506,
0.7894980907,
0.0331637375,
0.1579462141,
-0.9238968492,
0.0746523291,
-0.5274115801,
-0.3577297926,
-0.3153699338,
-0.5519766808,
0.391834408,
0.4004873931,
-0.0822482929,
0.8928584456,
-0.35802719,
0.083779566,
0.4848313034,
-0.0590825044,
0.3481630683,
-0.1431735605,
0.0580196381,
-0.3053340912,
-0.7519083619,
-0.4755190313,
0.7451793551,
0.3550960422,
0.7696290612,
-0.0594581105,
0.5549141169,
0.219193235,
0.2682140768,
-0.8383718133,
0.2962860465,
-0.282582432,
-0.6458301544,
-0.5280669332,
-0.2734557688,
-0.7277585864,
-0.2167876959,
-0.0224729758,
-0.5629566312,
0.1185188144,
0.2013970166,
0.0760262981,
0.0378056169,
-0.3496469557,
0.6371474266,
-0.3699035048,
-0.0062729763,
-0.4923226237,
-0.6161054969,
0.2737690806,
-0.0351002216,
-0.0937425792,
-0.1791942865,
-0.1064722762,
0.7799550295,
-0.5676580071,
0.6748424172,
0.1941532046,
0.052417323,
0.3779965937,
0.2604990005,
0.4699422121,
-0.1640461534,
-0.1251263171,
0.3217298687,
-0.3352505863,
-0.2074550688,
-0.4485893846,
0.4513454437,
-0.7340027094,
-0.6592398286,
-0.2363815755,
-0.708925128,
-0.0646254197,
0.0470289327,
0.6651456356,
0.3126124442,
-0.2495990098,
0.4359972179,
0.3804843724,
0.3296788037,
0.5392553806,
0.6325395107,
-0.0217682272,
-0.5255819559,
0.3171428144,
0.3354336917,
0.618725121,
0.647360146,
-0.0805776641,
-0.4356551766,
-0.3076461852,
-0.547333777,
0.0232044142,
-0.7335650325,
-0.3907089531,
-0.7038108706,
-0.4439505637,
-0.5094028115,
-0.1383574307,
-0.5514246821,
-0.5067116022,
-0.2453595549,
-0.1300965548,
0.4861775637,
0.502584815,
-0.2472113371,
0.6346060634,
-1.0696444511,
0.4878858924,
0.1377296746,
0.0728053004,
-0.3812081516,
-1.3731074333,
-0.3654220104,
-0.0322643593,
-0.087324515,
-1.0851534605,
0.5506474376,
0.2151037455,
0.6508209705,
0.0595573634,
0.064601779,
0.5988118052,
-1.0154421329,
0.4648311436,
0.3340703845,
-1.1135718822,
0.4548558891,
0.0602724291,
0.7646786571,
0.1601343155,
0.7080913186,
-0.6452124715,
-0.566031456,
-0.5257371664,
-0.9518383145,
0.7787927985,
0.334225744,
0.0337097868,
-0.1088391766,
-0.1041232347,
-0.082960777,
0.0570916235,
-0.3917765021,
-0.133092925,
-0.0735989064,
-0.1574094743,
-0.6798597574,
-0.3191551864,
0.0092114927,
-0.1105248779,
0.9461182952,
-0.0219729804,
0.2505737841,
0.2360749692,
-0.3533682227,
-0.5925878286,
0.3133473098,
0.6041727066,
0.5345833302,
-0.2655878663,
0.0478251129,
0.4184341729,
-0.3446191251,
0.5441480875,
0.3342337012,
-0.2895679474,
0.427788049,
0.6105014086,
0.8991434574,
0.1980909258,
-0.2129895836,
-0.0724428222,
0.2591432929,
0.1846538931,
-0.4452776909,
-0.0978643596,
0.2034278661,
-0.0103299022,
0.2928605676,
0.1878113747,
0.1042098328,
-0.4893563688,
0.5893122554,
-0.2427407503,
-0.9308816791,
-0.1618764997,
1.0472909212,
0.4533244371,
-0.9028629065,
0.8387228251,
0.1821296066,
-0.6364586949,
0.6732799411,
0.8017385602,
1.0922752619,
-1.0402556658,
-0.0679316893,
0.6081633568,
0.6210168004,
-0.0627395809,
-0.1831037998,
-0.1157889441,
-0.4949809313,
-0.4586774409,
-0.4801745415,
-0.2630991042,
-0.1078704149,
-0.773073554,
0.4929656982,
0.1789323539,
-0.4031556845,
0.0064205616,
-0.4030091465,
-0.6950129867,
0.3146829009,
0.1017881483,
0.7480168939,
-1.021019578,
0.9699363708,
0.3798156679,
-0.4704874456,
-0.5851040483,
-0.0270397887,
-0.0209615175,
-0.4862384498,
0.9758533835,
0.1019054875,
-0.2850443423,
0.212048322,
-0.235842675,
-1.051224947,
0.6750745773,
0.1074401587,
-0.8624282479,
0.3175590038,
0.1680419594,
0.5548889041,
-0.4900770485,
0.1324449331,
0.4564141631,
0.383946687,
-0.3274541199,
-1.1530438662,
0.0192404315,
-0.2514627576,
-0.0354896188,
0.3753478229,
-0.2675122917,
0.5362458229,
-0.1134853289,
-0.381585449,
0.0547510199,
0.7082677484,
-0.3098833859,
-0.056460686,
0.5912842155,
0.5159850121,
0.1063945591,
-0.0920126736,
1.2639262676,
-0.6558949947,
-0.2975123227,
1.3801093102,
-0.1423500031,
0.9086354971,
0.4141651392,
-0.0980194807,
0.2648011446,
0.5150192976,
0.1144105569,
0.4153293669,
0.0765099376,
-0.0773724467,
-0.5510883331,
-0.2846956551,
-0.4346390963,
0.5586585402,
0.4424335361,
-0.7141302228,
0.1112674549,
0.2436091155,
0.005084354,
0.3351285458,
0.1902818084,
0.7811932564,
0.2848392427,
-1.1094918251,
0.6536237001,
0.3158317208,
0.1550264955,
-0.713604033,
-0.030874541,
-0.2973814905,
0.1156426817,
0.0062190136,
-0.5344359875,
0.4042736292,
-0.2158929408,
-0.4839558899,
-0.3171806931,
0.3457683921,
-0.7135413289,
-0.5812794566,
0.4680871964,
0.2571055591,
0.2553595603,
0.1334863156,
-0.3974743783,
0.1298728883,
-0.1009913683,
-0.0405694917,
-0.118534483,
0.1359406561,
-0.3152121007,
0.6765055656,
0.5277400017,
-0.1053401083,
0.1666342616,
0.13052845,
0.3362777233,
-0.4420387447,
-0.5155704618,
-0.7600249648,
0.4550721347,
0.1948174387,
-0.2305800468,
0.7058064938,
0.6604721546,
0.8297854662,
-0.2868820131,
0.3892755508,
0.0549391359,
0.1512767822,
-0.5778617859,
0.3861795068,
-0.1417380571,
0.0626185536,
-0.0315991342,
-1.3172899485,
-0.1220404133,
0.3449481428,
-0.2896512151,
-0.309620589,
0.8654929399,
0.8135960102,
-0.0877029672,
-0.4305318892,
0.4535323381,
-0.0917140692,
0.2727723122,
0.3393033147,
0.6092970371,
-0.8623978496,
0.8809023499,
-0.7072486877,
0.0642346814,
-0.3019706309,
-0.7039586306,
-0.5357987285,
-0.8167549372,
-0.4745335281,
-0.3186295629,
0.1986889243,
0.7092399001,
1.0230787992,
-1.0424124002,
-0.5045704842,
0.0937377065,
0.0745100081,
-0.5455344319,
-0.2516230047,
-0.049380824,
-0.6258872747,
-1.1454700232,
0.6115034819,
0.0950826034,
0.2050617933,
0.2014057338,
-0.2941246927,
-0.2571235299,
0.2016378045,
0.5046569705,
0.2114461809,
-0.7634837031,
-0.2727853954,
0.0373773575,
-0.2286809385,
0.049966827,
0.9255709052,
-0.3439843059,
0.5716202855,
0.6122514606,
0.3298494518,
0.6134221554,
0.3775578737,
1.1366708279,
-0.8195230961,
0.358418107,
0.4940099716,
0.4560032487,
0.2723272741,
-0.4513049722,
0.6756938696,
0.1192419231,
-0.5144152045,
-0.5673081279,
0.3010643721,
-0.5722270608,
-0.1984066367,
0.9715897441,
0.039470043,
-0.0175182372,
0.0222201068,
-0.156701088,
0.6706616282,
-0.2792722881,
0.4289300144,
0.7428126335,
0.0354293846,
-0.2131731957,
-0.5319238901,
0.5483384728,
0.5472949743,
-0.4117570519,
-0.1854446679,
0.4502386451,
0.0184359793,
0.4932475984,
0.4764386117,
-0.2930466235,
0.4526424408,
0.3355590701,
0.3339377642,
-0.07109005,
-0.5429306626,
-0.2201850265,
-0.3420264423,
0.1044844612,
-0.4598402381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13199v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13199v1 | Knowledge-Retrieval Task-Oriented Dialog Systems with Semi-Supervision | 2023-05-22T16:29:20 | 2023-05-22T16:29:20 | Yucheng Cai, Hong Liu, Zhijian Ou, Yi Huang, Junlan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing task-oriented dialog (TOD) systems track dialog states in terms
of slots and values and use them to query a database to get relevant knowledge
to generate responses. In real-life applications, user utterances are noisier,
and thus it is more difficult to accurately track dialog states and correctly
secure relevant knowledge. Recently, a progress in question answering and
document-grounded dialog systems is retrieval-augmented methods with a
knowledge retriever. Inspired by such progress, we propose a retrieval-based
method to enhance knowledge selection in TOD systems, which significantly
outperforms the traditional database query method for real-life dialogs.
Further, we develop latent variable model based semi-supervised learning, which
can work with the knowledge retriever to leverage both labeled and unlabeled
dialog data. Joint Stochastic Approximation (JSA) algorithm is employed for
semi-supervised model training, and the whole system is referred to as that
JSA-KRTOD. Experiments are conducted on a real-life dataset from China Mobile
Custom-Service, called MobileCS, and show that JSA-KRTOD achieves superior
performances in both labeled-only and semi-supervised settings. | [
0.1026390344,
-0.9735029936,
0.7606748343,
-0.225736171,
-0.3569367826,
0.4061807394,
0.0273446199,
-0.4372844696,
0.0948160663,
0.4735508859,
-0.3902119398,
-0.4031346738,
-0.2483315766,
-0.1858627051,
-0.1311044693,
0.8286421895,
0.2396745235,
0.1106138006,
-0.3329928815,
0.1036854535,
-0.4855423868,
-0.4980148375,
-0.6462953091,
-0.4107872844,
0.1954907775,
0.1443607807,
0.4865607023,
0.157736659,
0.2765917778,
0.2191499323,
-0.2033749074,
0.4611828625,
-0.2968918085,
0.2219757587,
0.1147967577,
-0.691655159,
-0.3340042233,
-0.1568530798,
0.0881796554,
0.5520168543,
-0.3342033327,
0.0574124455,
-0.1501456052,
0.2692399323,
-0.5048713088,
0.3230061829,
-0.2779602408,
0.3677116036,
-0.0200938154,
-0.520612359,
-0.5561144352,
-0.4978744388,
0.6648083329,
-0.682379365,
0.0003120208,
0.1646345705,
0.6964526176,
0.1180624366,
-0.6877387762,
-0.3353128135,
-0.770057261,
0.9825241566,
-0.5926058292,
0.5320956111,
0.6418156624,
0.5845512748,
-0.1644032896,
-0.5314210057,
-0.1791879535,
-0.2939426899,
0.0605910756,
0.4015633166,
0.2199314833,
0.2487404197,
0.0849509239,
0.3812173605,
-0.2061584294,
-0.3592219055,
-0.5059540272,
-0.4966552854,
0.3976902068,
0.1559524834,
0.1400685459,
-0.3559233546,
-0.6617299914,
-0.0271624494,
-0.4894924164,
0.2011204064,
-0.1108068228,
0.3107026219,
0.0214564353,
0.4855676293,
-0.376749754,
1.0738576651,
0.2077369392,
-0.5131471157,
0.1486073881,
-0.5534511805,
-0.4236880839,
-0.1103923246,
0.5871542096,
0.4076618552,
-0.1076614112,
-0.5272135139,
-0.2874304056,
-0.4261899889,
0.2229574621,
-0.3624478281,
-0.1978654861,
-0.1910101473,
-0.5383991599,
-0.4712990224,
-0.1228549778,
-0.6930924654,
-0.1807096601,
-0.2653333843,
0.5322903991,
-0.2047555298,
-0.0182964597,
-0.2308313549,
-0.0992596075,
-0.0950553045,
0.6682599187,
-0.4487285018,
-0.0445411615,
0.1828306019,
0.7129303217,
-0.079073675,
0.3510741591,
-0.6081875563,
0.3944726586,
-0.2632477283,
0.5222402215,
-0.8729857206,
-0.6783345938,
-0.0137712164,
-0.1278406978,
-0.1504112184,
-0.768176198,
0.4661041498,
-1.0887243748,
0.447006464,
-0.2253644168,
-0.5509361625,
-0.0957213119,
0.2729873657,
-0.1940253228,
1.1572787762,
0.1138878465,
-0.6267191172,
0.3849271536,
-0.3280736208,
-0.3775920868,
-0.0135031985,
-0.2059132606,
-0.3100491464,
0.0963695124,
0.0025870462,
0.5677537918,
-0.4227444828,
0.4649356902,
-0.3030987084,
-0.2880815268,
-0.1181831509,
-0.3362280428,
0.6865247488,
0.3463447392,
0.0405864716,
-0.074159652,
-0.5098225474,
0.1383689791,
-0.1447089463,
-0.4890556037,
-0.7886591554,
-0.1105278358,
-0.4364717901,
0.2579666674,
0.4349226654,
-0.6967908144,
0.0968414918,
-0.224464938,
0.1605145633,
0.3775933087,
0.3434214294,
0.6023080349,
-0.21796152,
0.410769105,
0.2878981829,
0.2726465762,
0.0819700211,
-0.1910659522,
-0.570659101,
-0.1190336272,
0.3293879926,
0.6388002634,
-1.4249927998,
0.1370676458,
-0.0477963239,
-0.4810055494,
-0.2864859402,
0.0451468043,
0.7281090021,
0.7963293195,
0.2245173901,
-0.1553409398,
-0.3401036263,
-0.8534237146,
-0.1342884898,
-0.4277755022,
-0.226509437,
0.761259377,
0.0886802226,
0.1759611815,
1.0569220781,
-0.566701889,
-0.4191896319,
-0.1907473207,
0.2199264318,
-0.050470192,
0.1325972825,
0.2839974463,
-1.0291911364,
-0.5888665318,
0.0337982848,
-0.8762496114,
-0.1029627994,
0.0760796145,
-0.031616956,
0.0374596715,
0.407135129,
-0.5932022333,
0.5091466904,
0.0842583627,
-0.218168661,
0.4698464572,
-0.2271810323,
0.2272981405,
-1.1637587547,
-0.0153182065,
-0.0972931534,
-0.6570243835,
-0.7045940161,
-0.4781532586,
0.0566818602,
-0.1189691201,
-0.4714446366,
0.4992927313,
-0.4349292219,
-0.1251275688,
-0.1221576706,
0.151050508,
-0.1225828826,
0.5650975108,
0.2429021001,
1.146052599,
0.4018466175,
-0.8893268108,
0.2304653972,
0.361338526,
-0.3348862231,
0.5000354052,
-0.429960072,
0.1627864391,
-0.1135724485,
0.2041961551,
-0.5755873322,
0.0016116841,
0.0377540439,
-0.3099664748,
0.2188221663,
-0.4444305301,
-0.6314149499,
-0.2459348738,
0.0377225578,
0.1601902246,
0.3197806478,
-0.3935653865,
0.6867864728,
0.8353385925,
-0.1409362704,
-0.4632326066,
-0.0719759315,
-0.2410187423,
-0.1242187992,
-0.0562796667,
0.0191392433,
0.2045871168,
0.0113031194,
-0.2272479832,
-0.6124106646,
-0.2132332474,
0.0703904703,
0.1400827914,
0.4023897052,
0.2894856632,
0.2756861746,
0.2225116044,
0.0034125934,
-0.0436601266,
-0.4208381772,
0.2906187475,
0.1632091701,
-0.2266771644,
-0.4930131137,
0.0646107346,
0.3628784716,
-0.104948476,
0.4650602639,
0.2741175592,
-0.1462893933,
-0.1004407629,
-0.5292624831,
-0.3172968328,
-0.4389071465,
0.1894406825,
-0.5029284358,
-1.0434234142,
0.2545870543,
-0.286457032,
-0.0373804197,
-0.0852856636,
0.5172339678,
-0.4765171409,
0.9967065454,
0.695356071,
-0.0533885807,
0.8222973943,
-0.0484296083,
0.2310237139,
-0.6819685698,
-0.4682571888,
-0.2611012459,
0.1930710077,
-0.2385110706,
-0.6747485399,
0.6695729494,
0.1183012873,
0.1548609287,
0.2953467667,
-0.1935084909,
0.0958717838,
0.6494279504,
0.4301588535,
0.5712009072,
0.010534849,
-0.3321164548,
-0.0599124171,
-0.7017772794,
-0.5688862205,
1.0333162546,
0.1950619519,
0.8316038847,
0.037204124,
0.5109008551,
0.7169010639,
0.0169302262,
-0.4621735215,
0.6850428581,
0.1071918458,
-0.7825871706,
-0.2208379507,
-0.7247065902,
-0.6195832491,
0.2163699418,
0.0643831417,
-1.1513360739,
0.2696315348,
0.2411721647,
-0.4508295953,
0.2057262212,
-0.8889063597,
0.4737903476,
-0.0237077121,
-0.4056368172,
-0.1502006203,
-0.8783348203,
0.159925133,
-0.0096876146,
-0.1573142558,
-0.0800845176,
0.2919963896,
0.9904060364,
-0.3541578948,
0.9203013778,
-0.8035340905,
-0.060699109,
0.5738373399,
0.0207649823,
0.5723702312,
0.108324565,
0.0101913093,
-0.3492197692,
0.4746896923,
-0.3271013498,
-0.7388445735,
0.2912813723,
-0.6297845244,
-0.6832277179,
-0.1936402619,
-0.6986522079,
-0.7004868388,
0.3197866976,
-0.068087481,
0.5530881286,
-0.0796063393,
0.3138352334,
0.9467712641,
-0.0605616756,
0.135568276,
0.6086883545,
-0.2735557258,
-0.000730934,
0.8708149195,
0.1768200696,
0.4243237376,
0.8048823476,
-0.1472777873,
-0.476408422,
-0.2861082554,
-0.4554672837,
-0.0936489552,
-0.3486405015,
-0.429236263,
-0.9533470273,
-0.1256481856,
-0.0543433353,
0.2404428422,
-0.239213571,
-0.4853929579,
-0.3439275622,
-0.1395074129,
0.1217017174,
0.4130197167,
0.2340735197,
0.3641401827,
-0.8517210484,
0.2792952359,
0.6203631163,
0.1376103163,
0.1442358047,
-0.6428645849,
-0.3433257341,
0.2672788203,
-0.3509618044,
-0.8654331565,
0.1818071753,
-0.0466010533,
0.4743713737,
0.3092035055,
0.5149434805,
0.7072443962,
-0.1923466176,
0.4700252712,
0.1207831576,
-0.43206653,
0.6612124443,
-0.5222521424,
0.1041465923,
0.7568741441,
0.0534284525,
-0.2834409475,
-0.4637992084,
-0.6234098077,
-0.545701921,
0.9623652697,
0.3396061957,
0.0038020588,
0.1917045563,
0.2209878713,
0.0905848071,
0.510312736,
-0.1374291778,
-0.2449122965,
0.0570569821,
-0.306113869,
0.2861766219,
-0.277957201,
-0.2011958808,
0.1071817651,
0.7559637427,
-0.1024126485,
0.792966187,
0.3335236609,
-0.313000083,
0.1006089002,
0.4463137686,
0.2486143857,
0.6261984706,
-0.5836791396,
-0.029849207,
0.2296143472,
-0.4216115177,
0.1426216066,
0.1349921077,
-0.5479266644,
0.0268609244,
-0.2486777306,
0.8770027161,
0.0536256805,
-0.8347094655,
0.5269685984,
-0.1983239055,
0.0945359468,
-0.3051972389,
0.189062655,
-0.142727077,
0.5037304759,
0.7340883017,
-0.0770806745,
0.3522182405,
-0.5268229246,
0.2526559532,
0.4934144914,
-0.7113325596,
-0.3419985473,
0.5919966102,
0.3953555524,
-0.2590909302,
0.2622615695,
-0.2361655235,
-0.4497371316,
0.4306406975,
0.5447360277,
0.2980705202,
0.037528161,
0.4177700877,
-0.0633461028,
-0.0943242833,
-0.0584175736,
0.4733535647,
-0.7189863324,
-0.5401649475,
-0.1734255999,
-0.5108714104,
-0.5610750914,
-0.0693731532,
-0.8636718392,
-0.1287396699,
-0.281755209,
-0.4936675429,
-0.2789474428,
0.402903229,
-0.5301899314,
0.5258975625,
-0.1858659089,
0.9594361782,
-0.7475191951,
0.9595953822,
1.0070234537,
-0.1391892582,
-0.7053813934,
0.112973623,
-0.0316964164,
-0.538787365,
0.6287723184,
-0.2257615179,
-0.0592722259,
0.1288309097,
-0.1675348431,
-0.6225147843,
1.2310121059,
0.1311179549,
-0.3858925104,
-0.1769028306,
-0.0785085335,
0.6677429676,
-0.1660896689,
0.4401500523,
0.3386802673,
0.0968131572,
0.1565783024,
-1.2221103907,
-0.2250571698,
-0.15888156,
0.0786954388,
0.2288851589,
-0.9926049709,
0.0505017228,
-0.0051149558,
-0.2550351322,
-0.0220606718,
0.8613604903,
0.4416123629,
0.6382598877,
0.5904219747,
0.3922912776,
0.7301316857,
-0.1137453914,
0.8545516133,
-0.0846752152,
0.4806640148,
1.1403512955,
-0.0932365581,
0.5095171928,
0.6419886351,
-0.1977854818,
0.152033627,
0.6506955624,
0.2884337604,
0.9939400554,
-0.3863143921,
-0.4383411109,
-0.4843378365,
-0.5619074702,
0.0015464084,
0.2476892322,
0.2353664488,
-0.2407226861,
-0.1633489728,
0.2367626876,
0.0032173798,
-0.2157447487,
-0.123604551,
1.1193083525,
0.1048999205,
-0.6669416428,
0.3095087409,
-0.1316451728,
0.4337323308,
-0.4381255209,
0.0980610996,
-0.2014124393,
-0.0756974295,
0.0112935659,
-0.6246570945,
0.1034013703,
-0.0175378323,
-0.2958116233,
-0.221354112,
1.1055886745,
-0.4130257368,
-0.1974495947,
0.1937836409,
0.8170423508,
0.0851114839,
0.2321898788,
-0.5311877131,
-0.4029172957,
0.3042861223,
-0.2753654122,
0.4256919026,
0.3491304815,
-0.300684005,
0.9131968617,
0.5478646159,
-0.063263759,
0.1792229116,
0.0407512821,
0.9272723198,
-0.5615968108,
-0.5843935013,
-0.0933731347,
0.2301624864,
-0.3448483348,
0.078350246,
0.6699029803,
0.6476744413,
0.7540827394,
-0.0123861833,
0.9106267691,
-0.4657440186,
0.9288155437,
-0.389580965,
0.4496796131,
-0.6135541797,
0.3430617154,
-0.055657465,
-0.7021137476,
0.0233385172,
0.4806926847,
-0.6785335541,
0.1544137001,
0.2648473978,
0.834604919,
-0.2381861657,
0.1450432986,
0.4760046899,
0.0808126405,
0.1839021742,
0.4360632896,
0.9339421391,
-0.4354503751,
0.6216372252,
-0.3049316406,
-0.1560373902,
-0.3121722937,
-0.2737911344,
-1.1128810644,
-0.6330494285,
-0.0889717191,
-0.1170537695,
0.5283038616,
0.7116706371,
0.9506903887,
-0.6472184062,
-0.0297751725,
0.208112061,
0.1510335058,
0.0044560041,
-0.2375338376,
0.3613404632,
-0.3157868981,
-0.7398641109,
0.5444988608,
0.3668746352,
0.0370477624,
0.1575576365,
0.0597232655,
-0.347653538,
-0.1370437592,
0.6109045148,
0.2892481983,
-0.5086714625,
-0.2192040086,
0.0902318358,
-0.2103215009,
-0.0355635248,
0.7164102793,
-0.9308516979,
0.7289568782,
0.4109849334,
0.6576479673,
0.681476891,
0.3453268707,
0.5988177657,
-0.8848763108,
0.0675698742,
0.2537805736,
-0.1044386327,
0.089603737,
-0.4265969098,
0.3927132487,
0.3411561549,
-0.4531247318,
-0.8572756648,
0.1406550407,
-0.9118640423,
0.0229501817,
0.8487430215,
-0.3392614126,
-0.2138505876,
-0.635755837,
-0.1845102906,
0.4827585518,
-0.8570002913,
0.8984587789,
0.3033592105,
-0.0834245235,
-0.2882114947,
-0.8883689046,
0.4860853553,
0.6147549748,
-0.739015758,
0.0041832514,
0.4431492388,
0.2066375762,
0.1161825433,
0.7960145473,
-0.1667121798,
0.2738388181,
-0.3911093175,
-0.3174318671,
-0.0914600492,
-0.3070677519,
0.3562097847,
0.1606617123,
-0.0988774896,
-0.3045176268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13198v1 | Multilingual Holistic Bias: Extending Descriptors and Patterns to Unveil Demographic Biases in Languages at Scale | 2023-05-22T16:29:04 | 2023-05-22T16:29:04 | Marta R. Costa-jussà, Pierre Andrews, Eric Smith, Prangthip Hansanti, Christophe Ropers, Elahe Kalbassi, Cynthia Gao, Daniel Licht, Carleigh Wood | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | We introduce a multilingual extension of the HOLISTICBIAS dataset, the
largest English template-based taxonomy of textual people references:
MULTILINGUALHOLISTICBIAS. This extension consists of 20,459 sentences in 50
languages distributed across all 13 demographic axes. Source sentences are
built from combinations of 118 demographic descriptors and three patterns,
excluding nonsensical combinations. Multilingual translations include
alternatives for gendered languages that cover gendered translations when there
is ambiguity in English. Our benchmark is intended to uncover demographic
imbalances and be the tool to quantify mitigations towards them.
Our initial findings show that translation quality for EN-to-XX translations
is an average of 8 spBLEU better when evaluating with the masculine human
reference compared to feminine. In the opposite direction, XX-to-EN, we compare
the robustness of the model when the source input only differs in gender
(masculine or feminine) and masculine translations are an average of almost 4
spBLEU better than feminine. When embedding sentences to a joint multilingual
sentence representations space, we find that for most languages masculine
translations are significantly closer to the English neutral sentences when
embedded. | [
-0.5057849884,
-0.4048435688,
0.2380497605,
0.4898202717,
-0.0222556684,
0.1114438698,
-0.3780691326,
-0.6214588881,
0.1542679965,
0.4927991629,
-0.7110848427,
-0.5072513223,
-0.6380695105,
0.4440653026,
0.0165572539,
0.9527443647,
0.0803043768,
0.5337638855,
-0.3377957046,
-0.5632687807,
-0.3375534415,
-0.6057928801,
-0.0380457975,
-0.2397253215,
0.4408444166,
0.2784920335,
0.8973348141,
0.4402875602,
0.4550327361,
0.1842306256,
-0.0424982421,
0.1283651441,
-0.3009136915,
0.2752675712,
-0.314512372,
-0.425535351,
-0.4443357289,
0.1306275278,
0.2141236961,
0.9445857406,
-0.0460763834,
0.4556171,
0.092373006,
0.8106487393,
-0.6679661274,
0.3355016708,
-0.2791703045,
-0.0025554935,
-0.344709307,
-0.116795361,
-0.5189332962,
-0.2491072714,
0.2301691324,
-0.4465199709,
0.2191745937,
0.1454387456,
0.4659522474,
0.1281614304,
-0.9646167755,
-0.3727255464,
-0.462490797,
0.9601120353,
-0.5212600231,
0.5871152282,
0.593688488,
-0.0876302272,
0.1356707513,
0.0497233942,
-0.1496204287,
-0.1334125549,
-0.1677646786,
0.1273317486,
-0.402936101,
-0.2628006935,
0.0819281265,
0.0317338035,
-0.6555039883,
0.0043398668,
-0.4356917441,
-0.2147634774,
0.7758840322,
-0.0543633774,
0.4228486419,
-0.2536901832,
-0.0642341077,
-0.163045764,
-0.5876069665,
-0.2300383747,
0.9418118596,
0.3760777414,
-0.3179800808,
0.7085682154,
0.0793936476,
0.4713869691,
0.1351619512,
-0.0738729388,
0.8222218752,
-0.5818126202,
0.442815274,
0.1097564995,
0.7135967612,
0.8144240379,
0.5505517125,
-0.0133972708,
0.1746885329,
0.1138263792,
0.1945010126,
-0.5484933257,
0.2330759168,
-0.0303997304,
-0.5095416307,
-0.0436544009,
-0.0290808957,
-1.2595260143,
-0.3578406572,
-0.2496103644,
-0.4477133453,
-0.4371323287,
-0.2565201223,
0.2319779396,
-0.2599630952,
0.1538696587,
0.090226166,
-0.7342279553,
-0.0592524931,
0.2773900926,
0.6440554261,
-0.2869520187,
-0.2886738181,
-0.0744736195,
0.0302648507,
-0.4613955319,
0.6682093143,
-0.7490023971,
-0.4353222251,
0.1636658162,
0.0232426524,
0.1186008304,
-0.4614735246,
0.5331472158,
-0.1082451046,
0.5246542096,
-0.3389052451,
-0.0660921708,
-0.1411642134,
0.0774964392,
-0.7082913518,
1.1591110229,
0.2557479739,
-0.6992841959,
0.6314510107,
-0.4627670646,
-0.4923684299,
-0.1199001372,
-0.0956530869,
-0.2411423922,
0.0850728527,
0.3351456225,
0.2470000535,
-0.385101229,
0.464569211,
-0.6365303993,
0.2062627971,
0.0428590663,
-0.4304219782,
0.9068356752,
0.3444485962,
-0.3383846879,
0.1268348545,
-0.5737603307,
-0.2965771556,
0.0133349998,
-0.1759136468,
-0.7201448083,
-0.1066560745,
0.432692796,
0.5197155476,
0.1219300851,
-0.5699029565,
0.0554853231,
-0.4192786217,
0.4400895834,
0.5000687838,
-0.1474363953,
0.6372308135,
-0.1751058996,
0.6162490845,
0.2247529626,
0.1886992455,
-0.156514138,
-0.5950883031,
-0.3331549168,
-0.0584867075,
-0.1150899306,
0.5729063749,
-0.8414489627,
0.6919266582,
-0.3234524429,
-0.3544525206,
-0.6746340394,
0.2844070792,
0.5655966997,
-0.0442922637,
0.3561133444,
-0.2535068691,
-0.570635736,
-1.2266992331,
-0.5344893932,
-0.3511473238,
0.1032285541,
-0.0444937423,
0.7344657779,
-0.2972089648,
0.5733709931,
-0.330399543,
-0.4769241512,
-0.2207619101,
0.0461111404,
-0.0527302548,
0.3435940444,
0.9659131169,
-0.7986708283,
-0.4465329051,
0.1951619983,
-0.6906371117,
-0.163300395,
0.0489004329,
-0.2652523816,
0.1281633377,
0.4179635942,
-0.3811107278,
0.2590588629,
0.7841905355,
-0.679704845,
0.4293064475,
-0.1734257042,
0.073733069,
-1.2679719925,
-0.1770243496,
0.564842999,
-0.1105182394,
-0.3669695854,
0.2460455149,
0.015816275,
0.2086648941,
-0.5474253297,
0.5941399336,
-0.6977094412,
0.1017837152,
0.2513147593,
0.0873605385,
0.068782948,
0.3635616899,
-0.2797946334,
0.8909917474,
0.2469165176,
-0.2943222225,
0.2998815477,
0.4815136492,
-0.3085219562,
1.0654780865,
-0.3215127885,
-0.0821152553,
-0.7562505007,
0.3864463866,
-0.9027314782,
-0.179395929,
0.1498680562,
-0.4119586349,
0.0936536789,
0.1466263533,
-0.2663134038,
-0.4537674487,
-0.5243045688,
0.5362561345,
0.2142755538,
-0.1449306458,
0.386747241,
0.5774186254,
-0.223861441,
-0.6764174104,
-0.8057876825,
0.1551652849,
-0.3915705979,
-0.2013889849,
0.1651785076,
-0.1662043482,
-0.5649767518,
-0.0425672382,
0.123513326,
-0.0735494494,
-0.051355999,
-0.0744492486,
0.2098547518,
-0.11576543,
0.0973192975,
0.1537374705,
0.1253188103,
0.0904182941,
-0.4466904104,
0.5886472464,
-0.075573802,
-0.288466543,
-0.0126580866,
0.6995200515,
0.8706547022,
-0.2448533326,
0.7373618484,
0.5961703062,
-0.3078128099,
0.2538872361,
-0.5044768453,
-0.0087961685,
-0.3175344765,
0.5792704821,
-0.3772136569,
-0.7947981954,
0.6011220813,
0.3233175278,
0.165466398,
0.80055511,
0.8026837707,
0.0155016547,
1.2039915323,
0.2485596985,
-0.1470834464,
0.2864840925,
0.0615719296,
-0.1174548119,
-0.7175020576,
-0.2216077298,
-0.7151793242,
-0.3477474451,
-0.9953274727,
-0.5042344928,
0.2766946256,
-0.2308270931,
-0.190728873,
0.3498538136,
-0.3814031482,
0.3534912467,
0.4501673579,
0.0553261414,
0.1703009158,
0.0610563569,
-0.2015391588,
-0.6414916515,
-0.4688572586,
-0.611684978,
1.189353466,
0.3030183613,
0.728351295,
0.4322500229,
0.1547135413,
0.5586777329,
0.4242102802,
-0.5356044173,
0.1294496506,
-0.408700496,
-1.1321091652,
-0.0934180319,
-0.414560914,
-1.0977896452,
0.4882706702,
-0.1650670469,
-0.7306244373,
0.5256403089,
-0.0112303169,
0.0202374402,
0.1196221113,
-0.5478335619,
0.5946400762,
-0.3566721976,
-0.5268542171,
-0.1429834217,
-0.7480112314,
0.4449484646,
-0.2053029239,
0.709780097,
-0.4645099938,
-0.0744295865,
0.7006533146,
-0.0217521619,
1.037928462,
-0.0921459869,
-0.5898233652,
-0.1757753044,
-0.0608178675,
0.0225025099,
-0.0610994361,
-0.3597032726,
0.5427059531,
0.3543444276,
-0.5616172552,
-0.288372159,
0.4067021608,
-0.9954664707,
-0.4208434522,
-0.4654647708,
-0.7201334834,
-0.2581747174,
0.2314850241,
0.3824606836,
0.387980938,
-0.4327476621,
0.3533215523,
0.2703127265,
-0.4887267947,
0.2362989336,
0.2991379201,
-0.2976230681,
-0.515635848,
0.5244295001,
0.1232568547,
0.3136220276,
0.4161664248,
0.2462527156,
-0.5652415752,
-0.0324732251,
-0.7276793122,
0.2702973187,
-0.6880427003,
-0.0349236205,
-0.7043561935,
0.3056686223,
-0.6455376744,
-0.0468016081,
-0.3131014705,
-0.163081795,
-0.0002717347,
-0.0781701729,
0.127324909,
0.671869278,
0.0915226564,
0.3201684952,
-0.6267642975,
0.2365471274,
-0.1863253117,
0.0464113764,
-0.1560685784,
-0.4365738332,
-0.1211632714,
0.2783052325,
-0.3399460614,
-1.1343845129,
0.595520556,
0.3059950471,
0.6040511131,
0.492525816,
0.1584671438,
0.6227877736,
-0.5822122693,
0.8029446602,
0.3862909377,
-0.8559406996,
0.3284784555,
-0.5614834428,
0.5108217001,
0.7107523084,
0.4864025414,
-0.7400937676,
-0.6310469508,
-0.3112584949,
-0.8493818641,
0.5078339577,
-0.004456589,
0.4205859601,
-0.3111030459,
0.3616939485,
0.4527848363,
0.4185460806,
-0.6625772119,
-0.577642858,
-0.0694796816,
-0.3779585958,
-0.5066936016,
-0.3212832808,
-0.1383321285,
-0.3259974718,
0.5016311407,
-0.3868350387,
0.1340584308,
0.0189327002,
-0.3095888495,
-0.173804909,
0.5290964246,
0.7333937287,
0.8151804805,
-0.0780189857,
0.3793312609,
0.2082326114,
-0.6237411499,
0.5644935966,
-0.2061270326,
-0.2674629986,
0.2923615575,
0.6755102277,
0.7232224941,
0.2944298983,
-0.4112384319,
0.437084198,
0.0131889451,
-0.3005018234,
-0.2610172331,
-0.5475815535,
-0.0001225632,
-0.0689466521,
0.2994874418,
0.1639181376,
0.1534796953,
-0.6763259172,
0.2379158735,
0.4304131269,
-0.7100055218,
-0.5502435565,
0.7428785563,
0.3492915034,
-0.0473447144,
0.3144036531,
-0.1412933916,
-0.3748959601,
0.339153409,
0.4738612771,
0.8380306959,
-0.4517384171,
0.3537018597,
0.5009371042,
0.63699615,
-0.0754844546,
0.2633340061,
0.3858232796,
-0.9508734345,
-0.4167319238,
-0.5111514926,
-0.0679802224,
-0.2246879786,
-1.1195095778,
0.227445513,
0.1440482289,
-0.3558505177,
0.0811581388,
-0.4395444393,
-0.8517836928,
-0.1810788363,
0.2106551528,
0.714356482,
-0.9595173597,
0.6045565009,
0.952755332,
-0.4441114664,
-0.1931523979,
0.0724993274,
0.4109031856,
-0.8504342437,
0.6468061209,
0.1223321408,
-0.0090391906,
-0.1591420472,
-0.2136352509,
-0.7632367611,
0.5062530041,
0.7303768396,
-0.5314310193,
-0.2895000875,
0.2765311003,
0.6421390176,
-0.373239398,
0.4161936939,
0.6206925511,
0.7827398777,
-0.2830311954,
-0.8989543319,
-0.1997515559,
-0.3353841901,
0.0160595533,
0.152474165,
-0.5834345222,
0.7399871349,
-0.0439887941,
-0.0879760385,
-0.3235990703,
0.4016891122,
-0.0259440411,
0.1597342938,
0.4979609251,
0.3450143635,
0.5785934925,
-0.1667287648,
1.1608427763,
-0.5260225534,
0.3425270617,
1.0392020941,
-0.4294789135,
0.5587931871,
0.6740980744,
-0.5308964849,
0.5807380676,
0.6152017713,
0.3201721907,
0.364875108,
0.0735835806,
-0.0742153227,
-0.0920393988,
-0.577165544,
-0.3027662933,
0.6797765493,
0.3347982168,
-0.3402939141,
-0.3844730556,
0.4190458357,
0.3827710748,
0.2724217474,
-0.0426112637,
0.7334395647,
0.0806284621,
-0.760174036,
0.3804644048,
0.059675511,
0.9279348254,
-0.5481627584,
0.0728254393,
-0.2908983529,
0.2111262083,
-0.2625235915,
-0.8254805803,
0.4036306143,
-0.143355459,
-0.3583249748,
-0.5692409873,
0.3691132665,
-0.7614876628,
-0.7791522741,
0.5938428044,
0.9528828263,
0.1118792295,
0.0644728839,
-0.6888827085,
-0.2348643392,
0.2118717879,
-0.064999029,
0.2222846895,
0.4278323352,
-0.5003039837,
0.6244651079,
0.4863039553,
0.1842747629,
0.1271625012,
0.3049161136,
0.4323988855,
-0.5049721003,
-0.4695293307,
-1.082498312,
0.2371838242,
-0.0306559261,
-0.5446113348,
1.20518291,
0.6694164872,
1.0748997927,
-0.3017649055,
0.8423926234,
0.0737524554,
0.1435533911,
-0.1812628806,
0.469863534,
-0.5818926096,
-0.1382694542,
-0.3891235888,
-1.0345847607,
-0.3512134552,
0.6181508899,
-0.362839222,
0.0218332876,
0.7321071625,
0.4761606157,
0.1973587275,
-0.1258474588,
0.3258705139,
-0.077799052,
0.2388681173,
0.3199121952,
0.8012287021,
-0.351511687,
0.1867636889,
-0.0060573053,
-0.1068791226,
-0.0260951724,
-0.6187648177,
-0.8331178427,
-0.5841550231,
-0.3782499433,
-0.4545481801,
-0.1130212247,
1.2240364552,
0.7043891549,
-0.8793265224,
-0.4231896698,
0.3159584105,
-0.0005311479,
-0.403170526,
-0.2152729481,
-0.1096406057,
-0.1575329155,
-1.0220727921,
-0.0120008038,
0.3976688087,
-0.1589140594,
-0.7668225169,
-0.0794643909,
-0.416536659,
-0.0218949355,
0.8007538319,
-0.2819835544,
-0.9352594614,
-0.27085042,
0.1545541734,
-0.1557433456,
0.1063051447,
0.8636438251,
-0.1700914651,
0.5289680362,
0.3052555919,
0.3362265527,
0.1326862127,
-0.1303028315,
0.7385343313,
-1.0105003119,
0.5539767742,
0.143373549,
0.494204402,
0.4577556252,
-0.3739024997,
0.5940594077,
0.3784167171,
-0.0499966256,
-0.7116578221,
0.2877898216,
-0.6694559455,
-0.283187449,
1.4155805111,
-0.033294972,
-0.0648986325,
-0.4866410792,
-0.323508054,
0.1339163929,
-0.4809110761,
0.6047275066,
1.0563608408,
0.2343273908,
-0.2619427741,
-0.8616243005,
0.2081319243,
0.4798544645,
-0.9150912166,
0.2084141225,
0.7030410171,
0.0662296489,
0.3616650701,
0.3102788925,
-0.3207704127,
-0.029926626,
-0.1473911852,
0.4347569346,
0.4072303474,
-0.0697329193,
-0.2404345125,
-0.0168985128,
-0.0383327417,
0.1530141085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13197v1 | Challenging Decoder helps in Masked Auto-Encoder Pre-training for Dense Passage Retrieval | 2023-05-22T16:27:10 | 2023-05-22T16:27:10 | Zehan Li, Yanzhao Zhang, Dingkun Long, Pengjun Xie | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recently, various studies have been directed towards exploring dense passage
retrieval techniques employing pre-trained language models, among which the
masked auto-encoder (MAE) pre-training architecture has emerged as the most
promising. The conventional MAE framework relies on leveraging the passage
reconstruction of decoder to bolster the text representation ability of
encoder, thereby enhancing the performance of resulting dense retrieval
systems. Within the context of building the representation ability of the
encoder through passage reconstruction of decoder, it is reasonable to
postulate that a ``more demanding'' decoder will necessitate a corresponding
increase in the encoder's ability. To this end, we propose a novel token
importance aware masking strategy based on pointwise mutual information to
intensify the challenge of the decoder. Importantly, our approach can be
implemented in an unsupervised manner, without adding additional expenses to
the pre-training phase. Our experiments verify that the proposed method is both
effective and robust on large-scale supervised passage retrieval datasets and
out-of-domain zero-shot retrieval benchmarks. | [
-0.1056665927,
-0.3371643126,
0.4381390512,
0.2409179956,
-0.4528207779,
-0.0124894856,
0.1283442974,
-0.2185052633,
0.4987424314,
0.3783014715,
-0.2135135829,
-0.3949977756,
-1.0129621029,
0.2543779612,
-0.2295926362,
0.6215695143,
0.1029745862,
-0.0946412981,
-0.127070412,
-0.2010961473,
-0.7053741813,
-0.8513075113,
-0.6323333979,
0.1559622884,
0.3307112455,
-0.0003697337,
0.3829700053,
0.6343189478,
0.8124373555,
0.3211149573,
0.1085984781,
-0.1721990854,
-0.4738214612,
0.2889532149,
-0.0427332036,
-0.3929840922,
-0.2797418535,
-0.1438494474,
0.6803004742,
0.6847824454,
-0.0314220116,
0.0157442,
0.0666096732,
0.5722014904,
-1.0842572451,
0.2489734441,
-0.8966125846,
0.1893884838,
-0.2762723267,
-0.391035378,
-0.3106115758,
-0.1207167655,
0.1805095971,
-0.7729028463,
-0.1466708183,
0.0044297068,
0.832871139,
0.4474274814,
-0.6608679891,
-0.1560909748,
-0.3313724995,
0.5609896183,
-0.4453926384,
0.3282394707,
0.4851691425,
0.3024422824,
-0.059570536,
-0.8275776505,
-0.35242185,
0.2364631891,
-0.3783176243,
-0.01592209,
-0.3224920332,
0.2278380543,
0.2421194762,
0.2377392799,
-0.3021394014,
-0.3921071887,
-0.341062516,
-0.5619529486,
0.2585019171,
0.0512025207,
0.1819195747,
-0.311974436,
-0.5059179068,
-0.3532167971,
-0.5882502794,
0.2221900523,
0.1720821857,
-0.056733977,
0.3433367908,
0.3983697891,
-0.3073978424,
0.4527593255,
0.3074173331,
0.2295165956,
0.6423760653,
-0.2107508779,
-0.0705844909,
0.2259664685,
0.6713245511,
0.1228742748,
-0.0759415552,
-0.0432515442,
-0.5461908579,
-0.2794243395,
0.3937749863,
-1.0435011387,
-0.0435156599,
-0.1165052205,
-0.6406527758,
-0.0939181745,
0.4617419839,
-0.588527441,
0.036203634,
-0.0216045491,
1.1692287922,
-0.1856948584,
-0.4176636338,
0.3784984946,
-0.0534134507,
0.2859032452,
0.2612043321,
-0.7622665763,
0.0160859264,
0.5358271599,
0.7559102178,
-0.038567625,
-0.1284003854,
-0.9194515944,
0.2906636,
-0.2518697083,
0.4596203864,
-0.8513575792,
-0.3424043357,
-0.1077552214,
0.0553971678,
-0.2504422665,
-0.4456093013,
0.4895928204,
-0.7449607849,
-0.1899761111,
-0.5394594073,
-0.1723660231,
-0.0543979034,
0.4277867973,
-0.8664432168,
1.0036553144,
0.24700436,
-0.8845207095,
0.3359781802,
-0.6391900778,
-0.5639244318,
0.0776826218,
-0.2191192955,
-0.323672086,
0.1978500634,
0.576921463,
0.5441130996,
0.1971036643,
0.2110455334,
-0.0278915353,
-0.6879425645,
0.1524926424,
-0.4692266285,
0.4003098607,
0.2198787779,
-0.5912418962,
-0.0232532341,
-0.6332839727,
-0.1353732347,
0.0159340072,
-0.1398805976,
-0.7780578136,
-0.4161428213,
-0.4858607352,
0.0871675089,
0.4483572245,
-0.5519359112,
0.0182587728,
-0.2420724928,
0.4565182328,
0.6261235476,
0.1958478987,
0.5969151855,
-0.0088143153,
0.6279910803,
0.2960114181,
0.4243418276,
-0.3446522057,
-0.1951046437,
-0.7302961946,
-0.2418376356,
0.3721929491,
0.4151103199,
-0.882948935,
0.4000744224,
-0.2878791094,
-0.0537225641,
-0.9610806108,
-0.1344279647,
0.6163294315,
0.6824409366,
0.5141903758,
-0.5169565678,
-0.6108323336,
-0.6598363519,
-0.0546602607,
-0.1976927668,
-0.074685514,
0.1821215898,
0.4971404374,
-0.420486629,
0.8936036229,
-0.5555262566,
-0.5179712176,
-0.0559456572,
0.0625044927,
0.1125489101,
0.5659082532,
0.2864750028,
-1.012887001,
-0.4642225504,
-0.2709587812,
-0.6706978679,
-0.2868277431,
-0.0367719196,
-0.4881849587,
-0.13192904,
1.0179958344,
-0.510196209,
0.6646889448,
0.2106410414,
-0.2834087312,
0.2155455053,
-0.4403598309,
0.410176754,
-0.8941468596,
0.1925333291,
-0.6043595076,
-0.2541435361,
-0.4714744389,
-0.0502166077,
0.1593429893,
-0.2409620881,
-0.2912970185,
0.406820178,
-0.8191055059,
0.0588239022,
-0.054255385,
-0.1632366925,
0.208251521,
0.5225477815,
0.2304401994,
0.682448864,
0.5795286894,
-0.5348696113,
-0.1869883388,
0.1793548465,
-0.1599602401,
0.5953381658,
-0.7801302671,
0.2282117307,
-0.2613508999,
0.2483305633,
-0.5717275143,
0.1261066049,
0.3831042349,
-0.3500647545,
0.5909135938,
-0.3361726403,
-0.1724440306,
-0.1743725687,
-0.4148349464,
1.0373686552,
0.405849278,
-0.506323874,
0.6814075708,
0.5493501425,
-0.0964170247,
-0.9579080939,
-0.4271531701,
0.1456507593,
-0.2747046053,
-0.2611497641,
0.2743524015,
-0.1347192824,
0.123925671,
0.0753281042,
-0.2778544724,
0.1317090988,
0.1044429615,
0.2780128121,
-0.0220155567,
-0.1320847422,
0.0438537411,
0.1279394329,
-0.5312159657,
0.2042101771,
-0.5285460353,
0.3514559865,
-0.076749064,
-0.5876895189,
-0.0781849176,
0.8371240497,
0.2303308547,
-0.4727798402,
0.6523550749,
0.7485187054,
-0.3963218927,
0.0503371358,
-0.633238554,
-0.1808011979,
-0.529481113,
0.4172756374,
-0.852214098,
-0.9904291034,
0.5139058232,
0.1196881011,
-0.5129965544,
0.4491738975,
-0.0230525825,
0.0083913431,
0.9552696347,
0.63711375,
-0.1225873679,
0.4284930229,
-0.1339513212,
0.2127919346,
-1.0124042034,
-0.5367991924,
-0.3685085177,
-0.199363485,
-0.0881692544,
-0.6053241491,
0.6323130131,
0.2633061409,
-0.1662058532,
0.3704929948,
-0.7097240686,
0.6768477559,
0.6289125681,
0.1823135018,
0.3054082096,
0.0769033283,
-0.1635716707,
-0.1099093258,
-0.6902133226,
-0.163686201,
1.2367529869,
0.2413872182,
0.5411444306,
0.0268380344,
0.8452731371,
0.2104287744,
-0.118163377,
-0.3953953087,
0.5851851702,
0.089741528,
-0.4283824563,
-0.4329876006,
-0.6844236851,
-1.1153798103,
0.4729251266,
-0.1038554013,
-0.4193179607,
0.5482336283,
-0.0233591273,
-0.2395053506,
0.1449814737,
-0.6126664281,
0.7318723202,
0.0595698021,
-0.0123873707,
-0.0780313015,
-0.9476771951,
-0.0492070466,
-0.2066091299,
0.0365427211,
0.2583159506,
-0.1637483835,
0.8588672876,
-0.5804789066,
0.6404143572,
-0.4065074027,
0.0232096296,
0.2846648693,
0.276060909,
0.7014739513,
0.1544979513,
-0.0022245087,
0.3120921254,
0.0047959969,
-0.5181030035,
-0.7563037872,
0.3809245229,
-0.5855079293,
-0.881242156,
-0.550057292,
-0.2736349404,
-0.0410528444,
0.2139049023,
0.6042225361,
0.6851241589,
-0.0921730697,
0.2115053385,
0.8015888929,
0.0396587327,
0.6086598039,
0.2607849538,
0.3554112613,
-0.5632715225,
1.008507967,
0.0249719266,
0.2064338923,
0.8665939569,
-0.0434316136,
-0.3720726967,
-0.7992760539,
-0.1287419945,
0.1563625783,
-0.8503374457,
-0.4464996457,
-1.0296480656,
-0.4004044533,
-0.4125272036,
-0.3618771434,
-0.3060553074,
-0.282679975,
-0.2737976611,
-0.0362990871,
0.083230786,
0.6224066019,
-0.3666651547,
0.3460997939,
-0.8881973028,
0.1986423433,
0.4315585494,
0.3178813159,
0.0124203945,
-0.476357311,
-0.3082366288,
-0.1086448655,
0.2422485203,
-0.7122637033,
0.2865684628,
0.063376762,
0.71910429,
0.5907967687,
0.5946965218,
0.7393177152,
-0.2943761051,
0.477669239,
0.0383940637,
-1.072840333,
0.6538959742,
0.1010518149,
0.2961073816,
1.0091593266,
0.422675252,
-0.2991759181,
-0.1191675588,
-0.3953575194,
-1.1426956654,
0.4175417423,
0.4513840675,
0.2801192999,
-0.1044823006,
0.4083288908,
0.080127731,
0.2934768498,
-0.815089345,
0.1808101684,
-0.4789391458,
-0.2458266467,
0.1395202577,
-0.5082131028,
0.1749712825,
-0.2026392668,
0.4442180395,
-0.0645005777,
0.4788096547,
0.6397542953,
-0.7149123549,
0.1962558925,
0.2983956337,
0.2303034812,
0.2436156869,
-0.5146110654,
0.3348868489,
0.08940579,
-0.9304676056,
0.2204985023,
0.1196438074,
-0.3225786388,
0.1240465716,
0.6039221883,
0.9123696685,
0.3928461671,
-0.422214061,
1.0611160994,
-0.1586431414,
-0.0412263572,
-0.1299729049,
-0.2010459453,
-0.5606393218,
0.2335309535,
0.7949775457,
-0.1078383178,
0.3210512698,
-0.2739738226,
0.2538185716,
0.4206389189,
-0.7096031308,
-0.3193478882,
0.5877389312,
0.3411130905,
-0.0529783219,
0.3698486388,
-0.453628093,
-0.9789766073,
0.3772945404,
0.5584204197,
0.7938506603,
-0.336352855,
0.0991882086,
0.5017614365,
0.3540180922,
-0.0431718156,
0.0855085775,
-0.5690302849,
-0.2786948979,
-0.1214441881,
-0.5760819316,
0.0001923549,
-0.1723511964,
-0.6901054382,
0.0886120126,
-0.1146463826,
-0.0123392176,
-0.8172729611,
0.0043334542,
-0.4441886246,
0.1368656754,
-0.2227226198,
0.7464419603,
-0.4023851156,
0.7231932282,
0.2740789652,
-0.3196807206,
-0.7835060358,
0.2105378509,
-0.4151858091,
-0.7718727589,
0.8401953578,
0.3483150899,
-0.3185403645,
0.201573804,
0.0024198522,
-0.9241711497,
1.1529228687,
0.2725775838,
-0.6404567957,
-0.2203709781,
0.1253220886,
0.2209200561,
-0.5650241375,
0.6154882312,
0.2994280756,
0.2838502824,
0.2377367169,
-0.7886722088,
0.4589015543,
-0.4831608236,
0.0090636238,
0.3213566244,
-0.4272477031,
0.7558279634,
-0.2331892401,
-0.4042419493,
-0.2773698866,
0.6385095716,
-0.0447876975,
0.3891934752,
0.9936082959,
0.3816833496,
0.5973991156,
0.178679198,
0.6926087737,
-0.0026505052,
-0.0150327645,
0.8193310499,
-0.0119284214,
0.9493277073,
0.475153178,
0.1612857133,
0.2524324059,
0.3996649384,
0.2691611052,
0.8543065786,
0.1340819001,
-0.2261054218,
-0.3260113895,
-0.1048301309,
-0.8137662411,
0.4674983323,
0.2740671337,
-0.2455787212,
-0.1477527469,
0.185637638,
-0.05463944,
-0.0499806181,
-0.4292485416,
0.7476723194,
0.084938027,
-0.4169634879,
0.5137241483,
-0.2474975288,
0.8554647565,
-0.7871699929,
-0.0696393549,
-0.4074571133,
-0.0264036637,
0.0633030757,
-0.3990311921,
0.3309911191,
-0.3798180819,
0.0624975562,
-0.3634278476,
0.915176928,
-0.5947992802,
-0.2093561292,
0.4546120167,
0.2637377381,
0.1711798757,
-0.5451673865,
-0.218363896,
0.2688742578,
-0.1082769111,
-0.1877568513,
0.4418229163,
0.7740607858,
-0.1101512909,
0.4937132001,
0.6941571236,
0.0275509264,
0.1113915294,
0.1279769838,
0.8880013824,
-0.7830390334,
-0.7653935552,
-0.7342972755,
0.4374022484,
-0.1556394398,
-0.1767122746,
0.5403127074,
0.4984256327,
0.7236885428,
0.0147057883,
0.4709815085,
0.1734565943,
0.0492819659,
-0.6357755661,
0.8985754848,
-0.4540034533,
0.4213743508,
-0.5757623911,
-0.872879982,
-0.3380205929,
0.6670337915,
0.031179281,
-0.0971263722,
0.783465445,
0.8846475482,
-0.1303099245,
-0.3617220521,
0.4042653739,
0.0433354974,
0.2444732338,
1.0420769453,
0.8476189375,
-0.7960212827,
1.0169506073,
-0.0785294175,
-0.2849234045,
-0.3407720029,
-0.9162395597,
-1.0683523417,
-1.0335205793,
-0.3365698457,
-0.2720620036,
-0.0180937462,
0.6625865698,
0.833571732,
-0.5371757746,
0.3166738749,
0.221698463,
-0.0455906615,
0.0622010194,
-0.163826704,
0.6313791275,
-0.3233689964,
-0.5548140407,
0.2846677005,
0.4860294163,
0.2265155762,
-0.0344011858,
-0.148762241,
-0.0039356649,
0.1650186628,
0.635489583,
0.0984417871,
-0.1965563595,
-0.3899267018,
0.0538897179,
-0.2491712868,
0.0219526049,
1.1460902691,
-1.073500514,
0.4351101518,
0.461001277,
0.980163455,
0.7217821479,
-0.0936570168,
0.5720259547,
-0.7753955126,
0.1981562078,
0.2606878579,
0.3302385509,
0.2766036689,
-0.7007808685,
0.4336910844,
0.3354249895,
-0.2470971793,
-0.9149379134,
0.1461571604,
-1.0091403723,
-0.1483793259,
0.9707757235,
-0.3349374235,
-0.290087074,
-0.3499268591,
-0.1845146865,
0.1218597367,
-0.4479358792,
0.6815985441,
0.5855928659,
0.4224823713,
-0.2345291376,
-0.1161107942,
0.3913193047,
0.5655335188,
-0.5441874266,
-0.2557306886,
0.0365358926,
0.0731213167,
0.0081580551,
1.0766539574,
-0.3164860308,
-0.0820422918,
0.1072617844,
-0.2779023945,
-0.3823184967,
-0.4826231003,
-0.432759881,
0.3309861422,
-0.2333658338,
-0.5692011714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13194v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13194v2 | SEAHORSE: A Multilingual, Multifaceted Dataset for Summarization Evaluation | 2023-05-22T16:25:07 | 2023-11-01T22:29:53 | Elizabeth Clark, Shruti Rijhwani, Sebastian Gehrmann, Joshua Maynez, Roee Aharoni, Vitaly Nikolaev, Thibault Sellam, Aditya Siddhant, Dipanjan Das, Ankur P. Parikh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reliable automatic evaluation of summarization systems is challenging due to
the multifaceted and subjective nature of the task. This is especially the case
for languages other than English, where human evaluations are scarce. In this
work, we introduce SEAHORSE, a dataset for multilingual, multifaceted
summarization evaluation. SEAHORSE consists of 96K summaries with human ratings
along 6 dimensions of text quality: comprehensibility, repetition, grammar,
attribution, main ideas, and conciseness, covering 6 languages, 9 systems and 4
datasets. As a result of its size and scope, SEAHORSE can serve both as a
benchmark to evaluate learnt metrics, as well as a large-scale resource for
training such metrics. We show that metrics trained with SEAHORSE achieve
strong performance on the out-of-domain meta-evaluation benchmarks TRUE
(Honovich et al., 2022) and mFACE (Aharoni et al., 2022). We make the SEAHORSE
dataset and metrics publicly available for future research on multilingual and
multifaceted summarization evaluation. | [
-0.2991102636,
-0.1503325701,
0.0686991438,
0.6780013442,
-0.5426115394,
0.2042767704,
-0.300773114,
-0.4728051424,
0.3069938719,
0.1901035607,
-0.2356512696,
-0.5798877478,
-0.5727429986,
0.3739786744,
-0.1350290924,
1.4895387888,
0.0020424917,
0.0934687778,
-0.3644835651,
-0.7997215986,
-0.3096962273,
-0.4434476793,
-0.5166301131,
-0.2543840408,
0.6777858138,
0.3952849507,
0.6471816301,
0.5888636112,
0.6221365929,
0.3084048927,
0.1963140815,
0.2688519657,
-0.3526317477,
-0.0284195282,
-0.3314814568,
0.0553791784,
-0.6559410691,
-0.0210309289,
0.7192628384,
0.9724865556,
-0.1769898683,
0.6558805108,
0.1968368292,
0.9007478356,
-0.8800761104,
0.697773993,
-0.257212013,
0.0648775324,
-0.3784205019,
0.1916787475,
-0.1339393556,
-0.2585173845,
0.1905054897,
-1.0917807817,
-0.030393444,
-0.0710662752,
0.4157564044,
0.0252014268,
-0.6977703571,
-0.3691314161,
-0.0913872272,
0.8524112701,
-0.5620071888,
0.4455076456,
0.1505759209,
0.5210955143,
0.2572702467,
-0.7156364918,
-0.4303581119,
-0.0461252965,
-0.2854155302,
0.6400958896,
-0.0424043909,
-0.2541360259,
-0.2148149908,
0.5224694014,
-0.7376840115,
-0.1591251493,
-0.2796164155,
-0.4039978683,
0.9672809839,
0.2200152576,
0.1716958284,
-0.0239672232,
-0.0818998441,
-0.2150957882,
-0.2533164918,
0.3049833775,
0.3021391034,
0.4878793359,
-0.1246773675,
0.276216507,
-0.4791850448,
0.417655021,
-0.2857872546,
-0.3546921909,
0.6353706717,
-0.3126161993,
0.040823549,
0.1043202728,
0.9348625541,
0.750290215,
0.08378461,
-0.319218725,
-0.346624583,
-0.05761775,
-0.0156305972,
-0.5235517025,
-0.033214312,
0.2024764121,
-0.5770202875,
-0.2456967086,
0.3034865856,
-0.7189311981,
-0.4405020773,
-0.0909162611,
0.4953402579,
-0.1436796635,
-0.3044025004,
0.3437219858,
-0.3933550715,
-0.0059712431,
0.3147567809,
-0.860385716,
0.3161519468,
0.5674666166,
0.7656847239,
-0.4473038018,
-0.9029260874,
-0.8785879016,
0.2754197717,
-0.3634721935,
0.778961122,
-0.364924252,
-0.3408827186,
0.037429776,
0.2358943224,
-0.0268366467,
-0.51208812,
0.5464813709,
-0.3592386544,
0.3024812043,
-0.5456405282,
-0.2438128293,
-0.4598924816,
0.1807600111,
-0.9947380424,
0.6263241172,
0.1362880915,
-0.8682662249,
0.6017577052,
-0.835945189,
-0.938365519,
0.0432748497,
0.3047076166,
-0.4765286446,
-0.1032777876,
0.4560762942,
0.4911768138,
-0.2829998434,
0.2073235661,
-0.2993086278,
-0.3724962473,
-0.1205482036,
-0.051030498,
0.5918929577,
0.1472441852,
-0.1079116613,
0.031100031,
-0.863625288,
0.0539467223,
-0.0384289846,
-0.5346465111,
-0.4555784166,
-0.3266907632,
0.1528303921,
0.0167005304,
0.3607950211,
-0.4942051768,
-0.0614816919,
-0.2410391867,
0.3876703382,
-0.0322403051,
0.1635174602,
0.2310936451,
-0.5687227845,
0.4713305235,
0.013317503,
-0.0165615454,
-0.5000302196,
-0.2090027481,
-0.5030956864,
-0.1560581326,
0.4120564163,
0.537488699,
-0.8952921629,
0.2105019987,
-0.3694526255,
-0.6685546637,
-0.4986177981,
0.1186289042,
0.559696734,
0.4467155635,
0.4795514941,
-0.2880129218,
-0.3119099736,
-0.8631770015,
-0.6619355679,
-0.2107699513,
-0.1194988862,
-0.1219641119,
0.6694722772,
0.0319263078,
0.556878686,
0.0212489199,
-0.465934515,
-0.5590586662,
0.4098609388,
0.2062798589,
0.4096097946,
0.4028876722,
-0.3666548133,
-0.5065933466,
0.0815936252,
-1.1523211002,
-0.2307117879,
-0.2803696692,
0.0361693092,
-0.0982289985,
0.1238142401,
-0.4499263763,
0.026504213,
0.3109020293,
0.0107960943,
0.4799842238,
-0.2727620602,
0.2859033346,
-0.756665051,
0.4579894543,
0.006079827,
-0.2172901332,
-0.280959487,
0.1225477308,
0.217558533,
0.0492270216,
-0.3336175978,
0.5071888566,
-0.3143581748,
-0.3438596427,
0.0392713845,
0.5375149846,
0.3401662707,
0.418643415,
0.2216384858,
0.756244421,
0.252047509,
-0.5324848294,
0.4918029904,
0.6256633401,
-0.3882125616,
0.9947639108,
-0.8647230864,
-0.1476069987,
-0.2512542009,
0.3433870077,
-0.6279146671,
-0.2581315041,
-0.0699460953,
-0.2008963227,
0.0181204472,
0.1824173331,
-0.2540802658,
-0.1277736276,
-0.7041701674,
0.2857695222,
-0.1948914677,
-0.5966234207,
0.2310077101,
0.748421967,
-0.4264762402,
-0.99803859,
-0.5737621784,
0.31515643,
-0.274671644,
-0.5236857533,
0.2235353291,
0.086066559,
-0.3440368772,
-0.2823558152,
0.0557945967,
0.1017328054,
-0.0049619409,
-0.0307711978,
-0.0488244183,
-0.2317537516,
0.4530501366,
0.1986344308,
-0.2995460033,
-0.0208737366,
-0.2622733712,
-0.0672982633,
-0.6335386038,
-0.3057567179,
-0.1224373728,
0.135537684,
0.632709682,
-0.5821061134,
0.2336911112,
0.7847747207,
-0.13153328,
0.013285147,
-0.1844701767,
0.1904848814,
-0.3401255906,
0.5256850719,
-0.3212085068,
-0.4221762121,
0.5887323022,
-0.0312449951,
0.4697142243,
0.8577144742,
0.2767702639,
-0.1129187793,
0.6852974296,
0.4707000852,
-0.2396459877,
-0.0717434734,
-0.2863743901,
-0.439832598,
-0.7721948028,
-0.2336816043,
-0.2607821822,
-0.3506963849,
-0.3280378282,
0.2198389322,
0.6227715611,
-0.1064826921,
-0.1565123647,
0.1208667755,
-0.1232298017,
0.6914636493,
0.2590289414,
-0.113017261,
0.8031374812,
-0.2133731097,
-0.2259729207,
-0.1413065344,
-0.6803309917,
-0.7489379048,
1.1247819662,
0.2761956453,
0.3449587524,
0.1270400137,
0.3665376306,
0.5616024137,
0.5189287663,
-0.6489280462,
0.1777433157,
-0.2900705934,
-0.3878766596,
-0.7382002473,
-0.3828039169,
-1.0276757479,
0.7416728735,
-0.2274404168,
-0.1932402253,
-0.1215643212,
-0.229409799,
-0.4126314521,
0.157131508,
-0.3791643977,
1.0610803366,
-0.2673420906,
-0.2748781443,
-0.1582725048,
-0.8009863496,
0.5095223188,
-0.4459977448,
0.6107200384,
-0.0852444991,
-0.3675771952,
1.024949789,
-0.7005217075,
0.5587038398,
-0.1178028658,
-0.0438410677,
0.1800375581,
-0.1638408452,
0.1984404624,
0.4742189944,
-0.2002432346,
0.3181316555,
0.3513685763,
-0.4816162288,
-0.4401522577,
0.3242426813,
-0.8438515067,
0.0499722995,
-0.4195023477,
-0.3015196621,
-0.5198032856,
0.3440815508,
0.4104264081,
0.5433135033,
-0.5365449786,
0.1590179801,
0.0950692445,
-0.4046199322,
0.7004417181,
0.9104284048,
-0.2815438509,
-0.8583021164,
1.1132491827,
0.0654901788,
-0.2546422482,
0.3732889891,
0.1559706479,
-0.3959094584,
-0.3287180066,
-1.023971796,
0.1755414158,
-0.8387050033,
-0.246759519,
-0.5463674664,
0.1540646851,
0.1011151299,
-0.0037474267,
-0.3914083838,
-0.7646397948,
0.2490633726,
-0.0927573144,
0.0339058861,
1.048052907,
-0.2269183248,
0.5648376346,
-1.1072921753,
0.2119305134,
0.4921188653,
0.5466730595,
0.0430337973,
-0.6327059865,
-0.6665080786,
0.0366297327,
-0.2139284313,
-0.6357921958,
0.3359609842,
0.6647075415,
0.737210989,
0.2104304284,
0.0200112779,
0.517187953,
-0.1559008956,
0.7468973994,
0.0285290312,
-1.1731332541,
0.3111412525,
-0.5026643872,
0.6186220646,
1.0269411802,
0.4005306959,
-0.890619874,
-0.2840915918,
-0.3388411701,
-0.5717903376,
0.5167710185,
0.0463477708,
-0.0538813733,
0.2893383503,
0.27532354,
0.7589518428,
0.7072483301,
-0.5736308694,
-0.0682552233,
-0.651679039,
-0.0658341944,
-0.4118497968,
0.1036192328,
0.1509901732,
-0.1636289358,
0.7644260526,
-0.2564025223,
-0.4585737288,
-0.0439932048,
-0.7109929919,
-0.139353618,
-0.0130282724,
0.4654598236,
0.8392575979,
-0.0059987875,
0.0962415263,
0.5675672889,
-0.7174783349,
0.0162435696,
-0.0735525191,
0.0954802483,
0.2901111245,
0.9960713387,
0.3589294553,
0.3552105725,
-0.5858761072,
0.7885817885,
-0.2516055703,
-0.0625888035,
-0.0925246552,
-0.3606038094,
-0.1105199233,
0.1356416792,
0.3894409835,
-0.1925839931,
0.3679338694,
-0.3945156336,
0.2305649221,
0.1358761042,
-0.2976029813,
-0.4078482091,
0.5561435819,
0.4329020679,
0.264149636,
0.4263883531,
-0.4079525471,
-0.3493758738,
0.3864605427,
0.1071385592,
0.6964934468,
-0.1905988604,
0.4278810322,
0.560095191,
0.4787849486,
-0.0318479426,
0.3779681325,
0.0744674355,
-0.5856765509,
-0.3572968245,
-0.6065386534,
-0.7117063403,
0.2295456976,
-0.649284482,
0.233334139,
-0.2588578165,
-0.1530252248,
0.17978701,
0.2509600222,
-0.4376046658,
0.2674920857,
-0.0650284812,
0.7587303519,
-0.9274128079,
0.3329552412,
0.8978207707,
-0.6374536753,
-0.2576684654,
-0.3339535594,
-0.1330476552,
-0.5375390053,
0.3914805353,
0.2251175195,
-0.1576212496,
-0.3867571652,
-0.0756307021,
-0.7364410758,
1.0924866199,
0.3275086284,
-0.3500816524,
0.4506145418,
0.4260905683,
0.6222663522,
-0.5769077539,
0.4852756858,
0.615899682,
0.7350674272,
-0.1848680526,
-1.2562009096,
-0.1620367318,
-0.5866963863,
-0.2801358402,
-0.2166977525,
-1.1814684868,
0.6687259078,
-0.3320893049,
-0.086568661,
-0.384660542,
0.6112912893,
0.1253663003,
0.5874768496,
0.4569992423,
0.3016241789,
1.0612113476,
-0.0238135923,
0.7076314092,
-0.5624362826,
0.1589390188,
1.1320955753,
-0.2502845228,
0.7530788183,
-0.0865258127,
-0.233953163,
0.440325141,
0.7043322325,
0.0343149118,
0.4921585917,
-0.0535865575,
-0.0386492871,
-0.1554126889,
0.0619015843,
-0.4469688237,
0.619992137,
0.2276102901,
-0.042166926,
-0.4922197461,
0.0976366997,
-0.0503004901,
0.0005927245,
-0.3809790611,
0.9933448434,
0.02631904,
-0.4451593161,
0.5494312644,
0.115123041,
0.3931915462,
-0.4135807753,
0.1158083305,
-0.494448483,
-0.0646125302,
-0.4517241716,
-0.6798317432,
0.3142833412,
-0.1003303826,
0.0322476923,
0.010124837,
0.5339310765,
-0.4965776503,
-0.4575097263,
-0.0311714578,
0.8139850497,
0.4238555133,
-0.3025743365,
-0.5000255108,
-0.1489043534,
-0.4317231178,
-0.1907292306,
0.1635528505,
0.7814189792,
-0.2454303205,
0.6772910953,
0.4469034672,
0.0949763134,
-0.4379177392,
0.2073891461,
0.5683609247,
-0.546022892,
-0.7572174668,
-0.8017311096,
0.4107676148,
-0.1413820982,
-0.5585147142,
0.8041520715,
1.0768940449,
0.6898923516,
-0.1847628504,
1.3235818148,
0.6087837815,
0.5551933646,
-0.2477273643,
0.9989057779,
-0.5665598512,
0.2018668354,
-0.2601774037,
-1.0266002417,
-0.2825188935,
0.4657172561,
-0.2011136562,
0.0301135387,
0.7091175318,
0.1059081405,
-0.0174263958,
0.3875668943,
0.3098194897,
-0.2799755037,
-0.0439304188,
0.4660695493,
0.8917402029,
-0.5487583876,
0.5676698089,
-0.1402850002,
-0.357531935,
-0.1734271348,
-1.0039913654,
-0.864087224,
-0.5952308178,
-0.3027155995,
0.1270387918,
0.0815963596,
0.8319900632,
0.4598101974,
-0.9633831382,
-0.5347354412,
0.5116980672,
0.1251585037,
-0.4000213146,
-0.0839806944,
0.4436294138,
-0.5964078903,
-0.3955269456,
0.1596381217,
0.5371828675,
0.0243289191,
-0.4103132784,
-0.1493180543,
0.4120367765,
-0.1828559786,
0.8465237021,
0.2039745003,
-0.1903210431,
0.1184324995,
-0.2018602192,
-0.1254589707,
-0.0841505677,
0.5951250792,
-0.711802721,
0.4174606502,
0.1973492503,
0.4617800713,
0.5321692824,
-0.0484466441,
0.701708734,
-0.6720007658,
0.0285897292,
-0.0897410363,
0.5039096475,
0.5844555497,
-0.0675382242,
0.7025330067,
0.2351513505,
-0.2958137393,
-0.4580831528,
-0.2943262756,
-0.5654020905,
-0.0270136893,
0.7008839846,
-0.3918385208,
-0.0867426246,
-0.2941333652,
-0.1486021429,
0.3054123521,
-0.3481115997,
0.9538239241,
0.7580038309,
0.1483966261,
0.1269368231,
-0.6625658274,
0.5959831476,
0.1122273207,
-1.1012660265,
0.3024320602,
0.3122233748,
0.1711572409,
0.2222813964,
0.4673127532,
-0.0786553025,
0.4926639497,
-0.0080386009,
0.1275077015,
-0.1879324168,
-0.1468398124,
-0.4244355857,
0.1527661979,
-0.1071228981,
-0.0106083909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13192v2 | SimCSE++: Improving Contrastive Learning for Sentence Embeddings from Two Perspectives | 2023-05-22T16:24:46 | 2023-10-20T13:07:23 | Jiahao Xu, Wei Shao, Lihui Chen, Lemao Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper improves contrastive learning for sentence embeddings from two
perspectives: handling dropout noise and addressing feature corruption.
Specifically, for the first perspective, we identify that the dropout noise
from negative pairs affects the model's performance. Therefore, we propose a
simple yet effective method to deal with such type of noise. Secondly, we
pinpoint the rank bottleneck of current solutions to feature corruption and
propose a dimension-wise contrastive learning objective to address this issue.
Both proposed methods are generic and can be applied to any contrastive
learning based models for sentence embeddings. Experimental results on standard
benchmarks demonstrate that combining both proposed methods leads to a gain of
1.8 points compared to the strong baseline SimCSE configured with BERT base.
Furthermore, applying the proposed method to DiffCSE, another strong
contrastive learning based baseline, results in a gain of 1.4 points. | [
-0.4084092379,
-0.5281558633,
0.6011918783,
0.2206875384,
-0.4461122751,
0.1428426802,
-0.0807720497,
-0.6173294783,
0.3031261265,
0.3751559258,
-0.5387122035,
-0.5062918663,
-0.6506466866,
-0.2107291669,
-0.385214448,
1.0139584541,
0.0582460165,
0.5813784003,
-0.5078265071,
-0.06614618,
-0.7217207551,
-0.3715839684,
-0.7621007562,
-0.0179807488,
0.3728476465,
0.5456197858,
0.6960608363,
0.6818706393,
0.4991196692,
0.2289721668,
-0.3081325889,
0.2540412545,
-0.5648984909,
0.3329213858,
-0.0565399639,
-0.343829453,
-0.1224225461,
0.1165023968,
0.2742651105,
0.6560373306,
-0.1444139481,
-0.4326423109,
0.2735926509,
0.6050193906,
-0.8830302954,
0.0469289832,
-0.519210875,
0.1322732717,
-0.0816651955,
-0.0034816312,
-0.4362299144,
-0.3927787542,
0.063400276,
-0.6497038603,
0.1533314586,
-0.2717300653,
1.013430357,
0.3002255261,
-0.5043872595,
-0.5289620757,
-0.2498281002,
1.100689292,
-0.4205324948,
0.3037204742,
0.2091848999,
0.0351320654,
0.0771718174,
-0.5406569839,
-0.1483622342,
-0.5726350546,
-0.0948769897,
0.3950302005,
0.3522451222,
0.0938416049,
0.2889927328,
0.5012418032,
-0.0513186753,
-0.0452322736,
-0.3138024211,
-0.3508195877,
0.4984837174,
-0.1501878947,
0.1153524071,
-0.0246229265,
-0.4605816305,
-0.2180661261,
-0.5751863718,
0.0755597427,
0.4178187251,
0.329839021,
-0.2645248175,
-0.0503541417,
0.2152163684,
0.2986145318,
-0.026248211,
0.1687246412,
0.6934005618,
-0.4892138839,
0.0477516875,
0.0433073826,
0.2274328023,
0.1296856105,
0.3279904127,
-0.0789086521,
0.1698681712,
0.0712242648,
0.3726224899,
-1.0739448071,
-0.4835033119,
0.2306263447,
-0.3764120936,
-0.7193279266,
0.4031130075,
-0.6857180595,
-0.624968648,
-0.4811535478,
0.5076624751,
-0.8186782598,
-0.0722273141,
0.0692102686,
-0.2645710111,
-0.053781908,
0.5745634437,
-0.5479889512,
0.4171297848,
0.648907423,
0.6923687458,
-0.1896760911,
-0.0949813649,
-0.9592551589,
-0.1224588156,
-0.1764481962,
0.5665721297,
-0.6495667696,
-0.2748809755,
0.256940037,
-0.3225723207,
0.077094987,
-0.6804919243,
1.1185103655,
-0.0453361981,
0.2236292064,
-0.7392827272,
-0.8202544451,
-0.1558633596,
0.1541051567,
-0.6268211007,
0.9183975458,
-0.0291511696,
-0.880468905,
0.5295168757,
-0.6070927382,
-0.6252856851,
-0.2035246193,
-0.3405634165,
-0.8303815126,
0.2633297443,
0.3653928041,
0.3927362263,
0.2277750373,
0.2185853124,
-0.1967876554,
-0.8654792309,
0.1167189777,
-0.348167479,
0.985701561,
0.1964482367,
-0.0414141305,
-0.22256805,
-0.8480007052,
-0.0028258313,
-0.2142398059,
-0.0807480142,
-0.5418890715,
0.2428933233,
0.1392851323,
0.2437790334,
-0.0093800118,
-0.6606160998,
0.0554046072,
-0.2272563875,
0.3851715922,
0.4152449369,
0.0936590061,
0.2147700787,
-0.4074311852,
0.2047429681,
0.8890626431,
0.0079721231,
-0.2256816179,
-0.2114288658,
-0.9281079769,
-0.6307960153,
0.424497515,
0.7485486269,
-0.8073622584,
0.3619245589,
0.2092541605,
-0.18771559,
-0.7293146849,
0.1382869482,
0.5213783979,
0.3713734746,
0.7349047661,
-0.3473595679,
-0.6686373949,
-0.8729055524,
-0.0133775948,
0.0814174116,
0.1394096911,
0.4960369468,
0.3259040713,
0.1601610929,
0.5881991386,
-0.480861634,
-0.3196104169,
-0.2278644443,
0.1514776796,
-0.1267338246,
0.8546534181,
0.637111783,
-1.0032711029,
-0.5057718158,
-0.4822927415,
-0.6266596913,
-0.0437471159,
-0.2399999052,
-0.1623181403,
-0.156122759,
0.8560593724,
-0.4352323711,
0.1742876768,
0.3835082948,
-0.2606076598,
0.4893793166,
-0.1524362266,
0.1181238517,
-1.5340424776,
-0.4309698343,
0.1975904554,
-0.2546756268,
-0.6032863855,
0.0368057154,
0.2845378518,
-0.1570868492,
-0.529055059,
-0.0806308761,
-0.5807422996,
0.2317125201,
0.2269996107,
0.3133007288,
0.1244507283,
0.1535401344,
0.0633806288,
0.6813351512,
0.7837197185,
-0.4781348109,
-0.0365880094,
0.1362889856,
-0.3027516007,
0.6250388622,
-0.3709776103,
-0.2287185788,
-0.2415676266,
0.199737072,
-1.0472258329,
0.0219541006,
0.0979176387,
-0.2134896666,
0.6183236241,
0.2737992704,
-0.0425794609,
0.1418740302,
-1.0338140726,
0.2438168377,
0.368267864,
-0.5997741222,
-0.0572489798,
0.0838010684,
-0.0676705986,
-0.8164894581,
-0.9168649912,
-0.0095790233,
-0.006535972,
-0.434759438,
0.5689154863,
-0.0575278066,
-0.2268062383,
-0.0269292928,
0.0116765387,
-0.1531322449,
0.2451840788,
0.2478766441,
0.1099093929,
-0.2350423336,
0.5115127563,
0.4166483879,
-0.2717189491,
-0.2270151228,
0.1194066033,
0.3260752559,
0.0915963799,
-0.3743217289,
-0.6478663683,
0.4633385241,
0.2504517436,
-0.0185715258,
0.7473340034,
0.7592748404,
-0.0960799605,
-0.1323140562,
-0.6402829289,
-0.2822483778,
-0.4209789634,
0.7540926933,
-0.3828887939,
-0.8543401957,
0.4036705494,
-0.2232858092,
-0.1187084764,
0.1843064874,
0.1115113348,
-0.4493213296,
0.5142208934,
0.8279784918,
-0.0492033623,
0.7892351151,
-0.3054963946,
0.2850458026,
-0.6620084643,
-0.139679715,
-0.5345079899,
-0.4314491749,
-0.8844919205,
-0.4116428196,
0.0080803297,
0.5739040971,
-0.17862764,
0.4445472658,
-0.3374630511,
0.6060446501,
0.4216372669,
0.3412983716,
0.2352475375,
0.1040936559,
-0.3268797994,
-0.6209012866,
-0.4581382871,
-0.0662294924,
0.7166951895,
0.2546252608,
0.5009529591,
0.1088028848,
1.1156620979,
0.1848226786,
0.0780051425,
-0.6003194451,
0.3625014126,
-0.662317872,
-0.1706324369,
-0.0243017524,
-0.4247190058,
-0.4306453168,
0.4626557827,
-0.4190071225,
-0.6511516571,
0.7516341805,
0.1063505933,
-0.1577660888,
0.1764878035,
-0.8089420199,
0.8166432381,
0.0456662811,
-0.3613937795,
-0.4236558378,
-0.5429726839,
0.2670094073,
0.3728474677,
0.1765607893,
0.2596884966,
-0.2776156366,
0.1286312044,
-0.2960558534,
0.7247329354,
-0.2423647195,
-0.0439466722,
0.0609281361,
0.0995765105,
0.6692576408,
0.2335671782,
-0.3402479291,
0.1523676068,
-0.3603378534,
-0.5415753722,
-0.5358563066,
0.8782465458,
-0.8487516046,
-0.2565481365,
-0.4048025608,
-0.8200300932,
-0.2361708432,
-0.4076707065,
0.3862247467,
0.5935439467,
-0.1953260899,
0.5507428646,
0.7995423675,
-0.2055686563,
0.5615686178,
0.2125938982,
0.2766015828,
-0.4453678131,
1.1143738031,
0.228110984,
0.424601227,
0.4815662205,
-0.1248177662,
-0.0475513041,
-0.7544848919,
-0.085010156,
0.1115915254,
-0.5629673004,
-0.1779126376,
-0.6021214724,
-0.5850332975,
-0.1085346863,
-0.4697164893,
-0.3837299645,
-0.4601688385,
-0.4680549502,
-0.3206273615,
0.1710278839,
0.4217737615,
-0.116724506,
-0.0258971695,
-0.4175042808,
0.1217138693,
0.0581699982,
0.2949361503,
-0.1076356843,
-0.5046844482,
-0.2476032227,
0.0035261479,
-0.6324657798,
-0.8198261261,
0.0257068984,
0.3676841855,
0.4746033549,
0.4186721146,
0.1016811579,
0.8037868142,
-0.2437683046,
0.8663578629,
0.1856584102,
-1.1368876696,
0.4605703354,
0.045784995,
0.1438451409,
0.9350902438,
0.3583589792,
-0.3091450334,
-0.7219021916,
-0.7839769125,
-0.8709170222,
0.6033326983,
0.5813560486,
0.2893081009,
-0.1485669464,
0.5267615318,
0.1697933674,
0.3326768875,
-0.7654095888,
-0.2323251814,
-0.2246156782,
-0.2888335288,
0.0694703832,
-0.7085864544,
0.3211613297,
-0.2751086056,
0.7457975745,
0.1882058829,
-0.0693364218,
0.1493545473,
-0.2769985795,
0.1812918335,
0.4351716638,
0.5416238308,
0.4725357294,
-0.2708420753,
0.0189966056,
0.2962959707,
-0.7242785692,
-0.0501086861,
0.1010683849,
-0.4371034801,
0.1177676097,
0.556450665,
0.7405920029,
0.2834635675,
-0.4906689823,
0.8020672202,
0.0480278656,
-0.4123439789,
-0.0172031168,
0.1656835377,
0.1354332864,
0.1334863305,
0.1671238989,
0.3585719466,
0.4372053146,
-0.5407871604,
0.4827203453,
0.346470952,
-0.8213372827,
0.268991828,
0.167614162,
0.5393255353,
-0.0386138782,
0.5753469467,
-0.3699963689,
-0.3183251321,
0.9231960177,
0.4817066193,
0.8033856153,
-0.0489167646,
0.4669209421,
0.472422719,
0.1184993312,
-0.013188011,
0.3779151738,
-0.2253509313,
-0.768856287,
-0.5862469077,
-0.3385173082,
-0.5250686407,
0.1739443541,
-0.9826152325,
0.4765219092,
-0.199085921,
0.3106219769,
0.0612134971,
0.4372802079,
-0.2261269987,
0.1468790621,
0.0728917122,
0.7152622342,
-1.0431919098,
0.9329723716,
0.6631160378,
-0.7415333986,
-0.3905448318,
0.3873617649,
-0.0736809224,
-0.4096496999,
0.5973072052,
0.4348992407,
-0.1214021519,
-0.1400630772,
-0.5799523592,
-0.7155964375,
1.0044915676,
0.767070055,
-0.8906280994,
0.5347065926,
-0.1929656267,
0.4903440177,
-0.5506507754,
0.3644653559,
0.3931982517,
0.1924414337,
0.3874498606,
-0.4039966762,
0.0747045353,
-0.1239422709,
0.2453560978,
0.3477286696,
-0.6795310974,
1.0829594135,
-0.3457294106,
-0.2367196381,
0.2081789225,
0.4949288666,
0.0861863047,
0.1079821885,
0.4413350821,
0.8094214201,
0.7979560494,
-0.2138250023,
1.0034227371,
-0.175894469,
0.4740775526,
1.3413966894,
-0.2213191092,
0.9365276098,
0.6145102382,
-0.0588614382,
0.7408409119,
0.5349854827,
-0.1085179001,
0.6126992702,
0.3501063585,
-0.1349342763,
-0.5120080113,
-0.2058085799,
-0.4954218566,
0.0646183789,
0.2706110179,
-0.3720944524,
-0.4615750313,
0.0312022939,
0.1319604069,
0.5379833579,
-0.033774782,
0.7507531643,
0.2346467525,
-0.1891007721,
0.179793939,
-0.2565828264,
0.7585795522,
-0.3889421821,
-0.4148090184,
-0.3669471443,
0.4750403464,
-0.2814267278,
-0.5941286683,
0.2716622353,
-0.1810133457,
-0.3336850107,
0.0115402527,
0.3820055723,
-0.9122869968,
-0.6688396335,
0.5800048709,
0.3672561944,
0.131305635,
0.0562662259,
-0.891371429,
0.2333144397,
0.032793425,
0.151348725,
0.4986754656,
0.4112068713,
0.0425652154,
0.5103232265,
0.3648048341,
0.1229384094,
-0.3798787892,
0.6340865493,
0.776006639,
-0.5764068365,
-0.6668598652,
-0.9408673048,
0.7003550529,
-0.5819464922,
-0.1471400559,
0.5697011948,
0.5987015367,
0.7718038559,
0.0436879098,
0.4901703596,
0.0121973623,
0.5191974044,
-0.6935209036,
0.5173803568,
-0.5237982869,
0.4581714869,
-0.3290571868,
-0.9568863511,
-0.4771822691,
0.765071094,
-0.0908331349,
0.158184737,
1.0953752995,
0.8530166149,
-0.1137508452,
0.0235909168,
0.4075842202,
0.3595640957,
0.1926444024,
0.5650184155,
0.5600427985,
-0.8737761974,
0.6445809603,
-0.4578336477,
0.0783471391,
-0.220869109,
-1.0758935213,
-0.6964685917,
-0.2893122733,
-0.831659019,
-0.2161583304,
0.5467506051,
0.69929111,
0.8065871596,
-1.2260222435,
-0.1127333492,
-0.4862723649,
0.1979299784,
-0.658403039,
-0.2210481614,
0.4969835281,
-0.9163025618,
-0.6473125219,
0.080855161,
0.1392973512,
-0.0905178338,
-0.0428703725,
-0.0190602727,
-0.4194292128,
0.179627195,
0.5405840874,
-0.2772059739,
-0.518655479,
-0.4419955611,
-0.752343297,
-0.3762694597,
0.2518018484,
0.9729645252,
-0.6165792346,
0.3661792278,
0.4102720916,
0.5019424558,
0.6144703627,
0.3199863732,
0.2972497344,
-1.1478327513,
0.6491034031,
0.2166628987,
0.3599786758,
0.4429094493,
-0.622674346,
0.3147798181,
0.3216900229,
-0.070515357,
-0.5215670466,
0.2604504228,
-1.1229673624,
-0.4445424974,
0.6915650964,
-0.2223623097,
0.3568122387,
-0.1317483634,
-0.4477619529,
0.0604491457,
-0.6219915748,
0.7445671558,
0.9016730785,
0.045006223,
-0.324529171,
-0.3710618615,
0.8023924828,
0.5431575179,
-0.7469516397,
-0.1688865423,
0.5709158778,
0.1602277607,
0.3101420701,
0.0959422663,
-0.2991220951,
0.3950544894,
0.3132777512,
-0.0140772099,
-0.356972307,
-0.4034466147,
-0.49066329,
0.461150676,
-0.1769800335,
-0.439217031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13191v1 | Taxonomy Expansion for Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-22T16:23:46 | 2023-05-22T16:23:46 | Karthikeyan K, Yogarshi Vyas, Jie Ma, Giovanni Paolini, Neha Anna John, Shuai Wang, Yassine Benajiba, Vittorio Castelli, Dan Roth, Miguel Ballesteros | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Training a Named Entity Recognition (NER) model often involves fixing a
taxonomy of entity types. However, requirements evolve and we might need the
NER model to recognize additional entity types. A simple approach is to
re-annotate entire dataset with both existing and additional entity types and
then train the model on the re-annotated dataset. However, this is an extremely
laborious task. To remedy this, we propose a novel approach called Partial
Label Model (PLM) that uses only partially annotated datasets. We experiment
with 6 diverse datasets and show that PLM consistently performs better than
most other approaches (0.5 - 2.5 F1), including in novel settings for taxonomy
expansion not considered in prior work. The gap between PLM and all other
approaches is especially large in settings where there is limited data
available for the additional entity types (as much as 11 F1), thus suggesting a
more cost effective approaches to taxonomy expansion. | [
-0.5501263738,
-0.3516055942,
0.3511916399,
-0.1772157252,
-0.3849321306,
0.180885613,
-0.1140439659,
-0.6711233854,
0.319393903,
0.6191961765,
-0.3612686396,
-0.3366545141,
-0.6484366059,
0.5303176045,
-0.2967988849,
1.0932416916,
-0.0157988239,
-0.1636703461,
-0.4217905104,
-0.3121551573,
-0.3558163345,
-0.793854773,
-0.8365120292,
-0.402543813,
0.7564219832,
0.3084678352,
0.5064296126,
0.7298628688,
0.7635143399,
0.2236026227,
-0.4049266875,
0.3495459557,
-0.1267764121,
-0.1723629832,
-0.046039138,
-0.6121091843,
-0.6336762905,
-0.1295431852,
0.9146100283,
1.0006507635,
-0.1512942165,
0.0995907038,
-0.337511301,
0.4632463753,
-0.4215365648,
0.2120198458,
-0.4465967417,
0.1729882956,
-0.3464284837,
-0.1998540014,
-0.5049085021,
-0.0850908682,
0.7897338867,
-0.871102035,
0.2886159718,
0.0214978848,
0.8747040629,
0.2285912484,
-0.7331659198,
-0.1943227947,
-0.9019600153,
0.5600482225,
-0.535461843,
0.4533124566,
0.0839174911,
0.158755213,
-0.1856737584,
-0.9820341468,
-0.3963542283,
-0.1914376915,
-0.172425732,
0.0760409832,
-0.130137682,
0.256493032,
0.670458734,
0.4971993268,
-0.2356535643,
0.1612088829,
-0.3561597466,
-0.2211689651,
0.5280617476,
0.0338706672,
0.4107406437,
0.0085130725,
-0.7990887761,
-0.0296966806,
-0.6669985056,
-0.1205845699,
0.2977373898,
0.3900210559,
0.1022141427,
0.6207678318,
-0.0454437621,
1.0631030798,
-0.0156664569,
-0.1424914896,
0.4920897484,
-0.1953635812,
-0.2733407617,
0.2152028978,
0.2778323889,
0.1006874517,
-0.2226696908,
-0.2855246961,
-0.5483773351,
-0.0596568212,
0.0862321705,
-0.44324857,
-0.6175847054,
-0.0453818515,
-0.1693024337,
0.0645238608,
-0.1290908605,
-0.8051520586,
-0.6365072131,
-0.5785667896,
0.548656106,
-0.4304974079,
-0.4061877728,
-0.0263790898,
-0.346231699,
0.3266621828,
0.4297793508,
-0.5246098638,
0.4162759781,
0.7390323877,
0.9119576216,
-0.2545641065,
0.0517945848,
-0.5310975313,
0.1959725022,
-0.1580429375,
0.9502484798,
-0.7471341491,
-0.3065629005,
-0.1502482146,
0.0918286294,
-0.0183920693,
-0.7205704451,
0.4065763354,
-0.8071382046,
0.0988007709,
-0.1690289825,
-0.897756815,
-0.3194076717,
0.1109756157,
-1.1293795109,
0.8407950997,
0.3435239196,
-0.9271108508,
0.5586547256,
-0.6567819118,
-0.380399406,
0.4493543208,
0.0218962431,
-0.411865294,
0.2631877363,
0.0420121104,
-0.0155026959,
-0.4212605953,
0.3957540989,
-0.2526032627,
-0.0918263271,
0.2246134132,
-0.0024129776,
0.5325671434,
-0.0985429734,
0.0666095465,
0.0218448434,
-0.8851397038,
-0.2379205525,
-0.0998703316,
-0.5439952016,
-0.8346974254,
-0.2235423476,
-0.1819659173,
0.0549900606,
0.3628813028,
-0.5217313766,
0.2905021012,
-0.5845638514,
0.3043929935,
0.4774289429,
0.1486091912,
0.8366720676,
-0.2888460457,
0.5798910856,
0.2570125461,
0.0687673166,
-0.0437604934,
-0.6172407269,
-1.2927899361,
-0.4848276079,
1.1813846827,
0.4218710065,
-0.985799551,
0.3518503606,
-0.3850105703,
-0.4958273172,
-0.3791272938,
-0.1623760909,
0.1758313775,
0.6708335876,
0.4553925991,
-0.6807168126,
-0.9386929274,
-1.0556968451,
0.0253361892,
0.0193719026,
0.0035715627,
0.28036955,
0.6739715934,
-0.1748529077,
1.1286740303,
-0.3961743712,
-0.3165673018,
-0.2054645121,
0.2588883042,
0.2424972504,
0.310202986,
0.1566720158,
-0.9975628853,
-0.3303430676,
-0.089538224,
-0.45662269,
0.1278114468,
-0.3370735049,
-0.0429130681,
0.0298591927,
0.0387635492,
-0.4237971008,
0.3373233974,
0.1640763879,
0.1401857436,
0.1024914607,
-0.2468959391,
-0.5868826509,
-0.9661175013,
-0.0375683196,
0.2862062156,
-0.2796969712,
-0.9817169309,
-0.0159978215,
0.1379124522,
-0.1800776422,
-0.3169738948,
0.6843176484,
-0.9750225544,
-0.2493816167,
-0.3648423553,
-0.0942156315,
-0.2051948458,
0.208701238,
0.6550102234,
0.5074816942,
0.7165399194,
-0.7375831604,
0.4999869764,
0.2401664108,
-0.2007018328,
0.3315282166,
-0.3873033822,
0.1801557839,
-0.3804916143,
0.5345979929,
-0.6616373062,
-0.3685493767,
0.276180923,
-0.0938500091,
0.7143216133,
-0.3598690331,
-0.5706800222,
-0.5259215832,
0.0176116508,
0.2621586323,
0.4352209866,
-0.832295835,
1.1441479921,
0.5706655979,
-0.0434420817,
-0.3422709405,
-0.4816677868,
0.2359999567,
-0.4844641984,
-0.3761490583,
0.5686261654,
0.1219119877,
0.0243686736,
0.1352024227,
-0.3987012208,
-0.2480622828,
-0.0192592032,
0.1534823179,
0.3340816498,
-0.2777134776,
0.221218884,
-0.0228678174,
-0.122337006,
-0.0714270845,
-0.2225459665,
0.4668599069,
0.0973048285,
0.1398896128,
-0.4719057381,
0.240579769,
0.0845614895,
-0.3620463312,
0.6952909231,
0.2173303813,
-0.7351749539,
-0.2325436473,
-0.499969691,
-0.0940177441,
-0.4589203894,
0.2190607786,
-0.5533784628,
-0.6833872199,
0.4389937818,
-0.3517666757,
0.0454160161,
0.390599668,
0.1128666848,
0.1194475889,
0.6066716313,
0.9138149619,
0.401247263,
0.4873275459,
-0.2338666469,
0.1906388849,
-1.1698737144,
-0.5018168092,
-0.1018834487,
-0.3943687975,
-0.6744986773,
-0.5106832385,
0.1005604342,
-0.0020430237,
0.0322372206,
0.6430561543,
-0.6086736321,
0.4420308769,
0.8767312169,
0.1878720373,
0.2421084642,
0.2001181692,
0.1008341312,
0.0814271122,
-0.7045007944,
-0.3760323226,
1.1037695408,
0.4228506684,
0.367649287,
0.2601242959,
1.0756481886,
-0.0090077929,
0.821031332,
-0.8886569738,
0.5552424192,
-0.2599907219,
-0.6964413524,
-0.0953480005,
-0.5702887774,
-0.7765557766,
0.0781943947,
-0.0629064888,
-0.3836022615,
0.702892065,
0.0688496754,
-0.5480979681,
0.2858856022,
-0.7647370696,
0.457467407,
-0.3933413625,
0.1139562055,
0.5339522958,
-0.7745299339,
0.3227381408,
-0.5128126144,
-0.0095244832,
0.0037012147,
-0.5563691854,
1.2937716246,
-0.4030890763,
0.7868767381,
-0.3441665471,
-0.041805055,
0.3342023492,
-0.3300187886,
0.5328332782,
0.1328246593,
0.0765634775,
0.1884378791,
-0.2056561112,
-0.179734692,
-0.6048775911,
0.4210779071,
-0.6726056337,
-0.6670508385,
-0.9483010173,
-0.4671506584,
-0.4274592102,
0.2181820869,
0.2047856301,
0.2515183091,
0.3925012648,
0.0729788169,
0.9083260298,
-0.2781597376,
0.2659943104,
0.699958086,
0.0417401642,
-0.8325125575,
0.8343035579,
0.420938611,
0.1737724692,
0.5633273125,
-0.0419465601,
-0.4298948646,
-0.5383038521,
-0.2121310383,
0.3426017463,
-0.567502141,
-0.440764308,
-0.8142803311,
-0.381518364,
-0.1726825684,
0.3400276601,
-0.1395576894,
-0.4552481771,
-0.6498060226,
-0.0956349224,
0.5168660283,
0.4975840151,
-0.1362001002,
0.5784602761,
-0.5951142311,
0.1468269229,
0.2734164298,
0.3861199021,
-0.005279168,
-0.7851994634,
0.1431981027,
0.0332144499,
0.0088026393,
-1.1235733032,
0.4074761868,
0.3385694623,
0.5085602999,
0.2732948661,
0.1304872483,
0.8758906722,
-0.551728785,
0.4736634791,
0.4537560344,
-0.6144357324,
0.490775317,
-0.0905518979,
-0.0194501411,
0.3341433406,
0.6596169472,
-0.4063755274,
0.1685726196,
-0.6807880402,
-1.1630964279,
0.8324769139,
0.0330546647,
0.1510565579,
-0.0281219836,
0.5861615539,
0.2162256688,
0.1223549247,
-0.8049360514,
-0.5030491948,
0.080175817,
-0.0062205447,
-0.0844584107,
-0.4958765209,
-0.1291841567,
-0.3179752231,
0.7045359015,
0.2241249233,
0.4070222378,
0.2492604405,
-0.0263415873,
0.2608284354,
0.2059873641,
0.3619273603,
0.4084368646,
-0.2362312227,
0.307025224,
0.1974569857,
-0.2427463979,
0.1471874416,
0.5001121759,
-0.2634028792,
0.299631089,
0.153769806,
1.0027471781,
0.0447211489,
-0.478089422,
0.3659506142,
0.0365115516,
-0.144550994,
-0.5299145579,
-0.006281794,
0.0832900181,
0.1136135831,
0.3041037917,
-0.04376477,
0.1414414346,
-0.4123370647,
0.3450270593,
0.0635764971,
-0.4016382992,
-0.2145400792,
0.4967770278,
0.2507910728,
-0.3534055054,
0.7513754964,
-0.3802411854,
-0.5168610215,
0.8495283723,
0.7090027332,
0.4534241259,
-0.0635612756,
0.3038632274,
0.3889089525,
0.4562199116,
-0.2769510448,
0.2029091865,
0.0381348059,
-0.5887815952,
-0.3834188581,
-0.7186151743,
-0.4936143756,
0.4161780775,
-0.7219914794,
0.3761884868,
-0.4917756915,
-0.5064794421,
0.3000479043,
0.0280585401,
-0.6854540706,
0.4252646863,
0.4753044248,
1.142925024,
-0.7862186432,
0.7241531014,
1.0888646841,
-0.7087734342,
-0.6978948712,
-0.2499194741,
-0.2513694763,
-0.4109123647,
0.6706989408,
0.2529292703,
0.4757929146,
0.0012502832,
-0.0865032151,
-1.341904521,
1.0271660089,
0.195514828,
-0.9258764982,
-0.3066837788,
0.1642520577,
0.6495547295,
-0.4877407849,
0.0288503692,
0.406250298,
0.3597798347,
0.2305078357,
-0.7920452356,
-0.0845813677,
-0.0913515314,
0.3850711286,
0.5256593823,
-0.4197171628,
0.6568466425,
-0.1247180924,
-0.5079978704,
0.2487835288,
0.9079070091,
0.0203877985,
0.4882819951,
0.623167634,
0.6739012003,
1.1755251884,
-0.2154566795,
0.8588917851,
-0.0571484827,
0.4067713916,
1.7269858122,
-0.663215518,
0.7371532321,
0.3146316111,
-0.0830597803,
0.3023606837,
1.1918911934,
-0.5110605359,
0.6269257665,
0.3836544156,
-0.423024267,
-0.3442284167,
-0.4419798255,
-0.4834157526,
0.2429105639,
0.3650873899,
-0.5308765769,
-0.1306895614,
0.2948040068,
-0.2306533903,
-0.4642561376,
-0.4015484452,
0.950748086,
0.0721586272,
-0.3660667539,
0.1418929547,
0.0520587191,
0.8096461892,
-0.3563716114,
-0.0215218142,
-0.2729045153,
-0.1204120889,
-0.3008082509,
-0.4800619185,
0.1042811051,
-0.0498926565,
-0.1130321771,
0.05657617,
0.7541396022,
-0.4542248547,
-0.5722342134,
0.2437294871,
0.285254091,
0.1282254606,
0.1948803514,
-0.3736323416,
-0.4532397687,
-0.0588720702,
0.0246102531,
0.2846667171,
0.386962682,
-0.0959608257,
0.6569681168,
0.5841943622,
0.1761278957,
0.5314512253,
-0.0790371895,
0.8468927145,
-0.4537675381,
-0.1994335502,
-0.5013929009,
0.1903969646,
-0.4433453083,
-0.2146321237,
0.5127221942,
1.0116084814,
1.0438580513,
-0.0273560099,
0.7268627882,
-0.0342345461,
0.5295826793,
-0.2453793883,
0.2042473704,
-0.5810524225,
0.2775671184,
0.0386759825,
-1.0459427834,
-0.6404646039,
0.3818745315,
-0.5034325719,
-0.0808352605,
0.5579555631,
0.429407835,
-0.1065753922,
0.1000212356,
0.0607417934,
0.090511784,
0.0442983732,
0.5442198515,
1.0893675089,
-0.2443772405,
0.3349754214,
-0.5307844877,
-0.2810600996,
0.0782219768,
-0.7430348992,
-0.6924052238,
-0.3866536915,
-0.8583509922,
-0.3299425542,
-0.033562135,
0.7144830227,
0.6035020351,
-0.6504553556,
0.2709600329,
-0.0914428607,
-0.1132391989,
0.0197389759,
-0.1846211553,
0.2928568423,
0.0446180291,
-0.6146157384,
0.2007440031,
0.2189127207,
0.2588538826,
0.1131745502,
0.218967855,
-0.315590471,
0.134725675,
0.3238409758,
0.3999905884,
-0.7181250453,
-0.0462070964,
-0.1083057448,
0.3052060902,
0.2934118211,
0.6724439859,
-0.6874444485,
0.6323587298,
0.2707493007,
0.7799630165,
0.4539346695,
-0.084551841,
0.3064096868,
-0.880772233,
-0.1870456636,
0.3376970887,
0.4178134203,
0.4294924438,
-0.327018261,
0.6347789764,
0.3072381914,
-0.1568864286,
-1.060428977,
0.2093898058,
-1.1416655779,
0.1106147245,
1.1755466461,
-0.1750981808,
-0.3686234355,
-0.0033442571,
0.0961388722,
0.3774247766,
-0.3602075279,
0.3428617716,
0.5271109343,
-0.3802184761,
-0.1194359213,
-0.2385271639,
0.3112398088,
0.0678392872,
-0.8401278257,
-0.112943545,
0.4425621331,
0.6056315899,
0.3964007497,
0.6156392694,
0.0330856293,
0.1433688998,
-0.0936608985,
0.0341515802,
0.0174412224,
-0.5472354889,
-0.4610661566,
0.1645358205,
0.0367190465,
-0.1485128701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13186v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13186v3 | SCITAB: A Challenging Benchmark for Compositional Reasoning and Claim Verification on Scientific Tables | 2023-05-22T16:13:50 | 2023-10-23T07:19:30 | Xinyuan Lu, Liangming Pan, Qian Liu, Preslav Nakov, Min-Yen Kan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current scientific fact-checking benchmarks exhibit several shortcomings,
such as biases arising from crowd-sourced claims and an over-reliance on
text-based evidence. We present SCITAB, a challenging evaluation dataset
consisting of 1.2K expert-verified scientific claims that 1) originate from
authentic scientific publications and 2) require compositional reasoning for
verification. The claims are paired with evidence-containing scientific tables
annotated with labels. Through extensive evaluations, we demonstrate that
SCITAB poses a significant challenge to state-of-the-art models, including
table-based pretraining models and large language models. All models except
GPT-4 achieved performance barely above random guessing. Popular prompting
techniques, such as Chain-of-Thought, do not achieve much performance gains on
SCITAB. Our analysis uncovers several unique challenges posed by SCITAB,
including table grounding, claim ambiguity, and compositional reasoning. Our
codes and data are publicly available at https://github.com/XinyuanLu00/SciTab. | [
-0.0022551334,
-0.4282862842,
0.7861002684,
0.5297083259,
-0.122217685,
0.5668514967,
0.0671711117,
-0.572524488,
0.0612975135,
0.1554351449,
-0.3598215282,
-0.4410850108,
-0.5990298986,
0.531616807,
-0.2824322283,
1.030557394,
-0.2490057051,
0.3114641309,
-0.6680347919,
-0.049635984,
-0.5729599595,
-0.145084545,
0.1906647086,
-0.3441852033,
0.5136736035,
0.3421386182,
0.3930329978,
0.6370942593,
0.7318412662,
0.1999456435,
0.0728795156,
0.3895531297,
-0.1985585243,
0.3116870821,
-0.3901446462,
-0.5563163757,
-0.3349175751,
-0.1385810226,
0.75304389,
0.6644796133,
0.0403167978,
0.3254867494,
-0.4170205891,
0.5252607465,
-0.7947040796,
0.4279274344,
-0.6380828023,
0.1377937943,
-0.4494157732,
0.0812207833,
-0.7429590225,
-0.6612608433,
0.1436250657,
-0.3663634062,
0.0223157071,
0.2925168276,
0.8629859686,
0.3554749787,
-0.5932751298,
-0.2265469283,
-0.4319264591,
0.4806417823,
-0.2669122517,
0.5407542586,
0.2566502392,
0.1986988336,
-0.2335980982,
-0.9058862925,
-0.5970178843,
-0.4634360671,
-0.1187912598,
0.0350453481,
-0.3279027939,
-0.2272658944,
0.5431081057,
0.083157897,
-0.9827703834,
-0.1162761673,
-0.4589416385,
-0.3321529627,
0.3332844675,
0.0437530354,
0.274125278,
-0.4170591235,
-0.3073981106,
-0.3145109713,
-0.9261270165,
-0.1948277801,
0.1004418582,
-0.0208871569,
0.0808376595,
0.71601969,
-0.2989477813,
0.5041208267,
-0.1889878213,
0.3091524243,
0.2188275605,
-0.3186091185,
0.1386455446,
0.4709229767,
0.6822670102,
0.3420110941,
-0.2538718283,
-0.1848786622,
0.1749797612,
0.2581247091,
-0.0348052271,
-0.8692923188,
-0.5228437185,
0.3162410855,
0.0927543789,
0.0982167423,
0.0422845408,
-0.6199170351,
-0.4332494438,
0.2419012338,
0.633877039,
-0.3171964586,
-0.0193578992,
-0.0665292367,
-0.1803243309,
-0.0950055867,
0.2027964145,
-0.589304626,
0.1878355294,
0.6288776398,
1.0842092037,
-0.3044115007,
-0.1871681511,
-0.2175425589,
0.2453460395,
-0.4093654454,
1.3004362583,
-0.4478222728,
-0.2864129841,
-0.721183002,
-0.3169101477,
-0.0909684524,
-0.4739247859,
0.5947233438,
-0.3456290662,
0.1255985051,
-1.0048452616,
-0.5421926379,
0.1717392504,
0.1785213649,
-0.8027889132,
1.0602631569,
0.1783643067,
-0.8297389746,
0.9278629422,
-0.7792681456,
-0.453223139,
0.5566549897,
-0.2961262167,
-0.2732858956,
-0.1051639169,
0.0351458527,
0.0826956183,
-0.4184008539,
0.6311458349,
-0.3207100928,
-0.1482195556,
0.4788947701,
0.0285466686,
0.446667999,
0.4766998887,
-0.4233427048,
0.1060928032,
-0.8288923502,
0.2946987748,
0.1309274137,
-0.111441806,
-0.2757228017,
0.332190901,
-0.1001996994,
0.0067652506,
0.0545062684,
-0.8333117962,
0.3758527637,
0.0600281581,
0.7361488342,
0.448472321,
-0.0271200351,
-0.1528700441,
-0.4224648178,
0.1958667338,
-0.0897867978,
-0.2623018324,
-0.2183109969,
-0.2871791124,
-0.1929971129,
-0.3249811232,
0.7301610112,
0.3873238266,
-0.4134874344,
0.32135427,
-0.4238382876,
-0.8016639948,
-0.5066460967,
-0.2598461509,
0.2567593455,
0.8989339471,
0.7199390531,
-0.2003519088,
-0.766787827,
-1.1206703186,
-0.392586261,
-0.2527478933,
0.0076838285,
0.0646581873,
0.9048292637,
0.1400594413,
1.1685326099,
-0.4290402234,
0.1223933548,
-0.0538076572,
0.3105603456,
0.0988970771,
0.6480529904,
0.1794186234,
-0.6659154296,
-0.5950912237,
-0.0656779185,
-0.7790925503,
-0.422713846,
-0.0627714843,
0.210049659,
0.1242978051,
0.0945234224,
-0.9097054601,
0.0563828759,
0.3145645261,
-0.5833251476,
0.8238931298,
0.0636681691,
0.332298398,
-0.5552390218,
0.4118002653,
0.0390544459,
-0.2634985745,
-0.3431282938,
0.0495230034,
0.338069737,
0.108170867,
-0.2772834897,
0.3189087212,
-0.4059708416,
-0.0816947147,
-0.1327768117,
-0.1835158616,
0.2088342309,
-0.0358335748,
0.1102387607,
0.7818319798,
0.2887304425,
-0.1934618652,
0.2365199476,
0.5222792029,
-0.7594575286,
0.6179575324,
-0.9074426293,
-0.0227172095,
-0.0068434728,
0.8449803591,
-0.7760336995,
-0.4403498471,
0.1612248421,
-0.0345342755,
-0.0140927378,
0.1149691716,
-0.4883310199,
-0.4801560044,
-0.1150808781,
0.3341402709,
0.273996532,
-0.5630696416,
0.6448536515,
0.0952783301,
-0.2749964893,
-0.7834230065,
-0.5683416724,
0.3141408861,
-0.1124628484,
-0.5692732334,
0.5400389433,
0.0305889435,
-0.3015203476,
0.0790070668,
-0.851278007,
0.2035565376,
-0.0663556829,
0.2714188397,
0.1719195992,
-0.0125187272,
-0.1878142953,
0.1944815218,
0.0093133627,
0.5727149844,
0.0307076536,
0.386108011,
-0.4745981991,
-0.5151962042,
-0.2090712488,
0.1367501915,
0.4410019517,
-0.1134491488,
0.2748704553,
0.2509198487,
-0.3591575325,
-0.2688643038,
-0.7313962579,
-0.3735489547,
-0.4294930696,
0.6600428224,
-0.3935097158,
-0.6130591035,
0.6126481891,
-0.0958043188,
-0.0984662995,
0.5294770598,
0.390285939,
-0.1974437684,
0.8470122218,
-0.0604678802,
0.4490455687,
-0.192192167,
0.0338243172,
0.0008511553,
-0.4678326845,
-0.8317613602,
-0.9596791863,
-0.2127784789,
-0.2947219908,
-0.3695526719,
0.4548890889,
-0.390707165,
-0.2596109211,
0.5149162412,
-0.5777878165,
0.900249064,
0.5441471934,
0.3382974863,
0.6019536853,
-0.2368496805,
-0.06892851,
-0.2158811688,
-0.6381889582,
-0.4212677181,
0.8154868484,
0.27094087,
0.795678854,
-0.042941384,
0.4076316953,
0.5118976235,
0.4206043184,
-0.3176385164,
0.5540088415,
0.2099972069,
-0.8434247375,
0.0642359033,
-0.774366498,
-0.4622152746,
0.4854376912,
-0.3216285706,
-0.7233418226,
0.1757695228,
0.2575707138,
-0.2618020475,
0.1013702303,
-0.8594048619,
1.1589827538,
-0.5697298646,
-0.6858824492,
-0.1554943472,
-0.8304888606,
0.4452278018,
-0.0754311234,
-0.0506707989,
-0.1714628637,
0.3774922192,
0.8536159396,
-0.4407974482,
0.5632626414,
-0.2446525246,
0.2347915918,
0.1765488535,
0.3971759081,
0.6051794887,
0.0656351522,
0.0964177549,
0.0063141347,
0.6462651491,
-0.4713160396,
-0.4063309729,
0.4897982776,
-0.5203976035,
-0.4592299461,
-0.9215106964,
-0.6149388552,
-0.4872093797,
0.4261271656,
0.2249764502,
0.0571768135,
-0.1859170645,
0.6108155847,
0.5435160398,
0.0634247214,
0.0645990893,
0.4658693969,
0.0709049404,
-0.241856873,
0.8708580732,
0.1243212298,
0.0228079855,
0.1622783393,
0.2271349579,
-0.6366177201,
-0.7567338347,
-0.4038737118,
-0.0630685017,
-0.6398226619,
-0.475448668,
-0.7363615632,
0.2463326156,
-0.1406419128,
0.2064820081,
-0.4217993915,
-0.4870398939,
0.1848577112,
-0.2865673006,
0.2287802547,
0.7289863229,
-0.15368554,
0.0421762653,
-0.570902884,
0.1464138925,
0.0057963757,
0.4804417491,
-0.2889764905,
-0.1349186003,
-0.0133612184,
-0.1268337518,
-0.3098275065,
-1.0367796421,
-0.0824701712,
0.1425569504,
0.5429486036,
0.1480630189,
0.0668309554,
0.5150350928,
-0.4291224778,
0.7135881782,
0.0561585091,
-1.1778674126,
0.446056813,
-0.2315775901,
-0.0246285629,
0.857684195,
0.8279961348,
-0.2852144241,
-0.1996780336,
-0.4436379969,
-0.7647436857,
0.4080839157,
-0.1770927012,
-0.4673343003,
0.0507963561,
0.1662993133,
0.3239098787,
0.1971662194,
-1.0162314177,
0.2998406291,
-0.4701018631,
-0.2607393265,
0.4902334809,
-0.0132864434,
-0.3027795255,
-0.2134065628,
0.5561578274,
-0.162481755,
-0.1898891032,
0.3636458218,
-0.4058509469,
-0.1414067447,
0.3261280656,
0.7648203373,
0.9420803785,
-0.4230524004,
0.3860957921,
0.1310420483,
-0.5289296508,
0.1724732965,
0.142545566,
-0.4103484452,
-0.0978696346,
0.4035123289,
0.5824280977,
0.3409921825,
-0.9213540554,
0.2697534859,
0.1662682146,
-0.3051324189,
0.2322191894,
0.0522791632,
0.0037886882,
0.12477272,
0.8225358129,
0.1190649644,
0.0512039028,
-0.3820639849,
0.2679350674,
0.3957483172,
0.1041282788,
-0.3068523705,
0.9785765409,
-0.2101141065,
0.1603019387,
0.2797975838,
-0.0969617739,
-0.5486317873,
0.4812909961,
0.6400793195,
0.2805555463,
-0.0484389253,
0.4030862749,
0.282850951,
0.4947626889,
-0.3283341825,
0.3362512589,
-0.1639093757,
-0.3251610994,
-0.6164664626,
-0.3847022355,
-1.2288597822,
-0.0921878889,
-0.4330543578,
0.0296558347,
-0.5907079577,
-0.1908997148,
0.3876649439,
0.1649339199,
-0.3898270428,
-0.1247154698,
-0.3101642728,
1.0067470074,
-1.186106205,
0.5126638412,
0.5037699938,
-0.4223539233,
-0.749953866,
-0.6024461389,
-0.0076357294,
-0.4554730058,
0.8584797978,
0.061401736,
0.0373956934,
-0.2008454204,
-0.8874821067,
-0.6638752818,
0.8082817793,
0.5816489458,
-0.4137486219,
-0.1325885803,
0.1198875681,
0.5862947702,
-0.0292215925,
0.4373963475,
0.539604485,
1.0491931438,
0.2348363101,
-0.7494469285,
0.5159422159,
-0.150242433,
-0.643515408,
-0.1022956669,
-0.5835672021,
0.8419592381,
-0.2248171866,
-0.1649185121,
-0.2103354782,
0.8438616991,
0.719417572,
0.5496988297,
0.2564506233,
0.5225160718,
0.8359376788,
-0.5631098151,
0.5186852813,
-0.056910824,
0.1967905462,
1.248226881,
-0.9922744632,
0.5974215269,
0.5619202852,
-0.411154747,
0.8116667867,
0.7136028409,
-0.8332872987,
0.5045787096,
0.3090889752,
-0.0760703981,
-0.1196050793,
-0.1978820264,
-0.6790622473,
0.4692216814,
0.4309270084,
0.0401999392,
-0.4711500108,
-0.1908415258,
-0.1258618236,
0.1222607642,
0.1179579124,
0.4203804135,
-0.2204288542,
-0.7699249387,
0.2229914069,
-0.0556024238,
0.3242843747,
-0.7028542757,
-0.1648712456,
-0.0348735191,
-0.1528124809,
-0.5588985085,
-0.653922379,
0.2033515871,
0.0982505009,
0.1075594947,
-0.1263356209,
0.4372520447,
-0.3206481934,
0.0350755118,
-0.4119379818,
0.3912999332,
0.0453914404,
-0.0803675726,
-0.3787700832,
0.3181495368,
-0.1729091853,
-0.3077695668,
0.1742325127,
0.1497573853,
-0.2730814815,
0.7332134843,
0.6914523244,
0.1715088487,
-0.0566935129,
-0.2621594965,
0.7312175632,
-0.5132887959,
-0.588049531,
-0.8206496835,
0.2408151925,
-0.0600631088,
-0.1336664855,
0.8533021212,
0.946803689,
0.5427061915,
-0.1757855713,
0.5018858314,
-0.4189072549,
0.2612715065,
-0.4256928861,
0.8804230094,
-0.0796167478,
-0.0641968697,
-0.4266673923,
-0.8751803041,
-0.5397768617,
0.7545542121,
-0.25390172,
0.135591045,
1.1623595953,
0.43064183,
0.0384734459,
0.4855021834,
-0.2358214408,
0.3711841702,
0.5099437833,
0.581800878,
0.9064166546,
-0.1911839396,
0.2846164107,
-0.0166171826,
-0.1322162151,
-0.0980904549,
-1.3486377001,
-0.5725836158,
-0.5872867703,
-0.4667581618,
-0.6228247285,
-0.0322006308,
1.0936626196,
0.7103239298,
-0.9886434078,
0.0844421387,
-0.1073460132,
0.0839812905,
-0.134769246,
-0.1794621497,
0.5290024281,
0.2135771066,
-0.2830505669,
0.7273442149,
-0.0222138166,
0.079943113,
-0.2366956323,
0.3318925202,
-0.238380596,
-0.1186331958,
0.3361367583,
0.7058660984,
-0.3705824614,
-0.3186151087,
-0.0058507221,
-0.1076355726,
0.0911745876,
0.7821515203,
-0.7867355347,
0.12378674,
0.5055499077,
0.7003444433,
0.9116373658,
0.1867968589,
0.2067278177,
-0.7165309787,
-0.265227288,
0.5581032038,
0.4430468976,
0.291008532,
-0.0904712602,
0.5653882623,
0.4244809449,
-0.5215582252,
-1.6191405058,
-0.0658264831,
-1.2923594713,
-0.124125652,
0.4015693665,
0.0848450884,
-0.3553358018,
-0.0304872505,
0.0674034581,
-0.1487697959,
-0.3238617778,
0.9741039872,
0.9328439236,
-0.2647364438,
0.0930564553,
-0.2663407028,
0.5265407562,
0.6078538895,
-0.9799368382,
0.3070780933,
0.7612476349,
0.4814396799,
0.2960173786,
0.2714267373,
-0.156495437,
0.6086047888,
0.1225706413,
0.1959706098,
-0.5421444774,
-0.6797255278,
0.0812328979,
0.5655628443,
-0.0720041469,
0.5021471381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13179v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13179v2 | Teaching Probabilistic Logical Reasoning to Transformers | 2023-05-22T16:08:20 | 2024-02-09T17:29:19 | Aliakbar Nafar, Kristen Brent Venable, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | In this paper, we evaluate the capability of transformer-based language
models in making inferences over uncertain text that includes uncertain rules
of reasoning. We cover both Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) and generative
Large Language Models (LLMs). Our evaluation results show that both generations
of language models struggle with reasoning over uncertain text. We propose a
novel end-to-end fine-tuning approach, Probabilistic Constraint Training (PCT),
that utilizes probabilistic logical rules as constraints in the fine-tuning
phase without relying on these rules in the inference stage. To assess the
effectiveness of PCT, we utilize the related corpora and, additionally, create
a new and more challenging benchmark that, unlike the previous ones, uses
instance-specific rules. Our study demonstrates that PCT improves the
transformer-based language model's intrinsic reasoning and makes their
probabilistic logical reasoning process more explicit and explainable.
Furthermore, PCT equips these models to effectively handle novel situations,
including higher reasoning depth, new domains, and complex probabilistic
structures. | [
-0.1634872258,
-0.7989430428,
0.8614490032,
-0.0848692879,
-0.2072500437,
-0.1265112311,
-0.3586384654,
-0.070108898,
-0.7170341611,
0.641243875,
-0.7883448005,
-0.1333928853,
-0.5704701543,
0.0590319484,
-0.3099443913,
0.8580607772,
-0.1406866759,
-0.0972084254,
-0.0667876601,
0.3517842889,
-0.4417700469,
-0.4197430909,
-0.5095421076,
-0.4431236386,
-0.2591374218,
0.4416316748,
1.2009876966,
0.3521782756,
0.6332845092,
0.3279373646,
-0.0787690878,
0.279630661,
-0.2016029507,
0.0455635749,
-0.7978103161,
-0.8532587886,
0.0755512267,
-0.1091473624,
0.3278578222,
0.6906021833,
-0.2041397691,
-0.1556225568,
-0.3067551255,
0.2603249848,
-0.5797861218,
0.3835158944,
-0.9590115547,
0.1411688179,
0.0934824795,
-0.2152911276,
-0.843830049,
-0.3148545027,
0.0954758748,
-0.7716330886,
0.4293885827,
0.0854855552,
1.0086758137,
0.6837977767,
-0.4983425736,
-0.1353837699,
-1.1813622713,
0.7698651552,
-0.5622435212,
0.4160482883,
0.4501043856,
0.4711952209,
-0.3902812898,
-0.8008548021,
-0.920748055,
-0.1104720533,
-0.0433132462,
0.3223545849,
-0.090824388,
0.2160926163,
0.2091669291,
0.2409121245,
-0.331184715,
0.1202294081,
-0.0657715127,
0.0086432965,
0.4527179599,
-0.0107762916,
-0.1647152603,
-0.1379247457,
-0.3042269647,
-0.3155120313,
-0.4810261428,
0.0644543469,
0.4077763855,
0.2912130952,
0.0626907721,
0.5647492409,
-0.0676520616,
0.7105358839,
0.1968660802,
-0.2222610861,
-0.0837199092,
-0.0095638642,
-0.30044052,
-0.2289701253,
0.7403367758,
0.2480579913,
0.6621183157,
-0.2016578466,
-0.1702869833,
0.3806450367,
0.2084058076,
-0.5398358703,
-0.3288376629,
0.0796646699,
-0.3084732294,
-0.2226666361,
0.1848879457,
-0.3411205113,
-0.121305868,
-0.6095257401,
0.5768806338,
-0.8130078912,
-0.1209183037,
0.6308758855,
-0.0265566669,
0.382840693,
0.445181042,
-0.8934614658,
0.2827838957,
0.8681320548,
0.1316635907,
0.2205176055,
-0.1231355518,
-0.3593566418,
0.2567749918,
-0.2990552485,
0.9463959932,
-0.78743577,
-0.0785278231,
-0.0124964761,
0.0679021105,
-0.2185123861,
-0.5617467761,
1.1222171783,
-0.4230768383,
0.3784894347,
0.0140896039,
-0.7774240971,
-0.0073952414,
0.1571278274,
-0.186135903,
0.7032216191,
0.3379536271,
-0.7940571904,
0.3787823021,
0.0424741656,
-0.5005705357,
0.0719331354,
-0.365357846,
-0.5116055608,
0.099727273,
0.2956237793,
0.3577408791,
-0.4322875738,
0.7564643621,
-0.1097624153,
-0.2188230902,
0.2622029185,
-0.6977526546,
0.68470788,
0.2720035315,
-0.3325760663,
0.1507814676,
-0.7149604559,
-0.0324250981,
-0.082314685,
-0.1591219455,
0.1176341921,
0.539398849,
-0.0713378936,
0.4155726731,
-0.0349729583,
-0.3881841004,
0.154253751,
-0.3760844171,
0.5980038643,
0.6358494759,
-0.0499492697,
0.3105611503,
-0.2743764222,
0.4570913017,
0.0730879232,
0.3965943158,
-0.083791256,
-0.6002368331,
-0.8692617416,
-0.0434961654,
0.1829529107,
0.9542867541,
-0.994009912,
0.7590533495,
-0.0729145333,
-0.4205753207,
-0.5205473304,
-0.2051897794,
0.1862897426,
0.6458160281,
0.55265975,
-0.0020385829,
-0.4363110065,
-0.9265229106,
-0.3717602491,
-0.4717333615,
-0.2864269018,
-0.0834050179,
0.4626023173,
-0.1177116111,
1.1631168127,
-0.4019877315,
-0.2158894092,
-0.4905318022,
0.1580319107,
0.3612266183,
0.6184837222,
0.1463938951,
-0.9312112331,
-0.2504509687,
-0.12645863,
-0.5616071224,
-0.0389725193,
-0.7003737688,
0.0166626517,
-0.0927604884,
0.5574531555,
-1.0245997906,
0.5933845043,
0.1912962794,
-0.4764137864,
0.8398525715,
-0.4316103756,
-0.0956942439,
-0.795642972,
-0.4991336763,
0.0671463236,
-0.3324967027,
-0.4535868764,
0.1150706112,
-0.0046634311,
-0.0198025983,
-0.3087466657,
0.0619367883,
-0.0181970838,
0.3349129856,
-0.1852396578,
-0.0689844415,
-0.0905581787,
0.1944111586,
0.3856589198,
0.6606718302,
0.4518082142,
-0.3475371599,
0.1598297358,
0.4691057801,
-0.5203925371,
0.6037904024,
-0.5581794977,
-0.3386753201,
-0.2759286165,
0.3449231088,
-0.5843096375,
-0.0336519815,
0.1487432271,
-0.2564591169,
0.4153755903,
-0.031112276,
-0.7115693092,
-0.4817822576,
0.3841734231,
-0.0104455072,
0.7301188111,
-0.3309961855,
0.6968844533,
-0.0999022275,
0.1121867374,
-0.4628449678,
-0.5651402473,
-0.0190728027,
-0.0726012215,
-0.5091595054,
0.6191051006,
0.0051350561,
-0.3714798093,
0.1051975414,
-0.3200847208,
-0.1008537561,
0.2006501406,
0.0311917886,
0.0100235529,
-0.163446486,
0.0032319752,
0.0748147145,
-0.5250407457,
0.2470632046,
-0.4974396229,
0.2990308404,
-0.4214342535,
-0.6588858366,
-0.683326304,
0.0782984868,
0.2073315084,
-0.3444932699,
0.9206241965,
0.5785303116,
-0.3617400229,
-0.3893208802,
-0.4873335958,
-0.3664116859,
-0.4926742911,
0.406288743,
-0.6708661318,
-0.988521874,
0.3429788053,
-0.2554408312,
-0.2813465297,
0.6321851015,
0.5810638666,
-0.0812287554,
0.9697124958,
0.6933293343,
0.3563409448,
0.1692385375,
0.0001154774,
0.6718919277,
-0.2691225708,
-0.1844572723,
-0.4866024554,
0.1049379781,
-0.8524225354,
-0.7178239822,
0.0670723841,
0.4648507833,
-0.5319196582,
0.392444998,
-0.4635105431,
0.6440278292,
0.7080904245,
0.2300215811,
0.2822279334,
-0.3207531571,
-0.1313497275,
-0.0766985565,
-0.6555716395,
-0.709395349,
0.7048681378,
0.3530804813,
0.853338182,
0.0277177244,
0.3034122884,
-0.2323855013,
0.2321380377,
-0.5856741071,
0.3892831206,
-0.2731367946,
-0.7423414588,
-0.1966583133,
-0.6196944118,
-0.5178761482,
0.1231580377,
-0.2078194469,
-0.8797555566,
0.289850831,
0.0598791167,
-0.3168467581,
0.6809501052,
-0.7399507761,
0.9109402299,
-0.2267617732,
-0.27989766,
-0.0803651512,
-0.9212725759,
0.365552932,
-0.0935050175,
0.2802131176,
-0.0500120781,
0.2663374841,
0.1865349412,
-0.6355324984,
0.8675330281,
-0.0045278384,
-0.0451323129,
0.6053388119,
0.2968378961,
0.5235315561,
0.2533033788,
-0.2163886875,
-0.3160955012,
-0.0602396689,
-0.2508800626,
-0.6280942559,
0.048083324,
-0.8556162119,
-0.862459898,
-0.3466609418,
-0.8962259293,
-0.4636088312,
0.123240836,
0.4600872099,
0.0144327274,
0.2520802617,
0.2532182336,
0.9812370539,
-0.5121718645,
0.1524349451,
0.4804532528,
0.2101114541,
-0.1453506798,
0.7975420952,
-0.1247716844,
0.4626611471,
1.0866734982,
0.3343090117,
-0.2287498713,
-0.5126618147,
-0.1151215956,
0.0036291035,
-0.7705138922,
-0.2328723073,
-0.5491887927,
-0.4020843506,
-0.2457067221,
-0.3012474775,
-0.3958470523,
-0.6948949695,
-0.1339960843,
-0.2116708905,
0.2295550704,
0.3367524147,
0.1236080453,
0.7788138986,
-0.505440712,
0.3708308339,
0.3818408549,
0.3848178387,
-0.4377812743,
-0.7133703828,
0.1370562911,
-0.2135558426,
-0.5915570259,
-0.9208839536,
0.2347311229,
0.3198165298,
0.5659061074,
0.6040151715,
0.3106425107,
0.3698035479,
-0.5562319756,
0.5350548625,
0.0108590703,
-1.0997549295,
0.6321136355,
-0.5832244158,
0.1717212051,
0.6179898977,
0.2897094488,
-0.2270858288,
-0.5752859116,
-0.8346403241,
-0.7674311996,
0.5934554338,
0.4610898495,
-0.0366025977,
-0.2220046222,
0.492039144,
0.1189243495,
0.2804610133,
-0.7761316895,
-0.1364282519,
-0.2177427262,
-0.5610819459,
-0.0458031483,
-0.1615191251,
0.3233665824,
-0.4788399339,
0.8168551922,
-0.2133962363,
0.1628565043,
0.0585293286,
-0.1193616167,
-0.0777819976,
0.5309380293,
0.5037945509,
0.634773016,
-0.3715393245,
0.3227754235,
0.1302254498,
-0.1843775064,
0.215040639,
0.3996269703,
-0.3381941915,
-0.1190351546,
0.4483166039,
0.8573709726,
0.2047448754,
-0.8108547926,
0.4706141651,
-0.1564752609,
-0.3876532018,
-0.4179379046,
0.068442598,
0.1995577514,
0.2203728557,
0.2021542937,
0.3590208292,
-0.2326960415,
-0.3368522227,
0.4396763742,
0.1636171788,
-0.4016778171,
-0.2569748163,
1.1203424931,
-0.181556344,
-0.2823506296,
0.7491819263,
-0.424542129,
-0.8082517385,
0.5402069688,
0.8135687113,
0.5767323971,
-0.3578571975,
0.3239973783,
0.064336881,
0.9160698056,
-0.3265759647,
0.3737235665,
0.0718853325,
-1.0098135471,
-0.8260116577,
-0.6637796164,
-0.6126124859,
0.0071609546,
-0.4062142968,
0.3332134187,
-0.3889323771,
-0.0308518894,
-0.1327775419,
-0.3312196136,
-0.8118980527,
0.4800160229,
-0.00046928,
1.0316462517,
-0.9341238141,
0.77471596,
0.5688982606,
-0.4182411432,
-0.9417639375,
-0.0712483972,
-0.1691202074,
-0.5567229986,
0.6089445353,
0.1339102983,
0.2153619826,
-0.1328607202,
-0.3260401785,
-0.5691978335,
0.58409518,
0.7580884099,
-0.7951468229,
-0.0453549065,
0.6439095736,
0.6134477854,
-0.1233684197,
0.4730552435,
0.8603807688,
0.5202919245,
-0.0979810655,
-0.7660043836,
-0.1034490541,
-0.00869356,
-0.1087994501,
0.2040049732,
-0.5619517565,
1.0120921135,
-0.3121362329,
-0.0111854058,
-0.1197654977,
0.8992636204,
0.191533491,
0.0339321755,
0.612071991,
1.0093867779,
0.6900997758,
-0.4225875139,
1.087334156,
-0.3097593784,
0.4501128197,
1.465810895,
-0.3139210343,
0.8462738395,
0.4009690285,
-0.3331914544,
0.5779540539,
0.5615644455,
-0.0365911573,
0.4795753956,
0.3638280332,
-0.3039323986,
-0.9366359115,
-0.0461249091,
-0.1780040711,
0.4672005177,
0.5300427675,
-0.2505785823,
-0.2475466877,
-0.1189028993,
-0.1653633118,
0.3756822944,
0.076306276,
0.4193270504,
0.1855065972,
-0.6976732612,
0.1946092099,
0.2576982975,
0.445028156,
-0.3951362669,
0.3041067719,
0.0269770958,
0.6432753801,
-0.1424296796,
-0.8840788603,
0.4008154571,
-0.1713487953,
-0.2683221996,
-0.3777240813,
0.6482279301,
-0.2613901794,
-0.8023738265,
-0.0235132352,
0.4117299616,
-0.1428588033,
-0.1459823847,
-0.5630712509,
-0.2832708657,
0.0146566443,
-0.3443356156,
0.0433888882,
0.9386751056,
-0.2522831261,
0.8690974116,
0.3418034315,
-0.0402742922,
-0.0882002935,
0.4062457383,
0.595682025,
-0.4125648141,
-0.4949967861,
-0.7532227039,
0.4959762692,
0.2472970635,
-0.2527062893,
0.4538576603,
0.3753488064,
1.122595787,
-0.1814179868,
0.8431175351,
-0.020455813,
0.314385891,
-0.39948982,
0.2740454674,
-0.0421322696,
0.3130020201,
-0.2426957935,
-0.8382664323,
-0.3525592387,
0.9237814546,
-0.6437195539,
-0.0110941185,
0.7784118652,
0.5909520984,
-0.225500688,
0.3701304793,
0.1371521205,
0.1618397534,
0.4826100469,
0.8227570057,
1.085996747,
-0.4943248928,
0.5925523639,
-0.4579399824,
-0.2593773901,
0.1702068299,
-1.0352252722,
-0.7813640237,
-0.4013156593,
-0.4889795482,
-0.1574909538,
0.0693483874,
0.7664210796,
0.6267752647,
-0.9010212421,
0.0675856248,
-0.6386240125,
0.0912854299,
-0.4611939192,
-0.3046414256,
0.3507644534,
-0.5478756428,
-0.4476128817,
0.2134206742,
0.0397142395,
-0.0543402508,
0.1809999496,
0.045952931,
-0.0843425319,
0.1125513017,
0.4870002866,
-0.1175166368,
-0.7435250878,
-0.5696950555,
-0.1418151855,
0.3516395092,
-0.1340193152,
0.7069862485,
-0.919250071,
0.2973492444,
0.3566492498,
0.6930642128,
0.4446865022,
0.0705817789,
0.7741433978,
-0.5933394432,
0.3539403677,
0.385640949,
0.4312542677,
0.2960772216,
-0.1796989888,
0.4394638538,
0.3693988323,
-0.6292182207,
-0.7421244383,
0.5455090404,
-0.8343363404,
-0.4938842654,
0.9396227598,
-0.0670185164,
0.0973364487,
-0.2452175915,
0.006531998,
0.4705222845,
0.0843475088,
0.698808074,
0.5455287099,
-0.0349162221,
-0.314581424,
-0.7163742185,
0.4446609616,
0.6568331718,
-0.8776236773,
-0.0162384491,
0.0734074488,
0.1313712746,
-0.0530710593,
0.0897255167,
0.0722813532,
0.0355002582,
0.027842097,
-0.0319587141,
0.1236991361,
-0.3665070832,
0.113758795,
0.1852083057,
0.0986850783,
0.3664614856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13175v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13175v2 | Discovering Universal Geometry in Embeddings with ICA | 2023-05-22T16:04:44 | 2023-11-02T16:03:33 | Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Momose Oyama, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study utilizes Independent Component Analysis (ICA) to unveil a
consistent semantic structure within embeddings of words or images. Our
approach extracts independent semantic components from the embeddings of a
pre-trained model by leveraging anisotropic information that remains after the
whitening process in Principal Component Analysis (PCA). We demonstrate that
each embedding can be expressed as a composition of a few intrinsic
interpretable axes and that these semantic axes remain consistent across
different languages, algorithms, and modalities. The discovery of a universal
semantic structure in the geometric patterns of embeddings enhances our
understanding of the representations in embeddings. | [
-0.2287715375,
-0.7036042213,
0.8231546879,
0.1176407188,
-0.4337574542,
-0.1719874144,
0.1318069845,
-0.4216856956,
0.4249242246,
0.4262600243,
-0.6416236758,
-1.121973753,
-0.5456284285,
-0.2259412855,
-0.1434381008,
0.3278918862,
-0.1800173521,
0.4865270853,
-0.2655112743,
-0.5075120926,
-0.7178441286,
-0.3678025901,
-0.0926987529,
-0.1114510447,
0.1503610164,
0.381669879,
0.7718469501,
1.1204783916,
0.5798627138,
0.3503251672,
0.1098520383,
0.0163865704,
-0.3029105663,
-0.1539934427,
-0.2706301212,
-0.5316582322,
-0.1346927285,
0.0036811703,
0.6681842804,
0.954574585,
0.1687692255,
0.0241687596,
0.207211405,
0.6062495708,
-0.7374409437,
0.7309522629,
-0.6219164133,
0.4177168012,
-0.2261589468,
-0.3578239083,
-0.197583884,
-0.2613408566,
0.307767421,
-1.0876811743,
0.219647646,
-0.3038244545,
0.8101568222,
0.164081946,
-0.5176496506,
-0.6516400576,
-0.7029158473,
0.833838582,
-0.1001318693,
0.5170613527,
0.1857587397,
0.0159088261,
-0.2749944627,
-0.6474559903,
-0.4243833423,
-0.0873577893,
-0.2065102607,
0.0746952966,
-0.1221768931,
0.0348756872,
-0.1235809848,
0.136280179,
-0.3559115827,
0.1750217527,
-0.5089872479,
-0.2816040218,
0.5201534033,
0.044160746,
1.09055233,
-0.3772484064,
-0.6271871924,
-0.2465280741,
-1.0539326668,
0.0660981163,
0.3109099269,
0.42026034,
-0.1675510257,
0.8121443987,
0.0540105626,
0.2550416887,
-0.333658278,
-0.0740659237,
0.0654432774,
-0.0865278393,
-0.0933459476,
0.198948279,
0.6663012505,
0.0489598066,
0.1137555465,
-0.3590574563,
0.3289679587,
0.4979957044,
0.2443617582,
-0.4616902769,
-0.40987885,
-0.2388009131,
-0.6470222473,
0.0409389399,
0.4802434146,
-0.7180395126,
-0.0535133071,
-0.9079599977,
0.3645177186,
-0.5782449245,
-0.04783329,
0.0651242733,
-0.0448361002,
0.6254850626,
0.2487711608,
-0.7387202978,
0.1881347001,
0.9738316536,
0.6422774196,
0.0296617225,
-0.3269891441,
0.0126858484,
0.3865409195,
-0.6579884291,
1.3154838085,
-0.7545519471,
-0.4067339599,
0.0943533555,
0.2315867543,
0.1337404847,
-0.3475321233,
0.4417040944,
-0.3735218644,
0.113930054,
-0.6555179954,
-0.6555600762,
-0.716275394,
-0.0067963726,
-0.634978652,
0.6435379386,
-0.2436135858,
-0.5979570746,
0.6174525023,
-0.4375903308,
0.1517204344,
0.2158191949,
-1.0125981569,
-0.3762831986,
0.5837982297,
0.3715892136,
0.3308191299,
-0.0651818216,
-0.0730245113,
-0.6499800682,
-0.0994611233,
0.0237687305,
-0.0759718195,
0.8894209862,
-0.0928554535,
-0.2860803306,
0.0054648588,
-0.818338871,
0.0097223846,
0.0818738714,
0.0348733813,
-0.6672518849,
0.2648686469,
-0.164714545,
0.1556883752,
0.1428370178,
-0.9583580494,
0.2346404642,
0.0051520946,
-0.0602719523,
1.1129623652,
0.0423828512,
0.484720856,
0.1737172455,
0.3243643343,
0.0713278949,
-0.161901772,
0.0829021782,
-0.5849988461,
-0.5913270116,
-0.6617745757,
-0.0839090943,
0.4237084985,
-0.3882291615,
0.67935431,
-0.3036321104,
-0.3089527488,
-0.4275248051,
0.3079926968,
0.4635582864,
0.2525203228,
0.1498324722,
-0.602496326,
-0.4184470475,
-0.8959869742,
-0.0029148739,
0.1023801565,
-0.090112552,
-0.0573023558,
0.2607131302,
-0.0924522355,
0.8466008902,
-0.7909411788,
-0.6657201648,
0.021874845,
0.1743753552,
-0.2380072922,
0.656963706,
0.7048328519,
-0.4514278471,
-0.5760146379,
0.1545131505,
-1.3523097038,
0.3297902346,
0.0537839718,
-0.7545328736,
-0.4053766429,
0.6984989047,
-0.468554467,
1.0352977514,
0.2624416649,
-0.8118297458,
0.1045174301,
-0.4534358382,
-0.0831888467,
-0.9288061261,
-0.1996878535,
-0.1671420038,
0.0382241048,
-0.3466337025,
0.2322474569,
0.0055356389,
-0.3471038043,
-0.3726540506,
0.3428030908,
-0.7724209428,
-0.5428960919,
-0.2517094612,
0.2409355938,
0.0261194762,
0.6249078512,
-0.0132026738,
0.4532640874,
0.8217647672,
-0.4461444616,
0.0070853974,
0.6427069902,
-0.5291534662,
0.7145269513,
-0.5452765226,
0.1564544439,
-0.6494069695,
-0.067382887,
-1.1318300962,
0.1601944119,
0.1707316637,
-0.1586852223,
0.19519265,
-0.0398745611,
-0.3004566729,
0.0334306695,
-0.3470056653,
0.4294387698,
0.024209436,
-0.8236809969,
0.9053431749,
0.6153101921,
-0.0836307928,
-0.2762003541,
-0.3002184331,
-0.2000602782,
0.0242626593,
-0.6733151078,
0.4618847668,
-0.0594307594,
-0.1240480915,
0.406159848,
0.0572694167,
-0.1694096923,
0.1605809182,
0.501542747,
0.3123889565,
-0.4521574676,
0.0005936552,
-0.031052094,
-0.4433030784,
0.0253191404,
-0.4393714666,
0.5599056482,
-0.0827216431,
-0.6401352286,
-1.1753071547,
0.6112923622,
0.3979646266,
-0.2421097904,
0.4196324646,
0.4956422448,
-0.5738548636,
-0.0005545158,
-0.2012221217,
0.0262278114,
-0.4516518712,
0.369294256,
-0.5269648433,
-0.4437869191,
0.8404259086,
0.1036455408,
-0.1982156038,
0.6389456987,
0.3400454521,
0.0184167214,
1.3909337521,
1.3071177006,
0.0478743874,
0.4593301713,
-0.5554147363,
0.2135915458,
-0.6979824901,
-0.7551398873,
-0.6631724238,
-0.4537648559,
-0.8584138155,
-0.3194202185,
0.4347125888,
0.1652187258,
-0.0312360618,
-0.0574111193,
-0.5365792513,
0.741817832,
0.625760138,
0.1985093951,
0.2970719934,
0.3873174489,
-0.4044116735,
-0.2035649717,
-0.1491351128,
-0.4546723962,
1.1523538828,
0.1704826653,
0.8190137744,
-0.0526879355,
0.4337893724,
-0.05210476,
0.1881657839,
-0.8769181371,
0.401157558,
-0.5896264315,
-0.2464902699,
-0.0269611552,
-0.1185583621,
-1.0587623119,
0.4057986438,
-0.1816826612,
-0.9846593738,
0.7389473915,
-0.1584145576,
-0.0324483067,
0.6507674456,
-0.3845928311,
0.8417565227,
-0.0221534278,
0.2558277845,
-0.3728283346,
-0.1765111685,
0.1613365859,
0.4009582698,
-0.1478343755,
-0.4498266876,
0.1283690482,
0.6175757647,
-0.44778952,
0.8199528456,
-0.1661876589,
0.023551736,
0.516962111,
0.228330493,
0.0555826724,
0.1093298048,
0.4813937247,
0.3765698373,
-0.0044508846,
-0.7437180877,
-0.7530668378,
0.705308497,
-1.2687021494,
-0.296894908,
-0.3275681436,
-0.5541114211,
-0.1067574248,
0.2359571457,
0.2461020797,
0.7737820148,
-0.3458551466,
0.3945291638,
0.4941446781,
-0.1230978519,
0.3566026688,
0.3130101562,
-0.1326826066,
-0.3387634456,
0.797596097,
0.1809801161,
-0.3645894527,
0.4441509545,
0.2783515453,
-0.1978343129,
-0.5303206444,
-0.2358142734,
0.5108767748,
-0.9368015528,
-0.1223111972,
-0.5431889892,
-0.06201417,
-0.3547203541,
-0.3864322305,
-0.6481689811,
-0.4437952042,
-0.3922320902,
-0.4212410748,
0.0530244485,
1.4288957119,
-0.1829627305,
0.3361887038,
-0.6485940218,
0.2439488769,
0.5069076419,
0.2441008538,
-0.1099937409,
0.0262617879,
0.0565807708,
-0.1267922223,
-0.4854553938,
-0.64122504,
0.3013257682,
0.158667326,
0.7400448918,
0.8118005991,
-0.5217405558,
0.738124311,
-0.5247098207,
0.6268423796,
0.293948859,
-1.0000693798,
0.4225838184,
-0.12004783,
0.3564421833,
0.4429279268,
0.6708953977,
-0.1553249061,
-0.2151071876,
-0.5408803225,
-0.6247861385,
0.3171521425,
-0.1147254556,
0.1612723917,
0.0243839994,
0.4334859848,
0.1992723644,
-0.3009038866,
-0.5428418517,
-0.2140304893,
-0.2051740438,
-0.4868002832,
0.1758791655,
-0.4759371877,
-0.3677782416,
-0.0941699669,
0.3322844207,
-0.1969766319,
0.5862196088,
0.197126478,
-0.3539284766,
0.0839253962,
-0.1674916893,
0.2918151915,
1.1557865143,
-0.0979457721,
0.2147595733,
-0.4756332338,
-0.6639005542,
0.0261474438,
-0.0003648605,
-0.3330556452,
0.0962942466,
0.5673570633,
0.6774001122,
0.3032336831,
-0.2357135564,
0.4776265621,
-0.4692554176,
-0.0109983673,
-0.3208008409,
-0.3747881949,
-0.3192768991,
0.0916657075,
0.3000311553,
-0.1929387152,
0.0852383673,
-0.6267389655,
0.4593529105,
0.6048581004,
-0.7161250114,
-0.9312671423,
0.1049896106,
-0.2746705413,
0.2330593914,
0.8733686209,
-0.0780248418,
-0.3771856427,
0.479429841,
0.4491029382,
1.1582095623,
-0.3053635955,
0.5211871862,
0.1770514697,
0.1878434718,
0.4675731957,
0.6468855739,
0.0268677119,
-0.9842357635,
-0.2398819029,
-0.5991643667,
-0.065238677,
-0.3098175228,
-0.8903788328,
0.2934987545,
-0.7085831761,
0.3606053293,
0.075909473,
-0.1191875488,
-1.0846275091,
0.0743416697,
0.114698045,
0.4905701578,
-0.9985309243,
0.6192808151,
0.7308431268,
-0.5349686146,
-1.0080968142,
-0.3005232215,
0.3165284097,
-1.0916410685,
0.9537629485,
0.2056507319,
-0.0567509346,
-0.4633314013,
-0.5525457263,
-1.3598554134,
1.2655453682,
0.5360427499,
0.1371648163,
-0.1928388625,
0.3934626281,
0.4186720252,
-0.6138676405,
0.0169896819,
0.2024257183,
-0.0224427823,
0.2675135136,
-0.308732152,
0.0263070185,
-0.10588146,
0.314414084,
0.0082504973,
-0.1669795811,
0.9112206101,
0.0731514692,
-0.6631315351,
0.0971378088,
1.1871235371,
0.0465216152,
-0.1206706688,
0.3950597644,
0.9159780145,
0.8355181217,
-0.0089024547,
0.9144159555,
-0.3910910189,
0.3781318069,
0.9470010996,
0.239565596,
0.7616730332,
0.1705560535,
-0.0047142357,
1.0625998974,
0.3407583237,
0.2396628261,
0.7713026404,
-0.0211047456,
-0.2520135939,
-0.1668592095,
-0.3723506927,
-0.3646192849,
1.1806522608,
0.5420166254,
-0.0646239892,
-0.6001592278,
0.2891528606,
0.2289617211,
0.1531881839,
-0.4428191483,
0.9795469642,
0.1650092751,
-0.2275885493,
0.1514241993,
-0.1710167676,
0.2420531958,
-0.7018557191,
-0.2279934883,
-0.1558734626,
0.4205872118,
0.0869373903,
-0.5219777822,
0.4075889885,
-0.5968222618,
-0.0917271972,
-0.0885170028,
0.534902215,
-0.4025143981,
-0.8911316991,
0.5316946507,
0.2606036067,
-0.1165158078,
0.222627297,
-0.5359428525,
-0.0562371463,
-0.1093065888,
0.18183209,
0.1971485019,
0.9054895043,
-0.0076328903,
0.3325551152,
0.7310348749,
0.0908728242,
0.2753689587,
-0.3227536678,
0.951203227,
-0.7264140248,
-0.832544148,
-0.582639873,
0.4537384212,
0.1221728697,
-0.268717885,
0.8284336329,
0.3686139286,
1.0384070873,
-0.0082622478,
0.3634735942,
0.242877081,
0.1173035055,
-0.8503111601,
0.4643844664,
-0.2617871761,
-0.1781513691,
-0.3312420547,
-1.0231269598,
-0.4939185083,
0.7289131284,
-0.2768132687,
-0.4684052169,
0.7717151046,
0.6745424867,
-0.2800337374,
0.3012818694,
0.2642598748,
0.2442851216,
0.6875847578,
-0.0163814947,
0.7289794683,
-0.2323959023,
0.2017487586,
-0.4591143131,
-0.4138239622,
0.3390792012,
-0.8409916759,
-0.6027882695,
-0.640838623,
-0.2553849518,
-0.1589827985,
-0.1888412684,
0.6525899768,
0.6914409995,
-1.0875387192,
-0.3292890489,
-0.1936158985,
0.2873286903,
-0.040747501,
-0.2086602747,
1.0259003639,
-0.580992043,
-0.77604568,
0.3549164832,
0.5925448537,
0.1354308724,
-0.5823941827,
0.4391877055,
-0.1306924522,
-0.0279050153,
0.5818985701,
0.3615784645,
-0.4550379515,
-0.6473989487,
-0.2710253,
0.0957158431,
0.1993936002,
1.2200616598,
-0.4483036697,
0.7522449493,
0.7803387642,
0.7431941628,
0.1766453832,
-0.1661030799,
0.8130226135,
-0.5898159146,
0.5925230384,
-0.1317449659,
0.728466332,
0.3075796068,
-0.3348875642,
0.2199089825,
0.3984237015,
-0.3227042854,
-0.3018814921,
0.3031224012,
-0.8652744889,
-0.3650118709,
0.4792524278,
-0.5529410243,
-0.649189651,
0.0324032754,
0.0720436126,
0.0822877362,
0.2170587033,
0.8269646168,
0.4943369031,
-0.2742194831,
0.3512227237,
-0.012839755,
0.4940492809,
0.2228841782,
-0.8253061175,
-0.4323252439,
0.4841758907,
0.3706880808,
0.5518069267,
0.4767192304,
-0.5979872942,
0.066500105,
-0.0928441733,
0.1585535258,
0.3093842268,
-0.7698799968,
-0.1931357831,
0.303955704,
-0.1924502105,
-0.6204612851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13172v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13172v3 | Editing Large Language Models: Problems, Methods, and Opportunities | 2023-05-22T16:00:00 | 2023-11-30T08:55:24 | Yunzhi Yao, Peng Wang, Bozhong Tian, Siyuan Cheng, Zhoubo Li, Shumin Deng, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG | Despite the ability to train capable LLMs, the methodology for maintaining
their relevancy and rectifying errors remains elusive. To this end, the past
few years have witnessed a surge in techniques for editing LLMs, the objective
of which is to efficiently alter the behavior of LLMs within a specific domain
without negatively impacting performance across other inputs. This paper
embarks on a deep exploration of the problems, methods, and opportunities
related to model editing for LLMs. In particular, we provide an exhaustive
overview of the task definition and challenges associated with model editing,
along with an in-depth empirical analysis of the most progressive methods
currently at our disposal. We also build a new benchmark dataset to facilitate
a more robust evaluation and pinpoint enduring issues intrinsic to existing
techniques. Our objective is to provide valuable insights into the
effectiveness and feasibility of each editing technique, thereby assisting the
community in making informed decisions on the selection of the most appropriate
method for a specific task or context. Code and datasets are available at
https://github.com/zjunlp/EasyEdit. | [
-0.0731464028,
-0.9374944568,
0.7859922051,
0.0490231737,
0.1767762154,
0.2766459584,
-0.6274864674,
-0.3651509285,
-0.3638988733,
0.5141127706,
-0.5516031384,
-0.4897146225,
-0.617162466,
0.0781721249,
-0.4206363261,
0.6517026424,
-0.4177182913,
0.1498872787,
-0.2586136162,
-0.1142850593,
-0.6526082754,
-0.5806441903,
-0.7689269781,
-0.1366186738,
0.578170836,
0.3831106722,
0.7347377539,
0.8062859774,
0.7078598142,
0.3223474622,
-0.6897889376,
0.3138252497,
-0.6813909411,
0.26777336,
-0.3436808586,
-0.4120323658,
-0.8547109365,
-0.1323775798,
0.7058918476,
0.9085052013,
-0.2137306482,
0.2461172491,
0.1779158264,
0.6644205451,
-0.5076398253,
0.094924219,
-0.7753658891,
-0.1738803238,
-0.4204530418,
0.1542566419,
-0.2444498837,
0.0045824638,
-0.1524415761,
-0.4178762436,
0.1274081171,
-0.3524949253,
0.5046396255,
0.3626261652,
-0.3170099556,
-0.3315900266,
-0.7997357249,
0.572362721,
-0.7937529087,
0.434779346,
0.0797333121,
0.0463138856,
-0.5186129808,
-0.7128404975,
-0.4250751138,
0.1574154049,
0.1520661712,
-0.4180426896,
-0.3138129115,
0.1671980172,
0.5676465034,
0.3228485286,
-0.2637254298,
0.4752668142,
-0.2275505811,
-0.077854082,
0.6469419003,
0.3479359448,
0.3034219444,
-0.2317740172,
0.2874212563,
0.0861343518,
-0.8944379091,
0.0123342862,
0.368283093,
0.2736513019,
0.1590221524,
0.8220806122,
-0.3406733871,
0.8979538679,
-0.1777048707,
-0.0032841063,
0.0363731086,
-0.219625324,
-0.3410977721,
-0.3824744821,
0.2752717733,
0.3831983805,
0.0716627762,
0.0013513281,
-0.6078775525,
-0.3264110684,
0.1433212608,
-0.5197992921,
0.0211950094,
0.3820341229,
-0.3542089462,
-0.2373407483,
-0.2861278653,
-0.5523979068,
-0.6109554768,
-0.6546807289,
0.3360956311,
-0.1652181596,
-0.167711243,
0.4223262966,
0.0190130547,
-0.0135000711,
0.789808929,
-0.7046067119,
-0.0180810299,
0.9381824136,
0.7423356175,
-0.0637861416,
-0.2081530094,
-0.390432924,
0.1119774729,
-0.3790330589,
0.5475319028,
-0.634867847,
-0.4834206104,
-0.0707678646,
0.1181607395,
0.0114581008,
-0.5595320463,
0.4950979054,
-0.6053897142,
-0.2577724755,
-0.3253653049,
-0.7560203075,
-0.0449785776,
0.328677237,
-0.701372087,
0.9745023847,
-0.0655560941,
-0.3996023834,
-0.0829724371,
-0.7353780866,
-0.2842665613,
-0.3304158449,
0.292316258,
-0.3836448491,
0.4522063136,
0.3454806209,
0.4705554843,
-0.1649572551,
0.378670156,
-0.2088050246,
-0.1043994501,
0.3659944236,
-0.3956897557,
0.776704371,
0.1991078854,
-0.0259697251,
0.3765518367,
-0.8248225451,
-0.1145004556,
0.2687043548,
-0.4261830449,
-0.3066399097,
-0.0196867045,
-0.1220154241,
0.0604111962,
0.3235033751,
-0.4460710585,
0.6861313581,
-0.0909503028,
0.6393970847,
0.9623756409,
0.0143592525,
0.2577142715,
-0.2431427538,
0.6935378909,
-0.3071463108,
0.3813389838,
-0.2513472438,
-0.2354015708,
-0.9326530099,
-0.2315576375,
0.7362638712,
0.5262956619,
-0.627137959,
-0.029014999,
-0.179078728,
-0.7241500616,
-0.7465794683,
0.6428393126,
0.1503200084,
0.3007214069,
0.2349186689,
-0.0356182009,
-0.5558677912,
-0.7633810043,
-0.5288228989,
0.2632485032,
0.1707837433,
0.1555169672,
0.4666899145,
-0.4091342688,
0.9418528676,
-0.5073286295,
-0.0047604777,
-0.2246124595,
-0.0093645286,
0.2544980943,
0.6269023418,
0.2337176502,
-0.6040791273,
-0.3982072771,
-0.1502578706,
-0.6369778514,
-0.303722024,
-0.2500153482,
0.0071236263,
0.0347506218,
0.8407461643,
-0.7936633229,
0.2471003532,
0.4805423617,
0.063285619,
0.489800483,
-0.2722138166,
0.2061507404,
-0.6467346549,
-0.0329347514,
-0.0177383535,
-0.2128708214,
-0.8023117781,
0.4441148341,
0.2997747362,
-0.0794401988,
-0.6621799469,
0.5716953278,
-0.7739179134,
0.0516581684,
-0.2571023405,
0.0442501567,
-0.1594980806,
0.2521064281,
-0.1928936243,
0.6795423627,
0.5059685111,
-0.3336004913,
0.4627153873,
0.2301137149,
-0.5934125185,
0.1837830544,
-0.6202527881,
0.5824335814,
-0.3109352589,
0.0370122418,
-0.7774947882,
-0.1305130869,
0.2650446296,
-0.0535019673,
0.4796706438,
-0.3045268059,
-0.7442287803,
0.0009885699,
-0.2586216629,
0.3697469831,
0.1886713803,
-0.5317688584,
0.3943158984,
0.3933567405,
-0.5737398267,
-0.6646171212,
-0.5313692093,
0.6177839041,
-0.1932894588,
-0.5614184737,
0.357314229,
-0.0988893062,
-0.5609630942,
-0.0384721793,
0.0935341567,
0.1759883761,
0.4086306393,
0.0088956263,
0.1846505404,
0.0621851981,
0.1955301464,
0.1425534934,
-0.123323597,
-0.1508987993,
0.2560876012,
0.2314042002,
0.177208364,
-0.5572775006,
-0.3617447019,
0.2269961238,
0.5461062193,
-0.4349275231,
0.3586622179,
0.0929138064,
-0.5804496408,
-0.3168994486,
-0.6508408189,
0.0876122117,
-0.4825419486,
0.6806048751,
-0.4958426654,
-1.0025037527,
0.5503268242,
-0.4491803646,
0.1817119569,
0.2735325694,
0.4718330503,
0.0375782363,
1.0449656248,
0.7290712595,
0.2199600637,
0.3616470695,
-0.2186356932,
0.1112819016,
-1.0910286903,
-0.0561802723,
-0.5892965198,
-0.3230035305,
-0.4816259742,
-0.892295599,
0.2327919453,
0.1972871572,
0.1109123528,
0.1748453528,
-0.1311868131,
0.5105181336,
0.1364564896,
0.0892521441,
0.5897435546,
-0.312687844,
0.2120849937,
-0.2525321841,
-0.8502727151,
-0.7091140151,
1.1298794746,
0.5588673353,
0.823836565,
0.361202836,
0.3817026019,
0.2862645388,
0.4071534872,
-0.7187684178,
0.6863147616,
-0.2130118161,
-0.6583508253,
-0.4635819793,
-0.2345545292,
-0.7476494312,
0.1853047907,
-0.2287615836,
-0.4731152952,
0.3012527823,
0.2727630436,
-0.2700969279,
0.5752899051,
-0.454892844,
0.9699290991,
-0.366517812,
-0.4756415784,
-0.2026335299,
-0.4359713495,
0.3037280738,
-0.3675196469,
0.5052750111,
-0.138203457,
-0.1869209111,
0.461407721,
-0.4112425447,
0.859402597,
-0.0667230412,
-0.3940551877,
0.1618693918,
0.2081530988,
0.7948635221,
-0.0712238252,
-0.30215469,
0.1957736164,
-0.1608989984,
-0.2772332728,
-0.7273456454,
0.5766168833,
-0.3848031461,
-0.8480393887,
-0.1744749993,
-0.6170575619,
-0.4276631773,
0.1053089648,
-0.346316725,
0.3915100098,
-0.3064650297,
0.1338234693,
0.6118639112,
-0.476352483,
0.4556687176,
0.4049964547,
-0.4639798701,
-0.0605854876,
0.7575705051,
0.2797856033,
0.3420372307,
0.2156457603,
-0.0232124552,
-0.0037745887,
-1.107683897,
-0.4345797896,
0.1597258747,
-0.9847371578,
0.0057165856,
-0.5426313877,
-0.0471906438,
-0.3354018033,
-0.1572249234,
-0.4563272297,
-0.4773037434,
-0.3141624033,
-0.1009916589,
0.2759823203,
0.8918040991,
-0.1623815596,
0.362382859,
-0.7645435333,
0.1678478271,
0.2610381842,
0.3665007949,
0.0972911194,
-0.5094816089,
-0.2747828364,
0.0980121791,
-0.1011182889,
-0.6677932143,
0.2471606433,
0.0478857458,
0.5027022362,
-0.0811393261,
-0.2306607217,
0.9428718686,
-0.6363598704,
0.6573227644,
-0.2831799388,
-1.2630792856,
0.6090875268,
-0.373274982,
0.1857904047,
0.4223083556,
0.2517540455,
-0.9285970926,
-0.3062718213,
-0.2666115761,
-0.8033915162,
0.5164064169,
0.0237585548,
0.2613175213,
0.2419023514,
0.7981886268,
0.1776593775,
0.2747837901,
-0.4603584707,
-0.154715538,
0.3433504105,
-0.047653202,
-0.2063685209,
-0.476947248,
0.1038023606,
-0.4542137682,
0.8278321624,
0.1392518729,
-0.1634426713,
0.0496021099,
-0.5193452835,
-0.1543063968,
0.5175733566,
0.8362873793,
1.1187888384,
-0.2281962633,
-0.1281106174,
0.3603193462,
0.0061391387,
0.1273612082,
-0.1059536189,
-0.1918324083,
-0.0318321027,
0.3818455338,
0.8333795667,
0.2567631304,
-0.8866796494,
0.1898369491,
-0.0414827466,
-0.0399261899,
-0.0758073255,
0.0933937058,
0.2625197768,
0.3027960658,
0.2186379135,
-0.09662579,
-0.040479932,
-0.525709033,
-0.064186886,
0.4112683833,
-0.182276383,
-0.0258885603,
0.5165611506,
0.2682645917,
-0.6578754783,
0.5488407016,
-0.0547693856,
-0.4184367359,
0.4183859229,
0.1215260178,
0.653364718,
-0.1595250964,
-0.1074108481,
0.0848830789,
0.57262218,
-0.1644872725,
-0.0439806841,
0.4648373127,
-0.8152842522,
-0.8411958218,
-0.2895763218,
-0.682747364,
0.3397690058,
-0.4929009676,
0.44142434,
-0.4269671142,
-0.21768336,
0.1246913001,
-0.4045948982,
-0.5630587339,
0.0586332008,
0.0309180506,
0.9678966403,
-0.4887643158,
0.7769180536,
0.8253628612,
-0.0059551322,
-0.5004551411,
-0.2960545123,
0.280972898,
-0.7163717151,
0.4034043252,
-0.2006035447,
0.0141146472,
0.0569815785,
-0.5681592226,
-0.8861654401,
0.816517055,
0.529025197,
-1.0907301903,
-0.1050123572,
0.1891854852,
0.4682622254,
-0.140046224,
-0.157893151,
0.7420489192,
0.5873743892,
-0.2375085205,
-0.9331969023,
0.0138872787,
-0.1089979336,
0.2005434334,
0.1789861172,
-0.5339790583,
0.8346328139,
-0.2122614831,
0.0920120776,
0.2130359709,
0.4583762884,
-0.1376905441,
-0.0175044313,
0.5812026262,
0.5563110113,
0.6941561103,
-0.0172693003,
0.8142898679,
-0.2189615965,
0.5536623001,
1.2498503923,
-0.453345716,
0.7812959552,
0.5886268616,
-0.2081300169,
0.0739624277,
0.8821558952,
-0.0463769436,
0.0899169594,
0.4315676093,
-0.2310369313,
-0.3892445564,
0.1550408751,
-0.165629521,
0.6454026103,
0.4533355236,
-0.0982530266,
-0.2564745545,
0.2112727165,
0.2558032274,
0.1111995056,
-0.4549056292,
0.5620141625,
-0.0832938328,
-0.3813031018,
0.165223226,
0.5760513544,
0.6347624063,
-0.4293497503,
-0.1769568175,
-0.059734799,
0.1301491112,
-0.1300737411,
-0.7255639434,
0.3376104236,
0.3224388063,
-0.0663745701,
-0.6027296185,
0.7735456824,
-0.4349324703,
-0.5330597162,
0.1543444693,
0.7624578476,
-0.0909821391,
-0.1497699767,
-0.9514864087,
0.6043018103,
0.0786038712,
-0.4244621098,
0.3226425946,
0.3806544244,
0.0560239367,
0.7392154336,
0.653780818,
0.4151206613,
-0.1150120869,
-0.0632378682,
0.5718717575,
-0.7959865332,
-0.1300785244,
-0.926733017,
0.7682543993,
-0.0217810608,
-0.2831663489,
0.6574496031,
0.3706092238,
0.9543584585,
-0.1416015476,
0.7995043397,
0.0793876797,
0.5722062588,
-0.7481514812,
0.7063602209,
-0.4984573722,
0.6051489115,
-0.3969273269,
-0.8868739009,
-0.4596368968,
0.4346149266,
-0.3175763786,
-0.0085830996,
0.4536861777,
1.0594270229,
0.0212643538,
-0.1483079344,
0.2722633481,
0.5270172358,
0.4643815458,
0.1720902324,
0.9370552897,
-0.2849805355,
0.2264540642,
-0.5173806548,
-0.0778562501,
-0.1426274329,
-1.1860586405,
-0.5828019381,
-0.3546215296,
-0.6689972281,
-0.0546644181,
0.3139109612,
1.0705339909,
0.3753172159,
-0.6006504297,
-0.391617775,
0.2007251978,
0.4205226302,
-0.2287593782,
-0.1274219453,
0.3662276566,
-0.2422319204,
-0.9625270963,
0.6065303087,
0.2019961178,
0.0407406539,
-0.1524108052,
0.1096473709,
-0.280714035,
0.0428587273,
0.7211540937,
0.2301152498,
-0.5736472011,
-0.4728707373,
-0.1968450695,
-0.0595522225,
-0.0083378898,
0.9412755966,
-0.1869057417,
0.5813977718,
0.2115561962,
1.0264737606,
0.382712543,
-0.1494131386,
0.5657580495,
-0.6041011214,
-0.0792342499,
0.0256643966,
0.4655015171,
0.6270301938,
-0.1910605431,
0.5158247948,
0.2729242444,
-0.4897307158,
-1.2708251476,
-0.0051707113,
-0.9315873384,
-0.4542191327,
1.2541620731,
-0.0540757626,
-0.0818724483,
-0.0397236496,
-0.3865752518,
0.2612372339,
0.1532030851,
0.5699376464,
1.105936408,
-0.1671156734,
-0.2628048956,
-0.879534781,
0.3754315078,
0.4502561688,
-0.7747443318,
0.5270223022,
0.7549223304,
0.5097696781,
-0.3360930085,
0.3360582888,
-0.0665911213,
0.1637125313,
-0.4132203758,
0.2394016087,
-0.2332641631,
-0.2336902469,
-0.8603546619,
0.136533007,
0.4163028598,
0.3341487348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13169v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13169v2 | A Pretrainer's Guide to Training Data: Measuring the Effects of Data Age, Domain Coverage, Quality, & Toxicity | 2023-05-22T15:57:53 | 2023-11-13T14:50:06 | Shayne Longpre, Gregory Yauney, Emily Reif, Katherine Lee, Adam Roberts, Barret Zoph, Denny Zhou, Jason Wei, Kevin Robinson, David Mimno, Daphne Ippolito | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pretraining is the preliminary and fundamental step in developing capable
language models (LM). Despite this, pretraining data design is critically
under-documented and often guided by empirically unsupported intuitions. To
address this, we pretrain 28 1.5B parameter decoder-only models, training on
data curated (1) at different times, (2) with varying toxicity and quality
filters, and (3) with different domain compositions. First, we quantify the
effect of pretraining data age. A temporal shift between evaluation data and
pretraining data leads to performance degradation, which is not overcome by
finetuning. Second, we explore the effect of quality and toxicity filters,
showing a trade-off between performance on standard benchmarks and risk of
toxic generations. Our findings indicate there does not exist a
one-size-fits-all solution to filtering training data. We also find that the
effects of different types of filtering are not predictable from text domain
characteristics. Lastly, we empirically validate that the inclusion of
heterogeneous data sources, like books and web, is broadly beneficial and
warrants greater prioritization. These findings constitute the largest set of
experiments to validate, quantify, and expose many undocumented intuitions
about text pretraining, which we hope will help support more informed
data-centric decisions in LM development. | [
-0.4605251551,
-0.5300353765,
0.5062559247,
0.1750209033,
-0.3618275821,
-0.1968814433,
-0.0747227594,
-0.2970322967,
-0.302410692,
0.630060792,
-0.6787629724,
-0.5998428464,
-0.607468605,
-0.1314823627,
-0.3402785659,
1.1838995218,
-0.0776802748,
0.1571280211,
-0.348936379,
0.0291629806,
-0.2977585495,
-0.7774628997,
-0.5094194412,
-0.468708545,
0.7924531698,
0.242713511,
0.5982567668,
0.5882291794,
0.3042961359,
0.1749997586,
-0.166062817,
-0.2398018241,
-0.736761868,
-0.0488359667,
-0.1428467929,
-0.5616494417,
-0.4767264724,
0.3963227272,
0.452460885,
0.8846210837,
-0.0546880886,
-0.0549708903,
0.0750795752,
0.8017340899,
-0.8586143255,
-0.0983029976,
-0.4782689214,
0.1460358649,
-0.4079523385,
-0.449554354,
-0.4883803725,
-0.3649993241,
0.1205101982,
-0.7241750956,
0.1131938919,
0.0570745058,
0.862913847,
0.423745513,
-0.4978373647,
-0.1566850841,
-0.7781784534,
0.9281546474,
-0.7270778418,
0.6055040956,
1.0059144497,
0.2182594091,
0.0270168148,
-0.934148252,
-0.319807291,
-0.111231029,
-0.143332541,
0.0136661641,
0.1739048362,
0.1753174961,
0.2509638667,
0.4743668139,
-0.6767559052,
0.1918693185,
-0.43584764,
-0.3262769282,
0.5513210297,
0.1210308149,
0.3709687293,
0.3549468517,
-0.2431221157,
-0.1242628694,
-1.0060067177,
-0.1227417216,
0.6546690464,
0.1585121304,
0.1652652174,
0.2775575221,
-0.2769870758,
0.6473221779,
-0.298633188,
0.1371748,
0.2577358782,
-0.5999270082,
-0.1015076861,
-0.1399721652,
0.8220847845,
0.1051752269,
0.6139609218,
-0.3580271304,
-0.1340573877,
-0.1396743059,
0.6160077453,
-1.1112071276,
-0.5392896533,
0.1582134813,
-0.5374468565,
-0.2652660906,
-0.2401364744,
-0.66875875,
-0.2519096434,
-0.4546748102,
0.4853401184,
-0.4001680017,
-0.2460930645,
0.3819915056,
0.1073903292,
0.0354798809,
-0.0551369824,
-0.8380105495,
0.2909174562,
0.1694090068,
0.3389187455,
-0.1658053845,
-0.3947968185,
-0.1933637857,
-0.1983306855,
-0.2516187727,
0.8158653975,
-0.5361151695,
-0.4313875437,
0.1308849305,
-0.0546777286,
-0.0764213055,
-0.5137264132,
0.6386191845,
-0.8021720052,
0.3371657133,
-0.1774945706,
-0.6175543666,
0.1123250872,
-0.1050385609,
-0.7874796987,
0.8887810111,
0.1496736109,
-0.9055668116,
0.737488687,
-0.407631427,
-0.5732560754,
-0.0778507739,
0.0987669453,
-0.546243012,
-0.1641874611,
0.1375984997,
0.2068144381,
-0.1735453159,
0.2416708618,
-0.3510054946,
-0.3979345262,
0.1059785932,
-0.4499830604,
0.8195801973,
0.4498671889,
-0.034605246,
0.0782095864,
-0.8852984309,
0.3788324296,
0.0122887623,
-0.4693150222,
-0.3815589249,
0.2273166031,
0.1583085209,
0.2178794146,
-0.0286004115,
-0.2689187825,
-0.1435182542,
-0.1798082143,
0.2635415196,
0.4757525623,
0.01343254,
0.4895436466,
-0.3753961623,
0.5567765832,
0.211979568,
0.4020278156,
-0.2013807148,
-0.10634882,
-0.6206255555,
0.2322798073,
0.4279134572,
0.2741400301,
-0.7312232256,
0.5634272099,
-0.1666101068,
-0.591776073,
-0.3214171231,
0.2176673412,
0.5350057483,
0.1456718743,
0.6051347256,
-0.5217556357,
-0.5835167766,
-0.61920017,
-0.4730477631,
-0.191384688,
0.0503937192,
0.0580350794,
0.3178958297,
-0.4027975202,
0.9162904024,
-0.4223772287,
-0.2199356258,
-0.1651747376,
0.0473346338,
-0.0487653464,
0.5848195553,
0.626275897,
-0.5998958945,
-0.2887423635,
-0.348182261,
-0.5232976675,
-0.2783287168,
0.0986833051,
-0.3571107686,
-0.1769299209,
0.6761098504,
-0.2130144089,
0.3393749893,
0.5149422288,
-0.2673122883,
0.6117762923,
-0.1710220724,
-0.1122212335,
-0.5899867415,
0.1383160651,
0.0392265059,
-0.1171753556,
-0.8642510176,
-0.2363724858,
0.0994181931,
0.0473453552,
-0.5163224936,
0.5338758826,
-0.286493361,
0.430523932,
-0.2502067685,
-0.2014284134,
0.1489459574,
0.3070791662,
0.0731089041,
0.7910493612,
0.4382903278,
-0.9059717059,
-0.1292298436,
0.1817287505,
-0.5194867849,
0.3286117017,
-0.6595181227,
0.2567495704,
-0.1969299763,
0.2383421361,
-0.599444747,
0.2047306746,
0.2511336803,
-0.4237725437,
0.4197991192,
-0.1611198783,
-0.3337599933,
-0.2089576572,
0.0101740668,
0.5453768969,
0.4024513364,
-0.2731885016,
0.2975271642,
0.3862398863,
-0.1533206999,
-0.6573963761,
-0.6314940453,
-0.3686028421,
-0.3321028948,
-0.1898921728,
0.2521211207,
-0.375927031,
0.0578477122,
0.0404110141,
-0.3454522491,
-0.4972591996,
0.2465348542,
0.0993261337,
-0.0158295073,
-0.3105427623,
0.0329095945,
0.0060497574,
-0.3087618053,
0.4133655131,
-0.3563560545,
0.4447925091,
0.2188874781,
-0.1818442941,
-0.1009399593,
0.1246007606,
0.2800010741,
-0.4031072855,
0.9169584513,
0.5025525689,
-0.2601710856,
-0.3751928806,
-0.2313252985,
-0.188024193,
-0.481993258,
0.3946602643,
-0.3078739643,
-0.6071659327,
0.3522982895,
-0.0793743432,
-0.1462604553,
0.3114160001,
0.2994636595,
-0.1535207778,
0.8623069525,
0.632594645,
-0.0641794503,
0.7972410917,
-0.3313666284,
0.1963519156,
-0.5294377208,
-0.201620698,
-0.6365912557,
0.0634907484,
-0.3791913092,
0.0777241513,
-0.0199589226,
0.2100931406,
-0.6057927012,
0.0991733447,
-0.1367133409,
0.7118823528,
0.421304673,
0.3056927919,
0.1702302098,
-0.0496277511,
-0.0950981081,
-0.0832796991,
-0.7549645305,
-0.6087989807,
1.3293504715,
0.4542143941,
1.088706851,
-0.2497750372,
0.512421906,
0.0980428234,
0.5074527264,
-0.5257724524,
0.2908976674,
-0.35066396,
-1.0573788881,
-0.3242163062,
-0.5773098469,
-0.9974968433,
0.0668890029,
-0.1316640228,
-0.2907563746,
0.1673807651,
0.2120713592,
-0.2599615753,
0.0965106338,
-0.8785113692,
1.1397893429,
-0.4980604053,
-0.4440487325,
-0.0444513783,
-0.7409009337,
0.1168180779,
-0.4058087766,
0.2651354671,
-0.1279012114,
0.4039461613,
0.8662435412,
-0.3345790207,
0.8211216331,
-0.3937183022,
-0.0166663248,
0.3031662405,
-0.0957809612,
0.0541559942,
-0.2041393667,
-0.0792290345,
0.0001782574,
0.3706703186,
-0.5588680506,
-0.3549514711,
0.3694451749,
-1.0144847631,
-0.3031717241,
-0.2897341251,
-0.3289943933,
-0.5105614662,
0.5275924206,
0.4852257073,
0.4031079412,
-0.3072802126,
0.4250452518,
0.8385704756,
-0.4346193671,
0.0482677333,
0.6845011115,
-0.1360338032,
-0.0290147047,
0.955401361,
0.1698556691,
0.48491925,
0.3233763874,
0.1954259872,
-0.4426783323,
-0.9240078926,
-0.1601783484,
0.042049095,
-0.918846786,
0.0174000617,
-0.4717018604,
-0.4206184745,
-0.1836336404,
0.3564409018,
-0.3642070293,
0.0460004546,
-0.4098282456,
-0.1359617412,
0.1588302702,
0.5927564502,
0.1189308763,
0.766511023,
-0.699429512,
0.1495080143,
0.1983100027,
0.7786051631,
-0.1982236356,
-0.4679039121,
-0.5958842635,
0.2438524812,
-0.2246551961,
-0.7265863419,
0.1320120245,
0.337910831,
0.9012624025,
0.3820236325,
0.1352487057,
0.3277361095,
-0.5155194402,
0.689403832,
-0.1153357923,
-0.7084603906,
0.5488023758,
-0.302529633,
0.0475787222,
0.9235655069,
0.7329238653,
-0.3154455423,
-0.1493448764,
-0.4337249398,
-0.8797772527,
0.7892873287,
0.1069044471,
0.276535809,
0.2552422285,
0.4188389778,
0.2157494873,
0.1252904832,
-0.6884263754,
-0.5148423314,
-0.6021565795,
-0.2241883427,
-0.443585813,
-0.424223721,
0.0617918149,
-0.2750967145,
0.7165822983,
0.160263598,
-0.0401516892,
-0.1490905881,
-0.5122520924,
-0.0313986801,
0.2600067854,
0.2968851924,
0.7851675153,
-0.3450403512,
0.2135630101,
-0.1114340276,
-0.770601213,
0.30813995,
0.1345870942,
-0.0302308984,
-0.2040796876,
0.3713669479,
0.9549654722,
0.0584107041,
-0.4770332277,
0.4575468004,
-0.1107522622,
-0.1006084234,
-0.0671726018,
0.3226473927,
-0.1495363265,
-0.3155795336,
0.2138605416,
-0.103051506,
-0.0272007044,
-0.4145962,
0.4085964262,
0.0020480263,
-0.437641263,
-0.3453525603,
0.7823522091,
0.2376863509,
0.013909095,
0.6042686701,
-0.0175938103,
-0.3636419475,
0.4071983099,
0.4229349792,
0.5373513699,
-0.423358202,
0.1301289648,
0.2598847151,
0.4098659158,
-0.0993582308,
0.1013693884,
0.0694778562,
-0.9160326719,
-0.4740082026,
-0.6718162298,
-0.1336567551,
0.4991348088,
-0.7309750319,
0.1228371412,
-0.1369005591,
-0.3228121996,
0.0199049041,
0.1729987711,
-1.0479872227,
0.8063917756,
-0.0927103758,
0.9343106747,
-1.1594777107,
0.9547083974,
0.720990479,
-0.6084296703,
-0.731906414,
0.0977301523,
-0.3266146183,
-0.7114797235,
0.6198498607,
-0.0575757176,
0.0994089171,
0.3160681129,
-0.4790992439,
-0.6477099657,
0.6838867664,
0.185184285,
-0.3884547353,
-0.1512418985,
0.3045910299,
0.6108843088,
-0.096109271,
0.3934523761,
0.7693639994,
0.4331109524,
-0.1334522218,
-0.6709324121,
-0.2414377034,
-0.4379678071,
-0.0494198725,
-0.0070962813,
-0.1677357256,
0.6920232773,
0.0332483016,
-0.281945765,
-0.1067701355,
0.1735345572,
0.010825472,
0.4210007489,
0.5114619732,
0.5508382916,
0.3855631649,
-0.1190071255,
1.2124021053,
-0.2912505269,
0.1706832498,
1.0550740957,
-0.0992837176,
0.4986394644,
0.3499872088,
-0.4391997159,
0.3298406005,
1.0188155174,
0.3775663972,
0.906124413,
0.3908447027,
-0.0456393808,
-0.2562740147,
0.013904294,
-0.6113661528,
0.0257415548,
0.2879380286,
-0.4095056653,
-0.1688295901,
0.08996889,
-0.0089166313,
-0.0994235575,
-0.132806778,
0.7162047029,
0.2516436577,
-0.4442234337,
0.6094535589,
-0.2419110239,
0.4354692698,
-0.7580584884,
0.419716984,
-0.396805793,
0.2606318891,
-0.2158014029,
-0.7933004498,
0.2530822456,
-0.1664778739,
-0.20703125,
-0.4598158598,
0.7796049118,
-0.4865063727,
-0.0777751505,
0.3026356995,
0.77154845,
0.2874090672,
-0.3124024272,
-0.423314929,
0.1816344112,
-0.1854810268,
-0.5598059893,
0.3962751925,
0.5823017955,
0.037818253,
0.6236934066,
0.663036406,
0.2417458594,
0.1784727871,
0.3817945719,
0.9569307566,
-0.5145817399,
-0.3730827272,
-0.6325547695,
0.558978498,
0.2957481146,
-0.3125710487,
0.5104664564,
0.4789271355,
1.0664345026,
-0.0186893772,
0.8236021399,
0.3419341445,
0.2859238982,
-0.7100572586,
1.1064114571,
-0.4586872458,
0.2438751906,
-0.0142930085,
-1.0480294228,
-0.2205887139,
0.6305847168,
-0.4895142317,
0.5243657827,
0.8148401976,
0.5816145539,
-0.0004217939,
0.0839501768,
0.1299238354,
0.1373144984,
0.398584187,
0.43677333,
0.9930990934,
-0.4655278921,
0.5542008281,
-0.1965318322,
-0.0190645624,
-0.043375615,
-0.8980165124,
-0.987848103,
-0.673692584,
-0.1538322866,
-0.2433257997,
0.2251058072,
0.4180395603,
1.0009458065,
-0.7260397077,
0.0960902497,
-0.2570105493,
-0.0637391284,
0.0765040889,
-0.1234701574,
0.161538735,
-0.5414666533,
-0.3743538558,
0.2559396327,
-0.4511299133,
0.2342832536,
-0.2966200411,
-0.2716498077,
0.1053504571,
0.0130531248,
0.5689457059,
0.2487467378,
-0.2152279168,
-0.1371166259,
-0.0156701561,
-0.1825690269,
-0.0610920712,
1.0271805525,
-0.7844154835,
0.4950913787,
0.3468659222,
0.5771775246,
0.5013379455,
-0.1612024605,
0.5449106097,
-0.7884773016,
0.1252607554,
0.2914432585,
0.1509290487,
0.2106115222,
-0.1541043669,
0.4208023846,
0.0631640553,
-0.681812048,
-0.8752877116,
0.1202234626,
-0.4140619636,
-0.3050444424,
1.0915257931,
-0.2060296088,
0.096268557,
-0.3272444904,
-0.095417805,
0.3554928303,
0.0513645969,
0.6538531184,
0.9523619413,
0.2318221033,
-0.1408405006,
-0.7809140682,
0.8792161345,
0.4536575377,
-0.9820030928,
0.0383459069,
0.3771172166,
0.4684851468,
-0.1380975395,
0.8847665787,
-0.2134022564,
-0.0224708542,
0.0223470014,
-0.0799121708,
-0.0773754194,
-0.532982409,
-0.136182338,
-0.2583267987,
0.2249869704,
-0.048123274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13168v2 | LLMs for Knowledge Graph Construction and Reasoning: Recent Capabilities and Future Opportunities | 2023-05-22T15:56:44 | 2024-02-22T10:15:25 | Yuqi Zhu, Xiaohan Wang, Jing Chen, Shuofei Qiao, Yixin Ou, Yunzhi Yao, Shumin Deng, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR, cs.LG | This paper presents an exhaustive quantitative and qualitative evaluation of
Large Language Models (LLMs) for Knowledge Graph (KG) construction and
reasoning. We engage in experiments across eight diverse datasets, focusing on
four representative tasks encompassing entity and relation extraction, event
extraction, link prediction, and question-answering, thereby thoroughly
exploring LLMs' performance in the domain of construction and inference.
Empirically, our findings suggest that LLMs, represented by GPT-4, are more
suited as inference assistants rather than few-shot information extractors.
Specifically, while GPT-4 exhibits good performance in tasks related to KG
construction, it excels further in reasoning tasks, surpassing fine-tuned
models in certain cases. Moreover, our investigation extends to the potential
generalization ability of LLMs for information extraction, leading to the
proposition of a Virtual Knowledge Extraction task and the development of the
corresponding VINE dataset. Based on these empirical findings, we further
propose AutoKG, a multi-agent-based approach employing LLMs and external
sources for KG construction and reasoning. We anticipate that this research can
provide invaluable insights for future undertakings in the field of knowledge
graphs. The code and datasets are in https://github.com/zjunlp/AutoKG. | [
-0.4327102602,
-0.8712233901,
0.798238337,
-0.2635017633,
-0.1165902168,
0.2092421204,
-0.0331021771,
-0.5559278131,
0.0444030501,
0.4545056522,
-0.2025014162,
-0.6574845314,
-0.6790536642,
0.1972075105,
-0.2751742303,
0.538900733,
-0.2281266302,
-0.173367098,
-0.4958393276,
0.0409138948,
-0.4557109773,
-0.4569151402,
-0.6261447072,
-0.4078568518,
0.580947578,
0.1877536774,
0.7427553535,
0.9149705768,
0.2057010233,
0.4141409099,
0.1494665146,
0.4868652523,
-0.2515142858,
0.3014526367,
-0.1279834509,
-0.3280626237,
-0.5506384969,
0.2135741562,
0.6668535471,
0.4545776248,
0.1876534075,
0.1417682916,
-0.0833560973,
0.352815032,
-0.3266324103,
0.6916990876,
-0.6779224873,
-0.0071441825,
0.0098683629,
-0.0942313001,
-0.2204355299,
-0.3213112056,
0.1442848891,
-0.6395763755,
-0.0378944874,
0.3068464696,
0.7663575411,
0.2943283021,
-0.7504496574,
-0.5200753808,
-0.4467650652,
0.4706442654,
-0.7251966596,
0.6486085653,
0.2575835288,
0.489861995,
-0.4686163068,
-1.1555452347,
-0.5285733342,
-0.3086094856,
-0.0711229742,
0.1108546853,
-0.0887533873,
0.1480777562,
0.2918272018,
0.2213303596,
-0.4122070968,
0.1342557073,
-0.1678261459,
-0.3724429011,
0.6047331095,
0.2363213301,
0.2725153863,
-0.4406475723,
-0.23138991,
0.2138006687,
-0.7975561023,
-0.2421892285,
0.496907562,
0.0505950972,
0.2224357575,
0.8032874465,
-0.3791434467,
0.8589023948,
-0.3054946363,
-0.2851576805,
0.0767911747,
-0.4755929112,
-0.239123404,
-0.209470883,
1.0565985441,
0.1857471466,
0.4676636457,
-0.5773133636,
0.0450624488,
0.0330749266,
0.1026351005,
-0.6292340159,
-0.6195206046,
0.0282696504,
-0.3747817874,
-0.1791388839,
-0.2394076884,
-0.491410017,
-0.2891865075,
-0.4525299072,
0.1838552654,
-0.4644679725,
-0.3202971816,
-0.1012389809,
-0.2477585822,
0.2777566314,
0.4066874385,
-0.3294107318,
0.1427327394,
0.391109854,
0.6274682879,
-0.3223646581,
-0.2134958953,
-0.3512705863,
0.5017759204,
-0.3426564634,
0.8648419976,
-0.4669854045,
-0.2535814941,
-0.2364637554,
0.0203646738,
-0.078988418,
-0.4161061943,
0.3758207858,
-0.8434969783,
0.0417279899,
-0.4029958248,
-0.8855470419,
-0.2783434093,
0.5796582103,
-0.7437623739,
0.8573415875,
0.1742111146,
-0.676427424,
0.3139156699,
-0.5542041063,
-0.4662972391,
0.212015301,
-0.5332667828,
-0.272195816,
-0.4175874889,
0.2601207495,
0.6578062773,
-0.5123185515,
0.2074726522,
-0.5849336386,
0.1678464115,
0.13743788,
-0.2057230473,
0.6058175564,
0.4708781242,
-0.1326250136,
-0.1723036468,
-0.6212991476,
0.1503006667,
0.3515330553,
-0.365454942,
-0.0539364181,
0.2576120198,
-0.7546397448,
0.2582763731,
0.3408896029,
-0.4076344669,
0.4060228467,
-0.1586651951,
0.4649436772,
0.6230461001,
0.1346494257,
0.4463815391,
0.005108512,
0.7100478411,
-0.0822122395,
0.0863509923,
0.123828508,
-0.698163867,
-0.4463886917,
-0.2217062861,
0.3677907884,
0.4526107609,
-1.193426609,
0.1678097993,
-0.3131177425,
-0.417958796,
-0.1090933084,
0.3868486881,
0.2709805369,
0.671408236,
0.0882769004,
-0.0866241753,
-0.4222534299,
-0.7049548626,
-0.2041924596,
-0.3992264271,
0.1832275838,
0.3745833635,
0.3975753486,
-0.1925993264,
1.30600214,
-0.7192500234,
0.0894654542,
-0.3711933792,
-0.0085201636,
0.0641045794,
-0.0109114088,
0.5952242017,
-0.7651382685,
-0.5189464092,
0.123195678,
-1.0936151743,
-0.1377600282,
0.3624580801,
-0.1654174775,
-0.1027213335,
0.5904210806,
-0.8965179324,
0.0967364088,
0.3338436186,
-0.2505335212,
0.6892794967,
0.0678968579,
0.0759686977,
-1.0750442743,
-0.2359506041,
-0.0677976012,
-0.4513159692,
-0.6109099984,
-0.1451994926,
-0.111330457,
0.198849678,
-0.1926029027,
0.7071706057,
-0.7173030376,
-0.4042483568,
-0.2989092171,
0.3492723107,
-0.0327815972,
0.4433933198,
-0.1643879414,
0.6071335077,
0.4005433023,
-0.6111952066,
0.8713784814,
0.1796806753,
-0.346424669,
0.1395964324,
-0.4240693748,
0.276309967,
0.0318420827,
0.299091965,
-0.9882332087,
-0.4226737618,
0.5139203668,
-0.6048292518,
0.2961878181,
-0.4080197811,
-0.9425413609,
-0.6024454832,
0.0529706068,
0.1765624881,
0.4778946638,
-0.3689616919,
0.821129024,
0.6605163813,
-0.2367418408,
-0.3775582016,
-0.325081408,
0.1481125504,
-0.3439388871,
-0.7284848094,
0.0545544773,
0.0847427696,
-0.319585979,
0.3113443255,
-0.1219465137,
-0.1471667439,
0.0712348968,
0.1209237948,
0.1056832299,
-0.0941750258,
0.3291137516,
-0.1026784778,
-0.0862689614,
0.2374513298,
-0.5348175168,
0.2952782214,
-0.1048234776,
-0.4703094363,
0.144861877,
-0.2091770321,
0.3360788822,
-0.2367767692,
0.4989783764,
0.6682847738,
-0.1453228146,
-0.2594583631,
-0.6866217852,
-0.0223005041,
-0.4596756101,
0.3785068989,
-0.5094031692,
-1.0748294592,
0.5397047997,
-0.4866721034,
-0.0748735145,
0.6116829515,
0.5781710744,
-0.0324004553,
0.8751136065,
0.2258932739,
-0.2353184521,
0.1715600938,
-0.3019822538,
0.2420788556,
-0.6924235821,
-0.3078140914,
-0.332195133,
0.0592365079,
-0.5834007263,
-0.4561088979,
0.3465486467,
0.1744227856,
0.0013139793,
0.2465521693,
-0.3129215539,
0.2905864418,
0.3797493875,
-0.0822793096,
0.4787362814,
-0.0619165078,
-0.2215525061,
0.3728540242,
-1.0495153666,
-0.533436358,
1.1545727253,
0.2231912315,
0.5298838019,
0.0097018993,
0.4446077943,
0.3555075824,
0.5117609501,
-0.7355797887,
0.7205367088,
0.0586511679,
-0.5350467563,
-0.6036198139,
-0.734602809,
-0.9722160101,
0.2772912085,
0.0886969864,
-0.5944516063,
-0.2578383684,
0.2243039757,
-0.0619881339,
0.4367597997,
-0.8362772465,
0.7119172812,
-0.3143208325,
-0.2240312248,
0.1202626452,
-0.6457543969,
0.3940654099,
-0.0838419646,
0.3901589811,
-0.2675533593,
-0.0125529207,
0.6252886653,
-0.392154783,
0.8481547236,
-0.2396639585,
-0.2645247579,
0.8486194611,
-0.0376639552,
0.920363307,
-0.0805935711,
-0.1069479585,
0.1282865852,
-0.138702184,
-0.1401476711,
-0.7527035475,
0.5498332381,
-0.7321684957,
-0.5862563848,
-0.0023772819,
-0.6912373304,
-0.375338614,
0.290186286,
-0.0044713421,
0.4486214519,
0.02648082,
0.0488346554,
0.4550419748,
-0.2421533614,
0.2174880505,
0.4582301974,
-0.2642638385,
-0.5747872591,
0.8893988132,
0.3821112216,
0.2786997259,
0.2702066302,
0.1631168276,
-0.5209318995,
-0.7291661501,
-0.3713136017,
0.2775507271,
-1.0084648132,
-0.2652498186,
-0.81138134,
-0.3434106708,
-0.6513316631,
0.1803076118,
-0.1801868528,
-0.4048048556,
-0.0095270034,
-0.2678390145,
0.4908857942,
1.0722123384,
0.0325835645,
0.1768960357,
-0.6951025724,
0.3659242392,
0.4293884933,
0.2288606763,
-0.0517819114,
-0.1377475262,
-0.3723305166,
-0.1844519824,
-0.1933786422,
-0.9850926995,
0.2742243409,
-0.1502082944,
0.9793609381,
0.1885463595,
-0.0787793249,
0.4386875331,
-0.4198644459,
0.7042092681,
0.0035132871,
-0.4947173893,
0.1805498153,
-0.5665370822,
0.1797723174,
0.1658263206,
0.4137445986,
-0.1727873385,
-0.4174218774,
-0.6046752334,
-0.7023215294,
0.4979309738,
0.3548590839,
-0.358142525,
-0.1466045082,
0.6299791336,
-0.0399439186,
0.323926419,
-0.7552405,
-0.2988818288,
-0.0857910961,
-0.2196679413,
0.0316916332,
-0.3609972596,
0.0464270897,
-0.2534608245,
0.5638110638,
-0.2785740793,
0.3545210361,
0.0465348959,
-0.1798825413,
0.2061887383,
0.1197402924,
-0.02062889,
0.6597446799,
0.0822343901,
0.3347223997,
0.3922996819,
-0.1729771793,
0.1539181769,
0.3164259791,
0.0686702356,
-0.2202180922,
0.5375660658,
0.6136892438,
-0.0388611145,
-0.3484294116,
0.3458752334,
0.1664661318,
-0.4007795751,
-0.3142825067,
0.119993113,
0.424675107,
0.600486815,
0.0903723091,
-0.6193534732,
0.0692378953,
-0.4192967117,
0.0823522359,
0.6038351655,
-0.0965751186,
-0.2471985519,
0.5853101611,
0.0863907337,
0.0452262983,
0.6880341768,
-0.5504330397,
-0.6037709713,
0.7947484255,
0.3246357739,
0.6555765867,
-0.101080589,
0.1493918598,
0.1727695614,
0.3714307845,
0.11315009,
0.1547509879,
-0.1619898081,
-1.0392913818,
-0.8121873736,
-0.4736970961,
-0.3028006554,
0.050236132,
-0.0086541632,
-0.0202793367,
0.0685278699,
-0.2322912514,
-0.1055043489,
0.1506779492,
-0.7353588343,
0.2195278406,
-0.0521143861,
0.6753192544,
-0.631034255,
1.0013611317,
0.8565479517,
-0.3733534217,
-0.9650134444,
-0.3350462615,
0.0198855735,
-0.8168661594,
0.7543631196,
-0.1738161147,
-0.1293214262,
0.2281470895,
-0.6494864821,
-1.0785411596,
1.5179848671,
0.4043461978,
-0.276342988,
-0.2317615598,
0.4199354649,
0.3580079675,
-0.3001275659,
0.1551818103,
0.4283053279,
0.655305028,
0.3210850656,
-0.6944987178,
0.0823300779,
0.0122800265,
-0.2926874459,
0.3213844299,
-0.6485749483,
0.6191056371,
0.0506601632,
-0.1368897855,
-0.1021073461,
0.6928753257,
0.2285389453,
0.1611544043,
0.5572444201,
0.5771192312,
0.7802820206,
-0.0320386402,
1.1396770477,
-0.4781799316,
0.1072574481,
1.1167778969,
-0.2214334756,
0.1769466251,
0.1605646461,
-0.3020480871,
0.3666802347,
0.6326777935,
-0.0159222167,
0.3403229415,
0.202235803,
-0.1311628222,
-0.3637570143,
0.0154149719,
-0.2017787844,
0.4188884795,
0.4506407976,
-0.44660604,
-0.348580569,
-0.3245966434,
0.0925942138,
-0.5005210638,
-0.2164652646,
0.7241070271,
0.3666092157,
-0.6361231208,
0.0085036755,
-0.0998558179,
0.036723163,
-0.6675793529,
-0.1144976243,
0.0489013456,
-0.0920934156,
-0.0572023802,
-0.8826023936,
0.1731926799,
-0.0961049497,
0.1143620536,
-0.2854848504,
1.2795755863,
-0.2695612907,
-0.1866212487,
0.3933354318,
0.9130270481,
0.3302020431,
-0.0112697585,
-0.5891391635,
-0.2705655992,
0.017360393,
-0.56411165,
0.2911305428,
0.8891892433,
-0.0650556982,
0.7921803594,
0.5281376243,
0.1154197529,
0.1742618531,
0.0570897162,
0.9633252025,
-0.6013088226,
-0.2156198621,
-0.8976854682,
0.3302676678,
-0.1739131361,
0.109865509,
1.1261630058,
0.5643681884,
0.5874749422,
0.254329443,
1.108979702,
-0.1609059125,
0.3521083593,
-0.6569167376,
0.5085988045,
-0.3179287612,
0.0807684734,
-0.3049183786,
-0.8041210771,
-0.0331180505,
0.2103070617,
-0.5833896995,
0.2334664017,
0.6495900154,
0.5910031199,
0.059198156,
-0.0535703562,
0.3727207184,
0.328828454,
0.5330218673,
0.3110873997,
0.9912611246,
0.0093972152,
0.8398302197,
0.0052312938,
-0.044561632,
0.1376777589,
-1.0867956877,
-0.9417126179,
-0.4806068242,
-0.2075628191,
-0.1899484098,
-0.0185458474,
0.5945490599,
0.5117865205,
-0.2669919729,
-0.0774723515,
-0.2475508004,
0.3612599969,
0.259215802,
-0.194243893,
0.4174298942,
-0.3933396339,
-0.3638644516,
0.4825130999,
0.2487545162,
-0.0275250301,
-0.2255922556,
-0.3030658066,
-0.173214227,
-0.2120669633,
0.8132123351,
0.2009366155,
-0.6145173311,
-0.3223505318,
-0.0933915004,
0.1199468523,
0.0006183927,
0.6161036491,
-0.7376201153,
0.5154198408,
0.5396637321,
0.726934731,
0.8023585081,
-0.0155096548,
0.7719765306,
-0.5675051212,
-0.3315628767,
-0.1422268152,
0.4973790646,
0.25777632,
-0.2299675643,
0.8283536434,
0.4089192748,
-0.6989989281,
-0.4282153547,
0.4203855097,
-0.5941841602,
-0.3604179621,
1.5615929365,
-0.1644291133,
-0.1171887144,
-0.4260868132,
0.006153137,
0.6508389711,
-0.1504878253,
0.4732063115,
0.9107943177,
-0.4023053646,
-0.162900269,
-0.9171571136,
0.4186699986,
-0.1532096863,
-1.1190989017,
-0.1877703071,
0.7413914204,
0.4174809158,
-0.0349305868,
0.7861651778,
-0.075171113,
-0.1557121575,
0.004251,
0.0402596258,
-0.3977113664,
-0.2581172287,
0.2882103026,
0.355969578,
0.2440867275,
0.0177251473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13160v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13160v2 | Can ChatGPT Defend its Belief in Truth? Evaluating LLM Reasoning via Debate | 2023-05-22T15:47:31 | 2023-10-10T17:34:15 | Boshi Wang, Xiang Yue, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 have shown impressive
performance in complex reasoning tasks. However, it is difficult to know
whether the models are reasoning based on deep understandings of truth and
logic, or leveraging their memorized patterns in a relatively superficial way.
In this work, we explore testing LLMs' reasoning by engaging with them in a
debate-like conversation, where given a question, the LLM and the user need to
discuss to make the correct decision starting from opposing arguments. Upon
mitigating the Clever Hans effect, our task requires the LLM to not only
achieve the correct answer on its own, but also be able to hold and defend its
belief instead of blindly believing or getting misled by the user's (invalid)
arguments and critiques, thus testing in greater depth whether the LLM grasps
the essence of the reasoning required to solve the problem. Across a range of
complex reasoning benchmarks spanning math, commonsense, logic and BIG-Bench
tasks, we find that despite their impressive performance as reported in
existing work on generating correct step-by-step solutions in the beginning,
LLMs like ChatGPT cannot maintain their beliefs in truth for a significant
portion of examples when challenged by oftentimes absurdly invalid arguments.
Our work points to danger zones of model alignment, and also suggests more
careful treatments and interpretations of the recent findings that LLMs can
improve their responses based on feedback. | [
-0.4102492034,
-1.081099987,
0.8504424095,
-0.0113352519,
-0.2849901915,
0.2463181168,
-0.3112847209,
-0.3089672327,
-0.1538576186,
0.466185838,
-0.4498614669,
-0.2128464133,
-0.6280616522,
0.0019276291,
-0.1551053822,
0.8337741494,
-0.134510681,
0.0428763665,
-0.226313144,
-0.0560678355,
-0.5284309983,
-0.6528255939,
-0.4875695109,
-0.5091554523,
0.4534043372,
0.426520884,
0.8610675931,
0.2595683634,
0.6166830063,
0.3091400564,
-0.1631326228,
0.1407262385,
-0.643266201,
0.3558116555,
-0.2346238643,
-0.9064415693,
-0.3406330049,
0.10509637,
0.4863764942,
0.4246616662,
-0.3467705548,
-0.1683297157,
0.0989477709,
0.4600248933,
-0.2041632831,
0.1022893637,
-1.1714287996,
0.0598696694,
-0.2951057255,
-0.2445472777,
-0.5000930429,
-0.5032812953,
0.1820619851,
-0.3331028223,
0.1748427749,
0.3503877223,
1.2216664553,
0.2143924683,
-0.4133387208,
-0.4167882204,
-0.7544088364,
0.6336475015,
-0.9760064483,
0.2531040013,
0.0908958018,
0.5030102134,
-0.3309995532,
-0.4400399327,
-0.7884630561,
-0.394469887,
0.0822818503,
0.355646044,
-0.2023535371,
0.0797017738,
0.6529631615,
0.334685117,
-0.5266442299,
-0.1164067313,
-0.1312690526,
-0.1581874043,
0.5230286717,
0.1669762731,
0.0884771273,
-0.1015404761,
-0.5906105042,
-0.1018241569,
-1.0067359209,
-0.0869197249,
0.3156619966,
0.0811166465,
0.1712041199,
0.7597510815,
0.0712331831,
0.3615932167,
0.1103892475,
-0.0742602572,
-0.0771632791,
-0.040909484,
-0.2948659658,
0.2025066018,
0.6206297278,
0.4869183004,
0.432823509,
0.1210040525,
-0.3108071387,
0.3620856404,
0.229418382,
-0.7776679397,
-0.3476266563,
0.0839058384,
-0.1541567743,
-0.0753983259,
-0.1452936083,
-0.5370646715,
-0.4941054285,
-0.2506783605,
0.4040054977,
-0.4956059456,
-0.2752989233,
0.5138520598,
-0.0016123997,
0.3837863207,
0.5663276911,
-0.4935502112,
0.2560911477,
0.871440053,
0.6450273991,
-0.1371876746,
-0.0649060383,
-0.4049911201,
0.2158713043,
-0.5210830569,
1.2144569159,
-0.6195588112,
-0.4127455652,
-0.0646361709,
-0.1836657375,
-0.2971027493,
-0.6270709634,
0.8744900823,
-0.5797353387,
0.4124700725,
-0.7091630101,
-0.9560103416,
-0.1780275553,
0.8881357312,
-0.2762872279,
0.6893302798,
-0.4050788879,
-0.9127889276,
0.0741706863,
-0.5877016187,
-0.2329424024,
0.053653039,
-0.433914274,
-0.3639061451,
-0.0063563003,
0.0785192251,
0.2315449566,
-0.3006535172,
0.2313435227,
-0.655136168,
-0.2867436409,
0.5282148123,
-0.706327796,
0.4612791538,
0.1669995487,
-0.5466622114,
0.05346049,
-0.172822535,
0.0784364864,
0.5296730995,
-0.2916801274,
-0.1839494556,
0.2093641907,
-0.5620712042,
0.245356679,
-0.0331291743,
-0.647051692,
0.4502645433,
-0.4196806252,
0.4332005382,
0.9672020078,
0.059027493,
-0.1070141196,
-0.6063398719,
0.4677832723,
0.0443387032,
0.0889248475,
-0.0894403011,
-0.7201974988,
-0.9299228787,
0.1473116875,
0.2864258885,
0.5956917405,
-0.7508696318,
-0.0774492621,
-0.3397316635,
-0.3162271082,
-0.3404244184,
0.1150601879,
0.3299902678,
0.7198884487,
0.1954220235,
-0.2351978719,
-0.2210947871,
-0.9327322245,
-0.4220574796,
-0.5224810243,
0.0526274592,
0.4736818075,
0.5026962757,
-0.0195871443,
0.9266904593,
-0.6563347578,
0.2103229761,
-0.2858256996,
0.2132026702,
0.1673381627,
0.1962005496,
0.1943316907,
-0.8142350912,
-0.2612333,
-0.0658231303,
-0.7792700529,
-0.1952544451,
-0.1626146436,
-0.1508053839,
0.17946437,
0.2534153759,
-0.9144268632,
0.223086834,
0.2800121903,
-0.4865532517,
0.753041625,
0.0377412997,
0.2319822907,
-0.7116155028,
-0.2787791193,
-0.049804084,
-0.2994003892,
-0.3840795755,
-0.0391437896,
-0.1026800126,
0.2090346366,
-0.3130547404,
0.428750664,
-0.1398660392,
0.1470524073,
-0.2621759474,
0.3175581098,
0.0796025395,
0.4092661738,
0.1044514105,
0.6896328926,
0.2614188492,
-0.2873438001,
0.3137924075,
0.3029344082,
-0.408408016,
0.8029877543,
-0.8245798945,
0.2851966918,
0.0570841543,
0.2870177627,
-1.2056187391,
-0.134596169,
0.3100092113,
-0.3963912427,
0.1099760681,
-0.3443341851,
-0.6913537979,
-0.3807039261,
-0.168334052,
0.0706835613,
0.535680294,
-0.4349168241,
0.470734179,
0.2604890168,
-0.4077759385,
-0.5002306104,
-0.4799728692,
0.3319141865,
-0.4599694312,
-0.8527827263,
-0.0294790976,
-0.333646059,
-0.6637940407,
-0.0646985099,
-0.2527888417,
0.130410105,
0.072747387,
0.1591919512,
0.3852428794,
-0.4487964809,
0.2493510693,
-0.2048898786,
-0.0555193983,
0.3060513735,
-0.0984610766,
0.4460693896,
-0.5955622196,
-1.1047749519,
0.1111136153,
0.1263315827,
0.4247927964,
-0.0515676998,
0.2971092165,
0.2342188507,
-0.1052991971,
-0.2359120846,
-1.0100659132,
-0.3149602115,
-0.5085501671,
0.1765300632,
-0.3760628402,
-1.0977340937,
0.4211910963,
-0.4186719358,
0.2982591987,
0.3727808893,
0.7561798692,
-0.3798927963,
1.0414097309,
-0.0142074404,
0.1701642573,
-0.0461438671,
-0.0155218812,
0.320985198,
-0.6073225737,
-0.073434338,
-0.335426122,
-0.2448832095,
-0.2295459062,
-0.5689902306,
0.356644094,
0.0293363743,
-0.3282377422,
-0.0688583925,
-0.3080274463,
0.6757374406,
0.2031786442,
0.0902343765,
0.4113902748,
-0.3126533329,
-0.2751769423,
-0.2658195198,
-0.803599298,
-0.7789300084,
0.7142215967,
0.4983362556,
0.7899259329,
0.2758244872,
0.3088166714,
0.2246664315,
0.4924130142,
-0.8116621971,
0.7088068724,
0.3896901309,
-0.6627460122,
-0.1204628348,
-0.4916551411,
-0.7887467146,
0.5600615144,
-0.1223708466,
-0.4691833854,
-0.1355742663,
0.2147702277,
-0.2115821242,
0.6537532806,
-0.7887013555,
1.0185474157,
-0.4030690491,
-0.4505043924,
-0.2801249921,
-0.5202088952,
0.6795605421,
0.1743132919,
0.191068247,
-0.2338560969,
0.2757603824,
0.6093529463,
-0.2099331766,
0.9324874282,
-0.0751639679,
-0.3984177709,
0.4893846512,
0.4342363775,
0.5729044676,
0.0493853949,
0.2196041048,
-0.0425554402,
-0.068902038,
-0.4071191847,
-0.8167139888,
0.5133215189,
-0.4524135888,
-1.3831720352,
-0.3875292242,
-0.4548783898,
-0.4882346392,
0.080835022,
-0.0906612054,
0.2979670167,
-0.2373731285,
0.1112860665,
1.1163541079,
-0.0743216947,
0.079410702,
0.52536726,
-0.3175099492,
-0.1325584948,
0.7131654024,
0.0896905065,
0.631732285,
0.0409005508,
0.5182469487,
-0.4655124545,
-0.6304242015,
-0.4492762685,
0.1897789836,
-0.8797792792,
-0.1985543817,
-0.3491526544,
-0.1643137634,
0.003544275,
0.0531724729,
-0.4622874856,
-0.4137955308,
0.4565415084,
-0.1064894795,
0.1687976271,
0.712177217,
0.2185062021,
0.0463041849,
-0.6586116552,
0.0765228868,
0.6281386018,
0.1872260273,
-0.1088603213,
-0.517536521,
0.1929184496,
0.1634966731,
-0.697878778,
-0.8515120149,
-0.0210753828,
-0.1907767653,
0.5044723153,
0.499682039,
0.2310138494,
0.5917801261,
-0.5960852504,
0.7826240659,
0.0234644692,
-0.8456349969,
0.5019710064,
-0.5527817607,
0.1160305589,
0.2581358254,
0.108524248,
-0.5395573974,
-0.4422204196,
-0.7657532096,
-0.4061358869,
0.2621909082,
0.3686535358,
0.1204443946,
0.0220776349,
0.1935399771,
-0.0426103771,
0.1501155943,
-0.6547103524,
0.0849788263,
-0.1760814041,
0.1178753376,
0.2431115806,
-0.285523206,
-0.5931652784,
-0.0899611115,
0.6412376761,
-0.2789615691,
0.2119852304,
0.2717209756,
0.0931482539,
-0.0055796858,
0.5473600626,
0.7299717665,
0.5357208848,
-0.1047640443,
0.5265067816,
0.4046102762,
-0.1828928739,
0.0390757769,
-0.0263945051,
0.059993647,
-0.1047177315,
0.4403112233,
0.7201983333,
0.2580266595,
-0.8029660583,
0.7415144444,
-0.1809544563,
-0.3686371744,
0.0061846967,
0.2106544077,
0.4923188686,
0.4017938375,
0.0757746845,
0.1538460404,
-0.2509888113,
-0.5407768488,
0.2591632605,
0.5901136994,
-0.2100077569,
-0.205490008,
0.5150566101,
0.064714767,
-0.2395538688,
0.4839683175,
-0.1512817591,
-1.0723888874,
0.5897307992,
0.5697563291,
0.6295421124,
-0.0440204591,
0.0342437774,
0.0597860515,
0.3936328888,
-0.1134892404,
0.1683870256,
0.0717005655,
-1.0454331636,
-0.5118591785,
-0.0959392935,
-0.8650898933,
-0.0856689289,
-0.3102689385,
0.0735653713,
-0.4656002522,
-0.0807880908,
-0.2369656861,
0.0294037294,
-0.3262167275,
-0.0563211776,
0.2775501311,
0.8936982155,
-0.5704208016,
0.7540965676,
0.4018895328,
-0.0179903973,
-0.7750903368,
0.2424429953,
0.2174628228,
-0.9326893091,
0.4516452253,
0.0635544807,
-0.3844864666,
-0.4472474754,
-0.9298982024,
-0.4909987152,
0.8150093555,
0.6394729614,
-0.6287786961,
0.3235554099,
0.1744265705,
0.4834989607,
-0.0973213091,
0.3600870967,
0.3798157573,
0.6265776753,
0.5792909861,
-0.9466001987,
0.0354953259,
-0.2574722469,
-0.3726546764,
-0.0891207159,
-0.8430638909,
0.7387259603,
-0.3806954622,
-0.2852444649,
-0.3313882649,
0.5780245066,
0.6138618588,
0.3038213551,
0.7372513413,
0.6166511178,
0.9541211724,
-0.2493866682,
1.0327715874,
-0.0845846981,
0.3812628686,
1.1405354738,
-0.579369247,
0.8900574446,
0.3426024914,
-0.1569201052,
0.4246409237,
0.6189391613,
-0.0917422995,
0.1535830647,
0.4146737158,
-0.2185778171,
-0.7460903525,
0.0495938659,
-0.4410357475,
0.2172560096,
0.4258800745,
0.2901703715,
-0.3137440979,
-0.3288402259,
0.3377623558,
0.1839025617,
-0.0273331217,
0.5352694392,
0.2342390418,
-0.7023456097,
0.7026754022,
-0.1193158701,
0.5110054612,
-0.5917257071,
-0.1937701851,
-0.1737730056,
0.1705777943,
-0.0928713828,
-1.1825784445,
0.2386608124,
0.0959348604,
0.2337892503,
-0.2051619738,
0.764200747,
-0.2689031959,
-0.3226215839,
0.0776633397,
0.6670287251,
0.1727559119,
-0.0173413735,
-0.869558692,
0.1566218138,
0.0487185642,
-0.4377258122,
0.2741748989,
0.6217083931,
0.0605805553,
0.9491354823,
0.6139340401,
-0.0050841961,
-0.0153151583,
0.0742127895,
1.0290812254,
-0.4737949967,
-0.2243473232,
-1.2229247093,
0.1311208606,
-0.2145783603,
-0.1553407907,
0.9515858889,
0.6150729656,
0.6823477745,
0.254301697,
0.7976690531,
0.2259574085,
0.4367955625,
-0.6918241382,
0.5256865621,
-0.2884445786,
0.4846773446,
-0.2909578085,
-0.5876258016,
-0.1476639509,
0.6945448518,
-0.6067351699,
-0.0577761233,
0.6826375723,
0.7534218431,
-0.0915988088,
0.574211359,
0.3209313452,
0.646073103,
0.6386902332,
0.8290307522,
1.4777402878,
-0.0958368927,
0.5871781111,
0.0640391111,
-0.0985613167,
0.0530010015,
-0.9603945017,
-1.0490403175,
-0.228256911,
-0.3595857918,
-0.5830055475,
-0.0079920953,
0.8751464486,
0.3963510692,
-0.6750439405,
-0.1499067694,
0.0599227771,
0.4131256342,
0.0139973518,
-0.2148640752,
0.3378595114,
-0.3250716925,
-0.5838549137,
0.3547535241,
0.2403242141,
-0.0460837446,
-0.1522148103,
-0.1904485971,
0.0167313535,
0.4244143367,
0.4782359004,
0.1135320961,
-0.8751374483,
-0.6946981549,
-0.0794993266,
-0.1583013386,
0.4073670805,
0.8027799129,
-0.5663588047,
0.3535271883,
0.3091107309,
0.7610499859,
0.4006288648,
0.1580833644,
0.5742899776,
-0.1905434877,
-0.3284975886,
0.4451490045,
0.4927113652,
0.3396498263,
-0.0887337252,
0.4173961282,
0.5232989788,
-0.6699807048,
-0.8990985751,
0.3290194273,
-1.0577341318,
-0.2626194954,
1.2308436632,
-0.3153702021,
-0.0233289413,
-0.1654519886,
-0.5897978544,
-0.1129919216,
-0.2782039344,
1.0679625273,
1.0918534994,
-0.2593262792,
-0.0814578533,
-0.7880570292,
0.3880869746,
0.6754218936,
-0.6388155222,
0.4763091803,
0.271668613,
0.3869862854,
0.0568483248,
0.5451424122,
-0.0727456808,
0.0227904357,
-0.0304799341,
-0.2980210185,
0.0289683212,
-0.0090830876,
-0.0255489089,
0.254150182,
0.3047054708,
0.1362852156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13144v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13144v2 | Response Length Perception and Sequence Scheduling: An LLM-Empowered LLM Inference Pipeline | 2023-05-22T15:36:06 | 2023-05-28T08:22:19 | Zangwei Zheng, Xiaozhe Ren, Fuzhao Xue, Yang Luo, Xin Jiang, Yang You | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the field of AI,
demonstrating unprecedented capacity across various tasks. However, the
inference process for LLMs comes with significant computational costs. In this
paper, we propose an efficient LLM inference pipeline that harnesses the power
of LLMs. Our approach begins by tapping into the potential of LLMs to
accurately perceive and predict the response length with minimal overhead. By
leveraging this information, we introduce an efficient sequence scheduling
technique that groups queries with similar response lengths into micro-batches.
We evaluate our approach on real-world instruction datasets using the
LLaMA-based model, and our results demonstrate an impressive 86% improvement in
inference throughput without compromising effectiveness. Notably, our method is
orthogonal to other inference acceleration techniques, making it a valuable
addition to many existing toolkits (e.g., FlashAttention, Quantization) for LLM
inference. | [
-0.2801165283,
-0.5895745754,
0.8246520162,
0.390077889,
-0.1777117103,
0.155235216,
-0.169803068,
-0.4011454284,
0.329582423,
0.5435484648,
-0.7801588774,
-0.1110130176,
-0.4295331538,
0.1545702368,
-0.4416256845,
0.4997293353,
0.408434093,
0.0354952402,
-0.2215745002,
-0.0001612268,
-0.2625578642,
-0.0779886097,
-0.664275229,
-0.2678833902,
0.6886932254,
0.5683124065,
0.5785232186,
1.1875665188,
0.3458505571,
0.3209334314,
0.0196613092,
0.4260708094,
-0.2625623941,
0.1999024153,
0.1816498339,
-0.7387661338,
-0.4580056667,
-0.2199558169,
0.6972619295,
0.8986327648,
-0.1889549494,
0.4360673726,
0.2515825033,
0.6343550086,
-0.719786644,
-0.1271734983,
-0.589843154,
0.348192662,
0.0146922423,
-0.1371826082,
-0.7329381108,
-0.1864001155,
0.1304891407,
-0.6514365077,
0.1307365894,
0.2709360123,
0.1626238227,
0.6653093696,
-0.0562108122,
0.0930234417,
-0.6174708605,
1.0679577589,
-0.755410254,
0.5526747108,
0.0748651326,
0.5025618076,
-0.1712972969,
-1.0152951479,
-0.6690763831,
0.0882330984,
-0.0537330396,
0.0290844385,
0.2813071311,
0.1470677257,
0.3260868192,
0.3372428119,
-0.7577747703,
0.5578410029,
-0.0593643449,
0.0617831238,
0.4871728122,
0.4511679411,
-0.2615987062,
-0.0014042889,
-0.3264142573,
0.0457009412,
-0.5608513951,
-0.1439776421,
0.1151258275,
0.2370224893,
-0.0367837586,
0.6090067625,
-0.1986460239,
0.9258518815,
-0.1740630269,
-0.2601521015,
-0.2143856138,
-0.0036337301,
-0.7042637467,
-0.0900559723,
0.7153941989,
0.2506109178,
0.2037104964,
-0.231213659,
-0.0411290787,
0.1054167598,
0.2093931139,
-0.9864782095,
0.1756741405,
0.3423385918,
-0.2682968974,
-0.1508126557,
-0.2146661431,
-1.1016991138,
-0.519221127,
-0.2844944894,
0.0171154849,
-0.145961687,
0.1934734136,
0.0737870634,
0.036016982,
0.4565010965,
0.2662168145,
-0.8793606758,
0.1118073091,
0.8575485349,
0.9305758476,
-0.0853834823,
-0.0858934745,
-1.0925109386,
-0.0416143164,
-0.2460620403,
0.7397552133,
-0.7287274599,
-0.5190519094,
-0.2798549235,
-0.1269881427,
-0.0660119876,
-0.5055690408,
0.2155022025,
-0.8395057917,
-0.0936792865,
0.1670184284,
-0.7310702801,
0.1592983902,
0.0727064312,
-0.491404742,
0.6886039972,
-0.0468266308,
-0.4051577747,
0.0728700161,
-0.5885869861,
-0.391217351,
-0.0003544512,
-0.2792140841,
-0.1631103009,
0.051820077,
0.5330677032,
0.4036698639,
-0.535014987,
0.0404983498,
-0.3213774562,
-0.5736202002,
0.2042393088,
-0.4928916097,
0.489844054,
0.4898548722,
-0.1344666481,
0.2659844756,
-0.787699163,
0.146465078,
-0.065889366,
-0.59695822,
0.1893556714,
0.2723696828,
-0.4776363671,
-0.1163472682,
0.0635130927,
-0.4327417612,
0.1904041022,
-0.7199228406,
0.3954837024,
1.0947525501,
-0.3055816591,
0.6334308982,
-0.048505459,
0.9064477682,
-0.4003362954,
0.1727892756,
-0.2993327975,
-0.3303486109,
-0.8526101112,
-0.5124317408,
0.2444054782,
0.697909534,
-0.8541436791,
0.4103242159,
-0.5992580056,
-0.2042801678,
-0.7290139198,
0.1419685632,
0.4562754929,
0.6562827229,
0.3785894215,
-0.0473812819,
-0.6646691561,
-0.662615478,
-0.5883700848,
-0.104738079,
-0.6366617084,
0.400182873,
-0.131333515,
0.0024013773,
0.8600285649,
-0.5754805207,
0.3663615584,
-0.4088660479,
-0.0675454065,
0.5227459073,
0.0723411068,
0.2538711727,
-0.3710296154,
-0.3337695301,
-0.3656291962,
-0.7434468865,
-0.4301759005,
-0.0519117229,
-0.1415826678,
0.27636078,
0.4240938127,
-0.2676903605,
0.4284630418,
0.5982989073,
-0.2541553676,
0.3587788045,
0.2753905952,
-0.1289884001,
-0.8596925139,
-0.3061229885,
-0.0730738193,
-0.2465486079,
-0.2991861105,
0.0870749876,
-0.0822507665,
0.0887577757,
-0.5012006164,
0.6895109415,
-0.4456786513,
-0.6234757304,
-0.3195360005,
-0.0307523385,
0.0668750778,
0.4528482854,
-0.0546065532,
1.1253150702,
0.243588686,
-0.7446565032,
0.3084159195,
0.0503129922,
-0.5737925768,
0.1915814281,
-0.6051630378,
0.3842847943,
-0.0364844017,
0.3677007556,
-0.993319869,
-0.2491411269,
0.1552606672,
-0.2587737441,
0.0544930883,
-0.2519143522,
-0.4476525486,
-0.6155210733,
-0.3793945611,
0.2597545385,
0.7293645144,
-0.951030612,
0.8459845781,
-0.121922031,
0.0675607845,
-0.8172280192,
-0.9759319425,
-0.0913073942,
-0.3790063858,
-0.5333969593,
0.0754598081,
-0.1617093086,
-0.2679853141,
-0.5350998044,
-0.230439961,
0.0967444181,
0.2753610015,
0.292760551,
0.3082817495,
-0.4389112592,
0.0689472184,
0.1745045483,
0.1256475896,
0.0503064506,
-0.3554975986,
0.7011983991,
0.1150517315,
-0.394767791,
-0.4833036363,
0.1368298233,
0.5636000037,
-0.1640564054,
0.5980337858,
0.3829545379,
0.0030081307,
-0.292473197,
-0.5014082789,
-0.6014154553,
-0.5474534631,
0.121393919,
-0.2656171918,
-0.9284051657,
0.2976273596,
0.0309991129,
0.2466562241,
0.072892949,
0.3373739719,
0.0477130823,
0.8698019981,
0.2337042093,
-0.2522053421,
0.5427613258,
-0.3358229995,
0.3232233822,
-0.9291125536,
-0.0603180379,
-0.2923616171,
-0.6193791628,
-0.3366617262,
-0.7420377135,
0.4501277208,
-0.1381819695,
-0.5130339265,
-0.0466132611,
-0.337662667,
0.5591048002,
0.5229716301,
0.2543291152,
0.3439671695,
0.1684512794,
0.0054724962,
-0.0221805982,
-0.6839312315,
-0.551581502,
1.184412241,
0.1590631157,
0.8742628694,
0.1467649192,
0.3463619053,
0.3155121803,
0.3582656682,
-0.9957765341,
0.8684430718,
0.025178967,
-0.0192837324,
-0.4190014005,
-0.2935443521,
-0.8173121214,
0.309062928,
0.0383240283,
-0.8095528483,
-0.1045534238,
0.1535784304,
-0.7778906226,
0.3953538835,
-0.6304219365,
0.4946933389,
-0.2573416233,
-0.6125323772,
-0.309373498,
-0.8100665808,
0.3128372431,
0.0085976589,
0.1635636091,
-0.2526553869,
-0.3156545162,
0.6584547758,
-0.6580631137,
0.9210044146,
-0.0042503006,
0.1310517192,
0.3765874207,
-0.038529247,
0.3539384007,
0.0803375244,
-0.4041468799,
-0.1702827811,
-0.4488111138,
-0.4717379808,
-0.7862984538,
0.7217229009,
-0.3606974185,
-0.7077322006,
-0.0892576054,
-0.716910243,
-0.3289192915,
0.0014115566,
0.0234113596,
0.3085316718,
0.079423137,
-0.0990080908,
0.4318041503,
-0.3479140401,
0.8572461605,
0.6182656288,
-0.5234553218,
-0.1798380911,
0.5992246866,
-0.0215813778,
0.3522747755,
0.5685466528,
0.1399482489,
-0.4524638653,
-0.4459784329,
-0.705770731,
0.0299574174,
-0.3692281246,
-0.2950153947,
-0.7699725032,
-0.0614528582,
-0.4752434492,
-0.1186616123,
-0.2170290351,
-0.4951317906,
-0.3431077302,
-0.1776805818,
0.6526128054,
0.4228962362,
0.1086168513,
0.7423179746,
-0.7505888343,
0.3339490891,
0.5134297013,
0.3039387465,
0.3258086443,
-0.8728634715,
-0.0734204948,
-0.0927056968,
-0.4649537206,
-0.4754472673,
0.4980770946,
0.3421671391,
0.2202061415,
0.5338577628,
0.0578782596,
0.8160117865,
-0.6451102495,
0.8912129402,
-0.1416766793,
-0.6048381925,
0.566138804,
0.110154748,
0.2330442965,
-0.0170243047,
0.3504857123,
-0.2163727582,
-0.289403677,
-0.4007810652,
-0.9301162362,
0.3619913161,
-0.1836180985,
0.0428556278,
-0.3076175153,
0.3971818984,
0.0154362693,
0.1523855031,
-0.0338711739,
-0.2628352344,
0.1729251146,
-0.1280225813,
-0.0341146849,
-0.4098840952,
0.1065867171,
-0.3155718744,
0.2966542542,
-0.4885158837,
0.4125487208,
0.0995949656,
-0.1141573936,
0.1836058199,
0.3041866124,
0.3821380436,
0.8030420542,
-0.137166068,
0.0805610716,
0.3981490135,
-0.1828167289,
0.0705829039,
0.1566097587,
0.3830740452,
-0.1890929639,
0.4734617174,
0.7189660072,
0.0579792783,
-1.0223501921,
0.2219633609,
-0.0874101967,
0.2477689385,
-0.2409891337,
0.3125626445,
0.1143270731,
0.6386079192,
0.2788814604,
-0.3133415282,
0.3675109446,
-0.2295242548,
0.0942459404,
0.2042963207,
-0.0072168503,
-0.0141731668,
0.8937461972,
0.114600949,
-0.3738479316,
0.8714082837,
0.1608405709,
-0.2298521549,
0.9489279985,
0.4089875221,
0.6681501865,
-0.3327459395,
-0.1361334473,
0.2742511034,
-0.0992600992,
-0.0136653371,
0.261451453,
0.0009145973,
-0.7483252287,
-0.8335769773,
-0.9597010016,
-0.4741192162,
0.0885298923,
-0.7181574106,
0.001245714,
-0.7137448788,
0.0149110323,
0.0876527652,
-0.2890021205,
-0.5045650601,
0.0682879165,
0.282192409,
1.1885308027,
-0.5195134878,
0.7206027508,
0.3843985796,
0.0536111183,
-0.7265178561,
-0.120863229,
0.1595222354,
-1.2449252605,
0.4821814597,
0.3673782051,
-0.241197601,
0.14332214,
-0.5512849092,
-0.4366339743,
1.2040534019,
0.5406186581,
-0.9211017489,
0.0191201512,
0.1720588058,
0.3233809769,
-0.5583173037,
0.294580102,
1.1343153715,
0.303008616,
0.1910642534,
-0.6908986568,
-0.1006439701,
0.1891351938,
0.3076420426,
0.0629676133,
-0.5193282962,
0.3112793267,
-0.5531073213,
0.021378139,
0.3727020323,
1.1042560339,
0.4711398482,
0.3666763604,
0.5613922477,
0.7286316752,
0.8469303846,
0.0838293731,
1.3234606981,
-0.2212734818,
-0.0739041641,
1.3775564432,
-0.2688083351,
0.811514914,
0.6705910563,
-0.4429746568,
0.3998041451,
0.8222157955,
0.2138814628,
0.4379512668,
0.4588331282,
-0.6251089573,
-0.2974579632,
-0.2876760066,
-0.0960024372,
0.2918139398,
0.4917236865,
-0.6545829773,
0.1151299775,
-0.1495996416,
0.0336483791,
0.1296130568,
-0.4282494187,
0.6252560019,
0.2691265643,
-0.7443109155,
0.6068641543,
-0.2208522856,
0.7500364184,
-0.2209720165,
0.0201250184,
-0.638638556,
0.2462775856,
-0.074789986,
-0.8291407824,
0.3237522542,
0.15934591,
-0.3276966512,
-0.1650341302,
0.250297904,
-0.1140622869,
-0.45408988,
0.3271634281,
0.4876046777,
0.2845669985,
-0.0079404349,
-0.3433249891,
0.1463312656,
-0.0518549681,
-0.3343759775,
0.3137617111,
0.1363017112,
0.0140479943,
0.9072827101,
0.4865721166,
-0.0794028491,
0.4937133193,
0.056647215,
0.8348819613,
-0.4372000694,
-0.1740047038,
-1.1502275467,
0.311265707,
0.0562513508,
0.1448399574,
0.2743107975,
0.5291576385,
0.6242785454,
-0.1516558975,
0.710154593,
0.20624277,
0.6641737819,
-0.6973621845,
0.2875836492,
-0.4894374609,
0.7794194818,
0.2968042493,
-0.8048095703,
-0.2319844216,
0.4436193705,
-0.3731235266,
-0.1099185646,
0.3909916282,
0.8475114703,
-0.1509934366,
0.1070242971,
0.1043529883,
0.1939679086,
0.301856637,
0.5801174641,
0.7402745485,
-0.0725180507,
0.4626770616,
-0.2011053413,
-0.149997741,
-0.227193743,
-1.0346330404,
-0.7132958174,
0.0999127701,
0.0043351725,
-0.2821384668,
0.1769833267,
1.0107010603,
0.6018407941,
-0.5332415104,
-0.3943298757,
-0.1864928901,
0.2104147971,
-0.1805611551,
-0.3036458492,
0.1466146708,
-0.4450889528,
-0.8934611678,
0.7078365684,
0.1628031582,
-0.016397927,
-0.0200125091,
-0.0884819552,
-0.037416704,
0.1864610016,
0.8117416501,
0.3957672417,
-0.9046288729,
-0.3036769629,
0.1265421659,
0.1166171357,
0.1351362616,
0.6406298876,
-0.9662733078,
0.2843675017,
0.3909779787,
1.219845891,
0.4123141766,
-0.0321258493,
0.7534136772,
-0.8847304583,
0.34619385,
0.2742725909,
0.3529111743,
0.2808146477,
-0.3191591203,
1.0073422194,
0.1490801871,
-0.6128749251,
-0.8008453846,
0.316996187,
-0.8120789528,
-0.1376304179,
1.0363976955,
-0.2649668753,
-0.2364870906,
0.3267674744,
0.0947394967,
0.2367899865,
-0.2976439595,
0.6300418973,
0.2810655534,
-0.4634280801,
-0.4007728398,
-0.6751638055,
0.1429617852,
0.6045054793,
-0.7059882879,
0.0315673724,
0.4639076889,
0.0758396685,
-0.0978015214,
0.5222433209,
0.2792602479,
-0.0691499263,
-0.3723258078,
-0.2397126704,
0.1331016123,
-0.5701923966,
-0.2161989808,
-0.2161116302,
0.1193356887,
-0.5393263698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13142v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13142v1 | Better Sampling of Negatives for Distantly Supervised Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-22T15:35:39 | 2023-05-22T15:35:39 | Lu Xu, Lidong Bing, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Distantly supervised named entity recognition (DS-NER) has been proposed to
exploit the automatically labeled training data instead of human annotations.
The distantly annotated datasets are often noisy and contain a considerable
number of false negatives. The recent approach uses a weighted sampling
approach to select a subset of negative samples for training. However, it
requires a good classifier to assign weights to the negative samples. In this
paper, we propose a simple and straightforward approach for selecting the top
negative samples that have high similarities with all the positive samples for
training. Our method achieves consistent performance improvements on four
distantly supervised NER datasets. Our analysis also shows that it is critical
to differentiate the true negatives from the false negatives. | [
-0.9721964002,
-0.2401596308,
0.532399416,
-0.2924700379,
-0.136732012,
-0.1850726157,
-0.2037911713,
-0.6119849086,
0.7402027845,
0.3485419154,
-0.47872293,
-0.4949472249,
-0.8932422996,
0.4296450019,
-0.5269621611,
1.3295743465,
0.3277992606,
0.3271076083,
-0.1350240707,
-0.3325560391,
-0.253906697,
-0.5372434258,
-1.1138542891,
-0.2496114224,
0.6995457411,
0.3508438766,
0.0960544869,
0.2235426307,
0.5375562906,
0.2330527902,
-0.0720653981,
-0.09121342,
-0.5598391891,
0.2271002531,
-0.2913237214,
-0.3564288318,
-0.3628365397,
0.0570452698,
0.3890757263,
0.6785907149,
0.0570648722,
0.4114027619,
-0.3070031703,
0.5719377995,
-0.7182810903,
-0.1822440475,
-0.6546744108,
0.1512471735,
-0.5813269019,
-0.1254856735,
-0.3037185669,
-0.6048241258,
0.0758396983,
-0.7454439402,
0.5789357424,
-0.08246658,
1.1519593,
0.1771206856,
-0.3856899142,
-0.2064472586,
-0.6533846259,
1.1481528282,
-0.593198061,
0.4373892546,
0.5566964746,
0.3760127127,
0.045144733,
-0.0101343486,
-0.3696371913,
-0.2305734307,
0.0978113711,
-0.0857000649,
-0.0438030288,
-0.1682451963,
0.6043329239,
0.1151554883,
-0.0568705127,
0.2915257812,
-0.612578094,
-0.2944746614,
0.689242363,
-0.1682108194,
0.0890407339,
0.0180189945,
-0.2736906707,
-0.0064669182,
-0.6801741719,
-0.3426355422,
0.5766880512,
0.5480046272,
0.2243610322,
0.6967238188,
-0.540020287,
0.7743886709,
0.4328848422,
-0.2636794448,
0.7200462222,
0.0275371093,
-0.0253284443,
0.4171192944,
0.2977462113,
0.4908732474,
0.353056848,
-0.3877441883,
-0.4639707208,
0.0549127199,
0.1800531447,
-1.1176081896,
-0.3665899634,
0.1068523005,
-0.4583845735,
-0.3040500283,
0.0650133118,
-1.041244626,
-0.4956350327,
-0.7717270255,
0.4719018042,
-0.4136179984,
-0.0949936286,
-0.3431020379,
-0.4362732768,
-0.0359629057,
0.5296223164,
-0.6956725717,
0.6184797883,
0.4094909728,
0.5616029501,
-0.1064523682,
0.0470465943,
-1.1211344004,
-0.0245150067,
-0.2888031006,
0.8111325502,
-0.3904529512,
-0.1132079586,
-0.5202749372,
-0.0592884645,
0.2479032874,
-0.7333117127,
0.4352105856,
-0.7894153595,
0.3122290075,
-0.5664060712,
-0.7391226888,
-0.2041488439,
0.4521469176,
-0.7699124217,
0.8593107462,
0.1650031358,
-1.0354750156,
0.8333631754,
-0.1009646803,
-0.424546659,
0.0300733838,
-0.2564971745,
-0.9116365314,
0.100744009,
0.3226591051,
0.6006808877,
-0.0577782653,
0.4307223558,
-0.6101463437,
-0.6220533252,
-0.0568586178,
-0.0601725169,
0.8278177977,
0.1187625155,
-0.3627777994,
-0.4308260977,
-1.0281511545,
-0.0538032539,
-0.1039878801,
-0.0107682552,
-1.0294671059,
-0.0937185884,
-0.1970912516,
0.2288751155,
-0.2439166307,
-0.8067259789,
0.16468364,
-0.2543316782,
-0.0917631462,
0.5630589724,
0.2662701011,
0.680983305,
-0.3149240315,
0.5370489955,
0.0995806381,
-0.2301765531,
0.4359548092,
-0.166211918,
-0.613953352,
-0.5179845095,
0.4739238322,
0.3483525217,
-0.7193462849,
0.4379839897,
-0.4173383415,
-0.5581732392,
-0.1288637221,
0.1303173453,
0.09274555,
0.935099721,
0.8662602901,
-0.3423591554,
-0.6572724581,
-0.8470800519,
0.1493089944,
0.1277876347,
-0.1438195854,
0.3956424892,
0.6192532182,
-0.074108161,
0.8074595928,
-0.5566952229,
-0.597802639,
0.1149652675,
0.1786996573,
0.2700815201,
0.3219916523,
0.5804094076,
-0.8467102051,
-0.3874548376,
-0.5789146423,
-0.4342715442,
-0.1445877552,
-0.1988615096,
-0.2198967189,
-0.1339219213,
0.5444286466,
-0.3960829079,
0.1661696732,
0.2763225436,
0.0515690781,
0.3484190106,
0.2520608902,
0.0129933627,
-1.1513427496,
0.1832376122,
0.3341705501,
-0.0880851448,
-0.4362701476,
-0.3775508106,
0.0275103953,
0.1561918557,
-0.2949931622,
0.5850639343,
-0.8625798821,
-0.0026074301,
0.0133336373,
0.3414479196,
-0.0750526786,
0.0486387275,
0.2658555806,
0.5894724131,
0.674937129,
-0.8171086907,
0.3705587387,
0.1826476306,
-0.1495161951,
1.0732575655,
-0.2649783194,
-0.143956989,
-0.5544996262,
0.4623436034,
-0.4812460244,
-0.0836358815,
0.2367549837,
-0.2419386506,
0.6026162505,
-0.3754160404,
0.099247776,
-0.3370843828,
-0.5034094453,
0.4219403863,
0.3212301433,
-0.5630837679,
0.2407606244,
0.574745357,
-0.0173029266,
-0.6507266164,
-0.8182407022,
0.2488768399,
-0.4900034964,
0.1457271874,
0.68457973,
0.4298557937,
-0.2112418115,
0.038017977,
-0.1523172557,
-0.1717033684,
-0.1377376169,
0.2884654403,
0.1819874793,
-0.0728456452,
0.5504071116,
-0.1299323738,
-0.451066941,
-0.0890971646,
-0.3730983734,
0.2535226643,
0.2891797125,
-0.1888178587,
-0.48575598,
0.0046642441,
0.0180901326,
-0.1203842834,
0.6152341366,
0.6739110947,
-0.700810492,
-0.2115170211,
-0.8104363084,
-0.3961969316,
-0.3394906819,
0.220167011,
-0.293373704,
-0.5203029513,
0.2345851213,
-0.1230883896,
-0.3860720396,
0.3696717024,
0.028443953,
-0.1227888018,
0.4391030073,
0.608563602,
-0.4809076488,
0.6151652932,
-0.2982219756,
0.1432621032,
-0.9145368934,
-0.073848173,
-0.6119967699,
-0.3103811443,
-0.5938741565,
-0.2246448994,
0.0371115133,
0.1084728837,
-0.2319418192,
0.6411916614,
-0.7259751558,
0.4326014817,
0.6232070327,
0.1508596092,
0.0178071428,
0.1502139121,
0.1795001179,
-0.2416467667,
-0.028565092,
-0.4239632189,
0.8903750181,
-0.0090979328,
0.7268159389,
0.1146164164,
1.58852911,
0.0651645437,
0.706997335,
-0.7290064692,
0.5432097912,
-0.4157919586,
-0.77610147,
-0.3313484788,
-0.6623550653,
-0.798017323,
-0.2470968515,
-0.197222665,
-0.9397478104,
0.3921072185,
0.0512517542,
-0.5318891406,
0.4411453307,
-0.523432374,
0.3581701517,
-0.0553924926,
0.0402058214,
0.0472419299,
-0.6656770706,
0.1615757495,
-0.2868870795,
0.0252085626,
-0.0901659429,
-0.0069803735,
0.7642588615,
-0.3620278835,
0.5111267567,
-0.6805856824,
-0.0658485591,
0.4551850259,
0.0238360614,
0.6013156176,
0.1352872849,
-0.4772953689,
0.425963819,
-0.2781620026,
-0.2781734467,
-0.3578694463,
0.6347369552,
-0.470251292,
-0.2076755166,
-0.3880591094,
0.0235834606,
-0.0326112211,
0.3456482589,
0.3522302806,
0.6053718925,
0.0950627401,
0.0641686469,
0.6164481044,
-0.3729460537,
0.3149074018,
0.112385869,
-0.01286807,
-0.6790066361,
1.1418941021,
0.5434268713,
0.0329109319,
0.7690963149,
-0.289607197,
-0.202160269,
-0.5279788375,
-0.5702490807,
0.1620716006,
-0.4655252695,
-0.5877696276,
-0.8215717673,
-0.1668441296,
-0.1275646687,
-0.1334030926,
-0.4060170054,
-0.4644792378,
-0.4980922043,
-0.2296989411,
0.3059149384,
0.4224432409,
-0.0401980393,
0.0510920919,
-0.5738426447,
0.7033674717,
0.1533227116,
0.2620005906,
-0.0546993315,
-0.3651970029,
0.0509413034,
0.0268505011,
-0.0500619151,
-1.0059221983,
0.2765280306,
0.2933430374,
0.4365235269,
0.3290281892,
0.1814376563,
0.9919674993,
-0.3908062875,
0.5322499275,
0.2026995867,
-0.7252238393,
0.495450139,
-0.0160254054,
-0.0218173955,
1.1987599134,
0.6731795669,
-0.3810840547,
-0.1794870943,
-0.5852718949,
-0.9239119887,
0.5941087604,
0.0736789182,
0.1109559312,
-0.151465863,
0.4844203293,
0.2941229939,
0.2330908477,
-0.7402063012,
-0.3913574219,
0.1223156601,
-0.1622869819,
-0.0930140391,
0.0368105993,
0.0659806356,
-0.164367944,
1.0634031296,
-0.0552357957,
0.3088729084,
0.2625646889,
-0.0564225204,
-0.2408568859,
0.2744888365,
0.125861764,
0.301271081,
-0.3242239058,
0.3226808608,
0.6944228411,
-0.4760898054,
0.2974690795,
0.5272719264,
-0.5743041039,
0.071951896,
0.1645570248,
0.2563986182,
-0.2733990848,
-0.2530513406,
0.7388415337,
-0.1240321547,
-0.0019798428,
-0.4508842826,
-0.0156186158,
-0.0226076134,
0.2093534023,
0.3894931972,
0.4394604266,
0.3612230122,
-0.0115651675,
0.5561360717,
0.5158040524,
-0.6409859657,
-0.0316312797,
0.4855703115,
-0.0204557274,
-0.0267229341,
0.9670863152,
-0.7960770726,
-0.4574660659,
0.8080729246,
0.2531448305,
0.7064065933,
0.0940748453,
0.3126264513,
0.8431326747,
-0.0490706488,
-0.2308873087,
0.1847108603,
-0.3298279643,
-0.6409868002,
-0.5355687141,
-0.6923843026,
-0.2277685851,
0.1448676586,
-0.9741139412,
0.8151065111,
-0.157761991,
-0.6440401077,
0.191580832,
0.1998313218,
-0.6792612672,
0.7493025064,
0.5318054557,
0.6684491634,
-0.7399278283,
0.7735379934,
0.6917871833,
-0.4077179432,
-0.6707644463,
0.0453310572,
0.0980064943,
-0.2335778028,
1.0283488035,
0.568426311,
-0.132441029,
-0.0058759204,
-0.3480658531,
-1.1181815863,
1.1303603649,
0.1363064647,
-1.0294618607,
0.0423845202,
-0.4980764687,
0.5488010645,
0.087335676,
0.4826774299,
-0.1696433723,
0.1995057017,
0.020334566,
-0.481139034,
0.2717169821,
-0.1708142161,
-0.1919536889,
0.6986769438,
-0.5892435908,
0.7793040276,
-0.5219666958,
-0.2969410121,
0.1119513512,
0.543122828,
0.373182267,
0.6495121121,
0.6846666336,
0.9198459387,
0.8997024298,
-0.0419132896,
0.6950157881,
-0.1414383501,
0.5442336798,
1.4214429855,
-0.4523936808,
0.5840988755,
0.7289885283,
-0.2558994591,
0.292352587,
0.6345940232,
-0.6849325895,
0.7272989154,
0.6781210303,
-0.3341012895,
-0.0798908323,
-0.2280233949,
-0.4987166524,
0.1067002788,
0.0839735046,
-0.3525789082,
-0.5047614574,
0.0020633608,
0.0215175711,
-0.2758482993,
-0.1618484855,
0.7280592918,
0.2930422425,
-0.5546247363,
0.2183311433,
0.0131878015,
0.9640654325,
-0.2531395555,
-0.2129940987,
0.1941548884,
0.1627910137,
-0.4471544623,
-0.3522467911,
0.2395892143,
0.0195403881,
-0.0108877309,
-0.0922842845,
0.8057143092,
-0.3324260712,
-0.5171368122,
0.4264751971,
0.4632763863,
0.3777832091,
-0.1276303381,
-0.3896006644,
-0.5825477839,
-0.1655964404,
-0.3149628341,
0.2477439344,
0.4071036577,
-0.1861712486,
0.5161550641,
0.6074130535,
0.5994852185,
-0.0787041709,
0.423538208,
0.8301879764,
-0.7117488384,
-0.2577974796,
-0.8403305411,
0.0890818983,
-0.3866711557,
-0.4157766104,
0.7657604218,
0.6755359769,
1.2224831581,
0.1657175124,
0.5577017069,
-0.4186987877,
0.8141410947,
-0.1214154437,
0.4437326193,
-0.5027261376,
0.1995869279,
-0.5394017696,
-1.1318544149,
-0.5809960961,
0.7200348377,
-0.7740473151,
0.4187620282,
0.21468696,
0.8141919971,
-0.2705574036,
0.0475493483,
0.0699711442,
0.0458765514,
0.2418575436,
0.4390398562,
0.7765791416,
-0.6690451503,
0.271889478,
-0.7919249535,
0.1929791421,
-0.0647817701,
-1.0874733925,
-0.7833878994,
-0.2071714103,
-0.6607919335,
-0.2715357244,
0.1394805759,
1.0114972591,
1.0427091122,
-1.2982658148,
0.4268276691,
-0.1970083266,
0.0003057469,
-0.1935118735,
-0.2714098096,
0.381759584,
-0.0529489443,
-0.7334004641,
0.0329440273,
-0.1203915849,
0.0563045032,
0.1097438857,
-0.0181244668,
-0.2031802535,
-0.4220698774,
0.3249168098,
0.141022414,
-0.2375574112,
-0.2798517644,
-0.3101028204,
-0.3314846158,
-0.004061406,
0.3105200231,
-0.9406650662,
0.3943624794,
0.2423947901,
0.6676405668,
0.6407313347,
0.4069277346,
0.0287973974,
-0.7028856277,
-0.1394187361,
0.5025972724,
0.1722731292,
0.620960176,
-0.6208438277,
0.510238111,
0.2370871753,
-0.4936447144,
-0.6713662744,
-0.1660976261,
-0.9211807847,
0.0651280433,
1.1643948555,
-0.0475437567,
0.1651593149,
-0.105052568,
-0.0897957906,
0.4022167325,
-0.5349422693,
0.867125392,
0.5171160698,
-0.3313650489,
0.2097937316,
-0.7345852256,
0.2808720171,
0.3292730749,
-0.6385367513,
-0.5058028102,
0.4610990286,
0.6469430327,
0.3028736711,
0.8128317595,
-0.0976039991,
-0.1681676358,
-0.0510295033,
0.2330033928,
0.1012694761,
-0.3855487704,
-0.3875081837,
0.1939220279,
-0.1418530047,
-0.2389951944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13140v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13140v1 | Extrapolating Multilingual Understanding Models as Multilingual Generators | 2023-05-22T15:33:21 | 2023-05-22T15:33:21 | Bohong Wu, Fei Yuan, Hai Zhao, Lei Li, Jingjing Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual understanding models (or encoder-based), pre-trained via masked
language modeling, have achieved promising results on many language
understanding tasks (e.g., mBERT). However, these non-autoregressive (NAR)
models still struggle to generate high-quality texts compared with
autoregressive (AR) models. Considering that encoder-based models have the
advantage of efficient generation and self-correction abilities, this paper
explores methods to empower multilingual understanding models the generation
abilities to get a unified model. Specifically, we start from a multilingual
encoder (XLM-R) and propose a \textbf{S}emantic-\textbf{G}uided
\textbf{A}lignment-then-Denoising (SGA) approach to adapt an encoder to a
multilingual generator with a small number of new parameters. Experiments show
that the proposed approach is an effective adaption method, outperforming
widely-used initialization-based methods with gains of 9.4 BLEU on machine
translation, 8.1 Rouge-L on question generation, and 5.5 METEOR on story
generation on XLM-R$_{large}$. On the other hand, we observe that XLM-R is
still inferior to mBART in supervised settings despite better results on
zero-shot settings, indicating that more exploration is required to make
understanding models strong generators. | [
-0.4999728799,
-0.5672938824,
0.507152319,
0.2101505846,
-0.292227,
0.1236652955,
-0.3282439411,
-0.3806226552,
0.1595012993,
0.4945198298,
-0.4088624716,
-0.1367444247,
-0.4443000257,
0.3509262502,
-0.16229406,
0.9230712056,
-0.0672968701,
0.0012242447,
-0.0646267682,
-0.2969313264,
-0.4593134522,
-0.7751477957,
-0.5805446506,
-0.45795241,
0.350419879,
0.2948318422,
0.6235525608,
0.6628862023,
0.0222511701,
0.2959291339,
-0.0371023379,
0.2674603164,
-0.3353997469,
0.2137436122,
-0.0902934968,
-0.4894556999,
-0.3121666312,
-0.2724588215,
0.6342660189,
0.6471440792,
-0.2870600224,
0.1809369326,
0.2240197212,
0.4436930716,
-0.3828764856,
0.262050271,
-0.7706122398,
0.1537646055,
0.2703506649,
-0.3515414298,
-0.6091712117,
0.1758054793,
-0.4097163081,
-0.5873814821,
0.4391820431,
-0.0105226608,
0.7034764886,
0.1831512153,
-0.6021179557,
-0.2987449765,
-0.861137867,
0.763817966,
-0.7319799662,
0.5947911143,
0.1703482419,
0.4053662121,
0.0580002591,
-0.5165991187,
-0.4257141352,
0.018268751,
-0.168860063,
0.4499815106,
-0.2752995789,
-0.0793514848,
0.1956162304,
0.2814336121,
-0.4673239291,
0.1888596565,
-0.2905042768,
-0.022282429,
0.5954602957,
-0.0172272753,
0.2536749244,
-0.3390684724,
-0.1774953008,
-0.0868100747,
-0.7219521999,
-0.1205031201,
0.3830381334,
0.3895240724,
0.0527059063,
0.3826700747,
0.0173280872,
0.8584846854,
0.3290837109,
0.0267834906,
0.1704490334,
-0.3543861508,
-0.2048374861,
-0.1497130096,
0.6087554097,
0.0872017071,
0.1885975897,
-0.2911267281,
-0.2580143809,
-0.1302690506,
0.0883013532,
-0.8640733957,
-0.2796479762,
-0.00678067,
-0.4470740259,
-0.0139045417,
-0.2015165687,
-0.7810583115,
-0.1244398877,
-0.515514791,
0.466717422,
-0.4365864694,
-0.4571483135,
-0.0577799901,
0.107102491,
0.0940860882,
0.168872565,
-1.0861432552,
0.0688329265,
0.2255290598,
0.7363634706,
0.3176004887,
-0.5083786249,
-0.5176724195,
0.2524465919,
-0.2801892459,
0.7115520835,
-0.3577955663,
-0.2047717869,
-0.2161999643,
-0.0488107391,
-0.4158398509,
-0.2183249742,
0.1772352755,
-0.4372918606,
0.1504351795,
-0.0767801628,
-0.5636336803,
-0.41181463,
0.0549677871,
-0.5313262343,
0.5931513906,
-0.0787197724,
-0.3733641505,
0.3240013719,
-0.6443218589,
-0.2359642237,
-0.036393486,
-0.1454023421,
-0.2138351053,
0.3317511082,
0.8161917925,
0.5888846517,
-0.0852128267,
0.3984338045,
-0.0671983361,
0.1969212443,
0.2323691994,
-0.6853380799,
0.7049411535,
0.4208118021,
-0.181670174,
-0.0148323607,
-0.7981880307,
0.1604286134,
0.1329578459,
-0.1006634161,
-0.1853254586,
-0.1260667294,
0.0600914396,
0.5928231478,
-0.030473996,
-0.4080968201,
-0.092768833,
-0.2896930575,
0.4792972207,
0.6158484817,
-0.0101724826,
0.4516920447,
-0.0177986063,
0.9074561596,
-0.0171312653,
-0.0259024315,
-0.7822597623,
-0.3766265512,
-0.7768133283,
-0.1708930582,
0.3375920653,
0.3198882341,
-0.7873541713,
0.139807567,
-0.2738209665,
-0.5339571834,
-0.7339187264,
0.4054620266,
0.5967405438,
0.3665906489,
0.3722268343,
-0.136209771,
-0.4893757403,
-0.6756701469,
-0.5495328903,
-0.076692529,
0.0482986793,
0.2655080855,
0.3085070252,
-0.0839744955,
0.8148447275,
-0.273537308,
-0.0153970364,
-0.542981267,
0.1425898671,
0.2108745724,
0.453427285,
0.7462164164,
-0.8084970117,
-0.6237434149,
0.1701560467,
-0.873737514,
-0.1344254464,
-0.3883546889,
-0.0122259567,
0.1791106462,
0.6017244458,
-0.3608513772,
0.1871944964,
0.8389866948,
-0.4226249158,
0.3669868112,
-0.500100553,
0.1452045739,
-1.4370396137,
-0.0388143919,
-0.0373891592,
-0.3210872114,
-1.0214912891,
0.5141646862,
0.2792176604,
-0.3269498944,
-0.3148116469,
0.625595808,
-0.9653588533,
-0.1318820715,
-0.2353643179,
0.2225236446,
0.3423360884,
0.4610448182,
0.1384242475,
0.5237941742,
0.4602638483,
-0.6815553308,
0.2328196466,
0.3245915473,
-0.1211186349,
0.3906099498,
-0.5054901242,
0.3270736933,
-0.403570354,
0.1517365426,
-0.6656190753,
-0.1460382789,
-0.0136849014,
-0.5239921808,
0.6025608778,
-0.5683674216,
-0.3960886002,
-0.1442836076,
0.1347830743,
0.4039888084,
0.3868772984,
-1.04200387,
1.010679245,
0.246117726,
-0.4292938411,
-0.5473891497,
-0.7565626502,
0.3523819149,
-0.2535239756,
-0.6530652642,
0.1851323545,
-0.3157723546,
-0.2158717066,
-0.2397531867,
0.2648127079,
-0.09657076,
-0.0021570961,
-0.0324699916,
0.0001876686,
-0.3084493279,
0.1637795269,
0.3249837458,
-0.2068071216,
-0.0888411254,
-0.1341402084,
0.4895334244,
-0.0806377903,
-0.4912900329,
0.0129078384,
0.5667870641,
0.4161681235,
-0.4778197706,
0.8176320791,
0.5783350468,
-0.2581974268,
-0.1345888227,
-0.4637554586,
-0.2763682902,
-0.4465041459,
0.4776038229,
-0.6665013433,
-0.6524042487,
0.7547542453,
0.1879232526,
0.2445414662,
0.5793589354,
0.5534338355,
0.2978407443,
1.3627494574,
0.6678051353,
0.1748114973,
0.4004758596,
-0.0961789712,
0.1672306657,
-0.8690000176,
-0.0582397617,
-0.3928349018,
0.0774762034,
-0.4905467331,
-0.2553729713,
0.199695155,
0.3373725712,
0.1431714892,
0.3329788446,
-0.2264374346,
0.5030971169,
0.3964495957,
-0.1554280668,
0.3273223937,
0.2268703729,
-0.1647583097,
-0.1646885872,
-1.1597858667,
-0.388025701,
1.1177923679,
0.2037192881,
0.6747370362,
0.2844031751,
0.7434921861,
-0.2447481006,
0.4299656451,
-0.4704685807,
0.1425856352,
-0.1181316227,
-0.454836309,
-0.2137158066,
-0.5726454258,
-0.9051691294,
0.7377985716,
-0.0402878746,
-0.5919305086,
0.3876581788,
0.3775532246,
-0.2507064939,
0.4265835881,
-0.930978477,
0.7655604482,
-0.2304072827,
-0.0947372764,
-0.0141810887,
-0.3391816318,
0.2702101469,
-0.362565726,
0.619081378,
0.1594572961,
0.3240270019,
0.4083834887,
-0.2246878892,
0.7322048545,
-0.3569992185,
-0.3232426047,
0.1965622008,
0.1801886261,
0.4786434472,
0.1276382506,
-0.2843315601,
0.1313795745,
-0.2027369142,
-0.2927576303,
-0.8377233744,
0.5618688464,
-0.7026313543,
-0.4975953102,
-0.0929090679,
-0.6317920685,
-0.0196818449,
-0.0133794378,
0.4942744672,
0.8037102818,
-0.1077687964,
0.0246008821,
0.2460855544,
-0.2903126478,
0.5383791327,
0.7523556948,
-0.5756032467,
-0.4294074476,
0.9424126744,
0.2692656517,
0.4757573605,
0.2758943439,
0.1184294969,
-0.4074664414,
-0.4656704068,
-0.9898234606,
0.1163032204,
-0.9984160066,
-0.3512601852,
-0.9541084766,
-0.27224648,
-0.4735784829,
-0.2310017496,
-0.2629021704,
-0.5458993316,
-0.3974497914,
-0.2787825167,
0.4189654291,
0.699036479,
-0.5852609873,
0.2969250381,
-0.9055995941,
0.3773275912,
0.291833967,
-0.0071021738,
0.07679151,
-0.9250754714,
-0.6360368729,
0.2212216854,
-0.2215642035,
-0.8638277054,
0.8762012124,
0.5974327922,
0.6340926886,
0.3843176365,
-0.1605629921,
0.8884430528,
-0.5311929584,
0.6105343699,
0.1315522343,
-1.0021752119,
0.4599069059,
-0.1979643106,
0.4246827066,
0.2593416274,
-0.0191058759,
-0.6072038412,
-0.6340939403,
-0.5833383799,
-0.8250293136,
0.6074851751,
0.3331669569,
0.2916582525,
0.0485147759,
0.527100563,
0.3352579772,
0.0207473543,
-0.9395654798,
-0.3393178582,
-0.6425301433,
-0.1869092584,
-0.5917791724,
-0.2445205301,
0.1676963121,
-0.1643070728,
0.7651441097,
-0.4251531959,
0.2668938041,
0.1321702302,
-0.5499061942,
-0.096695967,
0.5027496815,
0.397695154,
0.7817569971,
0.1034098789,
0.2055770606,
0.2083159834,
-0.2248613834,
0.2986645401,
0.3833477795,
-0.3149589002,
0.1233555079,
0.2504663467,
0.9301236272,
0.0912901163,
-0.2878824472,
0.1771639585,
-0.1165119559,
-0.0484097376,
-0.0913483724,
-0.0706666484,
0.0687403381,
0.1462215036,
0.4061101675,
0.0151886987,
-0.0004346865,
-0.406254828,
0.1130906418,
0.2684885859,
-0.3802167475,
-0.5868775845,
0.6521040797,
0.0989908203,
-0.135491699,
0.3581022024,
-0.3495055735,
-0.6002450585,
0.6470873952,
1.0787929296,
0.8328675032,
-0.6717845798,
0.2689742446,
0.4361128211,
0.4363185167,
0.0885474384,
0.2104908675,
-0.0204036701,
-1.0145933628,
-0.7246938348,
-0.6404395103,
-0.2464507073,
-0.0532735772,
-0.933876276,
-0.1129917577,
0.0137577467,
0.1751165986,
0.1068460345,
-0.2885807753,
-0.7292540073,
0.2184126824,
-0.0254474673,
0.4987432957,
-0.8552638888,
0.6380211711,
0.6982780695,
-0.3706003726,
-0.7804384232,
-0.187805891,
-0.1859744638,
-0.6461946368,
0.4315202534,
0.1684516221,
-0.0953851715,
0.3650589585,
-0.213602826,
-0.8991013169,
0.874740541,
0.7384623885,
-0.5689105988,
0.1888358593,
-0.0023132833,
0.5394250154,
-0.5729826689,
0.3637941778,
0.2494165301,
0.4499812722,
-0.2043855041,
-0.7066603303,
-0.0620099418,
-0.4772248268,
-0.0164725129,
0.2180258036,
-0.5956148505,
0.9386345148,
-0.3728812039,
-0.2510468662,
-0.0480076671,
0.6854091883,
0.1757389754,
0.1243862957,
0.3476470411,
0.3828774989,
0.5930582285,
0.2395488173,
0.9833010435,
-0.5335570574,
0.3793070912,
1.2510756254,
-0.0882014781,
0.5674400926,
0.3986926973,
0.1453647912,
0.3876492977,
0.488404125,
0.0010827805,
0.3603006005,
-0.2156191617,
-0.1838366538,
-0.4620202482,
0.1428804249,
-0.356516391,
0.5628290772,
0.3755702376,
-0.574932158,
-0.2141251266,
0.271903038,
0.0288600568,
0.1736168116,
-0.4236170948,
0.8501929045,
0.2186386287,
-0.6136606932,
0.5206095576,
0.2457728237,
0.3747459948,
-0.3699205816,
0.0346772447,
-0.263492316,
0.1811526865,
-0.0514484793,
-0.4387008548,
0.3119831383,
0.2160975486,
-0.2188068777,
-0.4797335863,
0.7701565027,
-0.6539413333,
-0.9000199437,
0.519808948,
0.9431095719,
0.134847343,
-0.1617875993,
-0.5910239816,
-0.3744454384,
0.1539127231,
-0.3531802595,
0.3055188358,
0.4966016412,
0.2868694365,
0.5302907825,
0.6417866945,
-0.0601720177,
0.2160669267,
0.3223742545,
0.500338316,
-0.6316498518,
-0.5750585198,
-0.8866951466,
0.2724661827,
0.1517720819,
-0.1278750002,
1.0468604565,
0.4406587481,
0.7421837449,
-0.0713312924,
0.8828909397,
0.204991743,
0.2699842751,
-0.771165669,
0.887064755,
-0.5826089978,
0.0196563844,
-0.3508042991,
-0.9287421107,
-0.3595658541,
0.5577118397,
0.0961143896,
0.2305900007,
0.4156380892,
0.716632545,
-0.2174111903,
-0.0719144493,
0.6237560511,
0.4135727584,
0.4140366614,
0.3794102371,
0.8204895854,
-0.4211232662,
0.611815393,
-0.2023197562,
-0.1774555296,
0.0205524322,
-0.8059082031,
-0.9792900085,
-0.5442159176,
-0.2136231959,
-0.2216394842,
-0.071626775,
0.7689438462,
0.7253105044,
-0.7170963287,
-0.1893220693,
-0.2130538821,
-0.0257376209,
-0.3370646536,
-0.1504749656,
0.318908751,
-0.4400206804,
-0.7160165906,
0.6947942972,
0.1579428613,
0.2125720829,
-0.3683075011,
-0.2642895579,
0.1277861893,
0.1609326899,
0.7164378166,
0.2799658179,
-0.6081406474,
-0.1073910296,
-0.0239453129,
0.4521328509,
0.1042708755,
0.689029634,
-0.751540184,
0.7517476082,
0.0467746109,
0.357547909,
0.6803030372,
-0.1494930238,
0.971062541,
-0.7645599842,
0.120625712,
-0.0699625611,
0.6983377337,
0.5744001269,
-0.3389548659,
0.303250581,
-0.1312301457,
-0.4313726723,
-0.743398428,
0.5399568677,
-0.3267576694,
-0.184812963,
1.1775234938,
-0.3745479882,
-0.1992743462,
-0.2240715176,
-0.057718128,
0.4068985283,
-0.2579310238,
0.6833891869,
0.5060645938,
-0.0800535455,
-0.4382423759,
-0.421294421,
0.237816453,
0.4013956785,
-0.8508409262,
0.3428515792,
0.4298468828,
0.209054485,
0.1845762134,
0.4260877371,
-0.0156652723,
0.0885363221,
0.0380114205,
0.184975028,
-0.2858704031,
-0.4193308949,
-0.7712850571,
-0.026694065,
0.0322197489,
0.2203517407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13137v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13137v2 | EMNS /Imz/ Corpus: An emotive single-speaker dataset for narrative storytelling in games, television and graphic novels | 2023-05-22T15:32:32 | 2023-05-25T16:17:24 | Kari Ali Noriy, Xiaosong Yang, Jian Jun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | The increasing adoption of text-to-speech technologies has led to a growing
demand for natural and emotive voices that adapt to a conversation's context
and emotional tone. The Emotive Narrative Storytelling (EMNS) corpus is a
unique speech dataset created to enhance conversations' expressiveness and
emotive quality in interactive narrative-driven systems. The corpus consists of
a 2.3-hour recording featuring a female speaker delivering labelled utterances.
It encompasses eight acted emotional states, evenly distributed with a variance
of 0.68%, along with expressiveness levels and natural language descriptions
with word emphasis labels. The evaluation of audio samples from different
datasets revealed that the EMNS corpus achieved the highest average scores in
accurately conveying emotions and demonstrating expressiveness. It outperformed
other datasets in conveying shared emotions and achieved comparable levels of
genuineness. A classification task confirmed the accurate representation of
intended emotions in the corpus, with participants recognising the recordings
as genuine and expressive. Additionally, the availability of the dataset
collection tool under the Apache 2.0 License simplifies remote speech data
collection for researchers. | [
-0.547293067,
-0.7828921676,
0.2672629952,
0.2654292285,
-0.2732064128,
0.2909654975,
-0.3573138118,
-0.3890451193,
0.8760947585,
0.5935974121,
-0.9342235327,
-0.7154089808,
-0.5709438324,
0.473680228,
-0.6840239167,
1.0256710052,
0.2040192783,
-0.2736442387,
0.1177604124,
-0.2691635191,
-0.1103819385,
-0.5423321128,
-0.5910437107,
-0.1813500673,
0.7802658677,
0.5398141146,
0.9070385098,
0.8584621549,
0.3898889422,
0.2568914294,
0.1026679948,
0.1924085021,
-0.492228955,
0.6810597777,
0.0213637147,
-0.2377633899,
-0.2076123804,
-0.3561343551,
0.3957796991,
0.4236035049,
-0.2876766622,
0.4224311113,
-0.0256537106,
0.6620649695,
-0.3916258514,
-0.0170578659,
-0.1229137033,
0.468968153,
-0.4083452225,
-0.4962717891,
-0.4300028086,
-0.1765672863,
0.2711029947,
-0.6661505103,
0.2527925074,
0.1659298539,
0.6075106263,
0.2632831633,
-0.4164655507,
-0.573548317,
-0.8018047214,
0.6290621161,
-0.5861104727,
-0.0801766589,
0.3596783578,
0.2329557389,
0.2312904745,
-0.7081143856,
-0.5950089097,
-0.0003764419,
0.0866860673,
0.2769722939,
-0.7515041232,
0.0952372774,
0.2721688449,
0.0417928062,
-0.6877561808,
0.2183540463,
-0.2089528292,
0.0210316554,
0.723721981,
0.7450485229,
0.5369426608,
-0.4572096467,
-0.2876948118,
-0.1264974475,
-0.5885632038,
0.0679687783,
0.7906680107,
0.6711847782,
-0.4669707716,
0.6984098554,
-0.2742435038,
0.7988092899,
-0.1768262833,
-0.0336077772,
0.4256167412,
-0.2254970819,
0.0062627294,
0.5291206241,
0.8009450436,
0.4088658392,
0.2737215757,
-0.0873892978,
0.0265390519,
0.1179124862,
0.4206342995,
-0.7498524189,
0.1042377055,
0.3332080841,
-0.7823014855,
-0.3220585287,
-0.0330551639,
-1.10516119,
-0.508938849,
-0.5790572762,
0.0816481635,
-0.3839812279,
-0.4706908166,
-0.2140656114,
-0.430277884,
0.0006553598,
0.2437772453,
-1.2483968735,
0.3194889426,
0.7033067942,
1.0792022943,
-0.0565313995,
-0.074784942,
0.0765841454,
-0.0070866705,
-0.244049713,
0.8372601271,
-0.6302384138,
-0.1063319296,
0.2249322981,
-0.0082971854,
-0.0558498353,
-0.1550430655,
0.818005085,
-0.0762792379,
-0.1772081256,
-0.1737384796,
-0.4515161812,
-0.2400873005,
0.2448782325,
-0.7552766204,
0.7823581696,
0.064464733,
-0.5905221105,
0.0604473948,
-0.7334096432,
-0.2329563498,
-0.0631026402,
-0.1688809097,
0.0048296242,
0.0919179618,
0.1052543819,
0.3961143494,
-0.3990425169,
0.1199158207,
-0.2154694498,
-0.3519537151,
0.5137293935,
-0.5442578197,
0.5302093029,
0.5440856218,
-0.382188648,
0.0034002566,
-0.8264315724,
-0.0079959631,
0.1310578585,
0.1304764003,
-0.2871047258,
0.0891572833,
0.2349613309,
0.3310129344,
-0.206503287,
-0.9960339069,
-0.3639279604,
-0.5772053599,
0.3713554144,
0.4383239746,
-0.0067035905,
0.0829065517,
-0.4899033606,
0.7827281952,
-0.0221911222,
-0.0180210732,
-0.6644057631,
-0.5377081633,
-0.4938865304,
-0.1443571001,
0.0810271204,
0.6784049273,
-0.661857605,
0.3803834021,
-0.3956512213,
-0.7020674348,
-0.7202467918,
-0.1169900224,
0.5022741556,
0.4758861065,
0.064685218,
0.1648211479,
-0.6064601541,
-1.1056011915,
-0.1874326169,
-0.0489012152,
-0.2595338523,
0.2901860476,
0.1360540241,
0.2008912563,
0.9765318632,
-0.1230843216,
-0.3156288266,
-0.2906444073,
0.3062393665,
0.2488993704,
0.2844429016,
0.4974423051,
-0.9549105167,
-0.4599401951,
-0.0691102073,
-0.9854818583,
-0.269077152,
-0.0896814987,
0.1652902514,
0.0895103365,
0.131431073,
-0.2544794083,
0.5066282153,
0.9025807977,
-0.7718354464,
0.2965546548,
0.0203998145,
0.5595360994,
-1.0658878088,
-0.1090556458,
-0.1210078448,
0.1044995561,
-0.6326187849,
-0.5181471109,
-0.3572908938,
-0.3400047123,
-0.6815468073,
0.5575703382,
-0.4158326685,
-0.2373618186,
-0.1563533843,
0.6682698131,
0.1783627272,
0.3991617262,
-0.2030647248,
0.4499905407,
0.4596707225,
-0.3777565658,
0.9099425077,
0.9073982835,
-0.2602114975,
0.7394545078,
-0.4128333032,
0.1819959134,
-0.1776037514,
0.1336734742,
-0.9622216225,
-0.1917058825,
0.1010020971,
-0.6341056228,
0.1568563432,
0.0880770981,
-0.6038764119,
-0.2284277678,
-0.0019863315,
0.0657079816,
0.1800783873,
-0.7244372368,
0.8742942214,
0.5605589151,
-0.6374598742,
-0.5347782969,
-1.1367194653,
0.3907210231,
-0.301894933,
-1.0134308338,
0.3405969441,
0.1268244982,
-0.3523741066,
0.3007986248,
0.334315449,
0.007634555,
-0.2067413926,
0.6810449958,
-0.0366836675,
-0.4559780359,
0.4758786261,
0.2627579868,
-0.2785491347,
-0.0090585453,
0.4760145247,
0.436062485,
-0.1761901975,
-0.369946748,
-0.4674854577,
0.702801466,
0.3739488423,
0.0405207239,
0.8321495652,
0.647857666,
-0.3027491868,
-0.284783572,
-0.2851744592,
-0.1501849592,
-0.4190985262,
0.2963534594,
-0.5621355772,
-0.9715386033,
0.9626635909,
-0.0713876411,
-0.0707177222,
0.6010383964,
0.6164331436,
-0.2049353421,
1.0683525801,
0.0779012665,
0.3042489886,
0.552847743,
0.2145203948,
0.0165804867,
-0.7801616788,
-0.3261369765,
-0.6667641997,
-0.5904015899,
-0.4639278352,
0.1056162342,
0.0118530048,
-0.6039298177,
-0.3481265306,
0.1549930423,
-0.5237198472,
0.400306046,
0.3731970489,
0.2850615084,
0.1957953274,
0.0633513853,
0.2287583053,
-0.3858155608,
-0.6055745482,
-0.8057306409,
1.2062240839,
0.3798280954,
0.6421455741,
0.5155022144,
0.4766322076,
0.7967197299,
0.1991248578,
-0.6603168249,
0.247195676,
-0.349314332,
-0.7818041444,
-0.5518246889,
-0.2751990259,
-1.1371849775,
0.1970618963,
-0.4358163178,
-0.9554982781,
0.1850810051,
-0.1103169471,
-0.6202762723,
0.3677988946,
-0.6269969344,
0.9571811557,
-0.0587171204,
-0.1194988713,
-0.1780154109,
-0.910826683,
0.153544873,
-0.0699653476,
0.1586301327,
-0.5439324975,
-0.041474089,
0.9418714643,
-0.2603865266,
0.9235808849,
0.020489268,
0.3826659322,
0.6819818616,
0.2285524756,
0.2365545481,
-0.1428192854,
-0.4267272055,
0.2327866554,
0.1994419694,
-0.145935908,
-0.701164782,
0.5917008519,
-0.7353821993,
-0.1508518904,
-0.3289191723,
-0.4478598833,
-0.1858151108,
-0.1184427738,
0.1318616569,
1.0270943642,
-0.7761583328,
0.5081154108,
0.4478984475,
-0.4627983868,
0.4415014088,
0.4589046836,
-0.1210197285,
-0.4654866457,
0.608188808,
0.0868722647,
0.2814990878,
0.2856226563,
0.1550130248,
-0.3064125776,
-0.1639681906,
-0.6932439208,
-0.0522716492,
-0.8461238742,
-0.3778399825,
-0.9010494947,
-0.1686341316,
-0.2342445701,
-0.1815225631,
-0.4574213922,
-0.5445424914,
-0.312674433,
-0.5480201244,
0.6677006483,
0.8448113203,
-0.1989612877,
0.5833114386,
-1.0862852335,
0.3187302649,
-0.2176329494,
0.2515330613,
-0.2161976695,
-0.7453532219,
-0.1935250014,
0.0683691502,
-0.2106615156,
-1.1576170921,
1.0189167261,
0.3839650452,
0.4588754177,
0.4168787599,
0.2685635388,
0.3727960885,
-0.3086999953,
0.8244575262,
0.1700429469,
-0.9540675282,
0.5796722174,
-0.6375716925,
0.141151756,
0.4796251655,
0.0977788493,
-0.8911566138,
-0.3462752998,
-0.8011843562,
-0.8038156629,
1.0254899263,
0.2398757488,
0.364423424,
-0.0733277425,
0.0900430009,
0.2823189497,
0.2185937166,
-0.200981617,
-0.6034243107,
-0.1217375919,
-0.6417555809,
-0.2245458812,
-0.3285658658,
-0.3883560896,
0.0916133299,
0.4386754632,
-0.1587534696,
0.665525496,
0.2876051962,
0.1338106543,
-0.2683216035,
0.2366649806,
0.502517283,
0.3303076327,
-0.2949468791,
0.2591612935,
-0.0185926128,
-0.4142278135,
0.0776563808,
-0.0140774092,
0.0194047559,
0.3039800227,
0.2736366689,
1.1906708479,
0.3749982119,
-0.8545014858,
0.6000459194,
-0.1902602017,
-0.1575487703,
-0.6882050633,
-0.3285413682,
0.056811884,
0.4209937453,
0.323248148,
0.1002195477,
0.3123184144,
-0.4334328473,
0.2494780719,
-0.2665668428,
-0.5341095924,
-0.3224059045,
0.2132756561,
0.2580438554,
-0.3827653825,
0.825096786,
0.0040029725,
-0.3296326101,
0.9376629591,
0.954726398,
0.9713122249,
-0.2147836983,
0.6189091802,
0.5122177005,
0.3748793602,
0.216966629,
0.3160255849,
0.1096798405,
-0.944691062,
0.051770851,
-0.5934442282,
-0.8461991549,
-0.5077050328,
-0.7908252478,
0.0836290717,
-0.2233988047,
-0.3203930259,
0.1031741276,
-0.4237834513,
-0.6998963356,
0.2427170277,
0.5864765644,
0.6550403833,
-1.0856686831,
0.4275905788,
0.1552249491,
-0.4840990603,
-0.8493051529,
-0.5976302624,
0.4850030839,
-0.4546324313,
0.6213551164,
0.0609576479,
0.0423945561,
0.0927132517,
-0.3740252256,
-1.1381160021,
1.0436918736,
0.3790591359,
-0.4619502425,
0.1958238035,
0.2916312814,
0.8103578091,
-0.9137315154,
0.590742588,
0.4751865268,
0.5640660524,
0.1261973083,
-0.7062729597,
0.0716457739,
-0.4402783811,
-0.2963030636,
0.1746766716,
-0.5747597218,
0.65944314,
-0.0985483751,
-0.466917634,
-0.0260521639,
0.69837147,
0.2404207736,
0.6677991748,
0.3352399468,
0.2742682397,
0.7487520576,
-0.5077841282,
1.2486364841,
-0.1770486534,
0.0343238525,
1.13230896,
-0.1644344032,
0.9870334864,
0.3522123694,
-0.1117411554,
0.6270791888,
0.7806634307,
-0.0723627135,
0.2648069263,
0.2370581329,
-0.4040075243,
-0.0487331487,
-0.4542039335,
-0.1422499567,
0.7199127078,
0.7310608625,
-0.5940948129,
-0.1124686077,
0.5448126197,
-0.1214847416,
0.2457485944,
-0.1401965171,
0.7600972056,
0.2609213293,
-0.3968396187,
-0.1100825816,
-0.3703218699,
0.5142361522,
-0.7081070542,
-0.0943027437,
0.0885310173,
0.0384605713,
-0.5050339699,
-1.1036504507,
0.6648945808,
0.1952169389,
-0.1827577055,
-0.3820851445,
0.6851703525,
-0.5011068583,
-0.1536383927,
0.5435787439,
0.6349105835,
0.4482219815,
-0.0805870965,
-0.6805580854,
0.343133837,
-0.1263981909,
-0.5225473642,
0.2123804241,
0.7644517422,
0.3867533207,
0.5559857488,
0.5856052637,
0.0714678243,
0.1236242503,
0.3679583967,
0.5218837857,
-0.853726089,
-0.7886286378,
-0.6730555296,
0.4781660736,
-0.0295603741,
-0.6321294308,
0.810079217,
0.5685479641,
0.3525513113,
-0.1122300923,
0.736646831,
-0.2200584859,
0.9292983413,
-0.387919426,
0.7090611458,
-0.219064638,
-0.0904902667,
-0.3288608491,
-0.7833381295,
-0.227139771,
0.3107486367,
-0.0402261838,
-0.2418934852,
0.6244770885,
0.8010715246,
0.4050328732,
0.7402297854,
0.5707926154,
-0.0210073702,
0.0324444845,
0.4028546214,
1.1464911699,
-0.3306619525,
0.4017226696,
-0.2122845203,
-0.1483362019,
-0.0270582698,
-0.7886937261,
-0.702323854,
-0.7455847263,
-0.2806980908,
-0.5556909442,
0.0395177342,
1.333522439,
0.3194443285,
-0.73917979,
-0.1840280592,
0.401096642,
-0.2498877048,
-0.166263178,
-0.2583928108,
0.303815186,
0.0576938801,
-0.6555824876,
0.4941470325,
0.3380357921,
-0.1075450405,
0.0234726388,
-0.2147475183,
0.0193722378,
0.2295910716,
0.4018974304,
0.5201098323,
-0.6637289524,
-0.1652951986,
-0.0499637388,
-0.2680733204,
0.1521513015,
0.6726161838,
-0.4793043137,
0.8884986639,
0.3984212875,
0.6934167743,
0.6999956965,
0.0727607086,
0.5884551406,
-0.7943303585,
0.1952408254,
0.4101858139,
0.2905569077,
0.3340365887,
-0.4184319377,
0.6217600703,
0.0057018935,
-0.477651298,
-0.6985189915,
-0.0797870159,
-1.3506805897,
0.1369836628,
1.2476545572,
-0.2723275125,
-0.2904540002,
-0.3407770693,
-0.2567021549,
0.5112805367,
-0.6579759121,
0.3805007935,
0.7655656934,
-0.4169548452,
-0.2160118222,
-0.741645813,
0.3970659077,
0.1596872061,
-0.8754823804,
0.1533823609,
0.5081641078,
-0.1937949508,
0.286742121,
0.4302209616,
-0.2423162311,
0.010908151,
0.6864024401,
0.2955789268,
-0.2433335185,
-0.2318041027,
-0.5249450207,
0.3889336586,
-0.5947788358,
-0.0166810583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13120v1 | Partial Annotation Learning for Biomedical Entity Recognition | 2023-05-22T15:18:38 | 2023-05-22T15:18:38 | Liangping Ding, Giovanni Colavizza, Zhixiong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Motivation: Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a key task to support
biomedical research. In Biomedical Named Entity Recognition (BioNER), obtaining
high-quality expert annotated data is laborious and expensive, leading to the
development of automatic approaches such as distant supervision. However,
manually and automatically generated data often suffer from the unlabeled
entity problem, whereby many entity annotations are missing, degrading the
performance of full annotation NER models. Results: To address this problem, we
systematically study the effectiveness of partial annotation learning methods
for biomedical entity recognition over different simulated scenarios of missing
entity annotations. Furthermore, we propose a TS-PubMedBERT-Partial-CRF partial
annotation learning model. We harmonize 15 biomedical NER corpora encompassing
five entity types to serve as a gold standard and compare against two commonly
used partial annotation learning models, BiLSTM-Partial-CRF and EER-PubMedBERT,
and the state-of-the-art full annotation learning BioNER model PubMedBERT
tagger. Results show that partial annotation learning-based methods can
effectively learn from biomedical corpora with missing entity annotations. Our
proposed model outperforms alternatives and, specifically, the PubMedBERT
tagger by 38% in F1-score under high missing entity rates. The recall of entity
mentions in our model is also competitive with the upper bound on the fully
annotated dataset. | [
-0.2276043296,
-0.6503887773,
0.6566305161,
0.019030435,
-0.3617430627,
0.2921073735,
-0.1523903906,
-0.9522559047,
0.356048882,
0.3360154629,
-0.2018624395,
-0.569832921,
-0.4983508885,
0.8045383096,
0.053156428,
1.2331882715,
-0.0592933819,
0.3359086215,
-0.3630458713,
-0.2665711939,
-0.2572615147,
-0.4352299869,
-0.7759289145,
-0.5902195573,
0.7998977304,
0.1098208353,
0.199466303,
0.6645572186,
0.8624641895,
0.1776829064,
-0.2406922877,
0.1056050956,
-0.3176983297,
-0.0653733164,
-0.3335357606,
-0.2383048683,
-0.5402829051,
-0.140305534,
0.5969740748,
1.0196061134,
0.0654515028,
0.1115144342,
-0.1801964641,
0.5308721066,
-0.2971340716,
0.4009534121,
-0.4403527081,
0.3262897134,
-0.2809351683,
-0.1959242672,
-0.5054590702,
-0.0862059966,
0.5664035082,
-0.807313621,
0.5528510809,
0.1792223901,
1.2271767855,
0.3943396509,
-0.4397933781,
-0.2905717194,
-0.6206119061,
0.4101617038,
-0.2312716544,
0.5492677093,
0.369469136,
0.0737902075,
-0.1254169941,
-0.8378582597,
-0.2882329822,
-0.2341372222,
-0.1699786633,
0.335965842,
-0.2318577915,
0.2545726299,
0.5167856812,
0.2731064856,
-0.4365974963,
-0.0995889753,
-0.6821224689,
-0.241045177,
0.3550907373,
-0.0128204823,
0.0824210197,
-0.2015957385,
-0.6221686602,
0.1240983605,
-0.753498435,
-0.1098951623,
-0.1127891019,
0.2527768612,
0.0033211829,
0.3726101816,
-0.1134121642,
0.5371349454,
0.2158797979,
0.0359874927,
0.8344709277,
-0.4140297472,
-0.3507766128,
0.2470787168,
0.7955650091,
-0.1862047464,
-0.0724505559,
-0.5570424795,
-0.1104828566,
-0.1243614629,
0.1543682516,
-0.6355372667,
-0.6480294466,
0.2003387958,
-0.2734514177,
-0.1093473509,
-0.1848389506,
-1.0136862993,
-0.3900161684,
-0.3634319305,
0.5268402696,
-0.550221622,
0.0392018259,
0.0500800163,
-0.1865085959,
0.2253300399,
0.5028071404,
-0.1758458763,
0.242787689,
0.0824514329,
0.9739381671,
-0.0627902001,
-0.0107848234,
-0.482984215,
0.4929842651,
-0.1362225264,
0.8633626699,
-0.4862846732,
-0.5155293345,
-0.2323018461,
0.3548795879,
-0.1220733896,
-0.5970859528,
0.5147316456,
-0.4400042295,
-0.0329197943,
-0.4235253334,
-0.7964374423,
-0.3182568252,
-0.1999246925,
-0.867559135,
0.7693400979,
0.0037400511,
-1.0169922113,
0.4846469462,
-0.59763062,
-0.5571990013,
0.5033838749,
-0.2293415964,
-0.6934702396,
0.0314936601,
-0.0649915412,
0.4453525543,
-0.1143100634,
0.1924589276,
-0.394351989,
-0.2810757756,
0.3366017044,
0.1638777107,
0.5409513712,
-0.2056348324,
-0.4309026003,
-0.0570608974,
-0.8023054004,
-0.4148873091,
0.1608525515,
-0.4228349328,
-0.4880163968,
-0.123946175,
0.1455625743,
0.165543586,
0.0041067465,
-0.8769354224,
0.0113300942,
-0.5093694925,
0.3141411841,
0.5216519237,
0.3785059154,
0.5152897239,
-0.2581424117,
0.1877376735,
0.3051862121,
-0.1144157946,
0.231962949,
-0.4864630103,
-0.8247656226,
-0.792486012,
1.0286946297,
0.6144951582,
-0.8155615926,
0.359216392,
-0.1505019814,
-0.3923553824,
-0.6505272985,
-0.0725410953,
0.5710147023,
0.9080064297,
0.8446074128,
-0.2303402722,
-0.7965944409,
-1.0602872372,
0.0999537408,
-0.0741450414,
-0.0608898774,
0.2422000617,
0.9034699798,
-0.4404884875,
0.6984675527,
-0.2430206537,
-0.4630063772,
-0.0583607741,
0.1941237003,
-0.0095226737,
0.346390903,
0.3615866005,
-0.8998630047,
-0.2106178254,
0.0172465388,
-0.8590378761,
-0.0114524458,
-0.1335478872,
-0.2721625268,
0.1761002839,
0.0377319865,
-0.6343639493,
0.7015119195,
-0.0014509532,
-0.0313875824,
0.1964879185,
-0.367359221,
-0.0651222095,
-0.8850395083,
0.3265078068,
0.4134843647,
-0.5399466753,
-0.6086824536,
-0.2918285131,
0.3158767223,
0.0489236452,
-0.2875493169,
0.6390001774,
-0.8079959154,
0.129365176,
-0.1593093872,
-0.1844026893,
0.1145452261,
0.2647390962,
0.5316351056,
0.4150272608,
0.5089685917,
-0.6396924257,
-0.0274544973,
0.5155205131,
0.1130469143,
0.2276599109,
-0.8519430757,
0.1529729515,
-0.4750947058,
0.5324525833,
-0.7327761054,
-0.5068872571,
0.5100516677,
-0.3545644283,
0.7519987822,
-0.338414222,
-0.5564892292,
-0.2776351869,
-0.0485740788,
0.1332458258,
0.559374094,
-0.3423663974,
0.6964070201,
0.5468305945,
-0.1229118332,
-0.375311166,
-0.6217318177,
-0.0436370708,
-0.1033939049,
-0.0328731164,
0.6709113121,
0.0911914781,
0.1974244416,
0.250289917,
-0.2833361626,
-0.0089612007,
-0.0653873309,
0.5913013816,
0.5530981421,
0.0129200937,
0.2841227651,
0.1373821348,
-0.1601599902,
-0.2182428092,
0.1164848283,
0.0721471012,
-0.084370859,
-0.0370733812,
-0.3949694335,
0.2423412502,
0.0803217217,
-0.3655102551,
0.7772791982,
0.5252668262,
-0.9803305268,
0.1060743853,
-0.5344978571,
-0.0367515907,
-0.3420489132,
0.3994913399,
-0.1515092254,
-0.7905231118,
0.5174705386,
-0.1989434659,
-0.0954743624,
0.4968824387,
0.4767397642,
-0.2130709291,
0.5828155279,
0.5766993165,
0.3576609194,
0.2889743149,
-0.1295440644,
-0.0412655249,
-0.8791041374,
-0.5944117904,
-0.4090910852,
-0.193812564,
-0.3774027824,
-0.48178792,
0.3687983453,
0.1512319446,
-0.1528119445,
0.4776205122,
-0.5837127566,
0.3027394414,
0.5880311728,
0.6096653342,
0.0975915641,
0.2053139061,
-0.3228796124,
0.0897722766,
-0.4651012123,
-0.5049963593,
1.0580512285,
0.3450183272,
0.2803575099,
-0.0367311127,
1.03259027,
0.1593622118,
0.5278561115,
-0.6960987449,
0.3298349977,
0.1433405727,
-0.7230311036,
0.1257663369,
-0.6606507897,
-0.9235422611,
-0.1373109072,
-0.4626942575,
-0.7202225924,
0.5879917145,
0.0721192658,
-0.5737748146,
0.1540777683,
-0.6791904569,
0.6964086294,
-0.0104087815,
-0.3625252247,
0.3616767526,
-0.9762556553,
-0.0299973302,
-0.4089378417,
0.1625292301,
-0.0713914484,
-0.2198652476,
0.9663841128,
0.0603341684,
0.8994909525,
-0.2917222679,
0.6195054054,
0.0712209716,
-0.072143048,
0.3803022206,
0.3298231959,
0.1642128825,
0.631362617,
0.0117047196,
-0.5070042014,
0.0579546802,
0.3856619,
-0.6869994998,
-0.2926285565,
-0.9952554107,
-0.2148550302,
-0.2255210131,
0.1251862943,
0.4861295223,
0.2446954846,
0.1151812822,
0.0765831098,
1.0394158363,
-0.491345048,
0.3458701968,
0.5324100852,
0.234407708,
-0.8703449965,
0.6910668015,
0.1118055731,
-0.1772463173,
0.54020226,
-0.2864632607,
-0.2044468075,
-0.5067488551,
-0.4292872846,
0.7281453609,
-0.4283539057,
-0.6635130048,
-0.9699283242,
-0.196865648,
-0.2061707377,
0.0576014668,
-0.1839521676,
-0.0209145509,
-0.5545166135,
-0.3523395658,
0.480769366,
0.4721328318,
-0.1965286881,
-0.0071278061,
-0.8578907251,
0.2653046846,
-0.3470290005,
0.0920844823,
-0.2328980565,
-0.4622321129,
-0.1601558924,
0.0021539275,
-0.1117470637,
-1.2636213303,
0.1548477411,
0.3497387469,
0.6622748971,
0.1386466771,
-0.0329736918,
0.7025175691,
-0.812787652,
0.2669478357,
0.2858968973,
-0.534008503,
0.5618122816,
-0.1883905232,
-0.008417462,
0.6552523375,
0.8395696878,
-0.1440058351,
-0.0167784318,
-0.6175861955,
-1.0109333992,
0.5428740382,
0.3137686551,
-0.2804628611,
-0.3489501774,
0.6444827318,
0.335516274,
0.030949153,
-0.7721955776,
-0.4876022935,
0.1347844452,
-0.3312790096,
0.0347077437,
-0.166904673,
-0.0541361235,
-0.4302203953,
0.8695780039,
0.1549902409,
0.6661247611,
0.8062958121,
-0.198867172,
-0.1123404279,
0.10123007,
0.2728535235,
0.3767164648,
-0.3874536455,
-0.0890347064,
0.2088987529,
-0.4438538849,
-0.0246722307,
0.6328975558,
-0.277361095,
0.3593283296,
0.2938494682,
0.7953552604,
0.2817230523,
-0.6076011062,
0.5156074166,
-0.0828526616,
-0.3073621988,
-0.5109246373,
-0.2855875194,
0.2129326612,
0.3498135209,
0.3672186434,
0.3242384195,
0.2693603933,
-0.1217809394,
0.3653305471,
0.0713738725,
-0.7955824137,
-0.5787128806,
0.8126219511,
-0.076889351,
0.0566424839,
0.4548216462,
-0.3717725575,
-0.3900713027,
0.4480551481,
0.5623216629,
0.4727175832,
-0.0458415672,
0.1887261868,
0.456292212,
0.0619636811,
-0.2749356329,
0.1903261244,
0.0612272583,
-0.2398115993,
-0.4664311409,
-0.937354207,
-0.3992776871,
0.0275907665,
-0.7362564206,
0.4011370838,
-0.4106709659,
-0.526699841,
0.6217064857,
0.0458208136,
-0.9818381667,
0.271312505,
0.2508133948,
0.703623414,
-0.7644990683,
0.7120010257,
1.3646523952,
-1.0553597212,
-0.5967776775,
-0.2076203227,
-0.1263318658,
-0.3564267457,
0.8282321095,
0.2003612965,
0.3762103319,
0.038912449,
-0.2212987989,
-0.726334393,
1.1363110542,
0.3249931037,
-0.8110057116,
-0.4009064734,
-0.1667690128,
0.6874831915,
-0.0755145401,
0.2353261262,
0.0881697088,
0.0630360171,
0.257419616,
-0.9812639356,
0.08561147,
-0.1976325959,
-0.2568203807,
0.4648341835,
-0.4224148989,
0.5164368153,
-0.2266224623,
-0.2543368042,
0.1141255125,
0.4898367822,
0.3831032813,
0.7728867531,
0.1313264817,
0.5695847869,
0.9458716512,
-0.0383657813,
0.8111475706,
0.0373370536,
0.5353222489,
0.9879535437,
-0.5938895345,
0.788351655,
0.3875976503,
-0.1613641083,
0.4143381417,
0.8661931753,
-0.0552820638,
0.619977355,
0.2567965686,
-0.4108772874,
-0.3228983879,
-0.0568257719,
-0.4548881054,
0.1879809946,
0.4056799412,
-0.6728501916,
-0.0957826525,
0.3977283835,
0.1316637695,
-0.3043458164,
-0.2624981701,
0.947088182,
0.1930722296,
0.0927578956,
0.163995266,
-0.1824784279,
0.4982289076,
-0.3328930438,
-0.2669494152,
-0.1523449868,
0.1105455756,
-0.160887599,
-0.2756052017,
0.0615668073,
0.021542158,
-0.3839343488,
0.1935467422,
0.8648341298,
-0.3416416049,
-0.7442998886,
0.4967525005,
0.4820177555,
0.2986165881,
0.2475300729,
-0.638484776,
-0.3312803507,
-0.1187998429,
-0.1102195531,
0.4917713702,
0.6091801524,
0.0854316577,
0.3793168962,
0.5659583807,
0.3478695452,
-0.0925770849,
-0.3573044837,
0.71924752,
-0.6926593781,
-0.0347068645,
-0.7498754263,
0.1436553448,
-0.2734565139,
0.012636031,
0.4630185366,
0.7940024137,
1.0910191536,
-0.2755826414,
0.7116208673,
-0.0737988576,
0.9497089982,
-0.3103884459,
0.7408438325,
-0.4834502935,
-0.0087076416,
-0.398679167,
-0.7544519901,
-0.6070545316,
0.7254284024,
-0.4461569786,
-0.0253586657,
0.8427616954,
0.4000976086,
-0.1215724126,
0.1323760748,
0.2184763104,
0.1496091932,
-0.0722639114,
0.738545239,
0.5865818858,
-0.4474622309,
0.1626441479,
-0.5376217365,
-0.2086408883,
-0.0178035144,
-0.6582412124,
-1.1165304184,
-0.4571710527,
-0.7935426831,
-0.5010902882,
0.2882377505,
1.1610509157,
0.5883592367,
-0.8993822932,
0.4184284508,
0.0730135664,
-0.4079873562,
0.0154297445,
-0.1663735807,
0.5532492995,
-0.1153143495,
-0.5191621184,
0.2406897545,
0.3519496918,
0.2121671438,
0.4325672388,
0.0636239871,
-0.5115491152,
-0.1181506887,
0.2400214821,
0.4669739008,
-0.6023047566,
-0.1844591945,
-0.0950068235,
-0.2272968888,
0.2425548583,
0.4662787616,
-0.9855186343,
0.2553736567,
0.1850110888,
0.8812796474,
0.5450308323,
-0.0474467799,
-0.0313882343,
-0.6912165284,
-0.0606797338,
0.3861376643,
0.6029158831,
0.4550547898,
-0.4135859907,
0.6823433638,
0.6278384328,
-0.6404473186,
-0.9133021832,
-0.1876175702,
-1.2032387257,
-0.0296356604,
1.0710989237,
-0.3591932654,
-0.4612911642,
-0.261767,
-0.1406379193,
0.7294062972,
-0.5552653074,
0.432115674,
0.2641490102,
-0.3749859929,
0.0718005747,
-0.7841521502,
0.5083941221,
0.128790006,
-0.7247063518,
-0.3380284905,
0.6749668717,
0.6640151143,
0.1509868801,
0.6623263955,
-0.1779603958,
0.2466880232,
-0.1200002283,
0.3858423233,
-0.1638198048,
-0.3893992603,
-0.1962808222,
0.0908953771,
-0.0967876986,
-0.0641595796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13119v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13119v2 | Ambiguity Meets Uncertainty: Investigating Uncertainty Estimation for Word Sense Disambiguation | 2023-05-22T15:18:15 | 2023-06-10T03:27:31 | Zhu Liu, Ying Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Word sense disambiguation (WSD), which aims to determine an appropriate sense
for a target word given its context, is crucial for natural language
understanding. Existing supervised methods treat WSD as a classification task
and have achieved remarkable performance. However, they ignore uncertainty
estimation (UE) in the real-world setting, where the data is always noisy and
out of distribution. This paper extensively studies UE on the benchmark
designed for WSD. Specifically, we first compare four uncertainty scores for a
state-of-the-art WSD model and verify that the conventional predictive
probabilities obtained at the end of the model are inadequate to quantify
uncertainty. Then, we examine the capability of capturing data and model
uncertainties by the model with the selected UE score on well-designed test
scenarios and discover that the model reflects data uncertainty satisfactorily
but underestimates model uncertainty. Furthermore, we explore numerous lexical
properties that intrinsically affect data uncertainty and provide a detailed
analysis of four critical aspects: the syntactic category, morphology, sense
granularity, and semantic relations. The code is available at
https://github.com/RyanLiut/WSD-UE. | [
-0.529669404,
-0.8713051677,
0.8318644762,
-0.0291856639,
-0.2566525042,
-0.0605378747,
-0.1191671267,
-0.6934512258,
-0.2757030725,
-0.1842310578,
-0.5567855835,
-0.4120249152,
-0.9305912256,
-0.0734069645,
-0.1315504909,
0.2895492017,
-0.0193737559,
-0.0878313556,
-0.1605834067,
-0.1827780008,
-0.2932329476,
-0.1159049869,
0.0012838363,
-0.1947115958,
0.3038440943,
0.0997627228,
1.1215369701,
0.5239567757,
0.4351687133,
0.2067753673,
-0.4353509843,
0.0489875153,
-0.0962283537,
0.2233525664,
-0.2857800424,
-0.2698327005,
-0.0834736377,
0.0941780359,
0.2097067833,
1.1785752773,
-0.4807584286,
0.2819792032,
0.0038963275,
0.4325983822,
-1.0829242468,
0.0085245715,
-0.7291862369,
-0.1747510284,
-0.2068994343,
0.6215438843,
-0.010259998,
0.0096631991,
0.3000790775,
-0.8279150128,
0.0175155997,
0.2967585921,
1.1642465591,
0.7390283942,
-0.3999451697,
-0.3038095534,
-0.6190063357,
0.8147442937,
-0.6507927179,
0.8795809746,
0.6474456191,
0.2816281319,
-0.3983351588,
-0.7158924341,
-0.8710425496,
0.0912723988,
0.3809272349,
0.2967413962,
-0.3769514263,
0.2536002398,
0.0192604456,
0.3664517701,
-0.3691467941,
0.1483192742,
-0.102699846,
-0.3490560949,
0.5378041863,
-0.0528529771,
-0.2102685124,
-0.3044603765,
-0.4251922369,
-0.2484830171,
-0.0147679159,
0.162549004,
0.4342129529,
0.1326698065,
0.1188568696,
0.4480273128,
-0.3621969819,
1.0918174982,
-0.2903630435,
-0.1219851151,
0.220022127,
-0.3839994669,
-0.2958830595,
-0.3704124093,
0.7197875977,
0.2954892814,
0.0424722917,
-0.1805474013,
-0.3225556016,
0.2721212208,
0.4186426103,
-0.3058722019,
-0.030534165,
0.367729634,
-0.1283663213,
-0.1688356996,
0.1567801833,
-0.8041936755,
-0.3197224438,
-0.4290727675,
0.5108773112,
-0.5039849281,
-0.3091117442,
0.3174846768,
-0.4077204466,
-0.1326943487,
0.1991312057,
-0.4556871653,
0.2234230042,
0.3785274327,
0.4810348451,
-0.187071085,
-0.4027093351,
0.0643725246,
0.0895115882,
-0.5150036812,
0.5821765661,
-0.5634858012,
-0.5031300783,
-0.1152185798,
-0.4030344188,
0.0372630619,
-0.2936109602,
0.7364276648,
-0.4113042653,
-0.0054119891,
-0.1885919571,
-0.8959522247,
-0.1121450514,
0.1178110689,
-0.4938296378,
1.326667428,
0.4354688227,
-0.85471946,
0.9369854927,
-0.387422502,
0.0241581313,
0.0815757737,
-0.0571159162,
-0.0691772997,
0.5020711422,
0.0459511317,
0.298410207,
-0.1667600721,
0.3718536794,
-0.4883886278,
-0.4421590865,
0.3269613385,
-0.5877458453,
0.4583183527,
0.3701134026,
0.0318111144,
-0.2919839323,
-0.8266912103,
0.2334854901,
0.0238080807,
0.0324074179,
-0.6828607321,
0.0095262351,
-0.0233333297,
0.0740921721,
0.3288454413,
-0.4640616477,
0.0915635154,
-0.1857922077,
0.3089683354,
0.4678597748,
0.0333007202,
0.3857346773,
0.2105591595,
0.5174014568,
0.1140116975,
0.5092738271,
0.5167316794,
-0.5862522125,
-0.1513317823,
-0.0232649297,
0.7635885477,
0.4618037045,
-0.5099472404,
0.3107972741,
0.0085768048,
-0.6306669116,
-0.6633499861,
0.0251629166,
0.1631435752,
0.3586658537,
0.3931878805,
0.0142725641,
-0.276142627,
-0.4764009714,
-0.3177834153,
-0.4789761007,
-0.2724263966,
0.0129951444,
0.4105440974,
-0.4195842743,
1.2159285545,
-0.7874421477,
-0.0976716653,
-0.0529614165,
0.2869209349,
-0.0243660826,
0.1355279982,
0.2572441101,
-0.9500732422,
0.0717057809,
-0.4888216257,
-0.4087306559,
-0.0925118923,
0.2237911373,
-0.1243732721,
-0.0308267381,
0.4745060802,
-0.5986450315,
0.748120904,
0.703256309,
-0.184354201,
0.6123141646,
-0.3053851724,
-0.0771161392,
-1.0981547832,
-0.1303799301,
0.1937192827,
0.1456258744,
-0.4425877333,
0.1799606383,
0.2489472628,
0.2232293785,
-0.2292334884,
0.4875535667,
-0.529253006,
-0.0981661603,
-0.1040470377,
0.4608567655,
0.2472562194,
0.0308398847,
-0.0218974743,
0.6201195717,
0.5550596118,
-0.6775055528,
0.0745817125,
0.0847446918,
-0.5481800437,
0.6371236444,
-0.4951213598,
-0.4204697609,
-0.1610565782,
-0.20892708,
-0.9329642057,
-0.385409981,
0.1229836494,
-0.5544170141,
0.3869767785,
0.1124186888,
-0.4356632829,
-0.647900641,
-0.000092268,
0.243017301,
0.3033946157,
-0.1287032217,
0.031790182,
0.6062970757,
0.3635539114,
-0.6360808611,
-0.5538236499,
0.0430387445,
-0.3279154003,
-0.2201278061,
0.390910387,
-0.0710984096,
-0.708850801,
0.0171820614,
-0.5831189156,
-0.4782458842,
0.380060792,
0.273512423,
0.0442122929,
0.2547557652,
0.5429529548,
0.2699491382,
-0.0408208705,
-0.027405994,
-0.1943950206,
0.1404122263,
0.0619927794,
-0.6300604939,
-0.0799044892,
0.0929692835,
0.3374567628,
0.0063459999,
0.5391072631,
0.698074162,
-0.7864903212,
-0.2630256414,
-0.3311752975,
-0.1426371038,
-0.4406606555,
0.3551832438,
-0.6133165956,
-0.357276082,
0.4995349944,
-0.2825756669,
-0.1120239422,
0.3294569254,
-0.124282442,
-0.3958795071,
0.7936183214,
0.5646844506,
0.033500649,
0.1759834886,
0.1255954355,
0.4354936481,
-0.7107242346,
-0.0446704105,
-0.6178524494,
-0.0623848327,
-0.5583381653,
-0.4046104252,
0.3054244816,
0.7128270864,
0.0668044463,
0.2146888971,
-0.4746382535,
0.1293501109,
0.4250091612,
-0.1563867331,
0.263520211,
-0.4000677466,
-0.1686512679,
-0.3231692314,
-0.6034145951,
-0.3997772336,
0.7502107024,
0.2599105537,
0.8300673962,
0.1529789418,
0.5839449167,
0.2641080618,
-0.3932361305,
-0.7703242898,
0.1511723101,
0.2363280803,
-0.4451673627,
-0.5831149817,
-0.4075559378,
-1.1594682932,
0.5038588047,
-0.1234045103,
-0.8926357627,
0.2535942793,
0.0241698045,
-0.3429273665,
0.0791362599,
-0.7358542085,
0.8920654058,
0.1365950406,
-0.149925977,
0.2515967488,
-0.8527057767,
0.1482347548,
-0.1078472435,
0.5928122401,
-0.3405235708,
-0.2872776985,
0.4562604725,
-0.3065714538,
0.5846606493,
-0.1672066599,
-0.292104125,
0.4255617857,
0.1428991258,
0.3565122187,
0.1931923479,
-0.4361333847,
0.6134380698,
0.323957473,
-0.3589629531,
-0.4969090223,
0.1779117137,
-0.4207822084,
-0.3536279202,
-0.6762632728,
-0.7742915154,
-0.6803007722,
0.1259467155,
0.5076212883,
0.29375121,
-0.2181747705,
-0.4819359183,
0.601780057,
0.155614838,
0.5570119619,
0.2698064446,
0.0926490501,
0.2572867572,
0.6162790656,
0.3857372105,
0.4193578064,
0.0247426722,
0.3102850914,
-0.705916822,
-0.7595316172,
-0.5884928107,
-0.1011505499,
-0.5117256641,
-0.2151450813,
-0.291383177,
-0.0013911,
-0.442116797,
-0.0311577413,
-0.3210506439,
-0.072560586,
-0.3399028182,
-0.2789721489,
0.5586779714,
0.9353576899,
-0.1385513991,
0.380060941,
-0.5201114416,
0.1642562449,
0.0620188117,
0.5576318502,
-0.4617350399,
-0.6128981709,
0.0843707025,
0.4443969131,
-0.0076131751,
-1.0710572004,
0.203917101,
0.2482694238,
0.6666929126,
0.4529591799,
0.507009685,
0.9112516046,
-0.0742673278,
0.8405189514,
-0.0356976315,
-1.1292996407,
0.4730628431,
-0.1618804187,
0.5122950077,
0.8412544727,
0.3778655827,
-0.4259123206,
-0.5594171882,
-0.7962225676,
-0.8629016876,
0.2742955983,
0.0898400545,
-0.0523387976,
-0.0490300208,
0.4480051696,
0.1153629497,
0.4641028643,
-0.1901735961,
-0.1219628528,
0.0305404738,
-0.4685518742,
0.0731495321,
-0.224712491,
0.2213299274,
-0.0957244635,
0.3157560229,
-0.1912838966,
-0.109345302,
0.0246076118,
-0.261992991,
0.1477826685,
0.2334323376,
0.2946254611,
0.7821148634,
-0.2454861403,
0.2538422644,
0.2449163944,
-0.7354846597,
-0.1070154384,
0.103181228,
-0.1243461445,
0.2034161091,
0.2473013103,
0.4589091539,
0.3667657971,
-0.8210665584,
0.5445884466,
-0.1820874959,
-0.075054355,
-0.2497569621,
-0.0953695178,
0.0052734553,
0.0034179969,
0.3340043128,
0.1860364825,
0.3545331657,
-0.2808361053,
0.2656149268,
0.3202888668,
-0.5540023446,
-0.1314795613,
0.609518528,
-0.3477570415,
0.202987507,
0.2983138859,
-0.7169585228,
-0.3116414845,
0.3793161213,
0.2987656891,
0.1249190718,
-0.3293029666,
0.198889032,
0.1775308102,
0.4798674285,
-0.2620012462,
0.4903512597,
-0.0104849059,
-0.90559268,
-0.1198293045,
-0.8027775288,
-0.4678458273,
-0.1570224315,
-1.0872933865,
-0.0887759924,
0.0615151003,
-0.4501141906,
-0.1230681837,
0.1090664268,
-0.6009929776,
0.4475801289,
-0.0738127679,
0.9829657674,
-0.8519071341,
0.6926983595,
0.6018835306,
-0.2610287368,
-0.9604496956,
0.42539832,
0.1449717134,
-0.5893012285,
0.0235290732,
-0.0555398837,
0.0090616392,
-0.0317538753,
-0.3255057335,
-1.0172293186,
0.971504271,
0.2488644868,
-0.5166739225,
0.3347722292,
0.0862957239,
0.5281001925,
0.3201916814,
0.0736075267,
0.8379870057,
0.6698272824,
0.1111901775,
-0.8503908515,
-0.215214625,
0.1433784515,
0.1345669478,
0.3827705681,
-0.1761260331,
0.6999387145,
-0.3235542178,
-0.2729936242,
-0.1808647811,
0.7558011413,
0.0571441092,
0.4001838863,
0.6482934952,
0.8393728137,
1.3535662889,
-0.315467149,
0.976878047,
-0.0820138082,
0.2872272134,
1.0914696455,
-0.4829770029,
0.9301755428,
0.8363391757,
-0.6602159142,
0.1264068931,
1.1455355883,
0.3295593858,
0.373191148,
0.4366777241,
-0.2214694023,
-0.1861382872,
-0.2814750373,
-0.2100522071,
0.6890699863,
0.7074192166,
0.2948433161,
-0.1274735779,
0.0615690425,
-0.1331044137,
0.321089834,
-0.1507268548,
0.6402034163,
-0.0148711344,
-0.4551978409,
0.252158761,
-0.0163952876,
0.6072441936,
-0.6215768456,
0.2679422796,
-0.092426382,
-0.0427923501,
0.0991385579,
-0.883148253,
0.3507145047,
-0.3341041803,
-0.0332125686,
0.2383669317,
0.5307430625,
-0.2825460434,
-0.6355010867,
0.3617683649,
0.8117910624,
0.2609204352,
-0.2963077724,
-0.6450082064,
0.3044797182,
-0.2424214184,
-0.2886897624,
0.3884629905,
0.8138606548,
-0.1551805139,
0.6517023444,
0.253225863,
0.0976537317,
0.228934288,
0.1557438821,
0.3973171115,
-0.3284748495,
-0.2092339396,
-0.5454717278,
0.2667327225,
-0.0646336675,
-0.8968019485,
0.6996695995,
0.1362119764,
0.940639019,
0.2156486809,
0.6684238911,
-0.2876590192,
0.2942919731,
-0.2387775779,
0.4685151279,
-0.692026794,
-0.0524502844,
-0.4780978858,
-0.7256877422,
-0.3152602613,
0.6542189121,
0.0355307385,
-0.0081917197,
0.5950279236,
0.6145026684,
-0.0822365955,
0.1466954798,
0.5387681723,
-0.1320438236,
-0.2272088975,
0.2038450241,
0.4939109981,
-0.5219478011,
0.3895478845,
-0.4857334197,
-0.1901497394,
0.1519243419,
-0.9317220449,
-0.2098779827,
-0.8255804181,
-0.2709790766,
-0.0403219685,
-0.0801049396,
0.5952989459,
0.7044129968,
-0.5496304631,
0.1190882102,
-0.2741894126,
0.2675319016,
-0.5997680426,
-0.2207863927,
0.3081724048,
-0.3481948376,
-0.8598880172,
0.385708034,
-0.1218768656,
0.2000569403,
-0.0982445031,
0.0127506005,
-0.193113938,
0.2230374068,
0.2089453191,
-0.0718846694,
-0.8241629601,
-0.4117358029,
-0.0633026883,
-0.2753450871,
-0.4383737147,
0.1177965105,
-0.5747171044,
0.5359097719,
0.2257865667,
0.5627185702,
0.1370161176,
0.2256608754,
0.3536553979,
-0.9182846546,
0.2547686398,
0.0073929019,
0.4576686621,
0.0955254585,
-0.3515891731,
0.5887162089,
0.2726019919,
-0.2450366318,
-0.9745990634,
0.3437549174,
-0.9716371894,
-0.6371667385,
1.0238711834,
-0.0950401351,
-0.1739725471,
-0.4748650491,
0.0738641396,
0.2419525385,
-0.3373235762,
0.8680474162,
0.9289056659,
0.0621948875,
0.1025078371,
-0.8030893803,
0.4122371972,
0.3594915867,
-0.5246847272,
0.058110036,
0.4839116931,
0.0470690206,
0.074674435,
-0.0225465111,
0.2201258391,
0.0122652669,
0.3572298288,
0.1750701964,
0.057518214,
-0.1623081118,
-0.2252652049,
0.1021172628,
0.1743673533,
-0.427726984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13117v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13117v3 | AVeriTeC: A Dataset for Real-world Claim Verification with Evidence from the Web | 2023-05-22T15:17:18 | 2023-11-08T11:53:55 | Michael Schlichtkrull, Zhijiang Guo, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing datasets for automated fact-checking have substantial limitations,
such as relying on artificial claims, lacking annotations for evidence and
intermediate reasoning, or including evidence published after the claim. In
this paper we introduce AVeriTeC, a new dataset of 4,568 real-world claims
covering fact-checks by 50 different organizations. Each claim is annotated
with question-answer pairs supported by evidence available online, as well as
textual justifications explaining how the evidence combines to produce a
verdict. Through a multi-round annotation process, we avoid common pitfalls
including context dependence, evidence insufficiency, and temporal leakage, and
reach a substantial inter-annotator agreement of $\kappa=0.619$ on verdicts. We
develop a baseline as well as an evaluation scheme for verifying claims through
several question-answering steps against the open web. | [
-0.665577054,
-0.5744553208,
0.5010830164,
-0.0155406874,
0.1322749257,
-0.2567250431,
0.0155558316,
-0.7916196585,
0.050782539,
0.303684622,
-0.3964833915,
-0.456689775,
-0.3300313652,
0.3869154453,
-0.2139788717,
0.9688515067,
-0.1368834078,
-0.1747671962,
-0.4799295068,
-0.4263339043,
-0.0664887726,
-0.4824746251,
-0.3300887048,
0.0720650703,
0.4873957932,
0.7517924309,
0.5675950646,
0.7105054855,
0.8184930682,
0.2878856957,
0.4393839836,
0.5013750792,
-0.1514024287,
-0.1035227478,
-0.1238187626,
-0.5197235942,
-0.6033933759,
0.5098153949,
0.2972054482,
0.2521360517,
-0.1000548229,
0.4027578533,
-0.2003169358,
0.2878453732,
-1.1255730391,
0.102030471,
-0.4772126973,
0.2549805641,
-0.1186501905,
0.0505950041,
-0.4088488221,
-1.0366860628,
0.1434928328,
-0.8294429183,
0.3208075166,
0.24649252,
1.1055303812,
0.191992715,
-0.4826927185,
-0.5392980576,
-0.6681936979,
0.3245926797,
-0.4165411592,
0.4088183343,
0.8616042137,
0.5887487531,
0.2245920151,
-0.8484651446,
-0.7863746881,
-0.3085474968,
-0.0738361031,
0.2605878115,
-0.2286569178,
-0.214321062,
0.3557040393,
0.3532987237,
-0.5124765038,
-0.1386802047,
-0.4905439615,
-0.6779935956,
0.5212507248,
-0.3908590078,
0.1573360413,
-0.1013769209,
-0.432504952,
-0.2554967403,
-0.8499283195,
0.0046260427,
0.5956894755,
0.3299122453,
-0.031507723,
0.7657487392,
-0.4263461232,
0.4812137485,
-0.1512379348,
0.0667327121,
0.1649532914,
-0.1424714178,
-0.154132247,
0.6089779735,
0.6976442337,
0.557716012,
0.1417871267,
-0.0230252575,
0.1537258178,
0.1320140809,
0.3050529361,
-0.8161745667,
-0.193848148,
0.6256796122,
-0.5143327713,
-0.2895226181,
0.4339407682,
-0.7250177264,
-0.5427026749,
-0.1748389602,
0.3999382555,
-0.3679873645,
-0.0346731655,
-0.2762703896,
-0.1232155561,
-0.0930124447,
0.5295935273,
-0.010559842,
0.3156068921,
0.4285498857,
1.0849660635,
0.1100946739,
-0.0333185606,
-0.9834026694,
-0.185032472,
-0.5872735977,
1.3233348131,
-0.3963058889,
0.1709460616,
0.4956213832,
-0.0600653775,
0.4098516405,
-0.5374245048,
1.1822602749,
-0.7709830999,
0.2352961749,
-0.5918884873,
-0.6466480494,
-0.2495013177,
0.5889860392,
-1.0538110733,
0.8249452114,
-0.1843650341,
-0.7833232284,
0.7780262232,
-0.7815818191,
-0.3919776678,
0.1845371872,
-0.1774566919,
-0.0942905694,
0.001652792,
0.225079447,
0.185713321,
-0.2714289427,
-0.1312424093,
-0.5469124913,
0.1539835036,
0.428275615,
-0.3797261119,
0.8441633582,
0.4343363941,
-0.2178178132,
-0.0377627946,
-0.9827135801,
-0.0629855469,
-0.0734186545,
-0.4806965888,
-0.3966691792,
0.0078055668,
-0.0570651889,
0.2434551567,
0.1010041162,
-1.054964304,
0.2276407331,
0.132099241,
0.4191788137,
0.7384918332,
-0.0620482042,
-0.1163399369,
-0.4529444575,
0.1719945967,
-0.0880369619,
0.2640736699,
-0.0808088928,
-0.3103836477,
-0.9085097909,
-0.1354752928,
0.6748066545,
0.7231552601,
-0.5615432858,
0.3822215497,
-0.5102872252,
-0.1434688419,
-0.427865386,
-0.4017979801,
-0.0186022315,
0.5687026381,
0.6513704062,
-0.179729268,
-0.5899087787,
-1.0364774466,
-0.2885331213,
-0.4575122893,
-0.2455671728,
0.2577627301,
0.6309850216,
0.1585938931,
1.3976619244,
-0.3547569513,
-0.5648394227,
0.3287217617,
0.2255646735,
0.0448432192,
0.3763470054,
0.283695966,
-0.891757369,
-0.1291391701,
-0.0595384464,
-1.04753685,
0.116221182,
-0.0982505083,
-0.1558650881,
-0.1074524,
0.4789557755,
-0.3118124008,
0.6449534893,
0.2300308943,
-0.3032455146,
0.5488106012,
-0.2539664805,
0.6753217578,
-0.5222557783,
0.0005026556,
0.2440167367,
-0.5772619247,
-0.2995690703,
0.0448524542,
0.1835619658,
0.1874385625,
-0.4959308505,
0.3109714687,
-0.1613385677,
0.1761890054,
-0.0232653078,
0.331036061,
-0.1680387706,
0.2418319732,
0.0173624456,
0.5785925388,
-0.0057359664,
-0.9267764091,
0.6806987524,
0.5561108589,
-0.6174553037,
1.1495549679,
-0.4736910462,
0.0131097315,
0.1361670792,
0.5687359571,
-0.5671585202,
-0.6930528283,
0.2537562549,
-0.3539597988,
-0.4781897664,
-0.3565124571,
-0.4227695167,
-0.5012721419,
-0.2799498439,
0.166831851,
0.0049546035,
-0.9711661935,
0.7570213079,
0.3779291511,
-0.1000958085,
-0.6099464297,
-0.7330690026,
0.3903727829,
-0.0827110335,
-0.4932981431,
0.1741181612,
-0.0582053922,
-0.7946547866,
0.0253151245,
-0.1367101371,
-0.3204979599,
-0.2019135356,
0.3176686466,
-0.0129917478,
-0.2317153066,
0.0052252519,
-0.0877242163,
0.0974537283,
0.0770071894,
-0.4125632048,
0.1579243392,
-0.1799339503,
-0.8664952517,
-0.4517060816,
0.3118865788,
0.2939385772,
-0.1774167717,
0.4786963761,
0.2195895761,
-0.9216432571,
0.0754940212,
-0.8914746046,
0.0868819803,
-0.4115163088,
-0.1802751571,
-0.3154002726,
-0.5969572067,
0.6133128405,
-0.1907364428,
0.6611226201,
0.8963656425,
0.3306780756,
-0.030339729,
0.5842677355,
0.3083836436,
0.361112237,
0.084946245,
-0.1372943223,
0.0200433303,
-0.3599661589,
-0.4171332121,
-0.674552083,
-0.1223445162,
-0.3239556849,
-0.4894598722,
0.3993190825,
0.0758240893,
-0.3743717372,
0.1957233101,
-0.3150414526,
0.527118206,
0.8064284921,
0.4196552932,
0.7610974312,
0.1728730202,
-0.1661526114,
0.1651639342,
-0.4193820655,
-0.6430327296,
1.1130160093,
0.1323173791,
0.2733550072,
0.5333462954,
0.1856747419,
1.1706331968,
0.509848237,
-0.4547267854,
0.2496376783,
0.2818263471,
-1.0452274084,
-0.064825125,
-0.4426196218,
-0.4048699737,
0.2073275894,
-0.4751347601,
-0.7063255906,
0.6207045913,
0.4536248744,
-0.6986895204,
0.3056021333,
-0.2870356143,
0.5230541229,
-0.3476490676,
-0.6482256055,
-0.4002767205,
-0.5567076802,
0.3963876069,
0.2205337286,
0.4798571765,
-0.0936825275,
0.1828810126,
0.6168721914,
-0.9821764231,
0.6027934551,
-0.1335165352,
-0.1923087835,
0.697912991,
0.1526405364,
0.7830234766,
0.284786731,
-0.0262232125,
0.1784613132,
-0.191907227,
-0.2664743364,
-0.2154828757,
0.4635316133,
-0.4134192765,
-0.1163590476,
-0.8574199677,
0.066664584,
-0.3592768013,
0.2187393308,
0.4965490103,
0.7515482306,
-0.7895902395,
0.1947690696,
0.8401570916,
-0.0178269185,
0.2797450125,
0.3137769401,
0.1031602323,
-0.6638745666,
0.8945146799,
0.0279207285,
-0.151613757,
0.2786476612,
0.173302263,
-0.4172831476,
-0.3700342178,
-0.6507085562,
-0.29107216,
-0.9744783044,
-0.4083286822,
-0.7860575914,
0.1268417984,
-0.456266731,
0.1017158628,
-0.5114664435,
-0.6937448978,
0.2743581235,
-0.355466038,
0.6207835674,
0.9044252038,
-0.5643644929,
0.0764989778,
-0.5601465702,
0.5565187335,
0.5178248286,
0.5321583748,
-0.3374745846,
-0.1670091599,
-0.3608357012,
0.3972370327,
-0.0018815983,
-0.6519100666,
-0.201021716,
0.1809983999,
0.3995407522,
0.7453125119,
0.4973688126,
0.5845567584,
-0.670791924,
0.713504076,
0.1529922336,
-0.7888330817,
0.4918756783,
-0.1357625127,
-0.3882809579,
0.8391616344,
0.7391436696,
-0.5169086456,
0.1109972298,
-0.7261602283,
-0.6965128183,
0.6220253706,
0.4815382361,
-0.4956377149,
0.1121348217,
0.3095185161,
0.0508065186,
0.0284738988,
-0.4607932866,
-0.1831661314,
-0.5750933886,
-0.3037135303,
0.4732838273,
-0.1382410675,
-0.6947559118,
0.1604626477,
0.8184024096,
-0.3085846007,
0.2429440618,
0.6711224914,
-0.5959383249,
-0.0448171012,
0.1387758851,
0.4406102896,
0.8002468944,
-0.2508813143,
0.5076407194,
0.3171016574,
-0.6178237796,
0.1769797504,
0.2641166449,
-0.1473980546,
-0.0344283208,
0.6493159533,
0.4897406995,
-0.3230801523,
-0.7662376165,
0.5157951713,
-0.437517792,
-0.1780885011,
-0.6284607649,
-0.192474857,
-0.3865210712,
0.2070781589,
0.6113736629,
0.3314365745,
0.3797509968,
-0.533424437,
0.4257166684,
0.040967159,
-0.5644373298,
-0.0304353256,
0.7050200105,
0.3010631204,
-0.0240104124,
0.6452794075,
-0.1812924296,
-0.4102456868,
0.6294596195,
-0.0923714712,
0.5179827213,
-0.099805057,
0.2242701054,
0.5134022236,
0.601071775,
-0.36762622,
-0.0989056751,
-0.0769273713,
-0.6611036658,
-0.2220887095,
-0.4025854766,
-0.6486392021,
0.1542495191,
-0.5309653282,
0.0994123891,
-0.6515567303,
-0.2387207001,
0.0062781442,
-0.0766344666,
-0.8282489777,
0.4813302755,
0.0315079093,
0.9263792634,
-0.7767342925,
0.2004746199,
0.491319865,
-0.8266285062,
-0.2786428332,
0.0796751752,
0.4472968876,
-0.5726575851,
0.537463069,
0.2013803273,
-0.2561512291,
-0.3992979527,
-0.7932050228,
-0.7131177783,
0.6131154299,
0.2539446354,
-0.4668065012,
0.1851291806,
0.1249797493,
0.1680319905,
-0.4229372144,
0.5018338561,
0.3607335091,
0.6840820312,
0.0947675034,
-0.655466795,
0.1082280576,
-0.262555778,
-0.5712515116,
-0.4037286341,
-0.4743643403,
0.7039028406,
-0.3398478925,
-0.3048750758,
-0.1988715231,
1.1042791605,
0.0245037973,
0.1810400039,
0.9414787889,
0.4918757975,
1.0782147646,
-0.1471839398,
1.0288800001,
-0.1718095094,
0.2596647143,
1.3491002321,
-0.3638860881,
0.9105684161,
-0.0852991641,
-0.3431564271,
0.709651351,
0.8962014318,
-0.0459224433,
0.1061002985,
0.1431611925,
-0.252508074,
-0.6247104406,
-0.4827136397,
-0.1499406546,
0.2340640575,
0.2851237357,
0.0263387896,
-0.1549778432,
-0.0162265394,
0.1228579655,
0.0154883107,
-0.1224216968,
0.7312148213,
-0.289064616,
-0.7113263011,
0.1991170347,
-0.0033816318,
0.4384070039,
-0.4407776892,
-0.3505980968,
-0.108037971,
0.396702081,
-0.599627018,
-0.6084415317,
-0.0363392681,
0.4498567581,
-0.0576037802,
0.0950990543,
0.5690989494,
-0.1118037626,
-0.5094277263,
-0.1547148973,
0.3034462631,
0.1070635393,
-0.4116763771,
-0.2904562354,
-0.1601354182,
-0.2442202419,
-0.2178393602,
-0.1045741588,
0.4269474447,
-0.3106348515,
0.6397538781,
0.8525992036,
-0.0642271489,
-0.0343538001,
-0.0621781126,
0.6423587799,
-0.2238326818,
-0.5570701957,
-0.6344221234,
0.2957816124,
-0.730682373,
-0.2888630927,
0.7820284367,
0.9559889436,
0.7116616368,
0.2970792055,
1.2864454985,
-0.5430624485,
0.5612995625,
-0.5200369954,
0.6732646227,
-0.3875203729,
-0.2280580103,
0.0638618171,
-0.7307847738,
-0.283410728,
1.0789784193,
0.0306711812,
-0.1112078503,
0.7132365108,
0.3098056018,
-0.3826717734,
0.5304181576,
-0.2547376752,
0.2948914468,
0.4907968044,
0.0269841515,
0.8886317611,
-0.501332581,
0.7605938315,
-0.2361282855,
-0.4675064087,
-0.3985053599,
-1.1780103445,
-0.7225452065,
-0.3705723584,
-0.5978227258,
-0.9288796782,
-0.1281531006,
1.2393223047,
0.8415720463,
-1.2123608589,
-0.0136244865,
-0.09154322,
-0.0261458699,
-0.3787143826,
-0.1135672405,
0.4786019623,
-0.0488882251,
-0.4154551029,
0.3837120235,
-0.051143378,
-0.2071451992,
-0.1990691423,
0.1091600582,
-0.6284968853,
0.2297127247,
0.4877893329,
0.5102725029,
-0.3647792935,
-0.4665642977,
-0.3172188103,
0.1527490169,
0.3509276807,
1.1903020144,
-0.7732256651,
0.2816201448,
0.3811586499,
0.4691778421,
0.3811425567,
0.1860068738,
0.4854409099,
-0.6679400206,
0.0541866124,
0.1551469713,
0.5880599022,
0.354424417,
-0.2297845632,
0.6854639053,
0.2464073896,
-0.2893174887,
-0.7087600231,
0.121330753,
-0.7421374917,
-0.2302594334,
0.7293256521,
-0.277584374,
-0.1353219301,
-0.3373236358,
0.1660740525,
0.286118716,
-0.5547701716,
0.723320365,
0.8893882632,
0.0206274781,
0.3497624099,
-0.7365569472,
0.6413687468,
-0.3177636862,
-1.2446373701,
0.5220005512,
1.0428631306,
0.1351756901,
0.6937274933,
0.419971168,
-0.0074968515,
0.1525500715,
0.1134208441,
0.2834774852,
-0.0453309081,
-0.5176831484,
0.1506549418,
0.4319478273,
-0.2503301203,
-0.1904790103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13112v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13112v2 | Rethinking the Evaluation for Conversational Recommendation in the Era of Large Language Models | 2023-05-22T15:12:43 | 2023-11-03T02:49:46 | Xiaolei Wang, Xinyu Tang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jingyuan Wang, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | The recent success of large language models (LLMs) has shown great potential
to develop more powerful conversational recommender systems (CRSs), which rely
on natural language conversations to satisfy user needs. In this paper, we
embark on an investigation into the utilization of ChatGPT for conversational
recommendation, revealing the inadequacy of the existing evaluation protocol.
It might over-emphasize the matching with the ground-truth items or utterances
generated by human annotators, while neglecting the interactive nature of being
a capable CRS. To overcome the limitation, we further propose an interactive
Evaluation approach based on LLMs named iEvaLM that harnesses LLM-based user
simulators. Our evaluation approach can simulate various interaction scenarios
between users and systems. Through the experiments on two publicly available
CRS datasets, we demonstrate notable improvements compared to the prevailing
evaluation protocol. Furthermore, we emphasize the evaluation of
explainability, and ChatGPT showcases persuasive explanation generation for its
recommendations. Our study contributes to a deeper comprehension of the
untapped potential of LLMs for CRSs and provides a more flexible and
easy-to-use evaluation framework for future research endeavors. The codes and
data are publicly available at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/iEvaLM-CRS. | [
-0.3439183235,
-0.680346787,
0.5323947072,
0.288778007,
-0.3565587699,
0.0829890668,
-0.5980864167,
-0.4777107537,
0.023149848,
0.4618650675,
-0.5778158903,
-0.342574656,
-0.256467998,
-0.0805692449,
-0.274094671,
1.1525549889,
0.1361681372,
0.0623803735,
-0.4334184825,
0.0980749726,
-0.6635254622,
-0.5006474853,
-0.6602940559,
-0.6958829165,
0.40311867,
0.5097114444,
0.7908638716,
0.2397419214,
0.5974950194,
0.3263470531,
-0.1971975714,
0.114995487,
-0.8934754133,
0.1597836763,
0.1120048687,
-0.2265015244,
-0.3748486936,
-0.2124500722,
0.3733593822,
0.5423178673,
-0.3829156458,
-0.0698622242,
0.2222008556,
0.4353533089,
-0.4202469587,
0.291983068,
-0.7113512158,
0.0983817428,
0.1051859707,
-0.5035735369,
-0.4673927724,
-0.4681931734,
0.7433340549,
-0.4413768947,
-0.2013742328,
0.4000071883,
0.5283212066,
-0.2226542383,
-0.3721641898,
-0.4919374883,
-0.9213343263,
0.6581562161,
-0.607945621,
0.4884388149,
0.2164338231,
0.676374495,
-0.3584881425,
-0.5420688391,
-0.3832384348,
-0.9158946276,
0.0174174719,
0.1124577522,
-0.3851163089,
0.0902835503,
0.1513012201,
0.4509241879,
-0.4207085371,
0.0144696152,
-0.170792684,
-0.1523351818,
0.3656716049,
0.3654143512,
0.3355599344,
-0.0478177331,
-0.6450600028,
0.0524983443,
-0.640854001,
0.072588183,
0.2527469397,
0.2680709958,
-0.1713353097,
0.6229287386,
-0.1691330075,
0.4365013242,
0.1088573858,
0.082482405,
0.1577721834,
-0.2961131632,
-0.2162823528,
-0.0616343617,
0.8083456159,
0.8764923811,
0.6183227897,
-0.2417659014,
-0.0024927224,
-0.1408820301,
0.2009895593,
-0.9289025068,
-0.3222235739,
0.000062438,
-0.2958297431,
-0.3662179112,
-0.0741995424,
-0.7713730931,
-0.5886493325,
-0.2658871114,
0.2973054051,
-0.4853934944,
-0.0391155146,
0.2409777194,
0.0096426606,
0.0056066099,
0.4798432887,
-0.7250794172,
0.3165360689,
0.5233589411,
0.5553542376,
-0.036424078,
-0.2669234276,
-0.2753197551,
-0.030015612,
-0.0309332684,
0.9758691788,
-1.0289782286,
-0.6965547204,
0.1606238335,
-0.1591144651,
0.0130732926,
-0.5154573917,
0.7085999846,
-0.471765101,
0.1425403357,
-0.404227227,
-0.411767602,
-0.1264864057,
0.4037243426,
-0.1856883615,
0.8543842435,
-0.0647063851,
-0.4867968559,
0.415766269,
-0.7178076506,
-0.1864399463,
0.3283052444,
-0.0264457352,
-0.1287126839,
-0.270932436,
0.3276661932,
0.3430176377,
-0.5730112195,
0.4335578382,
-0.5389282107,
-0.7323654294,
0.4305396378,
-0.6544384956,
0.3851280212,
0.3201190531,
-0.091797635,
0.1794990897,
-0.4326457977,
0.1521511078,
0.0578108281,
-0.4885060787,
-0.0038710465,
0.1098091453,
0.0124197667,
-0.1719813943,
0.1190002635,
-0.3260715902,
0.1161554456,
-0.4536320269,
0.7059395909,
0.6460494995,
0.1164694279,
0.4428886771,
-0.360884577,
0.7065026164,
-0.3524374664,
0.1937462389,
-0.4140918553,
-0.3002293408,
-0.8860406876,
-0.1899376214,
0.2454484403,
0.3971931338,
-0.5219110847,
0.3068212271,
-0.4035997689,
-0.6532258987,
-0.3203403652,
-0.0068267477,
0.4002016783,
0.0208579395,
0.1126305833,
-0.3131147921,
-0.6520093083,
-0.9070381522,
-0.4030368924,
-0.5566943884,
-0.2835906744,
0.6895303726,
0.2679916322,
-0.4378687143,
0.8971315622,
-0.1761607677,
0.0395801254,
-0.355360359,
-0.1338792145,
0.0055904808,
0.2242258489,
0.2768109441,
-0.2076878101,
-0.2699539661,
0.0460645296,
-0.3857940435,
-0.3544666767,
-0.0887204707,
0.0122853313,
-0.3569819927,
0.1560334414,
-0.3527985811,
0.3245280087,
0.4531244636,
-0.186244458,
0.5871060491,
-0.3582117558,
0.3501684666,
-0.5119749308,
-0.2092833668,
0.209087193,
-0.2964762747,
-0.2954539657,
-0.0722219869,
-0.2736198008,
-0.3400607109,
-0.306316793,
0.4891159832,
-0.330752641,
0.0664692372,
-0.19715783,
0.5552538633,
0.0094760479,
0.3622328937,
-0.259653002,
0.6331665516,
0.2814564705,
-0.3856060207,
0.4357691109,
0.3197231591,
-0.4694985747,
0.6293581128,
-0.8709990978,
0.3078178763,
0.1365478337,
0.6462309361,
-1.0502724648,
0.0836755186,
0.2563912272,
-0.1515640467,
-0.2463090569,
-0.5021257997,
-0.2852493823,
-0.1791462302,
-0.3963242769,
0.2318748534,
0.5165625215,
-0.7074404955,
0.5069972873,
0.4122208953,
-0.1511504203,
-0.0685454383,
-0.2496204376,
0.5065802336,
-0.4266630411,
-0.9058123231,
0.216345787,
-0.2923564613,
-0.3906706572,
-0.3201027215,
0.0859218463,
0.2186737508,
0.1044951752,
0.5581403971,
0.2974660993,
-0.1127986461,
0.1275388896,
-0.3921316564,
-0.1329757124,
0.080594793,
-0.0915375352,
0.6968939304,
-0.6733517647,
-0.728117764,
-0.4183782339,
-0.042043779,
0.3938205242,
-0.0362004265,
0.2212322205,
0.6399639845,
-0.0834011585,
-0.1012479365,
-0.7152282,
-0.3053085506,
-0.4891812503,
0.4096593559,
-0.2669323385,
-0.958091855,
0.3097272515,
-0.2915118933,
0.0393383875,
0.1432600915,
0.8137969375,
-0.0245765001,
0.8703606725,
0.3108135462,
0.1542236209,
0.4893402457,
0.0285915826,
0.5002936721,
-0.9619461894,
-0.393486172,
-0.4806230366,
0.0098131876,
-0.5560747385,
-0.3816967607,
0.2896181345,
0.0337101482,
-0.0722415745,
0.1782607138,
-0.1545151919,
0.5462950468,
0.1878023446,
0.1628075242,
0.4363857806,
0.037961524,
-0.1767236739,
-0.0642728582,
-0.776766181,
-0.9571311474,
0.8186371922,
0.5282469988,
0.8795320988,
-0.0486701801,
0.0848126635,
0.4987292886,
0.333109498,
-0.9274530411,
0.7509250045,
0.2100556642,
-0.2192261219,
-0.2053696811,
-0.2237444222,
-1.0470119715,
0.4173259437,
-0.5053234696,
-0.9199438095,
-0.1883224398,
0.0713903457,
-0.3823310435,
0.041908931,
-0.9247422814,
0.6790412664,
-0.2255030423,
-0.345199734,
-0.4249092937,
-0.1877891421,
0.2623020411,
0.0533577688,
0.2272704244,
-0.1194555014,
0.465203464,
0.717581749,
-0.4615470171,
0.8502292037,
0.0687011257,
-0.0551725142,
0.3288905621,
0.3497918546,
0.5233312845,
0.3031371236,
-0.2073098272,
0.176775679,
0.1980037987,
-0.0151788043,
-0.6956089139,
0.9307239652,
-0.3939292729,
-0.7426960468,
-0.1976985782,
-0.2184644938,
-0.2724341154,
-0.1367165446,
-0.371792078,
0.5502089262,
-0.5490766764,
0.4418729842,
0.1748132408,
-0.4185480177,
0.0413206816,
0.6917386651,
-0.563744545,
-0.3640851974,
0.8289275765,
-0.2732441127,
0.029759489,
0.0067140651,
0.4115784466,
-0.3231360614,
-0.5716463923,
-0.4804836512,
0.059185259,
-0.6810689569,
0.2766500115,
-0.5038376451,
0.066476211,
-0.0121316509,
-0.1827388555,
-0.0512406193,
-0.0693323091,
0.0034162966,
-0.0580781996,
0.2831745744,
0.8566281796,
0.3133073449,
0.3612898588,
-0.5943495035,
-0.0775409713,
0.2911057472,
0.5924456716,
0.1931809187,
-0.6250084639,
-0.2506777048,
0.2097952068,
-0.3329291046,
-0.5761119723,
0.1058091521,
0.0394526869,
0.6351598501,
0.5629518628,
-0.0099691339,
0.7380819917,
-0.5936018229,
0.8615269661,
0.0883648321,
-0.6970722079,
0.2093059421,
-0.449651897,
0.2057622671,
0.4787915647,
-0.0905010626,
-0.7552295327,
-0.143403843,
-0.5678043962,
-0.9518207908,
0.4761459231,
0.4031849504,
0.3403348327,
-0.0838314444,
0.2441883087,
0.0959812552,
0.0989261121,
-0.5106962323,
0.0198562182,
0.1269298047,
0.1906607151,
-0.0611991808,
-0.7282462716,
0.0324303582,
0.1302563101,
0.7068273425,
0.1103860512,
0.2256226391,
0.0751541406,
-0.1372139007,
-0.1486649364,
0.4760299623,
0.2550228834,
0.7117292881,
-0.3721441627,
-0.0583874546,
0.4016469717,
-0.0924749598,
-0.2050472647,
-0.0488020368,
0.151686728,
-0.2473843843,
0.185709551,
0.9896924496,
0.5539207458,
-0.944432795,
0.5275312662,
-0.3388014436,
0.0760949776,
-0.4565716982,
0.044511117,
0.1805189997,
0.3337965608,
0.1552249491,
-0.1306826621,
0.1360814124,
-0.7143129706,
0.0153765269,
0.651211381,
-0.7022448778,
-0.2565205991,
0.2624048293,
0.5943268538,
-0.726331532,
0.3619660437,
0.1934647411,
-0.6996101737,
0.323256284,
0.3751141429,
0.8646333814,
0.1424907297,
0.1862715334,
-0.0063576712,
0.3313056529,
0.0927904546,
-0.2362208366,
-0.0847404301,
-0.6775850654,
-0.3486306369,
-0.5051306486,
-0.7818399072,
0.1720009297,
-0.3223241866,
0.6043643951,
-0.2483418882,
-0.1220858321,
0.0468367599,
-0.1396878511,
-0.7717820406,
0.0165762436,
0.0650961027,
0.5940431952,
-0.4855944812,
0.3779439926,
0.5914566517,
-0.1346493065,
-0.5455076098,
0.043147888,
-0.0533899218,
-0.892542541,
0.4370537996,
-0.0098870881,
-0.3113191724,
-0.2305133194,
-0.2692044675,
-0.2640876174,
0.9529735446,
0.4623614848,
-0.5799797177,
0.279001683,
0.105733797,
0.8932085633,
-0.4857465625,
1.1822561026,
0.5285291076,
0.5895139575,
0.1920784861,
-1.1690632105,
0.0251596346,
-0.3176605403,
0.0765301362,
-0.1005479321,
-0.7245019078,
0.1980185658,
-0.306522727,
-0.1851281822,
0.0398205481,
0.2065788656,
0.2594389021,
0.1837611943,
0.6667661071,
0.2391166836,
0.4609954655,
0.028617166,
1.1565403938,
-0.1572938859,
0.3240684867,
1.1237412691,
-0.527736187,
0.7770611644,
0.4914468527,
-0.5541305542,
0.4695390761,
0.7326463461,
-0.1456309557,
0.0143080382,
0.5758692026,
-0.1781400293,
-0.4495296776,
-0.1997713149,
-0.273549974,
0.4945570529,
0.170964703,
-0.2422852814,
-0.4953897297,
-0.1535807103,
-0.1835532337,
-0.0173786581,
0.1544335335,
0.903529942,
0.0951851457,
-0.4248336256,
0.6401290894,
-0.0096343011,
0.5100226402,
-0.5370748043,
-0.3598273396,
0.0718754381,
-0.1405313015,
-0.1591278166,
-0.7019553185,
-0.2834399343,
0.1158937514,
0.1294517666,
-0.2118054032,
0.8146518469,
-0.2508605719,
-0.2974819541,
0.370303452,
0.57056427,
0.4659824669,
-0.0195686277,
-0.5491643548,
0.0337654613,
0.2929875851,
-0.3859550655,
0.4406855404,
0.4780553281,
-0.0965592638,
1.1927990913,
0.9199228287,
-0.1178682745,
-0.4248588979,
0.3424323499,
0.8475806713,
-0.3943148851,
-0.4393065572,
-0.935113728,
0.2874894142,
0.1985544413,
-0.2045850456,
0.8228235245,
0.5643901229,
0.5674006343,
0.1874119937,
0.8728174567,
0.1919796169,
0.2263454646,
-0.443602562,
0.473738879,
-0.1387076974,
1.21913445,
-0.339740783,
-1.0231288671,
0.061790742,
0.4328925312,
-0.6729578972,
0.3212421834,
0.6299126148,
0.7705402374,
-0.0399461389,
0.4672902226,
0.4190610349,
0.1957129538,
0.3945836425,
0.3862934411,
1.2372825146,
-0.1111816466,
0.8518540263,
0.0006628169,
-0.2668747008,
-0.6668360233,
-1.169403553,
-0.9718427062,
-0.3022475243,
-0.2020339966,
-0.362683624,
0.428804487,
1.2373597622,
0.5733690858,
-0.4919838607,
-0.3830476105,
0.2420864105,
-0.0632717237,
0.1479468644,
-0.2413441539,
0.0509785302,
-0.0766033456,
-0.710616827,
0.6578191519,
0.3589583933,
0.0257695708,
-0.4467312098,
-0.1546715349,
0.2304535508,
0.0584269874,
0.5740913749,
-0.0931813493,
-0.8007331491,
-0.4187932014,
-0.3575412631,
0.1484934986,
0.164471969,
0.8782961369,
-0.9235057235,
0.6088767648,
0.1639989614,
0.5511724949,
0.4867370427,
0.0860953927,
0.8331647515,
-0.1105416566,
-0.2169040143,
0.1191355661,
0.4627558887,
0.3358051181,
-0.1818685234,
0.3432811499,
-0.1821240485,
-0.6903307438,
-0.8005748987,
0.0337631702,
-1.2077921629,
0.2738510072,
1.4908405542,
-0.2950410545,
0.129116416,
-0.2365496457,
-0.752600193,
-0.1506617665,
-0.8450887799,
0.8870406151,
0.7973156571,
0.0593819208,
0.0314470753,
-0.5927137733,
0.1705734134,
0.4347339869,
-0.4709894955,
0.3502718508,
0.5077866316,
0.3010854125,
-0.1886011213,
0.4609969556,
-0.0754842162,
-0.0084590744,
-0.3741372228,
0.0143520581,
-0.1165179089,
0.0334546119,
-0.4058457613,
0.0675761849,
0.5155372024,
0.2176704854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.13108v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.13108v3 | Debiased Automatic Speech Recognition for Dysarthric Speech via Sample Reweighting with Sample Affinity Test | 2023-05-22T15:09:27 | 2023-06-27T13:19:19 | Eungbeom Kim, Yunkee Chae, Jaeheon Sim, Kyogu Lee | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Automatic speech recognition systems based on deep learning are mainly
trained under empirical risk minimization (ERM). Since ERM utilizes the
averaged performance on the data samples regardless of a group such as healthy
or dysarthric speakers, ASR systems are unaware of the performance disparities
across the groups. This results in biased ASR systems whose performance
differences among groups are severe. In this study, we aim to improve the ASR
system in terms of group robustness for dysarthric speakers. To achieve our
goal, we present a novel approach, sample reweighting with sample affinity test
(Re-SAT). Re-SAT systematically measures the debiasing helpfulness of the given
data sample and then mitigates the bias by debiasing helpfulness-based sample
reweighting. Experimental results demonstrate that Re-SAT contributes to
improved ASR performance on dysarthric speech without performance degradation
on healthy speech. | [
-0.2282784581,
-0.5423020124,
0.1044723466,
-0.2599023581,
-0.4421979487,
0.3726406097,
-0.1571586877,
-0.4070485532,
0.5395779014,
0.1224456131,
-0.3547858596,
-0.3286186457,
-0.6848042607,
0.1956269145,
-0.3753336966,
0.516512394,
0.0392408334,
0.2860467732,
-0.1858547777,
-0.4949816763,
-0.4231894314,
-0.3030152917,
-0.5860599875,
-0.5130470991,
0.2420479804,
0.5656902194,
0.6605238914,
0.646666646,
0.4822155535,
0.3278416693,
-0.092129916,
-0.2802661955,
-0.284126997,
0.5224899054,
0.158110857,
-0.2302412689,
-0.6330957413,
0.1677944809,
0.7933979034,
0.9285673499,
-0.3607010543,
0.2293661982,
0.275015682,
0.7333571911,
-0.4335063398,
-0.0874109492,
-0.6695626378,
-0.0014316296,
-0.0926299319,
-0.1921368688,
-0.077176556,
-0.3989261389,
0.0974568278,
-0.5964894891,
0.2825165391,
0.0513543785,
0.3791117668,
0.8921689987,
0.0208217409,
0.0069080475,
-0.5948604345,
0.7511671185,
-0.5607887506,
0.676810801,
0.724412024,
0.5642188787,
-0.0667753443,
-0.4297418594,
-0.5112060308,
-0.4373860359,
0.3798881769,
0.0027778244,
-0.3072415292,
0.0993240774,
0.3242827356,
0.5984249711,
-0.6360046864,
0.2154078633,
-0.3034122586,
-0.3351503611,
0.8487452865,
-0.0221354607,
0.2529342771,
0.266531229,
-0.0643306896,
-0.2934969068,
-0.5025676489,
0.0152118281,
0.2899778783,
0.6390057206,
0.0864773542,
0.6124037504,
-0.19706361,
0.6054602265,
0.605125308,
-0.2659275532,
0.8821277022,
0.1172958761,
-0.1350574195,
0.6476454735,
0.3193125725,
0.303373158,
0.2359808683,
-0.2389690578,
-0.2290934175,
0.0867646262,
0.1581042856,
-0.5146368146,
-0.2481676489,
0.2767835855,
-0.6244817972,
-0.0808786079,
-0.1619707197,
-0.5922434926,
-0.6452390552,
-0.5797451138,
0.194827199,
-0.3737848103,
-0.3596858382,
0.0483973511,
-0.2141524255,
0.0018257261,
0.0587854981,
-0.7751961946,
0.584127605,
0.3885700703,
0.5932806134,
-0.4346112311,
-0.2633475661,
-1.0766897202,
0.0624010228,
0.0018227375,
0.7424132824,
-0.4593690634,
-0.5378624201,
-0.4931227863,
-0.1760673225,
-0.0149695436,
-0.8357316256,
0.6619695425,
-0.313709408,
-0.3397968411,
-0.2907980978,
-0.616958499,
-0.061580684,
0.0437046029,
-0.7063879371,
0.8452507854,
-0.0637299716,
-0.6521353126,
0.9862813354,
-0.1223088577,
-0.6048005223,
0.0784674957,
-0.3526753783,
-0.5123619437,
0.2906250358,
0.322432816,
0.0296505485,
-0.1094014868,
0.0575015992,
-0.6172173023,
-0.5775874853,
0.1368850172,
-0.5221389532,
0.5414658189,
0.3670926094,
-0.499251008,
0.0521223433,
-0.9675490856,
0.2218543738,
-0.1066394299,
-0.5263776183,
-0.5632731318,
0.0792092308,
-0.0687605366,
-0.0753047317,
-0.1779953539,
-0.8754989505,
0.0401121937,
-0.7095783353,
0.0948241055,
0.6162720919,
-0.3704724312,
0.2943603694,
-0.4881261587,
0.4682242274,
-0.0652785152,
-0.209455505,
0.7144502401,
-0.4043613076,
-0.4190536141,
-0.6181927323,
0.4794101715,
0.7324935198,
-0.5393723845,
0.9644597769,
-0.3662198186,
-0.2738301158,
-0.7901076674,
0.0924837962,
0.2957978547,
0.5762338638,
0.3967964947,
-0.4124964178,
-0.6217219234,
-0.7569900155,
-0.3454385698,
-0.2536598742,
-0.268592149,
0.2823635042,
-0.0283236541,
-0.2159191221,
0.808742702,
-0.3645908535,
-0.3944090307,
-0.3447422385,
-0.0106143551,
0.1311110407,
0.5058182478,
0.2321403921,
-0.6313153505,
-0.595724225,
-0.3148471713,
-0.2734545469,
-0.4131150842,
0.4179717302,
0.5042251945,
0.3602520525,
0.4737904966,
-0.1516168118,
0.7470264435,
0.36808002,
-0.157525152,
0.1773653775,
-0.1724192053,
0.193408519,
-0.8910668492,
0.1855870932,
-0.2018279135,
-0.2564623952,
-0.5844772458,
-0.5066524148,
-0.2861057222,
-0.2200477123,
-0.0579560548,
0.2878352702,
-0.3527834117,
-0.2215768993,
-0.6802377701,
0.0765980184,
-0.1402839869,
0.0268240999,
-0.021485189,
0.6786698103,
0.7793187499,
-0.506904304,
0.3755752146,
0.2224033475,
-0.2690812349,
0.8039476871,
-0.8956384063,
0.1753674895,
-0.1780113131,
0.1599494666,
-1.084505558,
-0.0510399602,
0.176425457,
-0.6863189936,
0.7801642418,
0.0887029022,
0.0674552172,
-0.5774505138,
-0.2781209946,
0.6919034719,
0.4477088153,
-0.5003861785,
0.5564654469,
0.7824081779,
-0.3390000761,
-0.616638124,
-0.7934918404,
-0.0855671912,
-0.4649282098,
-0.4886034727,
0.5031639934,
0.1068830192,
-0.4051919878,
-0.1213224977,
-0.451480478,
-0.1748563051,
0.0144852987,
0.4255188107,
-0.1470588297,
0.1580849588,
0.2254420221,
0.0790423155,
-0.4465670586,
-0.2173092663,
-0.2124242783,
0.4652990103,
-0.0504133068,
-0.7366129756,
-0.9257315993,
0.4381031096,
0.6253446341,
-0.0406128615,
0.0874982104,
0.4081527889,
-0.4770437479,
0.1035603657,
-0.8175113797,
-0.4047209024,
-0.4512867928,
0.2944413722,
-0.3899953663,
-0.7870765924,
0.6310955882,
0.2593917549,
-0.282892257,
0.3095061481,
0.542099297,
0.0628048331,
0.9199021459,
0.272696048,
-0.7470185757,
0.4580691457,
0.0317060053,
0.0349310935,
-0.7585241199,
0.1452539712,
-0.5917344093,
-0.8005126119,
-0.461553812,
-0.1930593103,
0.2210293561,
-0.4462382793,
-0.1723720282,
0.0258518606,
-0.7346717715,
0.3544556201,
0.8260083795,
0.3264282644,
0.2905235887,
0.3630455732,
-0.16007258,
-0.1543488503,
-0.3286720812,
-0.263030231,
1.1757885218,
0.3362953067,
1.2476935387,
-0.0879750401,
0.8855756521,
0.5435512662,
0.0827098563,
-1.0108941793,
0.3252533376,
-0.428113848,
-0.3005051613,
-0.605271399,
-0.5050148964,
-0.9058901668,
-0.1267947704,
0.1220979989,
-0.5588299632,
0.6914787292,
0.3745789826,
-0.7598788142,
0.2329287082,
-0.3614241779,
0.2580624223,
-0.2111167759,
-0.0270418879,
-0.377012074,
-0.6793093085,
-0.219528541,
0.1208457574,
-0.1663166285,
-0.2063407749,
0.1182945445,
0.8720529675,
-0.2169962376,
0.7699499726,
-0.6729062796,
0.1198616922,
0.3894362152,
-0.1999406815,
0.3177874982,
-0.0571604893,
-0.4662608206,
0.189143002,
-0.0672850683,
-0.066548869,
-0.3356724381,
0.8142316937,
-0.7128676176,
-0.7095503807,
-0.6271262169,
-0.6584383249,
-0.3351053596,
0.0818209574,
0.0161382481,
0.4469145536,
-0.2178424895,
0.3932223618,
0.4336446226,
-0.1073826104,
0.0565757826,
0.6061017513,
0.3166437149,
-0.7129786611,
0.9206067324,
0.2602303326,
0.1513318866,
0.1332062334,
0.3444733322,
-0.6522250175,
-0.8205471635,
-0.2945264578,
-0.1146789417,
-0.3945899904,
-0.1515047848,
-0.5167694688,
0.0006960614,
-0.7911016345,
0.111521706,
-0.2728273869,
-0.6070253849,
-0.1535428911,
-0.275999397,
0.2799163759,
0.2566667199,
-0.420665592,
-0.0658530742,
-0.5922887921,
0.6087427139,
0.4603941441,
0.5069748163,
-0.2630877197,
-0.7816391587,
0.0655600056,
0.2921432257,
-0.3740531206,
-0.6210260987,
0.374954015,
0.5635660887,
1.0368466377,
0.2456262857,
0.3757310212,
0.6633219123,
-0.4851557314,
0.4379805028,
-0.006937467,
-0.8412846923,
0.4979069531,
0.0181575771,
0.0527411886,
1.2408708334,
0.0828835592,
-0.2849829495,
-0.3133829236,
-0.3482502103,
-0.827375114,
0.5802953839,
-0.0845020711,
-0.2774207294,
0.1729149967,
0.5206558704,
0.025895685,
0.0967292637,
-0.191035226,
-0.2082452029,
-0.4209739566,
-0.4331583381,
-0.1922306567,
-0.1674197167,
-0.2668886781,
-0.6104416847,
0.5445700288,
-0.1826811284,
0.0605603829,
0.4326844215,
-0.0919390246,
-0.3717181385,
0.1308209747,
0.3765157759,
0.3356841803,
-0.3617318273,
0.1184315905,
0.397851795,
-0.9536004066,
0.5554587245,
0.5564504862,
-0.0876648203,
-0.2492557466,
0.0555613898,
0.6335425377,
-0.1895203143,
-0.6357547045,
0.36932078,
-0.2432922274,
-0.290191859,
-0.2832066417,
-0.0418989249,
-0.2664684951,
0.2457425445,
0.5065546632,
-0.1274043769,
0.416333437,
-0.1617761999,
0.6733477116,
0.5548800826,
-0.6322247386,
-0.1113853976,
0.5199488401,
0.33807078,
-0.2795962393,
0.7267152071,
-0.0537546761,
-0.3765567243,
0.5210695267,
0.4600579441,
1.1556895971,
-0.8157564402,
-0.1540255994,
0.1975958347,
0.1317710876,
0.201283291,
0.5412013531,
-0.0854128823,
-0.6994482875,
-0.2746624351,
-0.4643498361,
-0.4134057164,
-0.0705860779,
-0.9420823455,
0.103078343,
-0.1133712977,
-0.3316747248,
-0.1647145152,
0.1368352771,
-0.2529601157,
0.2948832512,
0.0769077837,
0.8008953929,
-0.8620593548,
0.8414157629,
0.6898655295,
-0.0714419112,
-0.6563411951,
0.3727058172,
0.3180842102,
-0.8960777521,
0.7705253363,
0.2512814105,
-0.317674011,
-0.0657790527,
0.0339827947,
-1.0650466681,
1.0925767422,
0.4705913663,
-0.5605973601,
0.5708386898,
0.2220773101,
0.4994303286,
-0.226269111,
-0.241547361,
0.6294240355,
0.41567716,
0.3737370372,
-1.1818845272,
0.0736079216,
-0.2975240648,
-0.2315334976,
-0.0595544726,
-0.2134899795,
0.5528262258,
-0.1688288301,
-0.1820270568,
-0.0297651384,
0.6358537078,
0.4719093442,
0.672452569,
1.09019804,
0.9096884727,
1.0837008953,
0.0463018194,
0.696959734,
-0.4197641909,
-0.0712748542,
1.2018498182,
-0.8010920286,
0.7628709078,
0.6061173081,
-0.1748488843,
0.0681499168,
0.4199967384,
0.1685680747,
0.6832796931,
0.6870240569,
-0.3986290991,
-0.308868736,
-0.1025719494,
-0.7171212435,
0.7728758454,
0.22040461,
-0.1494653225,
-0.0355975628,
0.1980910152,
-0.4356976748,
0.1872005761,
-0.2777296901,
0.962002635,
0.0705561563,
-0.3885913193,
0.7639304399,
-0.5166921616,
0.744615078,
-0.3120453954,
0.1648416668,
-0.004412787,
0.5661895275,
-0.2138421834,
-0.4702814221,
0.7981012464,
-0.1029983163,
-0.4203000963,
0.04898775,
0.8928788304,
-0.2949189246,
-0.6400781274,
0.2870878875,
0.2355283946,
0.1909213364,
-0.279766351,
-0.5899925232,
0.1576664001,
-0.0717461333,
-0.1647890657,
0.3365730047,
0.0237386655,
0.0919386894,
0.9152087569,
0.3937095106,
0.281072557,
-0.216479972,
0.4070262015,
1.0665130615,
-0.4659098983,
-0.351251632,
-0.6622572541,
0.2308320552,
-0.1328100711,
-0.0700481459,
0.7281835079,
0.5612226129,
0.3648416996,
0.2805339694,
0.7692306042,
-0.0785479546,
1.1136631966,
-0.0503590815,
1.0305652618,
-0.7017647624,
0.160403043,
-0.3540346324,
-0.4622894526,
-0.5535709858,
0.880215764,
-0.3883119822,
0.1709218621,
0.2771859765,
0.8200907111,
0.0220970456,
0.1915269643,
0.3128734827,
0.0930291712,
0.3226127028,
0.394587636,
0.563886404,
-0.2105944306,
0.436429888,
-0.3152574599,
-0.6504013538,
-0.0974573866,
-0.7074683905,
-0.590092063,
-0.4123203456,
-0.4164372981,
-0.2752985954,
0.1828334033,
1.105774045,
0.5440912843,
-1.1602855921,
-0.1475647092,
0.0620950274,
0.0400372706,
-0.5761898756,
-0.1385502219,
0.5625165105,
-0.1251505315,
-0.5735132098,
0.691845417,
-0.0086034965,
0.020373052,
-0.0157755837,
-0.2250885516,
0.1119048595,
-0.3881300688,
0.1149398386,
0.3547058105,
-0.4720923603,
-0.4915194809,
-0.0060831001,
0.2160848677,
-0.0573843978,
0.7406564355,
-0.8172203302,
0.4358093143,
0.5269665718,
0.7685082555,
0.0583400652,
0.2947208285,
0.5486639142,
-0.6319125891,
0.359934926,
0.6209362745,
0.4414407909,
0.3501363099,
-0.2842412591,
0.1792469174,
0.3458198905,
-0.8419080377,
-0.9203696847,
0.1015487388,
-1.0810757875,
0.2093341202,
1.0416226387,
-0.0749914721,
0.0907733291,
-0.5337285995,
-0.3201601505,
0.4159926176,
-0.5627578497,
1.0720117092,
0.2787632346,
-0.2828367054,
0.1354627609,
0.0037491797,
0.485016346,
0.3843002021,
-0.3992508948,
0.2881907523,
0.5722450614,
0.4234370589,
0.1426339,
0.7257218957,
-0.0412284583,
0.3338015079,
-0.0512487777,
0.022639636,
-0.2769394517,
-0.1910030544,
-0.571288228,
-0.0469384789,
0.1839743108,
-0.6926525831
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.